Commun. Math. Phys. 253, 1–24 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-004-1190-8
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type Luca Degiovanni1 , Franco Magri2 , Vincenzo Sciacca3 1
Dottorato in Matematica, University of Torino, via C. Alberto 10, 10123 Torino, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics and Applications, University of Milano Bicocca, via degli Arcimboldi 8, 20126 Milano, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] 3 Dottorato in Matematica, University of Palermo, via Archirafi 34, 90123 Palermo, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 1 November 2000 / Accepted: 13 May 2004 Published online: 5 November 2004 – © Springer-Verlag 2004
Abstract: We study a class of deformations of infinite-dimensional Poisson manifolds of hydrodynamic type which are of interest in the theory of Frobenius manifolds. We prove two results. First, we show that the second cohomology group of these manifolds, in the Poisson-Lichnerowicz cohomology, is “essentially” trivial. Then, we prove a conjecture of B. Dubrovin about the triviality of homogeneous formal deformations of the above manifolds. 1. Dubrovin’s Conjecture In this paper we solve a problem proposed by B. Dubrovin in the framework of the theory of Frobenius manifolds [2]. It concerns the deformations of Poisson tensors of hydrodynamic type. The challenge is to show that a large class of these deformations are trivial. In an epitomized form the problem can be stated as follows. Let M be a Poisson manifold endowed with a Poisson bivector P0 fulfilling the Jacobi condition [P0 , P0 ] = 0 with respect to the Schouten bracket on the algebra of multivector fields on M. A deformation of P0 is a formal series P = P0 + P1 + 2 P2 + · · · in the space of bivector fields on M satisfying the Jacobi condition [P , P ] = 0
(1)
Work sponsored by the Italian Ministry of Research under the project 40%: Geometry of Integrable Systems.
2
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
for any value of the parameter . The deformation is trivial if there exists a formal diffeomorphism φ : M → M, admitting the Taylor expansion φ = φ0 + φ1 + 2 φ2 + · · · , which pulls back P to P0 : P = φ ∗ (P0 ). Assume that the class of deformations P and of diffeomorphisms φ is restricted by a set of additional conditions to be described below. The demand is to prove that every allowed deformation is trivial, and to provide an explicit procedure to construct the trivializing map φ in the class of allowed transformations. In the concrete form suggested by Dubrovin, the manifold M is very simple but the class of allowed deformations is rather large. That is the source of difficulty of the problem. Indeed, the manifold M is the space of C ∞ -maps ua (x) from S 1 into IR n , and the bivector P0 is of hydrodynamic type [1]. By using the so-called “flat coordinates” ua in IR n , it can be written in the simple form P0 = g ab
d , dx
where the coefficients g ab are the entries of a constant, regular, symmetric n × n matrix (not necessarily positive definite). The allowed deformations P are a formal series of matrix-valued differential operators. The coefficient Pk has degree k + 1, and is written in the form Pk = A0 (u)
dk+1 dk + A (u; u ) + · · · + Ak+1 (u; ux , . . . , uk+1 ). 1 x dx k+1 dx k
The entries of the matrix coefficient Al are assumed to be homogeneous polynomials of degree l in the derivatives of the field functions ua (x). The degree of a polynomial is computed by attributing degree zero to the field functions, degree one to their first derivatives, degree two to the second derivatives, and so on. By this requirement the form of the operator Pk is fixed up to the choice of an increasing number of arbitrary functions of the coordinates ua . These functions, finally, must be chosen so to guarantee that the operator Pk is skewsymmetric Pk ∗ = −Pk
(2)
and that the Jacobi condition (1) is satisfied at the order k. This means that the first k operators Pl must be chosen so to verify the k conditions [Pi , Pj ] = 0 l = 1, . . . , k i+j =l
or, explicitly, 2[P0 , P1 ] = 0, 2[P0 , P2 ] + [P1 , P1 ] = 0, 2[P0 , P3 ] + 2[P1 , P2 ] = 0, ···
(3)
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
3
and so on. The conjecture of Dubrovin is that all these homogeneous deformations are trivial, and that the trivializing map is homogeneous as well. To better understand the problem, let us consider the scalar-valued case. According to the rules of the game the first three coefficients of the deformations P have the form P0 =
d , dx
d2 d + B(u)ux dx 2 dx +(C(u)uxx + D(u)ux 2 ), d2 d3 d P2 = E(u) 3 + F (u)ux 2 + (G(u)uxx + H (u)ux 2 ) dx dx dx +(L(u)uxxx + M(u)uxx ux + N (u)ux 3 ). P1 = A(u)
They depend on eleven arbitrary functions of the coordinate u. By imposing the skewsymmetry condition (2) this number falls to four. Indeed we get the seven differential constraints
A = 0, 2C = B, 2D = B ,
2F = 3E , 4L = 2G − E , 4N = 2H − E ,
4M = 2G + 4H − 3E . The remaining four functions are constrained by the Jacobi condition. To work out this condition we use the operator form of the Schouten bracket of two skewsymmetric operators P and Q. We need the following notations. We denote by Qu α the value of the differential operator Qu on the argument α, and by
˙ = Qu (α; u)
d Qu+s u˙ α|s=0 ds
˙ The adjoint of this derivative with respect to u˙ is its derivative along the vector field u. ∗ denoted by Qu (α; β). It is defined by
∗
˙ β = u, ˙ Qu (α; β), Qu (α; u), where the pairing between vector fields and 1-forms is defined, as usual, by ˙ ˙ β = u(x)β(x)dx. u, S1
(Of course, in the vector-valued case we have to sum over the different components.) Then the Schouten bracket is given by [4]:
∗
2[P , Q](α, β) = Pu (α; Qu β) − Pu (β; Qu α) − Qu · Pu (α; β)
∗
+Qu (α; Pu β) − Qu (β; Pu α) − Pu · Qu (α; β). In our example, the bivector P0 is constant. Therefore, the first two Jacobi conditions (3) take the simple form:
∗
P1 u (α; P0 β) − P1 u (β; P0 α) − P0 · P1 u (α; β) = 0
4
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
and
∗
P2 u (α; P0 β) − P2 u (β; P0 α) − P0 · P2 u (α; β)
∗
+P1 u (α; P1u β) − P1 u (β; P1u α) − P1u · P1 u (α; β) = 0 respectively. By expanding these operator conditions, we obtain two further relations B = 0,
4H = 2G + E , among the eleven functions (A(u), . . . , N(u)). Solving them and the previous ones we obtain that the first coefficients of P are: P1 = 0,
(4)
d2 d d3 3 P2 = E(u) 3 + E (u)ux 2 + G(u)uxx dx 2 dx dx 1 1 1 1 2 d + (G (u) + E (u))ux + G(u) − E (u) uxxx 2 2 dx 2 2 1 1 1 + G (u − E (u))uxx ux + (G (u) − E (u))ux 3 . 2 4 2
(5)
Up to the second order in , this is the most general homogeneous deformation in the scalar case. To check Dubrovin’s conjecture to the second-order in , it is enough to consider the homogeneous map φ (u) = u + R(u)ux + 2 (S(u)uxx + T (u)u2x ) + · · · and to use the operator form [4]
∗
P = φ u ·P0 · φ u
(6)
∗
of the transformation law for bivectors. As before, φ u denotes the adjoint operator of the Fréchet derivative of φ (u). By expanding Eq. (6), we find: P1 = 0, d2 d3 + 3(S (u) − R(u)R (u))u x dx 3 dx 2 d +(5S (u) − 4T (u) − R(u)R (u))uxx dx 2 d +(3S (u) − 2T (u) − R(u)R (u) − R (u) )ux 2 dx +2(S (u) − T (u))uxxx + 4(S (u) − T (u))uxx ux
P2 = (2S(u) − R 2 (u))
+(S (u) − T (u))ux 3 .
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
5
By comparison with Eq. (4) and Eq. (5), we realize that Dubrovin’s conjecture is true in the scalar case, up to the second order in . In fact the choices R(u) = 0, 1 S(u) = E(u), 2 5 1 T (u) = E (u) − G(u) 8 4
(7)
allow us to reconstruct the diffeomorphism φ from the deformation P . The questions now are: what happens at higher order in , or in the matrix case? What is the meaning of the relations (7) connecting P to φ ? Due to the great complexity of the computations, it is clear that any direct attack is beyond our reach. We have to devise an alternative approach. Our strategy is to convert the given problem into a problem in Poisson-Lichnerowicz cohomology. It is based on two remarks: 1. Poisson manifolds of hydrodynamic type are transversally constant. 2. The second cohomology group in the Poisson-Lichnerowicz cohomology of these manifolds is “essentially” trivial. The first remark concerns the symplectic foliation associated with the Poisson bivector P0 . In our example, this foliation is rather regular. All the leaves are affine hyperplane of codimension n. They are the level sets of n globally defined Casimir functions C a , a = 1, 2, . . . , n. Furthermore there exists an abelian group of symplectic diffeomorphisms which transform the symplectic leaves among themselves. The second remark concerns the bivectors Q fulfilling the condition [P0 , Q] = 0. They must be compared with the bivectors Q = LX (P0 ) which are Lie derivatives of P0 along any vector field X on M. The former are called 2-cocycles in the Poisson-Lichnerowicz cohomology defined by P0 on M [3]. The latter are called 2-coboundaries. Not all cocycles are coboundaries. A first simple obstruction is the vanishing of the Poisson bracket of the Casimir functions C a with respect to Q: {C a , C b }Q = 0.
(8)
Further obstructions depend on the topology of the manifold. The main result of the paper is the proof, in §3, that these further obstructions are absent on a Poisson manifold of hydrodynamic type. By a combined use of ideas of the theory of transversally constant Poisson manifolds (suitably extended to infinite-dimensional manifolds) and of the operator approach to the inverse problem of the Calculus of Variations in the style of Volterra [9, 8], we show that every 2-cocycle verifying Eq. (8) is a 2-coboundary, and we give an explicit formula for the vector field X (called the potential of Q). Several examples of this result are shown in §4, where possible applications to the classifications of bihamiltonian manifolds are also briefly discussed. Once equipped with this result, the conjecture of Dubrovin can be proved in a direct and simple way. First we notice that the homogeneous deformations pass the obstructions (8). Then we notice that the Jacobi condition [P , P ] = 0 may be replaced by a
6
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
recursive system of cohomological equations. This leads to a simple general representation of the deformation P . The argument goes as follows. Consider the first Jacobi condition [P0 , P1 ] = 0. It is already in a cohomological form. By the main result of §3, it follows that there exists a vector field X1 , such that P1 = LX1 (P0 ). By inserting this information into the second Jacobi equation 2 [P0 , P2 ] + [P1 , P1 ] = 0 we get a new cohomological equation 1 P0 , P2 − L2X1 (P0 ) = 0, 2 hence there exists a second vector field X2 such that 1 P2 = LX2 (P0 ) + L2X1 (P0 ). 2 By induction, one proves the existence of a sequence of vector fields {Xk }k∈IN such that all the coefficients Pk of the deformation P admits the representation j j j1 LXkk LXk−1 L X1 k−1 Pk = ··· (P0 ). (9) jk ! jk−1 ! j1 ! j1 +2j2 +···+kjk =k
This result gives complete control of the deformations of Poisson brackets of hydrodynamic type. In particular it allows us to give the following simple proof of Dubrovin’s (k) conjecture. Consider separately the different flows φtk associated with the vector fields Xk . Give them a different weight by setting tk = k , and make the ordered product of these flows by multiplying each flow by the subsequent one on the left. The result is the one-parameter family of the diffeomorphism
(k) φ = φ k . k≥1
It provides the solution we were looking for. Indeed, according to the theory of “Lie transform”, Eq. (9) are equivalent to the transformation law P = φ ∗ (P0 ) as required. We believe that the strategy sketched above is of interest in itself, and that it can be profitably used in a more general context. In our opinion it can provide, for instance, new insights on the problem of classification of bihamiltonian manifolds associated with soliton equations.
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
7
2. Transversally Constant Poisson Manifolds In this section we collect a few ideas of the theory of Poisson manifolds which are used later on to solve Dubrovin’s conjecture. Our interest is mainly centered around the difference between 2-cocycles and 2-coboundaries on a regular transversally constant Poisson manifold. We recall that a finite-dimensional Poisson manifold (M, P ) is regular if the symplectic foliation defined by the Poisson bivector P has constant rank. Let k denote the corank of the foliation. It follows that, around any point of the manifold, there exist k functions C a , a = 1, 2, . . . , k, which are independent and constant on each symplectic leaf. They are called Casimir functions. Their differentials dC a span the kernel of the bivector P . We also recall that the Poisson manifold is called transversally constant [7] if there exist k vector fields Za which are transversal to the symplectic leaves and are symmetries of P : LZ a (P ) = 0. Without loss of generality, one can assume that these vector fields satisfy the normalization conditions Za (C b ) = δab with respect to the chosen family of Casimir functions. The local structure of a transversally constant Poisson manifold is quite simple: essentially it is the product of a symplectic leaf and of the abelian group generated by the vector fields Za . In particular, the tangent space at any point m can be split into the direct sum Tm M = Hm ⊕ Vm of a “horizontal space” Hm (the tangent space of the symplectic leaf) and of a “vertical space” Vm , spanned by the vector fields Za . This splitting induces a corresponding decomposition of the dual space and, hence, of any tensor field on M. For a bivector Q the basic elements are the vector fields X a = QdC a and the horizontal bivector QH = πH ◦ Q ◦ πH ∗ , where πH denotes, as usual, the canonical projection on H along V . A simple computation gives 1 QH = Q + X a ∧ Za + X a (C b )Za ∧ Zb . 2
(10)
They already contain the clue of the distinction between 2-cocycle and 2-coboundaries. Lemma 1. If Q is a cocycle the vector fields Xa are symmetries of P and QH is a cocycle. If Q is a coboundary the vector fields Xa are Hamiltonian and QH is a coboundary.
8
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
Proof. If Q is a cocycle we have LQdF (P ) + LP dF (Q) = 0 for any function F . For F = C a , this equation shows that X a is a symmetry of P . Hence 1 a b a P , X ∧ Za + X (C )Za ∧ Zb = 0 2 since both Xa and Za are symmetries of P and X a (C b ) is a Casimir function. This show that [P , QH ] = 0 as claimed. If Q = LX (P ) is a coboundary, we find QdC a = LX (P )dC a = LX (P dC a ) − P dX(C a ) = −P dX(C a ) showing that with Therefore we find
with
QdC a = P dH a H a = −X(C a ). 1 Xa ∧ Za + X a (C b )Za ∧ Zb = LZ (P ) 2 Z = −H a Za .
This proves the second part of the lemma.
The previous remark alone is sufficient for later applications. However, in view of adapting the result to the case of infinite-dimensional Poisson manifolds of hydrodynamic type, it is better to restate it in a different form. The idea is to trade multivectors for forms. To this end, we first split the vector fields Xa into horizontal and vertical parts. Then, the components of the vertical parts are used to define the matrix {C a , C b }Q := X a (C b ). a are, instead, used to define k1-forms θ a living on the symplectic The horizontal parts XH leaves. They are given by a θ a (XF ) = XH (F ),
(11)
where XF = P dF is the Hamiltonian vector field associated with the function F . Similarly, the horizontal bivector QH is traded for a 2-form ω, living on the symplectic leaves, according to ω(XF , XG ) = QH (dF, dG). The outcome is that any bivector Q on a regular transversally constant Poisson manifold M is characterized by three elements:
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
9
1. the functions {C a , C b }Q , 2. the 1-forms θ a , 3. the 2-form ω. As a simple restatement of the previous lemma, we obtain the following result. Lemma 2. If Q is a cocycle {C a , C b }Q is a Casimir function, and the forms θ a and ω are closed. If Q is a coboundary the functions {C a , C b }Q vanish, and the forms θ a and ω are exact. We do not give the proof of this result; that can be found in [7]. Instead, for further convenience, we show its converse in the following form. Lemma 3. If the functions {C a , C b }Q vanish, {C a , C b }Q = 0,
(12)
θ a = dH a , ω = dθ,
(13) (14)
and the forms θ a and ω are exact,
the bivector Q is a coboundary. Its potential X is given by X = −H a Za + P θ.
(15)
Proof. The first assumption (12) entails that the vector fields Xa are tangent to the syma . Thus the definition (11) and the second assumption plectic leaves. Hence Xa = XH (13) leads to Xa = P dH a . Set Z = −H a Za . As in the proof of Lemma 1 we get Q = QH + LZ (P ).
(16)
Finally, we notice that the third assumption (14) entails QH (dF, dG) = ω(XF , XG ) = dθ (XF , XG ) = LP θ (P )(dF, dG). Hence the previous equation becomes Q = LP θ (P ) + LZ (P ) = LX (P ) as claimed.
A difficulty is readily met in trying to extend the previous result to infinite-dimensional manifolds. It is connected to the definition (10) of the bivector QH where the operation of the exterior product is used. We have found it difficult to extend this formula in the infinite-dimensional setting where vector fields and bivectors are represented by differential operators. To circumvent this difficulty, we can follow a two-step procedure, where the vector fields Xa come first, and only later the bivector QH is introduced as the complementary part of LZ (P ) in the splitting (16) of Q. This detour leads to an “eight step algorithm” to check if a given bivector Q on a transversally constant Poisson manifold is a coboundary. They are:
10
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
Check that the functions {C a , C b }Q vanish. Check that the vector fields QdC a are Hamiltonian: QdC a = P dH a . Introduce the transversal vector field Z = −H a Za . Compute the Lie derivatives of P along Z. Define the horizontal bivector QH according to: QH = Q − LZ (P ). Introduce the 2-form ω by factorizing QH according to: QH = P ◦ ω ◦ P . Check that this form is exact on the symplectic leaves. Compute its potential θ.
At the end of this long chain of tests, one can affirm that Q is a coboundary and construct its potential X according to Eq. (15). In the next section we shall display this procedure for manifolds of hydrodynamic type. 3. Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type Let now
d . dx We notice that this bivector admits k globally defined Casimir functions 1 ua (x)dx. C a (u) = P = P0 = g ab
0
Therefore its symplectic leaves are affine hyperplanes and the manifold is regular. We also notice that the vector fields Za : u˙ b = δab are globally defined transversal symmetries. Hence, the manifold is transversally constant as well. On this manifold we consider the class of bivectors Q which are represented by matrix-valued differential operators Q=
k≥0
Ak (u, ux , . . .)
dk dx k
(17)
and which satisfy the simple condition {C a , C b }Q = 0.
(18)
We stress that no homogeneity conditions are imposed on Q. So the present class of bivectors is bigger than that considered in Dubrovin’s conjecture. We shall prove Proposition 1. Each cocycle Q in this class is a coboundary. To appreciate the strength of this result, let us consider the case of a single loop function u(x). Condition (18) is automatically verified in this case, since there is only one Casimir function, and therefore we can conclude that every scalar-valued cocycle is a coboundary. This result is far from being trivial. Let us check this claim for the simple cocycle P2 considered in §1. We have to exhibit a vector field u˙ = X(u, ux , uxx )
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
such that
11
∗
−P2 = −LX (P0 ) = Xu ·P0 + P0 · Xu , ∗
where Xu is the formal adjoint of the Fréchet derivative Xu of the operator defining the vector field X. A reasonable guess is to look for a homogeneous vector field X = a(u)uxx + b(u)u2x . Since
d d2 + 2b(u)ux + a (u)uxx + b (u)u2x , 2 dx dx a simple computation leads to
Xu = a(u)
d2 d d3 + 3a (u)u + (5a (u) − 4b(u))uxx x 3 2 dx dx dx 2 d +(3a (u) − 2b (u))ux + 2(a (u) − b(u))ux xx dx +4(a (u) − b (u))ux uxx + (a (u) − b (u))u3x .
−LX (P0 ) = 2a(u)
The problem is solved by noticing that the relations 1 a(u) = − E(u), 2 1 5 b(u) = G(u) − E (u) 4 8 allow us to identify the operator LX (P ) with P2 , for any choice of the function E(u) and G(u) (see Eq. (5)), as claimed in Proposition 1. In this section we shall show that the above relations are simply an instance of the general formula (15), defining the potential X of any coboundary of a transversally constant Poisson manifold. The main difficulty is to identify the geometrical objects (the vector fields QdC a , the 1-forms θ a , and the 2-form ω) to be associated with each bivector of the form (17). To this end, it is useful to split the operator Q into the sum of three operators. The first operator has degree zero. Therefore it is simply a skewsymmetric matrix E, whose entries are functions of the loops ua (x) and of their derivatives. The d d second operator has order one. It is written as the anticommutator S · dx + dx · S of d a symmetric matrix S with dx . The third operator, finally, collects all the higher order terms. Lemma 4. Any bivector Q can be uniquely written in the form: Q=E+S·
d d d d + ·S + · · , dx dx dx dx
(19)
where is the skewsymmetric operator dk dk
k · k + k · k .
= dx dx k≥0
The coefficients k of this operator are alternatively symmetric and skewsymmetric matrices, according to the order of the derivatives.
12
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
This lemma is very simple to prove, but it is interesting because each term in the splitting (19) has a geometrical meaning. Roughly speaking, the first term E controls the brackets {C a , C b }Q , the second term controls the 1-forms θ a , and the third term controls the 2-form ω. By using this representation formula we can now work out the “eight step algorithm” stated at the end of the previous section. Step 1. The vanishing of the functions {C a , C b }Q . Since the differentials of the Casimir functions are the constant matrices δC a = δba δub we easily find
1
{C , C }Q = a
b
E ab dx,
0
where E ab is the entry of place (a, b) in the matrix E. Therefore, condition (18) holds iff there exists a second skewsymmetric matrix E such that E=
d (E). dx
Writing this condition in the commutator form E=
d d ·E −E · , dx dx
we can easily eliminate E from the representation (19) of Q. Setting B = E + S we get Q = Bt ·
d d d d + ·B + · · . dx dx dx dx
Finally we replace the differential operator
d dx
P = G·
by the Poisson bivector d . dx
We then arrive at the following useful second representation theorem. Lemma 5. Each bivector Q for which {C a , C b }Q = 0 can be uniquely represented in the form Q = At ·P + P ·A + P ··P ,
(20)
where A is the n × n matrix and is the skewsymmetric differential operator given by: B = G · A,
= G · · G.
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
13
Step 2. The vector fields QdC a are Hamiltonian. Since {C a , C b }Q = 0 we know that the vector fields QdC a are tangent to the symplectic leaves of P . Therefore there exist 1-forms θ a such that QdC a = P θ a . From the representation theorem we easily recognize that the 1-form θ a is given by the a th column of the matrix A. So the component b of the 1-form θ a is the entry Aab of place (a, b) of the matrix A: θba = Aab . We further know that the vector fields QdC a are symmetries of P by the cocycle condition. If we work out explicitly the condition LQdC a (P ) = 0
(21)
in the operator formalism we have
−LP θ a (P ) = P · θ a · P − P · θ a = P · (θ
a
−θ
a∗
∗
·P
) · P = 0.
This is the same as writing ∗ d d ·(θ a − θ a )· = 0. dx dx
Let us expand the differential operator θ a − θ a
θa − θa
∗
= A0 + A 1 ·
∗
(22)
in power of
d dx :
d d + · · · + An · n . dx dx
Substituting into the previous equation we obtain ∗ d d d d2 ·(θ a − θ a )· = A0x · + (A0 + A1x )· 2 + · · · dx dx dx dx n+1 d dn+2 +(An−1 + Anx )· n+1 + An · n+2 , dx dx
∗
showing that condition (22) can be verified iff θ a − θ a = 0. This means that the Fréchet derivative of the operator θ a is symmetric and, therefore, that this operator is the potential [6]. In geometric language this means that the 1-form θ a is closed and therefore exact, since the topology of the manifold M is simple. The potential is the functional 1 Ha = ha (u, ux , . . . )dx, 0
where, according to [5],
1
ha = 0
Aab (λu, λux , . . . )ub dλ.
We have thus proved that the vector fields QdC a are Hamiltonian.
(23)
14
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
Step 3. The transversal vector field Z. We choose the transversal vector field Z = −ha (u, ux , . . . )Za
(24)
(sum over the repeated index a). We notice that by this choice we depart slightly from the geometrical scheme. According to the third step of §2 we should have introduced at this point the vector field 1 a ˆ Z=− h (u, ux , . . . )dx Za 0
whose components are the functionals H a , instead of the associated densities ha . The ˆ a ) and so the functions C a are Casimir funcchange is permitted since Z(C a ) = Z(C tions also for Q − LZ P . This fact allows us to still define a 2-form ω but in general this is different from the one associated with the previous “horizontal” part of the bivector Q. Our choice has the advantage that the vector field Z is local. Step 4. The Lie derivative LZ (P ). The next step is to compute the Lie derivative of P along Z. In the operator formalism this is easily accomplished if we know the Fréchet derivative Zu of the vector field Z. This derivative is a matrix differential operator. A key property is that the zero-order term of this operator is the transpose of the matrix A defining the 1-form θ a . Lemma 6. The Fréchet derivative Z of the vector field Z may be uniquely represented as the difference Z = −At + P · R
(25)
of the transpose of the matrix A and of a factorized differential operator P · R, taking into account all the higher-order terms appearing in Z . Proof. The identity (25) is nothing else but a disguised form of the Lagrange identity
∗
(α, Zu φ) − (φ, Zu α) =
d B(α, φ) dx
(26)
used to define the formal adjoint of the operator Z . In this identity α and φ are arbitrary, and the bracket denotes the usual scalar product in IR n . We notice that, by Eq. (24) ∗ the vector Zu (el ) is the opposite of the Euler operator associated with the lagrangian density hl , δhl , δu and we write the identity (26), for α = el , in the operator form
∗
Zu (el ) = −
−hl (φ) +
n b=1
φb
δhl d B(el , φ), = b δu dx
where hl is the Fréchet derivative of the scalar differential operator hl . One easily recognizes in this equation the identity (25) by recalling that Alb =
δhl . δub
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
15
The identity (25) allows us to perform the fourth step in our program rather easily. By using once the operator form of the Lie derivative of P we obtain LZ (P ) = −Z ·P − P ·Z ∗ = At ·P + P ·A + P ·(R ∗ − R)·P . Steps 5 and 6. The horizontal bivector QH and the 2-form ω. By subtracting this identity from the basic representation formula (20), we obtain Q = LZ (P ) + P ·( + R − R ∗ )·P = LZ (P ) + P · ·P .
(27)
It allows us to identify the 2-form ω with the restriction to the symplectic leaves of P of the differential operator − , where
= + R − R∗ defined on M. The explicit computation of this form is algorithmic, as shown by the examples given in the next section. We can thus conclude that we have a systematic procedure to identify the 2-form ω. Step 7. The 2-form ω is exact. The last steps are now performed along a well-established path. The closure of the 2-form follows from the cocycle condition [P , Q] = 0. By using the operator form of this condition we obtain: [P , Q](α, β, γ ) = [P , P · ·P ](α, β, γ ) = α, P · u (Pβ; P γ ) + β, P · u (P γ ; P α) + γ , P · u (P α; Pβ) ∗
= α, P ·[ u (Pβ; P γ ) − u (P γ ; Pβ) + u (Pβ; P γ )] = 0. Therefore Q is a cocycle iff verifies the equation ∗
P ·[ u (Pβ; P γ ) − u (P γ ; Pβ) + u (Pβ; P γ )] = 0
(28)
for any choice of the arguments β and γ . Let us fix β. We can regard the previous equation as a differential equation on γ of the form
d d ·T · γ = 0, dx dx
where T is a suitable differential operator depending on β. By the argument already used in discussing Eq. (22) we see that this equation can be verified by any γ only if T = 0. This gives rise to a new differential system on β. Once again it can be satisfied by any β only if the equations are identically vanishing. Thus we conclude that the operator Eq. (28) holds iff ∗
u (φ; ψ) − u (ψ; φ) + u (φ; ψ) = 0 for any choice of the arguments φ and ψ. This is the closure condition for the 2-form .
16
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
Step 8. The potential θ . Since we are working on a manifold with simple topology, by the Poincaré lemma we can affirm the existence of a 1-form θ such that ω = dθ . In our particular context the 1-form θ may be represented as a vector-valued differential operator θ = θ (u, ux , . . . ) and its exactness, in operator formalism, may be explicitly written as ∗
= θu − θu ,
(29)
where θu is, as usual, the Fréchet derivative of the 1-form θ . Like in the finite-dimensional case, the operator θ can be reconstructed from by a quadrature. The formula 1 θ =−
λu (λu)dλ (30) 0
means that we must apply the matrix differential operator , evaluated at the point λu on the vector λu itself. Then we must integrate, term by term, the resulting vector-valued differential operator λu (λu), depending on λ, on the interval [0, 1]. Applications of this formula will be given in the next section. We have finally achieved our goal. By inserting the representation (29) of the 2-form
in the representation formula (28) of the cocycle Q we obtain ∗
Q = LZ (P ) + P ·(θu − θu )·P = LZ (P ) + LP θ (P ) = LZ+P θ (P ), showing that the cocycle Q is a coboundary. Furthermore we obtain the explicit formula X = Z + Pθ
(31)
for the potential X of Q, as in the finite-dimensional case. The proposition stated at the beginning of this section is thus completely proved. To prepare the discussion on Dubrovin’s conjecture, to be performed in the final section, it remains to understand what relation connects the class of homogeneous bivectors considered by Dubrovin (and described in §1) to the class of bivectors considered in this section. Lemma 7. The class of Dubrovin’s cocycles is strictly contained in the present class of cocycles. Proof. The point is to show that the homogeneity assumption (together with the cocycle condition) entails the involutivity condition (18) used to define our class of cocycles. To prove this result we exploit the well-known property that, for every cocycle, the bracket {C a , C b }Q is still a Casimir function of P . This means that P d({C a , C b }Q ) = 0, that is d δE ab = 0. dx δul
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
17
Let us write δE ab = Aab l . δul
(32)
By the above condition the functions Aab l are constant, and therefore l E ab = Aab l u +
d ab K . dx
Accordingly
1
{C , C }Q = a
b
0
l Aab l u dx.
ab The homogeneity condition of Dubrovin entails Aab l = 0, since E should have at least degree one. So the combined action of the cocycle and of the homogeneity condition entails the involutivity (18), as required.
We finally notice that the vector field Z and the 1-form θ associated with the homogeneous cocycle Q are themselves homogeneous operators, due to Eq. (23) and Eq. (30). Thus we can end our discussion by stating the following proposition Proposition 2. All cocycles in Dubrovin’s class are coboundaries, and their potentials are homogeneous operators. In our opinion, this is the deep reason for the validity of Dubrovin’s conjecture. 4. Three Examples As the first example we consider again the homogeneous third-order scalar differential operators (5). We have already shown that they are coboundaries by guessing the form of the vector field X, inside the class of homogeneous vector fields. Presently we want to rediscover systematically this vector field, by using the previous algorithm. We recall the main steps of this approach. 1. The starting point is the representation formula At ·P + P ·A + P ··P . It allows us to identify the matrix A and the 2-form . 2. The next step is to exploit the pieces of information encoded into the matrix A. Its columns are exact 1-forms, and their potentials are the Hamiltonians with Lagrangian densities ha . They allow us to define the transversal vector field Z = −ha Za . 3. The Fréchet derivative Z of this vector field is the last object to be analyzed. Through the second representation formula Z = −At + P ·R, it allows us to identify the operator R, which defines the deformation = + R − R ∗ of we are interested in. 4. At this point we compute the potential θ of the 2-form . The vector field X is given by the formula X = −H a Za + P θ. For the example at hand, the first representation formula reads d d + · [2α(u)uxx + α (u)ux 2 ] dx dx d d d d + · [β(u) + · β(u)] · , dx dx dx dx
P2 = [2α(u)uxx + α (u)ux 2 ]
18
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
where α(u) and β(u) are related to the previous coefficients E(u) and G(u) according to 1 1 α(u) = G(u) − E (u) , 4 2 1 β(u) = E(u). 2 Since P =
d dx ,
the “matrix” A is simply the scalar function
A(u; ux , uxx ) = 2α(u)uxx + α (u)ux 2 . We recognize in this expression the Euler operator associate with the Lagrangian density h(u; ux ) = −α(u)ux 2 . Consequently the vector field Z is given by Z(u; ux ) = α(u)ux
2
1 1 = G(u) − E (u) ux 2 . 4 2
Its Fréchet derivative is
Zu = −2α(u)uxx − α (u)ux 2 + 2
d [α(u)ux ], dx
and therefore Zu + At = 2
d [α(u)ux ]. dx
In this way we obtain the operator R = 2α(u)ux . Since R ∗ = R, the 2-form is simply given by
= β(u)
d d + · β(u). dx dx
This form is exact and its potential is given by 1 θ (u; ux ) = −β(u)ux = − E(u)ux . 2 It can be computed either by direct inspection or by using the equation 1 θ =−
λu (λu)dλ 0 1 d d β(λu) (λu) + (β(λu)) dλ. =− dx dx 0 Finally, the vector field X is given by 1 X = Z + P θ = − E(u)uxx + 2
5 1 G(u) − E (u) ux 2 . 4 8
It coincides with the vector field already obtained at the beginning of §3.
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
19
As the second example let us consider the non-homogeneous third-order scalar differential operator Q=
d3 d + 2u + ux . 3 dx dx
(33)
It is the well-known second Hamiltonian operator of the KdV hierarchy. By writing Q in the form d d d d d + ·u+ · Q=u· dx dx dx dx dx we identify A(u) = u, d . = dx Once again, we recognize in A the Euler operator associated with the lagrangian density h(u) =
1 2 u . 2
Consequently 1 Z = − u2 . 2 Its Fréchet derivative verifies the equation
Z + At = −u + u = 0. Hence R = 0, and =
d dx .
The potential θ of this 2-form is 1 θ = − ux . 2
The potential X associated with the operator Q is then 1 1 X = − u2 − uxx . 2 2
(34)
The final example concerns a non-homogeneous matrix-valued bivector Q. We consider the pair of Poisson bivectors 01 d (35) P = 1 0 dx and
Q=
3
d d − dx 3 + 2u dx + ux d 3v dx + vx
d 3v dx + 2vx d5
d3 dx 3
d2 dx 2
− 10 − 5ux 3 u 16 2 d 2 +( 3 u − 3uxx ) dx + ( 16 3 uux − 3 uxxx ) dx 5
(36)
20
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
associated with the Boussinesq hierarchy. It is well-known that P is a coboundary of Q. Indeed P is the Lie derivative of Q along the vector field u˙ = 0 . X−1 : v˙ = 21 Our aim is presently to show that Q is a coboundary of P , and we want to compute explicitly its potential X1 : Q = LX1 (P ). The boring part is the identification of the matrix A and of the operator . We start from the representation formula d d + dx ·S+ Q = E + S· dx d d dx ·[ 0 + ( 1 · dx + d3 +( 3 · dx 3
+
d d2 dx · 1 ) + ( 2 · dx 2 d3 d · 3 )]· dx dx 3
+
d2 · 2 ) dx 2
(37)
valid for any fifth-order bivector. By comparison with Eq. (36), we obtain 3 0 21 vx v u 2 E= , 0 = 0, , S= 3 8 2 2 − 21 vx 0 2 v 3 u − 3 uxx 1 0 0 −2 0 ,
2 = 0.
1 = , 3 = 0 21 0 − 53 u We notice that E is a total derivative with respect to x, guaranteeing that {C a , C b }Q = 0. Since d d 0 21 v 0 − 21 v · (38) E= + 1 · 1 −2v 0 dx dx 2v 0 we obtain the first representation formula of the operator Q, d d u v u 2v + · · Q= 8 2 2 8 2 2 u − u u − u 2v v dx dx 3 xx 3 3 xx 3 d − dx 0 d d + · · . 3 d 5 u − u 0 dd3 x − 10 dx dx 3 dx 3 x d by the bivector P , we obtain the second representation formula Replacing the operator dx 8 v u v 3 u2 − 23 uxx ·P + 8 2 2 Q=P· u 2v 3 u − 3 uxx 2v 3 d 10 d 5 − u − u 0 x 3 3 dx 3 +P · d x · P. d 0 − dx
It follows that
A=
v u
8 2 3u
− 23 uxx 2v
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
and
=
d3 d3 x
−
10 d 3 u dx
− 53 ux
0
21
0 d − dx
.
At this point we just repeat the usual scheme. We notice that the entries of the columns of A are the Euler operators associated with the Lagrangian densities h1 (u, v) = uv, 8 1 h2 (u, v; ux , vx ) = v 2 + u3 + u2x 9 3 respectively. Then we use the transversal symmetries u˙ = 1 z1 : , v˙ = 0 u˙ = 0 z2 : v˙ = 1 to build the vector field
Z:
u˙ = −uv v˙ = −v 2 − 89 u3 − 13 u2x .
Its Fréchet derivative verifies the equation −v −u v u + Z + At = d 8 2 2 −2v − 83 u2 − 23 ux dx 3 u − 3 uxx 2v d 0 0 . = · 2 − 3 ux 0 dx So the operator R is given by R=
− 23 ux 0 . 0 0
Since R = R ∗ we finally get = . Its potential θ is: 5 uu − 1 u θ = 3 x 1 2 xxx . 2 vx Consequently X1 :
u˙ = −uv + 21 vxx
v˙ = −v 2 − 89 u3 + 43 u2x + 53 uuxx − 21 uxxxx .
Let us finally consider the third vector field 2X0 = [X−1 , X1 ].
22
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
It is a conformal symmetry of both Poisson bivectors P and Q. Indeed 1 P, 2 1 LX0 (Q) = Q. 2 LX0 (P ) =
Furthermore, the vector fields (X−1 , X0 , X1 ) satisfy the commutation relations [X−1 , X0 ] = X1
[X1 , X0 ] = −X−1 .
Therefore by the present algorithm we have constructed the sl(2)-subalgebra of the W-algebra associated with the Boussinesq hierarchy. This remark suggests that the method used in this paper are potentially very useful in analyzing and classifying Poisson pencils on bihamiltonian manifolds. 5. Proof of Dubrovin’s Conjecture The key idea for proving the conjecture is to reduce the Jacobi identity [P , P ] = 0 to a sequence of cohomological equations. This is possible on a manifold of hydrodynamic type due to the results of §3. The outcome is a peculiar representation of the coefficients of the deformation P in terms of vector fields. Proposition 3. A sequence of homogeneous vector fields Xk may be associated with every homogeneous deformation P , in such a way that the coefficients Pk of the Taylor expansion of P are written as iterated derivatives of the given bivector P0 . To this end consider the Lie derivatives associated with the vector fields, and construct with them the operator Tk =
j
LXkk
j1 +2j2 +···+kjk =k
jk !
j
···
LX11 j1 !
to be referred to as the Schur polynomial of order k associated with the given sequence of vector fields. Then Pk = Tk (P0 ).
(39)
Proof. Let us first check the formula for k = 1. We know that the first coefficient P1 is a homogeneous bivector verifying the cocycle condition [P1 , P0 ] = 0. Hence, by the final proposition of §3 there exists a homogeneous vector field X1 , such that P1 = LX1 (P0 ). This proves the first case of identity (39). To prove by induction the remaining cases, we use the identity Tk ([P , P ]) =
k
[Tj (P ), Tl (P )].
j,l=0 j +l=k
It follows from the transformation law ψ∗ ([P , P ]) = [ψ∗ (P ), ψ∗ (P )]
(40)
On Deformation of Poisson Manifolds of Hydrodynamic Type
23
with respect to the special one parameter family of local diffeomorphisms φ(k) : M → M constructed as follows. First we compose the flows (φt1 , . . . , φtk ) associated with the vector fields (X1 , . . . , Xk ) so to obtain the multiparameter family of local diffeomorphisms (k)
φt1 ,··· ,tk = φtk ◦ · · · ◦ φt1 .
(41)
Then we reduce this family by setting tj = j .
(42)
By expanding Eq. (41) in powers of , and by equating the coefficients of k we obtain exactly Eq. (40). Assume presently that the representation (39) is true for the first n coefficients (P1 , . . . , Pn ). To prove that it is also true for Pn+1 we consider Eq. (40) for k = n + 1. We notice that this equation holds for any choice of the vector fields (X1 , . . . , Xn+1 ). In particular it holds also for Xn+1 = 0. Let us denote by Tˆn+1 = Tn+1 |Xn+1 =0 the restriction of the operator Tn+1 to the first n vector fields of the sequence. Then we can write n+1
Tˆn+1 ([P0 , P0 ]) =
[Tˆj (P0 ), Tˆl (P0 )].
(43)
j,l=0 j +l=n+1
By assumption [P0 , P0 ] = 0, and Pl = Tl (P0 ) = Tˆl (P0 )
∀l = 1, . . . , n.
Therefore Eq. (43) becomes: 2[P0 , Tˆn+1 (P0 )] +
n
[Pj , Pl ] = 0.
j,l=1 j +l=n+1
Let us compare this equation with 2[P0 , Pn+1 ] +
n
[Pj , Pl ] = 0,
j,l=1 j +l=n+1
expressing the Jacobi identity [P , P ] = 0 at the order n + 1 in . It takes the form of a cocycle condition: [P0 , Pn+1 − Tˆn+1 (P0 )] = 0.
24
L. Degiovanni, F. Magri, V. Sciacca
Therefore there exists a vector field Xn+1 such that Pn+1 = LXn+1 (P0 ) + Tˆn+1 (P0 ) = Tn+1 (P0 ). By induction this proves the representation formula (39) for any k.
To end the proof of Dubrovin’s conjecture it is sufficient now to notice that the infinite sequence of identities Pk = Tk (P0 )
(44)
P = φ∗ (P0 )
(45)
means that
(k)
for the limit φ of the sequence of the local diffeomorphism φ for k → ∞. Indeed, according to the theory of “Lie transform”, Eq. (44) is nothing else but the Taylor expansion of Eq. (45) in powers of . We have then obtained a constructive proof of Dubrovin’s conjecture. The relation k] φ(k) = φ[X ◦ · · · ◦ φ[X1 ] k
(46)
gives the approximation, at order k of the trivializing map φ : M → M we were looking for. Acknowledgements. We sincerely thank B. Dubrovin for introducing us to the problem of deformation of Poisson manifolds of hydrodynamic type. We also thank G. Falqui for many useful discussions. We finally thank the Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica of Rome, who supported a meeting on the geometry of Frobenius manifolds, giving us the occasion to meet all together and discuss the problem.
References 1. Dubrovin, B., Krichever, I.M., Novikov, S.P.: Integrable systems I. In: Encyclopaedia of Mathematical Sciences, 4, Dynamical systems IV, Berlin-Heidelberg-NewYork: Springer-Verlag, 1990, pp. 173–280 2. Personal communication during the “Intensive INDAM two-month seminar on the Geometry of Frobenius manifolds”, Milano, 2000. See also; B. Dubrovin, Y. Zhang,: Bi-Hamiltonian hierarchies in 2D topological field theory at one-loop approximation. Commun. Math. Phys. 198, 311–361 (1998) 3. Lichnerowicz, A.: Les varietes de Poisson et leurs algebres de Lie associees. J. Diff. Geom. 12, 253–300 (1977) 4. Magri, F., Morosi, C.: A Geometrical Characterization of integrable Hamiltonian Systems through the Theory of Poisson-Nijenhuis Manifolds. Quaderno S 19/1984 of the Department of Mathematics of the University of Milano 5. Tonti, E.: Inverse problem: its general solution. Differential geometry, calculus of variations, and their applications. In: Lecture Notes in Pure and Appl. Math. 100, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer, 1985, pp. 497–510 6. Vainberg, M.M.: Vatiational Methods for the Study of Nonlinear Operators. Holden-Day, 1964 7. Vaisman, I.: Lectures on the geometry of Poisson manifolds. Basel: Birkhäuser Verlag, 1994 8. Volterra, V.: Fonctions de lignes. Paris: Gauthier-Villars, 1913 9. Volterra, V.: Theory of functionals and of integral and integro-differential equations. NewYork: Dover Publications Inc., 1959 Communicated by N.A. Nekrasov
Commun. Math. Phys. 253, 25–49 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-004-1194-4
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Chern-Simons Theory, Matrix Integrals, and Perturbative Three-Manifold Invariants Marcos Marino ˜ Jefferson Physical Laboratory, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 21 August 2002 / Accepted: 10 May 2004 Published online: 5 November 2004 – © Springer-Verlag 2004
Abstract: The universal perturbative invariants of rational homology spheres can be extracted from the Chern-Simons partition function by combining perturbative and nonperturbative results. We spell out the general procedure to compute these invariants, and we work out in detail the case of Seifert spaces. By extending some previous results of Lawrence and Rozansky, the Chern-Simons partition function with arbitrary simply-laced group for these spaces is written in terms of matrix integrals. The analysis of the perturbative expansion amounts to the evaluation of averages in a Gaussian ensemble of random matrices. As a result, explicit expressions for the universal perturbative invariants of Seifert homology spheres up to order five are presented. Contents 1. 2. 3. 4.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Partition Function of Chern-Simons Theory . . . . Chern-Simons Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . The Chern-Simons Partition Function on Seifert Spaces 4.1 Seifert homology spheres . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Computation of the partition function . . . . . . 4.3 Connection to matrix models . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Asymptotic Expansion and Matrix Integrals . . . . . . 5.1 Asymptotic expansion of the exact result . . . . . 5.2 Evaluating the integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Universal perturbative invariants up to order 5 . . 6. Open Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.1 Group theory factors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.2 Matrix integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.3 Symmetric polynomials . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
26 27 29 32 32 33 36 38 38 40 43 43 45 45 45 46
26
M. Mari˜no
1. Introduction Chern-Simons theory [44] has been at the heart of the developments in three-manifold topology and knot theory for the last ten years. The partition function of Chern-Simons theory defines a topological invariant of three-manifolds, sometimes known as the Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariant, that can be studied from many different points of view. In general, the invariant thus obtained contains information about the threemanifold itself but also about the gauge theory group that one uses to define the theory. However, from a perturbative point of view it is clear that one can extract numerical invariants of the three-manifold which are intrinsic to it and do not depend on the gauge group. This goes as follows: if we compute the partition function in perturbation theory, the contribution at a given order consists of a sum of terms associated to Feynman diagrams. Each term is the product of a group dependent factor (the group weight of the diagram), and a factor involving multiple integrals of the propagators over the threemanifold. This last factor does not depend on the gauge group one started with, and in this sense it is universal. Therefore, one can extract from perturbation theory an infinite series of invariants, the so-called universal perturbative invariants of three-manifolds. The idea of looking at the perturbative expansion of Chern-Simons theory in order to extract numerical invariants that “forget” about the gauge group was first implemented in the context of knot invariants, leading to the theory of Vassiliev invariants and the Kontsevich integral (see [7, 28]). The perturbative approach to the study of the partition function of Chern-Simons theory has a long story, starting in [44]. This has been pursued from many points of view. On the one hand, the structure of the perturbative series has been analyzed in detail (see for example [3, 5] and [15] for a nice review), leading to the graph homology of trivalent graphs as a systematic tool to organize the expansion. On the other hand, the asymptotic expansion of the nonperturbative results has also been studied [26, 35–37, 29, 30], although so far all the analysis have focused on theories with gauge group SU (2). Finally, a mathematically rigorous theory of universal perturbative invariants of three-manifolds has been constructed starting from the Kontsevich integral: the so-called LMO invariant [31] and its Aarhus version [8]. The main goal of the present paper is to elaborate on the topological field theory approach to universal perturbative invariants. The point of view presented here is very similar to the one advocated in [1, 2] to extract Vassiliev invariants from Chern-Simons perturbation theory: first, one analyzes the structure of the perturbative series of an observable in the theory. This means, in practical terms, choosing a basis of independent group factors and computing its value for various gauge groups. In a second step, one computes the corresponding invariant nonperturbatively for those gauge groups, performs an asymptotic expansion, and extracts the universal invariants by comparing to the perturbative result. This program was applied successfully in [1, 2] to compute Vassiliev invariants of many knots. It turns out that, in the case of the Chern-Simons partition function, the first step is relatively easy, but the calculation of the partition function for arbitrary gauge groups in a way that is suitable for an asymptotic expansion turns out to be trickier, except in very simple cases. In this paper, some well-known results concerning the structure of the perturbative series are put together, and we carry out a detailed analysis up to order five. The focus is on a rather general class of rational homology spheres, Seifert spaces. The partition function of Chern-Simons theory with gauge group SU (2) on these spaces and its asymptotic expansion have been studied in [19, 35, 37]. The extension to higher rank gauge groups has also been considered [40, 22], but in forms that are not useful for a systematic perturbative expansion. In [30], Lawrence and Rozansky found a beautiful expression
Chern-Simons Theory
27
for the SU (2) partition function on Seifert spaces in terms of a sum of integrals and residues. It turns out that their result can be generalized to any simply-laced group and written in terms of integrals over the Cartan subalgebra of the gauge group (these kind of integrals already appeared in a related context in [36]). Interestingly, they are closely related to models of random matrices, and one can use matrix model technology to study the Chern-Simons partition function on these spaces. The resulting expressions can be expanded in series in a fairly systematic way, and by comparing the result with the general structure of the perturbative expansion, the universal perturbative invariants can be extracted. It should be mentioned that the full LMO invariant of Seifert spaces has been computed by Bar-Natan and Lawrence [9] by using techniques from the theory of the Aarhus integral. However, their result is rather implicit and involves a complicated graphical calculus. This paper is organized as follows: in Sect. 2, we review the computation of the ChernSimons partition function starting from a surgery presentation. In Sect. 3, we analyze in some detail the structure of the Chern-Simons perturbation series. In Sect. 4 we compute the exact partition function of Seifert spaces for simply-laced gauge groups, generalizing the results of Lawrence and Rozansky, and we make the connection to matrix models. In Sect. 5, we analyze the asymptotic expansion of the exact result, explain how to evaluate the matrix integrals, and present the results for universal perturbative invariants up to order five. In Sect. 6, we comment on the possible relevance of these results to other physical contexts, and some avenues for future research are suggested. The Appendix collects the explicit expressions for the group factors and the matrix integrals, together with a summary of the properties of symmetric functions that are used in the paper. 2. The Partition Function of Chern-Simons Theory In this section we review some well-known results about the computation of the ChernSimons partition function in terms of surgery presentations. An excellent summary, that we follow quite closely, is given in [36]. We consider Chern-Simons theory on a three-manifold M and for a simply-laced gauge group G, with action k 2 S(A) = (2.1) Tr A ∧ dA + A ∧ A ∧ A , 4π M 3 where A is a G-connection on M. We will be interested in framed three-manifolds, i.e. a three-manifold together with a trivialization of the bundle T M ⊕ T M. As explained in [4], for every three-manifold there is a canonical choice of framing, and the different choices are labeled by an integer s ∈ Z in such a way that s = 0 corresponds to the canonical framing. Unless otherwise stated, we will always work in the canonical framing, and we will explain below how to incorporate this in the calculations, following [26, 19, 30]. As shown by Witten in [44], the partition function of Chern-Simons theory Zk (M) = DAeiSCS (A) (2.2) defines an invariant of framed manifolds. There is a very nice procedure to evaluate (2.2) in a combinatorial way which goes as follows. By the Lickorish theorem (see for example [32]), any three-manifold M can be obtained by surgery on a link L in S3 . Let
28
M. Mari˜no
us denote by Ki , i = 1, . . . , L, the components of L. The surgery operation means that around each of the knots Ki we take a tubular neighborhood Tub(Ki ) that we remove from S3 . This tubular neighborhood is a solid torus with a contractible cycle αi and a noncontractible cycle βi . We then glue the solid torus back after performing an SL(2, Z) transformation given by the matrix pi ri (pi ,qi ) U . (2.3) = q i si This means that the cycles pi αi +qi βi and ri αi +si βi on the boundary of the complement of Ki are identified with the cycles αi , βi in Tub(Ki ). This geometric description leads to the following prescription to compute the invariants in Chern-Simons theory. By canonical quantization, one associates a Hilbert space to any two-dimensional compact manifold that arises as the boundary of a threemanifold, so that the path-integral over a manifold with boundary gives a state in the corresponding Hilbert space. As it was shown in [44], the states of the Hilbert space of Chern-Simons theory associated to the torus are in one to one correspondence with the integrable representations of the WZW model with gauge group G at level k. We will use the following notations in the following: r denotes the rank of G, and d its dimension. y denotes the dual Coxeter number. The fundamental weights will be denoted by λi , and the simple roots by αi , with i = 1, · · · , r. The weight and root lattices of G are denoted by w and r , respectively. Finally, we put l = k + y. A representation given by a highest weight is integrable if the weight ρ + is in the fundamental chamber Fl (ρ denotes as usual the Weyl vector, given by the sum of the fundamental weights). The fundamental chamber is given by w / l r modded out by the action of the Weyl group. For example, in SU (N ) a weight p = ri=1 pi λi is in Fl if r
pi < l,
and pi > 0, i = 1, . . . , r.
(2.4)
i=1
In the following, the basis of integrable representations will be labeled by the weights in Fl . In the case of simply-laced gauge groups, the Sl(2, Z) transformation given by U (p,q) has the following matrix elements in the above basis [26, 36]: (p,q) Uαβ
idπ Vol 21 [i sign(q)]|+ | w (p,q) (U = exp − ) (l|q|)r/2 12 Vol r · (w) n∈r /qr w∈W
iπ
× exp
lq
(pα 2 − 2α(ln + w(β)) + s(ln + w(β))2 .
(2.5)
In this equation, |+ | denotes the number of positive roots of G, and the second sum is over the Weyl group W of G. (U (p,q) ) is the Rademacher function: p+s pr = − 12s(p, q), (2.6) q s q where s(p, q) is the Dedekind sum
Chern-Simons Theory
29
s(p, q) =
q−1 1 πn π np cot cot . 4q q q
(2.7)
n=1
With these data we can already present Witten’s result for the Chern-Simons partition function of M. As before, suppose that M is obtained by surgery on a link L in S3 . Then, the partition function of M is given by: Z(M, l) = eiφfr Zα1 ,··· ,αL (L) Uα(p1 ρ1 ,q1 ) · · · Uα(pLLρ,qL ) . (2.8) α1 ,··· ,αL ∈Fl
In this equation, Zα1 ,··· ,αL (L) is the invariant of the link L with representation αi − ρ attached to its i th component (recall that the weights in Fl are of the form ρ + ). The phase factor eiφfr is a framing correction that guarantees that the resulting invariant is in the canonical framing for the three-manifold M. Its explicit expression is: L πkd (pi ,qi ) φfr = (U ) − 3σ (L) , 12l
(2.9)
i=1
where σ (L) is the signature of the linking matrix of L. 3. Chern-Simons Perturbation Theory The expression (2.8) gives the nonperturbative result for the partition function of M, and allows an explicit evaluation for many three-manifolds for any gauge group G and level k. However, from the point of view of Chern-Simons perturbation theory, the partition function can be also understood as an asymptotic series in l −1 , whose coefficients can be computed by evaluating Feynman diagrams. In this section we review some known facts about the perturbative expansion of Chern-Simons theory and we state our strategy to compute the universal perturbative invariants. We are interested in the perturbative evaluation of the partition function (2.2). Let us assume (as we will do in this paper) that M is a rational homology sphere. The classical solutions of the Chern-Simons action are just flat connections on M, and for a rational homology sphere these are a finite set of points. Therefore, in the perturbative evaluation one expresses Zk (M) as a sum of terms associated to stationary points: (c) Zk (M) = Zk (M), (3.1) c
where c labels the different flat connections A(c) on M. Each of the terms in this sum has a perturbative expansion as an asymptotic series in l −1 . The structure of the perturbative series was analyzed in various papers [44, 37, 5] and is given by the following expression: ∞ (c) (c) (c) (3.2) S x . Zk (M) = Z1−loop (M). exp =1
In this equation, x is the effective expansion parameter: x=
2πi . l
(3.3)
30
M. Mari˜no (c)
The one-loop correction Z1−loop (M) was first analyzed in [44], and has been studied in much detail since then. It has the form, (c)
Z1−loop (M) =
1 0 1 (2πx) 2 (dimHc −dimHc ) − 1 SCS (A(c) )− iπ ϕ (c) 4 |τR |, e x vol(Hc )
(3.4)
where Hc0,1 are the cohomology groups with values in the Lie algebra of G associated (c) to the flat connection A(c) , τR is the Reidemeister-Ray-Singer torsion of A(c) , Hc is the (c) isotropy group of A , and ϕ is a certain phase. More details about the structure of this term can be found in [44, 19, 26, 35, 36]. Our main object of concern in this paper are the terms in the exponential of (3.2) corresponding to the trivial connection, which we will simply denote by S . In order to make a precise statement about the structure of these terms, we have to explain in some detail what is the appropriate set of diagrams we want to consider. In principle, in order to compute S we just have to consider all the connected bubble diagrams with loops. To each of these diagrams we will associate a group factor times a Feynman integral. However, not all these diagrams are independent, since the underlying Lie algebra structure imposes the Jacobi identity:
fabe fedc + fdae febc + face fedb = 0.
(3.5)
e
This leads to the diagram relation known as IHX relation. Also, antisymmetry of fabc leads to the so-called AS relation (see for example [7, 15, 28, 39]). The existence of these relations between diagrams suggests to define an equivalence relation in the space of connected trivalent graphs by quotienting by the IHX and the AS relations, and this gives the so-called graph homology. The space of homology classes of connected diagrams will be denoted by A(∅)conn . This space is graded by half the number of vertices, and this number gives the degree of the graph. The space of homology classes of graphs at degree is then denoted by A(∅)conn . For every , this is a finite-dimensional vector space of dimension d( ). The dimensions of these spaces are explicitly known for low degrees (see for example [7]), and we have listed some of them in Table 1. Finally, notice that, given any group G, we have a map A(∅)conn −→ R
(3.6)
that associates to every graph its group theory factor r (G). This map is an example of a weight system for A(∅)conn . Every gauge group gives a weight system for A(∅)conn , but one may in principle find weight systems not associated to gauge groups, although so far the only known example is the one constructed by Rozansky and Witten in [38], which uses instead hyperK¨ahler manifolds. Table 1. Dimensions d( ) of A(∅)conn up to = 10
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
d( )
1
1
1
2
2
3
4
5
6
8
Chern-Simons Theory
31
We can now state very precisely what is the structure of the S appearing in (3.2): since the Feynman diagrams can be grouped into homology classes, we have
S =
r (G)I (M).
(3.7)
∈A(∅)conn
The factors I (M) appearing in (3.7) are certain (complicated) integrals of propagators over M. It was shown in [5] that these are differentiable invariants of the three-manifold M, and since the dependence on the gauge group has been factored out, they only capture topological information of M, in contrast to Zk (M), which also depends on the choice of the gauge group. These are the universal perturbative invariants defined by Chern-Simons theory. Notice that, at every order in perturbation theory, there are d( ) independent perturbative invariants. Of course, these invariants inherit from A(∅)conn the structure of a finite-dimensional vector space, and it is convenient to pick a basis once and for all. Here we will study these invariants up to order 5, and we choose the basis presented by Sawon in [39]: =1: =2: =3: =4:
e e J e
e
e
e
e
@
eee =5:
e
@
e
@ e @ (3.8)
As in [39], we will denote the graphs with k circles joined by lines by θk . Therefore, the graph corresponding to = 1 will be denoted by θ , the graph corresponding to = 2 will be denoted θ2 , and so on. The second graph for = 4 will be denoted by ω, and the second graph in = 5 by ωθ . The group factors associated to these diagrams can be easily computed by using the techniques of [12] (see also [6, 7]). Explicit results for all classical gauge groups are presented in the Appendix. Remark. 1. It is interesting to understand the framing dependence of the universal perturbative invariants (see [5] for a discussion of this issue). As shown in [44], the full partition theory Zk (M) changes as follows under a change of framing: Z→e
π isc 12
Z,
(3.9)
where s ∈ Z labels the choice of framing and c=
kd k+y
(3.10)
32
M. Mari˜no
is the central charge of the WZW model with group G. Using now that (see Appendix A) rθ (G) = 2yd,
(3.11)
we find that under a change of framing one has Iθ (M) → Iθ (M) −
s , 48
(3.12)
while the other universal perturbative invariants remain the same. Since we will work in the canonical framing of M, this will produce a canonical value of Iθ (M). 2. Notice that Chern-Simons theory detects the graph homology through the weight system associated to Lie algebras. Unfortunately it is known [43] that there is an element of graph homology at degree 16 that it is not detected by any weight system associated to simple Lie algebras. However, there is a very elegant mathematical definition of the universal perturbative invariant of a three-manifold that works directly in the graph homology. This is called the LMO invariant [31] and it is a formal linear combination of homology graphs with rational coefficients: ω(M) = ILMO (M) ∈ A(∅)conn [Q]. (3.13) ∈A(∅)conn
It is believed that the universal invariants extracted from Chern-Simons perturbation theory agree with the LMO invariant. More precisely, since the LMO invariant ω(M) is taken to be 0 for S3 , we have: ILMO (M) = I (M) − I (S3 ),
(3.14)
as long as the graph is detected by Lie algebra weight systems. In that sense the LMO invariant is more refined than the universal perturbative invariants extracted from Chern-Simons theory. 3. The Chern-Simons approach to the theory of universal perturbative invariants is very similar to the approach to Vassiliev invariants based on the analysis of vevs of Wilson loops in perturbation theory [1, 2]. The role of graph homology is played there by the homology of chord diagrams (see for example [7, 28]). 4. The Chern-Simons Partition Function on Seifert Spaces In this section we write the partition function of Chern-Simons theory on Seifert homology spheres as a sum of integrals over the Cartan subalgebra and a set of residues, by extending results of Lawrence and Rozansky [30] for SU (2). We also show that these integrals can be interpreted in terms of matrix integrals associated to a random matrix model. 4.1. Seifert homology spheres. Seifert homology spheres can be constructed by performing surgery on a link L in S3 with n + 1 components, consisting of n parallel and unlinked unknots together with a single unknot whose linking number with each of the other n unknots is one. The surgery data are pj /qj for the unlinked unknots, j = 1, · · · , n, and 0 on the final component. pj is coprime to qj for all j = 1, . . . , n, and the pj ’s are pairwise coprime. After doing surgery, one obtains the Seifert space
Chern-Simons Theory
33
M = X( pq11 , · · · , pqnn ). This is rational homology sphere whose first homology group H1 (M, Z) has order |H |, where H =P
n qj , pj j =1
and P =
n
pj .
(4.1)
j =1
Another topological invariant that will enter the computation is the signature of L, which turns out to be [30] n H qi σ (L) = − sign sign . (4.2) pi P i=1
For n = 1, 2, Seifert homology spheres reduce to lens spaces, and one has that L(p, q) = X(q/p). For n = 3, we obtain the Brieskorn homology spheres (p1 , p2 , p3 ) (in this case the manifold is independent of q1 , q2 , q3 ). In particular, (2, 3, 5) is the Poincar´e 2 m homology sphere. Finally, the Seifert manifold X( −1 , (m+1)/2 , t−m 1 ), with m odd, can be obtained by integer surgery on a (2, m) torus knot with framing t. 4.2. Computation of the partition function. In order to compute the partition function of M, we first have to compute the invariant of L for generic representations β − ρ, 1 , · · · , n of the gauge group G, where β − ρ is the irreducible representation coloring the unknot with surgery data 0, and i are irreducible representations coloring the unknots with surgery data pi /qi , i = 1, · · · , n. This can be easily done by using the formula of [44] for connected sums of knots, and one obtains: n Sβρ+ Zβ,ρ+1 ,··· ,ρ+n (L) = i=1 n−1 i . (4.3) Sρβ Therefore, the partition function of M will be given by (pi ,qi ) ni=1 ρ+i ∈Fl Sβρ+i Uρ+ iρ iφfr Zk (M) = e , n−2 S ρβ β∈F
(4.4)
l
where the framing correction is given by the general formula (2.9). Seifert homology spheres can be also obtained by doing surgery on n strands parallel to S1 in S2 × S1 [35], and then (4.4) follows from Verlinde’s formula [42]. This expression is not suitable for an asymptotic expansion in 1/ l, since it involves a sum over integrable representations that depends itself on l. In order to obtain a useful expression, we follow a series of steps generalizing the procedure in [36, 30]. First of (pi ,qi ) all, we perform the matrix multiplication ρ+i ∈Fl Sβρ+i Uρ+ . This gives iρ q πikd i (pi ,qi ) (−q ,p ) sign Sβρ+i Uρ+ = exp (4.5) Uβρ i i , iρ 4l pi ρ+i ∈Fl
where the SL(2, Z) transformation in the right hand side is given by −qi −si (pi ,qi ) = U (−qi ,pi ) , = S·U p i ri
(4.6)
34
M. Mari˜no
and the phase factor is needed in order to keep track of the framing. The partition function is then, up to a multiplicative constant, given by: β∈Fl
n−2 sin πl (β · α)
n
1
α>0
(wi )
i=1 ni ∈r /pi r wi ∈W
iπ 2 2 −qi β − 2β(lni + w(ρ)) + ri (lni + w(ρ)) . × exp lpi
(4.7)
If G is simply-laced, the summand is invariant under the simultaneous shift, β → β + lα,
ni → ni − qi α,
(4.8)
and also under ni → ni + pi α.
(4.9)
In these equations, α is any element in the root lattice. This invariance allows us to put ni = 0 in the above sum by extending the range of β: β = p + lα, where p ∈ Fl , and α = i ai αi , 0 ≤ ai < P . It is easy to see that the resulting summand is invariant under the Weyl group W acting on β, and by translations by lP α, where α is any root. We can then sum over Weyl reflections and divide by the order of W, denoted by |W|, and use the translation symmetry to extend the sum over β in the above set to a sum over β ∈ (w / lP r )\M. Here M denotes the set given by the wall of Fl together with its Weyl reflections and translations by lP α inside w / lP r (for SU (N ), the wall of Fl is given by the weights with i pi = l). We won’t need a precise description of the points of M in the following, since they only enter in the contribution of irreducible flat connections to the path integral [30]. After performing all these changes, and using the Weyl denominator formula α 2 sinh = (w)ew(ρ) , (4.10) 2 w∈W
α>0
we can write (4.7) as: 1 iπl ρ 2 ni=1 pri i e |W| ·e−
iπ H lP
β2
β∈(w / lP r )\M
n
(−2i) sin
i=1 α>0
1
α>0
sin πl (β · α)
n−2
π (β · α). lpi
(4.11)
The last step involves transforming the above sum in a sum over integrals and residues. To do that, we generalize slightly [30] and we introduce a holomorphic function of β1 , · · · , βr and x1 , · · · , xr given by: h(β, x) =
e−
α>0
e
iπ H lP
πi l (β·α)
β2
−e
f (β, x) , −2πiβi ) i=1 (1 − e
= r
2π i
e l β·x r n−2 −2πiβi ) − πl i (β·α) i=1 (1 − e (4.12)
Chern-Simons Theory
where β =
r
35
i=1 βi λi
∈ w ⊗ C, x =
r
i=1 xi αi
∈ r ⊗ C. This function satisfies:
h(β + lP α, x) = e2πiP α·x h(β, x − lH α),
(4.13)
for any α ∈ r . Notice also that h(β, x) has poles at the points of w , the weight lattice. Introduce now the integral over Cr : (x) =
Cr
(4.14)
h(β, x)dβ,
where C r = C × · · · × C is a multiple contour in Cr , and C is the contour considered in [30]: a line through the origin from (−1 + i)∞ to (1 − i)∞ for sign(H /P ) > 0 (if sign(H /P ) < 0, we rotate C by π/2 in the clockwise direction). This contour is chosen to guarantee good convergence properties as βi → ∞. Let us now shift the contour in such a way that it crosses all the poles corresponding to the weights in the chamber w / lP r . Using (4.13) it is easy to see that, if P α · x ∈ Z for any root α, the resulting integral can be written as r
(x − lH αi )−
(x − lH (αi + αj ))+· · ·+(−1)r−1 (x − lH
r
1≤i<j ≤r
i=1
αi ).
i=1
(4.15) The difference between the original integral and the shifted integral (4.15) can be written as f (β, x)e−2πit·β . (4.16) t∈r /H r
Cr
On the other hand, the effect of shifting the contour is to pick the residues corresponding to all the weights in the chamber w / lP r . Here the residue is understood as limβi →ni i (βi − ni )h(β, x), and the residues for the weights that are not in M are simply given by (2πi)−r f (β, x). Putting everything together we find, n∈(w / lP r )\M
f (n, x) =
t∈r /H r
×
Cr
f (β, x)e−2πiβ·t dβ − (2π i)r
Res(h(β, x), β = n),
(4.17)
n∈M
whenever P α · x ∈ Z. We can apply this formula to (4.11), since what we have there is just a sum of expressions of the form f (β, x) in (4.12), with x of the form α/P , α ∈ r . In this context, the sum over t ∈ r /H r is interpreted as a sum over reducible flat connections on the Seifert sphere, and of course t = 0 corresponds to the trivial connection. In the remainder of this paper we will focus on these contributions, i.e. we will not deal with the residue terms in (4.17), that should give the contribution of irreducible flat connections [37, 30]. In fact, we will only analyze in detail the contribution of the trivial connection in order to make contact with the universal perturbative invariants.
36
M. Mari˜no
In order to present the final result for the contribution of reducible flat connections to the partition function of Chern-Simons theory on Seifert spaces, we have to collect the prefactors, including the phases. Define as in [30]: φ = 3 sign
H P
+
n
12 s(qi , pi ) −
i=1
qi . pi
(4.18)
Therefore, the contribution of reducible flat connections to the Chern-Simons partition function of X( pq11 , · · · , pqnn ) is given by Vol w [sign(P )]|+ | π id sign(H /P )− π idy φ 12l e 4 Vol r |P |r/2 n β·α α>0 2 sinh 2pi i=1 −β 2 /2x−lt·β ˆ dβ e · n−2 . β·α t∈r /H r α>0 2 sinh 2
(−1)|+ | |W| (2πi)r
(4.19)
In this equation, φ is given by (4.18), and in obtaining the phase factor we have made use of the Freudenthal-De Vries formula ρ2 =
1 dy. 12
(4.20)
We have also introduced the hatted coupling constant xˆ =
Px , H
(4.21)
where x is the coupling constant given in (3.3). In the evaluation of the above integral we can rotate the integration contour C r to Rr as long as we are careful with phases in the Gaussian integral, as explained for example in [44]. If we specialize (4.19) to G = SU (2), we obtain the result derived in [30]. The expression (4.19) is in principle only valid for simply-laced groups, although the results for the perturbative series turn out to be valid for any gauge group. Notice that, in the sum over r /H r , the t’s that are related by Weyl transformations correspond to the same flat connection. Fortunately, each of the integrals in (4.19) is invariant under Weyl permutations of t, so in order to consider the contribution of a given flat connection, one can just evaluate (4.19) for a particular representative and then multiply by the corresponding degeneracy factor (i.e. the number of Weyl-equivalent t configurations giving the same flat connection). If one is just interested in obtaining the contribution of the trivial connection, one can use the shorter arguments of [36] and end up with (4.19) with t = 0. The contribution of the reducible connections can also be obtained by generalizing the arguments of [37] to the higher rank situation. 4.3. Connection to matrix models. In (4.19) we have written the contribution of reducible connections to the Chern-Simons partition function in terms of an integral over the Cartan subalgebra, since dβ = ri=1 dβi and βi are the Dynkin coordinates. In fact, the above expression can be interpreted as the partition function of a random matrix model (for a review of random matrices, see [34, 24]). To see this, let us consider a
Chern-Simons Theory
37
slight generalization of the above results to the U (N ) and O(2r) theories. The partition function for these groups can be obtained by writing β in terms of the orthonormal basis in the space of weights. Let us first consider the case of U (N ). Denote the orthonormal basis as {ek }k=1,... ,N , and put β = k βk ek (where βk are taken to be independent variables), t = k tk ek . It is well-known that the positive roots can be written as αkl = ek − el ,
1 ≤ k < l ≤ N.
(4.22)
Therefore, the integral in (4.19) becomes dβ e
−
2 ˆ k βk /2x−l k tk βk
n
i=1 k
k
2 sinh
2 sinh
βk −βl 2
βk −βl 2pi n−2 .
(4.23)
We can interpret the βk as the eigenvalues of a Hermitian matrix in a Gaussian potential and interacting through n i=1 k
βk − βl β k − βl + (2 − n) log 2 sinh log 2 sinh . 2pi 2
(4.24)
k
Notice moreover that for a small separation of the eigenvalues (4.24) becomes, at leading order,
log(βk − βl )2
(4.25)
k
which is the interaction between eigenvalues of the standard Hermitian matrix model. Therefore, the integral above can be interpreted as a nonlinear deformation of the usual Gaussian unitary ensemble (GUE). In fact, as we will see in detail in the next section, Chern-Simons perturbation theory means that we expand around the GUE, and the perturbative corrections are obtained by evaluating averages in this ensemble. Note that the non-trivial reducible flat connections, labeled by t, are interpreted in the matrix model language as a source term coupling linearly to the eigenvalues. Similar considerations apply to the orthogonal group O(2r). The positive roots can be written in terms of an orthonormal basis as follows: ± αkl = ek ± el ,
1 ≤ k < l ≤ r,
(4.26)
and the interaction between the eigenvalues reduces again, in the limit of small separation, to
log(βk2 − βl2 )2 ,
(4.27)
k
which is the eigenvalue interaction of the orthogonal ensemble O(N ) for even N .
38
M. Mari˜no
5. Asymptotic Expansion and Matrix Integrals 5.1. Asymptotic expansion of the exact result. In this subsection we will study the asymptotic expansion of the exact result obtained in the previous section for the contribution of the trivial connection t = 0. The expression (4.19) is very well suited for an asymptotic expansion in powers of x : we just have to expand the integrand in a power series of β, and integrate the result term by term with the Gaussian weight. The integrand has the expansion: n β·α 1 α>0 2 sinh 2pi i=1 2 = (β · α) f (β), (5.1) n−2 P |+ | β·α α>0 2 sinh α>0 2 where f (β) has the form f (β) =
1+
α>0
∞
as (β · α)
2s
.
(5.2)
s=1
The coefficients as can be obtained in a very straightforward way from (5.1). They are polynomials of degree s in n and in the power sums πj =
n
−2j
pi
(5.3)
.
i=1
One has, for example, 1 (π1 + 2 − n), 24 1 a2 = (16 + 5n2 − 18n − 10nπ1 + 20π1 + 5π12 − 2π2 ). 5760 a1 =
Let us analyze in more detail the structure of f (β). Define σj (β) = (β · α)2j .
(5.4)
(5.5)
α>0
By taking the log of (5.2), one finds: ∞
f (β) = exp
(c) ak σk (β)
(5.6)
,
k=1
(c) where the connected coefficients ak are defined in the usual way: log(1 + n ak x k ) = (c) k k ak x . An explicit expression for f (β) can be obtained as follows. Let k =(k1 , k2 , · · · ) be a vector whose components are nonnegative integers. Denote = j j kj , and define: (c) k
a =
(c) (aj )kj , j
σk (β) =
j
k
σj j (β).
(5.7)
Chern-Simons Theory
39
Then, f (β) = 1 +
1 (c) a σ (β), k k k!
(5.8)
k
We see that the perturbative expansion = j kj ! and the sum is over all vectors k. with k! of the partition function can be written in terms of the quantities 2 dβ2 (β)e−β /2 σk (β) Rk (G) = , (5.9) 2 dβ2 (β)e−β /2 where we have denoted 2 (β) =
(β · α)2 .
(5.10)
α>0
Notice that, when we write β in terms of the orthogonal basis (4.22) or (4.26), (5.10) is indeed the square of the Vandermonde determinant in the variables βj (for U (N )) or βj2 (for O(2r)). Therefore, as we anticipated before, the asymptotic expansion of the integral is an expansion around the corresponding Gaussian ensemble, and the perturbative corrections can be evaluated systematically as averages in this ensemble. We will denote 2 Z0 = dβ2 (β)e−β /2 , (5.11) so that the partition function on Seifert spaces can be written, using (4.19), as log
∞ Zk (M) 1 = − dyφx + log 1 + Z1−loop 24
=1 k|
j
j kj =
1 (c) a Rk (G) xˆ . k k!
(5.12)
In this equation Z1−loop is given by Z1−loop =
(−1)|+ | |W| (2πi)r
π id Vol w e 4 sign(H /P ) Z0 xˆ d/2 , Vol r |P |d/2
(5.13)
and indeed gives the one-loop contribution around the trivial connection. This follows by comparing the exact result with the perturbative expansion ∞
Zk (M) log = Z1−loop =1
r (G)I (M) x .
(5.14)
∈A(∅)conn
We also see that, by comparing (5.12) and (5.14), we can extract the value of the universal perturbative invariants I (M) at each order x . In order to do that we just have to eval uate Rk (G) for all vectors k with j j kj ≤ , and also the group factors r (G) for graphs with 2 vertices. Of course, from a mathematical point of view it is not obvious that the asymptotic expansion of the exact partition function has the structure predicted by the perturbation theory analysis. The fact that this is the case provides an important consistency check of the procedure.
40
M. Mari˜no
5.2. Evaluating the integrals. We now address the problem of computing the integrals in (5.9). As we explained in Sect. 4, the partition function of Chern-Simons theory on Seifert spaces can be interpreted as a matrix model with an interaction between eigenvalues of the form log(sinh(βi − βj )). In the perturbative approach we have to expand the sin in power series, and the integrals Rk (G) are nothing but averages of symmetric polynomials in the eigenvalues in a Gaussian matrix model. We will present two methods to compute these averages. The first method gives the complete answer only up to = 5, but it has the advantage of providing general expressions for any simply-laced gauge group. The starting point is the following identity: t (β · α) s(β · α) a 2 4 sinh sinh dβ e− 2 β 2 2 α>0 2π r/2 ts(ρ · α) 1 t 2 +s 2 2 = |W|(det(C)) 2 e 2a ρ 2 sinh , (5.15) a 2a α>0
where C is the Cartan matrix of the group. This formula is easily proved by using (4.10). Another useful fact is that σ1 (β) can be written as (see [14], pp. 519–20)
(β · α)2 = yβ 2 .
(5.16)
α>0
One can easily show that, by expanding (5.15) in s, t, and by using (5.16), it is possible to determine the integrals Rk (G) for any gauge group up to = 5, therefore this is enough for the computational purposes of the present paper. The answer is given in terms of y, d, and the quantities αk =
(α · ρ)2k .
(5.17)
α>0
For example, one finds: R(0,1,0,··· ) (G) = 5dy 2 .
(5.18)
The answers obtained by this method are listed in the Appendix. In order to evaluate the integrals (5.9) for arbitrary σk , it is important to have a more general and systematic method. Here is where the connection to matrix integrals becomes computationally useful. It is easy to see that, since the integrals Rk (G) are normalized, one can evaluate them in U (N ) and O(2r) instead of SU (N ) and SO(2r). Therefore, one has 2 1 dβ e− j βj /2 (βi − βj )2 σk (β), (5.19) Rk (SU (N )) = Z0 i<j
where σn (β) =
(βi − βj )2n . i<j
(5.20)
Chern-Simons Theory
41
In (5.19) one integrates over N independent variables β1 , · · · , βN . It is clear that the σk (β) are symmetric polynomials in these N variables. One can for example write (5.20) in terms of power sum polynomials Pj (β) (defined in (A.8)) as follows, 2n−1 1 s 2n σn (β) = N P2n (β) + Ps (β)P2n−s (β). (−1) s 2
(5.21)
s=1
The averages of symmetric polynomials in the Gaussian unitary ensemble can be evaluated in principle by using the Selberg integral [34], or the results of [10]. A more effective way is the following: any symmetric polynomial in the βi ’s can be written as a linear combination of Schur polynomials Sλ (β), which are labeled by Young tableaux associated to a partition λ (see (A.6)). Therefore, if we know how to compute the normalized average of a Schur polynomial, 2 1 dβ e− j βj /2 (βi − βj )2 Sλ (β), (5.22)
Sλ (β) = Z0 i<j
we can compute all Rk . An explicit expression for (5.22) has been presented in [25]. The result is the following: let |λ| be the total number of boxes in the tableau labeled by λ, and let λi denote the number of boxes in the i th row of the Young tableau. Define now the |λ| integers fi as follows fi = λi + |λ| − i,
i = 1, · · · , |λ|.
(5.23)
Following [25], we will say that the Young tableau associated to λ is even if the number of odd fi ’s is the same as the number of even fi ’s. Otherwise, we will say that it is odd. If λ is odd, the normalized average Sλ (β) vanishes. Otherwise, it is given by: A(A−1) f odd f !! f even f !!
Sλ (β) = (−1) 2 dim λ, (5.24) f odd,f even (f − f ) where A = |λ|/2 (notice that |λ| has to be even in order to have a non vanishing result). Here dim λ is the dimension of the irreducible representation of SU (N ) associated to λ, and can be computed by using the hook formula. This expression solves the problem of computing the averages (5.19) in the general case: we express the product of power sums appearing in (5.21) in terms of Schur polynomials by using the Frobenius formula (A.9), and then we compute the averages of these with (5.24). As an example of this procedure, let us compute R(0,1,0,··· ) (SU (N )). Using (5.21) and the Frobenius formula (A.9), we find: σ2 = (N − 1)S
− (N + 1)S
+ (N − 3)S
− (N + 3)S
+ 10S
. (5.25)
The averages of the different Schur polynomials can be computed from (5.24), and we obtain, after some simple algebra: R(0,1,0,··· ) (SU (N )) = 5N 2 (N 2 − 1), in agreement with (5.18).
(5.26)
42
M. Mari˜no
Let us now consider the orthogonal ensemble. The averages that we want to compute are given by 1 Z0
dβ e−
r
2 j =1 βj /2
1≤i<j ≤r
(βi2 − βj2 )2 σk (β),
(5.27)
where σn (β) =
(βi + βj )2n + (βi − βj )2n
i<j
= (2r − 22n−1 )Pn (βi2 ) +
n−1 2n s=1
2s
Ps (βi2 )Pn−s (βi2 ).
(5.28)
The functions σk (β) are now symmetric polynomials in the βi2 , so we can write them in terms of Schur polynomials Sλ (βi2 ). This allows to express the integrals (5.27) in terms of the integrals
∞
∞
···
0
0
dy 2 (y)(y1 . . . yr )α−1 e−(y1 +···+yr )/2 Sλ (y),
(5.29)
which are a special case of a generalization of the Selberg integral studied by Kadell [27], see also [33]. Their value is given by r!
r
(λi + α + r − i)
i=1
(λi − λj + j − i).
(5.30)
i<j
In our case, α = 1/2. The normalized average of a Schur polynomial is then:
Sλ (βi2 ) = 2|λ| dim λ
r (λi + 1/2 + r − i) . (1/2 + r − i)
(5.31)
i=1
In this equation, dim λ denotes the dimension of the representation of SU (r) associated to λ. This solves the problem of computing the averages (5.27) in the orthogonal ensemble. As a simple example, let us consider again k = (0, 1, 0, · · · ). It is easy to see that σ2 = (2r − 2)S
+ (14 − 2r)S ,
(5.32)
and one finds R(0,1,0,··· ) (SO(2r)) = 20 r(2r − 1)(r − 1)2 , in agreement with (5.18).
(5.33)
Chern-Simons Theory
43
5.3. Universal perturbative invariants up to order 5. Using the above ingredients, it is easy to find the universal perturbative invariants of Seifert spaces up to order 5. Although the coefficients as in (5.2) are functions of n and the Newton polynomials Pk (pi−2 ), the answer turns out to be more compact when written in terms of elementary symmetric polynomials Ek in the variables pi−2 − 1 by using (A.10) (so for example E1 = −n + ni=1 pi−2 ). One finds, 1 P Iθ = − φ − (2 + E1 ) , 48 H 1 P 2 Iθ2 = (1 + E1 + E2 ), 1152 H 1 P 3 E3 , Iθ3 = 13824 H 1 P 4 Iθ4 = 11059200 H × 82E4 − 46E3 − 18(1 + E2 + E3 )E1 − 9E22 − 18E2 − 9E12 − 9 , P 4 1 Iω = 2E4 − 6E3 + 2E1 (1 + E2 − E3 ) + E22 + 2E2 + E12 + 1 , 1382400 H P 5 1 Iθ5 = 55E5 + E4 (27E1 − 56) − E3 (9E2 + 36E1 + 8) , 66355200 H P 5 1 Iωθ = 5E5 − E4 (3E1 + 16) + E3 (E2 + 4E1 + 12) . (5.34) 8294400 H Note that the first universal invariant is given by λ(M) Iθ = , (5.35) 2 where λ(M) is the Casson invariant of M, in accord with the general result of [36] and with the result for the LMO invariant [31]. We have also checked that the value for Iθ2 listed above agrees with the value obtained in [9] for the LMO invariant using the Aarhus integral. It would be interesting to see if these invariants have some nice integrality properties. The perturbative SU (2) invariants of integral homology spheres do exhibit some integrality properties (discussed for example in [30]), but they include extra factors coming from the SU (2) group weights. In general, the invariants listed above are rational even for integral homology spheres. For example, Iθ3 ∈ Z/4 for Brieskorn 1 integral homology spheres. Also, Iθ2 − 1152 ∈ Z/2 for those spaces. 6. Open Problems Besides the original motivation of understanding universal perturbative invariants from a field theory point of view, the results presented here also provide a computationally feasible framework to study the Chern-Simons partition function with higher rank gauge groups. There are various avenues to explore in the context of Chern-Simons theory and the theory of three-manifold invariants. It would be interesting for example to understand the structure of perturbation theory in the background of a reducible nontrivial connection, and work out the asymptotic expansion starting from (4.19). One could also consider other three-manifolds (not necessarily rational homology spheres) and see in particular if the matrix model representation provided here can be generalized to other cases.
44
M. Mari˜no
There are also various interesting physical contexts in which the results of this paper might be relevant. Let us end by mentioning a few of them: 1) The computation of Rozansky-Witten invariants [38] involves the universal perturbative invariants of three-manifolds that are extracted from Chern-Simons theory, but the weight system is now associated to a hyperK¨ahler manifold (see [39] for a very nice review). Therefore, the universal perturbative invariants of Chern-Simons theory are relevant in Rozansky-Witten theory. On the other hand, this theory is an essential ingredient in the worldvolume theory of M2 membranes in manifolds of G2 holonomy [23], and the computation of the Rozansky-Witten partition function should play a role in understanding membrane instanton effects in G2 compactifications of M theory. 2) Chern-Simons theory on a three-manifold M describes topological A branes wrapping the Lagrangian submanifold M in the Calabi-Yau T ∗ M [45]. Moreover, the perturbative invariants of Chern-Simons theory correspond to topological open string amplitudes on that target. Having a systematic procedure to compute ChernSimons perturbative invariants may prove to be useful in further understanding topological open strings in those backgrounds. 3) Another consequence of our results is that topological A branes in T ∗ M are described by a matrix model, when M is a Seifert sphere. It has been recently shown [16] that topological B branes on some noncompact Calabi-Yau spaces are described by a Hermitian matrix model characterized by a potential W () with multiple cuts. It would be interesting to know if there is a relation between the matrix models of [16] and the ones presented here. Notice that according to our results the partition function of U (N ) Chern-Simons theory on S3 can be written as e− 12 N(N N! x
Z=
2 −1)
N dβi i=1
2π
e−
i
βi2 /2x
2 sinh
i<j
βi − βj 2 . 2
(6.1)
This describes open topological A strings on T ∗ S3 with N branes wrapping S3 , or equivalently (after the geometric transition of [21]) closed topological strings on the resolved conifold. In the limit x → 0, (6.1) gives the standard Gaussian model, as we have argued at length in this paper. On the other hand, it is shown in [16] that the Gaussian model (which corresponds to W () = 2 ) describes type topological B strings in the deformed conifold geometry. This is consistent with the fact that, as explained in [41], the deformed conifold geometry gives the mirror of the resolved conifold only at small ’t Hooft coupling t = N x, which for fixed N means precisely small x. This also suggests to consider multicut matrix models with a potential W (), as in [16], but where the eigenvalue interaction is not the usual one i<j (βi − βj )2 , but i<j (2 sinh((βi − βj )/2))2 . In view of the above observation, these deformed models might be relevant to understand the mirror of the geometric transition studied in [11, 16]. Indeed, a compact version of this, corresponding to a unitary matrix model where the βi are periodic variables, has been considered in [17] in order to describe the stringy realization of the N = 2 Seiberg-Witten geometry. 4) Although in this paper the focus has been on the perturbative expansion of the partition function, the matrix model is also very useful to understand its large N expansion. This is an interesting problem in itself, and it would be nice to see what is the connection to the approach of [18]. But of course the large N expansion of these models is particularly interesting in view of the large N dualities involving
Chern-Simons Theory
45
Chern-Simons theory [20, 21]. Although these dualities are not expected to hold for arbitrary Seifert spaces, the results presented here may be useful to understand in detail the case of lens spaces (already analyzed in [20]) and shed light on the situation for more general three-manifolds. Acknowledgements. I would like to thank Bobby Acharya, Mina Aganagic, Emanuel Diaconescu, Jaume Gomis, Rajesh Gopakumar, Shinobu Hikami, Jose Labastida, Greg Moore, Boris Pioline, Justin Sawon, Toshie Takata, Miguel Tierz and Cumrun Vafa for useful discussions and correspondence. Thanks to Justin too for providing me the graphs of his thesis. This work is supported by the grant NSF–PHY/98–02709.
A. Appendix A.1. Group theory factors. We first present the group theory factors associated to the connected graphs that give a basis of A(∅)conn up to order 5. The evaluation of these factors is straightforward by using the graphical techniques of Cvitanovi´c [12], and rather immediate for all of them (except for rω (G), that gives the quartic Casimir in the adjoint and has been computed for all gauge groups in the second reference of [12]). Our conventions are as in [12]: the Lie algebra in the defining representation has Hermitian generators Ti , i = 1, . . . , d satisfying the commutation relations [Ti , Tj ] = iCij k . The generators are normalized in such a way that the quadratic Casimir of the adjoint representation CA (which is defined here by CA δij = k,l Cikl Cj kl ) is twice the dual Coxeter number. This implies that Tr(Ti Tj ) = aδij with a = 1 for SU (N ) and Sp(N ), and a = 2 for SO(N ) (notice that these normalizations differ from the ones in [1, 2]). The group factor will be written in terms of the dual Coxeter y, the dimension of the group d, and α2 (where αk is defined in (5.17)). Their values for SU (N ), SO(N ) are listed in Table 2. The results for Sp(N ) follow from the Sp(N ) = SO(−N ) relation [13], Sp(N) SO(N) so for Sp(N ) one has d = N (N + 1)/2, y = N + 2 and α2 (N ) = α2 (−N ). The group theory factors for the graphs in (3.8) are listed in Table 3. A.2. Matrix integrals. We now list the results for the matrix integrals (5.9), up to order 5. The results for k1 = 0 are: R(0,1,0,··· ) (G) = 5 dy 2 , R(0,0,1,0,··· ) (G) = 35 dy 3 , R(0,2,0,0,··· ) (G) = 25 d(d + 12)y 4 − 2880α2 , R(0,0,0,1,0,··· ) (G) = 350 dy 4 − 1680α2 , R(0,1,1,0,0,··· ) (G) = 35 y 5d(d + 24)y 4 − 1728α2 , R(0,0,0,0,1,0,··· ) (G) = 4620 y dy 4 − 12α2 . Table 2. Dimensions, dual Coxeter numbers and α2 for SU (N) and SO(N) SU (N)
SO(N)
d
N2 − 1
1 2 N(N
y
N
α2
1 2 2 60 N (N
− 1)
N −2 − 1)(2N 2 − 3)
1 480 N(N
− 1)(N − 2)(8N 3 − 45N 2 + 54N + 32)
(A.1)
46
M. Mari˜no Table 3. Group theory factors for the Feynman graphs up to = 5
graph
group factor
1
2dy
2
2 4dy e e J e
8dy 3
3
4
e
e
e
e
16dy 4
@
5
@ eee
18dy 4 − 480α2
e
32dy 5
@
e
e
@
2y(18dy 4 − 480α2 )
The results for k1 > 0 can be obtained from (A.1) very easily: insertions of σ1 (β) can be reduced to insertions of β 2 by using (5.16), and these can be computed by taking derivatives with respect to a in (5.15). We have for example: R(2,1,0,··· ) (G) = 5d(d + 4)(d + 6)y 4 . Finally, the integral Z0 in (5.11) is given by r
1
Z0 = (2π) 2 |W|(det C) 2
(α · ρ).
(A.2)
(A.3)
α>0
Note that this combines with the rest of the factors in (5.13) to produce, up to an overall phase Z1−loop
1 (2π)|+ | Vol w 2 = (α · ρ), (l|H |)d/2 Vol r
(A.4)
α>0
where we have used that Vol r /Vol w = det(C). If instead of taking the volume of the root lattice in (A.4) we take that of the coroot lattice, the resulting expression for the partition function is probably valid for any gauge group. A.3. Symmetric polynomials. Here we summarize some ingredients of the elementary theory of symmetric functions that are used in the paper. A standard reference is [33]. Let x1 , · · · , xN denote a set of N variables. The elementary symmetric polynomials in these variables, Em (x), are defined as:
Chern-Simons Theory
47
Em (x) =
xi1 . . . xim .
(A.5)
i1 <...
The products of elementary symmetric polynomials provide a basis for the symmetric functions of N variables with integer coefficients. Another basis is given by the Schur polynomials, Sλ (x), which are labeled by Young tableaux. A tableau will be denoted here by a partition λ = (λ1 , λ2 , . . . , λp ), where λi is the number of boxes of the i th row of the tableau, and we have λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · ≥ λp . The total number of boxes of a tableau will be denoted by |λ| = i λi . The Schur polynomials are defined as quotients of determinants, det xjλi +N −i
Sλ (x) =
det xjN−i
.
(A.6)
A third set of symmetric functions is given by the Newton polynomials Pk (x). These are labeled by vectors k = (k1 , k2 , · · · , kp ), where the kj are nonnegative integers, and they are defined as Pk (x) =
p j =1
k
Pj j (x),
(A.7)
where Pj (x) =
N
j
(A.8)
xi ,
i=1
are power sums. The Newton polynomials are homogeneous of degree = j j kj and give a basis for the symmetric functions in x1 , · · · , xN with rational coefficients. They are related to the Schur polynomials through the Frobenius formula, λ (x), Pk (x) = χλ (k)S (A.9) λ
is the character of the where the sum is over all tableaux such that |λ| = , and χλ (k) symmetric group in the representation associated to λ and evaluated on the conjugacy class associated to k (this is the conjugacy class with kj cycles of length j ). Finally, one has the following relation between elementary symmetric polynomials and Newton polynomials, (−1) Em (x) = k
where the sum is over all vectors with
j
j
j (kj −1)
kj !j kj
Pk (x),
(A.10)
j kj = m.
References ´ 1. Alvarez, M., Labastida, J.M.F.: Numerical knot invariants of finite type from Chern-Simons perturbation theory. Nucl. Phys. B 433, 555 (1995) [Erratum-ibid. B 441, 403 (1995)]; Vassiliev invariants for torus knots. J. Knot Theory Ramifications 5, 779 (1996); Primitive Vassiliev invariants and factorization in Chern-Simons perturbation theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 189, 641 (1997) ´ 2. Alvarez, M., Labastida, J.M.F., P´erez, E.: Vassiliev invariants for links from Chern-Simons perturbation theory. Nucl. Phys. B 488, 677 (1997) ´ 3. Alvarez-Gaum´ e, L., Labastida, J.M.F., Ramallo, A.V.: A note on perturbative Chern-Simons theory. Nucl. Phys. B 334, 103 (1990)
48
M. Mari˜no
4. Atiyah, M.: On framings of three-manifolds. Topology 29, 1 (1990) 5. Axelrod, S., Singer, I.: Chern-Simons perturbation theory. In: Differential geometric methods in theoretical physics, Singapore World Scientific, 1991, pp. 3 6. Bar-Natan, D.: Perturbative aspects of the Chern-Simons topological quantum field theory. Ph.D. Thesis, 1991, in http://www.math.toronto.edu.il/∼drorbn/LOP.html, 1991 7. Bar-Natan, D.: On the Vassiliev knot invariants. Topology 34, 423 (1995) 8. Bar-Natan, D., Garoufalidis, S., Rozansky, L., Thurston, D.P.: The Aarhus integral of rational homology spheres, I, II, III. Selecta Mathematica, New Series 8, 315–339; 341–371 (2002), and Selecta Mathematica, To appear 9. Bar-Natan, D., Lawrence, R.: A rational surgery formula for the LMO invariant. Israel J. Math. 140, 29–60 (2004) 10. Br´ezin, E., Hikami, S.: Characteristic polynomials of random matrices. Commun. Math. Phys. 214, 214 (2000) 11. Cachazo, F., Intriligator, K.A., Vafa, C.: A large N duality via a geometric transition. Nucl. Phys. B 603, 3 (2001) 12. Cvitanovi´c, P.: Group theory for Feynman diagrams in non-Abelian gauge theories. Phys. Rev. D 14, 1536 (1976); Group Theory, Nordita, 1984, updated as Group theory. Exceptional Lie groups as invariance groups http://www.nbi.dk/GroupTheory/postscript.html, 2002 13. Cvitanovi´c, P., Kennedy, A.D.: Spinors in negative dimensions. Phys. Scripta 26, 5 (1982) 14. Di Francesco, P., Mathieu, P., S´en´echal, D.: Conformal field theory, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag, 1997 15. Dijkgraaf, R.: Perturbative topological field theory. In: String theory, gauge theory and quantum gravity ’93, Singapore: World Scientific, 1994, pp. 189 16. Dijkgraaf, R., Vafa, C.: Matrix models, topological strings, and supersymmetric gauge theories. Nucl. Phys. B 644, 3 (2002) 17. Dijkgraaf, R., Vafa, C.: On geometry and matrix models. Nucl. Phys. B 644, 21 (2002) 18. Douglas, M.R.: Chern-Simons-Witten theory as a topological Fermi liquid. http://arxiv.org/abs/hepth/9403119, 1994 19. Freed, D.S., Gompf, R.E.: Computer calculation of Witten’s three manifold invariant. Commun. Math. Phys. 141, 79 (1991) 20. Gopakumar, R., Vafa, C.: Topological gravity as large N topological gauge theory. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys.2, 413 (1998) 21. Gopakumar, R., Vafa, C.: On the gauge theory/geometry correspondence. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 3, 1415 (1999) 22. Hansen, S.K.: Reshetikhin-Turaev invariants of Seifert 3-manifolds and a rational surgery formula. Algebr. Geom. Top. 1, 627 (2001) 23. Harvey, J.A., Moore, G.W.: Superpotentials and membrane instantons. http://arxiv.org/abs/hepth/9907026, 1999 24. Itzykson, C., Drouffe, J.-M.: Th´eorie statistique des champs, 2. Paris: InterEditions, 1989 25. Itzykson, C., Zuber, J.B.: Matrix integration and combinatorics of modular groups. Commun. Math. Phys. 134, 197 (1990) 26. Jeffrey, L.C.: Chern-Simons-Witten invariants of lens spaces and torus bundles, and the semiclassical approximation. Commun. Math. Phys. 147, 563 (1992) 27. Kadell, K.W.J.: The Selberg-Jack symmetric functions. Adv. Math. 130, 33 (1997) 28. Labastida, J.M.F.: Chern-Simons gauge theory: ten years after. http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9905057, 1999 29. Lawrence, R.J.: Asymptotic expansions of Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariants for some simple 3-manifolds. J. Math. Phys. 36, 6106 (1995) 30. Lawrence, R., Rozansky, L.: Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariants of Seifert manifolds. Commun. Math. Phys. 205, 287 (1999) 31. Le, T.T.Q., Murakami, J., Ohtsuki, T.: On a universal perturbative invariant of 3-manifolds. Topology 37, 539 (1998) 32. Lickorish, W.B.R.: An introduction to knot theory. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag, 1998 33. MacDonald, I.G.: Symmetric functions and Hall polynomials. 2nd edn, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995 34. Mehta, M.L.: Random matrices. 2nd edn, London-New York: Academic Press, 1991 35. Rozansky, L.: A large k asymptotics of Witten’s invariant of Seifert manifolds. Commun. Math. Phys. 171, 279 (1995) 36. Rozansky, L.: A contribution of the trivial connection to Jones polynomial and Witten’s invariant of 3-D manifolds. 1, 2. Commun. Math. Phys. 175, 275, 297 (1996) 37. Rozansky, L.: Residue formulas for the large k asymptotics of Witten’s invariants of Seifert manifolds: The case of SU (2). Commun. Math. Phys. 178, 27 (1996)
Chern-Simons Theory
49
38. Rozansky, L., Witten, E.: HyperK¨ahler geometry and invariants of three-manifolds. Selecta Math. 3, 401 (1997) 39. Sawon, J.: Rozansky-Witten invariants of hyperK¨ahler manifolds. Ph.D. Thesis, http://arxiv.org/abs/math.DG/0404360, 2004 40. Takata, T.: On quantum P SU (N) invariants for Seifert manifolds. J. Knot Theory Ramifications 6, 417 (1997) 41. Vafa, C.: Superstrings and topological strings at large N. J. Math. Phys. 42, 2798 (2001) 42. Verlinde, E.: Fusion rules and modular transformations in 2-D conformal field theory. Nucl. Phys. B 300, 360 (1988) 43. Vogel, P.: Algebraic structure on modules of diagrams. Preprint 1997, at http://www.math.jussieu.fr/˜ vogel 44. Witten, E.: Quantum field theory and the Jones polynomial. Commun. Math. Phys. 121, 351 (1989) 45. Witten, E.: Chern-Simons gauge theory as a string theory. Prog. Math. 133, 637–378 (1995) Communicated by N.A. Nekrasov
Commun. Math. Phys. 253, 51–79 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-004-1206-4
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Characteristic Properties of the Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line Anne Boutet de Monvel1 , Vladimir Kotlyarov2 1 2
Institut de Math´ematiques de Jussieu, case 7012, Universit´e Paris 7, 2 place Jussieu, 75251 Paris, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Mathematical Division, Institute for Low Temperature Physics, 47 Lenin Avenue, 61103 Kharkiv, Ukraine. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 22 May 2003 / Accepted: 12 March 2004 Published online: 5 November 2004 – © Springer-Verlag 2004
Abstract: In this paper we describe characteristic properties of the scattering data of the compatible eigenvalue problem for the pair of differential equations related to the modified Korteweg-de Vries (mKdV) equation whose solution is defined in some halfstrip or in the quarter plane (0 < x < ∞) × [0, T ), T ≤ ∞. We suppose that this solution has a C ∞ initial function vanishing as x → ∞, and C ∞ boundary values, vanishing as t → ∞ when T = ∞. We study the corresponding scattering problem for the compatible Zakharov-Shabat system of differential equations associated with the mKdV equation and obtain a representation of the solution of the mKdV equation through Marchenko integral equations of the inverse scattering method. The kernel of these equations is valid only for x ≥ 0 and it takes into account all specific properties of the pair of compatible differential equations in the chosen half-strip or in the quarter plane. The main result of the paper is the collection A–B–C of characteristic properties of the scattering functions given below. 1. Introduction 1.1. Initial-boundary value problems on the half-line. Initial value problems on the whole line for nonlinear integrable equations such as the nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation, the Korteweg-de Vries equation, the sine-Gordon equation, etc. are well studied. The solvability of the Cauchy problem, multi-soliton solutions, the proof that these nonlinear equations are completely integrable infinite-dimensional Hamiltonian systems are the most significant results in the soliton theory on the whole line. At the same time the initial-boundary value problem on the half-line for nonlinear integrable equations has not been studied so far. In the last decade attention to those problem has strongly increased. Among papers [2–15, 20–33, 36–47] devoted to this problem, the most interesting results were obtained by A.S. Fokas [20], A.S. Fokas and A.R. Its [22–24]. Later, in [26] A.S. Fokas has proposed a general method for solving boundary value problems for two-dimensional linear and integrable nonlinear partial differential
52
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
equations. This method, which was further developed in [21, 27–29], is based on the simultaneous spectral analysis of the two eigenvalue equations of the associated Lax pair. It expresses the solution in terms of the solution of a matrix Riemann-Hilbert problem in the complex plane of the spectral parameter. The spectral functions determining the Riemann-Hilbert problem are expressed in terms of the initial and boundary values of the solution. The fact that these initial and boundary values are in general related can be expressed in a simple way in terms of a global relation satisfied by the corresponding spectral functions. In the framework of this approach we recently found characteristic properties of the scattering data for the compatible Zakharov-Shabat eigenvalue problem associated with focusing and defocusing nonlinear Schr¨odinger equations on the half-line with initial and boundary functions of Schwartz type [9]. Recently in [11] (see also [33]) an initial-boundary value problem for the mKdV equation on the half-line was analyzed by expressing the solution in terms of the solution of a matrix Riemann-Hilbert problem in the complex k-plane. In particular, it is shown that for a subclass of boundary conditions, the “linearizable boundary conditions”, all spectral functions can be computed from the given initial data by using algebraic manipulations of some “global relation”. Thus in this case, the problem on the half-line can be solved as efficiently as the problem on the whole line. But the general initial-boundary value problem on the half-line remains non-linearizable. Characteristic properties of the spectral functions were not considered in [11]. In this connection the characterization of the spectral functions becomes important. Besides, a description of the characteristic properties of the scattering or spectral data is a very important problem in itself [35]. Most papers initiated by problems on the half-line deal with nonlinear dynamics of the spectral or scattering data. We prefer the approach of A.S. Fokas and A.R. Its where scattering (spectral) data have trivial dynamics. But then analytic properties of the scattering data are more complicated. Therefore it is necessary to give their complete description when, of course, initial and boundary functions belong to suitable classes of functions. We introduce spectral data in a natural way as in ordinary scattering problems: • First, a “scattering matrix” for the x-equation (by initial function). • Then, a “scattering matrix” for the t-equation (by boundary functions). • Finally, a “scattering matrix” for the compatible x- and t-equations as a product. In this case a kernel of the Marchenko integral equations or a jump matrix of the corresponding Riemann-Hilbert problem has an explicit (x, t)-dependence. That makes it possible to study the asymptotic behavior of the solution of the non-linear problem by using, for example, the powerful steepest descent method of P. Deift and X. Zhou [16, 17] while the non-linear dynamics of the spectral or scattering data makes it almost impossible to obtain an effective asymptotics of the solution.
1.2. The initial-boundary value problem for the modified Korteweg-de Vries equation. In this paper we consider the problem to characterize “scattering data” for a compatible pair of differential equations attached to the modified Korteweg-de Vries (mKdV) equation. Let q(x, t) be a real-valued solution of the mKdV equation
x ∈ R+ ,
qt + qxxx − 6λq 2 qx = 0, t ∈ [0, T ), T ≤ ∞, λ = ±1
(1.1)
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
53
in the half-strip or quarter xt-plane and suppose the initial function q(x, 0) = u(x) with x ∈ R+ and the boundary values q(0, t) = v(t)
qx (0, t) = v1 (t)
qxx (0, t) = v2 (t) with t ∈ [0, T ],
T ≤∞
C∞,
and u(x) ∈ S(R+ ), where S(R+ ) is the Schwartz space of rapidly decreasing are functions on R+ , i.e. C ∞ functions whose derivatives of any order n ≥ 0 vanish at infinity faster than any negative power of x. For T = ∞ the boundary values are also supposed to be rapidly decreasing: v(t), v1 (t), v2 (t) ∈ S(R+ ). Remark. We consider here the IBV problem for the mKdV equation (1.1) in the first quarter (x ≥ 0, t ≥ 0) of the xt-plane. This problem differs from that studied in [11] which is also on the first quarter but for the mKdV equation of the form: qt − qxxx + 6λq 2 qx = 0. This form can be easily reduced to (1.1), but then the IBV problem is on the second quarter (x ≤ 0, t ≥ 0) of the xt-plane. Scattering (spectral) data for that problem have different analytic properties. It is well-known that for KdV and mKdV equations there are differences between the IBV problems for x > 0 and for x < 0. To study the solution q(x, t) we shall use spectral analysis of a compatible eigenvalue problem for the linear x-equation wx + ikσ3 w = Q(x, t)w, 1 0 , σ3 = 0 −1 0 q(x, t) Q(x, t) = , λq(x, t) 0
(1.2)
and for the linear t-equation ˆ t, k)w, wt + 4ik 3 σ3 w = Q(x, 3 ˆ Q(x, t, k) = 2Q (x, t) − Qxx − 2ik(Q2 (x, t) +Qx (x, t))σ3 + 4k 2 Q(x, t).
(1.3)
This is the well-known Ablowitz-Kaup-Newel-Segur [1] or Zakharov-Shabat [48] system of linear equations, which are compatible if and only if q(x, t) satisfies the mKdV equation. The main goal of the present paper is to study the scattering problem for compatible differential equations (1.2) and (1.3) on the half-strip or on the quarter of the xt-plane. We will combine the Marchenko integral equation and the corresponding Riemann–Hilbert problem in our approach to obtain characteristic properties of scattering data. We get a description of these characteristic properties and obtain a representation of the solution of the mKdV equation through Marchenko integral equations of the inverse scattering method. The kernel of these equations is valid for x ≥ 0 only and it takes into account all specific properties which occurred for compatible differential equations on the half-line. In particular, the solution of the mKdV equation given by our method does not have continuation for x < 0. It is well defined on the half-strip or on the quarter of the
54
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
JJ
2 J
J
1 3 J
J
J
J 4 6
J 5
J
JJ
Fig. 1. = {k ∈ C | Im k 3 = 0} and 1 , . . . , 6
xt-plane. Then, if one is using our representation of the solution of the mKdV equation and the explicit (x, t)-dependence of the kernel of the Marchenko integral equations or the jump matrix in the Riemann-Hilbert problem one can easily obtain the asymptotic behavior of the solution in the same way as in [16, 17 or 34]. 1.3. Scattering data: definition. Let q(x, t) be a real-valued solution of Eq. (1.1) with initial and boundary functions satisfying smoothness and decreasing assumptions described above. Let us define = {k ∈ C | Im k 3 = 0} and domains 1 , . . . , 6 as depicted on Fig. 1. Scattering data are introduced as follows: 1. The initial function u(x) = q(x, 0) and the x-equation (1.2) at t = 0 define the Jost solution (x, 0, k) = exp(−ikxσ3 ) + o(1), x → ∞ and a “scattering matrix” S(k) :=
−1
s2+ (k) −s1+ (k) (0, 0, k) = , −s2− (k) s1− (k)
¯ s1− (k) = s¯2+ (k),
¯ s2− (k) = λ¯s1+ (k).
In particular, they define • the spectral function r(k) = −s2− (k)/s2+ (k), called the “reflection coefficient”, and, in a generic situation: • eigenvalues kj ∈ C+ , j = 1, . . . , n, which are the zeros of s2+ (k) in C+ , • numbers1 mj = [is1+ (kj )˙s2+ (kj )]−1 , j = 1, . . . , n. 2. Boundary data v(t) = q(0, t), v1 (t) = qx (0, t), v2 (t) = qxx (0, t), with t ∈ [0, T ], T ≤ ∞ together with the t-equation at x = 0 define a solution Y (0, t, k) = exp(−4ik 3 tσ3 ),
1
The dot denotes differentiation with respect to k.
t ≤ T,
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
55
then a “scattering matrix"
p1− (k, T ) p1+ (k, T ) P (k, T ) := Y (0, 0, k) = , p2− (k, T ) p2+ (k, T ) ¯ T ), p − (k, T ) = λp¯ + (k, ¯ T) where p1− (k, T ) = p¯ 2+ (k, 2 1 and, together with S(k), another “scattering matrix" − r1 (k, T ) r1+ (k, T ) R(k, T ) = S(k)P (k, T ) = − . r2 (k, T ) r2+ (k, T ) 3. Now we introduce: • one more spectral function c(k, T ) =
p2− (k, T )
s2+ (k)r1− (k, T )
,
and, in a generic situation: • eigenvalues zj ∈ 2 , j = 1, . . . , m, which are the zeros of r1− (k, T ) in 2 , • numbers m2j = −i Resk=zj c(k, T ), j = 1, . . . , m, which depend on the initial and boundary functions. In what follows we consider the generic situation where initial and boundary functions are such that eigenvalues kj ∈ C+ , j = 1, . . . , n and zj ∈ 2 , j = 1, . . . , m are simple and finite in number, with s1+ (kj ) = 0, j = 1, . . . , n and s2+ (k) = 0, k ∈ R. Definition (scattering data). We define the set R = {s1+ (k), s2+ (k), k ∈ C+ ; p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ), k ∈ }, where
=
C if T < ∞, 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 5 if T = ∞,
as “scattering data” of the compatible eigenvalue problem for the system of differential equations (1.2)-(1.3) with q(x, t) satisfying the mKdV equation (1.1). 1.4. Scattering data: conditions A-B-C. Now we introduce three sets of conditions on the set of scattering data R. Conditions A. Conditions on s1+ (k), s2+ (k), p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ). ¯ s1+ (k), s2+ (k) are analytic in k ∈ C+ and sj+ (k) = s¯j+ (−k). + + 2 2 |s2 (k)| − λ|s1 (k)| ≡ 1 for k ∈ R. s2+ (k) = 1 + O(k −1 ), s1+ (k) = O(k −1 ), k ∈ C+ . If λ = 1, s2+ (k) = 0 in C+ . If λ = −1, s2+ (k) = 0, k ∈ C+ ⇒ s1+ (k) = 0. p1+ (k, T ) and p2+ (k, T ) are entire for T < ∞ or analytic in k ∈ if T = ∞. ¯ Moreover, pj+ (k) = p¯ j+ (−k). + + ¯ + + ¯ A6. p2 (k)p¯ 2 (k) − λp1 (k)p¯ 1 (k) ≡ 1 for k 3 ∈ R. A7. p2+ (k, T ) = 1 + O(k −1 ) and p1+ (k, T ) = O(k −1 ) for k ∈ , as k → ∞.
A1. A2. A3. A4. A5.
56
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
A8. If T < ∞, then p2+ (k, T ) = 1 + O
3T
e8ik k
, p1+ (k, T ) = O
3T
e8ik k
for k ∈
2 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 , as k → ∞. A9. s1+ (k), s2+ (k), p1+ (k, T ) and p2+ (k, T ) satisfy the relation: s1+ (k)p2+ (k, T ) − s2+ (k)p1+ (k, T )
c1 (k, T )e8ik 0,
=
3T
if T < ∞, if T = ∞,
where c1 (k, T ) is analytic in k ∈ C+ and O(k −1 ) as k → ∞. Definition. Let R be given. We define r(k), k ∈ R by r(k) = −λ
s¯1+ (k) s2+ (k)
.
Conditions B. Conditions on r(k), k ∈ R. B1. r(k) ∈ C ∞ (R). B2. The function
∞ −∞
r(k) eikx+8ik t dk 3
is C ∞ in x, t for x > 0 and t ≥ 0. Definition. Let R be given. We define c(k, T ), k ∈ C+ by c(k, T ) =
¯ T) λp¯ 1+ (k,
¯ T )s + (k) − λp¯ + (k, ¯ T )s + (k)] s2+ (k)[p¯ 2+ (k, 2 1 1
.
Conditions C. Conditions on c(k, T ), k ∈ C+ . C1. If λ = 1, c(k, T ) is analytic in the half-plane C+ for T < ∞ or in the domain 2 for T = ∞. C2. If λ = −1, c(k, T ) is meromorphic in the half-plane C+ for T < ∞, or in the domain 2 for T = ∞, where it can have poles at some points z1 , z2 , . . . , zm . C3. c(k) has C ∞ boundary values on R forn T < ∞, or on ∂2 for T = ∞. d r(k) dn c(k, T ) =− , n = 0, 1, 2, . . . . C4. If T = ∞, then n dk dk n k=0 k=0 C5. The function ∂2
is C ∞ in t.
c(k, T )e8ik t dk + 3
∞ −∞
r(k)e8ik t dk 3
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
57
1.5. Recovering of q(x, t) from scattering data. Then we prove that the solution q(x, t) of the non-linear problem (1.1) can be written q(x, t) = 2K2 (x, x, t),
(1.4)
where K2 (x, y, t), together with K1 (x, y, t), satisfies the Marchenko integral equations: ∞ K2 (x, z, t)H (z + y, t)dz = 0 for 0 ≤ x < y < ∞, (1.5) K1 (x, y, t) + λ x ∞ K1 (x, z, t)H (z + y, t)dz = 0 (1.6) K2 (x, y, t) + H (x + y, t) + x
with kernel 1−λ H (x, t) = 2 1 + 2π
kj ∈1
∂2
3 m1j eikj x+8ikj t
c(k, T )e
+
ikx+8ik 3 t
zj ∈2
dk
3 m2j eizj x+8izj t
1 + 2π
∞
−∞
+
kj ∈3
3 m3j eikj x+8ikj t
r(k)eikx+8ik t dk, 3
(1.7)
where m1j = [is1+ (kj )˙s2+ (kj )]−1 for kj ∈ 1 , m3j = [is1+ (kj )˙s2+ (kj )]−1 for kj ∈ 3 , and m2j = −i Resk=zj c(k, T ) for zj ∈ 2 . 1.6. Main theorem. The main result is that properties A–B–C are characteristic: Theorem. In the generic situation described above, Conditions A–B–C on R = {s1+ (k), s2+ (k), k ∈ C+ ; p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ), k ∈ } characterize the scattering data of a compatible eigenvalue problem (1.2)–(1.3) for xand t-equations defined by a solution q(x, t) of the mKdV equation (1.1) with initial function u(x) ∈ S(R+ ) and boundary values v(t), v1 (t), v2 (t) ∈ C ∞ [0, T ] if T < ∞, or v(t), v1 (t), v2 (t) ∈ S(R+ ) if T = ∞. Remark. Condition B2 (about smoothness of the integral with respect to x and t) is fulfilled if the initial and boundary functions obey the following relations: dn dn dn dn u(x) = v(t) = v (t) = v (t) =0 1 2 x=0 t=0 t=0 t=0 dx n dt n dt n dt n
(1.8)
for any n ≥ 0. In this case the reflection coefficient r(k) is in the Schwartz space S(R). Under these assumptions Condition C5 is also fulfilled. Remark. If u(x) ≡ 0, Conditions A1–A4 and B are trivial: r(k) ≡ 0, s1+ (k) ≡ 0, s2+ (k) ≡ 1, {k1 , . . . , kn } = ∅. There remain only Conditions A5–A9 and C. They mean that any solution of the mKdV equation in the half-strip or quarter plane with zero initial ¯ T ), analytic (λ = 1) or function is parametrized by only one function c(k, T ) = c(− ¯ k, meromorphic (λ = −1) in 2 with poles at z1 , . . . , zm .
58
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
2. Basic Solutions of Compatible x- and t-Equations Let us write the x- and t-equations in the form Wx = U (x, t, k)W, Wt = V (x, t, k)W,
(2.1) (2.2)
where U (x, t, k) and V (x, t, k) are matrices given by U (x, t, k) = Q(x, t) − ikσ3 , V (x, t, k) = 2Q3 (x, t) − Qxx − 2ik(Q2 (x, t) + Qx (x, t))σ3 + 4k 2 Q(x, t) − 4ik 3 σ3 . Lemma 1. Let the system (2.1), (2.2) be compatible for all k. Let W (x, t, k) satisfy the x-equation (2.1) for all t, and let W (x0 , t, k) satisfy the t-equation (2.2) for some x = x0 (including the case x0 = ∞). Then W (x, t, k) satisfies the t-equation for all x. Proof. See e.g. [9].
Notations. The over-bar denotes the complex conjugation. C± denotes the upper (lower) complex half plane. If A = A− A+ denotes a 2 × 2 matrix, the vectors A∓ denote the first and second columns of A. We also denote [A, B] = AB − BA. In this section we shall introduce basic solutions of compatible x- and t-equations.
2.1. First basic solution. The first basic solution is a matrix-valued Jost solution of the x-equation (1.2). It has the triangular integral representation (see e.g. [19]) (x, t, k) = e−ikxσ3 +
∞ x
3 K(x, y, t)e−ikyσ3 dy e−4ik tσ3 ,
(2.3)
where real-valued matrix K(x, y, t) has the form
K1 (x, y, t) λK2 (x, y, t) K(x, y, t) = K2 (x, y, t) K1 (x, y, t) with entries in C ∞ (R+ × R+ × R+ ) and rapidly decreasing as x + y → ∞ for any t ∈ R+ . Matrices K(x, x, t) and Q(x, t) are connected by the relation: [σ3 , K(x, x, t)] = Q(x, t)σ3 .
(2.4)
This last equality yields the important formula (1.4) for the solution q(x, t) of the modified Korteweg-de Vries equation. The matrix (x, t, k) satisfies the x-equation (1.2) 2 and it satisfies the t-equation (1.3) with x = ∞, because the matrix e−ik(x+4k t)σ3 is a solution of both Eqs. (1.2) and (1.3) with Q(x, t) ≡ 0. Lemma 1 implies that (x, t, k) satisfies the t-equation for any x ∈ R+ due to the compatibility of the x- and t-equations. The triangular integral representation (2.3) and Lemma 1 imply the following properties of the matrix-valued Jost solution (x, t, k) (cf. [19]):
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
59
Properties of the first basic solution. 1. (x, t, k) satisfies the x- and t-equations (1.2)–(1.3). 01 −1 ¯ 2. (x, t, k) = (x, t, k) for k ∈ R, = . λ0 3. det (x, t, k) ≡ 1 for k ∈ R. 4. (x, t, k) → (x, t, k) ∈ C ∞ (R+ × R+ × R). 5. + (x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ C+ , − (x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ C− . ¯ 6. ± (x, t, k) = ± (x, t, −k). 7. For k → ∞, 3 1 eikx+4ik t − (x, t, k) = + O(k −1 ) if Im k ≤ 0, 0 3 0 e−ikx−4ik t + (x, t, k) = + O(k −1 ) if Im k ≥ 0. 1 2.2. Second basic solution. Now let us introduce the second basic solution (x, t, k) of the x- and t-equations which satisfies the initial condition 10 (0, 0, k) = σ0 ≡ . (2.5) 01 It can be represented as a product of two matrices: (x, t, k) = ϕ(x, t, k)ϕ(t, ˆ k),
(2.6)
where ϕ(x, t, k) satisfies the x-equation under the condition ϕ(0, t, k) = σ0 , and ϕ(t, ˆ k) satisfies the t-equation with x = 0 under initial condition ϕ(0, ˆ k) = σ0 . Lemma 1 implies that (x, t, k) is a compatible solution of the x- and t-equations. The existence of the solution ϕ(x, t, k) and its representation x −ikxσ3 ϕ(x, t, k) = e + A(x, y, t)e−ikyσ3 dy (2.7) −x
by some integral kernel A(x, y, t) are proved in [9]. The matrix ϕ(t, ˆ k) can be found as a solution of the Volterra integral equation: t 3 3 ˆ ϕ(t, ˆ k) = e−4ik tσ3 + e4ik (τ −t) Q(0, τ, k)ϕ(τ, ˆ k)dτ, (2.8) 0
where ˆ Q(0, t, k) =
−2iλkv 2 (t)
2v 3 (t)+4λk 2 v(t)−2iλkv1 (t)−λv2 (t)
2λv 3 (t)+4k 2 v(t)+2ikv1 (t)−v2 (t) 2iλkv 2 (t)
Besides ϕ(t, ˆ k) has the integral representation: t 3 3 ϕ(t, ˆ k) = e−4ik tσ3 + B(t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds −t t 3 C(t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds + k 2 +ik −t
t
−t
D(t, s)e−4ik
3 sσ 3
ds,
.
(2.9)
60
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
which will be used below. The proof of this triangular representation can be done in the same way as in [9]. In the present case the matrix-valued real functions A(x, y, t), B(t, s), C(t, s) and D(t, s) are C ∞ and bounded in x, y, t, s. The triangular integral representations (2.6)–(2.9) yield the following properties of the solution (x, t, k): Properties of the second basic solution. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
(x, t, k) is a solution of the x- and t-equations. ¯ −1 for any k ∈ C. ¯ (x, t, k) = (x, t, k) ¯ for any k ∈ C. ¯ (x, t, k) = (x, t, −k) det (x, t, k) ≡ 1 for any k ∈ C. (x, t, k) → (x, t, k) ∈ C ∞ (R+ × R+ × C). (x, t, k) is analytic (entire) in k ∈ C. For k ∈ C, k → ∞,
(x, t, k) = I + O(k
−1
e2ikxσ3
e8ik 3 tσ3 2 )+O +O e−ik(x+4k t)σ3 . k k
8. For k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 , k → ∞, eikx+4ik t − (x, t, k) = 3
1 + O(k −1 ). 0
The last asymptotic relation can be easily proved using large k asymptotics for the functions ϕ ∓ (x, t, k) and ϕˆ − (t, k). ˆ k) be a 2.3. Third basic solution. Let = {k ∈ C | Im k 3 = 0} as above and let (t, solution of the Volterra integral equation ∞ 3 −4ik 3 tσ3 ˆ ˆ ˆ (t, k) = e − e−4ik (τ −t)σ3 Q(0, τ, k)(τ, k)dτ, k ∈ , t
ˆ ˆ where Q(0, t, k) is as in (2.8) and Q(0, t, k) ≡ 0 for t > T if T < ∞, that means ˆ k) satisfies the t-equation with x = 0 under the asymptotic condition the matrix (t, ˆ k) the triangular integral repreˆ k) = e−4ik 3 tσ3 + o(1) as t → ∞. Again, for (t, (t, sentation ∞ 3 −4ik 3 tσ3 ˆ (t, k) = e + L(t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds t ∞ ∞ 3 −4ik 3 sσ3 2 M(t, s)e ds + k N (t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds (2.10) +ik t
t
can be obtained as in [9]. Here the matrix-valued real functions L(t, s), M(t, s) and N(t, s) are C ∞ and bounded in t, s, and they vanish for s > 2T − t if T < ∞ or tend to zero as t + s → ∞ if T = ∞. We introduce the matrix ˆ k), Y (x, t, k) = ϕ(x, t, k)(t,
k ∈ ,
(2.11)
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
61
where ϕ(x, t, k) is as in (2.7). Lemma 1 implies that Y (x, t, k) is a solution of the xand t-equations with det Y (x, t, k) = 1 for k ∈ . ˆ k), hence also Y (x, t, k), is unbounded in t ∈ R+ . Since For k ∈ / the function (t, the integral equation is of Volterra type with τ ∈ (t, ∞), the first column Y − (x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ 2 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 and the second column Y + (x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 5 or Y (x, t, k) is an entire matrix-valued function if T < ∞. The properties of the solution Y (x, t, k) follow from the triangular integral representations (2.7) and (2.10): Properties of the third basic solution. Y (x, t, k) satisfies the x- and t-equations. ¯ −1 for k ∈ . Y (x, t, k) = Y¯ (x, t, k) det Y (x, t, k) = 1 for k ∈ . (x, t, k) → Y (x, t, k) ∈ C ∞ (R+ × R+ × ). Y + (x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 5 , Y − (x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ 2 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 or they are entire if T < ∞. ¯ = Y − (x, t, k), k ∈ 2 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 . 6. Y¯ − (x, t, −k) + ¯ ¯ = Y + (x, t, k), k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 5 . 7. Y (x, t, −k) 8. For k → ∞, k ∈ 2 ,
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
eikx+4ik t Y − (x, t, k) = 3
1 + O(k −1 ). 0
3. Analysis of the Direct Scattering Problem The basic solutions we have introduced are clearly linearly dependent: (x, t, k) = (x, t, k)S(k), Y (x, t, k) = (x, t, k)P (k), Y (x, t, k) = (x, t, k)R(k).
(3.1)
The matrices S(k), P (k) and R(k) depend neither on x nor on t because by virtue of the x-equation they do not depend on x, and by virtue of the t-equation they do not depend on t. Hence: S(k) = −1 (0, 0, k), k ∈ R; P (k) = Y (0, 0, k), k ∈ ; R(k) = S(k)P (k), k ∈ R.
(3.2)
We omit the dependence on T of the matrices P (k) = P (k, T ) and R(k) = R(k, T ) if T < ∞. Let us study the properties of these “scattering” (transition) matrices.
62
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
Properties of the scattering matrix S(k). They follow from the scattering problem for the x-equation with t = 0. Indeed, consider the problem on the whole x-line by putting 0 for x ∈ (−∞, 0) q(x, 0) = u(x) ˆ = u(x) for x ∈ [0, ∞). ˜ Let (x, k) be the Jost solution [19] normalized by ˜ (x, k) = e−ikxσ3 for x < 0 and let T˜ (k) be the transition matrix for that case, i.e. ˜ (x, k) = (x, 0, k)T˜ (k). Putting x = 0 we find S(k) ≡ T˜ (k). Hence the “scattering” matrix S(k) has all properties of the transition matrix T˜ (k) [19]: −1 for k ∈ R. ¯ • S(k) = S(k) • det S(k) ≡ 1 for k ∈ R. • S(k) ∈ C ∞ (R). For the half-line case there are additional properties: + s2 (k) −s1+ (k) where sj+ (k) = j+ (0, 0, k). • S(k) = −s2− (k) s1− (k) ¯ • s2+ (k) −s1+ (k) is analytic in k ∈ C+ and sj+ (k) = sj+ (−k). − − − − ¯ • −s2 (k) s1 (k) is analytic2 in k ∈ C− and sj (k) = sj (−k). • If k ∈ C+ and k → ∞, s2+ (k) = 1 + O(k −1 ),
s1+ (k) = O(k −1 ).
(3.3)
Let us prove some integral representations for s1+ (k) and s2+ (k). We use the limit formulas s1+ (k) = lim e−ikx 1+ (x, 0, k), x→−∞
s2+ (k) = lim e−ikx 2+ (x, 0, k), x→−∞
which follow from the definition of the matrix S(k). If one puts χj (x, k) = e−ikx j+ (x, 0, k) the x-equation yields ˆ χ1 + 2ikχ1 = u(x)χ 2 χ1 (x, k) → 0 as x → +∞, χ2 = −u(x)χ ˆ 1 χ2 (x, k) → 1 as x → +∞. Then, by integration: χ1 (x, k) = −
∞
x
χ2 (x, k) = 1 +
e2ik(y−x )u(y)χ ˆ 2 (y, k)dy, ∞
x
u(y)χ ˆ 1 (y, k)dy,
2 For an arbitrary function u(x), ˆ x ∈ R these analytic properties do not hold, s2+ (k) and s1− (k) are ˆ ≡ 0 for x < 0 and therefore s1+ (k) only analytic in k ∈ C+ and k ∈ C− respectively. In our case u(x) − and s2 (k) are also analytic in k ∈ C+ and k ∈ C− respectively.
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
63
therefore ∞ ∞ u(x)e2ikx dx − u(x)e2ikx dx K1 (x, x + y)eiky dy, (3.4) 0 0 ∞ ∞ 0 + ikx e dx u(y)K2 (y, y + x)dy, (3.5) s2 (k) = 1 −
s1+ (k) = −
∞
0
0
where K1 (x, y) and K2 (x, y) are entries of the kernel of the triangular integral transformation (2.3). The last two formulas allow to find the large-k asymptotic expansions at any order of s1+ (k) and s2+ (k) and to obtain (3.3), in particular, which is exact (precise) if u(0) = 0. The matrix S(k) = −1 (0, 0, k) is determined by u(x) ∈ S(R+ ). The entries of this matrix are not independent and can be recovered from one known function. Let s(k) ≡
s1+ (k)
s2+ (k)
be given and let dic be the set of zeros of the analytic function s2+ (k). As in [19] we shall consider a subset S0 (R+ ) of functions u(x) ∈ S(R+ ) for which s2+ (k) has a finite number of zeros: dic = {k1 , . . . , kn ∈ C+ | s2+ (kj ) = 0}, all of multiplicity 1, i.e. s˙2+ (kj ) = 0, and s2+ (k) = 0 for every k ∈ R. Since det S(k) ≡ 1, then |s2+ (k)|2 − λ|s1+ (k)|2 ≡ 1 for any k ∈ R. This identity yields the well-known formula: 1−λ 2 ∞ k − kj log(1 − λ|s(µ)|2 )dµ i + s2 (k) = exp . 2π −∞ µ−k k − k¯j
(3.6)
kj ∈C+
The remaining entries of S(k) are also recovered: s1+ (k) = s(k)s2+ (k),
¯ s2− (k) = λ¯s1+ (k),
¯ s1− (k) = s¯2+ (k).
So, if λ = 1, the function s2+ (k) has no zeros at all and the set dic is empty. It follows from the self-adjointness of the x-equation (1.2) and the obvious inequality: |s2+ (k)| ≥ 1 for k ∈ R. If λ = −1 then s2+ (k) may vanish at some points kj ∈ C+ . Since u(x) is real-valued, dic is symmetric with respect to the imaginary axis. We can enumerate the kj ’s in such a way that • kj = iκj , κj > 0 for j = 1, . . . , n1 ≤ n with n = n1 + 2n2 , • kn1 +l = −k¯n1 +n2 +l for l = 1, . . . , n2 . Let us briefly discuss the discrete spectrum of the x-problem, which may appear when λ = −1. The main relation of the x-scattering problem is 1 − (x, t, k) = − (x, t, k) + r(k) + (x, t, k) for k ∈ R, s2+ (k)
(3.7)
64
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
where r(k) = −
s2− (k) s2+ (k)
.
(3.8)
F (x, t, k) = − (x, t, k)/s2+ (k) is analytic in k ∈ C+ except for dic = {k1 , . . . , kn }, where it has poles. We have s2+ (kj ) = det − (x, t, kj ) + (x, t, kj ) = 0, then − (x, t, kj ) = γj1 + (x, t, kj ). Hence, Resk=kj F (x, t, k) = cj1 + (x, t, kj ) with cj1 =
γj1
s˙2+ (kj )
and
γj1 =
1
, s1+ (kj )
j = 1, . . . , n.
Note that s1+ (kj ) = 0 because otherwise we come to a contradiction: + (x, t, kj ) ≡ 0 since 1+ (0, 0, kj ) = s1+ (kj ) = 0 and 2+ (0, 0, kj ) = s2+ (kj ) = 0. We also assume all zeros are simple, i.e. s˙2+ (kj ) = 0. Using asymptotics of the function − (x, t, k) at k = ∞, for k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 , we find 3 1 −1 F (x, t, k) = + O(|k| ) e−ikx−4ik t for |k| → ∞, k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 , 0
(3.9)
that will be used below. So, we come to the following (cf. Conditions A and B): Properties of r(k), t (k) and kj . • The reflection coefficient r(k) belongs to C ∞ (R), r(−k) = r¯ (k) and r(k) = O(k −1 ) as k → ∞. It is the ratio of two functions −s2− (k) and s2+ (k) analytic in k ∈ C− and k ∈ C+ respectively, and |r(k)| < 1 if λ = 1. • The transition coefficient t (k) = [s2+ (k)]−1 is represented through formula (3.6), where |s(µ)| = |r(µ)|. • If λ = −1, ki = kj for i = j and Im kj > 0, j = 1, . . . , n, with: kj = iκj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n1 ≤ n = n1 + 2n2 , and kn1 +l = −k¯n1 +n2 +l , 1 ≤ l ≤ n2 . These properties follow from the x-scattering problem on the whole line. We take into ¯ is analytic in k ∈ C− account that for the half-line case the function s2− (k) = −¯s1+ (k) 1 and the constants γj are not independent parameters (that takes place for the whole line), and they are evaluated by means of the function s1+ (k) at kj : γj1 = 1/s1+ (kj ).
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
65
Properties of the scattering matrix P (k). They follow from the defining relation, i.e. from (3.2), (2.11), (2.10): ∞ 3 L(t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds P (k) = I + ∞ 0∞ 3 3 M(t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds + k 2 N (t, s)e−4ik sσ3 ds. +k 0
0
It is easy to find the following properties: ¯ −1 for k ∈ . • P (k) = P¯ (k) • det P (k) ≡ 1 for k ∈ . • P (k) is C ∞ in k ∈ . • If T < ∞ the matrix-valued function P (k) is entire in k ∈ C. • If T = ∞ the vector-function P + (k) is analytic in k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 5 , and P − (k) is analytic in k ∈ 2 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 . ¯ • P ± (k) = P ± (−k). • P (k) = σ0 + O(k −1 ), k ∈ , k → ∞. Properties of the scattering matrix R(k). Below we need to study properties of the “scattering” matrix R(k) introduced by Eqs. (3.1)–(3.2). The matrix R(k) has the following form − r1 (k) r1+ (k) ¯ ¯ for k ∈ R(k) = − r2+ (k) = r¯1− (k) , r1+ (k) = −¯r2− (k), r2 (k) r2+ (k) with r1− (k) = p1− (k)s2+ (k) − p2− (k)s1+ (k)
(3.10)
analytic in k ∈ C+ (if T < ∞) and k ∈ 2 (if T = ∞). Hence r2+ (k) is analytic in k ∈ C− (if T < ∞) and k ∈ 5 (if T = ∞). Furthermore r2− (k) = p2− (k)s1− (k) − p1− (k)s2− (k)
(3.11)
is analytic in k ∈ C− (for T < ∞) and k ∈ 4 ∪ 6 (for T = ∞), hence r1+ (k) is analytic in k ∈ C+ (for T < ∞) and k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 (for T = ∞). In the domains of analyticity we have the following symmetry properties: ¯ and r ± (k) = r ± (−k). ¯ r1± (k) = r1± (−k) 2 2 From (3.1) we derive Y + (x, t, k) = r1+ (k) − (x, t, k) + r2+ (k) + (x, t, k) with r1+ (k) = det(Y + (x, t, k) + (x, t, k)), r2+ (k) = det( − (x, t, k) Y + (x, t, k)). Let us put x = 0, and k = k1 + ik2 ∈ 1 ∪ 3 . Using (2.3), (2.11), (2.10) for large t we obtain |r1+ (k)| ≤ C1 (k) exp 8t K − (3k12 − k22 )k2 ,
66
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
where C1 (k) is independent of t, and K = max (3e2 kj − Im2 kj ) Im kj , 1≤j ≤n
where kj ∈ 1 ∪ 3 is an eigenvalue of the x-scattering problem. Taking into account the analyticity of the function r1+ (k) for k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 , choosing a large enough k and putting t → ∞ (if T = ∞) we find r1+ (k) ≡ 0 for any k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 , hence r2− (k) ≡ 0 for any k ∈ 4 ∪ 6 . So, we come to the main property of the compatible scattering problem for x- and t-equations. • If T = ∞ the “scattering” matrix R(k) is diagonal: ρ (k) 0 R(k) = − for k ∈ R 0 ρ+ (k) with ρ+ (k) =
p2+ (k) s2+ (k)
=
p1+ (k) s1+ (k)
,
ρ− (k) =
p1− (k) s1− (k)
=
p2− (k) s2− (k)
.
(3.12)
• We also have the important relation (Condition A9): p1+ (k)
p2+ (k)
≡
s1+ (k)
(3.13)
s2+ (k)
that says: the function p(k) := p1+ (k)/p2+ (k) being meromorphic in the domain 1 ∪ 3 has an analytic continuation into C+ up to the meromorphic function s(k) = s1+ (k)/s2+ (k). • If T < ∞, instead of (3.13) we have the so-called “global relation” [21]: s2+ (k)p1+ (k, T ) − s1+ (k)p2+ (k, T ) = r1+ (k, T ), where r1+ (k, T ) = c1 (k, T )e8ik with
c1 (k, T ) = −
∞
3T
K(0, y, T )eiky dy
0
is analytic in k ∈ C+ . We write down the dependence on T to emphasize that functions p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ), and r1+ (k, T ) really depend on T . The asymptotic behavior of S(k) and P (k) yields the following asymptotic expansions: ω2 ρ1 ω1 r1− (k) = 1 + + . . . , r2− (k) = + 2 + . . . for k → ±∞. k k k If T = ∞ then r2− (k) ≡ r1+ (k) ≡ 0. Since det R(k) ≡ 1, then ρ− (k)ρ+ (k) = |ρ+ (k)|2 ≡ 1. Hence, ρ± (k) can be written in the form: ρ± (k) = e±iν(k)
k∈R
(3.14)
with a real function ν(k) for k ∈ R. The function ν(k) has an analytic continuation to 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 which satisfies:
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
67
¯ ν(k) = −ν(−k), ¯ and ν(k) → 0 as k → ∞, • ν(k) = ν¯ (k), in view of the asymptotics of the functions s2+ (k) and p2+ (k). Indeed, in view of (3.12), pj+ (k) = ρ+ (k) sj+ (k) for j = 1, 2,
(3.15)
ρ+ (k) must have poles at the points where s1+ (k) and s2+ (k) vanish. On the other hand, s1+ (k) and s2+ (k) must simultaneously vanish at poles in view of the analyticity of the functions pj+ (k) for k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 . Hence + (x, t, k) vanish identically if k is a pole, which is impossible. So ρ+ (k) is analytic (without singularities) in k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 . Hence the functions pj+ (k) and sj+ (k) have a common set of zeros, possibly empty, in 1 ∪ 3 . The other statements about ν(k) are obvious. So, for r1− (k) which is analytic in k ∈ 2 we obtain: r1− (k) =
s2+ (k)
p2+ (k)
= e−iν(k) for k ∈ ∂2 .
(3.16)
The last formula follows from relations: r1− (k) = p1− (k)s2+ (k) − p2− (k)s1+ (k),
p1+ (k)s2+ (k) − p2+ (k)s1+ (k) = 0.
Hence the function r1− (k) has an analytic continuation to the domain 1 ∪ 3 , where it coincides with the function 1/ρ+ (k). Therefore the function r1− (k) does not vanish for k ∈ ∂2 , and its zeros are some points zj ∈ 2 . Let dbc be the set of zeros of the function r1− (k). Here we also assume that boundary functions are such that the number of zeros is finite: dbc = {z1 , . . . , zm ∈ 2 | r1− (zj ) = 0}, and all zeros are simple, i.e. r˙1− (zj ) = 0. We have dbc = ∅ if λ = 1. Let ρ(k) :=
r2− (k)
r1− (k)
.
The functions ρ(k) and r1− (k) are dependent. They satisfy the determinant relation 1 − λ|ρ(k)|2 =
1 , |r1− (k)|2
k ∈ R,
(3.17)
and ρ(k) ≡ 0 if T = ∞. They have the following properties: • ρ(k), r1− (k) ∈ C ∞ (R), and ρ(−k) = ρ(k), ¯ r1− (k) = r¯1− (−k). − • If T = ∞, ρ(k) ≡ 0 for k ∈ R, and r1 (k) = e−iν(k) , where ν(k) is described above. • If T < ∞, then 1−λ i ∞ log(1 − λ|ρ(s)|2 )ds k − zj 2 − r1 (k) = exp , k ∈ C+ . k − z¯ j 2π −∞ s−k zj ∈C+
(3.18)
68
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
• The function ρ(k) − r(k) =
p2− (k)
(3.19)
r1− (k)s2+ (k)
has an analytic continuation to C+ for T < ∞. For T = ∞ the r.h.s. is analytic only in 2 . The last item follows from Eqs. (3.10) and (3.11) which yield p1− (k) = r2− (k)s1+ (k) + r1− (k)s1− (k) = r1− (k) ×[1/s2+ (k) + s1+ (k)(ρ(k) − r(k))],
(3.20)
p2− (k) = r2− (k)s2+ (k) + r1− (k)s2− (k) = r1− (k)s2+ (k) ×[ρ(k) − r(k)] for k ∈ R.
(3.21)
For T < ∞ the difference ρ(k) − r(k) has an analytic continuation to C+ because the l.h.s. are analytic in k ∈ C+ . Hence, the r.h.s. must have analytic continuations to C+ . The second main relation of the compatible scattering problem is: 1 Y − (x, t, k) r1− (k) − (x, t, k) + ρ(k) + (x, t, k) = − (x, t, k)
G(x, t, k) =
for k ∈ R if T < ∞ for k ∈ R if T = ∞.
(3.22)
The function G(x, t, k) is analytic in k ∈ 2 , for k = zj and the zj ’s are poles of G. If r1− (zj ) = 0 then Y − (x, t, zj ) and + (x, t, zj ) are linearly dependent: Y − (x, t, zj ) = γj2 + (x, t, zj ),
j = 1, . . . , m,
Resk=zj G(x, t, k) = cj2 + (x, t, zj ),
cj2 =
hence γj2
r˙1− (zj )
with γj2 =
p1− (zj ) s1+ (zj )
=
p2− (zj ) s2+ (zj )
.
Using asymptotics of the function Y − (x, t, k) in the neighborhood of k = ∞ for k ∈ 2 , we find 3 1 −1 G(x, t, k) = + O(|k| ) e−ikx−4ik t 0 for |k| → ∞, k ∈ 2 . (3.23) This asymptotic formula will be used in the next section.
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
69
4. The Main Integral Equations The main relations of the compatible scattering problem follow from (3.1), (3.2) and (3.7), (3.22): F (x, t, k) = − (x, t, k) + r(k) + (x, t, k) for k ∈ R, G(x, t, k) = − (x, t, k) + ρ(k) + (x, t, k) for k ∈ R.
(4.1) (4.2)
These relations give: G(x, t, k) − F (x, t, k) = c(k) + (x, t, k), where c(k) can be written as follows c(k) = ρ(k) − r(k) =
p2− (k)
s2+ (k) r1− (k)
for
k ∈ C+ k ∈ 2
(4.3)
if T < ∞, if T = ∞.
(4.4)
Properties of c(k). Indeed, c(k) is meromorphic in C+ if T < ∞, and in 2 if T = ∞, ¯ because p − (k), s + (k) and r − (k) are analytic in k ∈ C+ if T < ∞, and c(k) = c(−k), 2 2 1 and in k ∈ 2 if T = ∞. Hence relation (4.3) is true for all k ∈ 2 . Furthermore, since ρ(k) = c(k) + r(k) ≡ 0 (T = ∞) for k ∈ R, c(k) satisfies Condition C4. The function c(k) has poles at the points zj , where s2+ (zj ) = r1− (zj ) = 0. Since the zeros of s2+ (k) and r1− (k) are simple and finite in number, all poles of c(k) are simple and also finite in number. Indeed, we only have to check the case s2+ (z0 ) = r1− (z0 ) = 0. Due to (3.10) we also find p2− (z0 ) = 0. If λ = 1 the function c(k) is regular analytic in the corresponding domains. We have the following relation on ∂2 : Y − (x, t, k − 0) − (x, t, k + 0) − = c(k) + (x, t, k) r1− (k − 0) s2+ (k + 0)
(4.5)
for k ∈ ∂2 . To deduce the integral equations of the inverse scattering problem let us put 1 −ikx−4ik 3 t − e for k ∈ ∂2 , h (x, t, k) = G(x, t, k) − 0 1 −ikx−4ik 3 t h+ (x, t, k) = F (x, t, k) − e for k ∈ R. 0 Let us consider the integral ∞ 1 1 3 − iky+4ik 3 t J (x, y, t) = h (x, t, k)e dk + h+ (x, t, k)eiky+4ik t dk. 2π ∂2 2π −∞ Using Eqs. (4.1), (4.2), (4.4), (2.3) we find 1 3 J (x, y, t) − h− (x, t, k)eiky+4ik t dk 2π ∂2 ∞ K1 0 λK2 = (x, y, t) + Fs (x + y, t) + (x, z, t)Fs (z + y, t)dz, 1 K2 K1 x
70
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
where Fs (x, t) =
1 2π
∞
−∞
r(k)eik(x+y)+8ik t dk. 3
On the other hand, using estimates (3.9) and (3.23) of F (x, t, z) and G(x, t, z) for large k, taking into account (4.3) (4.4), (4.5) and applying the Jordan lemma, we find 1−λ 3 J (x, y, t) = Resk=kj h+ (x, t, k)eiky+4ik t i 2 +i
kj ∈1 ∪3 s2+ (kj )=0
3 Resk=zj h− (x, t, k)eiky+4ik t
zj ∈2 r1− (zj )=0
1 3 [G(x, t, k) − F (x, t, k)]eiky+4ik t dk 2π ∂2 3 1−λ = m1j eikj y+4ikj t + (x, t, kj ) − 2 kj ∈1 3 ikj y+4ikj3 t + − mj e (x, t, kj ) −
kj ∈3
1 − λ 2 izj y+4izj3 t + − mj e (x, t, zj ) 2 zj ∈2 1 3 − c(k)eiky+4ik t + (x, t, k)dk. 2π ∂2 Finally we have the following integral equations of the inverse scattering: ∞ K1 (x, y, t) + λ K2 (x, z, t)H (z + y, t)dz = 0 for 0 ≤ x < y < ∞, (4.6) x ∞ K1 (x, z, t)H (z + y, t)dz = 0 (4.7) K2 (x, y, t) + H (x + y, t) + x
with the kernel 1 − λ 1 ikj x+8ikj3 t 2 izj x+8izj3 t 3 ikj x+8ikj3 t mj e + mj e + mj e H (x, t) = 2 zj ∈2 kj ∈1 kj ∈3 ∞ 1 1 3 3 c(k)eikx+8ik t dk + r(k)eikx+8ik t dk. (4.8) + 2π ∂2 2π −∞ The coefficients m1j , m2j , and m3j are given by m1j = [is1+ (kj )˙s2+ (kj )]−1 , m3j m2j
= =
kj ∈ 1 ,
[is1+ (kj )˙s2+ (kj )]−1 , kj − + − −1 p1 (zj )[is1 (zj )˙r1 (zj )]
∈ 3 ,
= p2− (zj )[is2+ (zj )˙r1− (zj )]−1 = −i Resk=zj c(k), z j ∈ 2 .
(4.9)
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
71
Using (4.7) for y = x one can prove that H (x, t) ∈ C ∞ (R+ × R+ ) and is rapidly decreasing in x, i.e. H (x, t) = O(x −∞ ), as x → ∞, since K1 (x, y, t) and K2 (x, y, t) are in C ∞ (R+ × R+ × R+ ) and also rapidly decreasing as x + y → ∞, and (4.7) is a Volterra integral equation with respect to the kernel H (x, t). All terms in (4.8) are clearly C ∞ and of the Schwartz type except for the last term: ∞ 1 3 r(k)eikx+8ik t dk 2π −∞ because the reflection coefficient r(k) vanishes at infinity as O(k −1 ) that follows from (3.3), (3.4). Thus we arrive at the requirement that this integral must be C ∞ in x, t (Condition B2). It is easy to see that under the additional condition (1.8) the reflection coefficient r(k) ∈ S(R), therefore Condition B2 can be omitted because the correspond (0, t) are ing integral is C ∞ . By assumption the boundary functions q(0, t), qx (0, t), qxx ∞ ∞ C , then we obtain the following condition: the kernel H (x, t) must be C in t when x = 0. Therefore the function ∞ 3 3 c(k)e8ik t dk + r(k)e8ik t dk ∂2
−∞
C∞.
Thus we arrive at the property given in Condition C5. should be For any fixed t ∈ R+ the function H (x, t) will be rapidly decreasing for x → ∞. Indeed, using the method of steepest descent and integration by parts we see that H (x, t) = O(x −∞ ) because c(k) and r(k) are C ∞ and, according to their asymptotic behavior, they vanish at infinity as well as their derivatives of any order. If T = ∞ we also use Condition C4. Remark. For t = 0 the kernel H (x, t)|t=0 coincides with the kernel ∞ 1 H0 (x) = mj eikj x + r(k)eikx dk, 2π −∞ kj ∈C+
because in this case (t = 0) the integral over ∂2 can be evaluated by using the residues of the function c(k). After integration we find that H (x, 0) = H0 (x). Then Marchenko integral equations with kernel H0 (x) yield q(x, 0) = u(x). Now it is natural to introduce the set R = {s1+ (k), s2+ (k), k ∈ C+ ; p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ), k ∈ }
(4.10)
and to call it (see §1.3) the set of scattering data of the compatible eigenvalue problem for the pair of differential equations (1.2), (1.3) defined by q(x, t) satisfying (1.1). The kernel H (x, t) of the Marchenko equations is completely defined by the scattering data R. Conditions A–B–C from the Introduction follow immediately from the properties proved above for the scattering data R. The properties given by Conditions A–B–C are characteristic, i.e. they are sufficient to ensure that the functions s1+ (k), s2+ (k), k ∈ C+ , and p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ), k ∈ , are the scattering data of compatible x- and t-equations (1.2), (1.3) with q(x, t) satisfying the mKdV equation (1.1) with an initial function u(x) ∈ S(R+ ) and boundary values v(t), v1 (t), v2 (t) ∈ C ∞ [0, T ] if T < ∞, or v(t), v1 (t), v2 (t) ∈ S(R+ ) if T = ∞. Anyway formula (1.4) and Marchenko integral equations (4.6), (4.7) represent a solution of the mKdV equation if the kernel (4.8) is sufficiently smooth and rapidly decreasing as x → ∞. It follows from statements in Sect. 6.
72
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
5. Formulation of the Riemann-Hilbert Problem Here we give a formulation of the inverse scattering problem as a Riemann-Hilbert problem which will be used for proving that the solution q(x, t) arising from Marchenko equations satisfies the boundary conditions. We recall that the equality q(x, 0) = u(x) is already proved. The main scattering relations (3.1) yield the following Riemann-Hilbert problem. Indeed, from (3.1) we derive: − (x, t, k) = − (x, t, k) + r(k) + (x, t, k), s2+ (k)
k ∈ R,
Y − (x, t, k) = − (x, t, k) + ρ(k) + (x, t, k), r1− (k)
k ∈ R,
+ (x, t, k) = + (x, t, k) + λ¯r (k) − (x, t, k), s1− (k)
Y + (x, t, k) + ¯ = + (x, t, k) + λρ(k) (x, t, k), r2+ (k)
Y − (x, t, k) − (x, t, k) = c(k) + (x, t, k), − s2+ (k) r1− (k)
Y + (x, t, k) + (x, t, k) ¯ − (x, t, k), − = λc( ¯ k) s1− (k) r2+ (k)
(5.1)
k ∈ R, k ∈ R,
(5.2)
k ∈ ∂2 ,
(5.3)
k ∈ ∂5 .
(5.4)
Let us define the sectionally meromorphic (analytic for λ = 1) matrix M(k, x, t): − 1 (x, t, k)eiθ + −iθ 1 (x, t, k)e s2+ (k) k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 − iθ (x, t, k)e + 2 −iθ 2 (x, t, k)e + − s2 (k) iθ Y1 (x, t, k)e + −iθ 1 (x, t, k)e r1− (k) k ∈ 2 − Y2 (x, t, k)eiθ + −iθ (x, t, k)e 2 − (k) r 1 M(k, x, t) = Y1+ (x, t, k)e−iθ − iθ 1 (x, t, k)e r2+ (k) k ∈ 5 + −iθ Y (x, t, k)e − 2 iθ 2 (x, t, k)e + r2 (k) + (x, t, k)e−iθ − 1 iθ 1 (x, t, k)e s1− (k) k ∈ 4 ∪ 6 . + 2 (x, t, k)e−iθ − iθ (x, t, k)e 2 s1− (k) Here θ = θ (x, t, k) = k(x + 4k 2 t). Then we have the following Riemann-Hilbert problem M− (k, x, t) = M+ (k, x, t)J (k, x, t),
k∈
(5.5)
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
73
on the contour = {k | Im k 3 = 0}. The orientation on the contour is chosen in such a way that the sign “+” (resp. “−”) corresponds to the left (resp. right) boundary values of the matrix M(k, x, t) in the domains 1 , 3 , 5 marked by “+”, and in the domains 2 , 4 , 6 marked by “−”. The corresponding graph is depicted on Fig. 2. + J−
+ −
− + 2 J
J 3 1
] J J
J
J
J 4 6
J
5 J ] J − + + −
J
+ −
Fig. 2. The oriented contour
The jump matrix has the form: −2iθ 1 λ¯ r (k)e arg k = 0, π ; −r(k)e2iθ 1 − λ|r(k)|2 π 2π 1 0 J (k, x, t) = ; arg k = , 2iθ 1 c(k)e 3 3 ¯ −2iθ 4π 5π 1 λc( k)e , . arg k = 0 1 3 3
The proof of Eqs. (5.5) is a simple algebraic verification of relations (5.1)–(5.4). Remark. The above Riemann-Hilbert problem is written for the case when the set of the eigenvalues is empty. More details about the Riemann-Hilbert problem for the mKdV equation and complete consideration of the initial-boundary value problem can be found in [11]. Remark. We consider the problem for the form (1.1) of the mKdV equation in the first quarter (x ≥ 0, t ≥ 0) of the xt-plane. This problem is different from that studied in [11], which is the initial boundary value problem for the same equation, but in the second quarter (x ≤ 0, t ≥ 0) of the xt-plane. Scattering (spectral) data for that problem have different analytic properties. It is well-known that for the KdV and mKdV equations there are differences between the initial boundary value problems for x > 0 and for x < 0.
74
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
Indeed, the kernel of the Marchenko integral equations, which have to be considered now in the domain −∞ < y < x ≤ 0, takes the form: H (x, t) =
3 3 1 − λ 5 ikj x+8ikj3 t m ˆ je + m4j eizj x+8izj t + m6j eizj x+8izj t 2 zj ∈4 zj ∈6 kj ∈5 ∞ 1 1 3 3 c(k)eikx+8ik t dk + (r(k) + c(k))eikx+8ik t dk, + 2π ∂5 2π −∞
where c(k) is now meromorphic (analytic for λ = 1) in 4 ∪ 6 .
To prove that q(x, t) satisfies the boundary condition we have also to formulate the Riemann-Hilbert problem for the t-equation. To do so let us define the sectionally meromorphic (analytic for λ = 1) matrix N (k, t): ˆ + (t, k)e−4ik 3 t − 3t 1 4ik ϕˆ1 (t, k)e p2+ (k) k ∈ 1 ∪ 3 ∪ 5 ˆ + (t, k)e−4ik 3 t − 3t 2 4ik ϕˆ2 (t, k)e p2+ (k) N(k, t) = ˆ − (t, k)e4ik 3 t 3t + 1 −4ik ϕˆ1 (t, k)e p1− (k) k ∈ 2 ∪ 4 ∪ 6 , − 4ik 3 t ˆ (t, k)e 3 + 2 −4ik t ϕˆ2 (t, k)e p1− (k) − ˆ k) = ˆ (t, k) ˆ + (t, k) are matrix where ϕ(t, ˆ k) = ϕˆ − (t, k) ϕˆ + (t, k) and (t, solutions (2.9) and (2.10) of the t-equation. Then it is easy to verify that N (k, t) is a solution of the following Riemann-Hilbert problem: N− (k, t) = N+ (k, t)J t (k, t),
k∈
(5.6)
on the contour (Fig. 2) oriented as above. The jump matrix J t (k, t) has the form: 3 1 p− (k)e4ik t J (k, t) = , 3 −p+ (k)e−4ik t 1 − p− (k)p+ (k)
t
where p− (k) = p2− (k)/p1− (k), p+ (k) = p1+ (k)/p2+ (k), and pj± (k) are the entries of the “scattering” matrix P (k). We have already proved that q(x, 0) = u(x). The proof that q(x, t) satisfies the (0, t) = v (t) is carried out by boundary values q(0, t) = v(t), qx (0, t) = v1 (t) and qxx 2 using Riemann-Hilbert problems (5.5) and (5.6) in the same manner as in [28]. The main tool in the proof is the existence of an analytic map from the Riemann-Hilbert problem (5.5) attached to M(k, 0, t) into the Riemann-Hilbert problem (5.6) attached to N (k, t) and using the “global relation” (Condition A9). Such a proof for the mKdV equation is precisely given in [11].
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
75
6. Inverse Scattering Problem Let R be scattering data (4.10) satisfying Conditions A–B–C. Then: Statements. 1. The xt-integral equation K(x, y, t) + H(x + y, t) + 0 ≤ x < y < ∞,
∞ x
K(x, z, t)H(z + y, t)dz = 0,
0≤t <∞
with the 2 × 2 matrix kernel
(6.1)
0 H (x, t) H(x, t) = , λH (x, t) 0
where real scalar function H (x, t) given by (4.8), is uniquely solvable in L1 (x, ∞) for any x ≥ 0 and t ≥ 0. 2. The solution K(x, y, t) belongs to C ∞ (R+ × R+ × R+ ), it and all its derivatives decrease faster than any negative power of x + y, for x + y → ∞, and t fixed. 3. The matrix ∞ 3 −ikxσ3 −ikyσ3 + K(x, y, t)e dy e−4ik tσ3 (x, t, k) = e x
satisfies the symmetry conditions ¯ (x, t, k) = (x, t, k)−1 ¯ ± (x, t, k) = ± (x, t, −k)
for k ∈ R, for k ∈ C± ,
and is a solution of the x-equation (1.2) with Q(x, t) given by Q(x, t) = σ3 K(x, x, t)σ3 − K(x, x, t).
(6.2)
4. (x, t, k) is a solution of the x-and t-equations constructed from the matrix Q(x, t) and its derivatives Qx (x, t), Qxx (x, t), using Eqs. (6.2), (1.2), (1.3) and (2.3). 5. The scattering data R of these compatible differential equations coincide with the chosen functions s1+ (k), s2+ (k), p1+ (k, T ), p2+ (k, T ). Statement 1 follows from Lemma 2 about the solvability of the xt-integral equations: Lemma 2. Let R be scattering data satisfying Conditions A–B–C. Then the xt-integral equations (4.6)–(4.8) have a unique solution in L1 (x, ∞). Proof. Under Conditions A–B–C the integral operator of the xt-integral equation is compact in L1 (x, ∞). Then, by Fredholm theory the xt-integral equation has a unique solution if the homogeneous equation has no non-zero solution. If a non-zero solution does exist in L1 (x, ∞), in view of the homogeneity of the integral equation, it is bounded, hence belongs to L2 (x, ∞). The integral operator is clearly skew-Hermitian in L2 (x, ∞), so we obtain a contradiction, because the only solution in this case is zero. For λ = 1 the proof is more complicated. For example, it follows from the solvability of the corresponding Riemann-Hilbert problem (5.5). In turn, the unique solvability of the Riemann-Hilbert problem is proved by the same way as in [50].
76
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
Statement 2 follows from Lemma 3: Lemma 3. Let Conditions A–B–C be fulfilled and (K1 (x, y, t), K2 (x, y, t)) be the solution of the xt-integral equations (4.6)–(4.8). Then (K1 (x, y, t), K2 (x, y, t)) ∈ C ∞ (R+ ×R+ ×R+ ). These functions and all their derivatives decrease faster than any negative power of x + y, for x + y → ∞, t fixed. Moreover, q(x, t) = 2K2 (x, x, t) C∞
(a) is in x and t, (b) decreases faster than any negative power of x for x → ∞, t fixed, (c) is a solution of the mKdV equation with initial function q(x, 0) = u(x) and bound (0, t) = v (t). ary values q(0, t) = v(t), qx (0, t) = v1 (t), qxx 2 Proof (of Statement 2). According to Lemma 2 the xt-integral equations have a solution K1 (x, y, t) K2 (x, y, t) K(x, y, t) = λK2 (x, y, t) K1 (x, y, t) which belongs to L1 (x, ∞). By Condition A, the kernel H (x + y, t) is in C ∞ (R+ × R+ ) and is fast decreasing as x + y → ∞ (end of Sect. 4). Therefore (K1 (x, y, t), K2 (x, y, t)) is in C ∞ (R+ × R+ × R+ ) and vanishes faster than any negative power of x + y as x + y → ∞, t fixed. The same is true for all their derivatives and for q(x, t). It is clear that H (x, t) satisfies: ∂3 ∂ H (x, t) + 8 3 H (x, t) = 0. ∂t ∂x Then it is well-known that q(x, t) solves the mKdV equation, cf. [1, 49]. The fact that q(x, t) satisfies the boundary conditions was discussed at the end of Sect. 5. Proof (of Statements 3 and 4). The proof of Statement 3 is well-known [1, 19]. In particular, formula (6.2) follows from Eq. (2.4). Statement 4 is also true. Indeed, due to Lemma 3, the function q(x, t) is a solution of the mKdV equation (1.1). Hence the constructed x- and t-equations are compatible. Therefore, according to Lemma 1, the matrix-valued function (x, t, k) solves the t-equation. Proof (of Statement 5). Let us consider compatible solutions (x, t, k) (2.3), (x, t, k) ˜ be the corre(2.6), and Y (x, t, k) (2.11) of the constructed x- and t-equations. Let R ˜ sponding scattering data. We have to show that R ≡ R. First of all one can find that the matrix K(x, y, 0) solves the xt-integral equation ˜ (6.1) (t = 0) with kernel H(x, 0) generated by ∞ 1 ik˜j x ˜ H (x) = m ˜ je + r˜ (k)eikx dk. 2π −∞ k˜j ∈C+ s˜2+ (k˜j )=0
On the other hand the matrix K(x, y, 0) solves the same integral equation (t = 0) with kernel H(x, 0) generated by ∞ 1 ikj x H (x) = mj e + r(k)eikx dk, 2π −∞ kj ∈C+ s2+ (kj )=0
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
since 1 2π
∂2
c(k)eikx dk =
kj ∈2 s2+ (kj )=0
m2j eikj x −
77
zj ∈2 r1− (zj )=0
m2j eizj x .
Hence F (x) = H˜ (x)−H (x) is a solution of the homogeneous Volterra integral equation ∞ F (2x) + K1 (x, y − x, 0)F (y)dy = 0, 2x
˜ j = mj (hence m ˜ 1j = m1j , which yields the identity F (x) ≡ 0. Therefore k˜j = kj , m m ˜ 3j = m3j ) and r˜ (k) ≡ r(k) for k ∈ R. Scattering data {s1+ (k), s2+ (k)} for the x-equation can be easily recovered [19] from r(k) and k1 , . . . , kn by using formula (3.6). For t > 0 by using (4.8) we shall now obtain the relation F (x, t) = H˜ (x, t)−H (x, t) ≡ 0, that yields c(k) ˜ ≡ c(k) and z˜ j = zj , m ˜ 2j = m2j . The uniqueness of c(k) follows from estimates for the functions pj+ (k) (Conditions A7 and A8). Then we recover ρ(k) = r(k) + c(k) and r1− (k) by using (3.19) and (3.18). Furthermore p1+ (k) and p2+ (k) are recovered by ¯ using (3.20), (3.21), an analytic continuation and symmetry conditions p1+ (k) = λp¯ 2− (k) + − ¯ ˜ (λ = ±1), p2 (k) = p¯ 1 (k). Hence R ≡ R. All Statements 1–5 on the inverse scattering problem are proved. As a consequence the main theorem (see §1.6) is also proved. References 1. Ablowitz, M.J., Segur, H.: Solitons and the Inverse Scattering Transform. Philadelphia: SIAM, 1981 2. Ablowitz, M.J., Segur, H.: The Inverse Scattering Transform: semi-infinite interval. J. Math. Phys. 16, 1054–1056 (1975) 3. Belokolos, E.D.: General Formulas for Solutions of Initial and Boundary-Value Problem for the sine-Gordon Equation. Teor. Mat. Fiz. 103, 358–367 (1995); Engl. Transl.: Theor. Math. Phys. 103, 613–620 (1995) 4. Berezanskii, Yu.M.: Integration of nonlinear difference equations by the method of the inverse spectral problem. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 281, 16–19 (1985); Engl. Transl.: Sov. Math. Dokl. 31, 264–267 (1985) 5. Berezanskii, Yu.M., Shmoish, M.: Nonisospectral flows of the semi-infinite Jacobi matrices. J. Nonlinear Math. Phys. 1, 116–146 (1994) 6. Bikbaev, R.F., Its, A.R.: Algebraic-Geometric solutions of a Boundary Value Problem for the Nonlinear Schr¨odinger Equation. Mat. Zametki 45, 3–9 (1989); Engl. Transl.: Math. Notes 45, 349–354 (1989) 7. Bikbaev, R.F., Tarasov, V.O.: Initial Boundary Value Problem for the Nonlinear Schr¨odinger Equation. J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24, 2507–2516 (1991) 8. Bikbaev, R.F., Tarasov, V.O.: An inhomogeneous boundary value problem on the semi-axis and on a segment for the sine-Gordon equation. Algebra i Analiz 3, 78–92 (1991); Engl. Transl.: St. Petersburg Math. J. 3, 775–789 (1992) 9. Boutet de Monvel, A., Kotlyarov, V.P.: Scattering problem for the Zakharov-Shabat equations on the semi-axis. Inverse Problems 16, 1813–1837 (2000) 10. Boutet de Monvel, A., Kotlyarov, V.P.: Generation of asymptotic solitons of the nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation by boundary data. J. Math. Phys. 44, 3185–3215 (2003) 11. Boutet de Monvel, A., Fokas, A.S., Shepelsky, D.: The mKdV equation on the half-line. J. Inst. Math. Jussieu 3, 139–164 (2004) 12. Calogero, F., De Lillo, S.: The Burgers Equation on the semi-infinite and finite intervals. Nonlinearity 2, 37–43 (1989) 13. Caroll, R., Bu, Q.: Solution of the forced nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation using PDE techniques. Appl. Anal. 41, 33–51 (1991)
78
A. Boutet de Monvel, V. Kotlyarov
14. Degasperis, A., Manakov, S.V., Santini, P.M.: On the Initial-Boundary Value Problems for Soliton Equations. JETP Lett. 74, 481–485 (2001) 15. Degasperis,A., Manakov, S.V., Santini, P.M.: Initial-BoundaryValue Problems for Linear and Soliton PDEs. Theoret. and Math. Phys. 133, 1475–1489 (2002) 16. Deift, P., Zhou, X.: A steepest descent method for oscillatory Riemann-Hilbert problems. Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 26, 119–123 (1992) 17. Deift, P., Zhou, X.: A steepest descent method for oscillatory Riemann-Hilbert problems. Asymptotics for the mKdV equation. Ann. Math. 137, 295–368 (1993) 18. Dubrovin, B.A.: Theta functions and nonlinear equations. Usp. Mat. Nauk 36, 11–80 (1981); Engl. Transl.: Russ. Math. Surv. 36, 11–92 (1982) 19. Faddeev, L.D., Takhtajan, L.A.:Hamiltonian Methods in the Theory of Solitons. Moscow: Nauka, 1986; Engl. Transl.: Berlin: Springer, 1987 20. Fokas, A.S.: An Initial Boundary Value Problem for the Nonlinear Schr¨odinger Equation. Phys. D 35, 167–185 (1989) 21. Fokas, A.S.: On the integrability of linear and nonlinear partial differential equations. J. Math. Phys. 41, 4188–4237 (2000) 22. Fokas, A.S., Its, A.R.: An initial-boundary value problem for the sine-Gordon equation in laboratory coordinates. Teoret. Mat. Fiz. 92, 387–403 (1992); Engl. Transl.: Theoret. and Math. Phys. 92, 964–978 (1992) 23. Fokas, A.S., Its, A.R.: An initial-boundary value problem for the Korteweg-de Vries equation. In: “Solitons, nonlinear wave equations and computation (New Brunswick, NJ, 1992)”. Math. Comput. Simulation 37, 293–321 (1994) 24. Fokas, A.S., Its, A.R.: The Linearization of the Initial Boundary Value Problem of the Nonlinear Schr¨odinger Equation. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 27, 738–764 (1996) 25. Fokas, A.S., Gelfand, I.M.: Integrability of Linear and Nonlinear Evolution Equations and the Associated Nonlinear Fourier Transform. Lett. Math. Phys. 32, 189–210 (1992) 26. Fokas, A.S.: A unified transform method for solving linear and certain nonlinear PDEs. Proc. Roy. Soc. London Ser. A 453, 1411–1443 (1997) 27. Fokas, A.S.: Two dimensional linear PDEs in a convex polygon. Proc. Roy. Soc. London Ser. A 457, 371–393 (2001) 28. Fokas, A.S., Its, A.R., Sung, L.Y.: The nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation on the half-line. Preprint, Cambridge University, 2001 29. Fokas, A.S.: Integrable Nonlinear Evolution Equations on the Half-Line. Commun. Math. Phys. 230, 1–39 (2002) 30. Gattobigio, M., Liguori, A., Mintchev, M.: The Nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation on the half-line. J. Math. Phys. 40, 2949–2970 (1999) 31. Habibullin, I.T.: B¨acklund Transformation and Integrable Boundary-Initial Value Problems. In: Nonlinear world 1, Kiev NTPP-89. River Edge, NJ: World Scientific, 1990, pp. 130–138 32. Habibullin, I.T.: The KdV equation on a half-line with a zero boundary condition. Teoret. Mat. Fiz. 119, 397–404 (1999); Engl. Transl.: Theoret. and Math. Phys. 119, 712–718 (1999) 33. Habibullin, I.T.: An initial-boundary value problem on the half-line for the mKdV equation. Funct. Anal. Appl. 34, 52–59 (2000) 34. Kotlyarov, V.P.: Asymptotic analysis of the Marchenko integral equation and soliton asymptotics of a solution of the nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation. Phys. D 87, 176–185 (1995) 35. Marchenko, V.A.: Sturm-Liouville operators and their applications. Kiev: Naukova Dumka, 1977 36. Sabatier, P.C.: New direct linearizations for KdV and solutions of the other Cauchy problem. J. Math. Phys. 40, 2983–3020 (1999) 37. Sabatier, P.C.: Elbow scattering and inverse scattering applications to LKdV and KdV. J. Math. Phys. 41, 414–436 (2000) 38. Sabatier, P.C.: Past and future of inverse problems. J. Math. Phys. 41, 4082–4124 (2000) 39. Sabatier, P.C.: Elbow scattering and boundary value problems of NLPDE. J. Nonlinear Math. Phys. 8, suppl., 249–253 (2001) 40. Sabatier, P.C.: Should we study sophisticated inverse problems? Inverse Probl. 17, 1219–1223 (2001) 41. Sakhnovich, L.A.: Explicit Formulas for Spectral Characteristics and Solution of the sinh-Gordon Equation. Ukr. Mat. Zh. 42, 1517–1523 (1990); Engl. Transl.: Ukr. Mat. J. 42, 1359–1365 (1990) 42. Sakhnovich, L.A.: Integrable Nonlinear equations on the semi-axis, Ukr. Mat. Zh. 43, 1578–1584 (1991); Engl. Transl.: Ukr. Math. J. 43, 1470–1476 (1991) 43. Sakhnovich, L.A.: The Goursat Problem for the sine-Gordon Equation and an Inverse Spectral Problem. Izv. Vyssh. Uchebn. Zaved. Mat. 36, 44–54 (1992); Engl. Transl.: Russian Math. (Iz. VUZ) 36, 42–52 (1992) 44. Sakhnovich, L.A.: Sine-Gordon Equation in Laboratory coordinates and Inverse Problem on the Semi-Axis. In: Boutet de Monvel, A., Marchenko, V.A. (eds.), Algebraic and Geometrical Methods in Mathematical Physics. Proceedings, Kaciveli 1993. Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1996, pp. 443–447
Scattering Data for the mKdV Equation on the Half-Line
79
45. Sklyanin, E.K.: Boundary Conditions for Integrable Equations. Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 21, 86–87 (1987); Engl. Transl.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 21, 164–166 (1987) 46. Sung, L.Y.: Solution of the Initial Boundary Problem of the nonlinear Schr¨odinger equation using PDE techniques. Preprint, Clarkson University, 1993 47. Tarasov, V.O.: The Boundary Value Problem for the Nonlinear Schr¨odinger Equation. Zap. Nauch. Semin. LOMI 169, 151–165 (1988) 48. Zakharov,V.E., Shabat,A. B.:An exact theory of two-dimensional self-focusing and one-dimensional automodulation of waves in a nonlinear medium. Soviet Phys. JETP 34, 62–78 (1972) 49. Zakharov, V.E., Shabat, A. B.: A scheme for integrating the nonlinear equations of mathematical physics by the method of the inverse scattering problem. I. Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 6, 43–53 (1974); Engl. Transl.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 8, 226–235 (1974) 50. Zhou, X.: The Riemann-Hilbert problem and inverse scattering. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 20, 966–986 (1989) Communicated by M. Aizenman
Commun. Math. Phys. 253, 81–119 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-004-1173-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-Geostrophic Model Didier Bresch1 , David G´erard-Varet2 1 2
LMC-IMAG, U.M.R. 5523, Universit´e Joseph Fourier, 38041 Grenoble, France UMPA, U.M.R. 5669, E.N.S. Lyon, 46 All´ee d’Italie, 69364 Lyon, France
Received: 21 August 2003 / Accepted: 31 March 2004 Published online: 5 November 2004 – © Springer-Verlag 2004
Abstract: We study in this paper the effect of small-scale irregularities on the quasi-geostrophic model. This study is motivated by some problems related to oceanography, as the Gulf Stream separation, or the impact of the topography on the global circulation. We first consider the role of coastal roughness in the phenomenon of western intensification of boundary currents. We show that the roughness is responsible for a nonlinear dynamics of the boundary layers, governed by a quasilinear elliptic equation. We thus extend substantially the classical derivation of Munk layers [15] and the results of convergence obtained in [10]. We then discuss the effect of a rough topography, by generalizing and justifying some formal computations of [17]. In particular, we derive rigorously a simplified model of oceanic circulation, with a nonlinear and nonlocal dissipative term due to the roughness.
1. Introduction This paper is devoted to the study of the so-called “quasi-geostrophic” system. We shall derive rigorously some new asymptotic models, accounting for roughness-induced effects. Before we present our results in more detail, let us introduce the problem in a precise way. The quasi-geostrophic system is a classical model of oceanic circulation. It reads ∂t + u1 ∂x + u2 ∂y ( + βy − F + ηB ) + r = β curl τ + Re−1 2 , u = (u1 , u2 )t = ∇ ⊥ , ∂ |∂ = 0, |∂ = ∂n |t=0 = 0. (1)
82
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
In these equations : • = (t, x) ∈ R is a stream function, associated to the velocity field u = (u1 (t, x), u2 (t, x))t . The time variable t lies in R+ , and the space variable x = (x, y) lies in a two-dimensional domain to be made precise later on. • d/dt = ∂t + u1 ∂x + u2 ∂y is the transport operator by the two-dimensional flow. • is the vorticity, and r, r > 0, is the Ekman pumping term. • F is due to the free surface with F the Froude number. • βy is the second term in the development of the Coriolis force. • ηB is a bottom topography term. • β curl τ is the vorticity created by the wind, where τ is a given stress tensor. • Re−1 2 is the usual viscosity term. Formally, system (1) is derived starting from three dimensional Navier-Stokes equations with a Coriolis force and a free surface : see [15] or [8] for a brief recall of this derivation. Mathematically, the justification of this derivation is open. But if the free surface is replaced by a rigid lid approximation, (1) with F = 0 can be rigorously derived, as shown by B. Desjardins and E. Grenier in [10]. Note that the derivation of the Quasi-geostrophic equations with F = 0 may be mathematically proved starting from a viscous Shallow water equations, see for instance [5]. Despite its simplicity, this model catches some of the main features of oceanic circulation. We refer the reader to [3, 15] for an extensive physical discussion. From a mathematical viewpoint, qualitative properties of (1) have also been widely studied [7, 10, 1, 4, 6]. Among the related papers, let us mention the important work of B. Desjardins and E. Grenier [10]. These authors have performed a complete boundary layer analysis, under various asymptotics, in domains = {χw (y) ≤ x ≤ χe (y),
ymin ≤ y ≤ ymax } .
They have notably derived the so-called Munk layers, responsible for the western intensification of boundary currents. In their stationary version, Eqs. (1) have been studied in [1, 4, 6], looking at for instance the influence of an island or the influence of the choice of boundary conditions. Remark that there exist other quasi-geostrophic models, see [9], depending on the small scale parametrizations. The aim of the present paper is to study roughness-induced effects on the quasi-geostrophic model. This work has strong physical motivation: the ocean bottom and coastal topography vary over a wide range of scales, the smallest of which can not be resolved in numerical computations. Such small-scale variations can not be seen in former theoretical studies, as topography terms depend regularly on x. There is therefore a need for the development of simplified models that account for the impact of the roughness on the large-scale ocean circulation. In a first part, we investigate the influence of rough shores. We consider the asymptotic behaviour of solutions of (1), as β goes to infinity, in a domain with rough boundaries. We extend the convergence result obtained in [10] about Munk layers. In the rough case, we show that the dynamics of the boundary layers is strongly modified. The usual Munk system of ordinary differential equations is replaced by a quasilinear elliptic equation, leading to serious additional difficulties. To overcome these difficulties, we use some methods introduced by one of the authors in [12], for rotating fluids in rough domains. In our view, it is an important step to progress in the understanding of the so-called “Gulf stream separation”. This expression refers to the abrupt separation of the Gulf Stream from the North American coastline, at Cape Hatteras. This phenomenon, which
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
83
has been observed for many years, seems to have very little variability: the current leaves the continent on a straight path without any visible deflection at the separation point. However, it is still poorly understood from a physical point of view: see [2] for more physical insight (in particular for a numerical study of the influence of boundary conditions on the separation point). Therefore, it is important to try to obtain new models which reflect the Gulf stream separation, taking into account for instance the effect of rough boundaries. In a second part, we investigate the effect of a rough bottom topography. We consider ζ rapidly oscillating functions ηB = ηB (x, y, x/ζ, y/ζ ), periodic in both variables, with ζ a small positive parameter. Such a study has been carried at a formal level and in the linear regime in articles [17] and [18]. We consider in this paper the “weakly nonlinear” case, which seems to be the most relevant (see [17] for a discussion on the choice of the scalings). That means: ζ → 0,
= ζ ψ,
u = ζ v,
Re−1 = νζ 2 ,
β, r, ν > 0 given.
Thus, system (1) becomes βy 1 ζ 2 2 (∂t + ζ v · ∇) ψ + ζ + ζ ηB + rψ = β curl τ + νζ ψ
v = (v1 , v2 )t = ∇ ⊥ ψ, ψ|t=0 = 0.
(2)
We show convergence results on the solutions ψ ζ of (2) as ζ → 0. As will be seen in the sequel, the limit system has a dissipative term, due to the small-scale roughness. This term is both nonlinear and nonlocal. In the linear case, it degenerates into a convolution product, turning the limit system into an integro differential system. All these results are in agreement with formal computations of [17]. The plan of the paper is as follows. In Sect. 2, we describe precisely the different domains we will consider and state the main results of the paper. In Sect. 3, we analyze ζ the case of rough shores. In Sect. 4, we look at the case of the periodic topography ηB . 2. Statement of the Results 2.1. Rough shores. In order to lighten notations, we assume throughout the study of rough coasts (Sect. 3) that r = 1, Re = 1. Up to minor changes, similar results would hold for arbitrary constants r and Re. Moreover, we use the parameter ε = β −1/3 preferentially to β. The reason is that ε is the natural size of the boundary layers arising in this study. Assuming F = 0, System (1) reads then ∂t + u1 ∂x + u2 ∂y ( + ε −3 y + ηB ) + = ε −3 curl τ + 2 , u = (u1 , u2 )t = ∇ ⊥ , (3) ∂ |∂ = 0, |∂ = ∂n |t=0 = 0.
84
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
2.1.1. The rough domain ε . Let us describe the domain ε where Eqs. (3) hold (see also Fig. 1). We write ε = εw ∪ w ∪ ∪ e ∪ εe . • is the “interior domain”, which, following notations of [10], is defined by
= χw (y) ≤ x ≤ χe (y), y ∈ [ymin , ymax ] , where χ w and χe are smooth functions defined for y ∈ [ymin , ymax ].
• w = (χw (y), y), y ∈ (ymin , ymax ) and e = (χe (y), y), y ∈ (ymin , ymax ) are “interfaces”. • εw and εe are the “rough shores”. More precisely, let γw = γw (Y ) and γe = γe (Y ) be smooth, positive and 1-periodic functions. We set
(4) εw = (x, y), 0 > x − χw (y) > −εγw (ε −1 y) ,
εe = (x, y), 0 < x − χe (y) < εγe (ε −1 y) . (5) We also define lateral boundaries
ε = χw (y) − εγw (ε −1 y), y , y ∈ (ymin , ymax ) , w
eε = χe (y) + εγe (ε −1 y), y , y ∈ (ymin , ymax ) . Remark. Up to a few more technicalities, one could consider more general (hence more realistic) domains: results below extend to functions γw = γw (y, Y ) (resp. γe = γe (y, Y )), with γw (y, ·) Tw (y)-periodic (resp. γe (y, ·) Te (y)-periodic).
ε
Ωw
ε
Γw
ε
Ωe
Ω
Σw
Σe
Fig. 1. The rough domain ε
ε
Γe
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
85
2.1.2. The boundary layer domains. The study of the boundary layers requires addi+ − tional boundary layer domains (Fig. 2). Namely, we define ωw = ωw ∪ σw ∪ ωw , where
+ ωw = X > 0, Y ∈ (0, 1) , σw = X = 0, Y ∈ (0, 1) ,
− ωw = (X, Y ), Y ∈ (0, 1), −γw (Y ) < X < 0 . We define similarly ωe = ωe− ∪ σe ∪ ωe+ . We call nw (resp. ne ) the outward unit normal vector at the boundary {X = −γw (Y )} (resp. {X = γe (Y )}). For all R > 0, we denote ωR = ωw ∩ {X > R}.
Finally, we set w = ∪k∈Z (X, Y + k),
X > −γw (Y ),
Y ∈ [0, 1]
2.1.3. Other notations. Let us introduce some more notations that will be useful in the study of the western boundary layer. Operators. For all y ∈ [ymin , ymax ], we set ∇w (y) = (∂X , ∂Y − χw (y)∂X )t ,
∇w⊥ (y) = (χw (y)∂X − ∂Y , ∂X )t ,
and define the operators w (y) and Qw (y) by: 2 w (y) = ∇w (y)2 = ∂X2 + χw (y)∂X − ∂Y ,
⊥ ⊥ ⊥ Qw (y)(, ) = ∇w (y) · ∇w (y) · ∇w (y) · ∇w (y) . Similarly, ∇e (y) = (∂X , −χe (y)∂X − ∂Y )t ,
∇e⊥ (y) = (χe (y)∂X + ∂Y , ∂X )t ,
y
ωw-
ωw+ σw
x Fig. 2. The boundary layer domain ωw
86
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
and 2 e (y) = ∇e (y)2 = ∂X2 + χe (y)∂X + ∂Y ,
˜ = ∇e⊥ (y) · ∇e⊥ (y)ψ · ∇e (y) · ∇e⊥ (y) . Qe (y)(ψ, ψ) Functional spaces. We name
V = ϕ ∈ C ∞ (w ) , ϕ 1-periodic in Y , (6)
V0 = ϕ ∈ V, (supp ϕ) ∩ ∂w = ∅, supp ϕ bounded in the X direction . (7) Finally, we define H2 (ωw ) = the closure of V in H 2 (ωw ), H02 (ωw ) = the closure of V0 in H 2 (ωw ),
(8) (9)
D02 (ωw ) = the completion of V0 for the norm ψ = D 2 ψ (L2 (ωw ))4 , (10) where D 2 ψ is the Hessian matrix of ψ. 2.1.4. Results. We want to consider System (3) in the limit of small ε, in the domain ε defined above. Let T > 0; for the sake of simplicity we assume that curl τ ∈ C ∞ [0, T ] × ε , curl τ |t=0 = 0. Since we consider a problem with zero initial data and a source term, we are actually studying well-prepared data, as in [10]. Moreover, in order to avoid problems near northern and southern boundaries, we assume as in [10] that: (11) ∃ λ > 0, curl τ = 0 for y ∈ ymax − λ, ymax ∪ ymin , ymin + λ . As pointed out in [10], System (3) is the vorticity formulation of a two-dimensional Navier-Stokes type equation : for all ε > 0, (3) has a unique smooth solution ε . As usual in boundary layer problems, the study of ε will require an additional system. For t ∈ [0, T ], x in ε , let x int (t, x) := curl τ (t, x , y) dx , (12) χe (y)
and for t ∈ [0, T ], y ∈ [ymin , ymax ],
χw (y)
φ(t, y) :=
curl τ (t, x , y) dx .
(13)
χe (y)
For all t ∈ [0, T ] and y ∈ [ymin , ymax ], we consider the following boundary layer systems, of unknown t,y = t,y (X), for X ∈ ωw : (14) Qw (y) t,y , t,y + ∂X t,y − (w (y))2 t,y = 0,
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
with the boundary conditions : t,y 1-periodic in Y, t,y |X=−γw (Y ) = −φ(t, y),
87
∂ t,y = 0. ∂nw X=−γw (Y )
(15)
Note that for fixed y, w (y) (and consequently (w (y))2 ) is an elliptic operator. We prove in Sect. 3 the following Theorem 2.1. There exist a constant φ∞ > 0 and a function w : [0, T ] × [ymin , ymax ] × ωw → R, such that if φ ∞ < φ∞ , for all (t, y), t,y = w (t, y, ·) is the unique weak solution in H2 (ωw ) of (14)–(15) (see remark below). Moreover, t,y belongs to H m (ωw ) for all m ≥ 0, and satisfies the estimate sup w (t, y, ·) H m (ωR ) ≤ Cm exp(−σ R), t,y
R ≥ R1 ,
(16)
where σ and R1 are independent of m. t,y 2 Remark. For all (t, y) and for all in H (ωw ), one can easily see that Eq. (14) has 2 a meaning in H0 (ωw ) . Furthermore, the boundary conditions (15) have also a meaning in the trace sense. Hence, “the unique weak solution of (14)–(15)” means the only function t,y satisfying (14) in (H02 (ωw )) , and (15) in the trace sense.
Once this auxiliary system is solved, we can prove our main convergence result. We prove in Sect. 3 Theorem 2.2. Let ε be the solution of System (3). There exists C∞ , such that if φ ∞ < C∞ , then ε L∞ (0,T ;H 1 (ε )) → 0 as ε → 0, ε − app
where
x − χw (y) y ε app (t, x) = int (t, x) + w t, y, , , ε ε
where int is given by (12) and w is given by Theorem 2.1. Remark. The previous theorem provides an approximation of ε at the main order. In fact for the proof, we will have to build an approximation up to the order ε that means under the form
x − χw (y) y ε 0 app = int (t, x) + w t, y, , ε ε
x − χw (y) y x − χw (y) y 0 1 +ε e t, y, , + w t, y, , . ε ε ε ε √ The two last quantities being of size ε in the H 1 norm, Theorem 2.2. will be obtained ε . by a classical energy estimate on the difference ε − app
88
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
Remark. Theorem 2.2 is the generalization to rough boundaries of the convergence theorem obtained in [10], for a domain without roughness. They proved a similar asymptotic result, with an asymptotic behaviour
x − χw (y) ε app (t, x) = int (t, x) + m t, y, . ε The stream function int was also given by (12), whereas the Munk layer term m = m (t, y, X) was the solution of ∂X m (t, y, ·) − (1 + χw (y)2 )2 ∂X4 m (t, y, ·) = 0, (17) ∂X m (t, y, ·) = 0, m (t, y, ·)|X=0 = −φ(t, y), X=0
with φ given by (13). Note that (17) is a simple linear differential equation in variable X. It is strongly different from the rough case, in which the boundary layer system (14)–(15) is genuinely two-dimensional, and nonlinear. Remark. A smallness assumption on the function φ of (13) is crucial, as can be seen from both theorems. It is first needed to prove the existence of the boundary layer term w . We then use it to prove the convergence theorem. Note that such condition was already present in the convergence theorem of [10]. As explained in this paper, it is deeply linked to the stability of the boundary layer : it can be read as a smallness condition on an appropriate Reynolds number. Remark. We recover the fact that the velocity is very large (O(ε −1/2 ) in L2 norm), due to the western boundary layer: it is the so-called intensification of western currents [3]. 2.2. Rough topography. ζ
2.2.1. The topography ηB . Throughout Sect. 4, we will study Eqs. (2), in = T2 = (R/Z)2 . Up to slight modifications, the case = R2 could be handled similarly. We still assume that curl τ ∈ C ∞ ([0, T ] × ), with curl τ |t=0 = 0. We assume that the bottom topography is given by
x ζ ηB (x) = ηB x, , ζ with ηB = ηB (x, X) smooth, 1-periodic in its variables. We assume ζ such that 1/ζ is an integer. 2.2.2. Results. We want to consider System (2) in the limit of small ζ . There again, we need auxiliary systems. 2 Let T > 0, and U = U (t, x) ∈ L∞ ((0, T ) × ) . We first consider the following ˜ x, X) for t > 0 and (x, X) ∈ T2 × T2 : equations, of unknown ψ˜ = ψ(t, ˜ + u˜ · ∇X X ψ˜ + U · ∇X X ψ˜ + u˜ · ∇X ηB + rX ψ˜ ∂ ψ t X (18) − ν (X )2 ψ˜ + U · ∇X ηB = 0, ˜ ∂X ψ˜ , ψ| ˜ t=0 = 0. u˜ = ∇X⊥ ψ˜ = −∂Y ψ,
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
89
of (18), Theorem 2.3. There exists a unique weak solution ψ ∞ 1 2 ∞ 2 ψ ∈L 0, T × ; H (Q) ∩ L 0, T ; L (; H (Q)) ,
T2
(t, ·) = 0. ψ
We now introduce what will be shown to be the limit system of (2). First, on the basis of Theorem 18, we define F : (L∞ ((0, T ) × ))2 → (L∞ ((0, T ) × ))2 by: for all x ∈ T2 , ˜ x, X) dX, ηB (x, X) ∇X ψ(t, F (U ) (t, x) = − T2X
where ψ˜ is the solution of (18), given by Theorem 2.3. We will show that it is dissipative, in the sense of Proposition 2.4. For all U in (L∞ ((0, T ) × ))2 , for all t ∈ (0, T ), for all x,
t
F (U ) (s, x) · U (s, x) ds ≥ 0.
0
The limit system is: for t > 0, x ∈ T2x , ∂t x ψ + β∂x ψ + u · ∇x ηB + rx ψ + curlx F(u) = β curl τ, u = ∇x⊥ ψ, ψ|t=0 = 0,
(19)
where the bar stands for the average in the rough variable X. We show in Sect. 4: Theorem 2.5. For all m > 1, there exists Tm > 0, such that System (19) has a unique solution ψ ∈ C [0, Tm ]; H m+1 (T2 ) , with for all t ≥ 0 , T2 ψ(t, x) dx = 0. Remark. The dissipative term curlx F(u0 ) in the limit system is of course due to the roughness: it is the mathematical translation of energy loss due to the friction at the bottom. Remark. System (19) is close to the one derived in [12], for rotating fluids in rough domains. Namely, the limit equation was of type ∂t x ψ + u · ∇x x ψ + curlx F(u) = 0 for a function F defined in a neighborhood of 0 in R2 , with values in R2 . In particular, in both cases, we do not manage to control curlx F(u) in Lp spaces, so that we can not conclude to the existence of global in time solutions, for instance through a Yudovitch scheme (cf. [14]).
90
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
However, we wish to point out a strong difference between the two cases: the function F is here non-local in time, whereas it was local for the rotating fluids system. In other words, for our model of oceanic circulation, the dissipative mechanisms depend on the whole history of the large scale flow. This appears clearly when one considers the linear case, i.e. omitting the nonlinear term in (2). Following [17], Eq. (19) becomes
t
∂t x ψ + β∂x ψ + u · ∇x ηB + rx ψ + curlx
R(t − τ, ·)u(τ, ·) dτ = β curl τ,
0
(20) for some kernel R. Thus, ψ obeys an integro-differential rather than a differential equation. For more on this linear case (such as numerical computations), see [17]. We now state the convergence result on solutions ψ ζ of System (2): Theorem 2.6. Let m > 1. Let u = ∇x⊥ ψ, where ψ ∈ C [0, Tm ]; H m+1 (T2x ) is the solution of (19) given by Theorem 2.5. Let uζ = ∇x⊥ ψ ζ , where ψ ζ is the solution of (2). Then 2 uζ → u in L∞ (0, Tm ); L2 () , as ζ → 0.
3. Rough Coasts This section is devoted to the proof of Theorems 2.1 and 2.2. In Subsect. 3.1, we formally derive an asymptotic expansion of the solution ε of (3). We recover formally functions int and w defined in the previous section. In Subsect. 3.2, we prove Theorem 2.1. In Subsect. 3.3, we prove Theorem 2.2.
3.1. Formal asymptotic expansion. In this part, we build formally an approximate soluε tion app of System (3). 3.1.1. Ansatz. We look for an approximation of the following type ε app (t, x, y)
n x − χw (y) y i i i = ε (t, x, y) + w t, y, , ε ε i=0
χe (y) − x y , , +ei t, y, ε ε
(21)
where • i (t, x, y) are interior terms, defined for t > 0, (x, y) ∈ ε , with support in the interior domain . • wi = wi (t, y, X, Y ) and ei = ei (t, y, X, Y ) are respectively the western and eastern boundary layer profiles. They are defined for t > 0, and X respectively in ωw and ωe , with 1-periodicity in the Y variable.
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
91
Dirichlet conditions. We expect the boundary layer terms to have no role far from the boundaries, which leads to the condition ei , wi −−−→ 0.
(22)
X→∞
ε We then want our approximate solution to satisfy app = 0 at ∂ε . It yields the following Dirichlet conditions: for all (t, y), = 0, ei (t, y, ·) = 0. (23) wi (t, y, ·) X=−γw (Y )
X=γe (Y )
ε Neumann conditions. We then want that ∂n app = 0 at ∂ε . It yields easily Neumann conditions on the boundary layer profiles, of the type: for all (t, y),
∂wi i = ϕw (t, y, X)|X=−γw (Y ) , ∂nw X=−γw (Y )
∂ei = ϕei (t, y, X)|X=−γe (Y ) , ∂ne X=−γe (Y ) (24)
i and ϕ i involve the k ’s and k for k ≤ i − 1. where functions ϕw e w e
Interface conditions. It remains to determine conditions at the interfaces. As the interior terms are zero outside , they create discontinuities at the interfaces w and e . Then boundary layer terms are added to cancel such discontinuities. This procedure is classical in roughness effect problems, see for instance [13, 12]. More precisely, to prove the convergence result, we will carry energy estimates on the difference of the stream ε . The roughness corrector ε is made to drop the surface functions φ ε = ε − app ext integral that appears when evaluating the viscous term ε ε ε ε ∂n (app (2 φ ε )φ ε = )app − ∇∂n app · ∇app
e ∪ w ε
e ∪ w + |D 2 φ ε |2 . ε
Sufficient conditions for this integral to vanish are ε = 0, k = 0, . . . , 3. ∂xk app
(25)
e ∪ w
Straightforward computations give the following jump conditions on the boundary layer terms: = − i (t, y, ·)|x=χw (y) , ψei (t, y, ·) = − i (t, y, ·)|x=χe (y) , ψwi (t, y, ·) |σw
|σw
(26) and ∂Xk ψwi (t, y, ·)
|σw
= fwi,k (t, y),
∂Xk ψei (t, y, ·)
|σw
= fei,k (t, y),
k = 1, . . . , 3, (27)
j
j
where the fwi,k and fei,k , k = 1, . . . , 3, depend on the j , w and e , j ≤ i − 1.
92
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
3.1.2. Derivation of the first profiles. We now derive the equations satisfied by the first profiles of the expansion (21). In the interior, we obtain at the leading order ε −3 the so-called Sverdrup relation ∂x 0 = curl τ.
(28)
We choose 0 to cancel at e , so that x 0 (t, x, y) = curl τ (t, x , y) dx
in ,
χe (y)
=0
in ε − .
(29)
+ − In the western layer, we have ∇ ∼ ε −1 ∇w (y). We find, for X in ωw ∪ ωw :
Qw (y)(w0 (t, y, ·), w0 (t, y, ·)) + ∂X w0 (t, y, ·) − (w (y))2 w0 (t, y, ·) = 0. (30) Remark. The quadratic operator Qw is deduced from the quadratic term (u · ∇) of system (3), replacing ∇ by ∇w = (∂X , ∂Y − χw ∂X )t . Indeed, we recall that (u · ∇) = (u · ∇) curl u = curl ((u · ∇)u) = ∇ ⊥ · ∇ ⊥ · ∇ ∇ ⊥ . We complete these equations by the interface and boundary conditions mentioned above, namely 0 w (t, y, ·) | σ = −φ(t, y), w k 0 ∂X w (t, y, ·) = 0, k = 1, . . . , 3 | σw ∂w0 (t, y, ·) w0 (t, y, ·) 1-periodic in Y, w0 (t, y, ·)X=−γ (Y ) = = 0. X=−γw (Y ) w ∂nw (31) In the eastern layer, we obtain homogeneous equations: for X ∈ ωe+ ∪ ωe− , Qe (y) e0 (t, y, ·), e0 (t, y, ·) − ∂X e0 (t, y, ·) − (e (y))2 e0 (t, y, ·) = 0.
(32)
The interface and boundary conditions are also homogeneous, thanks to our definition of 0 : ∂Xk e0 (t, y, ·) = 0, k = 0, . . . , 3, (33) |σe
e0 (t, y, ·) 1-periodic in Y,
e0 (t, y, ·)X=−γ
e
= (Y )
∂e0 (t, y, ·) = 0. (34) X=−γe (Y ) ∂ne
Of course, this system has the solution e0 ≡ 0. Remark. Our choice for the streamfunction 0 is the same as in [10]. It is due to the properties of the eastern coast, which cannot bear a large boundary layer. Indeed, as explained in [10], the equation satisfied by the eastern profile e0 in the non-rough case is −∂X e0 − (1 + (χe )2 )2 ∂X4 e0 = 0.
(35)
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
93
The characteristic equation of this ODE has only one root with negative real part, so that one can not impose simultaneously conditions on e0 , ∂x e0 at the boundary and a condition at infinity. The same difficulty appears in the rough case, as Eqs. (32) “contain” the differential equation (35). Note that such difficulty is not present in the western layer, as the underlying ODE ∂X w0 − (1 + (χw )2 )2 ∂X4 w0 = 0 has two characteristic roots with negative real parts. This ends the derivation of the first corrector terms. If we gather differently the leading order terms of the approximation, we obtain formally that in ε ,
x − χw (y) y ε app , , (t, x) ∼ int (t, x, y) + w t, y, ε ε where w = w (t, y, X) is defined by w (t, y, X) = w0 (t, y, X), w (t, y, X) =
+ X ∈ ωw ,
w0 (t, y, X) − int (t, x, y),
(36) X∈
− ωw .
(37)
Using Eqs. (30)–(31), we get (still at a formal level) the following equations on t,y = + ∪ ω− , w (t, y, ·): for X in ωw w Qw (y)( t,y , t,y ) + ∂X t,y − (w (y))2 t,y = 0, with
∂Xk t,y
t,y X=−γ
w (Y )
| σw
= 0,
= −φ(t, y),
(38)
k = 0, . . . , 3, ∂ t,y = 0. ∂nw X=−γw (Y )
(39)
As the jump conditions are homogeneous, Eq. (38) is in fact satisfied on all ωw . We thus recover formally the boundary layer system and the asymptotic result of Theorems 2.1 and 2.2.
3.2. The boundary layer system. The aim of this section is to prove Theorem 2.1. To do so, we use an equivalent formulation of (14), (15), more appropriate for a variational − treatment. Let us define = ψm (t, y, X) by: for X = (X, Y ) in ωw , ψm (t, y, X) = 0, + and for X = (X, Y ) in ωw , √ √ 3 3 1 ψm (t, y, X) = −φ(t, y) cos , (40) Dw (y)X + √ sin Dw (y)X 2 2 3 where φ is given by (13), and Dw (y) = (1 + (χw (y))2 )−2/3 . Note that for all (t, y), t,y + ∪ ω− , with the following jump conditions: ψm (X) = ψm (t, y, X) satisfies (14) in ωw w t,y t,y [ψm ]|σw = −φ(t, y), ∂X ψm |σw = 0.
94
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
If we set ψw0 (t, y, X) = w (t, y, X) − ψm (t, y, X), ψw0 (t, y, X) and denote ψ t,y X in ω+ ∪ ω− ,
=
= w (t, y, X) + int (t, x, y),
ψw0 (t, y, ·),
+ X ∈ ωw ,
X∈
(41)
− ωw ,
(42)
(14)–(15) are equivalent to the following equation: for t,y
t,y
Qw (y)(ψ t,y , ψ t,y ) + Qw (y)(ψm , ψ t,y ) + Qw (y)(ψ t,y , ψm ) +∂X ψ t,y − (w (y))2 ψ t,y = 0, ∂Xk ψ t,y = 0, k = 0, 1 | σw k t,y t,y ∂X ψ = − ∂Xk ψm , k = 2, 3. | σw | σw ∂ψ t,y = 0. ψ t,y 1-periodic in Y, ψ t,y X=−γw (Y ) = ∂nw X=−γw (Y )
(43)
(44)
We proceed in the following way: i) Under a smallness assumption on φ, we prove for all t, y the existence of a solution ψ t,y of (43)–(44) (in a sense to be made precise). ii) We show that ψ t,y belongs to H m (ωR ), for R > 1, and satisfies estimates (16). iii) Under a stronger smallness assumption on φ, we prove that ψ t,y is the unique solution of (43), (44). 3.2.1. Variational formulation. In this part, we show for all (t, y) the existence of a solution ψ t,y of (43)–(44). More precisely, we associate a variational formulation to these equations, and show the existence ofa solution for this formulation. ˜ ϕ on D02 (ωw ) × D02 (ωw ) × V0 by For all y, we define a trilinear form by ψ, ψ, ˜ φ =− (45) ∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w ∇w⊥ ψ˜ · ∇w⊥ ϕ. by ψ, ψ, ωw
One checks easily that
by
is well-defined for all y, satisfies ˜ ϕ = Qw (y) ψ, ψ˜ ϕ, by ψ, ψ,
˜ ϕ regular enough, and that for all ψ, ψ, by (ψ, ϕ, ϕ) = 0,
∀ ϕ ∈ V0 .
The variational formulation associated to (43)–(44) is: for all t, y, find ψ t,y ∈ D02 (ωw ) such that, for all ϕ in V0 , t,y t,y by ψ t,y , ψ t,y , ϕ + by ψ t,y , ψm , ϕ + by ψm , ψ t,y , ϕ 2,y t,y 2,y − < Dw ψ , D w ϕ > + ∂X ψ t,y ϕ = −(1 + (χw (y))2 ) ωw ωw
2 t,y 3 t,y × ∂X ψm ϕ + ∂ X ψm ∂X ϕ , (46) | σw
σw
| σw
σw
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
where 2,y Dw ψ=
95
2 ψ (1 + (χw (y))2 ) ∂X2 ψ −χw (y) ∂XY , 2 ψ −χw (y) ∂XY ∂Y2 ψ
and < , > stands for the euclidean matricial scalar product. We now prove Theorem 3.1. There exists φ∞ , such that if φ ∞ < φ∞ , there exists for all t ∈ [0, T ], for all y ∈ [ymin , ymax ] a function ψ t,y in D02 (ωw ) satisfying (46) for all ϕ in V0 . Proof of Theorem 3.1. The proof relies on a Galerkin scheme. Let (ϕn )n ∈ V0 be a basis of D02 (ωw ). We consider the sequel of approximate problems : For all n, find ψn of the form n ψn (t, y, X) = αk (t, y) ϕk (X), k=0 t,y
such that for all k ∈ {0, . . . , n}, for all (t, y), ψn = ψn (t, y, ·) satisfies t,y t,y t,y t,y t,y t,y by ψn , ψn , ϕk + by ψm , ψn , ϕk + by ψn , ψm , ϕk t,y 2,y t,y 2,y − < Dw ψ n , Dw ϕk > + ∂X ψn ϕk = −(1 + (χw (y))2 ) ωw ωw
t,y t,y × ∂X2 ψm ϕk + ∂X3 ψm ∂ X ϕk . | σw
| σw
σw
(47)
σw
• A priori estimates We start with a priori estimates. As t and y are simple parameters, we drop them temporarily in order to lighten notations: one can easily verify that all the constants Ci arising in the inequalities below can be chosen independent of t and y (and n). Multiplying the last equation by αk and summing over k leads to 2 2 < Dw ψ n , Dw ψn >= b(ψn , ψm , ψn ) + (∂X ψn ) ψn ωw ωw
(48) +(1 + (χw )2 ) ∂X2 ψm ψn + ∂X3 ψm ∂X ψn . | σw
| σw
σw
We obtain the following energy estimates: (ψn )2 We have (∂X ψn ) ψn = ∂X ( ) = 0. 2 ωw ωw The integrals over σw are bounded in the following way: ψn + ∂X3 ψm (1 + (χw )2 ) ∂X2 ψm | σw
≤ C1 |φ| ψn
σw
| σw
σw
σw
∂X ψn
− H 2 (ωw )
≤ C2 |φ| D 2 ψn L2 (ωw ) , −. where we have used Poincar´e’s inequality on ωw
(49)
96
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
It remains to estimate the trilinear term, i.e. to handle terms of the type +∞ 1 dY dX ∂i ∂j ψm (∂k ψn ) (∂l ψn ) , i, j, k, l ∈ {X, Y }. I= 0
We write I =
0
1
+∞
dY
0
dX ∂i ∂j ψm
∂k ψn (0, Y ) +
0
× ∂l ψn (0, Y ) +
X
X
dX ∂X ∂l ψn
dX ∂ ∂k ψn X
0
0
so that I = I1 + I2 + I3 + I4 , with 1 dY ∂k ψn (0, Y ) ∂l ψn (0, Y ) I1 =
+∞
dX ∂i ∂j ψm ,
X 1 +∞ I2 = dY ∂k ψn (0, Y ) dX (∂i ∂j ψm ) dX ∂X ∂l ψn , 0
0
0
0
1
I3 =
0 +∞
dY ∂l ψn (0, Y )
I4 =
X
dX (∂i ∂j ψm ) 0
dX ∂X ∂k ψn , 0
+∞
dY 0
0 X
dX (∂i ∂j ψm ) 0
1
X
dX ∂X ∂l ψn .
dX ∂X ∂k ψn 0
0
Through repeated use of the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, we get +∞
|I1 | ≤ sup dX |∂i ∂j ψm | ψn 2H 3/2 (σ ) Y
≤
w
0
C1 |φ| D ψn 2L2 (ω ) , w +∞ 2
√ dX |∂i ∂j ψm | X
|I2 | + |I3 | ≤ sup Y
0
ψn H 3/2 (σw ) D 2 ψn L2 (ωw )
≤ C2 |φ| D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω ) , w +∞
|I4 | ≤ sup dX |∂i ∂j ψm |X D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω Y
w)
0
≤ C3 |φ| D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω ) . w
Remark. With similar computations, one has more generally that : there exists C, σ > 0, such that for all ψ ∈ D02 (ωw ) and for all R ≥ 0, ⊥ ⊥ ⊥ 2 2 ψ · ∇ ψ ψ (50) ∇ ∇ · ∇ w w w m w ≤ C |φ| exp(−σ R) D ψn L2 (ω ) . w
ωR
If we gather all these bounds, we end with the a priori estimate 2 2 2 2 D ψn L2 (ω ) ≤ C5 < Dw ψ n , Dw ψn > w ωw ≤ C6 |φ| D 2 ψn L2 (ωw ) + D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω ) . w
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
97
Recovering the dependence on t and y, we get t,y
D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω
w)
t,y t,y ≤ ≤ C6 |φ(t, y)| D 2 ψn L2 (ωw ) + D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω ) . (51) w
In particular, if φ ∞ < C6 /2, we get t,y
D 2 ψn L2 (ωw ) ≤ 2 C6 |φ(t, y)|.
(52)
• Existence of ψn Let α = (α1 , . . . , αn )t , where ψn =
αk ϕk . Equations (47) read
F y, φ(t, y), α(t, y) = 0,
with F of type
F (y, φ, a) = Q1 (y, a, a) + Q2 (y, a, φ) + Q2 (y, φ, a) + A(y) a + L(y)φ. The Qi ’s come from the trilinear term by : they are smooth and bilinear in their last two variables. The matrix A(y) comes from the viscous term: it is smooth in y, and invertible, as the ϕk ’s are independent. The matrix L(y) is smooth and comes from the surface integral. Note that up to extending the functions χw and φ, one can assume that F : R × R × Rn → Rn . Moreover, it is straightforward that for all y in R, F (y, 0, 0) = 0,
∂F (y, 0, 0) invertible. ∂a
By the implicit function theorem, for all y, there exist neighborhoods Yy of y, Py of φ = 0, and Ay of a = 0, and a smooth function a from Yy × Py to Ay such that ∀ (y, ˜ φ, a) ∈ Yy × Py × Ay ,
F (y, ˜ φ, a) = 0
⇔
a = a(y, ˜ φ).
As [ymin , ymax ] is compact, we can find a covering of [ymin , ymax ] by a finite number of neighborhoods Yy1 , . . . , Yyn . Let P = ∩ni=1 Pyi ,
A = ∩ni=1 Ayi ,
and let ai : Yyi × Pyi → Ayi be the corresponding solution of F (y, φ, a) = 0, given by the implicit function theorem. Thanks to (52), there exists φ∞ such that, for φ ∞ < φ∞ , for all t ∈ [0, T ], for all y ∈ [ymin , ymax ], φ(t, y) belongs to P and for all i, ai (t, y, φ(t, y)) belongs to A. It is then straightforward to see that α(t, y) = ai (y, φ(t, y)) ,
t ∈ [0, T ],
y ∈ Yyi
is well-defined and is a smooth solution of the approximate problem.
98
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
• Convergence of ψn The estimate (52) shows that, uniformly in t and y, t,y ψn is a bounded sequence of D02 (ωw ). n
t,y Hence, for all (t, y), there exists ψ t,y ∈ D02 (ωw ), such that, up to a subsequence, ψn
n
converges weakly to ψ t,y , with (cf. (52)) D 2 ψ t,y L2 (ω) ≤ 2 C6 |φ(t, y)|.
t,y Moreover, using Rellich’s theorem (and again up to a subsequence), ψn converges s (ωw ), for any s < 2. It is then a routine argument to pass to strongly to ψ t,y in Hloc the limit into (47) as n goes to infinity, to obtain: for all t, y, ψ t,y satisfies (46) for all ϕ ∈ V0 . This ends the proof of Theorem 3.1.
Remark. We do not know at this point the behaviour at infinity of solutions ψ t,y . In particular, we still may not use ψ t,y as a test function in (46) (through a density argument), which would allow to conclude for uniqueness. Also, if we wish to use Sobolev injections, we need to distinguish between the oscillatory part of ψ (for which injections hold) and its average, as will be done in the next subsection. 3.2.2. H m estimates. Let φ ∞ < φ∞ as in Theorem 3.1, and let ψ t,y ∈ D02 (ωw ) sat2 (ω ). Besides, thanks to classical isfy (46) for all ϕ ∈ V0 . Note that ψ t,y belongs to Hloc w regularity results for elliptic operators, − + ψ t,y ∈ C ∞ ωw ∪ ωw , and satisfies (43) in the classical sense. In this part, we show that ψ t,y belongs to H m (ωR ) for all m ≥ 0 and for all R > 1. As t and y are simple parameters, we drop them from notations : it is straightforward to see that the various constants appearing in the inequalities below can be chosen independent of t and y. N Average and oscillations. We introduce the following notations: to all w ∈ L1loc R+ ×T N (N ≥ 1), we associate its vertical average w ∈ L1loc R+ and its oscillatory part N ∗ 1 + w ∈ Lloc R × T , through + ∀X = (X, Y ) ∈ R × T, w(X) = w dY, w∗ (X) = w(X) − w(X),
(X)
where for all R ≥ 0, (R) is the cross-section at X = R. In order to lighten notations, + instead of X > 0. we may sometimes consider w as a function of X ∈ ωw The aim of this paragraph is to prove Proposition 3.2. There exist C∞ ∈ R and C, σ > 0, such that for all R > 0, ψ − C∞ belongs to H 2 (ωR ) with ψ − C∞ H 2 (ωR ) ≤ C exp(−σ R) + D 2 ψ ∗ L2 (ωR/2 ) . (53)
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
99
Proof of proposition 3.2. As ψ belongs to D02 (ωw ), we have + ), ψ ∗ ∈ H 2 (ωw
ψ
(2)
∈ L2 ({X > 0}).
ψ satisfies for all X > 0 the linear differential equation 2 (4) (1) − 1 + (χw )2 ψ + ψ = −Qw (ψ, ψ) − Qw (ψ, ψm ) − Qw (ψm , ψ). Simple computations yield Qw (ψm , ψ) = Qw (ψ, ψm ) = 0 Qw (ψ, ψ) = Q(ψ ∗ , ψ ∗ ), so that ψ satisfies 2 (4) (1) − 1 + (χw )2 ψ + ψ = −Qw (ψ ∗ , ψ ∗ ). Remember that
(54)
˜ ψ) ˜ = ∇w × (∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w )∇w⊥ ψ . Qw (ψ,
Applying the last equality to ψ˜ = ψ ∗ and integrating in the Y variable leads to Qw (ψ ∗ , ψ ∗ ) = ∂X B(ψ ∗ , ψ ∗ ) for a bilinear operator B involving the derivatives of ψ ∗ up to order two. If we substitute this expression into (54) and integrate in the X variable, we finally obtain 2 (3) (55) − 1 + (χw )2 ψ + ψ = C∞ + B(ψ ∗ , ψ ∗ ), where C∞ is a real constant. Any solution ψ of Eq. (55) is given by ψ = C∞ + ϕ, with ϕ a solution of 2 (56) − 1 + (χw )2 ϕ (3) + ϕ = B(ψ ∗ , ψ ∗ ). This last equation can be expressed in the form of a first order system V = AV + F , with 0 10 ϕ 0 . 0 0 1 , F = 0 V = ϕ (1) , A = (57) −2 (2) 2 ∗ ∗ −B( , ) ϕ 00 1 + (χw ) −2/3 A is diagonalisable, with eigenvalues Dw , j Dw , j 2 Dw , with Dw = 1 + (χw )2 . Let E+ and E− be the eigenspaces corresponding respectively to 1 and {j, j 2 }, and let −2 −1 t P+ , P− be the associated eigenprojections. Note that E+ = C Dw , Dw , 1 . We introduce the “Green function” G(X) = eAX P − if X > 0, G(X) = e−AX P + if X < 0,
100
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
and
f (X) = F (X) f (X) = 0
if X > 0, if X < 0.
The function G ∗ f is a solution of the system V = AV + F . Thus, we can write, for a V0 ∈ C4 , for all X > 0, V (X) = eAX V0 + G ∗ f.
(58)
Note that G satisfies, for positive constants C and α, ∀ X,
|G(X)| ≤ C e−α|X| ,
and that f ∈ L1 (R). More precisely, one has easily that for all R > 0, |F | ≤ C D 2 ψ ∗ 2L2 (ωR ) . {X>R}
Proceeding exactly as in [12, p. 1473], one is able to obtain G ∗ F 2L2 ({X>R}) ≤ C exp(−αR) + D 2 ∗ 2L2 (ωR/2 ) .
(59)
(2)
= ϕ (2) ∈ L2 ({X > 0}), we necessarily have P+ V0 ∈ C2 × {0}. But Now, as ψ t −2 −1 E+ = C Dw , Dw , 1 , so that P+ V0 = 0. It yields the inequality: ϕ H 2 ({X>R}) ≤ C exp(−σ R) + D 2 ψ ∗ L2 (ωR/2 ) . As ψ −C∞ = ϕ+ψ ∗ , we finally obtain (53). This ends the proof of the proposition.
H m estimates on ψ − C∞ . In this paragraph, we prove Proposition 3.3. There exists σ > 0, such that for all m ≥ 0, for all R ≥ 1, ψ − C∞ ∈ H m (ωR ), with (60) ψ − C∞ H m (ωR ) ≤ Cm exp(−σ R) + ψ − C∞ H 2 (ωR−1 ) . The keypoint of the proof is the following lemma: + , 1-periodic in Y , satisfying Lemma 3.4. Let , f1 , f2 , ∈ C ∞ ωw (w )2 = ∇w⊥ · f1 + f2
+ in ωw ,
where ∇w = (∂X , ∂Y − χw ∂X )t . Then, for all s ≥ 1, δ ∈ (0, s), for all m ≥ 0, and 1 < q < ∞, m+3,q,s,s+1 ≤ C f1 m,q,s−δ,s+1+δ + f2 m,q,s−δ,s+1+δ + 2,q,s−δ,s+1+δ ,
where · m,q,s,t stands for the norm in W of s.
m,q
(61)
+ ωw ∪ {s < X < t)} , and C independent
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
101
Proof of Lemma 3.4. The proof of this lemma is very close to the proof of [11, Lemma 1.2], and relies on classical elliptic regularity results. Note that it is enough to prove the inequality (61) for s = 1: we can always come back to this case through a change of variable: X → X − ξ . This also implies that the constant C of the lemma is independent of s. + We content ourselves with proving: Let ψ, f1 , f2 ∈ C ∞ ωw , 1-periodic in Y , 2 ⊥ + ˜ for all 1 < q < ∞, satisfying (w ) ψ = ∇w · f1 + f2 in ωw . Then, for all 0 < δ < δ, ψ 3,q,1−δ,2+δ ≤ C f1 0,q,1−δ,2+ ˜ ˜ ˜ δ˜ + f2 0,q,1−δ,2+ δ˜ + ψ 2,q,1−δ,2+ δ˜ . (62) Indeed, the proof of the proposition follows easily by induction, applying (62) for ˜ ψ = ∂ α , f1 = ∂ α f1 , f2 = ∂ α f2 , |α| = m, and appropriate δ, δ. ˜ Let 0 < δ < δ and 1 < q < ∞ be fixed. Let 0 ≤ ζ ≤ 1 be a C ∞ function on R3 such that 1 3 ζ = 1 in K = [1 − δ, 2 + δ] × − , , 2 2 ˜ 2 + δ×] ˜ − 1, 2[. ζ = 0 outside a C ∞ open set O with K ⊂ O s]1 − δ, ˜ and u = ∇w⊥ ψ. We derive the following system on u: We set ψ˜ = ζ ψ, u˜ = ∇w⊥ ψ, ˜ ∇w⊥ · (w u) ˜ = ∇w⊥ · f˜1 + f2 in O, ∇w · u˜ = 0 in O, u˜ = 0 on ∂O,
(63)
f˜1 = (4∇w ζ · ∇w ) u + ζf1 , f˜2 = ζf2 + w ((w ζ )ψ) + 2 (∇w w ζ · ∇w ) ψ + (∇w (∇w ζ ) · ∇w (∇w ψ)) − 4∇w (∇w ζ ) · ∇w u − ∇w⊥ · f1 .
(64)
where
Using [11, Theorem 3.2, p. 130], there exists G ∈
1,q W0 (O)
such that
˜ Lq (O) . ∇ · G = f˜2 in O, with G W 1,q (O) ≤ C g The function F = (G2 , −G1 + χw G2 ), where G = (G1 , G2 )t satisfies ∇w × F = f˜2 ,
with F W 1,q (O) ≤ f˜2 Lq (O) .
Going from the vorticity formulation (63) to a velocity formulation, we obtain w u˜ + ∇w q = f˜1 + F in O, ∇w · u˜ = 0 in O, u˜ = 0 on ∂O. Classical estimates for elliptic systems yield u ˜ W 2,q (O) ≤ C f˜1 + F Lq (0) + u ˜ Lq (O) , which leads easily to (62).
(65)
102
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
Proof of Proposition 3.3. To prove this proposition, we work with the function ψ∞ := + the equation ψ − C∞ − ψm , which satisfies on ωw Qw (ψ∞ , ψ∞ ) + ∂X ψ∞ − 2w ψ∞ = 0, which can also be written, introducing u∞ = ∇ ⊥ ψ∞ , 2w ψ∞ = ∇w⊥ × (−u∞ · ∇w u∞ ) − ∂X ψ∞ .
(66)
Let us show that: for all δ > 0, there exists C > 0 such that ∀ R ≥ 1,
ψ∞ H 3 (ωR ) ≤ C ψ∞ H 2 (ωR−δ ) .
(67)
Let δ > 0; for all s ≥ 1, we have − u∞ · ∇w u∞ 0,3/2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C1 u∞ 0,6,s−δ,s+1+δ ∇w u∞ 0,2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C2 ψ∞ 22,2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C3 ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ .
(68)
Note that the constants Ci do not depend on s (thanks to the invariance by translation along X). We also have ∂X ψ∞ 0,3/2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C4 ∂X ψ∞ 0,2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C5 ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ , so that applying Lemma 3.4, we have ψ∞ 3,3/2,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ C6 u∞ · ∇w u∞ + ∂X ψ∞ 0,3/2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C7 ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ .
(69)
We now iterate the process and get an improved regularity. By Sobolev imbedding, we have u∞ 0,∞,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ C8 ψ∞ 3,3/2,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ C9 ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ . Hence, we get the following bound − u∞ · ∇w u∞ 0,2,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ C10 u∞ 0,∞,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ∇w u∞ 0,2,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ C11 ψ∞ 22,2,s−δ,s+1+δ ≤ C12 ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ . Moreover,
(70)
∂X ψ∞ 0,2,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ ,
so that applying again Lemma 3.4, ψ∞ 3,2,s,s+1 ≤ C u∞ · ∇w u∞ + ∂X ψ∞ 0,2,s−δ/2,s+1+δ/2 ≤ C ψ∞ 2,2,s−δ,s+1+δ ,
(71)
C
with independent of s. Using this last inequality with s = R + k, k = 1, 2, . . . , and summing over k, we get (67). Using the same type of bootstrap arguments with the derivatives of ψ∞ instead of ψ∞ , it is easy to show that more generally: for all m ≥ 3, for all δ > 0, there exists C > 0 such that: ∀ R ≥ 1,
ψ∞ H m (ωR ) ≤ C ψ∞ H 2 (ωR−δ ) .
Back to ψ − C∞ = ψ∞ + ψm , the proposition follows. It ends the proof.
(72)
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
103
Control of ψ at infinity. To show that ψ is in H m (ωR ) for all R > 0, it remains to prove that the constant C∞ of Proposition 3.2 is zero. On one hand, we multiply Eq. (43) by ψ(= ψ t,y ) and integrate on ω ∩ {X < R}. After a few integration by parts, using jump conditions (44), we are left with
2 2 ∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w ∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w⊥ ψ Dw ψ, Dw ψ = − ω∩{X
ω∩{X
−
ω∩{X
∇w⊥ ψm · ∇w ∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w⊥ ψm
− +
⊥ ⊥ ∇w ψm · ∇w ∇w ψ · ∇w⊥ ψ
ω∩{X
2
∂X (w ψ) ψ −
+ σ (R)
(∇w ∂X ψ) · ∇w ψ σ (R)
χw ⊥ ⊥ + · ∇w (ψ + ψm ) · ∇w ∇w ψ 1 σ (R)
χw + · ∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w ∇w⊥ ψm 1 σ (R) 2 2 3 +(1 + (χw ) ) ∂X ψm ψ + ∂ X ψm | σw
| σw
σw
∂X ψ .
(73)
σw
As ψ − C∞ belongs to H m (ωR ) for all R > 1, we may pass easily to the limit as R goes to infinity in (73) and obtain C2 2 2 Dw ψ, Dw ψ = b(ψ, ψm , ψ) + ∞ + (1 + (χw )2 ) 2 ωw
× ∂X2 ψm ψ + ∂X3 ψm ∂X ψ . (74) | σw
| σw
σw
σw
On the other hand, we use the fact that, up to a subsequence, ψn → ψ,
weakly in D02 (ωw ),
where ψn was built in Sect. 3.2.1. Hence, 2 2 Dw ψ, Dw ψ ≤ lim inf
n→+∞ ω w
ωw
2 2 Dw ψ n , Dw ψn .
Using (48) yields 2 2 lim inf Dw ψ n , Dw ψn = lim inf b(ψn , ψm , ψn ) + lim inf (1 + (χw )2 ) n→+∞ ω n→+∞ n→+∞ w
× ∂X2 ψm (75) ψn + ∂X3 ψm ∂X ψn . | σw
| σw
σw
σw
By the Rellich theorem, for all s > 2, we have up to a subsequence ψn → ψ,
s strongly in Hloc .
(76)
104
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
If we choose for instance s = 7/4, and thanks to the imbedding − H s (ωw ) → H 1 (σw ),
we deduce
lim inf (1 + (χw )2 ) ∂X2 ψm ψn + ∂X3 ψm ∂X ψn n→+∞ | σw σw | σw σw
= (1 + (χw )2 ) ∂X2 ψm ψ + ∂X3 ψm ∂X ψ . | σw
| σw
σw
(77)
σw
It remains to show that lim inf b(ψn , ψm , ψn ) = b(ψ, ψm , ψ). n→+∞
Thanks to (50),
ωR
⊥ ⊥ ⊥ ∇w ψn · ∇w ∇w ψm · ∇w ψn ≤ C1 |φ| exp(−σ R) D 2 ψn 2L2 (ω
w)
≤
C2
exp(−σ R),
(78)
where we have used the uniform bound (52). In the same way
∇w⊥ ψ · ∇w ∇w⊥ ψm · ∇w⊥ ψ ≤ C3 exp(−σ R).
ωR
Thus, for all ε > 0, there exists R such that |b(ψn , ψm , ψn ) − b(ψ, ψm , ψ)| ≤ ε +
ω∩{X
− ω∩{X
∇w⊥ ψn · ∇w ∇w⊥ ψn · ∇w⊥ ψm
∇w⊥ ψ
· ∇w
∇w⊥ ψ
⊥ ·∇w ψm .
(79)
The second term at the right-hand side goes to zero as n → +∞, using (76). Finally,
2 2 Dw ψ, Dw ψ ≤ b(ψ, ψm , ψ) + (1 + (χw )2 )
× ∂X2 ψm ψ + ∂X3 ψm ∂X ψ .
ωw
| σw
σw
The comparison with (74) yields C∞ = 0.
| σw
σw
(80)
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
105
Exponential decay. In this last paragraph, we prove the so-called “Saint-Venant” estimates on ψ, that means exponential decay estimates (16). Once again, we rather work + the equation with = ψ − ψm , which satisfies on ωw Qw (, ) + ∂X − 2w = 0. Combining Propositions 3.2 and 3.3, it is enough to prove Proposition 3.5. There exists R1 , C, σ > 0, such that D 2 ∗ L2 (ωR ) ≤ C exp(−σ R). |D 2 ψ ∗ |2 . An energy estimate on the previProof of Proposition 3.5. Let f (R) = ∀R ≥ R1 ,
ωR
ous equation gives f (R) ≤ C with
ωR
2 ∗ 2 ∗ Dw , Dw =C
6
(81)
Ik ,
k=1
Qw (, ∗ ) ∗ , I3 = Qw ( ∗ , ) ∗ , R R R ω ω ω ∗ ∗ ∗ 2 I4 = Qw ( , ) , I5 = − ((χw ) + 1)(∂X w ∗ ) ∗ , ωR σ (R) I6 = + (1 + (χw )2 )∂X |∇w ∗ |2 . (82) ∂X ∗ ∗ ,
I1 =
I2 =
σ (R)
I1 = − σ (R)
| ∗ |2 ≤ 0. 2
We have +∞ I4 = ∇w⊥ ∗ · ∇w w ∗ ∗ σ (R ) R ≤
∗
sup |∇w w | Y,X≥R
+∞
σ (R )
R
∗ 2
1/2
| |
σ (R )
|∇w⊥ ∗ |2
1/2 . (83)
Using Proposition 3.3, we obtain for R large enough sup |∇w w ∗ | ≤ δ, where δ Y,Z≥R
positive will be chosen later. Moreover, | ∗ |2 + |∇w⊥ ∗ |2 ≤ 2 σ (R )
σ (R )
σ (R )
|D 2 ∗ |2 .
Finally, I4 ≤ δf (R). The estimates of I2 and I3 are similar to the one of I4 . We get for R large enough, I2 + I3 ≤ δf (R).
106
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
We treat I5 in the following way: I5 = − (1 + (χw )2 ) ∂X w ∗ σ (R) 2 = −(1 + (χw ) ) ∂X w ∗ σ (R) 2 ≤ −(1 + (χw ) ) ∂X w ∗ σ (R) 2 ≤ −(1 + (χw ) ) ∂X w ∗
∗
∗ 2 + (1 + (χw ) ) w ∗ ∂X ∗ σ (R)
∗ + C |D 2 ∗ |2 σ (R)
∗ − Cf (R). (84)
σ (R)
Finally,
2 I6 = 1 + (χw ) ∂X
|∇w ∗ |2 . σ (R)
Back to the main energy estimate (81), we obtain for R large enough.
(1 − 2δ)f (R) ≤ −Cf (R) − (1 + (χw )2 ) ∂X w ∗ ∗ σ (R)
2 + 1 + (χw ) ∂X |∇w ∗ |2 ,
(85)
σ (R)
where C is a positive constant. We integrate this inequality between t > 0 large enough and +∞. It leads to +∞ f (R) dR + C1 f (t) ≤ C2 f (t), (86) t
where the Ci ’s are positive constants. We conclude thanks to [11, Lemma 2.2].
3.2.3. Uniqueness. In this part, we show for all (t, y) the uniqueness of the solution ψ t,y ∈ H02 (ωw ) of (43)–(44), under a smallness assumption on φ. Let (t, y) fixed, and t,y t,y t,y t,y ψ1 , ψ2 in H02 (ωw ) two solutions of (43)–(44), and θ = ψ1 − ψ2 . It satisfies, for all ϕ ∈ V0 , t,y t,y 2 2 − < Dw θ, Dw θ > +by (θ, ψ2 , ϕ) + by (ψ1 , θ, ϕ) ωw t,y t,y +by (θ, ψm , ϕ) + by (ψm , θ, ϕ) + (∂X θ) ϕ = 0. (87) ωw
As θ ∈ H02 (ωw ), there exists ϕn in V0 such that ϕn → θ in H02 (ωw ). It is then easy to pass to the limit in the above equation, as n goes to infinity, with ϕ = ϕn . It yields 2 2 − < Dw θ, Dw θ > +b(θ, ψm , θ ) = 0. ωw
Using (50), we obtain, |b(θ, ψm , θ)| ≤ C |φ| D 2 θ 2L2 (ω ) , w
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
so that
D 2 θ 2L2 (ω
w)
107
≤ C |φ(t, y)| D 2 θ 2L2 (ω ) . w
1/C ,
we obtain θ = 0, which concludes the proof of the Finally, for φ ∞ ≤ φ∞ < uniqueness. We thus may define, for φ ∞ < φ∞ a function ψw0 = ψw0 (t, y, X) by: f or all (t, y), ψw0 (t, y, ·) is the only solution in H02 (ωw )of (43) − (44). As already mentioned, if we come back to the original system (14), (15) and define w = w (t, y, X) by (41)–(42), it is clear that the function w satisfies the statements of Theorem 2.1. This ends the proof of Theorem 2.1. We end Sect. 3.2 by additional regularity results on ψw0 with respect to t and y. Indeed, to build the other profiles of expansion (21) requires the existence and control β β of ∂tα ∂y w0 (or equivalently ∂tα ∂y ψw0 ). This is possible thanks to k > 0, such that if φ < φ k , then Proposition 3.6. For all k ≥ 0, there exists φ∞ ∞ ∞ 0 k,∞ 2 i) ψw ∈ W (0, T ) × (ymin , ymax ); D0 (ωw ) .
ii) For all α, β, |α| + |β| ≤ k, for all R > 1, ∂tα ∂yβ ψw0 (t, y, ·) belongs to H m (ωR ), with sup ∂tα ∂yβ ψw0 (t, y, ·) H m (ωR ) ≤ Cm exp(−σ R), t,y
R ≥ R1 .
Proof of Proposition 3.6. We only give the main ideas of the proof. Indeed, precise computations are very close to those performed above, so that we do not give all the details • Case k = 0 Let ψn = ψn (t, y, X) be the approximation built in Subsect. 3.2. On one hand, estimate (52) shows that (ψn )n is a bounded sequence of E := L∞ (0, T ) × (ymin , ymax ); D02 (ωw ) . Thus, there exists a subsequence, that we still denote (ψn )n which converges for the weak star topology to a function ψ 0 of E. In particular, for any compact subset K of ωw , we get ∀ ϕ ∈ C ∞ ([0, T ] × [ymin , ymax ] × K), ψn ϕ −−−−→ ψ 0 ϕ. n→+∞
On the other hand, as ψw0 (t, y, ·) is the only solution of (43)–(44), one shows through standard arguments that for all (t, y), for all s < 2, ψn (t, y, ·) → ψw0 (t, y),
n → +∞,
Thanks to this last convergence, we also get ∞
∀ ϕ ∈ C ([0, T ] × [ymin , ymax ] × K), Finally, ψw0 ≡ ψ0 , and therefore belongs to E.
strongly in H s (K).
ψn ϕ −−−−→ n→+∞
ψw0 ϕ.
108
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
• Case k = 1 Let (hn ) be a sequence going to zero. The idea is to consider the sequence (ϕn = ϕn (t, y, X))n given by ϕn (t, y, ·) =
ψw0 (t + hn , y, ·) − ψw0 (t, y, ·) . hn
Note that ϕn converges to ∂t ψw0 in D ((0, T ) × (ymin , ymax ) × ωw ). Moreover, repeating the whole process above with ϕn instead of ψn , one shows that, for φ ∞ small enough, this sequence converges as above, to a function p = p(t, y, X) ∈ E. For all t, y, p(t, y, ·) is the unique solution of equations that are of the same type as (43)–(44). In particular, it satisfies exponential decay estimates of type (16). Finally, one has ∂t ψw0 = p ∈ E, with appropriate exponential decay estimates. In the same way, one has also ∂y ψw0 ∈ E, with appropriate exponential decay estimates. • Case k > 1 One applies inductively the same arguments, replacing ψw0 by its derivatives. 3.3. Convergence result. This part is devoted to the proof of Theorem 2.2. The scheme of the proof is classical: on the basis of the previous analysis, we build an approxiε of the type (21) with n = 1. We then perform energy estimates on mate solution app ⊥ ε ε ). ε v = ∇ ( − app 3.3.1. The approximate solution. Interior and eastern profiles. We recall that 0 is given by (29), and that e0 ≡ 0. j The next profiles are built inductively. Assume that the j and e , j ≤ i − 1, are k well-defined, with e and its derivatives decaying exponentially to zero. Then, the i th interior profile satisfies ∂X i = F i , where F i depends on the j , j ≤ i − 1. This defines i , up to the addition of a function of t and y. To determine this function we use the equation on the eastern profile ei . This profile satisfies a linear elliptic equation of the type −2e ei − ∂X ei = Gi ,
X ∈ ωe+ ∪ ωe− ,
(88)
fulfilled with jump and boundary conditions = − i (t, y, ·) , ei (t, y, ·) |σe |{x=χe (y)} ∂Xk ei (t, y, ·) = g i,k (t, y), k = 1, . . . , 3,
(89)
|σe
ei (t, y, ·) 1-periodic in Y, ei (t, y, ·)|X=γe (Y )
= 0,
∂nw ei (t, y, ·)|X=γe (Y )
(90) =h, i
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
109 j
where the Gi , g i,k , and hi depend on the j and e , j ≤ i − 1. If we introduce , X ∈ ωe+ , ψei = ei + i |{x=χe (y)}
ψei
=
X ∈ ωe− ,
ei ,
ψei is formally a solution of (88), (90), with the homogeneous jump condition = 0. ei (t, y, ·) |σe
(91)
Using the Lax-Milgram lemma, it is then direct to show the existence and uniqueness of the ψei solution of (88), (90), (91). Moreover, using the same kind of arguments as in Subsect. 3.3.2, one shows that there exists C = C(t, y) such that ψei (t, y, ·) + C(t, y) and its derivatives decay exponentially to zero. Hence, we choose i such that = C(t, y), i (t, y, ·) |{x=χe (y)}
ei (t, y, ·)
so that and ei .
decays exponentially to zero. This completes the construction of i
Western profiles. The first western profile w0 has been built in Sect. 3.2. The second profile w1 can be obtained by solving similar equations, taking into account the error term created by w0 . Such an error term is well controlled, thanks to Proposition 3.6. More generally, the following profiles are solutions of similar equations, with error terms coming from lower profiles. As the construction is straightforward but tedious, we will not detail it. 3.3.2. Final energy estimates. We now focus on the energy estimates on the difference ε be the approximation above, between the exact and the approximate solutions. Let app ε which is well defined (and regular enough) for φ ∞ small enough. Let uεapp = ∇ ⊥ app , ε ⊥ ε ε and u = ∇ , with satisfying (3). We wish to show that ε L∞ ε − app t
or equivalently that
uε − uεapp L∞ t
The difference
vε
=
uε
− uεapp
belongs to
−−→ 0,
(H 1 (ε ))
ε→0
−−→ 0.
(L2 (ε ))
H 1 (ε ),
ε→0
and satisfies
∂t v ε + v ε · ∇v ε + v ε · ∇uεapp + uεapp · ∇v ε +v ε + (ηB + βy)(v ε )⊥ + ∇q ε − v ε = R ε ∇ · vε = 0 ε v | ∪ = 0 ε w e ∂v = σε − q ε n ∂n | w ∪ e vε = ϕε
in ∪ εw ∪ εe , in ∪ εw ∪ εe , at w ∪ e , at w ∪ e , ε at w ∪ eε
(92)
110
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
with R ε L∞ −1 (ε )) = O(ε), t (H
σ ε L∞ (H 1/2 ( w ∪ e )) = O(ε), t
λ ϕ ε W 1,∞ (H 1/2 ( ε ∪ ε )) = O exp − , λ > 0. t w e ε
The boundary term ϕ ε is the trace of the western (resp. eastern) boundary layer at eε ε ): (resp. at w ε (t, y, χe (y) + εγe (ε −1 y))|eε , ϕ ε |eε = ϕw
ϕ ε |wε = ϕeε (t, y, χw (y) − εγw (ε −1 y))|wε , ε , ϕ ε , and their derivatives exponentially decaying in their last variable. This with ϕw e ε are zero for explains the exponential bound on ϕ ε . Note that thanks to (11), ϕeε and ϕw y ∈ [ymax − λ, ymax ] ∪ [ymin , ymin + λ].
Lift of the boundary term. We must add a corrector to v ε so as to correct the boundary ε conditions. Let w (y) = χw (y) − εγw (ε −1 y), eε (y) = χe (y) + εγe (ε −1 y). We set
ε (y))2 + 1 (2x − w ε ε ε ε θ(x − w (y)) w1 (t, x, y) = ϕe (t, y, w (y)) ε (y))2 + 1 (w
(2x − eε (y))2 + 1 ε ε ε + ϕw (t, y, e (y)) θ(x − e (y)) , eε (y)2 + 1 where θ belongs to Cc∞ ([−δ, δ]) for δ > 0 small enough. It is clear that w1ε W 1,∞ (H 1 (ε )) ≤ C exp(−λ /ε),
λ > 0. 3 Now, we may apply [11, Lemma 3.1]: there exists w2ε ∈ L∞ H01 (ε ) such that t
∇ · w2ε = −∇ · w1ε ,
w2ε L∞ ≤ C(ε ) ∇ · w1ε L∞ 1 ε 2 ε . t (H ( )) t (L ( ))
Moreover, we can choose
C(ε ) = C δ(ε )2 1 + δ(ε ) ≤ C ,
where δ is the Lebesgue measure on R2 , and C is independent of ε. A look at the proof also shows that the same inequality holds for time derivatives, so that finally w2ε W 1,∞ (H 1 (ε )) ≤ C ε 2 . t
If we set v ε = wε + w1ε + w2ε , w ε is solution of ∂t w ε + w ε · ∇w ε + w ε · ∇uεapp + uεapp · ∇w ε +w ε + (ηB + βy)(w ε )⊥ + ∇q ε − w ε = R˜ ε ∇ · w ε = 0 in ∪ εw ∪ εe , ε w | ∪ = 0 at w ∪ e , ε w e ∂w = σ˜ε at w ∪ e , − q ε n ∂n | w ∪ e wε = 0
ε at w ∪ eε
in ∪ εw ∪ εe , (93)
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
111
with R˜ ε L∞ −1 (ε )) = O(ε), t (H
σ˜ ε L∞ 1/2 ( ∪ )) = O(ε). w e t (H
Final estimates. The final estimates are very close to those of [12]. We get ∂t w ε (t, ·) 2L2 + w ε (t, ·) 2L2 + ∇w ε (t, ·) 2L2 ≤ σ˜ ε · w ε (t, ·) σ ε ε + R · w (t, ·) + w ε · ∇uεapp · w ε = I1 + I2 + I3 . ε
(94)
ε
• I1 satisfies ε |I1 | ≤ σ˜ ε L∞ −1/2 (ε )) w (t, ·) H 1/2 (ε ) t (H
≤ C1 ε ∇w ε (t, ·) L2 (ε ) ≤ C12 ε + ε ∇w ε (t, ·) 2L2 (ε ) . • Similarly, we get
(95)
|I2 | ≤ C2 ε + ε ∇w ε (t, ·) 2L2 .
• I3 is the most difficult to control, because the boundary layer part of uεapp has strong gradient. Indeed, ∇uεapp
=ε
−2
y x − χw (y) ∇w (y) uw t, y, , + higher order terms in ε, ε ε
where uw = ∇w (y)w . The worst term is then
y x − χw (y) ε −2 ∇w (y) uw t, y, , . J =ε ε ε ε Proceeding exactly as in [12, p. 1495], one obtains For φ ∞ small enough, |Jε | ≤
1 ∇wε (t, ·) 2L2 (ε ) , 2
which allows to absorb this term into the one coming from viscosity, and to conclude thanks to a Gronwall lemma. 4. Rough Topography 4.1. Formal Derivation. We try to build an approximate solution to system (2) in the following natural form: x y x y ζ ψapp = ψ 0 (t, x, y) + ζ ψ 1 (t, x, y, , ) + ζ 2 ψ 2 (t, x, y, , ) + . . . , ζ ζ ζ ζ
(96)
where ψ 0 describes the large scale circulation and the ψ i ’s, i ≥ 1 are correctors taking into account the effect of the rough topography, through the variables X, Y .
112
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
At order ζ −1 , we get the following equation on ψ 1 : ∂t X ψ 1 + u˜ 1 · ∇X X ψ 1 + u0 · ∇X X ψ 1 + u˜ 1 · ∇X ηB + rX ψ 1 − ν(X )2 ψ 1 + u0 · ∇X ηB = 0,
(97)
where u˜ 1 = ∇X⊥ ψ 1 , and u0 = ∇x⊥ ψ 0 . This last equation is of type (18), setting U := u0 := ψ 1 . and ψ We obtain the evolution equation on ψ 0 , by averaging in X, Y the equation at order ζ 0 . Note that the nonlinearity in (2) can be written (u = ∇ ⊥ ψ): ζ u · ∇ψ = ζ ∂y (div (u1 ⊗ u)) − ∂x (div (u2 ⊗ u)) . Thus, the largest nonlinear term with non-zero average appears at O(ζ ) only. We get ∂t x ψ 0 + β∂x ψ 0 + u0 · ∇x ηB + rx ψ 0 +∇X ηB · ∇x⊥ ψ 1 + ∇x ηB · ∇X⊥ ψ 1 = β curl τ, where the bar stands for the average in the rough variable X. Then, ∇X ηB · ∇x⊥ ψ˜ =
−∂X ηB ∂y ψ˜ + ∂Y ηB ∂x ψ˜
X,Y
ηB ∂y ∂X ψ˜ − ηB ∂x ∂Y ψ˜ = ∂x −ηB ∂Y ψ˜ + ∂y ηB ∂X ψ˜ X,Y X,Y + ∂x ηB ∂Y ψ˜ − ∂y ηB ∂X ψ˜ X,Y X,Y
˜ = curlx − ηB ∇X ψ˜ − ∇x ηB ∇X⊥ ψ, =
X,Y
X,Y
so that we recover the limit system (19).
4.2. The auxiliary systems. The aim of this section is to show that the systems formally derived above are well-posed. 4.2.1. Resolution of (18). In system (18), variables x, y are simply parameters, so that this system is very close to classical geostrophic equations. A simple Galerkin scheme leads to the existence and uniqueness of the solution ∈ L∞ (0, T ) × ; H 1 (Q) ∩ L2 0, T ; L∞ (; H 2 (Q) , ψ
T2
(t, ·) = 0. ψ
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
113
4.2.2. Dissipativity of F. We now prove Proposition 2.4. Let U ∈ (L∞ ((0, T ) × ))2 , and ψ˜ solution of (18). The dissipativity of F is equivalent to the inequality:
t ˜ − ηB ∇X ψ · U ≥ 0. (98) 0
X,Y
An integration by parts gives
˜ − ηB ∇ X ψ · U = X,Y
Now, we get from (18) that t ˜ ψ (∇X ηB · U ) = 0
X,Y
ψ˜ (∇X ηB · U ) .
(99)
X,Y
∂t 2 2 ˜ ˜ 2 r |∇X ψ| + ν |X ψ| + |∇X ψ| 2 X,Y X,Y X,Y 0 )X ψ + (u˜ · ∇X ψ )X ψ + (U · ∇X ψ t
X,Y
+ X,Y
X,Y
(−u˜ · ∇X ηB )ψ =
t 0
6
Ii .
(100)
i=1
t 1 ˜ ˜ ·)|2 ≥ 0. • As ψ(0, ·) ≡ 0, 0 I3 = |∇X ψ(t, 2 • We do not detail the treatment of I4 , I5 , I6 . Integrations by parts lead to I4 = I5 = . I6 = 0 using that U does not depend on X and u = ∇X⊥ ψ Thus, we obtain inequality (98), which ends the proof.
4.2.3. Resolution of (19). System (19) can be written curlx ∂t u0 + ∇x p 0 − (ηB + βy)(u0 )⊥ + ru0 + F(u0 ) = 0,
(101)
for any pressure p0 , so that it is a kind of “semilinear Euler equation”. Therefore, as we do not manage to control curlx F(u0 ) ∞ , it seems difficult to prove the existence of global solutions. Hence, we look for existence of local in time strong solutions. The only difficult point is to check that F behaves well with respect to functions in the space 2 L∞ (0, T ; H m (T2 )) , m > 1 = d2 . Once we have appropriate bounds on F, it is then routine to conclude through standard Galerkin or iterative schemes (see for instance [14] on classical Euler equations). 2 Let us fix M > 0, and set BT∞ (0, M) the ball of radius M in L∞ 0, T × T2 . We prove Proposition 4.1. Let m > 1. There exists T > 0, such that F sends BT∞ (0, M) ∩ 2 2 to L∞ 0, T ; H m (T2 ) , and is uniformly Lipschitzian on L∞ 0, T ; H m (T2 ) bounded subsets. Remark. Note that we have to look at a solution u0 in (L∞ ((0, T ) × ))2 in order to be able to pass to the limit in the nonlinear terms u1 · ∇X (X ψ 1 ) + u0 · ∇X (X ψ 1 ) which 1 are in the equation satisfied by ψ .
114
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
2 Remark. If u0 = ∇x⊥ ψ0 belongs to H m T2 ) , m > 1, and if we set M > u0 ∞ , Proposition 4.1 above allows us to build a solution in short time to (19), with u0 as initial data. Proof of Proposition 4.1. This proof relies on two lemmas. The first one is a generalization of the classical Schauder’s lemma about the behaviour of F (u) for u ∈ H m and F a smooth function (cf. [16]). Lemma 4.2. Let F be a C ∞ function from U ∈ (L∞ (0, T ))2 , U ∞ < M to (L∞ (0, T ))2 , such that F and its derivatives send bounded sets to bounded sets. Then F 2 2 to L∞ 0, T ; H m T2 , and is uniformly sends BT∞ (0, M)∩ L∞ 0, T ; H m T2 Lipschitzian on bounded subsets. The proof of this lemma is a straightforward adaptation of the proof of Schauder’s lemma [16]. For the sake of brevity, we skip it and refer to [16] for all necessary details. Let U ∈ (L∞ (0, T ))2 . We define G(U ) as the solution = (t, X, Y ) of ∂ + u · ∇X (X ) + U · ∇X (X ) + u · ∇X ηB + rX t X − ν (X )2 + U · ∇X ηB = 0, u = ∇X⊥ = (−∂Y , ∂X ).
(102)
As already mentioned in the proof of Theorem 2.3, such a system has a unique weak solution in the space E := L∞ 0, T ; H 1 (Q) ∩ L2 0, T ; H 2 (Q) , so that G is well defined as a function from (L∞ (0, T ))2 to E. The link between G and our functional F is made through the relation
ηB ∇X G u0 (·, x, y) (t, X, Y ) dX dY.
F(u )(t, x, y) = − 0
(103)
X,Y
Proposition 4.1 is then a direct consequence of Lemma 4.2 and of the following Lemma 4.3. There exists T > 0 such that G is a C ∞ function from u ∈ (L∞ (0, T ))2 , u ∞ < M to E. Moreover, G and its derivatives send bounded sets to bounded sets. Remark. This lemma can be seen as a result of smooth dependence on parameters for 2D Navier-Stokes equations. Proof of Lemma 4.3. We divide this proof into two parts
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
115
First part. We introduce an auxiliary function. Let T > 0. We define H : (L∞ (0, T ))2 × E × E → E, by: H(U, α, f ) is the solution of ∂ + U · ∇X (X ) + u · ∇X (X α) t X + u · ∇X ηB + rX − ν (X )2 = f, u = ∇X⊥ = (−∂Y , ∂X ).
(104)
We show that H is a smooth function and that each of its derivatives sends bounded sets to bounded sets. • Let t > 0. Multiplying by 1[0,t] and integrating both over Q and from 0 to t leads to the estimate ∇X (t, ·) 2L2
X
2
t
+r 0
∇(s, ·) 2L2 + ν X
t 0
X (s, ·) 2L2 = − f, 1[0,t] E ,E . X
(105) Hence, ∇X (t, ·) 2L2
X
2
t t ∇X (s, ·) 2L2 + ν X (s, ·) 2L2 +r X X 0 0
t
≤ C1 f E 0
1/2
X (t, ·) 2L2 X
+
sup ∇X (s, ·) L2
. (106)
X
0≤s≤t
Thus ∇X (t, ·) 2L2
X
2
t
+r 0
ν ∇(s, ·) 2L2 + X 2
≤ C2 f 2E + C1 f E
0
t
X (s, ·) 2L2 X
sup ∇X (s, ·) L2
X
0≤s≤t
(107)
.
Applying the last inequality for t from 0 to T yields sup 0≤t≤T
∇X (t, ·) 2L2
X
2
≤ C2 f 2E + C1 f E
sup ∇X (t, ·) L2
0≤t≤T
≤ C2 f 2E + C3 f 2E +
X
1 sup ∇X (t, ·) 2L2 . (108) X 4 0≤t≤T
Finally, we obtain H(U, α, f ) 2E ≤ C f 2E , where 2E = 2L∞ (0,T ;H 1 (Q)) + 2L2 (0,T ;H 2 (Q)) .
(109)
116
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
• We may now show that H is a smooth function. For two elements (U, α, f ) and (U˜ , α, ˜ f˜) in the domain of H, we set = H(U˜ , α, − , = H(U, α, f ), ˜ f˜), χ = V = U˜ − U, b = α˜ − α, g = f˜ − f.
(110)
It is then straightforward to see that χ = H(U˜ , α, F ), where · ∇X (X b) + g. F = −V · ∇X (X ) − ∇X⊥ · ∇X (X b) belong to E . First, for all φ ∈ E, Note that both V · ∇X (X ) and ∇X⊥ we have T T V · ∇X (X ) φ = V · ∇X φ (X ) 0
0
Q
Q
≤ V L∞ (0,T ) ∇φ L2 (0,T ×) (X ) L2 (0,T ×) ≤ C V L∞ (0,T ) E φ E . The other term is treated in the following way: T T ⊥ ⊥ ∇X · ∇X (X b) φ = ∇X · ∇X φ (X b) 0
0
Q
Q
· ∇X φ L2 (0,T ×) . ≤ X b L2 (0,T ×) ∇X⊥ Besides, · ∇X φ 2 2 ∇X⊥ ≤ L (0,T ×)
T 0
|2 |∇X φ|2 |∇X
Q T
≤
0
(t, ·) 2 4 ∇X φ(t, ·) 2 4 . ∇X L L
The Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequality yields T · ∇X φ 2 2 (t, ·) ∇X⊥ ≤ ∇X L (0,T ×) 0
(t, ·) L2 ∇X φ(t, ·) L2 X φ(t, ·) L2 × L2 X L∞ (0,T ;L2 ) X L2 (0,T ;L2 ) ∇X φ L∞ (0,T ;L2 ) X φ L2 (0,T ;L2 ) . ≤ ∇X Thus, we get
0
T
Q
· ∇X (X b) φ ≤ E b E φ E . ∇X⊥
(111)
Finally, V · ∇X (X ) E ≤ V L∞ (0,T ) E ,
· ∇X (X b) E ≤ E b E . ∇X⊥ (112)
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
117
Using estimates (109), (112), we deduce H(U˜ , α, ˜ f˜) − H(U, α, f ) 2 ≤ C V 2 + b 2 + g 2 ,
(113)
where · stands for the various appropriate norms. Thus, function H is lipschitzian and sends bounded sets to bounded sets. One checks easily that we may also write χ = H(U, α, F1 ) + H(U, α, F2 ),
(114)
where F1 = −∇ ⊥ · ∇X (X b) − V · ∇X (X ) + g, F2 = −∇ ⊥ χ · ∇X (X b) − V · ∇X (X χ ). Note that we have used the linearity of H in its last variable. Thanks to estimates (109) and (113) we have H(U, α, F2 ) = O( V 2 + b 2 + g 2 ). We have thus proved that H is differentiable and formula dH (U, α, f ) (V , b, g) = H(U, α, F1 ). If we introduce the (smooth) bilinear application Q and linear application L respectively defined by: Q (, (V , b, g)) = −∇ ⊥ · ∇X (X b) − V · ∇X (X ), L (V , b, g) = g, we have the relation dH (U, α, f ) (·) = H U, α, Q (H(U, α, f ), ·) + L (·) .
(115)
Thanks to this last relation, one can use a bootstrap argument, show that H is smooth, and that each of its derivatives sends bounded sets to bounded sets. Second part. We link G to H. We first note the identity G(U ) = H(U, G(U ), −U · ∇X ηB ). Thus, to prove that G(U ) is smooth (for T small enough), and that all its derivatives send bounded sets to bounded sets, it is enough to prove, for all U , the invertibility of the derivative of the function K : α −→ α − H(U, α, −U · ∇X ηB ). Using (115) leads to dK[α](·) = I d − H(U, α, B(, ·)), where
B(, b) = −∇ ⊥ · ∇X (X b),
= H(U, α, −U · ∇X ηB ).
118
D. Bresch, D. G´erard-Varet
Bounds (109) and (112) yield |||H(U, α, B(, ·))||| ≤ E . In the same spirit as (109), one can prove easily that 2E ≤ C |U |2 ηB 2L2 (Q) T , so that |||H(U, α, B(, ·))||| ≤
√
CM ηB L2 (Q)
√
T.
√ √ Thus, if CM ηB L2 (Q) T < 1, then dK[α] is invertible, which ends the proof of the proposition.
4.3. Convergence results. As usual, on the basis of the previous analysis, one can conζ ζ struct an approximate solution uζapp = ∇x⊥ ψapp , where ψapp is given by (96). Theorem ζ
2.6 then follows from an energy estimate on v = uζ − uapp . Note that uζapp ≈ ∇x⊥ ψ 0 + ∇X 1 ,
∇x uζapp ≈
1 2 1 ∇ , ζ X
so that we have the following bound on the nonlinear term ζ v · ∇x uζapp (t, ·) L2x ≤ C v L2x . All other terms are easy to handle, so that we do not give further details. Acknowledgements. This work has been partially supported by the GDR “Amplitude Equations and Qualitative Properties” (GDR CNRS 2103: EAQP) and by the IDOPT project in Grenoble.
References 1. Barcilon, V., Constantin, P., Titi, E.S.: Existence of solutions to the Stommel-Charney model of the Gulf Stream. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 19(6), 1355–1364 (1988) 2. Blayo, E., Verron, J.: The no slip condition and separation of western boundary currents. J. Phys. Oceanography 26, 1938–1951 (1995) 3. Bougeault, P., Sadourny, R.: Dynamique de l’atmosph`ere et de l’oc´ean. Palaiseau: Editions de l’Ecole Polytechnique, 2001
Roughness-Induced Effects on the Quasi-geostrophic Model
119
4. Bresch, D., Colin, T.: Some remarks on the derivation of the Sverdrup relation. J. Math. Fluid Mech. 4(2), 95–108 2002 5. Bresch, D., Desjardins, B.: Existence of global weak solutions for 2D viscous shallow water equations and convergence to the quasi-geostrophic model. Commun. Math. Phys. 238, 211–223 (2003) 6. Bresch, D., Guillen-Gonzalez, F., Rodr´ıguez-Bellido, M.A.: A corrector for the Sverdrup solution for a domain with islands. Applicable Anal. 83(3), 217–230 (2004) 7. Colin, T.: Remarks on a homogeneous model of ocean circulation. Asymptotic Anal. 12(2), 153–168 (1996) 8. Colin. T.: Mod`eles stratifi´es en m´ecanique des fluides g´eophysiques. Ann. Math. Blaise-Pascal 2, 229–243 (2002) 9. Constantin, P., Wu, J.: Behavior of solutions of 2D quasi-geostrophic equations. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 30(5), 937–948 (1999) (electronic) 10. Desjardins, B., Grenier, E.: On the homogeneous model of wind-driven ocean circulation. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 60(1), 43–60 (2000) (electronic) 11. Galdi, G.P.: An introduction to the mathematical theory of the Navier-Stokes equations. Vol. I, Vol. 38 of Springer Tracts in Natural Philosophy. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1994. Linearized steady problems 12. G´erard-Varet, D.: Highly rotating fluids in rough domains. J. Math. Pures Appl. 82(11), 1457–1498 (2003) 13. J¨ager, W., Mikeli´c, A.: On the roughness-induced effective boundary conditions for an incompressible viscous flow. J. Differ. Eqs. 170(1), 96–122 (2001) 14. Marchioro, C., Pulvirenti, M.: Mathematical theory of incompressible nonviscous fluids. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer Verlag, 1994 15. Pedlosky, J.:Geophysical fluid dynamics. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer Verlag, 1979 16. Rauch, J., Keel, M.: Lectures on geometric optics. In: Hyperbolic equations and frequency interactions (Park City UT 1995), Vol. 5 of IAS/Park City Math. Ser. Providence, RI: Am. Math. Soc. 1999, pp. 383–466 17. Vanneste, J.: Enhanced dissipation for quasi-geostrophic motion over small-scaletopography. J. Fluid. Mech. 407, 105–122 (2000) 18. Vanneste, J.: Nonlinear dynamics over rough topography: barotropic andstratified quasi-geostrophic theory. J. Fluid. Mech. 474, 299–318 (2003) Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 253, 121–155 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-004-1175-7
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Poisson Geometrical Symmetries Associated to Non-Commutative Formal Diffeomorphisms Fabio Gavarini Dipartimento di Matematica, Universit`a degli Studi di Roma “Tor Vergata”, Via della Ricerca Scientifica 1, 00133 Roma, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 14 September 2003 / Accepted: 20 April 2004 Published online: 5 November 2004 – © Springer-Verlag 2004
Abstract: Let G dif be the group of all formal power series starting with x with coeffi cients in a field k of zero characteristic (with the composition product), and let F G dif be its function algebra. In [BF] a non-commutative, non-cocommutative graded Hopf algebra Hdif was introduced via a direct process of “disabelianisation” of F G dif , taking the like presentation of the latter as an algebra but dropping the commutativity constraint. In this paper we apply a general method to provide four one-parameter deformations of Hdif , which are quantum groups whose semiclassical limits are Poisson geometrical symmetries such as Poisson groups or Lie bialgebras, namely two quantum function algebras and two quantum universal enveloping algebras. In particular the two Poisson groups are extensions of G dif , isomorphic as proalgebraic Poisson varieties but not as proalgebraic groups. A series of outlaws joined and formed the Nottingham group, whose renowned chieftain was the famous Robin Hopf N. Barbecue, “Robin Hopf” Introduction The most general notion of “symmetry” in mathematics is encoded in the notion of Hopf algebra. Then, among all Hopf algebras (over a field k), there are two special families which are of relevant interest for their geometrical meaning: assuming for simplicity that k have zero characteristic, these are the function algebras F [G] of algebraic groups G and the universal enveloping algebras U (g) of Lie algebras g. Function algebras are exactly those Hopf algebras which are commutative, and enveloping algebras those which are connected (in the general sense of Hopf algebra theory) and cocommutative. Given a Hopf algebra H , encoding some generalized symmetry, one can ask whether there are any other Hopf algebras “close” to H , which are of either one of the above mentioned geometrical types, hence encoding geometrical symmetries associated to H .
122
F. Gavarini
The answer is affirmative: namely (see [Ga4]), it is possible to give functorial recipes to get out of any Hopfalgebra H twopairs of Hopf algebras of geometrical type, say F [G+ ], U (g− ) and F [K+ ], U (k− ) . Moreover, the algebraic groups thus obtained are connected Poisson groups, and the Lie algebras are Lie bialgebras; therefore in both cases Poisson geometry is involved. In addition, the two pairs above are related to each other by Poisson duality (see below), thus only either one of them is truly relevant. Finally, these four “geometrical” Hopf algebras are “close” to H in that they are 1-parameter deformations (with pairwise isomorphic fibers) of a quotient or a subalgebra of H. The method above to associate Poisson geometrical Hopf algebras to general Hopf algebras, called “Crystal Duality Principle” (CDP in short), is explained in detail in [Ga4]. It is a special instance of a more general result, the “Global Quantum Duality Principle” (GQDP in short), explained in [Ga2, Ga3], which in turn is a generalization of the “Quantum Duality Principle” due to Drinfeld (cf. [Dr], §7, and see [Ga1] for a proof). Drinfeld’s QDP deals with quantum universal enveloping algebras (QUEAs in short) and quantum formal series Hopf algebras (QFSHAs in short) over the ring of formal power series k[[]]. A QUEA is any topologically free, topological Hopf k[[]]–algebra whose quotient modulo is the universal enveloping algebra U (g) of some Lie algebra g; in this case we denote the QUEA by U (g). Instead, a QFSHA is any topological Hopf k[[]]–algebra of type k[[]]S (as a k[[]]–module, S being a set) whose quotient modulo is the function algebra F [[G]] of some formal algebraic group G; then we denote the QFSHA by F [[G]]. The QDP claims that the category of all QUEAs and the category of all QFSHAs are equivalent, and provides an equivalence in either direction. From QFSHAs to QUEAs it goes as follows: given a QFSHA, say F [[G]], let J be its augmentation ideal (the kernel of its counit map) and set Fh [[G]]∨ := n≥0 −n J n . Then F [[G]] → Fh [[G]]∨ defines (on objects) a functor from QFSHAs to QUEAs. To go the other way round, i.e. from QUEAs to QFSHAs, one uses a perfectly dual recipe. Namely, given a QUEA, say U (g), let again J be its augmentation ideal; for each n ∈ N, let δn be the composition ⊗n of the n–fold iterated coproduct followed by the projection J makes n (this ⊗n sense onto −1 since U (g) = k[[]]·1U (g) ⊕ J ): then set U (g) := n≥0 δn U (g) , or more explicitly U (g) := η ∈ U (g)δn (η) ∈ n U (g)⊗n , ∀n ∈ N . Then U (g) → U (g) defines (on objects) a functor from QUEAs to QFSHAs. The functors ( )∨ and ( ) are inverse to each other, hence they provide the claimed equivalence. Note that the objects (QUEAs and QFSHAs) involved in the QDP are quantum groups; their semiclassical limits then are endowed with Poisson structures: namely, every U (g) is in fact a co-Poisson Hopf algebra and every F [[G]] is a (topological) Poisson Hopf algebra. The geometrical structures they describe are then Lie bialgebras and Poisson groups. The QDP then brings further information: namely, the semiclassical limit of the image of a given quantum group is Poisson dual to the Poisson geometrical object we start from. In short
Fh [[G]]∨ Fh [[G]]∨ = U (g× ),
i.e. (roughly)
Fh [[G]]∨ = U (g× ), (I.1)
where g× is the cotangent Lie bialgebra of the Poisson group G, and
U (g) U (g) = F G ,
i.e. (roughly)
U (g) = F G ,
(I.2)
Poisson Symmetries Associated to Non-Commutative Diffeomorphisms
123
where G is a connected Poisson group with cotangent Lie bialgebra g. So the QDP involves both Hopf duality (switching enveloping and function algebras) and Poisson duality. The generalization from QDP to GQDP stems from a simple observation: the construction of Drinfeld’s functors needs not to start from quantum groups! Indeed, in order to define either H ∨ or H one only needs that H be a torsion-free Hopf algebra over some 1-dimensional domain R and ∈ R be any non-zero prime (actually, even less is truly necessary, see [Ga2, Ga3]). On the other hand, the outcome still is, in both cases, a “quantum group”, now meant in a new sense. Namely, a QUEA now will be any torsion-free Hopf algebra H over R such that H H ∼ = U (g), for some Lie (bi)algebra g. Also, instead of QFSHAs we consider “quantum function algebras”,QFAs in short: here a QFA will be any torsion-free Hopf algebra H over R such that H H ∼ = F [G] (plus one additional technical condition) for some connected (Poisson) group G. In this new framework Drinfeld’s recipes give that H ∨ is a QUEA and H is a QFA, whatever is the torsion-free Hopf R–algebra H one starts from. Moreover, when restricted to quantum groups Drinfeld’s functors ( )∨ and ( ) again provide equivalences of quantum group categories, respectively from QFAs to QUEAs and vice versa; then Poisson duality is involved once more, like in (I.1–2). Therefore, the generalization process from the QDP to the GQDP spreads over several concerns. Arithmetically, one can take as () any non-generic point of the spectrum of R, and define Drinfeld’s functors and specializations accordingly; in particular, the corresponding quotient field k := R/R might have positive characteristic. Geometrically, one considers algebraic groups rather than formal groups, i.e. global vs. local objects. Algebraically, one drops any topological worry (–adic completeness, etc.), and deals with general Hopf algebras rather than with quantum groups. This last point is the one of most concern to us now, in that it means that we have (functorial) recipes to get several quantum groups, hence – taking semiclassical limits – Poisson geometrical symmetries, springing out of the “generalized symmetry” encoded by a torsion-free Hopf algebra H over R: namely, for each non-trivial point of the spectrum of R, the quantum groups H ∨ and H given by the corresponding Drinfeld’s functors. Note, however, that a priori nothing prevents any of these H ∨ or H or their semiclassical limits from being (essentially) trivial. The CDP comes out when looking at Hopf algebras over a field k, and then applying the GQDP to their scalar extensions H [] := k[] ⊗k H with R := k[] (and := itself). A first application of Drinfeld’s functors to H := H [] followed by specialization at = 0 provides the pair F [G ], U (g ) mentioned above: in a nutshell, + − ∨ , where hereafter X F [G+ ], U (g− ) = H , H := X X. Then =0
=0
=0
at = 0 applying once more Drinfeld’s functors to H∨ and to H and specializing ∨ ∨ . yields the pair F [K+ ], U (k− ) , namely F [K+ ], U (k− ) = H , H =0
=0
Finally, the very last part of the GQDP explained before implies that K+ = G− and k− = g× +. While in the second step above one really needs the full strength of the GQDP, for the first step instead it turns out that the construction of Drinfeld’s functors on H [] can be fully “tracked through” and described at the “classical level”, i.e. in terms of H alone. In addition, the exact relationship among H and the pair F [G+ ], U (g− ) can be made quite clear, and more information is available about this pair. We now sketch it in some detail.
124
F. Gavarini
Let J be the augmentation ideal of H , let J := J n n∈N be the associated (decreas := GJ (H ) the associated graded vector space and H ∨ := ing) J –adic filtration, H n H n∈N J . One can prove that J is a Hopf algebra filtration, hence H is a graded ∼ Hopf algebra. The latter happens to be connected and cocommutative, so H = U (g− ) for some Lie algebra g− ; in addition, since H is graded also g− itself is graded as a Lie is cocommutative allows to define on it a Poisson cobracket algebra. The fact that H which makes H into a graded co-Poisson Hopf algebra; eventually, this implies that g− . is a Lie bialgebra. The outcome is that our U (g− ) is just H On the other hand, one considers a second (increasing) filtration defined in a dual := GD (H ) be the manner to J , namely D := Dn := Ker(δn+1 ) n∈N . Let now H associated graded vector space and H := n∈N Dn . Again, one shows that D is a Hopf is a graded Hopf algebra. Moreover, the latter is commutative, algebra filtration, hence H = F [G+ ] for some algebraic group G+ . One proves also that H = F [G+ ] has so H is graded, G+ no non-trivial idempotents, thus G+ is connected; in addition, since H as a variety is just an affine space. The fact that H is commutative allows to define on it into a graded Poisson Hopf algebra: this means that a Poisson bracket which makes H . G+ is an algebraic Poisson group. Thus eventually F [G+ ] is just H and H can be The relationship among H and the “geometrical” Hopf algebras H expressed in terms of “reduction steps” and regular 1-parameter deformations, namely 1←→0 0←→1 ←−−−−−−−→ , H H −−→ H −− H ∨ ←−−−−−−−→ H
R D (H )
∨ R J (H )
(I.3)
where one-way arrows are Hopf algebra morphisms and two-way arrows are regular 1-parameter deformations of Hopf algebras, realized through the Rees Hopf algebras RD (H ) and RJ (H ∨ ) associated to the filtration D of H and to the filtration J of H ∨ . Hereafter “regular” for a deformation means that all its fibers are pairwise isomorphic as vector spaces. In classical terms, (I.3) comes directly from the construction above; (H ) = H and on the other hand, in terms of the GQDP it comes from the fact that RD
RJ (H ∨ ) = H∨ . As we mentioned above, the next step is the “application” of (suitable) Drinfeld functors to the Rees algebras RD (H ) = H and RJ (H ∨ ) = H∨ occurring in (I.3). The outcome is a second frame of regular 1-parameter deformations for H and H ∨ , namely 0←→1 1←→0 U g× H −→ H −− H ∨ ←−−−−−−−→ F [K+ ] = F G− + = U (k− ) ←−−−−−−−→ ∨ ∨ (H )
(I.4)
(H )
which is the analogue of (I.3). In particular, when H ∨ = H = H from (I.3) and (I.4) together we find H as the mid-point of four deformation families, whose “external points” are Hopf algebras of “Poisson geometrical” type, namely 0←→1 1←→0 U (g− ) ←−−−−−−−−→ H F G− ←−−−−−−−−→ H∨ (H∨ ) () × 0←→1 1←→0 F [G+ ] ←−−−−−−−−→ H ←−−−−−−−−→ U g+ H
(H )∨
which gives four different regular 1-parameter deformations from H to Hopf algebras encoding Poisson geometrical objects. Then each of these four Hopf algebras may be
Poisson Symmetries Associated to Non-Commutative Diffeomorphisms
125
thought of as a semiclassical geometrical counterpart of the “generalized symmetry” encoded by H . The purpose of the present paper is to show the effectiveness of the CDP, applying it to a key example, the Hopf algebra of non-commutative formal diffeomorphisms of the line. Indeed, the interest of the latter, besides its own reasons, grows bigger as we can see it as a toy model for a broad family of Hopf algebras of great concern in mathematical physics, non-commutative geometry and beyond. Now I present the results of this paper. Let G dif be the set of all formal power series starting with x with coefficients in a field k of zero characteristic. Endowed with the composition product, this is an infinite dimensional prounipotent proalgebraic group – known as the “(normalised) Nottingham group” among group-theorists and the “(normalised) group of formal diffeomorphisms of the line” among mathematical physicists – whose tangent Lie algebra is a special subalgebra of the one-sided Witt algebra. The function algebra F G dif is a graded, commutative Hopf algebra with countably many generators, which admits a neat combinatorial description. In [BF] a non-commutative version of F G dif is introduced: this is a non-commu tative non-cocommutative Hopf algebra Hdif which is presented exactly like F G dif but dropping commutativity, i.e. taking the presentation as one of a unital associative dif – and not outcome of applying to commutative – algebra; in other words, H is the dif dif a raw “disabelianization” process. In particular, H = H is graded and verifies F G H ∨ = H = H , hence the scheme () makes sense and yields four Poisson symmetries associated to Hdif . Note that in each line in () there is essentially only one Poisson geometry involved, since Poisson duality relates mutually opposite sides; thus any classical symmetry on the same line carries as much information as the other one (but for global-to-local differences). Nevertheless, in the case of H = Hdif we shall prove that the pieces of information from either line in () are complementary, because G+ and G− happen to be isomorphic as proalgebraic Poisson varieties but not as groups. In particular, we find that the Lie bialgebras g− and g× + are both isomorphic as Lie algebras to the free Lie algebra L(N+ ) over a countable set, but they have different, non-isomorphic Lie coalgebra structures. Moreover, G− ∼ = G+ as Poisson varieties, where N = G dif × N ∼ is a proaffine Poisson variety whose coordinate functions are in bijection with a basis of the derived subalgebra L(N+ ); indeed, the latter are obtained byiterated Poisson brackets of coordinate functions on G dif , in short because both F G− and F G+ are dif freely generated as Poisson algebras by a copy of F G . For G− we have a more precise result, namely G− ∼ = G dif N (a semidirect product) as proalgebraic groups: thus in a sense G− is the free Poisson group over G dif , which geometrically speaking is obtained by “pasting” to G dif all 1-parameter subgroups freely obtained via iterated Poisson brackets of those of G dif ; in particular, these Poisson brackets iteratively yield 1-parameter subgroups which generate N . We perform the same analysis simultaneously for G dif , for its subgroup of odd formal diffeomorphisms and for all the groups Gν of truncated (at order ν ∈ N+ ) formal diffeomorphisms, whose projective limit is G dif itself; mutatis mutandis, the results are the same. The case of Hdif is just one of many samples of the same type: indeed, several cases of Hopf algebras built out of combinatorial data – graphs, trees, Feynman diagrams, etc. – have been introduced in (co)homological theories (see e.g. [LR] and [Fo1, Fo2], and references therein) and in renormalization studies (see [CK1, CK2, CK3]); in most cases these algebras – or their (graded) duals – are commutative polynomial, like F G dif ,
126
F. Gavarini
and admit non-commutative analogues (thanks to [Fo1, Fo2]), so our discussion applies almost verbatim to them too, with like results. Thus the given analysis of the “toy model” Hopf algebra Hdif can be taken as a general pattern for all those cases.
1. Notation and Terminology 1.1. The classical zero characteristic. Consider the set data. Let k be a fixed field of G dif := x + n≥1 an x n+1 an ∈ k∀n ∈ N+ of all formal series starting with x: endowed with the composition product, this is a group, which can be seen as the group of all “formal diffeomorphisms” f : k −→ k such that f (0) = 0 and f (0) = 1 (i.e. tangent to the identity), also known as the Nottingham group (see, e.g., [Ca] and references dif therein). In fact, Gdif is an infinite dimensional (pro)affine algebraic group, whose function algebra F G is generated by the coordinate functions an (n ∈ N+ ). Giving to each an the weight1 ∂(an ) := n, we have that F G dif is an N–graded Hopf algebra, dif with polynomial structure F G = k[a1 , a2 , . . . , an , . . . ] and Hopf algebra structure given by
(an ) = an ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ an +
n−1
am ⊗ Q m n−m (a∗ ),
(an ) = 0,
m=1 n−1
S(an ) = −an −
n−1 am S Q m (a ) = −a − S(am )Qm n n−m ∗ n−m (a∗ ),
m=1
where Q t (a∗ ) :=
t k=1
+1
m=1
k
(k)
(k)
Pt (a∗ ) and Pt (a∗ ) :=
j1 ,...,jk >0 aj1 j1 +···+jk =t
· · · ajk (the
symmetric monic polynomial of weight m and degree k in the indeterminates aj ’s) for all m, k, ∈ N+ , and the formula for S(an ) gives the antipode by recursion. From now on, to simplify notation we shall write G := G dif and G∞ := G = G dif . Note also that the tangent Lie algebra of G dif is just the Lie subalgebra W1≥1 = Span {dn |n ∈ N+ } of d the one-sided Witt algebra W1 := Der k[t] = Span dn := t n+1 dt n ∈ N ∪ {−1} . ν In addition, for all ν ∈ N+ the subset G := f ∈ G an (f ) =0, ∀n ≤ ν is a normal subgroup of G; the corresponding quotient group Gν := G G ν is unipotent, with dimension ν and function algebra F Gν (isomorphic to) the Hopf subalgebra of F G generated by a1 , . . . , aν . In fact, the G ν ’s form exactly the lower central series of G (cf. [Je]). Moreover, G is (isomorphic to) the inverse (or projective) limit of these quotient groups Gν (ν ∈ N+ ), hence G is pro-unipotent; conversely, F [G] is the direct (or inductive) limit of the direct system of its graded Hopf subalgebras F [Gν ] (ν ∈ N+ ). Finally, the set G odd := f ∈ G dif a2n−1 (f ) = 0∀n ∈ N+ is another normal subgroup of G dif (the group of odd formal diffeomorphisms2 after [CK3]), whose function alge odd dif bra F G is (isomorphic to) the quotient Hopf algebra F G a2n−1 n∈N . The +
1
We say weight instead of degree because we save the latter term for the degree of polynomials. The fixed-point set of the group homomorphism : G → G , f → (f ) x → (f ) (x) := −f (−x) . 2
Poisson Symmetries Associated to Non-Commutative Diffeomorphisms
127
latter has the following denoting again the cosets of the a2n ’s with the like description: symbol, we have F G odd = k[a2 , a4 , . . . , a2n , . . . ] with Hopf algebra structure (a2n ) = a2n ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ a2n +
n−1
¯m a2m ⊗ Q n−m (a2∗ ),
(a2n ) = 0,
m=1
S(a2n ) = −a2n −
n−1
n−1 m ¯ n−m (a∗ ) = −a2n − ¯m a2m S Q S(a2m )Q n−m (a2∗ ),
m=1
¯ t (a2∗ ) := where Q
t k=1
m=1
2 +1 k
(k) (k) P¯t (a2∗ ) and P¯t (a2∗ ) :=
j1 ,...,jk >0 j1 +···+jk =t
a2j1 · · · a2jk
for all m, k, ∈ N+ . For each ν ∈ N+ we can consider also the normal subgroup odd G ν ∩ G odd : then F G odd is G ν ∩ G odd and the corresponding quotient Gνodd := G ν
a2n−1 (2n−1)∈N , in particular (isomorphic to) the quotient Hopf algebra F G odd ν it is the Hopf sub-algebra of F G odd generated by a2 , . . . , a2[ν/2] . All the F Gνodd ’s odd are graded Hopf (sub)algebras forming a direct system with direct limit F G ; conodd odd versely, the Gν ’s form an inverse system with inverse limit G . In the sequel we write G + := G odd and Gν+ := Gνodd . For each ν ∈ N+ , set Nν := {1, . . . , ν}; set also N∞ := N+ . For each ν ∈ N+ ∪ {∞}, let Lν = L(Nν ) be the free Lie algebra over k generated by {xn }n∈Nν and let Uν = U (Lν ) be its universal enveloping algebra; let also Vν = V (Nν ) be the k–vector space with basis {xn }n∈Nν , and let Tν = T (Vν ) be its associated tensor algebra. Then there are canonical identifications U (Lν ) = T (Vν ) = k {xn |n ∈ Nν } , the latter being the unital k–algebra of non-commutative polynomials in the set of indeterminates {xn }n∈Nν , and Lν is just the Lie subalgebra of Uν = Tν generated by {xn }n∈Nν . Moreover, Lν has a basis Bν made of Lie monomials in the xn ’s (n ∈ Nν ), like [xn1 , xn2 ], [[xn1 , xn2 ], xn3 ], [[[xn1 , xn2 ], xn3 ], xn4 ], etc.: details can be found e.g. in [Re], Ch. 4–5. In the sequel I shall use these identifications with no further mention. We consider on U (Lν ) the standard Hopf algebra structure given by (x) = x ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ x, (x) = 0, S(x) = −x for all x ∈ Lν , which is also determined by the same formulas for x ∈ {xn }n∈Nν alone. By construction ν ≤ µ implies Lν ⊆ Lµ , whence the Lν ’s form a direct system (of Lie algebras) whose direct limit is exactly L∞ ; similarly, U (L∞ ) is the direct limit of all the U (Lν )’s. Finally, with Bν we shall mean the obvious PBW-like basis of U (Lν ) w.r.t. some fixed total order of B , namely B := xb b = b1 · · · bk ; b1 , . . . , bk ∈ ν ν Bν ; b1 · · · bk . The same construction applies to make out “odd” objects, based + + on {xn }n∈N+ν , with N+ ν := Nν ∩ 2N (ν ∈ N ∪ {∞}), instead of {xn }n∈Nν, Lν = L(Nν ), + + + + + + Uν = U (Lν ), Vν = V (Nν ), Tν = T (V identifica ν ), with the+obvious canonical + + + tions U (L+ ν ) = T (Vν ) = k {xn |n ∈ Nν } ; moreover, Lν has a basis Bν made of Lie + monomials in the xn ’s (n ∈ N+ ν ), etc. The Lν ’s form a direct system whose direct limit + ) is the direct limit of all the U (L+ )’s. is L+ , and U (L ∞ ν ∞ Warning. In the sequel, we shall often deal with subsets {yb }b∈Bν (of some algebra) in bijection with Bν , the fixed basis of Lν . Then we shall write things like yλ with λ ∈ Lν : this means we extend the bijection {yb }b∈Bν ∼ Bν to Span {yb }b∈Bν ∼ = = Lν by linearity, so that yλ ∼ = b∈Bν cb b iff λ = b∈Bν cb b (cb ∈ k). The same kind of convention will be applied with Bν+ instead of Bν and L+ ν instead of Lν .
128
F. Gavarini
1.2. The noncommutative Hopf algebra of formal diffeomorphisms. For all ν ∈ N+ ∪ {∞}, let Hν be the Hopf k–algebra given as follows: as a k–algebra it is simply Hν := k {an |n ∈ Nν } (the k–algebra of non-commutative polynomials in the set of indeterminates {an }n∈Nν ), and its Hopf algebra structure is given by (for all n ∈ Nν ) (an ) = an ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ an +
n−1
am ⊗ Q m n−m (a∗ ),
(an ) = 0,
m=1
S(an ) = −an −
n−1
n−1 am S Q m (a ) = −a − S(am )Qm ∗ n n−m n−m (a∗ ),
m=1
(1.1)
m=1
(notation like in §1.1) where the latter formula yields the antipode by recursion. Moreover, Hν is in fact an N–graded Hopf algebra, once generators have been given degree – in the sequel called weight – by the rule ∂(an ) := n (for all n ∈ Nν ). By construction the various Hν ’s (for all ν ∈ N+ ) form a direct system, whose direct limit is H∞ : the latter was originally introduced3 in [BF], §5.1 (with k = C), under the name Hdif . + Similarly, for all ν ∈ N+ ∪ {∞} we set Kν := k {an |n ∈ N+ ν } (where Nν := + Nν ∩ (2N)): this bears a Hopf algebra structure given by (for all 2n ∈ Nν ) (a2n ) = a2n ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ a2n +
n−1
¯m a2m ⊗ Q n−m (a2∗ ),
(a2n ) = 0,
m=1
S(a2n ) = −a2n −
n−1 m=1
n−1 m ¯ n−m (a2∗ ) = −a2n − a2m S Q S(a2m )Qm n−m (a2∗ ) m=1
(notation of §1.1). Indeed, this is an N–graded Hopf algebra where generators have degree – called weight – given by ∂(an ) := n (for all n ∈ N+ ν ). All the Kν ’s form a direct system with direct limit K∞ . Finally, for each ν ∈ N+ ν there is a graded Hopf algebra epimorphism Hν −− Kν given by a2n → a2n , a2m+1 → 0 for all 2n, 2m + 1 ∈ Nν . Definitions and §1.1 imply that
Hν ab := Hν via an → an ∀n ∈ Nν Hν , Hν ∼ = F Gν , as N–graded Hopf algebras: in other words, the abelianization of Hν is nothing but F Gν . Thus in a sense one can think of Hν as a non-commutative version (indeed, the “coarsest” one) of F Gν , hence as a “quantization” of Gν itself: however, this is not a quantization in the usual sense, because F Gν is attained through abelianization, not via specialization of some deformation parameter. Similarly we have also
Kν ab := Kν Kν , Kν ∼ via a2n → a2n ∀2n ∈ N+ = F Gν+ , ν as N–graded Hopf algebras: in other words, the abelianization of Kν is just F Gν+ . In the following I make the analysis explicit for Hν , the case Kν being the same (details are left to the reader); I drop the subscript ν, which stands fixed, and write H := Hν . 3 However, the formulas in [BF] give the opposite coproduct, hence change the antipode accordingly; we made the present choice to make these formulas “fit well” with those for F G dif (see below).
Poisson Symmetries Associated to Non-Commutative Diffeomorphisms
129
1.3. Deformations. Let be an indeterminate. In this paper we shall consider several Hopf algebras over k[], which can also be seen as 1-parameter depending families of Hopf algebras over k, the parameter being k; each k–algebra in such a family can then be thought of as a 1-parameter deformation of any other object in the same family. As a matter of notation, if H is such a Hopf k[]–algebra I call the fibre of H (thought of as a deformation) any Hopf k–algebra of type H p()H for some irreducible p() ∈ k[]; in particular H =c := H ( − c)H , for any c ∈ k, is called specialization of H at = c. We start from H := H[] ≡ k[] ⊗k H: this is indeed a Hopf k[]–algebra, namely H = k[] {an |n ∈ Nν } with Hopf structure given by (1.1) again. Set also H() := k() ⊗k[] H = k() ⊗k H = k() {an |n ∈ Nν } , a Hopf k()–algebra ruled by (1.1) too.
2. The Rees Deformation H¯h∨ 2.1. The goal. The crystal duality principle (cf. [Ga2], §5, or [Ga4]) yields a recipe to produce a 1-parameter deformation H∨ of H which is a quantized universal enveloping algebra (QUEA in the sequel): namely, H∨ is a Hopf k[]–algebra such that H∨ = H and H∨ = U (g− ), the universal enveloping algebra of a graded =1
=0
Lie bialgebra g− . Thus H∨ is a quantization of U (g− ), and the quantum symmetry H is a deformation of the classical Poisson symmetry U (g− ). By definition H∨ is the Rees algebra associated to a distinguished decreasing Hopf algebra filtration of H, so that U (g− ) is just the graded Hopf algebra associated to this filtration. The purpose of this section is to describe explicitly H∨ and its semiclassical limit U (g− ), hence also g− itself. This will also provide a direct, independent proof of all the above mentioned results about H∨ and U (g− ) themselves. 2.2. The Rees algebra H ∨ . Let J := Ker H : H −→ k be the augmentation ideal of H, and let J := J n n∈N be the J –adic filtration in H. It is easy to show (see [Ga4]) that J is a Hopf algebra filtration of H; since H is graded connected we have th J H (n) is the n homogeneous component of H), whence = H+n := ⊕n∈N H(n) ∨(where n ∼ n∈N J = {0} and H := H n∈N J = H. We let the Rees algebra associated to J be H∨ := k[] ·
n −n J n = k[]−n · J n = k[] −1 · J ⊆ H() . (2.1) n≥0
n≥0
n≥0
Letting J := Ker H : H −→ k[] = k[] · J (the augmentation ideal of H ) one has H∨ =
n −n Jn = −1 J n≥0
n≥0
⊆ H() .
130
F. Gavarini
For all n ∈ Nν , set xn := −1 an ; clearly H∨ is the k[]–subalgebra of H() generated by J ∨ := −1 J , hence by {xn }n∈Nν , so H∨ = k[] {xn |n ∈ Nν } . Moreover, m n−1 k n−m+1 (xn ) = xn ⊗1 + 1⊗xn + xn−m ⊗ Pm(k) (x∗ ), (xn ) = 0, k m=1 k=1
m n−1 k n−m+1 S(xn ) = −xn − xn−m S Pm(k) (x∗ ) k
(2.2)
m=1 k=1
n−1 m k n−m+1 = −xn − S(xn−m )Pm(k) (x∗ ) k m=1 k=1
for all n ∈ Nν , due to (1.1). From this one sees by hand that the following holds: Proposition 2.1. Formulas (2.2) make H∨ = k[] {xn , |n ∈ Nν } into a graded Hopf k[]–algebra, embedded into H() := k() ⊗k H as a graded Hopf subalgebra. Moreover, H∨ is a deformation of H, for its specialization at = 1 is isomorphic to H, i.e.
H∨ := H∨ (−1)H∨ ∼ = H via xn mod (−1)H∨ → an (∀n ∈ Nν ) =1
as graded Hopf algebras over k. Remark. The previous result shows that H