Commun. Math. Phys. 283, 1–24 (2008) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0556-8
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds Fuquan Fang1, , Yuguang Zhang1, , Zhenlei Zhang2 1 Department of Mathematics, Capital Normal University, Beijing, P.R. China.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Nankai Institute of Mathematics, Weijin Road 94, Tianjin 300071, P.R. China.
E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 5 April 2007 / Accepted: 21 April 2008 Published online: 22 July 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: We consider the maximum solution g(t), t ∈ [0, +∞), to the normalized Ricci flow. Among other things, we prove that, if (M, ω) is a smooth compact symplectic 4-manifold such that b2+ (M) > 1 and let g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞), be a solution to (1.3) on M whose Ricci curvature satisfies that |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3 and additionally χ (M) = 3τ (M) > 0, then there exists an m ∈ N, and a sequence of points {x j,k ∈ M}, j = 1, . . . , m, satisfying that, by passing to a subsequence, dG H
(M, g(tk + t), x1,k , . . . , xm,k ) −→ (
m
N j , g∞ , x1,∞ , . . . , xm,∞ ),
j=1
t ∈ [0, ∞), in the m-pointed Gromov-Hausdorff sense for any sequence tk −→ ∞, where (N j , g∞ ), j = 1, . . . , m, are complete complex hyperbolic orbifolds of complex dimension 2 with at most finitely many isolated orbifold points. Moreover, m the convergence is C ∞ in the non-singular part of m N and Vol (M) = j g 0 1 j=1 Volg∞ (N j ), where χ (M) (resp. τ (M)) is the Euler characteristic (resp. signature) of M. 1. Introduction Let (M, g) be a compact Riemannian manifold. The Perelman λ-functional λ M (g) =
inf ∞
f ∈C (M)
e− f dvolg = 1},
{F(g, f ) :
(1.1)
M
The first author was supported by NSFC Grant No.10671097 and the Capital Normal University.
Current address: Department of Mathematical Sciences, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Tech-
nology, Daejeon, Republic of Korea. E-mail:
[email protected]
2
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
where F(g, f ) = M (Rg + |∇ f |2 )e− f dvolg and Rg is the scalar curvature of g. Note that λ M (g) is the lowest eigenvalue of the operator −4 + Rg . By [Pe1] the gradient flow of the Perelman λ-functional is Hamilton’s Ricci-flow evolution equation ∂ g(t) = −2Ric(g(t)). ∂t
(1.2)
The normalized Ricci flow equation on an n-manifold M reads 2R ∂ g(t) = −2Ric(g(t)) + g(t), ∂t n
(1.3)
Rdv
where Ric (resp. R) denotes the Ricci tensor (resp. the average scalar curvature M dv ). M Note that (1.2) and (1.3) differ only by a change of scale in space and time, and the volume 2 Vol(g(t)) is constant in t along the flow (1.3). If dim M = n, λ M (g) = λ M (g)Volg (M) n is invariant up to rescaling the metric. Perelman [Pe1] has proved that λ M (g(t)) is nondecreasing along the Ricci flow g(t) whenever λ M (g(t)) ≤ 0. This leads to the Perelman invariant λ M by taking the supremum of λ M (g) in the set M of all Riemannian metrics on M. By [AIL] the Perelman invariant λ M is equal to the Yamabe invariant whenever λ M ≤ 0, after the earlier estimations (cf. [An5, Pe2, Le4, FZ and Kot]). In particular, if (M, g) is a smooth compact oriented 4-manifold with a Spinc -structure c which is a monopole class (i.e., the associated Seiberg-Witten equation possesses an irreducible solution) so
that c12 (c)[M] > 0, by [FZ] λ M ≤ − 32π 2 c12 (c)[M]. Moreover, g is a Kähler-Einstein metric of negative scalar curvature if and only if λ M (g) = − 32π 2 c12 (c)[M]. However, there are plenty of 4-manifolds where the Perelman invariant λ M = − 32π 2 c12 (c)[M] but do not admit any Kähler Einstein metric. It is natural to study 4-manifolds with these extremal properties. For such a 4-manifold M, to seek for an “optimal” Riemannian metric on M with respect to the Perelman functional λ M : M → R, we want to consider a maximal solution g(t) which is a solution of the Ricci flow (1.3). We call a longtime solution g(t), t ∈ [0, +∞), to the Ricci flow (1.3) a maximum solution if lim λ M (g(t)) = λ M . For a compact 3-manifold, by Perelman [Pe2] all solutions of the t→∞ Ricci flow (1.2) with surgery exist for longtime and are maximum solutions, provided λ M ≤ 0. In the paper [FZZ] obstructions are found for the longtime solutions with bounded curvature to (1.3). In this paper we are going to study the maximum solutions of (1.3) with bounded Ricci curvatures instead. To avoid technique terminology we only state our results for symplectic 4-manifolds by using the celebrated work of Taubes [Ta]: if (M, ω) is a compact symplectic manifold with b2+ (M) > 1 (the dimension of self-dual harmonic 2-forms of M), the spinc -structure induced by ω is a monopole class. Moreover, in this situation c12 (c)[M] = 2χ (M) + 3τ (M), where χ (M) (resp. τ (M)) is the Euler characteristic (resp. signature) of M. Theorem 1.1. Let (M, ω) be a smooth compact symplectic 4-manifold satisfying that b2+ (M) > 1 and 2χ (M) + 3τ (M) > 0. If g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞), is a solution to (1.3) such that |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3, and lim λ M (g(t)) = − 32π 2 (2χ (M) + 3τ (M)), t→∞
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
3
then there exists an m ∈ N, and sequences of points {x j,k ∈ M}, j = 1, . . . , m, satisfying that, by passing to a subsequence, dG H
(M, g(tk + t), x1,k , . . . , xm,k ) −→ (
m
N j , g∞ , x1,∞ , . . . , xm,∞ ),
j=1
t ∈ [0, ∞), in the m-pointed Gromov-Hausdorff sense for any sequence tk −→ ∞, where (N j , g∞ ), j = 1, . . . , m, are complete Kähler-Einstein orbifolds of complex dimension 2 with at most finitely many isolated orbifold points. The scalar curvature (resp. volume) of g∞ is 1
−Volg0 (M)− 2
m 32π 2 (2χ (M) + 3τ (M)) (resp. Volg0 (M) = Volg∞ (N j )). j=1
Moreover, the convergence is C ∞ in the non-singular part of
m 1
Nj.
We first remark that, if the diameters diamg(tk ) (M) possess a uniform upper bound, then m = 1, and N1 is a compact Kähler-Einstein orbifold. Secondly, if the Ricci curvature bound in the above theorem is replaced by a uniform bound of sectional curvature, then every (N j , g∞ ), j = 1, . . . , m are complete Kähler-Einstein manifolds. By the same arguments as in [An5,An6], mj=1 N j can weakly embed in M, mj=1 N j ⊂⊂ M, i.e. for any compact subset K ⊂ mj=1 N j , there is a smooth embedding FK : K −→ M. Furthermore, there exists a sufficiently large compact subset K ⊂ mj=1 N j such that M\K admits an F-structure of positive rank. This type of geometric decomposition seems very useful to understand the diffeomorphism type of 4-manifolds. Theorem 1.2. Let (M, ω) be a smooth compact symplectic 4-manifold such that b2+ (M) > 1 and let g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞), be a solution to (1.3) such that |R(g(t))| ≤ 12. If in addition χ (M) = 3τ (M) > 0, then lim λ M (g(t)) = − 32π 2 (2χ (M) + 3τ (M)). t→∞
Moreover, if |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3, the Kähler-Einstein metric g∞ in Theorem 1.1 is complex hyperbolic. To conclude the section we point out that the main result in Theorem 1.1 (resp. Theorem 1.2) holds if the manifold is not symplectic but a compact oriented 4-manifold with a monopole class c1 (i.e. with a spinc -structure with non-vanishing Seiberg-Witten invariant) so that c12 = 2χ (M) + 3τ (M) > 0. 2. Preliminaries 2.1. Monopole class. Let (M, g) be a compact oriented Riemannian 4-manifold with a Spinc structure c. Let b2+ (M) denote the dimension of the space of self-dual harmonic 2-forms in M. Let Sc± denote the Spinc -bundles associated to c, and let L be the determinant line bundle of c. There is a well-defined Dirac operator D A : (Sc+ ) −→ (Sc− ).
4
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Let c : ∧∗ T ∗ M −→ End(Sc+ ⊕ Sc− ) denote the Clifford multiplication on the Spinc bundles, and, for any φ ∈ (Sc± ), let 1 q(φ) = φ ⊗ φ − |φ|2 id. 2 The Seiberg-Witten equations read D A φ = 0, c(FA+ ) = q(φ),
(2.1)
where A is an Hermitian connection on L, and FA+ is the self-dual part of the curvature of A. A solution of (2.1) is called reducible if φ ≡ 0; otherwise, it is called irreducible. If (φ, A) is a resolution of (2.1), one calculates easily that 1 |FA+ | = √ |φ|2 , 2 2
(2.2)
0 = −2|φ|2 + 4|∇ A φ|2 + Rg |φ|2 + |φ|4 ,
(2.3)
The Bochner formula reads
where Rg is the scalar curvature of g. The Seiberg-Witten invariant can be defined by counting the irreducible solutions of the Seiberg-Witten equations (cf. [Le2]). Definition 2.2 ([K]). Let M be a smooth compact oriented 4-manifold. An element α ∈ H 2 (M, Z)/torsion is called a monopole class of M if and only if there exists a Spinc structure c on M with first Chern class c1 ≡ α(mod torsion), so that the Seiberg-Witten equations have a solution for every Riemannian metric g on M. By the celebrated work of Taubes [Ta], if (M, ω) is a compact symplectic 4-manifold with b2+ (M) > 1, the canonical class of (M, ω) is a monopole class. 2.3. Kato’s inequality. Let (M, g) be a Riemannian Spinc -manifold of dimension n; the following Kato inequality is useful: Proposition 2.4 (Proposition 2.2 in [BD]). Let φ be a harmonic Spinc -spinor on (M, g), i.e. D A φ = 0, where D A is the Dirac operator and A is an Hermitian connection on the determinant line bundle. Then n−1 A 2 |∇ φ| ≤ |∇ A φ|2 |∇|φ||2 ≤ (2.4) n at all points where φ is non-zero. Moreover, |∇|φ||2 = |∇ A φ|2 occurs only if ∇ A φ ≡ 0. Note that the arguments in the proof of Proposition 2.2 in [BD] can be used to prove this proposition without any change, where the same conclusion was derived for Spinspinor φ. For any > 0, let |φ|2 = |φ|2 + 2 . If φ is harmonic, by the above proposition, |∇|φ| |2 ≤
|φ| n−1 A 2 |∇ φ| ≤ |∇ A φ|2 |∇|φ||2 ≤ |φ| n
(2.5)
at points where φ( p) = 0. Since { p ∈ M : φ( p) = 0} is dense in M for harmonic φ, we conclude that (2.5) holds everywhere in M.
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
5
2.5. Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula and Hirzebruch signature formula. Let (M, g) be a compact closed oriented Riemannian 4-manifold, χ (M) and τ (M) are the Euler number and the signature of M respectively. The Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula and the Hirzebruch signature theorem say that Rg2 1 1 + |Wg |2 − |Ricº|2 )dvg , and ( 8π 2 M 24 2 1 τ (M) = (|Wg+ |2 − |Wg− |2 )dvg , 12π 2 M
χ (M) =
(2.6) (2.7)
R
where Ricº = Ric(g) − 4g g is the Einstein tensor, Wg+ and Wg− are the self-dual and anti-self-dual Weyl tensors respectively (cf. [B]). If g is a Kähler-Einstein metric, then Rg2 = 24|Wg+ |2 ,
(2.8)
(cf. [B]) which will be used in the proof of Theorem 1.1. By Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula, one has an L 2 -bound of the curvature operator Rm(g) by the bounds of Ricci curvature, i.e. if |Ric(g)| < C, then |Rm(g)|2 dvg ≤ 8π 2 χ (M) + C1 V ol g (M), (2.9) M
where C and C1 are constants independent of (M, g). Let (N , g) be a complete Ricci-flat Einstein 4-manifold. Assume that |Rm(g)|2 dvg < ∞, and Volg (Bg (x, r)) ≥ Cr 4 ,
(2.10)
N
for all r > 0, a point x ∈ N , and a positive constant C. By Theorem 2.11 of [N], (N , g) is ALE. (i.e, Asymptotically Locally Euclidean space) of order 4. It is well-known that N is asymptotic to the cone on the spherical space form S 3 / , where ⊂ S O(4) is a finite group. The Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula implies that 1 1 χ (N ) = (2.11) |Rm(g)|2 dvg + 2 8π N || (cf. [N] and [An1]).
2.6. Curvature estimates for 4-manifolds. Now let’s recall a result of [CT], which is important to the proof of Theorem 1.1. Let (M, g) be a complete Riemannian 4-manifold. A subset U ⊂ M such that for all p ∈ U , sup Ric(g) ≥ −3, is called -collapsed if for all p ∈ U ,
Bg ( p,1)
V ol g (Bg ( p, 1)) ≤ . By Theorem 0.1 in [CG], there is a constant ε4 such that if U is -collapsed with sectional curvature |K g | ≤ 1 and ≤ ε4 , then U carries an F-structure of positive rank.
6
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Theorem 2.7 (Remark 5.11 and Theorem 1.26 in [CT]). There exist constants δ > 0, c > 0 such that: if (M, g) is a complete Riemannian 4-manifold with |Ric(g)| ≤ 3 and |Rm(g)|2 dvg ≤ C, M
and if E ⊂ M is a bounded open subset such that T1 (E) = {x ∈ M : dist(x, E) ≤ 1} is ε4 -collapsed with |Rm(g)|2 dvg ≤ δ ( f or all T1 (E)), Bg (x,1)
then
|Rm(g)|2 dvg ≤ cV ol g (A0,1 (E)), E
where A0,1 (E) = T1 (E)\E. 3. The Limiting Behavior of Ricci Flow In this section we study the limiting behavior of Ricci-flow with bounded Ricci curvatures on 4-manifolds. We will assume in this section that M is a smooth closed oriented 4-manifold with λ M < 0, and g(t), t ∈ [0, +∞), is a longtime solution of the normalized Ricci flow (1.3) with bounded Ricci-curvature. By normalization we may assume that |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3. By (2.9) there is a constant C independent of t such that |Rm(g(t))|2 dvg(t) ≤ C. M
˘ Let us denote by V the volume Volg(0) (M) = Volg(t) (M), and R(g(t)) = min x∈M
˘ R(g(t))(x) the minimum of the scalar curvature of g(t). It is easy to see that R(g(t)) ≤ 1 −2 λM V < 0. ˘ Lemma 3.1. (3.1.1) lim λ M (g(t)) = lim R(g(t)) = lim R(g(t)) = R∞, t→∞ t→∞ t→∞ (3.1.2) lim M |R(g(t)) − R(g(t))|dvg(t) = 0, t→∞ (3.1.3) lim M |Ricº(g(t))|2 dvg(t) = 0. t→∞
Proof. By Perelman [Pe1] λ M (g(t)) is a non-decreasing function on t, therefore the limit lim λ M (g(t)) exists since λ M < 0. Now let us denote by R ∞ the limit lim λ M (g(t)).
t→∞
t→∞
1
Note that R ∞ ≤ λ M V − 2 < 0. To prove (3.1.1), we first prove that both lim R(g(t)) t→∞
˘ exist and take values R ∞ . By the same arguments as in the proof of and lim R(g(t)) t→∞ Proposition 2.6 and Lemma 2.7 of [FZZ] we get that ˘ lim R(g(t)) − R(g(t)) = 0.
t→∞
˘ (cf. [KL] (92.3)). Therefore lim R(g(t)) = Observe that R(g(t)) ≥ λ M (g(t)) ≥ R(g(t)) ˘ R ∞ = lim R(g(t)). This proves (3.1.1). t−→∞
t→∞
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
7
Note that ˘ |R(g(t)) − R(g(t))|dvg(t) ≤ (R(g(t)) − R(g(t)))dv (R(g(t)) g(t) + M
M
M
˘ − R(g(t)))dv g(t) ˘ = 2(R(g(t)) − R(g(t)))V. Equation (3.1.2) follows from (3.1.1). By Lemma 3.1 in [FZZ], ∞ |Ricº(g(t))|2 dvg(t) dt < ∞, 0
M
and, by Lemma 1 in [Y], we have d 2 |Ricº(g(t))| dvg(t) ≤ −2 |∇ Ricº(g(t))|2 dvg(t) dt M M +4 |Rm||Ricº(g(t))|2 dvg(t) < D, M
where D is a constant independent of t. By the same argument as in the proof of Proposition 2.6 in [FZZ] (3.1.3) follows. The following is the main result of this section, which is an analogy of Theorem 10.5 in [CT], where the same conclusion was derived for closed oriented Einstein 4-manifolds with the same negative Einstein constant. The key point in our case is to use Lemma 3.1 to get non-collapsing balls and to prove the limiting metric is an Einstein metric (cf. Lemma 3.3 and Lemma 3.4 below). Proposition 3.2. Let M be a smooth closed oriented 4-manifold with λ M < 0. If g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞) is a solution to (1.3) such that |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3, and {tk } is a sequence of times which tends to infinity such that diamgk (M) −→ ∞, when k −→ ∞, where gk = g(tk ), then there exists an m ∈ N, and sequences of points {x j,k ∈ M}, j = 1, . . . , m, satisfying that, by passing to a subsequence, dG H
(M, gk , x1,k , . . . , xm,k ) −→ (
m
N j , g∞ , x1,∞ , . . . , xm,∞ )
j=1
in the m-pointed Gromov-Hausdorff sense for k → ∞, where (N j , g∞ ) j = 1, . . . , m are complete Einstein 4-orbifolds with at most finitely many isolated orbifold points {qi }. The scalar curvature (resp. volume) of g∞ is R ∞ = lim λ M (g(t)), t−→∞
(r esp. V = Volg0 (M) =
m
Volg∞ (N j )).
j=1
Furthermore, in the regular part of N j , {gk } converges to g∞ in both L 2, p (resp. C 1,α ) sense for all p < ∞ (resp. α < 1).
8
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
We divide the proof of Proposition 3.2 into several useful lemmas. A key result in the paper [CT] shows that, for any compact oriented Einstein 4-manifold (X, g) with Einstein constant −3, there exists a constant C depending only on the Euler number of X , and a point x ∈ X such that Volg (Bg (x, 1)) ≥ CVolg (X ) (cf. Theorem 0.14 [CT]). Cheeger-Tian remarked that the same result continues to hold for 4-manifolds which are sufficiently negatively Ricci pinched. The following lemma is an analogy of the result for the metric gk in Proposition 3.2. Lemma 3.3. There exists a constant v > 0, and a sequence {xk } ⊂ M such that Volgk (Bgk (xk , 1)) ≥ v. Proof. Let ε4 > 0 be the critical constant of Cheeger-Tian (cf. §1 [CT]), i.e., if X is a Riemannian 4-manifold which is ε4 -collapsed with locally bounded curvature, then X carries an F-structure of positive rank. We may assume that, for all x ∈ M and gk , Volgk (Bgk (x, 1)) < ε4 . By a standard covering argument, for any k, there exist finitely many points q1 , . . . , ql such that E = M\ li=1 Bgk (qi , 1) satisfies the hypothesis of Theorem 2.7. Moreover, l ≤ Cδ −1 , where C and δ are the constants in Theorem 2.7. Therefore, by Theorem 2.7 we conclude that, there is a constant C1 independent of k such that l |R(gk )|2 dvk ≤ 6 |Rm(gk )|2 dvk ≤ C1 Volgk (Bgk (qi , 1)). (3.1) E
E
i=1
On the other hand, by Lemma (3.1.2) k→∞ 2 2 | (R(gk ) − R(gk ) )dvk | ≤ 24 |R(gk ) − R(gk )|dvk −→ 0. E
E
Therefore 1 2 R ∞ Volgk (E) − R(gk )2 dvk ≤ R(gk )2 Volgk (E) − R(gk )2 dvk 2 E E = (R(gk )2 − R(gk )2 )dvk
(3.2)
E
1 2 ≤ R∞ V 4 1
for sufficiently large k since R ∞ ≤ λ M V − 2 < 0. By inserting (3.1) we get that 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 R ∞ (V − V ol gk (Bgk (qi , 1)) − R ∞ V ≤ R ∞ Volgk (E) − R ∞ V 2 4 2 4 l
i=1
≤ C1
l
Volgk (Bgk (qi , 1)),
i=1
and V ≤ C2
l
Volgk (Bgk (qi , 1)),
i=1
where C2 is a constant independent of k. Therefore, there is at least a ball among the l balls whose volume is at least CV2 l . The desired result follows.
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
9
Assuming that diamgk (M) → ∞ for k → ∞, by using the technique developed in [An3], the analogue of Theorem 3.3 in [An2] holds (cf. Theorem 2.3 in [An4]), i.e. there exist a sequence of points {xk } ⊂ M such that, by passing to a subsequence, dG H
{(M, gk , xk )} −→ (N∞ , g∞ , x∞ ), where N∞ is a 4-orbifold with only isolated orbifold points {qi }, g∞ is a complete C 0 orbifold metric, and g∞ is a C 1,α ∩ L 2, p Riemannian metric on the regular part of N∞ , for all p < ∞ and α < 1. Furthermore, {gk } converges to g∞ in the L 2, p (resp. C 1,α ) sense on the regular partof N∞ , i.e. for any r 1 and k, there is a smooth embedding Fk,r : Bg∞ (x∞ , r )\ i Bg∞ (qi , r −1 ) ⊂ N∞ → M such that, by passing to ∗ g converge to g in both L 2, p and C 1,α senses. a subsequence, Fk,r k ∞ Lemma 3.4. g∞ is an Einstein orbifold metric with scalar curvature R ∞ . Proof. We first prove that g∞ is an Einstein metric with scalar curvature R ∞ on the ∗ g converge to g 2, p (resp. C 1,α ) sense on regular part of N∞ . Since Fk,r k ∞ in the L −1 Bg∞ ( p∞ , r )\ i Bg∞ (qi , r ), for any r , by Lemma 3.1, we obtain that 2 0≤ |Ricº(g∞ )| dv∞ ≤ lim |Ricº(gk )|2 dvk = 0,
0≤
Bg∞ ( p∞ ,r )\
Bg∞ ( p∞ ,r )\
i
i
Bg∞ (qi ,r −1 )
Bg∞ (qi ,r −1 )
k−→∞ M
|R(g∞ )− R ∞ |dv∞ ≤ lim
k−→∞ M
|R(gk )− R(gk )|dvk = 0.
Therefore g∞ is a C 1,α Riemannian metric on Bg∞ ( p∞ , r )\ i Bg∞ (qi , r −1 ) which satisfies the Einstein equation in the weak sense. By elliptic regularity theory, g∞ is a smooth Einstein metric with scalar curvature R ∞ . Since g∞ is a C 0 -orbifold metric, i.e. for any orbifold point qi ∈ N∞ , there is a neighborhood Ui ∼ g∞ is a C 0 -Riemannian metric on = B(0, r )/ of qi such that B(0, r ) ⊂ R4 , where ⊂ S O(4) is a finite subgroup acting freely on S 3 , and g∞ | B(0,r )\{0} is the pull-back that g∞ is a smooth Einstein metric on metric of g∞ . Note g∞ )|2 dv < C < ∞. By the arguments as in B(0, r )\{0} satisfying that B(0,r ) |Rm( g∞ [An1] and [Ti], g∞ is a C ∞ Einstein metric on B(0, r ) (cf. the proof of Theorem C in [An1], and Sect. 4 in [Ti]). Hence g∞ is an Einstein orbifold metric. By the discussion before Lemma 3.4 we may choose sequences of points {x j,k } ⊂ k→∞
M, j = 1, . . . , , such that distgk (xi,k , x j,k ) −→ ∞ for any i = j, and dG H
{(M, gk , x1,k , . . . , x,k )} −→ (
N j , g∞ , x1,∞ , . . . , x,∞ ),
(3.3)
j=1
where (N j , g∞ , x j,∞ ), j = 1, . . . , are complete Einstein 4-orbifolds with only isolated singular points and scalar curvatures R ∞ . Furthermore, {gk } converges to g∞ in both L 2, p (resp. C 1,α ) sense on the regular parts of N j , j = 1, . . . , . Note that V ≥
i=1
Volg∞ (N j ).
(3.4)
10
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Lemma 3.5. The number of orbifold points of
N j is less than a constant depending
j=1
only on the Euler characteristic χ (M).
Proof. For each orbifold point q ∈ N j , there exists a sequence {qk } ⊂ M, and two constants r r1 > 0 such that: (3.5.1) q ∈ Bg∞ (x j,∞ , r ); (3.5.2) Bg∞ (q, r1 )\Bg∞ (q, σ ) lies in the regular part of Bg∞ (x j,∞ , r ) for any σ < r1 ; C 1,α
(3.5.3) (Bgk (qk , r1 )\Bgk (qk , σ ), gk ) −→ (Bg∞ (q, r1 )\Bg∞ (q, σ ), g∞ ). By the definition of harmonic radius (cf. [An3]), the harmonic radii of all points in Bgk (qk , r1 )\Bgk (qk , σ ) have a uniform lower bound, saying µ > 0, a constant depending on σ but independent of k. Clearly, there is a positive constant v0 (e.g., 21 Volg∞ (Bg∞ (x j,∞ , r ))) such that Volgk (Bgk (x j,k , r )) ≥ v0 . Note that the Sobolev constants C S,k of Bgk (x j,k , r ) are bounded from below by a constant depending only on v0 , r (cf. [An2] and [Cr]). Therefore, by [An2] again we get that Volgk (Bgk (qk , s)) ≥ Cs 4 for any s 1, where C is independent of k. Let us denote by rh,k the infimum of the harmonic radii of gk in the ball Bgk (qk , r1 ). k→∞
Note that rh,k −→ 0 since q is an orbifold point (cf. [An3]). Therefore, there is a point q¯k ∈ Bgk (qk , σ ) so that rh (q¯k ) = rh,k for sufficiently large k. −2 Consider the normalized balls (Bgk (qk , r1 ), rh,k gk ), which have harmonic radii at least 1. By passing to a subsequence if necessary, C 1,α
−2 (Bgk (qk , r1 ), rh,k gk , q¯k ) −→ (W, g¯ ∞ , q), ¯
where (W, g¯ ∞ ) is a complete Ricci-flat 4-manifold satisfying that ¯ r )) ≥ Cr 4 Volg¯∞ (Bg¯∞ (q,
(3.5)
for any r > 0. It is obvious that |Rm(g¯ ∞ )|2 dvg¯∞ ≤ lim inf |Rm(gk )|2 dvk ≤ C. k−→∞
W
M
Therefore (W, g¯ ∞ ) is an Asymptotically Locally Euclidean space (cf. Theorem 2.11 in [N] or [An1]), which is asymptotic to a cone of S 3 / , where ⊂ S O(4) is a finite group acting freely on S 3 . By the Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula 1 1 . (3.6) |Rm(g¯ ∞ )|2 dvg¯∞ + χ (W ) = 8π 2 W || By [An1] W is isometric to R4 , provided || = 1. Since the harmonic radius of g¯ ∞ at q¯ is 1, hence g¯ ∞ cannot be the Euclidean metric. Hence || ≥ 2. It is easy to verify that χ (W ) ≥ 1. By (3.6) we get that |Rm(g¯ ∞ )|2 dvg¯∞ ≥ 4π 2 . W
This proves that every orbifold point contributes to lim inf k−→∞
M
|Rm(gk )|2 dvk at least
4π 2 . By the rescaling invariance of the integral we conclude that the number of orbifold points β ≤ 4πC 2 .
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
11
The following lemma is an analogue of a result in Cheeger-Tian [CT]. Lemma 3.6. < χ (M)+β +1, where β := #{number of orbifold points in Lemma 3.5}. Proof. Suppose not, i.e, ≥ χ (M) + β + 1, by definition there are at least χ (M) + 1 components of 1 N j which are smooth complete non-compact Einstein 4-manifolds of finite volume, for simplicity saying N1 , . . . , Ns , where s ≥ χ (M) + 1. By Theorem 4.5 in [CT], for each 1 ≤ j ≤ s, |Rm(g∞ )|2 dvg∞ ≥ 8π 2 . Nj
L 2, p
Since (M, gk , xk, j ) −→ (N j , g∞ , x∞, j ), by the Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula and (3.1.3) in Lemma 3.1 we get that 8π 2 χ (M) = lim |Rm(gk )|2 dvgk ≥ |Rm(g∞ )|2 dvg∞ ≥ 8π 2 (χ (M) + 1). k−→∞ M
Nj
A contradiction. Let m denote the maximal value of all possible choices of the base point sequences in (3.3), which has a upper bound by Lemma 3.6. Lemma 3.7. Let Mk,r = M\ mj=1 Bgk (x j,k , r ). For sufficiently large r , there is a constant C independent of r such that lim Volgk (Mk,r ) ≤ C
m
k→∞
m
j=1
r Volg∞ (N j \Bg∞ (x j,∞ , )), 2
Volg∞ (N j ) = V.
(3.7)
(3.8)
j=1
Proof. We may choose r 1 such that, for any y ∈ mj=1 (N j \Bg∞ (x j,∞ , r − 1)), Volg∞ (Bg∞ (y, 1)) ≤ 21 ε4 , where ε4 > 0 is the critical constant of Cheeger-Tian (cf. proof of Lemma 3.3 or §1 [CT]). Now we claim that there is a constant k0 1 such that, for any k > k0 and any x ∈ Mk,r , Volgk (Bgk (x, 1)) ≤ ε4 . If it is false, without loss of generality we may assume a sequence of points {yk } ⊂ Mk,r such that Volgk (Bgk (yk , 1)) > ε4 .
(3.9)
Observe that the distance distgk (yk , xj,k ) → ∞ as k → ∞ for all 1 ≤ j ≤ m. Otherwise, −1 assuming distgk (yk , xj,k ) < ρ for some j and ρ > 0, we get that F j,k,ρ (yk ) → y∞ ∈ Bg∞ (x j,∞ , ρ)\Bg∞ (x j,∞ , r − 1), and so Volgk (Bgk (yk , 1)) → Volg∞ (Bg∞ (y∞ , 1)) ≤
1 ε4 2
(3.10)
12
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
∗ when k → ∞, since F j,k,ρ gk C 1,α -converges to g j,∞ , where
F j,k,ρ : Bg∞ (x j,∞ , ρ)\
Bg∞ (qi , ρ −1 ) ⊂ N∞ → M
(3.11)
i ∗ is a smooth embedding so that F j,k,ρ gk converges to g∞ in the C 1,α -sense (cf. the discussion before Lemma 3.4). A contradiction to (3.9). dG H
Note that (M, gk , yk ) −→ (N∞ , g∞ , y∞ ) where N∞ is a complete 4-orbifold different from each of N j , 1 ≤ j ≤ m. This violates the choice of maximality of m. Hence we have proved the claim. By a standard covering argument, for any k, there exist finitely many points I z 1,k , . . . , z I,k such that E k,r = Mk,r \ i=1 Bzi,k (1) satisfies the hypothesis of Theorem 2.7, where I is independent of k. By Theorem 2.7, there is a constant C independent of k such that
|R(gk )| dvk ≤ 6
|Rm(gk )|2 dvk ≤ C(
2
E k,r
E k,r
I
Volgk (Bgk (z i,k , 1))
i=1
+Volgk (A0,1 (Mk,r ))). By Lemma 3.1, for k 1, we have |R(gk ) − R(gk )|dvk < |R(gk ) − R(gk )|dvk −→ 0. E k,r
(3.12)
M
By (3.2) we get 1 2 R Volgk (E k,r ) − 2 ∞
R(gk )2 dvk ≤ E k,r
(R(gk )2 − R(gk )2 )dvk E k,r
≤ 24
|R(gk ) − R(gk )|dvk . E k,r
Since Volgk (Ek,r ) ≥ Volgk (Mk,r ) −
I
Volgk (Bgk (zi,k , 1)), by the above together we get
i=1
immediately that Volgk (Mk,r ) ≤ C(
I i=1
Volgk (Bgk (zi,k , 1)) + Volgk (A0,1 (Mk,r )))
|R(gk ) − R(gk )|dvk .
+24
(3.13)
E k,r
If distgk (zi,k , xj,k ) → ∞ for all 1 ≤ j ≤ m, by the same argument as above we get that Volgk (Bgk (zi,k , 1)) → 0 when k → ∞. Otherwise, there exists a subsequence ks → ∞ and an index j such that distgks (zi,ks , xj,ks ) < ρ
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
13
for some constant ρ. In both cases, we obtain lim sup Volgk (Bgk (zi,ks , 1)) ≤ k→∞
m j=1
r Volg∞ (Nj \Bg∞ (xj,∞ , )) 2
for r ρ. Therefore, by (3.12) and (3.13) we conclude immediately (3.7). By (3.7) it follows that lim Volgk (Mk,r ) → 0. Hence (3.8) follows. k,r→∞
By now Proposition 3.2 follows by the above lemmas. 4. Smooth Convergence on the Regular Part The main result of this section is the following: Proposition 4.1. Let M be a closed 4-manifold satisfying that λ¯ M < 0 and let g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞), be a solution to the normalized Ricci flow equation (1.3) on M with uniformly dG H
bounded Ricci curvature. If (M, g(tk ), pk ) −→ (N∞ , g∞ , p∞ ), where tk → ∞ and C 1,α
N∞ is a 4-dimensional orbifold, and g(tk ) −→ g∞ on the regular part R of N∞ (the compliment of the orbifold points), then, by passing to a subsequence, for all t ∈ [0, ∞), dG H
(M, g(tk + t), pk ) −→ (N∞ , g∞ (t), p∞ ), where g∞ (t) is a family of smooth metrics on R solving the normalized Ricci flow equation on R with g∞ (0) = g∞ . Moreover, the convergence is smooth on R × [0, ∞). In [Se] the convergence of Kähler-Ricci flow on compact Kähler manifolds with bounded Ricci curvature was studied. It seems that the arguments in [Se] could be applied to prove Proposition 4.1, but the authors can not follow completely her line. Therefore, we give a quite different approach, where we first give a curvature estimate of the Ricci flow similar to Perelman’s pseudolocality theorem. Using this curvature estimation we prove the limit Ricci flow exists on R × [0, ∞). Finally, we prove that R is exactly the regular part of every subsequence limit of (M, g(tk + t), pk ), for all t ∈ [0, ∞). We point out that our approach works only in dimension 4. We now give a curvature estimate for the Ricci flow which is an analogy of Perelman’s pseudolocality theorem (cf.[Pe1],Thm. 10.1). The difference is that here we use the hypothesis of local almost Euclidean volume growth, instead of the almost Euclidean isoperimetric estimate. The proof is much easier than that of Perelman’s pseudolocality theorem. Theorem 4.2. There exist universal constants δ0 , 0 > 0 with the following property. Let g(t), t ∈ [0, ( P r0 )2 ], be a solution to the Ricci flow equation (1.2) on a closed n-manifold M and x0 ∈ M be a point. If the scalar curvature R(x, t) ≥ −r0−2
whenever dist g(t) (x0 , x) ≤ r0 ,
and the volume Volg(t) (Bg(t) (x, r )) ≥ (1 − δ0 )Vol(B(r )) for all Bg(t) (x, r ) ⊂ Bg(t) (x0 , r0 ), where B(r ) denotes a ball of radius r in the n-Euclidean space and Vol(B(r )) denotes its Euclidean volume, then the Riemannian curvature tensor satisfies |Rm|g(t) (x, t) ≤ t −1 ,
whenever dist g(t) (x0 , x) < 0 r0 , and 0 < t ≤ (0 r0 )2 .
In particular, |Rm|g(t) (x0 , t) ≤ t −1 for all time t ∈ (0, (0 r0 )2 ].
14
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Proof. We use Claim 1 and Claim 2 of Theorem 10.1 in [Pe1] and adopt a contradiction argument. For any given small constants , δ > 0, set 0 = , δ0 = δ, then there is a solution to the Ricci flow equation (1.2), say (M, g(t)), not satisfying the conclusion of the theorem. After a rescaling, we may assume that r0 = 1. Denote by M¯ the nonempty set of pairs (x, t) such that |Rm|g(t) (x, t) > t −1 , then as in Claim 1 and Claim 2 of Theorem 10.1 in [Pe1], we can choose another space time point (x, ¯ t¯) ∈ M¯ with 1 0 < t¯ ≤ 2 , dist g(t¯) (x0 , x) ¯ < 10 , such that |Rm|g(t) (x, t) ≤ 4Q whenever t¯ −
1 −1 1 Q ≤ t ≤ t¯, dist g(t¯) (x, (100n)−1 Q −1/2 , ¯ x) ≤ 2n 10
where Q = |Rm|g(t¯) (x, ¯ t¯). It is remarkable that from the proof of Claim 2 of Theorem 10.1 in [Pe1], each such a space time point (x, t) satisfies dist g(t) (x, x0 ) < dist g(t¯) (x0 , x) ¯ + (100n)−1 Q −1/2 <
1 1 + (100n)−1 < . 10 2
Now choosing sequences of positive numbers k → 0 and δk → 0, we obtain a sequence of solutions (Mk , gk (t)), t ∈ [0, k2 ] and a sequence of points x0,k , x¯k ∈ Mk and times t¯k , with each satisfying the assumptions of the theorem and the properties described above. In particular, we have that Q k = |Rm k |gk (t¯k ) (x¯k , t¯k ) → ∞. Consider the sequence of pointed Ricci flow solutions (Bgk (t¯k ) (x¯k ,
1 1 −1/2 ¯ (100nk )−1 Q k ), Q k gk (Q −1 , 0]. k t + tk ), x¯ k ), t ∈ [− 10 2n
Using Hamilton’s compactness theorem for solutions to the Ricci flow, we can extract a subsequence which converges to a complete Ricci flow solution (M∞ , g∞ (t), x¯∞ ), 1 t ∈ (− 2n , 0], with |Rm ∞ |g∞ (0) (x¯∞ , 0) = 1. By assumption, the balls Bgk (t¯k ) (x¯k ,
1 1 −1/2 (100nk )−1 Q k ) ⊂ Bgk (t) (x0,k , ) 10 2
1 1 for any t ∈ [t¯ − 2n Q −1 , t¯], so the scalar curvature Rk (x, t) ≥ − 1 for t ∈ [t¯ − 2n Q −1 , t¯] −1/2 1 (100nk )−1 Q k ) and Volgk (t) (Bgk (t) (x, r )) ≥ (1−δk )Vol(B(r )) and x ∈ Bgk (t¯k ) (x¯k , 10 −1/2 1 1 (100nk )−1 Q k ), t ∈ [t¯ − 2n Q −1 , t¯]. for any metric ball Bgk (t) (x, r ) ⊂ Bgk (t¯k ) (x¯k , 10 Passing to the limit, we see that g∞ (t) has scalar curvature R∞ ≥ 0 everywhere and local volume Volg∞ (t) (Bg∞ (t) (z, r )) ≥ Vol(B(r )) for any balls Bg∞ (t) (z, r ) at time 1 t ∈ (− 2n , 0]. Then the local variation formula of the volume implies that R∞ ≡ 0 1 on M∞ × (− 2n , 0], see [STW] for details. By the evolution of the scalar curvature ∂ 1 R = R + 2|Ric∞ |2 , we get that Ric∞ ≡ 0 over M∞ × (− 2n , 0]. Then the ∞ ∞ ∂t Bishop-Gromov volume comparison theorem implies that g∞ (t) are flat solutions to the Ricci flow, which contradicts the fact that |Rm ∞ |(x¯∞ , 0) = 1. This ends the proof of the theorem.
The next lemma provides a comparison of the curvature of the normalized and unnormalized Ricci flow. By assumption, there is C¯ < ∞ such that |Ric| ≤ C¯ everywhere along the flow (M, g(t)). Note that by Lemma 3.1, there is some time T < ∞ such that 2R ∞ ≤ R(g(t)) ≤ 21 R ∞ < 0 whenever t > T . Fix any such time t¯ > T and let h(t) and ˜ t˜) be the solutions to the normalized and unnormalized Ricci flow with initial metric h(
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
15
˜ h(0) = h(0) = g(t¯) respectively, where t˜ = t˜(t) is the corresponding rescaled time for t. Denote by Rm t¯, Rict¯, Rt¯ and Rm t¯, Rict¯, R˜ t¯ the corresponding Riemannian curvature, Ricci curvature and scalar curvature of them, where |Rict¯| ≤ C¯ since h(t) = g(t¯ + t). Then we have ˜ t˜) exists for all time t˜ ∈ [0, ∞). Furthermore, there exist Lemma 4.3. The solution h( ¯ such that constants C and τ depending on λ¯ M and C, Rm t¯|(x, t˜), whenever t ≤ τ. t ≤ t˜ ≤ Ct, | Rm t¯|(x, t˜) ≤ |Rm t¯|(x, t) ≤ C| ˜ t˜) Proof. The solution h(t) has average scalar curvature R(t¯ + t) ≤ 21 R ∞ < 0, so h( ˜ ˜ d ˜ t˜)) = − R, also has average scalar curvature R < 0. From the evolution ln Vol(h( d t˜
˜ t˜)) increases strictly in t˜, so to normalize it, we need to compress the the volume Vol(h( ˜ t˜) exists space and time. Thus t˜ ≥ t and | Rm t¯|(x, t˜) ≤ |Rm t¯|(x, t) for all (x, t). So h( for all time. The last assertion means that the scaling factor from normalized Ricci flow to the unnormalized one is less than C on the time interval [0, τ ]. Consider the evolution of ˜ t˜): the average scalar curvature R( d ˜ R= d t˜
M (2| Rict¯|
2
− R˜ t2¯ )dvk
V olh˜ ( t˜) (M)
2 + R˜ ≤ ,
˜ ≤ ¯ since | ¯ | R˜ t¯| ≤ |Rt¯| ≤ C, ¯ | R| for some constant = (C), Rict¯| ≤ |Rict¯| ≤ C, ˜ 1 ¯ Note that the initial value R(0) = R(g(t¯)) ≤ R ∞ , so there is some constant |R| ≤ C. 2 ˜ t˜) ≤ 1 R for t˜ ∈ [0, τ˜ ]. Thus the scaling factor from normalized τ˜ = τ˜ () such that R( 4
∞
R(h(t)) ˜ t˜) , is less than 8 on the time interval R( = τ8˜ and C = 8.
Ricci flow to the unnormalized one, which equals t˜ ∈ [0, τ˜ ]. Now the result follows, by setting τ
The following lemma gives the estimation of the local volume along the Ricci flow. As in [Se], the proof uses Theorem A 1.5 of [CC]. By assumption, we have a solution (M, g(t)) to the normalized Ricci flow (1.3) and a sequence of times tk → ∞ and points dG H
C 1,α
pk such that (M, g(tk ), pk ) −→ (N∞ , g∞ , p∞ ) with g(tk ) −→ g∞ on the regular part R of the orbifold N∞ . For the space M or N∞ , let R,ρ be the set of points x such that dG H (B(x, r ), B(r )) < r for any r ≤ u, where u ≥ ρ is some constant depending on x. Here and after, B(r ) denotes a ball of radius r in 4-Euclidean space and B(x, r ) the metric ball of radius r with center x in a metric space. A weak version is WR,ρ , the set of points x such that there is u ≥ ρ with dG H (B(x, u), B(u)) < u. Lemma 4.4. For each q ∈ R, choose a sequence qk ∈ M that converges to q. Then for any > 0, there exist k0 , η, ρ > 0 such that
Vol(Bg(tk +t) (qk , r )) ≥ (1 − )Vol(B(r )), ∀r < ρ, k0 < k,
whenever Bg(tk +t) (qk , r ) ⊂ Bg(tk ) (qk , ρ) and t ∈ [−η, η].
16
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Proof. By the boundedness of the Ricci tensor, there is a universal constant ¯ > 1 such that Bg(t) ( p, −1 r ) ⊂ Bg(s) ( p, r ) ⊂ Bg(t) ( p, r ) for all = (C) t, s ∈ [tk − 1, tk + 1], p ∈ M and r > 0. By Theorem A.1.5 of [CC], for fixed > 0, there are δ = δ(, n), ρ = ρ(, n) > 0 such that x ∈ WRδ,r implies Vol(Bg(t) (x, r )) ≥ (1 − )Vol(B(r )) for each r ≤ ρ and x ∈ M. So by definition, it suffices to show qk ∈ Rδ,ρ with respect to each metric g(t), t ∈ [tk − η, tk + η], whe never qk ∈ Bg(tk ) (qk , ρ), for some constant η > 0. The constant ρ may be modified by a smaller one if necessary. Using Theorem A.1.5 of [CC] again, for fixed δ as above, there is δ1 = δ1 (δ, n) > 0 such that qk ∈ WR (2 +1)ρ implies qk ∈ Rδ,ρ for any qk ∈ Bg(t) (qk , 2 ρ). So it δ1 ,
1−δ
reduces to show qk ∈ WR
2
+1)ρ δ1 , (1−δ
with respect to each time t ∈ [tk −η, tk +η] for some
η > 0 small enough. In fact, as shown in [Se], dG H (Bg(tk ) (qk , ρ1 ), B(ρ1 )) < 21 δ1 ρ1 for some small number ρ1 and all k large enough. By the boundedness of the Ricci tensor again, there is a constant η ≤ 1 such that for each time t ∈ [−η, η], we have dG H (Bg(tk +t) (qk , ρ1 ), Bg(tk ) (qk , ρ1 )) < 21 δ1 ρ1 for all k. Thus dG H (Bg(tk +t) (qk , ρ1 ), 1 . B(ρ1 )) < δ1 ρ1 for each t ∈ [−η, η]. Now the result follows by setting ρ = (1−δ)ρ 2 +1 Note that in the proof, the constant δ1 = δ1 (, n), so the constant η depends only on ¯ By assumption, there is a compact exhaustion {K i }∞ of R and a sequence , n and C. i=1 of smooth embeddings Fi : K i → M such that Fi ( p∞ ) = pi and Fi∗ g(ti ) converges to g∞ in the local C 1,α sense. Following the lines described in [Se], we can prove Lemma 4.5. Denote by K i,k = Fk (K i ), then for any > 0 and i, there are k0 , η, ρ > 0 such that
Vol(Bg(tk +t) (qk , r )) ≥ (1 − )Vol(B(r )), ∀qk ∈ K i,k , k0 < k, t ∈ [−η, η] and r < ρ. Now we are ready to prove Proposition 4.1. Proof of Proposition 4.1. Assume that p∞ ∈ K i for each i. Set = δ0 in the previous lemma, where δ0 is just the constant in Theorem 4.2, then for one fixed K i , there exist k0 , η, ρ > 0 such that Vol(Bg(tk +t) (q, r )) ≥ (1−δ0 )Vol(B(r )) whenever q ∈ K i,k , k0 < k, t ∈ [−η, η] and r < ρ. Modifying ρ and η by smaller constants, we assume (0 ρ)2 ≤ 2η < τ , where τ and 0 are constants in Lemma 4.3 and Theorem 4.2 respectively. Let h k (t˜) be the corresponding solutions to the unnormalized Ricci flow equation with initial value h k (0) = g(tk − η), then Vol(Bh k (t˜) (q, r )) ≥ (1 − δ0 )Vol(B(r )) whenever q ∈ K i,k , r < ρ, k0 < k and t˜ satisfying t (t˜) ∈ [0, 2η], since the inequality Vol(B(q, r )) ≥ (1 − δ0 )Vol(B(r )) is scale invariant and Bh k (t˜) ⊂ Bg(tk +t (t˜)) (q, r ) for k large enough such that tk ≥ T +η for T chosen as above. Denote by Rm k the Riemannian curvature tensor of h k , then by Theorem 4.2 and Lemma 4.3, we have |Rm|(q, tk + t) ≤ C| Rm k |(q, t˜) ≤ C(t˜)−1 ≤ C(t − tk + η)−1 , for all q ∈ K i,k . Hence |Rm|(q, t) is uniformly bounded on K i,k × [tk − η2 , tk + η2 ]. By Hamilton’s compactness theorem of the Ricci flow solution, {(K i,k , g(tk + t), pk )}∞ k=1 converge along a subsequence to a solution to the normalized Ricci flow (K i,∞ , gi,∞ (t), pi,∞ ), t ∈ (− η2 , η2 ), in the local C ∞ sense. When we consider the time t = 0, then using a diagonalization argument, a subsequence of {(K i,k , g(tk ), pk )}i,k
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
17
will converge in the local C ∞ sense to a smooth Riemannian manifold (K ∞ , g∞ , p∞ ), which is just (R, g∞ ), by the uniqueness of the limit space. For fixed i, there is a family of metrics gi,∞ (t), t ∈ (− η2 , η2 ), on K i . As shown in [Se], we translate the time by η4 , say considering the sequence {(K i,k , g(tk + η4 + ∞ Cloc
t), pk )}k , and repeat the above argument, then obtain that {(K i,k , g(tk + t), pk )}k −→ (K i,∞ , gi,∞ (t), pi,∞ ) along another subsequence, on the time interval t ∈ (− η2 , η4 + η2 ). The essential point is that the estimate dG H (Bg(tk ) (qk , ρ1 ), B(ρ1 )) < 21 δ1 ρ1 in the proof of Lemma 4.4 holds for some constant ρ1 , simultaneously the time tk is replaced by tk + η4 , but the constant η in Lemma 4.5 is fixed in this procedure. Iterating this process infinite times we obtain the convergence on K i for all t ∈ [0, ∞). Then do the same thing for each K i , i = 1, 2, . . ., and after a diagonalization argument, we get that a ∞ Cloc
subsequence of {(K i,k , g(tk + t), pk )}k , say (K i,ki , g(tki + t), pki ) −→ (R, g∞ (t), p∞ ) for all t ∈ [0, ∞), with g∞ (0) = g∞ . ¯ t, We finally show that the completion of R with respect to the metric g∞ (t), say R is just N∞ , for each time t ∈ [0, ∞). Denote by S = N∞ \R the set of singular points ¯ t = R ∪ S for fixed time t. Assume of (N∞ , g∞ (0)), then it suffices to show that R Q S = {ql }l=1 , where Q ≤ β for β = β(M) by Lemma 3.5, and let ε > 0 be any small constant such that Bg∞ (0) (qi , ε) ∩ Bg∞ (0) (q j , ε) = ∅ whenever i = j. Denote by K ε = R\ pl Bg∞ (0) ( pl , ε), then using |Ric∞ | ≤ C¯ on R × [0, ∞) and by the ¯
evolution of the distance function, we obtain dG H ((R\K ε , g∞ (t)), S) ≤ e2Ct ε and ¯ t = R ∪ S, by letting ε → 0. consequently R We pose one remark at the end of this section: Remark. Perelman’s pseudolocality theorem still holds for the normalized Ricci flow in our situation, so if the solution does not spatially local collapse along a subsequence of space time points ( pk , tk ) with tk → ∞, then passing a subsequence, (M, g(tk + t), pk ) will converge to a family of orbifolds (N∞ , g∞ (t), p∞ ) with finite isolated singularities for all t ≥ 0. The convergence is smooth on the regular part. If λ M (g(t)) ≤ 0 for all time, then by the same argument as in [FZZ], the limits (N∞ , g∞ (t)) are Einstein; while if not, then the limits g∞ (t) will have nonnegative scalar curvature on the regular part and positive totally L 1 scalar curvature. We point out that in the second case, (M, g(t)) does locally non-collapsing for each time t, by Perelman’s local non-collapsing theorem. Furthermore, it seems that under this situation, the limit may satisfy a shrinking Ricci soliton equation and has smooth metric in the orbifold sense. We don’t have a detailed argument for this now and it forms part of a future study on normalized Ricci flow which exists for all time. 5. Proofs of Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 The main result of this section is the following Theorem 5.1. Let (M, c) be a smooth oriented closed 4-manifold with a Spinc -structure c. Assume that the first Chern class c1 (c) of c is a monopole class of M satisfying that c12 (c)[M] ≥ 2χ (M) + 3τ (M) > 0. Let g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞), be a solution to (1.3) so that |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3, and lim λ M (g(t)) = − 32π 2 c12 (c)[M]. t→∞
(5.1)
(5.2)
18
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Then there exists an m ∈ N, and sequences of points {x j,k ∈ M}, j = 1, . . . , m, satisfying that, by passing to a subsequence, dG H
(M, g(tk + t), x1,k , . . . , xm,k ) −→ (
m
N j , g∞ , x1,∞ , . . . , , xm,∞ ),
j=1
t ∈ [0, ∞), in the m-pointed Gromov-Hausdorff sense for any tk → ∞, where (N j , g∞ ) j = 1, . . . , m are complete Kähler-Einstein orbifolds of complex dimension 2 with at most finitely many isolated orbifold points {qi }. The scalar curvature (resp. volume) of g∞ is 1
−Volg0 (M)− 2
32π 2 c12 (c)[M] (r esp.
V = Volg0 (M) =
m
Volg∞ (N j )).
j=1
Furthermore, in the regular part of N j , {g(tk + t)} converges to g∞ in C ∞ -sense. Comparing with Proposition 3.2, Theorem 5.1 shows that the Einstein orbifolds are actually Kähler Einstein orbifolds under the additional assumptions. The key point in the proof is that the sequence of the self-dual parts of the curvatures of the connections on the determinant line bundles given by the irreducible solutions in the Seiberg-Witten equations converges to a non-trivial parallel self-dual 2-form on every component N j , which is a candidate of the Kähler form. ˘ Let (M, c) and g(t) be the same as in Thoerem 5.1, and let V , m, tk , x j,k , R(g(t)), gk , g∞ , N j and F j,k,r be the same as in Sect. 3. Assume that, for each k, (φk , Ak ) is an irreducible solution to the Seiberg-Witten equations (2.1). Let | · |k denote the norm with respect to the metric gk = g(tk ). The following lemma shows that the L 2 -norms of the self-dual parts FA+k tends to zero. Lemma 5.2.
lim
k−→∞ M
|∇ k FA+k |2k dvk = 0,
where ∇ k is the connection on 2 T ∗ (M) induced by Levi-civita connection. Proof. The Bochner formula implies that 1 R(gk ) 1 |φk |2k + |φk |4k . 0 = − k |φk |2k + |∇ Ak φk |2k + 2 4 4 By taking integration we get that R(gk ) 1 |φk |2k )dvk = − (|∇ Ak φk |2k + |φk |4k dvk . 4 4 M M
(5.3)
Since λ M (gk ) is the lowest eigenvalue of the operator −4k + R(gk ), for any 1 > 0, by definition λ M (gk ) |φk |2k, dvk ≤ (4|∇|φk |k, |2 + R(gk )|φk |2k, )dvk , (5.4) M
M
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
19
where | · |2k, = | · |2k + 2 . By Kato’s inequality (cf. (2.5)) and letting → 0, λ M (gk ) |φk |2k dvk ≤ (4|∇ Ak φk |2k + R(gk )|φk |2k )dvk = − |φk |4k dvk ≤ 0. M
M
M
As λ M (gk ) ≤ 0, by Schwarz inequality, 1 1 1 λ M (gk )( |φk |4k, dvk ) 2 = λ M (gk )Volgk (M) 2 ( |φk |4k, dvk ) 2 M M ≤ λ M (gk ) |φk |2k, dvk . M
Therefore
λ M (gk )( M
1 |φk |4k, dvk ) 2
≤ M
(4|∇|φk |k, |2 + R(gk )|φ|2k, )dvk .
Thus 1 Ak 2 2 4 4 (|∇ φk |k − |∇|φk |k, | )dvk ≤ − |φk |k dvk − λ M (gk )( |φk |4k, dvk ) 2 . M
M
M
(5.5) From (2.5), |∇|φk |k, ≤ Hence, by letting −→ 0, we have 1 1 |∇ Ak φk |2k dvk ≤ −(( |φk |4k dvk ) 2 + λ M (gk ))( |φk |4k dvk ) 2 . |2
3 2 Ak 4 |∇ φk |k .
M
M
(5.6)
M
+ denotes the self-dual part of the harmonic form representing the first Chern class If c1,k c1 (c) of c, by the Seiberg-Witten equation we get that + 2 |φk |4k dvk = 8 |FA+k |2 dvk ≥ 32π 2 [c1,k ] [M] ≥ 32π 2 c12 (c)[M]. (5.7) M
M
Note that, by the standard estimates for Seiberg-Witten equations, ˘ k ) ≥ |φk |2k − R(g
and, by Theorem 1.1 in [FZ], 32π 2 c12 (c)[M] + λ M (gk ) is non-positive. Hence 1 Ak 2 2 2 |∇ φk |k dvk ≤ −( 32π c1 (c)[M] + λ M (gk ))( |φk |4k dvk ) 2 M M 1 2 ˘ k )V 2 ( 32π 2 c (c)[M] + λ M (gk )) −→ 0, ≤ R(g (5.8) 1 when k −→ ∞, by (5.2) and Lemma 3.1. By the second one of the Seiberg-Witten equations again (cf. [Le2]), |∇ k FA+k |2k ≤
1 |φk |2k |∇ Ak φk |2k , 2
(5.9)
where ∇ Ak is the connection on (Sc) induced by the Levi-Civita connection. Hence 1 ˘ |∇ k FA+k |2k dvk ≤ | R(g(t ))| |∇ Ak φk |2k dvk −→ 0, k 2 M M when k −→ ∞.
20
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Regard FA+k as self-dual 2-forms of gk on U j,r = Bg∞ (x j,∞ , r )\ i Bg∞ (qi, j , r −1 ), ∗ where gk = F j,k,r +1 gk , and qi, j are the orbifold points of N j . Since |FA+k |2k =
1 1 ˘ 2 |φk |4k ≤ R(g k ) ≤ C, 8 8
(5.10)
where C is a constant independent of k, FA+k ∈ L 1,2 (gk ), and FA+k L 1,2 (g ) ≤ C , k
where C
is a constant independent of k. Note that · L 1,2 (g∞ ) ≤ 2 · L 1,2 (g ) for k 1 k
C 1,α since gk −→
g∞ on U j,r . Thus, by passing to a subsequence, a self-dual 2-form with respect to g∞ .
L 1,2 FA+k −→
j ∈ L 1,2 (g∞ ),
Lemma 5.3. For any j, j is a smooth self-dual 2-form on U j,r \∂U j,r such that ∇ ∞ j ≡ 0, and | j |∞ ≡ cont. = 0, where ∇ ∞ is the connection induced by the √ Levi-Civita connection of g∞ . Hence, g∞ is a Kähler metric with Kähler form 2 | jj | on U j,r . Proof. By Lemma 5.2 ∞ 2 0≤ |∇ j |∞ dv∞ = lim
k−→∞ U j,r
U j,r
|∇
∞
FA+k |2∞ dv∞ ≤ 2
lim
k−→∞ M
|∇ k FA+k |2k dvk = 0.
It is easy to see that j is a weak solution of the elliptic equation ∇ ∞ j = 0 on U j,r . By elliptic equation theory, j is a smooth self-dual 2-form on U j,r \∂U j,r , ∇ ∞ j ≡ 0, and | j |∞ ≡ cont. Now we claim that, for any j and r 1, U j,r | j |2∞ dv∞ = 0. If not, there exist js , s = 1, . . . , m 0 , m 0 ≤ m, such that U j ,r | js |2∞ dv∞ ≡ 0. By Lemma 3.1, s
˘ k ) = λ M V − 21 , which is the scalar curvature of g∞ , R ∞ = lim R(gk ) = lim R(g k−→∞
k−→∞
i.e. R ∞ = R(g∞ ). Note that, by (5.10) and Lemma 3.7, | j |2∞ dv∞ = lim
k−→∞ U j,r
U j,r
|FA+k |2k dvk
1 ˘ k )2 Volg (Uj,r ) lim R(g k 8 k−→∞ 1 2 = R ∞ Volg∞ (Uj,r ), 8
1 ˘ k )2 Volgk (M\ lim R(g |FA+k |2k dvk | ≤ Fk,j,r (Uj,r )) 8 k−→∞ ≤
lim |
k−→∞
M
|FA+k |2k dvk −
m j=1 U j,r
j
≤
1 2 C R∞ 8
m
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r ),
j=1
and, by Lemma 3.1, 2 2 lim | (R(gk ) − R ∞ )dvk | ≤ 24 lim (|R(gk ) − R(gk )| + |R ∞ k−→∞
M
k−→∞ M
−R(gk )|)dvk = 0,
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
21
where C is a constant independent of k. Hence, we obtain 2
R∞
Volg∞ (Uj,r ) ≥
j= j1 ,..., jm 0
m j=1 U j,r
8| j |2∞ dv∞ = lim
k−→∞
≥ lim
k−→∞ M
m
2
8|FA+k |2k dvk − C R ∞
j=1 U j,r
m
8|FA+k |2k dvk
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r )
j=1 2
≥ 32π 2 c12 (c)[M] − C R ∞
m
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r ).
j=1
The last inequality is obtained by (5.7). Thus, by (5.1), 2
R∞
2
j= j1 ,..., jm 0
Volg∞ (Uj,r ) ≥ 32π 2 (2χ (M) + 3τ (M)) − CR∞
m
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r ).
j=1
By the Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula and the Hirzebruch signature theorem, 1 1 1 2χ (M)+3τ (M) ≥ 2 ( R(gk )2 + 2|W + (gk )|2k )dvk − 2 |Ricº(gk )|2 dvk . 4π Uk,r 24 8π M L 2, p
By Lemma 3.1, and the fact that gk −→ g∞ on U j,r , we obtain that 2 R∞
m Volg∞ (Uj,r ) ≥ 8
j= j1 ,..., jm 0
2
R ( ∞ + 2|W + (g∞ )|2∞ )dv∞ U j,r 24
j=1 2
−C R ∞
m
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r ).
j=1
Note that, on any U j,r , j = j1 , . . . , jm 0 , ∇ ∞ j ≡ 0, | j |∞ ≡ cont. = 0, and j √ is a self-dual 2-form. Thus g∞ is a Kähler metric with Kähler form 2 | jj | on U j,r , 2
j = j1 , . . . , jm 0 . It is well known that R ∞ = 24|W + (g∞ )|2∞ for Kähler metrics (cf. [B]). Thus 2
R∞
j= j1 ,..., jm 0
2
Volg∞ (Uj,r ) ≥ R ∞
j= j1 ,..., jm 0
+
js = j1 ,..., jm 0 2
≥ R∞ +
1 3
2
Volg∞ (Uj,r ) − CR∞
m
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r )
j=1
2
R 8 ( ∞ + 2|W + (g∞ )|2∞ )dv∞ U j,r 24
j= j1 ,..., jm 0
js = j1 ,..., jm 0
2
Volg∞ (Uj,r ) − CR∞
m j=1
2
R ∞ Volg∞ (Ujs ,r ).
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r )
22
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Note that, for r 1, 2
1 3C R ∞
m
Volg∞ (Nj \Uj, 2r ) ≥
j=1
2
js = j1 ,..., jm 0
R ∞ Volg∞ (Ujs ,r ).
A contradiction. Thus, for all j, U j,r | j |2∞ dv∞ = 0, and ∇ ∞ j ≡ 0, | j |∞ ≡ cont. = 0. Thus we obtain the conclusion. Proof of Theorem 5.1. First, assume that diam g(tk ) (M) −→ ∞, when k −→ ∞. By Proposition 3.2 and Proposition 4.1, there exists a m ∈ N, and a sequence of points {x j,k ∈ M}, k ∈ N, j = 1, . . . , m, satisfying that, by passing to a subsequence, (M, g(tk + t), x1,k , . . . , xm,k ), t ∈ [0, ∞), converges to {(N1 , g∞ , x1,∞ ), . . . , (Nm , g∞ , xm,∞ )} in the m-pointed Gromov-Hausdorff sense, when k −→ ∞, where (N j , g∞ ) j = 1, . . . , m are complete Einstein 4-orbifolds with finite isolated orbifold points {qi }. The scalar curvature of g∞ is R ∞ = lim λ M (g(t)), and t−→∞
V = Volg0 (M) =
m
Volg∞ (N j ).
j=1
By Lemma 5.2, g∞ is a Kähler-Einstein metric in the non-singular part of
m
Nj.
j=1
Then by the same arguments as in Sect. 4 of [Ti], g∞ is actually a Kähler-Einstein m N j , {g(tk + t)}, t ∈ [0, ∞), orbifold metric. Furthermore, in the non-singular part of j=1
C ∞ -converges to g∞ by Proposition 4.1. If diam gk (M) < C for a constant C independent of k, we can also obtain the conclusion by the similar, but much easier, arguments as above. Theorem 5.4. Let (M, c) be a smooth compact closed oriented 4-manifold with a Spinc structure c. Assume that the first Chern class c1 (c) of c is a monopole class of M satisfying c12 (c)[M] = 2χ (M) + 3τ (M) > 0, and χ (M) = 3τ (M). If M admits a solution g(t), t ∈ [0, ∞) to (1.3) with |R(g(t))| ≤ 12, then lim λ M (g(t)) = − 32π 2 c12 (c)[M]. t−→∞
Furthermore, if |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3, the Kähler-Einstein metric g∞ in Theorem 5.1 is a complex hyperbolic metric. Proof. Let V = V ol g(t) (M). By the Chern-Gauss-Bonnet formula and the Hirzebruch signature theorem, 1 1 2χ (M) − 3τ (M) ≥ ( R(g(t))2 + 2|W − (g(t))|2 4π 2 M 24 1 − |Ricº(g(t))|2 )dvg(t) , (5.11) 2 where W − is the anti-self-dual Weyl tensor. Note that 2 R(g(t))2 dvg(t) ≥ R(g(t))2 V −→ R ∞ V = lim λ M (g(t))2 , M
t−→∞
(5.12)
Maximum Solutions of Normalized Ricci Flow on 4-Manifolds
23
when t −→ ∞, by Schwarz inequality and Lemma 3.1. By (5.11), (5.12), Lemma 3.1 and Theorem 1.1 in [FZ], 1 1 |W − (g(t))|2 dvg(t) + lim λ M (g(t))2 2χ (M) − 3τ (M) ≥ lim inf 2 t−→∞ 2π 96π 2 t−→∞ M 1 1 ≥ lim inf |W − (g(t))|2 dvg(t) + c12 (c)[M] t−→∞ 2π 2 M 3 1 1 = lim inf |W − (g(t))|2 dvg(t) + (2χ (M) + 3τ (M)). t−→∞ 2π 2 M 3 Since χ (M) = 3τ (M), we obtain
lim λ M (g(t)) = − 32π 2 c12 (c)[M],
t−→∞
and lim inf t−→∞
1 2π 2
|W − (g(t))|2 dvg(t) = 0. M
Now, assume that |Ric(g(t))| ≤ 3. Let tk , N j , gk , and g∞ be the same as above. For any j and compact subset U of the regular part of N j , − 2 0≤ |W (g∞ )|∞ dv∞ ≤ lim inf |W − (g(tk ))|2k dvk = 0, U
k−→∞
M
L 2, p
since g(tk ) −→ g∞ on U . Hence g∞ is a Kähler-Einstein metric with W − (g∞ ) ≡ 0. This implies that g∞ is a complex hyperbolic metric (cf. [Le1]). The desired result follows. Proof of Theorem 1.1 and Theorem 1.2. By the work of Taubes [Ta], if (M, ω) is a compact symplectic manifold with b2+ (M) > 1, the spinc -structure induced by ω is a monopole class. Moreover, since in this situation c12 (c)[M] = 2χ (M) + 3τ (M), Theorem 1.1 (resp. Theorem 1.2) is an obvious consequence of Theorem 5.1 (resp. Theorem 5.4). References [An1] [An2] [An3] [An4] [An5] [An6] [AIL] [B] [BD]
Anderson, M.T.: Ricci curvature bounds and einstein metrics on compact manifolds. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 2, 455–490 (1989) Anderson, M.T.: The l 2 structure of moduli spaces of einstein metrics on 4-manifolds. G.A.F.A. 2(1), 29–89 (1992) Anderson, M.T.: Convergence and rigidity of manifolds under ricci curvature bounds. Invent. Math. 102, 429–445 (1990) Anderson, M.T.: Degeneration of metrics with bounded curvature and applications to critical metrics of Riemannian functionals. Proc. Symp. Pure Math. 54, 53–79 (1993) Anderson, M.T.: Canonical metrics on 3-manifolds and 4-manifolds. Asian J. Math. 10, 127–163 (2006) Anderson, M.T.: Extrema of curvature functionals on the space of metrics on 3-manifolds. Calc. Var. and PDE 5, 199–269 (1997) Akutagawa, K., Ishida, M., LeBrun, C.: Perelman’s invariant, Ricci flow, and the Yamabe invariants of smooth manifolds. Arch. Math. 88(1), 71–76 (2006) Besse, A.L.: Einstein manifolds. Ergebnisse der Math. Berlin-New York:Springer-Verlag, 1987 Bär, C., Dahl, M.: Small eigenvalues of the conformal Laplacian. Geom. Funct. Anal. 13, 483–508 (2003)
24
[CC]
F. Fang, Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang
Cheeger, J., Colding, T.H.: On the structure of space with Ricci curvature bounded below I. J. Diff. Geom. 45, 406–480 (1997) [CG] Cheeger, J., Gromov, M.: Collapsing Riemannian Manifolds while keeping their curvature bounded I. J. Diff. Geom. 23, 309–364 (1986) [Cr] Croke, C.: Some isoperimetric inequalities and eigenvalue estimates. Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 13(4), 419–435 (1980) [CT] Cheeger, J., Tian, G.: Curvature and injectivity radius estimates for Einstein 4-manifolds. J. Amer. Math. Soci. 19, 487–525 (2006) [FZ] Fang, F., Zhang, Y.G.: Perelman’s λ-functional and the Seiberg-Witten equations. Front. Math. China, 2(2), 191–210 (2007) [FZZ] Fang, F., Zhang, Y.G., Zhang, Z.L.: Non-singular solutions to the normalized Ricci flow equation. Math. Ann. 340(3), 647–674 (2008) [H1] Hamilton, R.: Three-manifolds with positive Ricci curvature. J. Diff. Geom. 17, 255–306 (1982) [H2] Hamilton, R.: A compactness property for solutions of the Ricci flow. Amer. J. Math. 117, 545– 574 (1995) [K] Kronheimer, P.B.: Minimal genus in S 1 × M 3 . Invent. Math. 135(1), 45–61 (1999) [KL] Kleiner, B., Lott, J.: Notes on Perelman’s papers. http://arxiv.org/list/math.DG/0605667, 2006 [Kot] Kotschick, D.: Monopole classes and Perelman’s invariant of four-manifolds. http://arxiv.org/list/ math.DG/0608504, 2006 [Le1] LeBrun, C.: Einstein metrics and Mostow rigidity. Math. Res. Lett. 2, 1–8 (1995) [Le2] LeBrun, C.: Four-Dimensional Einstein Manifolds and Beyond. In: Surveys in Differential Geometry, Vol. VI: Essays on Einstein Manifolds, Boston:International Press, 1999, pp. 247–285 [Le3] LeBrun, C.: Ricci curvature, minimal volumes, and Seiberg-Witten theory. Invent. Math. 145, 279– 316 (2001) [Le4] LeBrun, C.: Kodaira dimension and the Yamabe probblem. Comm. Anal.Geom. 7, 133–156 (1999) [N] Nakajima, H.: Self-duality of ale Ricci-flat 4-manifolds and positive mass theorem. Adv. Stud. Pure Math. 18-I, 385–395 (1990) [Pe1] Perelman, G.: The entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications. http://arxiv.org/ list/math:/0211159, 2002 [Pe2] Perelman, G.: Ricci flow with surgery on three-manifolds. http://arxiv.org/list/math:DG/0303109v1, 2003 [Se] Sesum, N.: Convergence of a Kähler-Ricci flow. http://arxiv.org/list/math.DG/0402238v1, 2004 [STW] Sesum, N., Tian, G., Wang, X.D.: Notes on Perelman’s paper on the entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications. Preprint [Ta] Taubes, C.H.: More constraints on symplectic forms from Seiberg-Witten invariants. Math. Res. Lett. 2, 9–13 (1995) [Ti] Tian, G.: On Calabi’s conjecture for complex surface with positive first Chern class. Invent. Math. 101, 101–172 (1990) [W] Witten, E.: Monopoles and four-manifolds. Math. Res. Lett. 1, 809–822 (1994) [Y] Ye, R.: Ricci flow, Einstein metrics and space forms. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 338(2), 871–896 (1993) Communicated by P. Sarnak
Commun. Math. Phys. 283, 25–92 (2008) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0555-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras Liang Kong1,2,3 1 Max-Planck-Institute for Mathematics in the Sciences, Inselstrasse 22, D-04103 Leipzig, Germany 2 Institut Des Hautes Études Scientifiques, Le Bois-Marie, 35, Route De Chartres,
F-91440 Bures-sur-Yvette, France
3 Max-Planck-Institute for Mathematics, Vivatsgasse 7, D-23111 Bonn, Germany.
E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 10 April 2007 / Accepted: 1 April 2008 Published online: 24 July 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: Let V be a vertex operator algebra satisfying certain reductivity and finiteness conditions such that CV , the category of V -modules, is a modular tensor category. We study open-closed field algebras over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms for both open and closed sectors. We show that they give algebras over a certain C-extension of the so-called Swiss-cheese partial dioperad, and we can obtain Ishibashi states easily in such algebras. The Cardy condition can be formulated as an additional condition on such open-closed field algebras in terms of the action of the modular transformation S : τ → − τ1 on the space of intertwining operators of V . We then derive a graphical representation of S in the modular tensor category CV . This result enables us to give a categorical formulation of the Cardy condition and the modular invariance condition for 1-point correlation functions on the torus. Then we incorporate these two conditions and the axioms of the open-closed field algebra over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms into a tensor-categorical notion called the Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra. In the end, we give a categorical construction of the Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra in the Cardy case. Contents 0. 1.
2.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Partial Dioperads . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1 Partial dioperads . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 Conformal full field algebras . . . . 1.3 Open-string vertex operator algebras Swiss-Cheese Partial Dioperad . . . . . 2.1 2-colored (partial) dioperads . . . . 2.2 Swiss-cheese partial dioperads . . . 2.3 Open-closed field algebras over V . 2.4 Ishibashi states . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
26 30 31 35 37 38 38 41 43 48
26
L. Kong
3.
Cardy Condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 The first version . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 The second version . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Modular Tensor Categories . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Graphical representation of S : τ → − τ1 5. Categorical Formulations and Constructions 5.1 Modular invariant CV L ⊗V R -algebras . . 5.2 Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebras . . . . . . . . 5.3 Constructions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Proof of Lemma 4.30 . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
51 51 56 64 65 69 76 76 80 84 88
0. Introduction This work is a continuation of the works [HKo1-HKo3,Ko1,Ko2] and a part of an openstring extension of a program on the closed conformal field theory via the theory of vertex operator algebra. This program was initiated by I. Frenkel and largely developed by Huang [H1]-[H11]. Zhu’s work [Z] is also very influential in this development. Segal defined the (closed) conformal field theory [Se1] as a projective monoidal functor from the category of finite ordered sets with morphisms being the conformal equivalent classes of Riemann surfaces with parametrized boundaries to the category of locally convex complete topological vector spaces. This definition is very difficult to work with directly. Taking advantage of the theory of vertex operator algebra, Huang suggested to first construct all necessary structures on a dense subspace of the relevant complete topological vector space [H3], then complete it properly later [H5,H6]. This idea guided us in all our previous works [HKo1-HKo3,Ko1,Ko2], in particular in our formulation of the notion of algebra over the Swiss-cheese partial operad which catches only some genus-zero information of the whole structure on the dense subspace. This seemingly temporary structure on the dense subspace does not necessarily follow from that on the complete topological vector space, thus has its own independent values and is worthwhile to be formulated properly and extended to a theory of all genus. We will call such a theory on the dense subspace a (closed) partial conformal field theory. More precisely, a partial conformal field theory is a projective monoidal functor F : RS → GV between two partial categories RS, GV in which the compositions of morphisms are not always well-defined. RS is the category of finite ordered sets, and MorRS (S1 , S2 ) for any pair of such sets S1 , S2 is the set of the conformal equivalent classes of closed Riemann surfaces with |S1 | positively oriented punctures and local coordinates and |S2 | negatively oriented punctures and local coordinates [H3], and the compositions of morphisms in RS are given by the sewing operations on oppositely oriented punctures ([H3]), where the sewing operations are only partially defined. GV is the category of graded vector spaces with finite dimensional homogeneous spaces and a weak topology induced from the restricted dual spaces. For any pair of A, B ∈ Ob(GV), MorGV (A, B) is the set of continuous linear maps from A to B := n∈G B B(n) , where g
the abelian group G B gives the grading on B. For any pair of morphisms A − → B f
and B − → C in GV, using the projector Pn : B → B(n) , we define f ◦ g(u) := n∈G B f (Pn g(u)), ∀u ∈ A, and f ◦ g is well-defined only when the sum is absolutely convergent for all u ∈ A. We remark that by replacing the surfaces with parametrized boundaries in Segal’s definition by the surfaces with oriented punctures and local coor-
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
27
dinates in RS we have enlarged the morphism sets. Thus a Segal’s functor may not be extendable to a functor on RS. The above definition can be easily extended to include open strings by adding Riemann surfaces with (unparametrized!) boundaries and both oriented interior punctures and punctures on the boundaries to RS. We will call this open-string extended theory an open-closed partial conformal field theory. We denote the graded vector spaces associated to interior punctures (closed strings at infinity) and boundary punctures (open strings at infinity) by Vcl and Vop respectively. The sets of all genus-zero closed surfaces (spheres) with an arbitrary number of positively and negatively oriented punctures form a structure of sphere partial dioperad K (see the definition in Sect. 1.1). It includes as a substructure the sphere partial operad [H3], which only includes spheres with a single negatively oriented puncture. The sphere partial dioperad allows all sewing operations as long as the surfaces after sewing are still genus-zero. Hence to construct genus-zero partial conformal field theory amounts to construct projective K-algebras or algebras over a certain extension of K. In [HKo2], we introduced the notion of a conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R equipped with a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form, where V L and V R are two vertex operator algebras of central charge c L and c R respectively and satisfy certain finiteness and reductivity conditions. Theorem 2.7 in [Ko1] can be reformulated as follows: a conformal full field algebra Vcl over V L ⊗ V R equipped with a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form ˜ cL ⊗K ˜ c R , which is a partial dioperad extension canonically gives on Vcl an algebra over K of K. The sets of all genus-zero surfaces with one (unparametrized!) boundary component (disks) and an arbitrary number of oriented boundary punctures form the so-called disk partial dioperad denoted by D (see the definition in Sect. 1.1). F restricted on D induces a structure of algebra over a certain extension of D on Vop . In [HKo1], Huang and I introduced the notion of an open-string vertex operator algebra. We will show in Sect. 1.3 that an open-string vertex operator algebra of central charge c equipped with a ˜ c , which is a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form canonically gives an algebra over D partial dioperad extension of D. The sets of all genus-zero surfaces with only one (unparametrized!) boundary component and arbitrary number of oriented interior punctures and boundary punctures form the so-called Swiss-Cheese partial dioperad S (see the definition in Sect. 2.2). A typical elements in S is depicted in Fig. 1, where boundary punctures are drawn as an infinitely long strip (or an open string) and interior punctures are drawn as an infinitely long tube (or a closed string). Let V be a vertex operator algebra of central charge c satisfying the conditions in Theorem 0.1. We will show in Sect. 2.3 that an open-closed field algebra over V , which contains an open-string vertex operator algebra Vop and a conformal full field algebra Vcl , satisfying a V -invariant boundary condition [Ko2] and equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms on both Vop and Vcl , canonically gives an algebra over S˜ c , which is an extension of S. Note that all surfaces of any genus with an arbitrary number of boundary components, interior punctures and boundary punctures can be obtained by applying sewing operations to elements in S. Therefore, except for some compatibility conditions coming from different decompositions of the same surfaces with higher genus, an algebra over S˜ c if extendable uniquely determine the entire theory of all genus. In particular, the famous Ishibashi states [I] can be obtained in an open-closed field algebra equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms. An Ishibashi state is a coherent state ψ
28
L. Kong
Fig. 1. A typical element in the Swiss-Cheese partial dioperad S
in Vcl such that (L L (n) − L R (−n))ψ = 0, ∀n ∈ Z. In physics, Ishibashi states are obtained by solving the above equation. In Sect. 2.4, we show how to obtain Ishibashi states constructively and geometrically from vacuum-like states in Vop . Other surfaces which are not included in S only provide additional compatibility conditions. In 2-d topological field theories, only three additional compatibility conditions are needed to ensure the consistency of a theory of all genus [La,Mo1,Se2,MSeg,AN, LP]. The first compatibility condition says that both Vop and Vcl are finite dimensional. This guarantees the convergence of all higher genus correlation functions. The second condition is the modular invariance condition for 1-point correlation functions on torus. It is due to two different decompositions of the same torus as depicted in Fig. 2. This condition is automatically satisfied in 2-d topological field theories, but nontrivial in conformal field theories. The third condition is the famous Cardy condition which is again due to two different decompositions of a single surface as shown in Fig. 3.
Fig. 2. Modular invariance condition for 1-pt correlation functions on torus
= Fig. 3. Cardy condition
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
29
Now we turn to the compatibility conditions in conformal field theory. In this case, both Vcl and Vop in any nontrivial theory are infinite dimensional. We need to require the convergence of all correlation functions of all genus. This is a highly nontrivial condition and not easy to check for examples. So far the only known convergence results are in genus-zero [H7] and genus-one theories [Z,DLM,Mi1,Mi2,H9]. We recall a theorem by Huang. Theorem 0.1 ([H10,H11]). If (V, Y, 1, ω) is a simple vertex operator algebra V satisfying the following conditions: 1. V is C2 -cofinite; 2. Vn = 0 for n < 0, V(0) = C1, V is isomorphic to V as V -module; 3. all N-gradable weak V -modules are completely reducible, then the direct sum of all inequivalent irreducible V -modules has a natural structure of intertwining operator algebra [H4], and the category CV of V -modules has a structure of vertex tensor category [HL1]-[HL4,H2] and modular tensor category [RT,T]. For the intertwining operator algebra given in Theorem 0.1, Huang also proved in [H7,H9] that the products of intertwining operators and their q-traces have a certain nice convergence and analytic extension properties. These properties are sufficient for the construction of genus-zero and genus-one correlation functions in closed partial conformal field theory [HKo2,HKo3]. Since the modular tensor category CV supports an action of mapping class groups of all genus, it is reasonable to believe that the above conditions on V are also sufficient to guarantee the convergence of correlation functions of all genus. Assumption 0.2. In this work, we fix a vertex operator algebra V with central charge c, which is assumed to satisfy the conditions in Theorem 0.1 without further announcement. Besides the convergence condition and the axioms of projective K-algebra, Sonoda [So] argued on a physical level of rigor that it is sufficient to check the modular invariance condition in Fig. 2 in order to have a consistent partial conformal field theory of all genus. This modular invariance condition was studied in [HKo3]. In the framework of conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R , it was formulated algebraically as a modular invariance property of an intertwining operator of V L ⊗ V R . For an open-closed theory, besides the convergence condition, the axioms of algebra over S˜ c and the modular invariance condition, Lewellen [Le] argued on a physical level of rigor that the only remaining compatibility condition one needs is the Cardy condition. The Cardy condition in an open-closed conformal field theory is more complicated than that in topological theory and has never been fully written down by physicists. In Sect. 3.1, we derive the Cardy condition from the axioms of open-closed partial conformal field theory by writing out two sides of the Cardy condition in Figure 3 explicitly in terms of the ingredients of an open-closed field algebra (see Definition 3.4). Using results in [H9,H10], we can show that the Cardy condition can be reformulated as an invariance condition of the modular transformation S : τ → − τ1 on intertwining operators. There are still more compatibility conditions which were not discussed in [So,Le]. One also need to prove a certain algebraic version of uniformization theorems (see [H1,H3] for the genus-zero case). Such results for genus larger than 0 are still not available. But it seems that no additional assumption on V is needed. They should follow automatically from the properties of the Virasoro algebra and intertwining operators. This uniformization problem and convergence problems are not pursued further in this work.
30
L. Kong
In order to take advantage of some powerful tools, such as the graphic calculus in tensor category, in the study of the modular invariance condition and the Cardy condition, we would like to obtain categorical formulations of these conditions. It requires us to know the action of the modular transformation S in CV . Although the action of S L(2, Z) in a modular tensor category is explicitly known [MSei3,V,Ly,Ki,BK2], its relation to the modular transformation of the q-trace of the products of intertwining operators of V is not completely clear. This relation was first suggested by I. Frenkel and studied by Moore and Seiberg in [MSei3] but only on a physical level of rigor. Using Huang’s results on the modular tensor category [H10,H11], we derive a graphical representation of S in CV . This result enables us to give categorical formulations of the modular invariance condition and the Cardy condition. We incorporate them with the categorical formulation of open-closed field algebra over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms into a tensor-categorical notion called the Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra. As we discussed in previous paragraphs, it is reasonable to believe that open-closed partial conformal field theories of all genus satisfying the V -invariant boundary condition [Ko2] are classified by Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebras. However, to construct the high-genus theories explicitly is still a hard open problem which is not pursued in this work. In the end, we give an explicit construction of Cardy the CV |CV ⊗V -algebra in the so-called Cardy case in the physics literature (see for example [FFRS]). Note that this work is somewhat complementary to the works of Fjelstad, Fuchs, Runkel, Schweigert [FS,FRS1-FRS4,FjFRS1,FjFRS2]. We will leave a detailed study of the relationship between these two approaches to [KR]. The layout of this work is as follows: in Sect. 1, we introduce the notion of a sphere partial dioperad and disk partial dioperad and study algebras over them; in Sect. 2, we introduce the notions of the Swiss-cheese partial dioperad S and its C-extension S˜ c , and show that an open-closed conformal field algebra over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms canonically gives an algebra over S˜ c , and we also construct Ishibashi states in such algebras; in Sect. 3, we give two formulations of the Cardy condition; in Sect. 4, we derive a graphic representation of the modular transformation S; in Sect. 5, we give the categorical formulations of the nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms, the modular invariance condition and the Cardy condition. Then we introduce the notion of the Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra and give a construction. Convention of notations: N, Z, Z+ , R, R+ , C denote the set of natural numbers, integers, positive integers, real numbers, positive real numbers, complex numbers, respecˆ C ˆ and H ˆ be the tively. Let H = {z ∈ C|Imz > 0} and H = {z ∈ C|Imz < 0}. Let R, one point compactification of real line, complex plane and up-half plane (including the R-boundary) respectively. Let R+ and C× be the multiplication groups of positive real and nonzero complex numbers respectively. The ground field is always chosen to be C. Throughout this work, we choose a branch cut for logarithm as follows: log z = log |z| + iArg z,
0 ≤ Arg z < 2π.
(0.1)
We define power functions of two different types of complex variables as follows: z s := es log z ,
z¯ s := es log z ,
∀s ∈ R.
(0.2)
1. Partial Dioperads In Sect. 1.1, we recall the definition of (partial) dioperad and algebra over it, and intro˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ cR , duce sphere partial dioperad K, disk partial dioperad D and their extensions K
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
31
˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ c as examples. In Sect. 1.2, we discuss an algebra over K ˜ c R from a conformal D L R full field algebra over V ⊗ V . In Sect. 1.3, we discuss an algebra over D˜ c from an open-string vertex operator algebra. 1.1. Partial dioperads. Let us first recall the definition of dioperad given by Gan [G]. Let Sn be the automorphism group of the set {1, . . . , n} for n ∈ Z+ . Let m = m 1 +· · ·+m n be an ordered partition and σ ∈ Sn . The block permutation σ(m 1 ,...,m n ) ∈ Sm is the permutation which permutes n intervals of lengths m 1 , . . . , m n in the same way as σ permutes 1, . . . , n. Let σi ∈ Sm i , i = 1, . . . , k. We view the element (σ1 , . . . , σk ) ∈ Sm 1 ×· · ·×Sm k naturally as an element in Sm by the canonical embedding Sm 1 × · · · × Sm k → Sm . For ˆ j) = j any σ ∈ Sn and 1 ≤ i ≤ n, we define a map iˆ : {1, . . . , n −1} → {1, . . . , n} by i( ˆ j) = j + 1 if j ≥ i and an element i(σ ˆ ) ∈ Sn−1 by if j < i and i( −1 (i)( j). ˆ )( j) := iˆ−1 ◦ σ ◦ σ i(σ
Definition 1.1. A dioperad consists of a family of sets {P(m, n)}m,n∈N with an action of Sm × Sn on P(m, n) for each pair of m, n ∈ Z+ , a distinguished element IP ∈ P(1, 1) and substitution maps γ(i 1 ,...,i n )
P(m, n) × P(k1 , l1 ) × · · · × P(kn , ln ) −−−−−→ P(m − n + k1 · · · + kn , l1 + · · · + ln ) (P, P1 , . . . , Pn ) → γ(i1 ,...,in ) (P; P1 , . . . , Pn ) (1.1) for m, n, l1 , . . . , ln ∈ N, k1 , . . . , kn ∈ Z+ and 1 ≤ i j ≤ k j , j = 1, . . . , n, satisfying the following axioms: 1. Unit properties: For P ∈ P(m, n), (a) left unit property: γ(i) (IP ; P) = P for 1 ≤ i ≤ m, (b) right unit property: γ(1,...,1) (P; IP , . . . , IP ) = P. 2. Associativity: for P ∈ P(m, n), Q i ∈ P(ki , li ), i = 1, . . . , n, R j ∈ P(s j , t j ), j = 1, . . . , l = l1 + · · · + ln , we have γ(q1 ,...,ql ) γ( p1 ,..., pn ) (P; Q 1 , . . . , Q n ); R1 , . . . , Rl = γ( p1 ,..., pn ) (P; P1 , . . . , Pn ) (1.2) where Pi = γ(ql1 +···+li−1 +1 ,...,ql1 +···+li ) (Q i ; Rl1 +···+li−1 +1 , . . . , Rl1 +···+li ) for i = 1, . . . , n. 3. Permutation property: For P ∈ P(m, n), Q i ∈ P(ki , li ), i = 1, . . . , n, (σ, τ ) ∈ Sm × Sn , (σi , τi ) ∈ Ski × Sli , i = 1, . . . , n, γ(i1 ,...,in ) ((σ, τ )(P); Q 1 , . . . , Q n ) = ((σ, τ(k1 −1,...,kn −1) ), τ(l1 ,...,ln ) )γ(iτ (1) ,...,iτ (n) ) (P; Q τ (1) , . . . , Q τ (n) ), γ(i1 ,...,in ) (P; (σ1 , τ1 )(Q 1 ), . . . , (σn , τn )(Q n )) = ((id, iˆ1 (σ1 ), . . . , iˆn (σn )), (τ1 , . . . , τn ))γ −1 (P; Q 1 , . . . , Q n ). −1 (σ1 (i 1 ),...,σn (i n ))
We denote such a dioperad as (P, γP , IP ) or simply P. Remark 1.2. We define compositions i ◦ j as follows: P i ◦ j Q := γ(1,...,1, j,1,...1) (P; IP , . . . , IP , Q, IP , . . . , IP ). It is easy to see that γ(i1 ,...,in ) can be reobtained from i ◦ j . In [G], the definition of dioperad is given in terms of i ◦ j instead of γ(i1 ,...,in ) .
32
L. Kong
Definition 1.3. A partial dioperad has a similar definition as that of dioperad except the map γ(i1 ,...,in ) or i ◦ j is only partially defined and the same associativity holds whenever both sides of (1.2) exist. A (partial) nonassociative dioperad consists of the same data as those of a (partial) dioperad satisfying all the axioms of a (partial) dioperad except the associativity. The notion of homomorphism and isomorphism of a (partial pseudo-) dioperad are naturally defined. Remark 1.4. In the case of a partial dioperad, the definition using γ(i1 ,...,in ) or i ◦ j may have subtle differences in the domains on which γ(i1 ,...,in ) or i ◦ j is defined (see Appendix C in [H2] for more details). These differences have no effect on those algebras over partial dioperads considered in this work. So we will simply ignore these differences. Remark 1.5. Notice that a (partial nonassociative) dioperad {P(m, n)}m,n∈N naturally contains a (partial nonassociative) operad {P(1, n)}n∈N as a substructure. Definition 1.6. A subset G of P(1, 1) is called a rescaling group of P if the following conditions are satisfied: 1. For any g, g1 , . . . , gn ∈ G, Q ∈ P(m, n), γ(i) (g; Q) and γ(1,...,1) (Q; g1 , . . . , gn ) are always well-defined for 1 ≤ i ≤ m. 2. IP ∈ G and G together with the identity element IP and multiplication map γ(1) : G × G → G is a group. Definition 1.7. A G-rescalable partial dioperad is a partial dioperad P such that for any P ∈ P(m, exist gi ∈ G, i = 1, . . . , n such n), Q i ∈ P(ki , li ), i = 1, . . . , n there that γ(i1 ,...,in ) P; γ(i1 ) (g1 ; Q 1 ), . . . , γ(in ) (gn ; Q n ) is well-defined. The first example of partial dioperad in which we are interested in this work comes from K = {K(n − , n + )}n − ,n + ∈N [Ko2], a natural extension of the sphere partial operad K [H3]. More precisely, K(n − , n + ) is the set of the conformal equivalent classes of a sphere with n − (n + ) ordered negatively (positively) oriented punctures and local coordinate map around each puncture. In particular, K(0, 0) is an one-element set consisting of the conformal equivalent class of a sphere with no additional structure. We simply ˆ We use denote this element as C. (−1)
Q = ( (z −1 ; a0
(−n − )
, A(−1) ), . . . , (z −n − ; a0
, A(−n − ) ) |
(z 1 ; a0(1) , A(1) ) . . . (z n + ; a0(n + ) , A(n + ) ) )K ,
(1.3)
ˆ a (i) ∈ C× , A(i) ∈ C∞ for i = −n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + , to denote a where z i ∈ C, 0 ˆ with positively (negatively) oriented punctures at z i ∈ C ˆ for i = 1, . . . , n + sphere C (i = −1, . . . , −n − ), and with local coordinate map f i around each puncture z i given by: ∞ (i) (i) x ddx A j x j+1 ddx j=1 (a0 ) x if z i ∈ C, (1.4) f i (w) = e =e
∞
(i) j+1 d j=1 A j x dx
(i) d (a0 )x d x x
x=w−z i x= −1 w
if z i = ∞.
(1.5)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
33
We introduce a useful notation Q¯ defined as follows: (−n ) (−1) Q¯ = ( (¯z −1 ; a0 , A(−1) ), . . . , (¯z −n − ; a0 − , A(−n − ) )| (1)
(n + )
(¯z 1 ; a0 , A(1) ) . . . (¯z n + ; a0
, A(n + ) ) )K ,
(1.6)
where the “overline” represents complex conjugations. We denote the set of all such Q as TK (n − , n + ). Let TK := {TK (n − , n + )}n − ,n + ∈N . There is an action of S L(2, C) on TK (n − , n + ) as Mobius transformations. It is clear that K(n − , n + ) = TK (n − , n + )/S L(2, C).
(1.7)
We denote the quotient map TK → K as πK . The identity IK ∈ K(1, 1) is given by (1.8) IK = πK ( (∞, 1, 0)|(0, 1, 0) ), ∞ where 0 = (0, 0, . . . ) ∈ n=1 C. The composition i ◦ j is provided by the sewing operation i ∞− j [H3]. In particular, for n 1 , m 2 ≥ 1, P ∈ K(m 1 , n 1 ) and Q ∈ K(m 2 , n 2 ), Pi ∞− j Q is the sphere with punctures obtained by sewing the i th positively oriented puncture of P with the j th negatively oriented puncture of Q. The Sn − × Sn + -action on K(n − , n + ) (or T (n − , n + )) is the natural one. Moreover, the set {( (∞, 1, 0)|(0, a, 0) )|a ∈ C× }
(1.9)
together with multiplication 1 ∞1 is a group which can be canonically identified with group C× . It is clear that K is a C× -rescalable partial dioperad. We call it sphere partial dioperad. ˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ c R for c, c L , c R ∈ C, are trivial line The C-extensions of K, such as Kc and K × bundles over K with natural C -rescalable partial dioperad structures (see Sect. 6.8 in ˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ c R as ψK . [H2]). Moreover, we denote the canonical section K → K The next example of partial dioperad is D = {D(n − , n + )}n − ,n + ∈N , which is an extension of the partial operad of a disk with strips ϒ introduced [HKo1]. More precisely, D(n − , n + ) is the set of conformal equivalent classes of disks with ordered puncture on their boundaries and local coordinate map around each puncture. In particular, D(0, 0) is an one-element set consisting of the conformal equivalent class of a disk with no ˆ We use additional structure. We simply denote this element as H. (−n − )
Q = ( (r−n − ; b0
, B (−n − ) ), . . . , (r−1 ; b0(−1) , B (−1) )| (1)
(n + )
(r1 ; b0 , B (1) ) . . . (rn + ; b0
, B (n + ) ) )D ,
(1.10)
(i)
ˆ a ∈ R+ , B (i) ∈ R∞ for i = −n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + , to denote a where ri ∈ R, 0 ˆ with positively (negatively) oriented punctures at ri ∈ R ˆ for i = 1, . . . , n + disk H (i = −1, . . . , −n − ), and with local coordinate map gi around each punctures ri given by: ∞ (i) B j x j+1 ddx (i) x ddx j=1 gi (w) = e (b0 ) x if ri ∈ R, (1.11) =e
∞
(i) j+1 d j=1 B j x dx
(i) d (b0 )x d x x
x=w−ri x= −1 w
if ri = ∞.
(1.12)
34
L. Kong
We denote the set of all such Q as TD (n − , n + ). Let TD := {TD (n − , n + )}n − ,n + ∈N . The automorphism group of H, S L(2, R), naturally acts on TD (n − , n + ). It is clear that D(n − , n + ) = TK (n − , n + )/S L(2, R).
(1.13)
We denote the quotient map as πD . The identity ID ∈ D(1, 1) is given by ID = πD ( (∞, 1, 0)|(0, 1, 0) ).
(1.14)
The composition i ◦ j is provided by the sewing operation i ∞− j [HKo1]. In particular, for n 1 , m 2 ≥ 1, P ∈ D(m − , m + ) and Q ∈ D(n − , n + ), Pi ∞− j Q is the disk with strips obtained by sewing the i th positively oriented puncture of P with the j th negatively oriented puncture of Q. The Sn − × Sn + -action on D(n − , n + ) (or T (n − , n + )) is the natural one. The set {( (∞, 1, 0)|(0, a, 0) )|a ∈ R+ }
(1.15)
together with multiplication 1 ∞1 is a group which can be canonically identified with group R+ . It is clear that D is a R+ -rescalable partial dioperad. We call it the disk partial dioperad. D can be naturally embedded to K as a sub-dioperad. The C-extension Dc of D for c ∈ C is just the restriction of the line bundle Kc on D. Dc is also a R+ -rescalable partial dioperad and a partial sub-dioperad of Kc . We denote the canonical section on D → Dc as ψD . Now we discuss an example of a partial nonassociative dioperad which is important for us. Let U = ⊕n∈J U(n) be a graded vector space and J an index set. We denote the projection U → U(n) as Pn . Now we consider a family of spaces of multi-linear maps EU = {EU (m, n)}m,n∈N , where EU (m, n) := HomC (U ⊗m , U ⊗n ).
(1.16)
( j)
For f ∈ EU (m, n), g j ∈ EU (k j , l j ) and u p j ∈ U , 1 ≤ p j ≤ l j , j = 1, . . . , n, we say that (1)
(n)
(i1 ,...,in ) ( f ; g1 , . . . , gn )(u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u ln ) (1) (1) (n) (n) f Ps1 g1 (u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u l1 ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ Psn gn (u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u ln ) := s1 ,...,sn ∈J
is well-defined if the multiple sum converges absolutely. This gives rise to a partially defined substitution map, for 1 ≤ i j ≤ k j , j = 1, . . . , n, i1 ,...,in : EU (m, n) ⊗ EU (k1 , l1 ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ EU (kn , ln ) → EU (m + k − n, l), where k = k1 + · · · + kn and l = l1 + · · · + ln . In general, the compositions of three substitution maps are not associative. The permutation groups actions on EU are the usual one. Let = { i1 ,...,in }. It is clear that (EU , , idU ) is a partial nonassociative dioperad. We often denote it simply by EU . Definition 1.8. Let (P, γP , IP ) be a partial dioperad. A P-algebra (U, ν) consists of a graded vector space U and a morphism of partial nonassociative dioperad ν : P → EU .
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
35
When U = ⊕n∈J U(n) is a completely reducible module for a group G, J is the set of equivalent classes of irreducible G-modules and U(n) is a direct sum of irreducible G. G-modules of equivalent class n ∈ J , we denote EU by EU Definition 1.9. Let (P, γP , IP ) be a G-rescalable partial dioperad. A G-rescalable G is so that ν| P-algebra (U, ν) is a P-algebra and the morphism ν : P → EU G : G → End U coincides with the given G-module structure on U .
1.2. Conformal full field algebras. Let (V L , YV L , 1 L , ω L ) and (V R , YV R , 1 R , ω R ) be two vertex operator algebras with central charge c L and c R respectively, satisfying the conditions in Theorem 0.1. Let (Vcl , m cl , ιcl ) be a conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R . A bilinear form (·, ·)cl on Vcl is invariant [Ko1] if, for any u, w1 , w2 ∈ Vcl , ¯ 1 )cl (w2 , Y f (u; x, x)w = (Y f (e−x L
L (1)
x −2L
L (0)
⊗ e−x¯ L
R (1)
x¯ −2L
R (0)
u; eπi x −1 , e−πi x¯ −1 )w2 , w1 )cl , (1.17)
or equivalently, (Y f (u; eπi x, e−πi x)w ¯ 2 , w1 )cl = (w2 , Y f (e x L
L (1)
x −2L
L (0)
⊗ e x¯ L
R (1)
x¯ −2L
R (0)
u; x −1 , x¯ −1 )w1 )cl .
(1.18)
We showed in [Ko1] that an invariant bilinear form on Vcl is automatically symmetric. Namely, for u 1 , u 2 ∈ Vcl , we have (u 1 , u 2 )cl = (u 2 , u 1 )cl .
(1.19)
Vcl has a countable basis. We choose it to be {ei }i∈N . Assume that (·, ·)cl is also nondegenerate, we also have the dual basis {ei }i∈N . Then we define a linear map cl : C → Vcl ⊗ Vcl as follows: cl : 1 →
ei ⊗ ei .
(1.20)
i∈N
The correlation functions maps m (n) cl , n ∈ N of Vcl are canonically determined by Y and the identity 1cl := ιcl (1 L ⊗ 1 R ) [Ko2]. For Q ∈ TK (n − , n + ) given in (1.3), we define, for λ ∈ C, νcl (λψK (πK (Q))) (u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u n + ) in the following three cases:
(1.21)
36
L. Kong
1. If z k = ∞ for k = −n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + , (1.21) is given by −L R (0) L (−1) R L (−1) (n +n ) (−1) (−1) λ ei1 , 1cl , m cl − + (e−L + (A )−L + (A ) (a0 )−L (0) a0 i 1 ,...,i n − ∈N
. . . , e−L + (A L
(−n − ) )−L R (A(−n − ) ) +
e−L + (A L
. . . , e−L + (A L
(−n − ) −L L (0) (−n − ) ) a0
(a0
(1) )−L R (A(1) ) +
(n + ) )−L R (A(n + ) ) +
(1)
(a0 )−L
L (0)
(1)
a0
(n + ) −L L (0) (n + ) ) a0
(a0
z −1 , z¯ −1 , . . . , z −n − , z¯ −n − , z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , z n + , z¯ n + )
−L R (0)
−L R (0)
−L R (0)
ein− ,
u1,
u n+ ;
e ⊗ · · · ⊗ ei n − , (1.22) ∞ R j=1 A j L + ( j) for i1
cl
∞ where L +L (A) = A L L ( j) and L +R (A) = ∞ j=1 j + A = (A1 , A2 , . . . ) ∈ j=1 C; 2. If ∃ k ∈ {−n − , . . . , −1} such that z k = ∞ (recall (1.5)), (1.21) is given by the formula obtained from (1.22) by exchanging 1cl in (1.22) with e−L + (A L
(k) )−L R (A(k) ) +
(k)
(a0 )−L
L (0)
(k)
a0
−L R (0)
ei−k ;
(1.23)
3. If ∃ k ∈ {1, . . . , n + } such that z k = ∞ (recall (1.5)), (1.21) is given by the formula obtained from (1.22) by exchanging 1cl in (1.22) with e−L + (A L
(k) )−L R (A(k) ) +
(k)
(a0 )−L
L (0)
(k)
a0
−L R (0)
uk .
(1.24)
The following result is proved in [Ko1]. Proposition 1.10. The map νcl is S L(2, C)-invariant. ˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ c R → EC× , which is still denoted as νcl . Some Hence νcl induces a map K Vcl interesting special cases are listed below: ˆ = νcl (ψK (C)) νcl (ψK (πK (( (∞, 1, 0)| )K )) = νcl (ψK (πK (( |(∞, 1, 0), (0, 1, 0) )K )))(u ⊗ v) = νcl (ψK (πK (( (∞, 1, 0), (0, 1, 0)| )K ))) = νcl (ψK (πK (( (∞; 1, 0)|(z; 1, 0), (0; 1, 0) )K )))(u ⊗ v) =
(1cl , 1cl )cl idC , 1cl , (u, v)cl , cl , Y(u; z, z¯ )v,
ˆ is the single element in K(0, 0). where C ˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ c R -algebra (U, ν) is called smooth if Definition 1.11. A K 1. U = ⊕m,n∈R U(m,n) is a completely reducible C× -module, where z · u = z m z¯ n u, ∀z ∈ C× , u ∈ U(m,n) . 2. dim U(m,n) < ∞, ∀m, n ∈ R and dim U(m,n) = 0 for m or n sufficiently small. 3. ν is linear on fiber and smooth on the base space K. Theorem 2.7 in [Ko1] can be restated as the following theorem. ˜ cL ⊗ K ˜ c R -algebra. Theorem 1.12. (Vcl , νcl ) is a smooth K
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
37
1.3. Open-string vertex operator algebras. Let (Vop , Yop , 1op , ωop ) be an open-string vertex operator algebra. For r > 0 and v1 , v2 ∈ Vop , we define Yop (v1 , −r )v2 by Yop (v1 , −r )v2 := e−r L(−1) Yop (v2 , r )v1 .
(1.25)
Remark 1.13. Taking the analogy between the open-string vertex operator algebra and associative algebra, Yop (·, −r )· corresponds to the opposite product [HKo1]. An invariant bilinear form on an open-string vertex operator algebra Vop is a bilinear form (·, ·)op on Vop satisfying the following properties: (v3 , Yop (v1 , r )v2 )op = (Yop (e−r L(1) r −2L(0) v1 , −r −1 )v3 , v2 )op , (Yop (v1 , r )v3 , v2 )op = (v3 , Yop (e
−r L(1) −2L(0)
r
v1 , −r
−1
)v2 )op
(1.26) (1.27)
for r > 0 and v1 , v2 , v3 ∈ Vop . Lemma 1.14. (v1 , v2 )op = (v2 , v1 )op
(1.28)
Proof. The proof is exactly the same as that of Proposition 2.3 in [Ko1].
We further assume that (·, ·)op is nondegenerate. Let { f i }i∈R be a basis of Vop and { f i }i∈R its dual basis. We define linear map op : C → Vcl ⊗ Vcl as follows: fi ⊗ f i . (1.29) op : 1 → i∈R
The open-string vertex operator algebra (Vop , Yop , 1op , ωop ) naturally gives a bound(n) ary field algebra (Vop , m op , dop , Dop ) in which the correlation-function maps m op , n ∈ N are completely determined by Yop and 1op [Ko2]. For any Q ∈ TD (n − , n + ) given in (1.10). Let α be a bijective map α
{−n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + } − → {1, . . . , n − + n + }
(1.30)
so that s1 , . . . , sn − +n + , defined by si := rα −1 (i) , satisfy ∞ ≥ s1 > · · · > sn − +n + ≥ 0. Then we define, for λ ∈ C, νop (λψD (πD (Q)))(v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vn + )
(1.31)
as follows: 1. If rk = ∞, ∀k = −n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + , (1.31) is given by (n +n ) 1op , m op− + (w1 , . . . , wn − +n + ; s1 , . . . , sn − +n + ) λ
op
i 1 ,...,i n − ∈R
f i1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ f in− , (1.32)
(B ( p) )
( p)
(B (q) )
(q)
(b0 )−L(0) f i− p and wα(q) = e−L + (b0 )−L(0) vq for where wα( p) = e−L + p = −1, · · · − n − and q = 1, . . . , n + ; 2. If ∃ k ∈ {−n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + } such that rk = ∞, (1.31) is given by the formula obtained from (1.32) by exchanging the 1op with wα(k) .
38
L. Kong
Proposition 1.15. νop is S L(2, R) invariant. Proof. The proof is the same as that of Proposition 1.10.
˜ c → ER+ , which is still denoted as νop . Some interesting Hence νop induces a map D Vop special cases are listed explicitly below: ˆ = (1op , 1op )op idC , νop (ψD (H)) νop (ψD (πD (( (∞, 1, 0)| )))) = 1op , νop (ψD (πD (( |(∞, 1, 0), (0, 1, 0) ))))(u ⊗ v) = (u, v)op , νop (ψD (πD (( (∞, 1, 0), (0, 1, 0)| )))) = op , νop (ψD (πD (( (∞; 1, 0)|(r ; 1, 0), (0; 1, 0) ))))(u ⊗ v) = Yop (u, r )v, ˆ is the single element in D(0, 0) and r > 0. where H ˜ c -algebra (U, ν) is called smooth if Definition 1.16. A D 1. U = ⊕n∈R U(n) is a completely reducible R+ -module, where r · u = r n u, ∀r ∈ R+ , u ∈ U(m,n) . 2. dim U(n) < ∞, ∀n ∈ R and dim U(n) = 0 for n sufficiently small. 3. ν is linear on fiber and smooth on the base space D. ˜ c -algebra. Theorem 1.17. (Vop , νop ) is a smooth D Proof. The proof is same as that of Theorem 1.12.
2. Swiss-Cheese Partial Dioperad In Sect. 3.1, we introduce the notion of a 2-colored partial dioperad and algebra over it. In Sect. 3.2, we study a special example of a 2-colored partial dioperad called a Swiss-cheese partial dioperad S and its C-extension S˜ c . In Sect. 3.3, we show that an open-closed field algebra over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms canonically gives an algebra over S˜ c . In Sect. 3.4, we define boundary states in such algebra and show that some of the boundary states are Ishibashi states.
2.1. 2-colored (partial) dioperads. Definition 2.1. A right module over a dioperad (Q, γQ , IQ ), or a right Q-module, is a family of sets {P(m, n)}m,n∈N with an Sm × Sn -action on each set P(m, n) and substitution maps: γ(i 1 ,...,i n )
P(m, n) × Q(k1 , l1 ) × · · · × Q(kn , ln ) −−−−−→ P(m + k1 · · · + kn − n, l1 + · · · + ln ), (P, Q 1 , . . . , Q n ) → γ(i1 ,...,in ) (P; Q 1 , . . . , Q n ) (2.1) for m, n, l1 , . . . , ln ∈ N, k1 , . . . , kn ∈ Z+ and 1 ≤ i j ≤ k j , j = 1, . . . , n, satisfying the right unit property, the associativity and the permutation axioms of dioperad but with the right action of P on itself in the definition of dioperad replaced by that of Q.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
39
Homomorphism and isomorphism between two right Q-modules can be naturally defined. The right module over a partial dioperad can also be defined in the usual way. Definition 2.2. Let Q be a G-rescalable partial dioperad. A right Q-module is called (i) (i) (i) G-rescalable if for any P ∈ P(m − , m + ), Q i ∈ Q(n − , n + ) and 1 ≤ ji ≤ n − , i = 1, . . . , m + , there exist g j ∈ G, j = 1, . . . , m + such that γ( j1 ,..., jm + ) P; γ( j1 ) (g1 ; Q 1 ), . . . , γ( jm + ) (gm + ; Q m + ) (2.2) is well-defined. Definition 2.3. A 2-colored dioperad consists of a dioperad (Q, γQ , IQ ) and a family B , n B |n I , n I ) equipped with a S × S × S × S -action for n B , n I ∈ N, of sets P(n − B I + − + ± ± n− n +B n− n +I a distinguished element IP ∈ P(1, 1|0, 0), and maps (1)
(1) (1)
(1)
(m + )
P(m − , m + |n − , n + ) × P(k− , k+ |l− , l+ ) × · · · × P(k− γ(iB ,...,i m
(m + ) (m + ) (m + ) |l− , l+ )
, k+
+)
−−−−−−→ P(m − − m + + k− , k+ |n − + l− , n + + l+ ), 1
(1)
(1)
(n )
(n)
P(m − , m + |n − , n + ) × Q( p− , p+ ) × · · · × Q( p− + , p+ ) γ(Ij
1 ,..., jn + )
−−−−−−→ P(m − , m + |n − − n + + p− , p+ ), (1)
(m )
(1)
(m )
(2.3) (1)
(n )
where k± = k± + · · · + k± + , l± = l± + · · · + l± + and p± = p± + · · · + p± + , for (r ) (s) 1 ≤ ir ≤ k− , r = 1, . . . , m + , 1 ≤ js ≤ p− , s = 1, . . . , n + , satisfying the following axioms: 1. The family of sets P := {P(m − , m + )}m − ,m + ∈N , where P(m − , m + ) := ∪n − ,n + ∈N P(m − , m + |n − , n + ), equipped with the natural Sm − × Sm + -action on P(m − , m + ), together with identity element IP and the family of maps γ B := {γ(iB1 ,...,im ) } gives an dioperad. +
2. The family of maps γ I := {γ(Ij1 ,..., jn ) } gives each P(m − , m + ) a right Q-module + structure for m − , m + ∈ N.
We denote such a 2-colored dioperad as (P|Q, (γ B , γ I )). The 2-colored partial dioperad can be naturally defined. If the associativities of γQ , γ B , γ I do not hold, then it is called a 2-colored (partial) nonassociative dioperad. Remark 2.4. If we restrict to {P(1, m|0, n)}m,n∈N and {Q(1, n)}n∈N , they simply gives a structure of 2-colored (partial) operad [V,Kont,Ko2]. Now we discuss an important example of the 2-colored partial nonassociative dioperad. Let J1 , J2 be two index sets, Ui = ⊕n∈Ji (Ui )(n) , i = 1, 2 be two graded vector spaces. Consider two families of sets, EU2 (m, n) = HomC (U2⊗m , U2⊗n ), ⊗m −
EU1 |U2 (m − , m + |n − , n + ) = HomC (U1⊗m + ⊗ U2⊗n + , U1
⊗n −
⊗ U2
),
40
L. Kong
for m, n, m ± , n ± ∈ N. We denote both of the projection operators U1 → (U1 )(n) , (i) U2 → (U2 )(n) as Pn for n ∈ J1 or J2 . For f ∈ EU1 |U2 (k− , k+ |l− , l+ ), gi ∈ EU1 |U2 (m − , ( j) ( j) (i) (i) (i) m + |n − , n + ), i = 1, . . . , k+ , and h j ∈ EU2 ( p− , p+ ), j = 1, . . . , l+ , we say that (1)
(k )
(iB1 ,...,ik ) ( f ; g1 , . . . , gk+ )(u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ v (k++ ) ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vl+ ) + n+
(1) (1) (1) (1) := f Ps1 g1 (u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u (1) ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ v (1) )⊗ m+
s1 ,...,sk ∈J1
··· ⊗
(k ) Psk+ gk+ (u 1 +
(k ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ u (k+ + ) m+
n+
(k ) ⊗ v1 +
(k ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ v (k++ ) ) ⊗ v1 n+
⊗ · · · ⊗ vl+
(I j1 ,..., jl ) ( f ; h 1 , . . . , h l+ )(u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u k+ ⊗ w1(1) ⊗ · · · ⊗ w (l(l++) ) ) + p+
(1) (1) := f u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u k+ ⊗ Pt1 h 1 (w1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ w (1) ) p+
t1 ,...,tl ∈J2
⊗··· ⊗
Ptl+ h l+ (w1(l+ )
⊗ · · · ⊗ w (l(l++) ) ) p+
(i) (i) for u (i) j ∈ U1 , v j , w j ∈ U2 , are well-defined if each multiple sum is absolutely convergent. These give rise to partially defined substitution maps: (1)
(1)
(1)
(1)
(k )
(k )
(k )
(k )
EU1 |U2 (k− , k+ |l− , l+ )⊗ EU1 |U2 (m − , m + |n − , n + )⊗. . .⊗ EU1 |U2 (m − + , m + + |n − + , n + + ) (iB
1 ,...,i k+ )
−−−−−−→ EU1 |U2 (k− − k+ + m − , m + |l− + n − , n + ), (1)
(1)
(l )
(l )
EU1 |U2 (k− , k+ |l− , l+ ) ⊗ EU2 ( p− , p+ ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ EU2 ( p−+ , p+ − ) (I j
1 +···+ jl+ )
(1)
(l )
(1)
(l )
−−−−−−→ EU1 |U2 (k− , k+ |l− − l+ + p− + · · · + p−+ , p+ + · · · + p+ + ), (1)
(k )
(1)
(k )
where m ± = m ± + · · · + m ± + and n ± = n ± + · · · + n ± + . In general, (iB1 ,...,ik (I j1 +···+ jl
+
+)
and
) do not satisfy the associativity. Let
EU1 |U2 = {EU1 |U2 (m − , m + |n − , n + )}m ± ,n ± ∈N , EU2 = {EU2 (n)}n∈N , B := { (iB1 ,...,in ) } and I := { (I j1 ,..., jn ) }. It is obvious that (EU1 |U2 |EU2 , ( B , I )) is a 2-colored partial nonassociative operad. Let U1 be a completely reducible G 1 -module and U2 a, completely reducible G 2 -module. Namely, U1 = ⊕n 1 ∈J1 (U1 )(n 1 ) , U2 = ⊕n 2 ∈J2 (U2 )(n 2 ) where Ji is the set of equivalent classes of irreducible G i -modules and (Ui )(n i ) is a direct sum of irreducible G |G G i -modules of equivalent class n i for i = 1, 2. In this case, we denote EU1 |U2 by EU11|U22 . Definition 2.5. A homomorphism between two 2-colored (partial, nonassociative) dioperads (Pi |Qi , (γiB , γiI )), i = 1, 2 consists of two (partial, nonassociative) dioperad homomorphisms: νP1 |Q1 : P1 → P2 ,
and
νQ1 : Q1 → Q2
such that νP1 |Q1 : P1 → P2 , where P2 has a right Q1 -module structure induced by a dioperad homomorphism νQ1 , is also a right Q1 -module homomorphism.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
41
Definition 2.6. An algebra over a 2-colored partial dioperad (P|Q, (γ B , γ I )), or a P|Q-algebra consists of two graded vector spaces U1 , U2 and a 2-colored partial nonassociative dioperad homomorphism (νP |Q , νQ ) : (P|Q, (γ B , γ I )) → (EU1 |U2 |EU2 , ( B , I )). We denote this algebra as (U1 |U2 , νP |Q , νQ ). Definition 2.7. If a 2-colored partial dioperad (P|Q, γ ) is so that P is a G 1 -rescalable partial operad and a G 2 -rescalable right Q-module, then it is called G 1 |G 2 -rescalable. Definition 2.8. A G 1 |G 2 -rescalable P|Q-algebra (U1 |U2 , νP |Q , νQ ) is a P|Q-algebra G |G G2 so that νP |Q : P → EU11|U22 and νQ : Q → EU are partial nonassociative dioper2 ad homomorphisms such that νP |Q : G 1 → End U1 coincides with the G 1 -module structure on U1 and νQ : G 2 → End U2 coincides with the G 2 -module structure on U2 . 2.2. Swiss-cheese partial dioperads. A disk with strips and tubes of type (m − , m + ; n − , n + ) [Ko2] is a disk consisting of m + (m − ) ordered positively (negatively) oriented punctures on the boundary of the disk, and n + (n − ) ordered positively (negatively) oriented punctures in the interior of the disk, and local coordinate map around each puncture. Two disks are conformal equivalent if there exists a biholomorphic map between them preserving order, orientation and local coordinates. We denote the moduli space of disks with strips and tubes of type (m − , m + ; n − , n + ) as S(m − , m + |n − , n + ). We use the following notation: −m ( (r−m − , b0 − , B (−m − ) ), . . . , (r−1 , b0−1 , B (−1) ) |
(r1 , b1 , B (1) ), . . . , (rm , bm + , B (m + ) ) ) 0
+
−n ( (z −n − , a0 − ,
A
0 (−n − )
), . . . , (z −1 , a0−1 , A(−1) ) |
(z 1 , a01 , A(1) ), . . . , (z n + , a0n + , A(n + ) ) )
S
, (2.4)
ˆ b(i) ∈ R× , B (i) ∈ R and z j ∈ H, a ( j) ∈ C× , A( j) ∈ C for all where ri ∈ R, 0 0 k l i = −m − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , m + , j = −n − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , n + and k, l ∈ Z+ , to represent a disk with strips at ri with local coordinate map f i and tubes at z j with local coordinate map g j given as follows: f i (w) = e =e g j (w) = e
k
(i)
Bk x k+1 ddx
(i) k+1 d k Bk x dx
k
( j)
Ak x k+1 ddx
(i)
d
(i)
d dx
(b0 )x d x x|x=w−ri (b0 )x ( j)
x|x= −1 w
if ri ∈ R ,
(2.5)
if ri = ∞,
(2.6)
d
(a0 )x d x x|x=w−z j .
(2.7)
We denote the set of all such disks given in (2.4) as TS (m − , m + |n − , n + ). The automorphisms of the upper half plane, which is S L(2, R), change the disk (2.4) to a different but conformal equivalent disk. It is clear that we have S(m − , m + |n − , n + ) = TS (m − , m + |n − , n + )/S L(2, R). Let S = {S(m − , m + |n − , n + )}m − ,m + ,n − ,n + ∈N . The permutation groups (Sm − × Sm + ) × (Sn − × Sn + )
(2.8)
42
L. Kong
act naturally on S(m − , m + |n − , n + ). There are so-called boundary sewing operations [HKo1,Ko2] on S, denoted as i ∞−B j , which sews the i th positively oriented boundary puncture of the first disk with the j th negatively oriented boundary puncture of the second disk. Boundary sewing operations naturally induce the following maps: (1)
(1) (1)
(1)
(m + )
S(m − , m + |n − , n + ) × S(k− , k+ |l− , l+ ) × · · · × S(k− γ(iB ,...,i m
(m + ) (m + ) (m + ) |l− , l+ )
, k+
+)
−−−−−−→ S(m − − m + + k− , k+ |n − + l− , n + + l+ ), 1
(1)
(m )
(1)
(m )
(r )
where k± = k± + · · · + k± + , l± = l± + · · · + l± + for 1 ≤ ir ≤ k− , r = 1, . . . , m + . It is easy to see that boundary sewing operations or γ(iB1 ,...,im ) , together with permutation + group actions on the order of boundary punctures, provide S with the structure of a partial dioperad. There are also so-called interior sewing operations [HKo1,Ko2] on S, denoted as I th positively oriented interior puncture of a disk with the j th negai ∞− j , which sew the i tively oriented puncture of a sphere. The interior sewing operations define a right action of K on S: (1) (n + ) S(m − , m + |n − , n + ) × K( p− , p+(1) ) × · · · × K( p− , p+(n + ) ) γ(Ij
1 ,..., jn + )
−−−−−−→ S(m − , m + |n − − n + + p− , p+ ),
(2.9)
(1) (n + ) (s) + · · · + p± , for 1 ≤ js ≤ p− , s = 1, . . . , n + . Such action gives S a where p± = p± right K-module structure. Let γ B = {γ(iB1 ,...,in ) } and γ I = {γ(iI 1 ,...,in ) }. The following proposition is clear.
Proposition 2.9. (S|K, (γ B , γ I )) dioperad.
is
a
R+ |C× -rescalable
2-colored
partial
We call (S|K, (γ B , γ I )) Swiss-cheese partial dioperad. When it is restricted on S = {S(1, m|0, n)}m,n∈N , it is nothing but the so-called Swiss-cheese partial operad [HKo1,Ko2]. In [HKo1,Ko2], we show that the Swiss-cheese partial operad S can be naturally embedded into the sphere partial operad K via the so-called doubling map, denoted as δ : S → K . Such doubling map δ obviously can be extended to a doubling map S → K, still denoted as δ. In particular, the general element (2.4) maps under δ to (−1)
( (z −1 , a0
(−n − )
, A(−1) ), . . . , (z −n − , a0 (−1)
(¯z −1 , a0
(−n − )
, A(−1) ), . . . (¯z −n − , a0 (−1)
(r−1 , b0 (1)
, A(−n − ) ),
(n + )
(z 1 , a0 , A(1) ), . . . , (z n + , a0
, A(−n − ) ), (−m − )
, B (−1) ), . . . , (r−m − , b0
, B (−m − ) ) |,
, A(n + ) ),
(1)
(n + )
(¯z 1 , a0 , A(1) ), . . . , (¯z n + , a0 (1) (r1 , b0 ,
The following proposition is clear.
, A(n + ) ), (m + )
B (1) ), . . . , (rm + , b0
, B (m + ) ) )K .
(2.10)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras (i)
43
(i)
(i)
(i)
Proposition 2.10. Let Pi ∈ S(m − , m + |n − , n + ), i = 1, 2 and Q ∈ K(m − , m + ). If I Q exists for 1 ≤ i ≤ m (1) , 1 ≤ j ≤ m (2) and 1 ≤ k ≤ n (1) , P1 i ∞−B j P2 and P1 k ∞−l + + − 1 ≤ l ≤ m − , then we have δ(P1 i ∞−B j P2 ) = δ(P1 )
(1) 2n + +i
∞−(2n(2) + j) δ(P2 ), −
I δ(P1 k ∞−l Q) = (δ(P1 ) k ∞−l Q )
(1) n + +m + −1+k
¯ ∞−l Q.
(2.11)
By the above Proposition, we can identify S as its image under δ in K with boundary sewing operations replaced by ordinary sewing operations in K and interior sewing operations replaced by double-sewing operations in K as given in (2.11). The C-extension S˜ c (m − , m + |n − , n + ) of S(m − , m + |n − , n + ) is defined to be the pull˜ c (2n − + m − , 2n + + m + ). We denote the canonical section on S˜ c , which back bundle of K ˜ c , as ψS . The boundary (interior) sewing operations can be natis induced from that on K c B (∞ I ) and the corresponding substitution urally extended to S˜ . We denote them as ∞ ˜c⊗K ˜ c¯ on S˜ c defined by γ˜ I . maps as γ˜ B (γ˜ I ). There is a natural right action of K The following proposition is also clear. ˜ c ⊗K ˜ c¯ , (γ˜ B , γ˜ I )) is a R+ |C× -rescalable 2-colored partial dioProposition 2.11. (S˜ c |K perad. ˜c ⊗K ˜ c¯ , (γ˜ B , γ˜ I )) a Swiss-cheese partial dioperad We will call the structure (S˜ c |K with central charge c. Definition 2.12. An algebra over S˜ c viewed as a partial dioperad, (U, ν), is called smooth if 1. U = ⊕n∈R U(n) is a completely reducible R+ -module, where r · u = r n u, ∀r ∈ R+ , u ∈ U(m,n) . 2. dim U(n) < ∞, ∀n ∈ R and dim U(n) = 0 for n sufficiently small. 3. ν is linear on fiber and smooth on the base space S. ˜c ⊗K ˜ c¯ -algebra (U1 |U2 , ν Definition 2.13. An S˜ c |K ˜ c ⊗K ˜ c¯ , νK ˜ c ⊗K ˜ c¯ ) is smooth if both S˜ c |K (U1 , ν ˜ c ˜ c ˜ c¯ ) and (U2 , ν ˜ c ˜ c¯ ) as algebras over partial dioperads are smooth. S |K ⊗K
K ⊗K
2.3. Open-closed field algebras over V . Let (Vop , Yop , ιop ) be an open-string vertex operator algebra over V and (Vcl , Y, ιcl ) a conformal full field algebra over V ⊗ V . Let ( (Vcl , Y, ιcl ), (Vop , Yop , ιop ), Ycl−op )
(2.12)
be an open-closed field algebra over V [Ko2]. We denote the formal vertex operators assof ciated with Yop and Y as Yop and Y f respectively. Let ω L = ιcl (ω ⊗ 1), ω R = ιcl (1 ⊗ ω) and ωop = ιop (ω). We have Y f (ω L ; x, x) ¯ = Y f (ω L , x) = L(n) ⊗ 1x −n−2 , n∈Z
¯ = Y (ω , x) ¯ = Y (ω ; x, x) f
R
f Yop (ωop , x)
f
=
n∈Z
R
1 ⊗ L(n)x¯ −n−2 ,
n∈Z
L(n)x
−n−2
.
(2.13)
44
L. Kong
We also set L L (n) = L(n) ⊗ 1 and L R (n) = 1 ⊗ L(n) for n ∈ Z. For u ∈ V , we showed in [Ko2] that Ycl−op (ιcl (u ⊗ 1); z, z¯ ) and Ycl−op (ιcl (1 ⊗ u); z, z¯ ) are holomorphic and antiholomorphic respectively. So we also denote them simply by Ycl−op (ιcl (u ⊗ 1), z) and Ycl−op (ιcl (1 ⊗ u), z¯ ) respectively. By the V -invariant boundary condition [Ko2], we have Ycl−op (ω L , r ) = Yop (ωop , r ) = Ycl−op (ω R , r ).
(2.14)
We assume that both Vop and Vcl are equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms (·, ·)op and (·, ·)cl respectively. Lemma 2.14. For any u ∈ Vcl and v1 , v2 ∈ Vop and z ∈ H, we have (v2 , Ycl−op (u; z, z¯ )v1 )op = (Ycl−op (e−z L(1) z −2L(0) ⊗ e−¯z L(1) z¯ −2L(0) u; −z −1 , −¯z −1 )v2 , v1 )op .
(2.15)
Proof. Using (1.26), for fixed z ∈ H, we have, (v2 , Ycl−op (u; z, z¯ )v1 )op = (v2 , Ycl−op (u; z, z¯ )Yop (1, r )v1 )op = (v2 , Yop (Ycl−op (u; z − r, z¯ − r )1, r )v1 )op = (e−r
−1 L(−1)
Yop (v2 , r −1 )e−r L(1) r −2L(0) Ycl−op (u; z − r, z¯ − r )1, v1 )op (2.16)
for |z| > r > |z − r | > 0. Notice that e−r v2 = 1op , it is easy to see that
−1 L(−1)
∈ Aut(V op ), ∀r ∈ C. By taking
e−r L(1) r −2L(0) Ycl−op (u; z − r, z¯ − r )1
(2.17)
is a well-defined element in V op for |z| > r > |z − r | > 0. Because of the chirality splitting property of Ycl−op (see (1.72), (1.73) in [Ko2]), it is easy to show that (2.17) equals Ycl−op (e−z L(1) z −2L(0) ⊗ e−¯z L(1) z¯ −2L(0) u, r −1 − z −1 , r −1 − z¯ −1 )1
(2.18)
for r > |z − r | > 0. By the commutativity I of the analytic open-closed field algebra proved in [Ko2], we know that for fixed z ∈ H, e−r
−1 L(−1)
Yop (v2 , r −1 )Ycl−op (e−z L(1) z −2L(0)
⊗e−¯z L(1) z¯ −2L(0) u, r −1 − z −1 , r −1 − z¯ −1 )1 and e−r
−1 L(−1)
Ycl−op (e−z L(1) z −2L(0)
⊗e−¯z L(1) z¯ −2L(0) u, r −1 − z −1 , r −1 − z¯ −1 )Yop (v2 , r −1 )1 = e−r
−1 L(−1)
Ycl−op (e−z L(1) z −2L(0)
⊗e−¯z L(1) z¯ −2L(0) u, r −1 − z −1 , r −1 − z¯ −1 )er
−1 L(−1)
v2
(2.19)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
45
converge in different domains for r , but are an analytic continuation of each other along a path in r ∈ R+ . Moreover, using the L(−1) property of the intertwining operator and chirality splitting property of Ycl−op again, the right hand side of (2.19) equals Ycl−op (e−z L(1) z −2L(0) ⊗ e−¯z L(1) z¯ −2L(0) u, −z −1 , −¯z −1 )v2 for |r −1 − z −1 | > |r −1 |. Therefore, both sides of (2.15) as constant functions of r are analytic continuation of each other. Hence (2.15) must hold identically for all z ∈ H. For u 1 , . . . , u l ∈ Vcl , v1 , . . . , vn ∈ Vcl , r1 , . . . , rn ∈ R, r1 > · · · > rn and z 1 , . . . , zl ∈ H, we define (l;n)
m cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l ; v1 , . . . , vn ; z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , zl , z¯l ; r1 , . . . , rn ) (l;n)
:= e−rn L(−1) m cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l ; v1 , . . . , vn ; z 1 − rn , z¯ 1 − rn , . . . , zl − rn , z¯l − rn ; r1 − rn , . . . , rn−1 − rn , 0).
(2.20)
(l;n)
We simply extend the definition of m cl−op to a domain where some of ri can be negative. Note that such a definition is compatible with L(−1)-properties of m cl−op . Lemma 2.15. For u 1 , . . . , u l ∈ Vcl , v, v1 , . . . , vn ∈ Vcl , r1 , . . . , rn ∈ R, r1 > · · · > rn = 0 and z 1 , . . . , zl ∈ H, (l;n)
(v, m cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l ; v1 , . . . , vn ; z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , zl , z¯l ; r1 , . . . , rn ))op (l;n)
= (vn , m cl−op (F1 u 1 , . . . , Fl u l ; v, G 1 v1 , . . . , G n−1 vn−1 ; −1 ))op , −z 1−1 , −¯z 1−1 , . . . , −zl−1 , −¯zl−1 ; 0, −r1−1 , . . . , −rn−1
(2.21)
where −2L(0)
Fi = e−zi L(1) z i Gj =
−2L(0)
⊗ e−¯zi L(1) z¯ i
−2L(0) e−r j L(1)r j ,
, i = 1, . . . , l,
j = 1, . . . , n − 1.
(2.22)
Proof. By Lemma 2.14, (2.21) is clearly true for l = 0, 1; n = 0, 1. By (1.26) and (1.27), (2.21) is true for l = 0, n = 2. We then prove the lemma by induction. Assume that (2.21) is true for l = k ≥ 0, n = m ≥ 2 or l = k ≥ 1, n = m ≥ 1. Let l = k and n = m + 1. It is harmless to assume that 0 < rn−1 , |z i | < rn−2 , i = l1 + 1, . . . , l for some l1 ≤ l. Using the induction hypothesis, we obtain (l;n)
(v, m cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l ; v1 , . . . , vn ; z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , zl , z¯l ; r1 , . . . , rn ))op (l ;n−1)
(l−l ;2)
1 1 = (v, m cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l1 ; v1 , . . . , vn−2 , m cl−op (u l1 +1 , . . . , u l ; vn−1 , vn ;
zl1 +1 , z¯l1 +1 , . . . , zl , z¯l ; rn−1 , 0); z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , zl1 , z¯l1 ; r1 , . . . , rn−2 , 0))op (l ;n−1)
1 = (m cl−op (F1 u 1 , . . . , Fl1 u l1 ; v, G 1 v1 , . . . , G n−1 vn−1 ;
−1 , −¯zl−1 ; 0, −r1−1 , . . . , −rn−1 ), −z 1−1 , −¯z 1−1 , . . . , −zl−1 1 1 (l−l ;2)
1 m cl−op (u l1 +1 , . . . , u l ; vn−1 , vn ; zl1 +1 , z¯l1 +1 , . . . , zl , z¯l ; rn−1 , 0))op
(l−l ;2)
(l ;n−1)
1 1 = (m cl−op (Fl1 +1 u l1 +1 , . . . , Fl u l ; m cl−op (F1 u 1 , . . . , Fl1 u l1 ;
46
L. Kong −1 v, G 1 v1 , . . . , G n−1 vn−1 ; −z 1−1 , −¯z 1−1 , . . . , −zl−1 , −¯zl−1 ; 0, −r1−1 , . . . , −rn−2 ), 1 1 −1 G n−1 vn−1 ; −zl−1 , −¯zl−1 , . . . , −zl−1 , −¯zl−1 ; 0, −rn−1 ), vn )op 1 +1 1 +1 −1 −1 −rn−1 L(−1) (l−l1 ;2) −rn−2 L(−1) (l−l1 ;n−1) = (e m cl−op (Fl1 +1 u l1 +1 , . . . , Fl u l ; Ps e m cl−op (F1 u 1 , s∈R −1 −1 . . . , Fl1 u l1 ; v, G 1 v1 , . . . , G n−1 vn−1 ; −z 1−1 + rn−2 , −¯z 1−1 + rn−2 , −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 . . . , −zl−1 + rn−2 , −¯zl−1 + rn−2 ; rn−2 , −r1−1 + rn−2 , . . . , −rn−3 + rn−2 , 0), 1 1 −1 −1 G n−1 vn−1 ; −zl−1 + rn−1 , −¯zl−1 + rn−1 , 1 +1 1 +1 −1 −1 −1 . . . , −zl−1 + rn−1 , −¯zl−1 + rn−1 ; rn−1 , 0), vn )op . (2.23) −1
Note that the position of Ps and e−rn−2 L(−1) can not be exchanged in general. Because if we exchange their position, the sum may not converge and then the associativity law does not hold. We want to use analytic continuation to move it to a domain such that we can freely apply the associativity law. By our assumption on V , both sides of (2.23) are restrictions of the analytic function of the zl1 +1 , ζl1 +1 , . . . , zl , ζl , rn−1 on ζl1 +1 = z¯l1 +1 , . . . , ζl = z¯l . Let z˜l1 +1 , . . . , z˜l , r˜n−1 satisfy the following conditions: −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 | − z˜ −1 p + rn−2 |, r˜n−1 − rn−2 > | − z i + rn−2 |, rn−2 , −r j + rn−2 ,
(2.24)
for all i = 1, . . . , l, j = 1, . . . , n − 3 and p = l1 + 1, . . . , l. Note that such a condition define a nonempty open subset on Hl × R+ . Choose a path γ1 in the complement of the diagonal in Hl from initial point (zl1 +1 , . . . , zl ) to (˜zl1 +1 , . . . , z˜l ) and a path γ2 in R+ from rn−1 to r˜n−1 . We also denote the complex conjugate of path γ1 as γ¯1 , which is a path l in H . Combine γ1 , γ¯1 with γ2 , we obtain a path γ from (zl1 +1 , z¯l1 +1 , . . . , zl , z¯l , rn−1 ) to (˜zl1 +1 , z¯˜l1 +1 , . . . , z˜l , z¯˜l , r˜n−1 ). Analytically continuing the right hand side of (2.23) (l;n) along the path γ , we obtain, by the properties of m cl−op [Ko2], −1
(l−l ;2)
(l−l ;n−1)
1 1 (Fl1 +1 u l1 +1 , . . . , Fl u l ; Ps m cl−op (e−˜rn−1 L(−1) m cl−op
(F1 u 1 , . . . , Fl1 u l1 ;
−1 −1 , −¯z 1−1 + rn−2 , v, G 1 v1 , . . . , G n−1 vn−1 ; −z 1−1 + rn−2 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 −1 . . . , −zl−1 + rn−2 , −¯zl−1 + rn−2 ; rn−2 , −r1−1 + rn−2 , . . . , −rn−3 + rn−2 , 0), 1 1 −1 −1 G˜ n−1 vn−1 ; −˜zl−1 + rn−1 , −z¯˜l−1 + rn−1 , 1 +1 1 +1
−1 −1 −1 −1 . . . , −˜zl−1 + rn−1 , −z¯˜l−1 + rn−1 ; r˜n−1 − rn−2 , 0), vn )op ,
(2.25)
−2L(0)
where G˜ n−1 = e−˜rn−1 L(1)r˜n−1 . Using the associativity of open-closed field algebra and L(−1)-properties of m cl−op , we see that (2.25) further equals (l;n+1)
(m cl−op (F1 u 1 , . . . , Fl u l ; v, G 1 v1 , . . . , G˜ n−1 vn−1 ; −z 1−1 , −¯z 1−1 , . . . , −1 , −¯zl−1 , −˜zl−1 , −z¯˜l−1 , . . . , −zl−1 , −¯zl−1 ; 0, −r1−1 , . . . , −˜rn−1 ), vn )op . −zl−1 1 1 1 +1 1 +1 (2.26)
By analytically continuing (2.26) along the path −γ , which is γ reversed, we obtain the right hand side of (2.21). Hence (2.23) and the right hand side of (2.21) are analytic continuation of each other along path (−γ ) ◦ (γ ) which is a constant path. Hence (2.21) holds for l = k, n = m + 1.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
47
Now let l = k + 1, n = m. The proof is similar to the case l = k, n = m + 1. We only point out the difference. Using the smoothness of m cl−op , it is enough to prove the case when |z i | = |z j | for i, j = 1, . . . , l and i = j. Without losing generality, we assume that |z 1 | > · · · > |zl | > 0. Let n 1 ≤ n be the smallest so that 0 < r j < |zl | for j ≥ n 1 . Then we have (v, m (l;n) cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l ; v1 , . . . , vn ; z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , z l , z¯ l ; r1 , . . . , rn ))op (l−1;n 1 ) 1 +1) = (v, m cl−op (u 1 , . . . , u l−1 ; v1 , . . . , vn 1 −1 , m (1;n−n (u l ; vn 1 , . . . , vn ; cl−op
zl , z¯l ; rn 1 , . . . , rn ); z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , zl−1 , z¯l−1 ; r1 , . . . , rn 1 −1 ))op .
(2.27)
We can then apply (2.21) as in (2.23) for the case l ≤ k, n ≤ m, which is true by our induction hypothesis. The rest of the proof is entirely the same as that of the case l = k, n = m + 1. We define a map, for z, ζ ∈ C and z = ζ , ιcl−op (z, ζ ) : Vcl → V op as ιcl−op (z, ζ )(u) = Ycl−op (u; z, ζ )1op . We denote its adjoint as ι∗cl−op (z, ζ ). Namely, ι∗cl−op (z, ζ ) : Vop → Vcl is given by (ι∗cl−op (z, ζ )(w), u)cl = (w, ιcl−op (z, ζ )(u))op
(2.28)
for any u ∈ Vcl and w ∈ Vop . Let Q be an element in TS (n − , n + |m − , m + ) of form (2.4). Let α be the map (1.30) so that s1 , . . . , sn − +n + , defined as si := rα −1 (i) , satisfy ∞ ≥ s1 > · · · > sn − +n + ≥ 0. Then we define νcl−op (λψS (Q))(u 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ u m + ⊗ v1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ vn + )
(2.29)
as follows: 1. If s1 = ∞, (2.29) is given by (m − +m + ;n − +n + ) 1op , m cl−op λ (u −1 , . . . , u −m − , u 1 , . . . , u m + ; i 1 ,...,i m − ; j1 ,..., jn −
w1 , . . . , wn − +n + ; z −1 , z¯ −1 , . . . , z −m − , z¯ −m − , z 1 , z¯ 1 , . . . , z m + , z¯ m + ; s1 , . . . , sn − +n + ) op · ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ein− ⊗ f j1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ f jm − , (2.30) where u p = e−L + (A L
u q = e−L + (A L
wα(k) = wα(l) =
( p) )−L R (A( p) ) + (q) )−L R (A(q) ) +
( p)
(a0 )−L (q)
(a0 )−L
L (0)
L (0)
( p)
−L R (0)
a0
(q)
a0
−L R (0)
ei− p ,
uq ,
−L + (B (k) )
(k) e (b0 )−L(0) f j−k , (l) (l) e−L + (B ) (b0 )−L(0) vl ,
(2.31)
for p = −1, . . . , −n − , q = 1, . . . , n + , k = −1, . . . , −m − and l = 1, . . . , m + . 2. When rk = ∞ for some k = −m − , . . . , −1, 1, . . . , m + . Equation (2.29) is given by the formula obtained from (2.30) by exchanging 1op with wα(k) .
48
L. Kong
Lemma 2.16. νcl−op is S L(2, R)-invariant. Proof. The S L(2, R) is generated by the following three transformations 1. w → aw, ∀a ∈ R+ ; 2. w → w − b, ∀b ∈ R; 3. w → −1 w . That νcl−op is invariant under the first two transformations simply follows from the L(0)- and L(−1)-properties of m cl−op . That νcl−op is invariant under the third transformation is proved in Lemma 2.15. ×
R + |C Hence νcl−op induces a map S˜ c → EVop |Vcl , which is still denoted as νcl−op . We list a few interesting cases:
νcl−op ψS ( (∞, 1, 0)| ) ( |(z, 1, 0)) S = ιcl−op (z, z¯ ),
νcl−op ψS ( |(∞, 1, 0)) ((z, 1, 0)| ) = ι∗ (z, z¯ ), (2.32) S
and for b ∈ R+ , B ∈ R∞ , a ∈ C× , A ∈ C∞ and v ∈ Vop , we have
νcl−op ψS ( |(∞, b, B)) ((z, a, A)| ) S = a −L
L (0)
a¯ −L
R (0)
e−
∞
j=1 (−1)
j [A
jL
L (− j)+A
jL
R (− j)]
ι∗ (z, z¯ )(e−L + (B) b−L(0) v). (2.33)
˜c ⊗ Theorem 2.17. (Vop |Vcl , νcl−op , νcl ) is an R+ |C× -rescalable smooth S˜ c |K Kc¯ -algebra. Proof. The smoothness is automatic. We showed in [Ko2] that (Vop |Vcl , νcl−op , νcl ) is ˜ c | K˜ c ⊗ K c¯ -algebra. The rest of the proof is similar to an R+ |C× -rescalable smooth S that of Theorem 1.12 in [Ko1]. We omit the detail here. 2.4. Ishibashi states. As we mentioned in the introduction, an open-closed field algebra over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms for both open theory and closed theory contains all the data needed to grow to an open-closed partial field theory of all genus. Without adding more compatibility conditions, itself is already an interesting object to study. We show in this subsection that the famous “Ishibashi states” [I] can be studied in the framework of such an algebra. Throughout this subsection, we fix an open-closed algebra over V given in (2.12) and equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms (·, ·)cl and (·, ·)op . For u ∈ Vop and z 0 ∈ H, we define the boundary state Bz 0 (u) ∈ Vcl associated with u and z 0 by Bz 0 (u) = e L(−1) (¯z 0 − z 0 ) L(0) ⊗ e L(−1) z¯ 0 − z 0
L(0) ∗ ιcl−op (z 0 , z¯ 0 )(u).
(2.34)
Proposition 2.18. If u ∈ Vop is a vacuum-like vector [LL], i.e. L(−1)u = 0, then, for z 0 ∈ H, Bz 0 (u) is an Ishibashi state, i.e. (L L (n) − L R (−n))Bz 0 (u) = 0,
∀n ∈ Z.
(2.35)
Proof. For v ∈ Vcl , the following two functions of z : (u, Ycl−op (ω L , z + z 0 )Y(v; z 0 , z¯ 0 )1op )op , (u, Ycl−op (ω R ; z + z 0 )Y(v; z 0 , z¯ 0 )1op )op
(2.36)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
49
can be extended to a holomorphic function and an antiholomorphic function in {z|z+z 0 ∈ H, z = 0} respectively by our assumption on V . We denote the extended functions by g1 (ω L , z) and g2 (ω R , z¯ ) respectively. The following two limits:
4 z lim 1− g1 (ω L , z), z+z 0 →r z¯ 0 − z 0
4 z 1− g2 (ω R , z¯ ) (2.37) lim z+z 0 →r z¯ 0 − z 0 exist for all r ∈ R. Using (2.15), it is easy to see that the above two limits also exist ˆ if and only if u is vacuum-like. Hence, by V -invariant (or conformal for r = ∞ ∈ R invariant) boundary condition, we have
4
4 z z lim 1− 1− g1 (ω L , z) = lim g2 (ω R , z) (2.38) z+z 0 →r z+z 0 →r z¯ 0 − z 0 z¯ 0 − z 0 ˆ when L(−1)u = 0. for all r ∈ R On the other hand, for |z + z 0 | > |z 0 |, we have (u, Ycl−op (ω L , z + z 0 )Ycl−op (v; z 0 , z¯ 0 )1op )op = (u, Ycl−op (Y(ω L , z)v; z 0 , z¯ 0 )op 1op )op = (u, ιcl−op (z 0 , z¯ 0 )(Y(ω L , z)v))op = (ι∗cl−op (z 0 , z¯ 0 )(u), Y(ω L , z)v)cl = (Bz 0 (u), e L(1) (¯z 0 − z 0 )−L(0) ⊗ e L(1) z¯ 0 − z 0
−L(0)
Y(ω L , z)v)cl .
(2.39)
Note that one should check the convergence property of each step in (2.39). In particular, in the last step, the convergence and equality follow from the convergence of early −L(0) −L(−1) e ∈ Aut Vcl . For steps and the fact that (¯z 0 − z 0 )−L(0) e−L(−1) ⊗ z¯ 0 − z 0 0 < |z| < |Imz 0 |, it is easy to show that −L(0)
e L(1) (¯z 0 − z 0 )−L(0) ⊗ e L(1) z¯ 0 − z 0 Y(ω L , z)v
−2L L (0) z (1− z )L L (1) 1− = Y(e z¯0 −z0 · z¯ 0 − z 0 z 1 L ·(¯z 0 − z 0 )−L (0) ω L , z )v1 z¯ 0 − z 0 1 − z¯ 0 −z 0 −4
z z 1 = 1− (¯z 0 − z 0 )−2 Y(ω L , z )v1 , z¯ 0 − z 0 z¯ 0 − z 0 1 − z¯ 0 −z 0 where v1 = e L(1) (¯z 0 − z 0 )−L(0) ⊗ e L(1) z¯ 0 − z 0 and |z + z 0 | > |z 0 |, we obtain
−L(0)
(2.40)
v. Hence, for all 0 < |z| < |Imz 0 |
(u, Ycl−op (ω L , z + z 0 )Ycl−op (v; z 0 , z¯ 0 )1op )op −4
z = (Bz 0 (u), 1 − (¯z 0 − z 0 )−2 Y(ω L , f (z))v1 )cl , z¯ 0 − z 0
(2.41)
50
L. Kong
where f is the composition of the following maps: w → w + z 0 → −
w (w + z 0 ) − z 0 1 = w (w + z 0 ) − z¯ 0 z¯ 0 − z 0 1 − z¯ 0 −z 0
which maps the domain H − z 0 to the unit disk. Since g1 (ω L , z) is analytic and free of singularities for z + z 0 ∈ H\{z 0 }, the right hand side of (2.41) can also be extended to an analytic function in z ∈ H − z 0 \{0}. If we view f (z) as a new variable ξ , then the right hand side of (2.41) can be extended to an analytic function on {ξ |1 > |ξ | > 0}, which has a Laurent series expansion. By the uniqueness of Laurent expansion, the right hand side of (2.41) gives exactly such a Laurent expansion and thus is absolutely convergent ˆ By the propin {ξ |1 > |ξ | > 0}. Moreover, lim z+z 0 →r g1 (ω L , z) exists for all r ∈ R. erties of Laurent series, the right hand side of (2.41) must converge absolutely for all ˆ f (z) ∈ {ξ ||ξ | = 1} to the function given by lim z+z 0 →r g1 (ω L , z), r ∈ R. Similarly, for all 0 < |¯z | < |Imz 0 | and |z + z 0 | > |z 0 |, we have (u, Ycl−op (ω R , z + z 0 )Ycl−op (v; z 0 , z¯ 0 )1op )op −L(0)
= (Bz 0 (u), e L(1) (¯z 0 − z 0 )−L(0) ⊗ e L(1) z¯ 0 − z 0 Y(ω R , z¯ )v)cl
−2L R (0) z¯ z R (1− z −¯ )L R (1) z 0 0 1− = (Bz 0 (u), Y(e (z 0 − z¯ 0 )−L (0) ω R , g(¯z ))v1 )cl z 0 − z¯ 0
−4 z¯ = 1− (z 0 − z¯ 0 )−2 (Bz 0 (u), Y(ω R , g(¯z ))v1 )cl , (2.42) z 0 − z¯ 0 where g is the composition of the following maps: w → w + z¯ 0 → −
w (w + z¯ 0 ) − z 0 (w + z¯ 0 ) − z¯ 0 1 → − = w (w + z¯ 0 ) − z¯ 0 (w + z¯ 0 ) − z 0 z 0 − z¯ 0 1 − z 0 −¯ z0
which maps the domain −H − z¯ 0 to the unit disk. Moreover, the right hand side of (2.42), as a Laurent series of g(¯z ), is absolutely convergent for all g(¯z ) ∈ {ξ ||ξ | = 1} to ˆ lim z+z 0 →r g2 (ω R , z), r ∈ R. Also notice that g(r − z¯ 0 ) =
1 ∈ {eiθ |0 ≤ θ < 2π } f (r − z 0 )
(2.43)
ˆ Using (2.38) and by replacing z in (2.41) by r − z 0 and z¯ in (2.42) by for all r ∈ R. r − z¯ 0 , we obtain the following identity: (Bz 0 (u), Y(ω L , eiθ )v1 )cl = (Bz 0 (u), Y(ω R , e−iθ )v1 )cl e−4iθ ,
(2.44)
where eiθ = f (r − z 0 ), for all 0 ≤ θ < 2π . Notice that the existence of both sides of (2.44) follows directly from (2.38), which further follows from the condition of u being vacuum-like. Then we obtain (Bz 0 (u), L L (n)v1 )cl eiθ(−n−2) = (Bz 0 (u), L R (−n)v1 )cl eiθ(−n−2) n∈Z
n∈Z
for all 0 ≤ θ < 2π . Notice that v1 can be arbitrary. Therefore, we must have (2.35) when L(−1)u = 0.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
51
In physics, boundary states are usually obtained by solving Eq. (2.35). The solutions of such equation was first obtained by Ishibashi [I]. They are called Ishibashi states. The definition of boundary states we give in (2.34) is more general. Boundary conditions are also called “D-branes” in string theory. If u is not a vacuum-like vector, the boundary state (2.34) associated with u is also very interesting in physics (see for example [FFFS1]). Such boundary states are associated to the geometry on D-branes. In the end of Sect. 5.2, we will give a more natural (or algebraic) definition of D-brane. 3. Cardy Condition In this section, we derive the Cardy condition from the axioms of open-closed partial conformal field theory by writing out the algebraic realizations of the both sides of Fig. 3 explicitly. Then we reformulate the Cardy condition in the framework of the intertwining operator algebra. Throughout this section, we fix an open-closed field algebra over V given in (2.12) equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms (·, ·)op and (·, ·)cl . 3.1. The first version. In the Swiss-cheese dioperad, we exclude an interior sewing operation between two disks with strips and tubes and a self-sewing operation between two oppositely oriented boundary punctures on a single disk. The surface obtained after these two types of sewing operations can be the same cylinder or annulus. The axioms of open-closed partial conformal field theory require that the algebraic realization of these two sewing operations must coincide. This gives a nontrivial condition called Cardy condition (recall Fig. 3). Although the Cardy condition only involves genus-zero surfaces, its algebraic realization is genus-one in nature. This fact is manifest if we consider the doubling map δ. A double of a cylinder is actually a torus. Hence the Cardy condition is a condition on the equivalence of two algebraic realizations of two different decompositions of a torus. This is nothing but a condition associated to modularity. That an annulus can be obtained by two different sewing operations is also shown in Fig. 4. In particular, the surface (A) in Fig. 4 shows how an annulus is obtained by sewing two oppositely oriented boundary punctures on the same disk with strips and tubes in S(1, 3|0, 0), and surface (C) in Fig. 4, viewed as a propagator of the close string, can be obtained by sewing an element in S(0, 1|1, 0) with an element in S(0, 1|0, 1) along the interior punctures. We only show in Figure 4 a simple case in which there are only two boundary punctures and no interior puncture. In general, the number of boundary punctures and interior punctures can be arbitrary. However, all general cases can be reduced to this simple case by applying associativities. Notice that the two boundary punctures in this simple case can not be reduced further by the associativities. We only focus on this case in this work. The conformal map f between the surface (A) and (B) and g between the surface (C) and (B) in Fig. 4 are given by 1 log w, 2πi −τ log w. g(w) = 2πi f (w) =
(3.1) 1
It is also useful to know their inverses f −1 (w) = e2πiw , g −1 (w) = e2πi(− τ )w . For any 1 z ∈ C, we set qz := e2πi z and pz := e2πi(− τ )z . The radius of the outer circle of the
52
L. Kong
τ
s2
f
s1 −1
qs2
0
qτ
qs1
1 0
1/2
g
(A)
1
(B)
ps2 0
1
ps1
(C) Fig. 4. Cardy condition: two different sewings give same annulus
surface (C) in Fig. 4 is | ps1 | = 1 and that of the inner circle is 1
| ps2 | = eπi(− τ ) = q
1/2 . − τ1
(3.2)
As we have argued and will show more explicitly later, the Cardy condition is deeply related to modularity. In [H9], Huang introduced the so-called geometrically modified intertwining operators, which is very convenient for the study of modularity. He was motivated by the fact that it is much easier to study modularity in the global coordinates. Namely, one should choose the local coordinates at s1 , s2 in surface (B) in Fig. 4 as simple as possible. More precisely, we choose the local coordinates at s1 , s2 as πi
w → e 2 (w − s1 ), πi
w → e− 2 (w − s2 )
(3.3)
respectively. Correspondingly, the local coordinates at punctures qs1 , qs2 are
πi 1 1 log 1 + x , f qs1 (w) = e 2 2πi qs1 x=w−qs1
1 1 − πi 2 log 1 + x f qs2 (w) = e 2πi qs2 x=w−qs 2
respectively.
(3.4)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
53
Notice that both local coordinates f qs1 (w) and f qs2 (w) are real analytic. Hence
(i) ∃B j
(i)
∈ R, b0 ∈ R+ , i = 1, 2 such that f qs1 (w) = e x , x=w−qs1 ∞ (2) B j x j+1 ddx (2) x ddx j=1 f qs2 (w) = e (b0 ) x . ∞
j=1
(1)
B j x j+1 ddx
d (b0(1) )x d x
(3.5)
x=w−qs2
Then the algebraic realization of the surface (A) gives a map Vop ⊗ Vop → C. We assume 1 > |qs1 | > |qs2 | > |qτ | > 0. By the axiom of open-closed conformal field theory, this map must be given by (recall (1.25)) v1 ⊗ v2 → TrVop Yop (Tqs1 v1 , qs1 )Yop (Tqs2 v2 , qs2 )qτL(0) ,
(3.6)
where Tqs1 = e− Tqs2 = e− by
∞
j=1
∞
j=1
(1)
B j L( j) (2)
B j L( j)
(1)
(b0 )−L(0) , (2)
(b0 )−L(0) .
(3.7)
We need to rewrite Tqs1 and Tqs2 . Let A j , j ∈ Z+ , be the complex numbers defined log(1 + y) = e
∞
j=1
d A j y j+1 dy
y.
It is clear that A j ∈ R. Hence we also obtain:
d 1 1 log 1 + x = z −x d x e j∈Z+ 2πi z
A j x j+1 ddx
d
(2πi)−x d x x.
(3.8)
Lemma 3.1. Tqs1 = (qs1 ) L(0) e− Tqs2 = (qs2 ) L(0) e−
∞
A j L( j)
∞
(2πi) L(0) e− 2
A j L( j)
(2πi) L(0) e−2πi L(0) e
j=1 j=1
∞
πi
L(0)
, πi 2
∞
L(0)
L(0)
.
(3.9)
L(0)
= e j=1 D j L( j) d0 for any C j , Proof. By results in [BHL], if e j=1 C j L( j) c0 D j ∈ C, c0 , d0 ∈ C, we must have C j = D j and c0 = d0 . Therefore, by moving ∞ the factor (qs1 ) L(0) to the right side of e− j=1 A j L( j) in (3.9) and similarly moving the factor (qs2 ) L(0) in (3.9), we see that it is enough to show (1)
πi
(b0 ) L(0) = (qs1 ) L(0) (2πi) L(0) e− 2 (1) (b0 ) L(0)
L(0)
,
= (qs2 ) L(0) (2πi) L(0) e−2πi L(0) e
πi 2
L(0)
.
(3.10)
Using our conventions (0.1)(0.2), it is easy to check that the above identities hold.
54
L. Kong
Let W be a V -module. Huang introduced the following operator in [H9]: U(x) := x L(0) e−
∞
A j L( j)
j=1
(2πi) L(0) ∈ (EndW ){x}.
Thus (3.6) can be rewritten as follows: v1 ⊗ v2 → TrVop Yop (U(qs1 )v1 , qs1 )Yop (U(qs2 )e−2πi L(0) v2 , qs2 )qτL(0) , πi
(3.11)
πi
where v1 = e− 2 L(0) v1 and v2 = e 2 L(0) v2 . Now we consider the algebraic realization of the surface (C) in Fig. 4 obtained from an interior sewing operation between an element in S(0, 1|1, 0) and an element in S(0, 1|0, 1). Lemma 3.2. ∀r ∈ (0, 1) ⊂ R+ , the surface C in Fig. 4 is conformally equivalent to a surface Q 1 1 ∞1I Q 2 , where ˆ and local coordinates: 1. Q 1 ∈ S(0, 1|0, 1) with punctures at z 1 ∈ H, ∞ ∈ R p w−z s1 1 , r w − z¯ 1
πi w − z1 −τ log : w → e 2 ; 2πi w − z¯ 1
f z1 : w → (1) f∞
(3.12) (3.13)
ˆ with local coordinates 2. Q 2 ∈ S(0, 1|1, 0) with punctures at z 2 ∈ H, ∞ ∈ R
−r w − z 2 , (3.14) f z2 : w → ps2 w − z¯ 2
πi −τ w − z¯ 2 (2) : w → e− 2 . (3.15) f∞ log 2πi w − z2 Proof. Let us first define two disks D1 and D2 . D1 is the unit disk, i.e. D1 := {z ∈ C||z| ≤ 1}, which has punctures at ps1 , 0 and local coordinates: g ps1 : w → e
πi 2
−τ log w − s1 , 2πi
g0 : w → r −1 w.
(3.16) (3.17)
ˆ D2 is the disk {z ∈ C||z| ≥ | ps2 |} which has punctures at ps2 , ∞ and local coordinates: g ps2 : w → e g∞ : w →
− πi 2
−r . w
−τ log w − s2 , 2πi
(3.18) (3.19)
It is not hard to see that the surface C in Fig. 1 can be obtained by sewing the puncture 0 ∈ D1 with the puncture ∞ ∈ D2 according to the usual definition of the interior sewing operation. Then it is enough to show that D1 and D2 are conformally equivalent
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
55
to P and Q respectively. We define two maps h 1 : Q 1 → D1 and h 2 : Q 2 → D2 as follows: w − z1 h 1 : w → ps1 , w − z¯ 1 w − z¯ 2 h 2 : w → ps2 . w − z2 It is clear that h 1 and h 2 are both biholomorphic. We can check directly that h 1 and h 2 map punctures to punctures and preserve local coordinates as well. Using (2.33), we obtain the algebraic realization of the annulus C in Fig. 1 as follows: v1 ⊗ v2 → ((T1L ⊗ T1R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 1 , z¯ 1 )(T2 v1 ), (T3L ⊗ T3R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 2 , z¯ 2 )(T4 v2 ))cl , (3.20) where T1L ,R , T2 , T3L ,R , T4 are conformal transformations determined by local coordi(2) (1) (2) nates f z 1 , f ∞ , f z 2 , f ∞ , and (TiL ⊗ Ti R )∗ is the adjoint of TiL ⊗ Ti R with respect to πi
the bilinear form (·, ·)cl for i = 1, 3, and v1 = e− 2
L(0)
v1 and v2 = e
πi 2
L(0)
v2 .
Lemma 3.3. Recall the convention (0.2), we have −L(0) p −L(0) L(0) L(1) ps1 s1 T1L = (z 1 − z¯ 1 ) L(0) e L(1) , T1R = (z 1 − z¯ 1 ) e , r r
1 L(0) T2 = e z¯ 1 L(1) (z 1 − z¯ 1 )−L(0) U(1) − , τ L(0) p L(0) L(0) −L(1) ps2 s2 , T3R = (¯z 2 − z 2 ) e , T3L = (¯z 2 − z 2 ) L(0) e−L(1) r r L(0)
1 T4 = e z 2 L(1) (¯z 2 − z 2 )−L(0) U(1) − . τ Proof. From (3.12) and (3.14), we obtain f z 1 : w → (z 1 − z¯ 1 )
p x
d dx
r p −x
d dx
−x ddx −x 2 ddx
e
d
f z 2 : w → (¯z 2 − z 2 )−x d x e x
2 d dx
s1
s2
r
x , x=w−z 1 x .
(3.21) (3.22) (3.23) (3.24)
(3.25)
x=w−z 2
Then (3.21) and (3.23) is obvious. Notice that the expression (3.21) is independent of our choice of branch cut as long as we keep the convention (0.2). From (3.13) and (3.15), we obtain
−x d ∞ dx πi d 1 A j x j+1 ddx (1) −¯z 1 x 2 ddx x ddx −x ddx x dx j=1 2 − f ∞ (w) = e (z 1 − z¯ 1 ) e (2πi) e x , τ x= −1 w
(2) f∞ (w) = e−z 2 x
2 d dx
d
(¯z 2 − z 2 )x d x e
∞
j=1
A j x j+1 ddx
−x d dx d 1 (2πi)−x d x − τ
(3.26) πi d e− 2 x d x x . x= −1 w
(3.27)
56
L. Kong (1)
(2)
Recall that f ∞ , f ∞ are both real analytic. Similar to the proof of Lemma 3.1, to show (3.22) and (3.24) it is enough to show that (1) L(0) ) (b∞ (2) L(0) (b∞ ) (1)
1 L(0) − πi L(0) = (z 1 − z¯ 1 ) (2πi) e 2 , − τ
1 L(0) πi L(0) = (¯z 2 − z 2 )−L(0) (2πi) L(0) − e2 τ −L(0)
L(0)
(3.28) (3.29)
(2)
for some b∞ , b∞ ∈ R+ . Using our convention (0.1) and (0.2), it is a direct check that (3.28) and (3.29) holds. c − 24
Combining (3.11), (3.20) and additional natural factors qτ
,q
c − 24
− τ1
(see [Z,H9]),
which is due to the determinant line bundle on torus [Se1,Kr], we obtain the following formulation of the Cardy condition: Definition 3.4. The open-closed field algebra over V given in (2.12) and equipped with nondegenerate bilinear forms (·, ·)op and (·, ·)cl is said to satisfy Cardy condition if the left hand sides of the following formula, ∀z 1 , z 2 ∈ H, v1 , v2 ∈ Vop ,
TrVop Yop (U(qs1 )v1 , qs1 )Yop (U(qs2 )e−2πi L(0) v2 , qs2 )qτL(0)−c/24
−c/24 L R ∗ ∗ L R ∗ ∗ = (T1 ⊗ T1 ) ιcl−op (z 1 , z¯ 1 )(T2 v1 ), q 1 (T3 ⊗ T3 ) ιcl−op (z 2 , z¯ 2 )(T4 v2 ) −τ
cl
(3.30) converge absolutely when 1 > |qs1 | > |qs2 | > |qτ | > 0, and the right hand side of (3.30) converge absolutely for all s1 , s2 ∈ H satisfying Re s1 = 0, Re s2 = 21 . Moreover, Eq. (3.30) holds when 1 > |qs1 | > |qs2 | > |qτ | > 0. Remark 3.5. The dependence of z 1 , z 2 , r of the right hand side of (3.30) is superficial as required by the independence of z 1 , z 2 , r of the left hand side of (3.30). We will see it more explicitly later. Using the definition of boundary states (2.34), (3.30) can also be written as follows: TrVop Yop (U(qs1 )v1 , qs1 )Yop (U(qs2 )e−2πi L(0) v2 , qs2 )qτL(0)−c/24
ps2 L(0) −c/24 ps2 L(0) ⊗ q 1 Bz 2 (T4 v2 ) . (3.31) = Bz 1 (T2 v1 ), −τ − ps1 − ps1 cl
3.2. The second version. In this subsection, we rewrite the Cardy condition (3.30) in the framework of the intertwining operator algebra. Since V satisfies the conditions in Theorem 0.1, it has only finite number of inequivalent irreducible modules. Let I be the set of equivalence classes of irreducible V -modules. We denote the equivalence class of the adjoint module V as e, i.e. e ∈ I. Let Wa be a chosen representative of a ∈ I.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
57
For any V -module (W, YW ), we denote the graded dual space of W as W , i.e. = ⊕n∈C (W(n) )∗ . There is a contragredient module structure on W [FHL] given by , which is defined as follows: a vertex operator YW W
YW (u, x)w , w := w , YW (e−x L(1) x −2L(0) u, −x −1 )w
(3.32)
) (or simply W ) is the only module structure on for u ∈ V, w ∈ W, w ∈ W . (W , YW . We denote the equivalent class of W we use in this work. So we can set YW := YW Wa as a . It is harmless to set Wa = Wa . Moreover, W is canonically identified with W . Hence a = a for a ∈ I. By assumption on V , V ∼ = V , i.e. e = e. From [FHL], there is a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form (·, ·) on V such that (1, 1) = 1. This bilinear form specifies a unique isomorphism from V to V . In the rest of this work, we identify V with V using this isomorphism without mentioning it explicitly. For any triple V -modules W1 , W2 , W3 , we have isomorphisms W3 W3 → VW , r : VW 1 W2 2 W1
∀r ∈ Z
given as follows: r (Y)(w2 , z)w1 = e z L(−1) Y(w1 , e(2r +1)πi z)w2 , for Y ∈
W3 VW 1 W2
(3.33)
and wi ∈ Wi , i = 1, 2. The following identity r ◦ −r −1 = −r −1 ◦ r = id
(3.34)
is proved in [HL3]. W3 and r ∈ Z, a so-called r -contragredient operator Ar (Y) was introFor Y ∈ VW 1 W2 duced in [HL3]. Here, we use two slightly different operators A˜ r (Y) and Aˆ r (Y) introduced in [Ko1] and defined as follows: A˜ r (Y)(w1 , e(2r +1)πi x)w3 , w2 = w3 , Y(e x L(1) x −2L(0) w1 , x −1 )w2 , Aˆ r (Y)(w1 , x)w3 , w2 = w3 , Y(e−x L(1) x −2L(0) w1 , e(2r +1)πi x −1 )w2 ,
(3.35)
and w1 ∈ W1 , w2 ∈ W2 , w3 ∈ W3 . In particular, when W1 = V and = Y , ∀r ∈ Z. If Y ∈ V W3 , W2 = W3 = W , we have A˜ r (YW ) = Aˆ r (YW ) = YW W W1 W2
for Y ∈
W3 VW 1 W2
W then A˜ r (Y), Aˆ r (Y) ∈ VW 2W for r ∈ Z and 1
Let Y
3
A˜ r ◦ Aˆ r (Y) = Aˆ r ◦ A˜ r (Y) = Y. a3 ∈ Va1 a2 . We define σ123 := r ◦ A˜ r . It is easy to see wa 3 , Y(wa1 , x)wa2 = e−x
−1 L(−1)
(3.36) that
σ123 (Y)(wa 3 , x −1 )e−x L(1) x −2L(0) wa1 , wa2
(3.37)
for wa1 ∈ Wa1 , wa2 ∈ Wa2 , wa 3 ∈ Wa 3 . It is also clear that σ123 is independent of r ∈ Z. 3 = id a . We also denote σ −1 as σ It is proved in [Ko1] that σ123 132 . Clearly, we have 123 Va 3a 1 2
σ132 = Aˆ r ◦ −r −1 and
σ132 (Y)(w1 , x)w3 , w2 for wa1 ∈ Wa1 , wa2 ∈
= w3 , e−x
−1 L(−1)
Wa2 , wa 3
Wa 3 .
∈
Y(w2 , x −1 )e−x L(1) x −2L(0) w1
(3.38)
58
L. Kong
For any V -module W , we define a V -module map θW : W → W by θW : w → e−2πi L(0) w.
(3.39)
For Wa , we have θWa = e−2πi h a idWa , where h a ∈ C is the lowest conformal weight of Wa . respectively. Let We denote the graded dual space of Vcl and Vop by Vcl and Vop ϕcl : Vcl → Vcl and ϕop : Vop → Vop be the isomorphisms induced from (·, ·)cl and (·, ·)op respectively. Namely, we have (u 1 , u 2 )cl = ϕcl (u 1 ), u 2 , (v1 , v2 )op = ϕop (v1 ), v2
(3.40)
for u 1 , u 2 ∈ Vcl and v1 , v2 ∈ Vop . Vcl as a conformal full field algebra over V ⊗ V can be expanded as follows: Ncl Wr L (i) ⊗ Wr R (i) , Vcl = ⊕i=1
(3.41)
where r L , r R : {1, . . . , Ncl } → I. For a ∈ I, we choose a basis {ea;α }α∈N of Wa and a } dual basis {ea;α α∈N of Wa . Then {er L (i),α ⊗ er R (i),β }i=1,...,Ncl ,α,β∈N
(3.42)
{ϕcl−1 (er L (i);α ⊗ er R (i),β )}i=1,...,Ncl ,α,β∈N
(3.43)
is a basis of Vcl and
is its dual basis with respect to the nondegenerate bilinear form (·, ·)cl . Let T : CV ⊗V → CV be the tensor bifunctor. We showed in [Ko2] that there is a morphism ιcl−op : T (Vcl ) → Vop in CV (see (3.81),(3.82) in [Ko2] for the definition). We define a morphism ιcl−op : T (Vcl ) → Vop as a composition of maps as follows: −1 T (ϕcl )
ιcl−op
ιcl−op : T (Vcl ) −−−−→ T (Vcl ) −−−→ Vop .
(3.44)
W3 By the universal property of the tensor product [HL1-HL4], VW and HomV (W1 1 W2 W2 , W3 ) for any three V -modules W1 , W2 , W3 are canonically isomorphic. Given a morphism m ∈ HomV (W1 W2 , W3 ), we denote the corresponding intertwining operator as Ym . Conversely, given an intertwining operator Y, we denote its corresponding morphism as m Y . Therefore, we have two intertwining operators Yιcl−op and Yιcl−op corresponding to morphisms ιcl−op and ιcl−op respectively.
Lemma 3.6. For z ∈ H, we have ιcl−op (z, z¯ )(er L (i),α ⊗ er R (i),β ) = e z¯ L(−1) Yιcl−op (er L (i),α , z − z¯ )er R (i),α .
(3.45)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
59
Proof. It is proved in [Ko2] that m Ycl−op = m Y f ◦ (ιcl−op idVop ).
(3.46)
op
Using (3.46), when z ∈ H, ζ ∈ H and |ζ | > |z − ζ | > 0, we have ιcl−op (z, ζ )(er L (i),α ⊗ er R (i),β ) = Ycl−op (er L (i),α ⊗ er R (i),β ; z, ζ )1op f
= Yop (Yιcl−op (er L (i),α , z − ζ )er R (i),β , ζ )1 = eζ L(−1) Yιcl−op (er L (i),α , z − ζ )er R (i),β . (3.47) By the convergence property of the iterate of two intertwining operators, the right hand side of (3.47) is a power series of ζ absolutely convergent for |ζ | > |z − ζ | > 0 . By the property of power series, the right hand side of (3.47) must converge absolutely for all z ∈ H, ζ ∈ H. Because analytic extension in a simply connected domain is unique, we obtain that the equality (3.47) holds for all z ∈ H, ζ ∈ H. When ζ = z¯ , we obtain (3.45). Now we consider both sides of the Cardy condition (3.30) for an open-closed field algebra over V . On the left hand side of (3.30), we have qs2 < 0. Using (1.25) and (3.33), we obtain, ∀v3 ∈ Vop , Yop (U(qs2 )v2 , qs2 )v3 = e−|qs2 |L(−1) Yop (v3 , |qs2 |) U(qs2 )v2 = −1 (Yop )(U(qs2 )v2 , eπi |qs2 |)v3 . f
(3.48)
Hence we can rewrite the left hand side of (3.30) as follows: f f TrVop Yop (U(qs1 )v1 , qs1 )−1 (Yop )(U(qs2 )e−2πi L(0) v2 , eπi |qs2 |)qτL(0)−c/24 (3.49) for qs1 > |qs2 | > |qτ | > 0. We have the following result for the right hand side of (3.30). Proposition 3.7. For s1 , s2 ∈ H, Re s1 = 0, Re s2 = 0, −
c
((T1L ⊗ T1R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 1 , z¯ 1 )(T2 v1 ), q 124 (T3L ⊗ T3R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 2 , z¯ 2 )(T4 v2 ))cl −τ L(0)
N cl 1 = TrWr R (i) e−2πi L(0) Y1 U(q− 1 s1 ) − v1 , q− 1 s1 τ τ τ i=1
1 L(0) L(0)− c Y2 U(q− 1 s2 ) − v2 , q− 1 s2 q 1 24 , −τ τ τ τ where Y1 and Y2 are intertwining operators of types
Wr R (i) Vop Wr (i)
and
L
tively and are given by Y1 = σ123 (Yιcl−op ) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idW
r L (i)
),
Y2 = 0 (σ132 (Yιcl−op )) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idWr R (i) ).
Wr (i) L Vop Wr R (i)
(3.50)
respec-
(3.51) (3.52)
60
L. Kong
Proof. Let z 3 := z 1 − z¯ 1 and z 4 := z 2 − z¯ 2 . By (2.28) and (3.45), the left hand side of (3.50) equals ((T1L ⊗ T1R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 1 , z¯ 1 )(T2 v1 ), (T3L ⊗ T3R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 2 , z¯ 2 )(T4 v2 ))cl =
Ncl
(T3L ⊗ T3R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 2 , z¯ 2 )(T4 v2 ), er L (i),α ⊗ er R (i),β
i=1 α,β
=
ϕcl−1 (er L (i),α ⊗ er R (i),β ), (T1L ⊗ T1R )∗ ι∗cl−op (z 1 , z¯ 1 )(T2 v1 )
Ncl
T4 v2 , ιcl−op (z 2 , z¯ 2 )(T3L er L (i),α ⊗ T3R er R (i),β )
i=1 α,β
=
ιcl−op (z 1 , z¯ 1 )(ϕcl−1 (T1L er L (i),α ⊗ T1R er R (i),β )), T2 v1
Ncl
=
cl
op
op
T4 v2 , e z¯ 2 L(−1) Yιcl−op (T3L er L (i),α , z 2 − z¯ 2 )T3R er R (i),β
e z¯ 1 L(−1) Yιcl−op (T1L er L (i),α , z 1 − z¯ 1 )T1R er R (i),β , T2 v1
Ncl
cl
i=1 α,β
op
op
ϕop (T4 v2 ), e z¯ 2 L(−1) Yιcl−op (T3L er L (i),α , z 2 − z¯ 2 )T3R er R (i),β
i=1 α,β
e z¯ 1 L(−1) Yιcl−op (T1L er L (i),α , z 1 − z¯ 1 )T1R er R (i),β , ϕop (T2 v1 ) =
Ncl
−1
e−z 4
L(−1)
σ123 (Yιcl−op )(ϕop (e−¯z 2 L(1) T4 v2 ), z 4−1 )
i=1 α,β −1
z 4−2L(0) e−z 4
L(1)
T3L er L (i),α , T3R er R (i),β −1
T1R er R (i),β , e−z 3 −2L(0) −z 3−1 L(1)
z3 =
e
Ncl
L(−1)
σ123 (Yιcl−op )(ϕop (e−¯z 1 L(1) T2 v1 ), z 3−1 )
T1L er L (i),α −2L(0) −z 4−1 L(1)
σ123 (Yιcl−op )(ϕop (e−¯z 2 L(1) T4 v2 ), z 4−1 )z 4
e
T3L er L (i),α ,
i=1 α,β −1
ez4
L(1)
−1
T3R er R (i),β er R (i),β , (T1R )∗ e−z 3
L(−1)
·
−2L(0) −z 3−1 L(1)
σ123 (Yιcl−op )(ϕop (e−¯z 1 L(1) T2 v1 ), z 3−1 )z 3 =
Ncl
−1
er L (i),α , (T3L )∗ e z 4
L(−1) −2L(0) ˜ z4 A0
e
T1L er L (i),α −1
◦ σ123 (Yιcl−op )(e−z 4
L(1) 2L(0) z4
·
i=1 α,β −1
ϕop (e−¯z 2 L(1) T4 v2 ), eπi z 4 )e z 4
L(1)
−1
T3R er R (i),β er R (i),β , (T1R )∗ e−z 3 −1
σ123 (Yιcl−op )(ϕop (e−¯z 1 L(1) T2 v1 ), z 3−1 )z 3−2L(0) e−z 3
L(1)
T1L er L (i),α .
L(−1)
· (3.53)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
61
We define two intertwining operators as follows: (0)
Y1
r L (i)
(0)
Y2
= σ123 (Yιcl−op ) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idW
),
= A˜ 0 (σ123 (Yιcl−op )) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idW
r R (i)
).
(3.54)
Using (3.21),(3.22),(3.23) and (3.24), we further obtain that the left hand side of (3.53) equals Ncl p L(0) s2 −2L(0) er L (i),α , (¯z 2 − z 2 ) L(0) z 4 · r i=1 α,β
1 L(0) (0) 2L(0) −L(0) Y2 (z 4 (¯z 2 − z 2 ) U(1) − v2 , eπi z 4 ) τ L(0) p −L(0) L(0) L(0) ps2 s1 z¯ 2 − z 2 er R (i),β er R (i),β , (z 1 − z¯ 1 ) r r L(0)
p −L(0) 1 s1 Y2(0) (z 3−L(0) U(1) − v1 , z 3−1 )z 3−L(0) er L (i),α τ r
=
Ncl
TrW
r L (i)
i=1
Y2(0) (U( ps2 )(−1/τ ) L(0) v2 , E 1 )E 2 Y1(0) (U( ps1 )(−1/τ ) L(0) v1 , ps1 ), (3.55)
where E 1 = ps2 (¯z 2 − z 2 )z 4−2 eπi z 4 and −2L(0)
(¯z 2 − z 2 ) L(0) z 4 E 2 = psL(0) 2
(¯z 2 − z 2 )
L(0)
ps2 L(0) ps1 −L(0) z 1 − z¯ 1
L(0) −L(0) −L(0) z3 ps1 .
For E 1 , since z 4−1 is obtained by operations on the intertwining operator where z 4 is treated formally, z 4−1 really means |z 4 |−1 e−i E 1 = ps2 e
3πi 2
πi 2
. Therefore, we have
e−πi eπi e
πi 2
= e2πi ps2 .
(3.56)
For E 2 , keep in mind (0.1) and (0.2), we have ps 2L(0) L(0) L(0) E 2 = 2 (¯z 2 − z 2 ) L(0) (z 2 − z¯ 2 )−2L(0) (¯z 2 − z 2 ) (z 1 − z¯ 1 ) (z 1 − z¯ 1 )−L(0) ps1 = q L(0) e 1 −τ
=q
L(0) − τ1
3πi 2
3πi πi πi L(0) −2 πi 2 L(0) − 2 L(0) − 2 L(0) − 2 L(0)
e
e
e
e
e−2πi L(0) .
Therefore, we obtain that the left hand side of (3.53) further equals L(0)
Ncl 1 (0) TrW 20 (Y2 ) U( ps2 ) − v2 , ps2 r L (i) τ i=1
1 L(0) L(0) −2πi L(0) (0) q 1 e Y1 v1 , ps1 , U( ps1 ) − −τ τ
(3.57)
(3.58)
62
L. Kong
where we have used the fact that Y(·, e2πi x)· = 20 (Y)(·, x)· for any intertwining operator Y. By using the property of trace, it is easy to see that (3.58) multiplying q
nothing but the right hand side of (3.50).
c − 24
− τ1
is
Remark 3.8. It is easy to check that the absolute convergence of the left hand side of (3.53) by our assumption easily implies the absolute convergence of each step in (3.53). Notice that the absolute convergence of the right side of (3.50) is automatic because V is assumed to satisfy the conditions in Theorem 0.1. Hence, by tracing back the steps in above the proof, we see that the absolute convergence of the left hand side of (3.50) is also automatic. Now we recall some results in [H9,H10]. We follow the notations in [HKo3]. We denote the unique analytic extension of c L(0)− 24
a ;(1)
TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(e2πi z )wa , e2πi z )qτ in the universal covering space of 1 > |qτ | > 0 as
c L(0)− 24
a ;(1)
E(TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(e2πi z )wa , e2πi z )qτ
).
By [Mi2,H9], above formula is independent of z. Consider the map: for wa ∈ Wa , a ;(1)
c L(0)− 24
a ;(1)
1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ) : wa → E(TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(e2πi z )wa , e2πi z )qτ
).
(3.59)
a ;(1)
We denote the right hand side of (3.59) as 1 (Yaa1 1 ;i )(wa ; z, τ ). Notice that we choose to add z in the notation even though it is independent of z. We define an action of S L(2, Z) on the map (3.59) as follows:
ab a ;(1) (1 (Yaa1 1 ;i )) (wa ; z, τ ) cd L(0)
c 1 L(0)− 24 a1 ;(1) 2πi z 2πi z = E TrWa1 Yaa1 ;i U(e ) wa , e qτ , (3.60) cτ + d where
τ
=
aτ +b cτ +d
and
z
=
z cτ +d ,
for
ab cd
∈ S L(2, Z) and wa ∈ Wa . The following
theorem is proved in [Mi2,H7]. ij
Theorem 3.9. There exists a unique Aa2 a3 ∈ C for a2 , a3 ∈ I such that, for wa ∈ Wa ,
a ;(1) TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i
E =
a3 ∈I
where τ =
aτ +b cτ +d
U(e
2πi z
1 ) cτ + d
L(0) wa , e
2πi z
c L(0)− 24
a2 ;(2) Aa1 a2 E(TrWa1 Yaa (U(e2πi z )wa , e2πi z )qτ 2; j ij
and z =
c L(0)− 24 qτ
z cτ +d .
),
(3.61)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
63
0 1 on (3.59) induces, for each a ∈ I, an −1 0 a1 automorphism on ⊕a1 ∈I Vaa 1 , denoted as S(a). Namely, we have
In particular, the action of S =
a ;(1)
a ;(1)
S(1 (Yaa1 1 ;i )) = 1 (S(a)(Yaa1 1 ;i )).
(3.62)
a1 Combining all such S(a), we obtain an automorphism on ⊕a,a1 ∈I Vaa 1 . We still denote it a3 a as S, i.e. S = ⊕a∈I S(a). Then S can be further extended to a map on ⊕a,a3 ∈I Vaa 3 ⊗Va1 a2 given as follows: a ;(1)
a ;(1)
a;(2)
a;(2)
S(Yaa3 3 ;i ⊗ Ya1 a2 ; j ) := S(Yaa3 3 ;i ) ⊗ Ya1 a2 ; j .
(3.63)
There is a fusing isomorphism map [H4]: ∼ =
a4 → ⊕b∈I Vba ⊗ Vab1 a2 F : ⊕a∈I Vaa14a ⊗ Vaa2 a3 − 3
(3.64)
for a1 , a2 , a3 , a4 ∈ I. Using the isomorphism F, we obtain a natural action of S on ⊕b,a3 Vaa13b ⊗ Vab2 a3 . It is shown in [H7] that the following 2-points genus-one correlation function, for a1 a a1 , a2 , a3 , a4 ∈ I, i = 1, . . . , Naa 1 , j = 1, . . . , Na2 a3 and wak ∈ Wak , k = 2, 3, a ;(1)
a;(2)
c L(0)− 24
TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(qz 2 )Ya2 a3 ; j (wa2 , z 1 − z 2 )wa3 , qz 2 )qτ
(3.65)
is absolutely convergent when 1 > |e2πi z 2 | > |qτ | > 0 and 1 > |e2πi(z 1 −z 2 ) | > 0 and single-valued in the chosen branch. It can be extended uniquely to a single-valued analytic function on the universal covering space of M12 = {(z 1 , z 2 , τ ) ∈ C3 |z 1 = z 2 + pτ + q, ∀ p, q ∈ Z , τ ∈ H}. This universal covering space is denoted by M˜ 12 . We denote this single-valued analytic function on M˜ 12 as a ;(1)
a;(2)
c L(0)− 24
E(TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(qz 2 )Ya2 a3 ; j (wa2 , z 1 − z 2 )wa3 , qz 2 )qτ
).
We denote the space spanned by such functions on M˜ 12 by G1;2 . a ;(1) a;(2) a1 a For Yaa1 1 ;i ∈ Vaa 1 and Ya2 a3 ; j ∈ Va2 a3 , we now define the following linear map: a ;(1)
a;(2)
2 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ) :
⊕b2 ,b3 ∈I Wb2 ⊗ Wb3 → G1;2
as follows: the map restricted on Wb2 ⊗ Wb3 is defined by 0 for b2 = a2 or b3 = a3 , and by c L(0)− 24
a1 ;(1) E(TrWa1 Yaa (U(qz 2 )Yaa;(2) (wa2 , z 1 − z 2 )wa3 , qz 2 )qτ 1 ;i 2 a3 ; j
),
(3.66)
for all wak ∈ Wak , k = 2, 3. The following identity was proved in [H9]:
1 L(0) 1 1 L(0) 1 1 a1 ;(1) a;(2) − − z1, − z2 ; − wa2 ⊗ − wa3 2 (Yaa1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ) τ τ τ τ τ a ;(1) a;(2) = 2 (S(Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ))(wa2 ⊗ wa3 ) (z 1 , z 2 , τ ). (3.67)
64
L. Kong
One can also produce 2-point genus-one correlation functions from a product of two intertwining operators. It is proved in [H7] that ∀wak ∈ Wak , k = 1, 2, a ;(1)
a ;(2)
c L(0)− 24
TrWa4 Ya14a3 ;i (U(qz 1 )wa1 , qz 1 )Ya23a4 ; j (U(qz 2 )wa2 , qz 2 )qτ
,
(3.68)
is absolutely convergent when 1 > |qz 1 | > |qz 2 | > |qτ | > 0. Equation (3.68) has a unique extension to the universal covering space M˜ 12 , denoted as a ;(1)
a ;(2)
c L(0)− 24
E(TrWa4 Ya14a3 ;i (U(qz 1 )wa1 , qz 1 )Ya23a4 ; j (U(qz 2 )wa2 , qz 2 )qτ
).
(3.69)
Such functions on M˜ 12 also span G1;2 . We define a map a ;(1)
a ;(2)
2 (Ya14a3 ;i ⊗ Ya23a4 ; j ) : ⊕b1 ,b2 ∈I Wb1 ⊗ Wb2 → G1;2
(3.70)
as follows: the map restricted on Wb1 ⊗ Wb2 is defined by 0 for b1 = a1 , b2 = a2 , and by (3.69) for wa1 ∈ Wa1 , wa2 ∈ Wa2 . It was proved by Huang in [H7] that the fusing isomorphism (3.64) gives the following associativity: c L(0)− 24
E(TrWa4 Yaa14a;(1) (U(qz 1 )wa1 , qz 1 )Yaa23a;(2) (U(qz 2 )wa2 , qz 2 )qτ 3 ;i 4; j a4 ;(1) a3 ;(2) a4 ;(3) F(Ya1 a3 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a4 ; j , Ya5 a4 ;k ⊗ Yaa15a;(4) ) = 2 ;l
)
a5 ∈I k,l
a ;(3)
a ;(4)
c L(0)− 24
E(TrWa4 Ya54a4 ;k (U(qz 2 )Ya15a2 ;l (wa1 , z 1 − z 2 )wa2 , qz 2 )qτ
), (3.71)
where F(Yaa14a;(1) ⊗ Yaa23a;(2) , Yaa54a;(3) ⊗ Yaa15a;(4) ) is the matrix representation of F in the 3 ;i 4; j 4 ;k 2 ;l
⊗ Yaa23a;(2) }i, j , {Yaa54a;(3) ⊗ Yaa15a;(4) }k,l . Therefore, ∀wak ∈ Wak , k = 1, 2, we basis {Yaa14a;(1) 3 ;i 4; j 4 ;k 2 ;l obtain
1 L(0) 1 1 L(0) 1 1 a3 ;(1) a;(2) − − z1, − z2 ; − 2 (Ya1 a;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ) wa1 ⊗ − wa2 τ τ τ τ τ a ;(1) a;(2) = 2 (S(Ya13a;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ))(wa1 ⊗ wa2 ) (z 1 , z 2 , τ ). (3.72)
Combining (3.49), (3.50), (3.51), (3.52) and (3.72) and Remark 3.8, we obtain a simpler version of the Cardy condition. Theorem 3.10. The Cardy condition can be rewritten as follows: θWr R (i) ◦ σ123 (Yιcl−op ) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idW ) ⊗ 0 (σ132 (Yιcl−op )) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idWr R (i) ) r L (i) f f −1 Yop ⊗ −1 (Yop ) ◦ (θVop ⊗ idVop ) . (3.73) =S 4. Modular Tensor Categories This section is independent of the rest of this work. The tensor product theory of modules over a vertex operator algebra has been developed by Huang and Lepowsky [HL1][HL4,H2]. In particular, the notion of vertex tensor category is introduced in [HL1]. Huang later proved in [H11] that CV is a modular tensor category for V satisfying conditions in Theorem 0.1. In Sect. 4.1, we review some basic ingredients of the modular tensor category CV . In Sect. 4.2, we show how to find in CV a graphical representation of the modular transformation S : τ → − τ1 discussed in Sect. 3.2.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
65
4.1. Preliminaries. We recall some ingredients of vertex tensor category CV and those of modular tensor category structure on CV constructed in [H11]. There is an associativity isomorphism A, A : W1 (W2 W3 ) → (W1 W2 ) W3 , for each triple of V -modules W1 , W2 , W3 . The relation between the fusing isomorphism F (recall (3.64)) and the associativity isomorphism A in CV is described by the following commutative diagram: ⊕a5 ∈I Vaa14a5 ⊗ Vaa25a3
∼ =
/ HomV (Wa1 (Wa2 Wa3 ), Wa4 ) (A−1 )∗
F
⊕a6 ∈I Vaa64a3 ⊗ Vaa16a2
(4.1)
∼ =
/ HomV ((Wa1
Wa2 ) Wa3 , Wa4 )
where the two horizontal maps are canonical isomorphisms induced from the universal property of . We recall the braiding structure on CV . For each pair of V -modules W1 , W2 , there is also a natural isomorphism, for z > 0, R+P(z) : W1 P(z) W2 → W2 P(z) W1 , defined by P(z)
R+
(w1 P(z) w2 ) = e L(−1) T γ+ (w2 P(−z) w1 ),
(4.2)
where γ+ is a path from −z to z inside the lower half plane as shown in the following graph
(4.3) P(z)
The inverse of R+
P(z)
is denoted by R− , which is characterized by
P(z) R− (w2 P(z) w1 ) = e L(−1) T γ− (w1 P(−z) w2 ),
(4.4)
where γ− is a path in the upper half plane as shown in the following graph
(4.5) P(1)
We denote R± simply as R± . The natural isomorphisms R± give CV two different braiding structures. We choose R+ as the default braiding structure on CV . Sometimes, we will denote it by (CV , R+ ) to emphasize our choice of braiding isomorphisms. Notice that our choice of R± follows that in [Ko2], which is different from that in [H8,H11,Ko1]. For each V -module W , (3.39) defines an automorphism θW : W → W
66
L. Kong
called a twist. A V -module W is said to have a trivial twist if θW = idW . The twist θ and braiding R+ satisfy the following three balancing axioms θW1 W2 = R+ ◦ R+ ◦ (θW1 θW2 ), θV = idV , θW = (θW )∗ ,
(4.6) (4.7) (4.8)
for any pair of V -modules W1 , W2 . a } be a basis of V a for all a ∈ I such that it coincides with the vertex operator Let {Yea ea a = Y . We choose a basis YWa , which defines the V -module structure on Wa , i.e. Yea Wa a } of V a as follows: {Yae ae a a = −1 (Yea ). Yae
(4.9)
e } of V e as We also choose a basis {Yaa aa e e a a ˆ Yaa = Yaa = A 0 (Yae ) = σ132 (Yea ).
(4.10)
Notice that these choices are made for all a ∈ I. In particular, we have
a Yaa e = −1 (Yea ),
Yae a = Yae a = Aˆ 0 (Yaa e ).
The following relation was proved in [Ko1]. e −2πi h a e Yae a = e2πi h a 0 (Yaa −1 (Yaa ) = e ).
(4.11)
W3 For any V -modules W1 , W2 , W3 and Y ∈ VW , we denote by m Y the morphism 1 W2 in HomV (W1 W2 , W3 ) associated to Y under the identification of two spaces induced by the universal property of . Now we recall the construction of duality maps [H11]. We will follow the convention in [Ko1]. Since CV is semisimple, we only need to discuss irreducible modules. For a ∈ I, the right duality maps ea : Wa Wa → V and i a : V → Wa Wa for a ∈ I are given by
ea = m Y e , m Y e ◦ i a = dim a idV , aa
aa
where dim a = 0 for a ∈ I (proved by Huang in [H10]). The left duality maps ea : W a Wa → V and i a : V → Wa W a are given by ea = m Y e , m Y e ◦ i a = dim a idV . aa aa In a ribbon category, there is a powerful tool called graphic calculus. One can express various morphisms in terms of graphs. In particular, the right duality maps i a and ea are denoted by the following graphs:
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
67
the left duality maps are denoted by
and the twist and its inverse, for any object W , are denoted by
The identity (4.11) proved in [Ko2] is nothing but the following identity:
(4.12) This formula (4.12) is implicitly used in many graphic calculations in this work. a
3 a ;(1) Na a
A basis {Ya13a2 ;i }i=11 2 of Vaa13a2 for a1 , a2 , a3 ∈ I induces a basis {eaa13a2 ;i } of Hom (Wa1 Wa2 , Wa3 ). One can also denote eaa13a2 ;i as the following graph:
(4.13) Note that we will always use a to represent Wa and a to represent Wa in graphs for simplicity. By the universal property of P(z) , the map 0 : Vaa13a2 → Vaa23a1 induces a linear map 0 : HomV (Wa1 Wa2 , Wa3 ) → HomV (Wa2 Wa1 , Wa3 ) given as follows:
(4.14) Let us choose a basis { f
a3 a 1 a 2 N a1 a2 a3 ; j j=1
}
of HomV (Wa3 , Wa1 Wa2 ), denoted by
(4.15) such that
(4.16)
68
L. Kong
The following identity is proved in [Ko1]
(4.17) We prove a similar identity below. Lemma 4.1.
(4.18) Proof. Using the first balancing axiom (4.6), we have
(4.19) Then the lemma follows from the following relations:
(4.20)
(4.21) Similar to 0 , A˜ 0 , σ123 and σ132 can also be described graphically as proved in [Ko1]. We recall these results below.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
69
Proposition 4.2. a2
a3 A˜0 :
i
i
a1
a2
a1
a3
(4.22)
(4.23)
(4.24) 4.2. Graphical representation of S : τ → − τ1 . In [HKo3], we defined an action of α, β a1 ;(1) ⊗ Yaa;(2) ). More precisely, on 2 (Yaa 1; p 2 a3 ;q a ;(1)
a;(2)
(4.25)
a ;(1)
a;(2)
(4.26)
α(2 (Yaa1 1 ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q )) : ⊕a2 ,a3 ∈I Wa2 ⊗ Wa3 → G1;2 , β(2 (Yaa1 1 ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q )) : ⊕a2 ,a3 ∈I Wa2 ⊗ Wa3 → G1;2 are defined by a ;(1)
a;(2)
(α(2 (Yaa1 1 ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q )))(w2 ⊗ w3 ) a ;(1)
a;(2) ))(w2 2 a2 ;q
= (2 (Yaa1 1 ; p ⊗ Ya
⊗ w3 ; z 1 , z 2 − 1; τ ),
a1 ;(1) (β((Yaa ⊗ Yaa;(2) )))(w2 ⊗ w3 ) 1; p 2 a3 ;q a1 ;(1) ⊗ Yaa;(2) ))(w2 ⊗ w3 ; z 1 , z 2 + τ ; τ ) = (2 (Yaa 1; p 2 a3 ;q
(4.27)
if w2 ⊗ w3 ∈ Wa2 ⊗ Wa3 , and by 0 if otherwise. a1 a We also showed in [HKo3] that α induces an automorphism on ⊕a∈I Vaa 1 ⊗ Va2 a3 given as follows: a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(3) b;(4) Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j → e−2πi h a3 F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) b,c∈A k,l, p,q a ;(3)
b;(4)
a ;(5)
c;(6)
F(Ya21b;k ⊗ 2−1 (Ya3 a1 ;l ); Yca11 ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q ) a ;(5)
c;(6)
Yca11 ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q .
(4.28)
a1 a We still denote this automorphism and its natural extension on ⊕a,a1 ∈I Vaa 1 ⊗ Va2 a3 by α. The following lemma follows immediately from (4.28).
70
L. Kong
Lemma 4.3. α can also be expressed graphically as follows:
(4.29) For β, we prefer to use maps A˜ 0 and Aˆ 0 defined in (3.35) instead of the map A0 used in [HKo3]. We obtain the following lemma, which is proved in the Appendix. a1 a Lemma 4.4. β also induces an automorphism on ⊕a,a1 ∈I Vaa 1 ⊗ Va2 a3 given by
a ;(1)
a;(2)
Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j →
b∈I k,l c∈I p,q
a ;(1)
a ;(3)
F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) a;(2)
b;(4)
a ;(3) b;(4) b ;(5) c;(6) F( A˜ 0 (Ya21b;k ) ⊗ A˜ 0 (Ya3 a1 ;l ), Ycb ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q )
b ;(5) c;(6) Aˆ 0 (Ycb ; p ) ⊗ 20 (Ya2 a3 ;q ).
(4.30)
We still denote this automorphism by β. Lemma 4.5. β can be expressed graphically as follows:
(4.31) Proof. Using (4.30), we can see that β is the composition of following maps
a1 a ⊕a,a1 ∈I Vaa 1 ⊗ Va2 a3
F −1
/ ⊕b,a ∈I V a1 ⊗ Vab a 1 a2 b 3 1
b ⊗ Vc o ⊕b,c∈I Vcb a2 a3
A˜ 0 ⊗ A˜ 0
/ ⊕b,a ∈I V b ⊗ V a1 (4.32) 1 a3 b a2 a1
Aˆ 0 ⊗20
F
b ⊗ Vc . ⊕b,c∈I Vcb a2 a3
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
71
By the commutative diagram (4.1), (4.32) can be rewritten graphically as follows:
(4.33) a1 a We have introduced S, α, β all as isomorphisms on ⊕a,a1 ∈I Vaa 1 ⊗Va2 a3 . They satisfy the following well-known equation [MSei1,MSei3,H10,HKo3]:
Sα = β S.
(4.34)
We proved in [HKo3] that S is determined by the identity (4.34) up to a constant See . We will solve Eq. (4.34) for S graphically below. Proposition 4.6.
(4.35) Proof. Since we know that Eq. (4.34) determines S up to an overall constant See , we only need to check that (4.35) gives a solution to (4.34).
72
L. Kong
Combining (4.31) with (4.35), we obtain that
(4.36) The diagram in the right hand side of (4.36) can be deformed as follows:
(4.37) By (4.18), we have
(4.38) On the other hand, combining (4.29) with (4.35), we obtain
(4.39) Notice the diagram on the right hand side of (4.39) is exactly a deformation of the diagram on the right hand side of (4.38). Hence we obtain that the map defined as (4.35) gives a solution to the equation Sα = β S. To determine S completely, we need to determine See . This can be done by using other identities satisfied by S. Proposition 4.7. a ;(1) a ;(1) S 2 (a)(Yaa1 1 ;i ) = A˜ 0 (Yaa1 1 ;i )
(4.40)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
73 a ;(1)
a1 Proof. By the definition of S-cation on Yaa1 1 ;i ∈ Vaa 1 , we have
1 (S
2
a1 ;(1) (a)(Yaa ))(wa ; z, τ ) 1 ;i
=
a1 ;(1) 1 (Yaa ) 1 ;i
τ
L(0)
−1 τ
L(0) wa ; −z, τ
(4.41)
for wa ∈ Wa . Keep in mind our convention on the branch cut for a logarithm. We have
τ L(0)
−1 τ
L(0)
wa = eπi L(0) wa .
Hence we obtain a ;(1)
a ;(1)
1 (S 2 (a)(Yaa1 1 ;i ))(wa ; z, τ ) = 1 (Yaa1 1 ;i )(eπi L(0) wa ; −z, τ ).
(4.42)
By (A.47), we also have a ;(1)
1 (Yaa1 1 ;i )(eπi L(0) wa ; −z, τ ) c L(0)− 24 a ;(1) = E TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(e−2πi z )eπi L(0) wa , e−2πi z )qτ c L(0)− 24 a1 ;(1) = E Tr(Wa1 ) A˜ 0 (Yaa )(eπi L(0) U(e2πi z )wa , eπi e2πi z )qτ 1 ;i c L(0)− 24 a ;(1) = E Tr(Wa1 ) A˜ 0 (Yaa1 1 ;i )(U(e2πi z )wa , e2πi z )qτ a1 ;(1) ))(wa ; z, τ ). = 1 ( A˜ 0 (Yaa 1 ;i
(4.43)
Therefore, combining (4.42) and (4.43), we obtain (4.40).
The following lemma is proved in [BK2]. Lemma 4.8. Let D 2 = a∈I dim2 a. Then D = 0 and we have
(4.44) Proposition 4.9. (See )2 =
1 . D2
(4.45)
Proof. By (4.35), we have
(4.46)
74
L. Kong
Apply (4.12) to the graph in the right hand side of (4.46), we obtain
(4.47) By (4.44), the right-hand side of (4.47) equals
(4.48) By (4.40) and (4.22), we obtain (4.45).
So far, we have determined See up to a sign. Now we consider the relation between S and another generator of the modular group T : τ → τ + 1. We define a T -action on a1 1 (Yaa ) as follows: 1 ;i a1 a1 T (1 (Yaa ))(wa ; z, τ ) := 1 (Yaa )(wa ; z, τ + 1). 1 ;i 1 ;i
(4.49)
a1 It is clear that this action induces an action of T on Vaa 1 for all a, a1 ∈ I, given by c
2πi(h a − 24 ) a1 = e , T |Vaa
(4.50)
1
where h a is the lowest conformal weight of Wa . Lemma 4.10. S and T satisfy the following relation: (T −1 S)3 = S 2 = T −1 S 2 T.
(4.51)
Proof. Let wa ∈ Wa . We have a1 ;(1) (T −1 S)3 ((1 (Yaa ;i )))(wa ; z, τ ) ⎛1 ⎞ L(0)
L(0) −1 −1 a1 ;(1) ⎝ L(0) ) τ wa , −z, τ ⎠ . = 1 (Yaa −1 1 ;i τ − 1 − 1 τ −1
(4.52)
Keeping in mind our choice of branch cut, then it is easy to show that τ
L(0)
−1 −1 τ −1
−1
L(0)
−1 τ −1
L(0)
wa = eπi L(0) wa .
By (4.42), we obtain the first equality of (4.51). The proof of the second equality (4.51) is similar.
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
Proposition 4.11. Let p± =
See =
a∈I
75
e±2πi h a dim2 a. Then we have
1 2πic/8 1 −2πic/8 e = e . p− p+
(4.53)
Proof. In the proof of Theorem 3.1.16 in [BK2], Bakalov and Kirillov proved an identity, which, in our own notation, can be written as follows: c 2c 1 1 p+ e−2πi 24 ST −1 S = e 2 e2πi 24 T ST. (See )2 D 2 Se D
By (4.51) and the fact p− p+ = D 2 which is proved in [BK2], we simply obtain that See =
1 2πic/8 e . p−
Using (4.45) and p+ p− = D 2 , we also obtain the second equality.
We thus define D := p− e−2πic/8 = p+ e2πic/8 .
(4.54) D 2 . Then the action of mod-
Notice that this notation is compatible with the definition of ular transformation S(a) on ⊕a1 ∈I HomV (Wa Wa1 , Wa1 ) can be expressed graphically as follows:
(4.55) Proposition 4.12.
(4.56) Proof. Composing the map (4.55) with (4.56), we obtain a map given as follows:
(4.57) Apply (4.44) to the graph in (4.57), it is easy to see that the above map is the identity map. Remark 4.13. Bakalov and Kirillov obtained the same formula (4.55) in [BK2] by directly working with the modular tensor category and solving equations obtained in the so-called Lego-Teichmüller game [BK1]. In our approach, we see the direct link between the modular transformations of q-traces of the product (or iterate) of intertwining operators and their graphic representations in a modular tensor category.
76
L. Kong
Proposition 4.14.
(4.58)
(4.59) Proof. We only prove (4.58). The proof of (4.59) is analogous to that of (4.58). It is enough to show that the pairing between the image of (4.35) and that of (4.58) still gives δi j . This can be proved as follows:
(4.60) By (4.44), the right hand side of (4.60) equals
5. Categorical Formulations and Constructions In this section, we give a categorical formulation of modular invariant conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V L , open-string vertex operator algebra over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms and Cardy condition. Then we introduce a notion called Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra. In the end, we give a categorical construction of such an algebra in the Cardy case [FFFS2]. 5.1. Modular invariant CV L ⊗V R -algebras. We first recall the notion of coalgebra and Frobenius algebra ([FS]) in a tensor category. Definition 5.1. A coalgebra A in a tensor category C is an object with a coproduct ∈ Mor(A, A ⊗ A) and a counit ∈ Mor(A, 1C ) such that ( ⊗ id A ) ◦ = (id A ⊗ ) ◦ , ( ⊗ id A ) ◦ = id A = (id A ⊗ ) ◦ , which can also be expressed in term of the following graphic equations:
(5.1)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
77
Definition 5.2. Frobenius algebra in C is an object that is both an algebra and a coalgebra and for which the product and coproduct are related by (id A ⊗ m) ◦ ( ⊗ id A ) = ◦ m = (m ⊗ id A ) ◦ (id A ⊗ ),
(5.2)
or as the following graphic equations:
(5.3) A Frobenius algebra is called symmetric if the following condition is satisfied:
(5.4) Let V L and V R be vertex operator algebras satisfying the conditions in Theorem 0.1. Then the vertex operator algebra V L ⊗ V R also satisfies the conditions in Theorem 0.1 [HKo1]. Thus CV L ⊗V R also has a structure of modular tensor category. In particular, we choose the braiding structure on CV L ⊗V R to be R+− which is defined in [Ko2]. The twist θ+− for each V L ⊗ V R -module is defined by θ+− = e−2πi L
L (0)
⊗ e2πi L
R (0)
.
(5.5)
Duality maps are naturally induced from those of CV L and CV R . The following theorem is proved in [Ko1]. Theorem 5.3. The category of conformal full field algebras over V L ⊗V R equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms is isomorphic to the category of commutative Frobenius algebra in CV L ⊗V R with a trivial twist. Remark 5.4. In a ribbon category, it was proved in [FFRS] that a commutative Frobenius algebra with a trivial twist is equivalent to a commutative symmetric Frobenius algebra. Let I L and I R denote the set of equivalent class of irreducible V L -modules and R V -modules respectively. We use a and ai for i ∈ N to denote elements in I L and we use e to denote the equivalent class of V L . We use a¯ and a¯ i for i ∈ N to denote elements in I R , and e¯ to denote the equivalent class of V R . For each a ∈ I L (a¯ ∈ I R ), we choose a representative Wa (Wa¯ ). We denote the vector space of intertwining operators of type Wa W¯ 3 3 and W aW as Vaa13a2 and V¯ aa¯¯13a¯ 2 respectively, the fusion rule as Naa13a2 and Na¯a¯13a¯ 2 Wa 1 Wa 2 a¯ 1 a¯ 2 respectively. A conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R , denoted as Acl , is a direct sum of irreducible modules of V L ⊗ V R , i.e. N Acl = ⊕α=1 Wr (α) ⊗ Wr¯ (α) ,
(5.6)
78
L. Kong
c } where r : {1, . . . , N } → I L and r¯ : {1, . . . , N } → I R , for some N ∈ Z+ . Let {eab;i ¯ and {e¯c¯ } be basis for V c and V¯ c¯ , and { f ab } and { f¯a¯ b } be the dual basis respectively. ¯ j a¯ b;
a¯ b¯
ab
c; ¯ j
c;i
Then the vertex operator Y can also be expanded as follows: γ r¯ (γ ); j r (α)r (β) r¯ (α)¯r (β) r (γ );i Y= dαβ ( fr (γ );i , f¯r¯ (γ ); j ) er (α)r (β) ⊗ e¯r¯ (α)¯r (β) ,
(5.7)
α,β,γ i, j
γ
where dαβ defines a bilinear map r (γ ) r¯ (γ ) (Vr (α)r (β) )∗ ⊗ (V¯ r¯ (α)¯r (β) )∗ → C
for all α, β, γ = 1, . . . , N for some N ∈ N. diag Since the trace function picks out γ = β terms, we define Yα by β r¯ (β); j r (α)r (β) r¯ (α)¯r (β) r (β);i Ydiag := dαβ ( fr (β);i , f¯r¯ (β); j ) er (α)r (β) ⊗ e¯r¯ (α)¯r (β) . α β
(5.8)
i, j
diag Let Ydiag := α Yα . Of course, it is obvious to see that such defined Ydiag is independent of the choice of basis. We denote the representation of the modular transformation b b¯ L R ¯ respectively. S : τ → −1 ¯ I R Va¯ b¯ , by S (a) and S (a) τ on ⊕b∈I L Vab and ⊕b∈ In [HKo3], we defined the notion of modular invariant conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R (see [HKo3] for the precise definition). It basically means that the n-point genus-one correlation functions built out of q-q-traces ¯ are invariant under the action of modular group S L(2, Z) for all n ∈ N. Moreover, we proved the following results in [HKo3]. Proposition 5.5. Acl , a conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R , is modular invariant if it satisfies c L − c R = 0 mod 24 and = Ydiag S L (r (α)) ⊗ (S R (¯r (α)))−1 Ydiag α α
(5.9)
for all α = 1, . . . , N . We denote the morphism in HomC V L ⊗V R (Wr (α) ⊗ Wr¯ (α) ) (Wr (β) ⊗ Wr¯ (β) ), Wr (β) ⊗ Wr¯ (β) diag
which corresponds to Yα gorical condition:
by m Ydiag . Then (5.9) is equivalent to the following cateα
S L (r (α)) ⊗ (S R (¯r (α)))−1 m Ydiag = m Ydiag α
α
(5.10)
for all α = 1, . . . , N . Acl a⊗a;i ¯ Now we choose a basis {ba⊗ a;i ¯ } of HomC V L ⊗V R (Wa ⊗ Wa¯ , Acl ) and a basis {b Acl } of HomC V L ⊗V R (Acl , Wa ⊗ Wa¯ ) as follows:
(5.11)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
79
satisfying the following conditions: for all a ∈ I L , a¯ ∈ I R ,
(5.12) Then the condition (5.10) can be further expressed graphically as follows:
(5.13) for all a ∈ I L , a¯ ∈ I R , where D L and D R are the D defined by (4.54) in CV L and CV R respectively. Definition 5.6. Let V L and V R be so that c L − c R = 0 mod 24. A modular invariant CV L ⊗V R -algebra is an associative algebra (A, µ A , ι A ) satisfying the condition (5.13). Some properties of the modular invariant algebra follow immediately from the above definition, such as the following famous condition [MSei3]: a∈I L ,a∈ ¯ IR
(S L (e))ab Nbb¯ (S R (e)) ¯ −1 = Na a¯ , b¯ a¯
(5.14)
where Na a¯ is the multiplicity of Wa ⊗ Wa¯ in Acl for a ∈ I L , a¯ ∈ I R . We leave a more systematic study of modular invariant CV L ⊗V R -algebras to elsewhere. Theorem 5.7. Let V L and V R be so that c L − c R = 0 mod 24. The following two notions are equivalent: 1. modular invariant conformal full field algebra over V L ⊗ V R equipped with a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form, 2. modular invariant commutative Frobenius algebra with a trivial twist. Proof. The theorem follows from Theorem 5.3 and the equivalence between (5.9) and (5.13) immediately.
80
L. Kong
Remark 5.8. In the case V L ∼ =C∼ = V R , a modular invariant commutative Frobenius algebra with a trivial twist in CV L ⊗V R is simply a commutative Frobenius algebra over C, which is equivalent to a 2-dimensional topological field theory (see for example [BK2]). In this case, the modular invariance condition holds automatically.
5.2. Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebras. For an open-string vertex operator algebra Vop over V equipped with a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form (·, ·)op , there is an isomorphism ϕop : Vop → Vop induced from (·, ·)op (recall (3.40)). f In this case, Vop is a V -module and Yop is an intertwining operator. By comparing (1.26) with (3.37), and (1.27) with (3.38), we see that the conditions (1.26) and (1.27) can be rewritten as −1 Yop = ϕop ◦ σ123 (Yop ) ◦ (ϕop ⊗ idVop )
(5.15)
−1 ◦ σ132 (Yop ) ◦ (idop ⊗ ϕop ). = ϕop
(5.16)
f
f
f
Remark 5.9. The representation theory of the open-string vertex operator algebra can f a right V -module structure and be developed. In that context, σ123 (Yop ) gives Vop op Eq. (5.15) is equivalent to the statement that ϕop is an isomorphism between two right f a left V -module structure and Eq. (5.16) Vop -modules. Similarly, σ132 (Yop ) gives Vop op is equivalent to the statement that ϕop is an isomorphism between two left Vop -modules. But we do not need it in this work. Theorem 5.10. The category of open-string vertex operator algebras over V equipped with a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form is isomorphic to the category of symmetric Frobenius algebras in CV . Proof. We have already shown in [HKo1] that an open-string vertex operator algebra over V is equivalent to an associative algebra in CV . Let Vop be an open-string vertex operator algebra over V . Giving a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form (recall (1.26) and (1.27)) on Vop is equivalent to giving an satisfying the conditions (5.15) and (5.16). If we define isomorphism ϕop : Vop → Vop
(5.17)
(5.18)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
81
then (5.15) and (5.16) can be rewritten as
(5.19)
(5.20) Using the map ϕop and its inverse, we can obtain a natural coalgebra structure on F defined as follows:
(5.21) Similar to the proof of [Ko1, thm.4.15], (5.19) and (5.20) imply that such defined Vop and Vop give Vop a Frobenius algebra structure. Moreover, we also showed in [Ko1] that (5.19) implies the equality between ϕop and the left hand side of (5.4). Similarly, using (5.20), we can show that the right hand side of (5.4) also equals ϕop . Thus Vop has a structure of symmetric Frobenius algebra. We thus obtain a functor from the first category to the second category. Conversely, given a symmetric Frobenius algebra in CV , in [HKo1], we showed that it gives an open-string vertex operator algebra over V . It is shown in [FRS2] that either side of (5.4) is an isomorphism. Take ϕop to be either side of (5.4). Then (5.19) and (5.20) follow automatically from the definition (5.17) and (5.18). They are nothing but the invariance properties (recall (5.15)(5.16)) of the bilinear form associated with ϕop . Thus we obtain a functor from the second category to the first category. It is routine to check that these two functors are inverse to each other. Now we consider an open-closed field algebra over V given in (2.12) equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms (·, ·)op and (·, ·)cl . We assume that Vcl and Vop have the following decompositions: N
Ncl op Vcl = ⊕i=1 Wr L (i) ⊗ Wr R (i) , Vop = ⊕i=1 Wr (i) ,
where r L , r R : {1, . . . , Ncl } → I and r : {1, . . . , Nop } → I. We denote the embedding V
(i)
Vcl : Wr L (i) Wr R (i) → b(i)op : Wr (i) → Vop , the projection bVop : Vop → Wr (i) and b(i)
82
L. Kong
T (Vcl ) by the following graphs:
(5.22) We denote the map ιcl−op : T (Vcl ) → Vop [Ko2] by the following graph:
(5.23) Now we can express the Cardy condition (3.73) in graphs. The left hand side of (3.73) can be expressed by:
(5.24) By the universal property of tensor product, for ai ∈ I, i = 1, . . . , 6, we have a canonical isomorphism: ∼ =
⊕a∈I Vaa14a ⊗ Vaa2 a3 − → HomV (Wa1 (Wa2 Wa3 ), Wa4 ) Y1 ⊗ Y2 → m Y1 ◦ (idWa1 m Y2 ).
(5.25)
Under this canonical isomorphism, the Cardy condition (3.73) can be viewed as a condition on two morphisms in HomV (Vop (Vop Wr R (i) ), Wr R (i) ). In particular, the left hand side of (3.73) viewed as a morphism in HomV (Vop (Vop Wr R (i) ), Wr R (i) ) can be expressed as follows:
(5.26)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
83
We define a morphism ι∗cl−op : Vop → T (Vcl ) by
(5.27) Then using the morphism
ι∗cl−op ,
we can rewrite the graph in (5.26) as follows:
(5.28) Using (4.55), (5.26) and (5.28), we obtain a graphic version of the Cardy condition (3.73) as follows:
(5.29) Using the Frobenius properties of Vop , one can show that (5.29) is equivalent to the following condition:
(5.30) The asymmetry between chiral and antichiral parts in (5.29)(5.30) is superficial. Using (4.44), one can show that (5.30) is further equivalent to the following condition:
(5.31) We recall a definition in [Ko2].
84
L. Kong
Definition 5.11. An open-closed CV |CV ⊗V -algebra, denoted as (Aop |Acl , ιcl−op ), consists of a commutative symmetric associative algebra Acl in CV ⊗V , an associative algebra Aop in CV and an associative algebra morphism ιcl−op : T (Vcl ) → Vop , satisfying the following condition:
(5.32) The following theorem is proved in [Ko2]. Theorem 5.12. The category of open-closed field algebras over V is isomorphic to the category of open-closed CV |CV ⊗V -algebras. Definition 5.13. A Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra is an open-closed CV |CV ⊗V -algebra (Aop |Acl , ιcl−op ) such that Acl is modular invariant commutative symmetric Frobenius algebra in CV ⊗V and Aop a symmetric Frobenius algebra in CV and the Cardy condition (5.30) or (5.31) hold. Remark 5.14. Notice that, in the case V = C, the Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra (using (5.31)) exactly coincides with the usual algebraic formulation of 2-dimensional open-closed topological field theory [La,Mo1,Mo2,Se2,MSeg,AN,LP]. As we discussed in the introduction, we believe that open-closed partial conformal field theories of all genus satisfying the V -invariant boundary condition [Ko2] are classified by Cardy CV |CV ⊗V algebras. The following result is clear. Theorem 5.15. The category of open-closed field algebras over V equipped with nondegenerate invariant bilinear forms and satisfying the modular invariance condition and the Cardy condition is isomorphic to the category of Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebras. Definition 5.16. A V -invariant D-brane associated to a closed algebra Acl in CV ⊗V is a pair (Aop , ιcl−op ) such that the triple (Aop |Acl , ιcl−op ) gives a Cardy CV |CV ⊗V algebra. D-branes usually form a category as we will see in an example in the next subsection. 5.3. Constructions. In this section, we give a categorical construction of Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra. This construction is called the Cardy case in the physics literature [FFFS2]. Let us first recall the diagonal construction of the close algebra Vcl [FFRS,HKo2, Ko1,HKo3]. We will follow the categorical construction given in [Ko1]. Let Vcl be the object in CV ⊗V given as follows: Vcl = ⊕a∈I Wa ⊗ Wa .
(5.33)
The decomposition of Vcl as a direct sum gives a natural embedding V ⊗ V → Vcl . We denote this embedding as ιcl . We define a morphism µcl ∈ HomV ⊗V (Vcl Vcl , Vcl ) by
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
µcl =
a
Na13a2
a1 ,a2 ,a3 ∈A i, j=1
a a2 ; j
where eaa13a2 ;i and f a31 pairing given by
85
a a
a
f aa31;ia2 , f a 1; j2 eaa13a2 ;i ⊗ ea3 a ; j , 3
(5.34)
1 2
are basis vectors given in (4.13) and (4.15) and ·, · is a bilinear
(5.35) Notice that Vcl has the same decomposition as Vcl in (5.33). They are isomorphic as V ⊗ V -modules. There is, however, no canonical isomorphism. Now we choose a particular isomorphism ϕcl : Vcl → Vcl given by ϕcl = ⊕a∈I
D e−2πi h a idWa ⊗Wa . dim a
(5.36)
The isomorphism ϕcl induces a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form on Vcl viewed as V ⊗ V -module. The following theorem is a categorical version of Theorem 5.1 in [HKo3]. We give a categorical proof here. Theorem 5.17. (Vcl , µcl , ιcl ) together with the isomorphism ϕcl gives a modular invariant commutative Frobenius algebra in CV ⊗V with a trivial twist. Proof. It was proved in [Ko1] that (Vcl , µcl , ιcl ) together with the isomorphism ϕcl gives a commutative Frobenius algebra with a trivial twist. It remains to show the modular invariance. First, the bilinear pairing ·, · given in (5.35) can be naturally extended to a bilinear form, still denoted as ·, ·, on ⊕a,a1 ∈I (Wa1 , Wa Wa1 ) as follows: aa
1 1 1 f aaa , f bbb := δab δa1 b1 f aaa , f a ; j1 . 1 ;i 1; j 1 ;i
(5.37)
1
Then it is easy to see that to prove the modular invariance of Vcl is equivalent to prove that the bilinear form ·, · on ⊕a,a1 ∈I (Wa1 , Wa Wa1 ) defined above is invariant under 1 1 the action of (S −1 )∗ ⊗ S ∗ . Clearly, when b = a , (S −1 (a))∗ f aaa , (S(b))∗ f bbb = 0. 1 ;i 1; j When b = a , we have (using (4.58), (4.59) and (4.44))
86
L. Kong
Now we define Vop . Let X be a V -module. Let e X : X X → V and i X : V → X X be the duality maps defined in [Ko1]. Vop := X X has a natural structure of symmetric Frobenius algebra [FS] with ιop := i X , µop := id X e X id X , op := e X and op := id X i X id X . Now we define a map ιcl−op : T (Vcl ) → Vop by
(5.38)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
87
Lemma 5.18.
(5.39) Proof. By (5.27) and (5.38), we have
(5.40) It is easy to see that the last figure in (5.40) can be deformed to that on the right hand side of (5.39). Theorem 5.19. (Vcl , Vop , ιcl−op ) is a Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra. Proof. Recall that T (Vcl ) together with the multiplication morphism µT (Vcl ) = T (µcl )◦ ϕ2 and the morphism ιT (Vcl ) = T (ιcl ) ◦ ϕ0 is an associative algebra. We first prove that ιcl−op is an algebra morphism. It is clear that ιcl−op ◦ ιT (Vcl ) = ιop . It remains to show the following identity ιcl−op ◦ µT (Vcl ) = µop ◦ (ιcl−op ιcl−op ).
(5.41)
By the definition of ϕ2 , that of µcl and (5.38), we obtain
(5.42) It is easy to see that the right hand side of (5.42) equals
(5.43)
88
L. Kong
Using (4.17) to sum up the indices c1 and i, we obtain that (5.43) further equals
(5.44) Using (4.17) again, we obtain
(5.45) the right hand side of which is nothing but µop ◦ (ιcl−op ιcl−op ). The commutativity (5.32) follows from the following identity:
(5.46) In summary, we have proved that the triple (Vcl , Vop , ιcl−op ) is an open-closed CV |CV ⊗V -algebra. It remains to show that the Cardy condition (5.30) holds. We use (5.38), (5.39) and the definition of µop and op to express both sides of (5.30) graphically. Then it is easy to see that both sides are the deformations of each other. Theorem 5.19 reflects the general fact that consistent open theories (or D-branes) for a given closed theory are not unique. Instead they form a category. There are many good questions one can ask about Cardy CV |CV ⊗V -algebra, for example its relation to the works of Fuchs, Runkel, Schweigert and Fjelstad [FS,FRS1-FRS4,FjFRS1,FjFRS2]. We leave such topics to [KR] and future publications. A. The Proof of Lemma 4.30 Lemma A.1. For w1 ∈ Wa1 , wa ∈ Wa2 and wa 3 ∈ (Wa3 ) and Yaa13a2 ∈ Vaa13a2 , we have wa 3 , Y(U(x)wa1 , x)wa2 = A˜ r (Y)(U(e(2r +1)πi x −1 )e−(2r +1)πi L(0) wa1 , e(2r +1)πi x −1 )wa 3 , wa2 .
(A.47)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
89
Proof. Using the definition of Aˆ r , we see that the left hand side of (A.47) equals A˜ r (Y)(e−x L(1) x −2L(0) U(x)wa1 , e(2r +1)πi x −1 )wa 3 , wa2 .
(A.48)
In [H8], the following formula e x L(1) x −2L(0) e(2r +1)πi L(0) U(x)e−(2r +1)πi L(0) = U(x −1 )
(A.49)
is proved. Applying (A.49) to (A.48), we obtain (A.47) immediately. Now we are ready to give a proof of Lemma 4.4. Proof. We have, for wa2 ∈ Wa2 , wa3 ∈ Wa3 , a1 ;(1) ⊗ Yaa;(2) ))(wa2 ⊗ wa3 ))(z 1 , z 2 + τ, τ ) ((2 (Yaa 1 ;i 2 a3 ; j a ;(1) = E TrWa1 Yaa1 1 ;i (U(e2πi(z 2 +τ ) )· L(0)−
c
24 (wa2 , z 1 − (z 2 + τ ))wa3 , e2πi(z 2 +τ ) )qτ ·Yaa;(2) 2 a3 ; j a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(3) b;(4) F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) =
b∈I k,l
a ;(3) E TrWa1 Ya21b;k (U(e2πi z 1 )wa2 , e2πi z 1 ) c L(0)− 24
·Ya3 a1 ;l (U(e2πi(z 2 +τ ) )wa3 , e2πi(z 2 +τ ) )qτ b;(4)
.
(A.50) b;(4)
Using the L(0)-conjugation formula, we can move qτ from the right side of Ya3 a1 ;l to the left side of Yab;(4) . Then using the following property of trace: 3 a1 ;l TrWa1 (AB) = TrWb (B A),
(A.51)
for all A : Wb → Wa1 , B : Wa1 → Wb whenever the multiple sums in either side of (A.51) converge absolutely, we obtain that the left hand side of (A.50) equals a1 ;(1) ;(3) F −1 (Yaa ⊗ Yaa;(2) ; Yaa21b;k ⊗ Yab;(4) ) 1 ;i 2 a3 ; j 3 a1 ;l b∈I k,l
c L(0)− 24 b;(4) a ;(3) . E TrWb Ya3 a1 ;l (U(e2πi z 2 )wa3 , e2πi z 2 )Ya21b;k (U(e2πi z 1 )wa2 , e2πi z 1 )qτ (A.52)
Now apply (A.47) to (A.52). We then obtain that (A.52) equals a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(3) b;(4) F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) b∈I k,l
a ;(3) E Tr(Wb ) A˜ r (Ya21b;k )(U(e(2r +1)πi e−2πi z 1 )e−(2r +1)πi L(0) wa2 , e(2r +1)πi e−2πi z 1 )
c L(0)− 24 b;(4) . A˜ r (Ya3 a1 ;l )(U(e(2r +1)πi e−2πi z 2 )e−(2r +1)πi L(0) wa3 , e(2r +1)πi e−2πi z 2 )qτ
90
L. Kong
Now apply the associativity again and be careful about the branch cut as in [H8], then the left hand side of (A.50) further equals to a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(3) b;(4) F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) b∈I k,l c∈I p,q
a ;(3) b;(4) b ;(5) c;(6) ×F( A˜ r (Ya21b;k ) ⊗ A˜ r (Ya3 a1 ;l ), Ycb ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q ) c L(0)− 24 b ;(5) ×E Tr(Wb ) qτ Ycb ; p (U(e(2r +1)πi e−2πi z 2 )
c;(6) ·Ya2 a3 ;q (e−(2r +1)πi L(0) wa2 , eπi (z 1 − z 2 ))e−(2r +1)πi L(0) wa3 , e(2r +1)πi e−2πi z 2 ) . a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(3) b;(4) = F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) b∈I k,l c∈I p,q
a ;(3) b;(4) b ;(5) c;(6) ×F( A˜ r (Ya21b;k ) ⊗ A˜ r (Ya3 a1 ;l ), Ycb ; p ⊗ Ya2 a3 ;q ) c L(0)− 24 b ;(5) ×E TrWb qτ Aˆ r (Ycb ; p )(e(2r +1)πi L(0)
−(2r +1)πi L(0) πi −(2r +1)πi L(0) 2πi z 2 ×Yac;(6) (e w , e (z − z ))e w , e ) . a 1 2 a 2 3 a ;q 2 3
(A.53)
Choosing r = 0 and using Y(·, e2πi x)· = 20 (Y)(·, x)·, we obtain a ;(1)
a;(2)
((2 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ))(wa2 ⊗ wa3 ))(z 1 , z 2 + τ, τ ) a ;(1) a;(2) a ;(3) b;(4) F −1 (Yaa1 1 ;i ⊗ Ya2 a3 ; j ; Ya21b;k ⊗ Ya3 a1 ;l ) = b∈I k,l c∈I p,q
;(3) b ;(5) c;(6) ×F( A˜ 0 (Yaa21b;k ) ⊗ A˜ 0 (Yab;(4) ), Ycb ; p ⊗ Ya a ;q ) 3 a1 ;l 2 3 c L(0)− 24 b ;(5) c;(6) 2 ˆ ×E TrWb A0 (Ycb ; p )(0 (Ya2 a3 ;q )(wa2 , z 1 − z 2 )wa3 , e2πi z 2 )qτ .
(A.54) By the linear independency proved in [H10] of the last factor in each term of the above sum, it is clear that β induces a map given by (4.30). Acknowledgement. The results in Sect. 2.4 and 3.1 are included in author’s thesis. I want to thank my advisor Yi-Zhi Huang for introducing me to this interesting field and for his constant support and many important suggestions for improvement. I thank C. Schweigert for telling me the meaning of boundary states from a physical point of view. I also want to thank I. Frenkel, J. Fuchs, A. Kirillov, Jr. and C. Schweigert for some inspiring conversations on the subject of Sect. 4.2.
References [AN] [BHL] [BK1] [BK2] [C1]
Alexeevski, A., Natanzon, S.M.: Noncommutative two-dimensional topological field theories and hurwitz numbers for real algebraic curves. Sel. Math. 12(3–4), 377–397 (2006) Barron, K., Huang, Y.-Z., Lepowsky, J.: Factorization of formal exponential and uniformization. J. Alg. 228, 551–579 (2000) Bakalov, B., Kirillov, Jr., A.: On the lego-teichmüller game. Transform. Groups 5, 207 (2000) Bakalov, B., Kirillov, Jr., A.: Lectures on Tensor Categories and Modular Functors. University Lecture Series, Vol. 21, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 2001 Cardy, J.L.: Conformal invariance and surface critical behavior. Nucl. Phys. B 240, 514–532 (1984)
Cardy Condition for Open-Closed Field Algebras
[C2]
91
Cardy, J.L.: Effect of boundary conditions on the operator content of two-dimensional conformally invariant theories. Nucl. Phys. B275, 200–218 (1986) [C3] Cardy, J.L.: Operator content of two-dimensional conformal invariant theories. Nucl. Phys. B270, 186–204 (1986) [C4] Cardy, J.L.: Boundary conditions, fusion rules and the verlinde formula. Nucl. Phys. B324, 581–596 (1989) [DLM] Dong, C.-Y., Li, H.-S., Mason, G.: Modular-invariance of trace functions in orbifold theory and generalized moonshine. Commun. Math. Phys. 214, 1–56 (2000) [FFFS1] Felder, G., Fröhlich, J., Fuchs, J., Schweigert, C.: The geometry of wzw branes. J. Geom. Phys. 34, 162–190 (2000) [FFFS2] Felder, G., Fröhlich, J., Fuchs, J., Schweigert, C.: Correlation functions and boundary conditions in rational conformal field theory and three-dimensional topology. Compositio Math. 131, 189–237 (2002) [FFRS] Fröhlich, J., Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Correspondences of ribbon categories. Adv. Math. 199(1), 192–329 (2006) [FjFRS1] Fjelstad, J., Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Tft construction of rcft correlators v: proof of modular invariance and factorisation. Theory and Appl. of Categ 16, 392–433 (2006) [FjFRS2] Fjelstad, J., Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Uniqueness of open/closed rational CFT with given algebra of open states. http://arXiv.org/listhep-th/0612306, 2006 [FHL] Frenkel, I.B., Huang, Y.-Z., Lepowsky, J.: On axiomatic approaches to vertex operator algebras and modules. Memoirs Amer. Math. Soc. 104, 1993 [FRS1] Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Conformal correlation functions, frobenius algebras and triangulations. Nucl. Phys. B624, 452–468 (2002) [FRS2] Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Tft construction of rcft correlators I: partition functions. Nucl. Phys. B678, 511 (2004) [FRS3] Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Tft construction of rcft correlators III: simple currents. Nucl. Phys. B694, 277 (2004) [FRS4] Fuchs, J., Runkel, I., Schweigert, C.: Tft construction of rcft correlators IV: structure constants and correlation functions. Nucl. Phys. B 715(3), 539–638 (2005) [FS] Fuchs, J., Schweigert, C.: Category theory for conformal boundary conditions. Fields Institute Commun. 39, 25 (2003) [G] Gan, W.L.: Koszul duality for dioperads. Math. Res. Lett. 10(1), 109–124 (2003) [H1] Huang, Y.-Z.: Geometric interpretation of vertex operator algebras. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 9964–9968 (1991) [H2] Huang, Y.-Z.: A theory of tensor products for module categories for a vertex operator algebra, iv. J. Pure Appl. Alg. 100, 173–216 (1995) [H3] Huang, Y.-Z.: Two-dimensional conformal geometry and vertex operator algebras. Progress in Mathematics, Vol. 148, Boston: Birkhäuser, 1997 [H4] Huang, Y.-Z.: Generalized rationality and a “jacobi identity” for intertwining operator algebras. Selecta Math. (N. S.) 6, 225–267 (2000) [H5] Huang, Y.-Z.: A functional-analytic theory of vertex (operator) algebras. I. Commun. Math. Phys. 204(1), 61–84 (1999) [H6] Huang, Y.-Z.: A functional-analytic theory of vertex (operator) algebras. II. Commun. Math. Phys. 242(3), 425–444 (2003) [H7] Huang, Y.-Z.: Differential equations and intertwining operators. Commun. Contemp. Math. 7, 375–400 (2005) [H8] Huang, Y.-Z.: Riemann surfaces with boundaries and the theory of vertex operator algebras. Fields Institute Commun. 39, 109 (2003) [H9] Huang, Y.-Z.: Differential equations, duality and modular invariance. Commun. Contemp. Math. 7, 649–706 (2005) [H10] Huang, Y.-Z.: Vertex operator algebras and the verlinde conjecture. Commun. Contemp. Math. 10(1), 103–154 (2008) [H11] Huang, Y.-Z.: Rigidity and modularity of vertex tensor categories. math.QA/0502533, 2005 [HKo1] Huang, Y.-Z., Kong, L.: Open-string vertex algebra, category and operad. Commun. Math. Phys. 250, 433–471 (2004) [HKo2] Huang, Y.-Z., Kong, L.: Full field algebras. Commun. Math. Phys. 272, 345–396 (2007) [HKo3] Huang, Y.-Z., Kong, L.: Modular invariance for conformal full field algebras, math.QA/0609570, 2006 [HL1] Huang, Y.-Z., Lepowsky, J.: Tensor products of modules for a vertex operator algebra and vertex tensor categories, In: Lie Theory and Geometry, in honor of Bertram Kostant, R. Brylinski, J.-L. Brylinski, V. Guillemin, V. Kac (Eds.) Boston: Birkhäuser, 1994, pp. 349–383
92
[HL2] [HL3] [HL4] [I] [Ko1] [Ko2] [Kont] [Ki] [Kr] [KR] [La] [Le] [Ly] [LL] [LP] [Mi1] [Mi2] [Mo1] [Mo2] [MSei1] [MSei2] [MSei3] [MSeg] [RT] [Se1] [Se2] [So] [T] [V]
[Z]
L. Kong
Huang, Y.-Z., Lepowsky, J.: A theory of tensor products for module categories for a vertex operator algebra, I. Selecta Math. (N.S.) 1, 699–756 (1995) Huang, Y.-Z., Lepowsky, J.: A theory of tensor products for module categories for a vertex operator algebra, II. Selecta Math. (N.S.) 1, 757–786 (1995) Huang, Y.-Z., Lepowsky, J.: A theory of tensor products for module categories for a vertex operator algebra, III. J. Pure Appl. Alg. 100, 141–171 (1995) Ishibashi, N.: The boundary and crosscap states in conformal field theories. Mod. Phys. Lett. A4, 251 (1989) Kong, L.: Full field algebras, operads and tensor categories. Adv. Math. 213, 271–340 (2007) Kong, L.: Open-closed field algebras. Commun. Math. Phys. 280, 207–261 (2008) Kontsevich, M.: Operads and motives in deformation quantization. Lett. Math. Phys. 48, 35–72 (1999) Kirillov,, Jr. A.: On an inner product in modular tensor categories. J. Amer. Math. Soc 9(4), 1135–1169 (1996) Kriz, I.: On spin and modularity of conformal field theory. Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup. (4) 36(1), 57–112 (2003) Kong, L., Runkel, I.: Cardy algebras and sewing constraints, I, II, in preparation Lazaroiu, C.I.: On the structure of open-closed topological field theory in two dimensions. Nucl. Phys. B603, 497–530 (2001) Lewellen, D.C.: Sewing constraints for conformal field theories on surfaces with boundaries. Nucl. Phys. B372, 654 (1992) Lyubashenko, V.: Modular transformations for tensor categories. J. Pure Appl. Alg. 98(3), 297–327 (1995) Lepowsky, J., Li, H.-S.: Introduction to vertex operator algebras and their representations. Progress in Mathematics, 227, Boston, MA: Birkhäuser Boston, Inc. 2004 Lauda, A., Pfeiffer, H.: Open-closed strings: two-dimensional extended tqfts and frobenius algebras. Topology Appl 155(7), 623–666 (2008) Miyamoto, M.: Modular invariance of vertex operator algebras satisfying c2 -cofiniteness. Duke Math. J. 122(1), 51–91 (2004) Miyamoto, M.: Intertwining operators and modular invariance. math.QA/0010180, 2000 Moore, G.: Some comments on branes, g-flux, and k-theory. Internat. J. Mod. Phys. A16, 936–944 (2001) Moore, G.: D-branes, RR-Fields and K-Theory, I, II, III, VI. Lecture notes for the ITP miniprogram: The duality workshop: a Math/Physics collaboration, June, 2001; http://online.itp.ucsb. edu/online/mp01/moore1 Moore, G., Seiberg, N.: Classical and quantum conformal field theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 123, 177–254 (1989) Moore, G., Seiberg, N.: Naturality in conformal field theory. Nucl. Phys. B313, 16–40 (1989) Moore, G., Seiberg, N.: Lecture on RCFT. In: Physics Geometry and Topology. Edited by H.C. Lee, New York: Plenum Press, 1990 Moore, G., Segal, G.: D-branes and K-theory in 2D topological field theory. hep-th/0609042, 2006 Reshetikhin, N., Turaev, V.G.: Invariants of 3-manifolds via link polynomials of quantum groups. Invent. Math. 103(3), 547–597 (1991) Segal, G.: The definition of conformal field theory, Preprint, 1988; also In: Topology, geometry and quantum field theory. ed. U. Tillmann, London Math. Soc. Lect. Note Ser., Vol. 308. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004, 421–577 Segal, G.: Topological structures in string theory. R. Soc. Lond. Philos. Trans. A359, 1389–1398 (2001) Sonoda, H.: Sewing conformal field theories, I, II. Nucl. Phys. B311, 401–416, 417–432 (1988) Turaev.: Quantum invariant of knots and 3-manifolds, de Gruyter Studies in Mathematics, Vol. 18, Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 1994 Voronov, A.A.: The Swiss-cheese operad. In: Homotopy invariant algebraic structures, in honor of J. Michael Boardman, Proc. of the AMS Special Session on Homotopy Theory, Baltimore, 1998, ed. J.-P. Meyer, J. Morava, W. S. Wilson, Contemporary Math., Vol. 239, pp. 365–373 Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1999 Zhu, Y.-C.: Modular invariance of vertex operator algebras. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 9, 237–302 (1996)
Communicated by N.A. Nekrasov
Commun. Math. Phys. 283, 93–125 (2008) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0456-y
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Sharp Threshold of Global Existence and Instability of Standing Wave for a Davey-Stewartson System Zaihui Gan1,2 , Jian Zhang1 1 College of Mathematics and Software Science, Sichuan Normal University,
Chengdu 610068, P. R. China. E-mail:
[email protected]
2 The Institute of Mathematical Sciences, The Chinese University of Hong Kong,
Shatin, N.T., Hong Kong Received: 20 July 2007 / Accepted: 10 September 2007 Published online: 7 March 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: This paper concerns the sharp threshold of blowup and global existence of the solution as well as the strong instability of standing wave φ(t, x) = eiωt u(x) for the system: iφt + φ + a|φ| p−1 φ + bE 1 (|φ|2 )φ = 0, t ≥ 0, x ∈ R N ,
(DS)
+2 where a > 0, b > 0, 1 < p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. Firstly, by constructing a type of cross-constrained variational problem and establishing so-called cross-invariant manifolds of the evolution flow, we derive a sharp threshold for global existence and +2 blowup of the solution to the Cauchy problem for (DS) provided 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) +. Secondly, by using the scaling argument, we show how small the initial data are for the global solutions to exist. Finally, we prove the strong instability of the standing waves with finite time blow up for any ω > 0 by combining the former results.
1. Introduction In this paper we study the generalized Davey-Stewartson system: iφt + φ + a|φ| p−1 φ + bE 1 (|φ|2 )φ = 0, t ≥ 0, x ∈ R N ,
(1.1)
where φ = φ(t, x) is a complex-valued function of (t, x) ∈ R+ × R N , N ∈ {2, 3}, +2 is the usual Laplacian operator in R N , a and b are positive constants, 1 < p < (NN−2) +
+2 + = N − 2 when (we use the convention: (NN−2) + = ∞ when N = 2, and (N − 2) N = 3), E 1 is the singular integral operator with symbol σ1 (ξ ) = ξ12 /|ξ |2 , ξ ∈ R N , This work is supported by NSFC (No. 10726034, 10771151), Sichuan Youth Science and Technology Foundation (07ZQ026-009) and The Institute of Mathematical Sciences at The Chinese University of Hong Kong.
94
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
E 1 (ψ) = F −1 ξ12 /|ξ |2 Fψ, F −1 and F are the Fourier inverse transform and Fourier transform on R N , respectively (see [5,6,14,15]). The Davey-Stewartson system (1.1) has its origin in fluid mechanics, where for p = 3 and N = 2, it appears as mathematical models for the evolution of shallow-water waves having one predominant direction of travel (see[4–6]). Moreover, (1.1) is the N -dimensional extension of the Davey-Stewartson systems in the elliptic-elliptic case, iφt + λφx x + µφ yy + a|φ|p−1 φ = b1 φψx , (1.2) νψx x + ψ yy = −b2 |φ|2 x , where λ, µ, ν > 0, b1 , b2 are positive constants and a ∈ R. In this case, (1.2) describes the time evolution of two-dimensional surface of water waves having one propagation preponderantly in the x-direction (see [4–6]). In addition, according to the signs of µ and ν, system (1.2) may be classified as: − elliptic − elliptic : −elliptic − hyperbolic : −hyperbolic − elliptic : −hyperbolic − hyperbolic :
µ > 0, µ > 0, µ < 0, µ < 0,
ν > 0, ν < 0, ν > 0, ν < 0,
(1.3) (1.4) (1.5) (1.6)
although the last case does not seem to occur in the context of water waves [see also [4]]. A large amount of work [14,15,17,20–23,29,30] has been devoted to the study of the Davey-Stewartson systems. The Cauchy problem for the Davey-Stewartson systems in all physical relevant cases ((1.3)-(1.5)) has been studied in [14] by using functional analytical methods, in which Ghidaglia and Saut proved the solvability in the Sobolev spaces H 1 = H 1 (R2 ). In the case (1.4), Tsutsumi in [29] obtained the L p (R2 )-decay estimates of solutions of (1.1) (2 < p < ∞). In [23], Ozawa obtained the exact blowup solutions of Cauchy problem for (1.2). Ohta in [20–22] discussed the existence and nonexistence of stable standing waves for (1.1) under some conditions. Moreover, Guo and Wang in [15] studied blow-up in a finite time and global existence of the solutions to the Cauchy problem for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system with the case (1.3); Wang and Guo in [30] investigated the initial value problem and scattering of solutions to the generalized Davey-Stewartson systems; Li, Guo and Jian in [17] exploited the global existence and blowup of solutions to degenerate Davey-Stewartson equations. From the view-point of physics, the following problems are very important. Under what conditions will the water waves become unstable to collapse (blowup)? And under what conditions will the water waves be stable for all time (global existence)? Especially the sharp thresholds for blowup and global existence are pursued strongly (see Zhang [32–34] and their references). In the present paper, we investigate the sharp threshold of blowup and global existence of the Cauchy problem to the generalized Davey-Stewartson system (1.1) and the +2 instability of the standing waves for (1.1) provided 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + . To our knowledge, although there are some results [9,33,34] concerning the sharp condition for global existence of the solutions to the Cauchy problem for nonlinear Schrödinger equations, on the study of sharp threshold of blowup and global existence of the solutions to the Cauchy problem of the generalized Davey-Stewartson system (1.1), there is little work in the literature. For 1+ N4 ≤ p ≤ 3, in [7,8,27], the authors obtained the sharp threshold of global existence to the Cauchy problem for (1.1) by using the potential well argument
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
95
[24] and concavity method [16]. However, the methods in [7,8,27] can not be used to +2 solve the above problems for (1.1) for 3 < p < (NN−2) + . Therefore, it is interesting to +2 introduce some other methods to solve the related problems for 3 < p < (NN−2) + . In the present paper, motivated by the study of nonlinear Schrödinger equations [1,28,31,34], we construct a type of cross-constrained variational problem and establish its property, then apply it to (1.1). By defining the corresponding cross-invariant manifolds under the flow generated by the Cauchy problem of the Davey-Stewartson system (1.1), we establish the sharp threshold for global existence and blowup of the solutions to the Cauchy +2 problem for (1.1) with 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. In addition, by using the scaling arguments, we show how small the initial data are for the global solution of the Cauchy problem for (1.1) to exist. Finally, applying the sharp threshold and the property of the cross constrained variational problem, we can also prove the strong instability of +2 standing waves for (1.1) with finite time blowup for 1+ N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. +2 To our knowledge, these results are new for system (1.1) with 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. As for the standing waves for (1.1), Cipolatti [4] treated the standing waves with the existence of ground state by means of P. L. Lion’s concentration-compactness method [18,19]. By standing waves we mean special periodic solutions of the form
φ(t, x) = eiωt ϕ(x), where ω ∈ R and ϕ is a ground state of the problem: −ψ + ωψ − a|ψ| p−1 ψ − bE 1 (|ψ|2 )ψ = 0, x ∈ R N , ψ ∈ H 1 (R N ), ψ ≡ 0.
(1.7)
(1.8)
The so-called ground states are standing waves which minimize the action among all nontrivial solutions of the form (1.7). Both for physical and mathematical reasons, in recent years, many authors paid much attention to the stability and instability of the standing waves for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. Berestycki and Cazenave [1] investigated the instability of ground states; Cazenave and Lions [3] as well as Grillakis, Shatah and Strauss [13] obtained the existence of stable standing waves; Shatah and Strauss [26] established the instability of nonlinear bound states. Our idea is initiated by the works of Berestycki and Cazenave [1] as well as Weinstein [31]. In [1] and [31], the related variational problems have to be solved, the Schwarz symmetrization and complicated variational computation have to be conducted. But in the present paper, using the variational argument proposed in Zhang [34], we can refrain from solving the attaching variational problems, and directly establish the sharp threshold for global existence and blowup of solutions to the Cauchy problem of system (1.1) +2 for 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. Moreover, initiated by the work of Soffer and Weinstein [28], we also discuss the instability of the standing waves for (1.1) with finite +2 time blow up for 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. The major difficulties in the analysis of the Davey-Stewartson system (1.1) are the nonlinearity including the singular integral operator E 1 . Due to the singular integral operator E 1 in system (1.1) which is very different from the harmonic potential −|x|2 in Zhang [34], although the idea in the present paper is motivated mainly by Zhang [34], there are still many difficulties which need to be solved in order to obtain our results. The key to the idea is to construct a type of cross-constrained minimization problem, and establish so-called cross-invariant manifolds, which require us to search for proper
96
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
functionals. By the definitions of I (u), S(u) and Q(u) in Sect. 3, it is evident that they are different from those in [34]. In Zhang [34], every functional only includes a high+2 order nonlinearity, but in the present paper, since 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}, every functional has two high-order nonlinearities with different degrees, and one of the nonlinearities is the singular integral operator E 1 . For these reasons, compared to the argument in [34], our discussion will be more complicated and skillful. In addition, for the time being, as we have mentioned, the results in the present paper, especially those results concerning the sharp threshold for global existence and blowup are new +2 for system (1.1) under the conditions 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. It should be pointed out that system (1.1) has its origin in Fluid Mechanics for a ∈ R and b > 0. But to our knowledge, in the present paper, we only discuss the case a > 0 and b > 0. Furthermore, it is easily verified that our results in this paper can still cover the cases a = 0 and b > 0 as well as a > 0 and b = 0. For the time being, as far as the case a < 0 is concerned, whether the result concerning the sharp threshold for global existence holds or not remains open. At the end of this section, we give a brief outline of the rest of the paper. In Sect. 2 we collect some elementary facts which are useful for our analysis later. In Sect. 3 we establish the cross-invariant manifolds. The sharp threshold for global existence and blowup is treated in Sect. 4. Finally, we investigate the strong instability of the standing waves. 2. Preliminaries In this section, we will recall some known facts and give some elementary results which will be used and play important roles later. Firstly, we endow (1.1) with the initial data φ(0, x) = φ0 , x ∈ R N .
(2.1)
For system (1.1), Guo and Wang [15] as well as Cazenave [2] established the local well-posedness of the Cauchy problem in energy class H 1 (R N ). Now we state the following result about the local existence of weak solutions to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) in energy space H 1 (R N ) (see also [5],Theorem 2.1). Proposition 2.1. Let N ∈ {2, 3} and 1 ≤ p <
N +2 (N −2)+ .
Then the following holds:
(1) For any φ0 ∈ H 1 (R N ), there exists a unique solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) on a maximal time interval [0, T ) such that φ ∈ C([0, T ), H 1 (R N )) and either T = ∞ or else T < ∞ and lim φ H 1 (R N ) = ∞.
t→T
(2) We have conservation of charge and energy, that is |φ|2 d x = |φ0 |2 d x,
(2.2)
E(φ(t)) = E(φ0 )
(2.3)
for all t ∈ [0, T ), where a 1 1 E(φ) = |∇φ|2 d x − |φ| p+1 d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. (2.4) 2 p+1 4
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
97
Here and hereafter, for simplicity, we denote R N ·d x by ·d x. For more specific results concerning the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1), we refer the reader to [14]. In addition, by a direct calculation (see also Ohta [20–22]) we have Proposition 2.2. Let φ0 ∈ H 1 (R N ), |x|φ0 ∈ L 2 (R N ) and φ(t) be a solution of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) on [0, T ). Put J (t) := |x|2 |φ|2 d x. (2.5) Then one has J (t) = −4I m
¯ x, xφ∇ φd
(2.6)
and by (2.4), we have p−1 J (t) = 8 |∇φ|2 d x − 4N a |φ| p+1 d x − 2N b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x p+1 4N ( p − 1) − 16 a |φ| p+1 d x = 16E(φ0 ) − p+1 (2.7) −(2N − 4)b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. Thus the following result is true. +2 Corollary 2.1. Let φ0 ∈ H 1 (R N ) and N ∈ {2, 3}. For 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , when E(φ0 ) < 0, the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time.
Proof. We prove this corollary by contradiction. Suppose that the maximal existence time T of the solution φ to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) is infinity. Since N ∈ {2, 3}, +2 and 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , by (2.7) we have J (t) ≤ 16E(φ0 ), 0 ≤ t < ∞.
(2.8)
Through a classical analysis, the following identity is true: t J (t) = J (0) + J (0)t + (t − s)J (s)ds, 0 ≤ t < ∞.
(2.9)
0
From (2.8) it follows that J (t) ≤ 8E(φ0 )t 2 + J (0)t + J (0), 0 ≤ t < ∞.
(2.10)
Noting that J (t) is a nonnegative function, and J (0) = |x|2 |φ0 |2 d x, J (0) = −4I m xφ0 ∇ φ¯0 d x,
(2.11)
by E(φ0 ) < 0 and (2.10) we get that there exists T ∗ < ∞ such that lim∗ J (t) = 0. t→T
Namely,
lim
t→T ∗
|x|2 |φ|2 d x = 0,
which together with (2.2) leads us to the contradiction.
(2.12)
98
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
Remark 2.1. For system (1.1) without the singular integral operator E 1 , by Glassey [12] and (2.2), the following conclusion holds: Let φ0 ∈ H 1 (R N ). Then for 1 ≤ p < 1 + N4 , the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) has +2 a unique bounded global solution. For 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , when φ0 H 1 (R N ) is sufficiently small, the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) has a unique bounded global solution. Therefore, for system (1.1) without the singular integral operator E 1 , from Corollary 2.1 we see that p = 1 + N4 is the critical nonlinearity index for blowup and global existence of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). Thus, in that case, we call p = 1 + N4 a critical +2 case, 1 ≤ p < 1 + N4 a subcritical case, 1 + N4 < p < (NN−2) + a supercritical case. But for system (1.1) with the singular integral operator E 1 , when 1 ≤ p < 1 + N4 , the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) has a unique bounded global solution only for N = 1 using the method in Glassey [12], and whether the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) has a unique +2 bounded solution or not for N ∈ {2, 3} remains open. For 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , it is evident that the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) has global solutions and blowup solutions. Therefore, it is natural to search for the sharp threshold for global existence and blowup +2 of the solutions to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) for 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , which is interesting and remains open before we solve it in this paper. Remark 2.2. From (2.7), when N = 2, for the critical case p = 3 one has J (t) = 8E(φ0 )t 2 + J (0)t + J (0), which is a quadratic function about time t. This coincides with the case of system (1.1) without the singular integral operator E 1 . Now we give some known facts in Cipolatti [4,5]. Lemma 2.1. (Cipolatti [4]). Let E 1 be the singular integral operator defined in Fourier variables by F{E 1 (ψ)}(ξ ) = σ1 (ξ )F{ψ}(ξ ), where σ1 (ξ ) = ξ12 /|ξ |2 , ξ ∈ R N and F denotes the Fourier transform in R N : N 2 F{ψ}(ξ ) = (1/2π ) e−iξ x ψ(x)d x. For 1 < p < ∞, E 1 satisfies the following properties: i) E 1 ∈ L(L p , L p ), where L(L p , L p ) denotes the space of bounded linear operators from L p to L p . ii) If ψ ∈ H s , then E 1 (ψ) ∈ H s , s ∈ R. iii) If ψ ∈ W m, p , then E 1 (ψ) ∈ W m, p and ∂k E 1 (ψ) = E 1 (∂k ψ), iv)
k = 1, . . . , N .
E 1 preserves the following operations: -translation: E 1 (ψ(· + y))(x) = E 1 (ψ)(x + y), y ∈ R N , -dilatation: E 1 (ψ(λ·))(x) = E 1 (ψ)(λx), λ > 0, -conjugation: E 1 (ψ) = E 1 (ψ), where ψ is the complex conjugate of ψ.
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
99
Thus Lemma 2.1 yields directly the following properties. Remark 2.3. (Cipolatti [4] and Ohta[21]). Let B1 be the quadratic functional on L 2 defined by B1 (ψ) =
σ1 (ξ )|F(ψ)(ξ )|2 dξ.
It follows from the Parseval identity
f · gd x =
F[ f ]F[g]dξ, dξ = (2π )−N d x
(2.13)
that B1 (ψ) =
E 1 (ψ)ψd x,
and in particular we have B1 (ψ) ≤
|ψ|2 d x,
(2.14)
B1 ∈ C ∞ (L 2 , R), with B1 = 2E 1 . Therefore, from the definition of E 1 , the Parseval identity (2.13) and (2.14), we have
|ψ|2 E 1 (|ψ|2 )d x ≤
|ψ|4 d x
(2.15)
and
|ψ|2 E 1 (|ψ|2 )d x =
=
|ψ|2 F −1 σ1 (ξ )F(|ψ|2 )d x σ1 (ξ )|F(|ψ|2 )|2 dξ > 0.
Finally, we state an elementary lemma. Lemma 2.2. (Cipolatti [5]). For all φ ∈ S(R N , R) (the Schwartz space of rapidly decreasing functions), the following identities hold: (i) (ii) (iii)
φx · ∇φd x = −
N 2
|φ|2 d x. N |φ| p−1 φx · ∇φd x = − |φ| p+1 d x. p+1 N 2 E 1 (|φ| )φx · ∇φd x = − |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. 4
100
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
3. The Cross-Constrained Variational Problem and the Cross-Invariant Manifolds In this section, we first define some functionals and manifolds, then consider the constrained minimization problems. Since system (1.1) includes the singular integral operator E 1 , our arguments are more difficult than the related discussions on the system (1.1) without the singular integral operator E 1 . Throughout this paper, we limit our arguments to the case N ∈ {2, 3}. +2 For u ∈ H 1 (R N ), ω > 0 and 1 < p < (NN−2) + , we define the following functionals: ω a b 1 2 2 p+1 I (u) : = |∇u| d x + |u| d x − |u| d x − |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x, 2 2 p+1 4 (3.1) 2 2 p+1 2 2 S(u) : = |∇u| d x + ω |u| d x − a |u| d x − b |u| E 1 (|u| )d x, (3.2) N ( p − 1) N a |u| p+1 d x − b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x. Q(u) : = |∇u|2 d x − (3.3) 2( p + 1) 4 From Remark 2.3 it follows that 2 2 |u| E 1 (|u| )d x ≤ |u|4 d x.
(3.4)
By (3.4) and Sobolev’s embedding theorem, the above functionals are well-defined. In addition, we define a manifold N := u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0}, S(u) = 0 . We first define the constrained variational problem: dN := inf I (u).
(3.5)
N
Thus, we have the following results. Lemma 3.1. Let 1 < p <
N +2 (N −2)+
and N ∈ {2, 3}, then dN > 0.
Proof. From (3.1),(3.2) and (3.5), on N we get p−1 I (u) = a |u| p+1 d x + 2( p + 1) p−3 a |u| p+1 d x + = 4( p + 1) and
b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x, 4 1 (|∇u|2 + ω|u|2 )d x, 4
(|∇u|2 + ω|u|2 )d x = a
Since 1 < p < I (u) ≥
N +2 (N −2)+ ,
1 min 2
p−1 1 , p+1 2
(3.6)
|u| p+1 d x + b
|u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x.
a |u| p+1 d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x .
(3.7)
(3.8)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
101
By the Sobolev embedding theorem and (3.4), one gets a |u| p+1 d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x p+1 ≤ a |u| d x + b |u|4 d x |∇u| d x + ω
2 |u| d x 2
δ
|∇u| d x + ω 2
2
|u|2 d x
2
+C2 ≤C
p+1
|∇u|2 d x + ω
≤ C1
|u| d x 2
2
,
(3.9)
where δ = max{ p + 1, 4} ≥ 4 or δ = min{ p + 1, 4} > 2 since p > 1. Here and hereafter, C > 0 denotes various positive constants. From (3.7) and (3.9), it follows that p+1 a |u| d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x
δ 2 , ≤ C a |u| p+1 d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x thus
δ −1 2 p+1 2 2 ≥ C > 0. a |u| d x + b |u| E 1 (|u| )d x Since
δ 2
− 1 > 0, (3.10) implies that p+1 a |u| d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x ≥ C > 0.
Therefore (3.8), (3.11) and 1 < p <
N +2 (N −2)+
(3.10)
(3.11)
imply that I (u) ≥ C > 0, that is,
dN ≥ C > 0.
(3.12)
Lemma 3.2. There exists u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} such that S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0. Proof. From Ohta [21,22], it follows that there exists u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} such that u is a solution of the following Euler-Lagrangian equation: − u + ωu − a|u| p−1 u − bE 1 (|u|2 )u = 0.
(3.13)
Thus S(u) = 0, which is obtained from multiplying (3.13) by u and then integrating with respect to x on R N . Moreover, by (3.13) and Lemma 2.2, we have the Pohozaev identity, 2 1 N −2 a |u| p+1 d x − b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x = 0, |∇u|2 d x +ω |u|2 d x − N p+1 2 (3.14)
102
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
which is obtained from multiplying (3.13) by x · ∇u and then integrating with respect to x on R N . Noting that S(u) = 0, we get Q(u) = 0. Now we define a cross-manifold in H 1 (R N ) as follows: M := u ∈ H 1 (R N ), S(u) < 0, Q(u) = 0 .
(3.15)
Then the following result is true. Lemma 3.3. Let N ∈ {2, 3}. ThenM is not empty provided 1 +
4 N
≤p<
N +2 (N −2)+ .
Proof. We divide the proof into two steps: i) p = 3 and ii) p = 3. Step 1. We first treat the case i) p = 3. In this case, from Lemma 3.2, it follows that there exists u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} such that both S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0. Let vλ = λu(λx) for λ > 0, then vλ ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0}. By (3.2) and (3.3), we get S(vλ ) = λ4−N |∇u|2 d x + λ2−N ω |u|2 d x 4−N 4 4−N −λ a |u| d x − λ b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x
= λ4−N |∇u|2 d x − a |u|4 d x − b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x (3.16) +λ2−N ω |u|2 d x, Q(vλ ) = λ4−N
|∇u|2 d x −
N a 4
|u|4 d x −
N b 4
|u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x .
(3.17)
Thus S(u) = 0 implies that there exists λ∗ > 1 such that S(vλ∗ ) < 0. On the other hand, from λ∗ > 1 and Q(u) = 0, we still have Q(vλ∗ ) = 0. So vλ∗ ∈ M. This proves M is not empty for i) p = 3. +2 Step 2. Next we treat case ii) p = 3. In this case, by 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , we divide this case into the following three cases: (a) 3 < p < ∞, 7 ≤ p < 3, (b) 3 (c) 3 < p < 5,
when N = 2; when N = 3; when N = 3.
From Lemma 3.2, it follows that there exists u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} such that both S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0. For λ > 1, let v = λu, then v ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0}. Thus (3.2) and (3.3) imply that S(v) = |∇v|2 d x + ω |v|2 d x − a |v| p+1 d x − b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x 2 2 2 =λ |∇u| d x + λ ω |u|2 d x −λ p+1 a |u| p+1 d x − λ4 b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x, (3.18)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
Q(v) =
|∇v|2 d x −
= λ2 −λ4
N ( p − 1) a 2( p + 1)
|∇u|2 d x − λ p+1 N b 4
|v| p+1 d x −
N ( p − 1) a 2( p + 1)
N b 4
103
|v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x
|u| p+1 d x
|u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x.
(3.19)
N ( p−1) +2 From 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}, it follows that 2( p+1) < 1. Thus by S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0, we can always choose λ > 1 suitably such that S(v) < 0, Q(v) < 0,
N ( p − 1) a |v| p+1 d x > 0, 2( p + 1) N |∇v|2 d x − b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x > 0, 4 2 |∇v| d x − a |v| p+1 d x < 0, |∇v|2 d x −
(3.20) (3.21) (3.22)
and
|∇v| d x − b 2
|v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x < 0.
(3.23)
Step 2.1. We first prove case (a) 3 < p < ∞ and N = 2. 2
(a) Let vβ = β p−1 v(βx). Thus we have S(vβ ) = β
4 p−1
|∇v| d x − a
6−2 p p−1
|v| d x − β
|v| 10−2 p p−1
p+1
dx
|v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x,
4 p−1 Q(vβ ) = β p−1 a |v| p+1 d x |∇v|2 d x − p+1 1 10−2 p − β p−1 b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x. 2 +β
ω
2
2
b
(3.24)
(3.25)
p 10−2 p 6−2 p 6−2 p 4 > 10−2 By 3 < p < ∞, it follows that p−1 p−1 , p−1 > p−1 and p−1 < 0. ∗ Therefore Q(v) < 0, (3.20) and (3.25) imply that there exists β > 1 such that Q(vβ ∗ ) = 0. On the other hand, from β ∗ > 1, S(v) < 0, (3.22) and (3.24), it still has S(vβ ∗ ) < 0. So vβ ∗ ∈ M. Step 2.2. Next we prove case (b) 73 ≤ p < 3 and N = 3. In this case, one has 13 ≤ p − 2 < 1.
104
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
(b) Let vµ = µv(µx). Thus one has
S(vµ ) = µ |∇v|2 d x − b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x +µ−1 ω |v|2 d x − µ p−2 a |v| p+1 d x,
3 Q(vµ ) = µ |∇v|2 d x − b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x 4 3( p − 1) p−2 µ a |v| p+1 d x. − 2( p + 1)
(3.26)
(3.27)
Therefore by Q(v) < 0, from (3.21) and (3.27) it follows that there exists µ∗ > 1 such that Q(vµ∗ ) = 0. On the other hand, from µ∗ > 1, S(v) < 0, (3.23) and (3.26), it still follows that S(vµ∗ ) < 0. So vµ∗ ∈ M. Step 2.3. Finally, we prove case (c) 3 < p < 5 and N = 3. In this case, we have 5 − p > 11 − 3 p and 7 − 3 p < 0. 2
(c) Let vξ = ξ p−1 v(ξ x). Thus we have
5− p S(vξ ) = ξ p−1 |∇v|2 d x − a |v| p+1 d x 7−3 p 11−3 p 2 p−1 p−1 +ξ ω |v| d x − ξ b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x,
5− p 3( p − 1) 2 p+1 p−1 a |v| d x Q(vξ ) = ξ |∇v| d x − 2( p + 1) 3 11−3 p − ξ p−1 b |v|2 E 1 (|v|2 )d x. 4
(3.28)
(3.29)
Therefore, from (3.20), (3.29) and Q(v) < 0, it follows that there exists ξ ∗ > 1 such that Q(vξ ∗ ) = 0. On the other hand, from ξ ∗ > 1, S(v) < 0, (3.22) and (3.28), it still follows that S(vξ ∗ ) < 0. So vξ ∗ ∈ M. From the above arguments of Step 1 and Step 2, we obtain that M is not empty +2 provided 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. So far, we have completed the proof of Lemma 3.3. Now let us consider the cross-constrained minimization problem: dM := inf I (u),
(3.30)
M
then we have: Lemma 3.4. Let N ∈ {2, 3}. Then dM > 0 provided 1 +
4 N
≤p<
N +2 (N −2)+ .
Proof. Let u ∈ M. From S(u) < 0, it follows that u = 0. By Q(u) = 0, we obtain N ( p − 1) − 4 I (u) = a |u| p+1 d x 4( p + 1)
1 N ω − b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x + + (3.31) |u|2 d x. 8 4 2
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
105
+2 Since 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}, (3.31) and u ≡ 0 imply that dM ≥ 0. In the following, we prove dM > 0 by dividing the proof into two cases:
1)
The critical case. p = 1 +
4 N;
2)
The supercritical case. 1 +
4 N
N +2 (N −2)+ .
We first consider case 1) The critical case: p = 1 + N4 . Since we have showed dM ≥ 0, in this case, we argue by contradiction. If dM = 0, then from (3.30) there would exist a sequence {u n , n ∈ Z+ } ⊂ M such that Q(u n ) = 0, S(u n ) < 0 and I (u n ) → 0 as n → ∞. Since p = 1 + N4 , (3.31) implies that 2 2 |u n |2 d x → 0 as n → ∞. (3.32) |u n | E 1 (|u n | )d x → 0, From the Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequality
N ( p−1)
|v|
p+1
dx ≤ C
4
|∇v| d x 2
|v| d x 2
p+1 − N ( p−1) 2
4
, v ∈ H 1 (R N ), (3.33)
for p = 1 +
4 N
and u n we have
|u n | p+1 d x ≤ C
|∇u n |2 d x ·
2 |u n |2 d x
N
.
(3.34)
According to S(u n ) < 0, |u n |2 E 1 (|u n |2 )d x ≤ |u n |4 d x (2.15) and (3.34), we get for p = 1 + N4 , 2 2 p+1 |∇u n | d x + ω |u n | d x < a |u n | d x + b |u n |2 E 1 (|u n |2 )d x
|∇u n | d x ·
≤C
2 |u n | d x
2
2
N
N
4−N 2 2 2 · . |∇u n | d x |u n | d x 2
+C
(3.35)
For C in (3.35), by (3.32), we have when n sufficiently large, |∇u n |2 d x + ω |u n |2 d x
≥C
|∇u n | d x · 2
+C
2 |u n | d x 2
N
N
4−N 2 2 2 · . |∇u n | d x |u n | d x 2
(3.36)
It is obvious that (3.35) and (3.36) are contradictory. Since we have showed dM ≥ 0, thus we get dM > 0 for p = 1 + N4 .
106
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
Next we treat the supercritical case 2) 1 + Sobolev embedding inequality
4 N
|u|
p+1
dx ≤ C
N +2 (N −2)+ .
p+1
|∇u| d x + ω
|u| d x
2
In this case, we use the
2
2
.
(3.37)
From S(u) < 0, (2.15) and (3.37), it follows that |∇u|2 d x + ω |u|2 d x < a |u| p+1 d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x ≤C
|∇u| d x + ω
≤C
p+1
|u| d x
2
2
|∇u| d x + ω
|u| d x 2
|u|4 d x
+b
p+1
2
2
2
|∇u| d x + ω
+C
2
2
|u| d x 2
⎧ 2 W 2 ⎪ ⎪ C |∇u| d x + ω |u| d x , ⎨ when |∇u|2d x + ω |u|2 d x ≥ 1, ≤ m 2 2 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ C |∇u| d x + ω |u| d x2 , when |∇u| d x + ω |u|2 d x < 1, where W = max{( p + 1)/2, 2} ≥ 2 and m = min{( p + 1)/2, 2}. Since 1 + N +2 2 5 (N −2)+ and N ∈ {2, 3}, we get ( p + 1)/2 ≥ 1 + N ≥ 3 > 1. Thus we get 2 |∇u| d x + ω |u|2 d x ≥ C > 0.
4 N
< p<
(3.38)
In order to prove dM > 0, we divide the following proof into two cases: 2-i) N = 3, 73 < p < 5; 2-ii) N = 2, 3 < p < ∞. First we consider 2-i) N = 3, 73 < p < 5. In this case, by (3.31) we get 1 ω 3p − 7 p+1 2 2 a |u| d x + b |u| E 1 (|u| )d x + I (u) = |u|2 d x. 4( p + 1) 8 2 1 Let D = min{ 4(3 p−7 p+1) , 8 } > 0. Then by
1 D=
7 3
(3.39)
< p < 5, we get
when 3 8, 3 p−7 when 4( p+1) ,
≤ p < 5, 7 3
< p < 3.
Thus by (3.39), we obtain
ω I (u) ≥ D a |u| p+1 d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x + |u|2 d x. 2 From S(u) < 0 it follows that |∇u|2 d x + ω |u|2 d x ≤ a |u| p+1 d x + b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x,
(3.40)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
107
which together with (3.40) implies that
ω 2 2 I (u) ≥ D |u|2 d x. |∇u| d x + ω |u| d x + 2
(3.41)
By (3.38) and (3.41), we get I (u) ≥ C > 0.
(3.42)
Thus when N = 3, (3.30) implies that dM > 0 for 73 < p < 5. Next we consider 2-ii) N = 2, 3 < p < ∞. In this case, by (3.31) and (3.32), 2p − 6 ω a |u| p+1 d x + I (u) = (3.43) |u|2 d x. 4( p + 1) 2 In the following, we discuss by contradiction. If dM = 0, then from (3.43) there would exist a sequence {u n , n ∈ Z + } ⊂ M such that Q(u n ) = 0, S(u n ) < 0 and I (u n ) → 0 as n → ∞. Since 3 < p < ∞, (3.43) implies that |u n | p+1 d x → 0, |u n |2 d x → 0 as n → ∞. (3.44) From the Gagliardo-Nirenberg inequality for N = 2 and 3 < p < ∞,
( p−1)
|v| p+1 d x ≤ C
2
|∇v|2 d x
|v|2 d x , v ∈ H 1 (R2 ),
(3.45)
thus u n satisfies
( p−1)
|u n | p+1 d x ≤ C
|∇u n |2 d x
2
|u n |2 d x .
(3.46)
According to S(u n ) < 0, |u n |2 E 1 (|u n |2 )d x ≤ |u n |4 d x (2.15) and (3.46), using the Sobolev embedding inequality, we get |∇u n |2 d x + ω |u n |2 d x < a |u n | p+1 d x + b |u n |2 E 1 (|u n |2 )d x
( p−1)
≤C
2
|∇u n |2 d x
|∇u n |2 d x ·
+C
|u n |2 d x
|u n |2 d x.
(3.47)
For C in (3.47), from (3.44), it follows that when n sufficiently large, 2 |∇u n | d x + ω |u n |2 d x
( p−1)
≥C
|∇u n | d x
|u n | d x 2
+C
2
2
|∇u n |2 d x ·
|u n |2 d x.
(3.48)
108
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
It is obvious that (3.47) and (3.48) are contradictory. Since we have showed dM ≥ 0, thus we get dM > 0 for N = 2 and 3 < p < ∞. +2 So far, we have proved that dM > 0 for the supercritical case 1 + N4 < p < (NN−2) +. 4 Therefore from the above arguments of 1) and 2), we obtain dM > 0 for 1 + N ≤ p < N +2 (N −2)+ . This completes the proof of Lemma 3.4. Now we define d := min{dN , dM }.
(3.49)
Remark 3.1. For the time being, to our knowledge, for a > 0, b > 0, ω > 0, 1 + N4 ≤ +2 p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}, the question remains open: Under what conditions will it have d = dN , and under what conditions will it have d = dM ? But for some special cases, it is known that d = dN (that is, dM ≥ dN ). For example, +2 Case 1 (Zhang [35]). a > 0, b = 0, ω > 0, 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. Case 2 (Shu and Zhang [27]). a > 0, b > 0, ω = 1, p = 3 and N ≥ 3. Thus by Lemma 3.1 and Lemma 3.4, the following result is true. Proposition 3.1. Let N ∈ {2, 3}. Then d > 0 provided 1 + We further define K := φ ∈ H 1 (R N ),
I (φ) < d, S(φ) < 0,
4 N
≤p<
N +2 (N −2)+ .
Q(φ) < 0 .
(3.50)
Thus we have Lemma 3.5. Let N ∈ {2, 3}. Then K is not empty provided 1 +
4 N
≤p<
N +2 (N −2)+ .
Proof. From Lemma 3.2, there exists u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} such that both S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0. Put u λ (x) = λu(x), then by (3.1), (3.2) and (3.3), one has
S(u λ ) = λ2 |∇u|2 d x + ω |u|2 d x (3.51) −λ p+1 a |u| p+1 d x − λ4 b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x, N ( p − 1) p+1 λ a |u| p+1 d x Q(u λ ) = λ2 |∇u|2 d x − 2( p + 1) N 4 − λ b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x, (3.52) 4
1 I (u λ ) = λ2 |∇u|2 d x + ω |u|2 d x 2 1 a λ p+1 |u| p+1 d x − λ4 b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x. (3.53) − p+1 4 +2 Since d > 0 and 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , for λ > 1 large enough, in view of (3.51), (3.52) and (3.53) as well as S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0, one always has that S(u λ ) < 0, Q(u λ ) < 0 and I (u λ ) < d. Thus u λ ∈ K. This completes the proof of Lemma 3.5.
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
109
Furthermore, we have +2 Proposition 3.2. Let 1 + N4 < p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. Then K is an invariant manifold of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). That is, if φ0 (x) ∈ K, then the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) satisfies φ(t, ·) ∈ K for any t ∈ [0, T ).
Proof. Let φ0 ∈ K. According to Proposition 2.1, there exists a unique φ(t, ·) ∈ C([0, T ); H 1 (R N )) with T ≤ ∞ such that φ(t, x) is a solution of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). From (2.2), (2.3), (2.4) and (3.1), it follows that I (φ(t, ·)) = I (φ0 ),
t ∈ [0, T ).
Thus I (φ0 ) < d implies that I (φ(t, ·)) < d for any t ∈ [0, T ).
(3.54)
We first show S(φ(t, ·)) < 0 for t ∈ [0, T ) by contradiction. If otherwise, from the continuity, there were a t ∗ ∈ (0, T ) such that S(φ(t ∗ , ·)) = 0. By (3.54), it has φ(t ∗ , ·) ≡ 0. From (3.5) and (3.49), it follows that I (φ(t ∗ , ·)) ≥ dN ≥ d. This is contradictory to I (φ(t ∗ , ·)) < d for t ∈ [0, T ). Therefore S(φ(t, ·)) < 0 for all t ∈ [0, T ). Next we prove Q(φ(t, ·)) < 0 for t ∈ [0, T ) by contradiction. If otherwise, from the continuity, there were a t¯ ∈ (0, T ) such that Q(φ(t¯, ·)) = 0. Since we have showed S(φ(t¯, ·)) < 0, it follows that φ(t¯, ·) ∈ M. Thus (3.30) and (3.49) imply that I (φ(t¯, ·)) ≥ dM ≥ d. This is contradictory to I (φ(t¯, ·)) < d for t ∈ [0, T ). Therefore Q(φ(t, ·)) < 0 for all t ∈ [0, T ). From the above argument, we proved that φ(t, ·) ∈ K for any t ∈ [0, T ). Thus the proof of Proposition 3.2 is completed. By the same argument as Proposition 3.2, we get Proposition 3.3. Let N ∈ {2, 3}. Define K+ := φ ∈ H 1 (R N ), I (φ) < d, S(φ) < 0, Q(φ) > 0 , R− := φ ∈ H 1 (R N ), I (φ) < d, S(φ) < 0 , R+ := φ ∈ H 1 (R N ), I (φ) < d, S(φ) > 0 . +2 If 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , then K+ , R− and R+ are all invariant manifolds of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1).
Remark 3.2. For these manifolds defined in Proposition 3.3, we call R− and R+ invariant manifolds of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). In the course of nature, we call K and K+ cross-invariant manifolds of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). By the definitions of K, K+ and R+ , as well as (3.5), (3.30) and (3.49), the following result holds. Proposition 3.4. Let N ∈ {2, 3} and 1 +
4 N
≤p<
N +2 (N −2)+ .
Then
φ ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0}, I (φ) < d = R+ ∪ K+ ∪ K.
110
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
4. Sharp Threshold for Global Existence and Blowup In this section, we discuss the sharp sufficient condition for blowup and global existence. Firstly, we give a sufficient condition for blowup of the solutions to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). +2 Theorem 4.1. Let N ∈ {2, 3} and 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + . If φ0 (x) ∈ K and satisfies 2 N |x|φ0 ∈ L (R ), then the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time.
Proof. According to Ginibre and Velo [10,11], from |x|φ0 (x) ∈ L 2 (R N ), one has |x|φ ∈ L 2 (R N ). By φ0 ∈ K, Proposition 3.2 implies that φ(t, .) ∈ K for t ∈ [0, T ). Thus we have I (φ) < d, S(φ) < 0 and Q(φ) < 0. Now we put J (t) = |x|2 |φ|2 d x, (4.1) Equations(2.7) and (3.3) imply that J (t) = 8Q(φ(t, .)), t ∈ [0, T ).
(4.2)
Fix t ∈ [0, T ) and denote φ(t, .) = φ. Thus φ satisfies that I (φ) < d, Q(φ) < 0 and S(φ) < 0. In the following, we continue to prove Theorem 4.1 through two steps: Step 1. p = 3; Step 2. p = 3. We first consider Step 1. p = 3. N
Let φλ = λ 2 φ(λx). Then S(φλ ) = λ2 |∇φ|2 d x + ω |φ|2 d x N 4 N −aλ |φ| d x − λ b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x, N Q(φλ ) = λ2 |∇φ|2 d x − λ N a |φ|4 d x 4 N − λ N b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. 4
(4.3)
(4.4)
Since S(φ) < 0, it yields that there exists 0 < λ∗ < 1 such that S(φλ∗ ) = 0, and when λ ∈ (λ∗ , 1], S(φλ ) < 0. For λ ∈ [λ∗ , 1] and Q(φ) < 0, Q(φλ ) has the following three possibilities: 1-i) Q(φλ ) < 0 for λ ∈ [λ∗ , 1]; 1-ii) Q(φλ∗ ) = 0; 1-iii) There exist µ ∈ (λ∗ , 1) such that Q(φµ ) = 0. For the case 1-i) and 1-ii), we both have S(φλ∗ ) = 0 and Q(φλ∗ ) ≤ 0. It follows from (3.5), (3.30) and (3.49) that I (φλ∗ ) ≥ dN ≥ d. Moreover, we have 1 I (φ) − I (φλ∗ ) = (1 − λ∗ 2 ) |∇φ|2 d x 2 1 − (1 − λ∗ N ) a |φ|4 d x + b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 ))d x , (4.5) 4
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
Q(φ) − Q(φλ∗ ) = (1 − λ∗ 2 )
111
|∇φ|2 d x N ∗N 4 2 2 − (1 − λ ) a |φ| d x + b |φ| E 1 (|φ| ))d x . 4
(4.6)
According to 0 < λ∗ < 1 and N ∈ {2, 3}, (4.5) and (4.6) imply that 1 1 1 Q(φ) − Q(φλ∗ ) ≥ Q(φ). (4.7) 2 2 2 For the case 1-iii), we have Q(φµ ) = 0 and S(φµ ) < 0. Thus φµ ∈ M. From (3.30) and (3.49), it follows that I (φµ ) ≥ dM ≥ d. In addition, I (φ) − I (φλ∗ ) ≥
1 1 1 Q(φ) − Q(φµ ) ≥ Q(φ). 2 2 2 Since I (φλ∗ ) ≥ d and I (φµ ) ≥ d, in view of (4.7) and (4.8), we get ⎧ ⎨ Q(φ) ≤ 2(I (φ) − I (φµ )) ≤ 2[I (φ) − d], I (φ) − I (φµ ) ≥
⎩ Q(φ) ≤ 2(I (φ) − I (φ ∗ )) ≤ 2[I (φ) − d]. λ
(4.8)
(4.9)
From (2.2), (2.3), (2.4) and (3.1), it has I (φ) = I (φ0 ).
(4.10)
Thus by φ0 ∈ K and (4.2), we have J (t) = 8Q(φ) < 16[I (φ0 ) − d] < 0. Obviously J (t) can not verify the above inequality for all time (see also Glassey [12]). Therefore, from Proposition 2.1, it must be the case that T < ∞ , which implies lim φ(t, .) H 1 (R N ) = ∞. t∈T
That is, the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time for p = 3 and N ∈ {2, 3}. +2 Now we consider Step 2. p = 3. In this case, by N ∈ {2, 3} and 1+ N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) +, we divide the proof into two cases: +2 2-1) 3 < p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}; 2-2) 73 ≤ p < 3 and N = 3. Step 2-1) We first consider the case 2-1) 3 < p < In this case, let φβ = β S(φβ ) = β
N p+1
N +2− p(N −2) p+1
φ(βx). Then
N +2 (N −2)+
and N ∈ {2, 3}.
|∇φ| d x − a
|φ| p+1 d x (1− p)N (3− p)N +β p+1 ω |φ|2 d x − β p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x, N +2− p(N −2) p+1 Q(φβ ) = β |∇φ|2 d x N ( p − 1) N (3− p)N − a |φ| p+1 d x − β p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. 4( p + 1) 4 2
(4.11)
(4.12)
112
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
Since 3 < p <
N +2 (N −2)+
and N ∈ {2, 3}, we have
N + 2 − p(N − 2) (3 − p)N > , p+1 p+1
N + 2 − p(N − 2) > 0, p+1
(3 − p)N < 0. p+1
Thus Q(φ) < 0 implies that there exists β ∗ > 1 such that Q(φβ ∗ ) = 0, and when β ∈ [1, β ∗ ), Q(φβ ) < 0. For β ∈ [1, β ∗ ], because S(φ) < 0, S(φβ ) has the following two possibilities: 2-1-i) S(φβ ) < 0 for β ∈ [1, β ∗ ]. 2-1-ii) There exists 1 < µ ≤ β ∗ such that S(φµ ) = 0. For the case 2-1-i), we have Q(φβ ∗ ) = 0 and S(φβ ∗ ) < 0, that is, φβ ∗ ∈ M. From (3.30) and (3.49), it follows that I (φβ ∗ ) ≥ dM ≥ d. Moreover, we have
N +2− p(N −2) 1 p+1 1 − β∗ |∇φ|2 d x 2
(1− p)N ω 1 − β ∗ p+1 + |φ|2 d x 2
(3− p)N 1 1 − β ∗ p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x, − 4
N +2− p(N −2) p+1 Q(φ) − Q(φβ ∗ ) = 1 − β ∗ |∇φ|2 d x
(3− p)N N b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. 1 − β ∗ p+1 − 4 I (φ) − I (φβ ∗ ) =
Thus from β ∗ > 1, N ∈ {2, 3} and 3 < p < I (φ) − I (φβ ∗ ) ≥
N +2 (N −2)+ ,
(4.13)
(4.14)
it follows that
1 1 1 Q(φ) − Q(φβ ∗ ) = Q(φ). 2 2 2
(4.15)
For the case 2-1-ii), we have S(φµ ) = 0 and Q(φµ ) ≤ 0. Thus (3.5) and (3.49) imply that I (φµ ) ≥ dN ≥ d. Referring to (4.13) and (4.14), we have I (φ) − I (φµ ) ≥
1 1 1 Q(φ) − Q(φµ ) ≥ Q(φ). 2 2 2
(4.16)
For the case 2-1-i) and the case 2-1-ii), since I (φβ ∗ ) ≥ d, I (φµ ) ≥ d, from (4.15) and (4.16), it follows that
Q(φ) ≤ 2[I (φ) − I (φβ ∗ )] ≤ 2[I (φ) − d], Q(φ) ≤ 2[I (φ) − I (φµ )] ≤ 2[I (φ) − d].
(4.17)
From (2.2), (2.3), (2.4) and (3.1), one has I (φ) = I (φ0 ). Thus by φ0 ∈ K and (4.2), we have J (t) = 8Q(φ) < 16[I (φ) − d] = 16[I (φ0 ) − d] < 0.
(4.18)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
Step 2-2) Now we deal with the case 2-2), 3 4
7 3
113
≤ p < 3 and N = 3. In this case, let
φη = η φ(ηx). Then 3 p−9 1 S(φη ) = η 2 |∇φ|2 d x − η 4 a |φ| p+1 d x − 23 2 +η ω |φ| d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x, (4.19) 1 3( p − 1) 3 p−9 3 η 4 a |φ| p+1 d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. Q(φη ) = η 2 |∇φ|2 d x − 4( p + 1) 4 (4.20) From
7 3
≤ p < 3, it follows that 3p − 9 < 0, 4
3p − 9 1 3 ≥− >− . 4 2 2
Thus Q(φ) < 0 implies that there exists η∗ > 1 such that Q(φη∗ ) = 0, and when η ∈ [1, η∗ ), Q(φη ) < 0. For η ∈ [1, η∗ ], by S(φ) < 0, we get S(φη ) has the following two possibilities: 2-2-a) S(φη ) < 0 for η ∈ [1, η∗ ]. 2-2-b) There exists 1 < λ ≤ η∗ such that S(φλ ) = 0. For the case 2-2-a), we have Q(φη∗ ) = 0 and S(φη∗ ) < 0, that is, φη∗ ∈ M. From (3.30) and (3.49), it follows that I (φη∗ ) ≥ dM ≥ d. In addition, one has 1 3 1 ω 1 − η∗ 2 1 − η∗ − 2 |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x I (φ) − I (φη∗ ) = 2 2
(3 p−9 1 ∗ 4 a |φ| p+1 d x, 1−η − (4.21) 4 3 p−9 1 3 Q(φ) − Q(φη∗ ) = 1 − η∗ 2 1 − η∗ 4 a |φ| p+1 d x. (4.22) |∇φ|2 d x − 4 Thus from η∗ > 1 and
7 3
≤ p < 3, it follows that
I (φ) − I (φη∗ ) ≥
1 1 1 Q(φ) − Q(φη∗ ) = Q(φ). 2 2 2
(4.23)
For the case 2-2-b), we have S(φλ ) = 0 and Q(φλ ) ≤ 0. Thus (3.5) and (3.49) imply that I (φλ ) ≥ dN ≥ d. Referring to (4.21) and (4.22), we have I (φ) − I (φλ ) ≥
1 1 1 Q(φ) − Q(φλ ) ≥ Q(φ). 2 2 2
(4.24)
For the case 2-2-a) and the case 2-2-b), since I (φη∗ ) ≥ d, I (φλ ) ≥ d, from (4.23) and (4.24), it follows that Q(φ) ≤ 2[I (φ) − I (φη∗ )] ≤ 2[I (φ) − d], (4.25) Q(φ) ≤ 2[I (φ) − I (φλ )] ≤ 2[I (φ) − d]. From (2.2), (2.3), (2.4) and (3.1), one has I (φ) = I (φ0 ). Thus by φ0 ∈ K and (4.2), we have J (t) = 8Q(φ) < 16[I (φ) − d] = 16[I (φ0 ) − d] < 0.
(4.26)
114
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
Thus, from the arguments of Step 2-1 and Step 2-2, in view of (4.18) and (4.26), obviously J (t) can not verify the above inequality for all time (see also Glassey [12]). Therefore, from Proposition 2.1, it must be the case that T < ∞ , which implies lim φ(t, .) H 1 (R N ) = ∞. t∈T
That is, the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time for p = 3 and N ∈ {2, 3}. From the arguments of Step 1 and Step 2, the proof of Theorem 4.1 is completed. Remark 4.1. In Theorem 4.1, we developed a new argument to obtain the blowup property of the solutions to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). Since d > 0, we see that Theorem 4.1 is quite different from Corollary 2.1. If d ≤ 21 |φ0 |2 d x, then by (2.2), (2.3), (2.4), (3.1) and I (φ) < d, we can obtain E(φ0 ) < 0. Thus in this case, from Corollary 2.1, it can follow the result of Theorem 4.1. On the other hand, if d > 21 |φ0 |2 d x, then from I (φ) < d, it may conclude three cases: (1) E(φ0 ) > 0; (2) E(φ0 ) = 0; (3) E(φ0 ) < 0. So Theorem 4.1 includes the result that when initial energy is nonnegative, the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) can also blow up in finite time. This kind of results in Theorem 4.1 generalize the result in Corollary 2.1. In the following, we give a sufficient condition for global existence of the solutions to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1). +2 Theorem 4.2. Let N ∈ {2, 3} and 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + . If φ0 ∈ K+ ∪ R+ , then the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞).
Proof. We prove this theorem by two steps. Step 1. We prove the case φ0 ∈ K+ . Step 2. We prove the case φ0 ∈ R+ . Firstly, we consider Step 1. φ0 ∈ K+ . From φ0 ∈ K + , Proposition 3.3 implies that the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) satisfies that φ(t, ·) ∈ K+ for t ∈ [0, T ). For fixed t ∈ [0, T ), we denote φ(t, ·) = φ. So we have I (φ) < d, Q(φ) > 0 and S(φ) < 0. Thus φ ≡ 0. According to (3.1) and (3.3), I (φ) < d and Q(φ) > 0 yield that
1 2 ω − |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x 2 N ( p − 1) 2
1 1 − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x < d. (4.27) + 2( p − 1) 4 In the following, we divide the proof into six cases: 1) N = 2 and p = 3; 2) N = 3 and p = 3; 3) N = 2 and 3 < p < ∞; 4) N = 3 and p = 73 ; 5) N = 3 and 73 < p < 3; 6) N = 3 and 3 < p < 5. Step 1-1. We first consider the case 1), N = 2 and p = 3. By (4.27), we have ω (4.28) |φ|2 d x < d. 2
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
115
1 In the following, we prove that |∇φ|2 d x is bounded. Put φλ = λ 2 φ(λx). It follows from (3.3) that 1 1 Q(φλ ) = λ |∇φ|2 d x − a |φ|4 d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. (4.29) 2 2 By Q(φ) > 0, it follows that when λ → 0, Q(φλ ) < 0 and λ → 1, Q(φλ ) > 0. Thus by continuity, there exists a 0 < λ∗ < 1 such that Q(φλ∗ ) = 0. According to (3.1) and (3.3), we have ω ω ∗ −1 2 ∗ ∗ I (φλ ) = (4.30) |φ|2 d x. |φλ | d x = λ 2 2 From (4.28), it follows that I (φλ∗ ) < λ∗ −1 d.
(4.31)
Also, by (3.2) and (3.3), it follows from Q(φλ∗ ) = 0 and S(φ) < 0 that 2 ∗ ∗ S(φλ ) = ω |φλ | d x − |∇φλ∗ |2 d x = ωλ∗ −1 |φ|2 d x − λ∗ |∇φ|2 d x,
(4.31*)
which has two possibilities: 1-1-i) S(φλ∗ ) < 0. 1-1-ii)
S(φλ∗ ) ≥ 0.
We first treat 1-1-i), S(φλ∗ ) < 0. In this case, noting that Q(φλ∗ ) = 0, we get φλ∗ ∈ M. Thus by (3.30) and (3.49), one has I (φλ∗ ) ≥ dM ≥ d > I (φ),
(4.32)
I (φ) − I (φλ∗ ) < 0.
(4.33)
which implies that
That is,
1 1 ∗ − λ 2 2
|∇φ| d x + 2
By (4.28), it has |∇φ|2 d x <
1 1 ∗ −1 ω |φ|2 d x < 0. − λ 2 2
λ∗ −1 − 1 ω 1 − λ∗
|φ|2 d x < 2
λ∗ −1 − 1 d. 1 − λ∗
(4.34)
(4.35)
∗−1
Since 0 < λ∗ < 1, one has λ1−λ−1 ∗ > 0. Now we consider 1-1-ii), S(φλ∗ ) ≥ 0. In this case, from (4.31) it follows that I (φλ∗ ) −
1 S(φλ∗ ) < λ∗ −1 d. 4
(4.36)
116
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
Thus by (4.30) and (4.31)∗ , one gets 1 1 |∇φλ∗ |2 d x + ω |φλ∗ |2 d x < λ∗ −1 d. 4 4 Namely, λ
∗
|∇φ| d x + λ
which implies that
2
∗ −1
ω
(4.37)
|φ|2 d x < 4λ∗ −1 d,
|∇φ|2 d x < 4λ∗ −2 d.
(4.38)
By (4.35) and (4.38), we obtain that |∇φ|2 d x is bounded for any t ∈ [0, T ), which together with (4.28) yields that φ is bounded in H 1 (R N ). So Proposition 2.1 implies that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) globally exists on t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ K+ , p = 3 and N = 2. Step 1-2. Secondly, we treat the case 2), N = 3 and p = 3. By (4.27), we get 1 ω (4.39) |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x < d, 6 2 which implies that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) is bounded in H 1 (R N ) for any t ∈ [0, T ). So Proposition 2.1 implies that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) globally exists on t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ K+ , p = 3 and N = 3. Step 1-3. Thirdly, we deal with the case 3), N = 2 and 3 < p < ∞. In this case, it follows from Q(φ) > 0 that p−1 1 2 p+1 a |φ| d x + b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. |∇φ| d x > p+1 2 Thus (3.1) implies that
p−1 1 a |φ| p+1 d x + b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x 2( p + 1) 4 ω 1 1 2 p+1 + |φ| d x − a |φ| d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x 2 p+1 4
1 p−1 ω − a |φ| p+1 d x + = |φ|2 d x 2( p + 1) p+1 2 p−3 ω a |φ| p+1 d x + = |φ|2 d x, 2( p + 1) 2
I (φ) ≥
which together with I (φ) < d yields that p−3 ω a |φ| p+1 d x + |φ|2 d x < d. 2( p + 1) 2 Since 3 < p < ∞, we obtain ω 2
|φ|2 d x < d.
(4.40)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
In the following, we prove that Put φλ = λ 4
117
|∇φ|2 d x is bounded.
2 p+1
Q(φλ ) = λ p+1
φ(λx). It follows from (3.3) that p−1 1 6−2 p a |φ| p+1 d x − λ p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. |∇φ|2 d x − p+1 2 (4.41)
By Q(φ) > 0, one has when λ → 0, Q(φλ ) < 0, and when λ → 1, Q(φλ ) > 0. Thus by continuity, there exists 0 < λ∗ < 1 such that Q(φλ∗ ) = 0. According to (3.1) and (3.2), one has 4 1 ω 2−2 p |φ|2 d x I (φλ∗ ) = λ∗ p+1 |∇φ|2 d x + λ∗ p+1 2 2 1 1 6−2 p a |φ| p+1 d x − λ∗ p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x, (4.42) − p+1 4 2−2 p 4 ∗ p+1 2 ∗ p+1 ∗ S(φλ ) = λ |∇φ| d x + ωλ |φ|2 d x 6−2 p (4.43) −a |φ| p+1 d x − λ∗ p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. From S(φ) < 0, it follows that S(φλ∗ ) has two possibilities: 1-3-a) S(φλ∗ ) < 0; 1-3-b) S(φλ∗ ) ≥ 0. We first consider 1-3-a), S(φλ∗ ) < 0. In this case, noting that Q(φλ∗ ) = 0, one has φλ∗ ∈ M. Thus by (3.30) and (3.49), one has I (φλ∗ ) ≥ dM ≥ d > I (φ).
(4.44)
I (φ) − I (φλ∗ ) < 0.
(4.45)
Equation (4.44) implies that
That is,
4 1 1 ∗ p+1 − λ 2 2
|∇φ|2 d x
p 1 1 ∗ 2−2 − λ p+1 ω |φ|2 d x 2 2
p 1 1 ∗ 6−2 λ p+1 − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x + 4 4 < 0.
+
6−2 p
Since 3 < p < ∞ and 0 < λ∗ < 1, one has λ∗ p+1 So (4.40) and (4.46) imply that
p 1 1 ∗ 2−2 1 2 p+1 |∇φ| d x < λ / − − 2 2 2 < 2[(λ∗
2−2 p p+1
4
> 1, λ∗ p+1 < 1 and λ∗ 4 1 ∗ p+1 λ 2 4
− 1)/(1 − λ∗ p+1 )]d.
(4.46)
2−2 p p+1
> 1.
ω
|φ|2 d x (4.47)
118
Z. Gan, J. Zhang 2
Secondly, we deal with 1-3-b), S(φλ∗ ) ≥ 0. In this case, let φβ = β p+1 φλ∗ (βx). By (3.2), we get 2−2 p 4 S(φβ ) = β p+1 |∇φλ∗ |2 d x + β p+1 ω |φλ∗ |2 d x 6−2 p −a |φλ∗ | p+1 d x − β p+1 b |φλ∗ |2 E 1 (|φλ∗ |2 )d x. (4.48) From S(φλ∗ ) ≥ 0, it has S(φ1 ) = S(φλ∗ ) ≥ 0 for β = 1 and S(φβ ) < 0 for β close to zero. Therefore, there exists β ∗ ∈ (0, 1] such that S(φβ ∗ ) = 0. Thus by (3.5) and (3.49), it has I (φβ ∗ ) ≥ dN ≥ d > I (φ).
(4.49)
Since I (φβ ∗ ) =
2−2 p 4 1 ∗ ∗ p+1 ω (β λ ) |∇φ|2 d x + (β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 |φ|2 d x 2 2 6−2 p 1 1 a |φ| p+1 d x − (β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x, − p+1 4
which together with (4.49) implies that 4 1 1 − (β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 2
2−2 p ω 1 − (β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x 2
6−2 p 1 (β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 − 1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x + 4 < 0.
(4.50)
From 3 < p < ∞ and β ∗ λ∗ ∈ (0, 1) since β ∗ ∈ (0, 1] and λ∗ ∈ (0, 1), (4.40) and (4.50) yield that 2−2 p 4 (4.51) |∇φ|2 d x < 2[((β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 − 1)/(1 − (β ∗ λ∗ ) p+1 )]d. By (4.40), (4.47) and (4.51), we get that φ is bounded in H 1 (R N ). So Proposition 2.1 implies that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) globally exists on t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ K+ , N = 2 and 3 < p < ∞. Step 1-4. We then consider the case 4), N = 3 and p = 73 . In this case, by (4.27) we have ω 1 (4.52) |φ|2 d x + b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x < d. 2 8 9
We put φµ = µ 10 φ(µx). Then we get 4
Q(φµ ) = µ 5
3 |∇φ|2 d x − a 5
10 3 3 |φ| 3 d x − µ 5 b 4
|φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. (4.53)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
119
Thus Q(φ) > 0 implies that there exists a µ∗ ∈ (0, 1) such that Q(φµ∗ ) = 0. By (3.1), (3.3) and Q(φµ∗ ) = 0, we have ω 1 |φµ∗ |2 d x + b |φµ∗ |2 E 1 (|φµ∗ |2 )d x 2 8 ω ∗ − 65 1 ∗ 35 2 = µ |φ| d x + µ b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. 2 8
I (φµ∗ ) =
(4.54)
It follows from (4.53) and µ∗ ∈ (0, 1) that 6
I (φµ∗ ) < µ∗ − 5 d.
(4.55)
Now we consider S(φµ∗ ), which has two possibilities: 1-4-a) S(φµ∗ ) < 0; 1-4-b) S(φµ∗ ) ≥ 0. At first, we consider 1-4-a), S(φµ∗ ) < 0. In this case, noting that Q(φµ∗ ) = 0, we have φµ∗ ∈ M, which together with (3.30) and (3.49) implies that I (φµ∗ ) ≥ dM ≥ d > I (φ).
(4.56)
I (φ) − I (φµ∗ ) < 0,
(4.57)
So one has
namely,
1 1 ∗ 45 1 2 ∗ − 65 − µ 1−µ ω |φ|2 d x |∇φ| d x + 2 2 2 3 1 − 1 − µ∗ 5 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x < 0, 4
which implies that
∗ − 65 ∗ 45 ω |φ|2 d x −1 / 1−µ |∇φ| d x < µ 3 4 1 + 1 − µ∗ 5 / 1 − µ∗ 5 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. 2 2
(4.58)
By (4.52) and µ∗ ∈ (0, 1), we get |∇φ|2 d x < C.
(4.59)
Now we deal with 1-4-b), S(φµ∗ ) ≥ 0. In this case, from (4.55), it follows that I (φµ∗ ) −
6 3 S(φµ∗ ) < µ∗ − 5 d. 10
(4.60)
120
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
It follows that 1 ∗ 45 µ 5
1 ∗ − 65 ω |φ|2 d x |∇φ| d x + µ 5 1 ∗ 35 + µ b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x 20 2
6
< µ∗ − 5 d. Thus
|∇φ|2 d x < C.
(4.61)
Therefore, (4.52), (4.59) and (4.61) show that φ is bounded in H 1 (R N ) for any t ∈ [0, T ). Thus by Proposition 2.1, we get that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ K+ , N = 3 and p = 73 . Step 1-5. We further treat the case 5), N = 3 and 73 < p < 3. In this case, by (4.27), we get
2 1 ω 2 − |∇φ| d x + |φ|2 d x 2 3( p − 1) 2
1 1 − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x + 2( p − 1) 4 < d. (4.62) 2 1 > 0 and 2( p−1) − 41 > 0. Therefore, (4.62) implies Since 73 < p < 3, it has 21 − 3( p−1) that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) is bounded in H 1 (R N ) for any t ∈ [0, T ). Thus Proposition 2.1 implies that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ K+ , N = 3 and 73 < p < 3. Step 1-6. At last, we investigate the case 6), N = 3 and 3 < p < 5. In this case, from (3.3) and Q(φ) > 0, it follows that 1 1 p−1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x > − a |φ| p+1 d x, (4.63) |∇φ|2 d x + 4 3 2( p + 1)
which together with (3.1) and I (φ) < d implies that 1 ω p−3 2 2 a |φ| p+1 d x < d. |∇φ| d x + |φ| d x + 6 2 2( p + 1) Since 3 < p < 5, (4.64) yields that 1 ω |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x < d. 6 2
(4.64)
(4.65)
Equation (4.65)gives that φ is bounded in H 1 (R N ) for any t ∈ [0, T ). Thus Proposition 2.1 implies that the solution φ of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ K+ , N = 3 and 3 < p < 5. +2 Thus from Step 1-1-Step 1-6, for φ0 ∈ K+ , N ∈ {2, 3} and 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , we have proved that the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞).
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
121
Now we deal with Step 2. φ0 ∈ R+ . By φ0 ∈ R+ , Proposition 3.3 implies that the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) satisfies that φ(t, ·) ∈ R+ for t ∈ [0, T ). Then we have I (φ) < d and S(φ) > 0. By S(φ) > 0 and (3.2), one has
− a |φ| p+1 d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x > − |∇φ|2 d x + ω |φ|2 d x . (4.66) +2 From I (φ) < d and 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , one has the following two results: (1) For N ∈ {2, 3} and 3 ≤ p < ∞, it follows from I (φ) < d that ω 1 |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x 2 2 a 1 p+1 − |φ| d x − b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x 4 4 ≤ I (φ) < d.
(2) For N = 3 and 73 ≤ p < 3, it follows from I (φ) < d that ω 1 |∇φ|2 d x + |φ|2 d x 2 2 a 1 p+1 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x − |φ| d x − p+1 p+1 < I (φ) < d. Therefore (4.66), (4.67) and (4.68) imply that ω 1 2 |∇φ| d x + |φ|2 d x < d, 4 4 or
1 1 − 2 p+1
|∇φ| d x + ω
(4.68)
(4.69)
2
(4.67)
|φ| d x 2
< d.
(4.70)
+2 1 N In view of 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + , (4.69) and (4.70) imply that φ is bounded in H (R ) for any t ∈ [0, T ). Thus by Proposition 2.1, we obtain that the solution φ of the Cauchy +2 problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞) for φ0 ∈ R+ , 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. Through the arguments of Step 1 and Step 2, we complete the proof of Theorem 4.2.
By Theorem 4.1 and 4.2, using Proposition 3.4, we can get a necessary and sufficient condition for blowup of the solution to the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) for 1 + N4 ≤ p < N +2 (N −2)+ and N ∈ {2, 3}. +2 Theorem 4.3. Let 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. If φ0 satisfies I (φ0 ) < d, then the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time if and only if φ0 ∈ K.
In addition, by Theorem 4.2 and using the scaling argument, we can also get another sufficient condition for the global existence of the solution to the Cauchy problem (1.1)(2.1).
122
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
Corollary 4.1. (Small Data Criterion). Let 1 + N4 ≤ p < ω > 0. If φ0 ∈ H 1 (R N ) and satisfies |∇φ0 |2 d x + ω |φ0 |2 d x < 2d,
N +2 (N −2)+ ,
N ∈ {2, 3} and
(4.71)
then the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally in t ∈ [0, ∞). Proof. According to (3.1) and (4.71), we can get I (φ0 ) < d. In addition, we assert that S(φ0 ) > 0. If otherwise, from (3.2), there were a 0 < λ ≤ 1 such that S(λφ0 ) = 0. Thus by (3.5) and (3.49), I (λφ0 ) ≥ dN ≥ d. On the other hand,
(4.72)
|∇(λφ0 )| d x + ω |λφ0 |2 d x
= λ2 |∇φ0 |2 d x + ω |φ0 |2 d x 2
< 2λ2 d ≤ 2d,
(4.73)
which implies that I (λφ0 ) < d.
(4.74)
Equations (4.72) and (4.74) are contradictory. So S(φ0 ) > 0 holds. From the above argument, we get φ0 ∈ R+ , thus Theorem 4.2 yields the result of Corollary 4.1. Remark 4.2. Although the condition for global existence in Corollary 4.1 is not sharp, Corollary 4.1 gives an answer to the question: How small are the initial data, when the solution of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) exists globally? 5. Instability of the Standing Waves Using the methods in Berestycki and Cazenave [1] as well as Rabinowitz [25], one can easily obtain that the constrained variational problem (3.5) is attained. Let u be a solution of (3.5), that is we have dN = min I (u).
(5.1)
u∈N
Then u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} is a solution of (3.13). Thus φ(t, x) = eiωt u(x)
(5.2)
is a standing wave solution of (1.1). From (5.1), it follows that u(x) is a ground state solution of (3.13). Now we hope to study the instability of the standing wave (5.2). In general, it depends upon the frequency ω and the solvability of the following variational problem: dQ =
inf
{u∈H 1 (R N )\{0},Q(u)=0}
I (u).
(5.3)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
123
In the present paper, by Proposition 3.1 and Theorem 4.1, we can refrain from solving the problem (5.3), and show the instability of the standing wave (5.2), which commonly depends upon the frequency ω (see Cipolatti [5], Ohta [21,22]). In order to obtain the instability result, we first consider two lemmas which are key to our analysis later. Lemma 5.1. Let φ ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0}. Then there exists a unique µ > 0 such that S(µφ) = 0 and I (µφ) > I (λφ) for any λ > 0 and λ = µ. Proof. Let λ > 0. Then we have
2 2 2 S(λφ) = λ |∇φ| d x + ω |φ| d x p+1 p+1 4 −λ a |φ| d x − λ b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x,
1 I (λφ) = λ2 |∇φ|2 d x + ω |φ|2 d x 2 1 1 λ p+1 a |φ| p+1 d x − λ4 b |φ|2 E 1 (|φ|2 )d x. − p+1 4
(5.4)
(5.5)
Noting that (5.4) and (5.5), we obtain d I (λφ) = λ−1 S(λφ). dλ
(5.6)
Thus by (5.4) and (5.6), the result of Lemma 5.1 is true.
Lemma 5.2. Let u be a minimizer of (5.1). Then Q(u) = 0. Proof. Since u is a minimizer of (5.1), thus u is also a solution of (3.13) or (1.8). So multiplying (3.13) by x · ∇u, we get N −2 2 1 a |u| p+1 d x − b |u|2 E 1 (|u|2 )d x = 0, |∇u|2 d x +ω |u|2 d x − N p+1 2 (5.7) which is called Pohozaev identity. Note that S(u) = 0, (5.7) implies that Q(u) = 0.
Using Lemma 5.1 and Lemma 5.2, on the standing wave (5.2), we get the following instability theorem. +2 Theorem 5.1. For 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}, Let ω be such that dM ≥ dN . Then for the minimizer u of (3.5) and any ε > 0, there exists φ0 ∈ H 1 (R N ) with φ0 − u H 1 (R N ) < ε such that the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time.
Proof. Since dM ≥ dN , one has d = dN by (3.49). Because u is the minimizer of (3.5), it follows from Lemma 3.2 that there exists u ∈ H 1 (R N ) \ {0} such that both S(u) = 0 and Q(u) = 0. Thus by (3.2) and (3.3), for any λ > 1 we have S(λu) < 0,
Q(λu) < 0,
λ > 1.
(5.8)
124
Z. Gan, J. Zhang
On the other hand, from Lemma 5.1, S(u) = 0 implies that I (λu) < I (u) for any λ > 1. Note that I (u) = dN = d. Thus for any λ > 1, we have λu ∈ K. Now we take λ > 1, and λ is sufficiently close to 1 such that λu − u H 1 (R N ) = (λ − 1) u H 1 (R N ) < ε.
(5.9)
Then take φ0 = λu(x). From Theorem 4.1, it follows that the solution φ(t, x) of the Cauchy problem (1.1)-(2.1) blows up in finite time. Remark 5.1. Under the condition dM ≥ dN , Theorem 5.1 gives the strong instability of the ground state standing wave (5.2) for system (1.1) with finite time blow up when +2 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. For the related results on the instability of the standing wave (5.2) for system (1.1), there has been a lot of work (see Cipolatti [5] and Ohta [20–22]). Cipolatti [5] proved that if p ≥ 3 and N ∈ {2, 3}, then the standing wave (5.2) is unstable for any ω ∈ (0, ∞) and that if N = 2 and p = 3, then the standing wave (5.2) is strongly unstable for any ω ∈ (0, ∞). After that, the author [21] proved that if p ≥ 1 + N4 and N ∈ {2, 3}, then (5.2) is unstable for any ω ∈ (0, ∞), and if N = 3 and 1 < p < 73 , then there exists a positive constant ω0 = ω0 (a, p) such that (5.2) is unstable for any ω ∈ (ω0 , ∞). In addition, the author [20] showed that if N = 3 and 73 < p < 5, then (5.2) is strongly unstable for any ω ∈ (0, ∞). On the other hand, when N = 2 and p ≤ 3, the author [20] proved the existence of stable standing waves of (1.1). Further, under the condition N = 2 and p > 3 or N = 3 and p = 73 , the author [22] obtained that for any ω ∈ (0, ∞), (5.2) is strongly unstable in the sense of Definition 1.1 of [22]. It should be pointed out that in the present paper, we introduce the cross-invariant manifold to discuss the instability of standing waves for system (1.1) with finite time blow up. These kind of results partially answer the open problem proposed in [21, Remark 8]. In Theorem 5.1, by limiting frequency ω to satisfy dM ≥ dN , we get the strong +2 instability of (5.2) for 1 + N4 ≤ p < (NN−2) + and N ∈ {2, 3}. Of course, the condition dM ≥ dN is still vague. Further we need to determine for which ω, dM ≥ dN is true. Moreover, if dM < dN , is the standing wave (5.2) orbital stable? These problems remain open. Acknowledgements. This work is partially done when the first author visited the IMS of the Chinese University of Hong Kong. She would like to express her thanks for the hospitality of the IMS. Especially, she would like to express her deep gratitude to Professor Zhouping Xin for his valuable suggestions and constant encouragements.
References 1. Berestycki, H., Cazenave, T.: Instabilite´ des etats ´ stationnaires dans les equations ´ de Schrödinger et de Klein-Gordon non lineairees. ´ C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 293, 489–492 (1981) 2. Cazenave, T.: An introduction to nonlinear Schrödinger equations. Textos de Métodos, Vol. 22, Rio de Janeiro: Instituto de Mathemática-UFRJ,1989 3. Cazenave, T., Lions, P.L.: Orbital stability of standing waves for nonlinear Schrödinger equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 85, 549–561 (1982) 4. Cipolatti, R.: On the existence of standing waves for a Davey-Stewartson system. Comm. P.D.E. 17, 967–988 (1992) 5. Cipolatti, R.: On the instability of ground states for a Davey-Stewartson system, Ann. Inst. Henri Poincare. ´ Phys. Theor. ´ 58, 85–104 (1993) 6. Davey, A., Stewartson, K.: On three-dimensional packets of surface waves. Proc. R. Soc. London A 338, 101–110 (1974)
Global Existence Sharp Threshold and Instability in Davey-Stewartson System
125
7. Gan, Z.H., Zhang, J.: Sharp conditions of global existence for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system in three dimensional space. Acta Mathematica Scientia, Series A 26(1), 87–92 (2006) 8. Gan, Z.H., Zhang, J.: Sharp conditions of global existence for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system in two space dimensions. Math. Appl. 17(3), 360–365 (2004) 9. Gan, Z.H., Zhang, J.: Sharp conditions of global existence and collapse for coupled nonlinear Schrödinger equations. J. Part. Diff. Eqs. 17, 207–220 (2004) 10. Ginibre, J., Velo, G.: On a class of nonlinear Schrödinger equations. J. Funct. Anal. 32, 1–71 (1979) 11. Ginibre, J., Velo, G.: The global Cauchy problem for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. Ann.Inst. H. Poincare. ´ Anal. Non Lineaire ´ 2, 309–327 (1985) 12. Glassey, R.T.: On the blowing up of solutions to the Cauchy problem for nonlinear Schrödinger equations. J. Math. Phys. 18(9), 1794–1797 (1977) 13. Grillakis, M., Shatah, J., Strauss, W.A.: Stability theory of solitary waves in presence of symmetry I. J. Funct. Anal. 74, 160–197 (1987) 14. Ghidaglia, J.M., Saut, J.C.: On the initial value problem for the Davey-Stewartson systems. Nonlinearity 3, 475–506 (1990) 15. Guo, B.L., Wang, B.X.: The Cauchy problem for Davey-Stewartson systems. Commun Pure Appl. Math. 52(12), 1477–1490 (1999) 16. Levine, H.A.: Instability and non-existence of global solutions to nonlinear wave equations of the form Pu tt = −Au + F(u). Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 192, 1–21 (1974) 17. Li, Y.S., Guo, B.L., Jiang, M.R.: Global existence and blowup of solutions to a degenerate Davey-Stewartson equations. J. Math. Phys. 41(5), 2943–2956 (2000) 18. Lions, P.L.: The concentration-compactness principle in the calculus of variations, the locally compact case, Part I. Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré. Analyse Non linéaire 1, 109–145 (1984) 19. Lions, P.L.: The concentration-compactness principle in the calculus of variations, the locally compact case, Part I. Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré. Analyse Non linéaire 1, 223–283 (1984) 20. Ohta, M.: Stability of standing waves for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system, J. Dynam. Differ. Eqs. 6(2), 325–334 (1994) 21. Ohta, M.: Instability of standing waves for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincare´ 62, 69–80 (1995) 22. Ohta, M.: Blow-up solutions and strong instability of standing waves for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system in R 2 . Ann. Inst. Henri Poincare´ 63, 111–117 (1995) 23. Ozawa, T.: Exact blow-up solutions to the Cauchy problem for the Davey-Stewartson systems. Proc. Roy. Soc. London Ser. A 436(1897), 345–349 (1992) 24. Payne, L.E., Sattinger, D.H.: Saddle points and instability of nonlinear hyperbolic equations. Israel J. Math. 22(3-4), 273–303 (1975) 25. Rabinowitz, P. H.: On a class of nonlinear Schrödinger equations. Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 43, 270–291 (1992) 26. Shatah, J., Strauss, W.A.: Instability of nonlinear bound states. Commun. Math. Phys. 100, 173–190 (1985) 27. Shu, J., Zhang, J.: conditons of global existence for the generalized Davey-Stewartson system. IMA J. Appl. Math. 72(1), 36–42 (2007) 28. Soffer, A., Weinstein, M.I.: Resonances, radiation damping and instability in Hamiltonian nonlinear wave equations. Invent. Math. 36, 9–74 (1999) 29. Tsutsumi, M.: Decay of weak solutions to the Davey-Stewartson systems. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 182(3), 680–704 (1994) 30. Wang, B.X., Guo, B.L.: On the initial value problem and scattering of solutions for the generalized Davey-Stewartson systems. Sci. in China 44(8), 994–1002 (2001) 31. Weinstein, M.I.: Nonlinear Schrödinger equations and sharp interpolations estimates. Commun. Math. Phys. 87, 567–576 (1983) 32. Zhang, J.: On the finite-time behaviour for nonlinear Schrödinger equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 162, 249–260 (1994) 33. Zhang, J.: Sharp conditions of global existence for nonlinear Schrödinger and Klein-Gordon equations. Nonlinear Anal. 48, 191–207 (2002) 34. Zhang, J.: Sharp threshold for blowup and global existence in nonlinear Schrödinger equations under a harmonic potential. Commun. in PDE 30, 1429–1443 (2005) 35. Zhang, J.: Cross-constrained variational problem and nonlinear Schrödinger equation. In: Proceedings of the Smalefest 2000, F. Cucker, J. M. Rojas (eds.), Foundations of Computational Math. Series 457–469, River Edge, NJ: World Scientific, 2002 Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 283, 127–167 (2008) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0564-8
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe Alain Bachelot Université de Bordeaux, Institut de Mathématiques, UMR CNRS 5251, F-33405 Talence Cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 20 July 2007 / Accepted: 20 March 2008 Published online: 18 July 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: We investigate the global solutions of the Dirac equation on the Antide-Sitter Universe. Since this space is not globally hyperbolic, the Cauchy problem is not, a priori, well-posed. Nevertheless we can prove that there exists unitary dynamics, but its uniqueness crucially depends on the ratio beween the mass M of the field and the cosmological constant > 0: it appears a critical value, /12, which plays a role similar to the Breitenlohner-Freedman bound for the scalar fields. When M 2 ≥ /12 there exists a unique unitary dynamics. On the contrary, for the light fermions satisfying M 2 < /12, we construct several asymptotic conditions at infinity, such that the problem becomes well-posed. In all the cases, the spectrum of the hamiltonian is discrete. We also prove a result of equipartition of the energy. I. Introduction There has been much recent interest in the field theory in the covering space of the Anti-de-Sitter space-time C Ad S, that appears as the ground state of the gauged supergravity group [15]. This lorentzian manifold is the maximally symmetric solution of the Einstein equations with cosmological constant − < 0 included. Its topology is Rt × R3X , but its causality is non-trivial because it is non-globally hyperbolic: the Cauchy data on {t = 0} × R3 determines the evolution of the fields only in a region D, bounded by a null hypersurface, a Cauchy horizon. More precisely D is defined called 3 π by | t |< 2 − arctan . Thus we can think that to specify the physics 3 | X | apart from D, we have to impose some asymptotic constraint at infinity as | X |→ ∞. Since the conformal boundary of C Ad S is timelike, this condition can be considered as a boundary condition. It is exactly the case for the massless, conformally coupled scalar fields that are conformally invariant in C Ad S, and these fields have been studied in this spirit by Avis, Isham and Storey in [1]. For the massive fields the situation is different because the gravitational potential relative to any origin increases at large spatial
128
A. Bachelot
distances from the origin. It causes confinement of massive particles and prevents them from escaping to infinity. In fact, the situation is rather subtle and depends on the ratio between the mass from the field and the cosmological constant. This phenomenon has been discovered by Breitenlohner and Freedman [7,8], who have showed the existence of two critical values, the B-F bounds, for the scalar fields; the first one assures the positivity of the energy, and the second one assures the uniqueness of the dynamics. In this paper, we establish a similar result for the Dirac fields.1 The square of the mass of the spinors is compared with a unique B-F bound that is equal to /12. We shall see that the physics of the heavy fermions (M 2 ≥ /12) is uniquely determined, but there exists a lot of possible dynamics for the light fermions (M 2 < /12), involving the asymptotic forms, at the C Ad S infinity, of classical boundary conditions, local or non-local: MIT-bag, Chiral, APS conditions, etc. From the mathematical point of view, the solutions of the initial value problem are given in D by the Leray-Hadamard theorem for the hyperbolic equations ∂t = H(X, ∂ X ), and on the whole space-time, we solve the Cauchy problem by a spectral approach, i.e. we look for the solutions formally given by (t) = eitH (0). Therefore we have to construct self-adjoint extensions of the Dirac hamiltonian H(X, ∂ X ). This method was used by A. Ishibashi and R.M. Wald [21,22], for the integer spin fields. The paper is organized as follows. In Part II, we briefly describe the Anti-de-Sitter manifold, mainly the different systems of coordinates and the properties of the null and time-like geodesics. The explicit forms of the Dirac equation on C Ad S are described in Sect. III, and we state the main result, Theorem III.4. We perform the spinoidal spherical harmonics decomposition in the following part. The asymptotic conditions and the selfadjoint extensions are discussed in the final section. In a short appendix, we present a new proof of the B-F bounds for the Klein-Gordon equation. We end this introduction with some bibliographic information. Above all, we have to mention the works treating the scalar fields on C Ad S, [1,7,8,22]. We refer to [15,19,29] for a presentation of the Anti-de-Sitter universe. There are many mathematical works on the one-half spin field on curved space-time, in particular [4,17,18,25–28]. The gravitational potential plays the role of a variable mass that tends to the infinity at the space infinity; the rather similar Dirac equation on Minkowski space with increasing potential has been considered in [23,34,38]. The literature on the boundary value problems for the Dirac system is huge ; among important contributions, we can cite [5,6,9,10,16,20]. There are few papers concerning the deep problem of the global existence of fields on the non-globally hyperbolic lorentzian manifolds, in particular [2,11,13,21,32,37] .
II. The Anti-de-Sitter Space Time Given > 0, the anti-de-Sitter space Ad S is defined as the quadric (X 1 )2 + (X 2 )2 + (X 3 )2 − U 2 − V 2 = −
3
embedded in the flat 5-dimensional space R5 with the metric ds 2 = dU 2 + d V 2 − (d X 1 )2 − (d X 2 )2 − (d X 3 )2 . 1 The author thanks the anonymous referee for his valuable comments on the B-F bounds.
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
129
Ad S is the maximally symmetric solution of Einstein’s equations with an attractive cosmological constant − < 0. To describe Ad S it is convenient to set U = R cos T , V = R sin T , 3 3 then we can see that Ad S = ST1 × R3(X 1 ,X 2 ,X 3 ) , 2 2 R dT + d R 2 − (d X 1 )2 − (d X 2 )2 − (d X 3 )2 , 3 3 R = (X 1 )2 + (X 2 )2 + (X 3 )2 + .
ds 2Ad S =
For constant T , the slice {T } × R3 is exactly the 3-dimensional hyperbolic space H3 that is the upper sheet of the hyperboloid (X 1 )2 + (X 2 )2 + (X 3 )2 − W 2 = − 3 in the Minkowski space R4(X 1 ,X 2 ,X 3 ,W ) with the metric (d X 1 )2 + (d X 2 )2 + (d X 3 )2 − dW 2 . It is useful to use the spherical coordinates r=
(X 1 )2 + (X 2 )2 + (X 3 )2 ∈ [0, ∞[, and i f 0 < r, ω =
1 1 2 3 (X , X , X ) ∈ S 2 , r
for which the hyperbolic metric becomes 2 −1 2 2 dsH3 = 1 + r dr + r 2 dω2 , 3 where dω2 is the euclidean metric on the unit two-sphere S 2 , dω2 = dθ 2 + sin2 θ dϕ 2 , 0 ≤ θ ≤ π, 0 ≤ ϕ < 2π. We shall use the nice picture of the hyperbolic space, the so called Poincaré ball. We introduce 1 j 1 ≤ j ≤ 3, x = X j, 3 1 + 1 + r2 3
=
r 3 1+ 1+
2 3r
∈ [0, 1[,
then H3 can be seen as the unit ball B = {x := (x 1 , x 2 , x 2 ) ∈ R3 ; 2 = (x 1 )2 + (x 2 )2 + (x 3 )2 < 1} endowed with the metric 2 dsH 3 =
4 3 d2 + 2 dω2 , 0 ≤ < 1, ω ∈ S 2 . 1 − 2
130
A. Bachelot
We note that the time coordinate T is periodic, and this property implies the existence of closed timelike curves. To avoid this unpleasant fact, we replace T ∈ S 1 by t ∈ R, i.e. we change the topology, and we consider in this paper the Universal Covering Space of the anti-de-Sitter space-time, that is the lorentzian manifold C Ad S := (M, g) defined by M = Rt × R3(X 1 ,X 2 ,X 3 ) = Rt × B(x 1 ,x 2 ,x 3 ) , with the metric, −1 gµν d x µ d x ν = 1 + r 2 dt 2 − 1 + r 2 dr 2 − r 2 dω2 , 0 ≤ r < ∞, ω ∈ S 2 , 3 3 2
4 3 1 + 2 2 2 2 2 d , 0 ≤ < 1, ω ∈ S 2 . dt − + dω = 1 − 2 1 − 2 It will be useful to introduce a third radial coordinate, r = 2 arctan . x = arctan 3
(II.1)
Then the Anti-de-Sitter manifold can be described by: (t, x, θ, ϕ) ∈ R × [0,
π [×[0, π ] × [0, 2π [, 2
gµν d x µ d x ν = 1 + tan2 x g˜ µν d x µ d x ν , where g˜ is given by g˜ µν d x µ d x ν = dt 2 −
3 2 d x + sin2 xdθ 2 + sin2 x sin2 θ dϕ 2 .
Therefore, if the 3-sphere S 3 is parametrized by (x, θ, ϕ) ∈ [0, π ] × [0, π ] × [0, 2π [, and S+3 is the upper hemisphere [0, π2 [x ×[0, π ]θ × [0, 2π [ϕ , C Ad S can be considered = Rt × S+3 of the Einstein cylinder as conformally equivalent to the submanifold M (E, g), ˜ E := Rt × S 3 ,
π
(II.2)
2 = Rt × x = and the crucial point is that the boundary ∂ M 2 × Sθ,ϕ is time-like. Nevertheless, we should note that, unlike the black-hole horizon of the Schwarzschild metric (that is a characteristic submanifold of the Kruskal space-time), the time-like infinity of C Ad S, like the cosmological horizon of the De Sitter universe, (or a rainbow) is seen in the same way by any observer: since C Ad S is frame-homogeneous (i.e. any Lorentz frame on C Ad S can be carried to any other by the differential map of an isometry of C Ad S), no point is privileged. Finally we recall that the null geodesics of Ad S are straight lines in R5(X 1 ,X 2 ,X 3 ,U,V )
and the timelike geodesics are ellipses, intersection of Ad S with the 2-planes of R5 passing through the origin 0. As a consequence, C Ad S is geodesically complete, and time oriented by the Killing vector field ∂t , but its causality is not at all trivial: (1)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
131
given a point P on the slice t = 0, the future-pointing null geodesics starting from P form a curving cone of which the boundary approaches but does not reach the slice t =
π 2
2π
3 .
3 ,
hence C Ad S is not globally hyperbolic; (2) the future-pointing timelike geodesics on C Ad S starting from P, all meet a conjugate point Q at t = π 3 , P and Q project on antipodal points of Ad S. Therefore the time-like geodesics on C Ad S can be parametrized by (t, x(t))t∈R , where the function t → x(t) is t-periodic, with period These unusual properties yield important consequences for the propagation of
the fields: (1) suggests that we could have to add some condition at the “infinity” S 2 = ∂B to solve an initial value problem, at least for the massless fermions; nevertheless, since the massive particles propagate along the time-like geodesics, (2) seems to imply that such a condition is not necessary for the massive fields. In fact, the situation is rather subtle and depends on the ratio between the square of the mass of the fermion, and the cosmological constant. We shall see that no asymptotic constraint at infinity is necessary for the heavy spinors, but there are many possible physical constraints for the light masses. In all the cases, the spectrum of the hamiltonian of the massive fields is discrete. III. The Dirac Equation on C Ad S We consider the Dirac equation with mass M ∈ R on a 3+1 dimensional lorentzian manifold (M, g): µ
iγ(g) ∇µ ψ − Mψ = 0.
(III.1) µ
The notations are the following. ∇µ are the covariant derivatives, γ(g) , 0 ≤ µ ≤ 3, are the Dirac matrices, unique up to a unitary transform, satisfying: µ
µ
0∗ 0 ν ν = γ(g) , γ(g) = −γ(g) , 1 ≤ j ≤ 3, γ(g) γ(g) + γ(g) γ(g) = 2g µν 1. γ(g) j∗
j
(III.2)
Here A∗ denotes the conjugate transpose of any complex matrix A. We make the following choices for the Dirac matrices on the Minkowski space time R1+3 : γ µ are the 4 × 4 matrices of the Pauli-Dirac representation given for µ = 0, 1, 2, 3 by: γ = 0
where
I =
I 0 0 −I
, γ = j
0 σj −σ j 0
,
10 1 0 01 0 −i 1 2 3 , σ = , σ = , σ = . 01 0 −1 10 i 0
We also introduce another Dirac matrix that plays an important role in the boundary problems: 0I , (III.3) γ 5 := −iγ 0 γ 1 γ 2 γ 3 = I 0 that satisfies γ 5 γ µ + γ µ γ 5 = 0, 0 ≤ µ ≤ 3.
132
A. Bachelot
We know that when the metric is spherically symmetric,
1 gµν d x µ d x ν = F(r )dt 2 − dr 2 − r 2 dθ 2 + sin2 θ dϕ 2 , F(r ) µ
then, if we choose the local orthonormal Lorentz frame {ea , a = 0, 1, 2, 3} defined by 1 ea µ = g µµ 2 , i f µ = a, ea µ = 0 i f µ = a, the Dirac equation has the following form in (t, r, θ, ϕ) coordinates (see e.g. [26–28]): 1 1 ∂ ∂ 1 F
i 1 ∂ i F− 2 γ 0 + i F 2 γ 1 + + + γ2 + ∂t ∂r r 4F r ∂θ 2 tan θ ∂ i γ3 − M ψ = 0. + r sin θ ∂ϕ For the Anti-de-Sitter manifold we have
F(r ) = 1 + r 2 , 3
and it is convenient to make a first change of spinor ; we use the radial coordinate (II.1), and we put 1 4
(t, x, θ, ϕ) := r 1 + r 2 ψ(t, r, θ, ϕ). 3
(III.4)
Then we obtain the Dirac equation on the Anti-de-Sitter universe with the coordinates t ∈ R, x ∈ [0, π2 [, θ ∈ [0, π ], ϕ ∈ [0, 2π [: ∂ 1 1 1 0 3 ∂ 3 ∂ ∂
+ γ 0γ 1 + γ 0γ 2 + + γ γ
∂t ∂x sin x ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ i 3 0 + M γ = 0. (III.5) cos x Since the part of this differential operator involving ∂t , ∂x is with constant coefficients, the form of this equation is convenient to make a separation of variables by using the generalized spin spherical harmonics. But this decomposition has an inconvenience: since the one-half spin harmonics are not smooth functions on S 2 , the functional framework involves spaces that are different from the usual Sobolev spaces on S 2 as we shall see in the following part. It will also be useful to write the Dirac equation with the coordinates (t, , θ, ϕ) ∈ R × [0, 1[×[0, π ] × [0, 2π [. We put
(t, , θ, ϕ) := (t, x, θ, ϕ), : and the Dirac equation becomes: 3 ∂ 1 + 2
+ γ0 ∂t : 2 1 2 ∂ 1 1 2i M 3 1 ∂ 3 ∂ + γ + + γ + × γ
= 0. ∂ ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ 1 − 2 :
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
133
In the part involving γ 1 , γ 2 , γ 3 , we recognize the usual Dirac operator in spherical coordinates on R3 with the euclidean metric. This is a nice way to get the Dirac operator on C Ad S in cartesian coordinates. Adapting an approach of [33], we introduce 1
a := I − γ 1γ 2 − γ 2γ 3 − γ 3γ 1 , 2 ϕ
S(θ, ϕ) := e 2 γ
1γ 2
θ
e2γ
3γ 1
a.
(III.6)
We easily check that aa ∗ = I, SS ∗ = I, γ 1 a = aγ 2 , γ 2 a = aγ 3 , γ 3 a = aγ 1 . We put γ 1 (, θ ) := γ 1 , γ 2 (, θ ) := :
:
1 2 1 γ , γ 3 (, θ ) := γ 3, : sin θ
⎧ 1 ⎪ γ˜ (, θ, ϕ) := cos ϕ sin θ γ 1 + sin ϕ sin θ γ 2 + cos θ γ 3 , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1
⎨ 2 cos ϕ cos θ γ 1 + sin ϕ cos θ γ 2 − sin θ γ 3 , γ˜ (, θ, ϕ) := ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1
⎪ 3 ⎪ − sin ϕγ 1 + cos ϕγ 2 . ⎩ γ˜ (, θ, ϕ) := sin θ Tedious calculations give: 1 ≤ j ≤ 3, S(θ, ϕ)γ j (, θ ) = γ˜ j (, θ, ϕ)S(θ, ϕ). :
The cartesian coordinates x := (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) on B being x 1 = cos ϕ sin θ, x 2 = sin ϕ sin θ, x 3 = cos θ, ˜ on B by the relations we define the spinors , ˜ (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = (, θ, ϕ) :=
1 S(θ, ϕ) (, θ, ϕ), :
and the Dirac operators ⎧ ∂ ∂ ∂ ⎪ D : = γ1 1 + γ2 2 + γ3 3, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∂ x ∂ x ∂ x ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ ∂ ∂ ∂ ˜ : = γ˜ 1 + γ˜ 2 + γ˜ 3 , D ∂ ∂θ ∂ϕ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∂ ∂ ∂ 1 ⎪ 1 2 ⎩D + γ3 . :=γ +γ + : : ∂ : : ∂θ 2 tan θ ∂ϕ We omit the direct calculus that gives the links between these operators:
(III.7)
134
A. Bachelot
Lemma III.1.
1 ˜ ˜ (, θ, ϕ) = S(θ, ϕ) D (, θ, ϕ). (D) (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = D : : We denote S the operator that relates the spinors in cartesian and spherical coordinates: S : → S = , (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) :=
1 S(θ, ϕ) (x, θ, ϕ). tan x2
(III.8)
Then, if (t, .) is a solution of (III.5), the Dirac equation satisfied by (t, .) := S (t, .) for t ∈ R, x = (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) ∈ B has the form: 1 + 2 3 0∂ 3 2i M 1 ∂ 2 ∂ 3 ∂ γ + +γ +γ + γ = 0. (III.9) 1 2 3 2 ∂t 2 ∂x ∂x ∂x 1 − Since the charge of the spinor is the formally conserved L 2 norm, it is natural to introduce the Hilbert space: 4 2 L2 := L 2 B, dx , (III.10) 1 + 2 and given 0 ∈ L2 we want to solve the initial problem, i.e. to find a unique ∈ C 0 (Rt ; L2 )
(III.11)
(t = 0, .) = 0 (.),
(III.12)
∀t ∈ R, (t) L2 = 0 L2 .
(III.13)
solution of (III.9) satisfying:
and the conservation law:
Moreover, since
∂ ∂t
is a Killing vector field on C Ad S, it is natural to assume that t ∈ R −→ (0 → (t)) ,
(III.14)
is a group acting on L2 . Therefore we look for strongly continuous unitary groups U (t) on L2 that solve (III.5). According to the Stone theorem, the problem consists in finding self-adjoint realizations on L2 of the differential operator 3 1 + 2 2i M 0 1 ∂ 2 ∂ 3 ∂ γ γ +γ +γ + H M := i , (III.15) 1 2 3 2 2 ∂x ∂x ∂x 1− with domain
D(H M ) = ∈ L2 ; H M ∈ L2 ,
(III.16)
by adding suitable constraints at the CAdS infinity = 1. The answer crucially depends on the mass of the spinor. First we discuss the massless case. When M = 0, the Dirac system is conformal invariant, and it is equivalent to solving the Cauchy problem in the half of the Einstein
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
135
cylinder, Rt × S+3 . Therefore we can extend the initial data from the hemisphere S+3 to the whole sphere S 3 , and solve the Cauchy problem on the Einstein cylinder Rt × S 3 . This is tantamount to solving Eq. (III.9) on Rt ×R3x , instead of Rt ×Bx . This approach was used by S.J. Avis, C.J. Isham, D. Storey [1] for the scalar field, and later, by Y. Choquet-Bruhat for the Yang-Mills-Higgs equations [11]. By this way, we impose no boundary condition at the C Ad S infinity, or, in other words, a “perfectly transparent” boundary condition, and we easily obtain global solutions on C Ad S. We have to remark that since there exists a lot of ways to extend the initial data, such a solution is not uniquely determined by the Cauchy data on S+3 . Moreover the effect of this “perfectly transparent” condition is to recirculate the energy: the conserved charge is the L 2 -norm on S 3 while the L 2 -norm on S+3 is changing in time, and so (III.13) is not satisfied. In order to assure the conservation (III.13), we can take another route, and impose some “reflecting” boundary conditions on {x = π2 } × S 2 . In [1], several conditions are discussed for the scalar massless field. For the Dirac equation, we note that when M = 0, Eq. (III.9) has smooth coefficients up to the boundary | x |= 1. Therefore, in the massless case, we deal with a classical mixed hyperbolic problem, and different boundary conditions for the Dirac system with regular potential are well known (see e.g. [5,6,9,10,16,20]). We recall an important local boundary condition for the Dirac spinors defined on some open domain of the space-time, the so called generalized MIT-bag condition: n µ γ µ (t, x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = ieiαγ (t, x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ), (t, x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) ∈ ∂, 5
where n µ is the outgoing normal quadrivector at ∂ and α ∈ R is the chiral angle. When α = 0 this is the MIT-bag condition for the hadrons and when α = π this is the Chiral condition. Another fundamental boundary condition is the non-local APS condition introduced by M.F. Atiyah, V. K. Patodi, and I. M. Singer (see e.g. [6]) and defined by 1]0,∞[ (D∂ ) = 0 on ∂, where D∂ is the Dirac operator on ∂. More recently, O. Hijazi, S. Montiel, A. Roldan [20] have introduced the mAPS condition: 1]0,∞[ (D∂ ) I d − n µ γ µ = 0 on ∂. For = Rt × B, these boundary conditions become B(t, ω) = 0, (t, ω) ∈ R × S 2 ,
(III.17)
MIT − bag condition : BMIT = γ˜ 1 + i I d,
(III.18)
Chiral condition : BCHI = γ˜ 1 − i I d,
(III.19)
APS condition : BAPS = 1]0,∞[ D S 2 ,
(III.20)
mAPS condition : BmAPS = 1]0,∞[ D S 2 γ˜ 1 + I d ,
(III.21)
where
136
A. Bachelot
where D S 2 is the intrinsic Dirac operator on the two-sphere: 0 2 ∂ 3 ∂ ˜ + γ ˜
. γ ˜ D = iγ 2 S ∂θ ∂ϕ We conclude that there exists many unitary dynamics for the massless spin- 21 field on C Ad S, that we can easily construct by solving (III.9) with M = 0, (III.12), (III.17), by invoking the classical theorems on the mixed hyperbolic problems. In consequence, our work is mainly concerned with the massive field, and in the sequel, we consider only this case. When M = 0 the situation is very different because the potential blows up as → 1. The analogous situation of the infinite mass at the infinity of the Minkowski space has been investigated in [23,34]. In our case, the key result is the asymptotic behaviour, near the boundary, of the spinors of D(H M ). We note that it is sufficient to consider only the case of the positive mass, because the chiral transform −→ γ 5 changes M into −M since we have γ 5 H M γ 5 = H−M . We remark that the MIT-bag and the Chiral conditions are exchanged by the chiral transform, and the APS condition is chiral invariant. Theorem III.2. Let be in D (H M )with M ∈ R∗ . Then 4
1 , ∈ C 0 ]0, 1[ ; H 2 (Sω2
1 0
When M 2 >
12 ,
(ω) 2H 1 (S 2 ) d ≤ H M 2L2 . ω
we have (ω) L 2 (Sω2 ) = O
When M 2 =
12 ,
we have
1 − , → 1.
(III.22)
(III.23)
(III.24)
(III.25) ( − 1) ln (1 − ) , → 1. 1 4 When 0 < M 2 < 12 , we put m := M 3 , and there exists − ∈ H 2 (S 2 ) , 4 4 + ∈ L 2 (S 2 ) , and ψ ∈ C 0 [0, 1] ; L 2 (Sω2 ) satisfying (ω) L 2 (Sω2 ) = O
(ω) = (1 − )−m − (ω) + (1 − )m + (ω) + ψ(ω),
(III.26)
γ˜ 1 − + i− = 0, γ˜ 1 + − i+ = 0,
(III.27)
ψ(ω) L 2 (Sω2 ) = o
1 − , → 1.
(III.28)
1 4 1 4 Conversely, for any − ∈ H 2 +m (S 2 ) , + ∈ H 2 −m (S 2 ) satisfying (III.27), there exists ∈ D(H M ) satisfying (III.26) and (III.28).
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
137
Remark III.3. We shall see that (III.24) can be improved and when M 2 > 12 the el1 d 2 liptic estimate below (III.32) implies that 0 (ω) L 2 (S 2 ) (1−)2 < ∞. When ω 4 M 2 ≥ 12 , then ∈ C 0 (]0, 1] ; L 2 (Sω2 ) , but the trace of on ∂B does not exist for . Moreover we see with (III.23) that when M = 0, H M = 0 implies = M 2 < 12 4
1 for 0.The situation is different when M = 0: we have ∈ C 0 ]0, 1] ; H − 2 (Sω2
∈ D(H0 ), and this result is optimal: there exists ∈ L2 , = 0, with H0 = 0 and 4 4 1 (ω) ∈ H − 2 (Sω2 ) \ ∪s>− 1 H s (Sω2 ) . 2
, the elements of the domain of H M satisfy the homogeneous We note that when M 2≥ 12 Dirichlet Condition on ∂B. We shall see that H M is self-adjoint. On the contrary, when
, the trace of on ∂B is not defined, the leading term (1 − )−m − satis0 < M < 12 m fies the MIT-bag Condition and the next term (1 − ) + satisfies the Chiral Condition 12
(and the converse for −
< M < 0). We introduce natural generalizations of the
classic boundary conditions in terms of asymptotic behaviours near S 2 :
B(ω) L 2 (Sω2 ) = o 1− ,
(III.29)
and we consider the operators HB , B = B M I T , BC H I , B A P S , Bm A P S , defined as the differential operator H M endowed with the domain
D (HB ) := ∈ D(H M ); B(ω) L 2 (Sω2 ) = o 1− . We remark that (III.26), (III.27) and (III.28) imply: D HB M I T := { ∈ D(H M ); + = 0 i f M > 0, − = 0 i f M < 0} , D HBC H I := { ∈ D(H M ); − = 0 i f M > 0, + = 0 i f M < 0} , D HB A P S = D HBm A P S = ∈ D(H M ); 1]0,∞[ D S 2 + = 1]0,∞[ D S 2 − = 0 . We now construct a large family of asymptotic conditions, generalizing the previous one, by imposing a linear relation between − and + . If we denote ± 1 , ψ 2 , ψ 3 , ψ 4 ), the constraints of polarization (III.27) allow to express ψ 3,4 =t (ψ± ± ± ± ± 1,2 by using ψ± :
3 (ω) ψ± 4 (ω) ψ±
ω.σ = ± iω.σ
1 (ω) ψ± 2 (ω) , ω.σ := ψ±
3
ωjσ j. 1
We consider two densely defined self-adjoint operators (A± , D(A± )) on L 2 (S 2 ) × L 2 (S 2 ), satisfying 1
1
D(A+ ) = L 2 (S 2 ) × L 2 (S 2 ), D(A− ) ⊃ H 2 (S 2 ) × H 2 (S 2 ),
(III.30)
1 1 A± C ∞ (S 2 ) × C ∞ (S 2 ) ⊂ H 2 ±m (S 2 ) × H 2 ±m (S 2 ).
(III.31)
138
A. Bachelot 1
As an example, we can choose A− any hermitian matrix of H 2 (S 2 ; C2×2 ), and A+ any 1 hermitian matrix of H 2 +m ∩ L ∞ (S 2 ; C2×2 ). We define the operators (HA+ , D(HA+ )), (HA− , D(HA− )), where 1 " 1 ! ψ∓ ± ψ± = A . D (HA± ) := ∈ D(H M ); 2 2 ψ∓ ψ± For A− = A+ = 0, we obviously have HA∓ = HB M I T , HA± = HBC H I if ± M > 0. Furthermore, the chiral transform → γ 5 leads to the exchanges M → −M, HB M I T → HBC H I , HBC H I → HB M I T , HB A P S → HB A P S , HBA± → HBω.σ A±ω.σ . We now state the main theorem of this paper. Theorem III.4 (Main result). Given M ∈ R∗ , we consider the massive Dirac hamilto nian H M defined by (III.15), (III.16). When M 2 ≥ 12 , H M is essentially self-adjoint on ∞ 4 4 1 2 C0 (B) , and if M > 12 , then D (H M ) = H0 (B) , and for all ∈ D (H M ), we have the following elliptic estimate: H M L2 ≥ | M | − (III.32) ∇x L2 . 12 12 , HA+ , HA− , HB A P S , HBm A P S are self-adjoint on L2 , and HB A P S When M 2 < 12 = HBm A P S . The resolvent of any self-adjoint realization of H M , M ∈ R∗ , is compact on L2 , and so, the spectrum of these operators is discrete. We see that 12 is an important critical value. It plays exactly the same role that the bounds that Breitenlohner and Freedman have discovered for the scalar massive fields [7,8]. We recall that these authors have considered the Klein-Gordon equation 1 1 | g |− 2 ∂µ | g | 2 g µν ∂ν u − α 3 u = 0, for which α = 2 corresponds to the massless case. By a sharp analysis of the modes, they have established, among other results, that: (i) the natural energy is positive when α ≤ 9/4 , in particular for the light tachyons associated with 2 < α < 9/4; (ii) the dynamics is unique when α ≤ 5/4 ; (iii) there exists a lot of unitary dynamics when 5/4 < α < 9/4. For the sake of completeness we give in the one-page Appendix, a new and very simple proof of these results, based on a Hardy estimate and on the Kato-Rellich theorem. For the spin- 21 field with real mass, the most important conserved quantity is the L 2 -norm that is always positive, hence one bound will suffice to distinguish the different cases: it is 12 . We have to emphasize that this value was already presented in the discussion of the massive O Sp(1, 4) scalar multiplet in [7,8]. This multiplet consists√of a Dirac spinor with mass M, and two Klein-Gordon fields for which α = 2 ± M 3/ − 3M 2 /. We can easily check that α ≤ 9/4 for any M ∈ R, and α ≤ 5/4 iff M 2 ≥ /12. Therefore our own result is coherent with this particular model of Anti-de Sitter supersymmetry: the constraints for the uniqueness of the dynamics are simultaneously satisfied for the spin field and the scalar fields. The case α > 9/4 describes the heavy tachyons in C Ad S, and corresponds to the case of an imaginary mass for the Dirac field. This regime seems to be unphysical since the energy of a scalar tachyon is not positive, and the L 2 -norm of a spin- 21 field with an imaginary mass is not conserved. Of the mathematical point of view, it is doubtful that the global Cauchy problem with these parameters is well posed, and of the physical
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
139
point of view, we could suspect that the Ad S background is not stable with respect to the fluctuations of such fields. We do not address this situation in this paper. We now turn over to the Cauchy problem. Theorem III.5. Given 0 ∈ L2 , there exist solutions of (III.9), (III.11), (III.12), and all the solutions are equal for
3 π − 2 arctan . (III.33) (t, x) ∈ R × B, | t |< 2 When M 2 ≥ 12 , the Cauchy problem (III.9), (III.11), (III.12) has a unique solution. This solution satisfies (III.13).
We achieve this part with a result of equipartition of the energy. We know, [3], that the solutions ∈ C 0 (Rt ; L 2 (R3 ; C4 )) of the massive Dirac equation on the Minkowski space-time, satisfy ∗ γ 0 γ 5 (t, x)dx = 0. lim |t|→∞ R3
Since the spectrum of the possible hamiltonians for the massive fermions on C Ad S is discrete, we cannot expect such an asymptotic behaviour. Nevertheless, we establish the existence of a similar limit, in the weaker sense of Cesaro:
Theorem III.6. Let ∈ C 0 (Rt ; L2 ) be a solution of (III.9), given by (t)=e where H is a self-adjoint realization of H M , M ∈ R∗ . Then we have: 1 T lim ∗ γ 0 γ 5 (t, x)dxdt = 0. T →∞ T 0 B
it
3H
(0),
(III.34)
The proofs of these results are presented in Parts V and VI. They are made much easier by the use of the spherical coordinates. Operator S, defined by (III.8), that relates the spinors within the two systems of coordinates, is an isometry from π 4 L2 := L 2 [0, [x ×[0, π ]θ × [0, 2π [ϕ , sin θ d xdθ dϕ , (III.35) 2 onto L2 , and satisfies the intertwining relation H M S = SHm , where Hm is the differential operator ∂ i 1 1 0 3 ∂ 0 1 ∂ 0 2 + γ γ + + γ γ Hm := iγ γ ∂ x sin x ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ 3 m 0 γ , m=M . − cos x
(III.36)
(III.37)
The problem essentially consists in finding self-adjoint realizations of Hm in L2 . The difficulty comes from the blow-up of the gravitational interaction on the boundary. We see that H0 is just the Dirac operator on the 3-sphere S 3 ↔ [0, π ]x × [0, π ]θ × [0, 2π [ϕ , restricted to the upper hemisphere S+3 ↔ [0, π2 [x ×[0, π ]θ × [0, 2π [ϕ . The key result, Theorem V.1, deals with the asymptotic behaviour of ∈ D(Hm ) at the equatorial 2-sphere S 2 = ∂ S+3 , as x → π2 . The tool is a careful analysis based on the diagonalization of D S 2 by the spinoidal spherical harmonics.
140
A. Bachelot
IV. The Spinoidal Spherical Harmonics We start by introducing several tools based on the spinor representation of the rotation 2 2 group (see[14,26,35]). It is well known thatthere exists two Hilbert bases of L (S ), given by: T 1l (θ, ϕ) 2 ,n
, Tl
− 21 ,n
(l,n)∈I
! I := (l, n); l ∈ N + ! = (l, n); l ∈ N +
(θ, ϕ)
, (l,n)∈I
" 1 1 , n ∈ Z + , l− | n |∈ N 2 2 " 1 , n = −l, −l + 1, . . . , l , 2
(IV.1)
T±l 1 ,n (θ, ϕ) = e−inϕ P±l 1 ,n (cos θ ), 2
where P l
± 21 ,n
2
can be expressed in terms of generalized Jacobi functions:
P±l 1 ,n (X ) = Al±,n (1 − X )
±1−2n 4
2
(1 + X )
∓1−2n 4
d l−n l∓ 21 l± 21 (1 − X ) , (1 + X ) d X l−n
and the constant Al±,n
# $ $ l ∓ 1 !(l + n)! 2l + 1 (−1) i 2 % = 4π l ± 21 !(l − n)! 2l l ∓ 21 ! l∓ 12 n∓ 21
is chosen to normalize the basis functions (in comparison with the notations adopted in √ l are multiplied by (2l + 1)/4π ): the book [14], the functions Pm,n
2π 0
π 0
T±l 1 ,n (θ, ϕ)T l
± 12 ,n
2
(θ, ϕ) sin θ dθ dϕ = δl,l δn,n .
Therefore we can expand any function f ∈ L 2 (S 2 ) on both these bases bases f (θ, ϕ) = (l,n)∈I
u l±,n ( f )T±l 1 ,n (θ, ϕ), u l±,n ( f ) ∈ C, 2
and by the Plancherel formula: f 2L 2 =
| u l+,n ( f ) |2 = (l,n)∈I
(l,n)∈I
| u l−,n ( f ) |2 .
More generally, for s ∈ R, we introduce the Hilbert spaces W±s defined as the closure of the space ⎧ ⎫ ⎨ ⎬ W± u l±,n T±l 1 ,n ; u l±,n ∈ C (IV.2) f := ⎩ ⎭ 2 f inite
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
for the norm f 2W s := ±
(l,n)∈I
141
1 2s l l+ | u ±,n ( f ) |2 . 2
We note that the basis functions are not smooth on S 2 since T l
± 21 ,n
(θ, 2π ) = −T l
± 21 ,n
(θ, 0) # 0. Hence is not a classical Sobolev space on We state some properties of these spaces. Firstly it is easy to prove that for
s ≥ 0 =⇒ W±s = f ∈ L 2 S 2 ; f W±s < ∞ , W±s
S2.
and the topological dual of W±s can be isometrically identified with W±−s :
s ∈ R, W±s = W±−s . Secondly we show that W±s contains the test functions on ]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ . To see that, we recall the differential equations satisfied by the basis functions:
∂ 1 + ∂θ 2 tan θ
T±l 1 ,n 2
n 1 l T 1 −i l + =± T∓l 1 ,n , sin θ ± 2 ,n 2 2
(IV.3)
∂ l T 1 = −inT±l 1 ,n . ∂ϕ ± 2 ,n 2
(IV.4)
If f ∈ C0∞ (]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ ) then (∂θ + 21 cot θ ∓ sini θ ∂ϕ ) f ∈ C0∞ (]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ ) and for any integer N , the differential equation (IV.3) assures that 1 2N l ∂ 1 i ∂ 2N N l l+ + ∓ u ±,n ( f ) = (−1) u ±,n f ∈ l 2 (I ). 2 ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ We conclude that any test function belongs to W±s for any real s, and the series I u l±,n T l 1 ∈ W±s converges in the sense of the distributions on ]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ , in parti± 2 ,n
cular for all s < 0. We deduce that (∂θ + 21 cot θ ∓ sini θ ∂ϕ ), acting in the sense of the distributions, is an isometry from W±s onto W∓s−1 . But we have to be careful since the set of the test functions is not dense in general in W±s , s > 0: we cannot identify W −s with a subspace of distributions, and there can exist f ∈ W±−s \ {0} which is null in the 1
sense of the distributions on ]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ . For instance, since (sin θ )− 2 ∈ L 2 (S 2 ), we have √ 1 1 l T±l 1 ,n ∈ W±−1 , f ± W −1 = 2π, l+ u ∓,n √ f ± := ± 2 2 sin θ (l,n)∈I
but its restriction on the test functions is the null distribution because 1 i ∂ 1 ∂ + ∓ f ± |C ∞ (]0,π [θ ×]0,2π [ϕ ) = i √ 0 ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ sin θ = 0 in D (]0, π [×]0, 2π [).
142
A. Bachelot
Finally we investigate the links between W+s and W−s . We know that P 1l ,n = P−l 1 ,−n , 2
2
and Pl
± 21 ,n
1
= (−1)n∓ 2 P±l 1 ,n , 2
hence 1
u l±,n ( f ) = (−1)n∓ 2 u l∓,−n ( f ), and we have s ∈ R,
f ∈ W±s ⇐⇒ f ∈ W∓s , f W±s = f W∓s .
We warn that in general W+s = W−s . Indeed, given f ± ∈ W±1 , we have by (IV.3): ∂ 1 i ∂ 1 + ∓ f± = u l±,n ( f ± )T∓l 1 ,n ∈ L 2 (S 2 ). −i l + ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ 2 2 (l,n)∈I
We deduce that f ∈ W+1 ∩ W−1 =⇒ Then if we consider T 1
we see that
1 2 sin θ ∂ϕ T 1 , 1
1 2 1 1 2,2
(θ, ϕ) =
1 ∂ f ∈ L 2 (S 2 ). sin θ ∂ϕ
3 −i ϕ θ e 2 cos ∈ W+1 , 4π 2
∈ / L 2 (S 2 ), and we conclude that
2 2
W+1 = W−1 . Therefore it is convenient to introduce the isometry J on L 2 (S 2 ) defined by l J T+ 1 ,n = T−l 1 ,n . 2
Then we have
2
J ∗ T−l 1 ,n = T+l 1 ,n , 2
2
and J is an isometry from W+s onto W−s . We now return to the Dirac field. In: the same way, we can expand any spinor defined on S 2 , (θ, ϕ) ∈ L 2 (S 2 ; C4 ): ⎞ ⎛ l u 1,n T l 1 (θ, ϕ) − 2 ,n ⎟ ⎜ l ⎜ u 2,n T l 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ + 2 ,n
(θ, ϕ) = ⎟ , u lj,n ∈ C. ⎜ l ⎜ u 3,n T l 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ − 2 ,n (l,n)∈I ⎝ ⎠ u l4,n T l 1 (θ, ϕ) + 2 ,n
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
143
The main interest of this expansion is the following: if we consider the angular part of the hamiltonian Hm , ∂ 1 i ∂ 0 2 + + γ 0γ 3 , D := iγ γ ∂θ 2 tan θ sin θ ∂ϕ an elementary but tedious computation shows that: ⎛ l ⎞ u 4,n T l 1 (θ, ϕ) − 2 ,n ⎜ u l T l (θ, ϕ) ⎟ ⎟ 3,n 1 ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ + 21 ,n l+ D (θ, ϕ) = ⎜ l ⎟. 2 ⎜ u 2,n T−l 1 ,n (θ, ϕ) ⎟ (l,n)∈I ⎝ ⎠ 2 u l1,n T l 1 (θ, ϕ)
(IV.5)
+ 2 ,n
Hence it is natural to introduce the Hilbert spaces W s := W−s × W+s × W−s × W+s endowed with the norm: 4
W s := 2
j=1 (l,n)∈I
1 2s l 2 l+ | u j,n | . 2
(IV.6)
W s is also the closure for this norm, of the subspace − + + W f := W − f × Wf × Wf × Wf .
As a differential operator, D acts from W s to W s−1 and D endowed
with the domain W 1 is self-adjoint on W 0 . We see that the spectrum of (D, W 1 ) is ± l + 21 , l ∈ N , , its positive subspace L 2+ S 2 ; C4 is spanned by the eigenvectors T l 1 , 0, 0, T l 1 − 2 ,n + 2 ,n 0, T l 1 , T l 1 , 0 , (l, n) ∈ I , and the negative subspace L 2− S 2 ; C4 is spanned + 2 ,n − 2 ,n l l l l by the eigenvectors T 1 , 0, 0, −T 1 , 0, T 1 , −T 1 , 0 , (l, n) ∈ I . We can − 2 ,n
+ 2 ,n
+ 2 ,n
characterize these spaces by using the operator J :
L 2± S 2 ; C4
− 2 ,n
⎧⎛ ⎫ ⎞ ψ ⎪ ⎨ ⎬
⎪ ⎜ χ ⎟ = ⎝ . , ψ, χ ∈ L 2 S 2 ⎠ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ±J∗χ ⎭ ±J ψ
We easily obtain the orthogonal projectors K± on L 2± S 2 ; C4 : ⎛
1 1⎜ 0 K± = ⎝ 0 2 ±J ∗
0 0 1 ±J ∗ ±J 1 0 0
⎞ ±J 0 ⎟ . 0 ⎠ 1
(IV.7)
144
A. Bachelot
K± can be extended into bounded operators on W s , s ∈ R. These operators are used to define the global boundary conditions of M.F. Atiyah, V. K. Patodi, and I. M. Singer (see e.g. [6]): K± = 0,
(IV.8)
and the boundary condition introduced by O. Hijazi, S. Montiel, A. Roldan [20],
K+ I d + γ 1 = 0. W s is also invariant by the operator 5
Bα := γ 1 + ieiαγ , α ∈ R, involved in the local MIT-bag boundary condition: B0 = 0, and the chiral condition: Bπ = 0. If we consider the operator := γ 0 γ 2 D as a positive, unbounded, selfadjoint operator on W 0 with domain W 1 , then for 0 ≤ s ≤ 1, W s is the domain of s , that is to say, these spaces are spaces of interpolation (see e.g. [24]): W s = W 1, W 0 , 0 ≤ s ≤ 1. 1−s
The link between this space and the usual Sobolev spaces on S 2 is given by the following: Proposition IV.1. For any s ∈ R, the linear map
(θ, ϕ) −→ (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = S(θ, ϕ) (θ, ϕ), (x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ) ∈ S 2 , 4 defined from W f to L 2 S 2 , where S is given by (III.6) and x j , θ , ϕ are related to 4 (III.7), can be extended into a bounded isomorphism from W s onto H s (S 2 ) . Proof of Proposition IV.1. A tedious but elementary calculation shows that: S11 S12 , S(θ, ϕ) = S21 S22 where
ϕ ⎞ ⎛
ϕ θ θ θ θ −i iϕ i −i ϕ 1 ⎝ (1 + i) e 2 cos 2 + e 2 sin 2 (1 + i) e 2 cos 2 − e 2 sin 2 ⎠ S11 = S22 = , ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ 2 (1 − i) −e−i 2 cos θ + ei 2 sin θ (1 − i) ei 2 cos θ + e−i 2 sin θ 2 2 2 2 (IV.9) S12 = S21 =
00 . 00
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
145
Following [36], p.337, formula (3) with n = 0, we have √ √ θ l+ 12 l Pm,0 l + 1P 1 1 (cos θ ) = l − m + 1 cos (cos θ ) m− 2 ,− 2 2 √ θ l Pm−1,0 (cos θ ), + l + m sin 2 then since l l Pm,n = (−1)m+n Pn,m ,
we get for l ∈ N, m ∈ Z, −l ≤ m ≤ l + 1: 3 θ l+ 21 −i ϕ2 m−1 l − m + 1 x + 1 l T 1 Ym (θ, ϕ) cos e 1 (θ, ϕ) = (−1) − 2 ,m− 2 2 l +1 2 l + m x1 − i x2 l Ym−1 (θ, ϕ), +(−1)m−1 l +1 2
e
i ϕ2
1 2 θ l+ 12 m−1 l − m + 1 x + i x T 1 Yml (θ, ϕ) sin 1 (θ, ϕ) = (−1) − 2 ,m− 2 2 l +1 2 3 m−1 l + m 1 − x l Ym−1 (θ, ϕ). +(−1) l +1 2
In the same way, with [36], p.337, formula (4) with n = 0, we have √ √ θ l+ 12 l Pm,0 l + 1P 1 1 (cos θ ) = − l − m + 1 sin (cos θ ) m− 2 , 2 2 √ θ l Pm−1,0 (cos θ ), + l + m cos 2 then we get for l ∈ N, m ∈ Z, −l + 1 ≤ m ≤ l: 1 2 θ l+ 21 i ϕ2 m+1 l − m + 1 x + i x T1 Yml (θ, ϕ) e cos 1 (θ, ϕ) = (−1) 2 l +1 2 2 ,m− 2 3 m l +m x +1 l Ym−1 (θ, ϕ), +(−1) l +1 2
e
−i ϕ2
3 θ l+ 21 m+1 l − m + 1 1 − x T1 Yml (θ, ϕ) sin 1 (θ, ϕ) = (−1) 2 l +1 2 2 ,m− 2 1 2 m l + m x − ix l Ym−1 +(−1) (θ, ϕ). l +1 2
Since f → x j f is bounded on H s (S 2 ) and f belongs to H s (S 2 ) iff ∞
l
αl,m Yml ,
f = l=0 m=−l
l 2s | αl,m |2 < ∞, l,m
146
A. Bachelot
we conclude that the linear map → S(θ, ϕ) = is bounded from W f endowed 4 with the norm of W s to H s (S 2 ) , hence it can be extended into a continuous linear 4 map S : → from W s to H s (S 2 ) . Then S∗ is a bounded linear map from −s 2 4 4 H (S ) to W −s for any s ∈ R. Since S∗ = S ∗ (θ, ϕ) for ∈ C0∞ (S 2 ) , and S ∗ (θ, ϕ) = S −1 (θ, ϕ), we conclude that SS∗ = I d H s , S∗ S = I dW s . V. Asymptotic Behaviour at the Boundary In this part we investigate the properties of the spinors that belong to the natural domain of the hamiltonian, especially the asymptotic behaviours near the boundary. We begin with its form in spherical coordinates, Hm given by (III.37), and D (Hm ) := ∈ L2 ; Hm ∈ L2 . (V.1) Theorem V.1. For any ∈ D (Hm ) we have
π 1
∈ C 0 [0, [x ; W 2 , 2 (x, .)
1
W2
2
0
When
1 2
√ x , x → 0,
(V.3)
dx ≤ Hm 2L2 . sin x
(V.4)
=O
and when 0 < m we have π (x, .) 2W 1
(V.2)
< m, we have (x, .) L 2 (S 2 ) = O
When m = 21 , we have: (x, .) L 2 (S 2 ) = O
x−
π π −x , x → . 2 2
π π π ln −x , x → . 2 2 2 1
1
(V.5)
(V.6)
When 0 < m < 21 , there exists ψ− ∈ W−2 , χ− ∈ W+2 , ψ+ , χ+ ∈ L 2 (S 2 ), and φ ∈ C 0 [0, π2 ]x ; L 2 (S 2 ; C4 ) satisfying ⎛ ⎞ ψ− (θ, ϕ) −m
π ⎜ χ− (θ, ϕ) ⎟ −x
(x, θ, ϕ) = ⎝ −iψ (θ, ϕ) ⎠ − 2 iχ− (θ, ϕ) ⎛ ⎞ ψ+ (θ, ϕ) m
π ⎜ χ (θ, ϕ) ⎟ −x ⎝ + + φ(x, θ, ϕ), (V.7) + iψ+ (θ, ϕ) ⎠ 2 −iχ+ (θ, ϕ)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
147
φ(x, .) L 2 (S 2 ) = o 1
1
+m
π π −x , x → . 2 2 1
+m
Conversely, for any ψ− ∈ W−2 , χ− ∈ W+2 , ψ+ ∈ W−2
∈ D(Hm ) satisfying (V.7) and (V.8). When m = 0, then
π 1
∈ C 0 [0, ]x ; W − 2 . 2
−m
(V.8) 1
, χ+ ∈ W+2
−m
there exists
(V.9)
Remark V.2. Equation (V.4) shows that when m > 0, Hm = 0 implies = 0. On the contrary, when m = 0, the left member of (V.4) can be infinite even if H0 = 0. 1 Furthermore the space W − 2 is optimal for the traces on x = π2 : there exists ∈ D(H0 ) / ∪s>− 1 W s . As an example, we consider a sequence Cl,n (l,n)∈I ⊂ C such that ( π2 ) ∈ 2 such that 2 2 1 −1 1 s Cl,n < ∞, −1 < s ⇒ Cl,n = ∞, l+ l+ 2 2 (l,n)∈I
(l,n)∈I
we can take for instance Cl,n =
√ 1 , l log(l+1)
and we put ⎛
(x, θ, ϕ) =
Cl,n tan
x l+ 1
(l,n)∈I
2
(θ, ϕ)
⎞
1 ⎜ − 2 l,n ⎟ ⎜ −i T 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ ,n ⎜ ⎟. 2
⎝
2
Tl
0 0
⎠
Then we easily check that
π 2
∈ L2 , H0 = 0, 0 < s ⇒ 1 π
( , .) ∈ W − 2 \ ∪s>− 1 W s . 2 2
0
(x, .) 2W s d x = ∞,
Remark V.3. For 0 < m < 21 , the leading terms of satisfy the MIT-bag or the Chiral boundary condition since: ⎛ ⎞ ψ+ m
π ⎜ χ ⎟ − x ⎝ + ⎠ + B0 φ(x), B0 (x) = 2i iψ+ 2 −iχ+ ⎛ ⎞ ψ− −m
π ⎜ χ− ⎟ Bπ (x) = −2i −x ⎝ −iψ ⎠ + Bπ φ(x). − 2 iχ−
148
A. Bachelot
Proof of Theorem V.1. We expand any spinor (x, θ, ϕ) in the previous way: ⎞ ⎛ l u 1,n (x)T l 1 (θ, ϕ) − 2 ,n ⎟ ⎜ l ⎜ u 2,n (x)T l 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ + 2 ,n
(x, θ, ϕ) = ⎟, ⎜ l ⎜ u 3,n (x)T l 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ − 2 ,n (l,n)∈I ⎝ ⎠ u l4,n (x)T l 1 (θ, ϕ) + 2 ,n
and we have: 4
2L2 =
j=1 (l,n)∈I
Furthermore, for ∈ D(Hm ), (IV.5) gives: ⎛ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ Hm (x, θ, ϕ) = ⎜ ⎜ (l,n)∈I ⎝
u lj,n 2L 2 (0, π ) . 2
l (x)T l f 1,n
(θ, ϕ)
⎞
− 12 ,n ⎟ l f 2,n (x)T l 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ ⎟ + 2 ,n ⎟, l (x)T l f 3,n 1 (θ, ϕ) ⎟ − 2 ,n ⎠ l (x)T l (θ, ϕ) f 4,n + 12 ,n
with
⎧
l+ 21 ⎪ m l l l ⎪ ⎪ i u 3,n + sin x u l4,n − cos ⎪ x u 1,n = f 1,n , ⎪
⎪ ⎪
⎪ l+ 21 ⎪ m l l ⎨ −i u l + u l − cos 4,n x u 2,n = f 2,n ,
sin x 3,n , l+ 12 ⎪ l
⎪ m l l l ⎪ u + cos x u 3,n = f 3,n , ⎪ ⎪ i u 1,n + sin
x 2,n ⎪ ⎪ 1
⎪
l+ ⎪ 2 ⎩ −i u l m l l l 2,n + sin x u 1,n + cos x u 4,n = f 4,n ,
and 4
Hm L2 = 2
j=1 (l,n)∈I
l f j,n 2L 2 (0, π ) . 2
For 1 ≤ h, k ≤ 4, we put l,± l l l l u l,± hk,n = u h,n ± iu k,n , f hk,n = f h,n ± i f k,n .
We have
l + 1 im l,∓ l,∓ 2 l,± u l,± u 12,n = u − i f 34,n , 12,n ∓ sin x cos x 34,n
u l,± 34,n
∓
l + 21 l,± im l,∓ l,∓ u u =− − i f 12,n . sin x 34,n cos x 12,n
(V.10)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
149
Given w+l ∈ L 2 (0, π2 ), any solution v+l of l + 21 l d l π v+ − v = w+l , 0 < x < , dx sin x + 2 1 (]0, π ]) ⊂ C 0 (]0, π ]) and v l can be written: belongs to Hloc + 2 2
v+l (x)
=
x l+ 1 π2 2 tan − 2 2 x
π v+l ( )
tan tan
x l+ 21 2y
w+l (y)dy.
(V.11)
2
On the one hand, by integrating we get: π | v+l ( ) |2 ≤ C(l + 1)( v+l 2L 2 + w+l 2L 2 ). 2 On the other hand, we easily show that for 0 < x ≤
(V.12)
π 2
x 2l
y −2l−1 1 x −2l 1 − tan , tan tan dy ≤ 2 2l 2 2
π 2
x
therefore since tan(x/2) ≤ x on [0, π2 ], we obtain that:
x l+ 1 2
x 2l l 2 l π l 2 tan 2l v+ (x) − v+ , ≤| x | w+ L 2 (x, π2 ) 1 − tan 2 2 2 and we conclude that π v+l ( ) = 0 =⇒ l | v+l (x) |2 ≤| x | w+l 2L 2 . 2
(V.13)
l of Now the solutions v−
l + 21 l π d l l v− + v = w− ∈ L 2 (0, ), dx sin x − 2
(V.14)
have the form
x −l− 1 x 2 l v− (x) = C tan + 2 0
tan tan
y l+ 21 2x
l w− (y)dy.
(V.15)
2
Then, when v− ∈ L 2 (0, π2 ) and l ≥ 0, we have C = 0. Since for 0 ≤ x ≤ x 2l+1 y 1 x 2l+2 tan tan dy ≤ , 2 l +1 2 0
π 2
we have
we obtain that the L 2 solutions of (V.14) satisfy: l l (x) |2 ≤| x | w− 2L 2 . (l + 1) | v−
For any χ ∈ C0∞ ([0, π2 [), we apply the previous estimates to l l = χ u l,± v± 12(34),n , w± = +(−)
im l,∓ χ u l,∓ − iχ f 34(12),n − χ u l,± 12(34),n . cos x 34(12),n
(V.16)
150
A. Bachelot
From (V.13) and (V.16), we deduce 4
|
l
2 χ (x)u l,± hk,n (x) | ≤
C(χ ) | x |
hk=12,34
l u lj,n 2L 2 + f j,n 2L 2 ,
(V.17)
j=1
where C(χ ) > 0 depends only on χ . We get (V.2) and (V.3) that are consequences of (V.17). When m = 0, we can take l,∓ l l v± = u l,± 12(34),n , w± = −i f 34(12),n ,
and we get from (V.12) and (V.16) that 4
(l + 1)−1
2 | u l,± hk,n (x) | ≤ C | x |
l u lj,n 2L 2 + f j,n 2L 2 .
hk=12,34
(V.18)
j=1
This estimate yields (V.9). Now we have
l + 21 l,± m l,± l,∓ u l,± u 13,n = ± f 13,n u +i , 13,n ∓ cos x sin x 24,n
u l,± 24,n
±
l + 21 l,± m l,± l,∓ u 24,n = ∓ f 24,n u −i . cos x sin x 13,n
Given m ≥ 0, w+l ∈ L 2 (0, π2 ), any solution v+l of d l m l π v+ + v+ = w+l , 0 < x < , dx cos x 2 1 ([0, π [) ⊂ C 0 ([0, π [) and when belongs to Hloc 2 2
v+l (0) = 0, v+l can be written: v+l (x)
= 0
x
tan
π
4 tan π4
− −
m
x 2 y 2
w+l (y)dy.
(V.19)
Therefore the Cauchy-Schwarz estimate yields 1 < m =⇒| v+l (x) |≤ C w+l L 2 2 1 m = =⇒| v+l (x) |≤ C w+l L 2 2 0≤m<
π − x, 2
π
π − x ln −x , 2 2
m
π 1 =⇒| v+l (x) |≤ C w+l L 2 −x . 2 2
(V.20)
(V.21)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
151
We make this last estimate precise for 0 ≤ m < 21 : m π2 π
y −m l l −m π −x − tan w+ (y)dy v+ (x) − 2 2 4 2 0
π m+2 π ≤ C w+l L 2 + w+l L 2 (x, π ) −x −x , 2 2 2
(V.22)
in particular we have 0 < m =⇒ limπ v+l (x) = 0.
(V.23)
x→ 2
l of On the other hand the solutions v−
d l m l π l v − v = w− , 0<x< , d x − cos x − 2 have the form l v− (x)
π π 2 x −m − = Cl tan − 4 2 x
tan
π
4 tan π4
− −
y 2 x 2
m l w− (y)dy,
(V.24)
thus, −m
l ≤ wl L 2 (x, π ) π − x, v (x) − Cl tan π − x − − 2 4 2 2
(V.25)
and l v− ∈ L 2 (0,
0≤m<
1 π ), ≤ m =⇒ Cl = 0, 2 2
1 l (0) + =⇒ Cl = v− 2
(V.26)
π y m l tan w− (y)dy. − 4 2
π 2
0
We pick χ ∈ C0∞ (]0, π2 ] such that χ ( π2 ) = 1, and we apply the previous estimates to l,∓(±)
l,∓(±)
l,±(∓)
l l v± = χ u 13(24),n , w± = w13(24),n := ∓(±)χ f 13(24),n +(−)i
l + 21 l,∓(±) l,∓(±) χu −χ u 13(24),n . sin x 24(13),n
From (V.23) we deduce that when m > 0: lim u l1,n (x) − iu l3,n (x) = limπ u l2,n (x) + iu l4,n (x) = 0,
x→ π2
x→ 2
hence
limπ u l1,n (x)u l2,n (x) + (u l3,n (x)u l4,n (x) = 0.
x→ 2
(V.27)
152
A. Bachelot
Now multiplying (V.10) by u lj,n and taking the real part we get: l + 1 4 d l l 2 u 1,n u 2,n + (u l3,n u l4,n + | u lj,n |2 dx sin x 1
l l l l l l l = f 1,n u 4,n + f 2,n u 3,n + f 3,n u 2,n + f 4,n u l1,n , and thanks to (V.17) and (V.27) we obtain π 1 2 4 2 l+2 | u lj,n (x) |2 d x ≤ sin x 0 j=1
4 l f j,n 2L 2 , j=1
that proves (V.4). We also see that: 4
l,∓(±) w13(24),n
L 2 ≤ C(χ )
l f j,n L 2 .
(V.28)
j=1
Therefore when m ≥ 21 , (V.5) and (V.6) follow from (V.20), (V.21), (V.25) and (V.26). On the other hand, when 0 < m < 21 , (V.22), (V.25) and (V.28) assure there exists l,∓(± ϕ13(24),n ∈ C 0 ([0, π2 ]) such that: l,−(+)
u 13(24),n (x) =
π 2
−x
m
π 2
=
π 2
−x
−m
π 2
limx
x→ 2
π 4
−
y −m l,−(+) w13(24),n (y)dy 2
π − x, 2
tan
0
l,+(−) +ϕ13(24),n (x)
2 tan
0
l,−(+) + ϕ13(24),n (x)
u l,+(−) 13(24),n (x)
π 2
m y l,+(−) tan − w13(24),n (y)dy 4 2 − x2
−x π 4
π
π − x, 2 2 l,∓(±) ϕ13(24),n (x) = 0.
(l,n)∈I
We deduce that there exists ψ± , χ± ∈ L 2 (S 2 ) such that can be expressed according to (V.7), (V.8). It remains to prove the regularity of ψ− and χ− . We consider
cos x m
1 + iγ 1 . (x, θ, ϕ) := 1 + sin x Equations (V.7), (V.8) assure that ⎛
⎞ ψ− π ⎜ χ ⎟ (x, .) −→ ⎝ − ⎠ in W 0 as x → . −iψ− 2 iχ−
(V.29)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
153
We calculate
cos x m
∂ 1 1 0 Hm − (x, .) = D . 1 + iγ γ ∂x 1 + sin x sin x Since ∈ L 2 [0, π2 [x ; W 1 by (V.4), we deduce that
π ∈ L 2 [1, [x ; W 1 , 2
π ∂ ∈ L 2 [1, [x ; W 0 . ∂x 2 The theorem of the intermediate derivative ([24], p. 23) shows that π 0 1 0 ∈ C [1, ]x ; W , W 1 . 2 2 1 1 1 Recalling that W 1 , W 0 1 = W 2 , we conclude by (V.29) that ψ− ∈ W−2 , χ− ∈ W+2 . 2
1
1
∓m
∓m
Finally we consider ψ± ∈ W−2 , χ± ∈ W+2 , and we want to construct
∈ D(Hm ) satisfying (V.7) and (V.8). We choose f ∈ C0∞ ([0, 1[) such that f (0) = 1, and we put
(x) =
π 2
−x
−m
⎛
⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ψ− ψ+ m
π ⎜ χ− ⎟ ⎜ χ ⎟ − x ⎝ + ⎠ + φ(x), ⎝ −iψ ⎠ + iψ+ − 2 iχ− −iχ+
where ⎛ φ(x) =
π 2
−x
−m (l,n)∈I
π − [f l 2
u l−,n (ψ− )T l
− 21 ,n ⎜ l l ⎜ ⎜ u +,n (χ− )T+ 21 ,n x − 1] ⎜ ⎜ −iu l−,n (ψ− )T l 1 − 2 ,n ⎝ iu l+,n (χ− )T l 1 + 2 ,n
⎛
+
π 2
−x
m (l,n)∈I
π − [f l 2
u l−,n (ψ+ )T l
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
− 21 ,n ⎜ l ⎜ u +,n (χ+ )T l 1 ⎜ + 2 ,n x − 1] ⎜ l ⎜ iu −,n (ψ+ )T l 1 − 2 ,n ⎝ −iu l+,n (χ+ )T l 1 + 2 ,n
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟. ⎟ ⎠
We use the fact that 1∓2m π 2 π 1±2m l ( π2 −x ) 2
− x − 1 ≤ −x | f (t) | 1∓2m dt l 1±2m , f l 2 2 0
154
A. Bachelot
to get φ(x, .) 2L 2 (S 2 ) ≤ 2
π 2
−x
π l ( 2 −x )
(l,n)∈I
1−2m
| f (t) |
2 1−2m
dt
0
l 1+2m | u l−,n (ψ− ) |2 + | u l+,n (χ− ) |2 1+2m π
π l ( 2 −x ) 2
1+2m −x | f (t) | dt +2 2 0 (l,n)∈I
l 1−2m | u l−,n (ψ+ ) |2 + | u l+,n (χ+ ) |2 . The dominated convergence theorem assures that φ satisfies (V.8), and so ∈ L2 . To achieve the proof, we have to show that Hm ∈ L2 . We calculate: ⎛ π −m−1 2 −x 1− −x Hm (x) = m 2 cos x
π
(l,n)∈I
π f l 2 ⎛
−
π 2
−x
−m (l,n)∈I
π −x l f l 2
π 2
−x
−m
1 sin x
(l,n)∈I
− 21 ,n ⎜ l ⎜ u +,n (χ− )T l 1 ⎜ + 2 ,n ⎜ ⎜ −iu l−,n (ψ− )T l 1 − 2 ,n ⎝ iu l+,n (χ− )T l 1 + 2 ,n
π −x l+ f l 2
π 2
−x
m (l,n)∈I
⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
iu l+,n (χ− )T l
⎞
− 21 ,n l l ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 1 ⎜−iu −,n (ψ− )T+ 21 ,n⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ 2 ⎜ u l+,n (χ− )T−l 1 ,n ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ 2 u l−,n (ψ− )T l 1 + 2 ,n
u l−,n (ψ+ )T l
− 21 ,n
⎞
⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ u l+,n (χ+ )T l 1
π ⎜ + 2 ,n ⎟ −x ⎜ l f l ⎟ ⎜iu −,n (ψ+ )T l 1 ⎟ 2 − 2 ,n ⎠ (l,n)∈I ⎝ −iu l+,n (χ+ )T l 1 + 2 ,n ⎞ ⎛ l l u −,n (ψ+ )T 1 − 2 ,n ⎟ ⎜ l ⎟
π ⎜ u +,n (χ+ )T l 1 ⎟ ⎜ + ,n 2 f l −x l⎜ l ⎟ l ⎜ iu −,n (ψ+ )T 1 ⎟ 2 − 2 ,n ⎠ ⎝ −iu l+,n (χ+ )T l 1
π m−1 −x −m −x 1− 2 2 cos x
−
⎞
u l−,n (ψ− )T l
⎛
π
⎞
− 21 ,n ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ u l+,n (χ− )T l 1 ⎟ ⎜ + 2 ,n ⎟ −x ⎜ ⎟ ⎜−iu l−,n (ψ− )T l 1 ⎟ − 2 ,n⎠ ⎝ iu l+,n (χ− )T l 1 + 2 ,n
⎛
+
u l−,n (ψ− )T l
+ 2 ,n
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
155
⎛ +
π 2
−x
m
1 sin x
(l,n)∈I
⎜ 1 ⎜
π ⎜ −x l+ f l ⎜ 2 2 ⎜ ⎝
−iu l+,n (χ+ )T l
− 21 ,n l iu −,n (ψ+ )T l 1 + 2 ,n u l+,n (χ+ )T l 1 − 2 ,n u l−,n (ψ+ )T l 1 + 2 ,n
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟. ⎟ ⎠
In this sum, the leading terms have the form ±
(x, θ, ϕ) =
π 2
−x
±m (l,n)∈I
1
π −x l+ g ± (θ, ϕ), h l 2 2 l,n
where h ∈ C0∞ ([0, 1[) and
(l,n)∈I
1 1∓2m ± 2 ± l+ gl,n L 2 (S 2 ) < ∞, gl,n (ω)gl± ,n (ω)dω = δl,l δn,n . 2 S2
Taking account of the support of h, we evaluate
±
2L 2 (]0,π [×S 2 )
π
±2m 2 1 2 π ± 2 l+ −x = gl,n L 2 (S 2 ) π 1 2 2 2−l (l,n)∈I 2 h l 1 − x d x 2 1 1 1∓2m ± 2 ≤ l+ t ±2m | h(t) |2 dt gl,n L 2 (S 2 ) < ∞. 2 0 (l,n)∈I
Proof of Theorem III.2. Since the map S given by (III.8) satisfies (III.36), (III.22) and (III.23) follow from Proposition IV.1 and (V.2), and (V.4). Moreover, since π2 − x ∼ 1 2 (1 − ), (V.5) and (V.6) imply (III.24) and (III.25). Now, if we put ⎛
⎞ ψ± (θ, ϕ) ⎜ χ (θ, ϕ) ⎟ ± (ω) = S(θ, ϕ) ⎝ ± , ±iψ± (θ, ϕ) ⎠ ∓iχ± (θ, ϕ) (III.26) and (III.27) are consequences respectively of (V.7), and: ⎛ ⎞ ψ± (θ, ϕ)
⎜ χ (θ, ϕ) ⎟ = 0. γ˜ 1 ∓ i I d ± (ω) = S(θ, ϕ) γ 1 ∓ i I d ⎝ ± ±iψ± (θ, ϕ) ⎠ ∓iχ± (θ, ϕ)
156
A. Bachelot
Finally, for any − ∈
4 1 4 1 H 2 +m (S 2 ) , + ∈ H 2 −m (S 2 ) we define ± (θ, ϕ)
1
:= S ∗ (θ, ϕ)(ω) ∈ W 2 ∓m . When ± satisfy (III.27), then ± have the form ⎛ ⎞ ψ± (θ, ϕ) 1 1 +m +m ⎜ χ (θ, ϕ) ⎟
± (θ, ϕ) = ⎝ ± , ψ− ∈ W−2 , χ− ∈ W+2 , ⎠ ±iψ± (θ, ϕ) ∓iχ± (θ, ϕ) 1
ψ+ ∈ W−2
−m
1
, χ+ ∈ W+2
−m
,
and there exists ∈ D(Hm ) satisfying (V.7) and (V.8). We conclude that := S , belongs to D(H M ) and satisfies (III.26) and (III.28). At last, Remark III.3 directly follows from (V.9), Proposition IV.1 and Remark V.2. We end this part by an important result of compactness: Proposition V.4. Let K be the set K := ∈ D(Hm ), 2L2 + 2L2 ≤ 1 .
(V.30)
Then, when m > 0, K is a compact of L2 . Proof of Proposition V.4. We consider a sequence ( ν )ν∈N in K . We write ⎛
l u l,ν 1,n T
− 21 ,n
⎞
⎜ ⎟ ⎜ u l,ν T l ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 1 2,n + ,n ν ⎜ ⎟, 2
= ⎜ u l,ν T l ⎟ 1 ⎜ 3,n (l,n)∈I ⎝ − 2 ,n ⎟ ⎠ l u l,ν 4,n T 1 + 2 ,n
⎛
l,ν l f 1,n T
⎞
− 21 ,n
⎜ ⎟ ⎜ f l,ν T l ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 1 2,n + ,n ν ⎜ ⎟, 2 Hm = ⎜ f l,ν T l ⎟ 1 ⎜ 3,n (l,n)∈I ⎝ − 2 ,n ⎟ ⎠ l,ν l f 4,n T 1 + 2 ,n
and we have: 4 j=1 (l,n)∈I
l,ν 2 2 u l,ν j,n L 2 (0, π ) + f j,n L 2 (0, π ) ≤ 1. 2
2
The Banach-Alaoglu theorem assures that there exists ∈ K and a sub-sequence denoted ( ν )ν∈N again, such that ⎛ l ⎞ u 1,n T l 1 ⎜ l −l 2 ,n ⎟ ⎜ u 2,n T 1 ⎟ ⎜ + 2 ,n ⎟
ν = ⎜ l ⎟, ⎜ u 3,n T l 1 ⎟ − 2 ,n ⎠ (l,n)∈I ⎝ u l4,n T l 1 + 2 ,n ⎛ l l ⎞ f 1,n T 1 − 2 ,n ⎜ l l ⎟ ⎜ f 2,n T 1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ + ,n Hm ν Hm = ⎜ l l 2 ⎟ in L2 − ∗, ν → ∞. ⎜ f 3,n T 1 ⎟ − 2 ,n ⎠ (l,n)∈I ⎝ l Tl f 4,n 1 + 2 ,n
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
157
l,ν π l l 2 Since for any (l, n) ∈ I , j = 1, . . . 4, u l,ν j,n u j,n , f j,n f j,n , in L (0, 2 ) − ∗ as ν → ∞, we deduce from (V.11), (V.15), (V.19) and (V.24), that π l,ν l ∀x ∈ [0, ], u l,ν j,n (x) → u j,n (x), sup supπ | u j,n (x) |< ∞. 2 ν x∈[0, ] 2
Therefore l π u l,ν j,n − u j,n L 2 (0, ] → 0, ν → ∞.
(V.31)
2
Moreove, since m > 0, (V.4) implies: sup ν
For l ∈ N +
1 2
(l,n)∈I
1 2 l+ 2
4 l 2 u l,ν j,n − u j,n L 2 (0, π ) < ∞.
(V.32)
2
j=1
we put 4
ε
l,ν
l l 2 u l,ν j,n − u j,n L 2 (0, π ) .
:=
2
j=1 n=−l
Equations (V.31) and (V.32) show that 1 ∀l ∈ N + , εl,ν → 0, ν → ∞, A := sup 2 ν
1 2 l,ν l+ ε < ∞. 2 1
l∈N+ 2
−2 / Since εl,ν ≤ A l + 21 , the dominated convergence theorem implies that l εl,ν → 0, as ν → ∞, that is to say, ν strongly tends to in L2 . VI. Self-Adjoint Extensions When 0 < m < 21 , we define the linear map
⎞ ψ− 1 ⎜χ ⎟ : ∈ D(Hm ) −→ ( ) = ⎝ − ⎠ ∈ W 2 , ψ+ χ+ ⎛
where ψ± and χ± are given by (V.7), and we put ( ) = 0 when Theorem V.1 assures that
1 2
≤ m. We note that
1 1 1 1 1 +m +m −m −m ∀m ∈]0, [, W−2 × W+2 × W−2 × W+2 ⊂ (D(Hm )) . 2
We introduce the matrix
⎛
0 ⎜0 0 5 Q := −γ γ = ⎝ 1 0 The basic tool is a nice Green formula:
0 0 0 1
−1 0 0 0
⎞ 0 −1 ⎟ . 0 ⎠ 0
(VI.1)
158
A. Bachelot
˜ ∈ D(Hm ) we have Lemma VI.1. Given 0 < m, for any , ˜ >L2 = 2 < ( ), Q( ) ˜ >L2 − < , Hm ˜ >W 0 . < Hm ,
(VI.2)
Proof of Lemma VI.1. Equation (V.4) assures that any ∈ D(H m ) belongs to L 2 [0, π2 ]x ; W 1 , hence for any ε > 0, ∈ H 1 ]ε, π2 − ε[x ; W 0 . Since (D, W 1 ) is selfadjoint on W 0 , we evaluate ˜ >L2 = lim < iγ 0 γ 1 ( ˜ >L2 − < , Hm < Hm , ε→0
˜
(
π ˜ − ε) >W 0 − < iγ 0 γ 1 (ε), (ε) >W 0 , 2
π − ε), 2
and taking account of (V.3), (V.5), (V.6), (V.7) and (V.8) we get (VI.2).
We now investigate the self-adjoint extensions (H, D(H)) of Hm , with C0∞ (]0, π2 [x ×]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ ; C4 ) ⊂ D(H). The adjoint H∗ is just Hm with domain D(H∗ ) ⊂ D(Hm ), and we have: ˜ ∈ D(H∗ ), < ( ), Q( ) ˜ >W 0 = 0. ∀ ∈ D(H), ∀ When m ≥
1 2
we immediately obtain a first result of self-adjointness of Hm on L2 :
Proposition VI.2. When 21 ≤ m, Hm is essentially self-adjoint on C0∞ ]0, π2 [x×]0, π [θ×] 4 0, 2π [ϕ . Proof of Proposition VI.2. Let H be the operator defined by the differential operator Hm endowed with the domain D(H) = C0∞ (]0, π2 [x ×]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ ; C4 ). On the one hand, H is obviously symmetric, and on the other hand, its adjoint H∗ is just Hm with domain D(Hm ). Let any ± be in D(Hm ) such that H∗ ± ± i ± = 0, satisfies ∓2i 2L2 =< Hm ± , ± >L2 − < ± , Hm ± >L2 , and we conclude by (VI.2) that ± = 0.
When 0 < m < 21 , the situation is much more interesting: there exists a lot of self-adjoint realizations of Hm . First, we introduce the operators H M I T and HC H I respectively associated with the MIT-bag and the Chiral boundary conditions. They are defined as Hm endowed with the domains D (H M I T ) " ! π π −x , x → , := ∈ D(Hm ); γ 1 (x, .) + i (x, .) W 0 = o 2 2 (VI.3) D (HC H I ) " ! π π −x , x → . := ∈ D(Hm ); γ 1 (x, .) − i (x, .) W 0 = o 2 2 (VI.4)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
159
In fact these asymptotic conditions are reduced to linear constraints on the asymptotic profiles ± : we check by (V.7) that γ 1 (x, θ, ϕ) ± i (x, θ, ϕ) = ±2i
π 2
−x
±m
⎛
⎞ ψ± (θ, ϕ)
⎜ χ± (θ, ϕ) ⎟ 1 ⎝ ±iψ (θ, ϕ) ⎠ + γ ± i ϕ(x, θ, ϕ). ± ∓iχ± (θ, ϕ)
Thus (V.8) implies that D (H M I T ) = { ∈ D(Hm ); ψ+ = χ+ = 0} , D (HC H I ) = { ∈ D(Hm ); ψ− = χ− = 0} . We now construct a large family of self-adjoint extensions that are non-local generalizations of the MIT-bag and Chiral conditions. We consider densely defined self-adjoint operators (A± , D(A± )) on L 2 (S 2 ) × L 2 (S 2 ), satisfying 1
1
W−2 × W+2 ⊂ D(A− ), D(A+ ) = L 2 (S 2 ) × L 2 (S 2 ),
(VI.5)
1 1 ±m ±m A± C0∞ (]0, π [×]0, 2π [; C2 ⊂ W−2 × W+2 .
(VI.6)
We introduce the operators H A± defined as Hm endowed with the domain " ! ψ± ψ∓ = A± . D (H A± ) := ∈ D(Hm ); χ∓ χ± In particular, we have H A− = 0 = H M I T and H A+ =0 = HC H I . Proposition VI.3. When 0 < m < 21 , H A+ and H A− are self-adjoint on L2 . ˜ ∈ D(H A± ): Proof of Proposition VI.3. Since A± are self-adjoint, we have for , 1 0 ψ± ψ˜ ∓ ψ˜ ± ˜ >W 0 = , − A± = 0. (VI.7) < ( ), Q( ) χ± χ˜ ∓ χ˜ ± L 2 (S 2 ;C2 ) ˜ ∈ D(H∗ ± ), we have (VI.7) for any Therefore H A± are symmetric. Moreover, given A ∞
∈ D(H A± ) again. For all ψ± , χ± ∈ C0 (]0, π [×]0, 2π [), (VI.1) and (VI.6) assure there exists ∈ D(H A± ) such that ( ) = A+ (ψ+ , χ+ ), ψ+ , χ+ or ψ− , χ− , A− (ψ− , χ− ) . Therefore
0
ψ± χ±
1 ψ˜ ∓ ψ˜ ± , − A± = 0. χ˜ ∓ χ˜ ± L 2 (S 2 ;C2 )
˜ ∈ D(H A± ). We conclude that
160
A. Bachelot
Finally we consider the operators H A P S , Hm A P S associated with the APS and mAPS boundary conditions: " ! π π −x , x → , D (H A P S ) := ∈ D(Hm ); K+ (x, .) W 0 = o 2 2 D (Hm A P S ) " !
π π −x , x → , := ∈ D(Hm ); K+ I d + γ 1 (x, .) W 0 = o 2 2 where K+ is defined by (IV.7). Proposition VI.4. When 0 < m < 21 , we have D (H A P S ) = D (Hm A P S ) = { ∈ D(Hm ); K+ + = K+ − = 0} , and H A P S = Hm A P S is self-adjoint on L2 . Proof of Proposition VI.4. By (V.7), we have ⎞ 1 ⎜ −iJ ∗ ⎟ −x K+ (x) = ⎝ −i ⎠ (ψ− + iJ χ− ) 2 J∗ ⎛ ⎞ 1
π m ∗ ⎜ iJ ⎟ + −x ⎝ (ψ − iJ χ+ ) + K+ ϕ(x), i ⎠ + 2 J∗
π
K+ I d + γ 1
−m
⎛
⎞ 1 ∗ ⎜ −iJ ⎟
(x) = (1 − i) −x ⎝ −i ⎠ (ψ− + iJ χ− ) 2 J∗ ⎛ ⎞ 1
π m ∗ ⎜ iJ ⎟ +(1 + i) −x ⎝ (ψ − iJ χ+ ) i ⎠ + 2 ∗ J
1 +K+ I d + γ ϕ(x),
π
−m
⎛
thus we deduce from (V.8) that
π π 1 K+ (x, .) W 0 = o − x ⇔ K+ I d + γ (x, .) W 0 = o −x 2 2 ⇔ ψ± = ±iJ χ± ⇔ K+ + = K+ − = 0. (VI.8)
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
161
˜ ∈ D (H A P S ), we have < , Q >W 0 = 0, i.e. This equality assures that for , ˜ ∈ D H∗ H A P S is symmetric. Moreover, for any ∈ D (H A P S ), A P S , we have < χ+ , χ˜ − − iJ ∗ ψ˜ − > L 2 (S 2 ) − < χ− , χ˜ + + iJ ∗ ψ˜ + > L 2 (S 2 ) = 0.
(VI.9)
Since C0∞ (]0, π [×]0, 2π [) ⊂ W+1 , for any χ± ∈ C0∞ (]0, π [×]0, 2π [), J χ± belongs to W−1 and by (VI.1) there exists ∈ D(Hm ) such that ⎞ ⎛ −iJ χ− ⎜ χ− ⎟ . ( ) = ⎝ iJ χ+ ⎠ χ+ But such a satisfies (VI.8), that means that is in the domain of H A P S . Since χ± are arbitrary, (VI.9) implies χ˜ ± ± iJ ∗ ψ˜ ± = 0, ˜ ∈ D (H A P S ). that is equivalent to (VI.8). We conclude that
The remainder of the article is devoted to the demonstrations of the theorems of Part 3. As we have explained above, it is sufficient to consider only the case M > 0, since the chiral transform changes the sign of the mass. Proof of Theorem III.4. We denote by H the operator H M endowed with the domain 4 D(H) := C0∞ (B) . Since H M = SHm S−1 , Proposition VI.2 assures that H M is . essentially self-adjoint on S C0∞ 0, π2 x ×]0, π [θ ×]0, 2π [ϕ ; C4 when M ≥ 12 Proposition IV.1 and the Sobolev Imbedding Theorem imply that this set is included in ∞ 4 C0 (B) . Since H is symmetric, we deduce that it is essentially self-adjoint. To determine its domain and establish the elliptic estimate, we prove an inequality of Hardy type. Given a real valued function f ∈ C01 (]0, 1[), an integration by part gives: 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 f () f () d f () d = − f () d + 2 2 2 2 (1 − ) 2 0 1− 1− 0 0 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 ≤ f () d + f ()d, 2 0 (1 − 2 )2 2 0 4 1 ∈ L2 when ∈ H01 (B) , and we have the hence by density we get that 1− following Hardy estimate: 1 1 2 | (x) | dx ≤ | ∇x (x) |2 dx. (VI.10) ∀ ∈ H0 (B), (1− | x |2 )2 B B 4 Thus we see that H01 (B) ⊂ D(H M ) and the graph norm of H M is bounded by the H01 4 norm. Conversely, for ∈ C0∞ (B) , we use the Fourier transform of , the Parseval formula and the anticommutations relations (III.2) to remark that ∂i ∗ γ i γ j ∂ j + ∂ j ∗ γ j γ i ∂i dx = 0, B 1≤i< j≤3
162
A. Bachelot
then we calculate 2 3 2i M 12M 2 j 2 dx = | ∇ | + | |2 γ ∂ j + x 1 − 2 (1 − 2 )2 B B 3 4i M x j ∗ γ j dx. + 2 2 (1 − ) Therefore the Hardy inequality (VI.10) shows that when M > 12 , the elliptic estimate (III.32) holds: 2 12 2 H M L2 ≥ 1 − M | ∇x |2 dx, B 4 and the H01 -norm on C0∞ (B) is bounded by the graph norm of H M . Since H is essentially self-adjoint, we have H∗ = H. On the one hand D(H∗ ) = D(H M ). On the 4 other hand D(H) is the closure of C0∞ (B) for the graph norm. We conclude that 4 D(H M ) = H01 (B) when M > 12 and the first part of the theorem is proved. ∗ A± S , and A± satisfy (III.30) and (III.31), then A± = S11 Now when 0 < M < 12 11 where S11 is defined by (IV.9), satisfy (VI.5) and (VI.6). We deduce fom Proposition VI.3 that HA± = SH A± S−1 is self-adjoint. On the other hand, we have HB A P S = SH A P S S−1= SHm A P S S−1 = HBm A P S that is self-adjoint by Proposition VI.4. Finally ∈ D(H M ), 2L2 + H M 2L2 ≤ 1 is equal to SK where K defined by (V.30) is compact by Proposition V.4. We conclude that the resolvent of any self-adjoint realization of H M is compact.
Proof of Theorem III.5. Theorem III.4 provides a lot of solutions of the initial value it
H
problem: if H is a self-adjoint realization of H M , (t) = e 3 0 is a solution of (III.9), (III.11), (III.12) and (III.13). 2 Since the maximal globally hyperbolic domain in E including {t = 0}×[0, π2 [x ×Sθ,ϕ is given by 0 ≤| t |< 3 π2 − x , the maximal globally hyperbolic domain in M including {t = 0} × R3 is defined by the same relation, that is in (t, x) coordinates: 0 ≤| t |< 3 π2 − 2 arctan . We show that all the solutions are equal in this domain. Given satisfying (III.9), (III.11), we introduce for all ε > 0, 1 t+ε ε (t) = (s)ds. ε t
It is clear that ε ∈ C 1 (Rt ; L2 ), ε → in C 0 (Rt ; L2 ) as ε → 0. Moreover we can see that ε is a solution of (III.9), thus H M ε ∈ C 0 (Rt ; L2 ) and 3 ∂ 3 1 + 2 ∂ ∗ 0 j | ε |2 + ε γ γ ε = 0. ∂t 2 ∂x j j=1
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
163
! " where 0 We integrate this equality on (t, x), 0 ≤ t ≤ T, ≤ tan π4 − T 12 < T < π2 3 , and applying the Green formula we get | ε (T, x) |2 dx = | ε (0, x) |2 dx ≤tan( π4 −T
−
12 )
B
3 π 0≤t= ( 2 −2 arctan )≤T
| (t, x) |2 −
xj ∗ 0 j γ γ (t, x)dσ.
The last integral is non-negative since | x j γ j |≤ | |, and taking the limit as ε → 0, we obtain 2 | (T, x) | dx ≤ | (0, x) |2 dx. ≤tan( π4 −T
12 )
B
We conclude that = 0 for 0 ≤| t |< 3 π2 − 2 arctan if 0 = 0. Finally when M ≥ 12 , we use the fact that H M is self-adjoint to write d −it H −it H 3 M (t) 3 M e H M ε (t) + ∂t ε (t) = 0, =e −i ε dt 3
and we deduce that ε (t) = e that (t) = e
it
3 HM
0 .
it
3 HM
ε (0). Taking the limit in ε again, we conclude
Proof of Theorem III.6. Since the spectrum of H is discrete, and 0 is not an eigenvalue when M > 0, there exists an orthonormal basis of eigenvectors, (k )k∈N , with H M k = λk
3 k ,
λk ∈ R∗ . Now the crucial point is that k∗ γ 0 γ 5 k (x)dx = 0.
(VI.11)
B γ 0γ 5
= −γ 0 γ 5 H M , and we write 1 < k , γ 0 γ 5 k >L2 = < H M k , γ 0 γ 5 k >L2 λk 1 = − < k , γ 0 γ 5 H M k >L2 λk = − < k , γ 0 γ 5 k >L2 .
To see that, we note that H M
We can expand on this basis: ck eiλk t k (x), ck ∈ C,
(t, x) = k∈N
| ck |2 < ∞, k∈N
and taking advantage of (VI.11) we evaluate i(λ p −λq )T − 1 1 T ∗ 0 5 ∗e γ γ (t, x)dxdt = c p cq ∗ γ 0 γ 5 p (x)dx. T 0 B i(λ p − λq )T B q λ p =λq
The dominated convergence theorem assures that this sum tends to 0 as T → ∞.
164
A. Bachelot
VII. Appendix. Breitenlohner-Freedman Bounds for the Scalar Waves We consider the Klein-Gordon equation on the Anti-de Sitter space-time
1 1 | g |− 2 ∂µ | g | 2 g µν ∂ν u − α u = 0, 3 where α ∈ R is a coefficient linked to the mass ; the equation with α = 2 is conformally invariant and corresponds to the massless case. Using the radial coordinate x given by
(II.1), we introduce f (t, x, ω) := r u(t h := −∂x2 +
3 , r, ω)
that is solution of ∂t2 f + h f = 0 with
2−α 1 S2 . − cos2 x sin2 x ω
(VII.1)
First we investigate the positivity of the potential energy E( f ) :=
π 2
S2
0
| ∂ x f |2 +
2−α 1 | f |2 + 2 | ∇ Sω2 f |2 d xdω. cos2 x sin x
To estimate the second term, we employ a Hardy inequality. Given φ ∈ C01 ([0, 21 [; R) an integration by part gives 0
π 2
π π 2 1 1 φ(x)
1 2 2 φ φ φ 2 (x)d x (x)d x = − 2 (x) sin xd x ≤ 2 cos x cos x 2 0 cos2 x 0 π 2 2φ 2 (x) sin2 xd x, + 0
hence
π 2
0
1 φ 2 (x)d x ≤ 4 cos2 x
π 2
φ 2 (x)d x.
0
We deduce that for all f ∈ C0∞ (]0, π2 [x ×Sω2 ), < h f, f > L 2 ≥ min(9 − 4α, 1)
π 2
+ 0
S2
π 2
0
S2
| ∂x f |2 d xdω
1 1 9 | ∇ Sω2 f |2 d xdω ≥ min( − α, ) f 2L 2 , 2 4 4 sin x
and we conclude that the operator h endowed with the domain D(h) = C0∞ (]0, π2 [x ×Sω2 ), is (strictly) positive when α is (strictly) smaller than the upper bound of BreitenlohnerFreedman: 9 9 (r espectively α < ). (VII.2) 4 4 cos x We note that for α = 9/4 and f (x, ω) = 1+sin x , we have E( f ) = 0, hence ∗ f ∈ K er (h ) = {0}. α≤
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
165
To study the self-adjointness, we expand f (x, .) on the basis of the spherical harmonics Ylm l,m by writing ∞ m=l
π 2
π 2 L 2 ]0, [x ×Sω2 = Ll2 , Ll2 := L 2 ]0, [x ⊗ Ylm , 2 2 l=0 m=−l 3∞ therefore h is unitarily equivalent to l=0 hl where: m=l 2 d2 2 − α l(l + 1) π + C0∞ (]0, [) ⊗ Ylm . hl := − 2 + , D(hl ) = 2 dx cos2 x 2 sin x m=−l l(l+1) l(l+1) 2−α 2−α Since cos is a real valued function, bounded on ]0, π2 [, the 2 x + sin2 x − ( π −x)2 − x2 2 symmetric form of the Kato-Rellich theorem (see [31], Theorem X.13) assures that hl is essentially self-adjoint iff
kl := −
m2 =l d2 2−α l(l + 1) π + + , D(k ) = C0∞ (]0, [) ⊗ Ylm , l d x 2 ( π2 − x)2 x2 2 m = −l
is essentially self-adjoint. By Theorem X.10 of [31], kl is in the limit point case at zero when l ≥ 1, and in the limit point case at π2 if 2 − α ≥ 43 , i.e. α is smaller than the lower bound of Breitenlhoner-Freedman 5 (VII.3) α≤ , 4 and if α > 45 , kl is in the limit circle case at π2 . Then the Weyl’s limit point-limit circle criterion (see e.g. [30], Theorems 6.3 and 6.5), assures that kl is essentially self-adjoint when l ≥ 1, α ≤ 45 , and there exists an infinity of self-adjoint extensions associated with boundary conditions at π2 when l ≥ 1, α > 54 . The case l = 0 is particular. For α < 49 , the 1 1 + 94 −α − 94 −α π π π
−2
2 2 solutions of −u +(2−α)( 2 −x) u = 0 are u = c( 2 −x) +c ( 2 −x) , therefore k0 is always in the limit circle case at π2 and there exists a lot of self-adjoint
extensions. By the Kato-Rellich theorem ([31], Theorem X.12), the same results are true for hl . Since the spherically symmetric fields play a peculiar role, we introduce their orthogonal space " 2 ! ∞ π π 2 2 2 2 f (x, ω)g(x)d xdω = 0 = L∗ := f ∈ L (]0, [×S ); ∀g ∈ L (]0, [), Ll2 , 2 2 l=1
C0∞ (]0, π2 [×S 2 ) ∩ L∗2 , and
and h∗ denotes h endowed with the domain D(h∗ ) = considered as a densely defined operator on L∗2 . Since this operator is strictly positive when α < 49 , it is essentially selfadjoint iff its range is dense ([31], Theorem X.26). We easily ⊥
⊥
∞ (Ran(h )) Ll , and we conclude that h is essentially prove that (Ran(h∗ )) L∗ = ⊕l=1 l ∗ self-adjoint when α ≤ 45 . Finally we have proved the following: 2
2
Theorem VII.1. When α ≤ 49 (resp. α < 49 ), h is a positive (resp. strictly positive) symmetric operator on L 2 (]0, π2 [×S 2 ). When 45 < α < 49 there exists an infinity of self-adjoint extensions of h∗ on L∗2 , associated with boundary conditions on { π2 } × S 2 . When α ≤ 45 , h∗ is essentially self-adjoint.
166
A. Bachelot
References 1. Avis, S.J., Isham, C.J., Storey, D.: Quantum field theory in anti-de Sitter space-time. Phys. Rev. D 18(10), 3565–3576 (1978) 2. Bachelot, A.: Global properties of the wave equation on non globally hyperbolic manifolds. J. Math. Pures Appl. 81, 35–65 (2002) 3. Bachelot, A.: Equipartition de l’énergie pour les systèmes hyperboliques et formes compatibles. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré - Physique théorique 46(1), 45–76 (1987) 4. Bachelot-Motet, A.: Nonlinear Dirac fields on the Schwarzschild metric. Class. Quantum Grav. 15, 1815–1825 (1998) 5. Bartnik, R.A., Chru´sciel, P.T.: Boundary value problems for Dirac equations with applications. J. Reine Angew. Math. 579, 13–73 (2005) 6. Booß, B., Wojciechowski, K.P.: Elliptic boundary problems for Dirac Operators. Basel-Boston: Birkhäuser, 1993 7. Breitenlohner, P., Freedman, D.Z.: Stability in gauged extended supergravity. Ann. Phys. 144(2), 249–281 (1982) 8. Breitenlohner, P., Freedman, D.Z.: Positive energy in anti-de Sitter backgrounds and gauged extended supergravity. Phys. Lett. B 115(3), 197–201 (1982) 9. Brüning, J., Lesch, M.: On Boundary Value Problems for Dirac Type Operators I. Regularity and SelfAdjointness. J. Func. Anal. 185, 1–62 (2001) 10. Bunke, U.: Comparison of Dirac operators on manifolds with boundary. Suppl. di Rend. Circ. Mat. Palermo Serie II 133–141 (1993) 11. Choquet-Bruhat, Y.: Solutions globales d’équations d’ondes sur l’espace-temps Anti de Sitter. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 308, 323–327 (1989) 12. Cot˘aescu, I.I.: Normalized energy eigenspinors of the Dirac field on anti-de Sitter spacetime. Phys. Rev. D(3) 60(12), 124006 (1999) 13. Friedman, J.L., Morris, M.S.: Existence and Uniqueness Theorems for Massless Fields on a Class of Spacetimes with Closed Timelike Curves. Commun. Math. Phys. 186, 495–529 (1997) 14. Gelfand, I.M., Minlos, R.A., Shapiro, Z.Ya.: Representations of the rotation and Lorentz groups and their representations. London: Pergamon Press, 1963 15. Gibbons, G.W.: Anti-de-Sitter spacetime and its uses. In: Mathematical and quantum aspects of relativity and cosmology (Pythagoreon, 1998), Lecture Notes in Phys., 537, Berlin-Heidelberg-NewYork: Springer-Verlag, 2000, pp. 102–142 16. Grubb, G.: Spectral Boundary Conditions for Generalizations of Laplace and Dirac Operator. Commun. Math. Phys. 240, 243–280 (2003) 17. Häfner, D.: Creation of fermions by rotating charged black-holes. http://arxiv.org/list/, 2006 18. Häfner, D., Nicolas, J-P.: Scattering of massless Dirac fields by a Kerr black hole. Rev. Math. Phys. 16(1), 29–123 (2007) 19. Hawking, S.W., Ellis, G.F.R.: The large scale structure of space-time. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973 20. Hijazi, O., Montiel, S., Roldan, A.: Eigenvalue Boundary Problems for the Dirac Operator. Commun. Math. Phys. 231, 375–390 (2002) 21. Ishibashi, A., Wald, R.M.: Dynamics in non-globally-hyperbolic, static space-times: II. General analysis of prescriptions for dynamics. Class. Quantum Grav. 20, 3815–3826 (2003) 22. Ishibashi, A., Wald, R.M.: Dynamics in non-globally-hyperbolic, static space-times: III. Anti-de-Sitter space-time. Class. Quantum Grav. 21, 2981–3013 (2004) 23. Kalf, H., Yamada, O.: Essential self-adjointness of Dirac operators with a variable mass. Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A 76(2), 13–15 (2000) 24. Lions, J-L., Magenes, E.: Problèmes aux limites non homogènes et applications I. Paris: Dunod, 1968 25. Melnyk, F.: Scattering on Reissner-Nordstrøm metric for massive charged spin 1/2 fields. Ann. Henri Poincaré 4(n o 5), 813–846 (2003) 26. Nicolas, J-P.: Scattering of linear Dirac fields by a spherically symetric Black-Hole. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré - Physique théorique 62(n o 2), 145–179 (1995) 27. Nicolas, J-P.: Dirac fields on asymptotically flat space-times. Dissertationes Math., 408 (2002) 28. Nicolas, J-P.: Global exterior Cauchy problem for the spin 3/2 zero rest-mass fields in the Schwarzschild space-time. Comm. Partial Differ. Eqs. 22(n o 3-4), 465–502 (1997) 29. O’Neill, B.: Semi-Riemannian geometry. With Applications to Relativity. Pure and Applied Mathematics, 103, London-New York: Academic Press, 1983 30. Pearson, D.B.: Quantum scattering and spectral theory. London-New York: Academic Press, 1988 31. Reed, M., Simon, B.: Methods of modern mathematical physics, Vol. 2, Fourier Analysis, Self-Adjointness. New York: Academic Press, 1975
The Dirac System on the Anti-de Sitter Universe
167
32. Segev, I.: Dynamics in stationary, non-globally hyperbolic spacetimes. Class. Quantum Grav. 21, 2651–2668 (1994) 33. Shishkin, G.V., Villalba, V.M.: Dirac Equation in external vector fields: separation of variables. J. Math. Phys. 30, 2132–2143 (1989) 34. Schmidt, K.M., Yamada, O.: Spherically symmetric Dirac operators with variable mass and potential infinite at infinity. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. Kyoto Univ. 34, 211–227 (1998) 35. Vilenkin, N.J.: Special Functions and the Theory of Group Representations. Translations of Mathematical Monographs, Volume 22, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1968 36. Vilenkin, N.J., Klimyk, A.U.: Representation of Lie Groups and Special Functions, Vol. 1. Mathematics and Its Applications (Soviet Series), Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1991 37. Wald, R.M.: Dynamics in nonglobally hyperbolic, static space-times. J. Math. Phys. 21(12), 2802–2805 (1980) 38. Yamada, O.: On the spectrum of Dirac operators with the unbounded potential at infinity. Hokkaido Math. J. 26, 439–449 (1997) Communicated by G.W. Gibbons
Commun. Math. Phys. 283, 169–226 (2008) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0563-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU(2, 1) and G 2(2) M. Günaydin1,2 , A. Neitzke2 , O. Pavlyk3 , B. Pioline4,5 1 Physics Department, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA.
E-mail:
[email protected]
2 School of Natural Sciences, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, NJ, USA.
E-mail:
[email protected]
3 Wolfram Research Inc., 100 Trade Center Dr., Champaign, IL 61820, USA.
E-mail:
[email protected]
4 Laboratoire de Physique Théorique et Hautes Energies , Université Pierre et
Marie Curie - Paris 6, 4 place Jussieu, F-75252 Paris cedex 05, France. E-mail:
[email protected]
5 Laboratoire de Physique Théorique de l’Ecole Normale Supérieure ,
24 rue Lhomond, F-75231 Paris cedex 05, France Received: 22 July 2007 / Accepted: 14 March 2008 Published online: 22 July 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: Quasi-conformal actions were introduced in the physics literature as a generalization of the familiar fractional linear action on the upper half plane, to Hermitian symmetric tube domains based on arbitrary Jordan algebras, and further to arbitrary Freudenthal triple systems. In the mathematics literature, quaternionic discrete series unitary representations of real reductive groups in their quaternionic real form were constructed as degree 1 cohomology on the twistor spaces of symmetric quaternionicKähler spaces. These two constructions are essentially identical, as we show explicitly for the two rank 2 cases SU (2, 1) and G 2(2) . We obtain explicit results for certain principal series, quaternionic discrete series and minimal representations of these groups, including formulas for the lowest K -types in various polarizations. We expect our results to have applications to topological strings, black hole micro-state counting and to the theory of automorphic forms. 1. Introduction and Summary Despite much recent progress, classifying the unitary representations of a real reductive group G remains a challenging task, which has only been addressed in a few, typically low-rank cases, including for example S L(2, R) [1–3], S L(3, R) [4,5], SU (2, 1) [6], SU (2, 2) [7] and G 2(2) [8]. Even in well-charted cases, the available mathematical description is often not directly useful to physicists, who are in general more interested in explicit differential operator realizations than abstract classifications. The goal of this paper is to give an explicit description of aspects of principal and discrete series representations (and continuations of the discrete series) which arise when G is a quaternionic real form of a semi-simple group. For the sake of explicitness, we restrict to the rank 2 case – so G = SU (2, 1) or G = G 2(2) . Quaternionic real forms arise as symmetries of supergravity theories with 8 supercharges in three dimensions [9–13], and therefore Unité mixte de recherche du CNRS UMR 7589. Unité mixte de recherche du CNRS UMR 8549.
170
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
as spectrum-generating symmetries for black holes in four dimensional supergravity; a detailed discussion of this relation, which indeed motivated our interest in the first place, can be found in [14–16] and references therein. The simplest discrete series representations1 arise when K = U (1)× M, so that G/K is a Hermitian symmetric domain. The simplest example is G/K = S L(2, R)/U (1): G acts holomorphically on the upper half-plane by fractional linear transformations τ → (aτ + b)/(cτ + d), which preserve the Kähler potential K = − log[(τ − τ¯ )] up to Kähler transformations. This construction can be extended to all Hermitian symmetric tube domains using the language of Jordan algebras. Indeed, consider the “upper half plane” τ ∈ J + i J + , where J is a Euclidean Jordan algebra J of degree n and J + is the domain of positivity of J , equipped with the Kähler potential K = − log N (τ − τ¯ ), where N is the norm form of J 2 . The corresponding metric is invariant under a non-compact group G = Conf(J ), the “conformal group” associated to J , acting holomorphically by generalized fractional linear transformations on τ [24,25]. The ), resulting space is the Hermitian symmetric tube domain G/K = Conf(J )/Str(J ) = U (1) × Str 0 (J ) is the compact real form of the structure group3 of where Str(J J , which coincides with the maximal compact subgroup of G. The action of G on sections of holomorphic vector bundles over G/K leads to the holomorphic discrete series representations. The next simplest case, of interest in this paper, arises when G is in its quaternionic real form, such that K = SU (2) × M, and its Lie algebra decomposes as g = su(2)⊕M⊕(2, V ), where V is a pseudo-real representation of M. The symmetric space G/K , of real dimension 4d, is now a quaternionic-Kähler space, and does not generally admit a G-invariant complex structure. The twistor space Z = G/U (1) × M, a bundle over G/K with fiber CP1 = SU (2)/U (1), does however carry a G-invariant complex structure. In [26] this complex structure was exploited to construct a family of representations πk of G, labeled by k ∈ Z: namely, πk is the sheaf cohomology H 1 (Z, O(−k)) of a certain line bundle O(−k) over Z.4 πk is a representation of G, with Gelfand-Kirillov (functional) dimension 2d + 1, equal to the complex dimension of Z. For k ≥ 2d + 1, πk are discrete series unitary representations of G, called “quaternionic discrete series.” The πk for k < 2d + 1 are also of interest. In [26] special attention was paid to quaternionic groups of type G 2 , D4 , F4 , E 6 , E 7 , E 8 , such that d = 3 f + 4 with f = − 23 , 0, 1, 2, 4, 8. For these groups, it was shown that πk is irreducible and unitarizable even for k ≥ d + 1 (although it no longer belongs to the quaternionic discrete series for k < (2d +1)). Moreover, for selected smaller values of k, namely k = 3 f +2, k = 2 f +2 and k = f +2, πk was shown to be reducible but to admit a unitarizable submodule πk , of smaller Gelfand-Kirillov dimension, 2d = 6 f + 8, 5 f + 6, 3 f + 5 = d + 1, respectively. 1 Discrete series representations arise as discrete summands in the spectral decomposition of L 2 (G) under the left action of G. A basic result of Harish-Chandra [17,18] states that G admits discrete series representations if and only if its maximal compact subgroup K has the same rank as G itself. 2 The generalized upper half planes associated to Jordan algebras are sometimes called Köcher half-spaces since Köcher pioneered their study [19]. In particular, he introduced the linear fractional groups of Jordan algebras [20], which were interpreted as conformal groups of generalized spacetimes defined by Jordan algebras and extended to Jordan superalgebras in the physics literature [21–23]. The terminology stems from the well-known action of the conformal group S O(4, 2) on Minkowski spacetime, which arises when J is the Jordan algebra of 2 × 2 Hermitian matrices [21]. Choosing J = R leads instead to our original example G/K = S L(2, R)/U (1). 3 The structure group Str(J ) leaves the norm form N of the Jordan algebra J invariant up to an overall scaling. It decomposes as an Abelian factor R times the reduced structure group Str 0 (J ) which leaves the norm invariant. 4 For a definition of sheaf cohomology see e.g. [27].
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
171
The smallest of these representations is the “minimal” or “ladder” representation of G; the latter name refers to the structure of its K -type decomposition;5 a review of minimal representations can be found in [28]. Independently of these mathematical developments, it was shown in [25] that the conformal realization of the group Conf(J ) attached to a Jordan algebra J of degree 3, preserving a generalized light-cone N3 (τ − τ¯ ) = 0, could be extended to an action of a larger non-compact group, preserving a “quartic light-cone” ¯ + (α − α¯ + , ) ¯ 2 = 0, N4 ≡ I4 ( − )
(1.1)
where = (ξ I , ξ˜ I ) = (ξ 0 , ξ , ξ˜ , ξ˜0 ) is an element of the Freudenthal triple system ¯ a symplectic pairing invariant under the F = C ⊕ JC ⊕ JC ⊕ C associated to J , , linear action of Conf(J ) on , I4 a quartic polynomial invariant under this same action6 and α an additional complex variable of homogeneity degree two. This larger group was called the “quasi-conformal group” QConf(J ) attached to the Jordan algebra J , or more appropriately to the Freudenthal triple system F; its geometric action on (, α) was called the “quasi-conformal realization”. When J is Euclidean, QConf(J ) is a noncompact group in its quaternionic real form; other real forms can be similarly obtained from Jordan algebras of indefinite signature [25]. Moreover, it was observed in [29] for G = E 8(8) , and generalized to other simple groups in [30–32], that this quasi-conformal action on 2d + 1 variables could be reduced to a representation on functions of d + 1 variables, obtained by first adding one more variable (symplectizing) and then quantizing the resulting 2d + 2-dimensional symplectic space. This smaller representation was identified as the minimal representation of G = QConf(J ). Let us now comment briefly on the physics. Euclidean Jordan algebras J of degree three made their appearance in supergravity a long time ago [9,10,33]. MaxwellEinstein supergravity theories with N = 2 supersymmetry in D = 5 and a symmetric moduli space G/H such that G is a symmetry group of the action are in one-to-one correspondence with Euclidean Jordan algebras J of degree three. Their symmetry group in D = 5 is simply the reduced structure group Str 0 (J ) of J . Upon reduction to D = 4 and D = 3, the symmetry groups are extended to the conformal Conf(J ) and quasi-conformal groups QConf(J ), respectively. The corresponding moduli spaces are given by the quotient of the respective symmetry group by its maximal compact subgroup, and are special real, special Kähler and quaternionic-Kähler manifolds, respectively [9,10,13]. An explicit description of the quasi-conformal action QConf(J ) of D = 3 MaxwellEinstein supergravity theories with symmetric target spaces was obtained in [31]. Finally, it was observed in [15] that the minimal unitary representation of QConf(J ) is closely related to the vector space to which the topological string partition function naturally belongs. 5 We remind the reader of a few definitions. Suppose ρ is a representation of a real Lie group G on a vector space V . Let VK denote the space of K -finite vectors in V (i.e. those which generate a finite-dimensional subspace of V under the action of the maximal compact subgroup K ⊂ G). Then any representation of K which occurs in VK is called a K -type of ρ. Parameterizing the K -types by their highest weights µ, a “lowest K -type” is one with the minimal value of µ + 2ρ K 2 , where ρ K is half the sum of positive roots of K . A discrete series representation always has a unique lowest K -type. If the lowest K -type is the trivial representation, then it is also called the spherical vector and the representation ρ is deemed spherical. The Gelfand-Kirillov dimension measures the growth of the multiplicities of the K -types; morally it counts the number of variables xi needed to realize V as a space of functions. Finally, if all K -types in ρ occur with multiplicity 1 and lie along a ray in the weight space of K , then ρ is called a ladder representation. 2 6 I is expressible in terms of N via 8I () = ξ 0 ξ˜ − ξ ξ˜ 0 − 4ξ ξ˜ + 4ξ N3 (ξ ) + 4ξ˜0 N3 (ξ˜ ), 4 3 4 0
where ξ is related to ξ by the (quadratic) adjoint map, defined by (ξ ) = N (ξ ) ξ .
172
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
The minimal representation has also appeared in another physical context: in [34], a connection between the harmonic superspace (HSS) formulation of N = 2, d = 4 supersymmetric quaternionic Kähler sigma models that couple to N = 2 supergravity and the minimal unitary representations of their isometry groups was established. In particular, for N = 2 sigma models with quaternionic symmetric target spaces of the form QConf(J )/C onf(J ) × SU (2) there exists a one-to-one mapping between the quartic Killing potentials that generate the isometry group QConf(J ) under Poisson brackets in the HSS formulation, and the generators of the minimal unitary representation of QConf(J ). It would be important to understand physically how the minimal representation may arise by quantizing the sigma-model in harmonic superspace. The main goal of the present work is to explain the relation between the twistorial construction of the quaternionic discrete series in [26] and the quasi-conformal actions discovered in [25], and moreover to elucidate the sense in which the minimal representation is obtained by “quantizing the quasi-conformal action”. While our results are unlikely to cause any surprise to the informed mathematician, we hope that our exegesis of [26] will be useful to physicists, e.g. in subsequent applications to supergravity and black holes, and possibly to mathematicians too, e.g. in obtaining explicit formulae for automorphic forms along the lines of [35]. As the main body of this paper is fairly technical, we summarize its content below, including some open problems and possible applications: (i) The key observation is that the variables (, α) of the quasi-conformal realization have a natural interpretation as complex coordinates on the twistor space Z = G/U (1) × M over the quaternionic-Kähler space G/SU (2) × M, adapted to the action of the Heisenberg algebra in the nilpotent radical of the Heisenberg parabolic subgroup of G. The logarithm of the “quartic norm” N4 provides a Kähler potential (2.56) for the G-invariant Einstein-Kähler metric on Z.7 Using the Harish-Chandra decomposition, we also construct the complex coordinates adapted to another Heisenberg algebra related by a Cayley-type transform, whose center is a compact generator rather than a nilpotent one. These coordinates are the analogue of the Poincaré disk coordinates for S L(2, R)/U (1), and it would be interesting to give a Jordan-type description of the corresponding Kähler potential, given in (2.39) for G = SU (2, 1). (ii) It is also possible to view (, α) as real coordinates on G/P, where P is a parabolic subgroup of G with Heisenberg radical. This G/P arises as a piece of the boundary of Z or of G/K . (iii) The quasi-conformal action admits a continuous deformation by a parameter k∈C, corresponding to the action of G on sections of a line bundle over G/P induced from a character of P. This action provides a degenerate principal series representation, which is manifestly unitary for k ∈ 2+iR (SU (2, 1)) or k ∈ 3+iR (G 2(2) ). We tabulate the formulas for the infinitesimal action of g in this representation, and determine the spherical vector. (iv) When k is an integer, one can also consider sections on G/P which can be (in an appropriate sense) extended holomorphically into Z. Thus, the quasi-conformal action with , α complex as in i) leads to a differential operator realization of the action of G on these sections. When G = SU (2, 1) and k ≥ 3, as explained in [26], this action gives quaternionic discrete series representations; we explic7 This follows by specializing analysis performed in [36] of general “dual” quaternionic-Kähler spaces to symmetric spaces. It will be rederived below using purely group theoretic methods (in fact, this approach was a useful guide for the general analysis in [36]).
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
173
itly compute the K -finite vectors of this submodule in the principal series. When G = G 2(2) we similarly study the K -finite vectors of the principal series and identify a natural subset which has the same K -type decomposition as the quaternionic discrete series. (v) Given a class in H 1 (Z, O(−k)), the Penrose transform produces a section of a vector bundle over the quaternionic-Kähler base G/K annihilated by some “quaternionic” differential operators [37,38,36]. For G = SU (2, 1) and k even, we argue formally but explicitly in Sect. 2.4.5 that computing the Penrose transform of is equivalent to evaluating a matrix element between and the lowest K type of the quaternionic discrete series. A similarly explicit understanding of the Penrose transform for k odd remains an open problem, which would require a proper prescription for dealing with the branch cuts in the formula of [36]. (vi) The quasi-conformal action on Z can be lifted to a tri-holomorphic action on the hyperkähler cone (or Swann space) S = R × G/M, locally isomorphic to the smallest nilpotent coadjoint orbit of G C . In particular, the action of G on S preserves the holomorphic symplectic form. The minimal representation of G can be viewed as the “holomorphic quantization” of S. We show explicitly in Sect. 2.6 for SU (2, 1) and 3.4.1 for G 2,2 that the leading differential symbols of the generators of the minimal representation are equal to the holomorphic moment maps of the action of G on S, and identify the corresponding semi-classical limit. (vii) We determine explicitly the lowest K -type of the minimal representation, generalizing the analysis of [39] to these two quaternionic groups. For G 2(2) , the lowest K -type in the real polarization (3.119) bears strong similarities to the result found in [39] for simply laced split groups, while the wave function in the complex (upside-down) polarization (3.119) is analogous to the topological string wave function. (Such a relation is not unexpected, given the results of [15], which showed that the holomorphic anomaly equations of the topological string can be naturally explained in terms of the minimal representation.) We show further that the semi-classical limit of the lowest K -type wave function yields the generating function for a holomorphic Lagrangian cone inside the holomorphic symplectic space S, invariant under the holomorphic action of G.8 It would be very interesting to formulate the hyperkähler geometry of S in terms of this Lagrangian cone, by analogy to special Kähler geometry. The organization of this paper is as follows: In Sects. 2 and 3, for the two rank 2 quaternionic groups G = SU (2, 1) and G = G 2(2) successively, we give explicit parametrizations of the quaternionic-Kähler homogeneous spaces G/K and their twistor spaces, provide explicit differential operator realizations of the principal series, quaternionic discrete series and minimal representations, and compute their spherical or lowest K -type vectors. Throughout this paper we work mostly at the level of the Lie algebras. We are not careful about the discrete factors in any of the various groups that appear. We emphasize concrete formulas even if they are formal, in the spirit of the early literature on twistor theory.
8 This Lagrangian cone was already instrumental in [35], in extending the real spherical vector found in [39] to the adelic setting.
174
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
2. SU(2, 1) 2.1. Some group theory. The non-compact Lie group G = SU (2, 1) is defined as the group of unimodular transformations of C3 which preserve a given hermitian metric η with signature (+, +, −). It is convenient to choose ⎛ ⎞ 1 η = ⎝ 1 ⎠. (2.1) 1 The Lie algebra g = su(2, 1) consists of traceless matrices such that ηX + X † η = 0. This condition is solved by ⎛ ⎞ H + i J /3 E p − i E q , iE −2i J /3 −(E p + i E q )⎠ ≡ X i X i , X = ⎝F p + i Fq (2.2) −i F −(F p − i F q ) −H + i J /3 where {X i } = {H , J , E p , E q , E, F p , F q , F} are the real coefficients of the generators {X i } = {H, J, E p , E q , E,F p , Fq , F} in g. The latter are represented by anti-hermitian operators in any unitary representation. They obey the commutation relations consistent with the matrix representation above. In particular, E p , E q , E obey the Heisenberg algebra E p , E q = −2E, (2.3) while E, H, F generate a Sl(2, R) subalgebra [E, F] = H, [H, E] = 2E, [H, F] = −2F.
(2.4)
The center of the universal enveloping algebra U (g) is generated by the quadratic Casimir C2 =
1 2 3 2 1 1 H − J + (E p F p + F p E p + E q Fq + Fq E q ) + (E F + F E) 4 4 4 2
(2.5)
and cubic Casimir C3 =H 2 J + J 3 − E (F p2 + Fq2 ) + F(E 2p + E q2 )
(2.6)
+ (Fq E p − F p E q )H + (4E F − F p E p − Fq E q − 2)J. The Casimir operators take values [6]
1 4i C2 = p + q + ( p 2 + pq + q 2 ), C3 = ( p − q)( p + 2q + 3)(q + 2 p + 3) (2.7) 3 27 i ...i
in a finite-dimensional representation of SU (2, 1) corresponding to a tensor T j11... jqp with p upper and q lower indices (in particular, (C2 , C3 ) = (3, 0) and (4/3, 80i/27) for the adjoint and fundamental representations, respectively). It is convenient to continue to use the same variables ( p, q) defined in (2.7), no longer restricted to integers, to label the infinite-dimensional representations of SU (2, 1). Alternatively, one may define the “infinitesimal character” 1 1 1 x1 = − ( p + 2q + 3), x2 = ( p − q), x3 = (2 p + q + 3) 3 3 3
(2.8)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
J
J Fp+iFq
−2
Ep+iEq
+i
−1
175
+1
+2
J3
K−
H
J+
L0 −2i
−i
i
2i
L−
L+ S
Fp−iFq
−i
−i
Ep−iEq
J−
K+
Fig. 1. Root diagram of SU (2, 1) with respect to the mixed Cartan torus H, J (left) and the compact Cartan torus L 0 , J (right). The compact (resp. non-compact) roots are indicated by a white (resp. black) dot
with x1 + x2 + x3 = 0, such that the Weyl group of SU (2, 1) acts by permutations of (x1 , x2 , x3 ). In a unitary representation, either all xi are real, or one is real and the other two are complex conjugates [6]. In the former case one may choose to order x1 ≤ x2 ≤ x3 , corresponding to p ≥ −1, q ≥ −1. We shall be particularly interested in representations where p = q, such that the infinitesimal character is proportional to the Weyl vector (−1, 0, 1). The generators H, J generate a Cartan subalgebra of g. The spectrum of the adjoint action of Spec(J ) = {0, ±i}, Spec(H ) = {0, ±1, ±2}
(2.9)
shows that H and J are non-compact and compact, respectively. In fact, the generator H gives rise to a “real non-compact” 5-grading g = F|−2 ⊕ {F p , Fq }|−1 ⊕ {H, J }|0 ⊕ {E p , E q }|1 ⊕ E|2 ,
(2.10)
where the subscript denotes the eigenvalue under H . In this decomposition, each subspace is invariant under hermitian conjugation. Moreover J ⊕ {E, H, F} generate a U (1) × S L(2, R) (non-compact) maximal subgroup of G. The remaining roots arrange themselves into a pair of doublets of S L(2, R) with opposite charge under J ,
F p − i Fq E p − i E q F p + i Fq E p + i E q
(2.11)
as shown on the root diagram 1. The parabolic subgroup P = L N with Levi L = R × U (1) generated by {H, J } and unipotent radical N generated by {F p , Fq , F}, corresponding to the spaces with zero and negative grade in the decomposition (3.8), is known as the Heisenberg parabolic subgroup, and will play a central rôle in all constructions in this paper. For later purposes, it will be useful to introduce another basis of g adapted to a maximal compact subgroup K = SU (2) × U (1). We first go to a compact basis for the
176
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
S L(2, R) factor generated by E, F, H : 1 1 1 (F − E), K 0 = (2L 0 + 3J ), L ± = − √ (E + F ± i H ) , (2.12) 2 4 2 2 1 1 K ± = − E p ± i E q + (F p ± i Fq ) , J± = − √ E p ∓ i E q − (F p ∓ i Fq ) . 4 2 2 L0 =
Then {L + , L 0 , L − } and {K + , K 0 , K − } make two S L(2, R) subalgebras, with compact Cartan generators L 0 and K 0 , respectively, (2.13) L 0 , L ± = ±i L ± , [L + , L − ] = −i L 0 , (2.14) K 0 , K ± = ±i K ± , [K + , K − ] = −i K 0 . Since Spec(L 0 ) = {0, ± 2i , ±i}, (L 0 , J ) now form a Cartan torus, and L 0 gives rise to a new 5-grading, g = L − |−i ⊕ {K − , J− }|− i ⊕ {L 0 , J }|0 ⊕ {J+ , K + }| i ⊕ L + |i , 2
2
(2.15)
where the subscript denotes the eigenvalue under L 0 . Unlike the 5-grading (2.10), in (2.15) hermitian conjugation exchanges the positive and negative grade spaces. Next, we perform a π/3 rotation of the root diagram, and define 3 1 (F − E − 3J ), S = (F − E + J ), 4 √ 4√ = ±2 2i L ± , J± 1 ,∓ 3 = 2K ∓ .
J3 = J± 1 ,± 3 2
2
2
2
(2.16) (2.17)
Then {J+ , J3 , J− } and S generate the compact subgroup K = SU (2) × U (1),9 J3 , J± = ±i J± , [J+ , J− ] = 2i J3 . (2.18) In particular, J3 induces the “compact 5-grading” J− |−i ⊕ {L − , K + }|− i ⊕ {J3 , S}|0 ⊕ {K − , L + }| i ⊕ J+ |i , 2
2
(2.19)
where the subscript now denotes the J3 eigenvalue. The remaining roots can then be arranged as a pair of doublets under SU (2) with opposite U (1) S charges,
J− 1 ,− 3 J 1 ,− 3 2 2 2 2 (2.20) J− 1 , 3 J 1 , 3 2 2
2 2
as shown on the second root diagram on Fig. 1. In order to represent the generators in the compact basis by pseudo-hermitian matrices, it is convenient to change basis and diagonalize the hermitian metric (2.1), ⎞ ⎛ 1 ⎛ ⎞ √ 0 √1 1 2 ⎟ ⎜ 2 η ≡ CηC t = ⎝ −1 ⎠ , C = ⎝ √1 0 − √1 ⎠ . (2.21) 2 2 1 0 1 0 9 To be precise, K = (SU (2) × U (1))/Z . We abuse notation by suppressing this Z in most of what 2 2 follows.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
177
The generators preserving the metric η can now be parametrized as ⎞ ⎛ i −J − − 2 (J 3 + S) 2J − 1 ,− 3 2 2 ⎜ 2J 1 3 iS −2J − 1 , 3 ⎟ ⎠, ⎝ , 2 2
−2J 1 ,− 3
J+
2
i 2 (J 3
2
− S)
where J 3 , S are real, while J ± = J ∗∓ , J ± 1 ,± 3 = J ∗ 2
2
(2.22)
2 2
∓ 21 ,∓ 23
, J ± 1 ,∓ 3 = J ∗ 2
2
∓ 21 ,± 32
. By
analogy with the S L(2, R) = SU (1, 1) case, we shall refer to the matrix C as a Cayley rotation.
2.2. Quaternionic symmetric space. We now describe the geometry of the quaternionicKähler symmetric space K \G = (SU (2)×U (1))\SU (2, 1). This space is well known in the string theory literature as the tree-level moduli space of the universal hypermultiplet (see e.g. [11,40–42] for some useful background). It is in the class of “dual quaternionic manifolds”, in the sense that it can be constructed by the c-map procedure [43,12] from the trivial zero-dimensional special Kähler manifold with quadratic prepotential F = −i(X 0 )2 /2. In order to parameterize this space, we use the Iwasawa decomposition of G, ˜
g = k · e−U H · eζ E p −ζ Eq · eσ E ,
(2.23)
where k is an element of the maximal compact subgroup K = SU (2)×U (1). In terms of the fundamental representation, this is g = k ·e Q K , where e Q K is the coset representative ⎛ −U ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ 1 ζ˜ + iζ i σ − 21 (ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 ) e 1 ⎠·⎝ eQ K = ⎝ (2.24) 1 −(ζ˜ − iζ ) ⎠ . eU 1 The right-invariant g-valued 1-form is then ⎛ ⎞ −dU e−U (d ζ˜ + idζ ) ie−2U (dσ + ζ˜ dζ − ζ d ζ˜ ) ⎝ 0 θ = de Q K e−1 0 −e−U (d ζ˜ − idζ ) ⎠ . (2.25) QK = 0 0 dU Expanding θ on the compact basis of g, its 1-form components are
J−1,3 J 1,3 u¯ v¯ 2 2 2 2 =− , J − 1 ,− 3 J 1 ,− 3 vu 2
2
2
(2.26)
2
⎞ ⎞ ⎛ u¯ J− 3i 1 ⎝ J 3 ⎠ = − ⎝ i (v − v) ¯ ¯ ⎠ , S = − (v − v), 4 2 8 J+ u ⎛
(2.27)
where we defined the 1-forms 1 i u = − √ e−U (d ζ˜ + idζ ), v = dU − e−2U (dσ + ζ˜ dζ − ζ d ζ˜ ). 2 2
(2.28)
178
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
The non-compact components (2.26) give the quaternionic viel-bein of the invariant metric, while the compact components (2.27) give the spin connection, with restricted holonomy SU (2) × U (1). The invariant metric on K \G is thus given by ds 2 = 2(u u¯ + v v) ¯
2 1 2 = 2(dU )2 + e−2U d ζ˜ 2 + dζ 2 + e−4U dσ + ζ˜ dζ − ζ d ζ˜ . 2
(2.29)
The group G acts on the coset space K \G by right multiplication, followed by a left action of the maximal compact K = SU (2) × U (1) so as to maintain the Iwasawa gauge k = 1 in (2.23). The metric is invariant under this action. This gives an action of SU (2, 1) by Killing vectors on K \G: E Q K = ∂σ ,
E pQ K = ∂ζ˜ − ζ ∂σ ,
E qQ K = −∂ζ − ζ˜ ∂σ ,
J Q K = ζ ∂ζ˜ − ζ˜ ∂ζ , Fp Q K Fq Q K F QK
H Q K = −∂U − ζ ∂ζ − ζ˜ ∂ζ˜ − 2σ ∂σ ,
3ζ 2 − ζ˜ 2 1 2U = −ζ˜ ∂U −(σ +2ζ ζ˜ )∂ζ + e + ∂ζ˜ + ζ e2U + (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) −σ ζ˜ ∂σ , 2 2
2 ˜2 2U 3ζ −ζ 2U 1 2 ˜ 2 ˜ ˜ = ζ ∂U −(σ − 2ζ ζ )∂ζ˜ − e + ∂ζ + ζ e + (ζ + ζ ) +σ ζ ∂σ , 2 2
2
1 1 = −σ ∂U + e2U + (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) −σ 2 ∂σ − ζ˜ e2U + (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) + σ ζ ∂ζ 2 2
1 + ζ e2U + (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) − σ ζ˜ .∂ζ˜ . (2.30) 2
The action of G on K \G also induces a representation of G on L 2 (K \G). The quadratic Casimir in this representation is proportional to the Laplace-Beltrami operator of the metric (2.29), while the cubic Casimir vanishes identically: C2 =
1 1 √ 1 = √ ∂i gg i j ∂ j , C3 = 0. 4 4 g
(2.31)
2.3. Twistor space and Swann space. The twistor space Z is a CP1 = U (1)\SU (2) bundle over the quaternionic-Kähler space (SU (2) × U (1))\SU (2, 1), which carries a Kähler-Einstein metric. The fibration is such that the SU (2) “cancels” [44], so that Z is an homogeneous (but not symmetric) space, Z = (U (1) S × U (1) J3 )\SU (2, 1).
(2.32)
Let H denote the subgroup U (1) S ×U (1) J3 . In the following we construct two canonical sets of complex coordinates on Z, adapted to two different Heisenberg algebras, and relate them to the coordinates U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ on the base and the stereographic coordinate z on the sphere.10 10 Of course, these “coordinates on Z” really cover only an open dense subset; they become singular at the (canonically defined) north and south poles of the CP1 fibers.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
179
2.3.1. Harish-Chandra coordinates. The complex structure on Z can be constructed by using the Borel embedding H \G → PC \G C , where PC is the parabolic (Borel) subgroup of the complexified group G C , generated by the positive roots J 1 ,± 3 , J+ and 2 2 Cartan generators J3 , S. To obtain complex coordinates from this embedding we go to the Cayley-rotated matrix representation (2.22), and perform a N¯ A N decomposition, ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ 1 ab 1 pk ⎠ · ⎝ 1 q⎠ . (2.33) CeZ C −1 = ⎝ p˜ 1 ⎠ · ⎝ 1/a 2 1 a/b k˜ q˜ 1 The entries p, q, k in the upper-triangular matrix by construction provide holomorphic coordinates on Z. The lower-triangular and diagonal matrices are then expressed in terms of p, q, k and their complex conjugates p, ¯ q, ¯ k¯ by requiring that (2.33) is an element of SU (2, 1) rather than of its complexification: ¯ ¯ k k¯ − p p¯ + 1 p¯ − kq ( p ¯ q ¯ − k) k¯ p − p¯ q¯ p + q¯ p˜ = √ , k˜ = , q˜ = , (2.34a) √ k k¯ − p p¯ + 1 1 1/4 , b= , 1/4 ¯ ¯ (k k − p p¯ + 1) (k k − p p¯ + 1)1/4 1/4
a=
(2.34b)
where = 1 + k k¯ − q q¯ − k¯ pq − k p¯ q¯ + p pq ¯ q. ¯
(2.35)
These coordinates are adapted to the holomorphic action of the Heisenberg algebra generated by J− 1 ,± 3 , J− , in the sense that 2
2
J− 1 , 3 = −2(∂q + p∂k ), 2 2
J− 1 ,− 3 = 2∂ p , 2
2
J− = −∂k .
(2.36)
It is useful to record the action of the other generators in the compact basis, i 3i ( p∂ p + q∂q + 2k∂k ), S = ( p∂ p − q∂q ), 2 2 2 J+ = −kp∂ p − (k − pq)q∂q − k ∂k , J3 =
J 1 , 3 = −2 p ∂ p − 2(k − pq)∂q − 2kp∂k ,
(2.37a) (2.37b)
J 1 ,− 3 = −2k∂ p + 2q ∂q .
2
2
2 2
2
2
(2.37c)
A G-invariant metric on Z can be constructed in the usual way, by applying an L-invari−1 . In contrast to the case ant quadratic form on g to the g-valued 1-form θ = deZ · eZ of K \G, this quadratic form is not unique up to scalar multiple, but has parameters (α, β, γ ) ∈ R3 : 2 dsZ = α J + J − + β J 1 , 3 J − 1 ,− 3 + γ J 1 ,− 3 J − 1 , 3 . 2 2
2
2
2
2
(2.38)
2 2
These parameters can be fixed by requiring that the resulting metric on Z is EinsteinKähler. In particular, the Kähler potential must be proportional to the volume element. This uniquely fixes α = −2, β = γ = 4 (up to rescalings) and gives the Kähler potential 1 ¯ + |k − pq|2 − q q) K Z = log (1 + k k¯ − p p)(1 ¯ . (2.39) 2 This reproduces Eq. 7.28 in [45] upon identifying k = ζ /2, p = v, q = −u. Under the action of J 1 , 3 + J− 1 ,− 3 , J 1 ,− 3 + J− 1 , 3 , J+ + J− , K Z transforms by a Kähler 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 transformation K Z → K Z + f + f¯, with f proportional to p, q, k − 1 pq, respectively. 2
180
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
2.3.2. Iwasawa coordinates. We now exhibit the twistor space Z as an S 2 fibration over K \G, such that the S 2 fiber over any point on the base is holomorphically embedded in Z. For this purpose, we recall that the complex structure on S 2 = U (1)\SU (2) can be constructed using the Borel embedding U (1)\SU (2) → BC \S L(2, C). Here S L(2, C) ⊂ G C is generated by J+ , J3 , J− and BC is the Borel subgroup generated by J+ , J3 . The embedding is simply obtained by starting with a coset representative e ∈ U (1)\SU (2) and viewing it instead as a representative in BC \S L(2, C) (this is consistent since BC ∩ SU (2) = U (1).) The same class in BC \S L(2, C) is also represented by exp z J− for some z ∈ C (with one exception corresponding to z = ∞), giving the desired complex coordinate. Now we use the same idea for Z. So we return to the original matrix representation (2.2), and parameterize Z by the coset representative eZ = e−¯z J+ (1 + z z¯ )−i J3 e−z J− e Q K √ ⎛1 √z 2 (1 + 1 + z z¯ ) 2 1 ⎜ 1 − √1 z¯ = √ ⎝ 2 √ 1 + z z¯ 1 √z 2 (1 − 1 + z z¯ ) 2
√ ⎞ 1 + z z¯ ) ⎟ − √1 z¯ ⎠ · eQ K , 2 √ 1 2 (1 + 1 + z z¯ )
(2.40)
1 2 (1 −
(2.41)
where e Q K is a representative for K \G in the Iwasawa decomposition (2.24). The coordinate z is then a stereographic coordinate on the S 2 fiber over each point of K \G. By Cayley rotating (2.40) and performing the Harish-Chandra decomposition (2.33), we can now relate the complex coordinates p, q, k and their complex conjugates to the coordinates U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ on the base and the coordinate z on the fiber: 4
p=
− 1, √ 2 + 2iσ − ζ˜ 2 + 2i 2eU z(ζ + i ζ˜ ) √ 2 2eU (iζ + ζ˜ ) − ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 + 2iσ + 2 − 2e2U z , q= √ 2i 2z(ζ + i ζ˜ ) + 4eU √ 2 2eU z + 2(iζ + ζ˜ ) k= . √ 2 + 2iσ + 2e2U − ζ 2 − ζ˜ 2 + 2i 2eU z(ζ + i ζ˜ ) + 2e2U
− ζ2
(2.42a)
(2.42b)
(2.42c)
Rather than obtaining the metric on Z in the coordinates U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ, z, z¯ from the Kähler potential (2.39) by following the change of variables, we can simply decompose the −1 invariant form θZ = deZ eZ and plug into (2.38) using the values of α, β, γ that were determined above. The components of θZ along (U (1) × U (1))\SU (2, 1) read
J−1,3 J 1,3 1 u + zv v − z¯ u 2 2 2 2 , (2.43a) =− √ J − 1 ,− 3 J 1 ,− 3 2 1 + z z¯ v¯ − z u¯ u¯ + z¯ v¯ 2 2 2 2 J+ = −
1 1 + z z¯
J− = −
1 1 + z z¯
1 D z¯ d z¯ + u¯ − z¯ (v − v) ¯ + z¯ 2 u ≡ − , 2 1 + z z¯
1 dz + u + z(v − v) ¯ + z 2 u¯ 2
≡−
Dz , 1 + z z¯
(2.43b)
(2.43c)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
181
leading to the Kähler-Einstein metric 2 dsZ = |u|2 + |v|2 − 2
Dz D z¯ (1 + z z¯ )2
(2.44)
with signature (4, 2). The connection term in Dz is the projective SU (2) connection 1 1 Dz = dz − (A1 + i A2 ) + i A3 z − (A1 − i A2 )z 2 2 2 1 2 ¯ + z u, = dz + u + z(v − v) ¯ 2
(2.45)
where ¯ A1 = −(u + u),
A2 = i(u − u), ¯
A3 =
v − v¯ 2i
(2.46)
are the components of the SU (2) spin connection computed in (2.27). A basis of holomorphic (1,0) forms providing a holomorphic viel-bein of Z is given by the components of θZ with negative weight under J3 , √ 1 2Dz, u + zv, v¯ − z u¯ . (2.47) V=√ 1 + z z¯ The Kähler form can be written as ωZ = −
Dz D z¯ + i x a ωa , (1 + z z¯ )2
(2.48)
where x a is the unit length vector with stereographic coordinate z, x1 =
z + z¯ i(z − z¯ ) 1 − z z¯ , x2 = , x3 = , 1 + z z¯ 1 + z z¯ 1 + z z¯
(2.49)
and ωa are the quaternionic 2-forms on the base, ω1 =
1 1 1 (u v¯ − uv), ¯ ω2 = (u v¯ + uv), ¯ ω3 = (u u¯ − v v). ¯ 2i 2 2i
(2.50)
It may be checked that this triplet of 2-forms satisfies the constraints from quaternionic-Kähler geometry, dωi + i jk A j ∧ ωk = 0, d Ai + i jk A j ∧ Ak = 2ωi .
(2.51)
2.3.3. Complex c-map coordinates. While the complex coordinates p, q, k are adapted to the action of the generators J− 1 , 3 , J− 1 ,− 3 , J− , in the sequel it will be useful to 2 2 2 2 have complex coordinates ξ, ξ˜ , α adapted to the “non-compact” Heisenberg algebra E p , E q , E, i.e. such that the action of these generators takes the canonical form11 E p = ∂ξ˜ + ξ ∂α ,
E q = −∂ξ + ξ˜ ∂α ,
E = −∂α .
(2.52)
11 Since G acts holomorphically, we have abused notation by writing only the holomorphic part; the real vector fields would be obtained by adding the complex conjugates, in (2.52) and below.
182
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
The change of variables can be found by diagonalizing the action of these generators in the p, q, k variables, leading to i k 2 − ( p + 1)qk + p + 1 −k 2 + ( p + 1)qk + p + 1 ξ = √ , ξ˜ = √ , 2( p + 1)(−k + pq + q) 2( p + 1)(−k + pq + q) i(q + kp − p 2 q) α= ( p + 1)(k − pq − q)
(2.53a) (2.53b)
or, conversely, √ i ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 + 2iα + 2 ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 − 2iα + 2 2i 2(ξ − i ξ˜ ) , q= . p=− , k=− √ ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 − 2iα − 2 ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 − 2iα − 2 2 2(ξ + i ξ˜ ) (2.54) The full action of G is then given by E QC = −∂α ,
E p QC = ∂ξ˜ + ξ ∂α ,
E q QC = −∂ξ + ξ˜ ∂α ,
H QC = −ξ˜ ∂ξ˜ − ξ ∂ξ − 2α∂α ,
(2.55b)
F p QC
(2.55c)
Fq QC F QC
J QC = −ξ˜ ∂ξ + ξ ∂ξ˜ , 1 1 2 ξ(ξ˜ + ξ 2 ) + 2α ξ˜ ∂α , = (3ξ 2 − ξ˜ 2 )∂ξ˜ + (α − 2ξ˜ ξ )∂ξ − 2 2 1 1 2 ξ˜ (ξ˜ + ξ 2 ) − 2α ξ˜ ∂α , = − (3ξ˜ 2 − ξ 2 )∂ξ + (α + 2ξ˜ ξ )∂ξ˜ − 2 2 1 2 1 ξ(ξ˜ + ξ 2 ) + 2α ξ˜ ∂ξ˜ − = ξ˜ (ξ˜ 2 + ξ 2 ) − 2αξ ∂ξ 2 2 1 2 2 2 2 ˜ − (ξ + ξ ) − 4α ∂α . 4
(2.55a)
(2.55d)
(2.55e)
In the new coordinate system ξ, ξ˜ , α, the Kähler potential (2.39) (after a Kähler transformation by f = ( p + 1)(k − q − pq)) is KZ =
2 1 1 log N4 = log (ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 + 4(α − α¯ + ξ ξ¯˜ − ξ¯ ξ˜ )2 . (2.56) 2 2
¯˜ α) Here we note that N4 (ξ, ξ˜ , α; ξ¯ , ξ, ¯ is the quartic distance function of quasi-conformal geometry. Since G acts by isometries on Z, it leaves the Kähler potential (2.56) invari¯˜ α) ant up to Kähler transformations. Equivalently, the quartic norm N4 (ξ, ξ˜ , α; ξ¯ , ξ, ¯ ¯ ˜ α), defined by (2.56) transforms multiplicatively by a factor f (ξ, ξ˜ , α) f¯(ξ¯ , ξ, ¯ where the holomorphic function f depends on the generator under consideration. In particular, the “quartic light-cone” N4 = 0 is invariant under the full action of SU (2, 1), which motivated the appellation “quasi-conformal action” in [25]. Such a coordinate system adapted to the holomorphic action of a Heisenberg group exists for any c-map space and was used heavily in [36]. Moreover, the result (2.56) agrees with a general formula for the Kähler potential given there.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
183
2.3.4. Twistor map. Combining the changes of variables (2.42) and (2.53), we find that the complex coordinates (ξ, ξ˜ , α) are expressed in terms of the Iwasawa coordinates U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ, z, z¯ as i 1 ξ = ζ − √ eU z + z −1 , ξ˜ = ζ˜ + √ eU z − z −1 , (2.57a) 2 2 1 (2.57b) α = σ + √ eU z(ζ + i ζ˜ ) + z −1 (−ζ + i ζ˜ ) . 2 Again (ξ, ξ˜ , α) is a holomorphic (rational) function of z, at fixed values of U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ , so that the twistor fiber over any point is a rational curve in Z. Conversely, e2U = −
N4 8[(ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 ]
,
(2.58a)
2 2(α − α)( ¯ ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ ) + (ξ − ξ¯ ) ξ 2 − ξ¯ 2 + ξ˜ 2 − ξ¯˜ ζ =
ζ˜ =
σ =
2[(ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 ]
,
(2.58b)
,
(2.58c)
2 ¯ ¯ 2 2 2 ¯ ˜ ¯ ˜ ˜ ˜ 2(α¯ − α)(ξ − ξ ) + (ξ − ξ ) ξ − ξ + ξ − ξ 2[(ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 ]
α + α¯ − 2
2 ¯ ¯ 2 2 2 ˜ ¯ ˜ ¯ ˜ ˜ (α − α¯ + ξ ξ − ξ ξ ) ξ − ξ + ξ − ξ 2[(ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 ]
,
(2.58d)
ξ − ξ¯ − i(ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ ) (ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 − 2i(α − α¯ + ξ ξ¯˜ − ξ¯ ξ˜ ) z= × . ¯ ¯ ˜ ˜ ξ − ξ + i(ξ − ξ ) (ξ − ξ¯ )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ¯˜ )2 + 2i(α − α¯ + ξ ξ¯˜ − ξ¯ ξ˜ ) (2.58e) These formulae are in agreement with the general results in [36]. 2.3.5. Swann space. The twistor space Z admits an important complex line bundle O(2), which can be constructed in two different ways. On the one hand, one may use Z = H \G, and obtain O(2) by induction from H with character exp i J3 – in other words, a section of O(2) is a function on G which transforms under H by this character.12 This definition makes it clear that O(2) admits a Hermitian structure. On the other hand, one may construct O(2) using the Borel embedding Z → PC \G C , and define O(2) as the pullback to Z of the line bundle determined by the character exp H of PC . This second definition makes it clear that O(2) is a holomorphic line bundle; it is 12 By definition, the character “exp i J ” takes the value exp i J on exp(J J + SS) ∈ H ; we will use 3 3 3 3 this notation for characters frequently, always implicitly with respect to some basis of the corresponding Lie algebra.
184
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
what we will use in the discussion of quaternionic discrete series below. More generally, m define O(m) = O(2)⊗ 2 for m even; this is similarly a Hermitian holomorphic line bundle over Z. The Swann space S, also known as the hyperkähler cone over K \G, is the total space of O(−2) over Z; locally it could be parameterized by complex coordinates on Z plus one additional coordinate in the fiber of O(−2). It is naturally a hyperkähler manifold, with an SU (2) isometry rotating the complex structures into one another [46,45]. The circle in the unit circle bundle of O(−2) “cancels against” the U (1) in the denominator of (2.32). So this circle bundle is the homogeneous 3-Sasakian space U (1)\SU (2, 1), which can be parameterized by the coset representative e3S = eiφ J3 eZ .
(2.59)
S is then a real cone over this homogeneous space, S = R+ × U (1)\SU (2, 1).
(2.60)
−1 The right-invariant form θ3S = de3S e3S has J3 component J 3 = Dφ, where
i 1 z¯ dz − zd z¯ + 2(¯z u − z u) ¯ + (v − v)(z ¯ z¯ − 1) (2.61a) 1 + z z¯ 2 i = dφ + (2.61b) (¯z dz − zd z¯ ) + xa Aa , 1 + z z¯
Dφ = dφ +
while the other components are identical to those of θZ except for a rotation under U (1) J3 . The metric of the 3-Sasakian space is obtained by adding α J3 2 to (2.38), so as to enforce SU (2) (left) invariance. The metric on S is therefore 2 dsS2 = − dr 2 + r 2 Dφ 2 − dsZ , (2.62) with indefinite signature (4,4).
2.4. Quasi-conformal representations. 2.4.1. Principal series. An interesting family of “principal series” representations of G are obtained by induction from the parabolic subgroup P generated by {F, F p , Fq , H, J }, using the character χk = e−k H /2 of P for some k ∈ C. We now briefly recall the definition of induction, which we will use many times in this paper; see e.g. [47] for more details. The representation space of the induced representation consists of functions f on G which obey f (gp) = χk ( p) f (g). (2.63) These functions can also be thought of as representing sections of a homogeneous line bundle over P\G defined by the character χk . We represent them concretely by choosing specific representatives of P\G; a simple choice is to use elements of the opposite nilpotent radical N¯ generated by E p , E q , E, i.e. upper-triangular matrices.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
185
So to compute concretely the action of some E ∈ g, we act on the upper-triangular matrix ⎛ ⎞ 1 ζ˜ + iζ iσ − 21 (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) ⎝ ⎠ (2.64) 1 −ζ˜ + iζ 1 by E and then act from the left by a suitable X ∈ p to put the result back in upper triangular form. This gives a differential operator acting on (ζ, ζ˜ , σ ), to which we must add χk (X ) reflecting the twist by (2.63). The result is E QC = −∂σ , H
QC
F p QC Fq QC F QC
E p QC = ∂ζ˜ + ζ ∂σ ,
= −ζ˜ ∂ζ˜ − ζ ∂ζ − 2σ ∂σ − k,
E q QC = −∂ζ + ζ˜ ∂σ ,
(2.65a)
= −ζ˜ ∂ζ + ζ ∂ζ˜ , (2.65b) 1 1 ζ (ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 ) + 2σ ζ˜ ∂σ − k ζ˜ , = (3ζ 2 − ζ˜ 2 )∂ζ˜ + (σ − 2ζ˜ ζ )∂ζ − 2 2 (2.65c) 1 1 ζ˜ (ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 ) − 2σ ζ˜ ∂σ + kζ, = − (3ζ˜ 2 − ζ 2 )∂ζ + (σ + 2ζ˜ ζ )∂ζ˜ − 2 2 (2.65d) 1 2 1 ζ (ζ˜ + ζ 2 ) + 2σ ζ˜ ∂ζ˜ − ζ˜ (ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 ) − 2σ ζ ∂ζ = (2.65e) 2 2 1 − (ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 )2 − 4σ 2 ∂σ + kσ. 4 J
QC
The quadratic and cubic Casimirs are constants, C2 = −k(4 − k)/4, C3 = 0
(2.66)
corresponding to p = q = (k − 4)/2. If we choose k = 2 + is for s ∈ R, then this representation is infinitesimally unitary with respect to the L 2 inner product with measure dζ d ζ˜ dσ . 2.4.2. Quaternionic discrete series. In the last subsection we constructed the principal series representations using the action of G on appropriate sections of line bundles over P\G. There is a complex-analytic analogue of this construction, known as the quaternionic discrete series, which uses instead the action of G on the sheaf cohomology group H 1 (Z, O(−k)) [26], where O(−k) is the line bundle over Z defined in Sect. 2.3.5. Formally, the generators are obtained from (2.65) by replacing the real variables ζ, ζ˜ , σ on P\G by complex variables ξ, ξ˜ , α on PC \G C . For k = 0, they reduce to the holomorphic vector fields given in (2.55). The holomorphic functions f (ξ, ξ˜ , α) acted upon by these generators are to be interpreted as Cech representatives13 for classes in H 1 (Z, O(−k)) with respect to coverings by two open sets, in the spirit of the early literature on twistor theory. The resulting representation is formally unitary with respect to the inner product ¯˜ α) f1 | f2 = dξ d ξ˜ dα d ξ¯ d ξ¯˜ d α¯ e(k−4)K Z f 1∗ (ξ¯ , ξ, ¯ f 2 (ξ, ξ˜ , α). (2.67) Z
13 It is not obvious that one obtains all classes in H 1 (Z, O(−k)) in this way, but in most of our considerations we restrict ourselves to these, and indeed we simply write f ∈ H 1 (Z, O(−k)), where f is a section with singularities.
186
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Indeed, the invariant volume form on Z is e−4K Z |dξ d ξ˜ dα|2 (more generally −4 in the exponent would be replaced by −2d − 2, where d is the dimension of K \G) while the factor ek K Z comes from the Hermitian norm in O(−k) [36]. The formal inner product (2.67) however has to be interpreted with care, since f 1 and f 2 , being Cech representatives, are only well defined up to certain shifts by holomorphic functions; in order to get a well defined inner product, one must interpret (2.67) in a way that involves only contour integrals. Here we give only a formal heuristic account, which will be adequate for our purposes in Sect. 2.4.5. ¯ obtained by conWe begin by analytically continuing K Z to a function on Z × Z, sidering the holomorphic and antiholomorphic dependence independently. Then for any ¯ O(k ¯ − 4)) by f 1 ∈ H 1 (Z, O(−k)) we define fˆ1 ∈ H 1 (Z, ˆf 1 = dξ d ξ˜ dα e(k−4)K Z f 1 , (2.68) ¯ This construction is an anawhere the integral runs over some contour in Z × Z. logue of the “twistor transform” discussed in e.g. [48] for the case Z = CP3 . In [48] it is argued that this transform is involutive, fˆˆ = f ; we assume (and will make use of this fact in Sect. 2.4.5) that the same is true here.14 Complex conjugation gives f¯ˆ1 ∈ H 1 (Z, O(k − 4)), which can be paired with f 2 ∈ H 1 (Z, O(−k)) and contourintegrated, so that f | f = dξ d ξ˜ dα f¯ˆ f . (2.69) 1
2
1 2
This interpretation of (2.67) is still formal, since we did not specify the contours of integration. In the example we consider below there will be a natural choice. In general, however, it is difficult to make sense of this formal prescription, much less to check that it is positive definite; one instead checks the existence of a positive definite norm by a purely algebraic computation on a special basis of “elementary states” (in our context, these are the K -finite vectors). We do not perform such an analysis here, but rely on the results of [26]. There one finds that for k ≥ 2 the spaces H 1 (Z, O(−k)) are irreducible and unitarizable representations of G. For k ≥ 3 they belong to the discrete series and are called quaternionic discrete series representations. The representation at k = 2 is a limit of the quaternionic discrete series. 2.4.3. Quaternionic discrete series as subquotients of principal series. These quaternionic discrete series representations are expected to be obtained as subquotients of the principal series which we discussed above. To understand how this happens, we recall the simpler case of the unitary representations of S L(2, R). There the continuous principal series is realized in a space of sections of a line bundle Lk (k ∈ C) over the equator of CP1 = B+ \S L(2, C). If k ∈ Z, then Lk extends holomorphically over the whole of CP1 . The holomorphic and antiholomorphic discrete series are then obtained by restricting to sections which admit an analytic continuation from the equator over respectively the northern or southern hemisphere, and dividing out by the space of sections which can be continued over the whole of CP1 . 14 This is an analogue of the fact that on a Hermitian symmetric space the Kähler potential behaves as a reproducing kernel for holomorphic functions.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
187
In the quaternionic case the situation is similar. Firstly, the space P\G occurs as part of the boundary of Z in an appropriate sense; in terms of our coordinates (ξ, ξ˜ , α) on Z, this boundary is the locus where all coordinates become real (then they are identified with our coordinates on P\G by ξ → ζ , ξ˜ → ζ˜ , α → σ .) So for discrete values of k, one might expect to obtain a submodule of the principal series representation by considering those sections which are boundary values of holomorphic objects on Z, and then obtain a unitary representation as some quotient thereof.15 We will see this expectation realized in the algebraic discussion of the next subsection. 2.4.4. K -type decomposition. We now discuss the decomposition of the principal series representation under the maximal compact subgroup K = SU (2) × U (1), which we recall is generated by J± , J3 and S. We begin by constructing the spherical vector, invariant under K . For this purpose consider the action of K from the right on our coset representative for P\G, ⎛ ⎞ 1 ζ˜ + iζ iσ − 21 (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) ⎠. n=⎝ (2.70) 1 −ζ˜ + iζ 1 K acts on the three rows vi , preserving their Hermitian norms vi 2 . On the other hand, the action of P from the left mixes the rows. Since P is lower-triangular, though, its action on the top row is simple: it just acts by the character e H +i J /3 . Now consider the function −k/2
1 2 −k/2 2 2 2 2 2 ˜ ˜ = 1 + ζ + ζ + σ + (ζ + ζ ) (2.71) f K = v1
4 as an element in the principal series representation. By definition, to compute the action of k ∈ K on f K , we first transform n by k acting from the right, then act by a compensating element p ∈ P from the left to restore the form (2.70). This modifies (2.71) by a factor e−k H ( p)/2 . However, we also have to include the explicit factor ek H ( p)/2 from the definition of the principal series. So altogether we find that (2.71) is K -invariant. More generally, the highest weight vectors of SU (2) J (vectors annihilated by J+ ) are given by
f j,s
j− 1 s
1 + iσ − 21 (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) = 1 + iσ + 21 (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) 1 − iσ + 21 (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) −k/2 1 × 1 + ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 + σ 2 + (ζ˜ 2 + ζ 2 )2 4 ζ˜ + iζ
3
j+ 1 s 3
(2.72)
with eigenvalues ji and si for J3 and S, respectively. In Sect. 2.6.1 below, we shall see that these states have a simple expression in terms of the moment maps of the action of G on the symplectization of P\G. For now, we 15 The notion of “boundary value” in this case is somewhat subtler than it was in the case of S L(2, R), because on Z we deal not with functions but with cohomology classes. The reason is that the structure of Z near the boundary is more complicated than that of the upper half-plane; it is not contained in any convex tube domain, essentially because of the circle parameterized by the phase of z, which winds around the boundary. The correct notion of boundary value in this case should involve integration over this circle, as described in e.g. [49].
188
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
S
6
4−k k+8
k+6 10−k k 9/2
4−k k+6
k+4 8−k
k
6−k
10−k k+2
3 k+2
4−k k+4
6−k
k
6−k k+6 8−k k+2
10−k
6−k k+4
8−k
3/2 4−k k+2
k 4−k
k
4−k
k
6−k k+2
0
1
k
8−k k+4
2 6−k k+2 8−k k+4 k+2 6−k k+4
3
J
−3/2
Fig. 2. Structure of the module generated by the highest weights f j,s . The solid (resp. dotted) arrows denote the action of the raising (resp. lowering) operators, with coefficient proportional to the indicated function of k
observe that the highest weight states f j,s are mapped to each other by the action of the raising operators J 1 ,± 3 : 2
2
1 (3k + 6 j + 2s) f j+ 1 ,s+ 3 , 2 2 3√ 2 2 (3k + 6 j − 2s) f j+ 1 ,s− 3 . = 2 2 3
J 1 , 3 · f j,s = 2 2
J 1 ,− 3 · f j,s 2
2
(2.73)
Applying the lowering operators J− 1 ,± 3 gives a linear combination of the highest weight 2 2 state f j− 1 ,s± 3 and a descendant of f j+ 1 ,s± 3 : 2
2
2
2
(3 j − s)(6 + 6 j − 3k − 2s) 3k + 6 j + 2s J−1 · f j+ 1 ,s+ 3 , f j− 1 ,s+ 3 + √ 2 2 2 2 3(2 j + 1) 18 2(2 j + 1) √ (3 j +s)(6+6 j −3k +2s) 3k + 6 j − 2s f j−1 ,s−3 + 2 2 J−1 · f j+ 1 ,s− 3 . = 2 2 2 2 9(2 j +1) 3(2 j + 1) (2.74)
J− 1 , 3 · f j,s = 2 2
J− 1 ,−3 · f j,s 2
2
Using these equations, we may now study the structure of the module generated by f j,s and its descendants; it is pictured in Fig. 2. For generic k this module is irreducible and not manifestly unitarizable. When k is an integer, the situation is more interesting. For even integers k ≥ 2, there is an irreducible submodule generated by f j=(k−2)/2,s=0 . Its K -type decomposition coincides with that of the representation labeled by p = q = (k − 4)/2 in the parameterization of [6], namely, ∞
3m/2
m=k−2 s=−3m/2
[ j = m/2]s .
(2.75)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
189
We identify it as the quaternionic discrete series with index k (or limit discrete series for k = 2) [26]; in particular, it is unitarizable. It has no spherical vector unless k = 2. For (possibly negative) even integers k ≤ 2, we can similarly obtain the representation with p = q = −k/2, this time as a quotient instead of a submodule; namely, we divide out the submodule consisting of all states with 3 j − |s| < 3(k − 2)/2. The resulting representations are equivalent to the ones just discussed. In [26] one also finds quaternionic discrete series representations for odd k; one might wonder why we did not encounter those above. The answer is that strictly speaking they are not representations of G = SU (2, 1) but rather of its double cover. Correspondingly, they do not appear as subrepresentations of the principal series we considered here, but of a closely related “non-spherical principal series” representation of the double cover. 2.4.5. Matrix elements and Penrose transform. Suppose ρ is a spherical unitary representation of G, with spherical vector f K . Then ρ can be realized in the space of functions on K \G, by mapping any state f to the matrix element ϕ(e Q K ) = f |ρ(e−1 Q K ) f K .
(2.76)
ϕ is a function on K \G because the left action of k ∈ K on e Q K becomes a right action on e−1 Q K , hence a left action on f K , which is trivial because f K is spherical. Moreover, the ϕ so obtained obeys differential equations determined by ρ; in particular, it is an eigenfunction of the Laplacian on K \G with eigenvalue 2C2 (ρ). Even if ρ is not spherical one may still apply this construction replacing f K by any K -finite vector, and thus embed ρ into a space of sections of a homogeneous vector bundle over K \G, induced from the representation of K in which f K transforms. The sections so obtained have particularly good properties if f K is in the lowest K -type (e.g. for holomorphic discrete series representations they turn out to be holomorphic sections). We now apply this construction to the quaternionic discrete series representations, beginning with the special case k = 2. Using the Iwasawa decomposition (2.23) and the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula e A e B = e B e A e[A,B] when [A, B] is central, ˜
˜
−(σ −ζ ζ )E e−1 · eζ Eq · e−ζ E p · e−U H QK = e
(2.77)
and ˜
˜
−(σ −ξ ζ +ξ ζ )∂α · e−ζ ∂ξ · e ρ(e−1 QK ) = e
−ζ˜ ∂ξ˜
·e
U (∂U +ξ ∂ξ +ξ˜ ∂ξ˜ +2α∂α +k)
.
(2.78)
Applying this ρ(e−1 Q K ) to the spherical vector f K = f 0,0 yields
(U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ ; ξ, ξ˜ , α) = e2U + (ξ˜ − ζ˜ )2 + (ξ − ζ )2 2 −1 . −2U 2 1 2 2 ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ (σ +α+ ξ ζ −ξ ζ ) + (ξ − ζ ) +(ξ − ζ ) +e 4 (2.79) Since C2 (ρ) = −1, taking the inner product (2.76) between f and (2.79) yields an eigenfunction of the conformal Laplacian on K \G, Q K + 2 ϕ = 0. (2.80)
190
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Thus the transformed spherical vector (2.79) is the kernel for an integral operator which intertwines between the quaternionic discrete series and a subspace of the space of functions on K \G. In physics parlance, it is related to the boundary to bulk propagator for (2.80), upon taking the coordinates ξ , ξ˜ , α to be real — in that case they lie on a part of the boundary of Z, which may be identified with a boundary of K \G. (See [50] for an attempt to set up a bulk-boundary correspondence on this space.) Since K \G is a quaternionic-Kähler manifold there is an a priori different way to construct a function on K \G from f (ξ, ξ˜ , α) ∈ H 1 (Z, O(−2)), which is to apply the quaternionic Penrose transform [51,52]. Some details of this correspondence for quaternionic-Kähler spaces obtained by the c-map construction were worked out in [36], where a simple contour integral formula for the Penrose transform was established: Penrose[ f ] = ϕ(U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ ) = 2 e2U
dz f ξ(z), ξ˜ (z), α(z) . z
(2.81)
The resulting ϕ is annihilated by the conformal Laplacian Q K + 2. This agrees with (2.80) in the case of K \G, and in this context it can be checked directly by acting with Q K on the integrand of (2.81) and using (2.65):
2 z 1 2U z −1 f ξ(z), ξ˜ (z), α(z) = 0. (2.82) Q K + 2 − ∂z ∂z + z∂z + 2ie z∂α 2 2 Integration over z eliminates the total derivative, leading to (2.80). We now argue that these two constructions are in fact identical, i.e. f |ρ(e−1 Q K ) f K = Penrose[ f ]. According to our discussion of the inner product above, this is equivalent to dξ0 d ξ˜0 dα0 f = Penrose[ fˆ],
(2.83)
(2.84)
where = ρ(e−1 Q K ) f K ; then using (2.68) and the explicit form of K Z , (2.84) is equivalent to requiring that arises as the Penrose transform of 2 −1 1 (ξ, ξ˜ , α) = (α − α0 + ξ˜0 ξ − ξ˜ ξ0 )2 + (ξ − ξ0 )2 + (ξ˜ − ξ˜0 )2 . (2.85) 4 But this we can evaluate directly: the contour integral (2.81) defining Penrose[] has poles at z = z ± , where √ 2i 2eU (ζ − ξ0 ) − i(ζ˜ − ξ˜0 ) z+ = (2.86) 2i(σ − α0 + ξ˜0 ζ − ζ˜ ξ0 ) + (ζ − ξ0 )2 + (ζ˜ − ξ˜0 )2 − 2e2U and z − = −1/¯z + . The residue at z = z ± yields
= e2U + (ζ − ξ0 )2 + (ζ˜ − ξ˜0 )2 2 −1 (2.87) 1 (ζ − ξ0 )2 + (ζ − ξ0 )2 +e−2U (σ − σ0 + ξ˜0 ζ − ζ˜ ξ0 )2 + 4
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
191
which indeed agrees with the formula (2.79) for ρ(e−1 Q K ) f K as desired. Similar considerations apply for other even values of k. In that case the Penrose transform gives a section of Sym k−2 (H ); for c-map spaces, in a natural trivialization of H , the formula is given in [36] as dz 1 m ϕm (U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ ) = 2 ekU z 2 f ξ(z), ξ˜ (z), α(z) , (2.88) z where m = −k + 2, . . . , k − 2 labels the 2k − 3 components of ϕ. This turns out to agree with the matrix element construction, where we now use the (2k −3)-dimensional lowest K -type of the quaternionic discrete series. Establishing a similar correspondence for k odd would require a better understanding of the branch cuts appearing in the contour integral (2.81). 2.5. Minimal representation. For any real Lie group G there is a notion of “minimal unitary representation” introduced in [53] and much studied thereafter (see e.g. [28] for a recent review.) For many G the minimal representation can be characterized as the unitary representation of smallest Gelfand-Kirillov dimension. For G = SU (2, 1) the situation is somewhat degenerate and there are many representations sharing this minimal dimension, including the holomorphic and antiholomorphic discrete series 16 . We focus here on the representation constructed explicitly in [25] by truncation of the minimal unitary realization of E 8(8) and whose structure parallels that of the minimal representation of higher rank groups. With a slight change of notation and normalization relative to this reference, the generators can be written as i 3 E p = i xu, F p = i∂u ∂x + u − ∂u u∂u , (2.89a) 2x i E q = x∂u , Fq = u∂x + i∂ 3 − iu∂u u , (2.89b) 2x u 2 i i i E = x 2 , F = ∂x2 + 2 u 2 − ∂u2 − 1 , (2.89c) 2 2 8x i 2 1 ∂u − u 2 , (2.89d) H = x∂x + , J = 2 2 acting on functions of two variables (u, x). Equivalently, by defining y = x 2 and x0 = xu, we reach a presentation analogous to the one used in [39] for split groups,17 i x3 i i x0 ∂02 + 2i y∂0 ∂ y + 02 + ∂0 , 2 2y 2 2 3x 1 x0 , E q = y∂0 , Fq = − y∂03 + 2x0 ∂ y + 0 ∂0 + 2 2y 2y
x02 i i 1 2 E = y, H = x0 ∂0 + 2y∂ y + , J = y∂0 − , 2 2 2 y E p = i x0 ,
Fp =
F = 2i y∂ y2 − i
(2.90a) (2.90b) (2.90c)
x04 3i x02 2 i 4 i x0 3i ∂0 + ∂ − y∂ + i∂ y + 2i x0 ∂ y ∂0 + . + 3 8y 2y 4y 0 8 0 8y (2.90d)
16 In fact, this is true for the entire quaternionic family SU (n, 2). 17 The split real form of SU (2, 1) is S L(3, R).
192
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Any minimal representation is annihilated by the Joseph ideal in the universal enveloping algebra of g. This means that the generators of the minimal representations satisfy certain quadratic identities, e.g. H 2 + 2(E F + F E) + J 2 + 1 = 0, E 2p + E q2 + 4J E = 0, 1 1 C2 (J ) + S 2 + = 0. 9 4
(2.91a) (2.91b) (2.91c)
These hold in addition to the Casimir identities 3 C2 = − , C3 = 0, 4
(2.92)
corresponding to the parameters ( p, q) = (− 21 , − 21 ) in the classification of [6]. The generators (2.89) or (2.90) are antihermitian with respect to the inner product f 1 | f 2 = y −1 d y d x0 f 1∗ (y, x0 ) f 2 (y, x0 ) = d x du f 1∗ (u, x) f 2 (u, x), (2.93) so this representation is unitary. For later reference, we note that the (non-normalizable) states
x02 1 1 2 y 2 exp ± (2.94) = x exp ± u 2y 2 are invariant under the nilpotent radical N generated by F, F p , Fq , and carry charges (3/2, ±i/2) under the Cartan generators (H, J ). 2.5.1. Induction from the maximal parabolic and deformation. The minimal representation, in fact a one-parameter deformation thereof, can be obtained by induction from the maximal parabolic subgroup Q ⊂ G C generated by {F, F p , Fq , H, J, E p + i E q }. For this purpose, decompose any element of G C into a product ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ∗00 1 z ia g = ⎝ ∗ ∗ ∗⎠ · ⎝ 1 0 ⎠ . (2.95) ∗∗∗ 1 Then induction from the character exp[τ (H + i J /3)] of Q gives the action of G on sections f (z, a) over Q\G C by first order differential operators, E p = ∂z + i z∂a , F p = −(ia + z 2 )∂z − az∂a + τ z,
(2.96a)
E q = −i∂z − z∂a , Fq = −(a + i z )∂z − iaz∂a + iτ z,
(2.96b)
2
E = ∂a , F = −az∂z − a ∂a + τ a, τ H = −z∂z − 2a∂a + τ, J = −i z∂z + i . 3 2
(2.96c) (2.96d)
Set ν = −(2τ + 3)/3. Passing from f (z, a) to f (u, x) by the intertwining operator 1 2 1 2 2 i 2 f (z, a) = dud x x 1+4ν e− 2 u +iux z+ 4 x z + 2 ax f (u, x) (2.97)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
193
the action of G on f (u, x) is given by a one-parameter deformation18 of the minimal representation (2.89), E (ν) p = E p,
E q(ν) = E q ,
(ν)
Ek
= Ek ,
(2.98a)
5 i H (ν) = H + ν, J (ν) = J − ν, 2 2 i 1 (ν) F p = F p + ν (3u + 5∂u ), Fq(ν) = Fq + ν (5u + 3∂u ), 2x 2x 2i i 2 (ν) 2 F = F + ν 2 3∂u + 10x∂x + 3(1 − u ) + 2 ν(ν − 1) 4x x
(2.98b) (2.98c) (2.98d)
with Casimirs 3 2 (ν − 1), C3 = i ν(1 − ν 2 ), 4
(2.99)
1 1 ( p, q) = − (1 − 3ν), − (1 + 3ν) 2 2
(2.100)
C2 = corresponding to
in the notation of [6]. The resulting representation is not obviously unitary for ν = 0, as the inducing character exp[τ (H + i J /3)] is in general not unitary. We shall however find evidence in the next section that it is unitarizable at ν = ±1. The annihilator of the ν-deformed minimal representation is deformed to H 2 + 2(E F + F E) + J 2 − 2iν J + (1 − ν 2 ) = 0, E 2p + E q2 + 4J E + 2iν E = 0, 1 1 C2 (J ) + S 2 + 3iν S + (1 − ν 2 ) = 0, 9 4 while the vectors invariant under the nilpotent radical N are deformed to
x02 x02 1−ν 1−4ν y 2 exp − , y 2 exp , 2y 2y
(2.101a) (2.101b) (2.101c)
(2.102)
carrying charges ( 23 (1 + ν), − 2i (1 + ν)) and ( 23 (1 − ν), 2i (1 − ν)) under (H, J ), respectively. 2.5.2. K -type decomposition. For completeness, we now review the K -type decomposition of the minimal representation, i.e. the decomposition under the maximal compact subgroup SU (2) × U (1), as discussed in [25]. 19 For this purpose, we change polarization to oscillator representation for both the u and x variable, i.e. define au , au† , N by 1 √ (u − ∂u ) = au† , 2
1 √ (u + ∂u ) = au , 2
Nu = au† au ,
(2.103)
18 The fact that the minimal representation is not isolated is a peculiarity of the A series. 19 We should note that the positive and negative grade generators we define in this paper are opposite to
those of [25].
194
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
and similarly for x. The compact generator S is manifestly positive, 3 S= 2N x + 1 + x −2 Nu (Nu + 1) + 2Nu + 1 8
(2.104)
so the representation is of lowest-weight type. The positive grade generators in the 3-grading by S read √ 2 K + = au a x + (2.105a) (Nu + 1)au , x 1 1 (2.105b) L + = ax2 − 2 Nu (Nu + 1). 2 4x The only normalizable state annihilated by these two generators is ax† |0u,x , or, in the real polarization,
x02 1 2 1 2 1/2 f K = x exp − (u + x ) = y exp − y+ . (2.106) 2 2 y It is easy to check that this generator is a singlet of SU (2) J± ,J3 , but carries a non-zero charge −3i/2 under S. By acting with the raising operators K − and L − , we generate the complete K -type decomposition of the minimal representation, ∞ m m=0
2
− 3i2 (m+1)
,
(2.107)
where the term in the bracket is the spin of the SU (2) J representation, and the subscript indicates the S charge. This agrees with the K -type decomposition of the “ p-discrete” module at p = q = −1/2, as seen on Fig. 3, for k = 3. Let us now briefly discuss the ν-deformed minimal representation. It is easy to check that 1 f 0 = x 1−ν exp − (u 2 + x 2 ) (2.108) 2 is a singlet of SU (2) J , with charge − 3i2 (1 + ν) under S, and annihilated by the deformed generators K + , L + . Acting with deformed generators K − , L − produces a SU (2) J doublet with S3 = − 3i2 (2 + ν), 1 2 2 i 1 2 2 2−ν 2 exp − (u +x ) , f − 1 = √ (3+3ν −2y ) exp − (u +x ) . f 1 = −i u x 2 2 2 2 2 2 (2.109) For ν = −1, both of these states are annihilated by K + , L + , so generate a module corresponding to the semi-infinite line s = −3/2 j in the diagram on Fig. 3 for k = 4. Thus, the K -type decomposition of the ν-deformed minimal representation at ν = −1 has a ladder structure ∞ m m=1
2
− 3i2 m
.
(2.110)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2) y
y
k 2
y
k 3
4
4
4
2
2
2
j 1
2
1
2
j
4
3
1
-2
-2
-2
-4
-4
-4
y
k 4
j
4
3
195
y
k 5
k 6
2
y
4
4
3
k 8
7.5 4 5
2
2 2.5
j 1
2
j
j
4
3
1
2
3
4
2
5
4
6
8
-2.5 -2
-2
-5 -4 -7.5
-4
Fig. 3. K -type decomposition of the discrete series representations of SU (2, 1) in the ( j, y = 2/3s) plane, for low values of k = ( p − 4)/2 = (q − 4)/2. The quaternionic discrete series corresponds to the “ p + q discrete branch” in the terminology of [6]. The “ p-discrete” branch for k = 3 corresponds to the minimal representation, see Sect. 2.5.2. The second “ p-discrete branch” for k = 4, starting at ( j, s) = (1/2, ±3/2), corresponds to the deformed minimal representation at ν = ±1. For k = 5 and higher odd values of k, there are no “ p-discrete” or “q-discrete” branches, as the lowering operators J 1 ,± 3 map into forbidden regions, as 2
illustrated by the open links
2
As usual, we can use the lowest K -type to embed the minimal representation into the space of sections of a vector bundle on K \G, in this case a line bundle with −3/2 units of charge under S. For this purpose, as in (2.76), we let the coset representative e Q K act on the lowest K -type, and construct the intertwiner ˜
˜
(U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ ; u, x) = eU (x∂x + 2 ) · e−i ζ ux · eζ x∂u · e− 2 (σ −ζ ζ )x 1 1 3U − u 2 − (e2U + iσ )x 2 − = x exp 2 2 2 1
i
2
· f SU (2) (2.111) 1 ˜ x(2u + xζ )(ζ + i ζ ) . 2
The overlap f =
d x du f ∗ (u, x) (U, ζ, ζ˜ , σ ; u, x)
(2.112)
is then an eigenmode of the Laplacian twisted by S, Q K
1 2U 15 f = 0. − e ∂σ − 2 16
(2.113)
196
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
2.5.3. As a submodule of the principal series representation. In this section, we investigate to what extent the minimal representation (or its ν-deformation) may be viewed as a submodule of the principal series representation. To that purpose, we first observe that the Casimirs (2.99) and (2.66) agree for k = 1, 3(ν = 0) or k = 0, 4 (ν = ±1). Second, Eq. (2.101b) in the annihilator of the deformed minimal representation, when expressed in terms of the generators of the quasi-conformal action, becomes C0 ≡ (∂ζ + ζ˜ ∂σ )2 + (∂ζ˜ − ζ ∂σ )2 − 2iν∂σ = 0.
(2.114)
The physicist will recognize C0 as the Hamiltonian of a charged particle on the plane (ζ, ζ˜ ), with a constant magnetic field proportional to i∂σ . The spectrum of C0 (for the usual L 2 norm on the plane) consists of the usual infinitely degenerate Landau levels. Defining ∇ = ∂ζ + ζ˜ ∂σ + i(∂ζ˜ − ζ ∂σ ),
(2.115a)
∇¯ = ∂ζ + ζ˜ ∂σ − i(∂ζ˜ − ζ ∂σ ),
(2.115b)
one may rewrite (2.114) as C0 = ∇ ∇¯ − 2i(ν + 1)∂σ = 0.
(2.116)
¯ This constraint The lowest Landau level corresponds to functions annihilated by ∇. commutes with the action of G for k = 0, ν = −1: this is evidently so for the positive root generators E p , E q , E (the former two being the generators of magnetic translations on the plane), and it suffices to check invariance under the action of the lowest root generator F,
i F, ∇¯ = − [3(ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 ) − 2iσ ]∇¯ − k(ζ˜ + iζ ), 2
(2.117)
which indeed vanishes on the subspace annihilated by ∇¯ when k = 0. Solutions to ∇¯ = 0 are of the form 20 i 2 2 ˜ ˜ ˜ f (ζ, ζ , σ ) = g z ≡ ζ + iζ, a ≡ −σ + (ζ + ζ ) . (2.118) 2 It is straightforward to check that the quasi-conformal action reduces on this invariant subspace to the action (2.96) induced from the maximal parabolic at ν = −1. As far as the constraint C0 = 0 itself is concerned, one may check that it is invariant under the action of G at the values k = 1, ν = 0 appropriate for the undeformed minimal representation, as well as at k = 0, ν = −1 which we discussed above. Indeed, one may rewrite [F, C0 ] = −2σ C0 + 2(1 − k) (ζ 2 + ζ˜ 2 )∂σ − J + 2iν(ζ ∂ζ + ζ˜ ∂ζ˜ + k), (2.119) which is proportional to C0 for k = 1, ν = 0. From the point of view of the magnetic problem, this corresponds to non-normalizable states with energy below that of the 20 After Fourier transforming over σ , one recovers the usual form f = g (ζ˜ + iζ ) e− 2 K (ζ 2 +ζ˜ 2 )−i K σ of K 1
the lowest Landau level wave functions.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
197
lowest Landau level. In order to find the eigenmodes explicitly, it is useful to Fourier transform over ζ˜ , σ , ˜ f (ζ, ζ , σ ) = dp d K exp −i K σ − i p ζ˜ g(ζ, p, K ), (2.120) and redefine (P − 2K ζ )2 g(ζ, p, K ) = exp − h(ζ, P, K ), 4K
(2.121)
where P = p + K ζ . The constraint C0 = 0 becomes now an ordinary differential equation on h, ∂ζ2 + 2(P − 2K ζ )∂ζ − 2K (ν + 1) h(ζ, P, K ) ≡ 0. (2.122) For ν = −1, the solutions are
P2 P − 2K ζ h(ζ, P, K ) = h 1 (P, K ) + h 2 (P, K ) K −1/2 e− 2K erfi − √ . (2.123) 2K
Only the ζ -independent part h 1 (P, K ) obeys also (2.101a). Changing variables again by setting K = x 2 /2 = y/2 and P = −xu = −x0 , it is easy to check that the quasiconformal action on f (ζ, ζ˜ , σ ) at k = 0 gives precisely the deformed minimal representation (2.98) acting on h 1 (P, K ) at ν = −1. We conclude that the deformed minimal representation at ν = −1 can be embedded inside the principal series representation at k = 0 by
( p − K ζ )2 h( p + K ζ, K ). (2.124) f (ζ, ζ˜ , σ ) = dp d K exp −i K σ − i p ζ˜ − 4K The formula (2.124) can also be viewed as the matrix element ˜
f (ζ, ζ˜ , σ ) = f P | e−σ E−ζ Eq +ζ E p | h,
(2.125)
where f P is the P-covariant vector in the deformed minimal representation (2.102). For ν = 1, similar arguments show that the deformed minimal representation can be embedded inside the principal series representation at k = 0 via
( p − K ζ )2 h( p + K ζ, K ). (2.126) f (ζ, ζ˜ , σ ) = dp d K exp −i K σ − i p ζ˜ + 4K For other values of ν, the solution of (2.122) involves Hermite and hypergeometric functions,
P − 2K ζ 1 + ν 1 (P − 2K ζ )2 h = h 1 (P, K ) H− ν+1 − √ . + h 2 (P, K ) 1F1 , ; 2 4 2 2K 2K (2.127) It is worth noting that the formula (2.124) admits a simple generalization to all quaternionic groups, as we shall see for G 2(2) in (3.137) below.
198
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
2.6. The minimal representation as a quantized quasi-conformal action.. We now explain how the minimal representation can be viewed as the quantization of the quasi-conformal action of G, or equivalently how the quaternionic discrete series arises as a semi-classical limit of the minimal representation. 2.6.1. Lifting the quasi-conformal action to the hyperkähler cone. As a first step, it is useful to “deprojectivize” the quasi-conformal action, i.e. lift it to an action on the hyperkähler cone S. For this purpose, we introduce an extra variable t and interpret the k-dependent quasi-conformal action as an action of functions of four variables fˆ(t, ξ, ξ˜ , α) = e−kt f (ξ, ξ˜ , α). We then implement the change of variables found in [36], v = e2t , v 0 = ξ e2t , w0 =
i 1 ξ˜ , w = (α + ξ ξ˜ ). 2 4i
(2.128)
The coordinates v , v 0 , w , w0 are complex coordinates on the Swann space S, such that the holomorphic symplectic form takes the Darboux form = dw ∧ dv + dw0 ∧ dv 0 .
(2.129)
The quasi-conformal action on O(−k) over Z now corresponds to the holomorphic action of G on S, restricted to the subspace of homogeneous functions of degree −k under the rescaling v I → µ2 v I , w I → w I .
(2.130)
Being tri-holomorphic isometries, the holomorphic vector fields generating the action of G preserve the holomorphic symplectic form . They can be represented by holomorphic moment maps X , such that the contraction ι X = d X : ! ! i i i (v 0 )2 E p = v 0 , E q = v w0 , E = − v , H = −2v w −v 0 w0 , J = −w02 − , 2 4 4 (v )2 ! ! ! ! !
i (v 0 )3 3(v 0 )2 w0 2 0 3 + 4(w ) v + 16v w w + 2v 0 w , Fp = 0 0 , F q = −2v (w0 ) + 2 4 (v ) 2v ! ! i 4 4 0 3 0 2 0 4 2 16 w (v . − 4w ) − 64v w w (v ) − 24(v w v ) + (v ) F= 0 0 0 16(v )3 ! (2.131) Returning to the variables t, ξ, ξ˜ , α, the holomorphic moment maps become, i i i i E p = e2t ξ, E q = e2t ξ˜ , E = − e2t , H = e2t α, 2 2 4 2 ! ! ! ! i 2t 2 i 2t 2 2 ξ(ξ + ξ˜ ) + 2α ξ˜ , F q = e ξ˜ (ξ + ξ˜ 2 ) − 2αξ , Fp = e 4 4 ! ! i 2t 2 i 2t 2 2 2 2 4α + (ξ + ξ˜ ) , J = e (ξ + ξ˜ 2 ). F= e 16 ! ! 4
(2.132)
Arranging these holomorphic moment maps into an element Q of g∗ , one may check that Q 2 = 0 in our matrix representation, i.e. that Q is valued in the minimal co-adjoint orbit.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
199
In particular, the holomorphic moment maps satisfy classical versions of the identities (2.91), H 2 + 4E F + J 2 = 0, E 2p + E q2 + 4J E = 0, ! !! ! ! ! !! 1 C 2 = C 3 = 0, C2 (J ) + S 2 = 0. ! ! 9! ! The holomorphic moment maps of the compact generators are given by
3i 2t 1 1 + ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 + α 2 + (ξ 2 + ξ˜ )2 , e S= 4 ! 16
i 2t 1 2 3 2 2 2 2 ˜ ˜ 1 − 3ξ − 3ξ + α + (ξ + ξ ) , e J3 = 16 4 ! i 2t ξ ∓ i ξ˜ ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 ± 2iα − 2 , J± = √ e ! 8 2 1 2t 2 J ± 1 ,± 3 = e (ξ + ξ˜ 2 )2 + 4α(α ± 2i) − 4 , 16 ! 2 2 i ξ 2 + ξ˜ 2 ± 2iα + 2 . J ± 1 ,∓ 3 = − √ e2t ξ ∓ i ξ˜ ! 2 2 8 2
(2.133a) (2.133b)
(2.134a) (2.134b) (2.134c) (2.134d) (2.134e)
It is interesting to note that the K -type (2.72) may be rewritten in terms of these moment maps, up to an overall numerical factor, as
1
1 J 1 , 3 j+ 3 s J 1 ,− 3 j− 3 s 1 2 2 2 2 ! f j,s = ! S− 2 k . (2.135) S S ! ! ! The covariance of (2.135) under K is then easy to see, using the identities (2.133) obeyed by the holomorphic moment maps, and the fact that G acts by Poisson brackets, X f = {X , f }. ! Moreover, the vanishing locus of the holomorphic moment maps associated to the compact generators S, J3 , J± consists of two branches ξ = ±i ξ˜ , α = ±i or equivalently, in terms of the variables on the hyperkähler cone,
(v 0 )2 1 v0 w = ± 1 − 2 , w0 = ± . 4 (v ) 2v
(2.136)
(2.137)
These relations define two lagrangian cones C± , with generating functions S± : they may be rewritten as
1 (v 0 )2 . (2.138) v + w = ∂v S± , w0 = ∂v 0 S± , S± (v , v 0 ) = ± 4 v By construction, C± are invariant under the holomorphic action of K , since the Poisson brackets with the constraints vanish on the constraint locus. As we shall see momentarily, S− describes the semi-classical limit of the lowest K -type (2.106) of the minimal representation.
200
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
2.6.2. The classical limit of the minimal representation. We now return to the presentation (2.90) of the minimal representation acting on functions of y, x0 . The form (2.106) of the spherical vector suggests that a semi-classical limit exists as y, x0 are scaled simultaneously to infinity, if one restricts to wave functions of the form ˆ xˆ0 ) + O(1), f (y, x0 ) = exp [S(y, x0 )] , S(y, x0 ) = y S(
(2.139)
where xˆ0 = x0 /y is kept fixed in the limit y → ∞. Indeed, it is easy to check that, to leading order in this limit, the action of the infinitesimal generators on f produces ˆ ∂ ˆ S, ˆ xˆ 0 f + O(y), X · f = y X S, 0 !
(2.140)
for some (so far unspecified) function X . Changing variables to ! ˆ p0 = ∂x0 S(y, x0 ) = ∂xˆ0 S,
ˆ p y = ∂ y S(y, x0 ) = Sˆ − xˆ0 ∂xˆ0 S,
(2.141)
identifies the function X (y, x0 , p y , p0 ) as the leading differential symbol of the differential operator X in the!semi-classical limit (2.139). Further setting v = −2y, v 0 = 2x0 , w =
1 1 p y , w0 = − p 0 , 2 2
(2.142)
identifies X as the holomorphic moment map (2.131) associated to the tri-holomorphic action of G!on its hyperkähler cone S. Thus, we conclude that the minimal representation can be viewed as the quantization of the holomorphic symplectic manifold S. Furthermore, the semi-classical limit of the spherical vector (2.106) is given by the generating function S− of the Lagrangian cone S− defined in (2.138). One could also have given a real version of this construction, lifting the action of G on P\G to a real symplectic manifold by adding a single real coordinate. In that case we would say that the minimal representation arises by quantizing the real symplectic structure. Indeed, the real manifold so obtained is at least locally isomorphic to the minimal coadjoint orbit of G, so this makes contact with one of the standard ways of thinking about the minimal representation.
3. G 2(2) In this section, we describe the geometry of the quaternionic-Kähler space S O(4)\G 2(2) , and various associated unitary representations of G = G 2(2) . We will be somewhat briefer in this section since many of the constructions are parallel to ones we described for G = SU (2, 1) above. 3.1. Some group theory. It is convenient to represent the Lie algebra g of G = G 2(2) by the 7-dimensional matrix representation described in [54] (after some relabelings and change of normalization)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
⎛ Y0 Y−
−Y + 0
⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ Y− ⎜ "0 ⎜ 2 ⎜− 2 E ⎜ " 3 q 1 √3 E p 1 ⎜ ⎜ 2F 2 ⎜ 3 p1 √3 F q1 ⎜ √ ⎜ ⎜ − 2E q0 √23 E q1 ⎝√ 2F p0 − √2 F p1 3
0 −Y +
" − 23 F q1 √2 F p 1 3 √ 2F p0
"
2 3 E p1 2 √ Eq 1 3
√ √ − 2F q0 2E p0 √2 F q √2 E p 1 − "3 1 "3 − 23 F p1 − 23 E q1
√ −Y 0 2E q0 √ 2E p0 H + 21 Y 0 −E − √1 Y + 0 2 √ 1 1 2F −F −H + 2 Y 0 0 −√ Y+ 2 " q0 − 23 E p1 √1 Y− 0 H − 21 Y 0 −E 2 " 2 √1 Y − − 3 F q1 0 −F − 21 Y 0 − H
201
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟≡ X i X i , ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
2
(3.1) where, as in (2.2), X i are real coordinates dual to the generators, to be represented by anti-hermitian operators in a given unitary representation. These matrices preserve the signature (4+ , 3− ) metric ηi j d xi d x j = −2d x1 d x3 + d x22 + 2d x4 d x7 − 2d x5 d x6 and the three-form d x123 − d x247 + d x256 +
√ √ 2d x167 + 2d x345 ,
(3.2)
(3.3)
thus providing an embedding of G 2(2) inside S O(3, 4). The generators satisfy the commutation relations consistent with the matrix representation (3.1), in particular the Heisenberg algebra E p I , E q J = −2δ JI E, (3.4) the S L(2, R) algebras (2.4) and [Y0 , Y± ] = ±Y± , [Y− , Y+ ] = Y0 .
(3.5)
The quadruplet (E p0 , E p1 , E q1 , E q0 ) transforms as a spin-3/2 representation under this Sl(2). The quadratic Casimir is 1 1 2 H + 2E F + 2F E + (Y02 − Y+ Y− − Y− Y+ ) C2 = 4 3 (3.6) 1 # + (E p I F p I + F p I E p I + E q I Fq I + Fq I E q I ), 4 I =0,1
normalized so that C2 (adjoint) = 4. There is also a degree 6 Casimir, corresponding to the trace of the sixth power of the matrix (3.1), which we shall not attempt to write. This basis is adapted to the maximal subgroup S L(2, R)short × S L(2, R)long , where the first factor is generated by {H, E, F} while the second is generated by {Y− , Y0 , Y+ }. The Cartan generators H, Y0 are non-compact, with spectrum Spec(Y0 ) = {0, ±1/2, ±1, ±3/2}, Spec(H ) = {0, ±1, ±2},
(3.7)
The non-compact generator H gives rise to the “real non-compact 5-grading” F|−2 ⊕ {F p I , Fq I }|−1 ⊕ {H, Y0 , Y± }|0 ⊕ {E p I , E q I }|1 ⊕ E|2 .
(3.8)
202
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Define a parabolic subgroup P = L N with Levi L = R × S L(2, R) generated by {H, Y0 , Y+ , Y− } and unipotent radical N generated by {Fq0 , Fq1 , F p0 , F p1 , F}, corresponding to the spaces with zero and negative grade in the decomposition (3.8). We call P the Heisenberg parabolic subgroup. Now we introduce a different basis adapted to the maximal compact subgroup SU (2) × SU (2). We first go to a compact basis for the S L(2, R) × S L(2, R) group: 1 L ± = − √ (E + F ± i H ) , 2 2 1 R0 = √ (Y+ + Y− ), 2 such that
1 (F − E), 2 √ 1 Y+ − Y− ∓ i 2Y0 , R± = 2
L0 =
L 0 , L ± = ±i L ± , R0 , R± = ±i R± ,
(3.9a) (3.9b)
[L + , L − ] = −i L 0 ,
(3.10a)
[R+ , R− ] = −i R0 .
(3.10b)
Moreover, we define the eigenmodes √ √ √ 2 K 1,3 = −(E p0 − i E q0 )−i 3(E p1 − i E q1 )+(F p0 −i Fq0 )+i 3(F p1 − i Fq1 ) , 2 2 4 √ √ 2 √ 3(E p0 + i E q0 ) + i(E p1 + i E q1 ) + 3(F p0 + i Fq0 ) + i(F p1 + i Fq1 ) , K 1,1 = 2 2 4 √ √ 2 √ 3(E p0 −i E q0 )−i(E p1 − i E q1 )− 3(F p0 −i Fq0 )+i(F p1 − i Fq1 ) , K 1 ,− 1 = 2 2 4 √ √ √ 2 −(E p0 +i E q0 )+i 3(E p1 +i E q1 )−(F p0 − i Fq0 )+i 3(F p1 + i Fq1 ) , K 1 ,− 3 = 2 2 4 (3.11) where the eigenvalues under (−i L 0 , −i R0 ) are indicated in subscript. Note that the hermiticity conditions are now L †± = −L ∓ ,
† R± = −R∓ ,
K −l0 ,−r0 = −K l†0 ,r0 .
(3.12)
The roots K ± 1 ,± 3 and K ± 1 ,∓ 1 are compact, as indicated on the diagram. The compact 2 2 2 2 Cartan generator L 0 gives rise to the “non-compact holomorphic 5-grading” L − |−2i ⊕ {K − 1 ,± 1 , K − 1 ,± 3 }|−i ⊕ {L 0 , R0 , R± }|0 ⊕ {K 1 ,± 1 , K 1 ,± 3 }|i ⊕ L + |2i . 2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
(3.13) Now, we perform a π/3 rotation of the root diagram, and define J3 =
1 1 1 (L 0 + R0 ) = (F − E) + √ (Y+ + Y− ) 2 4 2 2
(3.14a)
S3 =
1 1 3 (3L 0 − R0 ) = (F − E) − √ (Y+ + Y− ) 2 4 2 2
(3.14b)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
203
as the new Cartan algebra. The new eigenmodes are now J− =
1 K 1 3, 2 − 2 ,− 2
J 1 ,− 3 = K − 1 , 3 , 2
2
1 3 3 K 1 , 3 , S− = K − 1 , 1 , S+ = K 1 ,− 1 , 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 $ √ 2 R+ , J 1 , 1 = K 1 , 1 , (3.15) = 2 2L + J 1 ,− 1 = 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3
J+ = J1,3
2 2
2 2
together with their hermitian conjugates. They satisfy the SU (2) × SU (2) algebra,
J3 , J± = ±i J± , S3 , S± = ±i S± ,
[J+ , J− ] = 2i J3 ,
(3.16a)
[S+ , S− ] = 2i S3 .
(3.16b)
The subscript on J now denotes the eigenvalues under (−i J3 , −i S3 ). The matrix representation adapted to this√ “compact basis” is obtained from (3.1) by a Cayley rotation using the matrix C = e matrix representation ⎛
1 2 i(J 3
+ S3 )
⎜ ⎜ S− ⎜ " ⎜ ⎜ −2i 13 J 21 , 21 ⎜ " ⎜ ⎜−2i 23 J − 21 ,− 21 ⎜ ⎜ −2 J 1 3 ⎜ − 2 ,− 2 ⎜ ⎜ −J − ⎝ 0
π 2 4 (R+ +R− )
−S + 1 2 i(J 3
−2i
− S3 )
0 J−
"
1 3
−2J
−2J − 1 , 3 2 2 " −2 23 J − 1 , 1 2 2 " −2 13 J − 1 ,− 1 2
"
. The generators in the compact basis then have the
J 1 2
1 1 2 ,− 2
2i −2
,− 23
"
2 3
J
2 3
J
√
−i 2S −
−2
1 3
1 2
,− 21
⎞
−2 J 1 , 3 2 2 " −2 13 J 1 , 1 2
2
0 √
0
i 2S +
√
0 "
, 21
√ −i 2S +
i S3
2
1 2
J − 1 ,− 1 2
2
−2J − 1 ,− 3 2
2
i 2S − −i S 3 " 2 −2 3 J − 1 , 1 −2 J − 1 , 3 2 2 2 2 " " −2i 23 J − 1 ,− 1 −2i 13 J − 1 , 1 2
2
2
2
J+
0
0
−J +
−S −
− 21 i(J 3 + S 3 )
⎟ ⎟ ⎟ " ⎟ 1 ⎟ −2 3 J 1 , 1 −2 J 1 , 3 2 2 2 2 ⎟ " " ⎟ −2 23 J 1 ,− 1 2i 23 J 1 , 1 ⎟. 2 2 2 2 ⎟ " ⎟ −2 J 1 ,− 3 −2i 13 J 1 ,− 1 ⎟ 2 2 2 2 ⎟ ⎟ − 21 i(J 3 − S 3 ) S+ ⎠ (3.17)
The generator J3 gives rise to the “compact 5-grading” J− |−2i ⊕ {T− , R− , U− , L − }|−i ⊕ {J3 , S3 , S+ , S− }|0 ⊕ {T+ , R+ , U+ , L + }|i ⊕ J+ |2i , (3.18) where we denoted T+ = J 1 ,− 3 , U+ = J 1 , 1 . The various gradings we have described 2 2 2 2 may be seen in Fig. 4. We now consider the S L(3, R) and SU (2, 1) subalgebras of G 2(2) . The S L(3, R) subalgebra is generated by the long roots in the non-compact basis. Its quadratic Casimir reads 1 1 1 1 C2 [S L(3, R)] = H 2 + Y02 + (E p0 F p0 + F p0 E p0 + E q0 Fq0 + Fq0 E q0 )+ (E F + F E). 4 3 4 2 (3.19)
204
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Y0 Fq0
R0
+3/2
Ep0
Tp
Ep1
Sm
Yp
Rp
Fq1 −2
−1
+1
H
+2
F
E Fp1
Up
−i
−i/2
+i/2
Eq1
L0
+i
Lm
Lp Um
Ym Fp0
Jp
+3/2i
Sp Rm
−3/2
Eq0
Jm
−3i/2
Tm
Fig. 4. Root diagram of G 2(2) with respect to the split Cartan torus H, Y0 (left) and the compact Cartan torus L 0 , R0 (right). The compact (resp. non-compact) roots are indicated by a white (resp. black) dot. The long roots generate S L(3, R) (left) and SU (2, 1) (right) subgroups, respectively
The SU (2, 1) subalgebra is generated by the long roots in the compact basis. Its quadratic Casimir reads 1 C2 [SU (2, 1)] = − S32 − (J32 + J− J+ + J+ J− ) 3 (3.20) 1 1 + J 1 , 3 J− 1 ,− 3 + J− 1 ,− 3 J 1 , 3 + J− 1 , 3 J 1 ,− 3 + J 1 ,− 3 J− 1 , 3 . 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 8 2 2 2 2 8 3.2. Quaternionic symmetric space. The long SU (2) J± ,J3 endows K \G = (SU (2) × SU (2))\G 2(2) with a quaternionic-Kähler geometry. In order to describe its geometry, we perform the Iwasawa decomposition g = k · e Q K (slightly adapted from [55]) e Q K = τ2−Y0 · e
√
2τ1 Y+
· e−U H · e
−ζ 0 E q0 +ζ˜0 E p0
·e
√ √ − 3ζ 1 E q1 + 33 ζ˜1 E p1
· eσ E , (3.21)
where k is an element of the maximal compact subgroup. This decomposition defines coordinates (τ1 , τ2 , ζ 0 , ζ 1 , ζ˜0 , ζ˜1 , U, σ ) on K \G, where τ = τ1 + iτ2 is an element of the upper half-plane. The invariant g-valued one-form θ = de Q K · e−1 Q K may be expanded on the compact basis, leading to the quaternionic viel-bein ⎞ ⎛ ⎛ ⎞ J−1,3 J 1,3 u¯ v¯ 2 2 2 2 ⎜ J 1 1 J1 1 ⎟ ⎜ e¯ E¯ ⎟ ⎜ −2,2 2,2 ⎟ , (3.22) ⎟ = −⎝ ⎜J J E e⎠ ⎝ − 21 ,− 12 21 ,− 21 ⎠ v u J − 1 ,− 3 J 1 ,− 3 2
2
2
2
and the SU (2) × SU (2) spin connection ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ √ ⎛ u¯ √ E¯ J− S − √ 3⎝ ⎝ J 3 ⎠ = − 1 ⎝ i (v − v) ¯ + 43 (e + e) ¯ ⎠ , ⎝ S3 ⎠ = −i 43 (v− v)+ ¯ 41 (e + e) ¯ ⎠, 4 2 2 J+ S u E + (3.23)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
205
where e−U u = √ 3/2 d ζ˜0 + τ d ζ˜1 + 3τ 2 dζ 1 − τ 3 dζ 0 , 2 2 τ2 i v = dU − e−2U (dσ + ζ˜0 dζ 0 + ζ˜1 dζ 1 − ζ 0 d ζ˜0 − ζ 1 d ζ˜1 ), √ 2 3 e=− dτ, 2τ2 e−U E = − √ 3/2 3d ζ˜0 + d ζ˜1 (τ + 2τ¯ ) + 3τ¯ (2τ + τ¯ )dζ 1 − 3τ τ¯ 2 dζ 0 . 2 6 τ2
(3.24a) (3.24b) (3.24c) (3.24d)
This form of the vielbein agrees with that of the c-map space with prepotential F = −(X 1 )3 / X 0 [43], as expected. The metric is then ds 2 = 2 u u¯ + v v¯ + e e¯ + E E¯ . (3.25) The right action of G on K \G is given by the vector fields E = ∂σ , = ∂ζ˜0 − ζ0 ∂σ , E q0 = −∂ζ0 − ζ˜0 ∂σ ,
E p0 √ = 3(∂ζ˜1 − ζ1 ∂σ ),
1 E q1 = √ (−∂ζ 1 − ζ˜1 ∂σ ), 3 0 1 H = −∂U − 2σ ∂σ − ζ ∂ζ 0 − ζ ∂ζ 1 − ζ˜0 ∂ζ˜0 − ζ˜1 ∂ζ˜1 ,
E p1
(3.26a) (3.26b) (3.26c) (3.26d)
1 Y+ = √ (∂τ1 + ζ0 ∂ζ 1 − 6ζ 1 ∂ζ˜1 − ζ˜1 ∂ζ˜0 ), 2
(3.26e)
1 Y− = √ (6τ1 τ2 ∂τ2 + 3(τ12 − τ22 )∂τ1 + 9ζ˜0 ∂ζ˜1 − 9ζ 1 ∂ζ 0 + 2ζ˜1 ∂ζ 1 ). 3 2
(3.26f)
The other negative roots are too bulky to be displayed. 3.3. Twistor space. The twistor space Z = (SU (2) S± ,S3 × U (1) J3 )\G 2(2)
(3.27)
can be parameterized by the coset representative eZ = e−¯z J+ (1 + z z¯ )−i J3 e−z J− e Q K .
(3.28)
As in Sect. 2.3.1, we can construct complex coordinates on Z using the Borel embedding: ⎛1 ⎞ ⎛∗ ∗ ⎞ ⎛1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗⎞ ∗ ∗
1
CeZ C
−1
⎜∗ ∗ ⎜ = ⎜∗ ∗ ⎝∗ ∗
1 1
1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ 1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ 1
⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟·⎜ ⎠ ⎝
∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗
⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟·⎜ ⎠ ⎝
∗ ∗ ∗ ∗
1 ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ 1 ∗ ∗⎟ ⎟ 1 ∗ ∗⎟. 1 ∗ ∗⎠ 1 1
(3.29)
The entries of the upper triangular matrix then provide a complex coordinate system such that the “compact Heisenberg algebra” J 1 ,± 1 /± 3 , J+ acts in a simple way, essentially 2
2
2
206
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
by shifts. The Kähler potential in these coordinates (analogous to the bounded domain coordinates of S L(2, R)/U (1)) appears to be complicated; we do not consider them further here. To get a simpler form for the Kähler potential we construct complex coordinates (ξ 0 , ξ 1 , ξ˜0 , ξ˜1 , α) adapted to the “real” Heisenberg algebra, related to the coordinates on the base and the stereographic coordinate on the fiber by i eU i eU (3.30) ξ 0 = ζ 0 + √ 3/2 z + z −1 , ξ 1 = ζ 1 + √ 3/2 τ¯ z + τ z −1 , 2 2 τ2 2 2 τ2 i eU i eU ξ˜1 = ζ˜1 − √ 3/2 3τ¯ 2 z + 3τ 2 z −1 , ξ˜0 = ζ˜0 + √ 3/2 τ¯ 3 z + τ 3 z −1 , 2 2 τ2 2 2 τ2 i eU α = σ + √ 3/2 τ¯ 3 ζ 0 − 3τ¯ 2 ζ 1 − τ¯ ζ˜1 − ζ˜0 z + τ 3 ζ 0 −3τ 2 ζ 1 −τ ζ˜1 − ζ˜0 z −1 . 2 2 τ2 These coordinates are an example of the “canonical” coordinates of quasi-conformal geometries defined by Jordan algebras [25,31]. Such coordinates in fact exist for all c-map spaces [36], and (3.30) agrees with the “twistor map” derived in that context in [36]. To compare the two, recall that the Kähler potential on the special Kähler base (the upper half-plane in this case) is e−K = 8τ23 . The Kähler potential on Z is 1 1 K Z = log N4 = log I4 (ξ I − ξ¯ I , ξ˜ I − ξ¯˜ I ) + (α − α¯ + ξ I ξ¯˜ I − ξ¯ I ξ˜ I )2 , (3.31) 2 2 where 1 4 I4 (ξ, ξ˜ ) = (ξ 0 )2 ξ˜02 + 4(ξ 1 )3 ξ˜0 + 2ξ 0 ξ˜0 ξ 1 ξ˜1 − (ξ 1 )2 ξ˜12 − ξ˜13 ξ 0 3 27
(3.32)
is the quartic invariant of S L(2, R) in its spin-3/2 representation, and N4 is the quartic distance function of quasi-conformal geometry, which defines the “quartic light-cone”. In parallel to the discussion of Sect. 2.3.5, one can also define the homogeneous line bundles O(m) over Z, and the total space of O(−2) gives the Swann space S. 3.4. Quasi-conformal representations. We construct a principal series representation of G by induction from the parabolic P, with the character χk = e−k H /2 of P. The infinitesimal action of G in this representation is determined as in Sect. 2.4.1, this time using the decomposition of G as −ζ 0 E q0 +ζ˜0 E p0
g = p·e ⎛
·e
√ √ − 3ζ 1 E q1 + 33 ζ˜1 E p1
· eσ E ,
⎞ √ 1 0 0 0 0 2ζ˜0 ⎜ ⎟ 1 0 0 0 − 23 ζ˜1 ⎜ 0 ⎟ √ 0 √ ⎜ ⎟ 1 ⎜√ 0 ⎟ 0 1 0 − 2ζ 0 2ζ √ ⎜ ⎟ ˜0 1 σ − ζ 0 ζ˜0 − 1 ζ 1 ζ˜1 0 2ζ˜0 ζ 1 − 2 ζ˜ 2 ⎟ , = p · ⎜ 2ζ 1 2 ζ˜1 2 ζ 3 3 9 1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 0 ⎟ 0 0 0 1 0 0 √ ⎜√ ⎟ ⎝ 2ζ 0 −2ζ 1 − 2 ζ˜1 0 2ζ 1 2 + 2 ζ 0 ζ˜1 1 σ + ζ 0 ζ˜0 + 1 ζ 1 ζ˜1 ⎠ 3 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 √ 2˜ 3 ζ1 −2ζ 1
(3.33)
(3.34)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
207
where p ∈ P. The generators act by H QC = −2σ ∂σ − ζ 0 ∂ζ 0 − ζ 1 ∂ζ 1 − ζ˜0 ∂ζ˜0 − ζ˜1 ∂ζ˜1 − k, E QC = −∂σ , √ QC QC E p0 = ∂ζ˜0 + ζ 0 ∂σ , E p1 = 3 ∂ζ˜1 + ζ 1 ∂σ , 1 QC ˜ ˜ −∂ E qQC = −∂ + ζ ∂ , E = + ζ ∂ √ 0 1 0 σ 1 σ , ζ ζ q1 0 3 √2 √ 1 1 0 1 3 1 QC QC ˜ ˜ Y+ = √ ζ ∂ζ 1 −3 2ζ ∂ζ˜1 − √ ζ1 ∂ζ˜0 , Y− = √ ζ0 ∂ζ˜1 −ζ ∂ζ 0 + ζ˜1 ∂ζ 1 , 3 2 2 2 1 0 3ζ ∂ζ 0 + ζ 1 ∂ζ 1 − 3ζ˜0 ∂ζ˜0 − ζ˜1 ∂ζ˜1 , Y0 QC = 2
3 1 QC 1 0˜ 1 02 ˜ 0 12 0 ˜ 1 2 0 ˜2 1 ˜ F = 2ζ +ζ ζ1 ζ +ζ ζ0 +σ ζ ∂ζ 0 + − ζ1 ζ +ζ ζ0 ζ − ζ ζ1 +σ ζ ∂ζ 1 3 9
1 2 2 1 2 1 0˜ ˜ 3 ˜ 1˜ 0 ˜2 ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ζ − ζ0 ζ ζ1 −ζ ζ0 +σ ζ0 ∂ζ˜0 + −6ζ0 ζ + ζ1 ζ −ζ ζ0 ζ1 +σ ζ1 ∂ζ˜1 + 3 27 1 −[I4 (ζ, ζ˜ ) + σ 2 ]∂σ − kσ, (3.35) where I4 (ζ, ζ˜ ) is the quartic polynomial defined in (3.32). The quadratic Casimir evaluates to 1 C2 = − k(6 − k). 4
(3.36)
This representation is unitary for k ∈ 3 + iR, with respect to the inner product f1| f2 =
dζ d ζ˜ dσ f 1∗ (ζ , ζ˜ , σ ) f 2 (ζ , ζ˜ , σ ).
(3.37)
Complexifying, we can also consider the holomorphic right action of G on sections of the line bundle O(−k) on the twistor space Z = PC \G C . The infinitesimal action is the complexification of the one above, where we replace the real variables ζ I , ζ˜ I , σ by complex variables ξ I , ξ˜ I , α. Naively this construction would require k ∈ Z, but in what follows, we will sometimes consider this action not only when k is integral but even when k ∈ 13 Z. Presumably this should be understood in terms of a triple cover of Z. This representation is formally unitary under the inner product f1| f2 =
¯˜ α) dξ d ξ˜ dα d ξ¯ d ξ¯˜ d α¯ e(k−6)K Z f 1∗ (ξ¯ , ξ, ¯ f 2 (ξ, ξ˜ , α). (3.38)
As discussed in Sect. 2.4.2 for G = SU (2, 1), we expect this formally unitary action on sections of O(−k) to yield a genuine unitary action on H 1 (Z, O(−k)) at least for k ≥ 3; for k ≥ 5 it should give the quaternionic discrete series of G 2(2) . Moreover, it should occur as a subquotient of the principal series for some k. We will discuss this further at the level of the K -finite vectors below.
208
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
3.4.1. Lift to hyperkahler cone. Similar to the discussion of Sect. 2.6.1 for G = SU (2, 1), the action of G = G 2(2) on holomorphic sections of O(−k) over Z is equivalent to an action on holomorphic functions of homogeneity degree −k on the Swann space S. Introducing the complex coordinates on S, 1 (α + ξ 0 ξ˜0 + ξ 1 ξ˜1 ), (3.39) 4i √ √ i 1 i 3 ξ˜1 , (3.40) v 0 = 3 3ξ 0 e2t , w0 = − √ ξ˜0 , v 1 = − √ ξ 1 e2t , w1 = 2 6 3 3 v = e2t , w = −
it is straightforward to compute the holomorphic vector fields corresponding to the action of G C on S and determine their holomorphic moment maps. Expressing the result in terms of the coordinates ξ I , ξ˜ I , α on Z and t in the C∗ fiber, we find the holomorphic moment maps i i i H = e2t α, Y 0 = e2t (3ξ 0 ξ˜0 + ξ 1 ξ˜1 ), E = − e2t , 2 4 4 ! ! ! i 2t 2 i 2t 0 1 Y + = − √ e ξ˜1 + 9ξ˜0 ξ , Y − = √ e ξ ξ˜1 − 3(ξ 1 )2 , ! ! 2 2 6 2 √ 3i 3 2t i i i e ξ˜0 , E p1 = e2t ξ˜1 , E q0 = √ e2t ξ 0 , E q1 = − e2t ξ 1 , E p0 = − 2 2 2 ! ! ! ! 6 3 i 3 2 F p0 = √ e2t −2ξ 1 + ξ 0 ξ˜1 ξ 1 + αξ 0 + ξ 0 ξ˜0 , ! 6 3 i 2t 2 e 3ξ˜1 ξ 1 − 9αξ 1 − 9ξ 0 ξ˜0 ξ 1 − 2ξ 0 ξ˜12 , F p1 = 18 ! i F q0 = − √ e2t 2ξ˜13 + 27ξ˜0 ξ 1 ξ˜1 + 27ξ 0 ξ˜02 − 27α ξ˜0 , ! 6 3 1 i 2t 0˜ 12 1˜ ˜ ˜ F q = e ξ0 ξ ξ1 − 6ξ − ξ1 (3α + ξ ξ1 ) , 2 3 !1 2 2 1 0 ξ˜ 3 0 2 ξ˜ 2 2 ˜ ξ ξ ξ 2ξ α i 2t 3 1 0 − ξ 0 ξ˜0 ξ˜1 ξ 1 − + − F= e 2ξ˜0 ξ 1 + 1 . (3.41) 2 6 27 2 2 ! In order to compute the moment maps in the compact basis, which will be relevant in ¯ transforming homothe next section, it is convenient to change variables to (a, b, a, ¯ b) geneously under the compact generator R0 : 1 1 ¯ ¯ ξ1 = i(a − a¯ + 3b − 3b), ξ 0 = − (a + a¯ − b − b), 8 24 1 1 ¯ ¯ ξ˜1 = (a + a¯ + 3(b + b)), ξ˜0 = i(a − a¯ − b + b), 8 8 i ¯ ¯ . a∂a − a∂ ¯ a¯ − 3b∂b + 3b∂ R0 = b 2
(3.42) (3.43) (3.44)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
209
The holomorphic moment maps for the generators in the compact basis then read i e2t ¯ ¯ 1728(1+α 2 )−a 2 a¯ 2 −4(a 3 b+ a¯ 3 b)−1296b ¯ b−8) , J3 = b¯ + 27b2 b¯ 2 −18a a(b 27648 ! i e2t ¯ 1728(1+α 2 ) − a 2 a¯ 2 −4(a 3 b+ a¯ 3 b)+432b ¯ b¯ + 8) , S3 = b¯ + 27b2 b¯ 2 − 6a a(3b 9216 ! i ¯ + 8iα − bb) ¯ , J+ = − √ e2t 2a 3 + 9a a¯ b¯ + 27b(8 ! 1728 2 i ¯ , ¯ + 8iα + bb) S+ = √ e2t a a¯ 2 + 6a 2 b + 9a(8 ! 576 2 e2t ¯ 1728(1 − α 2 )+3456iα+a 2 a¯ 2 + 4a 3 b + 4a¯ 3 b+18a J 1,3 = − ab ¯ b¯ − 27b2 b¯ 2 , 6912 !2 2 i e2t 2 ¯ ¯ , J 1 1 = i√ e2t a 2 +3a¯ b¯ , J 1,1 = b) √ a a¯ + 6a¯ 2 b+9a(−8−8iα+b ,− !2 2 ! 2 2 24 3 288 6 i e2t 3 ¯ − 8iα + bb) ¯ . J 1 ,− 3 = (3.45) √ 2a + 9a a¯ b¯ − 27b(8 !2 2 864 2 Substituting (3.41) in (3.1), a tedious computation shows that the holomorphic moment map, seen as an element of gC , is nilpotent of degree 2. Thus, the Swann space S is isomorphic (at least locally) to the complexified minimal nilpotent orbit of G 2(2) . In particular, we note the classical identities √ √ E 2p1 + 3E p0 E q1 − 2 2E Y + = 0, ! √ ! ! √ !! E q21 − 3E q0 E p1 − 2 2E Y − = 0, ! ! ! !! 3E p0 E q0 + E p1 E q1 − 4E Y 0 = 0, ! ! ! ! !! 9C2 (L ) − C2 (R ) = 9C2 (J ) − C2 (S ) = 0. ! ! ! !
(3.46a) (3.46b) (3.46c) (3.46d)
3.4.2. Some finite K -types. We now discuss the finite K -types of the principal series representation. The full K -type decomposition can be obtained using Frobenius reciprocity21 ; here we are interested in the explicit construction of some specific states. As in Sect. 2.4.4, we can construct the spherical vector f K by noting that the Heisenberg parabolic subgroup P acting on the two-form e4 ∧ e6 gives a 1-dimensional representation, where ei is the i th row of the matrix in (3.1), and K preserves the norm of each row; so we take f K = e4 ∧ e6 −k/2 ,
(3.47)
e4 ∧ e6 2 = I˜4 + (I6 + α Iˆ4 ) − 2[1 + I2 + (α 2 − I4 )]2 .
(3.48)
where
21 The Frobenius reciprocity theorem implies that the number of occurrences of a K -type σ in the principal series we consider is equal to the number of singlets in the decomposition of σ under K ∩ M, where M is the centralizer in K of A, appearing in the Langlands decomposition P = M AN ; see e.g. [47].
210
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Here, I4 is the quartic polynomial (3.32), invariant under S L(2, R), while I2 , I˜4 , Iˆ4 , I6 are homogeneous polynomials of respective degree 2, 4, 4, 6 in ξ I , ξ˜ I , invariant under the maximal compact subgroup S O(2) ⊂ S L(2, R). In terms of the variables (3.42), 1 1 3 i 3 ¯ I2 = (a a¯ + 3bb), I˜4 = − ba + a¯ 3 b¯ , Iˆ4 = a b − a¯ 3 b¯ , (3.49a) 12 27 27 1 4(ba 3 + b¯ a¯ 3 ) + a¯ 2 a 2 − 27b¯ 2 b2 + 18a ab I4 = ¯ b¯ , (3.49b) 1728 1 3 ¯ I6 = − 2a¯ 3 a 3 + 54a¯ 2 a 2 bb¯ + 9(a a¯ + 3bb)(ba + b¯ a¯ 3 ) . (3.49c) 5832 Using (3.45), one easily recognizes that the spherical vector is related to the quadratic Casimirs of SU (2) J and SU (2) S simply by −k/4 −k/4 = C2 (S )/9 (3.50) e−kt f K = C2 (J ) ! ! which makes the K invariance manifest. Other K -types may be obtained by acting on f K with the non-compact generators J± 1 ,± 3 . For example, a set of J+ -highest weights are obtained by acting with symme2 2 trized products of the raising operators J 1 ,± 3 , J 1 ,± 1 , which transform in the spin-3/2 2 2 2 2 representation of SU (2) S (antisymmetric combinations of these operators lead instead to J+ -descendants); these generate the spectrum
n 3 . (3.51) ⊗ Sn 2 J 2 S n To see this spectrum appearing more explicitly, note that a class of (J+ , S+ )-highest weight states can be obtained by acting on f K with M1 = J 1 , 3 , 2 2
(3.52a)
√
M2 = J 12, 1 + i 3J 1 ,− 1 J 1 , 3 , 2 2
2
2
(3.52b)
2 2
2 M3 = J 12, 3 J 1 ,− 3 + i J 1 , 3 J 1 , 1 J 1 ,− 1 + √ J 13, 1 , 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 2 2 1 M4 = J 12, 3 J 12,− 3 + J 12, 1 J 12,− 1 + 2i J 1 , 3 J 1 , 1 J 1 ,− 1 J 1 ,− 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 4i 4 + √ J 1 , 3 J 13,− 1 + √ J 13, 1 J 1 ,− 3 , 3 3 2 2 2 2 3 3 2 2 2 2 which satisfy [Mi , M j ] ≡ 0,
M12 M4 +
4 3 M − M32 ≡ 0 27 2
(3.52c)
(3.52d)
(3.53)
when acting22 on states annihilated by J+ . A generating function for the (S, J ) spectrum obtained by acting with the Mi on f K is Tr z S q 2J =
1 − q 6 z3 , (1 − q z 3/2 ) (1 − q 2 z) (1 − q 3 z 3/2 )(1 − q 4 )
(3.54)
22 For example, the second equation of (3.53) follows from M 2 M + 4 M 3 − M 2 = 416 J 2 J 2 − 1 4 3 27 2 9 1,3 + 2 2 √ 8J 31 3 J 1 ,− 3 J+ − 56i J 21 3 J 1 , 1 J 1 ,− 1 J+ − 409 3 J 1 , 3 J 31 1 J+ . 3 2 2 2 2 2,2 2,2 2 2,2 2 2 2
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
211
where the denominator corresponds to the action of Mi while the numerator reflects the constraint (3.53). This generating function indeed agrees with (3.51).23 As an example, the action of Mi on f K may be easily computed, ⎛ ⎞ S 3 J 1 , 3 − √i J 1 , 1 S + 3 !2 2! ⎠ fK , M1 f K = k ⎝ ! ! 2 2 (3.55a) C2 (J ) !
J + S+ M2 f K = k(3k − 2) ! ! (3.55b) fK , C2 (J ) !
J+ J 1,3 2 2 2 M3 f K = k(9k − 4) ! ! (3.55c) fK , C2 (J ) ! 2 J + M4 f K = k 2 (9k 2 − 4) (3.55d) fK , ! C2 (J ) ! where equalities hold up to unimportant numerical factors. Acting with the Mi on f K is not sufficient to construct all of the (J+ , S+ ) highest weight vectors. To see this explicitly, it is enough to note that there are other operators built from J± 1 , 3 , J± 1 , 1 which commute with S+ and J+ , for example 2 2
2 2
S 2+ P2 f K ≡ J 1 , 3 J− 1 , 1 − i J− 1 , 3 J 1 , 1 f K = k(k − 2) f K . (3.56) ! 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 C2 (J ) ! Nevertheless, we focus on (J+ , S+ )-highest weight states generated by the action of Mi only, of the form p1
− k − p − 1 ( p + p + p ) i p p p J 1 2 3 J + 3 S + 4 C2 (J ) 4 1 2 2 3 4 , f p1 , p2 , p3 , p4 = S 3 J 1 , 3 − √ J 1 , 1 S + , ! !2 2 !2 2 ! ! ! 3!2 2! (3.57)
where pi are integers related to the SU (2) J × SU (2) S spin by j=
1 1 ( p1 + p2 + 2 p3 ), s = (3 p1 + 3 p2 + 4 p4 ). 2 2
(3.58)
The set of such states is pictured in Fig. 5. Now we recall some results of [26]. First, the K -type decomposition of H 1 (Z, O(−k)) for k ≥ 3 is given by
∞ k−2+n 3 . (3.59) ⊗ Sn 2 2 S J n=0
For k ≥ 5 this gives a quaternionic discrete representation of G, which we expect to find as a submodule of the principal series. Indeed, when k − 2 is a multiple of 4, these K -types do appear in Fig. 5: they are the ones reached by acting with the Mi on f K and in particular using M4 at least 41 (k − 2) times. 23 A simple check is obtained by manipulating (3.54) to get % 2J = 1/(1 − q)4 , the partition n,S (2S + 1)q
function of four free bosons.
212
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
S 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
1
3
2
4
5
6
7
8
J
Fig. 5. The states (3.57) obtained by acting with the Mi on f K . Multiplicities are indicated by the number of concentric circles. The radius of the circle indicates the number of powers of M4 that need to be applied to f K in order to reach the state. This figure also represents the set of highest weight vectors one could obtain by acting with the Mi on some other ground state; in this case the labels J and S are shifted by the quantum numbers of the ground state, and in some cases one gets only a subset of the states pictured
The paper [26] also describes a pattern of other representations which would be expected to appear as submodules of the principal series for general quaternionic groups. While that analysis does not directly apply to G = G 2(2) we describe its naive extrapolation here, and explain how the expected K -type decompositions can be naturally obtained by acting with the operators Mi on an appropriate lowest K -type. The representations in question are supposed to correspond to the orbits of S L(2, C) acting on the complexified spin- 23 representation (C4 ). Their K -type decompositions would be of the form ∞ k−2+n 2
n=0
⊗ An (X ),
(3.60)
J
% where A(X ) = ∞ n=0 An (X ) is the algebra of functions on an orbit X of the action of S L(2, C) on C4 , considered as a representation of SU (2) S . There are three examples: (i) A representation π1 at k = 1, corresponding to the orbit X defined by I4 = 0. The K -type decomposition is obtained by removing the contribution of the operator M4 from (3.54), and acting on a highest weight vector with (J, S) = (0, 21 ) instead of f K : this gives 1
Trπ1 z S q 2J = z 2
(1 − q
1 − q 6 z3 . z) (1 − q 3 z 3/2 )
z 3/2 ) (1 − q 2
(3.61)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
213
This decomposition is multiplicity-free. π1 has Gelfand-Kirillov dimension 4, and K -types contained in a wedge — see the black dots on Fig. 5 (shifted by S = 21 ). It appears on the list of unitary representations of G 2(2) in [8]. at k = 2/3, corresponding to the locus where I = d I = (ii) A representation π2/3 4 4 24 0. Its K -type decomposition can be obtained by acting on a highest weight vector with (J, S) = (0, 2) with the operators M2 and M1 , but imposing the requirement that M22 = 0. It is represented in Fig. 5 by the two leftmost “Regge trajectories” of slope 3 (shifted by S = 2). at k = 4/3, corresponding to the locus where I = d I = (iii) A representation π4/3 4 4 2 d I4 = 0. This is the minimal or “ladder” representation of G 2(2) , with K -type decomposition
∞ m m=0
2
J
3m + 2 ⊗ 2
.
(3.62)
S
The highest weight states can be obtained by acting on the highest weight of a K -type with J = 0, S = 1 by the operator M1 only; it is represented in Fig. 5 by the leading “Regge trajectory” of slope 3 (shifted by S = 1). The values of k at which these submodules appear can be checked by analyzing the invariance of certain elements in the enveloping algebra, as explained in the case of the minimal representation in Sect. 3.5.6 below.
3.5. Minimal representation. The minimal representation of G 2(2) , of functional dimension 3, was first constructed in [53], and further analyzed in [26]. As we just recalled, it can be obtained as a submodule of a degenerate principal series representation [26]. According to the orbit philosophy, it arises by quantizing the minimal nilpotent orbit of G 2(2) , or equivalently by holomorphic quantization of the Swann space S. We start by recalling two different realizations of the minimal representation by differential operators, the first one acting on functions f (y, x0 , x1 ) of real variables, the second on functions f (x, a, b) of complex variables. 3.5.1. Real polarization. In the real polarization used in [39], iy 1 , Y0 = − (x1 ∂1 + 3x0 ∂0 + 2) , H = 2y∂ y + x0 ∂0 + x1 ∂1 + 2, 2 2
√ i x13 2 E p0 = −3 3y∂0 , F p0 = − √ x0 ∂ y − 2 , y 3 3 i 2 = − √ x0 , Fq 0 = − √ −y∂13 + 27i 2 + x0 ∂0 + x1 ∂1 + y∂ y ∂0 , 3 3 3 3 4x 2 ∂1 + 4x1 2i + x0 ∂12 , E p1 = y∂1 , F p1 = 2x1 ∂ y + 1 3y 9
E =−
Eq 0
24 The correspondence between orbits and representations in this case is somewhat degenerate, because actually this orbit is the same as the minimal orbit we discuss next (unlike what happens for other G, where the orbit defined by d I4 = 0 is different from that defined by d 2 I4 = 0).
214
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
4 1 E q 1 = i x1 , Fq 1 + x1 ∂1 + x0 ∂0 + y∂ y ∂1 , 3 3
x12 1 1 1 2 Y+ = √ (i y∂1 + 9x1 ∂0 ), Y− = − √ − x0 ∂1 − i , 3 y 2 2 2 2i 2 2 2 3x1 ∂1 + 6x1 ∂1 + 2 − 2i 2 + y∂ y + x0 ∂0 + x1 ∂1 ∂ y . F = − x0 ∂13 − 2 x13 ∂0 − 27 y 9y 6x 2 = − 1 ∂0 + 2i y
It is easy to check that the principal symbols associated to these generators agree with the holomorphic moment maps (3.41), upon identifying i i i v = −2y, v 0 = 2x0 , v 1 = 2x1 , w = − p y , w0 = p0 , w1 = p1 . 2 2 2 (3.63) The minimal representation in the real polarization is unitary under the inner product f1 | f2 =
d y d x0 d x1 f 1∗ (y, x0 , x1 ) f 2 (y, x0 , x1 ).
(3.64)
√ √ √ Alternatively, one may redefine q0 = −x0 / 27y, q1 = x1 / y, x = y [56], leading to the polarization used by [29,32], i E = − x 2, 2
i 3i 1 ∂x + F = − ∂x2 − I4 , 2 2x 18x 2 1 √ 3 2i 3q1 − 9q0 (q0 ∂0 + q1 ∂1 ) + q0 ∂x , E p0 = x∂0 , F p0 = 9x √ 1 4q1 + q12 ∂1 + 2i 3q0 ∂12 − 3q0 q1 ∂0 + q1 ∂x , E p1 = x∂1 , F p1 = 3x 1 √ 3 2 3∂1 + 9i(q0 ∂02 + q1 ∂0 ∂1 + 3∂0 ) + i∂0 ∂x , E q 0 = i xq0 , Fq0 = 9x √ 1 5i∂1 − iq1 ∂12 + 2 3q12 ∂0 + 3iq0 ∂0 ∂1 + i∂1 ∂x , E q 1 = i xq1 , Fq1 = 3x √ i 2 √ 1 Y+ = √ ∂1 + i 3q1 ∂0 , Y− = √ −iq12 + 3q0 ∂1 , 2 2 1 Y0 = − (3q0 ∂0 + q1 ∂1 + 2), H = x∂x + 2. (3.65) 2 where √ √ I4 (q , ∂ ) = 4 3q0 ∂13 + 4 3q13 ∂0 − 3iq12 ∂12 + 18iq0 q1 ×∂0 ∂1 + 9iq02 ∂02 + 3iq1 ∂1 + 27iq0 ∂0 − 8i.
(3.66)
In accord with irreducibility, the quadratic Casimir evaluates to a constant C2 = −14/9,
(3.67)
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
215
which coincides with that of the quaternionic discrete representation for k = 4/3 or k = −14/3. In addition, the minimal representation is annihilated by the Joseph ideal, e.g. √ 4Y+2 + 3 3(E p1 Fq0 − E p0 Fq1 ) √ √ E 2p1 + 3E p0 E q1 − 2 2E Y+ √ √ E q21 − 3E q0 E p1 − 2 2E Y− 3E p0 E q0 + E p1 E q1 − 4E Y0
= 0,
(3.68a)
= 0,
(3.68b)
= 0, = 0.
(3.68c) (3.68d)
These last three identities can be shown to imply the holomorphic anomaly equations satisfied by the topological amplitude in the one-modulus model with prepotential F = −(X 1 )3 / X 0 [15]. Other identities will be discussed in Sect. 3.5.3 below. For later reference, we note that the vector 0 −2/3
f P (y, x , x ) = (x ) 0
1
(x 1 )3 exp −i yx 0
(3.69)
transforms as a one-dimensional representation of the Heisenberg parabolic P (more specifically, it is annihilated by Y+ , Y0 , Y− , F p I , Fq I , F and carries charge 4/3 under H ). In particular, it is invariant under the Weyl reflection S with respect to the root E and therefore under Fourier transform over x 0 , x 1 . The power (P 0 )−2/3 is consistent with the semi-classical analysis in [57]. 3.5.2. Complex polarization. It is also useful to consider a different realization of the minimal representation [30], on functions f (x, a † , b† ) such that
R0 = i
√ √ 1 † 3 † 1 i i a a − b b− , R+ = √ a † a † + 3 ab , R− = √ a 2 + 3 a † b† , 2 2 2 2 2
L0 =
i 2 i (x − ∂x2 ) + 2 I4 (a, b), 4 9x
i 4 L ± = − √ (∂x ∓ x)2 + 2 I4 . (3.70) 9x 4 2
Here 9 √ 3 9 41 I4 (a, b) = − 3 a 3 b + a 3† b† − Na Nb − Na2 + Nb2 − 3Na − , (3.71) 2 4 4 16 where a, b, a † , b† are bosonic oscillators with [a, a † ] = 1, [b, b† ] = 1,
Na = a † a,
Nb = b† b
(3.72)
so that a ≡ ∂a † , b ≡ ∂b† ; we shall refer to this presentation as the “upside-up” complex polarization. Alternatively, we could consider functions f (x, a † , b) and represent b† = −∂b : this will be termed as the “upside-down” complex polarization, and will turn out to be the most convenient one to compute the lowest K -type. Irrespective of the
216
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
choice of polarization for the oscillator algebra, the generators in the non-compact basis read
i 4 (3.73) ∂x2 − 2 I4 , 2 9x √ x E p1 = − √ (a − a † ) + 3(b − b† ) , 2 2 x √ † E q0 = √ 3(a − a) − (b† − b) , 2 2
i E = − x 2, 2 i x √ † E p0 = √ 3(a + a) − (b† + b) , 2 2 √ ix E q1 = − √ (a † + a) + 3(b† + b) , 2 2
F =−
while the compact generators are given by
J+ J− S+ S−
Na − Nb + 21 i 2 a †3 =− ∂x − x − b− √ , 2 x 3 3 x
Na − Nb − 21 i 2 a3 † = ∂x + x + b + √ , 2 x 3 3 x
√ 1 5 i 3 2 a †2 b† 3 Na + Nb + 6 = ∂x − x − a−√ , 2 x 3 x
√ 1 1 i 3 2 a2b † 3 Na + Nb + 2 =− ∂x + x + a +√ . 2 x 3 x
(3.74a) (3.74b) (3.74c) (3.74d)
This presentation of the minimal representation is related to (3.63) by a Bogoliubov transformation which is the quantum version of the canonical transformation (3.42). It can be decomposed into (i) a Fourier transform with respect to x0 , f (y, x0 , x1 ) =
dp0 e−i p0 x0 /y f (y, p0 , x1 ),
(3.75)
(ii) a change of variables √ √ x 3 x √ (w − 3v), x1 = − 3w + v , p0 = − 18 2
y = x 2,
(3.76)
and finally (iii) a standard Bogoliubov transform f (x, v, w) =
√ 1 2 † 2 2 2 † exp [w + (b ) − v − a ] + 2(av − b w) f (x, a, b† ), 2 (3.77)
√ implementing the change from real to oscillator polarization a + a † = v 2, b + b† = √ of unitary transformation in fact implements w 2. One may check that this sequence √ the Cayley transform by C = e
π 2 4 (R+ +R− )
.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
217
3.5.3. K -type decomposition. Let us now discuss the K -type decomposition (3.62) of the minimal representation in more detail. We note that the correlation between the two spins is a straightforward consequence of the identity in the Joseph ideal25 9C2 (J ) − C2 (S) + 2 = 0.
(3.78)
The fact that the lowest K -type is a SU (2) J singlet and SU (2) S triplet26 is deeper, and will be further discussed below. We also note that the K -type decomposition (3.62) is consistent with the known decomposition of the minimal representation under S L(3, R) and SU (2, 1) [8]: indeed, the minimal representation is an irreducible representation in the non-spherical principal series of S L(3, R). The K -type decomposition of this representation, worked out in [5] (Eq. 7.8), [1] + [2] + [3]2 + [4]2 + [5]3 + [6]3 + [7]4 + [8]4 + · · ·
(3.79)
is consistent with the diagonal embedding of the maximal compact of S L(3, R) inside SU (2) J × SU (2) S . Under SU (2, 1), the minimal representation decomposes as a sum of three irreducible principal series representations of SU (2, 1) with infinitesimal characters (0, 13 , − 13 ), ( 13 , 0, − 13 ), ( 13 , − 13 , 0). These three representations correspond to the three supplementary series at p = q = −2/3 in the terminology of [6], and transform with different characters of the center Z3 of SU (2, 1). This is in agreement with the Casimirs, 8 C2 [S L(3, R)] = − , C3 [S L(3, R)] = 0, 9 8 C2 [SU (2, 1)] = − , C3 [SU (2, 1)] = 0, p = q = −2/3. 9
(3.80a) (3.80b)
Let us now further analyze (3.78), by rewriting them in terms of the generators of G acting in the minimal representation. Using 1 (J+ J− + J− J+ ) = −J3 (J3 ± i) − J∓ J± , 2 1 C2 (S) = −S32 − (S+ S− + S− S+ ) = −S3 (S3 ± i) − S∓ S± , 2
C2 (J ) = −J32 −
(3.81a) (3.81b)
we see that a normalizable eigenmode f of J3 , S3 satisfying the highest weight condition J+ f = S+ f = 0 necessarily has (J3 , S3 ) ∈ 2i N. From (3.78), we have 9J3 (J3 + i) − S3 (S3 + i) + 2 = 4(2R0 + i)( R˜ 0 + i) = 0,
(3.82)
where R0 =
1 (3J3 − S3 ), 2
1 R˜ 0 = (3J3 + S3 ). 2
(3.83)
25 A similar identity holds in the non-compact basis, 9C (L) − C (R) + 2 = 0. 2 2 26 This is an exception among quaternionic Lie groups; the lowest K -type of the minimal representation is
usually a singlet of the Levi factor of P, while carrying a non-zero SU (2) J spin [26].
218
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
Thus it is either an eigenmode of R0 = −i/2, or of R˜ 0 = −i. The second condition is inconsistent with the highest weight condition, so R0 = −i/2. With similar arguments we conclude that J+ f = S+ f = 0
⇒
J+ f = S− f = 0
⇒
J− f = S+ f = 0
⇒
J− f = S− f = 0
⇒
i i i m, S3 = (3m + 2), R0 = − , (3.84a) 2 2 2 i i i J3 = m, S3 = − (3m + 2), R˜ 0 = − , (3.84b) 2 2 2 i i i (3.84c) J3 = − m, S3 = (3m + 2), R˜ 0 = , 2 2 2 i i i J3 = − m, S3 = − (3m + 2), R0 = . (3.84d) 2 2 2 J3 =
In the following, we analyze the consequences of these equations in various polarizations. 3.5.4. Lowest K -type in the complex polarization. It turns out that the form of the lowest K -type is simplest in the complex polarization, where the generator R0 takes a simple form
1 † 3 1 . (3.85) R0 = i a a − b† b − 2 2 2 The following linear combinations of (3.74) lead to x-independent equations: √ √ i i T++ = a 3J+ + bS+ = − (a †2 + 3ab)(R0 + ), x 2 √ † √ † † 2 i † 2 T−− = 3a J− + b S− = − x(a + 3a b )(R0 − ), 3 2 √ √ T+− = a † 3J+ − bS− , T−+ = a 3J− − b† S+ ,
(3.86a) (3.86b) (3.86c)
where the first two lines are consistent with (3.84a). Now we restrict to a highest weight S+ f = 0, which is a singlet of SU (2) J , i.e. J+ f = J− f . It turns out that it is convenient to work in the “downside-up polarization” where b = ∂b† , a † = −∂a . The constraint R0 = −i/2 requires 1 a3 f (x, a, b† ) = (b† )−1/3 f 1 (x, z), z = √ † . 3 3b
(3.87)
The constraint T++ is automatically obeyed, however T−+ leads to a second order ordinary differential equation in z only, 1 2 2 2 z∂z − 2(z − )∂z + (z + x − ) f 1 (x, z) = 0. (3.88) 3 3 The solution is f 1 (x, z) = x 1/3 z 1/6 e z
√ √ K 1/3 2i x z f 2 (x) + I1/3 2i x z f˜2 (x) .
(3.89)
In the following, we assume that normalizability forces f˜2 (x) = 0. It is one of the drawbacks of the complex polarization that normalizability is difficult to check – at any
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
219
rate, it is straightforward to generalize the computation below to include both solutions. Requiring the action of S+ on (3.87) to vanish, we find
6x∂x − 12z∂z2 + 2(6z − 4)∂z + (1 − 6x 2 )
f 1 (x, z) = 0.
(3.90)
Combining this with (3.88), we can produce a first order partial differential equation
7 x∂x − 2z∂z + 2z + y − 6
2
f 1 (x, z) = 0
(3.91)
whose solution is f 1 (x, z) = x 7/6 e−x
2 /2+z
f 3 (x 2 z).
(3.92)
√ f 3 (u) = K 1/3 2i u .
(3.93)
This uniquely determines f 2 (x) = x −7/6 e−x
2 /2
,
It is now easy to check that the resulting function is annihilated by S+ , J+ , J− , J3 , and is an eigenmode of S3 = i. The remaining two states in the triplet may be obtained by acting with S− . Altogether, we find that the lowest K -type is √ K 1/3 2i x z , √ 2 = 2 3−1/4 x 3/2 a (b† )−1 e z−x /2 K 2/3 2i x z , √ 2 2 = − √ (ax/b† )3/2 e z−x /2 K 1/3 −2i x z . 3
f 0,1 = (ax 3 /b† )1/2 e z−x f 0,0 f 0,−1
2 /2
(3.94a) (3.94b) (3.94c)
The highest weights in the higher K -types can be obtained by acting with the raising operators J1/2,3/2 . For example, f 1,5 = 2 2
1 3 1 3/2 1/2 † −1 z−x 2 /2 x K 4 + i 3 4 a 2 x K 2 + 3 b† (2x 2 − 3)K 1 , (3.95) a (b ) e 3 3 3 3
where the argument of the Bessel function is as in f 0,1 . We note that semi-classically, all K -types behave as ⎡ 1 a3 2 x2 exp ⎣− + √ † + 3/4 i x 2 3 3b 3
(
⎤ a3 ⎦ . b†
(3.96)
As explained in (2.6.2), and further at the end of the next subsection, the argument of the exponential (or “classical action”) provides the generating function for a complex Lagrangian cone inside the hyperkähler cone S.
220
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
3.5.5. Lowest K -type in the real polarization. According to the above, the lowest K -type should be a triplet of SU (2) S , singlet under SU (2) J . Thus we impose the conditions J+ = J3 = J− = S+ = 0.
(3.97)
Note in particular that the generator F p0 − E p0 of rotations in the (y, x0 ) plane, which was at the start of the KPW solution for the spherical vector in the split case, no longer annihilates the state, so we need a different strategy. Our approach is to find a linear combination of the operators J+ , J3 , J− , S+ which involves first order differential operators only. The one of interest is $ 3 y S3 − 3J3 + 3i (J+ − 2J− − S+ ), (3.98) 2 x0 which allows to rewrite S3 as a first order differential operator in three variables, S3 = α y ∂ y + α0 ∂0 + α1 ∂1 + β,
(3.99)
where
x1 27i 2 x0 −12x12 + 9y 2 , α0 = −9x1 − + αy = y i − 9 y , α1 = , x0 2x0 3 2x0 β=
x1 (−6y + x12 + i x0 x1 ) . x0 y
(3.100)
(3.101)
The standard way to solve this equation is to integrate the flow dy = αy , ds
d x0 = α0 , ds
d x1 = α1 , ds
df = (β − s3 ) f. ds
(3.102)
Using inspiration from the split case [39], it is easy to find one constant of motion along the flow, 2 2 2 2 2 3/2 y + 27 x0 + 3 x1 z= . (3.103) 2 2 y 2 + 27 x0 To find the second constant of motion, and integrate the flow completely, we go to polar coordinates in the (y, x0 ) plane, √ √ y = 2 r cos θ, x0 = 3 3 r sin θ. (3.104) We now change variables to f (y, x0 , x1 ) = r
−2/3
h(z, r, θ ) exp −2i
x0 x13 y(2x02 + 27y 2 )
.
(3.105)
The action of S3 on h(z, r, θ ) is still a first order differential operator, but now involving only two variables r, θ : 1/2
2/3 z 3r S3 = −i cot θ ∂θ − −1 ∂r . (3.106) √ sin θ r 2
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
Again, the way to solve this equation is to integrate the flow 1/2
2/3 i dr 3r z dθ =− , =− −1 , √ ds tan θ ds sin θ r 2
dh = s3 . hds
221
(3.107)
The ratio of the first two equations gives dθ/dr , and produces a second constant of motion (in addition to z),
$ 2/3 z √ (1 − i eiθ )2 1 + i −1
t= (1 + i
eiθ )2
1−i
r 2
$
z √
r 2
2/3
.
(3.108)
−1
The third equation in (3.107) then constrains the θ dependence to h(z, r, θ ) = [cos θ ]−is3 h 1 (z, t),
(3.109)
where s3 is the eigenvalue under S3 , which we independently know to be s3 = i for the lowest K -type. We now express the action of the other generators J± , S+ , R0 on our ansatz
x0 x13 −2/3 f (y, x0 , x1 ) = cos θ r h 1 (z, r ) exp −2i . (3.110) y(2x02 + 27y 2 ) For this purpose, we express r, θ, z, t in terms of y, x0 , x1 using (3.103),(3.104) and
√
1 + " 3i 2x1 √ " 2 2x02 +27y 2 4 x0 2 2 x0 √ t = 1+ + 2x02 + 27y 2 , 2 27 y 27 y 1 − " 3i 2 2x1
(3.111)
2x0 +27y 2
and act with the original differential operators. We then set x1 = 0, and revert to z, t variables using $ √ 1 2 z 2 t 2 z. (3.112) x0 = 27(r − y ), r = √ , y = 2 1+t 2 The last two identities are only valid at x1 = 0, but that is sufficient to get the full action on h 1 (z, r ). We find, in particular, √ √ √ i t i 2t 3t z −3z +8 t ∂t +4 t 4t 2 ∂t2 −3z∂z − 3(t +1)z , R0 + = − 2 5/3 2 9(t + 1) z √ √ t J+ + J− = 2 3t z+3z+4 t ∂ −24 t z∂ ∂ −3(t−1)z . (3.113) t z t 18(t + 1)z 5/3 A semi-classical analysis of the z → ∞ limit gives the expansion √ √
2 t (1 + t)2 1/6 −z/2 5 1+ z −1 − h 1 (z, t) ∼ z e √ √ 36 t 3(1 + t)2 √ √
35 t 385 5005 t −85085 −3 −2 z + z + · · · . (3.114) + − √ 2+ √ 2+ 54(1+ t) 2592 3878(1+ t) 279936
222
M. Günaydin, A. Neitzke, O. Pavlyk, B. Pioline
This suggests the ansatz √ (1 + t)2 h 1 (z, t) = z 1/6 h 2 (z) + h 3 (z) . √ t
(3.115)
Indeed, we find that all constraints reduce to two ordinary differential equations for h 2 and h 3 , (1 + 3z)h 2 + 6z(h 2 + 4h 3 + 2h 3 ) = 0, (4 + 15z)h 2 + (54z − 2)h 3 + 12z(2h 2 + 9h 3 ) = 0,
(3.116a) (3.116b)
which decouple into
(1 + 18z + 9z 2 )h 2 − 36z(h 2 + zh 2 ) = 0,
(3.117a)
(9z − 5)h 3 − 36z h 3 = 0.
(3.117b)
2
2
Each of them has two independent solutions, but we keep only the one decaying at z → ∞ in order to ensure normalizability, leading to √ √ (1 + t)2 2/3 2 π 1/3 z U 7 , 4 ,7 (z), h 1 (z, t) = (3.118) z K 1/3 (z/2) + √ 6 3 3 t which correctly reproduces the subleading terms in (3.114). In total, the final answer for the lowest K -type in the real polarization is √ 2 √ 2 π 1/3 −2/3 (1 + t) 2/3 f 0,1 (y, x0 , x1 ) =(cos θ ) r z U 7 , 4 ,7 (z) z K 1/3 (z/2) + √ 6 3 3 t (3.119)
x0 x13 × exp −2i . y(2x02 + 27y 2 ) In the semi-classical limit, where y, x0 , x1 are scaled uniformly to ∞, it reduces to √ 2 −2/3 (1 + t) f 0,1 (y, x0 , x1 ) ∼ r (3.120) z 1/6 cos θ e−S , √ t where S is the “classical action” 2 3/2 2x0 2x1 2 2 + + y 27 3 2i x0 x1 3 . 2 S= − 2 y 2x0 + 27y 2 2 2x270 + y 2
(3.121)
The same reasoning as in Sect. 2.6.2 implies that S is the generating function of a holomorphic Lagrangian cone inside the hyperkähler cone S, invariant under the maximal compact K . The precise identification of the variables y, x0 , x1 in the minimal representation and the complex coordinates on S is given in (3.63). One may indeed check that the holomorphic moment maps of the compact generators vanish identically on the locus w I = ∂v I S.
Quasi-Conformal Actions, Quaternionic Discrete Series and Twistors: SU (2, 1) and G 2(2)
223
√ √ After rescaling x0 → x0 27/2, x1 → x1 / 2, we find that S can be cast in the same form as in Eq. 4.72 of [39], S=
x0 1
X − i " F, 2 y x 2 + y2
(3.122)
0
where X is an Sp(2n + 4) extension of the usual Sp(2n + 2) symplectic section appearing in the special geometry description of the c-map, X = y, x0 , x1 ; y˜ , x˜ 0 , y˜ 0 , X 2 = y 2 + y˜ 2 + (x0 )2 + (x1 )2 + (x˜ 0 )2 + (x˜ 1 )2 , (3.123) x3 y˜ = ∂ y F, xˆ i = ∂x i F, F = √ " 1 . 3 3 y 2 + x02
(3.124)
It would be interesting to see whether such a Sp(2n + 4) invariant description also exists for non-symmetric c-map spaces, or even for general hyperkähler manifolds, and to investigate whether the lowest K -type of the minimal polarization bears any relation to the topological string amplitude of the corresponding magical supergravity theory as discussed in [15]. 3.5.6. As a submodule of the principal series. We consider the submodule of the principal series annihilated by the “holomorphic anomaly” relations √ √ C+ ≡ E 2p1 + 3E p0 E q1 − 2 2E Y+ = 0, (3.125a) √ √ (3.125b) C− ≡ E q21 − 3E q0 E p1 − 2 2E Y− = 0 in the Joseph ideal (see (3.68b),(3.68c)). In terms of the differential operator realization (3.35), these conditions reduce to − 3(P 1 )2 + P 0 Q 1 = 0, (Q 1 )2 + 9Q 0 P 1 = 0,
(3.126a) (3.126b)
whe