Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
Three basic issues concerning interface dynamics in nonequilibrium pattern formation Wim van Saarloos Instituut-Lorentz, Leiden University, P.O. Box 9506, 2300 RA Leiden, Netherlands
Abstract In these lecture notes, we discuss at an elementary level three themes concerning interface dynamics that play a role in pattern forming systems: (i) We briefly review three examples of systems in which the normal growth velocity is proportional to the gradient of a bulk field which itself obeys a Laplace or diffusion type of equation (solidification, viscous fingers and streamers), and then discuss why the Mullins—Sekerka instability is common to all such gradient systems. (ii) Secondly, we discuss how underlying an effective interface or moving boundary description of systems with smooth fronts or transition zones, is the assumption that the relaxation time of the appropriate order parameter field(s) in the front region is much smaller than the time scale of the evolution of interfacial patterns. Using standard arguments we illustrate that this is generally so for fronts that separate two (meta)stable phases: in such cases, the relaxation is typically exponential, and the relaxation time in the usual models goes to zero in the limit in which the front width vanishes. (iii) We finally summarize recent results that show that so-called “pulled” or “linear marginal stability” fronts which propagate into unstable states have a very slow universal power-law relaxation. This slow relaxation makes the usual “moving boundary” or “effective interface” approximation for problems with thin fronts, like streamers, impossible. ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 47.54.#r; 68.35.Rh; 47.20.Ky; 02.30.Jr Keywords: Pattern formation; Interface dynamics; Relaxation
0. Introduction In this course, and in the two related lectures by Ebert and Brener on their work in [1,2], some basic features of the dynamics of growing interfaces in systems which spontaneously form nonequilibrium patterns will be discussed. The analysis of such growth patterns has been an active field of research in the last decade. Moreover, the field is quite diverse, with examples coming from various (sub)disciplines within physics, materials science, and even biology — combustion, convection, crystal growth, chemical waves in excitable media and the formation of Turing patterns, dielectric breakdown, fracture, morphogenesis, etc. We therefore cannot hope to review the whole field, but instead will content ourselves with addressing three rather basic topics which we consider to be of rather broad interest, in that they appear (in disguise) in many areas of physics and in some of the related fields. These three themes are explained below. 0370-1573/98/$19.00 ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved PII S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 9 8 ) 0 0 0 0 4 - 0
10
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
Our first theme concerns the generality of interfacial growth problems in which the normal growth velocity v is proportional to the gradient +U of a bulk field U (v &+U), and the associated long n n wavelength instability of such interfaces. As we shall see, one important class of interfacial growth problems with these properties is diffusion-limited growth: either the interface grows through the accretion of material via diffusion through one of the adjacent bulk phases, or the growth of the interface is limited by the speed through which, e.g., heat can be transported away from the interface through diffusion. Since the diffusion current near the interface is proportional to the gradient of the appropriate field in the bulk (a concentration field, the temperature, etc.), v &+U in such growth n problems. But these are not the only possibilities of how one can have an interface velocity proportional to +U. As we will discuss, in viscous fingering an air bubble displaces fluid between two closely spaced plates; as the fluid velocity between the plates is proportional to the gradient of a pressure field p, the fact that the air displaces all the fluid means that again at the interface v &+p. n Likewise, for an ionization front the interface velocity is determined mostly by the drift velocity of electrons in the electric field E"!+U, where now U is the electrical potential, and so again v &D+UD. As we shall see, all such interfacial growth problems where the bulk field itself obeys n a Laplace of diffusion equation, exhibit a long wavelength instability, the so-called Mullins—Sekerka instability [3]. This instability lies at the origin of the formation of many nontrivial growth patterns, and Brener and Ebert discussed examples of these at the school. Although this theme is not at all new, it is nevertheless useful to discuss it as an introduction and to stress the generality — the same Mullins—Sekerka instability plays a role in fractal growth processes like Diffusion Limited Aggregation [4]. The above issues are the subject of the first lecture and Section 1. In physics, it is quite common — and often done intuitively without even stating this explicitly — to switch back and forth between a formulation in terms of a mathematically sharp interface (an infinitely thin surface or line at which the physical fields or their derivatives can show discontinuities) and a formulation in terms of a continuous order parameter field which exhibits a smooth but relatively thin transition zone or domain wall. E.g., we think of the interface between a solid and its melt as a microscopically thin interface, whose width is of the order of a few atomic dimensions. Accordingly, the formulation of the equations that govern the formation of growth patterns of a solid which grows into an undercooled melt on much larger scales l have traditionally been 1!55%3/ formulated in terms of a sharp interface or boundary. The equations, which will be discussed below, are then the diffusion equation for the temperature in the bulk of the liquid and the solid, together with boundary conditions at the interface. These interfacial boundary conditions are a kinematic equation for the growth velocity of the interface in terms of the local interface temperature, and a conservation equation for the heat. The latter expresses that the latent heat released at the interface upon growth of the solid has to be transported away through diffusion into the liquid and the solid. In other words, in an interfacial formulation or moving boundary approximation, the appropriate equations for the bulk fields are introduced, but the way in which the order parameter changes from one state to the other in the interfacial region, is not taken into account explicitly:1 1 Note that if we consider a solid—liquid interface of a simple material so that the interface width is of atomic dimensions, there can be microscopic aspects of the interface physics that have to be put in by hand in the interfacial boundary conditions anyway, as they cannot really be treated properly in a continuum formulation. E.g., if the solid—liquid interface is rough, a linear kinetic law in which the interface grows in proportion to the local undercooling is appropriate. If the interface is faceted, however, a different boundary condition will have to be used.
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
11
the physics at the interface is lumped into appropriate boundary conditions. Such an interface formulation of the equations often expresses the physics quite well and most efficiently, and is often the most convenient one for the analytical calculations which we will present later. For numerical calculations, however, the existence of a sharp boundary or interface is a nuisance, as they force one to introduce highly non-trivial interface tracking methods. Partly to avoid this complication, several workers have introduced in the last few years different models, often referred to as phase-field models [5,6], in which the transition from one phase or state to another one is described by introducing a continuum equation for the appropriate order parameter. Instead of a sharp interface, one then has a smooth but thin transition zone of width ¼, where the order parameter changes from one (meta)stable state to another one. Numerically, such smooth interface models are much easier to handle, since one can in principle apply standard numerical integration routines.2 While we mentioned above an example where one has (sometimes in a somewhat artificial way) introduced continuum field equations to analyze a sharp interface problem, insight into the dynamics of problems with a moving smooth but thin transition zone is often more easily gained by going in the opposite direction, i.e., by viewing this zone as a mathematically sharp interface or shock front. An example of this is found in combustion [7,8]. In premixed flames, the reaction zone is usually quite small, and one speaks of flame sheets. Already long ago, Landau (and independently Darrieus) considered the stability of planar flame fronts by viewing them as a sharp interface [7,8]. In the last 20 years, much progress has been made in the field of combustion by building on this idea of using an effective interface description of thin flame sheets. Likewise, much of the progress on understanding chemical waves, spirals and other patterns in reaction diffusion systems rests on the possibility to exploit similar ideas [9,10]. Other examples from condensed matter physics: if the magnetic anisotropy is not too large, domain walls in solids can have an appreciable width, but for many studies of magnetic domains of size much larger than this width, we normally prefer to think of the walls as being infinitely thin [11]. Similar considerations hold for domains in liquid crystals [11]. In studies of coarsening (the gradual increase in the typical length scale after a quench of a binary fluid or alloy into the so-called spinodal regime where demixing occurs), both smooth and sharp interface formulations are being used [12—15]. At a summer school on statistical physics, it seems appropriate to note in passing that some of the model equations which include the order parameter are very similar to those studied in particular in the field of dynamic critical phenomena, such as model A, B,2, etc. in the classification of Hohenberg and Halperin [16]. Here, however, we are not interested in the universal scaling properties of an essentially homogeneous system near the critical point of a second-order phase transition, but in many cases in the nonlinear nonequilibrium dynamics of interfaces between
2 While the numerical code may be conceptually much more straightforward, the bottleneck with these methods is that one now needs to have a small gridsize, so as to properly resolve the variations of the order parameter field on the scale ¼. At the same time, one usually wants to study pattern formation on a scale l <¼, so that many gridpoints are 1!55%3/ needed. Hence, computer power becomes the limiting factor. Nevertheless, numerical simulations of dendrites using such phase-field models nowadays appear to present the best way to test analytical predictions and to compare with experimental data [6].
12
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
a metastable and a stable state. This corresponds to the situation near a first-order transition.3 When we consider in Section 3 fronts which propagate into an unstable state, this can be viewed as the interfacial analogue of the behavior when we quench a system through a second-order phase transition, especially within a mean-field picture,4 where fluctuations are not important.5 Finally, we also stress that while thermal fluctuations are essential to second-order phase transition, they can often be neglected in pattern forming systems, since the typical length and energy scales of interest in pattern forming systems are normally very large (see Section VI.D of [17] for further discussion of this point). A word about nomenclature. For many physicists, front, domain wall and reaction zone are words that have the connotation of describing smooth transition zones of finite thickness,6 while the word interface is being used for a surface whose thickness is so small that it can be treated as a mathematically sharp boundary of zero thickness. The approximation in which the interface thickness is taken to zero is sometimes referred to as a moving boundary approximation. Since neither this concept nor the meaning of the word “interface” is universally accepted, we will sometimes use effective interface description or effective interface approximation as an alternative to “moving boundary approximation” to denote a description of a front or transition zone by a sharp interface with appropriate boundary conditions. Of course, switching back and forth between a sharp interface formulation or one with a smooth continuous order parameter field is only possible if the latter reduces to the first in the limit in which the interface thickness ¼P0 (the interface width is illustrated in Fig. 8 below). Indeed, it is possible to derive an effective interface description systematically by performing an expansion of the equations in powers of ¼ (technically, this is done using singular perturbation theory or matched asymptotic expansions [5,6,21—23]). In such an analysis, the wall or front is treated as a sharp interface when viewed on the “outer” pattern forming length scale l <¼, and the 1!55%3/
3 This will be illustrated, e.g., by the Landau free energy f in Fig. 4b below. Here the states /"0 and /"/ both s correspond to minima of the free energy density f. In Section 2.1 fronts between these two (meta)stable states are discussed. 4 In the mean-field picture, the Landau free energy has below ¹ one (unstable) maximum at /"0 and one minimum # at some /"/ O0. Fronts propagating into an unstable state precisely correspond to fronts between these two states. s Compare Fig. 9b, where »"!f. 5 It is actually rather exceptional to have propagating interfaces when we quench a system through the transition temperature of a second-order phase transition, because the fluctuations make it normally impossible to keep the system in the phase which has become unstable long enough that propagating interfaces can develop. Nevertheless, there is one example of a thermodynamic system in which the properties of propagating interfaces were used to probe the order of the phase transition: for the nematic—smectic-A transition, which was predicted to be always weakly first order, the dynamics of moving interfaces was used to probe experimentally [18] the order of the transition close to the point which earlier had been associated with a tricritical point (the point where a second-order transition becomes a first-order transition). These dynamical interface measurements confirmed that the transition was always weakly first order [18]. Note finally that in pattern forming systems, the fluctuations are often small enough (see the remarks about this in the next paragraph of the main text) that fronts propagating into unstable states can be prepared more easily. For an example of such fronts in the Rayleigh—Benard instability, see [19]. 6 And even this is not true: in adsorbed monolayers walls usually have only a microscopic thickness; e.g., light and heavy walls are concepts that have been introduced to distinguish walls which differ in the atomic packing in one row; see, e.g., [20].
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
13
dynamics of the front or wall on the “inner” scale ¼ emerges in the form of one or more boundary conditions for this interface. E.g., one boundary condition can be a simple expression for the normal velocity of the interface in terms of the local values of the slowly varying outer fields, like the temperature. This brings us to the second theme and lecture of this course: for the adiabatic decoupling of slow and fast variables underlying an effective interface description, an exponential relaxation of the front structure and velocity is necessary. The point is that an interfacial description — mapping a smooth continuum model onto one with a sharp interface for the analysis of patterns on a length scale l <¼ — is only possible if we can make an adiabatic decoupling. In intuitive terms, this means 1!55%3/ that if we “freeze” the slowly varying outer fields (temperature, pressure, etc.) at their instantaneous values and perturb the front profile on the scale ¼ by some amount, then the front profile and speed should relax as exp(!t/q ) to some asymptotic shape and value which are given in terms &30/5 of the “frozen” outer field. If, moreover, the inner front relaxation time q vanishes as ¼P0 (e.g., &30/5 in the model we will discuss q &¼), then indeed in the limit ¼P0 the relaxation of the order &30/5 parameter dynamics within the front region decouples completely from the slow time and length scale variation of the outer fields, as in the limit ¼P0 both the length and the time scale become more and more separated. The adiabatic decoupling then implies that for ¼;l the front 1!55%3/ follows essentially instantaneously the slow variation of the outer fields in the region near the front. Accordingly, in the interfacial limit ¼P0 the front dynamics on the inner scale ¼ then translates into boundary conditions that are local in time and space at the interface. As we shall illustrate, for fronts between two (meta)stable states, the separation of both length and time scale as ¼P0 is normally the case, and this justifies an interfacial description. Of course, stated this way, the above point may strike you as trivial, as it is a common feature of problems in which fast variables can be eliminated [24]. However, it is an observation that we have hardly ever seen stressed or even discussed at all in the literature, and its importance is illustrated by our third theme: fronts propagating into an unstable state may show a separation of spatial scales in the limit ¼P0, but need not show a separation of time scales in this limit. Our reason for the last statement is that, as we will discuss, a wide class of fronts which propagate into an unstable state (the interfacial analogue of the situation near a second-order phase transition) exhibits slow power-law relaxation (&1/t). This certainly calls the possibility of an effective interface formulation with boundary conditions which are local in space and time into question, but the consequences of this power-law relaxation still remain to be fully explored. The connection between the issue of the front relaxation and the issue of the separation of time scales necessary for an effective interface description is still a subject of ongoing research of Ebert and myself. We will in these lecture notes only give an introduction to the background of this issue and to the ideas underlying the usual approaches, leaving the real analysis and a full discussion of this problem to our future publications [25]. That our third theme is not a formal esotheric issue, is illustrated by the fact that it grew out of our attempt to develop an interfacial description for streamers. As has been discussed by Ebert in her seminar, streamers are examples of a nonequilibrium pattern forming phenomenon. They consist of a very sharp fronts (¼+10 lm) which shows patterns with a size l of order 1 mm 1!55%3/ [32]. However, a streamer front turns out to be an example of a front propagating into an unstable state [1], and we have found through bitter experience that the standard methods to arrive at an interfacial approximation break down, and that the slow power-law relaxation lies at the heart of
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
14
this. Apart from this, the power-law relaxation is of interest in its own right, especially at a summer school on Fundamental Problems in Statistical Mechanics, as its universality is reminiscent of the universal behavior near a second order critical point in the theory of phase transitions — the common origin of both is in fact the universality of the flow near the asymptotic fixed point.
1. Gradient-driven growth problems and the Mullins—Sekerka instability 1.1. The dendritic growth equations When we undercool a pure liquid below the melting temperature, the liquid will not solidify immediately. This is because below the melting temperature the liquid is only metastable. Moreover, the solid—liquid transition is usually strongly first order, so that the nucleation rate for the solid phase to form through nucleation at small to moderate undercoolings is low. If, however, we bring a solid nucleus into the melt, the solid will start to grow immediately at its interfaces. Initially the shape of the solid germ remains rather smooth (we assume the interface to be rough, not faceted [29]), but once it has grown sufficiently large, it does not stay rounded (like an ice cube melting in a softdrink), but instead branch-type structures grow out. An example of such a so-called dendrite is shown in Fig. 1a. The basic instability underlying the formation of these dendrites is the Mullins—Sekerka instability discussed below, and which in this case is associated with the build-up near the interface of a diffusion boundary layer in the temperature. This in turn is due to the fact that while the solid grows, latent heat is released at the interface. In fact, the amount of heat released is normally so large that most of the heat has to diffuse away, in order to prevent the local temperature to come above the melting temperature ¹ . E.g., for water the latent heat released M when a certain volume solidifies is enough to heat up that same volume by about 80°C. So, since the undercooling is normally just a few degrees, most of the latent heat has to diffuse away in order for the temperature not to exceed ¹ . M The basic equations that model this physics are the diffusion equation for the temperature in the liquid and the solid, ¹/t"D+ 2¹ ,
(1)
together with the boundary conditions at the interface ¸/c v "!D[(+ ¹l) !(+ ¹4) ] , n,*/5 n,*/5 n
(2)
v "(1/b)[¹ (1!(p/¸)i)!¹*/5] . n M
(3)
Eq. (1) is just the normal heat diffusion equation for the temperature; it holds both in the liquid (¹"¹l) and in the solid (¹"¹4). At the interface, the temperature is continuous, so there ¹l"¹4"¹*/5. In Eq. (1), we have for simplicity taken the diffusion coefficient D in both phases equal. The first boundary condition (2) expresses the heat conservation at the interface: v is the n normal growth velocity of the interface, so ¸v is the amount of heat released at the surface per unit n time (¸ is the latent heat per unit volume). If we consider an infinitesimal “pillbox” at the interface,
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
15
Fig. 1. Examples of three growth patterns: a dendrite in (a), a viscous finger in (b), and streamer in (c). Usually, dendritic growth is studied in liquids with a melting temperature near room temperature. The one shown in (a) was observed in 3He [30] at 100 mK, and the fact that it is similar in shape and form to those usually observed illustrates the generality of dendritic growth (courtesy of E. Rolley and S. Balibar). In (b), a top view of a viscous finger is shown. The air inside the finger like pattern displaces the oil outside (from [31], with permission from the author). The streamer pattern is from a numerical simulation [32].
16
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
the heat produced has to be equal to the net amount of heat which is being transported out of the flat sides through heat diffusion. The heat current is in general !cD+ ¹, with c the specific heat per unit volume (the combination cD is the so-called heat conductivity), and we denote the components normal to the interface by (+ ¹l) and (+ ¹4) . After dividing by c, we therefore recognize in the n,*/5 n,*/5 right-hand side of Eq. (2) the net heat flow away from the interface. Note that this equation is completely fixed by a conservation law at the interface, in this case conservation of heat, and that it can be written down by inspection. The only input is the assumption that the interface is very thin. Moreover, it shows the structure we mentioned in the beginning, namely that the normal growth velocity is proportional to the gradient of a bulk quantity — the larger the difference in the gradients in the solid and the liquids is, the faster the growth can be. Finally, the second-boundary condition at the liquid—solid interface (3) is essentially the local kinetic equation which expresses the microscopic physics at the interface: We assume the interface to be rough, so that the interface can be smoothly curved [29]. ¹ [1!(p/¸)i] is then the melting M temperature of such a curved interface, where p is the surface tension. Here the curvature i is taken positive when the solid bulges out into the liquid; the suppression of ¹ in such a case can M intuitively be thought of as being due to the fact that there are more broken “crystalline” bonds if the solid is curved out into the liquid, but the relation follows quite generally from thermodynamic considerations [26]. The ratio (p/¸) is a small microscopic length, say of the order of tens of A_ ngstroms. The necessity of introducing the suppression of the local interface melting temperature will emerge later, when we will see that if we do not do so, there would be a strong short wavelength (“ultraviolet”) instability at the interface.7 Now that we understand the meaning of ¹ (1!(p/¸)i) as a local melting term of a curved M interface, we see that Eq. (3) just expresses the linear growth law for rough interfaces [29]; 1/b in this expression has the meaning of a mobility. If we take the limit of infinite mobility (1/bPR), the interface grows so easily that we can approximate (3) by (bP0) ¹*/5"¹ [1!(p/¸)i] , (4) M which is sometimes referred to as the local equilibrium approximation. We stress that the boundary condition (3) is local in space and time, i.e., the growth velocity v responds instantaneously to the local temperature and curvature. There are of course sound n physical reasons why this is a good approximation: the typical solid—liquid interfaces we are interested in are just a few atomic dimensions wide, and respond on the time-scale of a few atomic collision times (of order picoseconds) to changes in temperature [35], while Eqs. (1)—(3) are used to analyze pattern formation on length scales of order microns or more and with growth velocities of the order of a lm/s, say. Hence, an interface grows over a distance comparable to its width in a time of the order of 10~3 s, and the time scale for the evolution of the patterns is typically even slower.
7 Due to the crystalline anisotropy, the capillary parameter actually depends on the angles the interface makes with the underlying crystalline lattice. It has been discovered theoretically that this crystalline anisotropy actually has a crucial influence on dendritic growth: without this anisotropy, needle-like tip solutions of a dendrite do not exist, and the growth velocity of such needles is found to scale with a 7/4 power of the anisotropy amplitude. We refer to [26,28,34] for a detailed discussion of this point.
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
17
This wide separation of length and time scales justifies the assumptions underlying the interfacial boundary conditions. Eqs. (1)—(3), together with appropriate boundary conditions for the temperature far away from the interface, constitute the basic equations that describe the growth of a dendrite into a pure melt. They may look innocuous, as they appear to be linear equations, but they are not! The reason is that they involve the unknown position and shape of the interface through the boundary conditions, and that the dynamics of the interface depends in turn on the diffusion fields: the location of the interface has to be found self-consistently in the course of solving these equations! This is why such a so-called moving boundary problem is so highly nonlinear and complicated. These equations (with crystalline anisotropy included in the capillary term (p/¸)) were actually the starting point of Brener’s talk at the school, and the work he discussed [2] showed how challenging the nonlinear analysis necessary to obtain a phase diagram of growth patterns can be. Such work builds on many advances made in the last decade on understanding the growth velocity and shape of dendrites, and for a discussion of these we refer to the literature [34,36]. 1.2. Viscous fingering In viscous fingering, or Saffman—Taylor fingering, one considers a fluid (typically an oil) confined between two long parallel closely spaced plates. In Fig. 1b one looks from the top at such a cell — the plates, separated by a small distance b"0.8 mm, are thus in the plane of the paper. The two black sides in this photo constitute the lateral side walls; the oil between the plates cannot penetrate into these. The distance between these side walls is 10 cm, hence the lateral width of the cell is much smaller than the spacing b of the plates. The thin line is the air—fluid interface and the region inside the finger-like shape is air, while the oil is outside. The air is blown into the area between the plates from the right side of the figure. If the air—fluid interface initially stretches all the way across the cell from one sidewall to the other, one quickly finds that when the air is blown in, this interface is unstable, and that after a while a single finger-shaped pattern like the one shown in Fig. 1b penetrates to the left into the fluid. Understanding the shape and width of this finger has been a major theme in interfacial pattern formation [34]. In simple fluids it is so well understood that the analysis of the finger shapes when surfactants or polymers are added to the displaced fluid has become a way to learn something about the resulting properties of the fluid and the air—fluid interface [37]. We will content ourselves here with giving an introduction of the basic equations, aimed at bringing out the same gradient-driven structure of the interface equations. In viscous fingering experiments, the spacing b between plates is much smaller than the width of the cell (the distance between the two dark sides in Fig. 1b). As a result, the average fluid flow field varies in the plane of the cell only slowly over distances of the order of the lateral dimensions of the cell. Locally, therefore, the flow in the small direction normal to the planes is almost like that of homogeneous planar Poisseuille flow, for which we know that the average fluid velocity is !b2/(12g) times the gradient of the pressure p. Here g is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid. Hence, if we now introduce (x, y) as the height-averaged flow field between the plates of the cell, which we take to lie in the xy-plane, we have (x, y)"!b2/(12g)+p. Taking the fluid to be incompressible, + ) "0, implies that in the bulk of the fluid the pressure simply obeys the Laplace equation,
+ 2p"0 ,
(5)
18
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
while at the interface the fact that the air displaces all the fluid is expressed by . (6) v "!(b2/12g)(+p) n,*/5 n Furthermore, if we ignore the viscosity of the air and wetting effects, the pressure at the interface is nothing but the equilibrium pressure of a smoothly curved air—fluid interface, i.e., pD "p !pi , (7) int 0 where as before p is the surface tension and p the background pressure in the gas. The curvature 0 term !pi is the direct analogue of the one in Eq. (3); in the context of air—fluid interfaces it is known as the Laplace pressure term, and it corresponds to the well-known effect that the pressure inside a soap bubble is larger than the one outside. As in the case of crystal growth discussed above, the form of the boundary conditions can essentially be guessed on physical grounds and by appealing to the fact that the microscopic relaxation time at the interface is typically orders of magnitude smaller than the time and length scale of the pattern. 1.3. Streamer dynamics — a moving charge sheet? We finally introduce a problem which is not at all understood in detail but whose similarity with dendrites and viscous fingers motivated some of the issues discussed here [1]. The basic phenomenon is that when an electric field is large enough, an electron avalanche type can build up in a gas, due to the fact that free electrons get accelerated sufficiently that they ionize neutral molecules, thus generating more free electrons, etc. Streamers are the type of dielectric breakdown fronts that can occur in gases as a combined result of this avalanche type of phenomenon and the screening of the field due to the build-up of a charge layer. The basic equations that are being used to model this behavior are the following continuum balance equations for the electron density n and ion density % n , and the electric field E [32] ` n #+ ) j "Dn k EDa e~E0@@E@ , (8) t % % % % 0 (9) n #+ ) j "Dn k EDa e~E0@@E@ , ` % % 0 t ` and the Poisson equation
+ ) E"(e/e )(n !n ) . (10) 0 ` % The electron and ion current densities j and j are % ` j "!n k E!D +n , j "0 , (11) % % % % % ` so that j is the sum of a drift and a diffusion term, while the ion current j is neglected, since the % ` ions are much less mobile than the electrons. The right-hand side of Eqs. (8) and (9) is a source term due to the ionization reaction: In high fields free electrons can generate free electrons and ions by impact on neutral molecules. The source term is given by the magnitude of the electron drift current times the target density times the effective ionization cross section; the constant E in the ionization 0 probability depends on the mean free path of the electrons and the ionization energy of the neutral
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
19
gas molecules. The rate constant a has the dimension of an inverse length. The exponential 0 function expresses, that only in high fields electrons have a nonnegligible probability to collect the ionization energy between collisions. In Fig. 1c, we show a plot of the simulations of the above equations [32]. In this figure, a gap between two planar electrodes across which there is a large voltage difference is studied for parameters in the model that correspond to N gas. Initially, the electron density is essentially zero 2 everywhere except in a very small region near the upper electron. The simulation of Fig. 1c shows the situation 5.5 ns later; the lines in this plot are lines of constant electron density. The density differs by a factor 10 between successive lines. Since these lines are closely spaced — the electron density rises by a factor 1010 in a few lm — the simulations illustrate that a streamer consists of an ionized region (inside the contour lines) propagating into a nonionized zone. Inside this zone, almost all of the ionization takes place, and the total charge density is nonzero. It is this nonzero charge density that also screens the electric field from the interior of the streamer. We can therefore also think of the streamer as a moving charge sheet, whose shape is somewhat like a viscous finger. In fact, if the upper electrode is spherical rather than planar, one finds branched streamers which are reminiscent of dendrites [33]. Note that in this interfacial picture, the charge sheet is also the reaction zone where most of the ionization takes place, and that the build-up of the charge in this zone is at the same time responsible for the screening of the field in the interior of the streamer. An immediate question that comes to mind is whether we can analyze such a streamer as a moving interface problem by mapping the continuum equations onto a sharp interface of zero thickness, by taking the limit in which the charge sheet becomes infinitely thin [1]. If such an analysis can be done, very much along the lines of the analysis for combustion or for the so-called phase-field models mentioned in the introduction, one would intuitively expect that the dynamics in the transition zone would, in the ¼P0 limit, translate into boundary conditions at the interface. In particular, one expects one equation expressing charge conservation, and a kinematic relation for the normal velocity of the interface. Based on one’s experience with the other problems described earlier, this kinematic expression might be guessed to express the local interface velocity as a function of the instantaneous values of the “outer” fields at the interface. As we shall see in Section 3, this does not appear to be necessarily possible for front problems like streamers, which correspond to front propagation into unstable states. The physical reason that the nonionized region into which the streamer fronts propagate is unstable, is that as soon as there are free electrons, there is further ionization due to the source term on the right-hand side of the streamer equations (8) and (9). This leads to an avalanch type of phenomenon, with exponential growth of the electron density, characteristic of a linearly unstable state. Let us nonetheless not let ourselves get discouraged, but follow our nose and assert that if the electron diffusion is small, one would expect that the normal velocity of a streamer front like that of Fig. 1c is approximately equal to the drift velocity of the electrons on the outer side of the charge sheet, v +Dk E`D"Dk +U`D . (12) n % % Here U is the electrical potential, E"!+U, and the superscript # indicates the value of the field at the charge sheet, extrapolated from the nonionized region. A linear relation, like Eq. (12) is indeed found to a good approximation for negatively charged streamers [1]. Now, in the nonionized region outside the streamer, the charge density is essentially zero [n +0, n +0 in ` %
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
20
Eq. (11)], and hence here
+ 2U+0 in the nonionized region .
(13)
Thus, we see that if we do think of a streamer sheet as a moving charge sheet and assume that the potential inside the streamer is roughly constant due to the high mobility of the electrons, it falls within the same class of gradient driven problems as dendrites and viscous fingers: the normal velocity of the charge sheet is proportional to the gradient of a field U, which itself obeys a Laplace or diffusion equation. 1.4. The Mullins—Sekerka instability We now discuss the Mullins—Sekerka instability of a planar interface. We will first follow the standard analysis for the simplest case of a planar solidification interface [3,26—28], and then indicate why in the long wavelength limit the same instability happens for all gradient-driven fronts whose outer field obeys a Laplace or diffusion equation. The analysis of the planar interface appears at first sight to be somewhat of an academic problem, as we will find such an interface to be unstable. However, the analysis does identify the basic physics that is responsible for the formation of natural growth shapes and it helps us to identify the proper length scale for the growth shapes that result (the form of the dispersion relation also plays a role in analytical approaches to the dendrite and viscous finger problem [34]). We want to consider the stability of a planar interface which grows with velocity v. To do so, we write the diffusion equation in a frame m "z!vt moving with velocity v in the z-direction, v ¹/t!v ¹/m "D+ 2¹ . v
(14)
Note that now + 2 denotes the Laplacian in the moving x, y, m frame. Furthermore, we consider for v simplicity the limit bP0 so that the other two basic equations are Eqs. (2) and (4), (¸/c)v "!D[(+ ¹l) !(+ ¹4) ] , n n,*/5 n,*/5
(15)
¹*/5"¹ [1!(p/¸)i] . M
(16)
Let us first look for a steady-state solution, i.e., the solution for a plane growing with a constant velocity v in the z-direction into an undercooled liquid. Since according to boundary condition (16) ¹*/5"¹ for a plane, the solution in the solid is ¹4 "¹ , while solving the diffusion equation M 0 M (Eq. (14)) for a solutions ¹l that are stationary in the m frame yields 0 v ¹l (m )"(¹ !¹ )e~mv@lD#¹ , ¹4 "¹ . = 0 M 0 v M =
(17)
Here we have taken the position of the plane at m "0, ¹ is the temperature far in front of the v = plane, and l "D/v is the thermal diffusion length. The temperature profile given by Eq. (17) is D sketched in Fig. 2. Substitution of this result into the boundary condition for heat conservation (15) yields ¸/c"(¹ !¹ ) . M =
(18)
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
21
Fig. 2. Qualitative sketch of the temperature profile at a planar interface in solidification.
This equation shows that the temperature ¹ has to be precisely an amount ¸/c below the melting = temperature (this criterion is often refered to as unit undercooling), and it is an immediate consequence of heat conservation. For, in order for the plane to be able to move with a constant speed, the amount of heat in the diffusion boundary layer must be constant in time, in the co-moving frame, and hence the net effect of the moving interface is that it replaces a liquid volume element at a temperature ¹ by a solid volume element at a temperate ¹ , while the heat per unit = M volume which is generated is ¸. Equating this to the heat c(¹ !¹ ) necessary to give the required M = increase in temperature gives Eq. (18). In passing, we note that if the undercooling far away is less [(¹ !¹ )(¸/c], a planar M = solidification front will gradually slow down (v&1/Jt) due to the slow increase of the thickness of the boundary layer. This gradual decrease of the speed is slow enough that we can extend most of the analysis below by making a quasistationary approximation for the velocity, but for simplicity we will assume that condition (18) is satisfied. We now turn to a linear stability analysis of this planar interface. To do so, we assume that the interface is slightly perturbed, i.e., that the position of the interface deviates slightly from the planar position m "0. The strategy then is to write the interface position as m "f(x, y, t) v v with f(x, y, t) small, and to solve the diffusion equation and boundary conditions to first order in f(x, y, t). Since the unperturbed planar solution is translation invariant in the xy plane, the eigenmodes of the linearized equations are simple Fourier modes, and it suffices to analyze each Fourier mode separately. Moreover, for simplicity, we can take this mode to vary in the x direction only. We thus write the perturbed interface and the temperature field as single Fourier modes of the form f(x, y, t)"f eXt`*kx, d¹l,4"d¹l,4(m )eXt`*kx . k v
(19)
Our goal is to determine the dispersion relation, i.e., X as a function of k. If X is positive, the corresponding mode k grows, and the planar solution is unstable to that particular mode. Consider first the temperature diffusion equation. Since it is already linear, the functions d¹l,4(m ) satisfy the v simple differential equations 1 dd¹l,4(m ) d2d¹l,4(m ) k v# k v "(X/D!k2)d¹l,4(m ) . k v l dm2 dm D v v
(20)
22
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
The solutions of these equations are simple exponentials; when we impose that the perturbed temperature fields d¹l,4 have to decay to zero far away from the interface, we get 1 d¹l (m )"d¹le~qmv, q" (1#J1!4l2 X/D#4k2l2 ) , (21) D D k v k 2l D 1 d¹4 (m )"d¹4 eq{mv, q@" (!1#J1!4l2 X/D#4k2l2 ) . (22) k v k D D 2l D Furthermore, continuity of the temperature at the interface implies ¹l (m "f)#d¹l(m "f) v 0 v "¹ #d¹4(m "f). To linear order, we can take d¹l and d¹4 at m "0, since they are already M v v linear in the perturbations. Expanding ¹l (m "f) to linear order gives ¹l (m "f)" 0 v 0 v ¹ !(¹ !¹ )f/l #2 and so we simply get M M = D (23) d¹l !(¹ !¹ )l~1f "d¹4 . k M = D k Turning now to the boundary conditions (15) and (16), we note that the curvature i of the surface m "f becomes i"!2f/x2/[(1#(f/x)2)3@2]"!2f/x2#O(f2). The local equilibrium v interface boundary condition (16) therefore becomes with this result and Eq. (23) d¹4 "!(p/¸)¹ k2f , (24) k M k d¹l "(¹ !¹ )l~1f !(p/¸)¹ k2f . (25) k M = D k M k Finally, we need to linearize the conservation boundary condition (15). The relation between the z-component of the interface velocity and the normal velocity v is v "v#fQ "v cos h, where h is n z n the angle between the interface and the z or m direction. Since cos h"1/J1#(f/x)2, this gives to linear order v "v#fQ . Furthermore, the perturbed gradient at the liquid side of the interface has n two contributions, one from ¹l evaluated at the perturbed position of the interface, and one from 0 d¹l. One gets, using also Eq. (18), X"(v/l )[!1#ql #D(q#q@)(!d k2)] , D D 0 where
(26)
d "p¹ c/¸2 (27) 0 M is the capillary parameter, which has a dimension of length. Just like the ratio p/¸, d is typically 0 a small microscopic length, of the order of tens of A_ ngstrom, say. Eq. (26) is the dispersion relation for the growth rate X we were after. In this general form, it is not so easy to analyze8 for general k, since q and q@ depend k and X through Eqs. (21) and (22).
8 It is easy to verify from expressions Eqs. (21) and (22) that X"0 for k"0. This is a consequence of the fact that the system is translation invariant, so that a perturbation that corresponds to a simple shift of the planar interface neither grows nor decays.
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
23
Fig. 3. (a) Sketch of the dispersion relation (28) for the stability of the planar solidification interface, in the quasistationary approximation. The linear behavior of X with DkD is generic for gradient driven growth problems, while the stabilization for larger k values depends on the problem under consideration. (b) Sketch of the compression of the isotherms in front of a bulge of the interface. If such a bulge appears on a long enough length scale that the capillary suppression of the local melting temperature is not too large, then the enhanced heat diffusion near the bulge associated with the compression of the isotherms makes the interface unstable. This is the origin of the Mullins—Sekerka instability, which is generic to gradient-driven growth problems.
The expression for X becomes much more transparent if the diffusion coefficient D is large enough and the perturbations of short enough wavelength that both9X;Dk2 and kl ;1. This is D actually the relevant limit for small wavelengths, as then l is very large and timescales are slow. In D this case, Eqs. (21) and (22) show that q@+q+DkD, and then the dispersion relation (26) reduces to X+vDkD[1!2d l k2] . 0 D
(28)
This is the form in which the dispersion relation is best known. As Fig. 3 illustrates, X grows linearly for small k (long wavelength), and all modes with wave number k(k "1/J2d l have / 0 D positive growth rates and hence are unstable (k is the neutral wave number for which X"0). / Hence, a mode with this wave number neither grows nor decays). The maximum growth rate is for k "k /J3, i.e., for a wavelength j "2p/k "2pJ6d l . We thus see that the planar .!9 / .!9 .!9 0 D interface is unstable to modes within a whole range of wavenumbers. Hence, even if we could prepare initially a (nearly) flat interface, we would soon see that small protrusions, especially those with a spatial scale of order j , would start to grow out. Quite soon, the interface evolution is .!9 then not described anymore by the linearized equations, and one has to resort to some nonlinear analysis to understand the morphology of the patterns that subsequently arise. Typically, j still .!9 is an important length scale even for these growth shapes, but it definitely is not the only parameter that determines the scale and morphology of the patterns [26—28,34]. An example of this was discussed at the school by Brener [2].
9 One cannot choose X independently to satisfy these conditions; nevertheless, one can show that Eq. (28) is a good approximation to Eq. (26) if the diffusion coefficient is large enough that the conditions in the text are satisfied [27]. Physically, we can think of this limit as the one where the diffusion is so large that the temperature diffusion equation can be approximated by the Laplace equation.
24
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
Qualitatively, the origin of the Mullins—Sekerka instability is easy to understand with the help of Fig. 3b. If the interface has some protrusion into the liquid, then the isotherms are compressed in the neighborhood of this protrusion, provided the length scale of the protrusion is large enough that the suppression of the local melting term due to the capillary correction is small. This means that the heat diffusion away from the interface is enhanced, i.e., that the latent heat produced in this region of the interface diffuses away more easily. Hence, the interface can grow faster there, and the protrusion grows larger in time. It is important to realize that the instability that we identified above only occurs upon growth, and not upon melting if the heat necessary to melt the crystal is supplied through the melt. This is why ice cubes keep a smooth rounded shape during melting. You are encouraged to repeat the qualitative arguments of Fig. 3b to convince yourself of this.10 See [26] for help and further discussion of this point. Clearly, the physical mechanism underlying the Mullins—Sekerka instability is not limited to crystal growth: it arises wherever the growth of or dynamics of a free interface is proportional to the gradient of a field which itself obeys a Laplace equation or diffusion equation — in fact, the approximation q+q@+k that allowed us to reduce the dispersion relation to Eq. (28) amounts to replacing the diffusion equation by the Laplace equation in the quasi-stationary limit! Now that we have done the analysis once in detail, it is easy to see that the linear dispersion X&DkD which we found for solidification for small k (See Fig. 3a), is a general feature of diffusion limited or gradient driven interface dynamics. To be specific, consider an interface whose normal velocity v is n proportional to the gradient of some field U, which obeys the Laplace equation, v "+UD , + 2U"0 in the bulk . (29) n */5 For a planar solution with velocity v, we have then the solution U (z)"U@ z"vz. Again, we 0 0 consider perturbations f"feXt`*kx of the interface. In order that dU then obeys the Laplace equation, it must be of the form dU"dU e*kx~@k@z, z'0 . (30) k Since to linear order the interface velocity v in the presence of the perturbation is v#fQ , we now n have Xf "!DkDdU . (31) k k Finally, the boundary conditions on the planar interface are such that they can be written in terms of derivatives of the fields or the interface shape, and if the basic equations are translation invariant 10 But nature always comes up with surprising exceptions: if a spin-polarized 3He crystal melts, a magnetic boundary layer builds up in the crystal, i.e., one now has a diffusion layer building up in front of a melting interface, while the temperature field is approximately homogeneous since the latent heat is small and the temperature diffusion fast. The Mullins—Sekerka instability upon melting that this results into due to the fact that both the interface velocity and the position of the diffusion boundary layer are reversed, was predicted in 1986 [38]. It has just this summer been observed in the low temperature group in Leiden by Marchenkov et al. We emphasize that in general, the presence or absence of the Mullins—Sekerka instability depends both on the ratios of transport coefficients, and on the direction of the gradients. As stressed to me by John Bechhoefer, it is the fact that impurity diffusion is usually negligible in the solid phase that makes the instability so asymmetric at most solid—liquid interfaces. In Bechhoefer’s thesis work on nematic—isotropic interface dynamics, the transport coefficients are roughly the same in both phases, and in this case both melting and freezing instabilities were observed.
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
25
(i.e., there is no external field that tends to pin the position of the interface), then we must have in linear order U (m "f )#dU "terms of higher order in k , 0 v k k
(32)
hence, since U@ "v, 0 dU "!vf as kP0 . k k
(33)
Using this in Eq. (31), we find X+vDkD as kP0 .
(34)
This clearly shows the generality of the presence of unstable long wavelength modes with linear dispersion in gradient-driven interface dynamics. Not only solidification, but also viscous fingering, streamer formation and flames [7,8] are subject to this same type of instability, as our discussion earlier in this section demonstrates. The differences between the various problems mainly occur in the stabilizing behavior at short distance scales. These depend on the details of the physics, and are usually different for different problems. They have to be included, however, since otherwise the interface would be completely unstable in the short wavelength limit kPR. 1.5. The connection between viscous fingering and DLA An interesting illustration of the above observation is given by diffusion-limited aggregation (DLA), in which clusters grow due to accretion of Brownian particles. Hence the driving force for growth is essentially the same physics as above, a long-range diffusion field governed by the Laplace equation, but in this case there are no stabilizing smoothing terms at shorter wavelength. Only the particle size or the lattice serves as a short distance cutoff, and in this case the growth is fractal [4]. The connection between the viscous fingering problem and DLA is actually quite deep. In the viscous fingering case, the growth is deterministic, and controlled by solving the Laplace equation in the bulk. In DLA, the probability distribution of the random walkers is also governed by the Laplace equation and the flux at the boundary of the growing cluster is proportional to the gradient of the probability distribution of walkers — as we saw, this is the basic ingredient of the Mullins—Sekerka instability. More importantly, however, the DLA growth process is intrinsically noisy as one particle is added at a time, and as there is no relaxation at the boundary of the cluster. As pointed out by Kadanoff et al. [39,40], the noise can be suppressed by having a cluster grow only at a site once that site has been visited a number of times by a random walker, and by allowing particles at the perimeter to detach and re-attach to the cluster with a probability that depends on the number of neighbors at each site. With increasing noise reduction, DLA in a channel crosses over to viscous fingering. Another surprising connection is that the mean occupation profile of the average of many realizations of DLA clusters in a channel approaches the shape of a viscous finger. See [41,42] for details.
26
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
2. Smooth fronts as effective interfaces 2.1. Fronts between a stable and a metastable state in one dimension — existence, stability and relaxation We now turn our attention to a different but related issue, namely the question when we can map a model with a smooth front, domain wall or transition zone, onto a sharp interface model, with boundary conditions which are local in space and time. The answer to this question, namely that this typically can be done for problems in which the interface separates two (meta)stable states or phases may not be that surprising. Nevertheless, thinking about these issues helped us clarify some of the points which we feel have not been paid due attention to in the literature, and which come to the foreground in our work with Ebert and Caroli on streamers [1]. There you really run into trouble if you blindly apply the formalism as it is usually presented in the literature. This will be discussed in detail in our future publications with Ebert [25], and I will keep you in suspense till Section 3 for a brief sketch of our present results and implications. Further motivation for the analysis of this section was given in the introduction. I am convinced most — if not all — elements of the discussion below must appear at many places in the literature. For example, the first part of the analysis appears in one form or another in [12—15], but since it will arise in almost any Ginzburg—Landau type of analysis — the working horse of condensed matter physics — I presume most ingredients can be found at many more places (similar questions arise in the analysis of instantons in field theory). Nonetheless, we have not come across any discussion from the perspective that we will emphasize in [25], the relation between relaxation, interface limits, and solvability. The present section is intended to provide a summary of the background material that can be found at scattered places in the literature and to serve as an introduction to our papers [25]. To be concrete, we will present our discussion in terms of a dynamical equation in one dimension of the form //t"2//x2#g(/) .
(35)
Here / is a real order parameter. This equation is about the simplest model equation for the analysis of relaxation dynamics, but it captures the essentials of the issues that also arise in more complicated variants and extensions. Later, in our discussion of the coupling to other fields, it is useful to introduce appropriate parameters to tune the time and spatial scales of the variation of /, but for the present discussion of Eq. (35) we will not need these. We have therefore used the freedom to choose appropriate time and spatial scales to set the prefactors of the derivative terms to unity. It will turn out to be useful to express g(/) in terms of the derivative of two other functions, which both play the role of a potential in different circumstances: g(/),!df (/)/d/,d»(/)/d/ ,
(36)
so that equivalent forms of Eq. (35) are / 2/ df (/) / 2/ d»(/) " ! Q " # . t x2 d/ t x2 d/
(37)
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
27
As we shall see later on, f has the interpretation of a free energy density in a Ginzburg—Landau picture, while » will play the role of a particle potential in a standard argument in which there is a one-to-one correspondence between front solutions and trajectories of a particle moving in the potential ». We are interested in cases in which g(/) has two zeroes g(/ ) with g@(/ )(0; these correspond to 4 4 (meta)stable homogeneous solutions /"/ of Eq. (35). Indeed, if we linearize this equation about 4 / , and substitute */&eXt`*kx (very much like we have done before), then we find 4 X"g@(/ )!k2(0, which confirms that the state is linearly stable. Without loss of generality, we 4 can always take g(0)"0 (»@(0)"0), so that /"0 is one of the stable states. We will label the other linearly stable state simply / . Although this is not necessary, we will for simplicity also take 4 g antisymmetric [g(!/)"g(/)], so that the potentials f and » are symmetric. A typical example of a function g(/) and its corresponding potentials is sketched in Fig. 4. Note that there is also a third root of g(/) in between 0 and / , and that here g@(/ )'0. A homogeneous state /"/ is 4 6 6 therefore unstable (X"g@!k2'0 for small k). Let us now focus right away on front or domain wall type solutions of the type sketched in Fig. 5a: they connect a domain where / + / on the left to a domain where / + 0 on the right. 4
Fig. 4. The function g(/) and the associated potentials f (/) and »(/) used in our discussion of front solutions of Eq. (35).
Fig. 5. (a) Example of the type of moving front solution we are looking for. (b) The potential ». A moving front solution like the one sketched in (a) corresponds in the particle-on-the-hill analogy to the solution of the dynamical problem in which the particle starts at the top at / , moves down the hill and up the one in the center, and comes to rest at the center 4 top as the quasi-time m P R. v
28
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
Obvious questions are: what does the solution look like? In which direction will the front move? And how does it relax to its moving state? The answers to these questions can be obtained in a very appealing and intuitive way for this simple model equation by reformulating the questions into a form that almost every physicist is familiar with. However, the two main points — the existence of a unique solution and exponential relaxation — have more general validity. We can look for the existence of moving front solutions by making the Ansatz / (x!vt)"/ (m ), with m "x!vt. Such solutions are uniformly translating in the x frame, and v v v v hence stationary in the co-moving frame m . Substitution of this ansatz into Eq. (37) gives, after v a rearrangement d2/ d/ d»(/ ) v"!v v! v . (38) dm2 dm d/ v v v This equation is familiar to you: it is formally equivalent to the equation for a “particle” with mass 1 moving in a potential », in the presence of “friction”. In this analogy, which is summarized below, m plays the role of time, and v the role of a friction coefficient: v (39)
Clearly, the question whether there is a traveling wave solution of the type sketched in Fig. 5a translates into the question, in the particle-on-the-hill analogy: is there a solution in which the particle starts at the top of the potential » at / at “time” m "!R, rolls down the hill, and 4 v comes to rest at the top of the hill at /"0? In the language of the analogy the answer is immediately obvious: if the value »(/ ) of the potential at / is larger than at /"0, i.e., if 4 4 (40) *» , »(/ )!»(0) 4 is positive, then there must be a solution with a nonzero positive value of the velocity (the “friction coefficient”). Such a solution corresponds to a front which moves to the right so that the / + / 4 domain expands. In the opposite case, when the potential at / is lower than at 0 so that *»(0, 4 then such a solution only exists for “negative friction” so that enough energy is pumped into the system that the particle can climb the center hill. Negative friction corresponds to a left-moving front with v(0, so that the / + 0 domain expands. Let us make this a bit more precise by first asking what happens when the “friction” v is very large. Then, there is no solution where the particle moves from the top at / to the one at /"0: for 4 large friction the particle creeps down the hill and comes to rest in the bottom of the potential. When the friction is reduced, the particle loses less energy, and is able to climb further up on the left side of the well. Hence, if we keep on reducing the “friction” v, at some value v"v the particle has 0 just enough energy left to climb up all the way to the top at /"0, and get to rest there. In other words, at v"v , there is a unique solution of the type sketched in Fig. 5a. If v is reduced slightly 0 below v , the particle overshoots a little bit, and it finally ends up in the left well. So for v just below 0 v , there are no solutions with / P 0 for m P 0. However, if we keep on reducing v, there comes 0 v v
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
29
a point v"v where the particle first overshoots the middle top, then moves back and forth once in 1 the left well, and finally makes it to the center top — the profile / 1(m ) then has one node where v v / 1(m )"0. Clearly, we can continue to reduce v and find values v , v , v ,2 where the profile v v 2 3 4 / i has 2, 3, 4,2 nodes. As is illustrated in Fig. 6, we thus have a discrete set of moving front v solutions. Which one is stable and dynamically relevant? Intuitively, we may expect that the one with the largest velocity, v , is both the stable and the dynamically relevant one, since the multiple 0 oscillations of the other profiles look rather unphysical. This indeed turns out to be the case: if you start with an initial condition close to the profile / 1 with velocity v , you will find that the node v 1 either “peels off ” from the front region and then stays behind, or moves quickly ahead to disappear from the scene on the front end. In both cases, a front with velocity v emerges after a while. The 0 stability analysis of the front solutions which we will present later confirms that only the fastest v front solution is linearly stable. 0 Before turning to the linear stability analysis, we make a brief digression about the connection with a more thermodynamic point of view that is especially popular in studies of coarsening [12—15]. It is well known that Eqs. (35) and (37) can also be written as
P CA B
D
/ 1 / 2 dF #f (/) . "! , F" dx t 2 x d/
(41)
In a Ginzburg—Landau-like point of view, F plays the role of a free energy functional, whose derivative dF/d/ drives the dynamics, and f (/) is the coarse grained free energy density. This formulation brings out clearly that the dynamics is relaxational and corresponds to that of a non-conserved order parameter (the conserved case corresponds to //t"#+ 2dF/d/, so that :dx / remains constant under the dynamics). Note also that in statistical physics one often starts with postulating an expression for a coarse grained free energy functional like F, and then obtains the dynamics for / from the first equation in Eq. (41). One should be aware that in pattern formation, one usually has to start from the dynamical equations, and that these usually do not follow from some simple free energy functional [43]. An immediate consequence of Eq. (41) is that
P
P A B
dF dF / dF 2 " dx "! dx 40 , dt d/ t d/
(42)
Fig. 6. Graphical representation of the fact that a discrete set of moving front solutions is found at velocity values v , v , v ,2 The number of nodes of the corresponding profiles / is i. 0 1 2 vi
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
30
so that under the dynamics of /, F is a non-increasing function of time — it either decreases or stays constant (in technical terms: F is a Lyapunov functional). Since the homogeneous steady states /"0 and /"/ correspond to minima of f (/) and hence of F, this immediately shows that a front 4 moves in the direction so that the domain whose state has the lowest free energy density f expands. Since f"!», this is equivalent to the conclusion reached above, that the domain corresponding to the maximum value of the potential » expands. Consider now the case in which the states /"0 and / have the same free energy density: 4 *f,f (/ )!f (0)"!*»"0. They are then “in equilibrium”, and a wall or interface between 4 these two states does not move. Then the excess free energy per unit area, associated with the presence of this wall, which is nothing but the surface tension p is
P CA B
p" dx
D
1 / 2 0 #f (/ )!f (0) . 0 2 x
(43)
We can rewrite this by using the fact that energy conservation in the particle picture implies that the sum of the kinetic and “potential” energy (!f ) is constant, so that 1(/ /x)2!f (/ ) 0 2 0 "!f (0), since far away to the right / /x P 0 and / P 0. Using this in Eq. (43), we get 0 0
P
p" dx(/ /x)2 , 0
(44)
which is an expression which is very often used in square-gradient theories of interfaces. In our case, we can use it to obtain a physically transparant expression for the velocity v of the moving front: If we multiply Eq. (38) by d/ /dm and integrate over m , the term on the left-hand side becomes v v v :dm (d/ /dm )(d2/ /dm2)"1:dm (d/dm )(d/ /dm )2"0 since d/ /dm vanishes for m P $R. As v v v v v 2 v v v v v v v a result, we are left with !*f :dm [d/ /dm df/d/] v v " . v" v :dm (d/ /dm )2 :dm (d/ /dm )2 v v v v v v
(45)
This expression confirms again that the domain whose state has the lowest free energy f expands. But it shows more: for small differences *f, the velocity is small, so we can approximate / in the v denominator by / , the profile of the interface in equilibrium. But in this approximation, the 0 denominator is nothing but the surface tension of Eq. (44), so v + !*f/p, v small .
(46)
Thus, the response of the interface is linear in the driving force *f and the surface tension p plays the role of an inverse mobility coefficient. The above expressions are often used in the work on coarsening, and can be extended to include perturbatively the effect of curvature or slowly varying additional fields on the interface velocity. We will come to this later. We now return to the question of stability of the front solutions with velocity v , v ,2, using an 0 1 analysis that is inspired by a few simple arguments in [44]. Keep in mind that we will study the stability of front solutions in one dimension themselves, not the stability of a planar interface or front to small changes in its shape, like we did in Section 1. To study the linear stability of a front
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
31
solution / (m ), we write v v / i(m , t)"/ i(m )#g(m , t) , v v v v v
(47)
and linearize the dynamical equation Eq. (35) in g in the moving frame m to get v g g 2g "v # #g@(/ i)g#O(g2) . im v t x2 v
(48)
Since the equation is linear, we can answer the question of stability by studying the spectrum of temporal eigenvalues. To do so, we write g(m , t)"e~Ete~vmv@2t (m ) v E v
(49)
so that all modes with eigenvalues E'0 are stable. Upon substitution of this in Eq. (48), we get
(50)
which is nothing but the Schro¨dinger equation (with +2/m"1) and which explains why we used E for the temporal eigenvalue in the ansatz (Eq. (49)). In the analogy with quantum mechanics which we will now exploit, º(m ) plays the role of a potential, and we are interested in the energy v eigenvalues E of the quantum mechanical particle in this potential. If we find a negative eigenvalue, the profile / i is unstable, i.e., there is then at least one eigenmode of the linear evolution operator v whose amplitude will grow in time under the dynamics. In other words, if we take as an initial condition for the dynamics the uniformly translating profile / we considered plus a small v perturbation about this which has a decomposition along this unstable eigenmode, the perturbation proportional to this eigenmode will grow in time. Consider first the form of the potential º(m ) for v"v . In this case the front has a smooth v 0 monotonically decreasing profile of the form sketched in Fig. 5a. Both for m P!R and for v m PR, g@(/ 0) is negative, so º(m ) is positive for m $R. In between, around / 0"/ , g@(/) is v v v v v 6 positive as Fig. 4a shows, and so º(m ) is smaller than its asymptotic values in this range. The v resulting shape of º(m ) is sketched in Fig. 7 for a case in which º(!R)'º(R). Armed with v a physicist’s standard knowledge of quantum mechanics, we can now immediately draw the following conclusions: (1) The continuous spectrum corresponds to solutions t that approach plane wave states as E m P R in the case drawn in Fig. 7, and so they have an energy E5º(R)"(v2/4#Dg@(0)D)'0. v 0 In other words, the bottom of the continuous spectrum lies at a positive energy, and all the corresponding eigenmodes relax exponentially fast. (2) Next, consider the discrete spectrum. Since the original equation is translation invariant, if / 0(m ) is a solution, so is / 0(m #a)"/ 0(m )#a d/ 0(m )/dm #2. In other words, as the v v v v v v v v v perturbation is nothing but a small shift of the profile, the perturbation should neither grow nor decay. This implies that d/ 0(m )/dm must be a “zero mode” of the linear equation, i.e., be a solution v v v
32
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
Fig. 7. Sketch of the potential º(m ) which enters in the stability analysis of the front / between a stable and v v0 a meta-stable state. The asymptotes º(R) and º(!R) are both positive. The resulting eigenvalues spectrum is sketched on the right. Note that there always is an eigenvalue E"0 due to the translation mode.
of the Schro¨dinger equation Eq. (49) with eigenvalue E"0:11 E"0: t (m )"d/ 0(m )/dm . (51) 0 v v v v (3) Clearly, the “translation mode” d/ 0(m )/dm with eigenvalue zero is a “bound state solution” v v v [as it should, in view of Eq. (1)] since it decays exponentially to zero for m P$R. Moreover, v since / 0 decays monotonically, d/ 0(m )/dm (0, so the translation mode d/ 0(m )/dm does not v v v v v v v have a zero, i.e., is nodeless. Now it is a well-known result of quantum mechanics [45] that the bound state wave functions can be ordered according to the number of nodes they have: the ground state with energy E has no nodes, the first excited bound state (if it exists) has one node, and so on. 0 If we combine this with our observation that t "d/ 0(m )/dm is nodeless and has an eigenvalue 0 v v v E "0, we are led immediately to the conclusion that if there are other bound states, they must 0 have eigenvalues E'0. Taken together, these results show that apart from the trivial translation mode all eigenfunctions12 have positive eigenvalues E and so are stable: they decay as tPR. Moreover, there is a gap: if the form of the function g(/) is such that there are bound state solutions, then the mode that relaxes slowest is the first “excited” bound state solution t with eigenvalue E '0. Otherwise, the 1 1 slowest relaxation mode is determined by the bottom of the continuous spectrum. In either case, all nontrivial perturbations around the profile / 0 relax exponentially fast. v It is now easy to extend the analysis to the other front profile solutions / 1,/ 2, etc. Consider, e.g., v v / 1. The analysis of the continuous spectrum proceeds as before so the continuous spectrum again v
11 You can easily convince yourself that this is true by substituting / (m #a) in the original ordinary differential v0 v equation for the profile Eq. (38), expanding to linear order in a, and transforming to the function t. You then get Eq. (49) with E"0 and t "d/ (m )/dm . 0 v0 v v 12 There is actually a slightly subtle issue here that we have swept under the rug. In quantum mechanics, wave functions t which diverge as m P$R are excluded, as these cannot be normalized; due to the transformation Eq. (49) v from g to t, there can be perfectly honorable eigenfunctions g of fronts that do not translate into normalizeable wave functions t. In the present case, these eigenfunctions turn out to have large positive eigenvalues, and so they do not affect our conclusions concerning the relaxation, but for fronts propagating into unstable states one has to be much more careful. See Section 3 and [25] for further details.
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
33
has a gap. Again, the translation mode d/ 1(m )/dm neither grows nor decays, so has eigenvalue v v v zero, but now the fact that / 1 goes through zero once and then decays to zero implies that v d/ 1(m )/dm has exactly one node. According to the connection between the number of nodes of v v v bound state solutions and the ordering of the energy eigenvalues, there must then be precisely one eigenfunction with a smaller eigenvalue than the translation mode which has E"0. In other words, there is precisely one unstable mode. Likewise, all other profiles / i with i'0 are unstable v to i modes. In summary, our analysis shows that in the dynamical equation Eq. (35) for the order parameter /, there is a discrete set of moving front solutions. Only the fastest one is stable, and its motion is in accord with simple thermodynamic intuition. Moreover, the relaxation towards this unique solution is exponentially fast, as e~*Et, where *E is the gap to the lowest bound state eigenvalue, if one exists, or else to the bottom of the continuum band. 2.2. Relaxation and the effective interface or moving boundary approximation As explained in the introduction, in many cases one wants to map a problem with a smooth but thin front or interfacial zone onto one with a mathematically sharp interface with appropriate boundary conditions. We have termed this the effective interface approximation. Reasons for using this mapping can be either to replace a sharp interface problem by a computationally simpler one with a smooth front (e.g., a so-called phase-field model for a solidification front [5,6,46]) or to translate a problem with a thin transition zone (e.g., streamers [1], chemical waves [9,10], combustion [7,8]) onto a moving boundary problem, so as to be able to exploit our understanding of this class of problems. We will refer to this literature and to [23] for detailed discussion of the mathematical basis of such approaches. Here, we just want to emphasize how the exponential relaxation of front profiles that we discussed above is a conditio sine qua non for being able to apply this mapping. For concreteness, let us consider the following phase-field model which is a simple example of the type of models which have been introduced for studying solidification within this context [6,46] u/t"+ 2u#//t ,
(52)
e //t"e2+ 2/#g(/, u) ,
(53)
g(/, u)"!f//, f (/, u)"/2(/!1)2#ju/ .
(54)
In this formulation, / is the order parameter field, and u plays the role of a temperature. For fixed u, we recognize in Eq. (53) the order parameter equation that we have studied before: the potential f has a double-well structure for ju small. At u"0 the states /"0 and /"1 have the same free energy f, and the “liquid” state /"0 and “solid” state /"1 are then in equilibrium. As we have seen, an interface beween these two states then neither melts nor grows. For j'0, a positive temperature u makes the liquid-like state at the minimum near /"0 the lowest free energy state, and below the melting temperature u"0 the solid-like minimum near /"1 has the lowest free energy. The order parameter equation is coupled to the diffusion equation Eq. (52) for the temperature through the term //t. This term plays the role of a latent heat term when
34
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
solidification occurs: it is a source term in the interfacial zone, where / rapidly increases from about zero to one. Moreover, if the interface is locally moving with speed v , then //t+!v//m , so n v if we integrate through the thin interfacial zone we see that this term contributes a factor v , in n agreement with the fact that the latent heat released at the solid-melt interface is proportional to v . n In writing Eqs. (52)—(54), the space and time scales have been written in units of the “outer” scale on which the temperature field u varies. In these units, the interface width in the order parameter field / should be small, and this is why the parameter e;1 has been introduced in Eq. (53): it ensures that the interface width ¼ scales as e and that the time scale q for the order parameter relaxation is also of order e. It thus allows us to derive the effective interface equations mathematically using the methods of matched asymptotic expansions or singular perturbation theory [5,21,22] by taking the limit eP0. Since both ¼ and q scale as e the response of the interface velocity v stays finite as e goes to zero. n Although the mathematical analysis by which effective interface equations can be obtained is certainly more sophisticated and systematical than what will transpire from the brief discussion in this section, what seems to be the essential step in all the approaches is the following. In the term ju in g or f, which is often treated for convenience as a small perturbation, it is recognized that in the interfacial zone (of width of order e) u does not change much and hence can effectively be treated as a constant in lowest order. Moreover, since the shape of the interface is curved on the “outer” scale, the curvature i of the interfacial zone, when viewed on the inner scale of the front width, is treated as a small parameter which enters, as we shall see below, the equations in order e. This is because when ¼P0, the front becomes locally almost planar. As is illustrated in Fig. 8, one now introduces a curved local coordinate system o(r, t), s(r, t) where the o is oriented normal to the front and points in the direction of the / + 0 phase, which in a Ginzburg—Landau description is normally associated with the disordered phase (we thought of it as the “liquid” phase before). By choosing, e.g., the line o"0 to coincide with the contour line /"1, we ensure that this line follows 2 the interface zone. In the limit o P 0 we then have lim o/tDr"!v (s, t), n o?0
lim + 2o"i(s, t) . o?0
(55)
The derivation of an effective interface approximation now proceeds by introducing the stretched (curvilinear) coordinate m "o/e for the analysis of the inner structure of the front profile, and v assuming that the fields / and u can be expanded in a power series of e as ‘‘inner region”: /"/*/(m , s, t)#e/*/(m , s, t)#2 , 0 v 1 v u"u*/(m , s, t)#eu*/(m , s, t)#2 , 0 v 1 v
(56)
‘‘outer region”: /"/065(r, t)#e/065(r, t)#2 , 0 1 u"u065(r, t)#eu065(r, t)#2 . 0 1
(57)
These “inner” and “outer” expansions then have to obey matching conditions [23,46] (according to the theory of matched asymptotic expansions [21,22], the outer expansion of the inner solution has to be equal to the inner expansion of the outer solution). We will not discuss these here, but instead
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
35
Fig. 8. Qualitative sketch of a curved front of width ¼, and the local curvilinear coordinate system (o, s) used in the derivation of an effective interface model.
limit ourselves to an analysis of the inner problem.13 On the inner scale, we have14 e2+ 2"(2/m2)#ei(/m )#O(e2) . (58) v v Furthermore, we shall treat the term u in g formally as a term of order e and write v"v e#2 and 1 u"u e#2 — this is not so elegant and not necessary either, but it gets us to the proper answer 1 efficiently. As the velocity is then also of order e, this implies that / is then the stationary front 0 profile (/ /m "0) between two phases in equilibrium, so that from Eq. (54) the lowest order 0 v equation becomes 2/*/(m )/m2#g(/*/(m ), 0)"0 . (59) 0 v v 0 v The solution of this equation is just the equilibrium profile / that we introduced in our discussion 0 of the surface tension. Of course, it is not at all surprising that Eq. (59) emerges in lowest order, since at u"0 the two phases are in equilibrium. Now, in the next order, we get
A
B
K
/*/(m ) g(/*/, u) 2 0 u . (60) #g@(/*/) /*/(m )"!(v #i) 0 v ! 1 0 1 v 1 m u m2 v v u/0 This equation allows us to solve for /*/ in principle. But even without doing so explicitly, we can get 1 the most important information out of it. The operator between parentheses on the left is nothing but the linear operator we already encountered before: the Schro¨dinger operator in our discussion of stability. We then saw that this operator has a mode with eigenvalue zero, the translation mode d/ /dm . Moreover, since the operator is hermitian, it is also a left eigenmode with eigenvalue zero 0 v
13 You may easily verify yourself that by substituting Eq. (57) into Eqs. (52)—(54) the equation for /065 reduces to 0 g(/065, u065)"0 which shows that /065 is just “slaved” to u065: to lowest order, the order parameter in the bulk (outer) 0 0 0 0 region is the value of /065 which minimizes the free energy density f at the local temperature u065. 0 0 14 You can easily convince yourself of the correctness of this result by taking the interface as locally spherical with radius of curvature R. In spherical coordinates, the radial terms of + 2 are 2/r2#(2/r)/r, which gives e2+ 2 + e2(2/r2#(2/R)/r)"2/m #(ei)/m #2. v v
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
36
of this operator. This implies that for the equation to be solvable, the right hand side has to be orthogonal to the left zero mode d/ /dm . This condition leads to a so-called solvability condition. 0 v Upon multiplying Eq. (60) by d/ /dm and integrating, we can write this condition as an expression 0 v for the normal interface velocity v to lowest order in e, n d/ g(/ , u) 0 0 u :dm v dm 1 u v v "!i! . (61) n :dm (d/ /dm )2 v 0 v Here, we used the fact that /*/"/ . Moreover, in the integration on the right hand side, we can 0 0 take u constant, since the temperature does not vary to lowest order in the interfacial region (its derivatives do — see [46] for more details). The above expression is our central result. The fact that the prefactor of the curvature term on the right is unity comes from the fact that the curvature enters according to the expansion Eq. (58) of the diffusion term + 2 in precisely the same way as the velocity term that arises from the transformation to the co-moving curvilinear from m . When u "0, i.e., when we consider an v 1 interface between two equilibrium phases, it expresses the tendency of the interfaces to straighten out. This effect drives coarsening [12—15], and the motion is sometimes referred to as motion by mean curvature. The second term gives the driving term when the interface temperature u is not equal to the equilibrium temperature. The structure of this term is also quite transparent. In the denominator, we recognize the surface tension Eq. (44), and as we already discussed, the inverse of the surface tension plays the role of an interface mobility in the context of the type of models we consider. In the numerator we can write g in terms of !f (/ , u)// and then do the integral in 0 0 the same way as before in deriving Eq. (45); we then simply get 1 d*f v "!i! n p du
K
u, (62) u/0 where now *f is the difference in free energy densities at opposite sides of the interface. Clearly, the second term is exactly what we could have guessed on the basis of what we already knew before, and together with the curvature term it has exactly the same type of structure as the boundary condition Eq. (3) that we introduced in our first discussion of solidification. The complications that are necessary to model anisotropic kinetics and surface tension with a phase-field model are significant [6], but conceptually the analysis is essentially the same. By taking big steps, we have not done justice to the systematics of the analysis, and there is much more to say about it. If you want to know more, you will find entries to the literature in [5,6,23,46]. However, the point we want to bring to the foreground, following [25] is that in all such approaches, a hidden assumption is made in writing the inner expansion as /*/"/*/(o/e, s, t)#2 0 in Eq. (56). In doing so, we basically already assume that on the slow time scale t, the profile responds instantaneously to variations in the outer field u. This is why on the inner scale, the changes in the profile (like /*/) are given by ordinary differential equations with coefficients which 1 may vary on the outer slow time scale. As it happens, this is actually justified for these type of problems. For, we have seen that the relaxation of a profile goes exponentially fast, as the spectrum of temporal eigenvalues E has a finite gap *E. In the present case, where the time scale q in the order parameter equation scales as e, this means that the relaxation of the front profile goes as
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
37
e~*Et@e. This shows that as e P 0, the adiabatic assumption implicit in the above analysis is right, as the relaxation on the inner scale completely decouples from the slow scale variation of the outer fields. In other words, we have left out exponentially small terms as e P 0, but that is something that almost always happens when we perform an asymptotic expansion! As we shall see now, the adiabatic approximation cannot be made for fronts moving into an unstable state, such as streamers.15
3. Some elements of front propagation into unstable states — relaxation and the effective interface approximation We now briefly touch on a few elements of fronts propagating into unstable states. In view of the length restrictions on the contribution to the proceedings of the school, we only highlight some recent results obtained in collaboration with Ebert [25], which show that a large class of fronts propagating into an unstable state show universal power-law relaxation and that this makes the mapping of such fronts onto an effective interface model questionable. Our own motivation comes from our attempt to understand the streamer problem, but examples of fronts propagating into an unstable state arise in various fields of physics: they are important in many convective instabilities in fluid dynamics such as the onset of von Karman vortex generation [52], in Taylor [53] and Rayleigh-Be´nard [19] convection, they play a role in spinodal decomposition near a wall [54], the pearling instability of laser-tweezed membranes [55], the formation of kinetic, transient microstructures in structural phase transitions [56], the propagation of a superconducting front into an unstable normal metal [57], or in error propagation in extended chaotic systems [58]. The experimental relevance of the understanding of the relaxation of such fronts is illustrated on propagating Taylor vortex fronts. Here the measured velocities were about 40% lower than predicted theoretically [53], and only later numerical simulations [59] showed that this was due to slow transients. When one of the states is unstable, even a small perturbation around this state will grow out and spread; therefore, the properties of fronts that propagate into an unstable state depend on the initial conditions. If the initial profile is steep enough, arising, e.g., through local initial perturbations, it is known that the propagating front in practice always relaxes to a unique profile and velocity [44,47—49,51]. Depending on the nonlinearities, one generally can distinguish two regimes: as a rule, fronts whose propagation is driven (“pushed”) by the nonlinearities, resemble very much the fronts which propagate into a metastable state and which we have discussed extensively in Section 2 (e.g., their relaxation is also exponential in time). We will therefore not consider this regime, which is often refered to as “pushed” [50,51] or “nonlinear marginal stability” [49] any
15 At the summerschool, Roger Folch Manzanares nicely illustrated to me how one can go wrong with an effective interface approximation if one does not think about the stability of the equations on the inner scale: in a first naieve attempt to formulate phase field equations for the viscous finger problem, he had explored equations which did reduce to the standard viscous finger equations if one blindly followed the standard recipe for analyzing the e P 0 limit. However, the coupling of the phase field with the outer pressure-like field was such that the equations were completely unstable on the inner scale for small e. So do watch out!
38
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
Fig. 9. The functions g and » in the case of front propagation into unstable states. Compare Fig. 4, where the functions are drawn for the case of a front between a stable and a metastable state.
further. If, on the other hand, nonlinearities mainly cause saturation, fronts propagate with a velocity determined by linearization about the unstable state, as if they are “pulled” by the linear stability (“pulled” [50,51] or “linear marginal stability” [48,49] regime). Almost all important differences between “pulled” or “linear marginal stability” fronts propagating into an unstable state and those propagating into a metastable state trace back to the fact that in the latter case there typically is a discrete set of front solutions, only one of which is stable as was illustrated in Fig. 6, while in the former case there generally is a family of moving front solutions [44,47—49]. To illustrate this, we again turn to Eq. (35), but now take g(/) of the form sketched in Fig. 9a. In this case, g@(0)'0, so the state /"0 is unstable. If we again consider fronts propagating into this state, the potential » corresponding to this function g is the one shown in Fig. 9b. Now, the question of the existence of a uniformly translating profile / (x!vt)"/(m ) translates into the v v question “is there a solution in the particle on the hill analogy in which the particle starts at time m "!R at the top, and comes to the bottom as m P R?”. Obviously, there is such a solution v v for any positive value of the “friction coefficient” v: there is a continuous family of uniformly translating front solutions. It is useful to consider the relation between the velocity v which labels the front solutions, and the asymptotic decay rate K: if we linearize Eq. (35) around the state /"0 and write / & e~Kmv, then v we get vK"K2#g@(0), so K "1v $ J1v2!g@(0), g@(0)'0 . (63) B 2 4 For v'2g@(0), the roots are real, and K (K . For v(2g@(0), the roots are complex, meaning that ~ ` the front solutions decay to zero as / &cos(IK m )e~RKBmv. Clearly, the velocity v*"2g@(0) is v B v a special value, as the two roots coincide there K "K "K*. It is a well-known result that in such ~ ` a degenerate case, the front profile does not decay as a single exponential, but that instead in this case / *(m )&(m #const.)e~K*mv , (64) v v v so that the dominant behavior for large m is the m e~K*mv term. v v The special status of the value v* also becomes clear when we look at the stability analysis of the fronts / (m ). If we retrace the stability analysis of Section 2, then in this case the potential º(m ) in v v v the Schro¨dinger-type equation for the spectrum has an asymptotic value (v*)2/4!g@(0)"0. Hence,
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
39
according to our arguments the continuous spectrum associated with quantum mechanically allowable eigenfunctions16t comes all the way down to zero, i.e., there is no gap. This already gives a hint that there will be nonexponential relaxation. In the derivation of effective interface equations, we encountered solvability conditions which involved integrals of the form :dx(d/ /dx)2 — see Eq. (61). In the present case, the front velocity is 0 always nonzero, and as a result the stability operator is non-Hermitian [25]. If one tries to derive effective interface equations for such fronts using the same type of approach as discussed at the end of Section 2, one needs the zero mode of the adjoint operator of the problem with vO0 in the corresponding solvability condition. Because of the non-hermitian nature of this operator for vO0, this zero mode turns out to be evmv(d/ /dm ), and one encounters integrals of the type v v :dm evmv(d/ /dm )2 (note that for v"0, the zero mode of the adjoint operator reduces to the one we v v v used before, / /m ). As m PR, the integrand behaves as17 e(v~2K~)mv"eJv2@4~g{(0)mv. As a result, 0 v v the integrals that arise if one naively applies the standard analysis do not converge. Although there have been some suggestions [61] that one might regularize such integrals by introducing a cutoff which is taken to infinity at the end of the calculations, such fixes do not appear to work here and obscure the connection of this problem with the slow relaxation discussed below. We have not yet discussed the origin of the result that “pulled” fronts which emerge from sufficiently localized initial conditions move with a speed v* determined by the linear behavior of the dynamical equation [in our case, the fact that v* is determined solely by g@(0)]. The origin lies in the fact that any perturbation about the unstable state grows out and spreads by itself. This leads to a natural spreading speed of linear perturbations, and v* is nothing but this speed itself [49,60]. If nonlinearities mainly suppress further growth, then indeed the dynamically relevant front is “pulled” [50] by the leading edge whose dynamics is governed by the linearized equation. Ebert and I have recently found that one can build on this idea to analyze the relaxation of front profiles towards / * [25]. The main idea can be illustrated within the context of the dynamical equation v (Eq. (35)) as follows. Let us use the freedom of choosing appropriate space and time scales to take g@(0)"1. As the discussion following Eq. (63) shows, v*"2 and K*"1 in this case, and the linearized dynamical equation reads /(x, t)/t"2/(x, t)/x2#/(x, t) .
(65)
We now write the equation in the moving frame m "x!v*t moving with velocity v*"2, and v make the transformation /(m , t)"e~mvt(m , t). This is essentially the same type of transformation v v that we did before in Eq. (49) when we performed the stability analysis of moving front solutions. With these transformations, t simply obeys the diffusion equation t(m , t)/t"2t(m , t)/x2 . v v
(66)
16 At this point, the warning of footnote 12 becomes important: for fronts propagating into an unstable state, there are important eigenfunctions of the stability operator which are not in the class of eigenfunctions that are allowed in quantum mechanics, as they diverge as m P$R. These are especially important when studying the stability of front v solutions with velocity v'v*, as these are the type of solutions whose eigenvalue continues all the way down to zero. As a result, the stability spectrum is always gapless. See [25] for further details. 17 The factor Jv2/4!g@(0) in the exponential is zero at v*. At v*, the integrals still diverge, but only as a power law [25].
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
40
As is well known, in many diffusion type problems the long time asymptotics is governed by the fundamental similarity solution or one of its derivatives, like t4:."(1/t1@2)e~m2v@4t or t4:."!t4:./m "(m /2t3@2)e~m2v@4t , (67) 1 2 1 v v so it is not unreasonable to expect that one of these similarity solutions also governs the long time asymptotics in the leading edge here. If so, the corresponding function /(m , t) should approach the v dominant m e~mv term of Eq. (64) for large times. As t"eK*mv/, this means that the spatial v dependence of the similarity solution t4:. that we are looking for should go as m for m2;t. v v Clearly, the appropriate one is t4:.. Hence, this simple argument suggests that in the frame moving 2 with velocity v*"2, the dominant long time dynamics in the leading edge is (68) /&(m /t3@2)e~mv~m2v@4t"e~mv~3@2-/ t`-/ mv~m2v@4t . v If we now track the position m (t) of the point where /(m , t)"h, we get to dominant order from the h v requirement that the exponent in the above expression remains constant m "!3ln t#2 Q mQ "!(3/2t)#2 (69) h 2 h As mQ is the velocity of the point where /"h, we see that in the leading edge of the profile the h velocity relaxes towards v* as !3/(2t). This is precisely what was found by Bramson [62] from a rigorous analysis. Although the above argument is rather handwaving, we have recently found [25] that it can be made into a systematic asymptotic analysis which applies not just to the second-order dynamical equation (Eq. (35)), but also to higher-order partial differential equations which admit uniformly translating front solutions. The surprising finding is that not just the leading order &1/t relaxation term in the velocity is universal, but also the first subdominant &1/t3@2 term, which cannot be obtained from the sove argument: independent of the “height” h whose position we track, we find that the velocity v (t)"v*#mQ relaxes to v* as h h
A
B AB
1 3 Jp v "v*! * 1! #O , h t2 2K t K*JDt
(70)
where for the order parameter equation (35) with g@(0)"1, v*"2, K*"1 and D"1. In the more general case, D is a coefficient which plays the role of a diffusion coefficient, and which can be determined explicitly from the dispersion relation of the linearized equation. Moreover, also the shape of the profile relaxes with the same slow power laws in a universal way which is related to the existence of a family of front solutions. We refer to [25] for details. The above 1/t power law relaxation is clearly too slow to make an effective interface approximation with boundary conditions which are local in space and time possible for “pulled” fronts whose propagation into an unstable states originates in diffusive spreading and growth. To see this, consider, e.g., a spherically symmetric front in Eq. (35) in three dimensions which grows out from some localized region around the origin. For long times the front region is thin in comparison with the distance r from the origin and the curvature of the front is small and of order 2/r +2/(2v*t). & & Thus, the curvature is of the same order as the dominant relaxation term of the front, and one cannot simply express the instantaneous front velocity in terms of v* plus some kind of curvature correction, as we saw one can do for fronts between a stable and a metastable state. Some
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
41
preliminary numerical investigations have confirmed this. Whether some other interfacial description with memory type of terms can be developed, or whether there are other unexpected consequences of this slow relaxation, is at present an open question.
Acknowledgements Much of my thinking on the issues discussed in these lecture notes has been shaped by interactions and collaborations with Christiane Caroli and Ute Ebert. I wish to thank both of them. In addition, I want to thank Ute Ebert and Ramses van Zon for extensive comments on an earlier version of the manuscript, and Lucas du Croo de Jongh for teaching me how to make computer drawings.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
U. Ebert, W. van Saarloos, C. Caroli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 4178; Phys. Rev. E 55 (1997) 1530. E. Brener, H. Mu¨ller-Krumbhaar, D. Temkin, Phys. Rev. E 54 (1996) 2714. W.W. Mullins, R.F. Sekerka, J. Appl. Phys. 34 (1963) 323; J. Appl. Phys. 35 (1964) 444. P. Meakin, in: C. Domb, J.L. Lebowitz (Eds.), Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 12, Academic, New York, 1988. The literature on phase-field models is vast by now. An entry into the more mathematically oriented literature can be got from P.W. Bates, P.C. Fife, R.A. Gardner, C.K.R.T. Jones, Physica D 104 (1997) 1. An example where a phase-field model has been exploited numerically to study the dendrite problem is A. Karma, W.-J. Rappel, Phys. Rev. E 53 (1996) R3017, preprint, July 1997. These papers also give an entry to the more physics oriented literature. An early use of the word “phase-field model” is found in J.S. Langer, in: G. Grinstein, G. Mazenko (Eds.), Directions in Condensed Matter Physics, World Scientific, Singapore, 1986. J.D. Buckmaster, G.S.S. Lundford, Theory of Laminar Flames, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1982. A very nice elementary account of several of the essential ingredients of flame fronts and their instabilities can be found in J.D. Buckmaster, Physica 12D (1984) 173. See, e.g., E. Meron, Phys. Rep. 218 (1992) 1. R.E. Goldstein, D.J. Muraki, D.M. Petrich, Phys. Rev. E 53 (1996) 3933. M. Kle´man, Points, Lines and Walls in Liquid Crystals, Magnetic Systems and Various Ordered Media, Wiley, New York, 1983. J.D. Gunton, M. San Miguel, P.S. Sahni, in: C. Domb, J.L. Lebowitz (Eds.), Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 8, Academic, New York, 1983. A.J. Bray, Adv. Phys. 43 (1994) 357. J.S. Langer, in: C. Godreche (Ed.), Solids far from Equilibrium, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1992. Here, smooth interface models go back to the classic work of S.M. Allen, J.W. Cahn, Acta Metall. 27 (1979) 1085. P.C. Hohenberg, B.I. Halperin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 49 (1977) 435. M.C. Cross, P.C. Hohenberg, Rev. Mod. Phys. 65 (1993) 851. See M.A. Anisimov, P.E. Cladis, E.E. Gorodetskii, D.A. Huse, V.E. Podneks, V.G. Taratuta, W. van Saarloos, V.P. Voronov, Phys. Rev. A 41 (1990) 6749, and references therein. J. Fineberg, V. Steinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58 (1987) 1332. M.P.M. den Nijs, in: C. Domb, J.L. Lebowitz (Eds.), Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 12, Academic, New York, 1988. C.M. Bender, S.A. Orszag, Advanced Mathematical Methods for Scientists and Engineers, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1978. M. Van Dyke, Perturbation Methods in Fluid Mechanics, Parabolic Press, Stanford, 1975.
42
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43
[23] P.C. Fife, Dynamics of Internal Layers and Diffusive Interfaces, SIAM, Philadelphia, 1988. [24] For an overview of adiabatic decoupling in ordinary differential equations as a result of the separation of time scales, see e.g., N.G. van Kampen, Phys. Rep. 124 (1985) 69. [25] U. Ebert, W. van Saarloos, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 1650. [26] J.S. Langer, Rev. Mod. Phys. 52 (1980) 1; in: J. Souletie (Ed.), Chance and Matter, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1987. [27] B. Caroli, C. Caroli, B. Roulet, in: G. Godre`che (Ed.), Solids far from Equilibrium, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1992. [28] K. Kassner, Pattern Formation in Diffusion-Limited Crystal Growth, World Scientific, Singapore, 1996. [29] For a review of the issues related to the microscopic nature of the crystal-melt interface, see, e.g., J.D. Weeks, in: T. Riste (Ed.), Ordering in Strongly Fluctuating Condensed Matter Systems, Plenum, New York, 1980, or P. Nozie`res, in: G. Godre`che (Ed.), Solids far from Equilibrium, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1992. [30] E. Rolley, S. Balibar, F. Graner, Phys. Rev. E 49 (1994) 1500. [31] P. Tabeling, G. Zocchi, A. Libchaber, J. Fluid Mech. 177 (1987) 67. [32] P.A. Vitello, B.M. Penetrante, J.N. Bardsley, Phys. Rev. E 49 (1994) 5574. [33] P.A. Vitello, B.M. Penetrante, J.N. Bardsley, in: B.M. Penetrante, S.E. Schultheis (Eds.), Non-Thermal Plasma Techniques for Pollution Control, Springer, Berlin, 1993. [34] D.A. Kessler, J. Koplik, H. Levine, Adv. Phys. 37 (1988) 255; P. Pelce´, Dynamics of Curved Fronts, Academic, Boston, 1988; Y. Pomeau, M. Ben Amar, in: C. Godreche (Ed.), Dendritic growth and related topics, in: Solids far from Equilibrium, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1992; E.A. Brener, V.I. Mel’nikov, Adv. Phys. 40 (1991) 53. [35] For this reason, kinetic relations like Eq. (3) can easily be studied with computer simulations. For an example of this, see, e.g., J.Q. Broughton, G.H. Gilmer, K.A. Jackson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 49 (1982) 1496. The interface mobility coefficient1/b inEq. (3) is nothing but the slope of Fig. 3 in this paper. [36] E. Brener, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993) 3653. [37] D. Bonn, H. Kellay, M. BenAmar, J. Meunier, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 2132. [38] L. Puech, G. Bonfait, B. Castaing, J. Physique 47 (1986) 723. [39] L.P. Kadanoff, J. Stat. Phys. 39 (1985) 267. [40] D. Bensimon, L.P. Kadanoff, S. Liang, B.I. Shraiman, C. Tang, Rev. Mod. Phys. 58 (1986) 977. [41] A. Arneodo, Y. Couder, G. Grasseau, V. Hakim, M. Rabaud, in: F.H. Busse, L. Kramer (Eds.), Nonlinear evolution of spatio-temporal structures in dissipative continuous systems, Plenum, New York, 1990. [42] E. Brener, H. Levine, Y. Tu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 1978. [43] A very enjoyable article which discusses fronts in various non-gradient systems is M. San Miguel, R. Montagne, A. Amengual, E. Herna´ndez-Garcı´ a, Multiple front propagation in a potential non-gradient system, in: E. Tirapegui, W. Zeller (Eds.) Instabilities in Nonequilibrium Structures V, Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1996. [44] E. Ben-Jacob, H.R. Brand, G. Dee, L. Kramer, J.S. Langer, Physica D 14 (1985) 348. [45] A. Messiah, Quantum Mechanics, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1974. [46] R. Kupferman, O. Shochet, E. Ben-Jacob, A. Schuss, Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992) 16045. [47] D.G. Aronson, H.F. Weinberger, Adv. Math. 30 (1978) 33. [48] W. van Saarloos, Phys. Rev. 37 (1988) 211. [49] W. van Saarloos, Phys. Rev. A 39 (1989) 6367. [50] The terms pulled and pushed were introduced by A.N. Stokes, Math. Biosci. 31 (1976) 307. [51] G.C. Paquette, Y. Oono, Phys. Rev. E 49 (1994) 2368; G.C. Paquette, L.-Y. Chen, N. Goldenfeld, Y. Oono, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72 (1994) 76. [52] C. Mathis, M. Provansal, L. Boyer, J. Phys. Lett. 45 (1984) L483; G.S. Triantafyllou, K. Kupfer, A. Bers, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 1914. [53] G. Ahlers, D.S. Cannell, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50 (1983) 1583. [54] R.C. Ball, R.L.H. Essery, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 2 (1990) 10303; R.A.L. Jones, L.J. Norton, E.J. Kramer, F.S. Bates, P. Wiltzius, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 1326. [55] T.R. Powers, R.E. Goldstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997) 2555; see also L. Limat, P. Jenffer, B. Dagens, E. Touron, M. Fermigier, J.E. Wesfreid, Physica D 61 (1992) 166.
W. van Saarloos / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 9—43 [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62]
E.K.H. Salje, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 5 (1993) 4775. S.J. Di Bartolo, A.T. Dorsey, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 4442, and references therein. A. Torcini, P. Grassberger, A. Politi, J. Phys. A 27 (1995) 4533. M. Niklas, M. Lu¨cke, H. Mu¨ller-Krumbhaar, Phys. Rev. A 40 (1989) 493. L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Course of Theoretical Physics, vol. 10, Pergamon, New York, 1981. L.-Y. Chen, N. Goldenfeld, Y. Oono, G. Paquette, Physica A 204 (1994) 111. M. Bramson, Mem. Am. Math. Soc. 44 (1983) 285.
43
Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
Driven diffusive systems. An introduction and recent developments B. Schmittmann*, R.K.P. Zia Center for Stochastic Processes in Science and Engineering, Physics Department, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA, 24061-0435 USA
Abstract Nonequilibrium steady states in driven diffusive systems exhibit many features which are surprising or counterintuitive, given our experience with equilibrium systems. We introduce the prototype model and review its unusual behavior in different temperature regimes, from both a simulational and analytic view point. We then present some recent work, focusing on the phase diagrams of driven bi-layer systems and two-species lattice gases. Several unresolved puzzles are posed. ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 64.60.Cn; 66.30.Hs; 82.20.Mj Keywords: Non-equilibrium steady states; Driven diffusive systems
1. Introduction In nature, there are no true equilibrium phenomena, since all of these require infinite times and infinite thermal reservoirs or perfect insulations. Nevertheless, for a large class of systems, it is possible to set up conditions under which predictions from equilibrium statistical mechanics provide excellent approximations, as many of the inventions of the industrial revolution can attest to. By contrast, non-equilibrium phenomena are not only ubiquitous, but often elude the powers of the Boltzmann—Gibbs framework. Unfortunately, to date, the theoretical development of nonequilibrium statistical mechanics is at a stage comparable to that of its equilibrium counterpart in the days before Maxwell and Boltzmann. Using the intuition developed by studying equilibrium statistical mechanics, we are often “surprised” by the behavior displayed by systems far from equilibrium, even if they appear to be in time-independent states. For example, the well-honed arguments, based on the competition between energy and entropy, frequently fail dramatically. In * Corresponding author. Tel.: 1 540 231-6518; Fax: 1540 231 7511. 0370-1573/98/$19.00 ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved PII S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 9 8 ) 0 0 0 0 5 - 2
46
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
these lectures, we will present some explorations into the intriguing realm of non-equilibrium steady states, focusing only on a small class, namely, driven diffusive systems. Motivated by both the theoretical interest in non-equilibrium steady states and the physics of fast ionic conductors [1], Katz et al. [2] introduced a deceptively minor modification to a wellknown system in equilibrium statistical mechanics: the Ising [3] model with nearest-neighbor interactions. In lattice gas language [4], the time evolution of this model can be specified by particles hopping to nearest vacant sites, with rates which simulate coupling to a thermal bath as well as an external field, such as gravity. If “brick wall” boundary conditions are imposed in the direction associated with gravity (particles reflected at the boundary, comparable to a floor or a ceiling), and if the rates obey detailed balance, then this system will eventually settle into an equilibrium state, similar to that of gas molecules in a typical room on earth. Although there is a local bias in the hopping rates (due to gravity), thermal equilibrium is established by an inhomogeneous particle density, at all ¹(R. However, if periodic boundary conditions are imposed, then translational invariance is completely restored so that, in the final steady state, the particle density is homogeneous, for all ¹ above some finite critical ¹ , while a current will be # present. Clearly, for gravity, such boundary conditions can be imposed only in art, as by M.C. Escher.1 In physics, it is possible to establish such a situation with an electric field, e.g., by placing the d"2 lattice on the surface of a cylinder and applying a linearly increasing magnetic field down the cylinder axis. If the particles are charged, they will experience a local bias everywhere on the cylinder and a current will persist in the steady state. Echoing the physics of fast ionic conductors, we will therefore, use the term “electric” field to describe the external drive and imagine our particles to be “charged”, in their response to this drive. This is the prototype of a “driven diffusive system”. Now, such a system constantly gains (loses) energy from (to) the external field (thermal bath), so that the time-independent state is by no means an equilibrium state, a` la Boltzmann— Gibbs. Instead, it is a non-equilibrium steady state, with an unknown distribution in general. As discovered in the last decade, modifying the Ising model to include a simple local bias leads to a large variety of far-from-simple behavior. The scope of these lectures necessarily limits us to only a bird’s eye view. Since a more extensive review has been published recently [5], we will restrict these notes to a brief “introduction” to this subject. Instead, we choose to include some developments since that review. For completeness, we summarize, in Section 2, the lattice model introduced by KLS and the Langevin equation believed to capture its essence in the long-time large-distance regime. Section 3 is devoted to some of the surprising behavior displayed by this system, at temperatures far above, near, and well below ¹ . A collection of recent developments is presented in Section 4. In Section 5, # we conclude with a brief summary.
2. The microscopic model and a continuum field approach On a square lattice, with ¸ ] ¸ sites and toroidal boundary conditions, a particle or a hole x y may occupy each site. A configuration is specified by the occupation numbers Mn N, where i is a site i 1 In particular, see the lithograph Ascending and Descending, reproduced on the cover of Ref. [5].
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
47
label and n is either 1 or 0. Occasionally, we also use spin language, defining s,2n!1"$1. To access the critical point, half-filled lattices are generally used in Monte-Carlo simulations: + n "¸ ¸ /2. The particles are endowed with nearest-neighbor attraction (ferromagnetic, in spin i i x y language), modeled in the usual way through the Hamiltonian: H"!4J + n n , with J'0. Wi,jX i j The external drive, with strength E and pointing in the !y direction, will bias in favor of particles hopping “downwards”. To simulate coupling to a thermal bath at temperature ¹, the Metropolis algorithm is typically used, i.e., the contents of a randomly chosen, nearest-neighbor, particle—hole pair are exchanged, with a probability min[1, e~(*H~eE)@kBT]. Here, *H is the change in H after the exchange and e"(!1, 0, 1), for a particle attempting to hop (against, orthogonal to, along) the drive. Note that these dynamic rules conserve particle number. For E"0, this system will eventually settle into an equilibrium state which is precisely the static Ising model [3,4]. In the thermodynamic limit, it is known to undergo a second-order phase transition at the Onsager critical temperature ¹ (0)"(2.2692..)J/k . When driven (EO0), this system displays the same # B qualitative properties, i.e., there is a disordered phase for large ¹, followed by a second-order transition into a phase-segregated state for low ¹. However, with more scrutiny, this superficial similarity gives way to puzzling surprises. In particular, ¹ (E) appears to be monotonically # increasing with E, saturating at about 1.41¹ (0) [6] for E<J. Why should ¹ (R)'¹ (0) be # # # surprising? Consider the following “argument”. For very large E, hopping along y becomes like a random walk, in that *H is irrelevant for the rates. Therefore, hops along y might as well be coupled to a thermal bath at infinite ¹ (apart from the bias). Indeed, recall that our system gains energy from E and loses it to the bath, so that any drive may be thought of as a coupling to a second reservoir with higher temperature. Then, it seems reasonable that ¹ must be lowered to achieve ordering, since this extra reservoir pumps in a higher level of noise, helping to disorder the system! To date, there is neither a convincing argument nor a computation which predicts the correct sign of ¹ (E)!¹ (0), let alone the magnitude. In the next section, we will briefly review other puzzling # # discoveries, only a few of which are understood. To understand collective behavior in the long-time and large-scale limit, we often rely on continuum descriptions, which are hopefully universal to some extent. Successful examples include hydrodynamics and Landau—Ginzburg theories. Certainly, the u4 theory, enhanced by renormalization group techniques, offers excellent predictions for both the statics and the dynamics near equilibrium of the Ising model. Following these lines, we formulate a continuum theory for the KLS model, in arbitrary dimension d. In principle, such a description can be obtained by coarse-graining the microscopic dynamics [7] but we will pursue a more phenomenological approach here. Seeking a theory in the long-time, large-wavelength limit, we first identify the slow variables of the theory. These are typically f ordering fields which experience critical slowing down near ¹ , and # f any conserved densities. The KLS model is particularly simple since it involves a single ordering field, namely the local “magnetization” or excess particle density, u(x, t), which is also the only conserved quantity. Here, x stands for (x , x ,2, x , x "y). The last entry denotes the one-dimensional “parallel” 1 2 d~1 d subspace selected by E. Thus, we begin with a continuity equation, u#+ j"0, and postulate t
48
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
an appropriate form for the current j. In the absence of E, it simply takes its Model B [8] form, j(x, t)"!j+
dH #g(x, t) , du
with the Landau—Ginzburg Hamiltonian
PG
H"
H
q u 1 (+u)2# u2# u4 . 2 4! 2
As usual, qJ¹!¹ and u'0. While the first contribution to j is a deterministic term, reflecting # local chemical potential gradients, the second term, g, models the thermal noise. The noise is Gaussian distributed, with zero mean and positive second moment proportional to the unit matrix, i.e., Sg g T"2pd d(x!x@)d(t!t@), i, j"1,2, d. In the presence of E, we should expect at least two i j ij modifications to j, namely first, an additional contribution j modeling the non-vanishing mass E transport through the system and second, the generation of anisotropies, since E singles out a specific direction. By virtue of the excluded volume constraint, the “Ohmic” current j vanishes at E densities 1 and 0, corresponding to u"$1. Writing E for the coarse-grained counterpart of E, pointing along unit vector yL , the simplest form is therefore j "E(1!u2)[1#O(u)] yL , where the E O(u) corrections will turn out to be irrelevant for universal properties. Next, we consider possible anisotropies. Clearly, all + 2 operators should be split into components parallel (2) and transverse (+ 2) to E, accompanied by different coefficients. For example, the anisotropic version of the Model M B term q+ 2u will read (q 2#q + 2 )u, with two different “diffusion” coefficients for the parallel , M M and transverse subspaces. Should we expect both of these to vanish as ¹ approaches ¹ (E)? Or just # one of them — but which one? Recalling that the lowering of q, in the equilibrium system, is a consequence of the presence of interparticle interactions, we argue that E, stirring parallel jumps much more effectively than transverse ones, should counteract this effect in the parallel direction, having less of an impact in the transverse subspace. Thus, we anticipate that generically q 'q , so , M that criticality, in particular, is marked by q vanishing at positive q . This is borne out by the M , structure of typical ordered configurations, namely, single strips aligned with E, indicating that “antidiffusion”, i.e., q (0, dominates in the transverse directions below ¹ . Finally, the drive also M # induces anisotropies in the noise terms so that the second moment of their distribution should be taken as Sg g T"2p d d(x!x@)d(t!t@). Since the transverse subspace is still fully isotropic, we i j i ij define p "2"p , p . Generically, however, we should expect p , p O p . Summariz1 d~1 , d M , ing, we write down the full Langevin equation: u(x, t)"jM(q !+ 2)+ 2u#(q !2)2u!2a 2+ 2u t M M M , C M u # (+ 2#i2)u3#Eu2N!+g(x, t) , 3! M with noise correlations Sg (x, t)g (x@, t@)T"2p d d(x!x@)d(t!t@) . i j i ij
(1)
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
49
This equation forms the basis for the analytic study of the KLS model. Fortunately, we need not be concerned about the detailed dependence of its coefficients on the microscopic ¹, J, and E. While they are in principle calculable within an explicit coarse-graining scheme, the properties that we already outlined above suffice for our purposes. Moreover, it turns out that we can simplify the most general form, Eq. (1), depending on the temperature regime considered. We will return to this discussion in Sections 3.1 and 3.3 below. To conclude this section, let us take a glance at the structure of Eq. (1). Its basic form is u"F(u,+u,2)#f, with noise correlations Sf(x, t)f(x@, t@)T"2pNd(x!x@)d(t!t@) and p'0 t just a positive constant. For simplicity, we restrict ourselves to a scalar order parameter u and noise “matrices” N which do not depend on u (more general cases are discussed in, e.g., Refs. [9,10]. F is a functional of u and its derivatives. Given this basic form, a steady-state solution P*[u] for the configurational probability is easily found2provided F is “Hamiltonian”, i.e., if it can be written as N acting on a total functional derivative: F"!N(dH/du). In this case, P* is simply proportional to exp(!H/p), irrespective of the choice of N. We will refer to such a dynamics, in an operational sense [5], as “satisfying the fluctuation-dissipation theorem” (FDT) [11]. Model B falls into this category, with N"!+ 2. In contrast, for our driven system, F is just the expression in the M2N brackets of Eq. (1) and 1 , !+g, so that N"!(p 2#p + 2). Thus, this F is clearly not , M M Hamiltonian! In this fashion, our continuum theory reflects the fact that we are dealing with a generic non-equilibrium steady state. For completeness, we should point out that certain microscopically non-Hamiltonian dynamics may become Hamiltonian if viewed on sufficiently large length scales. The discussion of these subtleties [12—14], while intriguing, is beyond the scope of these lectures.
3. Surprising singular behavior, near and far from criticality For the d"2 Ising model in equilibrium, thermodynamic quantities are typically analytic, except at a single point, i.e., ¹ . In particular, being a model with only short-range interactions, # correlation functions are short-ranged far above ¹ , decaying exponentially with distance and # controlled by a finite correlation length. Far below criticality, a half-filled system in a square geometry will display two strips of equal width, as a result of the co-existence of a particle-rich (dense) phase with hole-rich one. Correlations of the fluctuations within each phase are also short-ranged. More interestingly, the interfaces between the phases do represent soft degrees of freedom, being the Goldstone mode of a broken translational invariance [15]. One consequence is a divergent structure factor (Fourier transform of the two-point correlation, of deviations from being straight). Although this behavior is singular, it is well understood and can be related to that of a simple random walk [16]. Only at criticality does the system possess non-trivial singular properties, the nature of which became transparent only in the 1970’s [17,26] despite Onsager’s tour-de-force in 1944 [18].
2 The easiest way to see the connection between F, N and P[u(x, t)] is to recast the Langevin equation in terms of its equivalent Fokker—Planck equation. See Ref. [9].
50
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
When driven into non-equilibrium steady states, this picture changes dramatically. In particular, non-trivial singular behavior appears at all ¹. While the transition itself remains second order, its properties fall into a non-Ising class. Here, we will present some of these surprising features briefly, referring the reader to Ref. [5] for more details. 3.1. T far above ¹ # Focusing on the behavior far above criticality, let us study the two-point correlation G(r) (r"(x, y)) and its transform, the structure factor, S(k). We first point out that the drive clearly induces an asymmetry between x and y, i.e., anisotropy beyond that due to the lattice. Thus, we should not be surprised if the familiar Ornstein Zernike form of S (J(1#m2k2)) were to become elliptical rather than circular, e.g., similar to Fig. 1a. However, simulations [2] showed that there is a discontinuity singularity in S at the origin, as in Fig. 1b. To be more precise, we may define lim y S(0, k ) k ?0 y (2) lim x S(k , 0) k ?0 x and measure the discontinuity by R!1. Though R does approach unity for ¹PR, it is about 4, for large E, even at twice the critical temperature. Further, it diverges as ¹P¹ ! We should remind # the reader that, for the equilibrium case, S may diverge at criticality, but R is unity always. Strange as it may seem, this behavior can be understood within the context of the continuum approach, Eq. (1). For ¹<¹ , both q and q are positive. Thus, the local magnetization u(x, t) # , M fluctuates around a stable minimum at zero, and neither the fourth-order derivatives nor the R,
Fig. 1. Schematic plot of structure factors. (a) Ellipses for a typical anisotropic Ising model in equilibrium. (b) “Butterfly” or “owl” pattern for a driven system.
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
51
non-linearities are necessary for stability. As a consequence, the behavior of the system in the disordered phase can be described by a much simpler, linear Langevin equation, namely, u(x, t)"j(q + 2#q 2)u!+g . t M M ,
(3)
With the help of a Fourier transform, we can easily find u(k, t) for any realization of g, and then compute averages over the Gaussian distributed g, with its second moment given by Eq. (1). This forms the starting point for the discussion of the disordered phase, quantified by, e.g., equal-time structure factors or three-point functions [19]. Here, we focus on the former, S(k),Su(k, t)u(!k, t)T, which can be easily computed: p k2#p k2 M x , y S(k)" , q k2#q k2#O(k4, k2k2, k4) M x , y x x y y
(4)
so that R"(p q )/(p q ). In order for this S to reduce to the equilibrium Ornstein—Zernike form, , M M , the FDT has to be invoked, which constrains R to unity. For the driven case, R is no longer constrained, so that a discontinuity develops. One consequence of such a singularity in S is that G becomes long-ranged, decaying as r~2 at large DrD. The amplitude, in addition to being J(R!1), has a dipolar angular dependence, so that an appropriate angular average of G is again shortranged [5]. To end this discussion, let us follow Grinstein’s argument [20] that such long-ranged power-law decays should be expected. Starting with the dynamic two-point correlation G(r, t), we know that the conservation law leads to the autocorrelation: G(0, t)Pt~d@2. In addition, being a diffusive system, we should expect r & Jt, at least far from criticality. Using naive scaling, we would write G(r, 0)PDrD~d! In other words, the generic behavior of G in a diffusive system is DrD~d decay, not exponential. In this case, the equilibrium system is the non-generic one, in which the amplitude of this generic term is forced to vanish, by FDT. Our familiarity with equilibrium systems is so strong that, on first sight, power law decays far above ¹ appear quite surprising. Finally, note that # a scaling argument of this kind cannot produce the angular dependence, a crucial feature of the generic singularities of driven diffusive systems. 3.2. T far below ¹ # Next, we turn to systems far below ¹ . Due to the conservation law, they typically display phase # co-existence, so that the dominant fluctuations and slow modes are those associated with the interface between the phases. Again, for the d"2 Ising model in equilibrium, there is a wealth of information on the properties of the interface [21]. In particular, being a one-dimensional object, the interface exhibits behavior identical to a simple random walk [16] at the large scales, such as widths diverging as J¸. In our case, if we study an interface aligned along the y axis, then, to a good approximation, we may specify the configuration by its position along x by the “height” function h(y). Known as capillary waves [22], these fluctuations have a venerable history. Since the interface is a manifestation of broken translational invariance, h(y) are the soft Goldstone modes [15], so that the associated structure factor S (q) , Sh(q)h(!q)T diverges as q~2. Of course, this h property is just the Fourier version of the J¸ divergence: : q~2 dq"O(¸). Interfaces with 1@L
52
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
Fig. 2. Log—log plot of interface structure factor vs. wavevector.
divergent widths are also known as “rough”; only for d'2 may interfaces in crystalline Ising-like models display transitions from rough to smooth phases. When driven, however, the interface width appears to approach a finite width at large distances. In particular, for E"2J, using lattices up to ¸ "60 and plotting the widths vs. ¸p with various y values of p, we found that the curves did not straighten out with p as low as 0.05 [23]. As a phenomenon, roughness suppression is not novel, gravity being the most common example. However, the drive here is parallel to the interface, reminiscent of wind driving across a water surface, which has a destabilizing effect by contrast. Subsequently, a more detailed simulation study [24] of the interface with ¸ 4600 showed that S(q) & q~2 for large q, crossing over to q~0.67 for y small q (Fig. 2). Since : q~0.67 dq"O(1) , the small q behavior is consistent with p"0. Though 1@L 0.67 appears temptingly close to a simple rational: 2, there is no viable theory so far (despite two 3 valiant attempts [25]. Finally, let us note that the crossover from rough to smooth occurs at the scale of q & E. Although no precise Monte-Carlo analysis of this crossover has been performed, it is consistent with E having the units of 1/length. In this respect, such a length is comparable to the capillary length which controls the crossover in the gravitationally stabilized interface. Of course, in that case, the small q behavior is simply q0! 3.3. Critical properties Finally, we turn to the critical region, described by q Z 0 in Eq. (1). In contrast to the situation M for ¹<¹ , we now need fourth-order terms in + to stabilize the system against large-wavelength # M fluctuations. Similarly, the non-linear terms are required to ensure a stable ordered phase below ¹ . # However, we still have q '0, so that fourth-order parallel gradients may safely be neglected. Thus, , near criticality, the leading terms on the right-hand side of Eq. (1) are (+ 2)2u and 2u, implying M that parallel and transverse wave vectors, k and k , scale naively as Dk D & Dk D2, i.e., parallel M , , M gradients are less relevant than transverse ones. More systematically, a naive dimensional
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
53
analysis [26] reveals that the non-linearity associated with E is the most relevant one, having an upper critical dimension d "5, distinct from the usual value of 4 for the Ising model. Dropping # irrelevant terms, Eq. (1) simplifies to u u(x, t)"jM(q !+ 2)+ 2u#2u# + 2u3#Eu2N!+ g (x, t) M M t M M M 3! M
(5)
with noise term (i, j"1,2, d!1) Sg (x, t)g (x@, t@)T"2p d d(x!x@)d(t!t@) . Mi Mj M ij Here, we have rescaled q to 1 and have kept the (naively irrelevant) non-linearity associated with u, , to ensure a stable theory below ¹ . This is the starting point for the analysis of universal critical # behavior. In this regime, large fluctuations on all length scales dominate the behavior of the system, so that renormalization group techniques are indispensable. To summarize very briefly, the Langevin equation (Eq. (5)) is recast as a dynamic functional [27], followed by a renormalized perturbation expansion in e , d!d [26]. The quartic coupling u must be treated as a dangerously irrelevant # operator. Gratifyingly, the series for the critical exponents can be summed, so that we obtain quantitatively reliable values even in two dimensions. The details are quite technical [28], so that we just review the key results here. The discussion leading to Eq. (5) already suggests that the critical behavior of the driven system is distinct from its equilibrium counterpart: the upper critical dimension is shifted to d "5, and # parallel and transverse wave vectors scale with different exponents. Anticipating renormalization, we reformulate their scaling as Dk D & Dk D1`D, introducing the strong anisotropy exponent D. To , M illustrate its importance, let us consider the wave vector scaling for the equilibrium Ising model. For isotropic exchange interactions, coarse-graining results in the usual Landau—Ginzburg Hamiltonian with gradient term (+u)2. Clearly, this cannot lead to anything but Dk D & Dk D. The only , M effect of anisotropies in the microscopic couplings is to give rise to different amplitudes, so that D remains zero. We refer to this situation as weak anisotropy, in contrast to strong anisotropy where DO0. Examples of the latter in equilibrium models include, e.g., Lifshitz points or structural phase transitions [29]. For any system with strong anisotropy, irrespective of its universality class, the renormalization group predicts the general scaling form of, e.g. the dynamic structure factor near criticality: S(k, t; q )"k~2`gS(k /k1`D, k /k, tkz; q /k1@l) . (6) M , M M Here, k is just a scaling factor. Eq. (6) can be viewed as a definition of the critical exponents l, z, g and D. The appearance of the latter is of course consistent with our earlier discussion. Different universality classes are distinguished by the characteristic values of these exponents, expressed, e.g., through their e-expansions. For our model, all exponents, except D, take their mean-field values: l"1, z"4, g"0 while D"1#e/3. A separate analysis yields the order parameter exponent 2 b"1. Note that all of these equalities are exact, i.e., all higher-order terms in the e-expansion 2 vanish! Care must be taken on two fronts, both associated with the presence of strong anisotropy, when comparing these exponents to Monte Carlo data. First, in the equilibrium Ising model, the same exponent g characterizes the divergence of the critical structure factor near the origin in k-space,
54
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
S(k, t"0; q "0) & DkD~(2~g) for kP0, and the power law decay of its Fourier transform, the M two-point correlations, G(r, t"0; q "0) & DrD~(d~2`g) as DrDPR. In contrast, four g-like expoM nents are needed in the driven case! Fortunately, scaling laws relate them to g and D. For example, we can define g via S(k "0, k , t"0; q "0) & Dk D~(2~gM), for Dk DP0. Using Eq. (6), we read off M , M M M M the simple result g "g. Similarly, we introduce g@ through the relation G(r , r "0, M @ , , M t"0; q "0) & r~(d~2`g ,), for r PR. Keeping track of D in the Fourier transform, we obtain , , M the less trivial scaling law g@ "(g!D(d!3))/(1#D). Since most simulations have focused on , two-dimensional systems, we set e"3, predicting D"2 and g@ "2. Monte Carlo data for the pair , 3 correlation along the drive beautifully display the expected r~2@3 decay [30]. Numerical evidence , for the strong anisotropy exponent is somewhat more indirect, extracted from an anisotropic finite size scaling analysis [6]. Convincing data collapse is obtained, using anisotropic systems of size ¸ ] ¸ with fixed “aspect” ratio ¸ /¸1`D, for the theoretically predicted values of the exponents. , M , M It is intriguing that the signals of continuous phase transitions in or near equilibrium, namely, a diverging length scale, scale invariance and universal behavior, also mark such transitions in far-from-equilibrium scenarios.
4. Some recent developments Beyond the topics discussed in the previous section, we may arbitrarily name three other “levels” of non-equilibrium steady-state systems. The first are associated with the KLS model itself, including fascinating results on higher correlations [19], failure of the Cahn—Hilliard approach to coarsening dynamics [31], models with shifted periodic and/or open boundary conditions [32], and systems with AC or random drives [33,14]. Topics in the next “level” involve various generalizations of KLS, such as other interactions [34,35], multi-layer systems, multi-species models, and systems with quenched impurities [36]. Further “afield” is a wide range of driven systems, e.g. surface growth, electrophoresis and sedimentation, granular and traffic flow, biological and geological systems, etc. In these brief lecture notes, we present two topics at the “intermediate level”: a driven bi-layer system and a model with two species. 4.1. Phase transitions in a bi-layer lattice gas The physical motivation for considering multi-layered systems may be traced to intercalated compounds [37]. The process of intercalation, where foreign atoms diffuse into a layered host material, is well suited for modeling by a driven lattice gas of several layers. In both physical systems and Monte Carlo simulations of a model with realistic parameters [38], finger formation has been observed. Both are transient phenomena, so that we might ask: are there any novel phenomena in the driven steady states? On the theoretical front, there are two motivations. To study critical behavior of the single layer KLS model, it is necessary to set the overall density at 1, with the consequence that two interfaces develop below criticality. These interfaces seriously 2 complicate the analysis, since their critical behavior is quite distinct from the bulk. One way to avoid these difficulties is to consider a bi-layer system [39], with no inter-layer interactions. Through particle exchange between the layers, the system may order into a dense and a hole-rich layer, neither of which has interfaces. Certainly, this is expected (and observed) in the equilibrium
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
55
case, where the steady state is just two Ising models, decoupled except for the overall conservation law. The other is using multilayer models as “interpolations” from two- to three-dimensional systems [40]. Motivations aside, what the simulations reveal is entirely unexpected. In the simplest generalization, a bi-layer system is considered as a fully periodic ¸ ] ¸ ] 2 model. The first simulations were carried out on the case with zero inter-layer interactions [40]. Therefore, within each layer, all aspects are identical to the KLS model. Particle exchanges across the layers, unaffected by the drive, are updated according to the local energetics alone, so that these jump rates are identical to a system in equilibrium. The overall particle density is fixed at 1. In the 2 absence of E, there would be a single second order transition at the Onsager temperature. Since the inter-layer coupling is zero, phase segregation at low temperatures will occur across the layers, i.e., the ordered phase is characterized by homogeneous layers of different densities (opposite magnetizations, in spin language). Having no interfaces, the free energy of the system is clearly lowest in such a state. At ¹"0, one layer will be full and the other empty, so that this state will be labeled by FE. Intriguingly, when E is turned on, two transitions appear [40]! As ¹ is lowered, the homogeneous, disordered (D) phase first gives way to a state with strips in both layers, reminiscent of two entirely unrelated, yet aligned, single-layer driven systems. We will refer to this state as the strip phase (S). As ¹ is lowered further, a first order transition takes the S phase into the FE state. Why the S state should interpose between the D and FE states was not understood. This puzzle, together with the presence of interlayer couplings in intercalated compounds, motivated our study of the interacting bi-layer driven system [41]. Within this wider context, the presence of two transitions is no longer a total mystery. On the other hand, this study reveals several unexpected features, leading to interesting new questions. Our system consists of two ¸2 Ising models with attractive inter-particle interactions of strength unity. Arranged in a bi-layer structure, the inter-layer interaction is specified by J. Thus, the “internal” Hamiltonian is just H,!4 +nn@!4J +nn@@, where the first sum is over nearest neighbors within a given layer while n and n@@ differ only by the layer index. The external drive, E, is imposed through the jump rates, as in Section 2. For simulations, we kept the overall density at 1 2 and chose J 3 [!10,10]. Note that negative J’s are especially appropriate for intercalated materials [37,38]. The eventual goal of such a study is to map out the phase diagram in the ¹—J—E space. So far, we have data for only three (positive) values of E. Not expecting further surprises, we believe that we have uncovered the main features of the phase diagram. To begin, let us point out various features in the equilibrium case. Here, the J'0 and the J(0 systems can be mapped into each other by a gauge transformation. Thus, in the thermodynamic limit, the phase diagram in the ¹—J plane is exactly symmetric. However, for the lattice gas constrained by a conservation law, the low-temperature states of these two systems are not the same, being S or FE, respectively. While the D—S or D—FE transitions are second order (shown as a line in Fig. 3), the S—FE line will be first order in nature (¹ axis from 0 to 1 in Fig. 3). Due to the presence of interfaces, the FE domain includes the J , 0 line. For the same reason, it “intrudes” into the J'0 half plane by O(1/¸), for finite systems. Of course, on the ¹ axis lies a pair of decoupled Ising systems, so that ¹ (J"0) assumes the Onsager value, as ¸PR. In general, ¹ (J) # # is not known exactly, though ¹ (J"$R) is precisely 2¹ (J"0), since every configuration of the # # two layers can be mapped into one in the usual Ising model. The lesson from equilibrium is now clear: the S state is as generic as the FE state in this wider context. As we will see below, the presence of two transitions does not represent a qualitative change from the equilibrium phase structure.
56
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
Fig. 3. Phase diagrams for the bi-layer Ising lattice gas. Solid lines are second-order transitions in the equilibrium case. Open/solid circles are continuous/discontinuous transitions in the driven case.
Turning to driven systems, we can no longer expect a symmetric phase diagram, since the drive breaks the Ising symmetry. The data for E"25 are shown in Fig. 3, in which the first/second-order transitions are marked as solid/open circles. We see that the only effect of the drive is to shift the phase boundaries. No new phases appear while the nature of the transitions remains unchanged. However, there are remarkable features. One is the lowering of the critical temperature for large DJD. Given that ¹ (E)'¹ (0) in the KLS model, it is quite unexpected that ¹ (DJD<1, E<1) is less # # # than its equilibrium counterpart. Perhaps more notable is the presence of a small region in the J(0 half plane, in which an S-phase is stable. Since particle-rich strips lie on top of each other, such a phase could not exist if either energy or entropy were to dominate the steady state. Concerned that its presence might be a finite size effect, we performed simulations using ¸’s up to 100, with J"!0.1 and ¹3[1.00, 1.20]. In all cases, the S-phase prevailed, leading us to conjecture that this region exists even in the thermodynamic limit. On the other hand, for lower ¹, the FE-phase penetrates into the J'0 half plane, as in equilibrium cases. Energetics seem to take the upper hand here. Though we believe that, as ¸PR, this part of the phase boundary will collapse onto the J"0 line, we have not checked the finite size effects explicitly. Of course, these “intrusions” into the positive/negative J region by the FE/S-phase are responsible for the appearance of two transitions in the studies of the J,0 model [40]. It would clearly be useful to develop some intuitive arguments which can “predict” these qualitative modification of the equilibrium phase structure. Since the usual energy—entropy considerations appear to fail, our attempt [41] is based on the competition between suppression of short-range correlations [42] and enhancement of long-range ones [30], as a result of driving. Let
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
57
us focus on the two-point correlations in the disordered phase with ¹ being lowered from R and see how they are affected by the drive. On the one hand, the nearest-neighbor correlations are found to be suppressed by E, consistent with the picture that the drive acts as an extra noise in breaking bonds. Taken alone, this suppression would lead to the lowering of the critical temperature, as pointed out in Section 2. On the other hand, as we showed above, the drive changes significantly the large distance behavior of G, from an exponential to a power law. Further, the amplitude is positive (negative) for correlations parallel (transverse) to E. Both the positive longitudinal correlations and the negative transverse ones should help the process of ordering into strips parallel to the field. In other words, the enhanced long-range parts favor the S-phase. Taken alone, we expect this effect to increase ¹ (E). Evidently, for the single-layer case, the latter effect “wins”. # For a bi-layer system, we need to take into account cross-layer correlations, which are necessarily short-ranged. Focusing first on the J"0 case, where short-range effects due to cross-layer interactions are absent, we are led to ¹ (0, E)/¹ (0, 0)'1. Indeed, this ratio is comparable to that in the single-layer # # case. Next, we consider systems with positive J. Without the drive, ¹ (J, 0) is of course enhanced # over ¹ (0, 0). For non-vanishing drive, it is not possible to track the competition between the short# and long-range properties of the transverse correlations. Evidently, for small J, the long-range part still dominates, so that ¹ (J, E)/¹ (J, 0)'1. However, for J<J , the presence of E effectively # # 0 lowers J, since the latter is associated with only short-range correlations. Since a lower effective J naturally gives rise to a lower ¹ , we would “predict” that ¹ (J, E)/¹ (J, 0) could decrease # # # considerably as J increases. From Fig. 3, we see that ¹ (J, E)(¹ (J, 0) for J55! The interplay of # # the competing effects is so subtle that either can dominate, in different regions of the phase diagram. Finally, we turn to the J(0 case. Here, the two effects tend to cooperate rather than compete, since the long-range parts favor the S-phase over the FE-phase. As a result, the domain of FE is smaller everywhere. In particular, note that the J(0 branch of ¹ (J, E) is significantly lower than # the J'0 branch. The small region of the S-phase can be similarly understood, at least at the qualitative level. In this picture, we may argue that the bicritical point and its trailing first order line should be “driven” to the J(0 half-plane. To end this subsection, we point out a few other interesting features. The order parameters of the S and FE phases are conserved and non-conserved, respectively. Based on symmetry arguments, we may expect that the critical properties of the two second order branches will fall into different universality classes. In contrast, the gauge symmetry forces static equilibrium properties to be identical along these two branches (only dynamic properties, e.g. the dynamical critical exponents, differ [43]. Since the drive breaks this symmetry, we can only speculate that the D—S transitions belong to the same class as the single layer, KLS model [28] while the D—FE ones should remain in the equilibrium Ising class [12]. Since these two classes are distinct, we can also expect a rich crossover structure near the bi-critical point. Assuming these conjectures are confirmed, we can truly marvel at the novelties a driving field can bring. 4.2. Biased diffusion of two species If the particles in the KLS model are considered “charged”, it is natural to explore the effects of having both positive and negative charges. Defined on a fully periodic ¸ ]¸ square lattice, x y a configuration of such a “two species” model can be characterized by two local occupation
58
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
variables, n` r and n~ r , which equal 1 (0), if a positive or negative particle is present (absent) at site r,(x, y). In spin language, this corresponds to a spin-1 model, and novel behavior is to be expected, since we have altered the internal symmetries of the local order parameter. For simplicity, we will restrict ourselves to zero total charge, Q,+r(n` r !n~ r )"0. Pursuing the analogy to electric charges, positive (negative) charges move preferentially along (against) the drive E which is directed along the !y axis. As a first step, we assume that there are no inter-particle interactions apart from an excluded volume constraint. Thus, our model can be viewed as the high-temperature, large E limit of a more complicated interacting system. To model biased diffusion, a particle with charge q"$1 jumps onto a nearest-neighbor empty site according to min[1, e~qE dy], where dy"0,$1 is the change in the y-coordinate of the particle. To allow charge exchange between neighboring particles, two nearest-neighbor sites carrying opposite charge may exchange their content with probability c min[1, e~qE dy]. Now, dy is the change in the y-coordinate of the positive particle. The parameter c sets the ratio of the characteristic time scales controlling, respectively, charge exchange and diffusion. Physical motivations for this model come from various directions: fast ionic conductors with several species of mobile charges [1], electric breakdown of water-in-oil microemulsions [44], and gel electrophoresis of charged polymers [45]. It can also be interpreted as a simple model for some traffic or granular flows [46,47]. Summarizing our simulation data, we first map out the phase diagram of the model, in the space spanned by E, the total mass density mN , +r(n` r #n~ r )/(¸ ¸ ), and c [48].3 Focusing on small c, x y the diffusive dynamics is limited by the excluded volume constraint. For sufficiently small E and mN , typical configurations are disordered, characterized by homogeneous charge and mass densities and fairly large currents. Nevertheless, this phase is highly nontrivial, supporting anomalous two-point correlations reminiscent of the KLS model: In generic directions, the familiar r~d decay prevails, with the remarkable exception of the field direction, where a novel r~(d`1)@2 dominates , [49]. With increasing E or mN , the tendency of the particles to impede one another becomes more pronounced, until a phase transition into a spatially inhomogeneous “ordered” phase occurs. Beyond the transition line E (mN , c), typical configurations are charge-segregated, consisting of # a strip of mostly positive charges “floating” on a similar strip of negative charges, surrounded by a background of holes. To explore these transitions more quantitatively, we need to define a suitable order parameter. Taking the Fourier transforms of the local hole and charge densities, 1 /I (k , k ), + [1!(n` r #n~ r )]expMik x#ik yN M , M , ¸¸ r x y and 1 + [n` tI (k , k ), r !n~ r ]expMik x#ik yN, M , M , ¸¸ r x y
3 The second paper in Ref. [48] discusses the adiabatic elimination procedure. For earlier work (c"0) see Refs. [51,56,57].
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
59
Fig. 4. Phase diagram for the driven two-species model. The system size is 30]30. The filled circles mark the lines of continuous transitions, while the open circles denote the spinodal lines associated with first order transitions. The inset shows a typical ordered configuration at mN "0.40, E"3.00 and c"0.02 with the open (filled) circles representing positive (negative) charges.
we select the components U,D/I (0, 2p/¸ )D and W,DtI (0, 2p/¸ )D since these are most sensitive to y y ordering into a single transverse strip. Naturally, we choose their averages SUT and SWT as our order parameters. To distinguish first from second-order transitions, we also measure their fluctuations and histograms. The resulting phase diagram is shown in Fig. 4. Typically, hysteresis loops in SUT, SWT and the average current are observed only for mN (mN (c), indicating that the 0 transitions are first order in this regime. On the other hand, fluctuations develop sharp peaks for larger mass densities, signalling continuous transitions. Larger values of c favor the disordered phase, so that the whole transition line shifts to higher E, the region between the spinodals narrows, and mN (c) moves to higher mass densities. Thus, we observe a surface of first-order transitions, 0 separated from a surface of continuous ones by a line of multicritical points: E (mN (c),c). # 0 While it is not surprising that the disordered phase is stable for large E provided the mass density is sufficiently small, it may appear rather counterintuitive that it should also dominate the mN [1 region. However, setting mN , 1 eliminates every hole in the system so that the dynamics is carried entirely by the charge exchange mechanism. Relabelling positive charges as “particles” and negative ones as “holes”, the model becomes equivalent to a non-interacting (i.e., J"0) KLS model. Also termed the asymmetric simple exclusion process (ASEP) in the literature, its steadystate solution is exactly known [50] to be homogeneous. Thus, for all c'0, our two-species model remains disordered along the entire mN , 1 line. For sufficiently large c, the data indicate quite clearly that a finite region of disorder persists, for any E, just below complete filling. For smaller c, however, it is less obvious whether such a region exists in the thermodynamic limit, since even a single hole can suffice to induce spatial inhomogeneities in a finite system: Acting as a catalyst for the charge segregation process, the hole creates a strip of predominantly positive charge, separated by a rather sharp interface from a similar, negatively charged domain, located “downstream”. The charge exchange mechanism tends to remix the charges but has little effect for small c. Eventually,
60
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
the hole ends up trapped in the interfacial region! Finally, we turn to larger values of c, specifically, cZ0.62: here, the charge exchange mechanism dominates over the excluded volume constraint and suppresses the ordered phase completely. So far, our discussion has mostly drawn upon Monte Carlo results. It is gratifying, however, that the same qualitative picture emerges from a mean-field theory, based upon a set of equations of motion for the local densities. We briefly summarize the analytic route. Since the numbers of both positive and negative charges are conserved, we begin with a continuity equation for the coarsegrained densities oB(r, t): oB#+jB"0. For simplicity, we focus on the case c"0, i.e., part ticle—hole exchanges, first. As for the KLS model, jB can be written as the sum of a diffusive piece and an Ohmic term,
G
jB"jB !+
dH doB
K
H
$EyL . oB The density-dependent mobility jB must vanish with both oB and the local hole density, u , 1!(o`#o~), i.e., jB"oBu. The “Hamiltonian” H"Mo` ln o`#o~ ln o~#u ln uN is just the mixing entropy associated with distributing ¸ ¸ o` positive and ¸ ¸ o~ negative charges x y x y over a lattice of ¸ ¸ sites. Note that the functional derivative dH/doB is taken at fixed oY since we x y are focusing on particle—hole exchanges here. To model the charge exchange mechanism, we simply add a similar term to jB, namely,
G
jB"j !+
H G
dH dH $EyL #cj@ !+ doB do
K
H
$EyL rB where j@"o`o~ vanishes with both o` and o~, and the functional derivative is taken at fixed hole density. Expressing the resulting equations in the more convenient variables u and charge density t,o`!o~, we obtain u"+M+u#EutyL N t
G
H
c t"+ c+t#(1!c)[u+t!t+u]!Eu(1!u)yL ! E[(1!u)2!t2] yL . t 2
(7)
These equations have to be supplemented by periodic boundary conditions and constraints on total mass and charge, (1!mN )¸ ¸ ":ddr u(r, t) and 0":ddr t(r, t). Also, to be precise, all x y Laplacians + 2 should be given the appropriate anisotropic interpretation. Using Eq. (7) as our starting point, we seek to recapture the major features of the phase diagram. First, the presence of two phases, uniform versus spatially structured, is reflected in the existence of both homogeneous and inhomogeneous steady-state solutions of Eq. (7). The existence of the former is evident, due to the conservation law. Anticipating homogeneity in the transverse directions, we seek the latter in the form u(y), t(y). Integrating Eq. (7) once, the stationary mass and charge currents appear as natural integration constants. Since the numbers of positive and negative charges are equal, the former must be zero, leaving us with the latter: J. The first equation allows us to eliminate t in favor of u, and, with u , J1#[c/(1!c)u] as the new variable, we can reduce the second equation to potential form, u@@"!d»(u)/du. The potential »(u), given explicitly in Ref. [48], exhibits a minimum for a range of J’s, so that inhomogeneous, periodic solutions of Eq. (7) exist. We note in passing that these may even be found explicitly, provided c"0 [51]. Otherwise,
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
61
numerical integration is of course always possible, yielding rather impressive agreement with simulation profiles. Interestingly, our equations of motion predict that E enters only through the scaling variable E¸ . If plotted accordingly, our simulation data confirm this scaling by collapsing y rather convincingly, at least within their error bars. However, the mere existence of two types of steady-state solutions is not sufficient to provide evidence for a phase transition. Therefore, we seek instabilities of these solutions, as the control parameters E, mN and c are varied. Performing a linear stability analysis, we find that a homogeneous solution with mass mN becomes unstable if the drive E exceeds a threshold value
S
2p 1!mN #cmN E (mN , c)" . H ¸ (1!mN )[(2!c)mN !1] y The most relevant perturbation is associated with the smallest wave vector in the parallel direction, (0, 2p/¸ ). A simple analysis of E (mN , c) shows that this instability can only occur within the interval y H 1/(2!c)(mN (1, so that, in particular, the homogeneous phase is always stable for c51. Clearly, we cannot identify this mean-field stability boundary with the true transition line: we have not considered the locus of instabilities associated with inhomogeneous solutions, and fluctuations have been neglected throughout. However, it is quite remarkable how well it mirrors the qualitative shape of the phase diagram. Finally, let us consider the order of the transitions. In principle, two routes can be pursued here. One of these, namely, the computation of the stability boundary of the inhomogeneous phase, E (mN , c), is rather subtle, involving three Goldstone modes [52]. Once E (mN , c) is known, values (mN , c) I I for which E and E coincide can be identified as loci of continuous transitions; otherwise, E and I H H E mark the “spinodals”, near a first-order transition, where the homogeneous/inhomogeneous I phases become linearly unstable. Alternatively, the adiabatic elimination of the fast modes results in an effective equation of motion for the slow ones which can then be analyzed. Since the technical details of this approach can be found in Ref. [48], we need only focus on the result which combines the expected with the surprising. Letting M(q , t) denote the complex amplitude of the unique slow M mode, associated with the band of wave vectors (q , 2p/¸ ), its equation of motion takes the M y Ginzburg—Landau form: M"!M(q#q2 )M#gMDMD2#O(M5)N . t M Here, q is the soft eigenvalue, which vanishes on the stability boundary and g"g(E, mN , c, ¸ ) is , a rather complicated function. As in standard Landau theory, the sign of g determines the order of the transition: if positive, the transition is continuous while negative g signals a first-order one. Since qK0, we can set E"E and discuss g on the stability boundary itself: being positive for H mN [1, it has a unique zero at a critical mN (c), below which it becomes negative. Since mN (c) increases 0 0 with c, we recover the qualitative behavior of the multicritical line observed in the simulations. The surprising aspect of this equation of motion, however, resides in the fact that M is O(2)-symmetric and q spans just a single spatial dimension. Given these symmetries, the Mermin—Wagner M theorem [53] should forbid the existence of long-range order! One might hope that a careful analysis of finite-size effects in this system would contribute to the disentanglement of this puzzle. We conclude with two comments. First, we noted earlier that the case mN ,1 is exactly soluble. There are, in fact, two other surfaces in the phase diagram, corresponding to c"1 and c"2, for
62
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
which certain distributions are exactly known. Setting c"1 implies that the rates for particle—hole and particle—particle exchanges become equal, so that any given particle, e.g. a positive charge, cannot distinguish between negative charges and holes. Thus, it experiences biased diffusion, equivalent to the non-interacting KLS model. Accordingly, the marginal steady-state distribution of the occupation numbers of one species is uniform, i.e., P[MnB P[Mn` r N]"+M Y r , n~ r N]J1, and nr N observables pertaining to a single species are trivial. For example, the two-point correlation functions for equal charges, Sn` r n` 0 T and Sn~ r n~ 0 T, vanish for rO0. The full distribution, P[Mn` r , n~ r N], however, is nontrivial, so that, e.g., the two-point function for opposite charges, Sn` r n~ 0 T, remains long-ranged [49]. A completely random system, marked by a uniform P[Mn` r , n~ r N] results only if c"2. Finally, we note that the one-dimensional version of our model is exactly soluble by matrix methods [54]. Second, it is natural to wonder about the consequences of having non-zero charge. This problem has only been investigated for c"0 [55], but the findings are quite remarkable. The system still orders into a charge-segregated strip, while supporting a nonvanishing mass current, reflected in an overall drift. If, e.g. positive charges outnumber negative ones, one might expect that the whole strip would drift in the field direction — in analogy with American football, where the team with fewer players tends to lose ground. In contrast, the strip wanders against the field, following the preferred direction of the minority charge! We should add that this model possesses several other intriguing properties, e.g., stable configurations with nontrivial winding number (“barber poles”) [56] or multiple-valued currents in the mean-field description [51]. To summarize, the remarkable richness of this deceptively simple system is clearly amazing.
5. Summary and outlook We have presented, within the limited scope of these lecture notes, a brief introduction to the statistical mechanics of driven diffusive systems and some recent developments in this ever expanding field. Focusing only on the proto-type model and two of the simplest generalizations, we pointed out a multitude of surprises, when we base our expectations on the experience with equilibrium systems. While some of these, e.g. the generic presence of singular correlations, are rather well understood, others, such as the nature of ordering in two-species models, remain unresolved. Of course, the holy grail of this whole field, namely, the fundamental understanding and theoretical classification of non-equilibrium steady states, still beckons at the distant horizon.
Acknowledgements It is a pleasure to especially acknowledge our collaborators on the recent work reported here: C.C. Hill, G. Korniss and K.-t Leung. Others are too numerous to mention but no less deserving. We thank the IXth International Summer School on Fundamental Problems in Statistical Mechanics, and particularly H.K. Janssen and L. Scha¨fer, for their hospitality. This research was supported in part by grants from NATO, the SFB 237 of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and the US National Science Foundation through the Division of Materials Research.
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45—64
63
References [1] S. Chandra, Superionic Solids. Principles and Applications, North-Holland, Amsterdam 1981. [2] S. Katz, J.L. Lebowitz, H. Spohn, Phys. Rev. B 28 (1983) 1655; J. Stat. Phys. 34 (1984) 497. [3] Ising, Z. Physik 31 (1925) 253. A more recent treatment is, e.g., B.M. McCoy, T.T. Wu, The Two-dimensional Ising Model, Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, MA, 1973. [4] C.N. Yang, T.D. Lee, Phys. Rev. 87 (1952) 404; T.D. Lee, C.N. Yang, Phys. Rev. 87 (1952) 410. [5] B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, in: C. Domb, J.L. Lebowitz (Eds.), Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 17, Academic, London, 1995. [6] K.-t. Leung, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 453 and Int. J. Mod. Phys. C3 (1992) 367; J.S. Wang, J. Stat. Phys. 82 (1996) 1409. [7] G.L. Eyink, J.L. Lebowitz, H. Spohn, J. Stat. Phys. 83 (1996) 385—472 . [8] P.C. Hohenberg, B.I. Halperin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 49 (1977) 435. [9] H. Risken, The Fokker—Planck Equation, Springer, Heidelberg 1989. [10] H.K. Janssen, in: C.P. Enz (Ed.), Dynamical Critical Phenomena and Related Topics, Lecture Notes in Physics, vol. 104, Springer, Heidelberg, 1979. [11] R. Kubo, Rep. Progr. Phys. 29 (1966) 255. See R. Graham, Z. Phys. 26 (1977) 397 and B 40 (1980) 149, for a much deeper discussion of this fundamental issue. [12] G. Grinstein, C. Jayaprakash, Y. He, Phys. Rev. Lett. 55 (1985) 2527. [13] H.K. Janssen, B. Schmittmann, Z. Phys. B 63 (1986) 517; R.K.P. Zia, B. Schmittmann, Z. Phys. B 97 (1995) 327. [14] B. Schmittmann, Europhys. Lett. 24 (1993) 109. [15] J. Goldstone, Nuovo Cim., 19 (1961) 154; H. Wagner, Z. Physik 195 (1966) 273. [16] H.N.V. Temperley, Proc. Cam. Phil. Soc. 48 (1952) 683; K.Y. Lin, F.Y. Wu, Z. Physik B 33 (1970) 181. [17] K.G. Wilson, Rev. Mod. Phys. C 47 (1975) 773. [18] L. Onsager, Phys. Rev. 65 (1944) 117 and Nuovo Cim. 6 (Suppl.) 261 (1949). [19] K. Hwang, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 326 and Phys. Rev. E 48 (1993) 800. [20] G. Grinstein, J. Appl. Phys. 69 (1991) 5441. [21] R.K.P. Zia, in: K.C. Bowler, A.J. McKane (Eds.), Statistical and Particle Physics: Common Problems and Techniques, SUSSP Publications, Edinburgh, 1984. See references herein. [22] F.P. Buff, R.A. Lovett, F.H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 15 (1965) 621. B. Widom, J.S. Rowlinson, Molecular Theory of Capillarity, Oxford, 1982. [23] K.-t. Leung, K.K. Mon, J.L. Valle´s, R.K.P. Zia, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61 (1988) 1744. Phys. Rev. B 39 (1989) 9312. [24] K.-t. Leung, R.K.P. Zia, J. Phys. A 26 (1993) L737. [25] K.-t. Leung, J. Stat. Phys. 50 (1988) 405 and 61 (1990) 341; C. Yeung, J.L. Mozos, A. Hernandez-Machado, D. Jasnow, J. Stat. Phys. 70 (1992) 1149. [26] D.J. Amit, Field Theory, the Renormalization Group and Critical Phenomena, 2nd revised edn., World Scientific, Singapore, 1984; J. Zinn—Justin, Quantum Field Theory and Critical Phenomena, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1989. [27] H.K. Janssen, Z. Phys. B 23 (1976) 377; C. de Dominicis, J. Phys. (Paris) Colloq. 37 (1976) C247. [28] H.K. Janssen, B. Schmittmann, Z. Phys. B 64 (1986) 503; K.-t. Leung, J.L. Cardy, J. Stat. Phys. 44 (1986) 567 and 45 (1986) 1087 (erratum). [29] R.M. Hornreich, M. Luban, S. Shtrikman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 35 (1975) 1678; R.A. Cowley, Adv. Phys. 29 (1980) 1; A.D. Bruce, Adv. Phys. 29 (1980) 111. [30] M.Q. Zhang, J.-S. Wang, J.L. Lebowitz, J.L. Valle´s, J. Stat. Phys. 52 (1988) 1461; P.L. Garrido, J.L. Lebowitz, C. Maes, H. Spohn, Phys. Rev. A 42 (1990) 1954. [31] C. Yeung, T. Rogers, A. Hernandez-Machado, D. Jasnow, J. Stat. Phys. 66 (1992) 1071; F.J. Alexander, C.A. Laberge, J.L. Lebowitz, R.K.P. Zia, J. Stat. Phys. 82 (1996) 1133. [32] J.L. Valle´s, K.-t. Leung, R.K.P. Zia, J. Stat. Phys. 56 (1989) 43; D.H. Boal, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Phys. Rev. A 43 (1991) 5214. [33] B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 357; B. Schmittmann, Europhys. Lett. 24 (1993) 109; E. Praestgaard, H. Larsen, R.K.P. Zia, Europhys. Lett. 25 (1994) 447 and references therein.
64
B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 45— 64
[34] K.-t. Leung, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 (1989) 1772; G. Szabo´, A. Szolnoki, Phys. Rev. B 47 (1993) 8260 and references therein; G. Szabo´, A. Szolnoki, T. Antal, Phys. Rev. E 49 (1994) 299. [35] K. Burns, L.B. Shaw, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, to be published. [36] V. Becker, H.K. Janssen, Europhys. Lett. 19 (1992) 13 and private communication; K.B. Lauritsen, H.C. Fogedby, Phys. Rev. E 47 (1992) 1563; B. Schmittmann, K.E. Bassler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 3581; B. Schmittmann, C.A. Laberge, Europhys. Lett. 37 (1997) 559. [37] M.S. Dresselhaus, G. Dresselhaus, Adv. Phys. 30 (1981) 139. [38] G.R. Carlow, P. Joensen, R.F. Frindt, Synth. Met. 34 (1989) 623 and Phys. Rev. B 42 (1990) 1124; G.R. Carlow, R.F. Frindt, Phys. Rev. B 50 (1992) 11 107. [39] K.K. Mon, unpublished. [40] A. Achahbar, J. Marro, J. Stat. Phys. 78 (1995) 1493. [41] C.C. Hill, R.K.P. Zia, B. Schmittmann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 514—517 and C.C. Hill, Senior Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 1996. [42] J.L. Valle´s, J. Marro, J. Stat. Phys. 49 (1987) 89. [43] B. Schmittmann, C.C. Hill, R.K.P. Zia, Physica A 239 (1997) 382. [44] M. Aertsens, J. Naudts, J. Stat. Phys. 62 (1990) 609. [45] M. Rubinstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 1946; T.A.J. Duke, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 (1989) 2877; Y. Schnidman, in: A. Friedman (Ed.), Mathematics in Industrial Problems IV, Springer, Berlin 1991; B. Widom, J.L. Viovy, A.D. Desfontaines, J. Phys I (France) 1 (1991) 1759. [46] O. Biham, A.A. Middleton, D. Levine, Phys. Rev. A 46 (1992) R6128; K.-t. Leung, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73 (1994) 2386. [47] H.M. Jaeger, S.R. Nagel, R.P. Behringer, Rev. Mod. Phys. 68 (1997) 1259. [48] G. Korniss, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Europhys. Lett. 32 (1995) 49 and J. Stat. Phys. 86 (1997) 721. [49] G. Korniss, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Physica A 239 (1997) 111; G. Korniss, B. Schmittmann, Phys. Rev. E 56 (1997) 4072. [50] F. Spitzer, Adv. Math. 5 (1970) 246. [51] I. Vilfan, R.K.P. Zia, B. Schmittmann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73 (1994) 2071. [52] R.K.P. Zia, B. Schmittmann, unpublished. [53] N.D. Mermin, H. Wagner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 17 (1966) 1133. [54] C. Godre`che, S. Sandow, private communication, to be submitted. [55] K.-t. Leung, R.K.P. Zia, Phys. Rev. E 56 (1997) 308. [56] K.E. Bassler, B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Europhys. Lett. 24 (1993) 115. [57] B. Schmittmann, K. Hwang, R.K.P. Zia, Europhys. Lett. 19 (1992) 19.
Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
An exactly soluble non-equilibrium system: The asymmetric simple exclusion process B. Derrida* Laboratoire de Physique Statistique, Ecole Normale Supe& rieure, 24 rue Lhomond, 75005 Paris, France
Abstract A number of exact results have been obtained recently for the one-dimensional asymmetric simple exclusion process, a model of particles which hop to their right at random times, on a one-dimensional lattice, provided that the target site is empty. Using either a matrix form for the steady-state weights or the Bethe ansatz, several steady-state properties can be calculated exactly: the current, the density profile for open boundary conditions, the diffusion constant of a tagged particle. The matrix form of the steady state can be extended to calculate exactly the steady state of systems of two species of particles and shock profiles. ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 05.40.#j; 05.60.#w
1. Introduction In equilibrium statistical mechanics, one usually associates an energy function E(C) to every possible configuration C of a system. At equilibrium, each configuration C has a weight proportional to exp[!E(C)/¹] P (C)"Z~1e~E(C)@T , (1) %2 where ¹ is the temperature and Z the partition function. The problem is then to calculate equilibrium properties by averaging over all configurations weighted by Eq. (1). The dynamics towards such an equilibrium is often described by a master equation of the form dP(C) "+ M(C, C@)P(C@) , dt C{
* E-mail:
[email protected]. 0370-1573/98/$19.00 ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved PII S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 9 8 ) 0 0 0 0 6 - 4
(2)
66
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
where M(C, C@) dt is the probability of a transition from configuration C@ to configuration C during the infinitesimal time interval dt. To conserve the probability, the diagonal term has to satisfy M(C, C)"! + M(C@,C) . C{EC (!M(C, C)P(C) dt represents the probability of escaping from configuration C during the time interval dt). To insure that a distribution P(C) evolving according to Eq. (2) has a long time limit independent of the initial condition, the rule of evolution M(C, C@) should not leave any subset of configurations disconnected from the rest (i.e. there should be a path of non-zero matrix elements connecting any pair of configurations). Moreover, the simplest way for the limit to be P (C) given %2 by Eq. (1) is to choose a matrix M(C, C@) which satisfies detailed balance, meaning that for any pair of configurations C ,C 1 2 M(C ,C ) P (C )"M(C ,C ) P (C ) . (3) 1 2 %2 2 2 1 %2 1 In out-of-equilibrium systems, there is usually no energy function E(C) and the system is only defined by its dynamical rules. Typically, for a system with stochastic dynamics, only a matrix M is given, and the evolution of the weights P(C) is governed by the master equation (2). In the long-time limit, the system usually (if all the configurations are connected) reaches a steady state P (C) 45%!$: 45!5% which in general does not satisfy the detailed balance condition (3) but only the weaker condition of stationarity: + M(C@, C)P (C)"+ M(C, C@)P (C@) . (4) 45%!$: 45!5% 45%!$: 45!5% C{ C{ Eq. (4) expresses the fact that the probabilities of entering and of leaving the configuration C during the time interval dt are equal. (The stationarity conditions (4) are weaker than detailed balance (3) since for a system of X configurations, stationarity imposes X equations (4) whereas detailed balance (3) usually requires many more conditions.) A trivial example of system reaching a steady state without satisfying detailed balance (3) is the problem of a biased random walker on a ring of N sites. During each infinitesimal time interval dt, the walker hops with probability p dt to its right and q dt to its left. There are N possible positions i for the walker and the solution of Eq. (4) for the steady state probability is just P (i)"1/N. 45%!$: 45!5% Obviously, M(i#1, i)P (i)"p/NOq/N"M(i, i#1)P (i#1) and detailed balance 45%!$: 45!5% 45%!$: 45!5% (3) is not satisfied as soon as there is a bias (i.e. pOq). In general, the steady state weights P (C) have to be determined by solving the equations 45%!$: 45!5% (Eq. (4)) and the expressions obtained are usually complicated. Once the steady state weights are known, the calculation of steady state properties becomes very similar to that of equilibrium properties: one has to average physical quantities with the steady state weights. One of the simplest non-equilibrium systems one can consider is the fully asymmetric simple exclusion process ASEP in one dimension [1—4]. The model describes a driven lattice gas [5] in one dimension with hard core repulsion. At large scale [6], the ASEP is expected [7—10] to be described by a noisy Burgers equation or equivalently by the Kardar—Parisi—Zhang equation. Therefore, the long time and large scale properties of the ASEP can be reinterpreted as asymptotic properties of directed polymers in a random medium or of growing interfaces.
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
67
In one dimension, the ASEP can be defined as follows. Each site of a one-dimensional lattice is either occupied by one particle or empty. A configuration of the system can therefore be characterized by binary variables Mq N where q "1 if site i is occupied by a particle and q "0 if site i is i i i empty. During every infinitesimal time interval dt, each particle hops with probability dt to its right if this site is empty (and does not move otherwise). For any initial configuration Mq (0)N, one can write the evolution of arbitrary correlation i functions by considering the possible events which occur during the time interval dt. For example, the evolution of the occupation q of site i during the time interval dt is given by i q (t) with probability 1!2 dt , i q (t#dt)" q (t)#q (t)!q (t)q (t) with probability dt , (5) i i~1 i i~1 i q (t)q (t) with probability dt , i i`1 (the first line corresponds to updating neither the bond (i!1, i) nor the bond (i, i#1), the second line corresponds to updating the bond (i!1, i) and the third line corresponds to updating the bond (i, i#1)) and the average over the history between times 0 and t leads to
G
dSq T i "Sq T!Sq T!Sq q T#Sq q T . i~1 i i~1 i i i`1 dt
(6)
For a pair of neighboring sites, one can write q (t#dt)q (t#dt) i i`1 q (t)q (t) with probability 1!3 dt , i i`1 (q (t)#q (t)!q (t)q (t))q (t) with probability dt , i i~1 i i`1 " i~1 q (t)q (t) with probability dt , i i`1 q (t)q (t)q (t) with probability dt , i i`1 i`2 which gives for the evolution equation of Sq q T i i`1 dSq q T i i`1 "Sq q T!Sq q T!Sq q q T#Sq q q T i~1 i`1 i i`1 i~1 i i`1 i i`1 i`2 dt
G
(7)
and a similar reasoning allows one to derive the evolution equations of higher correlations. What is visible in Eqs. (6) and (7) is that all the correlation functions are coupled in the hierarchy. To determine in Eq. (6) the one-point functions Sq T, one needs to know the two-point functions i Sq q T. Trying to calculate these nearest-neighbor correlations in Eq. (7) requires the knowledge i i`1 of further correlations Sq q T or of higher-order correlations Sq q q T and so on. This i~1 i`1 i~1 i i`1 shows that the problem is a N-body problem and so far it has not been possible to derive an expression of the correlations at time t, given an arbitrary initial condition Mq (0)N. i 2. The steady state for periodic conditions For periodic boundary conditions, its turns out that the steady state of the ASEP is particularly simple. For a system of P particles on a ring of N sites, one can show that in the steady state all
68
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
possible configurations have equal weight [11] as P! (N!P)! P (C)" . 45%!$: 45!5% N!
(8)
This is because, if n(C) is the number of clusters in the configuration C, the probability of leaving configuration C during the time interval dt is n(C)P(C) dt (by the move of the first particle of each cluster) whereas the probability of entering the configuration C is + P(C@) dt where the sum runs C{ over the configurations C@ obtained from C by moving one step backwards of the last particle of each cluster. As the number of configurations C@ is equal to the number of clusters n(C), the stationarity condition (4) is fulfilled when all configurations have equal weight. This simplicity of the steady state makes the calculation of equal time correlation functions very easy. For example P Sq T" ; i N
P(P!1) Sq q T" ; i j N(N!1)
P(P!1)(P!2) Sq q q T" . i j k N(N!1)(N!2)
The fact that the weights (8) of the configurations in the steady state are simple, Eq. (8) does not make all the steady state properties easy to calculate. For example, unequal time correlation functions like Sq (0)q (t)T are not known, even in the steady state. One of the simplest quantity i j which contains some information about unequal time correlations is the diffusion constant D of a tagged particle [12—14] on the ring. If we tag one of the particles (without in anyway changing its dynamics) and call ½ the number of hops the particle has made up to time t, one expects that the t following two limits exist: S½ T S½2T!S½ T2 t "v; t t "D lim lim (9) t t t?= t?= and these two limits define the velocity v and the diffusion constant D. The exact expressions of v and of D are given by [15] N!P v" , N!1
(10)
C
D
(2N!3)! (P!1)! (N!P)! 2 D" . (2P!1)! (2N!2P!1)! (N!1)!
(11)
The expression for v is a simple consequence of the fact (8) that all configurations with P particles have equal probability [11] in the steady state. The expression for D, on the other hand, is harder to obtain and was first derived in [15] using a generalization of the matrix approach discussed in Section 3. We will see in Section 4 that it can also be recovered using the Bethe ansatz. The expression of D in terms of correlation functions is usually complicated. However, for the ASEP on a ring with periodic boundary conditions, using the fact (8) that all configurations have equal weight, one can show that
P G
H
P2(N!P)2 N(N!P) 2N2 = dt Sq (t)[1!q (t)][1!q (0)]q (0)T! D" # . i i`1 i i`1 P(N!1) P2 N2(N!1)2 0
(12)
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
69
For large N, keeping the density o"P/N of particles fixed, Eq. (11) becomes
C
D
Jp (1!o)3@2 1 . DK o1@2 N1@2 2
(13)
The fact that D vanishes for NPR indicates that in the infinite system, for fixed initial conditions, the fluctuations in the distance travelled by a tagged particle are subdiffusive [12—14].
3. The steady state for open boundary conditions Another case for which the weights of the configurations in the steady state can be calculated exactly [16,17] is the ASEP with open boundary conditions [4] which is defined as follows: each site i of a one-dimensional lattice of N sites is either occupied (q "1) by a particle or empty (q "0); i i during a time interval dt (with dt;1), each particle has a probability dt of hopping to its right, provided the target site is empty; moreover, during the time interval dt, a particle may enter the lattice at site 1 with probability a dt (if this site is empty) and a particle at site N may leave the lattice with probability b dt (if this site is occupied). The evolution equations (Eqs. (6) and (7)) remain valid in the bulk (i.e., as long as all the sites involved in the equations belong to the system). At the boundary, they are modified to include the boundary effects. For example Eq. (6) becomes dSq T 1 "aS(1!q )T!Sq (1!q )T , 1 1 2 dt
(14)
dSq T N "Sq (1!q )T!bSq T . N~1 N N dt
(15)
In the steady state, all the equal time correlation functions become time independent. In particular, the left-hand sides of Eqs. (6), (7), (14) and (15) vanish. The steady state properties of this asymmetric exclusion model with open boundary conditions can be calculated exactly [16—18] for any N, a and b. The solution described below consists in writing the steady state weights of the configurations as the matrix elements of products of N matrices [17]. This type of approach, initially introduced in connection with the Bethe ansatz [19,20], has been used to solve several problems in statistical mechanics, in particular, the problem of directed lattice animals [21]. The main idea is to write the weight P (q 2q ) of each configuration in the steady state 45%!$: 45!5% 1 N as
T
U
N P (q 2q )"Z~1 ¼D < [q D#(1!q )E]D» , (16) 45%!$: 45!5% 1 N i i i/1 where D, E are matrices, S¼D, D»T are vectors, the q are the occupation variables and the i normalization factor Z is given by
T
U
N Z" + 2 + ¼D < [q D#(1!q )E]D» "S¼D(D#E)ND»T . i i q1/1,0 qN/1,0 i/1
(17)
70
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
In other words, in the product (16) a matrix D appears whenever a site is occupied (q "1) and i E whenever a site is empty (q "0). Since D and E do not commute in general, the weights i P (q 2q ) are complicated functions of the configuration Mq 2q N. 45%!$: 45!5% 1 N 1 N In [17] it was shown that Eqs. (16) and (17) do give the weights in the steady state of the asymmetric exclusion model when the matrices D and E and the vectors S¼D and D»T satisfy the following algebraic rules: DE"D#E ,
(18)
1 S¼DE" S¼D , a
(19)
1 DD»T" D»T . b
(20)
Proofs that this is so are rather easy and have already been published [17,22]. Let us just explain it with a simple example. Consider a configuration of the form (21) During each time interval dt, the probability of entering this configuration is S¼DEp~1DEDN~p~1D»T dt S¼D(D#E)ND»T
(22)
by coming from configuration (23) The probability of leaving this configuration is given by (a#b)
S¼DEpDN~pD»T dt S¼D(D#E)ND»T
(24)
since one particle may enter at site 1 or the particle at site N may leave. In the steady state these two expressions should be equal (4) to ensure that the weight of configuration (21) remains unchanged S¼DEp~1DEDN~p~1D»T"(a#b)S¼DEpDN~pD»T
(25)
and this equality is easy to check using Eqs. (18)—(20). A generalization of this reasoning to arbitrary configurations is given in [22] and provides a proof that Eq. (16) gives the steady state weight of all the configurations.
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
71
Once the weights are known from Eqs. (16) and (17), one can calculate all the equal time steady state properties. For example, the average occupation Sq T of site i is given by i (q 2q ) , Sq T" + 2 + q P i 45%!$: 45!5% 1 N i qN/0,1 q1/0,1 which becomes in terms of the matrices D and E and the vectors S¼D and D»T S¼D(D#E)i~1D(D#E)N~iD»T Sq T" . i S¼D(D#E)ND»T
(26)
(27)
We see that, to evaluate Eq. (27), one has to calculate the matrix elements of the form S¼DDm1En1Dm2En22D»T .
(28)
One way to do it [17,22] is to construct matrices and vectors which satisfy Eqs. (18)—(20). One can show, however, that the calculation of all these matrix elements can be done directly from the algebraic rules Eqs. (18)—(20) without using any specific representation of the algebra. First, from Eqs. (19) and (20), it is obvious that all the matrix elements of the form S¼DEpDqD»T are easy to calculate and is given by 1 S¼D»T . S¼DEpDqD»T" apbq
(29)
It is also easy to see, using DE"D#E, that any more complicated matrix element (28) can be reduced to simple matrix elements of the form (29). For example, the matrix element SE3DE2DT becomes, using Eq. (18) SE3DE2DT"SE5DT#SE4DT#SE3D2T . In particular, one can obtain that way the expression of the denominator S¼D(D#E)ND»T for all N as N p(2N!1!p)! b~p~1!a~p~1 S¼D(D#E)ND»T "+ . (30) b~1!a~1 N! (N!p)! S¼D»T p/1 In the large N limit, one can calculate from Eq. (27) the average occupation o"Sq T for a site i far i from the boundaries and one finds the phase diagram shown in Fig. 1 with the three following phases: Phase I: For a'1 and b'1, 2 2 (31) o"1 . 2 Phase II: For a(1 and a(b, 2 o"a . (32) Phase III: For b(1 and b(a, 2 o"1!b .
(33)
72
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
Fig. 1. The phase diagram. Fig. 2. The average occupation o"Sq
T of the central site versus a for N"61 and N"121 when b"0.2. (N`1)@2
Phase I is the maximal current phase, phase II is a low density phase and phase III is a high density phase. The lines a"1, b'1 and b"1, a'1 are second-order transition lines (o is continuous) 2 2 2 2 whereas the line a"b(1 is a first-order transition line (o is discontinuous). The first-order 2 transition can be seen in Fig. 2 where the average occupation of the central site o"Sq T is (N`1)@2 plotted versus a (at b"0.2 fixed) for two system sizes N"61 and N"121. As N increases, one observes that o becomes discontinuous along the first-order transition line a"b. There is a line in the phase diagram, the line a#b"1
(34)
along which there exists a solution of Eqs. (18)—(20) such that the matrices D and E commute. If one chooses D and E to be numbers, one must have from Eqs. (19) and (20), D"1/b and E"1/a and condition (18) imposes that 1/a#1/b"1/(ab) which leads to Eq. (34). Along this line, there is no correlation between the different sites and N P (q 2q )" < [q a#(1!q )(1!a)] . (35) 45%!$: 45!5% 1 N i i i/1 This line plays the role of a disordered line in usual statistical mechanics models [23]. One can try to calculate for the ASEP with open boundary conditions unequal time correlations. Because the steady state is more complicated than in the case of periodic boundary conditions, unequal time correlations are also much harder to obtain. So far only the diffusion constant of the integrated current, which generalises expression (11) to the case of open boundary conditions, has been calculated exactly [24]. However, contrarily to what was said in [24], the relation to unequal time correlation functions is usually much more complicated than (12).
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
73
4. The Bethe ansatz method For the ASEP, the Bethe ansatz was first used [25—27] to calculate the gap which gives the largest relaxation time in the system. In this section we will see that it gives also the diffusion constant (11) in the case of periodic boundary conditions [28]. Because on a ring the particles cannot overtake each other, they all cover the same distance ½ , t up to fluctuations which remain bounded when t becomes large. Therefore, if one calls X the total t distance covered by the three particles during the time t, one has X KP½ or more precisely, if one t t considers the generating function of X and of ½ , the two following limits coincide t t logSecXtT logSePcYtT lim "lim "j(c) (36) t t t?= t?= and their common value j(c) can be calculated using the Bethe ansatz. To see how the Bethe ansatz works, it is easier to consider a system of three particles (P"3) on a ring of N sites. One can show [28] that j(c) is the largest eigenvalue of a N(N!1)(N!2)/ 6]N(N!1)(N!2)/6 matrix. A configuration C of the system can be labelled by the positions 14x (x (x 4N of the three particles and if t(x , x , x ) is the eigenvector corresponding to 1 2 3 1 2 3 the eigenvalue j, the equations satisfied by t and j are jt(x , x , x )"ec[t(x !1, x , x )#t(x , x !1, x )#t(x , x , x !1)]!3t(x , x , x ) . 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 (37) These equations are valid only when the positions of the three particles are not neighbours (and x O1). If x "x #1, the hard core condition modifies Eq. (37) and it becomes 1 2 1 jt(x , x #1, x )"ec[t(x !1, x #1, x )#t(x , x #1, x !1)]!2t(x , x #1, x ) . 1 1 3 1 1 3 1 1 3 1 1 3 (38) Similarly, when x "x #1 one obtains 3 2 jt(x , x , x #1)"ec[t(x !1, x , x #1)#t(x , x !1, x #1)]!2t(x , x , x #1) . 1 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 (39) Lastly, periodic boundary conditions lead to jt(1, x , x )"ec[t(x , x , N)#t(1, x !1, x )#t(1, x , x !1)]!3t(1, x , x ) . (40) 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 Usually, solving the Eqs. (37) and (38) for arbitrary N is very hard because the problem is a three-body problem. The idea of the Bethe ansatz consists in trying to see whether a certain simple form for the eigenvector t(x , x , x ) can solve the eigenvalue problem. For P"3 particles, 1 2 3 one looks for an eigenvector which is a sum of 6 terms t(x , x , x )"A zx1zx2zx3#A zx1zx2zx3#2#A zx1zx2zx3 (41) 1 2 3 123 1 2 3 213 2 1 3 321 3 2 1 where the three parameters z , z , z and the 6 parameters A ,2, A are unknown. Then one 1 2 3 123 321 inserts this form (41) into Eqs. (37)—(40) to find the conditions that these parameters have to satisfy
74
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
for Eq. (41) to be an eigenvector. If one inserts Eq. (41) into Eq. (37), one finds
C
j(c)"ec
D
1 1 1 # # !3 z z z 2 3 1
(42)
and when one tries to satisfy Eqs. (38) and (39) also, one finds that ec!z ec!z 1A 2A "! , A "! 123 213 ec!z 231 ec!z 3 1 ec!z ec!z 1A 3A "! , A "! 312 ec!z 321 ec!z 132 2 1 ec!z ec!z 2A 3A "! , A "! 321 ec!z 312 ec!z 231 1 2 whereas Eq. (40) gives A "zNA "z~NA , 123 1 231 3 312 A "zNA "z~NA , 231 2 312 1 123 A "zNA "z~NA . 312 3 123 2 231 One can check that these linear equations for the A are compatible when the z are solutions of ijk i the following three equations: 3 z~N(ec!z )3" < (ec!z ) . (43) j i i j/1 Therefore, for each choice of the z which satisfy Eq. (43), expression (41) is an eigenvector with i eigenvalue (42). As we want the largest eigenvalue, one has to choose the solution such that j(c)P0 as cP0. This solution is obtained by choosing the solution of Mz , z , z N which converges to 1 2 3 M1, 1, 1N as cP0 (because the matrix is finite, there is no crossing of eigenvalues, so that the eigenvalue for any c can be obtained by continuity from the solution j(0) for c"0). It is straightforward to extend the Bethe ansatz from 3 particles to an arbitrary number P of particles. The eigenvector (41) becomes a sum of P! terms. The eigenvalue j(c) given by Eqs. (42) and (43) becomes for general P and N P 1 j(c)"!p#ec + , z i/1 i where the z satisfy i P z~N(ec!z )P"(!1)P~1 < (ec!z ) . i i j j/1
(44)
(45)
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
75
Finding the z solutions of Eq. (45) is not easy. It turns out that the right hand side of Eq. (45) is i independent of i, thus it can be rewritten as z~N(z !ec)P"B , i i where
(46)
P B"(!1)P~1 < (z !ec) . (47) j j/1 Now, we need to select the P roots z of Eq. (46) which tend to 1 as cP0 and BP0. To do that i we can use the Cauchy formula
Q
dz (z!ec)P~1[Pz!N(z!ec)] + h(z )" h(z) , (48) j 2piz (z!ec)P!BzN 1yjyP where the integration contour is a small circle (for small B) around ec which surrounds P roots of the polynomial (z!ec)P!BzN. Using h(z)"(ec!z)/z in Eq. (48), one gets = (Nq!2)! (Be(N~P)c)q . (49) j(c)"!P + (Pq)! (Nq!Pq!1)! q/1 The z are solutions of Eq. (46) and depend both on B and c which so far are not related. In k principle, one could use these z into Eq. (47) in order to find a self-consistent equation relating k B and c. A way of relating B and c, simpler than checking that Eq. (47) is satisfied, consists in writing that z z 2z "1 or equivalently 1 2 P P + log z "0 , (50) k k/1 which expresses the fact that the eigenvector associated to the largest eigenvalue is translational invariant (t(x , x , x )"t(x #1, x #1, x #1)). Using Eq. (48), one can rewrite (50) as 1 2 3 1 2 3 dz (z!ec)P~1[Pz!N(z!ec)] log z"0 (51) 2piz (z!ec)P!BzN
Q
and by expanding this last expression in powers of B, one obtains = (Nq!1)! c"! + (Be(N~P)c)q . (52) (Pq)! (Nq!Pq)! q/1 The two series (49) and (52) give j as a function of c by eliminating B (this elimination can of course be done for small B but the coefficients of j in powers of c are much more complicated than those appearing in Eqs. (49) and (52); moreover, as the largest eigenvalue j(c) remains isolated as c varies, the function j(c) given by the two series (Eqs. (49) and (52)) for small c can be analytically continued to the whole real axis).
76
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
With the two expressions (49) and (52), it is easy to calculate the successive derivatives of j with respect to c. From Eq. (36), one has
K
K
S½ T 1 dj S½2T!S½ T2 1 d2j t " t t " v"lim and D"lim (53) t t P dc 2P2 dc2 c/0 c/0 t?= t?= and this leads to Eq. (9). In fact, j(c) contains also all the higher cumulants of ½ and it can be used t to calculate the large deviation function [28]. In the case of open boundary conditions [24] (Section 3) as well for a ring with a partial asymmetry [29], the diffusion constant has been calculated by an extension of the matrix method of Section 3. The calculation by the Bethe ansatz has not been extended yet to these cases.
5. Two species of particle on a ring The matrix method of Section 3 can be generalized to obtain the exact steady state of systems of more complicated systems, in particular, systems with two species of particles [30]. Consider a ring of N sites with two species of particles represented by 1 and 2, and holes represented by 0 and in which the hopping rates are 1 0 P 0 1 with rate 1 , 2 0 P 0 2 with rate a ,
(54)
1 2 P 2 1 with rate b . One can show [30] that the steady state weights may be written as trace(X X 2X ) , (55) 1 2 N where X "D if site i is occupied by a 1 particle, X "A if it is occupied by a 2 particle and X "E if i i i it is empty, provided that the matrices D, A and E satisfy the following algebra: DE"D#E;
bDA"A;
aAE"A .
(56)
The last two of these equations are satisfied when A is given by A"D»TS¼D ,
(57)
and 1 DD»T" D»T; b
1 S¼DE" S¼D . a
(58)
So, one can use the same matrices D, E as those of Section 2 for the case of open boundary conditions, and construct matrix A from the vectors S¼D and D»T. The proof that Eqs. (55) and (56) gives the steady state of the two species problem is very similar to the proof for the case of open boundary conditions: one shows that the loss term and the gain
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
77
term for the probability of each configuration are equal. For example, for a configuration of the type (59) on a ring, the loss term during dt is (a#b) trace(EpDqArEs) dt
(60)
as there are only two possibilities of leaving this configuration and the gain term is trace(Ep~1DEDq~1ArEs) dt
(61)
as there is a single way of entering this configuration. For such configurations, it is almost evident from Eq. (56) that the loss term and the gain term coincide. To illustrate a situation with two species, let us consider on a ring of N sites a single particle 2 and P particles 1 [31,32]. The parameters a and b which appear in Eq. (54) are chosen such that b(1!a . This implies in particular that a(1 and b(1, so that the particle 2 is slower than particles 1 and as b(1, it plays the role of a moving obstacle. In other words, particles 1 can be thought as cars and the particle 2 as a single slow truck. Using the algebraic rules (56), it is possible to calculate ½(N, P) defined by
T
U
1 N~1 ½(N, P)" + 2 + d 1 2 N~1 ¼D < [q D#(1!q )E]D» q i i ` `q ,P S¼D»T qN~1/0,1 q1/0,1 i/1 and show that for 14P4N!2
(62)
N~P~1 P 1 (N!2!p)! (N!2!q)! [p(P!q)#q(N!1!P)] , (63) ½(N, P)" + + P! (N!1!P)! (P!q)! (N!1!P!p)! apbq p/0 q/0 whereas ½(N, 0)"a~(N~1) and ½(N,N!1)"b~(N~1). Then the average velocity v of particle 2 2 (the truck) is given by ½(N!1, P)!½(N!1, P!1) , v " 2 ½(N, P) whereas the average velocity v of particles 1 (cars) is given by 1 N ½(N!1, P!1) v "v # . 1 2 P ½(N, P)
(64)
(65)
These velocities are shown in Fig. 3 as a function of the density o"P/N of particles 1 for two system sizes (N"100 and N"200). For large N, we see that as o varies, v presents a plateau 2 for 1!a(o(b where v "a!b. Along this plateau, the ring consists of two macroscopic 2 regions: a region of high density o "1!a following the truck and a region of low density b `
78
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
Fig. 3. The velocities v and v of the particles 1 and 2 versus the density o of first class particles for two rings of 100 and 1 2 200 sites when a"0.15 and b"0.25. Finite size effects are small enough to make the curves for 100 and 200 hard to distinguish.
ahead of the truck. These two regions are of length ¸ "N(o!b)/(1!a!b) and ¸ " ` ~ N(1!a!o)/(1!a!b) so that the total density is ¸ o #¸ o ~ ~. o" ` ` N The expression of the average velocity v of the particles 1 can also be obtained in this coexistence 1 region, by ¸ o v #¸ o v ~ ~ ~ v " ` ` ` 1 P with v "1!o i.e. B B (1!a)b v "a!b# . 1 o In the thermodynamic limit, three phases can be observed as the density o"P/N of particles 1 varies. The steady state velocities v of the particles 1 and v of the particle 2 have the following 1 2 expressions (which can be obtained from the asymptotic behavior of Eq. (63)): For o(b,
v "1!o; v "a!o . 1 2 For b(o(1!a, v "a!b#(1!a)b/o; v "a!b . 1 2 For 1!a(o, v "1!o; v "1!b!o . 1 2 It is interesting to notice that in the range b(o(1!a, the truck (particle 2) has a constant velocity, whereas in that range, cars (particles 1) have an average velocity slower than 1!o (the velocity in absence of the truck). In this whole range there is a coexistence of two macroscopic
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
79
regions, one of low density b and one of high density 1!a, very similar to the coexistence between the liquid and the gas for a fluid. A case of the two species problem of particular interest and which, as we will see in Section 6, can be used to study shocks is that of first and second class particles [33—36]. This corresponds to a"b"1 in Eq. (54) so that all hopping rates are 1. Both first and second class particles hop forward when they have a hole to their right, but when a first class particle has a second class particle to its right, the two particles interchange positions. Thus, a second class particle tends to move backwards in an environment of a high density of first class particles and tends to move forwards in an environment of a low density of first class particles so that it gets trapped by a shock. The matrix method was used in [30] to calculate exactly the profile of a shock as seen from a second class particle by starting from the steady state weights (55) of the two species problem on a ring. We are going to see in Section 6 that the shock profile can also be calculated directly on an infinite line.
6. Shock profile It is possible to generalize the calculation of Sections 3 and 5 to describe shock profiles in an infinite system. Consider an infinite system with only one kind of particles (as in Sections 2—4). If the initial condition is a Bernoulli measure with density o at the right of the origin (i.e. the q are independent ` i and Sq T"o for i50) and with density o at the left of the origin (Sq T"o for i(0), the i ` ~ i ~ evolution of the ASEP develops a shock. The shock has a velocity v"1!o !o (66) ~ ` and this can be easily understood from the conservation of mass. The current far to the right of the shock is o (1!o ) and far to the left is o (1!o ). Therefore, in a large region containing the ` ` ~ ~ shock, the number of particles increases by [o (1!o )!o (1!o )]t during the time t. This ~ ~ ` ` increase in the number of particles has the effect of a translation of the shock of vt so that (o !o )vt"[o (1!o )!o (1!o )]t ~ ` ~ ~ ` ` which gives (66). A more delicate question is that of the shape of a shock. Because the dynamics is stochastic, one first needs to locate the shock. There exist several ways of locating the shock. For example, one can choose [38] an irrational value o which satisfies o (o (o and define the position of the * ~ * ` shock as the value m which minimizes S * m +m (q !o ), for m'0 , k/1 k * S " 0, for m"0 , (67) m !+0 (q !o ), for m(0 , k/~m`1 k * (as the density is o to the right of the shock, the sum increases like (o !o )m as mP$R, thus, ` B * for almost all configurations Mq N, there is a unique minimum m ). With this definition of the n *
G
80
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
position of the shock (which depends on o ), one can study the measure seen from this position. For * example, the profile Sq T is just the average occupation at position m #n (given that the minimum n * of Eq. (67) is located at m ). Obviously, as the location of the minimum depends on the value of o , * * the profile Sq T or the measure seen from the minimum m will depend on o . This means that two n * * observers looking at exactly the same physical situation, but using two different values of o to * locate the shock, will observe different profiles. The profile Sq T is, therefore, not an intrinsic n property of the shock. One can, however, define some properties of shocks [38] like sums of the type = U " + S(q !o )(q !o )T , (68) k n ~ n`k ` n/~= which are independent of the definition chosen to locate the shock and can therefore be thought as intrinsic properties of the shock. For example [38], one expects U to be always given by 1 = U " + S(q !o )(q !o )T"o (1!o ) 1 n ~ n`1 ` ~ ` n/~= irrespective of the method chosen to locate the shock, in particular irrespective of the value of o . * A convenient way of locating the shock consists in replacing one hole in the system by a second class particle (i.e. with dynamics given by Eq. (54) with a"b"1). This replacement does not affect the dynamics of the particles 1 and so does not disturb the configurations of the shock. The second class particle has a larger velocity in the region of density o than in the region of density o and ~ ` one can show that it gets trapped by the shock [30,33—35,37]. Therefore, the position of the second class particle can be used to locate the shock. One can try to describe the measure seen from this second class particle. It is possible to show [22,37,38] that the steady state weights of all possible environments of the second class particle in presence of a shock characterized by the two asymptotic densities o and o can be written in ` ~ a matrix form similar to Eq. (16). If the occupation numbers q are specified for the n sites at the left of second class particle and the i n@ sites at its right, the steady state probability of the configuration is given by
T C
DC
DU
~1 n{ Prob(q 2q ; q 2q )" ¼D < (Dq #E(1!q )) A < (Dq #E(1!q )) D» ~n ~1 1 n{ i i i i i/~n i/1 when the matrices A, D, E and the vectors D»T and S¼D satisfy DE"(1!o )(1!o )D#o o E , ~ ` ~ ` DA"o o A; AE"(1!o )(1!o )A , ~ ` ~ ` S¼D(D#E)"S¼D; (D#E)D»T"D»T ,
(69)
(70)
S¼DAD»T"1 . For example, Prob(1 1 0 2 1 1 0 1)"S¼DD2EAD2EDD»T. So as in Section 5, for each particle we put a D, for each hole an E and for the second class particle we put the matrix A. As in Section 3, it is easy to see that all the matrix elements of the form
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
81
S¼DDmAEnD»T can be calculated immediately from Eq. (71) S¼DDnAEn{D»T"[o o ]n[(1!o )(1!o )]n{ ~ ` ~ ` and that, by using the algebra (71), all the other matrix elements can be reduced by using the algebra to such elements. One can calculate that way the profile seen from the second class particle
G
S¼DA(D#E)n~1DD»T Sq T" n S¼DD(D#E)~n`1AD»T
for n51 , for n4!1 .
(71)
One finds in particular Sq T"o #o !o o ; 1 ` ~ ` ~
Sq T"o o ; ~1 ` ~
Sq T"o o #o o (1!o )(1!o ) ~2 ` ~ ~ ` ~ `
and so on, in agreement with [30]. One can check that the velocity v of the second class particle given by v"S(1!q )!q T"1!o !o 1 ~1 ` ~ coincides with the shock velocity (66), as it should since the second class particle is trapped by the shock. The algebra (71) which gives the measure seen from the second class particle, can of course be used to calculate all the intrinsic properties of the shock, in particular the sums U defined in k Eq. (68). It is possible to show [38] from the algebra (71) that there is a relation between the profile Sq T seen from the second class particle and the intrinsic sums (68) n U !U "(o !o )(o !Sq T) . k`1 k ` ~ ` k Of course such a relation has no reason to remain valid when the profile Sq T is seen from k a different location than the second class particle.
7. Conclusions The matrix method described in Sections 3, 5 and 6 has been extended recently to a number of cases: parallel dynamics [39,40], partial asymmetry [17,37,41—44], transient properties [45], systems with two or more species of particles [46—49], reaction diffusion models [50,51], cases with disorder [52]. However, there remains a number of simple generalizations of the asymmetric exclusion model such as the case of a fixed blockage [53], the calculation of general unequal time correlations [54], more general reaction diffusion models [55], open systems with several species of particles [56], for which exact solutions are still lacking. Trying to extend the Bethe ansatz calculation of Section 4 to other cases (several species, partial asymmetry, open boundary conditions) would certainly lead to new interesting results and make more transparent the link with the matrix method.
82
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83
Acknowledgements The content of these lectures is based on work done in collaboration with E. Domany, M.R. Evans, S. Goldstein, V. Hakim, S. Janowsky, J.L. Lebowitz, K. Mallick, D. Mukamel, V. Pasquier, E.R. Speer. I would like to thank them as well as D. Kim, V. Rittenberg, G. Schu¨tz, H. Spohn and R. Stinchcombe for useful discussions.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37]
F. Spitzer, Adv. Math. 5 (1970) 246. T.M. Liggett, Interacting Particle Systems, Springer, New York, 1985. H. Spohn, Large Scale Dynamics of Interacting Particles, Springer, New York, 1991. J. Krug, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 1882. B. Schmittmann, R.K.P. Zia, Statistical mechanics of driven diffusive systems, in: C. Domb, J.L. Lebowitz (Eds.), Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 17, Academic, New York, 1995. J.L. Lebowitz, E. Presutti, H. Spohn, J. Statist. Phys. 51 (1988) 841. T. Halpin-Healy, Y.-C. Zhang, Phys. Rep. 254 (1994) 215. A. De Masi, E. Presutti, E. Scacciatelli, Ann. Inst. Henri Poincare´: Probabilite´s et Statistiques 25 (1989) 1. C. Kipnis, S. Olla, S.R.S. Varadhan, Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 42 (1989) 115. J.L. Lebowitz, E. Orlandi, E. Presutti, Physica D 33 (1988) 165. P. Meakin, P. Ramanlal, L.M. Sander, R.C. Ball, Phys. Rev. A 34 (1986) 5091. A. De Masi, P.A. Ferrari, J. Statist. Phys. 38 (1985) 603. R. Kutner, H. van Beijeren, J. Statist. Phys. 39 (1985) 317. S.N. Majumdar, M. Barma, Phys. Rev. B 44 (1991) 5306. B. Derrida, M.R. Evans, D. Mukamel, J. Phys. A 26 (1993) 4911. B. Derrida, E. Domany, D. Mukamel, J. Stat. Phys. 69 (1992) 667. B. Derrida, M.R. Evans, V. Hakim, V. Pasquier, J. Phys. A 26 (1993) 1493. G. Schu¨tz, E. Domany, J. Stat. Phys. 72 (1993) 277. L.D. Faddeev, Sov. Sci. Rev. C 1 (1980) 107. R.J. Baxter, Exactly Solved Models in Statistical Mechanics, Academic, New York, 1982. V. Hakim, J.P. Nadal, J. Phys. A 16 (1983) L213. B. Derrida, M.R. Evans, in: V. Privman (Ed.), Non-equilibrium Statistical Mechanics in One Dimension, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1997, pp. 277. P. Ruja´n, J. Stat. Phys. 49 (1987) 139. B. Derrida, M.R. Evans, K. Mallick, J. Stat. Phys. 79 (1995) 833. D. Dhar, Phase Transitions 9 (1987) 51. L.H. Gwa, H. Spohn, Phys. Rev. A 46 (1992) 844. D. Kim, Phys. Rev. E 52 (1995) 3512; J. Phys. A 30 (1997) 3817. B. Derrida, J.L. Lebowitz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 209. B. Derrida, K. Mallick, J. Phys. A 30 (1997) 1031. B. Derrida, S.A. Janowsky, J.L. Lebowitz, E.R. Speer, Europhys. Lett. 22 (1993) 651; J. Stat. Phys. 73 (1993) 813. B. Derrida, in: Hao Bailin (Ed.), Stat. Phys. 19, Xiamen, China, World Scientific, Singapore, 1996, pp. 243—253. K. Mallick, J. Phys. A 29 (1996) 5375. E.D. Andjel, M. Bramson, T.M. Liggett, Probab. Theory Rel. Fields 78 (1988) 231. P.A. Ferrari, C. Kipnis, E. Saada, Ann. Probab. 19 (1991) 226. C. Boldrighini, G. Cosimi, S. Frigio, M.G. Nun8 es, J. Stat. Phys. 55 (1989) 611. E.R. Speer, The two species totally asymmetric exclusion process, in: M. Fannes, C. Maes, A. Verbeure (Eds.), Micro, Meso and Macroscopic Approaches in Physics, Plenum Press, New York, 1994. B. Derrida, J.L. Lebowitz, E.R. Speer, J. Stat. Phys. 89 (1997) 135.
B. Derrida / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 65—83 [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56]
B. Derrida, S. Goldstein, J.L. Lebowitz, E.R. Speer, J. Stat. Phys., in press. H. Hinrichsen, J. Phys. A 29 (1996) 3659. A. Honecker, I. Peschel, J. Stat. Phys. 88 (1997) 319. S. Sandow, Phys. Rev. 50 (1994) 2660. S. Sandow, G.M. Schu¨tz, Europhys. Lett. 26 (1994) 7. F.H.L. Essler, V. Rittenberg, J. Phys. A 29 (1996) 3375. K. Mallick, S. Sandow, J. Phys. A 30 (1997) 4513. R.B. Stinchcombe, G.M. Schu¨tz, Europhys. Lett. 29 (1995) 663; Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 140. M.R. Evans, Y. Kafri, M.H. Koduvely, D. Mukamel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 425. P.F. Arndt, T. Heinzel, V. Rittenberg, J. Phys. A 31 (1998) 833; J. Stat. Phys. 90 (1998) 783. F.C. Alcaraz, S. Dasmahapatra, V. Rittenberg, J. Phys. A 31 (1998) 845. A.B. Kolomeisky, preprint, 1997. H. Hinrichsen, S. Sandow, I. Peschel, J. Phys. A 29 (1996) 2643. M.J.E. Richardson, M.R. Evans, J. Phys. A 30 (1997) 811. M.R. Evans, Europhys. Lett. 36 (1996) 13; J. Phys. A 30 (1997) 5669. S.A. Janowsky, J.L. Lebowitz, Phys. Rev. A 45 (1992) 618. G.M. Schu¨tz, J. Stat. Phys. 88 (1997) 427. F.C. Alcaraz, M. Droz, M. Henkel, V. Rittenberg, Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 230 (1994) 250. M.R. Evans, D.P. Foster, C. Godre`che, D. Mukamel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 (1995) 208.
83
Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
Nonequilibrium dynamics of interfaces and lines Mehran Kardar Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Abstract The lectures examine several problems related to non-equilibrium fluctuations of interfaces and flux lines. We start by introducing the phenomenology of depinning, with particular emphasis on interfaces and contact lines. The role of the anisotropy of the medium in producing different universality classes is elucidated. We then focus on the dynamics of lines, where transverse fluctuations are also important. We shall demonstrate how various non-linearities appear in the dynamics of driven flux lines. The universality classes of depinning, and also dynamic roughening, are illustrated in the contexts of moving flux lines, advancing crack fronts, and drifting polymers. ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 47.55.Mh; 74.60.Ge; 75.60.Ch; 05.70.Ln Keywords: Depinning; Interfaces; Polymers; Flux lines
1. Depinning of interfaces 1.1. Introduction and phenomenology Depinning is a non-equilibrium critical phenomenon involving an external force and a pinning potential. When the force is weak the system is stationary, trapped in a metastable state. Beyond a threshold force the (last) metastable state disappears and the system starts to move. A simple example is provided by a point mass on a rough table. The mass is stationary until the external force F exceeds that of static friction F . Larger forces lead to an initial period of acceleration, # before the motion settles to a uniform velocity due to viscous forces. In the latter is proportional to velocity, the ultimate velocity of the point close to threshold behaves as vJ(F!F ). # While there are many other macroscopic mechanical examples, our main interest comes from condensed matter systems such as Charge Density Waves (CDWs) [1], interfaces [2], and contact lines [3]. In CDWs, the control parameter is the external voltage; a finite CDW current appears only beyond a threshold applied voltage. Interfaces in porous media, domain walls in random magnets, are stationary unless the applied force (magnetic field) is sufficiently strong. A key feature 0370-1573/98/$19.00 ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved PII S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 9 8 ) 0 0 0 0 7 - 6
86
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
of these examples is that they involve the collective depinning of many degrees of freedom that are elastically coupled. As such, these problems belong to the realm of collective critical phenomena, characterized by universal scaling laws. We shall introduce these laws and the corresponding exponents below for the depinning of a line (interface or contact line). Consider a line in two dimensions (Fig. 1) oriented along the x direction, and fluctuating along a perpendicular direction r. The configuration of the line at time t is described by the function r(x, t). The function r is assumed to be single valued, thus excluding configurations with overhangs. In many cases [2], where viscous forces dominate over inertia, the local velocity of a point on the curve is given by dr(x, t)/dt"F#f (x, r)#K[r] .
(1)
The first term on the right-hand side is a uniform applied force which is also the external control parameter. Fluctuations in the force due to randomness and impurities are represented by the second term. With the assumption that the medium is on average translationally invariant, the average of f can be set to zero. The final term in Eq. (1) describes the elastic forces between different parts of the line. Short-range interactions can be described by a gradient expansion; for example, a line tension leads to K[r(x)]"+ 2r or K[r(q)]"!q2r(q) for the Fourier modes. The surface of a drop of non-wetting liquid terminates at a contact line on a solid substrate [3]. Deformations of the contact line are accompanied by distortions of the liquid/gas surface. As shown by Joanny and de Gennes [4], the resulting energy and forces are non-local, described by K[r(q)]"!DqDr(q). For the case of a surface in three-dimensional deformations are described by r(x , x ). More 1 2 generally, we shall consider r(x), where x is a d-dimensional vector. In a similar spirit, we shall generalize the coupling to K[r(q)]"!DqDpr(q), which interpolates between the above two cases as p changes from one to two. Note, however, that the equation of motion need not originate from variations of a Hamiltonian, and may include non-linear couplings which will be discussed later on. When F is small, the line is trapped in one of many metastable states in which r/t"0 at all points. For F larger than a threshold F , the line is depinned from the last metastable state, and #
Fig. 1. Geometry of the line in two dimensions. Fig. 2. Critical behavior of the velocity.
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
87
moves with an average velocity v. On approaching the threshold from above, the velocity vanishes as (Fig. 2) v"A(F!F )b , (2) # where b is the velocity exponent, and A is a non-universal amplitude. A mean-field estimate for b was obtained by Fisher in the context of CDWs [5]. It corresponds to the limit p"0, where every point is coupled to all others, and hence experiences a restoring force proportional to Sr(x)T!r(x). The resulting equation of motion, dr(x)/dt"Sr(x)T!r(x)#F#f (x, r(x)), has to be supplemented with the condition Sr(x)T"vt. The self-consistent solution for the velocity, indeed, vanishes as (F!F )b, with an exponent that depends on the details of the random force. If # f (x, r(x)) varies smoothly with r, the exponent is b"3, while discontinuous jumps in the force (like 2 a saw-tooth) result in b"1. In fact, the latter is a better starting point for depinning in finite dimensions. This is because of the avalanches in motion (discussed next), which lead to a discontinuous coarse grained force. The motion just above threshold is not uniform, composed of rapid jumps as large segments of the line depin from strong pinning centers, superposed on the slower-steady advance. The jumps are reminiscent of avalanches in other slowly driven systems. In particular, Bak, Tang, and Wiesenfeld emphasized the role and importance of such events through the introduction of sand-pile models of self-organized criticality (SOC) [6]. The similarity to SOC is more clearly obtained if the depinning can be approached from below F by monotonically increasing # F in small increments, each sufficient to cause a jump to the next metastable state. These jumps have a power-law distribution in size, cutoff at a correlation length m which diverges at the transition as m&(F!F )~l . (3) # The size and width of avalanches becomes invariant on approaching F . For example, # Prob(width of avalanche'l)+(1/lB`1)oL (l/m ) , (4) ~ where the cutoff m diverges as in Eq. (3). The critical line is a self-affine fractal whose correlations ~ satisfy the dynamic scaling from S[r(x, t)!r(x@, t@)]2T"(x!x@)2fg(Dt!t@D/Dx!xDz) ,
(5)
defining the roughness and dynamic exponents, f and z, respectively. (Angular brackets reflect averaging over all realizations of the random force f.) The scaling function g goes to a constant as its argument approaches 0; f is the wandering exponent of an instantaneous line profile, and z relates the average lifetime of an avalanche to its size by q(m)&mz. Although, the underlying issues of collective depinning for CDWs and interfaces have been around for some time, only recently a systematic perturbative approach to the problem was developed. This functional renormalization group (RG) approach to the dynamical equations of motion was originally developed in the context of CDWs by Narayan and Fisher [7] (NF), and extended to interfaces by Nattermann et al. [8]. We shall provide a brief outline of this approach starting from Eq. (1). Before embarking on the details of the formalism, it is useful to point out
88
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
some scaling relations amongst the exponents which follow from underlying symmetries and non-renormalization conditions. 1. As mentioned earlier, the motion of the line close to the threshold is composed of jumps of segments of size m. Such jumps move the interface forward by mf over a time period mz. Thus, the velocity behaves as v&mf/mz&DF!F Dl(z~f) N b"l(z!f) . (6) # 2. If the elastic couplings are linear, the response of the line to a static perturbation e(x) is obtained simply by considering r (x, t)"r(x, t)!K~1[e(x)] , (7) e where K~1 is the inverse kernel. Since, r satisfies Eq. (1) subject to a force F#e(x)#f (x, r ), e e r satisfies the same equation with a force F#f (x, r!K~1[e(x)]). As long as the statistical properties of the stochastic force are not modified by the above change in its argument, SrT/e"0, and
T U
r (x) e "!K~1, or e(x)
T U
r (q) 1 e " . e(q) DqDp
(8)
Since it controls the macroscopic response of the line, the kernel K cannot change under RG scaling. From Eqs. (5) and (3), we can read-off the scaling of r(x), and the force dF, which using the above non-renormalization must be related by the exponent relation f#1/l"p .
(9)
Note that this identity depends on the statistical invariance of noise under the transformation in Eq. (7). It is satisfied as long as the force correlations S f (x, r) f (x@, r@)T only depend on r!r@. The identity does not hold if these correlations also depend on the slope r/x. 3. A scaling argument related to the Imry—Ma estimate of the lower critical dimension of the random field Ising model, can be used to estimate the roughness exponent [9] The elastic force on a segment of length m scales as mf~p. If fluctuations in force are uncorrelated in space, they scale as m~(f`1)@2 over the area of an avalanche. Assuming that these two forces must be of the same order to initiate the avalanche leads to f"(2p!1)/3 .
(10)
This last argument is not as rigorous as the previous two. Nonetheless, all three exponent identities can be established within the RG framework. Thus, the only undetermined exponent is the dynamic one, z. 1.2. Functional renormalization group A field theoretical description of the dynamics of Eq. (1) can be developed using the formalism of Martin et al. [10] (MSR): generalizing to a d-dimensional interface, an auxiliary field rL (x, t) is
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
89
introduced to implement the equation of motion as a series of d-functions. Various dynamical response and correlation functions for the field r(x, t) can then be generated from the functional,
P
(11)
P
(12)
Z" Dr(x, t)DrL (x, t)J[r] exp(S) , where S"i ddx dt rL (x, t)M r!K[r]!F!f (x, r(x, t))N . t
The Jacobian J[r] is introduced to ensure that the d-functions integrate to unity. It does not generate any new relevant terms and will be ignored henceforth. The disorder-averaged generating functional ZM can be evaluated by a saddle-point expansion around a mean-field (MF) solution obtained by setting K [r(x)]"vt!r(x). This amounts to MF replacing interaction forces with Hookean springs connected to the center of mass, which moves with a velocity v. The corresponding equation of motion is dr /dt"vt!r (t)#f [r (t)]#F (v) , (13) MF MF MF MF where the relationship F (v) between the external force F and average velocity v is determined MF from the consistency condition Sr (t)T"vt. The MF solution depends on the type of irregularity MF [7]: For smoothly varying random potentials, b "3, whereas for cusped random potentials, MF 2 b "1. Following the treatment of NF [7,11], we use the mean-field solution for cusped MF potentials, anticipating jumps with velocity of O(1), in which case b "1. After rescaling and MF averaging over impurity configurations, we arrive at a generating functional whose low-frequency form is
P
ZM " DR(x, t)DRK (x, t) exp(SI ) ,
P P
P
ddq du SI "! ddx dt [F!F (v)] RK (x, t)! RK (!q, !u)(!iuo#DqDp)R(q, u) MF (2p)w 2p #1 ddx dt dt@ RK (x, t)RK (x, t@)C[vt!vt@#R(x, t)!R(x, t@)] . 2
(14)
In the above expressions, R and RK are coarse-grained forms of r!vt and irL , respectively. F is adjusted to satisfy the condition SRT"0. The function C(vq) is initially the connected mean-field correlation function S(r (t)r (t#q)T . MF MF # Ignoring the R-dependent terms in the argument of C, the action becomes Gaussian, and is invariant under a scale transformation xPbx, tPbpt, RPbp~d@2R, RK Pb~p~d@2RK , FPb~d@2F, and vPb~d@2v. Other terms in the action, of higher order in R and RK , that result from the expansion of C [and other terms not explicitly shown in Eq. (14)], decay away at large length and time scales if d'd "2p. For d'd , the interface is smooth (f (0) at long length scales, and the # # 0 depinning exponents take the Gaussian values z "p, l "2/d, b "1. 0 0 0 At d"d , the action S has an infinite number of marginal terms that can be rearranged as # a Taylor series for the function C[vt!vt@#R(x, t)!R(x, t@)], when vP0. The RG is carried out by
90
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
integrating over a momentum shell K/b(DqD(K (we set the cutoff wave vector to K"1 for simplicity) and all frequencies, followed by a scale transformation xPbx, tPbzt, RPbfR, and RK Pbh~dRK , where b"el. The resulting recursion relation for the linear part in the effective action (to all orders in perturbation theory) is (F!F )/l"(z#h)(F!F )#constant , MF MF which immediately implies (with a suitable definition of F ) # (F!F )/l"y (F!F ) # F # with the exponent identity
(15)
(16)
y "z#h"1/l . (17) F The functional renormalization of C(u) in d"2p!e interface dimensions, computed to one-loop order, gives the recursion relation, C(u)/l"[e#2h#2(z!p)]C(u)#fu dC(u)/du !(S /(2p)d)d/duM[C(u)!C(0)]dC(u)/duN , (18) d where S is the surface area of a unit sphere in d dimensions. NF showed that all higher-order d diagrams contribute to the renormalization of C as total derivatives with respect to u, thus, integrating Eq. (18) at the fixed-point solution C*/l"0, together with Eqs. (9) and (17), gives f"e/3 to all orders in e, provided that :C*O0. This gives Eq. (10) for a one-dimensional interface, as argued earlier. This is a consequence of the fact that C(u) remains short-ranged upon renormalization, implying the absence of anomalous contributions to f. The dynamical exponent z is calculated through the renormalization of o, the term proportional to RK R, which yields t z"p!2e/9#O(e2) (19) and using the exponent identity (Eq. (6)), b"1!2e/9p#O(e2) .
(20)
Nattermann et al. [8] obtain the same results to O(e) by directly averaging the MSR generating function in Eq. (11), and expanding perturbatively around a rigidly moving interface. Numerical integration of Eq. (1) for an elastic interface [12] has yielded critical exponents f"0.97$0.05 and l"1.05$0.1, in agreement with the theoretical result f"l"1. The velocity exponent b"0.24$0.1 is also consistent with the one-loop theoretical result 1; however, a logar3 ithmic dependence v&1/ln(F!F ), which corresponds to b"0, also describes the numerical data # well. In contrast, experiments and various discrete models of interface growth have resulted in scaling behaviors that differ from system to system. A number of different experiments on fluid invasion in porous media [13] give roughness exponents of around 0.8, while imbibition experiments [14,15] have resulted in f+0.6. A discrete-model studied by Leschhorn [16], motivated by Eq. (1) with p"2, gives a roughness exponent of 1.25 at threshold. Since the expansion leading to
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
91
Eq. (1) breaks down when f approaches one, it is not clear how to reconcile the results of Leschhorn’s numerical work [16] with the coarse-grained description of the RG calculation, especially since any model with f'1 cannot have a coarse grained description based on gradient expansions. 1.3. Anisotropy Amaral et al. (ABS) [17] recently pointed out that various models of interface depinning in 1#1 dimensions fall into two distinct classes, depending on the tilt dependence of the interface velocity: 1. For models like the random field Ising Model [18] and some Solid On Solid models, the computed exponents are consistent with the exponents given by the RG analysis. It has been suggested [16], however, that the roughness exponent is systematically larger than e/3, casting doubt on the exactness of the RG result. 2. A number of different models, based on directed percolation (DP) [19,14] give a different roughness exponent, f+0.63. In these models, pinning sites are randomly distributed with a probability p, which is linearly related to the force F. The interface is stopped by the boundary of a DP cluster of pinning sites. The critical exponents at depinning can then be related to the longitudinal and transverse correlation length exponents l +1.70 and , l +1.07 of DP. In particular, f"l /l +0.63, and b"l !l +0.63, in agreement with M , M , M experiments. The main difference of these models can be understood in terms of the dependence of the threshold force F to the orientation. To include the possible dependence of the line mobility on its # slope, r, we can generalize the equation of motion to x r"K2r#i r#(j/2)( r)2#F#f (x, r) . (21) t x x x The isotropic depinning studied by RG corresponds to i"j"0. The usual mechanisms for generating a non-zero j are of kinematic origin [20] (jJv) and can be shown to be irrelevant at the depinning threshold where the velocity v goes to zero [11]. However, if j is not proportional to v and stays finite at the transition, it is a relevant operator and expected to modify the critical behavior. As we shall argue below, anisotropy in the medium is a possible source of the nonlinearity at the depinning transition. A model flux line (FL) confined to move in a plane [12,21] provides an example where both mechanisms for the non-linearity are present. Only the force normal to the FL is responsible for motion, and is composed of three components: (1) A term proportional to curvature arising from the smoothening effects of line tension. (2) The Lorentz force due to a uniform current density perpendicular to the plane acts in the normal direction and has a uniform magnitude F (per unit line length). (3) A random force nL ) f due to impurities, where nL is the unit normal vector [21]. Equating viscous dissipation with the work done by the normal force leads to the equation of motion h/t"J1#s2[2h/(1#s2)3@2#F#( f !sf )/J1#s2] , x h x
(22)
92
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
where h(x, t) denotes transverse displacement of the line and s, h. The nonlinearities generated x by J1#s2 are kinematic in origin20 and irrelevant as vP011, as can be seen easily by taking them to the left hand side of Eq. (22). The shape of the pinned FL is determined by the competition of the terms in the square brackets. Although there is no explicit simple s2 term in this group, it will be generated if the system is anisotropic. To illustrate the idea, let us take f and f to be independent random fields with amplitudes h x D1@2 and D1@2 respectively; each correlated isotropically in space within a distance a. For h x weak disorder, a deformation of order a in the normal direction nL takes place over a distance ¸
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
93
As emphasized above, the hallmark of anisotropic depinning is the dependence of the threshold force F (s) on the slope s. Above this threshold, we expect v(F, s) to be an analytical function of # F and s. In particular, for F'F (0), there is a small s expansion v(F, s)"v(F, s"0) # #j s2/2#2 . On the other hand, we can associate a characteristic slope sN "m /m &(dF)l(1~f), %&& M , to DP clusters where dF"F!F (0), and l is the correlation length exponent. Scaling then # suggests v(F, s)"(dF)hg(s/dFl(1~f)) ,
(23)
where h"l(z!f). Matching Eq. (23) with the small s expansion, we see that j diverges as (dF)~( %&& (as defined by ABS [17]) with /"2l(1!f)!h"l(2!f!z). In d"1, the exponents l and f are related to the correlation length exponents l and l of DP [24] via l"l +1.73 and , M , f"l /l +0.63, while the dynamical exponent is z"1. Scaling thus predicts /+0.63, in M , agreement with the numerical result of 0.64$0.08 in Ref. [17]. Close to the line F"F (0) (but at # a finite s), the dependence of v on dF drops out and we have v(F , s)JDsDh@l(1~f) . (24) # As z"1 in d"1, the above equation reduces to vJDsD, in agreement with Fig. 1 of Ref. [17]. Since v(F, s)"0 at F"F (s), Eq. (23) suggests # F (s)!F (0)J!DsD1@l(1~f) . (25) # # Note that Eqs. (24) and (25) are valid also in higher dimensions, though values of the exponents quoted above vary with d [24]. An interface tilted away from the hard direction not only has a different depinning threshold, but also completely different scaling behavior at its transition. This is because, due to the presence of an average interface gradient s"S+ hT, the isotropy in the internal x space is lost. The equation of motion for fluctuations, h@(x, t)"h(x, t)!s ) x, around the average interface position may thus include a non-zero i in Eq. (21). The resulting depinning transition belongs to yet a new universality class with anisotropic response and correlation functions in directions parallel and perpendicular to s; i.e.
G
Dx !x@ Df for x !x@"0 , , , t t Dx !x@Df@g for x !x@ "0 , t t , , where g is the ansiotropy exponent, and x denotes the d!1 directions transverse to s. t A suggestive mapping allows us to determine the exponents for depinning a tilted interface: consider the response to a perturbation in which all points along a (d!1)-dimensional cross section of the interface at a fixed x are pushed up by a small amount. This move decreases the , slope of the interface uphill but increases it downhill. Since F (s) decreases with increasing s, at # criticality the perturbation propagates only a finite distance uphill but causes a downhill avalanche. The disturbance front moves at a constant velocity (dx Jt) and hence z "1. (Such chains of , , moving sites were, indeed, seen in simulations of the d"2 model discussed below.) Furthermore, the evolution of successive cross-sections x (x ) is expected to be the same as the evolution in time t , of a (d!1)-dimensional interface! The latter is governed by the Kardar—Parisi—Zhang (KPZ) S[h(x)!h(x@)]2T"Dx !x@ DfF(Dx !x@D/Dx !x@ Dg) , , t t , ,
P
94
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
equation [20], whose scaling behavior has been extensively studied. From this analogy we conclude, f(d)"f
(d!1)/z (d!1), g(d)"1/z (d!1) . (26) KPZ KPZ KPZ In particular, the tilted interface with d"2 maps to the growth problem in 1#1 dimensions where the exponents are known exactly, yielding f(2)"1 and g(2)"2. This picture can be made more 3 3 precise for a lattice model introduced below. Details will be presented elsewhere. To get the exponent b for the vanishing of velocity of the tilted interface, we note that since z "1, v scales as the excess slope ds"s!s (F). The latter controls the density of the above , # moving fronts; s (F) is the slope of the critical interface at a given driving force F, i.e., F"F (s ). # # # Away from the symmetry direction, the function F (s) has a non-vanishing derivative and hence # dF"F!F (s)"F (s )!F (s)&ds&v . (27) # # # # We thus conclude that generically b"1 for tilted interfaces, independent of dimension. To check the above predictions, we performed simulations of the parallelized version of a previously studied percolation model of interface depinning [19]. A solid-on-solid (SOS) interface is described by a set of integer heights MhiN where i is a group of d integers. With each configuration is associated a random set of pinning forces Mgi3[0,1)N. The heights are updated in parallel according to the following rules: hi is increased by one if (i) hi4hj!2 for at least one j which is a nearest neighbor of i, or (ii) gi(F for a pre-selected uniform force F. If hi is increased, the associated random force gi is also updated, i.e. replaced by a new random number in the interval [0,1). Otherwise, hi and gi are unchanged. The simulation is started with initial conditions hi(t"0)"Int[si ], and boundary conditions hi#L"Int[s¸]#hi are enforced throughout. The x CPU time is greatly reduced by only keeping track of active sites. The above model has a simple analogy to a resistor-diode percolation problem [24]. Condition (i) ensures that, once a site (i, h) is wet (i.e., on or behind the interface), all neighboring columns of i must be wet up to height h!1. Thus, there is always “conduction” from a site at height h to sites in the neighboring columns at height h!1. This relation can be represented by diodes pointing diagonally downward. Condition (ii) implies that “conduction” may also occur upward. Hence, a fraction F of vertical bonds are turned into resistors which allow for two-way conduction. Note that, due to the SOS condition, vertical downward conduction is always possible. For F(F , conducting sites connected to a point lead at the origin, form a cone whose hull is the # interface separating wet and dry regions. The opening angle of the cone increases with F, reaching 180° at F"F , beyond which percolation in the entire space takes place, so that all sites are # eventually wet. If instead of a point, we start with a planar lead defining the initial surface, the percolation threshold depends on the surface orientation, with the highest threshold for the untilted one. Our simulations of lattices of 65 536 sites in d"1 and of 512]512 and 840]840 sites in d"2 confirm the exponents for depinning in the hard direction. For a tilted surface in d"1 the roughness exponent determined from the height—height correlation function is consistent with the predicted value of f"1 and different from f+0.63 of the untilted one. The dependence of the 2 depinning threshold on slope is clearly seen in the figure below, where the average velocity is plotted against the driving force for s"0 (open) and s"1 (solid) is shown in Fig. 3. The s"0 data 2 can be fitted to a power-law v&(F!F )h, where F +0.461, b"0.63$0.04 for d"1, and # #
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
95
Fig. 3. Average interface velocity v versus the driving force F, for d"1, s"0 (open circles), d"1, s"1 (solid circles), 2 d"2, s"0 (open squares), and d"2, s"1 (solid squares). 2
Fig. 4. Height—height correlation functions (a) along and (b) transverse to the tilt for an 8402 system at different times 324t41024. The interface at t"0 is flat; d"2, s"1, and F"0.144. 2
F +0.201, b"0.72$0.04 for d"2. Data at s"1 are consistent with Eq. (27) close to the # 2 threshold. We also measured height—height correlation functions at the depinning transition (Fig. 4). For a tilted surface in d"2, the height fluctuations and corresponding dynamic behaviors are different parallel and transverse to the tilt. The next figure shows a scaling plot of (a) C (r , t) , , ,S[h(x #r , x , t)!h(x , x , t)]2T and (b) C (r , t),S[h(x , x #r , t)!h(x , x , t)]2T against the , , t , t t t , t t , t scaled distances at the depinning threshold of an s"1 interface. Each curve shows data at a given 2 t"32, 64,2, 1024, averaged over 50 realizations of the disorder. The data collapse is in agreement with the mapping to the KPZ equation in one less dimension.
96
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
In summary, critical behavior at the depinning of an interface depends on the symmetries of the underlying medium. Different universality classes can be distinguished from the dependence of the threshold force (or velocity) on the slope, which is reminiscent of similar dependence in a model of resistor-diode percolation. In addition to isotropic depinning, we have so far identified two classes of anisotropic depinning: along a (hard) axis of inversion symmetry in the plane, and tilted away from it. We have no analytical results in the former case, but suggest a number of scaling relations that are validated by simulations. In the latter (more generic) case we have obtained exact information from a mapping to moving interfaces, and confirmed them by simulations in d"1 and 2. As it is quite common to encounter (intrinsic or artificially fabricated) anisotropy for flux lines in superconductors, domain walls in magnets, and interfaces in porous media, we expect our results to have important experimental ramifications. Another form of anisotropy is also possible for interfaces in 2#1 dimensions. If the directions x and y on the surface are not related by symmetry, the non-linear term in the KPZ equation can be generalized, leading to the depinning equation h"K 2r#K 2r#(j /2)( r)2#(j /2)( r)2#F#f (x, y, r) . (28) t x x y x x x y y In fact, the difference between K and K is not important as long as both are positive. It was first x y pointed out by Dietrich Wolf [25] that different signs of j and j lead to a different universality x y class for the case of annealed noise. More recently, it was demonstrated by Jeong et al. [26] that, with quenched noise, Eq. (28) describes a new universality class of depinning transitions with b+0.80(1), and anisotropic roughness exponents in the x and y directions. 2. Fluctuating lines 2.1. Flux line depinning The pinning of flux lines (FLs) in Type-II superconductors is of fundamental importance to many technological applications that require large critical currents [27]. Upon application of an external current density J, the motion of FLs due to the Lorentz force causes undesirable dissipation of supercurrents. Major increases in the critical current density J of a sample are # achieved when the FLs are pinned to impurities. There are many recent studies, both experimental [28,29] and theoretical [30,31], on collective pinning of FLs to point or columnar defects. Another consequence of impurities is the strongly non-linear behavior of the current slightly above the depinning threshold, as the FLs start to move across the sample. Recent numerical simulations have concentrated on the low-temperature behavior of a single FL near depinning [32,12,21], mostly ignoring fluctuations transverse to the plane defined by the magnetic field and the Lorentz force. Common signatures of the depinning transition from J(J to J'J include a broad-band # # ( f~a type) voltage noise spectrum, and self-similar fluctuations of the FL profile. The FL provides yet another example of a depinning transition. We now extend the methods of the previous section to the full three-dimensional dynamics of a single FL at low temperatures (Fig. 5). The shape of the FL at a given time t is described by r(x, t), where x is along the magnetic field B, and the unit vector e is along the Lorentz force F. Point impurities are modeled by , a random potential »(x, r), with zero mean and short-range correlations. In the presence of
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
97
Fig. 5. Geometry of the line in three dimensions.
impurities and a bulk Lorentz force F, the energy of a FL with small fluctuations is,
P G
H" dx
H
1 ( r)2#»(x, r(x, t))!r(x, t) ) F . 2 x
(29)
The simplest possible Langevin equation for the FL, consistent with local, dissipative dynamics, is k~1(r/t)"!dH/dr"2r#f (x, r(x, t))#F , (30) x where k is the mobility of the FL, and f"!+r». The potential »(x, r) need not be isotropic. For example, in a single crystal of ceramic superconductors with the field along the oxide planes, it will be easier to move the FL along the planes. This leads to a pinning threshold that depends on the orientation of the force. Anisotropy also modifies the line tension, and the elastic term in Eq. (30) is in general multiplied by a non-diagonal matrix K . The random force f (x, r), can be taken to have ab zero mean with correlations S f (x, r) f (x@, r@)T"d(x!x@)D (r!r@) . (31) a c ac We shall focus mostly on the isotropic case, with D (r!r@)"d D(Dr!r@D), where D is a function ac ac that decays rapidly for large values of its argument. While the flux line is pinned by impurities when F(F , for F slightly above threshold, we expect # the average velocity v"DD to scale as in Eq. (23). Superposed on the steady advance of the FL are rapid “jumps” as portions of the line depin from strong pinning centers. The cut-off length m on avalanche sizes diverges on approaching the threshold as m&(F!F )~l. At length scales up to m, # the correlated fluctuations satisfy the dynamic scaling forms, S[r (x, t)!r (0, 0)]2T"DxD2f,g (t/DxDz,) , , , , (32) S[r (x, t)!r (0, 0)]2T"DxD2fMg (t/DxDzM) , M M M where f and z are the roughness and dynamic exponents, respectively. The scaling functions g go a a a to a constant as their arguments approach 0. Beyond the length scale m, different regions of the FL
98
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
depin more or less independently and the system crosses over to a moving state, described by different exponents, which will be considered in the next section. The major difference of this model from the previously studied interface is that the position of the flux line, r(x, t), is now a two-dimensional vector instead of a scalar; fluctuating along both e and , e directions. One consequence is that a “no passing” rule [33], applicable to CDWs and interfaces, M does not apply to FLs. It is possible to have coexistence of moving and stationary FLs in particular realizations of the random potential. How do these transverse fluctuations scale near the depinning transition, and do they in turn influence the critical dynamics of longitudinal fluctuations near threshold? The answer to the second question can be obtained by the following qualitative argument: Consider Eq. (30) for a particular realization of randomness f (x, r). Assuming that portions of the FL always move in the forward direction, there is a unique point r (x, r ) that is M , visited by the line for given coordinates (x, r ). We construct a new force field f @ on a two, dimensional space (x, r ) through f @(x, r ),f (x, r ,r (x, r )). It is then clear that the dynamics , , , , M , of the longitudinal component r (x, t) in a given force field f (x, r) is identical to the dynamics of , r (x, t) in a force field f @(x, r ), with r set to zero. It is quite plausible that, after averaging over , , M all f, the correlations in f @ will also be short ranged, albeit different from those of f. Thus, the scaling of longitudinal fluctuations of the depinning FL will not change upon taking into account transverse fluctuations. However, the question of how these transverse fluctuations scale still remains. Certain statistical symmetries of the system restrict the form of response and correlation functions. For example, Eq. (30) has statistical space- and time-translational invariance, which enables us to work in Fourier space, i.e. (x, t)P(q, u). For an isotropic medium, F and are parallel to each other, i.e., (F)"v(F)FK , where FK is the unit vector along F. Furthermore, all expectation values involving odd powers of a transverse component are identically zero due to the statistical invariance under the transformation r P!r . Thus, linear response and two-point M M correlation functions are diagonal. The introduced critical exponents are then related through scaling identities. These can be derived from the linear response to an infinitesimal external force field e(q, u), s (q, u)"Sr (q, u)/e (q, u)T,d s (q, u) , ab a b ab a
(33)
in the (q, u)P(0, 0) limit. Eq. (30) is statistically invariant under the transformation FPF#e(q), r(q, u)Pr(q, u)#q~2e(q). Thus, the static linear response has the form s (q, u"0)"s (q, u"0)"q~2. Since e scales like the applied force, the form of the linear , M , response at the correlation length m gives the exponent identity f #1/l"2 . ,
(34)
Considering the transverse linear response seems to imply f "f . However, the static part of M , the transverse linear response is irrelevant at the critical RG fixed point, since z 'z , as shown M , below. When a slowly varying uniform external force e(t) is applied, the FL responds as if the instantaneous external force F#e is a constant, acquiring an average velocity, S r T"v (F#e)+v (F)#(v /F )e . ta a a a c c
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
99
Substituting v /F "dv/dF and v /F "v/F, and Fourier transforming, gives , , M M s (q"0, u)"1/[!iu(dv/dF)~1#O(u2)] , , (35) s (q"0, u)"1/[!iu(v/F)~1#O(u2)] . M Combining these with the static response, we see that the characteristic relaxation times of fluctuations with wavelength m are q (q"m~1)&(q2 dv/dF)~1&m2`(b~1)@l&mz, , , q (q"m~1)&(q2 v/F)~1&m2`b@l&mzM , M which, using Eq. (34), yield the scaling relations b"(z !f )l, z "z #1/l . (36) , , M , We already see that the dynamic relaxation of transverse fluctuations is much slower than longitudinal ones. All critical exponents can be calculated from f , f , and z , by using Eqs. (34) , M , and (36). Eq. (30) can be analyzed using the formalism of Martin, Siggia, and Rose (MSR) [10]. Ignoring transverse fluctuations, and generalizing to d-dimensional internal coordinates x3Rd, leads to an interface depinning model which was studied by Nattermann, Stepanow, Tang, and Leschhorn (NSTL) [8], and by Narayan and Fisher (NF) [11]. The RG treatment indicates that impurity disorder becomes relevant for dimensions d44, and the critical exponents in d"4!e dimensions are given to one-loop order as f"e/3, z"2!2e/9. NSTL obtained this result by directly averaging the MSR generating functional Z, and calculating the renormalization of the force—force correlation function D(r), perturbatively around the freely moving interface [D(r)"0]. NF, on the other hand, used a perturbative expansion of Z, around a saddle point corresponding to a meanfield approximation to Eq. (30) [34], which involved temporal force—force correlations C(vt). They argue that a conventional low-frequency analysis is not sufficient to determine critical exponents. They also suggest that the roughness exponent is equal to e/3 to all orders in perturbation theory. Following the approach of NF, we employ a perturbative expansion of the disorder-averaged MSR partition function around a mean-field solution for cusped impurity potentials [11]. All terms in the expansion involving longitudinal fluctuations are identical to the interface case, thus we obtain the same critical exponents for longitudinal fluctuations, i.e., f "e/3, , z "2!2e/9#O(e2). Furthermore, for isotropic potentials, the renormalization of transverse , temporal force—force correlations C (vt) yields a transverse roughness exponent f "5f /2!2, to M M , all orders in perturbation theory. For the FL (e"3), the critical exponents are then given by f "1, z +4, l"1, b+1, f "1, z +7 . (37) , , 3 3 M 2 M 3 To test the scaling forms and exponents predicted by Eqs. (23) and (32), we numerically integrated Eq. (30), discretized in coordinates x and t. Free boundary conditions were used for system sizes of up to 2048, with a grid spacing *x"1 and a time step *t"0.02 (Fig. 6). Time averages were evaluated after the system reached steady state. Periodic boundary conditions gave similar results, but with larger finite size effects. Smaller grid sizes did not change the results considerably. The behavior of v(F) seems to fit the scaling form of Eq. (23) with an exponent
100
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
Fig. 6. A plot of average velocity versus external force for a system of 2048 points. Statistical errors are smaller than symbol sizes. Both fits have three adjustable parameters: The threshold force, the exponent, and an overall multiplicative constant. Fig. 7. A plot of equal time correlation functions versus separation, for the system shown in Fig. 6, at F"0.95. The observed roughness exponents very closely follow the theoretical predictions of f "1, f "0.5, which are shown as , M solid lines for comparison.
b+0.3, but is also consistent with a logarithmic dependence on the reduced force, i.e., b"0. The same behavior was observed by Dong et al. in a recent simulation of the 1#1 dimensional geometry [12]. Since z , and consequently b, is known only to first order in e, higher-order , corrections are expected. By looking at equal time correlation functions, we find that transverse fluctuations are strongly suppressed, and that the roughness exponents are equal to our theoretical estimates within statistical accuracy. The excellent agreement for e"3 suggests that the theoretical estimates are indeed exact. The potential pinning the FL in a single superconducting crystal is likely to be highly anisotropic. For example, consider a magnetic field parallel to the copper oxide planes of a ceramic superconductor. The threshold force then depends on its orientation, with depinning easiest along the copper oxide planes. In general, the average velocity may depend on the orientations of the external force and the FL. The most general gradient expansion for the equation of motion is then, r /t"k F #i r #K 2r #1K r r #f (x, r(x, t))#2 a ab b ab x b ab x b 2 a,bc x b x c a
(38)
with S f (x, r) f (x@, r@)T"d(x!x@)C (r!r@) . (39) a b ab Depending on the presence or absence of various terms allowed by the symmetries of the system, the above set of equations encompasses many distinct universality classes. For example, consider the situation where depends on F, but not on the orientation of the line. Eq. (35) have to be
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
101
modified, since and F are no longer parallel (except along the axes with rP!r symmetry), and the linear response function is not diagonal. The RG analysis is more cumbersome: For depinning along a non-symmetric direction, the longitudinal exponents are not modified (in agreement with the argument presented earlier), while the transverse fluctuations are further suppressed to f "2f !2 (equal to zero for f "1) [35] (Fig. 7). Relaxation of transverse modes are still M , , characterized by z "z #1/l, and the exponent identity (Eq. (34)) also holds. Surprisingly, the M , exponents for depinning along axes of reflection symmetry are the same as the isotropic case. If the velocity also depends on the tilt, there will be additional relevant terms in the MSR partition function, which invalidate the arguments leading to Eq. (34). The analogy to FLs in a planes suggests that the longitudinal exponents for d"1 are controlled by DP clusters [19,14], with f +0.63. Since no perturbative fixed point is present in this case, it is not clear how to explore , the behavior of transverse fluctuations systematically. 2.2. Dynamic fluctuations of an unpinned flux line So far, we investigated the dynamics of a flux line near the depinning transition. Now, we would like to consider its behavior in a different regime, when the external driving force is large, and the impurities appear as weak barriers that deflect portions of the line without impeding its overall drift. In such non-equilibrium systems, one can regard the evolution equations as more fundamental, and proceed by constructing the most general equations consistent with the symmetries and conservation laws of the situation under study [36]. Even in a system with isotropic randomness, which we will discuss here, the average drift velocity, v, breaks the symmetry between forward and backward motions, and allows introduction of nonlinearities in the equations of motion [37,36]. Let us first concentrate on an interface in two dimensions (Fig. 1). By contracting up to two spatial derivatives of r, and keeping terms that are relevant, one obtains the Kardar—Parisi—Zhang [20] (KPZ) equation, r(x, t)"kF#K2r(x, t)#(j/2)[ r(x, t)]2#f (x, t) t x x with random force correlations S f (x, t) f (x@, t@)T"2¹d(x!x@)d(t!t@) .
(40)
(41)
For a moving line, the term proportional to the external force can be absorbed, without loss of generality, by considering a suitable Galilean transformation, rPr!at, to a moving frame. A large number of stochastic non-equilibrium growth models, like the Eden model and various ballistic deposition models are known to be well described, at large length scales and times, by this equation, which is intimately related to several other problems. For example, the transformation v(x, t)"!j r(x, t) maps Eq. (40) to the randomly stirred Burgers’ equation for fluid flow [38,39], x v#v v"K2v!j f (x, t) . (42) t x x x The correlations of the line profile still satisfy the dynamic scaling form in Eq. (5), nevertheless, with different scaling exponents f, z and scaling function g. This self-affine scaling is not critical, i.e., not obtained by fine tuning an external parameter like the force, and is quite different in nature
102
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
than the critical scaling of the line near the depinning transition, which ceases beyond the correlation length scale m. Two important nonperturbative properties of Eq. (40) help us determine these exponents exactly in 1#1 dimensions: 1. Galilean invariance (GI): Eq. (40) is statistically invariant under the infinitesimal reparametrization r@"r#ex, x@"x#jet, t@"t ,
(43)
provided that the random force f does not have temporal correlations [40]. Since the parameter j appears both in the transformation and Eq. (40), it is not renormalized under any RG procedure that preserves this invariance. This implies the exponent identity [39,40] f#z"2 .
(44)
2. Fluctuation—dissipation (FD) theorem: Eqs. (40) and (41) lead to a Fokker—Planck equation for the evolution of the joint probability P[r(x)],
P A
B
d2P dP P" dx r#¹ . t [dr(x)]2 dr(x) t
(45)
It is easy to check that P has a stationary solution
A
P
B
K P"exp ! dx ( r)2 . x 2¹
(46)
If P converges to this solution, the long-time behavior of the correlation functions in Eq. (5) can be directly read off Eq. (46), giving f"1. 2 Combining these two results, the roughness and dynamic exponents are exactly determined for the line in two dimensions as f"1, z"3 . (47) 2 2 Many direct numerical simulations and discrete growth models have verified these exponents to a very good accuracy. Exact exponents for the isotropic KPZ equation are not known in higher dimensions, since the FD property is only valid in two dimensions. These results have been summarized in a number of recent reviews [41—44]. As an aside we remark that some exact information is available for the anisotropic KPZ equation in 2#1 dimensions. Using a perturbative RG approach, Wolf showed [25] that in the equation r"K+ 2r#(j /2)( r)2#(j /2)( r)2#f (x, y, t) , (48) t x x y y the non-linearities Mj , j N renormalize to zero if they initially have opposite signs. This suggests x y logarithmic fluctuations for the resulting interface, as in the case of the linear Langevin equation. In fact, it is straightforward to demonstrate that Eq. (48) also satisfies a Fluctuation—Dissipation condition if j "!j . When this condition is satisfied, the associated Fokker—Planck equation x y has a steady-state solution
A
P
B
K P"exp ! dx dy (+r)2 . 2¹
(49)
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
103
This is a non-perturbative result which again indicates the logarithmic fluctuations resulting from Eq. (48). In this context, it is interesting to note that the steady state distribution for an exactly solvable discrete model of surface growth belonging to the above universality class has also been obtained [45]. Let us now turn to the case of a line in three dimensions (Fig. 5). Fluctuations of the line can be indicated by a two-dimensional vector r. Even in an isotropic medium, the drift velocity breaks the isotropy in r by selecting a direction. A gradient expansion up to second order for the equation of motion gives [46] r "[K d #K v v ]2r #[j (d v #d v )#j v d #j v v v ]( r r /2)#f (50) ta 1 ab 2 a b x b 1 ab c ac b 2 a bc 3 a b c xb xc a with random force correlations S f (x, t) f (x@, t@)T"2[¹ d #¹ v v ]d(x!x@)d(t!t@) . (51) a b 1 ab 2 a b Higher-order non-linearities can be similarly constructed but are, in fact, irrelevant. In terms of components parallel and perpendicular to the velocity, the equations are r "K 2r #(j /2)( r )2#(j /2)( r )2#f (x, t) , t, , x , , x, C xM , r "K 2r #j r r #f (x, t) , tM M x M M x, xM M
(52)
with S f (x, t) f (x@, t@)T"2¹ d(x!x@)d(t!t@) , , , , S f (x, t) f (x@, t@)T"2¹ d(x!x@)d(t!t@) . M M M The noise-averaged correlations have a dynamic scaling form like Eq. (32),
(53)
S[r (x, t)!r (x@, t@)]2T"Dx!x@D2f,g (Dt!t@D/Dx!x@Dz,) , , , , (54) S[r (x, t)!r (x@, t@)]2T"Dx!x@D2fMg (Dt!t@D/Dx!x@DzM) . M M M In the absence of non-linearities (j "j "j "0), Eq. (52) can easily be solved to give , C M f "f "1 and z "z "2. Simple dimensional counting indicates that all three non-linear terms , M 2 , M are relevant and may modify the exponents in Eq. (54). Studies of related stochastic equations [47,25] indicate that interesting dynamic phase diagrams may emerge from the competition between nonlinearities. Let us assume that j is positive and finite (its sign can be changed by , r P!r ), and focus on the dependence of the scaling exponents on the ratios j /j and j /j , as , , M , C , depicted in Fig. 8. (It is more convenient to set the vertical axis to j K ¹ /j K ¹ .) C M M , M , The properties discussed for the KPZ equation can be extended to this higher-dimensional case: 1. Galilean invariance (GI): Consider the infinitesimal reparametrization x@"x#j et, t@"t, r@ "r #ex, r@ "r . (55) , , , M M Eq. (52) are invariant under this transformation provided that j "j . Thus along this line in , M Fig. 8 there is GI, which once more implies the exponent identity f #z "2 . , ,
(56)
104
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
Fig. 8. A projection of RG flows in the parameter space, for n"1 transverse components.
2. Fluctuation—Dissipation (FD) condition: The Fokker—Planck equation for the evolution of the joint probability P[r (x), r (x)] has a stationary solution , M
A P C
K K , ( r )2# M ( r )2 P Jexp ! dx 0 2¹ x M 2¹ x , M ,
DB
,
(57)
provided that j K ¹ "j K ¹ . Thus, for this special choice of parameters, depicted by C , M M M , a starred line in Fig. 8, if P converges to this solution, the long-time behavior of the correlation functions in Eq. (54) can be directly read off Eq. (57) giving f "f "1. , M 2 3. ¹he Cole—Hopf (CH) transformation is an important method for the exact study of solutions of the one component non-linear diffusion equation [38]. Here we generalize this transformation to the complex plane by defining, for j (0, C
A
W(x, t)"exp
B
j r (x, t)#iJ!j j r (x, t) ,, , CM . 2K
(58)
The linear diffusion equation W"K2W#k(x, t)W , t x then leads to Eq. (52) if K "K "K and j "j . [Here Re(k)"j f /2K and Im(k)" , M , M , , J!j j f /2K.] This transformation enables an exact solution of the deterministic equation, and , CM further allows us to write the solution to the stochastic equation in the form of a path integral
P
W(x, t)"
(x, t)
G P C
DH
t xR 2 #k(x, q) Dx(q)exp ! dq 2K (0, 0) 0
.
(59)
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
105
Eq. (59) has been extensively studied in connection with quantum tunneling in a disordered medium [48] with W representing the wave function. In particular, results for the tunneling probability DWD2 suggest z "3 and f "1. The transverse fluctuations correspond to the phase in , 2 , 2 the quantum problem which is not an observable. Hence, this mapping does not provide any information on f and z which are, in fact, observable for the moving line. M M At the point j "j "0, r and r decouple, and z "2 while z "3. However, in general, M C , M M , 2 z "z "z unless the effective j is zero. For example, at the intersection of the subspaces with GI , M M and FD the exponents z "z "3 are obtained from the exponent identities. Dynamic RG , M 2 recursion relations can be computed to one-loop order [46,49], by standard methods of momentum-shell dynamic RG [39,40]. The renormalization of the seven parameters in Eq. (52), generalized to n transverse directions, give the recursion relations
C C
D
dK 1 j2 ¹ 1j j ¹ ,"K z!2# , ,#n M C M , , dl p 4K3 p 4K K2 , , M dK 1 j ((j ¹ /K )#(j ¹ /K )) M"K z!2# M C M M M , , M dl 2K (K #K ) p M M ,
D
1 K !K j ((j ¹ /K )!(j ¹ /K )) M , M C M M M , , , # K (K #K ) p K #K M , M M ,
C C
D
d¹ 1 j2 ¹ 1 j2 ¹2 ,"¹ z!2f !1# , , #n C M , , , dl p 4K3 p 4K3 , M
D
d¹ 1 j2 ¹ M"¹ z!2f !1# M , , M M dl p K K (K #K ) M , M , dj ,"j [f #z!2] , , , dl
C C
(60)
D
dj 1 j !j M"j f #z!2! , M ((j ¹ /K )!(j ¹ /K )) , M , M , , dl p (K #K )2 C M M M ,
D
dj 1 j K !j K , M M , ((j ¹ /K )!(j ¹ /K )) . C"j 2f !f #z!2# C M , M , , dl p K K (K #K ) C M M M , M , The projections of the RG flows on the two-parameter subspace shown in Fig. 8 are indicated by trajectories. They naturally satisfy the constraints imposed by the non-perturbative results: the subspace of GI is closed under RG, while the FD condition appears as a fixed line. The RG flows, and the corresponding exponents, are different in each quadrant of Fig. 8, which implies that the scaling behavior is determined by the relative signs of the three non-linearities. This was confirmed by numerical integrations [46,49] of Eq. (52), performed for different sets of parameters. A summary of the computed exponents are given in Table 1.
106
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
Table 1 Numerical estimates of the scaling exponents, for various values of model parameters for n"1. In all cases, K "K "1 , M and ¹ "¹ "0.01, unless indicated otherwise. Typical error bars are $0.05 for f, $0.01 for z/f. Entries in brackets , M are theoretical results. Exact values are given in fractional form j ,
j C
j M
f ,
z /f , ,
f M
z /f M M
20
20
20
0.48 (1/2)
3.0 (3)
0.48 (1/2)
3.0 (3)
20 20
20 5
2.5 25
0.75 0.51
1.7 3.4
0.50 0.56
3.7 2.9
5
5
!5
0.83
unstable 0.44 (No fixed point for finite f, z)
3.6
20
!20
!20
0.50 (1/2)
3.1 (3)
0.50 (1/2)
2.9 (3)
5
!5
5
0.52 (1/2)
3.3 (3)
0.57 (Strong coupling)
3.4
20
0
20
0.49 (1/2)
3.1 (3)
0.72 (0.75)
2.2 (2)
20
0
!20
0.48 (1/2)
3.0 (3)
0.65
1.4
0.50 (1/2)
4.0 (4)
2.9
0.51 (1/2)
4.0 (4)
20
20
0
0.84 (z (z ) , M
20
!20
0
0.55 (z (z ) , M
3.1 (z 'z ) M ,
The analysis of analytical and numerical results can be summarized as follows: j j '0: In this region, the scaling behavior is understood best. The RG flows terminate on the M C fixed line where FD conditions apply, hence, f "f "1. All along this line, the one-loop RG , , 2 exponent is z"3. These results are consistent with the numerical simulations. The measured 2 exponents rapidly converge to these values, except when j or j are small. M C j "0: In this case the equation for r is the KPZ equation (40), thus f "1 and z "3. The C , , 2 , 2 fluctuations in r act as a strong (multiplicative and correlated) noise on r . The one-loop RG , M yields the exponents z "3, f "0.75 for j '0, while a negative j scales to 0 suggesting M M M 2 , z 'z . Simulations are consistent with the RG calculations for j '0, yielding f "0.72, M M M M surprisingly close to the one-loop RG value. For j (0, simulations indicate z +2 and f +2 M M M 3 along with the expected values for the longitudinal exponents. j "0: The transverse fluctuations satisfy a simple diffusion equation with f "1 and z "2. M M 2 M Through the term j ( r )2/2, these fluctuations act as a correlated noise [40] for the longitudinal C xM mode. A naive application of the results of this reference [40] give f "2 and z "4. Quite , 3 , 3 surprisingly, simulations indicate different behavior depending on the sign of j . For j (0, C C z +3 and f +1 whereas for j '0, longitudinal fluctuations are much stronger, resulting in , 2 , 2 C
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
107
z +1.18 and f +0.84. Actually, f increases steadily with system size, suggesting a breakdown of , , , dynamic scaling, due to a change of sign in j j . This dependence on the sign of j may reflect the M C C fundamental difference between behavior in quadrants II and IV of Fig. 8. j (0 and j '0: The analysis of this region (II) is the most difficult in that the RG flows do not M C converge upon a finite fixed point and j P0, which may signal the breakdown of dynamic scaling. M Simulations indicate strong longitudinal fluctuations that lead to instabilities in the discrete integration scheme, excluding the possibility of measuring the exponents reliably. j '0 and j (0: The projected RG flows in this quadrant (IV) converge to the point j /j "1 M C M , and j ¹ K /j ¹ K "!1. This is actually not a fixed point, as K and K scale to infinity. The C M , , , M , M applicability of the CH transformation to this point implies z "3 and f "1. Since j is finite, , 2 , 2 M z "z "3 is expected, but this does not give any information on f . Simulations indicate strong M M , 2 transverse fluctuations and suffer from difficulties similar to those in region II. Eq. (52) are the simplest non-linear, local, and dissipative equations that govern the fluctuations of a moving line in a random medium. They can be easily generalized to describe the time evolution of a manifold with arbitrary internal (x3Rd) and external (r3Rn`1) dimensions, and to the motion of curves that are not necessarily stretched in a particular direction. Since the derivation only involves general symmetry arguments, the given results are widely applicable to a number of seemingly unrelated systems. We will discuss one application to drifting polymers in more detail in the next lecture, explicitly demonstrating the origin of the non-linear terms starting from more fundamental hydrodynamic equations. A simple model of crack front propagation in three dimensions [50] also arrives at Eq. (52), implying the self-affine structure of the crack surface after the front has passed. 2.3. Drifting polymers The dynamics of polymers in fluids is of much theoretical interest and has been extensively studied [51,52]. The combination of polymer flexibility, interactions, and hydrodynamics make a first principles approach to the problem quite difficult. There are, however, a number of phenomenological studies that describe various aspects of this problem [53]. One of the simplest is the Rouse model [54]: The configuration of the polymer at time t is described by a vector R(x, t), where x3[0, N] is a continuous variable replacing the discrete monomer index (see Fig. 9). Ignoring inertial effects, the relaxation of the polymer in a viscous medium is approximated by R(x, t)"kF(R(x, t))"K2R(x, t)#g(x, t) , (61) t x where k is the mobility. The force F has a contribution from interactions with near neighbors that are treated as springs. Steric and other interactions are ignored. The effect of the medium is represented by the random forces g with zero mean. The Rouse model is a linear Langevin equation that is easily solved. It predicts that the mean square radius of gyration, R2"SDR!SRTD2T, is ' proportional to the polymer size N, and the largest relaxation times scale as the fourth power of the wave number, (i.e., in dynamic light scattering experiments, the half-width at half-maximum of the scattering amplitude scales as the fourth-power of the scattering wave vector q). These results can be summarized as R &Nl and C(q)&qz, where l and z are called the swelling and dynamic ' exponents, respectively [55]. Thus, for the Rouse model, l"1 and z"4. 2
108
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
Fig. 9. The configuration of a polymer.
The Rouse model ignores hydrodynamic interactions mediated by the fluid. These effects were originally considered by Kirkwood and Risemann [56] and later on by Zimm [57]. The basic idea is that the motion of each monomer modifies the flow field at large distances. Consequently, each monomer experiences an additional velocity
P
P
1 F(x@)r2 #(F(x@) ) r )r c xx{ xx{ xx{+ dx@ d R(x, t)" dx@ 2R , (62) H t 8pg Dr D3 Dx!x@Dl x 4 xx{ where r "R(x)!R(x@) and the final approximation is obtained by replacing the actual distance xx{ between two monomers by their average value. The modified equation is still linear in R and easily solved. The main result is the speeding up of the relaxation dynamics as the exponent z changes from 4 to 3. Most experiments on polymer dynamics [58], indeed, measure exponents close to 3. Rouse dynamics is still important in other circumstances, such as diffusion of a polymer in a solid matrix, stress and viscoelasticity in concentrated polymer solutions, and is also applicable to relaxation times in Monte Carlo simulations. Since both of these models are linear, the dynamics remains invariant in the center of mass coordinates upon the application of a uniform external force. Hence, the results for a drifting polymer are identical to a stationary one. This conclusion is in fact not correct due to the hydrodynamic interactions. For example, consider a rod-like conformation of the polymer with monomer length b where R "b t everywhere on the polymer, so that the elastic (Rouse) force 0 x a 0a vanishes. If a uniform force E per monomer acts on this rod, the velocity of the rod can be solved using Kirkwood theory, and the result is [51] "[(!ln i)/4pg b ]E ) [I#tt] . (63) 4 0 In the above equation, g is the solvent viscosity, t is the unit tangent vector, i"2b/b N is the ratio 4 0 of the width b to the half-length b N/2 of the polymer. A more detailed calculation of the velocity in 0
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
109
the more general case of an arbitrarily shaped slender body by Khayat and Cox [59] shows that non-local contributions to the hydrodynamic force, which depend on the whole shape of the polymer rather than the local orientation, are O(1/(ln i)2). Therefore, corrections to Eq. (63) are small when N
110
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
different scaling regimes correspond to actual physical situations. The scaling results found by the RG analysis are verified by direct integration of equations, as mentioned in the earlier lectures. A more detailed discussion of the analysis and results can be found in our earlier work [49]. In constructing equations Eq. (64), we only allowed for local effects, and ignored the nonlocalities that are the hallmark of hydrodynamics. One consequence of hydrodynamic interactions is the back-flow velocity in Eq. (62) that can be added to the evolution equations Eq. (64). Dimensional analysis gives the recursion relation c/l"c[lz!1!(d!2)l]#O(c2) ,
(66)
which implies that, at the non-linear fixed point, this additional term is surprisingly irrelevant for d'3, and z"3 due to the non-linearities. For d(3, z"d due to hydrodynamics, and the non-linear terms are irrelevant. The situation in three dimensions is unclear, but a change in the exponents is unlikely. Similarly, one could consider the effect of self-avoidance by including the force generated by a softly repulsive contact potential
P
b dx dx@ V(r(x)!r(x@)) . 2
(67)
The relevance of this term is also controlled by the scaling dimension y "lz!1!(d!2)l, and b therefore this effect is marginal in three dimensions at the non-linear fixed point, in contrast with both Rouse and Zimm models where self-avoidance becomes relevant below four dimensions. Unfortunately, one is ultimately forced to consider non-local and non-linear terms based on similar grounds, and such terms are, indeed, relevant below four dimensions. In some cases, local or global arclength conservation may be an important consideration in writing down a dynamics for the system. However, a local description is likely to be more correct in a more complicated system with screening effects (motion in a gel that screens hydrodynamic interactions) where a first principles approach becomes even more intractable. Therefore, this model is an important starting point towards understanding the scaling behavior of polymers under a uniform drift, a problem with great technological importance.
Acknowledgements The work described here is part of the doctoral thesis of Deniz Ertas in the Physics Department of MIT. Financial support from the NSF through grant number DMR-93-03667 is gratefully acknowledged.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
H. Fukuyama, P.A. Lee, Phys. Rev. B 17 (1978) 535; P.A. Lee, T.M. Rice, Phys. Rev. B 19 (1979) 3970. R. Bruinsma, G. Aeppli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 52 (1984) 1547; J. Koplik, H. Levine, Phys. Rev. B 32 (1985) 280. P.G. de Gennes, Rev. Mod. Phys. 57 (1985) 827. J.F. Joanny, P.G. de Gennes, J. Chem. Phys. 81 (1984) 552. D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50 (1983) 1486.
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112 [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45]
111
P. Bak, C. Tang, K. Wiesenfeld, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 381; Phys. Rev. A 38 (1988) 364. D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 31 (1985) 1396; O. Narayan, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992) 11 520. T. Nattermann, S. Stepanow, L.H. Tang, H. Leschhorn, J. Phys. II France 2 (1992) 1483. Y. Imry, S.K. Ma, Phys. Rev. Lett. 35 (1975) 1399. P.C. Martin, E. Siggia, H. Rose, Phys. Rev. A 8 (1973) 423. O. Narayan, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993) 7030. M. Dong, M.C. Marchetti, A.A. Middleton, V. Vinokur, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 662. The identification of the exponent f"1 from correlation function has been questioned by H. Leschhorn, L.-H. Tang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 2973. M.A. Rubio, C.A. Edwards, A. Dougherty, J.P Gollub, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63 (1989) 1685; V.K. Horva´th, F. Family, T. Vicsek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 3207; S. He, G.L.M.K.S. Kahanda, P.-Z. Wong, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69 (1992) 3731. S.V. Buldyrev, A.-L. Barabasi, F. Caserta, S. Havlin, H.E. Stanley, T. Vicsek, Phys. Rev. A 45 (1992) R8313. F. Family, K.C.B. Chan, J.G. Amar, Surface Disordering: Growth, Roughening and Phase Transitions, Les Houches Series, Nova Science Publishers, New York, 1992. H. Leschhorn, Physica A 195 (1993) 324. L.A.N. Amaral, A.-L. Barabasi, H.E. Stanley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73 (1994) 62. H. Ji, M.O. Robbins, Phys. Rev. B 44 (1991) 2538; B. Koiller, H. Ji, M.O. Robbins, Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992) 5258. L.H. Tang, H. Leschhorn, Phys. Rev. A 45 (1992) R8309. M. Kardar, G. Parisi, Y.C. Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56 (1986) 889. C. Tang, S. Feng, L. Golubovic, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72 (1994) 1264. S. Stepanow, J. Phys. II France 5 (1995) 11. Z. Chaho´k, K. Honda, T. Vicsek, J. Phys. A 26 (1993) L171; S. Galluccio, Y.-C. Zhang, Phys. Rev. E 51 (1995) 1686; H. Leschhorn, cond-mat 9605018. D. Dhar, M. Barma, M.K. Phani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 47 (1981) 1238; D. Dhar, J. Phys. A 15 (1982) 1859; S.V. Buldyrev, S. Havlin, H.E. Stanley, Physica 200 (1993) 200; and references therein. D. Wolf, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 1783. H. Jeong, B. Kahng, D. Kim, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 5094. See, for example, G. Blatter, M.V. Feigel’man, V.B. Geshkenbein, A.I. Larkin, V.M. Vinokur, Rev. Mod. Phys. 66 (1994) 1125; and references therein. R.H. Koch et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 63 (1989) 1511; P.L. Gammel, L.F. Schneemener, D.J. Bishop, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 953. L. Civale et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 648; M. Leghissa et al., Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993) 1341. D.S. Fisher, M.P.A. Fisher, D.A. Huse, Phys. Rev. B 43 (1991) 130. D.R. Nelson, V.M. Vinokur, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68 (1992) 2398. Y. Enomoto, Phys. Lett. A 161 (1991) 185; Y. Enomoto, K. Katsumi, R. Kato, S. Maekawa, Physica C 192 (1992) 166. A.A. Middleton, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 92; Phys. Rev. B 47 (1993) 3530. H. Sompolinsky, A. Zippelius, Phys. Rev. B 25 (1982) 6860; A. Zippelius, Phys. Rev. B 29 (1984) 2717. In this case, the longitudinal direction is chosen to be along the average velocity v, not the Lorentz force F. M. Kardar, in: J.C. Charmet, S. Roux, E. Guyon (Eds.), Disorder and Fracture, Plenum, New York, 1990; T. Hwa, M. Kardar, Phys. Rev. A 45 (1992) 7002. M. Plischke, Z. Ra´cz, D. Liu, Phys. Rev. B 35 (1987) 3485. J.M. Burgers, The Nonlinear Diffusion Equation, Riedel, Boston, 1974. D. Forster, D.R. Nelson, M.J. Stephen, Phys. Rev. A 16 (1977) 732. E. Medina, T. Hwa, M. Kardar, Y. Zhang, Phys. Rev. A 39 (1989) 3053. F. Family, T. Vicsek (Eds.), Dynamics of Fractal Surfaces, World Scientific, Singapore, 1991. J. Krug, H. Spohn, in: C. Godreche (Eds.), Solids Far From Equilibrium: Growth, Morphology and Defects, edited by Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991. T. Halpin-Healy, Y.-C. Zhang, Phys. Rep. 254 (1995) 215. A.L. Barabasi, H.E. Stanley, Fractal Concepts in Surface Growth, CUP, Cambridge, 1995. M. Prahofer, H. Spohn, J. Stat. Phys. (1997), in press.
112
M. Kardar / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 85—112
[46] D. Ertas, M. Kardar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69 (1992) 929. [47] T. Hwa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69 (1992) 1552. [48] E. Medina, M. Kardar, Y. Shapir, X.-R. Wang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 (1989) 941; E. Medina, M. Kardar, Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992) 9984. [49] D. Ertas, M. Kardar, Phys. Rev. E 48 (1993) 1228. [50] J.P. Bouchaud, E. Bouchaud, G. Lapasset, J. Planes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993) 2240. [51] M. Doi, S.F. Edwards, Theory of Polymer Dynamics, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1986. [52] P.G. de Gennes, Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY, 1979. [53] R.B. Bird, Dynamics of Polymeric Physics, vols. 1—2, Wiley, New York, 1987. [54] P.E. Rouse, J. Chem. Phys. 21 (1953) 1272. [55] We have changed the notation to confer with the traditions of polymer science. l is f and z is z/f in terms of the notation used previously. [56] J. Kirkwood, J. Risemann, J. Chem. Phys. 16 (1948) 565. [57] B.H. Zimm, J. Chem. Phys. 24 (1956) 269. [58] See, for example, M. Adam, M. Delsanti, Macromolecules 10 (1977) 1229. [59] R.E. Khayat, R.G. Cox, J. Fluid. Mech. 209 (1989) 435.
Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
Collective transport in random media: from superconductors to earthquakes Daniel S. Fisher* Physics Department, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
Abstract In these lectures, a variety of non-equilibrium transport phenomena are introduced that all involve, in some way, elastic manifolds being driven through random media. A simple class of models is studied focussing on the behavior near to the critical “depinning” force above which persistent motion occurs in these systems. A simple mean field theory and a “toy” model of “avalanche” processes are analyzed and used to motivate the general scaling picture found in recent renormalization group studies. The general ideas and results are then applied to various systems: sliding charge density waves, critical current behavior of vortices in superconductors, dynamics of cracks, and simple models of a geological fault. The roles of thermal fluctuations, defects, inertia, and elastic wave propagation are all discussed briefly. ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 05.60.#w
1. Introduction Many phenomena in nature involve transport of material or some other quantity from one region of space to another. In some cases transport occurs in systems that are close to equilibrium with the transport representing only a small perturbation such as flow or electrical current in a metal, while in other cases it involves systems that are far from equilibrium such as a land-slide down a mountain, or a drop of water sliding down an irregular surface. Sometimes, particles or other constituents move relatively independently of each other like the electrons in a metal, while in other situations the interactions play an important role, as in the landslide and the water droplet. If the interactions are strong enough, all the particles (or other constituents) move together and the macroscopic dynamics involves only a small number of degrees of freedom. This is the case for a small water drop on, e.g. wax paper, which slides around while retaining its shape. But if the * Fax: #1 617 495-0416; e-mail: [email protected]. 0370-1573/98/$19.00 ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved PII S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 9 8 ) 0 0 0 0 8 - 8
114
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
interactions are not so strong relative to the other forces acting on the constituents, then the transport involves in an essential way many interacting degrees of freedom. This is the case for a larger water drop on an irregular surface for which the contact line between the droplet and the surface continually deforms and adjusts its shape in response to the competition between the surface tension of the water and the interactions with the substrate [1,2]. Such a moving drop and the landslide are examples of non-equilibrium collective transport phenomena, which will be the general subject of these lectures. This is, of course, an impossibly broad subject! We must thus narrow the scope drastically. Although the range of systems discussed here will, nevertheless, be reasonably broad, we will primarily focus on systems in which the interactions are strong enough so that the transported object (or at least some part of it) is elastic. We will use this in a general and somewhat loose sense that the transported object has enough integrity that if one part of it moves a long distance then so, eventually, must the other parts as well. Thus, the fluid drop is elastic if it does not break up — i.e. its perimeter retains its integrity — while a landslide is not elastic as some rocks will fall much further than others and the relative positions of the rocks will be completely jumbled by the landslide. We will be interested in systems in which the medium in which the transport occurs has static random heterogeneities (“quenched randomness”) which exert forces on the transported object that depend on where it is in space. Examples we will discuss are: interfaces between two phases in random media [3,4], such as between two fluids in a porous medium [5], or domain walls in a random ferromagnetic alloy; lattices of vortices in dirty type II superconductors [6]; charge density waves which are spatially periodic modulations of the electron density that occur in certain solids [7—9]; and the motion of geological faults [10,11]. In addition to the contact line of the fluid drop already mentioned [1,2], another well known — but poorly understood — example that we will, however, not discuss is solid-on-solid friction. In all of these systems, a driving force, call it F, can be applied which acts to try to make the object move, but this will be resisted by the random “pinning” forces exerted by the medium or substrate. The primary questions of interest will involve the response of the system to such an applied driving force [12]. If F is small, then one might guess that it will not be sufficient to overcome the resistance of the pinning forces; sections of the object would just move a bit and it would deform in response to F, but would afterwards be at rest. (Note that in most of what follows, we will ignore fluctuations so that the motion is deterministic and the objects can be said to be stationary.) If the force is increased, some segment might go unstable and move only to be stopped by stronger pinning regions or neighboring segments. But for large enough F, it should be possible to overcome the pinning forces — unless they are so strong that the object is broken up, an issue we will return to at the end — and the object will move, perhaps attaining some steady state velocity v. Basic questions one might ask are: is there a unique, history independent force, F separating the # static from the moving regimes? How does v depend on F (and possibly on history)? Are there some kinds of non-equilibrium critical phenomena when v is small? How does the system respond to an additional time or space dependent applied force? These are all macroscopic properties of the system. But we will also be interested in some microscopic properties: how can one characterize (statistically) the deformations of the object when it is stationary [13]? The dynamic deformations and local velocities when it is moving? The response to a small local perturbation? etc.
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
115
Motivated by possible analogies with equilibrium phase transitions [14], we can ask if there are scaling laws that might obtain near a critical force which relate, for example, the characteristic length scale ¸, for some process, to its characteristic time scale, q, via a power-law relation of the form q&¸z .
(1)
Trying to answer some of these questions — and to pose other more pointed questions — is the main aim of these lectures. In the next few sections a particular system and its natural (theoretical) generalizations will be studied and tools and ideas developed. In the last section, these are tentatively applied to various physical systems and some of the complicating features left out of the simple model systems are discussed. This leads naturally to many open questions.
2. Interfaces and models In order to develop some of the general ideas — both conceptual and computational — we will focus initially on an interface between two phases that is driven by an applied force through an inhomogenous medium [3,4]. The essential ingredients of a model of this system are: the forces of sections of the interface on nearby sections, i.e. the elasticity of the interface caused by its interfacial tension; the preference of the interface for some regions of the system over others due to the random heterogeneities; and some dynamical law which governs the time evolution of the local interface position. We will initially make several simplifying approximations, which we will come back and examine later. First, we assume that the interface is not too distorted away from a flat surface normal to the direction (z) of the driving force so that its configuration can be represented by its displacement field u(r) away from a flat reference surface. The coordinates R"(x, y, z) of points on the surface are then (x, y) " r and
z " u(r) .
(2)
Second, we will assume that the dynamics are purely dissipative, i.e. that inertia is negligible — a good approximation in many physical situations. Keeping only the lowest order terms in deviations from flat, we then have gu(r, t)/t " F#p(r, t)!f [r, u(r, t)] (3) 1 with F representing the driving force on the interface, f (R) representing the random “pinning” 1 forces of the heterogeneous medium on the interface which we assume for the present are not history or velocity dependent; g a dissipative coefficient; and
P P
5 p(r, t) " dr@ dt@ J(r!r@, t!t@)[u(r@, t@)!u(r, t)]
(4)
the “stress” on the interface from its elasticity which is “transmitted” by the kernel J(r, t). Short-range elasticity of the interface corresponds to JJd(t)+2d(r) . A schematic of such an interface and the forces acting on it is shown in Fig. 1.
(5)
116
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
Fig. 1. Schematic of a one-dimensional interface in a two dimensional disordered system illustrating the forces acting on the interface.
Keeping in mind some of the other problems of interest [1,15,16] in addition to interfaces, we will abstract to a more general problem of a d-dimensional elastic “manifold” !d " 2 for the interface — with more general interactions, which can be long-range, embodied in J(r, t). In addition to the form of J(r, t), the system will be characterized by the statistics of the pinning forces which impede interface motion near points where the interface has lower (free) energy; f (R) will generally 1 have only short-range correlations in space, i.e., in both u!u@ and r!r@. Even with these simplifying assumptions, the model Eqs. (3) and (4) is impossible to analyze fully due to the non-linearities implicit in the u dependence of f (r, u). Nevertheless, a lot of the qualitative behavior 1 can be guessed. If the driving force is sufficiently small, then it will be insufficient to overcome the pinning forces. But if F is increased slowly, it may overcome the pinning of some small segment of the interface which can then jump forwards only to be stopped by stronger pinning forces or by the elastic forces from neighboring still-pinned parts of the interface. But if the drive is larger, the neighboring regions may themselves not be strongly enough pinned to resist the increase in stress from the jumping section and may themselves jump forward leading to an “avalanche” of some larger region of the interface; this process might or might not eventually stop [13]. If the force is large enough — and certainly if it exceeds the maximum f — then it is not possible for the interface to be pinned 1 and the interface will move forward with some average velocity vN , albeit via very jerky motion both in space and time. In addition to the basic questions raised in the Introduction, we will be interested in the statistics of the sizes and dynamical properties of the avalanches [4,13,17]. The existence of a unique critical force can be established by a simple convexity argument that is valid if J(r, t) is non-negative [18]. If two configurations u and u of the interface at time t have the a b 0 property that one is “ahead” of the other, i.e. u (r, t )'u (r, t ) for all r; then u will be ahead of u at a 0 b 0 a b all later times. This can be seen by assuming the contrary and then considering the putative first
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
117
time t 't at which there is a point of contact; say u (r , t ) " u (r , t ) at some r . Then 1 0 a 1 1 b 1 1 1 [u (r , t)!u (r , t)]D 1"p[r , Mu N]!p[r , Mu N] b 1 t/t 1 a 1 b t a 1
P P
" dr@
t1 dt@ J(r !r@, t !t@)[u (r@, t@)!u (r@, t@)]'0 1 1 a b
(6)
since the pinning force at r is the same in both configurations and therefore cancels out. By 1 assumption the last expression in Eq. (6) is positive as long as J is non-negative so that for t't , 1 u is again ahead of u violating the assumption. a b The condition that J(r, t)50
(7)
for all r, t plays an important role in the theoretical analysis and frequently also in the physics of these types of systems. We will refer to models with this convexity property as monotonic; they have the property that if the displacements and the driving force F(t) increase monotonically with time, then so will the total “pulling force” — see later — on any segment. Except in the final section we will focus solely on monotonic models. We have shown that in monotonic models one configuration that is initially behind cannot “pass” another that is ahead of it [18]; therefore stationary and continually moving solutions cannot coexist at the same F; therefore F is unique. This is a big simplification and one that will not # occur generally, in particular not in some of the systems that we discuss in the last section. For forces well above F , one can use perturbative methods to study the effects of the random # pinning and compute, for example: the mean velocity, vN (F), the spatio-temporal correlations of the local velocities, and responses to additional applied forces [8]. Near F , however, life is # much more complicated as is usually the case near critical points — but for conventional equilibrium critical points the theoretical framework for dealing with the complexities is well established [14]. The most interesting behavior occurs in the critical regime; in particular one might expect processes — such as avalanches — to occur on a wide range of length and time scales. In order to make real progress, we will have to — at least initially — make further simplifications or approximations. One of the lessons from equilibrium critical phenomena is that analyzing simple models exactly or by controlled approximations is more useful than analyzing more realistic models by uncontrolled approximations; we will thus take the former route. But we must first find some clues as to what simplifications preserve — what we hope will be — the most essential features. Near the critical force, at any given time most of the interface will be moving very slowly if at all so that the left hand side of Eq. (3) will be close to zero. Thus, a first try might be to replace the actual dynamics with the adiabatic approximation that the forces at every point always balance exactly. Let us focus on one point r on the interface and divide the stress p(r), Eq. (4), into the local part JI u(r, t) and the non-local part, f , involving u(r@, t@) for r@ O r with p
P P
JI , dr@ dt@ J(r@, t@) .
(8)
118
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
We then have a balance between the local force, f #JI u and the pulling force, 1 /(r, t),f (r, t)#F . p The adiabatic approximation corresponds to
(9)
f (r, t)+/(r, t)!JI u(r, t) . (10) 1 But generally, because of the non-linearities in f (u), for a fixed / “applied” to u(r) there can be 1 multiple values of u which satisfy Eq. (10); as we shall see these play an important role in the physics. At this point, it is helpful to be more concrete. Let us consider a simple model of the pinning consisting of pinning sites u1(r) distributed for fixed r with random spacings between the u1(r), a a ¶ (r),u1 (r)!u1(r) (11) a a`1 a drawn, for each r and a, independently from a distribution P(¶ )d¶. The pinning force f [r, u(r)] " 0 except if u(r) is equal to one of the pinning positions, while for u(r) " u1(r), f can 1 a 1 take any value between zero and a yield strength, f , which is the same for each pin. A typical : realization of the pinning force f (u) on some segment of the interface is plotted in Fig. 2a. Note that 1 for a fixed /, there are several possible values of u given by the intersection of the line /!JI u with f (u). 1 If / is increased, then the particular (history dependent) force-balanced position u(/) that the interface point is following adiabatically can become unstable — for example, the configuration denoted by the circle in Fig. 2a — and u must jump to a new position. During the jump gu/t is clearly not small and Eq. (10) will not be satisfied. But if such jumps occur more rapidly than the time scales of interest then their primary effect will be a time lag between the actual u[/(t)] and an adiabatic solution u [/(t)] to Eq. (3). A way to capture this feature while preserving both the !$ physics of the time delays and the conceptually simplifying separation of motion into adiabatic and jump parts (with u/t " 0 in the adiabatic parts for the pinning model illustrated in Fig. 2), is to require u[/(r, t)] " u [/(r, t!t )] (12) !$ $ with some fixed (microscopic) delay time t . This is illustrated in Fig. 2 (top). Note that, formally, $ this can be accomplished, by taking gP0 and J(r, t) " J(r)d(t!t ). $ 3. Infinite-range model: mean-field theory The above discussion in terms of the local pulling force /(r, t) suggests that we could try to analyze the system crudely by assuming that the spatial and temporal fluctuations in /(r, t) are small so that / can be replaced by some sort of time-dependent average /M (t) which would then need to be determined self-consistently from the behavior of the neighboring regions that contribute to the stress at our chosen point r [8]. This is very analogous to the well-known mean-field approximation to conventional phase transitions: for example, in a magnetic system the statistical mechanics (or dynamics) of a single spin S(r) in the presence of a local effective field, h (r) from its %&& neighbors — the mean field — is analyzed and the mean field determined self-consistently from the condition that at all points the assumed SST entering the mean field h (r) " +r J(r!r@)SS(r@)T, is %&& {
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
119
Fig. 2. (top) Simple model of the forces on one segment of an interface. The segment can be pinned at the positions, u1 , of ia the vertical lines at which the pinning force can take any value up to the yield strength f . The intersections of the “comb” : representing the pinning force f (u ) and the diagonal line u!JI u with u the total pulling force from the applied force and 1 i i other segments of the interface, are the possible stationary positions of u indicated by the dots. The one of these with the i smallest u , u., plays a special role as discussed in the text. The amount *u that / needs to increase by to depin the i i segment from this pinning position is w JI . (bottom) Dynamics of the same segment of the interface as the pulling force is i increased. The actual u (t) (dotted), the adiabatic approximation to this (solid), and the time delayed approximation i (dashed) that is used in the analysis in the text are all shown.
the same as the computed SST. One of the advantages of this approximation is that it has a well-defined regime of validity: in the limit that the range of the interaction is very long [or more properly that the effective number of neighbors, (+ rDJ(r)D)2/+ rDJ(r)D2 is large] then the mean field theory becomes exact. But — users beware! — for fixed, but finite range interactions it can still fail near critical points as we shall see. In order to obtain analytic results in at least some model, we will study a strictly mean-field limit where each discrete segment of the interface — which we label simply by a subscript i since it is no
120
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
longer really a spatial coordinate — has an independent random pinning force f i(u ), of the form in 1 i Fig. 2, and the N segments are all coupled together by a uniform coupling J " J(t)/N , (13) ij i.e., infinite range forces. (Note that Eq. (13) includes a self-coupling piece but its effects are negligible in the desired NPR limit.) Much can be done for general non-negative J(t) and more complicated forms of f (u) using the actual dynamical evolution Eq. (3) [9], but to keep things 1 simple we will use the time-delayed adiabatic approximation discussed above with J(t) " JI d(t!t ) , (14) $ and the form of f i of Fig. 2a with independent randomness for each i. For simplicity, we will focus 1 on the strong pinning limit which corresponds to f 'JI ¶ . (15) : .!9 It is left to the reader to show that including some of the more “realistic” features within the infinite range model does not change the qualitative or other universal aspects of the results. Our task is now simple, at least in principle: we assume some mean field 1 + u (t!t ) , (16) i $ N i compute the evolution of each u (t) (from / "/M for all i) from some set of initial conditions, and i i then adjust our guessed /M (t) until the computed /M (t) " F#JI
1 (17) Su(t)T, + u (t) i N i is equal to [/M (t#t )!F]/JI for all t. $ We first try the simplest possibility: a constant /M (t). We can proceed graphically. From Fig. 2a we select for each i one of the possible stationary values of u . We have many choices; the only i constraint being that SuT " (/M !F)/JI .
(18)
But we must be careful: If we start choosing too many large u ’s, we may find that SuT will i become too large. We can thus ask: what are the minimum and maximum possible SuT for a given /M ? The minimum will turn out to be of primary interest so we focus on this: for each i, the minimum u , u.(/M ) corresponds to the first pinning position — i.e. one of the Mu1 N — to the i i ia right of the intersection of the line f " /!JI u with the line f " f that passes through the : tips of the “comb” — representing the yield strength — in Fig. 2a.1 Since the peaks are randomly positioned, Su T.*/ " Su.(/M )T " (/M !f )/JI #Sw T i i : i
(19)
1 The strong pinning condition f 'JI ¶ ensures that u. is at a pinning position. The general case can be worked out : .!9 i similarly.
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
121
with w the distance to the next pin which has the distribution2 i = 1 ¶P(¶ ) d¶ Prob(w) " . (20) ¶ ¶M w Here the quantity in parentheses is the probability distribution that a random point is in an interval of width ¶ between pins; this includes the factor of ¶/¶M with
P C
¶M ,
P
D
=
¶P(¶ ) d¶ (21) 0 because of the presence of more points in wider intervals. Integration of Eq. (20) by parts yields SwT " ¶2/(2¶M ) so that F f ¶2 ¶2 Su T.*/ " (/M !f )/JI # " #Su T! :# i i : JI JI 2¶M 2¶M
(22)
from Eqs. (16) and (19). For self-consistency, we must therefore have F4F " f !JI ¶2/2¶M (23) # : a non-trivial result for the critical force above which no static solutions are possible. Note that as the interaction strength, JI , is increased, the critical force decreases. Physically, this is a consequence of the elasticity causing the system to average over the randomness more effectively: pulling a stiff object over a rough surface is easier than pulling a flexible one. For F(F the number of stable solutions, N will be exponentially large with an “entropy” per # 4 segment (ln N )/N which is of order one well below F but decreases to zero at F as most of the u ’s 4 # # i will then need to take their minimum values to ensure self-consistency. What happens as F is increased slowly from below F so that the non-adiabaticity is negligible? # Since this will certainly result in SuT and hence /M increasing, we can understand the behavior from Fig. 2. As /M increases, some segments become unstable and jump to their next pinning positions. But this cannot happen unless they are stuck on the pin with smallest u1 , i.e. u.(/M ). Furthermore, ia i after a jump u will again be on the new smallest u1 for the increased /M . Thus the u ’s are gradually ia i swept to their minimum stable positions as F is increased towards F . # Above F , the segments continue to jump from one u.(/M ) to the next. But now the time # i delays must play a role. If we assume a solution which progresses uniformly on average, SuT " vN t, then /M " JI vN t!JI vN t #F . $
(24)
2 We use notations like “Prob(w)” to mean the probability that the continuous variable w is in the range w to w#dw, divided by dw; i.e. Prob(w) is the probability density (usually called by physicists “distribution”) of w. One must remember, however, that if variables are changed, e.g. from w to w@, then there is a Jacobian needed: Prob(w@) " (dw/dw@) Prob(w).
122
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
[Note that to ensure that u does not stop between pins, we again need the strong pinning condition JI ¶ (f ]. With all u " u.(/M ), our earlier analysis immediately yields self-consistency only when .!9 : i i F!F # vN " (25) JI t $ so that near criticality vN & (F!F )b # with the critical exponent
(26)
b"b "1 (27) MF in this infinite range mean-field model [5]. Note that a comparison of Eq. (25) for F
Fig. 3. Velocity versus driving force in a typical mean field model is indicated by the solid line. Note the linear dependence of vN on F just above F . The dashed line is the behavior in the absence of pinning. #
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
123
Fig. 4. Schematic of hysteresis loops that occur as the force is increased from zero to the critical force, decreased to the critical force in the opposite direction, and then cycled between these values. The direction of change of F is indicated by the arrows with the “1” denoting the first increase.
suggests that some of the asymptotic forms near F , such as Eq. (25) will be correct in realistic # models if the dimension of the “interface” is sufficiently large or the interactions are sufficiently long range [2,19]. We will return to these questions later, but for now we stick to the simple mean field model and ask what can be learned about “microscopic” properties, in particular the properties of avalanches that occur as the driving force is increased towards F . # 4. Avalanche statistics and dynamics In the mean-field model introduced in the previous section, the statistics and other properties of the avalanches of jumps that occur as the driving force is increased slowly can be worked out in substantial detail [20,21]. We will carry out the analysis using methods which can be generalized to provide useful information about the behavior with more realistic interactions. Let us consider what happens for F(F when F is increased by a very small amount. If the # increase is sufficiently small, then no segments will jump. But a slightly bigger increase — typically of order 1/N — will result in one jump. Let us call the time of this jump t " 0 and measure times in units of the delay time t so that with F held fixed after the avalanche starts, we have simple discrete $ time dynamics. The first jump can trigger n other jumps at time t " 1, with these triggering 1 n further ones at t " 2, etc. As long as the total number of jumps is finite, then in a large system 2 the mean SuT, and hence /M will have only advanced by an amount of order 1/N. Thus, all that will matter is the distribution of segments which are very close to jumping, i.e. those which will jump when /M is increased by a small amount *u . From Fig. 2a, we see that *u " JI w . For large N, all i i i but very special ways of preparing the conditions before the avalanche starts will yield a distribution of these small *u which are independent and randomly distributed with (initial-condition i dependent) density o , o(*u " 0) ; i
(28)
124
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
o thus measures a local susceptibility to jumping. We can now immediately conclude something about the mean number of jumps Sn T at a time t after the initial jump. Since the n jumps at time t t~1 t!1 will cause an increase in /M by, on average, JI S¶Tn (where we have used S¶T rather than t~1 ¶M since the distribution of ¶ ’s for the almost unstable segments and hence S¶T could depend on the initial conditions). This will cause, on average, oS¶Tn jumps at time t, i.e. t~1 Sn T " oS¶TJI Sn T . (29) t t~1 The crucial parameter is thus oS¶TJI ; if this is greater than one the avalanche will runaway. If the system is below F as we have assumed, it will eventually be stopped only when a finite fraction of # the segments have jumped and the system has found a stable — and more typical — configuration. But if oS¶TJI (1, then the expected total size of an avalanche s , + *u i i is simply SsT " S¶T/(1!oS¶TJI ) .
(30)
(31)
As we shall see however, this is not the typical size: even very close to criticality, i.e. e , 1!oS¶TJI <1 ,
(32)
most avalanches will be small. The distribution of avalanche sizes, as well as other interesting information on their dynamics, etc., can be obtained from generating function methods. Since these are a widely applicable tool, we will go through some of the details. For simplicity, we work in units with S¶T " 1 ,
(33)
JI " 1 .
(34)
We are interested in the time evolution of the displacements, in particular the increments nt m " + [u (t)!u (t!1)] " + ¶ , (35) t i i ta i a/1 where the M¶ N are the magnitudes of the n jumps that occur at time t (with m " 0 if n " 0). The ta t t t total size is simply = s" + m . (36) t t/0 The joint probability distribution of all the Mm N given the initial jump n " 1 t 0 PMm N , Prob[m ,m ,m 2Dn "1] , (37) t 0 1 2 0 contains the information of interest. Note that vertical bars as in Eq. (37) denote “given”, i.e. conditional probability. It is useful to define a generating function of the distribution including all
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
125
times up to ¹
T A
BU
T C Mk N , exp i + k m (38) T t t t P t/0 (usually we will drop the P). Note that C is simply the Fourier transform of P restricted to times T 4¹. We can derive a recursion relation for C in terms of C . For a given m , the number of T T~1 T~1 jumps triggered at time ¹ will be Poisson distributed with mean om , i.e. T~1 e~omT~1 Prob(n Dm )" (om )nT . (39) T T~1 T~1 n ! T Then, since m depends only on m , we can compute T T~1 Se*kTmTDMm N T"Se*ktmTDm T t t:T T~1 = nT " + Prob(n Dm )< d¶ P(¶ )e*kT¶Ta T T~1 Ta Ta nT/0 a/1 "exp[om (Se*kT¶T!1)] . (40) T~1 The last equality follows from Eq. (39); the resulting expression has similar m dependence to the T~1 T~1 T~1 . e*k m factor in C T~1 We thus find that
G
CP
DH
C [k ,2, k ] " C [k , , k ,j ] T 0 T T~1 0 2 T~2 T~1
(41)
!io(Se*jT¶T!1) , T~1
(42)
with j
T~1
"k
where j "k . (43) T T We can now iterate with the recursion relation Eq. (42) from the “initial” condition (43), eventually obtaining C Mk N " C (j Mk N) " Se*j0MktN¶T (44) T t 0 0 t (since n " 1). All the information has thus gone into j . As long as the system is stable, i.e. o41, 0 0 we can simply take ¹PR to recover the full information. [If o'1, then there is a non-zero (and computable) probability that s"R, and more care is needed.] To get the probability distribution of the total size s, we simply set all k " k and then t
P
Prob(s)" e~*kse*j*(k) k
(45)
with
P
k
,
P
1 = dk 2p ~=
(46)
126
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
and j*(k) the (stable) fixed point solution to Eq. (42). Let us first consider the behavior for large s. This will be dominated by the singularity in the lower half complex-k plane nearest to the real axis — a general property of Fourier transforms that can be seen by deforming the integration contour away from the real axis until it encounters a singularity. We only expect to have large avalanches for e , 1!o
(47)
small, so the interesting regime is k and e small which suggests j* small. We find that to leading order, j* + [!ie#J!e2#2ibk]/b
(48)
b , S¶2T
(49)
with
and the sign of the square root that has positive imaginary part for k real chosen. For k P 0, this gives j* "0 as it must for normalization of probability CMk "0N "1. The integration contour in t Eq. (45) can be deformed so that it is dominated by the cut at k"!1ie2/b for large s and we thus 2 have, after replacing the dummy variable k by k!1ie2/b and expanding in small k, 2 Prob(s) +
P
iJ2ik/b e~*kse~se2@(2b) .
(50)
k By “power counting”, we see that the branch cut must yield a 1/s3@2 dependence; hence for large s, Prob(s)&e~se2@(2b)/s3@2
(51)
[20]. Note that for small e, the mean SsT is dominated by large s avalanches which are rare since Prob(s&1/e2)&Prob(s'1/e2)&e .
(52)
We see from Eq. (51) that these yield SsT & 1/e as expected. Two questions now arise: First, can we trust this heuristic calculation? And, second, is the large s, small e behavior in Eq. (51) generic? The latter we have answered already: the large s behavior is the same (except for the coefficient b) as long as b"S¶2T(R. (The reader is encouraged to find the behavior associated with a power law tail in the distribution of ¶3 ). As far as justifying the result Eq. (51), for the case in which all the jumps are the same, ¶ " 1, one can compute Prob(s) exactly by changing the variable of integration to z " e*j*(k) so that the integral in Eq. (45) circles an sth order pole at z " 0. Cauchy’s theorem then yields Prob(s) " e~os(os)s~1/s! ,
(53)
with, of course, Prob (s " 0) " 0.
3 Note that arbitrarily large jumps can only occur in models that also have arbitrarily large local yield stresses, f . :
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
127
From the limiting large s form s! + sse~sJ2ps
(54)
the asymptotic behavior, Eq. (51), is found confirming the validity of the approximations made in our first derivation of this result. Note that the o dependence is simply via the (1/o)(oe~o)s factor in Eq. (53). It is nice that the exact result can be found in this case, but in general, asymptotic methods like those we have used above give more understanding and are more widely applicable. Nevertheless, to convince skeptical colleagues, a few exact results are useful! In addition to the distribution of avalanche sizes, we are also interested in their temporal evolution. For example, one might ask what is Sm DsT, i.e. what is the time development of an t average event of size s? This can be computed using the generating function. If we choose k "k for q O t q
(55)
k "k#l , t t
(56)
1 C /l D t " Sn e*ksT " j /l D t Se*j*(k)¶T t 0 t l /0 i = t l /0
(57)
and then
whose Fourier transform in k yields
P
P
m Prob(m , s) dm " m Prob(m Ds)dm Prob(s) " Sm DsTProb(s) . t t t t t t t
(58)
But by multiple use of the chain rule and Eq. (42), j /l " (j /k ) t`1(j /j ) t~1 ]2] (j /j ) 0 t~1 t k 0 1k 0 t t tj * evaluated with all j " j (k) and all k " k. q q For the constant ¶ " 1 case we obtain,
(59)
j /l D t " [oe*j*(k)]t . 0 t l /0 After shifting k as in Eq. (50) we see that, for e small and s and t large,
(60)
1 Sm DsT & t Prob(s)
P
e~se2@2e~*ks`*tJ2ik .
(61)
k This will be dominated by k & 1/s and hence the typical duration of an avalanche s will be q & Js .
(62)
Note that this is much less then the maximum possible duration q "s!1. The integral in .!9 Eq. (61) can be done exactly (by writing k"!ix2/2) yielding Sm DsT + te~t2@2s t
(63)
128
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
for large s independent of o. Again, the behavior for large s and 1;t;s is generic up to a coefficient b that should appear as in Eq. (51). For the particular constant ¶ case, the exact result can be computed from Eq. (58) yielding t#1 (s!1)!s~t for 04t4s!1 . Sm DsT" t (s!t!1)!
(64)
Note that this result includes the rare tail of events which have total duration t of order s; the asymptotic methods needed to obtain this are a variant of those used above although terms neglected in Eqs. (48) and (61) become important in this region. A schematic of the evolution of a large avalanche is shown in Fig. 5. Note that, on average, an avalanche which is going to be large starts with m growing linearly in time, independent of how big it will become; this is very different t from the behavior of typical avalanches even near to criticality which are small. Nevertheless, typical large avalanches will have large fluctuations of m away from Sm DsT; these can be studied by t t computing, e.g. Sm2DsT from which it can be concluded that a typical m for a large s avalanche is the t t same order as Sm DsT except for t<1/Js. The probability that a large avalanche stops before time t t can be computed from Prob(m "0Ds) which is found from C (k P#iR, k "k for qOt). t = t q So far, we have not attempted to relate the local susceptibility to jumps, o, to the original mean field model of the previous section. In general, o will depend on the past history. But on a generic approach to F from below (e.g. after “training” the system by a slow increase to F from # # F"!F ), o will approach unity at F and the cutoff sJ &1/(1!o)2 in the jump size distribution # # will diverge. Right at F there will be a power law distribution of avalanches sizes; this is analogous # to the power law distribution of clusters that occur at the critical point for conventional percolation [22]. One might also hope to make connections to power law spatial structures at percolation [22] as well as to spatial correlations at conventional equilibrium critical points. But to do this we will certainly have to move away from the infinite-range mean field model. This we do in the next section.
Fig. 5. Typical avalanche in a mean-field model showing the increase in size of the avalanche, m , at each time step. Note t that the fluctuations in m are larger when m is larger. t t
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
129
5. Toy model: Spatial structure of avalanches The simple mean-field model of avalanches discussed in the previous section can be extended in a relatively straightforward way to include spatial and temporal structure like that which arises for general non-negative stress transfer functions J(r, t), i.e. monotonic models. Spatial coordinates for n(r, t) are now needed and corresponding generating function variables k(r, t). In the mean-field model, the probability that a segment u(r) jumps in a small time interval is proportional to the increase in pulling force /(r) on it in that interval times a local jump susceptibility o. If we assume the same is true here, then we can generalize the recursion relation equation (42) to include general J(r, t):
P P
j(r, t)"k(r, t)!io dr@
=
dt@ J(r@!r, t@!t)Mexp[i¶j(r@, t@)]!1N
(65)
t for the case with all jump displacements ¶ equal. Many quantities of interest are computable by similar techniques to those in the previous section, often in terms of the spatio-temporal Fourier transform of J(r, t), J(q, u). The mean number of jumps at r at a time t after an avalanche is triggered at r"0 at time t"0 is
PP
1 . e~*ute*q > r 1!o¶J(q, u) q u The critical point is thus still given by Sn(r, t)T"
(66)
(o¶JI ) "1 #3*5
(67)
JI "J(q"0, u"0)
(68)
with and the mean total size is SsT"¶/(1!o¶JI )
(69)
as before. We will henceforth work in units with ¶"JI "1. A more interesting quantity is again the conditional mean:
PPP
1 Sn(r, t)DsT" Prob(s)
e~*kse*j*(k)e*q > re~*ut 1!o¶J(q, u)e*j*(k)
(70)
k u with j*(k) the fixed point solution to the mean-field recursion relation (42) or, equivalently, Eq. (65) with j and k independent of r and t. By changing variables one can show that (as in the previous section) conditional statistics like Eq. (70) are independent of o. The important physical quantity is q
K(q, u),1!J(q, u)
(71)
which embodies the information on the space and time-dependent elasticity. Changing variables to kPk#constant and noting that for large s, small k will dominate as before, we obtain
P
P
C
D
1 j2 Sn(q, u)DsT+ J2ps3e~*sk " dj e~(1@2)sj2Js3/2p . !i2ik#K(q, u) j2#K2(q, u) k
(72)
130
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
For an interface with dissipative dynamics and local elasticity, in the absence of pinning or driving forces we have, after rescaling lengths and times, simply u/t"+2u
(73)
so that K(q, u)"!iu#q2 .
(74)
But to understand the general behavior, and to apply the results to other physical systems, we would like to include the possibility of long range elasticity, i.e.,
P
dt J(r, t)&1/rd`aJ
(75)
in d-dimensions corresponding to the static K (q)&DqDaJ ,K(q, u"0) if aJ (2 or K (q)&q2 if aJ '2 . 4 4 We thus consider the general case of K (q)&DqDa with a42 with 4 a,min(aJ , 2) .
(76)
(77)
The total displacement a distance r from the avalanche starting point, during an avalanche of large size s, is obtained from Eq. (72) with u"0. We must thus evaluate :qe*q > r of the last expression in Eq. (72). For r"0, all q can contribute but j is small so that we can ignore the j2 in the denominator, yielding
TP
S*u(r"0)DsT,¶
U P
dt n(r"0,t)Ds &
1 [K (q)]2 q 4
(78)
which is of order one independent of s if d'd (a)"2a . (79) # We thus see the appearance of a special critical dimension above which no segment will jump more than a few times even in an arbitrarily large avalanche. Indeed, we will see that above the critical dimension driven interfaces will have only bounded small scale roughness. For d(d , the integral in Eq. (78) is infinite so that small q (i.e. small K) dominates and more # care is needed. The cutoff of : of Eq. (72) when K&j yields, with a typical j&1/Js and hence q q&s~1@2a, S*u(r"0)DsT&s1~d@2a .
(80)
Note the appearance of a non-trivial exponent relating *u and s. It depends, as is usually the case for critical phenomena, on the spatial dimension. As mentioned in the Introduction, Eq. (80) is just the kind of scaling law we expect near critical points. Eq. (80) relates characteristic scales of displacement to the characteristic scales of avalanche size. We can also say something about the spatial extent and shape of large avalanches, by computing S*u(r)DsT. For d'd (a), the integral in Eq. (72) will be cutoff for q'r by the e*q > r oscillations and #
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
131
hence dominated by q&1/r yielding S*u(r)DsT&1/rd~2a
(81)
for 1;r;s1@2a where the upper cutoff arises when K(q&1/r)&j&1/Js. For d(d , on the other hand, as long as r;s1@2a, :qe*q>r/(j2#K2) for typical j will be # 4 dominated by q&s~1@2a and S*u(r)DsT&s1~d@2p for r;s1@2p ,
(82)
i.e. the magnitude of typical displacements is approximately independent of r in this range. In all dimensions, *u(r) will fall off rapidly for larger r. The length ¸&s1@2a
(83)
is thus some measure of the diameter of an avalanche. Let us now try to interpret these results [Note that the skeptic could compute, e.g., S[*u(r)]2DsT, etc., to provide further support for the picture below]. For d'd , the fact that S*u(r)T is much less # than unity for r<1 strongly suggests that most segments will not jump even if they are within r;¸ of the avalanche center, rather only a fraction &1/rd~2a of them will jump, and these typically only once or a few times. The number of sites that have jumped at all within a distance R(¸ of the origin is of order R2a;Rd so that the avalanche is fractal. The total number of sites that jump, its “area” A is thus, by taking R&¸, A&¸d&&s;¸d
(84)
with the fractal dimension d "2a for d'd . (85) & # In lower dimensions, the picture is quite different. The approximate independence of S*u(r)DsT of r for r;¸ suggests that each site in this region jumps a comparable number of times &s1~d@(2a) (with fluctuations around this of the same order) and hence the avalanche is not fractal but has area A&¸d&sd@2
(86)
while the typical displacement is *u(r)&¸f
(87)
for r4¸ with f"2a!d
(88)
(for d'd , f"0). # The distribution of s at the critical point that occurs at oJI ¶"1, is the same as in the mean field model. This implies that Prob (diameter'¸)&1/¸i
(89)
132
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
with i"a .
(90)
The duration of an avalanche with dissipative dynamics — corresponding to K(q, u)+!iu#DqDp
(91)
— is given simply by scaling, i.e., q&¸z&s1@2
(92)
with the dynamical critical exponent z"a .
(93)
Note that the relation q&Js is (not surprisingly) the same as in the infinite-range mean-field model. We have found that in our toy model, many of the properties of large avalanches near to the critical point (actually any large avalanche although they are rare away from criticality), obey scaling laws which relate various characteristic physical properties to each other by power law relationships. For example, for d(d , an avalanche of diameter ¸ has typical size s&¸2a@d, # displacement *u&¸f and duration q&¸z. This type of scaling behavior is one of the key aspects of critical phenomena in both equilibrium and non-equilibrium systems. But there is more: if we scale all lengths by a correlation length m&e~1@a
(94)
which is the diameter above which avalanches become exponentially rare away from the critical point, and correspondingly displacements by mf, durations by mz, etc., then functions such as those that occur in the distribution of avalanche sizes, Eq. (51), or the average growth of the displacements during an avalanche, Su(r, t)/tDsT will be universal functions of scaled variables such as ¸/m. For example, from Eq. (72) we obtain, for K(q, u)"!giu#DgDqDa and d(d "2a, # C s u(r, t) r t s + u mf~z½ , , (95) C t m C mz C md`f t t u with s":dr *u(r) the total size, C and C non-universal (dimensionfull) coefficients which set the u t scales of the displacements and times; these depend on the random pinning, g, D, etc. The universal scaling function is
T
KU
A
PPP
½(R, ¹, m)"
Q X
B
dK e*Q > R~*XTe~(1@2)mK2Jm3/2p
C
D
K2 K2#(!iX#DQDa)2
(96)
which depends only on the dimension, the range of interactions, and the type of dynamics (i.e. dissipative), as is manifested in the low-frequency form of the stress transfer function K(q, u). As we shall see in the next section, a similar scaling structure is expected to exist in more realistic models. Let us now try applying the toy model results to the interface problem with d"2 and short-range elasticity, so that a"2. This dimension is less than d4)035~3!/'%"d (a"2)"4 , # #
(97)
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
133
so we have f"2, i.e. *u(¸)<¸, for large avalanches. But this is clearly unphysical: our original model for the interface assumed that it was close to flat so that, at least on large scales, we need small angles of the interface, i.e. +u;1. Thus, the result Eq. (87) violates the assumptions of our original model in this case. What has gone wrong? Is the original model bad or have we made some grievous errors in trying to analyze it? The answer is the latter and understanding why gives some clues as to how to do better. In the infinite range mean-field model, the odds of any given segment jumping more than once are very low as long as s;JN, since the odds of a specific segment jumping at all is small and each jump is almost independent by (justifiable) assumption. But in the finite range toy model, we assumed that this independence was still true, i.e. that the probability of a segment u(r) jumping in a short time interval depends only on the increase in pulling force, */(r), on it during that interval. But this is problematic: if a segment has just jumped, it is much less likely to do so again until its neighbors have caught up. The needed increase in /(r) for a subsequent jump will typically be of order one. [Actually this is true even in our toy model, but the cumulative effect of many jumps causes the problem: the needed */(r) to cause a large *u(r) that consists of many jumps should be */(r)+JI *u(r)$O(1) while in the toy model it is, for o"1 where large avalanches can occur, */(r)+JI *u(r)$JI J*u(r). This difference is responsible for major errors when avalanches involve large *u(r)’s but not for d'd (a) where *u(r)’s remain of order one.] # Our task, then, is to somehow take into account properly the anticorrelations between local susceptibilities to successive jumps. This will certainly involve ensuring that the statistical properties of M f [r, u(r)]N when all u(r) are increased by any fixed amount are preserved, i.e. the statistical 1 translational invariance of the system which is lacking in our toy avalanche model. Remarkably, in spite of its problems the toy model correctly gives the statistics and properties of avalanches for large s and small e in dimensions greater than d (a). The basic reason for this is the # observation mentioned above that each segment is unlikely to jump many times during even very large avalanches; a real understanding, however, relies on the renormalization group treatment discussed briefly in the next section.
6. Interfaces and scaling laws Motivated by the partial success of the toy model and general scaling concepts from more conventional critical phenomena, we will now approach the interface problem by making a scaling Ansatz. Specifically, we conjecture that large avalanches near the critical point have properties which scale with their diameter ¸ (or size s) as powers of ¸ [3,4]. In the toy model we found that the critical exponents which characterized these scaling laws, f, d , i and z depend on the dimension & of the elastic manifold, the power law decay of the interactions if they are long range, and on the type of dynamics, but not on other details of the system. This is the fundamental property of “universality”. In contrast, the critical force and coefficients in the scaling functions such as Eq. (95), will generally depend on details and hence are non-universal. We might thus hope that in dimensions d(d (a) for which the toy model fails, the exponents will still be universal functions of # d and a.
134
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
In addition to the four exponents already introduced, there should also be an exponent which characterizes the correlation length: this is the diameter above which avalanches become unlikely (like m&s1@2a&e~1@a in the toy model) [23]. As F increases towards F with a generic past history, .!9 # we conjecture that m&1/(F !F)l . (98) # If in the mean-field model the local jump susceptibility o is smooth at F [17] so that e&F !F, # # then l "1/a. This turns out to be the case for the fuller mean field model defined in 50:~.0$%Section 3. It appears that we have five separate exponents and we would like to understand whether there are some relations among them. Fortunately, this will turn out to be the case. First, however, we can eliminate one exponent. If, as we expect for d(d , f'0 so that some interface segments advance large distances in big # avalanches, then the elasticity will certainly make neighboring regions advance as well so that it seems implausible that avalanches would be fractal; thus we expect d "d (99) & for d(d . # The other relations between exponents are much more subtle. The simplest assumption — and one that is borne out — is that there is one basic length scale m within the interface and a basic scale *u&mf
(100)
in the direction of motion. [Note that we have been sloppy and not put the needed non-universal coefficients, as appeared in Eq. (95) into Eq. (100).] Thus, for example, if we started with a flat interface and gradually increased F, when e,F !F # is small, the interface would be rough on scales less than m, with S[u(r)!u(r@)]2T&Dr!r@D2f
(101)
(102)
for Dr!r@D;m, and be flat on longer scales with S[u(r)!u(r@)]2T&m2f
(103)
for Dr!r@D<m as shown in Fig. 6. Similarly, we conjecture that for e small, and s large [4,13] Prob(s)&(1/sB`1)H(s/md&`f)
(104)
with H(xP0)P1 and H(xPR)P0, i.e., a similar form to that found in the toy model. Scaling implies that the exponent for the distribution of avalanche probability as a function of diameter in Eq. (89) obeys i"B(d #f) . &
(105)
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
135
Fig. 6. Schematic of a one-dimensional interface with F somewhat below the critical force. After starting from a flat initial configuration, the typical displacements of the interface are of order mf with m the correlation length. On smaller length scales, the statistics of relative displacements as a function of separation has a simple scaling behavior as shown. An avalanche that occurs as the force is increased slightly is also shown.
We can now compute the “polarizability” of the system s,dSu(r)T/dFC
(106)
where the arrow denotes that F is increasing. This will be given by the sum over avalanches which are triggered with probability odF per segment of the interface yielding s&o
P
ds s H(s/md&`f) . s sB
(107)
With B(1, this is dominated by large s so that s&m(1~B)(d&`f)&e~(1~B)(d&`f)l .
(108)
But from the earlier results about the interface roughness, Eq. (103), we also have s&(d/dF)mf&e~(1`fl) .
(109)
We thus have B"(d !1/l)/(d #f) & & and hence i"d !1/l &
(110)
(111)
136
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
[4]. Note that these relations work in the toy model for d'd (a) but not for d(d (a) due to the # # problems discussed earlier. Another relation can be derived by considering the forces one avalanche exerts on another section of the interface. When an avalanche that moves a region of diameter ¸&m occurs, we expect it to also involve quite a few segments nearby to jump, but not many that are far away. In particular, distances R&m away should be borderline. The increase in pulling force from the original part of the avalanche on sections &R away will be *u&md`f/Rd`a
(112)
(for short range elasticity, a"2, the argument is more subtle). For R&m, this */ should be comparable to the deviation e from criticality or else we must not have properly identified the crossover distance. Thus, we should have *u(R&m)&1/ma~f&e&m~1@l
(113)
yielding the scaling law 1/l"a!f .
(114)
A further relation can be derived by considering the variations in the “local critical forces” F (r, ¸) needed to make a region of diameter ¸ advance by of order ¸f. We define #(115) el(r, ¸),F (r, ¸)!F #to be, loosely, the deviation from “local criticality”. Since the volume of the region through which the section of scale ¸ will advance is »&¸d`f, we expect that the random pinning forces in the region will make del(¸),Jvariance[el(r, ¸)]51/¸(d`f)@2
(116)
i.e. the region “does not know” F to better than this accuracy [24]. If at scale ¸&m, del(¸"m) # were much larger than e, then we would expect many regions of size m to be unstable so large avalanches that occurred in the past should have been even larger. Thus, we should have del(m)4e
(117)
yielding 1/l41(d#f) 2 from Eq. (116). This can be combined with Eq. (114) to yield
(118)
f51(2a!d) . 3 An upper bound of
(119)
f42a!d
(120)
follows from the observation that the toy model should overestimate the jumps of a typical segment in a large avalanche. For d'd , we expect f"0, i.e. interfaces which are flat on large scales. #
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
137
So far, we have not discussed the dynamics. One of the (helpful!) features of monotonic models, is that at the end of an avalanche, how much each segment has moved, *u(r), is independent of the dynamics although how long the avalanche takes, in what order jumps occur, etc., will depend on the dynamics [17,18]. Indeed, even the exponent z can depend on the stress transfer J(r, t). In particular for long-range interactions whose effect is only felt after a time proportional to r — i.e. finite velocity of information propagation — one must clearly have z41 (this can already be seen in the toy model if a(1) [25]. In general, however, we cannot say much about z without much more work. Nevertheless, using our scaling Ansatz, we can relate the dynamical behavior in the moving phase for F just above F to that for F(F [3,4,8]. In particular, we conjecture that the jerkiness of # # the motion occurs on length scales up to m&1/(F!F )l and times up to # q &mz (121) m while the motion is smoother on longer scales. This jerky motion will look like the dynamics within avalanches. If we consider, crudely, the motion to be made up of avalanches of scale m occurring at intervals of order q within each region of diameter m, then the velocity is simply m vN &mf/q &(F!F )b (122) m # with b"(z!f)l .
(123)
Note again, that with the exponents of the toy model for d'd : z"a, l"1/a, f"0 and b"1, the # scaling law (123) is obeyed. In the moving phase, the response of Su(r, t)!vN tT to a small additional static force dF e*q > r, q s(q)"dSu(q, u"0)T/dF , (124) q can be obtained exactly! (Note that here either sign of dF is okay if it is sufficiently small.) If the q variable change
P
u(r, t)"uJ (r, t)# e*q > r q
dF q JI !J(q, u"0)
(125)
which corresponds to transforming away the response in the absence of pinning, is made, then the statistical properties of the random pinning forces fI [r, uJ (r, t)],f [r,u(r, t)] (126) 1 1 as a function of uJ and r are identical to those of the original f . This is a consequence of the 1 underlying statistical rotational invariance of the system.4 We thus find that SuJ (r, t)T q"Su(r, t)T q dF dF /0 so that the average response is given exactly by the second term in Eq. (126), i.e. 1 1 s(q)" & . JI !J(q,u"0) DqDa
(127)
(128)
4 If the system is not rotationally invariant, the depinning critical behavior can be very different; see the discussion in [19].
138
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
Since s should scale as ¸f/¸1@l, we again obtain the scaling law (114). Note that since f is defined at F , the agreement of this result with that below threshold supports the notion that the appropriate # characteristic length scales above and below threshold will diverge at F with the same exponent l. # We have reduced the number of critical exponents to two basic ones; f and z which relate displacement and time scales to length scales. But, so far, we have neither a means of computing these exponents; nor more importantly, a way of justifying the scaling laws beyond the hand waving arguments given above (or variants of these); nor even a way of understanding the claimed universality of the exponents. But with the basic scaling picture in mind, we can try and appeal to the framework of the renormalization group which has been so successful in understanding equilibrium — and some non-equilibrium — critical phenomena. There are two substantial difficulties. One is associated with the basic physics: we must find a way of properly dealing with two kinds of scales in the pinned phase near F . First, the jumps of small segments happen on the basic microscopic time scale but # their existence and discrete nature is crucial. Large avalanches last for times which scale with their size out to q which is very large just below F and thus avalanche activity spans a broad range of m # scales. But, in addition, there is the time between avalanches set by the rate at which F is changed; as long as this is slow enough, it does not really matter except that the important anti-correlations between successive avalanches in the same region will only be felt on this very long time scale. The other main difficulty is associated with the history dependence in the pinned phase. For example, what should one average over to get sensible quantities? If the stress transfer, J(r, t), is non-negative, this difficulty can be circumvented if F is always increasing (or always decreasing): if this is the case, then from any stable initial condition the pulling force on every segment will increase monotonically with time. This feature is important for the physics as well as drastically simplifying the theoretical analysis. Nevertheless, even in such monotonic models, there will be history dependence. But near to F , this should, at worst, only modify non-universal coefficients as # long as the critical force is approached monotonically starting from a much lower force. A natural reproducible history results from starting at F"!F . # For monotonic models, a perturbative renormalization group (RG) analysis for dimensions near the upper critical dimension has been carried out [2—4]. The first result is that for d'd (a), the # decreased local susceptibiltiy to jumping after a segment has jumped is irrelevant in the RG sense, except on the very long time scales during which the whole system has advanced. In particular, this justifies our claim that, while the critical force and other non-universal properties will not be given correctly, universal features of avalanches such as critical exponents and scaling functions [e.g. H in Eq. (104) and ½ in Eq. (95)] will be given exactly by the toy model for d'd . In the moving phase, # some of the effects left out of the toy model will be important but mean field results like b"1 and f"0 will obtain.5
5 The velocity exponent, b, in mean field theory is not fully universal. It depends on whether or not the pinning forces are continuously differentiable and, if not, on the nature of the singularities in f (u). For all but discontinuous forces, this 1 causes long time scales in mean-field theory associated with the acceleration away from configurations that have just become unstable. With short range interactions, these should not play a role due to the jerky nature of u(r, t) caused by jumps. Thus the mean-field models with b "1 are the “right” ones about which to attempt an RG analysis. See [19]. MF
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
139
For d(d many new results can be obtained from the RG analysis. In addition to the derivation # of universality, scaling laws and perturbative computations of exponents that arise from a new critical fixed point of the RG, it is possible, in principle — although not yet carried out — to compute such quantities as the new universal scaling function that replaces ½ in Eq. (95), anticorrelations between avalanches in the same region, local velocity correlations in the moving phase, etc. Here we just quote the results for the exponents [2—4]. All the scaling laws derived heuristically above are found to be obeyed. The exponent f is f+1(d (a)!d) (129) 3 # to all orders in powers of d !d; indeed, this result — which saturates the lower bound Eq. (119) # — may well be exact. Numerical computations for d"a"1 yield f+0.34$0.02 consistent with 1 [25,26]. The dynamic exponent is found to be 3 2[d (a)!d] #O[(d !d)2] . z"a! # # 9
(130)
(131)
We thus find an interesting effect: the non-linearities of the avalanche process cause disturbances of the interface to propagate more rapidly at long scales than for an unpinned interface. The velocity exponent is then, from scaling, z!f 2(2a!d) b" +1! (1 , a!f 9a
(132)
i.e. a concave downwards vN (F) curve. Making the somewhat dangerous extrapolation to the interface with d"a"2, we get predictions of z+14, f+2, b+2 . (133) 9 3 3 At this point, except for some experiments on interfaces between two fluids that are being driven through porous media which give somewhat inconclusive results [5], there are not experiments, of which this author is aware, that test these results for interfaces. But as we shall see in the next section, there have been both experiments and numerical tests carried out on other systems.
7. Applications and complications In the previous section we saw how scaling ideas and intuition that arise from the simple solvable toy model could be used to develop an understanding of the behavior of interfaces near to the critical driving force that makes them move. Renormalization group methods can then be used to carry out concrete calculations and justify many of the conjectures. In particular, the general structure and existence of scaling laws and universality follows rather directly from the existence of an RG critical fixed point. One of the advantages of this framework is that it enables us to apply the general structure to other systems — such as (but not limited to) different dimensionalities and ranges of interactions. But in addition we can introduce various physical features left out of the simple models — even our
140
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
relatively realistic Eq. (3) — and ask whether they are relevant in the RG sense of changing (or destroying) the universal aspects of the critical behavior. In this section we will discuss several of the physical systems mentioned in the Introduction with an eye both to applying the ideas and seeing how they must be modified — or thrown away! — to account for the appropriate extra physics. 7.1. Charge density waves The best and perhaps really the only real test of critical behavior near to a depinning transition of an elastic manifold in a random medium is that of charge density waves (CDW) driven by an electric field [7]. The periodic electron density waves that occur within this class of materials are incommensurate with respect to the underlying crystalline periodicity in one direction so they could move freely in this direction — contributing to the current proportionally to their velocity — except for being pinned by randomly positioned impurities; see Fig. 7. These CDWs are thus three-dimensional elastic manifolds with short range interactions (the coulomb interactions are screened) in a three-dimensional random medium. Inertial effects are negligible. The primary difference from interfaces is in terms of the displacements u(r): in the frame of the crystal the random pinning forces f [r, u(r)] are periodic in 1 u(r)Pu(r)#j (134) CDW for all r, where j is the wavelength of the CDW. Although the resulting behavior near the CDW critical driving force is not much changed for d'd "4, the extra symmetry associated with this # periodicity changes the universality class for d(d . In particular, the exponents become [9] # f"0 , l"1, 2 4!d #O(4!d)2 , z"2! 3
(135)
Fig. 7. Schematic of a crystal with a charge density wave that is incommensurate with respect to the underlying lattice periodicity of the solid. The maxima in the difference between the actual electron charge density and that without the CDW are shown. An electric field pulls on the CDW which could move freely, except for being impeded by pinning forces of the impurities.
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
141
yielding scaling behavior above F involving the velocity exponent # b"zl"1!1(4!d)#O(4!d)2+5 (136) 6 6 in d"3. Experiments [27] carried out on CDWs and numerical simulations yield b+0.75!0.9 over 21 decades of F!F — surprisingly good agreement with the theoretical prediction. 2 # But should we really expect that CDWs will exhibit the critical behavior of an ideal elastic medium? In a precise sense, certainly not. ¹hermal fluctuations (or even quantum fluctuations) can cause sections of the CDW to overcome the barriers caused by the pinning and jump to lower energy local minima. For any non-zero electric field, this will cause the CDW to gradually creep forwards thereby contributing to the current. The critical behavior near the fluctuationless F will # thus be smeared out by fluctuations which are hence a relevant perturbation [8,28]. This is quite analogous to the role of a magnetic field near to ferromagnetic phase transitions, which also smears out the critical singularities. But as in the magnetic case, if the perturbation is small enough, critical behavior can still be observed over a wide range of scales and F!F with the smearing only # occurring very close to F . In general, fluctuation effects appear to be quite substantial in CDW # systems and the critical behavior is smeared out. But the experiments quoted above [27] were performed by applying an ac driving force in addition to the dc drive; this reduces the effects of thermal fluctuations and appears to yield a wide range over which they do not play much of a role. Another complication in CDWs — which might also be reduced by an additional ac drive — is defects in the CDW lattice, especially dislocations [29]. The pinning is very weak in CDWs implying that the stresses that would cause dislocations to form are unlikely to occur except perhaps on long length scales. In this weak pinning regime, the effects of dislocations are poorly understood. It now appears, however, that dislocations will not destroy the existence of the CDW phase in equilibrium [30]; this is not directly relevant to the non-equilibrium physics of interest here but may point to progress also on the more relevant issues. Nevertheless, at this point, whether or not defects always destroy the elastic depinning critical behavior that we have studied is an open question. 7.2. Superconductors One system that is quite similar in spirit to a CDW, but for which the strength of the pinning forces can readily be varied, is a vortex lattice in a type II superconductor. Vortex lattices are pinned by impurities that impede their motion under the action of a transport current which exerts a force on the vortices [6]. Since the voltage is proportional to the mean vortex velocity, vN (F) plots are simply voltage-current curves, F being simply proportional to the critical current density. # By making bulk superconducting samples, thin superconducting films or wires, or a normal layer sandwiched between two bulk superconductors, three, two and one dimensional systems can all be studied as well as, in the last case, a two dimensional lattice of roughly parallel vortex lines with no dislocations allowed. In principle, many systems and regimes can thus be investigated, subject to the complication of non-uniform forces on the vortices, dissipative heating effects, and natural tendencies of experimentalists to care more about the magnitude of the critical current density than about what happens when the superconductor fails, i.e. when the critical current is exceeded! Surprisingly, although thermal fluctuation driven transitions in both clean and dirty superconductors have received a lot of attention recently [6,31] the behavior near to critical currents has received far less [32].
142
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
If the pinning is very strong, the vortex lattice will be destroyed. What then (when thermal fluctuations can be neglected) will be the qualitative behavior near the critical force? In the case of two dimensional films in a perpendicular magnetic field that produces point-like vortices, the vortex flow just above F will almost certainly be confined to a sparse interconnected network of # irregular channels across the system, as sketched in Fig. 8. Some preliminary theoretical studies [33] and experiments of the critical behavior that can arise in this regime have been carried out and experiments that “see” the vortices performed [34], but even this simple case is far from understood. For more complicated cases of intermediate strength pinning or when three dimensional effects are important, even less is known. One thing that is clear, both theoretically [33] and experimentally [32], is that the critical force is history dependent. This and other history dependence — which can be caused by defect motion — is certain to play an important role in the physics. We note that in principle — and soon, if not quite now, in practice [34] — measurements of local vortex flow on small scales will be possible in some of the parameter regimes of greatest potential interest. Both macroscopic and microscopic information should be available in these superconducting vortex systems. Leaving the effects of lattice defects as an intriguing puzzle, we now turn to another type of physical effect that we have so far left out: the role of inertia and other related phenomena. 7.3. Cracks In contrast to CDWs and vortex lattices, interfaces between phases are “topological” and hence have elasticity which is robust for weak pinning, although for strong pinning they can become fractal and a very different “invasion percolation” behavior occurs. Various other elastic systems are also not directly susceptible to destruction by defects. In particular, the front of a planar tensile
Fig. 8. A thin superconducting film in a magnetic field, H, perpendicular to the film. A supercurrent provides a driving force for the vortices to move across the film. Just above the critical current for vortex motion, the vortices in most of the film can remain stationary with the vortex flow confined to a sparse network of vortex channels, as shown. The electric field is proportional to the average vortex flow rate.
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
143
Fig. 9. A solid with a crack under tensile loading. If the load is increased, the crack front can progress through the solid. In some circumstances, the crack is confined to a plane; this is the case discussed in the text.
crack in a heterogeneous solid has long range 1/r2 elastic forces mediated by the elasticity of the solid which act to keep the crackfront roughly straight; see Fig. 9 [15,16,34]. But random variations in the local toughness — the energy per unit area needed for crack growth — act to deform the crack front. This system is thus an example of an elastic manifold with d"1 and a"1. Numerical studies [25,26] with quasistatic (i.e. instantaneous on the time scales of the crack motion) stress transfer which corresponds to J(r, t)Jd(t)/r2 and hence is a monotonic system, yields results for f, z, l, and b in excellent agreement with the d"2!e expansion results [2]. But the resulting z+7 is less than one [2,25]. Therefore, even if the basic propagation of disturbances 9 along the crack front is slow on small scales (so that the quasistatic approximations would seem to be justified), near the critical point disturbances would propagate arbitrarily fast since the characteristic scale of the “velocity” along the crack front would scale as m/mz which diverges as mPR. This is clearly unphysical and so elastic wave propagation effects must change the asymptotic critical behavior. The simplest way to take the time delays associated with wave propagation into account is to use J(r, t)&(1/r2)d(t!r/c)
(137)
with c an elastic wave velocity. This is still a monotonic model, so only the dynamic exponent z will change. Theoretical arguments and numerical simulations [25] for this case yield z"1 exactly — so there is no problem with causality. From Eq. (123), we obtain b"1. But real elastic wave propagation is much more complicated [25,35]. If the crack grows by a segment of the crack front jumping forward only to be stopped by a tougher region, then a point on the crackfront a distance r away will initially feel no change in stress. Furthemore, when the longitudinal waves with velocity c arrive, the stress that tends to open the crack — analogous to l p(r,t) for the interface model — will actually decrease since J(r, tZr/c )(0 [25,36,37] Only when the l Rayleigh waves with slower velocity c 4c (c arrive will the opening stress become positive. But R t l when this occurs, there will be a rapid jump to a large peak value of the opening stress followed by
144
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
a gradual fall off to the eventual static stress increase which is
P
J(r, u"0)"
=
J(r, t) dt&1/r2 . (138) 0 This is highly non-monotonic behavior! Such stress overshoots can cause segments of the crack front to jump forward that would not have been triggered by the static stress changes. How often this occurs will depend on the heights of the stress peaks relative to the static stress increases, i.e. to the size of the overshoots. If the jumps of segments of the crack are slow and smooth (with duration long compared to the sound travel time across the jumping segment) then the stress overshoots will only occur far from the jumping segment and have small amplitude. Their effects should then be small and the quasistatic behavior should be observable, except, as we shall see, very near F . But any stress # overshoots will at least occasionally cause some extra jumping and we must understand their effect. Some intuition can be gleaned by considering what would happen if the stress increases never decayed to their static value, but stayed at their peak strength. This would correspond, roughly, to increasing the elastic interactions of the crack with itself. As we saw in the mean field model, such enhanced elasticity causes the critical force to decrease because of more effective averaging over the randomness [see Eq. (20)]. Thus we would expect avalanches to run away at a force below the quasistatic F . A careful analysis of the effects of realistic stress transfer peaks followed by decay # towards the static stress shows that the same basic picture obtains [11,25]. Consider a segment which, at the end of the quasistatic approximation to an avalanche, has a final stress on it which is very close to being enough to make it jump again. Then any overshoot in the stress on this segment that occured during the actual avalanche will, if the resulting peak stress is above the quasistatic final stress, cause it to undergo an extra jump. If, as is indeed the case, there is a small density of these extra jumps roughly randomly distributed within the avalanche, each of the extra jumps will trigger extra avalanches, for which one again has to consider the effects of the stress overshoots which make more avalanches, etc. One can show that this process will always run away for a sufficiently large avalanche — independent of how small the stress overshoots might be [11,25]. The stress peaks are thus a relevant perturbation which will change the critical behavior. Indeed, the runaway of large avalanches implies the coexistence of moving and stationary states and strongly suggests that the depinning transition in the presence of stress pulses will be either first order with a discontinuous and probably hysteretic vN (F) or have a continuous vN (F) but with a smaller critical force and different critical behavior [25]. What happens if the stress overshoots are small, say with strength parameterized by R? Then only avalanches with ¸5¸R&1/R1@yR
(139)
will typically be much affected by the stress peaks. The exponent yR is the RG eigenvalue for the relevant perturbation, R; it has been computed analytically [11,25] and checked numerically [25] for some types of stress overshoots, but it’s value is not yet understood analytically for the type of long-tail stress peaks that occur in the crack problem [25,37]. Experiments on very slowly advancing cracks confined to a plane [38] yield an estimate of the roughness exponent which characterizes the deviations of the crack front from a straight line, of f +0.55$.05 #3!#, &30/5
(140)
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
145
substantially larger then the quasistatic prediction of 1. However the large corrections to scaling 3 predicted by the RG analysis [25,39] may account for this discrepancy; beware of quoted error bars for exponents! It is possible, however, that real elastodynamic effects play a role even for slowly moving planar cracks. A related challenge is to understand the crack front distortions which manifest themselves in the roughness of the fracture surface left behind after a crack front passes: i.e. after the material is broken [16,36,40]. Again, elastodynamic effects may play a crucial role. In certain situations, cracks can form multiple branches — such as shattering of glass-, or just a few small branches near the crack front [35]. Under what circumstances crack branching might affect the onset of crack motion or the large scale shape of fracture surfaces is another open question. 7.4. Faults So far, except for crack front roughness, we have only discussed systems for which the simple measurements are of macroscopic properties such as vN (F). But there is one natural system in which, even though the length scales are huge, the measurements are of “microscopic” type: specifically, the statistics and other properties of “avalanches”. A crude model of a geological fault is the motion of two large blocks of crust in contact along a disordered but roughly planar surface, the fault, which move relative to each other; see Fig. 10. The motion is driven by forces exerted from far away (e.g. from the viscoelastic region beneath the crust) that are transmitted to the fault by the elasticity of the blocks. Rather than being driven by a constant force, the blocks are driven at a fixed time-averaged velocity that is extremely slow — of order millimeters to centimeters per year — compared to other characteristic velocities — e.g. the speed of sound in the rock [10]. Segments of the two dimensional fault plane interact with each other by long range 1/r3 stress transfer —as can be seen by dimensional analysis— and are pinned by heterogeneities on the two fault surfaces that have to rub past each other [11]. Earthquakes, of course, are just the “avalanches” that occur when some segment of the fault becomes unpinned and jumps forward triggering others [12,41]. The range of length scales of slipping regions is huge: from meters to hundreds of kilometers, with slips — changes in relative displacement across the fault plane *u — from millimeters to tens of meters.
Fig. 10. Schematic of two segments of crust which move relative to each other along a fault plane in a sequence of earthquakes. The driving forces are transmitted to the fault by the two halves of the crust moving with relative velocity, v.
146
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
Most theoretical approaches to modelling faults have involved physics driven by friction laws and inertial effects [42], with intrinsic heterogeneities playing a secondary role if included at all. An alternative approach [11], motivated by the systems we have discussed here, might be to start from the opposite end, a strongly disordered fault with quasistatic stress transfer, and then bring in other features such as elastic wave propagation (which is the manifestation of inertia) and frictional weakening. This has the advantage of building on an established theoretical framework in which the importance — or lack thereof — of various features can be considered. This is particularly useful as the parameter space in even relatively simple models is very large and thus hard to explore numerically — at least in ways that might convince a skeptic of the interpretations or predictions! If the forces that one side of the fault exerts on the other are independent of the history and the local slip velocities u(r, t)/t and the stress transfer is quasistatic, i.e. J &d(t)/r3, then this system qs falls into the class of generalized interface models with d"2 and a"1. But for this a, two is exactly the upper critical dimension so we can use the results of the toy model. The fault system acts as if it were driven just below F (by an amount that goes to zero for large system size) so that we can set # e"0.6 [Note that there should be logarithmic corrections to various quantities, as is usual at critical dimensions, but their effects are small]. The toy model is sufficiently simple, that one can include a realistic way of driving the faults, but for now we consider the simpler idealized infinite system. Several results can immediately be used [11]: the area of the region of the fault that slips in an earthquake will scale as the square of its diameter, ¸, the typical slip in this region will depend only logarithmically on ¸ (i.e. f"0), and the size, in this context called the moment, will scale as
P
M" dr *u(r)&¸2 .
(141)
Note that the moment magnitude often quoted in newspapers is m"log M#constant , (142) 30 the base 30 being for historical reasons, particularly consistency with the older Richter magnitude scale. The probability of different sized events in the simple model is Prob (moment'M)&1/MB
(143)
with B"1. 2 How do these predictions compare with observations? The moment of quakes is the best measured quantity, although for medium and larger size events, the duration q can also be measured well. The diameter — or generally the dimensions of the slipped region — and the slip *u can only be measured directly if the quake involves slip where the fault breaks through the surface of the earth. However, earthquake data are usually interpreted in terms of a crack picture in which
6 Whether critical behavior is considered “self-organized” or not is somewhat a matter of taste: if the systems we are considering are driven at very slow velocity, then they will be very close to critical. In another well known situation, when a fluid is stirred on large scales, turbulence exists on a wide range of length scales extending down to the scale at which viscous dissipation occurs. In both of these and in many other contexts the parameter which is “tuned” to get a wide range of scales is the ratio of some basic “microscopic” scale to the scale at which the system is driven.
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
147
f"1 and z"1 so that M
&¸3&q3 (144) #3!#, [10]. This scaling appears to be reasonably well justified observationally for large earthquakes and the M&q3 scaling perhaps also for intermediate size events. But for small events — i.e. most of them — only the moment can be measured reasonably reliably. Thus, perhaps, our M&¸2&q2 might not be ruled out for small events although it probably is for large ones. Note however, that in quakes of magnitude m"7 or so and above, the linear size (e.g. the diameter) is comparable to the depth of the crust (and other relevant length scales) so different scaling laws should in any case be expected for large earthquakes with a crossover between the two regimes [43]. The question of earthquake magnitude statistics is a complicated and controversial one. The famous Gutenberg—Richter law [44] states that the distribution of all earthquakes approximately satisfies Eq. (143) with a B+2, although it changes somewhat — perhaps for the reasons mentioned 3 above — around magnitude seven. The data cover over 12 orders of magnitude in the moment, equivalent to, assuming the crack scaling Eq. (144), four orders of magnitude in length scale. Understanding the Gutenberg—Richter law is a very interesting problem, tied closely to that of understanding the apparent fractal distribution of some geological features such as fault networks [41]. But our subject here is individual faults — at least if they really exist as well defined entities, a question which is also controversial. Observations of some highly disordered faults have been fitted — over a reasonable range — with B&0.5—0.6 [45]. This is perhaps encouraging although the apparent rough agreement with our Eq. (143) may well be fortuitous. Most faults, however, exhibit quite different behavior: a small regime (if at all) of power law statistics that can be fit by somewhat larger Bs, then a gap with few events and a narrow peak (which dominates the total slip) at a characteristic earthquake size in which the whole fault section slips [45]. This behavior, sketched in Fig. 11 (bottom), appears to be very different from the power-law scaling behavior we have found in our simple quasistatic heterogeneous model. However, behavior qualitatively similar to Fig. 11 (bottom) — with large characteristic earthquakes — has been found in simulations of models with inertia and frictional weakening but no intrinsic randomness although analytic understanding of these results is rather limited [42]. Can we understand qualitatively how both power-law and characteristic-earthquake types of behavior might arise starting from our simple randomness-dominated picture? Elastodynamic effects, as for the crack front problem discussed earlier, will result in peaks in the dynamic stress transfer that are larger than the static stress transfer. In addition, frictional weakening — the tendency for dynamic frictional forces to be less than static frictional forces — will also be present. Both of these effects will cause extra segments to slip that would not have slipped in quasistatic events. These, as for the crack front, will cause runaway of large earthquakes which will eventually be stopped only by strong “pinning” caused by the boundaries of the fault section, or by the unloading of the shear stress that is driving the fault. If the stress overshoot and frictional weakening effects are small, there should be a wide regime of power law scaling with B"1 which 2 can extend out to the largest quakes in the fault section. But if these effects are strong — as one might guess would be the case for a weakly disordered fault that is close to planar — intermediate size events will not occur and the behavior will be qualitatively similar to the characteristic-quake behavior observed in many faults [11]. Which behavior obtains would be determined by how the length scale above which events typically runaway compares with the length of the fault section.
148
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
Fig. 11. Schematic of two types of earthquake statistics observed on different geological faults; see [42]. The probability of quakes with a given moment is plotted on a log—log scale. (top) A fault with power law statistics of events. (bottom) A fault that exhibits “characteristic earthquake” behavior which refers to the peak in the distribution for large events of a characteristic size, with not many intermediate size events occurring.
Although this basic scenario of fault dynamics that was found in the simple heterogeneous fault model may have nothing to do with what happens in the real earth, analog laboratory systems might be found, or synthesized, in which some of these ideas could be tested. In these lecture notes, we have outlined a framework for studying the non-equilibrium “critical” behavior that occurs near the onset of macroscopic motion in many driven systems. This enables us to understand the origins, nature, and statistics of avalanche-like events that can occur in these systems, as well as other qualitative and quantitative aspects of the critcal behavior. But the examples given in this section have also illustrated a key point of these lectures: to be really useful, a phenomenological framework should be broad enough and robust enough to show the roots of its own failure. With judicious choice of which experimental systems to focus on — and some luck — this should enable enough predictions to be made that theoretical results and underlying assumptions built into models are falsifiable!
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150
149
Note on references. Since the literature in many of the areas discussed here is vast, I have generally tried to include references to papers that elucidate the main points using a framework similar to that of these notes, to review or introductory articles, and to recent papers that contain references to earlier literature, rather than referring directly to all the relevant original papers.
Acknowledgements Whatever understanding the author might have of the problems discussed here is due in large part to interactions over the past 15 years with students, postdocs and colleagues too numerous to mention. I am most grateful to all of them. I would also like to thank Jennifer Schwarz for comments on a preliminary version of the manuscript. This work has been supported in part by the National Science Foundation via grants DMR 9106237, DMR 9630064, and Harvard University’s MRSEC.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13]
[14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20]
P.G. deGennes, Rev. Mod. Phys. 57 (1985) 827. E. Ertas, M. Kardar, Phys. Rev. E 49 (1994) R2532. T. Natterman, S. Stepanow, L.-H. Tang, H. Leschorn, J. Phys. (France) II 2 (1992) 1483. O. Narayan, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993) 5949. The renormalization group analysis is based on that in [3]. J.B. Stokes, D.A. Weitz, J.P. Gollub, A. Dougherty, M.O. Robbins, P.M. Chaikin, H.M. Lindsay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57 (1986) 1718. G. Blatter, M.V. Feigelman, V.B. Geshkenbein, A.I. Larkin, V. Vinokur, Rev. Mod. Phys. 66 (1988) 1125 and references therein. For a general introduction to vortex dynamics, see M. Tinkham, Introduction to Superconductivity, 2nd ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, 1996. G. Gruner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 60 (1988) 1075 and references therein. D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 31 (1985) 1396. O. Narayan, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 46 (1992) 11520. For a general reference on earthquake dynamics, see e.g. K. Kanimori, E. Boschi (Eds.), Earthquakes: Observation, Theory, and Interpretation, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1983. D.S. Fisher, K. Dahmen, S. Ramanathan, Y. Ben-Zion, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997) 4885. D.S. Fisher, Friction and forced flow: collective transport in disordered media, in: A.R. Bishop, D.K. Campbell, P. Kumar, S. Trullinger (Eds.), Nonlinearity in Condensed Matter, Springer, New York, 1987. The importance of “avalanche” like phenomena in a variety of physical systems has been emphasized by P. Bak, C. Tang and collaborators, see e.g. P. Bak, C. Tang, C. Wiesenfeld, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 381; P. Bak, K. Chen, Sci. Am. 264 (1991) 46, and this and other critical-like phenomena dubbed “self-organized criticality”. See also [6,12]. P.C. Hohenberg, B.I. Halperin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 49 (1977) 435, for a review of equilibrium dynamic critical phenomena. S. Ramanathan, D. Ertas, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79 (1997) 873. H. Larralde, R.C. Ball, Europhys. Lett. 30 (1995) 287. A.A. Middleton, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 47 (1993) 3530. A.A. Middleton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68 (1992) 670. M. Kardar, Phys. Rep. 299 (1998) in this volume. The scaling law for distribution of avalanche sizes is the same as that in mean field models of “sandpiles” (see P. Bak, C. Tang, J. Stat. Phys. 51 (1988) 797) as well as that of cluster sizes in the mean field theory of percolation [22].
150 [21] [22] [23] [24]
[25] [26]
[27] [28] [29] [30]
[31] [32] [33] [34] [35]
[36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41]
[42] [43] [44] [45]
D.S. Fisher / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 113—150 K. Dahmen, J.P. Sethna, Phys. Rev. B 53 (1996) 14872. D. Stauffer, A. Aharony, Introduction to Percolation Theory, 2nd ed., Taylor & Francis, London, 1991. O. Narayan, A.A. Middleton, Phys. Rev. B 49 (1994) 244. J.T. Chayes, L. Chayes, D.S. Fisher, T. Spencer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57 (1986) 299; Comm. Math. Phys. 120 (1989) 501 present rigorous results and generalizations of a result of A.B. Harris, J. Phys. C 7 (1974) 1671, on correlation length exponents in random systems. S. Ramanathan, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B, in press; S. Ramanathan, Ph.D. Thesis, Harvard University, 1997. Other authors have found f+1; see J. Schmittbuhl, S. Roux, J.-P. Vilotte, K.J. Ma> l+y, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 (1995) 2 1787; P.B. Thomas, M. Paczuski, cond-mat 9602023. It is not clear whether the differences between these results and f+1 can be attributed to corrections to scaling or to some other source. 3 M.J. Higgins, S. Bhattacharya, A.A. Middleton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 3784. A.A. Middleton, Phys. Rev. B 45 (1992) 9465. S.N. Coppersmith, Phys. Rev. Lett. 65 (1990) 1044. The possible stability to dislocations of an elastic solid in a three dimensional weakly random medium has been discussed by various authors including J. Kierfeld, T. Natterman, T. Hwa, Phys. Rev. B 55 (1997) 626; T. Giamarchi, P. LeDoussal, Phys. Rev. B 52 (1995) 1242; D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997) 1964; see also [6]. D.S. Fisher, M.P.A. Fisher, D.A. Huse, Phys. Rev. B 43 (1991) 130; D.A. Huse, D.S. Fisher, M.P.A. Fisher, Nature 358 (1992) 553, for an introduction to the basic issues involved. M.J. Higgins, S. Bhattacharya, Physica C 257 (1996) 232. J. Watson, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. B 54 (1996) 938; Phys. Rev. B 55 (1997) 14909; A.-C. Shi, A.J. Berlinsky, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 1926. T. Matsuda et al., Science 271 (1996) 1393. For a general reference on analytical work on fracture dynamics, see L.B. Freund, Dynamic Fracture Mechanics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1990; and for a more phenomenological treatment, see B. Lawn, Fracture of Brittle Solids, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1993. S. Ramanathan, D.S. Fisher, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79 (1997) 877. J.R. Willis, A.B. Movchan, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 43 (1995) 319. J. Schmittbuhl, K.J. Ma> l+y, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997) 3888. O. Narayan, private communication. E. Bouchaud, J. Phys. C 9 (1997) 4319 and references therein. Various authors have studied the development and dynamics of fault networks using models that are somewhat related to those discussed here; see, e.g., K. Chen, P. Bak, S.P. Obukhov, Phys. Rev. A 43 (1991) 625; P.A. Cowie, C. Vanneste, D. Sornette, J. Geophys. Res. 98 (1993) 21809; P. Miltenberger, D. Sornette, C. Vanneste, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993) 3604; and references therein. See, e.g. J.M. Carlson, J.S. Langer, B.E. Shaw, Rev. Mod. Phys. 66 (1994) 658 and references therein. J.F. Pacheco, C.H. Schulz, L.R. Sykes, Nature 355 (1992) 71. B. Gutenberg, K.F. Richter, Ann. Geophys. 9 (1996) 1. S.G. Wesnowsky, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. 84 (1994) 1940, has analyzed the statistics of earthquakes on various faults in California.
Physics Reports 301 (1998) 151—185
Deterministic chaos and the foundations of the kinetic theory of gases J.R. Dorfman* Institute for Physical Science and Technology and Department of Physics, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland, 20742, USA
Abstract Recent work in dynamical systems theory has shown that many properties that are associated with irreversible processes in fluids can be understood in terms of the dynamical properties of reversible, Hamiltonian systems. That is, stochastic like behavior is possible for these systems. Here we review the basic theory for this stochastic-like behavior and show how it may be used to obtain an understanding of irreversible processes in gases and fluids. Recent, closely related, work on the use of kinetic theory to calculate dynamical quantities such as Lyapunov exponents is also discussed. ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 05.40.#j; 05.45.#b; 05.60.#w
1. Introduction Dynamical systems theory [1], of which chaos theory is a part, has its origins in two famous problems of classical physics: to find a solution for the three-body problem of celestial mechanics [2], and to find a proof of Boltzmann’s ergodic hypothesis for the equivalence of time and ensemble averages of dynamical quantities (such as the force per unit area on the wall of the container) for isolated systems composed of a large number of particles [3]. In each case a great deal of progress toward an understanding of both the possibilities and difficulties in finding solutions to these problems has been made possible, over the past several decades, by the development of powerful and sophisticated mathematical and computer methods. These developments are well summarized in a number of excellent books and papers on dynamical systems theory, some of which are listed as Refs. [1,4—7] as well as references contained therein. This article is a summary of a more extensive set of notes on this subject developed by the author
* E-mail: [email protected]. 0370-1573/98/$19.00 ( 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved PII S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 9 8 ) 0 0 0 0 9 - X
152
J.R. Dorfman / Physics Reports 301 (1998) 151—185
which presents these topics in a somewhat more leisurely way, and also contains an extensive discussion of the Boltzmann transport equation [8]. Another discussion of many of these topics can be found in Ref. [9]. The purpose of this article is to explain some of these developments and to explore their application to the issues that preoccupied Boltzmann, namely the foundations of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics, with a particular emphasis on the foundations of the kinetic theory of dilute gases of particles that interact with short-range forces [10—12]. The dynamical properties of such a dilute gas are somewhat easier to understand than those for other states of matter since in the main, the dynamics of a particle in a dilute gas consists of long periods of motion free from interactions with the other particles, punctuated by occasional and essentially brief collisions with other particles in the gas. That is, for a gas of particles with short-range forces, the mean free time between collisions is much longer than the average duration of a collision. Even for such an apparently simple system complicated and difficult questions arise such as: How does one reconcile the reversible equations of motion with the irreversible macroscopic properties of such a system, particularly as seen in the Second Law of Thermodynamics concerning the irreversible increase of entropy? Why is the Boltzmann equation, which is admittedly derived on the basis of stochastic rather than mechanical assumptions, so successful in predicting the properties of dilute gases, and in explaining the origin of the hydrodynamic properties of the gas? and so on. This article will try to show how such questions might be answered by chaos theory and to indicate the general lines of the answers, to the extent that the issues are understood at present. Our discussions will be based at first upon the work of Bowen [13], Ruelle [4,14], and Sinai [15], who are the principal architects of the modern theory of the dynamical foundations of statistical mechanics. Recent developments due to major contributions of many other authors will also be described here, with appropriate, though certainly incomplete, references to the literature [16]. The plan of this article is as follows: In Section 2 we will review the basic ideas of ergodicity and mixing for dynamical systems, and show their importance for statistical mechanics. We discuss the role of systems with few degrees of freedom, such as the baker’s map and the Arnold cat map, as systems that exhibit ergodic and mixing properties and serve as paradigms for the kinds of properties we would like to see in systems with many degrees of freedom. The exa