1996 IEEE NSREC IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference Short Course
Radiation Effects Challenges for 21st ...
41 downloads
1688 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
1996 IEEE NSREC IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference Short Course
Radiation Effects Challenges for 21st Century Space Systems
WI/
July 15,1996 Renaissance Esmeralda Resort Indian Wells, California Sponsored by IEEE NPSS Radiation Effects Committee Cosponsored by Defense Nuclear Agency Sandia National Laboratories Phillips Laboratory NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Jet Propulsion Laboratory
—
1996 IEEE NSREC IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference
Short Course
Radiation Effects Challenges for 21st Century Space Systems
July 15, 1996 Renaissance Esmeralda Resort Indian Wells, California
Copyright @ 1996 by The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. All rights reserved. Instructors are permitted to photocopy isolated articles for noncommercial classroom use without Ifee. For all other copying, reprint, or replication permission, write to Copyrights and Permissions Department, IEEE Publishing Services, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ, 08855-1331.
Table of Contents
SECTION
I
FOREWORD Ronald
.............................................................................I 1-4
L. Pease
RLP Research,
Inc.
SECTIONII
SPA CECRAFTANOMALIES AND FUTURE TRENDS ............................................................. . . . . 111-52 James C. Ritter Naval SECTION
Research
Laboratory
III
TOTAL DOSE RESPONSE OF BIPOLAR MICROCIRCUITS ..................+......................................... . . . .. 1111-78 David W. Emily Naval Surface Warfhre Center, Crane Division SECTIONIV
CATASTROPHIC SINGLE-EVENT EFFECTS IN THE NATURALS PACEENVIRONMENT Kenneth F. Galloway and Gregory H. Johnson The University of Arizona SECTION
................ . . . ..IV 1-72
V
DESIGN ISSUES FOR RADIA TION TOLERANT MICROCIRCUITS FOR SPACE ....................................... . . . . . v 1-54 David R. Alexander Mission Research Corporation
1996 NSREC SHORT COURSE
SECTION1
FOREWORD
Ronald L. Pease RLP Research, Inc.
FOREWORD
This is the seventeenth year that a Short Course has been offered at the IEEE Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Cotierence. The Short Course format provides the opportunity to cover topics in more depth than is possible with contributed papers, but is intended to be tutorial in nature. The theme for the 1996 Short Course is Radiation Effects Challenges for 21st Century Space Systems. The general approach for this year’s course, which has been taken with many of the past short courses, is to have topics on systems, ionizing radiation effects, heavy ion effects and hardening solutions. For each of these areas material has been selected that either has not been covered in the past or has not been covered in depth. The four topics relate to the overall theme in the following manner. The first topic is divided into two parts and sets the stage for the topics to follow. Background irdiormation is given on satellite anomalies to demonstrate that, to date, availability of hardened parts and conservative design practices have resulted in few system failures resulting from degradation or fictional failure of microelectronic parts. In the second part of the first topic trends for fbture satellites are discussed, showing that, unless system designers remain vigilant, a greater number of failures maybe expected in fiture systems. In the second topic, a new challenge in the area of ionization damage is presented for bipolar linear circuits, which are still widely used in space systems. In the third topic a challenge in the area of heavy ion phenomena is presented for catastrophic failure of microelectronic devices and circuits. In the final topic the challenge of designing with fewer radiation hardened components is addressed. A solution using a radiation tolerant design and layout methodology with a commercial foundry is presented. Much of the material presented this year is quite recent and covers research areas that are still very active. However, the intent has been to provide sufficient background ifiormation to make the material appeal to a wide audience. As mentioned above, the course is divided into four sections. The first section, Spacecraft Anomalies and Future Trends, discusses the various types of effects which produce anomalies in space systems, giving historical and other examples of such anomalies. A description is given for how system engineers search for the cause of the aberrant behavior of the system, and the accompanying phenomena which ofien provide valuable clues to the cause. Because the causes of many anomalies are never determined, it is difficult to accumulate comprehensive statistics on the distribution of causes of anomalies or failures in satellites. How anomalies are handled through onorbit comections or reprogramming is described, as well as how they are handled for fiture generations of the same space system. The second subject covered under this topic is trends in fiture space systems, and how those trends are tiected by radiation effects in microelectronics and photonic devices and systems. The future holds new types of systems such as cellular telephones and data transfer systems, and, equally important, greatly increasing numbers of satellites. The second section, Total Dose Response of Bipolar Microcircuits, discusses total dose effects in bipolar microcircuits, with emphasis on the recently discovered low dose rate sensitivity of many linear devices. Because past short courses have focused on CMOS microcircuits, the section begins
I-1
.
with fimdamentals of bipolar transistors operation and presents basic processing and device design details, contrasting the difference between vertical, lateral and substrate transistors. Basic total dose effects in bipolar transistors and digital and linear integrated circuits are presented as an introduction to the important low dose rate sensitivity in linear circuits. The remainder of the section is devoted to a discussion of the response of bipolar linear transistors and microcircuits as a fimction of dose rate and irradiation temperature. Recent theories to explain the dose rate mechanism are presented along with implications for hardness assurance. The third section, Catastrophic Single-Event Effects in the Natural Space Radiation Environment, covers catastrophic single particle effects in semiconductor devices and microcircuits. The section begins with an introduction to the space particle environment and the interaction of energetic particles with devices and circuits. The remainder of the section is divided according to the various catastrophic effects: burnout, gate rupture, dielectric rupture and latchup. Although many of these effects have been discussed briefly in previous short courses, none have been addressed in depth. For each of these effects the status of the experimental data is presented, followed by a discussion of modeling to understand the physical mechanisms. Based on the understanding of mechanisms, techniques for reducing susceptibility are presented. The section concludes with a summary of the important features of each effect as it relates to space applications. The fourth section, Design Issues for Radiation Tolerant Microcircuits for Space, presents design-related issues for space applications of radiation tolerant microcircuits, The section begins with a discussion of a general methodology for assessing the impact of different design approaches on the radiation hardness of integrated circuits. A typical microcircuit is partitioned into its fictional blocks, and the primary failure mechanisms associated with each fictional block are identified. Both heavy ion and total dose ionizing radiation effects are addressed. Several electrical and layout design alternatives for each fictional block are evaluated for their contributions to radiation tolerance. The general approach is illustrated for digital CMOS microcircuits, but suggestions for application to other integrated circuit types is also given. The section concludes with an application of the methodology to a radiation tolerant microcircuit. I would like to thank the five authors/presenters, Jim Ritter, Dave Emily, Ken Galloway, Greg Johnson, and Dave Alexander, for their efforts in making this short course a success. A great deal of personal time, on weekends and evenings, is required to meet the schedules and still filfill the commitments of a family and full time job. Although most of the authors have probably had second thoughts about accepting the responsibility of preparing the manuscripts and presentation material, I hope that, on reflection, they will be very satisfied with the results, as I’m sure are all of the short course attendees and readers of these notes. I would like to thank Lew Cohn of DNA for his efforts in reviewing the manuscripts and assuring that the material was cleared for public release. I would also like to thank the DNA Printing OffIce for printing the notebook. Without their efforts this Short Course Notebook would not have been possible. Ronald L. Pease Albuquerque, New Mexico
I-2
Biographies Ronald L. Pease Short Course Organizer RLP Research, Inc. Ronald L. Pease received his B. S. degree in physics from Indiana University in 1965 and pursued graduate studies in physics at the University of Washington, Seattle the following year. He joined NAD Crane (now NSWC-Crane Division) in 1966, where he performed radiation testing of missile components and headed the DNA Bipolar Program. From 1977-1979 he was with the BDM Corporation in Albuquerque, NM. In 1979 he joined Mission Research Corporation in Albuquerque where he was Manager of the Microelectronics Division. At MRC he was the principal investigator on several hardening and hardness assurance programs. In 1993 he formed his own company, RLP Research, where he is now a technical advisor and radiation effects analyst. Mr. Pease has been involved in the NSREC for many years, having served in a number of positions. He has over 40 publications and has won several outstanding and meritorious paper awards at the conference. James C. Ritter Naval Research Laboratory James C. Ritter is head of the Radiation Effects Branch of the Naval Research Laboratory where he has worked since 1962. For ten years at NRL he pursued basic research in nuclear physics. In 1971 he began peflorming and directing research in radiation effects in microelectronics. He has worked on the radiation hardening of satellite systems and has participated in revising the Joint Chiefs of Staff Guidelines for hardening satellites. He has been a Program Manager or Principal Investigator on a number of space experiments such as the Microelectronics and Photonics Test Bed and the Combined Release and Radiation Effects Satellite Microelectronics Experiment. He currently directs an extensive research program in radiation effects in semiconductor and superconductor devices and materials. Mr. Ritter was an instructor for the 1989 NSREC Short Course. David W. Emily Naval Surface Warfare Center, Crane Division David W. Emily received his B. S. degree with honors in electrical engineering from Purdue University in 1976. He has been employed by the Naval Surface Warfare Center, Crane Division since 1973. Initial assignments included reliability assessments and failure analysis of microelectronics. He has been involved in radiation effects research and testing since 1980. Responsibilities have included radiation hardness assurance evaluation of strategic missile components, development and testing of advanced technologies, and research into radiation effects on bipolar and BiCMOS processes. He currently manages the Technology Development Branch which support the research development and testing of radiation hardened microelectronics. Mr. Emily is active with NSREC and has served as official reviewer, session chairman and finance chairman. He has authored several papers in radiation effects, including the 1983 Outstanding Conference Paper.
I-3
Kenneth F. Galloway and Gregory H. Johnson The University of Arizona Kenneth F. Galloway is currently serving as a Professor and Department Head of Electrical and Computer Engineering at the University of Arizona. Prior to joining the University of Wlzona, Dr. Galloway held appointments at Indiana University(1966-’72), the Naval Weapons Support Center (1972-1974), the University of Maryland (1980-1986), and the National Bureau of Standards (19741986). He joined the University of tilzona in 1986. Dr. Galloway’s research interests include solidstate devices and semiconductor technology. He has authored or co-authored more than 100 technical publications. He was elected an IEEE Fellow in 1986 for “Contributions to the study of radiation effects in microelectronics”. He received the Medal of Honor from the University of Monpellier II. He has served in many capacities with the NSREC and RESG, including the positions of 1985 General Conference Chairman and Chairman of the RESG. Dr. Galloway received the B. A. degree from Vanderbilt University in 1962 and the Ph. D. degree from the University of South Carolina in 1966. Gregory H. Johnson received the B. S., M. S., and Ph. D. degrees in Electrical Engineering from the University of Arizona in 1988, 1990, and 1992, respectively. He held a National Research Council Post-Doctoral Fellowship at the USAF Phillips Laborato~ for two years following his graduate studies. Dr, Johnson is currently a Research Assistant Professor at the University of Arizona, where his research interests include radiation effects on microelectronics, microelectronic device physics, and long term aging effects on microelectronic device reliability. Gregory has presented several papers at previous NSRECS, including the Outstanding Cotierence Paper in 1991. David R Alexander Mission Research Corporation David R. Alexander received his B. S. in Electrical Engineering from the U. S. Air Force Academy in 1968 and his M. S. in Electrical Engineering from the University of New Mexico in 1973. From 1968 to 1973 he was an Air Force officer assigned to the Air Force Weapons Laboratory in Albuquerque, New Mexico, In 1973, he joined the BDM Corporation and was the principal investigator for several programs in radiation response modeling of microcircuits. In 1980, he became a member of the technical staff at %ndia National Laboratories. He is currently with Mission Research Corporation and has been Manager of MRC’s Microelectronics Division since 1993. At MRC, he has been responsible for applying computer-aided design and modeling practices to microcircuits. Mr. Alexander has been active in the NSREC for several years and has served in several positions. He has numerous teclin.ical publications and was a recipient of the Distinguished Poster Paper Award in 1988.
I-4
1996 NSREC SHORT COURSE
SECTIONII
SPA CECRAFTANOMALIES FUTURE TMNDS
James C. Ritter Naval Research Laboratory
AND
SPACECRAFT
ANOMALIES
AND FUTURE
TRENDS
JAMES C. RITTER NAVAL RESEARCH LABORATORY RADIATION EFFECTS BRANCH 1.0 2.0
3.0 4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0 8.0
Abstract Introduction Definition of Anomaly 2.1 Importance of Anomalies to Space Systems 2.2 2.3 Causes of Anomalies Space Environment Data Types of Anomalies 4.1 Radiation-Induced Anomalies 4.1.1 Spacecraft Charging 4.1.2 Single Event Effects 4.1.3 Total Dose 4.1.4 Displacement Damage Non-Radiation-Induced Anomalies 4.2 4.2.1 Mechanical 4.2.2 Software Learning from Anomalies Anomalies Can Lead to New Understanding 5.1 Preventing Software Anomalies 5.2 Publishing Anomaly Analyses 5.3 Future Trends 6.1 New Types of Military Space Systems Projected Increases in Numbers and Types of Commercial Spacecraft 6.2 6.3 Space Experiments to Get High Tech to Space in Record Time New Technologies and Radiation Effects Challenges 6.4 6.5 Use of COTS in Future Spacecraft Testing, Hardness Assurance and Shielding 6.6 6.7 Use of Plastic Parts New Technologies and new Effects in Future Systems 6.8 Conclusions and Summary References 1.0 ABSTRACT
This short course paper will discuss the various types of effects which produce anomalies in space systems giving historical and other examples of such anomalies and the results they have on the space systems. It will describe how system engineers search for the cause for the aberrant behavior of the system and the accompanying phenomena which often provide valuable clues to the cause (such as knowledge that a solar flare had recently occurred or that the spacecraft was in a geostationary orbit and the event happened shortly after 01996
IEEE II-1
,,
,
midnight). Because the causes of many anomalies are never determined, it is difficult to accumulate comprehensive statistics on the distribution of causes of anomalies or failures in satellites. It will describe how anomalies are handled through on-orbit corrections or reprogramming and how they are handled for future generations of the same space system. The second subject covered in this talk will be trends in future space systems and how those trends will be affected by radiation effects in microelectronic and photonic devices and systems. The future holds new types of systems such as cellular telephones and data transfer systems and, equally importantly, greatly increasing numbers of satellites. Both these trends and the introduction of new technologies will provide a variety of new radiation effects and new challenges for us and for future generations of scientists and engineers. 2.0 INTRODUCTION There have been spacecraft anomalies almost as long as there have been spacecraft. There were early examples of unexplained behavior and failure of spacecraft devices, subsystems and even of entire spacecraft dating from the late 1950’s when spacecraft were first placed into orbit. A number of the early failures occurred while we were learning to build space systems which had to do a large number of complex operations remotely. This is an expected part of the learning curve in any complicated operation. Many of these failures occurred in the start-up phase of the spacecraft following launch and injection into the proper orbit while the solar arrays and antennas were being deployed, the batteries charged, and subsystems checked out. Nevertheless even after we learned how to build space systems that worked reasonably reliably and far beyond the design lifetime, we were still plagued by a number of occurrences of what appeared to be random upsets or failures in spacecraft after they had been operating for some time. These anomalies particularly seemed to be noticed in the early 1970’s There may have been several reasons for this. By then we felt we knew how to build satellites and we expected the number of problems to decrease dramatically. At the same time, satellites were becoming much more complex which produced many more possible Microelectronic devices were also becoming much more (and more subtle) ways to fail. capable, but yet smaller, faster and lower power. This increased the vulnerability of the devices to effects produced by the natural space environment, and increased the probability of radiation-induced anomalies. 2.1 DEFINITION
OF ANOMALY
Definition: An anomaly is...an abnormality...an regular arrangement, general rule, or usual method.
irregularity...a
deviation from the
The above definition was taken from Webster’s Dictionary. In the scientific community, the above definition applies quite well; the only thing we might add is: ...an unexpected problem or failure. 2.2 IMPORTANCE
OF ANOMALIES
TO SPACE SYSTEMS
Sometimes anomalies can be just small perturbations on an otherwise perfectly operating system and can be unimportant in the larger scheme of things. For example, a single event upset (SEU) can occur in a sensor or memory which contains a lot of data. By its very nature, the error is sometimes obvious, or unimportant. A picture that contains one erroneous II-2
pixel would probably not even be detectable. One erroneous count out of 1000in data, introduces a O.10/0 error in the result and is generally negligible. An upset can also occur in a circuit which has an error detection and correction (EDAC) circuit in it. These types of anomalies cause little, if any, problem. Unfortunately, anomalies can also be of enormous importance to space systems. If an anomaly occurs and the solution isn’t found quickly, the affected device or subsystem or even the entire spacecraft can be lost. Anomalies present very tough problems to space system operators, because, by their very nature they are unexpected, and by Murphy’s Law, they always happen to the most important subsystem and at the worst possible time. The anomaly itself can cause a very serious problem, or the spacecraft operators can not understand the anomaly fully, and take an action which would ordinarily be safe, but which is not safe in the presence of the anomaly. The worst case examples of anomalies can involve turning on a thruster, or spinning up a reaction wheel, misprinting a critical antenna, producing excessive radiation damage in a solar array, or even causing an explosion. Good design practice generally excludes actions like turning on a thruster by a single anomaly. Serious actions like turning on a thruster require a series of steps like activating the thruster control circuit, applying power to the circuit, then giving the command. Such an action would require three separate anomalies and, hence, are very unlikely, but not unheard of as we shall see later. Excess radiation damage to the solar arrays, caused by a large solar flare, is, unfortunately, not as easily excluded by good design; the array is sized to accommodate the expected number of large flares and one can rarely afford to oversize the array, j ust in case a larger number of flares than expected, should occur. 2.3 CAUSES OF ANOMALIES Determining the cause of the anomaly is often not easy. There are usually a variety of clues that can be of significant help. The information needed to analyze the anomaly is listed in Table 1, along with some examples. The first thing to do is to describe just what happened and determine as closely as possible when it was first observed, noting what the spacecraft was doing at the time and what instructions it was carrying out. This often limits the type of anomaly, and the time is useful in later steps. The type of orbit and where the satellite was in the orbit when the anomaly occurred is a very valuable clue. The first example given in Table 1. under the orbit is a geostationary orbit. If the local time is between midnight and six AM, local satellite time, then there is an increased probability that the anomaly is an electrostatic discharge from surface charging, as we will see in the next section; if it occurs in the early afternoon, it is more likely to be caused by a deep dielectric discharge. Determining what the satellite’s radiation environment was at the time of, and shortly before the anomaly occurred, can provide information about the particle that produced the anomaly. If it occurred in the peak of the proton belts or in the South Atlantic Anomaly, it is very likely it was caused by a radiation belt proton. One of the most valuable clues is to look for a disturbance in the radiation environment during, or shortly before the anomaly occurred such as a large solar flare. Large solar flares can produce a number of effects in spacecraft, such as SEU’S and solar cell damage. Previous anomalies on the same satellite or simultaneous anomalies on other satellites in similar orbits are very useful in determining the cause. In the next sections we will illustrate these and other examples by a more detailed discussion.
II-3
,.
3.0 SPACE ENVIRONMENT
!
DATA
The space radiation environment around the time of an anomaly is often of a great deal of importance. It will be useful to describe briefly the space radiation environments which produce many anomalies. A detailed description of the space radiation environments would not be useful here. What is is an needed order of magnitude understanding of each of important the For most environments. _ 1 The Earth’s Radiation <s. effects, the most important environments are the Earth’s radiation belts, sometimes known as the Van Allen belts after their discoverer. The Earth’s radiation belts are shown pictorially in Figure 1 [After II-4
The figure shows the Stassinopoulosz. Earth’s proton and electron belts. One point to note is the asymmetry on the right mouse ear lobe which appears just off the coast of South America. This is known as the South Atlantic Anomaly (SAA). It is caused by the fact that the geometric center of the Earth’s magnetic field is not exactly at the center of the Earth and the field is inclined at 11 degrees to the equatorial plane. When spacecraft pass through the SAA they encounter large increases in particle fluences and this produces many anomalies. Figure 2 shows the integral fluences of protons with energy less than 30 MeV in units of protons/cm2-day as a function of satellite altitude for circular orbits of selected inclinations based on the AP-8 Minimum Mode13. Note that the belts peak at about 3300 km (1800 nmi). Most spacecraft operate either above or below these intense belts to reduce the undesired radiation unless the mission requires it. Figure 3 shows the
ELECTRON CIRCULAR
INTEGRAL
FLUSNCES
SARl?i
ORBITS
(SASED
ON AE4
AVERAGED
OF VARIOUS AND AH
OVER
INCLINATIONS
MODELS}
,@14
I
3
1-
-i
L4z!--1 “-03
F@re
I
1 z
346
3 Earth’s Electron Belts.
10
15
20
PROTON lNlE&RUmUc3
AVERAGED
EARTH ORBITS W VARIOUS INCLINATIONS (BASED ON APWIN NODEL) r, ~ L I
ALmJDEmousmDE oPsAuncALuus)
Figure 2 Earth’s Proton Belts
integral fluences of electrons with energy greater than 40 keV and also 1 MeV in units of electrons/cm2-day as a function of satellite altitude for circular orbits of selected inclination based on the AE-6 and AE-4 NASA Models4. The electron belts peak at about 5600 km (3000 nmi) without any material present. About 80 roils of aluminum will absorb one MeV electrons, so the lower curves can be used to get an indication of how the peak intensity shifts inside a spacecraft. F@we 4 shows the integrated proton fluences intercepted by a spacecraft in a Low Earth Orbit (LEO) when it crosses the SAAS. Notice how much time a LEO spacecraft spends in the SAA, nearly 30 minutes out of a 90 minute orbital period for a 1111 km orbit. The size and shape of the SAA is a strong function of orbital altitude and also of particle energy. If an anomaly occurs while a spacecraft is crossing the SAA, the anomaly was very likely caused by a proton.
II-5
We have discussed the Earth’s radiation belts now let us describe the cosmic ray and solar flare environments. Figure 5 shows the relative intensity of cosmic ray protons for solar maximum and minimum and a solar proton flare for comparison. The cosmic rays are much more energetic than solar flare protons. It is important to recognize that the solar minimum cosmic ray environment is more intense than that of the solar maximum. the cosmic rays penetrate more easily when the sun is less active. The I I I 1 I I I \!u\ Uv , J ,Dimlnm main point of this figure, however, is that if a “ ammmmmm 9@ mmlWcwu’rnmww~ solar flare occurs it dominates the cosmic ray environment by five or six orders of magnitude. Two very intense anomalously -4 Roton Fluence in the SAA [after large flares are shown in Figure 6, the very Stassinopoulos, Ref 5] energetic flare of February 26, 1956 and the very intense flare of August 4, 19727. When the term “ten percent worst case flare” is used, it means that there is only a 10 % chance of encountering a higher solar flare environment than it. Note that for the worst case environment the envelope of the 1972 flare is used above the intersection of the two curves, and the 1956 curve is used below that point. This envelope represents an extremely intense, high energy flare which has not actually been seen in nature. Figure 7 shows that even very ,.9 INTEGRAL PRow4
lW*O
‘
, ,.
i
w
t
1],,,
~hERGY SPECTRA
!,
lLW
ENERGY {MAO
-6 Solar Flare Spectra [After Adarns, Ref 71
Figure 5 Comparison of Cosmic Rays and Solar Flares [after Adarns, Ref q II-6
large amounts of shielding (up to 2 inches of aluminum) do not change the cosmic ray spectrum by very muchs. Large variations in the Earth’s radiation environment are caused by changing conditions on the sun and by the magnetic fields in the solar system which modify the access of solar and galactic particles to the near-Earth regions of space. The sun has an d over-all pattern of activity with an 11 year ml * ,,WI ml , cycle. This is shown in Figure 8 which shows lid 10-’ Id I& 10” D’ ~’ 10 I the pattern for both sunspot numbers and for LET In MeV em’ Is magnetically disturbed days (in which the geomagnetic index, Ap, is greater than 40)9. The incidence of many types of spacecraft _ 7 Cosmic My Spectra Behind anomalks such as electrostatic discharges from Various Shielding [After Adams Ref 8] surface charging follows this over-all pattern too. Figure 9 shows a more detailed look at the solar flare distribution with timel”. It is clear that solar flares are less likely to occur at solar minimum and they seem to have a higher probability of occurring on the leading and trailing edges of the solar cycle. The seasonal distribution of magnetic disturbances is shown in Figure 10’1. Note that the magnetic storms vary by about a factor of two over the year and are highest at the spring and fall equinoxes. This m-ak& upsets more probable during those seasons. ‘This same seasonal pattern is seen in spacecraft anomalies caused by surface charging.
‘t-
SunSPOts WMJ MwnctkStormDaw
,.
. Iwa
li?o
lwa
107s
mm
mm
&
-8 SunSpOtS and Magnetic Storms [After Allen Ref 9]
* 9 Solar Flare Protons for Cycles 20-22 [After Barth Ref 10]
II-7
4.0 TYPES OF ANOMALIES Anomalks can be separated into two for our purposes, broad categories non-radiationradiation-induced and induced. It seems clear that the Nuclear and Space Radiation Effects Conference attendees would be primarily interested in radiation-induced anomalies, and I will concentrate on them. Nevertheless, other anomalies will also be discussed because they are often important causes of the upset or loss of major space systems and it is necessary to have some understanding of them in order to gain some perspective. One important example of a mechanical anomaly will be discussed in some detail because it probably caused the loss of the Mars Observer spacecraft.
14% Major
[
M agnetlc
Storms:
1932-1991 11.Bn
8.1%
“-———–
I Jmwmr&r
MwJlm
JLd Au48a00sImIoac
Figure 10 Monthly Distribution of Magnetic The various types of spacecraft Storms [After allen, Ref 11] anomalies are shown in Table 2. The include anomalies radiation-induced electrostatic discharges that occur as a result of either surface or deep dielectric charge that builds up on the spacecraft. When such discharges occur, they can cause changes of state in memories, telemetry resets, breaMown paths across dielectrics, or they can short out a device. A second important type of anomaly is single event effects. SEE’s include single event upsets (SEU), single event Iatchup (SEL), single event burnout (SEB), and single event gate rupture (SEGR), among the better known effects. AU single event effects occur as the result of a single particle depositing energy along the path of a particle either directly or by means of a nuclear interaction with the material which can produce other particles. SEU often occurs in memories where it changes the state of one or more bits in the region where the particle strikes. SEUS can also give an undesired instruction to a microprocessor or even jump it to an undefined state. SELS can cause a device to burn out if the latched state draws enough current. A large pulse of current produced by a single particle can also cause a gate under bias to ruptu~ destroying the device (SEGR). Total ionizing dose can cause threshold voltage shifts or increased leakage current in CMOS devices which drives them out of specifications and causes failure. It can also cause failure in bipolar devices (operation outside of specifications) by reducing the gain or by increasing the leakage current. Displacement damage results from particles interacting directly with the atoms of the lattice and displacing them, causing charge trapping and recombination centers. This results, for example, in gain reductions in bulk devices and reductions in charge transfer efficiency in Charge Coupled Devices (CCD’S). We will discuss the four types of radiation-induced anomalies listed in Table 2 in order.
II-8
4.1 RADIATION-INDUCED
ANOMALIES
4.1.1 Spacecraft Charging Spacecraft anomalies such as upsets, switching errors and resets had been occurring regularly in some space systems in the early 1970’s. Just what was causing them was not understood. They seemed to be happening often to our major communication satellite systems which operate in a geostationary orbit. It was happening to both military systems such as the Defense SateUite Communication System (DSCS II) and the Defense Support Program (DSP) spacecraft and to commercial satellites as well such as Intelsat and Telesat. An example of the
II-9
,,
,
type of anomalies occurring in synchronous satellites is shownn in Table 3. The anomalies include a number of examples of logic or control circuit switching and other erroneous operations. It was noticed that when the locations of the anomalies were plotted as a function of when they occurred in terms of satelMe local time, the anomalies clustered into one large group (see Figure ll)n. -use a synchronous satellite has a 24-hour orbit, it circles the earth once per day and therefore stays over a fixed point on the equator. The time at that fixed point on 1 the earth is the spacecraft local time]. An v DSP LOGIC UPSEIS n i 0 OscsII RCAUPSETS unusually large fraction of the spacecraft v lMlfLSM IV o INIELSA1 Ill anomalies occurred in the midnight to six a.m. quadrant in the satellite’s local time (much larger than the expected 12). The -11 Local Tme dependence of Upset [After McPherson, Ref 13] probability that 31 out of 47 “anomalous events” would occur at random in a single quadrant was calculated as 3 chances in 109. Other work by DeForest14 indicated that synchronous satellites were probably being charged to high potentials by particles. The explanation suggested was that events occur preferentially just after midnight because the spacecraft passes through the geomagnetic tail where electrons, accelerated by geomagnetic activity, are injected and drift from midnight toward dawn. In addition, if the spacecraft is out of view of the sun, then solar photoelectrons can no longer provide a discharge mechanism. This problem was viewed as serious enough that an experimental spacecraft, was designed and launched specifically to study spacecraft charging, the Spacecraft Charging AT High Altitudes satellite, (SCATHA). One signature of dielectric discharges caused by spacecraft surface charging is the high probability of finding a large number of events occurring between midnight and dawn local time in a spacecraft having a high altitude orbit such as geosynchronous. If the discharges group in the afternoon local time there is a good probability that they result from deep dielectric discharges. These examples illustrate how environmental information can provide the necessary clues to recognize the source of the problem causing the anomaly. Figure 12 shows the insulator pulses (ESD’S) detected on the Internal Discharge Monitor instrument that were recorded onboard the Combined Release and Radiation Effects Satellite (CRRES) in a carefully
Figure 12 Orbital Distribution of CRRES Insulator Pulses [After Violet, Ref 15J 11-10
The flux of electrons with energy greater than 300 keV is also shown designed experiments. for comparison. The CRRES orbit ranges from about 200 nmi to 20,000 nmi in a geostationary transfer orbit inclined at 18 degrees to the equatorial plane. The x-axis is given in Earth radii in units of L, the Mclllwain L parameterlf, where L=l is the surface of the Earth. The geostationary orbit is at about L = 6.6. The spacecraft starts at the left side of the figure and moves down through the radiation belts until near L = 1 it passes under the belts then climbs back through them ending near its geosynchronous apogee on the right. The ESDS correlate well with the electron flux shown in the top part of the figure. The SEUS shown at the bottom nearly all occurred in the proton belts. It was a surprise that over 90 ‘A of the upsets were produced by protons. Before CRRES was launched it was predicted that most of the upsets would be produced by cosmic rays. 4.1.2 Single Event Effects Another effect which produces a large number of anomalies in space systems is Single Event Upset (SEU). The history of single event upsets is interesting. It started with a paper by Wallmark and MarcusI’, of RCA, published in 1962, in which the authors speculated that cosmic rays would be able to produce upsets in microcircuits as the microminiaturization trend continued and that cosmic ray upsets would set the ultimate limit on how small a device could be made. Their paper, however, was so far ahead of its time that it was largely overlooked. The next significant event took place 13 years later, in 1975, when Binder, Smith and Ho1man18, of the Hughes Corp., observed unexpected triggering of digital circuits in an operating sateUite and postulated that the bipolar flip-flop circuits were being upset by charge collected from the dense ionization track of an energetic heavy ion cosmic ray passing through an individual transistor. Binder, Smith and Holman calculated an upset rate which was within a factor of two of the observed results. This paper too was ahead of its time and did not awaken the community to the potential seriousness of the problem. In 1978, May and Woods19, of Intel Corp., discovered that anomalous upsets which were occurring in dynamic random access memories on the ground, were being caused by alpha particles emitted from trace amounts of thorium and uranium in the materials from which the device’s packages were made In 1978 also, Pickel and Blandford20, of the Rockwell Corp., studied anomalous upsets which were being obsemxl in NMOS dynamic RAMs used in a satellite system and concluded that these upsets were due to heavy ion cosmic rays. They also developed an approach for calculating upset rates to be expected in a cosmic ray environment. The Pickel and Blandford paper finally alerted the radiation effects community to the problem of heavy ion-induced cosmic ray upsets in microcircuits. It quickly became clear that both protons and neutrons could also induce SEU’S (Guenze#l and McNult#). Since the discovery of SEU’S, the number of Single Event Effects (SEE) has expanded greatly to Single Event Latch-up (SEL), Single Event Burnout (SEB), etc. One particular device has become famous (or infamous) for causing an unusually large number of upsets in operational spacecraft, the 93422 or 93L422. This device has been responsible for producing upsets in TDRS, LANDSAT, and DSCS and potential latchup in this device also caused the costly redesign of the Galileo spacecraft. The effect of a large solar flare such as that of October 1989 on the SEU rate is dramatic Solar flares are made up of a large number of particle types but are predominately protons. As shown in the top of Figure 13, the GOES-7 spacecraft detected x-rays emitted by the Sun during that solar flare ‘. The x-rays travel in a straight line toward the Earth. The solar flare particles are bent by the magnetic fields between the Sun and the Earth and they 11-11
,,
may or may not couple well to the- Earth, arriving somewhat later. Notice how the SEUS shown in the center of the figure follow the solar particle fluence. The fact that the SEUS track the proton fluences rather than the x-ray rates is illustrated clearly in Figure 14 for the March, 1991 solar flare event?4. Figure 15 shows the SEU rate observed on the TDRS 1 illustrating spacecraft the cosmic ray and solar flare It is important to effects2s. notice that the SEU rate peaks during solar minimum indicating that those SEU’S were produced by cosmic rays. There are also spikes on the curves cortwponding to the large solar flares of 1989 and 1991. Upsets on the UOSAT satellite observed from 1988 to 1992 in TMS 4416 64 bit NMOS dynamic RAMs are shown in Figure 1626. The upsets occur predominantly as the satellite passes through the SAA. This is typical behavior for a LEO satellite. Let us now look at single event latchup in an NEC 64 K CMOS RAM used in a geostationary and a LEO satellite. The details of the observations are given in Table 4 for the Engineering Test Satellite V launched by the NASDA into a geostationary orbit. The eight devices produced about 2.4 SEL per week and 0.76 SEU per week as shown during a period of 3.5 years. During the large solar flares of September 29, 1989 and October 19,1989 satellite 80-180
TDRS-l SEUS ●mdENERGETIC October W’
*$-7
-.
l-m z-
. Day
!6”
~~
SOLAR PARTICLSS
1989
19
20 ,
#
“
*
,C
.
.
_ 13 TDRS Memory Upsets With GoES-7 Data [After Allen, Ref 23]
Proton
SOLAR-TERRESTRIAL ENVIRONMENT March 1991
;
10”
-E
Id
/&L---—l+%————+ -
Id
.I.-.
MIMWN● LOdnna
urmw9
_ 14 CAMS-7Solar-Terrestrial Environment for March 1991 showing SEU’S [After Allen, Ref 24] 11-12
SEL and 50-70 SEU were observed respectively. The onorbit data are shown in Figure 1727. A more careful look at the data (Figure 18)28 shows that nearly 80 SEL’S were accumulated in a little over a day, an increase of over 200 in SEL rate. This same device (in a slightly different version) was also used in the ESA Earth Resources Satellite-1, a LEO satellite launched in 1991. This satellite had an on-board experiment called the Precision Rate and Range Range Experiment which only operated for five days before being destroyed by an overcurrent in the power supply shown in Table 5. Before shutdown, a number of SEU’S were observed and a processor reboot was required29 . The experimenters decided that UOSAT-Z
OHC
MEMORY
lJIWETS
: TEXAS
SEUSOBSERVEDON TDRS1
l$X16
1,987
1~88
45
: . d .
a
TMS4416
16k
. 4-I?lT
-0S
D=
-+5
-90 -100
–90
1,991
F@re 15 SEU’S Observed on TDRSS-1 Bariliot, Ref 25]
w
L . t
1$89 1,990 YEAR
o L.ngitud.
90
100
7995 Jh.mts in 1364 Dmy. Sq)f.~bae “SS - hlqy ,92
Figure 16 Dynamic RAM Upsets on UOSAT-1 [After Dyer, Ref 261
l@92
[After
the burnout was possibly caused by a proton induced They therefore Iatchup. the Engineering tested Development Model and Iatchups found that occurred in the 64 K RAM at the fluences shown. The burnout currents required in the ground tests matched the from seen those telemetry, were consistent with the total accumulated fluence and occurred in the SAA as shown in Figure 1930. SEL is going to be discussed in a great deal more detail in the later talk by Ken Galloway.
4.1.3 Total Dose The first anomaly in operation (and later, the loss) of a spacecraft due to total dose effects occurred very unexpectedly as shown in Table 6. A Bell Telephone Labs satellite called II- 13
,,
II -14
Telstar was launched into a 515 nmi by 3044 nmi orbit with 44.8 degrees of inclination on July 10, 1962. This is an orbit that passes through intense regions of the Van Allen belts. Telstar was launched just one day after a very large nuclear weapon (over 1 Megaton) was detonated at a high altitude of about 400 km. This Starfish nuclear test produced a large number of beta particles (electrons) which became trapped in the Earth’s magnetic field causing an intense, artificial radiation belt to form which lasted until the early 1970’s. This new radiation belt increased the expected total accumulated dose in the Telstar spacecraft by a factor of over 1000 This additional dose produced what was probably the first instance of the loss of a spacecraft due to total ionizing dose damage in a semiconductor device. The command decoder on Telstar I, consisting of diodes and narrow base transistors was not sensitive to displacement damage+ but was sensitive to total ionizing dose In mid-November, it became sluggish and on November 24, 1962 it failed. A series of creative steps were taken and it eventually recovered its function, but again failed, this time permanently, on February 21, 1963. Ground tests on two transistors with the same date code showed failure after 0.6 and 2.3 megarads and were consistent with the dose observed on The failure behavior Telstar. was also the same and it was concluded by Mayo et. al.31 that the failure was caused by surface damage to the Command
ON-ORBIT LATCH-UP ANDUPSETINNECM KCMOS R4MSONTHENASDAETS-VSPACECRAFT
F&n 17 On-Orbit Latchup and Upset of DRAMs [After Goka, Ref 271
ON-ORBIT LATCH-UP ANDUPSETIN NEC64K CMOS RAMSONTHENASDAETS-VSPACE~
Figure 18 On-Orbit SEUS and Latchup-in During Solar Flare [After Goka, Ref 28] II- 15
Dfi
Decoder caused by radiation enhanced from the Van Allen belts. In this case, the radiation unusual environment provided the clue to the cause of the anomaly and ground tests provided the proof or at least confirmed that a similar amount of radiation could cause a very similar effect in the suspected device. When the STARFISH burst was detonated in 1962 it destroyed a total of seven satellites within seven months, primarily due to solar cell damage. It gives pause to one contemplate how many military and
ON-ORBIT LATCH-UP IN AN NEC 64 K CMOS RAM ON THE ESA ERS-1 SPACECRAFT’
Figure 19 Orbii Positions of On-orbit Latchups in DRAMs [After Adarus, Ref 30] II -16
commercial satellites such a burst would destroy today considering the much larger number of spacecraft in orbit now and how rapidly the number is rising! 4.1.4 Displacement
Damage
Displacement damage is also sometimes the cause of spacecraft anomalies. Most displacement damage was historically associated with massive events such as large solar flares and it generally took place in analog rather than digital devices. It is often easier to determine the cause of damage in analog devices because they change in a continuous manner, rather than in one step, and when unexpected behavior starts to occur, it can often be monitored. The monitoring of a slow, but continuous change in an electronic part’s operational parameters is easier to detect than spotting a single, random event, such as a SEU. There is another reason that it was often easier to pin down in the past; it often caused problems in the spacecraft power system which is usually monitored in real time so that the anomaly was observed as it was happening. If you can see the power reducing as a solar flare occurs it is pretty easy to determine the cause. In this section we will begin by discussing some examples of classic displacement damage caused by charged particles such as protons or other heavier particles. There are many examples, but not much mystery. We will then go on to a more recent example where there aren’t many examples, but there is still a good deal of mystery. Solar cells are exceptionally vulnerable because they are on the outside of the spacecraft where they do not benefit from inherent shielding. They typically have 6-30 mil cover slips on the front and a light weight aluminum backing on the back The first example of displacement damage causing the loss of a space system from solar cell damage occurred in 1962. The Starfkh nuclear 70 weapon test, discussed r above under total dose, produced electrons and redistributed protons which caused premature degradation and failure in the solar arrays of three satellites in low-altitude orbits at the time. The three satellites, Transit 4B, Traac and Ariel became inoperable because of degradation in their solar cell power systems32. One I failed in 4 days, one in 24 and a third in 36 days. The solar cell output as a function of time in orbit is shown for Transit 4B and Traac33 in Figure 20. This
30332334536630 1s81 I
4080 196?.
co
loo1201401so lAomom’4oM ON )nMeEll
2s0300
Flgum 20 TRAAC and TRANSIT Solar Cell Outputs vs Time After Starfiih Burst [After Fwhell, Ref 33] II- 17
,.
,
rTTT7Tn II 41
I“”rlll 44
23
24
25
26
27
MARCH1%1
Figure 21 GOES-6 and GOES-7 Solar Cell Degradation [After Allen, Ref 3Sl
Produced by a Solar Flare
figure demonstrates the dramatic effects of Startlsh. With the quality of telemetry shown in Figure 20, it was pretty clear that solar panel degradation was responsible for the loss of the spacecraft, but the cause was a little more obscure. Did the trapped electrons from the weapon cause the degradation or was it caused by the protons which were redistributed by the weapon’s disturbance to the Earth’s magnetic field? One can tell whether damage is caused primarily by electrons or by protons by looking at how damage depends on the depth of shielding material. It happened that on the TELSTAR satellite (launched just after Startlsh) there were a series of solar cells with different coverslip thicknesses. By comparing the damage observed to that expected from electrons or protons of appropriate energies, the experimenters34 deduced that most of the damage was caused by protons. For comparison, we will now look at the more recent effects produced by a solar flare in the GOES-6 and GOES-7 spacecraft during the March 1991 solar flare, shown35 in Figure 21. As the Figure shows, in just nine days, the solar array lost as much power as was expected for three years of operation in a “normal” geostationary orbit environment. We now turn to some rather interesting new results of damage caused by very small fluences of protons. I have placed this under the displacement damage section because it is H- 18
caused by protons and not by Co 60 gamma rays. The problem is that this damage takes place at a very low dose or fluence level, much below that of classic displacement damage. The damage mechanism is not yet understood. The first anomaly appeared in 1993 when the Remote Command Unit (RCU) on a spacecraft failed after about three years in orbit. Fortunately there were redundant RCU’S on board. This same RCU was used on other spacecraft and after about three years in a similar orbit an RCU on the second spacecraft also failed. A year and half later, in 1995, a second RCU on the first spacecraft again failed (there are a number of RCU’S on board) but this time the failure was captured in real time telemetry. Since these RCU’S are used on a number of satellites the problem had a lot of urgency to be solved before another spacecraft with this type of RCU on board was launched. There was another, even more urgent reason for the Responsible Engineer to solve the problem quickly. When a spacecraft anomaly occurs, someone’s name and phone number is on the top of the list to be called at any time of the day or the night. When the first failure occurred, he was in California on business. When the second failure occurred, he was on a trip celebrating his anniversary with his wife in the wilderness. When the third anomaly occurred, he was golfing in Florida. Now, disturbing a business trip is annoying and ruining an anniversary trip with your wife is even worse, but being called back from a golf trip is unthinkable! Clearly something had to be done to solve this problem, and quickly!
3 r—
~~-nm
1-- --r--l
I
I I I I
.-. . . I ●
. 1700
B@kir
650
c!
o
2 -
❑
o
.G t!
0
0
●
1 – v
Vvvo Vo
v
() ~UJ~ .1
1
500
❑
o
450 100
lo
Total Dose (KRad(SI)) GAIN DEGIUDATION IN TRW 4NZ4A OP7YMSGLATORS AS A FUNCTION OF 63 MeV PROTON DAMAGE. SPBC MEANS THE CURRENT TRANSFER RATIO WAS MEASURHI WITH NO LOAD; FLIGHT MEANS m wAs MEASURED As mmm wm A LOAD (FROM REFERENCE 16).
l?igure 22 Opto-isolator Ref 36]
Gain Degradation
vs Dose [After Stapor,
II -19
The basic information for the for solution the problem was by now available. The units started to fail after a fixed time on orbit. That could be either a time or a radiation related failure. The anomalies investigation by the Tiger Team indicated that the failures were related to power switching in The the RCU’S. power switching was done by a TRW 4N24A Gtis optoisolator. This device is used to turn the unit on or off. With optical coupling, the chance of parasitic noise getting into the unit is minimized. The 4N24A devices had been tested by
the contractor and shown to work well, 4 l_ll_lHlll_f_’_7-~ l_T17’1--T” TT-rTl 11 ~ even after a dose of 1= 1 hundreds of kilorads & ; :“ v of Cobalt 60 gamma ● *O’ 800 rays. But there was 3 0 0 one disturbing bit of information; tests - 700 ❑ 0 i several conducted ❑ years earlier on a o slightly different - 600 ❑ 0 version had shown o 4N24A’s the that 1 “w v 500 141nAt3@t started failing after n o a lomspec only the equivalent of Q o 2mAspec o 0 5-10 Krads of protons. 1 1 1 1 t 1I 11 I 1 1 1 1 t 111 0 & t I 1 111 01 al A new set of 4N24’s 1 1 lo W was tested (along with TOTM DOSEOQad@O) a large variety of optoGAIN DM3RADAT30NIN TRW 4N24AOFTCHSOLA*RS “d isolators from other A FUNCITON OF 63 MeV FROTON DAMAGE IN THE MODIFIED manufacturers) at the III(3HT CIRCU~. SPECMEANSTHE CURREJ’TT’ TIUNSFER RATIO WAS MEASUREDWITH NO LOAQ FLIOHT MEANS IT WAS U.C. Davis cyclotron MEASUREDAS FLOWN W~ A LOAD (FROM REFERENCE16). using 63 MeV protons. The data is shown~ in which Figure 22. _ 23 Opt-isolator Gain Degradation Vs Dose for Higher shows how rapidly the Drive Currents [After Stapor, Ref 371 gain degrades after a 63 MeV proton dose of only a few Krads, especially in circuits which draw low drive currents. Further testing with higher drive currents (Figure 2337) or with other devices has shown methods of reducing the problem. As a result of the tesq two frees were identified: 1) modify the flight circuit to draw more drive current (20 ma, rather than 2 ma), and 2) shift to other devices e.g., the 4N49 from different manufacturers (OPTEK and Micropac).
I
This example has shown how sensitive opto-electronic devices can be to proton displacement damage compared to total ionizing dose from Cobalt 60 gamma rays. With the use of more opto-electronic devices in the future, this looks like an increasingly important problem for new space systems. Charge transfer devices - Charge Coupled Devices (CCD’S), Charge Injected Devices (CID’s), etc., have similar vulnerabilities at the same low levels and will also be a potential problem for future spacecraft. It seems probable that as we put more electro-optical devices on spacecraft, we will begin to have more of these anomalies caused by low fluences of protons or other particles. The Tiger Team believes that it has solved the problem which they believe was a radiation failure. I am not so sure, because, as shown in Table 7., I have also noted a coincidence which has occurred with 100VO frequency in this example~, namely that the Responsible Engineer has been out of town every time the anomaly has occurred! I suspect that it is correlated with time+ mther than with radiation, and that the solution is to keep him home and on the job! [In this example it has been necessary to delete a number of details (such as names) in order to protect the gu .... er, innocent] II -20
*
**
Ground tests show failures in 4N24A’s at similar doses. Emergency phone calls verify that Responsible Engineer is not at work
4.2 NON-RADIATION-INDUCED
ANOMALIES
Non-radiation-induced anomalies can result from random failures in devices, operator errors, such as sending an improper command, a malfunction in a mechanical subsystem, such as a reaction wheel, a software error through a transmitted or stored command, or from a variety of other causes. 4.2.1 Mechanical Determining the cause of an anomaly can be a very serious problem requiring a large team of experienced satellite designers and software experts. This is particularly true if a spacecraft is currently non operational and a Tiger Team is assembled to try to recover the spacecraft or if a failure has occurred and the failure is being investigated. A good example of a group assembled to determine the cause of a mission failure is illustrated in the Mars Observer Mission Failure Investigation Board39 which investigated what appears to be a failure in one of the mechanical subsystems, the propulsion subsystem. The Mars Observer program was conceived starting in 1981 and initiated as a new start in 1985. The scientific objectives of the project were to study the surface and atmosphere of Mars, its topography and magnetic field. The details of the program are shown in Table 8. The total program cost was expected to be about $415 M. It was originally planned for a shuttle launch, but after the Challenger explosion, the launch vehicle was shifted to a Titan III, and the planned launch was delayed for 26 months (the next Earth-Mars proper orientation). The Mars Observer was launched on 25 September, 1992 into a low altitude parking orbit and then it was injected into an interplanetary trajectory to begin its 11 month cruise phase (see Figure 24)40. 11-21
TABLE $415 M PROGRAM
!3
MARS OBSERVER
PROGRAM
TO STUDY SURFACE AND ATMOSPHERE
OF MAR$
LAUNCHED 25 SEPT 1992 INTO LEO THEN INJECTED INTO INTERPLANETARY TRAJECTORY TOWARD MARS AT 0021 ON 22 AUG 1993 BEGAN MARS ORBIT INSERTION UNDER CONTROL OF SOFTWARE NO DATA RECEIVED FROM SPACECRAFT
MANEUVERS
SINCE SEQUENCE
INITIATED
FAILURE REVIEW BOARD ASKED TO INVESTIGATE
Figure 24 Mars Observer Minion II -22
[after Ref 40]
All went well during the cruise phase, with only a few anomalies noted until the spacecraft was to begin the first step of its Mars orbit insertion. At 21 minutes after midnight GMT on 22 August 1993 a series of events was started to begin the Mars orbit insertion maneuvers. The system was under control of a sequence of software commands previously stored in the spacecraft computer. During all other events on the journey, a serious anomaly would activate a maneuver abort command, but at this critical time of insertion into the Mars orbit, which had to occur at a precise time, an abort could not be tolerated and hence all spacecraft abort criteria were temporarily disabled. The first step of the sequence was to pressurize the propulsion system. Because of concern that the traveling wave tubes in the RF power amplifiers might be damaged by the shock caused by the firing of the pyro valves, the RF amplifiers were turned off, as planned, just before the sequence was initiated. Unfortunately this meant that there would be no telemetry during the propellant tank pressurization sequence. No data have been received from the spacecraft since the sequence was initiated. Within three weeks of the telemetry failure of the Mars Observer, Daniel S. Goldin, NASA Administrator had requested Dr. Timothy Coffey, NRL’s Director of Research to establish a Failure Investigation Board to look into the failure. The Board consisted of eight other members and 29 technical advisom from NRL, NASA, NOAA, AFPL, the US Navy and the DMSP program ofilce. The Board was broken into six teams responsible for the spacecraft subsystems, namely: Electrical Power, Attitude and Articulation Control, Command and Data Handling, Mechanical, Telecommunications and Software. The Board presented its results after a four month investigation. The Board’s problem was to find the probable cause of the mishap when there was neither telemetry data nor any physical evidence available within 19 light minutes. The Board’s approach was to identify the possible failure modes that could have resulted in the immediate loss of telemetry. Many of these were random failures. The Board considered random failures to be highly improbable since the spacecraft had operated for nearly a year and a random failure would have had to occur during the 14 minute interval during which the telemetry was off and in which a very critical process was occurring. Accordingly, random failure modes were eliminated. Next the Board eliminated failure modes which were not compatible with the detection capabilities of the NASA Deep Space Network and the fact that they had received no further telemetry from the spacecraft. Finally the Board focussed on the commands, actions and software associated with the pressurization sequence which was This effort resulted in an evaluation of 59 to take place during the 14 minute interval. possible scenarios. The justifications for these conclusions are presented in Table 9. The first potential cause was a power supply electronics (PSE) power diode insulation failure. The PSE contains several diodes connected to the power bus. Inspection of the spare PSE box revealed several discrepancies including a misalignment of three often stud-mounted power diodes permitting the diode to come into, or very close to, direct contact with the chassis. On some diodes, a thin kapton insulator had embedded metal particles and scratches in a thermal insulator on both sides of the kapton. The shock from firing the pyro valves could have caused a breakthrough in the insulation causing a permanent short in any of these diodes which would short-circuit the power supply, destroying the spacecraft. Based on the inspectionof the sparePSE, the Board believes that this scenm”o must be retained as a possible cause of the loss of the downlink. II -23
*
**
Noted on spare PSE box. ESA and NASA initiators designed to same specifications,
but are not identical.
The second potential cause was a pressure regulator failure. If the pressure regulator failed in the open position it would cause a rapid over-pressure and a rupture of the nitrogen tetroxide tank, destroying the spacecraft. Failure of the regulator could have been caused by nitrogen tetroxide frozen in the regulator orifice, by contamination blocking the orifice, or by contamination in the seat causing leaking. Since nopost-assemblytestshadbeen cam”edout to vemfithatthesystemwascleanandthe temperatureof the regulatorwasnot known,theBoard reta”ned thisscenarioasapossiblecausefor the loss of the downlink The third potential cause was the failure of a pyro valve charge initiator. Some European Space Agency (ESA) initiator tests have resulted in initiator ejection from the valve body at speeds of 200 m& The ESA initiators are designed to the same specifications as the NASA initiators, but are not identical. The ESA initiators failure mode is from thread erosion. The Board had the acceptance test lot of NASA initiators examined and found erosion of about 50’% of their threads, though none had failed by initiator ejection. For these reasons the Board believes that pyro valvecharge initiator failure is apossiblecauseof loss of the downlink.
II -24
The cause listed as most probable was leaking of nitrogen tetroxide through the check valves which separated the nitrogen tetroxide from the rest of the pressurization side of the system. Since the valves were cold for most of the 11 month cruise, a scenario was proposed in which nitrogen tetroxide leaked through the check valves and condensed on the cold tubing upstream. The nitrogen tetroxide could then mix rapidly with monomethylhydrazine when the pressurization sequence was initiated, causing a rapid heating, rupturing of tubing, or an explosion. Tests indicated that as much as one to two grams of nitrogen tetroxide could have migrated through the valves, much more than enough to cause an explosion. Because nitrogen tetroxz”dewas shown in tests to be able to m“grate through check valves posing a n“sk of explosion, because of the correlation with the pressurization sequence, and due to the lack of other more compelling scenarios, the Board determined that the most probable cause was the unintended mixing of nitrogen tetroxide and monomethylhydrm”ne in the titanium tubing on the prasu~~”on sib of thepropufswnsystimcausedby m“gratkn through MO check vtdves during the 11 month cruisefrom Earth to Mam This example illustrates just how difficult it is to pin down completely the cause of a spacecraft anomaly, especially when telemetry or tapes of the event are not available. 4.2.2 Software The Clementine spacecraft was developed by the Naval Research Laboratory for the Ballistic Missile Defense Organization and it involved the participation of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, NASA, and the Jet Propulsion Laboratory as shown in Table 10. The program required only 22 months from program initiation to its launch on January 25,1994 and itdemonstrated the use of advanced technology sensors, light weight components and new computer and digital processing technologies. The program involved making a detailed map of the lunar surface then a fly-by of the near-Earth asteroid Geographos. Clementine provided the first space-based photos of the moon since the last Apollo lunar landing in 1972, taking over 1.8 million multi-spectral images in the visible, infrared, and
ON MAY 7 AN ANOMALY
OCCURRED DURING A TEST
TELEMETRY LOST FOR 20 MINUTES, WHEN RECOVERED SPINNING AT 82 rpm
II -25
CLEMENTINE
WAS
ultraviolet. The first part of the mission, the 70-day mapping of the moon, was remarkably successful as illustrated in Figure 25 which is a map of the south polar region of the moon taken through a red filter by Clementine41. Following completion of the lunar mapping phase, Clementine was supposed to leave the Earth-moon system and head for Geographos. On May 4, 1994 Clementine left lunar orbit and performed a series of maneuvers to make a gravity assisted fly-by of Geographos. New software for the Geographos portion of the mission was uploaded and tested. On May 7, during a centroiding test, the spacecraft experienced an onboard anomaly at 13:39:432 and all telemetry data was lost from the housekeeping processor for no reason. apparent For about twenty minutes the ground controllers struggled F@UW 25 CJementine Map of the South Polar Region of the Moon to recover telemetry. [After Ref 41] When the telemetry was finally recovered it was discovered that the spacecraft was in a rapidly spinning mode (at 82 RPM) and that the attitude control fuel supply was exhausted. The sequence of command events surrounding the anomaly is shown in Table 11. After six weeks of intensive investigation the cause of the anomaly was determined42 to be in the flight software. The anomaly was caused by software in the housekeeping processor. The software defect was in an error handling code that only showed up when a) an arithmetic underflow condition occurred and b) when certain lunar software routines were present. The defect caused the housekeeping processor to become corrupted and placed its instruction counter in an indeterminate location and allowed data execution to go forward from that point. This permitted indeterminate data to be placed on the housekeeping bus which under certain conditions fired the attitude control thrusters during autonomous operations. In the asteroid encounter which was being simulated at the time, the thrusters were purposely enabled to allow for autonomous operations. II -26
II -27
Before any action is taken on a spacecraft it is first simulated on a test bed which is an identical system on the ground which is supposed to be programmed with an identical set of instructions. Unfortunately, the housekeeping processor had been undergoing some unexpected resets during the mission and one reset had occurred on May 4. The spacecraft operators had been trying to discover the source of these resets. In doing so they had decided not to include two software patches in the spacecraft computer configuration. When they later loaded the centroiding program they inadvertently also left out three other patches. It was discovered later that none of these patches was present in the spacecraft computer, but they were present in the ground-based operations test bed, violating the assumption of identical In the dry run on the test bed which was carried out before software configurations. attempting the asteroid encounter simulation, the test bed (with the patches loaded) did not fire the thrusters and hence gave no warning of what was about to occur on the spacecraft. In later simulations without the Datches loaded it was seen that under certain conditions the test bed also gave the order to fire the thrusters. The Clementine example just discussed illustrates just how complex some spacecraft software anomalies can be. It only occurred under circumstances in which a latent defect in the program was permitted to take an unintended action because some other program which would protect the spacecraft was not in place. Under luckier circumstances, the program would have been ground-tested without the patches in place and would have shown that the thrusters could fire under these conditions. After investigation, the defect would have been removed or it would have then been required to check the spacecraft computer configuration for the patches before initiation of the asteroid fly-by simulation. Alternately, if the patches had been loaded in the spacecraft processor, the thrusters would not have fired and the defect in the code may never have been discovered. It is also possible that if the Program had had more time than 22 months, the program defect might have been discovered and corrected before launch. 5.0 LEARNING
FROM ANOMALIES
5.1 ANOMALIES
CAN LEAD TO NEW UNDERSTANDING
The history of the observation of anomalies in space systems began shortly after Sputnik I was launched on October 4, 1957. The first successful U.S. spacecraft was Explorer I, launched on January 31, 1958. A Geiger counter experiment put on board by J. A. Van Allen~ suddenly stopped counting. This anomalous behavior was investigated and it was found that the reason that the Geiger counter stopped counting was that it was, in fact, saturated by an extremely high count rate (much higher than had been expected) Van Allen concluded that the high count rate was caused by a very large number of charged particles trapped in the Earth’s radiation belts. Resolution of this anomaly led to the discovery of the earth’s radiation belts (now called the Van Allen belts). Anomalies which are carefully investigated can result in new discoveries such as the Earth’s radiation belts or in new radiation effects or damage mechanisms. 5.2 PREVENTING
SOFTWARE ANOMALIES
Preventing software anomalies is, almost by definition, very dif!lcult since they are unexpected. One way is to thoroughly check out the software. By repeatedly running the 11-28
program under a variety of conditions, potential defects can be discovered through ground simulation before launch. Even if a software defect escapes detection before launch, it can be found using the ground simulator which is kept in the same configuration as the space computer. If an anomaly is discovered in this way, it can be corrected before an action which makes use of the command containing the defect is taken by the spacecraft computer. The defect can even be discovered after activating the code, provided the action inadvertently taken by the spacecraft computer is not catastrophic. Software fixes can then be uploaded to prevent future recurrences. Even if a spacecraft is damaged or lost due to a software error, there is still a reason for investigating it thoroughly so that it can be corrected in other versions of the same or similar spacecraft or in the next generation of the spacecraft. 5.3 PUBLISHING
ANOMALY
ANALYSES
All spacecraft anomalies are taken very seriously because of their potential for producing a disaster. If the result of a spacecraft anomaly is not very visible however, e. g. if a device just upsets and can be recovered without a problem, the incident is likely to be examined briefly and noted in the log book (including the necessary corrective action), then forgotten. It is only when a spacecraft is lost, nearly lost, or if its status remains uncertain for an extended period of time that a Tiger Team is called in to trouble shoot the problem or a Board is convened to discover the cause. Very few anomalies or anomaly analyses will ever be published. There are several reasons for this. In most cases the cause is not found or pinned down completely. Many anomalies are unique to the particular spacecraft and reporting them through publication would not be useful to anyone other than the spacecraft operators. In addition most SPOS are not prone to publishing their errors or problems. In many ways it would be better if more anomalies were resolved and the results published. These anomalies could then be compiled and the probabilities of each type of anomaly could then be assessed for guidance to future spacecraft designers. 6.0 FUTURE TRENDS 6.1 NEW TYPES OF MILITARY
SPACE SYSTEMS
Future military space systems are facing an unusual opportunity now. With the decline of the cold war, the radiation hardness levels required for military systems are being dramatically reduced. At the same time, the Mid-east War has demonstrated the substantial advantages of space based communication, navigation and surveillance systems, and has also greatly increased performance requirements on such systems. For example, as shown in Table 12, before Desert Storm in the cold war era, there was little tactical use of space. Surveillance satellites were used primarily for intelligence purposes and so a slow revisit time of a few days or even weeks was considered quite acceptable as long as the pictures were of high quality and long term tendencies in the Soviet Union’s development of new weapons or facilities were detected in a timely manner. These satellite systems had large area coverage at low or moderate resolution and could make use of small area coverage at high resolution if a target was found to be of high interest. They also transferred their data to other satellites or to the ground at relatively low data rates. Communication among U.S. strategic assets and with the Navy’s fleet was handled primarily through the use of survivable geosynchronous communication satellite systems such as II -29
FLEETSATCOM, DSCS II and III, UHF FOLLOW-ON, and MILSTAR The Global Positioning System (GPS) was nearing completion and was operational, but its tremendous advantages for self location by ground troops was not fully realized and small, cheap, hand sets were not very available. The satellite systems built in this era were very large, heavy, capable, billion dollar systems. II -30
After Desert Storm, the military has become highly dependent on GPS for location and tracking of troops and equipment and for other uses as well. Space surveillance is now needed for tactical purposes (such as locating SCUDS), therefore high resolution coverage of large areas (such as entire battlefields) is desired and Field Commanders want continuous, rather than intermittent, coverage which in practice means very fast revisit times. In addition, we now expect to interface our satellite systems directly with our ground and sea weapons systems in real time. For example in overcoming the SCUD problem, we wanted to detect the (hidden) SCUDS or spot them on the launch pad, detect their launch, track them, determine their trajectory at a ground-based computer in the United States, and communicate with a missile launcher on the battle field, supplying proper coordinates in time to launch a Patriot missile to intercept and destroy them. The whole process could take no more than a few minutes. According to most reports that didn’t work very well, in general, but it did work at least in part, sometimes! Now it will be expected to work correctly, all the time. MILSTAR has recently demonstrated a successful crosslink between satellites. This technology will also be used more in the future. With the changes in the political and military landscape of Europe (including Bosnia), the dissolution of the Soviet Union, and the development of new and changing alliances, there will be demands for increased flexibility in future military space systems. The prospect of shrinking defense budgets assures that the solutions must be cost effective. In this environment of reduced threats and budgets, but enhanced demand for increased capabilities, higher data rates, better coverage, and more flexibility, there will be a great deal of pressure on the military to develop an entirely new generation of more capable, but cheaper, satellite systems. Furthermore, the reduced budgets and new policies on procurement of commercial parts whenever possible may require that the future systems be developed with commercial microelectronics and maybe using some, or even all, commercial spacecraft. This new generation of satellite systems will almost surely not be as large or as heavy, or as expensive as present systems, but it will have to be more capable and flexible. 6.2 PROJECTED SPACECRAFT
INCREASES
IN NUMBERS
AND
TYPES
OF COMMERCIAL
During the last several years, there has been an explosion in interest in commercial satellite systems. They have been proposed for world-wide cellular telephones, data transmission, faxing, direct broadcast television, movies and video conferencing as shown in Table 13. The projected investment in these new satellite systems is truly phenomenal, and the companies involved propose to build well more than 1000 spacecraft in the next ten years. The largest proposed system is that of Teledesic with 840 satellites plus spares for a total of nearly 1000 satellites in that one system alone. The cost of this system is projected at $9 B. Teledesic and other commercial communication satellite systems are shown in Table 14. The five systems described above in Table 14. are by no means the complete complement of proposed systems; there are at least 10-15 more that regularly are reported in newspapers. It is doubtful that all of these satellite systems will be able to obtain funding, FCC licenses, and be built. The five shown above are the larger cellular telephone satellites and are in general more likely to be developed than some others. As illustrated above, world-wide cellular telephone systems require very large numbers of spacecraft to provide global coverage and hence they require very large investments. There are certain trade-offs which are critical 11-31
,,
II -32
,
to the design of the system. The lower the orbit the smaller the ground antenna and the lower the power required for good signal strength. For hand held personal communications this is a critical need. Unfortunately, the lower the orbit, the larger the number of satellites required to obtain adequate coverage and the expense of the system goes up. To reduce the number of satellites, a designer must raise the orbit and this means larger antennas and more powerful transmitters. This type of system is more suitable for large, fixed ground stations. Of course as the orbits rise up into the intense radiation belts, the radiation-induced anomalies will increase too. There are other classes of commercial satellites including navigation, meteorological and remote imaging spacecraf~ The direct broadcast television system, which recently became operational is a satellite system designed to compete with cable TV. These commercial space systems are, in general, substantially smaller and lighter than military systems, but are remarkably capable. Not all of these systems will be economically viable and some of them will not be completed, but in the long run, competition for business will determine which ones succeed and which ones fail. This intense competition will generate strong pressure to use the latest state of the art devices in new systems to gain increased capability, but it will also require using devices which are sufficiently hard to survive in the orbits in which the spacecraft operate. Note that some of the systems shown in Table 14 operate in very severe orbits from a radiation standpoint. Any commercial space systems which develop a large number of anomalies will have serious problems if the anomalies cannot be resolved quickly and without significant impact on their users. Future commercial users will be even less understanding about anomalies, downtimes, and failures than present military and NASA users are. 6.3 SPACE EXPERIMENTS
TO GET HIGH TECH TO SPACE IN RECORD TIME
In the current design and construction of space systems, it is typical for it to require five to seven years from the time that the technology of choice is frozen until the spacecraft is actually launched. As shownain Figure 26, the devices must be chosen early in the program in order to provide time to order the devices, radiation test them, build an engineering model, build a flight qualified model, build a flight model, perform flight qualification testing, integrate the subsystem into the spacecraft, and launch it. The lead time gets even worse if there is a delay in launching the satellite. Satellite systems would benefit greatly if we could find a way to reduce the amount of time between the technology freeze date and the start of actual satellite operations. The use of smaller, less complex, less costly satellite systems will help reduce these times somewhat. There is a tremendous advantage of using the latest state of the art devices in space systems. These devices may represent breakthroughs in technology which can increase performance by several orders of magnitude, or they maybe just the latest device which has a factor of two or less gain in performance. In either case, there is a strong reason to try to get the devices or technology into space as rapidly as possible. There is only one small problem; namely, space System Project Offices (SPO’S) have been badly burned in the past by using new technologies in which the new vulnerabilities were not fully understood. This has a tendency to make them very sensitive to new technologies and to make them reluctant (with good reason) to rapidly introduce new technologies into their systems if they have not been For small changes, such as the newest generation of previously flight qualified. II -33
F~re
26 Typical Times Required to Build Space Hardware
[After Fox, Ref 44]
microelectronics, the problem is rather easily solvable. Thorough testing of the new devices at ground-based radiation facilities is generally suftlcient. The rest of the space qualification occurs as a part of qualification testing for the system. For the breakthroughs in technology, however, it is an entirely different matter; flight qualification is essential. The problem is, of course, how does a new technology get space qualified if no one is willing to fly it first? The only viable answer for the future, in my opinion, is to fly the newest technology in space experiments. In the future, space experiments will be used to demonstrate the performance gains of the new technology, and to show that they do not have any radiation effects or anomaly show stoppers. In this way we can get our latest generation of new devices and technologies into space in the most rapid time possible and increase the performance (and 11-34
reduce costs) of our next generation of space systems. In a properly designed space experiment, devices can be operating in space for the first time about one year after their initial acquisition. Before spacecraft System Program OffIces (SPOS) would be comfortable flying new technologies, the risk of using such technologies will have to be reduced. To reduce risk will require space testing of the modern generation of devices (sub-micron feature size) with concurrent more accurate ground testing and modelling programs and the development of prediction methods which more accurately predict the on-orbit performance of sub-micron devices. Better models are, of course, also needed for each significant change in technology It will also require better measurements of the space environment which occurs. simultaneously with measurement of space upset rates to reduce uncertainties. By using more accurate tests, models and environments we can reduce the over-all uncertainty associated with these new devices or technologies and therefore reduce the safety factors required for assurance of space system survivability and operability with a minimum of anomalies. If the uncertainties in predictions of radiation effects can be reduced, then spacecraft can be safely flown with much smaller safety margins. This will permit more modern devices to be flown. Carefully designed space experiments can make it possible for the next generation of space systems to have significant increases in performance, while maintaining the same reliability and operability. 6.4 NEW TECHNOLOGIES
AND RADIATION
EFFECTS CHALLENGES
When considering what the new technologies for space are going to be, it is never a good bet to bet against silicon. Silicon has run up against limit after limit and the Gurus have predicted it would lose out to a new technology only to see it overcome this new hurdle and out-perform its rival. It is a safe bet to say that for the foreseeable future silicon will be the technology of choice for the great bulk of the applications as shown in Table 15. There is a new emphasis on developing very large silicon solid state memories to replace less capable and less reliable tape units in spacecraft. These new solid state memories are like a loaf of bread made up of many slices. Each slice, however, is the latest state of the art memory unit available, currently a 16 Mbit or 64 Mbit Dynamic Random Access Memog (DRAM). There may be as many as 50-100 slices to produce multi-gigabit memory units. These large memories are extremely capable, but they are also very vulnerable to total dose, SEE, and probably to future anomalies. Large RAM’s, gate arrays, application specific integrated circuits (ASIC’S), and other logic circuits are the most used digital parts in space systems today. Gate arrays are finding a multitude of new uses in space. It appears likely that in the future we will have a very large number of new, high technology space systems. The effects of new technologies on new military and NASA space systems can already be seen. There is a shift from copper wired spacecraft with very large, heavy and expensive cable harnesses to a new generation of spacecraft which use Fiber Optic Data Busses (FODB) in place of wires as shown in Table 16. This can provide data transfer systems which are not only much lighter and less expensive, but also much higher speed (up to a few gigabits now) and more flexible. These new FODB’S will also contribute greatly to the ease of assembly of new spacecraft. The various spacecraft subsystems can be connected much more easily with fiber optic connections, rather than the more expensive and complex wiring harnesses. Furthermore, the wiring harnesses have to be soldered into place and if any II -35
connections need to be changed, it is very difllcult to make those reconnection, whereas, with a FODB system, recoupling is easy. It is expected that spacecraft will be able to be assembled in a matter of days rather than weeks, using the fiber optic technology. A typical ring data bus is i11ustrated4Sin Figure 27. The shift toward the use of fiber optic devices in space and toward faster subsystems and higher data rates has forced us to move from slower silicon devices to faster GaAs devices and very recently to even faster InP devices. Such moves can have large consequences from
II -36
the standpoint of vulnerability to SEE phenomena, total dose effects, and the occurrence of spacecraft anomalies. For example, GaAs has been shown to be somewhat less sensitive than silicon to total dose effects, but extremely sensitive to SEE. A new technique for growing GaAs at low temperatures (LT GaAs) has recently been shown to produce GaAs devices which have many orders of magnitude lower SEU cross sections~. A buffer layer is first grown at low temperatures of a few hundred degrees C, then annealed at higher temperature forming arsenic precipitates. These form charge trapping and recombination centers which do not allow any charge which may be deposited in the device to be collected thus providing a reduced SEU cross section. As illustrated in Table 17, these LT GaAs devices have the advantage of high speed performance, less sensitivity to backdating, Figure 27 TRW_HONEYWELL FODB Ring and low SEU cross sections similar to those [After Dale, Ref 45] of silicon devices. Figure 28 illustrates47 the reduction in sensitivity of LT GaAs over regular GaAs. The standard GaAs cross section is shown for a 336 stage shift register as a function of LET. When the same tests were made for an identical device with a LT GaAs buffer layer, no upsets were observed up to an LET of 90!
-d
‘!jijbk?. FODBRing
lnP has great potential for use in space. It is useful both as solar cells and as high speed devices. Its characteristics are shown in Table 18. Figure 29 showsa the radiation response of a selection of silicon, GaAs and InP solar cells. The beginning of life etllciency of both GaAs and InP are comparable and both have higher etliciency than silicon. Notice how much flatter the InP curves are than the silicon or GaAs curves. InP on silicon is not as well developed as InP on InP so its beginning of life efllciency is not as high but it is a much better material and much less expensive. InP has the potential to be a technology enabling technology because it II -37
HONE~LL G NQ 5
v ‘0-6
~
10-’
[+”’0
o
~ *= dl
“m
v
E 0 v
v
v C-12
98
MeV
FI-19 130 MoV Cl-35 209 MoV NI-58 260 M@V 1-127 320 MeV
10-8
1?
IJJ .* m
GaAs SEIUAL
m
8
9
10-5
~ 8 8 d
336 STAGE STANDA~ SHIFT REGISTERS
100
10”9
0
Serial
Mbps
m 40
m 20 LET
Data
Rata 1 60
9 80
100
(Me V*cm2/mg)
NO UPSETS OBSERVED ON DEVICES WITH LT BUFFER LAYERS UP TO AN LET OF 90
Figure 28 Reduction in Sensitivity in LTGaAs Shift Registers Compared to GaAs Devices [After Marshall, Ref 47] can be operated anywhere in the Earth’s radiation belts. This will permit satellites to be launched ‘much more-cheaply into a LEO orbit, then powered by low thrust thrusters to reach a geosynchronous orbit in weeks or even months and yet still have excellent solar power when they get there. InP is also a useful material for use in devices with its low SEU cross section, total dose insensitivity, and its very high speed performance; its only problem right now is that it is not easy to produce and package. InP is even less sensitive to total dose effects, and has been recently shown to be very insensitive to SEU49 as well. Figure 30 shows the cross section as a function of proton energy for an InP data sequence generator chip compared to unhardened GaAs. As the speed of a device increases its upset cross section also increases as shown in the II -38
figure for GaAs. The GaAs operates at 400 M bps, whereas the InP device operates at 13 G bps and yet has a SEU cross section three orders of magnitude lower.
Radiation Response of lnP/lnP lnP/Si, GaAslGe, and Si Solar Cells .
-20 $
AMO
c 6.5 USE OF COTS IN FUTURE SPACECRAFT
.{) .; w 10 c o -
In June 1994 Defense Secretary William ● InP/inP Perry issued a directive to . lnP/Si (2x4 cm2, Spire, 1995) t! military to use COTS a?s - ■ G~Ge parts in military systems (Solar Cell Radiation Handbook Addendum) c whenever possible. v Csi Regardless of the 6 (Solar Cell Radiation Handbook) , u directive, it is becoming a :.,2’ “’’;.,3’ “’1’014’ “’1 0,6’ 10’6 10’7 diftlcult problem to build spacecraft because of the 1 MeV Electron Fluence (cm-2) lack of hardened parts. .,. Military, NASA, and commercial spacecraft Figure 29 Radiation Response of InP Solar Cells Compared to builders may be forced to Silicon and GaAs Cells [After Walters, Ref 48] use COTS, even if they don’t want to, in future space systems. However, use of COTS in space systems contains significant risk. Let us examine the use of COTS parts in future space systems. ●
The advantages of using COTS devices in future space systems are shown in Table 19. The primary reason for wanting to use COTS devices is that they are state of the art devices,
II -39
whereas rad hard devices are hardened several years later than the same COTS device and hence Hughes lnP\ Proton Upset Test Results use several year old This means technology. I 1 1 1 10-9 that COTS devices are an Hughes 13 Gbps’ lnP ve. Unhardened Motorola GaAs ! order of magnitude more capable than rad hard devices. The choice is between a COTS Pentium or a rad hard 286-386 The microprocessor. choice is between a 64 M bit DRAM or a 1 M bit ,o-f4~ In addition, SR4M. 70 10 are COTS devices less substantially Proton Energy (Mev) expensive than rad hard devices. The worst case difference in price which I have encountered is for an RH 3000 which we wanted to buy for a space Figure 3(J Cross Section vs Proton Energy for InP Sequence The experiment. Generator Chip Compared to GaAs [After Marshall, Ref 49] microprocessor plus four or five glue chips would alone was $17 K and there was a lon~ and have cost nearly $100 K. The micromocessor . uncertain delivery time. We chose a less capable rad hard 3081 microprocessor, but in the 1
H -40
I
I
1
1
1
right orbit, we could have purchased a 64 bit IDT 4650 microprocessor for a few $ K, and had a more capable device. Commercial software is often much more available for COTS devices than for rad hard devices. Software development is a very costly part of building space systems today and is growing rapidly in complexity. If rad hard devices are not identical to an earlier version of a commercial device, then space system designers will have to develop much, if not all of the software for it. This is both expensive and time consuming. In addition, non-commercial software must be checked extra carefully for any errors and for its response to unexpected situations. It could become a prime candidate fo-rlater spacecraft anomalies. The U. S. rad hard electronics market was < 0.4°/0 of the commercial market and is shrinking rapidly. In 1991, there more were than 20 manufacturers of rad hard devices. Now, it is hard to count more than three or four (see Figure 31). The reasons why rad hard manufacturers are going out of business (or have gone) are illustrated in Table 20. The Cold War is over. Large and costly strategic systems such as nuclear missiles and radiation hardened satellite systems are going to be built in much fewer numbers. This leads to a perceived loss of future in the field and so it does not encourage investment in the area. Secondly, because of increases in commercial electronics orders (including those destined for commercial
CURRENT UNITED STATES RADIATION-HARDENED DEVICE SUPPLIERS ● ●
Honaywell Natkrlal
●
Loral
●
UTMC
DEVICE SUPPLIERS WHO NO LONGER SUPPORT THE RAD-HARD MARKET LSI ● TI
●
● ● ● ● ●
TRw Rockwell Im GE (RCA) sandia
● ●
Hughaa Raythaon
●
Martin-Marbtta
●
McDonnalkDougka
●
Motorola
● ●
Ford Mlcroekotronks AT&T
F@re 31 Current Radiation Hard Device Suppliers vs Suppliers in 1991
II -41
,.
,
space systems), the demand for commercial devices is beyond the current manufacturing capability. In addition, the commercial market is more profitable. When a company has unfulfilled orders for a high profit item and very few orders for a low profit item, it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to predict their course of action. Finally, equipment for each new generation of devices is becoming more expensive. A major change in device technology may cost up to $1 B or more for new equipment. Device manufacturers have to make these large investments every few years. Such an investment is not made lightly. In this environment, a large investment would certainly not be made for what could be perceived as a niche market. We have outlined the reasons for wanting to use COTS devices in future space systems, but there are many reasons why it will be difficult to use COTS devices in space. Some of the reasons are shown in Table 21. Survivability in even the natural space environment would now be ditllcult with many COTS devices, some of which are harder than 100 Krads and some of which are softer than 10 Krads. Of course, it depends on the orbit, and requirements for a system may vary from 10-20 Krads to 100 Krads or more. Many COTS devices are soft now, and advanced devices will be softer. In addition, COTS hardness varies somewhat making COTS hardness assurance an important new research area. Furthermore, while the reliability of COTS devices used in normal environments is no problem, their reliability in stressing environments (radiation, thermal, vibration, etc.) is uncertain. SPO’S will need to perform a large amount of measurements and testing to gain confidence in the space reliability of COTS devices in stressing environments. In order to be able to use COTS devices in future satellite systems, SPOS will need to buy them in large lots, possibly directly from the manufacturer, test them for radiation and other stresses, and place them in bonded storage until used (effectively space qualify the devices).
TABLE
21.
COTS
IIISAI)VANTAGES
Survivability In Many Desirable Orbits is Difficult Using Some COTS Devices, Other COTS Devices Will Survive in Most Orbits Many COTS Devices Fail Now at 10-50 Krads - Advanced Devices Will Be Softer Cots Hardness Is Not Controlfed and Varies Widely Reliability Of COTS Devices In Stressing Environments
Is Uncertain
COTS Devices Will Need To Be Tested And Placed Into Bonded Storage Cots Devices Will Have To Be Space Qualified There Is A New Generation Of COTS Devices Every 6-18 Months Safetv Factors Currentlv Used Are Too 13i@hfor Manv COTS
~evices
Another problem which will have to be faced is that COTS devices change rapidly; there is a new generation every 6-18 months, and small changes are made more often than that. This is both good and bad news. The good news is how rapidly a new device becomes available which is faster, more capable, or lower power. The bad news is that if you need a few II -42
more devices, after you have built the system, you may not be able to buy them because they are obsolete. Finally, the large safety factors often used in satellite systems are frequently too big for using COTS devices. For one space system we are working on, in the early 1980’s we somewhat arbitrarily set a specification of 100 Krads. We did this because it was not very difficult to get 100 K rad parts, and they were safe to use. Gradually we began getting more and more exceptions to the specification. We have recently reexamined the specification and now sometimes use 30 K rad parts and sometimes even less. Our on-orbit dosimeters show an expected dose of about 10 Krads in the spacecraft lifetime This safety factor has been reduced over the years and having an on-orbit dosimeter has certainly helped us to make that decision. We still buy 100 K rad parts whenever they are available. Any satellite system that plans to use COTS devices will have to depend on smaller safety factors; safety factors of ten will become increasingly diftlcult to obtain. 6.6 TESTING,
HARDNESS
ASSURANCE
AND SHIELDING
A space program which plans to use COTS devices has several alternatives for implementing radiation survivability. (It must be said at the outset that the thinking for implementing such a program has not been completed yet). First as shown in Table 22, an extensive testing program must be planned and implemented. It will be necessary to test a larger number of COTS devices to get a selection of devices which is suitable for use in a space program. It will be necessary to test devices from several manufacturers. It will also be necessary to invest in large lot buys of the devices so that if a device tests out well, or if the device manufacturer makes a change in the device there will be sutlicient devices for the space system. Poor lots will have to be used in breadboards, engineering development models, flight In many cases use of shielding will be qualified models, ground systems or discarded. required. If the system requirement is 50 Krads and only 25 K rad devices are available, then shielding is perhaps an optimal solution. Shielding is much cheaper than redesign. If only a
TABLE
EXTENSIVE
22.
USE OF COTS IN SPACE SYSTEMS
TESTING PROGRAM
REQUIRED
LOT BUYS SHIELDING ON-ORBIT UN-POWERED
SPARES
LATCHUP SCREENS EDC OR TMR MAY BE REQUIRED MUST DEVELOP NEW TECHNIQUES
FOR HARDENING
II -43
CRITICAL DEVICES
small number of devices with insutlicient hardness are to be used, then spot shielding is the preferred option. If a large number of devices with insufficient hardness are to be used in the system, then box shielding is likely to be more effective. The tendency toward building smaller, monopurpose spacecraft such as proposed by NASA may acerbate this problem. A possible solution which has not yet been proven, but which may be employed in future systems, is the use of on-orbi~ unpowered spares. To the extent that unpowered devices damage much less in a radiation environment, it may be possible to fly a small number of devices, e.g. two to four, in place of one very sensitive device. As the device damages a new, previously unpowered, device is switched in as a replacement. This would be a high risk procedure at present and the concept must be tested in a space experiment before it could be implemented in an operational space system. It may also be necessary to use a small number of devices for which none of the above approaches will work For example if the devices contemplated for the system have a measurable Single Event Latchup (SEL) cross section, most SPOS would not permit their use in their system. A device with a high SEU cross section or a very low total dose tolerance could also result in the proscription of its use. Alternatives such as Error Detection and Correction (EDC) codes or Triple Modular Redundancy (TMR) could certainly be used to help reduce the SEU problem in many cases, but at a cost of system efficiency. There would almost certainly remain a number of devices for which the above solutions would not work but yet were necessary to operate the system. In order to use these devices the SPO would have to harden them to total dose, SEU, and SEL. 6.7 USE OF PLASTIC PARTS At present many SPOS are being forced to consider the use of parts in plastic packaging because so many commercial parts come that way. There is still the feeling that these plastic parts still have lower reliability. Table 23 shows some of the considerations involved in making a decision to use plastic parts. There is currently a large disagreement among SPOS about the use of parts in plastic packages in their space systems. Some SPOS say they would redesign the whole system rather than use a plastic part. Others say that in the future they may have no choice but to use plastic parts because of the unavailability of parts in space qualified packaging. In the past parts in plastic packaging have not been as reliable as parts in ceramic or metal containers. There are some indications that this is changing, but the question is will they be reliable in stressing environments such as space with high radiation levels, a wide temperature range, high vibrational levels, etc.? This information simply is not known at present. Furthermore a new problem has recently surfaced. Devices have been shownW to exhibit different behavior in a radiation environment after burn-in than they do if they are not burned-in as shown hJ Figure 32. For devices in ceramic or metal packaging the problem is small, but for devices in plastic packaging, the problem appears critical. The flight qualified parts must be treated in exactly the same manner as the parts which will be flown. 6.8 NEW TECHNOLOGIES
AND NEW EFFECTS IN FUTURE SYSTEMS
Whenever new technologies are introduced into a new radiation environment such as space, new effects and anomalies are discovered. Furthermore, as shown in Table 24, the II -44
advances in technology in recent years has resulted in devices which have: (1) smaller feature sizes; (2) faster operation; (3) lower voltage and lower All of these power. desirable goals lead to devices which are more vulnerable to the effects of radiation. Smaller feature size means less capacitance, for example, and hence information is stored with less charge. Faster operation means that a decision that a zero or a one should be stored is made with less charge for the same current. Use of lower voltage or lower power devices means that less charge or energy is required to store
Cilii9
ICCJ-IMax vs. Dose/AnrIealfor Four Groups at High Dose Rate
Ckm
_Maxbnum
ICCHSrIK
+mE-oa 1.DOE44
1.00E48
1-* imlE-09 low-n 1.WE.11
PmRad
m Oow
(1%
180
Ambd
Figure 32 Difference in Behavior of Devices in a Radiation Environment Before and After Bum-in [After Clark, Ref 50]
II -45
,.
information. In each casq the information is stored using a smaller number of electrons. Each of these effects makes the device more vulnerable to radiation and means that small effects which were once negligible such as a cosmic ray or a proton passing through the devices are now much more likely to produce upset or damage. In the future this can only get worse. In this environment military, NASA, and commercial spacecraft builders will have to find costeffective ways of using devices which have become more vulnerable while at the same time controlling the effects of radiation-produced anomalies, upsets, and failures. If a new, serious, radiation effects problem were to come up as a result of reduced feature sizes or new technology, for example, then it is clear that we will not have the enormous resources at our disposal that DoD put into radiation hardening in the 1970’s and 1980’s.
II -46
Suppose the trends that we have been discussing come into practice in the near future. be? This question is addressed in Table 25, The device changes What will the consequences listed seem unavoidabk The technology changes and implementation choices are options for the SPO to decide, although he may ultimately have little choice about COTS or plastic packaging
use.
If the changes shown in Table 25 occur then there are going to be consequences which rmult direct4y from these changes. These projected consequence are shown in Table 26. Most of the changes will result in an increase in the number of anomalies and effects which have been hidden by the use of large safety factors will begin to show up, such as dose rate effects. One should not be unduly alarmed by the consequences listed in Table 26. Introduction of changes into new space systems is a self limiting process. If SPOS begin to get in trouble, they will become more consemative and introduce fewer changes. If they introduce a large number of these changes and still do not have insurmountable problems, they will end up with very flexible, high performance systems. The radiation effects community needs to provide them with a variety of good alternatives.
TABLE
26.
PROJECTED
PROBLEMS
FOR
FUTURE
SPACE
SYSTEMS
I
ACTION
CONSEQUENCE INCREASE
DEVICE
IN SINGLE
EVENT EFFECT$
MORE TOTAL DOSE EFFECTS
CHANGES
MORE DISPMCEMENT DEVICE AND TECHNOLOGY CHANGES
DAMAGE
I INCREASE IN ANOMALIES
I NEW
TYPES OF ANOMALIES
R4DIATION HARD DEVICE AVAHABILITY CHANGES
INCREASE IN ALL RADIATION INDUCED ANOMALIES AND FAILURES
IMPLEMENTATION
TNCREA$E IN ANOMALIES
CHOICES
I DOSE RATE EFFECTS APPEAR
7.0
CONCLUSIONS
AND SUMMARY
The first part of the paper has discussed the various effects which can produce anomalies in space systems concentrating on radiation-induced anomalies. The types of radiation-induced anomali~ discussed were ESD-surface and deep dielectric, SEE, total dose, and displacement damage effects. Other non radiation-induced anomalies were also discussed including operator error, mechanical malfunction, and software errors. The impact that anomalies can have on a space system has been illustrated with a number of examples. The II -47
causes of the anomalies are always important, but are usually very difficult to pin down. There are a number of clues to the causes such as the description and time of the anomaly, orbit, position in orbit, radiation environment and the previous anomalies observed on the spacecraft (or in similar spacecraft). Space environment data provides very valuable clues as to the causes particularly if a solar flare is present at the time or if the spacecraft is in an intense part of the radiation belts when the anomaly occurs or if the spacecraft is in a geosynchronous orbit and the anomalies occur predominately at a specific local time range. The Mars Observer and Clementine anomalies were discussed in some detail to illustrate how a Failure Review Board works and how many possible causes there can be for a complex anomaly. The second part of the paper discussed the new types of military, NASA, and other space systems which are being built or are in the planning stages. The use of new technology was described and the use of COTS and devices in plastic packages was discussed. The impact of the use of new technologies and devicm was also described.
II -48
8.0 REFERENCES
1.
Webster’s New Unive~l Unabridged Dictionary, and Schuster, New York, New York, p 75, 1983
2.
E. G. Stassinopoulos,
3.
D. M. Sawyer and J. I. Vette, “AP-8 Tnapped Proton Environment for Solar Maximum and Solar Minimum,” NSSDC/WDC-A-R&S 7(X)6, GSFC, Greenbelt, MD, (Dee 1976).
4.
M. J. Teague, K. W. Chan and J. I. Vette, “AE:6, A Model Environment of Trapped Electrons for Solar Maximum, ” NSSDC/WDC-A-R&S 76-04, GSFC, Greenbelt, MD, (May 1976) and G. W. Singley and J. I. Vette, “The AE-4 Model of the Outer Radiation Zone Electron Environment, HNSSDC 72-06, GSFC Greenbelt, MD, (August 1972). E. G. Stassinopoulos,
Second Edition,
Sirnon
NASA Goddard SFC, Private Communication,
NASA Goddard SFC, Private Communication,
1978.
1984.
J. H. Adams Jr., R. Silberberg, and C. H. Tsao, “Cosmic Ray Effects on Microelectronics, Part I: The Near Earth Particle Environment, ” NRL Nlemorandum Report 4506, (1981). 7.
J. H. Adams Jr. and A. Gelman, “ The Effects of Solar Flar~ on Single Event Upset Rates”, IEEE Tnm.s. Nut. Sci., NS-31, 1212, (1984).
8.
J. H. Adams Jr. and A. Gehnan, HThe Effects of Solar Flares on Single Event Upset Rat~”, IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS-31, 1212, (1984).
9.
J. H. Allen and D. C. Wilkinson, “Solar-Terrestrial Activity Affecting Systems in Space and on Earth” PUblished in So lar-Terrestrial R-e clicticmsIV Proceedings, Vol 1, pp 75-107.
10.
J. H. Allen and D. C. Wilkinson, ‘Solar-Terrdrial Activity Affecting Systems in Space and on Earthn Pub lished in Solar-Terrestrial PredictionslV Proceed imzs, Vol 1, pp 75-107.
11.
J. H. Allen and D. C. Wilkinson, ‘Solar-Terre&rial Activity Affecting Systems in Space and on Earth” PUblishe(l in So lar-Terr@rial PreclictionsIV Proceedin~s, Vol 1, pp 75-107.
12.
D. A. hlcphe~on and D. R. Schober, “Spacecraft Charging at High Altitudes: The SCATHA Satellite Program, ” presented at the AIAA 13th Aerospace Scienc= Meeting, Pasadena, CA, January 20-22, 1975.
13.
D. A. McPhemon and D. R. Schober, “Spacecraft Charging at High Altitudes: The SCATHA Satellite Program, ” presented at the AIAA 13th Aerospace Scienc~ Meeting, Pasadena, CA, January 20-22, 1975. II -49
14.
S. E. DeForest, “Spacecraft charging at synchronous Gecm hysical Resea rch, Vol. 77, 651 (1972)
15.
M. D. Violet and A. R. Fredrickson, “Spacecraft anomali= on the CRRES Satellite Correlated With the Environment and Insulator Samples”, IEEE Tnm.s. Nut. Sci.,NS-40, Dec. 1993
16.
C. E. McIllwain, “Coordinates for Mapping the Distribution of Magnetically Tmpped Particles”J. Geophys. Res., Vol 66, p 3681, (1%1).
17.
J. T. Wallmark and S. M. Marcus, “Minimum Size and maximum Packaging Density of Nonredundant Semiconductor Devices”, Proc. IRE, ~, 286 (1962).
18.
D. Binder, E. C,. Smith, and A. B. Hohnan, “Satellite Anomalies From Galactic Cosmic Rays, ” IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS-22, 2675 (1975).
19.
T. C. Nlay and M. H. Woods, “Alpha Particle Induced Soft Errors in Dynamic Memories, ” IEEE Trans. Elec. DeV. ED-26, 2 (1979).
20.
J. C. Pickel and J. T. Blandford, “Cosmic Ray Induced Errors in MOS Memory Cells, n IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS-25, 1166 (1978).
21.
C. S. Guenzer, E. A. Wolicki, and R. G. Allas, “Single Event Upset of Dynamic RAMS by Neutrons and Protons, n IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS26, 5048(1979)
22.
R. C. Wyatt, P. J. McNulty, P. Toumbas, P. L. Rothwell, and R. C. F&, “Soft Errors Induced by Energetic Protons, ” IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS26, 4905(1979).
23.
J. H. Allen and D. C. Wilkinson, “Solar-Terrestrial Activity Affecting Systems in Space and on Earth” PUblished in So lar-Terrest rial PredictionslV Proceed inm, Vol 1, pp 75-107
24.
J. H. Allen and D. C. Wilkinson, “Solar-Terr@rial Activit y Affecting Systems in Space and on Earth” PUbli,shed in Solar-Terrestrial PreclicticmsIV Proceed inm, Vol 1, pp 75-107
25.
C. Barillot, 1995.
26.
C. Dyer, ‘In-Flight
27.
T. Goka, S. Kuboyama, Y. Shimano, and T. Kawaanishi, “The On-Orbit hle.asurements of Single Event Phenomena By ETS-V Spacecraft”, IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS-38, 1693 (1991).
“In Flight Observed Anomalies,
Experiments,
II -50
” RADECS
orbits, ” Journal of
RADECS 95 Short Course,
95 Short Course,
1995.
28.
T. Goka, S. Kuboyama, Y. Shimano, and T. Kmwaanishi, “The On-Orbit Measurements of Single Event Phenomena By ETS-V Spacecmift”, IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., NS-38, 1693 (1991).
29.
L. Adams, E. J. Daly, R. Harboe-Sorensen, R. NickSon, J. Haines, W. Schafer, M. Conrad, H. Griech, J. Merkel, T. Schwall, and R. Henneck, ‘A Verified Proton Induced btchup in Space”, IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci. NS-39, 1804 (1992).
30.
L. Adams, E. J. Daly, R. Harboe-Sorensen, R. Nickson, J. Haines, W. Schafer, M. Commd, H. Griech, J. Merkel, T. Schwall, and R. Henneck, “A Verfiled Proton Induced btchup in Space”, KEEE Trans. Nut. Sci. NS-39, 1804 (1992).
31.
J. S. Mayo, H. Mann, F. J. Witt, D. S. Peck, H. K. Gurnmel, and W. L. Brown, “The Command System Malfunction of the TeLstar Satellite, ” NASA SP-32, Vol. 2, June 1%3.
32.
E. Weuaas, “Spacecraft Charging Effects on Satellites Following the Starf~h Event, ” CSC Report H/3-J-280, February 1978.
33.
R. E. Fischell, “ANNA-lB Solar Cell Damage Experiment, ” Tram ril)t _ of jhe Photovoltaic Suecialists Co fere ce. April 10, 1963, Washington D.C. (Available from Defense Docu;enta;ion Center as PIC-SOL 209/3 July 1963).
34.
W. L. Brown, J. D. Gabbe and W. Rosenzweig, ‘Results Radiation Experiments”, NASA SP-32, Vol 2. June 1%3.
35.
J. H. Allen and D. C. Wilkinson, “Solar-Terrestrial Activity Affecting Systems in Space and on Earth” N blishecl in So lar-Terrestrial Predicticmsrv proceed inm, Vol 1, pp 75-107.
36.
W. J. Stapor, A. B. Campbell, J. Golba, and P. T. McDonald, “Spacecraft Anomalies and Testing: OptO-isolators”, to be published.
37.
W. J. Stapor, A. B. Campbell, J. Golba, and P. T. McDonald, “Spacecraft Anomalies and Testing: OptO-isolators”, to be published.
38.
W. J. Stapor has assisted in the analysis of this correlation. Communication.
39.
Report of the Marx Observer Mission Failure Investigation Board. A Report to the Administrator, National Aeronautics and Space Administration on the Investigation of the August 1993 mission failure of the Itlars Observer spacecraft. Submitted by the Mars Observer Mission Failure Board. 31 December 1993.
11-51
of the Telstar
Private
40.
Report of the Man Observer Mission Failure Investigation Board. A Report to the Administrator, National Aeronautics and Space Administration on the Investigation of the August 1993 mission failure of the Mars Observer spacecraft. Submitted by the Mars Observer Mission Failure Board. 31 December 1993.
41.
“A Clementine
42.
Clementine Report
43.
J. A. Van Allen and L. A. Frank, ‘Radiation Radial Distance of 107,400 km”, Nature, Vol J. A. Van Allen, C. E. Mcllwain, and G. H. Observations With Satellite 1958 Epsilon,” J. (1959).
44.
A. J. Fox, NRL, Private Communication.
45.
C. J. Dale, NRL Private Communication.
46.
C. J. Dale, NRL Private Communication.
47.
P. Marshall,
48.
R. Walters, NRL, Private Communication.
49.
P. hlarshall,
50.
S. D. Clark, J. P. Bings, M. C. Maher, M. K. Williams, D. R. Alexander and R. L. Pease, “Plastic Packaging and Burn-in Effects on Ionizing Dose Response in CMOS MicrocircuitsH, IEEE Trans. Nut. Sci., Vol 42, No. 6, (Dee, 1995).
Collection”,
Spacecraft
NRL/SFA
NRL/SFA
NRL/PU/1230-94-261,
Failure
Report,
June, 1994
June 24, 1994 (IX-aft Version) NRL
Around the Earth to a 183, p 430, (1959) and Ludwig, ‘Radiation Geophys. Res. Vol 64, p 271,
Inc. Private Communication.
Inc. Private Communication.
II -52
1996 NSREC SHORT COURSE
SECTION
III
TOTAL DOSE RESPONSE OF BIPOLAR MICROCIRCUITS
Naval Stiace
David W. Emily Warfh.re Center, Crane Division
TOTAL DOSE RESPONSE OF BIPOLAR MICROCIRCUITS
David W. Emily Crane Division Naval Surface Warfare Center
This work was supported in part by the Naval Surface Warfare Center, Crane Division, and the Defense Nuclear Agency
III-1
III-2
TOTAL
DOSE RESPONSE OF BIPOLAR
MICROCIRCUITS
David W. Emily Naval Surface Warfare Center, Crane Division Technology Development Branch 1.0
2,0 3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
Introduction Bipolar Integrated Circuits in Modern Space Systems 1.1 Historical Perspective 1.2 Fundamentals of Bipolar Transistor Operation Bipolar Transistor Structures Vertical, Lateral, and Substrate Devices 3.1 Fabrication 3.2 Circuit Implementation 3.3 Transistor Total Dose Effects 4.1 Substrate, Sidewall, and Surface Inversion Gain Degradation 4.2 Integrated Circuit Response Digital 5.1 Linear 5.2 Low-Rate Effects Introduction 5.3 Low-Rate Effects Basic Mechanisms Theories 6.1 Transistor and Circuit Response 6.2 6.2.1 Bias Effects 6.2.2 Temperature Effects 6.2.3 Anneal Effects Modeling 6.3 SEM Irradiation 6.4 Hardness Assurance Test Method Development High-Temperature Irradiation 7.1 Post-Irradiation Anneal 7.2 Overtest 7.3 Future Trends and Conclusions
1.0 INTRODUCTION This session of the short course will discuss total dose effects in bipolar devices and microcircuits. Research into total dose effects in bipolar technology has long been overshadowed by CMOS research, especially since CMOS became the dominant integrated circuit (IC) technology for digital circuits during the 1980s. However, bipolar technology has continued to play an important role in mixed-signal and analog microcircuits used in current space systems. Recently, there has been a renewed interest in bipolar total dose effects due to the discovery of a
III-3
low dose rate effect in bipolar transistors and circuits. Considerable information has been presented recently on complex time-dependent effects in numerous bipolar processes. These may cause substantially lower failure levels at low dose rates with possible serious implications for space systems employing such devices. The response of bipolar microcircuits to total ionizing dose can be complex compared to CMOS. This complex response is due to several factors. Several types of bipolar transistors, each with a different total dose response, can be present in a single circuit. Additionally, different methods of transistor fabrication by manufacturers and the sensitivity of analog and mixedsignal circuit designs to small shifts in transistor parameters all contribute to complex IC responses. This discussion will cover the spectrum of bipolar total dose effects information, from basic transistor operation to the most recent microcircuit low-rate response theories, to provide a comprehensive review of total dose effects in bipolar microcircuits. The discussion will start with an overview of the important applications that bipolar integrated circuits have in modern spacecraft power, control, and signal processing systems. A historical perspective of radiation effects in bipolar devices over the years will then be presented. The fundamental operation of the bipolar transistor will be reviewed, along with different bipolar transistor structures, fabrication techniques, and typical circuit design implementations. Next, the dominant total-dose degradation mechanisms for bipolar transistors and how they affect the response of various integrated circuit types will be discussed. This will be used to introduce the recently reported excess degradation of bipolar integrated circuits when irradiated at low dose rates. Several case studies will be presented. Potential basic mechanisms responsible for the lowrate effect will be explored. Techniques used to investigate the low-rate response and results will be presented. These include temperature, bias and anneal tests, circuit modeling, and scanning electron microscope spot irradiation. Progress in the development of a hardness assurance test method for the low-rate effect will be reviewed. This short course section will conclude with a discussion of future bipolar technology trends and the potential effect on total-dose hardness. 1.1 Bipolar Integrated Circuits in Modern Space Systems CMOS has dominated as the fabrication process for digital ICS since the 1980s. For present-day digital microcircuits, bipolar is primarily limited to niche applications such as highspeed cache memories and limited mixed-technology areas such as output drivers for highWith the continual improvement in performance BiCMOS memories and microprocessors. CMOS performance, even these niche applications are rapidly converting to entirely CMOS. Bipolar remains the dominant process for linear and mixed-signal circuits, and BiCMOS is becoming an important process for high-performance analog-to-digital converters (ADCS) and The BiCMOS processes used for ADCS are considerably other mixed-signal microcircuits. different than the digital BiCMOS processes in that they are primarily bipolar or fully integrated bipolar-CMOS processes rather than CMOS with a sub-optimum bipolar device added. Bipolar is the dominant linear process due to performance advantages of higher voltage operation and current drive capability, lower noise, better linearity, and superior device matching. Figure 1 illustrates applications for bipolar microcircuits in a typical space satellite signal processing system. Bipolar microcircuits are the primary ICS used in the modern satellite power, signal processing, and control systems. III-4
The parts lists of five current production satellite systems were reviewed to identify commonly used bipolar linear ICS [1]. This review identified 162 different high-usage bipolar part types for the five satellites. Examples of the major functions that are used include operational amplifiers, analog-to-digital converters, comparators, digital-to-analog converters, analog switches, multiplexer, voltage regulators, voltage references, and pulse width modulators. Bipolar ICS account for 40?Z0to 50?Z0of the total microcircuits used in the average satellite or strategic missile system requiring radiation-hardened components. The electrical performance and parametric degradation of bipolar linear ICS are critical in many system applications. Input bias current or offset voltage is critical for an application such as a sensor buffer amplifier. Unlike digital ICS, where parametric degradation may need to be significant before having an impact on system performance, an offset voltage shift of millivolts or input bias current increase of microamps may cause serious system performance degradation. These small parametric shifts make testing linear and mixed-signal microcircuits response challenging.
ANALOG
& MIXED
Cryo Readout Multiplexer & Signal Processing
.-. r Ocal
High Precision Op-Amps
Signal
Processing
SIGNAL
APPLICATIONS Clock &
Analog-toDigital
Timing
Con;erter
GeneraIOr
Plane A may
High-Speed lnpuUOutput Interface Buffer m
Precision voltage Reference
Cfvlos Memory & Data Processor
/ J 28 Volts In –
Signal PrOcessin~COmputer Power Converter
Figure 1:
voltage Regulator
Bipolar
Microcircuit
Usagein TypicalSatelliteSystems.
1.2 Historical Perspective of Bipolar Total Dose Effects It is interesting to review the development, over the years, of information concerning total dose effects in bipolar devices and microcircuits. The evolution of bipolar technology, especially linear processes and product, has proceeded at a slow pace when compared to CMOS. To calibrate ourselves, the first commercially available monolithic bipolar amplifier to gain wide acceptance (the 709) was first introduced 31 years ago in 1965 [2]. This was followed shortly by the LM 101A amplifier in 1968[3]. This same part, with minor changes in circuit design and fabrication process, is still being designed into current and future satellites 28 years later in 1996.
III-5
As we go through this historical overview, it is also interesting to note that many of the problems then are still problems now. Research and testing performed on devices and circuits from about 30 years ago are still very relevant to the testing and research being performed in 1996. A compendium of papers primarily from the December IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science concerning total dose effects in bipolar devices and partially used in this review is listed in Appendix A. 1967- Acceptor-Like Surface Recombination States Identified as Dominant Mechanism for NPN Transistor Gain Degradation[4] In this paper by Maier of the Naval Radiological Defense Laboratory, it was reported that, until very recently, the accumulation of positive charge has been reported as the dominant mechanism responsible for the surface effect in oxide-passivated devices. A bipolar planar npn transistor with MOS field electrodes was used to verify the existence of the positive charge effect and to introduce the existence of acceptor-like surface recombination states. The additional surface recombination states were shown to be the dominant mechanism for loss in gain. 1968- Prediction and Selection System for Radiation Effects in Planar Transistors to Identify and Eliminate “Maverick” Devices[5] In this paper by Poch and Holmes-Siedle of RCA, an irradiate-anneal test is developed to identify “maverick” transistors. During testing of many bipolar devices under Cobalt-60 gamma radiation, infrequent cases were noted where the surface damage levels exceeded those predicted. Some devices were anomalously sensitive, with damage levels falling well outside the normal statistical distribution of sensitivity. It was, thus, important to identify a method of detecting these rare, but excessively sensitive, units. These maverick devices could occur even within a production lot, all manufactured and processed in the same manner. The method developed was a 50 krad(SiOz) irradiation followed by a 250”C bake for 16 hours to return the transistor parameters to approximately pre-radiation value. The devices behaved the same on a subsequent irradiation; thus, the irradiation-anneal was a stressing method for pre-selection. 1970- Radiation-Insensitive
Silicon Oxynitride Films for Use in Silicon Devices [6]
A silicon oxynitride film deposited on the surface of a planar npn transistor and then annealed in hydrogen was shown to improve the total dose hardness by up to 30 times in this paper by Schmidt and Ashner of Bell Telephone Laboratories. 1970- Selective Irradiation to Identify Sensitive Junctions, Hardening by Elevated Temperature Irradiation and Eff:cts of Plastic Packaging on Total Dose Hardness[7] A number of topics are discussed in this paper by Bauerlein of Siemens AG Research Laboratories. Selective irradiation of npn and pnp planar bipolar transistors was performed with a narrow electron beam to show that the increase in base current occurs only if the beam is directed to the immediate vicinity of the emitter-base pn-junction. Irradiation of the remainder of the transistor surface had no effect on the current gain. In a second topic, it was reported that npn bipolar planar transistors could be total-dose-hardened if they were irradiated to a high dose at
III-6
the same time the temperature biased.
of the devices is held between 200° and 250°C while forward-
In a third topic, the effects of plastic versus hermetic metal can packaging on the total dose hardness of planar npn and pnp bipolar transistors under various bias conditions were investigated. It was reported that, in all cases, there was no additional degradation of the gain for the plastic-packaged transistors. For the npn transistors packaged in hermetic metal cans and irradiated under collector-to-base reverse voltage, it was reported that there were increased degradation in current gain and increased scatter between individual test units. For the pnp transistors packaged in metal cans and irradiated under an emitter-to-base reverse voltage, it was reported that there was a considerable increase in the degradation of current gain, 1972- Roles of Charge Accumulation Degradation[8] [9]
and Interface States in NPN Surface
The relative roles of the radiation-induced interface states and oxide charges on the surface degradation of npn bipolar planar transistors are explained in these two papers by Sivo of Boeing. Sivo reports that, in general, the new interface states are the more important factor in the surface degradation of npn transistors as long as a strong inversion of the base surface is not developed that causes a “channel” between the emitter and base contact. Charge buildup would then become the primary factor if extensive channeling did develop, which would primarily occur at high doses. It was also reported that a strong inversion of the surface by a high enough positive oxide charge would be substantially retarded by a coincident high density of interface states due to the buildup of negative charges on the acceptor-like surface states in inversion. This effect will cause an arumrent saturation in the charge accumulation with dose. The nonuniform nature of the charge buildup and the charge of the interface states can contribute significantly to low-current gain degradation at low and medium doses. At high doses, once the channeling occurs, the high-cument gain can be seriously affected as well. 1974- Use of a Scanning Electron Microscope for Screening Bipolar Surface Effects[ 10] This is the first reported use of a Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) to irradiate pnp transistors in a paper by Lipman, Bruncke, and Crosthwait of Texas Instruments and Galloway and Pease of the Naval Ammunition Depot. Correlation of gain degradation was demonstrated between Cobalt-60 and the 20-keV electrons from the SEM.
1975- Total Dose Response of Bipolar Digital Devices [11][12][13] The first papers concerning total dose effects in digital bipolar microcircuits discuss the total dose results on high-speed emitter coupled logic (ECL) gates [11] by Daniel and Coppage of Sandia. Two papers report the effects of total dose gamma irradiation on the electrical characteristics of integrated injection logic (1%) devices and circuits [12] [13] by Pease of Naval Weapons Support Center and Raymond of Northrop Research and Technology Center.
III-7
1975- Testing and Hardening of Linear Microcircuits
14]
Ionizing radiation results are reported for a number of linear circuits, including the LM101A,LM102,LM108,LM111 , LM124, LM139, HA2520, HA2600, HA2620, and HA2700. The irradiate and anneal (IIWN) hardening technique was attempted on a number of part types and was reported to be an acceptable method for a few specific part types, while, in others, there were problems such as excessive degradation for the second irradiation. 1976- Process Investigations
of Total Dose Hard, 108 Op Amps[15]
Testing, analysis, and total dose hardening were performed on a 108 op amp in this paper by Palkuti of NRL and Sivo and Greegor of Boeing. The analysis was initiated with a total dose characterization of 108-type op amps that indicated that total dose sensitive devices could be radiation-hardened by modifying their standard processing. Extensive lot sampling over extended periods of time indicated significant lot-to-lot variation in the total dose sensitivity. The lot sampling indicated that devices from about 30% of the tested wafer lots exhibited Subsequent failure analysis by selective circuit significantly greater radiation sensitivity. irradiation with a SEM identified the critical op amp failure modes as primarily the result of super-beta-gain loss and leakage increase. A process-flow analysis with MOS capacitors on the selected baseline fabrication sequence was followed by a study of specific processing steps on the 108 hardness. Specific process steps were modified and the results presented. Using the defined process, it was possible to fabricate 108-type devices with minimal degradation at 1 Mrad(Si02). 1976- Irradiate-Anneal
Screening of Total Dose Effects[16]
The identification and elimination of maverick devices that exhibit much greater total dose sensitivity than the normal lot hardness distribution is again a topic in this paper by Stanley and Price of JPL. The effects of irradiate-anneal were measured for a number of linear bipolar devices, where normal and anomalous values obtained after the first irradiation and annealing were determined. It was found that, in almost all cases, reirradiation produced substantially greater shifts than the first irradiation. Unusual annealing behavior was also observed on some devices, such as the LM1 11. 1977- Analysis of Total Dose Response in Linear Integrated Circuits[17][18][
19]
A number of papers, through various analysis techniques, attempt to explain the response of linear integrated circuits to total dc~e irradiation. The first by Stanley and Gauthier of JPL [17] uses SEM irradiation at various levels of magnification to identi& sensitive areas and components that are responsible for the total dose degradation. Also discussed is the large variation in total dose response from device to device within the same date code. The second by Galloway and Roitman [18] of the National Bureau of Standards discusses a number of factors that must be considered in using the SEM, such as the depth-dose distribution of kilovolt electrons, dose rate uniformity, and the importance of biasing. The third paper by Johnston of Boeing [19] discusses neutron degradation in four common linear integrated circuits, but the circuit analysis discussed is very relevant to total dose degradation.
III-8
1977- Discussion of a Hard Off-the-Shelf SG1524 PWM and Total Dose Hardness Variation in LM 139s from Four Manufacturers[20] In this paper by Newell and Picciano of Ford Aerospace, the off-the-shelf total dose hardness of the SG1 524 pulse width modulator is analyzed and an attempt made to explain what is responsible for the significant total dose hardness. The wide variation in hardness of LM 139s from four different manufacturers is discussed, along with the test results and proposed explanation for the hardness differences. 1977- Evaluation of Integrated Injection Logic[21][22] Total dose results and analysis are reported on I% devices from five different manufacturers in this paper by Raymond of MRC and Pease of NWSC Crane. The use of bipolar processes for digital circuits, including memories and microprocessors, is rapidly increasing; and this paper and one by Donovan, Simons, and Burger of RTI discuss the future of LSI technologies. A subjective comparison of IS technologies in [21] rates FL slightly ahead of CMOS as the superior process in performance and hardness. Paper [22] also projects an optimistic future for 12L, with CMOS/SOS a close competitor. 1978- Hardness Assurance Considerations Structures[23]
for Total Dose Effects on Bipolar
This work assessed the theoretical understanding of long-term total dose effects in bipolar devices in support of the development of a hardness assurance technique in a paper by Hart, Smyth, van Lint, Snowden, and Leadon of MRC and IRT. The principal effort was directed at studying transistor gain degradation mechanisms by use of models relating semiconductor physical and electrical parameters to surface properties. Total dose effects on surface properties were used to identify critical physical parameters for use in hardness assurance procedures. Model implications and predictions were compared with existing data to evaluate their accuracy and usefulness as a tool. 1979-
Total Dose Homogeneity Study of the 108A Operational Amplifier[24]
Identification of maverick devices exhibiting a significantly lower total dose hardness was the subject of this paper by Johnston and Lancaster of JPL. This study investigated the homogeneity of the radiation response of components and complete 108A circuits at various levels of traceability, including diffusion lot-to-lot, wafer-to-wafer, and sub-wafer. Significant differences were found in the radiation hardness of the different diffusion lots. Even the variability of devices from a single wafer was larger than expected and was comparable to variability of devices from a single diffusion lot. Examination of the circuit data for large numbers of devices from single diffusion lots revealed that a small number of devices, approximate y 1?ZO, had a much different radiation response than the rest of the devices. In some cases, different failure mechanisms were responsible; but some devices simply had a different sensitivity to total dose. No electrical parameter could be identified that could be used to screen these devices.
III-9
,.
1981- SEM Analysis of Total Dose EffectsinAD571 Converter[25]
.
1% Analog-to-Digital
This paper by Gauthier of JPL investigated the total dose degradation mechanisms in the AD571 ADC, Sensitive areas of the circuit were identified by SEM irradiation, and then responsible components were identified. 1981- Total Dose Hardening of 108 Amplifier with Nitride Passivation[26] This paper by Condito, Lambert, and Schwartz of Precision Monolithic investigates the effect of different processing steps on the total dose hardness of the OP- 108A precision operational amplifier. Process lots with and without a silicon nitride surface passivation layer demonstrated that the nitride layer is the dominant step in assuring radiation-resistant circuits. Standard processed parts with the nitride layer demonstrated significantly lower degradation by a factor of 10 to 18 than the parts manufactured without it. 1981- Total Dose Hardness of Integrated Schottky Logic [27][28] Two papers by Johnson of Raytheon and Blice of NWSC Crane reported the total dose hardness of integrated Schottky logic transistors and circuits to be 10 Mrad(Si02). 1982- Total Dose Hardness of FL Logic Devices and SBP9989 Microprocessor[29]
[30]
Total dose hardness of six custom digital circuits designed and fabricated in an 1% process for the Global Position System is reported in this paper by Poblenz of Texas Instruments[29]. The circuits were found to be relatively hard to total doses of 1 Mrad(Si02). Similar hardness results were reported for the SBP9989 microprocessor in a paper by Woods of MIT[30]. 1983- Total Dose Effects in Recessed Oxide Digital Bipolar Microcircuits[3 1][32] Total dose failure levels of as low as 5 krad(Si02) are first reported in oxide-isolated In the first paper by Buschbom of Texas bipolar technologies in these two papers. Instruments[3 1], the failure of an advanced oxide isolated process is identified to be inversion of the base region along the oxide sidewall. In the second paper by Pease of MRC[32], low total dose failure levels of 10 to 100 krad(SiOz) are reported in oxide-isolated bipolar processes from five manufacturers. Failure modes are identified as (1) inversion of the p+ region at the bottom of the recessed oxide, causing channeling between adjacent buried layers; (2) inversion of the ptype base region along the recessed oxide sidewall, causing channeling between the emitter and collector of the npn transistor; and (3) an increase in surface recombination velocity along the sidewall due to fast surface states, causing an increase in p region sidewall currents. 1983- Comparison of Total Dose Effects in Linear ICS from Cobalt-60 and Electrons[33] Total ionizing dose response for fourteen linear IC types from eight manufacturers using Cobalt-60 and 2.2-MeV electrons sources is reported by Gauthier and Nichols of JPL. Electrons
III-10
are reported to almost always cause greater degradation Cobalt-60.
and lower device failure levels than
1984- Degradation Analysis of Lateral PNP Transistors[34] Degraded current gain due to x-ray irradiation in lateral pnp transistors is analyzed by Kato of Hitachi CentraI Research Laboratory. Base current is evaluated for two regions -- the depletion region of the emitter-base junction and the nondepleted charge-neutral region of the base surface. 1985- Total Dose Induced Hole Trapping and Interface State Generation in Bipolar Recessed Field 0xides[35] In an extension of the previous year’s reported work[32], the total-dose-induced trappedhole density, N.t, and interface state density, Nit, are investigated in bipolar recessed field oxides using test structures. New results include the effects of pn junction fringing fields on inversion voltage shift, 1987- Models for Total Dose Degradation of Linear Integrated Circuits[36] Mechanisms for total dose degradation of linear integrated circuits are discussed, including bulk effects, oxide charge buildup, and recombination at the Si-SiOz interface in this paper by Johnston and Plaag of Boeing. The dependence of damage on bias, dose, particle type, and energy is used in conjunction with two-dimensional modeling to identify the failure mechanism in a specific linear device type. The importance of surface recombination, along with the absence of bias dependence, is discussed in this paper. Substantial differences between Cobalt-60 and electrons are shown to be due to bulk darnage added to the surface darnage in the wide-base lateral and substrate pnp transistors. 1987- Total Dose Failure Levels for Circuits Using Bipolar Recessed Field Oxide Processes[37] [38] [39] The total dose failure levels for circuits fabricated in bipolar processes using recessed field oxide isolation are discussed in three papers. The papers by Schi~37] and Maurer[38] both discuss the hardness of these processes at low dose rates typical of space operation. Both papers report significantly higher failure threshold when the imadiation tests are conducted at low dose rates. This is due to the recessed field oxide failure mechanism and the annealing behavior. In the paper by Titus[39], the total dose failure threshold uniformity is mapped for several wafers. These include both standard processed wafers and ones with an enhanced field implant to improve total dose hardness. 1988- Bipolar Integrated Circuits Fabricated on Oxygen Implanted Silicon-on-Insulator Wafers[40] This paper by Platteter of NWSC Crane and Cheek of Texas Instruments describes the radiation improvements obtained by fabricating bipolar digital integrated circuits on oxygenMultiple low dose oxygen implants were used to implanted silicon-on-insulator substrates. 111-11
fabricate the wafers. Total dose hardness was reported to be significantly circuits compared to the bulk circuits.
higher for the SOI
1988- Comparison of Heavy Ion, Electrons, and Cobalt-60 Degradation Effects on an Advanced Digital Bipolar Process[41] Results are presented in this paper by Zoutendyk and Goben of JPL and Bemdt of Honeywell on measurements of the degradation effects of bromine heavy ions, electrons, and Cobalt-60 radiation on the current gain of bipolar transistors fabricated in an advanced process. Bromine was reported to produce the most degradation and Cobalt-60 the least. 1989- Total Dose Effects in Trench Isolation[42] Total dose effects in polysilicon-fflled trenches used for component isolation in an advanced commercial bipolar technology are reported on for the fust time in this paper by Enlow and Pease of MRC and Combs and Platteter of NWSC Crane. Test structures were designed and processed in an advanced trench-isolated bipolar process to study the total dose basic mechanisms. The generation and annealing behavior and effect on bias on Nil and NOt are reported. 1990- Radiation Hardening of BCDMOS Technology[43] The hardening of a power integrated circuit technology, containing bipolar, CMOS, and DMOS components, is reported in this paper by Desko, DarWish, Dolly, and Goodwin of AT&T and Titus of NWSC Crane. 1991- Low Dose Rate Effects in Advanced Bipolar Processes[44][45] The first report of increased gain degradation in bipolm devices irradiated at low dose rates is reported in this paper by Enlow and Pease of MRC, Combs of NWSC Crane, and Schrimpf and Nowlin of University of Arizona[44]. Implications of this finding on the 1019.4 test method are discussed in a paper by Fleetwood, Winokur, and Meisenheimer of Sandia[45]. In the paper by Enlow, total-dose-induced gain degradation in polysilicon and crystalline emitter The effects of bias, dose rate, and anneal temperatures are bipolar transistors is investigated. The bipolar test structures reported on are from four commercial technologies. discussed. Polysilicon emitter transistors show improved hardness over crystalline emitter transistors. Two of the three polysilicon technologies tested showed a continued decrease in gain during room temperature annealing, which may be due to post-imadiation buildup of interface traps. The gain degradation at a given total dose significantly increased as the dose rate was lowered, suggesting the existence of a dose rate phenomenon. The difference in dose for a given gain degradation at 1,1 versus 300 rad(SiOz)/s irradiations was near 50 for one of the polysilicon technologies. Both this paper and Fleetwood[45] suggest that Test Method 1019.4 hardness assurance test may not represent a worst case test for space environments.
III-12
1992- Trends in the Total Dose Response of Modem Bipolar Transistors[46] Factors that influence the total dose response of bipolar transistors, including emitter bias, transistor polarity, emitter technology, emitter geometry, base design, and irradiation dose rate, are reported in this paper by Nowlin and Schrimpf of University of Arizona, Erdow of MRC, and Combs of NSWC Crane. Advanced polysilicon and standard emitter transistors of both npn and pnp polarity processed in a trench-isolated, silicon-on-insulator technology were the subject of this study. Findings that were reported (for this technology) include: npn transistors degrade more than pnp transistors; devices with higher surface concentration degrade less; devices with smaller emitter perimeter-to-area ratios degrade less; collector bias does not affect gain degradation; reverse bias on the emitter is worst-case bias; increases in base current are larger at smaller base-emitter voltages; poly-ernitter devices are initially harder than standard emitter devices at low doses, but may become worse at large total doses; and degradation is worse at low dose rates. 1993- Charge Separation and Low Rate Effects h“Bipolar Transistors[47] [48] The role of net positive oxide-trapped charge and surface recombination velocity on excess base current in bipolar transistors is the subject of the paper by Kosier of University of Arizona[47]. Using test structures and transistors, two simple approaches for separating the effects of oxide charge and surface recombination velocity in bipolar transistors is described. Both are based on analysis of the log plot of the excess base current versus the emitter-base voltage. In the paper by Nowlin of the University of Arizona[48], the dose rate dependence of bipolar current-gain degradation is mapped over a wide range of dose rates for the fwst time. Annealing experiments following irradiation showed negligible change in base current at room temperature, but significant recovery at 100”C and above. Implications reported are that Test Method 1019.4 irradiate-anneal will not predict the worst case gain degradation. 1993- Converting a Bulk Radiation-Hardened Dielectrically Isolated Process[49]
BiCMOS Technology into a
The development and radiation test results of a dielectrically isolated radiation-hardened BiCMOS process are reported in a paper by DeLaus of Analog Devices, Emily and Mappes of NSWC Crane, and Pease of RLP Research. The process is fabricated on a bonded-wafer siliconon-insulator (S01) substrate and employs deep trenches for complete oxide isolation. Total dose hardness of the process was not affected, and the dose rate hardness exhibited substantial improvement. 1994- Low Rate Total Dose Response of Bipolar Transistors[50][5
1][52][53]
Investigations into identifying, understanding, and assessing the implications of low dose rate effects in bipolar transistors increased greatly in 1994 with three papers on this topic. A fourth paper reported on synergetic effects of radiation stress and hot carrier stress on the current In the first paper by Kosier of University of Arizona[SO], it is gain of bipolar transistors. reported that the excess base current in an irradiated bipolar transistor increases superlinearly with total dose at low total dose levels. In this regime, the excess base current depends on the charge-trapping properties of the oxide that covers the emitter-base junction. At higher total dose III-13
.
,,
-..
levels, the excess base current saturates at a value that is independent of how the charge accumulates. In the second paper by Fleetwood of Sandia[5 1], a physical model of the mechanisms responsible for enhanced low-rate gain degradation in bipolar devices is presented. The model suggests the presence of slowly transiting or metastably trapped holes in the bulk of the oxides. These act in tandem with more deeply trapped holes near the Si-Si02 interface to reduce the charge yield in the bulk of the oxide and increase the number of compensated holes in the oxide above the emitter-base junction. In the third paper by Nowlin[52], an apparent saturation of the dose rate dependence for gain degradation at dose rates below 10 rad(Si02)/s is reported. The results on elevated temperature irradiation are discussed and proposed as a possible hardness assurance test method. 1994- Low Rate Effects in Bipolar Circuits[54][55] [56][57] Four papers discuss the total dose response of bipolar linear and mixed-signal microcircuits, including total dose dose rate sensitivities. In the paper by Johnston[54], total dose degradation and dose rate effects in conventional transistors and linear integrated circuits are discussed. It was reported for some circuits and processes that the dose rate dependence may continue as low as .005 rad(Si02)/s. It was also presented that elevated temperature irradiation of a microcircuit at 60”C produced more degradation than at the same dose rate and normal temperature, but did not bound the low-rate degradation. In a paper by Beaucour[55], total dose response of LM 137 voltage regulators from four manufacturers is reported. Enhanced low dose rate degradation is reported in two of the manufacturers’ circuits. Selective SEM irradiation and mechanical probing were used to identi~ a lateral multi-collector pnp transistor as the sensitive circuit element. In a paper by McClure[56], total dose response of three bipolar linear microcircuits is reported at various dose rates, In all cases, lower dose rates produced greater degradation. In some cases, anneals following the high dose rate irradiation caused further degradation, but did not bound the low rate response. In a paper by Lee[57], the total dose response of three high-resolution BiCMOS analog-to-digital converters is reported at various dose rates. The dominant failure mode reported was due to the thick gate oxides. Rebound effects caused the response to be markedly different at high and low dose rates. 1995- Low Rate Effects in Bipolar Transistors[58] [59] [60][61] Low rate effect studies continue to be strong with three papers on the topic of low rate effects in bipolar transistors and a fourth on the effect of irradiate and anneal cycling. In the paper by Schmidt[58], the total-dose-induced gain degradation of lateral, substrate, and vertical pnp bipolar transistors is reported at various dose rates. Physical mechanisms are proposed to explain the greater degradation at low rates. In the paper by Schrimpf159], the gain degradation of a lateral pnp transistor is measured after irradiation at various elevated temperatures and several dose rates and then annealed at various temperatures. It is reported that the excess base “current for irradiation at 125°C and 167 rad(Si02)/s is nearly equal to that at 0.1 rad (Si02)/s. In the Belyakov[60] paper, a MOS test structure is used to identi~ the mechanism believed responsible for the increased low dose rate degradation in bipolar transistor gain, Shallow electron traps are reported to influence an increase in the positive charge yield. In the paper by Witczak[61], it is reported that gain degradation due to ionizing radiation in complimentary single-crystalline emitter bipolar transistors grew progressively worse after repeated cycles of
I-II-14
.
irradiation and anneal. A correlation is drawn between this degradation and mechanical stress in the oxide. 1995- Low Rate Effects in Bipolar Microcircuits[62] [63] The total dose response of five bipolar linear microcircuits from several manufacturers and irradiated at various dose rates and bias conditions is presented and analyzed in the paper by Johnston[62]. In one circuit, saturation damage is reported to be about 10 times greater at low dose rates than high dose rates, In another device, the dose rate response was reported to be very nonlinear with only minimal degradation occurring at 50 and .005 rad(Si)/s, but large degradation occurring at .002 rad(Si)/s. In other devices, the enhanced low rate degradation was reported to be very bias-dependent. In a paper by Carrii3re[63], total dose irradiation and anneal response is reported on several bipolar linear devices. Enhanced low rate degradation was reported on several devices, but post-irradiation anneal did not correlate with low rate sensitivity. 1995- Total Dose Response of BiCMOS and SiGe Processes[64][65 ][66] The total dose response of high-resolution analog-to-digital converters is reported in a paper by Lee[64]. Significant total dose hardness variation was reported with date code and dose rate. The cause of the low dose rate sensitivity was reported to be due to the CMOS circuit elements. The total dose response of a DC/DC Converter fabricated in a high-voltage bipolarCMOS process is reported in a paper by Titus[65]. Minimal degradation is reported to a total dose of 9 Mrad(Si02). In a third paper by Babcock, total dose response of high-perfommnce SiGe heterojunction bipolar transistors is reported. Minimal gain degradation was observed to 1 Mrad(Si) for transistors irradiated at 300”K and 77”K.
2.0 FUNDAMENTALS
OF BIPOLAR TRANSISTOR
OPERATION
This section will give a basic overview of bipolar transistor operation and commonly used For a more detailed description of the operation of bipolar terminology and definitions. transistors, there are many excellent sources of information, such as Physics of Semiconductor Devices by Sze. For comparison, MOS transistors are a majority carrier device with the current flowing through a channel formed between two junctions and controlled by an electric field from a gate electrode. By contrast, bipolar junction transistors are minority carrier devices with current flow through a base region between two semiconductor junctions and controlled by charge injection into the base region. Figure 2 shows the symbols and nomenclatures of the two polarities of bipolar junction transistors. In the following discussion, the more common npn transistor will be described; the results are applicable to the pnp transistor with an appropriate change of polarities.
rrI-15
,.
EMITTER
,
BASE COLLECTOR
~
-’
(a)
p-n-p
TRANSISTOR
(b)
n-p-n
TRANSISTOR
Figure2 Symbolsand Nomenclaturesof npn and pnp Transistors.
The normal operating conditions for an npn transistor are with the base emitter junction forward-biased and the collector base junction reverse-biased. Under these conditions, the transistor is said to be operating in the active region. For our transistor, this mearts that minority carrier electrons are injected into the p-type base region. The predominant current flow in the transistor is from collector to emitter and is controlled by the small base current due to the forward-biased base-emitter junction and which increases strongly as the forward voltage at the emitter junction increases, The gain (Q of a transistor is determined by the percentage of the electrons that escape recombination and transit the base region from collector to emitter divided by the base current. The base current is determined by a number of factors, but is primarily determined by the rate at which holes are lost from the base by injection across the emitter junction and the rate of hole recombination with electrons in the base, In each case, the lost holes must be resupplied through the base current 1~. For our purposes, the base current IB is divided into two components to analyze the effects of radiation -- a bulk component (_&ulk)and a surface component (I,Uti.u). For radiation effects concerns, changes in the bulk component of IB are primarily due to recombination centers in the base region, such as from neutron or electron displacement damage effects. The primary concern for total ionizing dose damage is the increase in the surface component of the base current. This will be discussed in more detail in section 4.2. B= ~/IB = ~(I~ul~+ ItiW=)
(1)
A Gummel plot is the primary means of showing the base and collector currents. In a Gummel plot, log 1, and log k are plotted versus V,,. The transistor gain ~fl,) is derived from the Gummel plots and is plotted as current gain versus V~ or L. Examples of these plots are shown in Figure 3.
III-16
1.0
IN 1 0-s
.
0.8
8
Iv 10-7
1 o~
lN 10-10
)
10-11
0.0
10-12
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.6
0.9
0.4
VEB(-v)
I
I
I
I
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.6
0.9
Vm (v)
Figure 3 (a) ExampleGummelPlots of IBand ~; (b) DerivedCurrentGainCurve.
3.0 BIPOLAR TRANSISTOR
STRUCTURES
Due to the long product lifetimes of some bipolar processes, there are currently many different bipolar processes being used to fabricate linear and mixed-signal microcircuits. The radiation response of the different processes and different transistors within each process may vary significantly. Factors that may influence the radiation response include transistor vertical geometry, layout, presence of electrical fields due to field plates and other vertical fields, fringing fields, surface doping concentration, surface oxide quality and thickness, and many other factors. This chapter will attempt to give a brief overview of the principal transistor devices currently used, fabrication differences that may influence the radiation response, and common circuit implementations. One rule that should be applied throughout this study is to always assume there is an exception to every rule. There are many variations to the devices and processes that are discussed in this chapter, so firsthand knowledge of the device of interest is important to understand the radiation response. 3.1 Vertical,
Lateral,
and Substrate
Transistors
The first major class of devices that we will discuss is the vertical, lateral, and substrate transistors used in the classical junction-isolated, medium-voltage, linear process. This process has evolved slowly since it was introduced in the late 1960s and is still commonly used to
III-17
.,
,,
,
fabricate the standard 40-volt linear product such as the LM- and OP-series of microcircuits. Figure 4, from [36], shows a cross section of the three common transistors implemented in this process.
EmitterBase Collector o
0
0
Emitter
Collector
0
0
w
p+
Base
1 p+
n-epi n+ p-substrate
p-substrate
Vertical npn
Lateral pnp
(a)
(b)
Emitter ?
Base ?
P2ss25! Substrate pnp (c)
Figure 4 Cross Sectionof TransistorStructuresUsed in MediumVoltageLinearICS
ShowingDominantCurrentFlow Paths.[36]
The vertical npn transistor shown in Figure 4(a) is typically the most common circuit element used in the medium-voltage linear circuits. The npn transistor is a high-gain vertical structure with minimal base surface area. The dominant current flow in this device is vertically, so surface oxides are expected to affect only the minor lateral component of the base current. The lateral pnp transistor shown in Figure 4(b) is a suboptimal device using the same diffusions that were optimized for the vertical npn. The lateral pnp transistor is formed with a buried layer that inhibits vertical current flow to the substrate (for this structure the substrate transistor is a parasitic transistor that reduces the gain). Typically. 95% to 97% of the current is in the lateral direction. Most lateral transistors use a collector ring or square that surrounds most of the emitter and confines the base area to the region between the two diffusions. Because the base surface in the active transistor region is predominantly low surface concentration n-epi, a field plate is commonly used to control surface effect. The field plate was first developed due to the low-quality surface oxides in the early days of IC fabrication and the tendency for ionic contamination to invert the base region, The field plate is typically an extension of the emitter metallization over the base region, but separated from it by the surface oxide. The presence or absence of a field plate and the surface layout and bias can have a strong effect on the total dose response of the lateral pnp. The substrate pnp transistor shown in Figure 4(c) is designed so that the dominant current flow occurs vertically. No buried layer is used. However, current can also flow laterally to the isolation diffusion, which is also the collector of this transistor. Depending on the base width of the vertical pnp component versus the lateral pnp component, the ratio of
III-18
vertical-to-lateral current flow can vary. Typically, the vertical component of the current flow is about 80% and the lateral about 20’-ZO.The substrate transistor also typically has a larger base surface area than the lateral transistor and so is sensitive to surface damage. Field plates are also used on some substrate devices to control surface effects and, thus, can also be a significant influence on the total dose response. A more modern bipolar process used to fabricate linear and mixed-signal ICS capable of operating at 10 volts or less and at circuit frequencies of up to 1 GHz is shown in Figure 5. This class of processes typically contains both high-performance vertical npn and pnp transistors. The Lateral cross section in Figure 5 shows devices fabricated on buried oxide SOI substrates. isolation is achieved with etched vertical trenches that have a regrown liner oxide and which are then refilled with polysilicon. Variations of this process, and especially earlier processes, may be processed on bulk wafers and employ recessed field oxide isolation. Although not common, a lateral pnp transistor may be implemented in these processes when a higher voltage device is required than the vertical npn or pnp transistor can support. The vertical npn and pnp transistors shown in Figure 5 typically have cutoff frequencies (f-r) from 2 to 10 GHz. The transistors have much shallower junctions and narrower bases than the previously discussed process due to the use of ion implantation, rather than diffusions, to form the junctions. The base is, typically, formed as a two-step process with a shallower and lighter implanted intrinsic base to form the active base region and a higher-doped extrinsic base to decrease base resistance and improve efficiency. This extrinsic base also gives a higher-doped surface concentration to reduce surface effects. The surface oxide at the critical emitter-base junction can vary greatly, depending on the process, resulting in much different radiation response. This will be discussed in more detail later.
PNP
NPN
1
I
Figure 5 DeviceCross Sectionof a Trench/SOIComplementaryBipolarProcess.[67]
111-19
,.
,
A major advance in bipolar technology has been the development of polysilicon emitters. Figure 6[44] shows the difference between a typical crystalline emitter npn transistor Fig. 6(a) and a polysilicon emitter npn transistor Fig. 6(b). The speed of the polysilicon emitter transistors, as measured by fT, is increased to 15 to 25 GHz for a 5-volt device. For 3.3-volt devices, the fTcan be increased to 30 to 50 GHz by scaling. N+ Polysilicon ilicon
Collector
N+
N+
Collector
(a)
(b)
(a) TypicalCross Sectionof a CrystallineEmitternpn Transistorand (b) TypicalCross Sectionof a PolysiliconEmitternpnTransistor.[44]
Figure 6
3.2 Bipolar Transistor Fabrication The principal fabrication factors that contribute to the total dose response of bipolar transistors are the quality and thickness of the surface oxide, especially at the emitter base junction and over the base area; the base and emitter doping concentration at the Si-Si02 interface; and, for displacement damage effects, the base width and lifetime. For the medium-voltage linear process shown in Figure 4, successive depositions (or, in some cases, implants) are performed followed by high-temperature diffusions. Successive layers of oxides that have been exposed to the different dopants are grown during these hightemperature steps and are, thus, heavily damaged. For example, the junction isolation diffusion that drives the p-isolation to the substrate is performed at 1200”C for five hours. Whether the oxide grown during this lengthy process step is removed for subsequent processing has been demonstrated to have a significant effect on total dose hardness[ 15]. Other fabrication steps that have been demonstrated to affect the total dose hardness are densification of the CVD after emitter formation, the use of a forming gas during emitter anneal, and the use of phosphorusdoped glassivation. It has been demonstrated that replacement of the surface oxide with a silicon nitride surface passivation layer can significantly improve total dose hardness [26]. There is no standard bipolar process, and variations between manufacturers may cause significantly different total dose responses for electrically similar transistors.
111-20
Crystalline emitter transistors are fabricated by direct ion implantation of the base and emitter regions. Direct implantation limits how shallow the junctions can be formed and also the base width that can be achieved. Also, metal contacts cannot be used on junctions that are less than 1 pm in depth. Typically, the surface concentrations of ion-implanted bipolar transistors are higher than diffused junctions. The oxide over the emitter-base junction region is also thinner due to the shorter process times associated with ion-implanted junctions compared to diffused junctions. One factor that varies between manufacturers is the amount of damage that is done to the surface oxide during the implant steps. In some processes, the surface oxide is removed in the emitter base region and replaced with a composite grown and deposited spacer oxide. This can create a large difference in radiation response. Polysilicon emitter transistors have several performance advantages over the crystalline Polysilicon can contact shallower emitters than with metal contacts. As emitter transistors. vertical device scaling produces shallower emitters, base current increases due to carrier Polysilicon emitters eliminate this high recombination at the metal.lsilicon interface[67]. recombination interface and also can be used as a diffusion source to form ultra-shallow emitters. The most advanced bipolar processes employ a self-aligned, double-polysilicon transistor. The double-polysilicon transistor uses a second layer of polysilicon to contact the base region. Advantages include reduced base area and, therefore, reduced collector-base capacitance. This also allows closer base-emitter contact and reduced base resistance. The radiation tolerance of polysilicon transistors has been demonstrated to be significantly better than crystalline emitter transistors[46] [50]. 3.3 Circuit Implementation Circuit design can have a significant effect on the total dose response of linear and mixedsignal circuits. Especially important is how the total dose sensitive lateral and substrate transistors are used in the circuit design. Some circuits, such as the LM1 11, LM139, and LM 124, use a substrate or lateral pnp directly in the input stage. The LM111 input stage is shown in Figure 7[36] along with the increase in input bias current. In this type of design, the input bias current k inversely proportional to the substrate transistor gain so that, as the transistor gain decreases, the input bias current increases.
111-21
~ +
Cobalt-60 2 MeV Electon
150
150
LM1l 1 Input Stage
Vm
100 A
50
Input
:
0
o 0
50
100
150
200
250
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 7 LM111Input Bias Stageand InputBias Currentvs. Total Dose.[36]
Lateral and substrate pnp transistors are often used in current sources that are internal to the input or output stage and, thus, are difficult to monitor for degradation. These current sources are designed to tolerate a wide range of gain. However, even in these applications, once the gain drops below a threshold level, the circuit will fail suddenly and catastrophically. This has been reported for the LM 108 operational amplifier[36] and the LM 137 voltage regulator[55]. In the case of the LM 137, a multi-collector lateral pnp, used as a current source in the startup stage, dropped below a critical gain value of 8, causing sudden failure. In many linear circuits, careful matching of components is required for proper circuit operation. In these circuits, identical transistors are laid out symmetrically to minimize any It has been reported[ 17] that small unbalancing due to temperature and loading effects. differential changes in gain degradation for these balanced pairs can cause substantial degradation of circuit performance. Different gain degradation in identical matched devices may be due to the influence of internal bias differentials during irradiation or to nonhomogeneous transistor radiation response. It has been reported that the assumption of homogeneous wafer response has limited validity [24]. In many cases, the uniformity of the total dose response of devices from a single wafer was substantially larger than expected and no better than that of several wafers from the same diffusion lot.
4.0 TRANSISTOR
TOTAL DOSE EFFECTS
Transistor total dose response is dependent on the type of process used for fabrication. In this section, the transistor response to total dose irradiation for each of the major processes The first section will deal with surface inversion discussed previously will be presented.
III-22
mechanisms, transistors.
and the second section will deal with gain degradation
in the different types of
4.1 Substrate, Sidewall, and Surface Inversion Inversion can occur in several locations in an oxide-isolated process. Typically, it occurs where a lightly doped, p-type silicon layer is adjacent to a thick field oxide. Figure 8 [35] shows a bipolar transistor with recessed field oxide isolation and several potential inversion regions.
=zz
X= N+ BURIED LAYER
N+ BURIED LAYER
~~ P SUBSTRATE
Figure 8 Typical Cross Section of Recessed Field Oxide Bipolar Transistor with Walled Emitters.[35]
Location 1 of Figure 8 is the inversion of the p+ region at the bottom of the recessed oxide, which causes channeling between adjacent buried layers. Inversion of p-type silicon at an Si02 interface is due to positive-type charge trapped in the SiOz next to the interface that depletes the p-type silicon surface to a maximum value. This was reported in five digital bipolar processes in [35] with failure thresholds as low as 5 krad(SiOz). Location 2 of Figure 8 is the inversion of the p-type base region along the recessed oxide sidewall, causing channeling between the collector and emitter of the npn transistor. Figure 9 shows a detailed view of the inversion area. Similar positive charge trapping in the recessed field oxide, as with the substrate inversion, causes the sidewall inversion. This failure mode was reported in two digital bipolar processes in [35] and was recently reported in [75] for a BiCMOS process where inversion of the base region of a walled npn transistor occurred. The tran~istor layout was redesigned to nest the emitter so that the emitter implant falls entirely within the active area. Devices with the nested emitter were fabricated and total dose testing performed. No collector-to-emitter leakage was observed to 1 Mrad(SiOz) for the redesigned, walled, bipolar transistor.
III-23
Inversion
n+
Emitter
p-Base
n-Epi
n+DUF
)
p-Substrate
Figure 9 Inversion Mechanism in Walled EmitterTransistor.[31]
Inversion can also occur in more advanced isolation methods and has been reported in trench isolation structures [42]. Figure 10 [42], shows a deep trench that has been formed by reactive ion-etching a deep groove through the n-epi and n+ buried layers and into the p-substrate. A p+ channel stop is implanted into the bottom of the trench, and then a thin liner oxide is grown. Under ionizing radiation, positive charge is The trench is finally refilled with poly-silicon. generated and trapped in the liner oxide, which -- depending on oxide thickness, trapping characteristics, and the doping concentration of the p-substrate and p+ channel implant -- can invert the p areas and cause a channel between the two n+ buried layers. In all cases of inversion, the formation of an inversion layer is strongly bias-dependent and is aided by a positive electric field.
Surface Field Oxide
Metallization
";j;;jjjj;~j.!!!; .:.".`.'}.`.'.".f {{<{..'.'.'.' \."'.".";." .jj;jjjj;;;i~.`i~, ~ N+ Buried
Thermal
N+ Buried
Layer .
Oxide ~
“ :~
Layer
Polysilicon
Leakage P- Substrate
:1
--+w--
c-.! L
Figure 10
Cross
Section
Current
P+ Implant ‘
of Parasitic
Trench
MOSFET.
[42]
Surface inversion can occur in some structures, depending on surface oxide thickness, oxide charge-trapping characteristics, surface doping concentration, dose rate, and electric fields. Inversion has been reported in the p-isolation[ 17] for some devices. In general, the surface
III-24
oxides are much thimer than recesssed field oxides; and surface concentrations of most active elements are high enough to prevent inversion. However, many linear circuits operate at very low currents, particularly in input structures and bias circuits that establish the operating conditions for the input stage. These circuits are inherently sensitive to small increases in leakage currents, such that even partial channeling can have a major impact on circuit performance and parametric degradation. 4.2 Transistor Gain Degradation A decrease in transistor gain can be due to a decrease in collector current or an increase in base current at a given base-emitter voltage. As discussed in Section 3.2, there are two basic components to the base current, a bulk and surface component; and gain can be expressed as the equation[23]: 13= L/I, = Ic/(Iti, + I~ru).
(2)
This course will primarily discuss the surface component of the base current; however, it has been shown that bulk darnage can have a significant effect on gain degradation on wide-base structures such as the lateral pnp and substrate pnp transistors [23][33][36] and even on advanced narrow-base npn transistors[41 ] and, thus, should not be ignored. Gain degradation due to bulk darnage is especially important when concerned with potential degradation from electrons and heavy ions. Since the bulk darnage adds to the surface darnage effects, much lower failure levels may occur in actual space environments than in conventional Cobalt-60 laborato~ testing. Since low-energy x-rays do not cause bulk darnage, they are a possible tool to help separate the bulk component from the surface component. Care must be taken in its use, however, due to the low fields present in most bipolar structures and the potential for lower charge yields from the x-rays. The surface component of base cument can increase from ionizing radiation because of several mechanisms, but is primarily due to an increase in interface states at the surface of the base and positive charge buildup near the emitter-base junction, which affect the surface potential and the extent of the emitter-base depletion region. Both result in an increase in the base recombination current and resultant decrease in gain. Many factors can affect the buildup of interface states and positive trapped charge and their effect on recombination current. Each factor will be considered separately in this discussion, but the total effect on a “real device” may be a complex combination of multiple factors. Care must be taken in comparing differences between similar devices to be sure that all factors are understood and considered in the total response comparison. The ionizing radiation response of an npn transistor is illustrated in Figure 11 in terms of the normalized ~ degradation, ~/flo, and log ~ and log IB versus VBE where POis the initial gain for a dose rate of 100 rad(Si)/s and dose levels up to 500 krads. The general features of this degradation are: (1) the gain degrades more rapidly at values of VBE below peak gain, (2) the gain peak moves to higher values of VBEat higher total doses, and (3) the gain degradation is a result of increases in IB with ~ remaining essentially unchanged. In some process technologies, ~ has been observed to increase with dose, especially under reverse emitter-base bias [52]; however, the dominant mechanism is excess base current, MB.
III-25
,.
,
-1
t
L
E
10’
“\.
-J
H“ 10-7 d
/.
:ficg;( } ‘“: 10-12
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
0.4
0.5
0.6
VBE (v)
0.7
0.8
0.9
v~~(v)
Figure 11 (a)Normalized Current Gain for Typical Vertical npn and (b) Gummel Characteristics Showing the Increase in Base Current with Total Dose.[46]
Ionizing radiation response mechanisms of an npn transistor have been treated in depth by Kosier, et al. [47] [50]. An analytical expression has been developed for the excess base current, AIB, that is caused by the oxide-trapped charge and interface states. The structure modeled is shown in Figure 12.
I
I
II
Figure 12 Representative Cross Section of the Devices Studied in This Work (Technology B).[70]
III-26
Intrinsic
Base
b
Lm
z
I Figure 13
L In
CoordinateConventionand GeometricDefinitions.[70]
The qualitative features of the analytic expression have been verified with a 2D device physics code using sheet charge in the oxide to represent the trapped oxide charge and a degraded surface recombination velocity to represent interface traps. Layout of the structure modeled is shown in Figure 13. The expression for the surface component of excess base current [70] is
(3)
where Nox is the trapped oxide charge, NS the interface doping density in the base, ~ Debye length, and ni is the intrinsic camier concentration.
is the
The mechanism for the increase in MB is an integration of the change in surface potential (which is caused by the oxide-trapped charge and affects the recombination rate at the base surface) and the radiation-induced increase in the surface recombination velocity, v~ti. The surface recombination rate is a strong function of surface potential, reaching a maximum when the surface is depleted and the hole and carrier concentrations are equal. This strong dependence is seen in the exponential factor exp(Nox2). This term is multiplied by the degraded surface recombination velocity, v~~, giving a superlinear dependence of MB on total dose. Once the surface becomes filly depleted and Nox is further increased, the surface becomes inverted,
III-27
driving the peak of the recombination below the surface. At this point, a maximum is reached for AIBj and the gain degradation saturates. Although an inversion layer forms ‘over the lightly doped portion of the base, a channel usually does not form from emitter to collector because the extrinsic base p+ base contact region blocks the channel. However, as discussed previously, in recessed field oxide walled emitter structures, a collector-to-emitter channel may be formed. The geometry dependence of& is observed in the ratio of the perimeter-to-area for the emitter-base junction at the surface. The other geometry term is the total surface area of the lighter doped intrinsic base surface. The emitter-base bias influences the initial rate increase in AIB because the emitter-base junction fringing electric field influences the buildup and spatial distribution of Nox and V~~. The worst-case bias is a reverse bias of the emitter-base, whereas the best case is forward bias. The oxide thickness and hole trapping cross sections also influence Nox. The depletion of the base region is affected by Nox and the surface doping density. The higher base surface doping will result in a lower increase in MB. As will be shown later, the low dose rate sensitivity is a result of a dose-rate-dependent value for both trapped charge and interface traps. Although the mechanism for MB in npn transistors is relatively well understood, the theory for lateral and substrate pnp transistors is not. An advanced state-of-the-art lateral pnp built with a polysilicon emitter and collector with LOCOS isolation has recently been modeled. The mechanisms for ~B appear to be Results will be presented at this year’s conference. dominated by an increase in v,ti in a region very close to the emitter-base junction surface perimeter. The effect of oxide-trapped charge is to accumulate the n-type base surface, which emitter occurs because the actually offsets the effect of vsti. Very little depletion of the p-ty r surface doping density of the polysilicon emitter is ve~ high (> 101 cm-3). Thus, in this structure, the effects of Nox and Vsutioppose rather than enhance each other; and the dependence of ~B with dose is sublinear rather than superlinear. However, the conventional diffused/impla.nted emitter of the lateral pnp shown in Figure 4b has a surface doping density comparable to the base Thus, in the conventional lateral pnp transistor, MB is region of a vertical npn transistor. expected to consist of a term, due to depletion of the emitter, that would be comparable to the MB of the npn. Since the principal component of emitter current is lateral rather than vertical, MB is expected to be much higher than in the npn transistor, resulting in much greater gain degradation. Efforts are underway to model this structure in PISCES. The dependence of/& and P on dose at high dose rates has been studied as a function of the process, device design, and test parameters in [46]. Each one will be addressed individually here, but remember that there may be complex interactions in a real device. Transistor polarity is the first factor considered. From the previous discussion, the positive oxide charge and interface states interact over the p-type base in the npn transistor to cause significant base current increase. In the pnp case, the positive charge and interface traps offset and result in less base current decrease. In general, with all other factors being equal, a pnp transistor will degrade less than an npn transistor. Figure 14 [46] shows the relative difference between similar vertical npn and pnp transistors.
III-28
1.0
-u----..
-::
-0.
-.
0.0 i
10
-..
“.
-,
L
-----u. -0.
‘.
. .
.
-u .
- v.
1
●
1 0.6
$ 0.4 0.1
02
0.0
0.01
10
Im
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 14 Total Dose Response of Similar
Vertical
npn and pnp Transistors.[46]
A second factor is oxide thickness, especially over the emitter-base junction area. In general, the thicker the oxide is over the base and base-emitter junction areas, the greater the total trapped charge and the larger the increase in base current. This has been reported in [62]. A third factor is the charge-trapping characteristics of the oxide over the emitter-base junction area. It has been shown by several[ 15][51 ] that oxide damaged during the fabrication process and left over the emitter-base area can have significantly higher charge-trapping efficiency than an oxide grown after most of the processing steps. This was demonstrated in [15] when the oxide that was present during the isolation diffusion process ( 1200”C for five hours) was stripped and regrown. It has also been demonstrated in [51] screen oxides that were implanted through and characterized. A fourth factor is the surface doping concentration, especially for the base and emitter areas. The more heavily doped the base or emitter surface is, the less depletion effect that the trapped charge will have on the surface. This is shown in Figure 15(a) [46] where a highly doped p+ ring was added to the base. More improvement would be obtained by increasing the doping of the entire base surface, but this would have a negative impact on the breakdown voltage. Figure 15(b) [46] shows the improvement with a higher-doped emitter. Since these are two different emitter technologies, other factors may also be influencing the improvement in hardness, such as improved emitter efficiency.
III-29
10
1.0
0.8 1 0.6
0.6
$
9’0.4
0.4
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2 a
0.0
,
I
r
I , ,I
10
,
8
,
0.O1
AIBflBoPoly-Emitler
0.0
100
0.01 10
100
Total Dose (krad(Si))
Total Dose (krad(Si))
Figure 15 (a)Effect of Increased Base Doping Ring on Improved Hardness (b) Comparison of Poly-Emitter with Silicon Emitter.[46]
A fifth factor Since the majority of the perimeter-to-area Figure 16 [46] shows
that influences transistor hardness is the emitter perimeter-to-area ratio. the increased base current occurs at the base-emitter perimeter, minimizing ratio will result in less base current increase and less gain degradation. the improvement from reducing the perimeter-to-area ratio.
1.0
$ ..::
0.8
e: ::....
L
o.. -0.
---
10
- n.
O.--”.q ..
-m
. ●
1 0.6
Q*
z
n=l
0.4
4 7
0.1
0.2 (
0.01
0.0 ~ 10
100
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 16 The Emitter Perimeter-to-Area Effect on the Total Dose Response of an npn Transistor.[46]
111-30
Transistor geomehy can be a significant factor in transistor total dose response. Especially important is the ratio of lateral current flow to surface current flow in the base area. In general, vertical transistors will be harder than surface devices. Figure 17 shows the total dose response of a vertical, substrate, and lateral pnp. In the vertical device, almost all of the current flow is in the vertical direction; and only a few percent is at the surface. For the substrate device, we previously showed that about 80?10of the current flow was vertical and 209i0 lateral. For the lateral device, the majority of the current flow is in the lateral direction. In Figure 17, we see that the vertical pnp transistor has the least degradation; the substrate pnp transistor degradation is second; and the lateral pnp transistor has the most degradation.
1.0
‘“O~ c
~
0.5
EzEl 0.0
~
LPNP(167
rsd(SIOJ/s)
~
SPNP(167
rsd(SIOJ/s)
~
VPNP(156
rsd(SIOJ/s)
I 1“0
1
I
101
l&
Total Dose
f
0.0
1P
(krad(SiOJ)
Figure 17 Normalized Current Gain (13)vs. Total Dose for Vertical, Substrate, and Lateral pnp.
Electric field in the oxide can be a significant factor in the total dose response. Determining the electric field can be quite complex, since there are nonuniform fringing fields induced by the junctions and vertical fields formed by any metallization or polysilicon layers that may lay on top of the device or area of interest. It has been shown previously that the field plates that are on most lateral and substrate devices can substantially improve the hardness. Many early experiments with gated transistor structures showed a strong dependence on total trapped charge and applied electric field. Figure 18 [46] shows the effect of different biases on a vertical npn For this transistor and layout, reverse bias during irradiation caused larger transistor. One must carefully analyze the device being tested to make sure all “parasitic” degradation. vertical fields that may be induced by overlying conductors are accounted for, because they may dominate a fringing field. Another factor in the total dose hardness is the injection level at which the gain degradation is measured. In almost all cases, gain degradation is worst at lower injection levels.
III-3 1
This occurs because there are increased surface effects at low injection levels. This can be observed in the L degradation at low V,E values for the Gummel characteristics in Figure 19, where the effects of characterizing a device at different injection levels is shown. One last factor that is important, but will be discussed in Section 6, is the dose rate and temperature at which irradiation is performed. It will be shown later, depending on many of the factors discussed here, that there may be increased degradation at low dose rates. In summary, factors which affect bipolar transistor hardness include: ● Transistor polarity (npn or pnp) ● Oxide thickness over base-emitter region ● Oxide trap efficiency ● Vertical electric field ● Fringing electric field ● Base surface concentration ● Emitter surface concentration ● Emitter perimeter-to-area ratio ● Transistor geometry (ratio of lateral to vertical current flow) ● Injection level ● Dose rate ● Temperature
1.0 m ::
=Z
k 10
@%:; ;8 ---
: : .
0.8
0-
P/P. - VBE= 0.5V
- . ❑ . plpo -
- -
0.6
~ . -a-
:
.
0.
‘%::
VBE= -2.OV
. ..Q . .
1
AIBnEKJ - VBE= 0.5V Al&
- VBE = -2.OV
Al&O-v~~=O.OV
0.4
0.1
0.2
[
0.0 ~ 10
0-01 100
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 18 The Effects of Bias During Irradiation.[46]
III-32
1.0
Q. . . . -.
L
0..
-
10
-.
0.8
. .
1 0.6 $
s .
0.4
.
0.1 .0.
0.2
~/~0- Measurement
. ❑ . ~/~0- Measurement +
AI#Bo
Bias.
0.6V
Bias=
0.7V
- Measurement
Bias = 0.6V
0.0
0.01 10
100
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 19 The Effect of Characterizing a Device at Different Injection Levels.[46]
5.0 INTEGRATED
CIRCUIT RESPONSE
This section will discuss the response of bipolar microcircuits to ionizing radiation. The first section will discuss the response of digital microcircuits that are primarily fabricated in oxide-isolated processes. The second section will discuss the more complex response of linear ICS and introduce low rate effects. 5.1 Total Dose Response of Digital Microcircuits Many of the early bipolar digital processes that have been reported on have been discontinued. These include integrated injection logic (12L) and integrated Schottky logic (ISL). Other processes, such as recessed field oxide bipolar processes, are still in limited production and are used for some mixed-signal applications. The failure modes for these processes are primarily associated with inversion associated with the recessed field oxide isolation, as discussed in Section 4.1. The radiation sensitivity of the circuits is found to be very sensitive to bias conditions during irradiation. In several cases, the failure mechanism is identified as substrate inversion, which causes a parasitic leakage path to form between the input transistor and a guard ring. When the input is biased high during irradiation, parametric failure occurs in 100% of the samples by 100 krad(Si). When the inputs are grounded during irradiation and normal power bias applied, all parameters and functionality are nearly constant and within specification up to 10 Mrad(Si). Failure analysis of these devices identifies a metallization run over the field oxide between the input structure and the guard ring. This metallization run acts as a gate for the
III-33
,,
,.
parasitic structure shown in Figure 8. The substrate will not invert unless a sufficient vertical field induced by this metallization run is present. Unless a careful analysis is performed to identi~ potential leakage paths, then testing should be performed with multiple bias conditions. Another common failure mode in digital bipolar circuits is sudden failure due to inversion of walled-emitter transistors. Testing of circuits that contain these transistors shows a gradual increase in supply current and then sudden circuit failure. With this type failure, in-situ bias was less critical. Circuits require bias to fail, but no pattern sensitivity was observed for specific structures. This is most likely due to the short channel that is required to invert the sidewall and the presence of adequate fringing field in most cases. Wafer mapping of the recessed field oxide failures[39] shows uniformity across the wafer, and from wafer to wafer within the same lot, to be good. Failure distributions were found to be within two sigma from wafer to wafer, indicating that a statistical sampling program can be used to predict the radiation response of the devices from lot sampling. Failure of digital bipolar devices fabricated in soft recessed field oxide processes is ve~ similar to CMOS fabricated in similar processes. The failure modes are predominantly inversion under or along the recessed oxide isolation and appear to have the same time response as CMOS. Test method 1019.4 should provide a conservative total dose test to predict the performance of these devices in space. 5.2 Linear Integrated Circuit Total Dose Response One of the earlier papers on total dose response of bipolar linear integrated circuits was published in 1975[ 14] and concerns the characterization and screening of devices for the Mariner Jupiter/Saturn spacecraft launched in 1977. Many of the linear integrated circuits of interest then are still being evaluated for current designs. These include the LM101A, LM108, LM124, HA2600, HA2620, and HA2700. Much of the concern at that time was identifying and screening out “maverick” devices that exhibited significantly greater total dose sensitivity, even though they were from the same lot and were processed no differently. No pre-irradiation electrical parameters could be identified that could screen out these devices. Considerable effort at that time was spent on developing an Irradiate-Anneal (IRAN) test method to irradiate devices to a low-to-moderate level and then perform a high-temperature anneal to anneal the radiation damage out. It was then projected that the devices would behave the same the second time and could be used as mission parts. Over the years, as data were collected on this test method, it was found that some devices did not respond the same on reirradiation or that the initial irradiation had to be so high that the damage could not be annealed out. This test method seemed to die out in the late 1970s. There was considerable information published on maverick devices [5] [ 14][ 15] [ 16][ 17][24] until 1980, but the cause of the unusual sensitivity or an effective screen was not identified in open publications. The primary test method for bipolar linear devices is to perform a step stress irradiation and characterize all ac and dc parameters at each level. Parameters that typically degraded or failed were input bias and offset currents and output offset voltage. A considerable amount of spot irradiation was performed in the late 1970s to identify the sensitive components that were causing the normal degradation 17][25]. As expected, the lateral and substrate pnp transistors III-34
were identified as being the sensitive elements in most designs. An excellent study by Johnston published in 1979[24] evaluated breakout transistors and LM108A operational amplifiers to investigate subwafer, wafer-to-wafer, and lot-to-lot variability. Again, the lateral pnp and substrate pnp were identified as being the sensitive elements. Maverick devices were still a problem with 1% identified as having a significant and sometimes different degradation than the normal lot distribution. No electrical parameter was identified that could be used to screen these devices. Some lots showed a very tight distribution in parameter degradation, while others showed a very broad distribution. Figure 20[24] shows this type distribution for two of the parameters on three lots.
35
35
~
mLots
A&B
I
o
L
o 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
01234567891011121314
AIB (lA)
AVO~(mV)
Figure 20 Distribution of Input bias Current and Output Offset Voltage Response to Total Dose for Three Lots of LM 108A.
Significant differences in response to electron irradiation compared to Cobalt-60 irradiation were reported in [33] [36] [41]. Previously, Figure 7 showed 2-MeV electrons producing three times the change and no signs of saturation at 250 kRad(Si) in input bias current for the LM111 comparator. Cobalt-60 saturated at 100 kRad(Si). This was identified as bulk damage in the wide-base substrate and lateral pnp. However, [41] reports an enhanced electron effect for an advanced bipolar technology with a fairly narrow base. If electrons are the predominant environment of concern, then irradiation in an electron source maybe advisable. 5.3 Low-Rate
Effects Introduction
It was first reported in 1991 by Enlow[44] that an advanced bipolar technology exhibited increased degradation when irradiated at lower dose rates. These initial data reported that the effect was observed for npn transistors in two processes from one manufacturer. Figure 21 shows the data from this first paper on the low-rate effect. Since the publication of this first paper, more than fifteen papers have been published on low-rate effects in bipolar transistors and microcircuits, showing bipolar processes and circuits from multiple manufacturers exhibit the Figure 22 is a well-published summary plot of the low-rate effect by low-rate effect. Johnston[54]. Figure 22 shows data on microcircuits from two manufacturers. For one circuit (LM108), no dose rate effect is observed. For another circuit (LM 101), the low-rate effect is
III-35
.,
observed to saturate at a factor of approximately 2x at dose rates below 1 rad(Si)/s. For other circuits (LM111 and LM324), no saturation in the effect is observed down to dose rates of .01 rad(Si)/s with factors of 5x and greater in degradation compared to irradiation at 50 rad(Si)/s. The remainder of the course will be spent on the recent research performed on low-rate effects in transistors and circuits and the progress toward identifying the basic mechanisms responsible and acceptable hardness assurance test methods. ,
().1 i
,, , . lff~i /
F
t
, *.1
i-
❑
, ~.,
,
,,. . v’.,
i
,
,
.
,
,
.
. 43’
n“
.
,
,fj.,
,
Q
.
,0.3
- a+ - 0-e-
.
0
},,,,,,,
1 - 1.1 2 -1.1 1 -300 2-300
Process
Procese Process Process
I , (36
,05
Total
Dose
radls radh radls radk
I
[
t
,0.4
107
(rad(SiOZ))
Figure 21 Change in A1/f3for npn in Two Processes vs. Total Dose at Two Dose Rates.[44]
* +
● A ■
LM108(npn) LM1o I (npn) LM1ll (pnp) LM324 (pnp)
-5
+ –4
-3
-2
-1
Discrete Transistors
0.001
0.01
0.1 Dose
Rate
1
10
100
(rad(Si)/see)
Figure 22 Effect of Dose Rate on Total Dose Damage Normalized to 50 Rad(Si)/s.
III-36
6.0 BIPOLAR LOW-RATE EFFECTS Enhanced total dose darnage at low dose rates has been studied extensively the last four years in bipolar processes, transistors, and microcircuits from multiple manufacturers. Test structures, transistors, or microcircuits are defined to exhibit enhanced low dose rate degradation when a measured parameter exhibits increased degradation at lower irradiation dose rates compared to the degradation at the same total dose at higher dose rates. The low-rate effect has been found to be nonexistent to minimal in some bipolar processes and severe in others. Even for processes that are known to exhibit the low-rate effect, only certain circuits maybe affected; and only some parameters may exhibit the enhanced degradation. It has also been observed to be bias-sensitive in some circuits, exhibit lot-to-lot variations, and -- in some devices -- to be extremely nonlinear. If one statement can be made to summarize the low rate effect, it is that it appears to be consistently inconsistent. In this section of the course, we will attempt to bring some consistency to our understanding of the dose rate effect. 6.1 Basic Mechanisms The enhanced low dose rate effect is a “true” dose rate effect rather than a timedependent effect as seen in MOS oxides. Thus, a post-irradiation anneal following a high dose rate irradiation will not produce the same results as observed at the end of a low dose rate irradiation. The “true” dose rate effect has been studied using MOS capacitors fabricated using a bipolar base oxide. A complete description of the study maybe found in the literature [51]. The major results of this investigation are: (1) the enhanced low dose rate effect occurs for a near zero electric field in the oxide during irradiation; and (2) the net trapped-hole density at low rate is larger, even though large numbers of holes and electrons are trapped at high and low dose rate. In addition to the “true” dose rate effects that occur as a result of different transport, recombination, and trapping properties during irradiation, there are also time-dependent effects following irradiations, especially after high dose rate irradiations. There are two models that have been proposed to explain the “true” dose rate effects [51 ][60]. A common feature of these models is that, if the irradiations are performed at either high electric field or at elevated temperature, the enhanced low dose rate effect should be minimized. The first model [51] suggests that, “during higher-rate irradiation, the large number of defects in the bulk of the oxide evidently retard the hole transport process by several decades over its normal duration. The slowly transporting or metastably trapped holes in the bulk of the oxide act in conjunction with the building space charge due to more deeply trapped holes near the Si/ SiOz interface to reduce the charge yield in the bulk of the oxide in the high-rate case as compared to the low-rate case. This reduction is due to the decreased local potential gradient (decreased local time-dependent electric field) between the trapped holes near the silicon interface and the gate, caused by increased positive charge in the oxide bulk or near the gate interface, as shown in Figure 23(a). The slowly transporting and/or metastably trapped holes III-37
.!
,.
.
in the bulk of the oxides also provide additional electrostatic fields during highrate irradiation that causes holes to be trapped, on average, a little closer to the Si/Si02 interface than during low-rate irradiation.”
m
@
++ + + +++ + +++++++++ +-
+
Delocalized Hole / Centers\
++
+ +
+
+
Holes in Deep Traps
+ ~++
+-
+- 4
-e-h Dipoles
1 —
+ ++ b +-
+++++++
I —
(a)
(b)
High Rate
Low Rate
Figure 23 Schematic Illustration of Mechanisms Contributing to Enhanced Net Positive Charge in Bipolar Screen Oxides at Low Dose Rates. Figure (a) Refers to High-Rate Irradiation and Figure (b) to Low-Rate Exposure. Mechanisms Apply to Soft Oxides at Low ElectricFields.[51 ]
“The reduction in charge yield at high rates due to these space charge effects, coupled with the relatively slow trapped-hole neutralization rate at O V for these devices, evidently accounts for the increase in trapped-hole density at low rates. That some holes are forced by the bulk space charge to be trapped a little closer to the silicon at high rates than they otherwise would be at lower rates facilitates the formation of neutral trapped-hole/electron dipoles near the silicon. Some dipoles will function electrically as border traps, and others will be electrically indistinguishable from annealed holes. This leads to the enhanced density near the Si/SiOz interface during the high-rate trapped-electron irradiations. Finally, space-charge and electrostatic back-pressure effects only dominate device response at low fields because the applied electric field dominates local fields for higher-field exposure.” The second model proposed in [60] suggests that “electron-trapped charge is smaller for large electric fields in oxides and low dose rates. For low dose rate conditions, the total positive charge in the oxide depends of the number of holes that escape recombination during dispersion transport. It is usually assumed that a hole combines with a free electron, but the interaction of a free hole with trapped electron must be taken into account. Thus, the presence of
III-38
negative-trapped charge in oxide can dramatically decrease the hole yield because of free hole recombination. The electron traps m important in bipolar screen oxides because the following conditions are satisfied. First, the electric field in the oxide is small. Therefore, the radiation-induced electron traps are occupied. Second, the conventional screen oxide is not radiation-hard, The capturing of holes takes place in the bulk of the oxide; therefore, the electron traps are generated along the entire path of the holes to the Si/Si02 interface. Under low dose rate irradiation, the occupation of electron traps is smaller than for moderate dose rates. It causes the decrease of hole loss due to the capture of holes at occupied electron traps, which leads to the increase of positive charge buildup. It means that the positive oxide-trapped charge in screen oxides increases with the decrease of dose rate. The thermal annealing of positive oxide-trapped charge at room temperature during long-time, low dose rate irradiation cannot compensate their growth caused by the increasing of positive charge yield.” Another model has been suggested [62] that may account for the time-dependent effects following the higher dose rate irradiation, such as the continued gain degradation in lateral and substrate pnp transistors. This model proposed in [62] suggests that “the hole transport, as described by the CTRW (continuous time random walk) model, can be applied to the thick field oxides and low electric fields present over the base-emitter junctions of bipolar transistors. Very thick oxides (= 1pm) are present over the base-emitter junction of substrate and lateral pnp transistors. It is assumed that the lowest dose rate for which devices still exhibit dose rate effects is due to the time required for charge to transport to the interface, which is extended to much longer time periods under low field conditions and also increases with oxide thickness. Previous field oxide work also showed that the fraction of the charge that remains trapped in the oxide bulk region is strongly This may explain why pnp transistors in the affected by the oxide thickness. junction-isolated processes exhibit more damage than npn transistors; oxides over the emitter-base region of pnp devices are approximately three times as thick as for npn transistors. Based on npn and pnp oxide thickness of 3500 and 10000 angstroms, respectively, the npn transistors should be affected by dose rates down to 1 rad(Si)/s and the pnp transistors down to .008 rad(Si)/s. Based on limited oxide thickness results, it predicts that the relative damage in npn transistors will be approximately a factor of two or three higher when bulk trapping is taken into Still account at low dose rates, compared to trapped charge at the interface. higher relative damage is expected for the thicker oxides in the pnp transistors, but it is not possible to estimate the magnitude of increased damage from the limited data available from field oxides. One possible explanation for the dose rate dependence is radiation-induced recombination, which would reduce the fraction of holes that are trapped in the bulk of the oxide. In order to test this assumption, an experiment was performed using the LM111 comparator under mixed dose rate conditions to examine the effect of nonconstant dose rates on enhanced damage.
III-39
One set of devices was initially irradiated at a low dose rate, increasing the dose rate to a much higher level after the initial irradiation was completed. The opposite dose rate scenario was used for a second set of devices. The results are shown in Figure 24, along with earlier results from a different group of devices irradiated at high rates. From the figure, it can be seen that high- and low-rate damage effects appear to be independent. These data suggest that, at least in thick oxides, once charge is trapped within the body of the oxide, little recombination occurs from the excess electron density produced by ionization. The implication is that charge in the bulk region acts independently from the mobile charge, a rather surprising result.”
500
500
50
rad(Si)/s
400
300 m
m “i
200
200
t t 100
50 rad(Si),
0
0
<
0
10
20
30
40
50
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 24 Degradation of Input Bias Current of an LM111 Comparator under Mixed Dose-Rate Conditions. [62]
In addition to the slow transport of holes in thick oxides at low fields, there may also be a slow buildup of interface states. If the primary mechanism for interface state buildup is the twostage process described by Winokur, et al.[71 ] and McLean, et al. [72], then the second stage buildup would be significantly increased in time for thick oxides at low field. However, there is some question about the actual nature of the interface state buildup in thick bipolar oxides, since it has been shown that there are prompt interface states in bipolar oxides that occur within milliseconds[73] [74]. Although models have been proposed to explain the enhanced low dose rate response, none of the models explains all of the observed behavior. Additional work will be required to fully explain both the irradiation and post-irradiation response.
111-40
6.2 Transistor and Circuit Response Increased gain degradation in bipolar transistors irradiated at low dose rates has been studied extensively for bipolar processes from several manufacturers since the first report in 1991. Figures 25 and 26 from [44] show the change in A1/~ for modern vertical crystalline emitter npn and pnp transistors irradiated to 70 krad(Si02) at three different dose rates and then annealed at room temperature. In each case, the gain degradation increased with decreasing dose rates and was a factor of two greater for the npn and three greater for the pnp for 1.1 versus 300 rad(Si02)/s at 70 krad. Minimal annealing was observed at room temperature for either transistor type.
1 ()-1
\\
10-2
~
VENDORA NPN 70 krad(SiO ) 1.1
rad(Si)jsec
-a-
16
rad(Si)/sec
~
3013 rad(Si)/sec
.
0 0
103
1(J4
105
106
Time (see) Figure 25 Change in A1/~ for Vertical Crystalline Emitter npn Transistor vs. Dose Rate.
III-4 1
10-’-T+~ VENDORA PNP
I ~
10-’
70 krad(SiO ) 1.1 rad(Si)/?sec
~
16
~
300
rad(Si)/sec rad(Si)/sec
-10-2
o%~ 0
0
103
104
105
106
Time (see) Figure 26 Change in A1/~ for Vertical Crystalline Emitter pnp Transistor vs. Dose Rate.
For a second process from Vendor B reported in [44], the A( l/~) degradation of a vertical polysilicon emitter npn transistor is a factor of four to seven greater for 1.1 versus 300 rad(Si02)/s at a total dose of 200 krad (SiOL). Additionally, for the Vendor B process, there was a continued decrease in gain for the devices irradiated at the higher dose rates during a room temperature anneal following irradiation. For the two Vendor C processes shown previously in Figure 21, the vertical polysilicon emitter npn transistor A( l/~) degradation was a factor of ten greater for process 1 and fifty times greater for process 2 for 1.1 versus 300 rad(SiOz)/s at a total dose of 200 krad (Si02). For the room temperature anneal testing of the process 1 and 2 devices irradiated at 300 rad(SiOz)/s, the process 1 device continued to decrease in gain, while the process 2 device gain was stable. Additional data on standard crystalline emitter npn transistor processes from [46] and [48] report a factor of 2x to 3x in base current increase when comparing low rate of 1 rad(SiOz)/s to 300 rad(Si02)/s Cobalt-60 irradiation. Figure 27 from [48] shows the additional increase in base current for this process at five different dose rates.
III-42
20
20
15-
1.5pm x 1.5~m Emitter
10-
-15
-10
5-
-5
—v o
BE- Ov I
100
101
I lr
I
o
1P
Dose Rata (rad(Si02)Asec)
Figure 27 Dose Rate Dependence of Standwd Crystalline Emitter Vertical npn Transistor.[48]
Similar dose-rate-dependent gain degradation has been shown for polysilicon emitter pnp transistors. The increase in base current for a lateral, substrate, and vertical geome~ device is shown in Figure 28 from [58]. All three devices show a strong dose rate dependence on gain degradation with the substrate device exhibiting a factor of 20x larger increase in excess base current and 10x greater increase for the lateral device for. 1 versus 1000 rad(Si02)/s. Although a limited dose rate range was presented for the vertical device, previous data from [44] would indicate an expected 10x to 20x factor for excess base current for the vertical pnp transistor over a. 1 to 1000 rad(Si02)/s dose rate range. Figure 29 from [58] replots the data from Figure 28 to The substrate pnp transistor still has show normalized current gain versus dose rate. approximately 7090 of its original gain after 100 krad (Si02) at the highest dose rate, but only about 1590 at the lowest dose rate. Similarly, the lateral pnp has about 2090 of the original gain after 100 krad (Si02) at the highest dose rate, but only about 3% at the lowest dose rate. For a circuit that may be designed to operate with a fixed minimum gain of 10 for a lateral pnp transistor and assuming an initial gain of 100, the circuit irradiated at the high rate would still have 2x margin for operation, while the circuit irradiated at the low dose rate would have failed long before 100 krad. Also, it should be noted that there is no indication that the dose rate dependence of gain degradation is saturating, even at dose rates below .1 rad(SiOz)/s.
III-43
.
,
,,
,
~1
I@
1 Figure 2s Excess Base Current
VPMP (500 kmd@lo*)) t
vs.
Dose
Rate
for Vertical, Substrate, and Laterai pnp Transistors.[58]
“L--
X.J) -
-
1
SPNP (loo
VPNP (500
kmd(sloJ) hmd(sloJ)
1~ ~
lIY
1~
101
101
lIY
DOW Rate
l(p
,@
,@
(rad(SiOJ/aec)
Figure 29 Normalized Current Gain vs. Dose Rate for Vertical, Substrate, and Lateral pnp Transistors.[58]
For some circuit parameters, the interaction between transistor degradation and the effect it will have on circuit parameter degradation are straightforward to analyze in some cases. Input bias current is one such case. A typical input structure was shown previously in Figure 7. In many cases, the input is directly driving the base of an input transistor; and, therefore, the input bias current is inversely proportional to the input transistor gain. The LM101 has a conventional vertical npn transistor for the input transistor. Figure 30 from [54] shows the change in input bias current for the LM 101 op amp versus total dose for several dose rates. Note that the degmdation is saturated at dose rates below .37 rad(Si)/s. Also, the low rate input bias current is
III-44
about a factor of two times greater at low rate versus high rate. This is similar to the transistor gain degradation reported for crystalline emitter vertical npn transistors shown in Figures 25 and 27, which exhibited a similar two to three times increase in base current for low rate versus high rate. Other circuits, such as the LM111 and LM324, utilize a substrate pnp transistor for the input transistor. Figure 31 from [54] shows the input bias current versus total dose at several dose rates for the LM324 comparator, which has a substrate pnp input transistor. For this circuit, there is a six times greater increase in input bias current between the high rate of 50 rad(Si)/s and the low rate of .005 rad(Si)/s at 15 krad(Si). Similarly, in [58], a much larger dose rate dependence was observed for the substrate pnp transistor, which was approximately twenty times over four decades of dose rate. Note also, in this case, that the dose rate dependence is not saturating until .005 to .002 rad(Si)/s.
20
20
15
➤
10
-10
-5
5 ~
0.02 red(Sl~sec 0.37 rad(SiYsec
~
50.0
❑
0
15
rad(si)kc
1“
I
I
I
I
0
10
20
30
40
o 50
Total Dose (rad(Si)) Figure 30 Change in Input Bias Cur-rentvs. Total Dose for LM 101 Op-Amp with Vertical npn Input Transistor for Several Dose Rates. [54]
III-45
350
350
300
300
250
200
150
100
50
50
0
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
Total Dose (rad(Si)) Figure 31 Change in Input Bias Current vs. Total Dose for LM324 Op Amp with pnp Substrate Input Transistor for Several Dose Rates.[54]
In the previous two examples, the parametric degradation was generally linear over a wide total dose range and was observable for a wide range of dose rates until saturating at very low dose rates. Other parameters exhibit more complex dose rate behavior. Figure 32 from [62] shows the change in input offset voltage (Vos) versus total dose for the LM324 op amp for several dose rates. For this parameter, there is minimal degradation in Vos versus total dose at dose rates of 50 or .005 rad(Si)/s out to a total dose of 70 krad(Si). However, when the dose rate is decreased to .002 rad(Si)/s, there is a large increase in Vos by 30 krad(Si). This large nonlinear response has serious hardness assurance implications in that, in this case, testing at higher rates and extrapolating the response to low rates do not predict the abrupt failure. The likely explanation for this type behavior is degradation of internal bias circuits, which causes sudden parametric or functional changes after the threshold for normal operation is exceeded. Many linear designs use lateral pnp transistors in the current sources and are designed to operate with a wide range of transistor gains. However, once the gain decreases below a minimum design value, the effect is to “starve” internal current sources, causing large changes in circuit parametric or functional performance once the operating threshold is exceeded. Further evidence of the degradation of internal current bias sources is shown in Figure 33 from [62]. Normalized power supply current versus total dose is shown for the same part type LM324, as shown in Figure 32, for several dose rates. The power supply current is decreasing with dose rate and total dose so that, at 25 krad(Si) at .002 rad(Si)/s, the total power supply current has decreased to less than 60’%0of the initial pre-rad value.
III-46
5
s
O.oozrlM(Sl)/COC
~
0.005rad(slysee 50.0 I’@slyeoc
~
~ 0’
0
s g -5-
--5
~B
-10-
--10 1.Ma94 ~tldAmpMlk blanlIhMhlmEmCbrOh Hu~ pup Input Tnndabr
-15
I
0
I
1
1
I
I
1020304050 Toti
Ikse
-15
1,
s070
so
(krad(Sl))
Figure 32 Input Offset Voltage vs. Total Dose for the LM324 Op Amp at Various Dose Rates. [62]
1.0
1.0
0.9
0.s
0.7
0.0
0.5
1,, ,, 0
1
5
10
1
15
1
1
20
2s
t 0.6 ao
Total Dme (krad(Si)) Figure 33 Normalized Power Supply Current vs. Total Dose for the LM324 Op-Amp at Various Dose Rates. [62]
The operating threshold for the current bias sources and circuits can vary greatly from circuit to circuit, even within the same process, and is primarily determined by the design margin that the circuit designer incorporates into the circuit. Also critical is the bias point for the transistors since, as shown previously, the transistor gain decreases much more rapidly at lower operating current levels. Since these are commercial Iineiu circuits, the circuit designer has chosen the operating point to achieve the targeted electrical performance, including power dksipation. Design margin is included to accommodate operation over the rated temperature
LII-47
.,
.
range, supply voltage, and normal manufacturing process variations while achieving required electrical performance and high manufacturing yield. A circuit with more design margin is likely to be more total-dose tolerant if all other factors are equal. For example, a circuit may be designed for a process that has a nominal lateral pnp gain of fifty, but will still operate within specification down to a minimum gain of ten. Some performance was probably sacrificed so that the circuit could operate over a wide range of conditions. Assume another circuit designed in the same process and designed for a minimum lateral pnp gain of twenty to achieve better performance. If the gain decreases the same for the lateral pnp in both circuits, the one designed to operate with a minimum gain of ten will be more total-dose tolerant (at least for nominal operating conditions) than the circuit requiring a gain of twenty. The LM137 voltage regulator is another circuit for which the gain degradation of a lateral pnp transistor was identified as the cause of low-rate failures at total dose levels below 15 krad(Si) for several manufacturers [55]. Selective irradiation with a scanning electron microscope, mechanical probing, and circuit analysis was used to identi~ a multi-collector lateral pnp in the startup circuit that was responsible for total dose failure. Devices that were irradiated at higher dose rates failed at two to three times higher levels. Probing of the lateral pnp transistors measured initial pre-rad gains of twenty that decreased to less than five at 15 krad(Si). Measurement and simulation of the circuit indicated that, when gain decreased below ten, a small additional gain decrease led to a large increase in the threshold voltage required for startup. The transistor identified as causing the failure also degraded faster than other lateral pnp transistors, which was attributed to the geome~ that had a larger perimeter region. Although no measurements were made directly relating pnp gain degradation to dose rate for this circuit, if the same trend as observed for the pnp transistor dose rate sensitivity reported in Figure 29 is applied, the failure levels observed and dose rate sensitivity would be similar. 6.2.1 Bias Effects The sensitivity of bipolw transistor gain degradation to applied bias during irradiation can vtu-y greatly between processes. In [46], it was reported that collector-base bias had a negligible effect on total dose gain degradation, which is consistent with the surface distance in the neutral base between the emitter-base junction and the collector. For the emitter-base junction, reverse bias produced slightly more gain degradation than no bias or a fonvard-biased emitter-base. However, in [54], it is reported that -- for discrete transistors -- gain degradation is strongly affected by collector-base voltage applied during irradiation. Much greater degradation occurred when the collector was biased at high voltage during irradiation and is four times greater for 50 volts collector-emitter bias than 10 volts. For most discrete devices, darnage was approximately a factor of two more when devices were irradiated under reverse bias (-2 volts) compared to moderate forward bias (0.5 volts). However, these results were for discrete transistors, whose fabrication process is significantly different than for monolithic integrated circuits. When four types of integrated circuits were irradiated at 50 rad(Si)/s in an unbiased condition, the darnage was nearly the same as in the biased case[54]. Similar results were reported in [63] when no bias was compared to static dc bias. Differences in total dose hardness between these two bias conditions were comparable to the part-to-part variation. Other similar results on many bipolar linear ICS were referred to in [56]. More significant bias effects were reported for high dose rate conditions in
III-48
[62] and are shown in Figures 34 and 35. Figure 34 shows the change in input bias current for the OP-27 op amp from one manufacturer for two dose rates and bias conditions. With the devices unbiased during irradiation, only a slight positive increase was measured for the input bias current, similar to the low dose response. When the circuit was irradiated under bias, a large negative input bias current occurred above 25 krad(Si) at high dose rates. Devices from a second manufacturer exhibited larger increases for the unbiased than the biased condition at the higher dose rate of 50 rad(Si)/s, as shown in Figure 35. These examples illustrate the different responses that can occur in the same part type from different manufacturers for various bias conditions and dose rates. The first time that a part type is radiation-tested, a conservative approach should be taken by evaluating the bias sensitivity for that particular device and not depending on extrapolating results from a similar part or same part type from a different manufacturer. Multiple mechanisms may also be involved in explaining the circuit response, each with a respective bias sensitivity.
m
r
1
H
400
-200
400
High Dose Rate =50 rad(SIYs
4oo -
Low Dose Rate = 0.005 rad(Si)ls ~ I-llghDoss Rats - Biased ~ l+lghDOSSRate - Unbiased ~ LOW DOSS R~e . Bias~
-soo -
-s00
,,,,,,l\,,l,.,, -1 Wo
0
I 10
r
-1000 20
30
40
so
Total Dose (krad(Si)) Figure 34 Input Bias Current vs. Total Dose for Linear Technology OP-27 Op Amp. [62]
11149
..
.
m 450 400 250 ~
Low DoseRate= 0.005rad(SIYaec
/F
m 250 2W 150 100 50 0
---
o
10
20
30
40
50
Total Dom @rad(Si))
Figure35 Input Bias Current vs. Total Dose for Analog Devices OP-27 Op Amp. [62]
6.2.2 Temperature
Effects
One of the models to explain the dose rate effect is that charge yield is reduced at high dose rates due to the large number of defects in the bulk of the oxide that retard the hole transport process by several decades of time, The slowly transporting or metastably trapped holes in the bulk of the oxide act in conjunction with the building space charge to reduce the charge yield in the bulk of the oxide in the high-rate case as compared to the yield in the low-rate case. To perform an independent check of this model, it was well known that hole transport is thermally activated. Moreover, delocalized hole centecs are typically neutralized at temperatures well below that at which deep hole traps anneal. An experiment was performed to see if capacitors, which simulated the screen-oxide over the base-emitter region, could be irradiated at a temperature high enough to speed the transport and/or annihilation of the metastable holes in the bulk of the oxide without significantly affecting the deeper trapped-hole distribution near the SiSi02 interface. The results of this experiment are shown in Figure 36 from [51], which shows the rnidgap voltage shift for a number of irradiations over a range of dose rates at 25°C compared to the shift at 60°C and 200 rad(SiOz)/s. Clearly, the midgap shift is larger after irradiation at 60°C than 25°C. Additionally, the 60”C at 200 rad(SiO#s irradiation shift is almost identical to the 25°C at 1 rad(SiOz)/s shift. To further validate the model, bipolar junction transistors were irradiated at 25°C and 60°C at varying dose rates. The results of this experiment are shown in Figure 37 from [51]. Again, the 200 rad (SiOz)/s irradiation at 60”C causes approximately three times greater increase in excess base current (and also in gain degradation, since the collector
nl-50
current is unaffected) than 25°C irradiation, consistent with the capacitor irradiation in Figure 36. At 20 rad(Si02)/s, the excess base current is even greater: However, at 1.7 rad(Si02)/s, significant annealing or compensation of holes in deep traps also occurs during the higher temperature irradiations, reducing the excess base current at 60”C. Still, the bipolar transistor response at elevated temperature and high dose rate is promising as a potential test technique to predict the low-rate response.
4.0
-4.0
900krad Biae = OV 25°C ● ● 60°c Dose=
B
45
E
-
●
4.5
25°C
--5.0
\ ●
--5.5
●
--6.0 ●
+5
I 10
1 Dme
Rate
I 100
-6.5 1000
(rad(SiOa)/see)
Figure 36 Midgap Voltage Shift vs. Dose Rate for 25 and 60°C Irradiation of Screen Oxide Showing Large Shift at 60°C, and High Rate is Equivalent to Low-RateShift.[51]
III-51
.,
,,
-
6
6 A
25°C 600C
~
-5
-4
A
-3 A
1!
-2
42 Is 01
A
-1
z
o 0.1
I 1 Do6e
I 10 Rate
I 100
I lmo
o
(rad(SiOJ/6ec)
Figure 37 Normalized Excess Base Current vs. Dose Rate at 100 krad(Si02) for 25 and 60”C Irradiation of npn Bipolar Transistor Showing 60°C and High Rate Bound Low Rate Increase.
A similar experiment was performed on lateral pnp bipolar transistors to validate the applicability of the theory for a different class of devices than discussed previously, Extensive high temperature testing was performed by irradiating devices at 24,45, 60, 80, 100, and 125°C at a dose rate of 167 rad(Si02)/s. Figure 38 from [59] shows the excess base current at V~ = 0.7V for lateral pnp devices irradiated to 100 krad(Si02). For comparison, the dashed line represents the degradation in devices irradiated at 0.1 rad (Si02)/s, but at room temperature. The excess base current increases approximately linearly with irradiation temperature in this temperature range, The continued increase in excess base current as a function of irradiation at the highest temperature of 125°C used in these experiments is surprising. However, devices irradiated at room temperature, but annealed at high temperature, show the damage begins to recover at 150”C. This suggests that 125°C may be close to the maximum temperature to maximize darnage for this process. The excess base current for the same devices is shown in Figure 39 from [59] versus total dose for devices irradiated at a variety of dose rates. It can be seen that the excess base current increase of the device irradiated at 100”C and the high dose rate of 167 rad(SiOz)/s is larger than any of the devices irradiated at lower dose rates and 25”C, including the devices at .01 rad(Si02)/s. High-temperature irradiation, as a method to predict the low-rate response, will be discussed in greater detail in a later section.
III-52
S.o —
3
-’
S.o
1S7 radh (x-ray)
5.0
-6.0
4.0
-4.0
3.0
-3.0
2 ———
———
20
—
Irmdlaiud
Dwl~
-2.0
at 0.1 MCUS(CO-so) -1.0
1.0
0.0
1 I 020408060100 Irradiation
1
1
1
I
0.0
120140
Temperature (“C)
Figure 3S Excess Base Current at V~~ = 0.7 V vs. Irradiation Temperature for Lateral pnp Transistor Irradiated to 100 krad(SiOJ at 167 rad (SiOJ/s in an X-ray Source. The Dashed Line Represents Devices Irradiated at 0.1 Rad (SiOJ/s in a CO-60 Source. The X-ray Data Have Been Scaled to Account for Source Differences. [59]
lW
10
1
Total Dose (krad(SiOJ) Figure 39 Excess Base Current vs. Total Dose for Devices Irradiated at a Variety of Dose Rates. The HighTemperature ( 10O°C), High-Rate (167 Rad(SiO#s Excess Base Current is Higher Than Any of the Low-Rate Devices. [59]
III-53
.,
.
.
,,
.
High temperature irradiation of circuits produced less dramatic results than the individual transistor testing. Figure 40 from [54] shows the results of irradiating LM111 comparators at various dose rates and temperatures. A substantial increase in input bias current occurred when the devices were irradiated at an elevated temperature of 60”C at 50 rad(Si02)/s compared to room temperature at the same dose rate. However, the net increase, a factor of about 1.7, was only about a third of the increase at low dose rates. Similar results were reported for elevated temperature irradiation of LM101, LM 124, and LM 139 circuits [1], where devices were irradiated at 125°C and 100 rad(SiOz)/s. This was compared to data taken at room temperature and .001 and .01 rad(SiOz)/s. Input bias current increased by about a factor of three for the elevated temperature high rate over the room temperature high rate, but was a factor of two to as much as eight less than the input bias current increase for the low-rate parts. Therefore, while elevated temperature irradiation of transistors appeared to be a promising test method to predict the low-rate response, it has not been validated for circuits. Additional work will be necessary to investigate optimal irradiation temperature and possible combination with overtest and annealing.
300
+ +
0.005 rad(Si)/s 0.02 rad(Si)/s
+ . . .
50 rad(Si)/s
I
60”C -50 rad/s
300
/
1
200
100 !-
0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Total Dose (rad(Si)) Figure 40 Effect of Elevated Temperature Irradiation on Input Bias Current Increase forLM111 Comparator Showing Elevated Temperature Causes Increased Damage vs. Room Temperature, But Does Not Bound Low Rate Damage.[54]
6.2.3 Post-Irradiation
Response
The post-irradiation response of bipolar transistors and circuits is varied, depending on the fabrication process, circuit type and manufacturer, measured parameter, and post-irradiation temperature. Figure 41 from [48] shows the post-irradiation response of a standard emitter vertical npn transistor that was irradiated to 500 krad(SiOz) at 240 rad(SiOz)/s and then annealed
III-54
under 2-V base-emitter reverse bias at various temperatures. For the room temperature annealing condition, the base current recovered slightly after the 150-minute anneal. For the isochronal anneal, slightly more recovery was observed from the 30-minute 60”C anneal; but significant recovery was observed after an additional 30-minute 100°C anneal and 30-rninute 150”C anneal. Continued, but smaller, recove~ was observed after 30-rninute 200 and 250”C 30-minute anneals shown. Similar nxults are shown in Figure 42 from [44] for a polysilicon emitter npn transistor that was annealed at 100”C. However, during the first 1000 to 3000 seconds of the anneal, there was a continued slight decrease in gain (presumably increase in base current); and then the gain continued to recover until the end of the 168-hour anneal.
12
1
J
I
I ------
----
---
12
. ..---..
- -10
10BtandardEmtttar
-0
82V Ravamse Elm 1.5pmx 1.5pm Emitter
6-
-6
4-
-4
-2
2— o
l~hronal Annaallng ROemI Tamparatura Annsallng
I Inlt
Poatrad
60”C
Anneal
I 1 W“C
1 150°c
I moot
o 250”C
Temperature
Figure41 Room Temperature and Isochronal Anneal of Reverse-Biased Standard Emitter npn after 50C-krad Irradiation at 240 rad(SiOJ/s Showing Recovery after 30-Minute Anneals at (A)60, (B)1OO,(C) 150, (D)200, (E)250°C. [48]
III-55
,.
,,
.
—— —— —— —— I r Range of 1.1 rad/s Data
- 10+
~
100°-200 kract(slo2)
~
100°-300
krad(sio2)
1 0
l@
ld
I@
lm
Time (see) Figure 42
Elevated Temperature Anneal of Polysilicon Emitter npn after 200- to 300-hd rad(Si02)/s Showing Continued Degradation and Then Recovery. [44]
Irradiation at 300
A set of experiments was designed to evaluate the post-radiation response of polysilicon emitter lateral pnp transistors. Unlike the npn transistors discussed previously, the laterid pnp transistors continued to degrade during room-temperature and elevated-temperature annealing. Figure 43 from [59] shows the excess base current versus time after being irradiated to 100 krad(Si02) at 10 rad(Si02)/s and annealed at room temperature. The excess base current continues to increase following irradiation and approaches the amount of degradation in devices irradiated at low dose rates, as shown by the dashed line(,05 rad(Si02)/s). After 48 hours, the increase in excess base current saturated and remained almost constant until the end of the 168hour post-irradiation test. Additional lateral pnp transistors were irradiated to 100 krad(Si02) at 167 rad(Si02)/s and then an isochronal anneal performed for 30 minutes at each temperature up to 150°C. Figure 44 from [59] shows the excess base current at Vw = 0.7 V versus anneal temperature. The base current increases slightly during the w,neals up to 125°C , before decreasing slightly during the 150°C anneal. These transistor results suggest that circuits may respond differently during postirradiation anneals, depending on the dominant degradation mechanism. If either crystalline or polysilicon emitter npn transistors are responsible for the degradation, the circuit may exhibit recovery during the post-irradiation anneal, especially if the anneal is performed at elevated temperature, If lateral pnp transistors dominate the circuit parametric or functional degradation,
III-56
the circuits may show additional degradation during the post-irradiation anneal and even degrade slightly more if the anneal is performed at elevated temperatures up to 125°C. If a third mechanism is involved, such as leakage current due to inversion of a p-surface layer, the device will likely show more response at a higher dose rate and recover during a post-irradiation anneal. Since many bipolar circuits can have all three mechanisms occurring simultaneously, the initial and post-radiation response can be quite complex.
ao
L
40
20
3 ---3.0
a 1.0
~o~
-m — -20
ao
0244SZ2W Total
1
Ilc6rd(sqys(m ——
20
-4.0
PO&rl-md-hnfull’Kmel
120
lulm
atwC(haula)
F@re 43 ExcessBase Currentvs. PostIrradiationRoom-TemperatureAnnealTime for Lateratpnp Irradiatedto 100krad(SiOJ at 10rad(Si02)/s (X-ray) Showing Continued
Figure 44 Excess Base Current vs. PostIrradiation Anneal Temperature for Lateral pnp Irradiated to 100 krad (Si02) at 167 rad(Si02)/s Cobalt-60 Showing Continued Degradation up to 125°C Anneal Temperature. [59]
Degradation Post-Irradiation. [59]
The different post-irradiation response of circuits at various post-irradiation temperatures is shown in the following examples. In [54], annealing tests were done after both low and high dose rate irradiations to see if the damage was stable. Devices were measured after annealing at room temperature for time periods of approximately 200 hours. Changes of only a few percent occurred in input bias current. Post-irradiation response was quite different for the Motorola LM139 comparator. Figure 45 from [63] shows this device to be dose rate sensitive with minimal degradation occurring in J&f,etat 200 kradh and significant degradation occurring at 15 krad/h and 300 rad/h. The postirradiation response of the 200 Icrad/h devices after an irradiation to 37 krad is shown in Figure 46 from [63]. ~ff~~ increased slightly at 25°C until 200 hours after irradiation, after which it However, when annealed at elevated temperature, ~ff~t increased decreased slightly. significantly at a post-irradiation temperature of 70”C and even more at 10O°C. This response may also be due to the balance between the input transistor matched pair and less to the absolute degradation in gain.
III-57
.
,,
.
4m m
m
100 0
4m~0
10
20 Total
90 Ihm
44
60
11---11:
so
0
lmzmsooua5m Time
(krad(si))
soo
(hours)
Ngure 46 b~~ vs. Anneal Time after 37 krad Irradiation at 200 kradh and at Three Anneal Temperatures for Motorola LM139. [63]
Figure 45 ~m~,vs. Total Dose at Three Dose Rates for Motorola LM 139.[63]
Post-imadiation room-temperature response for the 0P400 is shown in Figure 47 from [63]. The device exhibits little dose rate sensitivity with a 40-krad irradiation producing nearly equal increases in input bias current. However, the post-irradiation response is significantly different between the three dose rates. The highest rate device recovered 75% of the end-ofirradiation increase in input bias current. The lowest rate device recovered only about 20% of the end-of-irradiation increase. This is unusual in that no irradiation dose rate sensitivity was observed, but the post-irradiation anneal is sensitive to the irradiation dose rate.
20
t
,~o o
400 ‘rime
600
Soo
1000
Olol.ire)
Figure 47 25°C Annealing of 0P400 after 40 krad Irradiation Showing Significant Difference in Post-Irradiation Response, Depending on Irradiation Dose Rate.[63]
III-58
The post-irradiation response for the LMl 37 voltage regulator was evaluated for four different manufacturers in [55]. The post-irradiation response measurements for these devices consisted of a 24-hour at 25°C anneal immediately after irradiation, followed by a 168-hour at 100”C anneal. Parts from manufacturers A, B, and C exhibited the same functional failure mode of failure to regulate below a minimum voltage, referred to as VO~. Previous discussion of this device identified a lateral pnp transistor as believed to be responsible for the failure. The manufacturer D part exhibited only minor degradation. If a lateral pnp is responsible, it would be expected that the circuit would degrade further during the post-irradiation anneal. However, the devices from manufacturers A and C showed minimal change after the 24-hour and 25°C anneal, while the manufacturer B devices exhibited significant recove~ after the 24-hour anneal. All three manufacture’ devices exhibited almost complete recovery after the 168-hour and 100”C anneal. These results indicate that either the lateral pnp transistor is not the responsible failure mechanism or this pnp transistor has a different post-imadiation response than previously discussed. The post-irradiation response of the LM124, LM137, and LM139 ICS is discussed in [56] for a 168-hour at 25°C anneal followed by a 300-hour at 100”C anneal. The LM124 has a pnp input transistor, so input bias current is inversely proportional to the pnp transistor gain. The LM124 post-irradiation response follows the expected behavior by increasing slightly for the 25°C anneal, and then both the high rate and low rate increase substantially after the 100”C anneal. Most of the other LM124 parameters have some post-irradiation response, but the responsible circuit element is difllcult to identi@ without doing a detailed circuit analysis. The LM139 input bias current had a similar response to the LM124 with a slight increase for the 25°C anneal and then a substantial increase after the 100”C anneal. Again, this would be expected, since the LM 139 also has a pnp input transistor. The LM137 had a different post-irradiation response in that the device showed significant recovery after the anneal, as reported previously. This would also indicate that the pnp transistor gain degradation is not responsible for the degradation. It is obvious that, since many of the bipolar linear circuits contain a combination of lateral pnp, substrate pnp, and vertical npn transistors, the dose rate and post-irradiation response can be a complex combination of gain degradation for the three; and identi~ing the responsible circuit element(s) can require more sophisticated analysis tools. These will be discussed in the next two sections on circuit modeling and scanning electron microscope spot irradiation. 6.3 Circuit Modeling Circuit analysis is primarily performed using a combination of hand analysis by experienced circuit analysts and SPICE simulations. SPICE analysis requires an accurate netlist describing the complete circuit, as well as accurate bipolar transistor models to describe the preand post-electrical characteristics of the transistors. The netlist can be generated by cooperation from the manufacturer (which may be difficult) or by reverse engineering (which can be timeconsuming). A photomicrograph is taken of each circuit to be reverse-engineered and analyzed to determine transistor polarity, layout, and emitter area and geometry. One difllcult aspect of generating an accurate netlist is including all parasitic elements and potential parasitic elements Either breakout transistors (transistor die from a test chip that may be formed post-irradiation. typically dropped into a few circuit locations on the wafer) must be obtained from the manufacturer or transistors isolated from the circuit and microprobe to obtain pre-irradiation
III-59
.
electrical characteristics. At least one transistor of each polarity and, ideally, several with various geometries should be characterized to extract geometrical dependence of SPICE parameters, including radiation effects due to emitter area and perimeter. The transistor’s electrical data are input into a parameter extraction program such as UTMOSV to extract the Gurnrnel model parameters. These parameters are scaled by emitter area or emitter perimeter for each transistor and verified by running a SPICE curve-tracer plot and comparing actual data to the actual parameters. Once a set of pre-irradiation parameters is obtained, a circuit simulation is performed to verify the pre-irradiation electrical characteristics of the circuit and compare simulated to measured values. Irradiations are then performed on the breakouts or isolated transistors at high and low dose rates for several dose levels. Breakouts are much easier to characterize, since they can be packaged and irradiated with bias applied, such as in the application circuit design. Isolated transistors are much more difficult to work with, since no bias can be applied during irradiation; and obtaining good contact repeatedly can be difficult These irradiation data are fit to extract the degraded transistor model using microprobe. parameters and the simulation repeated to simulate the post-irradiation performance. Simulations are then compared to the actual measured response. Once a set pre- and post-rad model has been established and agreement has been obtained between simulated and measured response, the circuit model can be modified to identify the critical elements that determine the radiation response. The most difficult task in performing accurate circuit simulation is obtaining accurate degraded transistor models that incorporate all parasitic effects, such as electric field from layout and metallization runs. The SPICE simulations are also useful in obtaining the worst case dc bias conditions for the circuit irradiations, if the worst-case transistor bias is known. 6.4 SEM Irradiation Spot irradiation with a scanning electron microscope has long been a valuable tool for identifying sensitive circuit elements and even transistor areas [7] [10] [15] [17] [18] [25] [55] and was a popular tool in the 1970’s before x-ray irradiators became popular. The advantage of a SEM is that it can be focused to a very small area and used to selectively irradiate a single transistor junction, a single transistor, an area of an IC, or even an entire IC. The SEM has been used previously to identi~ the emitter-base junction as the total dose sensitive area of the bipolar transistor [7] and was used to identify transistors responsible for circuit failure [15] [17] [25]. Attention must be paid to the depth dose profile as the typical SEM has an energy of about 20-40 keV, so penetration depth is limited. Correlation to Cobalt-60 irradiations should be established if quantitative results are important. The SEM has been used more recently to identify a multi-collector lateral pnp transistor as the circuit element responsible for the failure of the LM 137 voltage regulator [55]. Typically, a SEM irradiation experiment is performed by setting up the circuit under investigation to monitor critical electrical parameters in situ. An entire circuit irradiation may then be made to correlate the Cobalt-60 irradiation results with the SEM irradiation and also establish dosimetry calibration. Depending on how much is known about the circuit design and potential sensitive areas or transistors, selective areas are irradiated to isolate the degradation down to the desired sensitive area. Caution must be observed when only irradiating small circuit areas, because gain balances may be upset, which may cause unrealistic degradation that would not occur when more uniform gain degradation occurs during Cobalt-60 degradation.
111-60
7.0 HARDNESS ASSURANCE
TEST METHOD DEVELOPMENT
The development of an efllcient and reliable test method to predict the low-rate response of bipolar circuits, while keeping the test time reasonable (especially in the radiation source), is critical to identifying robust devices for long-term space applications. Few facilities can afford to dedicate a radiation source for the months to years that would be required to test to the lowest rates at which the dose rate effects saturate. Few systems can afford the time that would be required to conduct such long-term tests. This next section will look at some potential test methods to accelerate the test time required to accurately and reliably predict the low-rate response. 7.1 High Temperature
Irradiation
Elevated temperature irradiation of transistors and circuits was discussed extensively in the previous section. Figure 35 showed that a conventional npn transistor irradiated at 60°C and at 20 to 200 rad(Si02)/s had a larger excess base current increase than an npn transistor irradiated at 25°C and at lower dose rates of 0.4 to 2 rad(SiOz)/s. Figures 36 and 37 showed similar results for a polysilicon emitter lateral pnp where an irradiation temperature of 100°C at 167 rad(Si02)/s bounded the excess base current increase for dose rates down to .01 rad(Si02)/s. While these transistor results were promising, they were both on developmental processes for which no doserate-sensitive circuits were available to validate the circuit response at elevated temperature. Elevated temperature irradiation at high dose rates of the LM101, LM1 11, LM124, and LM 139 circuits found that they failed to predict the low-rate response by a factor of two to eight, as reported previously and shown in Figure 38. Only one elevated temperature was tried for each of these circuits, so it is unlikely that the optimum elevated temperature was selected for the experiment, Unfortunately, these circuits were from a commercial process for which there were no test transistors available to help optimize the irradiation temperature. As noted before, the npn and pnp transistors have different acceleration factors; so there may not be one optimal temperature for circuits that contain both type devices. Additional work is needed to see if an optimal irradiation temperature exists for the processes and circuits that exhibit excessive low-rate degradation. Test transistors from the same process and, ideally, from the same lot as the circuits would greatly assist the effort. Even if an optimal low-rate temperature can be identified, it may not completely bound the low-rate response. A combination of high-temperature irradiation, overtest, and post-irradiation anneal may be required to completely bound the low-rate response and serve as a reliable test method. 7.2
Post-Irradiation
Anneal
Post-imadiation anneal testing of conventional and polysilicon npn and polysilicon NPN transistors tend to emitter lateral pnp transistors indicates that they behave opposite. recover slightly during room temperature anneal and recover significantly at higher temperature The lateral pnp transistors behave the opposite and exhibit significant additional anneals. degradation during room temperature anneal and degrade slightly more at elevated temperatures. Figures 39 through 42 previously indicated this behavior. As expected, there was a varied circuit response during the post-irradiation anneal, depending on what was the dominant circuit element
III-6 1
causing the degradation. Some circuits exhibited recovery, and others showed additional degradation. However, in almost all the reported cases, the post-irradiation degradation did not bound the low-rate response. Figure 48 from [56] shows the post-irradiation response tier a 168-hour 25°C anneal followed by a 100”C 30Q-hour anneal. For most of the parameters, the anneal did not bound the low-rate response, although it did for a few parameters. Additional testing would be required to see if this were valid for very low dose rates. Similar results were reported for the LM 124 as shown in Figure 49 from [56]. For some parameters, the anneal is still a factor of two short of predicting the low-rate response. Since, in most circuit cases, the dominant circuit element is not known, a 25°C anneal may be the optimal temperature to accelerate the pnp degradation without causing too much recovery in the npn transistors. Also, again, an anneal by itself as a test technique may not totally bound the-low-rate response.
III-62
10
Li
I
I
1
I , ––––4––-
-–––
-
a .–:–
-
I —— ___
_____
I
V=.5V v- . 0.4V V=.
Im%
==1 I
————— +AV13 -HI *AVQf
sv
___–;___
—_—_
––––&–
-–__.
_
~ W
0.1 0 (0)
Iv Toti
k
Iv (A(W)
Anneal
o
Im
100 Blad
10J
(d)
(b)
TM
Dom
m
Iv B&d
I ~Av(3+AVG
Anneal
(hrs)
I W,WB
-
lmo
llm
(rd(Si))
I
~&dB *
semi
- ––––––*–––––
$
iL
3 o~.
r —
––––-!---
-
-–––.
-
I
Y ––––;––_
1
SC
1 om-
-–––
I I
Im%
––––&
—
-–––.
+
I
-
I ..3
T
A
n
I I
0 0 (b)
Iv
I@ Total
Dose
lm Bw
(rad(Si))
la
Anneal (k)
I
lti
0 (,)
Toti
100
Iu
DOM (rad(Si))
Biased
Ium
.4nnanl
Iom (b)
I ––––+––-
-–––
-
I
––––L -–––a V=.w
I
_:dl_L___––
I -–:_
____J___
+AVG-~#IFkh -C-AVQ.LWRrh ?
tic
(
.
Ilmc
10 0 (c)
Iv
1P Toti
Dae
(rd(El))
Figure48
Im
BW
~139Low
Annd
Iom
0
(0
(hrd
Iv
Ta.bIDom(A(Si))
mdHigh Dow Rate Res~n=Post-htiiation
III-63
1P
100
Bti
bad
Annealing Behavior. [56]
Icm
@)
100
400
I
I
[
AVG-HI hRate AVG -LO Rate 1
A +
s j
I
––––-L–-–––-
1__––;––.
10
I
.–––.
& g
_ 25°C [
1Oo”c
I
~
___–~––_
I
-––_.
-
“ t
i, 2 R s .
,
c1
+–-
-–:–. 25°C
1
,
A R,=101d3
1Oo”c
I
___–J––_
~–––.
-
I
~AVG-Hi hRate -c- AVG -LOk Rate
I 0.1 7 0 (a)
I
0 1o~ Total Dose
105
100
1000
Biased Anneal (hrs)
(rad(Si))
104
o (d)
( 105
Total Dose (rad(Si))
! 100
1000
Biased Anneal (hrs)
1.0*
0.8-
$
‘$ m 0.6 -— g
~ U2
I
I
~_
0.2- –_____}_–––– I I
0.0 104
0
I@
Total Dose (rad(Si))
(b)
100
1000
Biased Anneal (hrs)
o (e)
1000
104
105
TotalDose(rad(Si))
100
1000
Biased Anneal (hrs)
1.0
* -C-
AVG-Hi hRate AVG-L.a
i
Rate
g 0.4 ––––––l––––––– ..! Y1
< 25-C
I
I
1Oo”c
I
––––––}_–___
:––.
-–––.
-
I 1 0 (c)
, 1o~
0.0 10$
Total Dose (rad(Si))
Figure49
100
Biased Anneal (hrs)
1000
0 (f)
10,
Total Dose (rad(Si))
1OS
r
r
i00
1000
Biased Anneal (hrs)
LM124Low and High Dose Rate Response and Post-Irradiation Annealing Behavior. [56]
7.3 Overt.est Overtesting, by irradiating a circuit at high dose rate to a high enough level beyond the requirement to simulate the low-rate response, will only be effective if the high-rate degradation keeps increasing linearly. In many cases, this method is not effective due to saturation at the high dose rates or nordinear increases at the low dose rates. Figure 50 from [62] shows the saturation of the high-rate response for the LM1 11, No reasonable amount of overtest at the high dose rate will predict the low-rate response that is saturating at a value of about ten times the high rate response. Another example is shown in Figure 51 from [62], where there is minimal response at the high dose rate (and even at low dose rates above the low-rate threshold for effect). It is, again, unlikely that any amount of reasonable overtest will be an effective predictor of the lowrate response.
lzm~
1
lzm lm
Im S@udm
/
dmm
- la
dmnlwmlmadullox
Em
m
II
4m
-10 am
-
0M2 d(slymc
-0-
-
6M
rd(e~ d(siync
1 -10
o o
20
40
‘rotil b
w
m
lm
m
(knd(so)
Figure 51 Nonlinear Input Offset Voltage Response of LM324 Op Amp at Low Dose Rate. [62]
Figure 50 Saturation Characteristics of LM I I 1 Comparator Input Current at Low and High Dose Rate. [62]
Can an effective test method be developed to predict the low rate response at reasonably high dose rates? Recent data from [68] indicate that there may be combinations of hightemperature irradiation, overtest, and post-irradiation anneal that can bound the low-rate response. Figures 52, 53, and 54 from [68] show the results from a combination of overtest with post-irradiation room temperature anneal. Figure 52 shows the input bias current increase for the LM139 comparator versus total dose and post-irradiation anneal time for various dose rates. Several devices are irradiated at a low rate of about 1.5 rad(Si02)/s to 200 krads. Other devices are irradiated to 500 (2.5x overtest) and 600 krads (3x overtest) at about 150 rad(SiOz)/s. Even at these factors of overtest, the highrate response is less than the low rate at 200 krads immediately after irradiation. However, after a 150-day unbiased room temperature anneal, the 2.5x overtest is only slightly less than the lowrate response (including low-rate anneal) and the 3x overtest bounds the low-rate response. Of coume, this technique would have to be validated for lower dose rates and additional devices and processes; but it is promising.
III-65
.,
,&.
Iv
Jw
lW
b
(rmdiBIOJ)
Tohl
OM
lm AmnBd lhlcl
lW
sm
,
w
W Told
(DDyd
omlm
1*
h
lmd(EIO~)
Im Anmd
h
2M
row.)
Figure 53 NationalLM111 Comparator Overtest and Anneal Results. [68]
Figure 52 LMl 39 Comparator Overtest and Anneal Results. [68]
Figure 53 shows the increase in input bias cument for the LM111 comparator versus total dose and post-irradiation anneal for various dose rates. One device is irradiated at a low rate of 1.5 rad(Si02)/s to 200 krads. A second device is irradiated to 600 krads (3x overtest) at a higher dose rate of about 165 rad(SiOz)/s. The high-rate irradiation stop point was past saturation and on the decline, so that the 200-krad low-rate point had about three times the input bias current increase as the high-rate point. At the end of the 150-day room temperature anneal, the high-rate device was only about 10% less than the low-rate device.
250 ~ ~ 2W -
#m4-txmawta = 1.4rWaw Total Daae = 2Wkred #27f3-Doae Rata =1S0 rad/aao Total
Dose
= WOkrod
~ 3 Qlm
-
t : K
100
E a 4
so
Annaal
Blaa:
Conduotlva
Foam
o IN
104
lN
o
60
lm
1s0
Anneal Time (Days)
Total Dose (rad(SiOZ))
Figure 54 LM124 Op Amp Overtest md Anneal Results. [68]
III-66
2m
Figure 54 shows the increase in input bias current for the LM124 op amp versus total dose and post-irradiation anneal time for two dose rates. One device was irradiated at a low dose rate of 1.4 rad(Si02)/s to a dose of 200 krads, and a second device was irradiated at a higher rate of 150 rad(Si02)/s to a dose 500 krads for an overtest of 2.5x. Even with the overtest, the increase in input bias current was less than the low-rate part immediately after irradiation. However, after a 150-day room temperature anneal, the input bias current for the higher-rate part had exceeded the low-rate increase. Although the sample size and type of circuits were limited, a combination of 2.5 to 3 times room-temperature irradiation at high dose rate followed by a 50day room-temperature anneal bounds the low-rate response. Additional verification testing needs to be confirmed at lower dose rates and on a larger set of circuits. Including an elevated temperature irradiation or anneal combination may allow for a reduced overtest or reduced anneal time.
8.0 FUTURE TRENDS Although bipolar technologies are not advancing at nearly the same rate as CMOS, there have been significant advances recently with polysilicon and double-poly emitters and bases, bonded-wafer substrates, device scaling, and silicon-germanium devices. Single and doublepolysilicon base and emitters permit extremely shallow emitter and base regions. These allow for narrower base widths of 500~ and less, which contribute to much higher cutoff frequencies (fT). Many current mainstream advanced-performance bipolar processes have fm of 5 to 10 GHz. State-of-the-art bipolar processes that are just becoming commercially available have frs of up to 25 GHz and support circuit applications with operational bandwidths of 1 to 2 GHz. Total dose test results are limited, but reports such as [69] indicate hardness of up to 1 Mrad(Si02) with minimal circuit performance degradation. This is likely due to the use of only vertical npn and pnp transistors and the high surface concentrations due to ion-implanted or polysilicon-doped base and emitter junctions and thinner surface oxides. Unfortunately, many of these processes and circuits are for low voltage operation of 5 V and less; so considerable system redesign would be required to utilize these circuits. Also, the broad “standard product” base of circuits, such as the LM- and OP-series of devices that many cument systems utilize, is not available in advanced technologies. Several bipolar processes, such as Analog Devices XFCB, Harris UHF, and UTMC ACUTE, employ bonded-wafer substrates and trench isolation for complete oxide isolation of each circuit element. A cross section of typical devices was shown previously in Figure 5. The oxide isolation gives improved noise performance and reduced parasitic capacitance, which allows for faster devices and circuits. The biggest radiation improvement is in the high dose rate environment, where latchup is eliminated and photocurrent collection reduced, resulting in improved upset. Total dose hardness can be improved because there are no potential device-todevice leakage paths; and the need for a long-temn isolation diffusion, which has been shown The circuit total dose hardness is previously to degrade total dose hardness, is eliminated. primarily determined by the transistor fabrication method, as has been previously discussed. One of the most recent bipolar advances is the development of the silicon-germanium heterojunction bipolar transistor (HBT). With base widths of 350~ or less, frs of up to 117 GHz III-67
Preliminary radiation test results on transistors from this process [66] have been reported. indicate the potential forgood total dose hardness. Applications forthis technology are targeted for 10- to 20-GH2 RF applications.
9.0 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to acknowledge the support of our sponsors, Mr. Lewis Cohn of the Defense Nuclem Agency and Mr. Al Kuehl of the US Army Space and Strategic Defense Command, for providing the funding that has made much of the research in this area possible. The many researchers who have dedicated years to performing research and publishing in this area have provided invaluable historical material that has been used extensively in the preparation of this Mr. Ron Pease has provided guidance into organizing what, at times, has course material. seemed like chaos. Mr. John Bings has re-engineered the figures and drawings into a high Mrs. Linda Ramsden has provided invaluable editorial support in turning quality format. fractured barely intelligible English into coherent material. Most of all, I am thankful for my wife, Pam, who has helped, many a late night, to keep me going on this.
III-68
REFERENCES
[1]
R. L. Pease, H.J. Tausch, H. Barnaby, R.D. Schrimpf, D.M. Schmidt, “Radiation Analysis Transistors of Bipolar and Circuits,” MRC/ABQ-R- 1764 final report to NAVSURFWARCENDIV Crane (December 1995).
[2]
R.J. Widlar, “A Unique Circuit Design For a High Performance Operational Especially Suited to Monolithic Construction,” Proc. NEC, Vol. XXI, p. 85 (October 1965).
[3]
R.J. Widlar, “Op Amp With Improved Input-current Characteristics,” 7, p. 38 (December 1968).
[4]
R. J. Maier, “Radiation Induced Surface Recombination in Oxide Passivated Transistors,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-14, No. 6, pp. 252-259 (1967).
[5]
A. G. Stanley, “Electron Irradiation of NPN Bipolar Transistors with Silicon Nitride Passivation,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS- 15, No. 6, pp. 168-175 (1968).
[6]
P. F. Schmidt and J. D. Ashner, “Radiation-Insensitive Silicon Oxynitride Films for Use in Silicon Devices,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-17, No. 6, pp. 11-17 (1970).
[7]
R. Bauerlein, “Investigation of the Surface Ionization Effect on Planar Silicon Bipolar Transistors and the Improvement of the Resistance to Radiation by an IrradiationAnnealing Treatment,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-17, No. 6, pp. 52-62 ( 1970).
[8]
L. L. Sivo, “Relative Roles of Charge Accumulation and Interface States in Surface Degradation (NPN Planar Transistors),” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS19, No. 6, pp. 305-312 (1972).
[9]
L. L. Sivo, “Investigation of Radiation-Induced Interface States Utilizing Gated-Bipolar and MOS Structures,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS - 19, No. 6, pp. 313-319 (1972).
[10]
J. A. Lipman, W.C. Bruncke, D. L. Crosthwait, K. F. Galloway, and R. L. Pease, “Use of a Scanning Electron Microscope for Screening Bipolar Surface Effects,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-21, No. 6, pp. 383-386(1974).
[11.
M. E. Daniel and F. N. Coppage, “Radiation Hardness of a High Speed ECL Microcircuit,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-22, No. 6, pp. 2595-2599 (1975).
[12.
R. L. Pease, “Radiation Damage to Integrated Injection Logic Cells,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-22, No. 6, pp. 2600-2604 (1975). III-69
,.
EEE, Vol. 16, No.
[13]
J. P. Raymond, T. Y. Wong, and K. K. Schuegraf, “Radiation Effects on Bipolar Integrated Injection Logic,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-22, No. 6, pp. 2605-2610 (1975).
[14]
W. E. Price and A. G. Stanley, “Hardening of MJS77 Spacecraft Against the Jupiter Radiation Belts,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-22, No. 6, pp. 26692674 (1975).
[15]
L. J. Palkuti, L. L. Sivo, R. B. Greegor, “Process Investigations of Total-Dose Hard, Type-108 Op Amps,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-23, No. 6, pp. 1756-1761 (1976).
[16]
A. G. Stanley and W. E. Price, “Irradiate-Anneal Screening of Total Dose Effects in Semiconductor Devices, ” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-23, No. 6, pp. 2035-2040 ( 1976).
[17]
A. G. Stanley and M. K. Gauthier, “SEM Analysis of Ionizing Radiation Effects in Linear Integrated Circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-24, No. 6, pp. 2060-2065 (1977).
[18]
K. F. Galloway and P. Roitman, “Important Considerations for SEM Total Dose Testing,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-24, No. 6, pp. 2066-2070 (1977).
[19]
A. H. Johnston, “The Application of Operational Amplifiers to H-ardened Systems,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-24, No. 6, pp. 2071-2078 (1977).
[20]
D, M. Newell and W. T. Picciano, “A Hard Off-the-Shelf SG1524 Pulse Width Modulator,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-24, No. 6, pp. 2079-2083 (1977).
[21]
J. P. Raymond and R. L. Pease, “A Comparative Evaluation of Integrated Injection Logic,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-24, No. 6, pp. 2327-2335 (1977).
[22]
R. P. Donovan, M. Simons, R. M. Gurger, “Radiation Hardened LSI for the 1980’s: CMOS/SOS vs. 12L,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-24, No. 6, pp. 2336-2340 (1977).
,[23]
A. R, Hart, J. B. Smyth, Jr., V. A. J. vanLint, D. P. Snowden, and R. E. Leaden, “Hardness Assurance Considerations for Long-Term Ionizing Radiation Effects on Bipolar Structures,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Sciences, Vol. NS-25, No. 6, pp. 1502-1507 (1978).
[24]
A. H. Johnston and C. A. Lancaster, “A Total Dose Homogeneity Study of the 108A Operational Amplifier,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Sciences, Vol. NS-26, No. 6, pp. 4769-4774 (1979).
111-70
[25]
M. K. Gauthier, J. Perret, and K. C. Evans, “SEM Analysis of Ionizing Radiation Effects in an Analog to Digital Converter (AD571 ),” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-28, No. 6, pp. 4051-4055 (1981),
[26]
V. Condito, N. Lambert, T. J. Schwartz, and S. Dodge, “The Effects of Nitride Passivation on the Total Dose Radiation Resistance of a Precision Operational Amplifier,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-28, No. 6, pp. 4325-4327 (1981).
[27]
R. B. Johnson, R. R. Travis, B, W. Schupp, and M. H. Seavey, “Radiation Response of Integrated Schottky Logic Circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-28, No. 6, pp. 4060-4065 (1981).
[28]
R. D. Blice and J. H. Collins, “Analysis of the Behavior of Integrated Schottky Logic in Neutron, Total Dose, and Dose Rate Environments,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-28, No. 6, pp. 4366-4375 (1981).
[29]
F. W. Poblenz, R. G. Carroll, D. A. Whitmire, B. W. Cheney, and D. L. Walthall, “Total Dose Response of STL and 12L Logic Devices,” JEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-29, No. 6, pp. 1727-1732 (1982).
[30]
J. P. Woods and J. V. MacPhee, “Total Dose Susceptibility of the SBP 9989 Microprocessor,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-29, No. 6, pp. 17401743 (1982).
[31]
M. L. Buschbom, E. N. Jeffrey, L. E. Rhine, and D. B. Spratt, “Garnrna Total Dose Effects on ALS Bipolar Oxide Sidewall Isolated Devices,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-30, No. 6, pp. 4105-4109 (1983).
[32]
R. L. Pease, R. M. Turfler, D. G. Platteter, D. W. Emily, and R. Blice, “Total Dose Effects in Recessed Oxide Digital Bipolar Microcircuits,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-30, No. 6, pp. 4216-4223 (1983).
[33]
M, K. Gauthier and D. K. Nichols, “A Comparison of Radiation Damage in Linear IC’S from Cobalt-60 Gamma Rays and 2.2 MeV Electrons,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-30, No. 60, pp. 4192-4196 (1983).
[34]
M. Kate, T. Nakamura, T. Toyabe, T. Okabe, and M. Nagata, “Degradation Analysis of Lateral PNP Transistors Exposed to X-Ray Irradiation,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-31, No. 6, pp. 1513-1517 (1984).
[35]
R. L. Pease, D. W. Emily, and H. E. Boesch, Jr., “Total Dose Induced Hole Trapping and Interface State Generation in Bipolar Recessed Field Oxides,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-32, No. 6, pp. 3946-3952 (1985).
III-7 1
. .
[36]
A, H. Johnston and R. E. Plaag, “Models for Total Dose Degradation of Linear Integrated Circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-34, No. 6, pp. 1474-1480 (1987).
[37]
D. Schiff, “Prediction of Dose to Failure Versus Dose Rate for a Recessed Oxide Digital Bipolar Microcircuit,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-34, No. 6, pp. 1742-1744 (1987).
[38]
R. H. Maurer and J. J. Suter, ‘Total-Dose Hardness Assurance for Low Earth Orbit,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-34, No. 6, pp. 1757-1762 (1987).
[39]
J. L. Titus and D. G. Platteter, “Wafer Mapping of Total Dose Failure Thresholds in a Bipolar Recessed Field Oxide Technology,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-34, No. 6, pp. 1751-1756 (1987).
[40]
D. G. Platteter and T. F. Cheek, Jr., ‘“The Use of Multiple Oxygen Implants for Fabrication of Bipolar Silicon-on-Insulator Integrated Circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-35, No. 6, pp. 1350-1354 (1988).
[41]
J. A. Zoutendyk, C. A. Goben, and D. F. Berndt, “Comparison of the Degradation Effects of Heavy Ion, Electron, and Cobalt-60 Irradiation in an Advanced Bipolar Process,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-35, No. 6, pp. 1428-1431 (1988).
[42]
E. W. Enlow, R. L. Pease, W. E. Combs, amd D. G. Platteter, “Total Dose Induced Hole Trapping in Trench Oxides,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-36, No. 6, pp. 2415-2422 (1989).
[43]
J. C. Desko, Jr., J. N. Darwish, M. C. Dolly, C. A. Goodwin, W. R. Dawes, Jr., and J. L. Titus, “Radiation Hardening of a High Voltage IC Technology (BCDMOS),” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-37, No. 6, pp. 2083-2088 (1990).
[44]
E. W. Enlow, R. L. Pease, W. E. Combs, R. D. Schrimpf, and R, N. Nowlin, “Response of Advanced Bipolar Process to Ionizing Radiation,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-38, No. 6, pp. 1342-1351 (1991).
[45]
D. M. Fleetwood, P. S. Winokur, and T. L. Meisenheimer, “Hardness Assurance for LowDose Space Applications,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-38, No. 6, pp. 1552-1559 (1991).
[46]
R.N. Nowlin, E. W. Enlow, R. D. Schrimpf, and W. E. Combs, “Trends in the TotalDose Response of Modem Bipolar Transistors,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, VO1.NS-39, No. 6, pp. 2026-2035 (1992).
[47]
S. L. Kosier, R. D. Schrimpf, R. N. Nowlin, D. M. Fleetwood, M. DeLaus, R. L. Pease, W. E. Combs, A. Wei, and F. Chai, “Charge Separation for Bipolar Transistors,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS40, No. 6, pp. 1276-1285 (1993).
111-72
[48]
R.N. Nowlin, D. M. Fleetwood,-R. D. Schrimpf, R. L. Pease, and W. E. Combs, “Hardness-Assurance and Testing Issues for Bipolar/BiCMOS Devices,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-40, No. 6, pp. 1686-1693 (1993).
[49]
M. DeLaus, D. Emily, B. Mappes, and R. Pease, “Converting a Bulk Radiation-Hardened BiCMOS Technology into a Dielectrically Isolated Process,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-40, No. 6, pp. 1774-1779 (1993).
[50]
S. L. Kosier, W. E. Combs, A. Wei, R. D. Schrimpf, D. M. FleetWood, M. DeLaus, and R. L. Pease, “Bounding the Total-Dose Response of Modern Bipolar Transistors,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-41, No. 6, pp. 1864-1870 (1994).
[51]
D. M. Fleetwood, S. L. Kosier, R. N. Nowlin, R. D. Schrimpf, R. A. Reber, Jr,, M. DeLaus, P. S. Winokur, A. Wei, W. E. Combs, and R. L. Pease, “Physical Mechanisms Contributing to Enhanced Bipolar Gain Degradation at Low Dose Rates,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, NS41, No. 6, pp. 1871-1883 (1994).
[52]
S. C. WitcX S. L. Kosier, R. D. Schrimpf, and K. F, Galloway, “Synergetic Effects on Radiation Stress and Hot-Carrier Stress on the Current Gain of NPN Bipolar Junction Transistors,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-41, No. 6, pp. 2412-2419 (1994).
[53]
R.N. Nowlin, D. M. Fleetwood, and R. D. Schrimpf, “Saturation of the Dose-Rate Response of Bipolar Transistors Below 10 Rad(Si02)/s: Implications for Hardness Assurance,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-41, No. 6, pp. 2637-2641 (1994).
[54]
A. H. Johnston, G. M. Swift, and B. G. Rax, “Total Dose Effects in Conventional Bipolar Transistors and Linear Integrated Circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-41, No. 6, pp. 2427-2436 (1994).
[55]
J. Beaucour, T. Carriere, A. Gach, D. Laxague, and P. Poirot, “Total Dose Effects on Negative Voltage Regulator,” IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, Vol. NS-41, No. 6, pp. 2420-2426 ( 1994).
[56]
S. McClure, R. Pease, W. Will, and G. Peny, “Dependence of Total Dose Response of Bipolar Linear Microcircuits on Applied Dose Rate:’ IEEE Transactions on Nuclear
Science, Vol. NS41, No. 6., pp. 25