Commun. Math. Phys. 211, 1 – 43 (2000)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 2000
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories Feng Xu Department of Mathematics, University of Oklahoma, 601 Elm Ave, Room 423, Norman, OK 73019, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 5 November 1998 / Accepted: 18 October 1999
Abstract: All unitary Rational Conformal Field Theories (RCFT) are conjectured to be related to unitary coset Conformal Field Theories, i.e., gauged Wess–Zumino–Witten (WZW) models with compact gauge groups. In this paper we use subfactor theory and ideas of algebraic quantum field theory to approach coset Conformal Field Theories. Two conjectures are formulated and their consequences are discussed. Some results are presented which prove the conjectures in special cases. In particular, one of the results states that a class of representations of coset WN (N ≥ 3) algebras with critical parameters are irreducible, and under the natural compositions (Connes’ fusion), they generate a finite dimensional fusion ring whose structure constants are completely determined, thus proving a long-standing conjecture about the representations of these algebras. 1. Introduction Conformal field theories (CFT) in two dimensions (cf. [MS]) have attracted great attention among mathematicians in recent years. A large class of CFT known as Rational CFT (RCFT) are more amenable than general CFT and the classification of RCFT is an outstanding open problem. Unitary coset CFT is a gauged Wess–Zumino–Witten (WZW) model with a compact Lie group G as a gauge group, and H , a subgroup of G, is gauged (cf. [KS]). It has been conjectured (cf. [MS, Witten]) that all unitary RCFT (except perhaps orbifolds, which are relatively better understood and also similar to the coset CFT, cf. p. 428 of [MS]) are related to unitary coset CFT. In the literature there have been several different mathematical approaches to CFT, see, for an example, [DL] for an approach using vertex operator algebras (cf. [B or FLM]). However, in the case of WZW model with a compact gauge group G , there is a manifestly unitary formulation of these unitary CFT using subfactor theory (cf. [J, W1 and L1]) and ideas from algebraic quantum field theory (cf. [Haag]). This formulation has various advantages besides producing the expected results, see, for an example, [X1 and X2] for some results on certain rings which seem
2
F. Xu
to be invisible in other approaches. In view of the importance of coset CFT among all RCFT, it is natural to use this unitary formulation to study unitary coset CFT, and this is the main purpose of this paper. To illustrate the new ideas in this paper we will focus on the case when G is a simply connected semisimple compact Lie group of type A, i.e., G = SU (N1 ) × SU (N2 ) × · · · × SU (Nn ). The ideas of this paper can be applied to all compact semisimple and simply connected Lie groups and we plan to consider them in separate publications. We will describe the paper in more details. In Subsect. 2.1, we define conformal precosheaf and their covariant representations as in [GL]. We then show how coset H ⊂ G naturally gives rise to an irreducible conformal precosheaf (Prop. 2.2) together with a class of covariant representations. As a first step we proved in Theorem 2.3 an irreducibility result in our setting by using vertex operators (cf. [FZ] or [Kacv]). To do this we show in Prop. 2.3 that certain smeared vertex operators are affiliated (cf. [Mv]) with some von Neumann algebras. Note that these smeared vertex operators are generally unbounded operators and one must be careful with the formal manipulations of them. Proposition 2.3 is proved by using a series of lemmas (Lemmas 1–6). It can be seen from the proof that the vertex operator algebra for coset H ⊂ G as defined on p. 67 of [Kacv] or §5 of [FZ] can be thought as of “germs” of our irreducible conformal precosheaf. Based on the physicists’ argument and well known examples, in Subsect. 2.3 two conjectures are formulated about these representations. The first conjecture states that the representations generate a finite dimensional ring under certain compositions, in other words, the CFT is really “rational”. The second conjecture is a formula about the square root of the minimal index or the statistical dimension (cf. 4.1) of these representations in terms of certain limits of characters, referred to as the “Kac–Wakimoto” formula in [L5]. Both conjectures are highly nontrivial. In particular, the second conjecture implies the Kac–Wakimoto conjecture in §2 of [KW]. The rest of the paper is devoted to the proof of the two conjectures in special cases. Section 3 is about proving the finite index by using certain commuting squares which play an important role in the type I I1 subfactor theory (cf. [Po, We]). However, we will consider factors of type I I I1 . First we introduce a notion of co-finiteness for a pair H ⊂ G. This notion is motivated by the conjectures of 2.3. Proposition 3.1, which follows from the commuting squares in Lemma 3.1, is a key observation of this paper. It implies that if H1 ⊂ H2 ⊂ G and H1 ⊂ G is cofinite, then H1 ⊂ H2 is cofinite. This leads to an infinite series of cofinite pairs in Cor. 3.1. Section 4 can be considered as an application of [X1 and X2] given the results of 3.1. We first recall some of the results of [X1] which are used in 4.2 to determine certain ring structures. These results are summarized in Theorem 4.1. Proposition 4.2 is the key observation in Sect. 4. It allows one to study the representations of coset H ⊂ G by using the theory which has been developed for G and H in some cases. Then we prove Theorem 4.2 which states that for a pair H ⊂ G which is cofinite, if similar results in Chap. V of [W2] hold for H , then Conj. 1 is also true. This result and Cor. 3.1 imply Conj. 1 for the infinite series in Cor. 4.2. In Subsect. 4.3 we study the cosets corresponding to diagonal inclusions by using Theorem 4.2 and prove in Theorem 4.3 that Conj. 2 is true for these cosets. We also prove in Theorem 4.3 a certain irreducibility result. The results in Theorem 4.3 in the special case of coset WN algebras with critical parameters have been long anticipated in both the mathematics and physics literature. For example these results are related to the conjectures in §3 and 4 of [FKW], which
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
3
are conjectured for what is known as “W-algebras”, and they are closely related to coset W -algebras in the vertex operator algebra sense (cf. [Watts]). In 4.4 we present more examples by using Theorem 4.2. The first example is the coset H ⊂ G, where H is the Cartan subgroup of G. This coset is related to Parafermions (cf. [DL]). We then consider a “Maverick” coset model considered in [DJ1] and determine the relevant ring structure. All the groups considered in this paper are assumed to be connected compact Lie groups unless stated otherwise. As we already noted before, G always denotes a simply connected semisimple compact Lie group of type A, i.e., G = SU (N1 ) × SU (N2 ) × · · · × SU (Nn ). 2. Coset CFT from Algebraic QFT Point of View 2.1. The irreducible conformal precosheaf and its representations. In this subsection we recall the basic properties enjoyed by the family of the von Neumann algebras associated with a conformal quantum field theory on S 1 (cf. [GL and FG]). By an interval in this paper we shall always mean an open connected subset I of S 1 such that I and the interior I 0 of its complement are non-empty. We shall denote by I the set of intervals in S 1 . We shall denote by P SL(2, R) the group of conformal transformations on the complex plane that preserve the orientation and leave the unit circle S 1 globally invariant. Denote by G the universal covering group of P SL(2, R). Notice that G is a simple Lie group and has a natural action on the unit circle S 1 . Denote by R(ϑ) the (lifting to G of the) rotation by an angle ϑ. This one-parameter subgroup of G will be referred to as a rotation a group (denoted by Rot) in the following. We may associate a one-parameter group with any interval I in the following way. Let I1 be the upper semi-circle, i.e. the interval {eiϑ , ϑ ∈ (0, π )}. By using the Cayley transform C : S 1 → R ∪ {∞} given by z → −i(z − 1)(z + 1)−1 , we may identify I1 with the positive real line R+ . Then we consider the one-parameter group 3I1 (s) of diffeomorphisms of S 1 such that C3I1 (s)C −1 x = es x, s, x ∈ R. We also associate with I1 the reflection rI1 given by rI1 z = z¯ , where z¯ is the complex conjugate of z. It follows from the definition that 3I1 restricts to an orientation preserving diffeomorphism of I1 , rI1 restricts to an orientation reversing diffeomorphism of I1 onto I10 . Then, if I is an interval and we choose g ∈ G such that I = gI1 we may set 3I = g3I1 g −1 , rI = grI1 g −1 . Let r be an orientation reversing isometry of S 1 with r 2 = 1 (e.g. rI1 ). The action of r on P SL(2, R) by conjugation lifts to an action σr on G, therefore we may consider the semidirect product of G ×σr Z2 . Since G ×σr Z2 is a covering of the group generated by P SL(2, R) and r, G ×σr Z2 acts on S 1 . We call (anti-)unitary a representation U of G ×σr Z2 by operators on H such that U (g) is unitary, resp. antiunitary, when g is orientation preserving, resp. orientation reversing. Now we are ready to define a conformal precosheaf.
4
F. Xu
An irreducible conformal precosheaf A of von Neumann algebras on the intervals of S 1 is a map I → A(I ) from I to the von Neumann algebras on a separable Hilbert space H that verifies the following properties: A. Isotony. If I1 , I2 are intervals and I1 ⊂ I2 , then A(I1 ) ⊂ A(I2 ). Conformal invariance. There is a nontrivial unitary representation U of G on H such that U (g)A(I )U (g)∗ = A(gI ), g ∈ G, I ∈ I. Positivity of the energy. The generator of the rotation subgroup U (R(ϑ)) is positive. Locality. If I0 , I are disjoint intervals then A(I0 ) and A(I ) commute. The lattice symbol ∨ will denote “the von Neumann algebra generated by”. Existence of the vacuum. There exists a unit vector (vacuum vector) which is U (G)invariant and cyclic for ∨I ∈I A(I ). Irreducibility. The only U (G)-invariant vectors are the scalar multiples of . The term irreducibility is due to the fact (cf. Prop. 1.2 of [GL]) that under the assumption of F ∨I ∈I A(I ) = B(H). We have the following (cf. Prop. 1.1 of [GL]): Proposition 2.1. Let A be an irreducible conformal precosheaf. The following hold: (a) Reeh–Schlieder theorem: is cyclic and separating for each von Neumann algebra A(I ), I ∈ I. (b) Bisognano–Wichmann property: U extends to an (anti-)unitary representation of G ×σr Z2 such that, for any I ∈ I, U (3I (2π t)) = 1itI , U (rI ) = JI , where 1I , JI are the modular operator and the modular conjugation associated with (A(I ), ). For each g ∈ G ×σr Z2 , U (g)A(I )U (g)∗ = A(gI ). (c) Additivity: if a family of intervals Ii covers the interval I , then A(I ) ⊂ ∨i A(Ii ). (d) Haag duality: A(I )0 = A(I 0 ).
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
5
Assume A is an irreducible conformal precosheaf as defined in the above. By Cor. B.2 of [GL], the only invariant vectors under the action of the one-parameter group U (3I (2πt)) are the scalar multiples of . This fact and (b) of Prop. 2.1 are usually referred to as the action of modular group as ergodic and geometric respectively. It follows that A(I ) is a type I I I1 factor for any I ∈ I (cf. Prop. 1.2 of [GL]). A covariant representation π of A is a family of representations πI of the von Neumann algebras A(I ), I ∈ I, on a separable Hilbert space Hπ and a unitary representation Uπ of the covering group G of P SL(2, R) such that the following properties hold: I ⊂ I¯ ⇒ πI¯ |A(I ) = πI (isotony), adUπ (g) · πI = πgI · adU (g)(covariance). A covariant representation π is called irreducible if ∨I ∈I π(A(I )) = B(Hπ ). By our definition the irreducible conformal precosheaf is in fact an irreducible representation of itself and we will call this representation the vacuum representation. Note that by Cor. B.2 of [GL], the vacuum representation is the unique (up to unitary equivalence) irreducible covariant representation which contains an eigenvector of the generator of the rotation group with lowest eigenvalue 0. A unitary equivalence class of covariant representations of A is called a superselection sector (cf. p. 17 of [GL]). The composition of two superselection sectors, similar to Connes’s fusion (cf. Chap.V of [W2]), can be defined (cf. § IV.2 of [FG] ). The composition is manifestly unitary, and this is one of the virtues of the above formulation. Now let G be the group as in the introduction. Let g = Lie(G), gC := g ⊗ C. Denote by gˆ the affine Kac–Moody algebra (cf. p. 163 of [KW]) associated to gC . Recall ˆ gˆ = gC ⊗ C[t, t −1 ] ⊕ Cc, where Cc is the 1-dimensional center of g. Denote by LG the group of smooth maps f : S 1 7→ G under pointwise multiplication. The diffeomorphism group of the circle DiffS 1 is naturally a subgroup of Aut(LG) with the action given by reparametrization. In particular G acts on LG. We will be interested in the projective unitary representations (cf. Chap. 9 of [PS]) π of LG that are both irreducible and have positive energy. This implies that π should extend to LG n Rot so that the generator of the rotation group Rot is positive. It follows from Chap. 9 of [PS] or p. 490 of [W2] that for fixed level (a finite set of positive integers, see the footnote on this page), there are only a finite number of such irreducible projective representations (cf. 4.3 for a list in the case G = SU (N )). These irreducible projective representations can be obtained by exponentiating the integrable representations of gˆ at the same level by Theorem 4.4 of [GW]. We refer the reader to III.7 of [FG] for a summary about the properties of these representations. Now let H ⊂ G be a connected Lie subgroup. Let π i be an irreducible projective representation of LG with positive energy at level L 1 on Hilbert space H i . When restricting to LH , π i is a projective representation of LH with positive energy. By the proposition on p. 484 of [W2], π i is a direct sum of irreducible projective representations of LH . Suppose when restricting to LH , H i decomposes as: X Hi,α ⊗ Hα , Hi = α
and πα are irreducible projective representations of LH on Hilbert space Hα . The set of (i, α) which appears in the above decompositions will be denoted by exp. The above 1 When G is the direct product of simple groups, L is a multi-index, i.e., L = (L , . . . , L ), where L ∈ N n 1 i corresponding to the level of the i th simple group. To save some writing we write the coset as H ⊂ GL or as H ⊂ G when the level is kept fixed in the question.
6
F. Xu
decomposition can also be obtained via exponentiation (cf. Theorem 4.4 of [GW]) from a similar decomposition (cf. (1.6.2) of [KW]) of the integrable representation of gˆ when restricting to hˆ (the affine Kac–Moody algebra associated with H ). We shall use π 0 (resp. π0 ) to denote the vacuum representation of LG (resp. LH ) on H 0 (resp. H0 ). This is the unique projective representation of LG (resp. LH ) which contains a nonzero vector, unique up to multiplication by a nonzero scalar, with the property that it is an eigenvector of the generator of rotation group with eigenvalue 0. Such vectors will be called vacuum vectors. By Theorem 3.2 of [FG] (also cf. §17 of [W2]) the vacuum representation π 0 of LG gives rise to an irreducible conformal precosheaf by the map I ∈ I → π 0 (LI G)00 on H 0 . Similarly I ∈ I → π0 (LI H )00 on H0 is an irreducible conformal precosheaf on H0 . Let (resp. 0 ) be a vacuum vector in π 0 (resp.π0 ) and assume = 0,0 ⊗ 0 with 0,0 ∈ H0,0 . We shall always assume that H ⊂ GL is not a conformal inclusion since the case of conformal inclusions has been considered in [X1]. For the definition of conformal inclusion, we refer the reader to p. 210 of [KW]. Lemma 2.2. (1) π 0 (LI H )00 is strongly additive , i.e., if I1 , I2 are the connected components of the interval I with one internal point removed, then: π 0 (LI H )00 = π 0 (LI1 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI2 H )00 ; (2) π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 H )0 = π 0 (LH )0 . Proof. Ad (1): Let P0 be the projection from H 0 onto 0,0 ⊗ H0 . Since the action of the modular group of π 0 (LJ G)00 with respect to is geometric and ergodic, it fixes globally π 0 (LJ H )00 , and by Takesaki’s theorem (cf. [MT] or p. 495 of [W2]), π 0 (LJ H )00 is a factor. So the map x ∈ π 0 (LJ H )00 → xP0 is a ∗-isomorphism (cf. p. 492 of [W2]). Hence to prove (1) we just need to show π0 (LI H )00 = π0 (LI1 H )00 ∨ π0 (LI2 H )00 . By Haag duality in Prop. 2.1 it is enough to show π0 (LI 0 H )00 = π0 (LI10 H )00 ∩ π0 (LI20 H )00 . By Reeh–Schlieder theorem in Prop. 2.1, the closed space spanned by π 0 (LJ H ) is P0 H 0 for any interval J , and by Takesaki’s theorem (cf. [MT] or (c) of Theorem on p. 495 of [W2]), π 0 (LJ H )00 = {CP0 }0 ∩ π 0 (LJ G)00 , so to prove (1) we just have to show that π 0 (LI 0 G)00 = π 0 (LI10 G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI20 G)00 . It is sufficient to show the above in the case when G is simple, and this follows from Theorem E of [W2].
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
7
Ad (2): Let I1 = I, I2 , I3 , I4 be four consecutive disjoint intervals on S 1 such that the closure of I ∪ I2 ∪ I3 ∪ I4 is S 1 . Let J1 = I10 , J3 = I30 . For any a ∈ LH , since H is connected, we can always choose a1 ∈ LJ1 H such that a1 |I˜1 = e, a1 |I˜3 = a|I˜3 , where e is the identity of G, I1 ⊂ I˜1 , I3 ⊂ I˜3 , and the closure of I˜1 and the closure of I˜3 are disjoint. Let a2 = aa1−1 , then a2 ∈ LJ3 H , and a2 a1 = a. Hence LJ1 H and LJ3 H generate LH algebraically, and π 0 (LJ1 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LJ3 H )00 = π 0 (LH )00 . By (1)
π 0 (LI2 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI3 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI4 H )00 = π 0 (LJ1 H )00 ; π 0 (LI1 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI2 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI4 H )00 = π 0 (LJ3 H )00 .
Hence and
π 0 (LJ1 H )00 ∨ π 0 (LJ3 H )00 ⊂ π 0 (LI H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI 0 H )00 , π 0 (LH )00 = π 0 (LI H )00 ∨ π 0 (LI 0 H )00 .
By taking the commutant of the above equality, the proof of (2) is complete. u t For each interval I ⊂ S 1 , we define: A(I ) := π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 P , where P is the projection from H 0 to the closed subspace H spanned by ∨J ∈I π 0 (LJ H )0 ∩π 0 (LJ G). Note that π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ⊃ π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 . On the other hand if x ∈ π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 , then x ∈ π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 H )0 , but π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 H )0 = π 0 (LH )0 by (2) of Lemma 2.1, so x ∈ π 0 (LH )0 . This shows that π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 = π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 . It follows that if x ∈ π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 , then as an operator on H 0 , it takes the form ⊕0,α B(H0,α ) ⊗ idα , and x ∈ H0,0 ⊗ 0 , so we have H ⊂ H0,0 ⊗ 0 . Proposition 2.3. The map I ∈ I → A(I ) as defined above is an irreducible conformal precosheaf. Proof. We have to check conditions A to F. A follows from π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 = π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 which is proved above, B and C follows from a lemma on p. 485 of [W2] except that we need to show that the action of G is nontrivial. Denote by U (t) the action of the g,h g,h rotation group on H0,0 and assume U (t) = exp(2π iL0 t), where L0 is the positive self-adjoint operator. Fix τ ∈ C with Imτ > 0. Then g,h
b00 (τ ) := exp((1/24)2π iτ (zm − z˙ m˙ ))trH0,0 exp(2π iτ L0 ) is a branching function (cf. 3.2.7 of [KW]), where (zm − z˙ m˙ ) is a nonnegative number defined as 1.4.2 of [KW]. We will not need the detailed expression of the branching
8
F. Xu
function in our argument, all we need to know is if H ⊂ G is not conformal, then zm − z˙ m˙ > 0 (cf. p. 210 of [KW]). Let us show that if H ⊂ G is not conformal g,h g,h which is assumed throughout this paper, then L0 6= 0. If L0 = 0, then b00 (τ ) = exp((1/24)2πiτ (zm − z˙ m˙ )) dim(H0,0 ). Since b00 (τ ) is well defined for Im τ > 0 (cf. p. 170 of [KW]), we must have dim(H0,0 ) < ∞, but by 2 (a) of Theorem B of [KW], zm˙ ) m −˙ ) as τ → 0 where b(0, 0) > 0. This is a contradiction, b00 (τ ) ∼ b(0, 0) exp( πi(z12τ g,h and shows that L0 6 = 0. So the action of G is nontrivial. F follows from the uniqueness of the vacuum (up to multiplication by a non-zero scalar) for LG. D and E follow from the definitions. u t The irreducible conformal precosheaf as in Prop. 2.2 is defined to be the irreducible conformal precosheaf of the coset H ⊂ GL . Note that when H = {e} is a trivial subgroup (e denotes the identity element in G), the irreducible conformal precosheaf defined above coincides with the one defined in III.8 of [FG]. Since the action of the modular group of π 0 (LI G)00 with respect to is geometric and ergodic, it fixes globally π 0 (LI H )00 , hence π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 , and by Takesaki’s theorem (cf. [MT] or p. 495 of [W2]), π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 is a factor. It follows that the map x ∈ π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 → xP ∈ π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 P is a ∗ isomorphism (cf. p. 492 of [W2]), and can be implemented by a unitary U1 : H 0 → H, i.e., x = U1∗ xP U1 , since π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 P is a type I I I1 factor by Prop. 2.2 and the remarks after Prop. 2.1. Let us define a class of covariant representations of A(I ) coming from the decompositions of irreducible projective representations π i of LG with respect to LH . By the remarks after Theorem B on p. 502 of [W2], for any fixed interval I , there exists a unitary map U : H i → H 0 such that π i (a) = U ∗ π 0 (a)U, ∀a ∈ LI G. For y = xP ∈ π 0 (LI H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)0 P , we define π i (y) = U ∗ U1∗ yU1 U. This gives a factor representation of A(I ). Let Pi,α be a projection from H i to a subspace Hi,α ⊗ α , where α is a unit vector in Hα . Then y ∈ A(I ) → πi,α (y) := π i (y)Pi,α is a subrepresentation of the factor representation π i , and so the map above is a ∗isomorphism (cf. p. 492 of [W2]). Denote by π i (g) the action of g ∈ G on H i . By the lemma on p. 485 of [W2], π i (g) can be written as π i (g) = ⊕α πi,α (g) ⊗ πα (g). One checks by using the definitions that the representations πi,α of A(I ) and the representations πi,α of G satisfy the covariance condition, and so πi,α are covariant representations of A(I ). The study of these representations is the main purpose of this paper. 2 The branching function here corresponds to b0 in the notations of [KW] on p. 187, where 0 always denotes 0 the vacuum representations. The assumption of Theorem B of [KW] follows from the definition 2.5.4 of [KW] when 3 = 0, λ = 0.
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
9
By the same argument as in the proof of (1) of Lemma 2.1 one can show that A(I ) as in Prop. 2.2 is strongly additive , i.e., if I1 , I2 are the connected components of the interval I with one internal point removed, then: A(I ) = A(I1 ) ∨ A(I2 ). In fact, by Haag duality in Prop. 2.1, it is sufficient to show that A(I 0 ) = A(I10 ) ∩ A(I20 ), which is equivalent to π 0 (LI 0 H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 G)00 = (π 0 (LI10 H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI10 G)00 ) ∩ (π 0 (LI20 H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI20 G)00 ) by the paragraph after Prop. 2.2. Let P be the projection defined before Prop. 2.2. By the Reeh–Schlieder theorem in Prop. 2.1 the closed space spanned by π 0 (LI 0 H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 G)00 is P H 0 for any interval I , and by Takesaki’s theorem (cf. [MT] or (c) of Theorem on p. 495 of [W2]), π 0 (LI 0 H )0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 G)00 = {CP }0 ∩ π 0 (LI 0 G)00 , so we just have to show that π 0 (LI 0 G)00 = π 0 (LI10 G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI20 G)00 . It is sufficient to show the above equation in the case G is simple, and in this case it follows from Theorem E of [W2]. Note that the inclusion (π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 ) ∨ π 0 (LI H )00 ⊂ π 0 (LI G)00 is irreducible. In fact ((π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 ) ∨ π 0 (LI H )00 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 = (π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 )0 ∩ (π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 ) = C, since π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 is a factor by the paragraph after Prop. 2.2. This fact can also be proved by using the fact that in H0,0 , the vacuum representation of A(I ) appears once and only once. We shall see in the next subsection that π0,0 is in fact the vacuum representation under general conditions. 2.2. π0,0 is the vacuum representation. As a first step in the study of representations πi,α we show that the representation of π0,0 on H0,0 is the vacuum representation. This is equivalent to H = H0,0 ⊗ 0 by definition. Theorem 2.4. Suppose H ⊂ G, and H is simply connected. Then H = H0,0 ⊗ 0 . Hence π0,0 is the vacuum representation.
10
F. Xu
The idea of the proof is to use smeared vertex operators. From the proof one can also see the close relation between our irreducible conformal precosheaf and the definition of the coset vertex operator algebra in §5 of [FZ]. In fact, the coset vertex operator algebra in §5 of [FZ] can be thought of as “germs” of ours. Let g (resp. h) be the Lie algebra of G (resp. H ). Choose a basis eα , e−α , hα in gC := g ⊗ C with α ranging over the set of roots as in §2.5 of [PS]. Let Xα := eα + e−α , Yα := i(eα − e−α ). Denote by gˆ the affine Kac–Moody algebra (cf. p. 163 of [KW]) associated to gC . Note gˆ = gC ⊗ C[t, t −1 ] ⊕ Cc, where P Cc is the 1-dimensional center of g. ˆ For X ∈ g, define X(n) := X ⊗ t n , X(z) := n X(n)z−n−1 as on p. 312 P P of [KT] and X + (z) := n<0 X(n)z−n−1 , X− (z) := n≥0 X(n)z−n−1 . Let π 0 be the vacuum representation of LG on H 0 with vacuum vector . Let D be the generator of the action of the rotation group on H 0 . For ξ ∈ H 0 , we define 0 = ∩ 0,s . ||x||s = ||(1 + D)s x||, s ∈ R. H 0,s := {x ∈ H 0 | ||x||s < ∞} and H∞ s∈R H 0 0,s Note that when s ≥ 0, H is a complete space under the norm ||.||s . H0 will denote 0 . The elements of H 0 the finite linear sum of the eigenvectors of D. Clearly H00 ⊂ H∞ 0 0 ) will be called finite energy vectors (resp. smooth vectors). The eigenvalue of (resp. H∞ D is sometimes referred to as energy. Let us recall a few elementary facts about vertex operators which will be used. See [FLM, Kacv or D] for an introduction on vertex operator algebras. Define End(H00 ) to be the space of all linear operators (not necessarily bounded) from H00 to H00 and set End(H00 )[[z, z−1 ]] := {
X
vn zn |vn ∈ End(H00 )}.
n∈Z
By the statement on p. 154 of [FZ] which follows from Theorem 2.4.1 of [FZ] there exists a linear map X ξ(m)z−m−1 ∈ End(H00 )[[z, z−1 ]] ξ ∈ H00 → V (ξ, z) = m∈Z
with the following properties: (1) ξ(−1) = ξ ; (2) If ξ = Xi1 (−1) . . . Xit (−1), then V (ξ, z) =: Xi1 (z) . . . Xit (z) :, where :, : are normal ordered products (cf. (2.38), (2.39) of [D]). V (ξ, z) is called a vertex operator of ξ . Let ψ ∈ H0,0 ⊗ 0 be an eigenvector of D with eigenvalue n ∈ N. Then ψ takes the form: X ψ= Ci1 ,...,it Xi1 (−n1 ) . . . Xit (−nt ), where the sum is finite , ni ≥ 0 and Ci1 ,...,it ∈ C. Since g is semi-simple, g = [g, g], so any X(−n), n > 1 can be expressed in terms of linear combinations of the form X(−1)Y (−1) . . . Z(−1).
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
11
Because is the vacuum, X = 0, ∀X ∈ g, so in Xi1 (−n1 ) . . . Xit (−nt ), if a certain X ∈ g appears, we can always move X to the right until it vanishes when acting on . For the above two reasons, we can assume that n1 = · · · = nt = 1. The vertex operator V (ψ, z) is then given by: V (ψ, z) =
X
Ci1 ,...,it : Xi1 (z) . . . Xit (z) :,
where :, : are normal ordered products by property (2) above. P Recall V (ψ, z) = m ψ(m)z−m−1 . Define V (m) := ψ(m + n − 1) P so we have V (ψ, z) = m V (m)z−m−n . This expression for V (ψ, z) is in accordance with the convention of [KT]. Note that V (−n) = ψ(−1) = ψ by property (1) above. P Let f = m f (m)zm be a test function with only a finite number of non-zero fm . Such f will be referred to as finite energy functions. Define ||f ||s =
X
(1 + |m|)s |f (m)|.
n∈Z
The smeared vertex operator V (ψ, f ) is defined to be: Z X 1 V (ψ, z)f dz = f (m + n − 1)V (m). V (ψ, f ) = 2πi S 1 m V (ψ, f ) is a well defined operator on H00 . Let V (ψ, f )F A be the formal adjoint of V (ψ, f ) on H00 . It is defined by the equation hV (ψ, f )x, yi = hx, V (ψ, f )F A yi, ∀x, y ∈ H00 , arises, we will where h, i is the inner product on the Hilbert space H 0 . When no confusionP write V (ψ, f ) simply as V (f ). Similarly for X ∈ g, we define X(f ) := n X(n)f (n). When the level is 1 H 0 admits a fermionic representation (cf. §13.3 of [PS] or I.6 of [W2]), and we will denote the underlying Hilbert space by F . In fact, to each simple component Gi of G there is a level 1 vacuum fermionic representation of LGi on Fi , i = 1, . . . , m, and F = F1 ⊗ F2 · · · ⊗ Fm . Lemma 2.5. (1) Let ξ ∈ H00 , and f is a finite energy function. There exists a positive integer a and c > 0 which are independent of f and ξ such that ||V (ψ, f )ξ ||s ≤ c||f |||s|+a ||ξ ||s+a ; (2) (1) is also true for V (ψ, f )F A for the same constants c and a.
12
F. Xu
Proof. Note by definition V (ψ, f ) =
Z
1 2πi
S1
V (ψ, z)f dz =
X
f (m + n − 1)V (m).
m
If we can show (1) for the case V (ψ, f ) = V (l), ∀l, then X f (l + n − 1)V (l)ξ ||s ||V (ψ, f )ξ ||s = || l∈Z
X ≤c (1 + |l|)|s|+a |f (l + n − 1)| ||ξ ||s+a l∈Z
≤ c(1 + |n|)|s|+a ||f ||s+a ||ξ ||s+a . So we just need to show (1) for the case V (ψ, f ) = V (l), ∀l. Also note that V (ψ, f ) is linear in ψ, so it is sufficient to prove (1) in the case when V (ψ, z) =: X1 (z) . . . Xn (z) :, and ξ is an eigenvector of D with eigenvalue µ. Similarly to prove (2) we just need to prove (2) in the case V (ψ, f )FA = V (l)F A , and ψ, ξ are as above. Note that : X1 (z) . . . Xn (z) : is a summation of 2n of expressions of the form Xi+ . . . Xj+ Xi−0 . . . Xj−0 . We will in fact prove the inequality in Lemma 2.5 for such expressions. This will finish the proof of Lemma 2.5 by definitions. We first prove this for level 1 and G is simple, and the representation is on F . To avoid too many subscripts we will denote the fermionic creation or annilation operators simply by a(m), since we only need to use the fact that a(m) increases the energy by m, i.e., [D, a(m)] = ma(m) on H00 and its norm is 1 in our proof. Note in terms of a(m), X X a(m − k)a(−m) − a(m)a(−m − k) X(k) = m>0
m≥0
when acting on finite energy vectors, cf. the expression in a theorem on p. 486 of [W2]. Notice that we have dropped all the subscripts here for simplicity. We will prove the lemma for V (z) = X + (z) . . . X+ (z)Y − (z) . . . Y − (z), where there are n X, Y and we have dropped the subscripts for simplicity. Then V (l)ξ is a sum of 2n expressions of the form: X a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n )ξ, where the sum is over a finite number of m1 , . . . , mn ’s, subject to a certain constraint. Let us now show by induction on n that 0 ≤ |mi | ≤ e(1 + |l| + µ), i = 1, . . . , 2n,
(1)
where e ≥ 1 depends only on V (z). When n = 1, it is contained in a proof on p. 488 of [W2]. Assume that the statement is true for k < n. Suppose V (z) = Y (z)X− (z). Then: X X Y (l − k)X(k) = Y (l − k)a(m − k)a(−m) k≥0
k≥0,m>0
−
X
k≥0,m≥0
Y (l − k)a(m)a(−m − k).
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
P
k≥0,m>0 Y (l
13
− k)a(m − k)a(−m)ξ is a sum of 2(n−1) of expressions of the form X a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n−2 )a(m − k)a(−m)ξ, k≥0,m>0,m1 ,...,m2n−2
where 0 ≤ mi ≤ e0 (1 + |µ − k| + |l − k|) by induction hypothesis, and e0 ≥ 1 depends only on Y (z). Note that the above expression is nonzero only if 0 < m ≤ µ, 0 ≤ k ≤ µ. It follows that the expression is the sum of X a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n )ξ m1 ,...,m2n
with 0 ≤ P |mi | ≤ e(1 + |l| + µ), i = 1, . . . , 2n, where e = 4e0 . The same conclusion holds for k≥0,m>0,m1 ,...,m2n−2 a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n−2 )a(m)a(−m − k)ξ . Suppose V (z) = X + (z)Y (z). Then X X X(k)Y (l − k) = a(m − k)a(−m)Y (l − k) k<0
k<0,m>0
−
X
a(m)a(−m − k)Y (l − k).
k<0,m≥0
P
k<0,m>0 a(m − k)a(−m)Y (l
X
− k)ξ is a sum of 2(n−1) of expressions of the form
a(m − k)a(−m)a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n−2 )ξ,
k<0,m>0,m1 ,...,m2n−2
where 0 ≤ mi ≤ e00 (1+|µ|+|l−k|) by induction hypothesis, and e00 ≥ 1 depends only on Y (z). Note that the above expression is nonzero only if 0 < m ≤ µ−l+k, l−µ < k < 0. It follows that the expression is the sum of X a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n )ξ m1 ,...,m2n
˜ + |l| + µ), i = 1, . . . , 2n, where e˜ = 4e00 . The same conclusion with 0 ≤ P |mi | ≤ e(1 holds for k<0,m≥0,m1 ,...,m2n−2 a(m)a(−m − k)a(m1 ) . . . a(m2n−2 )ξ . By induction (1) is proved. Since the norm of a(m) is 1, it follows from (1) that: ||V (l)ξ ||s ≤ c(1 + |µ − l|)s (1 + µ + |l|)a ||ξ ||, where c, a are independent of ξ and l. Note (1+|µ−l|)s (1+µ+|l|)a ≤ (1+µ)s+a (1+ |l|)s+a when s ≥ 0. When s < 0, the function 1 + x −s 1 + |x − l| has maximum (1 + l)−s when x ≥ 0, l ≥ 0, and 1 when x ≥ 0, l < 0. It follows that if s < 0, (1 + |µ − l|)s (1 + µ + |l|)a ≤ (1 + µ)s+a (1 + |l|)−s+a . So we have:
||V (l)ξ ||s ≤ c(1 + |l|)|s|+a ||ξ ||s+a .
14
F. Xu
Now let us consider the case when G is simple and level k > 1. On F ⊗k , Xi+ . . . Xj+ Xi−0 . . . Xj−0 is a summation of k n of expressions of the form: A := Y1 ⊗ Y2 · · · ⊗ Yl , and each Yi is of the form Xp+ . . . Xq+ Xp−0 . . . Xq−0 . Let ξ1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ξk be a vector in F ⊗k with Dξi = µi ξi , i = 1, . . . , k. Then: X Y1 (m1 )ξ1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ Yk (mk )ξk ||s ||A(l)ξ1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ξk ||s = || P
m1 ,...,mk , s
≤ (1 + |µ1 + · · · + µk − l|)
i
mi =l
X
||Y1 (m1 )ξ1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ Yk (mk )ξk ||
P
m1 ,...,mk ,
i mi =l
X
= (1 + |µ1 + · · · + µk − l|)s
P
m1 ,...,mk ,
||Y1 (m1 )ξ1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ Yk (mk )ξk ||
i mi =l,mi ≤µi
≤ (1 + µ1 + · · · + µk )s (1 + |l|)|s| × X 0 0 c0 (1 + |m1 |)b . . . (1 + |mk |)b ||ξ1 ||a 0 . . . ||ξk ||a 0 m1 ,...,mk , 0
P
i
mi =l,mi ≤µi 0
≤ c (1 + |l|)|s|+b k+k ||ξ1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ξk ||s+b0 k+k+a 0 k , P where in the second ≤ we use the result for k = 1, and in the last ≤ we used l− j 6=i µj ≤ mi ≤ µi , i = 1, . . . , k. The constants a 0 , b0 , c0 above are independent of l, ξ1 , . . . , ξk . Assume G = G1 × · · · × Gm , where Gi , i = 1, 2, . . . , m are simple factors of G. Let Fi be the level 1 vacuum fermionic representation of LGi , i = 1, . . . , m. On F1k1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ Fmkm , Xi+ . . . Xj+ Xi−0 . . . Xj−0 is still a finite sum of expressions of the form: A := Y1 ⊗ Y2 · · · ⊗ Yl , and each Yi is of the form Xp+ . . . Xq+ Xp−0 . . . Xq−0 . A similar argument as in the previous paragraph shows that the lemma is true for such expressions. Since the level (k1 , . . . , km ) vacuum representation of L(G1 × G2 × · · · × Gm ) appears t as a direct summand of F1k1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ Fmkm , we have proved the lemma. u 0 , and π 0 (V (f )) By (1) of Lemma 2.5 the domain of π 0 (V (f )) can be extended to H∞ can be defined for smooth f . When no confusion arises, we will denote π 0 (V (f )) simply by V (f ). Recall that an operator (not necessarily bounded) a is called affiliated with a von Neumann algebra M if U ∗ aU = a for any unitary U ∈ M 0 (cf. p. 16 of [Dix]). Our goal is to show that V (f ) is affiliated with a certain von Neumann algebra (cf. Prop. 2.3 below).
Lemma 2.6. Assume f is a smooth function. Then: 0 is in the domain of V (f )∗ . (1) Denote by V (f )∗ the adjoint of V (f ), then H∞ (2) The operator V (f ) is closable and (we will denote the closure of V (f ) by the same symbol) the space of finite energy vectors H00 is a core for V (f ); (3) Suppose M is a von Neumann algebra on H 0 with a generating self adjoint subset S ⊂ M, i.e., S ∗ = S and the C ∗ algebra generated by S is dense in M in strong topology. If V (f )sx = sV (f )x, ∀s ∈ S, x ∈ H00 ,
then V (f ) is affiliated with M 0 , j = 1, 2.
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
15
0 , there exists w ∈ H 0 such that Proof. Ad (1): It is enough to show that for any y ∈ H∞ 0 . hV (f )x, yi = hx, wi, ∀x ∈ H∞ 0 , then there exists a sequence of finite energy vectors x such that Note that if x ∈ H∞ n
lim ||xn − x||a = 0,
n→∞
where a > 0 is as in Lemma 2.5. By Lemma 2.5, lim ||V (f )xn − V (f )x||a = 0.
n→∞
So if hV (f )xn , yi = hxn , wi, ∀xn , then 0 . hV (f )x, yi = hx, wi, ∀x ∈ H∞
So we just have to prove the above equation for x ∈ H00 . 0 , we can First we consider the case that f is a finite energy function. Since y ∈ H∞ choose a sequence ym such that lim ||ym − y||a = 0,
m→∞
where a > 0 is as in Lemma 2.5. By definition we have hV (f )x, ym i = hx, V (f )F A ym i, and by (2) of Lemma 2.5 ||V (f )FA (ym − ym0 )|| ≤ c||f ||a ||ym − ym0 ||a . So {V (f )FA ym }m≥0 is a Cauchy sequence with a limit defined to be V (f )F A y. We can choose w = V (f )FA y. Also note that ||V (f )F A y|| ≤ c||f ||a ||y||a . Now let f be a smooth function, and choose a sequence fn of finite energy functions such that lim ||fn − f ||a = 0, n→∞
where constant a is as in Lemma 2.5. By the proof in the finite energy function case we have hV (fn )x, yi = hx, V (fn )F A yi. By Lemma 2.5 and the note above ||V (fn − f )x|| ≤ c||fn − f ||a ||x||a , ||V (fn − fn0 )F A y|| ≤ c||fn − fn0 ||a ||y||a . It follows that the sequence V (fn )F A y, ∀n > 0 is a Cauchy sequence with a limit denoted by w and hV (f )x, yi = hx, wi, ∀x ∈ H00 .
16
F. Xu
0 . Then one can find x ∈ H 0 such that Ad (2): By (1) V (f ) is closable. Let x ∈ H∞ n ||xn − x||a → 0 with a > 0 as in Lemma 2.5, and by Lemma 2.5 V (f )xn → V (f )x. This shows H00 is a core for V (f ). Ad (3): Suppose yn → y ∈ M in the strong topology and
V (f )yn x = yn V (f )x, ∀s ∈ S, and for all x ∈ the domain of V (f ), it follows immediately that yx is in the domain of V (f ) and V (f )yx = yV (f )x, ∀s ∈ S, and for all x ∈ the domain of V (f ). Since V (f )sx = sV (f )x, ∀s ∈ S, x ∈ H00 , 0 and H0 is a core for Vj (f ), it follows that V (f )sx = sV (f )x, ∀s ∈ S, and for all x ∈ the domain of V (f ). So V (f )s1 s2 . . . sn x = s1 s2 . . . sn V (f )x, ∀si ∈ S, i = 1, . . . , n and for all x ∈ the domain of V (f ) and finite n. (3) now follows from the definition. u t Suppose p ∗ = −p is a smooth test function. Assume that X ∈ g. It follows from §3 of [GW] (also cf. p. 489 of [W2]) that X(p) is essentially skew-self adjoint with core 0 to H 0 . H00 , and X(p) maps H∞ ∞ Lemma 2.7. Let X ∈ g. Then:
P j [X(p), V (ψ, f )]x = 0≤j ≤n V (X(j )ψ, j1! ddzpj f (z))x 0 , where n is the energy of ψ; for any smooth functions p, f and x ∈ H∞ 0 0 (2) If exp(tX(p))H0 ⊂ H∞ , −1 ≤ t ≤ 1, and Sup{|| exp(tX(p))x||s , −1 ≤ t ≤ 1} < ∞ for any x ∈ H00 , s > 0, then (1)
h[exp(X(p)), V (ψ, f )]x, yi Z 1 hexp(tX(p))[X(p), V (ψ, f )] exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yidt, = 0
for any smooth functions p = −p∗ , f and x ∈ H00 , y ∈ H00 . Proof. Note for x, y ∈ H00 , < X(k)V (ψ, z)x − V (ψ, z)X(k)x, y > is a polynomial in z, z−1 . We have (cf. for an example p. 327 of [KT] ): for z 6 = 0, Z 1 dwwk < X(w)V (ψ, z)x, y > < X(k)V (ψ, z)x−V (ψ, z)X(k)x, y >= 2π i Cz Z X 1 dwwk (w − z)−m−1 < V (X(m)ψ, z)x, y > = 2πi Cz m Z X 1 dwwk (w − z)−m−1 < V (X(m)ψ, z)x, y > = 2πi Cz m≤n =
X 1 d j zk hV (X(j )ψ, z)x, yi, j ! dzj
0≤j ≤n
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
17
where Cz is the boundary of a disk centered at z with radius 21 |z|, and in the last equation we used the fact that Z 1 d j zk 1 dwwk (w − z)−j −1 = 2πi Cz j ! dzj for 0 ≤ j ≤ n. Since H00 is dense, we have: X
x=
0≤j ≤n
X
=
1 2π i
Z S1
1 d j zk f (z)V (X(j )ψ, z) j ! dzj
V (X(j )ψ,
0≤j ≤n
1 d j zk f (z))x, j ! dzj
which is true for any finite energy function f and x ∈ H00 , and so it is true for any smooth P 0 by using approximation and Lemma 2.5. Let p = k function f and x ∈ H∞ k p(k)z 0 . By definition be a finite energy function and x ∈ H∞ X p(k)X(k), X(p) = k
and so (remember p =
P
k
p(k)zk )
[X(p), V (ψ, f )]x =
X
V (X(j )ψ,
0≤j ≤n
1 dj p f (z))x. j ! dzj
By Lemma 2.5 the above is also true for any smooth function p since we can always choose a sequence of functions pm , each pm is a finite energy function, and ||pm −p||s → 0 as m → ∞ for s greater than a given number which may depend on X, ψ, X(j )ψ, j = 0, . . . , n. 0 is a subset of C ∞ vectors of X(p) and V (f ) := V (ψ, f ). Let us Ad (2): Note H∞ check that the map s ∈ [0, 1] → A(s) := hexp(sX(p))V (f ) exp((1 − s)X(p))x, yi is a differentiable function with continuous derivative B(s) := hexp(sX(p))[X(p), V (f )] exp((1 − s)X(p))x, yi. Define C(s, t) := hexp(sX(p))V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi, (s, t) ∈ [0, 1] × [0, 1]. We shall repeatedly use the following elementary fact about C ∞ vectors (cf. p. 488 of [W2]): if ξ is a C ∞ vector of X(p), i.e., ξ is in the domain of X(p)n , ∀n ≥ 1, then the function u ∈ R → hexp(uX(p))ξ, ηi is a smooth function of u for any η ∈ H 0 .
18
F. Xu
0 is a subset of C ∞ vectors of X(p), it follows Since V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x ∈ H∞ that C(s, t) is a smooth function of s for fixed t. Also note
C(s, t) = hexp(sX(p))V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi = hexp((1 − t)X(p))x, V (f )∗ exp(−sX(p))yi, where we have used (1) of Lemma 2.6 and our assumption that exp(−sX(p))y ∈ 0 , 0 ≤ s ≤ 1. So C(s, t) is a smooth function of t for fixed s. We have (use (1) of H∞ Lemma 2.6 when computing derivatives with respect to t) the following partial derivatives: Cs (s, t) = hexp(sX(p))X(p)V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi, Css (s, t) = hexp(sX(p))X(p)2 V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi, Ct (s, t) = hexp(sX(p))V (f )(−X(p)) exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi, Ctt (s, t) = hexp(sX(p))V (f )X(p)2 exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi, Cst (s, t) = Cts (s, t) = hexp(sX(p))X(p)V (f )(−X(p)) exp((1 − t)X(p))x, yi. Note that all the derivatives above are smooth functions of one variable when the other variable is fixed. We have |Css (s, t)| ≤ || exp(sX(p))X(p)2 V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x|| ||y|| ≤ ||X(p)2 V (f ) exp((1 − t)X(p))x|| ||y|| ≤ C1 ||p||2a1 ||f ||a2 || exp((1 − t)X(p))x||a3 ||y|| ≤ C2 , where we used Lemma 2.5 in the third ≤, the assumption in the last ≤, and C1 , C2 , a1 , a2 , a3 are independent of s, t by Lemma 2.5 and the assumption. We can obtain similar estimates for other second partial derivatives, and so there exists a constant C 0 > 0 such that Sup{|Css (s, t)|, |Cst (s, t) = Cst (t, s)|, |Ctt (s, t)|, ∀(s, t) ∈ [0, 1] × [0, 1]} ≤ C 0 . By using the uniform bound for second partial derivatives and Taylor’s theorem in calculus, we have A(s + 1s) − A(s) = C(s + 1s, s + 1s) − C(s, s) = C(s + 1s, s + 1s) − C(s + 1s, s) + C(s + 1s, s) − C(s, s) 1 1 = Ct (s + 1s, s)1s + Ctt (s + 1s, θ1 )(1s)2 + Cs (s, s)1s + Css (θ2 , s)(1s)2 2 2 1 1 2 = (Ct (s, s) + Cts (θ3 , s)1s)1s + Ctt (s + 1s, θ1 )(1s) 2 2 1 2 + Cs (s, s)1s + Css (θ2 , s)(1s) 2 = B(s)1s + O((1s)2 ), where θi , i = 1, 2, 3 are between s and s + 1s, |O((1s)2 )| ≤
3C 0 |(1s)2 |, 2
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
19
and we have used B(s) = Ct (s, s) + Cs (s, s), which follows from definitions. It follows immediately that the derivative of A(s) is B(s) on [0,1]. A similar elementary exercise in calculus as above shows that B(s) is continuous on [0,1]. (2) now follows by the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus. u t Let T be the maximal torus of G and > = Lie(T ). By §13.3 of [PS], the level 1 vacuum representation of LT on Hilbert space F is also an irreducible representation of LG. Denote by π the representation of LG on F . Lemma 2.8. (1) Let k ∈ N and x ∈ F0 , where F0 denotes the set of finite energy vectors and v = exp(w(p)) with w ∈ >, p = −p∗ , ||p||k+1 < M. Then there exists a constant C which only depends on w, M, k and x ∈ F0 such that ||π(v)x||k ≤ C; (2) Let u = exp(X(p)), where X = Xα or X = Yα and p = −p∗ , ||p||k+1 < M. Then then there exists a constant C 0 which only depends on X, M, k and x ∈ F0 such that ||π(u)x||k ≤ C 0 ; (3) Let u = exp(X(p)), where X = Xα or X = Yα and p = −p∗ , ||p||k+1 < M. Denote by π 0 the vacuum representation of LG on H 0 . Then then there exists a constant C 00 which only depends on X, M, k and x ∈ H00 such that ||π 0 (u)x||k ≤ C 00 . Proof. Ad (1): The basic idea is contained in Prop. 9.5.15 of [PS] and we will recall the notations and facts in 9.5 [PS]. We can write LT ' H om(S 1 , T )×T ×V , where T is the subgroup of constant loops, and V is the vector space of maps a : S 1 → > with integral 0, which is regarded as a subgroup of LT by the exponential map a → exp(ia). The identity component of the central extension of LT in our case is canonically a product T × V˜ , where V˜ is the Heisenberg group associated to a skew form S defined on p. 63 of k ¯ [PS]. Write P V ⊗ C = A ⊕ A, where A is spanned by z > ⊗ C for k > 0. For a ∈ V ⊗ C, let a = n an zn , an ∈ > ⊗ C be its Fourier series. We define X (1 + |n|)s |an |, s ∈ R, ||a||s := n
and |.| is the norm on > ⊗ C induced from the restriction of the Killing form on >. The Hermitian form h, i on A defined by ha, a 0 i = −2iS(ξ¯ , η) is positive definite, where the skew form S is defined on p. 63 of [PS]. The only property we need about S is |S(a, a 0 )| ≤ ||a||0 ||a 0 ||1 , ∀a, a 0 ∈ V which follows from its definition.
20
F. Xu
The Hilbert space F is the completion of the symmetric algebra S(A) with respect to the Hermitian form above, which is extended from A to S(A) by the formula X ha1 , ai01 i . . . han , ai0n i, ha1 a2 . . . an , a10 a20 . . . an0 i = where the sum is over all permutations {i1 , . . . , in } of {1, . . . , n}. Note that for any a ∈ A, X an ea := n! n≥0
belongs to F . The vacuum vector in F is denoted by 1. As in the proof of Prop. 9.5.15 of [PS], it is sufficient to prove (1) for the case when v ∈ V˜ and x is the vacuum vector. Note that v = exp(w(p)) is identified with w(p) ˜ = ipw ∈ V˜ under the isomorphism LT ' Hom(S 1 , T ) × T × V above. The action of v on the vacuum vector 1 is given by (cf. p. 194 of [PS]): v.1 = e− 2 ha,ai ea , P where w(p) ˜ = a + a, ¯ and a(z) = i>0 ai zi . Let X i s ai zi , s ∈ N. a (s) (z) := 1
i>0
Note that ||a (s) ||0 ≤ ||a||s ≤ ||p||s |w|. We have: X
Dk an =
s1 ≥0,...sn ≥0,s1 +···+sn =k
and so
X
||D k a n || ≤
s1 ≥0,...sn ≥0,s1 +···+sn =k
k! a (s1 ) . . . a (sn ) , s1 ! . . . sn ! k! ||a (s1 ) . . . a (sn ) ||. s1 ! . . . sn !
Note that for 0 ≤ s1 , t1 ≤ k, |ha (s1 ) , a (t1 ) i| = |2S(a (s1 ) , a (t1 ) )| ≤ 2||a (s1 ) ||0 ||a (t1 ) ||1 ≤ 2||a||s1 ||a||t1 +1 ≤ 2||p||2k+1 |w|2 , hence
||a (s1 ) . . . a (sn ) ||2 = ha (s1 ) . . . a (sn ) , a (s1 ) . . . a (sn ) i ≤ n!2n |w|2n ||p||2n k+1 ,
where we used the definition of h, i on F as completion of S(A). So √ 1 ||D k a n || ≤ (n!) 2 ||p||nk+1 nk ( 2|w|)n , and ||D k v.1|| ≤ e− 2 ha,ai 1
∞ X n=1
≤
∞ X n=1
1 (n!)
1 2
1 (n!)
1 2
√ ||p||nk+1 nk ( 2|w|)n
√ ||p||nk+1 nk ( 2|w|)n .
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
21
This implies (1) by the definition of ||.||k . Ad (2): By the observation on p. 267 of [PS] there exists an element q ∈ G such that q exp(v(p))q −1 = exp(X(p)) up to a scalar as operators on F . Since the action of q commutes with the action of rotation, (2) follows from (1). Ad (3): It is enough to consider the case when G is simple. Since any level L vacuum representation appears as a direct summand of F ⊗L , we just have to prove (3) for the t representation π ⊗L , but this follows immediately from (2). u Lemma 2.9. (1) If f, p = −p∗ are smooth functions, then π 0 (exp(X(p)))π 0 (V (ψ, f ))x = π 0 (V (ψ, f ))π 0 (exp(X(p)))x for any x ∈ H00 , X ∈ Lie(H ); (2) Let f, p = −p ∗ be smooth functions on S 1 with support f ⊂ I and support p ⊂ I 0 . If X = Xα or X = Yα , then: π 0 (V (ψ, f ))π 0 (exp(X(p)))x = π 0 (exp(X(p)))π 0 (V (ψ, f ))x for any x ∈ H00 . Proof. Ad (1): If X ∈ Lie(H ), X(i)ψ = 0 for any i ≥ 0 by the definition of ψ, it follows from (1) of Lemma 2.7 that [X(p), V (ψ, f )]x = 0 0 . By (3) of Lemma 2.8, the condition of (2) of Lemma 2.7 (note in (2) of for any x ∈ H∞ Lemma 2.7 tX(p) = X(tp) by definition) is satisfied, and the identity follows by using (2) of Lemma 2.7 and the fact that H00 is norm dense in H 0 . Ad (2): Since the support of f and the support of p are disjoint, by (1) of lemma 3
[X(p), V (ψ, f )]x = 0 0 . By (3) of Lemma 2.8, the condition of (2) of Lemma 2.7 is satisfied, for any x ∈ H∞ and the identity follows by using (2) of Lemma 2.7 and the fact that H00 is norm dense t in H 0 . u
Lemma 2.10. Let S be the set which consists of elements π 0 (exp(X(p))) with p = −p∗ smooth if X ∈ Lie(H ), and p = −p∗ smooth, support p ⊂ I 0 if X = Xα or X = Yα . Then the C ∗ algebra generated by S is strongly dense in π 0 (LH )00 ∨ π 0 (LI 0 G)00 if H is simply connected. Proof. Note S = S ∗ . Since every element of LI 0 G (resp. LH ) is a product of exponentials in LI 0 g (resp. Lh), cf. p. 487 of [W2] (we use the fact that G, H are simply connected here), we just have to show every element of the form π 0 (exp(X(p))) with ⊂ I 0 , and X ∈ g is in the von Neumann algebra M p = −p ∗ smooth, support pP generated by S. Assume X = i ci Xi , where ci ∈ R and Xi is either Xα or Yα . Note that π 0 (X(p)) and π 0 (Xi (p)) are essentially skew self-adjoint operator with a common core H00 . By abuse of notations, we will use the same symbol to denote its closure. Let a ∈ M 0 . Then we have: π 0 (Xi (p))ax = aπ 0 (Xi (p))x
22
F. Xu
for any x ∈ H00 , so π 0 (X(p))ax = aπ 0 (X(p))x for any x ∈ H00 , and it follows that the closure of π 0 (X(p)) t is affiliated with M, so π 0 (exp(X(p))) is in M. u Proposition 2.11. Suppose H ⊂ G, H is simply connected, and π 0 is the vacuum representation of LG. Let f be a smooth function with support f ⊂ I . Then π 0 (V (ψ, f )) is affiliated with von Neumann algebra π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 . Proof. By Lemma 2.9, π 0 (V (ψ, f ))ux = uπ 0 (V (ψ, f ))x for any u ∈ S where S is the generating set as in Lemma 2.10 and x ∈ H00 . Note by Haag duality in Prop. 2.1, π 0 (LI G)0 = π 0 (LI 0 G)00 . The proposition now follows from (3) of Lemma 2.6 and Lemma 2.10. u t Now we can finish the proof of Theorem 2.3. Proof of Theorem 2.3. Let ψ ∈ H0,0 ⊗0 be an eigenvector of D with eigenvalue n ∈ N. Note ψ = V (−n) = V (ψ, p) with p = z−1 . Choose two smooth functions f1 and f2 , with support f1 ⊂ I1 ∈ I and support f2 ⊂ I2 ∈ I, and f1 + f2 = 1. Then ψ = V (ψ, p) = V (ψ, pf1 ) + V (ψ, pf2 ). By Prop. 2.11, the closed operator V (ψ, f ) is affiliated with π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LJ G)00 if the support f ⊂ J ∈ I. Let V (ψ, f ) = U |V | be the polar decomposition. By Lemma 4.4.1 of [Mv], U and exp(it|V |), ∀t ∈ R are in π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LJ G)00 . Since is in the domain of |V |, it follows by Stone’s theorem (cf. p. 266 of [RS]) that as t → 0, (eit|V | − )/t → |V |, and this shows V (ψ, f ) = U |V | ∈ π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LJ G)00 ⊂ H. So V (ψ, pf1 ) ∈ H, V (ψ, pf2 ) ∈ H, and it follows that ψ ∈ H by the expression given at the beginning of the proof. u t
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
23
2.3. Two conjectures. We will use the notations in 2.1. Conjecture 2.12. The covariant representations πi,α can be decomposed into a direct sum of a finite number of irreducible representations and the localized sectors corresponding to these irreducible representations generate a finite dimensional ring over C under the product of sectors (cf. 4.1). Conjecture 2.12 comes from the physicists’ argument that the coset H ⊂ G CFT is a rational CFT: there are only a finite number of primary fields. Here the primary fields correspond to the representations or sectors. In some cases, e.g., G ⊂ G × G where the inclusion is diagonal, there are also conjectures on the structure constants of the ring (cf. [FKW] and [BBSS]). More precisely the conjectures in §§3 and 4 of [FKW] are about certain representations of W-algebras with critical parameters. The W-algebras defined in [FKW] are closely related to the coset G ⊂ G1 × Gm (cf. [Watts]), for example, the representations of W-algebras in [FKW] have the same characters as those which come from the coset. We shall call the irreducible conformal precosheaves of the cosets SU (N) ⊂ SU (N)1 × SU (N)m coset WN -algebras with critical parameters. Note that coset W2 algebras with critical parameters are the irreducible conformal precosheaves corresponding to Virasoro algebras studied in [GKO and Luke]. g,h To state Conjecture 2.13, let L0 be the generator of the rotation group for the coset as in the proof of Prop. 2.3. Then e−βL0 , β > 0 is a trace-class operator on Hi,α by Theorem B of [KW]. Denote by di,α the statistical dimension (cf. 4.1) of πi,α . Then we have: (cf. [L5] and (4.27) of [FG]) Conjecture 2.13 (also known as Kac–Wakimoto formula in [L5]). di,α = limβ→0
T rHi,α e−βL0 . T rH0,0 e−βL0
Both of these conjectures are highly nontrivial. The results in [W2] prove these conjectures in the case G is of type A and H is a trivial group. For the case of coset W2 algebras with critical parameters the above conjectures follow from the results of [Luke]. Note that Conjecture 2.13 immediately implies the Kac–Wakimoto conjecture (cf. Conj. 2.5 in [KW]). In fact, Conjecture 2.13 can also be stated as: di,α =
b(i, α) , b(0, 0)
where b(i, α) is defined as in §2 of [KW] with our (i, α) identified with (3, λ) in (2.5.4) of [KW]. Conjecture 2.5 in [KW] states that b(i, α) > 0. Conjecture 2.13 is stronger than this since di,α ≥ 1 and b(0, 0) > 0 by definitions. Note that the Kac–Wakimoto hypothesis (cf. p. 161 of [KW]) also implies Kac– Wakimoto conjecture, but the first counter-example to Kac–Wakimoto hypothesis has been found in [X2] by considering subfactors associated with conformal inclusions. So far Conjecture 2.13 and hence the Kac–Wakimoto conjecture have been checked to be true in all known examples. 3. Commuting Squares We will use the notations of 2.1. All the cosets considered in this section are assumed to verify the assumptions of Theorem 2.4 unless stated otherwise. For the definitions and properties of statistical dimensions and minimal index, see 4.1.
24
F. Xu
Definition (Cofiniteness). The coset H ⊂ GL is called cofinite if the inclusion (π 0 (LI G)00 ∩ π 0 (LI H )0 ) ∨ π 0 (LI H )00 ⊂ π 0 (LI G)00 has finite statistical dimension. The statistical dimension of the inclusion is denoted by d(G/H ). Note that d(G/H ) does not depend on the choice of I by the covariance property of representations (cf. Prop. 2.1 of [GL]), and we can replace π 0 by any level L representation of LG in the above definition due to the local equivalence of these representations (cf. Theorem II. B of [W2]). Let π i be an irreducible projective representation of LG with positive energy at level L on Hilbert space H i . Recall (cf. 2.1) when restricting to LH , H i decomposes as: X Hi,α ⊗ Hα , Hi = α
and πα are irreducible projective representations of LH on the Hilbert space Hα , and the sum is over α such that (i, α) ∈ exp. Consider the following inclusions: (π i (LI G)00 ∩ π i (LI H )0 ) ∨ π i (LI H )00 ⊂ π i (LI G)00 ⊂ π i (LI 0 G)0 ⊂ ((π i (LI 0 G)00 ∩ π i (LI 0 H )0 ) ∨ π i (LI 0 H )00 )0 . Note that
π i (LI 0 G)0 ⊂ ((π i (LI 0 G)00 ∩ π i (LI 0 H )0 ) ∨ π i (LI 0 H )00 )0
has the same statistical dimension as (π i (LI 0 G)00 ∩ π i (LI 0 H )0 ) ∨ π i (LI 0 H )00 ⊂ π i (LI 0 G)00 which is d(G/H ). By the multiplicativity of statistical dimensions (cf. 4.1) the statistical dimension of the inclusion (π i (LI G)00 ∩ π i (LI H )0 ) ∨ π i (LI H )00 ⊂ ((π i (LI 0 G)00 ∩ π i (LI 0 H )0 ) ∨ π i (LI 0 H )00 )0 is di d(G/H )2 , where di is the statistical dimension of π i (LI G)00 ⊂ π i (LI 0 G)0 . On the other hand by the additivity Pof the statistical dimension (cf. 4.1)) the statistical dimension of the above inclusion is α d(i,α) dα , where d(i,α) and dα are the statistical dimensions of πi,α and πα respectively. So we have X d(i,α) dα . (3.1) di d(G/H )2 = α
When any of the statistical dimensions in formula (3.1) are ∞, then (3.1) is understood as the statement that both sides of the equation are ∞. See the paragraph before Prop. 4.2 for a slightly different derivation of formula (3.1). When i = 0 is the vacuum representation, the statistical dimension d0 of the inclusion π 0 (LI G)00 ⊂ π 0 (LI 0 G)0 is 1 by Haag duality in Prop. 2.1. It follows from formula (3.1) that H ⊂ GL is cofinite if and only if d(0,α) dα < ∞ for all (0, α) ∈ exp. Hence Conjecture 2.13 implies the cofiniteness for any coset.
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
25
For simplicity we will drop the subscript L in the following when no confusion arises. Note that if H = {e} is the trivial group , then H ⊂ G is cofinite. So the statement “if H1 ⊂ G is cofinite and H1 ⊂ H2 ⊂ G, then H2 ⊂ G is cofinite” is as difficult to prove as the statement “H2 ⊂ G is cofinite” by simply taking H1 = {e}. But we have: Proposition 3.1. Suppose H1 ⊂ H2 ⊂ G. (1) If H1 ⊂ G is cofinite, then H1 ⊂ H2 is cofinite, and d(G/H1 ) ≥ d(H2 /H1 ); (2) If H1 ⊂ H2 and H2 ⊂ G are cofinite, then H1 ⊂ G is cofinite and d(G/H1 ) ≤ d(G/H2 ) × d(H2 /H1 ). This proposition is proved below by using commuting squares. Commuting squares where all the algebras are finite type can be found in reference [We, Po]. But we will consider the case where all the algebras are type I I I . Since the action of the modular group of π 0 (LI G)00 with respect to the vacuum vector is geometric and ergodic (cf. 2.1), it follows from Takesaki’s theorem (cf. [MT] or p. 495 of [W2]) that the von Neumann algebras π 0 (LI Hi )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI Hi )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ), i = 1, 2 and π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ) ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) are factors, and there exist normal faithful conditional expectations i : π 0 (LI G)00 → π 0 (LI Hi )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI Hi )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) , i = 1, 2 and : π 0 (LI G)00 → π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ) ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ). Moreover, these conditional expectations preserve the state ω on π 0 (LI G)00 defined by ω(x) = (x, ), i.e., ω(x) = ω( 0 (x)), ∀x ∈ π 0 (LI G)00 , when 0 = 1 , 2 , respectively. Then we have: Lemma 3.2 (Commuting Square). (1) 1 · 2 = 1 · 2 = ; (2) 1 , 2 are minimal if has finite index. Proof. Assume the vacuum representation π 0 of LG decomposes with respect to LH2 as: H 0 = ⊕α HG/H2 ,0,α ⊗ HH2 ,α , then with respect to LH1 the decomposition is: H 0 = ⊕α HG/H2 ,0,α ⊗ HH2 ,α = ⊕α HG/H2 ,0,α ⊗ (⊕β HH2 /H1 ,α,β ⊗ HH1 ,β ). Let P1 be the projection from H 0 onto ⊕α HG/H2 ,0,α ⊗ HH2 /H1 ,α,0 ⊗ HH1 ,0 , P2 the projection from H 0 onto HG/H2 ,0,0 ⊗ ⊕β (HH2 /H1 ,0,β ⊗ HH1 ,β ), and P the projection from H 0 onto HG/H2 ,0,0 ⊗ HH2 /H1 ,0,0 ⊗ HH1 ,0 . It follows from definitions that P1 P2 = P2 P1 = P . By Theorem 2.4 and the Reeh– Schlieder Theorem in Prop. 2.1, Pi H 0 = π 0 (LI Hi )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI Hi )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ), i = 1, 2,
26
F. Xu
and P H 0 = π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ) ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ). So for any x ∈ π 0 (LI G)00 , we have: 1 (2 (x)) = P1 2 (x) = P1 P2 x = P x = (x), and similarly 2 (1 (x)) = (x). Since is separating for π 0 (LI G)00 , (1) of the lemma is proved. Note by the remark at the end of 2.2, the inclusions π 0 (LI Hi )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI Hi )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) ⊂ π 0 (LI G)00 are irreducible, so by Prop. 4.3 of [L4] i are unique and must be the minimal conditional expectations, i = 1, 2 if the index of is finite. u t Proof of Proposition 3.2. (1) As in the proof of Lemma 3.2, suppose the vacuum representation π 0 of LG decomposes with respect to LH2 as: H 0 = ⊕α HG/H2 ,0,α ⊗ HH2 ,α , and let P0 (resp. P00 ) be the projection from H 0 onto HG/H2 ,0,0 ⊗HH2 ,0 (resp. HG/H2 ,0,0 ⊗0 , where 0 is the vacuum vector in HH2 ,0 ). Then π 0 (LI H2 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) ' π 0 (LI H2 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 )P0 ' π0 (LI H2 )00 ⊗ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 )P00 ' π 0 (LI H2 )00 ⊗ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ), where ⊗ is the tensor product of von Neumann algebras and A ' B means A and B are *-isomorphic, since all the algebras above are factors. Note the ∗-isomorphism above from π 0 (LI H2 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) to π 0 (LI H2 )00 ⊗ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) maps π 0 (x) to π 0 (x) ⊗ 1, ∀x ∈ LI H2 , and y to 1 ⊗ y, ∀y ∈ π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 . So this ∗-isomorphism maps π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ) ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) onto (π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 )) ⊗ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ). It follows that the inclusion π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ) ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) ⊂ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 )
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
27
is conjugate to (π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 )) ⊗ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) ⊂ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ⊗ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ), hence it is irreducible and by Cor. 2.2 of [L6], its statistical dimension is d(H2 /H1 ). By Lemma 3.2, the minimal normal faithful conditional expectation 1 restricts to a normal faithful conditional expectation η from π 0 (LI H2 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ) to
π 0 (LI H1 )00 ∨ (π 0 (LI H1 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI H2 )00 ) ∨ (π 0 (LI H2 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)00 ).
By Prop. 4.3 of [L4], η is also minimal, and so dη = d(H2 /H1 ) ≤ d1 = d(G/H1 ) by the definition of the statistical dimension (cf. 4.1). To prove (2), note that η1 = is a minimal conditional expectation by Cor. 2.2 of [L6], and d ≥ d1 , so we have d(H2 /H1 )d(G/H2 ) = d ≥ d1 = d(G/H1 ), where we have used multiplicativity of statistical dimensions (cf. 4.1). u t We consider some examples when Prop. 3.1 can be applied. The conformal inclusion SU (n)m × SU (m)n ⊂ SU (nm)1 has been considered in [X2] and the decomposition is given in Theorem 1 of [ABI]. Let H = SU (n) be the first factor in the above inclusion. Lemma 3.3. π 0 (LI SU (nm))00 ∩ π 0 (LI SU (n))0 = π 0 (LI SU (m))00 . So the irreducible conformal precosheaf of coset SU (n) ⊂ SU (nm)1 is the irreducible conformal precosheaf of LSU (m) at level n. Proof. From the definition we have: π 0 (LI SU (nm))00 ∩ π 0 (LI SU (n))0 ⊃ π 0 (LI SU (m))00 . Since (cf. the remark after Prop. 2.2) the action of the modular group of π 0 (LI SU (nm))00 ∩ π 0 (LI SU (n))0 with respect to the vacuum vector is geometric and fixes globally π 0 (LI SU (m))00 , by Takesaki’s theorem (cf. [MT] or p. 495 of [W2]), we just have to show that π 0 (LI SU (nm))00 ∩ π 0 (LI SU (n))0 ⊂ π 0 (LI SU (m))00 . By the decomposition of H 0 with respect to LSU (n) × LSU (m) in Theorem 1 of [ABI], = 0,0 ⊗ 0 ∈ H0,0 ⊗ H0 , where H0,0 and H0 are vacuum representations of LSU (m) and LSU (n) respectively, and 0,0 , 0 are vacuum vectors for LSU (m) and LSU (n) respectively. By the Reeh–Schlieder Theorem in Prop. 2.1, π 0 (LI SU (m))00 = H0,0 ⊗ 0 , but by the observation before Prop. 2.3 we have π 0 (LI SU (nm))00 ∩ π 0 (LI SU (n))0 ⊂ H0,0 ⊗ 0 . It follows that π 0 (LI SU (nm))00 ∩ π 0 (LI SU (n))0 ⊂ π 0 (LI SU (m))00 , and the lemma is proved. u t
28
F. Xu
By Lemma 3.3, Theorem 1.2 of [X1] and formula (3.1), the inclusion SU (n)k+l ⊂ SU (n(k +l))1 is cofinite. Since SU (n)k+l ⊂ SU (n)k ×SU (n)l ⊂ SU (n(k +l))1 , where the first inclusion is diagonal, by (1) of Prop. 3.1 the diagonal inclusion SU (n)k+l ⊂ SU (n)k × SU (n)l is cofinite, and using (2) of Prop. 3.1 repeatedly we conclude that the diagonal inclusion SU (n)k ⊂ SU (n)1 × · · · × SU (n)1 is also cofinite, where there are k factors in the product. It follows by (1) Prop. 3.1 that SU (n)k1 +···+km ⊂ SU (n)k1 × · · · × SU (n)km is cofinite, ki ∈ N, i = 1, . . . , m, since SU (n)k1 +···+km ⊂ SU (n)k1 × · · · × SU (n)km ⊂ SU (n)1 × . . . SU (n)1 , where there are k1 + · · · + km factors in the last group. Suppose Hk ⊂ G1 is a conformal inclusion, H is simple and of type A, G is simple and k is the Dynkin index (cf. p. 170 of [KW]). An infinite list can be found in [X2]. Let l ∈ N. Since Hkl ⊂ Hk × · · · × Hk is cofinite by the previous paragraph and Hk × · · · × Hk ⊂ G1 × · · · × G1 is cofinite by Prop. 2.4 of [X1], it follows by (2) of Prop. 3.1 that Hkl ⊂ G1 × · · · × G1 is cofinite, and by (1) of Prop. 3.1 Hkl ⊂ Gl is cofinite. Finally let us consider the case H ⊂ Gm with G = SU (l) and H is the Cartan subalgebra of G, a l − 1 dimensional torus. We will first consider the inclusion H ⊂ G1 × · · · × G1 , ˜ := where there are m factors in the product, and the inclusion is diagonal. Define G G × G · · · × G, where there are m factors in the product. The irreducible projective representations of LH at level m have been classified in Prop. 9.5.10 of [PS]. Let us describe this result in our case. These irreducible projective representations are in fact representations of LH , which is a central extension of LH induced from the central extension LG of LG (cf. p. 483 of [W2] or Chap. 4 of [PS]). Write LH ' Hom(S 1 , H ) × H × V , where H is the subgroup of constant loops, and V is the vector space of maps f : S 1 → Lie(H ) with integral 0, which is regarded as a subgroup of LH by the exponential map. The density component of LH is canonically a product H × V˜ , where V˜ is the Heisenberg group defined by a skew form on V . The center of the identity component of LH is H × S 1 . Let ξ = (ξ1 , . . . , ξl−1 , (ξ1 . . . ξl−1 )−1 ) ∈ LH, where each ξi ∈ C ∞ (S 1 , S 1 ) has winding number xi , i = 1, . . . , l − 1. The conjugate action of ξ on the center H × S 1 of the identity component of LH is given by (cf. p. 192 of [PS]) x +(x1 +...xl−1 )
(t, u) → (t, ut1 1
x
l−1 . . . tl−1
+(x1 +...xl−1 )
),
where t = (t1 , . . . , tl−1 , (t1 . . . tl−1 )−1 ) ∈ H . Introduce an equivalent relation on Zl−1 by: (n1 , . . . , nl−1 ) ∼ (n01 , . . . , n0l−1 ) iff there exists (m1 , . . . ml−1 ) ∈ Zl−1 with m1 + · · · + ml−1 ∈ lZ such that (n01 , . . . , n0l−1 ) = (n1 + mm1 , . . . nl−1 + mml−1 ). Denote the equivalence class of (n1 , . . . , nl−1 ) by [n1 , . . . , nl−1 ] or simply [n]. The irreducible representation of LH at level m on Hilbert space H[n] has the following form (cf. p. 192 of [PS]): H[n] = ⊕(a1 ,...,al−1 )∼(n1 ,...,nl−1 ) H(a1 ,...,al−1 ) , where on H(a1 ,...,al−1 ) , the center H × S 1 of the identity component of LH acts as al−1 u × id, and on H(a1 ,...,al−1 ) the representation of the Heisenberg (t, u) → t1a1 . . . tl−1 group V˜ is irreducible (and unique by Prop. 9.5.10 of [PS]).
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
29
˜ := LG × . . . LG When restricting to LH , the vacuum representation π 0 of LG (there are m factors in the product) on (Hv )⊗m decomposes as: X H0,[n] ⊗ H[n1 ,...nl−1 ] , (Hv )⊗m = l|
P
i
ni
and π[n] are irreducible projective representations of LH on H[n1 ,...nl−1 ] (cf. §2.6 of [KW]). Let α ∈ LH × · · · × LH be a loop of the form ξ × 1 × · · · × 1, where ξ = (ξ1 , . . . , ξl−1 , (ξ1 . . . ξl−1 )−1 ) ∈ LH, and each ξi ∈ C ∞ (S 1 , S 1 ) has winding number xi , i = 1, . . . , l − 1. We can assume that α is localized on I . Define ˜ Adα .y := αyα −1 , Adα .π 0 (y) = π 0 (α)π 0 (y)π 0 (α −1 ), ∀y ∈ LG. ˜ Note (remember that LH is diagonally included in LG) Adα .y ∈ LH, Adα .π 0 (y) ∈ π 0 (LH ), ∀y ∈ LH. Then by definitions we have: π[n] (Adα y) ' π[n+b] (y), ∀y ∈ LH, where [n + b] = [n1 + b1 , . . . , nl−1 + bl−1 ], with bi = xi + (x1 + . . . xl−1 ), i = 1, . . . , l − 1. Note that this implies that π[n] has statistical dimension 1 since Adα is a localized automorphism. Also note that since Adα is an automorphism of π 0 (LH ), it is ˜ 00 for any interval J . also an automorphism of π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LJ G) We claim that π0,[n] (Adα .y) ' π0,[n+b] (y) ˜ In for any y ∈ A(J ), where A(J ) is the conformal precosheaf for the coset H ⊂ G. fact let U[n] : H[n] → H[n+b] be a unitary map intertwining the action of LH and the action of Adα .LH , and let W = V ⊗ U : H 0 → H 0 be a unitary map such that V ⊗ U (z ⊗ y) = V[n] z ⊗ U[n] y ∈ H0,[n+b] ⊗ H[n+b] for any z ⊗ y ∈ H0,[n] ⊗ H[n] . It follows that W ∗ π 0 (α) ∈ π 0 (LH )0 = ⊕[n] B(H0,[n] ) ⊗ idH[n] , so we have
0 ⊗ U[n] , π 0 (α) = ⊕[n] V[n]
0 : H 0 0 0 0 −1 where V[n] 0,[n] → H0,[n+b] is unitary. Note π (Adα .y) = π (α)π (y)π (α) , and π 0 (y) ∈ ⊕[n] B(H0,[n] ) ⊗ idH[n] , ∀y ∈ A(J ).
Hence
∗
π0,[n] (Adα .y) = V 0 [n] π0,[n+b] (y)V 0 [n] , ∀y ∈ A(J ).
Now choose x so that bi = −ni , i = 1, . . . , l − 1, we get ∗
π0,[n] (Adα .y) = V 0 [n] π0,[0] (y)V 0 [n] . So π0,[n] has the same statistical dimension as π0,[0] since Adα is a localized automorphism.
30
F. Xu
If π0,[0] is the vacuum representation, then π0,[n] has statistical dimension 1. Note π[n] also has statistical dimension 1, by formula (3.1) we conclude that the diagonal inclusion H ⊂ G1 × · · · × G1 is cofinite. We claim that π0,[0] is indeed the vacuum representation. Note this does not follow directly from Theorem 2.3 since we assume H is simply connected in the theorem. However, the assumption that H is simply connected is only used in the proof of Lemma 2.10. From the proof of Lemma 2.10, we see that the smeared vertex operators in Prop. 2.4 are affiliated with the von Neumann algebra ˜ 00 , π 0 ((LH )0 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G) where (LH )0 is the connected component of LH that contains the identity. Note that LH is generated as a group by (LH )0 and a set of elements with non-trivial winding ˜ So numbers, and we can certainly choose these elements to be in LI 0 H ⊂ LI 0 G. ˜ 00 . π 0 (LH )00 ⊂ π 0 ((LH )0 )00 ∨ π 0 (LI 0 G) ˜ 00 , then p ∈ π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G) ˜ 00 . On the other Hence if p ∈ π 0 ((LH )0 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G) hand ˜ 00 ⊃ π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G) ˜ 00 . π 0 ((LH )0 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G) So
˜ 00 = π 0 (LH )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G) ˜ 00 . π 0 ((LH )0 )0 ∩ π 0 (LI G)
˜ This shows that Prop. 2.11, and therefore Theorem 2.4 hold for any pair H ⊂ G ˜ as long as G is semisimple and simply connected. It follows now that Prop. 3.1 can be applied to the present case for H ⊂ Gm ⊂ G1 × · · · × G1 since we only use Theorem 2.4 in its proof. So we conclude that H ⊂ Gm is cofinite. To summarize, we have proved the following: Corollary 3.4. The following inclusions are cofinite: (1) Gk1 +k2 +···+km ⊂ Gk1 × · · · × Gkm , where the inclusion is diagonal, ki ∈ N, i = 1, . . . , m and G = SU (n); (2) Hlk ⊂ Gl , if Hk ⊂ G1 is a conformal inclusion where k is the Dynkin index, l ∈ N, H is simple and of type A and G is simple ; (3) H ⊂ Gm , where H is the Cartan subgroup of G. 4. Braided Endomorphisms All the cosets considered in this section are assumed to verify the assumptions of Theorem 2.4 unless stated otherwise. 4.1. Some results from [X1]. In this subsection we recall some of the results from [X1] which will be used in 4.2. We start with some preliminaries on sectors to set up notations. Let M be a properly infinite factor and End(M) the semigroup of unit preserving endomorphisms of M. In this paper M will always be a type I I I1 factor. Let Sect(M) denote the quotient of End(M) modulo unitary equivalence in M. It follows from [L3 and L4] that Sect(M) is endowed with a natural involution θ → θ¯ , and Sect(M) is a semiring: i.e., there are two operations +, × on Sect(M) which verifes the usual axioms. The multiplication of sectors is simply the composition of sectors. Hence if θ1 , θ2 are
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
31
two sectors, we shall write θ1 ×θ2 as θ1 θ2 . In [X1], the image of θ ∈ End(M) in Sect(M) is denoted by [θ]. However, since we will be mainly concerned with the ring structure of certain sectors in Sect. 4, we will denote [θ ] simply by θ if no confusion arises. Assume θ ∈ End(M), and there exists a normal faithful conditional expectation : M → θ(M). We define a number d (possibly ∞) by: d−2 := Max{λ ∈ [0, +∞)|(m+ ) ≥ λm+ , ∀m+ ∈ M+ } (cf. [PP]). If d < ∞ for some , we say θ has finite index or statistical dimension. In this case we define dθ = Min {d |d < ∞}. dθ is called the statistical dimension of θ . dθ2 is called the minimal index of θ . In fact in this case there exists a unique θ such that dθ = dθ . θ is called the minimal conditional expectation. It is clear from the definition that the statistical dimension of θ depends only on the unitary equivalence classes of θ . When N ⊂ M with N ' M, we choose θ ∈ End(M) such that θ(M) = N. The statistical dimension (resp. minimal index) of the inclusion N ⊂ M is defined to be the statistical dimension (resp. minimal index) of θ. Let θ1 , θ2 ∈ Sect(M). By Theorem 5.5 of [L3], dθ1 +θ2 = dθ1 + dθ2 , and by Cor. 2.2 of [L6], dθ1 θ2 = dθ1 dθ2 . These two properties are usually referred to as the additivity and multiplicativity of statistical dimensions. Also note by Prop. 4.12 of [L4] dθ = dθ¯ . If a sector does not have finite statistical dimension in any of the above three equations, then the equation is understood as the statement that both sides of the equation are ∞. Assume λ, µ, and ν ∈ End(M) have finite statistical dimensions. Let Hom(λ, µ) denote the space of intertwiners from λ to µ, i.e. a ∈ Hom(λ, µ) iff aλ(p) = µ(p)a for any p ∈ M. Hom(λ, µ) is a finite dimensional vector space and we use hλ, µi to denote the dimension of this space. Note that hλ, µi depends only on [λ] and [µ]. Moreover we have hνλ, µi = hλ, ν¯ µi, hνλ, µi = hν, µλ¯ i which follows from Frobenius duality (see [L2 Y]). We will also use the following notation: if µ is a subsector of λ, we will write µ ≺ λ or λ µ. A sector is said to be irreducible if it has only one subsector. Let θi , i = 1, . . . , n be a set of irreducible sectors with finite index. The ring generated by θi , i = 1, . . . , n under compositions is defined to be a vector space (possibly infinite dimensional) over C with a basis {ξj , j ≥ 1}, such that ξj are irreducible sectors, ξj 6 = ξj 0 if j 6 = j 0 , and the set {ξj , j ≥ 1} is a list of all irreducible sectors which appear as subsectors of finite products of θi , i = 1, . . . , n. The ring multiplication on the vector space is obtained naturally from that of Sect(M). Let M(J ), J ∈ I be an irreducible conformal precosheaf on Hilbert space H 0 . Suppose N(J ), J ∈ I is an irreducible conformal precosheaf and π 0 is a covariant representation of N(J ) on H 0 such that π 0 (N (J )) ⊂ M(J ) is a directed standard net as defined in Definition 3.1 of [LR] for any directed set of intervals. Fix an interval I and denote by N := N(I ), M := M(I ). For any covariant representation πλ (resp. π i ) of the irreducible conformal precosheaf N (J ), J ∈ I (resp. M(J ), J ∈ I), let λ (resp. i) be the corresponding endomorphism of N (resp. M) as defined in Sect. 2.1 of [GL]. These endomorphisms are obtained by localization in Sect. 2.1 of [GL] and will be referred to as localized endomorphisms for convenience. The corresponding sectors will be called localized sectors. See the paragraph after the proof of Lemma 4.2 for examples. We will use dλ and di to denote the statistical dimensions of λ and i respectively. dλ and di are also called the statistical dimensions of πλ and π i respectively, and they are independent of the choice of I (cf. Prop. 2.1 of [GL]).
32
F. Xu
Let π i be a covariant representation of M(J ), J ∈ I which decomposes as: X biλ πλ πi = λ
P when restricted to N(J ), J ∈ I, where the sum is finite and biλ ∈ N. Let γi := λ biλ λ be the corresponding sector of N. It is shown (cf. (1) of Prop. 2.8 in [X1]) that there are sectors ρ, σi ∈ Sect(N) such that: ρσi ρ¯ = γi . Notice that σi are in one-to-one correspondence with covariant representations π i , and in fact the map i → σi is an isomorphism of the ring generated by i and the ring generated ¯ ⊂ N is conjugate to π 0 (N (I )) ⊂ M(I ) (cf. (2) of Prop. 2.6 by σi . The subfactor ρ(N) in [X1]). Now we assume π 0 (N(I )) ⊂ M(I ) has finite index. Then for each localized sector λ of N there exists a sector denoted by aλ of N such that the following theorem is true (cf. [X1]): Theorem 4.1. (1) The map λ → aλ is a ring homomorphism; ¯ dλ = daλ ; (2) ρaλ = λρ, aλ ρ¯ = ρλ, ¯ aµ ρi; ¯ (3) hρaλ , ρaµ i = haλ , aµ i = haλ ρ, ¯ σi ρi ¯ ; (4) hρaλ , ρσi i = haλ , σi i = haλ ρ, (5) (3) (resp. (4)) remains valid if aλ , aµ (resp. aλ ) is replaced by any of its subsectors; (6) aλ σi = σi aλ . Proof. (1) to (4) follows from Theorem 3.2, 3.3, Cor. 3.4, Lemma 3.4, 3.5 of [X1], (5) is proved on p. 9 of [X2], and (6) is proved on p. 387 of [X1]. It should be noted that these results in Sect. 3 of [X1] are stated for conformal inclusions, but all the proof there applies verbatim to the present setting. u t 4.2. The ring structure. We will apply the results of 4.1 to the case when N (I ) = A(I ) ⊗ π0 (LI H )00 and M(I ) = π 0 (LI G)00 under the assumption that H ⊂ GL is cofinite, where A(I ) is as in Prop. 2.11 for the coset H ⊂ GL , and π0 denotes the vacuum representation of LH . Note that if H ⊂ GL is cofinite, then π 0 (N (I )) ⊂ M(I ) has finite index. By Theorem 4.1, for every localized endomorphism λ of N (I ) we have a map a : λ → aλ which verifies (1) to (6) in Theorem 4.1. Tensor Notation. Let θ ∈ End(A(I ) ⊗ π0 (LI H )00 ). We will denote θ by ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 if θ(p ⊗ 1) = ρ1 (p) ⊗ 1, ∀p ∈ A(I ), θ (1 ⊗ p0 ) = 1 ⊗ ρ2 (p0 ), ∀p0 ∈ π0 (LI H )00 , where ρ1 ∈ End(A(I )), ρ2 ∈ End(π0 (LI H )00 ). Lemma 4.2. (1) If θ = ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 , and X X [ρ1i ], [ρ2 ] = [ρ2j ], [ρ1 ] = i
j
where all the summations are finite. Then: X [ρ1i ⊗ ρ2j ]; [θ ] = i,j
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
(2)
33
hρ1 ⊗ ρ2 , σ1 ⊗ σ2 i = hρ1 , ρ2 ihσ1 , σ2 i, where ρ1 , σ1 are in End(A(I )), and ρ2 , σ2 are in End(π0 (LI H )00 ).
Proof. (1) follows immediately from the definitions. By (1), we just have to show (2) in the case that ρ1 , σ1 , ρ2 , σ2 are irreducible sectors. It is obvious that if ρ1 ' σ1 , ρ2 ' σ2 as sectors, then ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 ' σ1 ⊗ σ2 as sectors of N (I ). Now suppose ρ1 ⊗ ρ2 ' σ1 ⊗ σ2 as sectors of N(I ). This means there exists a unitary u ∈ N (I ) such that: uρ1 (p) ⊗ ρ2 (p 0 ) = σ1 (p) ⊗ σ2 (p0 )u, for any p ∈ A(I ), p 0 ∈ π0 (LI H )00 . By the statement on p. 123 of [Stra], there exists normal conditional expectation E : N (I ) → A(I ) ⊗ 1 such that E(u) 6 = 0. Applying E to the above equation and setting p 0 = 1, we have: E(u)ρ1 (p) = σ1 (p)E(u). Since ρ1 , σ1 are irreducible and E(u) 6 = 0, it follows that ρ1 ' σ1 as sectors. Similarly t one can show that ρ2 ' σ2 as sectors. This proves (2). u Recall from 2.1 πi,α of A(I ) are obtained in the decompositions of π i of LG with respect to subgroup LH , and we denote the set of such (i, α) by exp. For any J ∈ I, let U (J ) be a unitary operator from Hi,α to H0,0 such that: πi,α (p) = U (J )∗ π0,0 (p)U (J ), ∀p ∈ A(J ). Recall I is a fixed interval. Identify Hi,α with H0,0 by U (I 0 ), we may choose a representation unitarily equivalent to πi,α , still denoted by πi,α on H0,0 , with the property that πi,α (p0 ) = p 0 , ∀p0 ∈ A(I 0 ). It follows that πi,α (A(I )) commutes with A(I 0 ). By Haag duality in Prop. 2.1, πi,α (p) ∈ A(I ), ∀p ∈ A(I ), and so πi,α |A(I ) ∈ End(A(I )). We will denote πi,α |A(I ) by (i, α). The corresponding sector in Sect(A(I )) is also denoted by (i, α) when no confusion arises. Note that (i, α) is an irreducible sector if and only if πi,α is an irreducible covariant representation, since the coset conformal precosheaf A(J ), ∀J ∈ I is strongly additive by the remarks in 2.1 after Prop. 2.3. In fact suppose (i, α) is an irreducible sector. Let p ∈ (∨J ∈I πi,α (A(J )))0 . Then p ∈ πi,α (A(I 0 ))0 = A(I ). It follows that p ∈ Hom((i, α), (i, α)) = C, since (i, α) is irreducible. On the other hand if πi,α is irreducible, and p ∈ Hom((i, α), (i, α)). Then p ∈ A(I ) and so p ∈ (πi,α (A(I 0 )) ∨ πi,α (A(I )))0 . But πi,α (A(I 0 )) ∨ πi,α (A(I )) = ∨J ∈I πi,α (A(J )) by the strong additivity of the coset conformal precosheaf, so p ∈ (∨J ∈I πi,α (A(J )))0 = C, since πi,α is irreducible. Similarly one can show that (i, α) (j, β) if and only if πj,β appears as a direct summand of πi,α , and (i, α) is equal to (j, β) as sectors if and only if πi,α is unitarily equivalent to πj,β . Given (i, α) ∈ End(A(I )) as above, we define (i, α) ⊗ 1 ∈ End(N (I )) so that: (i, α) ⊗ 1(p ⊗ p 0 ) = (i, α)(p) ⊗ p0 , ∀p ∈ A(I ), p0 ∈ π0 (LI H )00 . It is easy to see that (i, α) ⊗ 1 corresponds to the covariant representation πi,α ⊗ π0 of N(I ). Note that this notation agrees with our tensor notation above. Also note that for
34
F. Xu
any covariant representation πx of A(I ), we can define a localized sector x ⊗ 1 of N (I ) in the same way as in the case when πx = πi,α . Each covariant representation π i of LG gives rise to an endomorphism σi ∈ End(N(I )) and (cf. Subsect. 4.1) X (i, α) ⊗ (α), ρσi ρ¯ = γi = α
where the summation is over those α such P that (i, α) ∈ exp. So by the properties of statistical dimensions (cf. 4.1) di dρ2 = α d(i,α) dα . Note that this is in fact formula (3.1), with dρ = d(G/H ) by definition. Proposition 4.3. Assume H ⊂ GL is cofinite. We have: (1) Let x, y be localized sectors of A(I ) with finite index. Then hx, yi = hax⊗1 , ay⊗1 i; (2) If (i, α) ∈ exp, then a(i,α)⊗1 ≺ a1⊗α¯ σi ; (3) Denote by d(i,α) the statistical dimension of (i, α). Then d(i,α) ≤ di dα , where di (resp. dα ) is the statistical dimension of i ( resp. α). Proof. Ad (1): By the assumption and Theorem 4.1, we have hax⊗1 , ay⊗1 i = hρax⊗1 , ρay⊗1 i = h(x ⊗ 1)ρ, (y ⊗ 1)ρi = hx ⊗ 1, (y ⊗ 1)ρ ρi ¯ X (0, δ) ⊗ δi = hx ⊗ 1, (y ⊗ 1) = hx ⊗ 1, =
X
X
δ
y(0, δ) ⊗ δi
δ
hx, y(0, δ)i × h1, δi,
δ
where in the last identity we used (2) of Lemma 4.2. Note h1, δi is equal to 1 iff δ corresponds to the vacuum representation of LH . When δ is the vacuum representation, (0, δ) corresponds to the representation π0,0 of A(I ), which by Th. 2.4, is the vacuum representation of A(I ), and corresponds to the identity sector. So we have: X hx, y(0, δ)i × h1, δi = hx, yi, δ
and the proof of (1) is complete. Ad (2): Since π i has finite statistical dimension and H ⊂ G is cofinite, P by formula (3.1) d(i,α) < ∞, dα < ∞, ∀(i, α) ∈ exp. So we can assume (i, α) = j mj xj , where the sum is finite, mj ∈ N, and xj is irreducible and has finite index. Note that xj is a localized sector of A(I ) (cf. Prop. 2.2 of [GL]), so axj ⊗1 is well defined, and it follows from (1) that axj ⊗1 is also irreducible. By Theorem 4.1, X mj axj ⊗1 . a(i,α)⊗1 = j
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
35
By using Theorem 4.1 and Lemma 4.2 we have: haxi ⊗1 , a1⊗α¯ σi i = haxi ⊗1 a1⊗α , σi i = haxi ⊗α , σi i ¯ σi ρi ¯ = haxi ⊗α ρ, ¯ = hρx ¯ i ⊗ α, σi ρi ¯ = hxi ⊗ α, ρσi ρi X (i, β) ⊗ βi = hxi ⊗ α, β
= hxi , (i, α)i = mi . This shows a(i,α)⊗1 =
X
mj axj ⊗1 ≺ a1⊗α¯ σi .
j
(3) follows immediately from (2) and the fact that (i, α) and a(i,α)⊗1 have the same statistical dimension by (2) of Theorem 4.1. u t Theorem 4.4. Suppose H ⊂ GL is cofinite, and every irreducible representation πα of LH has finite index, and the localized sectors {α} generate a finite dimensional ring over C under compositions. Then Conj. 1 of 2.3 is true. Proof. By (3) of Prop. 4.2, d(i,α) < ∞, ∀(i, α) ∈ exp, since di < ∞, dα < ∞ by our assumption. Hence each (i, α) decomposes into a direct sum of a finite number of irreducible sectors. By Prop. 2.2 of [GL], each πi,α decomposes into a direct sum of a finite number of irreducible covariant representations. By (6) of Theorem 4.1, a1⊗α¯ σi = σi a1⊗α¯ , so the ring Y generated by irreducible subsectors of a1⊗α¯ σi , ∀α, ∀i has finite dimension over C by (1) of Theorem 4.1 and the the assumption of the theorem. Denote by X the ring generated (under compositions) by the set of all irreducible sectors which appear as subsectors of (i, α), ∀(i, α) ∈ exp. By Prop. 4.3, the map x ∈ X → ax⊗1 is an injective homomorphism from X into Y . It follows that X is finite dimensional over C, and Conj. 2.12 of Subsect. 2.3 is proved. u t By Cor. 3.4, Theorem 4.4 and the theorem on p. 535 of [W2], we immediately have the following: Corollary 4.5. Conjecture 2.12 of Subsect. 2.3 is true for the following inclusions: (1) Gk1 +k2 +···+km ⊂ Gk1 × · · · × Gkm , where the inclusion is diagonal, ki ∈ N, i = 1, . . . , m and G = SU (n); (2) Hlk ⊂ Gl , if Hk ⊂ G1 is a conformal inclusion, where k is the Dynkin index , l ∈ N, l > 1, H and G are simple and of type A; (3) H ⊂ Gm , where H is the Cartan subgroup of G , m ∈ N, m > 1 and G is a simple type A group. Note in (2) and (3) of Cor. 4.5, we restrict l > 1 and m > 1 respectively to avoid the trivial case of conformal inclusions.
36
F. Xu
4.3. SU (N) ⊂ SU (N)m0 ×SU (N)m00 . In this subsection we consider the coset H ⊂ GL with H := SU (N), GL := SU (N )m0 × SU (N )m00 , where the embedding H ⊂ GL is diagonal. Let 31 , . . . , 3N−1 be the fundamental weights of sl(N ). Let k ∈ N. Recall \) at level k is the following that the set of integrable weights of the affine algebra sl(N subset of the weight lattice of sl(N ): (h)
P++ = {λ = λ1 31 + · · · + λN −1 3N −1 |λi ∈ N, λ1 + · · · + λN −1 < h}, where h = k + N. This set admits a ZN automorphism generated by σ1 : λ = (λ1 , λ2 , . . . , λN−1 ) → σ1 (λ) = (h −
N −1 X
λj , λ1 , . . . , λN −2 ).
j =1
P \) We define the color τ (λ) :≡ i (λi − 1)imod(N ) and Q to be the root lattice of sl(N (cf. §1.3 of [KW]). Note that λ ∈ Q if and only if τ (λ) ≡ 0 mod(N ). As in 2.1, we use i (resp. α) to denote the irreducible positive energy representations of LG (resp. LH ). To compare our notations with that of §2.7 in [KW], note that our i is (30 , 300 ) of [KW] , and our α is 3 of [KW]. We will identify i = (30 , 300 ) and α = 3, where 30 , 300 , 3 are the weights of sl(N ) at levels m0 , m00 , m0 +m00 respectively. \) at level m0 , m00 and m0 + m00 Denote by 00 , 000 , 0 the vacuum representations of sl(N 0 00 respectively. Note that for i = (3 , 3 ), α = 3, by Theorem 1.2 of [X1] the statistical dimensions of i and α are given by di =
a(30 )a(300 ) a(3) , , dα = a(00 )a(000 ) a(0)
where the positive numbers a(3), a(30 ) and a(300 ) are defined as in (0.4b) of [KW] (3) (a(3) is also equal to S30 as defined on p. 362 of [X1]). Suppose i = (31 0 , 31 00 ), j = (32 0 , 32 00 ), k = (33 0 , 33 00 ), α = 31 , β = 32 , δ = 33 . 30
00
33 33 δ Then the fusion coefficients Nijk := N3 30 3 0 N3 00 00 (resp. Nαβ := N31 32 )of LG (resp. 1 2 1 32 LH ) are well known and they are given by Verlinde formula (cf. Cor. 1 on p. 536 of [W2] and p. 288 of [Kac]). Recall πi,α are the covariant representations of the coset H ⊂ GL . The set of all (i, α) := (30 , 300 , 3) which appear in the decompositions of π i of LG with respect to LH is denoted by exp. This set is determined on p. 194 of [KW] to be (30 , 300 , 3) ∈ exp iff 30 + 300 − 3 ∈ Q. The ZN action on (i, α), ∀i, ∀α is denoted by
σ (i, α) := (σ (i), σ (α)) = (σ (30 ), σ (300 ), σ (3)), σ ∈ ZN . This is also known as diagram automorphisms since they correspond to the automorphisms of Dynkin diagrams. Note that dσ (i) = di , dσ (α) = dα by (3.2) of [Wal] and the formula for statistical dimensions above. Also note that this ZN action preserves exp and therefore induces a ZN action on exp. For each (i, α) ∈ exp, we will denote by [i, α] its orbit in exp under the ZN action. Theorem 4.6. Let H ⊂ GL be as in the previous paragraph. Then:
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
37
(1) a(i,α)⊗1 = σi a1⊗α¯ for all (i, α) ∈ exp; (2) Assume the action of ZN on exp is faithful, i.e., if σ (i) = i, σ (α) = α for some (i, α) ∈ exp, then σ = id. Then the covariant representations πi,α are irreducible and πi,α is unitarily equivalent to πj,β as covariant representations iff σ (i) = j, σ (α) = β for some σ ∈ ZN ; (3) Suppose the conditions of (2) hold. Denote by EXP the set of all irreducible localized sectors corresponding to the the covariant representations πi,α , ∀(i, α) ∈ exp. Then the set EXP is in one to one correspondence with the set {[i, α], ∀(i, α) ∈ exp}. Denote the elements of EXP by [i, α]. Define X σ (k) σ (δ) [k,δ] := Nij Nαβ . C[i,α][j,β] σ ∈ZN
Then the compositions are given by: [i, α][j, β] =
X [k,δ]
[k,δ] C[i,α][j,β] [k, δ];
(4) Conjecture 2.13 of 2.3 is true for H ⊂ GL . Proof. By Cor. 4.5 and Theorem 4.1, for any (i, α), (i 0 , α 0 ) we have: ha1⊗α¯ σi , a1⊗α 0 σi 0 i = ha1⊗α¯ a1⊗α 0 , σi¯ σi 0 i = ha1⊗αα ¯ 0 , σi¯ σi 0 i X j X β Nαα Nii =h ¯ 0 σj i ¯ 0 a1⊗β , β
X
=h
β
=
X β
j
β Nαα ¯ 0 1 ⊗ β,
β Nαα ¯ 0
X j
X j,δ
j
Nii ¯ 0 (j, δ) ⊗ δi
j Nii ¯ 0 h1, (j, β)i,
where 1 in the last = stands for the identity sector of A(I ), which by Theorem 2.4, corresponds to the representation π0,0 . So h1, (j, β)i 6 = 0 if and only if π0,0 appears as an irreducible summand in πj,β by the remarks after Lemma 4.2. Note that the vacuum vector (unique up to a nonzero scalar) of π0,0 has lowest energy (the eigenvalue of the generator of the rotation group) 0, and π0,0 is the unique (up to unitary equivalence) irreducible representation with this property (cf. remarks after Prop. 2.1). So π0,0 appears as an irreducible summand in πj,β if and only if there exists a nonzero (vacuum) vector in Hj,β with lowest energy 0. The set of such (j, β) was introduced on p. 186 in [KW] with our (j, β) corresponds to (M, µmod(δ)) in the notation of [KW] (in the notation on p. 186 of [KW], hM − hµ ≥ 0 is the eigenvalue of the generator of the rotation group in the coset Hilbert space by definition). This set in our case of diagonal inclusions is determined in (2.7.12) of [KW]. Translating (2.7.12) of [KW] into the notations of this paper, the statement is that π0,0 appears as an irreducible
38
F. Xu
summand in πj,β iff there exists σ ∈ ZN such that σ (0, 0) = (j, β), where 0 is used to denote the vacuum representation of G and H . Since (cf. (3.3) of [Wal]) σ (0)
Nii ¯0 we have:
σ (0)
0 = δσ (i),i 0 , Nαα ¯ 0 = δσ (α),α ,
ha1⊗α¯ σi , a1⊗α 0 σi 0 i =
X
δσ (i),i 0 δσ (α),α 0 hσ (0, 0), (0, 0)i.
(∗∗)
σ ∈ZN
Ad (1): We will prove (1) by using an “exhaustion” trick similar to the one used in §3 of [X3]. Suppose (i, α) = (i 0 , α 0 ) = (0, α), where 0 denotes the vacuum sector of LG. Note that σ (0) = 0 iff σ = 1. So we conclude from (**) that a1⊗α¯ is irreducible. By (2) of Prop. 4.3, a1⊗α¯ = a(0,α)⊗1 if (0, α) ∈ exp, and so d(0,α) = dα . Note that (cf. P the paragraph before Prop. 4.3) for fixed i, the statistical dimension of ρσi ρ¯ is given by α di,α dα , where the sum is over those α with (i, α) ∈ exp, which will be denoted by expi . Note that if i = (30 , 300 ), α = 3, then expi is a congruence class P m0 +m00 +N modQ (congruent to 30 + 300 ) by definition. So dρ2 = d1i α∈expi di,α dα . of P++ By (3) of Prop. 4.3, d(i,α) ≤ di dα , ∀(i, α) ∈ exp, hence X X dα dα = dα dα , dρ2 ≤ α∈expi
α∈exp0
where the last = follows from Cor. 2.7 of [KW]3 . But since d(0,α) = dα , we have: X dα dα . dρ2 = α∈exp0
It follows that all the ≤’s above are actually =, in particular di,α = di dα , and it follows from (2) of Prop. 4.3 that a(i,α)⊗1 = σi a1⊗α¯ . So we have (see the paragraph before Theorem 4.6): dσ (0,0) = dσ (0) dσ (0) = 1. On the other hand
hσ (0, 0), (0, 0)i ≥ 1,
it follows by comparing statistical dimensions that hσ (0, 0), (0, 0)i = 1. So we can improve (**) to ha1⊗α¯ σi , a1⊗α 0 σi 0 i =
X
δσ (i),i 0 δσ (α),α 0 .
(∗)
σ ∈ZN
Ad (2): By assumption expression (*) holds for a unique σ since the action is faithful. If (i, α) = (i 0 , α 0 ), then σ (i) = i 0 , σ (α) = α 0 iff σ = id, and we conclude from (*) that ha1⊗α¯ σi , a1⊗α¯ σi i = 1, 3 Note that our α correspond to 3 in Cor. 2.7 of [KW], d = a(3) , where 0 denotes the vacuum represenα a(0) m0 +m00 +N tation, and expi is a congruence class of P++ modQ.
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
39
i.e., a1⊗α¯ σi is irreducible. By (1) of Prop. 4.3 and (1) of Theorem 4.6 we conclude that if (i, α) ∈ exp, then (i, α) is irreducible, i.e., πi,α is irreducible by the remarks after Lemma 4.2. If σ (i) = j, σ (α) = β, then 1 ≥ ha1⊗α¯ σi , a1⊗β¯ σj i ≥ 1, where the first ≥ follows from the fact that a1⊗α¯ σi , a1⊗β¯ σj are irreducible, and the second ≥ follows from (*). So we must have a1⊗α¯ σi = a1⊗β¯ σj . By (1) of Prop. 4.3 and (1) of Theorem 4.6 h(i, α), (j, β)i = 1, so (i, α) is identical to (j, β) as sectors, since both sectors are irreducible. Hence πi,α is unitarily equivalent to πj,β as covariant representations by the remarks after Lemma 4.2. On the other hand if πi,α is unitarily equivalent to πj,β as covariant representations, then (i, α) is equal to (j, β) as sectors by the remarks after Lemma 4.2. By (1) of Prop. 4.3 and (1) of Theorem 4.6, a1⊗α¯ σi = a1⊗β¯ σj , so we must have σ (i) = j, σ (α) = β for some σ ∈ ZN by (*). This proves (2). Ad (3): Note that if (i, α) ∈ exp, (j, β) ∈ exp, by (1) and Theorem 4.1 we have: a(i,α)⊗1 a(j,β)⊗1 = σi σj a1⊗α¯ a1⊗β¯ X δ = Nijk Nαβ σk a1⊗δ¯ . k,δ
δ 6= Note by the characterization of exp (cf. p. 194 of [KW]) and 4.3.4 of [FKW], if Nijk Nαβ 0, then (k, δ) ∈ exp. Using (1) again we have:
a(i,α)⊗1 a(j,β)⊗1 =
X (k,δ)∈exp
δ Nijk Nαβ a(k,δ)⊗1 .
(3) now follows from (1) of Prop. 4.2 and (2). Ad (4): By (1) we need to show that b(i, α) = di dα , b(0, 0) where under the identification of i with (30 , 300 ) and α with 3, b(i, α) is given by (2.7.14) of [KW], and using the notations there we have b(i, α) = b(30 , 300 ; 3) = N a(30 )a(300 )a(3). 0 0 Note that d(3) = a(3) a(0) , and we have similar identities when 3, 0 is replaced by 3 , 0 and 300 , 000 . The proof of (4) is now complete by definitions. u t
40
F. Xu
Note that by (1) of Theorem 4.6 and formula (*) if σ (i) = i, σ (α) = α for some σ 6 = id, (i, α) ∈ exp, then a(i,α)⊗1 is not irreducible. Hence (i, α) is not irreducible by (1) of Prop. 4.3. This happens for example when N = 2, m0 ∈ 2N and m00 = 2, which is related to supersymmetric conformal algebras (cf. p. 195 of [KW]). Recall from Subsect. 2.3 coset WN algebras with critical parameters are defined to be the irreducible conformal precosheaves of cosets SU (N)m+1 ⊂ SU (N )m × SU (N )1 , which obviously satisfies (1) to (4) of Theorem 4.6. For N = 2, Theorem 4.6 is obtained in [Luke] by different methods. So we obtain a proof of a long-standing conjecture about representations of coset WN (N > 2) algebras with critical parameters, which is similar in the type A case to Conjecture 3.4 and Theorem 4.3 stated in §§3 and 4 of [FKW]. To compare (3) of Theorem 4.6 to Theorem 4.3 of [FKW], note that (p, p0 ) in [FKW] is identified with (m0 , m0 + 1) in our case, and (λi , λ0i ) in Theorem 4.3 of [FKW] is identified with [30i , 3i 00 , 3i ] in our case with λi = 30i , λ0i = 3i , and 3i 00 is the unique element such that 30i + 3i 00 − 3i ∈ Q. Then the compositions in Theorem 4.3 of [FKW] can be easily checked to be the same as (3) of Theorem 4.6 under the assumptions of Theorem 4.3 in [FKW]. 4.4. More examples. Let us consider the case H ⊂ Gm with G = SU (l) and H is the Cartan subalgebra of G, a l − 1 dimensional torus. This coset does not verify the conditions of Theorem 2.4, but Theorem 2.4 applies to this coset by the remark before Cor. 3.4. So we can apply the results of Sect. 4. Recall the equivalent relation on Zl−1 in 3.1 defined by: (n1 , . . . , nl−1 ) ∼ (n01 , . . . , n0l−1 ) iff there exists (m1 , . . . ml−1 ) ∈ Zl−1 with m1 + · · · + ml−1 ∈ lZ such that (n01 , . . . , n0l−1 ) = (n1 + mm1 , . . . nl−1 + mml−1 ). Denote the equivalence class of (n1 , . . . , nl−1 ) by [n] := [n1 , . . . , nl−1 ] or simply [n], and they are used to denote irreducible projective representations of LH . Let 3 be an irreducible weight of SU (l) at level m. Let τ (3) be the color of 3 , see 4.3. Then: H 3 = ⊕{[n]|(Pi ni −τ (3))∈l Z} H3,[n] ⊗ H[n] , P cf. §2.6 of [KW]. So the set exp = {(3, [n]), |( i ni − τ (3)) ∈ lZ} is determined, and (i, α) = (3, [n]) in the present case. Note that the sector [n] corresponds to an automorphism and has statistical dimension 1 (cf. Sect. 3 before Cor. 3.4). So a1⊗[n] has statistical dimension 1, and it follows that a1⊗[n] a1⊗[n] is the identity sector. So ha1⊗[n] σ3 , a1⊗[n] σ3 i = ha1⊗[n] a1⊗[n] σ3 , σ3 i = hσ3 , σ3 i = 1. Hence a1⊗[n] σ3 is irreducible for any [n], 3. So by Cor. 3.4 and (2) of Prop. 4.3 if (3, [n]) ∈ exp, a(3,[n])⊗1 = a1⊗[n] σ3 , and by (1) of Prop. 4.3 we have the following fusion rules: X 300 00 0 N33 (3, [n])(30 , [n0 ]) = 0 (3 , [n + n ]), 300
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
41
for any (3, [n]), (30 , [n0 ]) ∈ exp. By using (2.6.14) of [KW], one can immediately check that Conj. 2.13 of 2.3 is true in this case, as we did in the proof of (4) of Theorem 4.6. Note this coset is related to Parafermions, see [DL] for an approach using vertex operator algebras. Next we consider the case SU (2)4k ⊂ SU (3)k . When k = 1, SU (2)4 ⊂ SU (3)1 is a conformal inclusion, so by Cor. 4.5, the coset SU (2)4k ⊂ SU (3)k , k > 1 is rational, i.e., it verifies Conj. 2.12 of 2.3. In this particular example, we will use the notations in [ are labeled by an integer l with 0 denoting the §6 of [DJ1]. Thus the weights of sl(2) [ are labeled by a pair of integers (pq) vacuum representation and the weights of sl(3) with (00) denoting the vacuum representation. So (i, α) := (pq, l). In general, the identifications of (i, α) = (j, β) as sectors are related to certain Dynkin diagram automorphisms, as in (2) of Theorem 4.6. See [SY] for more examples. However, in [DJ1], a “Maverick” coset is given which violates the above identification rule. This is the coset SU (2)8 ⊂ SU (3)2 . From the first line of the Table on p. 4117 of [DJ1], we have: (00, 0) = (00, 8) = (11, 4) as sectors by Theorem 2.4 and the fact that the vacuum representation is the unique (up to unitary equivalence) representation which contains a nonzero (vacuum) vector with lowest energy 0. By using the above equation, Theorem 4.1 and Prop. 4.3, we find that the irreducible subsectors of a(pq,l)⊗1 generate a 6 dimensional ring whose basis is: 1, x := a(00,4)⊗1 y := a(10,2) y¯ := a(01,2) z := a(10,4)
= a1⊗4 − σ11 , = σ10 a1⊗2 − σ02 a1⊗2 , = a(10,2) , = σ02 , z¯ := a(01,4) = a(10,4) ,
where a¯ is√the conjugate of a. The statistical dimensions of a(00,4)⊗1 , a(10,2) , a(10,4) are √
5+1 given by 5+1 2 , 2 , 1 respectively. The fusion rules are also completely determined by the above formula, and we have
¯ = [1] + [x], [z3 ] = [1], [y] = [xz]. [x 2 ] = [1] + [x], [y y] By (1) of Prop. 4.3, the above formula determines the structure of the ring generated by the coset sectors. Conjecture 2.13 of 2.3 is also easily verified in this case. For more such “Maverick” cosets, see [DJ2]. Acknowledgement. I’d like to thank the referee for helpful suggestions. This work is partially supported by NSF grant DMS-9820935.
References [ABI] [B] [BBSS] [D]
Altschuler, D., Bauer, M. and Itzykson, C.: The branching rules of conformal embeddings. Commun. Math. Phys. 132, 349–364 (1990) Borcherds, R.: Vertex algebras, Kac–Moody algebras and the Monster. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 83, 3068–3071 (1986) Bais, F.A., Bouwknegt, P., Schoutens, K., Surridge, M.: Coset construction for extended Virasoro algebras. Nucl. Phys. B 304, 371–391 (1988) Dong, C.: Introduction to vertex operator algebras I: S¯urikaisekikenky¯usho K¯o ky¯uroku No. 904, 1–25 (1995). Also see q-alg/9504017
42
[DL] [DJ1] [DJ2] [Dix] [FG] [FKW] [FLM] [FZ] [GKO] [GL] [GW] [Haag] [J] [KW] [Kacv] [Kac] [KS] [KT] [L1] [L2] [L3] [L4] [L5] [L6] [LR] [Luke] [MT] [MS] [Mv] [Po] [PP] [PS] [RS] [Stra] [SY] [Wal] [We] [W1]
F. Xu
Dong, C. and Lepowsky, J.: Generalized vertex algebras and relative vertex operators. Progress in Mathematics 112 (1993) Dunbar, D. and Joshi, K.: Characters for Coset conformal field theories and Maverick examples. Inter. J. Mod. Phys. A 8 No. 23, 4103–4121 (1993) Dunbar, D. and Joshi, K.: Maverick examples of Coset conformal field theories. Mod. Phys. Letters A 8 29, 2803–2814 (1993) Dixmier, J.: von Neumann Algebras. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company, 1981 Fröhlich, J. and Gabbiani, F.: Operator algebras and Conformal field theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 155, 569–640 (1993) Frenkel, E., Kac, V. and Wakimoto, M.: Characters and Fusion rules for W-algebras via Quantized Drinfeld–Sokolov Reductions. Commun. Math. Phys. 147, 295–328 (1992) Frenkel, I.B., Lepowsky, J. and Ries, J.: Vertex operator algebras and the Monster. New York: Academic, 1988 Frenkel, I. and Zhu, Y.: Vertex operator algebras associated to representations of affine and Virasoro algebras. Duke Math. J. 66 1, 123–168 (1992) Goddard, P., Kent,A. and Olive, D.: Unitary representations ofVirasoro and super-Virasoro algebras. Commun. Math. Phys. 103 1, 105–119 (1986) Guido, D. and Longo, R.: The conformal spin and statistics theorem. Commun. Math. Phys. 181, 11–35 (1996) Goodman, R. and Wallach, N.: Structure and unitary cocycle representations of loop groups and the group of diffeomorphisms of the circle. J. Reine Angew. Math. 347, 69–133 (1984) Haag, R.: Local Quantum Physics. Berlin–Heidelberg–New York: Springer-Verlag, 1992 Jones, V.: Fusion en al´gebres de Von Neumann et groupes de lacets (d’aprés A. Wassermann). Seminarie Bourbaki 800, 1–20 (1995) Kac, V.G. and Wakimoto, M.: Modular and conformal invariance constraints in representation theory of affine algebras. Adv. in Math. 70, 156–234 (1988) Kac, V.G.: Vertex algebras for beginners. Providence, RI: AMS, 1997 Kac, V.G.: Infinite dimensional Lie algebras. 3rd Edition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990 Karabali, D. and Schnitzer, H.J.: BRST quantization of the gauged WZW action and coset conformal field theories. Nucl. Phys. B 329 3, 649–666 (1990) Tsuchiya, A. and Kanie, Y.: Vertex Operators in conformal field theory on P 1 and monodromy representations of braid group. Adv. Studies in Pure Math. 16, 297–372 (1988) Longo, R.: Proceedings of International Congress of Mathematicians. Cambridge, MA: International Press, 1994, pp. 1281–1291 Longo, R.: Duality for Hopf algebras and for subfactors, I. Commun. Math. Phys. 159, 133–150 (1994) Longo, R.: Index of subfactors and statistics of quantum fields, I. Commun. Math. Phys. 126, 217–247 (1989) Longo, R.: Index of subfactors and statistics of quantum fields II. Commun. Math. Phys. 130, 285–309 (1990) Longo, R.: An analogue of the Kac–Wakimoto formula and black hole conditional entropy. Commun. Math. Phys. 186, 451–479 (1997) Longo, R.: Minimal index and braided subfactors. J. Funct. Anal. 109, 98–112 (1992) Longo, R. and Rehren, K.-H.: Nets of subfactors. Rev. Math. Phys. 7, 567–597 (1995) Luke, T.: Operator algebras and Conformal Field Theory of the Discrete series representations of Diff(S 1 ). Dissertation, Cambridge (1994) Takesaki, M.: Conditional expectation in von Neumann algebra. J. Funct. Anal. 9, 306–321 (1972) Moore, G. and Seiberg, N.: Taming the conformal zoo. Lett. Phys. B 220, 422–430 (1989) Murray, F.J. and v. Neumann, J.: On rings of Operators. Ann. Math. 37, 116–229 (1936) Popa, S.: Classification of amenable subfactors of type II. Acta Math. 172, 352–445 (1994) Pimsner, M. and Popa, S.: Entropy and index for subfactors. Ann. Éc. Norm. Sup. 19, 57–106 (1986) Pressly, A. and Segal, G.: Loop Groups, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986 Reed, M. and Simon, B.: Methods of Mathematical Physics I: Functional Analysis. London–New York: Academic Press, 1980 Stratila, S.: Modular Theory in Operator Algebras. Editura Academiei, 1981 Schellekens, A.N. and Yankielowicz, S.: Field identification fixed points in the coset construction. Nucl. Phys. B 334, 67–102 (1990) Walton, M.: Fusion rules of Wess–Zumino–Witten Models. Nuc. Phys. B 340, 777–789 (1990) Wenzl, H.: Hecke algebras of type A and subfactors. Invent. Math. 92, 345–383 (1988) Wassermann, A.: Proceedings of International Congress of Mathematicians, Cambridge, Ma: Inernational Press, 1994, pp. 966–979
Algebraic Coset Conformal Field Theories
[W2]
43
Wassermann, A.: Operator algebras and Conformal field theories III. Invent. Math. 133, 467–538 (1998) [Watts] Watts, G.M.T.: W-algebras and coset models. Phys. Lett. B 245, 65–71 (1990) [Witten] Witten, E.: The central charge in three dimensions. V.G. Knizhnik’s Memorial Volume, 1989, pp. 530–559 [X1] Xu, F.: New braided endomorphisms from conformal inclusions. Commun. Math. Phys. 192, 349– 403 (1998) [X2] Xu, F.: Applications of braided endomorphisms from conformal inclusions. Inter. Math. Res. Notice. 1, 5–23 (1998); see also q-alg/9708013, and Erratum, Inter. Math. Res. Notice 8 (1998) [X3] Xu, F.: Jones–Wassermann subfactors for disconnected intervals. q-alg/9704003 [Y] Yamagami, S.: A note on Ocneanu’s approach to Jones index theory. Internat. J. Math. 4, 859–871 (1993) Communicated by H. Araki
Commun. Math. Phys. 211, 45 – 61 (2000)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 2000
Global Weak Solutions for a Shallow Water Equation Adrian Constantin, Luc Molinet Institut für Mathematik, Universität Zürich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zürich, Switzerland Received: 26 June 1999 / Accepted: 21 October 1999
Abstract: We show the existence and uniqueness of global weak solutions for an equation describing the motion of waves at the free surface of shallow water under the influence of gravity. 1. Introduction The nonlinear partial differential equation ut − utxx + 3uux = 2ux uxx + uuxxx , u(0, x) = u0 (x), x ∈ R,
t > 0, x ∈ R,
(1.1)
was obtained by the method of recursion operators by Fokas and Fuchssteiner [14] as a bi-Hamiltonian equation. Its physical derivation as a model for the unidirectional propagation of waves at the free surface of a shallow layer of water (with u(t, x) representing the water’s free surface above a flat bottom) is due to Camassa and Holm [3]. Equation (1.1) was also found independently by Dai [13] as a model for nonlinear waves in cylindrical hyperelastic rods with u(t, x) representing the radial stretch relative to a pre-stressed state. Camassa and Holm [3] found that the solitary waves for (1.1) are uc (x, t) = c ϕ(x − ct), x ∈ R,
(1.2)
where ϕ(x) := e−|x| , x ∈ R. Moreover, the solitary waves are solitons: they retain their individuality under interaction and eventually emerge with their original shapes and speeds (see [2–4]). The solitons are peaked waves and have to be understood (see [6]) as weak solutions of this equation – one can write (1.1) as a conservation law 1 ut + uux + ∂x p ∗ [u2 + u2x ] = 0, 2
(1.3)
46
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
with p(x) := 21 e−|x| , x ∈ R. According to Whitham [23], the solitary waves which are found in the shallow water theory have a symmetrical peaking of the crests with a finite angle there. In [6] results on the existence of classical solutions to (1.1) are obtained. The only way that a classical solution of Eq. (1.1) fails to exist for all time is that the wave breaks [5]: the solution remains bounded while its slope becomes unbounded in finite time. For results on wave breaking we refer to [8,19]. A model for waves on shallow water which presents wave breaking and soliton interaction phenomena was long-time sought after [23]. Other interesting aspects of Eq. (1.1) are its integrability as an infinite dimensional Hamiltonian system1 and the fact that the shallow water flow is just a transcription of the geodesic flow in the group of proper diffeomorphisms of the line modelled on H 1 (R) – see [15,18,20]. For initial profiles u0 ∈ H s (R) with s > 23 , it is known [16,22], that (1.1) has a unique solution in C([0, T ); H s (R)) for some T > 0. The fact that the solitons do not belong to the spaces H s (R) with s > 23 motivates the study of weak solutions to (1.1) that are suitable to treat soliton interaction. Some first results in this direction were recently obtained. In [7] it is proved that if u0 ∈ H 1 (R) is such that y0 := u0 − u0,xx ∈ M+ (R) 2 then there exists a global weak solution u ∈ L∞ ((0, ∞); H 1 (R)) of (1.1). It would be better to have some regularity in time for these weak solutions. Note that the solitons belong to the space C 1 (R+ ; L2 (R)) ∩ C(R+ ; H 1 (R)). The aim of this paper is to prove the following Theorem. If u0 ∈ H 1 (R) is such that y0 := u0 − u0,xx ∈ M+ (R), then equation (1.3) has a unique solution u ∈ C 1 (R+ ; L2 (R)) ∩ C(R+ ; H 1 (R)) with initial data u(0) = u0 + and such that the total variation of y(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·) ∈ M is uniformly R ·) 2:= u(t, R (R) 2 bounded on R+ . Moreover, E(u) := R (u + ux ) dx and F (u) := R (u3 + uu2x ) dx are conservation laws. The method of the proof relies on the approximation of the initial data u0 ∈ H 1 (R) by smooth functions producing a sequence of global solutions of (1.1) in H 3 (R). Suitable a priori estimates enable us to extract a subsequence of these solutions that converges weakly in H 1 (R). We use Helly’s theorem [21] to pass to the limit in the nonlocal nonlinear term from (1.3). By a regularization technique we then show that the obtained solution depends continuously on time. Note that we deal with the same class of initial data as in [7]. Therein the compensated compactness method was used to pass to the limit in the nonlocal nonlinear term from (1.3) in order to show the existence of a solution u ∈ L∞ (R+ ; H 1 (R)). We use here a different approach that enables us to obtain a better time-dependence and we also show the uniqueness of the weak solutions within the considered class. The example of the solitons (1.2), where y0 = 2c δ (here δ is the Dirac mass at zero), shows that our notion of weak solution is the appropriate one for Eq. (1.1). In Sect. 3 we comment about the relevance of our result in the study of the orbital stability of the solitons. The last section is devoted to a discussion of the problem of weak solutions for (1.1) in the periodic case. 1 The spectral and inverse spectral problem in the periodic case is treated in [10]. For the scattering problem see [1,10] – the inverse problem on the line is not fully understood. 2 M(R) is the space of Radon measures on R with bounded total variation and M+ (R) is the subset of positive measures.
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
47
2. Proof of the Theorem Before proceeding with the proof, let us first present some lemmas that will be of use in our approach. Lemma 1 ([6,7,11]). Let u0 ∈ H 3 (R) and assume that y0 := u0 − u0,xx is nonnegative and belongs to L1 (R). Then the initial value problem R (1.1) has a unique solution u ∈ C(R+ ; H 3 (R))∩C 1 (R+ ; H 2 (R)). Moreover, E(u) := R (u2 +u2x ) dx and F (u) := R 3 2 R (u +uux ) dx are conservation laws and if y(t, ·) := u(t, ·)−uxx (t, ·), then for every t ≥ 0 we have (a) u(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·) ≥ 0 and |ux (t, ·)| ≤ u(t, ·) on R, (a) ku(t, ·)kL1 (R) = ky(t, ·)kL1 (R) = ky0 kL1 (R) , (a) kux (t, ·)kL∞ (R) ≤ ky0 kL1 (R) and ku(t, ·)kH 1 (R) = ku0 kH 1 (R) . As the previous result plays an important role in our approach, let us explain informally the importance of the positivity assumption on y0 , without paying attention to technical details. Note that if g = f − fxx , then Z Z 1 ∞ x−ξ 1 x ξ −x e g(ξ ) dξ + e g(ξ ) dξ, x ∈ R, f (x) = 2 −∞ 2 x while fx (x) = −
1 2
Z
x
−∞
eξ −x g(ξ ) dξ +
1 2
Z x
∞
ex−ξ g(ξ ) dξ, x ∈ R.
If g(x) ≥ 0 on R, we see that fx2 (x) ≤ f 2 (x) on R. As the positivity of y(t, ·) is preseved by the flow of (1.1), cf. [6], we see that y0 (x) ≥ 0 on R ensures that u2x (t, x) ≤ u2 (t, x) on R as long as the corresponding solution u(t, ·) to (1.1) exists. The conservation law E(u) guarantees that the solution u(t, ·) remains bounded as long as it exists and, in view of the previous considerations, the slope of the solution will also be bounded. But in classical solutions to (1.1) singularities can arise only in the form of wave breaking, i.e. the solution remains bounded while its slope becomes unbounded in finite time [5]. This reasoning shows that the positivity of y0 ensures global existence for the corresponding solution to (1.1). Note that if for some x0 ∈ R we have y0 (x) ≤ 0 for x ≤ x0 while y0 (x) ≥ 0 for x ≥ x0 , with a proper change of sign, then the corresponding solution of (1.1) will blow up in finite time, [5]. Let us now recall a partial integration result for Bochner spaces (below h·, ·i is the H −1 (R), H 1 (R) duality bracket). Lemma 2 ([17]). Let T > 0. If f, g ∈ L2 ((0, T ); H 1 (R)) and
df dg , ∈ L2 ((0, T ); H −1 (R)), dt dt
then f, g are a.e. equal to a function continuous from [0, T ] into L2 (R) and Z t Z t d f (τ ) d g(τ ) , g(τ )i dτ + , f (τ )i dτ h h hf (t), g(t)i − hf (s), g(s)i = dτ dτ s s for all s, t ∈ [0, T ].
48
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
Throughout this paper, we will denote by {ρn }n≥1 the mollifiers Z −1 ρ(ξ ) dξ n ρ(nx), x ∈ R, n ≥ 1, ρn (x) := R
where ρ ∈ Cc∞ (R) is defined by
(
e1/(x 0
ρ(x) :=
2 −1)
for |x| < 1, for |x| ≥ 1.
The next two approximation results will be also very useful. Lemma 3. Let f : R → R be uniformly continuous and bounded. If µ ∈ M(R), then ρn ∗ (f µ) − (ρn ∗ f ) (ρn ∗ µ) −→ 0 in L1 (R). n→∞
Proof. Since supp (ρn ) ⊂ [− n1 , n1 ] for n ≥ 1, we have Z ρn (y − x)f (x) dµ(x) [ρn ∗ (f µ)](y) = Z =
R y+ n1 y− n1
ρn (y − x) [f (y) + θy (x)] dµ(x)
Z
= f (y)
y+ n1 y− n1
Z ρn (y − x) dµ(x) +
y+ n1
y− n1
ρn (y − x)θy (x) dµ(x),
where θy (x) := f (x) − f (y), x ∈ R. We infer that for n ≥ 1, [ρn ∗ (f µ)] − (ρn ∗ f )(ρn ∗ µ) = (f − ρn ∗ f )(ρn ∗ µ) + 9n , where
Z 9n (y) =
y+ n1
y− n1
(2.1)
ρn (y − x) θy (x) dµ(x), y ∈ R, n ≥ 1.
For n ≥ 1, note that
Z
kρn ∗ µkL1 (R) = = = ≤ ≤
sup ∞
ϕ∈L (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
sup
ϕ∈L∞ (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
sup ∞
ϕ∈L (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
R
ϕ(y)(ρn ∗ µ)(y) dy Z
Z
R
Z
R
ϕ(y)
R
ρn (y − x) dµ(x) dy
(ρn ∗ ϕ)(x) dµ(x)
sup
kρn ∗ ϕkL∞ (R) kµkM
sup
kρn kL1 (R) kϕkL∞ (R) kµkM = kµkM ,
ϕ∈L∞ (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1 ϕ∈L∞ (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
(2.2)
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
49
using Fubini’s theorem and Young’s inequality. Also, observe that Z y+ 1 n ρn (y − x) θy (x) dx, y ∈ R, n ≥ 1 [ρn ∗ f ](y) − f (y) = y− n1
≤
sup x∈[y− n1 ,y+ n1 ]
|θy (x)|, n ≥ 1.
From the above relation we infer by the uniform continuity of f that kρn ∗ f − f kL∞ (R) −→ 0. n→∞
On the other hand,
(2.3)
Z
k9n kL1 (R) = = ≤
sup ∞
ϕ∈L (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
sup ∞
ϕ∈L (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
sup
ϕ∈L∞ (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
≤ εn where
R
Z Z R R
ϕ(y)ρn (y − x)θy (x) dµ(x) dy
Z Z R
R
|ϕ(y)| ρn (y − x)|θy (x)| d|µ|(x) dy
Z Z
sup ∞
ϕ∈L (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
εn = sup
ϕ(y)9n (y) dy
R R
|ϕ(y)| ρn (y − x) d|µ|(x) dy,
sup
y∈R x∈[y− 1 ,y+ 1 ] n
|θy (x)|, n ≥ 1,
n
and |µ| is the total variation measure. We obtain that for n ≥ 1, Z sup [ρn ∗ |ϕ|](x) d|µ|(x) k9n kL1 (R) ≤ εn ∞ ϕ∈L (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
≤ εn
sup
ϕ∈L∞ (R) kϕkL∞ (R) ≤1
R
(2.4)
kρn ∗ |ϕ| kL∞ (R) kµkM ≤ εn kµkM ,
using again Fubini’s theorem and Young’s inequality. Combining (2.1)–(2.4) we get the statement. u t Lemma 4. Let f : R → R be uniformly continuous and bounded. If g ∈ L∞ (R), then ρn ∗ (fg) − (ρn ∗ f ) (ρn ∗ g) −→ 0 in L∞ (R). n→∞
Proof. Going through the first steps of the proof of Lemma 3, we get [ρn ∗ (fg)] − (ρn ∗ f )(ρn ∗ g) = (f − ρn ∗ f )(ρn ∗ g) + 8n , n ≥ 1, where
Z 8n (y) =
y+ n1
y− n1
ρn (y − x) θy (x) g(x) dx, y ∈ R, n ≥ 1,
(2.5)
50
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
and, as before, θy (x) := f (x) − f (y), x ∈ R. Note that by Young’s inequality kρn ∗ gkL∞ (R) ≤ kgkL∞ (R) , n ≥ 1, whereas
|8n (y)| ≤ kgkL∞ (R)
sup |f (x) − f (y)|, y ∈ R, n ≥ 1. |x−y|≤ n1
The previous two relations combined with (2.5) complete the proof in view of (2.3) and the uniform continuity of f . u t Remark. In Lemma 4 we showed that the difference of two sequences of smooth functions converges to zero in L∞ (R). It is interesting to note that for g ∈ L∞ (R) that is not continuous, none of the sequences is a Cauchy sequence in L∞ (R). We split the proof of the theorem in two parts. Existence proof. To show the existence of global weak solutions we proceed in several steps; namely a suitable approximation of the initial data u0 ∈ H 1 (R) by smooth functions un0 produces a sequence of global solutions un (t, ·) of (1.1) in H 3 (R); ii) proving that there is a subsequence of {un } which converges pointwise a.e. to a 1 (R × R) that satisfies (1.3) in the sense of distributions; function u ∈ Hloc + iii) showing that u ∈ Cw (R+ ; H 1 (R)), the space of continuous functions from R+ with values in H 1 (R) when the latter space is equipped with its weak topology; iv) establishing the strong continuity of the solution with respect to the temporal variable and the validity of the conservation laws E and F . i)
Step i) Let u0 ∈ H 1 (R) and assume that y0 := u0 − u0,xx ∈ M+ (R). Define un0 := ρn ∗ u0 ∈ H ∞ (R) for n ≥ 1. Clearly un0 −→ u0 in H 1 (R). n→∞
Note that
(2.6)
y0n := un0 − un0,xx = ρn ∗ y0 ≥ 0, n ≥ 1,
and ky0n kL1 (R) ≤ ky0 kM , n ≥ 1,
(2.7)
as one can see comparing with (2.2). Let un be the global solution of (1.1) with initial data un0 , cf. Lemma 1. Step ii) For fixed T > 0, the estimates provided by Lemma 1 and the form (1.3) of the equation show by means of Young’s inequality that the sequence {un }n≥1 is uniformly bounded in the space H 1 ((0, T ) × R). Therefore, it has a subsequence such that unk * u
weakly in H 1 ((0, T ) × R) for nk → ∞,
(2.8)
and unk −→ u nk →∞
a.e. on (0, T ) × R,
(2.9)
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
51
for some u ∈ H 1 ((0, T ) × R). Note that for fixed t ∈ (0, T ), we have by Lemma 1 and (2.7) that the sequence unx k (t, ·) ∈ BV (R) with V[unx k (t, ·)] = kunxxk (t, ·)kL1 (R)
≤ kunk (t, ·)kL1 (R) + ky nk (t, ·)kL1 (R) ≤ 2 ky0 kM
and
kunx k (t, ·)kL∞ (R) ≤ ky0nk kL1 (R) ≤ ky0 kM .
Here BV (R) is the space of functions with bounded variation and V(f ) is the total variation of f ∈ BV (R), cf. [21]. By Helly’s theorem (see [21]), there exists a subsequence, denoted again {unx k (t, ·)}, which converges at every point to some function v(t, ·) of finite variation with V(v(t, ·)) ≤ 2 ky0 kM . From (2.9) we have that for almost all t ∈ (0, T ), unx k (t, ·) → ux (t, ·) in D0 (R). This enables us to identify v(t, ·) with ux (t, ·) for a.e. t ∈ (0, T ). Therefore unx k −→ ux nk →∞
a.e. on (0, T ) × R,
(2.10)
and for a.e. t ∈ (0, T ), V(ux (t, ·)) = kuxx (t, ·)kM ≤ 2 ky0 kM .
(2.11)
Let us again fix t ∈ (0, T ). Note that the sequence {[un (t, ·)]2 + 21 [unx (t, ·)]2 }n≥1 is uniformly bounded in L2 (R), cf. Lemma 1 and (2.6). Therefore, it has a subsequence, denoted again {[unk (t, ·)]2 + 21 [unx k (t, ·)]2 }, converging weakly in L2 (R). For a.e. t ∈ (0, T ), we deduce from (2.9)–(2.10) that the weak L2 (R)-limit is [u(t, ·)]2 + 21 [ux (t, ·)]2 . As px ∈ L2 (R), a.e. on (0, T ) × R we have 1 1 ∂x p ∗ [(unk )2 + (unx k )2 ] −→ ∂x p ∗ (u2 + u2x ). n →∞ k 2 2
(2.12)
From the relations (2.9)–(2.10) and (2.12) we obtain that u satisfies Eq. (1.3) in D0 ((0, T ) × R). Step iii) From Lemma 1, Young’s inequality and the PDE, we infer that the sequence unt k (t, ·) is uniformly bounded in L2 (R) as t ∈ R+ . We also have an uniform bound on kunk (t, ·)kH 1 (R) for all t ∈ R+ and all n0k s. Hence the family t 7→ unk (t, ·) ∈ H 1 (R) is weakly equicontinuous on [0, T ] for any T > 0. It follows from the Arzela-Ascoli theorem that {unk } contains a subsequence, which we denote again by {unk }, which converges weakly in H 1 (R), uniformly in t. The limit function is u and is weakly continuous from R+ into H 1 (R). Since for a.e. t ∈ R+ , unk (t, ·) * u(t, ·) weakly in H 1 (R), we have ku(t, ·)kH 1 (R) ≤ lim inf kunk (t, ·)kH 1 (R) = lim inf kun0 k kH 1 (R) nk →∞
≤
lim inf ky0nk kL1 (R) nk →∞
nk →∞
≤ ky0 kM
for a.e. t ∈ R+ in view of Lemma 1 andYoung’s inequality. The previous relation implies that u ∈ L∞ (R+ × R).
52
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
Note that by Lemma 1, for all t ∈ R+ , we have kunx (t, ·)kL∞ (R) ≤ kun (t, ·)kL∞ (R) ≤ kun (t, ·)kH 1 (R) ≤ ky0n kL1 (R) ≤ ky0 kM , n ≥ 1.
Combining this with (2.10), we deduce that ux ∈ L∞ (R+ × R). Step iv) As u ∈ Cw (R+ , H 1 (R)), to conclude that u ∈ C(R+ , H 1 (R)) it is enough to show that the functional E(u(t)) = ku(t, ·)k2H 1 (R) is conserved in time. Indeed, if this holds, then ku(t) − u(s)k2H 1 (R) = ku(t)k2H 1 (R) − 2 u(t), u(s) 1 + ku(s)k2H 1 (R) H (R) 2 = 2 ku0 kH 1 (R) − 2 u(t), u(s) 1 , t, s ∈ R+ , H (R)
ku(t)k2H 1 (R)
and the scalar product in the last line converges to = ku0 k2H 1 (R) as s → t. The conservation of E(u) in time is proved by a regularization technique. As u solves (1.3) in distribution sense, we see that for a.e. t ∈ R+ , 1 2 u ) = 0, n ≥ 1. (2.13) 2 x Multiplying with ρn ∗ u, we obtain by integration and in view of Lemma 2 that for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1, Z Z 1 d (ρn ∗ u)2 dx + (ρn ∗ u)[ρn ∗ (uux )] dx (2.14) 2 dt R ZR h i 1 + (ρn ∗ u) ρn ∗ px ∗ (u2 + u2x ) dx = 0. 2 R ρn ∗ ut + ρn ∗ (uux ) + ρn ∗ px ∗ (u2 +
By differentiation of (2.13) we obtain a relation which multiplied by ρn ∗ ux yields after integration and in view of Lemma 2, that for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1, Z Z 1 d (ρn ∗ ux )2 dx + (ρn ∗ ux ) [ρn,x ∗ (uux )] dx 2 dt R ZR h i 1 + (ρn ∗ ux ) ∂x2 ρn ∗ p ∗ (u2 + u2x ) dx = 0. (2.15) 2 R Note that
∂x2 (p ∗ f ) = p ∗ f − f, f ∈ L2 (R).
1 As u2 (t, ·) + u2x (t, ·) ∈ L2 (R), being a weak L2 (R)-limit, we can rewrite relation 2 (2.15) as Z Z 1 d (ρn ∗ ux )2 dx + (ρn ∗ ux )[ρn,x ∗ (uux )] dx (2.16) 2 dt R R Z h i 1 + (ρn ∗ ux ) ρn ∗ p ∗ (u2 + u2x ) dx 2 ZR h 1 2 i 2 − (ρn ∗ ux ) ρn ∗ (u + ux ) dx = 0 2 R
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
53
for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1. Adding (2.14) and (2.16), integration by parts shows that for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1, Z h Z i 3 1 d (ρn ∗ ux )(ρn ∗ u2 ) dx (2.17) (ρn ∗ u)2 + (ρn ∗ ux )2 dx − 2 dt R 2 R Z Z 1 (ρn ∗ ux ) (ρn ∗ u2x ) dx = 0. + [ρn ∗ ux ] [ρn,x ∗ (uux )] dx − 2 R R Observe that lim kρn ∗ ux − ux kL2 (R) = lim kρn ∗ u2 − u2 kL2 (R) = 0.
n→∞
n→∞
Therefore for a.e. t ∈ R+ the second term in (2.17) converges to zero for n → ∞, 1 as u(t, ·) ∈ H h (R)R for a.e. i t ∈ R+ . Similarly, for a.e. t ∈ R+ the last term in (2.17) 1 3 converges to − 2 R ux for n → ∞ as ux ∈ L∞ (R+ × R). Further, note that Z
Z [ρn,x ∗ (uux )] [ρn ∗ ux ] dx = − (ρn,xx ∗ u) (ρn ∗ u) (ρn ∗ ux ) dx (2.18) R R Z h i + (ρn,xx ∗ u) (ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ ux ) − ρn ∗ (uux ) dx. R
Integration by parts shows that Z Z Z 1 1 3 (ρn,xx ∗ u) (ρn ∗ u) (ρn,x ∗ u) dx = − (ρn ∗ ux ) dx −→ − u3 dx. n→∞ 2 R 2 R x R (2.19) On the other hand, kρn,xx ∗ ukL1 (R) ≤ kuxx kM ≤ 2 ky0 kM , n ≥ 1,
(2.20)
in view of (2.2) and (2.11), whereas k(ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ ux ) − ρn ∗ (uux )kL∞ (R) −→ 0, n→∞
(2.21)
by Lemma 4 since ux (t, ·) ∈ L∞ (R) and u(t, ·) ∈ H 1 (R) ⊂ L∞ (R) is uniformly continuous on R. Therefore Z h i (ρn,xx ∗ u) (ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ ux ) − ρn ∗ (uux ) dx −→ 0, n→∞
R
and we showed that for a.e. t ∈ R+ the second to the last term in the relation (2.12) i h Z u3x dx for n → ∞. converges to 21 R
Let us now denote En (t) :=
Z h R
i (ρn ∗ u)2 + (ρn ∗ ux )2 dx, t ∈ R+ , n ≥ 1,
(2.22)
54
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
and define Gn (t) := 3
Z
Z (ρn ∗ ux )(ρn ∗ u2 ) dx − 2 [ρn ∗ ux ] [ρn,x ∗ (uux )] dx R Z R + (ρn ∗ ux ) (ρn ∗ u2x ) dx, t ∈ R+ , n ≥ 1. R
We proved above that for a.e. t ∈ R+ , d En (t) = Gn (t), n ≥ 1, dt
(2.23)
Gn (t) −→ 0.
(2.24)
and n→∞
From Lemma 2 applied to both ρn ∗ u and ρn ∗ ux , we have by (2.23) that Z t Gn (s) ds, t ∈ R+ , n ≥ 1. En (t) − En (0) =
(2.25)
0
We re-express the second term in Gn (t) by means of relations (2.18) and (2.19). Since kρn kL1 (R) = 1 for n ≥ 1, using appropriate combinations of Hölder’s and Young’s inequality and recalling (2.20), we obtain the existence of a constant K > 0 such that |Gn (t)| ≤ K, t ∈ R+ , n ≥ 1,
(2.26)
as u, ux ∈ L∞ (R+ × R). Relations (2.24)–(2.26) force lim [En (t) − En (0)] = 0, t ∈ R+ ,
n→∞
on account of Lebesgue’s dominated convergence theorem. For fixed t ∈ R+ , we therefore have E(u(t)) = lim En (t) = E(u0 ),
(2.27)
n→∞
in view of (2.6). This proves that u ∈ C(R+ ; H 1 (R)) and E is conserved along our solution. From (1.3) and Young’s inequality, it is now obvious that u ∈ C 1 (R+ ; L2 (R)). From Step iii) we know that for a.e. t ∈ R+ , unk (t, ·) * u(t, ·) weakly in H 1 (R). But kunk (t, ·) − u(t, ·)k2H 1 (R) = kunk (t, ·)k2H 1 (R) − 2 unk (t, ·), u(t, ·) 1 + ku(t, ·)k2H 1 (R) H (R) nk 2 = ku0 kH 1 (R) − 2 unk (t, ·), u(t, ·) 1 + ku0 k2H 1 (R) , H (R)
in view of Lemma 1 and (2.27). Therefore, relations (2.6) and (2.27) ensure kunk (t, ·) − u(t, ·)kH 1 (R) −→ 0 nk →∞
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
55
for a.e. t ∈ R+ . This relation shows that for a.e. t ∈ R+ F (unk (t, ·)) −→ F (u(t, ·)), nk →∞
as F is continuous in the H 1 (R)-norm. By Lemma 1, F (unk (t, ·)) = F (un0 k ) −→ F (u0 ), nk →∞
so that for a.e. t ∈ R+ , F (u(t)) = F (u0 ). Since t 7 → F (u(t)) is continuous, we infer t that F (u(t)) = F (u0 ) for all t ∈ R+ . u Remark. Convoluting (1.3) with the family of mollifiers Z {ρn }n≥1 and passing to the limit after integration for n → ∞, it is easy to see that law for our solution.
R
u(t, x) dx is also a conservation
Proof of uniqueness. Let u and v be two weak solutions of (1.3) within the class {f ∈ C 1 (R+ ; L2 (R)) ∩ C(R+ ; H 1 (R)) with the total variation of [f (t, ·) − fxx (t, ·)] ∈ M+ (R) uniformly bounded on R+ }. If M := sup{ku(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·)kM + kv(t, ·) − vxx (t, ·)kM }, t≥0
then for all (t, x) ∈ R+ × R, |u(t, x)| = |p ∗ [u(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·)](x)| ≤ kpkL∞ (R) ku(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·)kM ≤ |ux (t, x)| = |px ∗ [u(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·)](x)| ≤
1 M, 2
(2.28)
1 M, 2
and similarly |v(t, x)| ≤
1 1 M, |vx (t, x)| ≤ M, (t, x) ∈ R+ × R. 2 2
(2.29)
On the other hand, following the same procedure as in (2.2), we find that ku(t, ·)kL1 (R) = kp ∗ [u(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·)]kL1 (R) ≤ M, t ≥ 0, kux (t, ·)kL1 (R) = kpx ∗ [u(t, ·) − uxx (t, ·)]kL1 (R) ≤ M, t ≥ 0, kv(t, ·)kL1 (R) and kvx (t, ·)kL1 (R) ≤ M, t ≥ 0.
(2.30)
Let us define w(t, x) := u(t, x) − v(t, x),
(t, x) ∈ R+ × R.
Then for a.e. t ∈ R+ , we claim that Z Z d |ρn ∗ w| dx = (ρn ∗ wt ) sgn(ρn ∗ w) dx, dt R R and d dt
Z
(2.31)
Z R
|ρn ∗ wx | dx =
R
(ρn ∗ wxt ) sgn(ρn ∗ wx ) dx.
(2.32)
56
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
We justify (2.32) as the argument for (2.31) is similar. Let η : R+ → R be a decreasing C 2 function such that η(s) = 1 for s ∈ [0, 21 ], η(s) = e−s for s ≥ 1 and η is a polynomial on [ 21 , 1]. For R > 0, we put ηR (x) = η
|x| , x ∈ R. R
Applying Lemma 2 to the function |ρn ∗ wx | and ηR we infer that for all t ≥ 0 and n ≥ 1, Z Z |ρn ∗ wx |(t, x) ηR (x) dx − |ρn ∗ wx |(0, x) ηR (x) dx (2.33) R R Z tZ ∂t |ρn ∗ wx |(s, x) ηR (x) dx ds. = 0
R
But ∂t |ρn ∗ wx | = (ρn ∗ wxt ) sgn (ρn ∗ wx ) and t 7 → (ρn ∗ wxt ) = (ρn,x ∗ wt ) is uniformly bounded in L1 (R), as one can see from the PDE. Letting R → ∞ in (2.33), we obtain from Lebesgue’s dominated convergence theorem that for all t ∈ R+ , Z Z tZ Z |ρn ∗wx |(t, x) dx − |ρn ∗wx |(0, x) dx = ∂t |ρn ∗wx |(s, x) dx ds, n ≥ 1. R
R
0
R
Differentiating the above relation with respect to time, one obtains (2.32). Convoluting the PDE’s for u and v with ρn and using (2.31), we get that for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1, Z Z d |ρn ∗ w| dx = (ρn ∗ wt ) sgn (ρn ∗ w) dx dt R RZ = − [ρn ∗ (wux )] sgn (ρn ∗ w) dx ZR − [ρn ∗ (vwx )] sgn (ρn ∗ w) dx Z R (2.34) ρn ∗ px ∗ [w(u + v)] sgn (ρn ∗ w) dx − R Z 1 ρn ∗ px ∗ [wx (ux + vx )] sgn (ρn ∗ w) dx. − 2 R Using (2.28)–(2.30) and Young’s inequality, we infer that for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1, Z Z Z d |ρn ∗ w| dx ≤ 2M |ρn ∗ w| dx + 2M |ρn ∗ wx | dx + Rn (t), (2.35) dt R R R where
Rn (t) → 0 as t → ∞ |Rn (t)| ≤ K, n ≥ 1, t ∈ R+ .
(2.36)
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
57
Here and henceforth K > 0 is a constant depending on M and the H 1 (R)-norms of u(0) and v(0) – recall that H 1 (R)-norm is conserved for the class of solutions we are considering here. For example, Z Z [ρ ∗ (vw )] sgn (ρ ∗ w) dx |ρn ∗ (vwx )| dx ≤ n x n R R Z Z |ρn ∗ wx | |ρn ∗ v| dx + |ρn ∗ (vwx ) − (ρn ∗ v)(ρn ∗ wx )| dx ≤ R Z Z R 1 |ρn ∗ wx | dx + |ρn ∗ (vwx ) − (ρn ∗ v)(ρn ∗ wx )| dx, ≤ M 2 R R
and the second term on the right enters into the framework of Lemma 3. The uniform bound on the error term is attained by Young’s inequality and relations (2.28)–(2.30). The first and third term on the right-hand side of (2.34) can be dealt with analogously. The bound on the last term in (2.34) is slightly more complicated. As the procedure runs along the same lines with the bound on the first term on the right-hand side of the inequality (2.37), we prefer to give the details below for the latter one, slightly more cumbersome. In the same way, convoluting the PDE’s for u and v with ρn,x and using (2.32), we get for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1,
d dt
Z
Z
R
|ρn ∗ wx | dx =
(ρn ∗ wxt ) sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx Z = − [ρn ∗ (wx (ux + vx ))] sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx ZR (2.37) − [ρn ∗ (wvxx )] sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx ZR − [ρn ∗ (uwxx )] sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx ZR 1 1 − ρn ∗ pxx ∗ (u2 − v 2 + u2x − vx2 )sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx. 2 2 R R
Using the identity ∂x2 (p ∗ f ) = p ∗ f − f for f ∈ L2 (R), we easily estimate the last term of the right-hand side by Z Z 1 2 1 2 2 2 |ρn ∗ w| dx ρn ∗ pxx ∗ (u − v + ux − vx ) dx ≤ M 2 2 Z R R +M
R
|ρn ∗ wx | dx + Rn (t),
(2.38)
58
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
with Rn in the class (2.36). To treat the first term of the right-hand side of (2.37), observe that in view of (2.28)–(2.30), Z −
Z [ρn ∗ (wx (ux + vx ))] sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx ≤ ρn ∗ (|wx | (|ux | + |vx |)) dx Z Z R R ρn ∗ |wx | dx ≤ M ρn ∗ |wx | dx ≤ (kux kL∞ (R) + kvx kL∞ (R) ) Z R hZ R i |ρn ∗ wx | dx + M ρn ∗ |wx | − |ρn ∗ wx | dx ≤M R R Z |ρn ∗ wx | dx + Rn (t), t ∈ R+ , n ≥ 1, =M R
(2.39)
with Rn in the class (2.36). Observe that for a.e. t ∈ R+ and all n ≥ 1, Z −
[ρn ∗ (uwxx )]sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx Z = − (ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ wxx ) sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx ZR − [ρn ∗ (uwxx ) − (ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ wxx )] sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx Z ZR ∂ |ρn ∗ wx | dx + |ρn ∗ (uwxx ) − (ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ wxx )| dx ≤ − (ρn ∗ u) ∂x R Z Z R |ρn ∗ wx | (ρn ∗ ux ) dx + |ρn ∗ (uwxx ) − (ρn ∗ u)(ρn ∗ wxx )| dx = R
R
R
after integration by parts. From the previous estimate and Lemma 3 we easily infer that for n ≥ 1 and a.e. t ∈ R+ , Z Z [ρ ∗ (uw )] sgn (ρ ∗ w) dx| ≤ M |ρn ∗ wx | dx + Rn (t) n xx n,x R
R
(2.40)
with Rn belonging the class (2.36). We have now to deal with the second term on the right-hand side of (2.37). For n ≥ 1 and a.e. t ∈ R+ , note that Z Z [ρn ∗ (wvxx )] sgn (ρn,x ∗ w) dx ≤ (ρn ∗ w)(ρn ∗ vxx ) dx R R Z + |ρn ∗ (wvxx ) − (ρn ∗ w)(ρn ∗ vxx )| dx. R
In view of Lemma 3, the last expression can be estimated by a function Rn (t) in the class (2.36). On the other hand, for all n ≥ 1 and a.e. t ∈ R+ , Z (ρn ∗ w)(ρn ∗ vxx ) dx ≤ kρn ∗ wkL∞ (R) kρn ∗ vxx kL1 (R) R
≤ kρn ∗ wkW 1,1 (R) kvxx kM
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
59
in view of (2.2). Therefore, for all n ≥ 1 and t ∈ R+ we have Z Z |ρn ∗ w| dx [ρn ∗ (wvxx )] sgn (ρn ∗ wx ) dx ≤ M R R Z |ρn ∗ wx | dx + Rn (t), +M
(2.41)
with Rn in the class (2.36). From (2.37)–(2.41) we infer that for n ≥ 1 and a.e. t ∈ R+ , Z Z d |ρn ∗ wx | dx ≤ 4 M |ρn ∗ w| dx dt R RZ |ρn ∗ wx | dx + Rn (t), +4M
(2.42)
R
R
with Rn in the class (2.35). Adding (2.35) and (2.42) we obtain by Gronwall’s inequality that for all t ∈ R+ and n ≥ 1, Z t Z e6M(t−s) Rn (s) ds |ρn ∗ w| + |ρn ∗ wx | (t, x) dx ≤ R 0 i hZ |ρn ∗ w| + |ρn ∗ wx | (0, x) dx e6Mt . + R
Fix t > 0 and let n → ∞ in the above inequality. As w, wx ∈ L1 (R) by (2.28)–(2.30) and relation (2.36) holds, we obtain by Lebesgue’s dominated convergence theorem that Z hZ i |w| + |wx | (t, x) dx ≤ |w| + |wx | (0, x) dx e6Mt , t ∈ R+ . R
R
Uniqueness is now plain. u t Example (Solitons). Corresponding to the initial peaked profile of height c ∈ R+ , u0 (x) := c e−|x| , x ∈ R, Eq. (1.3) has a unique weak solution u(t, x) = c e−|x−ct| , (t, x) ∈ R+ × R. This solution is a solitary wave traveling with speed c. Example (The interaction of two solitons). As discovered by Camassa and Holm (see [3]), the solitary waves of Eq. (1.1) are solitons. Consider a weak solution that far out in the past is formed by two solitary waves with the taller one to the left of the shorter: u(t, x) ' c1 e−|x−c1 t| + c2 e−|x−c2 t| as t → −∞. Then it can be seen – for details we refer to [4,9] – that for suitable p1 , p2 , q1 , q2 ∈ W 1,∞ (R), Eq. (1.1) has the following solution in distribution sense: u(t, x) = p1 (t) e−|x−q1 (t)| + p2 (t) e−|x−q2 (t)| , t, x ∈ R. Moreover, u(t, x) ' c1 e
−|x−c1 t−2 ln
c1 c1 −c2 |
+ c2 e
−|x−c2 t−2 ln
c1 −c2 c2 |
as t → ∞.
The taller wave catches the shorter and they collide. No overlapping of the peaks occurs. After the collision the taller wave reappears to the right of the shorter one and eventually the two waves reemerge with their initial shapes and speeds. This shows that the solitary waves are solitons, retaining their identities after interaction.
60
A. Constantin, L. Molinet
3. Stability of the Solitons Due to the weak interaction of the solitons with each other it is reasonable to expect that they are stable. The appropriate notion of stability is orbital stability: a wave starting close to a solitary wave always remains close to some translate of it at all later times (the shape of the wave remains approximately the same for all times). For waves u0 ∈ H 3 (R) that approximate the solitons in a special way, a stability result was proved in [11]. The stability of the solitons is settled by Theorem A ([12]). If u ∈ C([0, T ); H 1 (R)) is a solution to (1.1) with ku(0, ·) − c ϕkH 1 (R) < then
ε4 and 0 < ε < c, 81 c4
ku(t, ·) − c ϕ(· − ξ(t))kH 1 (R) < ε f or t ∈ (0, T ),
where ξ(t) ∈ R is any point where the function u(t, ·) attains its maximum. In Theorem A, u ∈ C([0, T ); H 1 (R)) is a solution to (1.1) if u is a solution of (1.3) in the sense of distributions and E and F are conserved. The results in [22] show that if u0 ∈ H s (R) with s > 23 is such that y0 := u0 −u0,xx ≥ 0, then the profile u0 develops into a solution defined for all t ∈ R+ and entering in the framework of Theorem A. We therefore have the stability of the solitons with respect to perturbations within that class. However, a natural perturbation of a soliton is another nearby soliton and in this case the results in [16,22] are not applicable to guarantee that a solution of (1.1) exists even locally in time. If the initial profile u0 ∈ H 1 (R) with y0 := u0 −u0,xx ∈ M+ (R) is H 1 (R)-close to a soliton, then the corresponding solution (whose existence and uniqueness is guaranteed by our theorem) remains close to some translate of the soliton at all later times, in view of Theorem A. 4. The Periodic Case One can also look for spatially periodic weak solutions for Eq. (1.1). Our methods apply also to this case – one can follow exactly the same steps. Identifying all spaces of periodic functions with function spaces over the unit circle S in R2 , we obtain the following Proposition. If u0 ∈ H 1 (S) is such that y0 := u0 − u0,xx ∈ M+ (S), then equation (1.3) has a unique solution u ∈ C 1 (R+ ; L2 (S)) ∩ C(R+ ; H 1 (S)) with initial data + u(0) = u0 and such that the total variation of y(t, R ·) := u(t, ·) − Ruxx (t, ·) ∈ M (S) is uniformly bounded on R+ . Moreover, I (u) := S u dx, E(u) := S (u2 + u2x ) dx and R F (u) := S (u3 + uu2x ) dx are conservation laws. Remark. (a) The problem of weak solutions to (1.1) for initial data within the class {u0 ∈ H 1 (S): (u0 − u0,xx ) ∈ M+ (S)} was also considered in [9]. Therein it was proved that for every initial data in the above defined class, Eq. (1.3) has a weak solution u ∈ C(R+ ; H 1 (S)) with u(0) = u0 and such that I (u) and E(u) are conserved in time. The proof of the uniqueness of this weak solution given in [9] contains a flaw. However, the present approach shows the statement in [9] is correct and that the weak solution enjoys actually of a better regularity.
Global Weak Solutions for Shallow Water Equation
61
(b) The example of the periodic peakon u(t, x) =
cosh(x − t − [x − t] − 21 ) sinh( 21 )
, (t, x) ∈ R+ × R,
(here [·] stands for the integer part) ensures that the regularity of the weak solutions provided by the proposition is the optimal one. Acknowledgement. The authors are grateful for the useful suggestions made by the referee.
References 1. Beals, R., Sattinger, R. and Szmigielski, J.: Acoustic scattering and the extended Korteweg–de Vries hierarchy. Adv. in Math. 140, (190–206) (1998) 2. Beals, R., Sattinger, D. and Szmigielski, J.: Multipeakons and a theorem of Stieltjes. Inverse Problems 15, 1–4 (1999) 3. Camassa, and Holm, D.: An integrable shallow water equation with peaked solitons. Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 1661–1664 (1993) 4. Camassa, R., Holm. D. and Hyman, J.: A new integrable shallow water equation. Adv. Appl. Mech. 31, (1994) 5. Constantin, A.: Existence of permanent and breaking waves for a shallow water equation: A geometric approach. Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble), in press 6. Constantin, A. and Escher, J.: Global existence and blow-up for a shallow water equation. Annali Sc. Norm. Sup. Pisa 26, 303–328 (1998) 7. Constantin, A. and Escher, J.: Global weak solutions for a shallow water equation. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 47, 1527–1545 (1998) 8. Constantin, A. and Escher, J.: Wave breaking for nonlinear nonlocal shallow water equations. Acta Mathematica 181, 229–243 (1998) 9. Constantin, A. and Escher, J.: Well-posedness, global existence, and blow-up phenomena for a periodic quasi-linear hyperbolic equation. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 51, 475–504 (1998) 10. Constantin, A. and McKean, H.P.: A shallow water equation on the circle, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 52, 949–982 (1999) 11. Constantin, A. and Molinet, L.: Orbital stability of the solitary waves for a shallow water equation. Preprint, University of Zürich (1998) 12. Constantin, and W. Strauss, A.: Stability of peakons. Comm. Pure Appl. Math., in press 13. Dai, H.-H.: Model equations for nonlinear dispersive waves in a compressible Mooney–Rivlin rod. Acta Mechanica 127, 293–308 (1998) 14. Fokas, and Fuchssteiner, B.: Symplectic structures, their Bäcklund transformation and hereditary symmetries. Physica D 4, 47–66 (1981) 15. Kouranbaeva, S.: The Camassa-Holm equation as a geodesic flow on the diffeomorphism group. J. Math. Phys. 40, 857–868 (1999) 16. Li, Yi and Olver, P.: Well-posedness and blow-up solutions for an integrable nonlinearly dispersive model wave equation. J. Differ. Eqs., in press 17. Malek, J., Necas, J., Rokyta M. and Ruzicka, M.: Weak and Measure-valued Solutions to Evolutionary PDEs. London: Chapman & Hall, 1996 18. McKean, H.P.: Shallow water and the diffeomorphism group. Preprint, Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, New York, 1998 19. McKean, H.P.: Breakdown of a shallow water equation. Asian J. Math., to appear 20. Misiolek, G.: A shallow water equation equation as a geodesic flow on the Bott–Virasoro group. J. Geom. Phys. 24, 203–208 (1998) 21. Natanson, I.P. Theory of Functions of a Real Variable. New York: F. Ungar Publ. Co., 1964 22. Rodriguez-Blanco, G.: On the Cauchy problem for the Camassa–Holm equation. Preprint IMPA, Rio de Janeiro 155, 1998 23. Whitham, G.B.: Linear and Nonlinear Waves. New York: J. Wiley & Sons, 1980 Communicated by A. Kupiainen
Commun. Math. Phys. 211, 63 – 83 (2000)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 2000
Interactions in Noncommutative Dynamics William Arveson? Department of Mathematics, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA Received: 12 October 1999 / Accepted: 21 October 1999
To the memory of Irving Segal Abstract: A mathematical notion of interaction is introduced for noncommutative dynamical systems, i.e., for one parameter groups of ∗-automorphisms of B(H ) endowed with a certain causal structure. With any interaction there is a well-defined “state of the past” and a well-defined “state of the future”. We describe the construction of many interactions involving cocycle perturbations of the CAR/CCR flows and show that they are nontrivial. The proof of nontriviality is based on a new inequality, relating the eigenvalue lists of the “past” and “future” states to the norm of a linear functional on a certain C ∗ -algebra.
Introduction, Summary of Results In this paper we are concerned with one-parameter groups of ∗-automorphisms, of the algebra B(H ) of all bounded operators on a Hilbert space H , which carry a particular kind of causal structure. More precisely, A history is a pair (U, M) consisting of a oneparameter group U = {Ut : t ∈ R} of unitary operators acting on a separable infinitedimensional Hilbert space H and a type I subfactor M ⊆ B(H ) which is invariant under the automorphisms γt (X) = Ut XUt∗ for negative t, and which has the following two properties: (irreducibility) (
[
γt (M))00 = B(H ),
(0.1)
t∈R
? On appointment as a Miller Research Professor in the Miller Institute for Basic Research in Science. Support is also acknowledged from NSF grant DMS-9802474.
64
W. Arveson
(trivial infinitely remote past) \
γt (M) = C · 1.
(0.2)
t∈R
We find it useful to think of the group {γt : t ∈ R} as representing the flow of time in the Heisenberg picture, and the von Neumann algebra M as representing bounded observables that are associated with the “past”. However, this paper is concerned with purely mathematical issues concerning the dynamical properties of histories, with problems concerning their existence and construction, and especially with the issue of nontriviality (to be defined momentarily). An E0 -semigroup is a one-parameter semigroup α = {αt : t ≥ 0} of unit-preserving ∗-endomorphisms of a type I∞ factor M, which is continuous in the natural sense [2– 8,10,11,29–33]. The subfactors αt (M) decrease as t increases, and α is called pure if ∩t αt (M) = C1. There are two E0 -semigroups α − , α + associated with any history, α − being the one associated with the “past” by restricting γ−t to M for t ≥ 0 and α + being the one associated with the “future” by restricting γt to the commutant M 0 for t ≥ 0. By an interaction we mean a history with the additional property that there are normal states ω− , ω+ of M, M 0 respectively such that ω− is invariant under the action of α − and ω+ is invariant under the action of α + . Both α − and α + are pure E0 -semigroups, and when a pure E0 -semigroup has a normal invariant state then that state is uniquely determined, see (4.1) below. Thus ω− (resp. ω+ ) is the unique normal invariant state of α − (resp. α + ). Remarks. Since the state space of any unital C ∗ -algebra is weak∗ -compact, the MarkovKakutani fixed point theorem implies that every E0 -semigroup has invariant states. But there is no reason to expect that there is a normal invariant state. Indeed, we have examples (unpublished) of pure E0 -semigroups which have no normal invariant states. Notice too that ω− , for example, is defined only on the algebra M of the past. Of course, ω− has many extensions to normal states of B(H ), but none of these normal extensions need be invariant under the action of the group γ . In fact, we will see that if there is a normal γ -invariant state defined on all of B(H ) then the interaction must be trivial. In order to define a trivial interaction we must introduce a C ∗ -algebra of “local observables”. For every compact interval [s, t] ⊆ R there is an associated von Neumann algebra (0.3) A[s,t] = γt (M) ∩ γs (M)0 . Notice that since γs (M) ⊆ γt (M) are both type I factors, so is the relative commutant A[s,t] . Clearly AI ⊆ AJ if I ⊆ J , and for adjacent intervals [r, s], [s, t], r ≤ s ≤ t we have (0.4) A[r,t] = A[r,s] ⊗ A[s,t] , in the sense that the two factors A[r,s] and A[s,t] mutually commute and generate A[r,t] as a von Neumann algebra. The automorphism group γ permutes the algebras AI covariantly, (0.5) γt (AI ) = AI +t , t ∈ R. Finally, we define the local C ∗ -algebra A to be the norm closure of the union of all the AI , I ⊆ R. A is a C ∗ -subalgebra of B(H ) which is strongly dense and invariant under the action of the automorphism group γ .
Noncommutative Interactions
65
Remarks. It may be of interest to compare the local structure of the C ∗ -algebra A to its commutative counterpart, namely the local algebras associated with a stationary random distribution with independent values at every point [19]. More precisely, suppose that we are given a random distribution φ; i.e., a linear map from the space of real-valued test functions on R to the space of real-valued random variables on some probability space (, P ). With every compact interval I = [s, t] with s < t one may consider the weak∗ -closed subalgebra AI of L∞ (, P ) generated by random variables of the form eiφ(f ) , f ranging over all test functions supported in I . When the random distribution φ is stationary and has independent values at every point, this family of subalgebras of L∞ (, P ) has properties analogous to (0.4) and (0.5), in that there is a one-parameter group of measure preserving automorphisms γ = {γt : t ∈ R} of L∞ (, P ) which satisfies (0.5), and instead of (0.4) we have the assertion that the algebras A[r,s] and A[s,t] are probabilistically independent and generate A[r,t] as a weak∗ -closed algebra. One should keep in mind, however, that this commutative analogy has serious limitations. For example, we have already pointed out that in the case of interactions there is typically no normal γ -invariant state on B(H ), and there is no reason to expect any normal state of B(H ) to decompose as a product state relative to the decompositions of (0.4). There is also some common ground with the Boolean algebras of type I factors of Araki and Woods [1], but here too there are significant differences. For example, the local algebras of (0.3) and (0.4) are associated with intervals (and more generally with finite unions of intervals), but not with more general Borel sets as in [1]. Moreover, here the translation group acts as automorphisms of the given structure whereas in [1] there is no assumption of “stationarity” with respect to translations. For our purposes, the local C ∗ -algebra A has two important features. First, it gives us a way of comparing ω− and ω+ . Indeed, both states ω− and ω+ extend uniquely to γ -invariant states ω¯ − and ω¯ + of A. We sketch the proof for ω− . Proposition 0.1. There is a unique γ -invariant state ω¯ − of A such that ω¯ − AI = ω− AI for every compact interval I ⊆ (−∞, 0]. Proof. For existence of the extension, choose any compact interval I = [a, b] and any operator X ∈ AI . Then for sufficiently large s > 0 we have I − s ⊆ (−∞, 0] and for these values of s, ω− (γ−s (X)) does not depend on s because ω− is invariant under the action of {γt : t ≤ 0}. Thus we can define ω¯ − (X) unambiguously by ω¯ − (X) = lim ω− (γt (X)). t→−∞
This defines a positive linear functional ω¯ − on the unital ∗-algebra ∪I AI , and now we extend ω¯ − to all of A by norm-continuity. The extended state is clearly invariant under the action of γt , t ∈ R. The proof of uniqueness of the extension is straightforward, and we omit it. u t It is clear from the proof of Proposition 0.1 that these extensions of ω− and ω+ are locally normal in the sense that their restrictions to any localized subalgebra AI define normal states on that type I factor.
66
W. Arveson
Definition 0.2. The interaction (U, M), with past and future states ω− and ω+ , is said to be trivial if ω¯ − = ω¯ + . More generally, the norm kω¯ − − ω¯ + k gives some measure of the “strength” of the interaction, and of course we have 0 ≤ kω¯ − − ω¯ + k ≤ 2. If there is a normal state ρ of B(H ) which is invariant under the action of γ , then since ω− (resp. ω+ ) is the unique normal invariant state of α− (resp. α+ ) we must have ρ M = ω− , ρ M 0 = ω+ , and hence ω¯ − = ω¯ + = ρ A by the uniqueness part of Proposition 0.1. In particular, if the interaction is nontrivial then neither ω¯ − nor ω¯ + can be extended from A to a normal state of its strong closure B(H ). The second important feature of A is that there is a definite “state of the past” and a definite “state of the future” in the following sense. Proposition 0.3. For every X ∈ A and every normal state ρ of B(H ) we have lim ρ(γt (X)) = ω¯ − (X),
t→−∞
lim ρ(γt (X)) = ω¯ + (X).
t→+∞
Proof. Consider the first limit formula. The set of all X ∈ A for which this formula holds is clearly closed in the operator norm, hence it suffices to show that it contains AI for every compact interval I ⊆ R. We will make use of the fact (discussed more fully at the beginning of Sect. 5) that if ρ is any normal state of M and A is an operator in M then lim ρ(γt (A)) = ω− (A),
t→−∞
see formula (4.1). Choosing a real number T sufficiently negative that I +T ⊆ (−∞, 0], the preceding remark shows that for the operator A = γT (X) ∈ M we have limt→−∞ ρ(γt (A)) = ω− (A), and hence lim ρ(γt (X)) = lim ρ(γt−T (γT (X))) = ω− (γT (X)) = ω¯ − (X).
t→−∞
t→−∞
The proof of the second limit formula is similar. u t Thus, whatever (normal) state ρ one chooses to watch evolve over time on operators in A, it settles down to become ω¯ + in the distant future, it must have come from ω¯ − in the remote past, and the limit states do not depend on the choice of ρ. For a trivial interaction, nothing happens over the long term: for fixed X and ρ the function t ∈ R 7→ ρ(γt (X)) starts out very near some value (namely ω¯ − (X)), exhibits transient fluctuations over some period of time, and then settles down near the same value again. For a nontrivial interaction, there will be a definite change from the limit at −∞ to the limit at +∞ (for some choices of X ∈ A). A number of questions arise naturally. 1) How does one construct examples of interactions? 2) How does one determine if a given interaction is nontrivial? 3) What C ∗ -dynamical systems can occur as the C ∗ -algebras of local observables associated with an interaction? The purpose of this paper is to provide an effective partial solution of problem 1) and a complete solution of problem 2). The latter involves an inequality which we feel is of some interest in its own right. These results are summarized as follows. By an eigenvalue list we mean a decreasing sequence of nonnegative real numbers λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . with finite sum. Every normal state ω of a type I factor is associated with a positive operator of trace 1, whose eigenvalues counting multiplicity can be arranged
Noncommutative Interactions
67
into an eigenvalue list which will be denoted 3(ω). If the factor is finite dimensional, we still consider 3(ω) to be an infinite list by adjoining zeros in the obvious way. Given two eigenvalue lists 3 = {λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . } and 30 = {λ01 ≥ λ02 ≥ . . . }, we will write k3 − 30 k =
∞ X k=1
|λk − λ0k |
for the `1 -distance from one list to the other. A classical result implies that if ρ and σ are normal states of a type I factor M, then we have k3(ρ) − 3(σ )k ≤ kρ − σ k (see Sect. 3). Combining the results of [7] with the results of Sect. 1 below, we obtain the following result on the existence of interactions having arbitrary finite eigenvalue lists. Theorem A. Let n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞ and let 3− and 3+ be two eigenvalue lists, each of which has only finitely many nonzero terms. There is an interaction (U, M) whose past and future states ω− , ω+ have eigenvalue lists 3− and 3+ , and whose past and future E0 -semigroups are both cocycle perturbations of the CAR/CCR flow of index n. Remarks. Theorem A is established in Sect. 3. We conjecture that the finiteness hypothesis of Theorem A can be dropped. Theorem A gives examples of interactions, but it provides no information about whether or not these interactions are nontrivial. We will show that this is the case whenever the eigenvalue lists of ω− and ω+ are different. That conclusion depends on the following, which is the main result of this paper (and which applies to interactions with arbitrary...i.e., not necessarily finitely nonzero...eigenvalue lists). Theorem B. Let (U, M) be an interaction with past and future states ω− and ω+ , and let ω¯ − and ω¯ + denote their extensions to γ -invariant states of A. Then kω¯ − − ω¯ + k ≥ k3(ω− ⊗ ω− ) − 3(ω+ ⊗ ω+ )k. Remarks. Theorem B is proved in Sect. 4. Notice the tensor product of states on the right. For example, 3(ω− ⊗ ω− ) is obtained from the eigenvalue list 3(ω− ) = {λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . } of ω− by rearranging the doubly infinite sequence of all products λi λj , i, j = 1, 2, . . . into decreasing order. It can be an unpleasant combinatorial chore to calculate 3(ω− ⊗ ω− ) even when 3(ω− ) is relatively simple and finitely nonzero; but we also show in Sect. 4 that if A and B are two positive trace class operators such that 3(A ⊗ A) = 3(B ⊗ B), then 3(A) = 3(B). Thus we may conclude Corollary 0.4. Let (U, M), ω− , ω+ be as in Theorem B, and let 3− and 3+ be the eigenvalue lists of ω− and ω+ respectively. If 3− 6 = 3+ , then the interaction is nontrivial. The following implies that “strong” interactions exist. Corollary 0.5. Let n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞ and choose > 0. There is an interaction (U, M) having past and future states ω− , ω+ , such that α − and α + are cocycle perturbations of the CAR/CCR flow of index n, for which kω¯ − − ω¯ + k ≥ 2 − .
68
W. Arveson
Theorem B depends on a more general result concerning the asymptotic behavior of eigenvalue lists, which may be of some interest on its own. Let α = {αt : t ≥ 0} be an E0 -semigroup acting on B(H ), which is pure in the sense defined above. The commutants Nt = αt (B(H ))0 are type I subfactors which increase with t, and because of purity their union is strongly dense in B(H ). Let ρ be a normal state of B(H ). We require the following information concerning the behavior of the eigenvalue lists of the restrictions ρ Nt for large t. Theorem C. Let α be a pure E0 -semigroup acting on B(H ), which has a normal invariant state ω. Then for every normal state ρ of B(H ) we have lim k3(ρ αt (M)0 ) − 3(ρ ⊗ ω)k = 0.
t→∞
Remarks. One might expect that since the Nt increase to B(H ), the restriction of a normal state to Nt should look like ρ itself when t is large. Indeed, if the invariant state ω is a vector state then its only nonzero eigenvalue is 1 and 3(ρ ⊗ ω) = 3(ρ); in this case Theorem C implies that the restriction of ρ to Nt has almost the same list as ρ when t is large. On the other hand, if ω is not a vector state then 3(ρ ⊗ ω) is very different from 3(ρ), and Theorem C shows that this intuition is wrong. We also remark that Theorem C is itself a special case of a more general result that is independent of the theory of E0 -semigroups (see [9]). 1. Existence of Dynamics Flows on spaces are described infinitesimally by vector fields. Flows on Hilbert spaces (that is to say, one-parameter unitary groups) are described infinitesimally by unbounded self-adjoint operators. In practice, one is usually presented with a symmetric operator A that is not known to be self-adjoint (much like being presented with a differential equation that is not known to possess solutions for all time), and one wants to know if there is a one-parameter unitary group that can be associated with it. Precisely, one wants to know if A can be extended to a self-adjoint operator. This problem of the existence of dynamics was solved by von Neumann as follows. Every densely defined symmetric operator A has an adjoint A∗ with dense domain D∗ , and using A∗ one defines two deficiency spaces E− , E+ by E± = {ξ ∈ D∗ : A∗ ξ = ±iξ }. von Neumann’s result is that A has self-adjoint extensions iff dim E− = dim E+ (see [15, Sect. XII.4]). Moreover, when E− and E+ have the same dimension, von Neumann showed that for every unitary operator from E− to E+ there is an associated self-adjoint extension of A. The purpose of this section is to establish an analogous result which locates the obstruction to the existence of dynamics for pairs of E0 -semigroups of the simplest kind (Corollary 1.1 below). That is based on the following more general result. Let M be a type I subfactor of B(H ), and let α, β be two E0 -semigroups acting, respectively, on M and its commutant M 0 . We want to examine conditions under which there is a one-parameter unitary group U = {Ut : t ∈ R} acting on H whose associated automorphism group γt (A) = Ut AUt∗ has α as its past and β as its future in the sense that (1.1) γ−t M = αt , γt M 0 = βt , t ≥ 0. The following result asserts that there is such a unitary group U if and only if the product systems of α and β are anti-isomorphic.
Noncommutative Interactions
69
Theorem. Let E α = {E α (t) : t > 0} and E β = {E β (t) : t > 0} be the respective product systems of α and β, E α (t) = {x ∈ M : αt (y)x = xy, y ∈ M}, E β (t) = {x 0 ∈ M 0 : βt (y 0 )x 0 = x 0 y 0 , y 0 ∈ M 0 }, and assume that there is a one-parameter unitary group U = {Ut : t ∈ R} whose associated automorphism group satisfies (1.1). Then E α and E β are anti-isomorphic. Indeed, for every t > 0 we have Ut E α (t) = E β (t), and the map θ : E α → E β defined by (1.2) θ(v) = Ut v, v ∈ E α (t), t > 0, is an anti-isomorphism of product systems (i.e., it is a Borel-measurable map which is unitary on fibers, and which satisfies θ (vw) = θ (w)θ (v) for every v ∈ E α (s), w ∈ E α (t), s, t > 0). Conversely, if θ : E α → E β is any anti-isomorphism of product systems, then for every t > 0 there is a unique unitary operator Ut ∈ B(H ) which satisfies (1.2) for every v ∈ E α (t). {Ut : t > 0} is a strongly continuous semigroup of unitary operators tending strongly to the identity as t → 0+, and its natural extension to a one-parameter unitary group gives rise to an automorphism group γ which satisfies (1.1). Proof. Assume that γt (A) = Ut AUt∗ , t ∈ R satisfies (1.1). Fix t > 0. We claim first that Ut E α (t) ⊆ M 0 . Indeed, if x ∈ M then for every v ∈ E α (t) we have xUt v = Ut γ−t (x)v = Ut αt (x)v = Ut vx. Next, we claim that Ut E α (t) ⊆ E β (t). For v ∈ E α (t), the preceding shows that Ut v ∈ M 0 , so it suffices to show that βt (y)Ut v = Ut vy for every y ∈ M 0 . For that, write βt (y)Ut v = γt (y)Ut v = Ut yUt∗ Ut v = Ut yv = Ut vy, the last equality because v ∈ M commutes with y ∈ M 0 . Next, note that E β (t) ⊆ Ut E α (t). Choosing w ∈ E β (t), set v = Ut∗ w. Note that v ∈ M because for every y ∈ M 0 we have yv = yUt∗ w = Ut∗ γt (y)w = Ut∗ βt (y)w = Ut∗ wy = vy. Note next that the element v = Ut∗ w ∈ M actually belongs to E α (t). Indeed, for every x ∈ M we have αt (x)v = αt (x)Ut∗ w. Since γ−t restricts to αt on M, we have γt (αt (x)) = x and the right side can be written Ut∗ γt (αt (x)) = Ut∗ xw = Ut∗ wx = vx. The above shows that for every t > 0 we have a linear map θt : E α (t) → E β (t) defined by θt (v) = Ut v. By assembling these maps we get a Borel-measurable map θ : E α → E β which is linear on fibers. Notice that θt is actually unitary, since for v1 , v2 ∈ E α (t) we have hv1 , v2 i 1 = v2∗ v1 = (Ut v2 )∗ (Ut v1 ) = θ (v2 )∗ θ (v1 ) = hθ (v1 ), θ (v2 )i 1. Finally, θ is an anti-isomorphism, because for v ∈ E α (s), w ∈ E α (t) we have θ(vw) = Us+t vw = Ut (Us v)w = Ut θ (v)w = Ut wθ (v) = θ (w)θ (v).
70
W. Arveson
To prove the converse, fix an anti-isomorphism θ : E α → E β . For every t > 0 pick an orthonormal basis e1 (t), e2 (t) . . . for E α (t) (we will have to choose more carefully presently...but for the moment we choose an arbitrary orthonormal basis for each fiber space). For every t > 0 define an operator Ut ∈ B(H ) by Ut =
∞ X
θ (en (t))en (t)∗ .
n=1
One checks easily that Ut Ut∗ = Ut∗ Ut = 1, hence Ut is unitary. Ut also satisfies (1.2), for if v ∈ E α (t) then we have en (t)∗ v = hv, en (t)i 1 and hence Ut v =
∞ X
X
hv, en (t)i θ(en (t)) = θ (
n=1
hv, en (t)i en (t)) = θ (v).
n
Note too that since the ranges of the operators in E α (t) span H , any operator Ut that satisfies (1.2) is determined uniquely. In particular, Ut does not depend on the choice of orthonormal basis {en (t)} for E α (t). We may choose the orthonormal basis {en (t)} so that each section t 7 → en (t) ∈ E α (t) is Borel measurable (because of the measurability axiom of product systems [2, Property 1.8 (iii)]), and once this is done we find that the function t ∈ (0, ∞) 7 → Ut ∈ B(H ) is Borel measurable. We claim next that {Ut : t > 0} is a semigroup. Indeed, if w ∈ E α (s), v ∈ E α (t), then since θ(v) ∈ M 0 commutes with w ∈ M we have Us Ut vw = Us θ(v)w = Us wθ (v) = θ (w)θ (v) = θ (vw) = Us+t vw. Since E α (s + t) is spanned by such product vw and since E α (s + t)H spans H , we conclude that Us Ut = Us+t . At this point, we use the measurability proposition [2, Prop. 2.5 (ii)] (stated there for the more general case of cocycles) to conclude that a) Ut is strongly continuous in t for t > 0, and b) Ut tends strongly to 1 as t → 0+. Now extend U in the obvious way to obtain a strongly continuous one-parameter unitary group acting on H . Let γt (A) = Ut AUt∗ , A ∈ B(H ), t ∈ R. It remains to show that for every t > 0 we have γ−t M = αt and γt M 0 = βt . Choose x ∈ M. To show that γ−t (x) = αt (x), it suffices to show that γ−t (x)v = αt (x)v for every v ∈ E α (t) (because H is spanned by the ranges of the operators in E α (t)). But for such a v we have γ−t (x)v = U−t xUt v = U−t xθ (v) = U−t θ (v)x = vx = αt (x)v. Choose y ∈ M 0 . To show that γt (y) = βt (y) it suffices to show that γt (y)w = βt (y)w for all w ∈ E β (t). For such a w we have w = θ (v) = Ut v for some v ∈ E α (t), hence γt (y)w = Ut yUt∗ Ut v = Ut yv = Ut vy = wy = βt (y)w, and the proof is complete. u t We view the following result as a counterpart for noncommutative dynamics of von Neumann’s theorem on the existence of self-adjoint extensions of symmetric operators in terms of deficiency indices.
Noncommutative Interactions
71
Corollary 1.1. Let α and β be two E0 -semigroups, acting on B(H ) and B(K) respectively, each of which is a cocycle perturbation of a CCR/CAR flow. There is a oneparameter group of automorphisms of B(H ⊗ K) which satisfies the condition of (1.1) if, and only if, α and β have the same numerical index. Proof. Consider the type I subfactor M of B(H ⊗ K) defined by M = B(H ) ⊗ 1K . We have M 0 = 1H ⊗ B(K), and α (resp. β) is conjugate to the action on M (resp. M 0 ) defined by A ⊗ 1K 7 → αt (A) ⊗ 1K (resp. 1H ⊗ B 7 → 1H ⊗ βt (B)), t ≥ 0. Now the product system of any CAR/CCR flow is anti-isomorphic to itself. This follows, for example, from the structural results on divisible product systems of [2, Sect. 6]. Alternately, one can simply write down explicit anti-automorphisms of the product systems described on pp. 12–14 of [2]. Since the structure of the product system of any E0 -semigroup is stable under cocycle perturbations, the same is true of cocycle perturbations of CAR/CCR flows. The preceding theorem implies that there is a one-parameter group of automorphisms γ = {γt : t ∈ R} of B(H ⊗ K) satisfying γ−t (A ⊗ 1K ) = αt (A) ⊗ 1K ,
γt (1H ⊗ B) = 1H ⊗ βt (B)
for every t ≥ 0 iff the product systems E α and Eβ are anti-isomorphic. The preceding paragraph shows that this is true iff Eα and Eβ are isomorphic; and since α and β are simply cocycle perturbations of CAR/CCR flows, the latter holds iff α and β have the same numerical index. u t Corollary 1.2. Let α and β be two pure E0 -semigroups which are cocycle-conjugate to the CAR/CCR flow of index n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞. Then there is a history (U, M) whose past and future semigroups are conjugate, respectively, to α and β. Remarks on the existence and nonexistence of dynamics: general case. It is natural to ask if every E0 -semigroup α can represent both the past and future of some history. More precisely, is there a history whose past and future E0 -semigroups are both conjugate to cocycle perturbations of α? This is certainly the case for the CAR/CCR flows, by Corollary 1.2. But in general the answer can be no. We have recently received a manuscript of Boris Tsirelson [34] in which examples of product systems are constructed which are not anti-isomorphic to themselves. It is shown in [3] that every abstract product system is isomorphic to the product system of some E0 -semigroup. It follows that there are E0 semigroups α whose product systems are not anti-isomorphic themselves. Since cocycle perturbations of E0 -semigroups must have isomorphic product systems, the theorem proved above implies that such E0 -semigroups (i.e., those whose product systems are not anti-isomorphic to themselves) cannot serve as both the past and future of any history. On the other hand, for every E0 -semigroup α acting on B(H ), which is pure in the sense that ∩t αt (B(H )) = C·1, there is a history whose past is conjugate to α. To see why this is so, let E be its product system. Let E ∗ be the product system opposite to E (E ∗ is defined as the same structure as E except for multiplication, and in E ∗ multiplication is defined by reversing the multiplication of E). Since E ∗ is a product system, the results of [3] imply that there is an E0 -semigroup β, acting on B(K), whose product system is isomorphic to E ∗ and therefore anti-isomorphic to E. We may conclude from the
72
W. Arveson
theorem proved above that there is a one parameter group of automorphisms γ acting on B(H ⊗ K) which satisfies (1.1) by having α ⊗ 1 (acting on B(H ) ⊗ 1) as its past and 1 ⊗ β (acting on 1 ⊗ B(K)) as its future. 2. Eigenvalue Lists of Normal States In this section we emphasize the importance of the “eigenvalue list” invariant that can be associated with normal states of type I factors, and we summarize its basic properties. An eigenvalue P list is a decreasing sequence λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . of nonnegative real numbers satisfying n λn < ∞. If 3 = {λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . } and 30 = {λ01 ≥ λ02 ≥ . . . } are two such lists we write ∞ X |λn − λ0n | k3 − 30 k = n=1
30 ,
from 3 to thereby making the space of all eigenvalue lists into a for the complete metric space. Let A be a positive trace class operator acting on a separable Hilbert space H . The positive eigenvalues of A (counting multiplicity) can be arranged in decreasing order, and if there are only finitely many nonzero eigenvalues then we extend the list by appending zeros in the obvious way. This defines the eigenvalue list 3(A) of A. Notice that even when H is finite dimensional, 3(A) is an infinite list. The following basic properties of eigenvalue lists will be used repeatedly. `1 -distance
Proposition 2.1. 2.1.1 For every positive trace class operator A we have 3(A) = 3(A ⊕ 0∞ ), 0∞ denoting the infinite dimensional zero operator. 2.1.2 For positive trace class operators A and B, 3(A) = 3(B) iff A ⊕ 0∞ is unitarily equivalent to B ⊕ 0∞ . 2.1.3 If L is any Hilbert-Schmidt operator from a Hilbert space H1 to a Hilbert space H2 , then 3(L∗ L) = 3(LL∗ ). 2.1.4 For positive trace class operators A, B we have 3(A) = 3(B) iff trace(An ) = trace(B n ) for every n = 1, 2, . . . Proof. The assertion (2.1.1) is obvious, and (2.1.2) follows after a routine application of the spectral theorem for self-adjoint compact operators. Proof of (2.1.3). Let K1 ⊆ H1 be the initial space of L and let K2 = LK1 ⊆ H2 be its closed range. The polar decomposition implies that L∗ L K1 and LL∗ K2 are unitarily equivalent. Hence L∗ L ⊕ 0∞ and LL∗ ⊕∞ are unitarily equivalent and the assertion (2.1.3) follows from (2.1.2). u t Proof of (2.1.4). If 3(A) = {λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . } then n
trace(A ) =
∞ X k=1
λnk , n = 1, 2, . . .
Thus 3(A) = 3(B) implies that trace(An ) = trace(B n ) for every n ≥ 1. Conversely, suppose that trace(An ) = trace(B n ) for every n = 1, 2, . . . Choose a positive number M so large that the interval [0, M] contains the spectra of both operators
Noncommutative Interactions
73
A and B. The linear functional f 7 → trace(Af (A)) defined on the commutative C ∗ algebra C[0, M] is positive, hence there is a unique finite positive measure µA defined on [0, M] such that Z M f (x) dµA (x) = trace(Af (A)), f ∈ C[0, M]. 0
The restriction of µA to (0, M] is concentrated on σ (A) ∩ (0, M], and for every positive eigenvalue λ of A we have µA ({λ}) = λ · multiplicity of λ. Doing the same for the operator B, we find that by hypothesis Z M Z M x n dµA (x) = x n dµB (x), n = 0, 1, 2, . . . , 0
0
and hence by the Weierstrass approximation theorem µA and µB define the same linear functional on C[0, M]. It follows that µA = µB , and the preceding observations lead us to conclude that 3(A) = 3(B). u t We will also make use of the following classical result, originating in work of Hermann Weyl around 1912. Proposition 2.2. If A, B are positive trace class operators acting on the same Hilbert space H , then k3(A) − 3(B)k ≤ trace|A − B|. Proof. A proof can be found in the appendix of [29]. u t Remarks. Notice that since 3(A) depends only on the unitary equivalence class of A, Proposition 2.2 actually implies that trace|A0 − B 0 |, k3(A) − 3(B)k ≤ inf 0 A ,B0
where A0 (resp. B 0 ) ranges over all operators unitarily equivalent to A (resp. B). Indeed, though we do not require the fact, it is not hard to show that k3(A) − 3(B)k is exactly the distance (relative to the trace norm) from the unitary equivalence class of A ⊕ 0∞ to the unitary equivalence class of B ⊕ 0∞ . Thus the eigenvalue list 3(A) provides a more-or-less complete invariant for classifying positive trace class operators up to unitary equivalence. On the other hand, the eigenvalue list is also a subtle invariant. To illustrate the point, suppose that A has only two positive eigenvalues 3/4 and 1/4, and that B has only three positive eigenvalues 3/5, 1/5, 1/5. The spectrum of A ⊕ B is the union of the spectra and the spectrum of A ⊗ B is the set of products of elements from the two spectra; however, both of these sets must be rearranged in decreasing order. Thus 3(A ⊕ B) = {3/4, 3/5, 1/4, 1/5, 1/5, 0, . . . }, 3(A ⊗ B) = {9/20, 3/20, 3/20, 3/20, 1/20, 1/20, 0, . . . }. Notice that A has only eigenvalues of multiplicity 1, B has eigenvalues of multiplicities 1 and 2, but that A ⊗ B has an eigenvalue of “peculiar” multiplicity 3. In the case of
74
W. Arveson
larger spectra, the relation between say 3(A ⊗ B) and the individual lists 3(A) and 3(B) depends in a complex way on the relative sizes of eigenvalues, and the problem of rearranging the set of products into decreasing order can be a difficult combinatorial chore. Turning now to normal states, let M be a type In factor, n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞ (one can assume without essential loss that M is concretely represented as a subfactor of B(H ) for some Hilbert space H ), and let ρ be a normal state of M. There is a Hilbert space K of dimension n such that M is isomorphic as a ∗-algebra to B(K), and in this case any such ∗-isomorphism must be isometric and normal. Thus we may identify ρ with a normal state of B(K), and consequently there is a positive operator R ∈ B(K) of trace 1 such that ρ(T ) = trace(RT ), T ∈ B(K). The eigenvalue list of ρ is defined by 3(ρ) = 3(R). The preceding discussion leads immediately to the following. Proposition 2.3. 2.3.1 If ρ1 and ρ2 are normal states of type I factors M1 and M2 , and if ρ1 and ρ2 are conjugate in the sense that there is a ∗-isomorphism θ of M1 onto M2 such that ρ2 ◦ θ = ρ1 , then 3(ρ1 ) = 3(ρ2 ). 2.3.2 If ρ1 and ρ2 are two normal states of a type I factor M, then k3(ρ1 ) − 3(ρ2 )k ≤ kρ1 − ρ2 k. Proof. The first assertion is apparent after we realize Mk as B(Hk ), k = 1, 2, use the fact that a ∗-isomorphism of B(H1 ) onto B(H2 ) is implemented by a unitary operator from H1 to H2 , and make use of (2.1.2). The second assertion is the inequality of Proposition 2.2. t u 3. CP Semigroups and the Existence of Interactions The corollary of Sect. 1 implies that any pair of pure E0 -semigroups α− , α+ , which are both cocycle conjugate to the same CAR/CCR flow, can be assembled so as to obtain a history (U, M) whose past and future E0 -semigroups are conjugate to α− and α+ . Moreover, if both α− and α+ have normal invariant states then (U, M) is in fact an interaction. Thus we are led to ask what the possibilities are. PMore precisely, suppose we are given an eigenvalue list 3 = {λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . } with n λn = 1 and a nonnegative integer n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞. Does there exist a cocycle perturbation α of the CAR/CCR flow of index n which is pure, and which leaves invariant a normal state whose eigenvalue list is 3? We do not know the answer in general, but we conjecture that it is yes. The purpose of this section is to provide an affirmative answer for the cases in which 3 has only a finite number of nonzero terms (Theorem A). This is essentially the main result of [7] (together with Corollary 1.1), and we merely summarize the main ideas so as to emphasize the role of dilation theory and semigroups of completely postive maps (sometimes called quantum dynamical semigroups) acting on matrix algebras, for such constructions.
Noncommutative Interactions
75
Suppose that α = {αt : t ≥ 0} is an E0 -semigroup acting on B(H ), and assume further that there is a normal state ω of B(H ) which is invariant, ω ◦ αt = ω, t ≥ 0. Letting be the density operator of ω, ω(T ) = trace(T ), T ∈ B(H ), then the projection P on the closed range of is the support projection of ω, i.e., the largest projection with the property that ω(P ⊥ ) = 0. Using ω ◦ αt = ω, we find that ω(1 − αt (P )) = ω(αt (P ⊥ )) = ω(P ⊥ ) = 0, hence 1 − αt (P ) ≤ 1 − P , hence αt (P ) ≥ P , t ≥ 0.
(3.1)
The inequality (3.1) has the following consequence. If we identify B(P H ) with the corner P B(H )P , then for every t ≥ 0 we can compress αt so as to obtain a completely positive map φt on B(P H ), φt (X) = P αt (X) P H , X ∈ P B(H )P . More significantly, because of (3.1) we have the semigroup property φs ◦ φt = φs+t , as one can easily verify using P αs (A)P = P αs (P AP )P for A ∈ B(H ). Thus we have defined a semigroup φ = {φt : t ≥ 0} of normal completely positive maps of B(P H ) satisfying φt (1) = 1 for t ≥ 0, together with the natural continuity property
lim hφt (X)ξ, ηi = φt0 (X)ξ, η ,
t→t0
ξ, η ∈ P H, X ∈ B(P H ). We appear to have lost ground, in that we started with a semigroup of ∗-endomorphisms and now have merely a semigroup of completely positive maps. However, notice that the restriction of ω to B(P H ) = P B(H )P is a faithful normal state which is invariant under the action of φ, ω ◦ φt = ω, t ≥ 0. Notice too that in case there are only a finite number of positive eigenvalues in the list 3(ω) then P H is finite dimensional, and thus φ = {φt : t ≥ 0} is a CP semigroup acting essentially on a matrix algebra, which leaves invariant a faithful state with prescribed eigenvalues λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · ≥ λr > 0. If α began life as a pure E0 -semigroup then ω is an absorbing state for φ in the sense that for every normal state ρ of B(P H ), lim kρ ◦ φt − ωk = 0.
t→∞
(3.2)
Conversely and most significantly, if we can create a pair (φ, ω) satisfying the conditions of the preceding paragraph then it is possible to reconstruct a pair (α, ω) consisting of an E0 -semigroup α having an invariant normal state ω with the expected eigenvalue list by a “dilation” procedure which reverses the “compression” procedure we have described above. Moreover, if the CP semigroup φ has a bounded generator (as it will surely have in the case where P H is finite dimensional), then its dilation to an E0 -semigroup will be cocycle-conjugate to a CAR/CCR flow whose index can be calculated directly in terms of φ (the details can be found in [6] and [7]). The following summarizes the result of the construction of (φ, ω) for finite eigenvalue lists given in [7, Theorem 5.1].
76
W. Arveson
Theorem 3.1. Let λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · ≥ λr > 0 be a list of positive numbers and let ω be a state of the matrix algebra Mr (C) whose density operator has this ordered list of eigenvalues. There is a semigroup φ = {φt : t ≥ 0} of unital completely positive maps on Mr (C) which leaves ω invariant, satisfies (3.2), and which can be dilated to a pure cocycle perturbation of a CAR/CCR flow having a normal invariant state whose eigenvalue list has exactly λ1 ≥ · · · ≥ λr as its nonzero elements. Theorem 3.3 leads to the following (see pp. 40–42 of [7]). Corollary 3.2. Let n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞ and let 3 = {λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ . . . } be an eigenvalue list which has only a finite number of nonzero terms. There is a cocycle perturbation α of the CAR/CCR flow of index n which is pure, and which has an invariant normal state with eigenvalue list 3. Using Corollary 1.1 of, we deduce Theorem A of the introduction. Theorem A. Let n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞ and let 3− and 3+ be two eigenvalue lists having only a finite number of nonzero terms. There is an interaction (U, M) whose past and future normal states ω− , ω+ have eigenvalue lists 3− , 3+ respectively, and whose past and future E0 -semigroups are cocycle conjugate to the CAR/CCR flow of index n. 4. The Interaction Inequality Theorem A provides many examples of interactions, but it says nothing about whether or not these interactions are nontrivial. For that we need the inequality of Theorem B of the introduction. The purpose of this section is to prove Theorem B and discuss its consequences for interactions. Theorem B is based on the following more general result about E0 -semigroups. An E0 -semigroup α = {αt : t ≥ 0} acting on B(H ) is said to be pure if \ αt (B(H )) = C · 1. t≥0
Purity implies that for any two normal states ρ1 and ρ2 , lim kρ1 ◦ αt − ρ2 ◦ αt k = 0,
t→∞
see Proposition 1.1 of [7]. In particular, if there is a normal state ω which is invariant under α in the sense that ω ◦ αt = ω for every t ≥ 0 then ω must be an absorbing state in the sense that for every normal state ρ of B(H ) we have lim kρ ◦ αt − ωk = 0.
t→∞
(4.1)
Thus, if a pure E0 -semigroup has a normal invariant state then it is unique, and in particular the eigenvalue list 3(ω) of a normal invariant state ω provides a conjugacy invariant of pure E0 -semigroups. Given a pure E0 -semigroup acting on B(H ), the commutants Nt = αt (B(H ))0 are type I subfactors of B(H ) which increase with t, and by purity their union is a strongly dense ∗-subalgebra of B(H ). Let ρ be any normal state of B(H ). Since Nt is a type I factor, the restriction of ρ to Nt has an eigenvalue list, defined as in Sect. 3. The following result shows how these eigenvalue lists behave for large t.
Noncommutative Interactions
77
Theorem C. Let α = {αt : t ≥ 0} be a pure E0 -semigroup having a normal invariant state ω, and let Nt be the commutant αt (B(H ))0 . Then for every normal state ρ of B(H ) we have lim k3(ρ Nt ) − 3(ρ ⊗ ω)k = 0. t→∞
The proof of Theorem C requires some preparation. Lemma 4.1. Let {Ai : i ∈ I } be a net of positive trace class operators acting on a Hilbert space H and let B be a positive trace class operator such that trace (Ai ) = trace (B) for every i ∈ I . Suppose there is a set S ⊆ H , having H as its closed linear span, such that lim hAi ξ, ηi = hBξ, ηi , ξ, η ∈ S. i
Then trace|Ai − B| → 0, as i → ∞. Proof. By Proposition 1.6 of [7] it suffices to show that lim trace(Ai K) = trace(BK)
i→∞
for every compact operator K ∈ B(H ). The set S of compact operators K for which the assertion is true is a norm-closed linear space which contains all rank-one operators of the form ζ 7 → hζ, ξ i η, with ξ, η ∈ S. Since S spans H , it follows that S is the space of all compact operators. u t The next three lemmas relate to the following situation. We are given a normal ∗endomorphism α of B(H ) satisfying α(1) = 1. Let E be the linear space of operators E = {v ∈ B(H ) : α(x)v = vx, x ∈ B(H )}. If u, v are any two elements of E then v ∗ u is a scalar multiple of the identity operator, and in fact E is a Hilbert space relative to the inner product defined on it by v ∗ u = hu, viE 1. For any orthonormal basis v1 , v2 , . . . of E we have X vn xvn∗ , x ∈ B(H ). α(x) = n
Let ρ be a normal state of B(H ). It is clear that u, v ∈ E 7 → ρ(uv ∗ ) defines a bounded sesquilinear form on the Hilbert space E, hence by the Riesz lemma there is a unique bounded operator A ∈ B(E) such that hAu, viE = ρ(uv ∗ ), u, v ∈ E. A is obviously a positive operator and in fact we have trace A = 1, since for any orthonormal basis v1 , v2 , . . . for E, X X hAvn , vn i = ρ(vn vn∗ ) = ρ(α(1)) = ρ(1) = 1. trace A = n
n
The following result shows how to compute the eigenvalue list of the restriction of ρ to the commutant of α(B(H )) in terms of this “correlation” operator A.
78
W. Arveson
Lemma 4.2. Let ρ be a normal state of B(H ) and let A be the positive trace class operator on E defined by hAu, viE = ρ(uv ∗ ), u, v ∈ E. Then 3(ρ α(B(H ))0 ) = 3(A). Proof. By Proposition 2.3.1, it suffices to exhibit a normal ∗-isomorphism θ of B(E) onto α(B(H ))0 with the property that ρ(θ(T )) = trace(AT ), T ∈ B(E).
(4.2)
Consider the tensor product of Hilbert spaces E ⊗ H . In order to define θ we claim first that there is a unique unitary operator W : E ⊗ H → H which satisfies W (v ⊗ ξ ) = vξ , v ∈ E, ξ ∈ H . Indeed, for v, w ∈ E, ξ, η ∈ H we have
hvξ, wηiH = w ∗ vξ, η = hv, wiE hξ, ηi = hv ⊗ ξ, w ⊗ ηiE ⊗H . It follows that there is a unique isometry W : E ⊗ H → H with the stated property. W is unitary because its range spans all of H (indeed, any vector ζ orthogonal P to the range of W has the property v ∗ ζ = 0 for every v ∈ E, hence ζ = α(1)ζ = n vn vn∗ ζ = 0). For every X ∈ B(H ) we have W (1 ⊗ X)v ⊗ ξ = W (v ⊗ Xξ ) = vXξ = α(X)vξ = α(X)W (v ⊗ ξ ), hence W (1 ⊗ X)W ∗ = α(X). It follows that α(B(H ))0 = W (B(E) ⊗ 1)W ∗ , and thus we can define a ∗-isomorphism θ : B(E) → α(B(H ))0 by θ (T ) = W (T ⊗ 1)W ∗ . Writing u × v¯ for the rank-one operator on E defined by u × v¯ : w 7 → hw, viE u, we claim that (4.3) θ(u × v) ¯ = uv ∗ , for every u, v ∈ E. Indeed, if we pick a vector in H of the form η = wξ = W (w ⊗ ξ ), where w ∈ E and ξ ∈ H then we have θ(u × v)η ¯ = θ(w × v)W ¯ (w ⊗ ξ ) = W ((u × v) ¯ ⊗ 1)w ⊗ ξ = W ((u × v)w ¯ ⊗ ξ) ∗ ∗ = hw, viE W (u ⊗ ξ ) = hw, viE uξ = uv wξ = uv η, and (4.3) follows because H is spanned by all such vectors η. Now for every rank-one operator T = u × v¯ ∈ B(E) we have ρ(θ(T )) = ρ(θ(u × v)) ¯ = ρ(uv ∗ ) = hAu, viE = trace(AT ). Formula (4.2) follows for finite rank T ∈ B(E) by taking linear combinations, and the general case follows by approximating an arbitrary operator T ∈ B(E) in the strong operator topology with finite dimensional compressions P T P , P ranging over an increasing sequence of finite dimensional projections with limit 1. u t The following formulas provide a key step. Lemma 4.3. Let α, E be as above, let ρ be a normal state of B(H ) and let R ∈ L1 (H ) be its density operator ρ(X) = trace(RX), X ∈ B(H ). Define a linear operator L from E into the Hilbert space L2 (H ) of all Hilbert-Schmidt operators on H by Lv = R 1/2 v, v ∈ E. Then 4.3.1 hL∗ Lu, viE = ρ(uv ∗ ), u, v ∈ E, and
Noncommutative Interactions
79
4.3.2 for all ξ1 , ξ2 , η1 , η2 ∈ H we have
LL∗ (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ), η1 × η¯ 2
L2 (H )
D E = α(η2 × ξ¯2 )R 1/2 ξ1 , R 1/2 η1 . H
Proof of (4.3.1). Simply write D E
∗ L Lu, v E = hLu, LviL2 (H ) = R 1/2 u, R 1/2 v
L2 (H )
Proof of (4.3.2). We have
∗ LL (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ), η1 × η¯ 2
L2 (H )
= trace(v ∗ Ru) = ρ(uv ∗ ).
= L∗ (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ), L∗ (η1 × η¯ 2 ) E .
t u
(4.4)
Pick an orthonormal basis v1 , v2 , . . . for E. Then the right side of (4.7) can be rewritten as follows: X
L∗ (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ), vn E vn , L∗ (η1 × η¯ 2 ) E n
=
XD
ξ1 × ξ¯2 , R 1/2 vn
E
n
=
X n
L2 (H )
R 1/2 vn , η1 × η¯ 2
E L2 (H )
trace(vn∗ R 1/2 ξ1 × ξ¯2 )trace(R 1/2 vn η2 × η¯ 1 ) =
XD n
D
vn∗ R 1/2 ξ1 , ξ2
On the other hand, E D α(η2 × ξ¯2 )R 1/2 ξ1 , R 1/2 η1
E D
H
H
=
R 1/2 vn η2 , η1
.
vn (η2 × ξ¯2 )vn∗ R 1/2 ξ1 , R 1/2 η1
XD n
=
H
XD n
=
E
(η2 × ξ¯2 )vn∗ R 1/2 ξ1 , vn∗ R 1/2 η1
XD n
vn∗ R 1/2 ξ1 , ξ2
E D H
E H
E
η2 , vn∗ R 1/2 η1
H
E
H
,
and the last expression agrees with the bottom line of the previous formula. u t Lemma 4.4. For a pair A, B of self-adjoint compact operators on H , let A ◦ B be the bounded operator defined on the Hilbert space L2 (H ) of Hilbert-Schmidt operators by A ◦ B(T ) = AT B. Then A ◦ B is unitarily equivalent to A ⊗ B ∈ B(H ⊗ H ). Proof. Pick orthonormal bases e1 , e2 , . . . and f1 , f2 , . . . for H consisting of eigenvectors of A and B, Aen = αn en , Bfn = βn fn , n = 1, 2, . . . Letting em × f¯n be the rank-one operator ζ 7 → hζ, fn i en , then {em × f¯n : m, n = 1, 2, . . . } is an orthonormal basis for L2 (H ) and we have A ◦ B(em × f¯n ) = αm βn em × f¯n ,
m, n = 1, 2, . . .
Thus the unitary operator W : L2 (H ) → H ⊗ H defined by W (em × f¯n ) = em ⊗ fn , m, n = 1, 2, . . . satisfies W (A ◦ B)(em × f¯n ) = (A ⊗ B)W (em × f¯n ) for every t m, n = 1, 2, . . . , and hence W (A ◦ B)W ∗ = A ⊗ B. u
80
W. Arveson
Proof of Theorem C. Let R ∈ B(H ) be the density operator of the normal state ρ, trace(RT ) = ρ(T ), T ∈ B(H ). For every t > 0 let Et be the Hilbert space of intertwining operators associated with αt , Et = {T ∈ B(H ) : αt (A)T = T A, A ∈ B(H )}, 1/2 and let Lt : Et → L2 (H ) be the operator of Lemma 3, Lt v = R v, v ∈ Et . ∗ ∗ Lemma 4.3.1 implies that ρ(uv ) = Lt Lt u, v E , hence the correlation operator of ρ αt (B(H ))0 is L∗t Lt . By Lemma 4.2
3(L∗t Lt ) = 3(ρ αt (B(H ))0 ). On the other hand, (2.1.3) implies that 3(L∗t Lt ) = 3(Lt L∗t ). Thus it suffices to show that the eigenvalue lists of the operators Lt L∗t ∈ B(L2 (H )) converge to 3(ρ ⊗ ω), as t → ∞, in the metric of eigenvalue lists. By (4.3.2) we have D E
(4.5) Lt L∗t (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ), η1 × η¯ 2 L2 (H ) = αt (η2 × ξ¯2 )R 1/2 ξ1 , R 1/2 η1 , H
for all ξ1 , ξ2 , η1 , η2 ∈ H . Now since α is pure, αt (X) converges in the weak∗ -topology to ω(X)1 as t → ∞ (indeed, for every normal state σ , σ (αt (X)) converges to ω(X) = σ (ω(X)1), and the assertion follows because every element of the predual of B(H ) is a linear combination of normal states). Thus if we take the limit on t in the right side of (4.4) we obtain D D E E lim αt (η2 × ξ¯2 )R 1/2 ξ1 , R 1/2 η1 = ω(η2 × ξ¯2 ) R 1/2 ξ1 , R 1/2 η1 t→∞
H
= hη2 , ξ2 iH hRξ1 , η1 iH ,
H
where is the density operator of ω, ω(T ) = trace(T ), T ∈ B(H ). Let R ◦ be the operator on L 2 (H ) defined in Lemma 4.4, and notice that the right side of the preceding expression is R ◦ (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ), η1 × η¯ 2 L2 (H ) . Indeed, by definition of R ◦ we have R ◦ (ξ1 × ξ¯2 ) = Rξ1 × ξ2 , and
Rξ1 × ξ2 , η1 × η¯ 2 L2 (H ) = trace(η2 × η¯ 1 · Rξ1 × ξ2 ) = hRξ1 , η1 iH trace(η2 × ωξ2 ) hRξ1 , η1 iH hη2 , ξ2 iH , which, as asserted, agrees with the right side of the previous expression. Thus we have shown that
lim Lt L∗t (A), B L2 (H ) = hR ◦ (A), BiL2 (H ) t→∞
for rank-one operators A, B ∈ L2 (H ). Now Lemma 4.4 implies that R ◦ is unitarily equivalent to R ⊗ ∈ B(H ⊗ H ), and hence R ◦ is a positive trace class operator for which 3(R ◦ ) = 3(R ⊗ ) = 3(ρ ⊗ ω). On the other hand, Lemma 4.1 implies that lim trace|Lt L∗t − R ◦ | = 0.
t→∞
Noncommutative Interactions
81
By the inequality (2.3.2) we conclude that lim sup k3(Lt L∗t ) − 3(R ◦ )k ≤ lim trace|Lt L∗t − R ◦ | = 0. t→∞
t→∞
We have already seen that 3(R ◦ ) = 3(ρ ⊗ ω), and that 3(Lt L∗t ) = 3(ρ αt (B(H ))0 ). Thus Theorem C is proved. u t We now readily deduce the interaction inequality. Theorem B. Let (U, M) be an interaction with past and future states ω− and ω+ , and let ω¯ − and ω¯ + be their natural extensions to the local C ∗ -algebra A. Then kω¯ − − ω¯ + k ≥ k3(ω− ⊗ ω− ) − 3(ω+ ⊗ ω+ )k. Proof. Fix > 0. By Theorem C we can find T > 0 large enough so that for all t > T we have k3(ω+ A[0,t] ) − 3(ω+ ⊗ ω+ )k ≤ as well as
k3(ω− A[−t,0] ) − 3(ω− ⊗ ω− )k ≤ .
Now for t ≥ T , kω¯ + − ω¯ − k = kω¯ + ◦ γt − ω¯ − ◦ γ−t k ≥ kω¯ + ◦ γt A[−t,t] −ω¯ − ◦ γ−t A[−t,t] k = kω+ ◦ γt A[−t,t] −ω− ◦ γ−t A[−t,t] k.
(4.6)
Since γt gives rise to a ∗-isomorphism of A[−t,t] onto A[0,2t] while γ−t gives rise to a ∗-isomorphism of A[−t,t] onto A[−2t,0] , (2.3.1) implies that 3(ω+ ◦ γt A[−t,t] ) = 3(ω+ A[0,2t] ), and 3(ω− ◦ γ−t A[−t,t] ) = 3(ω− A[−2t,0] ). Thus by Proposition 2.3 the last term of (4.5) is at least k3(ω+ A[0,2t] ) − 3(ω− A[−2t,0] )k, which by our initial choice of T is at least k3(ω+ ⊗ ω+ ) − 3(ω− ⊗ ω− )k − 2. Since is arbitrary, the asserted inequality follows. u t Corollary 4.5. Let (U, M) be an interaction with past and future states ω− , ω+ . If 3(ω− ) 6 = 3(ω+ ), then the interaction is nontrivial. Proof. Contrapositively, suppose that the interaction is trivial and let − and + be the respective density operators of ω− and ω+ . Theorem B implies that − ⊗ − and + ⊗ + must have the same eigenvalue list. (2.1.4) of Proposition 2.1 implies that for every n = 1, 2, . . . we have trace(n− )2 = trace((− ⊗ − )n ) = trace((+ ⊗ + )n ) = trace(n+ )2 . Taking the square root we find that trace(n− ) = trace(n+ ) for every n = 1, 2, . . . and t another application of (2.1.4) leads to 3(− ) = 3(+ ). u
82
W. Arveson
Corollary 4.6. Let n = 1, 2, . . . , ∞ and choose > 0. There is an interaction (U, M) whose past and future E0 -semigroups are cocycle-conjugate to the CAR/CCR flow of index n such that kω¯ + − ω¯ − k ≥ 2 − . Proof. Choose positive integers p < q and consider the eigenvalue lists 3− = {1/p, 1/p, . . . , 1/p, 0, 0, . . . }, 3+ = {1/q, 1/q, . . . , 1/q, 0, 0, . . . }, where 1/p is repeated p times and 1/q is repeated q times. Theorem A implies that there is an interaction (U, M) whose past and future E0 semigroups are cocycle-conjugate to the CAR/CCR flow of index n, for which 3(ω− ) = 3− and 3(ω+ ) = 3+ . By Theorem B, kω¯ + − ω¯ − k ≥ k3(ω+ ⊗ ω+ ) − 3(ω− ⊗ ω− )k. If we neglect zeros, the eigenvalue list of ω− ⊗ ω− consists of the single eigenvalue 1/p 2 , repeated p2 times, and that of ω+ ⊗ ω+ consists of 1/q 2 repeated q 2 times. Thus k3(ω+ ⊗ ω+ ) − 3(ω− ⊗ ω− )k = p2 (1/p2 − 1/q 2 ) + (q 2 − p2 )/q 2 = 2 − 2p2 /q 2 , √ t and the inequality of Corollary 2 follows whenever q is larger than p 2/. u References 1. Araki, H. and Woods, E. J.: Complete Boolean algebras of type I factors. Publ. RIMS (Kyoto University) 2, ser. A, no. 2, 157–242 (1966) 2. Arveson, W.: Continuous analogues of Fock space. Memoirs Am. Math. Soc. 80 no. 3 (1989) 3. Arveson, W.: Continuous analogues of Fock space IV: Eessential states. Acta Math. 164, 265–300 (1990) 4. Arveson, W.: An addition formula for the index of semigroups of endormorphisms of B(H ). Pac. J. Math. 137, 19–36 (1989) 5. Arveson, W.: Quantizing the Fredholm index. In: Operator Theory: Proceedings of the 1988 GPOTSWabash conference, Conway, J. B. and Morrel, B. B. eds., Pitman Research Notes in Mathematics Series, London: Longman, 1990 6. Arveson, W.: Dynamical invariants for noncommutative flows. In: Operator algebras and Quantum Field Theory, Proceedings of the Rome conference, Doplicher et al., eds., 1996 7. Arveson, W.: Pure E0 -semigroups and absorbing states. Commun. Math. Phys. 187, 19–43 (1997) 8. Arveson, W.: On the index and dilations of completely positive semigroups. Int. J. Math., to appear 9. Arveson, W.: Eigenvalue lists of noncommutative probability distributions. Unpublished lecture notes, available from http://www.math.berkeley.edu/˜ arveson 10. Bhat, B.V.R.: Minimal dilations of quantum dynamical semigroups to semigroups of endomorphisms of C ∗ -algebras. Trans. A.M.S., to appear 11. Bhat, B.V.R.: On minimality of Evans-Hudson flows. Ppreprint 12. Chebotarev,A.M., Fagnola, F. : Sufficient conditions for conservativity of quantum dynamical semigroups. J. Funct. Anal. 153, 2, 131–153 (1993) 13. Davies E. B.: Quantum Theory of Open Systems. London–New York: Academic Press, 1976 14. Davies E. B.: Generators of dynamical semigroups. J. Funct. Anal. 34, 421–432 (1979) 15. Dunford, N. and Schwartz, J.: Linear Operators. II. New Yourk: Interscience, 1963 16. Evans, D.: Conditionally completely positive maps on operator algebras. Quart J. Math. Oxford 28 (2), 271–284 (1977) 17. Evans, D.: Quantum dynamical semigroups, symmetry groups, and locality. Acta Appl. Math. 2, 333–352 (1984) 18. Evans, D. and Lewis, J. T.: Dilations of irreversible evolutions in algebraic quantum theory. Comm. Dubl. Inst. Adv. Studies, Ser. A 24, 1977, 104 p. 19. Gelfand, I.M. and Vilenkin, N.Ya.: Generalized functions 4: Applications of harmonic analysis. New York: Academic Press, 1964 20. Gorini, V., Kossakowski, A. and Sudarshan, E.C.G.: Completely positive semigroups on N-level systems. J. Math. Phys.17, 821–825 (1976)
Noncommutative Interactions
83
21. Haag, R.: Local Quantum Physics. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1992 22. Hudson, R.L. and Parthasarathy, K.R.: Stochastic dilations of uniformly continuous completely positive semigroups. Acta Appl. Math. 2, 353–378 (1984) 23. Kümmerer, B.: Markov dilations on W ∗ -algebras. J. Funct. Anal. 63, 139–177 (1985) 24. Kümmerer, B.: Survey on a theory of non-commutative stationary Markov processes. In: Quantum Probability and Applications III, Lecture notes in Mathematics 1303 Berlin–Heidelberg–New–York: Springer, 1987, pp. 154–182 25. Lindblad, G.: On the generators of quantum dynamical semigroups. Commun. Math. Phys. 48, 119 (1976) 26. Mohari, A., Sinha, Kalyan B.: Stochastic dilation of minimal quantum dynamical semigroups. Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci. 102, 159–173 (1992) 27. Parthasarathy, K.R.: An introduction to quantum stochastic calculus. Basel: Birkhäuser Verlag, 1991 28. Pedersen, G.K.: C ∗ -algebras and their automorphism groups. London–New York: Academic Press, 1979 29. Powers, R. T.: Representations of uniformly hyperfinite algebras and their associated von Neumann rings. Ann. Math. 86, 138–171 (1967) 30. Powers, R. T.: An index theory for semigroups of endomorphisms of B(H ) and type I I factors. Can. J. Math. 40, 86–114 (1988) 31. Powers, R. T.: A non-spatial continuous semigroup os ∗-endomorphisms of B(H ). Publ. RIMS (Kyoto University) 23, 1053–1069 (1987) 32. Powers, R. T.: New examples of continuous spatial semigroups of endomorphisms of B(H ). Preprint 1994 33. Powers, R. T. and Price, G: Continuous spatial semigroups of ∗-endomorphisms of B(H ). Trans. A.M.S. 321, 347–361 (1990) 34. Tsirelson, B.: From random sets to continuous tensor products: Answers to three questions of W. Arveson. Preprint Communicated by H. Araki
Commun. Math. Phys. 211, 85 – 109 (2000)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 2000
Rational Solutions of the Master Symmetries of the KdV Equation Jorge P. Zubelli1 , D. S. Valerio Silva2 1 IMPA, Est. D. Castorina 110, RJ 22460-320, Brazil. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Matemática, UFES – Vitória – ES 29060-900, Brazil. E-mail:
[email protected]
Received: 28 January 1999 / Accepted: 22 October 1999
Abstract: In this article we characterize a certain class of rational solutions of the hierarchy of master symmetries for KdV. The result is that the generic rational potentials that decay at infinity and remain rational by all the flows of the master-symmetry KdV hierarchy are bispectral potentials for the Schrödinger operator. By bispectral potentials we mean that the corresponding Schrödinger operators possess families of eigenfunctions that are also eigenfunctions of a differential operator in the spectral variable. This complements certain results of Airault–McKean–Moser [4], Duistermaat–Grünbaum [10], and Magri–Zubelli [40]. As a consequence of bispectrality, the rational solutions of the master symmetries turn out to be solutions of a (generalized) string equation. 1. Introduction One remarkable feature of soliton theory is the fact that it brings to the forefront links between fields that are apparently unrelated. This can be traced as far back as the seminal work of Gardner, Greene, Kruskal and Miura [15] on the conserved quantities for the Korteweg–de Vries (KdV) equation. In their work, the presence of infinitely many conserved quantities was demonstrated making use of the scattering theory of Schrödinger operators. Deeply related to the existence of infinitely many conserved quantities is the remark that KdV is a bi-Hamiltonian system. If we denote by Xk the k th flow the KdV hierarchy, we have Xk (u) = ∂x
δHk−1 δHk = (−∂x3 + 4u∂x + 2ux ) , δu δu
where Hk is the k th conserved quantity of KdV. Furthermore, the two Poisson structures mentioned above are compatible in the sense that their linear combination gives again a Poisson structure. This circle of ideas was highlighted in the work of F. Magri [24,25], which could be considered the catalytic force in the work presented here.
86
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
By making use of the two structures above one is led naturally to the idea of writing a recursion operator to the KdV hierarchy. This can be done introducing the operator Nu = −∂x2 + 4u + 2ux ∂x−1 . def
Indeed, it is not hard to see that, at least formally, we have Xk = Nku X0 , where X0 (u) = ux . For example, k = 1 gives the usual KdV flow X1 (u) = 6uux − uxxx . The present article lies in the crossroads of many different areas. It concerns the characterization of the rational functions, decaying at infinity, that remain rational by the flows of a certain hierarchy {τj }∞ j =0 of nonlinear evolution equations, which is called the master symmetry hierarchy for KdV. This hierarchy, which plays an important role in the bi-Hamiltonian aspects of the KdV equation, is defined as follows: Start from the infinitesimal generator of the scaling transformations def
τ0 (u) =
1 xux + u, 2
and set, for k = 0, 1, · · · , def
τk+1 = Nu τk . It can be shown [40] that the KdV hierarchy {Xk }∞ k=0 and the master-symmetry satisfy hierarchy {τj }∞ j =0 [τj , τl ] = (l − j )τj +l ,
(1)
1 [τl , Xj ] = (j + )Xl+j . 2
(2)
and
Equation (1) corresponds to the celebrated (zero central charge) Virasoro relations. In fact, the master-symmetry vector fields under consideration are only the positive part of the Virasoro algebra. Equation (2) is telling us that the master-symmetry vector fields produce higher order flows of the KdV hierarchy by means of Lie derivatives. The connection between the bi-Hamiltonian structure of the KdV hierarchy and the mastersymmetries goes further. It can be shown that the Lie derivative of the first Poisson structure ∂x of the KdV hierarchy with respect to the vector field τ1 leads to the second structure [3]. Another instance of an exceptional link between different areas in soliton theory was displayed in the work of Duistermaat and Grünbaum [10] with the so-called “bispectral problem”. It was originally motivated by some questions in signal processing and computerized tomography [16–20]. The version of the bispectral problem that concerns us here goes as follows: Characterize the potentials u(x) for the Schrödinger operator L = −∂x2 + u whose eigenfunctions ϕ(x, λ) also satisfy a differential equation in the spectral parameter λ of the form A(λ, ∂λ )ϕ = 2(x)ϕ,
(3)
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
87
where A(λ, ∂λ ) is a differential operator of positive order, independent of x, and 2(x) is a smooth function. The solution of the bispectral problem for Schrödinger operators turned out to be directly connected to the theory of solitons, more specifically to the rational solutions of the KdV equation, which in turn were characterized in the work of Airault, McKean, and Moser [4]. See also [2,9]. Later on, it became clear that the connection between the bispectral property and other soliton equations went much deeper [34,38,39]. The existence of large families of rational solutions is yet another remarkable property possessed by many integrable PDEs. The rational solutions of the KdV hierarchy, and more generally of the Kadomtsev–Petviashvilli equation, are connected to Calogero–Moser systems and to many other important aspects of soliton theory [1,7,22,35]. It was shown in [10] that the rational solutions of the KdV equation are bispectral. However, they comprise only “half” of the bispectral potentials. The remaining potentials, which were also described in [10], do not remain rational by the flows of the KdV hierarchy. Another piece of the puzzle was added in [40]. It was shown therein that the mastersymmetries of the KdV hierarchy are tangent to all the manifolds of bispectral potentials. Those manifolds were constructed by successive Darboux transformations in [10]. As a consequence of the results in [40] it followed that the bispectral potentials, decaying at infinity, remain rational by the flows of the master-symmetries for KdV. The present work addresses a natural follow-up question to the results of [40]: Are the rational potentials that remain rational by the KdV master-symmetries necessarily bispectral potentials? Our answer to this question requires some technical discussion on what is meant by remaining rational by the KdV master symmetries. In Sect. 1.2 we address this issue and discuss the concept that we call generic rational potentials. Our main results are the following: Theorem 1. The generic rational potentials decaying at infinity that remain rational by all the flows of the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy are bispectral. This is obtained as a consequence of a result in [10], which we recall in Sect. 1.2, and the following result which we prove herein: Theorem 2. Let u(x) be a rational potential that decays at infinity and remains rational by the master-symmetry flow τ1 . If we denote by P the set of nonzero poles of u, then X 2 c , (4) u(x) = 2 + x (x − p)2 p∈P
where P satisfies the constraints X c + 3 p
q∈P \{p}
2 = 0, (p − q)3
p ∈ P.
(5)
Furthermore, if the set of nonzero poles P is nonempty and u is a generic rational solution of all flows in the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy then either, c = ν(ν + 1) with ν ∈ Z≥0 , or c = l 2 − 1/4 with l ∈ Z. Using again the results of [10], the characterization of the vanishing rational solutions of the master-symmetry hierarchy given in Theorem 2 yields a description in terms of the Darboux method, namely:
88
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Corollary 1. The class of generic rational solutions, decaying at infinity, of the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy consists of potentials obtained by successive rational Darboux transformations starting at u = 0 or u=
−1/4 . x2
1.1. Plan of the article. We conclude this introductory section with a little bit of background information on the bispectral problem, Darboux transformations, and the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy. In Sect. 2 we start the study of the rational solutions of the master-symmetry hierarchy for KdV. We characterize the constraints on the poles and their dynamics. The constraints in the present situation are similar to the ones of the Airault–McKean–Moser locus [4], with the difference that here the pole at zero has to be treated differently and introduces an extra parameter. This parameter is exactly the c that appears in Eq. (4). Section 3 is dedicated to the study of the compatibility between the locus constraints and the vector fields defined by the master symmetries. The conclusion is that if the potential remains rational by all the flows of the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy, then such flows are compatible with the locus conditions. In order toachieve our goal of characterizing the (vanishing) rational solutions of the hierarchy τj j ≥0 we will show in the next sections that the constant c of Eq. (4) takes only a certain set of discrete values, provided the set of nonzero poles is nonempty. The discreteness of the values of c is in fact the difficult part of our result. Our initial attempts of proving that using only the asymptotics at x = 0 or at x = ∞ failed. We eventually had to connect the two asymptotics, which led us to the use of the squared eigenfunction method. Section 4 is concerned with the effect of the master symmetries on their rational solutions. Those properties will then be used in Sect. 5 to conclude that the (vanishing) rational solutions of the master-symmetry flows are bispectral. We finish with a section containing some conclusions and suggestions for further research.
1.2. Background. In this section we shall collect background information on the bispectral problem for the Schrödinger operator, so as to make the paper accessible to a wider audience. For further information on the relationship between the bispectral problem and other areas we refer the reader to [21] and references therein. We shall first make precise what we mean by generic rational solutions of evolution equations. Let us consider an equation of the form ut = K(u).
(6)
In this paper we are concerned with rational solutions decaying at infinity. We explain this predilection in Sect. 6. Since we are interested in solutions that vanish at infinity, we write u in partial fraction decomposition form as u=
np XX p∈Q ν=1
cν,p . (x − p)ν
(7)
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
89
Here, as usual, Q denotes the set of distinct poles of u and np the leading order of each pole p. It is now natural to require the coefficients cν,p and the poles p ∈ Q to be smooth functions of time. We shall also require the condition that the cardinality of the set of poles remains constant and that the leading coefficient of each such singularity cνp ,p does not vanish. We shall call u satisfying such conditions generic. We elaborate on what we are missing with the generic assumption in Sect. 6. A slight, though convenient, abuse of language will be used: We shall say that u = u0 (x) is a rational solution of K if there exists an integral curve u = u(x, t), of (6) of the form (7), which is well defined in a sufficiently small neighborhood of t = 0, such that u(x, 0) = u0 (x). Likewise, we shall say that u0 is a rational solution of a hierarchy σj if it is a rational solution of each flow σj in the hierarchy. The main technique for producing all the bispectral Schrödinger potentials is the Darboux transformation. It has been widely used in the soliton literature and generalized in many directions. More information on the geometric aspects of the Darboux method can be found in [26,27] and references therein. The (classical) Darboux process starts off from an operator L = −∂x2 + u for which we know how to solve the eigenvalue problem Lφ = λφ for all λ. We factorize L as a product of two first order operators L = A∗ A,
(8)
e = AA∗ . The function where A = ∂x −v and A∗ is its formal adjoint. We then construct L 2 v satisfies u = vx + v , which is a Riccati equation that can be linearized by means of the transformation v = χ 0 /χ. It turns out that the linearized equation is Lχ = 0, which by hypothesis we know how to solve. The new potential is given by e u = u − 2vx . It is e with a possible exception e(x, λ) = Aφ(x, λ) is an eigenfunction of L, easy to see that φ of λ = 0. The upshot is that the process can be iterated; each time one introduces a new complex parameter. The final potential after N iterations depends (in general) on N parameters. The process of going from u to e u is called a Darboux transformation. This transformation is said to be rational if it starts from a rational potential and yields another rational potential. Example 1. If one starts with the potential u = 0, one gets after one Darboux transformation the potential u1 = 2/(x + t1 )2 , where t1 is an arbitrary constant. Another transformation yields (modulo translation) u2 = −2∂x2 log(x 3 + 12t). One can easily check that u2 is a rational solution of the KdV hierarchy. It is in fact a stationary solution of the flow X2 . Successive iterations of the method lead to the Adler-Moser sequence of polynomials [2]. Example 2. If one starts from u0 = (l 2 −1/4)/x 2 , where l ∈ Z>0 , one gets after applying Darboux (l − 1)2 − 1/4 − 2∂x2 log(1 + sx 2l ) . x2 Each of the two examples above are the first nontrivial families of bispectral potentials. The potential in Example 2 does not remain rational by the KdV hierarchy flows. It is, however, an example of a stationary solution of τ1 . Let us now return to the bispectral problem. A few elementary symmetries of the bispectral problem are the following: u(x, t) =
90
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Scaling. The map x 7 −→ x, which induces at the level of potentials u(x) 7 −→ 2 u(x). Translation. The map x 7 −→ x + t1 , which induces at the level of potentials u(x) 7 −→ u(x + t1 ). Addition of a constant. The map u(x) 7−→ u(x) + C. It can be shown [10] that bispectral potentials are necessarily rational functions of x. Furthermore, the only bispectral potentials that are unbounded are those of the form u = x, modulo the above symmetries. We shall, from now on, concentrate on the bispectral potentials decaying at infinity. The characterization of the bispectral potentials is given by Theorem 3 (Duistermaat and Grünbaum [10]). Let u be a bispectral potential decaying at infinity. Then, modulo the elementary symmetries above, u is of the form u = c/x 2 or it can be obtained from u = 0 or u = −1/4x 2 by iterations of rational Darboux transformations. We remark that the potentials obtained by rational Darboux transformations starting from 0 are exactly those that vanish at infinity and remain rational by the flows of the KdV hierarchy. On the other hand, it was shown in [40] that those potentials obtained starting from u = −1/4x 2 remain rational by the flows of the master symmetries of the KdV hierarchy. Theorem 4 (Prop. 4.3 of [10]). Let P be a balanced set and c = l 2 − 1/4 with l ∈ Z>0 . Suppose that u is of the form (4) with the configuration of nonzero poles P satisfying (5). Then, u(x) can be obtained by µ rational Darboux transformations starting from (l + µ)2 − 1/4 . x2 A natural question, which was addressed in [10], is what are the possible configurations of poles of a rational function in order for it to be bispectral. The next result gives an answer to this question. It is actually a particular case of a more general one in [10]. We shall use it in order to prove that the rational solutions of the master symmetries for KdV are bispectral. u0 (x) =
Theorem 5 (Duistermaat and Grünbaum [10]). Suppose that u is of the form X 2 c , u(x) = 2 + x (x − p)2
(9)
p∈P
where P is the set of nonzero poles of u. 1. If c = l 2 − 1/4, P is balanced, and satisfies l 2 − 1/4 + p3 then u is bispectral.
X q∈P \{p}
2 = 0, (p − q)3
∀p ∈ P,
(10)
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
91
2. If c = ν(ν + 1), ν ∈ Z≥ 0, and P satisfies ν(ν + 1) + p3
X q∈P \{p}
2 = 0, (p − q)3
X
p∈P
2 p2k+1
= 0,
∀p ∈ P,
(11)
∀k, 1 ≤ k ≤ ν
(12)
then u is bispectral. We close this section with a few remarks on the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy. The concept of master-symmetry was introduced in the work of Fokas and Fuchssteiner [11] and explored in a number of ensuing works [8, 12–13, 14,28–30]. The flow τ0 (u) = (1/2)xux + u is the infinitesimal generator of the one parameter group of scaling symmetries u(x) 7 → es u(es/2 x),
s ∈ R.
A short computation gives that the first (nontrivial) flow of the hierarchy is x τ1 (u) = − (uxxx − 6uux ) − 2uxx + 4u2 + ux ∂x−1 u. 2 For our purposes, we are concerned only with rational functions. We define therefore ∂x−1 as an integral along a path of the complex plane joining ∞ to x and avoiding all the poles of the function under consideration. Since we are looking for rational solutions, the rational functions under consideration must have zero residues at all poles. This makes the choice of the integral well defined. 2. Motion of the Poles Under τ1 2.1. Preliminaries. This section focus on the rational solutions of the first flow of the master-symmetry hierarchy, namely ut = τ1 [u],
(13)
where τ1 = Nu τ0 . 2.2. The form of the rational solutions. The first key remark in understanding the rational solutions of the flow τ1 , is that they must have the form X cp . u(x, t) = (x − p)2 p∈Q
This is a consequence of the following: Proposition 1. If u is a rational solution of (13), of the form (7), then we have 1. If p ∈ Q, then np = 2. 2. The coefficient cj,p = 0 unless j = 2 .
92
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Proof. This claim is a straightforward argument on the leading order term of the asymptotic expansion near a pole p of both sides of (13). The LHS gives (denoting the time derivative by˙ ) u˙ =
np XX p∈Q j =1
c˙j,p j pc ˙ j,p + . (x − p)j (x − p)j +1
The RHS is given by (Nu τ0 )(u) where 1 xux + u 2 1 X X cj,p (−j ) X X cj,p + = x 2 (x − p)j +1 (x − p)j p p j j X X cj,p (−j/2 + 1) jpcj,p = − . (x − p)j 2(x − p)j +1 p
τ0 [u] =
j
After plugging τ0 (u) given above into τ1 = Nu τ0 we get τ1 [u] = A + B + C, with XX
j (j + 1)(−(j/2) + 1)cj,p j (j + 1)(j + 2)pcj,p + , j +2 (x − p) 2(x − p)j +3 p j X X cj,p (−j/2 + 1) X X cj,p jpcj,p , − B = 4 (x − p)j (x − p)j 2(x − p)j +1 p p j j X X cj,p (−j/2 + 1) X X cj,p (−j ) pcj,p . + C = 2 (x − p)j +1 (x − p)j −1 (−j + 1) 2(x − p)j p p A=
−
j
j
Lemma 1. If p 6 = 0, then np ≤ 2. The leading term of A in the vicinity of a given pole p is j (j + 1)(j + 2)pcj,p 2(x − p)j +3
(14)
with j = np . On the other hand, the combined contributions of B and C, in the vicinity of p 6 = 0 is given by 2 −3jpcj,p
(x − p)2j +1
(15)
with j = np . If np > 2, then the leading term on the RHS would be the contribution from B and C, since in this case 2np + 1 > np + 3. But this cannot be balanced by the LHS whose highest order pole is np + 1, which is strictly less than 2np + 1. This proves the lemma.
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
93
On a similar vein we can show: Lemma 2. If p = 0, then np = 2. The fact that c1,p = 0 is an obvious consequence of the fact that any nonzero coefficient for (x − p)−1 would lead to logarithms on the RHS. This concludes the proof of the proposition. u t We are then left with u=
X p
c2,p . (x − p)2
Henceforth, we set cp = c2,p . Now, since np = 2 the leading coefficients of A, B and C combine to give p(6cp − 12)cp = 0. (x − p)5 Since we are assuming that p is indeed a pole of u, it follows that cp = 2 for p 6 = 0. We have thus proved Lemma 3. Under the assumptions of Proposition 1, the coefficient cp = 2 whenever p 6 = 0. We are now ready to state Proposition 2. If u is a generic rational solution of ut = τ1 [u], then u=
X 2 c + , 2 x (x − p)2
(16)
06 =p∈Q
where c is independent of t. Proof. It remains to show that c˙ = 0. The value of c˙ = 0 is the coefficient of the term in x −2 of A + B + C. However, A does not have any term in x −2 . After a partial fraction decomposition of B and C, we get Coeff(B + C, x −2 ) = 0. t Hence, the coefficient of the term in x −2 of the RHS vanishes. u Remark 1. We are now left with the task of studying rational functions of the form (16). Most of this paper is dedicated to showing that either c = ν(ν + 1) with ν ∈ Z≥0 or c = l 2 − 1/4 for l ∈ Z. This turns out to be much harder than the proof of Proposition 1. It is rather disturbing that we had to add the hypothesis that u(x) remains rational by the higher order flows {τk }k≥2 in order to get such a result. We are naturally led to formulate the following: Conjecture 1. The conclusion of Theorem 1 also holds if we assume that u(x) remains rational under the flow of τ1 only and not necessarily by all the flows of the mastersymmetry hierarchy.
94
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
2.3. The motion of the poles. We now consider the evolution equation satisfied by the poles of u(x, t) a rational solution of ut = τ1 (u). Once again they will be obtained by balancing the powers of (x − p) on both sides of this equation. As in the case of the rational solutions of KdV studied by [2,4,9] we encounter two types of consequences from the balancing of the powers of (x − p). The first ones are evolution equations for the poles. The second ones are constraints on the pole locations. Now, one major difference between the present situation and the rational solutions of KdV is the fact that here the equation is not invariant by translations. This is a direct consequence of the fact that x multiplies three of the terms in τ1 . As a result we have to consider two possibilities. Namely, zero as a stationary pole of u(x, t) and zero as a moving pole. If p = 0 at a certain time, say t = 0, and after that p(t) 6 = 0, then we can assume, without loss of generality, that c = 0 in Eq. (16). This gives that X 2 . u(x, t) = (x − p(t))2 p∈Q
After plugging u of this form into ut = τ1 (u) and comparing the terms in (x − p)−3 we obtain X 2 = 0. (p − q)3 q∈Q\{p}
But these are exactly the celebrated locus conditions of Airault–McKean–Moser. It is known that the (Airault–McKean–Moser) locus is empty, unless the total number of poles is of the form d(d + 1)/2, where d is a positive integer. It follows again from the results of [10] (Thm. 3.4) that if the locus is not empty, then u can be obtained by Darboux transformations from u0 = 0. Hence, u is bispectral. It turns out that in this case, u happens to remain rational by the flows of the KdV hierarchy. We have thus proved: Proposition 3. If a generic rational potential u(x), decaying at ∞, remains rational by the flow of τ1 and does not have x = 0 as a stationary pole, then it also remains rational by the flows of the KdV hierarchy. We now focus on the case that x = 0 is stationary. From now on, we refer to P as the set of nonzero poles of u. We shall also denote by Pp the set def
Pp = P \ {p} . Proposition 4. Let u be of the form u=
X 2 c + , 2 x (x − p)2
(17)
p∈P
where each nonzero pole p(t) of u(·, t) depends smoothly on t. Then, u is a solution of ut = τ1 (u)
(18)
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
95
if, and only if, the configuration of nonzero poles P(t) for u(·, t) satisfies X 1 = 0, c p
(19)
p∈P
X 2 c + = 0, 3 p (p − q)3
∀p ∈ P,
(20)
q∈Pp
and,
X 2p + q c , p˙ = −2 + p (p − q)2
p ∈ P.
(21)
q∈Pp
Proof. The proof of this result is a straightforward, albeit laborious, exercise in partial fraction decomposition. The evolution of the poles, which is given by conditions (21), is obtained by balancing the powers of (x − p)−3 on the left- and right-hand side of (18). Condition (19) appears by balancing the terms in x −3 . Condition (20) results from the t analysis of the powers of (x − p)−2 . Details can be found in [32]. u Remark 2. If we sum over all the poles the condition (20), we get X 1 = 0. c p3
(22)
p∈P
This equation appears also by balancing the terms in x −1 . Recall that the n-fold symmetric product S n (C) is the set of unordered n-tuples of distinct complex numbers. This set has the structure of a complex variety with local charts on Cn \ 1, where 1 = z = (z1 , · · · , zn ) ∈ Cn |∃i 6= j s.t. zi = zj . Let n be the number of nonzero poles of u. When c = 0 (or c=2) the subset of points in Cn (resp. Cn+1 ) described by condition (20) plays an important role in the theory of the rational solutions of KdV. It was called the locus by Airault, McKean, and Moser [4]. In analogy with the terminology of [4] we have the following: Definition 1. The set of points in S n (C) satisfying the constraints (19), and (20) will be called the locus. We shall denote it by Lc . A few natural questions arise: 1. For which values of c is the locus nonempty? 2. Is the vector field defined by (21) consistent with the locus conditions? 3. What is the relation between the locus Lc and the bispectral problem? We do not have the answer to the first question in its full generality. In the case c = 0, the locus is void unless n = d(d + 1)/2 for some d = 1, 2, · · · . See [4]. When c = l 2 − 1/4, then for certain values of n the locus is certainly non-void; this follows from the results of [40]. Indeed, in [40] it is shown that the master-symmetry flows are tangential to all the manifolds of bispectral potentials. In particular, it follows that the configurations of poles for the potentials obtained by successive applications of Darboux to u = −1/4x 2 are in the locus Lc for c = l 2 − 1/4.
96
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Example 3. Take l ∈ Z>0 and any s ∈ C. The potential u(x, t) =
(l − 1)2 − 1/4 − 2∂x2 log(1 + sx 2l ) x2
is a stationary rational solution of (18). In particular, its pole configuration satisfies the locus conditions with c = (l − 1)2 − 1/4 and 2l nonzero poles. The pole configuration corresponds to the 2l th roots of unity multiplied by s −1/2l . As for the second question, we shall address it in the next section, where we treat the problem of consistency of the locus condition with the vector fields. Finally, the third problem can be answered in part by stating the main result of this paper. Namely, if a generic rational potential u(x) decaying at infinity conserves such properties by all the flows of the KdV master-symmetries, then it is bispectral. 3. The Locus and Higher Order Flows In the previous section we saw that the generic vanishing rational solutions of τ1 are potentials of the form u=
X 2 c + . 2 x (x − p)2
(23)
p∈P
Furthermore, the configuration of nonzero poles P satisfies the constraints given by the locus conditions (19) and (20), and evolves according to X 2p + q c . p˙ = −2 + p (p − q)2 q∈Pp
The main question we address in this section is whether the evolution above is indeed consistent with the locus conditions. To do that, we shall assume that we are working with a regular point, of a nonempty locus. If this is the case, then a vector (p) ˙ p∈P belongs to the tangent space TP Lc iff the following conditions are satisfied: c
X p˙ = 0, p2
p∈P
X p˙ − q˙ p˙ 2 = 0 , ∀p ∈ P. c 4+ p (p − q)4 q∈Pp
We remark that a tangent vector (p) ˙ p∈P to S n (C) induces a tangent vector on the space of functions of the form (23) according to v˙ =
X p∈P
4p˙ . (x − p)3
(24)
The main goal of this section is to show that the master-symmetry vector fields induce vector fields on the locus Lc . More precisely, we will show that
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
97
Proposition 5. If u(x) is a generic rational solution, decaying at infinity, of the KdV master-symmetry flows {τi }i≥1 , then each τi induces a tangent vector to the locus, in the sense that X 4p˙ , τi [u] = (x − p)3 p∈P
where (p) ˙ p∈P ∈ T Lc . Proof. The generic assumption implies that u has the form (23) and that it makes sense to talk about the derivative of the poles along the flow of τi and τi+1 . We shall use the notation τj (p) to denote the time derivative of a pole p along the flow τj . The fact that τi+1 = Nu τi and that the rational solution of ut = τi+1 (u) has the form (23) implies that X −2µ0 (x − p)τi+1 (p) = τi+1 (u) = Nu τi (u), (25) p∈P
where µ(x) = x −2 . On the other hand, we have X −2µ0 (x − p)τi (p) Nu τi [u] = − ∂x2 + 4u + 2ux ∂x−1 def
=
X
p∈P
2µ000 (x − p)τi (p)
p∈P
X X 2µ(x − p) −2µ0 (x − q)τi (q) + 4 cµ(x) + p∈P
+ 2 cµ0 (x) +
X
q∈P
X 0 2µ (x − p) −2µ(x − q)τi (q).
p∈P
q∈P
After rearranging the terms we get X X 2µ000 (x − p)τi (p) − 24 µ(x − p)µ0 (x − p)τi (p) Nu τi [u] = p∈P
− 8c
p∈P
X
0
µ(x)µ (x − p)τi (p) − 4c
p∈P
− 16
X
X
µ0 (x)µ(x − p)τi (p)
p∈P 0
µ(x − q)µ (x − p)τi (p) − 8
p,q∈P p6=q
X
µ(x − q)µ0 (x − p)τi (q).
p,q∈P p6 =q
Hence, using that µ000 = 12µµ0 and swapping the rôles of p and q we have X X µ(x)µ0 (x − p)τi (p) − 4c µ0 (x)µ(x − p)τi (p) Nu (τi [u]) = − 8c p∈P
−8
X
p,q∈P p6=q
p∈P 0
µ(x − q)µ (x − p)[2τi (p) + τi (q)].
98
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Now, a partial fraction decomposition yields def
4 = Nu τi = − 8c
X
µ00 (p)x −1 − µ0 (p)x −2
p∈P
− µ00 (p)(x − p)−1 − 2µ0 (p)µ(x − p) + µ(p)µ0 (x − p) τi (p) X − µ00 (p)x −1 + 2µ0 (p)x −2 − 4c p∈P
+ µ(p)µ0 (x) + µ00 (p)(x − p)−1 + µ0 (p)µ(x − p) τi (p) X − µ00 (p − q)(x − p)−1 −8 p6=q 0
− 2µ (p − q)µ(x − p) + µ(p − q)µ0 (x − p) + µ00 (p − q)(x − q)−1 − µ0 (p − q)µ(x − q) 2τi (p) + τi (q) . Substituting this into Eq. (25) and comparing the terms of the same power we get, denoting p˙ = τi (p), Coeff(4, x −1 ) : − 24c
X
p−4 p˙ = 0,
(26)
X 2(p − q)−4 (p˙ − q) ˙ = 0, Coeff(4, (x − p)−1 ) : 24 cp−4 p˙ +
(27)
p∈P
Coeff(4, (x − p)
−2
Coeff(4, x −3 ) : 8c
) : − 24 cp
X
q∈Pp −3
+
X
−3
2(p − q)
p˙ = 0,
(28)
q∈Pp
p−2 p˙ = 0,
(29)
p∈P
X (p − q)−2 (2p˙ + q) ˙ = 4τi+1 (p). Coeff(4, (x − p)−3 ) : 16 cp−2 p˙ +
(30)
q∈Pp
Equations (26), (27), (29) show that τi is indeed tangent to the locus, whereas Eq. (30) t give us the effect of τi+1 on the poles. u Although the next two propositions will not be used in the sequel, we believe they provide further information about the constraints that the poles of u have to satisfy in order for it to be a rational solution of the master-symmetry hierarchy. The first one is a byproduct of the proof of Proposition 5 and is the analogue to the case at hand of a key result in [4] (Prop. 3). Namely, ˙ ∈ T Lc Proposition 6. Let u be of the form (23), with P a regular point in Lc . Then, (p) iff the residues of F = Nu def
X
p∈P
4p˙ (x − p)3
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
99
all vanish and X p˙ = 0. p2
p∈P
Furthermore, if this is the case then X 2p˙ + q˙ X cp˙ + (x − p)−3 . F = 16 p2 (p − q)2 p∈P
q∈Pp
Proof. Given (p) ˙ p∈P a tangent vector to S n (C) let’s consider the corresponding v˙ as ˙ after a computation similar to the given by Eq. (24). The action of Nu on the vector v, one in the previous result is given by an expression of the form 4. After looking into the coefficients of the terms in (x − p)−1 we get residues proportional to those in the RHS of Eqs. (26), (27), and (29). The first assertion then follows, since P is a regular point in the locus. Using Eqs. (29) and (30) gives the second assertion. u t Proposition 7. Let u be of the form (23). Then u belongs to the locus Lc iff c
X 1 = 0, p
p∈P
and for any closed pole-free path 0 we have I 1 u2 (x) dx = 0. 2π i 0
(31)
Proof. Just compute the residues of u2 using partial fraction decomposition. These residues are (except for numerical factors) the expressions on the LHS of Eqs. (19) and (20), which define the locus. The claim then follows by Cauchy’s formula. u t On a similar vein, one can show that if u is a vanishing rational solution of τ2 , then for any closed pole-free path 0, I 1 1 ( u2 + u3 )dx = 0. (32) 2π i 0 2 x The integrands for Eqs. (31) and (32) are the currents for the corresponding conserved quantities of the associated KdV hierarchy. 4. Asymptotic Expansions and Recursion Let us assume that the potential u is of the form u=
X 2 c + 2 x (x − p)2
(33)
p∈P
and that it remains rational by the flows of the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy. The first goal of this section is to show, in that case, that for sufficiently high i we have τi (u) = 0. More precisely, we have the following:
100
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Proposition 8. Let u be a potential of the form (33), where n denotes the number of nonzero poles. If u remains rational by all the KdV master symmetries τi , i ≥ 0, then τi (u) = 0 , i > (n − 1)/2.
(34)
The second goal is to show that if c is not of the form ν(ν + 1), ν ∈ Z≥0 , then the configuration of nonzero poles is balanced in the sense that P = −P. Proposition 9. Under the same assumptions of Proposition 8, if c is not of the form ν(ν + 1), with ν = 0, 1, 2, · · · , then the set of nonzero poles is balanced. In order to prove Propositions 8 and 9, we shall make use of the asymptotic expansion of the vector fields τi (u) for x → 0 as well as that for x → ∞. Let us denote by X def pk , k = ±1, ±2, · · · . πk = p∈P
The first proposition gives us the asymptotic behavior of the τi (u) as x → ∞. Lemma 4. Let u be given by Eq. (33), then in a neighborhood of x = ∞, X βki x −k−2−2i , τi (u) = k≥1
where
βk0
= −k(k + 1)πk and, for i ≥ 0, βki =
k + 2i 4c + 8n − (k + 2i − 1)(k + 2i + 1) βki−1 k + 2i − 1 X 4(2l + j + 4i) + (j + 1)πj βli−1 . l + 2i − 1 j +l=k j ≥1
Proof. The asymptotic expansion of u near x = ∞ is given by u(x) = (c + 2n)x −2 + 4π1 x −3 + 6π2 x −4 + · · · + 2(j + 1)πj x −j −2 + . . . = cx
−2
+
∞ X
αj x −j −2 ,
j =0
with αj = 2(j + 1)πj . Applying τ0 we get τ0 (u) =
∞ X j =1
βj0 x −j −2 ,
where βj0 = −j (j + 1)πj . The next step is to apply Nu , to get ∞ X k+2 [4c + 8n − (k + 1)(k + 3)]βk0 τ1 (u) = k+1 k=0 X 4(2l + j + 4) 0 (j + 1)πj βl x −k−4 . + l+1 j +l=k, j ≥1
t A straightforward induction gives the claimed formula for βki . u
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
101
Proof of Proposition 8. We have shown in Sect. 3 that the flows τi are tangent to the locus Lc . For (p1 , · · · , pn ) ∈ Cn \ 1 the n-tuple (π1 , · · · πn ) serves as coordinates for the ambient space of the locus. Furthermore, it passes to the quotient under the permutations of the p1 , · · · , pn . We shall denote by τi (πk ) the effect of the vector field τi on such coordinates. We expand u in the neighborhood of x = ∞ and look at the effect of τi on πk . Using Lemma 4 we get τi (u) = 4τi (π1 )x −3 + 6τi (π2 )x −4 + · · · + 2(k + 1)τi (πk )x −k−2 + · · · = β1i x −2i−3 + β2i x −2i−4 + · · · + βki x −k−2−2i + · · · . Hence, comparing the powers of x, we have that τi (πk ) = 0, provided i > (k − 1)/2. However, the knowledge of the numbers τi (πk ), for k = 1, · · · , n, uniquely determines the effect of τi on the poles p1 , · · · , pn . Hence, τi = 0 on the locus Lc for i > (n−1)/2. t u Remark 3. The argument used in the proof of Proposition 8 was inspired by the proof of Corollary 1, p. 109, of [4]. Our next goal is to prove Proposition 9. This will be done with the help of the asymptotic behavior of τj (u) at x = 0. Before delving into the more technical Lemma 6, we mention yet another elementary remark, namely: def
Lemma 5. Let P ={x1 , . . . , xn } be a set of n distinct nonzero complex numbers. Assume that −2j +1
x1
−2j +1
+ · · · + xn
= 0 , j = 1, 2, · · · , n.
(35)
Then, n is even and the set P is balanced, i.e., P = −P. Proof. Let’s consider the matrix
x1−1 .. A= .
x2−1 .. .
...
xn−1 .. . .
x1−2n+1 x2−2n+1 . . . xn−2n+1
Because of Eq. (35), the vector (1, . . . , 1) ∈ ker(A). Thus det(A) = 0. On the other hand, x1 · · · xn det(A) can be computed as a Vandermonde determinant giving Y 1 1 1 det(A) = − . 2 2 xi xj x1 . . . xn 1≤i<j ≤n
Since the numbers x1 , · · · , xn are distinct we have that there exists a pair (i, j ) 6 = (j, i) t s.t. xi + xj = 0. A simple induction yields the result. u Remark 4. Using the same techniques of Sect. 2 one can show that if u is a generic and vanishing rational solution of the flow τk , k ≥ 2, (but not necessarily of the others) then: The order of each singularity is precisely 2, no residue appears, and the coefficient c2,p for any nonzero pole p is of the form lp (lp + 1) with lp ∈ Z≥1 . In other words the solution u has the form X lp (lp + 1) c . u= 2 + x (x − p)2 p∈P
Furthermore, the value of the coefficient associated to the pole x = 0 is kept constant along the flow of τk .
102
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
We are now ready to state and prove: Lemma 6. Let u be a rational solution of the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy of the form (33), such that c 6 = ν(ν + 1) for every ν ∈ Z≥0 . Then, π−2k−1 = 0,
k = 1, 2, · · · .
Furthermore, τk (u) =
X r≥0
λkr x r ,
where λ0r = (r + 1)(r + 2)π−r−2 and the coefficients λkr are computed recursively by means of λkr =
X 2(l + 1) + 2 r +2 [4c − (r + 1)(r + 3)]λk−1 (j + 1)π−j −2 λk−1 + 4 , r+2 l r +3 l+1 j +l=r j,l≥0
for k ≥ 1. Proof. Start from the Laurent expansion of u at x = 0, u(x) = c x −2 +
∞ X
γk x k ,
k=0 def
where γk = 2(k + 1)π−k−2 . Applying τ0 we get
∞ X 1 λ0k x k , τ0 (u) = 1 + x ∂x u(x) = 2 k=0
def
with λ0k = (k + 1)(k + 2)π−k−2 . Hence, τ1 (u) =Nu τ0 (u) = − ∂x2 + 4u + 2ux ∂x−1 τ0 (u) =
∞ X k=0
−k(k − 1)λ0k x k−2
X ∞ ∞ X c j +4 2 + γj x λ0l x l x
j =0
2c +2 − 3 + x
l=0
∞ X j =0
.
j γj x
j −1
X ∞ l=0
λ0l x l+1 l+1
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
103
We remark that the last summation could, in principle, be added to an integration constant. A closer look, however, indicates that such a constant must vanish. Indeed, τ1 (u) cannot have a pole of order 3 at x = 0. Thus, τ1 (u) =
∞ X
k [4c − (k − 1)(k + 1)]λ0k x k−2 k+1
k=0 ∞ X
+
X 2[2(l + 1) + j ] γj λ0l x k l+1
k=0 j +l=k
=
∞ X r=−1
λ1r x r ,
with λ1r =
X 2[2(l + 1) + j ] r +2 [4c − (r + 1)(r + 3)]λ0r+2 + γj λ0l . r +3 l+1 j +l=r r≥0
Since u is a rational solution of τ1 , the residue of τ1 (u) at x = 0 vanishes. Hence, λ1−1 = 0 and 2cλ01 = 12cπ−3 = 0. Thus, π−3 = 0, since c 6= 0. This gives τ1 (u) =
X r≥0
λ1r x r .
The induction procedure now becomes clear. Assume that for all s, 1 ≤ s ≤ k, π−2s−1 = 0
and
τs (u) =
X r≥0
λsr x r ,
with λsr =
X 4[2(l + 1) + j ] r +2 [4c − (r + 1)(r + 3)]λs−1 (j + 1)πj −2 λs−1 . r+2 + l r +3 l+1 j +l=r
Then, τk+1 (u) =
X r≥−1
λk+1 xr , r
where = λk+1 r
X 2[2(l + 1) + j ] r +2 [4c − (r + 1)(r + 3)]λkr+2 + γj λkl . r +3 l+1 j +l=r r≥0
Here again, since u is a rational solution of {τj }j ≥1 , we have that the τk+1 (u) cannot have a pole of order 3 at x = 0. Thus the possible integration constant was omitted.
104
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Furthermore, the residue of τk+1 (u) vanishes at x = 0. This gives us that 0 = 2c λk1 X 2[2(l + 1) + j ] 3 k−1 k−1 = 2c [4c − 2 · 4]λ3 + γj λl 4 l+1 j +l=1
= 6c(c = 6c(c
+ 48cπ−3 λk−1 − 2)λk−1 3 0 − 2)λk−1 , 3
+ 16cπ−2 λk−1 1
since π−3 = 0
and
2c λk−1 = Resx=0 {τk (u)} = 0. 1
Using the induction hypothesis π−5 = · · · = π−2k−1 = 0 and the fact that Resx=0 {τk−1 (u)} = · · · = Resx=0 {τ1 (u)} = 0, we have λk1 =
3 5 2k + 1 k · ··· · 4 (c − 2)(c − 6) . . . (c − k(k + 1)) λ02k+1 = 0. 4 6 2k + 2
Since c 6 = ν(ν + 1), ν ∈ Z≥0 , we have λ02k+1 = (2k + 2)(2k + 3)π−2k−3 = 0. t Hence, π−2k−3 = 0, which concludes the induction. u Proof of Proposition 9. If c is not of the form ν(ν + 1), ν = 0, 1, 2, · · · , and u is a rational solution of the master-symmetry hierarchy, then Lemma 6 ensures that π−1 = π−3 = · · · = 0. This, in light of Lemma 5, gives us that the configuration P of nonzero poles is balanced. u t It now remains to analyze the situation when c = ν(ν + 1) with ν a positive integer. As a corollary of the proof of Lemma 6 we get Corollary 2. If u is of the form (33), with c = ν(ν + 1), ν = 0, 1, · · · , and remains rational by the flows of the master-symmetry hierarchy for KdV, then u is bispectral. Proof. If c = ν(ν + 1), with ν a positive integer, then the argument in the proof of Lemma 6 gives that π−3 = π−5 = · · · = π−2ν−1 = 0. Since the poles of u satisfy the locus condition, using Theorems 3.4 and 3.5 of [10] (recalled in Theorem 5) it follows that u is bispectral. u t
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
105
5. The Squared Eigenfunction Method In this section we shall complete the proof that the generic rational potentials that decay at infinity and remain rational by the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy are bispectral. In order to do that we shall make use of a technique inspired by the squared eigenfunction method of soliton theory. More precisely, we shall link the eigenfunctions of the Schrödinger operator def
Lφ = −∂x2 φ + u(x)φ = k 2 φ
(36)
with the solutions of the equation −Fxxx + 4uFx + 2ux F = 4k 2 Fx .
(37)
In fact, we shall be concerned only with the case k = 0. We recall that the LHS of this equation Ku = −∂x3 + 4u ∂x + 2ux is exactly the operator associated to the second symplectic structure of the KdV hierarchy. Furthermore, it is related to Nu by means of Ku = Nu ∂x . First, the classical result, which goes as follows: Proposition 10. Let u be analytic in a domain, and suppose that φ satisfies Eq. (36) in this domain. Then, F = φ 2 satisfies (37) in the same domain. The proof is a straightforward computation, and will be omitted. Let us concentrate, however, on a partial converse to such a statement that will play a crucial role in the sequel. Lemma 7. Let F be a solution of Ku F = 0, where u is analytic in a domain D ⊂ C. def
Take x0 a point in D ⊂ C and define in a sector S near x0 , the function φ = F 1/2 , where the choice of the square root is arbitrary. Then, inside S, φ is a solution of Lφ = αφ −3
(38)
for some α ∈ C, which depends on the choice of the square root. Proof. Since Ku F = 0 we have that −φφxxx − 3φx φxx + 4uφφx + ux φ 2 + φ(−φxxx + uφx + ux φ) + 3(Lφ)φx = 0. Hence, or better
φ(−φxx + uφ)x + 3φx Lφ = 0, φ(Lφ)x + 3φx Lφ = 0.
This gives Eq. (38) upon integration. u t Before establishing the crucial lemma to conclude the proof that the rational solutions of the master-symmetry hierarchy are bispectral, we need an elementary remark, namely:
106
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Remark 5. If u = c/x 2 , then obviously u is bispectral and in this case τ0 (u) = 0. In fact, the converse holds τ0 (u) = 0 iff u = c/x 2 , for some c ∈ C. Lemma 8. Let u be of the form (33), where P is nonempty, and c 6= ν(ν + 1) for every ν = 0, 1, 2, · · · . If u is a rational solution of the master-symmetry hierarchy, decaying at infinity, then c = l 2 − 1/4 with l ∈ Z. Proof. Because of Remark 5, we may assume that τ0 (u) 6= 0 since P is nonempty. From Proposition 8 it follows that there exists s ≥ 0 such that τs (u) 6 = 0
and
τs+1 (u) = 0.
Proposition 9 ensures that u is an even function and furthermore there exists l ∈ Z≥0 such that τs (u) = λx 2l + O(x 2l+2 ), x → 0,
(39)
where λ 6 = 0. We now integrate the rational function τs (u) and choose a constant of integration so that F = ∂x−1 τs (u) = λx 2l+1 + O(x 2l+2 ) . def
The function F belongs to the kernel of Ku , since Ku (F ) = Nu ∂x ∂x−1 τs (u) = τs+1 (u) = 0. Hence, because of Lemma 7 it follows that there exists α such that Lφ = αφ −3 .
(40)
Indeed, one chooses a point x0 sufficiently close to 0 so that Eq. (39) holds, and then uses analytic continuation in a suitable sector with vertex at 0. We now have to distinguish between two cases, depending on whether l vanishes or not. If l 6 = 0 we look at both sides of Eq. (40) to get, as x → 0, that [−(l 2 − 1/4) + c]λx l−3/2 (1 + O(x 2 )) = αλ−3/2 x −3l−3/2 (1 + O(x 2 )).
(41)
Hence, α = 0 and c = l 2 − 1/4, for some l ∈ Z \ {0}. On the other hand, if l = 0, let’s consider the analytic continuation of φ along a path joining 0 to ∞ and avoiding the poles of u. By the principle of the permanence of the functional identities, Eq. (40) remains valid along this path. Furthermore, since τs (u) = O(x −3 ) as x → ∞, it follows that F (x) = ∂x−1 τs (u)(x) = O(x −2 ) + C∞ , where C∞ is an integration constant. Hence, F is bounded, and so is φ = F 1/2 . We claim now that α, once again, is necessarily zero. Indeed, if C∞ = 0, then the RHS of Eq. (40) blows up as x → ∞, unless α = 0. If C∞ 6= 0, the LHS of (40) goes to zero as x → ∞, and hence α = 0. Once we know that α = 0, we look again at the behavior of x close to zero, which is given in this case by the LHS of Eq. (41). Since α = 0, it follows that c = −1/4. u t
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
107
6. Conclusion and Suggestions for Further Research We conclude this article with some final remarks and suggestions for further research. Concerning the restriction to vanishing rational potentials, one might wonder about the necessity of imposing this decay condition at infinity. However, if we look at the expression of the recursion operator Nu , we realize that in order for the operator ∂x−1 to be well defined we have to fix an integration constant. That was done by defining the integration from −∞ to x. It is precisely for this choice that the tangency result of [40] holds. Any other choice would lead to extra KdV flows which are not in general tangent to the manifolds of bispectral potentials. Furthermore, it is shown in [10] that any bispectral potential that does not vanish at infinity is of the form ax + b. Besides forming a rather degenerate and small class, such potentials do not remain rational by the flows of τ1 in any reasonable sense unless a = 0. In fact, it is not hard to see that rational potentials unbounded at infinity do not remain rational by τ1 no matter what choice one makes of the integration constant in ∂x−1 . The requirement that the potentials under consideration would vanish at infinity comes in the spirit of the usual normalization of bispectral potentials that are bounded at infinity. However, we did not analyze in detail the remaining possibility of rational solutions to the master-symmetries that are bounded though not vanishing at infinity. This would be an interesting follow-up of the present work. The assumption that we are dealing with generic rational solutions (decaying at infinity) rules out a number of degenerate situations that would make this work excessively technical. Unfortunately, it also rules out many bispectral potentials that remain rational by the flows of hierarchies such as KdV or the master symmetry hierarchy. In all examples we analyzed of such degenerate cases we had situations such as many poles colliding or splitting from a single one. The simplest example of such a situation for the KdV hierarchy is the rational solution u = −2∂x2 log(x 3 + 12t). For t = 0 we have a potential that does not satisfy our requirement, although for any other t it does fit in our scheme. Example 3 provides an instance of the same kind of phenomena for the KdV master-symmetry hierarchy. The issue of extending our results to non-generic rational solutions is a deep one since it is related to the collision of poles and the closure of the locus. For the Kadomtsev-Petviashvilli hierarchy a recent article of G. Wilson [35] addresses many subtle aspects of such problems. We believe that similar results to the ones stated in the present work would also be true with the generic assumption relaxed but the method of looking into the flows of the poles and its constraints employed throughout this paper would require a substantial adaptation. The topic of Darboux transformations, which was used by Duistermaat and Grünbaum to address the bispectral problem for Schrödinger operators [10] is still a central one in the solution of the bispectral problem. It was used also in the context of matrix operators to produce classes of bispectral differential operators [36,37,39]. This connection can also be found in further developments such as [5,23]. A natural follow-up question to the present work would be the characterization of the rational operators that remain rational by certain classes of Darboux transformations and its relation to the bispectral problem. In this respect an important reference would be the recent work [6]. In the latter, the authors generalize the results of [40] to bispectral operators of arbitrary rank and order. Given that the techniques of [6] are both sophisticated and powerful, they would be a natural starting point for the study of a similar question to the one addressed in the present work in the higher order case. Another possible avenue associated to the work presented here is the fact that the master-symmetry hierarchy for the KdV is a subset of the W∞ symmetries studied by
108
J. P. Zubelli, D. S. Valerio Silva
Orlov and Schulman [31]. The latter set of symmetries corresponds to a realization of the algebra generated by k j d z dzk j ∈Z,k≥0 in terms of vector fields on the algebra of pseudo-differential operators in one variable. The vector field associated to zj , j > 0, corresponds to the j th flow of the KP hierarchy, see [33] for details. Furthermore, the hierarchy of master symmetries for KdV discussed here, correspond only to a sub-algebra of W∞ . Namely, the positive part of a certain Virasoro algebra. The fact that the rational solutions, decaying at infinity, of the master-symmetry hierarchy are bispectral potentials leads naturally to the question: Would the operators with rational coefficients that remain rational by the positive part of the W∞ algebra be also bispectral? Or, should one impose some extra condition such as a string-type equation? We plan to address some of these questions in a future publication. Acknowledgements. We would like thank Franco Magri for helpful conversations. Both authors were supported by the Brazilian National Research Council, CNPq. JPZ was also supported by PRONEX-FINEP through grant 76.97.1008-00. In a regrettable oversight, due credit was not given to A. Fokas in [40] for the introduction of the mastersymmetry concept in his joint work with B. Fuchssteiner [11]. One of the authors (JPZ) takes the occasion to correct the mistake. The authors thank both referees for their detailed comments, which substantially improved the final version of the paper.
References 1. Ablowitz, M. J. and Segur, H.: Solitons and the Inverse Scattering Transform. SIAM Studies in Applied Mathematics, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 1981 2. Adler, M. and Moser, J.: On a class of polynomials connected with the KdV equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 61, 1–30 (1978) 3. Adler M. and van Moerbeke, P.: Compatible Poisson structures and the Virasoro algebra. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 47(1), 5–37 (1994) 4. Airault, H., Mc Kean, H. and Moser, J.: Rational and elliptic solutions of the KdV equation and a related many body problem. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 30, 95–148 (1977) 5. Bakalov, B., Horozov, E. and Yakimov, M.: General methods for constructing bispectral operators. Phys. Lett. A 222(1-2), 59–66 (1996) 6. Bakalov, B., Horozov, E. and Yakimov, M.: Highest weight modules over the W1+∞ algebra and the bispectral problem. Duke Math. J. 93(1), 41–72 (1998) 7. Calogero, F. and Degasperis, A.: Spectral Transform and Solitons. I. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1982 8. Carillo, S. and Fuchssteiner, B.: The abundant symmetry structure of hierarchies of nonlinear equations obtained by reciprocal links. J. Math. Phys. 30 (7), 1606–1613 (1989) 9. Choodnovsky, D. V. and Choodnovsky, G. V.: Pole expansion of nonlinear differential equations. Nuovo Cimento 40B, 339–353 (1977) 10. Duistermaat, J. J. and Grünbaum, F. A.: Differential equations in the spectral parameter. Commun. Math. Phys. 103 (2), 177–240 (1986) 11. Fokas, A. S. and Fuchssteiner, B.: The hierarchy of the Benjamin - Ono equation. Phys. Lett. A 86 (6-7), 341–345 (1981) 12. Fuchssteiner, B.: Mastersymmetries, higher order time-dependent symmetries and conserved densities of nonlinear evolution equations. Prog. Theor. Phys. 70 (6), 1508–1522 (1983) 13. Fuchssteiner, B.: Mastersymmetries for Completely Integrable Systems in Statistical Mechanics. In: L. Garrido, ed., Proc. Sitges Conference, Springer Lecture Notes in Physics 216, 1984, pp. 305–315 14. Fuchssteiner B. and Carillo, S.: The Action-Angle transformation for soliton equations. Physica A 166, 651–675 (1990) 15. Gardner, C.S., Greene, J.M., Kruskal, M.D. and Miura R. M.: Method for solving the Korteweg- de Vries equation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 1095–1097 (1967)
Rational Solutions of Master Symmetries of KdV Equation
109
16. Grünbaum, F. A.: The limited angle reconstruction problem in computed tomography. In: Proc. Symp. Appl. Math. Vol.27, L. Shepp, ed., Providence, RI: AMS 1982, pp. 43–61 17. Grünbaum, F. A.: A new property of reproducing kernels for classical orthogonal polynomials. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 95, 491–500 (1983) 18. Grünbaum, F. A.: Band and time limiting, recursion relations, and some nonlinear evolution equations. In: W. Schempp R. Askey, T. Koorwinder, ed., Special Functions: Group Theoretical Aspects and Applications, Dordrecht: Reidel, 1984, pp. 271–286 19. Grünbaum, F. A.: Some new explorations into the mystery of time and band limiting. Adv. in Appl. Math. 13(3), 328–349 (1992) 20. Grünbaum, F.A.: Time-band limiting and the bispectral problem. Comm. PureAppl. Math. 47(3), 307–328 (1994) 21. Harnad, J. and Kasman, A.: The Bispectral Problem, CRM Proceedings and Lecture Notes. Providence, Rhode Island: American Mathematical Society, 1998 22. Kasman, A.: Bispectral KP solutions and linearization of Calogero-Moser particle systems. Commun. Math. Phys. 172(2), 427–448 (1995) 23. Kasman, A. and Rothstein, M.: Bispectral Darboux transformations: The generalized Airy case. Physica D 102(3–4), 157–176 (1997) 24. Magri, F.: Equivalence transformations for nonlinear evolution equations. J. Math. Phys. 18(7), 1405– 1411 (1977) 25. Magri, F.: A simple model of the integrable Hamiltonian equation. J. Math. Phys. 19, 1156–1162 (1978) 26. Magri, F., Pedroni, M. and Zubelli, J. P.: On the geometry of Darboux transformations for the KP hierarchy and its connection with the discrete KP hierarchy. Commun. Math. Phys. 188(2), 305–325 (1997) 27. Magri, F. and Zubelli, J. P.: Bi-Hamiltonian formalism and the Darboux-Crum method. I. From the KP to the mKP hierarchy. Inverse Problems 13(3), 755–780 (1997) 28. Oevel, G., Fuchssteiner, B. and Blaszak, M.: Action-Angle representation of multisolitons by potentials of mastersymmetries. Prog. Theor. Phys. 83(3), 395–413 (1990) 29. Oevel, W.: A geometrical approach to integrable systems admitting time dependent invariants. In: Topics in soliton theory and exactly solvable nonlinear equations (Oberwolfach, 1986), Singapore: World Sci. Publishing, 1987, pp. 108–124 30. Oevel, W. and Fuchssteiner, B.: Explicit formulas for symmetries and conservation laws of the KadomtsevPetviashvili equation. Phys. Lett. A 88(7), 323–327 (1982) 31. Orlov, A. and Schulman, E.: Additional symmetries for integrable equations and conformal algebra representation. Lett. Math. Phys. 12(3), 171–179 (1986) 32. Valerio Silva, D. S.: “Rational Solutions of the Master-Symmetries for KdV and the Bispectral Problem” (in portuguese). PhD thesis, IMPA, Rio de Janeiro, 1998 33. van Moerbeke, P.: Integrable Foundations of String Theory. CIMPA - Summer School at Sophia-Antipolis. In: O. Babelon et al., ed., Lectures on Integrable Systems, Singapore World Scientific, 1994, pp. 163–267 34. Wilson, G.: Bispectral Commutative Ordinary Differential Operators. J. reine angew Math. 442, 177–204 (1993) 35. Wilson, G.: Collisions of Calogero-Moser particles and an adelic Grassmannian. Invent. Math. 133(1), 1–41 (1998), with an appendix by I. G. Macdonald 36. Zubelli, J. P.: Differential Equations in the Spectral Parameter for Matrix Differential Operators of AKNS Type. PhD thesis, University of California at Berkeley, 1989 37. Zubelli, J. P.: Differential equations in the spectral parameter for matrix differential operators. Physica D 43, 269–287 (1990) 38. Zubelli, J. P.: On the polynomial τ -functions for the KP hierarchy and the bispectral property. Lett. Math. Phys. 24, 41–48 (1992) 39. Zubelli, J. P. Rational solutions of nonlinear evolution equations, vertex operators and bispectrality. J. Differ. Eq. 97(1), 71–98 (1992) 40. Zubelli, J. P. and Magri, F.: Differential equations in the spectral parameter, Darboux transformations, and a hierarchy of master symmetries for KdV. Commun. Math. Phys. 141(2), 329–351 (1991) Communicated by T. Miwa
Commun. Math. Phys. 211, 111 – 136 (2000)
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
© Springer-Verlag 2000
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields with Small Nonconstant α in Exterior Domains R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl Department of Mathematics, University of Bayreuth, 95440 Bayreuth, Germany Received: 20 June 1999 / Accepted: 25 October 1999
Abstract: The existence of force-free magnetic fields in the exterior domain of some compact simply connected surface S is proved via an iteration scheme. The iteration starts with an arbitrary exterior vacuum field, which contains flux tubes originating and ending on S. At one cross-section of such a flux tube with S an arbitrary function α is prescribed. For small values of α (in the Hölder-norm 1, λ; 0 < λ < 1) the iteration is shown to converge to a force-free field with the prescribed values of α in a flux tube which is close to the vacuum flux tube and α = 0 outside. The force-free field is close (in the Hölder- norm 1,λ) to the starting vacuum field, in particular, it has the same field line topology, the same boundary values on S and satisfies the same decay conditions in spatial infinity. It is in general three-dimensional and requires no continuous symmetries. 1. Introduction In the framework of a magnetohydrodynamic description of plasmas force-free magnetic fields play a prominent role. Their characteristic property is the alignment of magnetic field and electric current and thus the vanishing of the Lorentz-force. Magnetic field B and current density j then satisfy (in a suitable normalization) the equations j = α B, curl B = j, div B = 0.
(1)
As a consequence of Eqs. (1) the scalar function α(x) is constant on magnetic field lines but may vary from field line to field line. Force-free fields with α constant in space are a special case; for obvious reasons they are sometimes termed linear force-free fields. The interest in force-free fields has (at least) two sources. The first is “magnetic relaxation”: Suppose there is a viscous but perfectly conducting plasma together with a magnetic field contained in a volume V . In general, the Lorentz-force does not vanish and
112
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
Fig. 1. A magnetic flux tube in the solar corona
the plasma, even if initially at rest, is set into motion. If there are no external forces the total energy in V must decrease because of viscous dissipation. Eventually, the plasma comes to rest, i.e. the system relaxes to a state of magnetostatic equilibrium. During this process the topology of knots and links of the magnetic lines remains conserved since by virtue of the perfect-conductivity assumption magnetic lines are frozen in the plasma. As a consequence magnetic helicity in any flux tube is a conserved quantity. The relaxed state is thus obtained by minimizing the total energy with the constraint of conserved helicity. These minimizing solutions are always force-free magnetic fields ([Wol], [Tay]). If the constraint of conserved helicity in any flux tube is weakened to conservation of helicity in the total plasma volume the relaxed state turns out to be a linear force-free field. However, besides the obvious advantage of a simplified problem, theoretical rationalizations of this replacement are doubtful ([Gra]). The other reasons for interest in force-free magnetic fields are astrophysical applications. Because of the high electrical conductivity of stellar material of even low density, stellar magnetic fields are usually accompanied by large electric currents ([LS], [Ch1]). If, moreover, the magnetic energy density dominates the plasma pressure which is the typical situation in stellar atmospheres, stationary magnetic fields have to be force-free. So, a variety of magnetic structures which have been observed in active regions of the solar corona (coronal loops, magnetic arcades, coronal mass ejections, etc.) have been modelled on the basis of force-free fields, see for instance [Pri] or [Bra]. Solar flares, for example, are nowadays attributed to a magnetic origin ([Al2]): Magnetic flux emerges from the solar convection zone into the coronal space. The simplest geometry is a looptype flux tube with footpoints anchored in the photosphere (see Fig. 1). Photospheric motions cause then a shearing and twisting of the magnetic flux tube up to the point where the flux tube becomes unstable. Finally, a substantial fraction of the free energy stored in the magnetic structure is released (probably by reconnection of magnetic field lines) in an eruptive event. Applications like these determine the geometric setting we will consider below. For linear force-free fields a well-posed boundary value problem of Neumann’s type can be formulated. Using integral equations ([Kr1]) or Hilbert space methods ([Sak], [YG]) this problem has been solved under quite general conditions. In the nonlinear case comparable results exist only if the problem is modified or restricted: A modified problem is obtained if the divergence-free condition is abandoned. In that case the abovementioned methods still work ([Pic], [Kr2]); these solutions, however, are obviously not appropriate for the description of magnetic fields and are merely of mathematical interest. The restricted problem refers to situations with plane – or axisymmetry. In that case the problem can be reduced to a single, in general nonlinear equation of elliptic
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
113
type for a scalar quantity describing the symmetric field ([LS]). For equations of such type an elaborate mathematical theory is available. Beyond these results there are yet a few special solutions developed for astrophysical purposes which are nonlinear and nonsymmetric ([CC], [Low]) and some nonexistence results in the whole space ([Ch2]) and in exterior domains ([Al1]) but no general existence results. What comes so far closest to a general solution has been obtained via an iteration scheme which works for small α and special initial configurations. This scheme has been proposed by [GR] and is here called α-iteration in analogy to the β- iteration, which has been devised for the more general problem of the existence of magnetohydrostatic equilibria ([Spi], [Lor]). The n th step of the α-iteration has the form hBn , ∇αn i = 0
in G,
αn |M = α 0
M ⊂ ∂G,
curl Bn+1 = αn Bn
in G,
div Bn+1 = 0
in G,
hν, Bn+1 i = g
on ∂G.
(2)
(3)
Here, G denotes an open domain in R3 , h. , .i the euclidian scalar product in R3 , ν is the exterior unit normal on ∂G, the function g is prescribed on ∂G and the function α 0 on such a part M of ∂G, where hν, B0 i 6= 0. Each step of the iteration requires the solution of an initial value problem for a linear first order differential equation (2) and of a Neumann-boundary value problem for inhomogeneous-harmonic vector fields (3). In case of convergence the iteration furnishes obviously a force-free magnetic field. In case of a bounded domain G Bineau ([Bin]) proved convergence of the iteration for small α0 and a harmonic initial field B0 . A nonzero lower bound on the field strength of B0 ensures finite length of all field lines in the flux tube emanating from M. As a result Bineau obtains a force-free magnetic field close to B0 with the prescribed values of α in a flux tube close to the initial one emanating from M. The proof of convergence, however, is at least incomplete. Bineau assumes a-priori bounds on kBk and k∇Bk as well as on the field line parameter without controlling these bounds in the course of the iteration. But in a rigorous treatment these bounds have to be controlled at every step of the iteration and, in particular, the bounds have to be uniform with respect to the iteration number n. This is no trivial matter since the bounds on the magnetic field and on the field line parameter depend on each other. The present paper furnishes also a convergence proof for the α-iteration, but differs in two respects from the work of Bineau. First, motivated from the astrophysical applications described above the underlying domain is not bounded but the exterior of a bounded simply connected domain. That is why we need some nonstandard potential-theoretic estimates in exterior domains (these are cited in Sect. 3) and why we have to formulate carefully the notion of an “admissible field configuration” (Sect. 4). The guideline is here again the astrophysical situation. Second, our convergence proof (Sect. 5) avoids the above mentioned shortcomings and presents in some detail the required estimates. One should note that the proof can easily be carried over to the simpler case of a bounded domain as well as to the case of the exterior of a bounded but multiply connected domain (see Remarks 3.3 and 5.6).
114
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
2. General Notations In the following, we assume G ⊂ R3 to be a bounded domain with smooth boundary; by “smooth” we mean sufficient regularity of ∂G without fixing the exact class of regularity. In all cases considered here the class C 6 will be sufficient. ˆ means the exterior of G, i.e. Furthermore, G ˆ := R3 \ G. G ν denotes, if not explicitly defined otherwise, the outer normal with respect to G. A closed surface S is here the smooth boundary ∂D of some bounded domain D ⊂ R3 , where D always lies locally at one side of the boundary. Then, in particular, S = ∂D is orientable. For δ > 0 we define G−δ := x ∈ G dist (x, ∂G) > δ , ∂G−δ := ∂ G−δ . The euclidian scalar product in R3 is denoted by h. , .i, i.e. 3 X xj yj . x, y :=
j =1
For some differentiable vector field B, the Jacobian matrix will be denoted by DB. For multiindices a = (a1 , a2 , a3 ) ∈ N30 we set D a f :=
∂x1a1
∂ |a| f , |a| := a1 + a2 + a3 , a! := a1 !a2 !a3 !. ∂x2a2 ∂x3a3
For a continuous function or vector field f in some (bounded or unbounded) domain G we set kf kC 0 (G ) := sup |f (x)|. Furthermore, for some function or vector field f and k ∈ N
x∈G
k D k f k := max k D a f k . |a|=k
If some matrix A = (aij ) : G ⊂ R3 → R3×3 is continuous, we set k A kC 0 (G ) :=
3 X i,j =1
kaij k2C 0 (G )
1/2
.
3. Hölder-Spaces and the Neumann-Problem for Inhomogeneous-Harmonic Vector Fields in Exterior Domains Hölder spaces are the appropriate function spaces in classical potential theory. the socalled Let G ⊂ R3 be a domain. For a function or a vector field f ∈ C k (G) and 0 < λ < 1 we define then k f kC k,λ (G ) :=
k X j =0
k D j f kC 0 (G ) +[D k f ]C λ (G ) ,
(4)
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
115
where [D k f ]C λ (G ) := max sup
|a|=k x,y∈G
|D a f (x) − D a f (y)| . |x − y|λ
Distinguishing between local and global Hölder continuity, the following notation is customary in the literature (see, for instance, [GT]): In the local case the condition kf kC k,λ (K) < ∞ holds for every compact subset K ⊂ G k,λ (G). If, however, the uniform and f belongs therefore to the space C k,λ (G) := Cloc condition kf kC k,λ (G ) < ∞ holds, f is said to be k,λ (G) f ∈ C k,λ (G) := Cunif k,λ (G) is a Banach space with the norm defined in (4). In order to simplify our and Cunif k,λ (G), deviating from this notation and because we are not interested in the spaces Cloc convention we set
ˆ := C 1,λ (G), ˆ C 1,λ (G) unif
ˆ := C 0,λ (G), ˆ C λ (G) unif
ˆ := R3 \ G for some bounded domain G ⊂ R3 . where G ˆ there exists an extension f ∈ C 1,λ (R3 ), f ˆ = f such that For every f ∈ C 1,λ (G) G kf kC 1,λ (R3 ) ≤ c1 kf kC 1,λ (G) ˆ , kf kC 0 (R3 ) ≤ c1 kf kC 0 (G) ˆ
(5)
with some constant c1 > 0 independent of f (see [GT], Lemma 6.37; the unboundedness ˆ is not relevant here). We note that this construction is linear. of G Later on the following properties of the Hölder norm will turn out to be useful: [f · g]C λ (G ) ≤ kf kC 0 (G ) · [g]C λ (G ) + [f ]C λ (G ) · kgkC 0 (G ) , kf · gkC λ (G ) ≤ kf kC λ (G ) · kgkC λ (G ) , [1/f ]C λ (G ) ≤ k1/f k2C 0 (G ) · [f ]C λ (G ) .
(6) (7) (8)
ˆ f ∈ C 1,λ (∂G) means f ◦µ ∈ C 1,λ (U ), where Concerning the boundary ∂G of G (or G) µ : U → ∂G is a chart of ∂G. The corresponding norm k.kC 1,λ (∂G) therefore depends on the chosen atlas. For a subset M ⊂ ∂G which is open in the topology of ∂G and some f ∈ C 1,λ (M) with compact support in M we also write f ∈ C01,λ (M). In addition to the Hölder-norm we also need in exterior domains a weighted norm characterizing the asymptotic behaviour to obtain global estimates for potential theoretic ˆ and % > 0 we set problems. Here for a function or a vector field f in G |k f |k% := sup |x|% |f (x)|. ˆ x∈G
If |k f |k% < ∞ we also write |f (x)| = O(|x|−% ), |x| → ∞. The following potential theoretic results on the Neumann problem for inhomogeneous-harmonic vector fields in exterior domains are cited without proof. The proofs can be found in [NvW].
116
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
Theorem 3.1 (Solvability and asymptotic behaviour). Let G ⊂ R3 be a bounded domain with smooth boundary and trivial topology (i.e. first and second Betti number are ˆ := R3 \ G, 1 < % < 3. Let, furthermore, zero), G ˆ R , |f (x)| = O |x|−% , |x| → ∞, f ∈ C λ G, ˆ R3 ∩ C λ G, ˆ R3 , w with zero flux , w ∈ C 1,λ G, |w(x)| = O |x|−% , |x| → ∞, g ∈ C 0 (∂G, R). Then the Neumann problem ˆ div v = f, curl v = w in G, hv, νi = g on ∂G, |x| → ∞ |v(x)| = O |x|1−% , has a unique solution. If f = 0, w = 0 then Z|v(x)| = O |x|−2 , |x| → ∞.
g d = 0 then even |v(x)| = O |x|−3 , |x| → ∞.
If f = 0, w = 0 and ∂G
The condition “w with zero flux” is necessary for the solvability of the problem and ˆ with outer normal ν˜ the integral means that for all closed oriented surfaces S ⊂ G Z
w, ν˜ d vanishes. This implies div w = 0. S
Theorem 3.2 (Hölder-Estimates). Suppose that 1 < % < 3, g ∈ C 1,λ (∂G) and let v be ˆ and there exists a the unique solution of the Neumann problem 3.1. Then v ∈ C 1,λ (G) constant c0 > 0 only depending on λ, %, G with k v kC 1,λ (G) ˆ + |k v |k%−1
≤ c0 · kf kC λ (G) ˆ + kwkC λ (G) ˆ + |k f |k% + |k w |k% + k g kC 1,λ (∂G) .
Remarks 3.3. (a) The corresponding Neumann-problem in the interior domain is solvable under the additional restriction Z Z f dx = gd. G
∂G
The asymptotic conditions, of course, are to be omitted. ˆ is multiply connected, i.e. if the first Betti-number n˜ of (b) If the exterior domain G ˆ ˆ is different from zero, the NeumannG, which is the number of handles of G or G, problem is still uniquely solvable under the same conditions, if the so-called generalized circulations Z 0j := hν × v, zj id, j = 1, . . . , n˜ ∂G
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
117
are prescribed, where {z1 , . . . , zn˜ } is an appropriate basis of the space ZR (G) := {v ∈ C 1 (G, R3 ) ∩ C 0 (G, R3 )| div v = 0, curl v = 0 in G, hν, vi = 0 on ∂G}. The asymptotic behaviour of the solution then is the same as stated in Theorem 3.1, but to obtain |v(x)| = O(|x|−3 ), |x| → ∞, the condition 01 = · · · = 0n˜ = 0 is necessary. P The estimate in Theorem 3.2 holds, if the term nj˜ =0 |0j | is added in the brackets on the right-hand side. 4. Field Lines and Admissible Configurations Field lines are here considered as curves with direction always parallel to the field vector and orientation which is induced by the vector field. Taking into account the invariance under reparametrization they can be described as solutions of the so-called field line equation γ˙ (t) = B γ (t) , where B stands for the vector field, t for the curve parameter and “ · ” means differentiation with respect to t. In the following we are interested in field line configurations ˆ with footpoints anchored on ∂G. which contain flux tubes in an exterior domain G Definition 4.1 (Assumptions and further notations). ˆ := R3 \ G, U ⊂ R2 boundary, G (1) Let G ⊂ R3 be a bounded domain with smooth open, M ⊂ ∂G open, U, µ, µ(U ) = M a local coordinate system for M, i.e. in particular µ : U → M is a homeomorphism and µ : U → R3 is twice continuously differentiable. Let ρ1 > 0 such that ∂µ ∂µ (1) (2) (s) ≥ ρ1 . ∀s = (s , s ) ∈ U : (1) (s) × (2) ∂s ∂s
ˆ R3 ) and ρ0 > 0 such that B, ν ≥ ρ0 , i.e. in particular, the (2) Let B ∈ C 1,λ (G, M field lines of B emanating from M have non-zero normal component. For s ∈ U let γ (., s) denote the solution of the initial value problem ˆ γ (0, s) = µ(s) ∈ M. γ˙ = B(γ ) in G, ˆ Let ]0, T (s)[ be the maximum interval of existence of γ (., s) in G, T (s) ∈ R+ ∪ {+∞}. We define now < T (s) , 0 M, B := (t, s) ∈ R3 s ∈ U, 0 < t 3 M, B := γ (t, s) (t, s) ∈ 0 M, B . ˆ emanating from M. The 3 M, B may be considered as the flux tube of B in G parameters t, s will be denoted as field line coordinates. For T > 0 we define furthermore min T , T (s) , 0 M, B, T := (t, s) ∈ R3 s ∈ U, 0 < t < 3 M, B, T := γ (t, s) (t, s) ∈ 0 M, B, T .
118
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
Observe that the solutions of γ˙ = B(γ ) are restrictions of the solutions of γ˙ = B(γ ), since B Gˆ = B, where B denotes the extension of B (see Sect. 3). From the theory of ordinary differential equations we shall use the following results: Lemma 4.2. Let G ⊂ R1+3 be open, f : G → R3 continuous, I ⊂ R an interval with 0 ∈ I , ϕ1 , ϕ2 ∈ C 1 (I, R3 ) with ∀t ∈ I : (t, ϕi (t)) ∈ G, i = 1, 2, and ε0 , δ0 , L > 0. Let, furthermore, the following conditions be satisfied: (i) | ϕ1 (0) − ϕ2 (0) | ≤ ε0 , (ii) ∀t ∈ I : | ϕ˙i (t) − f (t, ϕi (t)) | ≤ δ0 , i = 1, 2, (iii) ∀t ∈ I : | f (t, ϕ1 (t)) − f (t, ϕ2 (t)) | ≤ L | ϕ1 (t) − ϕ2 (t). Then for all t ∈ I the estimate holds: | ϕ1 (t) − ϕ2 (t) | ≤ ε0 + 2δ0 | t | eL|t . The following lemma describes the dependence of solutions of an ordinary differential on the initial values. Lemma 4.3. Let G ⊂ R1+3 be open , f : G → R3 continuously differentiable with respect to x ∈ R3 . Let ϕ(., 0, y) denote the solution of the initial value problem x˙ = f (t, x), x(0) = y. Then there exists vj (t) :=
∂ϕ (t, 0, y0 ), j = 1, 2, 3, ∂yj
for (0, y0 ) ∈ G, and vj solves the initial value problem v˙j (t) = Dx f (t, ϕ(t, 0, y0 )) · vj (t), vj (0) = ej , j = 1, 2, 3. Using these propositions and Definition 4.1 the following lemma is easy to prove. ˆ Lemma 4.4. 3(M, B) is open in G. ˆ U, µ, M, as in Definition 4.1, Definition 4.5 (Admissible configuration). Assume G, G, 1,λ 3 ˆ ρ0 , δ, T > 0, B ∈ C (G, R ) with extension B ∈ C 1,λ (R3 , R3 ). We denote the pair M, B as an admissible configuration with parameters ρ0 , T , δ , iff the following conditions are satisfied:
(i) B, ν ≥ ρ0 > 0 in M. (ii) For the solution γ (., s) of the initial value problem γ˙ = B(γ ) in R3 , γ (0, s) = µ(s) ∈ M, we have
∀ s ∈ U : ∃ T0 (s) ∈ ]0; T2 [ : γ T0 (s), s ∈ ∂G, ∃ Tδ (s) ∈ ]0; T2 [ : γ Tδ (s), s ∈ ∂G−δ .
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
119
Fig. 2. Admissible field configuration
The second condition in the definition above has the following meaning: Every field line ˆ starting from M returns to the surface ∂G with a finite value of parameter t. of B in G There is a uniform upper bound T2 for the values t = T0 (s) and t = Tδ (s) where the line γ (t, s) starting in µ(s) penetrates the surfaces ∂G and ∂G−δ (see Fig. 2). A non-vanishing penetration depth of the field lines is guaranteed in particular, if the absolute value of the normal component of B on the corresponding part of the surface is bounded from below. Lemma 4.6. Suppose that the configuration M, B is admissible with parameters ρ0 , T , δ . Then diam 3(M, B) < k B kC 0 (G) ˆ · T + diam M. Proof. We have Zt
Zt γ˙ (τ, s) dτ =
γ (t, s) − γ (0, s) = 0
so
B γ (τ, s) dτ,
0
γ (t1 , s1 ) − γ (t2 , s2 ) ≤ γ (t1 , s1 ) − γ (0, s1 ) + γ (0, s1 ) − γ (0, s2 ) + γ (0, s2 ) − γ (t2 , s2 ) ≤ | t1 | · k B kC 0 (G) ˆ +diam M+ | t2 | · k B kC 0 (G) ˆ < k B kC 0 (G) ˆ · T + diam M.
t u
ˆ µ, M, γ as in Definition 4.1, Lemma 4.7. Assume G, G, ˆ R3 ), ρ0 , T , δ > 0, B ∈ C 1,λ (G, the configuration M, B admissible with parameters ρ0 , T , δ , η ∈ ]0, 1[, B 0 ∈ ˆ R3 ) satisfying C 1,λ (G,
(i) B 0 , ν = B, ν in M and 1 (1 − η)δ · exp − c1 k B kC 1 (G) (ii) k B 0 − B kC 0 (G) ˆ < ˆ ·T . c1 T 2 Then M, B 0 is admissible with parameters ρ0 , T , ηδ .
120
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
Proof. Let γ denote the solution of the field line equation with respect to B, γ 0 the same with respect to B 0 according to Definition 4.1. Then, using the estimate (5) and Lemma T 4.2 (with ε0 = 0, f = B, L = kDBkC 0 (G) ˆ ) we get for 0 ≤ t ≤ 2 , | γ 0 (t, s) − γ (t, s) | ≤ 2 k B 0 − B kC 0 (R3 ) · t · exp{k DB kC 0 (R3 ) ·t} ≤ 2c1 k B 0 − B kC 0 (G) ˆ ·t · exp{c1 k B k
ˆ C 1 (G)
· t}.
Thus, assumption (ii) yields 0 γ Tδ (s), s − γ Tδ (s), s ≤ (1 − η)δ. For all x ∈ ∂G we have therefore 0 γ Tδ (s), s − x ≥ x − γ Tδ (s), s − γ 0 Tδ (s), s − γ Tδ (s), s ≥ δ − (1 − η)δ = ηδ. t The lemma follows then by continuity of γ 0 (. , s). u In the proof of the lemma to follow the field line coordinates will turn out to be useful to solve the first order linear partial differential equation
∇ψ, B = ϕ in flux tubes of the field B. ˆ µ, M, 3(M, B) be Theorem 4.8 (Solvability of the initial value problem). Let G, G, ˆ R3 ) with k B k 1 ˆ < ∞ and as in Definition 4.1, ρ0 > 0, B ∈ C 1 (G, C (G)
B, ν ≥ ρ0 in M. Furthermore, assume
ψ0 ∈ C 1 (M, R) and ϕ ∈ C 0 3(M, B), R .
Then the initial value problem
∇ψ, B = ϕ, ψ M = ψ0
(9)
has a unique solution in 3(M, B). Proof. (a) Let γ (., s) and T (s) be as in Definition 4.1. Since |B| is uniformly bounded, we have either T (s) = ∞, which is here also admitted, or lim γ (t, s) ∈ ∂G,
t%T (s)
in the case T (s) < ∞. From the uniqueness theorem for ordinary differential equations with Lipschitz-condition we know that every point lies on exactly one field line and that two different field lines cannot cross each other.
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
121
ˆ starting from M cannot return to M. Let (b) We show next that a field line of B in G ν˜ (s) := ν µ(s) be the outer normal with respect to G in the point µ(s) ∈ M ⊂ ∂G. We consider some solution γ (., s0 ) of the field line equation according to Definition 4.1 and assume that there is some t1 > 0, with γ (t1 , s0 ) := lim γ (t, s0 ) ∈ M t%t1
ˆ for t ∈ ]0, t1 [. Moreover, for τ > 0 sufficiently small, there exist and γ (t, s0 ) ∈ G continuous functions s(.) : ]t1 − τ, t1 [→ U and ϑ(.) : ]t1 − τ, t1 [→ R such that (10) γ (t, s0 ) = µ(s(t)) + ϑ(t) · ν˜ s(t) . We may assume s(.), ϑ(.) to be differentiable, and (without restriction) ˙ ϑ(t) < 0 on ]t1 − τ, t1 [
and
ϑ(t) & 0 for t % t1 .
Differentiating Eq. (10) with respect to t yields ∂µ ∂µ ˙ s(t) + s˙ (2) (t) · (2) s(t) + ϑ(t) · ν˜ s(t) (1) ∂s ∂s ∂ ν˜ ∂ ν˜ (1) + ϑ(t) s˙ (t) · (1) s(t) + s˙ (2) (t) · (2) s(t) . ∂s ∂s Taking the scalar product of Eq. (11) with ν˜ s(t) we get
˙ < 0, γ˙ (t, s0 ), ν˜ s(t) = ϑ(t) γ˙ (t, s0 ) = s˙ (1) (t) ·
(11)
and thus
B γ (t1 , s0 ) , ν˜ s(t1 ) ≤ 0,
which contradicts our assumption. (c) We first consider the initial value problem with homogeneous differential equation
(12) ∇ψhom , B = 0, ψhom M = ψ0 . Equation (12)1 means that ψhom is constant along the field lines of B:
∂ ψhom (γ (t, s)) = ∇ψhom γ (t, s) , γ˙ (t, s) ∂t
= ∇ψhom γ (t, s) , B γ (t, s) = 0. Therefore any solution of problem (12) satisfies (13) ψhom γ (t, s) = ψhom γ (0, s) = ψ0 µ(s) . From (a) and (b) we know that γ (., .) : 0 M, B → 3 M, B is a bijective mapping. Thus, conversely, ψhom : 3 M, B → R defined by Eq. (13) solves the problem (12).
122
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
Therefore ψhom is the unique solution of (12). For the inhomogeneous problem
∇ψinh , B = ϕ, ψinh M = 0 we can easily find the solution ψinh γ (t, s) =
Zt
ϕ γ (t 0 , s) dt 0
0
by differentiating both sides with respect to t. Finally, ψ γ (t, s) = ψhom γ (t, s) + ψinh γ (t, s) Zt = ψ0 µ(s) + ϕ γ (t 0 , s) dt 0 0
is the unique implicitly given solution of the initial value problem (9). u t Considering the preceding proof and Lemma 4.3 the next lemma follows easily. ˆ µ, M, γ , 3(M, B) be as in Definition 4.1, ρ0 , T , δ > 0, B ∈ Lemma 4.9. Let G, G, 1 1,λ 0 ˆ C (G), α ∈ C0 (M, R) and the configuration (M, B) admissible with parameters (ρ0 , T , δ). Furthermore, let α be the solution of the initial value problem
∇α, B = 0, α M = α 0 in 3(M, B). Then ˆ ⊂ 3 M, B . supp α ∩ G ˆ Therefore α is trivially extendable to G. Lemma 4.10. In addition to the assumptions given in Lemma 4.9 suppose div B = 0. ˆ Then αB has zero flux in G. Proof. Because of Lemma 4.9 we have ˆ ⊂ 3 M, B , supp αB ∩ G and Lemma 4.6 yields diam 3 M, B
0 we have thus With αB
G ∪ supp (αB) ⊂ KR (0). ∂KR (0)
= 0,
div αB = α div B + ∇α, B = 0
in KR (0) \ G
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
123
and applying Gauß’s theorem to KR (0) \ G we obtain Z Z Z
αB, ν d = αB, ν d − ∂G
∂KR (0)
div αB dx = 0,
(14)
KR (0)\G
where ν denotes the outer normal with respect to G on the left-hand side and with respect to KR (0) on the right-hand side of Eq. (14). ˆ and S = ∂D with a domain D ⊂ R3 . In the case Now let S be a closed surface in G ˆ Gauß’s theorem yields D⊂G Z Z
αB, ν d = div αB dx = 0, S
D
in the other case, G ⊂ D, using Eq. (14) and Gauß’s theorem applied to D \ G leads to Z Z Z
div αB dx = 0. (15) αB, ν d = αB, ν d + S
∂G
D\G
Here, ν denotes the outer normal with respect to D at S = ∂D on the left-hand side of the first equation of (15) and with respect to G at ∂G on the right-hand side. u t 5. Convergence of the α-Iteration 1,λ ˆ 3 ˆ
Lemma 5.1. Let G, G, µ, M be as in Definition 4.1, ρ0 , T > 0, B ∈ C (G, R ) with B, ν ≥ ρ0 . Let γ (., s) be the solution of the field line equation in Definition 4.1 with respect to B and let ∂γ ∂γ ∂γ Dγ := ∂t ∂s (1) ∂s (2)
denote the Jacobian matrix of γ . Then there exist (in both variables) monotonically increasing functions κ1 , κ2 : R0+ × R0+ → R0+ depending on G, ρ0 , M, µ and λ but not on B, T , such that ≤ κ1 k B kC 1,λ (G) k Dγ kC λ (0) ˆ ,T and , k (Dγ )−1 kC λ (0) ≤ κ2 k B kC 1,λ (G) ˆ ,T with 0 := 0(M, B, T ). Proof. For simplicity we do not distinguish between T and T (s) where T (s) < T (cf. Def. 4.1). Otherwise we would have to replace T by min(T (s), T ). This simplification is possible since B can always be extended to the entire space R3 with the consequence T (s) = ∞. (a) According to Lemma 4.3 ∂γ .,s (1) ∂s
and
∂γ .,s (2) ∂s
124
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
are solutions of the linear equation ω(t) ˙ = DB γ (t, s) · ω(t),
(16)
where DB is the Jacobian matrix of B. Since ∂γ ∂ ∂γ ∂ = B(γ ) = DB(γ ) · , ∂t ∂t ∂t ∂t γ˙ =
∂γ ∂t
is also a solution of Eq. (16). Furthermore, we have detDγ (0, s) = ∂γ (0, s) ∂γ (0, s) × ∂γ (0, s) ∂t (1) (2) ∂s ∂s
≥ ρ1 B µ(s) , ν˜ (s) ≥ ρ1 ρ0 > 0.
Thus
(17)
∂γ ∂γ ∂γ (., s), (1) (., s), (2) (., s) ∂t ∂s ∂s
is a fundamental system of solutions of Eq. (16) in 0(M, B). (b) Applying Lemma 4.2 (with δ0 = 0, ϕ1 = 0) we get ∂γ ∂γ ˆ ·t ∂s (j ) (t, s) ≤ ∂s (j ) (0, s) · exp kDBkC 0 (G) ≤ k Dµ kC 0 (U ) · exp kDBkC 0 (G) ˆ ·T for 0 ≤ t ≤ T , j = 1, 2. Obviously there is ∂γ ˆ . ∂t (t, s) ≤ k B kC 0 (G) ∂γ ∂γ (c) Now we estimate [Dγ ]C λ (0) . For ω = ∂γ ∂t , ∂s (1) , ∂s (2) we have Eq. (16) and thus for s1 , s2 ∈ U , ω(t,s ˙ 2 ) − DB γ (t, s1 ) · ω(t, s2 ) = DB γ (t, s2 ) − DB γ (t, s1 ) · ω(t, s2 ),
so
ω(t, ˙ s2 ) − DB γ (t, s1 ) · ω(t, s2 ) λ ≤ k Dγ kC 0 (0) · k DB kC λ (G) ˆ · | γ (t, s2 ) − γ (t, s1 ) | .
Lemma 4.2 yields then | ω(t, s2 ) − ω(t, s1 ) | ≤ | ω(0, s2 ) − ω(0, s1 ) | λ + 2 k Dγ kC 0 (0) · k DB kC λ (G) ˆ · sup | γ (τ, s2 ) − γ (τ, s1 ) | ·T τ ∈[0,T [ · exp kDBkC 0 (G) ˆ ·T ,
On the Existence of Force-Free Magnetic Fields
125
where | γ (τ, s2 ) − γ (τ, s1 ) | ≤ k Dγ kC 0 (0) · |s2 − s1 |. In the case ω =
∂γ ∂t
there is furthermore
| ω(0, s2 ) − ω(0, s1 ) | = | B µ(s2 ) − B µ(s1 ) | λ ≤ k DB kC 0 (G) ˆ · k µ kC λ (U ) · |s2 − s1 | ,
otherwise (ω =
∂γ , ∂s (j )
j = 1, 2)
| ω(0, s2 ) − ω(0, s1 ) | ≤ k Dµ kC λ (U ) · |s2 − s1 |λ . So, in any case | ω(t, s2 ) − ω(t, s1 ) | ≤ k Dµ kC λ (U ) + k DB kC 0 (G) ˆ · k µ kC λ (U ) |s2 − s1 |λ + 2 k Dγ k1+λ · k DB kC λ (G) ˆ ·T · exp kDBkC 0 (G) ˆ ·T C 0 (0) for s1 6 = s2 , 0 ≤ t ≤ T . Since ω satisfies the linear differential equation (16), we have, moreover, | ω(t2 , s) − ω(t1 , s) | ≤ T 1−λ · k ω˙ kC 0 (0) | t2 − t1 |λ ≤ T 1−λ · k DB kC 0 (G) ˆ · k Dγ kC 0 (0) for 0 ≤ t1 , t2 ≤ T , t1 6 = t2 , s ∈ U . Obviously, for t1 , t2 ∈ [0, T ], t1 6= t2 , s1 , s2 ∈ U , s1 6 = s2 we have | ω(t2 , s2 ) − ω(t2 , s1 ) | | ω(t2 , s1 ) − ω(t1 , s1 ) | | ω(t2 , s2 ) − ω(t1 , s1 ) | + . λ/2 ≤ 2 2 |s2 − s1 |λ | t2 − t1 |λ (t2 − t1 ) + |s2 − s1 | Therefore [ω]C λ (0) ≤ κ k B kC 1,λ (G) ˆ ,T , and applying the result of (b) we obtain k Dγ kC λ (0) ≤ κ1 k B kC 1,λ (G) ˆ ,T . (d) From the theory of linear ordinary differential equations it is well known that detDγ (t, s) = detDγ (0, s) · exp
Zt
traceDB γ (t 0 , s) dt 0 ,
0
and with the estimate (17) we have thus det Dγ (t, s) ≥ ρ1 ρ0 · exp − 3 k DB k 0 ˆ · T C (G)
126
R. Kaiser, M. Neudert, W. von Wahl
for (t, s) ∈ 0(M, B, T ). For the inverse of Dγ there holds the formula −1 1 ∂γ ∂γ ∂γ ∂γ ∂γ ∂γ T = × × . (18) · × Dγ detDγ ∂t ∂t ∂s (1) ∂s (2) ∂s (2) ∂s (1) −1 kC 0 (0) . Using the result of (b) we easily obtain the desired estimate for k Dγ −1 (e) Finally we look for an estimate for [ Dγ ]C λ (0) . Applying the estimates (6) and (8) we have −1 −1 −1 ≤ k detDγ kC 0 (0) · det Dγ · Dγ + Dγ C λ (0) λ −1 −1 · k det Dγ · Dγ k 0 + detDγ −1 λ −1C (0) ≤ k detDγ kC 0 (0) · detDγ · Dγ λ −1 2 + detDγ λ · k detDγ kC 0 (0) −1 · k detDγ · Dγ kC 0 (0) , and using Eq. (18), the estimate (7) and the results of (b),(c) and (d) we finally obtain −1 kC λ (0) ≤ κ2 k B kC 1,λ (G) t u k Dγ ˆ ,T . ˆ R3 ), ˆ µ, M as in Definition 4.1, T , ρ0 > 0, B ∈ C 1,λ (G, Lemma 5.2. Assume G,G, 1,λ 0 the configuration M, B admissible with parameters (ρ0 , T , δ) and α ∈ C0 (M, R). Let α be the trivial extension of the solution of the initial value problem (see Lemma 4.9)
∇α, B = 0, α M = α 0 . + + Then there exists a monotonically increasing function κ3 : R+ 0 × R0 → R0 depending 0 on G, µ, M, ρ0 , λ, but not on B, T , α , with the following property: 0 k α kC λ (G) ˆ , k α kC 1,λ (G) ˆ ≤ k α kC 1,λ (M) ·κ3 k B kC 1,λ (G) ˆ ,T ,
where k α 0 kC 1,λ (M) := k α 0 ◦ µ kC 1,λ (U ) . Proof. Using the notation of Theorem 4.8 we set ψhom = α, ψinh = 0 and define (19) ϑ(t, s) := α γ (t, s) = α 0 µ(s) , where γ stands as in Theorem 4.8 for the solution of the field line equation of B. We use again the abbreviation 0 := 0(M, B, T ). (a) We first estimate ϑ. It is easy to see that ∂ϑ =0 ∂t
and
k ϑ kC 0 (0) = k α 0 kC 0 (M) ,
and from (19) we have k ∇ϑ kC λ (0) ≤ k α 0 kC 1,λ (M) . (b) Next we estimate α. Using the abbreviation 3