Commun. Math. Phys. 293, 1–36 (2010) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-009-0885-2
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks in the High-Mach Number Limit∗ Jeffrey Humpherys1 , Olivier Lafitte2 , Kevin Zumbrun3 1 Department of Mathematics, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT 84602, USA.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 LAGA, Institut Galilee, Universite Paris 13, 93 430 Villetaneuse, France, and CEA Saclay, DM2S/DIR,
91 191 Gif sur Yvette Cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected] 3 Department of Mathematics, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47402, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 6 March 2008 / Accepted: 30 April 2009 Published online: 2 September 2009 – © Springer-Verlag 2009
Abstract: By a combination of asymptotic ODE estimates and numerical Evans function calculations, we establish stability of viscous shock solutions of the isentropic compressible Navier–Stokes equations with γ -law pressure (i) in the limit as Mach number M goes to infinity, for any γ ≥ 1 (proved analytically), and (ii) for M ≥ 2, 500, γ ∈ [1, 2.5] or M ≥ 13, 000, γ ∈ [2.5, 3] (demonstrated numerically). This builds on and completes earlier studies by Matsumura–Nishihara and Barker–Humpherys– Rudd–Zumbrun establishing stability for low and intermediate Mach numbers, respectively, indicating unconditional stability, independent of shock amplitude, of viscous shock waves for γ -law gas dynamics in the range γ ∈ [1, 3]. Other γ -values may be treated similarly, but have not been checked numerically. The main idea is to establish convergence of the Evans function in the high-Mach number limit to that of a pressureless, or “infinitely compressible”, gas with additional upstream boundary condition determined by a boundary-layer analysis. Recall that low-Mach number behavior is formally incompressible. Contents 1. 2.
3.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . 2.1 Profile equation . . . . . . 2.2 Eigenvalue equations . . . 2.3 Preliminary estimates . . . 2.4 Evans function formulation Description of the Main Results 3.1 Limiting equations . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
2 6 6 7 8 8 9 9
∗ This work was supported in part by the National Science Foundation award numbers DMS-0607721 and DMS-0300487.
2
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
3.2 Limiting Evans function . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Physical interpretation . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Analytical results . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Numerical computations . . . . . . . . 3.6 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Boundary-Layer Analysis . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Preliminary transformation . . . . . . . 4.2 Dynamic triangularization . . . . . . . 4.3 Fast/Slow dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Proof of the Main Theorem . . . . . . . . . 5.1 Boundary estimate . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Convergence to D 0 . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Numerical Convergence . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Discussion and Open Problems . . . . . . . Appendix A. Proofs of Preliminary Estimates . . Appendix B. Nonvanishing of D 0 . . . . . . . . Appendix C. Quantitative Conjugation Estimates Appendix D. An Illuminating Example . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
10 11 12 13 15 15 17 17 20 21 22 24 25 26 27 29 31 33 34
1. Introduction The isentropic compressible Navier-Stokes equations in one spatial dimension expressed in Lagrangian coordinates take the form vt − u x = 0, u x u t + p(v)x = , v x
(1.1)
where v is specific volume, u is velocity, and p pressure. We assume an adiabatic pressure law p(v) = a0 v −γ
(1.2)
corresponding to a γ -law gas, for some constants a0 > 0 and γ ≥ 1. In the thermodynamical rarified gas approximation, γ > 1 is the average over constituent particles of γ = (n + 2)/n, where n is the number of internal degrees of freedom of an individual particle [4]: n = 3 (γ = 5/3) for monatomic, n = 5 (γ = 7/5) for diatomic gas. For dense fluids, γ is typically determined phenomenologically [19]. In general, γ is usually taken within 1 ≤ γ ≤ 3 in models of gas-dynamical flow, whether phenomenological or derived by statistical mechanics [42,43,45]. It is well known that these equations support viscous shock waves, or asymptoticallyconstant traveling-wave solutions (v, u)(x, t) = (v, ˆ u)(x ˆ − st),
lim (v, ˆ u)(z) ˆ = (v, u)± ,
z→±∞
(1.3)
in agreement with physically-observed phenomena. In nature, such waves are seen to be quite stable, even for large variations in pressure between v± . However, it is a long-standing mathematical question to what extent this is reflected in the continuum-mechanical model (1.1), that is, for which choice of parameters (v± , u ± , γ ) are solutions of (1.3)
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
3
time-evolutionarily stable in the sense of PDE; see, for example, the discussions in [3,25]. The first result on this problem was obtained by Matsumura and Nishihara in 1985 [36] using clever energy estimates on the integrals of perturbations in v and u, by which they established stability with respect to the restricted class of perturbations with “zero mass”, i.e., perturbations whose integral is zero, for shocks with sufficiently small amplitude | p(v+ ) − p(v− )| ≤ C(v− , γ ), with C → ∞ as γ → 1, but C << ∞ for γ = 1. There followed a number of works by Liu, Goodman, Szepessy-Xin, and others [14,15,30,31,46] toward the treatment of general, nonzero mass perturbations; see [48–50] and references therein. A complete result of nonlinear stability with respect to general L 1 ∩ H 3 perturbations of smallamplitude shocks of system (1.1) was finally obtained in 2004 by Mascia and Zumbrun [35] using pointwise semigroup techniques introduced by Zumbrun and Howard [47,50] in the strictly parabolic case. (For a precise statement, including rates of convergence, see the subsuming Proposition 1.1 below.) The result of [35], together with the small-amplitude spectral stability result of Humpherys and Zumbrun [23]1 generalizing that of [36], in fact yields stability of small-amplitude shocks of general symmetric hyperbolic-parabolic systems, largely settling the problem of small-amplitude shock stability for continuum mechanical systems. However, there remains the interesting question of large-amplitude stability. The main result in this direction, following a general strategy proposed in [50], is a “refined Lyapunov theorem”2 established by Mascia and Zumbrun [34,49] for general symmetric hyperbolic–parabolic systems, stating that linearized L 1 ∩ H 3 → L 1 ∩ H 3 stability is equivalent to and nonlinear L 1 ∩ H 3 → L 1 ∩ H 3 stability is implied by spectral stability, defined as nonexistence of nonstable (nonnegative real part) eigenvalues of the linearized operator L about the wave, other than at λ = 0 (where there is always an eigenvalue, due to translational invariance of the underlying equations), together with transversality of the traveling-wave connection and hyperbolic stability of the corresponding discontinuous shock. Moreover, these same conditions imply also asymptotic orbital stability, defined as convergence to the family of translates of the unperturbed wave, in L p , p > 1, with optimal rates. For concreteness, we state below the specialization of this result to system (1.1), along with an extension of Raoofi [40] asserting phase-asymptotic stability, or convergence to a specific translate of the unperturbed wave, under the additional assumption that the initial perturbation has small L 1 -first moment. These results hold for general hyperbolic-parabolic systems and waves under the additional assumptions of transverality/hyperbolic stability. Under our hypotheses, transversality/hyperbolic stability hold always for traveling waves of (1.1), as discussed in detail in the introduction of [34]. Proposition 1.1 ([34]). For any p such that p < 0 and p (0) > 0, in particular for p as in (1.2) with γ ≥ 1, let (v, ˆ u)(x ˆ − st) be a spectrally stable traveling-wave (1.3) of (1.1). Then, for any solution (v, ˜ u)(x, ˜ t) of (1.1) with L 1 ∩ H 3 initial difference 1 The result of [23] is obtained by energy estimates combining the techniques of [36] with those of [14,15]; a similar approach has been used in [32] to obtain small-amplitude zero-mass stability of Boltzmann shocks. See [12,39] for an alternative approach based on asymptotic ODE methods. 2 “Refined” because the linearized operator L does not possess a spectral gap, hence e Lt decays time-algebraically and not exponentially; see [49,50] for further discussion.
4
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
E 0 := (v, ˜ u)(·, ˜ 0) − (v, ˆ u)
ˆ L 1 ∩H 3 sufficiently small and some uniform C > 0, (v, ˜ u) ˜ exists for all t ≥ 0, with
(v, ˜ u)(·, ˜ t) − (v, ˆ u)(· ˆ − st) L 1 ∩H 3 ≤ C E 0 (stability).
(1.4)
˙ ≤ C E 0 (1 + t)−1/2 such that Moreover, there exists |α(t)| ≤ C E 0 , |α(t)|
(v, ˜ u)(·, ˜ t) − (v, ˆ u)(· ˆ − st − α(t)) L p ≤ C E 0 (1 + t)−(1/2)(1−1/ p)
(1.5)
for all 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞ (asymptotic orbital stability). Proposition 1.2 ([40]). For (v, ˜ u), ˜ (v, ˆ u) ˆ as in Proposition 1.1, if the initial difference has in addition a sufficiently small L 1 -first moment ˜ u)(·, ˜ 0) − (v, ˆ u)|
ˆ L1 , E 1 := |x| |(v,
(1.6)
then also α converges to a limit α∞ as t → +∞, with ˙ ≤ C() max{E 0 , E 1 }(1 + t)−1/2+ , |α − α∞ |(t), (1 + t)1/2 |α(t)|
(1.7)
> 0 arbitrary (phase-asymptotic orbital stability). Remark 1.3. Under the additional assumption that the initial perturbation and its first two derivatives decay as E 0 (1 + |x|)−3/2 , E 0 sufficiently small, one may obtain also sharp pointwise bounds on the solution, along with the sharp rate (1.7), = 0 for the phase; see [20,21]. Such a localization condition, or the weaker (1.6) is necessary in order to obtain a rate of convergence for α; smallness in L 1 ∪ H 3 is not enough, as may be seen by the example of a small initial perturbation localized arbitrarily far from x = 0, which takes arbitrarily long to reach and substantially affect the location of the shock profile. Propositions 1.1–1.2 reduce the problem of large-amplitude stability to the study of the associated eigenvalue equation (L − λ)u = 0, a standard analytically and numerically well-posed (boundary value) problem in ODE, which can be attacked by the large body of techniques developed for asymptotic, exact, and numerical study of ODE. In particular, there exist well-developed and efficient numerical algorithms to determine the number of unstable roots for any specific linearized operator L, independent of its origins in the PDE setting; see, e.g., [8–11,24] and references therein. In this sense, the problem of determining stability of any single wave is satisfactorily resolved, or, for that matter, of any compact family of waves. To determine stability of a family of waves across an unbounded parameter regime, however, is another matter. It is this issue that we confront in attempting to decide the stability of general isentropic Navier–Stokes shocks. As pointed out in [23,50], zero-mass stability implies (and in a practical sense is roughly equivalent to) spectral stability. Thus, the original results of Matsumura and Nishida [36] imply small-amplitude shock stability for general γ and large-amplitude stability as γ → 1. Recently, Barker, Humpherys, Rudd, and Zumbrun [2] have carried out a numerical Evans function study indicating stability on the large, but still bounded, parameter range γ ∈ [1, 3], 1 ≤ M ≤ 3,000, where M is the Mach number associated with the shock. For discussion of the Evans function, see Sect. 2.4. Recall that Mach number is an alternative measure of shock strength, with 1 corresponding to | p(v+ ) − p(v− )| = 0 and M → ∞ corresponding to | p(v+ ) − p(v− )| → ∞; see Appendix A, [2], or Sect. 2.1 below. Mach 3, 000 is far beyond the hypersonic regime
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
5
M ∼ 101 encountered in current aerodynamics. However, the mathematical question of stability across arbitrary γ , M has remained open up to now. In this paper, we resolve this question, using a combination of asymptotic ODE estimates and numerical Evans function calculations to conclude, first, stability of isentropic Navier–Stokes shocks in the large Mach number limit M → ∞ for any γ ≥ 1, and, second, stability for all M ≥ 2, 500 for γ ∈ [1, 2.5] (for γ ∈ [1, 2], we obtain in fact stability for M ≥ 500) and for all M ≥ 13, 000 for γ ∈ [2.5, 3]. The first result is obtained analytically, the second by a systematic numerical study. Together with the numerical results of [2] (supplemented with additional computations for γ ∈ [2.5, 3]), this gives convincing numerical evidence of unconditional stability for γ ∈ [1, 3], independent of shock amplitude. As in [2], our numerical study is not a numerical proof, but contains the necessary ingredients for one; see discussion, Sect. 6. The restriction to γ ∈ [1, 3] is an arbitrary one coming from the choice of parameters on which the numerical study [2] was carried out; stability for other γ can be easily checked as well. (Note that all analytical results are for any γ ≥ 1.) In particular, we establish without aid of numerics the following theorem, an immediate consequence of Corollary 3.3 and Proposition 3.5 below. The rest of our results, both analytical and numerical, are stated after some preliminary preparations and discussion in Sect. 3. Theorem 1.4. For any γ ≥ 1, isentropic Navier–Stokes shocks are spectrally stable for Mach number M sufficiently large (equivalently, v+ sufficiently small, taking without loss of generality v− > v+ > 0 in (1.3)), hence nonlinearly stable in L 1 ∩ H 3 , with bounds (1.4)–(1.5), (1.7). Our method of analysis is straightforward, though somewhat delicate to carry out. Working with the rescaled and conveniently rearranged versions of the equations introduced in [2], we observe that the associated eigenvalue equations converge uniformly as Mach number goes to infinity on a “regular region” x ≤ L, for any fixed L > 0, to a limiting system that is well-behaved (hence treatable by the standard methods of [2,33,39]) in the sense that its coefficient matrix converges uniformly exponentially in x to limits at x = ±∞, but is underdetermined at x = +∞. On the complementary “singular region” x ≥ L, the convergence is only pointwise due to a fast “inner structure” featuring rapid variation of the converging coefficient matrices near x = +∞, but the behavior at x = +∞ is of course determinate. Performing a boundary-layer analysis on the singular region and matching across x = L, we are able to show convergence of the Evans function of the original system as the Mach number goes to infinity to an Evans function of the limiting system with an appropriately imposed additional condition at x = +∞, upstream of the shock. This reduces the question of stability in the high-Mach number limit to existence or nonexistence of zeroes of the limiting Evans function on eλ ≥ 0, a question that can be resolved by routine numerical computation as in [2], or by energy estimates as in Appendix B. The limiting system can be recognized as the eigenvalue equation associated with a pressureless (γ = 0) gas, that is, the “infinitely-compressible” limit one might expect as the Mach number goes to infinity. Recall that behavior in the low Mach number limit is incompressible [18,27,29]. However, the upstream boundary condition has to our knowledge no such simple interpretation. Indeed, to carry out the boundary-layer analysis by which we derive this condition is the main technical difficulty of the paper. Our results on the large-amplitude limit allow us to complete a global stability analysis for traveling-waves of a nontrivial, physically relevant, and much-studied system of equations, allowing us to conclude for this canonical model that isentropic
6
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
Navier–Stokes shocks are stable for a γ -law gas with γ ∈ [1, 3]. More, the large amplitude limit appears to serve as an organizing center governing behavior also of shocks of large but relatively modest size. See, for example, Figs. 2–4, from which universal stability may be deduced essentially by inspection. Indeed, together with the smallamplitude limit, this appears to essentially govern by interpolation behavior of shocks of all amplitudes. The study of this limit thus has importance apart from the specific physical interest of the high-Mach number regime. Besides their independent interest, the results of this paper seem significant as prototypes for future analyses. Our calculations use some properties specific to the structure of (1.1). In particular, we make use of surprisingly strong energy estimates carried out in [2] in confining unstable eigenvalues to a bounded set independent of shock strength (or Mach number). Also, we use the extremely simple structure of the eigenvalue equation to carry out the key analysis of the eigenvalue flow in the singular region near x = +∞ essentially by hand. However, these appear to be conveniences rather than essential aspects of the analysis. It is our hope that the basic argument structure of this paper together with [2] can serve as a blueprint for the global study of large-amplitude stability in more general situations. In particular, we expect that the analysis will carry over to the full (nonisentropic) equations of gas dynamics with ideal gas equation of state.
2. Preliminaries We begin by recalling a number of preliminary steps carried out in [2]. Making the standard change of coordinates x → x − st, we consider instead stationary solutions (v, u)(x, t) ≡ (v, ˆ u)(x) ˆ of vt − svx − u x = 0, u x u t − su x + (a0 v −γ )x = . v x
(2.1)
Under the rescaling (x, t, v, u) → (−εsx, εs 2 t, v/ε, −u/(εs)),
(2.2)
where ε is chosen so that 0 < v+ < v− = 1, our system takes the convenient form vt + vx − u x = 0, u x u t + u x + (av −γ )x = , v x where a = a0 ε−γ −1 s −2 .
2.1. Profile equation. Steady shock profiles of (2.3) satisfy v − u = 0, u u + (av −γ ) = , v
(2.3)
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
7
subject to boundary conditions (v, u)(±∞) = (v± , u ± ), or, simplifying, v −γ v + (av ) = . v Integrating from −∞ to x, we get the profile equation v = H (v, v+ ) := v(v − 1 + a(v −γ − 1)),
(2.4)
where a is found by setting x = +∞, thus yielding the Rankine-Hugoniot condition a=−
v+ − 1
−γ v+
−1
γ
= v+
1 − v+ γ. 1 − v+
(2.5) γ
Evidently, a → γ −1 in the weak shock limit v+ → 1, while a ∼ v+ in the strong shock limit v+ → 0. The associated Mach number M may be computed as in [2], Appendix A, as M = (γ a)−1/2
(2.6)
−γ /2
→ +∞ as v+ → 0 and M → 1 as v+ → 1; that is, the so that M ∼ γ −1/2 v+ high-Mach number limit corresponds to the limit v+ → 0. 2.2. Eigenvalue equations. Linearizing (2.3) about the profile (v, ˆ u), ˆ we obtain the eigenvalue problem λv + v − u = 0, h(v) ˆ u λu + u − v = , vˆ γ +1 vˆ
(2.7)
where h(v) ˆ = −vˆ γ +1 + a(γ − 1) + (a + 1)vˆ γ .
(2.8)
We seek nonstable eigenvalues λ ∈ { e(λ) ≥ 0} \ {0}, i.e., λ for which (2.7) possess a nontrivial solution (v, u) decaying at plus and minus spatial infinity. As pointed in [23,50], by divergence form of the equations, such solutions necessarily satisfy out +∞ +∞ v(x)d x = −∞ −∞ u(x)d x = 0, from which we may deduce that x x u(z)dz, v(x) ˜ = v(z)dz u(x) ˜ = −∞
−∞
and their derivatives decay exponentially as x → ∞. Substituting and then integrating, we find that (u, ˜ v) ˜ satisfies the integrated eigenvalue equations (suppressing the tilde) λv + v − u = 0, (2.9a) h(v) ˆ u λu + u − γ +1 v = . (2.9b) vˆ vˆ This new eigenvalue problem differs spectrally from (2.7) only at λ = 0, hence spectral stability of (2.7) is equivalent to spectral stability of (2.9). Moreover, since (2.9) has no eigenvalue at λ = 0, one can expect more uniform stability estimates for the integrated equations in the vicinity of λ = 0 [14,36,50].
8
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
2.3. Preliminary estimates. The following estimates established in [2] indicate the suitability of the rescaling chosen in Sect. 2.1. For completeness, we recall their proofs in Appendix A. Proposition 2.1 ([2]). For each γ ≥ 1, 0 < v+ ≤ 1, (2.4) has a unique (up to translation) monotone decreasing solution vˆ decaying to its endstates with a uniform exponential 1 1 rate, independent of v+ , γ . In particular, for 0 < v+ ≤ 12 and v(0) ˆ := v+ + 12 , 3x 1 |v(x) ˆ − v+ | ≤ e− 4 x ≥ 0, (2.10a) 12 x+12 1 e 2 x ≤ 0. (2.10b) |v(x) ˆ − v− | ≤ 4 Proposition 2.2 ([2]). Nonstable eigenvalues λ of (2.9), i.e., eigenvalues with nonnegative real part, are confined for any 0 < v+ ≤ 1 to the region := {λ : e(λ) + |m(λ)| ≤
1 √ γ+ 2
2 }.
(2.11)
2.4. Evans function formulation. Following [2], we may express (2.9) concisely as a first-order system ⎛
0 A(x, λ) = ⎝ 0 λvˆ
W = A(x, λ)W, ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ λ 1 u ⎠ , W = ⎝v ⎠ , = d , 0 1 dx λvˆ f (v) ˆ −λ v
(2.12) (2.13)
where f (v) ˆ = vˆ − vˆ −γ h(v) ˆ = 2vˆ − a(γ − 1)vˆ −γ − (a + 1), with h as in (2.8) and a as in (2.5), or, equivalently, 1 − v+ v+ γ 1 − v+ γ f (v) ˆ = 2vˆ − (γ − 1) − γ γ v+ − 1. v ˆ 1 − v+ 1 − v+
(2.14)
(2.15)
Eigenvalues of (2.9) correspond to nontrivial solutions W for which the boundary conditions W (±∞) = 0 are satisfied. Because A(x, λ) as a function of vˆ is asymptotically constant in x, the behavior near x = ±∞ of solutions of (2.13) is governed by the limiting constant-coefficient systems W = A± (λ)W,
A± (λ) := A(±∞, λ),
(2.16)
from which we readily find on the (nonstable) domain λ ≥ 0, λ = 0 of interest that there is a one-dimensional unstable manifold W1− (x) of solutions decaying at x = −∞ and a two-dimensional stable manifold W2+ (x) ∧ W3+ (x) of solutions decaying at x = +∞, analytic in λ, with asymptotic behavior µ± (λ)x ± W± V j (λ) j (x, λ) ∼ e
(2.17)
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
9
as x → ±∞, where µ± (λ) and V j± (λ) are eigenvalues and associated analytically chosen eigenvectors of the limiting coefficient matrices A± (λ). A standard choice of eigenvectors V j± [8,11,13,22], uniquely specifying W ± j (up to constant factor) is obtained by Kato’s ODE [26], a linear, analytic ODE whose solution can be alternatively characterized by the property that there exist corresponding left eigenvectors V˜ j± such that (V˜ j · V j )± ≡ constant, (V˜ j · V˙ j )± ≡ 0,
(2.18)
where “ ˙ ” denotes d/dλ; for further discussion, see [13,22,26]. Defining the Evans function D associated with operator L as the analytic function D(λ) := det(W1− W2+ W3+ )|x=0 ,
(2.19)
we find that eigenvalues of L correspond to zeroes of D both in location and multiplicity; moreover, the Evans function extends analytically to λ = 0, i.e., to all of λ ≥ 0. See [1,13,33,49] for further details. Equivalently, following [2,38], we may express the Evans function as +
1 · W − D(λ) = W (2.20) 1 |x=0 , + (x) spans the one-dimensional unstable manifold of solutions decaying at where W 1 x = +∞ (necessarily orthogonal to the span of W2+ (x) and W3+ (x)) of the adjoint eigenvalue ODE, . = −A(x, λ)∗ W W
(2.21)
The simpler representation (2.20) is the one that we shall use here. 3. Description of the Main Results We can now state precisely our main results.
3.1. Limiting equations. Under the strategic rescaling (2.2), both profile and eigenvalues equations converge pointwise as v+ → 0 to limiting equations at v+ = 0. The limiting profile equation (the limit of (2.4)) is evidently v = v(v − 1),
(3.1)
with explicit solution vˆ0 (x) =
1 − tanh(x/2) , 2
(3.2)
while the limiting eigenvalue system (the limit of (2.13)) is W = A0 (x, λ)W, ⎛ 0 λ 0 A0 (x, λ) = ⎝ 0 λvˆ0 λvˆ0
⎞
1 ⎠, 1 f 0 (vˆ0 ) − λ
(3.3) (3.4)
10
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
where f 0 (vˆ0 ) = 2vˆ0 − 1 = − tanh(x/2).
(3.5)
Indeed, this convergence is uniform on any interval vˆ0 ≥ > 0, or, equivalently, x ≤ L, for L any positive constant, where the sequence is therefore a regular perturbation of its limit. We will call x ∈ (−∞, L] the “regular region” or “regular side”. For vˆ0 → 0 on the other hand, or x → ∞, the limit is less well-behaved, as may be
seen by the fact that ∂ f /∂ vˆ ∼ vˆ −1 as vˆ → v+ , a consequence of the appearance of vvˆ+ in the expression (2.15) for f . Similarly, in contrast to v, ˆ A(x, λ) does not converge to A+ (λ) as x → +∞ with uniform exponential rate independent of v+ , γ , but rather as C vˆ −1 e−x/2 . We call x ∈ [L , +∞) therefore the “singular region” or “singular side”. (This is not a singular perturbation in the usual sense but a weaker type of singularity, at least as we have framed the problem here.) 3.2. Limiting Evans function. We should now like to define a limiting Evans function following the asymptotic Evans function framework introduced in [39] and establish convergence to this function in the v+ → 0 limit, thus reducing the stability problem as v+ → 0 to the study of the (fixed) limiting Evans function. However, we face certain difficulties due to the (mild) singularity of the limit, as can be seen even at the first step of defining an Evans function for the limiting system. For, the limiting coefficient matrix ⎛ ⎞ 0 λ 1 1 ⎠ A0+ (λ) := A0 (+∞, λ) = ⎝0 0 (3.6) 0 0 −1 − λ is nonhyperbolic (in ODE sense) for all λ, having eigenvalues 0, 0, −1 − λ; in particular, the stable manifold drops to dimension one in the limit v+ → 0. Thus, the subspace in which W2+ and W3+ should be initialized at x = +∞ is not self-determined by (3.6), but must be deduced by a careful study of the double limit v+ → 0, x → +∞. But, the computation ⎛ ⎞ 0 λ 1 1 ⎠ = A0+ (λ) = lim lim A(x, λ) lim A(+∞, λ) = ⎝0 0 x→∞ v+ →0 v+ →0 0 0 −γ − λ shows that these limits do not commute, except in the special case γ = 1 already treated in [36] by other methods. The rigorous treatment of this issue is the main work of the paper. However, the end result can be easily motivated on heuristic grounds. A study of limv+ →0 A(+∞, λ) on the set eλ ≥ 0 of interest reveals that eigenmodes decouple into a single “fast” (stable subspace) decaying mode (∗, ∗, 1)T associated with eigenvalue −γ − λ of strictly negative real part and a two-dimensional (center) subspace of neutral modes (r, 0)T associated 0λ with Jordan block , of which there is only a single genuine eigenvector (1, 0, 0)T . 00 For v+ small, therefore, A+ (λ) has also a single fast, decaying, eigenmode with eigenvalue near −γ − 1 and two slow eigenmodes with eigenvalues near zero, one decaying and the other growing (recall, Sect. 2.4, that the stable subspace of A+ has dimension two for eλ ≥ 0, λ = 0 and the unstable subspace dimension one).
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
11
Focusing on the single slow decaying eigenvector of A+ , and considering its limiting behavior as v+ → 0, we see immediately that it must converge in direction to ±(1, 0, 0)T . For, the sequence of direction vectors, since continuously varying and restricted to a compact set, has a nonempty, connected set of accumulation points, and these must be eigenvectors of limv+ →0 A+ with eigenvalues near zero. Since ±(1, 0, 0)T are the unique candidates, we obtain the result. Indeed, both growing and decaying slow eigenmodes must converge to this common direction, making the limiting analysis trivial. The same argument shows that ±(1, 0, 0)T is the limiting direction of the slow stable eigenmode of A0 (x, λ) as x → +∞, that is, in the alternate limit lim lim A(x, λ).
x→∞ v+ →0
Since V2+ := (1, 0, 0)T is the common limit of the slow decaying eigenmode in either of the two alternative limits limv+ →0 A+ and limv+ →0 A+ , it thus seems a reasonable choice to use this limiting slow direction to define an Evans function for the limiting system (3.4). On the other hand, the stable eigenmode V3 := (b−1 (λ/b + 1), b−1 , 1)T , b = −1 − λ, of A0+ is forced on us by the system itself, independent of the limiting process. Combining these two observations, we require that solutions W20+ and W30+ of the limiting eigenvalue system (3.4) lie asympotically in directions V2 and V3 , respectively, thus determining a limiting, or “reduced” Evans function D 0 (λ) := det(W10− W20+ W30+ )|x=0 ,
(3.7)
or alternatively 10+ · W 0− D 0 (λ) = W 1
|x=0
,
(3.8)
0+ defined analogously as a solution of the adjoint limiting system lying asympwith W 1 totically at x = +∞ in direction 1 := (0, 1, b¯ −1 )T = (0, 1, (1 + λ¯ )−1 )T V
(3.9)
orthogonal to the span of V2 and V3 , where “¯” denotes complex conjugate. (The prescription of W10− in the regular region is straightforward: it must lie on the one-dimensional unstable manifold of A0− as in the v+ > 0 case.) 3.3. Physical interpretation. Alternatively, the limiting equations may be derived by γ taking a formal limit as v+ → 0 of the rescaled equations (2.3), recalling that a ∼ v+ , to obtain a limiting evolution equation vt + vx − u x = 0, u x ut + u x = v x
(3.10)
12
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
corresponding to a pressureless gas, or γ = 0, then deriving profile and eigenvalue equations from (3.10) in the usual way. This gives some additional insight on behavior, of which we make important mathematical use in Appendix B. Physically, it has the interpretation that, in the high-Mach number limit v+ → 0, effects of pressure are concentrated near x = +∞ on the infinite-density side, as encoded in the special upstream boundary condition (u, u , v, v ) → c(1, 0, 0, 0) as x → +∞ for the integrated eigenvalue equation, which may be seen to be equivalent to the conditions imposed on W +j in the previous subsection.
3.4. Analytical results. Defining D 0 as in (3.7)–(3.8), we have the following main theorems, all valid for arbitrary γ ≥ 1. Theorem 3.1. For each γ ≥ 1 and λ in any compact subset of eλ ≥ 0, D(λ) converges uniformly to D 0 (λ) as v+ → 0. Corollary 3.2. For each γ ≥ 1 and any compact subset of eλ ≥ 0, D is nonvanishing on for v+ sufficiently small if D 0 is nonvanishing on , and is nonvanishing on the interior of only if D 0 is nonvanishing there. Proof. Standard properties of uniform limit of analytic functions. Corollary 3.3. For each γ ≥ 1, isentropic Navier–Stokes shocks are spectrally stable in the high-Mach number limit v+ → 0 if D 0 is nonvanishing on the wedge : e(λ) + |m(λ)| ≤
1 √ γ+ 2
2 , eλ ≥ 0
(3.11)
and only if D 0 is nonvanishing on the interior of . Proof. Corollary 3.2 together with Proposition 2.2. Remark 3.4. Likewise, on any compact subset of eλ ≥ 0, |D| is uniformly bounded from zero for v+ sufficiently small (M sufficiently large) if and only if |D 0 | is uniformly bounded from zero. Thus, isentropic Navier–Stokes shocks are “uniformly stable” for sufficiently small v+ , in the sense that |D| is bounded from below independent of v+ , if and only if D 0 is nonvanishing on as defined in (3.11). The following result completes our abstract stability analysis. The proof, given in Appendix B, is by an energy estimate analogous to that of [36].3 Proposition 3.5. The limiting Evans function D 0 (note: independent of γ ) is nonzero on
eλ ≥ 0. From Proposition 3.5 and Corollary 3.3 we obtain Main Theorem 1.4 stated in the Introduction. 3 Stability for γ = 1, proved in [36], already implies nonvanishing of D 0 outside the imaginary interval √ √ [−i 3/2, +i 3/2], by Corollary 3.3.
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
13
3.5. Numerical computations. Unfortunately, the energy estimate used to establish Proposition 3.5, though mathematically elegant, yields only the stated, abstract result and not quantitative estimates. A simpler and more general approach, that does yield quantitative information, is to compute the reduced Evans function numerically. We carry out this by-now routine numerical computation using the methods of [2]. Specifically, we map a semicircle ∂({ eλ ≥ 0} ∩ {|λ| ≤ 10}) enclosing for γ ∈ [1, 3] by D 0 and compute the winding number of its image about the origin to determine the number of zeroes of D 0 within the semicircle, and thus within . For details of the numerical algorithm, see [2,11,23]. The result is displayed in Fig. 1, clearly indicating stability. More precisely, the minimum of |D| on the semicircle is found to be ≈ 0.2433. Together with Rouchés Theorem, this gives explicit bounds on the size of the Mach number for which shocks are stable, as displayed in Table 1, Sect. 6. Specifically, computing numerically the first value of M at which |D − D 0 |/|D 0 | < 1/2 on the entire semicircle, we obtain the lower bounds M ≥ 500 for γ ∈ [1, 2], M ≥ 2, 400 for γ ∈ [2, 2.5], and M ≥ 13,000 for γ ∈ [2.5, 3], all corresponding approximately to v+ = 10−3 . Recall by Rouchés Theorem that winding number is unaffected by relative error |D − D 0 |/|D 0 | < 1. This is essentially a convergence study, since we rely on the assumed convergence of the relative error to zero in concluding that relative error remains < 1 also for Mach numbers larger than this minimum value. In Fig. 2, we superimpose on the image of the semicircle by D 0 its (again numerically computed) image by the full Evans function D, for a monatomic gas γ = 5/3 at successively higher Mach numbers v+ =1e-1,1e-2,1e-3,1e-4,1e-5,1e-6, graphically demonstrating the convergence of D to D 0 as v+ approaches zero and (numerically) verifying the conclusions of Table 1. In fact, we can see a great deal more from Fig. 2. For, note that the displayed contours are, to the scale visible by eye, “monotone” in v+ , or nested, one within the other (they do not appear so at smaller scales). Thus, lower-Mach number contours are essentially “trapped” within higher-Mach number contours, with the worst-case, outmost contour corresponding to the limiting Evans function D 0 . From this observation, we may conclude with confidence stability down to the smallest value M ≈ 5.5 displayed in the figure, corresponding (see Table 2) to v+ = 10−1 . Note, further, that the low-Mach number contours appear to be shrinking to a point as v+ → 1. This is indeed the case, as can be confirmed by the small-amplitude analysis of [39]; see Remark 3.6. That is, a great deal of topological information is encoded in the analytic family of Evans functions indexed by v+ , from which stability may be deduced almost by inspection. Behavior for other γ ∈ [1, 3] is similar. See, for example, the case γ = 3 displayed in Fig. 4, which is virtually identical to Fig. 2.4 Such topological information does not seem to be available from other methods of investigating stability such as direct discretation of the linearized operator about the wave [28] or studies based on linearized time-evolution or power methods [5,6]. This represents in our view a significant advantage of the Evans function formulation. Remark 3.6. Recall that the Evans function is not determined uniquely, but only up to a nonvanishing analytic factor [1,13]. The simple contour structure in Fig. 2 is thus partly due to a favorable choice of D induced by the initialization at ±∞ by Kato’s ODE [26], as described in [2,11,24]. A canonical algorithm for tracking bases of evolving subspaces, this in some sense minimizes “action”; see [22] for further discussion. 4 In particular, Fig. 4 indicates stability down to v = 10−1 , or Mach number ∼ 20, from which we may + conclude unconditional stability on the whole range γ ∈ [1, 3] of [2].
14
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
4 3 2
Im
1 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Re Fig. 1. The image of the semi-circular contour via the Evans function for the reduced system. Note that the winding number of this graph is zero. Hence, there are no unstable eigenvalues in the semi-circle 4 3 2
Im
1 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Re
Fig. 2. Convergence to the limiting Evans function as v+ → 0 for a monatomic gas, γ = 5/3. The contours depicted, going from inner to outer, are images of the semicircle under D for v+ =1e-1,1e-2, 1e-3,1e-4,1e-5,1e-6. The outermost contour is the image under D 0 , which is nearly indistinguishable from the image for v+ =1e-6
In particular, this leads to the surprisingly simple constant small-amplitude limit, as we show by explicit computation in Appendix D for the case of a Burgers shock. The small-amplitude analysis of [39] shows that the Evans function in the general case converges to a multiple of the Burgers Evans function, yielding the result in the general case. Remark 3.7. Note that the limiting equations, and the limiting Evans function D 0 are both independent of γ . To study high-Mach number stability for γ > 3, therefore,
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
15
requires only to examine D 0 on successively larger semicircles. Thus, our methods in combination with the those of [2], allow us to determine stability in principle over any bounded interval in γ , for γ ≥ 1 and for all Mach numbers M ≥ 1. Remark 3.8. As Fig. 2 suggests, an alternative method for determining stability, without reference to D 0 , is to compute the full Evans function for sufficiently high Mach number. That is, nonvanishing of D 0 , and thus stability of sufficiently high Mach number shocks for γ ∈ [1, 3], can already be concluded by large-but-finite Mach number study of [2] together with the fact that a limit D → D 0 exists (see also Remark 3.4). 3.6. Conclusions. The analytical result of Theorem 1.4 guarantees stability for γ ≥ 1, M sufficiently large. For γ ∈ [1, 2.5], our numerical results indicate stability for M ≥ 2,500 by a crude Rouche bound, and indeed much lower if further structure is taken into account. Together with the small and intermediate Mach number studies of [2,36] for M ≤ 3, 000, this yields unconditional stability of isentropic Navier–Stokes shocks for γ ∈ [1, 2.5] and M ≥ 1. Additional intermediate-strength computations supplementing [2] extend this result to γ ∈ [1, 3]. There is no inherent restriction to γ ∈ [1, 3]; as discussed in Remark 3.7, numerical computations can be carried out for any value of γ to determine stability (or instability) for all M ≥ 1. Indeed, our method of analysis indicates that the large-γ limit is quite analogous to the high-Mach number limit v+ → 0, suggesting the possibility to establish still more general results encompassing all γ ≥ 1, M ≥ 1. Our numerical results reveal also an unexpected “universality” of behavior in the high-Mach number regime, beyond just convergence to the limiting system. Namely, we see (cf. Figs. 2 and 4) that behavior for a given v+ is virtually independent of the value of γ . This also indicates that v+ and not M is the more useful measure of shock strength in this regime. 4. Boundary-Layer Analysis We now carry out the main work of the paper, analyzing the flow of (2.13) in the singular region. Our starting point is the observation that ⎛ ⎞ 0 λ 1 ⎠ 0 1 A(x, λ) = ⎝ 0 (4.1) λvˆ λvˆ f (v) ˆ −λ is approximately block upper-triangular for vˆ sufficiently small, with diagonal blocks
0λ ˆ − λ that are uniformly spectrally separated on eλ ≥ 0, as follows and f (v) 00 by f (v) ˆ ≤ 2vˆ − 1 ≤ −1/2.
(4.2)
We exploit this structure by a judicious coordinate change converting (2.13) to a system in exact upper triangular form, for which the decoupled “slow” upper lefthand 2 × 2 block undergoes a regular perturbation that can be analyzed by standard tools introduced in [39]. Meanwhile, the fast, lower righthand 1 × 1 block, since scalar, may be solved exactly.
16
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun 4 3 2
Im
1 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Re Fig. 3. Convergence to the limiting Evans function as v+ → 0 for γ = 1. The contours depicted, going from inner to outer, are images of the semicircle under D for v+ =1e-1,1e-2,1e-3,1e-4,1e-5,1e-6. The outermost contour is the image under D 0 4 3 2
Im
1 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Re Fig. 4. Convergence to the limiting Evans function as v+ → 0 for γ = 3. The contours depicted, going from inner to outer, are images of the semicircle under D for v+ =1e-1,1e-2,1e-3,1e-4,1e-5,1e-6. The outermost contour is the image under D 0
The global structure of this argument loosely follows the general strategy introduced in [39] of first decoupling fast and slow modes, then treating slow modes by regular perturbation methods. However, there are interesting departures that may be of use in other degenerate situations. First, we only partially decouple the system, to block-triangular rather than block-diagonal form as in more standard cases, and second, we introduce a more stable method of block-reduction taking account of usually negligible derivative terms in the definition of block-triangularizing transformations, which, if ignored, would in this case lead to unacceptably large errors.
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
17
4.1. Preliminary transformation. We first block upper-triangularize by a static (constant) coordinate transformation the limiting matrix ⎛ ⎞ 0 λ 1 ⎠ 0 1 A+ = A(+∞, λ) = ⎝ 0 (4.3) λv+ λv+ f (v+ ) − λ at x = +∞ using special block lower-triangular transformations I 0 I −1 R+ := , L + := R+ = λv+ θ+ 1 −λv+ θ+
0 , 1
(4.4)
where I denotes the 2 × 2 identity matrix and θ+ ∈ C1×2 is a 1 × 2 row vector. Lemma 4.1. For each γ ≥ 1, on any compact subset of eλ ≥ 0, for each v+ > 0 sufficiently small, there exists a unique θ+ = θ+ (v+ , λ) such that Aˆ + := L + A+ R+ is upper block-triangular, 11 λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) , (4.5) Aˆ + = 0 f (v+ ) − λ − λv+ θ+ 11 01 1 where J = and 11 = , satisfying a uniform bound 00 1 |θ+ | ≤ C.
(4.6)
Proof. Setting the (2, 1) block of Aˆ + to zero, we obtain the matrix equation θ+ (bI − λJ ) = −11T + λv+ θ+ 11θ+ , where b = f (v+ ) − λ, or, equivalently, the fixed-point equation θ+ = −11T + λv+ θ+ 11θ+ (bI − λJ )−1 .
(4.7)
By det(bI − λJ ) = b2 = 0, (bI − λJ )−1 is uniformly bounded on compact subsets of
eλ ≥ 0 (indeed, it is uniformly bounded on all of eλ ≥ 0), whence, for |λ| bounded and v+ sufficiently small, there exists a unique solution by the Contraction Mapping Theorem, which, moreover, satisfies (4.6). 4.2. Dynamic triangularization. Defining now Y := L + W and ˆ A(x, λ) = L + A(x, λ)R+ λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) = λ(vˆ − v+ )11T + λv+ ( f (v) ˆ − f (v+ ))θ+
11 , f (v) ˆ − λ − λv+ θ+ 11
we have converted (2.13) to an asymptotically block upper-triangular system ˆ λ)Y, Y = A(x,
(4.8)
18
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
ˆ with Aˆ + = A(+∞, λ) as in (4.5). Our next step is to choose a dynamic transformation of the same form I 0 I 0 −1 ˜ ˜ ˜ R := ˜ , L := R = (4.9) ˜ 1 , 1 − ˜ uniformly expoconverting (4.8) to an exactly block upper-triangular system, with nentially decaying at x = +∞: that is, a regular perturbation of the identity. Lemma 4.2. For each γ ≥ 1, on any compact subset of eλ ≥ 0, for L sufficiently ˜ = (x, ˜ large and each v+ > 0 sufficiently small, there exists a unique λ, v+ ) such ˆ that A˜ := L˜ A(x, λ) R˜ + L˜ R˜ is upper block-triangular, ˜ 11 λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) + 11 ˜ (4.10) A= ˜ 1 , 0 f (v) ˆ − λ − λv+ θ+ 11 − 1 ˜ and (L) = 0, satisfying a uniform bound ˜ | (x, λ, v+ )| ≤ Ce−ηx ,
η > 0, x ≥ L ,
(4.11)
independent of the choice of L, v+ . Proof. Setting the (2, 1) block of A˜ to zero and computing I 0 0 0 0 L˜ R˜ = = ˜ ˜ ˜ − 0 I −
0 , 0
we obtain the matrix equation ˜ − ˜ (bI − λ(J + v+ 11θ+ )) = ζ + 1 ˜ 1 , ˜
(4.12)
where b(x, λ, v+ ) := f (v) ˆ − λ − λv+ θ+ 11 and the forcing term ˆ − f (v+ ))θ+ ζ := λ(vˆ − v+ )11T + λv+ ( f (v) by derivative estimate d f /d vˆ ≤ C vˆ −1 together with the Mean Value Theorem is uniformly exponentially decaying: |ζ | ≤ C|vˆ − v+ | ≤ C2 e−ηx ,
η > 0.
(4.13)
˜ Initializing (L) = 0, we obtain by Duhamel’s Principle/Variation of Constants the representation (supressing the argument λ) x ˜ ˜ 1 )(y) ˜ (x) = S y→x (ζ + 1 dy, (4.14) L
where
S y→x
is the solution operator for the homogeneous equation ˜ − ˜ (bI − λ(J + v+ 11θ+ )) = 0,
or, explicitly, S y→x = e
x y
b(y)dy −λ(J +v+ 11θ+ )(x−y)
e
.
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
19
For |λ| bounded and v+ sufficiently small, we have by matrix perturbation theory that the eigenvalues of −λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) are small and the entries are bounded, hence |e−λ(J +v+ 11θ+ )z | ≤ Cez for z ≥ 0. Recalling the uniform spectral gap eb = f (v) ˆ − eλ ≤ −1/2 for eλ ≥ 0, we thus have |S y→x | ≤ Ce−η(x−y)
(4.15)
for some C, η > 0. Combining (4.13) and (4.15), we obtain x x y→x S ζ (y) dy ≤ C2 e−η(x−y) e−(η/2)y dy L
L
= C3 e−(η/2)x .
(4.16)
˜ Defining (x) =: θ˜ (x)e−(η/2)x and recalling (4.14) we thus have x ˜θ (x) = f + e(η/2)x ˜ 1θ˜ (y) dy, S y→x e−ηy θ1 where f := e(η/2)x
x L
(4.17)
L
S y→x ζ (y) dy is uniformly bounded, | f | ≤ C3 , and x (η/2)x S y→x e−ηy θ˜ 11θ˜ (y) dy e L
is contractive with arbitrarily small contraction constant > 0 in L ∞ [L , +∞) for |θ˜ | ≤ 2C3 for L sufficiently large, by the calculation x (η/2)x x y→x −ηy y→x −ηy ˜ e ˜1 11θ˜1 (y) − e(η/2)x ˜ θ θ S e S e 1 1 θ (y) 2 2 L L x ≤ e(η/2)x Ce−η(x−y) e−ηy dy θ˜1 − θ˜2 ∞ max θ˜ j ∞ j L x ≤ e−(η/2)L Ce−(η/2)(x−y) dy θ˜1 − θ˜2 ∞ max θ˜ j ∞ j
L
= C3 e
−(η/2)L
θ˜1 − θ˜2 ∞ max θ˜ j ∞ . j
It follows by the Contraction Mapping Principle that there exists a unique solution θ˜ ˜ of fixed point equation (4.17) with |θ(x)| ≤ 2C3 for x ≥ L, or, equivalently (redefining the unspecified constant η), (4.11). Remark 4.3. The above calculation is the most delicate part of the analysis, and the main technical point of the paper. The interested reader may verify that a “quasi-static” ˜ in (4.12) as an error, as is typically used in situations transformation treating term of slowly-varying coefficients (see for example [33,39]), would lead to unacceptable errors of magnitude O(|( f (v)) ˆ ||vˆ − v+ |) = O(|d f /d v|| ˆ vˆ − v+ |) = O(|v| ˆ −1 |vˆ − v+ |). One may think of the exact ODE solution (4.9) as “averaging” the effects of rapidlyvarying coefficients by integration of (4.12). Note that success of this approach depends
20
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
in principle only on spectral separation at infinity and not everywhere along the profile; thus, it may be considered as interpolating between the tracking and conjugation lemmas of [50,33,48,49,39], used respectively to treat slowly-varying- and asymptotically constant- coefficient systems. This seems likely to be of use also in other delicate situations. Remark 4.4. One may combine the static and the dynamic triangularization used in this section. We may define ˜ + λv+ θ+ , =
(4.18)
˜ ˜ and obtain the two different terms and λv+ θ+ as follows. Consider A being defined as I 0 L R + L Aˆ R, where L = and R := L −1 . One obtains − 1 A˜ =
λJ + 11 − + ( f (v) ˆ − λ − 11) − λ J + λv1 ˆ 1T
11 . f (v) ˆ − λ − 11
A necessary and sufficient condition for A˜ to be upper block-triangular is that solve ˆ − λ − .11) − λ J + λv1 ˆ 1T . = ( f (v)
(4.19)
If a solution is bounded at +∞ and → 0, then the limit of , called + , solves ( f (v+ ) − λ − + 11) + − λ + J + λv+ 11T = 0. The unique solution of this equation that is uniformly bounded by C|λ|v+ for 0 < v+ < 1/C and λ in a compact subset of ˜ = − λv+ θ+ and replacing in Eq. (4.19),
eλ ≥ 0 is + = λv+ θ+ . Considering now ˜ one obtains the equation (4.12) for . The preliminary, static, transformation is thus a way of subtracting the behavior at infinity (and choosing this behavior) in the dynamic triangularization and can be used in general. For each possible behavior at infinity, however, we have a different solution ˜ and our construction is the only one that ensures the uniform bounds in v+ at infinity. 4.3. Fast/Slow dynamics. Making now the further change of coordinates ˜ Z = LY and computing ˜ ) = LY ˜ + L˜ Y = ( L˜ A+ + L˜ )Y = ( L˜ A+ R˜ + L˜ R)Z ˜ , ( LY we find that we have converted (4.8) to a block-triangular system ˜ 11 ˜ = λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) + 11 Z = AZ ˜ 1 Z, 0 f (v) ˆ − λ − λv+ θ+ 11 − 1 related to the original eigenvalue system (2.13) by I I 0 W = L Z , R := R+ R˜ = , L := R −1 = − 1
0 . 1
(4.20)
(4.21)
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
21
Since it is triangular, (4.20) may be solved completely if we can solve the component systems associated with its diagonal blocks. The fast system z =
˜ 1 z f (v) ˆ − λ − λv+ θ+ 11 − 1
associated to the lower righthand block features rapidly-varying coefficients. However, because it is scalar, it can be solved explicitly by exponentiation. The slow system ˜ z z = λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) + 11
(4.22)
associated to the upper lefthand block, on the other hand, by (4.11), is an exponentially decaying perturbation of a constant-coefficient system z = λ(J + v+ 11θ+ )z
(4.23)
that can be explicitly solved by exponentiation, and thus can be well-estimated by comparison with (4.23). A rigorous version of this statement is given by the conjugation lemma of [37]: Proposition 4.5 ([37]). Let M(x, λ) = M+ (λ) + (x, λ), with M+ continuous in λ and | (x, λ)| ≤ Ce−ηx , for λ in some compact set . Then, there exists a globally invertible matrix P(x, λ) = I + Q(x, λ) such that the coordinate change z = Pv converts the variable-coefficient ODE z = M(x, λ)z to a constant-coefficient equation v = M+ (λ)v, satisfying for any L, 0 < ηˆ < η a uniform bound ˆ for x ≥ L. |Q(x, λ)| ≤ C(L , η, ˆ η, max |(M+ )i j |, dim M+ )e−ηx
Proof. See [37,49], or Appendix C.
(4.24)
By Proposition 4.5, the solution operator for (4.22) is given by P(x, λ)eλ(J +v+ 11θ+ (λ,v+ ))(x−y) P(y, λ)−1 ,
(4.25)
where P is a uniformly small perturbation of the identity for x ≥ L and L > 0 sufficiently large.
5. Proof of the Main Theorem With these preparations, we turn now to the proof of the main theorem.
22
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
5.1. Boundary estimate. We begin by establishing the following key estimates on + (L), that is, the value of the dual mode W + appearing in (2.20) at the boundary W 1 1 x = L between regular and singular regions. Lemma 5.1. For each γ ≥ 1, for λ on any compact subset of eλ ≥ 0, and L > 0 + normalized as in [13,39,2], sufficiently large, with W 1 1 | ≤ Ce−ηL 1+ (L) − V |W
(5.1)
as v+ → 0, uniformly in λ, where C, η > 0 are independent of L and 1 := (0, 1, (1 + λ¯ )−1 )T V is the limiting direction vector (3.9) appearing in the definition of D 0 . Corollary 5.2. For each γ ≥ 1, under the hypotheses of Lemma 5.1, 1 | ≤ Ce−ηL |W˜ 10+ (L) − V
(5.2)
10+ (L)| ≤ Ce−ηL 1+ (L) − W |W
(5.3)
and
0+ is the solution as v+ → 0, uniformly in λ, where C, η > 0 are independent of L and W 1 of the limiting adjoint eigenvalue system appearing in definition (3.8) of D 0 . Proof of Lemma 5.1. Making the coordinate-change Z˜ := R ∗ W˜ ,
(5.4)
R as in (4.21), reduces the adjoint equation W˜ = −A∗ W˜ to block lower-triangular form, Z˜ = − A˜ ∗ Z˜ ∗ ˜ − λJ + λv+ 11θ+ ) + 11 0 Z , (5.5) = ˜ 1)∗ − f (v) ˆ + λ¯ + λ¯ v+ (θ+ 11)∗ + ( 1 −11T with “¯” denoting complex conjugate. Denoting by V˜1+ a suitably normalized element of the one-dimensional (slow) stable subspace of − A˜ ∗ , we find, similarly as in the discussion of Sect. 3.2 that, without loss of generality, V˜1+ → (0, 1, (γ + λ¯ )−1 )T
(5.6)
0, while the associated eigenvalue µ˜ +1 → 0, uniformly for λ on an compact
eλ ≥ 0. The dual mode Z˜ 1+ = R ∗ W˜ 1+ is uniquely determined by the prop-
as v+ → subset of erty that it is asymptotic as x → +∞ to the corresponding constant-coefficient solution + eµ˜ 1 V˜1+ (the standard normalization of [2,13,39]). By lower block-triangular form (5.5), the equations for the slow variable z˜ T := ( Z˜ 1 , Z˜ 2 ) decouples as a slow system ∗ ˜ z˜ (5.7) z˜ = − λ(J + v+ 11θ+ ) + 11
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
23
dual to (4.22), with solution operator ¯
P ∗ (x, λ)−1 e−λ(J +v+ 11θ+ )
∗ )(x−y)
P(y, λ)∗
(5.8)
dual to—that is, the adjoint inverse of—(4.25), i.e. (fixing y = L, say), having solutions of general form ¯
z˜ (λ, x) = P ∗ (x, λ)−1 e−λ(J +v+ 11θ+ )
∗ )x
v, ˜
(5.9)
v˜ ∈ C2 arbitrary. Denoting by Z˜ 1+ (L) := R ∗ W˜ 1+ (L), therefore, the unique (up to constant factor) decaying solution at +∞, and v˜1+ := ((V˜ + )1 , (V˜ + )2 )T , we thus have evidently 1
1
¯
z˜ 1+ (x, λ) = P ∗ (x, λ)−1 e−λ(J +v+ 11θ+ )
∗ )x
v˜1+ ,
which, as v+ → 0, is uniformly bounded by |˜z 1+ (x, λ)| ≤ Cex
(5.10)
for arbitrarily small > 0 and, by (5.6), converges for x less than or equal to any fixed X simply to lim z˜ 1+ (x, λ) = P ∗ (x, λ)−1 (0, 1)T .
v+ →0
(5.11)
Defining by q˜ := ( Z˜ 1+ )3 the fast coordinate of Z˜ 1+ , we have, by (5.5), ˜ 1)∗ q˜ = 11T z˜ 1+ , ˆ − λ¯ − (λv+ θ+ 11 + 1 q˜ + f (v) whence, by Duhamel’s principle, any decaying solution is given by +∞ x ˜ q(x, ˜ λ) = e y b(z,λ,v+ )dz 11T z 1+ (y) dy, x
where
¯ λ, v+ ) = − f (v) ˜ λ, v+ ) := −b(y, ˜ 1)∗ , ˆ − λ¯ − (λv+ θ+ 11 + 1 b(y,
b as in (4.12). Recalling, for eλ ≥ 0, that eb˜ = − b ≥ 1/2, combining (5.10) and (5.11), and noting that b˜ converges uniformly on y ≤ Y as v+ → 0 for any Y > 0 to ˜ 0 11)∗ ˆ + λ¯ + ( b˜0 (y, λ) := − f 0 (v) = (1 + λ¯ ) + O(e−ηy ), we obtain by the Lebesgue Dominated Convergence Theorem that +∞ L ˜ q(L ˜ , λ) → e y b0 (z,λ)dz 11T (0, 1)T dy L+∞ L −ηz ¯ = e(1+λ)(L−y)+ y O(e )dz dy L
= (1 + λ¯ )−1 (1 + O(e−ηL )).
24
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
Recalling, finally, (5.11), and the fact that |P − I d|(L , λ), |R − I d|(L , λ) ≤ Ce−ηL for v+ sufficiently small, we obtain (5.1) as claimed.
Proof of Corollary 5.2. Applying Proposition 4.5 to the limiting adjoint system, ⎛ ⎞ 0 0 0 0 0 ⎠ W˜ + O(e−ηx )W˜ , W˜ = −(A0 )∗ W˜ = ⎝−λ¯ −1 −1 1 + λ¯ we find that, up to an I d + O(e−ηx ) coordinate change, W˜ 10+ (x) is given by the exact solution W˜ ≡ V˜1 of the limiting, constant-coefficient system ⎛ ⎞ 0 0 0 0 0 ⎠ W˜ . W˜ = −(A0 )∗ W˜ = ⎝−λ¯ −1 −1 1 + λ¯ This yields immediately (5.2), which, together with (5.1), yields (5.3).
Remark 5.3. Noting that (5.2) is sharp, we see from (5.3) that the error between W˜ 1+ (L) and W˜ 10+ (L) is already within the error tolerance of the numerical scheme used to approx 0+ is initialized at x = L with approximate value V˜1 [2,11,39]. imate D 0 , in which W 1 Thus, so long as the flow on the regular region x ≤ L well-approximates the exact limiting flow as v+ → 0, we can expect convergence of D to D 0 based on the known convergence of the numerical approximation scheme. 5.2. Convergence to D 0 . As hinted by Remark 5.3, the rest of our analysis is standard if not entirely routine. Lemma 5.4. For each γ ≥ 1, on x ≤ L for any fixed L > 0, there exists a coordinatechange W = T Z conjugating (2.13) to the limiting equations (3.4), T = T (x, λ, v+ ), satisfying a uniform bound |T − I d| ≤ C(L)v+
(5.12)
for all v+ > 0 sufficiently small. Proof. For x ∈ (−∞, 0], this is a consequence of the Convergence Lemma of [39], a variation on Proposition 4.5, together with uniform convergence of the profile and eigenvalue equations. For x ∈ [0, L], it is essentially continuous dependence; more precisely, observing that |A − A0 | ≤ C1 (L)v+ for x ∈ [0, L], setting S := T − I d, and writing the homological equation expressing conjugacy of (2.13) and (3.4), we obtain S − (AS − S A0 ) = (A − A0 ), which, considered as an inhomogeneous linear matrix-valued equation, yields an exponential growth bound S(x) ≤ eC x (S(0) + C −1 C1 (L)v+ ) for some C > 0, giving the result.
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
25
Proof of Theorem 3.1. Lemma 5.4, together with convergence as v+ → 0 of the unstable subspace of A− to the unstable subspace of A0− at the same rate O(v+ ) (as follows by spectral separation of the unstable eigenvalue of A0 and standard matrix perturbation theory) yields |W1− (0, λ) − W10− (0, λ)| ≤ C(L)v+ .
(5.13)
Likewise, Lemma 5.4 gives |W˜ 1+ (0, λ) − W˜ 10+ (0, λ)| ≤ C(L)v+ |W˜ 1+ (0, λ)| +|S0L→0 ||W˜ 1+ (L , λ) − W˜ 10+ (L , λ)|,
(5.14)
y→x
where S0 denotes the solution operator of the limiting adjoint eigenvalue equation W˜ = −(A0 )∗ W˜ . Applying Proposition 4.5 to the limiting system, we obtain |S0L→0 | ≤ C2 e−A+ L ≤ C2 L|λ| 0
by direct computation of e−A+ L , where C2 is independent of L > 0. Together with (5.3) and (5.14), this gives 0
|W˜ 1+ (0, λ) − W˜ 10+ (0, λ)| ≤ C(L)v+ |W˜ 1+ (0, λ)| + L|λ|C2 Ce−ηL , hence, for |λ| bounded, |W˜ 1+ (0, λ) − W˜ 10+ (0, λ)| ≤ C3 (L)v+ |W˜ 10+ (0, λ)| + LC4 e−ηL ≤ C5 (L)v+ + LC4 e−ηL .
(5.15)
Taking first L → ∞ and then v+ → 0, we obtain therefore convergence of W1+ (0, λ) and W˜ 1+ (0, λ) to W10+ (0, λ) and W˜ 10+ (0, λ), yielding the result by definitions (2.20) and (3.8). 6. Numerical Convergence Having established analytically the convergence of D to D 0 as v+ → 0 (M → ∞), we turn finally to numerics to obtain quantitative information yielding a concrete stability threshold. Specifically, for fixed γ , we numerically compute the “Rouché bound” consisting of the value of v+ at which the maximum relative error |D − D 0 |/|D 0 | over the semicircular contour ∂{ eλ ≥ 0, |λ| ≤ 10} around which we perform our winding number calculations becomes 1/2. Recall that Rouché’s Theorem guarantees for relative error < 1 that the winding number of D is equal to the winding number of D 0 , which we have shown to be zero, hence we may conservatively conclude stability for v+ less than or equal to this bound, or M greater than or equal to the corresponding Mach number. Computations are performed using the algorithm of [2]; results are displayed in Table 1. More detailed results are displayed for the monatomic gas case γ = 5/3 in Table 2. Results are similar for other γ ∈ [1, 3], as may be seen by comparing Figs. 2–4. From the quantitative gap and conjugation estimates given in Appendix C, which in turn yield a quantitative version of the Convergence Lemma of [39], one could in principle establish quantitative convergence rates for |D − D 0 |, by tracking constants carefully through the estimates of the previous sections. Indeed, one could do much better than the rather crude bounds stated for the general case by taking into account the
26
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun Table 1. Rouché bounds for various γ
γ
v+
Relative Error
Mach Number
3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0
1.27e-3 1.36e-3 1.49e-3 1.75e-3 2.8e-3
.5009 .5006 .5001 .4999 .4995
12765 2423 474 95.5 18.9
Table 2. Maximum relative and absolute differences between D and D 0 , for γ = 5/3 and λ on the semicircle of radius 10 v+
Mach Number
Relative Difference
Absolute Difference
1.0 (−6) 1.0 (−5) 1.0 (−4) 1.0 (−3) 1.0 (−2) 1.0 (−1)
7.71 (4) 1.13 (4) 1.64 (3) 2.44 (2) 36.1 5.50
0.1221 0.1236 0.1487 0.4098 0.9046 1.2386
0.0601 0.1445 0.4714 1.3464 2.8253 3.8688
eigenstructure of the actual matrices A± , A0± appearing in our analysis, and (crucial for good estimates, since bounds grow exponentially with dimension n) by observing that it suffices to use the gap and not the full conjugation lemma for the estimation of the single dual mode at plus infinity. That is, there are contained in our analysis, as in the study of [2], all of the ingredients needed for a numerical proof. Given the fundamental nature of the problem studied, this would be a very interesting program to carry out.
7. Discussion and Open Problems Besides long-time stability, our results have application also to existence of shock layers in the small-viscosity limit, which likewise reduces to the question of stability of the Evans function [17,41]. Indeed, spectral stability has been a key missing piece in several directions [48,49]. Our methods should have application also to spectral stability of large-amplitude noncharacteristic boundary layers, completing the investigations of [16,37,44]. It may be hoped that they will extend also to full gas dynamics and multi-dimensions, two important directions for further investigation. As discussed in the text, the problems of numerical proof and of stability in the large-γ limit are two other interesting directions for further study. More speculatively, our results suggest the possibility of a large-variation version of the results obtained by quite different methods in [7] on general viscous solutions (including not only noninteracting shocks, but shocks, rarefactions, and their interactions), and, through the physical insight provided into the high-Mach number limit, perhaps even a hint toward possible methods of analysis. Note that the results of [7] include not only convergence in the small-viscosity limit but also bounded L 1 stability for constant viscosity of general small-variation solutions. This would be an extremely interesting direction for further investigation.
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
27
Appendix A. Proofs of Preliminary Estimates Proof of Proposition 2.1. Existence and monotonicity follow trivially by the fact that (2.4) is a scalar first-order ODE with convex righthand side. Exponential convergence as x → +∞ follows, for example, by the computation (v+ − 1)(v −γ − 1) H (v, v+ ) = v (v − 1) − −γ v+ − 1 1 − v+ v+ γ = v (v − v+ ) + − 1 γ v 1 − v+ γ 1 − vv+ 1 − v+ = (v − v+ ) v − , γ 1 − vv+ 1 − v+ yielding v−γ ≤
H (v, v+ ) ≤ v − (1 − v+ ) v − v+ γ
by the elementary estimate 1 ≤ 1−x 1−x ≤ γ for 0 ≤ x ≤ 1. Convergence as x → −∞ follows by a similar, but simpler computation; see [2]. Lemma A.1. For each γ ≥ 1, the following identity holds for eλ ≥ 0: 1 ( e(λ) + |m(λ)|) v|u| ˆ 2− vˆ x |u|2 + |u |2 2 R R R √ h(v) ˆ ≤ 2 |v ||u| + v|u ˆ ||u|. γ R vˆ R
(A.1)
Proof. We multiply (2.9b) by vˆ u¯ and integrate along x. This yields h(v) ˆ ˆ 2+ vu ˆ u¯ + |u |2 = v u. ¯ λ v|u| γ R R R R vˆ We get (A.1) by taking the√ real and imaginary parts and adding them together, and noting that | e(z)| + |m(z)| ≤ 2|z|. Lemma A.2. For each γ ≥ 1, the following identity holds for eλ ≥ 0: h(v) ˆ |v |2 1 aγ |v |2 . + |u |2 = 2 e(λ)2 |v|2 + e(λ) + 2 R vˆ γ +1 vˆ γ +1 R R R vˆ
(A.2)
Proof. We multiply (2.9b) by v¯ and integrate along x. This yields h(v) ˆ 2 1 1 u (λv + v )v¯ . u v¯ − |v | = v ¯ = λ u v¯ + γ +1 R R R vˆ R vˆ R vˆ Using (2.9a) on the right-hand side, integrating by parts, and taking the real part gives h(v) ˆ |v |2 vˆ x 2 |v .
e λ u v¯ + u v¯ = + | +
e(λ) γ +1 2vˆ 2 R R R vˆ R vˆ
28
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
The right hand side can be rewritten as 1 h(v) ˆ |v |2 aγ 2 |v u v¯ = + | +
e(λ)
e λ u v¯ + . 2 R vˆ γ +1 vˆ γ +1 R R R vˆ
(A.3)
Now we manipulate the left-hand side. Note that ¯ λ u v¯ + u v¯ = (λ + λ) u v¯ − u(λ¯ v¯ + v¯ ) R R R R = −2 e(λ) u v¯ − u u¯ R R = −2 e(λ) (λv + v )v¯ + |u |2 . R
R
Hence, by taking the real part we get u v¯ = |u |2 − 2 e(λ)2 |v|2 .
e λ u v¯ + R
R
R
R
This combines with (A.3) to give (A.2). Lemma A.3. For each γ ≥ 1, for h(v) ˆ as in (2.8), we have h(v) ˆ 1 − v+ sup γ = γ γ ≤ γ. vˆ 1 − v+ vˆ
(A.4)
Proof. Defining g(v) ˆ := h(v) ˆ vˆ −γ = −vˆ + a(γ − 1)vˆ −γ + (a + 1),
(A.5)
ˆ = −1 − aγ (γ − 1)vˆ −γ −1 < 0 for 0 < v+ ≤ vˆ ≤ v− = 1, hence the we have g (v) maximum of g on vˆ ∈ [v+ , v− ] is achieved at vˆ = v+ . Substituting (2.5) into (A.5) and simplifying yields (A.4). Proof of Proposition 2.2. Using Young’s inequality twice on right-hand side of (A.1) together with (A.4), we get 1 ( e(λ) + |m(λ)|) v|u| ˆ 2− vˆ x |u|2 + |u |2 2 R R R √ h(v) ˆ ≤ 2 |v ||u| + v|u ˆ ||u| γ R vˆ R √ h(v) ˆ 2 ( 2)2 h(v) ˆ 1 2 2 ≤θ |v | + v|u| ˆ + v|u ˆ | + v|u| ˆ 2 γ +1 γ 4θ 4 R R vˆ R vˆ R 1 h(v) ˆ 2 γ 2 + <θ |v | + |u | + v|u| ˆ 2. γ +1 2θ 4 R R vˆ R Assuming that 0 < < 1 and θ = (1 − )/2, this simplifies to ( e(λ) + |m(λ)|) v|u| ˆ 2 + (1 − ) |u |2 R R 1 h(v) ˆ 2 1− γ + < |v | + v|u| ˆ 2. γ +1 2 2θ 4 R R vˆ
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
Applying (A.2) yields
29
( e(λ) + |m(λ)|)
R
v|u| ˆ 2<
1 γ + 1 − 4
R
v|u| ˆ 2,
or equivalently, ( e(λ) + |m(λ)|) < √ Setting = 1/(2 γ + 1) gives (2.11).
(4γ − 1) − 1 . 4(1 − )
Appendix B. Nonvanishing of D0 As pointed out in Sect. 3.3, the limiting eigenvalue system (3.3), (3.4), together with the limiting boundary conditions derived in Sect. 3.2 may be expressed equivalently as the integrated eigenvalue problem λv + v − u = 0, 1 − vˆ u v = , λu + u − vˆ vˆ corresponding to a pressureless gas, γ = 0, with special boundary conditions
(B.1b)
(u, u , v, v )(−∞) = (0, 0, 0, 0), (u, u , v, v )(+∞) = (c, 0, 0, 0).
(B.2)
(B.1a)
Motivated by this observation, we establish stability of the limiting system by a Matsumura–Nishihara-type spectral energy estimate exactly analogous to that used to prove stability for γ = 1 in [2,36]. Proof of Proposition 3.5. Multiplying (B.1b) by vˆ u/(1 ¯ − v) ˆ and integrating on some subinterval [a.b] ⊂ R, we obtain b b b b vˆ vˆ u u¯ 2 |u| d x + u ud d x. λ ¯ x− v ud ¯ x= 1 − v ˆ 1 − v ˆ 1 − vˆ a a a a Integrating the third and fourth terms by parts yields b b vˆ 1 vˆ u ud |u|2 d x + + λ ¯ x 1 − vˆ 1 − vˆ a 1 − vˆ a b 2 b |u | + dx + v(λv + v )d x a 1 − vˆ a u u¯ b = v u¯ + . 1 − vˆ a Taking the real part, we have b b 2 b vˆ |u | 2 2 2 |u| + |v| d x + dx g(v)|u| ˆ dx +
e(λ) 1 − vˆ a a a 1 − vˆ u u¯ 1 vˆ 1 |v|2 b |u|2 − = e v u¯ + − + a , 1 − vˆ 2 1 − vˆ 1 − vˆ 2
(B.3)
30
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
where g(v) ˆ =− Note that d dx
1 1 − vˆ
=−
1 2
vˆ 1 − vˆ
+
1 1 − vˆ
.
(1 − v) ˆ vˆ x v( ˆ vˆ − 1) vˆ . = = =− (1 − v) ˆ 2 (1 − v) ˆ 2 (1 − v) ˆ 2 1 − vˆ
Thus, g(v) ˆ ≡ 0 and the third term on the right-hand side vanishes, leaving b 2 b vˆ |u | |u|2 + |v|2 d x + dx
e(λ) 1 − v ˆ 1 − vˆ a a
e(u u) |v|2 b ¯ = e(v u) ¯ + − a . 1 − vˆ 2 We show next that the right-hand side goes to zero in the limit as a → −∞ and b → ∞. By Proposition 4.5, the behavior of u, v near ±∞ is governed by the limiting constant–coefficient systems W = A0± (λ)W , where W = (u, v, v )T and A0± = A0 (±∞, λ). In particular, solutions W asymptotic to (1, 0, 0) at x = +∞ decay exponentially in (u , v, v ) and are bounded in coordinate u as x → +∞. Observing that 1 − vˆ → 1 as x → +∞, we thus see immediately that the boundary contribution at b vanishes as b → +∞. The situation at −∞ is more delicate, since the denominator 1 − vˆ of the second term goes to zero at rate e x as x → −∞, the rate of convergence of the limiting profile v. ˆ By inspection, the limiting coefficient matrix ⎛ ⎞ 0 λ 1 1 ⎠, A0− = ⎝0 0 (B.4) λ λ 1−λ has eigenvalues 1±
√
1 + 4λ , 2 hence for eλ ≥ 0 the unique decaying mode at x = +∞ is the unstable eigenvector √ corresponding to µ = 1+ 21+4λ , with growth rate √ 1 + 1 + 4λ 1 1 √
e = + e 1 + 4λ > 1/2. 2 2 2 µ = −λ,
Thus, |u|, |u |, |v |, |v| ≤ Ce(1+)x/2 as x → −∞, > 0, and in particular e(u u) ¯ (1+)x x /e ≤ Cex → 0 1 − vˆ ≤ Ce as x → −∞. It follows that the boundary contribution at x = a vanishes also as a → −∞, hence, in the limit as a → −∞, b → +∞, +∞ +∞ 2 vˆ |u |
e(λ) |u|2 + |v|2 d x + d x = 0. (B.5) 1 − vˆ −∞ −∞ 1 − vˆ
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
31
But, for eλ ≥ 0, this implies u ≡ 0, or u ≡ constant, which, by u(−∞) = 0, implies u ≡ 0. This reduces (B.1a) to v = λv, yielding the explicit solution v = Ceλx . By v(±∞) = 0, therefore, v ≡ 0 for eλ ≥ 0. It follows that there are no nontrivial solutions of (B.1), (B.2) for eλ ≥ 0. Remark B.1. The above is equivalent to multiplying the system by the energy estimate 1 0 special symmetrizer , then taking the L 2 inner product with (v, u)T . The 0 v/(1 ˆ − v) ˆ analog of the high-frequency estimates of Appendix A would be obtained using the alter 1 − vˆ 0 native symmetrizer optimized for its effect on second-order derivative term 0 vˆ u /v. ˆ This may clarify somewhat the strategy of the energy estimates used in [2,36].
Appendix C. Quantitative Conjugation Estimates Consider a general first-order system W = A(x, λ)W.
(C.1)
Proposition C.1 (Quantitative Gap Lemma [13,50]). Let V + and µ+ be an eigenvector and associated eigenvalue of A+ (λ) and suppose that there exist complementary generalized eigenprojections (i.e., A-invariant projections) P and Q such that |Pe(A+ −µ
+ )x
ˆ | ≤ C1 e−ηx x ≤ 0,
−µ+ )x
ˆ |Qe(A+ | ≤ C1 e−ηx x ≥ 0, −ηx |(A − A+ )(x)| ≤ C2 e x ≥ 0,
(C.2)
with 0 ≤ ηˆ < η. Then, there exists a solution W = eµ x V (x, λ) of (C.1) with +
C1 C2 e−ηx |V (x, λ) − V + (λ)| ≤ for x ≥ L |V + (λ)| (η − η)(1 ˆ − )
(C.3)
provided (η − η) ˆ −1 C1 C2 e−ηL ≤ < 1. Proof. Writing V = (A+ − µ+ )V + (A − A+ )V and imposing the limiting behavior V (+∞, λ) = V + , we seek a solution in the form V = T V ,
+∞
Pe(A+ −µ )(x−y) (A − A+ )V (y)dy T V (x) := V − x x + Qe(A+ −µ )(x−y) (A − A+ )V (y)dy, + +
L
+
32
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
from which the result follows by a straightforward Contraction Mapping argument, using (C.2) to compute that +∞ + Pe(A+ −µ )(x−y) (A − A+ )(V1 − V2 )(y)dy |T V1 − T V2 |(x) = − x x + Qe(A+ −µ )(x−y) (A − A+ )(V1 − V2 )(y)dy + L +∞ ˆ ≤ C1 C2 e−η(x−y) e−ηy dy V1 − V2 L ∞ [L ,+∞) L
ˆ e−(η−η)L ˆ C1 C2 e−ηx
V1 − V2 L ∞ [L ,+∞) , = η − ηˆ
and thus T V1 − T V2 L ∞ [L ,+∞) ≤
C1 C2 e−ηL
V1 η−ηˆ
− V2 L ∞ [L ,+∞) .
Corollary C.2. Let V + and µ+ be an eigenvector and associated eigenvalue of A+ (λ), where A+ is n × n with at most k eigenvalues of real part < µ+ and max |(A+ − µ)i j | ≤ C0 ;
|(A − A+ )(x)| ≤ C2 e−ηx x ≥ 0,
(C.4)
0 < ηˆ < η. Then, there exists a solution W = eµ x V (x, λ) of (C.1) with +
ˆ 16nn!(C0 )n C2 e−ηx |V (x, λ) − V + (λ)| ≤ for x ≥ L, |V + (λ)| δ n (η − η)(1 ˆ − )
δ :=
η−ηˆ 2k+2 ,
provided
ˆ 16nn!(C0 )n C2 e−ηL δ n (η−η) ˆ
(C.5)
≤ < 1.
Proof. Without loss of generality, take µ ≡ 0. Dividing [−η, −η] ˆ into k + 1 equal subintervals, we find by the pigeonhole principle that at least one subinterval contains the real part of no eigenvalue of A+ . Denoting the midpoint of this interval by −η˜ > η, ˆ we have min | eσ (A+ ) − η| ˜ ≥ δ :=
η − ηˆ . 2k + 2
(C.6)
Defining P to be the total eigenprojection of A+ associated with eigenvalues of real part greater than ηˆ and Q the total eigenprojection associated with eigenvalues of real part less than η, ˆ and estimating Pe A+ x , Qe A+ x using the inverse Laplace transform representation 1 e A+ x = e zx (z − A+ )−1 dz, 2πi with chosen to be a rectangle of side 4nC0 centered about the real axis, with one vertical side passing through eλ ≡ −η˜ and the other respectively lying respectively to the right and to the left, and estimating |(λ − A+ )−1 | ≤ n!C0n−1 δ −n crudely by Kramer’s rule, we obtain (C.2) with C1 = 16nn!C0n δ −n , whence the result follows by Proposition C.1.
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
33
Corollary C.3 (Quantitative Conjugation Lemma). Proposition 4.5 holds for 0 < < 1 with C(L , η, ˆ η, max |(M+ )i j |, dim M+ ) = n := (dim M+ )2 , k :=
(dim M+ )2 −dim M , 2
when
ˆ 16nn!(C0 )n C2 e−ηx , δ n (η − η)(1 ˆ − )
ˆ 16nn!(C0 )n C2 e−ηL δ n (η−η) ˆ
≤ .
Proof. Writing the homological equation expressing conjugacy of variable- and constant-coefficient systems following [37], we have P = M+ P − P M+ + M. Considering this as an asymptotically constant-coefficient system on the n 2 -dimensional vector space of matrices P, noting that the linear operator M+ P := M+ P − P M+ , as a Sylvester matrix, has at least n zero eigenvalues and equal numbers of stable and unstable eigenvalues, we see that the number of its stable eigenvalues is not more than 2 k := n 2−n , whence the result follows by Corollary C.2.
Appendix D. An Illuminating Example Consider Burgers’ equation, u t + (u 2 )x = u x x , and the family of stationary viscous shock solutions uˆ (x) := − tanh(x/2),
lim uˆ (z) = ∓
z→±∞
(D.1)
of amplitude |u + − u − | = 2 going to zero as → 0. The linearized eigenvalue equation u = (uˆ u) + λu about u¯ , expressed in the x integrated variable w(x) := −∞ u(y)dy, appears as w = uˆ w + λw.
(D.2)
This reduces by the linearized Hopf–Cole transformation w = sech(x/2)z to the constant-coefficient linear oscillator equation z = (λ + 2 /4)z, yielding exact solutions √ 2 w ± (x, λ) = sech(x/2)e∓ /4+λx (D.3) decaying, respectively, as x → ±∞, with asymptotic behavior (D.4) W ± (x, λ) ∼ eµ± (λ)x V± (λ), where µ± (λ) := ∓(/2 + 2 /4 + λ and V± := (1, µ± (λ))T are the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the limiting constant-coefficient equations at plus and minus spatial T. infinity written as a first-order system, W± := (w, w )± − + Defining an Evans function D(λ) := det(W , W )|x=0 , we may compute explicitly (D.5) D(λ) = −2 2 /4 + λ.
34
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
However, this is not “the” Evans function D(λ) := det(W − , W + )|x=0 specified in Sect. 2.4, which is constructed, rather, from a special basis W± = c± (λ)W ± ∼ eµ± x V ± , where V± = c± (λ)V ± are “Kato” eigenvectors determined uniquely (up to a constant factor independent of λ) by the property that there exist corresponding left eigenvectors V˜ ± such that (V˜ · V )± ≡ constant, (V˜ · V˙ )± ≡ 0,
(D.6)
where “ ˙ ” denotes d/dλ; see [26,13,22] for further discussion. Computing dual eigenvectors V˜ ± = (λ + µ2 )−1 (λ, µ± ) satisfying (V˜ · V)± ≡ 1, and setting V ± = c± V ± , V˜ ± = V ± /c± , we find after a brief calculation that (D.6) is equivalent to the complex ODE, ± V˜ · V˙ µ˙ c˙± = − c± = − c± , (D.7) 2µ − ± V˜ · V which may be solved by exponentiation, yielding the general solution c± (λ) = C( 2 /4 + λ)−1/4 .
(D.8)
Initializing at a fixed nonzero point, without loss of generality c± (1) = 1,5 and noting that D (λ) = c− c+ D (λ), we thus obtain the remarkable formula (D.9) D (λ) ≡ −2 2 /4 + 1. That is, with the “Kato” normalization, the Evans function associated with a Burgers shock is not only stable (nonvanishing), but identically constant. Moreover, in the weak shock limit, → 0, D (λ) converges uniformly to the constant function D0 (λ) ≡ −2.6 References 1. Alexander, J., Gardner, R., Jones, C.: A topological invariant arising in the stability analysis of travelling waves. J. Reine Angew. Math. 410, 167–212 (1990) 2. Barker, B., Humpherys, J., Rudd, K., Zumbrun, K.: Stability of viscous shocks in isentropic gas dynamics. Commun. Math. Phys. 281(1), 231–249 (2008) 3. Barmin, A.A., Egorushkin, S.A.: Stability of shock waves. Adv. Mech. 15(1–2), 3–37 (1992) 4. Batchelor, G.K.: An introduction to fluid dynamics. Cambridge Mathematical Library. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999 5. Bertozzi, A.L., Brenner, M.P.: Linear stability and transient growth in driven contact lines. Phys. Fluids 9(3), 530–539 (1997) 6. Bertozzi, A.L., Münch, A., Fanton, X., Cazabat, A.M.: Contact line stability and undercompressive shocks in driven thin film flow. Phys. Rev. Lett. 81(23), 5169–5172 (1998) 7. Bianchini, S., Bressan, A.: Vanishing viscosity solutions of nonlinear hyperbolic systems. Ann. Math. (2) 161(1), 223–342 (2005) 5 In the numerics of Sect. 6, we initialize always at λ = 10. 6 Not to be confused with the limiting Evans function D 0 in the strong shock limit v → 0. +
Stability of Isentropic Navier–Stokes Shocks
35
8. Bridges, T.J., Derks, G., Gottwald, G.: Stability and instability of solitary waves of the fifth-order KdV equation: a numerical framework. Phys. D 172(1-4), 190–216 (2002) 9. Brin, L.Q.: Numerical testing of the stability of viscous shock waves. PhD thesis, Indiana University, Bloomington, 1998 10. Brin, L.Q.: Numerical testing of the stability of viscous shock waves. Math. Comp. 70(235), 1071–1088 (2001) 11. Brin, L.Q., Zumbrun, K.: Analytically varying eigenvectors and the stability of viscous shock waves. In: Seventh Workshop on Partial Differential Equations, Part I (Rio de Janeiro, 2001). Mat. Contemp. 22, 19–32, (2002). 12. Freistühler, H., Szmolyan, P.: Spectral stability of small shock waves. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 164(4), 287–309 (2002) 13. Gardner, R.A., Zumbrun, K.: The gap lemma and geometric criteria for instability of viscous shock profiles. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 51(7), 797–855 (1998) 14. Goodman, J.: Nonlinear asymptotic stability of viscous shock profiles for conservation laws. Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 95(4), 325–344 (1986) 15. Goodman, J.: Remarks on the stability of viscous shock waves. In: Viscous profiles and numerical methods for shock waves (Raleigh, NC, 1990), Philadelphia, PA: SIAM, 1991, pp. 66–72 16. Grenier, E., Rousset, F.: Stability of one-dimensional boundary layers by using Green’s functions. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 54(11), 1343–1385 (2001) 17. Guès, C.M.I.O., Métivier, G., Williams, M., Zumbrun, K.: Navier-Stokes regularization of multidimensional Euler shocks. Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup. (4) 39(1), 75–175 (2006) 18. Hoff, D.: The zero-Mach limit of compressible flows. Commun. Math. Phys. 192(3), 543–554 (1998) 19. Hoover, W.G.: Structure of a shock-wave front in a liquid. Phys. Rev. Lett. 42(23), 1531–1534 (1979) 20. Howard, P., Raoofi, M.: Pointwise asymptotic behavior of perturbed viscous shock profiles. Adv. Differ. Eqs. 11(9), 1031–1080 (2006) 21. Howard, P., Raoofi, M., Zumbrun, K.: Sharp pointwise bounds for perturbed viscous shock waves. J. Hyperbolic Differ. Eq. 3(2), 297–373 (2006) 22. Humpherys, J., Sandstede, B., Zumbrun, K.: Efficient computation of analytic bases in Evans function analysis of large systems. Numer. Math. 103(4), 631–642 (2006) 23. Humpherys, J., Zumbrun, K.: Spectral stability of small-amplitude shock profiles for dissipative symmetric hyperbolic-parabolic systems. Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 53(1), 20–34 (2002) 24. Humpherys, J., Zumbrun, K.: An efficient shooting algorithm for Evans function calculations in large systems. Phys. D 220(2), 116–126 (2006) 25. Il’in, A.M., Ole˘ınik, O.A.: Behavior of solutions of the Cauchy problem for certain quasilinear equations for unbounded increase of the time. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 120, 25–28 (1958); (see also AMS Translations 42(2), 19–23 (1964). 26. Kato, T.: Perturbation theory for linear operators. Classics in Mathematics. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1995, reprint of the 1980 edition 27. Klainerman, S., Majda, A.: Compressible and incompressible fluids. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 35(5), 629– 651 (1982) 28. Kreiss, G., Liefvendahl, M.: Numerical investigation of examples of unstable viscous shock waves. In: Hyperbolic problems: theory, numerics, applications, Vol. I, II (Magdeburg, 2000), Volume 141 of Internat. Ser. Numer. Math., Basel: Birkhäuser, 2001 pp. 613–621 29. Kreiss, H.-O., Lorenz, J., Naughton, M.J.: Convergence of the solutions of the compressible to the solutions of the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations. Adv. in Appl. Math. 12(2), 187–214 (1991) 30. Liu, T.-P.: Nonlinear stability of shock waves for viscous conservation laws. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 56(328), v–108 (1985) 31. Liu, T.-P.: Pointwise convergence to shock waves for viscous conservation laws. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 50(11), 1113–1182 (1997) 32. Liu, T.-P., Yu, S.-H.: Boltzmann equation: micro-macro decompositions and positivity of shock profiles. Commun. Math. Phys. 246(1), 133–179 (2004) 33. Mascia, C., Zumbrun, K.: Pointwise Green function bounds for shock profiles of systems with real viscosity. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 169(3), 177–263 (2003) 34. Mascia, C., Zumbrun, K.: Stability of large-amplitude viscous shock profiles of hyperbolic-parabolic systems. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 172(1), 93–131 (2004) 35. Mascia, C., Zumbrun, K.: Stability of small-amplitude shock profiles of symmetric hyperbolic-parabolic systems. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 57(7), 841–876 (2004) 36. Matsumura, A., Nishihara, K.: On the stability of travelling wave solutions of a one-dimensional model system for compressible viscous gas. Japan J. Appl. Math. 2(1), 17–25 (1985) 37. Métivier, G., Zumbrun, K.: Large viscous boundary layers for noncharacteristic nonlinear hyperbolic problems. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 175(826), vi+107 (2005)
36
J. Humpherys, O. Lafitte, K. Zumbrun
38. Pego, R.L., Weinstein, M.I.: Eigenvalues, and instabilities of solitary waves. Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. London Ser. A 340(1656), 47–94 (1992) 39. Plaza, R., Zumbrun, K.: An Evans function approach to spectral stability of small-amplitude shock profiles. Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. 10(4), 885–924 (2004) 40. Raoofi, M.: L p asymptotic behavior of perturbed viscous shock profiles. J. Hyperbolic Differ. Equ. 2(3), 595–644 (2005) 41. Rousset, F.: Viscous approximation of strong shocks of systems of conservation laws. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 35(2), 492–519 (electronic), (2003) 42. Serre, D.: Systems of conservation laws. 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999, translated from the 1996 French original by I. N. Sneddon 43. Serre, D.: Systems of conservation laws. 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000. translated from the 1996 French original by I. N. Sneddon 44. Serre, D., Zumbrun, K.: Boundary layer stability in real vanishing viscosity limit. Commun. Math. Phys. 221(2), 267–292 (2001) 45. Smoller, J.: Shock waves and reaction-diffusion equations. 2nd ed. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1994 46. Szepessy, A., Xin, Z.P.: Nonlinear stability of viscous shock waves. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 122(1), 53–103 (1993) 47. Zumbrun, K.: Refined wave-tracking and nonlinear stability of viscous Lax shocks. Meth. Appl. Anal. 7(4), 747–768 (2000) 48. Zumbrun, K.: Multidimensional stability of planar viscous shock waves. In: Advances in the theory of shock waves, Volume 47 of Progr. Nonlinear Differential Equations Appl. Boston, MA: Birkhäuser Boston, 2001, pp. 307–516 49. Zumbrun, K.: Stability of large-amplitude shock waves of compressible Navier-Stokes equations. In: Handbook of mathematical fluid dynamics. Vol. III, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 2004, pp. 311–533 with an appendix by Helge Kristian Jenssen and Gregory Lyng 50. Zumbrun, K., Howard, P.: Pointwise semigroup methods and stability of viscous shock waves. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 47(3), 741–871 (1998) Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 293, 37–83 (2010) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-009-0940-z
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds Jeremy Marzuola1 , Jason Metcalfe2 , Daniel Tataru3 , Mihai Tohaneanu4 1 Department of Applied Physics and Applied Mathematics, Columbia University,
New York, NY 10027, USA
2 Department of Mathematics, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill,
NC 27599-3250, USA
3 Department of Mathematics, University of California, Berkeley,
CA 94720-3840, USA
4 Department of Mathematics, Purdue University, West Lafayette,
IN 47907-2067, USA Received: 9 April 2008 / Accepted: 13 August 2009 Published online: 4 November 2009 – © The Author(s) 2009. This article is published with open access at Springerlink.com
Abstract: We study dispersive properties for the wave equation in the Schwarzschild space-time. The first result we obtain is a local energy estimate. This is then used, following the spirit of [29], to establish global-in-time Strichartz estimates. A considerable part of the paper is devoted to a precise analysis of solutions near the trapping region, namely the photon sphere. 1. Introduction The aim of this article is to contribute to the understanding of the global-in-time dispersive properties of solutions to wave equations on Schwarzschild black hole backgrounds. Precisely, we consider two robust ways to measure dispersion, namely the local energy estimates and the Strichartz estimates. Let us begin with the local energy estimates. For solutions to the constant coefficient wave equation in 3 + 1 dimensions, u = 0,
u(0) = u 0 , u t (0) = u 1 ,
we have the original estimates of Morawetz [33], 1 t 1 | ∇ u|2 (t, x) dt d x ∇u 0 2L 2 + u 1 2L 2 , 3 |x| 0 R
(1.1)
where ∇ denotes the angular derivative. To prove this one multiplies the wave equation by the multiplier (∂r + r1 )u and integrates by parts. Within dyadic spatial regions one can also control u, ∂t u and ∂r u. Precisely, we have the local energy estimates The authors were supported in part by the NSF grants DMS0354539 and DMS0301122. 1 There is another estimate commonly referred to as a Morawetz estimate. This corresponds to using the multiplier (t 2 + r 2 )∂t + 2tr ∂r . We will reserve the term Morawetz estimate for (1.1) and shall call the latter
estimate the Morawetz conformal estimate.
38
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu 1
3
R − 2 ∇u L 2 (R×B(0,R)) + R − 2 u L 2 (R×B(0,R)) ∇u 0 L 2 + u 1 L 2 .
(1.2)
See for instance [20,22,40–42]. One can also consider the inhomogeneous problem, u = f,
u(0) = u 0 , u t (0) = u 1 .
In view of (1.2) we define the local energy space L E M for the solution u by j 3j u L E M = sup 2− 2 ∇u L 2 (A j ) + 2− 2 u L 2 (A j ) , j∈Z
(1.3)
(1.4)
where A j = R × {2 j ≤ |x| ≤ 2 j+1 }. For the inhomogeneous term f we introduce a dual type norm j 2 2 f L 2 (A j ) . f L E ∗M = j∈Z
Then we have: Theorem 1.1. The solution u to (1.3) satisfies the following estimate: u L E M ∇u 0 L 2 + u 1 L 2 + f L E ∗M .
(1.5)
One may ask whether similar bounds also hold for perturbations of the Minkowski space-time. Indeed, in the case of small long range perturbations the same bounds as above were established very recently by two of the authors, see [30, Prop. 2.2] or [28, (2.23)] (with no obstacle, = ∅). See also [1,27] for related local energy estimates for small perturbations of the d’Alembertian. For large perturbations one faces additional difficulties, due on one hand to trapping for large frequencies and on the other hand to eigenvalues and resonances for low frequencies. The Schwarzschild space-time, considered in the present paper, is a very interesting example of a large perturbation of the Minkowski space-time, where trapping causes significant difficulties. The Schwarzschild space-time M is a spherically symmetric solution to Einstein’s equations with an additional Killing vector field K , which models the exterior of a massive spherically symmetric body. Factoring out the S2 component it can be represented via the Penrose diagram in Fig. 1. The radius r of the S2 spheres is intrinsically determined and is a smooth function on M which has a single critical point at the center. The regions I and I represent the exterior of the black hole, respectively its symmetric twin, and are characterized by the relation r > 2M. We can represent I as I = R × (2M, ∞) × S2 with a metric whose line element is 2M 2M −1 2 2 2 ds = − 1 − dt + 1 − dr + r 2 dω2 , r r
(1.6)
where dω2 is the measure on the sphere S2 . The Killing vector field K is given by K = ∂t , which is time-like within I . The differential dt is intrinsic, but the function t is only defined up to translations on I .
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
39
Fig. 1. The Penrose diagram for the Kruskal extension of the Schwarzschild solution
The regions I I and I I represent the black hole, respectively its symmetric twin, the white hole, and are characterized by the relation r < 2M. The same metric as in (1.6) can be used. The Killing vector field K is still given by K = ∂t , which is now space-like. Light rays can enter the black hole but not leave it. By symmetry light rays can leave the white hole but not enter it. The surface r = 2M is called the event horizon. While the singularity at r = 0 is a true metric singularity, we note that the apparent singularity at r = 2M is merely a coordinate singularity. Indeed, denote r ∗ = r + 2M log(r − 2M) − 3M − 2M log M, so that
2M −1 dr ∗ = 1 − dr, r
r ∗ (3M) = 0
and set v = t + r ∗ . Then in the (r, v, ω) coordinates the metric in region I is expressed in the form 2M 2 dv 2 + 2dvdr + r 2 dω2 , ds = − 1 − r which extends analytically into the black hole region I + I I . In particular, given a choice of the function t in region I , this uniquely determines the function t in the region I I via the same change of coordinates. In a symmetric fashion we set w = t − r ∗ . Then in the (r, w, ω) coordinates the metric is expressed in the form 2M ds 2 = − 1 − dw 2 − 2dwdr + r 2 dω2 , r which extends analytically into the white hole region I + I I . One can also introduce global nonsingular coordinates by rewriting the metric in the Kruskal-Szekeres coordinate system, v
v = e 4M ,
w
w = −e− 4M .
40
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
However, this is of less interest for our purposes here. Further information on the Schwarzschild space can be found in a number of excellent texts. We refer the interested reader to, e.g., [18,31 and 51]. As far as the results in this paper are concerned, for large r the Schwarzschild spacetime can be viewed as a small perturbation of the Minkowski space-time. The difficulties in our analysis are caused by the dynamics for small r , where trapping occurs. The presence of trapped rays, i.e. rays which do not escape either to infinity or to the singularity r = 0, are known to be a significant obstacle to proving local energy, dispersive, and Strichartz estimates and, in some cases, are known to necessitate a loss of regularity. See, e.g., [10 and 37]. There are two places where trapping occurs on the Schwarzschild manifold. The first is the surface r = 3M which is called the photon sphere. Null geodesics which are initially tangent to the photon sphere will remain on the surface for all times. Microlocally the energy is preserved near such periodic orbits. However what allows for local energy estimates near the photon sphere is the fact that these periodic orbits are hyperbolic. The second is at the event horizon r = 2M, where the trapped geodesics are the vertical ones in the (r, v, ω) coordinates. However, this second family of trapped rays turns out to cause no difficulty in the decay estimates since in the high frequency limit the energy decays exponentially along it as v → ∞. This is due to the fact that the frequency decays exponentially along the Hamilton flow, and in the physics literature it is well-known as the red shift effect. To describe the decay properties of solutions to the wave equation in the Schwarzschild space, it is convenient to use coordinates which make good use of the Killing vector field and are nonsingular along the event horizon. The (r, v, ω) coordinates would satisfy these requirements. However the level sets of v are null surfaces, which would cause some minor difficulties. This is why in I + I I we introduce the function v˜ defined by v˜ = v − µ(r ), where µ is a smooth function of r . In the (v, ˜ r, ω) coordinates the metric has the form 2M 2M 2 2 ds = − 1 − d v˜ + 2 1 − 1 − µ (r ) d vdr ˜ r r 2M (µ (r ))2 dr 2 + r 2 dω2 . + 2µ (r ) − 1 − r On the function µ we impose the following two conditions: (i) µ(r ) ≥ r ∗ for r > 2M, with equality for r > 5M/2. (ii) The surfaces v˜ = const are space-like, i.e. 2M µ (r ) > 0, µ (r ) > 0. 2− 1− r The first condition (i) insures that the (r, v, ˜ ω) coordinates coincide with the (r, t, ω) coordinates in r > 5M/2. This is convenient but not required for any of our results. What is important is that in these coordinates the metric is asymptotically flat as r → ∞. −1 near In the proof of the Strichartz estimates, it is also required that µ (r ) = 1 − 2M r r = 3M, which in other words says that we can work in the (r, t) coordinates near the photon sphere. However, this may be merely an artifact of our method.
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
41
Fig. 2. The Schwarzschild space partition represented on the Penrose diagram
We introduce a symmetric function v˜1 in I + I I , as well as the functions w˜ and w˜ 1 in I + I I , respectively I + I I . Given a parameter 0 < r0 < 2M we partition the Schwarzschild space into seven regions M = M R ∪ M L ∪ MR ∪ ML ∪ MT ∪ MC ∪ M B as in Fig. 2. The right/left top/bottom regions are M L = {v˜1 ≥ 0, r ≥ r0 } ⊂ I + I I, M R = {v˜ ≥ 0, r ≥ r0 } ⊂ I + I I, MR = {w˜ ≤ 0, r ≥ r0 } ⊂ I + I I , ML = {w˜ 1 ≤ 0, r ≥ r0 } ⊂ I + I I , the top and bottom regions are MT = {r < r0 } ∩ I I,
M B = {r < r0 } ∩ I I ,
and the central region MC is the remainder of M. Moreover, define − R = M R ∩ {v˜ = 0}, +R = M R ∩ {r = r0 }. and similarly for the other regions. In what follows we consider the Cauchy problem g φ = f,
φ|0 = φ0 ,
K˜ φ|0 = φ1 ,
(1.7)
where for convenience we choose the initial surface 0 to be the horizontal surface of symmetry 0 = {t = 0} ∩ (I + I ) and K˜ is smooth, everywhere timelike and equals K on 0 outside MC . Observe that we cannot use K on all of 0 since it is degenerate at the center (i.e. on the bifurcate sphere). Equation (1.7) can be solved as follows: (i) Solve the equation in MC with Cauchy data on 0 . Since MC is compact and has forward and backward space-like boundaries, this is a purely local problem.
42
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
(ii) Solve the equation in M R with Cauchy data on − R . The forward boundary of M R is +R , which is space-like. This is the most interesting part, where we are interested in the decay properties as v˜ → ∞. In a similar manner solve the equation in M L , MR and ML . (iii) Solve the equation in MT with initial data on the space-like surface T = {r = r0 } ∩ I I . Here one can track the solution up to the singularity and encounter a mix of local and global features. This part of the analysis is not pursued in the present article. A significant role in our analysis is played by the Killing vector field K , which in the (r, v) ˜ coordinates equals ∂v˜ . This is time-like outside the black hole but space-like inside it. Furthermore, it is degenerate at the center. Using the Killing vector field outside the black hole we obtain a conserved energy E 0 [φ] for solutions φ to the homogeneous equation g φ = 0. On surfaces t = const in the (r, t) coordinates the energy E 0 [φ](t) has the form
∞ 2M −1 2M 2 2 2 1− (∂r φ) +| ∇ φ| r 2 dr dω. (1.8) (∂t φ) + 1 − E 0 [φ] = r r S 2 2M Since the vector field K is degenerate at the center, so is the corresponding energy E 0 at r = 2M. Hence it would be natural to replace it with a nondegenerate energy, which on the initial surface 0 can be expressed as E[φ](0 ) =
S2
∞ 2M
3 1 2M − 2 2M 2 2 2 2 1− (∂t φ) + 1 − (∂r φ) +| ∇ φ| r 2 dr dω. r r (1.9)
Unfortunately this is no longer conserved, and this is one of the difficulties which we face in our analysis. We remark that a related form of a nondegenerate energy expression was introduced in [14] and proved to be bounded in the exterior region on surfaces t = const. Part of the novelty of our approach is to prove bounds not only in the exterior region, but also inside the event horizon. This is natural if one considers the fact that the singularity at r = 2M is merely a removable coordinate singularity. In order to do this, it is no longer suitable to measure the evolution of the energy on the surfaces t = const (see below). Thus the above energy E[φ](0 ) is relegated to a secondary role here and is used only to measure the size of the initial data. A priori the energy E[φ](t) of φ only determines its Cauchy data at time t modulo constants. However, in what follows we implicitly assume that φ decays at ∞, in which case φ can also be estimated via a Hardy-type inequality,
2M 1− r
− 1 2
r
1 2M 2 1− φ r dr dω (∂r φ)2 r 2 dr dω. r
−2 2
2
(1.10)
This is proved in a standard manner; the details are left to the reader. We shall now further describe our main estimates in the region M R : the local energy decay, the WKB analysis which yields a local energy decay with only a logarithmic loss, and finally the Strichartz estimates.
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
43
For the initial energy on − R we use 2 2 2 |∂ r 2 dr dω. ) = φ| + |∂ φ| + | ∇ φ| E[φ]( − r v ˜ R − R
For the final energy on +R we set |∂r φ|2 + |∂v˜ φ|2 + | ∇ φ|2 r02 d vdω. ˜ E[φ]( +R ) = +R
We also track the energy on the space-like slices v˜ = const, |∂r φ|2 + |∂v˜ φ|2 + | ∇ φ|2 r 2 dr dω. E[φ](v˜0 ) = M R ∩{v= ˜ v˜0 }
Thus E[φ]( − R ) = E[φ](0). For the local energy estimates one may first consider a direct analogue of the Minkowski bound (1.5). Unfortunately such a bound is hopeless due to the trapping which occurs at r = 3M. Instead, for our first result we define a weaker preliminary local energy space L E 0 with norm
1 2 2 3M 2 1 1 2 2 2 1 2 φ L E 0 = |∂ φ| + 1 − |∂v˜ φ| + | ∇ φ| + 4 φ r dr d vdω. ˜ 2 r r r2 r r MR r (1.11) Compared to the L E M norm we note the power loss in the angular and v˜ derivatives at r = 3M. The L E 0 norm is also weaker than L E M as r → ∞, but this is merely for convenience. At the same time we would like to also consider the inhomogeneous problem g φ = f . To measure the inhomogeneous term f , we introduce the norm L E 0∗ , which is stronger than L E ∗M : f 2L E ∗ = 0
3M −2 2 2 2 1− r f r dr d vdω. ˜ r MR
(1.12)
Again the important difference is at r = 3M. Our first local energy estimate is the following: Theorem 1.2. Let φ solve the inhomogeneous wave equation g φ = f on the Schwarzschild manifold. Then we have 2 E[φ]( +R ) + sup E[φ](v) ˜ + φ2L E 0 E[φ]( − R ) + f L E ∗ . v≥0 ˜
0
(1.13)
Here we made no effort to optimize the weights at r = 3M and r = ∞. This is done later in the paper. On the other hand the above estimate follows from a relatively simple application of the classical positive commutator method. The advantage of having even such a weaker estimate is that it is sufficient in order to allow localization near the interesting regions r = 3M and r = ∞, which can then be studied in greater detail using specific tools.
44
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
The first related results regarding the solution of the wave equation on Schwarzschild backgrounds were obtained in [50 and 24] which proved uniform boundedness in region I (including the event horizon). The first pointwise decay result (without, however, a rate of decay) was obtained in [49]. Heuristics from [36] suggest that solutions to the wave equation in the Schwarzschild case should locally decay like v −3 . For spherically symmetric data a v −3+ decay rate was obtained in [16], and under the additional assumption of the initial data vanishing near the event horizon, the v −3 decay rate was proved in [23]. In general the best known decay rate, proved in [14], is v −1 (see also [7]). We also refer the reader to [38], where optimal pointwise decay rates for each spherical harmonic are established for a closely related problem. Estimates related to (1.13) were first proved in [25] for radially symmetric Schrödinger equations on Schwarzschild backgrounds. In [2–4], those estimates are extended to allow for general data for the wave equation. The same authors, in [5,6], have provided studies that give improved estimates near the photon sphere r = 3M. Moreover, we note that variants of these bounds have played an important role in the works [7 and 14] which prove analogues of the Morawetz conformal estimates on Schwarzschild backgrounds. This allows one to deduce a uniform decay rate for the local energy away from the event horizon, though there is necessarily a loss of regularity due to the trapping that occurs at the photon sphere. Instead in this paper we restrict ourselves to time translation invariant estimates, and we aim to clarify/streamline these as much as possible. All of the above articles use the conserved (degenerate) energy E 0 [φ] on time slices, obtained using the Killing vector field ∂t . As such, their estimates are degenerate near the event horizon. Further progress was made in [14], where an additional vector field was introduced near the event horizon, in connection to the red shift effect. This led to bounds in the exterior region involving a nondegenerate form of the energy related to (1.9). The approach of [2,7,14 and 25] is to write the equation using the Regge-Wheeler tortoise coordinate and to expand in spherical harmonics. For the equation corresponding to each spherical harmonic, one uses a multiplier which changes sign at the critical point of the effective potential. Here we work in the coordinates (r, v, ˜ ω), though this is not of particular significance, and we do not expand into spherical harmonics. We prove (1.13) using a positive commutator argument which requires a single differential multiplier. We hope that this makes the methods more robust for other potential applications. During final preparations of this article, localized energy estimates proved without using the spherical harmonic decomposition also appeared in [15]. The methods contained therein are somewhat different from ours. Compared to the stronger norms L E M , L E ∗M the weights in (1.13) have a polynomial singularity at r = 3M, which corresponds to the family of trapped geodesics on the photon sphere. As a consequence of the results we prove later, see Theorem 3.2, the latter fact can be remedied to produce a stronger estimate. Theorem 1.3. Let φ solve the inhomogeneous wave equation g φ = f on the Schwarzschild manifold. Then (1.13) still holds if the coefficient (1 − 3M/r )2 in the L E 0 and the L E 0∗ norms is replaced by 3M −2 1 − ln 1 − . r
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
45
Now we have only a logarithmic singularity at r = 3M. The result above is only stated in this form for the reader’s convenience. The full result in Theorem 3.2 is stronger but also more complicated to state since it provides a more precise microlocal local energy estimate. The logarithmic loss is not surprising, since it is characteristic of geometries with trapped hyperbolic orbits (see for instance [9,12,34]). Indeed, a similar estimate in the semiclassical setting is obtained in [13] using entirely different techniques. Note, however, that the aforementioned estimate only involves logarithmic loss of the frequency; our result is stronger since it also implies bounds for (ln |r ∗ |)−1 u L 2 , which are necessary in order to prove Strichartz estimates. There are two regions on which the analysis is distinct. The metric is asymptotically flat, and thus, near infinity, one can retrieve the classical Morawetz type estimate. On the other hand, around the photon sphere r = 3M we take an expansion into spherical harmonics as well as a time Fourier transform. Then it remains to study an ordinary differential equation which is essentially similar to (∂x2 − λ2 (x 2 + ))u = f,
|| 1, |x| 1.
For this we use a rough WKB approximation in the hyperbolic region combined with energy estimates in the elliptic region. Airy type dynamics occur near the zeroes of the potential. Even though it is weaker, the initial bound in Theorem 1.2 plays a key role in the analysis. Precisely, it allows us to glue together the estimates in the two regions described above. We next consider the Strichartz estimates. For solutions to the constant coefficient wave equation on R × R3 , the well-known Strichartz estimates state that |Dx |−ρ1 ∇u L p1 L qx1 ∇u(0) L 2 + |Dx |ρ2 f t
p
q
L t 2 L x2
.
(1.14)
Here the exponents (ρi , pi , qi ) are subject to the scaling relation 3 1 3 + = −ρ p q 2
(1.15)
and the dispersion relation 1 1 1 + ≤ , p q 2
2 < p ≤ ∞.
(1.16)
All pairs (ρ, p, q) satisfying (1.15) and (1.16) are called Strichartz pairs. Those for which the equality holds in (1.16) are called sharp Strichartz pairs. Such estimates first appeared in the seminal works [8,43,44] and as stated include contributions from, e.g., [17,19,26,35 and 21]. If one allows variable coefficients, such estimates are well-understood locallyin-time. For smooth coefficients, this was first shown in [32] and later for C 2 coefficients in [39 and 45–47]. Globally-in-time, the problem is more delicate. Even a small, smooth, compactly supported perturbation of the flat metric may refocus a group of rays and produce caustics. Thus, constructing a parametrix for incoming rays proves to be quite difficult. At the same time, one needs to contend with the possibility of trapped rays at high frequencies and with eigenfunctions/resonances at low frequencies.
46
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Global-in-time estimates were shown for small, long range perturbations of the metric in [29] using an outgoing parametrix. In order to keep the parametrix outgoing one must allow evolution both forward and backward in time. This construction is based on an earlier argument in [48] for the Schrödinger equation. The smallness assumption, however, precludes trapping and does not permit a direct application to the current setup. On the other hand, a second result of [29] asserts that even for large, long range perturbations of the metric one can still establish global-in-time Strichartz estimates provided that a strong form of the local energy estimates holds. This switches the burden to the question of proving local energy estimates. The result in [29] cannot be applied directly to the present problem due to the logarithmic losses in the local energy estimates near the trapped rays. However, it can be applied for the near infinity part of the solution. In a bounded spatial region, on the other hand, we take advantage of the local energy estimates to localize the problem to bounded sets, in which estimates are shown using the local-in-time Strichartz estimates of [39,45]. Thus we obtain Theorem 1.4. If φ solves g φ = f in M R then for all nonsharp Strichartz pairs (ρ1 , p1 , q1 ) and (ρ2 , p2 , q2 ) we have E[φ]( +R ) + sup E[φ](v) ˜ + ∇φ2 p1
−ρ ,q L v˜ H˙ x 1 1
v≥0 ˜
2 E[φ]( − R ) + f p
ρ ,q2
2 L v˜ 2 H˙ x
. (1.17)
Here the Sobolev-type spaces H˙ s, p coincide with the usual H˙ s, p homogeneous spaces in R3 expressed in polar coordinates (r, ω). As a corollary of this result one can consider the global solvability question for the energy critical semilinear wave equation in the Schwarzschild space, g φ = ±φ 5 in M (1.18) φ = φ0 , K˜ φ = φ1 in 0 . Theorem 1.5. Let r0 > 0. Then there exists > 0 so that for each initial data (φ0 , φ1 ) which satisfies E[φ](0 ) ≤ , Eq. (1.18) admits an unique solution φ in the region {r > r0 } which satisfies the bound E[φ](r0 ) + φ H˙ s, p ({r >r0 }) E[φ](0 ) for all indices s, p satisfying 1 4 =s+ , p 2
0≤s<
1 . 2
Furthermore, the solution has a Lipschitz dependence on the initial data in the above topology. Some further clarification is needed for the function space H˙ s, p ({r > r0 }) appearing above, in view of the ambiguity due to the choice of coordinates. In a compact neighbourhood of the center region MC this is nothing but the classical H s, p norm. By compactness, different choices of coordinates lead to equivalent norms. Consider now the upper exterior region M R (as well as its three other mirror images). Using the coordinates (v, ˜ x) with x = ωr , we define H˙ s, p (M R ) as the restrictions to R+ × {|x| > r0 } of functions in the homogeneous Sobolev space H˙ s, p (R × R3 ).
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
47
2. The Morawetz-Type Estimate In this section, we shall prove Theorem 1.2. We note that the estimate (1.13) is trivial over a finite v˜ interval by energy estimates for the wave equation; the difficulty consists in proving a global bound in v. ˜ By the same token, once we prove (1.13) for some choice of r0 < 2M, we can trivially make the transition to any r0 < 2M due to the local theory. Thus in the arguments which follow we reserve the right to take r0 sufficiently close to 2M. We consider solutions to the inhomogeneous wave equation on the Schwarzschild manifold in M R , which is given by g φ = ∇ α ∂α φ = f. Here ∇ represents the metric connection. Associated to this equation is an energymomentum tensor given by 1 Q αβ [φ] = ∂α φ∂β φ − gαβ ∂ γ φ∂γ φ. 2 A simple calculation yields the most important property of Q αβ , namely that if φ solves the homogeneous wave equation then Q αβ [φ] is divergence-free: ∇ α Q αβ [φ] = 0, if ∇ α ∂α φ = 0. More generally, we have ∇ α Q αβ [φ] = ∂β φ g φ. In order to prove Theorem 1.2, we shall contract Q αβ with a vector field X to form the momentum density Pα [φ, X ] = Q αβ [φ]X β . Computing the divergence of this vector field, we have ∇ α Pα [φ, X ] = g φ X φ + Q αβ [φ]π αβ , where παβ =
1 (∇α X β + ∇β X α ) 2
is the deformation tensor of X . If X is the Killing vector field K then the above divergence vanishes, ∇ α Pα [φ, K ] = 0 if g φ = 0.
(2.1)
This gives rise to the E 0 [φ] conservation law outside the black hole. Naively, one may seek vector fields X so that the quadratic form Q αβ [φ]π αβ is positive definite. However, this may not always be possible to achieve. Instead we note that it may be just as good to have the symbol of this quadratic form positive on the characteristic set of g . Then it would be possible to make the above quadratic form positive after adding a Lagrangian correction term of the form q∂ γ φ∂γ φ. Such a term
48
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
can be conveniently expressed in divergence form modulo lower order terms. Precisely, for a vector field X , a scalar function q and a 1-form m we define 1 1 Pα [φ, X, q, m] = Pα [φ, X ] + qφ∂α φ − ∂α qφ 2 + m α φ 2 , 2 2 where m allows us to modify the lower order terms in the divergence formula. Then we obtain the modified divergence relation ∇ α Pα [φ, X, q, m] = g φ (X φ + qφ) + Q[φ, X, q, m],
(2.2) 1 Q[φ, X, q, m] = Q αβ [φ]π αβ + q∂ α φ ∂α φ + m α φ ∂ α φ + (∇ α m α − ∇ α ∂α q) φ 2 . 2
Theorem 1.2 is proved by making appropriate choices for X , q and m so that the quadratic form Q[φ, X, q, m] defined by the divergence relation is positive definite. In what follows we assume that X , q and m are all spherically symmetric and invariant with respect to the Killing vector field K . Lemma 2.1. There exist smooth, spherically symmetric, K -invariant X , q, and m in r ≥ 2M satisfying the following properties: (i) X is bounded2 , |q(r )| r −1 , |q (r )| r −2 and m has compact support in r . (ii) The quadratic form Q[φ, X, q, m] is positive definite, 3M 2 −2 Q[φ, X, q, m] r −2 |∂r φ|2 + 1 − (r |∂v˜ φ|2 + r −1 | ∇ φ|2 ) + r −4 φ 2 . r (iii) X (2M) points toward the black hole, X (dr )(2M) < 0, and m, dr (2M) > 0. We postpone the proof of the lemma and use it to conclude the proof of Theorem 1.2. Let X , q and m be as in the lemma. We extend them smoothly beyond the event horizon preserving the spherical symmetry and the K -invariance. By (2.1) we can modify the vector field X without changing the quadratic form Q in (2.3), ∇ α Pα [φ, X + C K , q, m] = g φ ((X + C K )φ + qφ) + Q[φ, X, q, m]. Here C is a large constant. We integrate this relation in the region D = {0 < v˜ < v˜0 , r > r0 } using the (r, v, ˜ ω) coordinates. This yields ˜ g φ ((X + C K )φ + qφ) + Q[φ, X, q, m] r 2 dr d vdω D
v= ˜ v˜0 d v, ˜ P[φ, X + C K , q, m]r 2 dr dω v=0 ˜ 2 − dr, P[φ, X + C K , q, m]r0 d vdω. ˜
=
r =r0
2 In the (r, v) ˜ coordinates
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
49
We claim that if C is large enough and r0 sufficiently close to 2M then the integrals on the right have the correct sign, E[φ](v˜1 )− d v, ˜ P[φ, X +C K , q, m]r 2 dr dω C E[φ](v˜1 ), v˜1 ≥ 0, (2.3) v= ˜ v˜1
dr, P[φ, X + C K , q, m] |∂r φ|2 + |∂v˜ φ|2 + |∂ω φ|2 + φ 2 ,
r = r0 .
(2.4)
If these bounds hold then the conclusion of the theorem follows by (ii) and CauchySchwarz. Indeed, a direct computation yields 1 2M 2M 2 2 d v, ˜ P[φ, ∂v˜ ] = − 2µ − 1 − µ |∂v˜ φ| + 1 − |∂r φ|2 2 r r + r −2 |∂ω φ|2 , respectively 2M dr, P[φ, ∂v˜ ] = |∂v˜ φ| + 1 − (∂r − µ ∂v˜ )φ∂v˜ φ. r 2
On the other hand
2M 2M 2 d v, ˜ P[φ, ∂r ] = 1 − 1 − µ |∂r φ| − 2µ − 1 − µ2 ∂v˜ φ∂r φ, r r
while
1 2M 2M − 2µ − 1 − µ2 |∂v˜ φ|2 − 1 − |∂r φ|2 2 r r + r −2 |∂ω φ|2 .
dr, P[φ, ∂r ] = −
We compute d v, ˜ P[φ, X + C K ] = (X (d v) ˜ + C)d v, ˜ P[φ, ∂v˜ ] + X (dr )d v, ˜ P[φ, ∂r ]. For large enough C we have X (d v) ˜ + C C. Therefore the first term on the right is negative definite for r > 2M. More precisely, it is only the coefficient of the |∂r φ|2 term which degenerates at r = 2M. However, due to condition (iii) in the lemma we have X (dr )(2M) < 0; therefore we pick up a negative |∂r φ|2 coefficient at r = 2M. Thus we obtain 2M 2 2 −2 2 −d v, ˜ P[φ, X + C K ] ≈ C |∂v˜ φ| + 1 − |∂r φ| + r |∂ω φ| + |∂r φ|2 , r r > 2M. Since all the coefficients in the quadratic form on the left are continuous, it follows that the above relation extends to r > r0 for some r0 < 2M depending on C, namely 0 < 2M − r0 C −1 .
(2.5)
50
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
In order to prove (2.3) it remains to estimate the lower order terms P[φ, 0, q, m] in terms of the positive contribution above. Since |q| r −1 and m has compact support in r , we can bound 1 2 |d v, ˜ P[φ, 0, q, m]| r −1 |φ| |∂v˜ φ|2 + |∂r φ|2 + r −2 |φ|2 . Then by Cauchy-Schwarz it suffices to estimate ∞ ∞ 2M −2 2 2 − 21 C 1− + 1 |∂r φ|2 r 2 dr r |φ| r dr C r r0 r0 which is a routine Hardy-type inequality. We next turn our attention to (2.4) and begin with the principal part dr, P[φ, X + C K ] = (X (d v) ˜ + C)dr, P[φ, ∂v˜ ] + X (dr )dr, P[φ, ∂r ]. Examining the expressions for the two terms above, we see that for r0 subject to (2.5) we have 2M |∂r φ|2 , dr, P[φ, X + C K ] C|∂v˜ φ|2 + |∂ω φ|2 − 1 − r = r0 . r0 Next we consider the lower order terms. The contribution of m is 1 m, dr φ 2 φ 2 2 due to condition (iii) in the lemma. The contribution of q is 1 qφdr, dφ − φ 2 dr, dq. 2 The coefficient of the second term is 1 − 2M r q , which is negligible for r0 close to 2M. In the first term we have 2M 2M ∂r φ + 1 − 1 − µ ∂v˜ φ. dr, dφ = 1 − r r All terms involving 1 − 2M are negligible, and since q is bounded we get r qφ∂v˜ φ C|∂v˜ φ|2 + φ 2 for large enough C. Proof of Lemma 2.1. It is convenient to look for X in the (r, t) coordinates, where we choose the vector field X of the form X = X 1 + δ X 2, with 2M ∂r , X 1 = a(r ) 1 − r
δ 1,
2M 2M −1 X 2 = b(r ) 1 − ∂t ∂r − 1 − r r
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
51
will be chosen to be smooth. Note that X is a smooth vector field and a and b 1 − 2M r in the nonsingular coordinates (r, v), since in these coordinates we have 2M 2M X 2 = b(r ) 1 − ∂r + ∂v , ∂r . X 1 = a(r ) 1− r r We remark that the vector field X 2 is closely related to the vector field Y introduced earlier in [14] in order to take advantage of the red shift effect. However, in their construction Y is in a form which is nonsmooth near the event horizon and which is restricted to the exterior region. The primary role played by X 2 here is to ensure that X + C K is time-like near the event horizon. The red-shift effect largely takes care of the rest. For convenience, we set 2M 1 2 t1 (r ) = 1 − r ∂ a(r ) . r r r2 A direct computation yields 2M 2 r − 3M a (r )(∂r φ)2 + a(r ) | ∇ φ|2 ∇ α Pα [φ, X 1 ] = 1 − r r2 1 − t1 (r )∂ γ φ ∂γ φ + X 1 φg φ, 2
(2.6)
respectively 2 1 2M ∂r φ − ∂t φ 1− ∇ Pα [φ, X 2 ] = b (r ) 2 r 2M r − 3M 1 1− b (r ) | ∇ φ|2 + b(r ) − r2 2 r 2M 1 1− b(r )∂ γ φ ∂γ φ + X 2 φg φ, − r r α
where γ
∂ φ ∂γ φ = −
2M 1− r
−1
(2.7)
2M 2 2 (∂r φ) − | ∇ φ| . (∂t φ) − 1 − r 2
We choose a so that the first line of the right side of (2.6) is positive. This requires that a (r ) r −2 ,
a(3M) = 0.
(2.8)
We choose b so that the first line of the right-hand side of (2.7) is positive. Precisely, we take b supported in r ≤ 3M with b=−
b0 (r ) 1−
2M r
,
r ∈ [2M, 3M],
with b0 smooth, decreasing in [2M, 3M) and supported in {r ≤ 3M}. In particular this guarantees that b0 (2M) > 0, which is later used to verify the condition (iii) in the lemma.
52
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
The exact choice of b0 is not important, and in effect b only plays a role very close to the event horizon r = 2M. Even though b is singular at 2M, the second term of the coefficient of | ∇ φ|2 in the second line of (2.7) is nonsingular. Hence if δ is sufficiently small this term is controlled by the first line in (2.6). Taking the above choices into account, we have 2 2M 2 1 2M Q[φ, X, 0, 0] = 1 − a (r )(∂r φ)2 + δ b (r ) 1− ∂r φ − ∂t φ r 2 r (2.9) 2 (r − 3M) 2 γ +O − q ∂ φ ∂ φ | ∇ φ| 0 γ r3 where
q0 (r ) =
1 1 2M . t1 (r ) + δ b(r ) 1 − 2 r r
The last term in (2.9) is a Lagrangian expression and is accounted for via the q term. The first three terms give a nonnegative quadratic form in ∇φ. This form is in effect positive definite for r < 3M, where b > 0. However for larger r it controls ∂r φ and ∇ φ but not ∂t φ. This can be easily remedied with the Lagrangian term. Precisely, we choose q of the form q = q 0 + δ1 q 1 ,
q1 (r ) = χ{r >5M/2}
(r − 3M)2 , r4
where χ{r >5M/2} is a smooth nonnegative cutoff which is supported in {r > 5M/2} and equals 1 for r > 3M. The positive parameter δ1 is chosen so that δ1 δ. Then the only nonnegligible contribution of δ1 q1 is the one involving ∂t φ. We obtain 2 2M 2 1 2M −2 2 ∂r φ − ∂t φ Q[φ, X, q, 0] = 1 − O(r )(∂r φ) + δ b (r ) 1− r 2 r 2M −1 (r − 3M)2 1 2 | ∇ φ| 1 − +O + δ q |∂t φ|2 − ∇ α ∂α q φ 2 . 1 1 3 r r 2 (2.10) The contribution of q1 can be made arbitrarily small by taking δ1 small. Hence it will be neglected in the sequel. At this stage it would be convenient to be able to choose a so that ∇ α ∂α t1 (r ) < 0. A direct computation yields ∇ α ∂α t1 (r ) = −La with 1 La(r ) = − 2 ∂r r
2M 2 2M 1 2 1− 1− r ∂r ∂r r a(r ) . r r 2r 2
Unfortunately it turns out that the condition La > 0 and (2.8) are incompatible, in the sense that there is no smooth a which satisfies both. However, one can find a with a logarithmic blow-up at 2M which satisfies both requirements. Such an example is r − 2M . a(r ) = r −2 (r − 3M)(r + 2M) + 6M 2 log M
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
53
This is in no way unique, it is merely the simplest we were able to produce. One verifies directly that a (r ) r −2 ,
La(r ) r −4 .
To eliminate the singularity of a above we replace it by a (r ) =
1 f (R), r2
where is a small parameter,
R = (r − 3M)(r + 2M) + 6M 2 log
r − 2M , M
and f (R) = −1 f ( R), where f is a smooth nondecreasing function such that f (R) = R on [−1, ∞] and f = −2 on (−∞, −3]. The condition (2.8) is satisfied uniformly with respect to small ; therefore the choice of δ is independent of the choice of . With this modification of a we recompute
2M −1 2 La = f ( R)La + O() f ( R) + O 1 − f ( R). r This is still positive except for the region { R < −1}. To control it we introduce an m term in the divergence relation as follows: Let γ (r ) be a function to be chosen later. We set 2M 2 2M m t = δb (r ) 1 − γ, m ω = 0. γ, m r = δb (r ) 1 − r r Then
2M 2M 1− ∂r φ − ∂t φ , m α ∂ α φ = δb (r )γ (r ) 1 − r r
while α
∇ m α = δr
−2
∂r
2M 1− r
2
2
r b (r )γ (r ) .
Hence, completing the square we obtain 2M 2 (r − 3M)2 | ∇ φ|2 Q[φ, X, q, m] = 1 − O(r −2 )(∂r φ)2 + O r r3 2M −1 + δ1 q 1 1 − |∂t φ|2 + nφ 2 r 2 1 2M 2M ∂r φ − ∂t φ + 1 − γφ , + δ b (r ) 1− 2 r r
54
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
where the coefficient n is given by 2M b (r ) 2M 2 1 −2 2 2M −1 ∂r r b(r ) 1 − −δ 1− γ (r )2 n=La − δr ∂r r 1 − 2 r r 2 r
2 2M 2M 2 1 −2 1 2 + δr γ ∂r r 1 − b (r ) + δγ 1 − b (r ). 2 r 2 r We assume that γ is supported in {r < 3M} and satisfies γ > −1.
0 ≤ γ ≤ 1, Then for r > 3M we have
n = La r −4 , while for r ≤ 3M we can write
2M 2 n = La + δγ (r ) 1 − b (r ) + O(δ). r
If R > −1 then, using the bound from below on γ , we further have n ≥ La + O(δ), which is positive provided that δ is sufficiently small. On the other hand in the region { R ≤ −1}, we have
1 2M −1 2M 2 2 n≥ δ 1 − b (r )γ (r ) + O(δ)+ O() f ( R) + O 1 − f ( R). 2 r r The γ term can be taken positive, while all the other terms may be negative so they must be controlled by it. The restriction we face in the choice of γ comes from the fact that 0 ≤ γ ≤ 1. Hence we need to verify that 2M −1 2 I = δ + | f ( R)| + 1 − | f ( R)| δ. r R≤−1 −1
Indeed, the interval of integration has size ≤ e−c ; therefore the above integral can be bounded by I e−c
−1
+ ,
which suffices provided that is small enough. Finally, note that 2M 2M X (dr )(2M) = a(r ) 1 − + δb(r ) 1 − (2M) < 0, r r
2M 2 m, dr (2M) = δb (r ) 1 − γ (2M) > 0. r So (iii) is also satisfied.
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
55
3. Log-Loss Local Energy Estimates The aim of this section is to prove a local energy estimate for solutions to the wave equation on the Schwarzschild space which is stronger than the one in Theorem 1.2. Consequently, we strengthen the norm L E 0 to a norm L E and we relax the norm L E 0∗ to a norm L E ∗ which satisfy the following natural bounds: φ2L E 0 φ2L E φ2L E M ,
(3.11)
f 2L E ∗ f 2L E ∗ f 2L E ∗ .
(3.12)
respectively
0
M
We note that these bounds uniquely determine the topology of the L E and L E ∗ spaces away from the photon sphere and from infinity. This is due to the fact that the local energy estimates in Theorem 1.2 have no loss in any bounded region away from the photon sphere. To define the L E, respectively L E ∗ , norms we consider a smooth partition of unity 1 = χeh (r ) + χ ps (r ) + χ∞ (r ), where χeh is supported in {r < 11M/4}, χ ps is supported in {5M/2 < r < 5M} and χ∞ is supported in {r > 4M}. Then we set φ2L E = χeh φ2L E M + χ ps φ2L E ps + χ∞ φ2L E M ,
(3.13)
φ2L E ∗ = χeh φ2L E ∗ + χ ps φ2L E ∗ps + χ∞ φ2L E ∗ .
(3.14)
respectively
M
M
The norms L E ps and L E ∗ps near the photon sphere are defined in Sect. 3.1 below, see (3.20), respectively (3.21); their topologies coincide with L E M , respectively L E ∗M , away from the photon sphere. With these notations, the main result of this section can be phrased in a manner similar to Theorem 1.2: Theorem 3.2. For all functions φ which solve g φ = f in M R we have 2 ˜ + E[φ]( +R ) + φ2L E E[φ]( − sup E[φ](v) R ) + f L E ∗ .
(3.15)
v>0 ˜
We continue with the setup and estimates near the photon sphere in Sect. 3.1, the setup and estimates near infinity in Sect. 3.2 and finally the proof of the theorem in Sect. 3.3.
56
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
3.1. The analysis near the photon sphere. Here it is convenient to work in the ReggeWheeler coordinates given by r ∗ = r + 2M log(r − 2M) − 3M − 2M log M. Then r = 3M corresponds to r ∗ = 0, and a neighbourhood of r = 3M away from infinity and the event horizon corresponds to a compact set in r ∗ . In these coordinates the operator g has the form 2M r − 2M r 1− g r −1 = L RW = ∂t2 −∂r2∗ − ∂ω + V (r ), V (r ) =r −1 ∂r2∗ r. r r3 (3.16) For r ∗ in a compact set the energy has the form E[φ] ≈ (∂t φ)2 + (∂r ∗ φ)2 + (∂ω φ)2 dr dω, and the initial local smoothing norms are expressed as φ2L E 0 ≈ (∂r ∗ φ)2 + r ∗ 2 ((∂ω φ)2 + (∂t φ)2 ) + φ 2 dr dωdt, respectively
f 2L E ∗ 0
On the other hand
r ∗ −2 f 2 dr dωdt.
≈
φ2L E M
≈
f 2L E ∗ ≈ M
(∂r ∗ φ)2 + (∂ω φ)2 + (∂t φ)2 + φ 2 dr dωdt, f 2 dr dωdt.
In the sequel we work with spatial spherically symmetric pseudodifferential operators in the (r ∗ , ω) coordinates where ω ∈ S2 . We denote by ξ the dual variable to r ∗ , 1 and by λ the spectral parameter for (−S2 ) 2 . Thus the role of the Fourier variable is played by the pair (ξ, λ), and all our symbols are of the form a(r ∗ , ξ, λ). To such a symbol we associate the corresponding Weyl operator Aw . Since there is no symbol dependence on ω, one can view this operator as a combination of a one dimen1 sional Weyl operator and the spectral projectors λ associated to the operator (−S2 ) 2 , namely Aw = a w (λ)λ . λ
All of our L 2 estimates admit orthogonal decompositions with respect to spherical harmonics, therefore in order to prove them it suffices to work with the fixed λ operators a w (λ), and treat λ as a parameter. However, in the proof of the Strichartz estimates later
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
57
on we need kernel bounds for operators of the form Aw , which is why we think of λ as a second Fourier variable and track the symbol regularity with respect to λ as well. Of course, this is meaningless for λ in a compact set; only the asymptotic behavior as λ → ∞ is relevant. Let γ0 : R → R+ be a smooth increasing function so that 1 y < 1, γ0 (y) = y y ≥ 2. Let γ1 : R+ → R+ be a smooth increasing function so that 1 2 γ1 (y) = y y < 1/2, 1 y ≥ 1. Let γ : R2 → R+ be a smooth function with the following properties: ⎧ 1 ⎨ √z < C, (y) y < z/2, z ≥ C, γ 0 γ (y, z) = √ ⎩ 1 2 z 2 γ1 (y /z) y ≥ z/2, z ≥ C, where C is a large constant. In the sequel z is a discrete parameter, so the lack of smoothness at z = C is of no consequence. Consider the symbol a ps (r ∗ , ξ, λ) = γ (− ln(r ∗ 2 + λ−2 ξ 2 ), ln λ), and its inverse ∗ a −1 ps (r , ξ, λ) =
γ (− ln(r ∗ 2
1 . + λ−2 ξ 2 ), ln λ)
We note that if λ is small then they both equal 1, while if λ is large then they satisfy the bounds 1
1 ≤ a ps (r ∗ , ξ, λ) ≤ a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ) ≤ (ln λ) 2 ,
(3.17)
1
∗ −1 ∗ (ln λ)− 2 ≤ a −1 ps (r , 0, λ) ≤ a ps (r , ξ, λ) ≤ 1.
√
We also observe that the region where y 2 > z corresponds to r ∗ 2 + λ−2 ξ 2 < e− Thus differentiating the two symbols we obtain the following bounds √
β
|∂rα∗ ∂ξ ∂λν a ps (r ∗ , ξ, λ)| ≤ cα,β,ν λ−β−ν (r ∗ 2 + λ−2 ξ 2 + e−
ln λ − α+β 2
)
,
ln λ .
(3.18)
respectively √
β
∗ −2 ∗ −β−ν ∗ 2 |∂rα∗ ∂ξ ∂λν a −1 (r +λ−2 ξ 2 +e− ps (r , ξ, λ)| ≤ cα,β,ν a ps (r , ξ, λ)λ
ln λ − α+β 2
)
, (3.19)
where α + β + ν > 0. These show that we have a good operator calculus for the corresponding pseudodifferential operators. In particular in terms of the classical symbol classes we have δ a ps , a −1 ps ∈ S1,0 ,
δ > 0.
58
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Then we introduce the Weyl operators A ps =
aw ps (λ)λ ,
λ
respectively A−1 ps =
w (a −1 ps ) (λ)λ .
λ
By (3.18) and (3.19) one easily sees that these operators are approximate inverses. More precisely for small λ, ln λ < C, they are both the identity, while for large λ, −1 w −1 a w ps (λ)(a ps ) (λ) − I L 2 →L 2 λ e
√
ln λ
,
ln λ ≥ C.
Choosing C large enough we insure that the bound above is always much smaller than 1. We use these two operators in order to define the improved local smoothing norms −1 φ L E ps = A−1 ps φ H 1 ≈ A ps ∇t,x φ L 2 ,
(3.20)
f L E ∗ps = A ps f L 2 .
(3.21)
t,x
Due to the inequalities (3.17) we have a bound from above for a w ps (λ), ∗ ∗ a w ps (λ) f L 2 a ps (r , 0, λ) f L 2 | ln |r || f L 2 , w respectively a bound from below for (a −1 ps ) (λ), w −1 ∗ ∗ −1 (a −1 f L 2 ps ) (λ) f L 2 a ps (r , 0, λ) f L 2 | ln |r ||
for f supported near r ∗ = 0. In particular this shows that for f supported near the photon sphere we have φ L E ps | ln |r ∗ ||−1 ∇φ L 2 ,
f L E ∗ps | ln |r ∗ || f L 2 ,
(3.22)
which makes Theorem 1.3 a direct consequence of Theorem 3.2. Our main estimate near the photon sphere is Proposition 3.3. a) Let φ be a function supported in {5M/2 < r < 5M} which solves g φ = f . Then φ2L E ps f 2L E ∗ps .
(3.23)
b) Let f ∈ L E ∗ps be supported in {11M/4 < r < 4M}. Then there is a function φ supported in {5M/2 < r < 5M} so that sup E[φ] + φ2L E ps + g φ − f 2L E ∗ f 2L E ∗ps . t
0
(3.24)
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
59
Proof. Due to (3.16) recast the problem in Regge-Wheeler coordinates. Denot we can ing u = r φ, g = 1 − 2M r r f , we have L RW u = g. Also it is easy to verify that for φ and f supported in a fixed compact set in r ∗ we have φ L E ps ≈ u L E ps ,
f L E ∗ps ≈ g L E ∗ps .
Hence in the proposition we can replace φ and f by u and g, and g by L RW . To prove part (a) we expand in spherical harmonics with respect to the angular variable and take a time Fourier transform. We are left with the ordinary differential equation (∂r2∗ + Vλ,τ (r ∗ ))u = g,
(3.25)
where Vλ,τ (r ∗ ) = τ 2 −
r − 2M 2 λ + V. r3
Depending on the relative sizes of λ and τ we consider several cases. In the easier cases it suffices to replace the bound (3.23) with a simpler bound ∂r ∗ u L 2 + (|τ | + |λ|)u L 2 g L 2 .
(3.26)
Case 1. λ, τ 1. Then we solve (3.25) as a Cauchy problem with data on one side and obtain a pointwise bound, |u| + |u r ∗ | g L 2 , which easily implies (3.26). Case 2. λ τ . Then Vλ,τ (r ∗ ) ≈ τ 2 for r ∗ in a compact set; therefore (3.25) is hyperbolic in nature. Hence we can solve (3.25) as a Cauchy problem with data on one side and obtain τ |u| + |u r ∗ | g L 2 , which implies (3.26). Case 3. λ τ . Then Vλ,τ (r ∗ ) ≈ −λ2 for r ∗ in a compact set; therefore (3.25) is elliptic. Then we solve (3.25) as an elliptic problem with Dirichlet boundary conditions on a compact interval and obtain 3
1
λ 2 |u| + λ 2 |u r ∗ | g L 2 , which again gives (3.26). Case 4. λ ≈ τ 1. In this case (3.26) is no longer true, and we need to prove (3.23), which in this case can be written in the form w w ∂r ∗ u L 2 + λ(a −1 ps ) (λ)u L 2 a ps (λ)g L 2 ,
(3.27)
where u, g are subject to (3.25). The ∂r ∗ u term above is present in order to estimate the high frequencies |ξ | λ. For lower frequencies it is controlled by the second term on the left of (3.27).
60
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
The potential V in (3.25) can be treated perturbatively in (3.23) and is negligible. The remaining part of Vλ,τ (r ∗ ) has a nondegenerate minimum at r = 3M which corresponds to r ∗ = 0. Hence we express it in the form Vλ,τ (r ∗ ) = λ2 (W (r ∗ ) + ), where W is smooth and has a nondegenerate zero minimum at r ∗ = 0 and || 1. We now prove the following: Proposition 3.4. Let W be a smooth function satisfying W (0) = W (0) = 0, W (0) > 0, and || 1. Let w be a solution of the ordinary differential equation (∂r2∗ + λ2 (W (r ∗ ) + ))w(r ∗ ) = g, supported near r ∗ = 0. Then (3.27) holds. It would be convenient to replace the norm on the right in (3.27) by a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ)g L 2 . This is not entirely possible since this is a stronger norm. However, we can split g into a component g1 with a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ)g1 ∈ L 2 plus a high frequency part: Lemma 3.5. Each function g ∈ L 2 supported near the photon sphere can be expressed in the form g = g1 + λ−2 ∂r2∗ g2 with g1 and g2 supported near the photon sphere so that √
a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ)g1 L 2 + |r ∗ 2 + e−
ln λ
1
| 8 g2 L 2 + λ−2 ∂r ∗ g2 L 2 a w ps (λ)g L 2 . (3.28)
Proof. The symbols a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ) and a ps (r ∗ , ξ, λ) are comparable provided that √
ln(r ∗ 2 + e−
ln λ
√
) ≈ ln(r ∗ 2 + e−
ln λ
+ λ−2 ξ 2 ).
This includes a region of the form √ 1 D = ln(λ−2 ξ 2 ) < ln(r ∗ 2 + e− ln λ ) . 8 We note that the factor 18 , arising also in the exponent of the second term in (3.28), is somewhat arbitrary. A small choice leads to a better bound in (3.28). If χ is a smooth function which is 1 in (−∞, −1] and 0 in [0, ∞) then we define a smooth characteristic function χ D of the domain D by χ D (r ∗ , ξ, λ) = χ (ln(λ−2 ξ 2 ) −
√ 1 ln(r ∗ 2 + e− ln λ )). 8
One can directly compute the regularity of χ D , 0 χ D ∈ S1,δ ,
δ > 0.
To obtain the decomposition of g we set g2 = q w g,
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
61
where the symbol of q is q(r ∗ , ξ, λ) = λ2 ξ −2 (1 − χ D ). w w Since (a −1 ps ) (λ) is an approximate inverse for a ps (λ), the estimate for g2 in the lemma can be written in the form √
(r ∗ 2 + e−
ln λ
1
w −2 w −1 w ) 8 q w (a −1 ps ) (λ) f L 2 + λ ∂r ∗ q (a ps ) (λ) f L 2 f L 2 . (3.29)
In the first term it suffices to look at the principal symbol of the operator product since −1+δ the remainder belongs to O P S1,δ for all δ > 0. To verify that the product of the −1 symbols is bounded we note that a ps is bounded. For the other two factors we consider two cases. If |ξ | λ then both factors are bounded. On the other hand if |ξ | λ then in the support of q we have √
λ−2 ξ 2 (r ∗ 2 + e−
ln λ
1
)8 ,
which gives √
q (r ∗ 2 + e−
ln λ − 18
)
.
The estimate for the second term in (3.29) is similar but simpler. It remains to consider the bound for g1 , which is given by g1 = (1 + λ−2 Dr2∗ q w )g,
Dr ∗ =
1 ∂r ∗ . i
As above, the bound for g1 can be written in the form w a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ)(1 + λ−2 Dr2∗ q w )(a −1 ps ) (λ) f L 2 f L 2 . δ , S 0 , and S δ for all δ > 0. Hence The three operators above belong respectively to S1,δ 1,δ 1,δ δ , and it suffices to show that its principal symbol is bounded. the product belongs to S1,δ But the principal symbol of the product is given by ∗ a ps (r ∗ , 0, λ)χ D a −1 ps (r , ξ, λ),
which is bounded due to the choice of D. Finally we remark that as constructed the functions g1 and g2 are not necessarily supported near the photon sphere. This is easily rectified by replacing them with truncated versions, g1 := χ1 (r ∗ )g1 ,
g2 := χ1 (r ∗ )g2 ,
where χ1 is a smooth compactly supported cutoff which equals 1 in the support of g. It is clear that the bound (3.28) is still valid after truncation.
62
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Using the above decomposition of g we write u in the form u = λ−2 g2 + u. ˜ For the first term we use the above lemma to estimate λλ−2 g2 L 2 + λ−2 ∂r ∗ g2 L 2 a w ps (λ)g L 2 , which is stronger than what we need. For u˜ we write the equation (∂r2∗ + λ2 (W + ))u˜ = g, ˜
g˜ = g1 − (W + )g2 .
(3.30)
For g˜ we only use a weighted L 1 bound, 1
˜ L 1 a w (λ−1 + |W + |)− 4 g ps (λ)g L 2 , which is obtained from the weighted L 2 bounds on g1 and g2 by Cauchy-Schwarz. For u˜ on the other hand, it suffices to obtain a pointwise bound: Lemma 3.6. For each λ−1 < σ < 1 and each function u˜ with compact support, we have 1
1
w λ(a −1 ˜ L 2 (σ + |W + |)− 4 ∂r ∗ u ˜ L ∞ + λ(σ + |W + |) 4 u ˜ L∞ . ps ) (λ)u
Proof. Since W has a nondegenerate zero minimum at 0, if > −σ then σ + |W + | ≈ σ + || + W . Hence without any restriction in generality we can replace (, σ ) by (0, σ + ||). Thus in the sequel we can assume that either = 0 or < −σ . We consider three cases: √
Case 1. ||, σ < e− ln λ . We consider an almost orthogonal partition of u˜ in dyadic regions with respect to r ∗ : √ 1 u˜ s , s0 = e− 2 ln λ . u˜ = u˜ <s0 + s0 ≤s<1 2 For each piece we can freeze r ∗ in the symbol of a −1 ps and estimate in L , w −1 (a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ s L 2 ≈ a ps (s, D, λ)u˜ s L 2 , w −1 (a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ <s0 L 2 ≈ a ps (0, D, λ)u˜ <s0 L 2 .
In the first case we use the symbol bound −1 λa −1 + s −δ |ξ |, ps (s, ξ, λ) λ| ln s|
δ > 0,
where the second term accounts for the region where |ξ | > λs δ . This yields w −1 −δ λ(a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ s L 2 | ln s| λu˜ s L 2 + s ∂r ∗ u˜ s L 2 .
In the support of u˜ s we have σ + |W + | ≈ s 2 ; therefore by Cauchy-Schwarz we obtain 1
1
w −1 4 ˜ L ∞ + s 1−δ (σ + |W +|)− 4 ∂r ∗ u ˜ L∞ . λ(a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ s L 2 | ln s| λ(σ + |W + |) u
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
63
The summation with respect to s follows due to the L 2 almost orthogonality of the w functions (a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ s , −1 w u˜ s λ (a ps ) (λ) s0 ≤s<1
⎛
λ⎝
s0 ≤s<1
L2
⎞1 2
w 2 ⎠ (a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ s L 2 1
1
λ(σ + |W + |) 4 u ˜ L ∞ + (σ + |W + |)− 4 ∂r ∗ u ˜ L∞ . w This orthogonality is due to the fact that the kernel of (a −1 ps ) (λ) decays rapidly on the −1+δ ∗ w scale in r , therefore the overlapping of the two functions of the form (a −1 λ ps ) (λ)u˜ s is trivially small for nonconsecutive values of s. On the other hand for the center piece u˜ <s0 a similar computation yields −δ w −1 λ(a −1 ps ) (λ)u˜ <s0 L 2 | ln s0 | λu˜ <s0 L 2 + s0 ∂r ∗ u˜ <s0 L 2 1
1
λ(σ + |W + |) 4 u ˜ L ∞ + s01−δ (σ + |W + |)− 4 ∂r ∗ u ˜ L∞ , where the weaker bound in the first term is due to the fact that 1 (σ + |W + |)− 2 dr ∗ ln λ. |r ∗ |<s0
√
Case 2. = 0, σ ≥ e−
ln λ .
Then we select s0 by s02 = σ and partition u˜ into u˜ = u˜ <s0 +
u˜ s .
s0 ≤s≤1
The analysis proceeds as in the first case, with the simplification that there is no longer 1 a singularity in the weight (σ + |W + |)− 2 for |r ∗ | < s0 . √
Case 3. σ, e−
ln λ
< −. Then we select s0 by s02 = − and partition u˜ into
u˜ = u˜ <s0 + u˜ s0 +
u˜ s .
s0 <s≤1
Then all pieces are estimated as in Case 2 with the exception of u˜ s0 , where we have to contend with the singularity in the weight. However, compared to Case 1 we have a better integral bound
1
|r ∗ |≈s0
|W + |− 2 dr ∗ 1
and the conclusion follows again.
64
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Due to the above lemma, it suffices to prove that, given || 1 and (u, g) supported near the photon sphere so that (∂r2∗ + λ2 (W + ))u = g,
(3.31)
then for some λ−1 < σ < 1 we have 1
1
1
(σ +|W +|)− 4 ∂r ∗ u L ∞ +λ(σ +|W +|) 4 u L ∞ (λ−1 +|W +|)− 4 g L 1 . (3.32) We remark that the first term on the left gives the L 2 bound for u r ∗ in (3.27). We consider three subcases depending on the choice of : Case 4 (i). λ−1 . Then |W + | ≈ r ∗ 2 + . Choosing σ = , it suffices to prove that: Lemma 3.7. Suppose that λ−1 . Then for u with compact support solving (3.31), we have 1
1
1
λ( + r ∗ 2 ) 4 |u| + ( + r ∗ 2 )− 4 |u r ∗ | ( + r ∗ 2 )− 4 g L 1 . Proof. We solve (3.31) as a Cauchy problem from both sides toward 0. For this we use an energy functional which is inspired by the classical WKB approximation, 1 1 3 1 E(u(r ∗ )) = λ2 (W + ) 2 u 2 + (W + )− 2 u r2∗ + Wr ∗ (W + )− 2 uu r ∗ . 2 1
Since |Wr ∗ | W 2 , the condition λ−1 guarantees that E is positive definite. Computing its derivative, we have 3 5 d 1 3 E(u(r ∗ )) = (Wr ∗ r ∗ (W + )− 2 − Wr2∗ (W + )− 2 )uu r ∗ ∗ dr 2 2 3 1 − 21 ∗ +(2(W + ) u r + Wr ∗ (W + )− 2 u)g. 2
This leads to the bound d 1 ∗ −1 −3 ∗ ∗ −1 dr ∗ E(u(r )) λ (W + ) 2 E(u(r )) + E 2 (u(r ))(W + ) 4 g. Since
3
λ−1 (W + )− 2 dr 1,
the conclusion follows by Gronwall’s inequality.
Case 4 (ii). || λ−1 . We choose σ = λ−1 . Then σ + |W + | ≈ λ−1 + r ∗ 2 . Hence it suffices to prove the pointwise bound: Lemma 3.8. Suppose that || λ−1 . Then for u with compact support solving (3.31), we have 1
1
1
λ(λ−1 + r ∗ 2 ) 4 |u| + (λ−1 + r ∗ 2 )− 4 |u r ∗ | (λ−1 + r ∗ 2 )− 4 g L 1 .
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
65
Proof. We use the same energy functional E as above. However, this time E is only 1 positive definite when W λ−1 or equivalently |r ∗ | λ− 2 . Applying Gronwall as in 1 the first case yields the conclusion of the lemma for |r ∗ | λ− 2 . 1 In the remaining interval {|r ∗ | λ− 2 } we view (3.31) as a small perturbation of the equation ∂r2∗ u = g. Precisely, we can use the energy functional 3
1
E 1 (u(r ∗ )) = λ 2 |u|2 + λ 2 |u r ∗ |2 , which satisfies
1 d 1 1 ∗ ∗ ∗ 2 E (u(r )) dr ∗ 1 λ 2 E 1 (u(r )) + E 1 (u(r ))λ 4 g.
This allows us to use Gronwall’s inequality to estimate the remaining part of u. 1
2
Case 4 (iii). − λ−1 . Then we choose σ = || 3 λ− 3 and prove the pointwise bound: Lemma 3.9. Suppose that − λ−1 . Then for u with compact support solving (3.31) we have 1
2
1
1
2
1
1
2
1
λ(|W +| + || 3 λ− 3 ) 4 |u|+(|W +|+|| 3 λ− 3 )− 4 |u r ∗ | (|W + | + || 3 λ− 3 )− 4 g L 1 . Proof. The energy E above is still useful for as long as it stays positive definite, i.e. if |Wr ∗ | < 2λ|W + |3/2 .
(3.33)
Given the quadratic behavior of W at 0, this amounts to 2
1
W + λ− 3 || 3 . In this range, due to (3.33) we obtain, as in Case 4(i), d 1 ∗ −1 −3 ∗ ∗ −1 dr ∗ E(u(r )) λ (W + ) 2 E(u(r )) + E 2 (u(r ))(W + ) 4 g, which by Gronwall’s inequality and Cauchy-Schwarz yields the desired bound. In a symmetric region around the zeroes of W + , 2
1
|W + | λ− 3 || 3 , the bounds for u and u r ∗ remain unchanged and Eq. (3.31) behaves like a small perturbation of ∂r2∗ u = g, and we can use a straightforward modification of the argument above. Finally, in the region 2
1
[r− , r+ ] = {W + < −Cλ− 3 3 }, we use an elliptic estimate. Denote 1
2
ω = |W + | + || 3 λ− 3 .
66
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Then multiplying Eq. (3.31) by −λu and integrating by parts we obtain r+ r+ r + λ|∂r ∗ u|2 + λ3 |W + ||u|2 dr ∗ = −λugdr ∗ + λuu r ∗ r−
r−
r−
1 4
λω u L ∞ (r− ,r+ ) ω
− 14
1
g L 1 + ω− 4 g2L 1 , (3.34)
where for the boundary terms at r± we have used the previously obtained pointwise bounds. On the other hand from the fundamental theorem of calculus one obtains r+ 1 λ|∂r ∗ u|2 + λ3 |W + ||u|2 dr ∗ , λ2 ω 4 u2L ∞ (r− ,r+ ) r−
where the bound (3.33) is used for the derivative of W in [r− , r+ ]. Combining the last two inequalities gives the desired bound for u, 1
1
λω 4 u L ∞ (r− ,r+ ) ω− 4 g L 1 .
(3.35)
Returning to (3.34), it also follows that r+ 1 λ|∂r ∗ u|2 + λ3 |W + ||u|2 dr ∗ ω− 4 g2L 1 .
(3.36)
r−
It remains to obtain the pointwise bound for u r ∗ . In [r− , r+ ] we have W < ||, there1 fore Wr ∗ || 2 . Given r0∗ ∈ [r− , r+ ] we consider an interval r0∗ ∈ I ⊂ [r− , r+ ] of size 1
|I | = cλ−1 ω(r0∗ )− 2 with a small c. In I the size of the weight ω is constant; indeed, ω can change at most by 1
1
|I ||Wr ∗ | = cλ−1 ω(r0∗ )− 2 2 cω(r0∗ ), 1
2
where at the last step we have used the bound ω(r0∗ ) ≥ || 3 λ− 3 . Within I we first use the L 2 bound (3.36) to estimate the average u rI ∗ of u r ∗ in I , |u rI ∗ |2
|I |
−1
1
I
1
|u r ∗ |2 dr ∗ ω(r0∗ ) 2 ω− 4 g2L 1 .
It remains to compute the variation of u r ∗ in I , which is estimated using the equation (∂r2∗ + λ2 (W + ))u = g and (3.35), I
|∂r2∗ u|dr ∗
1
I
1
λ2 ω|u| + |g|dr ∗ ω(r0∗ ) 4 ω− 4 g L 1 .
Together, the last two bounds show that 1
1
|u r ∗ (r0∗ )| ω(r0∗ ) 4 ω− 4 g L 1 . The proof of the lemma is concluded.
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
67
We continue with part (b) of the proposition. We switch to the Regge-Wheeler coordinates. By taking a spherical harmonics expansion it suffices to prove the result at a fixed spherical frequency λ. Let gλ be at spherical frequency λ with support in {11M/4 < r < 4M}. Using a time frequency multiplier with smooth symbol we can split gλ into two components, one with high ( λ) time frequency and one with low time frequency. We consider the two cases separately. Case I. gλ is localized at time frequencies {|τ | (1 + λ)}. This corresponds to Cases 1,2,3 in the proof of part (a). As a consequence of the results there we have the a-priori bound (|τ | + λ)u L 2 (∂r2∗ + Vλ,τ )u L 2 for all u with support in {5M/2 < r < 5M}. By duality this implies that for each g ∈ L 2 with support in {5M/2 < r < 5M} there exists a solution v to (∂r2∗ + Vλ,τ )v = g in3 {5M/2 < r < 5M} with (|τ | + λ)v L 2 g L 2 . Applying this at all time frequencies |τ | (1 + λ) we find a solution u λ to L RW u λ = gλ
(3.37)
in {5M/2 < r < 5M} so that (1 + λ)u λ L 2 + ∂t u λ L 2 gλ L 2 . 2 u and integrating by parts we obtain Multiplying Eq. (3.37) by χ ps λ
∂r ∗ (χ ps u λ )2L 2 λ2 χ ps u λ 2L 2 + χ ps ∂t u λ 2L 2 + u λ 2L 2 + gλ 2L 2 . Hence the function vλ = χ ps u λ satisfies ∇vλ L 2 gλ L 2 .
(3.38)
On the other hand, since gλ is supported in the smaller interval {11M/4 < r < 4M}, it follows that vλ solves the equation L RW vλ − gλ = [L RW , χ ps ]u λ . Here the right-hand side is supported in a region, away from the photon sphere, where the L 2 and L E ∗ps norms are equivalent. Then this is seen to satisfy L RW vλ − gλ L 2 gλ L 2 by applying (3.38) with χ ps replaced by a cutoff with slightly larger support. Finally, the standard energy estimates for vλ allow us to obtain uniform energy bounds for vλ from the averaged energy bounds in (3.38), thus improving (3.38) to ∇vλ L 2 + ∇vλ L ∞ L 2 gλ L 2 . 3 No boundary condition is imposed on v.
(3.39)
68
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Case II. gλ is localized at time frequencies {|τ | (1 + λ)}. This corresponds to Case 4 in the proof of part (a). We first observe that the result in part (a) can be strengthened to φ2L E ps f 2L E ∗
ps +L
1 L2
.
(3.40)
Indeed, suppose that f = f 1 + f 2 with f 1 ∈ L E ∗ps and f 2 ∈ L 1 L 2 . We solve the forward problem g φ2 = f 2 . By Theorem 1.2 and Duhamel’s formula we have φ2 L E 0 f 2 L 1 L 2 . We truncate φ2 → χ˜ ps (r )φ2 in a slightly larger set than the support of f 2 and compute g (χ˜ ps φ2 ) − f 2 L E ∗ps = [g , χ˜ ps ]φ2 L E ∗ps ≈ [g , χ˜ ps ]φ2 L 2 φ2 L E 0 , since the above commutator is supported in a compact set in r away from the photon sphere. From Duhamel’s formula and part (a) of the proposition it follows that χ˜ ps φ2 L E ps f 2 L 1 L 2 . On the other hand applying directly part (a) of the proposition to φ − χ˜ ps φ2 we obtain φ − χ˜ ps φ2 L E ps g (φ − χ˜ ps φ2 ) L E ∗ps f 1 L E ∗ps + f 2 L 1 L 2 . Hence (3.40) follows. As a consequence of (3.40) we obtain w λ(a −1 ps ) (λ)u λ L 2
inf
L RW u λ =g1 +g2
a w ps (λ)g1 L 2 + g2 L 1 L 2 .
By duality, from this bound from below for L RW , we obtain a local solvability result. Precisely, for each gλ at spherical frequency λ with support in {5M/2 < r < 5M} there is a function u λ in the same set which solves L RW u λ = gλ
(3.41)
w w λ((a −1 ps ) (λ)u λ L 2 + u λ L ∞ L 2 ) a ps (λ)gλ L 2 .
(3.42)
and satisfies the bound
δ w 2 Since (a −1 ps ) has an inverse in O P S1,0 , from the first term above we also obtain an L bound for u λ , namely
λ1−δ u λ L 2 a w ps (λ)gλ L 2 .
(3.43)
Since gλ is localized at time frequencies |τ | (1 + λ), it follows that u λ above can be assumed to have a similar time frequency localization. Hence (3.42) also gives w w (a −1 ps ) (λ)u λt L 2 + u λt L ∞ L 2 a ps (λ)gλ L 2 .
(3.44)
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
69
We can also obtain a similar bound for the r ∗ derivative of u λ . For the local energy w 2 part we multiply (3.41) by χ ps ((a −1 ps ) (λ)) χ ps u λ . After some commutations where all errors are bounded using the previous estimates we obtain w 2 2 −1 w 2 −1 w 2 (a −1 ps ) (λ)∂r ∗ (χ ps u λ ) L 2 λ (a ps ) (λ)χ ps u λ L 2 + (a ps ) (λ)χ ps u λt L 2
+λ2−2δ u λ 2L 2 + gλ 2L 2 . For the L ∞ L 2 bound on ∂r ∗ (χ ps u λ ) we consider a smooth compactly supported function 2 u and commuting we obtain χ (t). Then multiplying (3.41) by χ 2 χ ps λ χ ∂r ∗ (χ ps u λ )2L 2 λ2 χ χ ps u λ 2L 2 + χ χ ps u λt 2L 2 + u λ 2L 2 + gλ 2L 2 . Taking also (3.42) and (3.44) into account we have a bound on local averaged energy for χ χ ps u λ : 2 ∂r ∗ (χ χ ps u λ )2L 2 + λ2 χ χ ps u λ 2L 2 + ∂t (χ χ ps u λ )2L 2 a w ps (λ)gλ L 2 .
By energy estimates applied to χ χ ps u λ we can convert the averaged energy bound into a pointwise energy bound to obtain 2 ∂r ∗ (χ χ ps u λ )2L ∞ L 2 + λ2 χ χ ps u λ 2L ∞ L 2 + ∂t (χ χ ps u λ )2L ∞ L 2 a w ps (λ)gλ L 2 .
Summing up (3.42), (3.44) and the similar bounds above for the r ∗ derivatives we finally obtain w (a −1 ps ) (λ)∇(χ ps u λ ) L 2 + ∇(χ ps u λ ) L ∞ L 2 gλ L E ∗ ,
where ∇ = (∂r ∗ , ∂t , λ). On the other hand if gλ is supported in {11M/4 < r < 4M}, then u λ solves the equation L RW χ ps u λ − gλ = [L RW , χ ps ]u λ . The right-hand side is supported away from the photon sphere, where the L 2 and L E 0∗ norms are equivalent. Then, by applying Theorem 1.2 with χ ps replaced by a cutoff with slightly larger support, this is seen to satisfy L RW χ ps u λ − gλ L E 0∗ gλ L E ∗ps . The proof of the proposition is concluded.
3.2. The analysis at infinity. In the Schwarzschild space M, if a function u in M is supported in {r > 4M} we interpret it as a function in R × R3 by setting u(t, x) = u(t, r, ω) for x = r ω. We now state the analogue of Proposition 3.3. Proposition 3.10. a) Let φ solve g φ = 0 in {r > 4M}. Then χ∞ φ2L E M φ2L E 0 + E[φ](0).
70
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
b) Let f ∈ L E ∗M be supported in {r > 4M}. Then there is a function φ supported in {r > 3M} which solves g φ = f in {r M} so that sup E[φ](t) + φ2L E M + g φ − f 2L 2 f 2L E ∗ . M
t
(3.45)
Proof. a) For R > 0 we denote by χ>R a smooth cutoff function which is supported in {|x| > R} and equals 1 in {|x| ≥ 2R}. If R > 4M then (χ∞ − χ>R )φ2L E M φ2L E 0 . It remains to show that for a fixed sufficiently large R we have χ>R φ2L E M φ2L E 0 + E[φ](0). For this we notice that χ>R φ solves the equation g (χ>R φ) = f 1 (x)∇φ + f 2 (x)φ,
(3.46)
where f 1 and f 2 are supported in {R < |x| < 2R}. If R is sufficiently large then outside the ball {|x| ≤ R} the operator g is a small long range perturbation of the d’Alembertian. Then the estimate (1.5) applies, see e.g. [30, Prop. 2.2] or [28, (2.23)] (with no obstacle, = ∅) and we have χ>R φ2L E M E[χ>R φ](0) + g (χ>R φ)2L E ∗
M
E[φ](0) + [g , χ>R ]φ2L 2 E[φ](0) + φ2L E 0 ,
where in the last two steps we have used the compact support of g (χ>R φ) = [g , χ>R ]φ. b) Let R be large enough, as in part (a). For |x| > R the Schwarzchild metric g is a small long range perturbation of the Minkowski metric, according to the definition in [29]. We consider a second metric g˜ in R3+1 which coincides with g in {|x| > R} but which is globally a small long range perturbation of the Minkowski metric. Let ψ be the forward solution to g˜ ψ = f . Then we set φ = χ>R ψ. The estimate (1.5) holds for the metric g, ˜ therefore we obtain sup E[ψ](t) + ψ L E M f 2L E ∗ . t
M
Then the same bound holds as well for φ. Furthermore, we can compute the error g φ − f = (χ>R − 1) f + [g , χ>R ]ψ. This has compact spatial support, and can be easily estimated in L 2 as in part (a).
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
71
3.3. Proof of Theorem 3.2. Given f ∈ L E ∗ we split it into f = χeh f + χ ps f + χ∞ f. For the last two terms we use part (b) of Propositions 3.3, 3.10 to produce approximate solutions φ ps and φ∞ near the photon sphere, respectively near infinity. Adding them up we obtain an approximate solution φ0 = φ ps + φ∞ for the equation g φ = f . Due to (3.24) and (3.45) we obtain for φ0 the bound sup E[φ0 ](v) ˜ + φ0 2L E f 2L E ∗ ,
(3.47)
v˜
while the error f 1 = g (φ ps + φ∞ ) − f is supported away from r = 3M and r = ∞ and satisfies f 1 L E 0∗ ≈ f 1 L 2 f L E ∗ . Then we find φ = φ0 + φ1 by solving g φ1 = f 1 ∈ L E 0∗ ,
φ1 [0] = φ[0] − φ0 [0].
By Theorem 1.2 we obtain the L E 0 bound for φ1 . It remains to improve this to an L E bound for φ1 . By part (a) of Proposition 3.10 we can estimate χ∞ φ L E M . Near the photon sphere we would like to apply part (a) of Proposition 3.3 to χ ps φ. However we cannot proceed in an identical manner because part (a) of Proposition 3.3 does not involve the Cauchy data of φ at t = 0, and instead applies to functions φ defined on the full real axis in t. To address this issue we extend φ1 backward in t to the set MR , by solving the homogeneous problem g φ1 = 0 in MR , with matching Cauchy data on the common boundary of M R and MR . The extended function φ1 belongs to both L E(M R ) and L E(MR ), and now we can estimate χ ps φ1 via part (a) of Proposition 3.3. 4. Strichartz Estimates In this section we prove Theorem 1.4. The theorem follows from the following two propositions. The first gives the result for the right-hand side, f , in the dual local energy space: Proposition 4.11. Let (ρ, p, q) be a nonsharp Strichartz pair. Then for each φ ∈ L E with g φ ∈ L E ∗ + L 1v˜ L 2 we have ∇φ2L p H˙ −ρ,q E[φ](0) + φ2L E + g φ2L E ∗ +L 1 L 2 . v˜
v˜
(4.48)
The second one allows us to use L p2 L q2 in the right-hand side of the wave equation.
72
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Proposition 4.12. There is a parametrix K for g so that for all nonsharp Strichartz pairs (ρ1 , p1 , q1 ) and (ρ2 , p2 , q2 ) we have ˜ + E[K f ]( +R ) + K f 2L E + ∇ K f 2 p1 sup E[K f ](v)
L v˜ H˙ −ρ1 ,q1
v˜
f 2 p
L v˜ 2 H˙ ρ2 ,q2
,
(4.49) and the error estimate g K f − f L E ∗ +L 1 L 2 f v˜
p
L v˜ 2 H˙ ρ2 ,q2
.
(4.50)
We first show how to use the propositions in order to prove the theorem. Proof of Theorem 1.4. Suppose that g φ = f with f ∈ L p2 H˙ ρ2 ,q2 . We write φ as
φ = φ1 + K f with K as in Proposition 4.12. By (4.49) the K f term satisfies all the required estimates; therefore it remains to consider φ1 . Using also (4.50) we obtain g φ1 2L E ∗ +L 1 L 2 + E[φ1 ](0) E[φ](0) + f 2 p L
v˜
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
.
Then Theorem 3.2 combined with Duhamel’s formula yields ˜ E[φ](0) + f 2 p φ1 2L E + g φ1 2L E ∗ +L 1 L 2 + sup E[φ1 ](v) v˜
v˜
Finally the L p1 H˙ −ρ1 ,q1 bound for ∇φ1 follows by Proposition 4.11.
L
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
.
We continue with the proofs of the two propositions. Proof of Proposition 4.11. By Duhamel’s formula and Theorem 3.2 we can neglect the L 1 L 2 part of g φ. Hence in the sequel we assume that g φ ∈ L E ∗ . We use cutoffs to split the space into three regions, namely near the event horizon, near the photon sphere and near infinity, φ = χeh φ + χ ps φ + χ∞ φ. Due to the definition of the L E and L E ∗ norms we have E[φ](0) + φ2L E + g φ2L E ∗ E[χeh φ](0) + χeh φ2H 1 + g (χeh φ)2L 2 + E[χ ps φ](0) + χ ps φ2L E ps + g (χ ps φ)2L E ∗ps +E[χ∞ φ](0) + χ∞ φ2L E M + g (χ∞ φ)2L E ∗ . M
Proving this requires commuting g with the cutoffs. However this is straightforward since the L E and L E ∗ norms are equivalent to the H 1 , respectively L 2 , norm in the support of ∇χeh , ∇χ ps and ∇χ∞ . p It remains to prove the L v˜ H˙ −ρ,q bound for each of the three terms in ∇φ. We consider the three cases separately:
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
73
I. The estimate near the event horizon. This is the easiest case. Given φ supported in {r < 11M/4}, we partition it on the unit scale with respect to v, ˜ χ (v˜ − j)φ, φ= j∈Z
where χ is a suitable smooth compactly supported bump function. Commuting the cutoffs with g one easily obtains the square summability relation χ (v˜ − j)φ2H 1 + g (χ (v˜ − j)φ)2L 2 + E[χ (v˜ − j)φ](0) j∈N
φ2H 1 + g φ2L 2 + E[φ](0), where the energy term on the left is nonzero only for finitely many j. Since each of the functions χ (v˜ − j)φ have compact support, they satisfy the Strichartz estimates due to the local theory; see [32,39,47]. The above square summability with respect to j guarantees that the local estimates can be added up. II. The estimate near the photon sphere. For φ supported in {5M/2 < r < 5M} we need to show that ∇φ2L p H −ρ,q E[φ](0) + φ2L E ps + g φ2L E ∗ps . v˜
We use again the Regge-Wheeler coordinates. Then the operator g is replaced by L RW . The potential V can be neglected due to the straightforward bound V φ L E ∗ps φ L E ps . Indeed, for φ at spherical frequency λ we have 1
1
V φ L E ∗ps | ln(2 + λ)| 2 φ L 2 λ| ln(2 + λ)|− 2 φ L 2 φ L E ps . We introduce the auxiliary function ψ = A−1 ps φ. By the definition of the L E ps norm we have ψ H 1 φ L E ps .
(4.51)
L RW ψ L 2 φ L E ps + L RW φ L 2 .
(4.52)
We also claim that
2 Since A−1 ps is L bounded, this is a consequence of the commutator bound 2 [A−1 ps , L RW ] : L E ps → L ,
or equivalently 1 2 [A−1 ps , L RW ]A ps : H → L .
(4.53)
74
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
It suffices to consider the first term in the symbol calculus, as the remainder belongs to δ , mapping H δ to L 2 for all δ > 0. The symbol of the first term is O P S1,δ 2 −3 2 q(ξ, r ∗ , λ) = {a −1 ps (λ), ξ + r (r − 2M)λ }a ps (λ), 1+δ . For a better estimate we compute the Poisson bracket and a-priori we have q ∈ S1,δ
q(ξ, r ∗ , λ) = a −1 ps (λ)γ y (y, ln λ)
4ξr ∗ − 2ξ ∂r ∗ (r −3 (r − 2M)) , r ∗ 2 + λ−2 ξ 2
where y = r ∗ 2 + λ−2 ξ 2 . The first two factors on the right are bounded. The third is bounded by λ since ∂r ∗ (r −3 (r − 2M)) vanishes at r ∗ = 0. In addition, q is supported in 0 |ξ | λ. Hence we obtain q ∈ λS1−δ,δ . Then the commutator bound (4.53) follows. Given (4.51) and (4.52), we argue as in the first case, namely we localize ψ to time intervals of unit length and then apply the local Strichartz estimates. By summing over these strips we obtain ∇ψ L p H −ρ,q φ L E ps + L RW φ L 2 for all sharp Strichartz pairs (ρ, p, q). To return to φ we invert A−1 ps , φ = A ps ψ + (1 − A ps A−1 ps )φ. The second term is much more regular, ∇(1 − A ps A−1 ps )φ L 2 H 1−δ φ L E ps ,
δ > 0;
therefore it satisfies all the Strichartz estimates simply by Sobolev embeddings. For the main term A ps ψ we take advantage of the fact that we only seek to prove the nonsharp Strichartz estimates for φ. The nonsharp Strichartz estimates for ψ are obtained from the sharp ones via Sobolev embeddings, 3 3 + ρ2 = + ρ1 , ρ1 < ρ2 . q2 q1
∇ψ H −ρ2 ,q2 ∇ψ H −ρ1 ,q1 ,
To obtain the nonsharp estimates for φ instead, we need a slightly stronger form of the above bound, namely Lemma 4.13. Assume that 1 < q1 < q2 < ∞. Then 3 3 + ρ2 = + ρ1 . q2 q1
A ps u H −ρ2 ,q2 u H −ρ1 ,q1 , Proof. We need to prove that the operator B = O p w (ξ 2 + λ2 + 1)−
ρ2 2
A ps O p w (ξ 2 + λ2 + 1)
maps L q1 into L q2 . The principal symbol of B is b0 (r ∗ , ξ, λ) = (ξ 2 + λ2 + 1)
ρ1 −ρ2 2
a ps (r ∗ , ξ, λ),
ρ1 2
(4.54)
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
75
and by the pdo calculus the remainder is easy to estimate, ρ −ρ2 −1+δ
1 B − b0w ∈ O P S1,0
,
δ > 0.
The conclusion of the lemma will follow from the Hardy-Littlewood-Sobolev inequality if we prove a suitable pointwise bound on the kernel K of b0w , namely |K (r1∗ , ω1 , r2∗ , ω2 )| (|r1∗ − r2∗ ||ω1 − ω2 |2 )
−1+ q1 − q1 1
2
.
(4.55)
For fixed r ∗ we consider a smooth dyadic partition of unity in frequency as follows:
µ χ{λ≈µ} χ{|ξ |ν0 } + χ{|ξ |≈ν} , 1 = χ{|ξ |>λ} + ν=ν0
µ dyadic
where ν0 = ν0 (λ, r ∗ ) is given by √ ln ν0 (λ, r ∗ ) = ln λ + max{ln r ∗ , − ln λ}. This leads to a similar decomposition for b0 , namely
µ bµν . b0 = b00 + bµ,<ν0 + µ
ν=ν0
In the region |ξ | λ the symbol b0 is of class S ρ1 −ρ2 , which yields a kernel bound for b00 of the form |K 00 (r1∗ , ω1 , r2∗ , ω2 )| (|r1∗ − r2∗ | + |ω1 − ω2 |)−3−ρ1 +ρ2 . The symbols of bµν are supported in {|ξ | ≈ ν, λ ≈ µ}, are smooth on the same scale and have size ln(ν −1 µ)µρ2 −ρ1 . Hence their kernels satisfy bounds of the form |K µ,ν (r1∗ , ω1 , r2∗ , ω2 )| ln(ν −1 µ)µρ1 −ρ2 ν(|r1∗ − r2∗ |ν + 1)−N µ2 (|ω1 − ω2 |µ + 1)−N , and similarly for K µ,<ν0 . Then (4.55) follows after summation.
III. The estimate near infinity. Let us first recall the setup from [29]. We fix a Littlewood-Paley dyadic decomposition of frequency space in R3 , 1=
∞
Sk (D), supp sk ⊂ {2k−1 < |ξ | < 2k+1 }.
k=−∞
Functions u in R × R3 which are localized to frequency 2k are measured in u X k = 2k/2 u L 2 (A<−k ) + sup |x|−1/2 u L 2 (A j ) , j≥−k
where A j = R × {2 j ≤ |x| ≤ 2 j+1 },
A< j = R × {|x| ≤ 2 j }.
(4.56)
76
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
As in [29], by X 0 we denote the space of functions in R × R3 with norm u2X 0 =
∞
Sk u2X k ,
(4.57)
k=−∞
and by Y 0 the dual norm u2Y 0 =
∞
Sk u2 ,
k=−∞
Xk
where X k is the dual norm of X k . One can establish the following (see [29, Lemma 1]) Lemma 4.14. The following inequalities hold: sup 2− j/2 ∇u L 2 (A j ) ∇u X 0
(4.58)
uY 0 u L E ∗M .
(4.59)
j
and its dual
For small deviations from the Minkowski metric, one can also establish stronger local energy estimates involving the X 0 and Y 0 norms; more precisely, one can prove (see [29, Theorem 4]): Lemma 4.15. Let g˜ be a sufficiently small, long range perturbation of the Minkowski metric. Then, for all solutions u to the inhomogeneous problem g˜ u = f , one has ∇u2L ∞ L 2 + ∇u2X 0 E[u](0) + f 2Y 0 +L 1 L 2 . t
x
t
x
We now return to proving our estimate. For φ supported in {r > 4M} we need to show that ∇φ2L p H˙ −ρ,q E[φ](0) + φ2L E M + g φ2L E ∗ . M
(4.60)
For large R we split φ into a near and a far part φ = χ>R φ + χ
R φ](0) + χ>R φ2L E M + g (χ>R φ)2L E ∗ M
M
+ E[χ R}. But in this region the operator g is a small long range perturbation of ; therefore the results of [29] apply. More precisely, from [29, Theorem 7(a)] we obtain ∇φ2L p H˙ −ρ,q E[φ](0) + ∇φ2X 0 + g φ2L E ∗ .
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
77
This does not directly imply (4.60), since the X 0 norm is stronger than L E M . However, we can apply Lemma 4.15 and (4.59) to obtain the bound ∇φ2X 0 E[φ](0) + g φ2L E ∗ . M
Proof of Proposition 4.12. We split f into f = χeh f + χ ps f + χ∞ f and construct the parametrix separately in the three regions. I. The parametrix near the event horizon. We further partition the term χeh f into unit intervals χeh f = χ (v˜ − j)χeh f j
with χ supported in [−1, 1], so that each component has compact support in the region D j = {r0 ≤ r < 11M/4, j − 2 < v˜ < j + 2}. Let ψ j be the forward solution to g ψ j = χ (v˜ − j)χeh f. Due to the local Strichartz estimates for variable coefficient wave equations, we obtain the uniform bounds ∇ψ j L p1 H −ρ1 ,q1 (D j ) +∇ψ j L ∞ L 2 (D j ) +ψ j L ∞ L 2 (D j ) χ (v− ˜ j)χeh f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
Next we truncate ψ j using a cutoff function χ˜ (v˜ − j, r ) which is supported in D j and equals 1 in the support of χ (v˜ − j)χeh . Then the bound above also holds for the truncated functions φ j = χ( ˜ v˜ − j, r )ψ j , ∇φ j L p1 H −ρ1 ,q1 + ∇φ j L ∞ L 2 + φ j L ∞ L 2 (D j ) χ (v˜ − j)χeh f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
(4.61) In addition, g φ j − χ (v˜ − j)χeh f = [g , χ˜ (v˜ − j, r )]ψ j ; therefore g φ j − χ (v˜ − j)χeh f L 2 χ (v˜ − j)χeh f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
(4.62)
Finally, by energy estimates we also obtain a bound for the energy of φ j on the future space-like boundary of D j at r = r0 , ∇φ j L 2 (D j ∩{r =r0 }) + φ j L 2 (D j ∩{r =r0 }) χ (v˜ − j)χeh f To conclude we set K eh f =
j
φj.
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
(4.63)
78
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Summing up the bounds (4.61), (4.62) and (4.63) for φ j we obtain the desired bounds for K eh , namely sup E[K eh f ](v) ˜ + E[K eh f ]( +R ) + K eh f 2H 1 + ∇ K eh f 2L p1 H −ρ1 ,q1 v˜
χeh f 2 p L
2 H ρ2 ,q2
,
respectively the error estimate g K eh f − χeh f L 2 χeh f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
II. The parametrix near the photon sphere. We work in the Regge-Wheeler coordinates. Arguing as in the previous case we produce a parametrix K˜ ps with the property that, for each f supported in {5M/2 + < r < 5M − }, the function K˜ ps f is supported in {5M/2 < r < 5M} and satisfies the bounds sup E[ K˜ ps f ](t) + K˜ ps f 2H 1 + ∇ K˜ ps f 2L p1 H −ρ1 ,q1 f 2 p L
x,t
t
2 H ρ2 ,q2
,
and the error estimate L RW K˜ ps f − f L 2 f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
Then we define the localized parametrix near the photon sphere K ps as ˜ K ps f = A−1 ps K ps χ˜ ps A ps (χ ps f ), with χ˜ ps = 1 in the support of χ ps and slightly larger support. Then we show that K ps satisfies the required bounds. We recall that (ρ2 , p2 , q2 ) is a nonsharp Strichartz pair. Then by (4.54) we can write χ˜ ps A ps (χ ps f )
L p3 H ρ3 ,q3
χ ps f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
2 for some other Strichartz pair (ρ3 , p3 , q3 ) with p3 = p2 and q3 < q2 . Since A−1 ps is L bounded, from the above bounds for K˜ ps we obtain
sup E[K ps f ](t) + K ps f 2H 1 χ ps f 2 p L
t
2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
By using (4.54) with A ps replaced by the weaker operator A−1 ps we also obtain the L p1 H −ρ1 ,q1 bound for K ps f : ∇ K ps f 2L p1 H −ρ1 ,q1 ∇ K˜ ps χ˜ ps A ps (χ ps f )2L p H −ρ,q χ ps f 2 p L
2 H ρ2 ,q2
,
where (ρ, p, q) is another Strichartz pair with p = p1 and q < q1 . It remains to consider the error estimate, L RW K ps f − χ ps f L E ∗ +L 1 L 2 χ ps f v˜
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
,
(4.64)
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
79
for which we compute ˜ L RW K ps f − χ ps f = [L RW , A−1 ps ] K ps χ˜ ps A ps (χ ps f ) ˜ +A−1 ps (L RW K ps − I )χ˜ ps A ps (χ ps f ) +(A−1 ps χ˜ ps A ps − χ˜ ps )(χ ps f ). We consider each term in the above decomposition. For the first term, due to the H 1 bound for K˜ , we need the commutator bound 1 ∗ [L RW , A−1 ps ] : H → L E
or equivalently 1 2 A ps [L RW , A−1 ps ] : H → L ,
which is almost identical to (4.53) and is proved in the same manner. The bound for the second term is a direct consequence of the L 2 error bound for K˜ . −1+δ Finally, for the last term we know that (A−1 ps A ps − I ) ∈ O P S1,0 ; therefore using Sobolev embeddings we estimate (A−1 ps χ˜ ps A ps − χ˜ ps )(χ ps f )
1
L p2 H 2
χ ps f
L p2 H ρ2 ,q2
.
This concludes the proof of (4.64) since
1
1
1
L p2 H 2 ⊂ L 2 H 2 + L 1 H 2 ⊂ L E ∗ps + L 1 L 2 . III. The parametrix near infinity. We now consider the last component of f , namely χ∞ f . For some large R we separate it into two parts, χ∞ f = (χ∞ − χ>R ) f + χ>R f. The first part has compact support in r ; therefore we can handle it as in the first case (i.e. R f. We consider a second cutoff function χ˜ >R which is supported in r > R and equals 1 in the support of χ>R . Then we define >R K∞ f = χ˜ >R ψ∞ . >R satisfies the appropriate bounds, It remains to show that K ∞ >R >R >R sup E[K ∞ f ](t) + K ∞ f 2L E M + ∇ K ∞ f 2L p1 H˙ −ρ1 ,q1 χ>R f 2 p L
t
respectively the error estimate >R g K ∞ f − χ>R f L E ∗M χ>R f
L p2 H˙ ρ2 ,q2
.
These are easily obtained by applying the following lemma to ψ∞ :
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
,
80
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
Lemma 4.16. Let f ∈ L p2 H˙ ρ2 ,q2 . Then the forward solution ψ to g˜ ψ = f satisfies the bound sup E[ψ](t) + ψ2L E M + ∇ψ2L p1 H˙ −ρ1 ,q1 f 2 p L
t
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
.
(4.65)
It remains to prove the lemma. This largely follows from [29, Theorem 6], but there is an interesting technical issue that needs clarification. Precisely, [29, Theorem 6] shows that we have the bound sup E[ψ](t) + ∇ψ2X 0 + ∇ψ2L p1 H˙ −ρ1 ,q1 f 2 p L
t
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
.
(4.66)
By Lemma 4.14, we are left with proving that 3j
sup 2− 2 ψ L 2 (A j ) f j∈Z
L p2 H˙ ρ2 ,q2
.
(4.67)
We note that this does not follow from Lemma 4.14; this is a forbidden endpoint of the Hardy inequality in [29, Lemma 1(b)]. However, the bound (4.67) can still be obtained, although in a roundabout way. Precisely, from (4.66) we have sup E[ψ](t) f 2 p L
t
(4.68)
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
for the forward in time evolution, and similarly for the backward in time problem. On the other hand, a straightforward modification of the classical Morawetz estimates (see e.g. [27]) for the wave equation shows that the solutions to the homogeneous wave equation g˜ ψ = 0 satisfy sup 2−3 j ψ2L 2 (A j∈Z
j)
E[ψ](0).
(4.69)
Denote by 1t>s H (t, s) the forward fundamental solution for g˜ and by H (t, s) its backward extension to a solution to the homogeneous equation, g˜ H (t, s) = 0. Combining the bounds (4.68) and (4.69) shows that sup 2
−3 j
j
2 H (t, s) f (s)ds 2 R
L (A j )
f 2 p L
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
.
Since p2 < 2, by the Christ-Kiselev lemma [11], it follows that sup 2−3 j j
which is exactly (4.67).
∞ t
2 H (t, s) f (s)ds
L 2 (A
j)
f 2 p L
˙ ρ2 ,q2 2H
,
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
81
5. The Critical NLW In this section we prove Theorem 1.5. We first consider (1.18) in the compact region MC . We denote by ψ the solution to the homogeneous equation ψ|0 = φ0 , K˜ ψ|0 = φ1 ,
g ψ = 0,
and by T f the solution to the inhomogeneous problem T F|0 = 0, K˜ T f |0 = 0.
g (T f ) = f,
Then we can rewrite the nonlinear equation (1.18) in the form φ = ψ ± T (φ 5 ).
(5.70)
We define Sobolev spaces in MC by restricting to MC functions in the same Sobolev space which are compactly supported in a larger open set. By the local Strichartz estimates we have ψ
1
H 2 ,4 (MC )
E[φ](0 )
and T f
1
H 2 ,4 (MC )
f
1 4
H 2 , 3 (MC )
.
At the same time we have the multiplicative estimate φ 5
1 4
H 2 , 3 (MC )
φ5
1
H 2 ,4 (MC )
.
Then for small initial data we can use the contraction principle to solve (5.70) and obtain 1 a solution φ ∈ H 2 ,4 (MC ). In addition, still by local Strichartz estimates, the solution φ will have finite energy on any space-like surface, in particular on the forward and backward space-like boundary of MC . Thus we obtain E[φ]( − R ) E[φ](0 ). It remains to solve (1.18) in M R (and its other three symmetrical copies). Using the (v, ˜ r, ω) coordinates in M R we define ψ and T as above, but with Cauchy data on − R. By the global Strichartz estimates in Theorem 1.4, for (s, p) as in the theorem we have ψ L p H˙ s, p (M R ) E[φ]( − R) and T f L p H˙ s, p (M R ) f L 1 L 2 . In particular we can take p = 5 which corresponds to s = dings we have φ L 5 L 10 φ
3
H˙ 10 ,5
;
3 10 .
By Sobolev embed-
82
J. Marzuola, J. Metcalfe, D. Tataru, M. Tohaneanu
therefore φ 5 L 1 L 2 φ5
3
H˙ 10 ,5
.
Hence we can solve (5.70) using the contraction principle and obtain a solution φ ∈ 3 H˙ 10 ,5 . This implies that φ 5 ∈ L 1 L 2 , which yields all of the other Strichartz estimates, as well as the energy bound on the forward boundary +R of M R . This concludes the proof of the theorem. Acknowledgement. The authors are grateful to M. Dafermos and I. Rodnianski for pointing out their novel way of taking advantage of the red shift effect in [14], and to N. Burq and M. Zworski for useful conversations concerning the analysis near trapped null geodesics. Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
References 1. Alinhac, S.: On the Morawetz–Keel-Smith-Sogge inequality for the wave equation on a curved background. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. 42, 705–720 (2006) 2. Blue, P., Soffer, A.: Semilinear wave equations on the Schwarzschild manifold I: Local decay estimates. Adv. Differential Equations 8, 595–614 (2003) 3. Blue, P., Soffer, A.: The wave equation on the Schwarzschild metric II: Local decay for the spin-2 ReggeWheeler equation. J. Math. Phys. 46(1), 012502 (2005) 4. Blue, P., Soffer, A.: Errata for “Global existence and scatttering for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation on Schwarzschild manifolds”, “Semilinear wave equations on the Schwarzschild manifold I: Local decay estimates”, and “The wave equation on the Schwarzschild metric II: Local decay for the spin 2 Regge Wheeler equation”. http://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0608073v3, 2006 5. Blue, P., Soffer, A.: Phase space analysis on some black hole manifolds. J. Funct. Anal. 256(1), 1–90 (2009) 6. Blue, P., Soffer, A.: Improved decay rates with small regularity loss for the wave equation about a Schwarzschild black hole. http://arxiv.org/abs/math/0612168v1[math.Ap], 2006 7. Blue, P., Sterbenz, J.: Uniform decay of local energy and the semi-linear wave equation on Schwarzschild space. Commun. Math. Phys. 268, 481–504 (2006) 8. Brenner, P.: On L p − L p estimates for the wave-equation. Math. Z. 145, 251–254 (1975) 9. Burq, N.: Smoothing effect for Schrödinger boundary value problems. Duke Math. J. 123, 403–427 (2004) 10. Burq, N., Gérard, P., Tzvetkov, N.: Strichartz inequalities and the nonlinear Schrödinger equation on compact manifolds. Amer. J. Math. 126, 569–605 (2004) 11. Christ, M., Kiselev, A.: Maximal functions associated to filtrations. J. Funct. Anal. 179, 409–425 (2001) 12. Christianson, H.: Dispersive estimates for manifolds with one trapped orbit. Comm. Part. Diff. Eqs. 33, 1147–1174 (2008) 13. Colinde Verdière, Y., Parisse, B.: Equilibre instable en Regime Semi-classique: I - concentration microlocale. Commun. PDE. 19, 1535–1563 (1994) 14. Dafermos, M., Rodnianski, I.: The red-shift effect and radiation decay on black hole spacetimes. http:// arXiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0512119v1, 2005 15. Dafermos, M., Rodnianski, I.: A note on energy currents and decay for the wave equation on a Schwarzschild background. http://arXiv.org/ab0710.0171v1[math.Ap], 2007 16. Dafermos, M., Rodnianski, I.: A proof of Price’s law for the collapse of a self-gravitating scalar field. Invent. Math. 162, 381–457 (2005) 17. Ginibre, J., Velo, G.: Generalized Strichartz inequalities for the wave equation. J. Funct. Anal. 133, 50–68 (1995) 18. Hawking, S.W., Ellis, G.F.R.: The Large Scale Structure of Space-Time. Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics, No. 1., London, New York: Cambridge University Press, 1973 19. Kapitanski, L.: Some generalizations of the Strichartz-Brenner inequality. Leningrad Math. J. 1, 693–726 (1990) 20. Keel, M., Smith, H., Sogge, C.D.: Almost global existence for some semilinear wave equations. J. Anal. Math. 87, 265–279 (2002)
Strichartz Estimates on Schwarzschild Black Hole Backgrounds
83
21. Keel, M., Tao, T.: Endpoint Strichartz estimates. Amer. J. Math. 120, 955–980 (1998) 22. Kenig, C.E., Ponce, G., Vega, L.: On the Zakharov and Zakharov-Schulman systems. J. Funct. Anal. 127, 204–234 (1995) 23. Kronthaler, J.: Decay Rates for Spherical Scalar Waves in the Schwarzschild Geometry. http://arXiv.org/ abs/0709.3703v1[gr-qc], 2007 24. Kay, B., Wald, R.: Linear stability of Schwarzschild under perturbations which are nonvanishing on the bifurcation 2-sphere. Class. Quant. Grav. 4, 893–898 (1987) 25. Laba, I., Soffer, A.: Global existence and scattering for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation on Schwarzschild manifolds. Helv. Phys. Acta 72, 274–294 (1999) 26. Lindblad, H., Sogge, C.D.: On existence and scattering with minimal regularity for semilinear wave equations. J. Funct. Anal. 130, 357–426 (1995) 27. Metcalfe, J., Sogge, C.D.: Long-time existence of quasilinear wave equations exterior to star-shaped obstacles via energy methods. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 38, 391–420 (2006) 28. Metcalfe, J., Sogge, C.D.: Global existence of null-form wave equations in exterior domains. Math. Z. 256, 521–549 (2007) 29. Metcalfe, J., Tataru, D.: Global parametrices and dispersive estimates for variable coefficient wave equations. http://arXiv.org/abs/0707.1191v2[math.Ap], 2007 30. Metcalfe, J., Tataru, D.: Global parametrices and dispersive estimates for variable coefficient wave equations in exterior domains. http://arXiv.org/abs/0806.3409v2[math.Ap], 2009 31. Misner, C.W., Thorne, K.S., Wheeler, J.A.: Gravitation. San Francisco, CA: W. H. Freeman and Co., 1973 32. Mockenhaupt, G., Seeger, A., Sogge, C.D.: Local smoothing of Fourier integral operators and CarlesonSjölin estimates. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 6, 65–130 (1993) 33. Morawetz, C.: Time decay for the nonlinear Klein-Gordon equations. Proc. Roy. Soc. Ser. A. 306, 291–296 (1968) 34. Nonnenmacher, S., Zworski, M.: Quantum decay rates in chaotic scattering. http://arXiv.org/abs/0706. 3242v2[math-ph], 2007 35. Pecher, H.: Nonlinear small data scattering for the wave and Klein-Gordon equations. Math. Z. 185, 261–270 (1984) 36. Price, R.: Nonspherical perturbations of relativistic gravitational collapse. I. Scalar and gravitational perturbations. Phys. Rev. D (3) 5, 2419–2438 (1972) 37. Ralston, J.V.: Solutions of the wave equation with localized energy. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 22, 807–823 (1969) 38. Schlag, W., Soffer, A., Staubach, W.: Decay for the wave and Schroedinger evolutions on manifolds with conical ends, Part II. http://arXiv.org/abs/0801.2001v1[math.Ap], 2008 39. Smith, H.F.: A parametrix construction for wave equations with C 1,1 coefficients. Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 48, 797–835 (1998) 40. Smith, H.F., Sogge, C.D.: Global Strichartz estimates for nontrapping perturbations of the Laplacian. Comm. Part. Diff. Eqs. 25, 2171–2183 (2000) 41. Sterbenz, J.: Angular regularity and Strichartz estimates for the wave equation. With an appendix by I. Rodnianski. Int. Math. Res. Not. 2005, 187–231 (2005) 42. Strauss, W.A.: Dispersal of waves vanishing on the boundary of an exterior domain. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 28, 265–278 (1975) 43. Strichartz, R.S.: A priori estimates for the wave equation and some applications. J. Funct. Anal. 5, 218–235 (1970) 44. Strichartz, R.S.: Restrictions of Fourier transforms to quadratic surfaces and decay of solutions of wave equations. Duke Math. J. 44, 705–714 (1977) 45. Tataru, D.: Strichartz estimates for operators with nonsmooth coefficients and the nonlinear wave equation. Amer. J. Math. 122, 349–376 (2000) 46. Tataru, D.: Strichartz estimates for second order hyperbolic operators with nonsmooth coefficients II. Amer. J. Math. 123, 385–423 (2001) 47. Tataru, D.: Strichartz estimates for second order hyperbolic operators with nonsmooth coefficients III. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 15, 419–442 (2002) 48. Tataru, D.: Parametrices and dispersive estimates for Schroedinger operators with variable coefficients. Amer. J. Math. 130, 571–634 (2008) 49. Twainy, F.: The Time Decay of Solutions to the Scalar Wave Equation in Schwarzschild Background. Thesis, University of California San Diego, 1989 50. Wald, R.M.: Note on the stability of the Schwarzschild metric. J. Math. Phys. 20, 1056–1058 (1979) 51. Wald, R.M.: General Relativity. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1984 Communicated by S. Zelditch
Commun. Math. Phys. 293, 85–125 (2010) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-009-0880-7
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime Stefan Hollands1 , Robert M. Wald2 1 School of Mathematics, Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales CF24 4AG, UK.
E-mail: [email protected]
2 Enrico Fermi Institute and Department of Physics, University of Chicago,
Chicago, IL 60637, USA. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 22 May 2008 / Accepted: 6 May 2009 Published online: 1 September 2009 – © Springer-Verlag 2009
Abstract: The usual formulations of quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime make crucial use of features—such as Poincaré invariance and the existence of a preferred vacuum state—that are very special to Minkowski spacetime. In order to generalize the formulation of quantum field theory to arbitrary globally hyperbolic curved spacetimes, it is essential that the theory be formulated in an entirely local and covariant manner, without assuming the presence of a preferred state. We propose a new framework for quantum field theory, in which the existence of an Operator Product Expansion (OPE) is elevated to a fundamental status, and, in essence, all of the properties of the quantum field theory are determined by its OPE. We provide general axioms for the OPE coefficients of a quantum field theory. These include a local and covariance assumption (implying that the quantum field theory is constructed in a local and covariant manner from the spacetime metric and other background structure, such as time and space orientations), a microlocal spectrum condition, an “associativity” condition, and the requirement that the coefficient of the identity in the OPE of the product of a field with its adjoint have positive scaling degree. We prove curved spacetime versions of the spin-statistics theorem and the PCT theorem. Some potentially significant further implications of our new viewpoint on quantum field theory are discussed. 1. Introduction The Wightman axioms [27] of quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime are generally believed to express the fundamental properties that quantum fields possess. In essence, these axioms require that the following key properties hold: (1) The states of the theory are unit rays in a Hilbert space, H, that carries a unitary representation of the Poincaré group. (2) The 4-momentum (defined by the action of the Poincaré group on the Hilbert space) is positive, i.e., its spectrum is contained within the closed future light cone (“spectrum condition”). (3) There exists a unique, Poincaré invariant state (“the vacuum”). (4) The quantum fields are operator-valued distributions defined on a
86
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
dense domain D ⊂ H that is both Poincaré invariant and invariant under the action of the fields and their adjoints. (5) The fields transform in a covariant manner under the action of Poincaré transformations. (6) At spacelike separations, quantum fields either commute or anticommute. During the past 40 years, considerable progress has been made in understanding both the physical and mathematical properties of quantum fields in curved spacetime. Although gravity itself is treated classically, this theory incorporates some key aspects of general relativity and thereby should provide a more fundamental base for quantum field theory. Much of the progress has occurred in the analysis of free (i.e., nonself-interacting) fields, but in the past decade, major progress also has been made in the perturbative analysis of interacting quantum fields. Significant insights have thereby been obtained into the nature of quantum field phenomena in strong gravitational fields. In addition, some important insights have been obtained into the nature of quantum field theory itself. One of the key insights is that—apart from stationary spacetimes or spacetimes with other very special properties—there is no unique, natural notion of a “vacuum state” or of “particles”. Indeed, unless the spacetime is asymptotically stationary at early or late times, there will not, in general, even be an asymptotic notion of particle states. Consequently, it is essential that quantum field theory in curved spacetime be formulated in terms of the local field observables as opposed, e.g., to S-matrices. Since quantum field theory in curved spacetime should be much closer to a true theory of nature than quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime, it is of interest to attempt to abstract the fundamental features of quantum field theory in curved spacetime in a manner similar to the way the Wightman axioms abstract what are generally believed to be the fundamental features of quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime. The Wightman axioms are entirely compatible with the focus on local field observables, as needed for a formulation of quantum field theory in curved spacetime. However, most of the properties of quantum fields stated in the Wightman axioms are very special to Minkowski spacetime and cannot be generalized straightforwardly to curved spacetime. Specifically, a curved spacetime cannot possess Poincaré symmetry—indeed a generic curved spacetime will not possess any symmetries at all—so one certainly cannot require “Poincaré invariance/covariance” or invariance under any other type of spacetime symmetry. Thus, no direct analog of properties (3) and (5) can be imposed in curved spacetime, and the key aspects of properties (1) and (2) (as well as an important aspect of (4)) also do not make sense. In fact, the situation with regard to importing properties (1), (2), and (4) to curved spacetime is even worse than would be suggested by merely the absence of symmetries: There exist unitarily inequivalent Hilbert space constructions of free quantum fields in spacetimes with a noncompact Cauchy surface and (in the absence of symmetries of the spacetime) none appears “preferred”. Thus, it is not appropriate even to assume, as in (1), that states are unit rays in a single Hilbert space, nor is it appropriate to assume, as in (4), that the (smeared) quantum fields are operators on this unique Hilbert space. With regard to (2), although energy and momentum in curved spacetime cannot be defined via the action of a symmetry group, the stress-energy tensor of a quantum field in curved spacetime should be well defined as a distributional observable on spacetime, so one might hope that it might be possible to, say, integrate the (smeared) energy density of a quantum field over a Cauchy surface and replace the Minkowski spacetime spectrum condition by the condition that the total energy of the quantum field in any state always is non-negative. However, this is not a natural thing to do, since the “total energy” defined in this way is highly slice/smearing dependent, and it is well known in classical general
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
87
relativity that in asymptotically flat spacetimes, the integrated energy density of matter may bear little relationship to the true total mass-energy. Furthermore, it is well known that the energy density of a quantum field (in flat or curved spacetime) can be negative, and, in some simple examples involving free fields in curved spacetime, the integrated energy density is found to be negative. Consequently, there is no analog of property (2) in curved spacetime that can be formulated in terms of the “total energy-momentum” of the quantum field. Thus, of all of the properties of quantum fields in Minkowski spacetime stated in the Wightman axioms, only property (6) has a straightforward generalization to curved spacetimes! Nevertheless, it has been understood for quite some time that the difficulties in the formulation of quantum field theory in curved spacetime that arise from the existence of unitarily inequivalent Hilbert space constructions of the theory can be overcome by simply formulating the theory via the algebraic framework [14]. Instead of starting from the postulate that the states of the theory comprise a Hilbert space and that the (smeared) quantum fields are operators on this Hilbert space, one starts with the assumption that the (smeared) quantum fields (together with the identity element 1) generate a *-algebra, A. States are then simply expectation functionals . ω : A → C on the algebra, i.e., linear functionals that are positive in the sense that A∗ Aω ≥ 0 for all A ∈ A. The GNS construction then assures us that given a state, ω, one can find a Hilbert space H that carries a representation, π , of the *-algebra A, such that there exists a vector | ∈ H for which Aω = |π(A)| for all A ∈ A. All of the operators, π(A), are automatically defined on a common dense invariant domain, D ⊂ H, and each vector | ∈ D defines a state via A = |π(A)|. Thus, by simply adopting the algebraic viewpoint, we effectively incorporate into quantum field theory in curved spacetime the portions of the content of properties (1) and (4) above that do not refer to Poincaré symmetry. It is often said that in special relativity one has invariance under “special coordinate transformations” (i.e., Poincaré transformations), whereas in general relativity, one has invariance under “general coordinate transformations” (i.e., all diffeomorphisms). Thus, one might be tempted to think that the Minkowski spacetime requirements of invariance/covariance under Poincaré transformations could be generalized to curved spacetime by requiring a similar “invariance/covariance under arbitrary diffeomorphisms”. However, such thoughts are based upon a misunderstanding of the true meaning of “special covariance” and “general covariance”. By explicitly incorporating the flat spacetime metric, ηab , into the formulation of special relativity, it can easily be seen that special relativity can be formulated in as “generally covariant” a manner as general relativity. However, the act of formulating special relativity in a generally covariant manner does not provide one with any additional symmetries or other useful conditions on physical theories in flat spacetime. The point is that in special relativity, Poincaré transformations are symmetries of the spacetime structure, and we impose a nontrivial requirement on a physical theory when we demand that its formulation respect these symmetries. However, a generic curved spacetime will not possess any symmetries at all, so no corresponding conditions on a physical theory can be imposed. The demand that a theory be “generally covariant” (i.e., that its formulation is invariant under arbitrary diffeomorphisms) can always be achieved by explicitly incorporating any “background structure” into the formulation of the theory. If one considers a fixed, curved spacetime without symmetries, no useful conditions can be imposed upon a quantum field theory by attempting to require some sort of “invariance” of the theory under diffeomorphisms. However, there is a meaningful notion of “general covariance” that can be very usefully and powerfully applied to quantum field theory in curved spacetime. The
88
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
basic idea behind this notion is that the only “background structure” that should occur in the theory is the spacetime manifold and metric modulo diffeomorphisms, together with the time and space orientations and (if spinors are present in the theory) spin structure. The quantum fields should be “covariant” in that their construction should only make use of this background structure. Indeed, since the smeared quantum fields are associated with local regions of spacetime (namely, the support of the test function used for the smearing), it seems natural to demand that the quantum fields be locally constructed from the background structure in the sense that the quantum fields in any neighborhood O be covariantly constructed from the background structure within O. This idea may be formulated in a precise manner as follows [7,19,20]. First, in order to assure a well defined dynamics and in order to avoid causal pathologies, we restrict consideration to globally hyperbolic spacetimes (M, gab ). (We consider theories in arbitrary spacetime dimension D ≡ dim M ≥ 2.) If spinors are present in the theory, we also demand that M admit a spin structure. It is essential that the quantum field theory be defined on all D-dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetimes admitting a spin structure, since in essence, we can only tell whether the quantum field is “locally and covariantly constructed out of the metric” if we can see how the theory changes when we change the metric in an arbitrary way. The “background structure”, M, of the theory is taken to consist of the manifold M, the metric gab , the spacetime orientation— which may be represented by a nowhere vanishing D-form, ea1 ...a D on M—and a time orientation—which may be represented e.g. by the equivalence class of a time function T : M → R—i.e., we have M = (M, g, T, e).
(1)
(If spinors are present in the theory, and M admits more than one spin structure, then the choice of spin-structure over M also should be understood to be included in M.) For each choice of M, we assume that there is specified a *-algebra A(M) that is generated by a countable list of quantum fields φ (i) and their “adjoints” φ (i)∗ . These fields may be of arbitrary tensorial or spinorial type, and they are smeared with arbitrarily chosen smooth, compact support fields of dual tensorial or spinorial type. In order to determine if the quantum field theory and quantum fields φ (i) are “locally and covariantly constructed out of the background structure M”, we consider the following situation: Let (M, g) and (M , g ) be two globally hyberbolic spacetimes that have the property that there exists a one-to-one (but not necessarily onto) map ρ : M → M that preserves all of the background structure. In other words, ρ is an isometric imbedding that is orientation and time orientation preserving (and, if spinors are present, the choices of spin structure on M and M correspond under ρ). We further assume that ρ is causality preserving in the sense that if x1 , x2 ∈ M cannot be connected by a causal curve in M, then ρ(x1 ) and ρ(x2 ) cannot be connected by a causal curve in M . We say that the quantum field theory is locally and covariantly constructed from M (or, for short, that the theory is local and covariant) if (i) for every such M, M , and ρ we have a corresponding *-isomorphism χρ between A(M) and the subalgebra of A(M ) generated by the quantum fields φ (i) and φ (i)∗ smeared with test fields with support in ρ[M] and (ii) if ρ is a similar background structure and causality preserving map taking M to M , then χρ ◦ρ = χρ ◦ χρ . We further say that the quantum field φ (i) is locally and covariantly constructed from M (or, for short, that φ (i) is local and covariant) if for every such M, M , and ρ, we have χρ φ (i) ( f ) = φ (i) (ρ∗ ( f )),
(2)
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
89
where ρ∗ ( f ) denotes the natural push-forward action of ρ on the tensor/spinor field f on M. Note that in contrast to the notion of Poincaré covariance—which applies to quantum field theory on a single spacetime (namely, Minkowski spacetime)—the notion that a quantum field theory or quantum field is local and covariant is a condition that applies to the formulation of quantum field theory on different spacetimes. Nevertheless, the close relationship between these notions can be seen as follows: Suppose that we have a local and covariant quantum field theory, with local and covariant quantum fields φ (i) . Let M and M both be the background structure of Minkowski spacetime, and let ρ be a proper Poincaré transformation. Then ρ preserves all of the background structure, so for each proper Poincaré transformation, we obtain a *-isomorphism χρ : A → A, where A here denotes the quantum field algebra for Minkowski spacetime. Furthermore, if ρ and ρ are proper Poincaré transformations, we have χρ◦ρ = χρ ◦ χρ . Thus, every local and covariant quantum field theory in curved spacetime gives rise to a Poincaré invariant theory in this sense when restricted to Minkowski spacetime. Furthermore, if φ (i) is a local and covariant quantum field, then in Minkowski spacetime it transforms covariantly via Eq. (2) under proper Poincaré transformations. Note also that, more generally, in any curved spacetime with symmetries, a local and covariant quantum field theory will be similarly invariant under these symmetries, and a local and covariant quantum field will transform covariantly under these symmetries. But even for spacetimes without any symmetries, the requirement that the quantum field theory and quantum fields be local and covariant imposes a very powerful restriction akin to requiring Poincaré invariance/covariance in Minkowski spacetime. From these considerations, it can be seen that if we adopt the above algebraic framework for quantum field theory in curved spacetime and if we additionally demand that the quantum field theory and the quantum fields φ (i) be local and covariant, then we obtain satisfactory generalizations to curved spacetime of properties (1), (4), and (5) of the Wightman axioms in Minkowski spacetime. Since we already noted that (6) has a trivial generalization to curved spacetime, only properties (2) and (3) remain to be generalized to curved spacetime. We have already noted above that there is no analog of property (2) in curved spacetime that can be formulated in terms of the “total energy-momentum” of the quantum field. However, it is possible to reformulate the spectrum condition in Minkowski spacetime in terms of purely local properties of the quantum fields. Specifically, the “positive frequency” (and, thereby, positive energy) properties of states are characterized by the short-distance singularity structure of the n-point functions of the quantum fields, as described by their wavefront set. One thereby obtains a microlocal spectrum condition [5,6,24] that is formulated purely in terms of the local in spacetime properties of the quantum fields. This microlocal spectrum condition has a natural generalization to curved spacetime (see Sect. 2 below), thus providing the desired generalization of property (2) to curved spacetime. Consequently, only property (3) remains to be generalized. In Minkowski spacetime, the existence of a unique, Poincaré invariant state has very powerful consequences, so it is clear that a key portion of the content of quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime would be missing if we failed to impose an analogous condition in curved spacetime. However, as already mentioned above, one of the clear lessons of the study of free quantum fields in curved spacetime is that, in a general curved spacetime, there does not exist a unique, “preferred” vacuum or other state. Furthermore, even if a prescription for finding a unique “preferred state” on each spacetime could be found, since
90
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
generic curved spacetimes do not have any symmetries and states on different spacetimes cannot be meaningfully compared, there would appear to be no sensible “invariance” properties that such a preferred state could have. We do not believe that property (3) can be generalized to curved spacetime by a condition that postulates the existence of a preferred state with special properties. In addition, we question the fundamental status of demanding the existence of a state that is invariant under the symmetries of the spacetime. For example, it is well known that the free massless Klein-Gordon field in two-dimensional Minkowski spacetime does not admit a Poincaré invariant state. However, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the quantum field algebra of this field; the quantum field theory is “Poincaré covariant” and the quantum field transforms in a “Poincaré covariant manner” in the sense described above. Furthermore, there is no shortage of physically acceptable (“Hadamard”) states. Thus, the only thing unusual about this quantum field theory is that it happens not to admit a Poincaré invariant state. We do not feel that this is an appropriate reason to exclude the free massless Klein-Gordon field in two-dimensional Minkowski from being considered to be a legitimate quantum field theory. Similar remarks apply to the free Klein-Gordon field of negative m 2 in Minkowski spacetime of all dimensions. The classical and quantum dynamics of this field are entirely well posed and causal, although they are unstable in the sense of admitting solutions/states where the field grows exponentially with time. This instability provides legitimate grounds for arguing that the free Klein-Gordon field of negative m 2 does not occur in nature, but we do not feel that the absence of a Poincaré covariant state constitutes legitimate grounds for rejecting this theory as a quantum field theory; see Sect. 6 below for further discussion. For the above reasons, we seek a replacement of property (3) that does not require the existence of states of a special type. The main purpose of this paper is to propose that the appropriate replacement of property (3) for quantum field theory in curved spacetime is to postulate the existence of a suitable operator product expansion [26,29,31] of the quantum fields. The type of operator product expansion that we shall postulate is known to hold in free field theory and to hold order by order in perturbation theory on any Lorentzian curved spacetime [15]. We thus propose to elevate this operator product expansion to the status of a fundamental property of quantum fields1 . Although the assumption of the existence of an operator product expansion in quantum field theory in curved spacetime is remarkably different in nature from the assumption of the existence of a Poincaré covariant state in quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime, we will show in Sects. 4 and 5 below that it can do “much of the same work” as the latter assumption. It is shown in [21] how to exploit consistency conditions on the OPE in a framework closely related to that presented here. In particular, it is shown how perturbations of a quantum field theory can be characterized and calculated via consistency conditions arising from the OPE. We have an additional motivation for proposing to elevate the operator product expansion to the status of a fundamental property of quantum fields. For free quantum fields in curved spacetime, an entirely satisfactory *-algebra, A0 , of observables has been constructed [5,6,19], which includes all Wick powers and time-ordered products. However, the elements of A0 correspond to unbounded operators, and there does not seem to be any 1 Various axiomatic approaches to conformal field theories based on the operator product expansion have been proposed previously, see e.g. the one based upon the notion of “vertex operator algebras” given in [2, 11,23]. However, in contrast to our approach, these approaches incorporate in an essential way the conformal symmetry of the underlying space. In some approaches to quantum field theory on Minkowski space, the OPE is not postulated, but instead derived [3,4,10].
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
91
natural algebra of bounded elements (with, e.g., a C ∗ -structure) corresponding to A0 . Furthermore, A0 does not appear to have any natural topology (apart from a topology that can be defined a posteriori by using the allowed states as semi-norms). Fortunately, a topology is not actually needed to define A0 because the relations that hold in A0 can be expressed in terms of finite sums of finite products of fields. However, it is inconceivable that the relations that define an interacting field algebra will all be expressible in terms of finite sums of finite products of the fields. Thus, without a natural topology and without finitely expressible relations, it is far from clear as to how an interacting field algebra might be defined. We claim that an operator-product expansion effectively provides the needed “relations” between the quantum fields, and we will propose in this paper that these relations are sufficient to define a quantum field theory. In other words, we believe that an interacting quantum field theory is, in essence, defined via its operator-product expansion. From this perspective, it seems natural to view the operator product-expansion as a fundamental aspect of the quantum field theory. In the next section, we will describe our framework for quantum field theory in curved spacetime. In particular, we will provide a precise statement of what we mean by an operator-product expansion and the properties that we will assume that it possesses. In Sect. 3, we will state our axioms for quantum field theory in curved spacetime and explain how it is constructed from the operator-product expansion. Finally, in Sects. 4 and 5 we will show that our axioms have much of the same power as the Wightman axioms by establishing “normal” (anti-)commutation relations and proving curved spacetime versions of the spin-statistics theorem and PCT theorem. Some further implications of our new perspective on quantum field theory are discussed in Sect. 6. 2. General Framework for the Formulation of QFT We will now explain in much more detail our proposed framework for defining quantum field theory. We fix a dimension D ≥ 2 of the spacetime and consider all D-dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetimes (M, gab ). As explained in the previous section, we will assume that each spacetime is equipped with an orientation, specified by a nowhere vanishing D-form ea1 ...a D on M, and a time orientation, specified by (the equivalence class of) a globally defined time function T : M → R. The set of background data specified this way will be denoted M = (M, g, T, e).
(3)
In certain cases, more background structure may be prescribed, such as a choice of bundles in which the quantum fields live. For example, if spinors are present and if M admits more than one spin structure, then a choice of spin-structure over M is assumed to be given as part of the background structure2 , and is understood to also be part of M. It should be emphasized that two spacetimes with the same manifold and metric, 2 It is convenient to think of the background structure as a category [7], whose objects are the tuples M. Morphisms in the category of tuples M are isometric, causality, orientation, and other background structure preserving embeddings,
ρ : M → M .
(4)
Thus, ρ is a diffeomorphism M → M such that g = ρ ∗ g , such that ρ ∗ T represents the same timeorientation as T , such that ρ ∗ e represents the same orientation as e, and such that the causal relations in (M, g) inherited from (M , g ) coincide with the original ones. Furthermore, if M also includes the choice of a spin structure, then ρ must also preserve the spin structures.
92
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
but, e.g., with different time-orientations define distinct background structures. Below, we will consider quantum field theories associated with background structures, and we stress that, at this stage, the quantum field theories associated with different background structures (e.g., ones that merely differ in the choice of, say, time-orientation) need not have any relation whatsoever. The quantum fields present in a given theory will be assumed to correspond to sections of vector bundles over M. We will denote the various quantum fields by φ (i) , with i ∈ I , where I is a suitable indexing set, and we will write V (i) for the vector bundle over M, of which φ (i) corresponds to a section. It should be emphasized that i ∈ I labels all of the quantum fields present in the theory, not just the “fundamental” ones. Thus, even if we were considering the theory of a single scalar field ϕ, there will be infinitely many composite fields of various tensorial types corresponding to all monomials in ϕ and its derivatives, each of which would be labeled by a different index i. It will be convenient to also include a field denoted φ (1) in the list of quantum fields, which will play the role of the identity element, 1, in the quantum field algebra. We assume that each field φ (i) has been assigned a Bose/Fermi parity F(i) = 0, 1 modulo two. We further assume that there is an operation : I → I i → i ,
(5)
having the property that V (i ) = V (i), where for any vector space E, the vector space E consists of all anti-linear maps E v → C, with E v denoting the dual space of E. In particular, if i is associated with, say the vector bundle V (i) of spinors with P primed and U unprimed indices, then V (i ) is the bundle of spinors with U primed and P unprimed spinor indices. We demand that the star operation squares to the identity3 , i = i. We ∗ also require that φ (1 ) = φ (1) , i.e. that 1∗ = 1. As in many other approaches to quantum field theory, we will use the smeared fields φ (i) ( f )—with i ∈ I , and f a compactly supported test section in the dual vector bundle V (i)v to V (i)—to generate a *-algebra of observables, A(M). However, in most other algebraic approaches to quantum field theory, A(M) is assumed, a priori, to possess a particular topological and/or other structure (e.g., C*-algebra structure) and the algebraic relations within A(M)—together, perhaps, with specified actions of symmetry groups on A(M)—are assumed to encode all of the information about the quantum field theory under consideration. In particular, since the state space, S(M), is normally taken to consist of all positive linear maps on A(M), it is clear that S(M) cannot contain any information about the quantum field theory that is not already contained in A(M). We shall not proceed in this manner because it is far from clear to us what topological and other structure A(M) should be assumed to possess a priori in order to describe the quantum field theory. Instead, we shall view the theory as being specified by providing both an algebra of observables, A(M), and a space of allowed states, S(M). Essentially the only information about the theory contained in the algebra of obervables, A(M), will be the list of fields appearing in the theory and the relations that can be written as polynomial expressions in the fields and their derivatives. In our approach, the information normally encoded in the topology of A(M) will now be encoded in S(M). Of course, the semi-norms provided by S(M) could be used, a posteriori, to define a topology on A(M), but it is not clear that this topology would encode all of the information in S(M); in any case, we find it simpler and more natural to consider the quantum field theory to be defined by the pair {A(M), S(M)}. 3 This operation gives I the structure of an involutive category.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
93
The key idea of this paper is that we will obtain the pair {A(M), S(M)} in a natural (i.e., functorial) manner from the space of field labels I and another datum, namely, the collection of “operator product expansion (OPE) coefficients”. The OPE coefficients are a family (i )···(i ) C(M) ≡ C( j)1 n (x1 , . . . , xn ; y) : i 1 , . . . , i n , j ∈ I, n ∈ N , (6) (i )···(i n )
where each C( j)1
is a distribution on M n+1 , valued in the vector bundle π
E = V (i 1 ) × · · · × V (i n ) × V ( j)v −→ M n+1
(7)
that is defined in some open neighborhood of the diagonal in M n+1 . Thus, given C(M), we will construct both the algebra A(M) and the state space S(M) S(M) | C(M) dual pairing
| A(M)
Thus, in our framework, a quantum field theory is uniquely specified by providing a list of quantum fields I and a corresponding list of OPE coefficients C(M). The OPE coefficients will be required to satisfy certain general properties, which, in effect, become the “axioms” of quantum field theory in curved spacetime. Most of the remainder of this section will be devoted to formulating these axioms. However, before providing the axioms for C(M), we briefly outline how the algebra A(M) and the state space S(M) are constructed from C(M) for any background structure M = (M, g, T, e). The algebra A(M) is constructed by starting with the free algebra Free(M) generated by all expressions of the form φ (i) ( f ) with i ∈ I , and f a compactly supported test section in the dual vector bundle to V (i) . We define an antilinear *-operation on Free(M) by requiring that its action on the generators be given by [φ (i) ( f )]∗ = φ (i ) ( f¯),
(8)
where f¯ ∈ Sect 0 [V¯ (i)] is the conjugate test section to f ∈ Sect 0 (V (i)). The *-algebra A(M) is taken to be the resulting free *-algebra factored by a 2-sided ideal generated by a set of polynomial relations in the fields and their derivatives. These relations consist of certain “universal” relations that do not depend on the particular theory under consideration (such as linearity of φ (i) ( f ) in f and (anti-)commutation relations) together with certain relations that may arise from the OPE coefficients C(M). A precise enumeration of the relations that define A(M) will be given at the beginning of Sect. 3. The state space S(M) is a subspace of the space of all linear, functionals ω : A(M) → C that are positive in the sense that ω(A∗ A) ≡ A∗ Aω ≥ 0 for all A ∈ A(M). This subspace is specified as follows: First, we require that for any state ω ∈ S(M), the OPE coefficients in the collection C(M) in Eq. (6) appear in the expansion of the expectation value of the product of fields φ (i1 ) (x1 ) · · · φ (in ) (xn )ω in terms of the fields φ ( j) (y)ω , (i )...(i ) C( j)1 n (x1 , . . . , xn ; y) φ ( j) (y) . (9) φ (i1 ) (x1 ) · · · φ (in ) (xn ) ≈ ω
j
ω
94
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
Here “≈” means that this equation holds in a suitably strong sense as an asymptotic relation in the limit that x1 , . . . , xn → y. A precise definition of what is meant by this asymptotic relation will be given in Eq. (39) below. Secondly, we require that ω satisfy a microlocal spectrum condition that, in essence, states that the singularities of φ (i1 ) (x1 ) . . . φ (in ) (xn )ω are of “positive frequency type” in the cotangent space T(x∗ 1 ,...,xn ) M n . The precise form of this condition will be formulated in terms of the wave front set [22] (see Eqs. (23) and (24) below). We turn now to the formulation of the conditions that we shall impose on the OPE coefficients C(M). As indicated above, in our framework, these conditions play the role of axioms for quantum field theory. Each operator product coefficient C((ij)1 )···(in ) in C(M) is a distribution4 on M n+1 , valued in the vector bundle V (i 1 ) × · · · × V (i n ) × V ( j)v that is defined in some open neighborhood of the diagonal in M n+1 . We will impose the following requirements on these coefficients: C1) C2) C3) C4) C5) C6) C7) C8) C9)
Locality and Covariance, Identity element, Compatibility with the -operation, Commutativity/Anti-Commutativity, Scaling Degree, Asymptotic positivity, Spectrum condition, Associativity, Analytic dependence upon the metric.
Before formulating these conditions in detail, for each i ∈ I we define the dimension, dim(i) ∈ R, of the field φ (i) by5 1 (i)(i ) , (10) sup dim(i) := sd C(1) 2 backgrounds M where “sd” denotes the scaling degree of a distribution (see Appendix A) and it is understood that the scaling degree is taken about a point on the diagonal. In other words, dim(i) measures the rate at which the coefficient of the identity 1 in the operator product expansion of φ (i) (x1 )φ (i ) (x2 ) blows up as x1 → x2 . It will follow immediately from Condition (C3) below that dim(i ) = dim(i). Note also that dim(1) = 0. For distributions u 1 and u 2 on M n+1 , we introduce the equivalence relation u1 ∼ u2
(11)
to mean that the scaling degree of the distribution u = u 1 − u 2 about any point on the total diagonal is −∞. However, it should be noted that in the formulation of Condition 4 More precisely, each OPE coefficient is an equivalence class of distributions, where two distributions are considered equivalent if their difference satisfies Eq. (29) below for all δ > 0 and all T. Indeed, the OPE coefficients are more properly thought of as a sequence of (equivalence classes of) distributions, such that the difference between the n th and m th terms in the sequence satisfies Eq. (29) for δ = min(m, n). However, to avoid such an extremely cumbersome formulation of our axioms and results, we will treat each OPE coefficient as a distribution. 5 Note that, when V (i) is not equal to M × C, i.e., when φ (i) is not a scalar field, then quantities like (i)(i )
are, by definition, distributions taking values in a vector bundle. What we mean by the scaling degree C(1) here and in similar equations in the following such as Eq. (20) is the maximum of the scaling degrees of all “components” of such a bundle-valued distribution.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
95
(C8) below and in the precise definition of the operator product expansion, Eq. (39), we will need to consider limits where different points approach the total diagonal at different rates. We will then introduce a stronger notion of equivalence that, in effect, requires a scaling degree of −∞ under these possibly different rates of approach. It is this stronger notion that was meant in Eq. (9) above. (C1) Covariance. Let ρ : M → M be a causality preserving isometric embedding preserving the orientations, spin-structures, and all other background structure, i.e. ρ is a morphism in the category of background structures. We postulate that for each member of the above collection (6), we have (i )...(i n )
(ρ ∗ × · · · ρ ∗ × ρ∗−1 ) C( j)1
(i )...(i n )
[M ] ∼ C( j)1
[M].
(12)
(C2) Identity element. We require that (i )...(1)...(i n )
C( j)1
(i )...(i k )(i k+1 )...(i n )
(x1 , . . . , xn ; y) = C( j)1
(x1 , . . . xk−1 , xk+1 , . . . xn ; y), (13)
where the identity 1 is in the k th place. When n = 1, the condition involves the OPE coefficient C (i)(1) ( j)(x1 , x2 ; y) = C (i) ( j)(x1 ; y). This coefficient should be thought of as describing the operator product expansion around the reference point y of product of the field labelled by i and localized at the point x1 with the identity operator. These coefficients should hence merely implement a Taylor expansion around y, and to express this idea, we impose the following further conditions on those coefficients. As in a Taylor series, we demand that these coefficients depend only polynomially on the Riemannian normal coordinates of x1 relative to y (and are thus in particular smooth), and that (i)
(i)
C( j) (x; x) = δ( j) id(i) (x),
(14)
where id(i) (x) is the identity map in the fiber over x of the vector bundle V (i). Since a Taylor expansion of an operator at x1 around another point y involves the derivatives of the operators considered at y, and because derivatives tend to increase the dimension, (i) we further demand that C( j) = 0 if dim( j) < dim(i). Finally, if we Taylor expand a quantity at x1 successively around a second point x2 , and then a third point x3 , this should be equivalent to expanding it in one stroke around the third point. Thus, we require that we have (i) (i) (k) C(k) (x1 ; x2 )C( j) (x2 ; x3 ), (15) C( j) (x1 ; x3 ) = (k)
where we note that the sum is only over the (finitely many) field labels k such that dim(k) ≤ dim( j). (C3) Compatibility with . This relation encodes the fact that the underlying theory will have an operation analogous to the hermitian adjoint of a linear operator. The requirement is (i )...(i 1 )
C((ij)1 )...(in ) (x1 , . . . , xn , y) ∼ C( jn ) where π is the permutation
◦ π(x1 , . . . , xn , y),
1 2 ... n n + 1 . π= n n − 1 ... 1 n + 1
(16)
(17)
96
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
(C4) Commutativity/Anti-Commutativity. Let σ be the permutation 1 ... k k + 1 ... n + 1 σ = , 1 ... k + 1 k ... n + 1
(18)
and let F(i) be the Bose/Fermi parity of φ (i) . Then we have C((σj)i1 )...(σ in ) ◦ σ (x1 , . . . , xn , y) = −(−1) F(ik )F(ik+1 ) C((ij)1 )...(in ) (x1 , . . . , xn , y) (19) whenever xk and xk+1 are spacelike separated (and in the neighborhood of the diagonal in M n+1 , where the OPE coefficients are actually defined). (C5) Scaling Degree. We require that (i 1 )...(i n ) sd C(k) ≤ dim(i 1 ) + · · · + dim(i n ) − dim(k).
(20)
(C6) Asymptotic Positivity. Let i ∈ I be any given index. Then, for D ≥ 3 we postulate that dim(i) ≥ 0, and that dim(i) = 0 if and only if i = 1. Note that, because we are taking the supremum over all spacetimes in Eq. (10), our requirement that dim(i) > 0 (i)(i ) for i = 1 does not imply that the scaling degree of C(1) for i = 1 is positive for all spacetimes, since the coefficient may e.g. “accidentally” happen to have a lower scaling degree for certain spacetimes of high symmetry, as happens for certain supersymmetric theories on Minkowski spacetime. (i)(i ) On a spacetime M where the scaling degree of C(1) is dim(i), we know that if we scale the arguments of this distribution together by a factor of λ, and multiply by a power of λ less than 2dim(i), then the resulting family of distributions cannot be bounded as λ → 0. For our applications below, it is convenient to have a slightly stronger property, which we now explain. Let X a be a vector field on M locally defined near y such that ∇a X b = −δab at y. Let t be the flow of this field, which scales points by a factor of e−t relative to y along the flow lines of X a . If f is a compactly supported test section in V (i), we set f λ = λ−D ∗log λ f . This family of test sections becomes more and more sharply peaked at y as λ → 0. We postulate that, for any δ > 0 and any X a as above, there exists an f such that
2dim(i)−δ
(i)(i )
¯ (21) lim λ C(1) (x1 , x2 , y) f λ (x1 ) f λ (x2 ) dµ1 dµ2
= ∞, λ→0
M×M
uniformly in y in some neighborhood. This statement is slightly stronger than the statement that the scaling degree of our distribution is dim(i) on M, since the latter would only imply that the rescaled distributions under the limit sign in Eq. (21) contain a subsequence that is unbounded in λ for some test section F(x1 , x2 ) in V (i) × V (i ), not necessarily of the form f (x1 ) f¯(x2 ). The reason for the terminology “asymptotic positivity axiom” arises from Lemma 2 below. An alternative essentially equivalent formulation of this condition, which is related to “quantum inequalities”, is given in Appendix B. In D = 2 spacetime dimensions, the above form of the asymptotic positivity condition is in general too restrictive. The reason is that in D = 2, there are usually many fields φ (i) of dimension dim(i) = 0 different from the identity operator. For example,
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
97
for a free Klein-Gordon field, the basic field ϕ and all its Wick-powers have vanishing dimension—in fact, their OPE-coefficients have a logarithmic scaling behavior. A possible way to deal with this example would be to consider only composite fields containing derivatives, as this subspace of fields is closed under the OPE. For this subspace of fields, the asymptotic positivity condition would then hold as stated. Another possibility is to introduce a suitably refined measure of the degree of divergence of the OPE coefficients also taking into account logarithms. Such a concept would clearly be sensible for free or conformal field theories in D = 2, and it would also be adequate in perturbation theory (to arbitrary but finite orders). A suitable refinement of the above asymptotic positivity condition could then be defined, and all proofs given in the remainder of this paper would presumably still hold true, with minor modifications. For simplicity, however, we will not discuss this issue further in this paper, and we will stick with the asymptotic positivity condition in the above form. (C7) Spectrum condition. The spectrum condition roughly says that the singularities of a field product ought to be of “positive frequency type,” and is completely analogous the condition imposed on states that we will impose below: We demand that, near the diagonal, the wave front set (see Appendix A) of the OPE coefficient satisfies (i )...(i n )
WF(C( j)1
) ⊂ n (M) × Z ∗ M,
(22)
where the last factor Z ∗ M is the zero section of T ∗ M and corresponds to the reference point y in the OPE, and where the set n (M) ⊂ T ∗ M n \{0} is defined as follows. Consider embedded graphs G( x , y, p) ∈ Gm,n in the spacetime manifold M which have the following properties. Each graph G has n so-called “external vertices”, x1 , . . . , xn ∈ M, and m so-called “internal” or “interaction vertices” y1 , . . . , ym ∈ M. These vertices are of arbitrary valence, and are joined by edges, e, which are null-geodesic curves γe : (0, 1) → M. It is assumed that an ordering of the vertices is defined, and that the ordering among the external vertices is x1 < · · · < xn , while the ordering of the remaining interaction vertices is unconstrained. If e is an edge joining two vertices, then s(e) (the source) and t (e) (the target) are the two vertices γe (0) and γe (1), where the curve is oriented in such a way that it starts at the smaller vertex relative to the fixed vertex ordering. Each edge carries a future directed, tangent parallel covector field, pe , meaning that ∇γ˙e pe = 0, and pe ∈ ∂ V + . With this notation set up, we define x , y, p) ∈ Gm,n n,m (M, g) = (x1 , k1 ; . . . ; xn , kn ) ∈ T ∗ M n \{0}|∃ decorated graph G( such that yi ∈ J + ({x1 , . . . , xn }) ∩ J − ({x1 , . . . , xn }) for all 1 ≤ i ≤ m, pe − pe for all xi and such that ki = e:t (e)=xi
e:s(e)=xi
such that 0 =
e:s(e)=yi
pe −
pe for all yi ,
(23)
e:t (e)=yi
where J ± (U ) is the causal future resp. past of a set U ⊂ M, defined as the set of points that can be reached from U via a future resp. past directed causal curve. We set m,n . (24) n = m≥0
98
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
S0
S1
S3
S2
S4
S6
S5
Fig. 1. T = {S0 , S1 , . . . , S6 }, S0 = {1, 2, 3, 4}, S1 = {1, 2}, S2 = {3, 4}, S3 = {1}, S4 = {2}, S5 = {3}, S6 = {4}
Note in particular that the microlocal spectrum condition implies that the dependence of our OPE coefficients (6) on the reference point y is smooth. When the spacetime is real analytic, we require a similar condition for the “analytic” wave front set [22] WF A of the OPE coefficient. Our formulation of the microlocal spectrum condition is a weaker condition than that previously proposed in [5], based on earlier work of [24]. The microlocal spectrum condition of [5] is satisfied by the correlation functions of suitable Hadamard states in linear field theory, but need not hold even perturbatively for interacting fields. In essence, our formulation allows for the presence of interaction vertices, thus weakening the condition relative to the free field case. Our condition can be shown to hold for perturbative interacting fields [15]. (C8) Associativity. Following [15], a notion of associativity is formulated by considering configurations (x1 , . . . , xn ) of points in M n (where n > 2) approaching a point y ∈ M at different rates. For example, if we have 3 points (x1 , x2 , x3 ), we may consider all points coming close to each other at the same rate, i.e., assume that their mutual distances are of order ε, where ε → 0. Alternatively, we may consider a situation in which, say, x1 , x2 approach each other very fast, say, at rate ε2 , while x3 approaches x1 , x2 at a slower rate, say at rate ε. The first situation corresponds, intuitively, to the process of performing the OPE of a triple product of operators “at once”, while the second situation corresponds to first performing an OPE in the factors corresponding to x1 , x2 , and then successively performing a second OPE between the resulting fields and the third field situated at x3 . Obviously, for an arbitrary number n of points, there are many different possibilities in which configurations can come close. We classify the different possibilities in terms of “merger trees,” T. Each merger tree will give rise to a separate associativity condition. For this, one constructs curves in M n parametrized by ε, which are in M0n (the space M n minus all its diagonals) for ε > 0, and which tend to a point on the diagonal as ε → 0. These curves are labeled by trees T that characterize the subsequent mergers of the points in the configuration as ε → 0. A convenient way to formally describe a tree T (or more generally, the disjoint union of trees, a “forest”) is by a nested set T = {S1 , . . . , Sk } of subsets Si ⊂ {1, . . . , n}. “Nested” means that two sets are either disjoint, or one is a proper subset of the other. We agree that the sets {1}, . . . , {n} are always contained in the tree (or forest). Each set Si in T represents a node of a tree, i.e.,
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
root
y
99
S0
εv1
εv2
S1 ε2 v3
x1 ε
S2 ε2 v4 ε2 v6
x2 ε
ε2 v5
x4 ε
x3 ε
Fig. 2. T = {S0 , S1 , . . . , S6 }, x1 (ε) = εv1 + ε 2 v3 , x2 (ε) = εv1 + ε 2 v4 , x3 (ε) = εv2 + ε 2 v5 , x4 (ε) = εv2 + ε 2 v6
the set of vertices Vert(T) is given by the sets in T, and Si ⊂ S j means that the node corresponding to Si can be reached by moving downward from the node represented by S j . The root(s) of the tree(s) correspond to the maximal elements, i.e., the sets that are not subsets of any other set. If the set {1, . . . , n} ∈ T, then there is in fact only one tree, while if there are several maximal elements, then there are several trees in the forest, each maximal element corresponding to the root of the respective tree. The leaves correspond to the sets {1}, . . . , {n}, i.e., the minimal elements. For example for a configuration of n = 4 points, a tree might look like in the following figure, and the corresponding nested set of subsets is also given. In the following, we will consider only T with a single root. The desired curves x(ε) tending to the diagonal are associated with T and are constructed as follows. First, we construct Riemannian normal coordinates around the reference point y, so that each point in a convex normal neighborhood of y may be identified with a tangent vector v ∈ Ty M. We then choose a tetrad and further identify Ty M ∼ = R D , so that v is in fact D viewed as an element in R . With each set S ∈ T, we now associate a vector v S ∈ R D , which we collect in a tuple v = (v S1 , . . . , v Sr ) ∈ (R D )|T| , T = {S1 , . . . , Sr },
(25)
and we agree that v{1,...,n} = 0, and where |T| is the number of nodes of the tree, i.e. the number of elements of the set T. For ε > 0, we define a mapping ψT (ε) : (R D )|T| → (R D )|T| , (v S1 , . . . , v Sr ) → (x S1 (ε), . . . , x Sr (ε))
(26)
by the formula x S (ε) =
εdepth(S ) v S ,
(27)
S :S S
where depth(S ) is defined as the number of nodes that connect S with the root of the tree T. For ε sufficiently small, and v in a ball B1 (0)|T| , the vectors x S (ε) ∈ R D may be identified with points in M via the exponential map. If the vectors v S satisfy the condition that, v S = v S for any S , S that are connected to a common S by an edge, then the vector (x{1} (ε), . . . , x{n} (ε)) ∈ M n does not lie on any of the diagonals, i.e., any pair of entries are distinct from each other. Its value as ε → 0 approaches the diagonal of M n . The i th point in the configuration x{i} (ε) is obtained starting from y
100
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
by following the branches of the tree towards the i th leaf, moving along the first edge by an amount ε in the direction of the corresponding v S , then the second by an amount ε2 in the direction of the corresponding v S , and so forth, until the i th leaf is reached. The curve (x{1} (ε), . . . , x{n} (ε)) ∈ M n thus represents a configuration of points which merge hierarchically according to the structure of the tree T, as ε → 0. That is, the outermost branches of the tree merge at the highest order in ε, i.e., at rate εdepth of branch , then the next level at a lower order, and so forth, while the branches closest to the root merge at the slowest rate, ε. The following figure illustrates our definition. Thus, the points are scaled towards the diagonal of M n , even though possibly at different speeds, and the limiting element as ε → 0 is the element (y, . . . , y) on the diagonal6 . Using the maps ψT (ε) we can define an asymptotic equivalence relation ∼T,δ for distributions u defined on M |T| . For points within a convex normal neighborhood, and sufficiently small ε > 0, we can define the pull-back u ◦ ψT (ε). This may be viewed as a distribution in the variables v S ∈ R D , S ∈ T. We now define u ∼T,δ 0
:⇐⇒
lim ε−δ u ◦ ψT (ε) = 0 for δ > 0,
ε→0+
(29)
in the sense of distributions defined on a neighborhood of the origin in (R D )|T| . We write u ≈ 0 if u ∼T,δ 0 for all T and all δ. The condition that u ≈ 0 is stronger than the previously defined condition u ∼ 0 [see Eq. (11)], which corresponds to the requirement that u ∼T,δ 0 for all δ only for the trivial tree T = {{1}, . . . {n}, {1, . . . , n}}. We can now state the requirement of associativity. Recall that if T is a tree with n leaves, then ψT (ε) gives a curve in the configuration space of n points in M which represents the process of a subsequent hierarchical merger of the points according to the structure of the tree. If a subset of points in (x{1} (ε), . . . , x{n} (ε)) merges first, then one intuitively expects that one should be able to perform the OPE in those points first, and then subsequently perform OPE’s of the other points in the hierarchical order represented by the tree. We will impose this as the associativity requirement. For example, if we have 4 points, and the tree corresponds to the nested set of subsets T = {{1, 2}, {3, 4}, {1, 2, 3, 4}} as in the above figure, the pairs of points x{1} (ε), x{2} (ε) respectively x{3} (ε), x{4} (ε) approach each other at order ε2 , while the two groups then approach each other at a slower rate ε. We postulate that7 (i )(i )(i 3 )(i 4 )
C(i51) 2 i 6 ,i 7
(x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ; y) ∼T,δ
(i )(i 2 )
C(i61)
(i )(i 4 )
(x1 , x2 ; x6 ) C(i73)
(i )(i 7 )
(x3 , x4 ; x7 ) C(i56)
(x6 , x7 ; y),
(30)
where the sums are finite but carried out to sufficiently large order (depending on δ > 0). For the same product of operators, consider alternatively the tree T = {{1, 2, 3}, 6 However, if the vector (x (ε), . . . , x (ε)) ∈ M n is alternatively viewed as an element of the “Ful{1} {n} ton-MacPherson compactification” Mcn of the configuration space M n , then its limiting value may be viewed alternatively as lying in the boundary ∂ Mcn of the compactification, and the vectors v may be viewed as defining a coordinate system of that boundary, which thereby has the structure of a stratifold ∂ Mcn ∼ M[T], (28) = T
with each face T corresponding to a lower dimensional subspace associated with a given merger tree [1]. 7 Here, the distribution on the left side is viewed as a distribution in x , . . . , x , y with a trivial dependence 1 7 on x5 , x6 , x7 .
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
101
{1, 2, 3, 4}}. The corresponding associativity relation for the OPE coefficient is now (i )(i 2 )(i 3 )(i 4 )
C(i51)
(x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ; y) ∼T ,δ
(i )(i )(i ) (i )(i ) C(i61) 2 3 (x1 , x2 , x3 ; x6 ) C(i56) 4 (x6 , x4 ; y) i6
(31) It is important to note, however, that there is in general no simple relation between the right hand sides of Eqs. (30), (31) for different trees T and T . The corresponding relation for arbitrary numbers of points, and arbitrary types of trees is a straightforward generalization of this case, the only challenge being to introduce an appropriate notation to express the subsequent OPE’s. For this, we consider maps i : T → I which associate with every node S ∈ T of the tree an element i S ∈ I , the index set labelling the fields. If S ∈ T, we let S(1), S(2), . . . S(r ) be the branches of this tree, i.e. the nodes connected to S by a single upward edge. With these notations in place, the generalization of Eqs. (30) and (31) for an arbitrary number n of points, and an arbitrary tree T is as follows. Let T be an arbitrary tree on n elements, and let δ > 0 be an arbitrary real number. Then we have8 C((ij)1 )...(in ) (x1 , . . . , xn ;
y) ∼T,δ
i∈Map(T,I )
(i )...(i S(r ) ) x S(1) , . . . , x S(r ) ; x S C(i SS(1) )
,
S∈T
(32) where the sums are over i with the properties that i {1} = i 1 , . . . , i {n} = i n , i {1,...,n} = j.
(33)
The sum over i is finite, with dim(i S ) ≤ , where is a number depending on the tree T and the real number δ. Furthermore, it is understood that x{1} = x1 , . . . , x{n} = xn , and that x{1,...,n} = y. (C9) Analytic and smooth dependence. Due to requirement (C1), the OPE coefficients may be regarded as functionals of the spacetime metric. We require that the distributions C((ij)1 )...(in ) have an analytic dependence upon the spacetime metric. For this, let g (s) be a 1-parameter family of analytic metrics, depending analytically on s ∈ R. Then the corre(i )...(i ) sponding OPE-coefficients C( j)1 n are distributions in x1 , . . . , xn , y that also depend on the parameter s. We demand that the dependence on s is “analytic”. It is technically (i )...(i ) somewhat involved to define what one precisely means by this, because C( j)1 n itself is not analytic, but instead a distribution in the spacetime points. The appropriate way to make this definition rigorous was provided in [16,20]. Similarly, if the spacetime is only smooth, we require a corresponding smooth variation of the OPE coefficients under smooth variations of the metric. 8 Here, the distribution on the left is regarded as a distribution in x ; S ∈ T, with a trivial dependence on S the x S with S not equal to {1}, . . . , {n}, {1, . . . , n}.
102
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
3. Construction of the QFT from the OPE Coefficients Now that we have stated in detail all the desired properties of the OPE coefficients, we are ready to give the precise definition of quantum field theory. A quantum field theory in curved spacetime associated with a collection of OPE coefficients satisfying the above properties is the pair {A(M), S(M)} consisting of a *-algebra A(M) and a space of states S(M) on A(M) that is canonically defined by the operator product coefficients, C(M), for any choice of the background spacetime structure M. The algebra A(M) is defined as follows. To begin, let Free(M) be the free *-algebra generated by all expressions of the form φ (i) ( f ) with i ∈ I , and f a compactly supported test section in the vector bundle V (i) associated with the tensor or spinor character of φ (i) . The algebra A(M) is obtained by factoring Free(M) by a set of relations, which are as follows. A1) Identity. We have φ (1) ( f ) =
f dµ · 1.
A2) Linearity. For any complex numbers a1 , a2 , any test sections f 1 , f 2 , and any field φ (i) , we have φ (i) (a1 f 1 + a2 f 2 ) = a1 φ (i) ( f 1 ) + a2 φ (i) ( f 2 ). The linearity condition might be viewed as saying that, informally, φ (i) (x) f (x)dµ (34) φ (i) ( f ) = M
is a pointlike field that is averaged against a smooth weighting function. We shall often use the informal pointlike fields as a notational device, with the understanding that all identities are supposed to be valid after formally smearing with a test function. A3) Star operation. For any field φ (i) , and any test section f ∈ Sect 0 (V (i)), let f¯ ∈ Sect 0 (V¯ (i)), be the conjugate test section. Then we require that [φ (i) ( f )]∗ = φ (i ) ( f¯).
(35)
A4) Relations arising from the OPE. Let K ⊂ I be a subset of the index set, and let c(i) , i ∈ K be scalar valued differential operators [i.e., differential operators taking a section V (i) to a scalar function on M], such that (i )( j) sd < 0. (36) (c¯(i ) ⊗ c( j) )C(1) i, j∈K
Then we impose the relation 0=
c(i) φ (i) ( f )
(37)
i∈K
for all f ∈ C0∞ (M). Here the differential operators act in the sense of distributions, i.e., c(i) φ (i) ( f ) by definition means φ (i) (c(i) t f ), where t means the dual of a differential operator defined with respect to the volume element e associated with the metric. This relation can be intuitively understood as follows. Let O( f ) be the smeared quantum field defined by the right side of Eq. (37). If we consider the OPE of the quantity O(x1 )O(x2 )∗ , then the term involving the identity operator will have a negative scaling degree due to (36). Above, in the asymptotic positivity requirement, we demanded that
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
103
any one of our fields φ (i) except the identity field must have a non-negative scaling degree. It is natural to extend this postulate also to linear combinations of such fields such as O. In other words, O should vanish if its scaling degree is negative. This is what our requirement states. The above requirement serves to eliminate any redundancies in the field content arising e.g. from initially viewing, say, a field ϕ and ϕ as independent fields, or from initially specifying a set of linearly dependent fields. More nontrivially, this requirement should also serve to impose field equations in A(M). For example, in λϕ 4 -theory, we expect that a field equation of the form ϕ − m 2 ϕ − λϕ 3 = 0 should hold, where ϕ 3 is a composite field in the theory that should appear in the operator product expansion of three factors of ϕ. If such a field equation holds, then clearly ϕ − m 2 ϕ − λϕ 3 should have a trivial OPE with itself. In particular, the OPE coefficient multiplying the identity operator in this expansion should have arbitrarily low scaling degree. Thus, in this example, if we take c(1) = − m 2 , c(2) = −λ, and φ (1) = ϕ, φ (2) = ϕ 3 , then Eq. (36) should hold. Our requirement effectively demands that field equations hold if and only if they are implied by the OPE condition Eq. (36). A5) (Anti-)commutation relations. Let φ (i1 ) and φ (i2 ) be fields, and let f 1 and f 2 be test sections corresponding to their respective spinor or tensor character, whose supports are assumed to be spacelike separated. Then the relation φ (i1 ) ( f 1 )φ (i2 ) ( f 2 ) + (−1) F(i1 )F(i2 ) φ (i2 ) ( f 2 )φ (i1 ) ( f 1 ) = 0
(38)
holds in A(M). Having defined the algebra A(M), we next define the state space S(M) to consist of all those linear functionals . ω : A(M) → C with the following properties: S1) Positivity. The functional should be of positive type, meaning that A∗ Aω ≥ 0 for each A ∈ A(M). Physically, Aω is interpreted as the expectation value of the observable A in ω. S2) OPE. The operator product expansion holds as an asymptotic relation. By this we mean more precisely the following. Let φ (i1 ) , . . . , φ (in ) be any collection of fields, let δ > 0 be arbitrary but fixed, and let T be any merger tree as described in the associativity condition. Let ∼δ,T be the associated asymptotic equality relation between distributions of n spacetime points that are defined in a neighborhood of the diagonal which was defined in the associativity condition [see Eq. (29]. Then we require that (i )...(i ) φ (i1 ) (x1 ) · · · φ (in ) (xn ) ∼δ,T C( j)1 n (x1 , . . . , xn ; y) φ ( j) (y) , (39) ω
j
ω
where the sum is carried out over all j such that dim( j) ≤ , where is a number depending upon the tree T, and the specified accuracy, δ. S3) Spectrum condition. We have WF φ (i1 ) (x1 ) . . . φ (in ) (xn )ω ⊂ n (M),
(40)
where the set n (M) ⊂ T ∗ M n \{0} was defined above in Eq. (23). By definition, 1 (M) = ∅, so the microlocal spectrum condition says in particular that φ (i) (x)ω is smooth in x.
104
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
As part of our definition of a quantum field theory, we make the final requirement that there is at least one state, i.e., S(M) = ∅ for all M.
(41)
If the state space were empty, then this is a sign that the OPE is inconsistent, and does not define a physically acceptable quantum field theory. Remarks. (1) The OPE coefficients enter the construction of the algebra A(M) only via condition (A4). However, they provide a strong restriction on the state space S(M) via condition (S2). (2) If ω ∈ S(M) and A ∈ A(M), then ω(A∗ · A) is a positive linear functional on A(M) [i.e., satisfying (S1)] which can also be shown to satisfy (S3). This functional can be identified with a vector state in the Hilbert space representation of A(M) obtained by applying the GNS construction to ω, and is therefore in the domain of all smeared field operators. It is natural to expect that, in a reasonable quantum field theory, the OPE [i.e. (S2)] should hold in such states as well, but this does not appear to follow straightforwardly within our axiomatic setting. (3) There are some apparent redundancies in our assumptions in that commutativity/anti-commutativity conditions have been imposed separately on the OPE coefficients and the algebra (see Conditions (C4) and (A5)), and microlocal spectrum conditions have been imposed separately on the OPE coefficients and the states (see Conditions (C7) and (S3)). It is possible that our assumptions could be reformulated in such a way as to eliminate these redundancies, e.g., it is possible that Condition (A5) might follow from Condition (C4) with perhaps somewhat stronger assumptions about states. However, we shall not pursue these possibilities here. The construction of the pair {A(M), S(M)} obviously depends only upon the data entering that construction, namely the set of all operator product coefficients C(M), as well as the assignments i → V (i) and i → F(i) of the index set enumerating the fields with tensor/spinor character, and with Bose/Fermi character. Thus, any transformation on field space preserving the OPE and the Bose/Fermi character will evidently give rise to a corresponding isomorphism between the algebras, and a corresponding map between the state spaces. We now give a more formal statement of this obvious fact, and then point out some applications. Let ψ : M → M , not necessarily an isometry at this stage. Furthermore, for each ( j) pair of indices (i, j) ∈ I × I , assume that we are given a C-linear bundle map z (i) from V (i), viewed as a bundle over M, to V ( j), viewed as a bundle over M . We make the following requirements about the pair (ψ, z): First, we require that the following diagram commutes: ( j)
z (i)
V (i) −−−−→ V ( j) ⏐ ⏐ ⏐π , ⏐ πM M
(42)
ψ
M −−−−→ M where π M respectively π M are the bundle projections associated with the vector bundles V (i) and V ( j) over M respectively M that characterize the spinor/tensor character of the field labelled by i and j.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
105
(i)
We furthermore require that z ( j) = 0 unless dim( j) ≤ dim(i), and unless F(i) = F( j). Recalling that V (i ) is required to be equal to the hermitian conjugate bundle V (i), and denoting by con j the operation of conjugation mapping between these bundles, we also require as a consistency condition that ( j )
( j)
conjM ◦ z (i) = z (i ) ◦ conjM ,
(43)
for all indices i, j ∈ I . We say that a collection of OPE coefficients C(M) on M = (M, g, T, e) and a collection C (M ) on M = (M , g , T , e ) are equivalent under (z, ψ) if ( j) ( j )...( jn ) (i ) (i ) (i )...(i ) (z ( j11 ) × · · · × z ( jnn ) × (z v −1 )(k) ) C(k)1 [M] ∼ C( j)1 n [M ] ◦ ψ, (44) j1 ,..., jn ,k
see Eq. (11). Note that the sums are finite, since we are assuming that the number of ( j) fields less than a fixed dimension is finite, and note that (z v −1 )(k) denotes the inverse matrix of dual maps between the dual bundles. As before, let A(M) be the algebra and S(M) the state space defined from C(M), and similarly let A (M ) and S (M ) be defined from C (M ). By simply going through the definitions it is then clear that the following (almost trivial) lemma holds. Lemma 1. Under the consistency conditions (43) and (44), and assuming that ψ preserves all background structure (i.e., ψ is an isometric embedding preserving the causality relations, orientations, and spin structures) the map α(ψ,z) : A(M) → A (M ) ( j) (i) (i) α(ψ,z) : φM ( f ) → φM [(z v )( j) f ◦ ψ −1 ], (45) j v defines a linear *-homomorphism. The dual map α(ψ,z) between the corresponding state spaces defines a map S (M ) → S(M).
Another way of stating this result is to view the pairs (z, ψ) as described above as morphisms in the category whose objects are the OPE-coefficient systems C(M). The above lemma then says that the constructions of S(M) and of A(M) from C(M) are functorial in nature. We now discuss some applications of the lemma: Application 1. Consider the case where C(M) = C (M) for all M, z ((i)j) = δ((i)j) ψ∗ , ψ : M → M is an isometric embedding preserving orientations and any other background structure, and ψ∗ is the natural bundle map (push-forward) associated with ψ. Then (43) obviously holds, while (44) holds because of the locality and covariance property of the OPE coefficients. The map α(ψ,z) : A(M) → A(M ), whose existence is guaranteed by the lemma, then corresponds to the map χρ discussed in the Introduction. In particular, the assignment Background Structures → Algebras, M → A(M)
(46)
is functorial, in the sense that if ρ is an arrow in the category of background structures— i.e., an orientation and causality preserving isometric embedding from one spacetime
106
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
into another—then χρ is the corresponding arrow in the category of *-algebras—i.e., an injective *-homomorphism. Functoriality means that the assignment Isometric Embeddings → Algebra Homomorphisms, ρ → χρ
(47)
respects composition of arrows in the respective categories. Thus, in the terminology of the introduction, the assumptions of our framework define a local, covariant quantum field theory, and all fields φ (i) are local, covariant quantum fields. Furthermore, A : M → A(M) is a functor in the sense of [7]. Application 2. As the second application, consider an internal symmetry, i.e., consider the case that M = M , C(M) = C (M), ψ = id. Then α(id,z) acts upon A(M) as a *-automorphism, i.e., an internal symmetry. More generally, there could be an entire group G. In this case, we get an action of G on A(M) by ∗-automorphisms α(id,z) satisfying the composition law α(id,z) ◦ α(id,z ) = α(id,z◦z ) . Here the composition is defined as (i) ( j) z ( j) ◦ z (k) . (48) (z ◦ z )(i) (k) = j
The sum over j is finite because we are assuming that there are only a finite number of indices up to a given dimension. Application 3. Field redefinitions are covered by the case M = M , ψ = id. The lemma then states that there is a *-homomorphism, A(M) → A (M ). In other words, if we (i) change the definition of the field by a “mixing matrix” z ( j) and make a corresponding change of the OPE coefficients as in Eq. (44), then we obtain an equivalent theory. In renormalized perturbation theory, such changes arise naturally from changes in the renormalization conditions. Another simple consequence of our axioms is the following lemma. As above in (C6), let X a be a vector field on M locally defined near y such that ∇a X b = −δab at y. Let t be the flow of this field9 , which scales points relative to y by a factor of e−t . If f is a compactly supported test section in V (i), we set f λ = λ−D ∗log λ f for λ > 0. Lemma 2. For i = 1, there exists an M and test section f such that (i)(i ) lim λ2dim(i)−δ C(1) (x1 , x2 , y) f λ (x1 ) f¯λ (x2 ) dµ1 dµ2 = +∞, λ→0
(49)
M×M
for all sufficiently small δ > 0. Proof. Let ω be an arbitrary state. Then we have φ (i) ( f λ )φ (i ) ( f¯λ )ω ≥ 0, from the star axiom (C3), and the positivity of any state. Let M be such that the scaling degree (i)(i ) of C(1) equals 2dim(i). By the scaling degree and asymptotic positivity axioms (C5) and (C6), for sufficiently small δ > 0, the quantity 2dim(i) − δ is bigger than the scaling (i)(i ) degree of C( j) for any j = 1. Hence using Eq. (39) and 1ω = 1, we have (i)(i ) 2dim(i)−δ (i) (i ) ¯ φ ( f λ )φ ( f λ ) − C ( f λ , f¯λ ) = 0. (50) lim λ
λ→0
ω
(1)
9 It follows that we can write −1 log λ (x) = y + λ (x − y) in a suitable coordinate system covering y.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
107
By Axiom (C6), we can choose f so that the second term tends to ∞ in absolute value (i)(i ) as λ → 0. However, the first term is always non-negative. Therefore, C(1) ( f λ , f¯λ ) → +∞. 4. Normal (Anti-)Commutation Relations In our axioms, we assumed that every field φ (i) was either a Bose or Fermi field, i.e., that there was a consistent assignment i → F(i) ∈ Z2 such that (19) holds. A priori, there is no relation between F(i) and the Bose/Fermi character of the corresponding hermitian conjugate field, i.e., F(i ). We will now prove that, in fact, F(i) = F(i ) as a consequence of our axioms. Theorem 1. We have “normal (anti-)commutation relations,” in the sense that F(i) = F(i )
(51)
for all i ∈ I . Proof. Let f and h be compactly supported test sections with support in a convex normal neighborhood of a point y ∈ M. Let ω be a quantum state, i.e., a positive normalized linear functional A(M) → C. Using (35), we see that positivity immediately implies that ¯ (i ) ( f¯) ≥ 0. (52) φ (i) ( f )φ (i) (h)φ (i ) (h)φ ω
Assume now that the supports of f, h are spacelike separated. Then, using the (anti-) commutation relations Eq. (38), it follows that ¯ (i) (h) ≥ 0, p φ (i) ( f )φ (i ) ( f¯)φ (i ) (h)φ (53) ω
F(i)F(i )+F(i )2
. Clearly, if we could show that the expectation value where p = (−1) in this expression were positive for some test sections, f, h, in some spacetime, then it would follow that p = +1, i.e. F(i)F(i ) + F(i )2 = 0 mod 2,
(54)
and by reversing the roles of i and i , it would also follow that F(i)F(i ) + F(i)2 = 0 mod 2,
(55)
from which the statement F(i) = F(i ) modulo 2 would follow. Clearly, it suffices to show that the expectation value is asymptotically positive for a 1-parameter family of test sections f λ , h λ whose supports are scaled towards y ∈ M as λ → 0. To show this, we consider the particular merger tree T of Fig. 1, and the corresponding associativity condition. This tree corresponds to the scaling map T (ε) : x(1) → x(ε), with x1 (ε) = Exp y εv1 + ε2 v3 , x2 (ε) = Exp y εv1 + ε2 v4 ,
108
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
x3 (ε) = Exp y εv2 + ε2 v5 , x4 (ε) = Exp y εv2 + ε2 v6 , x5 (ε) = Exp y εv1 , x6 (ε) = Exp y εv2 ,
(56)
x7 (ε) = y. The corresponding associativity condition together with (S2) yields −δ (i) (i ) (i ) (i) φ (x1 (ε))φ (x2 (ε))φ (x3 (ε))φ (x4 (ε)) lim ε ε→0
−
j1 , j2 , j3
ω (i)(i ) (i )(i) C( j1 ) (x1 (ε), x2 (ε); x5 (ε)) C( j2 ) (x3 (ε), x4 (ε); x6 (ε))
( j )( j ) ×C( j31) 2 (x5 (ε), x6 (ε);
y) φ
( j3 )
= 0.
(y)
(57)
ω
This is to be understood in the sense of distributions in v1 , . . . , v6 . The sums go over all indices with dim( jk ) ≤ , where depends on δ. We now use Axioms (C5) and (C6) to analyze the scaling of the individual terms under the sum. It follows that
) (i )(i) lim εα C((i)(i j1 ) (x 1 (ε), x 2 (ε); x 5 (ε)) C ( j2 ) (x 3 (ε), x 4 (ε);
ε→0
( j )( j2 )
x6 (ε)) C( j31)
(58)
(x5 (ε), x6 (ε); y) = 0
if α > 8dim(i) − dim( j1 ) − dim( j2 ) − dim( j3 ) in the sense of distributions. Thus, the term under the sum with the potentially most singular behavior as ε → 0 is the one where dim( j1 ) = dim( j2 ) = dim( j3 ) is minimal, i.e. equal to 0, by Axiom (C6). If these dimensions vanish, then by Axiom (C6), we have jk = 1. Because 1ω = 1, and because the OPE coefficients involving only identity operators are equal to 1 by the identity axiom, we have 8dim(i)+δ (i) (i ) (i ) (i) φ (x1 (ε))φ (x2 (ε))φ (x3 (ε))φ (x4 (ε)) lim ε ε→0
(i)(i ) (i )(i) −C(1) (x1 (ε), x2 (ε), x5 (ε)) C(1) (x3 (ε), x4 (ε), x6 (ε))
ω
= 0,
(59)
for some δ > 0. We now integrate this expression against the test section f (v3 ) f¯(v4 ) ¯ 5 )h(v6 ), where f, h are of compact support, and change integration variables10 . Then h(v we get for the terms under the limit sign (i)(i ) (i )(i) (i) (i ) ¯ (i ) ¯ (i) φ ( f ε )φ ( f ε )φ (h ε )φ (h ε ) − C(1) ( f ε , f¯ε )C(1) (h¯ ε , h ε ). (60) ω
10 We should also integrate against a test function in v , v . But the result (60) is already smooth in these 1 2 variables, so we can omit this smearing.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
109
Here, we have defined f ε (x) = ε−2D f ◦ α1 (ε, x) and h ε (x) = ε−2D h ◦ α2 (ε, x) with αi (ε, . ) : M → R D are the maps that are defined in a sufficiently small neighborhood of y by α1 (ε, x) = ε−1 v1 + ε−2 Exp−1 y (x), α2 (ε, x) = ε
−1
v2 + ε
−2
Exp−1 y (x).
(61) (62)
(i)(i ) Finally, we use the Lemma 2 to conclude that there exist f, h such that both C(1) (i)(i ) ( f ε , f¯ε ) → +∞ and C(1) (h ε , h¯ ε ) → +∞ for some spacetime and some subsequence of ε → 0. In view of Eq. (60), it follows that
lim φ (i) ( f ε )φ (i ) ( f¯ε )φ (i ) (h¯ ε )φ (i) (h ε ) = +∞,
ε→0
ω
(63)
so the expectation value (53) is positive for the choice of test sections f, h given by f ε , h ε , see Eq. (61), for sufficiently small ε. These test sections will have spacelike separated support as long as Exp y v1 and Exp y v2 are spacelike, which we may assume to be the case. 5. The Spin-statistics Theorem and the PCT-theorem In this section, we prove that appropriate versions of the spin-statistics theorem and the PCT theorem hold in curved spacetime under our axiom scheme. We explicitly discuss the case when the spacetime dimension is even, D = 2m and discuss the case of odd dimensions briefly in Remark 2 below the PCT theorem. The key ingredient in both proofs is a relation, proven in [16], between the OPE coefficients C(M) on the background structure M = (M, g, T, e), and the OPE coefficients C(M) on the background structure M = (M, g, −T, e)
(64)
consisting of the same manifold M, the same metric g, the same orientation e, but the opposite time orientation T . For even spacetime dimensions D = 2m, this relation is11 : C((ij)1 )...(in ) [M]
∼
(i )...(i ) C( j1 ) n [M] ·
i−F( j) (−1)−U ( j) nk=1 i F(ik ) (−1)U (ik ) m even, n −F( j)+U ( j)−P( j) F(i )−U (i )+P(i ) k k k i m odd, k=1 i (65)
√ where i = −1. Here, we recall that with each quantum field φ (i) there is associated a bundle V (i) over M corresponding to the tensor or spinor character of the quantum field. In even spacetime dimensions D = 2m, such a bundle V (i) is a tensor product ⊗U (i)
V (i) = S−
⊗P(i)
⊗ S+
,
(66)
11 Note that the “bar” symbol is referring to the P T -reversed background structure in the term on the left side, while it means hermitian conjugation on the right side.
110
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
where the first factor corresponds to the U (i) “unprimed-” and the second to the P(i) “primed” spinor indices. More precisely, the bundles S± are defined as the ±1 eigenspaces of the chirality operator12 =
1 (−1)(m−1)(2m−1)/2 ea1 a2 ...a D γa1 γa2 · · · γa D , D!
2 = id S ,
(67)
acting on a 2m -dimensional complex vector bundle S over M of “Dirac spinors”. This bundle S corresponds to a fundamental representation of the Clifford algebra (in the tangent bundle) generated by the curved space gamma-matrices γa . There exists a linear isomorphism c : S → S, where S is the conjugate bundle of anti-linear maps S v → C. Owing to the relation = (−1)m−1 c c−1 , it follows that for even m, the bundles S± and S ∓ are isomorphic via c, while for odd m the bundles S± and S ± are isomorphic, and we will hence always identify these bundles. Thus, for even m the roles of primed and unprimed spinor indices [i.e., respective tensor factors in Eq. (66)] are exchanged when passing to the hermitian adjoint φ (i ) of a quantum field φ (i) , while for odd m the roles are not exchanged. We also note that the coefficients on the right side of Eq. (65) are sections in the (tensor product of the) spin bundles VM (i) referring to the time function T associated with M, while the coefficients on the left side are sections in the spinor bundles VM (i ) defined via the opposite time orientation −T associated with M. As explained in [16], there is a natural identification map between these bundles, and this identification map is understood in (65). The proof of (65) makes use of the microlocal, analytical, and causal properties of the OPE coefficients and proceeds via analytic continuation [16]. Since it is the main input in the proofs of both the spin-statistics theorem and the PCT theorem, we now outline, following [16], how (65) is proven within our axiomatic setting. We first consider the case where g is analytic. Let y ∈ M and introduce Riemannian normal coordinates x = (x 0 , . . . , x D−1 ) ∈ R D about y. In this neighborhood of y, consider the 1-parameter family of metrics g (s) for all |s| ≤ 1 defined by g (s) = gµν (sx) d x µ d x ν .
(68)
Note that this family, in effect, interpolates between the given metric g = g (1) and the flat Minkowski metric η = g (0) . We can expand g (s) in a power series in s about s = 0, which takes the form (s) gµν = ηµν +
∞
s n pµνβ1 ...βn−2 (y) x β1 . . . x βn−2 ,
(69)
n=2
where each p is a curvature polynomial p(y) = p[Rµνσρ (y), . . . , ∇(α1 · · · ∇α(n−2) ) Rµνσρ (y)]. It can then be shown, using Axiom (C1), that each OPE coefficient has an asymptotic expansion of the form (i )...(i n )
C( j)1
(x1 , . . . , xn , y) =
∞
(i )...(i n )
qk (y) · (Wk )( j)1
(x1 , . . . , xn ),
(70)
k=0
where qk = (qk )µ1 ...µk is a curvature polynomial of the same general form as the p, and where Wk = (Wk )µ1 ...µk are distributions defined on a neighborhood of 0 in (R D )n , 12 Here, the orientation D-form is normalized so that g a1 b1 . . . g a D b D e a1 ...a D eb1 ...b D = −D!.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
111
valued in the tensor product of (R D )⊗k with the spinor representation corresponding to the index structure of the quantum fields in the operator product considered. They transform covariantly under the connected component SpinR (D − 1, 1)0 of the spin group of D-dimensional Minkowski space. Consider now the map ρ defined in a suitable convex normal neighborhood, O, of y by (x 0 , . . . , x D−1 ) → (−x 0 , . . . , −x D−1 ). In Minkowski spacetime, this map would define an isometry which preserves spacetime orientation but reverses time orientation. In a general curved spacetime, this map does not define an isometry. Nevertheless, we may view ρ as a map ρ : (O, g (s) , e, T ) → (O, g (−s) , e, −T ).
(71)
Viewed in this manner, it is easily seen that ρ preserves all background structure, i.e., it is a causality preserving isometry that preserves orientations. Consequently, by the covariance axiom (C1), the relation (65) is equivalent to a corresponding relation between the OPE-coefficients on the spacetimes (M, g (s) , e, T ) and (M, g (−s) , e, T ), i.e., spacetimes with different metrics but the same orientation and time orientation. If one now differentiates this relation m-times with respect to s and puts s = 0 afterwards, then one can prove that (65) is equivalent to the relation Wk (x1 , . . . , xn ) =
∗
(−1) π Wk (−xn , . . . , −x1 ) · k
i−F( j) (−1)−U ( j) nk=1 i F(ik ) (−1)U (ik ) m even, n −F( j)−U ( j)+P( j) F(i )−U (i )+P(i ) k k k m odd, i k=1 i (72)
for all k = 0, 1, 2, . . .. Here, π is the permutation (17), which acts by permuting the implicit spinor/indices associated with the spacetime points xi . We have thus reduced the proof of (65) to the proof of a statement about Minkowski distributions Wk that transform covariantly under SpinR (D −1, 1)0 . To prove it, one next shows that Wk can be analytically continued, and that the analytic continuation transforms covariantly under the connected component of the identity in the complexified spin group SpinC (D −1, 1)0 . For this, one first proves, using the microlocal condition on the OPE-coefficients, that, near 0, the analytic wave front set [22], WF A , of Wk satisfies WF A (Wk ) ⊂ K .
(73)
Here, K is a conic set defined in terms of the Minkowskian metric η and orientation e, T , by
K = (y1 , k1 ; . . . ; yn , kn ) ∈ T ∗ (×n Br )\{0} ∃ pi j ∈ V¯+ , n ≥ j > i ≥ 1 : ki =
j: j>i
pi j −
p ji for all i ,
(74)
j: j
where V¯ + is the closure of the forward light cone V + in Minkowski space (defined with respect to the time orientation T ), V ± = {k ∈ R D | ηµν k µ k ν > 0, k µ ∇µ T > 0}.
(75)
112
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
The relation (73) is important because a theorem of [22] now guarantees that Wk is the distributional boundary value Wk (x1 , . . . , xn ) =
B. V.
(y1 ,...,yn )∈K v →0
Wk (x1 + iy1 , . . . , xn + iyn )
(76)
of a holomorphic function Wk (z 1 , . . . , z n ) that is defined in the “half-space” Wk : Br (0)n + iK v → C, some r > 0,
(77)
v where Br (0) is a ball of radius r in R D , where K is the “dual cone” of all covectors D n (y1 , . . . , yn ) ∈ (R ) with the property that ki · yi > 0 for all (k1 , . . . , kn ) ∈ K . Using the “edge of the wedge-theorem” [27], one proves that the holomorphic function Wk (z 1 , . . . , z n ) transforms covariantly under the spin group SpinR (D − 1, 1)0 . As explained in more detail in [16], one can use this in turn to prove the desired relation (72): For D = 2m and m even, we consider the chirality element in Eq. (67) in flat space, which is an element of the connected component of the identity of the complexified spin group SpinC (D − 1, 1)0 . It corresponds to the reflection element ρ : R D → R D , x → −x of the complexified Lorentz group S O(D − 1, 1; C) under the standard covering homomorphism between these groups. This is an immediate consequence of the relation γa −1 = −γa . Using the method of analytic continuation in overlapping patches, it can be shown that Wk may be continued to a single valued analytic function on an extension of the domain in Eq. (77), and it can be shown that this continuation transforms covariantly under . As explained above, acts as +id S+ on each tensor factor corresponding to a primed spinor index, and as −id S− on each tensor factor associated with an unprimed spinor index. Therefore, if we apply the transformation law of Wk under the element , then we obtain relation (72) for complex spacetime arguments, except that the order of the complex spacetime arguments z 1 , . . . , z n is reversed, and except for the factors relating to the Bose-Fermi character of the fields involved. In order to be able to take the limit Im z i → 0 from within K v , we must pass to so-called “Jost points” (z 1 , . . . , z n ) in the extended domain of holomorphicity. For such points, the (anti-)commutativity may be used, effectively allowing to permute the spacetime arguments in Wk in such a way that one can take the limit to real points from within K v as required in Eq. (76) afterwards. When permuting the arguments, we pick up the factors related to the Bose/Fermi character of the fields. For D = 2m and m odd, we consider instead the element i of the connected component of the identity of the complexified spin group SpinC (D − 1, 1)0 . This element again covers the reflection ρ(x) = −x on D-dimensional Minkowski space. It acts as +i id S+ on each tensor factor corresponding to a primed spinor index, and as −i id S− on each tensor factor associated with an unprimed spinor index. Again it can be shown that Wk may be continued analytically to a domain extending that in Eq. (77), and that it transforms covariantly under i on the extended domain. The additional factor of i gives rise to the different factors in Eq. (72) compared to the case when m is even. The rest of the argument is identical to that case. This proves the PCT-relation (65) for analytic spacetimes, and even dimensions D = 2m. The validity of the corresponding relation for smooth spacetimes then follows from the smoothness of the OPE-coefficients under smooth variations of the metric, since any smooth metric can be viewed as the limiting member of a smooth 1-parameter family of metrics g (λ) that are analytic for λ > 0 and smooth for λ = 0. The differences in the statement and proof of the PCT-relation (65) for odd spacetime dimension D are described in Remark 2 below, following the proof of the PCT-Theorem.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
113
We now are ready to state and prove the spin-statistics theorem within our framework. The statement and proof of this theorem closely parallel the Minkowski spacetime version: Theorem 2 (Spin-Statistics Theorem). If our axioms hold, then the spin statistics relation F(i) = U (i) + P(i) mod 2,
(78)
also holds, i.e. fields with integer spin (= one half the number of primed + unprimed spinor indices) have Bose statistics, while fields of half integer spin have Fermi statistics. Proof. Let i ∈ I , and, as above, we restrict consideration to the even dimensional case (i)(i ) D = 2m. Consider the PCT-relation (65) for the OPE-coefficient C(1) . This condition can be written as i F(i)+F(i ) (−1)U (i )+U (i) m even, (i)(i ) (i )(i) C(1) (x1 , x2 , y)M ∼ C(1) (x2 , x1 ; y)M · F(i)+U (i)−P(i)+F(i )+U (i )−P(i ) i m odd, (79) where we have used the hermitian conjugation axiom, and where we have used that F(1) = 0 since the identity is always a Bose field, by the identity axiom. When m is even, then U (i ) = P(i) because conjugation of a spinor exchanges the number of primed and unprimed indices. Furthermore, F(i) = F(i ) by Theorem 1, so we obtain (i)(i )
C(1)
(i )(i)
(x1 , x2 , y)M ∼ (−1) F(i)+U (i)+P(i) C(1)
(x2 , x1 ; y)M .
(80)
When m is odd, U (i ) = U (i) and P(i ) = P(i), because conjugation of a spinor does not change the number of primed and unprimed spinor indices in that case. Using this, we again obtain the expression Eq. (80) when m is odd. We now smear this expression with the test section f λ (x1 ) f¯λ (x2 ), where f λ (x) = λ−D f [y + λ−1 (x − y)].
(81)
We are taking here an f of compact support in a sufficiently small neighborhood of y covered by some coordinate system, and y + λ−1 (x − y) is computed in this arbitrary coordinate system. Furthermore, by Lemma 2, we may assume that Eq. (49) is satisfied for this choice for all sufficiently small δ > 0. Denote by dim(i) the dimension of the field labeled by i. It then follows from Eq. (80) that (i)(i ) 2dim(i)−δ λ C(1) (x1 , x2 ; y)M f λ (x1 ) f¯λ (x2 ) dµ1 dµ2 (i )(i) − p λ2dim(i)−δ C(1) (x2 , x1 ; y)M f λ (x1 ) f¯λ (x2 ) dµ1 dµ2 → 0 (82) as λ → 0, for all sufficiently small δ > 0 where p = (−1) F(i)+U (i)+P(i) . The first term goes to +∞ by Lemma 2, and hence the second term must be unbounded, too. In fact, arguing as in the proof of Lemma 2 (now for M), the second term goes to − p·∞. The two terms can only cancel for small λ if we have p = +1, meaning that F(i)+ P(i)+U (i) = 0 modulo 2. Hence the spin-statistics relation must hold.
114
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
Next, we state and prove the PCT theorem, the formulation of which is quite different from the Minkowski spacetime version (see the discussion below). Again, we restrict consideration here to D = 2m, and describe the differences occurring in odd dimensions in Remark 2 below: Theorem 3 (PCT-Theorem). Given a background structure M = (M, g, e, T ), we write M = (M, g, e, −T ). In spacetime dimension D = 2m, define the anti-linear map PCT : A(M) → A(M) by θM i F(i) (−1)U (i) when m is even, (i) (i) PCT ∗ θM : φM ( f ) → φ ( f ) · F(i)+U (i)−P(i) (83) M when m is odd. i PCT is an anti-linear *-isomorphism such that the diagram Then θM PCT θM
A(M) −−−−→ A(M) ⏐ ⏐ ⏐χρ χρ ⏐ PCT θM
(84)
A(M ) −−−−→ A(M ) as well as the diagram
PCT v θM
S(M ) −−−−→ S(M ) ⏐ ⏐ ⏐χ v ⏐ χρv ρ
(85)
PCT v θM
S(M) −−−−→ S(M) commute for every isometric, causality and orientation preserving embedding ρ : M → M . Here χρv denotes the dual of the linear map χρ , and θ PCT v denotes the dual of θ PCT . Proof. The proof of this theorem is, in essence, an application of lemma 1. In the notation of lemma 1, we choose M = (M, g, e, T ), we choose M = M, we take ψ = id (i) (i ) and we choose z ( j) = δ( j) ψ( j) where ψ( j) is the natural anti-linear bundle map from VM ( j) to VM ( j ) that is implicit in the formula (83), composed with the multiplication map by i F(i) (−1)U (i) when m is even and by i F(i)+U (i)−P(i) when m is odd. From this definition we then have (−1) F(i)/2+F(i )/2+U (i)−U (i ) · ψ(i ) ◦ conjM m even, conjM ◦ ψ(i) = F(i)+F(i )−U (i)−U (i )+P(i)+P(i ) (86) · ψ(i ) ◦ conjM m odd, i where con jM is the anti-linear map that sends a spinor to the hermitian conjugate spinor on M. Now for even m the number of unprimed spinor indices associated with V (i) is precisely equal to the number of primed indices P(i ) associated with V (i ), because V (i ) is assumed to be equal to V (i). Thus, P(i) = U (i ). Furthermore, we have F(i) = F(i ) by Theorem 1, and F(i) = U (i) + P(i) mod 2 by the spin-statistics theorem. Consequently, when m is even we have shown conjM ◦ ψ(i) = ψ(i ) ◦ conjM .
(87)
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
115
This immediately implies the required compatibility condition (43) required for lemma 1. When m is odd, then U (i) = U (i ) and P(i) = P(i ), and the compatibility condition again holds because of F(i) = F(i ) and the spin-statistics theorem. Thus, we have shown that the first input in lemma 1 holds. The second input is the compatibility of the OPE coefficients on M and M , Eq. (44). That condition is essentially equivalent to the relation (65), except that the latter relation also involves an additional complex conjugation of the OPE-coefficient. However it is immediately seen that this will result only in the following difference in the conclusion of lemma 1: Instead of the linear *-homomorphism as provided by this lemma, we now find that the PCT-map θ PCT defined by Eq. (83) yields an anti-linear *-homomophism. Remarks. (1) The above formulation of the PCT-theorem was suggested in [16]. As noted in [9] the theorem can be stated in the language of functors by saying that the functors M → A(M) and M → A(M) = A(M) are equivalent. (2) In odd spacetime dimensions D = 2m + 1, the chirality operator of Eq. (67) is proportional to the identity in S. Thus, in this case there is no decomposition S = S+ ⊕ S− as in the even dimensional case, and there is consequently no difference between “primed” and “unprimed” spinors. If we denote the number of spinor indices of a quantum field by N (i) (i.e., the bundle associated with the label i of the is V (i) = S ⊗N (i) ), then the factors in formula (65) are now field −F( j)−N ( j) F(i )+N (i k ) . In the proof of this formula, one must now consider the k i i 0 1 map ρ : (x , x , . . . , x D−1 ) → (−x 0 , −x 1 , . . . , +x D−1 ). This corresponds again to a change of time orientation in Minkowski spacetime which leaves the spacetime orientation invariant. The rest of the proof is similar. We now explain the relation of the above formulation of the PCT theorem to the usual PCT theorem in Minkowski spacetime (see e.g. [27]). Changing T → −T while keeping e unchanged is equivalent to changing parity (i.e., the spatial orientation s of a Cauchy surface induced by e and T via dT ∧ s = e) and time (i.e., the time function). Furthermore, the field appearing on the right side of Eq. (83) is usually referred to as the (i) “charge conjugate field” to φM ( f ). Thus our formulation of the PCT theorem asserts that the theory is indeed invariant under simultaneous PCT-reversal in the sense that the theory on M is “the same” as the theory on M with the fields replaced by their charge conjugates. However, note that our PCT theorem relates theories on the two different background structures, M and M. By contrast, the usual PCT theorem in Minkowski spacetime provides a symmetry of the theory defined on a single background structure, namely Minkowski spacetime with a fixed choice of orientation and time orientation. Indeed, the usual formulation of the PCT theorem in Minkowski spacetime asserts the existence of an anti-unitary operator : H → H on the Hilbert space, H, of physical states such that, if ρ denotes the isometry on the, say, even-dimensional Minkowski spacetime defined by ρ : (x 0 , x 1 , . . . , x D−1 ) → (−x 0 , −x 1 , . . . , −x D−1 ),
(88)
and if φ C is the charge conjugate field associated with φ defined by Eq. (83), then Ad φ(ρ(x)) ≡ φ(ρ(x))† = φ C (x). The relationship between these formulations can be seen as follows. Start with our formulation of the PCT theorem. The isometry ρ maps Minkowski spacetime M = (R D , η, e, T ) with a given choice of orientation e and time orientation T , to M = (R D , η, e, −T ). Thus, by “Application 1” of Lemma 1, we know that there is a
116
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
*-homomorphism χρ : A(M) → A(M) mapping the quantum fields φM ( f ) on M to ¯ Thus, if we define the “same” quantum fields φM (ρ∗ ( f )) on M. PCT Ad := χρ−1 ◦ θM ,
(89)
we obtain a result that is essentially equivalent to the usual Minkowski version (as suitably reformulated in an algebraic setting). Conversely, if we start with the usual formulation of the PCT theorem and if we define quantum field theory on A(M) in terms of quantum field theory on M by means of the map χρ , then we obtain a version essentially equivalent to our formulation by setting PCT θM = χρ ◦ Ad .
(90)
Although the above formulations are essentially equivalent in Minkowski spacetime, in a general spacetime, there does not exist any discrete isometry analogous to ρ. Thus, in general we only have a PCT theorem describing the relation between the theory defined on different backgrounds M and M. Of course in the case of a spacetime that admits an isometry ρ mapping (e, T ) to (e, −T ) (as occurs, e.g. in Schwarzschild and deSitter spacetimes), then a “same background structure” version of the PCT theorem can be given via Eq. (89). The example of a Robertson-Walker spacetime g = −dt 2 + a(t)2 dx · dx
(91)
with a(t) a strictly increasing function of t, may be useful for clarifying the physical meaning of our formulation of the PCT theorem in a general curved spacetime. If we choose the time orientation T = t, then the above metric describes an expanding universe, while if we take T = −t, it describes a corresponding contracting universe (with opposite choice of spatial orientation since we keep e fixed). In essence, our formulation of the PCT theorem relates phenomena/processes occuring in the expanding universe Eq. (91) to corresponding processes (involving the charge conjugate fields and also a reversal of parity) in the corresponding contracting universe. Since the metric Eq. (91) has no time reflection isometry ρ, there are no relations implied by the PCT theorem between phenomena/processes occurring in the expanding universe, Eq. (91) with T = t. As a concrete illustration of this, suppose that it were possible to give a definition of “particle masses” in curved spacetime—although it is far from obvious that any such useful notion exists. The PCT theorem would then imply that the mass of a particle in an expanding universe must be equal to the mass of the corresponding antiparticle in a contracting universe. However, it would make no statement about the masses of particles and antiparticles in the same universe13 . 13 It is worth noting that the “third Sakharov necessary condition” for baryogenesis in the early universe (namely, “interactions out of thermal equilibrium”) is based upon the (now seen to be unjustified) assumption that particle and antiparticle masses are equal in an expanding universe. However, to the extent that particle and antiparticle masses might differ in an expanding universe (even assuming that a useful notion of “particle mass” can be defined) as a result of the lack of a time reflection symmetry, it would probably not even be possible to define a notion of “thermal equilibrium” as a result of the lack of a time translation symmetry.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
117
6. Conclusions and Outlook In this paper we have proposed a new axiomatic framework for quantum field theory on curved spacetime. We demonstrated that our new framework captures much of the same content as the Wightman axioms by proving curved spacetime analogs of the spinstatistics theorem and PCT theorem. In this section, we discuss some of the implications and potential ramifications of the viewpoint suggested by this new framework. First, we address the issue of why we even seek an axiomatic framework for quantum field theory in curved spacetime at all. Since gravity is being treated classically, quantum field theory in curved spacetime cannot be a fundamental theory of nature, i.e., it must have a limited domain of validity. In particular, we have focused considerable attention in this paper on the OPE of quantum fields in curved spacetime, but the OPE is a statement about the arbitrarily-short-distance singularity structure of products of fields. One would not expect that quantum field theory in curved spacetime would give an accurate description of nature at separations smaller than, say, the Planck scale. Consequently, why should one seek a set of mathematically consistent rules governing quantum field theory that are rigorously applicable only in a regime where the theory is not expected to be valid? Our response to this question is that an exactly similar situation arises for classical field theory. Classical field theory also is not a fundamental theory of nature, and its description of nature makes essential use of differentiability/smoothness properties of the classical fields at short distance scales; one could not even write down the partial differential equations governing the evolution of classical fields without such short-distance-scale assumptions. However, if quantum field theory is any guide, the description of physical fields as smooth tensor fields is drastically wrong at short distance scales. Nevertheless, classical field theory has been found to give a very accurate description of nature within its domain of validity, and we have obtained a great deal of insight into nature by obtaining a mathematically precise formulation of classical field theory. It is our belief that there exists a mathematically consistent framework for quantum field theory in curved spacetime, and that by obtaining and studying this framework, we will not only get an accurate description of nature within the domain of validity of this theory, but we will also get important insights and clues concerning the nature of quantum gravity. We began our quest for the mathematical framework of quantum field theory in curved spacetime by seeking to generalize the Wightman axioms to curved spacetime in as conservative a manner as possible. As described much more fully in the Introduction, there are three key ingredients of the Wightman axioms that do not generalize straightforwardly to curved spacetime: (1) Poincaré invariance; (2) the spectrum condition; (3) existence of a Poincaré invariant state. We have seen in this paper that quantum field theory can be generalized to curved spacetime by replacing these ingredients by the following: (1’) quantum fields are locally and covariantly defined; (2’) the microlocal spectrum condition; (3’) existence of an OPE. Although the formulation of conditions (1’) and (2’) differs significantly from the formulation of conditions (1) and (2), the basic content of these conditions is essentially the same. Indeed, there would be no essential difference in the formulation of axiomatic quantum field theory in Minkowski spacetime if one replaced (1) and (2) with (1’) and (2’). By contrast, as we shall elucidate further below, the replacement of (3) by (3’) leads to a radically different viewpoint on quantum field theory. The most important aspect of this difference is that the existence of a “preferred state” no longer plays any role in the formulation of the theory. States are inherently
118
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
non-local in character, and the replacement of (3) by (3’)—along with the replacements of (1) with (1’) and (2) with (2’)—yields a formulation of quantum field theory that is entirely local in nature. In this way, the formulation of quantum field theory becomes much more analogous to the formulation of classical field theory. Indeed, one can view a classical field theory as being specified by providing the list of fields φ (i) occuring in the theory and the list of local, partial differential relations satisfied by these fields. Solutions to the classical field theory are then sections of the appropriate vector bundles that satisfy the partial differential relations as well as regularity conditions (e.g., smoothness). Similarly, in our framework, a quantum field theory is specified by providing the list of fields φ (i) occurring in the theory and the list of local, OPE relations satisfied by these fields. Thus, the OPE relations play a role completely analogous to the role of field equations in classical field theory. States—which are the analogs of solutions in classical field theory—are positive linear maps on the algebra A defined in Sect. 3 that satisfy the OPE relations as well as regularity conditions (in this case, the microlocal spectrum condition). We note that in classical field theory, the field equations always manifest all of the symmetries of the theory, even in cases where there are no solutions that manifest these symmetries. Similarly, in our formulation of quantum field theory, the OPE relations that define the theory should always respect the symmetries of the theory [30], even if no states happen to respect these symmetries. Our viewpoint on quantum field theory is more restrictive than standard viewpoints in that we require the existence of an OPE. On the other hand, it is less restrictive in that we do not require the existence of a ground state. This latter point is best illustrated by considering a free Klein-Gordon field ϕ in Minkowski spacetime (2 − m 2 )ϕ = 0,
(92)
where the mass term, m 2 , is allowed to be positive, zero, or negative. In the standard viewpoint, a quantum field theory of the free Klein-Gordon field does not exist in any dimension when m 2 < 0 and does not exist in D = 2 when m 2 = 0 on account of the non-existence of a Poincaré invariant state. However, there is no difficulty in specifying OPE relations that satisfy our axioms for all values of m 2 and all D ≥ 2. In particular, for D = 4 we can choose the OPE-coefficient C of the identity in the OPE of ϕ(x1 )ϕ(x2 ) to be given by C(x1 , x2 ; y) = 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 + m j[m x ] log[µ (x + i0t)] + m h[m x ] , (93) 4π 2 x 2 + i0t where x 2 = (x1 − x2 )2 and t = x10 − x20 . Here µ is an arbitrarily chosen mass scale and √ j (z) ≡ 2i 1√z J1 (i z) is an analytic function of z, where J1 denotes the Bessel function of order 1. Furthermore, h(z) is the analytic function defined by h(z) = −π
∞ k=0
[ψ(k + 1) + ψ(k + 2)]
(z/4)k , k!(k + 1)!
(94)
with ψ the psi-function. This formula for the OPE coefficient—as well as the corresponding formulas for all of the other OPE coefficients—is as well defined for negative m 2 as for positive m 2 . Existence of states satisfying all of the OPE relations for negative m 2 can be proven by the deformation argument of [12], using the fact that such states exist for positive m 2 .
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
119
Although, in our framework, the Klein-Gordon field with negative m 2 now joins the ranks of legitimate quantum field theories, this theory is not physically viable because, in all states, field quantities will grow exponentially in time14 . The potential importance of the above example is that it explicitly demonstrates that the local OPE coefficients can have a much more regular behavior under variations of the parameters of the theory as compared with state-dependent quantities, such as vacuum expectation values. The OPE coefficients in the above example are analytic in m 2 . On the other hand, the 2-point function of the global vacuum state is, of course, defined only for m 2 ≥ 0 and is given by 0|ϕ(x1 )ϕ(x2 )|0 = 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 + m j[m x ] log[m (x + i0t)] + m h[m x ] . (95) 4π 2 x 2 + i0t This behaves non-analytically in m 2 at m 2 = 0 on account of the log m 2 term. In other words, in free Klein-Gordon theory, vacuum expectation values cannot be constructed perturbatively by expanding about m 2 = 0—as should be expected, since no vacuum state exists for m 2 < 0—but there is no difficulty in perturbatively constructing the OPE coefficients by expanding about m 2 = 0. The above considerations raise the possibility that the well known failure of convergence of perturbation series in interacting quantum field theory may be due to the non-analytic dependence of states on the parameters of the theory, rather than any nonanalytic dependence of the fields themselves, i.e., that the OPE coefficients may vary analytically with the parameters of the theory. In other words, we are suggesting the possibility that the perturbation series for OPE coefficients may converge, and, thus, that, within our framework, it may be possible to perturbatively construct15 interacting quantum field theories. In order to do so, it will be necessary to define the basis fields φ (i) appropriately (see below and [18]) and also to parametrize the theory appropriately (since a theory with an analytic dependence on a parameter could always be made to appear non-analytic by a non-analytic reparametrization). Aside from the free Klein-Gordon example above, the only evidence we have in favor of convergence of perturbative expansions for OPE coefficients is the example of super-renormalizable theories, such as λϕ 4 -theory in two spacetime dimensions [17]. Here, only finitely many terms in a perturbative expansion can contribute to any OPE coefficient up to any given scaling degree, so convergence (up to any given scaling degree) is trivial. By contrast, for λϕ 4 -theory in two spacetime dimensions, the rigorously constructed, nonperturbative ground state n-point functions can be proven to be non-analytic at λ = 0 [25]. In cases—such as free Klein-Gordon theory above—where the OPE coefficients can be chosen to be analytic in the parameters of the theory, it seems natural to require that the theory be defined so that this analytic dependence holds. This requirement has some potentially major ramifications. Since vacuum expectation values of a product of fields (i.e., a correlation function) would be expected to have a non-analytic dependence on 14 In this respect, the quantum field of the Klein-Gordon field with negative m 2 behaves very similarly to the corresponding classical theory. The classical Klein-Gordon field with negative m 2 has a well posed initial value formulation and causal propagation (despite frequently expressed claims to the contrary). However, the classical Klein-Gordon field with negative m 2 is not physically viable since it is unstable, i.e., it admits solutions that grow exponentially with time. 15 However, we are not suggesting that it should be possible to perturbatively construct states of the theory. Even if one had the complete list of OPE coefficients, it would not be obvious how to construct states.
120
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
the parameters of the theory, it follows that if the OPE coefficients have an analytic dependence on these parameters, then, even in Minkowski spacetime, some of the fields appearing on the right side of the OPE of a product of fields must acquire a nonvanishing vacuum expectation value, at least for some values of the parameters. This point is well illustrated by the above Klein-Gordon example. It is natural to identify the next term in the OPE of ϕ(x1 )ϕ(x2 ) [i.e., the term beyond the identity term, whose coefficient is given by Eq. (93)] as being ϕ 2 (with unit coefficient), i.e., ϕ(x1 )ϕ(x2 ) ∼ C(x1 , x2 ; y)1 + ϕ 2 (y) + ... .
(96)
This corresponds to the usual “point-splitting” definition of ϕ 2 , except that C(x1 , x2 ; y) now replaces16 0|ϕ(x1 )ϕ(x2 )|0. If we take the vacuum expectation value of this formula (for m 2 ≥ 0, when a vacuum state exists) and compare it with Eq. (95), we obtain 0|ϕ 2 (y)|0 = −
m2 log(m 2 /µ2 ). 16π 2
(97)
Thus, we cannot set 0|ϕ 2 |0 = 0 for all values of m 2 . A similar calculation for the stress-energy tensor of ϕ yields 0|Tab (y)|0 =
m4 log(m 2 /µ2 )ηab . 64π 2
(98)
As in other approaches, the freedom to choose the arbitrary mass scale µ in Eq. (93) gives rise to a freedom to choose the value of the “cosmological constant term” in Eq. (98). However, unlike other approaches, there is no freedom to adjust the value of the cosmological constant when m 2 = 0 (i.e., we unambiguously obtain 0|Tab |0 = 0 in Minkowski spacetime in that case), and the m 2 -dependence of the cosmological constant is fixed (since µ is not allowed to depend upon m 2 ). A much more interesting possibility arises for interacting field theories, such as nonabelian gauge theories. In such theories, it is expected that there are “non-perturbative effects” that vary with the coupling parameter g as exp(−1/g 2 ). Such non-perturbative effects can potentially be very small compared with the natural scales appearing in the theory. If such non-perturbative terms occur the vacuum expectation values of products of fields and if—as we have speculated above—the OPE coefficients have an analytic dependence on the coupling parameter, then composite fields—such as the stress-energy tensor—must acquire nonvanishing vacuum expectation values that vary as exp(−1/g 2 ). This possibility appears worthy of further investigation. Acknowledgements. This research was supported in part by NSF Grant PHY04-56619 to the University of Chicago. 16 The point-split expression using 0|ϕ(x )ϕ(x )|0 yields the “normal ordered” quantity : ϕ 2 :. From the 1 2 point of view of quantum field theory in curved spacetime it is much more natural to define ϕ 2 via Eq. (96) than by normal ordering, since there is no generalization of normal ordering to curved spacetime that is compatible with a local and covariant definition of ϕ 2 [19]. Indeed, it follows from the results of [19] that Eq. (96) is the unique way to define ϕ 2 compatible with desired properties, with the only ambiguities in the definition of ϕ 2 arising from different allowed choices of C(x1 , x2 ; y). These correspond to a field redefinition of ϕ 2 by addition of a multiple of the identity.
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
121
A. Definition of the Scaling Degree and Wave Front Set of a Distribution In this Appendix, we recall the notion of scaling degree and of the wave front set of a distribution, which play an important role in the body of the paper. Quite generally, let u be a distribution on Rn . We say that u has scaling degree d at x = 0, if d is the smallest real number such that λδ u( f λ ) → 0 as λ → 0+, for all δ > d. Here, f λ (x) = λ−n f (λ−1 x) denotes the function of compact support that is obtained by rescaling a smooth test function f around x = 0, making it more and more sharply peaked at that point. The scaling degree at an arbitrary point is obtained by simply translating the distribution u or the test function f by the desired amount. We write sd x (u) = d for the scaling degree at a point x. We next recall the definition of the wave front set of a distribution u on Rn . Let χ be any smooth function of compact support. Then χ u is evidently a distribution of compact support, and its Fourier transform χ u(k) defines an entire function of k ∈ Rn . For any distribution v of compact support, we define its corresponding “singular set”, (v) as the collection of all k ∈ Rn such that | v (λk)| ≥ Cλ N ,
(99)
for some C > 0, and some N , and all λ > λ0 for some λ0 . We define the wave front set WF x (u) at a point x ∈ Rn as the intersection WF x (u) = (χ u), (100) χ :x∈supp χ
and we define WF(u) as the union WF(u) =
WF x (u).
(101)
x∈Rn
Each set WF x (u) is a conic set, in the sense that if k ∈ WF x (u), then so is tk for any t > 0, and k = 0 is never in WF x (u). It immediately follows from the definition that WF x (u) = ∅ if and only if u can be represented by a smooth function in an open neighborhood of x. In this sense, the wave-front set tells one at which points a distribution is singular. It also contains information about the most singular directions in local momentum space, which are represented by k ∈ WF x (u). It turns out that both the scaling degree of a distribution at a point x, as well as the wave front set at x are invariantly defined. By this one means the following. Let ρ : V → U be a smooth diffeomorphism between open sets U, V ⊂ Rn . Let u be a distribution supported in U , and let ρ ∗ u be the pulled back distribution in V , where the pull-back is defined by analogy with the pull back of a smooth function. Then it is easy to show that sd x (ρ ∗ u) = sdρ(x) (u). Furthermore, if x = ρ(x), and if we define ρ ∗ (x , k ) = (x, k), where k = [dρ(x)]v k , then one can show WF x (ρ ∗ u) = ρ ∗ WFρ(x) (u).
(102)
These relations imply that the scaling degree and the wave front set can be invariantly defined on an arbitrary manifold X , and that the wave-front set should be viewed as a subset of T ∗ X . In the body of the paper, we frequently consider the case X = M n+1 , and the scaling degree at the point (y, y, . . . , y), i.e., points on the total diagonal. To save writing, this is simply denoted sd u.
122
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
B. Equivalent Formulation of Condition (C6) In this Appendix, we relate the scaling degree (C5) and asymptotic positivity (C6) assumptions to other properties of the quantum field theory. The first is essentially just a repetition of a result obtained in [8]: Theorem 4. For any x ∈ M, and any (scalar) field T not equal to a multiple of the identity operator, we define the convex set Sx ⊂ R by Sx = {T (x) | a normalized state}
(103)
Then, Sx = R for at least one spacetime M. Remarks. The statement means that pointlike hermitian fields T (x) are unbounded from above and below, even though their classical counterpart (if the theory has a classical limit) might be manifestly non-negative, such as the Wick square T = ϕ 2 , or the energy density T = Tab u a u b of a free Klein-Gordon field ϕ. Proof. Choose any state . We may assume that T ( f ) = 0, because if not, we just need to replace T (x) by T (x) − T (x) 1. Also, we may assume without loss of generality that T ∗ = T , for otherwise we can just pass to the hermitian and anti-hermitian parts of T . Define A = cos α 1 + sin α
T( f ) 1/2
T ( f )T ( f )
,
(104)
for a real testfunction f , and define a new normalized state by .α = A . A∗ . Then T ( f )α = a sin 2α + b(1 − cos 2α),
(105)
where 1/2
a = T ( f )T ( f ) , b =
1 T ( f )T ( f )T ( f ) . 2 T ( f )T ( f )
Minimizing over α gives inf T ( f ) ≤ b −
a 2 + b2 .
Replacing f by − f also gives sup T ( f ) ≥ −b +
a 2 + b2 .
(106)
(107)
(108)
Now, consider a test function f with f dµ = 1, f (x) = 0, and let f λ (y) = λ−D f (x + λ−1 (y − x)), λ > 0. By Lemma 2, there exists a spacetime, a choice of f , and a state such that |T ( f λ )T ( f λ ) | ≥ c−1 λ−2d+2δ for some c > 0, sufficiently small δ > 0, and all λ < λ0 . d > 0 is the dimension of the field T . Also, combining the operator product expansion and the scaling degree axiom (C5), we have |T ( f λ )T ( f λ )T ( f λ ) | ≤ cλ−3d−δ , for all λ < λ0 . Combining these inequalities gives |T ( f λ )T ( f λ ) |3/2 ≥ c−2 λ4δ |T ( f λ )T ( f λ )T ( f λ ) | for all λ < λ0 .
(109)
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
123
We now consider two cases: (a) there exists a sequence λn → 0 such that |an /bn | ≥ ε > 0 for some ε and all n, where an , bn are defined using the rescaled testfunctions f n ≡ f λn . Then, as an → +∞, it follows immediately from Eq. (107) that inf T ( f n ) becomes arbitrarily small as n → ∞. It similarly follows from Eq. (108) that sup T ( f n ) becomes arbitrarily large as n → ∞. (b) |an /bn | → 0 for each sequence λn → 0. Then |bn | → ∞, and we may in fact assume that bn → +∞, for otherwise the statement follows immediately from Eqs. (107), (108). From the above inequality have an /bn ≥ c−2 λ4δ n for sufficiently large n. It follows that √ (109), we then 1 (using 1 + x ≥ 1 + 2+ε x for sufficiently small x ≥ 0) bn −
an2 + bn2 ≤ −
1 an2 1 1 ≤− λ4δ λ6δ−2d , (110) n an ≤ − 2 2 + ε bn (2 + ε)c (2 + ε)c3 n
for sufficiently large n. We can choose δ < 3d/2. Then the right side tends to −∞, and we conclude that inf T ( f n ) becomes arbitrarily small as n → ∞. It similarly follows that sup T ( f n ) becomes arbitrarily large as n → ∞. Our next result is in some sense a converse to the above result: Theorem 5. Let the set Sx be equal to R for a given spacetime M, and all hermitian operators T not equal to a multiple of the identity. Then for any i, k ∈ I with i = 1, and any sections v(i) of V (i) we have that
(k)(k ) (k)(k ) (v(k) ⊗ v¯(k ) )] < sd[C(1) (v(k) ⊗ v¯(k ) )]. sd[C(i)
(111)
Remarks. In generic spacetimes, we expect that the scaling degree of the right side is equal to 2dim(k), where dim(k) is the dimension of the field φ (k) ; see the scaling degree axiom (C5). We also expect the quantity on the left side to be equal to 2dim(k) − dim(i); see again (C5). Thus, the result tells us that, in this situation, dim(i) > 0 unless φ (i) is the identity field. Thus, in this sense, the assumption of the theorem implies the asymptotic positivity axiom (C6), or—stated differently—the asymptotic positivity axiom is inconsistent with not having Sx = R. Proof. By assumption, we can find a state such that T (x) > A for each A ∈ R. Consider an arbitrary, but fixed, finite collection φ (1) , . . . , φ (n) of fields. Each field is valued in some vector bundle V (i). The set of expectation values of this collection of fields forms a subset which we denote
! n
(1) (n)
K x = (φ (x) , . . . , φ (x) ) states ⊂ V (i)x =: Vx . (112) i=1
Because the set of states is convex (i.e., any convex linear combination of normalized states is again a normalized state), the set K x is a convex subset of Vx . We claim that, in fact, K x = Vx . Assume that this were not the case. Then, since any proper convex subset of a finite dimensional vector space can be enclosed by a collection of planes, there exists a collection of dual vectors c(i) ∈ V (i)v and an A ∈ R such that c(i) v (i) < A, for all (v (1) , . . . , v (n) ) ∈ K x . (113) Re (i)
However, this would mean by definition that if T = Re for all states , a contradiction.
c(i) φ (i) , then T (x) < A
124
S. Hollands, R. M. Wald
Assume that the statement of the theorem is not true. Let i = 1, . . . , n ∈ I be the field labels, with i = 1 for which the inequality (111) does not hold. From what we have just shown, if we define K x as above, then K x is equal to Vx . In particular, we may find states , , and nonzero v (i) with the property that φ (i) (x) = v (i) , φ (i) (x) = −v (i) .
(114)
Let f λ (x) = λ−D f (y + λ−1 (x − y)) be a test section in the dual of the space V (k), and let δ be a real number which is bigger than 2dim(k), but smaller than the left side of Eq. (111). Using the fact that φ (k) ( f λ )φ (k ) ( f¯λ ) ≥ 0 for all λ, we find from the operator product expansion that (k )(k) λδ C(i) ( f¯λ , f λ ; x)v (i) → +∞, (115) (i)
for at least one f and a subsequence of λ tending to 0. Applying a similar argument to the state gives that (k )(k) − λδ C(i) ( f¯λ , f λ ; x)v (i) → +∞, (116) (i)
for this subsequence of λ tending to 0. This is a contradiction, so the inequality (111) must hold.
References 1. Axelrod, S., Singer, I.M.: Chern-Simons perturbation theory. 2. J. Diff. Geom. 39, 173 (1994) 2. Borcherds, R.E.: Vertex algebras, Kac-Moody algebras, and the monster. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 83, 3068 (1986) 3. Bostelmann, H.: Operator product expansions as a consequence of phase space properties. J. Math. Phys. 46, 082304 (2005) 4. Bostelmann, H.: Phase space properties and the short distance structure in quantum field theory. J. Math. Phys. 46, 052301 (2005) 5. Brunetti, R., Fredenhagen, K., Köhler, M.: The microlocal spectrum condition and Wick polynomials on curved spacetimes. Commun. Math. Phys. 180, 633–652 (1996) 6. Brunetti, R., Fredenhagen, K.: Microlocal analysis and interacting quantum field theories: renormalization on physical backgrounds. Commun. Math. Phys. 208, 623–661 (2000) 7. Brunetti, R., Fredenhagen, K., Verch, R.: The generally covariant locality principle: A new paradigm for local quantum physics. Commun. Math. Phys. 237, 31 (2003); see also K. Fredenhagen,: Locally covariant quantum field theory. In: Proc. Int. Conf., Math. Phys. (Lisbon, Portugal, 2003), Singapore, World Scientific, 2005 8. Fewster, C.J.: Energy Inequalities in Quantum Field Theory. Proceedings of XIVth International Congress on Mathematical Physics, ed. J.-C. Zambrini, Singapore: World Scientific, 2005, p. 559 9. Fredenhagen, K.: Locally Covariant Quantum Field Theory. Proceedings of XIVth International Congress on Mathematical Physics, ed. J.-C. Zambrini, Singapore: Worl Scientific, 2003, p. 29 10. Fredenhagen, K., Hertel, J.: Local Algebras Of Observables And Point - Like Localized Fields. Commun. Math. Phys. 80, 555 (1981); Fredenhagen, K., Jorss, M.: Conformal Haag-Kastler nets, point - like localized fields and the existence of operator product expansions. Commun. Math. Phys. 176, 541 (1996) 11. Frenkel, I., Lepowsky, J., Meurman, A.: Vertex Operator Algebras and the Monster. Boston: Academic Press, 1988 12. Fulling, S.A., Narcowich, F.J., Wald, R.M.: Singularity structure of the two-point function in quantum field theory in curved spacetime, II. Ann. Phys. 136, 243 (1981) 13. Fulton, W., MacPherson, R.: A compactification of configuration spaces. Ann. Math. 139, 183 (1994) 14. Haag, R., Kastler, D.: An algebraic approach to quantum field theory. J. Math. Phys. 5, 848 (1964)
Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime
125
15. Hollands, S.: The operator product expansion for perturbative quantum field theory in curved spacetime. Commun. Math. Phys. 273, 1 (2007) 16. Hollands, S.: A general PCT theorem for the operator product expansion in curved spacetime. Commun. Math. Phys. 244, 209 (2004) 17. Hollands, S., Kopper, C.: In progress 18. Hollands, S., Wald, R.M.: In progress 19. Hollands, S., Wald, R.M.: Local wick polynomials and time ordered products of quantum fields in curved space. Commun. Math. Phys. 223, 289–326 (2001) 20. Hollands, S., Wald, R.M.: Existence of local covariant time-ordered-products of quantum fields in curved spacetime. Commun. Math. Phys. 231, 309–345 (2002) 21. Hollands, S.: Quantum field theory in terms of consistency conditions I: General framework, and perturbation theory via Hochschild cohomology. http://arxiv.org/abs/0802.2198v2[hep-th], 2008 22. Hörmander, L.: The Analysis of Linear Partial Differential Operators I. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1983 23. Kac, V.: Vertex Algebras for Beginners. Univ. Lect. Series 10, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1996 24. Radzikowski, M.J.: Micro-local approach to the Hadamard condition in quantum field theory on curved space-time. Commun. Math. Phys. 179, 529 (1996) 25. Rivasseau, V.: From Perturbative to Constructive Renormalization. Princeton Series in Physics, Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Pr., 1991 26. Schroer, B., Swieca, J.A., Volkel, A.H.: Global operator expansions in conformally invariant relativistic quantum field theory. Phys. Rev. D 11, 1509 (1975) 27. Streater, R.F., Wightman, A.A.: PCT, Spin and Statistics and All That. New York: Benjamin, 1964 28. Wald, R.M.: Quantum Field Theory on Curved Spacetimes and Black Hole Thermodynamics. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press, 1990 29. Wilson, K.G.: Nonlagrangian models of current algebra. Phys. Rev. 179, 1499 (1969) 30. Bernard, C., Duncan, A., LoSecco, J., Weinberg, S.: Exact spectral-function sum rules. Phys. Rev. D 12, 792–804 (1975), See the Appendix 31. Zimmermann, W.: Normal Products And The Short Distance Expansion In The Perturbation Theory Of Renormalizable Interactions. Annals Phys. 77, 570 (1973); seealso, Lect. Notes Phys. 558, Berlin Heidelberg-NewYork: Springer, 2008, p. 278 Communicated by G. W. Gibbons
Commun. Math. Phys. 293, 127–143 (2010) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-009-0927-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Focusing Components in Typical Chaotic Billiards Should be Absolutely Focusing Leonid A. Bunimovich1,2 , Alexander Grigo2 1 ABC Math Program, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, U.S.A 2 School of Mathematics, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, U.S.A.
E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] Received: 9 June 2008 / Accepted: 17 November 2008 Published online: 27 September 2009 – © Springer-Verlag 2009
Abstract: We demonstrate that the defocusing mechanism fails to work if not all focusing components of the boundary are absolutely focusing. More precisely, we construct billiard tables with arbitrary long free path away from a non-absolutely focusing component such that a nonlinearly stable periodic orbit exists. Therefore the only known standard procedure of constructing chaotic ergodic billiards works in general only if all focusing boundary components are absolutely focusing. 1. Introduction and Statement of the Main Results The foundation of the theory of hyperbolic systems with singularities was laid in Sinai’s seminal paper [20] where hyperbolicity and ergodicity for billiards with smooth dispersing boundary was proven. The situation changes drastically if a billiard table has at least one focusing component. Billiards with focusing boundaries demonstrate behaviors from completely regular to strongly chaotic. In fact, Lazutkin proved in [16,17] that for any strictly convex billiard table with smooth enough boundary there exist caustics near the boundary, which prevent global ergodicity and hyperbolicity. However, certain classes of hyperbolic and ergodic billiards with focusing boundary components were found in [3,4]. The mechanism behind this is called the mechanism of defocusing. It relies on the fact that a focusing beam will eventually go through a conjugate point, and will be dispersing afterwards. Therefore, if the free path to the next reflection is sufficiently large an essentially analogous situation to the case of dispersing billiard tables arises. This method of placing focusing boundary components sufficiently far away from other boundary components is the only known general procedure of constructing hyperbolic billiard tables, [21]. Therefore, after the discovery of the mechanism of defocusing the question of which focusing components could be components of the boundary of a chaotic (hyperbolic) billiard was raised. Two dual classes of such focusing components were introduced in
128
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
[21 and 18]. Then a much more general class of focusing components, admissible for chaotic billiard tables, was introduced [5–7 and 14]. (Formally the class of focusing components introduced in [14] seems to be more restrictive than the one in [6]. However, these two classes coincide [7].) These focusing components are called absolutely focusing, and were shown in [8,12] to allow for hyperbolicity and ergodicity. It was conjectured in [6] that in hyperbolic billiards each focusing component of the boundary must be absolutely focusing, and it was outlined there how one can construct a stable periodic orbit if at least one focusing component is not absolutely focusing. In this paper we show along the lines described in [6,8] that as soon as the absolutely focusing property of focusing boundary components fails to hold the general procedure of designing chaotic billiard tables generally fails. Even if one makes the free path after a reflection from a non-absolutely focusing component arbitrarily large, then such billiards can still have elliptic periodic points. Thus these billiards have islands of stability and are not completely hyperbolic. These results, once again, indicate that the mechanism of defocusing plays a key role in generic Hamiltonian systems which demonstrate the coexistence of islands of stability (KAM-islands) and chaotic hyperbolic components. The main result of this paper is the following: Theorem 1. Let Γ be a C 5 non-absolutely focusing curve of minimal length which encloses an angle of no more than π , or a small enough extension of such a curve. Then for every L > 0 there exist an open set (in the sense of C 5 ) of billiard tables Q(L , Γ ), Γ ⊂ ∂ Q(L , Γ ), which all have a nonlinearly stable periodic orbit with free path of length at least L before and after a sequence of consecutive reflections off of Γ . The C 5 (C k ) closeness of two billiard tables simply means that there are parametrizations of their respective boundaries, which are piecewise C 5 (C k ) and are piecewise close in the C 5 (C k ) sense as functions from [0, 1] → R2 . Remark 1. We would like to mention at this point that the corresponding result for a linearly stable, non-resonant periodic orbit can be proved when assuming only C 3 –smoothness, cf. Theorem 2 below. This is the usual assumption in the theory of hyperbolic billiards, which deals with the first derivative of the billiard map (or flow) only. To deduce nonlinear stability, however, we need, for technical reasons, to assume C 5 smoothness to be able to apply KAM theory (Moser’s twist theorem [19]), because it takes higher order derivatives of the billiard map into account. Dynamics on KAM-islands is characterized by a balance between focusing (convergence of nearby orbits) and defocusing (their divergence) while on chaotic components defocusing dominates focusing. Recall that dispersing is just a special case of defocusing (when the focusing time is negative) and neutral components of the boundary cannot generate by themselves a chaotic behavior [2]. Therefore, our results show that apparently there are no other mechanisms of hyperbolicity in billiards besides dispersing and defocusing. If both dispersing and focusing components are present, then they should be arranged in such a way that any initially parallel (infinitesimal) beam of rays in the course of its dynamics arrives at any curved (dispersing or focusing) component of the boundary being dispersing. Then dispersing either takes over focusing, which occurs in the part of phase space where hyperbolicity emerges, or these two are balanced, [9,10]. This happens on the part with regular dynamics (KAM-island). Thus defocusing is a fundamental mechanism of hyperbolicity (at least in billiards) and its violation leads to the creation of KAM-islands.
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
129
The structure of the paper is the following. In Sect. 2 we will review some basic properties of billiards. The construction of a linearly stable periodic orbit with a series of consecutive reflections off non-absolutely focusing components is described in Sect. 3. The nonlinear stability is first established for a very general setting in Sect. 4 and then applied in Sect. 5 to the linearly stable orbit constructed before, which will prove our main result Theorem 1. 2. Basic Facts about Billiards In this section the basic properties of billiards we will need are described. The notation used is chosen close to the one used in [11], which contains most of the results listed below. Let Q ⊂ R2 denote an open bounded domain with piecewise C 3 boundary ∂ Q. The dynamics generated by a point-like particle moving along straight lines inside Q and having specular reflections off the boundary ∂ Q is called billiard flow Φ t on the billiard table Q. The induced first return map F to the boundary ∂ Q, where only the state right after the reflection is considered, is called the associated billiard map. These constructions yield Φ t : Q × S 1 → Q × S 1 and F : ∂ Q × [−π/2, π/2] → ∂ Q × [−π/2, π/2], which are defined almost everywhere with respect to the Lebesgue measure. The natural coordinates for the billiard map are the arc length parameter s along the boundary, which we will assume to be oriented in the counterclockwise direction, and the angle of reflection ϕ relative to the normal direction. For the billiard flow the natural coordinates are the angle ω giving the direction of the velocity vector relative to the horizontal direction, and (x, y) denoting the position inside of Q. It is well known that the billiard map preserves the measure dµ = cos ϕ dϕ ds and that dν = dω d x d y is preserved by the billiard flow. (Indeed, even the volume forms are preserved.) In particular, the billiard map is symplectic in the coordinates (s, sin ϕ). When working with the billiard flow it is often more convenient to use the so called Jacobi coordinates (η, ξ, ω), which in infinitesimal form read dη = cos ω d x + sin ω dy and dξ = − sin ω d x + cos ω dy . The derivative of Φ t then becomes ∂(ξ t , ωt ) 1 0 t with Ut = and det Ut = 1, DΦ = 0 Ut ∂(ξ, ω) since η measures the distance in direction of the flow. We will refer to Ut as the reduced Jacobian of Φ t . Throughout the paper we denote by K = K(s) the (signed) curvature of the boundary at the point corresponding to the arc length parameter s. The sign of K is chosen such that it is negative for convex shaped boundary components, as in the case of a billiard inside a circle. Correspondingly, we shall call boundary components for which K < 0, K = 0, K > 0 focusing, neutral, dispersing, respectively. The derivative of the billiard map is given by 1 τ K + cos ϕ τ DF(s, ϕ) = − , cos ϕ1 τ K K1 + K cos ϕ1 + K1 cos ϕ τ K1 + cos ϕ1
130
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
where we set (s1 , ϕ1 ) = F(s, ϕ) and τ the distance (free path) between the two points along the straight line connecting them. In particular, the billiard map is of class C k−1 if the boundary components are of class C k . Another well known fact is that the (local) generating function of the billiard dynamics is (locally) given by the Euclidean distance along the straight line segments connecting the points of reflection. More precisely, consider a point (s0 , ϕ0 ) such that (sk , ϕk ):=F k (s0 , ϕ0 ) is well defined for 0 ≤ k ≤ n. Denote by Γi the boundary component on which the i th reflection occurs (i.e. on which (si , ϕi ) lies), so that Γi (si ) is the point of the i th reflection in the plane. Then L(s0 , . . . , sn ):=
n
Γi (si ) − Γi−1 (si−1 )
i=1
is the Euclidean length of the corresponding trajectory of the billiard flow, and ∂s0 L = − sin ϕ0 ,
∂si L = 0 for 1 ≤ i ≤ n − 1 ,
∂sn L = sin ϕn
hold, which is why L is the generating function (cf. Sects. 47 and 48 in [1] for details on generating functions). An important quantity to describe the billiard flow is the wavefront curvature B:=dω/ dξ , which obeys 1 1 = + t for a free flight of length t, Bt B0 2K at a point of reflection. B + = B − + R with R:= cos ϕ In geometric optics the second relation is called the mirror formula. In particular we have ct + dt B0 at bt Bt = for Ut = ct dt at + bt B0 which relates the wavefront curvature and the derivative of the flow. For a segment of a billiard trajectory γ we denote the wavefront curvature of an initially parallel beam of rays sent along γ by c a b , (1) with U (γ ) = Bout (γ ):= c d a where U (γ ) is the reduced Jacobian of the billiard flow along γ . 3. Construction of Linearly Stable Periodic Orbits In this section let Γ be a (focusing) C 3 curve of length l > 0, parametrized by its arc length. Definition 1 (Absolutely Focusing; see [5,6]). A closed, focusing component Γ is called absolutely focusing if every incoming infinitesimal beam of parallel rays leaves Γ , after a complete sequence of consecutive reflections, as a focusing beam.
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
131
Fig. 1. Illustration of the family of trajectories constructed in Lemma 1
It was shown in [7,8,12,14] that the defocusing mechanism applies to focusing boundary components which are absolutely focusing. Furthermore, it was also shown in [14] that every short enough piece of a focusing curve is absolutely focusing. This, in particular, motivates the following notion to characterize the transition between absolutely and non-absolutely focusing curves. Definition 2 (Non-Absolutely Focusing of Minimal Length). A focusing curve Γ is called non-absolutely focusing of minimal length, if every of its closed sub-arcs is absolutely focusing, but the curve itself is not absolutely focusing. Our approach is based on the one outlined in [6]. The first step is to show that for a non-absolutely focusing curve there exists an infinitesimal beam of parallel rays falling onto Γ which leaves Γ after its last reflection as arbitrary weakly focusing. In the second step such a beam is used to construct a stable periodic orbit. It is well known that the billiard map satisfies the so-called twist property ds1 /dϕ < 0, no matter which type of boundary components are considered. It is also well known that compositions of twist maps, and iterates of a twist map, are in general no longer twist maps. However, it was observed in [14] (Prop. 3.6) that when restricting the billiard map to absolutely focusing boundary components, then its iterates will still be twist maps. This property is the main technical step in the following key lemma, whose result is illustrated in Fig. 1. Lemma 1. Let Γ be a C k (k ≥ 3) non-absolutely focusing curve of minimal length enclosing an angle of no more than π , and let γ be a part of a billiard trajectory with N consecutive reflections off of Γ (possibly off its endpoints). Then there exists a family of trajectories (γ ) ≥0 with a C k−1 dependence on , such that γ0 = γ , and for all > 0 the trajectory γ has a sequence of N consecutive reflections off of Γ with no reflections off its endpoints. Proof. If all reflections of γ off of Γ are already in the interior of Γ , just set γ ≡ γ , so that we only consider such a γ with at least one reflection off of an endpoint of Γ in the following. If N = 1, then denote by γ the trajectory obtained by moving the point of reflection of γ by into the interior of Γ , while, say, keeping the angle of reflection constant. For N = 2, denote by γ the trajectory obtained by moving both points of reflection of γ by into the interior. The corresponding angles of reflection are then determined by the location of the new points of reflection. It remains to consider the case N ≥ 3. Since Γ does not enclose an angle of more than π , there are no back reflections possible. Hence the second point of reflection must be in the interior of Γ . Furthermore, by assumption on Γ , the sub-arc on which the 2nd up to the N th reflection take place is absolutely focusing.
132
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
To construct γ proceed as shown in Fig. 1. Increase the (absolute value of the) angle of reflection ϕ2 by . Then Proposition 3.6 in [14] shows that the i th reflection points, 3 ≤ i ≤ N , all move closer to the second one. And since the billiard map is of class C k−1 , the implicit function theorem asserts in this case that the dependence of new points of reflection on is C k−1 . Since the location of the second reflection does not change, the general twist property applied to the first reflection point shows that it also moves towards the second reflection point. Therefore the family of rays γ depends C k−1 –smooth on , and γ for > 0 has reflections only off the interior of Γ , as desired. Remark 2. Although the result of Lemma 1 seems entirely obvious, especially when looking at Fig. 1, this is not so. In fact, this is the only point in this paper where the restriction to curves enclosing an angle of no more than π comes in. The reason is that, in general, changing the angle of incidence (at some point of reflection) in either direction may not move all points of reflection into the interior of Γ , as stated in Lemma 1, because of possibly existing back-reflections. This makes the argument in the construction of the family of orbits of Lemma 1 fail in general when applying it to curves enclosing an angle of more than π . However, there are certainly situations where the result of Lemma 1 is true for such curves as well, e.g. for extensions to a curve enclosing an angle of more than π which do not destroy the constructed family of orbits. It was conjectured in [6] that for any non-absolutely focusing curve Γ there exists an infinitesimal beam of parallel rays falling onto Γ and leaving it as parallel beam. The next statement proves this claim in a slightly more restricted setting. Proposition 1. Let the C k (k ≥ 3) curve Γ be a small enough extension of a nonabsolutely focusing curve of minimal length, which encloses an angle of no more than π . Then there exists a family of rays (γ ) ≥0 , depending C k−1 –smoothly on , such that they all have the same number of reflections off of Γ , and a parallel beam sent along γ leaves Γ as a focusing one (parallel one) if > 0 ( = 0). Proof. Consider first the case where Γ is non-absolutely focusing of minimal length, enclosing an angle of no more than π . Then, by definition, there exists an incoming infinitesimal beam of parallel rays, say γ0 , which leaves Γ after a sequence of consecutive reflections as either a parallel or dispersing beam. By Lemma 1 there is a C k−1 –smooth family (γ ) ≥0 such that for any > 0, the ray γ has reflections off the interior of Γ only. Since any sub-arc of Γ is absolutely focusing, a parallel incoming beam sent along γ must leave as a focusing one. Hence the continuous dependence on shows that the parallel incoming beam along γ0 must leave as a parallel one, and the family (γ ) is as desired. Clearly, the constructed family (γ ) ≥0 is not destroyed if we allow for small enough extension of Γ , hence the above construction carries over to this more general case. In order to construct a linearly stable periodic orbit it is more convenient to work with the billiard flow, rather than the billiard map. Later on we will see that this changes when we want to establish nonlinear stability. The next statement shows that if a curve Γ is non-absolutely focusing, then, regardless of how large the free paths before and after a series of consecutive reflections off
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
133
of Γ are, a linearly stable periodic orbit can exist. To establish later nonlinear stability we need this (linearly stable) periodic orbit to be non-resonant, that means that the eigenvalues λ = e±i α of the corresponding monodromy matrix satisfy λ2 , λ3 , λ4 = 1. Theorem 2. Let Γ be a C 3 non-absolutely focusing curve of minimal length which encloses an angle of no more than π , or a small enough extension of such a curve. Then for every L > 0 there exists a billiard table Q(L , Γ ) with Γ as a focusing boundary component which has a linearly stable, non-resonant periodic orbit γ with free path of length at least L before and after a sequence of consecutive reflections off of Γ . Proof. Let (γ ) ≥0 be as in Proposition 1. From (1) we conclude that the reduced Jacobian U along γ must read U11 + a U = c
U12 + b 1 U11 + d
with a , b , c , d = o(1) as 0 .
The values of U11 and U12 satisfy U12 c + b c = U11 d +
a + a d U11
because det U = 1. Since Bout (γ ) < 0 for all > 0 holds, we must have c < 0 hence c sgn U11 < 0 U11 + a for all small enough. Let L > 0 be arbitrary, and consider τ with τ > 6 (L + |Γ |) whose value will be chosen in the following. For every > 0 we can close up γ to a periodic orbit γ˜ using three plane mirrors such that the length of the free path before and after the sequence of reflections off of Γ is at least L, and the total length of the orbit away from Γ is τ . This is illustrated in Fig. 2. The monodromy matrix M along γ˜ then reads M = −U
1 0
U11 + a τ =− c 1
U12 + b + τ U11 + τ a , 1 U11 + d + τ c
where the minus sign is due to the three reflections at the plane mirrors. In particular, the trace of M is − tr M = U11 + a +
1 + d + τ c U11
134
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
Fig. 2. Construction of the periodic orbit using plane mirrors such that the resulting orbit has free paths before and after hitting Γ of length at least L
so that − sgn U11 tr M = |U11 | +
1 |U11 |
− τ |c | + (a + d ) sgn U11
holds for all > 0, where we used c sgn U11 < 0. Now let ∗ be so small that the relations 2 3
|U11 | +
1 |U11 |
1 3 ≤ |U11 | + + (a ∗ + d ∗ ) sgn U11 ≤ |U11 | 2
|U11 | +
1 |U11 |
and |c ∗ | 6 (L + |Γ |) <
3 2
|U11 | +
1 |U11 |
−2
hold. By choosing τ∗ now such that 3 2
|U11 | +
1 |U11 |
− 2 < τ∗ |c ∗ | <
2 3
|U11 | +
1 |U11 |
− 1,
we have 1 < − sgn U11 tr M ∗ < 2 and τ∗ > 6 (L + |Γ |). And by varying τ∗ slightly we can ensure that the two complex eigenvalues λ = e±iα of M ∗ satisfy the non-resonance condition λ2 , λ3 , λ4 = 1. Therefore closing the orbit γ ∗ up to form a periodic orbit using three plane mirrors as shown in Fig. 2 with a total length away from Γ equal to τ∗ yields a linearly stable orbit with free path of length at least L before and after reflections off of Γ . Making the three plane mirrors now slightly dispersing C 3 curves, without changing the position of and tangent at the reflection points, preserves the periodic orbit, its linear stability, and its non-resonant property. Completing the billiard table in any way by not destroying the constructed periodic orbit finishes the proof.
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
135
4. An Auxiliary Stability Result To study the nonlinear stability of a linearly stable fixed point of a planar area-preserving mapping T one can use the so-called Birkhoff normal form. This approach was developed by Kolmogorov, Arnold and Moser and is usually referred to as KAM theory. The first step in this approach is finding the explicit form of the normal form, which is given in the following lemma. Lemma 2 ([13,15]). Let T (s, y) be an area-preserving C 4 mapping with an elliptic fixed point at the origin a s + a01 y + a20 s 2 + a11 s y + · · · + a03 y 3 + O4 (s, y), T (s, y) = 10 b10 s + b01 y + b20 s 2 + b11 s y + · · · + b03 y 3 and let λ = e±iα denote the complex eigenvalues of DT (0, 0). If λ2 , λ3 , λ4 = 1, then there exists a real-analytic canonical change of coordinates taking T into its Birkhoff 2 normal form z → λ z ei A |z| + O(|z|4 ) The first Birkhoff coefficient A reads sin α 2 cos α − 1 2 2 3 |c20 | + |c02 | , A = Im c21 + cos α − 1 2 cos α + 1 where
1 b10 a03 a01 b30 Im c21 = a10 −a21 + 3 −3 + b12 8 a01 b10 1 a01 a30 a01 b21 − b10 a12 − 3 − + 3 b03 8 b10 b10 2 2 b 1 a 1 b10 a01 01 10 2 |c20 | = − a02 + a20 + b11 + − b20 + b02 + a11 16 b10 a01 16 a01 b10 2 2 1 a01 b10 1 b10 a01 2 |c02 | = − a02 + a20 − b11 + − b20 + b02 − a11 16 b10 a01 16 a01 b10
are given in terms of the ai j and bi j . Theorem 2.13 in [19] shows that a nonzero Birkhoff coefficient A implies nonlinear (Lyapunov) stability. However, since we will be considering maps without knowing too many of their details, we cannot immediately make use of Lemma 2 to compute A directly. Therefore we seek a sufficient condition that allows us to conclude that A is nonzero. And since the actual formula for A is quite involved, it is much easier to try to find a map with non-vanishing Birkhoff coefficient among a continuous family of maps. In the rest of this section we will consider the following setting. Let s∗ ∈ R be a point and U ⊂ R a neighborhood of s∗ . For 0 > 0, consider a family of C 5 functions L : U × U → R2 for | | < 0 which satisfy s 4 + s14 + O5 (s, s1 ) and ∂s ∂s1 L 0 (0, 0) = 0 ∂ =0 L (s, s1 ) = C 24
(2)
136
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
for some C = 0. Denote the family of area-preserving maps generated by L by T (see Sects. 47 and 48 of [1] for details of this construction) which we will write in coordinate form as T (s, y) ≡ (S (s, y), Y (s, y)) . Assume further that the map T0 has an elliptic fixed point (s∗ , y∗ ), T (s∗ , y∗ ) = (s∗ , y∗ ) with y∗ :=∂s1 L 0 (s∗ , s∗ ) = −∂s L 0 (s∗ , s∗ ), and denote the eigenvalues of DT0 (s∗ , y∗ ) by λ = e±iα . We will assume that the nonresonance conditions λ2 , λ3 , λ4 = 1 hold for the elliptic fixed point of T0 . Let us set j
L i j :=∂si ∂s1 L 0 (s∗ , s∗ ) to simplify the notations. Proposition 2. The derivative of T0 at the fixed point (s∗ , y∗ ) reads 1 1 L 20 DT0 (s∗ , y∗ ) = − , L 11 L 20 L 02 − L 211 L 02 and the family of maps T satisfies ⎞ ⎛ 1 3 s 1 L 11 ∂ =0 T (s + s∗ , y + y∗ ) = −C ⎝ L 02 3 L 20 s+y 3 ⎠ + O4 (s, y) 6 L s + L 11 11 for s and y in a neighborhood of zero. Proof. The definition of the maps T (s, y) ≡ (S (s, y), Y (s, y)) in terms of the generating function L , ∂s L (s, S (s, y)) = −y and ∂s1 L (s, S (s, y)) = Y (s, y),
(3)
immediately shows 1 DT0 (s∗ , y∗ ) = − L 11
L 20 L 20 L 02 − L 211
1 L 02
for the derivative of T0 at the fixed point (s∗ , y∗ ). Differentiating Eqs. (3) with respect to , and evaluating at = 0 yields [s − s∗ ]3 + ∂s ∂s1 L 0 (s, S0 (s, y)) ∂ =0 S (s, y) 6 +O4 (s − s∗ , y − y∗ ), [S0 (s, y) − s∗ ]3 + ∂s21 L 0 (s, S0 (s, y)) ∂ =0 S (s, y) ∂ =0 Y (s, y) = C 6 +O4 (s − s∗ , y − y∗ ), 0=C
(4)
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
137
where we used the special property of the generating functions stated in Eq. (2). Solving now for the -derivatives of S and Y we obtain ∂ =0 S (s + s∗ , y + y∗ ) = −C
s3 + O4 (s, y), 6 L 11 1 L 20 s + y 3 L 02 s 3 ∂ =0 Y (s + s∗ , y + y∗ ) = −C −C + O4 (s, y) 6 L 11 6 L 11 by Taylor-expansion and (4).
The point of the specific form of the generating functions (2) is now clear. By Proposition 2 the change of the map to first order in is of third order in (s, y). Comparing this to the general form of the Birkhoff coefficients A , as given in Lemma 2, we see that ∂ | =0 A only involves the third order term Im c21 . This we can further exploit to obtain the main result of this section, which is the following Theorem 3. Let (s∗ , y∗ ) be a non-resonant elliptic fixed point of a family of planar area-preserving maps T which are generated in a neighborhood of (s∗ , y∗ ) by L satisfying (2), i.e. s 4 + s14 + O5 (s, s1 ) for some C = 0 ∂ =0 L (s + s∗ , s1 + s∗ ) = C 24 and ∂s ∂s1 L 0 (s∗ , s∗ ) = 0. Then there exists an ∗ > 0 such that for every ∈ (− ∗ , ∗ ) \ {0} the point (s∗ , y∗ ) is a nonlinearly stable fixed point of T with a nonzero first Birkhoff coefficient. Proof. Without loss of generality assume that (s∗ , y∗ ) = (0, 0), so that we are exactly in the setting discussed so far in this section. Also, by rescaling by C we may also assume that C = 1. Combining the general expression of the Birkhoff coefficient of Lemma 2 with the specific structure of the considered family of maps as given in Proposition 2 we obtain ∂ =0 A = ∂ =0 Im c21 1 b a 10 01 = a10 −∂ a21 + 3 ∂ a03 − 3 ∂ | =0 b30 + ∂ | =0 b12 8 a01 =0 b10 =0 a01 a01 1 ∂ a30 − ∂ | =0 b21 + 3 ∂ | =0 b03 , − b10 ∂ a12 − 3 8 b10 =0 b10 =0 because only third order terms appear in ∂ | =0 T . Using the Taylor expansion we can express the various coefficients ai j and bi j in terms of L i j as a10 = −
L 20 1 a10 b01 − 1 L 02 , a01 = − , b10 = , b01 = − L 11 L 11 a01 L 11
138
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
Fig. 3. General billiard table Q with an elliptic, non-resonant periodic orbit γ
and ∂ =0 a30 ∂ =0 a21 ∂ =0 a12 ∂ =0 a03
= − 16
1 L 11
=
a01 6
,
=0, =0, =0,
∂ =0 b30 ∂ =0 b21 ∂ =0 b12 ∂ =0 b03
= − 16 = − 21 = =
− 21 − 16
L 02 L 11 L 220 L 311 L 20 L 311 1 L 311
− = = =
3 1 L 20 1 6 L3 = 6 11 1 2 2 a10 a01 , 1 2 2 a10 a01 , 1 3 6 a01 ,
3 ], [b01 + a10
again by using the result of Proposition 2. Therefore we obtain 4 ) a 2 (1 + a10 2 2 2 2 − a01 a10 b01 + a01 + 2 a10 a01 . 16 ∂ =0 A = − 01 a10 b01 − 1
Since we assume that the fixed point is elliptic, we must have | tr DT0 | = |a10 +b01 | < 2 and a01 = 0. With t:=
a10 + b01 ∈ (−1, 1) 2
the above becomes a2 ∂ =0 A = 01 8
2 1 + a10
2 a01 1 + 2 (t − a10 )2 >0. ≥ 1 − t 2 + (t − a10 )2 8
Hence there exists an ∗ > 0 such that A = 0 holds true for all ∈ (− ∗ , ∗ ) \ {0}. Moser’s twist theorem then implies (see Theorem 2.13 in [19]) that the fixed point (s∗ , y∗ ) is nonlinearly stable with a nonzero first Birkhoff coefficient for all maps T with ∈ (− ∗ , ∗ ) \ {0}. 5. Construction of Nonlinearly Stable Periodic Orbits In this section we consider the nonlinear stability problem for a linearly stable periodic orbit γ on a general billiard table Q. A typical situation is shown in Fig. 3. Let N denote the number of reflections of γ , and let si and ϕi , i = 1, . . . , N , denote the arc length parameter and angle of reflection at the i th reflection point of γ , respectively. As before, let Φ t and F denote the billiard flow and billiard map, respectively.
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
139
Fig. 4. Construction of the curves Γ
Since we assume that the periodic orbit γ is linearly stable the eigenvalues of the linearized billiard map are complex conjugate of modulus one, hence λ1 = λ¯ 2 = ei α ≡ λ are the eigenvalues of DF N (s1 , sin ϕ1 ) for some angle α. Furthermore we assume that γ is non-resonant, i.e. λ2 , λ3 , λ4 = 1 holds. In the non-resonant case a result due to Moser (see Theorems 2.12 and 2.13 in [19]) guarantees that there exists a real-analytic canonical change of coordinates (s, sin ϕ) → z ∈ C in a neighborhood of any of the (si , sin ϕi ) such that it conjugates F N to its Birkhoff normal form z → λ z ei A |z| + O(|z|4 ) 2
with A ∈ R the first Birkhoff coefficient. A sufficient condition for nonlinear stability of γ then is a nonzero value for A, cf. Theorem 2.13 in [19]. Applying this strategy to our general setup seems intractable because we would need a way to decide whether or not A vanishes. Therefore we will not consider the nonlinear stability problem of γ on the given table Q. Instead we will introduce a family of tables Q , which are almost identical to Q and have γ as a periodic orbit. We then want to know whether γ is nonlinearly stable for at least some tables in that family. A construction of such a family, which allows us to analyze A as a function of the table was given in [13,15] in the context of two-periodic orbits. It consists of a local perturbation of the boundary curve in normal direction, maintaining a third order contact, as shown in Fig. 4. Lemma 3 (Local perturbation in normal direction). Let Γ be a C 5 curve, parametrized by its arc length s, for s in some interval I containing a neighborhood of s = 0. Let φ : I → R be a C 5 function with φ(0) = φ (0) = φ (0) = φ (0) = 0. Then the parametrization of the curve Γφ (ξ ):=Γ (ξ ) + φ(ξ ) n(ξ ) by its arc length reads Γφ (s) = Γ (s) + φ (0) n 0
s4 + O(s 5 ) 24
in a neighborhood of s = 0. Proof. Denote by t (s) = Γ (s) and n(s) = t (s)⊥ the tangent and normal vector of Γ (s), respectively. The definition of the curvature K(s) of Γ (s) yields n (s) = K(s) t (s)
140
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
Fig. 5. An arbitrarily small local perturbation of the boundary (in the sense of the C 4 topology) of the billiard table that preserves the elliptic periodic orbit and renders it nonlinearly stable
hence Γφ (ξ ) = [1 + K(ξ ) φ(ξ )] t (ξ ) + φ (ξ ) n(ξ ) . In particular we obtain Γφ (ξ ) = [1 + K(ξ ) φ(ξ )]2 + φ (ξ )2 = 1 + O(ξ 4 ) for the length of the tangent vector of Γφ . Therefore S (ξ ) =
0
ξ
Γφ (ζ ) dζ = ξ + O(ξ 5 )
for the arc length of Γφ . The claim that Γφ and Γ have a third order contact (in terms of their arc length parametrizations) at the reference point Γ (0) follows now immediately from the definition of Γφ and Taylor expansion of φ and n. This perturbation of the boundary was used in [13,15] to study the stability of two-periodic orbits on strictly convex billiard tables. More precisely, it was shown that the first Birkhoff coefficient can be made nonzero using an arbitrary small local boundary perturbation of the above type. The following theorem generalizes this construction to arbitrary linearly stable, non-resonant periodic orbits on arbitrary billiard tables. Theorem 4. Consider a billiard table Q with a linearly stable, non-resonant N -periodic orbit γ , which has reflections off of C 5 boundary components. Let s1 , . . . , s N denote the arc length parameters corresponding to the N points of reflection. Pick any of the si , say si∗ . Then for all small enough δ > 0 there exists a billiard table Q δ,i∗ , which is C 5 close to Q and coincides with Q outside the δ-neighborhood Bδ (Γ (si∗ )) of Γ (si∗ ), and such that γ is a nonlinearly stable periodic orbit on Q δ,i∗ with nonzero Birkhoff coefficient. Proof. After possibly relabeling the points, we may assume that i ∗ = 1, and without loss of generality we may choose the arc length parametrization of ∂ Q such that s1 = 0. Denote the boundary components of the i th point of reflection by Γi . Let δ > 0 be arbitrary, but so small that Bδ (Γ (s1 )) contains no other points of reflection, and has intersection only with the boundary component Γ1 (see Fig. 5 for an illustration).
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
141
Choose a C ∞ function φ : R → R with support in [−δ/2, δ/2] such that φ(0) = = φ (0) = φ (0) = 0, φ (0) = 1, |φ(s)| ≤ 1. Let n(s) denote the unit normal vector at the point Γ1 (s). Define
φ (0)
Γ1 (t):=Γ1 (t) + φ(t) n(t) for all ∈ [−δ/2, δ/2]. Clearly the graphs of Γ1 and Γ1 coincide outside Bδ (Γ (0)). Moreover, for small enough Γ1 has no self-intersections and thus defines a new billiard table Q by replacing Γ1 by Γ1 . By Lemma 3 Γ1 (s) = Γ1 (s) +
s4 + O(s 5 ) 24
in a neighborhood of s = 0. In particular, the tangent line at s = 0 is preserved, and hence the orbit γ remains N -periodic for all Q . In fact, since the generating function of the N th iterate of the billiard map in a small enough neighborhood of the periodic orbit γ reads L (s1 , . . . , s N , s N +1 ) = Γ2 (s2 ) − Γ1 (s1 ) + · · · + Γ N (s N ) − Γ N −1 (s N −1 ) + Γ (s N +1 ) − Γ N (s N ) , 1
the above expansion of
Γ1
immediately implies
Γ2 (s2 ) − Γ1 (s1 ) ∂ =0 L (s1 , . . . , s N , s N +1 ) = − · ∂ =0 Γ1 (s1 ) Γ2 (s2 ) − Γ1 (s1 ) Γ1 (s N +1 ) − Γ N (s N ) + · ∂ =0 Γ1 (s N +1 ) Γ1 (s N +1 ) − Γ N (s N ) s 4 + s N4 +1 + O5 (s1 , s N +1 ), = − cos ϕ1 1 24 because only two terms in L really depend on . The boundary curves are of class C 5 in a neighborhood of the reflection points, hence the associated (N -fold iteration of the) billiard map is of class C 4 . Since cos ϕ1 > 0 we can apply Theorem 3 to conclude that for all small enough nonzero values of , the N -periodic orbit γ is nonlinearly stable on Q . Let Q ∗ (Γ, L) denote one such table on which the periodic orbit γ is nonlinearly stable with nonzero first Birkhoff coefficient. Now we are in the position to prove our main result as stated in Theorem 1. Proof of Theorem 1. Let L > 0 be arbitrary, and Γ as in the statement of Theorem 1. By Theorem 2 there exists a billiard table Q(L , Γ ) with Γ ⊂ ∂ Q which has a linearly stable, non-resonant periodic orbit γ with free path of length at least L before and after a sequence of consecutive reflections off of Γ . Applying now the result of Theorem 4 we may assume that this orbit is actually non-linearly stable with nonzero Birkhoff coefficient, otherwise we slightly modify the original table Q(L , Γ ) as stated in Theorem 4, which does not change the length of the free path γ before and after Γ to a value less than L.
142
L. A. Bunimovich, A. Grigo
Notice that by the implicit function theorem the periodic orbit γ persists under any (not just the ones of the type as in Lemma 3, cf. the proof of Theorem 4) sufficiently small enough C 5 perturbation of the boundary of the constructed billiard table. The perturbed periodic orbits will have the same period and are elliptic with a free path before and after Γ of length at least L. By Lemma 2 the first Birkhoff coefficient depends C 3 continuously on the map, hence C 4 -continuously on the boundary. Thus all the perturbed periodic orbits will have a nonzero Birkhoff coefficient, and hence are non-linearly stable, provided that the perturbation of the boundary is small enough. 6. Conclusion It is well known that if at least one focusing component is present, then in order to ensure hyperbolicity the boundary should be arranged in such a way that all beams of rays focus after any sequence of consecutive reflection off the focusing part of the boundary, and defocus (i.e. pass through a conjugate point) before the next reflection from the curved (non-flat) part of the boundary of the billiard table. So far, there are only two examples [9,10] of hyperbolic billiards where this condition of defocusing between any reflection from a focusing component and the next reflection off the curved part of the boundary is violated. However, both of these classes of billiards are very special. In fact, the absence of defocusing between some reflections from a focusing part of the boundary and the next reflection (off the curved part of the boundary) is allowed in [9] only in those parts of the phase space where the billiard dynamics is integrable. Therefore focusing does not dominate dispersing in this part of the phase space while on the complementary part of the phase space the defocusing mechanism in the usual way ensures hyperbolicity. Likewise, in [10] the billiard table has a very specially designed part where one can control that focusing is dominated by dispersing, although the beams do not defocus after reflections off the focusing component, while on the complement of this part of phase space, yet again, the defocusing mechanism generates hyperbolicity. Therefore, one may conclude that in all hyperbolic billiards with focusing boundary components constructed so far, it is the mechanism of defocusing which is responsible for hyperbolicity. Hence, the standard strategy to construct ergodic chaotic billiards is to choose all focusing components to be absolutely focusing, and to move them sufficiently far away from all other regular (smooth) components of the boundary, e.g. [12]. In this paper we have shown that for this strategy it is very essential that all focusing components are absolutely focusing, and conjecture that in two-dimensional billiards with at least one focusing, but non-absolutely focusing boundary component typically there are stable periodic orbits. References 1. Arnold, V.I.: Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Vol. 60, second ed. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1989 2. Boldrighini, C., Keane, M., Marchetti, F.: Billiards in polygons. Ann. Probab. 6(4), 532–540 (1978) 3. Bunimovich, L.A.: On ergodic properties of certain billiards. Funk. Anal. i Priložen. 8(3), 73–74 (1974) 4. Bunimovich, L.A.: On the ergodic properties of nowhere dispersing billiards. Commun. Math. Phys. 65(3), 295–312 (1979) 5. Bunimovich, L.A.: Many-dimensional nowhere dispersing billiards with chaotic behavior. Phys. D 33(1–3), 58–64 (1988) 6. Bunimovich, L.A.: Conditions of stochasticity of two-dimensional billiards. Chaos 1(2), 183–187 (1991)
Focusing Components Should be Absolutely Focusing
143
7. Bunimovich, L.A.: On absolutely focusing mirrors. In: Ergodic Theory and Related Topics, III (Güstrow, 1990), Lecture Notes in Math., Vol. 1514, Berlin: Springer, 1992, pp. 62–82 8. Bunimovich, L.A.: Absolute focusing and ergodicity of billiards. Regul. Chaotic Dyn. 8(1), 15–28 (2003) 9. Bunimovich, L.A., Del Magno, G.: Track billiards. Commun. Math. Phys. 288, 699–713 (2009) 10. Bussolari, L., Lenci, M.: Hyperbolic billiards with nearly flat focusing boundaries, I. Physica D 237(18), 2272–2281 (2008) 11. Chernov, N., Markarian, R.: Chaotic billiards. In: Mathematical Surveys and Monographs. Vol. 127. Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 2006 12. Del Magno, G., Markarian, R.: On the Bernoulli property of planar hyperbolic billiards, 2006, available at http://www.ma.utexas.edu/mp_arc/c/06/06-164.pdf 13. Dias Carneiro, M.J., Oliffson Kamphorst, S., Pintode Carvalho, S.: Elliptic islands in strictly convex billiards. Erg. Th. Dynam. Syst. 23(3), 799–812 (2003) 14. Donnay, V.J.: Using integrability to produce chaos: billiards with positive entropy. Commun. Math. Phys. 141(2), 225–257 (1991) 15. Kamphorst, S.O., Pinto-de Carvalho, S.: The first Birkhoff coefficient and the stability of 2-periodic orbits on billiards. Exp. Math. 14(3), 299–306 (2005) 16. Lazutkin, V.F.: Existence of a continuum of closed invariant curves for a convex billiard. Usp. Mat. Nauk 2(3(165)), 201–202 (1972) 17. Lazutkin, V.F.: Existence of caustics for the billiard problem in a convex domain. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat. 37, 186–216 (1973) 18. Markarian, R.: Billiards with Pesin region of measure one. Commun. Math. Phys. 118(1), 87–97 (1988) 19. Moser, J.: Stable and Random Motions in Dynamical Systems. Princeton Landmarks in Mathematics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2001, with special emphasis on celestial mechanics, Reprint of the 1973 original, with a foreword by Philip J. Holmes 20. Sina˘ı, Y.G.: Dynamical systems with elastic reflections. Ergodic properties of dispersing billiards. Usp. Mat. Nauk 25(2 (152)), 141–192 (1970) 21. Wojtkowski, M.: Principles for the design of billiards with nonvanishing Lyapunov exponents. Commun. Math. Phys. 105(3), 391–414 (1986) Communicated by G. Gallavotti
Commun. Math. Phys. 293, 145–170 (2010) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-009-0906-1
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths Alexei Borodin1,2 , Senya Shlosman2,3 1 Department of Mathematics, Caltech, Pasadena, USA. E-mail: [email protected] 2 IITP, RAS, Moscow, Russia. E-mail: [email protected] 3 Centre de Physique Theorique, CNRS, Luminy, Marseille, France. E-mail: [email protected]
Received: 29 June 2008 / Accepted: 14 July 2009 Published online: 30 August 2009 – © Springer-Verlag 2009
Abstract: We consider a family of determinantal random point processes on the twodimensional lattice and prove that members of our family can be interpreted as a kind of Gibbs ensembles of nonintersecting paths. Examples include probability measures on lozenge and domino tilings of the plane, some of which are non-translation-invariant. The correlation kernels of our processes can be viewed as extensions of the discrete sine kernel, and we show that the Gibbs property is a consequence of simple linear relations satisfied by these kernels. The processes depend on infinitely many parameters, which are closely related to parametrization of totally positive Toeplitz matrices. 1. Introduction It is well known that the Gibbs random fields are defined via prescribing their conditional distributions. In the case of the nearest-neighbor interactions these distributions are given by some relatively simple relations. The computation of their correlation functions is on the other hand usually a very difficult problem, because it requires the passing to the thermodynamic limit. In comparison, the determinantal random fields (or random point processes, both terms are used) are defined in such a way that the correlation functions are given by relatively simple direct formulas, while the computation of the conditional distributions may again require taking the thermodynamic limit, since the dependence is usually long-range. The purpose of the present paper is the study of some 2D random fields n = n t = 0, 1, t ∈ Z2 , which are both determinantal and have in addition some kind of Gibbs property. We wanted to understand which properties of the kernel produce the Gibbsianity of the random field. It turns out that the property sought is some linear relation on the matrix elements of the kernel. Below we explain this statement for a certain class of 2D determinantal random fields. Every random assignment of the probabilities Pr field is specified by the (consistent) to the events n ti = 1, ti ∈ I ; n t j = 0, t j ∈ J , for any two non-intersecting finite sets
146
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
I, J ⊂ Z2 . We say that a random field n is a determinantal random field with the kernel K (·, ·) , if for every finite set I = ti ∈ Z2 , Pr K n ti = 1, ti ∈ I = det K si , s j s ,s ∈I . (1) i
j
The inclusion-exclusion principle then implies that the probability of a more general event Pr K n ti = 1, ti ∈ I ; n t j = 0, t j ∈ J = (−1)h det K˜ si , s j , si ,s j ∈I ∪J
where
⎧ ⎨K K˜ si , s j = K ⎩ K
si , s j if si = s j , if si = s j ∈ I, (s i , si ) s j , s j − 1 if si = s j ∈ J,
and h is the number of “holes”, i.e. indices t j ∈ J. We will refer to the sites with values 1 as “particles”. The above formula is sometimes referred to as the complementation principle, cf. A.3 of [3]. In this paper we study random fields n, corresponding to the kernels K constructed as follows. Suppose that for every k ∈ Z1 the function ψk (u) is given, which can be one of the following four functions:
−1
−1 , 1 − αk− u −1 , 1 + βk+ u , 1 + βk− u −1 , 1 − αk+ u with positive constants α ± , β ± . Let us also fix a complex number z with z > 0 and denote C± any contour that joins z¯ and z and crosses the real axis at a point of R± . For t = (σ, x) , t = (τ, y) we define ⎧ −1 τ ⎪ ⎪ 1 du ⎪ ⎪ ψk (u) if σ < τ, ⎪ x−y+1 ⎪ u ⎪ 2πi C+ k=σ +1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ 1 du K (σ, x; τ, y) ≡ K σ,τ (x − y) = ifσ = τ, (2) x−y+1 ⎪ 2πi C+ u ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ σ ⎪ ⎪ 1 du ⎪ ⎪ ψk (u) x−y+1 if σ > τ. ⎪ ⎩ 2πi C u − k=τ +1
Our main results concerning such determinantal random fields are threefold: 1. Due to the (particles or holes) interlacing property of our fields n, they can be interpreted as ensembles of non-intersecting infinite random lattice paths. (These ensembles are different for different kernels, and will be described in detail below.) 2. The collections ω = {ωi } of random lattice paths thus obtained are “Gibbs random paths ensembles”. They are defined by the action functional S K (ω) , which is local and is determined by the parameters of the kernel K . 3. The validity of the above two statements follows from simple linear relations that the matrix elements of the kernel K satisfy, and do not depend on K otherwise.
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
147
1.1. Gibbs path ensembles. We will define the Gibbs random path ensemble, corresponding to the additive functional S. Here S is a function defined on the set of all finite selfavoiding lattice paths ω, which has the additivity property: if ω = ω1 ∪ ω2 , ω1 ∩ ω2 = {t} ∈ ω, then S (ω) = S (ω1 ) + S (ω2 ). Let µ be a probability distribution on the set of families of non-intersecting double-infinite polygonal lattice paths ω = {ωi , −∞ < i < ∞}. Let ⊂ Z2 be a finite box, i.e. a finite connected subset of Z2 with connected complement. Let the paths ωi be fixed outside . We denote the restriction of ω to the complement of by ω¯ . Some of the paths from ω are entering and exiting . Let P be the set p1 , . . . , pk ∈ ∂ of all the entrance points to , while Q is the set of the exit points q1 , . . . , qk ∈ ∂ from . Let = 1 , . . . , k be a collection of non-intersecting lattice paths contained in , joining the points p1 , . . . , pk and q1 , . . . , qk . We denote the set of such k-tuples of paths by (P, Q). We say that the measure µ is a Gibbs measure with the action functional S, if for every triple (, P, Q) the conditional distributions of µ satisfy
exp {S ( ) + · · · + S ( )} 1 k µ ω¯ = , (3) Z (, P, Q) where Z (, P, Q) = ∈ (P,Q) exp {S ( 1 ) + · · · + S ( k )} is the partition function.
1.2. The interlacing property. This property of the random field n holds almost surely with respect to the measure Pr K , as we will show below. Its exact formulation is different at different locations and depends on the structure of the kernel K at this location. The picture on Fig. 1 illustrates the various cases which are described below. −1 If for some k we have ψk (u) = 1 − αk+ u , then in the strip Rk = (σ, x) ∈ Z2 : σ = k, k + 1 the following property holds Pr K -a.s.: For any two particles n (k,x1 ) = n (k,x2 ) = 1, x1 < x2 , of the configuration n, separated by a string of holes, n (k,x) = 0 for all x1 < x < x2 , we find on the neighboring line σ = k + 1 exactly one particle n (k+1,x) = 1 sitting in the set {(k + 1, x) : x1 ≤ x < x2 } , and the rest of points of this set host holes. This is the upward interlacing of particles. Consider now the correspondence π + , which n (k,x) = 1 the assigns to a particle particle n (k+1,π + (x)) = 1, where π + (x) = min y ≥ x : n (k+1,y) = 1 ≥ x. The correspondence π + is one-to-one with probability one. Let us connect each particle n (k,x) = 1 with the corresponding particle n (k+1,π + (x)) = 1 by the three-link path ωx,π + (x) = (k, x) , k + 21 , x ∪ k + 21 , x , k + 21 , π + (x) ∪ k + 21 , π + (x) , k + 1, π + (x) . (4) Then for different particles n (k,x ) = 1, n (k,x ) = 1 the connectors ωx ,π + (x ) , ωx ,π + (x ) do not intersect. We define the action S on each of these connectors by S ωx,π + (x) = π + (x) − x ln αk+ . (5) + Clearly, exp S ωx,π + (x) = (αk+ )π (x)−x , which can be seen as the product of factors αk+ over the unit pieces of the connector. −1 the situation is very similar, except the In the case when ψk (u) = 1 − αk− u −1 upward interlacing is replaced by the downward interlacing: The correspondence π + is
148
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
Fig. 1. The first two columns, together with the 5th and the 9th display ascending β-paths, the 3rd and the 4th – ascending α-paths, the 6th and the 10th – the descending β-paths, the 7th and the 8th – the descending α-paths
replaced by π − , which assigns to a particle n (k,x) = 1 the particle n (k+1,π − (x)) = 1, where π − (x) = max y ≤ x : n (k+1,y) = 1 ≤ x. Again, π − is one-to-one a.s., and the (downward) connectors ωx,π − (x) = (k, x) , k + 21 , x ∪ k + 21 , x , k + 21 , π − (x) ∪ k + 21 , π − (x) , k + 1, π − (x) (6) do not intersect. The action S is given by S ωx,π − (x) = x − π − (x) ln αk− . (7) For ψk (u) = 1 + βk+ u we have the upward interlacing of holes: If in the configuration n we have two holes n (k,x1 ) = n (k,x 2 ) = 0, x1 < x2 , separated by the string of particles n (k,x) = 1 for all x1 < x < x2 , then on the neighboring line σ = k + 1 we have Pr K -a.s. exactly one hole n (k+1,x) = 0 in the set {(k + 1, x) : x1 < x ≤ x2 } , while the rest of the points in this set is filled by the particles. We then define a correspondence χ + , assigning to every particle on the σ = k line a particle on the σ = k + 1 line, as follows. Take any string of consecutive particles n (k,x) = 1 for all x1 < x < x2 which is maximal, i.e. n (k,x1 ) = n (k,x2 ) = 0. We put χ + (x1 + 1) = min x ≥ x1 + 1 : n (k+1,x) = 1 , and then proceed inductively by putting χ + (x + 1) = min y > χ + (x) : n (k+1,y) = 1 .
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
149
The hole interlacing implies that χ + is a.s. well-defined, is one-to-one, and that for every particle n (k,x) = 1 we have either χ + (x) = x or χ + (x) = x +1. The particle connectors, which in this case are segments ωx,χ + (x) = (k, x) , k + 1, χ + (x) ,
(8)
clearly do not intersect each other. We put S ωx,χ + (x) =
0 ln βk+
if χ + (x) = x, if χ + (x) = x + 1.
(9)
This means that exp S ωx,χ + (x) is βk+ if the connector has slope 1, and 1 if the connector has slope 0. For ψk (u) = 1 + βk− u −1 we have likewise the downward interlacing of holes. The correspondence χ + is replaced by χ − , with the property that either χ − (x) = x or χ − (x) = x − 1. The connectors are non-intersecting segments ωx,χ − (x) = (k, x) , k + 1, χ − (x) ,
(10)
and we define S ωx,χ − (x) =
0 ln βk−
if χ − (x) = x, if χ − (x) = x − 1.
(11)
1.3. Main result. Now we can formulate our claims more precisely. Let us fix a sequence of functions ψk (u) , k ∈ Z1 , such that for every k the function ψk (u) is one of the four −1 −1 functions 1 − αk+ u , 1 − αk− u −1 , 1 + βk+ u , 1 + βk− u −1 , with α∗± , β∗± > 0. Let us also fix a complex number z, z > 0. Theorem 1. i) The kernel (2) defines a determinantal random field n on Z2 , which is invariant with respect to the shifts of the second coordinate. ii) The random field n possesses the interlacing property as defined in Sect. 1.2. In particular, there is a map ω, assigning to Pr K -a.e. realization of n a countable collection of non-intersecting lattice paths ωn = {ωi } , passing through all the particles of the configuration n. The construction of the collection ωn is given by (4), (6), (8) and (10). iii) The random paths ω thus constructed form the Gibbs Path Ensemble, as defined in Sect. 1.1. It corresponds to the action functional S, given by the formulas (5), (7), (9) and (11). iv) item For every k ∈ Z the matrix elements of the kernel K satisfy the following relations: −1 for the case ψk (u) = 1 − αk+ u , K k−1,τ (x − y) − δ
x=y τ =k−1
= K k,τ (x − y) − αk+ K k,τ (x − y − 1) ,
K σ,k (x − y) − δ x=y = K σ,k−1 (x − y) − αk+ K σ,k−1 (x − y − 1) ; σ =k
150
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
for the case ψk (u) = 1 + βk+ u , K k,τ (x − y) = K k−1,τ (x − y) − δ x=y τ =k−1 + + βk K k−1,τ (x − y − 1) − δ x=y+1 , τ =k−1 + K σ,k−1 (x − y) = βk K σ,k (x − y − 1) − δ σ =k + K σ,k (x − y) − δσ =k ; x=y+1
x=y
and similar relations for the α − , β − cases. The determinant identities, expressing the properties ii) and iii) above, are corollaries of these relations only, and thus hold true for any other kernel K , satisfying them. 2. Examples 1. Our first example will be Gibbs ensembles of the β-paths, introduced in (8) , (10). These are collections of non-intersecting infinite paths {ωi } on Z2 , such that if a path visits the point (σ, x) , then its next link is either the segment [(σ, x) , (σ + 1, x)] or the segment [(σ, x) , (σ + 1, x + 1)]. Now let = ( p, q) be a finite piece of such β-path, where p, q are the end-points of . We define the energy U ( ) of this path in the following way. Let − ( p, q) be the β-path, which is the lowest among all the β-paths connecting p and q. Then exp {−U ( )} is by definition the area surrounded by the loop ( p, q) ∪ − ( p, q). For a collection = { i } of finite paths we define H ( ) = i U ( i ). We call the measure µ on the ensemble ω of non-intersecting infinite β-paths the Gibbs measure corresponding to the energy H and the inverse temperature τ, if it has the following property. Let ⊂ Z2 be a finite volume, and the sets P = { p1 , . . . , pk ∈ ∂} , Q = {q1 , . . . , qk ∈ ∂} of the entrance points and exit points are fixed. Then the conditional distribution of µ on (P, Q) = { } under the condition that the path configuration ω¯ is fixed outside is given by the formula
exp {−τ H ( )} . (12) µ ω¯ = Z¯ (, P, Q) This definition is just a convenient rewriting of the relation (3) above. The advantage is that our function H here is manifestly translation-invariant. Our main result implies in particular that the determinantal random fields µκ,z defined by the kernel K = K (κ, z) with the functions ψk (u) = 1 + κekτ u , interpreted as path measures, are Gibbs measures with the energy H and the inverse temperature τ. Here κ > 0 is any real number. When the temperature τ −1 goes to zero, the Gibbs measures (12) are concentrated on ground-state configurations, which are local minima of the energy H. For low temperatures they are concentrated on configurations which are small perturbations of the ground state configurations, see Fig. 2. Note that the ground state configurations have their corner points confined to at most two nearest neighbor vertical lattice lines. One can say that for large τ our two-dimensional random field is essentially one-dimensional, and outside the strip of width ∼ τ −1 it is basically frozen. Along this vertical direction 2 it has the following correlation decay property: for every two finite subsets A, B ⊂ Z we have n A+x n B − n A n B → 0 as |x| → ∞. Here n A = (σ,x)∈A n σ,x .
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
151
Fig. 2. A ground state configuration of the β-paths, and a low-temperature configuration
Without loss of generality we can assume that |z| = 1. The parameter z then defines the “slope” of the “height function”, or, what is the same, the (constant) density of the paths in the path ensemble. Note now, that for every z the determinantal processes µκ,z are different for different values of κ. This follows just from the computation of the second correlation function for these processes. That means that there are continuum non-translation-invariant Gibbs measures (12), corresponding to the same slope and the same temperature. Of course, the field µκ,z is just a translate of the field µτ κ,z by the unit lattice vector. But the fields µκ,z with κ between 1 and τ are all different and are not related by the lattice shift transformation. One can understand better the role played by the parameter κ looking at the boundary conditions and the limiting behavior of the processes µκ,z . The restriction of the process to any vertical line σ = const gives the (translation-invariant) sine process with density arg z/π . Let us consider two such lines, say σ = ±k. Then the paths of the process µκ,z define in a natural way the coupling C (k, κ, τ ) between the two sine processes. Consider the limiting coupling C (κ, τ ) = limk→∞ C (k, κ, τ ). It turns out that the couplings C (κ, τ ) are still non-trivial (i.e. these couplings are not product-couplings), and are different for different κ. The two couplings C (κ, τ ) and C (τ κ, τ ) are related by the unit shift of one of the sine processes. The couplings C (κ, τ ) become trivial only in the limit when τ → 0. In this limit the fields µκ,z become fully translation invariant.
152
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
Fig. 3. The β-paths and the corresponding (deformed-)lozenge tiling
Fig. 4. The limit shape
A straightforward geometric interpretation of our ensemble of the β-paths is to relate them to the lozenge tilings of the plane. Our paths are then composed by the middle lines of all “vertical” plaquettes, see Fig. 3, cf. [9]. One may wonder about the existence of the asymptotic shape of the height function corresponding to the field µ1,z , i.e. to the choice ψk (u) = 1 + τ k u . However, this height function is almost frozen outside the strip of width ∼ τ −1 around the line σ = 0. If we scale this surface by the factor τ in all three dimensions, then the conjectural limit when τ → 0 is a non-random cylindrical surface. This surface has a gutter shape, see Fig. 4, and is given by the following geometric construction. To describe it we first recall the geometric construction (see [16] or [17]), used to obtain the limit shape CC K of the plane partitions by Cerf and Kenyon in [5]. For every positive unit vector n ∈ 2 = S 2 ∩ R3+ let ent (n) be the residual entropy of the lozenge tilings having the slope plane orthogonal to n (see Theorem 1.1 in [5]). Now define the
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
153
halfspaces K n = x ∈ R3 : (x, n) ≥ ent (n) . Let K = ∩n∈2 K n ; the boundary of the region K is precisely the surface CC K , describing the typical shape of a large plane partition. To describe the gutter shape we first define its slope, γ . This is determined by the frequency of the lines in our family (indeed, they are just the level lines of the height function). If z = eiϕ , then the density in question is the first correlation function of our ϕ determinantal process, and it is equal to πϕ . Therefore γ satisfies tan γ = 1−ϕ . Let us
define the vector m (γ ) = m x , m y , m z = − √1 , − √1 , tan γ . This is the direction of 2
2
our gutter. Consider the arc A (γ ) of vectors in the “triangle” 2 , which are orthogonal to m(γ ): A (γ ) = n ∈ 2 : (n, m (γ )) = 0 . Our gutter surface, G (γ ) , is defined to be the boundary of the convex region K (γ ) ≡ ∩n∈A(γ ) K n . Note that the surface G (γ ) consists of straight lines parallel to the vector m (γ ). The surfaces G (γ ) and CC K are tangent to each other along the common curve g (γ ) = G (γ )∩ CC K . Each of the curves g (γ ) is a smooth curve without straight pieces. Asymptotically
each of them approaches the Vershik curve CV : exp − √π x + exp − √π y = 1, 6 6 z = 0 , which belongs to the boundary of the curved part of the surface CC K . −1 2. Our second example isthe ensemble of αβ-paths, with ψ2k (u) = 1 − αk− u −1 and ψ2k+1 (u) = 1 + βk+ u . Again we will choose α and β to be geometric progressions, by putting αk− = (κekτ )−1 , βk+ = λekτ , with κ, λ, τ > 0. In the same way that the β-paths are related to the lozenge tiling, the αβ-paths are related to the domino tilings. The relation however is not so easy to explain; the corresponding construction, establishing the bijection between the two entities, is presented in [10], see also [13]. Figure 5 shows one collection of αβ-paths with κ = λ = 1 and τ = ∞ (which therefore should be called a ground state configuration). For k > 0 all the α-steps are zero height steps, while all the β-steps are ascending. For k < 0 all the β-steps are zero height steps, while all the α-steps are descending in a maximal possible way. Figure 6 shows the corresponding domino tiling. In domino tilings, the elementary moves correspond to finding a 2 × 2 square tiled by two dominoes, say horizontal, and replacing this pair of dominos by two vertical ones. If one assigns four weights a, b, c, d to the four possible positions of a single domino, then every move replacing a horizontal pair by a vertical one changes the overall weight by a constant factor. (If a, b are two horizontal weights, then the overall change will be cd by a factor ab .) In our case the overall weight after an elementary move depends on the κ τ parity of the 2 × 2 square, and is κ λ in one case, and λ e in the other. (The parity of the square is the parity of the sum of the coordinates of its lower-left corner.) This means
154
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
Fig. 5. A ground state configuration of αβ-paths
that the measures on the domino tilings that we have constructed, can not be obtained by assigning weights to single dominoes. Again, for τ = 0 our measures are non-translation-invariant, and by varying the ratio κ we obtain a whole continuum of different measures. λ In the case τ = 0, the two-parametric measure on lozenge tilings and the three-parametric measure on domino tilings are translation invariant with respect to all shifts of Z2 . These measures are well known; for lozenge tilings they were obtained in [11,14], and for domino tilings they were obtained in [4,6], see also [10]. As proved in [15], they are the only fully translation invariant ergodic measures. 3. Proof of the Main Result The proof of i of Theorem 1 is given in Sect. 4 below. We will start the proof of ii-iv by dealing with the special case when for each k ∈ Z1 the function ψk (u) is either (1 − αk u)−1 or (1 + βk u) , with αk , βk some positive constants. We will consider the general case at the end of the proof.
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
155
Fig. 6. The domino tiling, corresponding to the paths of Fig. 5
3.1. Linear relations. Let the sequence of functions ψk (u) be given, where for every k ∈ Z1 the function ψk (u) is either (1 − αk u)−1 or (1 + βk u) , with αk , βk some positive constants. In this subsection we will show that the kernel K σ,τ (x − y) satisfies the linear relations mentioned in Theorem 1. Indeed, if ψk (u) = (1 − αk u)−1 , then for σ = k − 1 and τ ≥ k,
K k−1,τ
1 (x − y) = 2πi
(1 − αk u) C+
τ
−1 ψ j (u)
k+1
du u x−y+1
= K k,τ (x − y) − αk K k,τ (x − y − 1) , the same for τ < k − 1: K k,τ (x − y) − αk K k,τ (x − y − 1) k−1 du 1 ψ j (u) (1 − αk u)−1 x−y+1 = 2πi C− u τ +1
−αk =
1 2πi
1 2πi
k−1
C− τ +1 k−1
ψ j (u) (1 − αk u)−1
ψ j (u)
C− τ +1
du u x−y+1
du u x−y
= K k−1,τ (x − y) ,
156
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
while for τ = k − 1 we have du 1 K k−1,k−1 (x − y) = , x−y+1 2πi C+ u K k,k−1 (x − y) − αk K k,k−1 (x − y − 1) du 1 du 1 = (1 − αk u)−1 x−y+1 − αk (1 − αk u)−1 x−y 2πi C− u 2πi C− u du 1 = , 2πi C− u x−y+1 which means that K k−1,k−1 (x − y) − K k,k−1 (x − y) + αk K k,k−1 (x − y − 1) = δx=y .
(13)
Altogether, these relations read = K k,τ (x − y) − αk K k,τ (x − y − 1) .
K k−1,τ (x − y) − δ
x=y τ =k−1
(14)
Also, if τ = k and σ ≤ k − 1, then 1 K σ,k (x − y) = 2πi
C+
τ
−1 ψ j (u)
(1 − αk u)
σ +1
du u x−y+1
= K σ,k−1 (x − y) − αk K σ,k−1 (x − y − 1) , and the same for σ > k. Since the diagonal elements K r,r (x − y) do not depend on r, for σ = k we have immediately from (13): K k,k (x − y) − K k,k−1 (x − y) + αk K k,k−1 (x − y − 1) = δx=y . Altogether, K σ,k (x − y) − δ x=y = K σ,k−1 (x − y) − αk K σ,k−1 (x − y − 1) .
(15)
σ =k
Likewise, for ψk (u) = (1 + βk u), σ = k and k − 1 > τ we have k−1 du 1 ψ j (u) (1 + βk u) x−y+1 K k,τ (x − y) = 2πi C− u τ +1
= K k−1,τ (x − y) + βk K k−1,τ (x − y − 1) , and similarly for k − 1 < τ. For τ = k − 1 we have du 1 K k,k−1 (x − y) = (1 + βk u) x−y+1 , 2πi C− u while K k−1,k−1 (x − y) + βk K k−1,k−1 (x − y − 1) =
1 2πi
C+
du
u
+ βk x−y+1
(16)
1 2πi
C+
du , u x−y (17)
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
157
so K k−1,k−1 (x − y) + βk K k−1,k−1 (x − y − 1) − K k,k−1 (x − y) du 1 = (1 + βk u) x−y+1 = δx=y + βk δx=y+1 . 2πi u Summarizing, we have K k,τ (x − y) = K k−1,τ (x − y) − δ
(18)
+ βk K k−1,τ (x − y − 1) − δ x=y+1 .
x=y τ =k−1
τ =k−1
(19) The last relation we obtain by considering for ψk (u) = (1 + βk u) the case when σ > k while τ = k − 1. Then we have
σ du 1 K σ,k−1 (x − y) = ψ j (u) (1 + βk u) 2πi C− u x−y+1 k+1
= K σ,k (x − y) + βk K σ,k (x − y − 1) . The same relation holds in the region σ < k, while for σ = k we use (18), which immediately implies that K k,k (x − y) + βk K k,k (x − y − 1) − K k,k−1 (x − y) = δx=y + βk δx=y+1 , thus getting us to
K σ,k−1 (x − y) = βk K σ,k (x − y − 1) − δ
σ =k x=y+1
+ K σ,k (x − y) − δσ =k .
(20)
x=y
3.2. Interlacing property. Simplest case. Let us start by checking the interlacing property in the simplest situations. In the case ψk (u) = (1 − αk u)−1 we will show that 1 ∗ 0 1 Pr K = 0, Pr K = 0, (21) 1 0 k−1,k ∗ 1 k−1,k 1∗ denotes the corresponding event in some two by two where the symbol 1 0 k−1,k square in the vertical strip {(k − 1, ∗) , (k, ∗)} . For the case σ = k with ψk (u) = (1 + βk u) we will show that 0 1 ∗ 0 Pr K = 0, Pr K = 0. 0 ∗ k−1,k 1 0 k−1,k
To save on notation, we will put k = 1, and we will write α, β, ψ instead of α1 , β1 , ψ1 . 1. The case ψ (u) = (1 − αu)−1 : Pr K
1 ∗ 1 0
= 0.
0,1
158
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
This relation is equivalent to showing that K 0,0 (0) K 0,0 (−1) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (1) = 0. det K 0,0 (1) K 0,0 (0) K 1,0 (0) K 1,0 (−1) K 1,1 (0) − 1 But this relation does hold, since the relation (15) implies that the last column is a linear combination of the remaining two. 2. The case ψ (u) = (1 − αu)−1 : Pr K
0 1 ∗ 1
= 0. 0,1
We have to check that K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,1 (0) det K 1,0 (−1) K 1,1 (0) K 1,1 (−1) = 0. K 1,0 (0) K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) But from (14) it follows that the first row is a combination of the remaining two. 3. The case ψ (u) = (1 + βu): Pr K
0 1 0 ∗
= 0.
(22)
0,1
We have thus to show the vanishing of K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,0 (−1) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (0) . det K 0,0 (1) K 1,0 (1) K 1,0 (0) K 1,1 (0) But the relation (19) tells us that the third row of the last determinant is a linear combination of the first two. 4. The case ψ (u) = (1 + βu): Pr K
∗ 0 1 0
= 0. 0,1
We thus need the vanishing of the determinant K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) det K 1,0 (0) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,1 (−1) . K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) − 1 But the first column is a combination of the second and the third, due to (20).
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
159
3.3. Elementary moves. We will prove the interlacing property in the general case by reducing the corresponding events to simpler ones. The reduction is done by applying to the configurations in question the transformations, which are called elementary moves. (For the case of lozenge tilings – see Case 1 below – an elementary move corresponds to the replacement of the tiling of the regular hexagon by three lozenges by a different one.) In this and the next section we will prove the set of identities, corresponding to the elementary moves of the paths. We will use them in Sect. 3.5. Since every move involves two adjacent columns of the lattice, we have four different types of moves, according to the four types – αα, αβ, βα, or ββ – of the column pairs. 1. We start with the case ψ1 (u) = (1 + β1 u) , ψ2 (u) = (1 + β2 u) . We will prove that β1 Pr K
∗ 0 1 1 1 ∗
= β2 Pr K
0,1,2
∗ 1 1 1 0 ∗
. 0,1,2
The corresponding determinant relation reads: K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) K (0) K 1,1 (0) K 1,1 (−1) K 1,2 (−1) β1 det 1,0 K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,2 (0) K (1) K (1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) 2,0 2,1 K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) K (0) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,1 (−1) K 1,2 (−1) . = β2 det 1,0 K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) K 1,2 (0) K 1,0 (1) K (1) K (1) K (0) K (0) 2,0
2,1
2,1
(23)
2,2
Due to the relation (20), applied to the first determinant, K 0,0 (0) K (0) det 1,0 K 1,0 (1) K (1) 2,0
K 0,1 (0) β1 K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) K 1,1 (0) β1 K 1,1 (−1) K 1,2 (−1) , K 1,1 (1) β1 K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,2 (0) K 2,1 (1) β1 K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0)
subtracting from the third column the first one and adding the second one, results in K 0,0 (0) K (0) det 1,0 K 1,0 (1) K (1) 2,0
K 0,1 (0) K 1,1 (0) K 1,1 (1) K 2,1 (1)
0 K 0,2 (−1) K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,2 (−1) 1 K 1,2 (−1) = − det K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,2 (0) . 0 K 1,2 (0) K 2,0 (1) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) 0 K 2,2 (0)
Due to the relation (19), applied to the second determinant, K 0,2 (−1) K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) β K (0) β2 K 1,1 (0) − 1 β2 K 1,1 (−1) β2 K 1,2 (−1) det 2 1,0 , K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) K 1,2 (0) K 1,0 (1) K (1) K 2,1 (1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) 2,0
160
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
subtracting from the second row the last one and adding the third one, results in: K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) 0 0 1 0 det K 1,2 (0) K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) K (1) K (1) K (0) K 2,2 (0) 2,0 2,1 2,1 K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,2 (−1) = − det K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,2 (0) . K 2,0 (1) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) But this is the same matrix as above. 2. Now we consider the case ψ1 (u) = (1 − α1 u)−1 , ψ2 (u) = (1 − α2 u)−1 . We have to prove that 0 ∗ ∗ 0 1 ∗ α1 Pr K = α2 Pr K , (24) ∗ 1 0 0,1,2 ∗ ∗ 0 0,1,2 or
K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (1) K 1,2 (0) α1 det K 1,0 (−1) K 1,1 (0) K 2,0 (−1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) − 1 K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (0) K 0,2 (1) K 1,1 (0) K 1,2 (1) . = α2 det K 1,0 (0) K 2,0 (−1) K 2,1 (−1) K 2,2 (0) − 1 Applying the relation (14) to the first two rows of the first determinant, we see that K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (1) det α1 K 1,0 (−1) α1 K 1,1 (0) α1 K 1,2 (0) K 2,0 (−1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) − 1 K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,2 (1) . = det K 1,0 (0) K 2,0 (−1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) − 1
Applying now the relation (15) to the second and third columns of the second determinant, we see the same result: K 0,0 (0) − 1 α2 K 0,1 (0) K 0,2 (1) α2 K 1,1 (0) K 1,2 (1) det K 1,0 (0) K 2,0 (−1) α2 K 2,1 (−1) K 2,2 (0) − 1 K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,2 (1) . = det K 1,0 (0) K 2,0 (−1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) − 1 3. We go to the case ψ1 (u) = (1 + β1 u) , ψ2 (u) = (1 − α2 u)−1 . Here we need to see that ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ 1 ∗ β1 Pr K = α2 Pr K , (25) 1 1 0 0,1,2 1 ∗ 0 0,1,2
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
which is the same as
β1 Pr K
∗ 0 ∗ 1 ∗ 0
161
= α2 Pr K
0,1,2
∗ 1 ∗ 1 ∗ 0
. 0,1,2
(The equivalence of the two identities follows from the simplest case of the interlacing property proved in the previous section.) Expressed via determinants, this is the relation K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (0) K 1,2 (1) β1 det K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (−1) K 2,2 (0) − 1 K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (0) K 1,2 (1) . = −α2 det K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (0) K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (−1) K 2,2 (0) − 1 By (20), subtracting in the first determinant, K 0,0 (0) β1 K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (0) det K 1,0 (1) β1 K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,2 (1) K 2,0 (0) β1 K 2,1 (−1) K 2,2 (0) − 1 the first column from the second one, makes it into K 0,0 (0) −K 0,1 (0) K 0,2 (0) K 1,2 (1) . det K 1,0 (1) −K 1,1 (1) K 2,0 (0) −K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) − 1 From (15), adding in the second determinant, K 0,0 (0) α2 K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (0) K 1,2 (1) , − det K 1,0 (1) α2 K 1,1 (0) K 2,0 (0) α2 K 2,1 (−1) K 2,2 (0) − 1 the third column to the second one results in K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,2 (0) K 1,2 (1) , − det K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) − 1 which is what we need. 4. The remaining case is ψ1 (u) = (1 − α1 u)−1 , ψ2 (u) = (1 + β2 u) . Here we need to see that 0 ∗ 1 0 1 1 α1 Pr K = β2 Pr K , (26) ∗ 1 ∗ 0,1,2 ∗ ∗ ∗ 0,1,2 which is the same as α1 Pr K
0 ∗ 1 ∗ 1 ∗
= β2 Pr K
0,1,2
0 ∗ 1 ∗ 0 ∗
. 0,1,2
162
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
The determinant relation to be checked is K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (0) −α1 det K 1,0 (−1) K 1,1 (0) K 1,2 (−1) K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (0) = β2 det K 1,0 (−1) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,2 (−1) . K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) By (14), applied to the first determinant, K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (0) − det α1 K 1,0 (−1) α1 K 1,1 (0) α1 K 1,2 (−1) , K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) the addition of the first row to the second one makes it into K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (0) K 1,1 (1) K 1,2 (0) . − det K 1,0 (0) K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) Applying (19) to the determinant K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (0) det β2 K 1,0 (−1) β2 K 1,1 (0) − 1 β2 K 1,2 (−1) , K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) we turn it, after subtracting the third row from the second one, into K 0,0 (0) − 1 K 0,1 (1) K 0,2 (0) det −K 1,0 (0) −K 1,1 (1) −K 1,2 (0) . K 2,0 (0) K 2,1 (1) K 2,2 (0) That finishes our proof. 3.4. Moves in a general environment. Now we have to check that the identities of the previous subsection hold in a more general situation. For the ββ case it means for example that ∗ 0 1 ∗ 1 1 β1 Pr K ∪ n V = β2 Pr K ∪ nV , 1 1 ∗ 0,1,2 1 0 ∗ 0,1,2
∗∗ ∗∗
is an arbitrary finite set, disjoint from the set , and where V ⊂ 0,1,2 ∗01 the symbol ∪ n V denotes the event that we have the configuration 1 1 ∗ 0,1,2 ∗01 in our window, and all the sites in V are occupied by the particles. Con1 1 ∗ 0,1,2 Z2
sider the case when V is just a single site (ζ, z) ∈ Z2 . Let us see that the same relations which were used in Subsect. 3.3, work here as well.
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
163
We need to show that K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) K 0,ζ (−z) K 1,2 (−1) K 1,ζ (−z) K 1,0 (0) K 1,1 (0) K 1,1 (−1) K 1,2 (0) K 1,ζ (1 − z) β1 det K 1,0 (1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K (1) K (1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) K 2,ζ (1 − z) 2,0 2,1 K (z) K (z) K (z − 1) K (z − 1) K ζ,ζ (0) ζ,0 ζ,1 ζ,1 ζ,2 K 0,0 (0) K 0,1 (0) K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) K 0,ζ (−z) K 1,2 (−1) K 1,ζ (−z) K 1,0 (0) K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,1 (−1) K 1,1 (1) K 1,1 (0) K 1,2 (0) K 1,ζ (1 − z) . = β2 det K 1,0 (1) K (1) K 2,1 (1) K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) K 2,ζ (1 − z) 2,0 K (z) K (z) K (z − 1) K (z − 1) K (0) ζ,0
ζ,1
ζ,1
ζ,2
ζ,ζ
(27) It is immediate to see that the same strategy which was used in the simplest case 4 × 4 works: application of (20) turns the determinant K 0,0 (0) K 1,0 (0) det K 1,0 (1) K (1) 2,0 K (z) ζ,0
K 0,1 (0) β1 K 0,1 (−1) K 0,2 (−1) K 0,ζ (−z) K 1,1 (0) β1 K 1,1 (−1) K 1,2 (−1) K 1,ζ (−z) K 1,1 (1) β1 K 1,1 (0) − 1 K 1,2 (0) K 1,ζ (1 − z) K 2,1 (1) β1 K 2,1 (0) K 2,2 (0) K 2,ζ (1 − z) K ζ,1 (z) β1 K ζ,1 (z − 1) K ζ,2 (z − 1) K ζ,ζ (0)
into K 0,0 (0) K 1,0 (0) det K 1,0 (1) K (1) 2,0 K (z) ζ,0
K 0,1 (0) K 1,1 (0) K 1,1 (1) K 2,1 (1) K ζ,1 (z)
0 K 0,2 (−1) K 0,ζ (−z) 1 K 1,2 (−1) K 1,ζ (−z) 0 K 1,2 (0) K 1,ζ (1 − z) , 0 K 2,2 (0) K 2,ζ (1 − z) 0 K ζ,2 (z − 1) K ζ,ζ (0)
while the rhs of (27) is treated as the rhs of (23). So one sees in this way that the identities of Subsect. 3.3 work for all sets V in all the cases. 3.5. Interlacing property. General case. 1. The case ψ1 (u) = (1 − α1 u)−1 . We will show now that ⎧⎛ ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎫ ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1 ∗ 1 ∗ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 0 ∗ ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎨⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ = Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ Pr K ⎜ ... ∗ ⎟ ⎪ ⎪ ⎠ ⎪ ⎠ ⎪ ⎝ ⎝ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 0 ∗ ⎪ ⎪ 0 0 ⎪ ⎩ ⎭ ⎩ 1 ∗ 0,1 1 1 0,1 ⎭ ⎧⎛ ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎫ ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1 ∗ 1 ∗ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎨⎜ 0 1 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ +Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ + · · · + Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ , ⎪ ⎪ ⎝0 1⎠ ⎪ ⎝0 0⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ⎩ 1 0 ⎭ 1 0 0,1 ⎭ 0,1 (28)
164
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
that is, if we have a configuration with two particles, separated by a vertical string of n − 2 holes, then with probability one the next column to the right has in the lower n − 1 cells exactly one particle and n − 2 holes. (So our sum above has n − 1 terms.) This is the particle interlacing property. We will prove it simultaneously with the complementary (reflected) statement: ⎧⎛ ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎫ ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∗ 1 ⎪ ⎪ 0 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ ∗ 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎨⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ = Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ ⎪ ⎪ ⎝∗ 0⎠ ⎪ ⎝1 0⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ∗ 1 ⎭ ⎩ ∗ 1 ⎭ 0,1 0,1 ⎧⎛ ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎫ ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 0 1 1 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 1 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎨⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ + · · · + Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ + Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ . ⎪ ⎪ ⎝0 0⎠ ⎪ ⎝0 0⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ∗ 1 ⎭ ⎩ ∗ 1 ⎭ 0,1 0,1 (29) The proof goes by induction on the length of the aforementioned string of the holes. The case of the empty string – i.e. n = 2 – was dealt with in Sect. 3.2. So suppose that we know already the relations (28) and (29) for all n < k. Let us prove them for n = k. First we can exclude the case in (28) when we have at least ⎛ two⎞particles in the second 0 1 ⎜0 0⎟ ⎟ ⎜ column. Indeed, that means that we have there a pattern ⎜ ... ... ⎟ with the string of ⎝0 0⎠ ∗ 1 0,1 holes in the second column of length less than k − 2, which is ruled out by induction hypothesis for (29). The same argument applies⎫to (29). ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎪ ⎪ 1 ∗ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 0 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎜ = 0, where we have k − 1 holes in It remains to show that Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ ⎪ ⎝0 0⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 1 0 ⎭ 0,1
the right column. Here we note that the above probability depends on K only through one parameter, α1 . So without loss of generality we can assume that we are in the “αα” situation, i.e. that ψ0 (u) = (1 − α0 u)−1 . Let us write our event as a sum of four events: ⎛
1 ⎜0 ⎜ ⎜ ... ⎝0 1
⎞ ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ ⎛ ∗ 1 1 ∗ 1 1 ∗ 0⎟ ⎜∗ 0 0 ⎟ ⎜∗ 0 0 ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ... ⎟ = ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ + ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ ⎠ ⎠ ⎝ ⎝ 0 1 0 0 0 0 0⎠ 0 0,1 ∗ 1 0 −1,0,1 ∗ 1 0 −1,0,1 ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ ⎛ 0 1 ∗ 0 1 ∗ ⎜∗ 0 0 ⎟ ⎜∗ 0 0 ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ + ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ + ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ . ⎝1 0 0 ⎠ ⎝0 0 0 ⎠ ∗ 1 0 −1,0,1 ∗ 1 0 −1,0,1
(30)
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
165
The first one has zero probability; this is our induction assumption. And to every one of the remaining events we can apply the move transformation (24), which makes the two particles in the middle column become one unit closer. After that we get a configuration, which has zero probability by induction hypothesis. This ends the proof of our statement. 2. The case ψ1 (u) = (1 + β1 u)−1 . We will show that ⎧⎛ ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎫ ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 0 ∗ ⎪ ⎪ 0 0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 1 ∗ ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎨⎜ 1 1 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ = Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ Pr K ⎜ ... ∗ ⎟ ⎪ ⎪ ⎝ 1 ∗⎠ ⎪ ⎝1 1⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 0 ∗ ⎭ ⎩ 0 ∗ ⎭ 0,1 0,1 ⎧⎛ ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ 0 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 1 0 ⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ⎜ + Pr K ⎜ ... ... ⎟ + · · · + Pr K ⎪ ⎠ ⎪ ⎝ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 0 ∗ ⎭ 0,1
⎧⎛ ⎪ 0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨⎜ 1 ⎜ ⎜ ... ⎪ ⎝1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 0
⎞ ⎫ ⎪ 1 ⎪ ⎪ 1⎟ ⎪ ⎬ ⎟ ... ⎟ . ⎪ 0⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∗ 0,1 ⎭ (31)
Here in the lhs we have the probability of the event that two holes are separated by the string of n −2 particles, while in the rhs we have a sum of probabilities of the n −1 events that the right column has exactly one hole in the upper n − 1 positions. This is the hole interlacing. Again, we will prove it by induction on n; the case n = 2 was established above, see (22). We will treat simultaneously the reflected event as well (compare with (28) and (29).) The presence of more than one hole in the right⎛column ⎞ in (31) is again ruled out 0 1 ⎜1 1⎟ ⎟ ⎜ by induction. To study the probability of the event ⎜ ... ... ⎟ we can without loss of ⎝1 1⎠ 0 ∗ 0,1 generality consider the case ψ0 (u) = (1 + β0 u)−1 , and we write ⎛
0 ⎜1 ⎜ ⎜ ... ⎝1 0
⎞ ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ ⎛ ∗ 0 1 ∗ 0 1 1 1⎟ ⎜0 1 1 ⎟ ⎜1 1 1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ... ⎟ = ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ + ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ ⎝∗ 1 1 ⎠ ⎝∗ 1 1 ⎠ 1⎠ 0 0 ∗ −1,0,1 0 0 ∗ −1,0,1 ∗ 0,1 ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ ⎛ ∗ 0 1 ∗ 0 1 ⎜0 1 1 ⎟ ⎜1 1 1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ + ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ + ⎜ ∗ ... ... ⎟ . ⎝∗ 1 1 ⎠ ⎝∗ 1 1 ⎠ 1 0 ∗ −1,0,1 1 0 ∗ −1,0,1
The first event is ruled out by induction, while the remaining three are movable, and the application of the corresponding move (the first one described in Sect. 3.3) reduces the length of the string of particles in the middle column (0th one) by one, so the remaining three events also have vanishing probability.
166
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
3.6. The downward paths. We will show now that the case of the functions ψ-s of the −1 and 1 + βk− u −1 can be reduced to the one when all ψk (u) are types 1 − αk− u −1 −1 of the form 1 − αk+ u or 1 + βk+ u . Indeed, we have the identities
−1
−1 = −αk− u 1 − (αk− )−1 u , 1 − αk− u −1
1 + βk− u −1 = βk− u −1 1 + (βk− )−1 u . Observe that multiplication of ψk (u) by a constant c leads to the conjugation of the kernel: ⎧ ⎨ cK (σ, x; τ, y) if σ ≥ k > τ, K (σ, x; τ, y) → c−1 K (σ, x; τ, y) if τ ≥ k > σ, ⎩ K (σ, x; τ, y) otherwise, which does not affect the determinants for the correlation functions. On the other hand, the multiplication of ψk (u) by u in the formula for the kernel is equivalent to the following transformation of the state space Z2 : (σ, x) if σ < k, (σ, x) → (σ, x + 1) if σ ≥ k. Under this transformation every configuration which was satisfying the downward interlacing (for particles or for holes) in the column {(σ, x) : σ = k, k + 1} will satisfy the upward interlacing, so the new configuration can still be associated with a collection of paths. It is straightforward to see that the change of the weight of a path affected by an elementary move is the same in both path configurations, compare the definitions (5), (7), (9), (11). That proves our statement. 3.7. The Gibbs property. Now we are in the position to check the Gibbs property of the field n viewed as the probability distribution over the lattice paths built from the patterns (4), (6), (8) and (10). After the preliminary work we did it is almost immediate. Indeed, we have already checked in Subsects. 3.3, 3.4 that the ratio of the probabilities of two configurations n V and n V which differ by an allowed move of one particle depends only on the type of the move and equals the exponent of the action difference for the corresponding paths. Let us take, in particular, any (finite simply-connected) box ⊂ Z2 , and fix the sets P and Q of the entrance and exit points of the paths on the boundary ∂. Note that in that case any allowed configuration of paths in can be obtained from any other by a sequence of elementary moves. This claim is essentially obvious; it follows from the fact that there is a minimal path joining any two points (if the set of paths joining the two points is nonempty), and induction on the number of paths. That finishes our proof. 4. Positivity ∞ Denote by the set of elements = (α, β, γ ) ∈ R∞ + × R+ × R+ such that ∞ ( i=1
αi < ∞,
∞ ( i=1
βi < ∞.
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
167
For ∈ , we denote by ψ the following meromorphic functions on C: ψ (u) = eγ u
∞ 1 + βju . 1 − αju
(32)
j=1
For + , − ∈ , we also set ψ + , − (u) = ψ + (u)ψ − (u −1 ). Coordinates of ± will be denoted as αi± , βi± , γ ± . Our goal is to prove the following statement, which is a slight generalization of Theorem 4.4 in [2]. Theorem 2. Fix a complex number z with z > 0 and denote by C± any contour that joins z¯ and z and crosses the real axis at a point of R± . Then for any doubly infinite sequences { + [k], − [k]}k∈Z of elements in , there exists a (unique) determinantal point process on Z × Z with the correlation kernel ⎧ −1 τ ⎪ 1 du ⎪ ⎪ ψ + [k], − [k] (u) , σ ≤ τ, ⎪ ⎨ 2πi x−y+1 u C+ k=σ +1 K (σ, x; τ, y) = (33) σ ⎪ 1 du ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ψ + [k], − [k] (u) x−y+1 , σ > τ. ⎩ 2πi u C− k=τ +1
Comments. 1. The kernels considered in the previous sections are the ones with each of ψ + [k], − [k] (u) having the form either (1 − αk u)−1 or (1 + βk u). 2. The classical fact that lies at the foundation of this theorem is that functions ψ (u) are generating functions of the totally positive sequences. This statement was independently proved by Aissen-Edrei-Schoenberg-Whitney in 1951 [1,7], and by Thoma in 1964 [18]. An excellent exposition of deep relations of this result to representation theory of the infinite symmetric group can be found in Kerov’s book [12]. 3. The equal time restriction of the kernel above is equivalent to the discrete sine kernel on Z; for any τ ∈ Z, 1 dζ |z| y sin((arg z)(x − y)) K (τ, x; τ, y) = . = x x−y+1 2πi C+ ζ |z| π(x − y) In particular, the density of particles is equal to arg z/π everywhere. The kernels K (σ, x; τ, y) may be viewed as extensions of the discrete sine kernel. 4. The class of the random point processes afforded by this theorem is closed under • projections of Z × Z to A × Z, where A = {an }+∞ n=−∞ is any doubly infinite sequence of integers; • shifts and reflection of either of the two coordinates of Z × Z; • particle-hole inversion on any subset of the form B × Z, where B ⊂ Z. 5. The projection of the process to the set {1, . . . , T } × Z depends only on ± [k] with k = 1, . . . , T . We will give two proofs of the theorem; one is essentially a reduction to Theorem 4.4 from [2], while the second one is “more constructive” — it explains how to build our process from a deformation of the uniform measure on large plane partitions.
168
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
Proof 1. Observe that the change of the integration variable u = r v, r > 0, replaces the formula for the kernel by a similar one with z → z/r , all coordinates of k+ ’s multiplied by r , all coordinates of k− ’s divided by r , and the integral itself multiplied by r y−x . The prefactor r y−x cancels out in the determinants of the form det[K (σi , xi ; σ j , x j )], thus it can be removed. Hence, it suffices to prove the claim for z with |z| = 1. Observe further, that multiplication of ψ + [m], − [m] (u) by u n in the formula for the kernel above is equivalent to the following transformation of the state space Z × Z: (σ, x), σ < m, (σ, x) → (σ, x + n), σ ≥ m. On the other hand, multiplication of ψ + [m], − [m] (u) by a constant c leads to the conjugation of the kernel ⎧ ⎪ σ + 1 ≤ m ≤ τ, ⎨cK (σ, x; τ, y), K (σ, x; τ, y) → c−1 K (σ, x; τ, y), τ + 1 ≤ m ≤ σ, ⎪ ⎩ K (σ, x; τ, y), otherwise, which does not affect the determinants for the correlation functions. The identities 1 − αu = −αu · (1 − α −1 u −1 ),
1 + βu = βu · (1 + β −1 u −1 )
then show that we can freely replace parameters αi+ [k] = α and βi+ [k] = β by αi− [k] = α −1 and βi− [k] = β −1 and the other way around, and such changes do not affect the statement that the kernel defines a random point process. Using such replacements we can then choose the parameters in such a way that all αi± [k], βi± [k] are in the segment [0, 1]. Since the statement of the theorem is stable under limit transitions, we can assume that all the parameters are strictly smaller than 1 without loss of generality. But if the parameters satisfy the conditions |z| = 1,
αi± [k], βi± [k] < 1, for all i, k
then our claim is exactly Theorem 4.4 in [2].
Proof 2. The argument is based on the Schur process of [14] (see also [8]) and can be constructed as follows. We use the definitions and notation of [14]. Let us construct a deformation of the Schur process. More precisely, the Schur process is parameterized by two sequences {φ + [m], φ − [m]}m∈Z+ 1 of functions holomorphic 2 and nonvanishing in some neighborhood of the interior (resp., exterior) of the unit disc. In order for the process to assign positive weights, the functions φ ± have to be such that all minors of the triangular Toeplitz matrices with symbols φ + (u) and φ − (u −1 ) are nonnegative; this is exactly the content of Comment 2 above. The concrete example of the Schur process studied asymptotically in [14] and [8] corresponds to the choice (1 − q −m u)−1 , m < 0, + φ [m](u) = 1, m > 0, 1, m < 0, φ − [m](u) = (1 − q m u −1 )−1 , m > 0.
Gibbs Ensembles of Nonintersecting Paths
169
Let us choose N consecutive values of m, say M, M + 1, . . . , M + N − 1, and replace the corresponding functions φ ± as follows: )+ [M + k](u) = ψ + [k] (u), φ
)− [M + k](u) = ψ − [k] (u −1 ), φ
for k = 0, . . . , N − 1. Taking the point of the limit shape with τ = 0 (near the corner), one readily sees that such a modification produces no impact on the asymptotic analysis of [14] until the * (2) very last stage — the computation of the residue denoted as in Sect. 3.1.6. The residue is an integral of the expression in formula (26) without the factor (z − w) in the denominator and with z = w, where (t, z) is defined by the formula (20). The computation gives 1 2πi
zc
ti
z¯ c m=t j
dw 1 φ + [m](w −1 )φ − [m](w −1 ) w h i −h j +(ti −t j )/2+1 +1
for ti ≥ t j and 1 − 2πi
z¯ c
tj
z c m=t +1 i
φ + [m](w −1 )φ − [m](w −1 )
dw w h i −h j +(ti −t j )/2+1
for ti < t j . If we now choose M in such a way that ti and t j lie in the set M, M + )± [M + k](u) we arrive at 1, . . . , M + N − 1, then substituting the deformed functions φ the kernel (33) with the change of variables tj ti −1 −1 → (y, x). w → u , z c → z , (ti , t j ) → (τ, σ ), hi + , h j + 2 2 Thus, we showed that determinants made from the kernel (33) are limits of the correlation functions of certain point processes.
References 1. Aissen, M., Edrei, A., Schoenberg, I.J., Whitney, A.: On the Generating Functions of Totally Positive Sequences. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 37(5), 303–307 (1951) 2. Borodin, A.: Periodic Schur process and cylindric partitions. Duke Math. J. 140(3), 391–468 (2006) 3. Borodin, A., Okounkov, A., Olshanski, G.: Asymptotics of Plancherel measures for symmetric groups. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 13, 491–515 (2000) 4. Burton, R., Pemantle, R.: Local characteristics, entropy and limit theorems for spanning trees and domino tilings via transfer-impedances. Ann. Probab. 21(3), 1329–1371 (1993) 5. Cerf, R., Kenyon, R.: The low-temperature expansion of the Wulff crystal in the 3D Ising model. Commun. Math. Phys. 222, 147–179 (2001) 6. Cohn, H., Kenyon, R., Propp, J.: A variational principle for domino tilings. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 14(2), 297– 346 (2001) 7. Edrei, A.: On the generating function of a doubly-infinite, totally positive sequence. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 74(3), 367–383 (1953) 8. Ferrari, P.L., Spohn, H.: Step fluctations for a faceted crystal. J. Stat. Phys. 113, 1–46 (2003) 9. Johansson, K.: Non-intersecting paths, random tilings and random matrices. Probab. Theory Rel. Fields 123(2), 225–280 (2002) 10. Johansson, K.: The arctic circle boundary and the Airy process. Ann. Probab. 33, 1–30 (2005) 11. Kenyon, R.: Local statistics of lattice dimers. Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré Probab. Statist. 33(5), 591–618 (1997)
170
A. Borodin, S. Shlosman
12. Kerov, S.V.: Asymptotic Representation Theory of the Symmetric Group and its Applications in Analysis. Translations of Mathematical Monographs, 219, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 2003 13. Luby, M., Randall, D., Sinclair, A.J.: Markov chain algorithms for planar lattice structures. SIAM J. Comp. 31, 167–192 (2001) 14. Okounkov, A., Reshetikhin, N.: Correlation function of Schur process with application to local geometry of a random 3-dimensional Young diagram. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 16(3), 581–603 (2003) 15. Sheffield, S.: Random Surfaces. Astérisque 304 (2005) 16. Shlosman, S.: Geometric variational problems of statistical mechanics and of combinatorics. Probabilistic techniques in equilibrium and nonequilibrium statistical physics. J. Math. Phys. 41(3), 1364–1370 (2000) 17. Shlosman, S.: The Wulff construction in statistical mechanics and in combinatorics. Russ. Math. Surv. 56(4), 709–738 (2001) 18. Thoma, E.: Die unzerlegbaren, positive-definiten Klassenfunktionen der abzählbar unendlichen, symmetrischen Gruppe. Math. Zeitschr. 85, 40–61 (1964) Communicated by H. Spohn
Commun. Math. Phys. 293, 171–183 (2010) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-009-0909-y
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Universal Approximation of Multi-copy States and Universal Quantum Lossless Data Compression Masahito Hayashi Graduate School of Information Sciences, Tohoku University, Sendai, 980-8579, Japan. E-mail: [email protected] Received: 18 July 2008 / Accepted: 19 May 2009 Published online: 1 September 2009 – © Springer-Verlag 2009
Abstract: We have proven that there exists a quantum state approximating any multi-copy state universally when we measure the error by means of the normalized relative entropy. While the qubit case was proven by Krattenthaler and Slater (IEEE Trans. IT 46, 810–819 (2009)), the general case has been open for more than ten years. For a deeper analysis, we have solved the mini-max problem concerning ‘approximation error’ up to the second order. Furthermore, we have applied this result to quantum lossless data compression, and have constructed a universal quantum lossless data compression. 1. Introduction Does there exist a quantum state approximating the n-copy state universally? If we measure the difference by a measure satisfying the axioms for distance, such a state does not exist. However, if we measure the difference between two states in terms of the normalized relative entropy, such a state does exist. For the classical (i.e., diagonal or commutative) case, Clarke and Barron [1] showed that the mixture state of n-fold tensor product states approximates all of the n-fold tensor product states. More precisely, they proved the following. Consider the set of diagonal density matrices {ρθ |θ ∈ ⊂ Rm } on H := Cd , and a prior distribution w(θ ) on . When their diagonal elements are twice continuously differentiable for the parameter θ and several regularity conditions for ρθ hold, they showed that the mixture state σw,n := ρθ w(θ )dθ satisfies the relation n m + log det I (θ ) − log w(θ ), D(ρθ⊗n σw,n ) ∼ (1) = log 2 2π e where I (θ ) is the Fisher information matrix (see [2]). In this paper, logarithms are taken to base 2. In particular, Clarke and Barron [3] proved that the mini-max of √ the constant det I (θ) √ term is given when the prior w is chosen as the so-called Jeffreys’ prior . det I (θ )dθ If we replace the relative entropy by another measure satisfying the axioms for distance and additivity D(ρ ⊗n σ ⊗n ) = n D(ρσ ), no state satisfies the relation (1)
172
M. Hayashi
and the measure D(ρ ⊗n σn ) behaves as O(n). That is, since the relative entropy does not satisfy the axioms for distance, such a state can exist. Concerning the quantum case, in 1996, Krattenthaler and Slater[4] derived its quantum extension for the qubit case. However, the general case has remained an open problem for more than ten years. Their paper did not provide a complete solution to the mini-max problem for the constant term. In this paper, we prove the existence of states σn on H⊗n satisfying D(ρ ⊗n σn ) ∼ =
d2 − 1 log n + O(1) 2
(2)
for all faithful states ρ on H, i.e., states ρ in the set S := {ρ| rank ρ = d}. Since the dimension of the state family S is d 2 − 1, the relation (2) can be regarded as a natural quantum extension of (1). More precisely, we calculate the following mini-max value: d2 − 1 log n , (3) min sup lim D(ρ ⊗n σn ) − {σn } ρ∈S n→∞ 2 which is the main result in this paper. Krattenthaler and Slater[4] treated the same problem for a restricted class of states {σn } in the qubit case. The term (3) expresses an approximation error in the sense of information processing. Recently, Hayashi [5] provided a universal coding for a classical-quantum channel. In his derivation, an approximating state σn was used instead of the true state ρ ⊗n . The reason that the code given in [5] works universally seems to be that this type of information-theoretic approximation (2) is valid. In the classical case, this relation is viewed as the asymptotic redundancy of prefixed variable-length lossless data compression[1,3]. Any distribution corresponds to the prefixed variable-length data compression via the Kraft inequality, and the minimum average length is the Shannon entropy[6]. When the code applied corresponds to the distribution σµ,n , the relation (1) expresses the asymptotic redundancy when the true state is ρ ⊗n . This fact means that a good information-theoretic approximation implies only a small amount of redundancy in the prefixed variable-length lossless data compression. That is, the relation (1) guarantees the existence of a universal variable-length lossless data compression in the classical case[1,3,7,8]. In the quantum case, it is known that there exists universal fixed-length data compression[9,10]. However, the quantum analogue of variable-length lossless data compression is not simple[11]. In order to determine the size of the memory storing the quantum information, we have to measure the length. This measurement demolishes the quantum state while the degree of the state demolition can be made infinitesimal[12]. Hence, it is impossible to interpret the length of the quantum case in the same way. Therefore, we would have to prepare a storage area of size equal to the maximum length of the given code in the framework of variable-length lossless data compression[13]. In order to avoid this problem, we regard the length of the code as the energy and treat the average energy because it is not necessary to measure the energy. In this paper, we formulate quantum variable-length lossless data compression in this way, and explain how the relative entropy D(ρ ⊗n σn ) expresses the asymptotic redundancy. This paper is organized as follows: In Sect. 2, we present some basic results of representation theory, and show (2). In Sect. 3, using the relations given in Sect. 2, we calculate (3). In Sect. 4, we numerically calculate (3) in the qubit case, and compare the result of Krattenthaler and Slater [4]. In Sect. 5, we treat quantum variable-length lossless data compression, and apply our result to this topic.
Universal Approximation of Multi-copy States
173
2. Representation Theory and Approximation of Multi-copy States In order to treat approximation in an information-theoretic sense, we consider the dual representation of the n-fold tensor product space by the special unitary group SU(d) and the n th symmetric group Sn . (Christandl[14] contains a good survey of representation theory for quantum information.) For this purpose, we focus on the Young diagram. When a vector of integers n = (n 1 , n 2 , . . . , n d ) satisfies the condition n 1 ≥ n 2 ≥ · · · ≥ n d ≥ 0 d and i=1 n i = n, the vector n is called a Young diagram (frame) of size n and depth d; the set of such vectors is denoted by Ynd . The size of this set is constrained by the inequality |Ynd | ≤ (n + 1)d−1 .
(4)
Since the sets {(n s(i) )|n ∈ Ynd } and {(n s (i) )|n ∈ Ynd } are distinct for any s = s ∈ Sd , n d−1 the relation |{n| i n i = n}| ∼ implies the following asymptotic behavior of the = (d−1)! d cardinality |Yn |: |Ynd | ∼ =
n d−1 . d!(d − 1)!
(5)
Using the Young diagram, we can characterize the irreducible decomposition of the natural action of SU (d) and Sn on the tensor space H⊗n : H⊗n = Un ⊗ Vn , n∈Ynd
where Un is the irreducible representation space of SU(d) characterized by n, and Vn is the irreducible representation space of the n th symmetric group Sn characterized by n. Here, we denote the representation of the n th symmetric group Sn by V : Sn s → Vs . According to Weyl’s dimension formula, the dimension of Un can be expressed as dim Un =
ni − n j + j − i d(d−1)
(6)
i< j
for any n ∈ Ynd , That is, for a given probability distribution p = ( p1 , . . . , pd ) on {1, . . . , d} satisfying the condition p1 > p2 > · · · > pd , when ( p1 , . . . , pd ) = ( nn1 , . . . , nnd ), d(d−1) i< j ( pi − p j ) ∼ dim Un = n 2 . (7) d−1 d−2 1 2 3 · · · (d − 1) Then, we denote the projection to the subspace Un ⊗ Vn by In , and define the following. ρn :=
1 dim Un ⊗ Vn
In , σU,n :=
n∈Ynd
1 ρn . |Ynd |
For any state ρ and any Young diagram n ∈ Ynd , the following relation holds: dim Un ρn ≥ In ρ ⊗n In .
(8)
174
M. Hayashi
Thus, (4), (6), and (8) yield the inequality (n + 1)
(d+2)(d−1) 2
σU,n ≥ ρ ⊗n .
(9)
Since σU,n is commutative with ρ ⊗n , we have (d + 2)(d − 1) log(n + 1) + log σU,n ≥ log ρ ⊗n . 2 Thus, we obtain (d + 2)(d − 1) log(n + 1). 2
D(ρ ⊗n σU,n ) = Tr ρ ⊗n (log ρ ⊗n − log σU,n ) ≤
Therefore, the state σU,n universally approximates the state ρ ⊗n in the sense of the normalized quantum relative entropy: 1 D(ρ ⊗n σU,n ) → 0. n Now, we calculate the value D(ρ ⊗n σU,n ) more precisely. In the following calculation, we focus on the set Y d := { p = ( p1 , p2 , . . . , pd−1 , 1 − p1 − · · · − pd−1 )| p1 > p2 > · · · > pd−1 > 1 − p1 − · · · − pd−1 > 0} of the probability distributions on {1, . . . , d}, and the density ρ( p) =
d
pi |ii|,
i=1 d is the standard orthonormal basis of H. Thus, for any state ρ, there where {|i}i=1 exist ∈ SU(d)/U (1)d−1 and p ∈ Y d such that ρ = ρ p, := U ρ( p)U† , where U is a representative of . In this calculation, it is essential to calculate the average of the random variable log |Ynd | + log dim Un + log dim Vn under the distribution Q p (n) := Tr ρ( p)⊗n In . In order to treat n∈Ynd Q p (n) log dim Vn asymptotically,
Matsumoto and Hayashi [15] introduced the quantity nn!! := Appendix D,1 they showed that
Q p (n)(log dim Vn − log
n∈Ynd
n! n 1 !n 2 !···n d ! .
In their
n! ) n!
sgn(s) i p δs(i) i< j ( pi − p j ) i ∼ log = δs(i) i< j ( pi − p j ) p s∈Sd
= log
i< j
i
i
sgn(s) i p δs(i) δs(i) i ( pi − p j ) − pi , log i< j ( pi − p j ) s∈Sd
(10)
i
1 Appendix D of [15] contains three systematic typos. In order to recover the correct meaning, replace S , n i > j, and n by Sd , i < j, and nπ , respectively.
Universal Approximation of Multi-copy States
175
δs(i) where δi := d − i and we have applied the formula = s∈Sd sgn(s) i pi i< j ( pi − p j ). In their Appendix C, they calculated n∈Ynd Q p (n) as
Q p (n) log
n∈Ynd
d −1 1 n! ∼ d −1 log n − log 2π e − log pi . = H ( p)n − n! 2 2 2
(11)
i
The combination of (5), (7), (10), and (11) yields
P(n)(log |Ynd | + log dim Un + log dim Vn )
n∈Ynd
∼ = H ( p)n + log
i< j
δs(i) sgn(s) i p δs(i) i log ( pi − p j ) − pi i< j ( pi − p j ) s∈Sd
d −1 1 d −1 log n − log 2π e − − log pi 2 2 2 i n d(d−1) i< j ( pi − p j ) n d−1 + log d−1 d−2 + log d!(d − 1)! 2 3 · · · (d − 1)1 2 d −1 d −1 ∼ log n − log 2π e = H ( p)n + 2 2 − log 2d−1 3d−2 · · · (d − 1)1 − log d!(d − 1)! + 2 log ( pi − p j )
−
i
i< j
δs(i) i pi
δs(i) 1 sgn(s) log pi − log pi 2 i< j ( pi − p j )
s∈Sd
∼ = H ( p)n +
i
d2
i
−1 log n + Cd − log d!(d − 1)! + C( p), 2
where d −1 log 2π e − log 2d−1 3d−2 · · · (d − 1)1 , 2 δs(i) sgn(s) i p δs(i) 1 i log pi + 2 log ( pi − p j ) − log pi . C( p) := − 2 i< j ( pi − p j ) Cd := −
s∈Sd
i
i< j
Hence, D(ρ ⊗n σU,n ) = − Tr ρ ⊗n log σU,n − n H (ρ) d2 − 1 ∼ log n + Cd − log d!(d − 1)! + C( p). = 2
i
176
M. Hayashi
3. Mini-max Problem From the discussion of the above section, it is possible to reduce the asymptotic 2 approximation error D(ρ ⊗n σU,n ) to d 2−1 log n universally. In this section, we treat the mini-max problem concerning the constant term, which is the second-order term. The following is our main result. Theorem 1. We obtain the following mini-max value:
d2 − 1 ⊗n log n = Cd + log eC( p) d p, min sup lim D(ρ σn ) − {σn } ρ∈S n→∞ 2 Yd
(12)
where d p := dp1 dp2 . . . pd−1 . The above mini-max value is realized when we choose C( n n) . the mixture state σ J,n := n∈Ynd Jn (n)ρn with the distribution Jn (n) := e n
n ∈Ynd
eC(
n )
This mini-max value is also attained by the mixture state σ˜ J,n := Y d ρ( p)⊗n J ( p)d p, ⊗n mixture with where ρ( p) is† the respect to the invariant measure µ on SU(d), i.e., ⊗n µ(dU ) = ρ ⊗n d. In addition, when the state σ is σ (Uρ( p)U ) ˜ J,n , n J,n or σ p, SU(d) the limit of (12) exists. Since the Jeffreys’ prior gives the mini-max solution in the classical case, the distribution J ( p)d pd can be regarded as a quantum extension of Jeffreys’ prior. Proof. Since the state ρ ⊗n is invariant under permutation, D(ρ ⊗n σn ) = − Tr[ρ ⊗n log σn ] − n H (ρ) is equal to − Tr[ρ ⊗n log Vs σn Vs† ] − n H (ρ) for any s ∈ Sn . Thus, the operator convexity of the function x → − log x implies that − Tr[ρ ⊗n log σn ] − n H (ρ) =
1 Tr[ρ ⊗n (− log Vs σn Vs† )] − n H (ρ) |Sn |
s∈Sn
≥ − Tr[ρ ⊗n log
1 Vs σn Vs† ] − n H (ρ). |Sn |
s∈Sn
Since the state s∈Sn |S1n | Vs σn Vs† is invariant under the action of Sn , we can restrict our states σn in (12) to permutation-invariant states. Due to the unitary covariance and operator convexity of the function x → − log x, the invariant measure µ on SU(d) satisfies d2 − 1 ⊗n sup lim D(ρ σn ) − log n 2 ρ n→∞ d2 − 1 = sup sup lim − Tr ρ( p)⊗n log U ⊗n σn (U ⊗n )† − n H ( p) − log n 2 p U ∈SU(d) n→∞
d2 − 1 ≥ sup lim − log n Tr ρ( p)⊗n log U ⊗n σn (U ⊗n )† µ(dU ) − n H ( p) − 2 p n→∞ SU(d)
d2 − 1 ⊗n ⊗n ⊗n † = sup lim − Tr ρ( p) log n log U σn (U ) µ(dU ) − n H ( p) − 2 p n→∞ SU(d)
d2 − 1 U ⊗n σn (U ⊗n )† µ(dU ) − n H ( p) − ≥ sup lim − Tr ρ( p)⊗n log log n. 2 p n→∞ SU(d)
Universal Approximation of Multi-copy States
177
Since the state SU(d) U ⊗n σn (U ⊗n )† µ(dU ) is invariant under the action of SU(d), we can restrict our states σn in (12) to states invariant under the SU(d) action. That is, we obtain d2 − 1 inf sup lim D(ρ ⊗n σn ) − log n {σn } ρ n→∞ 2 d2 − 1 ⊗n = inf sup lim D(ρ σ Pn ,n ) − log n , {Pn } ρ n→∞ 2 where Pn is a probability measure on Ynd and σ Pn ,n := n∈Ynd Pn (n)ρn . Since
C( nn ) n ∈Ynd e n d−1
→
eC( p) d p, Yd
we have D(ρ( p)⊗n σ Pn ,n ) Pn (n) d2 − 1 ∼ log n + Cd − log d!(d − 1)! + C( p) − log 1 = 2 |Ynd |
2 d −1 ∼ log n + Cd − log d!(d − 1)! + log( eC( p ) d p ) = d 2 Y n d−1 + log J ( p) − Q p (n) log Pn (n) d!(d − 1)! n
2 d −1 ∼ log n + Cd + log eC( p ) d p = 2 Yd + Q p (n)(log J ( p) − log Pn (n) − (d − 1) log n).
(13)
n
Only the second group depends on p in (13). In order to evaluate the second group, we consider the joint distribution Q J,n ( p, n) := J ( p)Q p (n). The marginal distribution Q J,n (n)(= Y d Q J,n ( p, n)d p) approaches Jn (n) because the variable nn approaches p in probability Q p [16,12] and J ( p) is continuous. The variable p approaches nn in probability under the conditional distribution Q J,n ( p|n). Then,
Q p (n)Jn ( p) dp log J ( p) Yd Y d Jn ( p)P p (n)d p C( nn ) n n ∈Ynd e ∼ = log J ( ) = log Jn (n) + log C( p) d p n Yd e ∼ (14) = log Jn (n) + (d − 1) log n. On the other hand, since nn approaches p in the probability distribution Q p (n), the random variable log Jn (n) − (d − 1) log n approaches log J ( p) in the probability distribution Q p (n) [16,12]. That is, Q p (n)(log J ( p) − log Jn (n) − (d − 1) log n) → 0 (15) n
for any p.
178
M. Hayashi
By using (14), the supremum of the second group of (13) concerning p is evaluated as follows. Q p (n)(log J ( p) − log Pn (n) − (d − 1) log n) sup p
≥ ∼ =
n
Yd
Q p (n)(log J ( p) − log Pn (n) − (d − 1) log n)J ( p)d p
n
Jn (n)(log Jn (n) − log Pn (n)) = D(Jn Pn ) ≥ 0.
n
Hence, lim
n→∞
n d2 − 1 log n) ≥ Cd + log Pn (n)(D(ρ( )⊗n σ Pn ,n ) − n 2 n
eC( p) d p. Yd
Due to (15), equality holds when Pn (n) = Jn (n). Therefore,
d2 − 1 eC( p) d p. min sup lim D(ρ ⊗n σn ) − log n = Cd + log {σn } ρ n→∞ 2 Yd Note that existence of the minimum value has been proven here. Since the state ρ( p)⊗n has the form n∈Ynd Q p (n)ρn , the state σ˜ J,n has the form n∈Ynd Q J,n (n)ρn . Because Q J,n (n) approaches Jn (n), the state σ˜ J,n also attains the mini-max value in (12). 4. Qubit Case In the qubit case, C2 and C( p) are calculated as follows: 1 C2 = − log 2π e − log 2, 2 C( p) = 2 log( p1 − p2 ) −
p1 p2 1 log p1 + log p2 − (log p1 + log p2 ). p1 − p2 p1 − p2 2
Therefore, our optimal prior has the form CeC( p) d pd = C
1 θ 4 cos θ tan cos θ dθ d tan θ 2
with the normalizing constant C under the parametrization p1 = cos2 θ2 and p2 = sin2 θ2 (0 ≤ θ ≤ π2 ). That is, the optimal prior distribution derived here coincides with the quasi-Bures distribution (21) in Slater [20] in the qubit case. Then, the term log Y 2 eC( p) d p can be numerically calculated as the value −0.50737. We obtain 3 min sup lim (D(ρ ⊗n σn ) − log n) = −3.5545. {σn } ρ∈S n→∞ 2 On the other hand, Krattenthaler and Slater [4] focus on the one-parameter family {ζn (u)| − ∞ < u < 1}, whose elements are given as mixtures of n-copy states under invariant measures qu , as stated in (1.7) of [4]. Their numerical calculation implies that min sup lim (D(ρ ⊗n ζn (u)) − u
ρ∈S n→∞
3 log n) = −2.3956 2
(16)
Universal Approximation of Multi-copy States
179
in the logarithmic base 2. Note that they calculated the l.h.s. of (16) to be the value −1.66050 working with the natural logarithmic base. Their result does not contradict our result because we take the minimum with respect to all sequences of states {σn } whereas they take it with respect to specific sequences of states {ζn (u)}. The difference −2.3956 − (−3.5545) = 1.1589 expresses the improvement resulting from the choice of the optimal approximating state. 5. Minimization of the Average Energy In this section, we apply the result obtained to quantum variable-length lossless coding. First, we present a formulation of variable-length lossless coding. Remember that the fixed-length code is given as the pair of an encoder and a decoder, in which, the encoder is a trace preserving completely positive (TP-CP) map from the set of states on H⊗n to the set of states on (C2 )⊗k for fixed n and k, and the decoder is a trace preserving completely positive (TP-CP) map with the opposite direction[17,18]. In the variable-length code, the coding length is not determined. So, the encoded space is given as the direct sum product of the tensor product spaces of the qubit system: H⊕ :=
∞ (C2 )⊗k , k=0
which is often called the Fock space. Then, the encoder is given as a trace preserving completely positive (TP-CP) map from the set of states on H⊗n to the set of states on the Fock space H⊕ and the decoder is given as a TP-CP map with the opposite direction. When we use this space for storing quantum information, we cannot determine the length of the stored state without state demolition. Further, the encoder given by a TP-CP map is an isometry map and the decoder is given as its adjoint map; it can recover the original state perfectly. So, such a code is called a lossless code. Note that our definition is more general than that of Boström and Felbinger [11] because they assume that the compressed state of the basis state belongs to the space (C2 )⊗n , i.e., it is not a superposition of states of different length. Furthermore, when we store a quantum state in terms of a Fock state, we do not have to know the length of the stored state. From another viewpoint, the average energy is an important quantity for physical realization because a higher energy damages the communication channel and storage. Note that it is not necessary to measure the energy. In this case, it is natural to treat the Hamiltonian H := ∞ k=0 k Pk , where Pk is the projection to the space (C2 )⊗k . In this case, when the initial state is given by ρ, the average energy is given as Tr HUρU † . Hence, it is appropriate to consider the minimization of the average energy for a given ensemble {(ρi , pi )} on H⊗n . The following lemma gives a lower bound for the average energy. Theorem 2. For any lossless code Un on H⊗n , we can choose the density σ (Un ) on H⊗n such that − Tr ρ log σ (Un ) − logn log d ≤ Tr HUn ρUn†
(17)
for any state ρ of H⊗n . Its proof is given in Appendix A, Since the relation − Tr ρ p log σ (Un ) − H (ρ p ) = D(ρ p σ (Un )) holds for the mixture of the ensemble ρ p := i pi ρi , the average energy Tr HUn ρ p Un† is greater than H (ρ p ) − log2 (n log2 d).
180
M. Hayashi
Next, we consider the small class of quantum lossless codes. When we concatenate two general quantum lossless codes, the concatenated lossless code is not necessarily determined. In order to avoid this problem, we consider the prefix quantum lossless d n on H⊗n code. A code Un on H⊗n is called a prefix when there exists a basis {|ei }i=1 k and a classical prefix code φ : {1, . . . , d n } → ∪∞ k=1 {0, 1} such that Un |ei = |φ1 (i) · · · φk (i) ∈ (C2 )⊗k ⊂ H⊕ . Note that the basis {|ei } does not necessarily have the tensor product form. Since the classical concatenated code of two classical prefix codes can be defined, the concatenated quantum lossless code of two prefix quantum lossless codes can be defined. Hence, it is natural to restrict our quantum lossless codes to prefix lossless codes. Due to the construction of the prefix code, the maximum length maxi |φ(i)| exists. Then, it is sufficient to store the subspace up to this size of Fock space. As is known in information theory [6], any classical prefix code φ satisfies the Kraft inequality 2−|φ(i)| ≤ 1, i
where |φ(i)| is the coding length. For any prefix quantum lossless code Un , we choose a classical prefix code φ such that Un |ei = |φ(i). Then, a quantum version of the Kraft inequality † c := Tr 2−i|Un HUn |i |ei ei | = 2−|φ(i)| ≤ 1 (18) i
holds. That is, the state σ (Un ) :=
i 1 c
i
†
2−i|Un HUn |i |ei ei | satisfies an inequality
− Tr ρ log σ (Un ) ≤ Tr HUn ρUn† , which is tighter than (17) Conversely, as is known in information theory [6], for any probability distribution pi , there exists a prefix classical code φ such that − log pi ≤ |φ(i)| ≤ − log pi + 1.
(19)
Hence, for a given state σ on H⊗n , based on its diagonalization σ = i pi |ii|, we choose the prefix classical code φ satisfying (19). Then, we can define the prefix quantum lossless code Un by Un |ei = |φ(i). The prefix quantum lossless code Un satisfies − Tr ρ log σ ≤ Tr HUn ρUn† ≤ − Tr ρ log σ + 1 for any state ρ on H⊗n . That is, a prefix quantum lossless code almost corresponds to a quantum state. Therefore we can identify a prefix quantum lossless code with its corresponding quantum state. Since the relation − Tr ρ p log σ (Un ) − H (ρ p ) = D(ρ p σ (Un )) holds for the mixture of the ensemble ρ p , the minimum of the average energy Tr HUn ρ p Un† among prefix quantum lossless codes is almost equal to the von
Universal Approximation of Multi-copy States
181
Neumann entropy H (ρ p ). Furthermore, the inequality (17) guarantees that even though we remove the prefix condition, it is impossible to increase the average energy very much. When we use a prefix quantum lossless code corresponding to a state σ and the