Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 1 – 22 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
On Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices? T. Gannon1 , M.A. Walton2,?? 1 Department of Mathematics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6G 2G1.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Silver Street,
Cambridge CB3 9EW, UK. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 7 October 1997 / Accepted: 7 March 1999
Abstract: We consider the fusion algebras arising in e.g. Wess–Zumino–Witten conformal field theories, affine Kac–Moody algebras at positive integer level, and quantum groups at roots of unity. Using properties of the modular matrix S, we find small sets of primary fields (equivalently, sets of highest weights) which can be identified with the variables of a polynomial realization of the Ar fusion algebra at level k. We prove that for many choices of rank r and level k, the number of these variables is the minimum possible, and we conjecture that it is in fact minimal for most r and k. We also find new, systematic sources of zeros in the modular matrix S. In addition, we obtain a formula relating the entries of S at fixed points, to entries of S at smaller ranks and levels. Finally, we identify the number fields generated over the rationals by the entries of S, and by the fusion (Verlinde) eigenvalues.
1. Introduction (1)
Fix an affine non-twisted algebra g = Xr , and level k. Put k := k + h∨ , where h∨ is 0 r the dual P Coxeter number of g. Let w , . . . , w denote its fundamental weights, and put ρ := ri=0 w i . Let P+k (g) be the set of all level k integrable highest weights of g. For example, r r X X λi wi | λi ∈ Z≥0 , λi = k}. P+k (A(1) r )={ i=0
i=0
the corresponding character. Sometimes it is convenient to write (λ0 , λ1 , Write chλ forP . . . , λr ) for i λi w i . When the level of a weight is known, we will often drop the w 0 component. For example, the element kw0 of P+k (g) will be denoted by 0. The ? This research was supported in part by NSERC.
?? On leave from the Physics Dept, Univ. Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada.
2
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
corresponding quantities for the underlying finite-dimensional Lie algebra g¯ will always be denoted with a bar. Under the familiar action of SL2 (Z) on the Cartan subalgebras of g, we find that the span of the level k characters chλ is stable. In particular, define a matrix S by: X (z|z) −1 z Sλ,µ chµ (τ, z, u). , ,u − = chλ τ τ τ k µ∈P+ (g)
S has several interesting properties. Most importantly: Lemma 1 (Kac–Peterson [16]). Let chν¯ denote the Weyl character of g¯ with highest weight ν¯ . Then for any λ, µ ∈ P+k (g), we have both S0,µ 6 = 0 and Sλ,µ µ+ρ = chλ −2πi (1.1a) =: χλ (µ). S0,µ k By Lemma 1, a useful expression for χλ (µ) is χλ (µ) =
X
X
mλ (β) exp[−2π i
γ · (µ + ρ)
β∈(λ) γ ∈W β
k
],
(1.1b)
where W is the (finite) Weyl group, where (λ) is the set of dominant weights of the representation of g¯ with highest weight λ, and where mλ (β) is the weight multiplicity. A classical result is: Lemma 2 (Cartan [3]). For each ν¯ , we can write chν¯ = Pν¯ (chw1 , . . . , chwr ) for some polynomial Pν¯ (x1 , . . . , xr ). Therefore,
χλ (µ) = Pλ¯ (χw1 (µ), . . . , χwr (µ)),
(1.2)
for all µ ∈ P+k (g). Define the fusion matrices Nλ by Verlinde’s formula [21]: ν = (Nλ )νµ := Nλ,µ
X γ ∈P+k (g)
Sλ,γ
Sµ,γ ∗ S . S0,γ ν,γ
(1.3)
Equation (1.3) tells us that the Nλ are simultaneously diagonalized by S, and have eigenvalues χλ (µ). The fusion algebra (or Verlinde algebra) of g at level k can be defined to be the C-span of {Nλ : λ ∈ P+k (g)}. It is associative and commutative, with ν : unit N0 = I and integer structure constants Nλ,µ X ν Nλ,µ Nν . Nλ Nµ = ν∈P+k (g) k
In fact it is isomorphic as an algebra to CkP+ (g)k , defined with componentwise addition and multiplication, and so a critical ingredient here in our definition is the choice of preferred basis {Nλ : λ ∈ P+k (g)}. Fusion algebras (or the corresponding fusion ring) appear in many different contexts, e.g. in rational conformal field theory (RCFT) [21]. The RCFTs with fusion algebras of the type discussed here, i.e. those associated with
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
3
some g, are known as Wess–Zumino–Witten models. Fusion algebras also appear in the study of quantum groups [19] and Hecke algebras [14] at roots of unity, Chevalley groups at nonzero characteristic [12], and quantum cohomology [22]. Call a set 0 = {γ 1 , . . . , γ n } ⊂ P+k (g) a fusion-generator if any Nλ can be written as a polynomial1 in Nγ 1 , . . . , Nγ n – in other words, if for each λ ∈ P+k (g) there is a polynomial Pλ (x1 , . . . , xn ) such that χλ (µ) = Pλ (χγ 1 (µ), . . . , χγ n (µ))
∀µ ∈ P+k (g).
(1.4a)
Equivalently, 0 is a fusion-generator2 iff for any λ, µ ∈ P+k (g), the only way we can have (1.4b) χγ ` (λ) = χγ ` (µ) for all ` = 1, . . . , n, is when λ = µ. The equivalence of the statements of (1.4a) and (1.4b) can be seen as follows. First, if (1.4b) holds, then (1.4a) implies χφ (λ) = χφ (µ) for all φ ∈ P+k (g). Multiplying ∗ and summing over φ ∈ P k (g) gives λ = µ, by the unitarity of the this result by Sν,φ + matrix S. In the other direction, we need to construct a polynomial Pλ in n = k0k variables, taking values χλ (µ) at m = kP+k (g)k distinct points. Let x := (x1 , . . . , xn ) denote a point in Cn , and let x a , a = 1, . . . , m be the points at which the required polynomial must take the values ya . Here xa,j = χγ j (µa ) and ya = χλ (µa ), where a labels the different weights of P+k (g). A polynomial of minimal degree satisfying the requirements can be constructed by the Lagrange interpolation formula: P (x) =
m X a=1
ya
m Y b=1,b6=a
r · (x − x b ) . r · (x a − x b )
Here r can be any (constant) vector such that r · (x a − x b ) vanishes iff a = b. By the fusion-rank Rk (g), we mean the minimum possible cardinality n = k0k of a fusion-generator 0. Such a 0 is called a fusion-basis. Question 1. For a given g and k, what is the fusion-rank Rk (g), and what is a fusionbasis? This problem was studied by Di Francesco and Zuber [6]. For the applications it should suffice to get a reasonable upper bound for the fusion-rank, and to find a 0 which realizes that bound. Incidentally, it was proven in [1] that there will be a fusion potential [13] corresponding to any fusion-generator 0. Question 1 seems a natural one from the fusion algebra perspective, and is especially interesting considering that the fusion-rank often turns out to be surprisingly low. This analysis should have consequences for the work of Moody, Patera, Pianzola, . . . on elements of finite order in a finite-dimensional Lie group (see e.g. [18,20] and references therein). It has direct relevance for the classification of conformal field theories (more precisely, their 1-loop partition functions; see e.g. [9,11,10]). Our results may lead to a new presentation of the fusion algebras, along the lines of the Schubert calculus of [13,15]. As another example, we mention that our problem may be related to finding bases for the quantum cohomology of Grassmannians [22]. 1 By Lagrange interpolation, “polynomial” here is equivalent to “function”. 2 Our definition should not be confused with the “bootstrapped” version of a fusion-generator used in [10].
4
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
Incidentally, these fusion algebras all have a rank of one, in a sense: precisely, the Krull dimension of a fusion algebra will be one. It is not difficult to find an element N of the fusion algebra in which every fusion matrix Nλ will be a polynomial. These N however will in general be nontrivial linear combinations of our basis vectors (1.3). For the applications we are interested in, this observation is not helpful. There is a natural basis for the fusion algebra, namely P+k (g), and an important condition is that fusion-generators are required to be subsets of that basis. (1) We will address Question 1 for g = Ar in Sect. 3. Our best lower bound for (1) Rr,k := Rk (Ar ) is given in Thm. 1(2); our best upper bound and smallest fusiongenerator is given in Thm. 3. Corollary 1 tells us precisely when {w1 } is a fusiongenerator. Corollary 2 answers Question 1 when r or k is small, and Conjecture 1 gives our guess for a general statement. Another question related to this one, which we will consider in Sect. 4, is: (1)
Question 2. For g = Ar , when is Nw1 invertible? The first fundamental weight w 1 is especially interesting, since (1.1b) and its fusion numbers Nwν 1 ,µ are so simple. Incidentally, Nλ is invertible iff Nλσ is, for any Galois element σ (see (2.6) below) – this holds in fact for any RCFT [5]. However, the inverse of a fusion matrix will only itself be a fusion matrix in the trivial cases: (Nλ )−1 = Nµ iff both λ = J a 0 and µ = J −a 0 for some a ∈ Z, where J is given in (2.1b) – again the analogue holds for any RCFT. (The proof of this uses the fact that the inverse of a nonnegative integer matrix can itself be integral and non-negative, only if it is a permutation matrix.) Our best condition for Nw1 being invertible is given in Thm. 6(3), while our best conditions for noninvertibility are Thms. 6(4),(5). Together, these answer Question 2 for most r, k. Conjecture 2 gives our guess for the general answer. A final question, which we solve in Sect. 6, was asked in [4]. It is interesting because of the Galois action (2.6) on the matrix S and on the fusion coefficients. (1)
Question 3. For Ar , what are the number fields Kr,k and Lr,k generated over the rationals by the entries Sλ,µ , and by the fusion (Verlinde) eigenvalues χλ (µ), respectively? The primary purpose of this paper is to develop tools for the analysis of affine fusions. We focus mostly on the most important case: Ar,k . We believe that these three questions are both interesting and representative. 2. The Ar,k Modular Matrix S (1)
For now, let us restrict attention to Ar,k (i.e. Ar at level k). Write r := r + 1, P+r,k := (1) (1) P+k (Ar ) and Rr,k := Rk (Ar ). The symmetry group of its Coxeter-Dynkin diagram is the dihedral group on r elements, generated by an order 2 conjugation C and an order r simple current J : Cλ = λ0 w0 + J λ = λr w 0 +
r X i=1 r X i=1
λr+1−i w i ,
(2.1a)
λi−1 w i .
(2.1b)
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
5
These act on the χλ (µ) by χCλ (µ) = χλ (Cµ) = χλ (µ)∗ ,
(2.2a)
b
χJ a λ (J µ) = exp[2πi(b t (λ) + a t (µ) + kab)/r] χλ (µ), where t (λ) :=
r X
j λj
(2.2b)
(2.2c)
j =1
is called the r-ality. A useful relation is t (J a λ) ≡ ak + t (λ) (mod r).
(2.2d)
Another “symmetry” of χλ (µ), when k 6 = 1, is rank-level duality [2]: eτ λ (τ µ)∗ , χλ (µ) = exp[2π i t (λ) t (µ)/rk] χ
(2.3a)
where τ λ denotes the weight in P+k−1,r+1 corresponding to the transpose (sometimes called “conjugate”) of the Young diagram of λ, after deleting any columns of length k in the transposed diagram (reminder: the i th row of the Young diagram of λ has P r j =i λj boxes). This deletion is a consequence of (2.4f) below. We will usually denote the quantities of Ak−1,r+1 with tildes. For example, τ w` = `e w1 . τ defines a bijection r,k k−1,r+1 . Note that between the J -orbits in P+ and the J˜-orbits in P+ t˜(τ λ) ∈ t (λ) − kZ≥0 ,
(2.3b)
since t (λ) is the number of boxes in the Young diagram of λ. The Weyl group of Ar is the symmetric group Sr . This gives us an essential property of S: its relation to the symmetric polynomials. In particular, we can see from (1.1b) that (2.4a) χλ (µ) = exp[2π i t (λ) t (µ + ρ)/rk] Sλ (x1 , . . . , xr ), Pr where x` := exp[−2πi µ(`)/k] for µ(`) := j =` (µj + 1). Sλ is a polynomial over Z P P – the Schur polynomial of shape ( ri=1 λi , ri=2 λi , . . . , λr ) [8] – symmetric in the xi , and homogeneous of degree t (λ). It is often convenient to write Sλ as a polynomial X Y m cm y` ` , (2.4b) Qλ (y1 , . . . , yrk ) = m=(m1 ,... ,mrk )
`
evaluated at the “power sums” of our xi : y` =
r X i=1
xi` = P` (x1 , . . . , xr ).
(2.4c)
The coefficients cm of Qλ can be expressed in terms of the characters of the symmetric group Sr (this is essentially the Frobenius–Schur duality), and each nonzero cm will have P j mj = t (λ) [8]. We will also write Sλ [µ] and P` [µ], when convenient. Note that P` [J m µ] = exp[2π i ` µ(r − m)/k] P` [µ] .
(2.4d)
6
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
A valuable special case of (2.4a) is χw` (µ) = exp[2π i ` t (µ + ρ)/rk]
X
xi1 · · · xi` .
(2.4e)
1≤i1 <···
Symmetric polynomials have an important variable-specialisation property which permits the number of variables to be increased (with the extra variables set to 0), and yet all algebraic relations3 among the symmetric polynomials will be preserved. This permits us to define χλ when λ has more than r components, using (2.4a) with variables 0 = · · · = 0, and we find x10 = x1 , . . . , xr0 = xr , and xr+1 0 if λ` > 0 for some ` > r , (2.4f) χ(λ0 ,λ1 ,... ,λr ,... ) (µ) = otherwise χ(λ0 ,λ1 ,... ,λr ) (µ) valid for any µ ∈ P+r,k . This can be directly understood using for example the construction of Schur polynomials from Young Tableaux. A special case of (2.4f) is χwr = 1 and χw` = 0 for ` > r. We will use (2.4f) in several places – see e.g. the proof of Thm. 3. Call λ ∈ P+r,k a J d -fixed point if d is the smallest positive integer satisfying J d λ = λ – in other words if the λi have period d. We will say λ is a fixed point if it is a J d -fixed point for some d < r. Note that if ϕ is a fixed point of J d , we can speak of a “truncated d,kd/r . We have weight” (ϕ0 , ϕ1 , . . . , ϕd−1 ) =: ϕ 0 ; by (2.5a) below it will lie in P+ d−1 d−1 X X dk ϕi = ϕi0 , = r i=0
t (ϕ) =
(2.5a)
i=0
d−1 r X r −d r r −d j ϕj + k = t 0 (ϕ 0 ) + k , d 2 d 2
(2.5b)
j =1
where t 0 denotes d-ality. There exist J d -fixed points in P+r,k iff d divides r and r/d divides k. In other words, the smallest fixed-point period is r/gcd{r, k}, and all other possible periods are multiples of this number. Also, if ϕ is a J r/d -fixed point, its rank-level dual τ ϕ is a J˜k/d -fixed point. By (2.2b), if µ is a J d -fixed point, then χλ (µ) = 0 whenever t (λ) 6 ≡ 0 (mod r/d). The same comment holds for µ if instead λ is a J d -fixed point. This is certainly not the only source of zeros in the matrix S however, as we shall see, but it is an important one. In fact, there are many more zeros at fixed points than this simple r-ality test suggests. For example, of all weights λ with t (λ) = r/d, the entry Sλ,ϕ will equal zero for every J d -fixed point ϕ, unless λ is a hook ( dr − a)w1 + w a . We will describe below the set N Z(d) of all weights λ which can have nonzero entries at J d -fixed points. Moreover, many different weights λ 6 = µ – even in the set N Z(d) – will have the same value Sλ,ϕ = Sµ,ϕ at all J d -fixed points ϕ. For example, for the hooks λ with t (λ) = dr , we will have χλ (ϕ) = ±χwr/d (ϕ) for all ϕ, where the sign is independent of ϕ. More generally, note that the right side of (2.8c) is independent of a 00 , except for the unimportant sign. 3 Such as (2.4), but not e.g. (2.3a), (2.6) or (2.8). More precisely, specialisation defines a homomorphism between the polynomial rings, taking Schur polynomials to Schur polynomials, power sums to power sums, etc.
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
7
Hence fixed point considerations are very important for both Questions 1 and 2, and play a large role in this paper. An unexpected symmetry of the matrix S is the Galois action discussed in [5]. For any σ ∈ Gal(Kr,k /Q), there exists a permutation µ 7 → σ µ of P+r,k such that σ Sλ,µ = σ (µ) Sλ,σ µ , σ χλ (µ) = χλ (σ µ),
(2.6a) (2.6b)
where σ (µ) ∈ {±1}. Similar equations hold for any other affine algebra g, and more generally for any RCFT. The field Kr,k here is generated over Q by all elements Sλ,µ ; if instead we are only interested in the permutation µ 7 → σ µ, and not the “parities” σ (µ), then we are more concerned with the effective Galois group Gal(Lr,k /Q) coming from the subfield Lr,k generated over Q by the fusion eigenvalues χλ (µ). Incidentally, Galois orbits tend to be nicely behaved – see e.g. Thm. 8 below. They also have been studied in the “elements of finite order” Lie group context – see e.g. [18, 20]. Galois group considerations are central to many arguments in this paper, so next we will quickly review the cyclotomic Galois group. The cyclotomic field Qn := Q[exp[2π i/n]] consists of all polynomials in ξn := exp[2π i/n]. The Galois group Gn := Gal(Qn /Q) is isomorphic to the multiplicative group (Z/nZ)× of integers coprime to n, taken mod n. More precisely, any automorphism σ ∈ Gn corresponds to some integer ` ∈ (Z/nZ)× , in such a way that σ ξn = ξn` . We write σ` for this σ . The classic example of a Galois automorphism is complex conjugation, which always corresponds to ` = −1. A subfield F of Qn will have Galois group Gal(F /Q) isomorphic to a factor group (equivalently here, a subgroup) of (Z/nZ)× . The previous properties of S are all well known. The following one, which relates S entries at fixed points to S entries at both smaller rank and level, appears to be new. We will call it fixed-point factorisation. Let ϕ be a fixed point of J d for Ar,k . Then we will show that χλ (ϕ) = 0 unless (i)
(i)
(∗) for each i = 1, . . . , r/d, there are precisely d integers 1 ≤ `1 < · · · < `d ≤ r P (i) for which λ(`j ) ≡ −i (mod r/d). (Recall λ(a) := rb=a (λb + 1).) Assume this for now. (∗) implies dr will divide t (λ) – which we already know – but it is much stronger. Write N Z(d) for the set of all weights λ ∈ P+r,k which obey (∗). We will see below that λ ∈ N Z(d)
⇐⇒
χλ
r/d−1 kd X di w 6= 0. r
(2.7a)
i=0
The fixed-point argument of this last equation has truncated weight 00 . Consider any λ ∈ N Z(d). Let π be the unique permutation of {1, . . . , r} defined by the following rule: for each 1 ≤ i ≤
r d
(i)
and 1 ≤ j ≤ d, put π(i + (j − 1) dr ) = `j . d−1,kd/r
π will exist iff (∗) holds. For each such i, let λ0(i) denote the weight in P+ with Dynkin labels (i) (i) λ(`j ) − λ(`j +1 ) (i) −1 (2.7b) λ0 j = r/d
8
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton d−1,kd/r
for j = 1, . . . , d − 1. As above, let ϕ 0 ∈ P+ (ϕ0 , ϕ1 , . . . , ϕd−1 ). Then we obtain the “factorisations” Sλ,ϕ = sgn π ξ (−1)t (λ)(1−d/r)
be the truncated weight
r r/d−1 2
Sλ0 0(1) ,ϕ 0 · · · Sλ0 0(r/d) ,ϕ 0 , k χλ (ϕ) = sgn π ξ (−1)t (λ)(1−d/r) χλ0 0(1) (ϕ 0 ) · · · χλ0 0(r/d) (ϕ 0 ),
(2.8a) (2.8b)
P (i) where ξ is the kd/r th root of unity equal to exp[2π i t 0 (ϕ 0 + ρ 0 ) i (λd + i − r/d)], and 0 0 where primes denote quantities in Ad−1,kd/r (we take S = χ = 1 for d = 1). Perhaps some examples at low rank and level will be helpful. For r = 3, k = 4, the only fixed points are (ϕ0 , ϕ1 , ϕ2 , ϕ3 ) = (2, 0, 2, 0), (0, 2, 0, 2), and (1, 1, 1, 1). N Z(1) consists of the J -orbits of (4,0,0,0) and (2,1,0,1), for a total of 8 weights out of the full 35. N Z(2) contains N Z(1) plus the J -orbits of (3, 0, 1, 0), (2, 2, 0, 0) and (2, 0, 2, 0), increasing the number of weights to 18 out of 35. All three fixed points are in the simple-current orbits of weights of the special type indicated in (2.7a) (for d = 1 or 2). Therefore, for these fixed points ϕ, we must have Sϕ,λ 6 = 0 for all weights λ in the appropriate N Z(d). For r = 3, k = 8, d = 2, however, there are fixed points such as ϕ = (3, 1, 3, 1) that are not of the type in (2.7a), i.e. (4, 0, 4, 0). In this case, we find that S(3,1,3,1),λ 6= 0 for only 48 weights λ, while N Z(2) has cardinality 75 (and kP+3,8 k = 165). The large discrepancy here between “48” and “75” is not surprising and is explained by (2.8): χϕ0 0 will vanish at a fifth of the points of P+2,4 . Incidentally, the total number of weights satisfying t (λ) ≡ 0 (mod r/d) is 85. This means there are 10 weights that satisfy the r-ality test necessary for χλ (ϕ) 6 = 0, yet still have χλ (ϕ) = 0 for all ϕ. Condition (∗) will become more severe as r and k increase. For example, with r = 3 and d = 2, the numbers of weights in N Z(2) compared with those with even r-ality, compared with those in P+3,k are: 196, 231, and 455 for k = 12; and 405, 489, and 969 for k = 16. As an example of how “factor weights” {λ0(i) } are found, consider the weight λ = (0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0) at r = 11, k = 6. Fix d = 4. The corresponding partition labels {λ(`)} are {17, 16, 14, 13, 12, 10, 8, 6, 5, 3, 1, 0}. Those congruent to −1 (mod r/d = 3) are {17, 14, 8, 5}. From these we find λ0(1) = (1, 0, 1, 0), where the zeroth Dynkin label is set so that the factor weight is at level kd/r = 2. We find λ0(2) = (0, 0, 0, 2) and λ0(3) = (1, 1, 0, 0) in similar fashion. For a more general example, consider any hook λ = aw1 + wb . It will lie in N Z(d) iff r/d divides a + b, in which case we find χaw1 +wb (ϕ) = ξ (−1)a+b+c+(a
00 +1)(c+a 0 +1)
χ(a 0 −1)w01 +w0c−a0 +1 (ϕ 0 ),
(2.8c)
where c = (a + b)d/r and a = dr a 0 − a 00 , for a 00 ∈ {1, . . . , dr }, and where ξ = 1 unless b > r − r/d, in which case ξ = exp[2π i t 0 (ϕ 0 + ρ 0 )r/dk]. The permutation π here is the product of c − a 0 + 1 disjoint a 00 -cycles. In this example, each λ0(i) = 00 except for 00 0 λ(a ) = (a 0 − 1)w01 + w0c−a +1 . Equation (2.8c) says that hooks in P+r,k act like hooks in d−1,kd/r , when their fusion eigenvalues are restricted to fixed points of J d . The most P+ interesting special case of (2.8c) is 0 χ (ϕ 0 ) if r/d divides ` . (2.8d) χw` (ϕ) = w0`d/r 0 otherwise
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
9
Lemma 3 (Fixed-point factorisation). Choose any Ar,k , any divisor d of gcd{r, k}, and any λ ∈ P+r,k . Then exactly one of the following holds: (i) Sλ,ϕ = χλ (ϕ) = 0 for all fixed points ϕ of J d ; or (ii) λ ∈ N Z(d) and so λ obeys (2.8a), (2.8b) for every fixed point ϕ of J d . The leading signs in (2.8) are independent of ϕ and so for our purposes are of no significance. The phase ξ depends only on ϕ and will often equal 1. Of course the right side of (2.8b) can be “linearised” by expanding it out using fusion coefficients. Conversely, it leads to the curious observation that the fusion coefficients of Ar,k can be seen in the fusion eigenvalues of A2r+1,2k evaluated at fixed points. At present we do not have formulas of equal generality for the other affine algebras with simple currents. Since their Coxeter–Dynkin diagrams are similarly related by the (1) “folding” by a simple current, one would expect that E6 would be related in this way (1) (1) (1) (1) to G2 , E7 to F4 , Dr for its vector simple current (i.e. the one interchanging w0 (1) and w1 , and wr−1 and wr ) to Cr−2 , etc. Perhaps an algebraic understanding of these equations can be obtained from the ideas in e.g. [7]. To prove Eqs. (2.8), first note that P` [ϕ] =
r
0 0 d P`d/r [ϕ ]
0
if r/d divides ` , otherwise
(2.9a)
0 [ϕ 0 ] or 0 (for r|d`, r 6 |d`, from which we immediately obtain that H` [ϕ] equals H`d/r respectively), for the “complete” symmetric polynomials H` := S`w1 , since (2.4b) for λ = `w 1 takes a simple form [8]. We have the determinantal formula [8]
Sλ = det(Hλ(i)−r+j )1≤i,j ≤r =
X
sgn σ Hλ(σ 1)−r+1 · · · Hλ(σ r)−r+r .
(2.9b)
σ
In this formula, H0 identically equals 1, and for negative `, H` is identically 0. Evaluated at the fixed point ϕ, this will be a sparse matrix: each row will have at most d nonzero elements, spaced r/d entries apart. If Sλ [ϕ] 6 = 0, then some prod(i) (i) uct Hλ(σ 1)−r+1 [ϕ] · · · Hλ(σ r)−r+r [ϕ] 6 = 0, and thus {`1 , . . . , `d } = {σ i, σ (i + dr ), . . . , σ (i + r − dr )} for each i. This shows that (∗) is satisfied, and that the permutation π exists. The sum in (2.9b) can be restricted to those σ in the coset (Sd )×(r/d) π ⊂ Sr , where the i th factor Sd permutes the indices congruent to i (mod r/d). So (2.9b) can now be written as the product of determinants, the i th one of which corresponds to the d−1,kd/r (note that (2.4f) is implicit in (2.7b)), which gives us (2.8b). weight λ0(i) ∈ P+ P di 0 0 Equation (2.7a) follows from (2.8b) and the fact that ( kd i w ) = 0 . Using the r product formula (= Weyl denominator formula) for S0,µ , we can show S0,ϕ =
r/d−1 2 r k
(S00 0 ,ϕ 0 )r/d .
Together with (2.8b), this immediately gives us (2.8a).
(2.9c)
10
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
3. Fusion-rank of Ar,k The original polynomial realisation [13,15] uses the Cartan fusion-generator 0 = {w1 , . . . , wr }, which works by Lemma 2. We can do better. From (2.2a) and Lemma 2, we see that Rr,k ≤ 2r , with 0 = {w1 , . . . , wbr/2c }, where bxc is the largest integer not larger than x. For example, the fusion-rank of A1,k and A2,k equals 1 for all k, with {w 1 } a fusion-generator. This result for A2 was first obtained in [6], though by a more complicated argument. We also obtain, from Thm. 2(3) below (rank-level duality), the bound Rr,k ≤ 2k + 1. We begin by collecting a few simple consequences of the previous comments. Parts (1) and (3) of Thm. 1 are technical facts we will use repeatedly in the rest of the paper. Theorem 1(2) gives a fairly strong lower bound on Rr,k . We give some consequences of Thm. 1(4) in the paragraph before Conjecture 1. Theorem 1 (Simple-current constraints). (1) Let 0 be a fusion-generator, and choose any µ ∈ P+r,k . Let 0µ be the set of all γ ∈ 0 for which χγ (µ) 6 = 0. Let d = gcd{r, k, t (γ )|γ ∈0µ } (put d = r if 0µ = ∅). Then µ is a J r/d -fixed point. (2) (Our best lower bound). LetQ 0 be any fusion-generator. Write out the prime decomposition D := gcd{r, k} = piai , where each prime pi is distinct. Then X ai . Rr,k ≥ If D 6 = r, we get the stronger bound Rr,k ≥ 1 +
X
ai .
More precisely, for each pi , and each `, 1 ≤ ` ≤ ai , there must be some γ ∈ 0 ∩ N Z(rpi` /D) (see Lemma 3) with gcd{D, t (γ )} = D/pi` . When D 6 = r, there must also be some γ ∈ 0 ∩ N Z(r/D) whose r-ality t (γ ) is a multiple of D. (3) Suppose J r/d µ = µ and J r/d ν = ν for some divisor d of r. Then for any weight λ, χλ (µ) = χλ (ν) 6 = 0 implies t (λ) t (µ) ≡ t (λ) t (ν) (mod d r). (4) When k 1 is some multiple of k 2 , then Rr,k1 ≥ Rr,k2 . Proof. (1) Let µ be a J c -fixed point. Then from the previous remarks, c must divide r, and r/c must divide both k and t (γ ) for each γ ∈ 0µ . Therefore c must be a multiple of r/d. Moreover χγ (J r/d µ) = χγ (µ) for all γ ∈ 0µ (hence all γ ∈ 0); since 0 is a fusion-generator this means J r/d µ = µ, and hence c = r/d. (2) We know that for every divisor d of D, there are J r/d -fixed points (more than one, unless d = D = r). Choose such a fixed point ϕ, say. Let 0ϕ be as in (1) – necessarily 0ϕ ⊆ N Z(r/d). Then, by (1), gcd{r, k, t (γ )|γ ∈0ϕ } = d. So we see there must be a subset 0d ⊆ 0, namely 0d = 0ϕ , such that gcd{D, t (γ )|γ ∈0d } = d. Note that each 0D/p` must contain some weight γ with gcd{D, t (γ )} = D/pi` (otherwise different i
J r/d -fixed points would not be distinguished by 0). This gives the first bound. If r 6= D, then there will be several J r/D -fixed points, and in order for 0 to distinguish them, 0D must be nonempty. This gives the second bound. (3) Let P` be the `th power sum polynomial (2.4c). From (2.4d) and (2.5a), P` [µ] 6 = 0 requires d to divide `. Consider the m = (m1 , m2 , . . . )th term in Qλ (see (2.4b)); either it will vanish at µ, or d will divide each ` with m` 6= 0. Since P` [µ] lies in the cyclotomic
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
11
field Q[exp[2πi `/k]], we find that Sλ [µ] lies in the cyclotomic field Q[exp[2π i d/k]]. Therefore (2.4a) applied to χλ (µ) = χλ (ν) 6 = 0 gives us the desired conclusion. (4) First note that we have the containment k 1 (P+r,k2 + ρ) ⊂ P+r,k1 + ρ. Moreover, k2
(1)
(2)
for any weight γ we have χγ ( k 1 (µ + ρ) − ρ) = χγ (µ) for all µ ∈ P+r,k2 , where the k2
superscripts indicate that k1 or k2 should be substituted for k in (1.1b). Suppose 0 (1) is a (2) (2) fusion-generator for Ar,k1 . Then for any µ, ν ∈ P+r,k2 , if we have χγ (µ) = χγ (ν) for all γ ∈ 0 (1) , then we know µ = ν. Now the ρ-shifted action of the affine Weyl group at level k2 will map any weight γ ∈ 0 (1) either to some γ 0 ∈ P+r,k2 or onto the “boundary” (2) (2) of P+r,k . In the former case we get χγ (µ) = ±χγ 0 (µ), for some sign independent of (2)
µ. In the latter case χγ (µ) = 0 for any µ, and can be ignored. Therefore, the set of weights γ 0 in P+r,k2 obtained in this way from those in 0 (1) will be a fusion-generator t for Ar,k2 . u Equation (2.3a) suggests that the fusion-generators for Ar,k should be related to those of Ak−1,r+1 . This is indeed so: Theorem 2 (Rank-level duality). (1) Suppose r does not divide k. Then Rr,k ≥ Rk−1,r+1 . Moreover, if 0 = {γ 1 , . . . , γ n } 0 = {J˜a1 τ γ 1 , . . . , J˜an τ γ n } is one for Ak−1,r+1 , is a fusion-generator for Ar,k , then e where each ai is chosen so that gcd{ai r + t (γ i ), k} = gcd{t (γ i ), r, k} for each i. (2) If r does not divide k, and k does not divide r, then Rr,k = Rk−1,r+1 ; in this case 0 , defined in (1), will be one for Ak−1,r+1 . if 0 is a fusion-basis for Ar,k , then e (3) If r does divide k, then Rr,k ≤ Rk−1,r+1 ≤ Rr,k + 1. Using the notation of (1), ˜ τ γ 1 , . . . , τ γ n } is a fusion-generator for Ak−1,r+1 . {J˜0, Proof. (1) Any weight of P+k−1,r+1 can be expressed as J˜b τ µ for some integer b and some weight µ ∈ P+r,k . So, it suffices to consider any µ, µ0 ∈ P+r,k and b ∈ Z for which eJ˜ai τ γ i (J˜b τ µ0 ) χ eJ˜ai τ γ i (τ µ) = χ
∀i ,
(3.1a)
and show that this implies τ µ = J˜b τ µ0 . Equation (3.1a) becomes χγ i (µ) = exp[2πi {rai + t (γ i )} {t (µ) − t (µ0 ) − rb}/rk] χγ i (µ0 ).
(3.1b)
Define 0µ as in Thm. 1(1). Because r does not divide k, we know 0µ 6= ∅. Equation (3.1b) and Thm. 1(1) imply that µ and µ0 will both be J r/d -fixed points, where d = gcdγ i ∈0µ {ai r + t (γ i ), k}. Then τ µ and J˜b τ µ0 will both be J˜k/d -fixed points. For each γ i ∈ 0µ , Thm. 1(3) and (3.1a) imply {rai + t (γ i )} {t (µ) − t (µ0 ) − rb} ≡ 0 (mod d k) . 0
(3.1c)
For each prime p|k, write p a and pa for the exact powers dividing k and d, re0 spectively: i.e. p a kk and pa kd. So a ≥ a 0 . If a = a 0 , then pa must divide both r and 0 t (µ) − t (µ0 ), by (2.5b). If a > a 0 , then pa k(rai + t (γ i )), for some γ i ∈ 0µ . Therefore 0 (3.1c) tells us that L := {t (µ)−t (µ )−rb}/k is an integer. Equation (3.1b) then implies χγ i (µ) = χγ i (J L µ0 ) for all i. Therefore µ = J L µ0 , so we may take µ = µ0 in (3.1a),
12
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
and absorb the L into b. Then r/d must divide L, i.e. k/d must divide b, i.e. J˜b τ µ = τ µ, and we see that (3.1a) can only be trivially satisfied. Hence Rk−1,r+1 ≤ Rr,k . (2) is immediate from part (1). (3) The first inequality comes from (1). That the given set is a fusion-generator follows by the proof of (1). More precisely, by replacing J˜ai τ γ i with J˜0˜ in (3.1a) implies L ∈ Z. The rest of the argument is as before. u t The Chinese Remainder Theorem tells us that it is always possible to choose the ai ’s in Thm. 2(1). Incidentally, in all cases of which we know, Rk−1,r+1 = 1 + Rr,k when r < k divides k. Earlier we suggested the upper bound Rr,k ≤ r/2, and now we also know Rr,k ≤ k + 1 (or k/2 if k fails to divide r). In fact we can do much better than this for most 2 pairs (r, k). The argument relies on the cyclotomic Galois group Gn described briefly in the previous section. Theorem 3 (Galois considerations). 0÷ := {w d : 2d ≤ r and d divides k } is a fusion-generator for Ar,k , called the divisor generator. A related fusion-generator is τ , defined by 0÷ {wd : 2d ≤ k and d divides k} when k does not divide r τ . := 0÷ k when k divides r {w } ∪ {wd : 2d ≤ k and d divides k} τ can be replaced with any hook `w 1 + w d−` for Moreover, each w d in 0÷ and 0÷ 1 ≤ ` ≤ d. th
Proof. The key observation here is that, because each xj is a k root of unity, for any ` there will exist a Galois automorphism σ ∈ Gk for which σ Pd (x1 , . . . , xr ) = P` (x1 , . . . , xr ),
(3.2)
where d = gcd{`, k}. Suppose, for all d ≤ r/2 dividing k, that χwd (µ) = χwd (µ0 ).
(3.3a)
We will show this implies µ = µ0 . Equations (3.3a) and (2.4a) give Swd [µ] = ξ d Swd [µ0 ]
(3.3b)
for all d ≤ r/2 dividing k, where ξ = exp[−2πi (t (µ) − t (µ0 ))/rk]. Equation (2.4b) reads Sw` [µ] =
(−1)`+1 ˙ ` (P1 [µ], . . . , P`−1 [µ]) P` [µ] + Q `
(3.4a)
˙ ` homogeneous in the same sense as Qλ (and so has no constant for some polynomial Q term). Let d be the smallest ` with P` [µ] 6 = 0. Then (3.4a) implies Sw` [µ] = 0 for all ` < d and Swd [µ] = ± d1 Pd [µ] 6 = 0, so either d = r (in which case µ = ( kr , kr , . . . , kr ) = µ0 ), or d ≤ r/2 by (2.2a). But (3.2) requires d to divide k, if it is to be minimal. Thus th (3.3b) holds. However both Swd [µ] and Swd [µ0 ] lie in Qk/d , so ξ must be a k root of unity.
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
13
We next want to show, by induction on `, that P` [µ] = ξ ` P` [µ0 ]
(3.4b)
for all ` ≤ r/2. If we could show this, we would be done, because by (3.4a) it would force χw` (µ) = χw` (µ0 ) for all ` ≤ r/2, i.e. µ = µ0 . Equation (3.4b) is clearly true for P1 = S1 , using (3.3b) with d = 1. By (3.2), it is then true for all ` with gcd{`, k} = 1. Take any divisor d ≤ r/2 of k, and suppose (3.4b) is true for all ` < d. Using (3.3b), Eq. (3.4a) means that (3.4b) is true for ` = d, and hence all ` with gcd{`, k} = d. Therefore (3.4b) is indeed true for all ` ≤ r/2, and µ = µ0 . The above remarks continue to hold if we replace each w d with any hook `w1 +w d−` (of all the weights λ with t (λ) = d, only the hooks have the variable yd appearing nontrivially in the corresponding polynomial Qλ (yi ) – see e.g. p.51 of [8]). Theorem 2 τ (the hooks dw 1 and J 0 = kw 1 can be applied to 0÷ gives us the fusion-generator 0÷ d k t replaced here with w and w , respectively). u In many special cases, most notably Cor. 1 and Cor. 2 below, we can prove that the divisor generator 0÷ is actually a fusion-basis. Another example: suppose gcd{r, k} = p ` for some prime p, so k will equal pm q for some m ≥ ` and some number q coprime to p. If all prime divisors of q are larger than r/2, then 0÷ will be a fusion-basis, and Rr,k = ` + 1 (if r 6 = p ` ) or Rr,k = ` (if r = p ` ). The reason is that here the lower bound for Rr,k from Thm. 1(2) agrees with the upper bound from Thm. 3. A special case of this occurs when both r and k are powers of p. In fact we know of only a few examples (for r ≤ k) where the divisor generator is not a fusion-basis. For r = 4, for example, we find by computer that the fusion-rank is one for k = 5, 9, 17 and 21. On the other hand, the computer program tells us that the fusion-rank is 2 for r = 4 and k = 7, 11, 13 and 15. This implies, by Thm. 1(4), that whenever k is a multiple of 12,16,18 or 20, R4,k = 2 and 0÷ will be a fusion-basis. Conjecture 1. At fixed rank r, the divisor generator 0÷ is a fusion-basis for all sufficiently high levels k. For reasons of simplicity, the case of greatest interest is when 0 = {w1 } is a fusiongenerator. The complete solution to this is a consequence of this theorem: Theorem 4. 0 = {w 1 , w2 , . . . , wm } is a fusion-generator of Ar,k iff 0÷ ⊆ 0 or τ ⊆ 0. 0÷ Proof. “⇐” is immediate from Thm. 3. “⇒” Suppose we could find a polynomial p(x) = x m1 + · · · + x m` − x n1 − · · · − x n` , not identically 0, such that: (a) (b) (c) (d)
` < r, 1 ≤ m1 < · · · < m` < k and 1 ≤ n1 < · · · < n` < k, x = exp[2πia/k] is a root of p(x), for each a = 1, 2, . . . , m, and P` P` i=1 mi = i=1 ni .
14
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
Then there would exist weights λ 6 = µ in P+r,k obeying χwa (λ) = χwa (µ) for each a = 1, . . . , m – in other words, 0 could not in this case be a fusion-generator. To see this, choose any r − ` distinct integers hi such that h1 = 0, the remaining hi obey 1 ≤ hi < k, and {hi } ∩ {mi } = {hi } ∩ {ni } = ∅. The hi and mj together equal the r values of λ(i), and the hi and nj together equal the r values of µ(i). Since p(x) 6 ≡ 0, we know µ 6 = λ. Condition (c) says that Pa [λ] = Pa [µ] for all a ≤ m, and (d) is just the statement that t (λ + ρ) = t (µ + ρ). Hence (c) together with induction on (3.4a) is equivalent to saying χwa (λ) = χwa (µ) for those a, and we are done. It is easy to find this polynomial in many cases. In particular, let d be the largest divisor of k with 2d ≤ min{r, k}, and assume d > m. Take p(x) to be (x 4 − x 3 − x 2 + x)(x k−n + x k−2n + · · · + x n + 1), where n = k/d. Then (c) and (d) are automatically satisfied. ` = 2d here, so (a) will be satisfied unless d = r/2. Also, (b) will be satisfied unless n ≤ 4, which can only happen if d = r/2 = k/2. This argument breaks down only when d = r/2. However, when r/2 divides k, there will be J 2 -fixed points, and by Thm. 1(2) we would require some γ ∈ 0 with t (γ ) a multiple of r/2 if 0 is to be a fusion-generator. τ is if simultaneously k|r, The ony remaining way 0 could fail to contain 0÷ ∩ 0÷ r 6 = k, and m < k. But then Thm. 1(2) applies, and 0 would not be able to distinguish t the J r/k -fixed points. u Corollary 1 (The first-fundamental generator). 0 = {w1 } is a fusion-generator iff both: (i) each prime divisor p of k satisfies 2p > min {r, k}, and (ii) either r divides k, or gcd{r, k} = 1. Incidentally, the proof of Thm. 4 also implies that at least one weight γ in any fusiongenerator must have t (γ ) ≥ d, where d is the largest divisor of k with d ≤ r/2 and d ≤ k/2. If this γ is not a hook, then in fact t (γ ) would have to be strictly larger than d. Corollary 2. Some fusion-bases for Ar,k are: 0÷ = {w1 } for r = 1 and 2, ∀k ≥ 1; 0÷ = {w1 } for r = 3 when k is odd; 0÷ = {w1 , w 2 } for r = 3 when k is even; τ = {w 1 } for k = 1, ∀r ≥ 1; 0÷ τ = {w 1 } for k = 2 and any even r; both 0 = {J 0, w 1 } and 0 τ = {w 1 , w 2 } for 0÷ ÷ k = 2 and any odd r > 1; τ = {w 1 } for k = 3 and any r coprime to 3; both 0 = {J 0, w 1 } and 0 τ = {w 1 , w 3 } • 0÷ ÷ for k = 3 and any multiple r > 3 of 3; τ = {w 1 } for k = 4 when r is even; 0 = {w 1 , w 2 } for k = 4 when r ≡ 1 (mod 4), • 0÷ ÷ τ = {w 1 , w 2 , w 4 } for k = 4 when r ≡ 3 r > 4; and both 0 = {J 0, w 1 , w 2 } and 0÷ (mod4), r > 4. • • • •
Corollary 2 follows immediately from Thm. 1(2) and Thm. 3. Some of these fusionbases are collected in the table. Corollary 2 tells us the fusion-rank when either r ≤ 3 or k ≤ 4. In addition, other fusion-bases are 0÷ = {w1 } for r = 4 when k is even, for r = 5 τ = {w 1 } for k = 6 when r is coprime to 6; 0 = {w 1 , w 2 } when k is coprime to 6, and 0÷ ÷ τ = {w 1 , w 2 } for k = 6 when r ≡ 1, 3 (mod for r = 5 when k ≡ 2, 4 (mod 6), and 0÷ τ = {w 1 , w 3 } for k = 6 6); and 0÷ = {w1 , w3 } for r = 5 when k ≡ 3 (mod 6), and 0÷ when r ≡ 2 (mod 6). The simplest cases we do not yet know the answer for are: r = 4
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
15
Table 1. Listed are Ar,k fusion-bases for low ranks and/or levels. The symbols | in rows of the table delimit sequences of fusion-bases that repeat indefinitely as the level k increases. For increasing ranks r, overlines and underlines work similarly in the columns. “l” signifies that Nw1 is invertible (see Sect. 4) r \ k
1
2
3
4
5
1
|{w 1 }| l
{w 1 }
{w 1 } l
{w 1 }
{w 1 } l
2
|{w 1 }| l
{w 1 } l
{w 1 }
{w 1 } l
{w 1 } l
3
|{w 1 } l
{w 1 , w2 }|
{w 1 } l
{w 1 , w2 }
{w 1 } l
4
{w 1 } l
{w1 } l
{w 1 } l
{w 1 } l
{w 2 }
5
{w 1 } l
{w 1 , w2 }
{w 1 , w3 }
{w 1 , w2 }
{w 1 } l
6
{w 1 } l
{w1 } l
{w 1 } l
{w 1 } l
{w 1 , w2 }
7
{w 1 } l
{w 1 , w2 }
{w 1 } l
{w 1 , w2 , w4 }
{w 1 } l
8
{w 1 } l
{w1 } l
{w 1 , w3 }
{w 1 } l
{2w 2 + w 5 } l
when k is odd (R ≤ 2); r = 5 when 6 divides k (R = 2 or 3); k = 5 when r is even (R ≤ 3); and k = 6 when 6 divides r (R = 3 or 4). Obviously to go further we need a better lower bound. Theorem 1(2) is the best we have, but it only exploits the presence of fixed points. 4. The Fusion Matrix of w 1 There are many times when it is useful to know whether particular S matrix elements are nonzero. This is the case for example in almost every modular invariant partition function classification attempt – e.g. see the underlying assumption in [17]. It is especially useful to answer this for the first fundamental weight w1 – in Thm. 5 below we give some consequences. For later convenience, define the sets Pr,k := {p prime : p ≤ min{r, k} and p divides k}, X ax x : ax ∈ Z≥0 }, Z≥ X := {
(4.1a) (4.1b)
x∈X
where X in (4.1b) is any set of natural numbers. Z≥ X is the set of all possible sums (repetitions allowed) of elements of X. For example, Z≥ {n} = {0, n, 2n, . . . } is the set of all nonnegative multiples of n. Theorem 5. (1) Suppose Sw1 ,µ = 0. Then Sλ,µ = 0 unless t (λ) ∈ Z≥ Pr,k . Both k and r must lie in Z≥ Pr,k . (2) Suppose there is only one prime divisor p of k not larger than min{r, k}. Then Sw1 ,µ = 0 iff µ is a fixed point. Proof. When k ≥ r, part (1) follows by considering the polynomial expression (2.4b) and using the Galois argument of (3.2): P` [µ] 6 = 0 requires ` ∈ Z≥ Pr,k . Taking λ = J 0 gives us k ∈ Z≥ Pr,k , and λ = wr (see (2.4f)) gives us r ∈ Z≥ Pr,k . When k < r, to show that we can restrict to primes p ≤ k, we use rank-level duality (2.3a) to get that t˜(τ λ) ∈ Z≥ Pr,k and then t (λ) ∈ Z≥ Pr,k follows from (2.3b) and the fact that k ∈ Z≥ Pr,k . For part (2), use part (1) and Thm. 1(1) to get that µ must be fixed by J r/p . t u
16
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
Note that the hypothesis of (2) holds whenever k is a power of a prime. This special case follows directly from (4.2) below, by using Gauss’ Lemma on factorising integral polynomials, and evaluating certain factored polynomials at 1. Theorem 5(2) however is much more general. Nw1 is invertible iff Sw1 ,µ 6 = 0 for all µ ∈ P+r,k . Equivalently, Nw1 is invertible iff r X
exp[2π i µ(j )/k] 6 = 0
j =1
∀µ ∈ P+r,k .
(4.2)
It is not hard to show that for k ≤ 4 or r ≤ 4, Nw1 is invertible iff gcd{r, k} = 1; in fact, for those r, k, χw1 (µ) = 0 only for fixed points µ. The identical conclusion holds for many other r and k, as we saw in Thm. 5(2). But Thms. 6(4),(5) below say that these cases are uncharacteristically well-behaved. For example, when r = 5, if 6 divides k ≥ 12, then Nw1 will not be invertible, even though there are no fixed points. Theorem 6 (Invertibility). (1) Nw1 is invertible iff N˜ w˜ 1 is, where the latter is the fusion matrix for Ak−1,r+1 . (2) If gcd{r, k} 6 = 1, then Nw1 cannot be invertible. (3) Nw1 is invertible if either r 6 ∈ Z≥ Pr,k or k 6∈ Z≥ Pr,k . (4) Suppose pq divides k, where p and q are distinct primes for which r ∈ Z≥ {p, q} – i.e. there exist nonnegative integers a, b such that ap + bq = r. If k ≥ pq(d qa e + d pb e), then Nw1 will not be invertible (dxe here denotes the smallest integer not smaller than x – e.g. d2e = 2, d3.1e = 4). (5) Suppose p1 , p2 , . . . , pn are primes dividing k for which r ∈ Z≥ {p1 , . . . , pn } – i.e. P Pj there exist nonnegative integers ai such that ai pi = r. If k ≥ pi pj h=i ah for any i < j , then Nw1 will not be invertible. Proof. (1) follows directly from (2.3a). (2) exploits the fact (see (2.2b)) that χw1 (ϕ) = 0 for any fixed point ϕ. (3) is a corollary of Thm. 5(1). (4) We want to construct a particular µ ∈ P+r,k such that χw1 (µ) = 0. To do this we find an arithmetic sequence pk Z + ci for each i = 1, . . . , a, and an arithmetic sequence k 0 q Z + cj
for each j = 1, . . . , b, such that none of these a + b sequences intersect. This
is easy to do, provided k is big enough. Choose as the ci ’s 0, qk , . . . , qk (q − 1), 1, 1 + k q,...
, 1 + qk (q − 1), etc., until we have chosen a of them (the last one will be d qa e − 1
plus some multiple of
k q ).
Next choose as the cj0 ’s d qa e, d qa e +
chosen b of them (the last one will be
d qa e
+
d pb e
k p,...,
until we have
− 1 plus some multiple of
k p ).
Our
a + b sequences will be disjoint, provided the bound on k is satisfied, and will intersect the interval 0 ≤ x < k in precisely ap + bq = r points. Let µ be the unique weight in P+r,k whose µ(`) equal those r points. Then χw1 (µ) = 0, because the sum in (4.2) along each of the a + b sequences is 0. (5) follows immediately from similar considerations: we are looking for ai series k k k Z pi + cij , where cij 6 ≡ ci` (mod pi ) for j 6 = `, and cij 6 ≡ ch` (mod pi ph ) for i 6 = h. Pi−1 t The choice cij = j − 1 + `=1 a` works. u
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
17
The proofs of Thms. P 6(4),(5) are constructive: their zeros arise when (4.2) finds itself p a sum of terms such as a=1 ξ a for ξ a primitive pth root of unity. A simple example of Thm. 6(4) is at r = 11, k = 30. With p = 3, q = 5, and a = 2, b = 1, the bound is saturated. One finds c1 = 0, c2 = 6 and c10 = 1. These yield 0, 10, 20; 6, 16, 26; and 1, 7, 13, 19, 25; respectively. So, there is a zero for the weight given by {µ(1), . . . , µ(r)} = {26, 25, 20, 19, 16, 13, 10, 7, 6, 1, 0}. Conjecture 2. For Ar,k , Nw1 fails to be invertible iff one can find distinct primes pi ≤ P k} dividing k and nonnegative integers ai , bi such that r = i ai pi and k = min{r, P i bi pi . In other words, we conjecture that the condition of Thm. 6(3) is an “iff”. Note that one way this condition will be satisfied is if gcd{r, k} 6 = 1. The conditions in Thms. 6(4),(5) are strongest when we take r < k (which without loss of generality we can). Also, the bound in 6(5) is best when the pi are labelled so that the largest are given indices near n/2. In practice the most useful special case of Thms. 6(4),(5) is: If one can find an odd prime p ≤ r for which 2p divides k and k ≥ 3p − 1, then Nw1 will not be invertible. The analogue of Thm. 1(4) is also valid here, but is not very useful. The answer to Question 2 for small r and k is indicated in the table. Computer checks were performed for r ≤ 9 and all levels k > r such that dim P+r,k < 300, 000. The results were consistent with Conjecture 2. Conjectures 1 and 2 are the simplest guesses consistent with our results, but it would be nice to test them against additional numerical data. Incidentally, conditions like “` ∈ Z≥ {n1 , . . . , nm }” are only strong when ` is small. For example, given any coprime numbers m and n, there are only (m − 1) (n − 1)/2 positive integers ` which do not lie in Z≥ {m, n} – the largest such ` is mn − m − n. So for fixed r, we know Conjecture 2 will hold for all sufficiently large k. 5. Extensions Because the fundamental weights are much simpler, the most interesting fusion-generators are the ones which consist only of fundamental weights: 0 ⊆ {w1 , . . . , wr }. We can speak of fundamental-fusion-generators and fundamental-fusion-rank FRr,k . All of the results in Sects. 3 and 4 also apply directly to FRr,k . By definition, Rr,k ≤ FRr,k , and Conjecture 1 predicts that, for fixed r, Rr,k = FRr,k for all sufficiently large k. Note however from the table that FR8,5 = FR4,9 = 2 while R8,5 = R4,9 = 1. Because of (2.8d), we can strengthen here the bound in Thm. 1(2). For example, if FRr,k equals the bound given in Thm. 1(2), then so must FRr/d−1,k/d for all divisors d of gcd{r, k}. One can also ask Question 2 for other weights, most importantly the other fundamental weights, and again (2.8b) will be very useful. For example, we know χw2 will vanish at some J 5 -fixed point of A9,14 , because Nw1 is not invertible for A4,7 . Of course Questions 1 and 2 can and should be asked of the fusion algebras for the other affine algebras, and similar arguments will apply. We have not investigated them, except to find some fusion-bases for C2,k and G2,k on the computer, and to get Thm. (1) 7 below for G2,k . Of course Rk (C2 ) must equal 2 for any even k, and we find the rank is also 2 for all odd k < 26 (the limit of our computer check), save k = 1, 3 and 9. For k = 1 and 9, the only fusion-bases are {w1 } and {2w1 + 6w2 }, respectively. At k = 3 there are four different fusion-bases: {2w 1 }, {w 2 }, {2w 1 + w2 }, and {2w2 }. A very
18
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
tempting conjecture is that the rank R(Cr,k ) equals 2 for all sufficiently large k (and probably for all k > 9). The situation for G2,k however is more surprising: Theorem 7. (1) When the level k is odd, {w 2 } is a fusion-basis for G2,k . (2) Nw2 fails to be invertible for G2,k iff either 4 or 30 divides k := k + 4. Proof. The key here is to reduce the G2,k quantities to A2,k+1 quantities, and use the fact that {w 1 } is a fusion-basis for A2,k+1 . Using (1.1b) and the simple Lie subalgebra A2 ⊂ G2 , we find χw2 (µ) = χ w1 (µ) + χ w2 (µ) + 1,
(5.1)
where underlines denote A2,k+1 quantities, and µ = µ1 w1 + (µ1 + µ2 + 1)w2 . So part (1) reduces to the following statement4 for A2,k+1 : for any λ, µ ∈ P+2,k+1 with λ 6 = Cλ and µ 6 = Cµ (only these nonselfconjugate weights correspond to G2,k ones), does the equality λ1 + 2λ2 + 3
) + cos(2π
λ2 − λ1
) + cos(2π
2λ1 + λ2 + 3
) (5.2a) 3k 3k 3k µ2 − µ1 2µ1 + µ2 + 3 µ1 + 2µ2 + 3 ) + cos(2π ) + cos(2π ) = cos(2π 3k 3k 3k
cos(2π
force either λ = µ or λ = Cµ? Write c1 , c2 , c3 for the three cosines on the left side of (5.2a), and write c10 , c20 , c30 for those on the right. Then (5.2a) says c1 + c2 + c3 = c10 + c20 + c30 , and since (2ν1 + ν2 + 3) + (ν2 − ν1 ) = ν1 + 2ν2 + 3, we also get c12 + c22 + c32 = 1 + 2c1 c2 c3 and c10 2 + c20 2 + c30 2 = 1 + 2c10 c20 c30 . Hit both sides of (5.2a) with the Galois automorphism σ2 (see Sect. 2). Since cos(2x) = 2 cos2 (x) − 1, we obtain c12 + c22 + c32 = c10 2 + c20 2 + c30 2 .
(5.2b)
Thus any symmetric polynomial in c1 , c2 , c3 will equal the corresponding symmetric polynomial in c10 , c20 , c30 . In particular 2λ1 + λ2 + 3 2 (5.2c) ) 3k 3k 3k µ2 − µ1 2µ1 + µ2 + 3 2 µ1 + 2µ2 + 3 ) − sin(2π ) − sin(2π ) . = sin(2π 3k 3k 3k
sin(2π
λ1 + 2λ2 + 3
) − sin(2π
λ2 − λ1
) − sin(2π
In other words, we know from (5.2a) that the real parts of χw1 (λ) and χw1 (µ) are equal, and from (5.2c) that their imaginary parts are also equal, up to a sign. Hence either λ = µ or λ = Cµ, and we have proven part (1). For part (2), note that χw2 (µ) = 0 is equivalent to (see (5.1)) 1 c1 + c2 + c3 = − , 2
(5.3a)
in the above notation. Consider first k odd. Then hitting (5.3a) with the Galois automorphism σ2 gives us c12 +c22 +c32 = 45 , and hence c1 c2 c3 = 18 . We can solve these equations, 4 For the remainder of the proof of part (1), we will switch to A 2,k+1 notation.
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
19
and we find 8ci3 +4ci2 −4ci −1 = 0, i.e. {c1 , c2 , c3 } = {cos(2π 17 ), cos(2π 27 ), cos(2π 37 )}. (1) However, these cosines cannot be realised by a weight in P+k (G2 ). Next, suppose k ≡ 2 (mod 4). We may assume (using G2,k notation) that exactly two of the arguments {3µ1 + 2µ2 + 5, µ2 + 1, 3µ1 + µ2 + 4} are odd, otherwise they would all be even and the argument would reduce to the k odd one. Here we use the automorphism σ3k/2−2 and find (relabeling the ci if necessary) that c32 − c12 − c22 = − 43 . We can solve for ci as before, and we find that either c3 = cos(2π 15 ) and {c1 , c2 } = 7 13 1 11 ), cos(2π 30 )}, or c3 = cos(2π 25 ) and {c1 , c2 } = {cos(2π 30 ), cos(2π 30 )}. {cos(2π 30 Either possibility requires 30 to divide k, in order to be realised by a weight of G2,k . When (1) 30 divides k, we do indeed get zeros: µ = (k/3 − 1, k/30 − 1, 3k/5 − 1) ∈ P+k (G2 ) works. (1) t Finally, suppose 4 divides k. Then µ = (k/4, k/4, k/4) ∈ P+k (G2 ) works. u (By w 2 here we mean the Weyl-dimension 7 fundamental weight of G2 , corresponding to the short simple root.) However, {w 2 } will not be a fusion-generator when k > 4 is even. Our computer program tells us that for k ≤ 24, the fusion-rank is 1 except for k = 6, 12, 16 and 20 (of course this implies it will also be 2 whenever k + 4 is a multiple of 10, 16, or 24). 6. Number Fields Associated with S By the field Kr,k we mean the smallest field containing the rationals and all of the entries Sλ,µ of S. Similarly, by the field Lr,k we mean the smallest field containing Q and all of the values χλ (µ). Because of their role in the Galois symmetry (2.6), it is natural to try to identify these fields. This question was posed in [4], and related questions have been considered in e.g. [18,20]. Another reason the question is interesting is that, as we shall see, it has a simple answer! We will give this answer in Cor. 3 below, for the most important case: Ar,k . The matrix S for any nontwisted affine algebra g is given in e.g. [16]. The expression for Sλ,µ consists of a sum s(λ, µ) over the Weyl group of g, multiplied by a constant c. For Ar,k , s(λ, µ) manifestly lies in the field Qrk , and c=
ir(r+1)/2 . r/2 √ k r +1
Using Gauss sums, which express square-roots of integers as sums of roots of unity, it can be shown that the constant c lies in either Qr if r is even, or Qrk if either r ≡ 3 (mod √ 4) or k is even, or Qrk [ ±2] if both k is odd and kr ≡ ±2 (mod 8). Thus we know Lr,k is always a subfield of Qrk , and Kr,k is always a subfield of Q4rk . Write [λ] for the orbit {J i λ} of λ by the simple currents. We will find our fields by first computing some Galois orbits. This result should be of independent value. Theorem 8. Consider any k > 2 and r 6 = 1. (1) Choose any fundamental weight wm with m ≤ min{r − 2, k − 2}, and any Galois automorphism σ` . Then (with one exception) σ` w m ∈ [wm ] ∪ [Cwm ] iff ` ≡ ±1 (mod k); for all other ` the quantum-dimension Sσ` wm ,0 /S0,0 of σ` w m will be strictly greater than that of w m . (The one exception is w2 for A3,4 , where each σ` fixes w2 .)
20
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
(2) When r 6 ≡ 1 (mod 4), σ` w1 = w1 iff ` = 1 (mod rk). When r ≡ 1 (mod 4) and k is even, then σ` w1 = w1 iff ` = 1 (mod rk/2). Proof. (1) Because of (2.1a), we may assume m ≤ r/2. Assume first that k ≥ r. From the Weyl denominator formula, we compute m Y | sin(π`n/k)|r−n Sσ` wm ,0 = Swm ,0 sin(πn/k)r−n n=1 r−m Y n=m+1
| sin(π`n/k)|r−n sin(πn/k)r−n
r Y
| sin(π `n/k)|r+1−n
n=r+1−m
sin(π n/k)r+1−n
(6.2a)
where we drop the middle product if m = r/2. We want to know when (6.2a) equals 1. This is easy, for k > r ≥ 2, since sin(π/k) < sin(2π/k) < · · · < sin(πr/k). Consider first m < r/2: of all possible choices of integers 1 ≤ n1 < n2 < · · · < nr+1 ≤ k/2, the minimum possible product of r − 1 sin(π n1 /k)’s, r − 2 sin(π n2 /k)’s, ..., r − m sin(π nm /k)’s, r − m sin(πnm+1 /k)’s, ..., m sin(π nr−m /k)’s, m sin(π nr+1−m /k)’s, ..., and 1 sin(π nr /k), is the choice n1 = 1, n2 = 2, ..., {nm , nm+1 } = {m, m + 1}, ..., nm+2 = m + 2, ..., {nr−m , nr+1−m } = {r − m, r + 1 − m}, ..., nm+1 = m + 1. This immediately forces ` ≡ ±1 (mod k) (for m > 1, just look at the first term; when m = 1, ` ≡ ±2 is eliminated by seeing what happens to the second term). If instead m = r/2, the exponents of sin(πn/k) in (6.2a) are no longer nonincreasing: near n = m + 1 we get the subproduct · · · sin(π(m − 1)/k)r−m sin(π m/k)r−m sin(π (m + 1)/k)r−m sin(π (m + 2)/k)r−m · · · . For m > 2, the proof that (6.2a) will always be greater than 1 for ` 6 ≡ ±1 (mod k), follows from the simple observation that sin(π/k) sin(π (m + 1)/k) < sin(2π/k) sin(π m/k): the least-harmful place to move “1” to is “2”, and the best place to move “m + 1” to is “m”, and yet even that (forgetting the other terms, which will make matters worse) will increase the product. The remaining case m = 2 corresponds to r = k = 4, i.e. to the given exception. This completes the argument for k ≥ r. When k < r, apply rank-level duality (2.3a): it is an exact symmetry of quantum-dimensions, and maps J -orbits to J˜-orbits. τ w m = mw˜ 1 , so we are interested in the ratio k−2 Y | sin(π`n/k)|k−1−n k−1 Y | sin(π ` (n + m)/k)| S˜σ` mw˜ 1 ,0 = . sin(πn/k)k−1−n n=1 sin(π (n + m)/k) S˜mw˜ 1 ,0 n=1
(6.2b)
The rest of the argument is as before: again m = r/2 causes minor problems. Now consider any ` = (−1)a + bk. Applying (2.6b) to the Cartan generators λ ∈ 1 {w , . . . , wr } and using (2.4e), we find σ` µ = C a J b t (µ+ρ) µ t whenever σ` ∈ Gal(Lr,k /Q). Applying (6.2b) to µ = w1 gives us part (2). u
(6.2b)
Fusion Algebras and Modular Matrices
21
Corollary 3. When both k > 2 and r 6 = 1, then Lr,k = Qrk and ( Qrk if either r 6 ≡ 1 (mod 4) or k is even . Kr,k = √ Qrk [ ±2] if r is odd and rk ≡ ±2 (mod 8) The proof of the corollary is immediate from Thm. 8, by regarding Galois orbit sizes: when r 6 ≡ 1 (mod 4), the Galois orbit of w 1 alone suffices, but when r ≡ 1 (mod 4) and k is even, we have σ1+rk/2 w 1 = w1 , so also use σ1+rk/2 0 = J r/2 0 6 = 0, which is obtained from (6.2b). What we find in all cases is that for any ` ∈ (Z/rkZ)× , ` 6 = 1, either σ` w 1 6 = w1 or σ` 0 6 = 0. This tells us Lr,k = Qrk , and Kr,k is then obtained by adjoining the constant c shown above. Similar statements to Thm. 8 can be found for other weights. For example, by ranklevel duality the identical result to Thm. 8(1) holds for any mw 1 , 0 ≤ m ≤ min{r − 2, k − 2}, and we can expect similar results for other hooks. When r ≡ 1 (mod 4) and k is odd, Q4rk is a degree 2 extension of Kr,k , which is in turn a degree 2 extension of Qrk . The results corresponding to Corollary 3 for k = 1, 2 or r = 1 can be easily found, but are more complicated and hence less interesting. We include them here for completeness. √ • Lr,1 = Qr . Kr,1 will equal either Qr , Qr [i], or Qr [ ±2], depending on whether or not r ≡ 0, 1 (mod 4), or r ≡ 3 (mod 4), or r ≡ ±2 (mod 8), respectively. if k is odd, and √ Q[cos(π/k)] if k is even. K1,k will equal either • L1,k = Q[cos(2π/k)] √ L1,k , or L1,k [ 2 sin(2π/k)], or L1,k [ 2], depending on whether k ≡ 0, 2, or k ≡ 3, or k ≡ 1 (mod 4), respectively. • Lr,2 = Qr [cos(2π/k)] if r is odd, and Qrk if r is even. Kr,2 will equal Lr,2 , unless r ≡ 3 (mod 4) when Kr,2 = Qrk . Acknowledgements. T.G. thanks A. Coste for showing him Questions 1 and 3, and C. Cummins for discussions. M.W. thanks the High Energy Physics group of DAMTP for hospitality, and W. Eholzer for reading the manuscript.
References 1. Aharony, O.: Generalized fusion potentials. Phys. Lett. B306, 276–282 (1993) 2. Altschuler, D., Bauer, M., and Itzykson, C.: The branching rules of conformal embeddings. Commun. Math. Phys. 132, 349–364 (1990) 3. Bourbaki, N.: Groupes et Algèbres de Lie. Chapitres IV-VI, Paris: Hermann, 1968 4. Buffenoir, E., Coste, A., Lascoux, J., Buhot, A., and Degiovanni, P.: Precise study of some number fields and Galois actions occurring in conformal field theory. Annales de l’I.H.P.: Phys. Théor. 63, 41–79 (1995) 5. Coste, A. and Gannon, T.: Remarks on Galois symmetry in rational conformal field theories. Phys. Lett. B323, 316–321 (1994) 6. Di Francesco, P. and Zuber, J.-B.: Fusion Potentials I. J. Phys. A26, 1441–1454 (1993) 7. Fuchs, J., Schellekens, B., and Schweigert, C.: From Dynkin diagram symmetries to fixed point structures. Commun. Math. Phys. 180, 39–97 (1996) 8. Fulton, W. and Harris, J.: Representation Theory: A First Course. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1991 9. Gannon, T.: Symmetries of the Kac–Peterson modular matrices of affine algebras. Invent. Math. 122, 341–357 (1995) 10. Gannon, T.: Kac–Peterson, Perron–Frobenius, and the classification of conformal field theories. e-print q-alg/9510026 (1995) 11. Gannon, T., Ruelle, Ph., and Walton, M.A.: Automorphism modular invariants of current algebras. Commun. Math. Phys. 179, 121–156 (1996) 12. Georgieu, G. and Mathieu, O.: Catégorie de fusion pour les groupes de Chevalley. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 315, 659–662 (1992)
22
T. Gannon, M.A. Walton
13. Gepner, D.: Fusion rings and geometry. Commun. Math. Phys. 141, 381–411 (1991) 14. Goodman, F. and Nakanishi, T.: Fusion algebras in integrable systems in two dimensions. Phys. Lett. B262, 259–264 (1991) 15. Goodman, F. and Wenzl, H.: Littlewood–Richardson coefficients for Hecke algebras at roots of unity. Adv. Math. 82, 244–265 (1990) 16. Kac, V. and Peterson, D.: Infinite-dimensional Lie algebras, theta functions and modular forms. Adv. Math. 53, 125–264 (1984) 17. Kreuzer, M. and Schellekens, A.N.: Simple currents versus orbifolds with discrete torsion – a complete classification. Nucl. Phys. B411, 97–121 (1994) 18. Moody, R.V. and Patera, J.: Characters of elements of finite order in Lie groups. SIAM J. Alg. Disc. Meth. 5, 359–383 (1984) 19. Pasquier, V. and Saleur, H.: Common structures between finite systems and conformal field theories through quantum groups. Nucl. Phys. B330, 523–526 (1990) 20. Pianzola, A.: The arithmetic of the representation ring and elements of finite order in Lie groups. J. Algebra 108, 1–33 (1987) 21. Verlinde, E.: Fusion rules and modular transformations in 2D conformal field theory. Nucl. Phys. B300, 360–376 (1988) 22. Witten, E.: The Verlinde algebra and the cohomology of the Grassmannian. In: Geometry, Topology and Physics. Conf. Proc. and Lecture Notes in Geom. Topol. Vol. VI, 1995, pp. 357–422 Communicated by R. H. Dijkgraaf
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 23 – 32 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Master Partitions for Large N Matrix Field Theories Matthias Staudacher?,?? Albert-Einstein-Institut, Max-Planck-Institut für Gravitationsphysik, Schlaatzweg 1, D-14473 Potsdam, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 30 October 1998 / Accepted: 7 March 1999
Abstract: We introduce a systematic approach for treating the large N limit of matrix field theories.
1. Introduction It has been known for thirty years that quantum field theory simplifies enormously if the number N of internal field components tends to infinity. In the case where the N components form a vector this leads to exact solutions in any dimension of spacetime. For physical applications, ranging from solid state physics to gauge theories and quantum gravity, a different situation is much more pertinent: The case of N 2 internal components that form a matrix. Here exact solutions have only been produced for very low dimensionalities. It is one of the outstanding problems of theoretical physics to extend large N technology to physically interesting dimensions. In the present article we will be concerned with matrix “spin systems”, that is Ddimensional Euclidean lattice field theories whose internal degrees of freedom are hermitian, complex or unitary N × N matrices. The idea is to treat the problem by a three step procedure: (1) Eguchi–Kawai reduction: Replace the N = ∞ field theory by a one-matrix model coupled to appropriate constant external field matrices. (2) Character expansion: Express the partition function of the one-matrix model of (1) as a sum over polynomial representations – labelled by Young diagrams – of U (N ). (3) Saddle point analysis: Find an effective Young diagram that dominates the partition sum of (2) in the large N limit. ? Supported in part by EU Contract FMRX-CT96-0012.
?? Current institute address: Am Mühlenberg, Haus 5, D-14476 Golm, Germany.
24
M. Staudacher
The insight that step (1) is possible is due to Eguchi and Kawai [1]. Intuitively it says that, if a saddle point configuration exists at N = ∞, it should be given by a single translationally invariant matrix (the so-called master field). In practice the reduction is rather subtle, and we will be using the twisted EK reduction [2] which results in a one-matrix model in external constant fields encoding the original (discrete) space-time. Step (2) is novel in this context and is the main focus of the present work. The onematrix model of (1) still has N 2 degrees of freedom, and it is well known that a saddle point for matrix models can only be found once the degrees of freedom are reduced as N 2 → N . The external fields encoding space-time prevent any naive reduction to the N eigenvalues of the matrix, which is the route of choice for simpler models without external fields. But is it possible to replace the matrix integral by a sum over partitions corresponding to a sum over all polynomial representations of U (N ). The crucial point is then that one ends up with a kind of one-dimensional spin model in Young diagram space with only N variables: the possible lengths of the N rows of the diagram. Step (3) might appear to be an exotic idea: we claim that the N = ∞ “master field” can be described by a “master partition”. However, it has already been recently demonstrated in a series of papers [3,4] that certain infinite sums over partitions are dominated by a saddle point configuration. This led to the solution of matrix models in external fields not treatable by any other method. The present models are more complicated, but not fundamentally different. The character expansions we find lead to a very interesting and apparently novel combinatorial problem in Young pattern space (see Sect. 4). More insight into this problem will be needed in order to proceed with the final step (3) of our program, the saddle point analysis. We introduce what we call “lattice polynomials” 4h ,ϒh which are polynomials in N1 . They depend on the Young diagram h and the precise nature of the space-time lattice. It might be objected that the present approach is futile unless one can demonstrate that the lattice polynomials 4h ,ϒh can be explicitly computed or at least bootstraped at N = ∞. But there is one important argument against this pessimistic assessment: The lattice polynomials 4h ,ϒh only depend on the nature of the lattice but not on the local measure of the minimally coupled (matrix) spins of the model1 . Therefore, solving interacting field theory in our language is of the same degree of complexity as solving the free field case. Finally we should mention that our program is very general since it applies in principle to any large N matrix spin system. It would be interesting to extend the method to matrix field theories with a gauge symmetry such asYang-Mills theory. Indeed the EK reduction was initially designed for lattice gauge theory [1]. Recently it was demonstrated by Monte Carlo methods that even the path integral of continuum gauge theory may be EK reduced to a convergent ordinary multiple matrix integral [5]. A rigorous mathematical proof, as well as an investigation on whether the reduced model reinduces the field theory as N → ∞, are still lacking. At any rate, reducing a D-dimensional gauge theory, one so far ends up with a nonlinearly coupled D-matrix model, which is not yet tractable by the present machinery unless it is understood how to perform a further reduction DN 2 → N 2 .
1 Except for the global symmetry of the matrix spins. In this paper we develop the theory in parallel for the case of U(N) global symmetry (hermitian matrices) and U(N ) × U(N ) symmetry (complex matrices). The other classical groups could presumably be treated as well, but it is well known that they do not lead to different large N limits.
Master Partitions for Large N Matrix Field Theories
25
2. Reduced Matrix Spin Systems Consider a spin model on a periodic lattice. In order to be specific we will sketch the method for a two-dimensional lattice, but higher (or lower) dimensions can be treated as well. We will not dwell on details since they are well explained elsewhere. The variables are N × N hermitian matrices M(x) defined on the lattice sites x Z Y DM(x) e−SH , ZH = x
SH = N Tr
X 1 x
2
M(x)2 + V M(x)
β X [M(x)M(x + µ) ˆ + M(x)M(x − µ)] ˆ , − 2
(1)
µ=1,2
where µˆ denotes the unit vector in the µ-direction. It is equally natural to consider general complex matrices 8(x) ∈ GL(N, C), in which case Z Y D8(x) e−SGL , ZGL = x
SGL = N Tr
X
8(x)8† (x) + V 8(x)8† (x)
x
−β
X
[8(x)8 (x + µ) ˆ + 8(x)8 (x − µ)] ˆ . †
(2)
†
µ=1,2
If V = 0 in Eqs. (1),(2) the model is free. The integration measures in Eqs. (1),(2) are the flat measures for hermitian and complex matrices: DM =
N dMii Y dReMij dImMij , √ −1 πN −1 2πN i=1 i<j
N Y
D8 =
N Y dRe8ij dIm8ij . (3) π N −1
i,j =1
A third, very important type of spin model is the so-called chiral field, which looks like the free complex model Eq. (2) Z Y DU (x) e−SU , ZU = x
SU = −βN Tr
X X
[U (x)U † (x + µ) ˆ + U (x)U † (x − µ)] ˆ ,
(4)
x µ=1,2
but the matrices U (x) ∈ U(N) are unitary. In this case the measure DU (x) is the Haar measure on the group. The model is therefore not free.
26
M. Staudacher
The Eguchi–Kawai reduction [1,2] states that the above lattice models can be replaced at N = ∞ by, respectively, the following one-matrix models coupled to constant external field matrices P and Q: Z 1 2 † † , (5) ZH = DM exp N Tr − M − V M + β MP MP + MQMQ 2 Z ZGL =
Z ZU =
h i D8 exp N Tr − 88† − V 88† × × exp βN Tr 8P 8† P † + 8P † 8† P + 8Q8† Q† + 8Q† 8† Q , (6)
DU exp βN Tr U P U † P † + U P † U † P + U QU † Q† + U Q† U † Q . (7)
Here P = PN and Q = QN are the famous N × N unitary “shift and clock” matrices 1 01 ωN 0 1 . . . . . . , Q = (8) PN = , . N . . N −2 01 ω 1
N
0
N −1 ωN
where ωN = exp 2πi N and PN QN = ωN QN PN . To be more precise, the free energies as well as appropriate correlation functions (see [2]) are identical to leading order in N1 in the lattice field theory and the corresponding one-matrix model. The thermodynamic limit, that is a lattice of infinite extent, is approached when N → ∞. We see that the structure of the lattice has been “hidden” in index space! It is natural to generalize the situation to a toroidal K × L lattice: P = PK ⊗ 1 N , K
Q = QL ⊗ 1 N , L
(9)
where N is chosen to be divisible by K and L. This allows to take the thermodynamic limit and the large N limit independently. If we put L = 1 (we can then equivalently omit Q altogether) the target space becomes a closed one-dimensional chain. We suspect that matrix models on arbitrary discrete target spaces can be EK reduced by appropriate external matrices, but this has not been worked out yet. 3. Character Expansions Now we turn to step (2) and rewrite the reduced hermitian, complex and unitary matrix integrals Eqs. (5), (6), (7) as sums over representations of U(N ). To this end introduce the following source integrals: Z h 1 i (10) ZH [J ] = DM exp N Tr − M 2 − V (M) + J M , 2 ZGL [J J¯] =
Z
h i D8 exp N Tr − 88† − V (88† ) + J 8 + 8† J¯ ,
(11)
Master Partitions for Large N Matrix Field Theories
ZU [J J¯] =
Z
27
h i DU exp N Tr J U + U † J¯ .
(12)
The two different ways of introducing a source are due to the U(N ) symmetry of hermitian matrices on the one hand and the U(N)×U(N ) symmetry of complex (and complex unitary) matrices on the other. The reduced models are easily obtained from the source integrals by applying an operator: ZH = exp
ZGL,U = exp
β , Tr ∂P ∂P † + ∂Q∂Q† · ZH [J ] J =0 N
(13)
β ¯ † + ∂P † ∂P ¯ + ∂Q∂Q ¯ † + ∂Q† ∂Q ¯ Tr ∂P ∂P . · ZGL,U [J J¯] J =J¯=0 N (14)
Here ∂,∂¯ denote N × N matrix differential operators whose matrix elements are ∂j i = ∂ ∂ ¯ ∂Jij and ∂j i = ∂ J¯ij . It is clear that the source integrals are class functions of, respectively, J and J J¯. Therefore they can be expressed as character expansions, with known (see [3, 4,6]) expansion coefficients. If V = 0, they read for the hermitian and complex source integrals, respectively, ZH [J ] = exp
X 1 χh (A2 )χh (J ), N Tr J 2 = 2
(15)
h
ZGL [J J¯] = exp N Tr J J¯ =
X
χh (A1 )χh (J J¯),
(16)
h
while for the unitary source integral one has [6] ZU [J J¯] =
X χh (A1 )χh (A1 ) h
χh (1)
χh (J J¯).
(17)
Here the sum runs over all partitions h labeled by the shifted weights hi = N − i + mi , where mi ≥ 0, i = 1, . . . , N, is the number of boxes in the i th row of the Young pattern associated to h. χh (J ) is the Schur function, dependent on J , on the diagram h. It is identical to the Weyl character of the matrix J corresponding to the representation labeled by h. A1 and A2 are defined through Tr Ak1 = N(δk,0 +δk,1 ) and Tr Ak2 = N (δk,0 +δk,2 ), and χh (1) is the dimension of the representation. For more details on the notation, and for explicit formulas for the characters χh (A1 ), χh (A2 ) and χh (1) see [3,4]. For a nonzero potential V , the hermitian and complex character expansions become a bit more complicated, but are still available: X 2h χh (J ), (18) ZH [J ] = h
ZGL [J J¯] =
X h
h χh (J J¯),
(19)
28
M. Staudacher
where 2h is given by Z h 1 i χh (A1 ) DM exp N Tr − M 2 − V (M) χh (M), 2h = χh (1) 2 and h by 2 Z i h χh (A1 ) D8 exp N Tr − 88† − V (88† ) χh (88† ). h = χh (1)
(20)
(21)
The integrals appearing in Eqs. (20), (21) are ordinary one-matrix integrals which may be computed rather explicitly as N × N determinants. Their analysis in the N → ∞ limit proceeds by employing standard techniques, supplemented by the methods of [3]. Now we apply the operators in Eqs. (13), (14) in order to generate the space-time lattice; this results in character expansions for the reduced matrix field theories. In the P hermitian case one has (here |h| = i mi =number of boxes in the Young diagram) X |h| χh (A2 ) 4h β 2 for V = 0, (22) ZH = h
ZH =
X
2h 4h β
|h| 2
for V 6 = 0,
(23)
h
with
1 Tr ∂P ∂P † + ∂Q∂Q† · χh (J ) . J =0 N The free complex, interacting complex, and the unitary case become X χh (A1 ) ϒh β |h| for V = 0, ZGL = 4h = exp
(24)
(25)
h
ZGL =
X
h ϒh β |h|
for V 6= 0,
(26)
h
ZU =
X χh (A1 )χh (A1 ) h
χh (1)
ϒh β |h| ,
(27)
with
1 ¯ + ∂Q∂Q ¯ † + ∂Q† ∂Q ¯ ¯ † + ∂P † ∂P . (28) · χh (J J¯) Tr ∂P ∂P J =J¯=0 N The character expansions Eqs. (22), (23), (25), (26), (27) are at the heart of our proposal. It is seen that they neatly separate the nature of the local spin weight (χh (A2 ),2h ,χh (A1 ),h , (χh (A1 ))2 (χh (1))−1 ) and the nature of the embedding space (4h ,ϒh ). As a striking example, note that from the point of view of our character expansion method the difference between the free Gaussian model on a toroidal lattice Eq. (25) and the non-trivial chiral model Eq. (27) is a simple, explicitly known factor ϒh = exp
N
Y (N − i)! χh (A1 ) = N |h| . χh (1) hi ! i=1
The character expansions involve sums over N variables only and we can write down a saddle point equation for the effective density of the master partition. In order to complete the program, we need a second bootstrap equation for the novel quantities 4h and ϒh , which contain the connectivity information of the lattice.
Master Partitions for Large N Matrix Field Theories
29
4. Lattice Polynomials Inspection of the quantities 4h and ϒh in eqs.(24),(28) shows that they are polynomials in the variable N1 of degree not higher than, respectively, 21 |h| − 1 and |h| − 2. They are zero if the number |h| of boxes in the Young pattern is odd. Conjugating the diagram gives the same polynomial except for the replacement N1 → − N1 . The first few can be computed by brute force calculation directly from the definitions Eqs. (24), (28), see Table 1. Table 1. The first few D = 2 lattice polynomials h 2
4h 2
ϒh 2
12
2
2
4
3 + 12 N1 5 + 4 N1
3 + 24 N1 + 54 12 N
31 22 212
6 5 − 4 N1
5 + 8 N1 + 18 12 N 6 5 − 8 N1 + 18 12
14
3 − 12 N1
3 − 24 N1 + 54 12
N
N
Here we used Tr(P k Ql ) = Nδk,0 δl,0 , which is true as long as |k| < N, |l| < N. We ∗ → 1 (remember ω = exp 2π i ): in other words, we assumed also replaced ωN → 1, ωN N N P and Q to commute at large N. Both assumptions are innocent at least in the strong coupling (small β) phase. If the model possesses a weak coupling phase (like e.g. the chiral field Eq. (7)), these assumptions may have to be reconsidered, if we want the character expansion to describe this second phase as well. This is because in the present approach we expect large N phase transitions to correspond to the situation where the number of rows of the master partition is of O(N ) (“touching transition”). Note that we cannot drop the other terms of O( N1 ) in 4h ,ϒh since the character expansions are for the partition function and not for the free energy. The direct calculation of the lattice polynomials quickly gets very tedious. The combinatorics involved seems to be of a novel type. While we have not yet found an efficient calculational scheme or recursive method, let us give some interesting representations for 4h and ϒh that may prove useful later. Introduce the following Gaussian measure on the space of M × N (M ≤ N) complex matrices 3:
[D3] =
N M Y Y dRe3ij dIm3ij i=1 j =1
πN −1
i h exp N Tr − 33† .
(29)
This measure is invariant under U(M) × U(N ). It is then fairly easy to prove (cf. [4]) the following representation for the character of the source: Z χh (J ) =
Z DU χh (U † )
[D3] exp N Tr U 3J 3† ,
(30)
30
M. Staudacher
where U ∈ U(M) is unitary and DU is the Haar measure on U(M). This formula is valid for diagrams h with at most M rows. Therefore 4h becomes, cf. Eq. (24) Z Z † 4h = DU χh (U ) [D3] exp N Tr 3† U 3P 3† U 3P † + 3† U 3Q3† U 3Q† . (31) After a Hubbard-Stratanovich transformation decoupling the quartic terms by Gaussian M × M complex matrices S and T (with measure as in Eq. (29) with N → M), and integration over 3, we obtain the representation Z Z † 4h = DU χh (U ) [DS][DT ] ∞ k X 1 SU ⊗ P + S † U ⊗ P † + T U ⊗ Q + T † U ⊗ Q† . × exp Tr M⊗N k k=1
(32) The combinatorial interpretation of the exponential in Eq. (32) is the following: we have a generating function for a non-commutative random walk on a two-dimensional lattice with variable U . The representation is useful for getting some exact results on the 4h , but we have not yet been able to compute the integral Eq. (32) exactly except for M = 1 (characters with just one row). E.g. we can find a generating function (with zi being the eigenvalues of U ) for the large N limit of 4h M Y i,j
X 1 =∞ = 4N χh (z) h 2 (1 − zi zj )
(33)
h
giving the constant terms of the lattice polynomials. This is however not sufficient for the large N limit of the field theory, as already mentioned. A curious feature of Eq. (32) is that we can take N → ∞ while keeping M in the range 1 M N . That is, it should be possible to find a saddle point for the situation where the row lengths are large compared to the number of rows, corresponding to the extreme strong coupling limit. Furthermore, it should be investigated whether the M × M matrices can be taken to commute as N → ∞. Similar, if slightly more complicated representations are possible for ϒh ; here the starting point is the expression Z Z 1 1 χh (J J¯) = DU χh (U † ) [D31 ][D32 ] exp N Tr U 2 31 J 3†2 + 32 J¯3†1 U 2 , (34) which means the lattice polynomials become Z Z † ϒh = DU χh (U ) [D31 ][D32 ]× 1 1 1 1 × exp N Tr 3†2 U 2 31 P 3†1 U 2 32 P † + 3†2 U 2 31 P † 3†1 U 2 32 P × 1 1 1 1 × exp N Tr 3†2 U 2 31 Q3†1 U 2 32 Q† + 3†2 U 2 31 Q† 3†1 U 2 32 Q , (35)
Master Partitions for Large N Matrix Field Theories
31
and the non-commutative random walk representation is Z Z † ¯ ][DT¯ ] ϒh = DU χh (U ) [DS][DS][DT ∞ k X 1 1 1 1 1 ¯ 2 ⊗ P † + T U 2 ⊗ Q + T¯ U 2 ⊗ Q† SU 2 ⊗ P + SU × exp Tr M⊗N k k=1 ∞ k X 1 ¯† 1 † 21 † † 21 † 21 † ¯ 2 S U ⊗P +S U ⊗P +T U ⊗Q+T U ⊗Q , × exp Tr M⊗N k k=1
(36) , cf. Eq. (33), but N1 corrections are different from which we find that ϒhN=∞ = 4N=∞ h (see Table 1). Again, for arbitrary one-row representations (M = 1) it is possible to obtain ϒh rather explicitly. Another potentially useful representation2 of the lattice polynomials is given by the following dual equations: Eq. (24) becomes 1 , (37) 4h = χh (∂) · exp Tr J P J P † + J QJ Q† J =0 N and Eq. (28) is dual to ¯ · exp 1 Tr J P J¯P † + J P † J¯P + J QJ¯Q† + J Q† J¯Q . (38) ϒh = χh (∂ ∂) J =J¯=0 N We could go on and discuss correlation functions which are naturally included into the present formalism. In particular, it is straightforward to give expressions for their character expansions in terms of modified lattice polynomials, and it remains true that the combinatorics is independent on whether the reduced field theory is free or interacting. This is however beyond the scope of the present article. While it is unclear whether the D ≥ 2 lattice polynomials can be computed exactly for a general partition, it should be stressed once more that this is unnecessary; all we need is an indirect method in order to extract the large N behavior. 5. Conclusions This solution to the problem of the large N limit of (non-gauge) matrix field theories is not yet complete since the structure of the lattice polynomials we introduced still needs to be further analyzed in order to be able to write the full set of saddle point equations. However we feel that we are definitely closing in on the large N problem, and that we have brought it into the simplest form to date. The proposed approach is concrete, systematic and rather general: we demonstrated that the reduction from N 2 to N variables is possible once one changes variables from matrices to partitions. In this language the master field becomes a master partition. Presumably one should first (re)derive in the current framework the exact solutions for some lower dimensional target spaces before dealing with the two (and higher) dimensional field theories. Acknowledgements. We thank Daya-Nand Verma and Brian G. Wybourne for interesting and useful discussions concerning the combinatorial aspects of this project. This work was supported in part by the EU under Contract FMRX-CT96-0012. 2 We thank D.-N. Verma for pointing this out to us.
32
M. Staudacher
References 1. Eguchi, T. and Kawai, H.: Reduction of dynamical degrees of freedom in the large N gauge theory. Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1063 (1982) 2. Eguchi, T. and Nakayama, R.: Simplification of Quenching Procedure for Large N Spin Models. Phys. Lett. B122, 59 (1982) 3. Kazakov, V.A., Staudacher, M. and Wynter, T.: Character Expansion Methods for Matrix Models of Dually Weighted Graphs. hep-th/9502132, Commun. Math. Phys. 177, 451 (1996); Almost Flat Planar Diagrams. hep-th/9506174, Commun. Math. Phys. 179, 235 (1996); Exact Solution of Discrete 2D R 2 Gravity. hep-th/9601069, Nucl. Phys. B471, 309 (1996) 4. Kostov, I. and Staudacher, M.: Two-Dimensional Chiral Matrix Models and String Theories. hepth/9611011, Phys. Lett. B394, 75 (1997); Kostov, I., Staudacher, M. and Wynter, T.: Complex Matrix Models and Statistics of Branched Coverings of 2D Surfaces. hep-th/9703189, Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 283 (1998) 5. Krauth, W. and Staudacher, M.: Finite Yang-Mills Integrals. AEI-065, hep-th/9804199, accepted for publication in Phys. Lett. B. 6. Bars, I.: U (N) Integral for the Generating Functional in Lattice Gauge Theory. J. Math. Phys. 21, 2678 (1980) Communicated by R. H. Dijkgraaf
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 33 –55 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Statistics of Return Times: A General Framework and New Applications Masaki Hirata1 , Benoît Saussol2 , Sandro Vaienti2 1 Mathematical Department, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Japan. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Centre de Physique Théorique, Luminy, Marseille and PHYMAT, Mathematical Department, University of
Toulon, France. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected] Received: 4 August 1998 / Accepted: 9 March 1999
Abstract: In this paper we provide general estimates for the errors between the distribution of the first, and more generally, the K th return time (suitably rescaled) and the Poisson law for measurable dynamical systems. In the case that the system exhibits strong mixing properties, these bounds are explicitly expressed in terms of the speed of mixing. Using these approximations, the Poisson law is finally proved to hold for a large class of non hyperbolic systems on the interval. 1. Introduction The investigation of asymptotically rare events is growing up as a new direction in the understanding of statistical properties of dynamical systems. By “asymptotically rare” events we mean, in a wide sense and following the terminology in the review paper of [Coe97], those events which have asymptotically zero probability but which occur with a well determined asymptotic limit law. In the dynamical setting, where we have a probability space (X, B, µ) with a measurable µ-preserving mapping T acting on it, the “events” will usually be the visits into a sequence of sets k ∈ B of positive measure but with their measure going to zero in the limit of large k. We call the event “rare”, when the expected entrance time in k diverges with k. A well-known result in ergodic theory shows how abundant are the “asymptotically rare” events. Let us consider in fact an ergodic measure µ for an endomorphism T and take a measurable subset : then Kac’s theorem [CFS82] says that the expectation of the return time to , starting from , is just µ()−1 . Kac’s theorem suggests the good normalization to keep in order to study the asymptotic distribution of the return time to . The natural object will thus be the distribution: (1) F (t) = µ x ∈ τ (x)µ() > t , where τ (x) is the first return time to provided that x ∈ and µ is the normalized restriction of µ to . The question will be whether the limit of F (t) exists when the
34
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
measure goes to zero and what kind of distribution is recovered. The condition that the starting point x in (1) belongs to could be relaxed by asking that x belongs to the whole space. In this case, F (t) will give the distribution of the “visiting time” into , but in order to get its asymptotic distribution, a suitable normalization is needed [GS97]. The situations sketched above could be considerably refined, producing richer processes (see the quoted paper [Coe97] for an historical account of these questions and an exhaustive bibliography). We will however explore some of them in this paper under a more general perspective and successively by giving applications to class of systems never investigated before. Let us first come back to formula (1) and replace with a decreasing sequence of neighborhoods of a given point z ∈ X, ε (z), such that their measure goes to zero when ε → 0+ . Then for some classes of hyperbolic dynamical systems, notably axiom A diffeomorphisms [Hir93], transitive Markov chains [Pit91], expanding maps of the interval with a spectral gap [Col96] and in the more general setting of systems verifying a strong mixing property (“self-mixing” condition and ϕ-mixing [Hir95]), and recently even in the case of rational maps with critical points in the Julia set [Hay98a], it is possible to prove that the distribution Fε (z) (t) goes to the exponential-one law e−t and this for µ-almost every z ∈ X. A strong improvement of this kind of result appears in the paper [GS97], where an upper bound for the difference t −t µ τA (x) > − e µ(A)λ(A) was explicitly computed in the case of ϕ-mixing systems and where A is a cylinder set, and λ(A) a suitable normalizing factor. Recently [Hay98b] obtained an exponential error estimate for the quantity like (1) in the case of parabolic rational maps. To enrich the process, and the statistics, one successively introduce the K th return time, τKε (x), from ε into itself (see the precise definition in the next section), where ε = ε (z) is still a neighborhood of some point z ∈ X. For the dynamical systems quoted above, a Poisson statistics can be proved, by showing that the distribution of successive return times into ε satisfies, for z µ-a.e. t K −t (x) −→ e . µε x ∈ ε τKε (x) ≤ t < τK+1 ε ε→0+ K!
(2)
The preceding results deserve further investigations at least in two directions: 1. extend them to non-hyperbolic dynamical systems and, more ambitiously, check their robustness when the system loses strong mixing properties. 2. prove an error estimate even for the distribution of successive return times (2) and relate this approximation rate, if possible, to the statistical properties of the system like correlations decay or spectral properties. We try to give partial answer to these questions in this paper. The general setting we put in, is the return(s) times to the set starting from itself, as expressed in formulas (1) and (2) (although in Theorem 2.1 we will also consider points starting everywhere). The first attempt was to give, for measure preserving dynamical systems, a general upper bound for the difference between the distribution of the (rescaled) first return time and the exponential-one law e−t and then between the distribution of high-order (rescaled) t K −t e . We do not make any hypothesis on the set , nor return times and the Poisson law K! on the ergodic properties of µ; nevertheless these bounds are expressed in terms of the
Statistics of Return Times
35
self-interactions of the set and can be explicitly computed when typical rates of mixing are known (uniform mixing, α-mixing or ϕ-mixing). In this context, our bounds greatly improve and simplify the hypothesis of self-mixing condition of [Hir95], which was a powerful tool to get sufficient condition for the Poisson statistics. This first part of the paper is essentially due to one of us (B.S.) and is part of his Ph.D. Thesis [Sau98b]. In the second part we apply the preceding bounds to new situations. The systems we treat are some non-uniformly hyperbolic maps of the interval; these maps are characterized by a structure parameter, say α, which measures the order of tangency at a neutral fixed point and governs the algebraic decay of correlations (in our example the order is n1−1/α ). If µ denotes the absolutely continuous invariant measure, we prove Poisson statistics (in the sense precise above), by giving an explicit approximation of the asymptotic law in terms of the measure of the set n , where in this case n is a decreasing sequence of cylinder sets chosen around almost all points in the interval. To be precise the error is of the type: µ(n )β , for any β < 1 − α, and therefore β is explicitly related to α and optimized just by 1 − α. For the distributions of the K th return times the bounds simply become µ(n )β/K . By inspecting these results, we could argue that the non-hyperbolic character of the maps reflects in the error term; to be more precise we think that as soon as the degree of non-uniform hyperbolicity of the map is monitored by a structure parameter α, this parameter will appear explicitly in the approximation to the Poisson law, which suggests, on the converse, that we could use Poissonian statistics to test lack of hyperbolicity. Our claim is motivated by two more observations: first, in getting these bounds we proved a sort of α-mixing for the map with a rate which was exactly the same as the algebraic rate for the correlations’ decay. Second, in the forthcoming paper [Sau98a] the return times is analyzed for a class of piecewise expanding multidimensional maps. Although the mixing properties are much more difficult to handle with, especially for the presence of singularity lines and the geometry of their shape, the uniform dilatation will provide bounds on the form: µ(n )β and µ(n )β/K for all β < 1, which reflects the fact that all the quantities involved, and the correlations’ decay too, admit exponential estimates. We will come back to these questions in Sect. 4. As a final remark, we address two questions: 1. Our analysis is local: the events are chosen around almost all points which we could call, following a widespread tradition, generic (for our statistics). What happens if we consider non-generic points (discarding of course some trivial situation like fixed points)? Could we see their (possibly different) statistics by involving some sort of large deviation argument ? 2. What is the place of Poissonian statistics regarding other ergodic characterizations of dynamical systems? For example: what is the largest class of ergodic dynamical systems enjoying a Poissonian statistics? Conversely, does an invariant measure satisfying that behavior imply strong ergodic properties too?
2. General Bounds on the Distribution of Return Times We will consider in this section a probability space (X, B, µ) together with a measure preserving transformation T acting on X. The basic object will be the return time into a positive measure set U starting from U defined by n o τU (x) = inf k ≥ 1| T k x ∈ U ∪ {∞}.
36
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
µ(A ∩ U ) . We µ(U ) then recall Kac’s theorem which says that the conditional expectation of τU given U is finite, and equal to 1/µ(U ), when µ is ergodic. As indicated in the introduction, Kac’s result suggests how to properly rescale the return time when we are interested in its distribution.
We define as usual the conditional measure µU on U by µU (A) =
2.1. First return time. We begin to show that the distribution of the first return time into the set U starting from U is close to an exponential one law if and only if the two distributions of the first return time starting, respectively from U and everywhere, are close. Theorem 2.1. Let us define c(k, U ) = µU (τU > k) − µ(τU > k) and set c(U ) = supk |c(k, U )|. The distribution of the (rescaled) first return time into the set U differs from the exponential-one law by at most d(U ) := 4µ(U ) + c(U )(1 + log c(U )−1 ), namely: t −t − e ≤ d(U ), sup µ τU > µ(U ) t≥0 which is still true starting from U : sup µU τU > t≥0
t µ(U )
− e ≤ d(U ). −t
Conversely, the difference between the two distributions (starting inside U and everywhere) can be bounded in terms of the distance e c(U ) := supt≥0 |µU (τU > t/µ(U )) − −t e |, precisely: c(U ) ≤ 2µ(U ) + e c(U )(2 + loge c(U )−1 ). Remark 2.2. Whenever µ(U ) > 0 the return time’s law is discrete and this allow us to get a lower bound for the rate of convergence. More precisely, we have the following proposition: Proposition 2.3. For each k ≥ 0, εk,U := µ (τU > k) − e−kµ(U ) + µ (τU > k + 1/2) − e−(k+1/2)µ(U ) ≥
e−kµ(U ) µ(U ). 4
In particular, ε0,U ≥ µ(U )/4. Proof of Proposition 2.3. Let k ≥ 0 be an integer. Since τU takes only integer values, the distribution for t = kµ(U ) and t 0 = (k + 1/2)µ(U ) is the same, then εk,U ≥ |exp(−kµ(U )) − exp(−(k + 1/2)µ(U ))| ≥ exp(−kµ(U ))(1 − e−µ(U )/2 ) ≥
e−kµ(U ) µ(U ). 4
t u
Statistics of Return Times
37
Proof of Theorem 2.1. Let us remark that for any k ≥ 1 we have µ(τU = k) = µ(U ∩ {τU > k − 1}).
(3)
Since {τU > k} = T −1 (U c ∩ {τU > k − 1}) by the invariance of µ we get that µ(τU > k) = µ(τU > k − 1) − µ(U ∩ {τU > k − 1}), whence the result. Next, for all k > 0 we have µ(τU > k) = µ(τU > k − 1) − µ(U )µU (τU > k − 1) = µ(τU > k − 1) − µ(U )[µ(τU > k − 1) + c(k, U )] = µ(τU > k − 1)[1 − µ(U )] − µ(U )c(k, U ). Then it follows by an immediate induction that k
µ(τU > k) = (1 − µ(U )) − µ(U )
k X
c(j, U )(1 − µ(U ))k−j .
j =1
Hence for all t ≥ 0, putting kt = [t/µ(U )], we have kt X µ(τU > kt ) − (1 − µ(U ))kt ≤ µ(U ) |c(j, U )| ≤ tc(U ).
(4)
j =1
Setting z = − log c(U ), and kz = [z/µ(U )], we get (1 − µ(U ))kz ≤ e−kz µ(U ) ≤ c(U )eµ(U ) ≤ c(U ) + 2µ(U ), for any t > z, µ(τU > kt ) ≤ µ(τU > kz )
≤ (1 − µ(U ))kz + zc(U ) ≤ 2µ(U ) + c(U )(1 − log c(U )) which gives µ(τU > kt ) − (1 − µ(U ))kt ≤ 2µ(U ) + c(U )(1 − log c(U )). Instead for any t ≤ z the same estimate holds by inequality (4). Since, by an easy computation |(1 − µ(U ))kt − e−t | ≤ 2µ(U ), we get for any t ≥ 0, µ(τU > kt ) − e−t ≤ 4µ(U ) + c(U )(1 − log c(U )), which proves the first part of the theorem. Moreover, since µU (τU > kt ) − µ(τU > kt ) = |c(kt , U )| ≤ c(U ), we finally have for each t ≥ 0, µU (τU > kt ) − e−t ≤ 4µ(U ) + c(U )(2 − log c(U )).
38
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
The converse part is proven in the same way. For k ≥ 1, µ(τU > k) = 1 − µ(τU ≤ k) = 1−
k X
µ(τU = j )
j =1
= 1 − µ(U )
k X
µU (τU > j − 1),
j =1
where we used in the last equality the relation (3). Hence k X −kµ(U ) −(j −1)µ(U ) −kµ(U ) | ≤ 1 − µ(U ) e −e c(U ) |µ(τU > k) − e + kµ(U )e j =1 1 − e−kµ(U ) −kµ(U ) − e c(U ) ≤ 1 − µ(U ) + kµ(U )e 1 − e−µ(U ) µ(U ) −kµ(U ) ) 1 − + kµ(U )e c(U ) ≤ (1 + e 1 − e−µ(U ) ≤ 2µ(U ) + kµ(U )e c(U ). c(U )−1 /µ(U ): This gives, whenever k ≤ k0 := loge |c(k, U )| ≤ 2µ(U ) + e c(U ) loge c(U )−1 . For k > k0 we simply have |c(k, U )| ≤ µ(τU > k0 ) + µU (τU > k0 ) c(U ). ≤ 2µ(U ) + e c(U ) loge c(U )−1 + e−k0 µ(U ) + e
t u
The last theorem gives a necessary and sufficient condition to obtain the exponential law, that is d(U ) → 0. However, such a quantity is not very transparent for dynamical systems, that is why we give a criterion to estimate it. This kind of condition is a generalization of the so-called “self-mixing condition” introduced in [Hir95]. Lemma 2.4. Let U ⊂ X a measurable set. The following estimate holds: c(U ) ≤ inf { aN (U ) + bN (U ) + N µ(U )| N ∈ N}, where the quantities are defined by aN (U ) = µU (
N [
T −j U ) = µU (τU ≤ N ),
j =1
bN (U ) = sup |µU (T −N V ) − µ(V )| V ∈U∞
with U = {U, U c }, Un =
Wn−1 k=0
T −k U and U∞ = ∪n σ (Un ).
Statistics of Return Times
39
Proof. Let N ∈ N. If k < N, we just bound c(k, U ) by |µU (τU > k) − µ(τU > k)| = |µU (τU ≤ k) − µ(τU ≤ k)| ≤ |µU (τU ≤ k)| + |µ(τU ≤ k)| ≤ aN (U ) + kµ(U ) ≤ aN (U ) + N µ(U ). Otherwise, let us remark that {τU > k} and {τU ◦ T N > k − N } differ only on {τU ≤ N }, and by hypothesis |µU (τU > k) − µU (τU ◦ T N > k − N )| ≤ µU (τU ≤ N ) = aN (U ). Moreover |µU (τU ◦ T N > k − N) − µ(τU > k − N )| = |µU (T −N (τU > k − N)) − µ(τU > k − N )| ≤ bN (U ). But {τU > k − N } and {τU > k} differs only on {τU ◦ T k−N ≤ N }, hence |µ(τU > k − N) − µ(τU > k)| ≤ µ(τU ◦ T k−N ≤ N ) = µ(τU ≤ N ) ≤ N µ(U ). We finally get for each k, N ∈ N, |µU (τU > k) − µ(τU > k)| ≤ aN (U ) + bN (U ) + N µ(U ), which concludes the proof, since N is arbitrary. u t We remark that bN (U ) is bounded by α(N) if the partition U = {U, U c } is α-mixing, and by γ (N ) if it is uniformly mixing (see Definition 2.1 below). To simplify, we could say that the exponential law holds when there exists some N so small that only few points of U come back in U before N steps, but large enough such that T N U is uniformly spread out. Definition 2.1 (Speed of mixing). Let (X, B, T , µ) be a dynamical system and ξ a W −j ξ and σ (ξ ) the finite or countable measurable partition of X. We set ξk = k−1 k j =0 T σ -algebra generated by ξk . 1. Uniform mixing. The partition ξ is uniformly mixing with speed γ (n) going to zero for n going to infinity if for any n, γ (n) = sup k,l
sup
R∈σ (ξk ) S∈T −(n+k) σ (ξl )
|µ(R ∩ S) − µ(R)µ(S)|.
2. α-mixing. The partition ξ is α-mixing with speed α(n) going to zero for n going to infinity if for any n, µ(R ∩ S) sup α(n) = sup µ(R) − µ(S) . k,l R∈ξk S∈T −(n+k) σ (ξl )
40
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
3. ϕ-mixing. The partition ξ is ϕ-mixing with speed ϕ(n) going to zero for n going to infinity if for any n, µ(R ∩ S) sup ϕ(n) = sup µ(R)µ(S) − 1 . k,l R∈σ (ξk ) S∈T −(n+k) ξl
4. Weak-Bernoulli. The partition ξ is weak-Bernoulli with speed β(n) going to zero when n goes to infinity, if for any n, X |µ(R ∩ S) − µ(R)µ(S)|. β(n) = sup k,l
R∈ξk S∈T −(n+k) ξl
Remark 2.5. We state some general implications and results verified by the preceding types of mixing. 1. ϕ-mixing implies α-mixing which implies uniform mixing. For any n, γ (n) ≤ α(n) ≤ ϕ(n). 2. ϕ-mixing implies weak-Bernoulli which implies uniform mixing. For any n, γ (n) ≤ β(n) ≤ ϕ(n). 3. If ξ is a generating partition of an uniformly mixing dynamical system, then the system is mixing. 4. If ξ is a generating weak-Bernoulli partition then the system is metrically conjugated with a Bernoulli shift. 2.2. Successive return times. We will now investigate the properties of successive return times to the set U . For this purpose, let us define the k th return time in U by ( 0 if k = 0, (k) τU (x) = (k−1) τU (x) + τU (T τU (x) (x)) if k > 1. Observe that the difference between two consecutive return times follows the same law than the first, for the simple reason that (K+1)
τU
(K)
− τU
(K)
= τU ◦ T τU
and the measure µU is invariant with respect to the induced application on U . Theorem 2.6. Let U ⊂ X be a measurable set, and U = {U, U c } the partition associated to it. Given an integer K and a rectangle QK in RK , the differences between successives normalized return times in U are independent and exponentially distributed up to f (K, U ) (see (5) below), where f (K, U ) is defined depending on the type of mixing by (α) When (X, T , µ) is α-mixing for U, with speed α 1 , then f (K, U ) = K 3d(U ) + inf {α(M) + 3Mµ(U )} . M∈N
1 We just need that mixing property for some special sets, more precisely, we are interested by
µ(R ∩ S) α 0 (N) = sup − µ(S) µ(R)
j, N ∈ N, R ∈ Uj , T j R ⊂ U, V ∈ T −j −N U∞ .
Statistics of Return Times
41
(γ ) When the partition U is uniformly mixed by (X, T , µ) with speed γ , then f (K, U) = K 4d(U ) +
inf
M∈N γ (M)<µ(U )2
γ (M) µ(U )2
2 − K log
γ (M) µ(U )2
+ 3Mµ(U ) .
Indeed the following inequality holds: Z Y K 1 (1) (2) (1) (K) (K−1) −si K )∈ e ds QK − µU (τU , τU −τU , . . . , τU −τU µ(U ) QK i=1
≤ f (K, U ). (5) Remark 2.7. Note that the mixing assumption is made only for the special partition U. If the system has a partition Z (not necessarily with two elements), uniformly mixing with speed γZ , then for any cylinder U ∈ Zn of order n, the partition U = {U, U c } is still uniformly mixing with speed γU (M) ≤ γZ (M − n). The proof of the theorem is inspired by [CG93], with the following differences: 1) U is any measurable set; 2) we take care of the approximations to get an estimation of the error; 3) we still get an estimation even if the system is uniformly mixing; however, it is interesting whenever γ (M) = o(1/M 2 ). Proof of Theorem 2.6. Let us remark first that if we denote by F = T τU the induced application on U , then for each k ∈ N, (k+1)
τU
(k)
− τU = τU ◦ F k .
We set τk = (τU , τU ◦ F, · · · , τU ◦ F k−1 ). We will show that the inequality (5) holds by induction on K. For K = 1, we apply Theorem 2.1 which gives, setting Q1 = [u, v], Z v e−s ds| |µU (τU ∈ [u, v]) − u
= |µU (τU > v) − µU (τU > u) − (e−u − e−v )| ≤ 2d(U ). Let’s suppose that the inequality (5) is true for K; we want to prove that it is also true for K + 1. Let [r, s] be the projection of QK+1 onto the last coordinate, and for k = K, K + 1 denote: Dk = U ∩ τk−1 (
1 Qk ). µ(U )
For any M ∈ N, the set defined by n o EK+1 (M) = DK ∩ x ∈ U | τU ◦ T M ◦ F K (x) ∈ [r, s]/µ(U ) − M verifies the inclusions EK+1 (M) ∩ {τU ◦ F K > M} ⊂ DK+1 ⊂ EK+1 (M) ∪ {τU ◦ F K ≤ M}.
42
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
Theorem 2.1 shows that the two sets which bound DK+1 do not differ too much, namely, µU (τU ◦ F K ≤ M) = µU (τU ≤ M) ≤ 1 − e−Mµ(U ) + d(U ) ≤ Mµ(U ) + d(U ). Therefore we get the first bound |µU (DK+1 ) − µU (EK+1 (M))| ≤ Mµ(U ) + d(U ).
(6)
So the problem reduces to prove that µU (EK+1 (M)) follows the expected law. We j (K) decompose the sets EK+1 (M) over AK = U ∩ {τU = j }. We have j
j
EK+1 (M) ∩ AK = DK ∩ AK ∩ T −(M+j ) {τU ∈
[r, s] − M}. µ(U )
j
We can now use the mixing with R = DK ∩ AK ∈ σ (Uj ) and S = T −(M+j ) {τU ∈ [r, s]/µ(U ) − M}. According to the type of mixing, we get two approximations: (α) When the partition U is α-mixing: j
j
|µU (EK+1 (M) ∩ AK ) − µU (DK ∩ AK )µ(τU ∈
[r, s] − M)| µ(U )
j
≤ α(M)µU (DK ∩ AK ). Summing over the possible values of j we get: |µU (EK+1 (M)) − µU (DK )µ(τU ∈
[r, s] − M)| ≤ α(M)µU (DK ) ≤ α(M). µ(U )
(7)
Now Theorem 2.1 gives |µ(τU ∈
[r, s] [r, s] − M) − (e−r − e−s )| ≤ |µ(τU ∈ ) − (e−r − e−s )| + 2Mµ(U ) µ(U ) µ(U ) ≤ 2(Mµ(U ) + d(U )).
We briefly recall the approximations done with their respective errors [r,s] −r − e−s ) µU (DK+1 )→µU (EK+1 (M))→µU (DK )µ{τU ∈ µ(U ) }→µU (DK )(e ↓ ↓ ↓ Mµ(U ) + d(U ) α(M) 2(Mµ(U ) + d(U ))
This allows us to show that the difference Z K+1 Y −si K+1 e ds µU (DK+1 ) − QK+1
(8)
i=1
is bounded by the quantity f (K, U ) + 3Mµ(U ) + α(M) + 3d(U ) ≤ f (K + 1, U ), which proves the induction and concludes the proof of this first case. (γ ) We now consider the case when U is uniformly mixing:
Statistics of Return Times
43
Let M be such that γ (M) < µ(U )2 . As a first step, we can restrict ourselves to the case γ (M) > 0. In fact, when QK ⊂ [0, z]K , with z = − log µ(U )2 QK \ [0, z]K ⊂
K [ k=1
K−k Rk−1 + ×]z, ∞] × R+
which implies using Theorem 2.1 K
µU (µ(U )τK ∈ QK \ [0, z] ) ≤
K X k=1
(k+1)
µU (τU
(k)
− τU > z/µ(U ))
= KµU (τU > z/µ(U )) ≤ K(e−z + d(U )). Moreover Z
K Y
QK \[0,z]K i=1
e−si ds K ≤
K Z X
K Y
k−1 K−k k=1 R+ ×]z,∞]×R+ i=1
e−si ds K ≤ Ke−z .
Next, by decomposing according to µU (µ(U )τK ∈ QK ) = µU (µ(U )τK ∈ QK ∩ [0, z]K ) + µ(µ(U )τK ∈ QK \ [0, z]K ), we get f (K, U ) ≤ K(2e−z + d(U )) + f 0 (K, U ), where f 0 (K, U ) is the maximum of the difference (5) for the boxes QK ⊂ [0, z]K . We then estimate f 0 (K, U ). First by uniform mixing we get j
j
|µU (EK+1 (M) ∩ AK ) − µU (DK ∩ AK )µ(τU ∈ [r, s]/µ(U ) − M)| ≤
γ (M) µ(U )
and then we sum over all possible2 values j of τ (K) , |µU (EK+1 (M)) − µU (DK )µ(τU ∈ [r, s]/µ(U ) − M)| ≤
Kzγ (M) . µ(U )2
The same computation performed after estimation (7) (where now α(M) is replaced zγ (M) + by Kzγ (M)/µ(U )2 in inequality (7)), gives the bound f 0 (K + 1, U ) ≤ K µ(U )2 3(d(U ) + Mµ(U )). Then for each M, f 0 (K, U ) ≤ K 2
zγ (M) + 3K(d(U ) + Mµ(U )). µ(U )2
Since M is arbitrary, our choice of z implies that the inequality (5) is verified with γ (M) γ (M) 2−K log +3Mµ(U ) . u t f (K, U ) = K 4d(U ) + inf 2 µ(U ) µ(U )2 M∈N γ (M)<µ(U )2
2 Since Q ⊂ [0, z]K , the K th return time is less or equal to Kz, hence it takes at most [Kz] different K values.
44
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
We are now ready to give the most important result of this section, namely, to prove the Poisson statistics for successive return times. Let N (t) be the number of visits into U up to the normalized time t/µ(U ), o n (K) N(t) = sup K > 0| τU ≤ t/µ(U ) . It turns out that N(t) is a discrete random variable whose law is close to a Poissonian one, more precisely we have Theorem 2.8. The distribution of the number of visits N (t) differs from the Poissonian law by K µU (N(t) = K) − t e−t ≤ g(t, K, U ) + g(t, K + 1, U ), K! p where for each k ≥ 0 g(t, k, U ) = 12t k /k + k k−1 k f (k, U ). Proof. It is a consequence of the weak dependence of the differences of successives return times established by Theorem 2.6. We first remark that t t (K) (K+1) } ∩ {τU } > µU (N(t) = K) = µU {τU ≤ µ(U ) µ(U ) = µU τ (K) ≤ t/µ(U ) − µU τ (K+1) ≤ t/µ(U ) . It is then sufficient to compute the measure of points whose k th rescaled return time is ek (t) the distribution of the sum of the smaller than t, for k = K, K + 1. If we put P differences of successive return times, we know that when the latter are i.i.d. random variables with the same exponential law, then setting n o Lk (t) = (s1 , . . . , sk ) ∈ Rk+ s1 + · · · + sk ≤ t we get ek (t) = Pk (t) := P
Z
k Y
Lk (t) i=1
e−si dsi
t K −t e . K! The difficulty comes now from the fact that we have to translate Theorem 2.6 given for boxes on the simplex Lk (t). Let’s suppose that f (k, U ) < 1, otherwise there is nothing to prove. Hence the integer defined by N = [k/f (k, U )k+1 ] is bigger than k. We consider the uniform partition of [0, t]k by cubes of size t/N. Let 1k be the union of those cubes Qk included P in the interior of Lk (t), for which for any (s1 , . . . , sk ) ∈ Qk , ki=1 si < t and 6k those which intersect the boundary, i.e. the union of those cubes such that there exists which gives the classical result PK (t) − PK+1 (t) =
Statistics of Return Times
45
s2 t
s t
1
Fig. 1. Partition of the cube [0, t]k for k = 2. 6k is the union of dotted squares and 1k the union of shaded rectangles Rk (Qk ).
P (s1 , . . . , sk ) ∈ Qk with ki=1 si = t. By using the notation τk introduced in the proof of Theorem 2.6 we have, Z k Y (k) −si k e ds δ := µU (τU ≤ t/µ(U )) − Lk (t) i=1 Z Y Z Y k k 1k 6k )− )+ e−si ds k + µU (τk ∈ e−si ds k ≤ µU (τk ∈ µ(U ) µ(U ) 1k 6k ≤ δ1 + δ2 + δ3 .
i=1
i=1
To estimate δ1 , we put 5 for the projection over the k − 1 last coordinates; then the sets Rk (Qk ) = {Q0k ∈ 1k |5(Q0k ) = 5(Qk )} are boxes, and their number is bounded by N k−1 (see Fig. 1). For each of these boxes Theorem 2.6 gives an error smaller than f (k, U ), and then we get δ1 ≤ N k−1 f (k, U ). To compute δ2 and δ3 , we first remark that a straightforward combinatorial calculus k of cubes inside 6 , C k ≤ 6N k−1 (see [Sau98b]). But for each gives, for the number CN k N cube Qk ⊂ 6k Theorem 2.6 gives Z µU (τk ∈ Qk ) ≤
k Y
Qk i=1
e−si ds k + f (k, U ).
Summing over all the cubes contained in 6k one has δ2 ≤ 6N k−1 f (k, U )+δ3 . Moreover Z Y k e−si ds k is bounded by the volume of Qk equal to (t/N )k , which the integral gives δ3 ≤
Qk i=1 6N k−1 t k /N k . We
then deduce that
δ ≤ δ1 + δ2 + δ3 ≤ N k−1 f (k, U ) + 12t k /N which implies δ ≤ 12t k /k + k k f (k, U ) by the previous choice of N. u t
46
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
3. Applications In the preceding chapter we gave general estimates for the error between the distribution of the number of visits into a set U and the Poissonian law. We could wonder whether this law is attained in the limit of µ(U ) → 0. Put in this way the question is not very clear. What we need is instead to localize a sequence of neighborhoods Uε (z) shrinking to zero and ask whether the Poisson law holds in the limit ε → 0. This approach was successfully carried out by several authors as reminded in the introduction.Although their results were applied to dynamical systems, the inspiration and some of the techniques of the proofs were of probabilistic nature (theory of moments, Laplace transform). Here we follow a purely dynamical direction, trying to extract all the statistical information by the ergodic properties of the system. In this way we are able, for example, to exhibit the Poissonian statistics for a large class of non uniformly hyperbolic maps of the interval, widely studied in the last years especially to determine the rate of decay of correlations and the central limit theorem. Some statistical properties of these maps have been studied in the paper [LSV97] (this paper contains a quite complete bibliography on the subject), where an absolutely continuous invariant probability measure (acim) is first constructed, and then it is shown that it enjoys a polynomial decay of correlations. One feature of these maps is that they are characterized by a structure parameter (the order of tangency at an indifferent fixed point), which governs the statistical properties, and that can be viewed as an indicator of the “weak” hyperbolicity of the map. Actually, it turns out that this parameter appears even in the approximation to the Poissonian law. Let’s then consider for 0 < α < 1 the following map of the unit interval: ( x(1 + 2α x α ) ∀x ∈ [0, 1/2) . T (x) = 2x − 1 ∀x ∈ [1/2, 1] We recall some properties and results which we will need in the following, and we refer the reader to the quoted paper for more informations and proofs. This application has a finite Markov partition (with two elements), but for our purposes it is more convenient to work with the countable one ξ generated by the left preimages an of 1, ξ = { Am | m ∈ N} an ≤ 2. with An =]an+1 , an ]. We will often use in the following the easy bound an+1 We can associate to each point z ∈ X =]0, 1] an unique infinite sequence ω = ω1 ω2 ... with the property that T m−1 z ∈ Aωm for all integer m ≥ 1. We denote by ξm the dynamical partition ξ ∨ T −1 ξ · · · T −m+1 ξ and call its elements m-cylinders. We denote with ξm (z) ∈ ξm the m-cylinder which contains z. The sequence ω satisfies the admissibility condition: ωm ωm+1 appears in ω if and only if ωm = 0 or ωm+1 = ωm − 1. We say that a non empty cylinder C = [ω1 . . . ωk ] ∈ ξk is maximal if it maps onto X after exactly k iterations, which is easily seen to be equivalent to ωk = 0. 3.1. Some mixing properties. We begin with a brief survey of some results proved by two of us (B.S., S.V) in the joint paper [LSV97] with Carlangelo Liverani. We showed that the density h of the acim belongs to a certain cone of functions C∗ (a), which will be characterized later (see Lemma 3.2), provided a is big enough, and satisfies3 : 3 We recall the formal definition of the Perron Frobenius operator P acting on function f : [0, 1] → R: P 1 Pf (x) = T y=x D1 T f (y). One easily check that µ is an acim iff h = dµ dx is a fixed point of P on L (dx). y
Statistics of Return Times
47
Lemma A (Lemma 2.2 in [LSV97]). The cone C∗ (a) is left invariant by the PerronFrobenius operator P , i.e. P (C∗ (a)) ⊂ C∗ (a). Lemma B (Lemma 2.3 in [LSV97]). The density h belongs to the cone C∗ (a), and verifies in particular whenever x ≤ y, h(x) ≤ (y/x)α+1 , h(y) h(x) ≤ ax −α .
(9) (10)
Proposition C (Distortion inequality, proof of Proposition 3.3 in [LSV97]). There exists some constant 1 such that for all k and x, y ∈ C ∈ ξk , Dx T k ≤ 1 < ∞. Dy T k
(11)
We will suppose without loss of generality that a ≥ 41. Theorem D (Theorem 4.1 in [LSV97]). In the proof of this theorem we in particular got that for f ∈ C∗ (a),
n
(12)
P f − λ(f ) 1 ≤ 8(n)kf kL1 (λ) L (λ)
with 8(n) = Cn− α +1 (log n) α = OL (n− α +1 ), where we define by 1
1
1
OL (ε) = O(ε(log ε−1 )r ) in the limit ε → 0, for any constant r. We then need a few more results on the speed of mixing which turn out to be useful for the statistics of return times and also to establish the weak-bernoullicity of the map. Lemma 3.1. For any z ∈ X, and for any m such that ξm (z) is maximal, the partition U = {ξm (z), ξm (z)c } satisfies a property close to the α-mixing, namely µ(R ∩ T −N−j S) 1 − µ(S) = OL ((N − m)1− α ). α 0 (N ) = sup sup sup µ(R) j ∈N R∈Uj S∈U∞ T j R⊂U
Proof. Let z be a point of X and m be an integer such that ξm (z) is maximal. Let U be the partition given by ξm (z) and its complement, and Uj the refinement of U. For R ∈ Uj such that T j R ⊂ U , we have R ∈ σ (ξm+j ) and R is a union of maximal k ∈ ξm+j ; choose V ∈ ξm+j one of these maximal cylinders. For any cylinders Vm+j −(N +j ) B there exists a set W ∈ B such that R = T −(N+j ) W . We then have S∈T (∗) := µ(V ∩ S) − µ(V )µ(S) Z Z = 1I V 1I W ◦ T N+j hdλ − µ(V )h1I W dλ Z = P N+j [h(1I V − µ(V ))]1I W dλ ≤ kP N+j [h(1I V − µ(V ))]kL1 (λ) .
48
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
By exploiting the fact that V is maximal we continue the preceding bound as
(∗) ≤ P N−m [P j +m (h1I V ) − µ(V )] 1 + P N −m [µ(V )h − µ(V )] L (λ)
L1 (λ)
≤ 4a8(N − m)µ(V ), with 8 given by inequality (12), provided P m+j (h1I V ) ∈ C∗ (a), which is the case by Lemma 3.2 below. We conclude the proof by summing over all the maximal cylinders of R. u t Lemma 3.2. For any maximal cylinder V ∈ ξp , P p (h1I V ) ∈ C∗ (a). p
Proof. We first set f := P p (h1I V ) and TV : V → X the restriction of T p to V . Since T p is injective over V we can rewrite f as −p
−p
f (x) = h ◦ TV (x)Dx TV
which in particular shows that f is continuous. To prove that f belongs to the cone of smooth functions C∗ (a) we must verify the following four properties which just define the cone: 1. f is continuous and positive, that is clear in our case. −p 2. f is decreasing. Since h ∈ C∗ (a), h decreases. In addition, TV is decreasing and −p −p concave, therefore h ◦ TV and DTV decrease. −p α+1 f (x) increases. Since TV : X → V is increasing, an equivalent statement 3. x 7 → x is that 1 (T p u)α+1 h(u) Du T p is increasing with u ∈ V . Observing that p α+1 1 T u u Du T p increases over V ∈ ξp (which is true for p = 1 and the general case is proved by α+1 recurrence), and R u 7 → u h(u) increases, we obtain the result. 4. f (x) ≤ ax −α f . Since f is continuous, there exists v ∈ V such that Z 1 . f = f (T p v) = h(v) Dv T p The distortion estimate (11) for u ∈ V ∈ ξp gives Dv T p ≤ 1. Du T p Moreover since h decreases, inequality (9) yields h(aω1 +1 ) aω1 α+1 h(u) ≤ ≤ ≤ 4. h(v) h(aω1 ) aω1 +1
Statistics of Return Times
49 −p
As a consequence, we get for u = TV x, 1 1 ≤ 4h(v) ≤ ax −α f (x) = h(u) Du T p Dv T p
Z f,
because x ≤ 1 and 41 ≤ a. u t We finally prove that the countable partition ξ , and therefore the two-elements one, is weakly Bernoulli. Theorem 3.3. The partition ξ is weakly Bernoulli for (X, T , µ) with speed β(n) = OL (n1−1/α ). Proof. We begin to recall the following result by Hofbauer and Keller [HK82] which permits to bound β(n) as β(n) ≤ sup
X
m∈N R∈ξ
kP n+m ((1I R − µ(R))h)kL1 . λ
(13)
m
Then it will be enough to bound kP m+n ((1I R − µ(R))h)k with R ∈ ξm . Let pR ≥ m be the integer for which R ∈ ξpR is maximal. We decompose the sum over all the cylinders R ∈ ξm into two blocks. Let M(m, n) be the set of maximal cylinders for pR < m + n/2. When R ∈ M(m, n), the same computation performed in Lemma 3.1 gives kP m+n ((1I R − µ(R))h)kL1 ≤ µ(R)OL ((m + n − pR )1−1/α ) = µ(R)OL (n1−1/α ). λ
Then the set of cylinders which do not belong to M(m, n) is exactly T −m+1 [0, an/2 ], whose measure is equal to µ(T −m+1 [0, an/2 ]) = µ([0, an/2 ]) =
Z
an/2
h(x)dx = O(n1−1/α ).
0
This proves the theorem. u t
3.2. Statistics of return times. We now come back to the study of return times and the first step will be the estimation of the quantities involved in the error term given by Lemma 2.4. Lemma 3.4. There exists a constant B such that for any k and C ∈ ξk with T −k C ∩C 6= ∅, sup P k 1I C ≤ Bk −1−1/α .
(14)
50
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
Proof. Let k0 be such that Dak0 T ≤ 2, and put r = Dak0 T > 1. Let C = [ω1 ...ωk ] be a k-cylinder such that T −k C ∩ C 6 = ∅. This implies that ωk ω1 is admissible. We want to estimate sup P k 1I C = 1/ inf C DT k . If ωj ≤ k0 for all j = 1..k, then DT k ≥ r k . Else, take j such that ωj = max1≤i≤k ωi . Either j = 1, and consequently ωk = 0 or ωj −1 = 0. In the last case we have inf DT k ≥ C
inf
[ω1 ...ωj −1 ]
DT j −1
inf
[ωj ...ωk ]
DT k+1−j ≥ 1−1
inf
[ωj ...ωk ω1 ...ωj −1 ]
DT k .
By this argument we are led to consider the worst case which is given by a cylinder of type C = [(k − 1)(k − 2)...0]. For T k C = [0, 1], the distortion formula (11) and the estimation ak ≤ ck −1/α given by Lemma 3.2 in [LSV97] we get Dak T k = c0 k 1+1/α for some constant c0 , from which the lemma follows by taking B ≥ 1/c0 such that t Bk 1−1/α ≥ r k for all k > 0. u We now introduce the first return time of a cylinder U which plays a crucial role in [Hir95]. We define it as τ (U ) = inf { τU (x)| x ∈ U }. Lemma 3.5. The quantity aN (U ) defined in Lemma 2.4 for U = ξm (z) is bounded by, aN (U ) =
N µ(U ) 41 . inf h λ(T τ (U ) U )
Proof. We suppose N > τ (U ) otherwise aN (U ) = 0. Set τ = τ (U ); for each z in X we have aN (U ) ≤
N X j =1
=
N X j =τ
1 µ(T −j U ∩ U ) µ(U ) 1 µ(U )
Z
≤ N sup sup j =τ..N U
P j (1I U h)1I U dλ P j (1I U h) . h
Now the distortion (11) and the regularity of the density (9) give P τ (1I U h) = h ◦ TU−τ DTU−τ 1I T τ U Z 1 ≤ 41 h ◦ TU−τ DTU−τ 1I T τ U dλ λ(T τ U ) T τ U µ(U ) . ≤ 41 λ(T τ U ) Finally, P h = h and since P is a positive operator one has P j −τ infh h P j −τ 1I 41 µ(U ) P j (1I U h) ≤ sup P τ (1I U h) ≤ sup P τ (1I U h) ≤ . h h h inf h λ(T τ U ) t u
Statistics of Return Times
51
The next step will be to show that τ (U ) is almost everywhere big enough to give a good upper bound in the previous lemma for aN (U ). We first define in full generality the local rate of return for cylinders. As a matter of fact, we would like to point out that the first return time of a set into itself allows to define and compute an interesting dimension-like characteristic which we called the Afraimovich-Pesin dimension in [PSV98]. Definition 3.1. Let ζ a partition of X. Denote with ζn (x) the element of ζ ∨ T −1 ζ ∨ · · · ∨ T −n+1 ζ which contains x ∈ X. We then define the local (lower and upper) rate of return for cylinders as τ (ζn (x)) . R ζ (x) = lim n n→∞ Proposition 3.6. (i) Both R ζ and R ζ are sub-invariant, namely R ζ ◦ T ≤ R ζ and Rζ ◦ T ≤ Rζ . (ii) Assume that ζ is a measurable partition of the measurable space X, and µ is an invariant probability, then R ζ and R ζ are µ-a.e. invariant. (iii) Moreover, whenever µ is ergodic R ζ and R ζ are µ-a.e. constant Proof. (i) Let x ∈ X. For each integer n > 0, we have: ζn (x) ∩ T k ζn (x) 6 = ∅ H⇒ ζn−1 (T x) ∩ T k ζn−1 (T x) 6 = ∅, which implies that τ (ζn−1 (T x)) ≤ τ (ζn (x)). (ii) is a standard property of sub-invariant functions on finite measure spaces and then (iii) follows immediately. u t We state the following result which can be improved for some subshifts4 . Proposition 3.7. For µ-almost every z ∈ X, the lower rate of return for cylinders is equal to 1. R ξ (z) = 1. Proof. Let 1/2 < δ < 1. Consider the set (we denote Nm (z) = τ (ξm (z))), Lm := { z ∈ A0 | Nm (z) ≤ δm}. If ∞ X
µ(Lm ) < ∞,
(15)
m=1
then the Borel-Cantelli Lemma ensures that for almost every z ∈ A0 , we have Nm > δm, up to finitely many m. By sending δ to 1 we show that R ξ (z) ≥ 1 almost everywhere on A0 . Then for the preceding proposition (iii) and the ergodicity of the measure µ, we 4 We have in fact the following: Theorem. Suppose that µ is a Gibbs state for the Hölder potential ϕ on some irreducible and aperiodic subshift of finite type with finite alphabet ζ , then µ-almost everywhere, R ζ = R ζ = 1.
Proof. An easiest version of the Proposition 3.7 gives the lower bound, while the uniform upper bound τ (Cn ) ≤ n + n0 holds, where Cn is a cylinder of order n, and n0 is the lowest power for which the transition matrix becomes strictly positive.
52
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
get the same bound almost everywhere. The equality finally follows since each time that T m−1 z ∈ A0 , we have T m ξm (z) = X hence Nm (z) ≤ m. In order to prove (15) it is sufficient to consider the Lebesgue measure instead of µ (since the density h is bounded from below). We have λ(Lm ) =
[m/2] X
δm X
λ(Nm = k) +
k=1
λ(Nm = k).
k=[m/2]+1
(1)
+
(2)
We now perform a detailed analysis of the sets appearing in the preceding formula. (1): In this case, the cylinder ξm (z) with Nm = k must be of the form ξm (z) = [(ω1 .. .ωk )(ω1 ...ωk )...(ω1 . ..ωk )...]. | {z } [m/k]
Therefore when k ≤ [m/2], the cylinder is completely determined by its first k symbols. Put C = [ω1 ...ωk ]; we say that a cylinder of length k is admissible (admis) when it is the beginning of a cylinder of Lm with Nm = k. Then we can bound (1) by (1) ≤
[m/2] X
X
λ(C ∩ T −k C ∩ · · · ∩ T −[m/k−1]k C)
k=1 C admis
≤
[m/2] X
X
k=1 C admis
≤
[m/2] X
sup
k=1 C admis
sup P k 1I C
[m/k]−1
C
k
sup P 1I C
[m/k]−1
C
λ(C) .
We first remark that T k being injective over C ∈ ξk , we have P k 1I C ≤ 1/ inf DT k ≤ 1/2. A0
1+ α1
We split the last sum in three pieces by fixing k0 as the biggest integer for which k0 eB , where B is the constant in Lemma 3.4. We then have by using Lemma 3.4,
≥
m/3 [m/2] k0 X X X [m/k]−1 −1−1/α m/k−2 (1/2) + (Bk ) + Bk −1−1/α . (1) ≤ k=1
m/3
k=k0
The first and the last sum are easily shown to be summable with respect to m. For the second term, we observe that the terms (Bk −1−1/α )m/k−2 are increasing in k when k is bigger than k0 . A direct estimation of the sum is B31/α m−1/α which is summable with respect to m. (2): In this case, the cylinder ξm (z) has the form ξm (z) = [ω1 ...ωm−k ωm−k+1 ...ωk ω1 ...ωm−k ]. | {z } | {z } | {z } m−k
2k−m
m−k
Statistics of Return Times
53
As before, we set C = [ω1 ...ωm−k ], and we say that C is admissible (admis) when it is the beginning of a cylinder of Lm with Nm = k, (2) ≤
δm X
X
λ(C ∩ T −k C)
k=[m/2]+1 C admis
≤
δm X
sup sup P k 1I C .
k=[m/2]+1 C admis C
Let first p = p(C) ≥ m − k be such that C ∈ ξp is maximal (i.e. p(C) is the smallest p for which C ∈ ξp ). When p < k, since 1 ∈ C∗ (a) the inequality (12) and Lemma 3.4 give sup P k 1I C ≤ sup P p 1I C sup P k−p 1 ≤ a2α Bp−1−1/α ≤ a2α B(m − k)−1−1/α . C
C
When p ≥ k, C ∈ ξk and T −k C ∩ C 6 = ∅ we have P k 1I C ≤ Bk −1−1/α . But k ≥ m − k ≥ (1 − δ)m, and then the sum (15) is summable for any δ < 1. u t We are now ready to state and prove the main theorems of this section ¯ Theorem 3.8. For µ-almost every z ∈ X and β < β(α), t − exp(−t) = O(µ(ξm (z))β ), sup µξm (z) τξm (z) > µ(ξm (z)) t≥0 ¯ where the critical exponent β(α) = 1 − α. Proof. Let ε be a positive number. Let z be a typical point for Proposition 3.7 and for the Shannon–McMillan–Breiman theorem. We want to apply Lemma 2.4; Let m(ε) such that for any m > m(ε) we have (1 − ε)m ≤ τ (ξm (z)), µ(ξm (z)) ≤ exp(−m2hµ /3) and also µ(ξεm (T [(1−ε)m] z)) ≥ exp(−(2[εm])hµ ). For the sake of simplicity, we put for any m, Um = ξm (z). For any m > m(ε) such that Um is maximal, we have (1 − ε)m ≤ τ (Um ) ≤ m, and all the iterates T j Um for 1 ≤ j < m are at a distance bigger than am from the neutral fixed point (because Um is −α so maximal). If τ (Um ) < m then the density stays bounded on the orbit T j Um by bam we have aα aα λ(T τ (Um ) Um ) ≥ m µ(T τ (Um ) Um ) ≥ m exp(−2εmhµ ). b b On the other hand, when τ (Um ) = m we still get λ(T τ (Um ) Um ) = 1 ≥
α am exp(−2εmhµ ). b
Lemma 3.5 gives us the following estimation with N = µ(Um )−α+ε , aN (Um ) = O(µ(Um )1−α−3ε ).
54
M. Hirata, B. Saussol, S. Vaienti
Lemma 3.1 with R = Um gives us bN (Um ) = OL ((µ(Um )−α+ε − m)1− α ) = OL (µ(Um )(−α+ε)(1− α ) ). 1
1
We can then apply Lemma 2.4, which gives c(Um ) =≤ aN (Um ) + bN (Um ) = O(µ(Um )β ) for β ≤ 1 − α − 3ε and β ≤ 1 − α − 2ε(1/α − 1). We finally end up with d(Um ) = O(µ(Um )β )
(16)
for any β < 1 − α, since ε is arbitrary small, which conclude the proof by applying Theorem 2.1. u t ¯ Remark 3.9. The preceding theorem shows that the critical exponent β(α) is smaller than 1.We point out that, by using Proposition 2.3 the power β¯ cannot exceed 1. Theorem 3.10. For µ-almost every z ∈ X, we have for any t ≥ 0 and K ≥ 0 and ¯ β < β(α), K µξ (z) Nξ (z) (t) = K − t exp(−t) = O(µ(ξm (z))β/(K+1) ). m m K! ¯ with the critical exponent β(α) = 1 − α. Proof. Let z be a typical point satisfying the preceding theorem and m such that Um = ξm (z) is maximal. By invoking the footnote of Theorem 2.6, it will be sufficient to use the weakened α-mixing condition 1 α 0 (M) = OL ((M − m)α− α ) given by Lemma 3.1 to apply Theorem 2.6. Take M = µ(Um )−α ; we thus find for β < 1 − α, and by the estimation (16) and Theorem 2.6 an error of the order f (K, Um ) = const[d(Um ) + α 0 (M) + Mµ(U )] = O(µ(Um )β ). By applying Theorem 2.8, the error for the probability to have K successive visits is of t the order µ(Um )β/(K+1) for all β < 1 − α. u 4. Concluding Remarks We conclude with few observations. First, the proofs for the exponential-one law and the Poisson law given in Sect. 3 for a class of non uniform hyperbolic maps, can be easily adapted, and they are even easier, to all the cases quoted in the introduction, namely: Axiom A diffeomorphisms, transitive Markov chains, expanding maps of the interval with a spectral gap and in general to all ϕ-mixing dynamical systems. For such systems, an estimation for the error can also be done: following the arguments of Theorems 3.8 and 3.10, one can easily see that the critical exponent β¯ is equal to 1. This supports our beliefs that: (i) the error terms of type µ(U )β could be optimal and (ii) the non uniform hyperbolicity of the map reflects in the critical exponent: in that case, in fact, it should be strictly smaller than one. Acknowledgements. We would like to thank Viviane Baladi for a careful reading of a preliminary version of this work and Bernard Schmitt for useful discussions. B.S. acknowledges the ESF for support during the workshop “Probabilistic methods in non-hyperbolic dynamics” in Warwick.
Statistics of Return Times
55
References [Coe97] [Col96] [CG93] [CFS82] [GS97] [Hay98a] [Hay98b] [Hir93] [Hir95] [HK82] [LSV97] [PSV98] [Pit91] [Sau98a] [Sau98b]
Coelho, Z.: Asymptotic laws for symbolic dynamical systems. Lectures given in Temuco, Chili, 1997 Collet, P.: Some ergodic properties of maps of the interval, Dynamical systems (Temuco, 1991/1992) (Paris), Travaux en Cours, vol. 52, Paris: Hermann, 1996, pp. 55–91 Collet, P. and Galves, A.: Statistics of close visits to the indifferent fixed point of an interval map. J. Stat. Phys. 72, no. 3-4, 459–478 (1993) Cornfeld, I.P., Fomin, S.V. and Sina˘ı, Ya.G.: Ergodic theory. vol. 245, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1982 Galves, A. and Schmitt, B.: Inequalities for hitting time in mixing dynamical systems. Random Comput. Dynam. 5, no. 4, 337–347 (1997) Haydn, N.: The distribution of the first return time for rational maps. 1998, USC Haydn, N.: Statistical properties of equilibrium states for rational maps. 1998, USC Hirata, M.: Poisson law for Axiom A diffeomorphisms. Ergodic Theory Dynamical Systems 13, no. 3, 533–556 (1993) Hirata, M.: Poisson law for the dynamical systems with the “self-mixing” conditions. In: Dynamical systems and chaos, Vol. 1 (Hachioji, 1994) (River Edge, NJ), River Edge, NJ: World Sci. Publishing, 1995, pp. 87–96 Hofbauer, F. and Keller, G.: Ergodic properties of invariant measures for piecewise monotonic transformations. Math. Z. 180, no. 1, 119–140 (1982) Liverani, C., Saussol, B. and Vaienti, S.: A probabilistic approach to intermittency. Ergodic Theory Dynamical Systems (1997). To appear Penné, V., Saussol, B. and Vaienti, S.: Fractal and statistical characteristics of recurrence times. To appear in Journal de Physique (Paris), 1998, Proceeding of the conference “Disorder and Chaos” (Rome, 22–24th Sept. 1997), in honour of Giovanni Paladin Pitskel, B.: Poisson limit law for Markov chains. Ergodic Theory Dynamical Systems 11, no. 3, 501–513 (1991) Saussol, B.:Absolutely continuous invariant measures for multidimensional expanding maps. 1998, Submitted Saussol, B.: Etude statistique de systèmes dynamiques dilatants. Ph.D.thesis, Université de Toulon et du Var, 1998
Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 57 – 103 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators with Negative Singular Poisson Potential Frédéric Klopp1 , Leonid Pastur2,3 1 Département de Mathématique, Institut Galilée, U.M.R 7539 C.N.R.S, Université de Paris-Nord, Avenue
J.-B. Clément, F-93430 Villetaneuse, France. E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Département de Mathématique, Université Paris VII, 2, Place Jussieu, F-75005 Paris, France.
E-mail:
[email protected]
3 Mathematical Division, Institute for Low Temperature Physics, 47, Lenin’s Ave., 310164, Kharka, Ukraine
Received: 18 November 1998 / Accepted: 9 March 1999
Abstract: We develop a method of asymptotic study of the integrated density of states (IDS) N (E) of a random Schrödinger operator with a non-positive (attractive) Poisson potential. The method is based on the periodic approximations of the potential instead of the Dirichlet-Neumann bracketing used before. This allows us to derive more precise bounds for the rate of approximations of the IDS by the IDS of respective periodic operators and to obtain rigorously for the first time the leading term of log N (E) as E → −∞ for the Poisson random potential with a singular single-site (impurity) potential, in particular, for the screened Coulomb impurities, dislocations, etc. Contents 0. Introduction: Problems and History . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. The Assumptions and the Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1 The integrated density of states . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 The asymptotics of the IDS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Periodic Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 A general approximation result . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Application to the estimation of the integrated density of states 3. The Lower Bounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 The general case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 The case when V is bounded from below . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 The case when V has power law singularities . . . . . . . . . 4. The Upper Bounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 The general case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Proof of Proposition 4.1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 The case when V has power law singularities . . . . . . . . . 5. Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1 The structure of the Poisson potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58 61 62 62 65 65 75 76 76 79 80 81 81 81 87 91 91
58
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
5.2 An a-priori estimate on the density of states . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 5.3 Exponential decay estimates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 5.4 Some useful facts about the single site potential Hamiltonian Hg . . . . . 97 0. Introduction: Problems and History The Integrated Density of States (IDS) is one of the simplest but quite important characteristics of the random Schrödinger operator. Among numerous problems related to the IDS, the problem of its asymptotic behavior near the edges of the spectrum is well known and studied. The results of these studies can be summarized as follows. One has to distinguish two types of spectral edges: stable and fluctuational (see e.g. [7,18,21]). The latter are special for shortly correlated random potentials. In the simplest case of the lower edge of the spectrum, they are determined by the absolute minimum of the potential since the spectrum in a neighborhood of this edge exists only because of the (arbitrarily large) fluctuations of the potential arbitrarily close to the minimum. By using the quantum mechanical terminology one can call these portions of the realization the potential wells. A heuristic derivation of the fluctuational asymptotics of the IDS was proposed by I.Lifshitz in the early 60’s [16,17]. The asymptotics is given by the probability to have a potential well whose ground state energy is close enough to the spectral edge. Since the probability of these realizations having the form of very broad or deep potential wells (and known also as optimal fluctuations) is usually exponentially small, one has to deal here with a version of the large deviation technique in the spectral context. In particular, to determine the asymptotic formula for the IDS one has to be able to give a rather detailed description of the statistics of these special realizations. This is why precise and explicit asymptotic formulae are known only for comparatively restricted classes of random potentials. One of the widely studied random potentials is the Poisson potential having the form X V (x − xj ), (0.1) Vω (x) = j
where {xj } is the Poisson point field of the density µ in Rd and V (x), the one-site (or single site) potential, is a function decaying sufficiently fast at infinity. The Poisson potential is of considerable interest both in spectral theory and in the theoretical physics of disordered systems. It possesses a number of nontrivial asymptotic regimes, only part of which has been studied so far. One has to mention first the case of the nonnegative one-site potential V (x) of compact support. In this case E = 0 is a fluctuational edge and according to I. Lifshitz, N(E) ' exp(−const · E −d/2 ), E → +0.
(0.2)
The right-hand side of this formula is just the probability to have a well (a region of Rd free of xj ’s) of width L ' E −1/2 ; the latter relation is due to the uncertainty principle. In other words, the asymptotics of the IDS in this case is determined by an optimization procedure, balancing of the quantum and the probabilistic components of the problem. This is why formula (0.2) is often called the quantum Lifshitz tail. Rigorous derivations of various versions of (0.2) (e.g. its logarithmic or even its double logarithmic forms) have required a number of rather sophisticated probabilistic and spectral techniques (see
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
59
e.g. [3,21,27,30,31,11] for results and references). Here and below we use the symbol “'” to denote the asymptotic equivalence without indicating explicitly the order of the remainder and respective constants. Other asymptotic regimes of the IDS for the potential (0.1) correspond to the case when the one-site potential has a non-positive part, i.e. inf V (x) < 0, so that the lower edge of the spectrum is E = −∞. In this case one has to distinguish the two asymptotic regimes, usually called quantum and classical. We will present respective asymptotic formulae by using a version of Lifshitz’s arguments adapted to this case. Recall the definition of the IDS. It is the limit as L → +∞ of the expectation of the normalized counting function of eigenvalues of the Schrödinger operator H3L , where H3L is the restriction of Hω = −1 + Vω to L2 (3L ) (see e.g. [21,7]). Here 3L is the cube of the Rd of center zero and of side length L. The definition shows that the IDS can be regarded as the probability to find an eigenvalue of H3L lying below a given energy E. For E → −∞ these eigenvalues are produced by very deep potential wells, created by large clusters of k Poisson points xj ’s, confined to sufficiently small regions of the space, say a cube of the side length l << L. The respective probability is d
e−µl (µl d )k /k!.
(0.3)
Assume first that l is independent of k. This corresponds to a single site potential that varies relatively slowly with respect to the exponential decay of the single site ground state. Then, the IDS has to be asymptotically equivalent to the probability (0.3) in which k is determined by the equation E(k) = E, where E(g) is the ground state energy of the well gV (x). In other words, for a non positive one-site potential V (x) optimal fluctuations are potential wells whose form is roughly kV (x). Thus, we have to find the ground state energy E(g) of the well gV (x) as the function of its coupling constant g and then the asymptotic form of the IDS will be given by (0.3) in which k = g(E), where g(E) is the asymptotic inverse of −E(g) for E → −∞, g → +∞. Since the leading contribution to (0.3) in this case is given by the factor 1/k!, the asymptotic formula should have the form N(E) ' exp(−g(E) log g(E)), E → −∞
(0.4)
log N(E) ' −g(E) log g(E), E → −∞.
(0.5)
or
The simplest case when this formula can be made rigorous is when V (x) is continuous at its (negative) absolute minimum. In this case E(g) = gV (0)(1 + o(1)), E → −∞.
(0.6)
The respective rigorous formula log N(E) =
E log |E|(1 + o(1)), E → −∞ V (0)
(0.7)
was proved in [20] using a combination of variational and Wiener integral techniques. The formula is obviously classical because it includes only the characteristics of the potential but not the Laplacian. In addition it can be easily shown that the r.h.s. of (0.4) is the asymptotic form of the logarithm of P (Vω (x) < E). This provides one more evidence of the classical nature of the formula.
60
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
This paper is devoted to quantum versions of (0.4), i.e. to singular single site potentials V (x). Despite a considerable amount of physical results in the question (see e.g. [18, 4]) rigorous results are almost absent, except the one dimensional case of point one-site potentials V (x) = −g0 δ(x), g0 > 0,
(0.8)
where δ(x) is the Dirac delta-function. In this case by using the special Markov processes technique one can obtain (see [18]) an asymptotic of the form s s E E log (1 + o(1)), E → −∞, log N(E) = −2 E0 E0 where E0 = −g02 /4. We see that formula (0.5) is only valid up to a factor 2. This difference is the result of a tunneling phenomenon related to the question how close to one another should k potentials (0.8) be in order to be regarded as the potential k ∗ (k)δ(x), i.e. the potential of same shape as (0.8) and of amplitude k ∗ (k). In other words, in this case contrary to the classical case, the radius of the exponential decay of the single site ground state is much larger than the width of the single site potential. Thus the optimal cluster should be much smaller (i.e. its radius should tend to 0 sufficiently fast) in order to be modeled by a single site potential of some effective amplitude k ∗ (k). ∗ We shall see below that in many interesting cases l ' k −α for some α ∗ > 0. Because ∗ of that, the factor k −α dk in (0.3) will also contribute to the asymptotic formula of the IDS. The study of this phenomenon is one of the topics dealt with in the present paper. In this paper we study the case of the singular one-site potential (mainly with powerlaw singularities) following in essence the scheme outlined above. We find the precise form of k ∗ (k) (see Theorem 1.4 and 1.6 below). This became possible owing to an improvement of one of the technique in the field, based on approximations of the Schrödinger operator in the whole space by the operator with the same potential but defined in a finite box whose size is properly chosen as a function of energy. Previous versions of this technique were based on the so called Neumann–Dirichlet bracketing where the boxes with the Neumann and Dirichlet boundary conditions were used to construct the upper and the lower bounds for the IDS. The error in these bounds is of the order O(L−1 ), where L is the size of the box. This precision is not sufficient to treat the quantum case. Therefore, we approximate the IDS of the random model by the IDS of some well chosen periodic Schrödinger operators and obtain much more precise bounds (see Sect. 2 and more precisely Lemmas 2.1 and 2.3)). This method was proposed in [11] and has been used to solve several problems in the field ([10,12]). We obtain the once logarithmic versions of (0.4), i.e. (0.5) with explicit g(E) and constants in front of g(E) log g(E) (see Theorems 1.5 and 1.6). Let us now give just one example of the results presented in Sect. 1.2; let V , the single site potential, be the 3-dimensional attractive screened Coulomb potential V (x) = e−|x| , widely used in semiconductor physics (see e.g.[4]). In this case we prove − |x| p log N(E) = −2 |E| log |E|(1 + o(1)), E → −∞, (see Theorem 1.6 and the discussion following it). The role of the IDS in the spectral theory and theoretical physics of disordered systems is well known and appreciated (see [2,7,21,4,18]). However, there is one more reason to
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
61
study this quantity. Since the pioneering papers of I. Lifshitz, the study of the IDS has been providing a first important step in the study and in the understanding of more complex properties and quantities in a respective version of the strong localization regime. In particular, the IDS is the first moment (see formula (1.4)) of the spectral kernel of the Schrödinger operator. From the mathematical physics point of view, the IDS determines the equilibrium properties of disordered systems, i.e. of the ideal gas of elementary excitation (electrons, phonons, spin waves, etc.) in the random environment. The study of the kinetic properties of this gas and of the interaction effects requires knowledge of higher moments of the spectral kernel, the second moments first of all. The knowledge of these correlators allows one to answer a number of relevant questions concerning the existence and the nature of the localization and behavior of related quantities. In particular, in a subsequent paper ([13]), we use the technique developed in this paper in order to find the large deficit asymptotic behavior of the inter-band light absorption coefficient. The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 1, we define the framework of our study and give a brief account of our results. We also present several examples at the end of the section. In Sect. 2, we first prove the basic relation (1.4) expressing the IDS in terms of the spectral family of the random Schrödinger operator. Then we construct our main technical tool, the periodic approximations of the IDS. Sections 3 and 4 are devoted to the derivation of the lower and upper bounds for the IDS using the periodic approximations. Section 5 contains auxiliary facts on the statistics of the Poisson field, on random Schrödinger operators and on the structure of the ground state of the Schrödinger operator with a singular single site potential. 1. The Assumptions and the Results Let V : Rd → R be a function such that V = V1 + V2 , where H1 For some C > 0 and any x ∈ Rd , |V1 (x)| ≤ Ce−|x|/C . H2 The function V2 is compactly supported and satisfies V2 ∈ Lp (Rd ), where p > p(d) and p(d) = 2 if d ≤ 2 and p(d) = d/2 if d ≥ 3. H3 For some set of positive measure E, V E < 0. Define the random potential
Z
Vω (x) =
Rd
V (x − y)m(ω, dy),
(1.1)
where m(ω, dy) is a random Poisson measure of concentration µ. Vω is an ergodic random field on Rd . Consider the random Schrödinger operator Hω = −1 + Vω .
(1.2)
One has Theorem 1.1 ([7]). Under the assumptions made above, Hω is essentially self-adjoint on C0∞ (Rd ) ω-almost surely. Under our assumptions on V , we know that the almost sure spectrum of Hω is 6 = R ([21,7]).
62
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
1.1. The integrated density of states. Let 3 be a cube centered at 0 in Rd . We define D to be the Dirichlet restriction of H to 3. Pick E ∈ R. Consider the quantity Hω,3 ω Nω,3 (E) =
1 D ]{eigenvalues of Hω,3 smaller than or equal to E}. Vol(3)
(1.3)
Then one has Theorem 1.2 ([7]). Under the assumptions made above, there exists a non-random, nondecreasing, non-negative, right continuous function N (E) such that, ω-almost surely, for all E ∈ R, E a continuity point of N, Nω,3 (E) converges to N (E) as 3 exhausts Rd . N (E) is the integrated density of states (IDS) of Hω . As N is non-decreasing, one can define its distributional derivative dN. It is a positive measure and is supported on the almost sure spectrum of Hω (see [7,21]). One has the following result: Theorem 1.3. For ϕ ∈ C0∞ (R), we have (ϕ, dN) = E(tr(1C(0,1) ϕ(Hω )1C(0,1) )),
(1.4)
where C(0, 1) is the cube of center 0 and side length 1. Formula (1.4) is well known under more restrictive assumptions on the potential Vω , i.e. for less singular single site potentials V (see [21]). 1.2. The asymptotics of the IDS. To describe the asymptotic behavior of N (E) near −∞, we will need to define an auxiliary operator. For g ∈ R, define H (g) = −1 + gV .
(1.5)
Under our assumptions on V , V is relatively form bounded with respect to −1 with relative bound 0. Hence, H (g) admits a unique self-adjoint extension. Let σ (H (g)) denote its spectrum. It is lower semi-bounded. The infimum of σ (H (g)), i.e. the ground state energy of H (g) will be denoted by E(g). Let ϕg be the respective ground state, i.e. the unique positive normalized eigenfunction of H (g) associated to energy E(g) ([22,26]). In the sequel it will often be more convenient to work with E− (g) = −E(g) instead of E(g) itself. From assumption H 3, one easily infers that E− (g) → +∞ when g → +∞ (see Sect. 5). Moreover E− is strictly increasing in a neighborhood of +∞. Let g be an inverse of E− in a neighborhood of +∞. g is strictly increasing. In the regular (classical) case, it was found that g is governing the first term asymptotic of log N (cf [21,20]). In the singular (quantum) case, the singular set of V will play a special part in the asymptotics. To measure this role, we introduce the notion of asymptotic ground state, i.e. Definition 1.1. Let g ∈ (1, +∞) 7 → ψg ∈ H 1 (Rd ). We will say that ψg is an asymptotic ground state if and only if • the vector ψg is normalized. • ∃g0 > 1, l0 > 0 such that ∀g ≥ g0 , supp ψg ⊂ C(0, l0 ) (where C(x, l) denotes the • cube of center x and side length l). |h(H (g) − E(g))ψg , ψg i| → 0 as g → +∞. (1.6) |E(g)|
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
63
In Lemma 5.6, we prove the existence of an asymptotic ground state. For a ∈ Rd , we define the translation τa by τa V (x) = V (x − a) and we define ( Aψg = α > 0;
lim
sup
g→+∞ |a|≤g −α
) g|h(τa V − V )ψg , ψg i| =0 . E− (g)
If Aψg 6 = ∅, then we define α ∗ (ψg ) := inf Aψg . Moreover, we define A to be the union of all Aψg . By Lemma 5.6, we know that A 6 = ∅. We define α ∗ := inf A.
(1.7)
Roughly speaking, the dependence of the radius of the exponential decay of the single ∗ site potential ground state on the coupling constant g is of the form g −α . This determines the characteristic size l of the optimal cluster. Then we prove Theorem 1.4. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 3, for sufficiently large E, one has −(1 + α ∗ d)g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)) ≤ log N (−E) ≤ −g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)). (1.8) One may complain that Theorem 1.4 is somewhat imprecise in that it only gives a two sided estimate. But, as we will see below, this is in some way unavoidable as the true asymptotic depends not only on g but also on the singular set of the negative part of V . More precisely, as can be seen from Theorem 1.6 (and from the proof of Theorem 1.4), the asymptotics of the IDS depends on the way the eigenfunction associated to the lowest eigenvalue for the operator −1 + gV concentrates near the singular set of the negative part of V as g becomes large. In general the correction also depends on the geometry of the singular set. For example, if the singular set is a segment (e.g. a dislocation), using the techniques developed in Sect. 3, one can see that neither the lower nor the upper bound given by Theorem 1.4 are sharp. The two sided estimate (1.8) can be made more precise if we know more on V . The first and simplest example we give is the case when V is bounded from below, reaches its minimum at a single point, say 0, and is continuous near 0. Then one easily proves that α ∗ = 0 and the upper and lower bounds in (1.8) coalesce to give (0.7). We will now give other results that, we think, enclose most of the physically relevant examples. Let v− be the essential infimum of V and assume that V is bounded from below, say H1’ −∞ < v− < 0. It is easy to show that g(E) ∼ E/|v− | when E → +∞ (see Lemma 5.5). We obtain Theorem 1.5. Under the assumptions H 1, H 2 and H 1’, one has log N(−E)
∼
E→+∞
−g(E) log g(E)
∼
E→+∞
E log E. v−
Here and in the rest of the paper, a ∼ b will always mean a = b(1 + o(1)).
(1.9)
64
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
This result extends (0.7) removing the continuity assumption near the minimum. Consider now an example a bit more singular. In this case, d = 2 and V2 (x) = log− |x|, x ∈ R2 , where, for a ≥ 0, log− a = min{log a, 0}. Using the inequality log− |x| + log R ≤ log− R|x| ≤ log |x| for 0 < R < 1 and the variational principle for the ground state energy, one shows that, in this case, E− (g) ∼ g/2 log g, hence g(E) ∼ 2E/ log E. g→+∞
E→+∞
One also shows that α ∗ = 0 for this single site potential. Therefore, Theorem 1.4 tells us that log N(−E)
∼
E→+∞
−g(E) log g(E)
∼
E→+∞
−2E.
Hence, the asymptotic formula (0.5) is also valid for certain mildly singular potentials. Another case where one can find an asymptotic for log N is when V has only power law singularities. Let q be a positive integer and pick q positive exponents (νi )i=1,...,q and q functions (hi (θ))i=1,...,q continuous on the sphere Sd−1 . For 1 ≤ i ≤ q, consider the potentials Vi (x) =
hi (θ(x)) x . where θ (x) = ν i |x| |x|
Assume that
(1.10)
( 0 < νi <
1 if d = 1, 2, 2 if d ≥ 3.
(1.11)
Then Vi is relatively form bounded with respect to −1 with relative bound 0 and we can consider the operators H i = −1 + Vi with form domain H 1 (Rd ). For 1 ≤ i ≤ q, Ei denotes the ground state energy of H i . Now we assume that H 1” • There exists q distinct points (xi )i=1,...,q in Rd and q continuous compactly supported function (Wi )i=1,...,q such that Wi (0) = 1 and V2 (x) =
q X
Wi (x − xi )Vi (x − xi ) =
i=1
q X
τxi (Wi Vi )(x).
(1.12)
i=1
• For some 1 ≤ i0 ≤ q, we have Ei0 < 0. Notice that assumption H 1” implies assumptions H 2 and H 3. Define ν † = sup {νi ; 1 ≤ i ≤ q such that Ei < 0} , n o E− = sup |Ei |; 1 ≤ i ≤ q such that Ei < 0 and νi = ν † , α† =
1 . 2 − ν†
(1.13) (1.14) (1.15)
†
Then, by Lemma 5.7, we know that E− (g) ∼ E− g 2α when g → +∞. In addition, using the periodic approximation scheme, in this case, we can find an upper bound having the same form as the lower bound in (1.8) where α ∗ is replaced by α † (Proposition 4.4). On the other hand, we prove that α ∗ ≤ α † (Lemma 3.1). From these two facts and from Theorem 1.4, we deduce α ∗ = α † and
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
65
Theorem 1.6. Under the assumptions H1 and H 1”, one has log N(−E)
∼
E→+∞
−(1 + α † d)g(E) log g(E),
† E 1−ν /2 d − ν† E − 1+ log . E→+∞ 2 E− E−
(1.16)
∼
We see that the lower bound in (1.8) is rather universal. There exist other methods to obtain this bound, for instance a version of the variational method of [18,21] (also [13]). This method also gives a sharp lower bound for practically all asymptotic formulae for log N (−E) known so far. This is true in particular for the Poisson potential with a nonpositive single site potential. Thus it is the upper bound that has been requiring different techniques depending on the specific potential (see e.g. [3,27,30,11]). Assumptions H1 and H 1” include most physically interesting cases as, for example, e−|x| . In this case the 3-dimensional attractive screened Coulomb potential V (x) = − |x| we have α ∗ = α † = 1 and E− = 1 (see [15]); thus √ log N(−E) ∼ −2 E log E. E→+∞
There is another physically interesting case that has not been discussed here: it is the case of point potentials. Such potentials will be studied in a sequel to this paper [13]. 2. Periodic Approximations 2.1. A general approximation result. In this subsection, we will show how to adapt the periodic approximation scheme developed in [11] to the case of unbounded potentials. The main new technical problems will come from the fact that, in the present case, the negative part of the random potential grows much faster at infinity than in the case dealt with in [11] or when the single site potential is bounded. In the sequel C(x, l) will denote the cube of center x and side length l. For y ∈ Rd and f a function on Rd , fy will denote the translate of f by y i.e. fy (x) = f (x − y). Fix ω; the support of the Poisson measure m(ω, dy) is a set of discrete points that we denote by (xk (ω))k∈N . We then define the following periodic potential: X X V (x − β − xk (ω)) (2.1) Vω,n = β∈nZd
k;xk (ω)∈C(0,n)
and the corresponding periodic Schrödinger operator Hω,n = −1 + Vω,n .
(2.2)
By our regularity assumptions on V , ω-almost surely, Hω,n is relatively form bounded with respect to −1 (see [2]). It is essentially self-adjoint on C0∞ (Rd ). We can define the integrated density of states Nω,n (E) of this periodic operator by the same limit procedure as in the case of the random operator (see [22,14]). We will now compare N (E) and E(Nω,n (E)). We prove
66
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Lemma 2.1. For any α ∈ (0, 1), there exists C > 1 and ρ > 0 (depending only on d) such that, for any ϕ ∈ C0∞ (R), for k ∈ N∗ and n ∈ N∗ , we have j Cµ −(1−α)k Ck log k ρ+k d ϕ (x) . e sup (|x| + C) |E((ϕ, dNω,n )) − (ϕ, dN)| ≤ Ce n jx d x∈R 0≤j ≤k+ρ
(2.3) Remark 2.1. The proof shows that the constant C obtained in Lemma 2.1 is independent of the concentration µ of the Poisson process. Before starting the proof of Lemma 2.1, let us recall some basic facts about the density of states of a periodic Schrödinger operator. Let T∗n = Rd /(2π nZd ). For θ ∈ T∗n , we can consider Hω,n,θ the unique self-adjoint operator defined by the quadratic form k∇ϕk2 + hVω ϕ, ϕi on L2θ,loc (i.e. the set of L2loc -functions that satisfy the boundary conditions ϕ(x + nγ ) = einθγ ϕ(x) for γ ∈ Zd and x ∈ Rd ; this set is endowed with the usual scalar product on L2 (C(0, n))). We know that Hω,n,θ has a compact resolvent (see [23]); hence its spectrum is discrete. Let us denote its eigenvalues by E0 (θ, ω, n) ≤ E1 (θ, ω, n) ≤ · · · ≤ En (θ, ω, n) ≤ . . . , The functions (θ 7 → En (θ, ω, n))n∈N are Lipschitz continuous in θ and one has En (θ, ω, n) → +∞ as n → +∞ (uniformly in θ ). One proves that the IDS of Hω,n satisfies
Z 1 X dθ Nω,n (E) = (2π)d {θ ∈T∗n ; En (θ,ω,n)≤E}
(2.4)
n∈N
and (ϕ, dNω,n )) =
1 tr(1C(0,n) ϕ(Hω,n )1C(0,n) ). Vol(C(0, n))
for any ϕ ∈ C0∞ (R) (see [24,23] or [28]). The rest of this subsection will be devoted to the proof of Lemma 2.1. To prove this result we will need the formula given in Theorem 1.3. The proof of this formula will be given at the end of the section. Let us proceed with the proof of Lemma 2.1. Fix ϕ ∈ C0∞ (R). We want to estimate |E((ϕ, dNω,n )) − (ϕ, dN )|. The computation done in the proof of Theorem 5.1 in [11] gives E((ϕ, dNω,n )) = E(tr(1C(0,1) ϕ(Hω,n )1C(0,1) )). Here we used the fact that the Poisson process is Zd -homogeneous. Notice that our regularity assumptions on Vω,n are weaker than the one used in [11] and [22]. Indeed, ω almost surely, Vω,n is only relatively form bounded with respect to −1 with relative bound 0 (see Lemma 5.1). Nevertheless the proofs of the relevant results in these papers extend easily to the case of relatively form bounded perturbations of −1. Now we only have to estimate |E(tr(1C(0,1) (ϕ(Hω,n )−ϕ(Hω ))))|. This is done with an integral representation of ϕ(H ) using an almost analytic extension of ϕ. Pick ϕ ∈ S(R) (the Schwartz space of rapidly decreasing functions). An almost analytic extension of ϕ is a function ϕ˜ : C → C satisfying
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
67
1. For z ∈ R, ϕ(z) ˜ = ϕ(z). 2. supp(ϕ) ˜ ⊂ {z ∈ C; |Im(z)| < 1}. 3. ϕ˜ ∈ S({z ∈ C; |Im(z)| < 1}). ∂ ϕ˜ (x + iy) · |y|−n (for 0 < |y| < 1) is bounded in 4. The family of functions x 7 → ∂z S(R) for any n ∈ N. Such extensions always exist for ϕ ∈ S (see [19]) and, one has the following estimates: there exists C > 0 such that for n ≥ 0, α ≥ 0, β ≥ 0, one has ∂β ∂ ϕ˜ (x + iy) sup sup x α β |y|−n · ∂x ∂z 0<|y|≤1 x∈R (2.5) 0 ∂ β0 ϕ α n log n+α log α+β+1 sup sup x (x) . ≤C 0 ∂x β β 0 ≤n+β+2 x∈R α 0 ≤α
Let ϕ˜ be an almost analytic extension of (i + x)q ϕ(x) for some q > d/2, q integer. Then, by [5] and [8], we know that, for any n and ω ∈ , the following formula holds: Z i ∂ ϕ˜ (2.6) (z) · (i + Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 dz ∧ dz. ϕ(Hω,n ) = 2π C ∂z For q > d/2, 1C(0,1) (i + Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 is trace-class and we have tr 1C(0,1) ϕ(Hω,n )1C(0,1) Z ∂ ϕ˜ i (z) · tr 1C(0,1) (i + Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 1C(0,1) dz ∧ dz. = 2π C ∂z
(2.7)
By Lemma 5.1 and Sect. B.12 in [26], we know that ω-almost surely Hω is essential self-adjoint on C0∞ (Rd ) and that 1C(0,1) (i + Hω )−q (z − Hω )−1 is trace-class. Hence, (2.6) and (2.7) also hold for Hω . We are now going to use Lemma 5.1. We pick p0 ∈ (p(d), p) and b = 1, and compute |E(tr(1C(0,1) (ϕ(Hω,n ) − ϕ(Hω ))))| Z ∂ ϕ˜ 1 (z) E ≤
1C(0,1) (i + Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 2π C ∂z
−(i + Hω )−q (z − Hω )−1 1C(0,1) dxdy (2.8) tr X 1 Z ∂ ϕ˜ (z) E 1{ω; V ∈ (α,1,p0 )\ (α,1,p0 )} K(z, ω) dxdy, ≤ ω k k−1 2π C ∂z k≥1
where
K(z, ω) = 1C(0,1) (i +Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 −(i + Hω )−q (z−Hω )−1 1C(0,1) . tr
Here k · ktr denotes the trace-class norm. We need to estimate 1C(0,1) ((i + Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 − (i + Hω )−q (z − Hω )−1 )1C(0,1)
68
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
under the assumption Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ). Therefore, we imitate the method used in [11]. We write
1C(0,1) ((i + Hω,n )−q (z − Hω,n )−1 − (i + Hω )−q (z − Hω )−1 )1C(0,1) ≤ A + B, tr
(2.9) where
A = 1C(0,1) (z − Hω,n )−1 − (z − Hω )−1 (i + Hω )−q 1C(0,1) tr
−1 −1 −q = 1C(0,1) (z − Hω,n ) (i + Hω ) 1C(0,1) Vω,n − Vω (z − Hω )
tr
and
B = 1C(0,1) (z − Hω,n )−1 (i + Hω,n )−q − (i + Hω )−q 1C(0,1) tr
q−1 X
−1 l−q −l
= 1C(0,1) (z − Hω,n ) (i + Hω,n ) Vω,n − Vω (i + Hω ) 1C(0,1)
.
l=1 tr
The estimates for A and B being obtained essentially in the same way, we will write the details for A only. Pick χ ∈ C0∞ (Rd ) such that 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1, χ ≡ 1 on C(0, 1/2) and X χγ4 ≡ 1. Then, we have χ ≡ 0 outside of C(0, 3/2) such that γ ∈Zd
A≤
X
1C(0,1) (z−Hω,n )−1 χγ 0
L(H −1 ,L2 )
γ 0 ∈Zd ,β∈Zd
· χγ 0 (z − Hω )−1 χβ
χγ 0 (Vω,n −Vω )χγ 0
L(L2 ,H 1 )
L(H 1 ,H −1 )
·
· χβ3 (i + Hω )−q 1C(0,1) . tr
Here χβ (·) = χ(·−β). By Lemma 5.4 applied to Hω and to Hω,n , for Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ), we know that, for some > 0, ρ ≥ 1 and C > 0, for all γ 0 ∈ Zd and β ∈ Zd , we have 0 1−α
e−·η(z,K)|γ |
≤ C ,
1C(0,1) (z − Hω,n )−1 χγ 0 L(H −1 ,L2 ) η(z, K)ρ
C 0 1−α 1−α
e−·η(z,K)||γ | −|β| | ,
χγ 0 (z − Hω )−1 χβ 2 1 ≤ ρ L(L ,H ) η(z, K) 1−α
e−·η(z,K)|β|
3 −q ,
χβ (i + Hω ) 1C(0,1) ≤ C tr η(z, K)ρ
|Imz| and ρ depends only on d |z| + K + C and q. By Lemma 5.3 and the growth estimate known for Vω,n and Vω (when Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 )), we know that, for γ 0 ∈ Zd , we have
0 α
χγ 0 (Vω,n − Vω )χγ 0 L(H 1 ,H −1 ) ≤ C(1 + |γ |) . p
where K = Ck p−p0 , η(z, K) = η(z, K, 1) =
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
69
On the other hand, due to the exponential decay of V1 and the compact support of V2 , there exists C > 0 such that, for |γ 0 | ≤ n/2, we have
−n/C
χγ 0 (Vω,n − Vω )χγ 0 . L(H 1 ,H −1 ) ≤ Ce Hence, if we multiply these estimates and sum the result in γ and γ 0 , we get that A≤C
n(d+3)α −·η(z,K)n1−α e . η(z, K)ρ
(2.10)
For B, we get an estimate analogous to (2.10); only the constants change. Plugging this into (2.9) and (2.8), summing over k using the estimate (5.1) for the probability of c (α, 1, p 0 ), we get k (d+3)α
|E(tr(1C(0,1) (ϕ(Hω,n ) − ϕ(Hω ))))| ≤ Cn
1 2π
Z ∂ ϕ˜ (z) S(z, n)dxdy, (2.11) C ∂z
where S(z, n) :=
X (Cµ)k k!
k≥1
ρ p |Imz| − n1−α p p−p 0 + C |z| + Ck e |z|+Ck p−p0 +C . |Imz|
As suppϕ˜ ⊂ {z ∈ C; |Im(z)| < 1}, using the notation z = x + iy, for l ∈ N∗ , we estimate S(z, n) for |y| < 1 by S(z, n) ≤
X (Cµ)k k≥1
k!
≤ n−l(1−α) = n−l(1−α)
ρ p |y| − p p−p 0 (|x| + C)k e (|x|+C)k p−p0 |y| |x| + C |y| |x| + C |y|
ρ+l X ρ+l
k≥1
p (Cµ)k p−p ρ k 0 k!
n1−α
|y|n1−α (|x| + C)
l
1−α
e
|y| − n(|x|+C) k
−
p p−p 0
fl (t), (2.12)
where t =
fl (t) :=
|y|n1−α and |x| + C X (Cµ)k k≥1
k!
k
p ρ p−p 0
tle
p 0 −tk p −p
≤
X (Cµ)k k≥1
k!
k
p ρ p−p 0
lk
p p−p 0
l e−l
l l X (Cµ)k (ρ+l) p l l p−p 0 ≤ k ≤ e−l e−l L!(eCµe − eCµ ), k! k≥1
(2.13)
70
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
where L denotes the smallest integer larger than (ρ + l)
p . Here we used Stirling’s p − p0
formula and the identity X (Cµ)k X (Cµ)k X k l X 1 X (Cµ)k = kl = (ek −1) = eCµe −eCµ . l! k! k! l! k! l≥1
k≥1
k≥1
l≥1
k≥1
Hence, for some C > 0 (independent of l, n, z and µ), we have ρ+l Cµ −(1−α)l Cl log l |x| + C e . S(z, n) ≤ Ce n |y|
(2.14)
Plugging this into (2.11) and using estimate (2.5) for almost analytic extensions, we get (2.3) and end the proof of Lemma 2.1. u t Remark 2.2. In the proof of Lemma 2.1, we only have used the fact that the space of realization could be written as = ∪n n , where the probability P (c n ) was decreasing fast enough, and that in these subsets, we had uniform estimates on the quantity we want to compute. Obviously, to get such a decomposition, one does not need to have a Poisson potential but only a homogeneous random field with suitable bounds at infinity. This idea is applicable to many other random Schrödinger operators. Proof of Theorem 1.3. By [21], we know that, for φ ∈ C0∞ (R) and for almost every ω, we have 1 D tr(φ(Hω,3 )) 3→Rd Vol(3) 1 D ))) E(tr(φ(Hω,3 = lim d Vol(3) 3→R X 1 D E(tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 )1C(γ ,1) )), = lim 3→Rd Vol(3) d
hφ, dNi = lim
(2.15)
γ ∈3∩Z
D is defined in Sect. 1.1. On the other hand, as H is homogeneous, for any where Hω,3 ω d γ ∈ Z , we have
E(tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω )1C(γ ,1) )) = E(tr(1C(0,1) φ(Hω )1C(0,1) )). So that E(tr(1C(0,1) φ(Hω )1C(0,1) )) =
1 Vol(3)
X
E(tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω )1C(γ ,1) )).
γ ∈3∩Zd
Hence, by (2.15), to get Eq. (1.4), we just have to prove that 1 X D E tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 )1C(γ ,1) )−tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω )1C(γ ,1) ) = 0. lim 3→Rd Vol(3) γ ∈3∩Zd (2.16)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
71
To shorten the notations, let 3L = C(0, L) be the cube of center 0 and side length L. Pick > 0. To prove (2.16), one could try to prove that, for any γ ∈ Zd , one has D )1 )−tr(1 φ(H )1 ) lim A(γ , 3L ) := lim E tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 ω C(γ ,1) C(γ ,1) C(γ ,1) L L→∞
3L →Rd
=0 (2.17) in some uniform way. However, this may be difficult as, because of the Dirichlet boundary conditions, A(γ , 3L ) may have some non-uniform behavior for γ close to the boundary of 3L . So we are going to split the difficulty into two parts; on the one hand, we will show that, for any > 0 and for γ ∈ 3L \ 3(1−)L , we will show that A(γ , 3L ) stays bounded (uniformly in L, ω). As there are only very few such terms, this part of the sum tends to 0. On the other hand, for γ ∈ 3(1−)L , we will show that A(γ , 3L ) tends to 0 uniformly in L and ω. As in the proof of Lemma 2.1, uniformity in ω cannot be achieved over the whole set of realization, but only over subsets whose measure we control (see Lemma 5.1). This will suffice. D ). Hence, To estimate A(γ , 3L ), we will use (2.6) to compute φ(Hω ) and φ(Hω,3 L we see that we only need to estimate the following expression (cf. (2.9)): D D )−1 (i + Hω,3 )−q 1C(γ ,1) ) tr(1C(γ ,1) (z − Hω,3 L L
− tr(1C(γ ,1) (z − Hω )−1 (i + Hω )−q 1C(γ ,1) ),
where q > d/2 is an even integer. To do this we need a way to compare the resolvent of the Dirichlet problem on 3L with the resolvent of Hω over the whole space. We use the ◦
following resolvent identity (see e.g. [1]): let χ ∈ C02 (3L ) then, for Imz 6= 0, we have D D )−1 χ + (z − Hω,3 )−1 [−1, χ](z − Hω )−1 . χ (z − Hω )−1 = (z − Hω,3 L L
(2.18)
Pick α, k and p 0 are taken as in Lemma 2.1. We will use the following lemma Lemma 2.2. Assume that q > d is an even integer and that ω is such that Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ). Then, there exists Cq > 0 such that, for any 30 ⊂ 3L (30 measurable) and λ ≥ 1, we have pd
d
D )−1 kTq ≤ Cq k 2q(p−p0 ) L q k(i + Hω,3 L
(1+ α2 )
−1/2 130 kTq ≤ Cq |30 |1/q . k(λ − 1D 3L )
,
(2.19) (2.20)
Here, p and p(d) are defined in H1, p 0 satisfies p(d) < p0 < p, |30 | denotes the measure of 30 and 1/q . k · kTq = tr | · |q Let us postpone the proof of this result to finish the proof of Theorem 1.3. Pick > 0 to be chosen precisely later. Pick ω such that Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ). Hence, by Lemma 5.1, (i) (r) we can decompose Vω = Vω + Vω , where p0
(i)
• Vω(i) ∈ Lloc,unif (3L ) and supx∈3L kVω kLp0 (C(x,1)) ≤ 1, (r)
p
• for x ∈ 3L , |Vω (x)| ≤ Ck p−p0 Lα .
72
F. Klopp, L. Pastur p
For 0
(r)
(i)
By Lemma 5.3 and the estimate given on Vω and Vω above, we get that, for L large enough, −1/2 −1/2 Vω|3l (λ − 1D kL(L2 ) < k(λ − 1D 3L ) 3L )
1 . 2
Hence, combining the two estimates of Lemma 2.2, we get 1
(2+d
d
D )−1 13L \3(1−2)L kTq ≤ C q k 2(p−p0 ) Lα L q k(i + Hω,3 L
(1+ α2 )+ dq
.
(2.21)
So, by formula (2.6), we get that, for ω such that Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ), we have (2+d
1
α+ dq + d(q−1) (1+ α2 ) q
D )13L \3(1−2)L )| ≤ Ck 2(p−p0 ) q L |tr(φ(Hω,3 L
.
Hence, taking the expectation in ω and summing over all k, we get that h i 1 α(1+ d(q−1) D 2q ) Ld . )13L \3(1−2)L ) ≤ C q L E tr(φ(Hω,3 L Finally, we obtain h i X 1 D E tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 )1 ) C(γ ,1) L Vol(3L ) γ ∈3L \3(1−2)L γ ∈Zd h i 1 1 α(1+ d(q−1) D 2q ) . )13L \3(1−2)L ) ≤ C q L = E tr(φ(Hω,3 L Vol(3L )
(2.22)
On the other hand, let χ be a C0∞ -function supported in 3L that is constant equal to 1 in 3(1−)L . For γ ∈ 3(1−2)L , we use the resolvent formula (2.18) to write D D )−q 1C(γ ,1) = (i + Hω,3 )−q χ1C(γ ,1) (i + Hω,3 L L D = (i + Hω,3 )−(q−1) χ(i + Hω )−1 1C(γ ,1) L
D − (i + Hω,3 )−(q−1) [1, χ] (i + Hω )−1 1C(γ ,1) L −q
= χ (i + Hω )
q X D 1C(γ ,1) − (i + Hω,3 )−j [1, χ] (i + Hω )−q+j −1 1C(γ ,1) . L j =1
Hence D )−q 1C(γ ,1) = (i + Hω )−q 1C(γ ,1) + R(L), (i + Hω,3 L
(2.23)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
73
where R(L) = −(1 − χ)(i + Hω )−q 1C(γ ,1) − q X D (i + Hω,3 )−j [1, χ] (i + Hω )−q+j −1 1C(γ ,1) . − L j =1
By the support properties of 1 − χ and [1, χ], by Lemma 5.4 and by the assumption on ω, we have that, for some C > 0, if εL ≥ 1, then p
1−α /(Ck p/(p−p 0 ) )
kR(L)kT1 ≤ Ck p−p0 e−(L)
.
Plugging this into (2.6), we get that, for some C > 0, D )1C(γ ,1) ) − tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω )1C(γ ,1) )| ≤ |tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 L p
1−α /(Ck p/(p−p 0 ) )
≤ Ck p−p0 e−(L)
.
(2.24)
Taking the expectation of (2.24), summing in k and using (5.1) in the same way as in (2.14), we get that D )1C(γ ,1) ) − tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω )1C(γ ,1) )| ≤ C(L)−(1−α) . E |tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 L (2.25) Then, by (2.22) and (2.25), we have that 1 Vol(3L )
X γ ∈3L ∩Zd
D E tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω,3 )1C(γ ,1) ) = L =
1 Vol(3L )
X
E tr(1C(γ ,1) φ(Hω )1C(γ ,1) ) + Q(L),
γ ∈3L ∩Zd
where 1
α(1+ d(q−1) 2q )
|Q(L)| ≤ C(L)−(1−α) + C q L
+ CL−1 .
If we choose β = α(q + d(q − 1)/2), set = L−β and pick 0 < α < 1/3 small enough so that 1 − β > 1/2, we get that Q(L) → 0 as L → +∞. This completes the proof of Theorem 1.3. u t Remark 2.3. Remark 2.2 applies also for the proof of Theorem 1.3. Proof of Lemma 2.2. Under our assumptions on ω, we have Vω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ). Hence, (i) (r) by Lemma 5.1, we can decompose Vω = Vω + Vω , where p0
(i)
• Vω(i) ∈ Lloc,unif (3L ) and supx∈3L kVω kLp0 (C(x,1)) ≤ 1, (r)
p
• for x ∈ 3L , |Vω (x)| ≤ Ck p−p0 Lα .
74
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
For ϕ ∈ C0∞ (3L ), this yields D i r ϕ, ϕi = h−1D hHω,3 3L ϕ, ϕi + hVω ϕ, ϕi + hVω ϕ, ϕi L p 1 p−p 0 Lα + 1 kϕk2 . ≥ h−1D 3L ϕ, ϕi − C k 2
(2.26)
Equation (2.26) and the variational principle for eigenvalues immediately imply that D )≥ λj (Hω,3 L
p 1 p−p 0 Lα + 1 , ) − C k λj (−1D 3L 2
where λj (H ) denotes the j th eigenvalue of H (ordered increasingly counting multiplicity). Hence q
D )−1 kTq = k(i + Hω,3 L
X
≤
j ∈N
X j ∈N
1
D )]2 1 + [λj (Hω,3 L
q/2
1+ p
(2.27)
0
p−p Lα +1) λj (−1D 3 )<4C(k L
X
+
j ∈N
1
p
0
p−p Lα +1) λj (−1D 3 )≥4C(k
p
p−p 0 Lα 1 + [λj (−1D 3L ) − C(k
+ 1)]2
q/2 .
L
d Now the eigenvalues of −1D 3L are known explicitly: for j = (j1 , . . . , jd ) ∈ (N \ {0}) , 2 X π jp2 . Hence, Eq. (2.27) tells us that one has λj (−1D 3L ) = 2 L 1≤p≤d
d/2 p D −1 q 2 p−p0 α ) k ≤ 4CL (k L + 1) + k(i + Hω,3 Tq L X
+
p √ 0 |j |≥2 CL(k p−p Lα +1)1/2
L2q
p
L4 + [|j |2 − CL2 (k p−p0 Lα + 1)]2
q/2
d/2 p ≤ 4CL2 (k p−p0 Lα + 1) + X
+
L2q
p √ 0 |j |≥2 CL(k p−p Lα +1)1/2
L4 + |j |4 /2
q/2
d/2 p ≤ 4CL2 (k p−p0 Lα + 1) + Cq Ld pd
α
≤ Cq k 2(p−p0 ) Ld(1+ 2 ) . This completes the proof of (2.19). The proof of (2.20) will follow from an explicit computation. Pick λ ≥ 1. As a corollary of the Golden–Thompson inequalities (see
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
75
[25]), we have q
−1/2 −q/4 2 130 kTq ≤ k130 (λ − 1D kT2 k(λ − 1D 3L ) 3L ) X −q/4 −q/4 = h(λ − 1D 130 (λ − 1D ϕj , ϕj i 3L ) 3L ) j ∈(N\{0})d
X
=
j ∈(N\{0})d
1 h130 ϕj , ϕj i, (λ + λj )q/2 (2.28)
where, for the sake of simplicity, we denoted the eigenvalues of −1D 3L by (λj )j and the associated eigenvector by (ϕj )j . The vector ϕj being explicitly known, one easily computes d 2 |30 |. h130 ϕj , ϕj i ≤ L Plugging this into Eq. (2.28), as λ ≥ 1, we get q −1/2 130 kTq k(λ − 1D 3L )
d 2 ≤ L
X j ∈(N\{0})d
|30 | ≤ Cq |30 |, (1 + λj )q/2
t using the explicit formula given above for λj . u
2.2. Application to the estimation of the integrated density of states. We prove Lemma 2.3. Pick ν > 0. There exists β > 0 and Eν > 0 such that, for E > Eν and for n ≥ E β , one has ν
ν
E(Nω,n (−E − 1)) − e−E ≤ N(−E) ≤ E(Nω,n (−E + 1)) + e−E .
(2.29)
Proof of Lemma 2.3. Pick ν > 0 arbitrary. By Eq. (5.13), the a-priori estimate on N given in Lemma 5.2, we know that, for some τ > 0, N(−E τ ) ≤
1 −E ν e . 4
(2.30)
Hence we just have to estimate N(−E) − N(−E τ ). Therefore introduce two functions ϕ± defined by ϕ± = 1[−E τ ∓ 1 ,−E± 1 ] ∗ ϕ0 , 2
2
C0∞ (R)
is a non-negative Gevrey class function of Gevrey exponent ρ > 1 where ϕ0 ∈ such that ϕ0 ≡ 1 on [− 41 , 41 ] and suppϕ0 ⊂ [− 21 , 21 ]. The functions ϕ± are then Gevrey class of Gevrey exponent ρ and suppϕ± ⊂ [−E τ − 1, −E + 1] (see e.g. [6]). Then one has hϕ− , dNi ≤ N(−E) − N(−E τ ) ≤ hϕ+ , dNi.
(2.31)
76
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Using the Gevrey estimates for the derivatives and the estimates on the support of ϕ± , by Lemma 2.1, we have that, for some C > 0, and for all n ∈ N∗ and all k ∈ N∗ , |hϕ± , dNi − E(hϕ± , dNω,n i)| ≤ Cn−(1−α)k eCk log k (E τ + C)ρ+k (ρ + k)η(ρ+k) . (2.32) We optimize the right-hand side of (2.32) in k to get 1 1−α (E τ +C)) η+C
|hϕ± , dNi − E(hϕ± , dNω,n i)| ≤ e−(η+C)(n
.
Hence, for some β > 0, if n ≥ E β , we have |hϕ± , dNi − E(hϕ± , dNω,n i)| ≤
1 −E ν . e 4
(2.33)
Thus E(Nω,n (−E − 1) − Nω,n (−E τ + 1)) ≤ E(hϕ− , dNω,n i) ≤ E(hϕ+ , dNω,n i) ≤ E(Nω,n (−E + 1) − Nω,n (−E τ − 1)). (2.34) Using (5.14) to estimate Nω,n (−E τ ± 1) and summing Eqs. (2.30), (2.31) and (2.34), we end the proof of Lemma 2.3. u t Remark 2.4. Notice that we could have estimated N (−E) with E(Nω,n (−E ± )) (for small). The price to pay to get an error of the same size as in (2.29) would have been to take n of size E β −ζ for some ζ > 0. This was used in [12] to get precise asymptotics for N at high energy for a different model. 3. The Lower Bounds In this section, we will prove the asymptotic lower bound on the approximated density of states dNω,n defined in Sect. 2.1 in the different cases considered in the introduction. 3.1. The general case. We prove the following general bound Proposition 3.1. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 3, there exist β0 > 0 such that, for any β > β0 and n = [E β ], we have log E(Nω,n (−E − 1)) ≥ −(1 + α ∗ d)g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. (3.1) Here [·] denotes the integer part of ·. Proof. The strategy used to prove the lower bound is quite obvious: we construct a normalized vector ϕ such that h(H + Vω )ϕ, ϕi ≤ −E − 1, this with a sufficiently large probability. The right candidate will be an asymptotic ground state for H (g) for g chosen properly (see Sect. 1.2). Pick n = [E β ] and l = [| log E|β ]. Pick ρ > 1 large, 0 < ε < 1 small, 0 < α < 1 and 1 < k large. Let ψg be an asymptotic ground state for H (g) such that α ∗ (ψg ) < α ∗ (1+ε) (see Sect. 1.2). Define k,E = 1k,E ∩ 2E ,
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
77
where 1k,E = {ω : k(1 + 2ε) ≥ m(ω, C(0, k −α
∗ (1+ε)
)) = m(ω, C(0, l)) ≥ k(1 + ε)}, (3.2)
2E = {ω : ∀γ ∈ r0 Zd , m(ω, C(γ , r0 )) < E ρ (|γ |α + 1)}.
(3.3)
Here r0 is chosen such that suppV2 ⊂ C(0, r0 ). We minorize the probability of 1k,E ∗ by the probability that m(ω, C(0, k −α (1+ε) )) = k(1 + ε) and that m(ω, C(0, l) \ ∗ (1+ε) −α )) = 0. Using (5.2) to minorize the probability of 2E , for E sufficiently C(0, k large, we get that the probability of k,E is estimated by ∗
−dα (1+ε) )k(1+ε) C 1 d (µk − , P (k,E ) ≥ e−Cµl C 0(k(1 + ε)) 0(E ρ /2)
(3.4)
where C > 0 is a constant independent of l, k and ε, and 0 is the Euler 0-function. For ω ∈ k,E , we have (i) (e) )ψk , ψk i + hVω,n ψk , ψk i, h(−1 + Vω,n )ψk , ψk i = h(−1 + Vω,n
where Vω(i) =
Z C(0,l)
V (x − y)m(ω, dy) and Vω(e) =
Z Rd \C(0,l)
V (x − y)m(ω, dy), (i,e)
i.e. they are the parts of Vω with centers in C(0, l) or outside of C(0, l), and Vω,n is built from these in the same way as Vω,n is from Vω (see Eq. (2.2)). As V2 is of compact support, as V1 is exponentially decaying and as ω ∈ 2E , using the support properties of asymptotic ground states (see Definition 1.1), we get that β /C
(e) ψk , ψk i| ≤ CE ρ e−| log E| |hVω,n
.
(3.5)
∗
On the other hand, if we set m(ω) = m(ω, ∗B(0, k −α (1+ε) )) and define (xi (ω))i to be the points supporting m(ω, dx) in B(0, k −α (1+ε) ), we have h(−1 + Vω(i) )ψk , ψk i = h(−1 + m(ω)V )ψk , ψk i +
m(ω) X
h(τxi (ω) V − V )ψk , ψk i
i=1
= h(−1 + kV )ψk , ψk i +
m(ω) X m(ω) − k hkV ψk , ψk i + h(τxi (ω) V − V )ψk , ψk i k i=1
≤ E(k) + o(E(k)) + ε(E(k) + o(E(k))) +
m(ω) X
|h(τxi (ω) V − V )ψk , ψk i|.
i=1
(3.6) We used the fact that ψk is an asymptotic ground state and the fact that ω ∈ 1k,E .
78
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
As m(ω) ≤ k(1 + 2ε) and α ∗ (ψg ) < α ∗ (1 + ε), the definition of α ∗ (ψg ) tells us that m(ω) X 1 h(τxi (ω) V − V )ψk , ψk i → 0 as k → +∞. E− (k) i=1 Plugging all this into (3.6), we get h(−1 + Vω(i) )ψk , ψk i ≤ E(k)(1 + o(1) + ε) as k → +∞.
(3.7)
If we now chose k = g(E)(1 + ε),
(3.8)
then, for sufficiently large k, we get h(−1 + Vω(i) )ψk , ψk i ≤ −(E + 1).
(3.9)
But, as an asymptotic ground state, ψk vanishes outside some fixed cube independent of k; hence for E sufficiently large, it vanishes in a neighborhood of the boundary of the cube C(0, n) and can be continued so as to satisfy any quasi-periodic boundary conditions on C(0, n) (see Sect. 2.1). This implies that there exist C > 0 independent of n and E such that for ω ∈ k,E and k given by (3.8), we have Nω,n (−E − 1) ≥ n−d /C.
(3.10)
Taking into account the probability estimate (3.4), if ρ is large enough and as k ≥ E δ for some δ > 0 by (5.30), we get ∗
−dα (1+ε) )k(1+ε) 1 d (µk . E(Nω,n (−E − 1)) ≥ E −βd e−Cµl C 0(k(1 + ε))
So that, as E tends to +∞, we get log[E(Nω,n (−E − 1))] ≥ −(1 + ε + dα ∗ (1 + ε))g(E) log g(E)(1 + 8ε). As we can choose ε as small as we please, this ends the proof of Proposition 3.1. u t By Lemma 5.5, we know that, for some C > 0 and α > 1, g(E) ≤ CE for some C > 0 and sufficiently large E. Thus, if β > 1 is large enough and ν in Eq. (2.29) satisfies ν > 1, Lemma 2.3 and Proposition 3.1 immediately imply Proposition 3.2. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 3, we have log N (−E) ≥ −(1 + α ∗ d)g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞.
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
79
3.2. The case when V is bounded from below. We now assume that V is bounded from below, i.e. that V− is bounded. We then prove Proposition 3.3. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 1’, there exist β0 > 0 such that, for any β > β0 and n = [E β ], we have (3.11) log E(Nω,n (−E − 1)) ≥ −g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. Proof. The strategy of the proof is the one used in the proof of Proposition 3.1. Recall that v− is the essential infimum of V . Then, for any ε > 0, we can find χ ∈ C0∞ (Rd ) such that Z Z V (x)χ 2 (x)dx ≤ v− + ε/2 and χ 2 (x)dx = 1. Rd
Rd
Recall that τa χ(x) = χ(x − a). As V ∈ L1 (Rd ), there exists δ > 0 such that Z |V (x)| · |τa χ 2 (x) − χ 2 (x)|dx ≤ ε/2. sup |a|≤δ Rd
Pick now n and l as in the proof of Proposition 3.1; pick k large and define δ,E = 1δ,E ∩ 2E , where 2E is defined in (3.3) and (see (3.2)) 1δ,E = {ω; k(1 + 2ε) ≥ m(ω, C(0, δ)) = m(ω, C(0, l)) ≥ k(1 + ε)}. Using (5.2), we get that the probability of δ,E is estimated by P (δ,E ) ≥
C 1 −Cµl d (µδ)kd(1+ε) e − . C 0(k(1 + ε)) 0(E ρ /2)
(3.12)
Pick ω ∈ δ,E . An argument similar to that used in the proof of Proposition 3.1 in which ∗ k −α (1+ε) is replaced by δ yields (cf. (3.6)) h(−1 + Vω,n )χ, χi = k∇χk2 + +
m(ω) XZ i=1
m(ω) XZ
τxi (ω) (V χ 2 ) +
i=1 (e) χ, χi [τxi (ω) V ](τxi (ω) χ 2 − χ 2 ) + hVω,n
≤ k(1 + ε)(v− + ε) + C + O(1/E).
(3.13)
Hence, if we take k = E/|v− |(1 + ε/|v− |), for E sufficiently large, we get (cf. (3.9)) h(−1 + Vω,n )χ, χi ≤ −E − 1. This inequality and the probability estimate (3.12) give, for some C > 0 independent of E and ε E (1 + Cε) log E. log E(Nω,n (−E − 1)) ≥ − |v− | This ends the proof of Proposition 3.3. u t
80
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
By the same argument as above, we get Proposition 3.4. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 1’, if V is bounded from below then, we have log N(−E) ≥ −g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. This ends the proof of Theorem 1.5 as the asymptotic upper bound given by Theorem 1.4 coalesces with the lower bound given by Proposition 3.4. 3.3. The case when V has power law singularities. Let us assume that V2 satisfies assumption H1.2”. We will show that Lemma 3.1. Under the assumptions H1 and H 1”, we have α† ≥ α∗. Proof. To estimate α ∗ we will use the asymptotic ground state constructed for H (g) in (i ) Lemma 5.7. Pick i0 and ψg 0 as in Lemma 5.7. Let α > α † . If the support of χ (cf. Lemma 5.7) is small enough, then, for |a| ≤ g −α and g large enough, we have (i )
8(a) =
(i )
gh(τa V − V )ψg 0 , ψg 0 i E− (g)
(i )
(i )
(i )
(i )
(i )
(i )
=
gh[τa (Wi0 Vi0 ) − Wi0 Vi0 ]ψg 0 , ψg 0 i gh[τa V1 − V1 ]ψg 0 , ψg 0 i + E− (g) E− (g)
=
gh[(τa Wi0 Vi0 ) − Wi0 Vi0 ]ψg 0 , ψg 0 i + o(1), E− (g)
as V1 is bounded and g = o(E− (g)). Hence to estimate 8(a), it is enough to estimate the expression (i )
(i )
gh[τa (Wi0 Vi0 ) − Wi0 Vi0 ]ψg 0 , ψg 0 i E− (g) Z g Wi0 (x − a)Vi0 (x − a) − Wi0 (x)Vi0 (x) χ 2 (x)|ϕg(i0 ) (x)|2 dx = E− (g) |x|
=
†
(3.14) where
Z I (a) =
Wi0 (g −α (x − b))Vi0 (x − b)−Wi0 (g −α x)Vi0 (x)
†
|x|
†
†
· χ 2 (g −α x)|ϕ (i0 ) (x)|2 dx, †
where b = g α a. Notice that b → 0 when g → +∞ as α > α † and |a| ≤ g −α . † Moreover, by Lemma 5.7, E− (g) ∼ Cg 2α (for some C). Hence to show that α > α ∗ , we just need to show that I (a) → 0 when g → +∞. This is easily seen cutting I (a) †
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
81
into two parts. In the first one, we integrate over some small neighborhood of 0 and this is small as χ and ϕ (i0 ) are bounded and the singularities of Vi0 are integrable; outside of this neighborhood, the potentials Vi0 and Vi0 (· − b) are continuous and as ϕ (i0 ) is in L2 , we can conclude using Lebesgue’s Dominated Convergence Theorem. This implies t that α ≥ α ∗ . As it holds for any α > α † , we get the result of Lemma 3.1. u Combining Lemma 3.1 with Theorem 1.4, we get Proposition 3.5. Under the assumptions H1 and H 1”, one has −(1 + α † d)g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)) ≤ log N (−E), E → +∞. In Sect. 4.3 we improve on the general upper bound given in Theorem 1.4 so that the new upper bound coalesces with the lower bound obtained here. 4. The Upper Bounds In this section, we will prove the asymptotic upper bound on the approximated density of states dNω,n defined in Sect. 2.1 in the different cases considered in the introduction. 4.1. The general case. We prove the following general bound Proposition 4.1. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 3, there exists β0 > 0 such that, for any β > β0 and n = 2[E β ] · [| log E|β ], we have (4.1) log E(Nω,n (−E + 1)) ≤ −g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. By Lemma 5.5, we know that, for some C > 0 and α > 1, g(E) ≥ CE 1/α for some C > 0 and E large enough. So that if we pick β > 1 large enough so that ν defined in Eq. (2.29) satisfies ν > 1, Lemma 2.3 and Proposition 4.1 immediately imply Proposition 4.2. Under the assumptions H1, H 2 and H 3, we have log N(−E) ≤ −g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. Taking into account Proposition 3.2, this ends the proof of Theorem 1.4. We now turn to the proof of Proposition 4.1. 4.2. Proof of Proposition 4.1. The idea of the proof is to show that, if Hω,n,θ has some low energies, then the corresponding potential Vω must have a very deep well, i.e. the corresponding realization of the Poisson measure must put sufficiently many points inside the cube C(0, n) and those points must be sufficiently close to each other. The main technical difficulty comes from the fact that our single site potential is not of finite range; so we need some a priori estimate on Nω,n that tells us that the behavior of Vω outside of C(0, n) does not interact too much with the one inside, more precisely, that this interaction can be large only with a small probability. Actually we need this not only on the scale of the large cube used in the periodic approximation but also on a much smaller scale, namely the scale of the size of the cube where we want the Poisson points to pile up. Pick β > 0 large. Set n = 2[E β ] · [| log E|β ] and l = [| log E|β ]. Pick ρ > 0 large and let 2E be defined as in (3.3). Then we prove
82
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Lemma 4.1. For some C > 0 and sufficiently large E, we have E(Nω,n (−E + 1)) ≤ E(Nω,n (−E + 1)12 ) + E
C . 0(E ρ /2)
(4.2)
Proof. We decompose E(Nω,n (−E + 1)) = E(Nω,n (−E + 1)12 ) + A, E
where α and
p0
are as in Lemma 5.1, X E(Nω,n (−E + 1)1k (α,1,p0 )\(2 ∪k−1 (α,1,p0 )) ) A= E
k≥1
+ E(Nω,n (−E + 1)10 (α,1,p0 )\2 ) E X E(Nω,n (−E + 1)1k (α,1,p0 )\k−1 (α,1,p0 ) ) ≤
(4.3)
k≥E ρ
as, for k < E ρ , by the proof of Lemma 5.1, we have k (α, 1, p0 ) ⊂ 2E . For ω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ) (see Lemma 5.1), we have p
(r) k∞ ≤ C(E log E)αβ k p−p0 . kVω,n
Hence, if N denotes the density of states of −1, for ω ∈ k (α, 1, p0 ), we get p Nω,n (−E + 1) ≤ N −E + 2 + C(E log E)αβ k p−p0 p d/2 . ≤ C −E + 2 + C(E log E)αβ k p−p0 Plugging this into (4.3) and computing the sum over k using (5.1), we get Lemma 4.1. t u Define Vω(i) (x) =
Z
V (x − y)m(ω, dy) and Vω(e) (x) =
C(0,n+2l)
Z V (x − y)m(ω, dy) Rd \C(0,n+2l)
(4.4) (i,e)
and the corresponding periodized potentials Vω,n (see Eq. (2.1)). Note that the peri(e) odized potentials are of period n. As V2 is compactly supported, Vω,n is almost surely bounded for l (i.e. E) large. We will estimate its magnitude later. The proof of Proposition 4.1 will be a consequence of the following lemmas: Lemma 4.2. For any ε > 0, there exists E0 and k0 such that, if k > k0 , E > E0 and ∀x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) ≤ k, then, for any θ ∈ Tn∗ , we have C k (e) k∞ − C((n/2l)d + 1) · ke−l/C − 2 − kVω,n Hω,n,θ ≥ −E− 1−ε εl
(4.5)
(4.6)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
83
and Lemma 4.3. Pick δ > 0. If E is large enough and if k ≥ E δ , then, log [P ({ω; ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) > k})]
∼
E→+∞
−k log k.
(4.7)
Before proving Lemmas 4.2 and 4.3, we finish the proof of Proposition 4.1. Therefore, fix ε > 0 and set k = g(E − 2)(1 − ε). For ω ∈ 2E , we have, for some C > 0, β /C
(e) k∞ ≤ E ρ e−(log E) kVω,n
.
(4.8)
Hence, using (4.6) and the bounds known for g(E) given in Lemma 5.5, we get that for ω ∈ 2E such that ∀x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) ≤ k, for any θ ∈ Tn∗ , we have Hω,n,θ ≥ −E + 3/2. In other words, we have ]{eigenvalues of Hω,n,θ ≤ −E + 1} = ]{eigenvalues of Hω,n,θ ≤ −E + 1}1{ω∈2 : ∃x∈C(0,n+2l), m(ω,C(x,2l))>k} . E
By the definition of Nω,n , using Fubini’s Theorem, we compute E(Nω,n (−E + 1)12 ) E Z E(]{eigenvalues of Hω,n,θ ≤ −E + 1}12 )dθ = Z
=
Tn∗ Tn∗
E
h
i E ]{eigenvalues of Hω,n,θ ≤ −E +1}1{ω∈2 : ∃x∈C(0,n+2l), m(ω,C(x,2l))>k} dθ. E
(4.9) On the other hand, for ω ∈ 2E (2E is defined in (3.3)), we have 0
(i) kLp (C(0,n)) ≤ CE β(d+α )+ρ , kVω,n
hence, using Corollary 5.1, there exists ν > 0 such that 1 0 Hω,n,θ ≥ − 1n,θ − E (β(d+α )+ρ)ν , 2 where −1n,θ is the Laplace operator on C(0, n) with quasi-periodic boundary conditions. This implies that, for some C > 0, ]{eigenvalues of Hω,n,θ ≤ −E + 1} 0
≤ ]{eigenvalues of − 1n,θ ≤ CE (β(d+α )+ρ)ν − 2E + 2} 0
≤ Cnd (E (β(d+α )+ρ)ν − E + 1)d/2 . Plugging this into (4.9), we get 0
E(Nω,n (−E + 1)12 ) ≤ C(E (β(d+α )+ρ)ν − E + 1)d/2 E
· P ({ω; ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) > k}. Notice that, by Lemma 5.5, our choice of k fulfills the assumptions of Lemma 4.3. Therefrom we deduce that, if E is large enough, then log E(Nω,n (−E + 1)) ≤ −g(E) log g(E)(1 − 2ε). This completes the proof of Proposition 4.1 u t
84
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
4.2.1. The proof of Lemma 4.2. Consider the partition of the cube C(0, n) into cubes of side length l, i.e. [ C(γ , l), C(0, n) = γ ∈l Zd |γ |≤n/ l
and the covering
[
C(0, n) ⊂
C(γ , 2l).
γ ∈l Zd |γ |≤n/ l
Set L = 2[E β ] and consider a Zd -periodic partition of unity of Rd , i.e. X X χγ2+β , 1= β∈LZd γ ∈Zd ∩C(0,L)
where χ ∈ C0∞ (Rd ) such that χ ≡ 1 on C(0, 1/2), 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1 and suppχ ⊂ C(0, 3/2). For γ ∈ lZd , define χγ ,l (x) = χ((x − γ )/ l). Then, one has X X χγ2+β,l . 1= β∈nZd γ ∈l Zd ∩C(0,n)
Assume (4.5) holds and consider ϕ ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) satisfying the quasi-periodic boundary conditions ϕ(x + nγ ) = einθγ ϕ(x) for γ ∈ Zd and x ∈ Rd (i.e. ϕ ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) ∩ L2θ,loc (C(0, n))) such that kϕk = 1. Note that k · k and h·, ·i denote respectively the usual norm and scalar product in L2 (C(0, n)). For small positive ε, we compute (i) (e) )ϕ, ϕi + hVω,n ϕ, ϕi h(−1 + Vω,n )ϕ, ϕi = h(−1 + Vω,n (i) (e) ϕ, ϕi − kVω,n k∞ ≥ k∇ϕk2 + hVω,n X (i) (e) = χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕi − kVω,n k∞ kχγ ,l ∇ϕk2 + hVω,n γ ∈l Zd ∩C(0,n+l)
1 (i) hV χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕi ≥ (1 − ε) k∇ χγ ,l ϕ k + 1 − ε ω,n γ ∈l Zd ∩C(0,n+l) X 1 (e) k ∇χγ ,l ϕk2 − kVω,n k∞ + 1− ε d γ ∈l Z ∩C(0,n+l) X 2 1 (i) ≥ (1 − ε) hV χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕi k∇ χγ ,l ϕ k + 1 − ε ω,n d
X
2
γ ∈l Z ∩C(0,n+l)
−
C (e) − kVω,n k∞ . εl 2
Define Vω(i,γ ) = =
Z C(γ ,2l)
Z
V (x − y)m(ω, dy) and Vω(e,γ )
C(0,n+2l)\C(γ ,2l)
V (x − y)m(ω, dy)
(4.10)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
85 ((i,e),γ )
and the corresponding periodized potentials Vω,n (see Eq. (2.2)). Then (4.5) tells us that m(ω, C(0, n + 2l)) ≤ C(n/2l)d · k. Using this and the exponential decay of V1 , we get that, for some C > 0, (e,γ )
sup |Vω,n (x)| ≤ (n/2l)d · ke−l/C ,
x∈C(γ ,l)
(i,γ ) sup Vω,n − Vω(i,γ ) (x) ≤ Cke−l/C .
x∈C(γ ,l)
So that (4.10) gives us −1 +
X
h(−1 + Vω,n )ϕ, ϕi ≥ (1 − ε)
γ ∈l Zd ∩C(0,n+l)
−
1 (i,γ ) V χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕ 1−ε ω
C (e) − kVω,n k∞ − C((n/2l)d + 1) · ke−l/C . εl 2
(4.11)
Now, if (xj (ω))j =1,...,m(ω,C(γ ,2l)) denotes the support of m(ω, dx) in C(γ , 2l), we write 1 (i,γ ) V χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕ −1 + 1−ε ω + * m(ω,C(γ ,2l)) X 1 τxj (ω) V χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕ = −1 + 1−ε j =1
=
1 m(ω, C(γ , 2l))
m(ω,C(γ X ,2l))
−1 +
j =1 m(ω,C(γ X ,2l))
1 ≥− m(ω, C(γ , 2l)) j =1 k ≥ −E− kχγ ,l ϕk2 . 1−ε
E−
m(ω, C(γ , 2l)) τxj (ω) V 1−ε
χγ ,l ϕ, χγ ,l ϕ
m(ω, C(γ , 2l)) kχγ ,l ϕk2 1−ε
(4.12) Here we have used (4.5). Plugging (4.12) into (4.11), we get C k (e) k∞ − C((n/2l)d + 1) · ke−l/C . − 2 − kVω,n h(−1 + Vω,n )ϕ, ϕi ≥ −E− 1−ε εl (4.13) Lemma 4.2 follows then from the fact that C ∞ (Rd )∩L2θ (C(0, n)) is dense in the domain t of Hω,n,θ . u 4.2.2. The proof of Lemma 4.3. Define P (n, k, l) = P ({ω; ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) > k}). We will assume that k, n and l are large and that they satisfy d
(n + l)d+1 el = o(l −kd 0(k)).
(4.14)
86
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
We will prove a lower and an upper bound on P (n, k, l). We start with the lower bound. Consider the partition of the cube C(0, n + 2l) into cubes of side length 2l, i.e. [ C(γ , 2l). C(0, n + 2l) = γ ∈2l Zd |γ |≤n/2l+1
Using the independence for disjoint cubes and the homogeneity of the Poisson field, we obtain that P (n, k, l) ≥ P ({ω; ∃γ ∈ 2lZd , |γ | ≤ n/2l + 1; m(ω, C(γ , 2l)) > k}) d
= 1 − (1 − P (m(ω, C(0, 2l)) > k))(n/2l+1) . d
By definition, P (m(ω, C(0, 2l)) > k) ≥ e−µ(2l) we get
(4.15)
(µ(2l)d )k . Plugging this into (4.15), k!
log P (n, k, l) ≥ −k log k(1 + o(1)) when k, n and l tend to +∞ under the assumption (4.14). To get an upper bound, we consider the partition of the cube C(0, n + 2l) into cubes of side length 4l, i.e. [ C(γ , 4l). C(0, n + 2l) = γ ∈4l Zd |γ |≤n/(4l)+1/2
For any x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), there exists γ ∈ 4lZd , |γ | ≤ n/(4l) + 1/2 such that C(γ , 4l) ∩ C(x, 2l) = C(x, 2l). Hence, P ({ω; ∀x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) ≤ k}) ≥ ≥ P ({ω; ∀γ ∈ 4lZd , |γ | ≤ n/2l + 1/2; m(ω, C(γ , 4l)) ≤ k}) that is, using the stationarity of the Poisson process, P ({ω; ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 2l)) > k}) X P ({ω; m(ω, C(γ , 4l)) > k}) ≤ γ ∈4l Zd , |γ |≤n/2l+1/2
≤ (n + 2l)d P ({ω; m(ω, C(0, 4l)) > k}). On the other hand P ({m(ω, C(0, 4l)) > k}) =
X j >k
dµ
e−(4l)
[µ(4l)d ]j (µ(4l)d )k ≤ . j! k!
This then implies that log P (n, k, l) ≤ −k log k(1 + o(1)) when k, n and l tend to +∞ under assumption (4.14). u t
(4.16)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
87
4.3. The case when V has power law singularities. We now assume that H 1” holds. Obviously, modifying V1 , we can assume that the functions Wi do not change sign and that the supports of distinct Wi are pairwise disjoint. We then prove Proposition 4.3. Under the assumptions H1 and H 1”, there exists β0 > 0 such that, for any β > β0 and n = 2[E β ] · [| log E|β ], we have log E(Nω,n (−E + 1)) ≤ −(1 + α † d)g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. (4.17) Taking into account Lemma 5.5 and Lemma 2.3, as a corollary to Proposition 4.3, we get Proposition 4.4. Under the assumptions H1 and H 1”, we have log (E(N (−E + 1))) ≤ −(1 + α † d)g(E) log g(E)(1 + o(1)), E → +∞. This ends the proof of Theorem 1.6 if one takes into account Proposition 3.5. 4.3.1. Proof of Proposition 4.3. The idea guiding this proof is essentially the same as the one guiding the proof of Proposition 4.1. The difference comes from the fact that, as E− (g) increases faster than linearly in g, if we want to gather k single site potentials sufficiently close together so as to get the effect of having k single site potentials exactly at the same point, we need the single site potentials to be roughly at a distance less † than k −α from each other. Hence, the scale on which we want the Poisson points to concentrate is much smaller than the one used to prove the upper bound in the general case. This leads to some supplementary technical difficulties as the single site potentials have a finite non-zero range. Recall that (xi )1≤i≤q are the singularities of the single site potential V (see Sect. 1.2). We define [ C(x − xi , r). (4.18) K(x, r) = 1≤i≤q
Pick ε > 0 small and define the events ˜ 1 = {ω ∈ 2E : ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, K(x, k −(α † −2ε) )) > k}, ˜ 2 = {ω ∈ 2E : ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, 1)) > k 1+εν † }, ˜ 2. ˜ = ˜1∪ and Pick β > 0 large. Set n = 2[E β ] · [| log E|β ] and l = [| log E|β ]. Pick ρ > 0 large. Taking into account Lemma 4.1, Proposition 4.3 is a direct consequence of the following two lemmas (cf. Lemmas 4.2 and 4.3). Lemma 4.4. For any ε > 0, there exists E0 and k0 such that, if k > k0 and E > E0 , if ω ∈ 2E and if ∀x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, K(x, k −(α
† −2ε)
)) ≤ k and m(ω, C(x, 1)) ≤ k 1+εν
†
(4.19)
then, for any θ ∈ T∗n , we have † † Ck 2(α −ν ε/2) k β † (1 + ε) − − E ρ e−(log E) /C − Ck 1+εν , Hω,n,θ ≥ −E− 1−ε ε (4.20)
88
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
and Lemma 4.5. Pick δ > 0. Then, if E is large enough and if k ≥ E δ , the probability of ˜ satisfies the event ˜ log P ()
∼
E→+∞
−(1 + (α † − 2ε)d)k log k.
(4.21)
We now pick k = [(1 − ε)g(E/(1 + 2ε))], i.e. k is of order of magnitude E 1−ν /2 as † † † E → +∞ (see Lemma 5.7). In that case, for sufficiently small ε, k 1+εν and k 2(α −ν ε/2) are o(E). Hence Proposition 4.3 follows from Lemma 4.1, Lemma 4.4 and Lemma 4.5 in the same way as Proposition 4.1 followed from Lemmas 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3. †
4.3.2. The proof of Lemma 4.4. We are going to proceed along the same lines as in the (i,e) proof of Lemma 4.2. The potentials Vω,n are defined as in (4.4). Fix ϕ ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) ∩ L2θ (C(0, n)) normalized by kϕk = 1. Then (i) (e) ϕ, ϕi + hVω,n ϕ, ϕi hHω,n,θ ϕ, ϕi = h−1ϕ, ϕi + hVω,n
(4.22)
β /C
(i) ϕ, ϕi − E ρ e−(log E) ≥ h−1ϕ, ϕi + hVω,n
using (4.8). We can split (i) (i,1) (i,2) = Vω,n + Vω,n , Vω,n
where Vω(i,1)
Z =
C(0,n+2l)
(i,2)
V1 (x − y)m(ω, dy) and
Vω(i,2)
Z =
C(0,n+2l)
V2 (x − y)m(ω, dy).
(i)
Vω,n contains all the local singularities of Vω,n and, as V1 is exponentially decaying, there exists C > 0 such that for ω ∈ 2E satisfying (4.19), we have (i,1) k∞ ≤ Ck 1+εν . kVω,n †
Hence (4.22) gives β /C
(i,1) ϕ, ϕi − E ρ e−(log E) hHω,n,θ ϕ, ϕi ≥ h−1ϕ, ϕi + hVω,n
†
− Ck 1+εν .
(4.23)
Consider now a periodic partition of the unity of the cube C(0, n) of the form X χγ2 , 1C(0,n) = γ ∈0
where the χγ are supported on cells of size roughly k −α +ν ε/2 . These cells are centered † † at the points of 0 = δ(k)Zd ∩ C(0, n), where δ(k) = 1/[k α −ν ε/2 ]. Here [·] denote the integer part. These functions can then be chosen so that, for some C > 0, we have †
†
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
89
sup k∇χγ k2∞ + sup k1χγ k∞ ≤ Cδ(k)−2 ≤ Ck 2(α
γ ∈0
† −ν † ε/2)
γ ∈0
(4.24)
for some C > 1. We compute h−1ϕ, ϕi =
X
k∇(χγ ϕ)k2 + h|∇χγ |2 ϕ, ϕi − 2Re(h∇(χγ ϕ), ϕ∇χγ i)
γ ∈0
1 X k∇(χγ ϕ)k + 1 − h|∇χγ |2 ϕ, ϕi ≥ (1 + ε) ε γ ∈0 γ ∈0 X 1 † † 2 k∇(χγ ϕ)k + C 1 − k 2(α −ν ε/2) . ≥ (1 − ε) ε
X
2
(4.25)
γ ∈0
On the other hand (i,1) ϕ, ϕi = hVω,n
X γ ∈0
(i,1) hVω,n χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi.
Set V˜i = Wi Vi . As the Wi ’s are of compact support, so are the V˜i . Hence, for some R0 positive, we have X (i,1) χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi = hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi hVω,n 1≤j ≤q, u≥1 xu (ω)+xj ∈C(γ ,R0 )
X
=
1≤j ≤q, u≥1
hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi †
xu (ω)+xj ∈C(γ ,k 2ε−α )
X
+
1≤j ≤q, u≥1
hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi, †
xu (ω)+xj ∈C(γ ,R0 )\C(γ ,k 2ε−α )
(4.26) where the (xu (ω))u≥1 are the support of the Poisson measure m(ω, dy). † For |γ − xu (ω) − xj | ≥ k ε−α and x in the support of χγ , one has † † † |τxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )(x)| ≤ Ck εν −α ν . †
We have assumed that, for any x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), one has m(ω, C(x, 1)) ≤ k 1+εν ; hence, we obtain X † † † † hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi ≥ −Ck −2εν +α ν +1+εν 1≤j ≤q, u≥1
†
xu (ω)+xj ∈C(γ ,R0 )\C(γ ,k 2ε−α )
= −Ck 2α
† −εν †
. (4.27)
90
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Hence, to estimate hHω,n,θ ϕ, ϕi using Eqs. (4.25), (4.26) and (4.27), we only need to estimate A := k∇(χγ ϕ)k2 +
1 1−ε
X
hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi.
1≤j ≤q, u≥1
†
xu (ω)∈K(γ ,k 2ε−α )
Therefore, we notice that, as the (xj )1≤j ≤q are distinct, for k sufficiently large, for any ω, † any γ and any u, there is at most a single 1 ≤ j ≤ q such that xu (ω) ∈ C(γ −xj , k 2ε−α ). Hence, by (4.18), we get a partition †
Q := {xu ; xu (ω) ∈ K(γ , k 2ε−α )} [ [ † {xu ; xu (ω) ∈ C(γ − xj , k 2ε−α )} =: Qj . = 1≤j ≤q
1≤j ≤q †
Set m(ω) = m(ω, K(γ , k 2ε−α )) and qj = ]Qj . We compute q 1 XX hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi A = k∇(χγ ϕ)k + 1−ε j =1 Qj q X X 1 m(ω) qj k∇(χγ ϕ)k2 + hτxu (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi = m(ω) 1−ε 2
j =1
=
q X j =1
≥
1 m(ω)
X
Qj
k∇(χγ ϕ)k2 +
Qj
m(ω) hτx (ω)+xj (V˜j )χγ ϕ, χγ ϕi 1−ε u
q X qj X m(ω) E˜ j kχγ ϕk2 , m(ω) (1 − ε) j =1
Qj
where E˜ j (g) is the ground state of −1 + g V˜j . In Sect. 5.4, we prove that the lowest of these ground states is asymptotic to E(g) as g → +∞. Hence, for k sufficiently large, by (4.19), we have A ≥ −(1 + ε)E−
m(ω) k kχγ ϕk2 ≥ −(1 + ε)E− kχγ ϕk2 . 1−ε 1−ε
(4.28)
Combining this with Eqs. (4.25), (4.26) and (4.27), we end the proof of Lemma 4.4. u t ˜ 1 ). 4.3.3. The proof of Lemma 4.5. We first prove an asymptotic lower bound for P ( Recall that K is defined by (4.18). We notice that, for E large enough, P ({ω ∈ 2E : ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, K(x, k −(α ≥ P ({ω ∈
2E
† −2ε)
)) > k}) ≥
: ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, C(x, k −(α
† −2ε)
)) > k}).
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
91
Hence, using the proof of the lower estimate in Lemma 4.3, we get ˜ 1) log P ( ≥ −1. E→+∞ (1 + (α † − 2ε)d)k log k
(4.29)
lim inf
˜ 1 ). We partition C(0, n+3l) into cubes Let us prove the asymptotic upper bound for P ( † † of side length k −(α −2ε) , the cubes being indexed by 4k = k −(α −2ε) Zd ∩ C(0, n + 3l). † For 1 ≤ i ≤ q, let γi be the projection of xi on the lattice k −(α −2ε) Zd . Then, for any x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), there exists γ ∈ 4k such that K(x, k −(α
† −2ε)
[
)⊂
C(γ − γi , 4k −(α
† −2ε)
).
1≤i≤q
Hence P ({ω ∈ 2E : ∃x ∈ C(0, n + 2l), m(ω, K(x, k −(α −2ε) )) > k}) [ X † P ω ∈ 2E ; m ω, C(γi + γ , 4k −(α −2ε) ) > k ≤ γ ∈4k 1≤i≤q [ † † C(γi , 4k −(α −2ε) ) > k . ≤ ((n + 3l)k (α −2ε) )d P ω ∈ 2E : m ω, †
1≤i≤q
As k > E δ and as n and l are at most of polynomial size in E, this gives lim sup E→+∞
˜ 1) log P ( ≤ −1. † (1 + (α − 2ε)d)k log k
Combined with (4.29), we get ˜ 1) log P (
∼
E→+∞
−(1 + (α † − 2ε)d)k log k.
(4.30)
On the other hand, Lemma 4.3 tells us that ˜ 2) log P (
∼
E→+∞
†
−(1 + εν † )k 1+εν log k.
˜ 1 ). In view of (4.30), this completes the ˜ 2 ) is negligible with respect to P ( So that P ( proof of Lemma 4.5. u t 5. Appendix 5.1. The structure of the Poisson potential. Let V ∈ Lp (Rd ) be a potential satisfying assumptions H1, H 2 and H 3. Let m(ω, dx) be a Poisson measure of concentration µ. Consider the potential Vω defined by (1.1). One has
92
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Lemma 5.1. For any α ∈ (0, 1), p0 < p and 0 < b < 1, there exists C > 0, such that ω-almost surely, Vω ∈
[
k (α, b, p0 ),
k≥1
where, for k ≥ 1, k (α, b, p0 ) is the set of measurable functions V : Rd → C that can be written in the form V = V (r) + V (i) , where V (r) and V (i) satisfy −p 0
p
1. |V (r) (x)| ≤ Ck p−p0 b p−p0 (|x|α + 1) for x ∈ Rd , p0
2. V (i) ∈ Lloc,unif and kV (i) k
p0
Lloc,unif
≤ b (here k · kLp
= sup k · kLp (C(x,1)) ).
loc,unif
x∈Rd
Moreover, there exists C > 0 such that P({Vω 6 ∈ k (α, b, p0 )}) ≤
(Cµ)k . k!
(5.1)
Proof. Fix α, p 0 and b as in the lemma. Pick 0 < α 0 < α. As V2 is compactly supported, there exists r0 > 1 such that suppV2 ⊂ C(0, r0 ). Let 0 = r0 Zd . Pick k > 0. Define 0 Pk,α 0 := P ({∃γ ∈ 0; m(ω, C(γ , r0 )) ≥ k(|γ |α + 1)}). Using (4.16), we compute Pk,α 0 ≤
X
0
P ({ω; m(ω, C(γ , r0 )) ≥ k(|γ |α + 1)}
γ ∈0 0
X (µr d )k(|γ |α +1) 0 ≤ 0 (k(|γ |α + 1))! γ ∈0 ≤C
(5.2)
(µr0d )k for some C > 0. k!
We write Vω = V1,ω + V2,ω ,
(5.3)
Z where V1,ω (x) =
Rd
Z V1 (x − y)dm(ω, y) and V2,ω (x) =
Now assume that ω is such that 0
Rd
V2 (x − y)dm(ω, y).
∀γ ∈ 0, m(ω, C(γ , r0 )) < k(|γ |α + 1),
(5.4)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
93
and (xn (ω))n∈N the points in the support of m(ω, dx). We will estimate V1,ω and V2,ω separately. V1,ω can be estimated as in [9]. One has |V1,ω (x)| ≤
X
X
|V1 (x − xn (ω))|
β∈r0 Zd xn (ω)∈C(β,r0 )
≤C
X
e−|x−β|/C m(ω, C(γ , r0 ))
β∈r0 Zd
≤C
(5.5)
X
β∈r0
e
−|x−β|/C
α0
k(|β| + 1)
Zd 0
≤ Ck(|x|α + 1). As V2 ∈ Lp (Rd ), for K ≥ 1, we have Z
p0
Rd
1|V2 (x)|≥K |V2 (x)| dx
1/p0
Z =
1|V2 (x)|≥K |V2 (x)| |V2 (x)|
Rd
≤K
p0 −p
p
p 0 −p p0
1/p0 dx
p/p0
kV2 kLp .
(5.6) (r)
(i)
Let us introduce a notation: take a function W and decompose it into W = WK + WK , where (r)
(i)
WK := 1|W (x)|≤K W and WK := 1|W (x)|>K W.
(5.7)
Fix a sequence of positive numbers (Kγ )γ ∈0 . As suppV2 ⊂ C(0, r0 ), V2,ω can be rewritten as (i)
(r)
V2,ω = V2,ω + V2,ω ,
(5.8)
where we define (i,r)
V2,ω (x) :=
X
1C(γ ,r0 ) (x)
γ ∈0
X
(i,r)
xn (ω)∈C(γ ,2r0 ) p0 p α,
Pick a > 0, Kγ = a(|γ |β + 1) and set β = by (5.6), we have
(V2 )Kγ (x − xn (ω)) .
α0 =
(i)
p−p0 p α.
Then, for some C > 0,
k1C(γ ,r0 ) V2,ω kLp0 ≤ Cm(ω, C(γ , 2r0 ))(a(|γ |β + 1)) ≤ Cka
p 0 −p p0
p 0 −p p0
0
α 0 +β p p−p 0
(|γ |
+ 1) ≤ 2Cka
p 0 −p p0
(5.9) ,
and (r)
0
k1C(γ ,r0 ) V2,ω k∞ ≤ Cka(|γ |α +β + 1) ≤ Cka(|γ |α + 1).
(5.10)
94
F. Klopp, L. Pastur p0
p0
Pick a = (2−d b) p0 −p (Ck) p−p0 (where C is the constant appearing in (5.9)). As r0 > 1, (i) (i) ≤ 2d sup k1C(γ ,r0 ) V2,ω kLp0 . Hence, by (5.9), we get we have kV2,ω k p0 Lloc,unif
γ ∈0
(i)
kV2,ω k
p0
Lloc,unif
≤ b.
(5.11)
Moreover, by (5.10), for some C > 0, for x ∈ Rd , we have (r)
p
−p 0
|V2,ω (x)| ≤ Ck p−p0 b p−p0 (|x|α + 1).
(5.12)
Now putting together Eqs. (5.3), (5.5), (5.8), (5.11) and (5.12), we see that if ω is such 0 that ∀γ ∈ 0, m(ω, C(γ , r0 )) < k(|γ |α + 1), then Vω ∈ k (α, b, p0 ). Taking into account Eq. (5.2), we get Lemma 5.1. u t 5.2. An a-priori estimate on the density of states. Recall that N denotes the integrated density of states of Hω . We prove Lemma 5.2. Under assumption H1, H 2 and H 3, there exists C > 0 such that, for E > 1, we have 1 2p−d log N(−E) ≤ − E 2p log E, C
(5.13)
and, for any n ≥ 1 and E > 1, we have 1 2p−d log E(Nω,n (−E)) ≤ − E 2p log E. C
(5.14)
Proof. Equations (5.14) and (5.13) are proved along the same lines. We will only write the details for (5.13). By [21], we know that, for any cube 3 and E > 0, we have 1 N smaller than or equal to − E} ]{eigenvalues of Hω,3 N (−E) ≤ E Vol(3) 1 X N E 1{ω; m(ω,3)=n} ]{eigenvalues of Hω,3 smaller than or equal to −E} , = Vol(3) n∈N
(5.15) N denotes the restriction of H to 3 with the Neumann boundary conditions. where Hω,3 ω One has the
Lemma 5.3. Pick p > p(d) (p(d) is defined in assumption H 2). If V ∈ Lp (Rd ) then, d and E > 0, (E − 1)−α/2 V (E − 1)−α/2 is bounded on L2 (Rd ) and for for α > 2p some Cα,p > 0, one has k(E − 1)−α/2 V (E − 1)−α/2 kL(L2 ) ≤ Cα,p kV kLp (Rd ) E −α+d/2p .
(5.16)
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
95
Proof. Using classical properties of the Fourier transform from Lp to Lq (q −1 +p−1 = 1 and 1 ≤ p ≤ 2) (see e.g. [6]), one shows (E−1)−α/2 is bounded from L2 (Rd ) to Lr (Rd ) α 1 1 for < + with the bound r 2 d α
k(E − 1)−α/2 kL2 →Lr ≤ Cα,r E − 2 +
d(2−r) 4r
.
One concludes using duality and Hölder’s inequality. u t Lemma 5.3, admits an immediate corollary p
Corollary 5.1. Pick p > p(d). Let V ∈ Lloc,unif (Rd ) be such that kV (i) kLp Then, there exists C > 0 such that, for φ ∈ H 1 (Rd ) and > 0, we have d
h|V |φ, φi ≤ k∇φk2L2 (Rd ) + C d−2p kφk2L2 (Rd ) .
loc,unif
≤ 1.
(5.17)
We now continue the proof of Lemma 5.2. The identity (5.17) can be carried over to H 1 (3) in the following way. Let φ ∈ H 1 (3); we can extend φ to Rd and we denote this extension by φ˜ (see [29,32]). By definition, φ˜ |3 = φ. Moreover we know that, for some C > 0, ˜ L2 (Rd ) ≤ C0 k∇φkL2 (3) . ˜ L2 (Rd ) ≤ C0 kφkL2 (3) and k∇ φk kφk
(5.18)
Pick x0 ∈ Rd and define Vx0 (x) = V (x −x0 ). Then, for φ ∈ H 1 (3) and > 0, by (5.17) ˜ φi ˜ L2 (Rd ) h|Vx0 |φ, φiL2 (3) = h|Vx0 |13 φ, d
˜ 2 2 d + C d−2p kφk ˜ 22 d ≤ k∇ φk L (R ) L (R ) d
≤ C0 k∇φk2L2 (3) + C0 C d−2p kφk2L2 (3) , Hence, there exists C > 0 such that, for any x0 ∈ Rd , > 0 and φ ∈ H 1 (3), we have d
h|Vx0 |φ, φiL2 (3) ≤ k∇φk2L2 (3) + C d−2p kφk2L2 (3) .
(5.19)
Now pick ω such that m(ω, 3) = n. By (5.19), for φ ∈ H 1 (3), we have d
hVω φ, φiL2 (3) ≥ −nk∇φk2L2 (3) − Cn d−2p kφk2L2 (3) . Pick =
1 to get 2n h(−1 + Vω )φ, φiL2 (3) ≥
2p 1 k∇φk2L2 (3) − Cn 2p−d kφk2L2 (3) . 2
(5.20)
Hence 2p
N ≥ −Cn 2p−d . Hω,3
(5.21)
96
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
As a direct consequence of (5.20), we get that N smaller than or equal to − E} ]{eigenvalues of Hω,3 2p
2p−d − E} ≤ ]{eigenvalues of − 1N 3 smaller than or equal to Cn
≤ CVol(3)n
2p 2p−d
(5.22)
.
Plugging this into (5.15), for some C > 0 (depending on 3), we obtain X 2p C E 1{ω; m(ω,3)=n}Vol(3)n 2p−d N (−E) ≤ Vol(3) 2p−d n≥E
X
≤C
n≥E
≤C
n
2p−d 2p
/C
2p
2p 2p−d
(µVol(3))n n!
/C
E(µVol(3))E
2p−d 2p
/C
2p−d 2p
(E /C)! This ends the proof of Lemma 5.2. u t
.
5.3. Exponential decay estimates. One has Lemma 5.4. Let α ∈ (0, 1), p > p(d) (p(d) is defined in assumption H 2) and q > d/2. Pick χ ∈ C0∞ (Rd ) such that 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1, χ ≡ 1 on C(0, 1/2) and χ ≡ 0 outside of C(0, 3/2). Then, there exists Cα,p,q,χ > 0 and α,p,q,χ > 0 such that, for any V of the form V = V i + V r , where p
• V i ∈ Lloc,unif and kV i kLp
• For some K > 0,
Vr
loc,unif
≤ b (for some b > 0).
satisfies | V r (x) |≤ K(|x|α + 1) for all x ∈ Rd ,
there exists Cb > 0 such that, for any (γ , γ 0 ) ∈ Zd × Zd and z ∈ C \ R, one has kχγ (z − (−1 + V ))−1 χγ 0 kTq ≤ Cα,p,q,χ
kχγ (z − (−1 + V ))−1 χγ 0 kL(L2 ,H 1 )
(1 + |γ 0 |)α η(z, K, b)
0
· e−α,p,q,χ ·η(z,K,b)|δα (γ )−δα (γ )| , (1 + |γ |)α ≤ Cα,p,q,χ η(z, K, b)
(5.23)
· e−α,p,q,χ ·η(z,K,b)|δα (γ )−δα (γ )| ,
(5.24)
0
|Imz| . Here χγ (·) = χ(·−γ ), |z| + K + Cb k · kTq denotes the norm in the q th Schatten class, H 1 (Rd ) is the usual Sobolev space H 1 (Rd ) = (1 − 1)−1/2 L2 (Rd ) and dist(z, z0 ) denotes the distance in C.
where δα (x) = (1+x 2 )(1−α)/2 and η(z, K, b) =
Proof. Up to small modifications, the proof of this result is the same as the proof of Lemma 4.1 in [9]. Let us just say that, in order to prove (5.24), we use the fact that t (1 + x 2 )α/2 ∇(z − (−1 + V ))−1 is bounded on L2 (Rd ) for Imz 6= 0 (see [26]). u
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
97
5.4. Some useful facts about the single site potential Hamiltonian Hg . Recall that, for g ∈ R, in Sect. 1.2, we have defined H (g) = −1 + gV and −E− (g) to be the infimum of the spectrum of H (g). It is well known that, for g large enough, −E− is a simple eigenvalue ([23,26]); hence it is analytic in g. Moreover it is convex (by the variational principle). Its first and second derivative are positive. Let ϕg be the unique positive normalized ground state associated to −E− (g). Then the eigenvalue equation gives k∇ϕg k2 + ghV ϕg , ϕg i = −E− (g). 0 (g) = −hV ϕ , ϕ i; so that E (g) satisfies Hence E− g g − 0 (g). k∇ϕg k2 + E− (g) = gE−
(5.25)
Let g be an inverse of E− in a neighborhood of +∞. Then, one has the following Lemma 5.5. Let V ∈ Lp (Rd ) where p is chosen as in assumption H 2. Then, there exists C > 0 such that, for g and E sufficiently large, one has 2p 1 g ≤ E− (g) ≤ Cg 2p−d . C
E− (g) is bounded if and only if V− is bounded. g In this case, we have: E− (g) ∼ kV− k∞ g. g→+∞ Z Z |ϕg |2 dx + |∇ϕg |2 dx → 0 as g → +∞. ∃R > 0 such that |x|>R
|x|>R
(5.26) (5.27)
(5.28)
2p
k∇ϕg k2 ≤ Cg 2p−d .
(5.29)
1 2p−d E 2p ≤ g(E) ≤ CE. C ∃C > 0, E0 > 0 such that ∀a > 0, ∀E > E0 , one has g(E) ≤ g(E + a) ≤ g(E) + Ca.
(5.30) (5.31)
Proof. The two sided bound (5.26) is an immediate corollary of (5.17) and of assumption H 3. The definition of g and (5.26) give (5.30). The proof of (5.27) is easy and left to the reader. By Eqs. (5.25) and (5.26), for g large enough, we have 0 (g) ≥ E−
1 1 E− (g) ≥ . g C
Integrating this relation, we get E− (g + k) − E− (g) ≥
k . C
Hence, as g is increasing, for E large enough and a > 0, we have g(E) ≤ g(E + a) ≤ g(E− (g(E) + Ca)) = g(E) + Ca. 0 is increasing, for This completes the proof of (5.31). Let us now prove (5.29). As E− ε > 0, we have 0 (g) ≥ εk∇ϕg k2 E− (g(1 + ε)) − E− (g) ≥ εgE−
98
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
by Eq. (5.25). Equation (5.29) is then an immediate consequence of (5.26). Let us now prove (5.28). We will distinguish two cases when V− is bounded and when it is not. Let us start with assuming V− bounded and let v− be its essential infimum. Then, by (5.27), as g → ∞, we have Z k∇ϕg k2 + g V |ϕg |2 dx = gv− + o(g). Hence,
Z 0≤
(V − v− )|ϕg |2 dx ≤ o(1).
(5.32)
By assumptions H1 and H 2, there exists δ > 0 such that for |x| ≥ 1/δ, V (x) − v− ≥ δ. Then, as V − v− is non negative, Eq. (5.32) tells us that Z |ϕg |2 dx ≤ o(1). |x|≥1/δ
If V is not bounded from below, let χ be a C0∞ cut-off for the cube C(0, R). The eigenvalue equation for ϕg gives us (−1 − E(g))[(1 − χ )ϕg ] = gV (1 − χ)ϕg + 2∇χ · ∇ϕg + 1χ ϕg . So that (1 − χ)ϕg = a1 + a2 + a3 , where a1 = g(−1 − E(g))−1 [V (1 − χ)ϕg ], a2 = 2(1 + E(g))−1 [∇χ · ∇ϕg ], a3 = (1 + E(g))−1 [1χ ϕg ]. For R large enough, V is bounded on the support of 1 − χ; this and (5.27) implies that ka1 k + ka3 k → 0 as g → +∞. We write a2 = 2 (1 + E(g))−1 [1, ∇χ] + ∇χ (1 + E(g))−1 ∇ϕg . As (1 + E(g))−1 ∇ → 0 in L2 -operator norm when g → +∞, we have ka2 k → 0 as g → +∞. Hence k(1 − χ)ϕg k → 0 as g → +∞. We compute k∇[(1 − χ )ϕg ]k2 = 2h(1 − χ)∇ϕg , ϕg ∇χi + h1χ ϕg , χϕg i = 2h∇[(1 − χ)ϕg ], ϕg ∇χi − 2h(∇χ)2 ϕg , ϕg ∇χ i + h1χ ϕg , χϕg i. For R sufficiently large, by what we have just proved, the last two terms in the equation above tend to 0 as g → +∞. Using the Cauchy–Schwartz inequality, this implies k∇[(1 − χ )ϕg ]k2 ≤ 2k∇[(1 − χ)ϕg ]kkϕg ∇χ k + o(1). As kϕg ∇χ k → 0 when g → +∞, we get that k∇[(1 − χ)ϕg ]k → 0 when g → +∞. This completes the proof of Eq. (5.28) hence of Lemma 5.5. u t
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
99
As a corollary of this lemma, we get Lemma 5.6. Let V ∈ Lp (Rd ) where p is chosen as in assumption H 2. Then, there exists R0 > 0 such that, if χ ∈ C0∞ (Rd ), 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1, χ(x) = 1 if |x| ≤ R0 and χ (x) = 0 if |x| ≥ 2R0 , then ψg = χ · ϕg /kχ · ϕg k is an asymptotic ground state and we have ) ( g|h(τa V − V )ψg , ψg i| = 0 6 = ∅. α > 0; lim sup g→+∞ |a|≤g −α E− (g) Proof. If we pick χ as above for R0 large enough, by Lemma 5.5, we know that k(1 − χ )ϕg k + k(1 − χ)∇ϕg k → 0 as g → +∞.
(5.33)
Then, as ϕg is the ground state of H (g), we compute h(H (g) − E(g))ψg , ψg i = h(H (g) − E(g))(1 − χ)ϕg , (1 − χ)ϕg i = −E(g)k(1 − χ)ϕg k2 + h∇χ∇ϕg , (1 − χ)ϕg i + h1χ ∇ϕg , (1 − χ)ϕg i. Equation (5.33) tells us that ψg is an asymptotic ground state as kχ · ϕg k → 1 when g → +∞. Define φg = (E− (g) − 1)1/2 ϕg . Then, by (5.26) and (5.29), we have 2p
kφg k2 ≤ Cg 2p−d . Pick a ∈ Rd and write h(τa V − V )ϕg , ϕg i = h0(g)φg , φg i, where 0(g) = (E− (g) − 1)−1/2 (τa V − V )(E− (g) − 1)−1/2 . We now estimate the norm of 0(g). We write 0(g) = (τa − 1)(E− (g) − 1)−1/2 V (E− (g) − 1)−1/2 τ−a + + (E− (g) − 1)−1/2 V (E− (g) − 1)−1/2 (τ−a − 1). Hence, for 0 < δ < 1/2 such that −1 + 2δ + d/2p < 0, by Lemma 5.3, we have k0(g)k ≤ 2k(τa − 1)(E− (g) − 1)−δ kk(E− (g) − 1)−1/2+δ V (E− (g) − 1)−1/2 k ≤ C[E− (g)]−1+δ+d/2p |a|δ (E− (g))−δ , writing (τa − 1)(E− (g) − 1)−δ as a Fourier multiplier. Hence 2p g|h(τa V − V )ϕg , ϕg i| −αδ+ 2p−d . ≤ Cg[E− (g)]−2+d/2p g sup E− (g) |a|≤g −α
100
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Using (5.26) and picking α large enough, we get lim
sup
g→+∞ |a|≤g −α
g|h(τa V − V )ϕg , ϕg i| = 0. E− (g)
Now using Eqs. (5.26), (5.33) and the fact that, for R0 large enough, τa V −V is bounded outside {|x| ≤ 2R0 }, we get lim
sup
g→+∞ |a|≤g −α
g|h(τa V − V )ψg , ψg i| = 0. E− (g)
This ends the proof of Lemma 5.6. u t To end this section we describe the ground state energy of H (g) and an asymptotic ground state in the case when V satisfies assumption H,1”. For 1 ≤ i ≤ q, define Hgi = −1 + gVi , where Vi is defined in Eq. (1.10). Hgi is a form bounded perturbation of −1 with relative bound 0. By the homogeneity properties of Vi , when Ei < 0 (Ei is the ground state energy of H1i ), it is obvious that the ground state energy of Hgi is given by 2
Ei (g) = Ei g 2−νi .
(5.34) (i)
Define E† (g) = inf Ei (g). Moreover, if ϕi is the ground state of H1i then ϕg , the ground state of Hgi has the following form: d 1 ϕg(i) (x) = g 2(2−νi ) ϕi g 2−νi x .
(5.35)
We have Lemma 5.7. Assume V satisfies assumptions H1 and H 1”. Then, we have E(g)
∼
g→+∞
E† (g).
Moreover, if 1 ≤ i0 ≤ q is such that Ei0 (g) = E† (g), then, if χi0 is a C0∞ cut-off function (i ) (i ) (i ) for a sufficiently small neighborhood of xi0 , ψg 0 (·) = χi0 ϕg 0 (·−xi0 )/kχi0 ϕg 0 (·−xi0 )k is an asymptotic ground state for H (g). Proof. Fix ε > 0 small. As in Sect. 4.3, at the cost of adding a term to V1 , we may assume that the functions Wi stay non-negative and smaller than 1 + ε and that the support of the Wi are two by two disjoint. For 1 ≤ i ≤ q, let χi be a C0∞ cut-off function of a on the support of χi , the function Wi (· − xi ) stays larger neighborhood of xi such that, P than 1 − ε. Define χ02 = 1 − 1≤i≤q χi2 . Pick ϕ ∈ H 1 (Rd ). Then, for any ε > 0, we
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
101
have q q X X 2 h−1χi ϕ, ϕi + ghV χi2 ϕ, ϕi hH (g)ϕ, ϕi = i=0
=
q X i=0
+
i=0
k∇(χi ϕ)k2 − 2Rehχi ∇ϕ, ϕ∇χi i − h|∇χi |2 ϕ, ϕi q X i=1
≥ (1 − ε)
ghτxi (Wi Vi )χi2 ϕ, ϕi + ghV0 ϕ, ϕi q X i=1
(5.36)
k∇(χi ϕ)k2 +
g hτx (Wi Vi )χi ϕ, χi ϕi 1−ε i
q 1 X k∇χi · ϕk2 , + ghV0 ϕ, ϕi + 1 − ε i=0
where V0 is some bounded potential (depending on ε). On the other hand, on the support of χi , we have Wi Vi ≥ Vi − ε|V |i where |V |i (·) :=
|hi (·)| . | · |νi
Hence k∇(χi ϕ)k2 +
g hτx (Wi Vi )χi2 ϕ, ϕi ≥ 1−ε i
g hτx (Vi )χi ϕ, χi ϕi + ≥ (1 − ε) k∇(χi ϕ)k2 + 1−ε i g 2 hτx (|V |i )χi ϕ, χi ϕi . (5.37) + ε k∇(χi ϕ)k − 1−ε i
By Eq. (5.37), we get that k∇(χi ϕ)k2 +
g hτx (Wi Vi )χi2 ϕ, ϕi ≥ (1 + εC)Ei 1−ε i
g kχi ϕk2 1−ε
(5.38)
for some constant C (independent of ε) given by the lowest eigenvalue of −1 − g|V |i . Here we used the fact that this eigenvalue has the same growth rate in g as Ei (g); indeed, in the present case, this growth rate only depends on the homogeneity properties of the potential |V |i (as can be seen by a scaling argument). Putting Eqs. (5.38) and (5.36) together, we obtain that, there exists C > 0, such that, for any ε > 0 small and ϕ ∈ H 1 (Rd ), we have g + O(g) kϕk2 . hH (g)ϕ, ϕi ≥ (1 − ε)E† 1−ε This proves that lim sup g→+∞
E(g) ≤ 1. E† (g)
102
F. Klopp, L. Pastur
Pick 1 ≤ i0 ≤ q such that Ei0 (g) = E† (g) and χ a C0∞ cut-off function for a sufficiently (i ) (i ) small neighborhood of xi0 . By the definition of ϕg 0 , it is immediate that kχϕg 0 k → 1 as g → +∞. An immediate computation gives that (i )
(i )
hH (g)χϕg 0 , χϕg 0 i = 1. g→+∞ Ei0 (g) lim
This implies that lim inf
g→+∞
E(g) ≥ 1. E† (g)
Hence, it completes the proof of Lemma 5.7. u t Acknowledgement. F. K. thanks the Erwin Schrödinger Institute (Vienna) where this work was partially done and A. Trouvé for interesting discussions about Poisson processes. The authors are grateful to the referee for his very careful reading of the paper and for his pertinent remarks that allowed them to correct a number of misprints and to make several important improvements.
References 1. Combes, J.M. and Hislop, P.D.: Localization for some continuous random hamiltonians in d-dimensions. J. Funct. Anal. 124, 149–180 (1994) 2. Cycon, H.L., Froese, R.G., Kirsch, W. and Simon, B.: Schrödinger Operators. Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1987 3. Donsker, M. and Varadhan, S.R.S.: Asymptotics for the Wiener sausage. Commun. Pure and App. Math. 28, 525–565 (1975) 4. Efros, M. and Shlovski, B.: Electronic properties of doped semi-conductors. Heidelberg: Springer Verlag, 1984 5. Helffer, B. and Sjöstrand, J.: On diamagnetism and the De Haas-Van Alphen effect. Ann. de l’Institut Henri Poincaré, série Phys. Théor. 52, 303–375 (1990) 6. Hörmander, L.: The analysis of linear partial differential equations. I. Vol. 256 of Grundlehren der Mathematischen Wissenschaften, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer Verlag, 1990 7. Kirsch, W.: Random Schrödinger operators. In: A.Jensen H.Holden, editor, Schrödinger Operators, Number 345 in Lecture Notes in Physics, Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1989 8. Klopp, F.: An asymptotic expansion for the density of states of a random Schrödinger operator with Bernoulli disorder. Random Operators and Stochastic Equations 3 (4), 315–332 (1995) 9. Klopp, F.: A low concentration asymptotic expansion for the density of states of a random Schrödinger operator with Poisson disorder. J. Funct. Anal. 145, 267–295 (1995) 10. Klopp, F.: Band edge behaviour for the integrated density of states of random Jacobi matrices in dimension 1. J. Stat. Phy. 90 (3–4), 927–947 (1998) 11. Klopp, F.: Internal Lifshits tails for random perturbations of periodic Schrödinger operators. Duke Math. J. 1999. To appear 12. Klopp, F.: Precise high energy asymptotics for the integrated density of states of an unbounded random Jacobi matrix. Rev. Math. Phys. 1999. To appear 13. Klopp, F. and Pastur, L.: In progress 14. Kuchment, P.: Floquet theory for partial differential equations. Vol. 60 of Operator Theory: Advances and Applications, Basel: Birkhäuser, 1993 15. Landau, L. and Lifshitz, L. Mécanique quantique, théorie non-relativiste. Moscou: Editions MIR, 1966 16. Lifshitz, I.M.: Structure of the energy spectrum of impurity bands in disordered solid solutions. Sov. Phys. JETP 17, 1159–1170 (1963) 17. Lifshitz, I.M.: Energy spectrum structure and quantum states of disordered condensed systems. Sov. Phys. Uspekhi 7, 549–573 (1965) 18. Lifshitz, I.M., Gredeskul, S.A. and Pastur, L.A. Introduction to the theory of disordered systems. NewYork: Wiley, 1988 19. Mather, J.N. On Nirenberg’s proof of Malgrange’s preparation theorem. In: Proceedings of Liverpool Singularities-Symposium I, Number 192 in Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1971
Lifshitz Tails for Random Schrödinger Operators
103
20. Pastur, L.: Behaviour of some Wiener integrals as t → +∞ and the density of states of the Schrödinger equation with a random potential. Teor.-Mat.-Fiz 32, 88–95 (1977) (in Russian) 21. Pastur, L. and Figotin, A.: Spectra of Random and Almost-Periodic Operators. Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1992 22. Reed, M. and Simon, B.: Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics, Vol IV: Analysis of Operators. New-York: Academic Press, 1978 23. Reed, M. and Simon, B. Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics, Vol I: Functional Analysis. New-York: Academic Press, 1980 24. Shubin, M.A. Spectral theory and index of elliptic operators with almost periodic coefficients. Russ. Math. Surv. 34, 109–157 (1979) 25. Simon, B.: Trace ideals and their applications. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979 26. Simon, B.: Schrödinger semigroups. Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 7, 447–526 (1982) 27. Simon, B.: Lifshitz tails for the Anderson model. J. Stat. Phys. 38, 65–76 (1985) 28. Sjöstrand, J.: Microlocal analysis for periodic magnetic Schrödinger equation and related questions. In: Microlocal analysis and applications, Vol. 1495 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1991 29. Stein, E.: Singular integrals and Differentiability properties of functions. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1970 30. Sznitman, A.: Lifshitz tails and Wiener sausages. I. J. Funct. Anal. 94, 223–246 (1990) 31. Sznitman, A.: Fluctuations of principal eigenvalues and random scales. Commun. Math. Phys. 189, 337– 363 (1997) 32. Taylor, M. Partial differential equations. New-York–Berlin: Springer, 1996 Communicated by Ya. G. Sinai
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 105 – 136 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces of Sheaves on Rational Surfaces Lothar Göttsche International Center for Theoretical Physics, Strada Costiera 11, P.O. Box 586, 34100 Trieste, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 26 August 1998/ Accepted: 10 March 1999
Abstract: We compute generating functions for the Hodge numbers of the moduli spaces of H -stable rank 2 sheaves on a rational surface S in terms of theta functions for indefinite lattices. If H lies in the closure of the ample cone and has self-intersection 0, it follows that the generating functions are Jacobi forms. In particular the generating functions for the Euler numbers can be expressed in terms of modular forms, and their transformation behaviour is compatible with the predictions of S-duality. We also express the generating functions for the signatures in terms of modular forms. It turns out that these generating functions are also (with respect to another developing parameter) the generating function for the Donaldson invariants of S evaluated on all powers of the point class. 1. Introduction Let (S, H ) be a rational algebraic surface with an ample divisor. We assume that KS H ≤ 0. In the current paper we want to compute the Betti numbers and Hodge numbers of the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) of H -semistable torsion-free sheaves of rank 2 on S. In [V-W] Vafa and Witten made a number of predictions about the Euler numbers of moduli spaces of sheaves on algebraic surfaces: in many cases their generating functions should be given by modular forms. In the case of rational surfaces this cannot be true for all polarizations H : The moduli spaces and their Euler numbers depend on H , and this dependence is not compatible with the modularity properties. We study the limit of the generating function for the Euler numbers as H approaches a point F on the boundary of the ample cone with F 2 = 0 (see below for the definitions). It turns out that this limit is indeed a (quasi)-modular form (see Sect. 2.3). More generally we will relate the generating functions for the Hodge numbers and Betti numbers of the MSH (C, d) to certain theta functions of indefinite lattices, which were introduced and studied in [G-Z] in order to show structural results about Donaldson invariants. That the Euler numbers and signatures are given by modular and quasimodular
106
L. Göttsche
forms follows then from the fact that these theta functions are Jacobi forms. As in [G-Z], where the Donaldson invariants were studied, the theta functions enter the calculations by summing over walls. The ample cone has a chamber structure, and the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) only change when H crosses a wall. The structure of the walls for the moduli spaces is precisely the same as for the Donaldson invariants. Therefore we can use again the same theta functions as in [G-Z]. We write our results for the χy -genera instead of for the Hodge numbers, which is equivalent as all the cohomology is of type (p, p) [Be]. One could also have instead used the Poincaré polynomial, but I believe that in general the χy -genus will be better behaved. By specializing the generating functions for the χy -genera of the moduli spaces, we also obtain that the generating functions for the signatures are given by modular forms, a fact that does not seem to have been predicted by the physics literature. It turns out that the generating function for the signatures is better behaved than that for the Euler numbers. If F lies on the boundary of the positive cone, then the corresponding generating function for the signatures is a modular form and not just a quasimodular form. A surprising and interesting result is that the signatures of the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) are closely related to the corresponding Donaldson invariants 8S,H C . For any point H in the ample cone, the generating function for the signatures is also the r generating function for the Donaldson invariants 8S,H C (p ) evaluated on all powers of the point class p ∈ H0 (S, Z). The signatures of the moduli spaces are just the coefficients of the Fourier development of this generating function, whereas the Donaldson invariants are (up to some elementary factors) the coefficients of the development of this function into powers of a modular function u(τ ) for 0(2). In particular knowing all the signatures of the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) is equivalent to knowing all the Donaldson r invariants 8S,H C (p ). This relation also persists under our extension of the generating functions and, together with the formulas for the K3 surfaces, suggests a similar result for any algebraic surface. The proof of this result uses the conjecture of Kotschick and Morgan [K-M]. Feehan and Leness [F-L1,F-L2,F-L3,F-L4] are working towards the proof of this conjecture. This paper grew out of discussions with Jun Li on some aspects of [V-W]. I would like to thank K. Yoshioka for several very useful comments, G. Thompson for useful discussions and the referee for many useful comments and improvements. While preparing this manuscript I learned about related work. In [M-N-V-W] new predictions are made about the Euler numbers of MSF (C, d), where S is a rational elliptic surface, F is the class of a fibre and CF even.Yoshioka [Y4] has shown these predictions. Li and Qin ([L-Q1,L-Q2]) have shown blowup formulas for the Euler numbers and virtual Hodge polynomials of MSH (C, d) for arbitrary S. After this paper was submitted Baranovsky [Ba] displayed an action of the oscillator algebra on the cohomology of the moduli spaces MSF (r, C, d) and gave a simple relation between the Betti numbers of the Gieseker and Uhlenbeck compactifications.
2. Notations, Definitions and Background In this paper S usually denotes a smooth algebraic surface over C. Often we will assume S to be also rational. For a variety Y over C, we denote by upper case letters the classes in H 2 (Y, C), unless they appear as walls (see below), when we denote them by Greek letters. For A, B ∈ H 2 (Y, C) the intersection product on H 2 (Y, C) is just denoted by AB. Later we will also need the negative of the intersection product, which we denote
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
107
by hA, Bi. For a smooth compact variety Y of complex dimension d let X (−1)p+q hp,q (Y )x p y q h(Y, x, y) := p,q
be the Hodge polynomial (note the signs), and let d
H (Y ) = H (Y : x, y) := (xy)− 2 h(Y, x, y). , y 1/2 is that it is symmetric around The advantage of this (Laurent) polynomial in x 1/2P degree 0. In a similar way let P (Y ) = P (Y : y) = i (−1)i bi (Y )y i−d := H (Y : y, y) be the (shifted) Poincaré polynomial (again note the signs) and let Xy (Y ) = H (Y : 1, y) be the (shifted) χ−y -genus. Then the Euler number of Y is e(Y ) = X1 (Y ) = P (Y, 1), d and the signature is σ (Y ) := (−1) 2 X−1 (Y ). 2.1. Virtual Hodge polynomials and the Weil conjectures. Virtual Hodge polynomials were introduced in [D-K]. For Y a complex variety the cohomology Hck (Y, Q) with compact support carries a natural mixed Hodge structure. If Y is smooth and projective, this Hodge structure coincides with the classical one. Following [Ch], we put XX (−1)k hp,q (Hck (Y, Q))x p y q . hv (Y : x, y) := p,q
k
These virtual Hodge polynomials have the following properties (see [Ch]). If Y is a smooth projective variety, then hv (Y : x, y) = h(Y : x, y). For Z ⊂ Y Zariski-closed we have hv (Y : x, y) = hv (Y \ Z : x, y) + hv (Z : x, y). For f : Z −→ Y a Zariski-locally trivial fibre bundle with fibre F , we have hv (Z : x, y) = hv (Y : x, y)hv (F : x, y). Finally e(Y ) = hv (Y, 1, 1) for any complex variety Y . We denote by X (−1)i bvi (Y )y i = pv (Y : y) := hv (Y : y, y) i
the virtual Poincaré polynomial. If Y has pure complex dimension d (or sometimes when d Y has expected dimension d), we write Hv (Y ) = Hv (Y : x, y) := (xy)− 2 hv (Y : x, y), Xyv (Y ) := Hv (Y : 1, y) and Pv (Y ) = Pv (Y : y) := y −d pv (Y : y). If Y is smooth and projective of dimension d we have therefore Hv (Y ) = H (Y ), Xyv (Y ) = Xy (Y ) and Pv (Y ) = P (Y ). Let Y be an arbitrary quasiprojective variety (not necessarily irreducible or smooth) over C. We want to show that the Weil conjectures still compute the virtual Poincaré polynomials. This was pointed out to me by Jun Li, and seems to be known to the experts. Proposition 2.1. There is a finitely generated subring A = Z[a1 , . . . , al ] ⊂ C and a variety YA over A, such that Y = YA ×A C, and the following holds: For m a maximal ideal of A we put Ym := YA ×A A/m. There is a nonempty dense open subset U of spec(A), such that if m ∈ U is a maximal ideal of A with quotient field Fq , then there exist complex numbers (ai,j )i,j with |ai,j | = q i/2 , such that for all n ∈ Z>0 , i
v (Y ) X bX n (−1)i ai,j . #Yq (Fq n ) =
i
j =1
108
L. Göttsche
Proof. If Y is smooth and projective, this is part of the Weil conjectures, proven by Deligne [De]. The general case is a simple consequence of this and resolution of singularities in characteristic 0. Let d be the largest dimension of a component of Y . The proof is by induction on d, the case d = 0 being trivial. Write Y = Y0 t W , where Y0 is the smooth locus of Y , and let Y˜ = Y0 t Z be a smooth compactification of Y . Then pv (Y, z) = p(Y˜ , z) + pv (W, z) − pv (Z, z). Let A = Z[a1 , . . . , al ] ⊂ C be a finitely generated subring, such that Y , Y˜ , Z, W are already defined over A. Let U be an open dense subset of spec(A) where the proposition applies to Y˜ (by the usual Weil conjectures) Z and W (by induction). Let m ∈ U be a maximal ideal with quotient field t Fq . Then #Ym (Fq n ) = #Y˜m (Fq n ) + #Wm (Fq n ) − #Zm (Fq n ), and the result follows. u 2.2. Moduli spaces. Let again S be an algebraic surface, H a general ample divisor on S, and let C ∈ H 2 (X, Z). Let MSH (r, C, d) denote the moduli space of H -semistable sheaves E on S (in the sense of Gieseker-Maruyama), with c1 (E) = C and discriminant H 2 d = c2 (E) − r−1 2r C . Let MS (r, C, d)s denote the open subspace of H -slope stable H sheaves and NS (r, C, d) the subspace of H -slope stable locally free sheaves. If d is sufficiently large, then MSH (r, C, d) is irreducible and generically smooth of dimension e = 2rd − (r 2 − 1)χ(OS ) (see e.g. [H-L]). We put MSH (C, d) := MSH (2, C, d), MSH (C, d)s := MSH (2, C, d)s and NSH (C, d) := NSH (2, C, d). If S is a rational algebraic surface and H is an ample divisor with H KS ≤ 0, then a slope stable sheaf E fulfills Ext2 (E, E) = Hom(E, E ⊗ KS ) = 0, and therefore MSH (r, C, d)s is smooth of dimension e = 2rd − (r 2 − 1). 2.3. Modular forms. We give a brief review of the results for modular that we will forms need. It might be helpful to also look at [G-Z] Sect. 2.2. Let H := τ ∈ C Im(τ ) > 0 be the complex upper half-plane. For τ ∈ H let q := e2π iτ and q 1/n := e2π iτ/n . For We always use the principal branch of a ∈ Q we often write√(−1)a instead of eπia . √ the square root (with τ ∈ H for τ ∈ H and a ∈ R>0 for a ∈ R>0 ). We recall the definition of quasimodular forms from [K-Z]. A modular form of weight k on a subgroup 0 ⊂ Sl(2, Z) of finite index is a holomorphic function f on H satisfying aτ + b ab k ∈0 = (cτ + d) f (τ ), τ ∈ H, f cd cτ + d growing at most polynomially in 1/=(τ ) as =(τ ) → 0. An almost holomorphic modular form of weight k is a function F on H with the same transformation properties and growth P −m for conditions as a modular form which is of the form F (τ ) = M m=0 fm (τ )(=(τ )) M ≥ 0 and fi holomorphic functions. Functions f which occur as (the holomorphic part of F ) f0 (τ ) in Psuch an expansion are called quasimodular forms of weight k. We denote σk (n) := d|n d k and by σ1odd (n) the sum of the odd divisors of n. For even k ≥ 2 let Bk X + σk−1 (n)q n Gk (τ ) := − 2k n>0
is the k th
be the Eisenstein series, where Bk Bernoulli number. Note that Gk is a modular form of weight k on SL(2, Z) for k ≥ 4, but is only quasimodular for k = 2, i.e.
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
109
G2 (τ ) + 1/(8π=(τ )) is an almost holomorphic modular form of weight 2. Equivalently c(cτ + d) aτ + b = (cτ + d)2 G2 (τ ) − (2.1) cτ + d 4π i Q (see [Z2, p. 242]). Let η(τ ) := q 1/24 n>0 (1 − q n ) be the Dedekind eta function and 1 := η24 the discriminant. We have the transformation laws r τ η(τ ) see [C, VIII.3.] (2.2) η(τ + 1) = (−1)1/12 η(τ ), η(−1/τ ) = i G2
We write y := e2πiz for z a complex variable. Recall the classical theta functions X 2 (−1)nν q (n+µ/2) /2 y n+µ/2 (µ, ν ∈ {0, 1}) (2.3) θµ,ν (τ, z) := n∈Z
(see e.g. [C, Ch. V], where however the notations and conventions are slightly different), and the “Nullwerte” η(τ )5 , η(τ/2)2 η(2τ )2 η(2τ )2 0 , (τ ) = θ1,0 (τ, 0) = 2 θ1,0 η(τ ) θ (τ ) := θ0,0 (τ, 0) =
0 θ0,1 (τ ) = θ0,1 (τ, 0) =
η(τ/2)2 , η(τ )
(2.4)
θ1,1 (τ, 0) = 0.
We use the same notations also for µ, ν arbitrary in Q. The identities (2.4) follow readily from the product formulas 1 1 1 Y (1 − q n )(1 − q n y)(1 − q n y −1 ), (2.5) θ1,1 (τ, z) = q 8 (y 2 − y − 2 ) θ0,1 (τ, z) =
Y
n>0 n
(1 − q )(1 − q n− 2 y)(1 − q n− 2 y −1 ), 1
1
n>0
and the fact that θµ,ν (τ, z) = θµ,0 (τ, z + ν). θ1,1 has the transformation behaviour r τ π iz2 /τ 1/4 e θ1,1 (τ, z). θ1,1 (τ + 1, z) = (−1) θ1,1 (τ, z), θ1,1 (−1/τ, z/τ ) = −i i (2.6) By the product formulas (2.5) we see that θ0,1 (τ, z)θ1,1 (τ, z) = We write e θ1,1 (τ, z) :=
η(τ )2 θ1,1 (τ/2, z). η(τ/2) θ1,1 (τ, z) y 2 − y− 2 1
1
(2.7)
.
From the definitions it is straightforward to see that θµ+2,0 (τ, z) = θµ,0 (τ, z), θµ+2,1 (τ, z) = −θµ,1 (τ, z), µ ∈ Q.
(2.8)
110
By
L. Göttsche (−n−1/2)2 4
(n+1/2)2 4
=
0 (2τ ) = θ1/2,0
X
= (±(n/2 + 1/2))2 , one also checks immediately that
q (n+1/4) = 2
n∈Z
0 (τ/2) θ1,0 1 X (n+1/2)2 /4 η(τ )2 q = = . 2 2 η(τ/2)
(2.9)
n∈Z
) Following [Gö3,G-Z], we set f (τ ) := (−1)−1/4 η(τ θ (τ ) . Let e2 and e3 be the 2-division values of the Weierstraß ℘-function at τ/2 and (1 + τ )/2 respectively, i.e. X 1 +2 σ1odd (n)q n/2 , e2 (τ ) = 12 n>0 X 1 (−1)n σ1odd (n)q n/2 , +2 e3 (τ ) = 12 3
n>0
(see e.g. [H-B-J, p.132]). It is easy to see that e3 (2τ + 1) = e2 (2τ ). We also see that 0 (2τ ) and f (2τ + 1) = η(2τ )4 /η(τ )2 . We write θ (2τ + 1) = θ0,1 u(τ ) := − Remark 2.2. Let
η(2τ )8 f (τ )2 . , u(τ ) := u(2τ + 1) = − 3e3 (τ ) 3e2 (2τ )η(τ )4
(2.10)
12 0 −1 11 2 , S := . T := , V := T = 01 1 0 01
Let 0u = ±hV 2 , V S, SV i; this is a subgroup of index 6 of SL(2, Z). u(τ ) is a modular 21 . It is function on 0u . Let 0(2) := A ∈ Sl(2, Z) A ≡ id mod 2 . Let X := 01 easy to see that X−1 0u X = 0(2). In other words a function g(τ ) is a modular function on 0u , if and only if h(τ ) := g(2τ + 1) is a modular function on 0(2). In particular u(τ ) is a modular function on 0(2). 2.4. Theta functions for indefinite lattices. We review the definition of theta functions for indefinite lattices from [G-Z]. Let 0 be a lattice, i.e. a free Z module 0 together with a Z-valued bilinear form hx, yi on 0. The extension of the bilinear form to 0C := 0 ⊗ C and 0R = 0 ⊗R is denoted in the same way. The type of 0 is the pair (r −s, s), where r is the rank of 0 and s the largest rank of a sublattice of 0 on which h , i is negative definite. ab , Let M0 be the space of meromorphic functions on H × 0C . For v ∈ 0Q , A = cd and k ∈ Z we put f |v(τ, x) := q hv,vi/2 exp(2πihv, xi)f (τ, x + vτ ), x hx, xi aτ + b f , . f |k A(τ, x) := (cτ + d)−k exp − πi cτ + d cτ + d cτ + d
(2.11) (2.12)
Now assume that 0 is unimodular of type (r − 1, 1). We fix a vector f0 ∈ 0R with hf0 , f0 i < 0, and let C0 := f ∈ 0R hf, f i < 0, hf, f0 i < 0 , S0 := f ∈ 0 f primitive, hf, f i = 0, hf, f0 i < 0 .
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
For f ∈ S0 put
111
D(f ) := (τ, x) ∈ H × 0C 0 < =(hf, xi) < =(τ ) ,
and for f ∈ C0 put D(f ) := H × 0C . For t ∈ R we put µ(t) := 1, if t ≥ 0 and µ(t) = 0 otherwise. Let f, g ∈ C0 ∪ S0 . For c ∈ 0 and (τ, x) ∈ D(f ) ∩ D(g) we put X f,g (2.13) µ(hξ, f i) − µ(hξ, gi) q hξ,ξ i/2 e2π ihξ,xi , 20,c (τ, x) := ξ ∈0+c/2
f,g
f,g
and 20 := 20,0 .
f,g
Assume now that f, g ∈ S0 . Then (see [G-Z]) the function 20,c,b has a meromorphic extension to H × 0C , which is defined as follows. Let F : H × C2 → C; (τ, u, v) 7 →
η(τ )3 θ1,1 (τ, (u + v)/(2π i)) , θ1,1 (τ, u/(2π i))θ1,1 (τ, v/(2π i))
(see [Z1]; note the different conventions for θ1,1 in [Z1]). We have X X F (τ, u, v) = q nm e−nu−mv − q nm enu+mv , n≥0,m>0
n>0,m≥0
(see [G-Z, Sect. 3.1]). Assume hf, gi = −N ∈ Z<0 . We denote by [f, g] the lattice generated by f and g and by [f, g]⊥ its orthogonal complement. Let L := [f, g] ⊕ [f, g]⊥ . For (τ, x) ∈ H × 0C , we put X f,g q hξ,ξ i/2 e2π ihξ,xi . (2.14) 2L (τ, x) := F (N τ, −2πihf, xi, 2πihg, xi) ξ ∈[f,g]⊥
Let P be a system of representatives of 0 modulo L. Then, using the notation of (2.11), the meromorphic extension is given by X f,g f,g 2L (τ, x)|(t + c/2). (2.15) 20,c := t∈P
For f, g ∈ S0 the following is shown in [G-Z]: For |=(hf, xi)/=(τ )| < 1, |=(hg, xi)/=(τ )| < 1 we have X
1
f,g
20,c (τ, x) =
1 − e2πihf,xi − +
hξ,f i=0 hf,gi≤hξ,gi<0
X
1 1 − e2πihg,xi X ξ ·f >0>ξ ·g
q hξ,ξ i/2 e2π ihξ,xi
hξ,gi=0 hf,gi≤hξ,f i<0
q hξ,ξ i/2 e2π ihξ,xi
q hξ,ξ i/2 e2π ihξ,xi − e−2π ihξ,xi .
112
L. Göttsche
Here the sum is taken over all ξ ∈ 0 + c/2. For b, c ∈ 0 and any characteristic vector w of 0 we have f,g
f,g
(20,c /θ σ (0) )|S(τ, x + b/2) = (20,b /θ σ (0) )(τ, x + c/2), f,g
f,g
20,c (τ + 1, x) = (−1)3hc,ci/4−hc,wi/2 20,c (τ, x + (w − c)/2), f,g 20,c (τ
hc,ci/2
+ 2, x) = (−1)
(2.16)
f,g 20,c (τ, x).
The last two formulas are elementary consequences of Definition (2.13), which also hold for f, g ∈ C0 ∪ S0 . 2.5. Hilbert schemes. For a general algebraic surface S, we denote by S [n] the Hilbert scheme of subschemes of length n on S. S [n] is smooth of dimension 2n [F], and its Hodge numbers have been computed ([E-S,Gö1,G-S,Ch,dC-M]). Using (2.5), the results can be easily translated to X
Xy (S [n] )q n−e(S)/24 =
n≥0
η(τ )σ (S)−χ (OS ) . θ˜1,1 (τ, z)χ (OS )
(2.17)
(Recall that we write y := e2πiz .) In particular X n≥0
e(S [n] )q n−e(S)/24 =
X 1 η(τ )σ (S) [n] n n−e(S)/24 , σ (S )(−1) q = . η(τ )e(S) η(2τ )2χ (OS ) n≥0
3. Relation to Locally Free Sheaves and Blowup Formulas In this section let S be an arbitrary smooth projective surface, and let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z). Let b S be the blowup of S in a point and E the exceptional divisor. Let H be a general ample divisor on S (general means that it does not lie on a wall with respect to (r, C), see [Y3]; in the case r = 2 we will discuss walls and chambers in the next section). We will usually denote the cohomology classes on S and their pullbacks to b S by the same letter. H (r, C +bE, d) the space of slope stable sheaves on b S which are stable We denote by Mb s S
H −E (r, C + bE, d)s for with respect to (the pullback of) H . It can be identified with Mb S > 0 small enough. We want to relate the virtual Poincaré polynomials of MSH (r, C, d)s , NSH (r, C, d) and H (r, C + bE, d)s . In fact we will see that the generating function for b S is obtained Mb S from that for S by multiplying by a suitable theta function and dividing by a power of the eta function. The results are easy consequences of corresponding results of Yoshioka about the counting of points of these moduli spaces over finite fields and of Prop. 2.1. We write
Pv (MSH (r, C, d)s ) = y −e pv (MSH (r, C, d)s , y), Pv (NSH (r, C, d)) = y −e pv (NSH (r, C, d), y),
where e = 2rd − (r 2 − 1)χ(OS ) is the virtual dimension, which agrees with the actual dimension for d sufficiently large.
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
113
Proposition 3.1. Let S be an algebraic surface and let H be a general ample divisor on S. 1. X d≥0
r Y 4 YY i+1 Pv (MSH (r, C, d)s )q d = (1 − y i−2b q k )(−1) bi (S) k≥1 b=1 i=0
X Pv (NSH (r, C, d))q d , d≥0
in particular X d≥0
re(S)/24 X q e(MSH (r, C, d)s )q d = e(NSH (r, C, d))q d . η(τ )re(S) d≥0
2. Let A = (aij )ij be the (r − 1) × (r − 1)-matrix with entries aij = 1 for i ≤ j and aij = 0 otherwise. We view elements of Rr−1 as column vectors. We write I for the column vector of length r − 1 with all entries equal to one. Then r/24 X X q t t H Pv (Mb (r, C + bE, d)s )q d = (y 2 )v AI q v Av r S η(τ ) b d≥0
v∈Zr−1 + r I
X Pv (MSH (r, C, d)s )q d , d≥0
in particular X d≥0
H e(Mb (r, C + bE, d)s )q d = S
q r/24 η(τ )r
X
qv
t Av
v∈Zr−1 + br I
X
d≥0
e(MSH (r, C + bE, d)s )q d .
Proof. (1) is a consequence of ([Y1], Thm. 0.4) and Prop. 2.1. Let X be a surface over Fq . For every sheaf E in MXH (r, C, d)s (Fq ) there is an exact sequence 0 → E → E ∨∨ → E ∨∨ /E → 0, where E ∨∨ ∈ NSH (r, C, d − k)s (Fq ) and E ∨∨ /E ∈ QuotkE ∨∨ (Fq ) for a suitable k ≤ d. In fact it is easy to see that if E is defined over Fq , then it is defined over Fq if and only if both E ∨∨ and E ∨∨ /E are. For a sheaf F over X we denote by QuotkF the (Grothendieck) scheme of quotients of length k of F and by QuotkF,p the subscheme (with the reduced structure) of quotients with support in the point p ∈ X. If F is locally free of rank r and p is defined over Fq , we get isomorphisms QuotkF,p ' QuotkO⊕r ,p over Fq . In X
particular #QuotkF,p (Fq ) = #QuotkO⊕r ,p (Fq ). Therefore the proof of ([Y1], Thm. 0.4) for X
114
L. Göttsche
the numbers #QuotkO⊕r (Fq ) can be repeated for #QuotkF (Fq ), the only numbers entering X
the calculation being the #QuotkF,p (Fq n ). Therefore #QuotkF (Fq ) = #QuotkO⊕r (Fq ) (see X
also Y1, p.194). This gives #MXH (r, C, d)s (Fq ) =
X
#NXH (r, C, d − k)s (Fq ) · #QuotkO⊕r (Fq ). X
k≤d
Applying Prop. 2.1 to a good reduction X of S modulo q, we obtain immediately XX pv (MSH (r, C, d)s )q d d≥0 d≥0
r Y 4 YY X i+1 = (1 − y 2rk+i−2b q k )(−1) bi (S) pv (NSH (r, C, d))q d , k≥1 b=1 i=0
d≥0
(recall the signs in the definition of pv ). By the definition of Pv and the formula e = 2rd − (r 2 − 1)χ(OS ), we see that in order to replace pv by Pv we have to replace the factor (1 − y 2rk+i−2b q k ) by (1 − y i−2b q k ). (2) We apply Prop. 2.1 to ([Y3], Prop. 3.4). Using again e = 2rd − (r 2 − 1)χ (OS ) we obtain X H Pv (Mb (r, C + bE, d)s )q d S d≥0
P X q r/24 X = (y 2 )w(a1 ,... ,ar ) q − i<j ai aj Pv (MSH (r, C, d)s )q d . η(τ )r d≥0
(a1 ,... ,ar )
P Here the sum runs through the r-tuples (a1 , . . . , ar ) in Z + br with ri=1 ai = 0, and X X aj − ai +r ai aj . w(a1 , . . . , ar ) = 2 i<j ≤r
i<j ≤r
We note that equivalently we can let the sum run through the (r−1)-tuples (a1 , . . . , ar−1 ), P and put ar = − r−1 i=1 ai . Then X X ai aj = ai aj . − i<j ≤r
Furthermore we have
X
(aj − ai )2 = 2r
i<j ≤r
and
X
j ≤i≤r−1
X
ai aj
j ≤i≤r−1
! r−1 X (aj − ai ) = −2 (r − i)ai .
i<j ≤r
i=1
Putting things together, we obtain w(a1 , . . . , ar ) =
r−1 X (r − i)ai = (a1 , . . . , ar−1 )AI. i=1
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
Finally we note that X
115
ai aj = (a1 , . . . , ar−1 )A(a1 , . . . , ar−1 )t .
t u
j ≤i≤r−1
Remark 3.2. 1. Li and Qin ([L-Q1,L-Q2]) have shown a blowup formula for the virtual Hodge polynomials in the case r = 2 using completely different methods. In particular they also obtain a blowup formula for the Euler numbers. Their method also gives a blowup formula for the virtual Hodge polynomials of the Uhlenbeck compactification. We write again Hv (MSH (r, C, d)s ) = (xy)−e/2 hv (MSH (r, C, d)s ) with e = 2rd − (r 2 − 1)χ(OS ). Then, writing x = e2π iu , their result can be rewritten as 1/12 X X q θ0,0 (2τ, u + z) H Hv (Mb (C, d)s )q d = Hv (MSH (C, d)s )q d , S η(τ )2 d≥0 d≥0 1/12 X X q θ1,0 (2τ, u + z) H Hv (Mb (C + E, d)s )q d = Hv (MSH (C, d)s )q d . S η(τ )2 d≥0
d≥0
This is the case r = 2 of the formula X H Hv (Mb (r, C + bE, d)s )q d S d≥0
=
q r/24 η(τ )r
X
v t AI
(xy)
v∈Zr−1 + br I
q
v t Av
X Hv (MSH (r, C, d)s )q d . d≥0
I expect that this formula holds for all r. P 2. Using [Y5], Prop. 3.1(2) can also be rewritten: Let Ar−1 = (x1 , . . . , xr ) i xi = P 0 be the Ar−1 -lattice and e1 , . . . , er−1 its standard basis. Let a := r−1 i=1 i(r − i)ei and λ = (1 − 1/r, −1/r, . . . , −1/r). Then the theta function on the left hand side in Prop. 3.1 can be written as X y hv,ai q hv,vi/2 , v∈Ar−1 +bλ
where h , i is the pairing of Ar−1 . This was pointed out to me by K. Yoshioka. 4. Wallcrossing and Theta Functions 4.1. Wallcrossing. Now let S again be a rational algebraic surface. Let 0 be the lattice H 2 (S, Z) with the negative of the intersection form as a quadratic form, i.e. for A, B ∈ 0 let hA, Bi = −AB. In this section we want to relate the Hodge numbers of the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) to the theta functions 2F,H 0,C from [G-Z]. The dependence of the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) on the polarization H and the corresponding dependence of the Donaldson invariants has been studied by a number of authors [Q1,Q2,F-Q,Gö2, E-G,Y2,Y3,L]. We follow (with some modifications) the notations in [Gö2,E-G].
116
L. Göttsche
An ample divisor H is called good if KS · H ≤ 0. We denote by CS the ample cone of S and by CSG the subcone of all good ample divisors. A class ξ ∈ H 2 (X, Z) + C/2 is called of type (C, d) if ξ 2 + d ∈ Z≥0 . In this case we call W ξ := ξ ⊥ ∩ CS the wall defined by ξ . If ξ ⊥ ∩ CSG 6 = ∅, we call W ξ a good wall. The chambers of type (C, d) are the connected components of the complement of the walls of type (C, d) in CS . If L and H lie in the same chamber of type (C, d), then MSL (C, d) = MSH (C, d). We say that L lies on a wall of type C, if Lξ = 0 for some class ξ ∈ H 2 (X, Z) + C/2. Theorem 4.1. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z). Let H, L ∈ CSG not on a wall of type C. Then 1.
X d≥0
Xyv (MSH (C, d)) − Xyv (MSL (C, d)) q d−e(S)/12
η(τ )2σ (S)−2 (y 2 − y − 2 ) L,H = 20,C (2τ, KS z), θ1,1 (τ, z)2 X (e(MSH (Cd)) − e(M L (C, d)))q d−e(S)/12 1
d≥0
=
1
1 Coeff2πiz 2L,H 0,C (2τ, KS z) . η(τ )2e(S)
2. Assume now that C 6 ∈ 2H 2 (S, Z). Then we can replace Xyv by Xy in (1). Furthermore X (e(NSH (C, d)) − e(NSL (C, d)))q d = Coeff2π iz 2L,H 0,C (2τ, KS z) d≥0
X d≥0
=
(−1)e(d)/2 (σ (MSH (C, d)) − σ (MSL (C, d)))q d−e(S)/12
η(τ )2σ (S) L,H 2 (2τ, KS /2). 2iη(2τ )4 0,C
Here e(d) := 4d − 3 is the dimension of MSH (C, d). Proof. This is essentially a reformulation of Thm. 3.4 from [Gö2]. Assume that H and L do not lie on a wall of type C. The result of [Gö2] gives y 2d−3/2 (Xyv (MSH (C, d)) − Xyv (MSL (C, d))) = ξ KS − y −ξ KS X 2 2 2y y d+ξ Xy ((S t S)[d+ξ ] )y d−ξ , = y(y − 1) ξ
where the sum runs through all classes of type (C, d) with ξ H < 0 < ξ L. We sum over P P [n] n 2 . all d ≥ 0. We use (2.17), noting that n≥0 Xy ((S t S)[n] )q n = n≥0 Xy (S )q We obtain X Xyv (MSH (C, d)) − Xyv (MSL (C, d)) q d−e(S)/12 = d≥0
η(τ )2σ (S)−2 X −ξ 2 y ξ KS − y −ξ KS q = . 1 1 θ˜1,1 (τ, z)2 y 2 − y− 2 ξ
(4.1)
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
117
The sum on the right-hand side runs through all ξ ∈ H 2 (X, Z) + C/2 satisfying ξ H < g,f 0 < ξ L. Using the definition (2.13) of the theta functions 20,c , we obtain. X θ1,1 (τ, z)2 Xyv (MSH (C, d)) − Xyv (MSL (C, d)) q d−e(S)/12 1 − 21 2σ (S)−2 2 η(τ ) (y − y ) d≥0 X 2 q −ξ y ξ KS − y −ξ KS = ξ ∈H 2 (S,Z)+C/2 ξ H <0<ξ L
X
=
q hξ,ξ i y hξ,KS i − y −hξ,KS i
ξ ∈0+C/2 hξ,H i<0
=
X
q hξ,ξ i (µ(hξ, Li) − µ(hξ, H i))y hξ,KS i
ξ ∈0+C/2
= 2L,H 0,C (2τ, KS z). Specializing (4.1) to the Euler number we obtain: X d≥0
e(MSH (C, d)) − e(MSL (C, d)) q d−e(S)/12 = 1 = η(τ )2e(S)
X
X
1 2 2ξ KS q −ξ η(τ )2e(S) H ξ <0
2hξ, KS iq hξ,ξ i
hH,ξ i<0
1 Coeff2πiz (2L,H 0,C (2τ, KS z)). η(τ )2e(S) The last line follows directly from (2.13). Assume now that C 6 ∈ 2H 2 (S, Z). Then MSH (C, d) = MSH (C, d)s and MSL (C, d) = L MS (C, d)s are smooth, and we can replace Xyv (MSH (C, d)) by Xy (MSH (C, d)) and Xyv (MSL (C, d)) by Xy (MSL (C, d)). Furthermore we get by Prop. 3.1, X (e(NSH (C, d)) − e(NSL (C, d)))q d = Coeff2π iz 2L,H 0,C (2τ, KS z) . =
d≥0
Finally we obtain from (4.1), X (−1)−e(d)/2 (σ (MSH (C, d)) − σ (MSL (C, d)))q d−e(S)/12 d≥0
ξ KS − (−1)−ξ KS η(τ )2σ (S) X (−1) 2 = q −ξ η(2τ )4 (−1)1/2 − (−1)−1/2 ξ H <0<ξ L X η(τ )2σ (S) q hξ,ξ i (−1)hξ,KS i − (−1)−hξ,KS i = 2iη(2τ )4 hξ,H i<0
=
η(τ )2σ (S) 2iη(2τ )4
2L,H 0,C (2τ, KS /2).
118
L. Göttsche
As the signature can only be nonzero if e(d) is even, we can replace (−1)−e(d)/2 by (−1)e(d)/2 . u t 4.2. Extension of the invariants. A class F ∈ H 2 (X, Z) is called nef if its intersection with every effective curve is nonnegative. The real cone C S,R of nef classes is the closure of the ample cone. Let δ(CS ) be the set of primitive classes in (C S,R \ CS,R ) ∩ H 2 (S, Z), and put C S := CS ∪ δ(CS ). Let SS := F ∈ δ(CS ) F 2 = 0 . An upper index G will indicate that we allow only classes H with H KS ≤ 0. We now extend the generating functions for the χy -genera, Euler numbers and signatures of the MSH (C, d) to the whole of C S . Definition 4.2. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z). 1. Let F ∈ δ(CSG ), and assume that CF is odd. Then, for each d, the class F lies in the closure of a unique chamber α ⊂ CSG of type (C, d). We put MSF (C, d) := MSH (C, d) for H ∈ α. 2. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z), and let H ∈ CSG , not lying on a wall of type C. Let F ∈ C S . If F ∈ δ(CS ), we assume that KS F 6 = 0 or F C is odd. We put X Xyv (MSH (C, d))q d−e(S)/12 XS,F C := d≥0
η(τ )2σ (S)−2 (y 2 − y − 2 ) . θ1,1 (τ, z)2 1
+ 2H,F 0,C (2τ, KS z)
1
If C 6 ∈ 2H 2 (S, Z) we can replace Xyv (MSH (C, d)) by Xy (MSH (C, d)). We also put (ES,F C )0 := ES,F C :=
X
e(NSH (C, d))q d + Coeff2π iz 2H,F 0,C (2τ, KS z) ,
d≥0 (ES,F C )0 . η(τ )2e(S)
Finally we put 6CS,F = 0 if C 2 ≡ 0 modulo 2, and otherwise 6CS,F :=
X η(τ )2σ (S) H,F (−1)e(d)/2 σ (MSH (C, d))q d−e(S)/12 + 2 (2τ, KS /2). 2iη(2τ )4 0,C d≥0
The cocycle condition G,H F,H 2F,G 0,C + 20,C = 20,C (Rem. 3.4 from [G-Z])
(4.2)
S,F S,F S,F are indeand Thm. 4.1 imply that the definitions of XS,F C , (EC )0 , EC and 6C pendent of H .
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
119
Remark 4.3. The definitions above are motivated as follows. Denote by XSF (C, d), S,F S,F ESF (C, d) and SSF (C, d) the coefficients of q d−e(S)/12 in XS,F C , EC and 6C . Then 1. If F ∈ CSG does not lie on a wall of type (C, d), then by Thm. 4.1 XSF (C, d) = Xy (MSF (C, d)), ESF (C, d) = e(MSF (C, d)) and SSF (C, d) = (−1)e(d)/2 σ (MSF (C, d)). If C ≡ 0 modulo 2, then the moduli space MSF (C, d) will sometimes be singular. We defined σ (MSF (C, d)) := 0, which is reasonable, as MSF (C, d) has odd complex dimension. 2. If L ∈ CS fulfills KS L > 0, then MSL (C, d) is not necessarily smooth, and the wallcrossing formulas of Thm. 4.1 need not be true. We extend the generating function by formally requiring that Thm. 4.1 holds. We have seen above that this gives a consistent definition of the generating functions. I believe that there exists a geometric definition of the Xy (MSL (C, d)) given by this generating function. 3. If F ∈ CS lies on a finite number of walls of type (C, d), then XSF (C, d) is the average of the Xy (MSG (C, d)) over all the chambers of type (C, d) which contain F in their closure (and similarly for ESF (C, d) and SSF (C, d)). 4. If F ∈ SS and CF is even, then F usually lies on infinitely many walls of type (C, d) and in the closure of infinitely many chambers. We can view XSF (C, d) as a renormalized average over all these chambers. Note that in this case XSF (C, d) need not be a Laurent polynomial in y and ESF (C, d), and SSF (C, d) need not be integers. Remark 4.4. Note that we did not define XS,F C for F ∈ SS in case KS F = 0 and F C H,F even. The point is that in this case 20,C (2τ, KS z) is not well-defined: 2H,F 0,C (2τ, ·) has a pole along F ⊥ . If S is the blowup of P2 in 9 points and F = −KS , it is easy to see that H (MSL (C, d)) is constant for L near F , and one can therefore define Xy (MSF (C, d)) := Xy (MSL (C, d)). This case has been studied byYoshioka [Y4] in order to check predictions from [M-N-V-W]. S,F In the future, whenever we deal with XS,F C , EC for F ∈ SS , we implicitly assume that KS F 6 = 0 or CF is odd. Corollary 4.5. Let F , G in C S , then η(τ )2σ (S)−2 G,F 2 (2τ, KS z), θ1,1 (τ, z)2 0,C S,G G,F (ES,F C )0 − (EC )0 = Coeff2πiz 20,C (2τ, KS z) , 1 S,G Coeff2π iz 2G,F ES,F C − EC = 0,C (2τ, KS z) , 2e(S) η(τ ) η(τ )2σ (S) G,F 2 (2τ, KS /2). 6CS,F − 6CS,G = 2iη(2τ )4 0,C S,G −2 2 ) XS,F C − XC = (y − y 1
1
Proof. This is straightforward from Thm. 4.1, Def. 4.2 and the cocycle condition (4.2). t u 4.3. Birational properties. Let b S be the blowup of S in a point, and let E be the excepS, Z). tional divisor. We identify H 2 (S, Z) with E ⊥ ⊂ H 2 (b
120
L. Göttsche
Corollary 4.6 (Blowup formulas). Assume C 6 ∈ 2H 2 (S, Z), then for all F ∈ C S we have θ0,0 (2τ, z) S,F θ1,0 (2τ, z) S,F b XC , XS,F XC . C+E = η(τ )2 η(τ )2 1 b b S,F 6 S,F , 6C+E = 0. 2. 6CS,F = η(2τ ) C 3. If F ∈ CS or F ∈ δ(CS ) and F C is odd, then b
1. XS,F C =
b
ES,F C =
0 (2τ ) θ1,0 θ(2τ ) S,F b S,F E , E = ES,F . C+E C η(τ )2 η(τ )2 C
Proof. If C 6 ∈ 2H 2 (S, Z) and F ∈ CSG does not lie on a wall of type (C), or if F ∈ F (C, d) and δ(CSG ), and CF is odd, then by [Be] all the cohomology of MSF (C, d), Mb S F (C + E, d) is of type (p, p). Therefore in this case the result follows from the of Mb S blowup formulas from [L-Q1,L-Q2]. Alternatively one can use Prop. 3.1. In order to check the result for general F , we have to check that the blowup formula is compatible 0 := H 2 (b S, Z) with the negative of the with our extension. Let 0 := H 2 (S, Z) and b intersection forms. By definition the compatibility of XS,F C with the blowup formulas amounts to the easy formulas G,F G,F (τ, Kb 2b S z) = θ0,0 (τ, z)20,C (τ, KS z), 0 ,C G,F G,F (τ, Kb 2b S z) = θ1,0 (τ, z)20,C (τ, KS z). 0 ,C+E
The result for the signatures follows by 0 (2τ ) θ0,1 1 θ0,0 (2τ, 1) , θ1,0 (2τ, 1) = θ1,1 (τ, 0) = 0. = = η(τ )2 η(τ )2 η(2τ )
t u
Immediately from (2) we get: Corollary 4.7. Assume that π : S → X is the blowup of a rational surface X in finitely G many points. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z) \ π ∗ (H 2 (X, Z)). Let F ∈ π ∗ (C X ) not on a wall of type G )), assume that CF is odd. Then σ (M F (C, d)) = 0. (C, d). If F ∈ π ∗ (δ(CX S S,G Corollary 4.5 expresses the differences XS,F C − XC in terms of the theta functions 2 2F,G 0,C . We now want to show that in case C 6 ∈ H (S, Z) we can for suitable G also
S,F express XS,F and 6CS,F in terms of 2F,G C , EC 0,C . We use the following easy fact (see e.g.[Q1,H-L]).
Lemma 4.8. Let π : X → P1 a rational ruled surface. Let S be obtained from X by successively blowing up a number of points. Let G be pullback of the class of a fibre of π. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z) with CG odd. Then MSG (C, d) = ∅ for all d. S of S Proposition 4.9. Let F ∈ C S . Assume C 6 ∈ 2H 2 (S, Z). There exists a blowup e S,G G such that Xe = 0. Let E , . . . , E be the classes of the in n points and a G ∈ Se 1 n C S
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
121
exceptional divisors, and write e 0 := 0 ⊕ hE1 , . . . , En i. Then η(τ )2σ (S)−2 2G,F (2τ, Ke S z), 0 ,C θ1,1 (τ, z)2 θ0,0 (2τ, z)n e G,F Coeff2πiz 2e (2τ, Ke S z) 0 ,C = , η(τ )2e(S) θ(2τ )n
XS,F C = ES,F C 6CS,F
G,F (2τ, Ke η(τ )2σ (S) 2e S /2) 0 ,C = . 0 (2τ )n 2iη(2τ )4 θ0,1
Proof. Any rational surface S can be blown up in such a way that e S is a blowup of a ruled surface X, and CG is odd for G the pullback of the fibre. Then by Lem. 4.8 MSG (C, d) = ∅ e
= 0. The formulas are then a straightforward application for all d, and therefore XS,G C of Thm. 4.1 and the blowup formula Cor. 4.6. u t is invariant under deformations of the triple (S, H, C). Corollary 4.10. XS,H C Let p1 , p2 , p3 be three non-collinear points in P2 . Let L1 , L2 , L3 be the lines through pairs of the pi with pi , pj ∈ Lk for distinct indices i, j, k. Let X be the blowup of P2 in p1 , p2 , p3 , let E1 , E2 , E3 be the exceptional divisors and E 1 , E 2 , E 3 the strict transforms of L1 , L2 , L3 . They can be blown down to points p1 , p2 , p3 to obtain another projective plane P2 . Let H and H be the hyperplane classes on P2 and P2 . Let S be the blowup of X in additional points p4 , . . . , pr with exceptional divisors E4 , . . . , Er . We denote the pullbacks of H and H by the same letters. Then H = 2H − E1 − E2 − E3 , E i = H − Ej − Ej for i, j, k distinct in {1, 2, 3}. We can view S both as a blowup of P2 in p1 , . . . , pr and as a blowup of P2 in p1 , p2 , p3 , p4 , . . . , pr . The P change of viewpoint amounts to a Cremona transform on H 2 (S, Z) sending dH − ri=1 ai Ei to (2d − a1 − a2 − a3 )H − (d − a2 − a3 )E1 − (d − a1 − a3 )E2 − (d − a1 − a2 )E3 −
r X
ai Ei .
i=4
This shows: Corollary 4.11. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, Z) and F ∈ C S . Let G be the group generated by the Cremona transforms and the permutations of E1 , . . . , Er . Then for all g ∈ G we have S,g(F ) = Xg(C) , and, if F ∈ CS , or F ∈ δ(CSG ) with F C odd, then MSF (C, d) = XS,F C g(F )
MS
(g(C), d) for all d.
5. Transformation Properties on the Boundary Vafa and Witten [V-W] made predictions for the modular behaviour of generating functions of the Euler numbers of moduli spaces of sheaves on algebraic surfaces. Up to eventual quasimodularity their generating function ZC (which can be essentially identified with EF,S C ) should fulfill the equations τ −e(S)/2 X S (−1)DC ZD . (5.1) ZCS (τ + 1) = ZCS ; ZCS (−1/τ ) = ±2−b2 (S)/2 i D
122
L. Göttsche
Here is a root of unity, and D runs through a system of representatives of H 2 (S, Z) modulo 2H 2 (S, Z). We want to show that for F ∈ SS a similar transformation behaviour holds for XS,F C . Formulas similar to those of (5.1) for the Euler numbers then follow as a corollary. In addition we also get the modular behaviour for the signatures. For the purpose of this section we will for F ∈ C S define := XS,F 0
η(τ )2 η(τ )2 b b S,F ES,F , := 0 XS,F E , E0 θ1,0 (2τ, z) θ1,0 (2τ ) E
where b S is the blowup of S in a point, and E is the class of the exceptional divisor, i.e. we formally use the blowup formulas Cor. 4.6 (which do not apply). This is similar to the approach for the Donaldson invariants. We put for any H ∈ CS XF,S C , y 1/2 − y −1/2 KS2 G2 (τ ) (τ ) − Coeff(2π iz)−1 2H,F FCS,F (τ ) := ES,F C 0,C (2τ, KS z). 2η(τ )2e(S)
YCS,F (τ, z) :=
H,F Note that in case CF is odd we just have FCS,F (τ ) := ES,F C (τ ), because 20,C (2τ, KS z)
is holomorphic at z = 0. By the cocycle condition (4.2) FCS,F (z) is independent of H . Theorem 5.1. For all C ∈ H 2 (S, Z) and all F ∈ SS with F KS 6= 0 we have 1. YCS,F transforms according to the rules YCS,F (τ + 1, z) = (−1)−e(S)/6−C /2 YCS,F (τ, z), r −b2 (S) 2τ S,F exp(−π i(KS2 /2 + 2)z2 /τ ) YC (−1/τ, z/τ ) = −i i X (−1)CD Y S,F (τ, z) . · 2
D∈H 2 (S,Z)/2H 2 (S,Z)
D
2. FCS,F transforms according to FCS,F (τ + 1) = (−1)−e(S)/6−C /2 FCS,F (τ ), r −e(S) X τ S,F 2−b2 (S)/2 FC (−1/τ ) = − i 2 2
D∈H (S,Z)/2H 2 (S,Z)
3. Assume C 2 is odd. Then
(−1)CD FDS,F (τ ).
η(τ )2 6 S,F is a modular function on 0(2). η(2τ )σ (S) C
Remark 5.2. By the fact that G2 (τ ) + 1/(8π=(τ )) transforms like a modular form of weight 2, we could also define FCS,F (τ ) := ES,F C (τ ) +
KS2 Coeff(2π iz)−1 2H,F 0,C (2τ, KS z), 16π =(τ )η(τ )2e(S)
and get the same transformation behaviour in 2.
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
123
Proof. (1) Let F, G ∈ SS . We first want to show that (1) holds if we replace YCS,F and YDS,F by YCS,F − YCS,G and YDS,F − YDS,G . By Cor. 4.5 we have YCS,F − YCS,G =
η(τ )2σ (S)−2 G,F 2 (2τ, KS z). θ1,1 (τ, z)2 0,C
By (2.2) and (2.6), we know that 2σ (S)−2 η(τ + 1)2σ (S)−2 −e(S)/6 η(τ ) = (−1) , θ1,1 (τ + 1, z)2 θ1,1 (τ, z)2 τ −b2 (S) η(τ )2σ (S)−2 η(−1/τ )2σ (S)−2 2 = − e−2π iz /τ . 2 θ1,1 (−1/τ, z/τ ) i θ1,1 (τ, z)2
Furthermore, putting T (τ, z) := 2G,F 0,C (2τ, KS z) we get by (2.16), T (τ + 1, z) = (−1)−C T (−1/τ, z/τ ) =
2 /2
T (τ, z),
2G,F 0,C (−2/τ, KS z/τ ) r b2 (S) τ 2i
=i
exp(−πiKS2 z2 /2τ )2G,F 0 (τ/2, KS z/2 + C/2).
Putting this together, we obtain r = −i
2τ i
−b2 (S)
(YCS,F − YCS,G )(−1/τ, z/τ ) = exp(−πi(KS2 /2 + 2)z2 /τ )2G,F 0 (τ/2, KS z/2 + C/2).
Finally we have 2G,F 0 (τ/2, KS z/2 + C/2) = X = (−1)DC D
X
X (µ(hξ, Gi) − µ(hξ, F i))q hξ,ξ i/4 (−1)Cξ y hKS ,ξ i/2 ξ ∈0
(µ(hξ, Gi) − µ(hξ, F i))q hξ,ξ i y hKS ,ξ i
ξ ∈0+D/2
X = (−1)DC 2G,F 0,D (2τ, KS z).
(5.2)
D
This shows (1) for YCS,F − YCS,G . It is therefore enough to show (1) YCS,F for all S, C and S → S be the blowup in a point with exceptional divisor one particular F ∈ SS . Let : b E. By the blowup formulas Cor. 4.6 and the definition of XS,F we get 0 b
YCS,F (τ, z) =
θ0,0 (2τ, z) S,F θ1,0 (2τ, z) S,F b S,F YC (τ, z), YC+E (τ, z) = YC (τ, z), 2 η(τ ) η(τ )2
and therefore θ0,0 (2τ, z) S,F YC (τ + 1, z), η(τ )2 θ1,0 (2τ, z) S,F b S,F (τ + 1, z) = (−1)1/2−1/6 YC (τ + 1, z). YC+E η(τ )2 b
YCS,F (τ + 1, z) = (−1)−1/6
124
L. Göttsche
By the transformation behaviour of θ0,0 , θ1,0 (see [C, Sect. V.8.]) and η we also see r θ0,0 (τ/2, z/2) S,F i b S,F exp ((πi/2)z2 /τ ) YC (−1/τ, z/τ ), YC (−1/τ, z/τ ) = 2τ η(τ )2 r θ0,1 (τ/2, z/2) S,F i b S,F exp ((πi/2)z2 /τ ) (−1/τ, z/τ ) = YC (−1/τ, z/τ ). YC+E 2τ η(τ )2 Using the elementary identities θ0,0 (τ/2, z/2) = θ0,0 (2τ, z) + θ1,0 (2τ, z), θ0,1 (τ/2, z/2) = θ0,0 (2τ, z) − θ1,0 (2τ, z) b
it follows that (1) holds for YCS,F for all C ∈ H 2 (S, Z) if and only if it holds for YCS,F for all C ∈ H 2 (b S, Z). As any two rational surfaces can be connected by a sequence of blowups and blow downs, it is enough to check the result for S = P1 × P1 and F the class of a fibre of the first projection. Let G be the class of a fibre of the second b projection. By Lem. 4.8 we have YGS,F = YFS,F +G = 0. Denote by P2 the blowup of P2 in 2 P2 , Z) be the class of a hyperplane. a point with exceptional divisor E1 . Let H ∈ H (b P2 be the blowup in a point with exceptional divisor E2 . There exists a Let σ : e P2 → b blowup : e P2 → P1 × P1 with exceptional divisor E such that σ ∗ (H − E1 ) = ∗ (F ) ∗ and E = (F ) − E2 . By Cor. 4.6 and our definition of Y0S,F we get that YFS,F =
η(τ )2 e b ,H −E1 P , ∗ (F ) = YHP2−E , Y ∗2 1 θ0,0 (2τ, z) (F )
Y0S,F =
η(τ )2 e b ,H −E1 P ,ε∗ (F ) YE 2 = YHP2−E . 1 θ1,0 (2τ, z)
By F 2 = G2 = 0, F G = 1, (1) follows. (2) By an argument that is very similar to that at the end of the proof of (1), it is enough to show the formula for the difference FCS,F − FCS,G , for F, G ∈ SS . The trans2 formation behaviour FCS,F (τ + 1) = (−1)−e(S)/6−C /2 FCS,F (τ ) follows immediately from the corresponding transformation behaviour of YCS,F . By the transformation behaviour of 2G,F 0,C (2τ, KS z), the transformation properties (2.1) of G2 and (5.2), we see that UC (τ, z) := exp(2π 2 KS2 G2 (τ )z2 )2G,F 0,C (2τ, KS z), transforms according to r
UC (−1/τ, z/τ ) = i
τ 2i
−b2 (S)
X
UD (τ, z).
D∈H 2 (S,Z)/2H 2 (S,Z)
By definition (FCS,F − FCS,G )(τ ) =
1 Coeff2π iz UC (τ, z), η(τ )2e(S)
and (2) follows. (3) Let b S be the blowup of S in a point. By the blowup formula Cor. 4.6, we see that the statements for (S, F, C) and (b S, F, C) are equivalent. Therefore, by Prop. 4.9, we can assume that there exists a G ∈ SSG such that XS,G C = 0 and 6CS,F (τ ) =
η(τ )2σ (S) G,F 2 (2τ, KS /2). 2iη(2τ )4 0,C
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
125
By [G-Z], Thm 3.13.1) the function τ 7 → G(τ ) =
θ(τ )σ (S) G,F 20,C (τ, C/2) f (τ )
is a modular function on 0u . Therefore, by Rem. 2.2, τ 7→ G(2τ + 1) is a modular function on 0(2). By (2.16), we have −3C 2G,F 0,C (2τ + 1, C/2) = (−1)
2 /4+CK /2 S
2G,F 0,C (2τ, KS /2),
and by Rem. 2.2 we see that η(τ )2σ (S)+2 θ(2τ + 1)σ (S) . = f (2τ + 1) η(2τ )σ (S)+4 The result follows. u t 6. The Signature and the Donaldson Invariants Let again S be a rational algebraic surface, let H ∈ CS , and let E be a differentiable complex vector bundle on S, with Chern classes (C, c2 ). Let d := c2 − C 2 /4 and e := 4d − 3. Let Ae (S) be the set of polynomials of weight e in H2 (S, Q) ⊕ H0 (S, Q), where a ∈ H2 (S, C) has weight 1, and the class p ∈ H0 (S, Z) of a point has weight 2. The Donaldson invariants corresponding to E, the Fubini-Study metric associated to H , and the homology orientation determined by the connected component of L ∈ H 2 (S, R) L2 > 0 containing H are a linear map 8S,H C,e : Ae (S) → Q. Let X M := 8S,H Ae (S) → Q. 8S,H C C,e : A∗ (S) := e≥0
e≥0
In [K-M] it is shown (more generally for simply connected 4-manifolds S with b+ = 1, where now H is the period point of a Riemannian metric on S), that 8S,H C,e depends
S,L only on the chamber of type (C, d) of H , and that 8S,H C,e − 8C,e can be expressed as S , for ξ running through the classes of type (C, d) with a sum of wallcrossing terms δξ,e S . ξ H < 0 < ξ L. Kotschick and Morgan make a conjecture about the structure of the δξ,e
S (x e ) is a polynomial in ξ x, x 2 whose coefficients depend Conjecture 6.1. [K-M] δξ,e 2 only on ξ , e and the homotopy type of S. S,L Using this conjecture the difference 8S,H C,e − 8C,e was in [Gö3] and [G-Z] expressed in terms of modular forms and theta functions. In a series of (in part forthcoming) papers [F-L1,F-L2,F-L3,F-L4] Feehan and Leness work towards a proof of Conjecture 6.1. In [F-L1] some necessary gluing results are proven. We will in this section assume Conjecture 6.1 and show that for any class H ∈ C S the generating function for the signatures σ (MSH (C, d)) is also (with respect to a different r development parameter) the generating function for the Donaldson invariants 8S,H C (p ), evaluated on the powers of the point class p. The reason for this result is that both Donaldson invariants and the signatures of the moduli spaces vanish in certain chambers, the chamber structures for Donaldson invariants and signatures are the same, and the wallcrossing terms for Donaldson invariants and signatures are related.
126
L. Göttsche
Theorem 6.2. Assume Conjecture 6.1. Let H ∈ C S . Then h 4η(τ )2 i S,H r (CKS +1)/2 (p ) = (−1) Coeff 6 8S,H . r+1 u(τ ) C η(2τ )σ (S) C Here Coeffu(τ )r+1 V (τ ) is the coefficient of u(τ )r+1 in the Laurent development of V (τ ) in powers of u(τ ). In particular, if H ∈ CSG does not lie on a wall of type C or F ∈ δ(CS ) with CF odd, then X (−1)e(d)/2 σ (MSH (C, d))q d−e(S)/12 = d≥0
= (−1)(CKS +1)/2
η(2τ )σ (S) 4η(τ )2
X
r≥0
r r+1 8S,H . C (p )u(τ )
Proof. We note that the result is trivially true if C 2 is even. We assume that C 2 is odd. Case 1: Assume that S is the blowup of a ruled surface and that CG is odd for G the pullback of the class of the fibre of the ruling. Then we get by Prop. 4.9, 6CS,H =
η(τ )2σ (S) G,H 2 (2τ, KS /2). 2iη(τ )4 0,C
On the other hand we get by [G-Z, Cor. 4.3] and Lem. 5.1, # " σ (S) 3 2 2θ (τ ) X,H G,H 20,C (τ, C/2) . 8C (pr ) = Coeffu(τ )r+1 (−1) 4 C f (τ ) We make the transformation τ → 2τ + 1. By (2.16) we get −3C 2G,H 0,C (2τ + 1, C/2) = (−1)
Using also Rem. 2.2, we get
2 /4+CK /2 S
2G,H 0,C (2τ, KS /2).
# 2η(τ )2σ (S)+2 H,G = (−1) Coeffu(τ )r+1 2 (2τ, KS /2) η(2τ )σ (S)+4 0,C h 4η(τ )2 i S,H 6 . = (−1)(CKS +1)/2 Coeffu(τ )r+1 C η(2τ )σ (S) This shows the first part. To show the second part, we need to see that the smallest power 4η(τ )2 6 S,H is u(τ ). We see that u(τ ) is of u(τ ) that occurs in the development of η(2τ )σ (S) C r 8S,H C (p )
"
CKS /2
1
q 2 multiplied with a power series in q. In case C 2 ≡ 1 modulo 4 it follows from the definition that 6CS,H is q −e(S)/12+3/4 multiplied with a power series in q. If C 2 ≡ 3 S (C, d) is only nonempty if the expected dimension 4d − 3 modulo 4, the fact that MH is nonnegative implies that 6CS,H is q −e(S)/12+5/4 multiplied with a power series in q. This shows the second part. General case: Let e S be the blowup of S in n points, so that Case 1 applies to e S. Then by the blowup formulas for the Donaldson invariants [F-S] and by Cor. 4.6, e
e
S,H S,H r r = 8S,H C (p ) = 8C (p ), 6C
The result follows. u t
1 6 S,H . η(2τ )n C
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
127
Corollary 6.3. If F ∈ SSG , CF is odd and σ (S) > −8, then σ (MSF (C, d)) = 0. Proof. This follows immediately from [G-Z, Cor. 5.5]. u t Remark 6.4. Theorem 6.2 and the results for the K3 surface suggest that there should be a general formula relating the Donaldson invariants and the signatures of the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) for all simply connected algebraic surfaces S even if pg (S) > 0. In general the moduli spaces MSH (C, d) will be very singular, and one first has to find a suitable definition of the signature. The simplest formula that fits the known data seems to be the following: X (−1)e(d)/2 σ (MSH (C, d))q d−e(S)/12 = d
χ (OS ) X η(2τ )σ (S) w(τ ) 8SC (p r )u(τ )r+1 , = ± (2η(τ ))2χ(OS ) r≥0 where w(τ ) = χ (OS ) χ (OS ) 1 2u(τ )+1 + 2u(τ )−1 , 2 1 2
2u(τ )
if 3χ(OS ) − C 2 ≡ 2 mod 4,
2u(τ )
1 + 2u(τ ))χ(OS ) − (−1)χ (OS ) (1 − 2u(τ ))χ (OS ) , if 3χ(OS ) − C 2 ≡ 0 mod 4.
The formula has the following features: 1. It gives the correct result for rational surfaces and for K3-surfaces. 2. It is compatible with the blow-up formulas of [F-S] for the Donaldson invariants and with those of Prop. 3.1 for the signatures. 3. It is compatible with taking the disjoint union of algebraic surfaces. The formula for the rational surfaces is just Thm. 6.2, and the compatibility with the blowup formulas is obvious. We check the formula for the K3 surfaces. We know by [G-H] that, for generic polarization H and suitable C ∈ H 2 (X, Z), the moduli space MXH (C, d) has the same Hodge numbers as X[2d−3] . Let L and M be two such classes in H 2 (X, Z), satisfying L2 ≡ 2 modulo 4 and M 2 ≡ 0 modulo 4. Using (2.17), this gives X (−1)e(d) (σ (MXH (L, d)) + σ (MXH (M, d))q d−2 = d≥0
=
X d≥0
(−1)n σ (S [n] )q (n−1)/2 =
1 . η(τ )4 η(τ/2)16
For the Donaldson invariants we have the following results: X fulfills the simple type 2 = (−1)C /2 for all C ∈ H 2 (S, Z) (see e.g. [Kr-M]). Therefore we condition and 8S,H C X,H 2r 2r 2r+1 ) = 22r+1 , i.e. get 8X,H L (p ) = −2 and 8M (p X r≥0
X,M r r r+1 (8X,H =− L (p ) + 8L (p ))u(τ )
η(2τ )8 u(τ ) =4 . 1 + 2u(τ ) η(τ/2)8
128
L. Göttsche
The last identity is an elementary exercise in modular forms (e.g. one multiplies both sides with a suitable modular form on 0(2) such that they both become modular forms on 0(2) and compares the first few coefficients). Putting this together, we obtain X (σ (MXH (L, d) − σ (MXH (M, d))q d−2 d≥0
2 η(2τ )σ (X) X X,H r X,H = (8 (p ) + 8M (pr ))u(τ )r+1 (4η(τ ))2χ(OX ) r≥0 L 2 X X,H η(2τ )σ (X) = (1 − 2u(τ ))2 8L (pr ) (4η(τ ))2χ(OX ) r≥0 2 X X,H η(2τ )σ (X) 2 r = (1 − 1/(2u(τ ))) 8M (p ) . (4η(τ ))2χ(OX ) r≥0
The result follows by collecting the odd powers of u(τ ) (for L) and the even powers of u(τ ) (for M). Remark 6.5. Note that u(τ ) is the modular function on 0(2) that occurs in a natural way in physics ([W], there it is called u). In [M-W] the Donaldson invariants of 4-manifolds with b+ = 1 were (using physics arguments) related to (Borcherds type [Bo]) integrals over the “u-plane” H/ 0(2). This suggests that also many results of this paper could be reformulated in terms of such integrals. For the Euler number we can prove a weaker statement along the same lines. We can relate the generating functions for the difference of the Euler numbers for two polarizations H, L to the difference of certain Donaldson invariants between H and L. Let kS be the Poincaré dual of KS . Proposition 6.6. Let H , L ∈ CS not on a wall of type 0. Then 6 X iη(2τ ) S,L S,L r r r+1 = 8S,H . ES,H 0 −E0 0 (kS p )−80 (kS p ) u(2τ ) 2θ(2τ )σ (S)+2 η(τ )e(S) r≥0
Proof. The proof is similar to the case of the signature. By Corollary 4.5 we have i h 1 S,L L,H − E = Coeff (2τ, K z) . 2 ES,H 2π iz S 0 0 0,0 η(τ )2e(S) i h As H, L ∈ CS , we see that Coeff2πiz 2L,H 0 (2τ, Ks z) starts in degree ≥ 1/2 in q. Using this, we get from [G-Z], Cor 4.3, X S,H r r+1 80 (kS pr ) − 8S,L 0 (kS p ) u(2τ ) r≥0
" = Coeff2πiz =
#
2θ(2τ )σ (S) H,L 20,0 (2τ, KS z) f (2τ )2
2iθ(2τ )σ (S)+2 η(τ )2e(S) S,L (E0 − ES,H 0 ). η(2τ )6
t u
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
129
Remark 6.7. This result can be reformulated as follows. The expression 6 X η(2τ ) r r+1 + 8S,H ES,H 0 0 (kS p )u(2τ ) 2iθ(2τ )σ (S)+2 η(τ )e(S) r≥0
is independent of H ∈ CS . 7. Examples 7.1. Rational ruled surfaces. Let S be a rational ruled surface. Let F be the class of a fibre of the ruling, and let G be a section with G2 ≤ 0. By Lem. 4.8 we know = 0 if CF = 1. We will compute XS,F that XS,F and ES,F C F F . Furthermore we set F+ F +G (F, d) for > 0 sufficiently small, so that there is no wall of MS (F, d) := MS type (F, d) between F and F + G. 1 1 y 2 − y − 2 η(τ ) S,F , Proposition 7.1. 1. XF = θ1,1 (τ, z)2 θ1,1 (τ, 2z) 1 1 X 1 y 2 − y− 2 1 η(τ )3 F Xy (MS + (F, d))q d− 3 = − , 2. η(τ )2 θ1,1 (τ, z)2 θ1,1 (τ, 2z) y − y −1 d≥0
3. ES,F F =
2G2 (τ ) + 1 2G2 (τ ) X F , e(MS + (F, d))q d− 3 = 8 η(τ ) η(τ )8
1 12
.
d≥0
Proof. Let F1 , F2 be the fibres of the two projections of P1 × P1 to P1 . By a sequence of blowups and blowdowns (S, F ) can be obtained from (P1 × P1 , F1 ), where in each blowup F is replaced by its total transform. By the blowup formula Cor. 4.6 we get = XPF11 ×P1 ,F1 . We can therefore assume that S = P1 × P1 and F = F1 , G = F2 . XS,F F
= 0 and By Cor. 4.8 we get XS,G F 1
XS,F F
1
y2 −y2 = 2G,F (2τ, −2F z − 2Gz). η(τ )2 θ1,1 (τ, z)2 0,F
By (2.15) we have 3 2G,F 0,F (2τ, x) = η(2τ )
=
θ1,1 (·, h(F − G), ·i) (2τ, x) θ1,1 (·, −hG, ·i)θ1,1 (·, hF, ·i) F /2
η(2τ )3 θ0,1 (2τ, h(F − G), xi) . θ0,1 (2τ, −hG, xi)θ1,1 (2τ, hF, xi)
Thus 2G,F 0,F (2τ, −2F z − 2Gz) = By (2.7) we get XS,F F
0 (2τ ) η(2τ )3 θ0,1
θ0,1 (2τ, 2z)θ1,1 (2τ, 2z)
1 1 y 2 − y − 2 η(τ ) = . θ1,1 (τ, z)2 θ1,1 (τ, 2z)
.
130
L. Göttsche +
To get the χy -genus of MSF (F, d), we note that X d≥0
y 2 − y− 2 +G (τ, −2F z − 2Gz) , lim 2G,F 0,F 2 2 η(τ ) θ1,1 (τ, z) →0 1
+
Xy (MSF (F, d)q d− 3 = 1
1
and by formula (3.9.1) from [G-Z], G,F +G (τ, −2F z − 2Gz) = 2G,F 0,F (τ, −2F z − 2Gz) − lim 20,F →0
1 . y − y −1
To finally obtain the formulas for the Euler numbers we use the formula 1 2 η(τ )3 = exp Gk (τ )(2π i)k , (see [Z1]), θ1,1 (τ, z) 2πiz k! and Coeff2πiz
1 1 t =− . u −1 y−y 12
7.2. The rational elliptic surface. Let m ∈ Z≥0 . Let S be the blowup of P2 in 4m + 5 P points, and assume that F := (m + 2)H − mE1 − 4m+5 i=2 Ei is nef, e.g. F is the fibre of a fibration of S over P1 , such that the genus of the generic fibre is m. Theorem 7.2. If m is odd, then θ1,1 (τ, mz) , θ1,1 (τ, z)e θ1,1 (τ/2, z)θ0,1 (τ, (m − 1)z)η(τ )η(τ/2)4m+3 m = , η(τ/2)4m+8
S,F 1. XS,F H + X E1 = S,F 2. ES,F H + EE1
S,F + 6ES,F = 3. 6H 1
1 . η(τ )2 η(τ/2)4m+4
If m is even, then θ1,1 (τ, mz) , e θ1,1 (τ, z)θ1,1 (τ/2, z)θ0,1 (τ, (m − 1)z)η(τ )η(τ/2)4m+3 m = , η(τ/2)4m+8
S,F 1. XS,F H +E2 + XE1 +E2 = S,F 2. ES,F H +E2 + EE1 +E2
S,F S,F 3. 6H +E2 = 6E1 +E2 = 0.
Proof. We mostly deal with the case m = 2l − 1 odd. The proof in the case m even is analogous. Let 0 = H 2 (S, Z) with the negative of the intersection form. Let G := H − E1 . Then by Lem. 4.8 and Cor. 4.5, y 2 − y− 2 G,E1 G,F (2τ, K z) + 2 (2τ, K z) . 2 S S 0,H 0,H η(τ )16l+2 θ1,1 (τ, z)2 1
S,F XS,F H + XE1 =
1
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
131
Let [G, F ] be the lattice generated by G and F , and let [G, F ]⊥ be its orthogonal complement in 0. We write 3 := [G, F ] ⊕ [G, F ]⊥ . By hF, F i = hG, Gi = 0, hF, Gi = −2, hE1 , F i = 1 − 2l, hE1 , Gi = −1, hE2 , F i = −1, hE2 , Gi = 0 we see that 3 has index 4 in 0, and that 0, E1 , E2 , E2 + E1 form a system of representatives of 0 modulo 3. Therefore we get by (2.15): G,F G,F |0 + |E1 + |E2 + |E1 +E2 |H /2 +E1 /2 2G,F 0,H + 20,E1 = 23 = 2G,F |0 + |E1 + |E2 + |E1 +E2 |0 + |G/2 |E1 . 3
P ai even . Then the map ϕ : D8l → [G, F ]⊥ Let D8l := (a1 , . . . , a8l ) ∈ Z8l 8l i=1 P defined by (a1 , . . . , a8l ) 7 → 8l i=1 ai (Ei+1 − G/2) is easily seen to be an isomorphism of lattices. It is well-known (and easy to check) that
Y 1 Y θ0,0 (τ, xi ) + θ0,1 (τ, xi ) . 2D8l (τ, (x1 , . . . , x8l )) = 2 8l
8l
i=1
i=1
So we get by (2.14),
η(2τ )3 θ1,1 (2τ, hF − G, xi) · θ1,1 (2τ, hF, xi)θ1,1 (2τ, h−G, xi) 8l+1 8l+1 Y 1 Y θ0,0 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) + θ0,1 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) . · 2
2G,F 3 (τ, x) =
i=2
i=2
If H (τ, x) is a function H × (0C ) → C satisfying H (τ, x) = θa,b (nτ, hL, xi)H1 (τ, x) for some L ∈ 0Q , then, for W ∈ 0,
H |W (τ, x) = θa+2hW,L/ni,b (nτ, hL, xi)H1 |W (τ, x).
We have hH, F i = −(2l + 1), hH, Gi = −1 and hH, Ei i = 0 for i ≥ 2; hE1 , F i = −(2l − 1), hE1 , Gi = −1 and hE1 , Ei i = 0 for i ≥ 2; hE2 , F i = −1, hE2 , Gi = 0 and hE2 , E2 i = 1, hE2 , Ei i = 0 for i ≥ 3. We also use repeatedly (2.8). Using this we obtain the following:
132
L. Göttsche
Put A(τ, x) :=
η(2τ )3 θ1,1 (2τ, hF − G, xi) , θ1,1 (2τ, hF, xi)θ1,1 (2τ, h−G, xi)
B(τ, x) :=
−η(2τ )3 θ1,1 (2τ, hF − G, xi) , θ0,1 (2τ, hF, xi)θ0,1 (2τ, h−G, xi)
C(τ, x) :=
η(2τ )3 θ0,1 (2τ, hF − G, xi) , θ1,1 (2τ, hF, xi)θ0,1 (2τ, h−G, xi)
η(2τ )3 θ0,1 (2τ, hF − G, xi) , θ0,1 (2τ, hF, xi)θ1,1 (2τ, h−G, xi) 8l+1 8l+1 Y 1 Y θ0,0 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) + θ0,1 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) , α(τ, x) := 2
D(τ, x) :=
β(τ, x) := γ (τ, x) := δ(τ, x) :=
i=2
i=2
8l+1 1 Y
8l+1 Y
2
θ1,0 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) +
i=2
i=2
8l+1 1 Y
8l+1 Y
2
θ0,0 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) −
i=2
i=2
8l+1 1 Y
8l+1 Y
2
θ1,0 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) −
i=2
θ1,1 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) , θ0,1 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) , θ1,1 (τ, hEi − G/2, xi) .
i=2
Then we get G,F 2G,F 3 |0 (τ, x) := A(τ, x)α(τ, x), 23 |E1 (τ, x) := B(τ, x)β(τ, x),
G,F 2G,F 3 |E2 (τ, x) := C(τ, x)γ (τ, x), 23 |E1 +E2 (τ, x) := D(τ, x)δ(τ, x),
G,F 2G,F 3 |G/2 (τ, x) := D(τ, x)α(τ, x), 23 |G/2+E1 (τ, x) := C(τ, x)β(τ, x),
G,F 2G,F 3 |G/2+E2 (τ, x) := B(τ, x)γ (τ, x), 23 |G/2+E1 +E2 (τ, x) := A(τ, x)δ(τ, x).
By hKS , Ei − G/2i = 0 and hE1 , Ei − G/2i = 1/2 for i ≥ 2, we see that 0 0 (τ ))8l + (θ1/2,1 (τ ))8l )/2, α|E1 /2 (τ, KS z) = ((θ1/2,0 0 0 (τ ))8l + (θ3/2,1 (τ ))8l )/2, β|E1 /2 (τ, KS z) = ((θ3/2,0 0 0 (τ ))8l − (θ1/2,1 (τ ))8l )/2, γ |E1 /2 (τ, KS z) = ((θ1/2,0 0 0 (τ ))8l − (θ3/2,1 (τ ))8l )/2. δ|E1 /2 (τ, KS z) = ((θ3/2,0
Now we note that by (2.8) and (2.9), 0 0 (τ ) = θ3/2,0 (τ ) = θ1/2,0
η(τ/2)2 0 0 , θ1/2,1 (τ ) = −θ3/2,1 (τ ). η(τ/4)
Putting things together, we get that G,F 2G,F 0,E1 (τ, KS z) + 20,H (τ, KS z) =
(A + B + C + D)|E1 /2 (τ, KS z) ·
η(τ/2)16l . η(τ/4)8l
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
133
The orthogonal projections of 0, E1 and E2 and E1 + E2 to [F, G] are a system of representatives of [F /2, G/2] modulo [F, G]. Therefore (A + B + C + D)(τ, x) = 2G,F [G/2,F /2] (τ, x) =
η(τ/2)3 θ1,1 (τ/2, hF /2 − G/2, xi) . θ1,1 (τ/2, hF /2, xi)θ1,1 (τ/2, h−G/2, xi)
Finally by hE1 , F i = 1 − 2l, hE1 , −Gi = 1, we get 2G,F [G/2,F /2] |E1 /2 (2τ, KS z) = − =
η(τ )3 θ1,1 (τ, hF /2 − G/2, KS iz) θ0,1 (τ, hF /2, KS iz)θ0,1 (τ, h−G/2, KS iz)
η(τ )3 θ1,1 (τ, (2l − 1)z) . θ0,1 (τ, (2 − 2l)z)θ0,1 (τ, z)
Putting this together, we obtain (y 2 − y − 2 )η(τ )3 θ1,1 (τ, (2l − 1)z) η(τ )16l = η(τ )16l+2 θ1,1 (τ, z)2 θ0,1 (τ, (2 − 2l)z)θ0,1 (τ, z) η(τ/2)8l θ1,1 (τ, (2l − 1)z) = . θ1,1 (τ, z)e θ1,1 (τ/2, z)θ0,1 (τ, (2 − 2l)z)η(τ )η(τ/2)8l−1 1
XS,F H
+ XS,F E1
1
S,F In the last line we have used (2.7). To get the formula for ES,F H + EE1 , take the limit θ1,1 (τ,(2l−1)z) |z=0 = 2l − 1 and e θ1,1 (τ/2, 0) = z → 0. It is immediate from (2.5) that θ1,1 (τ,z)
η(τ/2)3 . Therefore S,F ES,F H + EE1 =
2l − 1 2l − 1 = . 0 8l+4 8l+2 η(τ/2) η(τ )η(τ/2) θ0,1 (τ )
S,F + 6ES,F we put z = π i, to obtain To get the formula for 6H 1 S,F + 6ES,F = 6H 1
1 0 (τ/2)θ 0 (τ )η(τ )η(τ/2)8l−1 θ1,0 0,1
=
1 η(τ )2 η(τ/2)8l
.
In the case m = 2l even, we again have that 0, E1 , E2 , E1 + E2 form a system of representatives of 0 modulo 3. So we get G,F G,F |0 + |E1 + |E2 + |E1 +E2 |0 + |G/2 |E1 +E2 . 2G,F 0,H +E2 + 20,E1 +E2 = 23 Essentially the same computations as in the case m odd give the result. u t Let now S be the blowup of P2 in 9 points. Let H be the pullback of the hyperplane class, and let E1 , . . . , E9 be the classes of the exceptional divisors. Let F := 3H − P9 i=1 Ei . Then KS = −F . An interesting case is when S is a rational elliptic surface, and F is the class of a fibre. In [M-N-V-W] the generating functions of the Euler numbers e(MS (C, d)) are predicted in case CF is even. This prediction was proven in [Y4]. As an immediate consequence of Thm. 7.2 we can compute the Hodge numbers of the MSF (C, d) in case F C is odd. For the Betti numbers this result was already obtained (more generally for regular elliptic surfaces) in [Y6] using completely different methods. By [Be] the result about the Hodge numbers for S is a direct consequence.
134
L. Göttsche
Theorem 7.3. Let C ∈ H 2 (S, d) with C 2 odd. Then MSF (C, d) has the same Hodge numbers as S [2d−3/2] . In particular the Hodge numbers depend only on d, and we have X 1 , Xy (MSF (H, d)) + Xy (MSF (E1 , d)) q d−1 = 1. e θ1,1 (τ/2, z)η(τ/2)9 d≥0 X 1 , e(MSF (H, d)) + e(MSF (E1 , d)) q d−1 = 2. η(τ/2)12 d≥0 X 1 . 3. σ (MSF (H, d)) − σ (MSF (E1 , d)) q d−1 = η(τ )2 η(τ/2)8 d≥0
Remark 7.4. 1. We can recover the Hodge numbers of MSF (C, d): X d≥0
Xy (MSF (H, d))q d−1
1 i + , e θ1,1 (τ/2, z)η(τ/2)9 e θ1,1 ((τ + 1)/2, z)η((τ + 1)/2)9 X Xy (MSF (E1 , d))q d−1 =
d≥0
=
1 i − . 9 e e θ1,1 (τ/2, z)η(τ/2) θ1,1 ((τ + 1)/2, z)η((τ + 1)/2)9
2. We can also use Thm. 6.2 to compute the generating functions for the signatures. From [G-Z], Sect. 5.3 we get 8S,F H (1 + p/2) = 1, and by the simple type condition S,F r r 8H (p ) is 2 if r even and 0 otherwise. After some calculations this gives X d≥0
σ (MSF (H, d))q d−1 = 12e2 (2τ )
η(2τ )8 . η(τ )22
A similar calculation using [G-Z], Sect. 5.3 and Thm. 6.2 gives X d≥0
σ (MSF (E1 , d))q d−1 = −8
η(2τ )16 . η(τ )26
It is an exercise in modular forms to show that 12e2 (2τ )
η(2τ )8 η(2τ )16 1 + 8 = , 22 26 2 η(τ ) η(τ ) η(τ ) η(τ/2)8
and thus to recover part (3) of Thm. 7.3. 3. If X is a K3 surface, L a primitive line bundle and H a generic ample line bundle on X, then it was shown in [G-H] that MXH (L, d) has the same Hodge numbers as X [2d−3] , and in [H] that MXH (L, d) is deformation equivalent to X[2d−3] . There should be a similar proof of Thm. 7.3 as that in [G-H]. Furthermore I expect that, in case C 2 odd, MSF (C, d) is deformation equivalent to S [2d−3/2] . More generally similar results also should hold for arbitrary rank.
Theta Functions and Hodge Numbers of Moduli Spaces
135
4. In physics the polarized rational elliptic surface (S, F ) is often called 21 K3. This is related to the fact that one can degenerate an elliptic K3 surface to the union of 2 rational elliptic surfaces intersecting along a fibre. The generating function of the χy -genera of the MXH (L, d) (L primitive and allowing L2 both congruent 0 modulo 4 and congruent 2 modulo 4) on the K3 surface is just the square of the generating function on S. One could ask whether this result can also be shown by degenerating the moduli spaces MXH (L, d). Proof (of Thm. 7.3). We first show that the MSF (C, d) depend only on d. Let G be the subgroup of Aut (H 2 (S, Z)) generated by the Cremona transforms and the permutations of E1 , . . . , E9 . F is invariant under the operation of G, and therefore, by Cor. P 4.11, MSF (C, d) ' MSF (g(C), d) for all g ∈ G. We can assume that C = nH − i ai Ei with n, a1 , . . . , a9 ∈ {0, 1}. Let m be the number of indices i ≥ 1 with ai = 1. By renumbering E1 . . . E9 we can assume that either C = H or C = E1 , in which case we are done, or (h, a1 , a2 , a3 ) is one of (0, 1, 1, 1) or (1, 0, 1, 1). The Cremona transform replaces (h, a1 , a2 , a3 ) by (1, 0, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0, 0), and the result follows by induction on m. As KS F ≤ 0, the moduli spaces MSF (C, d) are smooth, and by [Be] all their cohomology is of Hodge type (p, p). Therefore the theorem follows from the case l = 1 of Thm. 7.2. u t
References [Ba] [Be] [Bo] [C] [dC-M] [Ch] [D-K] [De] [E-G] [E-S] [F-S] [F] [F-L1] [F-L2] [F-L3] [F-L4] [F-Q] [Gö1] [Gö2]
Baranovsky, V.: Moduli of sheaves on surfaces and action of the oscillator algebra. Preprint math.AG/9811092 Beauville, A.: Sur la cohomologie de certaines espaces de modules de fibrés vectoriels. In: Geometry and Analysis. (Bombay, 1952) Bombay: Tata Inst. Fund. Res., 1995, pp. 37–40 Borcherds, R.: Automorphic forms with singularities on Grassmannians. Invent. Math. 132, 491–562 (1998) Chandrasekharan, K: Elliptic functions. Grundlehren 281, Berlin Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1985 de Cataldo, M.A., Migliorini, M.: The Douady space of a complex surface. Preprint math.AG/9811199 Cheah, J.: On the cohomology of Hilbert schemes of points. J. Alg. Geom. 5, 479–511 (1996) Danilov, V.I., Khovanskii, A.G.: Newton Polyhedra and an algorithm for computing Hodge–Deligne numbers. Math. USSR Izvestiya 29, 279–298 (1987) Deligne, P.: La conjecture de Weil I. Publ. Math. IHES 43, 273–307 (1974) Ellingsrud, G. and Göttsche, L.: Variation of moduli spaces and Donaldson invariants under change of polarisation. J. reine angew. Math. 467, 1–49 (1995) Ellingsrud, G., Strømme, S.A.: On the homology of the Hilbert scheme of points in the plane. Invent. Math. 87, 343–352 (1987) Fintushel, R., Stern, R.: The blowup formula for Donaldson invariants. Ann. Math. 143, 529–546 (1996) Fogarty, J.: Algebraic families on an algebraic surface. Am. J. Math. 90, 511–521 (1968) Feehan, P.M.N., Leness, T.G.: Donaldson invariants and wall-crossing maps, I: Continuity of gluing maps. Preprint math.DG/9812060 Feehan, P.M.N., Leness, T.G.: Donaldson invariants and wall-crossing maps, II: Surjectivity of gluing maps. In preparation Feehan, P.M.N., Leness, T.G.: Donaldson invariants and wall-crossing maps, III: Bubble-tree compactifications and manifolds-with-corners structures. In preparation Feehan, P.M.N., Leness, T.G.: Donaldson invariants and wall-crossing maps, IV: Intersection theory. In preparation Friedman, R., Qin, Z.: Flips of moduli spaces and transition formulas for Donaldson polynomial invariants of rational surfaces. Commun. in Analysis and Geometry 3, 11–83 (1995) Göttsche, L.: The Betti numbers of the Hilbert schemes of points on a smooth projective surface. Math. Ann. 286, 193–207 (1990) Göttsche, L.: Change of polarization and Hodge numbers of moduli spaces of torsion free sheaves on surfaces. Math. Zeitschr. 223, 247–260 (1996)
136
L. Göttsche
Göttsche, L.: Modular forms and Donaldson invariants for 4-manifolds with b+ = 1. J. Am. Math. Soc. 9, 826–843 (1996) [G-H] Göttsche, L., Huybrechts, D.: Hodge numbers of moduli spaces of stable sheaves on K3 surfaces. Int. J. Math. 7 No. 3, 359–372 (1996) [G-S] Göttsche, L., Soergel, W.: Perverse sheaves and the cohomology of Hilbert schemes of smooth algebraic surfaces. Math. Ann. 296, 235–245 (1993) [G-Z] Göttsche, L., Zagier, D.: Jacobi forms and the structure of Donaldson invariants for 4-manifolds with b+ = 1. Sel. Math. New. Ser. 4, 69–115 (1998) [H-B-J] Hirzebruch, F., Berger, T., Jung, R.: Manifolds and modular forms. Aspects of Math. E20, Braunschweig–Wiesbaden: Viehweg, 1994 [H] Huybrechts, D.: Birational symplectic manifolds and their deformations. J. Diff. Geom. 45, 488–513 (1997) [H-L] Huybrechts, D., Lehn, M.: The Geometry of Moduli Spaces of Sheaves. Aspects of Math. Vol. E 31, Braunschweig–Wiesbaden: Vieweg 1997 [K-Z] Kaneko, M., Zagier, D.: A generalized Jacobi theta function and quasimodular forms. In: R. Dijkgraaf, C. Faber, G. van der Geer (eds.) The moduli space of curves. Boston: Birkhäuser, 1995, pp. 165–172 [K-M] Kotschick, D., Morgan, J.: SO(3)-invariants for 4-manifolds with b+ = 1 II. J. Diff. Geom. 39, 433–546 (1994) [Kr-M] Kronheimer, P., Mrowka, T.: Embedded surfaces and the structure of Donaldson’s Polynomial invariants. J. Diff. Geom. 33, 573–734 (1995) [L] Leness, T.G.: Donaldson wall-crossing formulas via topology. Forum Math. (1998) to appear, dgga/960316 [L-Q1] Li, W.-P., Qin, Z.: On blowup formulae for the S-duality conjecture of Vafa and Witten. Preprint mathAG/9805054 [L-Q2] Li, W.-P., Qin, Z.: On blowup formulae for the S-duality conjecture of Vafa and Witten II: The universal functions. Preprint mathAG/9805055, to appear in Math Research letters [M-N-V-W] Minahan, J.A., Nemeschansky, D., Vafa, C., Warner, N.P.: E-Strings and N = 4 Topological Yang-Mills Theories. hep-th/9802168 [M-W] Moore, G., Witten, E.: Integration over the u-plane in Donaldson theory preprint hep-th/9709193 [Q1] Qin, Z.: Moduli of stable sheaves on ruled surfaces and their Picard groups. J. reine angew. Math. 433, 201–219 (1992) [Q2] Qin, Z.: Equivalence classes of polarizations and moduli spaces of sheaves. J. Diff. Geom. 37, 397– 413 (1993) [V-W] Vafa, C., Witten, E.: A Strong Coupling Test of S-Duality. Nucl. Phys. B 431 (1994) [W] Witten, E.: Monopoles and four-manifolds. Math. Research Letters 1, 769–796 (1994) [Y1] Yoshioka, K.: The Betti numbers of the moduli space of stable sheaves of rank 2 on P2 . J. reine angew. Math. 453, 193–220 (1994) [Y2] Yoshioka, K.: The Betti numbers of the moduli space of stable sheaves of rank 2 on a ruled surface. Math. Ann. 302, 519–540 (1995) [Y3] Yoshioka, K.: Chamber structure of polarizations and the moduli space of stable sheaves on a ruled surface. Int. J. Math. 7, 411–431 (1996) [Y4] Yoshioka, K.: Euler characteristics of SU (2) instanton moduli spaces of rational elliptic surfaces. preprint math.AG/9805003 [Y5] Yoshioka, K., Betti numbers of moduli of stable sheaves on some surfaces. Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Suppl.) 46, 263–268 (1996) [Y6] Yoshioka, K.: Numbers of Fq -rational points of moduli of stable sheaves on elliptic surfaces. Moduli of vector bundles, Lect. Notes in Pure and Applied Math. 179, Marcel Dekker, 297–305 [Z1] Zagier, D.: Periods of modular forms and Jacobi theta functions. Invent. math. 104, 449-465 (1991) [Z2] Zagier, D.: Introduction to Modular forms. In: From Number Theory to Physics, eds. W. Waldschmidt, P. Moussa, J.-M. Luck, C. Itzykson, Berlin–Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1992
[Gö3]
Communicated by R. H. Dijkgraaf
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 137 – 155 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem Xiao Zhang Institute of Mathematics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100080, P. R. China. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 26 October 1998 / Accepted: 10 March 1999
Abstract: Total angular momentum for asymptotically flat manifolds is defined. Positive mass theorem for initial (spin) data set (M, gij , pij ) with nonsymmetric pij is proved. As an application, we establish positive mass theorems involving total linear momentum and total angular momentum. This gives an answer to a problem of S. T. Yau in his Problem Section [Ya2] and a partial answer to his recent conjecture on the relationship among total energy, total linear momentum, total angular momentum and entropy of black hole. 1. Introduction In general relativity, basic quantities are total energy, total linear momentum, total angular momentum and entropy of black hole (i.e., area of apparent horizon). Total energy and total linear momentum can be defined on asymptotically flat manifolds. Let (M, gij , hij ) be a 3-dimensional Riemannian manifold with metric tensor gij , and a 2-symmetric tensor hij . M is called asymptotically flat of order τ if there is a compact set K ⊂ M such that M − K is the disjoint union of a finite number of subsets M1 , · · · , Mk − called the “ends” of M − each diffeomorphic to R 3 − Br , where Br is the closed ball of radius r with center at the coordinate origin. Under the diffeomorphism the metric of Ml ⊂ M is of the form gij = δij + aij
(1.1)
in the standard coordinates {x i } on R 3 , where aij satisfies aij = O(r −τ ),
(1.2)
∂k aij = O(r
−τ −1
),
(1.3)
∂l ∂k aij = O(r
−τ −2
).
(1.4)
138
X. Zhang
Furthermore, the 2-symmetric tensor hij satisfies hij = O(r −τ −1 ), ∂k hij = O(r
−τ −2
).
We will often identify the end Ml ⊂ M with the corresponding set Ml ⊂ R 3 . For asymptotically flat manifold M, the total energy of end Ml is defined as Z 1 lim El = (∂j gij − ∂i gjj )di , 16π r→∞ Sr,l the total linear momentum of end Ml is defined as Z 1 (hki − gki hjj )di , lim Plk = 8π r→∞ Sr,l
(1.5) (1.6)
(1.7)
(1.8)
where Sr,l is the sphere of radius r in end Ml ⊂ R 3 . When the asymptotic order τ > 21 , total energy is independent on the choice of asymptotic coordinates, and vanishes when τ > 1 [Ba1]. The Riemannian version of Positive Mass Conjecture was proved first by R. Schoen and S. T. Yau [SY1,SY2,SY3]. Theorem 1.1 (Schoen, Yau). Let (M, gij , hij ) be a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order 1. If M satisfies the following dominant energy condition: sX X X X 1 2 2 hii ) − hij ) ≥ ( (∇i hj i − ∇j hii ))2 , (1.9) (R + ( 2 i
i,j
j
i
where R is the scalar curvature of M, then, for each end Ml , we have El ≥ 0.
(1.10)
If El0 = 0 for some l0 , then M can be isometrically embedded into 4-dimensional Minkowski space R 3,1 as a spacelike hypersurface so that gij is the induced metric from R 3,1 and hij is the second fundamental form. In particular, M is topologically R 3 . Alternatively, there is a Lorentzian version of the Positive Mass Conjecture which was proved then by E. Witten [Wi], and, soon later, was completed by Parker and Taubes [PT]. Theorem 1.2 (Witten). Let N be a 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifold with Lorentzian metric g˜ of signature (−1, 1, 1, 1), which satisfies the Einstein equations R˜ R˜ αβ − g˜ αβ = Tαβ , 2
(1.11)
where R˜ αβ , R˜ are Ricci curvature, scalar curvature of g˜ respectively. Let M ⊂ N be a spacelike hypersurface with induced Riemannian metric gij , and the second fundamental form hij . (M, gij , hij ) is asymptotically flat of order 1. If M satisfies the following dominant energy condition sX T0i2 , (1.12) T00 ≥ i
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
139
where we choose an orthonormal frame {eα } on N with e0 timelike, then, for each end Ml , we have sX Plk2 . (1.13) El ≥ k
If El0 = 0 for some l0 , and T00 ≥ |Tαβ |, then M has only one end and N is flat over M. qP 2 They can also improve El ≥ 0 by El ≥ k Plk by their argument in Schoen and Yau’s Positive Mass Theorem [Ya1]. By Gauss and Codazzi equations, (1.12) is equivalent to (1.9). Hence two versions of Positive Mass Theorem are equivalent. On the other hand, the Penrose inequality, which was proved by Huisken and Ilmanen [HI1,HI2], see also [Ba2,Br,Gi,He1] for partial or related results, gives the relation between total energy and area of apparent horizon. In [Ya2], S.T.Yau asked what a good definition of total angular momentum for asymptotically flat space is and what the relationship would be with total mass (Problem 120). In Spring 1997, S.T. Yau conjectured also that the most general case of “Positive Mass Theorem/Penrose inequality” should be as follows: Under a certain kind of “dominant energy condition”, one should have r A , El ≥ |Pl | + |Jl | + 16π where Pl , Jl are total linear momentum, total angular momentum of end Ml respectively, and A is the area of apparent horizon. The above conjecture of Yau deduces to Penrose inequality when hqij = 0. (See also a
A if (1.9) holds related conjecture of Huisken and Ilmanen that the ADM rest mass ≥ 16π [HI2]). It should also have its analogous version on higher dimensional asymptotically q
A by some universal constant times n−2 flat manifolds, simply replacing the part 16π n−1 power of entropy of the black hole, where n is the dimension of manifold, see [Va] for some evidence. We refer to [AH,AM,AS,St] for many important works on angular momentum on more restrictive asymptotically flat 3-dimensional manifolds in spacetime which can be conformally compactified in the sense of Penrose, and the limit of magnetic part of asymptotic the Weyl curvature tensor vanishes at spacelike infinity of Minkowski space. On these manifolds, total angular momentum can be defined in terms of the Weyl curvature tensor and conformal factor. Unfortunately, the concept of angular momentum remains somewhat problematical [Pe]. In this paper, we shall give total angular momentum a “good” definition and study its relations with total energy and total linear momentum. From now on, we always denote (M, gij , hij ) (hij = hj i ) as a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order τ in the sense that 2,α (M), gij − δij ∈ C−τ
X i
hij ∈ hii ∈
0,α C−τ −1 (M), 1,α C−τ −1 (M).
(1.14) (1.15) (1.16)
140
X. Zhang
(Here, and henceforth, definitions of weighted Sobolev and Hölder spaces follow from Bartnik [Ba1].) Let ρz be the distance function of M with respect to some fixed point z ∈ M. ρz is Lipschitz. Let ij k be the components of the volume element of M relative to an arbitrary frame. Definition 1.1. For any 3-dimensional manifold (M, gij , hij ) (hij = hj i ), the local angular momentum density h˜ zij with respect to point z ∈ M is defined as 1 h˜ zij = i 2
uv
(∇u ρz2 )(hvj − gvj trg (h)).
(1.17)
2-tensor h˜ zij is bounded on any compact set K˜ ⊂ M, but it might have good smoothness, depending on the smoothness of hij , near infinity on the ends. Moreover, since j uv is anti-symmetric with respect to j and v, we have 1 trg (h˜ z ) = j uv (∇u ρz2 )(hvj − gvj trg (h)) = 0. 2
(1.18)
Note that h˜ zij is not symmetric in general. (One can also define local angular momentum density with respect to any global function f on M, replacing ρz2 by f in (1.17).) Definition 1.2. For 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold (M, gij , hij ) in the above sense, the total angular momentum of end Ml with respect to point z ∈ M is defined as Z 1 lim (1.19) h˜ z di , Jlkin (z) = 8π r→∞ Sr,l ki the total angular momentum of end Ml with respect to point x0 ∈ R 3 with coordinates {x0u } is defined as Z 1 v (x u − x0u )(hvi − gvi trg (h))di . (1.20) lim Jlkex (x0 ) = 8π r→∞ Sr,l ku (Note that Jlkex (0) is defined as total angular momentum in [CK].) In classical theory, total angular momentum is defined as Z kuv x u T v0 ∗ 1 Jk = R3
with origin of coordinates at the system’s center of mass, where Tv0 is the momentum density of system [MTW]. If there is a symmetric 2-tensor hij such that X ∂i hv i − ∂v tr(h), Tv0 = i
then
Z kiv (hvi − δvi tr(h)) ∗ 1 + lim kuv x u (hv i − δvi tr(h)) ∗ dx i r→∞ S R3 r Z = lim kuv x u (hv i − δvi tr(h)) ∗ dx i . Z
Jk =
r→∞ S r
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
141
Therefore the definitions (1.19), (1.20) of total angular momentum coincide with the one in the classical case up to a constant. Inspired by it, we can also define total angular momentum with respect to z ∈ M as Z 1 in (∇i ρz2 )(hj k − gj k trg (h)) (z) = Cn lim Jlij r→∞ S 2 r,l (1.21) 2 k − (∇j ρz )(hik − gik trg (h)) d , and with respect to x0 ∈ R n with coordinates {x0u } as Z ex (x0 ) = Cn lim (x i − x0i )(hj k − gj k trg (h)) Jlij r→∞ S r,l
− (x
j
j − x0 )(hik
− gik trg (h)) dk
(1.22)
for higher dimensional asymptotically flat manifolds, where Cn is some universal constant, Sr,l is the sphere of radius r in end Ml ⊂ R n . Note that the total angular momentum Jlkex (x0 ) of each end depends on the choice of point in R 3 . Hence the one with respect to the center of mass of each end, if it exists, will play a special role in general relativity. For a class of 3-manifolds M with an asymptotically flat end and satisfying much more special asymptotic conditions than the ones of (1.2), (1.3), (1.4), Huisken and Yau proved that the center of mass does exist if the mass is positive [HY], i.e., there is a unique round sphere foliation of constant mean curvature for the asymptotically flat end such that their center of gravity converges to a vector a ∈ R 3 which depends only on the geometry of M. Therefore it defines a geometric center of mass. Although the same statement in their paper is not claimed, it is believed the center of mass will still exist for those ends which satisfy asymptotic conditions (1.2), (1.3), (1.4) and have positive total energy [Hu]. We first prove a Positive Mass Theorem for 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifolds (M, gij , pij ) with nonsymmetric pij . We also generalize it to higher dimensional almost asymptotically flat spin manifolds. Definition 1.3. For any n-dimensional manifold (M, gij , pij ) (n ≥ 3) with metric tensor gij and an arbitrary 2-tensor pij , local mass density is defined as µ=
X X 1 2 pii )2 − pij ), (R + ( 2 i
(1.23)
i,j
where R is the scalar curvature of M, local momentum densities are defined as X (∇i pj i − ∇j pii ), (1.24) ωj = i
χj = 2
X
∇i (pij − pj i ).
(1.25)
i
(M, gij , pij ), the dominant energy condition, is satisfied if sX sX ωj2 , (ωj + χj )2 }. µ ≥ max{ j
j
(1.26)
142
X. Zhang
(M, gij , pij ) is called almost asymptotically flat of order τ if on each end Ml ⊂ M the metric is of the form (1.1) which is uniformly equivalent to the flat metric on R n − Br and there exists q > n such that 2,q
aij ∈ W−τ (M), R ∈ L (M) ∩ L 1
(1.27) q 2 ,−τ −2
(M).
(1.28)
Furthermore, the 2-tensor pij together with its associated 2-form X θ= (pij − pj i )ei ∧ ej
(1.29)
i,j
satisfy that there exists a compact set K˜ ⊃ K and C > 0 such that 0,α ˜ pij ∈ C−τ −1 (M − K),
˜ |pij − pj i | < C on K, X ˜ pii | < C on K, | i
X i
(1.30) (1.31) (1.32)
1, q
pii ∈ W−τ2−1 (M),
(1.33)
dθ, d ∗ θ ∈ L q ,−τ −2 (M).
(1.34)
2
For a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifold (M, gij , pij ), the total energy of end Ml is defined by (1.7) also and the total linear momentum of end Ml is defined as the same as (1.8) except to replace hij by pij . We refer to [Ba1,PT,Sc, Zh1] for definitions of total energy and total linear momentum on higher dimensional manifolds. Theorem 1.3. Let (M, gij , pij ) be a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , where pij is an arbitrary 2-tensor. If M satisfies the dominant energy condition (1.26), then, for each end Ml , we have sX Plk2 . (1.35) El ≥ k
If equality holds in (1.35) for some end Ml0 , then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El0 = 0 and gij is C 2 , pij is C 1 , then the following equations hold on M Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k = 0, ∇i pj k − ∇j pik = 0, X ∇i (pij − pj i ) = 0.
(1.36) (1.37) (1.38)
i
Theorem 1.4. Let (M, gij , pij ) be an n-dimensional almost asymptotically flat spin manifold of order n − 2 ≥ τ > n−2 2 (n > 3), where pij is an arbitrary 2-tensor. If M satisfies the following dominant energy condition: sX s X sX ωj2 , (ωj + χj )2 } + κj2 , (1.39) µ ≥ max{ j
j
1≤j ≤n−3
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
143
denoting p˜ ab = pab − pba , where κj2 =
X
(p˜ j i p˜ kl + p˜ j k p˜ li + p˜ j l p˜ ik )2 ,
(1.40)
i,k,l;k>l>i>j
then, for each end Ml , we have El ≥
sX k
Plk2 .
(1.41)
If equality holds in (1.41) for some end Ml0 , then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El0 = 0 and gij is C 2 , pij is C 1 , then X k
(Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k )ek el −
√ = − −1(
k
X
−(
l,a,b;i6=l6=a6=b6=j 6=i
X
j a b
∇i pab e e e −
a,b;i6=a6=b6=j 6=i
X
√ X −1 (∇i pj k − ∇j pik )ek ∇j pab ei ea eb )
(1.42)
a,b;i6 =a6 =b6 =j 6 =i j l a b
pab pil e e e e −
X
pab pj l ei el ea eb )
l,a,b;i6 =l6 =a6 =b6 =j 6 =i
as an endomorphism of S, where Rij kl is curvature tensor of M. e on Our argument is inspired by Witten [Wi,PT]. We define a Dirac type operator D (spin) initial data set (M, gij , pij ) with nonsymmetric pij , which is analogous to the one used by Witten on Lorentzian manifolds. The crucial point is that this Dirac–Witten e and e is not self-adjoint, but there are nice Weitzenböck formulas for D e∗ D operator D eD e∗ . Then our Positive Mass Theorem is a direct consequence of these formulas. We D also observe that the existence of the Dirac–Witten equation (subsequently, the Positive Mass Theorem) actually holds for a class of much more generally asymptotic 2-tensor pij , namely, almost asymptotically flat manifolds, which can be applied to local angular momentum density. Now we can easily see that total energy is greater or equal to the norm of total linear momentum for any asymptotically flat spin manifold (M n , gij , hij ) (n ≥ 3, hij = hj i ) which satisfies the dominant energy condition, and equality for some end implies the manifold has only one end. Furthermore, when total energy is zero for some end and n ≤ 7, by solving Jang’s equation, the same as [SY3], one can prove that M is topological R n and can be embedded into R n,1 as a spacelike hypersurface so that gij is the induced metric from R n,1 and hij is the second fundamental form. This avoids the difficulty to prove there is a positive definite metric on the space of Spin(n, 1) spinors for n ≥ 5 when one tries to generalize the Lorentzian version of the Positive Mass Theorem to higher dimensional spin manifolds [Zh1,Zh2,Zh3]. As an application of Theorem 1.3, we prove the following two Positive Mass Theorems involving total angular momentum. This gives an answer to Problem 120 in [Ya2] and a partial answer to Yau’s conjecture. Theorem 1.5. Let (M, gij , hij ) be a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , where hij = hj i . Suppose there is a regular point z ∈ M and the dominant
144
X. Zhang
energy condition (1.26) holds for pij = h˜ zij , then, for each end Ml , and each point x0 ∈ lz (if lz is nonempty), we have sX sX (Jlkin (z))2 = (Jlkex (x0 ))2 . (1.43) El ≥ k
k
If equality holds in (1.43), then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El = 0 and h˜ zij is C 1 , then (1.36), (1.37) and (1.38) hold true for pij = h˜ z . ij
Theorem 1.6. Let (M, gij , hij ) be a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , where hij = hj i . Suppose there is a regular point z ∈ M and the dominant energy condition (1.26) holds for pij = hij ± h˜ zij , then, for each end Ml and each point x0 ∈ lz (if lz is nonempty), we have sX sX (Plk ± Jlkin (z))2 = (Plk ± Jlkex (x0 ))2 . (1.44) El ≥ k
k
If equality holds in (1.44), then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El = 0 and hij ± h˜ zij is C 1 , then (1.36), (1.37) and (1.38) hold true for pij = hij ± h˜ z . ij
We refer to Sect. 4 for related definitions in the above two theorems. We shall address in another paper the Positive Mass Theorem involving total angular momentum for higher dimensional manifolds. 2. Dirac–Witten Operator Let (M, gij , pij ) be an n-dimensional spin Riemannian manifold with metric tensor gij and 2-tensor pij . Fix a point p ∈ M and an orthonormal basis {ei } of Tp M such that (∇i ej )p = 0, where ∇ is the metric connection of M. Let {ei } be the dual frame. Let S be the spinor bundle of M with Hermitian metric h , i. The metric connection ∇ of M induces a metric connection (also denoted by ∇) on S. Define the modified connections ∇˜ and ∇¯ on S by √ −1 X ˜ pij ej , (2.1) ∇i = ∇i + 2 j √ √ X −1 X −1 pij ej − pj k ei ej ek . (2.2) ∇¯ i = ∇i + 2 2 j
j,k;i6 =j 6 =k6 =i
In a local orthonormal coframe {ei } of M, Dirac operator D and Dirac–Witten opere are defined by ator D X ei ∇i , (2.3) D= i
e= D
X i
ei ∇˜ i
(2.4)
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
145
respectively. We have the following Lichnerowicz formula: 1 D 2 = ∇ ∗ ∇ + R, 4
(2.5)
where R is the scalar curvature of M. In terms of (2.1), we have e=D+ D
√
−1 X pij ei ej . 2
(2.6)
i,j
Moreover, d(hφ, ψi ∗ ei ) = (h∇i φ, ψi + hφ, ∇i ψi) ∗ 1 √ X = (h∇˜ i φ, ψi + hφ, (∇˜ i − −1 pij ej )ψi) ∗ 1 = (h∇¯ i φ, ψi + hφ, (∇¯ i −
√
(2.7) (2.8)
j
−1
X
pij ej )ψi) ∗ 1,
(2.9)
j
d(hei φ, ψi ∗ ei ) = (hDφ, ψi − hφ, Dψi) ∗ 1 √ X e ψi − hφ, (D e + −1 pii )ψi) ∗ 1. = (hDφ,
(2.10) (2.11)
i
Hence, ∇˜ i∗ = −∇˜ i +
√ X −1 pij ej
(2.12)
j
√ −1 X pij ej , 2 j X √ pij ej , ∇¯ i∗ = −∇¯ i + −1 = −∇i +
(2.13) (2.14)
j
√ √ X −1 X −1 pij ej + pj k ei ej ek , 2 2 j j,k;i6 =j 6 =k6 =i √ X ∗ e e pii D = D + −1 = −∇i +
i
=D+
√
−1
X i
√ −1 X pii + pij ei ej . 2 i,j
Now we prove the following three Weitzenböck formulas.
(2.15) (2.16) (2.17)
146
X. Zhang
Theorem 2.1. X
√ −1
e = ∇ ∗∇ + e∗ D D
pj k ei ej ek ∇i +
i6=j 6=k6=i
X
√ −1 2
X
X
ei ej ek ∇i pj k
i6 =j 6 =k6 =i
1 + (R + ( pii )2 − pij pkl ei ej ek el ) 4 i i6=j,k6=l √ √ −1 X −1 X j ∇i (pij − pj i )e − ∇j pii ej − 2 2 i,j
(2.18)
i,j
√ X 1 1 ωj ej ) + F, = ∇¯ ∗ ∇¯ + (µ + −1 2 2
(2.19)
√ X 1 eD e∗ = ∇¯ ∇¯ ∗ + 1 (µ − −1 (ωj + χj )ej ) − F, D 2 2
(2.20)
j
j
where
F=
P
0 (n = 3), i ej ek el (n > 3). p p e ij kl i6=j 6=k6=l6=i
(2.21)
Proof. By (2.17), we have √ −1 X ∗e 2 e ∇k pij ek ei ej D D=D + 2 i,j,k √ X √ X √ X − −1 pij ej ∇i + −1 pij ei ∇j + −1 pij ei ej D −
1X 2
i
i,j
pii
X i,j
i,j
1 X pij ei ej − pij pkl ei ej ek el 4
i6 =j
i,j,k,l
√ √ −1 X 2 =D + ∇k pij ek ei ej + −1 2 i,j,k
X
ei ej ek pj k ∇i
i6 =j 6 =k6 =i
1 X 1 X + ( pii )2 − pij pkl ei ej ek el . 4 4 i
i6=j,k6=l
Hence (2.18) follows from Lichnerowicz formula (2.5). By (2.15), we have √ X √ −1 X ∗ ∗ ei ej ek ∇i pj k + −1 ei ej ek pj k ∇i ∇¯ ∇¯ = ∇ ∇ + 2 i6=j 6=k6=i i6 =j 6 =k6 =i √ X X X 1 1 1 −1 2 − ∇i pij ej + pij − pij pkl ei ej ek el − F. (2.22) 2 4 4 2 i,j
i,j
i6 =j,k6 =l
Hence (2.19) follows. On the other hand, (2.2), (2.15), (2.6) and (2.17) give √ X ∇i pij ej + F, ∇¯ ∇¯ ∗ − ∇¯ ∗ ∇¯ = −1
(2.23)
i,j
e∗ D e= eD e∗ − D D
√ X −1 ∇j pii ej . i,j
(2.24)
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
147
Hence (2.20) follows. u t Now we can derive the following integral form of Weitzenböck formula (2.19): Theorem 2.2. Z Z √ X e ∗ ei = ¯ 2 + 1 hφ, (µ + −1 hφ, ∇¯ i φ + ei Dφi |∇φ| ωj ej )φi 2 ∂M M j Z 1 e 2. hφ, Fφi − |Dφ| (2.25) + 2 M Proof. It follows from (2.9), (2.11) and (2.19). u t 3. Positive Mass Theorem If (M, gij , pij ) is a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 1 i 2 with asymptotic coordinates {x }, then, on end, we have 1 (3.1) ∇j = ∂j − 0kj l dx k dx l + O(r −2τ −1 ), 4 √ X e = dx j ∂j − 1 0kj l dx j dx k dx l + −1 pij dx i dx j + O(r −2τ −1 ), (3.2) D 4 2 i,j
where 0kj l =
1 (∂j gkl + ∂l gkj − ∂k gj l ). 2
(3.3)
Let δ = τ for 1 > τ > 21 and δ = 1 − ε for τ = 1, where ε > 0 is chosen such e D e∗ give the maps for the following weighted Sobolev spaces that 1 > δ > 21 . Thus D, defined by connection ∇ on S, 2,q
e D
1,q
e∗ D
0,q
W−δ (S) −→ W−δ−1 (S) −→ W−δ−2 (S). e 0 ∈ W 1,q (S), and D e∗ Dφ e 0 ∈ W 0,q (S). For constant spinor φ0 , ∂j φ0 = 0, we have Dφ −δ−1 −δ−2 Recall the Pauli representation of the coframe {ei } on a spinor bundle √ √ 0 0 1 −1 √0 −1 , e2 7 → √ , e3 7 → e1 7 → . (3.4) −1 0 −1 0 0 − −1 Obviously, e1 e2 e3 = I d. Now we recall a lemma, which can be easily proved in the spirit of [PT], see also [Zh1]. Lemma 3.1. Suppose (M, gij , pij ) is a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat man¯ = 0, ∇φ ¯ a =0 ifold of order τ > 0, and φ, {φa } are C 1 spinors which satisfy either ∇φ or ∇¯ ∗ φ = 0, ∇¯ ∗ φa = 0. (i) If limx→∞ φ(x) = 0, where the limit is taken along M in one asymptotic end, then φ = 0.
148
X. Zhang
(ii) If {φa } are linearly independent in some end, then they are linearly independent everywhere on M. Proof. (i) By the assumption, we have √ √ −1 X −1 j pij e φ + ∇i φ = ∓ 2 2 j
X
pj k ei ej ek φ.
j,k;i6 =j 6 =k6 =i
Then |d|φ|2 | = 2|<eh∇φ, φi| ≤ C|p||φ|2 . This implies |d ln |φ|| ≤ Cr −τ −1 on the ˜ Integrating it along a path from x0 ∈ M complement of the zero set of φ on M − K. gives −τ −|x|−τ )
|φ(x)| ≥ |φ(x0 )|eC(|x0 |
.
Taking x to be the first zero of φ along the path of integration, or taking the limit as ˜ Since |x| → ∞ if no such zero exists, shows that φ(x0 ) = 0. Hence φ = 0 on M − K. φ satisfies the following Dirac-type equation, √ √ −1 X −1 X ( pii )φ − (1 ± 1) (pij − pj i )ei ej φ, Dφ = ∓ 2 4 i
i,j
therefore φ = 0 by Unique Continuation Property. P (ii) Suppose there are constant Ca such that φ = a Ca φa vanishes at some point ¯ = 0 or ∇¯ ∗ φ = 0, we can repeat the above argument to conclude that x0 ∈ M. Since ∇φ t φ → 0 on each end. Hence Ca = 0 and it follows. u Proposition 3.1. If (M, gij , pij ) is a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 and the dominant energy condition (1.26) holds, then the map e : W 2,q (S) −→ W 0,q (S) e∗ D D −δ −δ−2
(3.5)
is an isomorphism. e is asymptotic to the standard Laplacian operator ∇ ∗ ∇ e∗ D Proof. Note that, by (2.18), D e is Fredholm with index e∗ D in the sense of Bartnik [Ba1]. Hence D e∗ D| e 2,q ) = ind(∇ ∗ ∇| 2,q ), ind(D W (S) W (S) −δ
(3.6)
−δ
see [Ba1]. Weighted Holder ¨ inequality and elliptic regularity imply Coker(∇ ∗ ∇|W 2,q (S) ) = Ker((∇ ∗ ∇)∗ |W 0,q¯
−1+δ (S)
−δ
) = Ker(∇ ∗ ∇|W 2,q¯
−1+δ (S)
),
(3.7)
2,q q ∗ q−1 . By the maximal principle, ∇ ∇ has trivial kernel both on W−δ (S) and e∗ D) e = 0 and we only need to show that the kernel of D e∗ D e (S). Thus ind(D
where q¯ = 2,q¯
on W−1+δ
e = 0, then e∗ Dφ on W−δ (S) is trivial. Let φ ∈ W−δ (S) satisfy D Z Z Z Z 2 ∗e i i e e e e ∗ ei → 0 |Dφ| = hφ, D Dφi + he φ, Dφi ∗ e = hei φ, Dφi 2,q
M
2,q
M
∂M
∂M
e = 0. Therefore ∇φ ¯ = 0 on M by (2.25). Hence φ = 0 by Lemma as x → ∞. Thus Dφ 3.1 (i). The proof of proposition is complete. u t
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
149
Proposition 3.2. If (M, gij , pij ) is a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 and the dominant energy condition (1.26) holds, then the map e∗ : W 1,q (S) −→ W 0,q (S) D −δ−1 −δ−2
(3.8)
is injective. e∗ | 1,q ). Then (2.20) gives ∇¯ ∇¯ ∗ φ + Proof. Let φ ∈ Ker(D W−δ−1 (S) P j j (ωj + χj )e )φ = 0. By (2.9), we have,
1 2 (µ
√ −1
−
d(h∇¯ i∗ φ, φi ∗ ei ) = (h∇¯ ∇¯ ∗ , φi) − h∇ ∇¯ ∗ , ∇ ∇¯ ∗ i) ∗ 1 √ X 1 (ωj + χj )ej )φi) ∗ 1 = −(|∇¯ ∗ φ|2 + hφ, (µ − −1 2 j
Hence Z
√ X 1 |∇¯ ∗ φ|2 + hφ, (µ − −1 (ωj + χj )ej )φi = − 2 M j
Z ∂M
h∇¯ i∗ φ, φi ∗ ei → 0
as x → ∞. Thus ∇¯ ∗ φ = 0, and φ = 0 by Lemma 3.1 (i). The proof of proposition is complete. u t Proposition 3.3. If (M, gij , pij ) is a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 and the dominant energy condition (1.26) holds, then for any constant spinor φ0 on ends, the following boundary value problem has a unique solution φ ∈ W 2,q (S), e Dφ = 0, (3.9) limr→∞ φ = φ0 . e 0 ∈ W 0,q (S), by Proposition 3.1, there is unique φ1 ∈ W 2,q (S) e∗ Dφ Proof. Since D −δ −δ−2 e 1 =−D e 0 . Then φ = φ1 + φ0 satisfies D e = 0. Since Dφ e ∈ e∗ Dφ e∗ Dφ e∗ Dφ such that D 1,q e = 0 by Proposition 3.2 and φ is the unique solution of (3.9). u W (S), then Dφ t −δ−1
Theorem 3.1. Let (M, gij , pij ) be a 3-dimensional almost asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , where pij is an arbitrary 2-tensor. If M satisfies the dominant energy condition (1.26), then, for each end Ml , we have sX El ≥ Plk2 . (3.10) k
If equality holds in (3.10) for some end Ml0 , then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El0 = 0 and gij is C 2 , pij is C 1 , then the following equations hold on M: Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k = 0, ∇i pj k − ∇j pik = 0, X ∇i (pij − pj i ) = 0. i
(3.11) (3.12) (3.13)
150
X. Zhang
Proof. Let constant spinor φ0 6 = 0 on Ml , and φ0 = 0 on other ends. Denote φ = φ1 +φ0 , 2,q where φ1 ∈ W−δ (S), as the corresponding solution of (3.9) for this φ0 . We have Z
√ X ¯ 2 + 1 hφ, (µ + −1 |∇φ| ωj ej )φi 2 M j √ Z X −1 X hφ0 , dx i dx j ∇˜ j φ0 − pj k dx i dx j dx k φ0 i ∗ dx i = 2 ∂M∞ i6=j i6=j 6 =k6 =i Z X 1 = hφ0 , − 0kj l dx i dx j dx k dx l φ0 i ∗ dx i 4 ∂M∞ i6=j √ Z X −1 X + hφ0 , pj k dx i dx j dx k − pj k dx i dx j dx k )φ0 i ∗ dx i ( 2 ∂M∞ i6=j i6 =j 6 =k6 =i Z 1 = hφ0 , (∂j gij − ∂i gjj )φ0 i ∗ dx i 4 ∂M∞ √ Z −1 (pki dx k − hjj dx i )φ0 i ∗ dx i + hφ0 , 2 ∂M∞ √ = 4π(hφ0 , El φ0 i + hφ0 , −1Plk dx k φ0 i). qP 2 −1Plk dx k has eigenvalue ± k Plk . Now we take φ0 as the eigenspinor of qP 2 eigenvalue − k Plk with |φ0 | = 1, we therefore obtain the first part of the theorem. ¯ = 0. Hence it That the equality implies there is at least one spinor φ such that ∇φ follows from Lemma 3.1 (i) that M has only one end. If total energy vanishes, then, by Lemma 3.1 (ii), there is {φa } which form a basis of the spinor bundle everywhere on M ¯ a = 0. So in a local frame {ei } of M, such that ∇φ √
Note
∇ i φa = −
√ √ −1 −1 pik ek φa + iab pab φa . 2 2
Thus √ √ −1 −1 ∇i pj l el φa − pj l el ∇i φa 2 2 √ √ −1 −1 + j ab ∇i pab φa + j ab pab ∇i φa 2 √2 1 1 −1 ∇i pj l el φa − pj l pik el ek φa + iab pab pj l el φa =− 4 4 √2 1 1 −1 j ab ∇i pab φa + j ab pab pil el φa − iab j cd pab pcd φa . + 2 4 4
∇i ∇j φa = −
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
151
Therefore 1 − Rij kl ek el φa = (∇i ∇j − ∇j ∇i )φa 4 √ 1 −1 (∇i pj k − ∇j pik )ek φa + (pik pj l − pil pj k )ek el φa =− 2 4 √ −1 − (3.14) (iab ∇j pab − j ab ∇i pab )φa . 2 Thus X
(Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k )ek el φa =
√ X −1 (∇i pj k − ∇j pik )ek φa
k
k
+
√ −1(iab ∇j pab − j ab ∇i pab )φa (3.15)
for a basis {φa } of S. This implies X √ X (Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k )ek el = −1 (∇i pj k − ∇j pik )ek k
k
√ + −1(iab ∇j pab − j ab ∇i pab ) (3.16)
as an endomorphism of S. In terms of Clifford representation (3.4), we obtain Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k = 0, ∇i pj k − ∇j pik = 0, iab ∇j pab − j ab ∇i pab = 0.
(3.17) (3.18) (3.19)
The first two equations are exactly Gauss and Codazzi equations of spacelike hypersurface in R 3,1 if pij is symmetric. Equation (3.19) is equivalent to X 1 ∇i (pij − pj i ) = 0. χj = 2
(3.20)
i
Therefore the proof of the theorem is complete. u t Remark 3.1. Note that (3.13) implies d ∗ θ = 0, (3.12) implies dθ = 0. Therefore if we assume that there is no L2 form on M in Theorem 3.1, then the vanishing of total energy for some end implies pij = pj i . Hence M is topologically R 3 which can be isometrically embedded into a 4-dimensional Minkowski space R 3,1 as a spacelike hypersurface so that gij is the induced metric from R 3,1 and pij is the second fundamental form. Remark 3.2. Suppose M has a finite number of apparent horizons, i.e., there are a finite number of 2-surface 6k , each of them is a topological 2-sphere with mean curvature H6k = ±trg (p)|√6k . Denote nk as a normal covector of 6k . We take the boundary condition φ = ± −1nk φ on each 6k . Under this condition, Z e ∗ ei hφ, ∇¯ i φ + ei Dφi 6k
vanishes. This verifies that Theorem 3.1 holds true for black holes, see [GHHP,He2] for the case of symmetric hij .
152
X. Zhang
Remark 3.3. Suppose N is a 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifold and M is a spacelike hypersurface of N with induced metric gij and the second fundamental form hij . Let {eα ; α = 0, 1, 2, 3} be a coframe of N such that ei is tangential to M and e0 is normal to M. Let ∇ N be a Lorentzian metric connection on a hypersurface spinor bundle of M [Wi,PT,Zh1,Zh2,Zh3]. For any 2-tensor p¯ ij on M, we define modified connections on a hypersurface spinor bundle by 1X p¯ ij e0 ej , (3.21) ∇˜ i = ∇iN + 2 j √ X 1X −1 N 0 j ¯ p¯ ij e e − p¯ j k ei ej ek . (3.22) ∇i = ∇i + 2 2 j
j,k;i6 =j 6 =k6 =i
Suppose (M, gij , hij + p¯ ij ) is almost asymptotically flat of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , then the equivalent Lorentzian version of Theorem 3.1 can be proved similarly in terms of the e = ei ∇˜ i . We leave it as an exercise. Dirac–Witten operator D Remark 3.4. Theorem 3.1 holds true also for Bondi energy-momentum. The same argument is extended to arbitrary n-dimensional spin manifolds. Theorem 3.2. Let (M, gij , pij ) be an n-dimensional almost asymptotically flat spin manifold of order n − 2 ≥ τ > n−2 2 (n > 3), where pij is an arbitrary 2-tensor. If M satisfies the dominant energy condition (1.39), then, for each end Ml , we have sX Plk2 . (3.23) El ≥ k
If equality holds in (3.23) for some end Ml0 , then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El0 = 0 and gij is C 2 , pij is C 1 , then X √ X (Rij kl + pik pj l − pil pj k )ek el − −1 (∇i pj k − ∇j pik )ek k
k
X
√ = − −1(
a,b;i6=a6=b6=j 6=i
−(
X
X
∇i pab ej ea eb −
∇j pab ei ea eb )
(3.24)
a,b;i6 =a6 =b6 =j 6 =i
X
j l a b
pab pil e e e e −
l,a,b;i6=l6=a6=b6=j 6=i
pab pj l ei el ea eb )
l,a,b;i6 =l6 =a6 =b6 =j 6 =i
as an endomorphism of S, where Rij kl is curvature tensor of M. 4. Angular Momentum In this section, we assume that (M, gij , hij ) (hij = hj i ) is a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order τ in the sense that, 2,α , gij − δij ∈ C−τ
X i
hij ∈ hii ∈
0,α C−τ −1 , 1,α C−τ −1 .
(4.1) (4.2) (4.3)
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
153
Let h˜ zij be the local angular momentum density with respect to point z ∈ M and θ˜ z be its associated 2-form. Definition 4.1. The point z ∈ M is called “regular” if there exists q > 3 and a compact set K˜ ⊃ K such that 0,α ˜ h˜ zij ∈ C−τ −1 (M − K),
(4.4)
d θ˜ z , d ∗ θ˜ z ∈ L q ,−τ −2 (M).
(4.5)
2
For any z ∈ M, its “influence domain” lz with respect to end Ml is the set of point x0 ∈ R 3 such that i uv ∂u (ρz2 − σxl 0 )(hvj − gvj trg (h)) = O(r −2τ −1 ), i
uv
∂u gkl (hvj − gvj trg (h))(x
k
− x0k )(x l
− x0l )
= O(r
−2τ −1
)
(4.6) (4.7)
as x → ∞ on end Ml , where σxl 0 is the barrier function defined on R 3 − Br with respect to end Ml and point x0 ∈ R 3 by j
σxl 0 (x) = gij (x i − x0i )(x j − x0 ),
(4.8)
where gij is understood to be a function on R 3 − Br . As an example, let us see a symmetric 2-tensor hij defined on R 3 with flat metric, hii = −f + Fii , hij = 2f + Fij (i 6= j ),
(4.9) (4.10)
where f , Fij are certain smooth functions which satisfy asymptotic orders f = O(r −2 ), Fij = O(r −3 ).
(4.11) (4.12)
It is not hard to see that the influence domain 0 of origin is the line spanned by vector a = (1, 1, 1). For each x0 ∈ lz , we have 1 h˜ zij = i uv (∇u σxl 0 )(hvj − gvj trg (h)) + O(r −2τ −1 ) 2 = iu v (x u − x0u )(hvj − gvj trg (h)) + O(r −2τ −1 ) as x → ∞ on end Ml . Therefore, Z 1 lim h˜ z di Jlkin (z) = 8π r→∞ Sr,l ki Z 1 lim = v (x u − x0u )(hvj − gvj trg (h))di 8π r→∞ Sr,l iu = Jlkex (x0 ).
By taking pij = h˜ ij , pij = hij ± h˜ ij in Theorem 3.1 respectively, we can obtain the following two Positive Mass Theorems involving total angular momentum.
154
X. Zhang
Theorem 4.1. Let (M, gij , hij ) be a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , where hij = hj i . Suppose there is a regular point z ∈ M and the dominant energy condition (1.26) holds for pij = h˜ zij , then, for each end Ml and each point x0 ∈ lz (if lz is nonempty), we have sX sX (Jlkin (z))2 = (Jlkex (x0 ))2 . (4.13) El ≥ k
k
If equality holds in (4.13), then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El = 0 and h˜ zij is C 1 , then (3.11), (3.12) and (3.13) hold true for pij = h˜ z . ij
Theorem 4.2. Let (M, gij , hij ) be a 3-dimensional asymptotically flat manifold of order 1 ≥ τ > 21 , where hij = hj i . Suppose there is a regular point z ∈ M and the dominant energy condition (1.26) holds for pij = hij ± h˜ zij , then, for each end Ml and each point x0 ∈ lz (if lz is nonempty), we have sX sX in 2 (Plk ± Jlk (z)) = (Plk ± Jlkex (x0 ))2 . (4.14) El ≥ k
k
If equality holds in (4.14), then M has only one end. Furthermore, if El = 0 and hij ± h˜ zij is C 1 , then (3.11), (3.12) and (3.13) hold true for pij = hij ± h˜ z . ij
Remark 4.1. Theorem 4.1 holds true when M contains minimal 2-spheres and Theorem 4.2 holds true when M contains apparent horizons, due to Remark 3.2 and (1.18). Acknowledgements. The author would like to express his gratitude to Professor S. T. Yau for his suggestion and especially for bringing the center of mass to his attention, and to thank Professors R. Bartnik, F. H. Lin, K. Liu, L. F. Tam, G. Tian, J. P. Wang and W. P. Zhang for their interest in this work and useful conversations. This work was finished while the author visited Max-Planck-Institute for Mathematics in the Sciences, Leipzig, Germany. He would like to thank Professor J. Jost for his invitation and to thank the institute for its hospitality and financial support.
References [ADM] Arnowitt, S., Deser, S., Misner, C.: Coordinate invariance and energy expressions in general relativity. Phys. Rev. 122, 997–1006 (1961) [AH] Ashtekar, A., Hansen, R.: A unified treatment of null and spatial infinity in general relativity. I. Universal structure, asymptotic symmetries, and conserved quantities at spatial infinity. J. Math. Phys. 19, 1542–1566 (1978) [AM] Ashtekar, A., Magnon-Ashtekar, A.: On conserved quantities in general relativity. J. Math. Phys. 20, 793–800 (1979) [AS] Ashtekar, A., Streubel, M.: On angular momentum of stationary gravitating systems. J. Math. Phys. 20, 1362–1365 (1979) [Ba1] Bartnik, R.: The mass of an asymptotically flat manifold. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 36, 661–693 (1986) [Ba2] Bartnik, R.: Quasi-spherical metrics and prescribed scalar curvature. J. Diff. Geom. 37, 31–71 (1993) [Br] Bray, H.: The Penrose inequality in general relativity and volume comparison theorems involving scalar curvature. Thesis, Stanford University, 1997 [CK] Christodoulou, D., Klainerman, S.: The global nonlinear stablity of Minkowski space. Princeton Math. Series 41, Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press, 1993
Angular Momentum and Positive Mass Theorem
[Gi]
155
Gibbons, G.: Collapsing shells and the isoperimetric inequality for black holes. Class. Quant. Grav. 14, 2905–2915 (1997) [GHHP] Gibbons, G., Hawking, S., Horowitz, G., Perry, M.: Positive mass theorems for black holes. Commun. Math. Phys. 88, 295–308 (1983) [Ha] Harvey, R.: Spinors and calibrations. London: Academic Press, 1989 [HE] Hawking, S., Ellis, S.: The large scale structure of space-time. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1973 [He1] Herzlich, M.: A Penrose-like inequality for the mass of Riemannian asymptotically flat manifolds. Commun. Math. Phys. 188, 121–133 (1997) [He2] Herzlich, M.: The positive mass theorem for black holes revisited. J. Geom. Phys. 26, 97–111 (1998) [Hu] Huisken, M.: The private communication [HI1] Huisken, G., Ilmanen, T.: The Riemannian Penrose inequality. (Announcement) Int. Math. Res. Not. 20, 1045–1058 (1997) [HI2] Huisken, G., Ilmanen, T.: The inverse mean curvature flow and the Riemannian Penrose inequality. Preprint [HY] Huisken, G., Yau, S.T.: Definition of center of mass for isolated physical systems and unique foliations by stable spheres with constant mean curvature. Invent. Math. 124, 281–311 (1996) [LP] Lee, J., Parker, T.: The Yamabe problem. Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 17, 31–81 (1987) [Li] Li, P.: Lecture notes on geometric analysis. Lecture Notes Series No. 6 – Research Institute of Mathematics and Global Analysis Research Center, Seoul National University, Seoul, 1993 [MTW] Misner, C., Thorne, K., Wheeler, J.: Gravitation. (19th printing), New York: W.H. Freeman and Company, 1995 [PT] Parker, T., Taubes, C.: On Witten’s proof of the positive energy theorem. Commun. Math. Phys. 84, 223–238 (1982) [Pe] Penrose, C.: Some unsolved problems in classical general relativity. Seminar on differential geometry, ed. S.T.Yau, Annals of Math. Stud. 102, Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press, 1982, pp. 631–668 [Sc] Schoen, R.: Variational theory for the total scalar curvature functional for Riemannian metric and related topics. Lecture Notes in Math. 1365, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1987, pp. 120–154 [St] Streubel, M.: Conserved quantities for isolated gravitational system. Gen. Rel. Grav. 9, 551–561 (1978) [SY1] Schoen, R., Yau, S.T.: On the proof of the positive mass conjecture in general relativity. Commun. Math. Phys. 65, 45–76 (1979) [SY2] Schoen, R., Yau, S.T.: The energy and the linear momentum of spacetimes in general relativity. Commun. Math. Phys. 79, 47–51 (1981) [SY3] Schoen, R., Yau, S.T.: Proof of the positive mass theorem. II Commun. Math. Phys. 79, 231–260 (1981) [Va] Vafa, C.: Geometric physics. Doc. Math., Extra Vol. ICM 1998 (I), pp. 375-394 [Wi] Witten, E.: A new proof of the positive energy theorem. Commun. Math. Phys. 80, 381–402 (1981) [Ya1] Yau, S.T.: The private communication [Ya2] Yau, S.T.: Problem section. Seminar on differential geometry, ed. S.T. Yau, Annals of Math. Stud. 102, Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press, 1982, pp. 699–706 [Zh1] Zhang, X.: Positive mass conjecture for 5-dimensional Lorentzian manifolds. submitted [Zh2] Zhang, X.: Positive mass theorem for modified energy condition. submitted [Zh3] Zhang, X.: Positive mass theorem for hypersurface in 5-dimensional Lorentzian manifolds. Comm. Anal. Geom., to appear [Zh4] Zhang, X.: Lower bounds for eigenvalues of hypersurface Dirac operators. Math. Res. Lett. 5, 199–210 (1998) Communicated by H. Nicolai
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 157 – 183 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
On the Structure of the Small Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces Alberto Collino1 , Masao Jinzenji2,? 1 Dipartimento di Matematica, Universita’ di Torino, Via Carlo Alberto 10, 10123 Torino, Italy.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Department of Physics, University of Tokyo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113, Japan.
E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 29 November 1996 / Accepted: 15 March 1999
Abstract: We give an explicit procedure which computes for degree d ≤ 3 the correlation functions of topological sigma model (A-model) on a projective Fano hypersurface X as homogeneous polynomials of degree d in the correlation functions of degree 1 (number of lines). We extend this formalism to the case of Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces and explain how the polynomial property is preserved. Our key tool is the construction of universal recursive formulas which express the structure constants of the quantum cohomology ring of X as weighted homogeneous polynomial functions of the constants of the Fano hypersurface with the same degree and dimension one more. We propose some conjectures about the existence and the form of the recursive laws for the structure constants of rational curves of arbitrary degree. Our recursive formulas should yield the coefficients of the hypergeometric series used in the mirror calculation. Assuming the validity of the conjectures we find the recursive laws for rational curves of degree four. 1. Introduction ∗ (M k ) in the quantum cohomology ring of a In [16], we studied the Kähler sub-ring Hq,e N k N−1 , where we used numerical computation based hypersurface MN of degree k in CP on the torus action method. We worked under the condition that c1 (MNk ) is not negative, i.e. under the hypothesis N ≥ k. The following statements summarize the content of that paper:
1. For N ≤ 9 with N − k ≥ 2, we computed that the main relation satisfied by the ∗ (M k ) has the simple form generator Oe of Hq,e N (Oe )N−1 − k k (Oe )k−1 · q = 0.
(1.1)
? Present address: Graduate School of Mathematical Sciences, University of Tokyo, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, 153-8914, Japan.
158
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
∗ (M k ) can be ex2. Under the same restriction as for 1 the structural constants of Hq,e N pressed as polynomial functions of a finite set of integers. These integers are basically the Schubert numbers of lines, and they do depend on the degree of the hypersurface but not on its dimension. 3. An explanation for (1.1) was found by looking at a toric compactification of the moduli space of maps from CP 1 to CP N−1 . It was said that the boundary portion of the moduli space should turn out to be irrelevant for the calculation, under the condition N − k ≥ 2.
The justification for 1 and 2 was based on numerical computations and the explanation of 3 was heuristic. Givental [11] gave a mathematically rigorous proof of (1.1). He constructed the fundamental solution of the Gauss–Manin system (the deformation parameter is restricted to the Kähler deformation) associated to the A-model on MNk by inventing a powerful extension of the torus action method and he showed that it satisfies the linear ODE of ∗ (M k ) hypergeometric type if N − k ≥ 2. This ODE yields the main relation of Hq,e N (1.1) by means of a certain limit procedure (in his notation h¯ → 0). Givental also treated the cases when N − k is 1 or 0 and he showed that the solution above satisfies the linear ODE of hypergeometric type if a) some multiplicative factor is added (when N − k = 1); b) some multiplicative factor is added and a coordinate transformation (the mirror map) is performed (when N = k). In this way he proved the mirror symmetry conjecture, namely that topological sigma models on Calabi–Yau manifolds realized as complete intersections in projective space can be solved by the analysis of hypergeometric series. His proof of the symmetry seems to rely on the flat metric condition, namely on the fact that the three point functions which include the identity operator do not receive quantum correction. His arguments are quite powerful and deep, but we can hardly see what is happening microscopically. The original motivation of the present paper was an attempt to prove (1.1) by descending induction on N, see [6]. Our program is to construct recursive formulas that ∗ (M k ) as weighted homogeneous polynomials in express the structural constants of Hq,e N k ∗ the structural constants of Hq,e (MN+1 ). Our method is based on a geometric process, which we call the specialization procedure, but unfortunately it works only up to the case of cubic curves. We believe that it should be possible to find and construct universal recursive laws also for curves of higher degree. We state some ansatz on the expected structure of such formulas. The main expected property says that if the index N − k ≥ 2 then the recursive laws should stay the same, independently of N and k. When the hypersurface is of Fano index 1 then the recursion law for the Schubert numbers of lines changes, while the formulas for curves of higher degree do not. Coming to the Calabi– Yau situation, N = k, the recursion relation is modified for all degrees. In this case the main relation of (1.1) must be changed entirely. ∗ (M N ) and evaluated We first computed the recursion relation for lines in case of Hq,e N the degree 1 part of the relation [16]. The result had a structure strongly reminiscent of the situation from mirror symmetry [18] and we speculated that the above correction and the correction terms argued in [18] are closely related. On the other hand the universal recursion laws valid for the case N − k ≥ 2 can be formally iterated by descent of dimension (while keeping the degree of the hypersurface fixed) twice more down to the case of a Calabi–Yau. What we conjecture here, and verify in part, is that this formal procedure yields the coefficients of the hypergeometric series which appear in the mirror
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
159
calculation, but without use of the mirror conjecture. At this point the construction of the structure constants for the quantum ring of the Calabi–Yau hypersurface can be realized by the standard procedure that arises from the flat metric condition. Coming back to the main relation above, we can prove it modulo (q 4 ) as follows. We construct explicit recursion relations for d ≤ 3 and start the descending induction where N is large enough with respect to the fixed degree k so that the only non-trivial quantum corrections comes from lines. This procedure yields (1.1) and 2. We expect that the universal recursive procedure should provide interesting information also for the case when MNk is a hypersurface of general type, i.e. N < k. Our paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2 we recall first the main properties of the structure of the quantum Kähler ∗ (M k ) and then we study the quantum product with primitive cohomology algebra Hq,e N classes for the Fano case, k < N. In Sect. 3 we introduce the specialization calculation and derive the recursion relations for rational curves of degree at most 3 under the assumption that the hypersurface is a Fano manifold. In Sect. 4 we try to extend the specialization procedure to Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces and determine how the recursion laws should be modified up to degree 2. Using this we evaluate the main relation of the quantum ring and compare it with the result from mirror symmetry. We find here the motivation to organize our findings in a compact form by means of the hypergeometric series used in mirror calculation. At this point some computations induce us to state a conjecture which says how to modify the recursion relation for cubic curves in the Calabi–Yau case. In Sect. 5 we present a set of conjectures which should provide a guiding rule in the explicit construction of the recursive formulas for rational curves of higher degree. Assuming the conjectures we can explicitly construct the recursive formulas for degree four.
2. Quantum Cohomology of Fano Hypersurfaces ∗ (M k ). Let M k be the generic and non-singular 2.1. The quantum Kähler sub-ring Hq,e N N hypersurface of degree k in CP N−1 . By the Lefschetz theorem the cohomology ring H ∗ (MNk ) splits into two parts. One of them is the Kähler sub-ring generated by the Kähler form e induced from the hyperplane section H of CP N −1 , and the other is the primitive part, which is a subspace of the middle dimension cohomology H N −2 (MNk ). ∗ (M k ). It is generated additively by We first consider the quantum Kähler sub-ring Hq,e N Oeα (α = 0, 1, 2, · · · N − 2), where Oeα represents the BRST- closed operator induced ∗ (M k ) are determined by means of from eα ∈ H ∗ (MNk ). The multiplication rules of Hq,e N the flat metric and the three point correlation functions (or Gromov–Witten invariants): N,k ηαβ αβ
Z := hOe0 O Oeβ iM k = eα
N
k MN
eα ∧ eβ = k · δα+β,N −2 ,
1 · δα+β,N−2 , k Z ∞ X = hOeα Oeβ Oeγ iM k = qd αβ
N,k = δγα , ηN,k = ηN,k ηβγ N,k Cα,β,γ
N
d=0
(2.1) (2.2)
k
M ¯ N M 0,d,3
φ1∗ (eα ) ∧ φ2∗ (eβ ) ∧ φ3∗ (eγ ). (2.3)
160
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji k
¯ MN represents the moduli space of stable maps from 3-pointed Here q := exp(t), M 0,d,3 k
¯ MN → M k . genus 0 curves to MNk and φi is the natural i th evaluation morphism M 0,d,3 N Mk
¯ N is the space of rational curves of degree d with three punctures in M k . Basically M 0,d,3 N The rules of quantum multiplication are N,k η γ δ Oe δ = Oeα · Oeβ = Cα,β,γ
∞
X 1 N,k,d 1 N,k q d Cα,β,γ OeN −2−γ . Cα,β,γ OeN −2−γ := k k
(2.4)
d=0
∗ (M k ), and therefore One should note that Oe is a multiplicative generator of Hq,e N it is enough to determine the multiplication rule between Oe and Oeα . The topological N,k is non-zero only if 1 + α + β = N − 2 + (N − k)d, hence selection rule yields that C1αβ it is:
Oe · Oeα =
∞ X d=0
1 N,k,d q d C1,α,N−3−α+(N −k)d Oeα+1−(N −k)d . k
(2.5)
For conventional reasons, we rewrite (2.5) as follows: Oe · OeN −2−m = OeN −1−m + LN,k,d m
∞ X d=1
q d LN,k,d OeN −1−m−(N −k)d , m
1 N,k,d := C1,N −2−m,m−1+(N−k)d . k
(2.6)
∗ (M k ) coincides with the classical cohoHere we have used the fact that q 0 part of Hq,e N
are the structure constants of the quantum ring. One mology ring. The integers LN,k,d m should think of kLN,k,d as the number of rational curves of degree d on MNk which meet a m linear section of dimension m and a second linear section of the right (= m+(N −k)d−1) are independent of N if N ≥ k + 2, and therefore codimension. We shall see that LN,k,1 m we write them simply as Lkm ; we refer to them as the Schubert number of lines. Note that Lkm = Lkk−m−1 . Gromov–Witten invariants of genus 0 vanish by insertion of Oe0 . Since MNk is a N −2 dimensional manifold we obtain: 6 = 0 H⇒ 1 ≤ N − 2 − m ≤ N − 2, 1 ≤ m − 1 + (N − k)d ≤ N − 2 LN,k,d m ⇐⇒ max{0, 2 − (N − k)d} ≤ m ≤ min{N − 3, N − 1 − (N − k)d}. (2.7) These vanishing conditions translate into 6 = 0 H⇒ 0 ≤ m ≤ (N LN,k,d m H⇒ 1 ≤ m ≤ (N H⇒ 0 ≤ m ≤ (N H⇒ 2 ≤ m ≤ (N
− 1) − (N − k)d (N − k ≥ 2), − 3) (N − k = 1, d = 1), − 1) − (N − k)d (N − k = 1, d ≥ 2), − 3) (N − k = 0).
(2.8)
We remark explicitly that if the dimension N is large with respect to k (N ≥ 2k) then the only non trivial quantum correction left is due to curves of degree 1.
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
161
As we said above Oe is a multiplicative generator of the ring, and then there are coefficients γ which give the representations: OeN −1−m = (Oe )N−1−m −
∞ X d=1
q d γmN,k,d (Oe )N −1−m−(N−k)d .
(2.9)
∗ (M k ). One has When we set m = 0 we obtain the main relation of Hq,e N
Oe · ((Oe )N−2−m −
∞ X d=1
= (Oe )N−1−m −
∞ X d=1
+ −
∞ X d=1 ∞ X
N,k,d q d γm+1 (Oe )N −2−m−(N −k)d )
q d γmN,k,d (Oe )N −1−m−(N−k)d
LN,k,d q d (Oe )N−1−m−(N−k)d m
d 0 =1
0 N,k,d 0 0 q d γm+(N−k)d (Oe )N−1−m−(N−k)(d+d ) ,
(2.10)
and therefore it is N,k,d = LN,k,d − γmN,k,d − γm+1 m
d−1 X d 0 =1
0
0
N,k,d LN,k,d−d γm+(N m −k)(d−d 0 ) .
(2.11)
This yields: γmN,k,d
=
d X
X
l=1 Pl
l−1
(−1)
i=1 di =d
N −1−(N X−k)d
···
jl =m
j2 j3 X X
l Y
j2 =m j1 =m
i=1
! LN,k,dPi i−1 ji +( n=1 dn )(N−k)
.
(2.12) ∗ (M k ) is of the form of (O )N −1 −k k (O )k−1 ·q = 0 The fact that the main relation of Hq,e e e N [16,11] is equivalent to
γ0N,k,1 =
N−1 X j =1
γ0N,k,d =
LN,k,1 = kk , j
d X
X
l=1 Pl
(−1)l−1
i=1 di =d
(d ≥ 2).
N −1−(N X−k)d
···
jl =0
j2 Y j3 X l X j2 =0 j1 =0 i=1
LN,k,dPi i−1 ji +(
n=1 dn )(N−k)
= 0.
(2.13)
162
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
2.2. The role of primitive cohomology. In this subsection we consider the general structure of the quantum cohomology ring of a Fano hypersurface V of degree k in Pn+1 (n ≥ 3) including the primitive part. It is H2 (V , Z) = Zq, where kq is the class of a plane section, and H 2 (V , Z) is spanned by the class x(:= e) of the hyperplane section H . The ring H ∗ (V , Q) is generated by x and by the primitive cohomology H n (V , Q)0 , with the relations x n+1 = 0, x ∪ a1 = 0, R −1 n a1 ∪ a2 = k V (a1 ∧ a2 )x for aR1 , a2 primitive classes. We shall denote by ( | )V the intersection form, hence (a|b)V = V a ∧ b. For 0 ≤ i ≤ n, xi (:= ei ) is the class of the linear section of V of codimension i, so that x = x1 . The vectors xi span the invariant part R of H ∗ (V , Q), which is the orthogonal complement of H n (V , Q)0 . We recall that the Fano index of V is h P = h(V ) = n + 2 − k. Let Z{H2 (V , Z)} be the graded homogeneous ring of formal series nd q d with integer coefficients. One introduces a ring structure on α ∗ , β ∗ in H ∗ (V , Z) the quantum H ∗ (V , Z{H2 (V , Z)}) by the rule that for P homogeneous ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ d multiplication product is α · β = l (α , β )d q , where (α ∗ , β ∗ )0 is the ordinary cohomology product, and (α ∗ , β ∗ )d is a class of degree deg(α ∗ )+deg(β ∗ )−2hd defined by the condition ((α ∗ , β ∗ )d |γ ) = [α ∗ , β ∗ , γ ; d; V ](= hOα ∗ Oβ ∗ Oγ iV ,d,gravity ). This last term is the GW invariant, which can be informally defined as the number of rational curves of degree d on V meeting the representative submanifold A,B,G in general position. We shall use the associativity and the grading properties of ·, whose rigorous and highly non-trivial construction is due to Ruan and Tian [27]. We recall some facts from [28]. Tian observed that the GW classes [α1 , . . . , αl ; d; V ] are invariant under monodromy action, which is a direct corollary of the main result in [27], and he applied this explicitly to cases like hypersurfaces by using the Picard-Lefschetz theorem. Proposition 1 (Tian). If m − l is odd and as are primitive classes then [xi1 , . . . , xil , al+1 , . . . , am ; d; V ] = 0. Proof. The statement holds when n is odd P for trivial reasons, indeed by definition [xi1 , . . . , xil , al+1 , . . . , am ; j ; V ] = 0 if 2( ij )+(m−l)n 6 = 2n+2hd +2(m+l −3). Coming to the case when the hypersurface V is even dimensional, we recall that the monodromy group M is generated by reflections defined by the vanishing cycles. The case of even dimensional quadrics is readily checked, since the vanishing cohomology has rank one in this case. On the other hand if n > 3 and k > 3, by the same argument explained in p.384 of [26], a lemma of Deligne yields that the Zariski closure M¯ is in fact the full group of isometries of H ∗ (V , C)0 . Thus the GW invariant above defines a symmetric multilinear form with an odd number of entries, invariant under the orthogonal group. It is clear that such a form vanishes. u t If h ≥ 2 Tian’s result yields x · a = 0, for a ∈ H n (V , Q)0 . Instead we have Proposition 2. If h = 1 then x · a = k!aq. Proof. The statement is equivalent to [x, a1 , a2 ; 1] = −k!(a1 |a2 )V ; here ai are primitive classes and [x, a1 , a2 ; 1] is the GW number of the lines which meet them. Our proof of this equality is based on a remark of Beauville, [1, 4, Application II]. In this direction we also need to prove the formula below, which is a generalization of a result of Tyurin, [29, 3] and [22]. Let W be a general hypersurface whose generic hyperplane section is V . Then the Fano variety F (W ) of lines on W is a non-singular irreducible of dimension k and there are k! lines on W which meet a general point, [22]. The variety F (V ) is a nonsingular subvariety of codimension 2 in F (W ). The natural P 1 bundle p : L → F (W )
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
163
surjects λ : L → W with degree k!. We denote by γ : BF → V the restriction of λ to V , where γ has degree k!. Then β : BF → F (W ) is the blow up along F (V ) and the projection of the exceptional divisor π : E → F (V ) is the restriction of p. We denote here i : E → BF and j : V → W the natural inclusions. The cohomology of a blow up decomposes as a direct sum, in our case H ∗ (BF, Q) = i∗ π ∗ (H ∗−2 (F (V ), Q)) ⊕ β ∗ (H ∗ (F (W ), Q)). Now γ∗ H ∗ (BF, Q) → H ∗ (V , Q) is a surjection, because γ : BF → V is. It is known that the primitive cohomology is contained in the image (γ i)∗ π ∗ (H ∗−2 (F (V ), Q)), [22]. We need the stronger result that given a primitive class a there is a class α with γ ∗ (a) = i∗ π ∗ α. To prove this statement we first note that it is equivalent to β∗ γ ∗ (a) = 0, and then we consider a cycle A which represents a and which is in general position with respect to the locus covered by the lines on V . We have β∗ γ ∗ (A) = β∗ (λ∗ (j∗ (A)) ∩ BF ), and then j∗ (A) = 0 in H n+2 (W, Q)) because primitive classes are annihilated by j∗ . Fix next the primitive classes a1 and a2 so that γ ∗ a1 = i∗ π ∗ α1 , γ ∗ a2 = i∗ π ∗ α2 . One has equality of degrees of intersection (γ ∗ a1 |γ ∗ a2 )BF = k!(a1 |a2 )V , because the degree of γ is k!. On the other hand the excess intersection formula of [9] yields (i∗ π ∗ α1 |i∗ π ∗ α2 )BF = −(π ∗ α1 |π ∗ α2 · ζ )E = −(α1 |α2 )F (V ) , here ζ denotes the tautological class of E as a P 1 bundle, and ζ is known to be the opposite of the class of the normal bundle of E in BF . Thus k!(a1 |a2 )V = −(α1 |α2 )F (V ) . Now it is geometrically clear, and is the idea from [1], that [x, a1 , a2 ; 1] = (π∗ i ∗ γ ∗ a1 |π∗ i ∗ γ ∗ a2 )F (V ) = (α1 |α2 )F (V ) . Tian’s vanishing implies also that the quantum product of the hyperplane class with a linear section is of type X ad,s xs−dh q d , x · xs−1 = xs + i≥1
where ad,s = k −1 [xs−1 , xn+dh−s , x; d] are the structure constants. We set w := x +k!q, if h = 1, and otherwise w := x, and we write ws the s th power of w with respect to the quantum product. Then w satisfies a unique minimal monic equation F = 0, of degree(n+1), the equation which is found by setting s = n+1 in the displayed P[(n+1)/ h] cd w n+1−dh q d . For primitive formula. This is of the form F := w n+1 + d=1 P [n/ h] classes a and b we have a·b = k −1 (a|b)V (w n + d=1 bd w n−dh q d ). Following Tian we P[n/ h] note that associativity yields 0 = (w·a)·b = k −1 (a|b)V (w n+1 + d=1 bd wn+1−dh q d ), and thus cd = bd for 1 ≤ d ≤ n, cn+1 = 0. Beauville in [1] studied the structure of the quantum ring of Fano hypersurfaces of degree small with respect to the dimension. Beauville’s result deals with the case n ≥ 2k − 3, in this case only the coefficient c1 6 = 0. Now −c1 is the sum of the Schubert numbers of lines on V , and it turns out that −c1 = k k hence: Theorem 1. The quantum cohomology of V over the rational numbers is generated by w and H n (V , Q)0 with relations (i) wn+1 = k k w k−1 q, (ii) w · a = 0, (iii) a · b = k −1 (a|b)V (w n − k k wk−2 q). This theorem in fact always holds, the hardest part (i) is a deep theorem of Givental [11], while (ii) and (iii) follow from the same arguments used before. u t
164
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
3. Recursion Relations for the Structure Constants of Fano Hypersurfaces This section is devoted to the proof of the following recursion laws and of some related results: Theorem 2. Consider a hypersurface MNk in CP N −1 of degree k; if the 1st Chern class N − k ≥ 2 then the basic structure constants satisfy the following recursion relations: = LN+1,k,1 =: Lkm , LN,k,1 m m 1 +1,k,1 +1,k,1 = (LN+1,k,2 + LN+1,k,2 + 2LN · LN LN,k,2 m m m m+(N−k) ), 2 m−1 1 +1,k,3 (4LN+1,k,3 = + 10LN+1,k,3 + 4LN LN,k,3 m m m−2 m−1 18 +1,k,1 N +1,k,2 + 12LN+1,k,2 · LN+1,k,1 · LN m−1 m+2(N−k) + 9Lm m+2(N−k)
(3.1) (3.2)
+ 6LN+1,k,2 · LN+1,k,1 m m+1+2(N−k) +1,k,2 N +1,k,1 + 6LN+1,k,1 · LN+1,k,2 · LN m−1 m−1+(N −k) + 9Lm m−1+(N−k)
+ 12LN+1,k,1 · LN+1,k,2 m m+(N −k) N +1,k,1 + 18LN+1,k,1 · LN+1,k,1 m m+(N −k) · Lm+2(N−k) ).
(3.3)
Our arguments are heuristic. We embed X := MNk as the linear section of a general k in CP N so that hypersurface Y := MN+1 k ∩ H, MNk = MN+1
(3.4)
where the hyperplane H is identified with CP N −1 . Next we introduce the notation N N hOea1 Oea2 · · · Oeam iM k ,d,gravity = [AN a1 , Aa2 , · · · , Aam ; d, N, k]. N
(3.5)
N −1 and in general Here the spaces AN ai are linear subspaces of codimension ai in CP position, so that k P DM k (eai ) = AN ai ∩ MN . N
(3.6)
We introduce below the “special position” correlation functions, N +1 N +1 ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H, · · · , AN+1 G[AN+1 a1 a2 am ∩ H, Aam+1 , · · · , Aam+n ; d, N + 1, k]. (3.7)
∩ H ’s is a linear subspace in CP N of codimension ai + 1 which lies Clearly AN+1 ai N−1 = H . The special position correlation function should count the number in CP of rational curves of degree d on Y with m labeled points on them which belong to the corresponding linear spaces and which have the further property that points with different labels stay distinct. By taking the linear spaces in general position in CP N −1 we may N +1 N +1 ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H, · · · , AN+1 assume that [AN+1 a1 a2 am ∩ H, Aam+1 , · · · , Aam+n ; d, N, k] has no contribution from reducible curves on X. Now an irreducible curve of degree d which cuts H in d + 1 points lies on it and then
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
165
N N [AN a1 , Aa2 , · · · , Aad+1 ; d, N, k] + R +1 ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H, · · · , AN = G[AN+1 a1 a2 ad+1 ∩ H ; d, N + 1, k],
(3.8)
where R measures the contributions due to the connected reducible curves on Y which satisfy the conditions. In the cases that we consider, R does not occur for lines and conics and it is a finite set for the case of cubic curves, as we compute below. For curves of degree 4 or more the family of reducible curves supporting R may be of positive dimension and we are not able to determine the contribution due to them. For this reason we shall restrict to the case of curves of degree d at most equal to 3. The following lemma, the specialization formula, gives a procedure for computing the N+1 N+1 degree of G[AN+1 a1 ∩ H, Aa2 ∩ H, · · · , Aad+1 ∩ H ; d, N + 1, k], because by definition N+1 N+1 N+1 +1 N +1 N +1 G[Aa1 +1 , Aa2 +1 , · · · , Aam +1 ; d, N +1, k] = [AN a1 +1 , Aa2 +1 , · · · , Aam +1 ; d, N +1, k]. N+1 By moving AN+1 as+1 +1 into Aas+1 ∩ H one has Lemma 1. N +1 N +1 ∩ H, · · · , AN+1 ∩ H, AN+1 G[AN+1 a1 as as+1 +1 , Aas+2 +1 , · · · , Aas+t +1 ; d, N + 1, k] N +1 N +1 ∩ H, · · · , AN+1 ∩ H, AN+1 = G[AN+1 a1 as as+1 ∩ H, Aas+2 +1 , · · · , Aas+t +1 ; d, N + 1, k] + s X j =1
N+1 N +1 N +1 G[AN+1 ∩ H, · · · , AN+1 ∩ H, a1 aj −1 ∩ H, Aaj +as+1 ∩ H, Aaj +1 ∩ H, · · · , Aas
N+1 AN+1 as+2 +1 , · · · , Aas+t +1 ; d, N + 1, k].
(3.9)
Here we explain the definition of the special position G-W invariants. Given a projective variety Z Kontsevich [20] has constructed the coarse moduli ¯ space M¯ := M(Z, m, β) of stable maps of homology class β to Z. M¯ is the set of equivalence classes of data [C, p1 , . . . , pm , µ], where µ : C → Z is the “stable” map, C is a varying, projective, connected, nodal curve of arithmetic genus 0, and p1 , . . . , pm are distinct, labeled nonsingular points on C. We refer to [10] for a detailed discussion of this construction. The canonical evaluation maps ρi : M¯ → Z are defined ¯ m, β) by ρi ([C, p1 , . . . , pm , µ]) = µ(pi ). The interior M(Z, m, β) is the locus in M(Z, ¯ corresponding to nonsingular irreducible domain curves. We write M(Z, A, β) when the index set of labels is a set A instead of [n] = {1, . . . , n}. There are forgetful ¯ ¯ A, β) → M(Z, A − B, β), defined when B is a subset of A. Let maps φB : M(Z, now Z be a general non-singular Fano hypersurface of dimension n ≥ 3 and of index h(Z) = n + 2 − deg(Z). We consider the case when β is the class of a curve of degree d ¯ and we assume that M(Z, m, d) has the expected dimension dimZ +dh(Z)+m−3 and similarly for the boundary components. We recall that such components are associated with the choice of a partition A ∪ B of the set [m] := {1, . . . , m} and of the choice of d1 ¯ and d2 with d = d1 + d2 . The boundary component D(A, B; d1 , d2 ) is defined as the locus of moduli points corresponding to reducible domain curve C = C1 ∪ C2 , where µ∗ (Ci ) has degree di . Here the curve C is obtained by gluing at • the curve C1 which has on it points marked by the elements in A and a further point, labeled by •. and C2 , which has on it points marked by the elements in B and a further point, also labeled by •. ¯ ¯ ¯ B ∪ {•}, d2 ). A ∪ {•}, d1 ) ×Z M(Z, There is an identification D(A, B; d1 , d2 ) = M(Z, In what follows we take n + 2 = N and define Ti , i = 1, . . . , m to be linear spaces of codimension ti ≥ 1 in P n+2 and in general position there. As before Y
166
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
P is a Fano hypersurface of degree k. We assume that ti is the expected dimension ¯ dimY + dh(Y ) + m − 3 of M(Y, m, d). We define [t1 , . . . , tm ; d, Y ] to be the degree of the zero cycle [T1 , . . . , Tm ; d, Y ], which we define to be the intersection product of the cycles ρi−1 (Ti ). Here we assume that those cycles intersect transversally in a finite number of points, each one of which is associated with an irreducible source curve and with the property that the corresponding map sends different labeled points to different images. By definition [t1 , . . . , tm ; d, Y ] is one of the GW invariants of Y , and it is called basic if m = 3 and if at least one of the ti is 1. The GW invariants on X are defined in a similar way, by means of linear spaces Si ⊂ P n+1 . We shall use the convention that Si and Ti are spaces of the same dimension, so that Si is obtained by moving Ti into P n+1 . Given linear spaces as above we write G[S1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+1 , . . . , Ts+t ; d; Y ] to rep¯ resent the open cycle in M(Y, s + t, d) which can be informally described as the set of rational curves of degree d on Y with s + t marked points such that the images of the labeled points pj belong to the space with the same label, T and such that for j ≤ s and i ≤ s if pj and pi have the same image point in Sj Si then this point is a double point for the image curve. We shall use the notation that si is the codi= ti − 1, because mension of Si in P n+1 so that si P P of our convention. The codimension of the preceding cycle is j (sj + 1) + j tj . Our aim is to compute the degree of G[S1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+1 , . . . , Ts+t ; d; Y ] when its expected dimension is 0. By abuse of notations we shall often use the same notation to represent both a cycle of dimension 0 and the degree of the said cycle. We define M¯ 0 (s) to be the complement ¯ ¯ in M¯ := M(Y, s + t, d) of the union of the components of type D(A, B; d1 , d2 ) with d2 = 0 and with at least two elements of B which are ≤ s. Thus we have ¯ The evaluation ρi restricts to ρ(s)0 on M¯ 0 (s). Our definiM¯ 0 (s + 1) ⊂ M¯ 0 (s) ⊂ M. i tion is that G[S1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+1 , . . . , Ts+t ; d; Y ] is the intersection product of the cycles (ρ(s)oj )−1 (Sj ),j = 1, . . . s, (ρ(s)ol )−1 (Tl ), l = s + 1, . . . , s + t. If the codimensions sj and tl are fixed the set of lists (S1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+1 , . . . , Ts+t ) is parameterized by a product of Grassmann manifolds, hence it is an irreducible variety and then there is an open dense subset of it where the degree of G[S1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+1 , . . . , Ts+t ] is maximum. We shall assume that our lists come from this subset. We start by noting that [S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; X] and G[S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; Y ] both have the same expected dimension, which we take to be 0. Proposition 3. If the given cycles are zero dimensional then G[S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; Y ] = [S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; X] + R, ¯ where R is supported on the boundary locus of M(Y, m, d) and more precisely on the locus corresponding to reducible domain curves with reducible image. In order to compute the degree of [S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; X] we need to verify that the dimension of the preceding cycles is in fact 0 and then to compute their degrees. Now we have by assumption that [S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; X] has the correct dimension 0, so the dimension of G[S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; Y ] can fail to be also = 0 only if R fails. Of course the dimension of R can be detected by looking at decomposable curves on Y ; that is to the behavior of rational curves of degree strictly less than d. As we have said above the degree of G[S1 , . . . , Sd+1 ; d; Y ] is determined by a reduction procedure, which is performed by moving linear spaces Ti which are in general position in P n+2 to spaces Si of the same dimension, which are contained in the hyperplane P n+1 and in general position there. Our main tool is the next proposition; we have only heuristic arguments to support it.
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
167
Proposition 4. Provided that the dimensions of the cycles below are 0 as it is expected then degree G[S1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+1 , . . . , Ts+t ; d; Y ] = degree G[S1 , . . . , Ss , Ss+1 , Ts+2 , . . . , Ts+t ; d; Y ] X + degree ψi−1 G[S1 , . . . , Si−1 , Si,s+1 , Si+1 , . . . , Ss , Ts+2 , . . . , Ts+t ; d; Y ], ¯ + t] − {i, s + 1}, {i, s + where Si,s+1 := Si ∩ Ss+1 and where ψi is the isomorphism D([s ¯ 1}; d, 0) → M(Y, ([s + t] − {i, s + 1}) ∪ {•}, d). The specialization lemma is just a restatement of this proposition. The following procedure gives the recursive formulas: +1 ∩ H, AN +1 ∩ 1. By iterative application of the specialization formula we write G[AN a b N+1,d−1 ∩H, · · · , A ∩H ; d, N +1, k] in terms of the standard correlation H, AN+1,1 1 1 k . functions of Y = MN+1 2. We decompose the standard correlation functions found in Step 1 as polynomials in the basic G-W invariants of Y , by which we mean the functions
hOea Oeb Oe id,M k
N +1 ,gravity
.
This step is done by means of the first reconstruction theorem of Kontsevich and Manin or, equivalently, by the microscopic version of the DWVV equations. +1 ∩ H, AN +1 ∩ H , 3. We compute the contribution of reducible curves in G[AN a b N+1,d−1 AN+1,−1 ∩ H, · · · , A ∩ H ; d, N + 1, k]. 1 1 The 1st step gives next equalities. In writing them we use the convention that if the number of insertion points gets lower than 3 then we insert an hyperplane condition and divide by the degree of the curve: ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H ; 1, N + 1, k] G[AN+1 a b N+1 N +1 = [AN+1 a+1 , Ab+1 ; 1, N + 1, k] − [Aa+b+1 ; 1, N + 1, k]
(a + b = N − 3 + (N − k)),
∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H ; 2, N + 1, k] G[AN+1 a 1 b N+1 N+1 +1 N +1 ; 2, N + 1, k] − [AN = [AN+1 a+1 , Ab+1 , A2 a+2 , Ab+1 ; 2, N + 1, k] N+1 − [AN+1 a+1 , Ab+2 ; 2, N + 1, k] N+1 +1 ; 2, N + 1, k] + 2[AN − [AN+1 a+b+1 , A2 a+b+2 ; 2, N + 1, k]
(a + b = N − 3 + 2(N − k)),
168
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
+1,2 G[AN+1 ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H, AN+1,1 ∩ H, AN ∩ H ; 3, N + 1, k] a 1 1 b
N+1,1 N+1 , AN+1,2 ; 3, N + 1, k] = [AN+1 a+1 , Ab+1 , A2 2
N+1 N+1 +1 N +1 N +1 ; 3, N + 1, k] − 2[AN ; 3, N + 1, k] − 2[AN+1 a+1 , Ab+2 , A2 a+2 , Ab+1 , A2
N+1,1 +1 N +1 N +1 , AN+1,2 ; 3, N + 1, k] − [AN ; 3, N + 1, k] − [AN+1 2 a+1 , Ab+1 , A3 a+b+1 , A2
N+1 N+1 N +1 + 2[AN+1 a+1 , Ab+3 ; 3, N + 1, k] + 2[Aa+2 , Ab+2 ; 3, N + 1, k] N+1 + 2[AN+1 a+3 , Ab+1 ; 3, N + 1, k]
N+1 N +1 ; 3, N + 1, k] + [AN+1 ; 3, N + 1, k] + 4[AN+1 a+b+2 , A2 a+b+1 , A3
− 6[AN+1 a+b+3 ; 3, N + 1, k] (a + b = N − 3 + 3(N − k)).
(3.10)
We assume now that the Fano index of X is at least 2, namely N − k ≥ 2, then a + b + 1 k ) + 1, and therefore (3.10) is truncated in an obvious is greater than N = dim(MN+1 +1 N +1 N +1 way. At this point we recall the definition [AN a1 , Aa1 , · · · , Aam ; d, N + 1, k] = hOea1 Oea2 · · · , Oeam id,M k ,gr . In order to proceed we need to express N +1
hOea Oeb Oe2 id,M k
N +1 ,gr
and hOea Oeb Oe3 id,M k
N +1 ,gr
in terms of hOea Oeb Oe id,M k ,gr . Our tool is the first reconstruction theorem of KontN +1 sevich and Manin [21], and it yields hOea Oeb Oem ihOeN −1−m Oe Oe i hOea Oeb Oem ihOeN −1−m Oe2 Oe i hOea Oeb Oe2 Oem ihOeN −1−m Oe Oe i = hOea Oe Oe2 Oem ihOeN −1−m Oeb Oe i
= = + +
hOea Oe Oem ihOeN −1−m Oeb Oe i, hOea Oe2 Oem ihOeN −1−m Oeb Oe i, hOea Oeb Oem ihOeN −1−m Oe2 Oe Oe i hOea Oe Oem ihOeN −1−m Oeb Oe2 Oe i. (3.11)
We find in the end, if the Fano index of X is at least 2: 1 N+1 G[AN+1 N−2−m ∩ H, Am−1+(N−k) ∩ H ; 1, N + 1, k] k := Lkm , (3.12) = LN+1,k,1 m 1 N+1 N +1 ∩ H ; 2, N + 1, k] G[AN+1 N−2−m ∩ H, Am−1+2(N−k) ∩ H, A1 k 1 +1,k,1 + LN+1,k,2 + 2LN+1,k,1 · LN (3.13) = (LN+1,k,2 m m m+(N−k) ), 2 m−1 1 N +1,1 +1,2 N+1 G[AN+1 ∩ H, AN ∩ H ; 3, N + 1, k] 1 N−2−m ∩ H, Am−1+3(N−k) ∩ H, A1 k 1 + 10LN+1,k,3 + 4LN+1,k,3 = (4LN+1,k,3 m m−2 m−1 6 +1,k,1 N+1,k,2 + 12LN+1,k,2 · LN+1,k,1 · LN m−1 m+2(N−k) + 12Lm m+2(N−k) + 6LN+1,k,2 · LN+1,k,1 m m+1+2(N−k) N+1,k,1 N +1,k,1 + 6LN+1,k,2 + 12LN+1,k,2 m−1+(N−k) · Lm−1 m−1+(N−k) · Lm
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
169
N+1,k,1 + 12LN+1,k,2 m+(N−k) · Lm N+1,k,1 +1,k,1 + 18LN · LN+1,k,1 m m+(N−k) · Lm+2(N−k) ).
(3.14)
We make the hypothesis that the Schubert varieties of conics and lines on Y and on X which are associated with the given linear spaces Si , Tj and their intersections have the right dimension. A count of dimensions shows that for the cases of degree 1 and degree 2 there is no contribution from the reducible curves and therefore N+1 N,k,1 G[AN+1 N−2−m ∩ H, Am−1+(N−k) ∩ H ; 1, N + 1, k]/k = Lm
and N+1 N+1 ∩ H ; 2, N + 1, k]/k = LN,k,2 . G[AN+1 m N−2−m ∩ H, Am−1+(N−k) ∩ H, A1
For cubic curves there is a contribution due to the reducible connected curves which are made of a line lying on X and of a conic lying on Y . There are two cases which occur, in one instance the line meets AN+1 N−2−m ∩ H , and the conic meets the line and N+1 Am−1+3(N −k) ∩ H . In the other case the incidence conditions with the linear spaces are reversed. In this way N+1,1 +1,2 N+1 ∩ H, AN ∩ H ; 3, N + 1, k]/k G[AN+1 1 N −2−m ∩ H, Am−1+3(N−k) ∩ H, A1
+R = 3LN,k,3 m
1 k
1 1 +1,k,2 + LN+1,k,2 · LN,k,1 + LN · LN,k,1 . = 3LN,k,3 m m m+2(N−k) 2 2 m−1+(N−k) m
t u
(3.15)
We come now to the case of Fano index 1. The same type of computations as above yield: Theorem 3. If X is a hypersurface of degree k in CP k the recursion relations for the basic invariants of conics and cubic curves are the same as given in Theorem 1, instead the numbers of lines satisfy the law = Lk+2,k,1 − Lk+2,k,1 = Lk+2,k,1 − k!. Lk+1,k,1 m m m 0
(3.16)
Proof. In this case, a + b + 1 = N − 2 + d, from (3.10). Then we obtain ∩ H, AN+1 ∩ H ; 1, N + 1, k] [AN+1 a b
N+1 N +1 = [AN+1 a+1 , Ab+1 ; 1, N + 1, k] − [AN −1 ; 1, N + 1, k] (a + b + 1 = N − 1). t u
(3.17)
Now we can prove: Corollary 1. The main relation of the quantum ring of a Fano hypersurface MNk with index N − k ≥ 2 is of the form (Oe )N−1 − k k (Oe )k−1 q = 0 up to q 3 .
(3.18)
170
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
Proof. The recursion relations of Theorem 2 do not change γ0N,k,d , namely γ0N,k,d = γ0N+1,k,d . If N ≥ 2k + 1, then γ0N,k,d = 0(d ≥ 2), because of the vanishing conditions due to the topological selection rule.On the other hand γ0N,k,1 = k k , from Schubert calculus cf. [1]. u t Corollary 2. The main relation of the quantum cohomology ring of a Fano hypersurface of index 1 and dimension k − 1 is of the form (Oe + k!q)k − k k (Oe + k!q)k−1 q = 0
(3.19)
up to q 3 . Proof. Consider the multiplication rule (2.6): Oek−1−m + Oe · Oek−1−m := Oek−m + qLk+1,k,1 m
∞ X d=2
q d Lk+1,k,d Oek−m−d . (3.20) m
This gives: + k!)Oek−1−m + (Oe + k!q) · Oek−1−m = Oek−m + q(Lk+1,k,1 m = Oek−m +
∞ X d=1
∞ X d=2
q d Lk+1,k,d Oek−m−d m
q d L˜ k+1,k,d Oek−m−d . m
(3.21)
Set now F = Oe + k!q, use F as a multiplicative generator and write k−m
Oek−m = (F )
−
∞ X d=1
q d γ˜mk+1,k,d (F )k−m−d (m = 0, 1, · · · , k − 1).
(3.22)
A standard computation yields γ˜0k+1,k,d = γ0k+2,k,d , and we conclude by descending induction as in the proof of the preceding corollary. u t Our last result is also easily proved by descending induction on N . can be written as Corollary 3. If d ≤ 3 and N − k ≥ 1) the structure constants LN,k,d m a homogeneous polynomial of degree d in the structure constants of lines Lkm . 4. Recursive Formulas in the Calabi–Yau Case Here we try to understand how the recursive formulas change when the hypersurface becomes of Calabi–Yau type, i.e. when we deal with Mkk of degree k in CP k−1 . In this situation we can proceed as before for lines and conics. On the other hand we cannot use the same method for curves of degree 3, because it is difficult in this case to control the contribution from reducible curves. We give instead conjectural recursive formulas for cubics. In the last part of the section we explain the trend of thought which led us to the conjecture. We recall first that given a general point on Mkk there are no rational curves meeting k,k,d = Lk,k,d = Lk,k,d it, and therefore Lk,k,d 0 1 k−1 = Lk−2 = 0.
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
171
Theorem 4. The recursive laws for lines and conics on a Calabi–Yau hypersurface of degree k are for 2 ≤ m ≤ k − 3, = Lk+1,k,1 − Lk+1,k,1 , Lk,k,1 m m 1 1 Lk,k,2 = (Lk+1,k,2 + Lk+1,k,2 − Lk+1,k,2 − Lk+1,k,2 m m 0 1 2 m−1 k+1,k,1 2 k+1,k,1 +2(Lm − L1 ) ).
(4.1)
(4.2)
Proof of Theorem 4. We go back to the specialization formula (3.10), which we use with the condition a + b = N − 3 because now we have N = k. Repeated use of the first reconstruction theorem yields 1 k+1 G[Ak+1 k−2−m ∩ H, Am−1 ∩ H ; 1, k + 1, k] k − Lk+1,k,1 , = Lk+1,k,1 m 1 1 k+1 k+1 ∩ H ; 2, k + 1, k] G[Ak+1 k−2−m ∩ H, Am−1 ∩ H, A1 k 1 + Lk+1,k,2 − Lk+1,k,2 − Lk+1,k,2 = (Lk+1,k,2 m 0 1 2 m−1 k+1,k,1 k+1,k,1 k+1,k,1 + 2Lm · (Lm − L1 )).
(4.3)
(4.4)
Next we check the contribution from reducible curves. For lines there are no reducible curves, so that 1 k+1 k,k,1 G[Ak+1 k−2−m ∩ H, Am−1 ∩ H ; 1, k + 1, k] = Lm . k
(4.5)
In case of conics, the reducible curves are given by two intersecting lines, one lying on k k , hence it is ∩ H and the other on Mk+1 Mkk = Mk+1 1 k+1 k+1 G[Ak+1 ∩ H ; 2, k + 1, k] k−2−m ∩ H, Am−1 ∩ H, A1 k + Lk+1,k,1 · Lk,k,1 = Lk,k,2 m m . 1
(4.6)
t u =0 Next we deal with cubic curves, the Calabi–Yau condition implies again Lk,k,3 m for 0 ≤ m ≤ 1, k − 2 ≤ m ≤ k − 1, our proposal for the remaining m is the following: Conjecture 1. The recursive law for curves of degree 3 on Mkk and for 2 ≤ m ≤ k − 3 becomes: = Lk,k,3 m
1 (4Lk+1,k,3 + 10Lk+1,k,3 + 4Lk+1,k,3 m m−2 m−1 18 − 10Lk+1,k,3 − 4Lk+1,k,3 0 1 + 12Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 + 12Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 m m m m−1 + 6Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 m m+1
+ 6Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 + 12Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 m m−1 m−1 m−1 + 12Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 m m
172
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
+ 18(Lk+1,k,1 − Lk+1,k,1 )2 · (Lk+1,k,1 + 2Lk+1,k,1 )) m m 1 1 1 k+1,k,2 k+1,k,1 1 k+1,k,2 k+1,k,1 − Lm−1 · Lm − Lm · Lm 6 6 3 3 − Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 − Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 m m 4 0 4 1 5 5 − Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 − Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 1 1 12 1 12 0 1 − Lk+1,k,2 · Lk+1,k,1 2 3 1 1 − 3Lk+1,k,1 · (Lk+1,k,2 + Lk+1,k,2 − Lk+1,k,2 − Lk+1,k,2 m 1 0 1 2 m−1 k+1,k,1 2 k+1,k,1 + 2(Lm − L1 ) ).
(4.7)
We came to this formula by means of the following considerations. Using Theorem 4 ∗ (M k ) up to degree 2, this reads: one can compute the main relation of Hq,e k (1 − (k k − (k − 2)Lk1 − 2Lk0 )q − (2k k Lk0 + (k − 3)k k Lk1 − 3(Lk0 )2 − (2k − 6)Lk1 Lk0 − k k − 2 k+1,k,2 2 L1 − Lk+1,k,2 − )q − · · · )(Oe )k−1 = 0. 0 2 2
(k − 3)(k − 2) k 2 (L1 ) 2 (4.8)
On the other hand one has from [18] and [16] that the main relation can be written using the k − 2 point correlation function of the pure matter theory in the form Qk−2
h
k
j =1 Oe (zj )iM k ,matter
(Oe )k−1 = 0,
(4.9)
k
and that it is h
k−2 Y j =1
Oe (zj )iM k ,matter = k + k k+1 (1 − 2a1 − (k − 2)(b1 ))q k
+ k 2k+1 (1 − 2a1 − b1 + 3(a1 )2 − 2a2 + 2a1 · b1 (k − 2)(k − 3) + (k − 2)(−b1 + 4a1 · b1 + 2(b1 )2 − 2b2 ) + (b1 )2 )q 2 + · · · . 2 (4.10) Here ad =
(kd)! , (d!)k k kd
bd = ad (
k−1 d X X i=1 m=1
m ) i(ki − m)
are the coefficients of the hypergeometric series associated to the solutions W0 (x) =
∞ X d=0
ad edx ,
W1 (x) =
∞ X d=1
bd edx + W0 (x)x,
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
173
of the differential equation ((
1 d 2 d k−1 d d k−1 ) + )( + )···( + ))Wi (x) = 0. − ex ( dx dx k dx k dx k (4.11)
By comparison of (4.8) with (4.10), we notice the following equalities: k k a1 = Lk0 , k k b1 = Lk1 , 1 + 2(Lk0 )2 ), k 2k a2 = (Lk+1,k,2 2 0 1 + Lk+1,k,2 + 2Lk1 Lk1 ) + Lk1 Lk0 . k 2k b2 = (Lk+1,k,2 0 4 1
(4.12)
These equalities can be organized more systematically by means of generating functions. To this aim we need: be the integer obtained by applying Definition 1. For arbitrary N and k let L˜ N,k,d m formally the recursive laws of Theorem 2. x x ˜ k,k Remark. One should note: (i) L˜ k,k i (e ) = Lk−1−i (e ), (ii) if the index N − k is at least N,k,d must be the ordinary structural constant LN,k,d of the Fano hypersurface. 2 then L˜ m m
Now we can rewrite (4.12) as , k k a1 = L˜ k,k,1 0 k,k,1 k k b1 = L˜ , 1
, k a2 = L˜ k,k,2 0 1 k 2k b2 = L˜ k,k,2 + L˜ k,k,1 · L˜ k,k,1 . 1 0 2 1 2k
(4.13)
After having performed some numerical computations, we have noticed that also the following relations should hold true: , k 3k a3 = L˜ k,k,3 0 1 1 + L˜ k,k,2 · L˜ k,k,1 + L˜ k,k,1 · L˜ k,k,2 . k 3k b3 = L˜ k,k,3 0 1 0 3 1 2 1
(4.14)
Consider next the generating functions: ˜ := 1 + L˜ k,k i (q)
∞ X d=1
q˜ d , L˜ k,k,d i
q˜ := ex ,
(4.15)
and define t := x + (
∞ X
∞ X bj k e )/( aj k kj ej x ).
j =1
j =0
kj j x
(4.16)
174
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
The preceding equalities motivate us to expect: ˜ = L˜ k,k 0 (q)
∞ X j =0
dt x aj k kj ej x , L˜ k,k . 1 (e ) = dx
(4.17)
˜ automatically gives the information of the B-model on the Thus, we expect that Lk,k m (q) mirror manifold of Mkk without using the mirror conjecture. We use the virtual structure ˜ to define a virtual quantum product determined by the action of a ring constants L˜ k,k m (q) generator G which operates according to the rules: x m G · Oem−1 = L˜ k,k k−1−m (e )Oe , (m = 1, 2, · · · , k − 2) G · Oek−2 = 0.
(4.18)
x We note the relation G = G · 1 = L˜ k,k k−2 (e )Oe . We expect that the structure constants of the virtual action satisfy the following equality, which in fact may be checked up to q˜ 3 using the recursive laws for the Fano case: k−1 Y i=0
x k x −1 L˜ k,k i (e ) = (1 − k e ) ,
(4.19)
and this yields the relation: x 2 k−1 = 0. (1 − k k ex ) · (L˜ k,k 0 (e )) · (G)
(4.20)
Note that multiplicative factor in (4.20) is nothing but the reciprocal of the generalized Yukawa coupling of the B-model [18]. On the other hand the true quantum cohomology ring satisfies a similar multiplication rule: Oe · 1 = Oe ,
t m (m = 2, 3, · · · , k − 2), Oe · Oem−1 = Lk,k k−1−m (e )Oe Oe · Oek−3 = Oek−2 , Oe · Oek−2 = 0, where ∞ X k,k t Lk,k,d edt . Li (e ) := 1 + i
(4.21)
(4.22)
d=1
t We can compute Lk,k i (e ) in concrete examples using the method of torus localization. See [17] for details and results. Now we search for a transformation rule to pass from the virtual to the true quantum multiplication. To this aim we find it useful to introduce a formal definition:
Definition 2. The commutative product (∗) between differential operators of the form dm f (x) dx m is given by: (f (x)
dn d m+n dm ) ∗ (g(x) ) = (f (x) · g(x)) . dx m dx n dx m+n
(4.23)
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
175
d d Given the coordinate change x = x(t) we define a map from dx operators to dt operators by means of the rule
f (x)
dt m d m dm ) → f (x(t))( . dx m dx dt m
(4.24)
At this point we can relate the quantum product laws using as an intermediate step the product of differential operators. To start we propose the correspondence Oe =
d d , G= . dt dx
(4.25)
Then one has d x m ∗ Oem−1 = L˜ k,k k−1−m (e )Oe , (m = 1, 2, · · · , k − 2), dx d ∗ Oek−2 = 0, dx
(4.26)
and d ∗ 1 = Oe , dt
d t m (m = 2, 3, · · · , k − 3), ∗ Oem−1 = Lk,k k−1−m (e )Oe dt d d ∗ Oek−3 = Oek−2 , ∗ Oek−2 = 0. dt dt
(4.27)
It follows from (4.26): d x ˜ k,k x d = dt · d . ∗ 1 = L˜ k,k k−2 (e ) · Oe = Lk−2 (e ) · dx dt dx dt
(4.28)
This equality suggests that (4.26) and (4.27) become isomorphic if we use the transformation of differential operators defined above. Compare now the coefficients for Oeα in (4.26) with (4.27), then the wished isomorphism yields the equality α Y
x(t) dx (L˜ k,k ) )= k−1−j (e dt
j =1
α Y j =1
t Lk,k k−1−j (e ).
(4.29)
We find in this way the transformation laws that we were looking for; they are: x(t) ) L˜ k,k dx i (e t = L˜ k,k = Lk,k (ex(t) ) i i (e ). k,k x(t) dt L˜ (e )
(4.30)
1
This is the rule that provides the recursive formulas for curves of arbitrary degree d on the Calabi–Yau hypersurface Mkk once we know the recursive formulas for curves up to degree d on Fano hypersurfaces. At this point we obtain the recursive formulas for cubics in Conjecture 1 by means of elementary calculations.
176
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
Example. The true quantum cohomology ring of the quintic Calabi–Yau threefold is: Oe · 1 = Oe , Oe · Oe = Oe2 (1 + 575et + 975375e2t + 1712915000e3t + · · · ), O e · O e 2 = Oe 3 , Oe · Oe3 = 0.
(4.31)
while the associated virtual ring is: G · 1 = Oe (1 + 770ex + 1435650e2x + 3225308000e3x + · · · ), G · Oe = Oe2 (1 + 1345ex + 3296525e2x + 8940963625e3x + · · · ),
G · Oe2 = Oe3 (1 + 770ex + 1435650e2x + 3225308000e3x + · · · ), G · Oe3 = 0.
(4.32)
Using (4.30) we find that: 575 = 1345 − 770, (4.33) 975375 = 3296525 − 1435650 + 770 · 770 (4.34) − 1345 · 770 − 770 · (1345 − 770), 1712915000 = 8940963625 − 3225308000 + 2 · 770 · 1435650 − 7703 + 1345 · (770)2 − 1345 · 1435650 − 3296525 · 770 − 2 · 770 · (3296525 − 1435650 + 770 · 770 − 1345 · 770) 1 3 (4.35) + ( · (770)2 − · 1435650) · (1345 − 770). 2 2 5. On the Construction of the Recursive Formulas for Rational Curves of Larger Degree Motivated by the preceding results, we begin this section by proposing some conjectures. They are strong enough to allow in principle the construction of the expected recursive formulas for curves of higher degree, and we explicitly produce the law for the d = 4 case. Conjecture 2. There are universal recursive polynomial laws which express the structure +1,k,n on a Fano variety in terms of LN (1 ≤ n ≤ d). The formulas constants LN,k,d m m have the following properties: 1. The form of the recursive polynomials is invariant if the index N − k ≥ 2, and the equality γ0N,k,d = γ0N+1,k,d for the coefficients in the fundamental relations is a consequence of them. 2. If N − k = 1 the recursive formulas change only for the case of lines, i.e. d = 1. represents the result of a formal We keep the notations of Sect. 4, so that L˜ N,k,d m x iteration of the recursive functions for fixed k down to any chosen N, and then L˜ k,k m (e ) is the associated generating function.
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
177
Conjecture 3. Formal iteration of the laws of Conjecture 2 for descending N down to the case N = k yields the coefficients of the hypergeometric series used in the mirror calculation, i.e., it should be , k dk ad = L˜ k,k,d 0 k dk bd =
d−1
1 ˜ k,k,d X 1 ˜ k,k,m ˜ k,k,d−m L L + · L0 . d 1 m 1
(5.1)
m=1
The same procedure gives the structure constants of the quantum cohomology ring of the Calabi–Yau hypersurface of degree k, according to the rule t Lk,k i (e ) =
x(t) ) L˜ k,k i (e . L˜ k,k (ex(t) )
(5.2)
1
Here we set
dt x := L˜ k,k 1 (e ). dx
Remark. It is an immediate consequence of the conjectures and of the vanishing conis a polynomial of degree d in the ditions of Sect. 2 that the structure constant LN,k,d m constants Lkm , N ≥ k. We proceed now to the construction of the recursive formulas for the case d = 4. Our method is based on the expectation that the specialization procedure gives if not the right coefficients at least the right monomials which appear in the recursive laws. We formalize this below with a conjecture. We start by constructing some technical formulas for the factorization of the Gromov– Witten invariants. P Let {n∗ } := {n1 , n2 , · · · , nl } and ind({n∗ }) = lj =1 (nj − 1). We formally define ind({∅}) to be 0. We have a formula for the correlation functions (Gromov–Witten invariants) of the topological sigma model on MNk +1 coupled to gravity, which reads: k −1 h·Oea Oen1 Oen2 · · · Oenl Oeb id,M k
N +1 ,gr
=
d1 d X X d1 =0 d2 =0 ind({n Y∗ }) i=0
dind({n∗ })−1
···
X
C d ({n∗ }; d1 , d2 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) )
dind({n∗ }) =0 N+1,k,d −d
i i+1 Ln+1−a−i+(N −k+1)(d−di ) ,
d0 := d, N − k + 1 ≥ ind({n∗ }) + 1.
(5.3) (5.4)
The coefficients C d ({n∗ }; d1 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) ) which appear here have the following properties: C d ({m}; d1 , · · · , dm−1 ) = 1, d
(5.5) d
C ({n∗ } ∪ {1}; d1 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) ) = dC ({n∗ }; d1 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) ).
(5.6)
178
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
One can determine C d ({n∗ }; d1 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) ) by means of the recursive relation, C d ({n∗ }; d1 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) ) X (C d−dind({l∗ })+nl −1 ({l∗ } ∪ {nl − 1}; d1 − dind({l∗ })+nl −1 , = {l∗ }q{m∗ }={n∗ }/{nl }
{m∗ }6=∅
· · · , dind({l∗ })+nl −2 − dind({l∗ })+nl −1 ) ·
C dind({l∗ })+nl −1 ({m∗ }; d1+ind({l∗ })+nl −1 , · · · , dind({n∗ }) ) · dind({l∗ })+nl −1 )
+ C d−dind({n∗ }) ({n∗ }\{ne } ∪ {nl − 1}; d1 − dind({n∗ }) , · · · , dind({n∗ })−1 − dind({n∗ }) ). (5.7) Proof. We prove (5.7) by induction of ind({n∗ }). We denote Oen1 Oen2 · · · Oenl as Oe{n∗ } for brevity. The first reconstruction theorem of KM yields: X
d X
{l∗ }q{m∗ }
d0 =0
={n∗ }/{nl }
k −1 hOea Oe{l∗ } Oeb Oenl +ind({m∗ })−(N −k+1)d0 id−d0 ,gr · · k −1 hOeind({l∗ })−(N −k+1)(d−d0 )+a+b Oe{m∗ } Oenl −1 Oe id0 ,gr
=
X
d X
{l∗ }q{m∗ }
d0 =0
={n∗ }/{nl }
k −1 hOea Oe{l∗ } Oenl −1 Oeb+1+ind({m∗ })−(N −k+1)d0 id−d0 ,gr · · k −1 hOea−1+nl +ind({l∗ })−(N −k+1)(d−d0 ) Oe{m∗ } Oe Oeb id0 ,gr . (5.8)
The l.h.s. of (5.8) has the contribution of d0 = 0 and of {m∗ } = {∅} because ind({n∗ }) − (N − k + 1)d0 ≤ −1, (d0 ≥ 1) and because the classical correlation function remains non-zero only if the number of the operator insertion point equals 3. Then we have (the l.h.s.) of (5.8) = k −1 hOea Oe{n∗ } Oeb id,gr .
(5.9)
On the other hand, we can rewrite the r.h.s. of (5.8) from the assumption of induction, d d−d X X0
X
(
{l∗ }q{m∗ }={n∗ }/{nl } d0 =0 t1 =0 {m∗ }6=∅
ind({l∗Y })+nl −2 i=0
(
d0 X u1 =0
ind({m Y∗ }) j =0
···
X
C d−d0 ({l∗ } ∪ {nl − 1}; t1 , · · · , tind({l∗ })+nl −2 ) ·
tind({l∗ })+nl −2 =0
N+1,k,t −t
i i+1 Ln+1−a−i+(N−k+1)(d−d )· 0 −ti )
uind({l∗ })−1
···
tind({l∗ })+nl −3
X
d0 C d0 {m∗ }; u1 , · · · , uind({m∗ }) ) ·
uind({l∗ }) =0 N+1,k,u −u
j j +1 Ln+1−a+1+ind({l ) ∗ })−j +(N−k+1)(d−d0 )+(N−k+1)(d0 −uj )
(5.10)
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces d d−d X X0
X
+
179
···
{l∗ }q{m∗ }={n∗ }/{nl } d0 =0 t1 =0 {m∗ }6=∅
tind({n∗ })−2
X
C d−d0 ({n∗ }\{ne } ∪ {nl − 1}; t1 ,· · ·, tind({n∗ })−1 ) ·
tind({n∗ })−1 =0
·
ind({n ∗ })−1 Y i=0
N+1,k,t −t
N+1,k,t −t
i i+1 i i+1 Ln+1−a−i+(N−k+1)(d−d · Ln+1−a−ind({n . ∗ })+(N−k+1)(d−d0 ) 0 −ti )
t Then an appropriate change of ti ’s and ui ’s leads to (5.7). u The specialization process can be done systematically employing the formula: [Aa1 −1 ∩ H, Aa2 −1 ∩ H, · · · , Aad+1 −1 ∩ H ; d, N + 1, k] d+1 X
=
X
(−1)d+1−m ([Aind(U1 )+1 , Aind(U2 )+1 , · · · , Aind(Um )+1 ; d, N + 1, k] ·
m=1 qm j =1 Uj ={a∗ } Uj 6=∅
·(
m Y
(] (Uj ) − 1)!)).
(5.11)
j =1
We apply formally the process of specialization to quartic curves. Combining (5.7) with (5.11), we obtain: +R 16LN,k,4 n 13 13 3 3 = L4n−3 + L4n−2 + L4n−1 + L4n 2 2 2 2 + 2L1n−2 L3n−2+N−k + 2L1n−1 L3n−2+N −k + 6L1n L3n−2+N −k + 8L1n−1 L3n−1+N−k + 12L1n L3n−1+N −k + 6L1n L3n+N −k + 3L2n−2 L2n−1+2(N−k) + 7L2n−1 L2n−1+2(N−k) + 6L2n L2n−1+2(N−k) + 10L2n−1 L2n+2(N−k) + 7L2n L2n+2(N−k) + 3L2n L2n+1+2(N−k) + 6L3n−2 L1n+3(N−k) + 12L3n−1 L1n+3(N −k) + 6L3n L1n+3(N −k) + 8L3n−1 L1n+1+3(N−k) + 2L3n L1n+1+3(N−k) + 2L3n L1n+2+3(N−k) + 4L1n−1 L1n−1+N−k L2n−1+2(N−k) + 9L1n L1n−1+N −k L2n−1+2(N−k) + 10L1n L1n+N−k L2n−1+2(N−k) + 12L1n L1n+N −k L2n+2(N−k) + 8L1n−1 L2n−1+N−k L1n+3(N−k) + 14L1n L2n−1+N −k L1n+3(N −k) + 14L1n L2n+N−k L1n+3(N−k) + 8L1n L2n+N −k L1n+1+3(N−k) + 12L2n−1 L1n+2(N−k) L1n+3(N−k) + 10L2n L1n+2(N−k) L1n+3(N −k) + 9L2n L1n+1+2(N−k) L1n+3(N−k) + 4L2n L1n+1+2(N−k) L1n+1+3(N−k) + 16L1n L1n+N−k L1n+2(N−k) L1n+3(N −k) .
(5.12)
180
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
+1,k,d Here and further down we drop N +1, k from LN for simplicity. We determine next n the contribution from the connected reducible curves R indirectly, namely by means of a conjecture on the structure of the recursive formulas which is motivated by the results that we have found for curves of degree up to 3.
Conjecture 4. The prototype result obtained from the specialization exhausts all the addends that appear in the “true” recursive formula and the coefficients described by the following generating polynomial remain unchanged after subtraction of the contribution from “R” term:
d−1 Y
(
j =1
j x + (d − j )y + zj ). d
(5.13)
Examples. d=2 d=3 d=4
x+y ) + z1 , 2 2x + y 2x 2 + 5xy + 2y 2 x + 2y )+( )z1 + ( )z2 + z1 z2 , ( 9 3 3 3x 3 + 13x 2 y + 13xy 2 + 3y 3 ) ( 32 3x 2 + 10xy + 3y 2 3x 2 + 4xy + y 2 x 2 + 4xy + 3y 2 )z3 + ( )z2 + ( )z1 +( 8 16 8 3x + y x+y x + 3y +( )z1 z2 + ( )z1 z3 + ( )z2 z3 4 2 4 + z1 z2 z3 . (5.14) (
The remaining unknown coefficients are found by means of the constraints that they must satisfy. One condition is that the recursive laws must be compatible with the main relation of the Kähler sub-ring, i.e. with (Oe )N −1 − k k (Oe )k−1 q = 0. We use also the symmetry of the recursive formulas arising from the equality LN,k,d = LN,k,d n N −1−(N−k)d−n . 1 As a result the only unknown coefficients left are the ones of Ln−1 L3n−2+N −k and of L1n L3n−1+N −k . By symmetry they coincide with the coefficients of L3n L1n+1+3(N −k) and of L3n−1 L1n+3(N −k) respectively. Using the condition imposed by the main relation we find that their sum must be 7/9. Everything is reduced to the computation of the coefficient of L1n−1 L3n−2+N−k . Now we have already the recursive laws for the curves of degree at most 3, and then iterated use of the recursive formula (with the unknown coefficients) from N ≥ 2k region (in this region, what we need is only the Schubert numbers !) down to the N = k region yields linear functions on the remaining unknown coefficients. At this point the information that we have about the coefficients of the hypergeometric series ad and bd in Conjecture 3 provide us with an infinite number of linear relations, by varying k.
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
181
Using these arguments we compute that the coefficient of L1n−1 L3n−2+N−k is 1/6. We have thus obtained the law for curves of degree 4: = 32−1 (3L4n−3 + 13L4n−2 + 13L4n−1 + 3L4n ) LN,k,4 n
+ 72−1 (9L1n−2 L3n−2+N−k + 12L1n−1 L3n−2+N−k + 16L1n L3n−2+N −k + 36L1n−1 L3n−1+N−k + 44L1n L3n−1+N −k + 27L1n L3n+N −k )
+ 16−1 (3L2n−2 L2n−1+2(N−k) + 6L2n−1 L2n−1+2(N−k) + 4L2n L2n−1+2(N−k) + 10L2n−1 L2n+2(N−k) + 6L2n L2n+2(N−k) + 3L2n L2n+1+2(N−k) ) + 72−1 (27L3n−2 L1n+3(N−k) + 44L3n−1 L1n+3(N−k) + 16L3n L1n+3(N −k) + 36L3n−1 L1n+1+3(N−k) + 12L3n L1n+1+3(N −k) + 9L3n L1n+2+3(N−k) ) + 12−1 (3L1n−1 L1n−1+N−k L2n−1+2(N −k) + 4L1n L1n−1+N −k L2n−1+2(N−k) + 6L1n L1n+N−k L2n−1+2(N−k) + 9L1n L1n+N −k L2n+2(N−k) ) + 6−1 (3L1n−1 L2n−1+N−k L1n+3(N−k) + 4L1n L2n−1+N −k L1n+3(N−k) + 4L1n L2n+N−k L1n+3(N−k) + 3L1n L2n+N −k L1n+1+3(N −k) ) + 12−1 (9L2n−1 L1n+2(N−k) L1n+3(N −k) + 6L2n L1n+2(N−k) L1n+3(N −k) + 4L2n L1n+1+2(N−k) L1n+3(N−k) + 3L2n L1n+1+2(N−k) L1n+1+3(N−k) ) + L1n L1n+N−k L1n+2(N−k) L1n+3(N−k) .
(5.15)
We have checked numerically that this formula is compatible with the previous conjecture (3.1) on the relation satisfied by the coefficients ad and bd . We have also checked that the formula for quartic curves yields the right Gromov–Witten invariant for the quintic threefold when we use the same conjecture. Remark. Looking at the recursive laws for the Fano case established so far, we expect that the number of addends appearing in the laws for degree d is the number of monomials of degree d in d variables, (2d − 1)!/(d!(d − 1)!). Of course the procedure that we have used for the determination of the recursive formula for d = 4 is in principle applicable to any d. For example we have also determined the recursive formula for d = 5. See (hep-th 9611053), the web version of this paper. On the other hand a general description of the coefficients that appear in the conjectural recursive formula of arbitrary degree is still an open problem. 6. Conclusion In this paper, we proved the property that up to degree 3 the correlation functions of the hypersurfaces MNk in CP N−1 (N ≥ k) can be written as polynomial functions of a finite number of integers Lkm . For instance in the quintic case these numbers are 1345, 770, 120. In proving this, we have found certain recursive formulas that are invariant in the c1 (MNk ) ≥ 2 region. They yield the “bare” B-model or “bare” coordinates of the deformation space of the complex structure of the mirror manifold associated to Mkk . This completely agrees with the results of Givental, which say that in the c1 (MNk ) ≥ 2 region the sigma models on (MNk ) can be solved with the hypergeometric series without
182
A. Collino, M. Jinzenji
coordinate transformation i.e., (the bare deformation parameter is good coordinate of the A-model) and that in the Calabi–Yau case, one has to transform the bare coordinate by the mirror map. In sum one can see the B-model as the toric quantum cohomology compatible with the toric compactification of the moduli space of the pure matter theory. In the Calabi–Yau case one has to introduce the mirror map to compensate for the gap between the toric compactification of the moduli space of the pure matter theory and the exact moduli space. These conclusions agree with the arguments of [24]. Possibly the case of complete intersections in projective space can be achieved by changing the input integers Lkm . One may try to search for the generalization of our arguments to the case of complete intersections in weighted projective spaces. Acknowledgement. A. C. thanks A. B. Givental, J. Lewis, C. Peters, S. A. Strømme, G. Tian, A. Tyurin. M. J. thanks T. Eguchi, K. Hori, A. Matsuo, M. Kobayashi, members of Algebraic Geometry Group in Dept. of Mathematical Science in Tokyo Univ., M. Nagura andY. Sun for discussions and kind encouragement. A.C. has been partially supported by Science Project Geom. of Alg. Var. n. 0-198-SC1 , and by fundings from M.U.R.S.T. and G.N.S.A.G.A. (C.N.R.) Italy. M. J has been supported by a grant of Japan Society for Promotion of Science.
References 1. Beauville, A.: Quantum cohomology of complete intersections. Mathematical, Physics Analysis and Geometry 168, 384–398 (1995) 2. Bertram, A.: Quantum Schubert Calculus. To appear in Advances in Mathematics 3. Bloch-Murre: On the Chow group of certain types of Fano threefolds. Compositio Math. 39, 47–105 (1979) 4. Candelas, P. and de la Ossa, X.: Nucl. Phys. B355, 415 (1991) 5. Candelas, P., de la Ossa, X., Green, P. and Parkes, L.: Phys. Lett. 258B, 118 (1991); Nucl. Phys. B359, 21 (1991) 6. Collino, A.: Some computations on the quantum cohomology algebra of a Fano hypersurface. Informal draft (1996) 7. Dubrovin, B.: The geometry of 2D topological field theories. In: Integral systems and quantum groups. LNM 1620, Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1996, pp. 120–348 8. Ellingsrud, Strømme, S.A.: Bott’s formula and enumerative geometry. J. AMS 9, n. 1, 175–193 (1996) 9. Fulton, W.: Intersection Theory. Ergebnisse der Math. und ihrer Grenzgebiete 3. Folge Band 2, Berlin– Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1984 10. Fulton and Pandharipande: Notes on stable maps and quantum cohomology. In: Proceedings of symposia in pure mathematics: Algebraic geometry Santa Cruz 1995, (J. Kollar, R. Lazarsfeld, D. Morrison eds.) Volume 62, Part 2, Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society, pp. 45–96 11. Givental, A.B.: Equivariant Gromov–Witten Invariants. Internat. Math. Res. Notices 13 613–663 (1996) 12. Greene, B.R., Morrison, D.R. and Plesser, M.R.: Mirror Manifolds in Higher Dimension. Commun. Math. Phys. 173, 559–598 (1995) 13. Griffiths, P. and Harris, J.: Principles of Algebraic Geometry. New York: Wiley, 1978 14. Hosono, S.,Klemn, A.,Theisen, S. and Yau, S.T.: Mirror Symmetry, Mirror Map and Applications to Calabi–Yau Hypersurfaces. Commun.Math.Phys. 167, 301–350 (1995) 15. Intriligator, K.: Fusion residues. Modern Physics letters A6 Number 38, 3543–3556 (1991) 16. Jinzenji, M.: On Quantum Cohomology Rings for Hypersurfaces in CP N −1 . J. Math. Phys. 38, 5775– 5802 (1997) 17. Jinzenji, M.: Construction of Free Energy of Calabi–Yau Manifold embedded in CP N −1 via Torus Actions. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A12, 5775–5802 (1997) 18. Jinzenji, M. and Nagura, M.: Mirror Symmetry and An Exact Calculation of N − 2 point Correlation Function on Calabi–Yau Manifold embedded in CP N −1 . Int. J. Mod. Phys. A11, 171–202 (1996) 19. Keel, S.: Intersection theory of moduli spaces of n-stable pointed curves of genus zero. Trans. Am, 330, 545–574 (1992) 20. Kontsevich, M.: Enumeration of Rational Curves via Torus Actions. In: The moduli space of curves, R.Dijkgraaf, C.Faber, G.van der Geer (Eds.), Progress in Math., 129, Basel–Boston: Birkhäuser, 1995, pp. 335–368 21. Kontsevich, M., Manin,Y.: Gromov–Witten Classes, Quantum Cohomology, and Enumerative Geometry. Commun. Math. Phys. 164, 525–562 (1994)
Quantum Cohomology Rings of Projective Hypersurfaces
183
22. Lewis, J.: The cylinder correspondence for hypersurfaces of degree n in P n . Am. J. of Math. 110, 77–114 23. Li, J.,Tian, G.: Quantum Cohomology of Homogeneous Varieties. alg/geom/9504009 24. Morrison, D.R. and Plesser, M.R.: Summing the Instantons: Quantum Cohomology and Mirror Symmetry in Toric Varieties. Nucl. Phys. B440, 279–354 (1995) 25. Nagura, M. and Sugiyama, K.: Mirror Symmetry of K3 Surface. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A10, 233 (1995) 26. Persson, U., Peters, C.: Some aspects of the topology of algebraic surfaces. Israel Mathematical conference Proceedings Vol. 9, 377–392 (1996) 27. Ruan, Y., Tian, G.: A mathematical theory of quantum cohomology. J. Diff. Geom. 42 no.2, (1995) 28. Tian, G.: Quantum cohomology and its associativity. In: Proc. of 1st Current Developments in Math., Cambridge: Cambridge International Press, 1995 29. Tjurin, A. N.: Five lectures on three-dimensional varieties. (Russian) Uspehi Mat. Nauk 27 no. 5, (167), 3–50 (1972) 30. Vafa, C.: Topological Mirrors and Quantum Rings. hep-th/9111017 31. Witten, E.: Mirror Manifolds and Topological Field Theory. In: Essays on Mirror Manifolds, ed. S.-T.Yau, Hong Kong: Int. Press. Co., 1992, pp. 120–180 Communicated by R. H. Dijkgraaf
Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 185 – 233 (1999)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 1999
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials Saeed Zakeri? Department of Mathematics, SUNY at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, NY 11794, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 29 August 1998 / Accepted: 19 March 1999
Abstract: We study the one-dimensional parameter space of cubic polynomials in the complex plane which have a fixed Siegel disk of rotation number θ , where θ is a given irrational number of Brjuno type. The main result of this work is that when θ is of bounded type, the boundary of the Siegel disk is a quasicircle which contains one or both critical points of the cubic polynomial. We also show that these boundaries vary continuously as one moves in the parameter space. This is most nontrivial near the set of cubics with both critical points on the boundary of their Siegel disk. We prove that this locus is a Jordan curve in the parameter space. Most of the techniques and results can be generalized to polynomials of higher degrees. Contents 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Cubic Parameter Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Components of the Interior of M(θ) . . . . . . . . . . . Renormalizable Cubics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quasiconformal Conjugacy Classes . . . . . . . . . . . Connectivity of M(θ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Critical Parametrization of Blaschke Products . . . . . . A Blaschke Parameter Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Surgery . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Blaschke Connectedness Locus C(θ) . . . . . . . . Continuity of the Surgery Map . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Renormalizable Blaschke Products . . . . . . . . . . . Surjectivity of the Surgery Map . . . . . . . . . . . . . Siegel Disks with Two Critical Points on Their Boundary
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
186 189 193 199 201 203 205 208 213 216 218 221 224 229
? Current address: Department of Mathematics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6395, USA.
186
S. Zakeri
1. Introduction Let f be a polynomial of degree d ≥ 2 in the complex plane and consider the following statements: • (Ad ) “If f has a fixed Siegel disk 1 of bounded type rotation number, then ∂1 is a quasicircle passing through some critical point of f .” • (Bd ) “If f has a fixed Siegel disk 1 such that ∂1 is a quasicircle passing through some critical point of f , then the rotation number of 1 is a bounded type.” Statement (A2 ) is a theorem of Douady, Ghys, Herman and Shishikura, (Bd ) is open, even for d = 2,1 and one of the main corollaries of this work is (A3 ): Theorem. Let P be a cubic polynomial which has a fixed Siegel disk 1 of rotation number θ . Let θ be of bounded type. Then the boundary of 1 is a quasicircle which contains one or both critical points of P . In fact, we study the one-dimensional slice in the cubic parameter space which consists of all cubics with a fixed Siegel disk of a given rotation number. Many of the results apply to all rotation numbers of Brjuno type and can be generalized to polynomials of degree d ≥ 4. Siegel disks provide examples of quasiperiodic dynamics. Let p be an irrationally indifferent fixed point of a rational map f : b C→b C. This means that f (p) = p and the multiplier f 0 (p) is of the form e2πiθ , where the rotation number 0 < θ < 1 is irrational. When f is linearizable near p, the largest domain 1 on which the linearization is possible is simply-connected and is called the Siegel disk of f centered at p. Every punctured Siegel disk 1 r {p} is foliated by dynamically-defined real-analytic invariant curves. However, as we get close to ∂1, these invariant curves may become more wiggly, and in the limit we lose control of their distortion. So, a priori, we do not even know if ∂1 is a Jordan curve. The topology and geometry of the boundary of Siegel disks is a current field of research in Holomorphic Dynamics. It was conjectured by Douady and Sullivan in the early 80’s that the boundary of every Siegel disk of a rational map has to be a Jordan curve (see [D1]). To this date, this has remained an open problem, even for polynomials, even when the degree is 2. Even worse, there are very few explicit examples of polynomials for which we can effectively verify this conjecture. For instance, it is easy to see that local-connectivity of the Julia set implies the boundary of a Siegel disk to be a Jordan curve, but except for one case in the quadratic family [Pe], we do not know how to check local-connectivity of the Julia set of a rational map which has a Siegel disk (and even in that single case, the boundary being a Jordan curve is proved as a first step in the proof of local-connectivity). On the other hand, there are examples of non locally-connected quadratic Julia sets whose Siegel disks are bounded by quasicircles [H3] or indifferent linearizable germs with non locally-connected “ hedgehogs” whose Siegel disks are bounded by smooth or even quasianalytic Jordan curves [Pr2]. It is known that in any counterexample to the DouadySullivan conjecture, the boundary of the Siegel disk must either be very complicated (an indecomposable continuum) or very simple (a circle with infinitely many topologist’s sine curves planted on it) [R]. Let [a1 , a2 , . . . , an , . . . ] be the continued fraction expansion of the rotation number θ and pn /qn = [a1 , a2 , . . . , an ] be its nth rational approximation, where every an is a positive integer. According to the theorem of Brjuno–Yoccoz [Y], every holomorphic 1 Note added in proof (July 1999): Carsten Petersen has announced a proof of (B ) for d ≥ 2. d
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
187
germ with an indifferent fixed point of multiplier e2π iθ is linearizable if and only if θ satisfies the condition ∞ X log qn+1 n=1
qn
< +∞.
(1.1)
Such θ is called of Brjuno type. It is not hard to show that this set has full measure in the unit interval. The set of irrational numbers of Brjuno type contains two important arithmetic subsets: (1) numbers of Diophantine type, the set of all 0 < θ < 1 for which there exist positive constants C and ν such that |θ − p/q| > C/q ν for every rational number 0 < p/q < 1; and (2) numbers of bounded type, the set of all 0 < θ < 1 for which supn an < +∞. Another issue is the existence of critical points on the boundary of Siegel disks. This problem was first studied by Ghys under the assumption that the boundary is a Jordan curve and the rotation number is Diophantine [G]. Later Herman improved the result by showing that when the rotation number is Diophantine and the action on the boundary is injective, there must be a critical point on the boundary [H1]. A very short proof of this theorem is now possible with knowledge of “Siegel compacts” as recently introduced by Perez-Marco [Pr1] (see [Z2] for such a proof). In the case of quadratic polynomials, no critical point on the boundary of the Siegel disk automatically implies that the map acts injectively on this boundary. Hence one concludes that for θ of Diophantine type, the critical point of Qθ : z 7 → e2πiθ z + z2 is on the boundary of the Siegel disk centered at 0. Later Herman gave the first example of a θ of Brjuno type for which the boundary of the Siegel disk for Qθ is disjoint from the entire orbit of the critical point [H3]. The most significant example in which one can explicitly show that the boundary of a Siegel disk is a Jordan curve containing a critical point is the quadratic map Qθ : z 7 → e2πiθ z + z2 , with θ of bounded type. The idea, originally due to Ghys but utilized by Douady, Herman and Shishikura, is to consider the degree 3 Blaschke product z−3 2πit (θ) 2 z fθ (z) = e 1 − 3z which has a double critical point at 1 and 0 < t (θ ) < 1 is chosen such that the rotation ´ atek number of the restriction of fθ to the unit circle is θ . Using a theorem of Swi¸ and Herman on quasisymmetric linearization of critical circle maps ([Sw,H2]), one can redefine fθ on the unit disk to make it quasiconformally conjugate to the rigid rotation by angle θ. After modifying the conformal structure of the sphere on the unit disk and all its preimages, one applies the Measurable Riemann Mapping Theorem of Morrey-Ahlfors-Bers to prove that the resulting map is quasiconformally conjugate to a quadratic polynomial Q. But the image of the unit disk has to be a Siegel disk of rotation number θ for Q, and there is only one such quadratic up to an affine conjugacy, so Q must be √ conjugate to Qθ , which proves (A2 ). The Julia set of Qθ for the golden mean θ = ( 5 − 1)/2 and its self-similar properties was studied empirically by physicists in the early 80’s (see [MN,W]). For general θ of bounded type, it has been a subject of recent rigorous studies by mathematicians (see for example [Pe,GJ,Mc3,YZ]). In a very recent work [Z4], using a non-quasiconformal surgery on fθ , we find explicit arithmetical conditions on unbounded type rotation numbers θ which guarantee the Siegel disk of Qθ is a Jordan curve passing through the critical point. In any attempt to generalize (A2 ) to higher degrees, one must address several problems. In fact, the main difficulty is not the surgery which can be performed in all degrees
188
S. Zakeri
in a similar way, provided that one has the appropriate Blaschke products in hand. Instead, we have to face a different set of questions such as parametrization of the candidate Blaschke products by their critical points, combinatorics of various “drops” of their Julia sets, continuity of the surgery, and surjectivity of this operation. None of these issues arises in degree 2, where the corresponding parameter spaces are single points. In this paper we address these questions in detail for cubic polynomials although many of the arguments apply to higher degrees as well. We introduce the parameter space P cm (θ ) of critically marked cubic polynomials with a Siegel disk of a given rotation number θ of Brjuno type, which is canonically isomorphic to the punctured plane. The connectedness locus M(θ) ⊂ P cm (θ ) (the analogue of the Mandelbrot set for the quadratic family) is the set of all cubics with both critical orbits bounded (see Fig. 1). In the interior of M(θ), every cubic is either hyperbolic-like, for which the free critical point approaches an attracting cycle, or capture, for which the free critical point eventually maps into the Siegel disk, or of neither type, in which case it is called queer. (There may be no queer components. In any case, no example is known.) The presence of hyperbolic-like cubics in P cm (θ) implies the existence of copies of the Mandelbrot set all over M(θ), while captures appear as components in M(θ ) which look like Siegel disks in the dynamical plane. The most significant property of queer cubics is that their Julia sets support invariant line fields and in particular have positive Lebesgue measure (Theorem 3.4). Motivated by the Douady-Ghys-Herman-Shishikura approach, we introduce an auxiliary family of degree 5 critically marked Blaschke products which serve as models for cubics in P cm (θ) in the same way fθ does for the quadratic Qθ . We show that these Blaschke products can be parametrized by their critical points (Theorem 7.1) and we use this parametrization to define the parameter space B cm (θ ) which is also homeomorphic to the punctured plane. A connectedness locus C(θ ) ⊂ B cm (θ ) can be defined similarly. When θ is of bounded type, one can perform a quasiconformal surgery on Blaschke products in B cm (θ ) in order to obtain critically marked cubics in P cm (θ ). The result of this surgery does not depend on various choices we make along the way (Proposition 9.2), hence it gives rise to a well-defined surgery map S : B cm (θ ) → P cm (θ ). Continuity of S is far from being straightforward and depends on the fact that the parameter spaces have one complex dimension (Theorem 11.1). In fact, in higher degrees, the proof of this continuity step is the only part our techniques for cubics polynomials fail to apply. Various evidence suggest that the connectedness loci C(θ ) and M(θ ) are in fact homeomorphic. One can go even farther as to speculate that S is a homeomorphism. Although we provide some evidence to support this, we only need to show that S is surjective (Theorem 13.6) in order to get the desired results in the dynamical plane of cubics. Surjectivity follows from an injectivity result (Theorem 13.3) which in particular shows that S induces a homeomorphism between the complementary components of C(θ ) and M(θ). The proof of the injectivity result relies on various tools developed along the way, especially a renormalization scheme to “extract” Qθ from some cubics in P cm (θ ) and fθ from some Blaschke products in Bcm (θ ). Surjectivity of S proves (A3 ). As another consequence, we obtain the following Theorem. For θ of bounded type, the boundary of the Siegel disk of P ∈ P cm (θ ) is a continuous function of P in the Hausdorff topology. It is interesting to contrast this result with the fact that the Julia set of P undergoes drastic implosions near the boundary of M(θ ), especially near the set of cubics with both critical points on the boundary of their Siegel disk. We study this locus and describe its topology:
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
189
Theorem. For θ of bounded type, the set 0 of all cubics in P cm (θ ) with both critical points on the boundary of their Siegel disk is a Jordan curve. Figure 18 shows the Jordan curve 0. We conclude with a topological characterization of this set as the common boundary of the two complementary components of M(θ ) (Theorem 14.4). 2. A Cubic Parameter Space We begin by considering the space of all cubic polynomials which have a fixed Siegel disk of multiplier λ = e2πiθ centered at the origin. Here 0 < θ < 1 is a given irrational number of Brjuno type satisfying the condition (1.1). By the theorem of Brjuno–Yoccoz [Y], every holomorphic germ z 7 → e2πiθ z + O(z2 ) with θ of Brjuno type is holomorphically linearizable near 0. In particular, every cubic polynomial of the form z 7 → λz + a2 z2 + a3 z3 ,
(2.1)
with (a2 , a3 ) ∈ C × C∗ has a Siegel disk centered at the origin. We are not directly interested in the rather big space of all such cubics. Instead, we would like to consider the space of affine conjugacy classes of these cubics together with a marking of their critical points. A few words on the notion of “marking” is in order; however, we will hardly refer to the following formal definition in the rest of this paper. Roughly speaking, a marking of the critical points of a cubic P of the form (2.1) is a choice of labeling these critical points. It can be thought of as a surjective function m from the set {1, 2} to the set of critical points of P . Two such critically marked cubics (P , m) and (Q, m0 ) are affinely conjugate if there is a dilation ϕ : z 7 → αz such that ϕ ◦ P = Q ◦ ϕ and m0 = ϕ ◦ m. In other words, an affine conjugacy must also respect the markings. We denote the space of affine conjugacy classes of such critically marked cubics by P cm (θ). One way to parametrize P cm (θ) is as follows: In each conjugacy class we choose the unique critically marked cubic (P , m) whose second critical point m(2) is located at z = 1 in the complex plane. The first critical point m(1) will then be located at some point c 6 = 0. It is easy to see that such a cubic has the form 1 1 2 1 (2.2) Pc : z 7 → λz 1 − (1 + )z + z . 2 c 3c Note that using this normal form, every cubic comes automatically with a marking of its critical points. Thus (2.2) provides us with an identification P cm (θ ) ' C∗ . Under this identification, the natural Z2 -action on P cm (θ ) (swapping the markings of the critical points) corresponds to the involution c 7 → 1/c. By an abuse of notation, we often identify the cubic Pc ∈ P cm (θ) with the parameter c ∈ C∗ . The parameter space P cm (θ) has two very special points: P1 which corresponds to the conjugacy class of cubics of the form (2.1) with one critical point, and P−1 which corresponds to the conjugacy class of those cubics whose critical points are centered. The pair {P1 , P−1 } coincides with the set of fixed points of the natural Z2 -action on P cm (θ ). To understand the implication of marking the critical points, let us also consider the space P(θ ) of affine conjugacy classes of cubics of the form (2.1), this time with no particular marking. Every cubic in (2.1) can be conjugated to a monic cubic of the form z 7 → λz + az2 + z3 ,
190
S. Zakeri
where a ∈ C, and this polynomial is uniquely determined by ±a. In other words, the space P(θ ) is parametrized by the invariant ζ = a 2 ∈ C, hence it can be identified with the complex plane. Consider the map which sends every critically marked cubic in P cm (θ ) to its unique monic representative in P(θ ). This amounts to “forgetting” the markings of the critical points. It is easy to check that in the coordinates we have chosen, this map P cm (θ) → P(θ) is given by 1 2 3 . ζ = λc 1 + 4 c It follows that P cm (θ) is a double cover of P(θ ), branched over the points c = ±1. Note that by the above formula ζ (c) = ζ (1/c), as expected. Notation and Terminology. Throughout this work, the Siegel disk of the cubic Pc centered at the origin is denoted by 1c . When we do not want to emphasize the dependence on c, we denote the Siegel disk of a cubic P by 1P . By the grand orbit GO(1P ) we mean the set of all points in the plane which eventually map to the Siegel disk under the iteration of P . In other words, [ P −k (1P ). GO(1P ) = k≥0
Remark. From classical Fatou–Julia theory, we know that every point on the boundary of the Siegel disk 1c must be in the closure of the orbit of either c or 1 [M1, Corollary 11.4]. According to Herman [H1], Pc |∂1c has a dense orbit. It follows that the orbit of either c or 1 must accumulate on the entire boundary of 1c . The “size” of a Siegel disk can be measured by the following invariant: Definition (Conformal Capacity). Consider the Siegel disk 1c for c ∈ C∗ and the ' unique linearizing map hc : D(0, rc ) −→ 1c , with hc (0) = 0 and h0c (0) = 1. The radius rc > 0 of the domain of hc is called the conformal capacity of 1c and is denoted by κ(1c ). Alternatively, κ(1c ) can be described as the derivative ϕc0 (0) of the unique linearizing ' map ϕc : D −→ 1c normalized by ϕc (0) = 0 and ϕc0 (0) > 0. Naturally, one is interested in the behavior of the function c 7 → κ(1c ). This function is upper semicontinuous [Y], so a priori it can jump to a lower value, meaning that the Siegel disk 1c can shrink by a very small perturbation of the cubic Pc . Later we will see that for θ of bounded type, the closed Siegel disk 1c is a quasidisk which moves continuously in the Hausdorff topology on compact subsets of the plane (see Theorem 13.9). Therefore, in that case κ(1c ) is actually continuous as a function of c. On the other hand, for arbitrary θ of Brjuno type, I do not know if c 7 → κ(1c ) is continuous. However, we have the following general theorem of Yoccoz [Y]: Theorem 2.1. Let 0 < θ < 1 be an irrational number of Brjuno type, and set W (θ ) = P∞ n=1 (log qn+1 )/qn < ∞. Let S(θ) be the space of all univalent functions f : D → C with f (0) = 0 and f 0 (0) = e2πiθ , with the maximal Siegel disk 1f ⊂ D. Finally, define κ(θ ) = inf f ∈S(θ) κ(1f ). Then, there is a universal constant C > 0 such that | log(κ(θ )) + W (θ)| < C.
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
191
√ Fig. 1. The connectedness locus M(θ ) for θ = ( 5 − 1)/2
We obtain the following statement which will be used in Theorem 5.3. Corollary 2.2. In the family {Pc } of cubic polynomials in (2.2), the conformal capacity function c 7 → κ(1c ) is locally bounded away from 0. Definition. We define the cubic connectedness locus M(θ ) as the set of all critically marked cubics P ∈ P cm (θ) whose Julia sets J (P ) are connected. It follows from classical Fatou–Julia theory that P ∈ M(θ ) if and only if both critical points of P have bounded orbits [M1, Theorem 17.3]: M(θ ) = {c ∈ C∗ : The Julia set J (Pc ) is connected} = {c ∈ C∗ : Both sequences {Pc◦k (c)} and {Pc◦k (1)} are bounded}. Since Pc and P1/c are affinely conjugate as maps when we neglect markings of their critical points, M(θ) as a subset of the c-plane is invariant under the mapping √ c 7 → 1/c. Figure 1 shows the connectedness locus M(θ) for the golden mean θ = ( 5 − 1)/2 = 0.61803399... and Fig. 2 shows the details of the same set near the unit circle. Proposition 2.3. (a) M(θ) is compact and contained in the open annulus A( (b) The complement C∗ r M(θ) has exactly two connected components ext which are mapped to one another by c 7 → 1/c. Moreover,
1 , 30). 30 and int
ext = {c ∈ C∗ : Pc◦k (c) → ∞ as k → ∞}, int = {c ∈ C∗ : Pc◦k (1) → ∞ as k → ∞}. Later we will prove that ext (hence int ) is homeomorphic to a punctured disk. This will show that M(θ) is a connected set (Theorem 6.1).
192
S. Zakeri
Fig. 2. Details of the same connectedness locus near the unit circle
Proof. (a) M(θ) is clearly closed. Let mc = (4.38) max{|c|, 1}.
(2.3)
If |z| ≥ mc , then |Pc (z)| ≥ (
1 1 1 ( |z| − |z|)|z| − 1)|z| |c| 3 4.38
≥ (0.46|z| − 1)|z| ≥ 1.0148 |z|, from which it follows that K(Pc ) ⊂ D(0, mc ),
(2.4)
where K(Pc ) is the filled Julia set of Pc . Now if |c| ≥ 30, then 1 1 |Pc (c)| = | c − ||c| ≥ (4.5)|c| > mc , 6 2 which implies Pc◦k (c) → ∞ as k → ∞. Therefore M(θ ) ⊂ D(0, 30), hence by 1 symmetry M(θ) ⊂ A( , 30). 30 (b) Let ext be the unbounded connected component of C∗ r M(θ ). Since M(θ ) is invariant under c 7 → 1/c, there exists a corresponding component int of the complement of M(θ ) containing a punctured neighborhood of the origin. By the proof of (a), we have ext ⊂ {c ∈ C∗ : Pc◦k (c) → ∞ as k → ∞} and similarly int ⊂ {c ∈ C∗ : Pc◦k (1) → ∞ as k → ∞}.
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
193
Suppose that there exists a bounded connected component U of C∗ r M(θ ) which is not int . Then 0 < sup |c| = R < +∞. c∈∂U
If c ∈ ∂U , it follows from (2.4) that for each k ≥ 0, |Pc◦k (c)| and |Pc◦k (1)| are not greater than mc , and sup mc ≤ (4.38) max{R, 1} < +∞. c∈∂U
Since U 6 = int , we have ∂U ⊂ ∂M(θ) and both Pc◦k (c) and Pc◦k (1) are holomorphic in U as functions of c. It follows from the Maximum Principle that the iterates Pc◦k (c) t and Pc◦k (1) are uniformly bounded throughout U , which is a contradiction. u 3. Components of the Interior of M(θ) First we give the following dynamical characterization of the boundary of the connectedness locus M(θ), which is reminiscent of the similar property of the Mandelbrot set. For terminology and basic results on holomorphic motions and J -stability, see for example [Mc2]. Theorem 3.1 (Boundary of M(θ) is Unstable). The boundary ∂M(θ ) is the set of parameters for which the corresponding cubics are not J-stable in P cm (θ ). Proof. A polynomial Pc0 ∈ P cm (θ) is J -stable if and only if both sequences {Pc◦k (c)} and {Pc◦k (1)} are normal for c in a neighborhood of c0 ([Mc2, Theorem 4.2]. If c0 ∈ ext , then c0 escapes to infinity under iterations of Pc0 , while 1 has bounded orbit. For c close to c0 , the orbit of c under Pc will still converge to infinity while 1 will have bounded orbit, with a bound given by mc in (2.3). It follows from Montel’s theorem that both sequences are normal throughout a neighborhood of c0 . Hence c0 is J -stable. Similarly, every Pc0 with c0 ∈ int is J -stable. If c0 belongs to the interior of M(θ ), then both c0 and 1 will have orbits contained in D(0, mc0 ) and the same holds for all c sufficiently close to c0 . Again both sequences {Pc◦k (c)} and {Pc◦k (1)} are normal in a neighborhood of c0 . Finally, if c0 belongs to the boundary of M(θ ), then a small perturbation will make either c or 1 escape to infinity. Hence at least one of the sequences {Pc◦k (c)} or t {Pc◦k (1)} fails to be normal in any neighborhood of c0 . u Corollary 3.2. Let Pc0 ∈ P cm (θ) have an indifferent periodic orbit other than the fixed point at the origin. Then c0 ∈ ∂M(θ). Proof. Otherwise c0 will be a J -stable parameter by the above theorem. But any stable indifferent cycle has to be persistent ([Mc2, Theorem 4.2]. So the indifferent cycle (z(c0 )) 7 → z(c0 ) can be continued analytically to z(c0 ) 7 → Pc0 (z(c0 )) 7 → · · · 7 → Pc◦k−1 0 the whole plane as a function of c and the multiplier function c 7→ (Pc◦k )0 (z(c)) remains constant. This is clearly impossible, since for example when c = 3 − 6λ, Pc (c) = c is a superattracting fixed point, hence there cannot be any indifferent periodic point other than 0. u t Definition (Types of Components). A component U of the interior of M(θ ) is called hyperbolic-like if for every c ∈ U , the orbit of either c or 1 under Pc converges to an attracting cycle. U is called a capture component if for every c ∈ U , either c or 1
194
S. Zakeri
Fig. 3.
Fig. 4.
Fig. 5.
Fig. 6.
eventually maps into the Siegel disk 1c . In case U is neither hyperbolic-like nor capture, we call it a queer component. We say that Pc is hyperbolic-like, capture, or queer if the corresponding parameter c belongs to such a component. For example, there is a hyperbolic-like component in the form of the main cardioid of a large copy of the Mandelbrot set on the lower right corner of Fig. 1. For every c in this component, the orbit of the critical point c of Pc converges to an attracting fixed point. On the other hand, the large component which is attached on the right side of the unit circle to c = 1 is a capture, consisting of all c for which Pc (c) belongs √ to 1c . Figure 3–7 show examples of the filled Julia sets of cubics in P cm (θ ) for θ = ( 5 − 1)/2. Figure 3 is the filled Julia set of a hyperbolic-like cubic. The large topological disk in black is the immediate basin of attraction of an attracting fixed point. Figure 4 is the filled Julia set of a capture, with a critical point in the large preimage of the Siegel disk on the right. The cubic in Fig. 5 is located at the “cusp” of the large cardioid in the right lower corner of Fig. 1, hence it has a parabolic fixed point. Figure 6 has two critical points on the boundary of its Siegel disk. Finally, the cubic in Fig. 7 belongs to ext so it has a disconnected Julia set. There are countably many components each quasiconformally homeomorphic to the quadratic Siegel filled Julia set with the same rotation number. The uncountably many remaining components are single points. In the above definition, we tacitly assumed that hyperbolic-like or capture cubics define components of the interior of M(θ). The condition of being hyperbolic-like is clearly open. It is also closed in the interior of M(θ ) since by Theorem 3.1 a cubic P in the interior of M(θ) is J -stable, so in a small neighborhood of it the number of attracting
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
195
Fig. 7.
cycles remains constant [Mc2, Theorem 4.2]. This number is 1 if P is accumulated by hyperbolic-like cubics. Now consider the property of being capture for P ∈ P cm (θ ). It follows from Theorem 3.1 that when a capture cubic P belongs to the interior of M(θ ), there is an open neighborhood of P consisting of captures. Let V be the component of the interior of the set of capture cubics containing P . Similarly, define U to be the component of the interior of M(θ) containing P . Clearly V ⊂ U . If they are not equal, choose a cubic Q ∈ ∂V ∩ U . Since Q is J -stable, for all Q0 in a small neighborhood of Q, a critical point of Q0 belongs to the Fatou set of Q0 if and only if the corresponding critical point of Q belongs to the Fatou set of Q. If we choose Q0 ∈ V , there is a critical point of Q0 which hits the Siegel disk 1Q0 . It follows that the same is true for Q, hence Q is capture, which contradicts Q ∈ ∂V . This proves V = U . In other words, when a capture cubic P belongs to the interior of M(θ), the entire component of the interior of M(θ ) containing P consists of captures, hence the name “capture component”. However, the above argument does not rule out the possibility of a capture being on the boundary of the connectedness locus M(θ ). In fact, that the capture condition is open follows from a different type of argument which is standard in deformation theory of rational maps (see Theorem 5.3). Conjecturally, queer components do not exist. But if they do, every cubic in a queer component exhibits an outstanding property: It admits an invariant line field on its Julia set, and in particular, its Julia set has positive Lebesgue measure. The proof of this fact depends on the harmonic λ-lemma of Bers and Royden [BR] as well as the elementary observation of Sullivan [Su2] that if the boundary of a Siegel disk moves holomorphically in a family of rational maps, then there is a choice of holomorphically varying Riemann maps for the Siegel disks (also see the new expanded version [McS]). There is a technical difficulty showing up in the proof: For a general θ of Brjuno type, it is not known whether the boundary of the Siegel disk of a P ∈ P cm (θ ) is a Jordan curve. For this reason, the
196
S. Zakeri
extension of holomorphic motions to the grand orbits of Siegel disks will require some extra work. We will repeatedly use the following lemma of L. Bers [B], [DH2]: Lemma 3.3 (Bers Sewing Lemma). Let E ⊂ C be closed and U and V be two open ' ' neighborhoods of E. Let ϕ : U −→ ϕ(U ) and ψ : V −→ ψ(V ) be two homeomorphisms such that • ϕ is K1 -quasiconformal, • ψ|V rE is K2 -quasiconformal, • ϕ|∂E = ψ|∂E . Then the map ϕ q ψ defined on V by (ϕ q ψ)(z) =
ϕ(z) z ∈ E ψ(z) z ∈ V r E
is a K-quasiconformal homeomorphism with K = max{K1 , K2 }. Moreover, ∂(ϕ qψ) = ∂ϕ almost everywhere on E. Theorem 3.4 (Invariant Line Fields for Queer Cubics). Let U be a queer component of the interior of M(θ). Then for any c ∈ U , the Julia set J (Pc ) has positive Lebesgue measure and supports an invariant line field. Proof. Fix some c0 ∈ U . We first note that every Fatou component of Pc0 eventually maps to the Siegel disk 1c0 and the mapping is a conformal isomorphism: There cannot be further attracting cycles (since Pc0 is not hyperbolic-like) or indifferent periodic orbits (see Corollary 3.2). In particular, K(Pc0 ) = GO(1c0 ). Choose some c ∈ U with c 6 = c0 , and let '
ϕc : C r K(Pc0 ) −→ C r K(Pc ) be the conformal conjugacy given by composition of the Böttcher maps √of Pc0 and Pc . A brief computation using the normal form (2.2) shows that ϕc (z) = c/c0 z + O(1) and we can choose the branch of the square root near c0 for which ϕc0 (z) = z. Since ϕc depends holomorphically on c, it defines a holomorphic motion of C r K(Pc0 ). By the harmonic λ-lemma [BR], this motion extends to a unique holomorphic motion b ϕc of the entire plane, which is now defined only for c in a small neighborhood V of c0 , with the following properties: • For every c ∈ V , b ϕc is a quasiconformal homeomorphism of the plane. ∂b ϕc dz is harmonic in GO(1c0 ). • For every c ∈ V , the Beltrami differential ∂b ϕc dz It is easy to see that uniqueness of this extended motion implies that b ϕc conjugates Pc0 to Pc on the entire plane (compare [McS]). In fact, one can replace b ϕc by Pc−1 ◦ b ϕc ◦ Pc0 on GO(1c0 ), which also extends ϕc , where the branch of Pc−1 is determined uniquely ϕc = Pc−1 ◦ b ϕc ◦ Pc0 by uniqueness. by the values of b ϕc on the Julia set J (Pc0 ). Hence b Next, we want to show that the restriction b ϕc : GO(1c0 ) → GO(1c ) is a conformal conjugacy. As Sullivan observes in [Su2], the fact that the boundary of 1c moves holomorphically for c ∈ U (Theorem 3.1) implies that there is a choice of the Riemann map ζc : D → 1c such that ζc (0) = 0 and c 7 → ζc is holomorphic in c. Define a conformal
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
197
conjugacy ψc : 1c0 → 1c by ψc = ζc ◦ ζc−1 , and extend it to a conformal conjugacy 0 ψc : GO(1c0 ) → GO(1c ) by taking pull-backs as follows. Take any component W of (1c0 ) and let Wc = b ϕc (W ) be the corresponding component of Pc−n (1c ). Define Pc−n 0 . Since c 7 → ψc is holomorphic and ψc = id on ψc : W → Wc by ψc = Pc−n ◦ ψc ◦ Pc◦n 0 GO(1c0 ) when c = c0 , it follows that ψc defines a holomorphic motion of GO(1c0 ). bc of the entire By the harmonic λ-lemma, ψc extends to a unique holomorphic motion ψ plane which is defined for c in a neighborhood V 0 of c0 and has harmonic Beltrami difϕc , it follows that ferential on CrK(Pc0 ). By an argument similar to the one we used for b bc respects the dynamics, i.e., it conjugates Pc0 to Pc on the entire plane. In particular, ψ it sends the marked critical point c0 of Pc0 to the marked critical c of Pc . Let us assume for example that the forward orbit of c0 accumulates on the boundary of 1c0 . Then the ϕc was also a conjugacy to begin with, for all c ∈ V ∩ V 0 same is true for c and 1c . Since b bc (c0 ) = c = b bc (Pc◦k (c0 )) = Pc◦k (c) = b we have ψ ϕc (c0 ), and by induction ψ ϕc (Pc◦k (c0 )) 0 0 for all k. Since every point on the boundary of 1c0 is in the closure of the forward orbit bc and b bc and b ϕc agree on ∂1c0 . Evidently this shows that ψ ϕc of c0 , we conclude that ψ agree on the boundary of every bounded Fatou component of Pc0 , hence on the entire Julia set J (Pc0 ). It follows then from the Bers Sewing Lemma 3.3 that ϕc q ψc defined by b ϕ (z) z ∈ C r GO(1c0 ) (ϕc q ψc )(z) = bc ψc (z) z ∈ GO(1c0 ) is a quasiconformal homeomorphism which has harmonic Beltrami differential in C r J (Pc0 ). Note that ϕc qψc is an extension of both ϕc and ψc . By uniqueness, we conclude bc . In particular, when c ∈ V ∩ V 0 , b ϕc is conformal away from the Julia set that b ϕc ≡ ψ J (Pc0 ). ϕc would have been conformal, conNow, if the Julia set J (Pc0 ) had measure zero, b tradicting c 6 = c0 . So J (Pc0 ) has positive measure. The desired invariant line field is then given by b ϕc∗ (σ0 ), the pull-back of the standard conformal structure σ0 on the plane t by b ϕc . u The existence of holomorphic motions in the above proof was the crucial fact which made the conformal extensions possible. In the case we have “static” quasiconformal conjugacies, such conformal extensions are still possible once we assume that the boundaries of Siegel disks are Jordan curves. Let 1 be a Jordan domain containing the origin and Rt : z 7 → e2πit z be the rigid rotation on the unit circle. Let ζ : 1 → D be any conformal isomorphism with ζ (0) = 0. Then the homeomorphism ht1 : ∂1 → ∂1 defined by ht1 = ζ −1 ◦ Rt ◦ ζ is the intrinsic rotation of ∂1 by angle t. By Schwarz Lemma, ht1 is independent of the choice of ζ . Now suppose 11 and 12 are two Jordan domains containing 0 and t is irrational. Let ϕ : ∂11 → ∂12 be a homeomorphism satisfying ϕ ◦ ht11 = ht12 ◦ ϕ. Then two points a1 ∈ 11 and a2 ∈ 12 have the same conformal position with respect to ϕ if ζ1 (a1 ) = ζ2 (a2 ), where the ζj : 1j → D are conformal isomorphisms with ζj (0) = 0 and ζ1 = ζ2 ◦ ϕ on ∂11 . Lemma 3.5 (Extending QC Conjugacies). Let P and Q be two cubics in P cm (θ ) such that the boundaries of the Siegel disks 1P and 1Q are Jordan curves. Let ϕ : C → C be a quasiconformal homeomorphism whose restriction C r GO(1P ) → C r GO(1Q ) conjugates P to Q. Then (a) If P is not capture, there exists a quasiconformal homeomorphism ψ : C → C which conjugates P and Q, which is conformal on GO(1P ) and agrees with ϕ on C r GO(1P ).
198
S. Zakeri
α1
U1 ∗ c1
β1
P
V1
γ1 v1
α1’
U2
ψ α 2’
V2
β2
Q
c2 ∗
v2
γ2
α2 Fig. 8. Extending ϕ in the capture case
(b) If P is capture, we can construct a ψ as in (a) if and only if the captured images of the critical points of P and Q in 1P and 1Q have the same conformal position with respect to ϕ. Proof. (a) Fix some b1 ∈ ∂1P and let b2 = ϕ(b1 ). Consider conformal isomorphisms ' ' ζ1 : 1P −→ D and ζ2 : 1Q −→ D, with ζ1 (0) = 0 = ζ2 (0) and ζ1 (b1 ) = 1 = ζ2 (b2 ), which conjugate P on 1P and Q on 1Q to the rigid rotation Rθ : z 7→ e2π iθ z on D. Since the boundaries of 1P and 1Q are Jordan curves, ζ1 and ζ2 extend homeomorphically to the closures. The composition ψ = ζ2−1 ◦ ζ1 : 1P → 1Q is conformal and conjugates P on 1P to Q on 1Q . Also ψ(b1 ) = ϕ(b1 ) = b2 and by induction ψ(P ◦k (b1 ))) = Q◦k (b2 ) = ϕ(P ◦k (b1 )). Since the orbit of b1 is dense on the boundary of 1P , we have ψ|∂1P = ϕ|∂1P . Therefore, ψ gives the required extension of ϕ to the Siegel disk 1P . It is now easy to extend ψ to the grand orbit GO(1P ): P ◦k maps any component of P −k (1P ) isomorphically onto 1P . Hence we can define ψ on any such component as the composition Q−k ◦ ψ|1P ◦ P ◦k , where the branch of Q−k is determined by the values of ϕ on the Julia set J (P ). Clearly this composition is conformal inside this component and agrees with ϕ on its boundary. ψ defined this way is a quasiconformal homeomorphism by the Bers Sewing Lemma 3.3, with U = V = C and E = C r GO(1P ). (b) Now let P be capture. The construction of ψ goes through as in case (a) except for the last part where we want to extend ψ by taking pull-backs. Suppose that there exists a positive integer k such that the critical point c1 of P belongs to the component U1 of P −k (1P ). Let V1 = P (U1 ) and let v1 = P (c1 ) be the critical value in V1 . Since P : ∂U1 → ∂V1 is a double covering and ϕ conjugates P to Q on the Julia sets, there must be a critical point c2 of Q in a component U2 of Q−k (1Q ), with ∂U2 = ϕ(∂U1 ). Similarly define V2 and v2 . By the proof of part (a) we can define ψ inductively up to the (k − 1)th preimages of 1P , including V1 . This gives us a conformal isomorphism ψ : V1 → V2 which necessarily maps v1 to v2 , because by our assumption P ◦k (c1 ) and Q◦k (c2 ) have the same conformal position in 1P and 1Q and so one gets mapped to the other by ψ|1P . Choose any simple arc γ1 in V1 connecting v1 to some boundary point β1 . The simple arc γ2 = ψ(γ1 ) in V2 connects v2 to the boundary point β2 = ψ(β1 ).
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
199
Pull γ1 back by P to get two branches of a simple arc passing through the critical point c1 with two distinct endpoints α1 and α10 on the boundary of U1 . Similarly we consider the pull-back of γ2 by Q and we get two endpoints on the boundary of U2 , which we label as α2 = ϕ(α1 ) and α20 = ϕ(α10 ) (see Fig. 8). Now the inverse Q−1 can be defined analytically over V2 r γ2 and has two branches which take values in two different connected components of U2 r Q−1 (γ2 ). Define ψ on U1 as the composition Q−1 ◦ ψ ◦ P , where the boundary orientation tells us which of the two branches of Q−1 has to be taken. This way we extend ψ to U1 and ψ can then be defined on further t preimages of 1P similar to the case (a). u 4. Renormalizable Cubics This section briefly studies the class of renormalizable cubics in P cm (θ ). These are the cubics with disjoint critical orbits from which one can extract the quadratic Qθ : z 7 → e2πiθ z + z2 by straightening. From a different point of view, one may consider a renormalizable cubic with connected Julia set as the result of “intertwining” the quadratic Qθ with another quadratic with connected Julia set (compare [EY]). For background on polynomial-like maps, straightening and hybrid classes, see for example [DH2]. Definition. A cubic P ∈ P cm (θ) is called renormalizable if there exists a pair of Jordan domains U and V , with 0 ∈ U b V , such that the restriction P |U : U → V is a quadratic-like map hybrid equivalent to Qθ : z 7→ e2π iθ z + z2 . When θ is irrational of bounded type, it follows from the work of Douady-Ghys-HermanShishikura [D2] that the boundary of the Siegel disk of Qθ is a quasicircle passing through the critical point. Hence the same is true for the Siegel disk 1P when P is renormalizable. To prove the next theorem, we need the following useful lemma of Kiwi in [K]. This lemma in particular shows that each indifferent cycle for a cubic P ∈ P cm (θ ) must attract its own critical point. Lemma 4.1 (Separation Lemma). Let P be a polynomial with connected Julia set. Then there exists a finite collection of closed preperiodic external rays, separating the plane into disjoint open simply-connected sets {Uj }, such that: • Each Uj contains at most one non-repelling periodic point or periodic Fatou component of P . • If z1 7 → · · · 7 → zp 7 → z1 is a non-repelling cycle meeting Ui1 7→ · · · 7 → Uip 7→ Ui1 , Sp then j =1 Uij contains the entire orbit of at least one critical point of P . Theorem 4.2. A cubic P ∈ P cm (θ) is renormalizable if either of the following conditions holds: (a) P has a non-repelling periodic orbit other than 0 which is not parabolic. (b) P has disconnected Julia set. Proof. First assume that we are in case (a) so that J (P ) is connected. Let R be the finite collection of the closed preperiodic external rays given by the Separation Lemma 4.1. Let V be the component of C r R which contains 0, cut off by an equipotential of K(P ). Finally, let U be the component of P −1 (V ) containing 0. Since all the rays in R are preperiodic, P (R) ⊂ R, hence U ⊂ V . U necessarily contains a critical point of P since
200
S. Zakeri
√ Fig. 9. Filled Julia set of the quadratic Qθ : z 7 → e2π iθ z + z2 for θ = ( 5 − 1)/2
otherwise Schwarz lemma and |P 0 (0)| = 1 would imply that U = V and P |U : U → V is a conformal isomorphism conjugate to a rotation. This would contradict the fact that U intersects the basin of attraction of infinity for P . The other critical point of P has to stay away from V because by the second part of the Separation Lemma its entire orbit lives in the cycle of components of C r R which contains the non- repelling periodic orbit of P . Since by our assumption the non-repelling cycle of P is not parabolic, the landing points of the external rays in R must all be repelling. Therefore, by a simple “thickening” procedure (see for example [M3]), we can assume that U ⊂ V , so that P |U : U → V is a quadratic-like map. Up to affine conjugation, there is only one quadratic polynomial which has a fixed Siegel disk of rotation number θ , so this quadratic-like map has to be hybrid equivalent to Qθ : z 7 → e2πiθ z + z2 . Now suppose that J (P ) is disconnected. For > 0, let U be the connected component of {z ∈ C : GP (z) < } containing the Siegel disk 1P , where GP : C → {x ∈ R : x ≥ 0} is the Green’s function of K(P ). It is not hard to see that for small , t P |U : U → U3 is a quadratic- like map, necessarily hybrid equivalent to Qθ . u Figures 3 and 7 demonstrate the above theorem. In either example, one can see the filled Julia set of the quadratic-like restriction P |U : U → V given by the above theorem, which is quasiconformally homeomorphic to the filled Julia set of Qθ : z 7 → e2π iθ z + z2 in Fig. 9. Remark. When P ∈ P cm (θ) has a parabolic cycle, we can no longer expect to extract Qθ from it by straightening. However, there must be a homeomorphic embedding K(Qθ ) → K(P ), conformal in the interior of K(Qθ ), which conjugates Qθ to P . This can be proved directly when θ is of bounded type (by using Theorem 13.7), and in the general case by using the parabolic surgery recently introduced in [Ha]. Corollary 4.3. Let θ be an irrational number of bounded type. Let P ∈ P cm (θ ) be hyperbolic-like or have disconnected Julia set J (P ). Then J (P ) has Lebesgue measure zero.
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
201
Proof. Let P |U : U → V be the quadratic-like restriction given by Theorem 4.2 and let K be its filled Julia set. Since this restriction is hybrid equivalent to Qθ : z 7→ e2π iθ z+z2 whose Julia set has measure zero by the theorem of Petersen [Pe], we simply conclude that ∂K has Lebesgue measure zero. It is well-known that the forward orbit of almost every point z ∈ J (P ) accumulates on the ω-limit set of the critical points of P [Ly, Prop. 1.14], which in this case is just ∂1P together with the attracting periodic orbit (resp. ∂1P ) if P is hyperbolic-like (resp. with disconnected Julia set). So the orbit of almost every z ∈ J (P ) accumulates on ∂1P . This implies that for all n ≥ N = N(z), P ◦n (z) ∈ V . This can happen only if or equivalently z ∈ P −N (∂K). We conclude that, up to a set of measure P ◦N (z) ∈ ∂K S zero, J (P ) = N≥0 P −N (∂K). But the right-hand side has measure zero because ∂K does. This proves that J (P ) has Lebesgue measure zero as well. u t
5. Quasiconformal Conjugacy Classes In this section we characterize the quasiconformal conjugacy classes in P cm (θ ).A central role is played by the following: Theorem 5.1 (Parametrization of QC Conjugacy Classes). Let Pc0 , Pc1 be distinct cubics in P cm (θ) and let ϕ : C → C be a K-quasiconformal homeomorphism which conjugates Pc0 to Pc1 , i.e., ϕ ◦ Pc0 = Pc1 ◦ ϕ and ϕ(c0 ) = c1 . Then there exists a holomorphic map t 7 → ct from an open disk D(0, r) (r > 1) into C∗ which maps 0 to c0 and 1 to c1 , such that for every t ∈ D(0, r), Pc0 is conjugate to Pct by a Kt - quasiconformal homeomorphism ϕt : C → C. Moreover, Kt → 1 as t → 0. Proof. The idea of the proof is standard in Holomorphic Dynamics (see [Su2,DH2]); however, we briefly sketch it here because similar arguments appear again in the rest of this work. Define a conformal structure σ on C by σ = ϕ ∗ σ0 , where, as usual, σ0 is the standard conformal structure on C. (To simplify the notation, in what follows we identify a conformal structure on C with its associated Beltrami differential.) Since Pc1 is holomorphic, Pc0 has to preserve σ . Since ϕ is quasiconformal, kσ k∞ < 1. Define a one-parameter family {σt } of complex-analytic deformations of σ by σt = tσ , where t ∈ D(0, r) and r > 1 is chosen such that rkσ k∞ < 1. By the Measurable Riemann Mapping Theorem [AB], there exists a unique quasiconformal homeomorphism ϕt of the plane which solves the Beltrami equation ϕt∗ σ0 = σt and fixes 0, 1 and ∞. Define P t = ϕt ◦ Pc0 ◦ ϕt−1 . Since Pc0 is holomorphic, it acts as a pure rotation on Beltrami differentials. Hence Pc∗0 σ = σ implies Pc∗0 σt = σt and therefore P t is a quasiregular self-map of the plane which preserves σ0 and is conjugate to a cubic polynomial. It is then easy to see that P t itself is a cubic polynomial with a fixed Siegel disk of rotation number θ centered at 0 with a marked critical point at z = 1. Note that t 7 → σt is holomorphic, so the same is true for t 7→ ϕt and hence t 7→ P t by the analytic dependence of the solutions of the Beltrami equation on parameters [AB]. Therefore the map t 7 → ct which defines the second critical point of P t so that P t = Pct is holomorphic. It is easy to see that ct has all the required properties. u t Corollary 5.2. Quasiconformal conjugacy classes in P cm (θ ) are either single points or open and connected. In particular, cubics on the boundary ∂M(θ ) are quasiconformally rigid, i.e., their conjugacy classes are single points.
202
S. Zakeri
Theorem 5.3 (Capture is an open condition). Let Pc0 be a capture cubic. Then there is an open neighborhood U ⊂ P cm (θ) of c0 such that for every c ∈ U , Pc is also capture. In particular, capture cubics belong to the interior of the connectedness locus M(θ ). (c0 ) ∈ 1c0 and k ≥ 1 is the smallest Proof. To fix the ideas, let us assume that Pc◦k 0 (c ) 6 = 0. Let A ⊂ 1c0 be the annulus bounded by such integer. First assume that Pc◦k 0 0 (c0 ). Take a conformal ∂1c0 and the analytic invariant curve in 1c0 passing through Pc◦k 0 '
isomorphism ψ : A −→ A(1, ), with = e2π mod(A) > 1, which conjugates Pc0 on A to the rotation on A(1, ). Postcompose ψ with a (non- conformal) dilation A(1, ) → A(1, 2 ) to get a quasiconformal homeomorphism ϕ : A → A(1, 2 ) conjugating Pc0 to the rotation. Define a Pc0 -invariant conformal structure σ on C by putting σ = ϕ ∗ σ0 on A and pulling it back by the inverse branches of Pc0 to the entire grand orbit of A. Set σ = σ0 elsewhere. As in the proof of Theorem 5.1, we define σt = tσ for t ∈ D(0, r) for some r > 1, solve the Beltrami equation ϕt∗ σ0 = σt and set P t = ϕt ◦ Pc0 ◦ ϕt−1 . Then P t is a capture cubic in P cm (θ) and P 0 = Pc0 . The holomorphic mapping t 7 → P t is not constant because mod(ϕ1 (A)) is the same as the modulus of A equipped with the conformal structure σ , which in turn is (1/2π) log( 2 ) = 2 mod(A). Hence P 1 6 = P 0 and the mapping t 7 → P t is open. Now consider the case where Pc◦k (c0 ) = 0. In this case, by Corollary 2.2, the confor0 mal capacity of 1c has a positive lower bound for all c sufficiently close to c0 . It follows that there exists an > 0 such that for all c close to c0 , 1c ⊃ D(0, ). Hence a small t perturbation of Pc0 will still be a capture cubic. u By a center of a hyperbolic-like component U ⊂ M(θ ) we mean a cubic Pc ∈ U with one of the critical points c or 1 being periodic. Similarly, a center of a capture component will be a cubic with one critical point eventually mapped to the indifferent fixed point at the origin. Lemma 5.4 (Existence of Centers). Every hyperbolic-like or capture component of the interior of M(θ) has a center. By the remark after the proof, centers of hyperbolic-like or capture components are unique when θ is of bounded type. Proof. First let U be a hyperbolic-like component. For every c ∈ U , consider the multiplier m(c) of the unique attracting periodic orbit of Pc . The mapping c 7→ m(c) from U into D is easily seen to be proper and holomorphic. Hence it vanishes at a finite number of points in U . Now let U be capture. To be more specific, let us assume that for every c ∈ U , Pc◦k (c) belongs to the Siegel disk 1c , and let k be the smallest such integer. Since Pc is J -stable by Theorem 3.1, the boundary of 1c moves holomorphically. Then, as in the proof of Theorem 3.4, there is a holomorphically varying choice of the Riemann maps ζc : D → 1c with ζc (0) = 0. Define a map m : U → D by m(c) = ζc−1 (Pc◦k (c)). Clearly m is holomorphic. Let cn ∈ U be any sequence which converges to c ∈ ∂U as (cn ) ∈ 1cn and wn = m(cn ) = n → ∞. For simplicity, put ζcn = ζn . Let zn = Pc◦k n ζn−1 (zn ) ∈ D. If wn does not converge to the unit circle, we can find a subsequence wn(j ) such that wn(j ) → w ∈ D as j → ∞. Since the family of univalent functions
Dynamics of Cubic Siegel Polynomials
203
{ζn : D → C} is normal, by passing to a further subsequence if necessary, we may assume that ζn(j ) → ζ locally uniformly on D. Clearly ζ (D) ⊂ 1c . Therefore, ζ (w) = limj ζn(j ) (wn(j ) ) = limj zn(j ) = Pc◦k (c) ∈ 1c . But this means that Pc is capture, which contradicts c ∈ ∂U . This proves that wn converges to the unit circle. Hence m is a proper t map. Now, as before, m−1 (0) has to be non-vacuous and finite. u Remark. To show uniqueness of centers, by Theorem 5.1 it would be enough to prove that any two centers for a component are quasiconformally conjugate. When the rotation number θ is of bounded type, this can be proved by a pull-back argument similar to Lemma 3.5 since in this case the boundary of 1P for P ∈ P cm (θ ) is a Jordan curve by Theorem 13.7 (compare [Mc1] or [M2], where uniqueness of centers is shown for every hyperbolic component in the space of polynomial maps). Theorem 5.5 (QC Conjugacy Classes in P cm (θ )). Quasiconformal conjugacy classes in P cm (θ ) are given by the following list: (a) Hyperbolic-like or capture components of the interior of M(θ ) with the center(s) removed. (b) The two components ext and int . (c) Queer components of the interior of M(θ). (d) Centers of hyperbolic-like or capture components. (e) Single points on the boundary of M(θ). Proof. Corollary 5.2 shows that no conjugacy class intersects two distinct members of the above list. It also proves that (d) and (e) are in fact conjugacy classes. Also the proof of Theorem 3.4 shows that every queer component is a conjugacy class. That (a) and (b) are quasiconformal conjugacy classes follows from the fact that over the components of t type (a) or (b), the family {Pc } has no critical orbit relations ([McS], Theorem 2.7). u 6. Connectivity of M(θ) In this section we prove that M(θ) is connected. This amounts to showing that each of its complementary components ext and int are homeomorphic to the punctured disk. One way to do this is to mimic the standard Douady–Hubbard proof of connectivity of the Mandelbrot set [DH1]: We can construct a holomorphic branched covering 8 : ext → C r D by assigning to each Pc ∈ ext the position of the critical point c in the Böttcher coordinate of Pc . 8 extends holomorphically to infinity with 8−1 (∞) = ∞. The degree of this map is 3, so to prove that ext is a punctured disk we must show that 8 has no critical point other than ∞. (This additional difficulty does not show up in the case of the Mandelbrot set where the similar map has degree 1.) To prove that 8 is locally injective, one can start with two nearby polynomials in the same fiber of 8 and de fine a conformal conjugacy between them near infinity by composing their Böttcher coordinates. This conjugacy can be conformally extended using the dynamics to the entire basin of attraction of infinity. Then a delicate argument is necessary to prove that one can extend the conjugacy further to the complex plane in a holomorphic way, proving that the two polynomials are identical (see [Z3] for details of such a proof). However, to prove that ext is a punctured disk, it would be much easier to use methods of Teichmüller theory of rational maps as developed in [McS]. (There one can also find a different proof for connectivity of the Mandelbrot set.) Let P ∈ P cm (θ ). By definition, the Teichmüller space Teich(P ) consists of all pairs (Q, [ϕ]), where Q ∈ P cm (θ ) and
204
S. Zakeri
c γ
Fig. 10.
ϕ : C → C is a quasiconformal conjugacy between P and Q, i.e., P ◦ ϕ = ϕ ◦ Q. Here [ϕ] means that we only remember the isotopy class of ϕ. The modular group Mod(P ) is the group of isotopy classes of quasiconformal homeomorphisms commuting with P . Mod