Commun. Math. Phys. 263, 1–19 (2006) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1491-6
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Characterization and ‘Source-Receiver’ Continuation of Seismic Reflection Data Maarten V. de Hoop1 , Gunther Uhlmann2, 1
Center for Computational and Applied Mathematics, Purdue University, 150 N. University Street, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195-4350, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 29 June 2004 / Accepted: 3 October 2005 Published online: 26 January 2006 – © Springer-Verlag 2006
Abstract: In reflection seismology one places sources and receivers on the Earth’s surface. The source generates elastic waves in the subsurface, that are reflected where the medium properties, stiffness and density, vary discontinuously. In the field, often, there are obstructions to collect seismic data for all source-receiver pairs desirable or needed for data processing and application of inverse scattering methods. Typically, data are measured on the Earth’s surface. We employ the term data continuation to describe the act of computing data that have not been collected in the field. Seismic data are commonly modeled by a scattering operator developed in a high-frequency, single scattering approximation. We initially focus on the determination of the range of the forward scattering operator that models the singular part of the data in the mentioned approximation. This encompasses the analysis of the properties of, and the construction of, a minimal elliptic projector that projects a space of distributions on the data acquisition manifold to the range of the mentioned scattering operator. This projector can be directly used for the purpose of seismic data continuation, and is derived from the global parametrix of a homogeneous pseudodifferential equation the solution of which coincides with the range of the scattering operator. We illustrate the data continuation by a numerical example.
1. Introduction In reflection seismology one places sources and receivers on the Earth’s surface. The source generates elastic waves in the subsurface, that are reflected where the medium properties, stiffness and density, vary discontinuously. Seismic data collected in the field are often not ideal for data processing and application of inverse scattering methods. Typically, data are measured on the Earth’s (two-dimensional) surface; the location of the
This research was supported in part under NSF CMG grant EAR-0417891. Partly supported by a John Simon Guggenheim fellowship.
2
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
receiver relative to the source can be coordinated by offset and azimuth. We employ the term data continuation to describe the act of computing data that have not been collected in the field. Special cases of data continuation are the so-called ‘transformation to zero offset’ (derived from what seismologists call Dip MoveOut [7] to generate data at zero offsets, and ‘transformation to common azimuth’ (derived from what seismologists call Azimuth MoveOut [2]) to generate data at a fixed, prescribed azimuth. Data continuation can also play the role of ‘forward extrapolation’ [9] in a data regularization scheme. Seismic data are commonly modeled by a scattering operator developed in a highfrequency single scattering approximation. In this approximation one assumes that the medium is described by a singular contrast superimposed on a smooth background. Under geological constraints, often, the contrast is a conormal distribution. Initially, we focus on the determination of the range of the forward scattering operator that models the singular part of the data in the single scattering approximation. This encompasses the analysis of the properties of, and the construction of, a minimal elliptic projector that projects the space of distributions on the acquisition manifold to the range of the mentioned scattering operator. This projector can be directly used for the purpose of seismic data continuation, and is derived from the global parametrix of a homogeneous pseudodifferential equation the solution of which coincides with the range of the scattering operator. Through characterization of features in the data, applications of data continuation extend to survey design (i.e. the design of the acquisition geometry describing the locations of the source-receiver pairs). The range of the scattering operator can also be used as a criterion for muting the data for features that are undesirable for the purpose of imaging the data (such as multiple scattered waves). The notion of data continuation has been introduced in exploration seismology quite some time ago. As early as in 1982, Bolondi et al. [3] came up with the idea of describing data offset continuation and Dip MoveOut in the form of solving a partial differential equation. Their approach, built on the approach of Deregowski and Rocca [7], is valid in homogeneous media for acoustic waves while their partial differential operator is approximate only. An ‘exact’ partial differential equation for space dimension n = 2 that addresses mentioned offset continuation was later derived by Goldin [11]. In this application it is implicitly used that the kernel of the associated partial differential operator determines the range of the operator that models the singular part of seismic data – in the single scattering approximation. The operator can be written in the form of a generalized Radon transform. Heuristically, the procedure and analysis presented in this paper can be thought of as a generalization from two to higher dimensions, from acoustic to elastic, and from homogeneous to heterogeneous media, of Goldin’s ‘offset continuation’ equation approach. Let the data be denoted by d = d(s, r, t), where s denotes source position, r receiver position, t the time, while (s, r, t) ∈ Y and Y denotes the acquisition manifold. Let Y ⊂ R2n−1 . We introduce the map κ: (s, r, t) → (z, tn , h), z = 21 (r + s), h = 21 (r − s), tn = tn (h, t) =
t2 −
4h2 , v2
where, v is the acoustic wave speed. Let r be the pull back of d by the inverse of this map, r = (κ −1 )∗ d. The singular support of r can be parametrized by (z, h) according to (z, Tn (z, h), h) with Tn (z, h) = tn (h, T (z, h)), in which the function T (z, h) denotes the traveltime of a particular reflection in the data; in seismological terms, the function
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
3
Tn is the traveltime ‘after Normal MoveOut correction’. Goldin’s equation is of the form (n = 2) 2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂ (1) − 2 . +h P r = 0, P := tn ∂tn ∂h ∂h2 ∂z This equation is supplemented with the initial conditions r(z, tn , h)|h=h0 ,
∂r (z, tn , h)|h=h0 . ∂h
The first initial condition represents what seismologists call a post-normal-moveout constant-offset section at half offset h0 ; the second initial condition is the first-order derivative of post-normal-moveout section at half offset h0 . Goldin’s equation is not exact in the sense that it does not account for the symbols of the reflection operators associated with the reflectors in the subsurface. The notion of data continuation has also been introduced and exploited in helical x-ray transmission tomography (CT) [22]. Consider a flat area detector, which is contained in the plane described by Cartesian coordinates (u, v). Let R denote the radius of the helix and 2πh its pitch. Let λ denote the angle describing rotation of the cone vertex. The axial shift of the assembly of the x-ray source and the detector is denoted by ζ . The data are denoted by g = g(u, v, λ, ζ ). In this case, John’s equation [19] describing the range of the Radon transform is used. John’s equation for the x-ray transform in dimension 3 is given by R2
∂ 2g ∂ 2g ∂g ∂ 2g ∂ 2g ∂ 2g − 2u + (R 2 + u2 ) =R − Rh + uv 2 . ∂u∂ζ ∂v ∂u∂v ∂λ∂v ∂v∂ζ ∂v
(2)
This equation is supplemented with the initial conditions g(u, v, λ, ζ )|ζ =0 that are measured. (The standard form of John’s equation is much simpler than (2).) Gel’fand and Graev [10] have generalized John’s result to k-planes in Rn . John’s (and Goldin’s) partial differential equation in higher space dimension is second order and of ultrahyperbolic type. The seismic forward scattering operator is a Fourier integral operator and can be identified with a generalized Radon transform [1, 5, 23]. We characterize seismic data by analyzing the range of the forward scattering operator. This range coincides with the kernel of a self-adjoint, second-order pseudodifferential operator, P , derived from annihilators, Pi , of the data, d, Pi d = 0, P = Pi2 . (3) i
Let Q denote the global parametrix of P . The mentioned elliptic minimal projector then follows to be π = I − QP + smoothing operator
(4)
and provides the Fourier integral operator for continuing the singular part of the data. The annihilators are functionally dependent on the background medium, and hence can be used to form a criterion to estimate it. This estimation is known to seismologists as
4
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
‘velocity analysis’ and can be formulated as a reflection tomography problem. Thus, data continuation and reflection tomography, and imaging, are intimately connected. The results presented in this paper are based on the work by Guillemin and Uhlmann [15]. Here, we speak of ‘data’ continuation rather than ‘offset’ continuation, because our approach continues data in sources and receivers and not only in offset due to the heterogeneity of the subsurface we can allow. 2. Modeling of Seismic Data in the Single Scattering Approximation The propagation and scattering of seismic waves is governed by the elastic wave equation, which is written in the form Wil ul = fi ,
(5)
where ul =
ρ(x)(displacement)l ,
fi = √
1 (volume force density)i , ρ(x)
(6)
∂ cij kl (x) ∂ . ∂xj ρ(x) ∂xk
(7)
and Wil = δil
∂2 + Ail + l.o.t., ∂t 2
Ail = −
Here, x ∈ Rn and the subscripts i, j, k, l ∈ {1, . . . , n}; ρ is the density of mass while cij kl denotes the stiffnesss tensor. The system of partial differential equations is assumed to be of principal type. It supports different wave types (modes), one ‘compressional’ and n − 1 ‘shear’. We label the modes by M, N, . . . . For waves in mode M, singularities are propagated along bicharacteristics, that are determined by Hamilton’s equations generated by a Hamiltonian BM , ,
dt = 1, dλ
dξ ∂ = − BM (x, ξ ) , dλ ∂x
dτ = 0. dλ
∂ dx = BM (x, ξ ) dλ ∂ξ
(8)
The BM follow from the diagonalization of the principal symbol matrix of Ail , as the square roots of its eigenvalues. Clearly, the solution may be parameterized by t. We denote the solution of (8) subject to and initial values (x0 , ξ0 ) at t = 0 by (xM (x0 , ξ0 , t), ξM (x0 , ξ0 , t)). In the contrast formulation the total value of the medium parameters ρ, cij kl is written as the sum of a smooth background constituent ρ(x), cij kl (x) and a singular perturbation δρ(x), δcij kl (x), viz. ρ + δρ, cij kl + δcij kl . This decomposition induces a perturbation of Wil (cf. (7)), δWil = δil
δρ(x) ∂ 2 ∂ δcij kl (x) ∂ − . 2 ρ(x) ∂t ∂xj ρ(x) ∂xk
The scattered field, in the single scattering approximation, satisfies Wil δul = −δWil ul .
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
5
Data are measurements of the scattered wave field δu, which we relate here to the Green’s function perturbation: They are assumed to be representable by δGMN ( x, x , t) for ( x, x , t) in some acquisition manifold, which contains the receiver and source points and time. Let y → ( x (y), x (y), t (y)) be a coordinate transformation, such that y = (y , y ) and the acquisition manifold, Y say, is given by y = 0. We assume that the dimension of y is 2 + c, where c is the codimension of the acquisition geometry. For example, for marine acquisition in seismic reflection data, c = 1, while also in global seismology for many, but not all, regions c = 1 – seismologists recognize this as lack of ‘azimuthal’ coverage. An example of c = 2 is provided by the common-‘offset’ acquisition geometry. In this framework, the data are modeled by δρ(x) δcij kl (x) x (y , 0), x (y , 0), t (y , 0)). (9) , → δGMN ( ρ(x) ρ(x) ξ0 ), We investigate the propagation of singularities by this mapping. Let τ = ∓BM (x0 , and ξ0 , ± t), x = xN (x0 , ξ0 , ± t), x = xM (x0 , ξ = ξM (x0 , ξ0 , ± t), ξ = ξN (x0 , ξ0 , ± t).
t = t + t,
ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t), η(x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t)) by transforming ( x, x , t + t, ξ , ξ, τ) We then obtain (y(x0 , to (y, η) coordinates. We invoke the following assumptions that concern scattering over π and rays grazing the acquisition manifold, Assumption 1. There are no elements (y , 0, η , η ) with (y , η ) ∈ T ∗ Y \0 such that there is a direct bicharacteristic from ( x (y , 0), ξ (y , 0, η , η )) to ( x (y , 0), − ξ (y , 0, η , η )) with arrival time t (y , 0). Assumption 2. The matrix ∂y has maximal rank. ∂(x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t)
(10)
The propagation of singularities by (9) is governed by the canonical relation ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t), η (x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t); x0 , ξ0 + ξ0 ) | , (11) MN = {(y (x0 , ∗ ∗ BM (x0 , ξ0 ) = BN (x0 , ξ0 ) = ∓τ, y (x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t) = 0} ⊂ T Y \0 × T X\0. The condition y (x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t) = 0 determines the traveltimes t for given (x0 , ξ0 ) and t for given (x0 , ξ0 ). Following Maslov and Fedoriuk [21], we choose coordinates for MN of the form (yI , x0 , ηJ ),
(12)
where I ∪ J is a partition of {1, . . . , 2n − 1 − c}, with associated generating function SMN = SMN (yI , x0 , ηJ ). The phase function in these coordinates becomes MN =
MN (y , x0 , ηJ ). Let τ = 21 ( τ + τ ) and τ¯ = τ − τ . The map (x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t) → (x0 , yI , y , ηJ , τ¯ )
(13)
6
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
is bijective. Thus, for y = 0 and τ¯ = 0 we can express ( ξ0 , ξ0 ) as functions of (yI , x0 , ηJ ). The amplitude associated with MN , to leading order, can be written in the form |bMN (yI , x0 , ηJ )| ∂( x, x , t) −1/2 ∂(x0 , ξ0 , ξ0 , t, t ) 1/2 1 − n+1+c 4 . (14) = (2π ) det ∂(y , y ) det ∂(x , y , y , η , τ¯ ) 2 4τ 0 I y =0,τ¯ =0 J
δcij kl , are described by conormal distributions. We consider the We assume that δρ ρ ρ case of a single interface, and a jump discontinuity in (δρ, δcij kl ) across this interface. Let κ : Rn → Rn , x → z be a coordinate transformation such that the interface is given by zn = 0. The corresponding cotangent vector is denoted by ζ , and transforms −1 t according to ζi (x, ξ ) = (( ∂κ ∂x ) )ij ξj ; the z form coordinates on the manifold X, and δc we write z = (z , zn ). We introduce the distributions (δρ, ij kl ) by pull back with κ: δρ(κ(x)) = δρ(x),
δc ij kl (κ(x)) = δcij kl (x).
(15)
Then ∂ ∂z = n ρ + l.o.t., δρ ∂x ∂x
ρ =
∂ δρ, ∂zn ∂ δ c
where ρ contains a factor δ(zn (x)), and similarly for ∂xij kl . Substituting (15) into the integral over X representing the high-frequency Born approximation for scattered waves, and integrating by parts, then yields an oscillatory integral representation in which wMN;0 (yI , x, ηJ )
δcij kl (x) δρ(x) + wMN ;ij kl (yI , x, ηJ ) , ρ(x) ρ(x)
where w stands for the contrast-source radiation patterns derived from the pseudodifferential operators that diagonalize the elastodynamic system of equations [23], has been replaced by ∂zn δ(zn (x)). 2iτ RMN (yI , x, ηJ ) ∂x n Here we use that τ will be one of the components of ηJ . Also (· · · ) ∂z ∂x δ(zn (x)) ∂zn dx = zn =0 (· · · ) det ∂x ∂z ∂x dz becomes the Euclidean surface integral over the surface or manifold zn = 0. Theorem 1 [23]. Suppose Assumptions 1, and 2 are satisfied microlocally for the relevant part of the data. Let MN (y, x, ηJ ) and bMN (yI , x, ηJ ) be the phase function and amplitude introduced above. Then the mapping ∂zn refl F : ∂x δ(zn (x)) → GMN (y),
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
7
where
− |J2 | − 3n−1−c 4 Grefl (y) = (2π ) (2iτ (ηJ ) bMN (yI , x, ηJ )RMN (yI , x, ηJ ) + l.o.t.) MN X ∂zn × (16) ∂x δ(zn (x)) exp[i MN (y, x, ηJ )] dxdηJ , defines a Fourier integral operator with canonical relation MN and of order n−1+c −1. 4 F models seismic reflection data. In the Kirchhoff approximation, one can identify the principal part of RMN with the plane-wave reflection coefficient: Using (13) we find the (x, ξ0 , ξ0 ) associated with (yI , x, ηJ ). A reflection from an incident N -mode with covector ξ0 into a scattered M-mode with covector ξ0 takes place, at x, if the frequencies are equal and ξ0 + ξ0 is in the wavefront set of δ(zn (x)). Given ξ0 , ξ0 one can identify the down- and upgoing modes µ(M), ν(N ) relative to the interface, and define (at least to highest order) the reflection coefficient at x, RMN = Rµ(M),ν(N) (z (x), ζ (x, ξ0 ), τ ) if zn (x) = 0,
(17)
see De Hoop and Bleistein [4] and Stolk and De Hoop [23]. The Kirchhoff approximation requires the following assumption Assumption 3. There are no rays tangent to the interface zn = 0, i.e. elements in MN associated with (x(z , 0), ξ0 (z , 0, ζ , 0)) or with (x(z , 0), ξ0 (z , 0, ζ , 0)) (cf. (11)). For a treatment of reflection and transmission of waves in the elastic case, using microlocal analysis, see Taylor [24]; for the acoustic case, see also Hansen [16]. Examples ∂zn of conormal distributions, ∂x δ(zn (x)), in the Earth sciences the reflections off which are observed, include the core-mantle boundary, thermal and chemical boundary layers in the deep mantle, fault zones, and geological interfaces in sedimentary basins.
3. Extension of the Scattering Operator For simplicity of notation, from here on, we drop the subscripts MN and consider a single mode pair. In the single scattering approximation, subject to restriction to the acquisition manifold Y , the singular part of the medium parameters is a function of n variables, while the data are a function of 2n − 1 − c variables. Here, we discuss the extension of the scattering operator to act on distributions of 2n − 1(−c) variables, equal to the number of degrees of freedom in the acquisition.
3.1. The wavefront set of seismic data . The wavefront set of the modeled data is not arbitrary. This is a consequence of the fact that data consist of multiple experiments designed to provide a degree of redundancy, which we explain here. Assumption 4 (Guillemin [13]). The projection πY of on T ∗ Y \0 is an embedding.
8
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
This assumption is known as the Bolker condition. It admits the presence of caustics. Because is a canonical relation that projects submersively on the subsurface variables (x, ξ ) (using that the operator Wil is of principal type), the projection of (11) on T ∗ Y \0 is immersive [17, Lemma 25.3.6 and (25.3.4)]. In fact, only the injectivity part of the Bolker condition needs to be verified. The image L of πY is locally a coisotropic submanifold of T ∗ Y \0. Hence, for each (y, η) ∈ L, (T(y,η) L)⊥ ⊂ T(y,η) L. Setting V(y,η) = (T(y,η) L)⊥ , the vector bundle V → L whose fiber at (y, η) is (T(y,η) L)⊥ , is an integrable subbundle of T L. Applying [14, Prop. 8.1], from the Bolker condition it follows that L satisfies their Axiom F: the foliation of L associated with V is fibrating, i.e. there exists a C ∞ Hausdorff manifold X and a smooth fiber map L → X whose fibers are the connected leaves of the foliation defined by V . We choose coordinates revealing the mentioned fibration. Since the projection πX of on T ∗ X\0 is submersive, we can choose (x, ξ ) as the first 2n local coordinates on ; the remaining dim Y − n = n − 1 − c coordinates are denoted by e ∈ E, E being a manifold itself. The sets X (x, ξ ) = const. are the isotropic fibers of the fibration of H¨ormander [18], Theorem 21.2.6, see also Theorem 21.2.4. Duistermaat [8] calls them characteristic strips (see Theorem 3.6.2). Also, ν = ξ −1 ξ is then identified as the migration dip. The wavefront set of the data is contained in L and is a union of such fibers. The map πX πY−1 : L → X is a canonical isotropic fibration, known to seismologists as map migration. We consider again the canonical relation and suppose that Assumption 4 is satisfied. We define as the mapping πY πX−1 , : (x, ξ, e) → (y(x, ξ, e), η(x, ξ, e)) : T ∗ X\0 × E → T ∗ Y \0, which is known to seismologists as map demigration. This map conserves the symplectic form of T ∗ X\0. Indeed, let σY denote the fundamental symplectic form on T ∗ Y \0. We consider the vector fields over an open subset of L with components wxi = ∂(y,η) ∂xi and similarly for wξi and wei . Then σY (wxi , wxj ) = σY (wξi , wξj ) = 0, σY (wξi , wxj ) = δij , σY (wei , wxj ) = σY (wei , wξj ) = σY (wei , wej ) = 0.
(18)
The (x, ξ, e) are ‘symplectic coordinates’ on the projection L of on T ∗ Y \0. In the following lemma, we extend these coordinates to symplectic coordinates on an open neighborhood of L, which is a manifestation of Darboux’s theorem stating that T ∗ Y can be covered with symplectic local charts. Lemma 1. Let L be an embedded coisotropic submanifold of T ∗ Y \0, with coordinates (x, ξ, e) such that (18) holds. Denote L (y, η) = (x, ξ, e). We can find a homogeneous canonical map G from an open part of T ∗ (X × E)\0 to an open neighborhood of L in T ∗ Y \0, such that G(x, e, ξ, ε = 0) = (x, ξ, e).
3.2. An invertible Fourier integral operator. Let M be the canonical relation associated with the map G we introduced in Lemma 1, i.e. M = {(G(x, e, ξ, ε); x, e, ξ, ε)} ⊂ T ∗ Y \0 × T ∗ (X × E)\0.
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
9
We now construct a Maslov-type phase function for M that is directly related to a phase function for . Suppose (yI , x, ηJ ) are suitable coordinates for , at ε = 0. For ε small, the constant-ε subset of M allows the same set of coordinates, thus we can use coordinates (yI , ηJ , x, ε) on M. Now there is (see Theorem 4.21 in Maslov and Fedoriuk [21]) a function S(yI , x, ηJ , ε), called the generating function, such that M is given by yJ = −
∂S , ∂ηJ
∂S ξ = − , ∂x
ηI =
∂S , ∂yI
e=
∂S . ∂ε
(19)
Thus a phase function for M is given by (y, x, e, ηJ , ε) = S(yI , x, ηJ , ε) + ηJ , yJ − ε, e.
(20)
A phase function for then follows as
(y, x, ηJ ) = (y, x, ∂S ∂ε |ε=0 , ηJ , 0) = S(yI , x, ηJ , 0) + ηJ , yJ . We introduce the amplitude b(yI , x, ηJ , ε) on M such that b(yI , x, ηJ , ε = 0) coincides with the amplitude in Theorem 1. To leading order, ∂ b=0 ∂ε because the coordinates εi are in involution. We construct a mapping from the reflectivity function to seismic data, extending the mapping from contrast to data. This is done by applying the results of Sect. 3.1 to the Kirchhoff modeling formula (16). We apply the change of coordinates on from (yI , x, ηJ ) to (x, ξ, e) to the symbol RMN and write now RMN = R(x, ξ, e). To highest order, R does not depend on ξ and is simply a function of (x, e). Theorem 2 [23]. Suppose microlocally that Assumptions 3 (no grazing rays at any interface), 1 (no scattering over π), 2 (transversality), and 4 (Bolker condition) are satisfied. Let H be the Fourier integral operator, H: E (X × E) → D (Y ), with canonical relation given by the extended map G : (x, ξ, e, ε) → (y, η) constructed in Sect. 3.1, and with amplitude to highest order given by (2π )n/2 2iτ (ηJ )b(yI , x, ηJ , ε) expressible in terms of the coordinates (x, e, ξ, ε). Then the data, in both Born and Kirchhoff approximations, can be modeled by H acting on a distribution r(x, e) of the form r(x, e) = R(x, Dx , e) c(x),
(21)
where R stands for a smooth e-family of pseudodifferential operators and c ∈ E (X). For n the Kirchhoff approximation the distribution c equals ∂z ∂x δ(zn (x)), while the principal symbol of the pseudodifferential operator R equals R(x, e), so to highest order ∂zn (22) r(x, e) = R(x, e) ∂x δ(zn (x)).
10
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
For the Born approximation the function r(x, e) is given by a pseudodifferential opera−1 (w tor R with principal symbol (2iτ MN ;0 (x, ξ, e), wMN;ij kl (x, ξ, e)), acting
(x, ξ, e)) on a distribution c given by
δcij kl δρ ρ , ρ
, so to highest order
δcij kl (x) δρ(x) r(x, e) = (2iτ (x, Dx , e))−1 wMN ;0 (x, Dx , e) +wMN;ij kl (x, Dx , e) . ρ(x) ρ(x) The operator H is invertible. Remark 1. Microlocally, we have obtained the following diagram (suggested by Symes, personal communication) H
E (X × E) −→ D (Y ) R(x, Dx , e) ↑ ↑ Id E (X)
F
−→
(23)
D (Y )
We note that R(x, Dx , e) is of order 0. H −1 maps data into what seismologists call common-image-point gathers (the integral over ε replaces the notion of beamforming; e plays the role of scattering angle and azimuth). 4. A Procedure for Data Continuation 4.1. The range of the scattering operator. If n − 1 − c > 0, there is a redundancy in the data parametrized by the variable e. The redundancy in the data manifests itself as a redundancy in images of the subsurface from these data. A smooth background is considered ‘acceptable’ if the data are contained in the range of F (or H ). If a smooth background is acceptable, then applying the operator H −1 of Theorem 2 to the data results in a reflectivity distribution r(x, e), the singular support (in x) of which does not depend on e. One way to measure the agreement in singular supports between images of reflectivity r(x, e) parametrized by e is by taking a derivative with respect to e. Taking (21) as the point of departure, we find that ∂ ∂R ∂R R(x, Dx , e) − (x, Dx , e) r(x, e) = R(x, Dx , e), (x, Dx , e) c(x). (24) ∂e ∂e ∂e Hence, microlocally where R(x, Dx , e) is elliptic, ∂R ∂ R(x, Dx , e) − (x, Dx , e) ∂e ∂e ∂R (x, Dx , e) R(x, Dx , e)−1 r(x, e) = 0 − R(x, Dx , e), ∂e
(25)
to all orders. We observe that the first operator acting on distributions in (x, e) in the sum is of order 1, the second operator is of order 0, while the third operator is of order −1. Falling back on (22) we exploit that, up to leading order, the operator R acts as a multiplication by R(x, e). Clearly, ∂zn ∂R R(x, e), (x, e) ∂x δ(zn (x)) = 0, ∂e
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
11
cf. (24). Substituting (21) into (25) reveals that the operator in between parentheses on ∂ the left-hand side equals (R(x, e) ∂e − ∂R ∂e (x, e)) up to the leading two orders. Hence, R(x, e)
∂ ∂R − (x, e) r(x, e) = 0 ∂e ∂e
(26)
up to the highest two orders. Conjugating the operator in between parentheses in (26), or in (25), with the invertible Fourier integral operator H , we obtain a pseudodifferential operator on D (Y ) [23] Lemma 2. Let the pseudodifferential operators Pi (y, Dy ) : D (Y ) → D (Y ) of order 1 be given by the composition ∂ ∂R Pi (y, Dy ) = H R(x, e) − (x, e) H −1 , i = 1, . . . , n − 1 − c . ∂ei ∂ei r
Then for Kirchhoff data d(y) modeled by F , we have to the highest two orders, Pi (y, Dy )d(y) = 0, i = 1, . . . , n − 1 − c.
(27)
Microlocally, for values of e where R(x, e) = 0, the operator Pi (y , Dy ) can be modeled after (25) such that (27) is valid to all orders. The principal part of the symbol of Pi is denoted by pi , while the next order term in the symbol’s polyhomogeneous expansion is denoted by pi;0 . The subprincipal symbols (which show up naturally in the Weyl calculus of symbols), ci , of the annihilators are 2p i then given by ci := pi;0 + 2i j ∂y∂j ∂η . j Remark 2. The wavefront set of the data is contained in L = πY ( ), which, in analogy with the eikonal equation, is also the submanifold of T ∗ Y \0 defined by pi (y, η) = 0,
i = 1, . . . , n − 1 − c,
(28)
where pi is the principal symbol of Pi as before, and is of codimension 2 [2(n − 1) − c + 1] − (3n − 1 − c) = n − 1 − c, which is also the dimension of the covector ε. n−1
The operator F in Theorem 1 is continuous H 2 (X) → L2 (Y ). We now define the operator projection, π : L2 (Y ) → L2 (Y ), onto the range of the scattering operator F . Microlocally, π 2 = π. Since Assumption 4 is satisfied, using [14, Prop. 8.3], π is an elliptic minimal projector. By [14, Theorem 6.6], the kernel of 2 P = P12 + · · · + Pn−1−c
(29)
is identical with the range of π . More precisely, let Q denote the global parametrix of P , then, by [14, Theorem 6.7], π = I − QP + smoothing operator.
(30)
12
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
4.2. A global parametrix. The construction of a global parametrix, Q, for an operator of the type P is given by Guillemin and Uhlmann [15]. A natural parametrix for P would 1 have as principal symbol 2 . However, this expression becomes singu2 p1 + · · · + pn−1−c lar at the set {p1 = · · · = pn−1−c = 0}. A class of operators, containing pseudodifferential operators with singular symbols, was introduced by Guillemin and Uhlmann [15]. The wavefront set of the kernels of these operators consist of two Langrangian manifolds, 0 and 1 say, intersecting cleanly in a submanifold of given codimension. In our case, 0 is the diagonal diag(T ∗ Y \0) in T ∗ Y \0 × T ∗ Y \0, while 1 is the fiber X
product L × L. The Lagrangian submanifold 1 ⊂ T ∗ Y \0 × T ∗ Y \0 precisely consists of points on the joint flowout from diag(T ∗ Y \0) ∩ {p1 = · · · = pn−1−c = 0} by the Hamiltonian flows of the Hp1 , . . . , Hpn−1−c , where Hpi denotes the Hamiltonian field associated with the function pi . The flowout is described by the solution to the Hamilton systems with parameters ei , ∂yj ∂pi = (y, η), ∂ei ∂ηj
∂ηj ∂pi =− (y, η), ∂ei ∂yj
1 ≤ i, j ≤ n − 1 − c.
(31)
The Lagrangian submanifolds 0 and 1 intersect cleanly in a submanifold of codimension n − 1 − c, see Remark 2. Guillemin and Uhlmann’s construction relies on the introduction of the space of distributional half densities, I p,l (Y ×Y ; 0 , 1 ), defining a class of Fourier integral operators with singular symbols, with the properties ∩l I p,l (Y × Y ; 0 , 1 ) = I p (Y × Y, 1 ) (defining standard Fourier integral operators with canonical relation 1 ) for p fixed, and ∩p I p,l (Y × Y ; 0 , 1 ) = C0∞ (Y × Y ) for l fixed. Viewing the Schwartz kernel of the identity (I ) as an element of I 0,0 (Y × Y ; 0 , 1 ), Guillemin and Uhlmann’s recursive construction results in QP = I − π + R, where the kernel of π belongs to ∩l I p,l (Y × Y ; 0 , 1 ), and R is a smoothing operator with kernel in ∩p I p,l (Y × Y ; 0 , 1 ). Here, we discuss the properties of Q. We observe that 1 ◦ 1 = 1 . The elliptic minimal projector π , introduced in the previous subsection, is a Fourier integral operator with canonical relation 1 , (31)
L −→ L ↓ ↓ X −→ X
(32)
The wavefront set of Q is contained in 0 ∪ 1 . Q is a pseudodifferential operator on 1 0 \( 0 ∩ 1 ) and its principal symbol there is given by σ0 = 2 up 2 p1 + · · · + pn−1−c to Maslov factors and half densities. Q is a Fourier integral operator on 1 \( 0 ∩ 1 ). Its principal symbol, σ1 , solves the transport equation n−1−c
iHpi − ci
2
σ1 = σπ
i=1
on 1 \( 0 ∩ 1 ), where σπ denotes the symbol of π . (We return to the evaluation of σπ in Sect. 6.) The expression between parentheses is an elliptic differential operator of
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
13
order 2 on each fiber of L. The equation is Laplace’s equation in every leaf of the foliation generated by the commuting vector fields Hpi , i = 1, . . . , n − 1 − c. The principal symbol σ1 has a conormal singularity at 0 ∩ 1 , expressible by an appropriate Fourier transform of the singularity of σ0 , see [15, (5.14)].
4.3. Data continuation. We apply the results of the previous subsections to the problem of source-receiver continuation of seismic data: Seismic data are commonly measured on an open subset of the manifold of all possible observations. Continuation of these data from the open subset to the full acquisition manifold is desired for various data processing procedures, including imaging – in the seismic literature this continuation is referred to as the ‘forward extrapolation’ step within data regularization [9], or ‘data healing’. Theorem 3. Suppose u is a distribution belonging to the range of the scattering operator F . Let χ = χ (y, Dy ) be a pseudodifferential operator of order 0 that acts as a cutoff in phase space T ∗ Y \0. Assume that we observe u0 = χ u in accordance with the constraints of the acquisition geometry. Suppose χ is elliptic on a leaf of the foliation of L, then WF(π u0 ) intersected with this leaf is equal to WF(u) intersected with the same leaf. In this case, π heals the data on this leaf. Proof. We observe that u = πv for some v. Then u0 = (χ π) v.
(33)
Because π 2 u = u, it is natural to investigate πu0 , i.e. πu0 = (πχ π) v.
(34)
If χ is elliptic on a leaf of the foliation of L, then (π − π χ π ) v = 0, or u − π u0 = 0, microlocally on this leaf. This implies the statement in the theorem. We implement π by making use of the following observation. In view of the Bolker condition, Assumption 4, the composition F ∗ F is an elliptic pseudodifferential operator of order n − 1. Let denote the parametrix for F ∗ F . The operator F F ∗ belongs to Guillemin and Sternberg’s algebra RL [14] of Fourier integral operators with canonical relation 1 [6]. Clearly, (F F ∗ )2 = F F ∗ microlocally, while I − F ∗ F = I − F ∗ F is the orthogonal projection onto the kernel of F ∗ F . Indeed, F F ∗ is precisely an elliptic minimal projector [14, Proof of Thm. 8.3] of the type introduced in Sect. 4. The symbol of this operator follows by the standard composition calculus. Following the composition of F with F ∗ in F F ∗ , we represent the canonical relation 1 as the composition of canonical relations with ∗ . Remark 3. The transformation to zero offset (TZO) of seismic data, which is derived from Dip MoveOut, can be expressed in the form R0 π , where R0 is the restriction of distributions on Y to an acquisition manifold with coinciding sources and receivers: In this case, y = (y , y ) with y = ( 21 (s + r), t) and y = 21 (r − s) if (s, r, t) are the original local coordinates on Y . Assumption 2, subject to this substitution, guarantees that the composition, R0 π, is again a Fourier integral operator.
14
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
5. Goldin’s Equation Revisited In context of the simplest seismic scattering theory, in a background that essentially is constant, the following simplications are made. To begin with, the source, s, and receiver, r, points in Y are assumed to be contained in a flat surface, Rn−1 , while e is initially replaced by half source-receiver offset h = 21 (r − s) ∈ Rn−1 . Thus y is replaced by (s, r, t); we write η = (σ, ρ, τ ). Essentially, we assume that the rays between reflector and acquisition surface are straight, see Fig. 1. We repeat the NMO correction, 4h2 κ : (s, r, t) → (z, tn , h), z = 21 (r + s), h = 21 (r − s), tn = t 2 − 2 , v of the introduction. (The subscript n refers in this section to normal moveout.) Here, v could be thought of as the so-called NMO velocity, which can be introduced for ‘pure mode’ scattering (i.e. M = N ), even in the anisotropic media under consideration here [12]; Goldin, however, restricts his analysis to an isotropic medium and compressional waves. We will reproduce Goldin’s result here in the context of our analysis subject to the substitutions n = 2 and c = 0 (and m = 1). NMO correction applied to the data yields (κ −1 )∗ d. Including a so-called geometrical spreading correction, a multiplication by time t, then leads to the map d(s, r, t) → ((κ −1 )∗ (t d))(z, tn , h)
(35)
that replaces (H −1 d)(x, e); the point x has attained coordinates (z, tn ). The outcome is of the form r(z, tn , h) = Rn (z, h) cn (tn − Tn (z, h)).
Fig. 1. Geometry underlying the annihilator symbol for constant coefficients
(36)
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
15
Equation (36) replaces (22). The reflection time, T (s, r, x) maps under κ according to 4h2 T (s, r, x) → Tn (z, h) = (T (z − h, z + h, x))2 − 2 . v We observe that, in the simplication considered, Rn is independent of tn , while cn is not only a function of (z, tn ) but also of h. Hence, a simple derivative of r with respect to h, motivated by (26), would not yield a vanishing outcome up to leading order. Instead, it is possible to construct a candidate operator P1 , acting on the data, directly. In Fig. 1 we introduce angles α and γ ; in fact, (x, α, γ ) can be identified with (x, ν, e). Using simple trigonometric identities (including the law of sines) and the geometry in Fig. 1 α (observing that the total length of the reflected ray is vt = (r − s) cos sin γ with 2γ denoting the scattering angle and α denoting the incidence angle of the zero-offset ray at the surface), it follows that τ
(r − s)2 2 −1 (σ − ρ)−2 (r − s) t −τ σρ = 0 (37) p1 (s, r, t, σ, ρ, τ ) = t + v2 v2 defines the points in L (Remark 2) in the simplification under consideration; p1 is v dependent. Applying the coordinate transformation implied by κ to this symbol, and multiplying the result by frequency τ , yields p (z, tn , h, ζ, τn , ε) = (τp1 )(κ(s, r, t), ((κ )−1 )t (σ, ρ, τ ))
(38)
p (z, tn , h, ζ, τn , ε) = −tn τn ε + h (ζ 2 − ε 2 ),
(39)
or
which defines the principal symbol of an operator P ; we observe that p is v independent. We recover Goldin’s equation, P (z, tn , h, Dz , Dtn , Dh )r = 0,
2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂ P (z, tn , h, Dz , Dtn , Dh ) = tn − 2 , −h ∂tn ∂h ∂z2 ∂h
(40)
which is valid up to highest order. It would be valid up to the next order if we had not applied the geometrical spreading correction in (35). Accounting for this correction leads to a subprincipal symbol contribution: 2 ∂ ∂2 ∂ ∂2 P (z, tn , h, Dz , Dtn , Dh ) := tn −h . − − 2 2 ∂tn ∂h ∂z ∂h ∂h Through the coordinate transformation implied by κ, we obtain a subprincipal symbol contribution to the operator with principal symbol p1 (cf. (37)). Note that the operator P is of second order unlike the operator annihilating r in (26) which is of first order. However, in (38) we introduced a multiplication by τ , raising the order by one. A first-order operator derived from P in (40) follows to be P (z, tn , h, Dz , Dtn , Dh ) =
∂ ∂h
−1
h tn
∂2 ∂2 − ∂h2 ∂z2
+
∂ . ∂tn
16
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
We write down the Hamiltonian system describing the flowout as in (31); there is only one such system since n − c − 1 = 1. We use the first-order symbol, p (z, tn , h, ζ, τn , ε) = τn − εthn (ζ 2 − ε 2 ) (we omitted a factor i), so that 2hζ ∂z =− ∂e εtn
,
∂ζ = 0, ∂e
∂tn =1 ∂e
,
∂τn h = − 2 (ζ 2 − ε 2 ), ∂e εtn
∂h 2h ζ2 h , =− 2 + ∂e ε tn tn
(41)
∂ε 1 (ζ 2 − ε 2 ). = ∂e εtn
We set e = tn , and eliminate τn . To this end, we introduce the slowness vectors ζ and ε according to ζ = τn ζ and ε = τn ε. Substituting τn = εthn (ζ 2 − ε 2 ) (using that p = 0), and the equation for
∂τn ∂e ,
then yields the system
2h ζ ∂z =− ∂tn ε tn
,
∂ ζ = ∂tn
ζ , tn
∂h h 1 =− + , ∂tn ε tn
∂ ε = ∂tn
ζ2 . ε tn
(42)
We note that tn and h are directly related to one another. Indeed, let the zero-offset reflecton time be given by T0 = T (z0 , z0 , x) = Tn (z0 , 0). Then, for given z, h Tn = 2 . T0 (h − (z − z0 )2 )1/2 Along bicharacteristics, h v2 =− ε tn 4 sin2 α
(43)
is invariant (i.e. its derivative with respect to e is zero). We can convert tn to half scattering angle γ – keeping (x, α) fixed – according to the relation cos α cos γ Tn = , T0 (cos2 α − sin2 γ )1/2
T0 =
2V . v
(44)
We discuss in as much the kernel of P determines the range of F under the simplication (‘straight rays’) under consideration. The range is described by wavefields of the form −1 cos2 γ + V C ¯ r(x, γ ) δ(t − T ), T = T (s, r, x), (45) d(s, r, t) = vt cos γ obtained after preprocessing d for time signature (a 2.5D correction) and source or receiver radiation characteristics, applying an appropriate pseudodifferential operator. In (45), V = 21 vT (z, z, x) denotes the length of the zero-offset ray, and C = x 2 (x1 ) cos3 α denotes the curvature of the reflector, see Fig. 1. We have assumed that the reflecting
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
17
interface can be described by the graph (x1 , x 2 (x1 )). (If the interface is the zero level ∂z2 set of z2 = z2 (x1 , x2 ) then we assume that ∂x = 0.) Equation (45) is the outcome of 2 a stationary phase calculation of the scattered field in the Kirchhoff approximation. We ¯ r, t) and obtain set r(x, γ ) ≡ 1 and apply (κ −1 )∗ to d(s, r¯ (z, tn , h) = An (z, h) δ(tn − Tn ), Tn = Tn (z, h), −1 cos2 γ + V C t , An = vt cos γ tn
(46)
because | dtdtn | = ttn . Expression (46) is indeed of the form (36). To verify whether the wavefields in (45), via (46), coincide with functions in the kern nel of P , up to leading order, we first notice that by derivation p (z, Tn , h, −iτn ∂T ∂z , τn , n −iτn ∂T ∂h ) = 0. Secondly, we consider the transport equation derived from (40), which is given by Tn − 2h
∂Tn ∂h
∂Tn ∂An ∂An + 2h + hAn ∂h ∂z ∂z
∂ 2 Tn ∂ 2 Tn − 2 ∂z ∂h2
= 0.
n ∂Tn The velocity vector associated with a ray or characteristic is given by ( ∂T ∂z , ∂h ). Thus, along a characteristic, the transport equation becomes
−
1 dAn ∂Tn −1 ∂ 2 Tn ∂ 2 Tn = 0, + h Tn − An dTn ∂h ∂z2 ∂h2
(47)
where we made use of (42). We change variables according to (44), with 1 dTn sin2 α sin γ . =− Tn dγ (cos2 α − sin2 γ ) cos γ Furthermore, using the ray geometry, we find the identity Tn
∂ 2 Tn ∂ 2 Tn − ∂z2 ∂h2
∂ 2T cos2 γ sin2 α + V C cos2 γ =4 T = 4 + . ∂s∂r v2 v 2 cos2 γ + V C
(48)
Substituting identity (48) and invariant (43) into (47), applying the change of variables (44), leads to the equation, −
1 dAn + An dγ
1 1 − (cos2 α − sin2 γ ) cos2 γ + V C
sin γ cos γ = 0.
(49)
This equation can be directly integrated to yield solutions for An of the type (46). We conclude that the kernel of P generates wavefields of the type (45) which comprise the range of the scattering operator subject to processing for time signature and setting r(x, γ ) ≡ 1.
18
M.V. de Hoop, G. Uhlmann
6. Numerical Example The minimal elliptic projector π is a Fourier integral operator and is directly implementable and applicable to data. This is the subject of this section. Indeed, given a smooth background model, we can construct a minimal elliptic projector for data continuation by operator composition, F F ∗ . On the other hand, however, in Sect. 4 we showed that, given the annihilators of the data (in practice, just their principal parts), we can construct the global parametrix Q, from which the elliptic minimal projector follows. This procedure is related to what Guillemin and Sternberg call relative geometrical quantization. We include an example to confirm the computability of our result. The algorithm used is designed and explained in [20]. In our example, n = 2 and χ is replaced by a smooth cutoff ψY ; the cutoff restricts the data to the set {(s, r, t) | s, r ∈ Rn−1 , r −s > h0 , t ∈ (0, T )}. The goal is to continue the data to an acquisition manifold with the constraint
r − s > h0 removed. Elastic-wave data were simulated over a model illustrated in Fig. 2 (top). The P-wave velocities are shown in grey scale; a low-velocity Gaussian lens was inserted (white-to-grey). The continuation is illustrated for the P-wave constituents even though the simulated data contained S waves as well. By selecting the vertical
Fig. 2. A numerical example of data continuation: The top figure is the isotropic P-wave velocity model used in the reflection data simulation, containing a Gaussian (low velocity) lens (in white). The bottom two figures both show a shot record (receiver location versus time) with source location at the black vertical line in top figure; the left record shows the outcome of continuation (the data in between the two vertical lines was missing) while the right record shows the original simulated data
Characterization of Seismic Reflection Data
19
displacement component, most energy in the wavefield can be attributed to P waves. For one value of s the synthetic data as a function of r and t are shown in Fig. 2 (bottom, right). We set T = 3s and h0 = 500m. The input to the continuation (u0 ) were the data with r values in between the black vertical lines removed Fig. 2 (bottom, left). The result of the continuation is plotted in between the black vertical lines of the same figure and should be compared with Fig. 2 (bottom, right). References 1. Beylkin, G.: The inversion problem and applications of the generalized Radon transform. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. XXXVII, 579–599 (1984) 2. Biondi, B., Fomel, S., Chemingui, N.: Azimuth moveout for 3-D prestack imaging. Geophysics 63, 574–588 (1998) 3. Bolondi, G., Loinger, E., Rocca, F.: Offset continuation of seismic sections. Geoph. Prosp. 30, 813–828 (1982) 4. De Hoop, M.V., Bleistein, N.: Generalized radon transform inversions for reflectivity in anisotropic elastic media. Inverse Problems 13, 669–690 (1997) 5. De Hoop, M.V., Brandsberg-Dahl, S.: Maslov asymptotic extension of generalized Radon transform inversion in anisotropic elastic media: A least-squares approach. Inverse Problems 16, 519–562 (2000) 6. De Hoop, M.V., Malcolm, A.E., Le Rousseau, J.H.: Seismic wavefield ‘continuation’ in the single scattering approximation: A framework for Dip and Azimuth MoveOut. Can. Appl. Math. Q. 10, 199–238 (2002) 7. Deregowski, S.G., Rocca, F.: Geometrical optics and wave theory of constant offset sections in layered media. Geoph. Prosp. 29, 374–406 (1981) 8. Duistermaat, J.J.: Fourier integral operators. Boston: Birkh¨auser, 1996 9. Fomel, S.: Theory of differential offset continuation. Geophysics 68, 718–732 (2003) 10. Gel’fand, I.M., Graev, M.I.: Complexes of straight lines in the space Cn . Funct. Anal. Appl. 2, 39–52 (1968) 11. Goldin, S.: Superposition and continuation of transformations used in seismic migration. Russ. Geol. and Geophys. 35, 131–145 (1994) 12. Grechka, V., Tsvankin, I., Cohen, J.K.: Generalized Dix equation and analytic treatment of normalmoveout velocity for anisotropic media. Geoph. Prosp. 47, 117–148 (1999) 13. Guillemin, V.: In: Pseudodifferential operators and applications (Notre Dame, Ind., 1984), Chapter “On some results of Gel’fand in integral geometry”, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1985, pp. 149–155 14. Guillemin, V., Sternberg, S.: Some problems in integral geometry and some related problems in microlocal analysis. Amer. J. of Math. 101, 915–955 (1979) 15. Guillemin, V., Uhlmann, G.: Oscillatory integrals with singular symbols. Duke Math. J. 48, 251–267 (1981) 16. Hansen, S.: Solution of a hyperbolic inverse problem by linearization. Commun. Par. Differ. Eqs. 16, 291–309 (1991) 17. H¨ormander, L.: The analysis of linear partial differential operators. Volume IV. Berlin: SpringerVerlag, 1985 18. H¨ormander, L.: The analysis of linear partial differential operators. Volume III. Berlin: SpringerVerlag, 1985 19. John, F.: The ultrahyperbolic differential equation with four independent variables. Duke Math. J. 4, 300–322 (1938) 20. Malcolm, A.E., De Hoop, M.V., Le Rousseau, J.H.: The applicability of DMO/AMO in the presence of caustics. Geophysics 70, 51 (2005) 21. Maslov, V.P., Fedoriuk, M.V.: Semi-classical approximation in quantum mechanics. Dordrecht: Reidel Publishing Company, 1981 22. Patch, S.K.: Computation of unmeasured third-generation VCT views from measured views. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 21, 801–813 (2002) 23. Stolk, C.C., De Hoop, M.V.: Microlocal analysis of seismic inverse scattering in anisotropic, elastic media. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 55, 261–301 (2002) 24. Taylor, M.E.: Reflection of singularities of solutions to systems of differential equations. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 28, 457–478 (1975) Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 263, 21–64 (2006) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1492-5
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment A. Faggionato1 , H. Schulz-Baldes2 , D. Spehner3 1 2 3
Weierstrass Institut f¨ur Angewandte Analysis und Stochastic, 10117 Berlin, Germany Institut f¨ur Mathematik, Technische Universit¨at Berlin, 10623 Berlin, Germany Fachbereich Physik, Universit¨at Duisburg-Essen, 45117 Essen, Germany
Received: 21 July 2004 / Accepted: 16 September 2005 Published online: 24 January 2006 – © Springer-Verlag 2006
Abstract: We consider a random walk on the support of an ergodic stationary simple point process on Rd , d ≥ 2, which satisfies a mixing condition w.r.t. the translations or has a strictly positive density uniformly on large enough cubes. Furthermore the point process is furnished with independent random bounded energy marks. The transition rates of the random walk decay exponentially in the jump distances and depend on the energies through a factor of the Boltzmann-type. This is an effective model for the phonon-induced hopping of electrons in disordered solids within the regime of strong Anderson localization. We show that the rescaled random walk converges to a Brownian motion whose diffusion coefficient is bounded below by Mott’s law for the variable range hopping conductivity at zero frequency. The proof of the lower bound involves estimates for the supercritical regime of an associated site percolation problem. 1. Introduction 1.1. Main Result. Let us directly describe the model and the main results of this work, deferring a discussion of the underlying physics to the next section. Suppose given an infinite countable set of random points {xj } ⊂ Rd distributed according to some ergodic stationary simple point process. One can identify this set with the simple counting measure ξˆ = j δxj having {xj } as its support, and then write x ∈ ξˆ if x ∈ {xj }. The σ -algebra B(Nˆ ) on the space Nˆ of counting measures on Rd is generated by the family of subsets {ξˆ ∈ Nˆ : ξˆ (B) = n}, where B ⊂ Rd is Borel and n ∈ N. The distribution Pˆ of the point process is a probability on the measure space (Nˆ , B(Nˆ )). It is stationary and ergodic w.r.t. the translations x → x + y of Rd . In the sequel, we need to impose boundedness of some κth moment defined by ρκ := EPˆ ξˆ (C1 )κ , (1) ˆ Then ρ = ρ1 is the so–called where C1 = [− 21 , 21 ]d and EPˆ is the expectation w.r.t. P. intensity of the process.
22
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
To each xj is associated a random energy mark Exj ∈ [−1, 1]. These marks are drawn independently and identically according to a probability measure ν. Again, {(xj , Exj )} is naturally identified with an element ξ of the space N of counting measures on Rd × [−1, 1], and the distribution P of the marked process is a measure on (N , B(N )) (with B(N ) defined similarly to B(Nˆ )). The distribution P is said to be the ν–randomization of Pˆ [Kal]. It is stationary and ergodic w.r.t. Rd –translations. In order to assure that {xj } contains the origin, we consider the measurable subset N0 = {ξ ∈ N : ξ({0} × [−1, 1]) = 1} furnished with the σ -algebra B(N0 ) = {A ∩ N0 : A ∈ B(N )}. The random environment is given by a configuration ξ ∈ N0 randomly chosen along the Palm distribution P0 associated to P. Roughly, one can think of P0 as the probability on (N0 , B(N0 )) obtained by conditioning P to the event N0 (see Sect. 2). Note that almost each environment is a simple counting measure, and therefore it can be identified with its support as we will do in what follows. For a fixed environment ξ ≡ {(xj , Exj )} ∈ N0 let us consider a continuous-time random walk over the points {xj } starting at the origin x = 0 with transition rates from x ∈ ξˆ to y ∈ ξˆ given by cx,y (ξ ) := exp − |x − y| − β(|Ex − Ey | + |Ex | + |Ey |) , x = y , (2) where β > 0 is the inverse temperature. More precisely, let ξ = D([0, ∞), supp(ξˆ )) be the space of right-continuous paths on the support of ξˆ having left limits, endowed ξ ξ with the Skorohod topology [Bil]. Let us write (Xt )t≥0 for a generic element of ξ . If P0 denotes the distribution on (ξ , B(ξ )) of the above random walk starting at the origin, ξ ξ ξ ξ then the set of stationary transition probabilities pt (y|x) := P0 (Xs+t = y|Xs = x), x, y ∈ ξˆ , t ≥ 0, s > 0 satisfy the following conditions for small values of t [Bre]: ξ
(C1) pt (y|x) = cx,y (ξ ) t + o(t) if x = y; ξ (C2) pt (x|x) = 1−λx (ξ ) t +o(t) with λx (ξ ) := y∈ξˆ cx,y (ξ ), where cx,x (ξ ) := 0. It is verified in Appendix A that, provided that ρ2 < ∞, no explosions occur and thus the random walk is well-defined for P0 –almost all ξ . Our main interest concerns the long time asymptotics of the random walk and the diffusion matrix D defined by 1 ξ (a · Da) = lim a ∈ Rd , EP0 EPξ (Xt · a)2 , (3) t→∞ t 0 where (a · b) denotes the scalar product of the vectors a and b in Rd . The main results of the work are (i) the existence of the limit (3) in any dimension d ≥ 1 as well as the convergence of the (diffusively rescaled) random walk to a Brownian motion with finite covariance matrix D ≥ 0; (ii) a quantitative lower bound on D in dimension d ≥ 2 under given assumptions on the energy distribution ν and either one of the following two technical hypotheses. Let denote the Lebesgue measure and CN = [−N/2, N/2]d . Given A ⊂ Rd , let FA be the σ –subalgebra in B(Nˆ ) generated by the random variables ξˆ (B) with B ⊂ A and B ∈ B(Rd ). (H1) Pˆ admits a lower bound ρ > 0 on the point density: ξˆ (CN ) ≥ ρ (CN ), with ρ and N0 independent on ξˆ .
ˆ ∀ N ≥ N0 , P-a.s. ,
(4)
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
23
(H2) Pˆ satisfies the following mixing condition: there exists a function h : R+ → R+ with h(r) ≤ c(1 + r 2d+7+δ )−1 for some c, δ > 0 such that for any r2 ≥ r1 > 1, ˆ ˆ ˆ ∀ A ∈ FCr1 , P-a.s. (5) ≤ r1d r2d−1 h(r2 − r1 ) , P(A|FRd \Cr ) − P(A) 2
We feel that Hypotheses (H1) and (H2) cover nearly all interesting examples see however Example 2 below. The uniform lower bound (H1) holds in the case of random and quasiperiodic tilings and, more generally, the so-called Delone sets [BHZ]. The type of mixing condition (H2) is inspired by decorrelation estimates holding for Gibbs measures of spin systems in a high temperature phase [Mar]. It is satisfied for a stationary Poisson point process as well as for point processes with finite range correlations. Due ˆ (H2) implies that Pˆ is a mixing, and, in particular, ergodic point to the stationarity of P, process (see [DV, Chap. 10]). We can now state more precisely the above-mentioned results. Theorem 1. Let Pˆ be the distribution of an ergodic stationary simple point process on Rd , let P be the distribution of its ν–randomization with a probability measure ν on [−1, 1], and let P0 be the Palm distribution associated to P. Assume that ρ12 < ∞ and that δ(xj ,Ej ) ⇒ ξ = Sx ξ := δ(xj −x,Ej ) ∀ x ∈ Rd \ {0}, P a.s. (6) ξ= j
j
Condition (6) is automatically satisfied if ν is not a Dirac measure. Then: ξ
(i) The limit in (3) exists and the rescaled process Y ξ,ε = (εXtε−2 )t≥0 defined on ξ
(ξ , P0 ) converges weakly in P0 -probability as ε → 0 to a Brownian motion W D with covariance matrix D. Namely, for any bounded continuous function F on the path space D([0, ∞), Rd ) endowed with the Skorohod topology, → E F WD in P0 -probability . EPξ F Y ξ,ε 0
(ii) Suppose d ≥ 2 and let either (H1) or (H2) be satisfied. Furthermore, suppose that there are some positive constants α, c0 such that, for any 0 < E ≤ 1,
Then
ν([−E, E]) ≥ c0 E 1+α .
(7)
d(α+1) α+1 D ≥ c1 β − α+1+d exp −c2 β α+1+d 1d ,
(8)
where 1d is the d × d identity matrix and c1 and c2 are some positive β-independent constants. The important factor in the lower bound (8) is the exponential factor and not the power law in front of it (on which we comment below though). Based on the following heuristics due to Mott [Mot, SE], we expect that the expression in the exponential in (8) captures the good asymptotic behavior of ln D in the low temperature limit β ↑ ∞ if ν([−E, E]) ∼ c0 E 1+α as E ↓ 0. Indeed, as β becomes larger, the rates (2) fluctuate widely with (x, y) because of the exponential energy factor. The low temperature limit effectively selects only jumps between points with energies in a small interval [−E(β), E(β)] shrinking to zero as β ↑ ∞. Assuming that D is determined by those
24
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
jumps with the largest rate, one obtains directly the characteristic exponential factor on the r.h.s. of (8) by maximizing these rates for a fixed temperature under the constraint that the mean density of points xj with energies in [−E(β), E(β)] is equal to ρ ν([−E(β), E(β)]) ∼ c0 ρE(β)1+α . One speaks of variable range hopping since the characteristic mean distance |x − y| between sites with optimal jump rates varies heavily with the temperature. A crucial (and physically reasonable, as discussed below) element of this argument is the independence of the energies Ex . The selection of the points {xj } with energies in the window [−E(β), E(β)] then corresponds mathematically to a p-thinning with p = ν([−E(β), E(β)]). It is a well-known fact (see e.g. [Kal, Theorem 16.19]) that an adequate rescaling of the p-thinning of a stationary point process converges in the limit p ↓ 0 (corresponding here to β ↑ ∞) to a stationary Poisson point process (PPP). Hence one might call the stationary PPP the normal form of a model leading Mott’s law, namely the exponential factor on the r.h.s. of (8), and we believe that proving the upper bound corresponding to (8) should therefore be most simple for the PPP. In dimension d = 1, a different behavior of D is expected [LB] and this will not be considered here. Note that statement (i) does not necessarily imply that the motion of the particle is diffusive at large time, since it could happen that D = 0. (α+1)(2−d)
The preexponential factor in (8) can be improved to β (1+α+d) by means of formal scaling arguments on the formulas in Sects. 4 to 6. As we are not sure that this is optimal and we do not control the constant c2 in (8) anyway, we choose not to develop this improvement in detail.
1.2. Physical discussion. Our main motivation for studying the above model comes from its importance for phonon-assisted hopping conduction [SE] in disordered solids in which the Fermi level (set equal to 0 above) lies in a region of strong Anderson localization. This means that the electron Hamiltonian has exponentially localized quantum eigenstates with localization centers xj if the corresponding energies Exj are close to the Fermi level. The DC conductivity of such materials would vanish if it were not for the lattice vibrations (phonons) at nonzero temperature. They induce transitions between the localized eigenstates, the rate of which can be calculated from first principle by means of the Fermi golden rule [MA, SE]. In the variable range hopping regime at low temperature, the Markov and adiabatic (or rotating wave) approximations can be used to treat quantum mechanically the electron-phonon coupling [Spe]. Coherences between electronic eigenstates with different energies decay very rapidly under the resulting dissipative electronic dynamics and one can show that the hopping DC conductivity of the disordered solid coincides with the conductivity associated with a Markov jump process on the set of localization centers {xj }, hence justifying the use of a model of classical mechanics [BRSW]. Because Pauli blocking due to Fermi statistics of the electrons has to be taken into account, this leads to a rather complicated exclusion process (e.g. [Qua, FM]). If, however, the blocking is treated in an effective medium (or mean field) approximation, one obtains a family of independent random walks with rates which are given by (2) in the limit β ↑ ∞ [MA, AHL]. Let us discuss the remaining aspects of the model. The stationarity of the underlying simple point process {xj } simply reflects that the material is homogeneous, while the independence of the energy marks is compatible with Poisson level statistics, which is a general rough indicator for the localization regime and has been proven to hold for an Anderson model [Min]. The exponent α allows to model a possible Coulomb pseudogap in the density of states [SE].
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
25
Having in mind the Einstein relation between the conductivity and the diffusion coefficient (which can be stated as a theorem for a number of models [Spo]), the lower bound (8) gives a lower bound on the hopping DC condutivity. In the above materials, the DC conductivity shows experimentally Mott’s law, namely a low-temperature behavior which is well approximated by the exponential factor in the r.h.s. of (8) with α = 0, as predicted by Mott [Mot] based on the optimization argument discussed above. In certain materials having a Coulomb pseudogap in the density of state, Mott’s law with α = d −1 is observed, as predicted by Efros and Shklovskii [EF]. A first convincing justification of Mott’s argument was given by Ambegoakar, Halperin and Langer [AHL], who first reduced the hopping model to a related random resistor network, in a manner similar to the work of Miller and Abrahams [MA], and then pointed out that the constant c2 in (8) can be estimated using percolation theory [SE]. Our proof of the lower bound (8) is inspired by this work. Let us also mention that the low frequency AC conductivity (response to an oscillating electric field) in disordered solids has recently been studied within a quantum-mechanical one-body approximation in [KLP]. Here the energy necessary for a jump between localized states comes from a resonance at the frequency of the external electric field rather than a phonon. It leads to another well-known formula for the conductivity which is also due to Mott. 1.3. Overview. Let us develop the main ideas of the proof of Theorem 1, leaving precise statements and their proofs to the following sections. The model described above is a random walk in a random environment. A main tool used in this work is the contribution of De Masi, Ferrari, Goldstein and Wick [DFGW] which is based on prior work by Kipnis and Varadhan [KV]. They construct a new Markov process, called the environment viewed from the particle, which allows to translate the homogeneity of the medium ξ into properties of the random walk. In Sect. 3, we argue that Xt has finite moments ξ w.r.t. P0 (dξ )P0 (Proposition 1) and study the generator of the process environment viewed from the particle when the initial environment is chosen according to the Palm distribution P0 (Propositions 2 and 3), thus allowing to apply the general Theorem 2.2 of [DFGW] to deduce the existence of the limit (3). The convergence to a Brownian motion stated in Theorem 1 also follows, but this could have been obtained (avoiding an analysis of the infinitesimal generator) by applying Theorem 17.1 of [Bil] and Theorem 2.1 of [DFGW]. The results of [DFGW] also lead to a variational formula for the diffusion matrix D (Theorem 2 below). The main virtue of this formula is that it allows to bound D from below through bounds on the transition rates. The first step in proving Theorem 1(ii) is to define a new random walk with transition rates bounded above by the rates (2). This is done in Sect. 4 in the following way. For a fixed configuration ξ ∈ N0 of the environment, consider the set {xjc } = {xj : |Exj | ≤ Ec } of all random points having energies inside a given energy window [−Ec , Ec ] with 0 < Ec ≤ 1. The distribution Pˆ c of these points is obtained from P by a δc -thinning with δc = ν([−Ec , Ec ]). Given a cut-off distance rc > 0, consider the random walk on supp(ξˆ ) with the transition rates cˆx,y (ξ ) = χ (|x −y| ≤ rc )χ (|Ex | ≤ Ec )χ (|Ey | ≤ Ec ), where χ is the characteristic function. Since we want this random walk to have a strictly positive diffusion coefficient in the limit Ec → 0, one must choose rc such that the mean number of points xj with energies in [−Ec , Ec ] inside a ball of radius rc is larger than an Ec -independent constant c3 > 0. This mean number is equal to c4 δc rcd and is larger than c5 Ec1+α rcd by assumption (7), where c4 and c5 are constants depending on ρ and d −(1+α)/d only. Hence rc = c6 Ec . It is shown in Proposition 5 that the diffusion matrix of
26
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
the new random walk is equal to δc D(rc , Ec ), where D(rc , Ec ) is the diffusion matrix of a random walk on {xjc } with energy-independent transition rates χ (|x − y| ≤ rc ). By the monotonicity of D in the jump rates and since cx,y (ξ ) ≥ exp(−rc − 4βEc ) cˆx,y (ξ ), one gets using also assumption (7) and the constant c0 therein: D ≥ c0 Ec1+α e−rc −4βEc D(rc , Ec ) .
(9)
In Sect. 5, a lower bound on D(rc , Ec ) is obtained by considering periodic approximants (in the limit of large periods) as in [DFGW]. The diffusion coefficient of these approximants can be computed as the resistance of a random resistor network. The resistance of the random resistor network is bounded by invoking estimates from percolation theory in Sect. 6, hence showing that, if rc is large enough, D(rc , Ec ) > c7 1d , where −(1+α)/d c7 > 0 is independent on Ec , β. Recalling that rc = c6 Ec , an optimization w.r.t. d Ec of the right member of (9) then yields Ec = c8 β − 1+α+d and thus the lower bound (8). Let us note that this optimization is the same as in the Mott argument discussed above and that Ec ↓ 0 and rc ↑ ∞ as β ↑ ∞. Moreover, our optimized lower bound results from a critical resistor network roughly approximating the one appearing in [AHL]. The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2 we recall some definitions and results about point processes and state some technical results needed later on. The statements (i) and (ii) of Theorem 1 are proven in Sect. 3 and in Sects. 4 to 6, respectively. In Appendix A we show that the continuous-time random walk in the random environment is well defined by verifying the absence of explosion phenomena. Appendix B contains some technical proofs about the Palm measure. Appendix C is devoted to the proof of Proposition 1. 2. The Random Environment In this section, we recall some properties of point processes (for more details, see [DV, FKAS, MKM, Kal, Tho]). In the sequel, given a topological space X, B(X) will denote the σ -algebra of Borel subsets of X. Given a set A, |A| will denote its cardinality. Moreover, given a probability measure µ, we write Eµ for the corresponding expectation. 2.1. Stationary simple marked point processes. Given a bounded complete separable metric space K, consider the space N := N (Rd × K) of all counting measures ξ on Rd × K, i.e. integer-valued measures such that ξ(B × K) < ∞ for any bounded set B ∈ B(Rd ). One can show that ξ ∈ N if and only if ξ = j δ(xj ,kj ) where δ is the Dirac measure and {(xj , kj )} is a countable family of (not necessarily distinct) points in Rd × K with at most finitely many points in any bounded set. Then kj is called the mark at xj . Given ξ ∈ N , we write ξˆ ∈ N (Rd ) for the counting measure on Rd defined by ξˆ (B) = ξ(B × K) for any B ∈ B(Rd ). Given x ∈ Rd , we write x ∈ ξˆ whenever x ∈ supp(ξˆ ). If ξˆ ({x}) ≤ 1 for any x ∈ Rd , we say that ξ ∈ N is simple and write kxj := kj for any xj ∈ ξˆ . A metric on N can be defined in the following way [MKM, Sect. 1.15]. Fix an element d k ∗ ∈ K. Denote by Br (x, k) and Br the open balls in R × K of radius r > 0 centred ∗ on (x, k) and on (0, k ), respectively. Let ξ = i∈I δ(xi ,ki ) and ξ = j ∈J δ(xj ,kj ) be elements of N , where I , J are countable sets. Then ξ and ξ are close to each other if any point (xi , ki ) contained in Bn is close to a point (xj , kj ) for arbitrary large n, up
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
27
to “boundary effects”. More precisely, given a positive integer n, let dn (ξ, ξ ) be the infimum over all ε > 0 such that there is a one-to-one map f from a (possibly empty) subset D of I into a subset of J with the properties: (i) supp(ξ ) ∩ Bn−ε ⊂ {(xi , ki ) : i ∈ D}; (ii) supp(ξ ) ∩ Bn−ε ⊂ {(xj , kj ) : j ∈ f (D)}; (iii) (xf (i) , kf (i) ) ∈ Bε (xi , ki ) for i ∈ D. −n
One can show that dN (ξ, ξ ) = ∞ n=1 2 dn (ξ, ξ ) is a bounded metric on N and for this metric N is complete and separable. Moreover, the sets {ξ ∈ N : ξ(B) = n}, B ∈ B(Rd × K), n ∈ N, generate theBorel σ -algebra B(N ) and dN generates the coarsest topology such that ξ ∈ N → ξ(dx, dk) f (x, k) is continuous for any continuous function f ≥ 0 on Rd × K with bounded support. Finally, by choosing different reference points k ∗ one obtains equivalent metrics. A marked point process on Rd with marks in K is then a measurable map from a probability space into N . We denote by P its distribution (a probability measure on (N , B(N ))). We say that the process is simple if P-almost all ξ ∈ N are simple. The translations on Rd extend naturally to Rd × K by Sx : (y, k) → (x + y, k). This induces an action S of the translation group Rd on N by (Sx ξ )(B) = ξ(Sx B), where B ∈ B(Rd × K) and x ∈ Rd . For simple counting measures, δ(y−x,ky ) . Sx ξ = y∈ξˆ
A marked point process is said to be stationary if P(A) = P(Sx A) for all x ∈ Rd , A ∈ B(N ), and (space) ergodic if the σ -algebra of translation invariant sets is trivial, i.e., if A ∈ B(N ) satisfies Sx A = A for all x ∈ Rd then P(A) ∈ {0, 1}. Due to [DV, Prop. 10.1.IV], if P is stationary and gives no weight to the trivial measure without any point (which will be assumed here), then P ξ ∈ N : supp(ξˆ ) = ∞ = 1 . (10) The marked point processes studied in this work are obtained by the procedure of randomization, which we recall now together with the related notion of thinning (see [Kal]). ˆ be a stationary simple point process (SSPP) on Rd , ν be a probability measure Let ˆ is the stationary simple marked on [−1, 1] and p ∈ [0, 1]. The ν–randomization of point process (SSMPP) ν obtained by assigning to each realization ξˆ = i∈I δxi of ˆ the measure ξ = i∈I δ(xi ,Ei ) , where {Ei }i∈I are independent identically distributed ˆ of ˆ is the SSPP on random variables having distribution ν. Finally, the p–thinning p d R obtained by assigning to each realization ξˆ the measure i∈I Pi δxi , where {Pi }i∈I are independent Bernoulli variables with Prob(Pi = 1) = p and Prob(Pi = 0) = 1 − p. ˆ p are examples of stationary cluster processes, also Both the point processes ν and called homogeneous cluster fields (see [DV, Chap. 8] and [MKM, Chap. 10]). In particular, ergodicity is conserved by ν–randomization and p–thinning ([DV, Prop. 10.3.IX] and [MKM, Prop. 11.1.4]). To conclude, let us give a few examples. Example 1. A Poisson point process (PPP) appears, as already discussed, naturally as limit distribution of thinnings. Given a measure µ on X, with X equal to Rd or Rd × [−1, 1], the PPP on X with intensity measure µ is defined by the two conditions (i) for any B ∈ B(X), ξ(B) is a Poisson random variable with expectation µ(B); (ii) for any
28
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
disjoint sets B1 , . . . , Bn ∈ B(X), ξ(B1 ), . . . , ξ(Bn ) are independent. A PPP on Rd is stationary if and only if its intensity measure µ is proportional to the Lebesgue measure, µ = ρ dx. In such a case it is an ergodic process satisfying the hypothesis (H2) of Theorem 1 and all moments ρκ , κ > 0 in (1) are finite. Its p–thinning is the PPP on Rd with intensity pρ while its ν–randomization is the PPP on Rd × [−1, 1] with intensity measure ρ dx ⊗ ν. Example 2. Let us associate to the uniformly distributed random variable y in the unit cube C1 the point measure ξˆ = z∈Zd δz+y . The corresponding point process is an ergodic SSPP satisfying ρκ = 1 for any κ > 0. Although this process satisfies (H1), the SSMPP obtained from it via p-thinning and ν-randomization does not and does also not satisfy (H2). However, Theorem 1(ii) is still valid for this SSMPP, as can be checked by restricting the analysis of Sect. 6 to regions which are unions of boxes of the form z + [0, 1)d , z ∈ Zd and using the independence of ξˆ (A) and ξˆ (B) when A, B are disjoint unions of such boxes. Other examples of ergodic SSMPP can be obtained by means of SSPP with short– range correlations (see [DV, Exercise 10.3.4]). Of particular relevance for solid state physics are point processes associated to random or quasiperiodic tilings [BHZ], which satisfy the hypothesis (H1) of Theorem 1. 2.2. The Palm distribution. In what follows, it will always be assumed that Pˆ and P are defined as in Theorem 1 and that (6) is satisfied if ν is a Dirac measure. In order to shorten notations, we will write N and Nˆ for N (Rd ×[−1, 1]) and N (Rd ), respectively. We would like now to “pick up at random” a point among {xj } and take it as the origin. One thus looks at the following borelian subset of N :
N0 := ξ ∈ N : 0 ∈ ξˆ . Since N0 is closed, it defines a bounded complete separable metric space. Note that x ∈ ξˆ if and only if Sx ξ ∈ N0 . The Palm distribution P0 on N0 associated to P is now defined as follows. map G from N into N (Rd × N0 ) given by Consider the measurable ∗ ∗ ξ → ξ = x∈ξˆ δ(x,Sx ξ ) . Let P = G∗ P be the distribution of the marked point prod cess on R × N0 with mark space N0 , namely P ∗ is the image under G of the probability measure P on N . It is easy to show that G ◦Sx = Sx∗ ◦G for x ∈ Rd , where Sx∗ is the action ∗ on Rd × N0 of the translations given by (y, ξ ) → (y + x, ξ ). As a result, P is also stationary. Then, for any fixed A ∈ B(N0 ), the measure µA (B) = P ∗ (dξ ∗ ) ξ ∗ (B ×A) on Rd is translation invariant and thus proportional to the Lebesgue measure. This implies that, for any N > 0 and any A ∈ B(N0 ), 1 ∗ ∗ ∗ CP (A) := P (dξ ) ξ (C1 × A) = d P ∗ (dξ ∗ ) ξ ∗ (CN × A). N N (Rd ×N0 ) N (Rd ×N0 ) The Palm distribution associated to P is the probability measure P0 on N0 obtained from CP by normalization, namely, P0 = ρ −1 CP , where ρ is defined in (1). Thus, for any N > 0, 1 1 P0 (A) := ξˆ (dx) χA (Sx ξ ) , P(dξ ) (11) ρ Nd N CN
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
29
where χA is the characteristic function on the Borel set A ⊂ N0 . One can show [FKAS, Theorem 1.2.8] that for any nonnegative measurable function f on Rd × N0 , 1 dx P0 (dξ ) f (x, ξ ) = P(dξ ) (12) ξˆ (dx) f (x, Sx ξ ) , ρ N Rd N0 Rd which is used in [DV] as the definition of P0 . Similarly, there is a Palm distribution Pˆ 0 on Nˆ 0 := {ξˆ ∈ Nˆ : 0 ∈ ξˆ } associated to the distribution Pˆ of a SSPP on Rd . It is known that the Palm distribution of a stationary PPP on Rd with distribution Pˆ (Example 1 above) is the convolution Pˆ 0 = Pˆ ∗ δδ0 of Pˆ with the Dirac measure at ξˆ = δ0 (i.e. Pˆ 0 is simply obtained by adding a point at the origin). The Palm distribution of a PPP on Rd ×[−1, 1] with intensity measure ρ dx ⊗ν is the convolution P0 = P ∗ζ , where ζ is the distribution of a marked point process obtained by ν–randomization of δδ0 . The Palm distribution associated to the SSPP in Example 2 is Pˆ 0 = δx∈Zd δx . Its ν–randomization is the Palm distribution of the ν–randomization of Example 2. We collect in the lemma below a number of results on the Palm distribution which will be needed in the sequel. Their proofs are given in Appendix B. Lemma 1. (i) Let k : N0 ×N0 → R be a measurable function such that ξˆ (dx) |k(ξ, Sx ξ )| and ξˆ (dx) |k(Sx ξ, ξ )| are in L1 (N0 , P0 ). Then ˆ P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) k(Sx ξ, ξ ) . P0 (dξ ) ξ (dx) k(ξ, Sx ξ ) = (ii) Let ∈ B(N ) be such that Sx = for all x ∈ Rd . Then P() = 1 if and only if P0 (0 ) = 1 with 0 = ∩ N0 . (iii) Let P be ergodic and A, B ∈ B(N0 ) be such that B ⊂ A, P0 (A \ B) = 0 and Sx ξ ∈ A for any ξ ∈ B and any x ∈ ξˆ . Then P0 (A) ∈ {0, 1}. (iv) Let Aj ∈ B(Rd ) for j = 1, . . . , n. Then n n c c n+1 ˆ ˆ ≤ EP ξˆ (A˜ j )n+1 , (13) EP 0 ξ (Aj ) + EP ξ (C1 ) ρ ρ j =1
j =1
where A˜ j := ∪x∈C1 Aj + x and c is a positive constant depending on n. Remark 1. Here we point out a simple geometric property of point measures ξ within the set W := ξ ∈ N0 : Sx ξ = ξ ∀x ∈ Rd \ {0} , (14) which will be fundamental in order to apply the methods developed in [KV] and [DFGW]. Let us consider a sequence {xn }n≥0 of elements in supp(ξˆ ) with x0 = 0 and set ξn := Sxn ξ . The ξn can be thought of as the environment viewed from the point xn . Due to the definition of W, {xn }n≥0 can be recovered from {ξn }n∈N by means of the identities xn+1 − xn = (ξn , ξn+1 ), where the function : W × N0 →
n ∈ N,
Rd
is defined as x if ξ
= Sx ξ , (ξ , ξ
) := 0 otherwise .
Note that, by Lemma 1(ii), condition (6) is equivalent to P0 (W) = 1.
(15)
30
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
3. Variational Formula The main object of this section is to show the following result, implying Theorem 1(i). Theorem 2. Let P satisfy the assumptions of Theorem 1(i). Then the limit (3) exists and D is given by the variational formula 2 P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx)c0,x (ξ ) a · x +∇x f (ξ ) , a ∈ Rd ,(16) (a · D a) = inf f ∈L∞ (N0 ,P0 )
with ∇x f (ξ ) := f (Sx ξ ) − f (ξ ) . ξ
(17) ξ
Moreover, the rescaled process Y ξ,ε := (εXtε−2 )t≥0 defined on (ξ , P0 ) converges weakly in P0 –probability as ε → 0 to a Brownian motion W D with covariance matrix D. The proof is based on the theory of Ref. [KV] and [DFGW] and, in particular, Theorem 2.2 of [DFGW]. Because of the geometric disorder and the possibility of jumps between any of the random points, the application of this general theorem to our model is technically considerably more involved than in the case of the lattice model with jumps to nearest neighbors studied in [DFGW, Sect. 4]. As a preamble, let us state a result on ξ the process Xt proven in Appendix C which will be used several times below. Proposition 1. Let P satisfy ρκ < ∞ for some integer κ > 3. Then, given t > 0 and 0 < γ < κ − 3, ξ EP0 EPξ |Xt |γ < ∞ . 0
Remark 2. From the variational formula of the diffusion matrix D given in Theorem 2 one can easily prove (see e.g. [DFGW]) that D is a multiple of the identity whenever P is isotropic (i.e., it is invariant under all rotations by π/2 in a coordinate plane). In this case, the arguments leading to a lower bound on D are slightly simpler (and can be easily adapted to the general case). Therefore, in order to simplify the discussion and without loss of generality, in the last Sects. 5 and 6 we will assume P to be isotropic. 3.1. The result of De Masi, Ferrari, Goldstein and Wick. A main idea in [DFGW] is to study the process (SXξ ξ )t≥0 with values in the space N0 of the environment cont
ξ
figurations, instead of the random walk (Xt )t≥0 . This process is called the process ξ environment viewed from the particle. It is defined on the probability space (ξ , P0 ), with ξ = D([0, ∞), supp(ξˆ )). Let Pξ be its distribution on the path space := D([0, ∞), N0 ) (endowed as usual with the Skorohod topology). A generic element of will be denoted by ξ = (ξt )t≥0 . Let us set P := P0 (dξ )Pξ . The environment process is the process (ξt )t≥0 defined on the probability space (, P) with distribution P. This is a continuous–time jump Markov process with initial measure P0 and transition probabilities P(ξs+t = ξ | ξs = ξ ) = Pξ (ξt = ξ ) =: pt (ξ |ξ )
∀ s, t ≥ 0
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
with, for any ξ ∈ W,
pt (ξ |ξ ) =
if ξ = Sx ξ for some x ∈ ξˆ , otherwise .
ξ
pt (x|0) 0
31
(18)
For any time t ≥ 0, let us introduce the random variable Xt : → Rd defined by Xt (ξ ) := s (ξ ) , (19) s∈[0,t]
where
s (ξ ) :=
x 0
if ξs = Sx ξs − otherwise
and the sum runs over all jump times s for which s (ξ ) = 0. Note that {X[s,t] := Xt − Xs : t > s ≥ 0} defines an antisymmetric additive covariant family of random variables as defined in [DFGW], and Xt has paths in D([0, ∞), Rd ). The crucial link to the dynamics of a particle in a fixed environment is now the following: due to Remark 1, for any ξ ∈ W, the distribution of the process (Xt )t≥0 defined on (, Pξ ) is equal to ξ the distribution P0 of the randomwalk on supp(ξˆ ) (naturally embedded in Rd ) starting at the origin. Recalling that P = P0 (dξ ) Pξ , this implies ξ EP0 EPξ (Xt · a)2 = EP (Xt · a)2 , (20) 0
which gives a way to calculate the diffusion matrix D from the distribution P on . In order to apply Theorem 2.2 of [DFGW], it is enough to verify the following hypothesis: (a) the environment process is reversible and ergodic; (b) the random variables X[s,t] , 0 ≤ s < t are in L1 (, P); (c) the mean forward velocity exists: ϕ(ξ ) := L2 −lim t↓0
(d) the martingale Xt −
t 0
1 EPξ (Xt ) . t
(21)
ds ϕ(ξs ) is in L2 (, P).
Let us assume ρ12 < ∞. Then, statement (a) will be proved in Proposition 2, Subsect. 3.3. The statement (b) follows from Proposition 1. The L2 -convergence in (c) will be proved in Subsect. 3.4 (Proposition 4), where we also show the L2 -convergence in the following formula defining the mean square displacement matrix ψ(ξ ): 1 (a · ψ(ξ )a) := L2 −lim EPξ (a · Xt )2 . (22) t↓0 t The last point (d) is a consequence of Proposition 1 assuring that Xt ∈ L2 (, P) and t the fact that 0 ds ϕ(ξs ) ∈ L2 (N0 , P0 ), which can be proved by means of the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality, the stationarity of P following from (a), and the property ϕ ∈ L2 (N , P0 ).
32
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
Once hypotheses (a)-(d) have been verified, one can invoke [DFGW, Theorem 2.2 and Remark 4, p. 802] to conclude that limit (3) exists and that the rescaled random walk Y ξ,ε converges weakly in P0 –probability to the Brownian motion W D with covariance matrix D given by (3), and that D is moreover given by ∞ dt ϕ · a , et L ϕ · a , (23) (a · Da) = EP0 (a · ψa) − 2 P0
0
where L is the generator of the environment process and the integral on the r.h.s. is finite. Formula (16) can be deduced from the expressions of L, ϕ and ψ established in the following subsections (Propositions 3 and 4) by using a known general result on self-adjoint operators stated in (47) below. 3.2. Preliminaries. Before starting to prove the above-mentioned statements (a)-(d), let us fix some notations and recall some general facts about jump Markov processes. In what follows, given a complete separable metric space Z we denote by F(Z) the family of bounded Borel functions on Z and, given a (not necessarily finite) interval I ⊂ R, we denote by D(I, Z) the space of right continuous paths z = (zt )t∈I , zt ∈ Z, having left limits. The path space D(I, Z) is endowed with the Skorohod topology [Bil] which is the natural choice for the study of jump Markov processes. For a time s ≥ 0, the time translation τs is defined as τs : D([0, ∞), Z) → D([0, ∞), Z),
(τs z)t := zt+s .
Moreover, given 0 ≤ a < b, we denote by R[a,b] the function R[a,b] : D([0, ∞), Z) → D([a, b], Z),
(R[a,b] z)t := lim za+b−t−δ . δ↓0
R[a,b] z is the time–reflection of (zt )t∈[a,b] w.r.t. the middle point of [a, b], and it can naturally be extended to paths on [0, a + b]. A continuous–time Markov process with path in D([0, ∞), Z) and distribution p is called stationary if Ep (F ) = Ep (F ◦τs ) for all s ≥ 0 and for any bounded Borel function F on D([0, ∞), Z). It is called reversible if Ep (F ) = Ep (F ◦ R[a,b] ) for all b > a ≥ 0 and any bounded Borel function F on D([0, ∞), Z) such that F (z) depends only on (zt )t∈[a,b] . Thanks to the Markov property, one can show that stationarity is equivalent to Ep f (z0 ) = Ep f (zs ) , ∀ s ≥ 0 , ∀ f ∈ F(Z), (24) while reversibility is equivalent to Ep f (z0 )g(zs ) = Ep g(z0 )f (zs ) ,
∀ s ≥ 0 , ∀ f, g ∈ F(Z) .
(25)
In particular, stationarity follows from reversibility. process is called Finally, the Markov (time) ergodic if p(A) ∈ {0, 1} whenever A ∈ B D([0, ∞), Z) is time-shift invariant, i.e. A = τs A for all s ≥ 0. Recall that if the Markov process is stationary then it can be extended to a Markov process with path space D(R, Z) and the resulting distribution is univocally determined (this follows from Kolmogorov’s extension theorem and the regularity of paths). Now stationarity, reversibility and ergodicity of the extended process are defined as above by means of τs , s ∈ R, and R[a,b] , −∞ < a < b < ∞. Then one can check that these properties are preserved by extension (for what concerns ergodicity,
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
33
see in particular [Ros, Chapter 15, p. 96–97]). Therefore our definitions coincide with those in [DFGW]. All the above definitions and remarks can be extended in a natural way to discrete–time Markov processes (with path space Z N ). Moreover, in the discrete case, stationarity and reversibility are equivalent respectively to (24) and (25) with s = 1. We conclude this section recalling the standard construction of the continuous–time random walk satisfying conditions (C1) and (C2) in the Introduction. We first note that these conditions are meaningful for P0 –almost all ξ if EP0 (λ0 ) < ∞. In fact, due to the bound λx (ξ ) ≤ e4β e|x| λ0 (ξ ), one can infer from EP0 (λ0 ) < ∞ that λx (ξ ) < ∞ for any x ∈ ξˆ , P0 a.s. We note that the condition EP0 (λ0 ) < ∞ is equivalent to ρ2 < ∞ due to the following lemma: Lemma 2. For any positive integer k, EP0 (λk0 ) < ∞ if and only if ρ k+1 < ∞. Proof. Note that for suitable positive constants c1 , c2 one has ξˆ (C1 + z)e−|z| ≤ λ0 (ξ ) ≤ c2 ξˆ (C1 + z)e−|z| , c1 z∈Zd
P0 -a.s.
z∈Zd
Next let us expand the k th power of these inequalities. By applying Lemma 1(iv) and using the stationarity of P, one gets that EP0 (λk0 ) < ∞ if ρ k+1 < ∞. Suppose now that EP0 (λk0 ) < ∞. Then the above expansion in k th power implies that EP0 (ξˆ (C1 )k ) < ∞. Since due to (11), 2d 2d k ˆ P(dξ ) ξˆ (dx) ξˆ (C1 + x)k ≥ EP (ξˆ (C1/2 )k+1 ) , EP0 (ξ (C1 ) ) = ρ N ρ C1/2 one concludes that EP (ξˆ (C1/2 )k+1 ) < ∞, which is equivalent to ρk+1 < ∞.
The construction of the continuous–time random walk follows standard references (e.g. [Bre, Chap. 15] and [Kal, Chap. 12]) and can be described roughly as follows: After arriving at site y ∈ ξˆ , the particle waits an exponential time with parameter λy (ξ ) and then jumps to another site z ∈ ξˆ with probability pξ (z|y) :=
cy,z (ξ ) . λy (ξ )
(26)
More precisely, consider ξ ∈ N0 such that 0 < λz (ξ ) < ∞ for any z ∈ ξˆ and set ξ ˜ ξ is denoted by X˜ nξ ˜ ξ := supp(ξˆ ) N . A generic path in . Given x ∈ ξˆ , let P˜ x n≥0 ˜ ξ of a discrete–time random walk on supp(ξˆ ) starting in x and be the distribution on having transition probabilities p ξ (z|y). Let , Q be another probability space where ξ the random variables Tn,z , z ∈ ξˆ , n ∈ N, are independent and exponentially distributed ξ with parameter λz (ξ ), namely Q Tz,n > t ) = exp −λz (ξ )t . On the probability space ˜ ξ × , P˜ xξ ⊗ Q) define the following functions: ( ξ
ξ
ξ ξ 0,X˜ 0
R0 := 0 ; Rn := T ξ
+T
ξ ξ 1,X˜ 1
+ ··· + T ξ
ξ ξ n−1,X˜ n−1 ξ
n∗ (t) := n if Rn ≤ t < Rn+1 .
if
n≥1,
34
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner ξ
ξ
Note that n∗ (t) is well posed for any t ≥ 0 only if limn↑∞ Rn = ∞. If P˜ xξ ⊗ Q lim Rnξ = ∞ = 1 , n↑∞
(27)
ξ ξ )t≥0 , defined P˜ x ⊗Q–almost ξ n∗ (t)
then, due to [Bre, Theorem 15.37], the random walk ( X˜
everywhere, is a jump Markov process whose distribution satisfies the infinitesimal conξ ditions (C1) and (C2). The condition limn↑∞ Rn = ∞ assures that no explosion phenomenon takes place, notably only finitely many jumps can occur in finite time intervals. In Appendix A we prove that (27) is verified if ρ2 < ∞. 3.3. The environment viewed from the particle. The process environment viewed from the particle and the environment process have been introduced in Sect. 3.1. Given t > 0, we write n∗ (t) for the function on the path space = D ([0, ∞), N0 ) associating to each ξ ∈ the corresponding number of jumps in the time interval [0, t]. Motivated by further applications, it is convenient to consider also the discrete–time versions of the above processes. Consider the discrete-time Markov process SX˜ ξ ξ n≥0 defined on n ˜ := N N and denote a generic path ˜ ξ , P˜ ξ , call P˜ ξ its distribution on the path space 0 0 ˜ by (ξn )n≥0 . Such a Markov process can be thought of as the environment viewed in ξ from the particle performing the discrete–time random walk with distribution P˜ 0 . Let us point out a few properties of the distribution P˜ ξ . First, we remark that due to the covariant relations cz,y (Sx ξ ) = cz+x,y+x (ξ ) , λy (Sx ξ ) = λy+x (ξ ), (28) ˜ ξ , P˜ ξ ) and the process (λ0 (ξn ))n∈N defined on the process λX˜ ξ (ξ ) n∈N defined on ( 0 n ˜ P˜ ξ ) have the same distribution. Moreover, due to Remark 1, if ξ ∈ W, then the (, ˜ P˜ ξ ) by ζ0 = 0 and process (ζn )n∈N defined on (, ζn =
n−1
(ξk , ξk+1 ) , ∀ n ≥ 1 ,
k=0
˜ ξ with distribution P˜ ξ . Finally, it is conwhere (ξ, ξ ) is given by (15), has paths in 0 venient to consider a suitable average of the distributions P˜ ξ . To this aim, let Q0 be the probability measure on N0 defined as Q0 (dξ ) :=
λ0 (ξ ) P0 (dξ ) , EP0 (λ0 )
Q0 (dξ )P˜ ξ . If ξ ∈ W, the transition probabilities are λ−1 if ξ = Sx ξ ,
0 (ξ )c0,x (ξ ) p(ξ |ξ ) := P˜ ξn+1 = ξ |ξn = ξ = 0 otherwise .
and set P˜ :=
Note that, due to (28) and the symmetry of the jump rates (2), λ0 (ξ )p(ξ |ξ ) = λ0 (ξ )p(ξ |ξ ).
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
35
Proposition 2. Let ρ2 < ∞. Then the process (ξt )t≥0 defined on (, P) is reversible, i.e. EP f (ξ0 )g(ξt ) = EP g(ξ0 )f (ξt )
∀ f, g ∈ F(N0 ) , ∀ t > 0 ,
(29)
and is (time) ergodic if P is ergodic. Similarly, the discrete-time Markov process (ξn )n≥0 ˜ is reversible and is (time) ergodic. ˜ P) defined on (, Having at our disposal Lemma 1, the proof follows modifying arguments of e.g. [DFGW]. Proof. We give the proof for the continuous–time process, the discrete–time case being similar. We first verify the symmetric property pt (ξ |ξ ) = pt (ξ |ξ ). Actually, thanks to the construction of the dynamics given in Sect. 3.2, one can show that for any positive integer n and any ξ = ξ (0) , ξ (1) , . . . , ξ (n−1) , ξ (n) = ξ ∈ N0 , Pξ n∗ (t) = n, ξR1 =ξ (1) , . . . , ξRn =ξ (n) =Pξ n∗ (t) = n, ξR1 = ξ (n−1) , . . . , ξRn =ξ (0) , where, given ξ ∈ , R1 (ξ ) < R2 (ξ ) < . . . denote the jump times of the path ξ . Next, given f, g ∈ F(N0 ) one gets by applying Lemma 1(i) and using pt (ξ |ξ ) = pt (ξ |ξ ) that P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) pt (Sx ξ |ξ ) f (ξ )g(Sx ξ ) = P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) pt (Sx ξ |ξ ) f (Sx ξ )g(ξ ), (30) which is equivalent to (29). Hence P is reversible. Due to Corollary 5 in [Ros, Chap. IV], in order to prove ergodicity it is enough to show that P0 (A) ∈ {0, 1} if A ∈ B(N0 ) has the following property: Pξ (ξt ∈ A) = χA (ξ ) for P0 –almost all ξ . Given such a set A, then there exists a Borel subset B ⊂ A such that P0 (A \ B) = 0 and Pξ (ξt ∈ A) = 1 for any ξ ∈ B. Fix ξ ∈ B and x ∈ ξˆ , then Pξ (ξt = Sx ξ, ξt ∈ A) = Pξ (ξt = Sx ξ ) > 0 (the last bound follows from the positivity of the jump rates). Hence Sx ξ ∈ A. Lemma 1(iii) implies that P0 (A) ∈ {0, 1}, thus allowing to conclude the proof. Let P fulfill the assumption of Proposition 2. Then,
(Tt f )(ξ ) := EPξ f (ξt ) =
ξˆ (dx) pt (Sx ξ |ξ ) f (Sx ξ ) ,
P0 a.s.
(31)
defines a strongly continuous contraction semigroup on L2 (N0 , P0 ) (Markov semigroup). Actually, (i) Tt : L2 (N0 , P0 ) → L2 (N0 , P0 ) is self-adjoint by (29) and is a contraction by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and the stationarity of P; (ii) Tt+s = Tt Ts follows from the Markov nature of the process; (iii) the continuity follows from the following argument: first observe that it is enough to prove the continuity of Tt f at t = 0 for f ∈ L∞ (N0 , P0 ), which is obtained from the dominated convergence theorem and ξ the estimate |(Tt f − f )(ξ )| ≤ 2f ∞ (1 − pt (0|0)). Let us denote by L the generator of the Markov semigroup (Tt )t≥0 and by D(L) ⊂ L2 (N0 , P0 ) its domain.
36
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
Proposition 3. Let P satisfy ρ4 < ∞. Then L is nonpositive and self–adjoint with core L∞ (N0 , P0 ). For any f ∈ L∞ (N0 , P0 ), one has for P0 -a.e. ξ , (32) (Lf )(ξ ) = ξˆ (dx) c0,x (ξ ) ∇x f (ξ ) , where ∇x f is defined in (17), and, moreover, 1 P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) c0,x (ξ ) (∇x f (ξ ))2 . f, (−L)f P0 = 2
(33)
Proof. The self-adjointness of L follows from [RS, Vol.2, Theorem X.1]. Actually, (i) L is closed as a generator of a strongly continuous semigroup [RS, Vol.2, Chap. X.8]; (ii) L is symmetric because Tt is self-adjoint; (iii) the spectrum of L is included in (−∞, 0] by contractivity of the semigroup. Note that (iii) also implies that L is non-positive. We use the abbreviation Lp for Lp = Lp (N0 , P0 ), p = 2 or ∞. For any f ∈ L∞ , denote by f the function defined by the r.h.s. of (32). Due to Lemma 2, EP0 (λ20 ) < ∞ and in particular 2 P0 (dξ )(f )(ξ ) ≤ 4 f 2∞ EP0 λ20 < ∞ , thus implying that : L∞ → L2 is a well-defined operator. We claim that L2 − lim t↓0
Tt f − f = f , t
∀ f ∈ L∞ .
(34)
Note that (34) implies that L∞ ⊂ D(L) and Lf = f for all f ∈ L∞ . Since moreover Tt is a contraction and Tt L∞ ⊂ L∞ , it then follows from [RS, Vol.2, Theorem X.49] that L∞ is a core for L and L is the closure of . Finally, using (30) in the limit t → 0, by straightforward computations (33) can be derived from (32). Let us now prove (34). We assume ξ ∈ W and we set, for ξ = ξ , pt,1 (ξ |ξ ) := Pξ (ξt = ξ , n∗ (t) = 1) = pt (ξ |ξ ) − Pξ (ξt = ξ , n∗ (t) ≥ 2) . Thanks to the construction of the dynamics described in Sect. 3.2 and due to the estimate 1 − e−u ≤ u, u ≥ 0, one has for any x ∈ ξˆ and x = 0, ξ ξ ξ pt,1 (Sx ξ |ξ ) ≤ P˜ 0 ⊗ Q(X˜ 1 = x, T0,0 ≤ t) = pξ (x|0)(1 − e−λ0 (ξ )t ) ≤ c0,x (ξ ) t .(35) Let f ∈ L∞ . In view also of (31) and ξˆ (dx) pt (Sx ξ |ξ ) = 1, ˆ Tt f − f − t f (ξ ) = ξ (dx) f (Sx ξ ) − f (ξ ) pt (Sx ξ |ξ ) − c0,x (ξ ) t ≤ 2 f ∞ ξˆ (dx) pt (Sx ξ |ξ ) − pt,1 (Sx ξ |ξ ) {x=0} + ξˆ (dx) −pt,1 (Sx ξ |ξ ) + c0,x (ξ ) t . {x=0}
The first integral in the second line can be bounded by Pξ (n∗ (t) ≥ 2). The second integral equals − Pξ ( n∗ (t) = 1 ) + λ0 (ξ ) t = −1 + e−λ0 (ξ )t + λ0 (ξ ) t + Pξ (n∗ (t) ≥ 2) .
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
37
By collecting the above estimates, we get 2 32 f 2∞ 1 2 P T ≤ E f − f − tf E (n (t) ≥ 2) t ∗ P P ξ 0 0 t2 t2 2 2 8f ∞ −λ0 t + E + λ t −1 + e . (36) 0 P 0 t2 By using the estimate (e−u − 1 + u)2 ≤ u3 /2 for u ≥ 0 and the finiteness of EP0 (λ30 ), it is easy to check that the second term in the r.h.s. tends to zero as t → 0. In order to bound the first term, we observe that ξ ξ ξ Pξ n∗ (t) ≥ 2 ≤ P˜ 0 ⊗ Q(T0,0 ≤ t, T ˜ ξ ≤ t) 1,X1 −λ0 (ξ )t = 1−e ξˆ (dx) p(Sx ξ |ξ ) 1 − e−λ0 (Sx ξ )t . Due to the estimate 1 − e−u ≤ u, this implies the bound 2 Pξ (n∗ (t) ≥ 2) ≤ t λ0 (ξ ) ξˆ (dx) p(Sx ξ |ξ )λ0 (Sx ξ ) = t 2 λ0 (ξ ) EP˜ ξ λ0 (ξ1 ) (. 37) Due also to the estimate 1 − e−u ≤ 1, it is also true that Pξ (n∗ (t) ≥ 2) ≤ t EP˜ ξ λ0 (ξ1 ) .
(38)
˜ one obtains By multiplying the last two inequalities, and using the stationarity of P, 2 1 EP0 Pξ2 (n∗ (t) ≥ 2) ≤ t EP0 λ0 (ξ ) EP˜ ξ λ0 (ξ1 ) 2 t ≤ t EP0 λ0 (ξ )EP˜ ξ λ20 (ξ1 ) = t EP0 λ30 , thus implying that the first term on the r.h.s. of (36) goes to 0 as t → 0.
3.4. Mean forward velocity and infinitesimal square displacement. Proposition 4. Let P satisfy ρ12 < ∞ and let ϕ be the Rd -valued function on N0 and ψ be the function on N0 with values in the real symmetric d × d matrices, respectively defined by ˆ ϕ(ξ ) = ξ (dx) c0,x (ξ ) x , (a · ψ(ξ )a) = ξˆ (dx) c0,x (ξ ) (a · x)2 . (39) (i) ϕ(ξ ) is in L2 (N0 , P0 ) and is equal to the mean forward velocity given by the convergent L2 -strong limit (21). (ii) (a · ψ(ξ )a) is in L2 (N0 , P0 ) and is equal to the infinitesimal mean square displacement given by the convergent L2 -strong limit (22). We point out that ϕ(ξ ) and ψ(ξ ) are well defined for P0 almost all ξ since ρ2 < ∞ (see for example the proof of Lemma 2).
38
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
Proof. (i) One has 2 2 1 2 P P0 (dξ ) EPξ Xt χ n∗ (t) = 1 − t ϕ(ξ ) (dξ ) E (X ) − t ϕ(ξ ) ≤ 0 Pξ t 2 2 t t 2 2 + 2 P0 (dξ ) EPξ Xt χ n∗ (t) ≥ 2 . (40) t We first show that the first term on the r.h.s. vanishes as t → 0. Using the same notation as in the proof of Proposition 3 and invoking (35), 2 EP0 EPξ Xt χ n∗ (t) = 1 −t ϕ(ξ ) 2 ˆ ξ (dx) pt,1 (Sx ξ |ξ )−t c0,x (ξ ) x = EP0 {x=0}
is bounded according to the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality by EP0 ξˆ (dx) −pt,1 (Sx ξ |ξ ) + t c0,x (ξ ) {x=0}
{y=0}
ξˆ (dy) −pt,1 (Sy ξ |ξ ) + t c0,y (ξ ) |y|2 .
(41)
Let us denote by I1 (ξ ) and I2 (ξ ) the (non negative) integrals over ξˆ (dx) and ξˆ (dy) respectively. Using the identities of the proof of Proposition 3, the inequality 0 ≤ −1 + e−u + u ≤ u2 , u ≥ 0, and (37), we deduce I1 (ξ ) = −1 + e−tλ0 (ξ ) + tλ0 (ξ ) + Pξ (n∗ (t) ≥ 2) ≤ t 2 λ0 (ξ )2 + t 2 λ0 (ξ ) EP˜ ξ (λ0 (ξ1 )). Moreover, I2 (ξ ) ≤ t ξˆ (dy)c0,y (ξ )|y|2 . Hence (41) is bounded by t 3 EP0 λ20 (ξ ) ξˆ (dy) c0,y (ξ )|y|2 +EP0 λ0 (ξ )EP˜ ξ (λ0 (ξ1 )) ξˆ (dy) c0,y (ξ )|y|2 . As long as ρ4 < ∞, the first expression can be bounded by applying Lemma 1(iv) (see the argument leading to Lemma 2). A short calculation shows that the second expression equals P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) c0,x (ξ ) ξˆ (dz) cx,z (ξ ) ξˆ (dy) c0,y (ξ ) |y|2 and is therefore bounded if ρ4 < ∞ (again by means of Lemma 1(iv)). Resuming the results obtained so far, one gets 1 EP Xt χ n∗ (t) = 1 − t ϕ(ξ )2 = O(t) . P (dξ ) (42) 0 ξ t2 We now turn to the second term in (40). By Proposition 1, EP0 (EPξ (|Xt |γ )) < ∞ as long as 0 < γ < κ − 3 whenever ρκ < ∞ for κ integer. By applying twice the H¨older inequality, if γ > 2, γ γ2 2 2γ −2 1− γ2 EP0 EPξ Xt χ n∗ (t) ≥ 2 ≤ EP0 EPξ Xt EP0 Pξ n∗ (t) ≥ 2 γ −2 .
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
39
Let us take (38) to the power γ /(γ − 2), multiply the result by (37). This yields 2γ −2 3γ −4 3γ −4 3γ −4 2γ −2 γ −2 γ −2 . EP0 Pξ n∗ (t) ≥ 2 γ −2 ≤ t γ −2 EP0 λ0 (ξ ) EP˜ λ0 (ξ1 ) = t γ −2 EP0 λ0 ξ
Hence, by Lemma 2, if ρκ < ∞ is satisfied for integer κ > (4γ − 6)/(γ − 2) and γ < k − 3, there is a finite constant C > 0 such that 3γ −4 2 (43) EP0 EPξ Xt χ n∗ (t) ≥ 2 ≤ C t γ . One concludes the proof by choosing γ > 4 and by combining (40), (42) and (43), as long as κ > 7. (ii) One follows the same strategy. The first term in the equation corresponding to (40) can be dealt with in exactly the same way. In the argument for the second term, |Xt | is replaced by |Xt |2 so that one needs 2γ < κ − 3, hence κ > 11. 3.5. Proof of Theorem 2. Since all conditions (a)-(d) of Subsect. 3.1 have been checked in the preceding subsections, as already pointed out, one can invoke [DFGW, Theorem 2.2] to conclude that the limit (3) exists and that the rescaled random walk Y ξ,ε converges weakly in P0 –probability to the Brownian motion W D . We can now also derive the variational formula (16) from the general expression (23). Let us first quote some general results concerning self–adjoint operators. Let (, µ) be a probability space and denote by . , . µ and by .µ the scalar product and the norm on H = L2 (, µ). Let L : D(L) → H be a nonpositive self–adjoint operator with (dense) domain D(L) ⊂ H and assume C ⊂ D(L) is a core of L. The space of D(|L|1/2 ) ∩ (Ker(L))⊥ H1 is the completion 1/2 1/2 under the norm f 1 := |L| f µ for f ∈ D(|L| ), while the dual H−1 of H1 −1/2 ) = Ran(|L|1/2 ) under . , . µ can be identified with the completion −1/2 of D(|L| ϕ µ for ϕ ∈ D(|L|−1/2 ). Given under the .−1 -norm defined as ϕ−1 := |L| ϕ ∈ H ∩ H−1 , the dual norm ϕ−1 admits several useful characterizations: ϕ2−1 =
|ϕ, f µ |2 = f 21 f ∈H1 ∩H sup
sup f ∈C ∩(Ker(L))⊥
|ϕ, f µ |2 , f 21
(44)
where the last identity results from the fact that C is a core for L. Moreover, the identity ϕ2−1 = sup 2 ϕ, f µ − f, (−L)f µ (45) f ∈C
is obtained by using the nonlinearity in f of the expression in the r.h.s. of (45) and observing that ϕ ∈ (Ker(L))⊥ . Finally, it follows from spectral calculus that ∞ dt ϕ, et L ϕµ . (46) ϕ2−1 = 0
In what follows, we extend the definition of · −1 to the whole space H by setting ϕ−1 := ∞ whenever ϕ ∈ H and ϕ ∈ H−1 . Thanks to this choice, identities (44), (45) and (46) are true for all ϕ ∈ H. Invoking (45) and (46), one obtains ∞ dt ϕ · a , et L ϕ · a = sup 2 ϕ · a , f P0 − f, (−L)f P0 . 0
P0
f ∈L∞ (N0 ,P0 )
(47) Using (33), (39) and Lemma 1(i), a short calculation starting from (23) yields (16).
40
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
4. Bound by Cut-off on the Transition Rates This section and the next ones are devoted to the proof of Theorem 1(ii). In particular, ˆ P and ν satisfy the conditions of Theorem 1(ii) although many partial we assume that P, results are true under much weaker conditions. The variational formula (16) is particularly suited in order to derive bounds on the diffusion matrix D. For example, due to the monotonicity of the jump rates cx,y (ξ ) in the inverse temperature β, one deduces that the diffusion matrix is a non-increasing function of β. The aim of this section is to obtain more quantitative bounds. Given an energy 0 ≤ Ec ≤ 1, we define the map c : N → Nˆ := N (Rd ) as follows: c (ξ ) (A) := ξ(A × [−Ec , Ec ]) , A ∈ B(Rd ) . (48) d Note that Pˆ c := P ◦ −1 c is the distribution of a point process on R with finite intensity ˆ ˆ ρc := EPˆ c ( ξ (C1 ) ) ≤ EP ( ξ (C1 ) ) = ρ, and in general
EPˆ c ( ξˆ (C1 )κ ) ≤ ρκ ,
∀ κ > 0.
(49)
In what follows, we assume that ρc > 0. It can readily be checked that Pˆ c is an ergodic SSPP on Rd . We write Pˆ 0c for the Palm distribution associated to Pˆ c . Note that the distribution Pˆ c is obtained from Pˆ by δc –thinning with δc := ν([−Ec , Ec ]). Thus, ρc = δc ρ. The relation between the Palm distributions P0 and Pˆ 0c is described in the following lemma. Lemma 3. For any Borel set A ∈ B(Nˆ 0 ) one has Pˆ 0c (A) = ρ ρc−1 P0 ( |E0 | ≤ Ec , c (ξ ) ∈ A ). Proof. The assertion is proven by comparing the two following identities obtained from (11): 1 c c ˆ ˆ ˆ P0 (A) = P (d ξ ) ξˆ (dx)χA (Sx ξˆ ) , ρc Nˆ C1 1 P0 ( |E0 | ≤ Ec , c (ξ ) ∈ A ) = P(dξ ) ξˆ (dx) χ (|Ex | ≤ Ec ) χA (c (Sx ξ )) ρ N C1 1 = P(dξ ) c (ξ ) (dx) χA Sx (c (ξ )) . ρ N C1 Proposition 5. Fix a distance rc > 0 and an energy 0 ≤ Ec ≤ 1 and let Pˆ 0c be as above. Moreover, define ϕc (ξˆ ) := ξˆ (dx) cˆ0,x x , (a · ψc (ξˆ )a) := ξˆ (dx) cˆ0,x (a · x)2 (50) as functions on Nˆ 0 , where cˆ0,x := χ (|x| ≤ rc ). Then the diffusion matrix D for the ξ process (Xt )t≥0 in Theorem 2 admits the following lower bound D ≥
ρc −rc −4 β Ec e Dc (rc , Ec ) , ρ
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
41
where
(a · Dc (rc , Ec ) a) := EPˆ c (a · ψc a) 0
∞
− 2
dt ϕc · a , et Lc ϕc · a ˆ c , (51) P0
0
and Lc is the unique self–adjoint operator on L2 (Nˆ 0 , Pˆ 0c ) such that (Lc f )(ξˆ ) =
ξˆ (dx) cˆ0,x ∇x f (ξˆ ) ,
∀ f ∈ L∞ (Nˆ 0 , Pˆ 0c ) .
(52)
One can prove by the same arguments used in the proof of Proposition 3 that Lc is well-defined and self–adjoint. Let Pˆ c and Pˆ cˆ be the probability measures on the path ξ
ˆ := D( [0, ∞), Nˆ 0 ) associated to the Markov process with generator Lc and space initial distribution Pˆ 0c and δξˆ , respectively, with ξˆ ∈ Nˆ 0 . One can prove that these Markov processes are well–defined (in particular, Pˆ c is well–defined for Pˆ c –almost all ξˆ ) ξˆ
0
and exhibit a realization as jump processes by means of the same arguments used in Sect. 3.2 (note that, for a suitable positive constant c, ξˆ (dx)cˆ0,x ≤ c λ0 (ξ ) for any ξ ∈ N0 , thus allowing to exclude explosion phenomena from the results of Appendix A). Finally, ˆ Xt (ξˆ ) is defined as in (19). given ξˆ ∈ , Proof. Note that c0,x (ξ ) ≥ e−rc −4 β Ec c˜0,x (ξ ) , where c˜x,y (ξ ) := χ |Ex | ≤ Ec , |Ey | ≤ Ec , |x − y| ≤ rc )
,
x, y ∈ ξˆ .
Then (16) implies that (a · Da) ≥ e−rc −4 β Ec g(a), where 2 g(a) := inf P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) c˜0,x (ξ ) a · x + ∇x f (ξ ) ≥0. f ∈L∞ (N0 ,P0 )
By the same arguments used in the proof of Proposition 3 one can show that there is a unique self–adjoint operator L˜ on L2 (N0 , P0 ) such that ˜ (Lf )(ξ ) := ξˆ (dx) c˜0,x (ξ ) ∇x f (ξ ) , ∀ f ∈ L∞ (N0 , P0 ). Moreover, L∞ (N0 , P0 ) is a core of L˜ and ˜ P = 1 P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx)c˜0,x (ξ ) (∇x f (ξ ))2 , f, (−L)f 0 2 Next let us introduce the functions ϕ(ξ ˜ ) = ξˆ (dx) c˜0,x (ξ ) x ,
˜ )a) = (a · ψ(ξ
∀f ∈ L∞ (N0 , P0 ).(53)
ξˆ (dx) c˜0,x (ξ ) (a · x)2 .
42
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
Then we obtain by means of straightforward computations and the identities (45), (46) and (53) that ˜ P ˜ − 2 supf ∈L∞ (N0 ,P0 ) 2 ϕ˜ · a, f P0 − f, (−L)f g(a) = EP0 (a · ψa) 0 ∞ ˜ ˜ = EP0 (a · ψa) − 2 0 dt ϕ˜ · a , et L ϕ˜ · a . P0
At this point, in order to get (51), it is enough to show that ˜ = δc EPˆ c (a · ψc a) , EP0 (a · ψa) 0
and
˜ ϕ˜ · a , et L ϕ˜ · a
P0
= δc ϕc · a , et Lc ϕc · a ˆ c . P0
This can be derived from Lemma 3 and the following identities, where c is defined by (48): ψ˜ = χ (|E0 | ≤ Ec ) ψc ◦ c , ϕ˜ = χ (|E0 | ≤ Ec ) ϕc ◦ c , ˜ ◦ c ) = χ (|E0 | ≤ Ec ) (Lc f ) ◦ c . L(f 5. Periodic Approximants and Resistor Networks In this section, we compare Dc (rc , Ec ) to the diffusion coefficient of adequately defined periodic approximants, which then in turn can be calculated as the conductance of a random resistor network as in [DFGW]. There have been numerous works on periodic approximants; a recent one containing further references is [Owh]. 5.1. Random walk on a periodized medium. Let us choose a given direction in Rd , say, the direction parallel to the axis of the first coordinate. Given a fixed configuration ξˆ ∈ Nˆ and N > rc , we define the following subsets of Rd ξˆ
QN : = supp(ξˆ ) ∩ Cˇ 2N , ξˆ
ξˆ
+ − V N : = QN ∪ N ∪ N ,
± N := Zd ∩ {x : x (1) = ±N, |x (j ) | < N for j = 2, . . . , d}, ξˆ ±
BN
ξˆ
± := QN ∩ BN ,
− + := {x ∈ Cˇ 2N : x (1) ∈ (−N, −N + rc ]} and BN := where Cˇ 2N := (−N, N )d , BN (1) ˇ {x ∈ C2N : x ∈ [N − rc , N )}. ξˆ
ξˆ
ξˆ
ξˆ
Next let us introduce a graph (V N , E N ) with set of vertices V N and set of edges E N . ξˆ
ξˆ
Two vertices x, y ∈ QN are connected by a non-oriented edge {x, y} ∈ E N if and only ξˆ +
ξˆ −
if |x − y| ≤ rc ; moreover, all vertices x ∈ BN (respectively x ∈ BN ) are connected ξˆ
+ − ± to all y ∈ N (respectively y ∈ N ) by an edge {x, y} ∈ E N and the points of N are not connected between themselves.
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment ξˆ
ξˆ
ξˆ
43 ξˆ
We now define another graph (VN , EN ) obtained from (V N , E N ) by identifying the vertices x− = (−N, x (2) , . . . , x (d) ) ξˆ
x+ = (N, x (2) , . . . , x (d) ) .
and
ξˆ
Let us write π : V N → VN for the identification map on the sets of vertices. Hence ξˆ
ξˆ
ξˆ
− + π(N ) = π(N ) and π restricted to QN is the identity map. The set VN = π(V N ) − ) is represents the medium periodized along the first coordinate. A vertex y ∈ π(N ξˆ +
ξˆ −
ξˆ
connected to all vertices x ∈ BN ∪ BN by an edge of EN . ξˆ
ξˆ
Now a continuous–time random walk with state space VN and infinitesimal generator
LN is given by
ξˆ LN f (x) =
ξˆ
c({x, y}) f (y) − f (x) ,
ξˆ
∀ x ∈ VN ,
ξˆ
y∈VN : {x,y}∈EN ξˆ
where the bond-dependent transition rates c({x, y}) are defined for any {x, y} ∈ EN by ξˆ 1 if x, y ∈ QN , (54) c({x, y}) = − − 1− if x ∈ π(N ) or y ∈ π(N ). | | N
ξˆ
ξˆ
ξˆ
Clearly the generator LN is symmetric w.r.t. the uniform distribution mN on VN given by 1 ξˆ mN = ˆ δx . V ξ ξˆ x∈VN
N
ξˆ
ξˆ
Hence the Markov process with generator LN and initial distribution mN is reversible. Note that it is not ergodic, however, if there are more than one cluster (equivalence class of edges). In the latter case, the ergodic measures are the uniform distributions on a given cluster and this is sufficient for the present purposes. ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ We write PN (respectively PN,x ) for the probability on the path space N = D [0, ∞), ξˆ ξˆ VN associated to the random walk with initial distribution mN (respectively δx ) and ξˆ
generator LN .
ξˆ
Let us introduce an antisymmetric function d1 (x, y) on VN such that ξˆ (1) (1) if x, y ∈ QN , y − x ξˆ − d1 (x, y) = y (1) + N if y ∈ QN , y (1) < 0, x ∈ π(N ), (1) ξˆ − if y ∈ QN , y (1) > 0, x ∈ π(N ) . y −N Finally, given t ≥ 0, we define the random variable (1)ξˆ d1 (ωs− , ωs ) , XN,t (ω) = s∈[0,t] : ωs =ωs−
44
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner ξˆ
where (ωs )s≥0 ∈ N . It is the sum of position increments along the first coordinate (1)ξˆ
axis for all jumps occurring in the time interval [0, t]. Clearly, XN,t gives rise to a time-covariant and antisymmetric family so that, as in Sect. 3, [DFGW, Theorem 2.2] can be used in order to deduce the following result. Proposition 6. Given N ∈ N, N > rc , and ξˆ ∈ Nˆ , lim
t↑∞
(1)ξˆ 1 ξˆ E ξˆ (XN,t )2 = DN , P t N ξˆ
where the diffusion coefficient DN is finite and given by ∞ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ dt ϕN , et LN ϕN DN = mN ψN − 2 0
ξˆ
ξˆ
,
ξˆ
mN
(55)
ξˆ
with ψN , ϕN (scalar) functions on VN defined as ξˆ ξˆ c({x, y}) d1 (x, y)2 , ϕN (x)= ψN (x)= ξˆ y : {y,x}∈EN
c({x, y}) d1 (x, y).
(56)
ξˆ y : {y,x}∈EN
5.2. Link to periodized medium. Here we show that the diffusion matrix (51) can be bounded from below in terms of the average of the diffusion coefficient associated to the periodized random media. Our proof follows the arguments of [DFGW, Prop. 4.13], but additional technical problems are related to the randomness of geometry (absence of any lattice structure) and possible (albeit integrable) singularities of the mean forward velocity and infinitesimal mean square displacement. Proposition 7. Suppose that for 1 ≤ p ≤ 8 lim
N↑∞
ρc (C2N ) = 1 ˆξ (C2N ) + a2N
in Lp ( Nˆ , Pˆ c ) ,
(57)
± where ρc := EPˆ c (ξˆ (C1 )) and a2N := |N | = (2N − 1)d−1 . Then, for any t > 0, ˆ ˆ ξ ξ (58) lim EPˆ c mN ψN = EPˆ c ψc(11) , 0 N↑∞ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ lim EPˆ c ϕN , et LN ϕN ξˆ = ϕc(1) , et Lc ϕc(1) ˆ c , (59) (11)
P0
mN
N↑∞
(1)
where ψc and ϕc are the first diagonal matrix element of the matrix ψc and the first component of the vector ϕc introduced in (50), respectively. Since Dc (rc , Ec ) is given by (51) and is a multiple of the identity (cf. Remark 2), the identities (58) and (59) combined with Fatou’s Lemma immediately imply: Corollary 1. Under the same hypothesis as above, Dc (rc , Ec ) ≥
ξˆ lim sup EPˆ c DN N↑∞
where 1d is the d × d identity matrix.
1d ,
(60)
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
45
Before giving the proof, let us comment on its assumptions. In Sect. 6 we will show that condition (57) is always satisfied. Due to (49), ρp < ∞ implies EPˆ c ( ξˆ (C1 )p ) < ∞ for any p > 0. As Pˆ c is ergodic, this implies the following ergodic theorem, an extension of [DV, Theorem 10.2]. We recall that a convex averaging sequence of sets {An } in Rd is a sequence of convex sets such that An ⊂ An+1 and An contains a ball of radius rn with rn → ∞ as n → ∞. Lemma 4. Suppose that ρp < ∞, p ≥ 1. Then, given a convex averaging sequence of Borel sets {An } in Rd , ξˆ (An ) → 1 ρc (An )
in Lp ( Nˆ , Pˆ c ) ,
ξˆ (An ) → 1 ρc (An )
and
Pˆ c -a.s.
We will also need a bound on EPˆ c ((ξˆ (An )/ (An ))p ), uniformly in n, for a sequence of sets that does not satisfy the assumptions of Lemma 4. To this aim we note that, given a Borel set B ⊂ Rd which is a union of k non-overlapping cubes of side 1, one has p ∀ p ≥ 1. (61) EPˆ c ξˆ (B)/k ≤ EPˆ c ξˆ (C1 )p ≤ ρp , This follows from the stationarity of Pˆ c and the convexity of the function f (x) = x p , x ≥ 0. Proof of Proposition 7. Without loss of generality, we assume rc = 1. Note that, since Pˆ is stationary with finite intensity ρ1 , one has P-a.s. ξˆ (∂Ck ) = 0 for all k ∈ N. In what follows we hence may assume ξ to be as such, thus allowing to simplify notation since C2N ∩ supp(ξˆ ) = Cˇ 2N ∩ supp(ξˆ ). A key observation in order to prove (58) and (59) is the following identity, valid for any nonnegative measurable function h defined on Nˆ 0 . It follows easily from (12): EPˆ c ∀ B ∈ B(Rd ). (62) ξˆ (dx)h(Sx ξˆ ) = ρc (B) EPˆ c (h), B
0
From this identity we can deduce for any h ∈ L2 (N0 , Pˆ 0c ) that 1 lim EPˆ c ξˆ (dx)h(Sx ξˆ ) = EPˆ c (h) . (63) 0 N↑∞ ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N C2N −2 In fact, due to (62), it is enough to show that 1 1 ˆ ˆ EPˆ c ξ (dx)h(Sx ξ ) ↓ 0 , as N ↑ ∞. − ξˆ (C2N )+a2N ρc (C2N−2 ) C2N−2 (64) By applying twice the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and by invoking (62), we obtain 2 l.h.s. of (64) ρ (C 2 ξˆ (C 2N−2 ) 2N−2 ) c ≤ EPˆ c −1 ˆξ (C2N ) + a2N ρc2 (C2N−2 )2 2 1 EPˆ c ξˆ (dx)h(Sx ξˆ ) ξˆ (C2N−2 ) C2N −2 ρ (C 2 ξˆ (C c 2N−2 ) 2N−2 ) −1 ≤ EPˆ c EPˆ c (h2 ) . 0 ˆξ (C2N ) + a2N ρc (C2N−2 )
46
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
At this point, (64) follows by applying the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality to the first expectation above and then applying (61) and the limit (57) for p = 4. ξˆ
N,
ξˆ
Let now hN be a function on VN such that for some constant c > 0 independent of ξˆ |hN (x)|
≤ c
ξˆ (B1 (x))
if x ∈ QN ,
|BN |
otherwise ,
ξˆ
ξˆ
a2N
ξˆ
ξˆ −
ξˆ +
ξˆ
where BN = BN ∪ BN and B1 (x) is the closed unit ball centered in x. Note that ψN ξˆ
and ϕN satisfy this inequality. We claim that the mean boundary contribution vanishes in the limit: 1 ξˆ lim EPˆ c for 1 ≤ p ≤ 4. (65) |hN (x)|p = 0 , N↑∞ ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N ξˆ ξˆ x∈VN \QN −1
In fact, the sum in (65) can be bounded by ξˆ
p
c a2N
|BN |p p a2N
+ cp
p
ξˆ (B1 (x))
(66)
.
ξˆ ξˆ x∈QN \QN −1
By the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality EPˆ c
a2N ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N
ξˆ
|BN |p
1
≤ E 2ˆ c
p
P
a2N
2 a2N
(ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N )2
1
E 2ˆ c
ξˆ
|BN |2p
P
2p
.
a2N
The first factor on the r.h.s. is negligible as N ↑ ∞ because of the limit (57) for p = 2, while the second factor is bounded, uniformly in N , because of (61). For the second summand in (66), we use twice the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and invoke (62) to deduce 1 p 1 ξˆ (C2N \ C2N−2 ) EPˆ c ≤ E 2ˆ c ξˆ B1 (x) P (ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N )2 ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N ξˆ ξˆ x∈QN \QN −1 1
×E 2ˆ c P
1 ξˆ (C2N \ C2N−2 )
p 2 ξˆ B1 (x)
ξˆ
ξˆ
x∈QN \QN −1
1 1 2 2p ξˆ (C2N \ C2N−2 ) ≤ ρc (C2N \ C2N−2 )EPˆ c . E 2ˆ c ξˆ B1 (0) P0 (ξˆ (C2N ) + a2N )2 The last factor is bounded by hypothesis, the first one converges to 0 as N ↑ ∞ because of Lemma 4 and (57). ξˆ ξˆ (11) In order to prove (58) observe that ψc (Sx ξˆ ) = ψN (x) if x ∈ QN−1 . Therefore we can write 1 1 ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ mN (ψN ) = ξˆ (dx)ψc(11) (Sx ξˆ )+ ψN (x) . ξˆ (C2N )+a2N C2N−2 ξˆ (C2N )+a2N ξˆ
x∈VN \C2N−2
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment ξˆ
47
ξˆ
Now (58) follows easily from (63) and (65) with hN := ψN . Note that by the same arguments one can prove ˆ ˆ
ξ ξ = EPˆ c (|ϕc(1) |p ) < ∞ , 1 ≤ p ≤ 4 , (67) lim EPˆ c mN |ϕN (x)|p N↑∞
0
which will be useful below. In order to prove (59), we fix 0 < α < 1 and set M = 2N − 2[N α ], where [N α ] denotes the integer part of N α . Moreover, we define the hitting times ξˆ
ξˆ
τN (ω) = inf {s ≥ 0 : ωs ∈ C2N−2 } ,
ξˆ
ω = (ωs )s≥0 ∈ N = D([0, ∞), VN ).(68)
ξˆ ξˆ Recall the definitions of the distribution Pˆ cˆ , PN,x and PN given in Sects. 4 and 5.1. ξ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ Thanks to the identity (et LN ϕN )(x) = E ξˆ ϕN (ωt ) , we can write PN,x
ξˆ
ξˆ
ξˆ
EPˆ c ϕN , et LN ϕN where
ξˆ mN
ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ = EPˆ c A1,N + A2,N + A3,N ,
ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ A1,N = mN χ (x ∈ CM ) ϕN (x) E ξˆ ϕN (ωt ) , PN,x ˆξ ˆξ ˆξ ξˆ ξˆ A2,N = mN χ (x ∈ CM ) ϕN (x) E ξˆ χ (τN ≤ t) ϕN (ωt ) , PN,x ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ A3,N = mN χ (x ∈ CM ) ϕN (x) E ξˆ χ (τN > t) ϕN (ωt ) . PN,x
Then (59) follows from ξˆ lim EPˆ c A1,N = 0, N↑∞ ξˆ lim EPˆ c A2,N = 0,
N↑∞
ξˆ lim EPˆ c A3,N = ϕc(1) , et Lc ϕc(1) Pˆ c . 0 N↑∞
(69)
Let us first prove the first limit in (69). By several applications of Cauchy-Schwarz ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ inequality and due to the identity PN = mN (dx)PN,x , we get 1 1 E ˆ c Aξˆ ≤ E 2 mξˆ V ξˆ \ CM E 2 mξˆ ϕ ξˆ (x)2 E 1,N N N N N ˆc ˆc P
P 1 2
ξˆ
ξˆ
≤ E ˆ c mN VN \ CM P 1 2
= E ˆc P
ξˆ ξˆ mN VN
\ CM
P
ξˆ PN,x
ξˆ
ϕN (ωt )2
1 ˆ 41 ξ ξˆ E 4ˆ c mN ϕN (x)4 E ˆc E
P 1 2
E ˆc P
ξˆ mN
ξˆ ϕN (x)4 ξˆ
P
ξˆ PN
ξˆ
ϕN (ωt )4
, ξˆ
where the last identity follows from the stationarity of LN w.r.t. mN . Due to the dominated convergence theorem, the first expectation on the r.h.s. goes to 0, while the second expectation is bounded due to (67).
48
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
In order to prove the second limit in (69), we apply twice the Cauchy-Schwarz ξˆ inequality in order to obtain the bound EPˆ c A2,N by 1 ˆ ˆ 1 ξˆ 1 ξˆ
ξ ξ ξˆ ξˆ E 2ˆ c mN ϕN (x)2 E 4ˆ c E ξˆ ϕN (ωt )4 E 4ˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM )PN,x (τN ≤ t) P
P
P
PN
(70) Again, because of stationarity and (67), the first two factors on the r.h.s. are bounded while the last one converges to 0 due to Lemma 5 below. ˆ = D([0, ∞), Nˆ 0 ) Finally we prove the last limit in (69). To this aim, given ξˆ ∈ and x ∈ CM , we set
τN,x (ξˆ ) = inf s ≥ 0 : x + Xs (ξˆ ) ∈ C2N−2 , (71) where Xs (ξˆ ) is defined as in (19). Note that for x ∈ CM ∩ supp(ξˆ ), ξˆ
ϕN (x) = ϕc(1) (Sx ξˆ ),
E
ξˆ PN,x
ξˆ ξˆ χ (τN > t) ϕN (ωt ) = EPˆ c χ (τN,x > t) ϕc(1) (ξˆt ) . Sx ξˆ
Therefore ˆ! ξˆ "
ξ . EPˆ c A3,N = EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) ϕc(1) (Sx ξˆ ) EPˆ c χ (τN,x > t) ϕc(1) (ξˆt ) Sx ξˆ On the other hand, by applying the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality as in (70) and due to Lemma 5, we obtain ˆ! "
ξ = 0. lim EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) |ϕc(1) (Sx ξˆ )| EPˆ c χ (τN,x ≤ t) |ϕc(1) (ξˆt )| N ↑∞
Sx ξˆ
The last two identities imply ˆ! ξˆ "
ξ lim EPˆ c A3,N = lim EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) ϕc(1) (Sx ξˆ ) EPˆ c ϕc(1) (ξˆt ) . N ↑∞ N↑∞ Sx ξˆ (72) Observe now that (63) remains valid if the integral is performed on CM in place of C2N −2 (the arguments used in the proof there work also in this case) and the function h(ξˆ ) is defined as h(ξˆ ) = ϕc(1) (ξˆ ) EPˆ c ϕc(1) (ξˆt ) = ϕc(1) (ξˆ ) et Lc ϕc(1) (ξˆ ) . ξˆ
Note that h ∈ L2 (Nˆ 0 , Pˆ 0c ). Therefore we can conclude that the r.h.s. of (72) is equal to (1) (1) ϕc , et Lc ϕc Pˆ c . 0
ξˆ
Lemma 5. Let τN and τN,x be defined as in (68) and (71), and let M = 2N − 2[N α ]. Then ˆ! "
ξ ξˆ ξˆ lim EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) PN,x τN ≤ t = 0, (73) N↑∞ ˆ! "
ξ = 0. (74) lim EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) Pˆ c ˆ τN,x ≤ t N↑∞
Sx ξ
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
49
Proof. One can check by a coupling argument that the two expectations in (73) and (74) coincide: for each N ∈ N+ , ξˆ ∈ Nˆ and x ∈ CM ∩ supp(ξˆ ), one can define a probability ξˆ ˆ such that measure µ on × N
ξˆ
ˆ = P (A), µ(A × ) N,x
ξˆ
µ(N × B) = Pˆ c ˆ (B), Sx ξ
ξˆ
ˆ ∀A ∈ B(N ), ∀B ∈ B(),
ξˆ ξˆ and such that, µ almost surely, τN (ω) = τN,x (ξˆ ) and ωs = x+Xs (ξˆ ) for any 0 ≤ s < τN . ξˆ ξˆ Such a coupling µ implies Pˆ c ˆ τN,x ≤ t = PN,x τN ≤ t . Thus we need to prove Sx ξ only (73). Moreover, without loss of generality, we assume rc = 1. To this aim let us cover C2N−2 \ CM by disjoint cubes C1,i of side 1, i ∈ I , so that C2N−2 \ CM = ∪i∈I C1,i (the boundaries of these cubes are suitably chosen for them to be disjoint). Finally, given a positive integer n, we set
I∗n = {(l1 , . . . , ln ) ∈ I n : lj = lk if j = k}. ξˆ
For paths ω such that τN (ω) < ∞, let us define k = k(ω) as the number of different ξˆ
cubes C1,i , i ∈ I , visited by the particle in the time interval [0, τN (ω) ) and more k over we define by induction (i1 , . . . , ik ) ∈ I∗k , (x1 , . . . , xk ) ∈ C2N−2 \ CM with xj ∈ C1,ij ∀j : 1 ≤ j ≤ k, and (t1 , . . . , tk ) as follows: Let x1 be the first point reached in C2N −2 \ CM and t1 be the time spent in x1 before jumping away. The index i1 is characterized by the requirement that x1 ∈ C1,i1 . Suppose now that i1 , . . . , ij , x1 , . . . , xj and t1 , . . . , tj have been defined and that j < k. Then xj +1 is the first point ξˆ in C2N −2 \ CM ∪ C1,i1 ∪ · · · ∪ C1,ij visited during the time interval [0, τN (ω) ) and tj +1 is the time spent at xj +1 during such a first visit. Moreover, ij +1 is such that xj +1 ∈ C1,ij +1 . ξˆ
Now let Ti , i ∈ I and ξˆ ∈ Nˆ , be a family of independent exponential random variξˆ
ables (all independent from the above random objects) and such that Ti has parameter #1,i ), where ξˆ C #1,i = {y ∈ Rd : dist(y, C1,i ) ≤ 1 }. C Since, given ξˆ , k and (x1 , . . . , xk ), tj (1 ≤ j ≤ k) are independent exponential variables #1,ij and since k ≥ kmin := [N α ] − 1, we and tj has parameter not larger than ξˆ C obtain ˆ! "
ξ ξˆ ξˆ EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) PN,x τN ≤ t =
|I |
n=kmin l∈I∗n
≤
|I | n=kmin l∈I∗n
ˆ! ξ EPˆ c mN χ (x∈CM ) y∈
$n
"
ξˆ ξˆ PN,x τN ≤ t, k = n, xl = yl , 1 ≤ l ≤ n
ξˆ j =1 C1,lj ∩VN
ˆ! " ξ ξˆ EPˆ c mN χ (x ∈ CM ) PN,x k = n, i1 = l1 , . . . , in = ln
ξˆ
ξˆ × Prob Tl1 + · · · + Tln ≤ t ,
(75)
50
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
where the last inequality follows from the bound ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ ξˆ PN,x τN ≤ t | k = n, x1 = y1 , . . . , xn = yn ≤ Prob Tl1 + · · · + Tln ≤ t . In order to estimate the probability in the r.h.s., we use an argument to that similar #1 ) , where of the proof of Proposition 1 in Appendix C. Let us define m := EPˆ c ξˆ (C #1 = {y ∈ Rd : dist(y, C1 ) ≤ 1}. Given κ > 0 and l ∈ I∗n as above, we define C A = A(κ, l) as follows
#1,lj > κ m > n . A = ξˆ ∈ Nˆ : j : 1 ≤ j ≤ n and ξˆ C 2 Then, by the Chebyshev inequality and the stationarity of Pˆ c , 2 #1,lj > κ m ≤ 2 Pˆ c ξˆ (C #1 ) > κ m → 0, Pˆ c A ≤ EPˆ c j : 1 ≤ j ≤ n and ξˆ C n as κ → ∞. Note that the complement Ac of A can be written as
#1,lj ≤ κ m ≥ n Ac = ξˆ ∈ Nˆ : j : 1 ≤ j ≤ n and ξˆ C , 2 ∗ where [n/2]∗ is defined as n/2 for n even and as (n + 1)/2 for n odd. If ξˆ ∈ Ac then at ξˆ ξˆ least n2 ∗ of the exponential variables Tl1 , . . . ,Tln have parameter not larger than κ m. Then, by a coupling argument (e.g. Appendix C), we get for all ξˆ ∈ Ac , ξˆ ξˆ Prob Tl1 + · · · + Tln ≤ t ≤ e−κ mt
∞ r=[n/2]∗
(κ m t)r =: φ(κ, n) . r!
Due to the above estimates and since n ≥ kmin = [N α ] − 1, we get #1 ) > κ m + φ(κ, N α ) . r.h.s. of (75) ≤ 2 Pˆ c ξˆ (C The lemma follows by taking first the limit N ↑ ∞ and then the limit κ ↑ ∞.
5.3. Random resistor networks. We conclude this section by pointing out that the diffuξˆ
sion coefficient DN of the periodized medium can be expressed in terms of the effective ξˆ
ξˆ
conductance of the graph (V N , E N ) when assigning suitable bond conductances. More ξˆ
ξˆ
precisely, consider the electrical network given by the graph (V N , E N ), where the bond ξˆ
{x, y} ∈ E N has conductivity c({π(x), π(y)}) with c({·, ·}) defined in (54). Then, the ξˆ
− to effective conductance GN of this network is defined as the current flowing from N + − + N when a unit potential difference between N to N is imposed. It can be calculated from Ohm’s law and the Kirchhoff rule as follows. Let the electrical potential V (x) − + vanish on the left border N , be equal to 1 on the right border N , and satisfy:
c({π(x), π(y)}) V (y) − V (x) = 0 for any ξˆ
y : {y,x}∈E N
ξˆ
x ∈ QN .
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
51
Then the effective conductance is given by the current flowing through the surfaces {x ∈ [−N, N]d : x (1) = ±N }: ξˆ
GN =
1 − V (x) .
V (x) =
ξˆ − x∈BN
(76)
ξˆ + x∈BN
ξˆ
By a well-known analogy it is linked to the diffusion coefficient DN (see e.g. [DFGW, Prop. 4.15] for a similar proof): Proposition 8. One has ξˆ
DN =
8 N2 ξˆ |V N |
ξˆ
GN .
(77)
6. Percolation Estimates Let us set Fr := FRd \Cr and recall that ρc = ρ δc with δc = ν([−Ec , Ec ]).
6.1. Point density estimates. Here we show how the ergodic properties of Lemma 4 combined with the hypothesis (H1) or (H2) imply (57). Proposition 9. Suppose that ρ8 < ∞ and that the hypothesis (H1) or (H2) holds. For 1 ≤ p ≤ 8, lim
N↑∞
ρc (CN ) = 1 ˆξ (CN ) + aN
in Lp ( Nˆ , Pˆ c ) ,
(78)
where aN = (N − 1)d−1 . We will first prove the following criterion. Lemma 6. Property (78) holds if one has, for some 0 < ρ < ρ, lim N p Pˆ ξˆ (CN ) ≤ ρ N d = 0 .
N↑∞
(79)
Proof. We first check that (79) implies that, for some 0 < ρ
< ρ δc , lim N p Pˆ c ξˆ (CN ) ≤ ρ
N d = 0 .
N↑∞
(80)
If δc = 1, this is clearly true so let us suppose that 0 < δc < 1. Set δ˜c = 1 − δc . If Cjk denotes the binomial coefficient, we have
52
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
N d ] [ρ c ˆ
d ˆ ˆ ξˆ (CN ) = k) P ξ (CN ) ≤ ρ N = P(
k=0 ∞
+
k=[ρ
N d ]+1 [ρ N d ]
≤
k
ˆ ξˆ (CN ) = k) P(
j =k−[ρ
N d ] k
ˆ ξˆ (CN ) = k)+ sup P(
k>[ρ N d ]
k=0
j k−j Cjk δ˜c δc
Cjk δ˜c δc
j k−j
j =k−[ρ
N d ]
≤ Pˆ ξˆ (CN ) ≤ ρ N d +exp(−c[ρ N d ](δc − ρ
/ρ )2 ), where the last inequality, given ρ
< δc ρ , follows from a standard large deviation type estimate for Bernoulli variables with some c > 0. Multiplying by N p , (79) thus implies (80). Now set AN = {ξˆ : ξˆ (CN ) ≤ ρ
N d }. Then, for some c > 0 independent of N , p ρc (CN ) p fN (ξˆ ) := − 1 ≤ c ρc N p χAN (ξˆ ) + fN (ξˆ ) χAcN (ξˆ ) . ξˆ (CN ) + aN Integrating w.r.t. Pˆ c , the first term vanishes in the limit N ↑ ∞ because of (80). For the second, let us first note that Lemma 4 implies that limN↑0 fN χAcN = 0 holds Pˆ c -a.s. Furthermore, |fN χAcN | ≤ c
< ∞ uniformly in N so that the dominated convergence theorem assures that limN↑0 EPˆ c (fN χAcN ) = 0. Proof of Proposition 9. Due to Lemma 6 we only need to show that (79) is satisfied for some ρ < ρ. This is trivially true if (H1) holds. Hence let us consider the case where (H2) holds. This implies E ˆ (f | Fr ) − E ˆ (f ) ≤ f ∞ r d r d−1 h(r2 − r1 ) , ˆ P-a.s. , (81) 2 1 2 P P where f is a bounded FCr1 –measurable function.
Let C1i denote the unit cube centered at i ∈ Zd and Cˇ 1i be the interior of C1i . Let j IN ⊂ Zd be such that CN = ∪i∈IN C1i and Cˇ 1i ∩ Cˇ 1 = ∅ if i = j . Hence |IN | = N d . ˜ ˜ Given M > 0, set Y˜i (ξˆ ) = min{ξˆ (Cˇ 1i ), M 2 } and Yi = Yi − EPˆ (Yi ). Note that Yi is centered, FC i –measurable and Yi ∞ ≤ M. We choose M large enough so that 1 ρ˜ := E ˆ (Y˜i ) > ρ which is possible because limM↑∞ E ˆ (Y˜i ) = ρ > ρ . Now P
ξˆ (CN ) ≤ ρ N d
⊂
i∈IN
P
Yi (ξˆ ) ≥ (ρ˜ − ρ )N d . Y˜i (ξˆ ) ≤ ρ N d ⊂ i∈IN
Hence it is sufficient to show that, for a > 0, Yi ≥ aN d = 0 . lim N p Pˆ N↑∞
i∈IN
(82)
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
By the Chebyshev inequality, one has for any even q ∈ N: 1 Pˆ Yi ≥ aN d ≤ q dq EPˆ Yi1 · · · Yiq . a N
53
(83)
i1 ,... ,iq ∈IN
i∈IN
We will now bound the sum in the r.h.s. of (83). Let us define the norm x = max{|x (k) | : 1 ≤ k ≤ d} on Rd (recall that x (k) is the k th component of x) and introduce the notation i = (i1 , . . . , iq ), I N = (IN )q , and rj (i) = min{ij − ik : k = 1, . . . , q, k = j }. If r1 (i) = · · · = rN (i) = 0, i.e., if each point appears at least twice in (i1 , . . . , iq ), then use the bound EPˆ (Yi1 · · · Yiq ) ≤ M q . The number of i ∈ I N satisfying this property is at most cN dq/2 (here and below c is a varying constant depending only on d and on q). i Suppose now that, say, r1 (i) = r ≥ 1. Then the open cubes Cˇ 1i2 , . . . , Cˇ 1q are contained i1 in A := Rd − C2r−1 and thus Yi2 , . . . , Yiq are FA -measurable. Using the conditional expectation, (81) and the fact that Yi1 is centered and Yij ∞ ≤ M, EPˆ (Yi1 · · · Yiq ) ≤ M q−1 EPˆ EPˆ (Yi1 |FA ) ≤ M q h(2r − 2) (2r − 1)d−1 . Note that EPˆ (Yi1 · · · Yiq ) is invariant under permutations of the indices i1 , . . . , iq . Hence
EPˆ (Yi1 · · · Yiq ) ≤ c
N
EPˆ (Yi1 · · · Yiq )
r=0 i∈K N (r)
i∈I N
≤ c M q N dq/2 + c M q
N
h(2r − 2) (2r − 1)d−1 |K N (r)| ,
r=1
where K N (r) = {i ∈ I N : r1 (i) = r, r2 (i) ≤ r, . . . , rq (i) ≤ r}. One has |K N (r)| ≤ c N dq/2 r dq/2−1 .
(84)
In fact, on the set of points i1 , . . . , iq (treated as distinguishable) let us define a graph structure by connecting two points i ∼ j with a bond whenever i − j ≤ r. We call G(i) the resulting graph. Note that each connected component of G(i) has cardinality at least 2 whenever i ∈ K N (r), therefore G(i) has at most q/2 connected components. We claim that, given 1 ≤ l ≤ q/2, {i ∈ K (r) : G(i) has l connected components} ≤ c(N/r)dl r dq−1 . (85) N In order to prove (85), suppose that the connected component containing i1 has cardinality k1 , while the other components have cardinality k2 , . . . , kl respectively. Each component can be built by first choosing one of its points in IN (there are N d possible choices), then its neighboring points w.r.t. ∼ (for each such neighboring point there are at most cr d possible choices) and then iteratively adding neighboring points w.r.t. ∼. Therefore, the j th component can be built in at most cN d r d(kj −1) ways. If j = 1, since i1 has a neighboring point at distance exactly r, the upper bound can be improved by cN d r d−1+d(k1 −2) . Summing over all possible k1 , . . . , kl such that k1 + · · · + kl = q, one gets (85). Since r ≤ N, (85) implies |K N (r)| ≤
q/2 l=1
c(N/r)dl r dq−1 ≤ c(N/r)dq/2 r dq−1 ,
54
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
thus concluding the proof of (84). It implies ∞ q dq/2 1 + c
EPˆ (Yi1 · · · Yiq ) ≤ M N h(2r − 2) r dq/2+d−2
.
(86)
r=1
i∈I N
Provided that dq > 2p and the sum over r converges, that is, if dq/2 − d ≤ 8, we get the result (79) by combining (82), (83), and (86). Choosing for q the smallest even integer larger than 16/d, (79) is true for 1 ≤ p ≤ 8 and dq/2 − d ≤ 8 as required. 6.2. Domination. Due to Proposition 9, we may apply the results of Sect. 5 so that combining with Proposition 3, 2 8 N ˆ ξ D ≥ ν([−Ec , Ec ]) e−rc −4βEc lim sup EPˆ c ˆ GN . (87) ξ N→∞ |V N | ξˆ
rc from below, we will discretize the In order to bound the conductance GN for N space Rd using cubes of appropriate size and spacing. Given r2 ≥ r1 > 0, let us then consider the following functions on Nˆ : σj (ξˆ ) := χ ξˆ (Cr1 + r2 j ) > 0 , j ∈ Zd . (88) They form a random field = (σj )j ∈Zd on the probability space (Nˆ , Pˆ c ). If Pˆ is a PPP, the σj are independent random variables. For a process with finite range correlations, this independence can also be assured by an adequate choice of r1 and r2 , but in general the σj are correlated. The side length r1 and spacing r2 are going to be chosen of order O(rc ) in such a way that all points of neighboring cubes have an euclidean distance less ξˆ
ξˆ
than rc and they are thus connected by an edge of the graph (V N , E N ). Next note that the σj take values in {0, 1}. We shall consider the associated site percolation problem with bonds between nearest neighbors only [Gri]. For this purpose, p we shall compare with a random field Z p = (zj )j ∈Zd of independent and identically p p distributed random variables with Prob(zj = 1) = p and Prob(zj = 0) = 1 − p. In this independent case, it is well-known that there is a critical probability pc (d) ∈ (0, 1) such that, if p > pc (d), there is almost surely a unique infinite cluster, while for p < pc (d) there is almost surely none [Gri]. We will need somewhat finer estimates for the supercritical regime. Let |.| denote the Euclidean norm in Rd . A left-right crossing (LR-crossp ing) with length k − 1 of C2N of a configuration (zj )j ∈Zd is a sequence of distinct points p y1 , . . . , yk in C2N ∩ Zd such that |yi − yi+1 | = 1 for 1 ≤ i < k, zyi = 1 for 1 ≤ i ≤ k, (1) (1) (1) (s) (s) y1 = −N , yk = N, −N < yi < N for 1 < i < k, and finally yi = yj for any s ≥ 3 and for 1 ≤ i < j ≤ k. Two crossings are called disjoint if all the involved yj ’s are distinct. In the same way, one defines disjoint LR-crossings for (σj )j ∈Zd . Note that this definition of LR-crossings for d ≥ 3 uses LR-crossings in 2-dimensional slices only. For the random field Z p , the techniques of [Gri, Sect. 2.6 and 11.3] transposed to site percolation imply that, if p > pc (2), there are positive constants a = a(p), b = b(p), and c = c(p) such that for all N ∈ N+ , Prob Z p has less than bN d−1 disjoint LR–crossings in C2N ≤ c e−a N . (89)
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
55
In order to transpose this result on Z p to one for , we will use the concept of stochastic dominance [Gri, Sect. 7.4]. One writes ≥st Z p whenever EPˆ c (f ()) ≥ EProb (f (Z p )) ,
(90)
for any bounded, increasing, measurable function f : {0, 1}Z → R (recall that a function is increasing if f ((zj )j ∈Zd ) ≥ f ((zj )j ∈Zd ) whenever zj ≥ zj for all j ∈ Zd ). As the event on the l.h.s. of (89) is decreasing, ≥st Z p with p > pc (2) implies that for all N ∈ N+ , Pˆ c (σj )j ∈Zd has less than bN d−1 disjoint LR–crossings in C2N ≤ c e−a N . (91) d
Moreover, let us call the configurations ξˆ in the set on the l.h.s. N -bad, those in the complementary set N-good. For every N –good ξˆ , let us fix a set of at least configuration bN d−1 disjoint LR–crossings in C2N for σj (ξˆ ) j ∈Zd and denote it CN (ξˆ ). Given an LR–crossing γ in C2N , we write L(γ ) for its length. Note that, since the LR–crossings are self–avoiding, L(γ ) = |supp(γ )| − 1 for all γ ∈ CN (ξˆ ). Moreover, since paths in CN (ξˆ ) are disjoint and have support in C2N ∩ Zd , γ ∈CN (ξˆ ) |supp(γ )| ≤ (2N + 1)d . The above estimates imply that γ ∈CN (ξˆ ) L(γ ) ≤ (2N + 1)d ≤ (4N )d . In particular, due to the Jensen inequality, for any N–good configuration ξˆ ,
1 |CN (ξˆ )|2 b2 N d−2 . ≥ ≥ L(γ ) 4d γ ∈CN (ξˆ ) L(γ ) ˆ γ ∈CN (ξ )
(92)
This will allow us to prove a lower bound on (87). Hence we need the following criterion for domination. Lemma 7. ≥st Z p holds with r1 = r, r2 = 2r if Pˆ and r > 0 satisfy the following: There exists ρ > 0 such that r d ν([−Ec , Ec ]) ≥ −
ln(p/2) , ρ
(93)
and 3p Pˆ ξˆ (Cr ) < ρ r d F2 r ≤ 1 − , 2
ˆ P–a.s.
(94)
Proof. The proof is based on the following criterion [Gri, Sect. 7.4]: if for any finite subset J of Zd , i ∈ Zd \ J and zj ∈ {0, 1} for j ∈ J satisfying Pˆ c (σj = zj ∀j ∈ J ) > 0, one has Pˆ c (σi = 1 | σj = zj ∀ j ∈ J ) ≥ p ,
(95)
then ≥st Z p . Hence let J, i, zj be as above and set δ˜c := 1 − δc and J0 := {j ∈ J : zj = 0} as well as J1 := {j ∈ J : zj = 1}. Moreover, given k ∈ NJ0 and s ∈ NJ+1 , let W (k, s) := ξˆ ∈ Nˆ : ξˆ (Cr + 2rj ) = kj ∀j ∈ J0 , ξˆ (Cr + 2rj ) = sj ∀j ∈ J1 .
56
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
Then Pˆ c (σi = 0 | σj = zj ∀j ∈ J ) n$ $ ˜ ˜kj j ∈J (1 − δ˜csj ) ˆ ˆ J n∈N P ξ (Cr + 2ri) = n , W (k, s) δc j ∈J0 δc k∈NJ0 1 s∈N+1 = . $ kj $ sj ˜ ˜ ˆ W (k, s) J1 P j ∈J0 δc j ∈J1 (1 − δc ) k∈NJ0 s∈N+
Within this, we can, moreover, replace Pˆ ξˆ (Cr + 2ri) = n , W (k, s) = Pˆ ξˆ (Cr + 2ri) = n | W (k, s) Pˆ W (k, s) . Finally, note that W (k, s) ∈ FA , where A = Rd \ C2r + 2ri . As δ˜c ≤ e−δc , we obtain the following bound
d Pˆ ξˆ (Cr + 2ri) = n | W (k, s) δ˜cn ≤ Pˆ ξˆ (Cr + 2ri) < ρ r d | W (k, s) + e−δc ρ r . n∈N
ˆ (93) and (94) imply (95). Due to the stationarity of P,
6.3. Proof of Theorem 1(ii). We fix p > pc (2) and ρ < ρ. Then, given Ec , we choose rc such that (93) is satisfied, i.e. rc = c(Ecα+1 )−1/d for some constant c. As rc ↑ ∞ in the limit of low temperature, we can next check that the condition (94) also holds. This is trivial for a process with a uniform lower bound (4) on the point density. For a mixing point process satisfying (5), one has Pˆ ξˆ (Cr ) < ρ r d F2r ≤ Pˆ ξˆ (Cr ) < ρ r d + r d (2r)d−1 h(r) , Pˆ − a.s. Due to the hypothesis on h, the second term converges to 0 in the limit r ↑ ∞. If ρ < ρ, the first one can be bounded by the Chebychev inequality: ξˆ (C ) ξˆ (C ) 1 r r
d
ˆ ξˆ (Cr ) ≤ ρ r ) ≤ Pˆ ˆ P( P(dξ ) − ρ > ρ − ρ ≤ − ρ .
(Cr ) (Cr ) ρ−ρ By Lemma 4, the expression on the r.h.s. can be made arbitrarily small by choosing r sufficiently large, thus implying that (94) is satisfied for r sufficiently large. In conclusion, due to Lemma 7, (91) holds for r large enough, i.e. temperature low enough. We fix such a value r satisfying (91) and call it rp . Consider the variables (σj )j ∈Zd defined for r1 = rp , r2 = 2rp and choose rc = 1 (d+8) 2 rp . This assures that, if neighboring sites j and j in Zd have σj (ξˆ ) = σj (ξˆ ) = 1, then Crp + 2j rp and Crp + 2j rp contain each a point and these points are separated by a distance less than rc . Two neighboring sites j and j in Zd such that σj (ξˆ ) = σj (ξˆ ) = 1 define a bond of the site percolation problem. To such a bond one can associate (at least) two points x ∈ supp ξˆ ∩ (Crp + 2j rp ) and y ∈ supp ξˆ ∩ (Crp + 2j rp ) separated by a distance less than rc . Given N integer, we define Nˆ := max n ∈ N : Crp + 2rp j ⊂ C2[rp N] , ∀j ∈ C2n ∩ Zd .
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
57
Note that Nˆ = O(N ). If j, j ∈ C2Nˆ ∩ Zd , then the above associated points x and y are ξˆ
ξˆ
linked by an edge of the graph (V [rp N] , E [rp N] ) defined in Sect. 5.1. Each LR-crossing of C2Nˆ for the site percolation problem gives in a natural way a connected path of edges ξˆ
ξˆ
± of the graph (V [rp N] , E [rp N] ) which connects the boundary faces N .
ξˆ ˆ For a N–good configuration ξˆ , we now bound the conductance G[rp N] from below. For
ξˆ + ˆ− , N }, this purpose, let us consider the random resistor network with vertices Q[rp N] ∪{ˆ N ξˆ
ξˆ
where unit conductances are put on all edges in E [rp N] with vertices in Q[rp N] as well as ξˆ ±
± and all points of B[rp N] . This new network between the two added boundary points ˆ N is obtained from the one of Sect. 5.1 upon placing superconducting wires between all + − + and [r so that they can be identified with a single point ˆ N and vertices of [r p N] p N]
ξˆ − − . The conductance gN of this new network (defined as the current flowing from ˆ N ˆ N + to ˆ N when a unit potential difference is imposed between these two points) is precisely ξˆ
± have the same potential (0 or 1 respectively) equal to G[rp N] because all points of [r p N] ξˆ ±
and each has links to all points of B[rp N] with equal conductances summing up to 1. ξˆ
In order to bound gN from below, we now invoke Rayleigh’s monotonicity law which states that eliminating links (i.e. conductances) from the network always lowers its conductance. ˆ For a given N-good configuration ξˆ , we cut all links but those belonging to the family + − and ˆ N is of disjoint paths associated to CNˆ (ξˆ ). Each of these paths γ connecting ˆ N self-avoiding and hence has a conductance bounded below by 1/L(γ ). As all the paths ξˆ of C ˆ (ξˆ ) are disjoint and they are connecting ˆ + and ˆ − in parallel, g is the sum of N
N
N
N
ξˆ
the conductances of all paths and it follows from (92) that gN ≥ c(b)N d−2 for some positive constant c(b) depending on b. We therefore deduce that 2 2 [rp N ] [rp N] ξˆ EPˆ c ˆ G[rp N] ≥ c(b) EPˆ c ˆ N d−2 χ (ξˆ is Nˆ –good ) . ξ ξ |V [rp N] | |V [rp N] |
Due to (91) and Proposition 9 the r.h.s. converges to a positive value. Combining this with the estimate (87) we obtain − α+1 d
D ≥ C ν([−Ec , Ec ]) e−rc −4βEc ≥ C Ec1+α exp(−cEc
− 4βEc ) ,
where C and C are positive constants. Optimizing the exponent leads to Ec = c β − α+1+d which completes the proof. d
A. Proof that the Random Walk is Well-Defined Proposition 10. Let P be ergodic with ρ2 < ∞. Then for P0 –almost all ξ ∈ N0 and for ξ all x ∈ ξˆ , there exists a unique probability measure Px on ξ = D([0, ∞), supp(ξˆ )) of
58
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner ξ
a continuous–time random walk starting at x whose transition probabilities pt (y|x) := ξ ξ ξ Px (Xs+t = y|Xs = x), x, y ∈ ξˆ , t ≥ 0, s ≥ 0 satisfy the infinitesimal conditions (C1) and (C2). Proof. The uniqueness follows from [Bre, Chap. 15]. In order to prove existence, due to the construction described in Sect. 3.2, we only need to prove (27) for P0 –almost all ξ and for any x ∈ ξˆ . According to [Bre, Prop. 15.43], condition (27) is implied by the following one: P˜ xξ
∞ n=0
1 =∞ = 1. λX˜ ξ (ξ )
(96)
n
Due to the identity ξ P˜ 0
∞ n=1
1 ξ 1 = ∞ X˜ 1 = x = P˜ xξ =∞ , λX˜ ξ (ξ ) λX˜ ξ (ξ ) ∞
n=0
n
∀ x ∈ ξˆ ,
n
the proof will be completed if we can show (96) for x = 0 and P0 –almost all ξ and, in particular, if we can show ∞ ∞ 1 1 ξ P˜ =∞ = Q0 (dξ ) P˜ 0 =∞ =1, λ0 (ξn ) λX˜ ξ (ξ ) n=0
n=0
n
˜ P˜ , and Q0 are defined in Sect. 3.3. Due to Proposition 2, P˜ where the distributions P, 0 is ergodic and therefore, according to ergodic theory (see [Ros, Chap. IV]), ξ
N 1 1 1 1 = = EQ0 , N↑∞ N λ0 (ξn ) λ0 EP0 (λ0 )
lim
˜ P-almost surely,
n=0
thus allowing to conclude the proof.
Remark 3. Explosions are excluded if supx∈ξˆ λx (ξ ) < ∞ (in such a case (96) is always true), but this simple criterion is typically not satisfied in our case. For instance, for a PPP e−|x−y| ≥ e−4β−1 sup ξˆ (C1 + x) = ∞, P0 -a.s. sup λx (ξ ) ≥ e−4β sup x∈ξˆ
x∈ξˆ y∈ξˆ ,|y−x|≤1
x∈ξˆ
B. Proof of Lemma 1 Note that the statements (ii) and (iii) of Lemma 1 are proved in [FKAS, Corollary 1.2.11 and Theorem 1.3.9] in dimension d = 1. The proof below is valid for any dimension d. Proof of Lemma 1. (i) Let h(ξ, ξ ) := k(ξ, ξ ) − k(ξ , ξ ). By the definition (11) of the Palm distribution P0 , ∀N > 0, ∀A ∈ B(Rd ) and for any non negative measurable function f , 1 ˆ (dy) P(dξ ) ξ ξˆ (dx)f (Sy ξ, Sx ξ ) . P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx)f (ξ, Sx ξ )= ρN d A CN A+y (97)
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
59
The antisymmetry of h(ξ, ξ ) and the identity above imply 1 ˆ (dy) P(dξ ) ξ ξˆ (dx)h(Sy ξ, Sx ξ ).(98) P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) h(ξ, Sx ξ )= ρN d Rd CN Rd \CN Let us split the last integral into two integrals over Rd \ CN+√N and over CN+√N \ CN . Using (97) again, 1 ˆ ˆ P(dξ ) ξ, S ξ ) ξ (dy) ξ (dx)h(S y x ρN d CN Rd \CN +√N ≤ P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) |k(ξ, Sx ξ )| + |k(Sx ξ, ξ )| , Rd \C√N
which converges to zero as N → ∞ by the dominated convergence theorem. The same holds for 1 ˆ (dy) ˆ (dx) h(Sy ξ, Sx ξ ) , P(dξ ) ξ ξ ρN d CN C √ \CN N+ N
since, due to (97), it can be bounded by 1 ˆ P(dξ ) ξ (dx) ξˆ (dy) |k(Sy ξ, Sx ξ )| + |k(Sx ξ, Sy ξ )| √ d ρN d CN + N \CN R √ d d (N + N ) − N P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dy) |k(Sy ξ, ξ )| + |k(ξ, Sy ξ )| . = d d N R Letting N → ∞ in (98) leads to the result. (ii) Since ∈ B(N ) is translation invariant, one has χ0 (Sx ξ ) = χ (ξ ) for all ξ ∈ N and x ∈ ξˆ . The above remark together with (11) gives 1 1 P(dξ ) ξˆ (C1 ) . ξˆ (dx)χ0 (Sx ξ ) = P(dξ ) P0 (0 ) = ρ ρ C1 Comparing with (1), this yields P0 (0 ) = 1 if P() = 1. Reciprocally, always due to (1), if P0 (0 ) = 1, one gets ξˆ (C1 ) = 0 for P–almost all ξ ∈ N \ , and by translation invariance ξ = 0 for P–almost all ξ ∈ N \ , thus * implying that P() = 1. (iii) Let us suppose that P0 (A) = P0 (B) > 0 and set := x∈Rd Sx B. This is a translation-invariant Borel subset of N (see Lemma 8) and B ⊂ ∩ N0 ⊂ A. In particular, P() ∈ {0, 1} by the ergodicity of P. Since χB (Sy ξ ) ≤ χ (ξ ) for all ξ ∈ N and y ∈ Rd , it follows from (11) that 1 1 ξˆ (dy) χB (Sy ξ ) ≤ P(dξ ) P(ξ )ξˆ (C1 ) . P0 (B) = ρ N ρ C1 Therefore, P() = 0 would imply that P0 (B) = 0, in contradiction with our assumption. Thus P() = 1. But ∩ N0 ⊂ A, therefore the statement follows from (ii). (iv) The thesis follows by observing that (11) implies k k 1 1 ˆ ˆ ˆ EP0 P(dξ ) ξ (dx) P(dξ )ξˆ (C1 ) ξ (Aj ) = ξ (Aj +x) ≤ ξˆ (A˜ j ) ρ N ρ N C 1 j =1 j =1 j =1 k
60
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
k+1 and by applying the estimate a1 · · · ak+1 ≤ c(k +1) (a1k+1 +· · ·+ak+1 ), a1 , . . . , ak+1 ≥ 0. * Lemma 8. Let A ∈ B(N0 ). Then x∈Rd Sx A ∈ B(N ).
Proof. Let us introduce the following lexicographic ordering on Rd : x ≺ y if and only if either |x| < |y| or |x| = |y| and there is k, 1 ≤ k ≤ d, such that x (k) < y (k) and x (l) = y (l) for l < k (here x (k) is the k th component of the vector x). Given ξˆ ∈ Nˆ , one can then order the support of ξˆ according to ≺: {y1 (ξˆ ), y2 (ξˆ ), . . . , yN (ξˆ )} if N := ξˆ (Rd ) < ∞ , ˆ supp(ξ ) = otherwise , {yj (ξˆ )}j ∈N+ where yj ≺ yk whenever j < k. For any n ∈ N, let xn : Nˆ → Rd then be defined as yn (ξˆ ) if n ≤ ξˆ (Rd ) , xn (ξˆ ) = yN (ξˆ ) if n > N := ξˆ (Rd ) . Using an adequate family of finite disjoint covers of Rd and the fact that ξˆ ∈ Nˆ → ξˆ (B) is a Borel function for every Borel set B ⊂ Rd , one can verify that xn is a Borel function for each n. Moreover, supp(ξˆ ) = {xn (ξˆ ) : n ∈ N} for all ξˆ ∈ Nˆ . Due to the definition of the Borel sets in N and Nˆ , the map π : N → Nˆ given by π(ξ ) = ξˆ is Borel, and by [MKM, Sect. 6.1] the function F : Rd × N → N given by F (x, ξ ) = Sx ξ is even continuous. Hence we conclude that Hn (ξ ) := F xn (ξˆ ), ξ = Sxn (ξˆ ) ξ , Hn : N → N0 , function. Now is a Borel function. Its restriction Hˆ n : N0 → N0 is then also * a Borel −1 (A) is a Borel ˆ given a Borel subset A of N0 , we conclude that (A) := ∞ H n=1 n subset in N0 . One can check that (A) = {ξ : ξ = Sx η for some η ∈ A and x ∈ ηˆ }. Since N0 is a Borel subset of N , it follows that (A) is a Borel subset of N as is H1−1 (A) since H1 is a Borel function. The identity + Sx A , H1−1 (A) = x∈Rd
now completes the proof. C. Proof of Proposition 1
Proof of Proposition 1. Due to the construction of the dynamics given in Sect. 3.2, ξ ξ EP0 EPξ |Xt |γ = EP0 EP˜ ξ ⊗Q |X˜ ξ |γ . 0
0
n∗ (t)
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
61
Let p, q > 1 be such that 1/p + 1/q = 1. Due to the H¨older inequality, ξ EP0 EP˜ ξ ⊗Q |X˜ ξ
n∗ (t)
0
≤
|γ
∞
=
ξ ξ EP0 EP˜ ξ ⊗Q |X˜ nξ |γ χ n∗ (t) ≥ 1 χ n∗ (t) = n 0
n=1
∞
1 1 ξ q p ξ EP0 EP˜ ξ ⊗Q |X˜ nξ |γ q χ n∗ (t) ≥ 1 EP0 P˜ 0ξ ⊗ Q (n∗ (t) = n) . 0
n=1 ξ
ξ ξ 0,X˜ 0
Clearly, n∗ (t) ≥ 1 means T
≤ t. It then follows from the estimate 1 − e−u ≤ u,
u ≥ 0, that ξ EP˜ ξ ⊗Q |X˜ nξ |γ q χ n∗ (t) ≥ 1 = 1 − e−λ0 (ξ )t EP˜ ξ |X˜ nξ |γ q ≤ λ0 (ξ )t EP˜ ξ |X˜ nξ |γ q . 0
0
0
(99) We then obtain ∞ ξ EP0 EPξ |Xt |γ ≤C 0
1/q Q0 (dξ )EP˜ ξ |X˜ nξ |γ q 0
n=1
1/p ξ ξ ˜ P0 (dξ )P0 ⊗ Q n∗ (t)=n ,
(100)
with C = [t EP0 (λ0 )]1/q . We claim that there is a (time-independent) constant C > 0 such that (101) Q0 (dξ ) EP˜ ξ |X˜ nξ |γ q ≤ C nγ q . 0
To show this, let us note first that, given X˜ 0 = 0, by another application of the H¨older inequality, ξ
n−1 ξ γ q ξ n−1 ξ γ q ξ γ q−1 X˜ X˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ξ γ q , X = − X ≤ n n m m+1 m+1 − Xm m=0
m=0
where it has been assumed that γ q > 1. One can derive from the stationarity of P˜ and Remark 1 that ξ ξ γ q ξ γ q ˜ ˜ = Q0 (dξ ) EP˜ ξ X˜ 1 := C
Q0 (dξ ) EP˜ ξ Xn+1 − Xn 0
0
for any n ∈ N. One concludes the proof of (101) by checking that C is finite. Actually, by (26), EP0 (λ0 ) C is equal to |x| P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) e− 2 , P0 (dξ ) ξˆ (dx) c0,x (ξ )|x|γ q ≤ c for a suitable constant c. The r.h.s. can be bounded by means of Lemma 1(iv) and the same argument leading to Lemma 2. In view of (100) and (101), the proposition will be proved if we can show that the ξ ξ expectation EP0 (P˜ 0 ⊗ Q(n∗ (t) = n)) converges to zero more rapidly than n−(γ +1)p as
62
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner
n → ∞. Let us fix 0 < α < 1. We will show that, if l > 0 is such that EP0 (λl+1 0 ) < ∞, then ξ ξ EP0 P˜ 0 ⊗ Q n∗ (t) = n = O(n−αl ) .
(102)
To this end, let us first make a general observation. Let λ > 0 and let T1 , . . . , Tk be independent exponential variables on some probability space (, µ), with parameters λ1 , . . . , λk ≤ λ. Define the random variables Tj := (λj /λ)Tj , j = 1, . . . , k. These are independent identically distributed exponential variables with parameter λ. As Tj ≤ Tj , this shows that ∞ (λt)k (λt)j +k µ T1 + · · · + Tk ≤ t ≤ µ T1 + · · · + Tk ≤ t = e−λt ≤ . (j + k)! k! j =0
(103) ξ In order to proceed, for all ξ ∈ N0 , let us set Bn := x ∈ ξˆ : λx (ξ ) ≤ nα as well as Aξn :=
n ξ ˜ ξ : ∃ J ⊂ In , |J | > , X˜ ξ ∈ Bnξ ∀ j ∈ J , X˜ k )k≥0 ∈ j 2
ξ ξ where In := {0, . . . , n − 1} and |J | is the cardinality of J . We write P˜ 0 ⊗ Q n∗ (t) = n = gn (ξ ) + hn (ξ ) with
gn (ξ ) := P˜ 0 ⊗ Q ξ
ξ n∗ (t) = n ∩ Aξn ,
hn (ξ ) := P˜ 0 ⊗ Q ξ
ξ n∗ (t) = n ∩ (Aξn )c .
ξ ξ We first estimate gn . Obviously {n∗ (t) = n} is contained in { j ∈J T
j,X˜ j
ξ
≤ t}. As a
result, gn (ξ ) ≤
χ xj ∈ Bnξ ∀ j ∈ J χ xi ∈ / Bnξ ∀ i ∈ In \ J
J ⊂In ,|J |>n/2 x0 ,... ,xn−1 ∈ξˆ
ξ ξ ξ ξ P˜ 0 X˜ 0 = x0 , . . . , X˜ n−1 = xn−1 Q Tj,xj ≤ t
≤
max
k=[n/2]+1,... ,n−1
(nα t)k
k!
j ∈J
.
√ Thanks to the Stirling formula k! ∼ k k e−k 2πk as k → ∞, the last expression can be bounded by a constant times (2 e t)n/2 n−n(1−α)/2 and is thus exponentially small. We now turn to EP0 (hn ), n ≥ 1. Clearly, ξ P˜ 0
Aξn
n−1 c 2 ξ 2 ξ ≤ EP˜ ξ χ X˜ 0 ∈ / Bnξ +· · ·+χ X˜ n−1 ∈ / Bnξ = EP˜ ξ λ0 (ξm ) > nα . n 0 n m=0
Mott Law as Lower Bound for a Random Walk in a Random Environment
63
By Proposition 2 and invoking Chebyshev’s inequality, one obtains for any l > 0, c c ξ ξ ξ EP0 hn ≤ P0 (dξ )P˜ 0 ⊗ Q n∗ (t) ≥ 1 ∩ Aξn ≤ t P0 (dξ ) λ0 (ξ )P˜ 0 Aξn ≤
n−1 2t P0 (dξ ) λ0 (ξ ) EP˜ ξ λ0 (ξm ) > nα = 2t EP0 λ0 χ (λ0 > nα ) n m=0
2t ≤ αl EP0 λl+1 , 0 n where the second inequality follows from the same argument leading to (99) and the ˜ This proves (102). We may now choose equality follows from the stationarity of P. p = α −1 > 1 arbitrarily close to 1 so that γ q > 1 and such that one may take for l the smallest integer strictly greater than γ + 1. For such a choice the sum (100) converges. We can now invoke Lemma 2 to get the result. ˇ y, B. Derrida, P. A. Ferrari, D. Gabrielli, A. Acknowledgement. We would like to thank A. Bovier, J. Cern´ Ramirez and R. Siegmund-Schultze for very useful comments. The work was supported by the SFB 288, SFB/TR 12 and the Dutch-German Bilateral Research Group “Mathematics of random spatial models from physics and biology".
References [AHL]
Ambegoakar, V., Halperin, B.I., Langer, J.S.: Hopping Conductivity in Disordered Systems. Phys, Rev B 4, 2612–2620 (1971) [BRSW] Bellissard, J., Rebolledo, R., Spehner, D., von Waldenfels, W.: In preparation [BHZ] Bellissard, J., Hermann, D., Zarrouati, M.: Hull of Aperiodic Solids and Gap Labelling Theorems. In: Directions in Mathematical Quasicrystals, M.B. Baake, R.V. Moody, eds., CRM Monograph Series, Volume 13, Providence, RI: Amer. Math.Soc., (2000) 207–259 [Bil] Billingsley, P.: Convergence of Probability Measures. New York: Wiley, 1968 [BS] Bolthausen, E., Sznitman, A.-S.: Ten lectures on random media. DMV Seminar 32 Basel: Birkh¨auser, 2002 [Bre] Breiman, L.: Probability. Reading, MA: Addison–Wesley, 1953 [DV] Daley, D.J., Vere–Jones, D.: An Introduction to the Theory of Point Processes. New York: Springer, 1988 [DFGW] De Masi, A., Ferrari, P.A., Goldstein, S., Wick, W.D.: An Invariance Principle for Reversible Markov Processes. Applications to Random Motions in Random Environments. J. Stat. Phys. 55, 787–855 (1989) [EF] Efros, A.L., Shklovskii, B.I.: Coulomb gap and low temperature conductivity of disordered systems. J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 8, L49–L51 (1975) [FM] Faggionato, A., Martinelli, F.: Hydrodynamic limit of a disordered lattice gas. Probab. Theory Related Fields 127, 535–608 (2003) [FKAS] Franken, P., K¨onig, D., Arndt, U., Schmidt, V.: Queues and Point Processes. Berlin: Akadamie-Verlag, 1981 [Gri] Grimmett, G.: Percolation. Second Edition, Grundlehren 321, Berlin: Springer, 1999 [KV] Kipnis, C., Varadhan, S.R.S.: Central Limit Theorem for Additive Functionals of Reversible Markov Processes and Applications to Simple Exclusion. Commun. Math. Phys. 104, 1–19 (1986) [Kal] Kallenberg, O.: Foundations of Modern Probability. Second Edition, New York: Springer-Verlag, 2001 [KLP] Kirsch, W., Lenoble, O., Pastur, L.: On the Mott formula for the a.c. conductivity and binary correlators in the strong localization regime of disordered systems. J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 36, 12157–12180 (2003) [LB] Ladieu, F., Bouchaud, J.-P.: Conductance statistics in small GaAs:Si wires at low temperatures: I. Theoretical analysis: truncated quantum fluctuations in insulating wires. J. Phys. I France 3, 2311–2320 (1993) [Mar] Martinelli, F.: Lectures on Glauber dynamics for discrete spin models. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Vol. 1717, Berlin-Heidelberg-Newyork: Springer, 2000
64 [MKM] [MR] [MA] [Min] [Mot] [Owh] [Qua] [RS] [Ros] [SE] [Spe] [Spo] [Tho]
A. Faggionato, H. Schulz-Baldes, D. Spehner Matthes, K., Kerstan, J., Mecke, J.: Infinitely Divisible Point Processes. Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Physics, Newyork: Wiley, 1978 Meester, R., Roy, R.: Continuum Percolation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996 Miller, A., Abrahams, E.: Impurity Conduction at Low Concentrations. Phys. Rev. 120, 745– 755 (1960) Minami, N.: Local fluctuation of the spectrum of a multidimensional Anderson tight binding model. Commun. Math. Phys. 177, 709–725 (1996) Mott, N.F.: J. Non-Crystal. Solids 1, 1 (1968); N. F. Mott, Phil. Mag 19, 835 (1969); Mott, N.F., Davis, E.A.: Electronic Processes in Non-Crystaline Materials. New York: Oxford University Press, 1979 Owhadi, H.: Approximation of the effective conductivity of ergodic media by periodization. Probab. Theory Related Fields 125, 225–258, (2003) Quastel, J.: Diffusion in Disordered Media. In: Funaki, T., Woyczinky, W., eds., Proceedings on stochastic method for nonlinear P.D.E., IMA volumes in Mathematics 77, New York: Springer Verlag, 1995, pp. 65–79 Reed, M., Simon, B.: Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics I-IV. San Diego: Academic Press, 1980 Rosenblatt, M.: Markov Processes. Structure and Asymptotic Behavior. Grundlehren 184, Berlin: Springer, 1971 Shklovskii, B., Efros, A.L.: Electronic Properties of Doped Semiconductors. Berlin: Springer, 1984 Spehner, D.: Contributions a` la th´eorie du transport e´ lectronique dissipatif dans les solides ap´eriodiques. PhD Thesis, Toulouse, 2000 Spohn, H.: Large Scale Dynamics of Interacting Particles. Berlin: Springer, 1991 Thorisson, H.: Coupling, Stationarity, and Regeneration. New York: Springer, 2000
Communicated by M. Aizenman
Commun. Math. Phys. 263, 65–88 (2006) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1494-3
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group Giovanni Landi1 , Chiara Pagani2 , Cesare Reina2 1 2
Dipartimento di Matematica e Informatica, Universit`a di Trieste, Via A.Valerio 12/1, 34127 Trieste, Italy, and I.N.F.N., Sezione di Napoli, Napoli, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] S.I.S.S.A. International School for Advanced Studies, Via Beirut 2-4, 34014 Trieste, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected]
Received: 7 September 2004 / Accepted: 16 August 2005 Published online: 24 January 2006 – © Springer-Verlag 2006
Abstract: We construct a quantum version of the SU (2) Hopf bundle S 7 → S 4 . The quantum sphere Sq7 arises from the symplectic group Spq (2) and a quantum 4-sphere Sq4 is obtained via a suitable self-adjoint idempotent p whose entries generate the algebra A(Sq4 ) of polynomial functions over it. This projection determines a deformation of an (anti-)instanton bundle over the classical sphere S 4 . We compute the fundamental Khomology class of Sq4 and pair it with the class of p in the K-theory getting the value −1 for the topological charge. There is a right coaction of SUq (2) on Sq7 such that the algebra A(Sq7 ) is a non-trivial quantum principal bundle over A(Sq4 ) with structure quantum group A(SUq (2)).
Contents 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Odd Spheres from Quantum Symplectic Groups . 2.1 The quantum groups Spq (N, C) and Spq (n) 2.2 The odd symplectic spheres . . . . . . . . . 2.3 The symplectic 7-sphere Sq7 . . . . . . . . . 3. The Principal Bundle A(Sq4 ) → A(Sq7 ) . . . . . . 3.1 The quantum sphere Sq4 . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 The SUq (2)-coaction . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Representations of the Algebra A(Sq4 ) . . . . . . 4.1 The representation β . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 The representation σ . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. The Index Pairings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Quantum Principal Bundle Structure . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
66 67 67 68 70 72 73 76 79 79 79 80 82
66
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
6.1 The associated bundle and the coequivariant maps . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Classical Hopf Fibration S 7 → S 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
85 86 88
1. Introduction In this paper we study yet another example of how “quantization removes degeneracy” by constructing a new quantum version of the Hopf bundle S 7 → S 4 . This is the first outcome of our attempt to generalize to the quantum case the ADHM construction of SU (2) instantons together with their moduli spaces. The q-monopole on two dimensional quantum spheres has been constructed in [8] more than a decade ago. There the general notion of a quantum principal bundle with quantum differential calculi, from a geometrical point of view was also introduced. With universal differential calculi, this notion was later realised to be equivalent to the one of Hopf-Galois extension (see e.g. [14]). An analogous construction for q-instantons and their principal bundles has been an open problem ever since. A step in this direction was taken in [3] resulting in a bundle which is only a coalgebra extension [4]. Here we present a quantum principal instanton bundle which is a honest Hopf-Galois extension. One advantage is that non-universal calculi may be constructed on the bundle, as opposite to the case of a coalgebra bundle where there is not such a possibility. In analogy with the classical case [1], it is natural to start with the quantum version of the (compact) symplectic groups A(Spq (n)), i.e. the Hopf algebras generated by matrix j elements Ti ’s with commutation rules coming from the R matrix of the C-series [25]. These quantum groups have comodule-subalgebras A(Sq4n−1 ) yielding deformations of the algebras of polynomials over the spheres S 4n−1 , which give more examples of the general construction of quantum homogeneous spaces [8]. The relevant case for us is n = 2, i.e. the symplectic quantum 7-sphere A(Sq7 ), which is generated by the matrix elements of the first and the last column of T . Indeed, as 4 1 . A similar conjugation occurs for the elements of the middle we will see, T i ∝ T4−i columns, but contrary to what happens at q = 1, they do not generate a subalgebra. The algebra A(Sq7 ) is the quantum version of the homogeneous space Sp(2)/Sp(1) and the injection A(Sq7 ) → A(Spq (2)) is a quantum principal bundle with “structure Hopf algebra” A(Spq (1)). Most importantly, we show that Sq7 is the total space of a quantum SUq (2) principal bundle over a quantum 4-sphere Sq4 . Unlike the previous construction, this is obviously not a quantum homogeneous structure. The algebra A(Sq4 ) is constructed as the subalgebra of A(Sq7 ) generated by the matrix elements of a self-adjoint projection p which generalizes the anti-instanton of charge −1. This projection will be of the form vv ∗ with v a 4 × 2 matrix whose entries are made out of generators of A(Sq7 ). The naive generalization of the classical case produces a subalgebra with extra generators which vanish at q = 1. Luckily enough, there is just one alternative choice of v which gives the right number of generators of an algebra which deforms the algebra of polynomial functions of S 4 . At q = 1 this gives a projection which is gauge equivalent to the standard one. This good choice becomes even better because there is a natural coaction of SUq (2) on A(Sq7 ) with coinvariant algebra A(Sq4 ) and the injection A(Sq4 ) → A(Sq7 ) turns out to be a faithfully flat A(SUq (2))-Hopf-Galois extension.
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
67
Finally, we set up the stage to compute the charge of our projection and to prove the non-triviality of our principal bundle. Following a general strategy of noncommutative index theorem [10], we construct representations of the algebra A(Sq4 ) and the corresponding K-homology. The analogue of the fundamental class of S 4 is given by a non-trivial Fredholm module µ. The natural coupling between µ and the projection p is computed via the pairing of the corresponding Chern characters ch∗ (µ) ∈ H C ∗ [A(Sq4 )] and ch∗ (p) ∈ H C∗ [A(Sq4 )] in cyclic cohomology and homology respectively [10]. As expected the result of this pairing, which is an integer in principle being the index of a Fredholm operator, is actually −1 and therefore the bundle is non-trivial. Clearly the example presented in this paper is very special and limited, since it is just a particular anti-instanton of charge −1. Indeed our construction is based on the requirement that the matrix v giving the projection is linear in the generators of A(Sq7 ) and such that v ∗ v = 1. This is false even classically at generic moduli and generic charge, except for the case considered here (and for a similar construction for the case of charge 1). A more elaborate strategy is needed to tackle the general case. 2. Odd Spheres from Quantum Symplectic Groups We recall the construction of quantum spheres associated with the compact real form of the quantum symplectic groups Spq (N, C) (N = 2n), the latter being given in [25]. Later we shall specialize to the case N = 4 and the corresponding 7-sphere will provide the ‘total space’ of our quantum Hopf bundle. 2.1. The quantum groups Spq (N, C) and Spq (n). The algebra A(Spq (N, C)) is the associative noncommutative algebra generated over the ring of Laurent polynomials Cq := C[q, q −1 ] by the entries Ti j , i, j = 1, . . . , N of a matrix T which satisfy RTT equations: R T1 T2 = T2 T1 R ,
T1 = T ⊗ 1 ,
T2 = 1 ⊗ T .
In components (T ⊗ 1)ij kl = Ti k δj l . Here the relevant N 2 × N 2 matrix R is the one for the CN series and has the form [25], R=q
N
ei i ⊗ e i i +
ei i ⊗ ej j + q −1
i,j =1
i=1
+(q − q −1 )
N i=j,j
N i,j =1
i>j
ei j ⊗ ej i − (q − q −1 )
N
ei i ⊗ e i i
i=1 N
q ρi −ρj εi εj ei j ⊗ ei j ,
i,j =1
i>j
where i = N + 1 − i ; ei j ∈ Mn (C) are the elementary matrices, i.e. (ej i )kl = δj l δ ik ; εi = 1, for i = 1, . . . , n ; εi = −1, for i = n + 1, . . . , N ; (ρ1 , . . . , ρN ) = (n, n − 1, . . . , 1, −1, . . . , −n).
(1)
68
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
The symplectic group structure comes from the matrix Ci j = q ρj εi δij by imposing the additional relations T CT t C −1 = CT t C −1 T = 1. The Hopf algebra co-structures (, ε, S) of the quantum group Spq (N, C) are given by .
(T ) = T ⊗ T ,
ε(T ) = I ,
S(T ) = CT t C −1 .
In components the antipode explicitly reads
S(T )i j = −q ρi +ρj εi εj Tj i .
(2)
At q = 1 the Hopf algebra Spq (N, C) reduces to the algebra of polynomial functions over the symplectic group Sp(N, C). The compact real form A(Spq (n)) of the quantum group A(Spq (N, C)) is given by taking q ∈ R and the anti-involution [25] T = S(T )t = C t T (C −1 )t .
(3)
2.2. The odd symplectic spheres. Let us denote xi = Ti N ,
v j = S(T )N j ,
i, j = 1, . . . , N .
As we will show, these generators give subalgebras of A(Spq (N, C)). With the natural involution (3), the algebra generated by the {xi , v j } can be thought of as the algebra A(Sq4n−1 ) of polynomial functions on a quantum sphere of ‘dimension’ 4n − 1. From here on, whenever no confusion arises, the sum over repeated indexes is understood. In components the RTT equations are given by Rij kp Tk r Tp s = Tj p Ti m Rmp rs .
(4)
Hence Rij kl Tk r = Tj p Ti m Rmp rs S(T )s l , and in turn S(T )p j Rij kl = Ti a Rap rs S(T )s l S(T )r k , so that S(T )a i S(T )p j Rij kl = Rap rs S(T )s l S(T )r k .
(5)
Conversely, if we multiply Rij kp Tk r = Tj l Ti m Rml rs S(T )s p on the left by S(T ) we have S(T )l j Rij kp Tk r = Ti m Rml rs S(T )s p .
(6)
We shall use Eqs. (4), (5) and (6) to describe the algebra generated by the xi ’s and by the v i ’s.
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
69
The algebra Cq [xi ] From (4) with r = s = N we have Rij kp xk xp = Tj p Ti m Rmp NN .
(7)
Since the only element Rmp NN ∝ em N ⊗ ep N (m, p ≤ N ) which is different from zero is RNN NN = q, it follows that Rij kp xk xp = q xj xi ,
(8)
and the elements xi ’s give an algebra with commutation relations xi xj = qxj xi ,
i < j, i = j ,
xi xi = q −2 xi xi + (q −2 − 1)
i−1
q ρi −ρk εi εk xk xk ,
i < i .
(9)
k=1
The algebra Cq [v i ] Putting a = p = N in Eq. (5), we get v i v j Rij kl = RNN rs S(T )s l S(T )r k . The sum on the r.h.s. reduces to RNN NN S(T )N l S(T )N k and the v i ’s give an algebra with commutation relations v l v k Rlk j i = qv i v j .
(10)
Explicitly v i v j = q −1 v j v i , i i
i < j, i = j ,
2 i i
v v = q v v + (q − 1) 2
N
q ρk −ρi εk εi v k v k ,
i < i .
(11)
k=i +1
The algebra Cq [xi , v j ]. Finally, for l = r = N Eq. (6) reads: v j Rij kp xk = Ti m RmN Ns S(T )s p . Once more, the only term in R of the form em N ⊗ eN s (m ≤ N ) is eN N ⊗ eN N and therefore v j Rij kp xk = q xi v p .
(12)
Explicitly the mixed commutation rules for the algebra Cq [xi , v j ] read, xi v i = v i xi + (1 − q −2 )
i−1 k=1
i
v k xk + (1 − q −2 )q ρi −ρi v i xi , if i>i
i
xi v = q −2 v xi , xi v j = q −1 v j x i ,
i = j
and
i < j ,
xi v j = q −1 v j x i + (q −2 − 1)q ρi −ρj εi εj v i xj ,
i = j
and
i > j . (13)
70
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
The quantum spheres Sq4n−1 . Let us observe that with the anti-involution (3) we have the identification v i = S(T )N i = x¯ i . The subalgebra A(Sq4n−1 ) of A(Spq (n)) generated by {xi , v i = x¯ i , i = 1, . . . , 2n} is the algebra of polynomial functions on a sphere. Indeed N S(T )T = I ⇒ S(T )N i Ti N = δN = 1, i.e.
x¯ i xi = 1 .
(14)
i
Furthermore, the restriction of the comultiplication is a natural left coaction L : A(Sq4n−1 ) −→ A(Spq (n)) ⊗ A(Sq4n−1 ) . The fact that L is an algebra map then implies that A(Sq4n−1 ) is a comodule algebra over A(Spq (n)). At q = 1 this algebra reduces to the algebra of polynomial functions over the spheres S 4n−1 as homogeneous spaces of the symplectic group Sp(n): S 4n−1 = Sp(n)/Sp(n−1). 2.3. The symplectic 7-sphere Sq7 . The algebra A(Sq7 ) is generated by the elements xi = Ti 4 and x¯ i = S(T )4 i = q 2+ρi εi Ti 1 , for i = 1, . . . , 4. From S(T ) T = 1 we have the sphere relation 4i=1 x¯ i xi = 1. Since we shall systematically use them in the following, we shall explicitly give the commutation relations among the generators. From (9), the algebra of the xi ’s is given by x1 x2 = qx2 x1 , x1 x3 = qx3 x1 , x2 x4 = qx4 x2 , x3 x4 = qx4 x3 , x4 x1 = q −2 x1 x4 , x3 x2 = q −2 x2 x3 + q −2 (q −1 − q)x1 x4 ,
(15)
together with their conjugates (given in (11)). We have also the commutation relations between the xi and the x¯ j deduced from (12): x1 x¯ 1 x1 x¯ 3 x2 x¯ 2 x2 x¯ 3 x2 x¯ 4 x3 x¯ 3 x3 x¯ 4 x4 x¯ 4
= x¯ 1 x1 , x1 x¯ 2 = q −1 x¯ 2 x1 , −1 3 = q x¯ x1 , x1 x¯ 4 = q −2 x¯ 4 x1 , = x¯ 2 x2 + (1 − q −2 )x¯ 1 x1 , = q −2 x¯ 3 x2 , = q −1 x¯ 4 x2 + q −1 (q −2 − 1)x¯ 3 x1 , = x¯ 3 x3 + (1 − q −2 )[x¯ 1 x1 + (1 + q −2 )x¯ 2 x2 ] , = q −1 x¯ 4 x3 + (1 − q −2 )q −3 x¯ 2 x1 , = x¯ 4 x4 + (1 − q −2 )[(1 + q −4 )x¯ 1 x1 + x¯ 2 x2 + x¯ 3 x3 ] ,
(16)
again with their conjugates. Next we show that the algebra A(Sq7 ) can be realized as the subalgebra of A(Spq (2)) generated by the coinvariants under the right-coaction of A(Spq (1)), in complete analogy with the classical homogeneous space Sp(2)/Sp(1) S 7 .
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
71
Lemma 1. The two-sided *-ideal in A(Spq (2)) generated as Iq = {T1 1 − 1, T4 4 − 1, T1 2 , T1 3 , T1 4 , T2 1 , T2 4 , T3 1 , T3 4 , T4 1 , T4 2 , T4 3 } with the involution (3) is a Hopf ideal.
Proof. Since S(T )i j ∝ Tj i , S(Iq ) ⊆ Iq which also proves that Iq is a *-ideal. One easily shows that ε(Iq ) = 0 and (Iq ) ⊆ Iq ⊗ A(Spq (2)) + A(Spq (2)) ⊗ Iq .
Proposition 1. The Hopf algebra Bq := A(Spq (2))/Iq is isomorphic to the coordinate algebra A(SUq 2 (2)) ∼ = A(Spq (1)). Proof. Using T = S(T )t and setting T2 2 = α, T3 2 = γ , the algebra Bq can be described as the algebra generated by the entries of the matrix
1 0 T = 0 0
0 0 α −q 2 γ¯ γ α¯ 0 0
0 0 . 0 1
(17)
The commutation relations deduced from RTT equations (4) read: α γ¯ = q 2 γ¯ α , αγ = q 2 γ α , γ γ¯ = γ¯ γ , αα ¯ + γ¯ γ = 1 ; α α¯ + q 4 γ γ¯ = 1 .
(18)
Hence, as an algebra Bq is isomorphic to the algebra A(SUq 2 (2)). Furthermore, the restriction of the coproduct of A(Spq (2)) to Bq endows the latter with a coalgebra . structure, (T ) = T ⊗ T , which is the same as the one of A(SUq 2 (2)). We can conclude that also as a Hopf algebra, Bq is isomorphic to the Hopf algebra A(SUq 2 (2)) ∼ = A(Spq (1)).
Proposition 2. The algebra A(Sq7 ) ⊂ A(Spq (2)) is the algebra of coinvariants with respect to the natural right coaction .
R : A(Spq (2)) → A(Spq (2)) ⊗ A(Spq (1)) ;
.
R (T ) = T ⊗ T .
Proof. It is straightforward to show that the generators of the algebra A(Sq7 ) are coinvariants: R (xi ) = R (Ti4 ) = xi ⊗ 1 ; R (x¯ i ) = −q 2+ρi εi R (Ti1 ) = x¯ i ⊗ 1, thus the algebra A(Sq7 ) is made of coinvariants. There are no other coinvariants of degree one since each row of the submatrix of T made out of the two central columns is a fundamental comodule under the coaction of SUq 2 (2). Other coinvariants arising at higher even degree are of the form (Ti2 Ti3 − q 2 Ti3 Ti2 )n ; thanks to the commutation relations of A(Spq (2)), one checks these belong to A(Sq7 ) as well. It is an easy computation to check that similar expressions involving elements from different rows cannot be coinvariant.
72
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
The previous construction is one more example of the general construction of a quantum principal bundle over a quantum homogeneous space [8]. The latter is the datum of a Hopf quotient π : A(G) → A(K) with the right coaction of A(K) on A(G) given by the reduced coproduct R := (id ⊗ π ), where is the coproduct of A(G). The subalgebra B ⊂ A(G) made of the coinvariants with respect to R is called a quantum homogeneous space. To prove that it is a quantum principal bundle one needs some more assumptions (see Lemma 5.2 of [8]). In our case A(G) = A(Spq (2)), A(K) = A(Spq (1)) with π(T ) = T . We will prove in Sect. 6 that the resulting inclusion B = A(Sq7 ) → A(Spq (2)) is indeed a Hopf Galois extension and hence a quantum principal bundle. 3. The Principal Bundle A(Sq4 ) → A(Sq7 ) The fundamental step of this paper is to make the sphere Sq7 itself into the total space of a quantum principal bundle over a deformed 4-sphere. Unlike what we saw in the previous section, this is not a quantum homogeneous space construction and it is not obvious that such a bundle exists at all. Nonetheless the notion of quantum bundle is more general and one only needs that the total space algebra is a comodule algebra over an Hopf algebra with additional suitable properties. The notion of quantum principle bundle, as said, is encoded in the one of Hopf-Galois extension (see e.g. [8, 14]). Let us recall some relevant definitions [20] (see also [22]). Recall that we work over the field k = C. Definition 1. Let H be a Hopf algebra and P a right H -comodule algebra with multiplication m : P ⊗ P → P and coaction R : P → P ⊗ H . Let B ⊆ P be the subalgebra of coinvariants, i.e. B = {p ∈ P | R (p) = p ⊗ 1}. The extension B ⊆ P is called an H Hopf-Galois extension if the canonical map χ : P ⊗B P −→ P ⊗ H , χ := (m ⊗ id) ◦ (id ⊗B R ) ,
p ⊗B p → χ (p ⊗B p) = p p(0) ⊗ p(1) (19)
is bijective. We use Sweedler-like notation R p = p(0) ⊗ p(1) . The canonical map is left P -linear and right H -colinear and is a morphism (an isomorphism for Hopf-Galois extensions) of left P -modules and right H -comodules. It is also clear that P is both a left and a right B-module. The injectivity of the canonical map dualizes the condition of a group action X×G → X to be free: if α is the map α : X × G → X ×M X, (x, g) → (x, x · g) then α ∗ = χ with P , H the algebras of functions on X, G respectively and the action is free if and only if α is injective. Here M := X/G is the space of orbits with projection map π : X → M, π(x · g) = π(x), for all x ∈ X, g ∈ G. Furthermore, α is surjective if and only if for all x ∈ X, the fibre π −1 (π(x)) of π(x) is equal to the residue class x · G, that is, if and only if G acts transitively on the fibres of π . In differential geometry a principle bundle is more than just a free and effective action of a Lie group. In our example, thanks to the fact that the “structure group” is SUq (2), from Th. I of [28] further nice properties can be established. We shall elaborate more on these points later on in Sect. 6 . The first natural step would be to construct a map from Sq7 into a deformation of the Stieffel variety of unitary frames of 2-planes in C4 to parallel the classical construction
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
73
as recalled in Appendix A. The naive choice we have is to take as generators the elements of two (conjugate) columns of the matrix T . We are actually forced to take the first and the last columns of the matrix T because the other choice (i.e. the second and the third columns) does not yield a subalgebra since commutation relations of their elements will involve elements from the other two columns. If we set x1 x¯ 4 q −1 x¯ 3 x2 v= (20) −q −3 x¯ 2 x3 , −4 1 −q x¯ x4 we have v ∗ v = I2 and the matrix p = v v ∗ is a self-adjoint idempotent, i.e. p = p ∗ = p2 . At q = 1 the entries of p are invariant for the natural action of SU (2) on S 7 and generate the algebra of polynomials on S 4 . This fails to be the case at generic q due to the occurrence of extra generators, e.g. p14 = (1 − q −2 )x1 x¯ 4 ,
p23 = (1 − q −2 )x2 x¯ 3 ,
(21)
which vanish at q = 1. 3.1. The quantum sphere Sq4 . These facts indicate that the naive quantum analogue of the quaternionic projective line as a homogeneous space of Spq (2) has not the right number of generators. Rather surprisingly, we shall anyhow be able to select another subalgebra of A(Sq7 ) which is a deformation of the algebra of polynomials on S 4 having the same number of generators. These generators come from a better choice of a projection. On the free module E := C4 ⊗ A(Sq7 ) we consider the hermitian structure given by h(|ξ1 , |ξ2 ) =
4
j j ξ¯1 ξ2 .
j =1
To every element |ξ ∈ E one associates an element ξ | in the dual module E ∗ by the pairing ξ | (|η) := ξ |η = h(|ξ , |η). Guided by the classical construction which we present in Appendix A, we shall look for two elements |φ1 , |φ2 in E with the property that φ1 |φ1 = 1 ,
φ2 |φ2 = 1 ,
φ1 |φ2 = 0 .
As a consequence, the matrix valued function defined by p := |φ1 φ1 | + |φ2 φ2 | ,
(22)
is a self-adjoint idempotent (a projection). In principle, p ∈ Mat4 (A(Sq7 )), but we can choose |φ1 , |φ2 in such a way that the entries of p will generate a subalgebra A(Sq4 ) of A(Sq7 ) which is a deformation of the algebra of polynomial functions on the 4-sphere S 4 . The two elements |φ1 , |φ2 will be obtained in two steps as follows.
74
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
i Firstly we write the relation 1 = x¯ xi in terms of the quadratic elements x¯ 1 x1 , 2 3 4 x2 x¯ , x¯ x3 , x4 x¯ by using the commutation relations of Sect. 2.3. We have that 1 = q −6 x¯ 1 x1 + q −2 x2 x¯ 2 + q −2 x¯ 3 x3 + x4 x¯ 4 . Then we take, |φ1 = (q −3 x1 , −q −1 x¯ 2 , q −1 x3 , −x¯ 4 )t ,
(23)
(t denoting transposition) which is such that φ1 |φ1 = 1. Next, we write 1 = x¯ i xi as a function of the quadratic elements x1 x¯ 1 , x¯ 2 x2 , x3 x¯ 3 , x¯ 4 x4 : 1 = q −2 x1 x¯ 1 + q −4 x¯ 2 x2 + x3 x¯ 3 + x¯ 4 x4 . By taking, |φ2 = (±q −2 x2 , ±q −1 x¯ 1 , ±x4 , ±x¯ 3 )t we get φ2 |φ2 = 1. The signs will be chosen in order to have also the orthogonality φ1 |φ2 = 0; for |φ2 = (q −2 x2 , q −1 x¯ 1 , −x4 , −x¯ 3 )t this is satisfied. The matrix
q −3 x1 −q −1 x¯ 2 v = (|φ1 , |φ2 ) = q −1 x3 −x¯ 4
q −2 x2 q −1 x¯ 1 . −x4 −x¯ 3
(24)
(25)
is such that v ∗ v = 1 and hence p = vv ∗ is a self-adjoint projection. Proposition 3. The entries of the projection p = vv ∗ , with v given in (25), generate a subalgebra of A(Sq7 ) which is a deformation of the algebra of polynomial functions on the 4-sphere S 4 . Proof. Let us compute explicitly the components of the projection p and their commutation relations. 1. The diagonal elements are given by p11 = q −6 x1 x¯ 1 + q −4 x2 x¯ 2 , p22 = q −2 x¯ 2 x2 + q −2 x¯ 1 x1 , p33 = q −2 x3 x¯ 3 + x4 x¯ 4 , p44 = x¯ 4 x4 + x¯ 3 x3 , and satisfy the relation q −2 p11 + q 2 p22 + p33 + p44 = 2 .
(26)
Only one of the pii ’s is independent; indeed by using the commutation relations and the equation x¯ i xi = 1, we can rewrite the pii ’s in terms of t := p22 , as p11 = q −2 t , p22 = t , p33 = 1 − q −4 t , p44 = 1 − q 2 t . Equation (26) is easily verified. Notice that t is self-adjoint: t¯ = t.
(27)
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
75
2. As in the classical case, the elements p12 , p34 (and their conjugates) vanish: p12 = −q −4 x1 x2 + q −3 x2 x1 = 0 ,
p34 = −q −1 x3 x4 + x4 x3 = 0 .
3. The remaining elements are given by p13 = q −4 x1 x¯ 3 − q −2 x2 x¯ 4 , p23 = −q −2 x¯ 2 x¯ 3 − q −1 x¯ 1 x¯ 4 ,
p14 = −q −3 x1 x4 − q −2 x2 x3 , p24 = q −1 x¯ 2 x4 − q −1 x¯ 1 x3 ,
with pj i = p¯ ij when j > i. By using the commutation relations of A(Sq7 ), one finds that only two of these are independent. We take them to be p13 and p14 ; one finds p23 = q −2 p¯ 14 and p24 = −q 2 p¯ 13 . Finally, we also have the sphere relation, 2 2 2 (q 6 − q 8 )p11 + p22 + p44 + q 4 (p13 p31 + p14 p41 ) + q 2 (p24 p42 + p23 p32 ) 2
= x¯ i xi = 1 .
(28)
Summing up, together with t = p22 , we set a := p13 and b := p14 . Then the projection p takes the following form −2 q t0 a b −q 2 a¯ t q −2 b¯ 0 p= (29) . q −2 b 1 − q −4 t 0 a¯ 1 − q 2t b¯ −q 2 a 0 By construction p∗ = p and this means that t¯ = t, as observed, and that a, ¯ b¯ are con2 jugate to a, b respectively. Also, by construction p = p; this property gives the easiest way to compute the commutation relations between the generators. One finds, ab = q 4 ba , ab ¯ = ba¯ , ta = q −2 at , tb = q 4 bt ,
(30)
together with their conjugates, and sphere relations a a¯ + bb¯ = q −2 t (1 − q −2 t) , ¯ = (1 − q −4 )t 2 . bb¯ − q −4 bb
¯ = t (1 − t) , q 4 aa ¯ + q −4 bb
It is straightforward to check also the relation (28).
(31)
¯ t ¯ b, b, We define the algebra A(Sq4 ) to be the algebra generated by the elements a, a, with the commutation relations (30) and (31). For q = 1 it reduces to the algebra of polynomial functions on the sphere S 4 . Otherwise, we can limit ourselves to |q| < 1, because the map q → q −1 , yields an isomorphic algebra.
a → q 2 a, ¯
¯ b → q −2 b,
t → q −2 t
76
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
At q = 1, the projection p in (29) is conjugate to the classical one given in Appendix A by the matrix diag[1, −1, 1, 1] (up to a renaming of the generators). Our sphere Sq4 seems to be different from the one constructed in [3]. Two of our generators commute and most importantly, it does not come from a deformation of a subgroup (let alone coisotropic) of Sp(2). However, at the continuous level these two quantum spheres are the same since the C ∗ -algebra completion of both polynomial algebras is the minimal unitization K ⊕ CI of the compact operators on an infinite dimensional separable Hilbert space, a property shared with Podle´s standard sphere as well [24]. This fact will be derived in Sect. 4 when we study the representations of the algebra A(Sq4 ). 3.2. The SUq (2)-coaction. We now give a coaction of the quantum group SUq (2) on the sphere Sq7 . This coaction will be used later in Sect. 6 when analyzing the quantum principle bundle structure. Let us observe that the two pairs of generators (x1 , x2 ), (x3 , x4 ) both yield a quantum plane, x1 x2 = qx2 x1 , x3 x4 = qx4 x3 ,
x¯ 1 x¯ 2 = q −1 x¯ 2 x¯ 1 , x¯ 3 x¯ 4 = q −1 x¯ 4 x¯ 3 .
Then we shall look for a right-coaction of SUq (2) on the rows of the matrix v in (25). Other pairs of generators yield quantum planes but the only choice which gives a projection with the right number of generators is the one given above. The defining matrix of the quantum group SUq (2) reads α −q γ¯ (32) γ α¯ with commutation relations [30], αγ = qγ α , α γ¯ = q γ¯ α , α α¯ + q 2 γ¯ γ = 1 , αα ¯ + γ¯ γ = 1 .
γ γ¯ = γ¯ γ ,
We define a coaction of SUq (2) on the matrix (25) by, −3 q x1 q −2 x2 −q −1 x¯ 2 q −1 x¯ 1 . α −q γ¯ ⊗ δR (v) := . q −1 x3 −x4 γ α¯ −x¯ 4 −x¯ 3
(33)
(34)
We shall prove presently that this coaction comes from a coaction of A(SUq (2)) on the sphere algebra A(Sq7 ). For the moment we remark that, by its form in (34) the entries of the projection p = vv ∗ are automatically coinvariants, a fact that we shall also prove explicitly in the following. On the generators, the coaction (34) is given explicitly by δR (x1 ) = x1 ⊗ α + q x2 ⊗ γ δR (x2 ) = −x1 ⊗ γ¯ + x2 ⊗ α¯ δR (x3 ) = x3 ⊗ α − q x4 ⊗ γ δR (x4 ) = x3 ⊗ γ¯ + x4 ⊗ α¯ ,
, δR (x¯ 1 ) = q x¯ 2 ⊗ γ¯ + x¯ 1 ⊗ α¯ = δR (x1 ) , , δR (x¯ 2 ) = x¯ 2 ⊗ α − x¯ 1 ⊗ γ = δR (x2 ) , , δR (x¯ 3 ) = −q x¯ 4 ⊗ γ¯ + x¯ 3 ⊗ α¯ = δR (x3 ) , δR (x¯ 4 ) = x¯ 4 ⊗ α + x¯ 3 ⊗ γ = δR (x4 ),
(35)
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
77
from which it is also clear its compatibility with the anti-involution, i.e. δR (x¯ i ) = δR (xi ). The map δR in (35) extends as an algebra homomorphism to the whole of A(Sq7 ). Then, as alluded to before, we have the following Proposition 4. The coaction (35) is a right coaction of the quantum group SUq (2) on the 7-sphere Sq7 , δR : A(Sq7 ) −→ A(Sq7 ) ⊗ A(SUq (2)) .
(36)
Proof. By using the commutation relations of A(SUq (2)) in (33), a lengthy but easy computation gives that the commutation relations of A(Sq7 ) are preserved. This fact also shows that extending δR as an algebra homomorphism yields a consistent coaction.
Proposition 5. The algebra A(Sq4 ) is the algebra of coinvariants under the coaction defined in (35). Proof. We have to show that A(Sq4 ) = {f ∈ A(Sq7 ) | δR (f ) = f ⊗ 1}. By using the commutation relations of A(Sq7 ) and those of A(SUq (2)), we first prove explicitly that the generators of A(Sq4 ) are coinvariants: δR (a) = q −4 δR (x1 )δR (x¯ 3 ) − q −2 δR (x2 )δR (x¯ 4 ) = q −4 x1 x¯ 3 ⊗ (α α¯ + q 2 γ¯ γ ) − q −2 x2 x¯ 4 ⊗ (γ γ¯ + αα) ¯ = (q −4 x1 x¯ 3 − q −2 x2 x¯ 4 ) ⊗ 1 = a ⊗ 1, δR (b) = −q −3 δR (x1 )δR (x4 ) − q −2 δR (x2 )δR (x3 ) = −q −3 x1 x4 ⊗ (α α¯ + q 2 γ¯ γ ) − q −2 x2 x3 ⊗ (γ γ¯ + αα) ¯ = −(q −3 x1 x4 + q −2 x2 x3 ) ⊗ 1 = b ⊗ 1, δR (t) = q −2 δR (x¯ 2 )δR (x2 ) + q −2 δR (x¯ 1 )δR (x1 ) = q −2 x¯ 2 x2 ⊗ (α α¯ + q 2 γ¯ γ ) + q −2 x¯ 1 x1 ⊗ (γ γ¯ + αα) ¯ −2 2 −2 1 = (q x¯ x2 + q x¯ x1 ) ⊗ 1 = t ⊗ 1. By construction the coaction is compatible with the anti-involution so that ¯ = δR (b) = b¯ ⊗ 1. ¯ = δR (a) = a¯ ⊗ 1, δR (b) δR (a) In fact, this only shows that A(Sq4 ) is made of coinvariants but does not rule out the possibility of other coinvariants not in A(Sq4 ). However this does not happen for the following reason. From Eq. (35) it is clear that w1 ∈ {x1 , x3 , x¯ 2 , x¯ 4 } (respectively w−1 ∈ {x2 , x4 , x¯ 1 , x¯ 3 }) are weight vectors of weight 1 (resp. −1) in the fundamental comodule of SUq (2). It follows that the only possible coinvariants are of the form (w1 w−1 − qw−1 w1 )n . When n = 1 these are just the generators of A(Sq4 ).
Remark 1. The last part of the proof above is also related to the quantum Pl¨ucker coordinates. For every 2 × 2 matrix of (25), let us define the determinant by det
a11 a12 a21 a22
:= a11 a22 − q a12 a21 .
(37)
78
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
(Note that a12 , a21 do not commute and so in the previous formula the ordering between them is fixed.) Let mij be the minors of (25) obtained by considering the i, j rows. Then m12 = q 2 p11 = t , m13 = p14 = b , m14 = −q p13 = −q a , m23 = p24 = −q 2 a¯ , m24 = −q p23 = −q −1 b¯ , m34 = −q p33 = q −3 t − q .
(38)
At q = 1, these give the classical Pl¨ucker coordinates [1]. The right coaction of SUq (2) on the 7-sphere Sq7 can be written as α −γ¯ 0 . qγ α ¯ 0 δR (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ) = (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ) ⊗ 0 0 α 0 0 −qγ
0 0 , γ¯ α¯
(39)
together with δR (x¯i ) = δR (xi ). In the block-diagonal matrix which appears in (39) the second copy is given by SUq (2) while the first one is twisted as α −γ¯ 1 0 α γ¯ 1 0 = . qγ α¯ 0 −1 −qγ α¯ 0 −1 A similar phenomenon occurs in [3]. Remark 2. It is also interesting to observe that δR (v ∗ v) = v ∗ v ⊗ 1 = 1 ⊗ 1 . Indeed, δR (φ1 |φ1 ) = δR (q −6 x¯ 1 x1 + q −2 x2 x¯ 2 + q −2 x¯ 3 x3 + x4 x¯ 4 ) = (−q −5 x¯ 2 x1 + q −2 x1 x¯ 2 + q −1 x¯ 4 x3 − x3 x¯ 4 ) ⊗ γ¯ α +(q −4 x¯ 2 x2 + q −2 x1 x¯ 1 + x¯ 4 x4 + x3 x¯ 3 ) ⊗ γ¯ γ +(q −6 x¯ 1 x1 + q −2 x2 x¯ 2 + q −2 x¯ 3 x3 + x4 x¯ 4 ) ⊗ αα ¯ ¯ +(−q −5 x¯ 1 x2 + q −2 x2 x¯ 1 + q −1 x¯ 3 x4 − x4 x¯ 3 ) ⊗ αγ = φ2 |φ1 ⊗ γ¯ α + φ2 |φ2 ⊗ γ¯ γ + φ1 |φ1 ⊗ αα ¯ + φ1 |φ2 ⊗ αγ ¯ = 1 ⊗ (γ¯ γ + αα) ¯ =1⊗1, δR (φ2 |φ2 ) = δR (q −2 x1 x¯ 1 + q −4 x¯ 2 x2 + x3 x¯ 3 + x¯ 4 x4 ) = (q −4 x¯ 2 x1 − q −1 x1 x¯ 2 − x¯ 4 x3 + qx3 x¯ 4 ) ⊗ α γ¯ +(q −4 x¯ 2 x2 + q −2 x1 x¯ 1 + x¯ 4 x4 + x3 x¯ 3 ) ⊗ α α¯ +(q −4 x¯ 1 x1 + x2 x¯ 2 + x¯ 3 x3 + q 2 x4 x¯ 4 ) ⊗ γ γ¯ +(q −4 x¯ 1 x2 − q −1 x2 x¯ 1 − x¯ 3 x4 + qx4 x¯ 3 ) ⊗ γ α¯ 2 φ1 |φ1 ⊗ γ γ¯ −q φ1 |φ2 ⊗ γ α¯ = −q φ2 |φ1 ⊗ α γ¯ +φ2 |φ2 ⊗ α α+q ¯ 2 = 1 ⊗ (α α¯ + q γ γ¯ ) = 1 ⊗ 1 , δR (φ1 |φ2 ) = q −5 δR (x¯ 1 )δR (x2 ) − q −2 δR (x2 )δR (x¯ 1 ) −q −1 δR (x¯ 3 )δR (x4 ) + δR (x4 )δR (x¯ 3 ) = 0, since δR defines a coaction on Sq7 and so preserves its commutation relations.
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
79
4. Representations of the Algebra A(Sq4 ) Let us now construct irreducible ∗-representations of A(Sq4 ) as bounded operators on a separable Hilbert space H. For the moment, we denote in the same way the elements of the algebra and their images as operators in the given representation. As mentioned before, since q → q −1 gives an isomorphic algebra, we can restrict ourselves to |q| < 1. We will consider the representations which are t-finite [19], i.e. such that the eigenvectors of t span H. Since the self-adjoint operator t must be bounded due to the spherical relations, from ¯ it follows that the spectrum should the commutation relations ta = q −2 at, t b¯ = q −4 bt, 2k ¯ be of the form λq and a, b (resp. a, ¯ b) act as rising (resp. lowering) operators on the eigenvectors of t. Then boundedness implies the existence of a highest weight vector, i.e. there exists a vector |0, 0 such that t |0, 0 = t00 |0, 0 , a |0, 0 = 0, b¯ |0, 0 = 0 . By evaluating
q 4 aa ¯
+ bb¯ =
(1 − q −4 t)t
(40)
on |0, 0 we have
(1 − q −4 t00 )t00 = 0. According to the values of the eigenvalue t00 we have two representations. 4.1. The representation β. The first representation, that we call β, is obtained for t00 = 0. Then, t |0, 0 = 0 implies t = 0. Moreover, using the commutation relations (30) and (31), it follows that this representation is the trivial one t = 0, a = 0, b = 0 ,
(41)
the representation Hilbert space being just C; of course, β(1) = 1. 4.2. The representation σ . The second representation, that we call σ, is obtained for t00 = q 4 . This is infinite dimensional. We take the set |m, n = Nmn a¯ m bn |0, 0 with n, m ∈ N, to be an orthonormal basis of the representation Hilbert space H, with N00 = 1 and Nmn ∈ R the normalizations, to be computed below. Then t |m, n = tmn |m, n , a¯ |m, n = amn |m + 1, n , b |m, n = bmn |m, n + 1 . By requiring that we have a ∗-representation we have also that a |m, n = am−1,n |m − 1, n , b¯ |m, n = bm,n−1 |m, n − 1 , with the following recursion relations: am,n±1 = q ±2 am,n ,
bm±1,n = q ±2 bm,n ,
bm,n = q 2 a2n+1,m .
By explicit computation, we find tm,n = q 2m+4n+4 , 1 −1 am,n = Nmn Nm+1,n = (1 − q 2m+2 ) 2 q m+2n+1 ,
−1 = (1 − q 4n+4 ) 2 q 2(m+n+2) . bm,n = Nmn Nm,n+1 1
(42)
80
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
In conclusion we have the following action: t |m, n = q 2m+4n+4 |m, n , a¯ |m, n = (1 − q
2m+2
1 2
) q
(43)
m+2n+1
|m + 1, n ,
1 2
a |m, n = (1 − q 2m ) q m+2n |m − 1, n , 1
b |m, n = (1 − q 4n+4 ) 2 q 2(m+n+2) |m, n + 1 , b¯ |m, n = (1 − q 4n ) 2 q 2(m+n+1) |m, n − 1 . 1
It is straightforward to check that all the defining relations (30) and (31) are satisfied. In this representation the algebra generators are all trace class: Tr(t) = q 4
m
Tr(|a|) = q
q 2m
q 4n =
n
1 (1 − q 2m+2 ) 2 q m+2n = m,n
≤
q4 (1 − q 2 )(1 − q 4 )
,
1 q (1 − q 2m+2 ) 2 q m 1 − q2 m
q m q q = , 1 − q2 m (1 − q)(1 − q 2 )
Tr(|b|) = q 4
1
(1 − q 4n+4 ) 2 q 2(n+m) =
m,n
(44)
1 q4 (1 − q 4n+4 ) 2 q 2n 1 − q2 n
q 4 2n q4 ≤ q = . 1 − q2 n (1 − q 2 )2 From the sequence of Schatten ideals in the algebra of compact operators one know [29] that the norm closure of trace class operators gives the ideal of compact operators K. As a consequence, the closure of A(Sq4 ) is the C ∗ -algebra C(Sq4 ) = K ⊕ CI. 5. The Index Pairings The ‘defining’ self-adjoint idempotent p in (29) determines a class in the K-theory of Sq4 , i.e. [p] ∈ K0 [C(Sq4 )]. A way to prove its nontriviality is by pairing it with a nontrivial element in the dual K-homology, i.e. with (the class of) a nontrivial Fredholm module [µ] ∈ K 0 [C(Sq4 )]. In fact, in order to compute the pairing of K-theory with K-homology, it is more convenient to first compute the corresponding Chern characters in the cyclic homology ch∗ (p) ∈ H C∗ [A(Sq4 )] and cyclic cohomology ch∗ (µ) ∈ H C ∗ [A(Sq4 )] respectively, and then use the pairing between cyclic homology and cohomology [10]. Like it happens for the q-monopole [14], to compute the pairing and to prove the nontriviality of the bundle it is enough to consider H C0 [A(Sq4 )] and dually to take a suitable trace of the projector. The Chern character of the projection p in (29) has a component in degree zero ch0 (p) ∈ H C0 [A(Sq4 )] simply given by the matrix trace, ch0 (p) := tr(p) = 2 − q −4 (1 − q 2 )(1 − q 4 ) t ∈ A(Sq4 ).
(45)
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
81
The higher degree parts of ch∗ (p) are obtained via the periodicity operator S; not needing them here we shall not dwell more upon this point and refer to [10] for the relevant details. As mentioned, the K-homology of an involutive algebra A is given in terms of homotopy classes of Fredholm modules. In the present situation we are dealing with a 1-summable Fredholm module [µ] ∈ K 0 [C(Sq4 )]. This is in contrast to the fact that the analogous element of K0 (S 4 ) for the undeformed sphere is given by a 4-summable Fredholm module, being the fundamental class of S 4 . The Fredholm module µ := (H, , γ ) is constructed as follows. The Hilbert space is H = Hσ ⊕ Hσ and the representation is = σ ⊕ β. Here σ is the representation of A(Sq4 ) introduced in (43) and β given in (41) is trivially extended to Hσ . The grading operator is 1 0 γ = . 0 −1 The corresponding Chern character ch∗ (µ) of the class of this Fredholm module has a component in degree 0, ch0 (µ) ∈ H C 0 [A(Sq2n )]. From the general construction [10], the element ch0 (µev ) is the trace τ 1 (x) := Tr (γ (x)) = Tr (σ (x) − β(x)) .
(46)
The operator σ (x) − β(x) is always trace class. Obviously τ 1 (1) = 0. The higher degree parts of ch∗ (µev ) can again be obtained via a periodicity operator. A similar construction of the class [µ] and the corresponding Chern character were given in [21] for quantum two and three dimensional spheres. We are ready to compute the pairing: [µ], [p] := ch0 (µ), ch0 (p) = −q −4 (1 − q 2 )(1 − q 4 ) τ 1 (t) = −q −4 (1 − q 2 )(1 − q 4 ) Tr(t) = −q −4 (1 − q 2 )(1 − q 4 )q 4 (1 − q 2 )−1 (1 − q 4 )−1 = −1 .
(47)
This result shows also that the right A(Sq4 )-module p[A(Sq4 )4 ] is not free. Indeed, any free module is represented in K0 [C(Sq4 )] by the idempotent 1, and since [µ], [1] = 0, the evaluation of [µ] on any free module always gives zero. We can extract the ‘trivial’ element in the K-homology K 0 [C(Sq4 )] of the quantum sphere Sq4 and use it to measure the ‘rank’ of the idempotent p. This generator corresponds to the trivial generator of the K-homology K0 (S 4 ) of the classical sphere S 4 . The latter (classical) generator is the image of the generator of the K-homology of a point by the functorial map K∗ (ι) : K0 (∗) → K0 (S N ), where ι : ∗ → S N is the inclusion of a point into the sphere. Now, the quantum sphere Sq4 has just one ‘classical point’, i.e. the 1-dimensional representation β constructed in Sect. 4.1. The corresponding 1summable Fredholm module [ε] ∈ K 0 [C(Sq4 )] is easily described: the Hilbert space is C with representation β; the grading operator is γ = 1. Then the degree 0 component ch0 (ε) ∈ H C 0 [A(Sq2n )] of the corresponding Chern character is the trace given by the representation itself (since it is a homomorphism to a commutative algebra), τ 0 (x) = β(x) ,
(48)
82
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
and vanishes on all the generators whereas τ 0 (1) = 1. Not surprisingly, the pairing with the class of the idempotent p is [ε], [p] := τ 0 (ch0 (p)) = β(2) = 2 .
(49)
6. Quantum Principal Bundle Structure Recall that if H is a Hopf algebra and P a right H -comodule algebra with multiplication m : P ⊗ P → P and coaction R : P → P ⊗ H and B ⊆ P is the subalgebra of coinvariants, the extension B ⊆ P is H Hopf-Galois if the canonical map χ : P ⊗B P −→ P ⊗ H , p ⊗B p → χ (p ⊗B p) = p p(0) ⊗ p(1) ,
(50)
is bijective. As mentioned, for us a quantum principle bundle will be the same as a Hopf-Galois extension. For quantum structure groups which are cosemisimple and have bijective antipodes, as is the case for SUq (2), Th. I of [28] grants further nice properties. In particular the surjectivity of the canonical map implies bijectivity and faithfully flatness of the extension. Moreover, an additional useful result [26] is that the map χ is surjective whenever, for any generator h of H , the element 1 ⊗ h is in its image. This follows from the left P -linearity -colinearity of the map χ . Indeed, and right H let h, k be two elements of H and pi ⊗ pi , qj ⊗ qj ∈ P ⊗ P be such that χ( pi ⊗B pi ) = 1 ⊗ h, χ ( qj ⊗B qj ) = 1 ⊗ k. Then χ ( pi qj ⊗B qj pi ) = 1 ⊗ kh, that is 1 ⊗ kh is in the image of χ. But, since the map χ is left P -linear, this implies its surjectivity. Definition 2. Let P be a bimodule over the ring B. any Given two elements |ξ1 and |ξ2 . m in the free module E = C ⊗ P , we shall define ξ1 ⊗B ξ2 ∈ P ⊗B P by
.
ξ1 ⊗B ξ2 :=
m
j j ξ¯1 ⊗B ξ2 .
(51)
j =1
. Analogously, one can define quantities ξ1 ⊗ ξ2 ∈ P ⊗ P with the same formula as above and tensor products taken over the ground field C. Proposition 6. The extension A(Sq7 ) ⊂ A(Spq (2)) is a faithfully flat A(Spq (1))-HopfGalois extension. Proof. Now P = A(Spq (2)), H = A(Spq (1)) and B = A(Sq7 ) and the coaction R of H is given just before Prop. 2. Since A(Spq (1)) A(SUq 2 (2)) has a bijective antipode and is cosemisimple ([19], Chap. 11), from the general considerations given above in order to show the bijectivity of the canonical map χ : A(Spq (2)) ⊗A(Sq7 ) A(Spq (2)) −→ A(Spq (2)) ⊗ A(Spq (1)) , it is enough ¯ γ¯ of A(Spq (1)) in (17) are in its image. to show that all generators α, γ , α, Let T 2 , T 3 be the second and third columns of the defining matrix T of Spq (2). We shall think of them as elements of the free module C4 ⊗ A(Spq (2)). Obviously,
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
83
T i |T j = δ ij . Recalling that A(Spq (2)) is both a left and right A(Sq7 )-module and using Def. 2, we have that . . T 2 ⊗A(Sq7 ) T 2 T 2 ⊗A(Sq7 ) T 3 α −q 2 γ¯ . . χ = 1 ⊗ . . 3 2 3 3 γ α ¯ T ⊗A(Sq7 ) T T ⊗A(Sq7 ) T
Indeed,
. 2 χ ( T 2 ⊗A(Sq7 ) T 2 ) = T i R Ti2 = T 2 |T 2 ⊗ α + T 2 |T 3 ⊗ γ = 1 ⊗ α , . 3 χ ( T 3 ⊗A(Sq7 ) T 2 ) = T i R Ti2 = T 3 |T 2 ⊗ α + T 3 |T 3 ⊗ γ = 1 ⊗ γ ;
a similar computation giving the other two generators. Proposition 7. extension.
The extension A(Sq4 )
⊂
A(Sq7 ) is a faithfully flat A(SUq (2))-Hopf-Galois
Proof. Now P = A(Sq7 ), H = A(SUq (2)) and B = A(Sq4 ) and the coaction δR of H is given in Prop. 4. As already mentioned A(SUq (2)) has a bijective antipode and is cosemisimple, then as before in order to show the bijectivity of the canonical map χ : A(Sq7 ) ⊗A(Sq4 ) A(Sq7 ) −→ A(Sq7 ) ⊗ A(SUq (2)) , we have to show that all generators α, γ , α, ¯ γ¯ of A(SUq (2)) in (32) are in its image. Recalling that A(Sq7 ) is both a left and right A(Sq4 )-module and using Def. 2, we have that . . φ1 ⊗A(Sq4 ) φ1 φ1 ⊗A(Sq4 ) φ2 α −q γ¯ . , χ = 1 ⊗ . . γ α ¯ φ2 ⊗A(Sq4 ) φ1 φ2 ⊗A(Sq4 ) φ2 where |φ1 , |φ2 are the two vectors introduced in Eqs. (23) and (24). Indeed
. χ ( φ1 ⊗A(Sq4 ) φ1 ) = χ q −6 x¯ 1 ⊗A(Sq4 ) x1 + q −2 x2 ⊗A(Sq4 ) x¯ 2 +q −2 x¯ 3 ⊗A(Sq4 ) x3 + x4 ⊗A(Sq4 ) x¯ 4 = q −6 x¯ 1 δR (x1 ) + q −2 x2 δR (x¯ 2 ) + q −2 x¯ 3 δR (x3 ) + x4 δR (x¯ 4 ) = q −6 x¯ 1 x1 ⊗ α + q −5 x¯ 1 x2 ⊗ γ + q −2 x2 x¯ 2 ⊗ α − q −2 x2 x¯ 1 ⊗ γ +q −2 x¯ 3 x3 ⊗ α − q −1 x¯ 3 x4 ⊗ γ + x4 x¯ 4 ⊗ α + x4 x¯ 3 ⊗ γ = φ1 |φ1 ⊗ α = 1 ⊗ α ,
. χ( φ2 ⊗A(Sq4 ) φ1 ) = q −5 x¯ 2 δR (x1 ) − q −2 x1 δR (x¯ 2 ) − q −1 x¯ 4 δR (x3 ) + x3 δR (x¯ 4 )
= q −5 x¯ 2 x1 ⊗ α + q −4 x¯ 2 x2 ⊗ γ − q −2 x1 x¯ 2 ⊗ α + q −2 x1 x¯ 1 ⊗ γ −q −1 x¯ 4 x3 ⊗ α + x¯ 4 x4 ⊗ γ + x3 x¯ 4 ⊗ α + x3 x¯ 3 ⊗ γ = φ2 |φ1 ⊗ α + φ2 |φ2 ⊗ γ = 1 ⊗ γ , with similar computations for the other generators.
84
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
It was proven in [4] that the bundle constructed in [3] is a coalgebra Galois extension [9, 6]. The fact that our bundle A(Sq4 ) ⊂ A(Sq7 ) is Hopf-Galois shows also that these two bundles cannot be the same. On our extension A(Sq4 ) ⊂ A(Sq7 ) there is a strong connection. Indeed a H -HopfGalois extension B ⊆ P for which H is cosemisimple and has a bijective antipode is also equivariantly projective, that is there exists a left B-linear right H -colinear splitting s : P → B ⊗ P of the multiplication map m : B ⊗ P → P , m ◦ s = idP [27]. Such a map characterizes the so-called strong connection. Constructing a strong connection is an alternative way to prove that one has a Hopf Galois extension [12, 13]. In particular, if H has an invertible antipode S, an equivalent description of a strong connection can be given in terms of a map : H → P ⊗ P satisfying a list of conditions [17, 7] (see also [15, 5]). We denote by the coproduct on H with Sweedler notation (h) = h(1) ⊗ h(2) , by δ : P → P ⊗ H the right-comodule structure on P with notation δp = p(0) ⊗ p(1) , and δl : P → H ⊗ P is the induced left H -comodule structure of P defined by δl (p) = S −1 (p(1) ) ⊗ p(0) . Then, for the map one requires that (1) = 1 ⊗ 1 and that for all h ∈ H , χ ((h)) = 1 ⊗ h , (h(1) ) ⊗ h(2) = (id ⊗ δ) ◦ (h) , h(1) ⊗ (h(2) ) = (δl ⊗ id) ◦ (h).
(52)
The splitting s of the multiplication map is then given by s :P →B ⊗P ,
p → p(0) (p(1) ) .
Now, if g, h ∈ H are such that (g) = g 1 ⊗ g 2 and (h) = h1 ⊗ h2 satisfy condition (52) so does (gh) defined by (gh) := h1 g 1 ⊗ g 2 h2 .
(53)
If H has a PBW basis [18], this fact can be used to iteratively construct once one knows its value on the generators of H . For H = A(SUq (2)), with generators, α, γ , α¯ and γ¯ , the PBW basis is given by α k γ l γ¯ m , with k, l, m ∈ {0, 1, 2, . . . } and γ k γ¯ l α¯ m , with k, l ∈ {0, 1, 2, . . . } and m ∈ {1, 2, . . . } [30]. Then, for our extension A(Sq4 ) ⊂ A(Sq7 ) the map can be constructed as follows. Firstly, we put (1) = 1 ⊗ 1. Then, on the generators we set . . (α) := φ1 ⊗ φ1 , (α) ¯ := φ2 ⊗ φ2 , . . (γ ) := φ2 ⊗ φ1 , (γ¯ ) := −q −1 φ1 ⊗ φ2 . These expressions for satisfy all the properties (52): Firstly, χ ((α)) = 1 ⊗ α follows from the proof of Prop. 7. Then, (id ⊗ δ) ◦ (α) = q −6 x¯ 1 ⊗ δx1 + q −2 x2 ⊗ δ x¯ 2 + q −2 x¯ 3 ⊗ δx3 + x4 ⊗ δ x¯ 4 . . = φ1 ⊗ φ 1 ⊗ α + φ 1 ⊗ φ 2 ⊗ γ = (α) ⊗ α − q(γ¯ ) ⊗ γ = (α(1) ) ⊗ α(2) .
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
85
Moreover (δl ⊗ id) ◦ (α) = q −6 (α ⊗ x¯ 1 − q 2 γ¯ ⊗ x¯ 2 ) ⊗ x1 + q −2 (q γ¯ ⊗ x1 + α ⊗ x2 ) ⊗ x¯ 2 +q −2 (q 2 γ¯ ⊗ x¯ 4 + α ⊗ x¯ 3 ) ⊗ x3 + (−q γ¯ ⊗ x3 + α ⊗ x4 ) ⊗ x¯ 4 . . = α ⊗ φ1 ⊗ φ1 − q γ¯ ⊗ φ2 ⊗ φ1 = α ⊗ (α) − q γ¯ ⊗ (γ ) = α(1) ⊗ (α(2) ) . Similar computations can be carried for γ , α¯ and γ¯ . That an iterative procedure constructed by using (53) on the PBW basis leads to a well defined on the whole of H = A(SUq (2)) will be proven in the forthcoming paper [23] where other elaborations coming from the existence of a strong connection will be presented as well. 6.1. The associated bundle and the coequivariant maps. We now give some elements of the theory of associated quantum vector bundles [8] (see also [11]). Let B ⊂ P be a H -Galois extension with R the coaction of H on P . Let ρ : V → H ⊗ V be a corepresentation of H with V a finite dimensional vector space. A coequivariant map is an element ϕ in P ⊗ V with the property that (R ⊗ id)ϕ = (id ⊗ (S ⊗ id) ◦ ρ)ϕ
(54)
where S is the antipode of H . The collection ρ (P , V ) of coequivariant maps is a right and left B-module. The algebraic analogue of bundle nontriviality is translated in the fact that the HopfGalois extension B ⊂ P is not cleft. On the other hand, it is know that for a cleft Hopf-Galois extension, the module of coequivariant maps ρ (P , V ) is isomorphic to the free module of coinvariant maps 0 (P , V ) = B ⊗ V [8, 14]. For our A(SUq (2))-Hopf-Galois extension A(Sq4 ) ⊂ A(Sq7 ), let ρ1 : C2 → C2 ⊗ A(SUq (2)) be the fundamental corepresentation of A(SUq (2)) with 1 (A(Sq7 ), C2 ) the right A(Sq4 )-module of corresponding coequivariant maps. Now, the projection p in (29) determines a quantum vector bundle over Sq4 whose module of section is p[A(Sq4 )4 ], which is clearly a right A(Sq4 )-module. The following proposition in straightforward Proposition 8. The modules E := p[A(Sq4 )4 ] and 1 (A(Sq7 ), C2 ) are isomorphic as right A(Sq4 )-modules. Proof. Remember that p = vv ∗ with v in (25). The element p(F ) ∈ E, with F = (f1 , f2 , f3 , f4 )t , corresponds to the equivariant map v ∗ F ∈ 1 (A(Sq7 ), C2 ).
We expect that a similar construction extends to every irreducible corepresentation of A(SUq (2)) by means of suitable projections giving the corresponding associated bundles [23]. Proposition 9. The Hopf-Galois extension A(Sq4 ) ⊂ A(Sq7 ) is not cleft. Proof. As mentioned, the cleftness of the extension does imply that all modules of coequivariant maps are free. On the other hand, the nontriviality of the pairing (47) between the defining projection p in (29) and the Fredholm module µ constructed in Sect. 5 also shows that the module p[A(Sq4 )4 ] ρ (A(Sq7 ), C2 ) is not free.
86
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
Acknowledgements. We thank the referee for many useful comments and suggestions. We are grateful to Tomasz Brzezi´nski and Piotr M. Hajac for several important remarks on a previous version of the compuscript. Also, Eli Hawkins, Walter van Suijlekom, Marco Tarlini are thanked for very useful discussions.
A. The Classical Hopf Fibration S 7 → S 4 We shall review the classical construction of the basic anti-instanton bundle over the four dimensional sphere S 4 in a ‘noncommutative parlance’ following [16]. This has been useful in the main text for our construction of the quantum deformation of the Hopf bundle. We write the generic element of the group SU (2) as w1 w2 w= . (55) −w¯ 2 w¯ 1 The SU (2) principal fibration SU (2) → S 7 → S 4 over the sphere S 4 is explicitly real4 2 ized as follows. The total space is S 7 = {z = (z1 , z2 , z3 , z4 ) ∈ C4 , i=1 |zi | = 1} , with right diagonal action w1 w2 0 0 −w¯ 2 w¯ 1 0 0 S 7 × SU (2) → S 7 , z · w := (z1 , z2 , z3 , z4 ) . (56) 0 0 w1 w 2 0 0 −w¯ 2 w¯ 1 The bundle projection π : S 7 → S 4 is just the Hopf projection and it can be explicitly given as π(z1 , z2 , z3 , z4 ) := (x, α, β) with x = |z1 |2 + |z2 |2 − |z3 |2 − |z4 |2 = −1 + 2(|z1 |2 + |z2 |2 ) = 1 − 2(|z3 |2 + |z4 |2 ) , α = 2(z1 z¯ 3 + z2 z¯ 4 ) , β = 2(−z1 z4 + z2 z3 ) . (57) One checks that |α|2 + |β|2 + x 2 = ( 4i=1 |zi |2 )2 = 1 . We need the rank 2 complex vector bundle E associated with the defining left representation ρ of SU (2) on C2 . The quickest way to get this is to identify S 7 with the unit sphere in the 2-dimensional quaternionic (right) H-module H2 and S 4 with the projective line P1 (H), i.e. the set of equivalence classes (w1 , w2 )t (w1 , w2 )t λ with (w1 , w2 ) ∈ S 7 and λ ∈ Sp(1) SU (2). Identifying H C2 , the vector (w1 , w2 )t ∈ S 7 reads z 1 z2 −¯z z¯ v = 2 1. (58) z3 z4 −¯z4 z¯ 3 This is actually a map from S 7 to the Stieffel variety of frames for E. In particular, notice that the two vectors |ψ1 , |ψ2 given by the columns of v are orthonormal, indeed v ∗ v = I2 . As a consequence, p := vv ∗ = |ψ1 ψ1 | + |ψ2 ψ2 | is a self-adjoint idempotent (a projector), p2 = p, p ∗ = p. Of course p is SU (2) invariant and hence its entries are functions on S 4 rather than S 7 . An explicit computation yields 1+x 0 α β 1 0 1 + x −β¯ α¯ , p= (59) α ¯ −β 1 − x 0 2 β¯ α 0 1−x
A Hopf Bundle Over a Quantum Four-Sphere from the Symplectic Group
87
where (x, α, β) are the coordinates (57) on S 4 . Then p ∈ Mat4 (C ∞ (S 4 , C)) is of rank 2 by construction. The matrix v in (58) is a particular example of the matrices v given in [1], for n = 1, k = 1, C0 = 0, C1 = 1, D0 = 1, D1 = 0. This gives the (anti-)instanton of charge −1 centered at the origin and with unit scale. The only difference is that here we identify C4 with H2 as a right H-module. This notwithstanding, the projections constructed in the two formalisms actually coincide. Finally recall that, as mentioned already, the classical limit of our quantum projection (29) is conjugate to (59). The canonical connection associated with the projector, ∇ := p ◦ d : ∞ (S 4 , E) → ∞ (S 4 , E) ⊗C ∞ (S 4 ,C) 1 (S 4 , C),
(60)
corresponds to a Lie-algebra valued (su(2)) 1-form A on S 7 whose matrix components are given by Aij = ψi |dψj ,
i, j = 1, 2 .
(61)
This connection can be used to compute the Chern character of the bundle. Out of the curvature of the connection ∇ 2 = p(dp)2 one has the Chern 2-form and 4-form given respectively by 1 tr(p(dp)2 ) , 2πi 1 C2 (p) := − 2 [tr(p(dp)4 ) − C1 (p)C1 (p)] , 8π C1 (p) := −
(62)
with the trace tr just an ordinary matrix trace. It turns out that the 2-form p(dp)2 has vanishing trace so that C1 (p) = 0. As for the second Chern class, a straightforward calculation shows that 1 [(x0 dx4 − x4 dx0 )(dξ )3 + 3dx0 dx4 ξ (dξ )2 ] 32π 2 3 = − 2 [x0 dx1 dx2 dx3 dx4 + cyclic permutations] 8π 3 = − 2 d(vol(S 4 )) . 8π
C2 (p) = −
(63)
The second Chern number is then given by c2 (p) =
S4
C2 (p) = −
3 8π 2
S4
d(vol(S 4 )) = −
3 8 2 π = −1 . 8π 2 3
(64)
The connection A in (61) is (anti-)self-dual, i.e. its curvature FA := dA + A ∧ A satisfies (anti-)self-duality equations, ∗H FA = −FA , with ∗H the Hodge map of the canonical (round) metric on the sphere S 4 . It is indeed the basic Yang-Mills anti-instanton found in [2].
88
G. Landi, C. Pagani, C. Reina
References 1. Atiyah, M.: The geometry of Yang-Mills fields. Lezioni Fermiane. Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei e Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa 1979 2. Belavin, A., Polyakov, A., Schwartz, A., Tyupkin, Y.: Pseudoparticles solutions of the Yang-Mills equations. Phys. Lett. 58 B, 85–87 (1975) 3. Bonechi, F., Ciccoli, N., Tarlini, M.: Noncommutative instantons on the 4-sphere from quantum groups. Commun. Math. Phys. 226, 419–432 (2002) 4. Bonechi, F., Ciccoli, N., D¸abrowski, L., Tarlini, L.M.: Bijectivity of the canonical map for the non-commutative instanton bundle. J. Geom. Phys. 51, 71–81 (2004) 5. Brzezi´nski, T., D¸abrowski, L., Zielinski, B.: Hopf fibration and monopole connection over the contact quantum spheres. J. Geom. Phys. 50, 345–359 (2004) 6. Brzezi´nski, T., Hajac, P.M.: Coalgebra extensions and algebra coextensions of Galois type. Commun. Algebra 27, 1347–1368 (1999) 7. Brzezi´nski, T., Hajac, P.M.: The Chern-Galois character. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, Ser. I 333, 113–116 (2004) 8. Brzezi´nski, T., Majid, S.: Quantum group gauge theory on quantum spaces. Commun. Math. Phys. 157, 591–638 (1993) Erratum 167, 235 (1995) 9. Brzezi´nski, T., Majid, S.: Coalgebra Bundles. Commun. Math. Phys. 191, 467–492 (1998) 10. Connes, A.: Noncommutative geometry. London-New York: Academic Press, 1994 11. Durdevich, M.: Geometry of quantum principal bundles I. Commun. Math. Phys. 175, 427–521 (1996); Geometry of quantum principal bundles II. Rev. Math. Phys. 9, 531–607 (1997) 12. D¸abrowski, L., Grosse, H., Hajac, P.M.: Strong connections and Chern-Connes pairing in the HopfGalois theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 247–264 (1999) 13. Hajac, P.M.: Strong connections on quantum principal bundles. Commun. Math. Phys. 182, 579–617 (1996) 14. Hajac, P.M., Majid, S.: Projective module description of the q-monopole. Commun. Math. Phys. 206, 247–264 (1999) 15. Hajac, P.M., Matthes, R., Szyma´nski, W.: A locally trivial quantum Hopf fibration. http:// arXiv.org/list/math.QA/0112317, 2001; to appear in Algebra and Representation Theory 16. Landi, G.: Deconstructing monopoles and instantons. Rev. Math. Phys. 12, 1367–1390 (2000) 17. Majid, S.: Quantum and braided group Riemannian geometry. J. Geom. Phys. 30, 113–146 (1999) 18. Kassel, C.: Quantum groups. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer 1995 19. Klimyk,A., Schm¨udgen, K.: Quantum groups and their representations. Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer Verlag, 1997 20. Kreimer, H.F., Takeuchi, M.: Hopf algebras and Galois extensions of an algebra. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 30, 675–692 (1981) 21. Masuda, T., Nakagami, Y., Watanabe, J.: Noncommutative differential geometry on the quantum SU (2). I:An algebraic viewpoint. K-Theory 4, 157–180 (1990); Noncommutative differential geometry on the quantum two sphere of P.Podle´s. I: An algebraic viewpoint. K-Theory 5, 151–175 (1991) 22. Montgomery, S.: Hopf algebras and their actions on rings. Providence, RI: AMS 1993 23. Pagani, C.: In preparation 24. Podle´s, P.: Quantum spheres. Lett. Math. Phys. 14, 193–202 (1987) 25. Reshetikhin, N.Yu., Takhtadzhyan, L.A., Faddeev, L.D.: Quantization of Lie groups and Lie algebras. Leningrad Math. J. 1, 193–225 (1990) 26. Schauenburg, P.: Bi-Galois objects over Taft algebras. Israel J. Math. 115, 101–123 (2000) 27. Schauenburg, P., Schneider, H.: Galois type extensions of noncommutative algebras. In preparation 28. Schneider, H.: Principal homogeneous spaces for arbitrary Hopf algebras. Israel J. Math. 72, 167–195 (1990) 29. Simon, B.: Trace ideals and their applications. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1979 30. Woronowicz, S.L.: Twisted SU(2) group. An example of a noncommutative differential calculus. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. 23, 117–181 (1987) Communicated by L. Takhtajan
Commun. Math. Phys. 263, 89–132 (2006) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1482-7
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory Daniel S. Freed1 , Gregory W. Moore2 1
Department of Mathematics, University of Texas at Austin, 1 University Station, Austin, TX, 78712-0257, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Physics, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ 08855-0849, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 21 September 2004 / Accepted: 26 January 2005 Published online: 24 January 2006 – © Springer-Verlag 2006
Abstract: In anomaly-free quantum field theories the integrand in the bosonic functional integral—the exponential of the effective action after integrating out fermions—is often defined only up to a phase without an additional choice. We term this choice “setting the quantum integrand”. In the low-energy approximation to M-theory the E8 -model for the C-field allows us to set the quantum integrand using geometric index theory. We derive mathematical results of independent interest about pfaffians of Dirac operators in 8k + 3 dimensions, both on closed manifolds and manifolds with boundary. These theorems are used to set the quantum integrand of M-theory for closed manifolds and for compact manifolds with either temporal (global) or spatial (local) boundary conditions. In particular, we show that M-theory makes sense on arbitrary 11-manifolds with spatial boundary, generalizing the construction of heterotic M-theory on cylinders.
Contents 1. Determinants, Pfaffians, and η-Invariants . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Determinant line bundle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Odd dimensions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. 8k + 3 dimensions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. ζ -functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. M-theory Action on Closed Manifolds . . . . . . . . . . 3. (8k + 3)-Dimensional Manifolds with Boundary . . . . 3.1. Generalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Global boundary conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Local boundary conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. M-Theory Action on Compact Manifolds with Boundary
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
92 92 95 97 100 101 103 104 105 106 109
The work of D.F. is supported in part by NSF grant DMS-0305505. The work of G.M. is supported in part by DOE grant DE-FG02-96ER40949
90
4.1. Actions and anomalies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Temporal boundary conditions . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. Spatial boundary conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Further Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. The E8 -model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. M2-branes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. Boundary values of C-fields . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4. Temporal boundaries and the Hamiltonian anomaly 5.5. Topological terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix A: The Gravitino Path Integral . . . . . . . . . . . A.1. The gravitino theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.2. Local analysis of the equations of motion . . . . . A.3. Partition function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.4. Boundary conditions for ghosts . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix B: Quaternionic Fredholms and Pfaffians . . . . .
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
109 111 114 117 117 118 119 120 121 124 124 125 126 128 129
The low-energy approximation to M-theory is a refinement of classical 11-dimensional supergravity. It has a simple field content: a metric g, a 3-form gauge potential C, and a gravitino. The M-theory action contains rather subtle “Chern-Simons” terms which, on a topologically nontrivial manifold Y , raise delicate issues in the definition of the (exponentiated) action. Some aspects of the problem were resolved by Witten [W1]. The key ingredients are: a quantization law for C and a background magnetic current induced by the fourth Stiefel-Whitney class of the underlying manifold; an expression for the exponentiated Chern-Simons terms using an E8 gauge field and an associated Dirac operator in 12 dimensions; and finally a sign ambiguity in the gravitino partition function. In [DFM] the link to E8 was used to construct a model for the C-field and define precisely the action, assuming that the metric g is fixed. The present paper gives a complete treatment of the M-theory action as a function of both C and g. Furthermore, we treat manifolds with boundary. The boundary may have several components and each component is interpreted either as a fixed time slice (temporal boundary) or a boundary in space (spatial boundary). We do not mix temporal and spatial boundary conditions. Our discussion of spatial boundaries in §4.3 generalizes the case Y = X × [0, 1], where X is a closed 10-manifold, which was described in the work of Horava and Witten [HW1, HW2]. Our analysis here makes it clear that the anomaly cancellation is local. (As emphasized in [BM] the locality of anomaly cancellation in the Horava-Witten model is far from obvious.) In particular, we show that there is no topological obstruction to formulating M-theory on an 11-manifold with an arbitrary number of boundary components, provided an independent E8 super-Yang-Mills multiplet is present on each component. The analysis here is more than a cancellation of anomalies in M-theory. Already in [W1] Witten showed that there is a nontrivial Green-Schwarz mechanism canceling global anomalies on closed 11-manifolds. We go further and show that the anomaly is canceled canonically. This is a crucial distinction for the following reason. The absence of anomalies is a necessary condition for a quantum theory to be well-defined, but the cancellation mechanism depends on physically measurable choices. Put differently, there are undetermined phases if the configuration space of bosonic fields is not connected. As we explain quite generally in §4.1, the exponentiated effective action after integrating out fermionic fields is naturally a section of a hermitian line bundle with covariant derivative over the space of bosonic fields. The absence of anomalies means
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
91
that the line bundle is geometrically trivializable, i.e., the covariant derivative is flat with no holonomy. If there are no anomalies then global trivializations exist, and a choice of trivialization determines the integrand of the bosonic functional integral. When we make such a choice we say we have set the quantum integrand. The general uniqueness question for settings of the quantum integrand is discussed in §5.5. Our main result is that in M-theory there is a canonical choice of trivialization, thus a canonical setting of the quantum integrand of M-theory. The procedure by which we set the quantum integrand of M-theory is, as we have mentioned, an example of the GreenSchwarz mechanism. Quite generally, by the Green-Schwarz mechanism we mean that setting the quantum integrand involves a trivialization of the tensor product of two line bundles with covariant derivative, one coming from integration over fermionic fields and the other from the simultaneous presence of electric and magnetic current; see [F2, F3 , Part 3 ] for a general discussion. The integral over fermionic fields is a section of a pfaffian line bundle. In this paper we use the E8 -model for the C-field to define the exponentiated electric coupling. This has the advantage that the associated line bundle with covariant derivative is defined by Atiyah-Patodi-Singer η-invariants associated to the E8 -gauge fields. With this model, then, we can analyze both line bundles in the context of standard invariants of geometric index theory and explicitly write down the trivialization which sets the quantum integrand. The mathematical results we apply to M-theory are given in §1 for closed manifolds and in §3 for manifolds with boundary. Determinant and pfaffian line bundles are usually considered for families of Dirac operators on even dimensional manifolds, but our interest here is in the odd dimensional case. As we explain in §1.2 there is a second natural real line bundle with covariant derivative in odd dimensions, defined using the exponentiated η-invariant, and it is isomorphic to the determinant line bundle (Proposition 1.16). This isomorphism is equivalent to a trivialization of the tensor product—the trivialization needed for the physics—since the second line bundle is real. This isomorphism induces a real structure on the determinant line bundle in odd dimensions. Also, it induces a nonflat complex trivialization of the determinant line bundle, so gives a definition of the determinant of the Dirac operator in odd dimensions as a complex number [S]; see Remark 1.20. This definition is often used in the physics literature, and is arrived at with Pauli-Villars regularization [R1, R2, ADM]. However, the definition as an element of the determinant line is more fundamental. There is an important refinement (Proposition 1.31) to pfaffians in dimensions 3, 11, 19, . . . which includes the dimensions of interest in M-theory: 11 for the bulk and 3 for M2-branes (§5.2). This refinement is topological in a sense made precise in Appendix B (Proposition B.2). We take up the generalization of this isomorphism to Dirac operators on manifolds with boundary in Sect. 3. Most often considered in the geometric index theory literature are boundary conditions of global type, which in the physics correspond to a temporal boundary. The generalization of the basic theorem to this case is straightforward (§3.2). Local boundary conditions arise in the physics from spatial boundaries, but because they do not exist for every Dirac operator they are less studied. The generalization to this case is more subtle and (in general dimensions) is the subject of the forthcoming thesis of Matthew Scholl. The applications to M-theory on manifolds with boundary appear as Theorem 4.16 (temporal boundary) and Conjecture 4.35 (spatial boundary). Our treatment falls short by not defining precisely the partition function of the Rarita-Schwinger (gravitino) field. The definition commonly used in the literature seems
92
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
ill-defined due to singularities related to the zeromodes of bosonic ghosts for supersymmetry transformations. Moreover, the derivation of the standard expression in terms of pfaffians of Dirac operators assumes an off-shell formulation of supergravity, something which is lacking in the 10- and 11-dimensional cases. Nevertheless, we take the standard expression as motivation for the line bundle with covariant derivative of which the Rarita-Schwinger partition function is a section. We present a derivation of the standard formula in Appendix A, mostly to motivate the local boundary conditions for the ghost fields which are used in Sect. 4.3. The precise definition of the Rarita-Schwinger partition function is a general issue which we leave to future work. Another issue we do not confront is the dependence of the covariant derivative on the Rarita-Schwinger line bundle on background fluxes. Nontrivial dependence can in principle arise from terms of the form ψGψ in the supergravity action. (There are additional terms of a similar nature in heterotic M-theory.) We believe the above issues will not drastically alter the discussion we give, which is based on the simple assumption that the Rarita-Schwinger partition function is a section of the line bundle in Eq. (2.2), equipped with the standard covariant derivative. Some general issues of independent interest arose during our investigations. One concerns the definition of anomalies and the setting of quantum integrands for manifolds with temporal boundaries. This forms part of the discussion in §4.1 and is elaborated in §5.4 where we relate it to the Hamiltonian interpretation of anomalies. There are interesting mathematical questions which underlie that discussion, but they are not treated here. Another issue concerns boundary values for fields with automorphisms, such as gauge fields. Then the boundary condition includes a choice of isomorphism (for example, see [FQ] where gauge theories with finite gauge groups are treated carefully), and this shows up in the physics as certain phases, such as θ-angles. In §5.3 we indicate how this works for the C-field in M-theory. 1. Determinants, Pfaffians, and η-Invariants The geometry of determinant line bundles was developed in [Q, BF]; see [F1] for a survey. In §1.1 we recall the main points. Our discussion is phrased in general terms and applies in arbitrary dimensions. In odd dimensions Clifford multiplication by the volume form induces a real structure on the determinant line bundle, which we explain in §1.2 by introducing a manifestly real line bundle associated to the η-invariant [APS] and proving it is isomorphic to the determinant line bundle. In §1.3 we prove a refinement in dimensions 8k + 3 (k ∈ Z≥0 ) coming from the quaternionic structure. Some details about ζ -functions are addressed in §1.4.
1.1. Determinant line bundle. Definition 1.1. Let T be a smooth manifold. A geometric family of Dirac operators parametrized by T consists of: (i) a Riemannian manifold Y → T ; that is, a fiber bundle Y → T , a metric on the relative tangent bundle T (Y/T ) → Y, and a horizontal distribution H on Y (thus H ⊕ T (Y/T ) = T Y); and (ii) a bundle M = M 0 ⊕M 1 → Y of complex Z/2Z-graded Cliff(Y/T )-modules with compatible metric and covariant derivative.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
93
The metric and horizontal distribution determine a Levi-Civita covariant derivative on T (Y/T ) → Y. The Riemannian metrics determine a bundle Cliff(Y/T ) → Y of (finite dimensional) Clifford algebras: the fiber at y ∈ Y is the real Clifford algebra of the relative cotangent space Ty∗ (Y/T ). The Clifford module structure on M is given as a map γ : T ∗ (Y/T ) −→ End(M)
(1.2)
which obeys the Clifford relation γ (θ1 )γ (θ2 ) + γ (θ2 )γ (θ1 ) = −2θ1 , θ2 ,
θ1 , θ2 ∈ Ty∗ (Y/T ),
y ∈ Y. (1.3)
We ask that the image consist of odd skew-adjoint transformations. The compatibility in the last line of Definition 1.1 also requires that (1.2) be flat. For each t ∈ T the Dirac operator Dt = γ ◦ ∇ is defined on sections of M Y → Yt . It is odd relative to the t Z/2Z-grading.1 To illustrate the notation let T be a point, so D is a Dirac operator on a single manifold Y . Suppose first that dim Y = 2m is even and Y is spin. Then for the standard Dirac operator M = S is the bundle of Z/2Z-graded spinors with homogeneous components S 0 , S 1 of complex rank 2m−1 , the bundles of chiral spinors. The Dirac operator interchanges the chirality of homogeneous spinor fields. The covariant derivative on S is induced from the Levi-Civita covariant derivative. If dim Y = 2m + 1 is odd, then we usually say that spinors are ungraded: there is no chirality. In the Z/2Z-graded setup we can take each of S 0 , S 1 to be the ungraded spinor bundle of complex rank 2m . This is compatible with the observation that for any Z/2Z-graded Cliff(Y )-module M → Y Clifford multiplication by the volume form provides an isomorphism M 0 → M 1 if dim Y is odd; see the next section for consequences. For Dirac operators with coefficients in a vector bundle E → Y take M = S ⊗ E. We occasionally denote this Dirac operator as ‘DM ’. In the application to field theory the parameter space is typically an infinite dimensional space B of all bosonic fields; from this point of view we study the pullback by a map T → B. Given a geometric family of Dirac operators parametrized by T let H = H0 ⊕ H1 −→ T
be the Hilbert space bundle whose fiber at t ∈ T is the space of L2 sections of M Y → t Yt . Assume each fiber Yt is closed, i.e., compact without boundary. Then the Dirac operator Dt extends to an odd self-adjoint operator on Ht , and so Dt2 to an even selfadjoint operator on Ht . The spectrum of Dt2 is nonnegative, discrete, has no accumulation points, and the eigenspaces are graded finite dimensional subspaces of Ht . Furthermore, if λ2 > 0 is an eigenvalue of Dt2 , then Dt /λ is an isometry from the even component of the λ2 -eigenspace to the odd component. Define spec0 (Dt2 ) to be the spectrum of Dt2 restricted to Ht0 . There is a canonical open cover {Ua }a≥0 of T : Ua = t ∈ T : a ∈ / spec0 (Dt2 ) . (1.4) 1 We remark that the Z/2Z-grading on M is not the physics grading of bosonic and fermionic fields. In our exposition here sections of M—for example, spinor fields—are treated as ordinary commuting fields. When we turn to the physics applications in §2 we use the proper action for fermionic fields.
94
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
On Ua we introduce the Z/2Z-graded vector bundle H(a) = H0 (a) ⊕ H1 (a) −→ Ua
(1.5)
whose fiber H(a)t at t ∈ T is the sum of the eigenspaces of for eigenvalues less than a. Then H(a) is smooth of finite rank, with constant rank on each component of Ua . Furthermore, the geometric data induces a metric and covariant derivative on H(a). The Dirac operator D restricts to an operator D(a) on H(a). Global geometric invariants of Dirac operators are constructed by patching invariants on Ua . Recall that the determinant line Det E of a finite dimensional ungraded vector space E is its highest exterior power. A linear map S : E0 → E1 between vector spaces of the same dimension has a determinant det S ∈ Hom(Det E0 , Det E1 ) ∼ (1.6) = Det E1 ⊗ (Det E0 )∗ Dt2
which is the induced map on the highest exterior power. The line which appears in (1.6) is the determinant line of the Z/2Z-graded vector space E0 ⊕E1 . It is natural to grade Det E by dim E. For our purposes we take the grading to lie in Z/2Z rather than Z. Returning to the family of Dirac operators, define the line bundle Det H(a) = Det H1 (a) ⊗ Det H0 (a)∗ −→ Ua . For b > a we set H(a, b) = H0 (a, b) ⊕ H1 (a, b) −→ Ua ∩ Ub whose fiber at t is the sum of the eigenspaces of Dt2 for eigenvalues between a and b. There is a canonical isomorphism Det H(a) ⊗ Det H(a, b) −→ Det H(b)
on Ua ∩ Ub
(1.7)
and a canonical nonzero det D(a, b) of Det H(a, b), where D(a, b)t : H0 (a, b)t → H1 (a, b)t is the restriction of the “chiral” Dirac operator Dt0 : Ht0 → Ht1 . From (1.7) we obtain the patching isomorphism section2
Det H(a) −→ Det H(b)
on Ua ∩ Ub ,
(1.8)
and a cocycle identity on Ua ∩Ub ∩Uc , whence a global smooth line bundle Det D → T . Furthermore, the sections det D(a) of Det H(a), defined analogously to det D(a, b), patch to a smooth section det D of Det D → T . The patching isomorphism (1.8) preserves the Z/2Z grading of the determinant line: the parity of Det Dt is the parity of index Dt0 . The metric and covariant derivative on H(a) induce a metric and covariant derivative on Det H(a), but these are not preserved by (1.8). Modify the metric and covariant derivative to obtain invariance under patching: multiply the metric on Det H(a)t by λ2 (1.9) a<λ2 λ2 ∈spec0 (Dt2 )
and add the 1-form
Tr ∇D ◦ D −1 H0 H0 (a)
(1.10)
to the covariant derivative on Det H(a). We use ζ -function regularization to define (1.9) and (1.10); see §1.4 for details. 2
For ease of notation we write ‘det D’ instead of the more accurate ‘det D 0 ’.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
95
Proposition 1.11. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on closed manifolds parametrized by T . Then there is a functorially associated Z/2Z-graded complex line bundle Det D −→ T with metric and covariant derivative, and a section det D which vanishes at t ∈ T for which Dt has a nonzero kernel. There are formulas for the holonomy and curvature of the determinant line bundle, but we will not need them in this paper. 1.2. Odd dimensions. Now suppose the fibers of Y → T have odd dimension and are oriented. Let ω denote Clifford multiplication by the relative volume form; it is an odd √ endomorphism of M. Multiply by a suitable power of −1 to arrange ω2 = 1. Also, ω commutes with γ (θ ) for any relative cotangent vector θ and is flat, so commutes with the Dirac operator D on any fiber. (This commutation is not in the graded sense.) The composition ωD is a first-order even self-adjoint operator with discrete real spectrum, the spectrum has no accumulation points, and the spectrum is unbounded both positively and negatively. Observe (ωD)2 = D 2 so that eigenvalues of ωD square to eigenvalues of D 2 . The self-adjoint operator ωD on H0 is what is usually termed the Dirac operator in odd dimensions. Let spec0 (ωt Dt ) denote the spectrum of ωt Dt on Ht0 for each t ∈ T ; an eigenvalue is repeated in spec0 (ωt Dt ) according to its multiplicity. Define the open cover {Vα }α∈R of T : / spec0 (ωt Dt ) . Vα = t ∈ T : α ∈ Note that Uα 2 = Vα ∩ V−α . Define η(α) : Vα → R 0 0 to be the ζ -function regularization of # λ ∈ spec (ωt Dt ) : α < λ −# λ ∈ spec (ωt Dt ) : λ < α . Namely, for s ∈ C with Re s >> 0 define η(α)t [s] = sign(λ − α)|λ|−s − sign(α) · # spec0 (ωt Dt ) ∩ {0} λ∈spec0 (ωt Dt ) \ {0}
and set η(α)t to be the value of the meromorphic continuation of η(α)t [s] at s = 0. For α < β we have η(β)t η(α)t on Vα ∩ Vβ . (1.12) = − # λ ∈ spec0 (ωt Dt ) : α < λ < β 2 2 We use (1.12) to construct two invariants. First, let T denote the group of unit norm complex numbers. Then
η(α) τ (α) = exp 2πi : Vα −→ T (1.13) 2 is invariant under patching, so defines a global function τD : T −→ T.
(1.14)
96
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
Second, we use the integers in the last term of (1.12) to patch a principal Z-bundle on T : the fiber at t ∈ T is
α<λ<β . n : R \ spec0 (ωt Dt ) −→ Z : n(β) = n(α) − # λ ∈ spec0 (ωt Dt ) The spectral flow of ωD around a loop in T is the monodromy of this principal Z-bundle. Also, η/2 is a section of the associated real affine bundle constructed from the translation action of Z on R. Topologically, each construction determines a class in H 1 (T ; Z), and the classes are equal. The reduction to H 1 (T ; Z/2Z) is represented geometrically by a complex line bundle L → T with compatible real structure, metric, and covariant derivative. Its fiber at t ∈ T is
α<λ<β # λ∈spec0 (ω D ) 0 t t f (α) . (1.15) Lt = f : R \ spec (ωt Dt ) −→ C : f (β) = (−1) Over Vα the map f → f (α) gives an isomorphism with the trivial bundle, and we use it to define the real structure, metric, and covariant derivative. Note that the covariant derivative has order two, that is, L⊗2 is canonically geometrically trivial. On Ua ⊂ T the Clifford multiplication ω restricts to a flat isometry ω(a) : H0 (a) → H1 (a), so induces a trivialization det ω of Det H(a) → Ua . We use it to identify the determinant line bundle with the line bundle L. Proposition 1.16. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on closed odd dimensional manifolds parametrized by T . Then there is a functorial trivialization 1 of L ⊗ Det D → T which is geometric in the sense that |1| = 1,
(1.17)
∇1 = 0.
It induces a real structure on Det D with respect to which the section det D is real. Proof. The fiber of L ⊗ Det D at t ∈ T is
α<λ<β # λ∈spec0 (ω D ) 0 t t g(α) . (L ⊗ Det D)t = g : R \ spec (ωt Dt ) −→ Det Dt : g(β)=(−1) (1.18) Let α ≥ 0. Define 1 on Uα 2 by det ω(α 2 ) g(−α) = det ωD H0 H0 (α 2 )
∈
Det H(α 2 ).
If β > α then under the patching (1.8) we have g(−α) −→ =
det ω(α 2 ) det D(α 2 , β 2 ) det ωD H0 H0 (α 2 ) det ω(α 2 ) det ω(α 2 , β 2 ) det ωD(α 2 , β 2 ) det ωD H0 H0 (α 2 )
#
= (−1)
#
= (−1)
−β<λ<−α λ∈spec0 (ωt Dt )
−β<λ<−α λ∈spec0 (ωt Dt )
det ω(β 2 ) det ωD H0 H0 (β 2 ) g(−β)
(1.19)
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
97
which matches (1.18). Thus 1 is well-defined. The definition (1.9) of the metric shows |1| = 1. We verify ∇1 = 0 at the end of §1.4. Finally, 1 induces an isomorphism Det D ∼ = L, in view of the isomorphism L ∼ = L−1 , and if det Dt = 0 then det Dt corresponds to the function f ∈ Lt whose value at 0 is f (0) = | det ωt Dt | (ζ -regularized), so is real. Remark 1.20. The real structure on Det D is a bit indirect, as opposed, say, to the real structure on the pfaffian line bundle in 8k + 3 dimensions, which is defined in the next subsection directly in terms of the geometry. In fact, there is a natural complex trivializa1/2 tion of L, namely the square root τD of (1.14). In the notation of (1.15) it is defined by −1/2 f (α) = exp 2π iη(α)/4 . Then Proposition 1.16 renders the ratio det D · τD a global complex function. It is sometimes defined to be the determinant in odd dimensions, both in the mathematics [S , §4 ] and physics literature [R1, R2, ADM]. Notice that the trivial1/2 ization τD has unit norm but is not flat. Rather, we can modify the covariant derivative 1/2 1/2 on L by the imaginary 1-form −∇τD and then τD is flat relative to the new covariant derivative. The 1-form used to modify the covariant derivative has a local formula—up to a factor it is the 1-form component of the integral of the usual index density over the fibers of Y → T . 1.3. 8k + 3 dimensions. Assume the fibers of Y → T are closed of dimension 8k +3 for some integer k ≥ 0. Then the fibers of Cliff(Y/T ) → Y have a quaternionic structure.3 Thus assume also that the fibers of M → Y are quaternionic4 and that the geometry respects the quaternionic structure.5 For example, if the fibers of Y → T are spin, then we can take M to be the relative spin bundle, or the relative spin bundle tensored with a real vector bundle on Y. In this case the determinant and η-invariant have refinements due to the fact that the eigenspaces of Dt2 are quaternionic, so have even complex dimension. Let J : M → M be the quaternionic structure. Then J commutes with ω and D, hence for each t ∈ T with D /t = J ωt Dt : Yt (M 0 ) −→ Yt (M 0 ),
(1.21)
and the latter is formally skew-adjoint: D /t ψ1 , ψ2 + D /t ψ2 , ψ1 |dy| = 0
(1.22)
Yt
The complex conjugate E of a complex vector space E is defined thus: E = E as sets, the additional laws on E and E are equal, the scalar multiplication is conjugated. Write e¯ ∈ E for the element which equals e ∈ E. Then for λ ∈ C we have λ¯ · e¯ = λ · e. A quaternionic structure is a linear map J : E → E such that J J = − idE . (A linear map E → E is often termed an antilinear map on E, but we prefer to use only linear maps.) 4 In the physics literature the quaternionic structure on spinor fields is usually written “J ψ = Cψ ∗ ”, where C is the charge conjugation matrix. Hence J is usually regarded as anti-linear. 5 To wit, if J : M → M denotes the quaternionic structure, then J is unitary and ∇J = 0. The unitarity implies 3
J ψ, ψ = −J ψ , ψ,
ψ, ψ ∈ M.
In addition γ (θ) ∈ End M is quaternion linear for each cotangent vector θ .
98
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
for all sections ψ1 , ψ2 ∈ Yt (M 0 ) of M 0 Y → Yt . Here ·, · is the hermitian metric t
on M—a homomorphism from M ⊗M to the trivial bundle—and |dy| is the Riemannian 0 /t : Ht0 → Ht ∼ measure on Yt . The operator (1.21) extends to a skew-adjoint operator D = (Ht0 )∗ . A skew-adjoint operator S : E → E∗ on a finite dimensional complex vector space E is equivalently a 2-form ωS ∈ 2 E∗ . Suppose dim E = 2n is even. Then the pfaffian of S is pfaff S =
ωSn ∈ Det E∗ , n!
(1.23)
and the graded line Det E∗ has even parity. If dim E is odd, then pfaff S = 0 and the parity of Det E∗ is odd. In all cases (pfaff S)⊗2 = det S as elements of (Det E∗ )⊗2 . If J : E → E is a quaternionic structure, then of course dim E is even. Furthermore, det J : Det E → Det E is a real structure. If S commutes with J , then det J (pfaff S) = pfaff S, i.e., pfaff S is a real element of Det E∗ . Recall from (1.4), (1.5) the open cover {Ua }a≥0 of T and the finite rank complex vector bundles H0 (a) → Ua . Now D / restricts to a skew-adjoint operator D /(a) : H0 (a) → 0 ∗ H (a) , so defines pfaff D /(a) ∈ Det H0 (a)∗ . Since H0 (a) is quaternionic, Det H0 (a)∗ has even parity, a real structure, and pfaff D /(a) is even. Analogous to (1.8) we patch on Ua ∩ Ub using pfaff D /(a, b) ∈ Det H0 (a, b)∗ . To patch the metric and covariant derivative we alter the correction factors (1.9) and (1.10) using the fact that every eigenvalue has even multiplicity. Namely, write spec0 (Dt2 ) = H spec0 (Dt2 ) ∪ H spec0 (Dt2 ) and replace (1.9) by its square root λ2 (1.24) a<λ2 λ2 ∈H spec0 (Dt2 )
and (1.10) by Tr H ∇D ◦ D −1 H0 H0 (a) .
(1.25)
Here ‘Tr H ’ is the trace of a quaternion linear operator on a quaternionic vector space. Proposition 1.26. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on closed (8k + 3)dimensional manifolds parametrized by T . Then there is a functorially associated complex line bundle Pfaff D / −→ T . of even parity with metric and covariant derivative, a compatible real structure, and a real section pfaff D / which vanishes at t ∈ T for which Dt has a nonzero kernel. There is a canonical isomorphism Det D ∼ /)⊗2 which preserves the real structure, = (Pfaff D metric, and covariant derivative. Under this isomorphism det D = (pfaff D /)⊗2 . Remark 1.27. Since the covariant derivative on Pfaff D / has order two, it follows that Det D has a canonical geometric trivialization, i.e., a section 1 which satisfies (1.17).
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
99
Proof. We comment only on the isomorphism. On Ua it is given as det(J ω) ⊗ idDet H0 (a)* : Det H1 (a) ⊗ Det H0 (a)∗ −→ (Det H0 (a)∗ )⊗2 . The isomorphism commutes with the patching (1.8) on Ua ∩ Ub and carries det D to (pfaff D /)⊗2 . The latter fact shows that it preserves the real structures; that it preserves the metrics and covariant derivatives follows from the formulas (1.9)/(1.24) and (1.10)/(1.25). The quaternionic structure also leads to a refinement of the η-invariant. Proposition 1.28. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on closed (8k + 3)dimensional manifolds parametrized by T . Then there is a functorially associated global function 1/2
τD : T −→ T
(1.29)
whose square is (1.14). 1/2
To construct τD we simply modify (1.12) to η(α)t η(β)t = − # λ ∈ H spec0 (ωt Dt ) : α < λ < β 4 4
on Vα ∩ Vβ
and exponentiate as in (1.13). The quaternionic structure also leads to a principal Z-bundle over T whose square (or double) is the one mentioned after (1.14), as well as a square root of the line bundle L → T constructed in (1.15):
α<λ<β # 1/2 Lt = f : R \ H spec0 (ωt Dt ) −→ C : f (β)=(−1) λ∈H spec0 (ωt Dt ) f (α) . (1.30) Note that the square L → T has a canonical geometric trivialization. Finally, we have the following refinement of Proposition 1.16. Proposition 1.31. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on closed (8k + 3)dimensional manifolds parametrized by T . There is a functorial geometric trivialization 1 of L1/2 ⊗ Pfaff D /. The trivialization 1 is real, in addition to satisfying (1.17). Proposition 1.31 is essentially a topological statement, as is explained in Appendix B. Proof. Replace (1.19) with pfaff J (α 2 ) f (−α) = pfaff ωD H0 H0 (α 2 )
∈
Det H0 (α 2 )∗ ,
where J (α 2 ) is the restriction of J to H0 (α 2 ) and the denominator is the ζ -regularized product |λ|. α<|λ| λ∈H spec0 (ωt Dt )
100
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore 1/4
Remark 1.32. The square root τD of (1.29) is a complex section of L1/2 . In the notation 1/2 of (1.30) it is defined by f (α) = exp 2πiη(α)/8 . Its role is not analogous to that of τD in Remark 1.20, which is used as a trivialization to define a complex determinant: the real structure on Pfaff D / comes directly from the geometry and hence should be respected. A direct consequence of Proposition 1.31 is that the product 1/4
Pfaff D / · τD : T −→ C is a well-defined global function. This product appears as part of the M-theory action; see §2. 1.4. ζ -functions. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on closed manifolds parametrized by T , and work on the open set Ua ⊂ T of (1.4). Define the ζ -functions ζ (a)[s] = Tr (D 2 )−s H0 H0 (a) (1.33) and
A(a)[s] = Tr (D 2 )−s ∇D D −1 H0 H0 (a) .
For Re(s) sufficiently large ζ (a)[s] is a smooth function and A(a)[s] a smooth 1-form on Ua . The basic analytic results are: the function ζ (a)[s] has a meromorphic continuation to s ∈ C which is holomorphic at s = 0; the function A(a)[s] has a meromorphic continuation to s ∈ C with a simple pole at s = 0. The product in (1.9) is, by definition,
d exp − ζ (a)[s] ds s=0 and the trace in (1.10) is d s A(a)[s] . ds s=0 Rewrite (1.33) as ζ (a)[s] = Tr (D 1 D 0 )−s , where D = restriction to
0 D 1 relative to H D0 0 H0 H0 (a). Applying
= H0 ⊕ H1 and we omit from the notation the the differential on T we find
dζ (a)[s] = −s Tr (D 1 D 0 )−(s+1) (∇D 1 ◦ D 0 + D 1 ◦ ∇D 0 ) .
(1.34)
Since D is self-adjoint, and using the cyclicity of the trace, we conclude dζ (a)[s] = −2s Re Tr (D 1 D 0 )−s ∇D 1 ◦ (D 1 )−1 = −2s Re A(a)[s]. (1.35) These manipulations are valid for Re s >> 0, and by analytic continuation for all s. The s-derivative at s = 0 is used in the proof of Proposition 1.11 to show that the metric and covariant derivative on Det D are compatible.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
101
Now assume the manifolds are odd dimensional, as in §1.2. Then ωD 0 = D 1 ω and we have Tr (D 1 D 0 )−(s+1) D 1 ∇D 0 = Tr (D 1 D 0 )−(s+1) D 1 ω2 ∇D 0 = Tr (D 1 D 0 )−(s+1) ωD 0 ∇D 1 ω = Tr ω(D 0 D 1 )−s (D 1 )−1 ∇D 1 ω = Tr ωD 0 (D 1 D 0 )−(s+1) ∇D 1 ω = Tr (D 1 D 0 )−(s+1) ∇D 1 ◦ D 0 . Comparing with (1.34) and (1.35) we see that A(a)[s] is real, and so we may omit ‘Re’ in (1.35). Now we complete the proof of Proposition 1.16 by checking that ∇1 = 0, where 1, defined in (1.19), is in our current notation g(−α) =
det ω(α 2 ) d exp − 21 ds ζ (α 2 )[s]
∈
Det H(α 2 ).
s=0
The covariant derivative on Det H(α 2 ) is ∇ 0 +
d 2 ds s=0(sA(α )[s])
for ∇ 0 the natural
covariant derivative. Note ∇ 0 det ω(α 2 ) = 0. A short computation shows that (1.35) (without ‘Re’) immediately implies ∇1 = 0. 2. M-theory Action on Closed Manifolds M-theory is an 11-dimensional theory. Let Y be an 11-manifold, which in this section we assume is closed. There are two bosonic fields: a Riemannian metric g and a field C which is locally a 3-form on Y . We review the C-field below. There is a single fermionic field, the gravitino or Rarita-Schwinger field ψ, and to accommodate it we also assume that Y is spin.6 Let S 0 ⊕ S 1 → Y be the basic Z/2Z-graded complex Cliff(Y )-module. As explained in the paragraph following (1.3) we may take S 0 = S 1 to be the standard ungraded rank 32 complex spin bundle. Set RS = RS 0 ⊕ RS 1 = S ⊗ T ∗ Y . Then the Rarita-Schwinger field ψ is a section of RS 0 . Note that S, and so also RS, carries a quaternionic structure. Let DS be the Dirac operator on S and DRS the Dirac operator on RS. The effective action for the gravitino is usually written as exp(− gravitino ) = “
pfaff D /RS , (pfaff D /S ) 3
(2.1)
which is a function of the metric g. See Appendix A for a formal derivation and discussion. Recall also from the introduction that our treatment drops certain terms from the 6 M-theory respects parity reversal, so exists on non-oriented and even non-orientable manifolds (which then carry a certain pin structure). In this paper, though, we assume that all manifolds are oriented.
102
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
supergravity action. While (2.1) is problematic, what seems certain is that in a definitive treatment of the gravitino the effective action is a section of the line bundle /S )⊗(−3) −→ T Pfaff D /RS ⊗ (Pfaff D
(2.2)
over any family of Riemannian spin manifolds Y → T . In §1.3 we showed that (2.2) carries a natural real structure, metric, and covariant derivative. Furthermore, its square is canonically trivial (including its geometry). We use the model for the C-field expounded in detail in [DFM], and defer to that paper for details. A C-field is an object in a groupoid CY . In the quantum theory one is instructed to integrate over the space of equivalence classes. The groupoid CY depends on the Riemannian metric g, so the space of equivalence classes of bosonic fields in M-theory is a fiber bundle: the base is the space of equivalence classes of metrics, fiber the space of equivalence classes of C-fields for a fixed metric. An object in CY is a pair (A, c) consisting of a connection A on a principal E8 -bundle7 P → Y and a 3form c ∈ 3 (Y ). We do not review in detail the morphisms or the space of equivalence classes; see [DFM , §3]. Our interest here is in the factor in the exponentiated action, which is usually written in terms of a local 3-form C as
1 C ∧ G ∧ G − C ∧ I8 (g) ”, (2.3) “ exp 2πi Y 6 where I8 (g) is a certain combination of Pontrjagin forms (representing (4p2 −p12 )/192). We now make (2.3) precise in this model for the C-field. Definition 2.4. Let T be a smooth manifold. A family of M-theory data on closed manifolds parametrized by T consists of: (i) a family of closed spin Riemannian 11-manifolds Y → T in the sense of Definition 1.1(i); (ii) a principal E8 -bundle P → Y with a connection A; and (iii) a 3-form c ∈ 3 (Y). Let g denote the metric. Associated to this data are Cliff(Y/T )-modules S → Y and RS → Y generalizing those described in the previous paragraph for a single manifold. We also have a Cliff(Y/T )-module M(A) = S ⊗ Ad P constructed from the induced connection on the real adjoint vector bundle; it also carries a compatible quaternionic structure. Remark 2.5. A family of M-theory data is more information than a family of fields on 11-manifolds, all parametrized by T . For example, the connection A has components in directions transverse to the fibers, as does the 3-form c. These extra components do not affect the definition of the action (2.6) below, but they do enter into the definition of the covariant derivative on the line bundles (2.2) and (2.7). In the bosonic functional integral one is meant to work once and for all with a fixed family parametrized by equivalence classes of bosonic fields. Assume that the fibers of Y → T are closed. Then (2.3) is, by definition [DFM, (4.12)]. 1/2 1/4 −3/4 g, (A, c) . exp(−Sgauge ) g, (A, c) = τDM(A) · τDRS · τDS · exp 2π i Y/T
(2.6) 7
In the notation ‘A’ is understood to signify the connection as well as the bundle P which carries it.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
103
1/2
Here τDM(A) is the global invariant (1.29) for the Clifford module M(A); the next two factors are defined in Remark 1.32; and g, (A, c) is an 11-form whose precise formula is not of interest here. Observe that the first and last factors of (2.6) are globally defined functions on T , whereas the product of the two middle factors is a section of a complex line bundle, namely the bundle 1/2 1/2 ⊗(−3) −→ T LRS ⊗ LS
(2.7)
in the notation of §1.3. Theorem 2.8. Let Y → T be a family of M-theory data parametrized by T with closed fibers. Then the product exp(− gravitino ) · exp(−Sgauge ) is a well-defined function on T . Proof. Use the isomorphism of Proposition 1.31 to construct a trivialization of the tensor product of (2.2) and (2.7). Remark 2.9. The E8 model for the C-field includes equivalences in the groupoid CY and it is crucial that (2.6) is invariant under those equivalences. This is shown in [DFM, §4]. Remark 2.10. The setup of Definition 2.4 and Theorem 2.8 includes the cancellation of gravitational anomalies. To see this, let Y be a fixed closed spin 11-manifold and Met(Y ) the space of metrics on Y . Suppose Diff (Y ) is a group of spin diffeomorphisms of Y which acts freely on the space of metrics. Then Met(Y ) × Y / Diff (Y ) −→ Met(Y )/ Diff (Y ) is a family of closed spin 11-manifolds with a canonical metric along the fibers. This is part of a family of M-theory data parametrized by Met(Y )/ Diff (Y ). The application of Theorem 2.8 to this family is the statement that the quantum integrand is invariant under Diff (Y ). We interpret (2.6) as an “electric coupling” factor in the exponentiated action. That is more evident in the heuristic form (2.3), though the cubic self-coupling of the gauge field is a notable departure from typical electric couplings. The anomaly cancellation and setting of the quantum integrand in Theorem 2.8—of a fermionic pfaffian with an electric coupling—is an example of the Green-Schwarz anomaly cancellation mechanism. 3. (8k + 3)-Dimensional Manifolds with Boundary We return to the general mathematical theory of geometric invariants of Dirac operators, now on compact manifolds with boundary. There are two types of boundary conditions for Dirac operators. The global Atiyah-Patodi-Singer boundary conditions [APS] are ubiquitous in the index theory literature. Local boundary conditions do not exist for arbitrary Dirac operators in even dimensions, so have not been as widely studied. There is, however, a general class of local boundary conditions—for both even and odd dimensions—which lead to geometric invariants analogous to those in the closed case. The general story, in all dimensions, is discussed in Matthew Scholl’s thesis [Sch]. Here we state refinements of his results in the (8k + 3)-dimensional case, as this is what we need for M-theory.
104
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
3.1. Generalities. Let Y be an oriented odd dimensional Riemannian manifold with boundary and M → Y a complex Z/2Z-graded Cliff(Y )-module. Recall from §1.2 that there is an odd endomorphism ω of M—a multiple of Clifford multiplication by the volume form—which is flat, commutes with the Dirac operator D, and squares to the identity. Set N = M ∂Y . We decompose the restriction of ω to ∂Y as ω = γ ν · ω∂
on ∂Y ,
(3.1)
where γ ν is Clifford multiplication by the dual to the outward-pointing unit normal vector, and so ω∂ is Clifford multiplication by a multiple of the volume form on ∂Y . Then γ ν and ω∂ are commuting endomorphisms of N , with γ ν odd, ω∂ even, and (γ ν )2 = (ω∂ )2 = − idN . Decompose N = N+ ⊕ N −
(3.2)
N 0 = N+0 ⊕ N−0
(3.3)
√ according to the eigenvalues ± −1 of ω∂ . Since ω∂ is even the homogeneous pieces N 0 , 1 N decompose separately. The boundary ∂Y is an oriented Riemannian manifold and N → ∂Y restricts to a Cliff(∂Y )-module. Let γ denote the Clifford action. Then N with the Z/2Z-grading (3.2) is a Cliff(∂Y )-module for a modified Clifford action: θ ∈ Ty∗ (∂Y ) acts as γ ν γ (θ). The modified Clifford action preserves N 0 ⊂ N , whence
is a Z/2Z-graded Cliff(∂Y )-module. The associated Dirac operator is
∂ 0 D− ∂ D = ∂ 0 D+
(3.4)
relative to the decomposition (3.2). By the previous remark (3.4) operates on sections of (3.3), i.e., maps sections of N 0 to sections of N 0 . Assume now that Y and M are products near the boundary. In other words, postulate for some > 0 an isometry of the product (−, 0] × ∂Y onto a neighborhood U of ∂Y ⊂ Y and of the pullback of N → ∂Y to (−, 0] × ∂Y with M U , including the metric and covariant derivative. Then γ ν extends over U as do the decompositions (3.1), (3.2) and the Dirac operator (3.4). On U the Dirac operator D decomposes as D = γ ν (∂ν − D ∂ ), where ∂ν is differentiation along the unit normal vector, defined using the product structure on M U . Specialize to dim Y = 8k + 3 and M quaternionic, as in §1.3. The quaternionic struc0 ture J commutes with ω∂ , which has imaginary eigenvalues, and since J : M 0 → M 0 it follows that J (N±0 ) ⊂ N ∓ . In particular, neither N+0 nor N−0 is quaternionic. Rather, J induces a pointwise symplectic pairing λy , λ˜ y −→ Jy λy , λ˜ y ,
λy , λ˜ y ∈ Ny0 ,
y ∈ ∂Y.
(3.5)
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
105
The homogeneous subspaces (N+0 )y and (N−0 )y are lagrangian and pair nondegenerately under (3.5). Assume Y is compact. By integration we obtain a global version of the symplectic form: ˜ |dy|, λ, λ˜ = J λ, λ λ, λ˜ ∈ ∂Y (N 0 ). (3.6) ∂Y
The boundary Dirac operators ∂ D± : ∂Y (N±0 ) −→ ∂Y (N∓0 )
(3.7)
are skew-adjoint relative to (3.6). 0 Recall from (1.21) that on Y we set D / = J ωD : Y (M 0 ) → Y (M ). On a closed manifold this operator is formally skew-adjoint, but on an arbitrary compact manifold the skew-adjointness equation (1.22) acquires a boundary term: ˜ + D ˜ ψ |dy| = D /ψ, ψ /ψ, J ω∂ ψ ∂ , ψ˜ ∂ |dy|, ψ, ψ˜ ∈ Y (M 0 ). Y
∂Y
(3.8) ∂ + ψ ∂ and ψ ∂ +ψ ∂ . Then, up to a factor, the boundary term ˜ = ψ˜ + ˜− Write ψ ∂Y = ψ+ − ∂Y in (3.8) may be expressed in terms of (3.6) as ∂ ˜∂ ∂ ∂ ψ+ , ψ− + ψ˜ + , ψ− .
(3.9)
An elliptic boundary condition for D / is a suitable “half-dimensional” subspace of
∂Y (N 0 ). It determines a formally skew-adjoint operator if the subspace is lagrangian with respect to (3.9). For a local elliptic boundary condition the subspace is the space of sections of a lagrangian subbundle of N 0 → ∂Y . 3.2. Global boundary conditions. Atiyah-Patodi-Singer [APS] introduced global boundary conditions for first-order Dirac operators in the even dimensional case. Generalizations and the odd dimensional analog were studied in many works: see, for example, [SW] and the references therein. We begin with a special class of boundary conditions [J] used to construct the global invariant (3.11) below. Let Y → T be a family of compact (8k + 3)-manifolds and M → Y a Z/2Z graded Cliff(Y/T )-module with compatible quaternionic structure. Set N = M ∂Y . On the boundary family ∂Y → T there is an induced Z/2Z-graded Cliff(∂Y/T )-module N 0 = N+0 ⊕ N−0 , as in (3.3) and associated family of Dirac operators D ∂ , as in (3.4). ∂ ⊕ H∂ → T be the bundle whose fiber at t ∈ T is the space of L2 sections Let H∂ = H+ − 0 of N ∂Y → ∂Yt . Write T = Ua as in (1.4) and recall from (1.5) the finite rank bunt dle H∂ (a) → Ua . A global boundary condition for the restriction of Y → T over Ua is specified by a family of isometries ∂ ∂ It : H+ (a)t → H− (a)t
which are skew-adjoint relative to the pairing (3.7): ˜ λ = 0, It λ, λ˜ + It λ,
∂ (a)t . λ, λ˜ ∈ H+
106
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
The corresponding boundary condition8 on ψ ∈ Yt (M 0 ) is ∂) (D t ∂ ψ+ = 0, + It ⊕ ∂ (D )2t
∂ ψ−
(3.10)
∂ + ψ∂ ∈ 0 0 where ψ ∂ = ψ+ ∂Yt (N+ ⊕ N− ) is the restriction of ψ to ∂Yt and we decom− ∂ ∂ pose (H+ )t into the direct sum of H+ (a)t and its orthogonal complement. The Dirac (a,I ) is elliptic with the boundary conditions defined by (a, I ). Moreover, it is operator Dt also formally skew-adjoint: the boundary term in (3.8) vanishes for ψ, ψ˜ whose restriction to ∂Yt satisfies (3.10), as follows immediately from (3.9) and the skew-adjointness of the operator in (3.10). (a,I ) are exactly the same as those in the closed case [DF, The analytic properties of Dt Appendix A]. The geometric invariants of §1.3 are defined and Proposition 1.26 holds. We do not repeat them here. There is an important generalization of this discussion which replaces the subspace of boundary values defined by (3.10) with a subspace W which is sufficiently “close” and is lagrangian with respect to (3.9). The space of admissible W forms a restricted Grassmannian [Se2, Lecture 2]. We refer to [Wo] for details. 1/2 The particular invariant τD (a,I ) : Ua → T has a global meaning when we consider its behavior under change of global boundary condition (a, I ). Namely, it patches to a global section
τD : T −→ (Pfaff D ∂ )−1 1/2
(3.11)
of the inverse pfaffian line bundle (Pfaff D ∂ )−1 of the family of Dirac operators on ∂Y → T associated to the Cliff(∂Y/T )-module N 0 → ∂Y. In other words, a fiber of (Pfaff D ∂ )−1 is the line of suitably equivariant functions τ on the space of global boundary conditions (a, I ), or equivalently the line of suitably equivariant functions on the restricted Grassmannian of subspaces W . The equivariance is defined by a cocycle c which depends only on the boundary data: τ (a , I ) = τ (a, I ) c (a , I ), (a, I ) ;
(3.12)
1/2
see [DF , Theorem 1.4 ] for details. Note that |τD | = 1. In particular, Pfaff D ∂ is 1/2 topologically trivial. (It is not in general geometrically trivial as ∇τD may be nonzero.) 3.3. Local boundary conditions. Return now to a single manifold Y , an (8k +3)-dimensional compact Riemannian manifold; M → Y a quaternionic Cliff(Y )-module; and N 0 → ∂Y the induced Cliff(∂Y )-module (3.3). Definition 3.13. A local boundary condition is a flat unitary section of End N 0 → ∂Y which is even relative to (3.3), satisfies 2 = idN 0 , anticommutes with T ∗ (∂Y ) ⊂ Cliff(∂Y ), and anticommutes with J in the sense that J = −¯ J . 8
In a Hamiltonian interpretation (3.10) projects out the negative energy modes.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
107
The Cliff(∂Y )-action is defined after (3.2). It follows that the involutions and ω∂ commute, so we can separately decompose N+0 and N−0 according to the eigenvalues ±1 of : N±0 = N±0 [+] ⊕ N±0 [−]. The domain of the Dirac operator D / with local boundary condition is the set of 0 all ψ ∈ Y (M ) whose restriction ψ ∂ to the boundary satisfies (ψ ∂ ) = ψ ∂ .
(3.14)
Because anticommutes with J the boundary term in (3.8) vanishes and D / is formally skew-adjoint. Also, these local boundary conditions are elliptic: the topological and geometric invariants of §1.3 are well-defined [Sch]. Local boundary conditions always exist in odd dimensions. √ √ For the (8k + 3)-dimensional case we have the special boundary conditions = −1 ω∂ and = − −1 ω∂ . Furthermore, we can choose the sign independently on different components of ∂Y . Remark 3.15. Suppose Y is spin and M = S ⊗ E → Y, where S is the Z/2Z-graded spin bundle and E is a real vector bundle. Let F = E ∂Y . On the boundary the spin bundle into eigenspaces of ω∂ , so for the restriction of the even part we have splits ∂ ⊕S ∂ .A local boundary condition amounts to a splitting F = F ⊕F , 0 ∂ S ∂Y = S = S+ + − − and the boundary condition (3.14) translates to ∂ ∂ ⊗ F+ ⊕ S− ⊗ F− ). ψ ∂ ∈ ∂Y (S+
(3.16)
√ √ If = − −1 ω∂ or = −1 ω∂ , then F− = 0 or F+ = 0 and (3.16) specializes to ∂ ⊗ F) ψ ∂ ∈ ∂Y (S+
or
∂ ψ ∂ ∈ ∂Y (S− ⊗ F ).
Since graded commutes with Cliff(∂Y ), it anticommutes with the Dirac operator D ∂ , which therefore restricts to operators D ∂ [±] : ∂Y N+0 [±] −→ ∂Y N−0 [∓] .
(3.17)
Also, as anticommutes with J , the domain and codomain in (3.17) are dually paired (pointwise by (3.5)) and the operators in (3.17) are formally skew-adjoint. The operators in (3.17) are the Dirac operators D ∂ [+] and D ∂ [−] associated to the Z/2Z-graded Cliff(∂Y )-modules N 0 [+] = N+0 [+] ⊕ N−0 [−], N 0 [−] = N+0 [−] ⊕ N−0 [+]. Now suppose T parametrizes a geometric family of Dirac operators on compact (8k + 3)-manifolds, as in the previous sections. By contrast with the global boundary conditions, a local boundary condition may be defined over the entire √ parameter space T . In particular, as remarked previously the special choices = ± −1 ω∂ exist for all families.
108
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
Theorem 3.18. Let D be a geometric family of Dirac operators on compact (8k + 3)manifolds parametrized by T with local boundary condition . As in (1.21) define D / = ∂ J ωD . Let D [±] be the induced Dirac operators (3.17) on the boundary family. Then there is a geometric isomorphism
Pfaff D /
⊗2
−1 ∼ = Pfaff D ∂ [+] ⊗ Pfaff D ∂ [−] .
(3.19)
The isomorphism preserves the metric and covariant derivative. There is no compatible real structure; indeed, Pfaff D / → T may have nontrivial curvature. While (3.19) expresses the square of the pfaffian line bundle explicitly, in general we cannot express Pfaff D / directly in terms of boundary data. See, for example, Proposition 1.31 for the √ case where the boundary is empty. But for the special √ boundary conditions = ± −1 ω∂ we can say more. For definiteness take = − −1 ω∂ , so that the right-hand side of (3.19) is Pfaff D ∂ [+] = Pfaff D ∂ . Recall from (3.11) that −1/2 −1/2 there is a global section τD of this line bundle, with |τD | = 1. The following simple observation defines a square root of this bundle and section. Lemma 3.20. Let K → T be a smooth complex line bundle with metric and covariant derivative, and s : T → K a nonzero section. Then there is a functorially defined line bundle K 1/2 → T with metric, covariant derivative, and nonzero section s 1/2 : T → K 1/2 together with an isomorphism (K 1/2 )⊗2 ∼ = K under which (s 1/2 )⊗2 = s. Also, 1 ∇s 1/2 1/2 1/2 1/2 |s | = |s| and ∇s =2 s s . Proof. The section s gives an isomorphism of K with the trivial bundle: the geometry is 1/2 to be the trivial bundle characterized by the function |s| and the 1-form ∇s s . Take K ∇s 1 with metric |s|1/2 and covariant derivative 2 s . Under these isomorphisms both the section s and its square root s 1/2 are identified with the constant function 1. Conjecture √ 3.21. In the situation of Theorem 3.18 for the special boundary conditions = ± −1 ω∂ there are geometric isomorphisms √ = − −1 ω∂ , √ = −1 ω∂ .
1/2 Pfaff D / ∼ , = Pfaff D ∂ ∼ ∂ −1/2 , Pfaff D / = Pfaff D
(3.22)
∓1/2
The square roots are defined by the sections τD of (Pfaff D ∂ )±1 and Lemma 3.20. More generally, suppose ∂Y = (∂Y )√ i is written as a disjoint √ union of components and on each (∂Y )i we choose either i = −1 ω∂ or i = − −1 ω∂ . Then 1/2 Pfaff D / ∼ ⊗ = Pfaff D ∂
Pfaff D (∂Y )i
−1
,
i such √ that i = −1 ω∂
where D /(∂Y )i is the boundary Dirac operator (3.4) on the i th boundary component. Notice that if ∂Y = ∅ then (3.22) reduces to Proposition 1.31.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
109
4. M-Theory Action on Compact Manifolds with Boundary The two types of mathematical boundary conditions discussed in §3—global and local— correspond in physics to what we term temporal and spatial boundaries. In real time (Lorentzian signature) a temporal boundary is a spacelike hypersurface. In quantum field theory one associates a Hilbert space to a temporal boundary, and then the functional integral represents a state in the Hilbert space attached to the boundary. Global boundary conditions for fermionic fields determine a second state in the Hilbert space, and the functional integral with fixed global boundary conditions is the inner product of the two states. A spatial boundary is simply a boundary of space, so in the real time picture a boundary of each spacelike hypersurface. In quantum field theory spacetime locality requires that boundary conditions for spatial boundaries be defined pointwise, so are local. They are part of the definition of the theory. In this section we generalize Theorem 2.8 to allow temporal or spatial boundaries. We first discuss the formal structure in general. 4.1. Actions and anomalies. Consider a quantum field theory defined on a closed manifold Y . Let BY denote the space of bosonic fields. Fields with internal symmetry, such as gauge fields and metrics, are best thought of as objects in a groupoid, so we assume in general that BY is a groupoid. The effective exponentiated action, after integrating out any fermionic fields in the theory, is a section exp(−Seff ) : BY −→ KY
(4.1)
of a line bundle9 KY → BY with metric and covariant derivative ∇. The notation in (4.1) implies that morphisms (gauge transformations) in BY are lifted to KY and that exp(−Seff ) is invariant. The expression exp(−Seff ) is meant to include everything: integrated out fermionic fields, kinetic energy factors, Chern-Simons type factors, etc. In quantum field theory one imagines that the space BY of equivalence classes of bosonic fields carries a measure and one defines the partition function as the integral of exp(−Seff ) over BY with respect to that measure; correlation functions are defined similarly. Even formally this integral is not defined—one cannot add the values of exp(−Seff ) at different points as they lie in distinct lines. Therefore, to define formally the quantum theory we need as well a section 1 : BY → KY
(4.2)
|1| = 1, ∇1 = 0.
(4.3)
which trivializes KY geometrically:
Then exp(−Seff ) : BY −→ C 1
(4.4)
9 For our purposes a groupoid B consists of a manifold B 0 of objects, a manifold B 1 of morphisms, and a pair of maps B1 ⇒ B0 which define the source and target of a morphism. (Of course there is more structure: an identity map, composition laws, etc.) A line bundle with covariant derivative on B is a line bundle with covariant derivative K → B0 and an isomorphism of the two pullbacks of K to B1 . (The isomorphism must satisfy compatibilities which we do not spell out here.)
110
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
is a global function that one could integrate over BY if one had a measure. In some theories the effective action is naturally a function, say in a theory with only scalar fields and no fermionic fields, so a trivialization (4.2) does not enter explicitly, but in more complicated theories the effective exponentiated action is naturally in the form (4.1) and a trivialization is needed. The obstruction to the existence of a trivialization 1 which satisfies (4.3) is the anomaly. The factors (2.1), (2.6) in the effective exponentiated M-theory action on a closed manifold each have this form. Theorem 2.8 may be interpreted as the construction of a geometric trivialization 1 for their product. As we mentioned in the introduction there can be different choices of 1, two choices differ by a locally constant function on BY , and the different phases on the connected components are moreover constrained by locality conditions. Making a consistent choice is called setting the quantum integrand. See §5.5 for a general discussion of the uniqueness question. Part of the significance of Theorem 2.8 is that we find a canonical isomorphism, allowing us to set the quantum integrand for M-theory on closed 11-manifolds. If Y is compact with spatial boundary then the story is much the same. Here one needs local boundary conditions on all fields, which are part of the definition of the space of fields. With BY understood to be the space (or groupoid) of bosonic fields satisfying the given local boundary conditions, the discussion of the previous paragraph goes through unchanged. ∂ of Now suppose Y is compact with temporal boundary. Then there is a space F∂Y ∂ ∂ allowed boundary conditions for all the fields; it is a fiber bundle F∂Y → B∂Y with base ∂ for the bosonic fields. The fibers are boundary the space of boundary conditions B∂Y conditions for the fermionic fields, which are of global type. In a well-defined theory ∂ over the space of fields one is meant to do the functional integral for each f ∈ F∂Y ∂ , which is whose boundary values equal f . In that case one obtains a “function” on F∂Y ∂ ∂ allowed to be rather a section of a nontrivial line bundle K∂Y → F∂Y . In fact, in any theory we start with the classical action and first integrate out the fermionic fields. This yields the effective exponentiated action, which is a section exp(−Seff ) : BYeff −→ KY
(4.5)
of a line bundle KY → BYeff . Here BYeff is the fiber product π
∂ BYeff −−−−→ F∂Y ρ
(4.6)
∂ BY −−−−→ B∂Y
(In other words, a field in BYeff is a pair (b, f ) consisting of a bosonic field b on Y and a boundary condition f for both bosonic and fermionic fields such that the boundary value of b is10 the bosonic part of f .) The bosonic functional integral is an integral over the ∂ , nominally with integrand (4.5). In other words, we integrate fibers of π : BYeff → F∂Y over the space of equivalence classes of bosonic fields with fixed boundary conditions for both bosonic and fermionic fields. But this is ill-defined as it stands, even formally, as the integrand does not take values in a fixed line. We would like the line to depend only on the boundary values of the bosonic fields on Y , since these are what are held 10 For groupoids of fields the fiber product is in the categorical sense: a field in B eff includes a choice Y of isomorphism of the boundary value of b with the bosonic part of f .
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
111
fixed in the functional integral. Therefore, to define the functional integral over the fibers of π we must specify a generalization of the trivialization (4.2): a line bundle ∂ ∂ K∂Y → F∂Y
(4.7)
with metric and covariant derivative together with an isomorphism ∂ 1 : π ∗ (K∂Y ) −→ KY
(4.8)
∂ → F ∂ is which preserves the metric and covariant derivative. The line bundle K∂Y ∂Y not derived from (4.5), but rather is constructed prior to (4.8). We explain this in §5.4. Using (4.8) we define ∂ 1−1 ◦ exp(−Seff ) : BYeff −→ π ∗ (K∂Y ),
(4.9)
∂ ) → F ∂ . Its (formal) integral over the space of equivalence classes a section of π ∗ (K∂Y ∂Y ∂ → F ∂ . Note (4.9) specializes to (4.4) if ∂Y = ∅. in fibers of π is a section of K∂Y ∂Y In §5.4 we amplify this general discussion. In particular, we relate this Lagrangian (functional integral) point of view to the Hamiltonian approach to anomalies.
Remark 4.10. To clarify the notation consider a theory with a gauge field A and a spinor field ψ coupled to a vector bundle associated to A. Then BY is the groupoid of gauge ∂ of boundary conditions on the boson is the groupoid fields A on Y and the space B∂Y of gauge fields A∂ on ∂Y . For the fermion let HA∂ be the Hilbert space of L2 spinor fields ψ ∂ on ∂Y . A boundary condition for the spinor field ψ on Y is a “half-dimensional” subspace W ⊂ HA∂ which is roughly complementary to the boundary values of ∂ is a pair (A∂ , W ) harmonic spinor fields; cf. the discussion in §3.2. So an object in F∂Y and an object in the groupoid BYeff is a pair (A, W ). The partition function with boundary condition (A∂ , W ) is formally written as dA dψ e−S(A,ψ) . A ∼ ψ ∈W =A∂ ∂Y
∂Y
The result of the inner integral is the pfaffian of a Dirac operator, which is (4.5) in the general discussion above. The outer integral is the integral over equivalence classes in the fiber of π in (4.6). 4.2. Temporal boundary conditions. We resume our discussion of M-theory from §2, now on a compact 11-manifold Y with boundary, which in this subsection is assumed temporal. The part of the effective exponentiated action which concerns us is the product of the gravitino partition function (2.1) and an electric coupling (2.6) which depends on the C-field and the metric. In the notation of §4.1 the groupoid of bosonic fields has objects BY = (g, C) , where g is a metric on Y and C = (A, c) is a C-field, in the model reviewed in §2. The groupoid of boundary conditions on both bosonic and fermionic fields has objects ∂ F∂Y = g ∂ , C ∂ , WRS , WS ,
112
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
where g ∂ , C ∂ are the restrictions of g, C to ∂Y and WRS , WS are global boundary conditions (§3.2) for the Dirac operators DRS , DS which appear in (2.1); the latter are the boundary conditions on the fermionic fields. The fiber product (4.6) is BYeff = g, C, WRS , WS . The generalization of Definition 2.4 to compact manifolds with boundary is the following. Definition 4.11. Let T be a smooth manifold. A family of M-theory data on compact manifolds with temporal boundary parametrized by T consists of: (i) a family of compact spin Riemannian 11-manifolds Y → T in the sense of Definition 1.1(i); (ii) a principal E8 -bundle P → Y with a connection A; (iii) a 3-form c ∈ 3 (Y); (iv) families of subspaces WRS , WS which are global boundary conditions for the oper∂ , D∂ . ators DRS ∂ S∂ Here S = S 0 ⊕ S1 → Y is the spinor bundle. The induced boundary Cliff(∂Y/T )-module is S ∂ = (S 0 ∂Y )+ ⊕ (S 0 ∂Y )− ; see (3.3). For the Rarita-Schwinger Cliff(Y/T )module RS = S ⊗ T ∗ Y the induced Cliff(∂Y/T )-module is RS ∂ ⊕ S ∂ , where RS ∂ = S ∂ ⊗ T ∗ (∂Y/T ).
(4.12)
Now we are in a position to define the factors (2.1), (2.6) of interest for a family of M-theory data with temporal boundary conditions. For the gravitino this is straightfor/S with global boundary conditions WRS , WS determine ward: the Dirac operators D /RS , D pfaffian line bundles (2.2) and a section exp(− gravitino ) : T −→ Pfaff D /RS ⊗ (Pfaff D /S )⊗(−3) .
(4.13)
For (2.6) we note first that the last factor is simply a function on T . The first factor is, according to (3.11), a global section ∂ −1 τDM(A) : T −→ (Pfaff DN(A ∂ )) 1/2
of the pfaffian line bundle of the boundary family of Dirac operators on the Cliff(∂Y/T ) module N(A∂ ) = S ∂ ⊗ Ad P ∂Y with connection induced from A∂ = A ∂Y . Now the product of the square of the middle two factors is a global section of a product L of pfaffian line bundles defined from the boundary data (see (3.11)): 1/2
−3/2
τDRS · τDS
−1 ⊗3 ∂ : T −→ L := Pfaff DRS ⊗ Pfaff DS∂ ∂ . ∂ ⊕S ∂
(4.14)
Lemma 3.20 determines a square root 1/4
−3/4
τDRS · τDS
: T −→ L1/2
(4.15)
for a hermitian line bundle with covariant derivative L1/2 → T equipped with an isomorphism (L1/2 )⊗2 ∼ = L.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
113
Theorem 4.16. Let Y → T be a family of M-theory data parametrized by T with compact fibers and temporal boundary. Then there is a suitable “trivialization” 1 such that exp(− gravitino ) · exp(−Sgauge ) /1 is a section of a hermitian line bundle with connection ∂ −1 ⊗ K −→ T (Pfaff DN(A ∂ ))
(4.17)
which only depends on the boundary data. The bundle K → T is defined in (4.19) below. According to the discussion surrounding (4.9), the fact that (4.17) depends only on boundary data is what is needed to set up the functional integral. We remark that for fixed metric the line bundle (4.17) was discussed in [DFM, §5]. Also, Theorem 4.16 should play an important role in the extension of the computation of [DMW] to manifolds with boundary. Proof. Let T˜ → T be the fiber bundle whose fiber over t ∈ T is the restricted Grassmannian of all possible boundary conditions WRS , WS for the Dirac operators D /RS , D /S ˜ at t; see Definition 4.11(iv). There is a section s : T → T which picks out the particular WRS , WS in the family of M-theory data. 1/2 −3/2 By the definition of the line bundle in (3.11) the product τDRS τDS in (4.14) lifts to an equivariant complex-valued function on T˜ ; the equivariance condition is (3.12). The square root11 of this nonzero function is also equivariant and is a section of a hermitian line bundle which we denote L˜ 1/2 → T˜ . The square (L˜ 1/2 )⊗2 is canonically geometrically trivial. Observe that a point in the fiber of L1/2 at t ∈ T is the space of equivariant sections of L˜ 1/2 restricted to the fiber of T˜ → T over t. Now for fixed boundary conditions (WRS , WS ) the argument of Proposition 1.31 applies to the Dirac operators D /RS , D /S to produce a trivialization /S )⊗(−3) ⊗ s ∗ L˜ 1/2 . (4.18) 1 : T −→ Pfaff D /RS ⊗ (Pfaff D Dividing the product of (4.13) and (4.15) by (4.18) we obtain 1/4
−3/4
exp(− gravitino ) · τDRS · τDS 1
−1 : T −→ L1/2 ⊗ s ∗ L˜ 1/2 .
We claim that the line bundle
−1 −→ T K := L1/2 ⊗ s ∗ L˜ 1/2
(4.19)
depends only on boundary data. This is a nontrivial claim because each factor, defined using Lemma 3.20, depends on the τ 1/2 -invariant of the entire manifold with boundary. Note first that K⊗2 ∼ = L, since the square of L˜ 1/2 is geometrically trivial. Furthermore, as described above a section of L is a suitably equivariant function on T˜ . Hence there is an evaluation map ev : L −→ s ∗ (trivial).
(4.20)
× → This is a special case of Lemma 3.20 which we can make more explicit. Let C be the double × → C which is equivaricover of the nonzero complex numbers. It carries a canonical function z1/2 : C ant for the Z/2Z-action and squares to the identity on C× . It may be viewed as a section of a hermitian line bundle on C× with covariant derivative of order 2 whose square is isomorphic to the trivial bundle. 1/2 −3/2 ˜ : T → C× . In general we pull back from this universal case, for example here by the map τD τD C×
11
RS
S
114
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
This may be regarded as a nonzero section of s ∗ (trivial) ⊗ L∗ → T , so by Lemma 3.20 determines a square root, which is in fact the inverse of the line bundle K in (4.19). As the evaluation map (4.20) depends only on boundary data, we are done.
4.3. Spatial boundary conditions. As a preliminary we state the existence of a “parity involution” σ on C-fields and its effect on the electric coupling (2.6). We defer the proof and discussion to §5.1. Proposition 4.21. Let Y be a compact Riemannian spin 11-manifold with metric g. Then there is an involution12 (A, c) → (A, c)σ on the groupoid of C-fields such that −1 . exp(−Sgauge ) g, (A, c)σ = exp(−Sgauge ) g, (A, c)
(4.22)
Recall that exp(−Sgauge ) g, (A, c) is an elementof a complex line, so implicit in (4.22) is afunctorialisomorphism between the line for g, (A, c)σ and the inverse of the line for g, (A, c) . The field strength G changes sign under σ , and (4.22) is a refined version of the observation that (2.3) is an odd function of the local 3-form C. This involution is relevant to the parity-invariance of M-theory. In this paper we are interested instead in the induced involution on boundary values of C-fields. Recall the Cliff(∂Y )-modules S ∂ and RS ∂ , defined in and before (4.12). Also recall that the Rarita-Schwinger Cliff(Y )-module RS = S ⊗ T ∗ Y induces the Cliff(∂Y )-module RS ∂ ⊕ S ∂ . Finally, the Cliff(Y )-module M(A) = S ⊗ Ad P induces the Cliff(∂Y )-module N (A∂ ) = S ∂ ⊗ Ad P ∂ , where A is a connection on the E8 -bundle P → Y and P ∂ → ∂Y is its restriction to the boundary. Define the line −1 −1/2 1/2 ⊗3 ∂ ∂ ⊗ Pfaff DRS ⊗ Pfaff DS∂ ∂ Lgauge (g ∂ , A∂ , c∂ ) = Pfaff DN(A ∂) ∂ ⊕S ∂ −1 −1/2 ∂ ∂ ∼ ⊗ Pfaff DRS ⊗ Pfaff DS∂ ∂ . (4.23) = Pfaff DN(A ∂) ∂ 1/2
−1/2
The square roots in the first line of (4.23) are defined by the functions τDRS and τDS which play the role of ‘s’ in Lemma 3.20; cf. (3.11). The exponentiated electric coupling (2.6) lives in the line exp(−Sgauge ) g, (A, c) ∈ Lgauge g ∂ , (A∂ , c∂ ) . (4.24) Proposition 4.25. Continuing with Proposition 4.21, let (A∂ , c∂ )σ be the parity-reversal of the boundary values of (A, c). Then there is a functorial isomorphism Lgauge g ∂ , (A∂ , c∂ )σ ∼ = Lgauge g ∂ , (A∂ , c∂ ) ⊗2 ∂ ∂ ∂ ⊗(−2) ⊗ Pfaff DRS . ⊗ Pfaff DN(A ∂) ∂ ⊗ Pfaff DS ∂ (4.26) Furthermore, in a family this isomorphism preserves the metrics and covariant derivatives. 12 This is to be understood in the categorical sense: we are given an equivalence of σ 2 with the identity functor.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
115
Turning to M-theory on manifolds with spatial boundary, we note from the beginning that in addition to the usual fields g, C, ψ there is a bosonic field and a fermionic field χ which live on the boundary. Definition 4.27. Let T be a smooth manifold. A family of M-theory data on compact manifolds with spatial boundary parametrized by T consists of : (i) a family of compact spin Riemannian 11-manifolds Y → T in the sense of Definition 1.1(i); (ii) a principal E8 -bundle P → Y with a connection A; (iii) a 3-form c ∈ 3 (Y); (iv) a principal E8 -bundle Q → ∂Y with a connection ; √ (v) for√each component (∂Y)i of ∂Y = (∂Y)i a choice i = −1 ω∂ or i = − −1 ω∂ ; and (vi) a choice of boundary value isomorphism: see (4.31). We now examine the product of (2.1) and (2.6) using local boundary conditions based on the choice of i . The restriction ψ ∂ of the Rarita-Schwinger field ψ ∈ Y (RS 0 ) to ∂Y decomposes into tangential and normal components: ψ ∂ = ψT∂ + ψν∂ .
(4.28)
Let (ψ ∂ )i denote the restriction to (∂Y)i . Then the boundary condition for the gravitino operator DRS is: √ √ ω∂ (ψT∂ )i = ± −1 (ψT∂ )i √ as i = ∓ −1 ω∂ . (4.29) ∂ ∂ ∂ ω (ψν )i = ∓ −1 (ψν )i There are three “ghost” fields; see Appendix A. The boundary conditions are given in (A.12), (A.13), and (A.14). Those in (A.12) and (A.13) lead to pfaffian line bundles which cancel, due to the opposite signs in those equations. The remaining ghost ghψ has boundary condition (A.14), which we repeat here as √ √ ω∂ (ghψ ∂ )i = ∓ −1 (ghψ ∂ )i as i = ∓ −1 ω∂ . Therefore, taking into account cancellations, Conjecture 3.21 implies that the effective exponentiated gravitino action exp(− gravitino ) is a section of −1 ∂ 1/2 Lgravitino = (Pfaff DRS ⊗ Pfaff DS∂ ∂ ∂) (∂Y) −1 (∂Y) ⊗2 ⊗ ⊗ Pfaff DS ∂ i Pfaff DRS ∂ i −→ T . (4.30) i such √ that i = −1 ω∂
Note that ψν∂ and ghψ combine to give the second factor in each bracketed expression on the right-hand side of (4.30). Let i be the restriction of to (∂Y)i . The boundary condition for the C-field (A, c) on (∂Y)i specifies an isomorphism with or its parity reversal, depending on the sign of i : ! √ if i = − −1 ω∂ ; ∂ ∂ ∼ (i , 0), √ (A , c )i = (4.31) (i , 0)σ , if i = −1 ω∂ .
116
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
The isomorphism is a morphism in the groupoid of C-fields; the choice of isomorphism is part of the data, and it enters (4.32) below. According to (4.24) the exponentiated electric coupling exp(−Sgauge ) takes values in the line bundle Lgauge defined in (4.23). The boundary condition (4.31) and isomorphism (4.26) allow us to rewrite Lgauge in terms of the field . Let N(i ) → (∂Y)i denote the Cliff(∂Y)i -module S (∂Y)i ⊗ Ad Q (∂Y) . i Then the boundary isomorphism (4.31) determines an isomorphism of line bundles Lgauge ∼ =
∂ Pfaff DRS ∂
⊗
−1/2
⊗ Pfaff DS∂ ∂ ⊗
(∂Y)
Pfaff DN(ii)
−1
i such √ that i =− −1 ω∂
(∂Y) (∂Y) (∂Y) ⊗(−2) Pfaff DN(ii) ⊗ Pfaff DRS ∂ i ⊗ Pfaff DS ∂ i −→ T .
i such √ that i = −1 ω∂
(4.32) Finally, χ is a spinor field with values in Ad Q; the chirality of χ depends on the sign of i . Let χi be the restriction of χ to (∂Y)i . Then ! χi ∈
√ if i = − −1 ω∂ ; √ if i = −1 ω∂ .
N (i )+ , N (i )− ,
The exponentiated effective action for χi is (∂Y)
exp(−Sχi ) = pfaff D /N(ii)
or
(∂Y)
pfaff D /N(ii)
−1
(4.33)
,
depending on the sign of i , so the effective exponentiated action for χ is a section of Lχ =
i such √ that i =− −1 ω∂
(∂Y)
Pfaff DN(ii)
⊗
(∂Y)
Pfaff DN(ii)
−1
−→ T .
(4.34)
i such √ that i = −1 ω∂
The tensor product of the factors of interest is therefore a section of the tensor product Lgravitino ⊗ Lgauge ⊗ Lχ → T of (4.30), (4.32), and (4.34), which manifestly has a geometric trivialization. We summarize this discussion in the following, which is rendered as a conjecture since it is based on Conjecture 3.21. Conjecture 4.35. Let Y → T be a family of M-theory data parametrized by T with compact fibers and spatial boundary. Then the product exp(− gravitino ) · exp(−Sgauge ) · exp(−Sχ ) is a section of a line bundle over T which has a distinguished geometric trivialization 1. Therefore, the anomalies in the individual factors cancel and the theory is well-defined with spatial boundary, at least from the point of view of anomalies. Notice that this anomaly cancellation and setting of the quantum integrand work without restriction on the number of boundary components or the topology of the fibers of Y → T , as in Fig. 1.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
117
√ 1 = − −1ω ∂
2 =
(∂Y )1
√
−1ω ∂
(∂Y )2
Y
(∂Y )r
√ r = ± −1ω ∂
Fig. 1. M-Theory is well-defined topologically on 11-manifolds with arbitrary numbers of spatial boundary components and arbitrary chirality projects on each component. Each component carries an independent E8 super Yang-Mills multiplet
5. Further Discussion In this section we record brief remarks on several aspects of the main text. We begin by outlining a construction of the involution (Proposition 4.21) which is needed in §4.3. Next, in §5.2 we remark that an analysis in 3 dimensions, which is parallel to that we did in 11 dimensions, sets the quantum integrand for an M2-brane. M-theory also admits M5-branes, and these are magnetically charged under the C-field. We do not know how to treat magnetic current with the E8 -model, however, so we do not discuss M5-branes in the present paper. The spatial boundary condition for the C-field involves a choice of isomorphism (4.31), and in §5.3 we explain the effect of this choice on the partition function. Finally, in §5.4 we elaborate a bit on our discussion of anomalies and setting the quantum integrand on manifolds with temporal boundary. In particular, we relate it to the Hamiltonian description of anomalies, though we leave a full development for future investigation. 5.1. The E8 -model. The E8 -model for the gauge field C, as introduced in [DFM] and briefly reviewed in §2 of this paper, has many nice features. The fact that the gauge action (2.6) is expressed in terms of geometric index theory invariants allows the direct definition of the partition function that we have given in Theorem 2.8, Theorem 4.16, and Conjecture 4.35. Also, the connection with E8 is crucial for understanding the GreenSchwarz anomaly cancellation for the E8 × E8 Type I supergravity. However, this model has a defect: the algebraic structure of C-fields is not at all explicit. In other words, the space of equivalence classes of C-fields is a torsor for an abelian group,13 and so the groupoid of C-fields must be a torsor in a categorical sense, i.e., a torsor for a Picard category. We do not need this structure, but in §4.3 we do need an involution σ (compatible with the additive inverse on the associated abelian group). We indicate now how to construct σ . Quite generally, we can replace a groupoid with an equivalent groupoid. 13
It is not an abelian group because of the shift in the quantization condition; see [W1].
118
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
Definition 5.1. An equivalence of groupoids C1 , C2 is a functor F : C1 → C2 such that there exists a functor G : C2 → C1 and natural transformations (homotopies) G ◦ F ⇒ idC1 and F ◦ G ⇒ idC2 . Gauge fields are modeled by groupoids, and equivalent groupoids are equally good for the purposes of setting up the functional integral. Of course, different models have different advantages as we see here. On the other hand, we can use the equivalence to transport structure between equivalent groupoids. For example, suppose C2 in the definition has an involution σ2 , that is a functor σ2 : C2 → C2 and a natural transformation σ2 ◦ σ2 ⇒ idC2 . Then σ1 = G ◦ σ2 ◦ F is an involution on C1 . We apply this discussion to C-fields. In [DFM , §3.4 ] we introduce a model for C-fields based on differential cocycles [HS] and prove that it is equivalent to the E8 -model. Let λ(g) ∈ 4 (Y ) denote the Pontrjagin form which represents half the first Pontrjagin class. We regard it as a singular cocycle with real coefficients. Then an object in the differential cocycle model is a triple (a, h, ω) ∈ C 4 (Y ; Z) × C 3 (Y ; R) × 4 (Y ) which satisfies δa = 0, 1 δh = ω − aR + λ(g), 2 dω = 0. The presence of 21 λ(g) reflects the shift in the quantization law mentioned in the previous footnote. The field strength of (a, h, ω) is ω. To define an involution on these triples we need to use a cocycle λ ∈ C 4 (Y ; Z) which represents half the Pontrjagin class as an integer cohomology class; see the next paragraph for a discussion. Then the desired involution (a, h, ω) −→ (λ − a, −h, −ω) sends the field strength to its opposite. Transport it to the E8 -model to define the involution σ of Proposition 4.21. We do not know a direct construction of the desired integer cocycle λ on a Riemannian spin manifold Y , i.e., a construction which only uses the Riemannian metric. We must introduce additional data; see [BryM] for one such construction. Our choice is to pass from the category of Riemannian manifolds to an equivalent category whose objects are Riemannian spin manifolds together with a classifying map of the principal spin bundle of frames; the morphisms of the latter ignore the classifying map. Then we fix once and for all a cocycle λuniv on the classifying space and define λ as the pullback via the classifying map. We must still prove (4.22) and (4.26). To do so it stands to reason that the exponentiated action exp(−Sgauge ) and the line bundle Lgauge should be defined in the model where the involution is apparent; then we can check (4.22) and (4.26) in that model. This is done in [FH]. (In fact, that paper uses an equivalent model closely related to the differential cocycle model.) 5.2. M2-branes. For our purposes here an M2-brane is a 3-dimensional compact neat14 spin submanifold ⊂ Y of the 11-dimensional spin manifold of M-theory. There is a 14
‘Neat’ means that ∩ ∂Y = ∂ and the intersection is transverse.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
119
fermionic field on , a partner to the position of in Y , namely a spinor field λ coupled to the half spin bundle of the normal bundle of in Y . Assume first that is closed. We focus on two factors in the exponentiated effective action. The first is the effective action exp(− λ ) of the spinor field λ, the pfaffian of a Dirac operator on . This is analogous to (2.1). The second is analogous to (2.3) and may be formally written as
“ exp 2πi
C ”.
As in (2.6) we define it precisely in terms of the E8 -model for the C-field: −1/4 exp(−SM2-gauge ) g, (A, c) = CS (A) · τD · exp 2π i c . S
(5.2)
Here CS is the exponentiated E8 Chern-Simons invariant (corresponding to the generator in H 4 (BE8 ; Z)) and the second factor is a power of the τ -invariant of the Dirac operator on acting on spinors S. Each of exp(− λ ) and exp(−SM2-gauge ) is a section of a line bundle with metric and covariant derivative. The analog of Theorem 2.8, which states that the product of these line bundles has a canonical geometric trivialization, is proved with the same analysis (§1.3) of Dirac operators in 8k+3 dimensions, specifically Proposition 1.31. The extension to temporal boundaries for the M2-brane, in which case ∂ ⊂ ∂Y , proceeds analogously to §4. We comment only on the case of a spatial boundary, still assuming ∂ ⊂ ∂Y . There is an additional factor involving fields on ∂, which plays a role analogous to (4.33). This is the partition function of a chiral, level 1, E8 WZW model coupled to the E8 gauge field restricted to ∂. This factor combines with the E8 Chern-Simons term in (5.2) to define the membrane amplitude as a well-defined function. These chiral degrees of freedom have a fermionic formulation when the structure group of reduces to SO(16). In this case the discussion is analogous to §4.3.
5.3. Boundary values of C-fields. For M-theory with spatial boundary there is a specified15 isomorphism (4.31) of the boundary value of the C-field with the boundary C-field derived from the E8 -connection . Let BY (C) be the space of equivalence classes of C-fields on Y and B∂Y () the space of equivalence classes of E8 -connections on ∂Y . There is a subset S ⊂ BY (C) × B∂Y () of the product consisting of equivalence classes which are isomorphic on ∂Y (with the boundary condition (4.31)). The space of equivalence classes of fields in the model with spatial boundary is a principal fiber bundle BY
eff
(C, ) −→ S
(5.3)
with structure group
H 2 (∂Y )i ; R/Z .
(5.4)
i
The action of the structure group changes the isomorphism (4.31) on the boundary. 15 That a choice of isomorphism is needed was stated in §4.1 in the words “(4.6) is a fiber product in the categorical sense”.
120
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
The product exp(− gravitino ) exp(−Sgauge ) exp(−Sχ ) eff : BY (C, ) −→ C 1 is defined by Conjecture 4.35. This function is not constant"on the i.e., fibers of (5.3), is not the pullback of a function on S. Rather, λ = (λi ) ∈ H 2 (∂Y )i ; R/Z acts as i # √ " eff multiplication by exp(2π −1Ni (∂Y )i λi ) at a point of BY (C, ), where Ni is i
(∂Y )
the index of the Dirac operator DN(ii ) . There is a similar formula for the effect on the partition function of an M2-brane ⊂√Y ; then Ni is replaced by ±1 depending on the sign of the boundary condition i = ± −1 ω∂ in Definition 4.27(v). Consider the special case of heterotic M-theory [HW1, HW2]. Here Y =√[0, 1] × X for a closed spin 10-manifold X. The signs in Definition 4.27(v) are 0 = − −1ω∂ and √ 1 = −1ω∂ . One recovers the usual heterotic fields on X by integrating the M-theory fields over [0, 1]. Thus the “integral” of —the sum over the two boundary components—is the E8 × E8 gauge field of the heterotic theory and the integral16 of C is the B-field of the heterotic theory. This B-field is not “closed”: its differential is computed from Stokes’ theorem. (For example, the field strength H ∈ 3 (Y ) of B is a 3-form which satisfies dH = tr F12 + tr F22 − tr R 2 , where (F1 , F2 ) is the curvature of the E8 × E8 bundle, R is the Riemannian17 curvature, and the traces are suitably normalized.) Now the structure group (5.4) is the product of two copies of H 2 (X; R/Z). The diagonal acts trivially in the effective heterotic theory. For the anti-diagonal we identify H 2 (X; R/Z) with the group of isomorphism classes of flat gerbes.18 Then the action of the anti-diagonal adds an equivalence class of flat gerbes to the given equivalence class of B-fields. Said more precisely, the B-field is a differential cochain of degree 3 which trivializes a fixed differential cocycle of degree 4 constructed from the metric and E8 × E8 -connection. The action in question adds a flat differential cocycle of degree 3 to the B-field. This can be measured through its effect on the amplitude of a worldsheet instanton, realized as an open M2-brane in heterotic M-theory.
5.4. Temporal boundaries and the Hamiltonian anomaly. The description in §4.1 of ∂ → F∂ , anomalies in the case of temporal boundaries, specifically the line bundle K∂Y ∂Y is related to the Hamiltonian interpretation of anomalies. The latter was explained by Fadeev and Shatashvili [Fa, FS] and Segal [Se3] as follows. Hamiltonian quantization of fermions on a manifold X leads to a bundle of projective Hilbert spaces over the space of bosons on X, and to quantize the bosons one must lift this projective bundle to a vector bundle. The obstruction is measured topologically by an integral cohomology class of degree three which, more importantly, has a natural geometric realization as we now explain; see [MS, CM, CMM] for further discussion. Set X = ∂Y to be the boundary 16
This integral may be defined in the differential cocycle model discussed in §5.1; see [HS]. In a more precise treatment R would be the curvature of a connection with torsion determined by H . 18 These are the type of “B-field” which appear in Type II theories. They are “closed”. 17
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
121
of a spacetime to make contact with §4.1. Then this cohomology class is described by a ∂ [2] over the fiber product line bundle with covariant derivative L → F∂Y p2
∂ [2] − ∂ F∂Y −−−→ F∂Y ρ p1 ∂ F∂Y
ρ
∂ −−−−→ B∂Y
where ρ is the map in (4.6). Recall that the fiber of ρ is the space of fermionic boundary conditions for fixed bosonic boundary conditions—a restricted Grassmannian of subspaces W —and given two such subspaces W, W there is a natural determinant ∂ [3] there is an isomorphism L line LW,W . Further, over the triple fiber product F∂Y W,W ∂ . The lift of the projective bundle ∼ = LW,W ⊗ LW ,W . This is the data of a gerbe on B∂Y to a vector bundle mentioned above is encoded by a trivialization of this gerbe, which ∂ → F ∂ and an isomorphism is a line bundle with covariant derivative K∂Y ∂Y ∂ ∂ p1∗ K∂Y ⊗ L −→ p2∗ K∂Y
(5.5)
∂ [2]. with appropriate compatibility on F∂Y ∂ ∂ The line bundle K∂Y → F∂Y appears in (4.7). Thus to define a theory which includes temporal boundaries we must first resolve the Hamiltonian anomaly on ∂Y —i.e., produce ∂ → F ∂ satisfying (5.5)—and then specify the isomorphism (4.8). the line bundle K∂Y ∂Y This must be done in a consistent way for all manifolds Y , constrained by physical requirements such as locality (gluing laws). In the 8k +3 dimensional situation considered in this paper, the cancellation of anomalies (and setting of the quantum integrand) is Theorem 4.16. Furthermore, we expect that an analog of Proposition 1.31, which we do not work out here, may be used to ∂ → F ∂ directly from the boundary data. Namely, the electric coupling construct K∂Y ∂Y ∂ , just as the Hamiltonian quantization of fermions term determines a gerbe over B∂Y does, and the product of the two gerbes should have a canonical trivialization. (In this case both gerbes have a compatible real structure.) This is the Hamiltonian version of the Green-Schwarz mechanism. It would be interesting to investigate further the many mathematical questions underlying this brief sketch.
5.5. Topological terms. The trivialization 1 in (4.2) which sets the quantum integrand need not be unique. The ratio of two choices is a locally constant function ∂ Z : B∂Y −→ C
(5.6)
of unit norm. (We resume the notation of §4.1.) Each trivialization 1 must satisfy gluing laws, though we have not attempted to make them precise here. Nonetheless, there is a natural gluing assumption for the ratio (5.6) of two trivializations, namely that it has the properties of the exponential of a topological term [DeF, Chapter 6] in a classical action. Thus it extends to manifolds Y with boundary, it lies in a complex line which only depends on the boundary data, and it is multiplicative under gluing. Considering that (5.6) is also locally constant, we can simply say that it is the partition function of a topological quantum field theory (TQFT) with special properties.
122
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
Definition 5.7. An invertible topological quantum field theory (ITQFT) on oriented n-manifolds is an n-dimensional TQFT in which (i) the complex vector space LZ attached to an oriented (n − 1)-manifold Z is onedimensional; (ii) there is a natural isomorphism LZ ∼ = L−1 Z , where Z is the oppositely oriented manifold; (iii) the invariant ZY of an n-manifold Y is nonzero; and (iv) ZY = ZY−1 . An ITQFT is unitary if in addition LZ is hermitian and |ZY | = 1. Note that in a general TQFT there is no analog of axioms (ii) and (iv); the pairing between the vector space associated to Z and that associated to Z is induced from the cylinder on Z; see [Qu, Se2, Lecture 1]. Also, recall that in a general unitary TQFT the inverses in (ii) and (iv) are replaced by the complex conjugates. The category of manifolds on which the ITQFT is defined depends on the field content. For example, in M-theory it is the bordism category whose objects are spin 10-manifolds equipped with a degree four integral cohomology class. (We term this an ITQFT on 11-manifolds of the given type, as it is an 11-dimensional theory.) Summarizing, ratios of settings of the quantum integrand are ITQFTs. We do not have a definitive classification of ITQFTs in general, nor in the case relevant to M-theory, but will report several observations. Proposition 5.8. Let Z be the partition function of an ITQFT on compact oriented n-manifolds, and suppose Z(S n ) = 1. Then Z is an oriented bordism invariant of n-manifolds: if Y = ∂W for W a compact oriented (n + 1)-manifold, then Z(Y ) = 1. Proof. More generally, let W be a bordism between closed oriented n-manifolds Y0 and Y1 . Choose a Morse function f : W → [0, 1] with Y0 = f −1 (0), Y1 = f −1 (1), and such that for each critical value c ∈ (0, 1) there is a unique critical point in Yc = f −1 (c). Then for > 0 sufficiently small, Yc+ is obtained from Yc− by a surgery. Namely, there is a compact n-manifold Y− with boundary diffeomorphic to S p × S q , p + q = n − 1, so that Yc− Y− ∪ (D p+1 × S q ), Yc+ Y− ∪ (S p × D q+1 ). Here D r+1 is the r-dimensional ball with boundary S r . The gluing law implies that Z(Yc− ) = Z(Y− )−1 · Z(D p+1 × S q ), Z(Yc+ ) = Z(Y− )−1 · Z(S p × D q+1 ),
(5.9)
where the product is the inner product in the one-dimensional Hilbert space attached to S p × S q . Also, the gluing law applied to the decomposition S n = (D p+1 × S q ) ∪ (S p × D q+1 ) shows that −1
1 = Z(S n ) = Z(D p+1 × S q )
· Z(S p × D q+1 ).
(5.10)
Combining (5.9) and (5.10) we conclude Z(Yc− ) = Z(Yc+ ), whence Z(Y0 ) = Z(Y1 ).
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
123
The converse, that the exponential of an R/Z-valued bordism invariant of oriented n-manifolds defines an ITQFT with Z(S n ) = 1, is true. The argument, due to M. Hopkins, uses ideas from homotopy theory. We do not give it here. Next, observe that the product of two ITQFTs is again an ITQFT. Now for each λ ∈ C with λ = 0 there is a simple ITQFT whose partition function Zλ on a closed n-manifold Y is Zλ (Y ) = λχ(Y )/2 , where χ (Y ) is the Euler characteristic. In even dimensions we have Zλ (S n ) = λ, which proves the following. Corollary 5.11. Let Z be the partition function of an ITQFT on compact oriented n-manifolds, n even, and suppose Z(S n ) = λ. Then Z = Zλ · Z , where Z is an oriented bordism invariant. Corollary 5.11 gives the complete story for oriented manifolds in even dimensions. We suspect that any ITQFT on compact oriented manifolds in odd dimensions has Z(S n ) = 1, thus is a bordism invariant, but we do not have a proof in general. For n = 3 dimensions, the first nontrivial case, there is a proof for oriented manifolds. Proposition 5.12. Let Z be the partition function of an ITQFT on compact oriented 3-manifolds. Then Z(S 3 ) = 1. Proof. Since the Hilbert space associated to S 2 is one-dimensional, we have Z(S 1 × S 2 ) = 1. Choose Heegaard decompositions S 1 × S 2 Y− ∪g Y+ , S 3 Y− ∪g Y+
(5.13)
for g a closed oriented 2-manifold of genus g ≥ 3. The gluing maps in (5.13) differ by an orientation-preserving diffeomorphism of g , and the ratio of Z(S 3 ) to Z(S 1 × S 2 ) = 1 is the action of this diffeomorphism on the one-dimensional Hilbert space associated to g . But that action is part of a one-dimensional representation of the mapping class group, and for genus g ≥ 3 the mapping class group is perfect [P], whence the action is trivial and Z(S 3 ) = 1. In higher dimensions we can show that if n is odd, then Z(S n ) is a fourth root of unity. For example, write S 5 (D 3 × S 2 ) ∪S 2 ×S 2 (S 2 × D 3 ), S 3 × S 2 (D 3 × S 2 ) ∪S 2 ×S 2 (S 2 × D 3 ), and that the ratio of the gluing maps, the orientation-preserving diffeomorphism 0 1observe 2 × S 2 , has order 2. Then of S 10 S 3 × S 2 (D 2 × S 1 ) × S 2 ∪(S 1 ×S 1 )×S 2 S 1 × S 2 × S 2 (D 2 × S 1 ) × S 2 ∪(S 1 ×S 1 )×S 2
(S 1 × D 2 ) × S 2 , (S 1 × D 2 ) × S 2 ,
124
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
and the ratio of the gluing maps is the orientation-preserving diffeomorphism 01 −1 0 of S 1 × S 1 times the identity of S 2 , which has order 4. Finally, note that Z(S 1 × X) = 1 for any X. The argument continues to all higher odd-dimensional spheres. For the applications to quantum field theory, string theory, and M-theory we need to complete these arguments and extend them to other bordism categories of manifolds. Finally, we remark that there are ITQFTs in n = 3 dimensions which have Z(S 3 ) = 1. One such example is Chern-Simons theory for the group U1 at the lowest level. Then Z(S 3 ) is a 24th root of unity. This is not a contradiction to Proposition 5.12: recall the “framing anomaly” of Chern-Simons theory [W2]. It translates to the assertion that Chern-Simons theory is defined on a different bordism category. For this particular case we also have a spin structure, so we obtain the bordism category of string manifolds string (or, in the older literature, MO8-manifolds). The relevant bordism group 3 is cyclic of order 24—it agrees with the framed bordism group in this low dimension— and we conjecture that this U1 Chern-Simons theory is constructed from an isomorphism string 3 → Z/24Z. Appendix A: The Gravitino Path Integral A.1. The gravitino theory. In this appendix we review the formal definition of the partition function of a gravitino as commonly used in supergravity. (See [N, K, vN, FT] for a sample of the literature. For a good recent account of the boundary conditions in heterotic M-theory see [M].) As we will note this subject has not been adequately investigated in the literature, and consequently our discussion has some important gaps. Filling these gaps is beyond the scope of this paper. In this appendix we simply indicate how the standard discussion proceeds. Let Y be a Riemannian spin manifold of any dimension and S → Y a spin bundle. The gravitino field is a section of S ⊗ T ∗ Y . One may impose chiral and/or Majorana projections. The equations of motion are written using an operator R defined by composition of Clifford multiplication by 3-forms with the covariant derivative: R : (S ⊗ T ∗ Y ) → (S ⊗ T ∗ Y ). In local coordinates x M , M = 1, . . . , n, we have ψ = ψM dx M and we define: (Rψ)M := γ MNP ∇N ψP , where γ MNP denotes Clifford multiplication by the three-form dx M ∧ dx N ∧ dx P . The equation of motion Rψ = 0 follows from the action ¯ ψRψ |dy|. (A.1) Y
We would therefore like to make sense of the formal gravitino path integral # ¯ Z = [dψ]e− Y ψRψ|dy| .
(A.2)
In general, the path integral (A.2) formally vanishes, because the action has an anticommuting gauge symmetry: ψM → ψM + ∇M .
(A.3)
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
125
One may easily check that this is a local gauge symmetry of the action (A.1) when the background Riemannian metric is Ricci-flat. In this case, one attempts to define the true partition function Z of the gravitino by “dividing by the volume of the gauge group.” Unfortunately, this volume is zero, so one must proceed somewhat formally. When the background metric is not Ricci-flat (A.3) is not a local symmetry of (A.1). Nevertheless, the full supergravity action has a local (super) gauge invariance which involves the transformation (A.3). However, if the background is not on-shell the gauge transformations do not close into a super Lie algebra of symmetries and one must use the BV formalism to quantize the theory. This in turn leads to substantial complications in the quantization of supergravity which we will not discuss. Instead we will restrict attention in this appendix to backgrounds with vanishing G-flux and Ricci-flat metrics. This restriction is a first significant gap in our discussion. A.2. Local analysis of the equations of motion. Since the action (A.1) has a gauge symmetry, quantization involves ghost fields. In order to understand the nature of these ghosts let us review briefly the standard discussion of the physical degrees of freedom of the gravitino (see, for example, [vN, F3 , Appendix ]). Here we study the equations of motion in flat Minkowski space. Thus S = S0 ⊕ S1 is a Z/2Z-graded real representation of the Lorentz spin group. The gravitino operator fits into a complex ∇
∇∗
R
0 → 0 (S0 ) −→ 1 (S0 ) −→ 1 (S1 ) −→ 0 (S1 ) −→ 0.
(A.4)
The space of gauge inequivalent solutions of the equations of motion is the degree one cohomology of (A.4). In a flat Minkowski space of n dimensions we analyze this cohomology as follows. Write the wave equation in a momentum basis γ MNP kN ψP = 0. Now use γM γ MNP = (2 − n)γ NP . Hence, for n − 2 = 0, γ MN kM ψN = 0. Now use two more gamma matrix identities to write: γ MN kM ψN = (γ · k)(γ · ψ) + k · ψ, (γ
MN
kN )(γ · ψ) = γ
MNP
(A.5)
kN ψP + γ (k · ψ) − (γ · k)ψ . M
M
(A.6)
From (A.5), (A.6) we conclude that if we fix the gauge γ · ψ = 0, then k · ψ = 0 and (γ · k)ψ M = 0. We will henceforth fix this gauge. From (γ · k)ψ M = 0 we learn that for ψ M = 0 we must have k 2 = 0. Now, since k 2 = 0, any gravitino wave-function can be expanded (i) ψM = kM s1 + k¯M s2 + M si ,
where k 2 = k¯ 2 = 0; k · k¯ = 1; and (i) , i = 3, . . . , n, form a basis for the transverse ¯ From k · ψ = 0 we learn s2 = 0. Now we still have the gauge space to the span of k, k.
126
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
freedom to shift ψM → ψM + kM s1 preserving the gauge choice γ · ψ = 0. Thus, we can fix the gauge completely by taking (i)
ψM = M si . (i)
Note that we still have γ M M si = 0 and (γ · k)si = 0, for each i. Now from (γ · k)si = 0 we learn the following. Choose a frame so that k = E(1, h, 0n−2 ) with h = ±1. Then (γ · k) = Eγ 0 (1 − hγ 0 γ 1 ) is proportional to a projection operator, so under the decomposition Spin(1, n) ⊃ Spin(1, 1) × Spin(n − 2) (i)
we have si ∈ [2[(n−2)/2] ]h is an irreducible spinor of Spin(n−2). Next from γ M M si = 0 (i) we learn that M si is in the irreducible representation of the tensor product of the vector of Spin(n − 2) with the spinor [2[(n−2)/2] ]. Thus, the cohomology gives the expected physical solutions. An important lesson we may draw from this computation is that in the BRST quantization there will be three ghosts. Two of these will be of the same chirality as the gravitino, k M ψM and kM , while the third ghost, γ · ψ, will be of opposite chirality. A.3. Partition function. We return to Euclidean field theory and so to a Riemannian manifold Y with Z/2Z-graded spin bundle S = S 0 ⊕ S 1 → Y . If we follow the paradigm of abelian gauge theory then the most natural definition of the gravitino partition function follows from the complex (A.4). Let R ⊥ be the restriction to (ker R)⊥ . Then the partition function should be Z=
det R ⊥ det ∇M , det (−∇ ∗ ∇)
(A.7)
where ∇M : 0 (S 0 ) → ker R. Let us first formally justify (A.7) using the BRST procedure. We fix the gauge using ∇ M ψM = s, where s is an arbitrary spinor. This leaves unfixed the covariantly constant spinors, which, by our assumption of Ricci-flatness, are the same as the harmonic spinors. We will deal with gauge fixing this finite dimensional part of the gauge group below Eq. (A.10). Following standard procedure we now write: 1= d δ s − ∇ M (ψM + ∇M ) (det − ∇ ∗ ∇)−1 , 0 (S 0 )⊥
where 0 (S 0 )⊥ is the orthogonal complement of kerD/ = ker(−∇ ∗ ∇). This expression is to be inserted in (A.2). Using gauge invariance of the action we may write:
# ¯ Z= d dψδ s − ∇ M ψM (det − ∇ ∗ ∇)−1 e− ψRψ|dy| . 0 (S 0 )⊥
The formal division by the gauge group removes the first factor to produce the partition function Z. The remaining integral may be evaluated to give (A.7), by the choice of gauge s = 0.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
127
Unfortunately, (A.7) is not in a form convenient for anomaly analysis. A second form follows from the formal BRST procedure by choosing a different gauge, s = γ · ψ, for an arbitrary spinor s ∈ 0 (S 1 )⊥ . We now write 1= dδ s − γ M (ψM + ∇M ) (det D + )−1 (A.8) 0 (S 0 )⊥
for D + : 0 (S 0 ) → 0 (S 1 ) the Dirac operator. We now insert (A.8) into (A.2), shift the field, and divide by the volume of the gauge group to obtain the gauge-fixed expression # ¯ Z = dψδ(s − γ · ψ)(det D + )−1 e− ψRψ . The ghost fields may be introduced by writing the determinant in (A.8) in terms of commuting ghost and antighost β fields as # ¯ + + −1 (det D ) = dβde− βD . At this point, rather than setting s = 0 we average over s using the expression # 1 − s¯ D − s|dy| 1= dse , (A.9) (det D − )1/2 0 (S 1 )⊥ where D − : 0 (S 1 ) → 0 (S 0 ) is the Dirac operator. We now invoke an algebraic identity. If φM = ψM + 21 γM (γ · ψ) then 1 ¯ +∗ φ = ψRψ ¯ −φD − (n − 2)(γ · ψ)D(γ · ψ). T Y 4 Thus, again formally dividing by the volume of the gauge group we obtain Z=
(det DT+∗ Y )1/2 . (det D + )(det D − )1/2
(A.10)
Since the path integral is independent of the choice of gauge we conclude that (A.10) is the same as (A.7). There remains the gauge-fixing of the supersymmetry transformations by the covariantly constant spinors. For this finite dimensional supergauge group we will again insert 1= dF (, ψ, g), (A.11) ker D
where F is a distribution concentrated on some gauge slice. (There does not appear to be any particularly natural choice for F .) Now the Berezin measure d on the odd vector space ker D transforms as a section of the line bundle (Det ker D)−1 . The latter is identified with Pfaff D /. By (A.11) F (, ψ, g) transforms in the inverse line bundle. In the gauge fixing procedure we factor out the gauge group leaving behind F (0, ψ, g) in the path integral. The product F (0, ψ∗ (g), g) · Z is a section of a determinant line bundle. Specifically, for dim Y = 11 we identify S 0 and S 1 using the volume form (§1.2) and rewrite (A.10) using pfaffians (§1.3). This yields (2.1) and provides the motivation for our choice of line bundle with covariant derivative in (2.2).
128
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore
A.4. Boundary conditions for ghosts. Let us finally consider the analysis of the gravitino determinant for dim Y = 11 in the presence of a boundary, as in §4.3. For further simplicity we will assume the boundary Dirac operator D ∂ has no zeromodes. The boundary conditions on the gravitino are given in (4.29), and we make a definite choice of sign. Recall that the restriction ψ ∂ of the Rarita-Schwinger field ψ to ∂Y decomposes into its tangential and normal components (4.28). Then the boundary conditions are: √ ω∂ ψT∂ = + −1 ψT∂ , √ ω∂ ψν∂ = − −1 ψν∂ , where T denotes the tangential component and ν the normal component. These boundary conditions imply that the gauge group must be restricted by √ ω∂ ∇T ∂ = + −1 ∇T ∂ , √ ω∂ ∇ν ∂ = − −1 ∇ν ∂ . (A.12) We then choose boundary conditions on β so that D + is skew-adjoint: √ ω∂ ∇T β ∂ = − −1 ∇T β ∂ , √ ω∂ ∇ν β ∂ = + −1 ∇ν β ∂ .
(A.13)
The third ghost determinant comes from integrating over s (A.9), which has the same boundary condition as γ · ψ: √ (A.14) ω∂ (s ∂ ) = − −1 s ∂ . The boundary conditions (A.12) and (A.13) do not fit the discussion on local boundary conditions for Dirac operators given in §3.3. We can relate them to the standard ones, at least topologically. Note first that if there are no covariantly constant spinors on the boundary, which we assume, then the first equation in (A.12) is equivalent to 0 ). Similarly, the first equation in (A.13) is equivalent to the the condition ∂ ∈ 0∂Y (S+ 0 ∂ 1 condition β ∈ ∂Y (S− ). Let us define 0 0 $0 (S 0 ) := { ∈ 0 (S 0 )| ∂ ∈ 0∂Y (S+ ), (∇ν )∂ ∈ 0∂Y (S− )}.
We then have the diagram 0
- $0 (S 0 ) D+
0
- 0 (S 0 ) ∂ 0 ∈
0 ∂Y (S+ )
π+ ◦ ∇ν
D+
? - 0 (S 1 ) ∂ 0 β ∈
0 ∂Y (S− )
? - 0 (S 1 )
0,∂ 0 (S+ )
- 0
γν ∗ π+ ◦ ι-
? 1,∂ 0 (S+ )
- 0
where π+ is the projection to the positive chirality spinors and ι∗ is pullback to the boundary. Each vertical arrow is a Fredholm operator. The right-most arrow is an isomorphism, and hence it follows that topologically the determinant lines (and Pfaffian lines) associated to the other two vertical arrows are isomorphic. We expect that the metrics and covariant derivatives similarly match up, but we have not checked the details.
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
129
Appendix B: Quaternionic Fredholms and Pfaffians We prove a theorem about a special space of Fredholm operators which is a topological version of Proposition 1.31. We include it here to emphasize the topological nature of the latter. We remark that the similar Proposition 1.16 is not topological; there is no analog for Fredholm operators.19 For determinants and pfaffians on spaces of Fredholm operators, see [Q] and [Se1]. Dirac operators on compact manifolds are special examples of Fredholm operators. Whereas Dirac operators have discrete spectrum with no accumulation points, a basic fact for the geometric constructions of §1, general Fredholm operators have continuous spectrum. Spaces of Fredholm operators are classifying spaces for K-theory [AS]. Let H be a separable complex Hilbert space with a unitary quaternionic structure J : H → H. Thus J J = − idH and J is skew-adjoint in the sense that J v, w + J w, v = 0,
v, w ∈ H.
Define F = {T : H → H : T is Fredholm, T is skew-adjoint, T J = J T }. This space of skew-adjoint quaternion Fredholm operators has two contractible components and a third component which is a classifying space for KR −3 . There are two natural real line bundles Pfaff → F and L1/2 → F which we now construct. A subspace A ⊂ H is said to be quaternionic if J (A) = A. For finite dimensional quaternionic A ⊂ H we define the open set UA = {T ∈ F : T (A) ⊆ A, T (H) ⊕ A = H}. Let Pfaff A → UA be the real line bundle whose fiber at T ∈ UA is the pfaffian of the skew-adjoint operator T A : A → A. The real structure is given by pfaff J A . (See the paragraph containing (1.23) for a discussion of finite-dimensional pfaffians.) If A ⊂ B then on UA ∩ UB there is a canonical isomorphism Pfaff B ∼ = Pfaff A ⊗ Pfaff B/A , where the fiber of Pfaff B/A at T is the Pfaffian line of T : B/A → B/A. The pfaffian of that operator is nonzero and real, and this gives an isomorphism Pfaff A → Pfaff B . For A ⊂ B ⊂ C a cocycle identity is satisfied, so by patching we obtain a global real line bundle Pfaff → F. To construct the bundle L1/2 → F we observe that for T ∈ F the composition (T S ) = J T : H → H is self-adjoint Fredholm and quaternion linear in the sense that J S (T ) = S (T ) J . So its eigenspaces For the A ⊂ H finite dimen are quaternionic. 1/2 (T ) sional quaternionic set SA = S (T ) A . Let LA → UA be the real line bundle whose fiber at T is
α<λ<β # (T ) (T ) fA : R \ H spec(SA ) −→ R : fA (β) = (−1) λ∈H spec(SA ) fA (α) . (B.1) 19 The space of self-adjoint Fredholm operators on a complex Hilbert space has only one natural real line bundle, analogous to (1.15) and the construction below; there is no nontrivial (real) determinant line bundle.
130
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore (T )
(T )
On A ⊂ B we note that SB/A : B/A → B/A is invertible, so the spectrums of SA 1/2
(T )
1/2
and SB agree in a neighborhood of 0 ∈ R. Define an isomorphism LB → LA which identifies fA and fB if fA = fB in this neighborhood of zero. This satisfies a cocycle identity, so defines a global line bundle L1/2 → F. It carries a natural metric. Proposition B.2. The real line bundles Pfaff → F and L1/2 → F are isomorphic. Equivalently, the tensor product L1/2 ⊗ Pfaff → F is trivializable. For this topological theorem we make a choice (of a norm) to specify a trivialization. In the result for Dirac operators, Proposition 1.31, the trivialization is required to have unit norm, and this leads to the canonical construction in the proof of that result. Proof. The space F is paracompact, so use a partition of unity to construct a metric on Pfaff → F. Set JA = J A . The bundle Pfaff A → UA has a trivialization pfaff JA . Under the patching isomorphism on UA ∩ UB the ratio of the trivializations of Pfaff B (T ) and Pfaff A is the pfaffian of the self-adjoint operator SB/A : B/A → B/A, that is, (T )
the product of its (real) eigenvalues viewing SA as a quaternion linear operator. Use instead the unit norm trivialization pfaff JA /| pfaff JA | on UA . Then the transition function on UA ∩ UB is (T )
pfaff SB/A (T )
| pfaff SB/A |
.
(B.2)
(T )
Since A is finite dimensional the spectrum of SA is finite, so the domain of fA in (B.1) contains an interval (−∞, α) for some α ∈ R. Let fA (−∞) denote the value of fA 1/2 on this interval. Trivialize LA → UA by the function fA with fA (−∞) = 1. The transition functions for this trivialization are exactly (B.2). Acknowledgements. We thank Emanuel Diaconescu and Michael Hopkins for many discussions on these topics and Laurent Baulieu and Edward Witten for additional discussions. We also thank the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics and Aspen Center for Physics for providing wonderful environments in which to carry out this work. G. M. would also like to thank the LPTHE at Jussieu, Paris for hospitality, and the participants of the Simons Workshop in Mathematics and Physics at SUNY Stony Brook for asking some good questions.
References [ADM] Alvarez-Gaum´e, L., Della Pietra, S., Moore, G.: Anomalies and odd dimensions. Ann Phys 163, 288 (1985) [APS] Atiyah, M.F., Patodi, V.K., Singer, I.M.: Spectral asymmetry and Riemannian geometry. I Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 77, 43–69 (1975) II Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 78, 405– 432 (1975) III Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 79, 71–9 (1976) [AS] Atiyah, M.F., Singer, I.M.: Index theory for skew-adjoint Fredholm operators. Publ. Math. Inst. Hautes Etudes Sci. (Paris) 37, 5–26 (1969) [BM] Bilal, A., Metzger, S.: Anomaly cancellation in M-theory: a critical review. Nucl.Phys. B 675, 416–446 (2003) [BF] Bismut, J.M., Freed, D.S.: The analysis of elliptic families I: Metrics and connections on determinant bundles. Commun. Math. Phys. 106, 159–176 (1986) [BryM] Brylinski, J.-L., Mclaughlin, D.: The geometry of degree four characteristic classes and of line bundles on loop space. Duke Math. J. 75, 603–638 (1994) [CM] Carey, A.L., Murray, M.K.: Faddeev’s anomaly and bundle gerbes. Lett. Math. Phys. 3 29–36 (1996)
Setting the Quantum Integrand of M-Theory
131
[CMM] Carey, A.L., Mickelsson, J., Murray, M.K.: Bundle gerbes applied to quantum field theory. Rev. Math. Phys. 12, 65–90 (2000) [DF] Dai, X., Freed, D.S.: η-invariants and determinant lines. J. Math. Phys, 5155–5194 (1994); Erratum, ibid 42, 2343–2344 (2001) [DeF] Deligne, P, Freed, D.S.: Classical field theory In: Deligne, P., Etingof, P., Freed, D.S., Jeffrey, L.C., Kazhdan, D., Morgan, J.W., Morrison, D.R., Witten, E. (eds.,) Quantum Fields and Strings: A Course for Mathematicians, 2 volumes. Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society, pp. 137–225 (1999) [DFM] Diaconescu, E., Freed, D.S., Moore, G.: The M-theory 3-form and E8 gauge theory. http://arxiv.org/list/th/0312069, 2003 [DMW] Diaconescu, D.E., Moore, G.W., Witten, E.: E(8) gauge theory, and a derivation of K-theory from M-theory. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 6, 1031 (2003) [Fa] Faddeev, L.D.: Operator anomaly for the gauss law. Phys.Lett.B 145, 81–84 (1984) [FS] Faddeev, L.D., Shatashvili, S.L.: Algebraic and Hamiltonian methods in the theory of nonabelian anomalies. Theor. Math. Phys. 60, 770–778 (1985) Teor. Mat. Fiz. 60, 206–217 (1984) [FT] Fradkin, E.S., Tseytlin, A.A.: Quantum properties of higher dimensional and dimensionally reduced supersymmetric theories. Nucl. Phys. B 227, 252 (1983) [F1] Freed, D.S.: On determinant line bundles Mathematical Aspects of String Theory. In: Yau, S.T.(ed.,) Singapore: World Scientific Publishing, pp. 189–238 (1987) [F2] Freed, D.S.: Dirac charge quantization and generalized differential cohomology. Surv. Differ. Geom., VII (2000), Cambridge, MA: International Press, pp. 129–194 (2002) [F3] Freed, D.S.: K-Theory in Quantum Field Theory info. In: Freed, D.S., Jenquin, J.J. (eds.,) Current developments in mathematics, 2001, Somerville, MA: Int. Press, pp. 41–87 (2002) [FH] Freed, D.S., Hopkins, M.J.: In preparation [FQ] Freed, D.S., Quinn, F.: Chern-Simons theory with finite gauge group. Commun. Math. Phys. 156, 435–472 (1993) [HS] Hopkins, M.J., Singer, I.M.: Quadratic functions in geometry, topology, and M-theory. http://arxiv.org/list/math.AT/0211216, 2002 [HW1] Horava, P., Witten, E.: Heterotic and Type I string dynamics from eleven dimensions. Nucl. Phys. B 460, 506–524 (1996) [HW2] Horava, P., Witten, E.: Eleven-dimensional supergravity on a manifold with boundary. Nucl. Phys. B 475, 94–114 (1996) [J] Jenquin, J.J.: Spin TQFTs and Chern-Simons gauge theory. Ph. D. thesis, 2004 [K] Kallosh, R.: Modified Feynman rules in supergravity. Nucl. Phys. B 141 141 (1978) [MS] Mickelsson, J., Scott, S.: Functorial QFT, gauge anomalies and the Dirac determinant bundle. Commun. Math. Phys. 219, 567–605 (2001) [M] Moss, I.G.: Boundary terms for supergravity and heterotic M-theory. http://arxiv.org/list/hepth/0403106, 2004 [N] Nielsen, N.: Ghost counting in supergravity. Nucl. Phys. B 140, 499 (1978) [P] Powell, J.: Two theorems on the mapping class group of a surface. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 68, 347–350 (1978) [Q] Quillen, Q.: Superconnections and the Chern character. Topology 24, 89–95 (1985) [Qu] Quinn, F.: Lectures on axiomatic topological quantum field theory. In: Geometry and quantum field theory (Park City, UT, 1991), IAS/Park City Math. Ser., 1, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1995, pp. 323–453 [R1] Redlich, N.: Gauge noninvariance and parity nonconservation of three-dimensional fermions Phys. Rev. Lett. 52, 18 (1984) [R2] Redlich, N.: Parity violation and gauge noninvariance of the effective gauge field action in three-dimensions. Phys. Rev. D 29, 2366 (1984) [Sch] Scholl, M.: Ph. D. thesis, in preparation [SW] Scott, S.G., Wojciechowski, K.P.: The ζ -determinant and Quillen determinant for a Dirac operator on a manifold with boundary. Geom. Funct. Anal. 10, 1202–1236 (2000) [Se1] Segal, G.: The definition of conformal field theory. In: Tillmann, U. (ed.,) Topology, Geometry and Quantum Field Theory (Proceedings of the 2002 Oxford Symposium in Honour of the 60th Birthday of Graeme Segal). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004, pp. 421–577 [Se2] Segal, G.: Topological field theory (“Stanford Notes”), http://www.cgtp.duke.edu/ITP99/segal/ [Se3] Segal, G.: Fadeev’s anomaly in Gauss’s law. Oxford University Preprint [S] Singer, I.M.: Families of Dirac operators with applications to physics. In: The mathematical ´ Cartan (Lyon, 1984), Ast´erisque, pp. 323–340 (1985) heritage of Elie [vN] van Nieuwenhuizen, P.: Supergravity. Phys. Rep. 68, 189 (1981) [W1] Witten, E.: On flux quantization in M-theory and the effective action. J. Geom. Phys. 22, 1–13 (1997)
132 [W2] [Wo]
D.S. Freed, G.W. Moore Witten, E.: Quantum field theory and the Jones polynomial. Commun. Math. Phys. 121, 351– 399 (1989) Wojciechowski, K.P.: The ζ -determinant and the additivity of the η-invariant on the smooth, self-adjoint Grassmannian. Commun. Math. Phys. 201, 423–444 (1999)
Communicated by M.R. Douglas
Commun. Math. Phys. 263, 133–172 (2006) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1495-2
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval Anne Boutet de Monvel1 , Athanassis S. Fokas2 , Dmitry Shepelsky3 1
Institut de Math´ematiques de Jussieu, case 7012, Universit´e Paris 7, 2 place Jussieu, 75251 Paris, France. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0WA, U.K. E-mail:
[email protected] 3 Mathematical Division, Institute for Low Temperature Physics, 47 Lenin Avenue, 61103 Kharkiv, Ukraine. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 8 October 2004 / Accepted: 4 August 2005 Published online: 26 January 2006 – © Springer-Verlag 2006
Abstract: Let q(x, t) satisfy an integrable nonlinear evolution PDE on the interval 0 < x < L, and let the order of the highest x-derivative be n. For a problem to be at least linearly well-posed one must prescribe N boundary conditions at x = 0 and n − N boundary conditions at x = L, where if n is even, N = n/2, and if n is odd, N is either (n − 1)/2 or (n + 1)/2, depending on the sign of ∂xn q. For example, for the sine-Gordon (sG) equation one must prescribe one boundary condition at each end, while for the modified Korteweg-de Vries (mKdV) equations involving qt + qxxx and qt − qxxx one must prescribe one and two boundary conditions, respectively, at x = 0. We will refer to these two mKdV equations as mKdV-I and mKdV-II, respectively. Here we analyze the Dirichlet problem for the sG equation, as well as typical boundary value problems for the mKdV-I and mKdV-II equations. We first show that the unknown boundary values at each end (for example, qx (0, t) and qx (L, t) in the case of the Dirichlet problem for the sG equation) can be expressed in terms of the given initial and boundary conditions through a system of four nonlinear ODEs. We then show that q(x, t) can be expressed in terms of the solution of a 2 × 2 matrix Riemann-Hilbert problem formulated in the complex k-plane. This problem has explicit (x, t) dependence in the form of an exponential; for example, for the case of the sG this exponential is exp{i(k − 1/k)x + i(k + 1/k)t}. Furthermore, the relevant jump matrices are explicitly given in terms of the spectral functions {a(k), b(k)}, {A(k), B(k)}, and {A(k), B(k)}, which in turn are defined in terms of the initial conditions, of the boundary values of q and of its x-derivatives at x = 0, and of the boundary values of q and of its x-derivatives at x = L, respectively. This Riemann-Hilbert problem has a global solution. 1. Introduction The sine-Gordon (sG), the modified Korteweg-de Vries I (mKdV-I) and the modified Korteweg-de Vries II (mKdV-II) equations are examples of integrable nonlinear evolution equations in one space variable. Integrable PDEs have the distinctive property that
134
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
they can be written as the compatibility condition of two linear eigenvalue equations, which are called a Lax pair [27]. An effective method for solving the initial value problem for integrable evolution equations on the line was discovered in 1967 [23]. This method can be thought of as a nonlinear Fourier transform method. It was realized in [12] that the extension of this method to initial boundary value problems requires a deeper understanding of the following question: What is the fundamental transform for solving initial boundary value problems for linear evolution equations with x-derivatives of arbitrary order? The investigation of this question has led to the discovery of a general approach for solving boundary value problems for linear and for integrable nonlinear PDEs [13]. For integrable nonlinear evolution PDEs this approach is based on the simultaneous spectral analysis of the two linear eigenvalue equations forming the Lax pair, and on the investigation of the so-called global relation, which is an algebraic relation coupling the relevant spectral functions. Regarding initial boundary value problems for nonlinear integrable evolution equations on the half-line we note the following: The rigorous implementation of the method of [12] to the nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation (NLS) was presented in [21]. Analogous results for the sG, the KdV (with dominant surface tension) and the mKdV-II equations were presented in [15] and [3]. The most difficult step in the method of [12] is the analysis of the global relation. Although rigorous results in this direction were obtained in [21], the relevant formalism is quite complicated. A dramatic simplification was announced in [2] where it was shown that the global relation can be effectively analyzed if one introduces a Gelfand-Levitan-Marchenko representation for the eigenfunction the t-part 1 of (t,k) of the Lax pair evaluated at x = 0. If this eigenfunction is denoted by 2 (t,k) , and if the functions involved in its Gelfand-Levitan-Marchenko representation are denoted by {Lˆ j , Mˆ j }21 , then it is shown in [2] that, in the case of the Dirichlet problem for the NLS equation, qx (0, t) can be explicitly expressed in terms of {Lˆ j , Mˆ j }21 and of the initial and boundary conditions (q(x, 0) and q(0, t)). This yields qx (0, t) in terms of a system of four nonlinear ODEs satisfied by the functions {Lˆ j , Mˆ j }21 . A further important development is presented in [16], where it is shown that it is possible to express {Lˆ j , Mˆ j }21 in terms of 1 and 2 . Thus the formalism presented in [16] expresses qx (0, t) in terms of a system of two nonlinear ODEs satisfied by the functions 1 and 2 . Similarly, it is shown in [16] that the unknown boundary values for the sG, the mKdV-I, and the mKdV-II equations can also be expressed in terms of a system of two nonlinear ODEs. Regarding initial boundary value problems for nonlinear integrable evolution equations on the interval we note the following: The solution q(x, t) of the mKdV-II equation in terms of a 2 × 2 matrix Riemann-Hilbert problem was obtained in [5, 6]. However, the relevant global relation was not analyzed in this paper. The analogous RH problem for the NLS equation together with the analysis of the global relation is presented in [20]; the latter analysis is based on the results of [2]. In the present paper, using the general methodology of [15] and the recent results of [16], we analyze the following IBV problems: sG ∂ 2q ∂ 2q − + sin q = 0, 0 < x < L, 0 < t < T , ∂t 2 ∂x 2 q(x, 0) = q0 (x), qt (x, 0) = q1 (x), 0 < x < L, q(0, t) = g0 (t), q(L, t) = h0 (t), 0 < t < T ,
(1.1) (1.2)
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval
135
mKdV-I ∂q ∂ 3q + 3 − 6λq 2 q = 0, λ = ±1, 0 < x < L, 0 < t < T , ∂t ∂x q(x, 0) = q0 (x), 0 < x < L, q(0, t) = g0 (t), q(L, t) = h0 (t), qx (L, t) = h1 (t), 0 < t < T ,
(1.3) (1.4)
mKdV-II ∂q ∂ 3q − 3 + 6λq 2 q = 0, λ = ±1, 0 < x < L, 0 < t < T , ∂t ∂x q(x, 0) = q0 (x), 0 < x < L, q(0, t) = g0 (t), qx (0, t) = g1 (t), q(L, t) = h0 (t), 0 < t < T .
(1.5) (1.6)
We assume that q(x, t) is a real-valued function and that the functions q0 (x), q1 (x), gj (t), hj (t) are sufficiently smooth. We also assume that the given initial and boundary values are compatible at {x = 0, t = 0} and at {x = L, t = 0}. The above equations admit a Lax pair formulation of the form µx + if1 (k)σˆ 3 µ = Q(x, t, k)µ, ˜ µt + if2 (k)σˆ 3 µ = Q(x, t, k)µ,
k ∈ C.
(1.7)
Here σˆ 3 denotes the matrix commutator with the Pauli matrix σ3 : σ3 = diag{1, −1},
σˆ 3 A = [σ3 , A],
eσˆ 3 A = eσ3 Ae−σ3 ,
for any 2 × 2 matrix A. The eigenfunction µ(x, t, k) is a 2 × 2 matrix valued function of the arguments indicated, f1 (k) and f2 (k) are given analytic functions of k, and the 2 × 2 matrix val˜ are given functions of k, of q(x, t), and of the derivatives of ued functions Q and Q q(x, t). The particular form of these functions for the sG, the mKdV-I, and the mKdV-II equations will be given in Sect. 2. The analysis of an initial boundary value problem for an equation possessing the Lax pair (1.7) involves the following steps. Step 1: A Riemann-Hilbert formulation under the assumption of existence. We assume that there exists a smooth solution q(x, t), 0 < x < L, 0 < t < T . We use the simultaneous spectral analysis of the associated Lax pair to express q(x, t) in terms of the solution of a 2 × 2-matrix Riemann- Hilbert (RH) problem defined in the complex k-plane. This problem has explicit (x, t) dependence in the form of exp{2i(f1 (k)x + f2 (k)t)}, and it is uniquely defined in terms of the so-called spectral functions: {a(k), b(k)},
{A(k), B(k)},
{A(k), B(k)}.
(1.8)
The spectral functions {a(k), b(k)} are expressed in terms of the initial conditions, while {A(k), B(k)} and {A(k), B(k)} are expressed in terms of the boundary values {gl (t)}n−1 0 l l and {hl (t)}n−1 0 , respectively, where gl (t) = ∂x q(0, t) and hl (t) = ∂x q(L, t). For the sG equation, n = 2, while for the mKdV-I and mKdV-II equations, n = 3.
136
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
Furthermore, we will show that the spectral functions (1.8) are not independent but they satisfy the global relation ¯ ¯ e2if1 (k)L a(k)A(k) − ρb(k)B(k) B(k) − a(k)B(k) − b(k)A(k) A(k) = e2if2 (k)T c(k),
(1.9)
where c(k) = c(k; T ) is of O
1 + e2if1 (k)L k
as |k| → ∞ and
ρ=
λ for mKdV, −1 for sG.
Step 2: Existence under the assumption that the spectral functions satisfy the global relation. Motivated from the results of Step 1, we define the spectral functions (1.8) in terms of the initial conditions and in terms of the smooth functions {gl (t)}n−1 and 0 {hl (t)}n−1 . We assume that the boundary values are such that the spectral functions sat0 isfy the global relation (1.9). We also define q(x, t) in terms of the solution of the RH problem formulated in Step 1. We then prove that: (i) q(x, t) is defined globally for all 0 < x < L, 0 < t < T ; (ii) q(x, t) solves the given nonlinear equation; (iii) q(x, t) satisfies the initial conditions; furthermore, ∂xl q(0, t) = gl (t), ∂xl q(L, t) = hl (t), 0 ≤ l ≤ n − 1. Step 3: The analysis of the global relation. Given a subset of the boundary values {gl (t)}n−1 and {hl (t)}n−1 as boundary conditions (N boundary conditions at x = 0 0 0 and n − N boundary conditions at x = L), we characterize the remaining part of the boundary values through the solution of a system of nonlinear ODEs. For the sG and the mKdV-I equations, N = 1, while for the mKdV-II equation, N = 2. We now discuss further the above steps. The analysis of Step 1 is based on the introduction of appropriate eigenfunctions which satisfy both parts of the Lax pair. It was shown in [14] that for a polygonal domain with N corners, there exists a canonical way of choosing such eigenfunctions: there exist N such eigenfunctions, each of them normalized with respect to each corner. Thus in our case we introduce four eigenfunctions, {µj (x, t, k)}41 , see Fig. 1, such that µ1 (0, T , k) = I,
µ2 (0, 0, k) = I,
µ3 (L, 0, k) = I,
µ4 (L, T , k) = I,
(1.10)
where µj are 2×2 matrices and I = diag{1, 1}. It can be shown that these eigenfunctions are simply related through three matrices s, S, and SL : s(k) = µ3 (0, 0, k), −1 , S(k) = eif2 (k)T σ3 µ2 (0, T , k)e−if2 (k)T σ3 −1 . SL (k) = eif2 (k)T σ3 µ3 (L, T , k)e−if2 (k)T σ3
(1.11)
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval
137
τ
τ
τ
τ
T
T
T
T
t
t
t
0
x
t
y
y L
0
x
0
L
µ2
µ1
y
y x
0
L
µ3
x
L
µ4
Fig. 1. The contours used for the definition of µ1 , . . . , µ4
These matrices satisfy certain symmetry properties, thus they can be denoted by ¯ b(k) a(k) s(k) = , ¯ a(k) ρb(k) ¯ B(k) ¯ B(k) A(k) A(k) S(k) = , SL (k) = . (1.12) ¯ A(k) ¯ A(k) ρB(k) ρB(k) Regarding Step 2 we note that Eqs. (1.11) and (1.12) motivate the definitions a(k) = ϕ2 (0, k), ¯ A(k) = 2 (T , k),
B(k) = −e2if2 (k)T 1 (T , k),
¯ A(k) = 2 (T , k),
B(k) = −e2if2 (k)T 1 (T , k),
where the vectors
ϕ1 (x, k) , ϕ2 (x, k)
b(k) = ϕ1 (0, k),
1 (t, k) , 2 (t, k)
satisfy the boundary conditions ϕ1 (L, k) 0 1 (0, k) 0 = , = , 1 1 ϕ2 (L, k) 2 (0, k)
k ∈ C,
1 (t, k) 2 (t, k) 1 (0, k) 0 = , 1 2 (0, k)
(1.13)
(1.14)
(1.15)
and they solve the x-part of the Lax pair evaluated at t = 0, the t-part of the Lax pair evaluated at x = 0, and the t-part of the Lax pair evaluated at x = L, respectively. Thus the vectors (1.14) depend on the initial conditions, on the boundary values at x = 0, n−1 {gl (t)}n−1 0 , and on the boundary values at x = L, {hl (t)}0 , respectively. The global existence of q(x, t) is based on the unique solvability of the associated RH problem, which in turn is based on the distinctive nature of the functions defining the jump matrices: the functions have explicit (x, t)-dependence in an exponential form and they involve the spectral functions s(k), S(k), and SL (k), which have the symmetry properties expressed in (1.12). Using these facts it can be shown that the associated homogeneous RH problem has only the trivial solution (i.e. there exists a vanishing lemma). The proof that q(x, t) solves the given nonlinear PDE uses the standard arguments of the dressing method [30]. The proof that q(x, 0) = q0 (x) (q(x, 0) = q0 (x) and qt (x, 0) = q1 (x) in the case of the sG) is based on the fact that the RH problem satisfied at t = 0 is equivalent to a RH problem derived in terms of s(k) which characterizes q0 (x)
138
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
(q0 (x) and q1 (x) in the case of the sG). The proofs that {∂xl q(0, t) = gl (t)}n−1 and that 0 n−1 l {∂x q(L, t) = hl (t)}0 make crucial use of the global relation (1.9). Thus this relation is not only a necessary condition but it is also a sufficient condition for existence. Hence given initial conditions and a subset of {gl (t), hl (t)}n−1 defining a well-posed initial0 boundary value problem, the main problem becomes to show that the global relation characterizes the remaining part of {gl (t), hl (t)}n−1 0 . The analysis of Step 3 is based on the Gelfand-Levitan-Marchenko representation of the eigenfunctions (t, k) and (t, k). For example, in the case of the sG equation, it can be shown [16] that can be expressed in terms of four functions {Mj (t, s), Lj (t, s)}21 , −t < s < t, t > 0, satisfying a hyperbolic system of four PDEs as well as the Goursat boundary conditions on the characteristics: 1 L1 (t, t) = − (g˙ 0 (t) + g1 (t)), 8 1 M1 (t, t) = − sin g0 (t), 4
L2 (t, −t) = 0, M2 (t, −t) = 0.
(1.16)
Similarly, can be expressed in terms of four functions {Mj (t, s), Lj (t, s)}21 , −t < s < t, t > 0, satisfying 1 L1 (t, t) = − (h˙ 0 (t) + h1 (t)), 8 1 M1 (t, t) = − sin h0 (t), 4
L2 (t, −t) = 0, M2 (t, −t) = 0.
(1.17)
Using the definitions (1.13) and letting T vary, it can be shown that [16]
A(t, k) = 1 +
t
i e 2 (k+1/k)τ 2L2 (t, t − 2τ )
0
g (t) i 0 − −M2 (t, t − 2τ ) + tan M1 (t, t − 2τ ) dτ, k 2
t i (k+1/k)τ B(t, k) = − 2iL1 (t, 2τ − t) e2 0
g (t) 1 0 − M1 (t, 2τ − t) + tan M2 (t, 2τ − t) dτ. k 2
(1.18)
Similar expressions are valid for A and B, with Lj , Mj , g0 replaced by Lj , Mj , h0 , respectively. Substituting the expressions for A, B, A, B in the global relation (1.9) and letting k → 1/k in the resulting equation, we obtain two relations coupling g0 , h0 , Lj , Mj , Lj , Mj .
(1.19)
It is remarkable that these two relations can be explicitly solved for g1 and h1 in terms of the quantities appearing in (1.19). Having solved the global relation it is now possible to formulate the final result in terms of the functions 1 , 2 , 1 , 2 , see Eqs. (4.21) and (4.25).
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval
139
2. A Riemann-Hilbert Problem Formulation Under the Assumption of Existence Let σj denote the Pauli matrices 01 , σ1 = 10
0 −i σ2 = , i 0
1 0 σ3 = . 0 −1
The sG and the mKdV equations admit the Lax pair formulation (1.7), where f1 , f2 , Q, ˜ are given below. and Q sG: 1 1 1 1 k− , f2 (k) = k+ , 4 k 4 k i i sin q i Q(x, t, k) = − (qx + qt )σ1 − σ2 + (cos q − 1)σ3 , 4 4k 4k ˜ Q(x, t, k) = Q(x, t, −k). f1 (k) =
(2.1a) (2.1b)
mKdV-I: f1 (k) = k, f2 (k) = 4k 3 , 0 q Q(x, t, k) = , λq 0 ˜ Q(x, t, k) = 4k 2 Q − 2ik(Q2 + Qx )σ3 + 2Q3 − Qxx .
(2.2a) (2.2b)
mKdV-II: f1 (k) = −k, f2 (k) = 4k 3 , 0 q Q(x, t, k) = , λq 0 ˜ Q(x, t, k) = −4k 2 Q − 2ik(Q2 + Qx )σ3 − 2Q3 + Qxx .
(2.3a) (2.3b)
The Lax pair (1.7) can be written as d ei(f1 (k)x+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3 µ = W,
(2.4)
where W is the exact 1-form defined by ˜ . W (x, t, k) = ei(f1 (k)x+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3 Qµdx + Qµdt
(2.5)
Throughout this section we assume that there exists a sufficiently smooth solution q(x, t), 0 < x < L, 0 < t < T of the corresponding nonlinear equation.
140
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
2.1. Eigenfunctions. Define the matrix-valued functions µj , j = 1, 2, 3, 4, by
(x,t) µj (x, t, k) = I + e−i(f1 (k)x+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3 W (y, τ, k),
(2.6)
(xj ,tj )
where (x1 , t1 ) = (0, T ), (x2 , t2 ) = (0, 0), (x3 , t3 ) = (L, 0), (x4 , t4 ) = (L, T ). If the paths of integration are chosen to be parallel to the x and t axes, then (2.6) yields the following equations:
x µ1 (x, t, k) = I + e−if1 (k)(x−y)σˆ 3 (Qµ1 )(y, t, k)dy 0
T ˜ 1 )(0, τ, k)dτ, −e−if1 (k)x σˆ 3 e−if2 (k)(t−τ )σˆ 3 (Qµ t
x µ2 (x, t, k) = I + e−if1 (k)(x−y)σˆ 3 (Qµ2 )(y, t, k)dy 0
t −if1 (k)x σˆ 3 ˜ 2 )(0, τ, k)dτ, +e e−if2 (k)(t−τ )σˆ 3 (Qµ
(2.7b)
0
µ3 (x, t, k) = I −
(2.7a)
L
e−if1 (k)(x−y)σˆ 3 (Qµ3 )(y, t, k)dy
t ˜ 3 )(L, τ, k)dτ, (2.7c) +e−if1 (k)(x−L)σˆ 3 e−if2 (k)(t−τ )σˆ 3 (Qµ x
0
L
µ4 (x, t, k) = I −
e−if1 (k)(x−y)σˆ 3 (Qµ4 )(y, t, k)dy
x
−e−if1 (k)(x−L)σˆ 3
T
˜ 4 )(L, τ, k)dτ . e−if2 (k)(t−τ )σˆ 3 (Qµ
(2.7d)
t
The domains where the exponentials appearing in (2.7) are bounded, are separated by the curves {k ∈ C | Im f1 (k) · Im f2 (k) = 0}. Define the domains Dj , j = 1, 2, 3, 4, as follows: D1 D2 D3 D4
= = = =
{k {k {k {k
∈ C | Im f1 (k) > 0 and ∈ C | Im f1 (k) > 0 and ∈ C | Im f1 (k) < 0 and ∈ C | Im f1 (k) < 0 and
Im f2 (k) > 0}, Im f2 (k) < 0}, Im f2 (k) > 0}, Im f2 (k) < 0}.
(2.8)
See Fig. 2. Let the columns of a 2 × 2 matrix µ be denoted by Then the columns of µj are analytic and bounded in the following domains in the complex k-plane (which are determined by the domains of boundedness of the exponentials involved in the relative integral equations): (µ(1)
(1)
(2)
(2)
(1)
(1)
(2)
(2)
(1)
µ1 , µ3 : D2 , µ1 , µ3 : D3 , µ2 , µ4 : D1 , µ2 , µ4 : D4 .
µ(2) ).
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval D2
141
D4
D1
D1
D1
D3
D3
D2
D4
D4
D2
D2
D3
D3
D1
D4
mKdV-I
mKdV-II
sG
Fig. 2. The domains D1 , . . . , D4 for mKdV-I, mKdV-II, and sG
Thus, in each Dj there exists a 2 × 2 matrix-valued eigenfunction, which is analytic and (1) (2) bounded. For example, in D1 the matrix is (µ2 µ4 ), etc. For particular values of x or t, the domains of boundedness of the eigenfunctions are larger than indicated above. In particular, for t = 0, the domains of boundedness of µ2 are the following: (1)
(2)
(2)
(1)
µ2 (x, 0, k), µ3 (x, 0, k) : {Im f1 (k) > 0} = D1 ∪ D2 , µ2 (x, 0, k), µ3 (x, 0, k) : {Im f1 (k) < 0} = D3 ∪ D4 . For x = 0, the domains of boundedness of µ1 and µ2 are the following: (1)
(2)
(2)
(1)
µ1 (0, t, k) and µ2 (0, t, k) : {Im f2 (k) < 0} = D2 ∪ D4 , µ1 (0, t, k) and µ2 (0, t, k) : {Im f2 (k) > 0} = D1 ∪ D3 . For x = L, the domains of boundedness of µ3 and µ4 are the following: (2)
(1)
(1)
(2)
µ3 (L, t, k) and µ4 (L, t, k) : {Im f2 (k) < 0} = D2 ∪ D4 , µ3 (L, t, k) and µ4 (L, t, k) : {Im f2 (k) > 0} = D1 ∪ D3 . ˜ have certain symmetry 2.2. Other properties of eigenfunctions. The matrices Q and Q properties, which, in turn, imply the following symmetries for µ: ¯ 22 , (µ(x, t, k))11 = (µ(x, t, k))
¯ 21 (µ(x, t, k))12 = ρ (µ(x, t, k))
(2.9)
and ¯ µ(x, t, −k) = µ(x, t, k).
(2.10)
In the domains where µ is bounded, µ(x, t, k) = I + O
1 , k
|k| → ∞.
(2.11)
˜ are traceless together with (2.11) imply The fact that Q and Q det µ(x, t, k) = 1.
(2.12)
142
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
2.3. Spectral functions. Since the eigenfunctions µj are solutions of the system of differential equations (1.7), they are simply related as follows: µ3 (x, t, k) = µ2 (x, t, k)e−i(f1 (k)x+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3 s(k), µ1 (x, t, k) = µ2 (x, t, k)e
−i(f1 (k)x+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3
µ4 (x, t, k) = µ3 (x, t, k)e
−i(f1 (k)(x−L)+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3
(2.13a) (2.13b)
S(k), SL (k).
(2.13c)
Evaluating (2.13a) at x = t = 0, we find s(k) = µ3 (0, 0, k).
(2.14)
Evaluating (2.13b) at x = t = 0, we find S(k) = µ1 (0, 0, k).
(2.15)
Evaluating (2.13b) at x = 0, t = T , we find −1 S(k) = eif2 (k)T σˆ 3 µ2 (0, T , k) . Evaluating (2.13c) at x = L, t = 0, we find SL (k) = µ4 (L, 0, k).
(2.16)
Evaluating (2.13c) at x = L, t = T , we find −1 SL (k) = eif2 (k)T σˆ 3 µ3 (L, T , k) . Equations (2.13a), (2.13b) imply µ4 (x, t, k) = µ2 (x, t, k)e−i(f1 (k)x+f2 (k)t)σˆ 3 s(k)eif1 (k)Lσˆ 3 SL (k). The definitions of s(k), S(k), and SL (k) imply the following results:
L s(k) = I − eif1 (k)y σˆ 3 (Qµ3 )(y, 0, k)dy,
(2.17)
(2.18)
0
where µ3 (x, 0, k), 0 < x < L, is the solution of the integral equation
L µ3 (x, 0, k) = I − e−if1 (k)(x−y)σˆ 3 (Qµ3 )(y, 0, k)dy.
(2.19)
x
Similarly,
S(k) = I +
T
˜ 2 )(0, τ, k)dτ eif2 (k)τ σˆ 3 (Qµ
−1
0 T
SL (k) = I +
e
if2 (k)τ σˆ 3
˜ 3 )(L, τ, k)dτ (Qµ
,
(2.20)
,
(2.21)
−1
0
where µ2 (0, t, k) and µ3 (L, t, k), 0 < t < T are the solutions of the integral equations
t ˜ 2 )(0, τ, k)dτ, e−if2 (k)(t−τ )σˆ 3 (Qµ (2.22) µ2 (0, t, k) = I + 0
t ˜ 3 )(L, τ, k)dτ, µ3 (L, t, k) = I + e−if2 (k)(t−τ )σˆ 3 (Qµ (2.23) 0
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval
143
respectively. Note that Q(x, 0) is determined by q(x, 0) (q(x, 0) and qt (x, 0) for the sG), ˜ ˜ Q(0, t, k) is determined by {∂xl q(0, t)}n−1 0 , and Q(L, t, k) is determined by n−1 l {∂x q(L, t)}0 . The symmetry properties (1.12) of the spectral functions follow from the symmetry properties (2.9) of the associated eigenfunctions. Equations (2.18)–(2.23) and the determinant condition (2.12) imply the following properties of the spectral functions: Properties of a(k), b(k). (i) For the mKdV-I and mKdV-II, a(k) and b(k) are entire functions; for the sG, a(k) and b(k) are analytic in the punctured plane C \ {0}. ¯ 2if1 (k)L , b(k)e ¯ 2if1 (k)L are bounded in D¯ 1 ∪ D¯ 2 (here D¯ denotes (ii) a(k), b(k), a(k)e the closure of a domain D). (iii) For |k| → ∞, 1 + e2if1 (k)L 1 + e2if1 (k)L a(k) = 1 + O , b(k) = O . (2.24) k k ¯ − ρb(k)b(k) ¯ = 1, k ∈ C. (iv) a(k)a(k) ¯ ¯ (v) a(−k) = a(k), b(−k) = b(k). Properties of A(k), B(k). (i) For the mKdV-I and mKdV-II, A(k) and B(k) are entire functions. For the sG, A(k) and B(k) are analytic in the punctured plane C \ {0}. (ii) A(k) and B(k) are bounded in D¯ 1 ∪ D¯ 3 . (iii) For |k| → ∞, 1 + e2if2 (k)T 1 + e2if2 (k)T A(k) = 1 + O , B(k) = O . k k
(2.25)
¯ − ρB(k)B(k) ¯ = 1, k ∈ C. (iv) A(k)A(k) ¯ ¯ (v) A(−k) = A(k), B(−k) = B(k). Properties of A(k), B(k). Same properties as A(k), B(k). Remark. We note that q(x, 0) (q(x, 0) and qt (x, 0) for the sG equation) can be expressed in terms of {a(k), b(k)} through the solution of a Riemann-Hilbert problem [15]. This problem is a singular RH problem: its solution can have poles (at possible zeros of a and a), ¯ therefore, residue relations have to be added to its formulation. Here we present an alternative construction of the RH problem, which is regular relative to an augmented contour containing additional parts {k ∈ C : |k| = Rj } surrounding the poles of f1 (k) and f2 (k) (see [32]). In such a formulation, we do not need any hypothesis on the zeros of a(k). Define the domain D0 as follows: |k| < R D0 = ε < |k| < R
for mKdV-I and mKdV-II, for sG,
(2.26)
144
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
where ε, R are chosen such that all the zeros of a(k) from D1 ∪ D2 are in D0 . Define a sectionally holomorphic, matrix-valued function (2) (x, 0, k) µ (1) µ (x, 0, k) 2 k ∈ (D3 ∪ D4 ) \ D¯ 0 , ¯ 3 a( k) (1) M (x) (x, k) = µ2 (x, 0, k) (2) k ∈ (D1 ∪ D2 ) \ D¯ 0 , µ3 (x, 0, k) a(k) k ∈ D0 . µ2 (x, 0, k)
(2.27)
Similarly to µ3 (x, 0, k), µ2 (x, 0, k) in (2.27) is determined by (2.7b) for t = 0. Then (x) the limits M± (x, ζ ) of M (x) (x, k) as k approaches the oriented contour (x) in the complex k-plane from the corresponding side (see Fig. 3) are related by: (x)
(x)
M− (x, ζ ) = M+ (x, ζ )J (x) (x, ζ ),
ζ ∈ (x) ,
(2.28)
where the jump matrix J (x) is defined by: b(k) −2if1 (k)x e 1 − a(k) ¯ 2 k ∈ 1 , ¯ b(k) b(k) ρ e2if1 (k)x 1 − ρ a(k) a(k) ¯ I k ∈ ∂{D1 ∪ D2 } ∩ D¯ 0 , ¯ a(k) 0 J (x) (x, k) = (2.29) ¯ 0 } \ ¯ 1 , 1 k ∈ ∂{D ∪ D \ D 3 4 −2if (k)x 1 ¯ ρb(k)e ¯ a(k) a(k) −b(k)e−2if1 (k)x 1 k ∈ ∂{D1 ∪ D2 \ D¯ 0 } \ ¯ 1 , 0 a(k) with 1 = ∂{D1 ∪ D2 } \ D¯ 0 . Here ∂D denotes the boundary of a domain D. Define a sectionally holomorphic, matrix-valued function (2) µ2 (0, t, k) (1) k ∈ (D2 ∪ D4 ) \ D¯ 0 , µ (0, t, k) ¯ 1 A( k) (1) M (t,0) (t, k) = µ2 (0, t, k) (2) k ∈ (D1 ∪ D3 ) \ D¯ 0 , µ1 (0, t, k) A(k) k ∈ D0 , µ2 (0, t, k)
R 0
mKdV-I Fig. 3. The oriented contour
0
0
sG
mKdV-II (x) :
the jumps across the thin parts of
(x)
are trivial
(2.30)
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval
145
where D0 is of the form (2.26) containing all the zeros of A(k) in D1 ∪ D3 . Similarly to µ2 (0, t, k), µ1 (0, t, k) in (2.30) is determined by (2.7a) for x = 0. Then the limits (t,0) M± (t, ζ ) of M (t,0) (t, k) as k approaches the contour in the complex k-plane, see Fig. 4, are related by: (t,0)
M−
(t,0)
(t, ζ ) = M+
(t, ζ )J (t,0) (t, ζ ),
where the jump matrix J (t,0) is given by B(k) −2if2 (k)t e 1 − ¯ A(k) k ¯ ρB( k) 1 2if (k)t 2 e A(k) ¯ A(k)A(k) k I A(k) −B(k)e−2if2 (k)t J (t,0) (t, k) = 1 k 0 A(k) ¯ A( k) 0 k ¯ 2if2 (k)t 1 P B(k)e ¯ A(k)
ζ ∈ ,
(2.31)
∈ 2 , ∈ ∂{D1 ∪ D3 } ∩ D¯ 0 , (2.32) ∈ ∂{(D1 ∪ D3 ) \ D¯ 0 } \ ¯ 2 ,
∈ ∂{(D2 ∪ D4 ) \ D¯ 0 } \ ¯ 2 ,
with 2 = ∂{D1 ∪ D3 } \ D¯ 0 . Similarly, define a sectionally holomorphic, matrix-valued function (2) µ3 (L, t, k) (1) k ∈ (D2 ∪ D4 ) \ D¯ 0 , µ (L, t, k) ¯ 4 A(k) (1) M (t,L) (t, k) = µ (L, t, k) (2) 3 k ∈ (D1 ∪ D3 ) \ D¯ 0 , µ (L, t, k) 4 A(k) k ∈ D0 , µ3 (L, t, k)
(2.33)
where D0 is of the form (2.26) containing all the zeros of A(k) in D1 ∪ D3 . Similarly to µ3 (L, t, k), µ4 (L, t, k) in (2.33) is determined by (2.7d) for x = L. Then the limits
mKdV-I, II
sG
Fig. 4. The oriented contour : the jumps across the thin parts of are trivial
146 (t,L)
M±
A. Boutet de Monvel, A.S. Fokas, D. Shepelsky
(t, ζ ) of M (t,L) (t, k) as k approaches the contour are related by: (t,L)
M−
(t,L)
(t, ζ ) = M+
(t, ζ )J (t,L) (t, ζ ),
ζ ∈ ,
(2.34)
where the jump matrix J (t,L) (t, ζ ) is constructed similarly to (2.32) with A(k), B(k) replaced by A(k), B(k). 2.4. Global relation. Evaluating Eq. (2.17) at x = 0, t = T , and writing µ2 (0, T , k) in terms of S(k) we find µ4 (0, T , k) = e−if2 (k)T σˆ 3 S −1 (k)s(k)eif1 (k)Lσˆ 3 SL (k). Multiplying this equation by exp{if2 (k)T σˆ 3 } and using the definition of µ4 (x, T , k) we find
L −I + S −1 (k)s(k) eif1 (k)Lσˆ 3 SL (k) + eif2 (k)T σˆ 3 eif1 (k)y σˆ 3 (Qµ4 )(y, T , k)dy = 0. 0
(2.35)
The (1, 2) element of (2.35) is (k ∈ C) ¯ ¯ − P b(k)B(k) B(k) − a(k)B(k) − b(k)A(k) A(k) e2if1 (k)L a(k)A(k) = e2if2 (k)T c(k), where
(2.36)
c(k) = c(k, T ) = −
L
e2if1 (k)y (Qµ4 )12 (y, T , k)dy = (µ4 )12 (0, T , k) (2.37)
0
2if1 (k)L is of O 1+e k as k → ∞. The global relation (2.36) expresses, in spectral terms, the relation between the initial and boundary values of the solution of the given nonlinear equation. 2.5. The jump conditions for the eigenfunctions. Relating the vector solutions of (1.7) in the respective domains by using (2.13) and the definitions of the spectral functions (2.14)–(2.16), we find M− (x, t, k) = M+ (x, t, k)J (x, t, k),
k ∈ ,
(2.38)
where M± (x, t, k) are the limit values (as k approaches from ± ) of a sectionally holomorphic function M(x, t, k) defined as follows: (2) µ (1) 1 k ∈ D3 \ D¯ 0 , µ3 ¯ d( k) (1) ¯ (2) µ4 a(k) µ2 k ∈ D4 \ D¯ 0 , d (k) ¯ ¯ a(k) 1 M = µ(1) (2.39) (2) 1 k ∈ D2 \ D¯ 0 , µ 3 d(k) (1) (2) µ2 µ4 a(k) k ∈ D1 \ D¯ 0 , a(k) d1 (k) k ∈ D0 , µ2
Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on a Finite Interval
147
where ¯ − ρb(k)B(k), ¯ d(k) = a(k)A(k) d1 (k) = a(k)A1 (k) + ρe
2if1 (k)L
k ∈ D 2 ∪ D4 ,
¯ 1 (k), b(k)B
k ∈ D1 ∪ D3 .
(2.40)
The jump matrix J (x, t, k) has explicit (x, t)-dependence: J (x, t, k) = e(−if1 (k)x−if2 (k)t)σˆ 3 J0 (k),
(2.41)
where J0 (k) is constructed from