1999 IEEE NSREC IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference Short Course
Radiation Effects in the Space Telecom...
376 downloads
2586 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
1999 IEEE NSREC IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference Short Course
Radiation Effects in the Space Telecom Environment
July 12, 1999 Sponsored by: IEEE/NPSS Radiation Effects Committee Supported by: Defense Threat Reduction Agency Sandia National Laboratories Air Force Research Laboratory Jet Propulsion Laboratory NASA – Goddard Space Flight Center Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
1999 IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference
Short Course
Radiation Effects in the Space Telecom Environment July 12, 1999 Norfolk Virginia
Copyright© 1999 by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. All rights reserved. Instructors are permitted to photocopy isolated articles for noncommercial classroom use without fee. For all other copying, reprint, or replication permission, write to Copyrights and Permissions Department, IEEE Publishing Services, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 08555-1331.
Table of Contents
SECTION I …………………………………………………………... I 1-5 INTRODUCTION Daniel M. Fleetwood Sandia National Laboratories
SECTION II ……………………………………………………….. II 1-85 BASIC MECHANISMS FOR SINGLE-EVENT EFFECTS Paul E. Dodd Sandia National Laboratories
SECTION III …………………………………….……………… III 1-114 TOTAL-DOSE EFFECTS: MODELING FOR PRESENT AND FUTURE Jean-Luc Leray CEA/DAM Ile-de-France
SECTION IV ………………………………..…………………… IV 1-110 PROTON EFFECTS AND TEST ISSUES FOR SATELLITE APPLICATIONS Paul W. Marshall, Consultant Cheryl J. Marshall, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center
SECTION V ………………………………………………………... V 1-68 SYSTEM LEVEL MITIGATION STRATEGIES William F. Heidergott Motorola, Inc., Satellite Communications Group
AFTERWORD …………. Order information for Short Course CD ROM
1999 IEEE NSREC SHORT COURSE
SECTION I
INTRODUCTION
Daniel M. Fleetwood Sandia National Laboratories
Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
INTRODUCTION This Short Course covers in a tutorial fashion selected topics of relevance to space telecommunications systems. This is the 20th year in which the Short Course has been offered in conjunction with the IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference (NSREC). The themes of the short course are selected each year to reflect the varying interests and requirements of the attendees of the IEEE NSREC. This year’s theme “RADIATION EFFECTS IN THE SPACE TELECOM ENVIRONMENT” is especially appropriate given the emerging interest in large-scale commercial space telecommunications systems. However, the information contained within the four segments should be useful to all systems that must operate reliably in the challenging radiation environment of space. The greatest challenge to commercial success in space is the integration of commercial and custom components into a system that can achieve its mission reliably and affordably. Rising to this challenge requires knowledge of the space radiation environment external to and within the satellite or spacecraft of interest, the effects of the environment on electronic and photonic devices, and system engineering techniques to mitigate these effects where possible. These requirements present significant constraints on component selection, and on system design and operation. The space telecommunications systems that best meet these challenges through proper assessment of the environment, disciplined parts selection and testing, judicious use of design margin, and efficient system design and integration will be the ones that best exploit commercial opportunities in space. The outline of the course is as follows: In Section II “BASIC MECHANISMS FOR SINGLE-EVENT EFFECTS” Paul Dodd presents an overview of the mechanisms responsible for single-event effects (SEE), with a particular eye toward the use of physics-based modeling and simulation to shed light on the fundamental processes involved. After a brief review of the space radiation environment responsible for SEE, nondestructive and destructive SEE failure modes are discussed. Techniques for mitigating SEE are reviewed, as well as newer topics such as particle energy effects and gate rupture in thin oxides. Future trends in SEE susceptibility are also addressed, including growing concerns for SEE in terrestrial microelectronics. In Section III “TOTAL-DOSE EFFECTS: MODELING FOR PRESENT AND FUTURE” Jean-Luc Leray reviews the basic mechanisms of total ionizing dose effects on semiconductor devices in the natural space environment. Time dependent effects on radiation response are discussed, as are new issues of especial interest to commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) parts. Detailed examples are presented that incorporate numerical modeling of total dose effects in several cases of interest. In Section IV “PROTON EFFECTS & TEST ISSUES FOR SATELLITE APPLICATIONS” Paul and Cheryl Marshall briefly review the proton environments, and
I-1
discuss single event, total ionizing dose, and displacement damage issues specific to proton effects in space. Case studies are presented that illustrate typical applications of single event rate predictions and displacement damage analysis tools. Current issues pertaining to emerging technologies, on-orbit predictions, and test fidelity are also discussed. In Section V, “SYSTEM LEVEL MITIGATION STRATEGIES” Bill Heidergott addresses the commercial space telecommunications industry and satellite systems, space environment effects on spacecraft payloads, and design for radiation environment compatibility. The presentation includes brief discussions of the environment, models, and effects on devices; the primary focus is on single event upset and transient effects, and fault tolerance techniques for mitigating their impact to system operations. I want to personally thank the five Short Course authors, Paul Dodd, Jean-Luc Leray, Paul Marshall, Cheryl Marshall, and Bill Heidergott for their efforts in preparing this Short Course. It is the diligence and expertise of the authors that has continued the tradition of excellence in NSREC Short Courses through the years, and that makes it a highlight of the conference week and a resource for the remainder of the year. This year, we are especially pleased that this tradition has been recognized with a CD-ROM that contains previous NSREC Short Courses from 1980-1998, provided to each course registrant. We thank the Radiation Effects Steering Group (especially Dale Platteter) and the 1999 NSREC Conference Committee for making this possible. I also thank Lew Cohn for his efforts in reviewing the Short Course and ensuring that the notes were printed on schedule, and the DTRA printing office for printing the notebooks.
Daniel M. Fleetwood Albuquerque, New Mexico
I-2
Biographies Daniel M. Fleetwood Short Course Organizer Sandia National Laboratories Daniel M. Fleetwood received his B. S. in Physics and Applied Mathematics from Purdue University in 1980, and his M. S. and Ph. D. degrees in Physics from Purdue in 1981 and 1984. He is a Distinguished Member of the Technical Staff in the Radiation Technology and Assurance Department at Sandia National Laboratories. He has been active in the field of radiation effects in microelectronics since joining Sandia in 1984, is the author or co-author of more than 175 publications, and holds two patents. In 1997 and 1998 he received R&D 100, Industry Week, and Discover Magazine awards for co-invention of a nonvolatile memory based on hydrogen-annealed SiO2. Dr. Fleetwood has served the radiation effects community as a guest editor of the December 1988-1990 and April 1996 special issues of the IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, as technical program chair and short course instructor for the IEEE NSREC, and as vice-chair/publications on the Radiation Effects Steering Group. He has received Outstanding Paper Awards for the 1985, 1988, and 1995-1998 IEEE NSREC’s and 1988, 1990, and 1995 HEART Conferences. He was awarded the International Correspondence Chess Master title in 1997, and is a member of The American Physical Society, Phi Beta Kappa, Sigma Pi Sigma, and a Fellow of IEEE. Dr. Fleetwood has accepted the position of Professor of Electrical Engineering at Vanderbilt University beginning August 1999.
Paul E. Dodd Sandia National Laboratories Paul E. Dodd received his B.S. and M.S. in Electrical Engineering from Purdue University in 1988 and 1989. He received his Ph.D. from Purdue in 1993 for research on novel cryogenic InAs bipolar transistors and experimental and theoretical studies of GaAs-based heterojunction bipolar transistors. He joined Sandia National Laboratories in 1993, and is a Senior Member of the Technical Staff in the Radiation Technology and Assurance Department. He is actively involved in the development of Sandia’s 0.5-µm and 0.35-µm bulk and SOI CMOS technologies, and the computer simulation of singleevent, total-dose, and transient radiation effects on microelectronics. Dr. Dodd has served the radiation effects community as publicity chairman and session chairman for the IEEE NSREC, and has been a session chairman for the Single-Event Effects Symposium. He has also served the IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting as a member of the Modeling and Simulation technical subcommittee and session chairman. Dr. Dodd is the author or co-author of more than 30 publications and is a member of the IEEE.
I-3
Jean-Luc Leray CEA/DAM Ile-de-France Jean-Luc Leray received his Engineering Degree from the “Ecole Centrale des Arts et Manufactures de Paris” in 1978, and the “Docteur d'État es Sciences Physiques” Degree from the University of Orsay, Paris, in 1989. Meanwhile, he was successively research engineer, project leader, and group leader at "Commissariat A l'Energie Atomique" (CEA), the French Agency for Atomic Energy. In 1992, he became head of the Radiation Hardening Section at CEA. In 1994, Dr. Leray was awarded "Grand Prix de l’Electronique Général Ferrié" by SEE (Société des Electriciens et des Electroniciens, Paris) and FIEE (French Federation of the Electronic Industries) for works in design and hardening of integrated technologies for military, space, and high-energy physics applications. Dr. Leray has served as Session Chair for the IEEE NSREC, and as Short Course Instructor and Technical Program Chair for RADECS. He is the author or coauthor of more than 110 publications and 4 book chapters, and holds one patent. In 1998, he was awarded the medal "Chevalier des Palmes Académiques" by the Ministry of Education and Research. Dr. Leray is now a scientific assistant and program advisor to the director of the department in charge of hardening matters at CEA. He is a "Membre Sénior" of SEE and a Senior Member of the IEEE.
Paul W. Marshall Consultant Paul W. Marshall received his B. S. in Physics from James Madison University in 1980, his M. S. in Radiation Biophysics from the Medical College of Virginia in 1982, and his Ph. D. from the Department of Nuclear Engineering and Engineering Physics at the University of Virginia in 1985. Since 1985, he has been employed by SFA, Incorporated, under contracts supporting the Naval Research Laboratory’s Radiation Effects Branch. His activities there have included development of proton test capabilities for microelectronic and photonic components of interest to satellite developers. Basic mechanisms of proton interactions have been a major emphasis in his studies of displacement damage and single event effects from protons. Since 1991 Dr. Marshall has been engaged, first as a collaborator and more recently as a consultant, with the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center’s Radiation Effects Group where he supports component and subsystem evaluations for numerous flight projects and continues investigations into basic mechanisms of proton and other radiation effects in emerging technologies. Dr. Marshall has chaired sessions and served on several committees for the NSREC, and he is a member of the IEEE and NPSS with over 80 published papers.
I-4
Cheryl J. Marshall NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Cheryl J. Marshall received her B. S. degrees in Physics and Chemistry from Georgetown University in 1979, and her Ph.D. in Physics from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in 1986. From 1986 until 1998, she worked as a research physicist for the Naval Research Laboratory, investigating basic mechanisms of radiation damage in microelectronic and optoelectronic technologies critical to satellite imaging and communications. She also served as Section Head of the Emerging Technologies Section in the Radiation Effects Branch at NRL, and provided flight program support. Dr. Marshall has served as the Defense Threat Reduction Agency’s Program Area Reviewer for Single Event Effects, and chaired the 10th and 11th Single Event Effects Symposia. Since 1998, Dr. Marshall has worked for the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, evaluating radiation effects in emerging technologies and providing flight program support. She has participated in the IEEE NSREC on several committees and chaired sessions (including the Poster Session in 1998). She is a member of the IEEE and NPSS with over 80 published papers.
William F. Heidergott Motorola, Inc., Satellite Communications Group William F. Heidergott received his B. S. in Electrical Engineering from the University of Arizona in 1974. Since joining Motorola, Inc., he has worked in the design and development of CMOS custom devices, application specific integrated circuits and standard products, and subsystem design and system development for numerous DoD, NASA, and commercial space programs. Mr. Heidergott’s recent assignments include program engineering support in design for radiation environment compatibility and management of technology for commercial space programs. In 1998 he chaired the inaugural NSREC session on radiation effects in commercial electronics and space systems.
I-5
BASIC MECHANISMS FOR SINGLE-EVENT EFFECTS Paul E. Dodd Sandia National Laboratories Albuquerque, New Mexico 1.0
Introduction
2.0
Brief Overview of Environments 2.1 Trapped Particles 2.1.1 Protons 2.1.2 Heavy Ions 2.2 Transient Particles 2.2.1 Solar Event Protons and Heavy Ions 2.2.2 Galactic Cosmic Rays 2.3 Secondary Particles
3.0
Basic Mechanisms for Non-Destructive Single-Event Effects 3.1 Charge Deposition 3.1.1 Direct Ionization 3.1.2 Nuclear Reaction Effects 3.2 Charge Collection 3.2.1 Basic Physics of Charge Transport 3.2.2 New Charge-Collection Mechanisms in Submicron Devices 3.3 Single-Event Upset Mechanisms in DRAMs 3.3.1 Storage Cell Errors 3.3.2 Bit-Line Errors 3.3.3 Combined Cell and Bit-Line Errors 3.4 Single-Event Upset Mechanisms in SRAMs 3.5 Single-Event Upset in Other Circuit Types 3.6 Single-Event Multiple-Bit Upset 3.7 Particle Energy Effects 3.8 Mitigation Techniques 3.8.1 Technology Hardening 3.8.2 Circuit- and System-Level Hardening
4.0
Basic Mechanisms for Destructive Single-Event Effects 4.1 Single-Event Latchup 4.1.1 Single-Event Latchup Mechanism 4.1.2 Mitigation Techniques 4.2 Single-Event Gate Rupture 4.2.1 Single-Event Gate Rupture Mechanism 4.2.2 Single-Event Gate Rupture in Power MOSFETs 4.2.3 Single-Event Gate Rupture in Thin Gate Oxides 4.3 Single-Event Burnout
II-1
5.0
Modeling and Simulation of Single-Event Mechanisms 5.1 Interaction Models 5.1.1 Track Structure Models 5.2 Physics-Based Device Models 5.2.1 3D Device and Mixed-Level Simulations 5.2.2 Recent Enhancements
6.0
Future Trends 6.1 Technology Drivers Impacting Single-Event Effects 6.2 Hardening Strategies 6.3 Terrestrial and High-Altitude Single-Event Effects 6.3.1 The Atmospheric Radiation Environment 6.3.2 Historical Perspective and Recent Studies 6.3.3 Mitigation Techniques
7.0
Summary and Conclusions
8.0
Acknowledgments
9.0
References
II-2
1.0
INTRODUCTION
Single-event effects (SEE) in microelectronics are caused when highly energetic particles present in the natural space environment (e.g., protons, neutrons, alpha particles, or other heavy ions) strike sensitive regions of a microelectronic circuit. Depending on several factors, the particle strike may cause no observable effect, a temporary disruption of circuit operation, or even permanent damage to the device or integrated circuit (IC). Single-event effects may be broadly characterized as either non-destructive or destructive SEE. Examples of non-destructive SEE include single-event upset in logic or memory circuits (SEU, or equivalently, soft errors) and single-event current transients (SET) in photodetectors. Destructive SEE include such phenomena as single-event latchup (SEL, which can be either destructive or non-destructive depending on circuit design), single-event burnout (SEB), and single-event gate rupture (SEGR). Any of these effects can cause unacceptable system performance in space applications, and possibly jeopardize mission success. In this short course segment, we will examine the basic physical mechanisms causing singleevent effects in microelectronics for spaceborne applications. We start with a brief overview of the particle environment encountered in space in order to get to know the enemy. We will then discuss the mechanisms and characteristics of many of the non-destructive and destructive SEE mentioned above in detail, including techniques for mitigation. Next we review modeling and simulation methods that have proved useful for gaining physical insight and predicting SEE in microelectronics. We conclude with a look into technology trends that may affect future device susceptibility to SEE and areas of emerging concern. Reflecting their relative importance in the commercial marketplace, most of this short course segment will focus on silicon MOS devices and circuits, but where appropriate we will examine other technologies of interest.
II-3
2.0
BRIEF OVERVIEW OF ENVIRONMENTS
Previous NSREC Short Course segments have given excellent detailed descriptions of the space radiation environment [1,2]. Several review articles on the subject were also published as part of the recent Special Issue on Single Event Effects and the Space Radiation Environment in the IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science [3-8]. The intent is not to repeat a great deal of this information here, but rather to give a brief overview of some of the more important points that may be of use later as SEE mechanisms are discussed. The reader is directed to the above references for more details on the space radiation environment. 2.1
Trapped Particles
Charged particles that come into contact with the Earth’s magnetic field can become trapped in the near-Earth environment. These particles include electrons, protons, and heavy ions. Electrons are very important components of the space environment because they inflict damage on spacecraft through total ionizing radiation dose and spacecraft charging effects [9-11]. Because electrons do not usually contribute to single-event effects, we will limit our discussions to trapped proton and heavy ion populations. The trapped particle belts (Van Allen belts) consist of two regions of trapped particles: an inner belt centered at about 1.5 Earth radii, and an outer belt of particles at about 5 Earth radii, separated by a region of reduced (but non-zero) particle flux (the so-called “slot” region). References [1] and [2] contain helpful illustrations of the belt structure around the Earth. Although the origin of trapped particles in the near-Earth environment is not completely understood [1], sources include the solar wind and transient solar events, cosmic ray particles from interplanetary space, and reaction products from cosmic ray collisions with the Earth’s atmosphere. It was recently discovered that transient solar events can actually produce new trapped particle belts of surprisingly long duration [4,6]. 2.1.1
Protons
Regardless of origin, energetic protons do exist in the near-Earth environment and are one of the most prominent sources of SEE. They range in energy from tens of keV to hundreds of MeV, with fluxes as high as 105 protons/cm2/sec for protons with energy > 30 MeV [1]. Protons with these energies are easily able to penetrate shielding and impinge on electronics within spacecraft. The altitude at which proton flux peaks depends on the proton energy, with high energy (>30 MeV) protons being cut off by around 3.5 Earth radii, but lower energy protons existing throughout the slot region. Probably the most important region for proton SEE is the South Atlantic Anomaly (SAA), a region off the east coast of South America with greatly increased proton flux at altitudes less than 1000-2000 km. The SAA exists because of the difference between the Earth’s geographic spin axis and its magnetic axis, which causes a localized region of lower magnetic field off the Argentine coast [1]. During passes through the SAA, the flux of energetic (>30 MeV) protons can be more than 104 times as intense than at equivalent altitudes over other regions of the Earth [12]. The SAA is illustrated in Figure 2.1, which shows flux contours for protons with energy > 30 MeV as a function of latitude and longitude at altitudes of 500 km (Fig. 2.1a), 1000 km
II-4
(Fig. 2.1b), and 3000 km (Fig. 2.1c) [1]. At low altitudes, the SAA is highly localized, and as altitude increases, the SAA becomes less distinct until at 3000 km (Fig. 2.1c) the normal Van Allen belt structure re-emerges. 2.1.2
Heavy Ions
The Van Allen belts are predominantly composed of trapped electrons and protons, but it is now well accepted that heavy ions are also trapped by the Earth’s magnetic field. The origin of these particles is thought to be anomalous cosmic rays, which are neutral interstellar particles that drift into the solar system, become ionized by the solar wind and accelerated to 10’s of MeV/nucleon, and are subsequently trapped by the magnetosphere [1]. Trapped heavy ions (e.g., He, C, N, O, and Ne) have been measured by the SAMPEX spacecraft, and an example geographic distribution is shown in Figure 2.2 for oxygen ions [13]. Similar results have been
a)
b)
c) Figure 2.1
Integral proton flux contours as a function of latitude and longitude after Barth [1]. Altitudes are a) 500 km, b) 1000 km, and c) 3000 km. Note the South Atlantic Anomaly, which is visible at lower altitudes but disappears by 3000 km. II-5
obtained by the Japanese satellite MIDORI [14]. The oxygen ions shown in the polar regions in Fig. 2.2 are not trapped heavy ions, but are due to galactic cosmic rays, as discussed below. Trapped oxygen ions are evident in the region near the SAA for the same reason that proton fluxes are greatest there, i.e., the lower magnetic field in the SAA allows the ion flux to dip down to lower altitudes. The peak in trapped heavy ion fluxes is at altitudes just above the inner proton belt (i.e., 1.8 to 2 Earth radii). Because the trapped heavy ions have relatively low energies (10’s of MeV/nucleon), these particles may not penetrate through spacecraft shielding and therefore are not expected to be a major concern for SEE [1]. 2.2
Transient Particles
In this section, the classification of “transient” particles encompasses all particles in the nearEarth space environment that are not stably trapped in the magnetosphere. This includes particles introduced into the environment by solar events such as flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), as well as energetic ions incident from interstellar space. 2.2.1
Solar Event Protons and Heavy Ions
The activity level of the Sun is never constant, but follows a cyclical variation of active years followed by quiet years. The period of recent solar cycles has varied between 9 and 13 years, with an average of about 11 years. Solar cycle activity is frequently gauged by the observed number of sunspots, but many solar processes show the same variation. Importantly for the
Figure 2.2
Geographic distribution of trapped oxygen ions during solar quiet time as measured by the Mass Spectrometer Telescope (MAST) on SAMPEX [13]. II-6
present case, this includes the incidence of energetic solar events, with maximum numbers of solar flares and CMEs occurring during active years. Solar events still occur during solar quiet times, but they occur less frequently. We have long associated solar flares with an increased flux of energetic particles, but the evidence appears to support that CMEs may be more important [1]. Solar events can be broadly characterized as being either gradual or impulsive. The gradual events produce a raised particle flux that decays slowly over several hours or even days, and have been correlated to CMEs. These events are proton-rich and can produce high-energy (> 30 MeV) proton fluences higher than 109 protons/cm2 accumulated over a few days. Gradual events are responsible for the majority of large proton fluence events, and occur at a frequency of about 10 per year during solar maximum conditions. Impulsive events are by definition of much shorter duration (hours at most), and are marked by increased fluences of heavy ions and low energy electrons. Impulsive events produce heavy ion fluences that can be orders of magnitude above the galactic cosmic ray background. These heavy ions have energies ranging from tens of MeV/nucleon to hundreds of GeV/nucleon, but at the upper end of this range the flux falls below the galactic cosmic ray background. Impulsive events may be associated with solar flare activity and are responsible for about 1000 small solar particle events per year at solar maximum [1,3]. Figure 2.3 shows solar event proton fluences for the last three solar cycles, superimposed over a plot of the sunspot number [1]. The cyclical variation of the sunspot number is readily apparent, as is the fact that most (but not all) high-fluence proton events occur during solar active years. While solar particle events can be broadly classified as gradual or impulsive, individual events have their own very unique properties in terms of duration, particle fluence, energy spectrum, etc. Stassinopoulos et al. have presented a classification system where events are classified from small to extremely large, and solar cycles are classified from extremely mild to Event Fluences For Cycles 20 - 22 1011
Cycle 21
Cycle 22
> 10 MeV; > 108 p/cm2 > 30 MeV; > 107 p/cm2 Zurich Smoothed Sunspot Number
200 180 160
Protons/cm2
1010 140 120 109
100 80 60
108 40 20 10
Zurich Smoothed Sunspot Number
Cycle 20
0
7
1965
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
Year
Figure 2.3
Correlation of proton solar event fluence to sunspot number for solar cycles 20-22 [1]. Sunspot number is shown by the solid line plot, and proton solar event fluences by the bars.
II-7
extremely severe [5]. It can be seen in Figure 2.3 that solar cycle 20 was in general extremely quiet with the exception of an extremely large solar event in August 1972; this solar cycle was classified as very mild. Solar cycle 21 was extremely mild, with no individual events of highenergy proton fluence > 109 protons/cm2. By contrast, solar cycle 22 had 8 events with highenergy proton fluence > 109 protons/cm2; this cycle is considered extremely severe [5]. Some events (such as the August 1972 event) are actually a series of closely-spaced events, where proton fluxes have not yet decayed to their original level before the next event occurs. The importance of individual large solar events cannot be overestimated – the August 1972 event by itself accounted for 84% of the total high-energy proton fluence received by spacecraft during the entire 20th solar cycle. Accurate models to predict worst-case particle fluence from solar events are crucial to appropriate parts selection and survivable spacecraft design. 2.2.2
Galactic Cosmic Rays
6-Hour-Averaged Flux (cm2-s-sr)-1
Solar event particles are true transient particles in the sense that elevated fluxes of particles are observed only for a short time following an event (although recall that following a large event increased levels of trapped particles are observed and in some cases can produce new trapped particle belts). In contrast, galactic cosmic rays (GCR) form a background component of radiation that shows a slow cyclical variation with solar activity. GCRs are composed of very highly energetic protons and heavy ions that come from outside the solar system. These particles must fight against the solar wind to enter the solar system and are therefore at their maximum intensity at solar minimum and drop off a factor of 2 to 10 at solar maximum. The cyclical variation of GCRs is shown in Figure 2.4, which is a plot of 25-95 MeV/nucleon He flux over a 20-year period as measured by the IMP-8 satellite [15]. The spikes on this plot are due to increased heavy ion fluences from solar events. Note that these spikes are more likely to occur at solar maximum, when the baseline GCR heavy ion flux is lowest.
Figure 2.4
Solar cycle variation of heavy ions (in this case He nuclei) as measured by the Cosmic Ray Telescope (CRT) aboard the IMP-8 satellite [15]. Note the spikes in He flux caused by solar events. II-8
The particle composition of GCRs is shown in Figure 2.5 [16]. Protons comprise about 83% of the GCR flux, He nuclei (alpha particles) account for 13%, 3% are electrons, and the remaining 1% are heavier nuclei. Even though they are not very abundant, heavy ions are very important to SEE because they deposit the most energy per unit pathlength, as discussed in later sections. Note that beyond Fe, the heavy ion flux drops dramatically. This turns out to be important, because the energy deposited by an ion per unit pathlength depends on its atomic number. Ions heavier than Fe are more ionizing, but are much less abundant. Therefore, radiation hardening microelectronics so that they don’t experience SEE from ions up to Fe can result in low SEE rates. This is sometimes referred to as the “iron threshold.” GCRs that come into contact with the near-Earth environment encounter Earth’s geomagnetic field. Because they are so energetic (tens of MeV/nucleon to hundreds of GeV/nucleon), they do not become trapped and are not significantly attenuated by spacecraft shielding. GCRs that hit the atmosphere form a cascade of secondary particles, as mentioned in the next section. GCRs with polar trajectories can penetrate to low altitudes because of the reduced geomagnetic rigidity in the polar regions. Spacecraft with high inclination angles are therefore at greatest risk of encountering SEE due to GCRs. 2.3
Secondary Particles
Secondary particles are produced when GCRs strike the Earth’s atmosphere and produce a shower of particles in the atmospheric environment. Because this component of the radiation environment is important only for microelectronics operating in the Earth’s atmosphere, a description of the secondary particle environment will be delayed until Section 6.3, Terrestrial and High-Altitude Single-Event Effects.
Figure 2.5
Particle composition of galactic cosmic rays [16]. Note that Hydrogen and Helium nuclei (i.e., protons and alpha-particles) account for the vast majority of GCR flux, while heavy ions comprise only about 1%. II-9
3.0
BASIC MECHANISMS FOR NON-DESTRUCTIVE SINGLE-EVENT EFFECTS
All non-destructive single-event effects are caused by the same fundamental mechanism: collection of charge at a sensitive region of a microcircuit following the passage of an energetic particle through the device. In this section we look at the release of mobile carriers along the path of an incident particle, the collection of these carriers, and how the resulting transient currents interact with the circuit to generate a single-event upset. 3.1
Charge Deposition
By definition, as ionizing radiation passes through a target material electrons and holes are released along the path of ionizing particles. There are two primary methods by which carriers are released: direct ionization by the incident particle and ionization by secondary particles created by nuclear reactions between the incident particle and the target material. Direct ionization can cause SEU if the incident particle (such as a heavy ion) is ionizing enough to free a very high density of carriers. For lighter particles (e.g., protons), direct ionization may produce an insufficient amount of charge to cause upset directly and SEU may instead be due to ionization produced by secondary particles. 3.1.1
Direct Ionization
As we have said, when an energetic particle passes through a semiconductor material it frees charged carriers along its path as it loses energy. When all of its energy is lost, the particle comes to rest in the semiconductor, having traveled a total path length referred to as the particle’s range. We frequently use the terms linear energy transfer (LET) or dE/dx to describe the energy loss per unit path length of a particle as it passes through a material. LET has the seemingly odd units of MeV-cm2/mg, but this is simply because the energy loss per unit path length (in MeV/cm) is normalized by the density of the target material (in mg/cm3). We can easily relate the LET of a particle to its charge deposition per unit path length, because for a given material it takes a certain amount of energy to release an electron-hole pair. For example, in silicon one electronhole pair is produced for every 3.6 eV of energy lost, and silicon has a density of 2328 mg/cm3 [17]. Using these values it is easy to show that an LET of 97 MeV-cm2/mg corresponds to a charge deposition of 1 pC/µm. This conversion factor of about 100 is handy to keep in mind if you need to go back and forth between energy loss (LET) and charge deposition. A curve of particular interest for understanding the interaction of a given energetic particle with matter is the LET of the particle versus depth as it travels through the target material. Figure 3.1 shows such a curve for a 210-MeV chlorine ion traveling through silicon (a common heavy ion beam used for SEU testing at the Tandem Van de Graaff at Brookhaven National Laboratory). Such curves are readily obtained using computer codes derived from the work of Ziegler, et al (e.g., the TRIM and SRIM family of codes, [18]). This figure shows the basic characteristics of ion-induced charge deposition as a function of depth. A peak in the charge deposition occurs as the particle nears its range, and then a precipitous drop in deposition as the particle reaches its range and comes to rest. The peak in charge deposition is referred to as the Bragg peak, and in general occurs as the particle reaches an energy near 1 MeV/nucleon. A more rigorous discussion of the Bragg curve and the Bragg peak is found in reference [19].
II-10
30
2
LET (MeV-cm /mg)
Bragg Peak
20
10
0 0
20
40
60
80
Depth (µm) Figure 3.1
Linear energy transfer (LET) vs. depth curve for 210-MeV chlorine ions in silicon.
Whether or not the charge deposited through direct ionization is sufficient to cause an upset of course depends on the individual device and circuit that has been struck as well as the strike location and trajectory. Direct ionization is the primary charge deposition mechanism for upsets caused by heavy ions, where we rather loosely define a heavy ion as any ion with atomic number Z ≥ 2 (i.e., He and above, or put another way, particles other than protons, electrons, neutrons, or pions). Lighter particles such as protons do not usually produce enough charge by direct ionization to cause upsets in memory circuits, but recent research has suggested that as devices become ever more susceptible, upsets due to direct ionization by protons may occur [20,21]. This effect has not been experimentally confirmed to date. As discussed in references [21] and [22], these upsets will likely be difficult to observe and of limited importance to the overall upset rate because the upset rates will continue to be dominated by proton-silicon reactions for typical orbits and spacecraft configurations. In contrast to memories, upsets in photodiodes used in optocoupler applications have been observed and correlated to direct ionization by protons [2326]. Single-event current transients (SET) resulting from proton direct ionization are capable of causing upsets in these photodiodes because they are by design very large and operate at very high data rates [27]. A recent analysis suggests that a combination of direct ionization and recoils are responsible for the anomalous angular dependence of proton upsets in optocouplers [28]. Charge-coupled devices (CCDs) can also be sensitive to direct ionization by protons because of their large collection depths [29]. For more information on these devices and their susceptibility to protons the reader is directed to the third segment of this short course [30]. 3.1.2
Nuclear Reaction Effects
As mentioned above, direct ionization by light particles usually does not produce a high enough charge density to cause upsets. Unfortunately, this does not mean that we can ignore
II-11
these lighter particles. Protons and neutrons can both produce significant upset rates due to indirect mechanisms. As a high-energy proton or neutron enters the semiconductor lattice it may undergo an inelastic collision with a target nucleus. This may result in the emission of alpha (α) or gamma (γ) particles and the recoil of a daughter nucleus (e.g., Si emits α-particle and a recoiling Mg nucleus), or a spallation reaction, in which the target nucleus is broken into two fragments (e.g., Si breaks into C and O ions), each of which can recoil. Any of these reaction products can now deposit energy along their paths by direct ionization. Because these particles are much heavier than the original proton or neutron, they can deposit higher charge densities as they travel and therefore may be capable of causing an SEU. These inelastic collision products typically have fairly low energies and do not travel far from the particle impact site. They also tend to be forward-scattered in the direction of the original particle; this has consequences for the SEU sensitivity as a function of the angle of incidence [31]. Historically neglected, recent experiments and simulations have shown that elastic collisions may become important for very sensitive devices [32,33]. Low-energy secondary particles (primarily protons and neutrons) generated within packaging or shielding may be an even more significant source of SEU in these sensitive devices [33]. Once a nuclear reaction has occurred, the charge deposition is not greatly different in character from a directly ionizing heavy ion strike. Therefore, once deposited, it is subject to the same fields and concentration gradients and is collected in a similar manner. 3.2
Charge Collection
The basic properties of charge collection following a particle strike have been studied using a variety of experimental and theoretical methods. Broadbeam charge collection spectroscopy measurements have been used to determine SEU-sensitive volumes in SRAMs [34-36], and ion microbeams and lasers have been used with high-speed sampling oscilloscopes to measure charge-collection transients in Si and GaAs devices [37-46]. Ion microbeams and lasers have also been used to map integrated charge collection as a function of position in ICs [45,47,48], and more recently as a function of both time and position [49]. The physics of charge collection have also been intently studied through the use of two- and three-dimensional numerical simulation [50,51]. It is beyond the scope of this short course segment to comprehensively review the massive literature on charge collection; we seek to touch the main highlights and recent developments only. 3.2.1
Basic Physics of Charge Transport
There are basically only three mechanisms that act on the charge deposited by an energetic particle strike: 1) carriers can move by drift in response to applied or built-in fields in the device, 2) carriers can move by diffusion under the influence of carrier concentration gradients within the device, or 3) carriers can be annihilated by recombination through direct or non-direct processes. These three mechanisms are of course not unique to the particle strike problem and are in fact the governing processes of charge transport in semiconductors under most operating conditions [52]. When a particle strikes a microelectronic device, the most sensitive regions are reversebiased p/n junctions, as illustrated in Figure 3.2. The high field present in a reverse-biased junction depletion region can very efficiently collect the particle-induced charge through drift processes, leading to a transient current at the junction contact. The situation is not too dissimilar II-12
from the operation of a solar cell, where large-area p/n junctions are reverse-biased to collect charge liberated in the semiconductor by sunlight. Strikes near a depletion region can also result in a significant transient current as carriers diffuse into the vicinity of the depletion region field where they can be efficiently collected. Note that even for direct strikes, diffusion plays a role as carriers generated beyond the depletion region can diffuse back toward the junction. Shortly following the discovery of SEU, researchers at IBM used numerical device simulators to compute the response of reverse-biased p/n junctions to alpha-particle strikes [50,53,54]. An important insight gained from these early charge-collection simulations was the existence of a transient disturbance in the junction electrostatic potential, which was termed the “field funnel,” as shown in Figure 3.3 [53]. Charge generated along the particle track can locally collapse the junction electric field due to the highly conductive nature of the charge track and separation of charge by the depletion region field. This funneling effect can increase charge collection at the struck node by extending the junction electric field away from the junction and deep into the substrate, such that charge deposited some distance from the junction can be collected through the efficient drift process. The funnel effect has been investigated in further detail by later researchers [55-59], including the influence of epitaxial substrates on the transient charge-collection characteristics [60-62]. Several important additional insights have been gained from these studies. The reader is referred to [59-62] for more comprehensive discussions of funneling, but here are a few key points to keep in mind:
Ion Pa th
1) The term “funnel length” is a misnomer (as is funneling itself to some extent). There is no well-defined length that can be associated with funneling from a physical standpoint [58,61,62]. Funnel length is thus only a useful concept inasmuch as it can be used as a quasi-physical “fudge factor” in error rate calculations. In this case it can be used to represent any charge collection from outside the defined sensitive volume, including the effects of funneling.
Funnel
–+ +– – + Drift +– –+ + – Diffusion ++ –+
Depletion Region
Recombination Figure 3.2. Illustration of an ion strike on a p/n junction showing drift, diffusion, recombination, and funneling. II-13
2) Expecting funnel-assisted drift charge collection to be “prompt” can be misleading. In cases where the substrate is lightly-doped, funneling can take a long time (nanoseconds) to develop and to collect charge [54,60]. 3) Funneling does not require a direct strike on a depletion region. Near misses can also cause funneling if a high enough carrier density diffuses into the depletion region to collapse it [54,61]. 4) Funneling in epitaxial diodes is limited by the heavily-doped substrate underneath the epi layer. Once sufficient minority carriers are removed from the epi layer, the depletion region is reformed, funneling stops, and charge collection continues at a much slower rate. This leads to a characteristic knee in the charge-collection characteristics of n/p epitaxial diodes, as shown by the dashed curve in Fig. 3.4 [60,61]. 5) Because of differences in the hole and electron mobility, funneling occurs in reversebiased n/p diodes, but is much weaker or nonexistent in equivalent p/n diodes. This is indicated in Fig 3.4 by the lack of a knee in the p/n charge-collection characteristics (solid curve). [59,61]. 6) The total charge collected in an epitaxial diode can be approximated by the charge liberated in the epitaxial layer plus the charge liberated within a diffusion length of the epi/substrate boundary [61]. Funneling affects the rate at which the charge deposited in the epi layer is collected, but does not appear to change the total charge collection, since this charge would usually be collected even in the absence of funneling. While in some cases important to charge collection in isolated p/n junctions with constant applied bias, the role of the funnel is less significant in the case of static circuits such as SRAMs, where reverse-biased transistor junctions are connected to active external circuitry. In this scenario, the applied voltage at the struck junction is not constant, and in fact very often the
Figure 3.3. Illustration of funneling in an n+/p silicon junction following an ion strike: a) electrostatic potential, b) electron concentration. Note that contours of electrostatic potential are distorted along the path of the ion [53]. II-14
Figure 3.4. Charge-collection transients in n+/p and p+/n epitaxial diodes following ion strikes [61]. Note the lack of a knee in the p+/n diode curve, which indicates that funneling is very weak for this case. struck node may switch from being reverse-biased to zero-biased (see Section 3.4). This loss of bias at the struck node tends to lessen the importance of drift collection (and hence the funnel) as the single-event transient proceeds [63]. In such cases, funneling may play a role in the early-time response of the circuit by helping initially flip the node voltage, but it is late-time collection by diffusion that ensures the bit stays flipped (see Section 3.4 for further details about the upset process in SRAM circuits). 3.2.2
New Charge-Collection Mechanisms in Submicron Devices
The charge-collection response of a single p/n junction is generally presumed to accurately depict the response of the sensitive junction of a transistor, typically a reverse-biased drain region. Studies have indicated that a new charge-collection mechanism may exist for submicron MOS transistors which requires considering the entire transistor [64,65]. Termed the alphaparticle source-drain penetration effect (ALPEN), this charge-collection mechanism results from a disturbance in the channel potential that the authors referred to as a funneling effect. The effect is illustrated in Figure 3.5a and is triggered by a particle strike that passes through both the source and the drain at near-grazing incidence. Immediately following the strike, the electrostatic potential in the channel region is perturbed to the extent that i) there is no longer a potential barrier between the source and channel, and ii) there is a substantial potential gradient between the source and the drain. These two conditions together can lead to a significant (but short-lived) source-drain conduction current which mimics the “on” state of the transistor. This mechanism was revealed by 3D alpha-particle simulations and has been experimentally verified. The experiments indicate that source charge injection due to the ALPEN mechanism increases rapidly II-15
a)
b)
Figure 3.5. a) Illustration of the alpha-particle induced source-drain penetration (ALPEN) effect [64]. b) Charge injected by the source due to the ALPEN mechanism as a function of gate length. For gate lengths below 0.5 µm, this mechanism may become critical. for effective gate lengths below about 0.5 µm, as shown in Fig. 3.5b. Later work predicted the same direct channel conduction mechanism can occur in 0.3-µm gate length MOSFETs even for normal incidence strikes, and can lead to charge multiplication [66]. This mechanism may forebode a serious vulnerability to SEU for deep submicron MOSFETs. A somewhat similar, but distinct mechanism exists when electrons or holes released by a particle strike are confined to a well or body region in which a transistor is located. For example, for an n-channel MOS transistor located in a p-well, electrons induced by a particle strike can be collected at either the drain/well junction or the well/substrate junction. However, holes left in the well raise the well potential and lower the source/well potential barrier, and the source injects electrons into the channel, as illustrated in Figure 3.6 [67-70]. These electrons can be collected at the drain, where they add to the original particle-induced current and can cause an increased SEU sensitivity. Because the electrons are injected over the source/well barrier, this is referred to as a bipolar transistor effect, where the source acts as the emitter, the channel as the base region, and the drain as the collector. Reducing the channel length effectively decreases the base width, and the effect becomes more pronounced [69]. Essentially the same effect occurs in floating body silicon-on-insulator (SOI) devices, where excess carriers in the body turn on the parasitic bipolar transistor [69,71,72]. This bipolar effect severely impacts the intrinsic SEU hardness of floatingbody SOI transistors.
II-16
Source
Gate
Drain
P-Well
N-Substrate
Figure 3.6. Electron concentration contours inside an n-channel MOS transistor following a heavy ion strike [70]. The bipolar effect is evidenced by the contours emanating from the source, showing that the source is injecting electrons into the p-well, where they may be collected at the substrate or at the drain.
3.3
Single-Event Upset Mechanisms in DRAMs
We’ve seen how an ion strike releases charge along its path through a semiconductor and how this charge can be collected by p/n junctions, but what really matters is determining whether the event actually causes an error in circuit operation. In the following subsections we’ll study how charge collection interacts with the circuit type and design to create a single-event upset. The focus will primarily be on memory circuits, but we’ll briefly address SEU in other circuit types at the end of the section. SEUs in terrestrial electronics were first observed in DRAMs [73,74]. DRAMs have historically been quite susceptible to soft errors because they rely on passive storage of charge to represent information. Their charge state is readily modified by funnel-assisted drift or diffusion following an energetic particle strike. DRAMs have therefore received less use in space systems as engineers have preferred SRAM technologies [75]. As the need for very large amounts of onboard memory is increasing, the use of DRAM technologies in space systems is becoming more common [76-81]. DRAMs are prone to SEU due to three primary mechanisms: storage cell errors, bit-line errors, and a combination of the two. The reader is directed to the review article by Massengill [75] for an excellent in-depth summary of SEU effects in DRAMs. 3.3.1
Storage Cell Errors
Figure 3.7 illustrates the mechanism for storage cell errors in a field plate capacitor DRAM [75]. In this kind of DRAM a stored “0” is represented by electrons occupying a potential well under the field plate, while a stored “1” corresponds to electrons being depleted under the plate. Following a particle strike, electrons can be collected at the reverse-biased field plate. In the case of a stored “0”, this just reinforces the original state, but a stored “1” can look like a stored “0” after electron collection. DRAM storage cell errors therefore can characteristically show a very II-17
large pattern dependence. Note also that data patterns may be inverted internally depending on the memory, so that “0” to “1” errors are observed externally [73,74]. Two other effects can lead to storage cell errors in DRAMs. The ALPEN effect described in Section 3.2.2 can lead to channel conduction that shunts charge onto the storage cell, disturbing the cell information [64]. In DRAMs with closely spaced trench storage cells, charge can be transferred between two storage nodes by a particle track shunt effect [82]. In this case, the particle track intersects neighboring storage nodes in opposite memory states, and the resulting charge transfer between nodes can upset one or both storage nodes. 3.3.2
Bit-Line Errors
Bit-line errors can result if sufficient charge is collected during a read cycle to create a charge imbalance on the precharged bit lines [75]. Because they can only occur during a read cycle, bitline errors have a direct dependency on the read access frequency, with an increasing error rate as the access frequency increases [83,84]. Bit-line errors can be caused by strikes to the access transistor drains along the floating bit-line or strikes to the sense amplifier circuitry itself [75,85]. Because of their inverse dependency on cycle time, bit-line errors become a significant reliability concern as memory speeds increase. 3.3.3
Combined Cell and Bit-Line Errors
A new failure mode for DRAMs was demonstrated ten years ago when it was found that charge collection at both the storage cell and bit line that was insufficient to individually cause an upset could cause an error in combination [86]. This new failure mode, dubbed the combined cell-bit line (CCB) error, was shown to dominate the storage cell and bit-line error rates for very short cycle times. The three components of soft errors in a 512K DRAM are shown in Figure 3.8 as a function of the cycle time. Note the independence of storage-cell errors on cycle time, and the domination of CCB errors for short cycle times [86].
Ion Path Bit Line
Poly Word Line Poly
Field Plate Poly +
+ -+
+
n+
n+
Stored Information Charge
Figure 3.7. Illustration of storage cell SEU in a field-plate DRAM after Massengill [75]. Collection of electrons at the reverse-biased field plate reinforces a stored “0,” but can lead to an upset of a stored “1.” II-18
104 Source: AM241
Soft Error Rate (arbitrary units)
103
102
10
1
CCB Component Bit Line Component Cell Component
10-1 10
102
103
104
105
Cycle Time (ns)
Figure 3.8. Components of soft-error rate in a DRAM [86]. The storage cell component is not dependent on the cycle time, while soft errors involving the bit lines increase dramatically as the cycle time decreases. 3.4
Single-Event Upset Mechanisms in SRAMs
The upset process in SRAMs is quite different from DRAMs, due to the active feedback in the cross-coupled inverter pair that forms a typical SRAM memory cell. When an energetic particle strikes a sensitive location in a SRAM (typically the reverse-biased drain junction of a transistor biased in the “off” state [70,87], for example the “off” n-channel transistor shown in Figure 3.9), charge collected by the junction results in a transient current in the struck transistor. As this current flows through the struck transistor, the restoring transistor (“on” p-channel transistor in Fig. 3.9) sources current in an attempt to balance the particle-induced current. Unfortunately, the restoring transistor has a finite amount of current drive, and equally importantly, a finite channel conductance. Current flow therefore induces a voltage drop at the drain of the restoring transistor. This voltage transient in response to the single-event current transient is actually the mechanism that can cause upset in SRAM cells. The voltage transient is essentially similar to a write pulse, and can cause the wrong memory state to be locked into the memory cell. In SRAM cells, there are four possible sensitive strike locations, namely the four transistor drains interior to the SRAM circuit. An important consideration for charge collection is whether the junction is located inside a well or in the substrate [70,87]. A diagram of mechanisms for each drain strike location in an n-substrate technology is shown in Figure 3.10. Generally speaking, in each case the transient resulting from an ion strike has a quick initial response followed by a slower, sustained current mechanism [70]. For example, in the familiar outsidethe-well “off” strike (Figure 3.10a), there is an initial drift photocurrent (ip ) followed by diffusion II-19
VDD “on” p-channel (restoring transistor)
Rfb
Ion Strike
Feedback
Rfb
“off” n-channel (struck transistor)
Figure 3.9. Competition between the feedback process and the recovery process governs the SEU response of SRAM cells. current (id ). Both currents are directed such that they tend to raise the struck node voltage and cause SEU. This is the most sensitive strike location for most technologies [87]. In the outsidethe-well “on” strike (Figure 3.10b), the initial drift current again raises the node voltage, but this reinforces the stored logic state. As the node rises, the struck junction becomes slightly forwardbiased, and a conduction (diffusion) current flows opposite to the initial drift current, returning the SRAM to its initial state. This strike location does not produce SEU. Inside-the-well strikes are particularly interesting because of shunt and bipolar effects that can occur in multilayer structures [67]. For the inside-the-well “off” strike (Figure 3.10c), the initial drift current pulls down the struck node potential, initiating the upset process. As the transient proceeds, holes deposited in the p-well are collected at the p-well ties, raising the well potential and leading to injection of electrons by the source [67,68,70,88]. This initiates the inside-the-well bipolar effect discussed in Section 3.2.2 and illustrated in Fig. 3.6. Electrons collected by the substrate do not contribute to upset because the substrate is attached to VDD . However, electrons collected by the n-drain constitute a bipolar current in the same direction as the initial photocurrent, and do contribute to the upset process [70]. For small geometries, the inside-the-well “off” strike can become an important mechanism. In the inside-the-well “on” strike (Figure 3.10d), the ion strike bridges two n-type regions that are at an initial potential difference of VDD . The result is a shunt current that quickly raises the struck node voltage and starts the upset process [89]. This mechanism is self-limiting. As the struck node voltage rises, the potential difference across the shunt disappears. Similar to the inside-the-well “off” strike, holes collected at the p-well ties initiate a bipolar effect, but this time the bipolar current tends to restore the node to its original state. For small geometries, the bipolar effect is strong enough to provide a great deal of intrinsic protection from such strikes [70]. Interestingly, incident particles far below the upset threshold are often sufficiently ionizing to induce a momentary voltage “flip” at the struck node of an SRAM. For example, Figure 3.11 shows drain voltage transients in an SRAM for a particle strike with LET well below the upset II-20
threshold, just below the upset threshold, and just above the upset threshold. Even the particle with LET well below the upset threshold causes a significant voltage transient at the struck drain. Whether an observable SEU occurs depends on which happens faster: the feedback of the voltage transient through the opposite inverter, or recovery of the struck node voltage as the single-event current dies out [63,89,90]. Note that in terms of the fundamental charge-collection characteristics discussed in Section 3.2, drift (including funneling effects) is responsible for the rapid initial flip of the cell, while long-term charge collection by diffusion prolongs the recovery process; both mechanisms are critical to the upset process. The recovery time of an SRAM cell to a particle strike depends on many factors, such as the particle LET, the strike location, etc. From a technology standpoint, the recovery time depends on the restoring transistor current drive and minority carrier lifetimes in the substrate [89,90]. A higher restoring current leads to a faster recovery time, as do decreased minority carrier lifetimes. a) Outside-the-well OFF Strike
b) Outside-the-well ON Strike
VDD
VDD VDD
n-epi p+
VDD
p+
ip
n-epi p+
p+
id
ip
id
VDD➟VDD+
0➟VDD
ip = drift photocurrent id = diffusion current ib = bipolar current
c) Inside-the-well OFF Strike VDD
is = shunt current
VDD
VDD
n+ p-well n-epi
VDD
VDD➟0
0➟VDD➟0
ip
is
ib
n+
n+ p-well n-epi
VDD
Figure 3.10.
d) Inside-the-well ON Strike
ib
n+
VDD
Illustration of possible SRAM upset strike locations and mechanisms [70]. II-21
5.0
Struck Drain Voltage (V)
Threshold LET ≈ 42 MeV-cm2/mg
4.0 2
LET = 9 MeV-cm /mg
3.0 2.0
2
LET = 40.5 MeV-cm /mg
1.0
2
LET = 45 MeV-cm /mg
0.0 10-14
10-13
10-12
10-11
10-10
10-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
Time (s) Figure 3.11. SRAM struck drain voltage transients for ion strikes with LET well below, just below, and just above the SEU threshold. Even the ion strike with LET well below the actual SEU threshold is sufficiently ionizing to momentarily flip the struck node voltage. This is because a higher restoring current is more quickly able to re-establish the struck node voltage, while decreased substrate minority carrier lifetimes reduce the diffusion current at the struck node. The cell feedback time is simply the time required for the disturbed node voltage to feed back through the cross-coupled inverters and latch the struck device in its disturbed state. This time is related to the cell write time and in its simplest form can be thought of as the RC delay in the inverter pair. This RC time constant is thus a critical parameter for determining SEU sensitivity in SRAMs – the smaller the RC delay, the faster the cell can respond to voltage transients (including write pulses) and the more susceptible the SRAM is to SEU. Obviously this has implications for the sensitivity of future, higher speed technologies, as discussed in Section 6. 3.5
Single-Event Upset in Other Circuit Types
Although we have concentrated on SEU in memory circuits, the reader should be aware that SEUs can occur in almost any integrated circuit. For example, SEU is not constrained to digital circuits, but occurs in analog circuits as well. We have already mentioned the problem of SET in optocouplers, which can lead to errors in data transmission [23,28]. Errors are observed in many analog circuit types, including operational amplifiers [91-93], comparators [93,94], and analogto-digital converters (ADCs) [95-97]. Upsets in ADCs are interesting in that analog errors are observed as corruptions in digital output codes [98]. Figure 3.12 shows an example of analog SEU in a 12-bit ADC, where the SEUs appear as a distribution of erroneous codes around the expected output (4 codes centered at 1428 that were removed in this plot for clarity [95]). An excellent summary of SEU in analog ICs is found in [98]. II-22
Figure 3.12. SEU in a 12-bit analog-to-digital converter [95]. Errors are indicated by deviations from the expected digital output codes (4 codes centered at 1428 that were removed in this plot for clarity). SEUs also occur in digital circuits other than memories, prime examples being microprocessors [99-103] and digital signal processors [103,104]. These digital logic circuits are very difficult to test for SEU due to their complexity, especially for advanced high-speed technologies [105]. Errors in logic circuits are also very sensitive to critical timing windows and logic paths, and may never propagate to the output pins [106-109]. As circuit operating speeds continue to increase, the probability of a momentary glitch in a line voltage from a single-event transient (SET) propagating through a logic path to become an observable error rises. Given the ever-growing demand for higher functionality, faster speeds, and greater integration in tomorrow’s space systems, SEU testing increasingly complex logic ICs will be one of the biggest challenges for the future. 3.6
Single-Event Multiple-Bit Upset
Single-event multiple-bit upsets (MBUs) occur when a single particle strike causes more than one error in an IC. For example, diffusion of charge to closely-spaced junctions can upset more than one bit in both SRAM and DRAM cells [60,110]. For a particle striking an IC at a grazing angle of incidence, the charge track may intersect several sensitive regions and cause multiple upsets [111]. The effects of MBU are typically alleviated by a combination of error-correcting codes that work on a word-by-word basis (see Section 3.8.2) and layout rules that prevent physically-adjacent bits from belonging to the same word of memory. Still, single-word multiplebit upsets (SMUs) can occur and pose a substantial threat to system integrity [112]. MBUs have been observed in on-orbit spacecraft data [113,114].
II-23
Multiple-bit upset in DRAMs has been studied fairly extensively using experiments and 2D cylindrically-symmetric simulations [110,115,116]. Figure 3.13 shows an example error map obtained from heavy-ion exposure of a 256Kb DRAM. MBU error locations are shown as solid capacitor areas, surrounded by the outlines of adjacent capacitors where no errors were observed [110]. Simulations showed that for normal-incidence strikes the charge-collection mechanism responsible for MBU in DRAMs was lateral diffusion of the ion-induced charge to multiple junctions. Funneling can increase charge collected at the struck node, reducing the charge available for diffusive transport to adjacent nodes [115]. Zoutendyk et al. found that for the small capacitances typically associated with individual storage elements, funnel-assisted drift collection for direct hits on a storage node is very limited. For direct bit-line hits with larger nodal capacitance, however, substantially reduced charge collection at adjacent nodes was observed [110]. Ion tracks that do not hit a junction therefore allow the greatest amount of lateral charge transport and constitute the worst-case strike location for MBU [110]. The issue of MBUs in SRAMs has also been studied using simulations [60,117]. In [60], two adjacent SRAM cells were simulated, and the strike location was varied to determine the region of sensitivity to multiple-bit upset from normally-incident heavy ion strikes. A simulated error map was produced showing the region of vulnerability to MBU, as shown in Figure 3.14. Only strikes incident between the two cells were capable of producing MBU for the ion strikes simulated in this work. Strikes directly incident on the drain of one cell resulted in upset of the struck cell, but insufficient charge was collected at the adjacent cell to cause upset. The mechanism for multiple-bit upset in the simulated SRAMs thus was found to be diffusion from between-cell strikes, similar to the DRAM results [60]. For grazing angles of incidence and very closely-spaced cells, however, drift collection and funneling can be expected to play greater roles.
Figure 3.13. Physical map of a cluster of errors due to single-event multiple-bit upset in a 256K DRAM [110]. Error locations are shown as solid black capacitor regions, while outlined capacitor regions indicate bits without errors. II-24
4 µm D ra in
xx
x
xx
D ra in
x x x
T1
G a te
x x x x x x
G a te
T2
S o urc e
S o urc e
S trik e h e re u p s e ts bo th c e lls S trike h e re up s e ts a s in g le ce ll
Figure 3.14. Simulated multiple-bit upset map for two adjacent SRAM cells [60]. For this SRAM, diffusion of charge from ion strikes between cells is responsible for MBU.
3.7
Particle Energy Effects
Heavy-ion tests at accelerator facilities are frequently performed to study mechanisms of SEU, estimate on-orbit error rates, and qualify parts for use in space-based systems. In most facilities used for such SEU testing, the energy of the particles is on the order of a few (1-10) MeV per nucleon (or equivalently, MeV/amu). However, in the actual space environment, the energy of particles reaches hundreds of GeV/amu, with a peak flux at a few hundred MeV/amu [1]. Figure 3.15 shows the galactic cosmic ray energy spectrum for Fe ions in a geostationary orbit at solar minimum conditions behind 100 mil of Al shielding [118]. The range of ion energies available at typical low-energy accelerators such as the Tandem Van de Graaff at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) is marked by the light gray band. Higher energy ions (10-100 MeV/amu) are available at a few facilities, for example the GANIL cyclotron in France and the National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory (NSCL) at Michigan State University. The range of ions available at these facilities is marked by the darker gray band in Figure 3.15. Note that even the “high” energy facilities produce ions with energies well below the maximum encountered in space. The linear energy transfer (LET) of the Fe ions as a function of energy is denoted in Figure 3.15 by the shading of the symbols. The usual low-energy test facilities produce ions with energies where they have maximum LET (greater than 20 MeV-cm2/mg for the case of Fe) but lower fluences in space. Ions with intermediate energies (10-100 MeV/amu) are much more abundant and can still possess large enough LETs (between 5 and 20 MeVcm2/mg for Fe) to be of concern, especially for sensitive commercial technologies. Note also that spacecraft shielding becomes ineffective with increased ion energy [1]. Extremely high-energy ions usually have low LETs (less than 0.2 MeV-cm2/mg for Fe) and therefore do not pose a serious SEU threat except for very sensitive devices. At a given LET, a high-energy cosmic ion track will have a much larger radius and much longer range than a low-energy accelerator ion track. This might lead to different chargeII-25
Ion Fluence (#/cm2/day/MeV/amu)
100 2
Ion LET (MeV-cm /mg) 0.2 5
10-1
20
10-2 10-3 10-4
"High" Low Energy Energy Test Test Range Range (GANIL (BNL) & MSU)
10-5 10-6 10-1
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
Energy (MeV/amu) Figure 3.15. Galactic cosmic ray iron spectrum vs. energy with LET denoted by symbol shading [118]. Ion energies available at typical accelerator facilities range from approximately 1-100 MeV/amu. collection properties, and hence, different SEU response. Recent SEU tests at high-energy accelerator facilities have indeed suggested a difference in IC response to particles with different energies. For example, differences between low- and high-energy ion tests have been seen to date in SEU thresholds and saturation cross-sections [119,120], single-event multiple-bit upset (MBU) occurrence [111,121,122], and unexplained inconsistencies in single-event burnout data [123]. Yet, in some cases, no appreciable difference has been observed between low- and highenergy heavy ion data [124-126]. The results that show differences are worrisome in that they raise concerns about the fidelity of accelerator-based tests for simulating the response of parts to the real high-energy ion environment found in space [127,128]. There are certainly cases where low-energy and high-energy ions have unambiguously given different test results. In these cases, however, it is the greatly increased range of high-energy ions that has led to differences rather than radial track structure effects. For example, in grazing angle irradiations, the greatly increased track-length of high-energy ions leads to multiple-bit upsets of many more cells along the track than would be seen with the shorter range of low-energy ions [111,121]. There may be other cases where the larger range of high-energy ions leads to different results, such as cases where the ions must pass through a great deal of material to reach the sensitive region [129]. Devices with vertical structures (e.g., power MOSFETs) may be sensitive to charge collection deep within the substrate and may exhibit interesting energy effects [130]. A recent study using carefully controlled experiments demonstrated that for four CMOS SRAM technologies, no significant differences were observed between low- and high-energy II-26
heavy ion SEU data [118]. For example, Figures 3.16 and 3.17 show low- and high-energy data for two of the tested technologies, a 256Kb SRAM and a 1Mb SRAM. Within experimental uncertainty, the cross-section data measured with low-energy ions (open symbols) and highenergy ions (solid symbols) appear the same. In the few inconclusive cases where there may have been small differences, the low-energy ion data were always conservative compared to the highenergy data. This suggests that standard low-energy ion testing is sufficiently (but not overly) conservative for CMOS SRAM technologies down to 0.5 µm (the smallest technology tested). The results were explained by the fact that the track structures of low- and high-energy ions are not greatly different except in the outer regions where they have low charge density. Due to the large radial extent of the track, high-energy ions might be expected to cause more MBUs than equivalent low-energy ions. The authors of [118] therefore examined their highenergy SEU data for evidence of MBUs. None of the almost 4000 error maps taken at low- and high-energy facilities showed physically adjacent upset locations. Unfortunately, only about 400 of the error maps were from high-energy facilities, but none of these maps gave evidence of an increase in normal-incidence MBUs due to high-energy ions. Of course, at grazing angles of incidence we would expect a big difference between low- and high-energy MBU results due to range effects. In the future it is possible that there will be devices sensitive to the low induced charge densities in the outer regions of high-energy ion tracks, but this does not appear to be the case yet. If such effects do appear, they may manifest themselves as an increase in the cross-section for high-energy ions as devices become more sensitive to indirect strikes that do not hit the junction [118]. These results validate the continued use of standard low-energy heavy ion test facilities such as the BNL Tandem Van de Graaff and the Berkeley 88" Cyclotron for part testing
Cross-section (cm2 )
100 10-1 10-2 Matra 65656 256Kb SRAM All SNs VDD = 4.5 V
10-3 10-4
Brookhaven GANIL MSU
-5
10
10-6 0
10
20
30
40
2
Effective LET (MeV-cm /mg) Figure 3.16. High- vs. low-energy SEU cross-sections for 256Kb SRAMs manufactured in a 0.8-µm radiation-tolerant technology [118]. II-27
Cross-section (cm2 )
100 10-1 10-2 Matra 65608E 1Mb SRAM VDD = 4.5 V
10-3 10-4
Brookhaven GANIL MSU
-5
10
10-6 0
10
20
30
40
2
Effective LET (MeV-cm /mg) Figure 3.17. High- vs. low-energy SEU cross-sections for 1Mb SRAMs manufactured in a 0.5-µm radiation-tolerant technology [118]. and qualification. This is important because the low-energy facilities are in general much better developed as user facilities, more accessible, and considerably cheaper to use. There are cases (e.g., grazing angle of incidence studies) where the use of high-energy ions is essential because of their increased range, and it is possible that in the future energy effects will become more significant. It is also possible that other device types or materials will prove to be more sensitive to energy effects than the Si CMOS SRAMs tested here. Based on the similarity in low-energy and high-energy ion track structures this seems unlikely, but cannot be positively ruled out. For the present, it appears that in most cases standard low-energy heavy-ion test methods are adequate to qualify similar technologies for current spacecraft use. 3.8
Mitigation Techniques
SEU mitigation techniques can be roughly classified into three distinct categories. Systemlevel techniques deal with SEU at the system architecture level. Circuit-level techniques rely on changes in the circuit design to reduce SEU sensitivity. Technology- or device-level hardening requires fundamental changes to the underlying fabrication technology used to manufacture ICs. Because they flow directly from the basic mechanisms of SEU, we will concentrate on technology hardening methods and give only a brief description of circuit- and system-level hardening. A review of several hardening techniques is also found in [131]. 3.8.1
Technology Hardening
The most fundamental method for hardening against SEU is to reduce charge collection at sensitive nodes. This can be accomplished in DRAMs and SRAMs by introducing extra doping layers to limit substrate charge collection [132]. In advanced SRAMs, triple-well [133] and even II-28
quadruple-well [134] structures have been proposed to decrease SEU sensitivity. Retrograde wells and buried layers can also be used to provide an internal electric field that opposes substrate charge collection [135,136]. Even the simple use of an epitaxial substrate instead of a bulk substrate affords some level of reduced charge collection [60,83]. In GaAs-based heterojunction insulated gate FETs (HIGFETs), the use of GaAs buffer layers grown at low temperatures (LT GaAs) has proven a very effective means of limiting charge collection [44,137,138]. The LT GaAs buffer layer prevents charge-enhancement mechanisms and substantially reduces charge collection (by as much as a factor of 100 [44]) because of its subpicosecond minority carrier lifetimes [139]. Figure 3.18 shows measured drain charge-collection transients for 3-MeV α-particle strikes, illustrating the dramatic reduction in charge collection for the LT GaAs HIGFET [44]. An effective technique for reducing charge collection in silicon devices is the use of SOI substrates [140]. In this case the collection volume is reduced by the fact that the active device is fabricated in a thin silicon layer that is dielectrically isolated from the substrate. A diagram of a thin-film partially-depleted SOI transistor is shown in Figure 3.19. In a typical thin-film SOI device, the source and drain penetrate all the way to the buried isolation oxide (BOX). This substantially reduces the SEU-sensitive area, because the reverse-biased drain junction area is limited to the depletion region between the drain and the body of the transistor, as shown in Fig. 3.19. Charge deposited in the silicon substrate underneath the BOX cannot be collected at the drain due to the dielectric isolation. Unfortunately, as briefly mentioned in Section 3.2.2, charge deposited in the body region (for example, by a particle strike to the gate region) can trigger a bipolar mechanism that limits the SEU hardness of SOI circuits [71,140]. Following a
Figure 3.18. Measured charge-collection transients in LT GaAs and conventional GaAs HIGFETs following a 3-MeV alpha-particle strike [44]. Charge collection is greatly reduced by the incorporation of the LT GaAs buffer layer. II-29
Gate
STI
n+ Source
n+ Drain
p Body Buried Oxide
~2000 A STI ~2000 A
Substrate
Figure 3.19. Diagram of a thin-film partially-depleted n-channel SOI transistor. The chargecollection volume is greatly reduced because the top silicon active layer is very thin. Unfortunately, ion strikes to the body region can initiate a bipolar conduction mechanism that limits the SEU hardness of SOI circuits. particle strike to the body of an n-channel SOI transistor, electrons can be collected at the source and drain electrodes. Holes can only escape through the body tie contact, if there is one, or slowly through recombination if there is no body tie. Residual holes left in the body raise the body potential and trigger the lateral parasitic bipolar transistor inherent to the SOI transistor, with the source serving as the emitter, the body as the base, and the drain as the collector. This bipolar current considerably lowers the SEU hardness of SOI and can even lead to a single-event induced latch-up condition in SOI transistors without body ties if the bipolar conduction is sustained [72]. Body ties are sometimes used commercially to reduce floating-body effects under DC operation, and careful attention to body tie design is crucial to maintaining good SEU performance [71,141146]. Even in body-tied SOI designs, manufacturers have found it necessary to incorporate other hardening methods for applications where very high upset thresholds are desired [147,148]. Fully-depleted SOI transistors exhibit reduced floating-body effects, and have shown excellent SEU performance [149]. Given an understanding of the upset mechanism in SRAMs, we can immediately understand another typical technology-level technique used to harden SRAMs against SEU. We have discussed (Section 3.4) how the SEU process in an SRAM is essentially a race condition between the feedback and recovery processes. To harden an SRAM, we need to either slow the feedback process or decrease the recovery time. The feedback process can be slowed by adding either resistance or capacitance to the feedback loop [150]. Cross-coupled feedback resistors (see Fig. 3.9) are the classical method of increasing the cell feedback time by increasing the RC delay in the feedback loop. Unfortunately, because the SEU process in SRAMs looks just like the write process, this same RC delay directly impacts the write pulse width of the SRAM. The resistive decoupling technique is very effective, as illustrated in Figure 3.20. This figure shows the measured SEU cross-section (area of the chip sensitive to SEU) as a function of LET for a microprocessor before and after hardening by resistive decoupling [101]. The predicted upset rate in a geosynchronous orbit for the unhardened microprocessor is about once a day, while in the resistively-hardened part it is about once per century. Unfortunately, the effectiveness of resistive hardening does not come without a price. We have already mentioned the speed penalty incurred by adding feedback resistors. Probably even
II-30
Figure 3.20. Measured SEU cross-section of a 16-bit commercial microprocessor showing the effectiveness of resistive hardening for mitigating SEU [101]. worse than this penalty is the increased process complexity introduced by adding feedback resistors. These resistors are typically implemented in the cell layout as lightly-doped polysilicon regions. Because the resistivity of polysilicon is very sensitive to the doping concentration and numerous other factors, it is very difficult to control the resistor value [151]. Rockett reports that SEU feedback resistor variance may be as much as half the mean value [152]. To add to this problem, polysilicon resistivity has a negative temperature dependence. This leads to a temperature dependence of both the write speed and the SEU response. As low temperature, the feedback resistance increases, providing good SEU performance, but slowing the maximum operating frequency. At higher temperature, the part operates faster, but the SEU threshold drops. These characteristics make it challenging to optimize a resistively-hardened technology so that it will operate within specifications across a wide temperature range. A variation on the resistive hardening method is the use of gated resistors (essentially thinfilm polysilicon transistors) as a feedback element [152]. The advantage of this approach is that during a write pulse the feedback resistance can be lowered to reduce the impact of the feedback element on operating speed. A diagram of the gated resistor-hardened SRAM cell is shown in Figure 3.21. During a write operation, the resistor gates are clocked into a low-resistance condition by the wordline pulse, greatly improving the write speed over a standard resistivelyhardened SRAM. At all other times the resistors are in their “off” (high-resistance) state and protect against SEU in the usual manner. The gated-resistor SRAM is therefore faster than a standard resistively-hardened SRAM, has reduced temperature dependence, and may require no additional area to implement [152]. It does, however, require two levels of polysilicon, which although fairly common, are not present in all technologies. II-31
Figure 3.21. Diagram of a gated-resistor hardened SRAM [152]. Clocking the gated resistor with the wordline reduces the feedback resistance during write pulses, thereby minimizing the timing penalties usually associated with feedback resistors. A similar, but distinct, approach has been used to harden high-density SRAMs in SOI [153]. In this approach an extra transistor is fabricated in the silicon device layer in parallel with a standard cross-coupled polysilicon feedback resistor. Under normal operation, this transistor is off, and the feedback signal must pass through the resistor in the usual manner. During a write pulse, the transistor is turned on, effectively shorting out the feedback resistor and maintaining the write performance of the memory cell. Other decoupling techniques have been proposed that place resistors or diodes in different locations [154-157], usually for the purpose of reducing the impact of the resistors on timing parameters or increasing manufacturability. For the most part these techniques have not been widely used (if at all) and have their own associated tradeoffs. Capacitors have been successfully used as a feedback element in SOI SRAMs [140,147,148], and very recently as a means to improve the soft-error performance of deep-submicron CMOS SRAMs for terrestrial applications [158]. While adding capacitance still degrades timing parameters, one advantage is reduced temperature-dependence compared to resistive hardening. 3.8.2
Circuit- and System-Level Hardening
Because of the invasive nature of device-level hardening (i.e., the requirement for fundamental changes in the manufacturing process), easier to implement methods have been a frequent topic of research. The goal of circuit-level hardening techniques is to design circuits that are inherently SEU-hardened and can therefore be manufactured using any commercial fabrication process. Also sometimes referred to as design-level hardening, this can be an important technique in cases when parts from a radiation-hardened technology are not available II-32
[159]. Several design-hardened SRAM and latch circuits have been proposed and fabricated [160-165]. These memory cells typically rely on redundant circuit elements (usually 12-16 transistors per memory cell as opposed to 6 in a standard unhardened cell) to protect against SEU. Because of the large number of transistors per cell, these designs consume considerably more area (and frequently more power) than 6 transistor cells. While these cells can be appropriate for protecting a limited number of critical data paths, they are not usually suitable for very highly-integrated circuits. A design-hardened SEU tolerant DRAM cell that is comparable in size to conventional single transistor DRAMs has also been proposed [166]. System-level hardening approaches include the use of error detection and correction (EDAC) circuitry to monitor and correct errors as they occur [167-169]. This approach requires that extra bits of information be stored with the data to reconstruct the original data in the event of an upset. System overhead can be non-negligible, but this is sometimes the only method available if relatively susceptible parts must be used. Cruder methods such as watchdog timers, redundancy, lockstep operation, majority voting, etc., are commonly used to detect control system errors [170]. While simple in concept, overhead can again be significant, but in many cases this is the only option available to the spacecraft engineer. Last year’s NSREC Short Course segment by Kinnison and this year’s segment by Heidergott contain additional information on system-level hardening methodology [170,171].
II-33
4.0
BASIC MECHANISMS FOR DESTRUCTIVE SINGLE-EVENT EFFECTS
In this section we will briefly discuss mechanisms for destructive SEE, namely single-event latchup (SEL), single-event gate rupture (SEGR), and single-event burnout (SEB). This is not intended to be a complete list of destructive SEE failure modes, but are some of the more commonly encountered effects. For a more comprehensive discussion of destructive SEE, the reader is directed to the recent NSREC Short Course segment by Johnson and Galloway [172]. 4.1
Single-Event Latchup
It is well-documented that in semiconductors with a p/n/p/n structure, a high-current destructive failure mode known as latchup can occur [173]. Unfortunately, just such a structure occurs in all CMOS technologies when an n-channel transistor is located next to a p-channel transistor, such as in a CMOS inverter used in an SRAM. The p/n/p/n structure can be thought of as a connection of two parasitic bipolar junction transistors (BJTs), as illustrated in Figure 4.1 [174]. For the CMOS structure shown in this figure, a parasitic lateral npn transistor is formed by the n-channel source (emitter), p-substrate (base), and n-well (collector). Similarly, a parasitic vertical pnp transistor is formed by the p-channel source (emitter), n-well (base), and p-substrate (collector). Note that the collector of each parasitic BJT is the base region of its counterpart. This leads to a positive feedback loop between the two transistors, although in normal operation both transistors are in an “off” condition. Depending on interdevice spacing, junction depths, doping densities, etc., the parasitic BJTs can be turned “on” and the positive feedback loop can be activated by a device overvoltage, improper sequencing of power supplies, or the presence of a large substrate or n-well current [173]. Once triggered, the device goes into a sustained highcurrent mode that can destroy the device due to thermal runaway or failure of metallization [174].
Figure 4.1. Illustration of the parasitic latchup structure inherent to bulk CMOS technologies [174]. II-34
Usually it is necessary to reduce or remove power from a device in a latched state to return it to normal operation before destructive failure. 4.1.1
Single-Event Latchup Mechanism
The astute reader will note that one of the triggering mechanisms for latchup listed above was well or substrate currents. This is, of course, exactly what one has in the case of an energetic particle strike, so it should not be surprising that latchup can indeed be initiated by a single-event strike. Single-event latchup (SEL) was observed in ground tests as early as 1979 [175], and at first was limited to heavy ions and bulk technologies. As technology parameters evolved, it was found that some devices fabricated on epitaxial substrates could exhibit latchup [176], and worse still, that protons could induce latchup in sensitive technologies [177-179]. It is beyond our purpose here to give a comprehensive discussion of all that is known on SEL. The reader is referred to many excellent reviews and analyses of the subject for further information [172,174-178,180-186]. As mentioned above, the latchup condition is triggered when the parasitic BJTs inherent in CMOS turn “on”, establishing a positive feedback loop. For SEL, the triggering involves four distinct steps, as described by Johnston, et al. [174]: 1) The particle strike induces a transient current in the well-substrate junction, which in turn results in a voltage drop within the well. The magnitude of the voltage drop depends on the resistivity of the well, well depth, and distance of the strike from the well tie contact. 2) If the voltage drop in the well is large enough, the vertical parasitic BJT becomes forward biased and magnifies current flow into the substrate due to bipolar amplification. 3) Current flowing in the substrate from the vertical BJT produces a voltage drop in the substrate, which in turn forward biases the lateral BJT. Collector current from the lateral BJT provides base current to the vertical BJT, initiating the positive feedback process. 4) Once the regenerative feedback process begins, current increases rapidly and the device can remain latched even after the subsidence of the original particle-induced current. References [174,180,186] give further details of the charge-collection process and initiation of SEL. 4.1.2
Mitigation Techniques
Like almost any single-event effect, techniques have been developed to mitigate the occurrence of SEL. One difference with SEL is that since latchup can also be initiated by electrical signals in normal terrestrial ICs, it is not unique to the space environment. This means that high-volume commercial IC manufacturers also have to deal with latchup on their own accord. Unfortunately, it does not follow that just because an IC is latchup immune in normal environments it will also be latchup free in space [174]. However, the same general techniques that improve latchup characteristics on the ground can usually be expected to improve the SEL response in space environments. The keys to decreasing latchup susceptibility are to decrease the ability of the parasitic BJTs to become forward biased, and to decrease the current gain of the BJTs should they become forward biased. Factors which make it harder to forward bias the BJTs include increasing the substrate and well doping levels (heavier doping decreases series resistance and hence limits II-35
voltage drops) and increasing the well thickness (thicker decreases resistance and again limits voltage drops). Using an epitaxial substrate can decrease latchup sensitivity both by limiting the charge-collection volume, and by decreasing the substrate series resistance. Increasing the spacing between devices lowers the current gain of the lateral BJT (basically by increasing the base thickness), and increasing the well thickness can do the same for the vertical BJT. While at first it seemed that fabrication on epitaxial substrates was enough to eliminate latchup, this can no longer be considered to be the case. Figure 4.2 shows a compilation of data where the latchup threshold LET for several devices and technologies is plotted against the epitaxial layer thickness. The data were compiled from [186,187] after the method of [174]. Because latchup depends on a diverse set of process and layout parameters, there is no clear trend, and in fact one of the most SEL-sensitive parts ever tested is an AMD K-5 microprocessor (latchup threshold = 0.4 MeV-cm2/mg) fabricated on a very thin (2.5 µm) epitaxial substrate [186]. This unexpected result indicates that SEL could become a serious concern for advanced devices that may be designed with very little margin to the latchup point. Other technology changes which decrease latchup susceptibility include the use of retrograde wells and trench isolation [188,189]. The effectiveness of trench isolation for decreasing latchup sensitivity depends heavily on the trench depth, with deeper trenches preventing latchup better than shallow trenches. In technologies such as CMOS/SOI or CMOS/SOS, the latchup path can be completely eliminated due to total dielectric isolation between adjacent devices [190]. Guard bands have been used to lower latchup sensitivity [180,191,192], as have neutron-irradiated substrates to kill parasitic BJT gain [193].
AMD K-5 (0.35 mm)
Figure 4.2. Latchup threshold as a function of epitaxial layer thickness for several technologies [174]. The AMD K-5 is one of the most single-event latchup-sensitive parts that has been tested, even though it is fabricated on a thin epitaxial substrate. II-36
4.2
Single-Event Gate Rupture
Dielectric breakdown can occur when the electric field across an insulating material exceeds some threshold value. When initiated by an energetic particle strike to the gate region of an MOS device, this phenomenon is referred to as a single-event gate rupture (SEGR). In this section we will present the basic mechanism for SEGR, and discuss recent results obtained in power MOSFETs and devices with thin gate oxides. 4.2.1
Single-Event Gate Rupture Mechanism
Single-event gate rupture has been studied most extensively for power devices such as double-diffused power MOSFETs (DMOS), so we will use this device for describing the SEGR mechanism. As shown in Figure 4.3, current flow in the DMOS structure is vertical rather than lateral as in a standard MOSFET [194,195]. Application of a positive bias to the gate in this nchannel DMOSFET inverts the p-body region to form a channel between the n-source at the top of the structure and the drain (substrate) contact at the bottom of the structure. To handle large currents, the full structure usually contains hundreds or thousands of these cells connected in parallel. The thick lightly-doped epitaxial region allows the power MOSFET to sustain high voltages without breakdown. When an ion strikes the neck region through the gate oxide, SEGR can occur as charge is transported near the Si/SiO2 interface. As charge from the ion strike accumulates underneath the gate region (and depending on the gate bias), the electric field in the gate insulator can temporarily increase to above the critical field to breakdown, causing a localized dielectric failure (i.e., an SEGR). The SEGR response in vertical power MOSFETs has two components [196]. The “capacitor response” describes the interaction of the ion directly with the gate dielectric, inducing an oxide breakdown at a lower field than would occur in the absence of the ion strike. If a drain bias is applied when the ion strike occurs, part of the drain voltage Io n P a th neck
G a te
p+
S o u rc e
n+ p
n+ p
p+
ho le s ele ctron s n ep ila ye r n + s u bs tra te
D ra in
Figure 4.3. Structure of a vertical power MOSFET and current flow paths following a heavy ion strike [195]. II-37
may be transferred through the epitaxial layer to the gate interface [194]. This part of the response is referred to as the “substrate response.” Increasing the gate voltage increases susceptibility to SEGR through the capacitor response by increasing the pre-existing electric field in the oxide. Increasing the drain voltage also increases the susceptibility to SEGR because part of this voltage can be coupled to the interface through the substrate response. 4.2.2
Single-Event Gate Rupture in Power MOSFETs
Typical SEGR data taken for vertical power MOSFETs include the critical field to dielectric breakdown as a function of LET [197]. Note that because SEGR is a destructive event, obtaining such data requires that many devices be destroyed during the experiment. Semi-empirical expressions that relate the voltage threshold for SEGR as a function of bias conditions, oxide thickness, and incident particle LET have been developed for specific devices and fit measured SEGR data very well [197,198]. As implied above, the sensitive region for SEGR in vertical power MOSFETs is the neck region under the gate contact, since this is where high fields exist in an oxide. Much of this gate area is not necessary to device operation, and recent studies have proposed eliminating parts of the gate polysilicon (e.g., the cross-hatched region in Fig. 4.3) to decrease the area sensitive to SEGR [199]. Two interesting recent papers have studied the effects of ion energy on SEGR in vertical power MOSFETs [196,200]. The first of these showed that the substrate response had a clear dependence on ion energy [200]. As ion energy increased, the maximum gate voltage that could be applied without producing SEGR decreased until the ion range was sufficient to penetrate the entire epitaxial layer. At this point the device was most sensitive to SEGR. The results were explained by the fact that this condition resulted in the maximum amount of charge being deposited into the epitaxial layer [200]. The authors noted that at zero drain bias (i.e., no substrate response component), there appeared to be no energy dependence of the SEGR gate bias threshold. This observation spurred further research to explicitly measure the capacitor response as a function of ion energy [196]. In this study, no apparent difference was found in the SEGR gate bias threshold as a function of ion, corroborating the earlier data. Data from this study are shown in Figure 4.4. Note the surprising result that the gate bias at the onset of SEGR does not track with the LET value, appearing to be a constant value regardless of the ion energy. Although the results are still not fully understood, the authors presented a new model for the critical gate field to cause SEGR in terms of the atomic number of the incident ion rather than its LET. Further study is necessary in this field to develop physical explanations for this result. 4.2.3
Single-Event Gate Rupture in Thin Gate Oxides
SEGR effects have been studied for some time in power devices, but a topic that has recently received a considerable amount interest is SEGR in logic and memory ICs. As gate oxide thicknesses decrease, SEGR could become a problem in ICs because they will likely be operated at somewhat higher electric fields. Hard errors have occasionally been observed during heavy ion tests of SRAMs, and have been attributed to local total ionizing dose deposition (“microdose”) [201-203]. In 1994, Swift et al. noted the occurrence of a new kind of hard error in 4 Mbit DRAMs that was clearly inconsistent with the microdose phenomenon [204]. For example, these errors did not disappear with high-temperature annealing and showed different retention-time characteristics than microdose hard errors. Other characteristics of the mechanism seemed
II-38
Figure 4.4. Energy dependence of SEGR failure threshold in vertical power MOSFETs for niobium ions [196]. The failure threshold is roughly constant even though the ion LET varies considerably over the energy range. consistent with SEGR failures, but the mechanism was not conclusively identified. Of particular concern was the fact that 4 Mbit DRAMs from the same manufacturer that had undergone a die shrink (0.8 µm to 0.6 µm) were even more sensitive to SEGR, showing hard errors at lower LET and with a much greater cross-section. The electric fields at which ruptures were observed were less than 3 MV/cm. These results led Johnston et al. to conclude that SEGR could become a major failure mechanism for scaled microelectronics in space [205]. Below a feature size of about 0.25 µm, it was predicted that the threshold LET for SEGR would fall below that of Fe, a significant component of the galactic cosmic ray flux. If this were to happen, the SEGR error rate in space would increase several orders of magnitude, making the usage of deep submicron devices in space problematical. This prediction has inspired recent research into scaling trends and mechanisms for SEGR in thin gate oxides [206-209]. The first of these studies investigated the impact of oxide thickness on the critical electric field to rupture in gate oxide capacitors and CMOS ICs [206]. The authors found much higher critical fields to rupture than in [204]. Their results for gate oxide capacitors with an area of ~10-3 cm2 are shown in Figure 4.5 as a function of particle LET and gate oxide thickness. The critical field for SEGR is higher than 5 MV/cm in all cases, and decreasing the oxide thickness increases the critical field for SEGR at any given LET. Similar trends were observed for 16 Kbit and 256 Kbit SRAMs and 12-stage delay chains, although the critical fields to rupture were somewhat lower [206]. The thinnest oxides in Figure 4.5 have critical fields approaching 8 MV/cm, suggesting that advanced technologies may in fact show improved resistance to SEGR. This improvement in critical field to rupture II-39
12
ECR (MV/cm)
10 8
6.5 nm 6.0 nm
6
12 nm 18 nm
4 2 0 20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
2
LET (MeV-cm /mg) Figure 4.5. Critical field to SEGR in thin oxide capacitors as a function of ion LET [206]. correlated well to improved breakdown field strengths prior to irradiation, due to reduced defect generation by hot carriers in thin oxides. It was cautioned, however, that future voltage scaling is highly uncertain and if fields do exceed 5 MV/cm, SEGR could still be a significant concern. Another issue is that not all gate oxides can be expected to behave the same. Oxides from different processes have in fact exhibited different critical fields to rupture. In [207], for example, capacitors with 4.5-nm and 7.5-nm gate oxides from a different process showed much lower critical fields to SEGR compared to the data of [206], although the qualitative trend was similar. As noted by the authors, these differences due to processing make it difficult to conclusively establish whether in the future SEGR will be a problem for a particular technology operating at a specific oxide thickness and power supply voltage. It does appear, however, that the preirradiation dielectric breakdown field strengths are a reliable indicator of relative SEGR vulnerability. Regardless of processing technology, the published data all confirm that for a given oxide thickness, the higher the pre-irradiation breakdown field, the higher the critical field to SEGR [206,208,209]. Clearly there are some technologies where the critical field to SEGR is in the range of 5-6 MeV/cm, at least for high LET ions. Whether SEGR will in fact be a problem in the future depends on many factors, including what voltage scaling trends are actually adopted and if alternative dielectric materials are used [208]. Recent work has probed not only scaling trends, but also the underlying mechanisms for SEGR in thin gate oxides [208,209]. Based on a limited amount of data for varying ion fluences, earlier work suggested that multiple ion hits might be necessary to initiate SEGR [207]. More extensive data gathered since then conclusively show that there is at most a small effect of fluence per irradiation step on the SEGR threshold. Figure 4.6 shows the critical voltage to rupture measured in capacitors with a 7-nm oxide as a function of the number of ions received per irradiation step [209]. There is only a very weak dependence: 15% difference in critical II-40
voltage to SEGR over more than three orders of magnitude of fluence per step. Two pre-stress points are also marked on the plot. For these two points, capacitors were pre-stressed at zero bias with a fluence of 2×108 ions/cm2. Even after this enormous pre-stress†, the voltage to rupture remained unchanged. These data strongly support a true single-ion model for gate rupture [209]. Although SEGR appears to be a true single-ion effect, there is no question that an accumulated fluence of particles does introduce damage to the oxide. This damage (termed precursor ion damage in [209]) does not affect the SEGR threshold, but does increase capacitor leakage currents. Figure 4.7 shows measured I-V curves for a 7-nm capacitor after exposure to successive fluences of Au ions at increasing bias voltages [209]. The fluence step between each curve is 106 ions/cm2. At irradiation bias voltages below 3.7 V, increasing leakage currents beyond 2 V are observed with accumulated particle fluence. This leakage current is associated with precursor ion damage. After 3.7 V was applied during the heavy ion exposure the capacitor’s I-V curve changed dramatically, with the leakage current increasing by four orders of magnitude. This pronounced change in the I-V curve is the characteristic signature of SEGR. The critical voltage to SEGR in this 7-nm oxide capacitor for 360-MeV Au ions is thus 3.7 V. Accumulated fluence damage effects such as those shown before rupture in Fig. 4.7 are an interesting topic to study from a basic mechanisms standpoint. However, the data show that precursor ion damage and SEGR in thin oxides are largely unrelated effects. Also, because of the very low flux of high-LET particles in the near-Earth environment (on the order of 7 Br
6
VCR (V)
5 Au
4 3 2
After prestress of 2E8 ions/cm2 w/ no bias
1
Nominal Fluence
0 1
10
100
1000
10000
Average Ions/Step Figure 4.6. Critical voltage to rupture as a function of heavy ion fluence per step [209]. Only a weak dependence of the rupture voltage is observed over more than three orders of magnitude of particle fluence per step. †
For reference, it would take roughly the present age of the universe to accumulate a fluence of high-LET particles this large in the near-Earth environment.
II-41
10-4
Gate Current (A)
10-5
Area = 0.0025 cm2
Irradiation Bias Pre 3.0 V 3.2 V 3.3 V 3.4 V 3.5 V 3.6 V 3.7 V
10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 0
1
2
3
4
5
Gate Voltage (V) Figure 4.7. Thin oxide capacitor current-voltage characteristics after successive 106 ions/cm2 irradiations with increasing gate bias [209]. Precursor ion damage is evidenced by the increasing gate current above 2 V as ion fluence was accumulated. The sudden increased current at all voltages for the 3.7-V irradiation is the characteristic signature of SEGR; this capacitor had a SEGR failure threshold of 3.7 V. 0.4 ions/cm2/year with LET ≥ 40 MeV-cm2/mg), precursor ion damage is not expected to have any practical impact on reliability in space. For further information on particle-induced damage effects in thermal and nitrided oxides, the reader is directed to [209]. SEGR has been investigated in oxides thinner than 5 nm [208,209]. These oxides can behave fundamentally differently than thicker oxides. Specifically, they often exhibit a soft breakdown characteristic rather than the hard breakdown shown in Fig. 4.7. For example, 4.5-nm oxide capacitors tested in [208] showed soft breakdown leakage currents on the order of tens to hundreds of µA, compared to 1-10 mA rupture currents observed in identical capacitors with 7.5-nm oxides. Similarly, 5-nm oxide capacitors tested in [209] typically showed only a gradual increase in leakage current similar to precursor ion damage buildup, even at fields as high as 12 MV/cm. For a few capacitors clear rupture signatures were obtained, but these were rare. In cases such as these, the ability to sweep full I-V curves at the irradiation site is invaluable, as simple current monitoring is not very instructive. Interestingly, reliability studies of very thin oxides often show similar soft breakdown characteristics [210]. Another recent result of interest is the angular dependence of SEGR in thin oxides. Traditionally, normal incidence is considered to be the worst-case ion trajectory for SEGR, with the critical voltage to rupture showing a somewhat less than cos(θ) dependence [194]. In early work on SEGR, Wrobel predicted that the angular dependence would disappear when the oxide thickness approached the diameter of the ion track [211]. In [209], the authors investigated the angular dependence of the critical field to rupture as a function of oxide thickness. Their results II-42
are shown in Figure 4.8, where the critical field has been normalized to the value at normal incidence. The results clearly show that the angular dependence of SEGR does indeed disappear for thin oxides. The fact that off-normal ion strikes are effective at producing SEGR increases the threat environment in the isotropic heavy ion environment of space, and this must be accounted for when estimating SEGR susceptibility for thin oxides [209]. The angular data have been explained in terms of ion track structure, and an analytical model for the angular dependence based on a conductive pipe mechanism has been proposed [209]. 4.3
Single-Event Burnout
Single-event burnout (SEB) due to heavy ions, neutrons, and protons has been observed in both vertical power MOSFETs and bipolar transistors [194,195,212-216]. Similar to single-event latchup, SEB is a destructive failure mechanism that comes about due to a parasitic bipolar transistor structure inherent to some devices. Looking again at the power MOSFET structure in Fig. 4.3, a parasitic bipolar transistor is formed by the n-source (emitter), p-body (base), and nepitaxial (collector) regions. Following an ion strike, currents flowing in the p-body can forward bias the emitter-base junction of the parasitic BJT due to the finite conductivity of the p-body region. The parasitic BJT is now operating in the forward active regime, and if the drain-tosource voltage is higher than the breakdown voltage (BVCEO) of the parasitic BJT, avalanche multiplication of the BJT collector current can occur. If this positive feedback (regenerative) current is not limited, it can lead to junction heating and the eventual burnout of the device [212].
2.5 Normalized ECR (MV/cm)
283-MeV Br LET ~ 37 MeV-cm2/mg 1/cos(θ)
2.0
19.2 nm Wrobel '87
1.5
18 nm 12 nm
1.0
7 nm
1
2
3
1/cos(θ) Figure 4.8. Angular dependence of the critical field to rupture for oxides of varying thickness [209]. The angular dependence disappears as the oxide thickness approaches the diameter of the 283-MeV bromine ion track. II-43
One fortunate difference between SEB and SEGR is that non-destructive test procedures exist for SEB. In the simpler of these techniques, a load resistor attached to the drain of the MOSFET provides current limiting and prevents destructive SEB [217]. Current pulses at the source can be counted as SEB events and the SEB cross-section can be non-destructively obtained as a function of either the drain voltage or the particle LET. A newer technique, called Energetic ParticleInduced Charge Spectroscopy (EPICS), measures the collected charge from SEB events rather than sensing current pulses [218]. This technique was developed to give more information on the triggering mechanisms responsible for SEB, and has offered experimental confirmation of the mechanisms described above. An example of results using EPICS for power MOSFETs is shown in Figure 4.9 [218]. At low drain voltages (Fig. 4.9a), a single peak at a collected charge of about 10 pC was observed and corresponded to charge collection in the depletion layer. At moderate drain voltages (Fig. 4.9b), a second peak appears and indicates that the parasitic BJT has been turned on and the source is injecting current into the device. Note that the original peak also moves to the right (higher charge collection) somewhat. This movement was postulated to be due to avalanche multiplication of the primary ion-induced current [218]. At still higher drain voltages (Fig. 4.9c), the regenerative feedback mechanism is established and SEB occurs. This results in a new peak with 3-4 orders of magnitude more collected charge; this peak is the characteristic signature of SEB in EPICS measurements. A new variation on the EPICS technique was recently reported by Kuboyama, et al. [216]. In this study, the authors connected an EPICS system to both the base and collector electrodes of the bipolar transistors under test. Using the “2-dimensional” EPICS spectra, the authors were able to distinguish between SEB events due to ion strikes to different areas of the emitter.
Figure 4.9. Illustration of energetic particle induced charge spectroscopy (EPICS) technique for measuring single-event burnout [218]. II-44
Many other studies of SEB have been performed; not all of them can be summarized here. These include studies of the position-dependence of SEB [219], temperature-dependence of SEB [220], and hardening strategies [221-223]. The interested reader is directed to references [212223] and references therein for further information.
II-45
5.0
MODELING AND SIMULATION OF SINGLE-EVENT MECHANISMS
From the earliest history of numerical device modeling, the radiation effects community has recognized the value of computational modeling for providing insight into the effects of ionizing radiation on microelectronic devices. In fact, pioneering work on one-dimensional drift-diffusion numerical modeling was presented at the Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference as early as 1967 [224,225], winning the Best Paper award for that year [224]. This early work focused on transient radiation response, as single-event upset (SEU) would not be observed experimentally until almost 10 years later [226]. Given the consequences of SEU (potential loss of mission for space applications, a possible show-stopper for increased integration density in terrestrial memory cells), the rapid development of models to explain and predict radiation effects was essential. The development and use of numerical models for radiation effects has proceeded on many levels: the interaction of ionizing particles with matter, physical device simulators that predict the response of devices to incident radiation, circuit simulators that model circuit response to a single event, and codes that predict the error rate that will be observed for a specific part flying in particular orbit. In this short course segment we will only discuss the models that most directly pertain to the actual upset process itself, namely models for simulating ion track structure in semiconductors, and device/circuit models that predict the response of devices to the ion track. Models for predicting error rates have been covered elsewhere [19,22,227]. 5.1
Interaction Models
As discussed earlier, energetic particles can interact with an IC through either direct ionization or nuclear interactions. Computer codes have been developed that simulate spallation reactions and/or upset rates for protons, neutrons, and other cosmic ray components [36,228232]. Since spallation reactions eventually cause upset through the direct ionization process also, we will limit our discussion here to models that predict the direct ionization-induced ion track structure in the semiconductor. The reader is directed to the above references if they desire further information on the simulation of nuclear reactions. 5.1.1
Track Structure Models
An aspect of SEU and charge-collection simulation that has received considerable attention recently is that of the ion-strike track structure used as input to physical device simulation. Most work until the last few years has employed a simple cylinder of uniform charge generation to represent the ion strike. Detailed calculations of ion strike track structure have been performed using Monte Carlo methods [128,233]. As mentioned in Section 3.7, differences in the track structure between typical particles used in SEU experiments and high-energy particles which might be encountered in a real space environment have raised concerns over the fidelity of the operating environment simulated by accelerator tests [118,128]. Charge production around the path of an incident particle is accomplished by the release of energetic electrons (also referred to as delta rays) along the track, which subsequently travel away from the path and produce further electron-hole pairs. The higher the energy of the incident particle, the higher the energy of the delta rays and the larger the radial extent of the induced charge distribution. As it passes through the silicon device, the particle loses energy and hence II-46
the delta rays also become less energetic, releasing charge nearer the center of the path as the particle nears the end of its range. Incident particles therefore generate a characteristic coneshaped charge plasma in the silicon IC. Analytic models for ion track structure have been developed [234-236] and introduced to the radiation effects community [118,237,238]. These models are easy to implement as computer programs, and due to their analytic nature run very quickly. Analytic methods of computing track structure divide the target material into thin slabs perpendicular to the ion path. The incident ion and energy are specified, and the delta ray distribution and radial deposition of charge are calculated analytically in the first slab [237]. The particle energy is updated based on the energy deposition in the slab and the calculation proceeds to the next slab. In some codes, the LET in the slab is calculated by a call to a TRIM subroutine [18], and the energy is instead updated based on this LET and the thickness of the slab [118]. This method may be more accurate because the radial energy deposition tends to somewhat underestimate the energy loss in the slab, especially near the end of the ion path [237]. Analytical track structure codes have been extensively validated against available Monte Carlo results in the literature. Figure 5.1 compares the analytically-computed radial track structures of high- and low-energy ions that have the same incident LET of 11.4 MeV-cm2/mg: 210 MeV Cl and 5.04 GeV Kr [118]. The higher-energy ion strike is more nearly representative of a cosmic particle that might be encountered in the space environment, but such particles are difficult to achieve in typical laboratory particle accelerators. The Cl ion has an energy of 6 MeV/amu, and the Kr ion has an energy of 60 MeV/amu (ranges in silicon are 63.1 µm and 1.1 mm, respectively). The generated charge density at the silicon surface is shown, as a function of radius from the center of the ion track. Note that both axes of this figure are plotted on a log scale, and the charge density is very 1023
Charge Density (cm-3)
1022 210 MeV Chlorine
1021 1020 1019 1018 1017
5.04 GeV Krypton
1016 1015 1014 1013
Gaussian Approximation
1012 1011 0.001
0.01
0.1
1
10
100
Radial Distance (µm) Figure 5.1. High- and low-energy ion track radial charge distribution profiles [118]. Both ions have the same surface-incident LET. II-47
highly peaked about the center of the ion track. The maximum delta-ray radius at the surface for the 210 MeV Cl strike is about 1.9 µm, so beyond this point the generated charge density falls to zero. For the 5.04 GeV Kr strike the maximum delta-ray radius is about 100 µm, so a low density of carriers (with respect to the central core of the track) exists out to this point. For the highenergy Kr ion, the charge deposited beyond 1.9 µm amounts to less than 15% of the total. Since the curves have the same integral charge (i.e., the ions have the same surface-incident LET), this means the high-energy ion has 15% less charge in the central region of the track (evidenced in Figure 5.1 by the fact that the Kr curve is slightly underneath the Cl curve at small radii). If there were a difference in the SEU response caused by the two ions, one would expect the low-energy ion to be more upsetting since the track is slightly more concentrated and can deposit a greater amount of charge in a small sensitive volume [118]. For the high-energy ion, more charge is deposited at large distances where it may not be collected by the sensitive node [239]. Still, this is expected to be a small effect, since so little of the high-energy ion’s charge is deposited past the boundary of the low-energy ion’s path. For a given ion strike, there is also the more fundamental issue of variation of charge density along the path (i.e., LET is not constant as a function of depth, as seen in Fig. 3.1). Detailed studies of the importance of faithfully representing the track structure within device simulations have shown that it is important to include this effect [240,241]. Neglecting this effect can change the transient current response by as much as 20%, while various fits to the radial track structure typically produce less than a 5% change in the total charge collected for ion strikes on simple p/n diodes [241]. In any event, since the analytic track structures are relatively easy to compute, simulation track structures including at least the variation of LET along the path and reasonable estimates of radial charge distribution are recommended [240]. 5.2
Physics-Based Device Models
In previous sections, we have mentioned device modeling and in some cases shown device simulation results, but so far we have been deliberately vague about the actual techniques used for device modeling. In the present section we will remedy this situation and go into some detail into the actual device models used, what they tell us, and some interesting new developments in the field. Certainly the most commonly used formalism for device simulation is that of drift-diffusion models. In a drift-diffusion model, the semiconductor device equations are derived from the Boltzmann Transport Equation using numerous approximations. The equations to be solved are the Poisson equation and the current continuity equations [17], & (1) ∇ •ε E = ρ , & ∂n ∇ • Jn = q R − G + , ∂t
(2)
& ∂p ∇ • J p = q G − R − , ∂t
(3)
together with the constitutive relationships for current density (the actual drift-diffusion equations): II-48
& & J n = qnµ n E + qDn ∇n , & & J p = qpµ p E − qD p ∇p .
(4) (5)
& & In these equations, E and J are the electric field and current density vectors, ρ is the net charge density, R and G are carrier recombination and generation rates, and n and p are the electron and hole densities. In addition, q is the electronic charge, and µ and D are carrier mobility and diffusivity, respectively. These equations are discretized and solved on the mesh using finite-difference or finite-element techniques [242,243]. Drift-diffusion models are highly evolved, and relatively speaking, not terribly computationally intensive, except in the case of 3D models. Because of the assumptions they are based on, however, they are ill-suited to treat many effects becoming important in small-geometry devices, such as velocity overshoot, carrier heating, and quasi-ballistic transport [244]. Nevertheless, because of their computational efficiency, they remain the workhorse simulation tool, even for deep submicron devices. The next step up the device-simulation hierarchy is hydrodynamic and energy balance codes. Based on fewer assumptions, these codes begin to treat non-local effects, but are correspondingly more computer-intensive, based on five equations of state rather than the three of the driftdiffusion method. Energy balance options are available in commercial drift-diffusion-based codes [245], but have not been extensively used for SEU calculations. 2D energy transport codes have been used for ion-induced charge-collection simulations in GaAs devices, where offequilibrium effects are particularly important [138,246,247]. The top rung of the device simulation ladder is Monte Carlo simulation, which makes the fewest assumptions and approximations [248]. Rather than being based on approximations to complicated macroscopic equations, Monte Carlo methods describe carrier transport on a fundamental, microscopic scale using classical equations of motion (e.g., Newton’s first law). The motion of individual carriers is followed as they drift in fields and interact with scattering centers until statistical significance is achieved. Few assumptions are involved other than transport is described using classical physics. The penalty is very high computational intensity as the trajectories of many thousands of particles must be tracked to attain meaningful statistics. The utility of the Monte Carlo method for simulating radiation-induced charge collection was realized very quickly [249]. Early simulations computed two-dimensional “collection maps” of alpha-particle generated carriers in regular arrays of cells, while a follow-up study looked at scaling effects on SEU in DRAMs [249,250]. The methodology was also extended to cosmic-ray induced SEUs [251]. To reduce computation time, these simulations treated the third dimension (depth into the substrate) with analytic models. Monte Carlo simulation has also been applied to studying SEU in short-channel CMOS on SOI technologies [252]. Recently, a fully threedimensional Monte Carlo simulator has been described [253], and used in combination with a circuit simulator [254]. Due to high computational requirements, the response during only the first hundred or so picoseconds was calculated, but continuing improvements in computer speed and computational efficiency can be expected to overcome these limitations. In the future, Monte Carlo SEU simulations may become more commonplace, especially as Monte Carlo algorithms are frequently inherently easy to parallelize.
II-49
5.2.1
3D Device and Mixed-Level Simulations
One of the many challenges of device simulation of radiation effects is the need for advanced, three-dimensional modeling tools. The inherently three-dimensional nature of an ion passing through a microelectronic device is difficult to address with the two-dimensional simulation programs that are routinely used in the semiconductor industry for device analysis. The development of full three-dimensional tools has been fairly recent, however, and much insight has been gained in the past through the use of two-dimensional programs [50,53,54,56,67, 87,89,90,138,154,182,255-263]. The fundamental problem with representing a three-dimensional ion strike in fewer dimensions is shown in Figure 5.2. In a two-dimensional simulation, all quantities are assumed to be extruded into the third dimension, and hence either the correct generated charge density or the correct total charge can be simulated, not both. Scaling schemes have been proposed that adjust the Auger recombination rate in an attempt to correct for geometry effects [258]. Another method is to use quasi-three-dimensional versions of the popular PISCES-II code, based on cylindrical symmetry and coordinate transformations [264]. Many charge collection and SEU studies have been performed using these modified two-dimensional codes [57,59,61,110,115,116,240,241, 265-268]. Unfortunately, there are few devices that exhibit circular symmetry, although through clever use of geometrical approximations, cylindrically symmetric simulations have proven revealing and surprisingly accurate in some cases [110,116]. Full 3D device codes are necessary to model the effects of angled ion strikes [68,241,269] Fully-3D device simulators were first reported in the literature in 1980 [270,271], and some of the early work on three-dimensional device simulation was motivated by alpha-particle reliability issues [272-274]. An early comparison of 2D and 3D charge-collection simulations showed that while the transient responses were qualitatively similar, significant quantitative differences existed, both in the magnitude of the current response and the time scale over which
-+ + + + + -
-+
-+
-+
-+
+ + + + -
+ + + + -
Ion Strike
Two-Dim ensional
Quasi-Three-Dimensional
Three-Dimensional
Correct charge density or Correct total charge Incorrect geom etry Com putationally efficient
Correct charge density Correct total charge Incorrect geom etry Com putationally efficient
Correct charge density Correct total charge Correct geom etry Com putationally intensive
Figure 5.2. Illustration of the inherently three-dimensional nature of ion strikes [51].
II-50
collection was observed [275]. The implication of these results is that while 2D simulations may provide basic insight, 3D simulation is necessary if truly predictive results are to be obtained. Throughout the 1980s companies developed internal 3D device simulators [276-280], but most of these were proprietary and optimized for super-computers. Only in the present decade have numerical techniques and microprocessor speeds been sufficiently improved to bring such tools to the desktop workstation. In the last few years fully three-dimensional device simulators have become commercially available [245,281-283]. Optimized for high-end workstations, a fairly large 3D simulation can generally be performed in about a day. Another consideration that arises in modeling charge collection and SEU is the tight coupling of device and circuit response to incident ionizing radiation. In SRAMs, for example, modeling the struck transistor with typical constant boundary conditions (or even including passive, lumped elements) will never result in an upset being observed in the simulation – by construction the device will always return to its pre-strike state. The best that can be done in this situation is to study the charge-collection characteristics of the struck device, and compare the collected charge to some critical charge to upset. However, the usefulness of this approach is extremely limited for SRAMs, since the charge-collection characteristics are greatly influenced by external loading and the feedback mechanism in latches [67,284]. Additionally, the critical charge itself may be ill-defined, once again being dependent on external loading and specific circuit designs [63,88,285]. Nevertheless, unloaded device simulation has been useful for studying the basic physical properties of charge collection, and for studying DRAMs, where loading effects are not as prevalent and critical charge is well-defined by noise margins [75]. For studying the upset process itself in SRAMs, circuit simulation has been a more usable tool. The single-event induced transient current is modeled as a current source at the struck node, and the effects on the SRAM are calculated with a circuit simulator such as SPICE [285-288]. One strength of this approach is the large scale of the circuit in question that can be modeled; another is its computational efficiency. A drawback is the accuracy of the transient current used as the input stimulus. For example, if the current is based on device simulations of a struck, unloaded device [117], then the circuit simulation inherits the inaccuracy of the improperlyloaded device simulation. If the charge collection input is approximated using one-dimensional, analytical models [288], even greater inaccuracy may result, particularly for heavily-ionizing particles. Still, circuit simulations have provided considerable insight into SEU in SRAMs and have resulted in improvements to hardening techniques for a variety of circuits [131,150,152, 155,166,286,289,290]. In the best of all possible worlds, one would desire a simulation methodology for SRAMs that allows either modeling the entire memory cell in the device domain, or allows concurrent solution of device and circuit equations. The former method has been used quite successfully with the simulation code SIFCOD [291], which permits numerical modeling of multiple devices at once. Modeling an SRAM cell consists of four simultaneous device simulations, tied together through contact boundary conditions, as illustrated in Figure 5.3 [67]. These simulations were the first reported that were capable of studying the actual upset process at the device level, and were thus key to forming an understanding of fundamental mechanisms leading to upset [67,89,90]. Because four numerical device simulations must be performed at once, this technique is fairly computer intensive. More importantly, however, the SIFCOD program performed only 2D computations and hence suffered from the geometric limitations that have been discussed above. II-51
N+
N+
P+
N-EPITAXIAL
N+
+ P
VDD
P2
P1
N+
P-WELL
+ P
N+
N-EPITAXIAL
P+
+
N+
N+
N
N+
N-EPITAXIAL
P
+
P+
ION PATH
N1 N
N+
+
N2
P
+
P+
P-WELL
N-EPITAXIAL
N+
VSS
Figure 5.3. Illustration of the use of multiple simultaneous device simulation to compute the SEU characteristics of a CMOS SRAM [67]. Each device’s characteristics are simulated in the multidimensional device domain. Commercial 3D simulators such as Davinci have a similar capability to simultaneously simulate multiple devices [245], but are not generally used in this mode. Recently, the simultaneous solution of device and circuit equations has been increasingly used. This technique, known as mixed-mode or mixed-level simulation, was developed by Rollins at USC/Aerospace in the late 1980s [292]. The term “mixed-level” is probably less confusing and more descriptive than “mixed-mode.” In a mixed-level simulation of SEU, the struck device is modeled in the “device domain” (i.e., using multi-dimensional device simulation), while the rest of the memory cell is represented by SPICE-like compact circuit models, as illustrated in Figure 5.4. The two regimes are tied together by the boundary conditions at contacts, and the solution to both sets of equations is rolled into one matrix solution [292,293]. The advantage is that only the struck device is modeled in multiple dimensions, while the rest of the circuit consists of computationally-efficient SPICE models. This decreases simulation times over multiple-device techniques and greatly increases the complexity of the external circuitry that can be modeled. Mixed-level capability has been incorporated into many of the commerciallyavailable 3D device codes [245,281-283]. These codes were first used to study SEU in CMOS SRAMs in 1991 [294], and since then have received a great deal of continued use for this purpose [51]. II-52
VDD
Circuit Simulation
Particle Strike
Device Simulation
Figure 5.4. Mixed-level simulations solve the device and circuit equations simultaneously, taking advantage of the localization of the ion strike. Only the struck device is modeled in the multidimensional device domain, reducing the computational burden. 5.2.2
Recent Enhancements
A drawback of the mixed-level method is that coupling effects between adjacent transistors have been shown to exist at the device level using 2D simulations [258]. These effects cannot be taken into account when only the struck device is modeled at the device level. To address this difficulty, a recent paper has described simulation of the entire SRAM cell in the 3D device domain [295]. An illustration of the technique is shown in Figure 5.5 (interconnects between device regions are defined in the usual manner for an SRAM cell, but are not shown in the illustration for clarity). The authors compared the results to standard mixed-level simulations and found that in cases where no coupling effects between transistors existed, mixed-level simulations were adequate to reproduce the full SRAM cell results. For some strike locations, however, coupling effects between adjacent transistors were observed [295]. Mixed-level simulations are incapable of predicting such effects. As inter-device spacing decreases with increasing integration levels, coupling effects can be expected to become more important, and simulating entire the SRAM cell in the device domain may become routinely necessary [295]. Techniques like mixed-level simulation are useful for in-depth studies of SEU in specific small-scale circuits and for given ion strikes. A system designer, however, is more likely to be interested in the total error rate for a large circuit containing many transistors, and operating in some particular environment of interest. Because this is a very difficult problem, requiring detailed environmental models, the probability that a given ion strike causes an SEU is usually treated using analytical methods such as the rectangular parallelpided (RPP) model. Typical methods of solution have been covered in a previous short course and review articles [19,22,227]. Two groups have recently reported on large-scale SEU simulation systems which are aimed at predicting system error rates using a more first-principles basis of the interaction of ions with devices.
II-53
The simpler of these two models [296] targeted the terrestrial alpha-particle-induced softerror rate (SER) in SRAMs. In this system, analytic models with fitting parameters based on 3D device simulations were used for the alpha-induced charge collection and noise current. An equivalent circuit was extracted and circuit simulations were used to determine error margin, or the probability of an upset for a given incident alpha-particle energy and angle. In parallel with this, the probability of a given alpha-particle being emitted by the metal wiring (interconnects or on-chip solder bumps) and impinging on the circuit was computed from topography simulations and emission rates of the materials. The SER is then just the running summation of the probability that a given alpha-particle will be emitted multiplied by the probability that such an alpha-particle would cause an error. Comparisons of simulated and experimentally-observed error rates were reasonably close at low supply voltages, but only within a factor of five at higher voltages, with the simulations underestimating the observed SER [296]. The authors later rewrote the model to include neutron-generated reaction products and found improved agreement with accelerated data obtained using a high-flux neutron beam [297-299]. IBM has taken a similar approach in the development of their advanced soft-error modeling system (SEMM) [300-302]. This code models both terrestrial cosmic rays and on-chip alphaparticle sources, and includes a nuclear spallation simulator to model particle-silicon recoil spectra from first principles [230,303]. In addition to a nuclear spallation model, SEMM includes a Monte Carlo model for diffusion of the incident charge based on the earlier work of Sai-Halasz [249-251], fitting to transient device simulation to determine the temporal shape of the charge collected at the various junctions, circuit simulation to determine critical charges, and can also
p-channel transistors
Ion Path
n-channel transistors
Figure 5.5. Illustration of the simulation of an entire SRAM cell in the three-dimensional device simulation domain. II-54
incorporate statistical data from process variations. This is very computationally intensive, so SEMM makes extensive use of history files to reduce the amount of computation necessary for any one run. Good agreement has been obtained between SEMM results and field experiments with no parameter adjustments, indicating the predictive nature of the model. Figure 5.6 shows the simulated components of the soft-error rate in a bipolar chip [304]. Components are computed due to both alpha-particle sources and the cosmic ray spectrum. Alpha-particle sources include three levels of metal, Pb-Sn solder pads, and a ceramic layer. Note that for events with small critical charge, alpha particles are dominant and mostly come from the Pb-Sn solder and ceramic materials. For critical charges above 250 fC, only cosmic ray events are capable of inducing upset in this chip. IBM has marketed a soft-error simulation service to outside customers based on these capabilities [305].
Figure 5.6. Simulations of relative soft-error rate in a bipolar memory cell due to terrestrial cosmic rays and various on-chip and package-related alpha-particle sources [304].
II-55
6.0
FUTURE TRENDS
One of the biggest worries for single-event effects is how technology trends will impact device susceptibility in the future. Effects such as SEU have already been getting worse with technology evolution. In this section, we discuss key technology drivers, how technology trends may affect hardening strategies, and the phenomenon of single-event effects in ground-based and aircraft microelectronics, a topic of growing concern. 6.1
Technology Drivers Impacting Single-Event Effects
Technology parameters that influence the SEU sensitivity include gate length, gate oxide thickness, and power supply voltage. Increased SEU susceptibility as gate length is decreased has been well documented, and may be due to direct channel conduction [66], bipolar coupling mechanisms between the source and drain [70], or decreased gate capacitance as the gate area is reduced [260]. Figure 6.1 shows an example of the decreased threshold for SEU for two strike locations as gate length is decreased and all other parameters are held constant [70]. The strike locations are the center of the drain for the outside-the-well “off” transistor and the inside-thewell “off” transistor (panels (a) and (c) in Figure 3.10). The results shown were obtained using 3D mixed-level simulations of a model p-substrate technology with 150 kΩ feedback resistors. As gate length is decreased, the SEU threshold for outside-the-well “off” strikes decreases slightly, and the threshold for inside-the-well “off” strikes decreases rapidly due to the bipolar effect [70]. As the power supply is decreased and all other parameters are held constant, the SEU threshold again decreases due to reduced current drive in the restoring transistor and less stored
1000 Outside the well OFF Inside the well OFF
100
10 0.0
1.0 Gate Length (µm)
2.0
Figure 6.1. Scaling trend for SEU threshold LET as a function of gate length from simulations of a p-substrate technology with feedback resistors [70]. All other technology parameters were held constant. II-56
charge in the cell. Simulations of this situation are shown in Figure 6.2a. However, reductions in power supply voltage are usually accompanied by reduced gate oxide thickness. Thinner gate oxides result in higher gate capacitance and higher current drives, so SEU thresholds increase with decreasing gate oxide thickness if all other parameters are constant (Figure 6.2b). However, if all parameters are taken into account, the overall trend is still a general increase in SEU susceptibility with each technology generation. This trend is shown in Figure 6.3, which is a plot of the simulated and experimentally-measured SEU threshold for SRAMs without feedback resistors in the three most recent Sandia CMOS technologies [70]. A factor that is at least as important as the fundamental changes to the physics is simply the reduction in total capacitance as technologies shrink. Remember that the feedback time for the SRAM cell is to first order related to the RC delay in the inverter pair. As device areas shrink, the gate and drain capacitance shrinks, making the device faster but consequently much more susceptible to SEU. SEU can therefore be expected to continue as a growing concern for scaled technologies. Another area that is likely to become increasingly important is the propagation of singleevent transients (SETs) in digital logic circuits. The problem here is that as circuit speeds rise, the probability that a momentary glitch will be clocked as valid data and propagated down the line increases. For example, in Figure 3.11 we saw that even a particle well below the upset threshold can cause a momentary flip in the state of an SRAM cell. Consider the case where this memory cell is actually a digital latch circuit in a microprocessor. In the example of Figure 3.11, if this latch value is read 10 picoseconds after an ion strike and the value is clocked down the line, it matters little that the struck latch eventually returns to its original state, because the corrupt value has already been passed on to the next stage of the circuit. These types of errors are likely to become a pervasive problem as clock speeds continue to increase, and will be difficult to protect against, especially in commercial microprocessors where speed is paramount. It has been suggested that for circuits built in technologies below 0.35 µm, propagated SETs will be a 100
50
10
10 2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5 50
5.0
VDD (V)
a)
100 150 200 Oxide Thickness (Angstroms)
250
b)
Figure 6.2. Simulated scaling trends for SEU threshold LET as a function of a) power supply voltage, and b) gate oxide thickness. II-57
Threshold LET (MeV-cm2/mg)
100 Experimental Range
10
1 0.0
1.0
2.0
Feature Size (µm) Figure 6.3. Overall SEU threshold LET technology trend for the last three generations of Sandia CMOS SRAMs without feedback resistors [70]. The points are the results of 3D mixed-level simulations, and the shaded regions are the measured range. primary single-event failure mode [306]. The interested reader is directed to the final segment of this short course for more information on SETs in digital logic circuits and mitigation strategies [171]. For SEL, the trends from technology evolution are more difficult to predict. Technology trends working to increase SEL susceptibility are decreased well thicknesses and interdevice spacing. On the other hand, the decreased power supply voltages demanded in newer low-power technologies may alleviate latchup concerns, while technologies such as trench isolation also tend to improve latchup resistance. If CMOS/SOI technology proves to be manufacturable and becomes a mainstream technology solution, traditional latchup concerns may vanish. 6.2
Hardening Strategies
A considerable concern for SRAMs requiring SEU hardness in the future is whether traditional resistive hardening techniques will remain a viable option. The resistive decoupling technique is fundamentally incompatible with high speed because it relies on slowing the cell down so that it cannot respond quickly to SEU voltage transients. This tends to mean that the write performance of hardened SRAM cells has to be kept at a nearly constant level to maintain a constant level of SEU hardness. Also, because a smaller, faster SRAM cell has lower capacitance, the feedback resistance required to harden the cell has to be raised to compensate. This can lead to a requirement for very large resistors in advanced technologies. This point is illustrated in Figure 6.4, which shows the results of 3D mixed-level simulations of two resistively-hardened SRAM technology generations. The simulated SEU threshold LET is plotted as a function of feedback resistor value for a 0.6-µm, 5-V technology with transistor widths of II-58
2.3 µm and 1.3 µm, and for a 0.35-µm, 3.3-V technology with a transistor width of 0.75 µm. As can be seen from the predictions, achieving a target LET threshold of 40 MeV-cm2/mg would require a 200-kΩ resistor for the 2.3×0.6 µm2 device, a 600-kΩ resistor for the 1.3×0.6 µm2 device, and a whopping 1.1-MΩ resistor for the 0.75×0.35 µm2 device. Such large resistors would be very difficult to controllably manufacture and would show a significant temperature dependence [151]. Because of this problem and stagnant performance levels, it is likely that for applications requiring a high level of SEU hardness, devices below about 0.5-µm will utilize other hardening techniques, such as SOI, active feedback elements, or circuit hardening. 6.3
Terrestrial and High-Altitude Single-Event Effects
To this point we have discussed the natural space radiation environment and how it interacts with microelectronics to cause single-event effects. A radiation environment also exists in the Earth’s atmosphere, and although less harsh than the space environment, it can also give rise to SEE. In the following sections we will discuss the high-altitude and terrestrial radiation environments and their effects on microelectronics in aircraft electronics systems and at ground level. 6.3.1
The Atmospheric Radiation Environment
2.3 x 0.6 µm
80
2
Threshold LET (MeV-cm /mg)
The atmospheric radiation environment comes about as a result of the space radiation environment impinging on Earth’s atmosphere. As very highly energetic cosmic rays enter the upper atmosphere they interact with oxygen and nitrogen in the atmosphere and produce a
60
1.3 x 0.6 µm
40
0.75 x 0.35 µm
20
0 0
500
1000
1500
Feedback Resistance (kΩ) Figure 6.4. Predicted SEU threshold LET vs. feedback resistance from 3D mixed-level simulations of a 0.6-µm, 5-V technology and a 0.35-µm, 3.3-V technology. Note the requirement for extremely large resistors as the fabrication technology scales. II-59
cosmic ray shower of daughter products [1,307-309]. Note that the primary galactic cosmic rays are so energetic that some of the daughter products can reach all the way through the atmosphere to ground level, equivalent to passing through more than 13 feet of concrete [308]. A diagram of a cosmic ray shower is shown in Figure 6.5. The daughter products primarily responsible for causing upsets in high-altitude and terrestrial electronics are neutrons and protons [307]. The fluxes of neutrons and protons have similar characteristics with respect to energy and altitude variation, with both populations extending to energies greater than 1 GeV. Both neutrons and protons show a maximum flux at an altitude of 55,000-60,000 feet (17-18 km), with the sea-level flux being several hundred times lower than at aircraft altitudes [307]. A plot of the altitude variation of the neutron flux is shown in Figure 6.6a. The neutron flux also varies as a function of latitude, as shown in Figure 6.6b. The neutron flux is highest at the poles, because the primary galactic cosmic rays can penetrate furthest into the atmosphere there due to reduced geomagnetic rigidity [1]. Models have been produced that give the variation of atmospheric neutron flux as a function of altitude, latitude, and solar activity [310]. Note that the atmospheric neutron flux varies with solar activity due to its dependence on the incident galactic cosmic ray flux. Further details on the terrestrial and high-altitude radiation environment can be found in [307,309] and references therein.
Figure 6.5. Illustration of the terrestrial cosmic ray shower caused by the interaction of galactic cosmic rays with the Earth’s atmosphere [308]. II-60
a)
b) Figure 6.6. Variation of the atmospheric neutron flux with a) altitude, and b) latitude [307]. 6.3.2
Historical Perspective and Recent Studies
Oddly enough, the first paper to ever deal with the issue of SEU was not a paper on the use of electronics in the space environment, but a paper assessing scaling trends in terrestrial microelectronics [311]. Interestingly, the authors predicted that the minimum volume of semiconductor devices would be limited to about 10 µm on a side due to terrestrial cosmic ray upsets! The actual occurrence of soft errors in terrestrial microelectronics did not manifest itself until some time later, shortly after the first observations of SEU in space [73]. This first paper from authors at Intel found a significant error rate in DRAMs as integration density increased to 16K and 64K, spurring a flurry of SEU-related work in the late 1970’s [312]. The primary cause of soft errors at the ground level was quickly diagnosed as alpha-particle contaminants in packaging materials. For example, according to Ziegler, the Intel problem was traced to a new LSI ceramic packaging plant that had just been built downstream from the tailings of an abandoned uranium mine [308]. Radioactive contaminants in the water used by the factory were contaminating the ceramic packages they manufactured. After considerable early activity, the II-61
terrestrial soft error problem was mostly alleviated by using low-activity materials and on-chip shielding coatings [308,313]. Occasionally, changes in suppliers or procedures have caused semiconductor manufacturers temporary but considerable headaches due to raised radioactive contaminant levels in materials such as nitric and phosphoric acid [308,314]. The march toward higher integration densities has made soft-error concerns a continual design consideration for advanced DRAM and SRAM development in the last decade. A particular area of recent concern is flip-chip packaging technologies that place a source of alpha particles (Pb-Sn solder bumps) right on the die itself, where they cannot be shielded by coating layers [299]. Even in the absence of on-chip sources of radiation, recent studies have conclusively proved that terrestrial cosmic rays (primarily neutrons) are a significant source of soft errors in both DRAMs and SRAMs [315-317]. Upsets have been observed both at ground level and in aircraft and have been convincingly correlated to the altitude and latitude variation of the neutron flux, as shown in Figure 6.7 [307,315,317]. Lage, et al. have shown that even without alpha particles, a baseline of cosmic-ray upsets still exists for high-density SRAMs [316]. This result is shown in Figure 6.8, which plots the correlation between the measured accelerated soft error rate (ASER, measured using an intense alpha-particle source placed over the SRAM) and the system soft error rate (SSER, the real application error rate measured in many SRAMs operating over a long period of time). If the system SEU rate were due entirely to alpha particles, there would be a simple direct correlation between the SSER and the ASER, but instead the data show a baseline SER due to neutron upsets even in the absence of alpha-particle upsets [316]. O’Gorman has shown that neutron upsets disappear for DRAMs placed 200 meters underground in a salt mine, while they increase dramatically for systems operated above 10,000 feet in Leadville, CO [315]. In addition to SEU observed in memories used in large computer systems and aircraft, upsets have been observed in SRAMs used in implantable medical devices such as cardiac defibrillators
Figure 6.7. Excellent correlation is observed between upsets recorded in avionics and the atmospheric neutron flux [307]. II-62
Figure 6.8. Correlation between system SER (SSER, from field testing) and accelerated SER (ASER, from intense alpha-particle source testing) [316]. The SSER exhibits a baseline error rate due to neutron-induced upsets. [318]. Neutron-induced single-event burnout has even caused destructive failures in large-area, high-voltage power diodes used for railroad applications in Europe [319]. 6.3.3
Mitigation Techniques
Neutron-induced ground-level upset rates have been estimated to be 1-2×10-12 upsets/bit-hr across a range of commercial DRAMs and SRAMs [317]. For a computer workstation with 1 Gbit of memory (128 Mbytes), this could lead to as many as 1-2 errors per month, depending on how much of the memory space is in daily use [317]. Revelations such as these have significant implications for manufacturers of commercial memory chips and computer systems, because systems can’t realistically be shielded against incident neutrons. Meeting specified failure rates is expected to be a significant challenge for commercial semiconductor manufacturers. Terrestrial soft error failure rate specifications are usually given in terms of FIT rates, where FIT = Failure in Time = 1 error in 109 device hours. A typical specification is to maintain a FIT rate less than 1000 [316]. A complicating factor is that since FIT rates are specified per device, meeting a constant FIT rate specification actually requires reducing the error rate per bit as the number of bits per device is increased. It has been suggested that because manufacturers of commercial microelectronics for terrestrial applications have had to deal with alpha-particle-induced upsets from packaging materials, commercial parts will by design remain hard to at least the alpha-particle threshold, as illustrated in Figure 6.9 [207]. This figure shows the critical charge to upset as a function of gate
II-63
length, with the horizontal line indicating the maximum charge supplied by a 5-MeV alpha particle. Indeed, there is historical evidence supporting this view as data from more than 10 years of microprocessor evolution show a constant upset threshold just above the threshold for alpha particle upset. However, it is also known that many manufacturers have specific soft-error driven design rules for placement of devices relative to on-chip solder bumps and/or use hardened circuit designs for I/O circuitry that must be in the vicinity of such on-chip alpha sources [299,320]. This clearly implies that many devices being manufactured are in fact already below the alpha-particle threshold for upset. Many of the techniques traditionally used in the radiation effects community to SEU-harden devices are of such a nature that they would never be adopted by commercial manufacturers. They tend to consume more power, reduce manufacturability, and severely impact IC performance. Commercial DRAMs have generally exhibited a fairly constant SEU performance because DRAM manufacturers have intentionally maintained the unit cell capacitance through the use of clever modifications to the storage cell [321]. The nodal capacitance for SRAMs, however, has been steadily shrinking [316]. To counteract increased terrestrial soft error rates, manufacturers may find it necessary to explicitly add capacitance to high-density SRAMs [158,316]. Lage has predicted that this will be necessary for the 4 Mbit generation of SRAMs and beyond [316]. Design-hardened circuits may be useful for critical paths or circuitry, but because of area penalties will not be adopted on a large scale [320]. The use of error-correcting memory architectures is already becoming more common again and this trend will likely continue. Mitigating soft errors in high-speed digital logic circuits will be especially challenging. Fault-
Figure 6.9. Technology trend for critical charge to upset as a function of feature size, suggesting that SEU sensitivity will be kept above the alpha-particle limit by manufacturers [207]. II-64
tolerant systems are routinely used in aircraft mechanical systems and seem a natural choice for preventing neutron-induced SEU in avionics [322]. SOI is a possible solution to the terrestrial SEU problem, although as noted previously SOI is not automatically upset immune. Manufacturers have demonstrated the ability to produce ultra large-scale SOI DRAMs [323], microprocessors [324], and SRAMs [325], although others remain skeptical of the advantages of SOI [326]. In any event, the fact that commercial manufacturers will be studying SEU should prove beneficial to the radiation effects community inasmuch as it brings new resources to bear on the problem.
II-65
7.0
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
In this short course segment we began with a review of the radiation environment encountered by space telecommunications systems. In general, the environment consists of trapped and transient protons, heavy ions, and electrons. Because electrons are rarely important for SEE, they were not treated in this segment. Protons are trapped by the Earth’s magnetic field in two belts around the planet, an inner belt and an outer belt. Trapped heavy ions also exist but are not in general energetic enough to cause SEE in shielded systems. The South Atlantic Anomaly is a localized region of intense proton flux at low altitudes (<3000 km) and is an important SEE threat for systems operating in low Earth orbits. Transient particles (protons and heavy ions) ejected by solar events are also important contributors to SEE. Solar events follow a several-year cyclical variation but can occur at any time and produce large particle fluences. The galactic cosmic ray background is inversely proportional to the solar cycle and produces highenergy heavily-ionizing particles. Secondary neutrons and protons are produced by the interaction of galactic cosmic rays with the atmosphere and are important for terrestrial and high-altitude SEE. Non-destructive SEE are caused by charge deposition by direct ionization from heavy ions, and indirect ionization from protons and neutrons. The deposited charge can be collected by drift and diffusion in semiconductor devices, causing current transients that can result in circuit malfunction. Funneling can increase the charge collected due to drift processes, and is especially important for DRAMs and devices not fabricated on epitaxial substrates. In SRAMs, voltage transients can cause upsets by mimicking the write process. In complex and high-speed circuits such as microprocessors, even a momentary glitch can propagate through an IC to cause upsets. SEUs are not unique to digital circuits, and have been observed in analog devices. Multiple-bit upsets occur when more than one bit in a digital circuit is upset by a single particle strike. Mitigation techniques for SEU include system-level methods such as error detection and correction, lockstep execution, and redundant systems using voting. Circuit-level methods are also effective, and several SEU-hardened latch designs have been proposed. These techniques have the advantage of allowing the use of commercial fabrication technologies, but usually lead to greatly increased transistor counts. Traditional radiation-hardened circuits use process techniques such as lightly-doped polysilicon feedback resistors to provide SEU immunity. While very effective, passive feedback elements reduce circuit performance and degrade IC manufacturability. SEE can also cause permanent failures in ICs, such as single-event gate rupture (SEGR), burnout (SEB), or latchup (SEL). Latchup is a concern for any standard CMOS technology, and can be triggered by particle strikes in ICs that are otherwise immune to electrically-induced latchup. Thin epitaxial substrates are usually effective at limiting SEL, but recent data indicate that this may not always be the case. Lower supply voltages in the future may reduce the SEL susceptibility of low-power ICs. SEGR, long a concern for power devices, is a possible concern for other ICs as the gate oxide is thinned. Recent data show that thinner oxides have higher critical fields to rupture, but on the other hand, devices are being run at higher fields these days. In the end the susceptibility of commercial ICs to SEGR in space environments will depend on what scaling rules the manufacturers choose for terrestrial operation. SEB remains a concern primarily for power devices, and must be considered for proper system design. II-66
Simulations of SEE have been crucial to developing an understanding of the mechanisms behind SEE and for suggesting methods for hardening devices. As devices continue to evolve to smaller dimensions, device-level modeling will encounter new challenges such as the ion strike affecting more than a single transistor at a time. A greater level of usefulness can be reached when simulation tools prove to be validated and predictive. At this level, simulations become essential during the design process for reducing the number of “fab-and-test” cycles that must be completed to develop radiation-hardened technologies. Technology trends are unfortunately such that SEE are likely to become even more of a concern for the future. Decreasing feature sizes, lower operating voltage, and higher speeds all conspire to increase susceptibility to SEU. Upset in avionics is an established concern. Upset at the ground level will continue to be an increasing concern for manufacturers of microelectronics for terrestrial applications. The use of flip-chip packaging and multiple levels of metals will only serve to further exacerbate the problem. Typical methods of mitigation that either increase the transistor count or reduce IC performance will likely not be acceptable to commercial manufacturers, and new methods will need to be developed. Silicon-on-insulator (SOI) technology may help in this regard, but is not a magic bullet to end all SEE concerns. Hopefully, the fact that commercial manufacturers must deal with SEE concerns will provide a collateral benefit to the radiation effects community as more resources are brought to bear on the problem.
II-67
8.0
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The author is grateful for the continuing support, encouragement, and camaraderie of the Radiation Technology and Assurance Department at Sandia National Laboratories. Were it not for the accumulated expertise in the department and hours of stimulating discussions with Peter Winokur, Fred Sexton, Marty Shaneyfelt, Jim Schwank, Dan Fleetwood, and a host of others, the understanding of basic mechanisms of single-event effects represented in this paper would not have been possible. I especially want to thank my family and friends for their patience and understanding as I undertook this work, and especially my wife Melanie whose encouragement was unwavering. I would also like to acknowledge the partial support of Lew Cohn and the Defense Threat Reduction Agency. Sandia is a multiprogram laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company, for the United States Department of Energy under contract DE-AC04-94AL85000.
II-68
9.0
REFERENCES
[1]
J. L. Barth, “Modeling Space Radiation Environments,” 1997 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Snowmass, CO.
[2]
C. S. Dyer, “Space Radiation Environment Dosimetry,” 1998 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Newport Beach, CA.
[3]
J. Feynman and S. B. Gabriel, “High-energy charged particles in space at one astronomical unit,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 344-352, 1996.
[4]
M. S. Gussenhoven, E. G. Mullen, and D. H. Brautigam, “Improved understanding of the Earth’s radiation belts from the CRRES satellite,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 353-368, 1996.
[5]
E. G. Stassinopoulos, G. J. Brucker, D. W. Nakamura, C. A. Stauffer, G. B. Gee, and J. L. Barth, “Solar flare proton evaluation at geostationary orbits for engineering applications,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 369-382, 1996.
[6]
C. S. Dyer, A. Sims, and C. Underwood, “Measurements of the SEE environment from sea level to GEO using the CREAM and CREDO experiments,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 383-402, 1996.
[7]
E. J. Daly, J. Lemaire, D. Heynderickx, and D. J. Rodgers, “Problems with models of the radiation belts,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 403-415, 1996.
[8]
D. Boscher, S. Bourdarie, and T. Beutier, “Dynamic modeling of trapped particles,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 416-425, 1996.
[9]
T. P. Ma and P. V. Dressendorfer, Ionizing Radiation Effects in MOS Devices & Circuits, (Wiley, New York, 1989).
[10]
R. L. Pease, “Total-dose issues for microelectronics in space systems,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 442-452, 1996.
[11]
A. R. Frederickson, “Upsets related to spacecraft charging,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 426441, 1996.
[12]
E. L. Petersen, “Soft errors due to protons in the radiation belt,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 3981-3986, 1981.
[13]
J. R. Cummings, A. C. Cummings, R. A. Mewaldt, R. S. Selesnick, E. C. Stone, T. T. von Rosenvinge, and J. B. Blake, “SAMPEX measurements of heavy ions trapped in the magnetosphere,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1458-1462, 1993.
[14]
T. Kohno, H. Miyasaka, H. Kato, C. Kato, T. Goka, and H. Matsumoto, “Heavy ion radiation in space observed by Japanese satellite,” Proc. 3rd Int. Workshop Rad. Effects on Semiconductor Devices for Space Application, Takasaki, Japan, pp. 90-95, 1998.
[15]
A. J. Tylka, W. F. Dietrich, and P. R. Boberg, “Probability distributions of high-energy solar-heavy-ion fluxes from IMP-8: 1973-1996,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2140-2149, 1997.
[16]
F. W. Sexton, “Measurement of single event phenomena in devices and ICs,” 1992 IEEE NSREC Short Course, New Orleans, LA.
[17]
S. M. Sze, Physics of Semiconductor Devices, (Wiley, New York, 1981).
[18]
J. F. Ziegler, J. P. Biersack, and U. Littmark, The Stopping and Range of Ions in Solids, (Pergamon Press, New York, 1985).
[19]
E. L. Petersen, “Single Event Analysis and Prediction,” 1997 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Snowmass, CO.
All references are unclassified
II-69
[20]
J. Barak, J. Levinson, M. Victoria, and W. Hajdas, “Direct processes in the energy deposition of protons in silicon,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2820-2826, 1996.
[21]
S. Duzellier, R. Ecoffet, D. Falguère, T. Nuns, L. Guibert, W. Hajdas, M. C. Calvet, “Low energy proton induced SEE in memories,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2306-2310, 1997.
[22]
E. L. Petersen, “Approaches to proton single-event rate calculations,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 496-504, 1996.
[23]
P. W. Marshall, C. J. Dale, M. A. Carts, and K. A. LaBel, “Particle-induced bit errors in high performance fiber optic data links for satellite data management,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 1958-1965, 1994.
[24]
K. A. LaBel, P. W. Marshall, C. J. Marshall, M. D’Ordine, M. Carts, G. K. Lum, H. S. Kim, C. M. Seidleck, T. Powell, R. Abbott, J. Barth, and E. G. Stassinopoulos, “Proton-induced transients in optocouplers: in-flight anomalies, ground irradiation test, mitigation and implications,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 1885-1892, 1997.
[25]
R. A. Reed, P. W. Marshall, A. H. Johnston, J. L. Barth, C. J. Marshall, K. A. LaBel, M. D’Ordine, H. S. Kim, and M. A. Carts, “Emerging optocoupler issues with energetic particle-induced transients and permanent radiation degradation,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2833-2841, 1998.
[26]
C. J. Marshall, P. W. Marshall, M. A. Carts, R. A. Reed, and K. A. LaBel, “Proton-induced transient effects in a metal-semiconductor-metal (MSM) photodetector for optical-based data transfer,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2842-2848, 1998.
[27]
P. W. Marshall, C. J. Dale, and K. A. LaBel, “Space radiation effects in high performance fiber optic data links for satellite data management,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 645-653, 1996.
[28]
A. H. Johnston, G. M. Swift, T. Miyahira, S. Guertin, and L. D. Edmonds, “Single-event upset effects in optocouplers,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2867-2875, 1998.
[29]
G. R. Hopkinson, C. J. Dale, and P. W. Marshall, “Proton effects in charge-coupled devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 614-627, 1996.
[30]
P. W. Marshall and C. J. Marshall, “Proton Effects and Test Issues for Satellite Applications,” 1999 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Norfolk, VA.
[31]
R. A. Reed, P. J. McNulty, and W. G. Abdel-Kader, “Implications of angle of incidence in SEU testing of modern circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2049-2054, 1994.
[32]
C. Inguimbert, S. Duzellier, R. Ecoffet, and J. Bourrieau, “Proton upset rate simulation by a Monte Carlo method: importance of the elastic scattering mechanism,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 22432249, 1997.
[33]
M. W. Savage, P. J. McNulty, D. R. Roth, and C. C. Foster, “Possible role for secondary particles in proton-induced single event upsets of modern devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 27452751, 1998.
[34]
P. J. McNulty, W. J. Beauvais, and D. R. Roth, “Determination of SEU parameters of NMOS and CMOS SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1463-1470, 1991.
[35]
R. A. Reed, P. J. McNulty, W. J. Beauvais, and D. R. Roth, “Charge collection spectroscopy,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1880-1887, 1993.
[36]
P. J. McNulty, “Single-event effects experienced by astronauts and microelectronic circuits flown in space,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 475-482, 1996.
[37]
R. S. Wagner, J. M. Bradley, C. J. Maggiore, J. G. Beery, and R. B. Hammond, “An approach to measure ultrafast-funneling-current transients,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1651-1656, 1986.
All references are unclassified
II-70
[38]
R. S. Wagner, J. M. Bradley, N. Bordes, C. J. Maggiore, D. N. Sinha, and R. B. Hammond, “Transient measurements of ultrafast charge collection in semiconductor diodes,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1240-1245, 1987.
[39]
R. S. Wagner, N. Bordes, J. M. Bradley, C. J. Maggiore, A. R. Knudson, and A. B. Campbell, “Alpha, boron, silicon, and iron ion-induced current transients in low-capacitance silicon and GaAs diodes,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, pp. 1578-1584, 1988.
[40]
S. J. Heileman, W. R. Eisenstadt, R. M. Fox, R. S. Wagner, N. Bordes, and J. M. Bradley, “CMOS VLSI single event transient characterization,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 36, no. 6, pp. 2287-2291, 1989.
[41]
I. Nashiyama, T. Hirao, T. Kamiya, H. Yutoh, T. Nishijima, and H. Sekiguti, “Single-event current transients induced by high energy ion microbeams,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1935-1940, 1993.
[42]
D. McMorrow, J. S. Melinger, N. Thantu, A. B. Campbell, T. R. Weatherford, A. R. Knudson, L. H. Tran, and A. Peczalski, “Charge-collection mechanisms of heterostructure FETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, pp. 2055, 1994.
[43]
J. R. Schwank, F. W. Sexton, T. R. Weatherford, D. McMorrow, A. R. Knudson, and J. S. Melinger, “Charge collection in GaAs MESFETs fabricated in semi-insulating substrates,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1585-1591, 1995.
[44]
D. McMorrow, T. R. Weatherford, W. R. Curtice, A. R. Knudson, S. Buchner, J. S. Melinger, J. H. Tran, and A. B. Campbell, “Elimination of charge-enhancement effects in GaAs FETs with a low-temperature grown GaAs buffer layer,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1837-1843, 1995.
[45]
S. Buchner, A. B. Campbell, T. Weatherford, A. Knudson, P. McDonald, D. McMorrow, B. Fischer, S. Metzger, and M. Schlögl, “Charge collection in GaAs MESFET circuits using a high energy microbeam,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2897-2903, 1996.
[46]
D. McMorrow, J. S. Melinger, A. R. Knudson, S. Buchner, and A. B. Campbell, “Charge-collection mechanisms of AlGaAs/GaAs HBTs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2274-2281, 1997.
[47]
F. W. Sexton, “Microbeam studies of single-event effects,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 687695, 1996.
[48]
S. Buchner, J. B. Langworthy, W. J. Stapor, A. B. Campbell, and S. Rivet, “Implications of the spatial dependence of the single-event upset threshold in SRAMs measured with a pulsed laser,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2195-2202, 1994.
[49]
H. Schöne, D. S. Walsh, F. W. Sexton, B. L. Doyle, P. E. Dodd, J. F. Aurand, R. S. Flores, N. Wing, “Time-resolved ion beam induced charge collection (TRIBICC) in microelectronics,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2544-2549, 1998.
[50]
C. M. Hsieh, P. C. Murley, and R. R. O’Brien, “A field-funneling effect on the collection of alpha-particlegenerated carriers in silicon devices,” IEEE Electron Device Lett., vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 103-105, 1981.
[51]
P. E. Dodd, “Device simulation of charge collection and single-event upset,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 561-575, 1996.
[52]
R. F. Pierret, Advanced Semiconductor Fundamentals, Volume VI of the Modular Series on Solid State Devices, (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1987).
[53]
C. M. Hsieh, P. C. Murley, and R. R. O’Brien, “Dynamics of charge collection from alpha-particle tracks in integrated circuits,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 38-42, 1981.
[54]
C. M. Hsieh, P. C. Murley, and R. R. O’Brien, “Collection of charge from alpha-particle tracks in silicon devices,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 30, no. 6, pp. 686-693, 1983.
[55]
F. B. McLean and T. R. Oldham, “Charge funneling in n and p-type Si substrates,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 29, no. 6, pp. 2018-2023, 1982. All references are unclassified
II-71
[56]
H. L. Grubin, J. P. Kreskovsky, and B. C. Weinberg, “Numerical studies of charge collection and funneling in silicon device,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 31, no. 6, pp. 1161-1166, 1984.
[57]
L. D. Edmonds, “A simple estimate of funneling-assisted charge collection,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 2, pp. 828-833, 1991.
[58]
L. D. Edmonds, “A theoretical analysis of steady-state photocurrents in simple silicon diodes,” JPL Publication 95-10, March 1995.
[59]
N. E. Islam, R. D. Pugh, C. P. Brothers, W. M. Shedd, B. K. Singaraju, J. W. Howard, Jr., H. Dussault, and O. Fageeha, “Basic mechanisms for enhanced prompt charge collection in a n+p junction following single charged particle interaction,” J. Appl. Phys., vol. 84, no. 5, pp. 2690-2696, 1998.
[60]
P. E. Dodd, F. W. Sexton, and P. S. Winokur, “Three-dimensional simulation of charge collection and multiple-bit upset in Si devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2005-2017, 1994.
[61]
L. D. Edmonds, “Charge collection from ion tracks in simple EPI diodes,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 1448-1463, 1997.
[62]
L. D. Edmonds, “Electric currents through ion tracks in silicon devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 3153-3164, 1998.
[63]
P. E. Dodd and F. W. Sexton, “Critical charge concepts for CMOS SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1764-1771, 1995.
[64]
E. Takeda, D. Hisamoto, and T. Toyabe, “A new soft-error phenomenon in VLSIs– the alpha-particleinduced source/drain penetration (ALPEN) effect,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 109-112, 1988.
[65]
E. Takeda, K. Takeuchi, D. Hisamoto, T. Toyabe, K. Ohshima, and K. Itoh, “A cross section of α-particleinduced soft-error phenomena in VLSIs,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 36, no. 11, pp. 2567-2575, 1989.
[66]
S. Velacheri, L. W. Massengill, and S. E. Kerns, “Single-event-induced charge collection and direct channel conduction in submicron MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2103-2111, 1994.
[67]
J. S. Fu, C. L. Axness, and H. T. Weaver, “Memory SEU simulations using 2-D transport calculations,” IEEE Electron Device Lett., vol. 6, no. 8, pp. 422-424, 1985.
[68]
R. L. Woodruff and P. J. Rudeck, “Three-dimensional numerical simulation of single event upset of an SRAM cell,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1795-1803, 1993.
[69]
O. Musseau, “Charge collection and SEU mechanisms,” Radiat. Phys. Chem., vol. 43, no. 1/2, pp. 151-163, 1994.
[70]
P. E. Dodd, F. W. Sexton, G. L. Hash, M. R. Shaneyfelt, B. L. Draper, A. J. Farino, and R. S. Flores, “Impact of technology trends on SEU in CMOS SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 27972804, 1996.
[71]
S. E. Kerns, L. W. Massengill, D. V. Kerns, Jr., M. L. Alles, T. W. Houston, H. Lu, and L. R. Hite, “Model for CMOS/SOI single-event vulnerability,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 36, no. 6, pp. 2305-2310, 1989.
[72]
H. Iwata and T. Ohzone, “Numerical analysis of alpha-particle-induced soft errors in SOI MOS devices,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 39, no. 5, pp. 1184-1190, 1992.
[73]
T. C. May and M. H. Woods, “A new physical mechanism for soft errors in dynamic memories,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 33-40, 1978.
[74]
T. C. May and M. H. Woods, “Alpha-particle-induced soft errors in dynamic memories,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 2-9, 1979.
[75]
L. W. Massengill, “Cosmic and terrestrial single-event radiation effects in dynamic random access memories,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 576-593, 1996.
All references are unclassified
II-72
[76]
D. C. Shaw, G. M. Swift, and A. H. Johnston, “Radiation evaluation of an advanced 64Mb 3.3V DRAM and insights into the effects of scaling on radiation hardness,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1674-1680, 1995.
[77]
T. Matsukawa, S. Mori, T. Tanii, T. Arimura, M. Koh, K. Igarashi, T. Sugimoto, and I. Ohdomari, “Evaluation of soft-error hardness of DRAMs under quasi-heavy ion irradiation using He single ion microprobe technique,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2849-2855, 1996.
[78]
K. A. LaBel, M. M. Gates, A. K. Moran, H. S. Kim, C. M. Seidleck, P. Marshall, J. Kinnison, and B. Carkhuff, “Radiation effect characterization and test methods of single-chip and multi-chip stacked 16Mbit DRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2974-2981, 1996.
[79]
C. I. Lee, D. N. Nguyen, and A. H. Johnston, “Total ionizing dose effects on 64Mb 3.3V DRAMs,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 97-100, 1997.
[80]
R. Harboe-Sørensen, M. Brüggemann, R. Müller, and F. J. Rombeck, “Radiation evaluation of 3.3 volt 16 M-bit DRAMs for solid state mass memory space applications,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 74-79, 1998.
[81]
K. A. LaBel, P. W. Marshall, J. L. Barth, R. B. Katz, R. A. Reed, H. W. Leidecker, H. S. Kim, and C. J. Marshall, “Anatomy of an in-flight anomaly: investigation of proton-induced SEE test results for stacked IBM DRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2898-2903, 1998.
[82]
J.-H. Chern, P. Yang, P. Pattnaik, and J. Seitchik, “Alpha-particle-induced charge transfer between closely spaced memory cells,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 822-834, 1986.
[83]
D. S. Yaney, J. T. Nelson, and L. L. Vanskike, “Alpha-particle tracks in silicon and their effect on dynamic MOS RAM reliability,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 10-16, 1979.
[84]
T. Toyabe, T. Shinoda, M. Aoki, H. Kawamoto, K. Mitsusada, T. Masuhara, and S. Asai, “A soft error rate model for MOS dynamic RAMs,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 362-367, 1982.
[85]
G. Schindlbeck, “Analysis of dynamic RAMs by use of alpha irradiation,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 30-34, 1979.
[86]
T. V. Rajeevakumar, N. C. Liu, W. H. Henkels, W. Hwang, and R. Franch, “A new failure mode of radiation-induced soft errors in dynamic memories,” IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., vol. 9, no. 12, pp. 644-646, 1988.
[87]
H. T. Weaver, “Soft error stability of p-well versus n-well CMOS latches derived from 2D, transient simulations,” IEDM Tech. Digest, pp. 512-515, 1988.
[88]
C. Detcheverry, C. Dachs, E. Lorfèvre, C. Sudre, G. Bruguier, J. M. Palau, J. Gasiot, and R. Ecoffet, “SEU critical charge and sensitive area in a submicron CMOS technology,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2266-2273, 1997.
[89]
C. L. Axness, H. T. Weaver, J. S. Fu, R. Koga, and W. A. Kolasinski, “Mechanisms leading to single event upset,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1577-1580, 1986.
[90]
H. T. Weaver, C. L. Axness, J. S. Fu, J. S. Binkley, and J. Mansfield, “RAM cell recovery mechanisms following high-energy ion strikes,” IEEE Electron Device Lett., vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 7-9, 1987.
[91]
R. Koga, S. D. Pinkerton, S. C. Moss, D. C. Mayer, S. LaLumondiere, S. J. Hansel, K. B. Crawford, and W. R. Crain, “Observation of single event upsets in analog microcircuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1838-1844, 1993.
[92]
R. Ecoffet, S. Duzellier, P. Tastet, C. Aicardi, and M. Labrunee, “Observation of heavy ion induced transients in linear circuits,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 72-77, 1994.
[93]
M. V. O’Bryan, K. A. LaBel, R. A. Reed, J. L. Barth, C. M. Seidleck, P. Marshall, C. Marshall, and M. Carts, “Single event effect and radiation damage results for candidate spacecraft electronics,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 39-50, 1998. All references are unclassified
II-73
[94]
D. K. Nichols, J. R. Coss, T. F. Miyahira, and H. R. Schwartz, “Heavy ion and proton induced single event transients in comparators,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2960-2967, 1996.
[95]
T. L. Turflinger and M. V. Davey, “Transient radiation test techniques for high-speed analog-to-digital converters,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 36, no. 6, pp. 2356-2361, 1989.
[96]
T. L. Turflinger, M. V. Davey, and B. M. Mappes, “Single event effects in analog-to-digital converters: device performance and system impact,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2187-2194, 1994.
[97]
S. Bee, G. R. Hopkinson, R. Harboe-Sørensen, L. Adams, and A. Smith, “Heavy-ion study of single event effects in 12- and 16-bit ADCs,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 58-67, 1998.
[98]
T. L. Turflinger, “Single-event effects in analog and mixed-signal integrated circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 594-602, 1996.
[99]
S. E. Diehl-Nagle, J. E. Vinson, and E. L. Petersen, “Single-event upset rate predictions for complex logic systems,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 31, no. 6, pp. 1132-1138, 1984.
[100]
R. Koga, W. A. Kolasinski, M. T. Marra, and W. A. Hanna, “Techniques of microprocessor testing and SEU-rate prediction,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 4219-4224, 1985.
[101]
F. W. Sexton, W. T. Corbett, R. K. Treece, K. J. Hass, K. L. Hughes, C. L. Axness, G. L. Hash, M. R. Shaneyfelt, and T. F. Wunsch, “SEU simulation and testing of resistor hardened D-latches in the SA3300 microprocessor,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1521-1528, 1991.
[102]
V. Asenek, C. Underwood, R. Velazco, S. Rezgui, M. Oldfield, Ph. Cheynet, and R. Ecoffet, “SEU induced errors observed in microprocessor systems,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2876-2883, 1998.
[103]
S. H. Crain, W. R. Crain, K. B. Crawford, S. J. Hansel, P. Yu, and R. Koga, “Single event effects test results for the 80C186 and 80C286 microprocessors and the SMJ320C30 and SMJ320C40 digital signal processors,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 51-57, 1998.
[104]
R. Koga, K. B. Crawford, S. J. Hansel, W. R. Crain, S. H. Penzin, and S. W. Miller, “The risk of utilizing SEE sensitive COTS digital signal processor (DSP) devices in space,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2982-2989, 1996.
[105]
W. J. Stapor, “Single Event Effects (SEE) Qualification,” 1995 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Madison, WI.
[106]
N. Kaul, B. L. Bhuva, and S. E. Kerns, “Simulation of SEU transients in CMOS ICs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1514-1520, 1991.
[107]
M. P. Baze, S. Buchner, W. G. Bartholet, and T. A. Dao, “An SEU analysis approach for error propagation in digital VLSI CMOS ASICs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1863-1869, 1995.
[108]
S. Buchner, M. Baze, D. Brown, D. McMorrow, and J. Melinger, “Comparison of error rates in combinational and sequential logic,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2209-2216, 1997.
[109]
M. P. Baze and S. P. Buchner, “Attenuation of single event induced pulses in CMOS combinational logic,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2217-2223, 1997.
[110]
J. A. Zoutendyk, L. D. Edmonds, and L. S. Smith, “Characterization of multiple-bit errors from single-ion tracks in integrated circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 36, no. 6, pp. 2267-2274, 1989.
[111]
O. Musseau, F. Gardic, P. Roche, T. Corbière, R. A. Reed, S. Buchner, P. McDonald, J. Melinger, L. Tran, and A. B. Campbell, “Analysis of multiple bit upsets (MBU) in a CMOS SRAM,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2879-2888, 1996.
[112]
R. Koga, S. D. Pinkerton, T. J. Lie, and K. B. Crawford, “Single-word multiple-bit upsets in static random access devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1941-1946, 1993.
[113]
J. B. Blake and R. Mandel, “On-orbit observations of single event upset in Harris HB-6508 1K RAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1616-1619, 1986.
All references are unclassified
II-74
[114]
C. I. Underwood, J. W. Ward, C. S. Dyer, and A. J. Sims, “Observations of single-event upsets in nonhardened high-density SRAMs in Sun-synchronous orbit,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 18171827, 1992.
[115]
J. A. Zoutendyk, H. R. Schwartz, and L. R. Nevill, “Lateral charge transport from heavy-ion tracks in integrated circuit chips,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1644-1647, 1988.
[116]
J. A. Zoutendyk, L. S. Smith, and L. D. Edmonds, “Response of a DRAM to single-ion tracks of different heavy-ion species and stopping powers,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1844-1848, 1990.
[117]
Y. Song, K. N. Vu, J. S. Cable, A. A. Witteles, W. A. Kolasinski, R. Koga, J. H. Elder, J. V. Osborn, R. C. Martin, and N. M. Ghoniem, “Experimental and analytical investigation of single event, multiple bit upsets in poly-silicon load, 64K × 1 NMOS SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1673-1677, 1988.
[118]
P. E. Dodd, O. Musseau, M. R. Shaneyfelt, F. W. Sexton, C. D’hose, G. L. Hash, M. Martinez, R. A. Loemker, J.-L. Leray, and P. S. Winokur, “Impact of ion energy on single-event upset,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2483-2491, 1998.
[119]
S. Duzellier, D. Falguère, L. Moulière, R. Ecoffet, and J. Buisson, “SEE results using high energy ions,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1797-1802, 1995.
[120]
W. J. Stapor, A. Knudson, J. D. Kinnison, B. G. Carkhuff, and H. Dussault, “A comparison of single-event results from lower energy and higher energy ion beams,” presented at the 32nd Ann. Int. Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conf., Madison, WI, 1995.
[121]
T. L. Criswell, P. R. Measel, and K. L. Wahlin, “Single event upset testing with relativistic heavy ions,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 31, no. 6, pp. 1559-1562, 1984.
[122]
A. B. Campbell, O. Musseau, V. Ferlet-Cavrois, W. J. Stapor, and P. T. McDonald, “Analysis of single event effects at grazing angle,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 3, pp. 1603-1611, 1998.
[123]
D. K. Nichols, K. P. McCarty, J. R. Coss, A. Waskiewicz, J. Groninger, D. Oberg, J. Wert, P. Majewski, and R. Koga, “Observations of single event failure in power MOSFETs,” IEEE NSREC Radiation Effects Data Workshop Record, pp. 41-54, 1994.
[124]
R. Ecoffet, S. Duzellier, D. Falguère, L. Guibert, and C. Inguimbert, “Low LET cross-section measurements using high energy carbon beam,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2230-2236, 1997.
[125]
R. A. Reed, M. A. Carts, P. W. Marshall, C. J. Marshall, S. Buchner, M. LaMacchia, B. Mathes, and D. McMorrow, “Single event upset cross sections at various data rates,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2862-2867, 1996.
[126]
R. Koga, S. H. Crain, W. R. Crain, K. B. Crawford, and S. J. Hansel, “Comparative SEU sensitivies to relativistic heavy ions,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2475-2482, 1998.
[127]
W. J. Stapor, P. T. McDonald, A. R. Knudson, A. B. Campbell, and B. G. Glagola, “Charge collection in silicon for ions of different energy but same linear energy transfer (LET),” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1585-1590, 1988.
[128]
R. C. Martin, N. M. Ghoniem, Y. Song, and J. S. Cable, “The size effect of ion charge tracks on single event multiple-bit upset,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1305-1309, 1987.
[129]
O. Musseau, V. Ferlet-Cavrois, A. B. Campbell, W. J. Stapor, and P. T. McDonald, “Comparison of single event phenomena for front/back irradiations,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2250-2255, Dec. 1997.
[130]
J. L. Titus, C. F. Wheatley, K. M. Van Tyne, J. F. Krieg, D. I. Burton, and A. B. Campbell, “Effect of ion energy upon dielectric breakdown of the capacitor response in vertical power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2492-2499, 1998.
[131]
S. E. Kerns and B. D. Shafer, Eds., “The design of radiation-hardened ICs for space: a compendium of approaches,” Proc. IEEE, vol. 76, no. 11, pp. 1470-1509, 1988. All references are unclassified
II-75
[132]
S.-W. Fu, A. M. Mohsen, and T. C. May, “Alpha-particle-induced charge collection measurements and the effectiveness of a novel p-well protection barrier on VLSI memories,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 32, no. 1, pp. 49-54, 1985.
[133]
D. Burnett, C. Lage, and A. Bormann, “Soft-error-rate improvement in advanced BiCMOS SRAMs,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 156-160, 1993.
[134]
J. D. Hayden, R. C. Taft, P. Kenkare, C. Mazur, C. Gunderson, B. Y. Nguyen, M. Woo, C. Lage, B. J. Roman, S. Radhakrishna, R. Subrahmanyan, A. R. Sitaram, P. Pelley, J. H. Lin, K. Kemp, and H. Kirsch, “A quadruple well, quadruple polysilicon BiCMOS process for fast 16 Mb SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 41, no. 12, pp. 2318-2325, 1994.
[135]
T. Kishimoto, M. Takai, Y. Ohno, T. Nishimura, and M. Inuishi, “Control of carrier collection efficiency in n+p diode with retrograde well and epitaxial layers,” Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., vol. 36, pt. 1, no. 6A, pp. 34603462, 1997.
[136]
M. Takai, T. Kishimoto, Y. Ohno, H. Sayama, K. Sonoda, S. Satoh, T. Nishimura, H. Miyoshi, A. Kinomura, Y. Horino, and K. Fujii, “Soft error susceptibility and immune structures in dynamic random access memories (DRAMs) investigated by nuclear microprobes,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 696-704, 1996.
[137]
P. W. Marshall, C. J. Dale, T. R. Weatherford, M. Carts, D. McMorrow, A. Peczalski, S. Baier, J. Nohava, and J. Skogen, “Heavy ion SEU immunity of a GaAs complementary HIGFET circuit fabricated on a low temperature grown buffer layer,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1850-1855, 1995.
[138]
T. R. Weatherford, D. McMorrow, A. B. Campbell, and W. R. Curtice, “Significant reduction in the soft error susceptibility of GaAs field-effect transistors with a low-temperature grown GaAs buffer layer,” Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 67, no. 5, pp. 703-705, 1995.
[139]
D. McMorrow, T. R. Weatherford, S. Buchner, A. R. Knudson, J. S. Melinger, L. H. Tran, and A. B. Campbell, “Single-event phenomena in GaAs devices and circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 628-644, 1996.
[140]
O. Musseau, “Single-event effects in SOI technologies and devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 603-613, 1996.
[141]
G. E. Davis, L. R. Hite, T. G. W. Blake, C. E. Chen, H. W. Lam, and R. DeMoyer, “Transient radiation effects in SOI memories,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 4432-4437, 1985.
[142]
L. W. Massengill, D. V. Kerns, S. E. Kerns, and M. L. Alles, “Single event charge enhancement in SOI devices,” IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 98-99, 1990.
[143]
M. L. Alles, S. E. Kerns, L. W. Massengill, J. E. Clark, K. L. Jones, and R. E. Lowther, “Body tie placement in CMOS/SOI digital circuits for transient radiation environments,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1259-1264, 1991.
[144]
J. Gautier, M. M. Pelella, and J. G. Fossum, “SOI floating-body, device and circuit issues,” IEDM Tech. Digest, pp. 407-410, 1997.
[145]
J. Sleight and K. Mistry, “A compact Schottky body contact technology for SOI transistors,” IEDM Tech. Digest, pp. 419-422, 1997.
[146]
J. W. Sleight, K. R. Mistry, and D. A. Antonaidis, “Transient measurements of SOI body contact effectiveness,” IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., vol. 19, no. 12, pp. 499-501, 1998.
[147]
L. R. Hite, H. Lu, T. W. Houston, D. S. Hurta, and W. E. Bailey, “An SEU resistant 256k SOI SRAM,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 2121-2125, 1992.
[148]
N. van Vonno and B. R. Doyle, “A 256k SRAM implemented in SOI technology,” Proc. RADECS-93, pp. 392-395, 1993.
[149]
P. Francis, J.-P. Colinge, and G. Berger, “Temporal analysis of SEU in SOI/GAA SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 2127-2137, 1995. All references are unclassified
II-76
[150]
J. L. Andrews, J. E. Schroeder, B. L. Gingerich, W. A. Kolasinski, R. Koga, and S. E. Diehl, “Single event error immune CMOS RAM,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 29, no. 6, pp. 2040-2043, 1982.
[151]
P. S. Winokur, F. W. Sexton, D. M. Fleetwood, M. D. Terry, M. R. Shaneyfelt, P. V. Dressendorfer, and J. R. Schwank, “Implementing QML for radiation hardness assurance,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1794-1805, 1990.
[152]
L. R. Rockett, Jr., “Simulated SEU hardened scaled CMOS SRAM cell design using gated resistors,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 5, pp. 1532-1541, 1992.
[153]
L. M. Cohn, Defense Threat Reduction Agency, private communication.
[154]
H. T. Weaver, C. L. Axness, J. D. McBrayer, J. S. Browning, J. S. Fu, A. Ochoa, and R. Koga, “An SEU tolerant memory cell derived from fundamental studies of SEU mechanisms in SRAM,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1281-1286, 1987.
[155]
R. L. Johnson, Jr., and S. E. Diehl, “An improved single event resistive-hardening technique for CMOS static RAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1730-1733, 1986.
[156]
A. Ochoa, Jr., C. L. Axness, H. T. Weaver, and J. S. Fu, “A proposed new structure for SEU immunity in SRAM employing drain resistance,” IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., vol. 8, no. 11, pp. 537-539, 1987.
[157]
S. Verghese, J. J. Wortman, and S. E. Kerns, “A novel CMOS SRAM feedback element for SEU environments,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1641-1646, 1987.
[158]
F. Ootsuka, M. Nakamura, T. Miyake, S. Iwahashi, Y. Ohira, T. Tamaru, K. Kikushima, and K. Yamaguchi, “A novel 0.20 µm full CMOS SRAM cell using stacked cross couple with enhanced soft error immunity,” IEDM Tech. Digest, pp. 205-208, 1998.
[159]
D. R. Alexander, “Design Issues for Radiation Tolerant Microcircuits for Space,” 1996 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Indian Wells, CA.
[160]
L. R. Rockett, Jr., “An SEU hardened CMOS data latch design,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1682-1687, 1988.
[161]
H. T. Weaver, W. T. Corbett, and J. M. Pimbley, “Soft error protection using asymmetric response latches,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1555-1557, 1991.
[162]
M. N. Liu and S. Whitaker, “Low power SEU immune CMOS memory circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1679-1684, 1992.
[163]
D. Wiseman, J. Canaris, S. Whitaker, J. Venbrux, K. Cameron, K. Arave, L. Arave, M. N. Liu, and K. Liu, “Design and testing of SEU/SEL immune memory and logic circuits in a commercial CMOS process,” IEEE NSREC Data Workshop Record, pp. 51-55, 1993.
[164]
R. Velazco, D. Bessot, S. Duzellier, R. Ecoffet, and R. Koga, “Two CMOS memory cells suitable for the design of SEU-tolerant VLSI circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2229-2234, 1994.
[165]
T. Calin, M. Nicolaidis, and R. Velazco, “Upset hardened memory design for submicron CMOS technology,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2874-2878, 1996.
[166]
G. R. Agrawal, L. W. Massengill, and K. Gulati, “A proposed SEU tolerant dynamic random access memory (DRAM) cell,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2035-2042, 1994.
[167]
D. C. Bossen and M. Y. Hsaio, “A system solution to the memory soft error problem,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 390-397, 1980.
[168]
C. L. Chen and M. Y. Hsiao, “Error-correcting codes for semiconductor memory applications: a state-ofthe-art review,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 124-134, 1984.
[169]
P. M. O’Neill and G. D. Badhwar, “Single event upsets for space shuttle flights of new general purpose computer memory devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 5, pp. 1755-1764, 1994.
All references are unclassified
II-77
[170]
J. D. Kinnison, “Achieving Reliable, Affordable Systems,” 1998 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Newport Beach, CA.
[171]
W. F. Heidergott, “System Level Mitigation Strategies,” 1999 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Norfolk, VA.
[172]
G. H. Johnson and K. F. Galloway, “Catastrophic Single-Event Effects in the Natural Space Radiation Environment,” 1996 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Indian Wells, CA.
[173]
R. R. Troutman, Latchup in CMOS Technology : The Problem and its Cure, (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1986).
[174]
A. H. Johnston, “The influence of VLSI technology evolution on radiation-induced latchup in space systems,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 505-521, 1996.
[175]
W. A. Kolasinski, J. B. Blake, J. K. Anthony, W. E. Price, and E. C. Smith, “Simulation of cosmic-ray induced soft errors and latchup in integrated-circuit computer memories,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 26, no. 6, pp. 5087-5091, 1979.
[176]
D. K. Nichols, W. E. Price, M. A. Shoga, J. Duffey, W. A. Kolasinski, and R. Koga, “Discovery of heavyion induced latchup in CMOS/Epi devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, p. 1696, 1986.
[177]
L. Adams, E. J. Daly, R. Harboe-Sørensen, R. Nickson, J. Haines, W. Schafer, M. Conrad, H. Griech, J. Merkel, T. Schwall, and R. Henneck, “A verified proton-induced latch-up in space,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1804-1808, 1992.
[178]
D. K. Nichols, J. R. Coss, R. K. Watson, H. R. Schwartz, and R. L. Pease, “An observation of protoninduced latchup,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1654-1656, 1992.
[179]
B. Johlander, R. Harboe-Sørensen, G. Olsson, and L. Bylander, “Ground verification of in-orbit anomalies in the double probe electric field experiment on Freja,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 27672771, 1996.
[180]
G. Bruguier and J.-M. Palau, “Single particle-induced latchup,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 522-532, 1996.
[181]
K. Soliman and D. K. Nichols, “Latchup in CMOS devices from heavy ions,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 30, no. 6, pp. 4514-4519, 1983.
[182]
J. G. Rollins, W. A. Kolasinski, D. C. Marvin, and R. Koga, “Numerical simulation of SEU induced latchup,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1565-1570, 1986.
[183]
A. H. Johnston and B. W. Hughlock, “Latchup in CMOS from single particles,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1886-1893, 1990.
[184]
Y. Moreau, H. de La Rochette, G. Bruguier, J. Gasiot, F. Pélanchon, C. Sudre, and R. Ecoffet, “The latchup risk of CMOS technology in space,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1831-1837, 1993.
[185]
H. de La Rochette, G. Bruguier, J.-M. Palau, J. Gasiot, and R. Ecoffet, “The effect of layout modification on latchup triggering in CMOS by experimental and simulation approaches,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2222-2228, 1994.
[186]
A. H. Johnston, G. M. Swift, and L. D. Edmonds, “Latchup in integrated circuits from energetic protons,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2367-2377, 1997.
[187]
T. Chapuis, H. C. Erems, and L. H. Rosier, “Latch-up on CMOS/Epi devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1839-1842, 1990.
[188]
A. G. Lewis, R. A. Martin, T. H. Huang, J. O. Chen, and M. Koyanagi, “Latchup performance of retrograde and conventional n-well CMOS technologies,” IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., vol. 34, no. 10, pp. 2156-2160, 1987.
[189]
P. V. Gilbert, P. E. Crabtree, and S. W. Sun, “Latch-up performance of a sub-0.5 micron inter-well deep trench technology,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 731-734, 1993. All references are unclassified
II-78
[190]
J. P. Colinge, Silicon on Insulator Technology: Materials to VLSI, (Kluwer Academic, Boston, 1991).
[191]
A. Ochoa, Jr. And P. V. Dressendorfer, “A discussion of the role of distributed effects in latch-up,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 4292-4294, 1981.
[192]
N. Shiono, Y. Sakagawa, T. Matsumoto, and Y. Akasaka, “A 64K SRAM with high immunity from heavy ion induced latch-up,” IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 20-22, 1986.
[193]
J. R. Adams and R. J. Sokel, “Neutron irradiation for prevention of latchup in MOS integrated circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 26, no. 6, pp. 5069-5073, 1979.
[194]
J. L. Titus and C. F. Wheatley, “Experimental studies of single-event gate rupture and burnout in vertical power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 533-545, 1996.
[195]
G. H. Johnson, J.-M. Palau, C. Dachs, K. F. Galloway, and R. D. Schrimpf, “A review of the techniques used for modeling single-event effects in power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 546-560, 1996.
[196]
J. L. Titus, C. F. Wheatley, K. M. Van Tyne, J. F. Krieg, D. I. Burton, and A. B. Campbell, “Effect of ion energy upon dielectric breakdown of the capacitor response in vertical power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2492-2499, 1998.
[197]
J. L. Titus, C. F. Wheatley, D. I. Burton, M. Allenspach, J. Brews, R. D. Schrimpf, K. Galloway, I. Mouret, and R. L. Pease, “Impact of oxide thickness on SEGR failure in vertical power MOSFETs; Development of a semi-empirical expression,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1928-1934, 1995.
[198]
C. F. Wheatley, J. L. Titus, and D. I. Burton, “Single-event gate rupture in vertical power MOSFETS; An original empirical expression,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2152-2159, 1994.
[199]
M. Allenspach, C. Dachs, G. H. Johnson, R. D. Schrimpf, E. Lorfèvre, J.-M. Palau, J. R. Brews, K. F. Galloway, J. L. Titus, and C. F. Wheatley, “SEGR and SEB in n-channel power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2927-2931, 1996.
[200]
J. L. Titus, C. F. Wheatley, M. Allenspach, R. D. Schrimpf, D. I. Burton, J. R. Brews, K. F. Galloway, and R. L. Pease, “Influence of ion beam energy on SEGR failure thresholds of vertical power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2938-2943, 1996.
[201]
R. Koga, W. R. Crain, K. B. Crawford, D. D. Lau, S. D. Pinkerton, B. K. Yi, and R. Chitty, “On the suitability of non-hardened high density SRAMs for space applications,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1507-1511, 1991.
[202]
C. Dufour, P. Garnier, T. Carrière, J. Beaucour, R. Ecoffet, and M. Labrunée, “Heavy ion induced single hard errors on submicronic memories,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1693-1697, 1992.
[203]
T. R. Oldham, K. W. Bennett, J. Beaucour, T. Carrière, C. Poivey, and P. Garnier, “Total dose failures in advanced electronics from single ions,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1820-1830, 1993.
[204]
G. M. Swift, D. J. Padgett, and A. H. Johnston, “A new class of single event hard errors,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2043-2048, 1994.
[205]
A. H. Johnston, C. I. Lee, B. G. Rax, and D. C. Shaw, “Using commercial semiconductor technologies in space,” Proc. RADECS-95, pp. 175-182, 1995.
[206]
F. W. Sexton, D. M. Fleetwood, M. R. Shaneyfelt, P. E. Dodd, and G. L. Hash, “Single event gate rupture in thin gate oxides,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2345-2352, 1997.
[207]
A. H. Johnston, “Radiation effects in advanced microelectronics technologies,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 3, pp. 1339-1354, 1998.
[208]
A. H. Johnston, G. M. Swift, T. Miyahira, and L. D. Edmonds, “Breakdown of gate oxides during irradiation with heavy ions,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2500-2508, 1998.
All references are unclassified
II-79
[209]
F. W. Sexton, D. M. Fleetwood, M. R. Shaneyfelt, P. E. Dodd, G. L. Hash, L. P. Schanwald, R. A. Loemker, K. S. Krisch, M. L. Green, B. E. Weir, and P. J. Silverman, “Precursor ion damage and angular dependence of single event gate rupture in thin oxides,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 25092518, 1998.
[210]
B. E. Weir, P. J. Silverman, D. Monroe, K. S. Krisch, M. A. Alam, G. B. Alers, T. W. Sorsch, G. L. Timp, F. Baumann, C. T. Liu, Y. Ma, and D. Hwang, “Ultra-thin gate dielectrics: They break down, but do they fail?” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 73-76, 1997.
[211]
T. F. Wrobel, “On heavy ion induced hard-errors in dielectric structures,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 1262-1268, 1987.
[212]
A. W. Waskiewicz, J. W. Groninger, V. H. Strahan, and D. M. Long, “Burnout of power MOS transistors with heavy ions of Californium-252,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1710-1713, 1986.
[213]
J. L. Titus, G. H. Johnson, R. D. Schrimpf, and K. F. Galloway, “Single-event burnout of power bipolar junction transistors,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1315-1322, 1991.
[214]
D. L. Oberg, J. L. Wert, E. Normand, P. P. Majewski, and S. A. Wender, “First observations of power MOSFET burnout with high energy neutrons,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2913-2920, 1996.
[215]
J. W. Adolphsen, J. L. Barth, and G. B. Gee, “First observation of proton induced power MOSFET burnout in space: The CRUX experiment on APEX,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2921-2926, 1996.
[216]
S. Kuboyama, K. Sugimoto, S. Shugyo, S. Matsuda, and T. Hirao, “Single-event burnout of epitaxial bipolar transistors,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2527-2533, 1998.
[217]
D. L. Oberg and J. L. Wert, “First nondestructive measurements of power MOSFET single event burnout cross sections,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1736-1744, 1987.
[218]
S. Kuboyama, S. Matsuda, T. Kanno, and T. Ishii, “Mechanism for single-event burnout of power MOSFETs and its characterization technique,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1698-1703, 1992.
[219]
C. Dachs, F. Roubaud, J.-M. Palau, G. Bruguier, J. Gasiot, and P. Tastet, “Evidence of the ion’s impact position effect on SEB in n-channel power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 21672171, 1994.
[220]
G. H. Johnson, R. D. Schrimpf, K. F. Galloway, and R. Koga, “Temperature dependence of single-event burnout in n-channel power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1605-1612, 1992.
[221]
J. L. Titus, L. S. Jamiolkowski, and C. F. Wheatley, “Development of cosmic ray hardened power MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 36, no. 6, pp. 2375-2382, 1989.
[222]
T. F. Wrobel and D. E. Beutler, “Solutions to heavy ion induced avalanche burnout in power devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1636-1641, 1992.
[223]
C. Dachs, F. Roubaud, J.-M. Palau, Guy Bruguier, J. Gasiot, P. Tastet, M.-C. Calvet, and P. Calvel, “Simulation aided hardening of n-channel power MOSFETs to prevent single event burnout,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 1935-1939, 1995.
[224]
C. W. Gwyn, D. L. Scharfetter, and J. L. Wirth, “The analysis of radiation effects in semiconductor junction devices,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 14, no. 6, pp. 153-169, 1967.
[225]
V. A. J. van Lint, J. H. Alexander, D. K. Nichols, and P. R. Ward, “Computerized model for response of transistors to a pulse of ionizing radiation,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 14, no. 6, pp. 170-178, 1967.
[226]
D. Binder, E. C. Smith, and A. B. Holman, “Satellite anomalies from galactic cosmic rays,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 22, no. 7, pp. 2675-2680, 1975.
[227]
J. C. Pickel, “Single-event effects rate prediction,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 483-495, 1996.
[228]
P. J. McNulty, W. G. Abdel-Kader, and G. E. Farrell, “Proton induced spallation reactions,” Radiat. Phys. Chem., vol. 43, pp. 139-149, 1994. All references are unclassified
II-80
[229]
R. A. Reed, P. J. McNulty, W. J. Beauvais, W. G. Abdel-Kader, E. G. Stassinopoulos, and J. L. Barth, “A simple algorithm for predicting proton SEU rates in space compared to the rates measured on the CRRES satellite,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2389-2395, 1994.
[230]
H. H. K. Tang, G. R. Srinivasan, and N. Azziz, “Cascade statistical model for nucleon-induced reactions on light nuclei in the energy range 50 MeV-1 GeV,” Phys. Rev. C, vol. 42, pp. 1598-1622, 1990.
[231]
E. Normand, “Extensions of the burst generation rate method for wider application to proton/neutroninduced single event effects,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2904-2914, 1998.
[232]
C. Vial, J.-M. Palau, J. Gasiot, M. C. Calvet, and S. Fourtine, “A new approach for the prediction of the neutron-induced SEU rate,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2915-2920, 1998.
[233]
R. N. Hamm, J. E. Turner, H. A. Wright, and R. H. Ritchie, “Heavy-ion track structure in silicon,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 26, no. 6, pp. 4892-4895, 1979.
[234]
E. J. Kobetich and R. Katz, “Energy deposition by electron beams and δ rays,” Phys. Rev., vol. 170, no. 2, pp. 391-396, 1968.
[235]
M. P. R. Waligórski, R. N. Hamm, and R. Katz, “The radial distribution of dose around the path of a heavy ion in liquid water,” Int. J. Radiat. Appl. Instrum. D, vol. 11, no. 6, pp. 309-319, 1986.
[236]
R. Katz, K. S. Loh, L. Daling, and G. R. Huang, “An analytic representation of the radial distribution of dose from energetic heavy ions in water, Si, LiF, NaI, and SiO2,” Rad. Eff. Def. Solids, vol. 114, no. 1, pp. 15-20, 1990.
[237]
W. J. Stapor and P. T. McDonald, “Practical approach to ion track energy distribution,” J. Appl. Phys., vol. 64, no. 9, pp. 4430-4434, 1988.
[238]
O. Fageeha, J. Howard, and R. C. Block, “Distribution of radial energy deposition around the track of energetic charged particles in silicon,” J. Appl. Phys., vol. 75, no. 5, pp. 2317-2321, 1994.
[239]
M. A. Xapsos, “Applicability of LET to single events in microelectronic structures,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1613-1621, Dec. 1992.
[240]
H. Dussault, J. W. Howard, Jr., R. C. Block, M. R. Pinto, W. J. Stapor, and A. R. Knudson, “Numerical simulation of heavy ion charge generation and collection dynamics,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1926-1934, 1993.
[241]
H. Dussault, J. W. Howard, Jr., R. C. Block, M. R. Pinto, W. J. Stapor, and A. R. Knudson, “The effects of ion track structure in simulating single event phenomena,” Proc. RADECS93, pp. 509-516, 1993.
[242]
M. Kurata, Numerical Analysis for Semiconductor Devices, (D. C. Heath and Co., Lexington, 1982).
[243]
S. Selberherr, Analysis and Simulation of Semiconductor Devices, (Springer-Verlag, Vienna, 1984).
[244]
M. S. Lundstrom, Fundamentals of Carrier Transport, Volume X of the Modular Series on Solid State Devices, (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1990).
[245]
Davinci 4.1 User’s Manual (Avant! Corporation, TCAD Business Unit, 1998).
[246]
T. R. Weatherford, D. McMorrow, W. R. Curtice, A. R. Knudson, and A. B. Campbell, “Single event induced charge transport modeling of GaAs MESFETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 18671871, 1993.
[247]
J. S. Melinger, S. Buchner, D. McMorrow, W. J. Stapor, T. R. Weatherford, and A. B. Campbell, “Critical evaluation of the pulsed laser method for single event effects testing and fundamental studies,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2574-2584, 1994.
[248]
K. Hess, Monte Carlo Device Simulation: Full Band and Beyond, (Kluwer Academic, Boston, 1991).
[249]
G. A. Sai-Halasz and M. R. Wordeman, “Monte Carlo modeling of the transport of ionizing radiation created carriers in integrated circuits,” IEEE Electron Device Lett., vol. 1, no. 10, pp. 211-213, 1980. All references are unclassified
II-81
[250]
G. A. Sai-Halasz, M. R. Wordeman, and R. H. Dennard, “Alpha-particle-induced soft error rate in VLSI circuits,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 29, no. 4, pp. 725-731, 1982.
[251]
G. A. Sai-Halasz, “Cosmic ray induced soft error rate in VLSI circuits,” IEEE Electron Device Lett., vol. 4, no. 6, pp. 172-174, 1983.
[252]
C. Brisset, P. Dollfus, P. Hesto, and O. Musseau, “Monte Carlo simulation of the dynamic behavior of a CMOS inverter struck by a heavy ion,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 619-624, 1994.
[253]
C. Brisset, P. Dollfus, N. Chemarin, R. Castagné, and P. Hesto, “Three-dimensional Monte Carlo simulation of submicron devices,” Proc. 5th Int. Conf. Simulation of Semiconductor Devices and Processes (SISDEP), pp. 189-192, 1993.
[254]
C. Brisset, P. Dollfus, O. Musseau, J.-L. Leray, and P. Hesto, “Theoretical study of SEUs in 0.25-µm fullydepleted CMOS/SOI technology,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2297-2303, 1994.
[255]
J. P. Kreskovsky and H. L. Grubin, “Simulation of charge collection in a multilayer device,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 4140-4144, 1985.
[256]
W. T. Anderson, A. R. Knudson, F. A. Buot, H. L. Grubin, J. P. Kreskovsky, and A. B. Campbell, “Experimental and theoretical study of alpha particle induced charge collection in GaAs FETs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1326-1331, 1987.
[257]
J. S. Fu, C. L. Axness, and H. T. Weaver, “Two-dimensional simulation of single event induced bipolar current in CMOS structures,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 31, no. 6, pp. 1155-1159, 1984.
[258]
J. S. Fu, H. T. Weaver, R. Koga, and W. A. Kolasinski, “Comparison of 2D memory SEU transport simulation with experiments,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 4145-4149, 1985.
[259]
J. S. Fu, K. H. Lee, R. Koga, W. A. Kolasinski, H. T. Weaver, and J. S. Browning, “Processing enhanced SEU tolerance in high density SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1322-1325, 1987.
[260]
J. S. Fu, K. H. Lee, R. Koga, F. W. Hewlett, R. Flores, R. E. Anderson, J. C. Desko, W. J. Nagy, J. A. Shimer, R. A. Kohler, and S. D. Steenwyk, “Scaling studies of CMOS SRAM soft-error tolerances– from 16k to 256k,” IEDM Tech. Digest, pp. 540-543, 1987.
[261]
J. G. Rollins, J. Choma, Jr., and W. A. Kolasinski, “Single event upset in SOS integrated circuits,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1713-1717, 1987.
[262]
J. H. Chern, J. A. Seitchik, and P. Yang, “Single event charge collection modeling in CMOS multi-junctions structure,” IEDM Tech. Digest, pp. 538-541, 1986.
[263]
D. McMorrow, J. S. Melinger, A. R. Knudson, S. Buchner, L. H. Tran, and A. B. Campbell, “Chargeenhancement mechanisms of GaAs field-effect transistors: experiment and simulation,” Proc. RADECS-97, pp. 346-352, 1997.
[264]
J. G. Rollins, T. K. Tsubota, W. A. Kolasinski, N. F. Haddad, L. Rockett, M. Cerrila, and W. B. Hennley, “Cost-effective numerical simulation of SEU,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1608-1612, 1988.
[265]
J. A. Zoutendyk, L. S. Smith, G. A. Soli, and R. Y. Lo, “Experimental evidence for a new single-event upset (SEU) model in a CMOS SRAM obtained from model verification,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 1292-1299, 1987.
[266]
J. A. Zoutendyk, E. C. Secrest, and D. F. Berndt, “Investigation of single-event upset (SEU) in an advanced bipolar process,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1573-1577, 1988.
[267]
A. R. Knudson and A. B. Campbell, “Comparison of experimental charge collection waveforms with PISCES calculations,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1540-1545, 1991.
[268]
E. Worley, R. Williams, A. Waskiewicz, and J. Groninger, “Experimental and simulation study of the effects of cosmic particles on CMOS/SOS RAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1855-1860, 1990. All references are unclassified
II-82
[269]
P. E. Dodd, M. R. Shaneyfelt, and F. W. Sexton, “Charge collection and SEU from angled ion strikes,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2256-2265, 1997.
[270]
E. M. Buturla, P. E. Cottrell, B. M. Grossman, K. A. Salsburg, M. B. Lawlor, and C. T. McMullen, “Threedimensional finite element simulation of semiconductor devices,” IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conf. Digest of Tech. Papers, pp. 76-77, 1980.
[271]
E. M. Buturla, P. E. Cottrell, B. M. Grossman, and K. A. Salsburg, “Finite-element analysis of semiconductor devices: the FIELDAY program,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 218-231, 1981.
[272]
E. Takeda, K. Takeuchi, E. Yamasaki, T. Toyabe, K. Ohshima, and K. Itoh, “The scaling law of alphaparticle induced soft errors for VLSI’s,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 542-545, 1986.
[273]
D. Hisamoto, T. Toyabe, and E. Takeda, “Alpha-particle-induced source-drain penetration (ALPEN) effects— A new soft error phenomenon,” Ext. Abs. Conf. Solid-State Dev. Mat., pp. 39-42, 1987.
[274]
J. H. Chern, J. T. Maeda, L. A. Arledge, Jr., and P. Yang, “SIERRA: a 3-D device simulator for reliability modeling,” IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. 8, no. 5, pp. 516-527, 1989.
[275]
J. P. Kreskovsky and H. L. Grubin, “Numerical simulation of charge collection in two- and threedimensional silicon diodes— a comparison,” Solid–State Electron., vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 505-518, 1986.
[276]
A. Yoshii, H. Kitazawa, M. Tomizawa, S. Horiguchi, and T. Sudo, “A three-dimensional analysis of semiconductor devices,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 184-189, 1982.
[277]
T. Toyabe, H. Masuda, Y. Aoki, H. Shukuri, and T. Hagiwara, “Three-dimensional device simulator CADDETH with highly-convergent matrix solution algorithms,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 32, no. 10, pp. 2038-2043, 1985.
[278]
W. Fichtner, R. L. Johnston, and D. J. Rose, “Three-dimensional numerical modeling of small-size MOSFETs,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 28, no. 10, pp. 1215-1216, 1981.
[279]
M. R. Pinto, W. M. Coughran, Jr., C. S. Rafferty, R. K. Smith, and E. Sangiori, “Device simulation for silicon ULSI,” in Computational Electronics, edited by K. Hess, J. P. Leburton, and U. Ravaioli (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1991), pp. 3-13.
[280]
N. Shigyo and R. Dang, “Analysis of an anomalous subthreshold current in a fully recessed oxide MOSFET using a three-dimensional device simulator,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 441-445, 1985.
[281]
Taurus Process/Device User’s Manual (Avant! Corporation, TCAD Business Unit, 1998).
[282]
Athena/Atlas User’s Manual (Silvaco International, 1997).
[283]
DESSIS User’s Manual, Release 4, Vol. 5 (ISE Integrated Systems Engineering AG, 1997).
[284]
P. E. Dodd, “Analyzing heavy-ion-induced charge collection in Si devices by three-dimensional simulation,” presented at the 13th Int. Conf. on the Application of Accelerators in Research and Industry, Denton, TX, 1994.
[285]
S. E. Kerns, “Transient-ionization and single-event phenomena,” in Ionizing Radiation Effects in MOS Devices and Circuits, edited by T. P. Ma and P. V. Dressendorfer (Wiley, New York, 1989), pp. 485-576.
[286]
L. W. Massengill, “SEU modeling and prediction techniques,” 1993 IEEE NSREC Short Course, Snowbird, UT.
[287]
R. J. McPartland, “Circuit simulations of alpha-particle-induced soft errors in MOS dynamic RAM’s,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 31-34, 1981.
[288]
R. L. Johnson, Jr., S. E. Diehl-Nagle, and J. R. Hauser, “Simulation approach for modeling single event upsets on advanced CMOS SRAMs,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 4122-4127, 1985.
[289]
D. D. Tang and C. Chuang, “A circuit concept for reducing soft error in high-speed memory cells,” IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 201-203, 1988. All references are unclassified
II-83
[290]
K. Gulati, L. W. Massengill, and G. R. Agrawal, “Single event mirroring and DRAM sense amplifier designs for improved single–event–upset performance,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 20262034, 1994.
[291]
M. S. Mock, Numerical Analysis of Semiconductor Devices and Integrated Circuits, edited by B. T. Browne and J. J. H. Miller (Boole Press, Dublin, 1981).
[292]
J. G. Rollins and J. Choma, Jr., “Mixed-mode PISCES-SPICE coupled circuit and device solver,” IEEE. Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. 7, no. 8, pp. 862-867, 1988.
[293]
K. Mayaram, J. H. Chern, and P. Yang, “Algorithms for transient three-dimensional mixed-level circuit and device simulation,” IEEE Trans. Computer-Aided Design, vol. 12, no. 11, pp. 1726-1733, 1993.
[294]
K. Mayaram, P. Yang, and J. H. Chern, “Transient three-dimensional mixed-level circuit and device simulation: Algorithm and applications,” Proc. ICCAD-91, pp. 112-115, 1991.
[295]
Ph. Roche, J. M. Palau, K. Belhaddad, G. Bruguier, R. Ecoffet, and J. Gasiot, “SEU response of an entire SRAM cell simulated as one contiguous three dimensional device domain,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2534-2543, 1998.
[296]
S. Satoh, R. Sudo, H. Tashiro, N. Higaki, and N. Nakayama, “CMOS-SRAM soft-error simulation system,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 339-343, 1994.
[297]
Y. Tosaka, S. Satoh, T. Itakura, K. Suzuki, T. Sugii, H. Ehara, and G. A. Woffinden, “Cosmic ray neutroninduced soft errors in sub-half micron CMOS circuits,” IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 99-101, 1997.
[298]
Y. Tosaka, S. Satoh, K. Suzuki, T. Sugii, N. Nakayama, H. Ehara, G. A. Woffinden, and S. A. Wender, “Measurements and analysis of neutron-reaction-induced charges in a silicon surface region,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 2, pp. 173-178, 1997.
[299]
Y. Tosaka, S. Satoh, T. Itakura, H. Ehara, T. Ueda, G. Woffinden, and S. A. Wender, “Measurement and analysis of neutron-induced soft errors in sub-half-micron CMOS circuits,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 45, no. 7, pp. 1453-1458, 1998.
[300]
G. R. Srinivasan, P. C. Murley, and H. K. Tang, “Accurate, predictive modeling of soft error rate due to cosmic rays and chip alpha radiation,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 12-16, 1994.
[301]
G. R. Srinivasan, H. K. Tang, and P. C. Murley, “Parameter-free, predictive modeling of single event upsets due to protons, neutrons, and pions in terrestrial cosmic rays,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 2063-2070, 1994.
[302]
P. C. Murley and G. R. Srinivasan, “Soft-error Monte Carlo modeling program, SEMM,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 109-118, 1996.
[303]
H. H. K. Tang, “Nuclear physics of cosmic ray interaction with semiconductor materials: particle-induced soft errors from a physicist’s perspective,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 91-108, 1996.
[304]
G. R. Srinivasan, “Modeling the cosmic-ray-induced soft-error rate in integrated circuits: an overview,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 77-89, 1996.
[305]
Soft Error Rate Prediction Service, IBM Microelectronics Division brochure, 1994.
[306]
D. G. Mavis and P. H. Eaton, “Temporally redundant latch for preventing single event disruptions in sequential integrated circuits,” Mission Research Corporation Tech. Rep. P8111.29, September 1998.
[307]
E. Normand, “Single-event effects in avionics,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 461-474, 1996.
[308]
J. F. Ziegler, H. W. Curtis, H. P. Muhlfeld, C. J. Montrose, B. Chin, M. Nicewicz, C. A. Russell, W. Y. Yang, L. B. Freeman, P. Hosier, L. E. LaFave, J. L. Walsh, J. M. Orro, G. J. Unger, J. M. Ross, T. J. O’Gorman, B. Messina, T. D. Sullivan, A. J. Sykes, H. Yourke, T. A. Enger, V. Tolat, T. S. Scott, A. H. Taber, R. J. Sussman, W. A. Klein, and C. W. Wahaus, “IBM experiments in soft fails in computer electronics (1978-1994), IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 3-18, 1996. All references are unclassified
II-84
[309]
J. F. Ziegler, “Terrestrial cosmic rays,” IBM J. Res. Develop., vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 19-39, 1996.
[310]
E. Normand and T. J. Baker, “Altitude and latitude variations in avionics SEU and atmospheric neutrons,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 1484-1490, 1993.
[311]
J. T. Wallmark and S. M. Marcus, “Minimum size and maximum packing density of nonredundant semiconductor devices,” Proc. IRE, vol. 50, pp. 286-298, 1962.
[312]
See numerous papers in the 1978-1980 proceedings of the IEEE NSREC and the IEEE International Reliability Physics Symposium.
[313]
T. C. May, “Soft errors in VLSI: present and future,” IEEE Trans. Components, Hybrids, Manuf. Tech., vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 377-387, 1979.
[314]
Z. Hasnain and A. Ditali, “Building-in reliability: soft errors– a case study,” Proc. IEEE Int. Reliability Phys. Symp., pp. 276-280, 1992.
[315]
T. J. O’Gorman, “The effect of cosmic rays on the soft error rate of a DRAM at ground level,” IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, vol. 41, no. 4, pp. 553-557, 1994.
[316]
C. Lage, D. Burnett, T. McNelly, K. Baker, A. Bormann, D. Dreier, and V. Soorholtz, “Soft error rate and stored charge requirements in advanced high-density SRAMs,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 821-824, 1993.
[317]
E. Normand, “Single event upset at ground level,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 2742-2750, 1996.
[318]
P. D. Bradley and E. Normand, “Single event upsets in implantable cardioverter defibrillators,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 2929-2940, 1998.
[319]
E. Normand, J. L. Wert, D. L. Oberg, P. P. Majewski, P. Voss, and S. A. Wender, “Neutron-induced single event burnout in high voltage electronics,” IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2358-2366, 1997.
[320]
Private communication, numerous US semiconductor and computer manufacturers.
[321]
M. Takada, “DRAM technology for giga-bit age,” Ext. Abs. Solid-State Dev. Mat. Conf., pp. 874-876, 1993.
[322]
A. H. Taber and E. Normand, “Investigation and characterization of SEU effects and hardening strategies in avionics,” DNA Technical Report DNA-TR-94-123, 1995.
[323]
Y. H. Koh. M. R. Oh, J. W. Lee, J. W. Yang, W. C. Lee, C. K. Park, J. B. Park, Y. C. Heo, K. M. Rho, B. C. Lee, M. J. Chung, M. Huh, H. S. Kim, K. S. Choi, W. C. Lee, J. K. Lee, K. H. Ahn, K. W. Park, J. Y. Yang, H. K. Kim, D. H. Lee, and I. S. Hwang, “1 gigabit SOI DRAM with fully bulk compatible process and body-contacted SOI MOSFET structure,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 579-582, 1997.
[324]
K. Mistry, G. Grula, J. Sleight, L. Bair, R. Stephany, R. Flatley, and P. Skerry, “A 2.0V, 0.35µm partiallydepleted SOI-CMOS technology,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 583-586, 1997.
[325]
D. J. Schepis, F. Assaderaghi, D. S. Yee, W. Rausch, R. J. Bolam, A. C. Ajmera, E. Leobandung, S. B. Kulkarni, R. Flaker, D. Sadana, H. J. Hovel, T. Kebede, C. Schiller, S. Wu, L. F. Wagner, M. J. Saccamango, S. Ratanaphanyarat, J. B. Kuang, M. C. Hsieh, K. A. Tallman, R. M. Martino, D. Fitzpatrick, D. A. Badami, M. Hakey, S. F. Chu, B. Davari, and G. G. Shahidi, “A 0.25 µm CMOS SOI technology and its application to 4 Mb SRAM,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 587-590, 1997.
[326]
R. Chau, R. Arghavani, M. Alavi, D. Douglas, J. Greason, R. Green, S. Tyagi, J. Xu, P. Packan, S. Yu, and C. Liang, “Scalability of partially depleted SOI technology for sub-0.25 µm logic applications,” IEDM Tech. Dig., pp. 591-594, 1997.
All references are unclassified
II-85
1999 IEEE NSREC IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference Short Course
TOTAL DOSE EFFECTS: MODELING FOR PRESENT AND FUTURE Jean-Luc Leray CEA/DAM Ile-de-France
Approved for public release; diffusion is unlimited
1998 IEEE NSREC Short Course TOTAL DOSE EFFECTS: MODELING FOR PRESENT AND FUTURE Jean-Luc Leray CEA/DAM Ile-de-France B.P. 12, F-91680 Bruyères-Le-Châtel, France
1.
COURSE DESCRIPTION
2.
CONTEXT: TOTAL-DOSE ENVIRONMENT IN SPACE 2.1. 2.2. 2.3.
2.4. 2.5. 2.6. 3.
Recalling the order of magnitude of radiation in space The orbits and example of mission dose profiles The interactions: permanent effects of the cumulated dose 2.3.1. Interactions and track radii. Uniform or dispersed dose? 2.3.2. Equivalence between fluxes and dose rates Radiative environments and simulation of these environments Hardening vs. Shielding? Trade-offs between weight and cost Example at the component level: LEO satellites
ANALYTICAL MODELING OF TRAPPING EFFECTS IN MOS TRANSISTORS 3.1. 3.2. 3.3. 3.4. 3.5. 3.6.
3.7.
3.8. 3.9.
3.10. 3.11. 3.12.
Consequences for transistors and circuits The basic picture for hole and electron trapping Charge contained in the insulator and threshold voltage shift of MOS transistor Positive and negative trapped charge: present understanding First step: creation and separation of electron-hole pairs in SiO2 Second step: motion of the holes 3.6.1. Basic observations 3.6.2. Interpretation 3.6.3. Modeling of the early regime of motion and the self trapping of holes Third step: towards permanent trapping of charge 3.7.1. Modeling the trapping 3.7.2. Equations relative to carriers 3.7.3. Equations relative to trapped carriers 3.7.4. Equation relative to the electric field 3.7.5. Equations relative to the currents Solution for the steady-state case of irradiation: Mean free paths for holes and electrons. Limiting cases Case of a single type of trap 3.9.1. Solution for positive bias 3.9.2. Solution for negative bias Low dose and high dose regimes in the simplifying case of interface trapping Analytical modeling Practical applications 3.12.1. Electrical measurement techniques 3.12.2. Behavior in the low dose regime III-1
3.13.
3.14. 3.15.
4.
NUMERICAL MODELING OF TRAPPING 4.1. 4.2.
4.3. 4.4.
4.5. 5.
Annealing, reverse-annealing and rebound Modeling the trapping and thermal detrapping effects 5.2.1. Modeling PIE in terms of energy spectra: principles and equations 5.2.2. Results
TRAPPING AND LINKS WITH THE MANUFACTURING PROCESS 6.1. 6.2.
6.3.
6.4.
7.
Background Simplified Numerical 1D on laptop computer: the TRAPPOXR v.4 code and various applications 4.2.1. V-Model 4.2.2. J-Model 4.2.3. Trends in modeling 4.2.4. Method used in TRAPPOXR v.4 and code implementation 4.2.5. The effects of gate bias: the cases of trapping in volume and at interface Case of an unhardened power MOS transistor. The field collapse effect 4.4.1. Consequences in the case of an irradiation under positive gate bias 4.4.2. Consequences in the case of an irradiation under negative gate bias 4.4.3. Conclusions 4.4.4. Numerical illustrations using three different codes Gate bias switching
DETRAPPING AND TIME-EVOLVING EFFECTS 5.1. 5.2.
6.
3.12.3. Case of charge trapping at the SiO2/Si interface 3.12.4. Case of charge trapping in the bulk of the oxide 3.12.5. Case of a multilayer insulator 3.12.6. Behavior in the high dose regime Simple method to evaluate the hardness factor of a MOS process for the trapping of holes 3.13.1. Simplified formula 3.13.2. Number of traps Nt as a key parameter Extraction of trap parameters Case where two type of traps are present 3.15.1. Case of uniform distribution of traps 3.15.2. Case of interfacial distribution of traps
Defects Some views on response of thermal oxides modeling 6.2.1. Manufacturing process of the thermal oxide 6.2.2. Gate oxide thickness downscaling Empirical Process engineering curves for the thermal gate oxide and modeling 6.3.1. Correlations concerning oxidations and anneals 6.3.2. Furnace Anneals and Rapid Anneals (RTA) Some theories about the process engineering empirical curves 6.4.1. Interpretation by the flow of SiO2 6.4.2. Interpretation in term of exo-diffusion of oxygen
INTERFACE STATES 7.1.
Consequences of interface state build-up for ∆VTN and ∆VTP III-2
7.2. 7.3.
Consequence for mobility reduction in silicon Interface state build-up
8.
BIPOLAR TRANSISTORS
9.
LEAKAGE CURRENTS: VISIBLE AND HIDDEN TRANSISTORS 9.1.
9.2. 9.3. 9.4. 10.
Edge field oxides (E-FOX) modeling 9.1.1. Lateral thick oxides: LOCOS type 9.1.2. Example of consequences of leakage for circuits 9.1.3. Conceptual modeling of edge transistors and experiments 9.1.4. Numerical modeling of edge leakage transistors 9.1.5. Trends of supply voltage during irradiation 9.1.6. Other types of edge oxides Planar isolation oxides (P-FOX) The case of leakage in bipolar technologies Consequences of leakage currents for CMOS circuits and perspectives linked to progress of the integration
SOI TECHNOLOGIES 10.1. 10.2. 10.3. 10.4.
Principles of SOI technologies The three types of SOI technologies Parasitics in a thin-film SOI technology Modeling the trapped charge in SOI devices
11.
CONCLUSIONS: TRENDS, MODELING, AND NEW ISSUES
12.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
13.
APPENDIX 13.1. 13.2.
14.
Self-consistent codes used Parameters 13.2.1. Parameters used in chapter 4 13.2.2. Parameters used in chapter 10
REFERENCES
III-3
1. COURSE DESCRIPTION Knowing the dose only is insufficient to assess the actual impact of ionizing radiation on electronic components. Due to annealing, reverse-annealing effects, all affected by voltage bias, dose-rate and operation during mission profile is also of utmost importance. A lot of work has been done in the last 40 years, with the vast majority having been published in IEEE Transactions. A lot of models, data, perspectives have been compiled in NSREC Short Courses since 1980. For instance, one can refer to the 1998 issue of this series, especially “Basic Mechanisms for the New Millenium” by Paul V. Dressendorfer, which recalls much of the physics involved in radiation effects [Dres-98]. Consequently, we shall not address in detail all the work done by generations of experts these last 40 years, as thorough treatments of this rich and still mysterious subject have been done. The objective of this chapter is therefore only to give a review on the subject of total dose modeling with emphasis on analytical and numerical schemes as developed now. We shall also only introduce the debatable issues of interface states, bipolar transistors and prediction and specification in a time-dependent radiation environment. As leakage currents in MOS technologies are a major concern for the range of dose considered, we shall focus on modeling of the oxide trapped charge, especially in medium-to-thick oxides, and describe situations in field oxides of bulk CMOS and buried oxides in SOI. For that purpose, we shall follow a natural roadmap, starting from basics to go on with analytical equations and modeling, and finally use computer codes, lab-made or commercially available. 2. CONTEXT: TOTAL-DOSE ENVIRONMENT IN SPACE 2.1.
RECALLING THE ORDER OF MAGNITUDE OF RADIATION IN SPACE
Two types of particles can be encountered by space vehicles and interact inside components in spite of shields: -
A pervasive component that comes directly from outer space (Sun, our galaxy, foreign galaxies).
-
Another component that resides in magnetic fields of the Van Allen Belts and impacts the spacecraft orbiting in them or crossing them.
The components of these fluxes have been extensively studied and are recalled of fig. 1. The reader can refer for further description to recent Short Courses of this collection [Barth-97], [Dyer-98].
III-4
a) Trapped-electron
Figure 1.
b) Trapped-proton
Radiation environment and particle densities close to the Earth [Daly-88].
Figure 2 translates these fluxes into the actual dose a silicon device receives at a given location per second, from trapped electron and proton belts, being shielded by 2.1 millimeters of aluminum (CRRES experiment data). As for fig. 1, these data are recorded for a “quiet” situation, i.e. without enhancement due to Solar transient activiy.
Figure 2.
2.2.
In-orbit dose rate received behind a 2.1 mm Al shield [Kern-92].
THE ORBITS AND EXAMPLE OF MISSION DOSE PROFILES
Constellations of satellites devoted to the global consumer market, have been the major innovations of the last decade. These telecommunication constellations had been preceded by military networks and by Global Positioning Networks such as GPS in the United States and Glonass in the former USSR. As the push of the telecommunication market requires more complex features of satellites, the altitude of the orbits gets more into the radiation belts and the total dose or ionizing radiation absorbed increases. Table 1 and fig. 3 depict some examples. It can be seen that the next III-5
generation of systems will roughly need to endure 10 times more radiation dose than the present one. Status
perigee x apogee/inclin. External D ose
D ose / 1 mm A lu.
Manned LEO: Space Stations Space Station
project
450 x 450 km
51°
150 krad/year
1 krad/year
Little or Big Low Earth Orbit (<2000km): Constellations Iridium
operational
780 x 780 km
86°
1.7 M rad/year
9 krad/year
note: w ith overshielding = > 1 krad/year
Celestri
project
1400 x 1400
48°
17 M rad/year
63 krad/year
Teledesic
project
1400 x 1400
84.6°
18 M rad/year
51 krad/year
Skybridge
project
1457 x 1457
55°
28 M rad/year
73 krad/year
(abandoned)
note: w ith overshielding = > 7 krad/year
Ecco
project
2000 x 2000
0°
81 M rad/year
670 krad/year 50 krad/year
note: w ith overshielding = >
MEO (10000km)/GEO (36000km):GPS, Telecommunication Relays,etc
Table 1.
G eosynchronous any satellite
35790 x 35790 0°
1.1 G rad/year 1.1 M rad/year overshielding = > 1-2 krad/year
G PS-II
operational
22600 x 22600 55°
9.1 G rad/year
(or G LO N ASS
= end of life
19132 x 19132
overshielding = >
64.8° )
1.9 M rad/year 1-10 krad/year
Yearly radiation doses for various types of satellites (overshielding example is given for RadpakTM shield case [SEI]).
in
circular
orbits
DOSE in Krad(Si)
1 000 D o s e v s A lt itude 9 Y ears & 5 5 ° ( 10 m m A l )
100
10
1 100
1 000
10 000
100 000
C IRC U LA R O R B IT A L T IT U D E in km
Figure 3.
Indication of the dose received behind 10 mm Aluminum for 50 to 60° orbit as a function of altitude. Trend for present and new spacecrafts or constellations (Space Station, Celestri, Skybridge, GPS-II, etc) [Calv-99].
This increased regime needs enhanced strategies of procurement, modeling of radiation effects and radiation hardness assurance. 2.3.
THE INTERACTIONS: PERMANENT EFFECTS OF THE CUMULATED DOSE
III-6
2.3.1. INTERACTIONS AND TRACK RADII. UNIFORM OR DISPERSED DOSE? In matter, the interaction of photons, ions, protons or high-energy electrons present in the environment generates secondary electrons that are themselves very energetic with respect to the energies of the valence electrons or even of core electrons of atoms.
Figure 4.
Cascades of electrons resulting from the primary interaction.
Thus, secondary electrons can ionize atoms, generating electron-hole pairs or collective excitations of valence electrons (plasmon modes). Oscillations of plasmon modes can eventually generate electron hole pairs. As long as energies of the generated electrons and holes are greater than the minimal energy required for an electron-hole pair, they can in turn generate supplementary pairs. Consequently, one lone photon of high energy, or electron or proton or ion, can create thousand or million of electron-hole pairs. 2.3.2. EQUIVALENCE BETWEEN FLUXES AND DOSE RATES For uniformly deposited dose, a simple relation ties energy, fluence and absorbed ionizing dose derivatives: & = 1.6 10 −5 D
(1)
dE ρdx
Φ
with & D Φ dx dE ρ In
the derivative of the absorbed dose in rad(material).s-1 the particle flux in cm-2.s-1 the elementary abscissa in cm, projected along the particle track (flux vector) the ionizing energy in MeV transferred per dx mass density of the material in g.cm-3
dE , the Linear Energy Transfer (LET) in MeV.cm2.mg-1 can be easily recognized. ρdx
From the tables of LET versus particles and energies, the following set of curves can be obtained III-7
(fig. 5). For practical use, one has to be careful to observe conditions of validity, i.e. sufficient number of particles and sufficiently far from interfaces between materials so that secondary electrons clouds overlap and be considered as homogeneous. Integrating over time, it gives also the relation between dose and fluence.
Figure 5.
Relation between dose and fluence for homogeneous dose deposition (after [VanL-75], completed).
2.4. RADIATIVE ENVIRONMENTS AND SIMULATION OF THESE ENVIRONMENTS Photon interactions are not a primary concern for satellites in the natural environment. However, photon interactions are important in hardness assurance testing of devices devoted to space equipment, since most laboratories use photon sources (low energy X-rays or high energy gamma rays) to simulate total-dose effects for space applications [Holm-93], [Adam-91]. This is well suited for simulation of military environments and the nuclear power industry [Shar-94], [Coen-95] where gamma photons are encountered [Glas-77], [Boud-93], which both result from nuclear energy. But the concern exists for the reproduction of space ionizing radiation, and for the recent concern of high energy physics equipment [Stev-92], where the environments deal mostly with charged particles whereas tests are made with low energy X-rays or high energy gamma rays sources (this issue of great concern has been treated at length in other references, notably: NSREC Short Courses and [Brow-90], [Flee-95], [1019], [1892], [22900], [Wino-94]). 2.5. HARDENING VS. SHIELDING? TRADE-OFFS BETWEEN WEIGHT AND COST The figure 6 gives the range (in aluminum) of typical particles encountered in the field of radiation hardening. It can be seen that, for typical thickness compatible with reasonable shield III-8
weight (1 to 5 millimeters), most of radiation penetrates, if energy exceeds cutoff of photons above 20 keV, electrons above 1 MeV, and protons above 10 MeV. Hopefully, the disposition of the equipments in satellite provide natural shielding, but nevertheless total dose cannot be avoided, especially for those satellite orbiting deep into van Allen Belts. Extra-weight must be more and more avoided, as the goal for constellation is a drastic gain in launch cost. On the other hand, the use of components from the global commercial market rises questions about hardness assurance methods. This is why these new requirements force to pay more attention to prediction of in-orbit behavior of components, especially so as to take profit of their natural annealing capabilities. To get grounds to these efforts, a method is to go back to basics and step-by-step provide models capable of accurate numerical description of reality based ground-tests, being extrapolated to in-orbit mission. Range in aluminum (mm)
Energy (MeV) Figure 6.
2.6.
Orders of magnitude of particle range in matter [Adams-91].
EXAMPLE AT THE COMPONENT LEVEL: LEO SATELLITES
Table 2 illustrates the range of doses in a typical LEO orbit (800 to 900 km). It shows that the required hardness of a given part depends on the position inside the spacecraft. This results in a very broad spectrum from 1 to 16 kilorad(Si)/year. High-level functions are protected by positioning the component deep inside the spacecraft. In Constellation satellites orbiting higher, the dose can be 10 times as much.
III-9
Category Diodes
Transistors
Linear Integrated Circuits Digital Integrated Circuits
Function Ultra High Frequency Signal Zener UHF Bipolar Power MOS Amplifiers Regulators Bipolar TTL-LS CMOS 4000B HCMOS
Microprocessors Memories Table 2.
Dose (krad(Si)) per Year 12 8 4 16 5 1 3 4 8 4 1.5 1 1
Example of a LEO Satellite [CTTS].
3. ANALYTICAL MODELING OF TRAPPING EFFECTS IN MOS TRANSISTORS The ionizing dose affects MOS technologies by mainly two different phenomena that lead to the presence of trapped charge. This results in an induced electrical field, which is added to the applied field existing in the functioning component and disturbs this field. As an example, one can take the simplest case of signal (low-power) MOS transistor 2N4351 (Ntype) and 3N164 (P-type) irradiated all pins shorted (fig. 7).
Figure 7.
Examples of variations of the threshold voltage for small-signal discrete N and P-MOS transistors (irradiated with Co-60 gamma rays under VGS=VDS=VBS =0 V).
III-10
In this figure are summarized certain typical features of total dose effects on MOS devices: -
linear dependence at low dose
-
sublinear regime at intermediate dose
-
saturation or very slow dependence at high dose
-
variation with manufacturing lots
-
difference between N and P type transistors
The basic frame of understanding is that “something” is building up under the influence of dose. This “something” may takes several forms according to the type of the device, the time scale at which it is considered and the way the device has been manufactured, and therefore a comprehensive modeling is required to master all the aspects. This course will only introduce certain aspects, some others being beyond the scope, or some question being too much a matter of research or debate to be addressed in a course. The similar beginnings at low dose is attributed to a common phenomenon to N and P-type, whereas the difference at larger dose is attributed to another different phenomenon which can produce similar effects in N and P, but with sign opposed. More specifically, the variation of threshold voltage is divided into two components named as follows: (2)
∆VtN = ∆VotN + ∆VitN
Figure 8.
and
∆VtP = ∆VotP − ∆VitP
Interpretation of threshold voltage shifts as the sum of two components.
Figure 8 displays the typical negative threshold voltage variation for PMOS, and the firstly negative then positive variation for NMOS. This last phenomenon is due to the fact that ∆VOT saturates, while ∆VIT presents much weaker (or no) saturation. The position from the point of III-11
turn-around according to laws and parameters, as well as the thickness of the oxide and the electric field (bias) has to be analyzed. In the following, we first address the common component to the two types of transistors. 3.1.
CONSEQUENCES FOR TRANSISTORS AND CIRCUITS
For transistors of N type, consequences of negative threshold voltage values, or positive but close to zero (<0.5 V), are an increase of the NMOS leakage current. At higher levels of irradiation, there is the loss of functionality of the circuit which contains the transistor. At the level of integrated circuit, these effects provoke loss of performance, increase of the power consumption, then circuit failure. This increase of leakage of various kinds that happens equally in other types of technology as CMOS, leads notably to increases of power consumption, contributes to drops of the bipolar transistor gain, and increases of the noise and the offsets of linear circuits. 3.2.
THE BASIC PICTURE FOR HOLE AND ELECTRON TRAPPING
Although the sketches of mechanisms that occur from the initial interaction until the “permanent trapping” are numerous, complex and not fully understood up to now, it can be crudely described in a few words as follows: if a transistor is exposed to high energy ionizing irradiation, electronhole pairs are created uniformly throughout the oxide. Immediately after their generation, electrons drift rapidly out of the oxide toward the negative electrode (within picoseconds) and holes drift toward the other electrode depending on the electric field direction (fig. 9). However, even before electrons leave the oxide, some fraction will recombine with holes. The fraction of holes that survives initial recombination is then available for either trapping or escaping toward electrodes.
S i-p E
electrons flux
X-Rays
electron traps
f
Rp
S iO2
Rn hole traps
R : Recombination : Charged T r aps : Neutral Trap
holes flux
Gate (V>0) Electric Field
Figure 9.
Illustration of charge transport and trapping in the MOS structure for positive gate bias [Herv-93].
III-12
3.3. CHARGE CONTAINED IN THE INSULATOR AND THRESHOLD VOLTAGE SHIFT OF MOS TRANSISTOR For a standard thermal oxide, the drift of the threshold voltage is related to the density of charge present in the insulator by:
1 t ox x ρ( x ) dx C ox ∫0 t ox
(3)
∆Vt = −
with
0 and tox ρ( x ) = q p( x) − n ( x) C ox =
ε ox t ox
the abscissa of gate and silicon interface, respectively the net volume charge (charge density) present in the oxide the gate oxide capacitance per unit area
The net trapped charge density resulting from the irradiation can have many causes: (i) In volume - free charge just after their creation - self-trapped charge again capable of movement by processes such hopping from trapping site to other trapping site [Mott-77]. (ii) In volume or in interface boundary - charge deeply trapped on defects, or more generally modification of the state of defect charge, in volume or in interface. (iii) At the interface with silicon strictly speaking - interface states. Interface states are, in principle, sites that are able to exchange charge with the silicon in indefinitely reversible manner, in thermodynamic equilibrium with the electronic population of the surface of the silicon. This must be done in a finite time (generally in the order of a microsecond for so-called “rapid states” that are usually the most common). These sites are therefore located practically in the “interfacial layer” and, in the sense of extended wave functions of this interface, they belong both to the silicon and to the oxide. It is important to note that interface states are not charged by themselves, but “porters” (sites) of charge (Bardeen states [Scho-39]). It is therefore natural to think that lattice defects, notably those caused at the interface by secondary effects of irradiation, are the cause of such electrically-active sites (e.g. Pb centers) (c.f. also mechanisms of Revesz-Griscom, reminded hereafter). But one can also note that some states cannot be defects in the crystalline sense of the term, but quantum levels caused by the passage of a system to an other (states of Tamm [Tamm32]). Some authors have imagined that charges trapped close to the interface could create allowed levels in the forbidden band-gap of the interfacial silicon by simple electrostatic influence. III-13
The standard classification is by convention that resulting from the “Deal Commission” [Deal80], approved by the Electrochemical Society and the IEEE (fig. 10).
Figure 10. Classification of charges [Deal-80].
Since then, finer studies have shown that reality is not as clear. It seems likely that there exist sites in the volume close to the interface that exchange charge with the surface of the silicon [Fleet-92], in a reversible manner as for states, but much more slowly (these slow states are called “border traps” or “switching states”). There also exist time-evolving phenomena that are identified by the (irreversible) neutralization of charge in the volume close to the interface. In what follows, we develop simple statements without describing the “border traps” concepts. Restrained to the charges that do not exchange reversibly with silicon, the global formula for threshold voltage shift here becomes: (4)
∆Vot = −
q ε ox
∫
t ox
0
x . [p t ( x ) − n t ( x ) + p( x ) − n ( x )] dx
where Vot is the oxide-trapped charge, and nt and pt are the oxide-trapped electron and hole densities of charge (in units charge.cm-3). The exact trap profile is most of the time unknown. It is therefore convenient to define an integral of this density rather than the profile itself. One can define ∆Qe and ∆Qh (more simply Qe and Qh when no ambiguity occurs), as: (5)
t Q e = ∫ ox x . [n ( x ) + n t ( x )] dx
(6)
t Q h = ∫ ox x . [p( x ) + p t ( x )] dx
0
0
To more easily allow reasoning on trapped charge profile, two useful additional quantities can be III-14
defined to represent the charge distribution by its first moment, i.e. the location of charge centroids in the oxide:
xe =
(7)
xh =
(8)
∫
t ox
0
x . [n ( x ) + n t ( x )] dx Q tot
∫
t ox
0
x . [p( x ) + p t ( x )] dx Q tot
where t Q tot = ∫ ox
(9)
0
[p t ( x) − n t ( x ) + p(x ) − n (x )] dx
is the total charge present (except the interface and border traps), and: (10)
t Q ot = ∫ ox x . [p t ( x ) − n t ( x ) + p( x ) − n ( x )] dx 0
is the projected total charge (note that all the quantities Q are surface densities of charges expressed in unit “number of charges per unit area”). Therefore, one can write a simple expression of the voltage shift, each term with a different signification:
(11)
∆Vot = −
Q ot (Q − Q e ) t =− h = − ox C ox C ox ε ox
xh xe − Q tot t ox t ox
The free carrier density, as will be computed numerically in next sections, is insignificant in long-lasting natural irradiations (n and p are between 100 and 106 carriers.cm-3 for dose rates ranging between 10-3 and 103 rad.s-1). It is of course not the case for trapped charges as they accumulate on trapped sites: densities up to 1018 cm-3 can be reached. In this course, we will develop as possible the models that link: -
The ∆Vot threshold voltage shift and the trapped charge Qe and Qh, projected at the silicon interface.
-
The trapped charge Qe and Qh and the charge density profile nt and pt.
-
The charge profile nt and pt and the density of traps Ntn and Ntp.
-
The density of traps Ntn and Ntp and the material and process characteristics.
3.4. POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE TRAPPED CHARGE: PRESENT UNDERSTANDING III-15
The positive and negative charges trapped in the oxide therefore consist of the fraction of the holes and electrons that has not been lost via recombination, and eventually trapped. In the first decade of radiation effects, it was believed that trapped holes only exist, as the trapped charge always revealed as positive. However, evidences of negative charge appeared in metal-implanted oxides [e.g., Wang-75]. Later, it was recognized that trapped charge could be evidenced, even before irradiation, in pure thermal oxides [Shan-83] by combination of Thermally Stimulated Current technique (TSC) and Capacitance-Voltage measurement (C-V). However, the amount of trapped electrons is generally lower as compared to the quantity of trapped holes, which explains the general observation of a net positive trapped charge.
Table 3.
Type of oxide
Thickness
Range of dose
Thermal hard (ATT) Thermal hard (wet) Thermal hard (wet) Thermal hard Thermal hard (wet) Thermal hard (dry) Thermal hard Thermal soft Thermal soft SIMOX (SOI oxide)
18 nm 23 nm 47 nm 45 nm 100 nm 104 nm 98 nm 350 nm 348 nm 380 nm
5 Mrad 2 Mrad 1 Mrad 0.1-5 Mrad 0.5 Mrad 0.25 Mrad Idem 6 krad 20 krad 1 Mrad
Range of the electric field +1 to 2 MV/cm +1 to 2 MV/cm +1 to 2 MV/cm + 1 MV/cm +1 to 2 MV/cm +1 to 2 MV/cm + 2 MV/cm + 1 MV/cm +1 to 2 MV/cm -0.75 MV/cm
Qe/Qh and method used 0.48 TSC 0.083 TSC 0.47 TSC 0.55 TSC 0.14 TSC 0.43 TSC 0.46 TSC 0.15 TSC 0.19 TSC 1.3 (∆Vot bi-ex. fit)
Ratio of trapped electrons Qe to trapped holes Qh as measured under various circumstances (TSC from [Flee-92], bi-exponential fit (sect. 3.15.2 for SIMOX from [Lera-88, Pail95c]).
As recalled in table 3, the ratio of trapped electrons to trapped holes ranges from some percent to one half [Fleet-92], table 2, adapted). However, it is likely that a coherent modeling should require the two components. These data were interpreted in terms of wet and dry process, as in fig. 11.
Figure 11. Trapped electrons/trapped holes ratio for various processes [Flee-92].
III-16
In some specific cases, such as oxides used as substrate insulator for Silicon-On-Insulator under negative bias during irradiation, this ratio can be superior to 1, meaning that the net charge is negative in this case [Lera-88]. However, we shall consider as a first approach valid a first sight that the net charge is globally positive, as it has been considered for 30 years from the late 50’s In table 4, electron and hole densities of traps are measured instead of trapped charges (according to a method described in [Pail-95a] and [Pail-99] and summarized tn section 3.14). As will be seen later, the two items generally differ because a quantity depicting capacity of traps to be filled (NTN and NTP) is not generally the same as another measuring the amount of traps filled (Qe or Qh). Type of oxide
Thickness
Range of dose
SIMOX
380 nm
1 Mrad
SIMOX
80 nm
1 Mrad
UNIBONDTM
400 nm
1 Mrad
Thermal wet 400 nm annealed 1320°C
1 Mrad
Table 4.
Range of the electric field + and – 1 MV/cm + and – 1 MV/cm + and – 1 MV/cm + and – 1 MV/cm
NTH/NTP and method used 0.2 to 0.8 Vt-Vg 1 Vt-Vg 0.06 Vt-Vg 0.75 Vt-Vg
Reference [Pail-93] [Pail-95a] [Pail-95a] [Pail-93]
Ratio of electrons trap NTN to hole traps NTP densities as measured under various circumstances.
It can be seen that holes, although generally the most numerous, never come alone. In this course, this will be the guideline for further understanding. 3.5. FIRST STEP: CREATION AND SEPARATION OF ELECTRON-HOLE PAIRS IN SIO2 Globally, electron and holes are created in equal quantities at a rate: (12)
R0 =
∂n ∂p = = g 0 D' ∂t ∂t
g0 =
ρ = 7.8 1012 w
with: (13)
cm −3 . rad(SiO 2 ) −1
and ρ=2.27 g.cm-3. w=18 eV is the average energy required to generate one electron and one hole in SiO2 via high-energy interactions (an experimental value). Note that, the experimental uncertainty being of the order of 1 eV, some authors use g0=8.2 1012 coming from w=17 eV. However, SiO2 seems to be an exception as compared to Si, GaAs, C, etc., because a certain amount of electron and holes recombine, and this recombination depends essentially on the electric field applied. This “mutual recombination” of the generated carriers is the first part of a series of processes, well separated in time, whereas charge trapping is the last picture. In this series of successive interactions and physics that takes place from the very early moment of energy deposition, let us come back to this early events when the tracks take form. III-17
Figure 13. Fraction of unrecombined pairs versus the applied electric field for various incident radiations [McGa-80], [Oldh-83].
Figure 12. Separation of electron and holes.
According to the particles that interact with the oxide, the density of ionization is more or less important and two borderline cases are considered: -
The recombination of one particle of the pair undertaken with the parent particle. It is the case for electrons or incident photons that give a weak density of ionization.
-
The recombination undertaken randomly with a not-correlated particle in the ionized column. It is the case for ionization due to heavy particles.
The fraction of pairs that overcome this initial recombination and separate depends therefore on energy and the type of the incident particle and also on the electrical field present in the insulator that favors this separation. This fraction has been characterized by several independent workers working on scaled technologies since the mid 70’s: [Ausm75] initiated with 105 nm oxide and 4 keV electrons, [Srou-77b] compared the yield at 77K and 300K, [Hugh-75] for thermal SiO2 and suprasil glass in pulsed irradiation mode, [Boes-76] with 13 MeV electrons at 80K, [Peas-85] studied thick oxide under very low fields used in bipolar emitter-base spacers. A representation can be found in data recalled on fig. 12. Brown and Dozier made thorough studies of dependence versus the energy of photons and the structure of the ionizing tracks ([Dozi-81], [Brow-81], [Oldh-81/83/85]). [Oldh-82, [Oldh-84] and [Ausm-86] presented a refined analytical or numerical model taking into account the track density. A very simple model helps to picture the reasoning [Brow-81]. First, it is assumed that the cloud of holes and the cloud of electrons are swept apart in time tr by an applied field. Second, it is assumed that while the electron and the hole clouds overlap, electron-hole recombination takes place following bimolecular kinetics, i.e. (14)
dR = −χ R 2 dt
where χ is a recombination coefficient and R is the electron (and the hole) density at time III-18
t. This equation can be integrated simply: (15)
1 1 = + χ tr Rf Ri
with t r = d µ E is the time needed for columns separation, and µ the (ambipolar) mobility. This leads to the simplest formula for the non-recombination or yield function: (16)
Y(E)= R f / R i =
E / Ec 1 + E / Ec
with Ec a critical field defined by µ E c = χ . This simple calculation of “columnar” recombination is not always adequate because it supposes sufficiently dense tracks ([Oldh-84] showed it is valid for 107 electrons and holes generated per cm of track, i.e. for protons below 3 MeV, and electrons below 3 keV). Otherwise, a better model would be the “geminate” recombination, based on similar physics but where carriers are more dilute so that they recombine as isolated pairs [Ausm86]. It leads anyway to similar conclusions. On fig. 13, the yield dependence is presented versus energy of particles, that is to say, track density. One notes the low yield for heavy particles and the influence of the electrical field Eox. For Co-60 and 10 keV X-rays, several updates were made in the late 80’s and in the 90’s, and precise comparison have been made ([Bene-86], [Shan-91]). When one comes to analytical approximations, sigmoid curves can be suggested, such as, for X and γ photons:
(17)
E Y(E) = 1 + c E
−m
where m and Ec are coefficient that depends on the type of radiation. Table 5 gives examples of fitting parameters. Photons From [Flament95] From [Oldh-81/83/85] Table 5.
Co-60 γ rays 1.17-1.33 MeV Ec (MV/cm)=0.65 m = 0.9 0.5 0.7
X rays 10 keV 1.35 0.9 1.35 0.9
Coefficients for the empirical function of non-recombination Y(E).
More specifically to take into account a possible residue Y0 at zero field and temperatures above 150 K (as evoked by [Ausm-86]):
III-19
(18)
(19)
Y(E) = Y0 +
Y(E) =
1 − Y0 E 1 + Ec
( )
E + E0 m E + Ec
m
or (other approximate expression):
and E0 = Y0 . EC
with Y0 is about 0.05 at room temperature [Farm-73], [Lera-89a]. 3.6.
SECOND STEP: MOTION OF THE HOLES
3.6.1. BASIC OBSERVATIONS From the point of view of electron and hole processes, one can consider that, whatever the duration of irradiations, it can be decomposed into an infinite series of small quasiinstantaneous elementary irradiations. This method of the “pulsed response” allows a more didactic statement of the successive processes that follow the creation of electron-hole pairs (fig. 14). The use of «flash X» or linac irradiation machines provides conditions to measure the real impulse response of MOS and to suitably model the successive phenomena [Hugh-75a, Hugh-75b, Curt-77, Lera-85, Lera-89a, Peyr-91].
BEFORE
+V
DURING IRRADIATION
DURING AND AFTER IRRADIATION
+V
+V
gate SiO2
+- +- + - +- +- + - +-+ - + - + - + - + +-+-+ - + - + - + -
+ + + + + + + +
Si IONIZATION AND RECOMBINATION
DRIFT, DIFFUSION AND TRAPPING
Figure 14. Generation and the trapping of charge in the insulator of MOS structures.
Contrarily to semiconductors where the free carrier mobilities of electrons and holes have similar magnitudes, they differ here by several orders of magnitude. For electrons, III-20
mobility µ e of about 10 cm2.V-1.s-1 has been reported [Hugh-75] from photocurrent measurements. On the contrary, the positive charge due to holes is slowly evacuated, allowing one to define an effective mobility derived from the time-of-flight of the moving holes [Boes-75, Curt-77]: (20)
µ peff =
t ox E . t1/ 2
with t1/2 the time needed for decreasing the charge to one-half its original value. This behavior has been first attributed to shallow traps situated to the vicinity of the valence band. Their apparent mobility µ peff varies therefore strongly with the temperature [Srou-76], [Srou-77b], [Boes-75], [Curt-77], [Lera-85]: (21)
µ peff = µ p0 exp(-Ei/kT)
In [Hugh-75b], an example of parameter set is given: µ peff = 20cm2/V.s exp(-0.6eV/kT) for thick thermal SiO2 film (862 nm).
III-21
3.6.2. INTERPRETATION In fact, there is a broad distribution of activation energies, and it has been shown that the shallow traps were intrinsic to SiO2 in the sense that the hole becomes self-trapped due to its own electrostatic potential on oxygen atoms constituting the network (polaron effect, [Mott-77, McLe-77]). This is probably why this behavior is so universal among the various kinds of oxides tried, although a slight dependency of activation energies has been found to depend on process [Lera-85], with high-temperature annealed oxides having smaller t1/2, higher hole mobility and lower activation energies. This might be related to the hopping mechanism between sites, favored by denser oxides [Lera-89a]. The figure 15 summarizes the main transport and trapping mechanisms in SiO2 by showing the importance of the spatial and energy distribution of traps.
Free hole
self-trapping
hopping transport
Figure 15. Simplified illustration of transport and trapping mechanisms of holes in SiO2 [McLe-77].
A global hole movement occurs as determined by this trap-controlled mobility under the electrical field toward electrodes. This movement has been measured after irradiations delivered in pulsed mode with X-ray or electron flash machines, and modeled by describing the transport equations in the presence of traps distributed in volume and in energy [Boes-74], [Boes-77], [Lera-89a], [Peyr-91]. For time scales of the order of irradiation experiments, [Wino-94] suggests to use an activation energy of about 0.4 eV.
III-22
It must be noted that such polaron behavior has been investigated for electrons, but no evidence has been found [Othm-80]. R.C. Hughes made thorough investigations on SiO2 photocurrents, and mesured the dependence of electron drift velocity versus electric field (fig. 16). It is similar with other type of semiconductors, except that the critical field is higher (200 kV/cm). This is attributed to the high value of the optical phonons in this material. Ferry calculated the theoretical value of the saturation velocity (2 107 cm s-1) [Ferr], which is in good agreement with the experimental value of Hughes [Hugh-73, Hugh-78].
Figure 16. Drift velocity of electrons in SiO2 versus electric field for three thicknesses of Suprasil-II glass [Hugh-75]. The slope is the electron mobility of 21± ±2 cm2 V-1 s-1.
3.6.3. MODELING OF THE EARLY REGIME OF MOTION AND THE SELF TRAPPING OF HOLES For “free” holes (called also “dry holes” as opposed to “self-trapped” holes or “polaron”), Hughes introduced and indirectly measured a lifetime τp0 before it becomes self trapped. For this to achieve, he measures the product µ p0τp0 ≈ 1.4 10-12 cm2 V-1 by integrating the current released in thermal silicon dioxide irradiated by 3 nanosecond pulses [Hugh-78]. This value is also found in other type of experiments [Curt-75, Boes-76, Srou-76, Srou-77a]. Hughes derived a value for τp0 by theoretical estimation of µ p0, based on the value of the mass attributed to the free holes. With µ p0=1 cm2 V-1 s-1, it gives τp0 ≈ 1.4 10-12 s which is a value compatible with the self-trapping phenomenology [Hugh-98]. So, if we note p0 and jp0 the “dry” hole density and current:
(22)
∂p 0 ∂jp 0 & Y(E) − p 0 + = go D ∂t ∂x τ p0
In steady state, the first term can be neglected (it requires that the dose rate does not vary much in time comparable with τp0, which might be questionable in case of heavy ion strike, for instance). If we neglect diffusion before the drift term, the current equation becomes simply jp0 = p0 µ p0 E. The differential equation can be solved in x for 1D problems: (23)
& Y(E) τp0 (1 − exp − x µ p 0 τ p 0 E ) p0 = go D
Provided that E < tox/µ p0τp0 = 106 V cm-1 for tox=10 nm, the “dry” hole density is nearly uniform and we can have an order of magnitude of the steady-state free hole density: p0 ≈ 7 carriers cm-3 III-23
per rad/s, which could seem very low. However, these carriers must not be neglected. They are not lost as they appear as inputs in the following equations related to the subsequent step where the deep trapping occurs. 3.7.
THIRD STEP: TOWARDS PERMANENT TRAPPING OF CHARGE
In the vicinity of the semiconductor interface, there exists a disturbed region that is the transition between the crystalline silicon and the amorphous silicon dioxide. Deep hole traps, initially neutral, become converted into positive fixed charge by trapping holes (and eventually relaxing into another configuration state which stabilizes the trapping). The probability of capture for a hole is a function of the density of empty traps, and therefore scales with dose initially, before becoming sublinear and saturating at higher doses. 3.7.1.
MODELING THE TRAPPING
Before modeling the detrapping, we shall follow the method developed in [Pail-99], which is a complete treatment of models having been proposed these 20 last years by [McGa-80] for low dose regime, and extended to saturation regime in [Lera-89a]. All these models are based on trapping of hole and electron participating to the flux on a given trap profile, according to the proposition of [Kran-87]. Here, the fluxes are defined by drift-diffusion equations. Note that an alternative formulation exists, where the “flux” is defined as the product of the thermal velocity by the carrier density. These two alternatives categorized as the “J-Model” and the “V-Model” will be compared in the section 4.2. We first describe the J-Model which is probably easier to picture out, and which has been much more in use during the last decade. 3.7.2.
EQUATIONS RELATIVE TO CARRIERS
As mentioned above, during irradiation two charge trapping mechanisms can take place in the oxide for each type of carrier. The continuity equations (for holes in the valence band and for electrons in the conduction band of silica) can thus be written by taking into account the generation term, the flux gradient and both trapping phenomena. Using a one-dimensional formulation, and noting simply p the hole density at interest for this deep trapping model, we get: (24)
∂n ∂jn (x, t ) & Y(E) − σnt(E)jn(x,t)[NTN(x)−nt(x,t)] −σnr(E)jn(x,t)pt(x,t) + = go D ∂t ∂x
(25)
∂p ∂jp (x, t ) p 0 + = − σpt(E)jp(x,t)[NTP(x)−pt(x,t)] −σpr(E)jp(x,t)nt(x,t) ∂t ∂x τ p0
where: n(x,t) and p(x,t) are respectively the density of free electrons in the conduction band and that of free holes in the valence band, go is the density of electron-hole pairs generated per rad(SiO2), represents the dose rate [rad(SiO2).s-1], Y(E) is the probability of escaping initial recombination (also called the yield function), nt(x,t) and pt(x,t) are respectively the density of trapped electrons and trapped holes, t designates the time evolved since the beginning of irradiation, and q represents the charge of the electron. Note that current densities are defined III-24
here as currents of particles (in cm-2.s-1) and not currents of charges (in A.cm-2). By replacing the value obtained for p0 in the steady state, and provided that E < tox/µ p0τp0 = 106 V cm-1 for tox=10 nm, we have:
(26)
&τ g 0 Y(E) D p0 h0 (1 − exp − x µ p0 τ p0 E )= g 0 Y(E) D& (1 − exp − x µ p0 τ p0 E ) = τh0 τh0
So, under these assumptions only, and for x > µ p0τp0 E, the equation of hole trapping s