ELECTRONIC, SPECTROSCOPIC AND ELASTIC PROPERTIES OF EARLY TRANSITION METAL COMPOUNDS
I. POLLINI, A. MOSSER, J. C. PARLEBAS INFM, Dipartimento di Fisica dell+Universita` di Milano, Via Celoria 16; I-20133 Milano, Italy IPCMS - CNRS (UM 7504), 23 rue du loess, F-67037 Strasbourg Cedex, France
AMSTERDAM } LONDON } NEW YORK } OXFORD } PARIS } SHANNON } TOKYO
Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Electronic, spectroscopic and elastic properties of early transition metal compounds I. Pollinia , A. Mosserb , J.C. Parlebasb; ∗ a
INFM, Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Universita di Milano, Via Celoria 16; I-20133 Milano, Italy b IPCMS, CNRS (UM 7504), 23 rue du loess, F-67037 Strasbourg Cedex, France Received December 2000; editor: D:L: Mills
Contents 1. Introduction 1.1. Basic remarks and a brief overview 1.2. Delocalized and localized models 1.3. The e1ects of electron correlations on spectroscopic properties 2. Pretransition and scandium compounds 2.1. Model formulation of the core level XPS 2.2. Tendencies at the very beginning of the series 3. Titanium compounds 3.1. Electron band structure and valence band XPS of Ti dioxides 3.2. Ti core level XPS spectra of TiO2 3.3. A few insights about Ti2 O3 4. Vanadium compounds 4.1. BIS, valence band and core level XPS of V2 O5 , VO2 and V2 O3
3 3 6 10 18 18 20 22 23 25 28 29 29
4.2. Resonant photoemission 4.3. A related problem: VCn clusters for V adsorption on graphite 5. Chromium compounds 5.1. Valence band XPS and BIS 5.2. Core level XPS 6. Systematic trends 7. Spectroscopic and elastic properties of sub-stoichiometric TiCx , and TiNx compounds 7.1. Core level XPS 7.2. Electron band structure and valence band XPS of Ti carbides and nitrides 7.3. Young’s modulus 8. Summary and outlook 9. Glossary of symbols and acronyms Acknowledgements References
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: 00-33-3-88107072; fax: 00-33-3-88107249. E-mail addresses:
[email protected] (I. Pollini),
[email protected] (A. Mosser),
[email protected] (J.C. Parlebas).
c 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. 0370-1573/01/$ - see front matter PII: S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 0 1 8 - 7
32 34 40 40 44 48 50 51 52 59 61 64 66 66
2
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Abstract Photoemission experiments on early 3d transition metal compounds (TMC), involving both valence bands and core levels of the 3d elements, are reviewed. Extensive use is made of ab initio schemes as well as simple models and the emphasis is put on understanding the results of experiments more than on the experimental details and methods. Compounds of the TMs are Drst analyzed in terms of ab initio band structure calculations, which are shown to be usually suEcient as far as the interpretation of valence photoemission spectra is concerned. A discussion of ultraviolet valence band photoemission (UPS) and bremsstrahlung isochromat spectroscopy (BIS) is also made. Other theories involving conDguration interaction (CI) in the modelization are then shown to be necessary for an understanding of the core-level photoemission spectra and the observed satellite features. The electronic structure of a wide range of early TMCs, from Sc to Cr, is discussed by means of the CI cluster model analysis of the metal 2s-, 2p-, 3s- and 3p-level X-ray photoemission spectra (XPS). Early TMCs, like Ti, V, Cr oxides and halides (e.g. CrF3 , CrCl3 ) have been originally regarded as typical Mott–Hubbard (MH) systems. The MH model results from the electron correlations which dominate the inter-atomic overlaps that lead to bands. The concept of 3d-ligand orbital hybridization leads to the Zaanen–Sawatsky–Allen (ZSA) theory and to the charge transfer (CT) systems. Moreover, we discuss how the analysis of 3s XPS spectra can predict or not the formation of localized magnetic moments. The values of the charge transfer energy and d–d Coulomb repulsion energy U point to systematic trends for the early TM compounds as found in the case of late TM compounds. Simple and competing mechanisms for the excitation of photoemission satellites are presented and the systematic trends for the compounds of the early TM series are discussed. Finally, in addition to the study of the above stoichiometric compounds, we review recent results on the electronic properties of substoichiometric binary alloy (TiNx , TiCx ) by means of core and valence XPS spectra. Self-consistent ab initio calculations with empty spheres at the empty lattice ligand sites performed on these alloys provide the total densities of the occupied states to be compared with the observed valence XPS spectra. An extension of calculations to full potential methods is necessary c 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights for interpreting the elastic properties, e.g. the bulk modulus. reserved. PACS: 79.60.−i; 71.20.−b; 61.72.−y Keywords: Valence and core XPS; BIS; Transition metal compounds; Electronic structure; Electron correlations; Cluster model; Substoichiometric compounds; Bulk modulus
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
3
1. Introduction In this introducting section we would like to brieJy recall a few basic ideas concerning the electronic structure of transition metal compounds (Sections 1.1 and 1.2). The purpose is not to provide an exhaustive state of the art of the subject, but rather to introduce a few concepts, especially on the description of electron correlations (Section 1.3), which will be further developed in the following chapters. 1.1. Basic remarks and brief overview Transition metal compounds (TMC) have been a subject of study for many years because of their diverse physical properties. In spite of their apparently similar electronic structures, having unDlled 3d shells, their electrical conductivities vary widely from metallic to insulating behavior, and they show besides diverse magnetic properties. According to independent electron band theory most of TMCs should be metallic because of their unDlled 3d shells. Some of them (CuS, NiTe, CoS, VO2 ) are indeed metals, but many compounds are insulators (CuO, NiF2 , NiO, CrCl3 ) or subject to metal-to-nonmetal transitions (NiS, V2 O3 , Ti2 O3 ) depending on temperature or pressure. To solve this apparent contradiction Mott (1949, 1990) and Hubbard (1963, 1964a) considered the following charge Juctuations of interatomic type: din djn → din−1 djn+1 ;
(1.1)
where i and j label TM sites and n is the number of d electrons per site (Fig. 1.1a). They proposed that for electronic conduction to occur the energy required for the above process should be less than the 3d band (dispersional) bandwidth w (Fig. 1.2). That is, for some TMCs, the large value of the d–d Coulomb energy U makes it impossible for the charge Juctuation in Eq. (1.1) to occur, so that these compounds become Mott–Hubbard (MH) insulators (U ¿w) in spite of their unDlled d shells. However, when U ¡w, TMCs will be metallic, as predicted by elementary band theory. MH model was devised to explain the insulating nature of NiO (U ¿w), which in a one electron picture would be metallic due to the partial occupation of the Ni 3d shell (formally 3d 8 , Ni2+ ) (Feinleib and Adler, 1968). However, in its simplest form MH
Fig. 1.1. Schematic representation of an ionic lattice consisting of TM ions (d n ) and closed shell anions. Charge Juctuation excitations in MH (a) and CT (b) regimes are illustrated. In the CT regime the p–d hybridization (V) between TM and ligands (L) is also indicated.
4
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 1.2. Energy level diagrams corresponding to an ionic ground state and electron removal excitation spectra. The dispersion 3d bandwidth w and the anion (p-like) valence bandwidth W are shown. The Coulomb energy ∼ EG + W=2) are indicated for the excitations as shown in parameter U and the charge transfer energy parameter (= Fig. 1.1.
theory fails to account for the metallic behavior of NiS, although even in this case is U ¿w. First of all, the theory requires a wide range of U values (depending on anions), from higher values of about 8–10 eV in insulating compounds, such as NiO (Fujimori and Minami, 1984; Sawatzky and Allen, 1984; Hufner et al., 1984; Sawatzky, 1987; Hufner, 1985, 1994, 1995; Bengone et al., 2000) to lower values of the same order of magnitude as the 3d bandwidth w (less than 1 eV) in metallic compounds, such as CuS, NiS and CoS (Sawatzky and Allen, 1984; Hufner, 1985; Usuda and Hamada, 2000). Besides, the conductivity gap in late 3d TMCs appears to be directly related to anion electronegativity. Such a big change of the U parameter and the bandgap variation with anions are not likely to be described adequately by the MH model. Since TM 3d electrons are fairly localized in TMCs it is diEcult to explain why the correlation energy (U ) and bandgap (Eg) values are so much dependent upon the anions. The MH model can probably better explain the properties of some early TMCs (Sc, Ti, V, Cr) as compared to the case of late TMCs (Cu, Ni, Co, Fe). A comprehensive discussion of the properties of TMCs in the framework of the MH picture has been reviewed some years ago by Adler (1968), Wilson (1972, 1973, 1985) and Brandow (1977). In 1985 a theory due to Zaanen et al. (ZSA) was proposed to describe the band gap and electronic structure of TMCs consistently, by modifying the conventional MH model (Zaanen et al., 1985; Sawatzky, 1987). This theory considers two types of charge Juctuations for the conduction mechanism. The Drst one, described in Eq (1.1), is the “interatomic polar Juctuation” or MH-type Juctuation. The other type of charge Juctuation is the charge transfer (CT) process between ligand p and metal d levels: din → djn+1 L ;
(1.2)
where L denotes a hole in the anion p band (Fig. 1.1b). The CT process requires to take into account the charge transfer energy . The conductivity gap is always determined by the minimum energy for the creation of uncorrelated electrons and holes excited from the ground state (Fig. 1.2). ZSA theory makes use of the single impurity Anderson (1961) model (SIAM)
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
5
Fig. 1.3. (a) One-electron diagram for TMCs (oxides). The di1erent nature of the band gap is shown in (b) the Mott–Hubbard diagram for a TMC, with Udd ¡ and EG (MH) = Udd ; (c) the charge transfer-diagram for a TMC, with Udd ¿ and EG (CT) = .
or its extension to the periodic Anderson model (PAM), the so-called “two hybridized band” MH model (e.g. Parlebas, 1990 and refs. therein). The signiDcant parameters of the theory are the hybridization strength V between the ligand (L) band and metal 3d states, the anion valence bandwidth W (∼5 eV), the Coulomb energy U , the d bandwidth w and the charge transfer energy . Thus, according to ZSA theory, TMCs can be classiDed as metals (U ¡w or ¡W ) and insulators in the MH regime (w¡U ¡) or insulators in the CT regime (W=2¡¡U ). Fig. 1.3 presents some typical diagrams used for the description of the electronic properties of transition metal oxides (TMOs) and TMCs. Progress in photoemission spectroscopy (PES) has allowed the direct determination of the parameters of the theory from the experimental data (Hufner, 1995). One of most reliable methods for investigating the electronic structures of TMCs is X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS), particularly when it is supplemented by inverse photoemission and ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS). In fact, valence band XPS spectra (v-XPS) measure the energy of the Dlled states and bremsstrahlung isochromat spectroscopy (BIS) that of the empty conduction states, either for stoichiometric and substoichiometric compounds (see Section 7.2). Moreover, one cannot discuss high energy spectra, such as core level photoemission or photoabsorption spectra (c-XPS or XAS), without explicitly taking into account the hybridization e1ects between
6
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
TM 3d orbitals and L orbitals, as it was shown in the case of late TMCs (van der Laan et al., 1981; Fujimori and Minami, 1984; Okada and Kotani, 1992a, 1993). Many TMCs also show weak satellite structures, which are often studied in TM 2p core level spectra. In insulating Cu halides, for instance, satellite features have been explained by a model which is based on the same physical picture and uses the same parameters (; U; V ) for the analysis of UPS and BIS spectra (van der Laan et al., 1981). In c-XPS spectra a new parameter Udc (=Q), the Coulomb attraction energy between the core hole and the 3d electrons, is introduced. By Dtting the energy positions and intensities of the main peak and satellites in 2p-XPS spectra, one can determine the parameters ; U; V and Udc , which in turn give information on the electronic structure of the valence band. The interpretation of PES satellite structures, as due to di1erent screening channels, was Drst proposed for La metal by Kotani and Toyozawa (Kotani and Toyozawa, 1973, 1974) on the basis of the Anderson model and subsequently applied to other metals and insulators by Gunnarsson and Schonhammer (1983, 1985) and Kotani et al. (1988). Neglecting the widths of TM 3d and L valence bands one obtains the so-called cluster model (CM), which is based on a molecular orbital description (Asada and Sugano, 1976; Larsson, 1975, 1976), and is equivalent to the CT model. Finally, it is worthwhile to recall that other powerful experimental techniques are used for the study of the electronic structure of TMCs, such as resonant photoemission spectroscopy (RPES), Raman scattering or soft X-ray emission spectroscopy (SXES). In particular, RPES (Davis, 1982, 1986) and SXES (Ederer and McGuire, 1996) can be useful for determining the nature of the band gaps and investigating hybridization e1ects in TMCs. In principle, a unique set of parameters (; U; V; : : :) should be valid in order to analyse the results from di1erent experimental techniques (XPS, XAS, XES; : : :). 1.2. Localized and delocalized models In this section we just recall a few basic concepts of the ligand (or crystal) Deld theory (LFT) (Section 1.2.1) and band picture (Section 1.2.2), as far as TMCs are concerned. 1.2.1. Ligand (crystal) <eld theory It is well known that 3d orbitals are split in energy by the surrounding ligand Deld (LF) in TMCs. This e1ect is not primarily due to the electrostatic repulsion, but comes from the bonding interactions of TM orbitals with L orbitals (Sections 3.2 and 4.3). The hybridized d states are really combinations of TM d and ligand p orbitals. The d orbitals which point directly towards ligand atoms form combinations with a stronger degree of overlap than combinations, formed by d orbitals pointing between the ligand atoms. The antibonding orbitals are higher in energy and this forms a major contribution to LF splitting. Sometimes the d state bandwidth may be less than LF splitting, giving a gap between lower t2g and upper eg bands. In this case, a compound with six d electrons can have a full t2g band and be non-metallic. However, quite a number of TMCs are metallic and have a d band a few eV wide. A simple approach for understanding the electronic structure in TMCs and interpreting photoemission and photoabsorption spectra is given by the localized CM. If one considers a TM ion surrounded by L ions with the assumption that electron correlation is so strong that electronic excitations are essentially atomlike, then only a small cluster needs to be considered.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
7
Many investigators have treated the CM with the LFT by including the multiplet e1ects in the TM ion. In this case the optical spectra have been interpreted in terms of forbidden transitions within the crystal Deld multiplets of the d n conDguration (Sugano et al., 1970). These ideas have provided a starting point for the discussion of UPS and XPS data Drst obtained in TMCs (Eastman and Freeouf, 1975; Hufner and Wertheim, 1975; Pollini, 1994). In this case, one expects that the photoemission intensity at the top of the valence band will be dominated by d emission because the TM d state cross section is larger than that of ligand p levels at most photon energies. The main parameters of LFT are the splitting between the eg and t2g levels (10Dq) and the Racah integrals A, B and C, which are linear combinations of the Slater integrals F0 , F2 and F4 . UPS measurements made on NiO, CoO, FeO, MnO and Cr 2 O3 (Eastman and Freeouf, 1975) have given the partial density of states (DOS) for the O2p and TM3d states. 6 e2 with symmetry The NiO (3d 8 ) compound, for example, has a ground state conDguration t2g g 3 A . The photoemission process would then correspond to a transition to the 3d 7 conDguration 2g 6 e1 (2 E) plus a continuum electron and the dipole selection rule will give the three Dnal states t2g g 5 2 4 2 and t2g eg ( T1g and T1g ) with relative intensities 2, 4 and 2, respectively. A similar analysis was also made for XPS data (Wertheim and Hufner, 1972). These studies have indicated that the 3d states are conDned to a narrow 3d band (1–2 eV) located at about 3 eV above the O2p band (Eastman and Freeouf, 1975; Uozumi et al., 1993). The same picture was later used for describing the main 3d emission in v-XPS spectra of trivalent Cr halides (Pollini, 1994, 1998). In Cr 3+ compounds (3d 3 ; CrCl3 and Cr 2 O3 ) all 3d-electrons are in a spin-up state and therefore, irrespective of which electron is photoemitted, the Dnal state is always a triplet and a single peak should be observed in the photoemission spectra of CrCl3 and Cr 2 O3 compounds (Section 5.1). In the same spirit, in Fig. 1.4, the UPS spectra of Ti2 O3 (3d 1 ), V2 O3 (3d2 ), Fe2 O3 (3d 5 ) and NiO (3d 8 ) are reported and compared to each other. With increasing 3d-shell occupation, the cation 3d and O2p bands move closer to each other, indicating an increasing hybridization. This fact has suggested that Ti2 O3 and V2 O3 might be considered MH compounds with a correlation gap between occupied and unoccupied d-states (lower and upper Hubbard bands), while Fe2 O3 and NiO should be more likely CT compounds, with a correlation gap containing the O2p states (Hufner, 1985, 1995). We recall however that this simple picture may break down in some cases, when one makes c-XPS or RPES experiments. As a matter of fact, it turns out to be necessary to include the e1ect of conDguration interactions (CI) in the CM in order to reach a better agreement with experiment (Fujimori and Minami, 1984; Davis, 1986; Parlebas et al., 1990; see also Sections 3.2 and 4.3). As recalled, many of these compounds are metals and present a 3d band 2–4 eV wide, as it occurs, for example, in TiO, TiC and TiN compounds (Ohring, 1992; Soriano et al., 1997; Guemmaz et al., 1997a and refs. therein). These compounds may also contain a large proportion of lattice vacancies, which make the lattice to contract and decrease the distance between metal atoms resulting in a large overlap between them. Section 7 will be devoted to the study of lattice e1ects observed in TiC and TiN. 1.2.2. Limitations of the band picture The band picture of electrons fails when the various interactions neglected in band calculations, such as non-periodic potentials, electron–phonon interaction or parts of the
8
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 1.4. UPS spectra of Ti2 O3 ; V2 O3 ; Fe2 O3 and NiO compounds (adapted from Hufner, 1995).
electron–electron interaction, become larger than the band width. Electron–electron interaction is taken into account to some extent in the usual band calculation (mean Deld theory) and, when the Hartree–Fock approximation is applicable, the one-electron excitation energies are determined from the calculated band structure. This is known as the Koopman’s theorem (Kittel, 1963). For example, the energy of a semiconductor is simply given as the energy di1erence between the bottom of the conduction band and the top of the valence band. It is the sum of the energies needed to extract an electron from the top of the valence band to inDnity and that of adding an electron to the bottom of the conduction band. When electron correlation is large, however, the energy gap cannot be obtained so simply, because the energy spectrum itself is altered at every stage of the process. In the Madelung description of an ionic solid core and valence state energies were simply obtained by correcting the free-ion energy levels by the electrostatic potential existing at the site of each ion. This approach was successful for core levels, but did not give a good description of the valence electrons, since it neglected the e1ects of wave-function overlap leading to band formation and hybridization. A better description of the electronic properties of TMCs requires a complete band structure calculation, where the inclusion of intra-atomic exchange can account for the insulating properties in some cases (Mattheiss, 1972). The reason for the failure of the band model in TMCs is the neglect of the electron repulsion, which gives a MH or CT insulator, although metallic properties can be observed when the TM orbital overlap is strong enough. The fact that TiO and VO are metallic, but MnO, FeO, CoO and NiO are not, can be understood in consideration of the large overlap of 3d orbitals in the early transition metal series, while the insulating properties of late TMOs are chieJy due to the contraction of 3d orbitals which occurs as the nuclear charge increases.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
9
Band structure calculations of TMCs in which exchange and electron correlations are replaced by an e1ective one-electron potential (Madelung, 1978) often predict metallic ground states or gaps which are an order of magnitude smaller than the ones observed experimentally (Terakura et al., 1984). These calculations are based on the density functional theory (DFT) (Hohenberg and Kohn, 1964), which applies strictly only to ground state properties. Here the interaction of electrons with the periodic crystal potential is fully included and leads to itinerant Bloch states. The Coulomb interaction between electrons is treated in a self-consistent way, so that electron correlation in the ground state is accounted for, at least approximately, as in the case of the local spin density approximation (LSDA) (Kohn and Sham, 1965). One shortcoming of DFT calculations is that they do not contain correlations e1ects relevant for excitations from the ground state. As a consequence the agreement or disagreement between calculated and experimental DOS results yields information on the e1ects of correlations on single-particle spectra, the so-called self-energy e1ects (Ziman, 1969; Hufner, 1995). It is well known that problems arise when the DFT-LSDA approach is applied to materials with metal ions that contain incomplete d- or f-shells, such as TMOs and rare earths compounds. For instance, Terakura et al. attempted a self-consistent treatment of the exchange and correlation e1ects with the LSDA. Their result pictured O2p bands deep and completely occupied, TM 4s and 4p states high in energy and completely unoccupied and TM3d bands in between, as shown in Fig. 7 of Terakura’s article. In MnO the calculated exchange splitting was large enough to split the 3d bands into spin-up and spin-down bands, with only the up-bands occupied, while in NiO an additional ligand Deld gap, due to the Ni3d–O2p hybridization, split the spin-down band into t2g and eg sub-bands with the former one Dlled. In MnO and NiO gaps were rather small (0.4 and 0:3 eV, respectively), while the insulating antiferromagnetic FeO and CoO were computed to be metallic. The physical origin of the LSDA failure can be traced back to the mean-Deld character of the Kohn–Sham (1965) equations, where the electron–electron correlation potential is understimated for strongly correlated electronic systems. Recently various forms of the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) have been introduced in order to take into account the inhomogeneity of the charge density in real systems. GGA corrections yield in general correct values of the cohesive energies and equilibrium distances for solids containing light atoms up to the 3d elements (metals). The version suggested by Perdew (1986a,b, 1991), Perdew and Yue (1986) and Perdew et al. (1997) has been also used for MnO and NiO and has given insulators with sizable gaps (although still too small), while FeO and CoO were still calculated to be metallic. This problem was partly overcome by using a di1erent GGA parametrization, which calculated the insulating ground states of FeO and CoO in qualitative agreement with experiment (Dufek et al., 1994; Blaka et al., 1996). Methods using DFT plus GGA approximations applied to solids have greatly changed the calculation approach giving a correct ground state energy and improved lattice parameters for many solids (Perdew et al., 1992; Becke, 1988). Another approach using the self-interaction correction (SIC) approximation was introduced by Svane and Gunnarsson (1990); Svane (1992); Szotek et al. (1993). The electronic structure of NiO, CoO, FeO and MnO was also obtained by Wei and Qi (1994), who have calculated magnetic moments, energy gaps and orbital character of the states near the Fermi energy in agreement with experiment. In conclusion it turns out that an improved agreement with experiments can be reached for TM monoxides by means of “LSDA +U ” approaches
10
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
(Anisimov et al., 1991; Lichtenstein and Katsnelson, 1998; Ezhov et al., 1999; Bengone et al., 2000), where the 3d states have been treated separately through the on-site Coulomb interaction U . These results have indicated that this approach shows order-of-magnitude improvements over the conventional LSDA calculations, giving a correct description of the insulating ground state (antiferromagnetic) of TMOs (see also Usuda and Hamada, 2000). Finally we recall the important “Drst principles” approach predicting the quasi-particle properties of solids given by the GW approximation (Hedin, 1965 and 1999). GWA extends the HF approximation for the self energy (exchange potential), by replacing the bare Coulomb potential by the dynamically screened potential W and the one-electron Green function G. GWA can be said to describe an electron polaron, an electron surrounded by an electronic polarization cloud, which greatly resembles the ordinary polaron, dressed by a cloud of phonons. The dynamical screening adds crucial features beyond the HF approximation: with GWA not only band structures, but also spectral functions can be calculated, as well as charge densities, momentum distributions and total energies. The remarkable point is due to the inclusion of many-body e1ects in the calculation of the electronic properties without omitting the chemical bonding e1ects, unlike the parametrized Hubbard model. Hedin has recently focused the main physical concepts of the GW approximation (Hedin, 1999 and references therein) with the praiseworthy aim to extend these ideas to spectroscopies as photoemission (Lee et al., 1999), electron scattering and X-ray absorption, as typical cases in need of improvements, where the e1ects of electron correlation are in general treated in a rather incomplete way. Another example is given by NiO, where self-consistent GW calculations have given a much better description than the one obtained by a pure LDA approach (Aryasetiawan and Gunnarsson, 1995 and 1998). However the non-local Coulomb interactions make such calculations very much time consuming. In a more standard way, simple examples of band calculations using ab initio methods with LDA will be also reported later and discussed in the case of Ti dioxides (Section 3.1), carbides and nitrides (Section 7.2). The special case of electronic band structure calculations addressed to substoichiometric compounds will be presented in Section 7.2., while the need of using full potential methods to treat their elastic properties will be emphasized in Section 7.3. 1.3. The e?ects of electron correlations on spectroscopic properties Before discussing possible origins of satellites which show up in core level XPS spectra (Sections 1.3.3 and 1.3.4), we will introduce the Mott–Hubbard model (Section 1.3.1), the Zaanen–Sawatsky–Allen theory and the charge transfer model (Section 1.3.2). 1.3.1. The Mott–Hubbard model This model is perhaps the simplest description of the electron correlation e1ects in solids. It was Drst discussed by Gutzwiller (1963, 1964) in an attempt to describe the e1ect of correlations for d-electrons in transition metals and then extensively by Hubbard (1963, 1964b, 1965, 1966), especially in the context of metal–insulator transitions. The Hamiltonian is characterized by a kinetic energy term Tij denoting the hopping of an electron from a site i to its nearest site j, and by the extra energy cost U of putting two electrons (spin up and spin down) on the same site.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
The Hubbard Hamitonian is + H= Tij ci cj + U ni ni− ; ij
11
(1.3)
i
+ where the operator ci creates an electron of spin in the Wannier state centered on Ri , and cj annihilates an electron of spin at the site Rj . Tij is the Fourier transform of the Bloch energies and the factor U is the Coulomb repulsion energy between two electrons with opposite spins on the same site. In the Wannier representation the term U is given by the matrix element arising from the four Wannier functions centered on the same site:
ii|g|ii = U :
(1.4)
The Hamiltonian contains the three parameters: T0 = Tii ; T1 = Tij and U . The T0 term represents the mean energy of the d band, the parameter T1 = Tij is zero unless i and j are nearest neighbors and is equal to half of the d band, i.e. 2T1 = w, and the matrix element Tij describes the electron hoppings between nearest neighbors. In the absence of U , this is just a tight-binding Hamiltonian with atomic energy levels i (k) at all sites being the same (zero) and with nearest neighbor overlap Tij leading to a band of one-electron states. The Mott–Hubbard correlation term U is, in the atomic limit, the di1erence between the ionization energy I and the electron aEnity A. The model is characterized by the dimensionless parameter (T=U ) and the electron density or average number of electrons per site n, which can range from zero to two. The Hubbard model is a “highly oversimpliDed model” for strongly interacting electrons in solids: there is little doubt that it is too simple to describe actual solids faithfully. It has no long-range Coulomb repulsion between electrons, no orbital degeneracy or many-band e1ects, no electron– lattice coupling and assumes a perfectly ordered lattice. Nevertheless, the Hubbard model is one of the most important historical models in theoretical physics. The parameters of the model Tij and U are in general poorly known. However, experimentally determined values for these parameters are essential for a meaningful discussion of the TMCs within the framework of the Hubbard Hamiltonian. The bandwidth can in principle be obtained directy from the experimental data and the magnitude of U is most directly determined by combining photoemission (PES) and bremsstrahlung isochromat spectroscopy (BIS). PES measures roughly the energies of the singly ionized electronic states, while BIS measures the energies of conDgurations with one-electron added. The di1erence in the energies d n−1 and d n+1 for a particular ground d electron conDguration d n is just the quantity I − A = U measured in situ. The values of U are in general considerably less than their atomic values (I − A) especially in metals. This point was emphasized quite early by Herring (1966) in his review on the magnetism in transition metals. The reduction is due to the screening by other electrons physically present in the unit cell of the solid (see for example, Parlebas et al., 1990). The parameter Tij is not determinable directly by experiment, but electron dispersion curves E(k) have been obtained from ARUPS experiments for several transition metals (Eastman and Himpsel, 1981; Himpsel, 1983). By Dtting to a tight-binding type model, the hopping integrals can be inferred. First principle band-structure calculations also lead to estimates of Tij for simple systems.
12
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
The parameters which determine the metal–insulator transition are the d state bandwidth w and the Coulomb repulsion U . The transition occurs when w≈U , an insulator being characterized by wU , and a metal by wU . Hubbard worked out the special cases of a parabolic density of states at √ U = 0, and also presented a solution that exhibits “an insulator–metal transition” at w=U = 2= 3. For small w=U , the atomic limit is obtained and the two bands are separated by an energy gap, Eg . For large values of w=U , the Bloch limit results and one gets a single half Dlled band, with Fermi energy at T0 + U=2. The e1ect of the electron–electron repulsion is to make the partially Dlled band d insulating, when the interaction between TM atoms becomes small. The study of the Mott–Hubbard metal–insulator transition has recently attracted much interest again, being an example of how strong correlation drastically changes the properties of a system (Georges et al., 1996). As it is known, the MH transition was originally studied without orbital degeneracy for simplicity, however, for many real systems, the orbitals primarily involved in the transition are degenerate, and if the orbital degeneration Nd is taken into √ account, the ratio w=U , where the MH transition takes place is increased by roughly a factor Nd . In fact, the electron hopping reduces the MH gap in the limit of a large Coulomb interaction U as EG ≈U − w Nd ; (1.5) √ because the hopping contribution grows as w Nd (Gunnarsson et al., 1996, 1997). Moreover, metal–insulator transitions do not arise only in TMCs, but also in glasses, in amorphous semiconductors, in dilute solutions and in the impurity band conduction, where, for instance, one may Dnd abrupt leaps in conductivity, if a particular parameter, as the temperature or the defect concentration, is varied. Not all of these phenomena are of course, Mott transitions, and in many cases it is not even clear which is the resonable mechanism (Madelung, 1978; Mott, 1990). For a quantitative discussion of the Hubbard approximation, the possibility for its extensions and applications the classical articles by Adler (1968); Doniach (1969) and Mott and Zinamon (1970) are recommended and some more recent contributions (Tasaki, 1998; Lieb, 1998) should be consulted. Nevertheless, we should also add that the simple one-band Hubbard model is not appropriate to describe the insulating properties of a number of materials, since it turns out that many TMCs present a band gap strongly a1ected by the nature of the ligands (anions), whereas, according to this model, the energy gap only involves the d–d Coulomb interaction on the TM atom, and the magnitude of the gap is nearly independent of the nature of the anions. For instance, it would not be easy to explain why compounds like NiS and CuS are metallic (see for example Usuda and Hamada, 2000 and refs. therein), while NiO and CuO are insulators with similar values of U (see also Lombardo et al., 1998). Thus, in many cases, one is forced to consider a model which takes also into account the electronegativity of the anions. 1.3.2. The Zaanen–Sawatsky–Allen theory and the charge transfer model The basic problem with the interpretation of the photoelectron emission in late TMCs stems from the fact that the previously considered Hubbard–Mott model neglects the large 3d ionization energies of the TM ions and the hybridization of 3d electrons with ligand p electrons. Thus, another possibility is that there is a large gap in the d states due to electron correlations, but that the energy gap corresponds to charge transfer (CT) transitions from the anion p-valence
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
13
band to the empty metal d states, a p–d gap. This also leads to insulating behavior, however in this case the energy gap will also depend on the electronegativity of the anions. This means that the d-like states of the valence band are in fact a mixture of ligand p electrons and metal 3d-electrons and they can be written as d n L. The valence band now leads to two Dnal states after photoemission, namely to d n−1 L and d n L states, where the Drst corresponds to the state already considered, but the second, not considered so far, has been produced by the ligand-to-metal charge transfer out of the photoionized state d n−1 L. The d n−1 L and d n L states contain the same number of electrons or holes and therefore tend to mix. For example, in NiO, the d 8 L state produces most of the weight near the Fermi energy, while the d 7 L state produces most of the ∼ 9 eV (Sawatzky and Allen, 1984; Hufner et al., 1984; weight in the satellite structure at EB = Hufner and Riesterer, 1986). Thus one realizes that there are two types of electronic excitations possible in the valence band of TMCs, that is the excitation of a 3d-electron from a TM ion and its transfer to another TM ion, governed by the energy U in the spirit of the Hubbard model, and, in addition, the excitation of a ligand electron onto a TM ion described by the CT energy . The relative magnitude of the energies U and determines whether a material is a MH or a CT compound, as shown in Fig. 1.3, where the various diagrams used for the discussion of the electronic properties of TMOs are reported (Sawatzky, 1987). 1.3.3. Satellite structure Excitation of valence electrons accompanying the core level photoemission of the 3d and 4f ions in solids causes the appearance of satellite features on the high binding energy side of the main emission in c-XPS spectra. The origin of such satellites has been the subject of a large number of investigations (Shirley, 1978) and is still matter of research. It was originally suggested that satellites could arise from the simultaneous excitations (shake-up) of outer electrons, although it was not clear which levels were involved. Strong TM 2p electron satellites in the iron group compounds were observed for ions with almost-Dlled shells (Cu2+ ; Ni2+ and Co2+ ) and half-Dlled shells (Mn2+ and Fe2+ ), but no satellite features were observed for the Dlled shell in Zn2+ (Rosencwaig et al., 1971). Intense “shake-up” satellites were also observed from Ti 2s and Ti 2p photoemission lines in TiF3 and TiO2 , and Sc 2s and Sc 2p lines in ScF3 and Sc2 O3 (Wallbank et al., 1973a, 1978). These satellites have been observed at an energy separation of 12–13 eV from the photoemission main lines. Their origin was attributed to excitations of electrons from ligand orbitals to metal 3d states, in analogy to the explanation Drst given by Kim for the satellites observed in Ni2+ and Cu2+ compounds (Kim, 1974). In Fig. 1.5 we report, as an example, the cases of TiF3 (Ti 2s XPS) and TiO2 (Ti 2p XPS). Further photoemission experiments in the 2p-XPS spectra of early TMCs, such as Sc trihalides and Ti tetrahalides, again showed satellites at about 10 –13 eV higher binding energy with respect to the main lines, but the origin of the satellite peaks was di1erently interpreted. As a matter of fact, an exciton mechanism (de Boer et al., 1984) was proposed for the origin of satellite peaks (Section 1.3.4), although it has been later shown that the CT mechanism can also explain satellite peaks, if the p–d hybridization strength is suEciently large (Parlebas, 1992). Nevertheless, in some systems we can expect competition between the charge transfer and the exciton mechanism, as formally discussed in the original de Boer’s article. For other systems, on the other hand, it is rather well established that the satellite structures seen in 2p-XPS of late
14
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 1.5. (a) Ti 2s XPS spectrum of TiF3 and (b) Ti 2p XPS spectrum of TiO2 (adapted from Wallbank et al., 1973b).
TMCs originate from the CT mechanism of valence electrons (van der Laan et al., 1981; Zaanen et al., 1986; Oh, 1988; Park et al., 1988; Okada and Kotani, 1992b). The importance of CT has been also conDrmed in the analysis of the 3d-XPS of rare-earth compounds (Gunnarsson and Schonhammer, 1983; Jo and Kotani, 1986; Kotani, 1987; Kotani et al., 1988; Kotani, 1999). Satellites observed in the spectra of the Drst row TMCs have been mostly explained by CT transitions, within the framework of the sudden approximation and molecular orbital theory (Hufner, 1995). Satellite transitions result from electron excitation in the valence shell as a result of the change in central potential caused by the sudden removal of an electron from the core shell. Through these studies, many late TM compounds, such as CuO and NiO, have been
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
15
Fig. 1.6. Schematic representation of the exciton model. The Dlled circle (•) means an electron; the empty one (◦) represents a hole. Final state (0) corresponds to the main line and Dnal state (1) to the exciton satellite. Also shown is the wave function for the valence electron in the initial and the Dnal states.
classiDed as CT-type insulators instead of MH insulators, as originally made. Recently, Bocquet et al. (1992, 1996) have analyzed the 2p-XPS spectra for several Ti and V oxides with formal valence d 0 to d 6 and have classiDed them as intermediate compounds between CT and MH compounds. Moreover, these studies suggest that the CT theory developed within the cluster impurity Anderson model (CIAM) is applicable to the analysis of the high-energy spectra of early TMCs as well as of the late TM systems (Parlebas, 1992; Okada and Kotani, 1992a, 1993; Kotani et al., 1995; Parlebas et al., 1995). 1.3.4. Other mechanisms for core level XPS satellites In heavy TMCs the charge transfer mechanism from the TM 3d to ligand p levels accounts for the satellites observed in core XPS spectra (Okada and Kotani, 1992b). In light TMCs, there is however some evidence that other mechanisms may be necessary to explain the data (de Boer et al., 1984). For example estimates of the binding energies can be made from the measured optical gaps and molecular calculations and these satellite energies are larger than expected for the charge-transfer process. The chemical trends also disagree with the mechanism. In addition, weaker satellites at lower binding energies have also been observed, so that a new model has been introduced that tries to describe the low-energy satellites, as due to ligand-to-metal charge transfer processes, and the high-energy (¿7 eV) satellites as due to excitations of excitons. The mechanism for screening the core hole created by the photoemission is the polarization of the surroundings. In compounds with polarizable ions (halides and oxides), the screening of a core hole on a cation can be produced by the polarization of the ligands. As polarization corresponds to a mixing in of the higher states, one can expect satellites due to transitions to these states. The energy of excitons and satellites should then be close to the optical excitation energies. A simple version of this model is sketched in Fig. 1.6. The creation of a core hole on the metal atom polarizes the ligand atoms, mixing s and p orbitals. In the ground state, only the p orbital is occupied. The Dnal state with the lower-energy orbital occupied gives the main line. Excitation of electrons to higher orbitals originates the satellite. Electron excitation corresponds
16
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Table 1.1 Satellite separations (eV) for the Ti 2s, Ti 2p, Sc 2s and Sc 2p photoelectron lines in 3d 0 and 3d 1 compounds (de Boer et al., 1984) Compounds
2s
2p1=2
2p3=2
ScF3 Sc2 O3 TiO2 TiF3
12.0 12.0 13.4 12.6
12.0 10.8 12.6 12.7
12.2 11.3 13.3 12.4
Table 1.2 Measured satellite distance Es to TM 2p main peak, measured intensities I3=2 and I1=2 of satellites relative to the 2p3=2 and 2p1=2 main line, metal–ligand distance R, calculated polarizabilities Ep, and calculated intensity ratio I c = Ep=Es Compounds
ES
I3=2
I1=2
R
Ep
Ic
ScF3 ScCl3 ScBr 3 ScI3 Sc2 O3 TiF4 TiCl4 TiBr 4 TiI4 TiO2
12.3 9.6 8.6 7.4 11.2 13.4 9.6 8.7 7.3 13.4
0.25 0.2 0.15 0.15 0.3 0.19 0.08 0.14 0.18 0.25
0.35 0.4 0.3 0.1 0.4 0.43 0.28 0.04 0.25 0.40
2.01 2.58 2.76 2.97 2.11 1.90 2.22 2.31 2.55 1.96
2.4 2.1 2.2 2.4 3.2 2.2 2.7 3.0 3.2 4.0
0.20 0.22 0.25 0.32 0.29 0.17 0.28 0.34 0.44 0.30
to an electron–hole pair on the ligand atom and becomes an exciton in the solid. By means of the exciton model it is also possible to calculate the intensities of the satellites from the anion polarizability. Comparison of the theory using anion polarizabilities with experimental satellites intensities and energies is generally favorable, as one can see in Tables 1.1 and 1.2, adapted from de Boer’s article. The measured satellite distances to metal 2p main peaks and the experimental intensities are reported for Sc and Ti halides and oxides (Sc2 O3 and TiO2 ) to show the prevision of the model. The Sc 2p spectra of Sc trihalides are also presented in Fig. 1.7, where the so-called exciton satellites are shown. The question naturally arises whether the exciton satellite mechanism can explain the satellite structures of all early TMCs, as it seems from a perusal of vacuum ultraviolet spectra available for TiO2 and Ti2 O3 compounds, gaseous TiCl4 and crystalline CrCl3 and CrBr 3 solids (Guizzetti et al., 1976). All compounds have a region up to 9 eV in the oxides and up to 6 or 7:7 eV in the halides, which is ascribed to a charge transfer transition from the anion p to the metal 3d orbitals. The XPS satellites show a striking similarity with these spectra. Satellites are observed between 3 and 7 eV and at 14 eV in TiO2 and BaTiO3 (Sen et al., 1976; Chermette et al., 1980); at 4.0 and 9:4 eV in gaseous TiCl4 (Wallbank et al., 1978), and at 11 eV in CaF2 (Rublo1, 1972). For the layered compounds CrCl3 and CrBr 3 , recent data reported in v-XPS (Pollini, 1999, 2000) seem to indicate a competition
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
17
Fig. 1.7. Sc 2p XPS spectra of ScF3 ; ScCl3 ; ScBr 3 and ScI3 (adapted from de Boer et al., 1984).
between the exciton mechanism and the charge transfer process. For example, in CrCl3 and CrBr 3 , the v-XPS and the 3s-, 3p- and 2p-XPS data show satellites located around 8 and 11 eV away from the main emission bands, which seems a large energy separation to be explained only by the charge-transfer model with reasonable parameters. In this sense, the interest for the exciton satellite mechanism may be considered, since the exciton mechanism appears to dominate over the CT model, when the CT energy is large and the Q (=Udc ) parameter is small and there are besides many empty 3d orbitals. In the following sections (2–5), putting main emphasis on CI–CT models, we will analyze and discuss some examples of core level spectra for pre- and early-TMCs, including the chromium compounds (Section 5), and consider the systematic trends observed along the TM series (Section 6). Among the various kinds of TMCs, the early transition metal oxides (TMOs) of the Drst TM row show a great variety of electronic and magnetic properties and will be largely considered here. Also in Section 4.3 we will calculate and discuss an other mechanism for the 3s-XPS satellite, i.e. the so-called multiplet splitting due to the presence of a localized magnetic moment (Shirley, 1978; Fadley, 1988). Section 7 will be devoted to review similar topics in substoichiometric titanium compounds and to the study of their elastic properties (Guemmaz et al., 1997, 1999, 2000).
18
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
2. Pretransition and scandium compounds In this section we Drst consider the simplest mechanism responsible for the main line-versussatellite structure in the c-XPS of early 3d TMCs. In our simple model, as already mentioned in the preceding section, the physics of the c-XPS is described only in terms of a few pertinent parameters, such as the on-site Coulomb repulsion U , the charge-transfer energy , the hybridization energy V related to the metal-ligand transfer integrals and the core-hole-3d-electron Coulomb attraction energy Q (=Udc ) (Parlebas, 1992, 1993; Parlebas et al., 1995). In Section 2.1, we recall our model formulation of c-XPS in the case of a series of pre- and early-TM insulating compounds, nominally characterized by a 3d 0 conDguration in the ground state. Then, in Section 2.2, we present some results and a general discussion relevant to the very early TMCs as well as K and Ca compounds. As far as those last compounds are concerned let us just recall that several years ago a method was also presented for the calculation of the imaginary part of the dielectric function (Parlebas and Mills, 1978) when the transition involved a core level in an insulator (Fliyou et al., 1987): especially X-ray absorption spectra in alkali halides could be qualitatively understood in terms of a simple method used for a schematic model. 2.1. Model formulation of the core level XPS Here we consider early-TMCs characterized by the following band structure somewhat related to the previously presented CT model (Section 1.3.2): a completely Dlled ligand band (LB), mostly arising from anion states, and separated by an energy gap of a few eV from the empty conduction d bands, t2g and eg (often separated by another gap). Actually, in our simpliDed formulation we only keep in mind an electron system consisting of a Dlled LB and a degenerate 3d level as well as the corresponding core level (2s or 2p TM level). Similarly to the case of the 4f 0 La insulating compounds (La2 O3 ; LaF3 ) (Kotani et al., 1987), the 3d level in the ground state of the TMC is assumed to be well above the LB, so that it is practically empty; this corresponds to the nominally 3d 0 conDguration. However, due to conDguration interaction we have to consider a strong mixture of 3d 0 and 3d 1 L conDgurations where L means a ligand hole in the LB. See also the appreciable hybridization V found in Section 3.1 between the LB and the 3d states by Khan et al. (1991). Actually, we also consider the 3d 2 L2 conDguration in the ground state. In the Dnal state of the c-XPS, the 3d level is pulled down by the core hole potential—Udc , and a similar conDguration-interaction mixture takes place between c3d 1 L and c3d 2 L2 , where c labels the core hole. It is interesting to note the analogy of the present situation with what happens in copper dihalides (van der Laan et al., 1981) or in CuO (Mosser et al., 1991), for example, where 3d 10 L and 3d 9 conDgurations are strongly mixed. The Dlled band single impurity Anderson model (SIAM) Hamiltonian of our system is written as H = HL + HTM + Hmix ; where HL =
k;!
L (k)a+ L (k; !)aL (k; !) ;
(2.1) (2.2)
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
HTM = d0
!
a+ d (!)ad (!) + Udd
!¿#
+ + c a+ c ac − (1 − ac ac )Udc
and
19
+ a+ d (!)ad (!)ad (! )ad (! )
!
a+ d (!)ad (!)
(2.3)
√ Hmix = (V= N ) [a+ L (k; !)ad (!) + h:c:] ;
(2.4)
k;!
where L (k); d0 and c are the energies of the LB states, 3d level, and core level, respectively, + + and a+ L (k; !); ad (!) and ac are the electron creation operators in the corresponding states. Here k denotes the index of energy level (k = 1; : : : ; N ) in the LB and ! speciDes both the spin and orbital degeneracies (! = 1; : : : ; Nd ). Actually Nd can be taken between 2 (only spin degeneracy) and 10 (full d spin–orbital degeneracy). However, the spin and orbital degeneracies for the core states are here disregarded as well as the corresponding spin–orbit coupling (see Section 3.2.1 where spin–orbit coupling has been included), since in our model we do not try to describe the full (core 2p) multiplet structure, but only one component (2p3=2 ). Similarly the cubic crystal Deld e1ect on the d0 level is ignored since it is not a basic parameter to calculate the satellite features in this case. The Hamiltonian used in (2.1) is based on a broken translational symmetry for the 3d states of the TM ion (3d single-site model). Such an approximation is expected to make sense if the dispersional 3d-bandwidth is small as usual in 3d insulating compounds. We could, of course, also break the anion translational symmetry ending up with the previously considered cluster calculation (van der Laan et al., 1981; Uozumi et al., 1997; Bocquet et al., 1992, 1996), but usually the LB width is quite large and therefore rather well taken into account with a band model. Eq. (2.1) simply treats the 3d states of the TM ion as impurity states (the core hole Udc acting like an impurity potential) in a lattice formed by itinerant ligand states. Let us recall that in the case of the present Dlled LB SIAM, it is easy to obtain the exact solutions of the preceding ‘two-electron’ Hamiltonian (2.1) (Kotani et al., 1988). The ground state |g, when the core level is occupied (a+ c ac = 1), is then expressed as a linear combination of the following basis states: |d 0 ; |d 1 ; L(k)
and
|d 2 ; L(k1 ); L(k2 )
(2.5)
with, respectively, 0, 1 and 2 holes in the LB. Also, each Dnal state |f of the c-XPS is expressed, apart from the emitted photoelectron, as a linear combination of the following states: |d 0 ; c; |d 1 ; L(k)c
and
|d 2 ; L(k1 ); L(k2 ); c
(2.6)
where c is a core hole. An important quantity is the ligand-to-metal charge transfer energy , deDned by the energy di1erence between the 3d 0 and 3d 1 L conDgurations: ≡ E[3d 1 L] − E[3d 0 ] = d0 − p ;
(2.7) d0
is the degenerate where p is the center of the LB (hereafter taken as the energy origin) and energy of the d states. In our model we treat the Dlled LB as a Dnite periodic system consisting of N discrete levels with equal spacing and in our numerical results, we take N = 6, which is enough for a good convergence (Kotani et al., 1988). We also take W ≈5:5 eV as a good
20
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
order of magnitude for the width of the ligand band in typical early TMCs we are considering. Actually the precise value of 5:5 eV is taken from the LMTO band structure calculation by Khan et al. (1991) made on the O 2p-band of rutile TiO2 (Section 3.1). Finally, for simplicity, we put Nd = 2 in the following numerical applications. However, the essential features of the spectrum do not change much with Nd , provided that Nd V 2 is kept constant (Kotani et al., 1988). That means that, e.g., V = 6 eV with Nd = 2 is essentially equivalent to V ≈3:46 eV with Nd = 6 (like t2g ) or to V ≈2:68 eV with Nd = 10 (like t2g + eg ). Disregarding the interaction of the emitted photoelectron with other electrons (sudden approximation), the c-XPS is Dnally expressed as F(EB ) = |f|g|2 L(EB + Eg − Ef ) : (2.8) f
In Eq. (2.8) L(x) is a Lorentzian deDned as L(x) = 'c =[(x2 + 'c2 )], where EB is the electronic binding energy obtained by subtracting the kinetic energy of the photoemitted core electron from the energy ! of the incident photon (EB = ! − ), and 'c (=1 eV) labels the spectral broadening of our empirical Lorentzian function, the width arising from the core hole lifetime and experimental resolution. 2.2. Tendencies at the very beginning of the series Let us Drst remark that in Eq. (2.3), Udd and Udc are not really independent parameters. In our numerical calculation we take the parameter value Udd somewhat smaller (or at most equal) than Udc because the average distance between two 3d electrons is usually larger than the distance between a 3d- and a core-electron. In free atoms, the ratio Udd =Udc has been found to vary between 0.7, when c = 2p, and 0.9, when c = 3p, (de Boer et al., 1984). In Fig. 2.1, we have shown the c-XPS results for a range of values of the ratio Udd =Udc from 0.666 (Fig. 2.1a) to 0.875 (Fig. 2.1f), in reasonable agreement with the de Boer’s results. Actually, Fig. 2.1 summarizes a qualitative study of the e1ect of increasing the couple values (Udd ; Udc ) with respect to the Dxed parameter. The CT energy was taken as 4 eV, with a LB width of 5:5 eV, i.e. a bandgap of 1:25 eV between d0 and the highest LB state, before considering any e1ect of Udd or Udc on d0 . From Fig. 2.1, and quite generally, we can distinguish two regimes of parameter values (Zaanen et al., 1985; Bocquet et al., 1992): i) (Udd ; Udc )¡, (as in Fig. 2.1a), where the satellite is practically absent from the spectra; ii) (Udd ; Udc ) ¿ (as in Figs. 2.1c–f), where the satellite is clearly visible, even for small V values. For a simpliDed analytical model, restricted to two conDgurations, we refer to van der Laan et al. (1981): this model relates the position of the satellite and its intensity to ; V and Udc (but does not include Udd ). Veal and Paulikas (1985) reported 2p-XPS spectra for 2+; 3+, and 4+ cations in CaF2 ; ScF3 and TiF4 Juorides (see Fig. 7 of their article). For all these pre- and early-3d insulating compounds, where the cation conDguration is a nominally pure 3d 0 4s0 , satellites are separated from the main core line by 10 –15 eV. As far as Sc 2p XPS spectra of ScF3 compounds is concerned one should also see Fig. 1.7. The situation seems similar to that of CaO; Sc2 O3 , and TiO2 compounds (de Boer et al., 1984; Veal and Paulikas, 1985). For the calcium compounds (CaF2 , CaO), the satellite peaks are the weakest ones, but still visible. However, in the K 2p-XPS of potassium halides, like KF (Veal and Paulikas, 1985), where the cation conDguration corresponds again to 3d 0 4s0 ,
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
21
Fig. 2.1. c-XPS spectra in 3d 0 oxides plotted against binding energy for various hybridization strengths V =1; 2; : : : ; 7 eV and with (Udd ; Udc )=(a) (2; 3); (b) (3; 4); (c) (4; 5); (d) (5; 6); (e) (6; 7); (f ) (7; 8) eV. The other parameters are = 4 eV; Nd = 2; 'c = 1 eV.
no satellite structure can be discerned and attributed to local screening states. In this case, the unDlled 3d states are located too far above the LB (wide-band-gap material) so that, even in the Dnal state of the 2p-XPS spectra, the 3d levels are still well above the LB and cannot participate in the local screening of the core hole. In our calculation (Fig. 2.2) we have shown that if the charge transfer energy becomes larger and larger, from 3 to 9 eV, then the satellite becomes smaller and smaller (as in Ca compounds) and Dnally disappears (in K monohalides) for (Udd ; Udc ). It is interesting to underline that, contrary to K + , the Ca2+ cation in the Dnal state of the c-XPS shows a low-lying 3d behavior, which is typical of the considered cation in the whole early TM series for insulating compounds. The important common feature is that, in the Dnal state, the Drst unoccupied allowed level is 3d like. The main c-XPS peak (at low binding energy) roughly corresponds to a locally well-screened state 3d 1 and the higher binding energy satellite corresponds to a locally poorly screened state 3d 0 . The fact that K and Ca ions show di1erent, but predictable satellite structures, gives support to the 3d-screening
22
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 2.2. c-XPS spectra in 3d 0 oxides plotted against binding energy for various charge-transfer energies = 3; 4; : : : ; 9 eV and with (Udd ; Udc ) = (3; 4) eV; (V; Nd ) = (5 eV; 2); ' = 1 eV.
model for the core hole. Moreover, the energy separation between the main and satellite peaks (van der Laan et al., 1981) is observed to increase in the series CaF2 ; ScF3 ; TiF4 (Veal and Paulikas, 1985) or CaO; Sc2 O3 ; TiO2 (de Boer et al., 1984), which is again in agreement with the increase of the hybridization parameter V in our model, going from Ca to Ti compounds (Fig. 2.1d–f). In conclusion in this section we have calculated the c-XPS spectra, which result from the creation of a core hole within the Dlled-band SIAM. Our simpliDed calculation seems to explain well the spectra for the series of the very early TM insulating compounds, characterized by a nominally 3d 0 conDguration in the ground state, including those compounds which involve pre-transitional elements like K or Ca. 3. Titanium compounds Now, we essentially focus on the Ti compounds with nominal 3d 0 conDgurations, with TiO2 as a typical example. Although Section 3 is essentially restricted to valence band (Section 3.1) and core XPS (Section 3.2), we would like to mention the X-ray emission spectra (XES) measured in the region of Ti 2p and O 1s excitation threshold by Tezuka et al. (1996) as well as the resonant XES analyzed in details by Finkelstein et al. (1999) and Matsubara et al. (2000). Also, the soft X-ray Raman scattering has been recently investigated at the Ti 2p absorption edge of TiO2 (Harada et al., 2000) and the corresponding Ti 1s absorption edge has been revisited (see Uozumi et al., 1992; Joly et al., 1999). Titanium dioxide is an important compound with applications in a number of areas, such as photocatalysis. Here, we limit ourselves to the case of the TiO2 rutile structure. However, a comparison between TiO2 rutile, anatase and
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
23
brookite structures has been also performed with the help of reJection spectra measurements of TiO2 single crystals by Sekiya et al. (1998). The case of Ti2 O3 will be then mentioned in Section 3.3. 3.1. Electron band structure and valence band XPS of Ti dioxides As introduced in Section 1.2.2, we would like here to recall some band structure calculations and results (Section 3.1.1) as well as their comparison with experimental v-XPS spectra (Section 3.1.2) in the typical case of TiO2 compounds. 3.1.1. LMTO calculations and results W c = 2:89 A W and u = 0:31. TiO2 (rutile) crystallizes into tetragonal structure with a = 4:49 A; The unit cell contains 2 Ti and 4 O atoms. The core charge distribution for Ti and O was obtained through a self-consistent Dirac atomic potential. Electrons up to and including O 1s and Ti 3p were treated as frozen core electrons. We used two energy panels for the band structure calculation (Khan et al., 1991) within local density approximation (LDA), using a self-consistent linear muEn tin orbital (LMTO) method in the atomic sphere approximation (ASA), where the combined correction is properly included. The scalar-relativistic SchrXodinger equation with the von Barth–Hedin exchange correlation (von Barth and Hedin, 1974) was solved. We considered the muEn-tin orbitals of angular momentum s, p and d for O and Ti atoms and we diagonalized a matrix of 54 × 54 order. The eigenvalues and eigenvectors were calculated on a grid of 75 k-points in the irreducible 1=16th Brillouin zone. The one-electron energy bands have been calculated in the high symmetry directions '–M –X –'–Z–R–X –M –A–Z (Fig. 1 from Khan et al., 1991). In the present paper, we call as valence band (VB) the ligand band (LB), which lies between −0:72 and −0:1625 Ry (Fig. 3.1), and the Drst conduction band (CB) is placed over the forbidden gap (3:06 eV). According to this band scheme, TiO2 is a semiconductor with an indirect forbidden gap of 3:06 eV. In the calculation of Kazowski and Tait (1979) they also obtained an indirect forbidden gap, but with another minimum of the CB. Although they used the same LMTO method, they however performed their calculation without (i) the combined correction, (ii) with a small number of basis functions, and lastly (iii) without the exchange correlation. Fig. 3.1 shows the total DOS per unit cell. In the Ti Wigner–Seitz spheres (WSS) the d symmetry is so dominant that the presence of s and p symmetries is almost unobserved, although non zero (Khan et al., 1991). The number of states of di1erent symmetries and of di1erent chemical origins in LB and CB have been also tabulated in Khan’s article. Actually, all bands correspond to mixed states and in each case all di1erent symmetries are present. The LB is mainly of O 2p origin (80%), but it also contains 13% Ti 3d and 7% of the other symmetries. The Drst CB is 75% Ti ‘d’ (t2g ), about 11% each of O p and O d, and it also contains a small amount of Ti p. The Ti t2g band is about 2:3 eV wide. Beyond the forbidden gap of 2:7 eV starting from the lower band, we obtain the next conduction band mainly of Ti eg origin. This band is split into two bands because of the crystal structure. The lower band (1 eV wide) is mainly of x2 –y2 symmetry of Ti origin. Beside our calculation, another LMTO calculation has been performed for TiO2 by Poumellec et al. (1991), exhibiting slight di1erences as compared to our results (see inset in Fig. 3.1): (i) the width of the VB is smaller, (ii) the indirect forbidden gap is reduced to 2 eV and (iii) there is no additional
24
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 3.1. Total DOS per unit cell in TiO2 compounds according to Khan et al. (1991). The insert shows the same result, according to Poumellec et al. (1991).
forbidden gap within the conduction bands. However, both band calculations are deduced from LMTO methods which include the exchange corrections. Nevertheless, in Khan’s calculation, the convergence was considered achieved when the experimental gap (3:06 eV) was obtained, since it is known that any band structure calculation for insulators in the LDA with exchange corrections gives a band gap which is too small in general (see Section 1.2.2). In order to recover a realistic band gap it would be necessary to use the X. Slater potential, with . ¿ 1 (Khan and Callaway, 1980). See also Finkelstein et al. (1999) for the application to TiO2 of a recent full potential LMTO method (FPLMTO). 3.1.2. Experimental valence band XPS and discussion Valence photoemission spectra (v-XPS) and ultraviolet photoelectron spectra (UPS) on TiO2 (rutile) have been measured by Tezuka et al. (1994, 1996) together with bremsstrahlung isochromat spectra. Although the experimental resolution of the BIS was not as good as that of Beaurepaire et al. (1993), nevertheless Tezuka et al. were able to estimate the magnitude of the fundamental bandgap from the joint v-XPS-BIS spectra of TiO2 (see Fig. 1 of Tezuka et al., 1994). The estimated magnitude is in good agreement with that obtained in Khan’s energy band calculation. Moreover, the v-XPS gives information about the density of states (DOS) of occupied levels. Fig. 3.2 reports the experimental UPS (excitation energy at 80 eV) and v-XPS spectra of TiO2 which have been compared to the preceding DOS curves shown in Fig. 3.1, convoluted with a Gaussian broadening function (due to experimental resolution) of width 1:0 eV. The convoluted DOS curve based on Poumelec’s result shows a two-peak proDle in rough agreement with the experimental spectra, whereas the DOS curve based on Khan’s calculation exhibits a wider width and a more complicate shape when compared to the
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
25
Fig. 3.2. Experimental UPS and v-XPS spectra of TiO2 compared to the convoluted DOS values of Khan et al. (1991) and Poumellec et al. (1991) (adapted from Tezuka et al., 1994).
experiment. The origin of the discrepancy is probably related to the problem of convergence (and fundamental gap) in semiconductor calculations, as mentioned before. As far as the dispersion curves E(k) are concerned, the calculated valence-band structure of TiO2 has been compared to ARUPS data measured with synchrotron radiation from the (1 0 0) and (1 1 0) crystal surfaces (Hardman et al., 1994). A reasonable agreement was found between the experimental data and the calculations made by Glassford et al. (1990) and Poumellec et al. (1991).
3.2. Ti core level XPS spectra of TiO2 In this section, in order to mimic a rough band structure of TiO2 , we consider a TiO6 cluster localized model with an adequate crystalline geometry, which essentially provides a Dnite number of 2p states of oxygen, hybridized with the 3d orbitals at one Ti photoexcited site. However, this cluster impurity Anderson model (CIAM) allows us to extend the SIAM Hamiltonian given by Eq. (2.1) (Section 3.2.1) and to calculate the corresponding core level XPS spectra (Section 3.2.2).
26
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
3.2.1. Cluster impurity Anderson model for TiO6 (Oh symmetry) The following analysis is based on a MO6 octahedral CIAM (Okada et al., 1992, 1994) with M = Ti. For the calculation of TM c-XPS, the Hamiltonian was given by the adaptation and extension of Eq. (2.1): H = HL + HTi + Hmix ; where HL =
';
HTi =
p a+ p' ap' ;
!
+
d d!+ d! +
2
+ 0d
!1 ;!2
Hmix =
!
(3.2) 2p p+ ! p! +
!1 ;!2 ;!3 ;!4
gpd (!1 ; !2 ; !3 ; !4 ) d!+1 d!2 p+ !3 p!4
1 g (!1 ; !2 ; !3 ; !4 )d!+1 d!2 d!+3 d!4 2 ! ;! ;! ;! dd 1
and
(3.1)
';
3
4
(˜l · ˜s)!1 ;!2 d!+1 d!2 + 0p
!1 ;!2
+ V (')(d' ap' + a+ p' d' ) :
(˜l · ˜s)!1 ;!2 p+ !1 p!2
(3.3)
(3.4)
Here vi denotes the combined indices representing the spin () and orbital (') states, and ' runs over t2g and eg states. HL describes the ligand molecular orbitals, which couple to the 3d orbitals through the hybridization Hmix . The HTi describes the atomic 3d and 2p electron states of the TM ion. In Eq. (3.3) the gpd and gdd symbols represent the Coulomb interaction between 2p and 3d states and that between 3d states, respectively, and include the Slater integrals in their explicit forms; 0d and 0p are the spin–orbit coupling parameters. The Hamiltonian H is diagonalized within the basis states in the space of 3d n , 3d n+1 L; 3d n+2 L2 conDgurations, where n = 0 for TiO2 and L represents a ligand hole. We have deDned the key parameters, ; Udd and Udc , as follows: the CT energy is given by E[d n+1 L] − E[d n ] = , and the Coulomb interaction Udd is deDned by E[d n+2 L2 ] − E[d n+1 L] = + Udd , where E[d n+2 L2 ]; E[d n+1 L] and E[d n ] represent the conDguration average energy of d n+2 L2 ; d n+1 L and d n , respectively. The 2p core hole potential −Udc (2p) is deDned by E[2pd n+1 L] − E[2pd n ] = − Udc (2p). The spectrum of Ti c-XPS is expressed as in Eq. (2.8): |f(XPS)|g|2 L(EB + Eg − Ef (XPS)) ; (3.5) F(EB ) = f
where |g and |f(XPS) represent the initial and Dnal states with energy Eg and Ef (XPS), respectively, and EB is the binding energy. 3.2.2. Core-level XPS We analyze Ti 2p, 3s and 3p XPS of TiO2 with the full multiplet TiO6 cluster model (3.1). The symmetry of the cluster is approximately taken as Oh , because the deviation from Oh
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
27
Fig. 3.3. Experimental (a) and theoretical (b) and (c) results of Ti 2p-XPS of TiO2 . In (b) the e1ect of the covalency hybridization is taken into account, while it is disregarded in (c).
symmetry in TiO2 is too small to a1ect the XPS spectra. According to experimental data (Sen et al., 1976) displayed in Fig. 3.3a (see also Fig. 1.5b), Ti 2p XPS consists of two main peaks, i.e. 2p3=2 and 2p1=2 core levels, each of which is accompanied by a satellite about 13 eV above the main peak. With the same parameter values as those obtained in the analysis of Ti 1s pre-edge XAS (Kotani et al., 1995), we can fairly well reproduce the Ti 2p XPS spectrum. After a slight readjustment of parameters [V (eg ) = 3:0 eV; Udd = 4:0 eV; Udc = 6:0 eV), the calculated result (Okada et al., 1992) is shown in Fig. 3.3b. As an origin of the satellite, an exciton mechanism has been proposed (de Boer et al., 1984, Section 1.3.4), where a simultaneous excitation of O 2p to O 3s states gives rise to the satellite. However, in the present calculation the satellite is caused by the charge transfer (CT) e1ect due to the strong covalency hybridization. If we disregard the CT e1ect by putting V (eg ) = V (t2g ) = 0, the satellite vanishes as shown in Fig. 3.3c. Another e1ect of the hybridization is to make the 2p1=2 main peak broader than the 2p3=2 one. The broadening of the 2p1=2 peak is caused by the multiplet splitting which is induced by the hybridization, so that the peak is narrowed in Fig. 3.3c. These facts are an evidence of the strong covalency hybridization in TiO2 . In the present calculation, the ground state consists of 3d 0 (39.5%), 3d 1 L (48.2%) and 3d 2 L2 (12.3%) conDgurations, resulting in the average 3d electron number equal to 0.73. The calculations of Ti 3s and 3p XPS were made with the same parameter values as those used for 2p XPS, except that Udc , for the 3s and 3p core states is taken to be smaller by 1 eV than the 2p state. Furthermore, in the calculation of the Ti 3s-XPS, we have taken into account the intra-atomic conDguration interaction (CI) between 3s1 3p6 3d n and 3s2 3p4 3d n+1 conDgurations. The result (Okada et al., 1992) is shown in Fig. 3.4, and compared with the corresponding experimental data (dots) (Tezuka et al., 1994). The agreement between the theoretical and
28
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 3.4. Experimental (dots) and theoretical (solid curve) results of (a) Ti 3s-XPS and (b) Ti 3p-XPS of TiO2 .
experimental results is fairly good. The 13 eV satellite of Ti 3p-XPS is still caused by a CT e1ect, while the complicated satellite structure of Ti 3s-XPS seems to come from the combined CT and CI e1ects. From the systematic analysis so far given, we can conclude that in TiO2 the e1ective hybridization 1 Ve1 (∼7 eV) is larger than the CT energy (∼4 eV), so that the ground state has a strongly mixed valent nature. Besides, the Coulomb interaction Udd (=4–5 eV) is as large as the parameter. It is to be mentioned that the Ti 2p-XAS as well as the v-XPS-BIS spectra of TiO2 can also be reasonably reproduced with these parameter values, by using the preceding TiO6 cluster model (Beaurepaire et al., 1993). 3.3. A few insights about Ti2 O3 Let us now shortly comment on Ti2 O3 sesquioxides, which were considered as “MH insulators” with a nominal “Ti3+ (3d 1 )” ground state. However, no detailed analysis of the high-energy spectroscopic data had been made until the analysis made by Uozumi et al. (1996) and Tezuka et al. (1996). Experimentally, they observed the Ti 2p XPS spectrum of Ti2 O3 as well as the corresponding resonant photoemission (RPES) at the Ti 2p excitation threshold, and then they interpreted their results within a TiO6 CIAM. The satellite structure of the 2p XPS was assigned to a CT satellite, while the RPES was explained through the e1ect of a strong covalency hybridization. Finally, Uozumi et al. (1996, 1997) classiDed the Ti2 O3 compounds as intermediate-type insulators between CT and MH insulators as well as the V2 O3 ; Cr 2 O3 ; Mn2 O3 sesquioxides (whereas they classiDed Fe2 O3 compounds as CT insulators).
1
Ve1 is the e1ective hybridization strength between 2p3d 0 and 2p3d 1 L conDgurations (or between 3d 0 and 3d 1 L conDgurations in the ground state), which is given by [6{V (t2g )}2 + 4{V (eg )}2 ]1=2 ; 6 and 4 being the number of empty places of the t2g and eg states, respectively (see Eqs. (4.3) and (5.1)).
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
29
4. Vanadium compounds Let us now consider the cases of V2 O5 , VO2 and V2 O3 compounds, studied with PES, BIS and c-XPS techniques (Section 4.1), and with resonant photoemission (Section 4.2). Section 4.3 will be devoted to the special examples of VC2 and VC6 cluster models. 4.1. BIS, valence band and core level XPS of V2 O5 , VO2 and V2 O3 Here we consider the binary oxides V2 O5 , VO2 and V2 O3 , of vanadium with cation valence 5, 4 and 3, respectively, corresponding to the formal valence shell conDguration 3d 0 , 3d 1 and 3d 2 . The V2 O5 compound (e.g. Shin et al., 1993) is a diamagnetic insulator with a gap of EG = 2 eV, while VO2 undergoes an insulator-to-metal transition with a sharp conductivity increase of almost Dve orders of magnitude at 340 K: its gap in the insulating low-temperature phase amounts to EG = 0:5 eV (see for example, Blaauw et al. (1975) and Sawatzky and Post (1979)). The V2 O3 compound crystallizes in the corundum structure and exhibits an insulator-to-metal transition with a 6 –7 orders of magnitude jump in the conductivity at 160–170 K and a gap of 0:2–0:3 eV in the insulating phase. Despite the many e1orts towards obtaining an understanding of their electronic behavior, the vanadium oxides still pose many open questions. V2 O3 for example has often been regarded as a prototype for the spin 12 -MH compounds with U ¡ (Hufner, 1985, 1994, 1995; Shin et al., 1995, 1996). The metallic and insulating behaviors as well as the metal-to-insulator transitions have been analyzed in terms of these parameters (U; ) and their relation to the bandwidths W and w of the O 2p and TM 3d bands. However, the nature of the phase transition in V2 O3 and the inJuence of the antiferromagnetic ordering on it are still a matter of controversy (Thomas et al., 1994; Ezhov et al., 1999). VO2 is nominally a 3d 1 system (like Ti2 O3 ), while TiO2 (Section 3.2) is a nominally 3d 0 . When one goes from TiO2 to VO2 , one expects a decrease of the parameter in analogy with the behavior of late TMCs (Bocquet et al., 1992, 1996), while the change of other parameters should be much smaller. To calculate the PES (or v-XPS) it is possible to adjust Eq. (3.1), by considering the hole in the VB and not in the core level (Udc = 0), and using a similar VO6 cluster system (Okada and Kotani, 1993; Beaurepaire et al., 1993), as in the case of TiO6 . BIS spectra can also be calculated with the same scheme (always Udc = 0). In the Dnal state of BIS, when an incident electron has been absorbed into a 3d orbital with the emission of a photon, the ground state |g turns into the Dnal states f(BIS) with energies {Ef (BIS)} and the BIS spectrum is expressed as a summation over the f(BIS) states: + FBIS (E) = f(BIS)|d' |gL(E − Ef (BIS) + Eg ) ; (4.1) f
'
where the Lorentzian includes the spectral broadening formed by the lifetime of the Dnal states and the experimental resolution. In the case of VO2 , PES and BIS have been calculated for = 2 eV, and the same parameters used for TiO2 compounds. The result (Fig. 4.1) is in fairly good agreement with the available experimental data (Uozumi et al., 1993). In Fig. 4.1, the calculated PES essentially consists of a broad VB which mainly originates from the O 2p character. On the other hand, the calculated BIS shows a two peak structure which mainly correspond to the Ti t2g and eg orbitals. In addition to the experimental PES spectrum of VO2
30
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 4.1. Photoemission spectrum (PES) and bremsstrahlung spectrum (BIS) calculated for VO2 (adapted from Uozumi et al., 1993).
Fig. 4.2. VB-PES for VO2 compounds. The sum of the partial density components V2p-SXES and O1s-SXES gives the PES spectrum (adapted from Shin et al., 1998).
the experimental SXES spectrum compound is shown in Fig. 4.2, where the hybridization of O2p and V3d band is demonstrated experimentally. The VB-PES of VO2 consists mainly of O2p and V3d components: the O2p component, with two structures as calculated above, is dominant at higher binding energy and the V3d component is located just below the Fermi level (see also Fig. 4.1). The PES spectrum can be resolved into the V2p and O1s components
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
31
Fig. 4.3. Experimental (dots) core-level V2p-XPS photoemission for V2 O3 compounds: in the theoretical spectrum (full line) two CT satellites are obtained, to which only one is visible in the experiment (S) (adapted from Uozumi et al., 1998).
by SXES: the V2p emission reJects the V3d partial density of states and the O1s emission reJects the O2p partial density of states (see the diagram of levels). One sees that the band B of Fig. 4.2 has a strong 3d component in the O2p band; on the other hand, there is also an intensity of the O2p component in the 3d band at the Fermi level. Thus, these results indicate how the two components are hybridized with each other (Shin et al., 1998). A systematic XPS study of the core levels within the CIAM framework has been recently performed for many early TMOs (Uozumi et al., 1993, 1997). In the case of V 2p-XPS of V2 O3 (3d 2 conDguration) the satellite structure related to the V 2p1=2 feature is not easily observed (Fig. 4.3) because of the superposition of a sharp O1s peak occurring at about the same excitation energy (Sawatzky and Post, 1979). The cluster model predictions for the metal 2p core-level XPS spectra of V oxides have been obtained by varying the parameter basis of the Ti oxide case in order to provide a good Dt to the experimental data. For example, Fig. 4.3 shows the calculated V2p-XPS and the experimental data in V2 O3 : the 2p1=2 and 2p3=2 peaks due to spin–orbit splitting of the 2p core-level are observed in the spectrum together with the O1s peak. In addition to the main peaks, satellite structures indicated by CT are seen in the calculated spectra. The satellites originate from the CT mechanism, which is similar as that in 2p-XPS of the late TMCs. The satellite associated with the 2p3=2 peak can be seen in the experimental data, whereas the satellite associated with the 2p1=2 peak is obscured by the O1s line as already mentioned. Both main peak and satellite are strongly mixed states between cd n and cd n+1 L conDgurations, as in the case of Ti2 O3 (and Cr 2 O3 compounds). As a characteristic feature of the experimental data of the TM 2p-XPS (Ti to Fe sesquioxides), one can see that the energy separation ES between the main peak and the corresponding CT satellite systematically changes from about 12 eV for Ti2 O3 to 6:5 eV for Fe2 O3 . This variation in ES is mainly caused by the p–d e1ective hybridization energy Ve1 : Es = |( − Udc )2 − 4(Ve1 )2 |1=2 ≈2Ve1 ;
(4.2)
32
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 4.4. VB-XPS spectra of V2 O3 ; VO2 and V2 O5 at room temperature, showing the O2p and V3d contributions (adapted from Zimmermann et al., 1998, 1999).
where Ve1 is deDned by Ve1 = [N (eg ){V (eg )}2 + N (t2g ){V (t2g )}2 ]1=2 :
(4.3)
Since V (eg ) itself decreases monotonically from 3:0 eV for Ti2 O3 to 1:9 eV for Fe2 O3 and N (t2g ) increases from 9 for Ti2 O3 to 5 for Fe2 O3 , Ve1 systematically decreases from 6:9 eV for Ti2 O3 to 3:2 eV for Fe2 O3 . It is important to note that Ve1 is rather large in early TMCs so as to give in Eq. (4.2) ES ≈2Ve1 , because | − Udc |Ve1 in most cases. In this way the systematic change in ES (main peak-satellite distance) is mainly caused by the hybridization energy Ve1 (Uozumi et al., 1997). Finally, an experimental comparison of the VB-XPS spectra of V2 O3 , VO2 and V2 O5 compounds is presented in Fig. 4.4. The VB are separated into a main part, covering the binding energy range from 3 to 9 eV and a separate small peak near the Fermi level, which is absent for V2 O5 , and then grows in intensity with formal d 1 and d 2 occupations in the other two oxides. Therefore, it would be tempting to interpret the VB spectra in these oxides in terms of a simple ionic picture, namely to assign the main part to the Dlled O2p shell and the structure at low binding energy to the increasing number of V3d electrons. However, it has been shown that there is a considerable hybridization which mixes the orbital character of these spectral features and modiDes the electronic properties in these oxides (Zimmermann et al., 1998, 1999). 4.2. Resonant photoemission Some RPES results will be now recalled in order to better understand the electronic properties of this interesting class of materials. RPES from atomic 3d states occurs when the energy of the ionizing photons coincides with the 3p–3d optical absorption threshold. As the photon energy is
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
33
changed from below to above the threshold, the 3d photoelectron yield is observed to increase dramatically. This phenomenon has been extensively investigated in both atoms and solids and comprehensive reviews have been published about a decade ago (Davis, 1986; Parlebas et al., 1990). In large part, these studies have been concentrated on the phenomenon in the rare-earth metals and heavy transition metals (Z¿25, where Z is the atomic number). Far fewer studies of the resonance in the light transition metals have been undertaken. It was however remarked that the 3p–3d PES resonance in the light TMs, such as Ti, V and Cr, is very di1erent from that of heavier TMs (Bethel et al., 1983; Barth et al., 1985). For example, the resonance proDles (plots of the emission intensity versus photon energy) in the lighter metals do not display the characteristic Fano-type line shape observed for the heavier ones. These resonance were found to extend over 40–50 eV in photon energy as opposed to approximately 10 eV in the heavier metals. These studies have been also undertaken with the hope of using the resonance e1ect to identify the extent of d-state hybridization in the O 2p peaks in oxides of these metals. The enhancement of the 3d photoabsorption yield at photon energies close to the 3p–3d optical absorption threshold can be written in an atomic picture as 3p6 3d n + h! → 3p6 3d n−1 + e− () ;
(4.4)
where a photon of energy h! ionizes the neutral atom and eject a 3d electron with kinetic energy , 3p optical absorption can be written as 3p6 3d n + h! → [3p6 3d n+1 ]∗ ;
(4.5)
where the photon energy h! is close to the 3p threshold and the asterisk denotes an excited state. The [3p6 3d n+1 ]∗ state consists of a hole in the 3p shell of a metal ion and an extra electron in the d shell of the same atom. This excited state can de-excite by a number of mechanisms. One such mechanism is the autoionization, [3p6 3d n+1 ]∗ → [3p6 3d n ]∗ + e− ( ) ;
(4.6)
followed by a super-Coster–Kronig (SCK) Auger decay, [3p6 3d n ]∗ → 3p6 3d n−2 + e− ( ) ;
(4.7)
where is the kinetic energy of the d electron emitted in the M23 M45 M45 Auger event. Since the energies of the emitted electron in this decay channel are di1erent from the energies of the photoemitted electron, no resonance occurs. However, in competition with this mechanism there is a direct recombination, [3p6 3d n+1 ]∗ → 3p6 3d n−1 + e− () :
(4.8)
Here the Dnal state and the electron kinetic energy are identical to those following the conventional 3d photoemission of Eq. (4.4). Thus, the process of direct recombination can interfere with the 3d photoemission process and produces a characteristic narrow, asymmetrical line shape (the Fano line shape) for the resonance proDle (Fano, 1961). RPES experiments in VO2 , V2 O3 and V2 O5 have shown that both O 2p and V 3d bands present resonant enhancement through the vanadium 3p–3d threshold (Smith and Henrich, 1988; Zimmermann et al., 1998). For example, Smith and Henrich observed in Ti2 O3 and V2 O3 a strong angular anisotropy, probably related to the molecular-orbital structure of these oxides. Also the maximum in the cation 3d
34
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
resonant emission occurred at the same photon energy in both metals and oxides, indicating a signiDcant degree of localization of the cation resonance. These results, together with the RPES determination of the VB electronic structure of Cr 2 O3 , were found similar to those observed in Ti2 O3 and V2 O3 , so that these authors claimed that all the compounds should be considered MH insulators (Li et al., 1992). Moreover, vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) reJectance and PES of V2 O5 , VO2 and V2 O3 have been measured to investigate the 3d-band structure, the electron correlation e1ects (Shin et al., 1990) and the metal–insulator phase transitions. Since the DOS at the Fermi level in V2 O3 was found to be rather low, even in the metallic phase, it was concluded that electron correlation e1ects were important in these oxides and it was thereby suggested that a Mott-type metal–insulator transition is induced in V2 O3 . However, recent vand c-XPS results (Bocquet et al., 1996; Zimmermann et al., 1998) have shown with a cluster model calculation that a considerable hybridization mixes the orbital character of the spectral features of the three vanadium oxides. These results reveal the importance of the covalency in vanadium oxides and seem thus to demand a reconsideration of the standard classiDcation of these oxides as simple MH compounds. 4.3. A related problem: VCn clusters for V adsorption on graphite In Section 4.3.1 we recall a preliminary study (Parlebas et al., 1997) for the calculation of 3d-metal core 3s-XPS spectra in the case of the dilute limit of vanadium adsorption on graphite, i.e. by considering only one 3d-metal atom adsorbed at a bridge position on the graphite surface (0001) and irradiated by an incident X-ray photon of energy h!. In Section 4.3.2 we then present various extensions shown in Section 4.3.1 of the preliminary calculation made by Kruger et al. (1997, 1999). 4.3.1. Bridge position in VC2 and appearance of localized magnetic moments Historically, what prompted us to perform the present calculation was the result of Binns et al. (1992). These authors found a satellite structure in the vanadium 3s-XPS which was ascribed to the presence of magnetic moments on V surface atoms of an islanded V Dlm. However, as far as the appearance of magnetism is concerned for a vanadium condensed system, it is well known that the interactions between nearest neighbors of vanadium atoms in general hinders the onset of localized magnetic moments (Parlebas and Gautier, 1973). Thus, in the present model, we only envision the most favorable case for V magnetism i.e. a single V atom, adsorbed on graphite at a bridge position, as it will become clear afterwards. For this reason we extend the SIAM and take into account both the Udc core-hole screening and the Jdc exchange term between the spins of the core electrons and 3d electrons in the Dnal state of the c-XPS process. Actually, the c-XPS spectra strongly reJect many-body e1ects arising from the outer electrons of an irradiated material. When a 3s core hole is produced at a 3d transition metal atom by an incident photon, the outer electron system is perturbed by the core hole charge and screens it: Udc is more precisely the Coulomb integral between a 3d and a 3s electron as already deDned in the preceding sections. In this process the core hole plays the role of a “test charge” which induces a many-body dielectric response of the outer electron system. However, since the 3s core hole has not only a charge but also a spin, it can also play the role of a “test spin”, thereby inducing a magnetic response of the outer electron system mediated by the exchange integral Jdc . In order
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
35
to complete Eq. (2.1) and in addition to Udc already present, we had to keep Udd , the Coulomb integral between two d electrons, originally introduced in the pioneer work of Anderson (1961) and to include the corresponding exchange integrals Jdd and Jdc not yet included in Eq. (2.1). As usual, Vkm labels the hybridization term between a |dm state among the Dve 3d orbitals of a given spin and a |k substrate band state of same spin. For simplicity, in this preliminary study, we only took two “band” orbitals to describe the 2pz band of graphite in the Fermi energy region: one below (k = ) and one above (k = ∗ ) the Fermi level, representing the bonding (ligand) and antibonding (conduction) parts of the graphite -band. In our Hamiltonian, the two “band” orbitals are not coupled directly but rather through the transition-metal 3d orbitals by the hybridization Vkm . This simplest model is equivalent to considering only two carbon atoms (2sz spin orbitals) like a diatomic C2 molecule, hybridized with a vanadium atom (5 spin d orbitals) just sitting at a bridge position upon a diatomic molecule and building a VC2 cluster. Also, in this preliminary calculation, we limit ourselves to the case of a nominally 3d 3 adsorbed vanadium atom, i.e. we focus on the divalent atomic conDguration 3d 3 4s2 . Altogether we got 5 electrons (3 “d” and 2 “pz ”) which are ascribed to our considered VC2 cluster in the initial state (ground state) of the core level photoemission process, when the core orbital is still Dlled. Then we diagonalized the Hamiltonian in the subspace |d 3 ; |d 4 ; |d 2 ∗ and |d 3 ∗ , where means a hole in the ligand orbital. In the Dnal state of the photoemission process, where a 3s core hole c had just been created, we took the subspace |cd 3 ; |cd 4 ; |cd 2 ∗ and |cd 3 ∗ . The charge transfer energies, = E(d 4 ) − E(d 3 ) and ∗ = E(d 2 ∗ ) − E(d 3 ) are deDned between |d 3 and |d 4 , |d 2 ∗ , respectively. Our parameters values (Parlebas et al., 1997) appear in the caption of Fig. 4.5. Comparable values for the Coulomb integrals Udd and Udc had already been used within similar calculations on V sesquioxides V2 O3 (Section 4.1). The low spin conDguration (in Fig. 4.5, Sd = 1=2) shows essentially a two peak structure with a small charge transfer satellite at about 7 eV from the main line. In this case, the exchange splitting cannot be resolved. On the contrary, in the high spin conDguration (Fig. 4.5, Sd = 3=2) the exchange splitting is quite large and gives rise to a big exchange satellite at about 4 eV from the main line. Also this last feature of the high spin conDguration is not very sensitive neither to the charge transfer energies and ∗ , nor to the hybridization strength Vkm = Vd = Vd∗ . As a matter of fact, already within the present preliminary model, the spectrum of the low spin conDguration Dts much better the experimental data (small satellite) of Binns et al. (1992) than the high spin conDguration. Our preliminary conclusion was that the satellite in V 3s-XPS spectra of dilute V upon graphite (VC2 cluster) was most likely due to charge transfer, i.e. core hole screening, rather than to localized magnetism on the V atom. This does not exclude the presence of a small V magnetic moment. The same conclusion was already suggested in a very crude model with no exchange interaction, no d orbital degeneracy and with a Dlled d band approximation (Rakotomakevitra et al., 1995). The present model is now systematically extended, in the following subsection, to various geometrical positions of the adsorbed atom. Special emphasis is put on the study of a VC6 cluster. 4.3.2. Hollow position in VC6 (C6v symmetry) and other positions First of all, let us consider in detail the “hollow position” (Kruger et al., 1997) where the adatom sits above the center of a C6 ring at a distance h from it (C6v symmetry). The
36
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 4.5. Calculated 3s-XPS spectra of V upon graphite i.e. a VC2 cluster for (a) low (1=2) and (b) high (3=2) V 3d spin conDgurations, using a phenomenological model and the following parameters (eV): Udd = = ∗ = 5; Vd = Vd∗ = ' = 2; Udc = 7; Jdc = 2:5; Jdd = 0:4; ∗ − = 5; ' characterizes the spectral broadening due to Dnite lifetime of the core hole and experimental resolution (from Parlebas et al., 1997).
C-cluster Hamiltonian was diagonalized by constructing appropriate molecular orbitals (MOs) which transform as the irreducible representations of the symmetry group (Fig. 4.6). The energies of the various six carbon MOs are expressed in terms of the Slater–Koster integral pp between nearest-neighbor C atoms. Following Priester et al. (1982), the following choice was made: pp = −3:33 eV, which led to a reasonably good description of the -band structure of graphite; TM d orbitals and C MOs were then coupled through hybridization, which vanished for certain symmetry (Fig. 4.6). By the construction of symmetrical C MOs, the number of non-vanishing hybridization integrals (between the TM atom and the C cluster) was minimized. In contrast to our preliminary model (Section 4.3.1), the hybridization integrals Vkm now depend on the adatom–surface distance h, essentially through the Slater–Koster integrals pd and pd between V and C atoms, which themselves are functions of h (Kruger et al., 1997). Because of d–d correlation, the one-electron d of the TM atom has no direct physical meaning. Rather
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
37
Fig. 4.6. Scheme of the Hamiltonian when the adatom sits at a hollow position corresponding to a VC6 cluster. Thick horizontal lines represent orbitals: transition-metal core and d orbitals on the left and C cluster (molecular) orbitals on the right. In the atomic limit (V = 0) the lower half (¡p ) is double occupied, the upper half (¿p ) empty. The order of the d orbitals is 3z2 –r 2 ; yz; zx; xy, x2 –y2 . Thin solid lines indicate non-zero hybridization integrals. Dotted lines symbolize electron correlation (from KrXuger et al., 1977).
than d , we therefore again specify the quantity = E(d n+1 p ) − E(d n ) = d + nUdd − p , i.e., the charge-transfer energy for moving one electron from the center of the carbon MO spectrum (p = F ) to the TM d orbitals. Here n is the number of d electrons in the atomic limit (V = 0). Since each Cpz orbitals adds one electron, the VC6 cluster contains n + 6 electrons altogether. For clarity we give below the explicit form of the Hamiltonian which incorporates Jdd and Jdc into Eq. (2.1). Again H = HL + HTM + Hmix ; where
(4.9)
k a+ k ak ; k HTM = d a+ a+ m am + c c ac
HL =
m
+ Udd
m¡m
+ Udc
m
and Hmix =
km
(4.10)
+ a+ m am am am − Jdd
+ a+ m am ac ac − Jdc
(Vkm (h)a+ k am + h:c:) :
Sm · Sm
m¡m
Sm · Sc
(4.11)
m
(4.12)
38
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 4.7. Calculated V 3s-XPS spectra as a function of h for n = 3 and = 2:5; 5:0 eV. Both values of correspond to small charge transfer between V and C6 (hollow position) (from Kruger et al., 1997).
Here c, m and k refer to the 3s core orbital, the Dve 3d orbitals and the cluster molecular + and a+ are the corresponding creation operators; labels the orbitals respectively; a+ c ; am k 1 two spin directions. Sm = 2 a+ m am is the spin operator for electrons in orbital m. Here are the matrix elements of the Pauli spin matrices = (x ; y ; z ). Jdd and Jdc are the exchange integrals between two d electrons and between a d and a core electron, respectively. As in the preceding subsection the Hamiltonian was diagonalized in the conDguration– interaction approach; the values for Udd , Jdd , Udc and Jdc were kept the same as before (Parlebas et al., 1997), but now the h-dependent hybridization is fully calculated (Kruger et al., 1997). Recently Peng et al. (1996) determined the equilibrium position of a single non-magnetic Fe atom adsorbed on the graphite surface by ab initio “full potential linearized augmented plane wave” (FLAPW) total energy calculation. They actually considered an extremely dilute Fe monolayer. W above the surface was found to be the stable position. With this value The hollow site 1:6 A W (Fig. 4.7). In the as a rough estimation for vanadium, h was varied between 1.0 and 2:5 A atomic state, vanadium has, as in the preceding subsection (Section 4:2:1), a 3d 3 4s2 conDguration. We shall take n = 3 in Fig. 4.7 which leads to the correct atomic limit (V → 0 ⇔ h → ∞). For small heights, i.e. strong hybridizations, the system has a low spin behavior with a total W for = 2:5 eV, the system d-spin Sd = −7=27B = 0:6. At a critical h, which is about 1:5 A switches to a high-spin state with Sd around 3=2. The spin transition is a consequence of the competition between magnetic and chemical energies, i.e. adsorption energy. Also there is a strong correlation between Sd and the occupancies of the |xy, |x2 –y2 and |3z 2 –r 2 orbitals. The magnetic transition can be phenomenologically explained using an atomic model which includes a crystal Deld term (Kruger et al., 1997). In Fig. 4.7, the calculated XPS spectra are shown as a function of h, for = 2:5 and 5:0 eV in the case of n = 3. The low-to-high spin
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
39
transition occurs when the vanadium adatom moves away from the C6 surface. The low-spin spectra (low h) are characterized by a main line and a small satellite which is due to Dnal-state charge transfer as a result of core hole screening; the exchange splitting cannot be resolved since it is too small. In the high-spin regime (high h) the spectral shapes depend strongly on the parameter . For = 5:0 eV they are very atomic-like with a simple exchange splitting of Jdc (Sd + 1=2) = 5 eV; Dnal-state charge-transfer features are very small. For = 2:5 eV, however, the spectra are more complex, showing essentially a three-peak structure. No clear distinction between the exchange-split main line and charge-transfer satellite can be made. Again if we compare these spectra with the experimental ones by Binns et al. (1992), we Dnd the best agreement in the low-spin regime close to the transition point, although the main-line in the satellite splitting is a little larger here than in the experiment. Quite recently Kruger et al. (1999) have extended the preceding study to the whole 3d-series selfconsistently for the three characteristic adsorption sites: hollow, on-top and bridge. In addition to the previously considered work of Peng et al. (1996), on the same subject, at least for W we should also an Fe adatom, which was shown to be stable at the hollow site with h = 1:6 A, recall two other calculations in the Deld. Montero et al. (1994) compared the stability of the di1ering adsorption sites for a V atom on graphite by means of electronic structure calculations using the semi-empirical complete neglect of di1erential overlap (CNDO) method; they found that the stable position of the V adatom is the hollow site with an adatom–surface distance h W and that bridge and on-top sites are less stable. Also Du1y et al. (1998) between 1.7 and 1:8 A, calculated the stable positions and magnetic moments of 3d-TM adatoms on graphite, using a linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO) molecular approach within density functional theory (DFT): they obtained that the early 3d-TM elements up to Cr and Mn (thus including W while the late 3d-TM elements Fe, Co, Ni occupy V) occupy the on-top position with h = 2:1 A, W the hollow site with h = 1:5 A. Moreover, for all the 3d elements, except Mn, the d-charge of the adatom was found closer to that of a monovalent ion, i.e. 3d n+1 4s1 rather than of a divalent ion i.e., 3d n 4s2 , as given by the free atom electronic conDguration. However the Sd spin values reported by Du1y et al. (1998) were smaller by an amount of 0.2– 0.5, as compared to the Drst Hund’s rule results applied to the monovalent 3d-ions, i.e. Sd = |no − 5|=2 with no = n + 1. Again, Mn is an exception, with Sd = 2:3, which is by 0.3 larger than the corresponding Hund’s rule for a 3d 6 ion. Now, taking the preceding equilibrium positions and related h values, Kruger et al. (1999) found that the various 3d-adatoms along the series are each in a high spin (Hund’s rule) ground state. Upon decreasing h, however, they observed in some cases, a Drst order spin transition to a low spin state. These spin transitions are accompanied by electronic transitions between di1ering d-orbitals and can be explained in an e1ective crystal Deld model. The photoemission spectra obtained by Kruger et al. (1999) show intra-atomic exchange splitting as well as charge transfer satellites from Dnal state core hole screening by graphite -electrons; the intensity of the charge transfer satellites increases with no , the d-electrons number, which reJects the increasing electron-electron correlation, from light to heavy 3d-elements. Finally, we again address the comparison with the experimental data of 3s-XPS of V clusters on graphite reported by Binns et al. (1992). In the beginning of the present subsection we showed that these experimental spectra can be interpreted by the V 3d adatom (hollow site) being in the low-spin regime; the observed satellite is then due to the charge transfer e1ect rather than to a magnetic moment on V. This seems to contradict recent results of Kruger et al. (1999),
40
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
where a large magnetic moment of 47B was found for the (monovalent) V adatom at the on-top W It must be kept in mind, however, that our model deals with equilibrium-position with h=2:1 A. a single adatom while experiments were carried out on clusters with a size of a few nanometers. Finally, we believe that a single V adatom on graphite may be in a high spin state in agreement with Du1y et al. (1998), but that the V clusters of Binns et al. (1992, 1999) are in a low spin state (or in an antiferromagnetic state) due to later-atomic d–d electron hopping. We hope that this issue will be clariDed by new experimental and theoretical studies in near future. 5. Chromium compounds The most controversial topics in TMCs, i.e. the character of the valence and conduction electron states and the origin of band gaps, have been also studied and discussed for di1erent types of chromium compounds (mainly oxides and halides). In this section we brieJy review a few valence band XPS and BIS results for chromium compounds (Section 5.1); then we present some corresponding core level XPS spectra (Section 5.2). 5.1. Valence band XPS and BIS Metallic CrO2 , with a Curie temperature Tc ∼390 K is the only ferromagnet of this class. Schwarz (1986) used the LSDA band theory to predict that the spin moment would be the full 27B required by Hund’s rules for the Cr 4+ (3d 2 ) ion. The Fermi level lies in a partly Dlled band for the majority (up-spin) electrons, but for minority (down-spin) electrons it lies in the semiconducting gap, which separates the Dlled oxygen 2p levels from the chromium 3d levels. This behavior has been named “half-metallic” by de Groot et al. (1983). Recent LSDA band calculations (Lewis et al., 1997) agree with the Schwarz’s band structure and provide an analysis of the transport measurements using band theoretical parameters. Resistivity measurements have given an electron mean free path, which is only a few angstroms at 600 K, with the resistivity always rising as the temperature increases (Lewis et al., 1997). The electronic structure of CrO2 has been also studied by PES and by speciDc heat measurements (Tsujioka et al., 1997). The Cr 3d band shows a splitting into a upper and lower Hubbard bands, with a small but Dnite density of states at the Fermi level, consistent with the metallic behavior. Lewis et al. (1997) reported a combined plot of UPS and BIS spectra of CrO2 compounds which they compared with theoretical spectra deduced from LSDA and LSDA + U band structure calculations (Fig. 5.1). One can notice that the large splitting (∼5 eV) between the prominent Cr 3d peaks is closer to the value (∼4:5 eV) obtained from the LSDA+U calculation rather than that (∼1:6 eV) obtained from the LSDA calculation. The underestimate of the splitting in the LSDA calculation is due to the neglect of the Hubbard splitting of the 3d band by ∼U . This quantity is estimated to be ∼ 3:4 eV, close to the value used in the LSDA + U calculation, which predicts an insulating U= gap only for U ¿6 eV. In conclusion, these recent results put CrO2 into the category of the “bad metals”, together with the high-Tc superconductors, the high-T metallic phase of VO2 and the ferromagnet SrRuO3 . Either for insulating Cr oxides, such as Cr 2 O3 or for halides of chromium, such as CrX3 (X=Cl, Br), the self-consistent one-electron band-structure description breaks down, because of
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
41
Fig. 5.1. Combined UPS and BIS spectra for CrO2 compounds: experimental data (thick line); theoretical results from LSDA (dotted line) and LSDA + U (thin line) (adapted from Lewis et al., 1997).
the strong electron correlations (Antoci and Mihich, 1978). As for the origin of the bandgaps (EG ), Ronda et al. (1987) pointed out that the most reliable methods for determining EG are a comparison of direct and inverse PES, or better, photoconductivity measurements. CrCl3 and CrBr 3 compounds are magnetic insulators with an energy gap of about 2.3 and 2:1 eV, respectively, and an ionicity parameter fiDT ≈0:80 (Pollini, 1998). This parameter was calculated within the framework of Phillips theory (Phillips and van Vechten, 1969), earlier applied to divalent TMCs with open shell conDguration (Thomas and Pollini, 1985). The low temperature structure of CrX3 is like that of layered BiI3 crystals. CrCl3 has a hexagonal unit cell with 3 (monoclinic with four forW and c = 17:47 A W below 238 K. The space group is C2h a = 5:952 A 3 mula units per unit cell) above 240 K and C2i (rhombohedral with two formula units per unit W and c = 18:20 A W cell) at lower temperatures. CrBr 3 has a hexagonal unit cell with a = 6:26 A 3 and its low temperature structure has the space group C2h . Valence XPS results are reported in Fig. 5.2 for layered CrCl3 and CrBr 3 crystals and have been compared to the experimental v-XPS (and BIS) spectra of Cr 2 O3 insulating compounds (Uozumi et al., 1997). These spectra are rather similar and can be divided into the main band (1–10 eV) and the satellite region (10 –15 eV). A weak satellite feature was Drst detected in the VB-XPS spectrum of a high quality CrCl3 crystal, but was not considered in the earlier discussion of the data so that the main emission band was simply assigned to Cr 3d 2 (poorly screened) Dnal states (Pollini, 1994). In Cr 2 O3 , the main peak and satellite are largely separated because of the strong p–d hybridization strength with an energy distance Es given by Eq. (4.2). In CrX3 , the main Cr 3d structure, partly mixed with the nearby Cl 3p and Br 4p bands, is located at binding energies around 3 eV and the Dnal state peak position for a BIS experiment has been indicated in Fig. 5.2. The BIS position has been extrapolated by inspection of vacuum ultraviolet reJectance (Fig. 5.3) and EELS data measured on CrCl3 and CrBr 3 crystals (Carricaburu et al., 1986; Pollini et al., 1989) and by taking into consideration the various
42
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 5.2. Valence XPS spectra for layered CrCl3 (a) and CrBr 3 (b) compounds (from Pollini, 1999).
Fig. 5.3. Vacuum ultraviolet reJectance for CrCl3 (a) and CrBr 3 (b) compounds (from Carricaburu et al., 1986).
electronic processes discussed in these experiments. The PES and BIS peaks give an indication of the Cr 3d 2 and Cr 3d 4 energy level positions (Hubbard bands), whose separation yields the Coulomb energy U (=Udd ) to zero order both in CrBr 3 and CrCl3 (U =3:6 and 4:6 eV). Energy corrections due to p–d hybridization reduce then the solid state value U and the value of atomic origin Ubare , which has been determined by estimating approximately the hybridization shifts p–d in Cr halides. In Cr 2 O3 , the satellite feature (S) has an energy separation (ES ) from the main line given by ES ≈11:5 eV, while in CrCl3 and CrBr 3 , the weak satellite structures detected
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
43
Table 5.1 Solid state parameters (eV) of early transition metal compounds rough estimated through the analysis of 2p-XPS and v-XPS, UV reJectance and EELS spectraa Compounds
dn
U (∗ )
V
Ve1
ES
EG
References
Ti2 O3 V 2 O3
d1 d2
3.0 3.9 2.3 3.5
6.9 6.8 6.5 7.6
2.5
d3
11.1–11.5
2.6 –2.8
CrCl3
d3
1.7
3.6
7.9
2.3
Bocquet et al. (1996) Bocquet et al. (1996) Zimmermann et al. (1999) Uozumi et al. (1997) Bocquet et al. (1996) Pollini (1999)
CrBr 3 MnO
d3 d5
5.5 6.5
4.5 4.0 3.8 5.2 5.5 4.0 3.5 3.5 7.0
12.0 12.0
Cr 2 O3
6.0 4.0 5.5 5.2 5.5 6.5
1.7 1.9
3.6 4.2
7.7 10.5
2.1 4.5 – 6.0
Pollini (1999) Park et al. (1988)
a
Ue1 = U − 9: the e1ective U1 can be reduced considerably from the bare U by an hybridization shift 9, since the states near the energy gap can have a large ligand p character.
in VB-XPS have a distance from the main emission of ES ≈7:9 eV and ≈7:7 eV, respectively. The satellite origin in the spectra of CrX3 is due, in the spirit of the CI cluster model, to the e1ective hybridization Ve1 between the 3d 2 and 3d 3 L Dnal states Ve1 = [(6 − n)(Tt2g )2 + 4(Teg )2 ]1=2 ;
(5.1)
where Tt2g and Teg are the one-electron mixing matrix elements: Teg = eg |H |eg = V and Tt2g = t2g |H |t2g = 0:5 V. In the simple case, when the Hamiltonian is restricted to d n and d n+1 L
conDgurations, the main peak–satellite splitting ES in VB-XPS is given by Eq. (4.2). In many early TMCs the parameters , U and Ve1 have comparable values and the e1ect of covalency is important in the properties of the ground and Drst ionization state, suggesting that the hole introduced in the ionization state is spread over the neighbouring ligand sites. However, the e1ective hybridization parameter in CrX3 has a value of Ve1 ∼ 3:7 eV, which is slightly lower than in early TMCs, where Ve1 = 6–9 eV (Bocquet et al., 1996; Uozumi et al., 1997). Thus the satellite structure may be assigned to slightly mixed 3d 3 L and 3d 2 conDgurations. Also the main Cr 3d emission, formerly assigned to poorly screened 3d 2 Dnal hole-state energies (¿U ), is in fact weakly screened by a ligand electron transferred into the 3d Dnal state conDguration. In this case, however, the Coulomb interaction, due to the 3d valence hole, does not seem strong enough to widely separate the di1erent Dnal state conDgurations and only a CM calculation could predict their relative weights quantitatively. In Table 5.1, the cluster model parameters for Cr trihalides (Pollini, 2000) and some typical early TMOs have been listed. We remark that Ti2 O3 and V2 O3 may be classiDed as MH compounds (Bocquet et al., 1996; Saitoh et al., 1995), while Cr 2 O3 seems an intermediate compound. In the case of CrCl3 and CrBr 3 insulators, we have U ¡, i.e. the Coulomb repulsion energy U is lower than the CT energy, but larger than the dispersional 3d bandwidth w (0:5 eV); the e1ective hybridization Ve1 (3.7 eV) is of the same order of magnitude of U and . It is also worth noting that the V values here found (1.7–1:8 eV) for CrX3 almost agree with the value (V ∼1:5 eV) earlier estimated with the spectroscopic model (Pollini, 1998) and that, besides, they are consistent with the values
44
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 5.4. Charge transfer versus Mott–Hubbard classiDcation in terms of (; U ) (adapted from Fujimori et al., 1987).
of many early TMOs. Thus, although it is possible that Cr halides might have an intermediate character as some early TMOs, one can however see from Fig. 5.4 that the ionic Cr trihalides are inside the MH region (large values of ) and located close to MH insulators, such as TiO and V2 O3 (Fujimori et al., 1987) (Fig. 5.4). The analysis of the valence band spectrum shows that the satellite–main peak distance is governed by the e1ective hybridization, which may inJuence the classiDcation scheme of light TMCs. However, the ionicity parameter of CrX3 points out that the calculated p–d hybridization energy in CrCl3 and CrBr 3 is not as large as in early TMOs. Also the importance of the correlation energy U in determining the insulating nature of CrX3 is conDrmed. Nevertheless, the correct picture of each Dnal state (main peak or satellite) in these compounds in the valence band region is represented by a mixture of screened and unscreened conDgurations, with a lower degree of e1ective screening in the states at lower binding energy. 5.2. Core level XPS Core-level spectra obtained in crystalline CrCl3 (Pollini, 2000) seem to reproduce again the same features observed in the valence band region, with satellites which can be interpreted either within the charge transfer or, possibly, by the competing exciton model. However, in the case of core-level photoemission, one has also to check whether the observed satellites arise exclusively from intrinsic Dnal-state e1ects, or whether extrinsic losses, e.g. due to plasmon excitation, may contribute to them, especially in cases where the main line-to-satellite separation takes a value of a typical plasmon energy. Fig. 5.5 shows the core-level Cr 3p-XPS and Cr 3s-XPS results for CrCl3 for binding energies between 25 and 125 eV. The general aspect of the photoemission core-level spectrum is rather similar to that previously reported (Pollini, 1994), but the improved
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
45
Fig. 5.5. 3s and 3p Cr XPS spectra of CrCl3 compounds (from Pollini, 2000).
quality surface of freshly grown crystals has shown new features and weak details which were not observed before. In the Cr 3p-XPS, at binding energy between 35 and 60 eV, a satellite structure (S) is well separated from the main line, but the analysis is complicated by the existence of a pronounced multiplet splitting and spin-orbit e1ects. The main line at about 45 eV ∼ 8:8 eV from the main line and a spread of is followed by the weak satellite (S) at ES = spectral features up to about 70 eV. In Cr 3s-XPS of CrCl3 the main emission, split by ex∼ 75 and 79:3 eV, accompanied by a satellite (S) at change interaction, presents peaks at EB = ∼ ES = 10 eV and a broad band at about 22 eV from the main peak. These photoemission spectra resemble somewhat the Cr 3p and Cr 3s core level spectra reported for CrCl3 (Okusawa, 1984) and Cr 2 O3 (Uozumi et al., 1997), but with di1erent energy values for satellites. In the Cr 3s-XPS of Cr 2 O3 measured by Uozumi et al. (1997), in addition to the two main peaks ∼ 10 eV and split by the 3d–3s exchange interaction, one also observes two CT satellites at EB =
46
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 5.6. EELS spectrum of CrBr 3 (from Pollini et al., 1989).
∼ 20 eV (see Fig. 3 in Okusawa’s paper). The Cr 3s spectra are governed a CI satellite at EB = by the exchange coupling of the spin of the 3s core hole to the total spin with the intensity ratio between the split peaks given by S=(S + 1). For late TMCs this picture seems to work already with diEculties, suggesting one to use with cautions the splitting as a rough measure for the 3d occupation and magnetic moment (Fadley et al., 1969; Hermsmeier et al., 1988; van Acker et al., 1988; Kinsinger et al., 1990). Also, for intermediary-to-early TMCs, there seems to be no direct correlation of the exchange splitting with the actual magnetic moment (see also Section 4.3.2). In Cr 3p-XPS Dnal states of CrCl3 , the Coulomb multiplet coupling between the 3p hole and the 3d electrons becomes larger and a1ects the spectral shape, as in the Cr 3p spectrum of Cr 2 O3 . The satellite structure (S) observed in Fig. 5.5 can be due to a CT process: this would be supported by the observation and analysis of a similar satellite in Cr 3p-XPS in Cr 2 O3 observed ∼ 10 eV from the main line. However, it cannot be excluded that, owing to the larger at ES = value of the main-to-satellite ES distance, the satellite could be also assigned to an excitonic process involving the 4s, 4p metal orbitals, in correspondence with the energy values observed for interband p–s transitions in the optical spectra. As for the 22 eV satellite band, which has the same energy distance as the plasmon maximum seen in EELS spectra of CrCl3 (Carricaburu et al., 1986; Pollini et al., 1989), it could be assigned to plasma oscillations (extrinsic satellite) on these grounds. Plasmon maxima have been observed in EELS spectra at 20 eV (CrBr 3 ) and 22 eV (CrCl3 ); Fig. 5.6 shows an example of an EELS spectrum measured in CrBr 3 samples. Thus, it seems that the satellite structures observed in photoelectron spectra of CrCl3 can be described within the approach of the charge transfer model as in early and late TMCs, although the electronic conDgurations for the main line and satellites may not be the same. It is however not sure that the charge transfer model can explain satellite structures of all the transition metal photoelectron spectra, for instance in the photoemission core-level spectra. In this connection, we have to recall that the exciton satellite mechanism may be dominant over the charge-transfer satellites, when is large and U is small and there are many empty 3d orbitals.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
47
Fig. 5.7. Cr 2p-, 3s- and 3p-XPS spectra of CrO2 and Cr 2 O3 compounds (adapted from Zimmermann et al., 1999).
Fig. 5.7 shows a summary of the experimental core level XPS spectra in CrO2 and Cr 2 O3 in relation to cluster model results (Zimmermann et al., 1999). The metallic ferromagnet CrO2 is considered as an important material widely used for its magnetic properties; it is one of the few TMOs both metallic and magnetic that belongs to the class of itinerant ferromagnets. Surprisingly, band structure calculations, transport properties, Hubbard splitting and electron correlations have been studied only very recently (Schwarz, 1986; Lewis et al., 1997; Tsujioka et al., 1997). The Cr 2p spectra are characterized by a strong spin-orbit splitting into the 2p1=2 and 2p3=2 parts. The coupling increases with the atomic number of the TM from TiO2 through V oxides (7–8 eV) and the Cr oxides (nearly 10 eV) to a value of more 12 eV for Fe oxides. The main Cr 3s photoemission line shows a well separated exchange satellite, which is split o1 by 4:1 eV in Cr 2 O3 . The Cr 3p-XPS spectra also exhibit a satellite structure well separated from the main line, but contrary to the case of the Cr 2p-XPS spectra, the spin–orbit splitting is small and is only reJected in a broadening of the main lines. However, for Cr compounds the pronounced multiplet splitting makes a precise determination of satellite position and weight very diEcult. In CrF2 compounds for a study of the photoemission of Cr 2p and 3s XPS lines
48
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 6.1. Theoretical charge transfer energy versus d-electron number n (from Kotani et al., 1995).
on one hand and of the CrL2; 3 absorption edges on the other hand, we refer to Okada et al. (1994) and Theil et al. (1999), respectively. 6. Systematic trends The electronic structure of early TMCs seems determined by a balance between charge-transfer energy, dd electron correlations and covalency. In the previous section a list of model parameter values for (; U; V ) as well as for the resulting ES , the main line–satellite distance, and the bandgap energy EG has been reported in a few cases in order to discuss recent results on early TMCs (Table 5.1). However, one further needs to know how , U and V are related to n, the net d-electron occupancy and whether the trends established for the late TMCs continue along the whole Drst transition metal row. Hybridization between the metal 3d orbitals and the ligand 2p O orbitals, in the case of TMOs, is included via the one-electron mixing matrix elements deDned as d7 |H |L7 = V7 ;
(6.1)
where V7 =V if 7 indicates the 3z 2 − r 2 or x2 − y2 orbitals; V7 =V if 7 indicates the xy, yz or zx orbitals; L7 and d7 are a ligand electron and a 3d electron, respectively, with the same orbital symmetry. The Slater–Koster parameters (Harrison, 1980) pd and pd, where pd=pd = −2:2, reJect the anisotropic √ hybridization strength of the ligand p orbitals with the metal eg and t2g orbitals; also V = 3 pd and V = 2 pd. The spin and orbital degeneracy is accounted for by the number of conDgurations in the transfer integrals. These points are touched upon in Figs. 6.1– 6.3, which we have adapted from Kotani et al. (1995) and Bocquet et al. (1996). The values of the , U and pd parameters are displayed graphically versus the d-electron number n. These values were carried out by means of a cluster model (CIAM) with the full multiplet structure of the TM ion: they were chosen in such a way that the calculated spectra of XPS and BIS are in good agreement with the experimental data (Uozumi et al., 1997). One can see in Fig. 6.1 that, for a series of compounds with the same ligand, the parameter falls
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
49
Fig. 6.2. Theoretical Coulomb energy U (=Udd ) versus d-electron number n (adapted from Bocquet et al., 1996).
by about 1–2 eV for each decrease in the formal d-electron number and valence state, due to the lowering of the 3d orbitals in the energy diagrams. As one goes along the TM series from Ti to Fe, for any series of compounds, one Dnds a general linear decrease in the parameter reJecting the increasing electronegativity of the metal cation. As for the U parameter (Fig. 6.2), one expects that its value for the early TMCs could be relatively small, as the wave function of the 3d electrons should be fairly extended and the correlation e1ects rather weaker. This can also be seen from the overall decrease in U by going from Fe to Ti. For oxides with the same cation (for example VO2 and V2 O5 ), it turns out that U increases slightly with the decreasing of the d-electron number, probably due to the shrinking of the 3d orbital radius. The correlation becomes larger as the nuclear charge increases in the 3d elements. As the nuclear charge increases, the radius becomes smaller and the e1ective electron density increases. The radius then increases at the end of the 3d period. The metal-insulator transition often appears at both ends of the 3d period, that is, around (Ti, V) and (Ni, Cu) and the magnetic insulators appears at the middle of the period. Thus there seems to be boundaries between (Ti, V) and (Ni, Cu) within which the correlation is large enough to make, for example, oxides insulators. The correlation is not so large in 4d and 5d elements and for most of their oxides the band picture works rather well. However, it must be noted that this statement is an oversimpliDed view. In fact, there are many metallic oxides of the 3d elements other than Ti, V, Ni and Cu. The most remarkable variation between the early and late TMCs is in the value of pd (Fig. 6.3), which falls between 2 and 3 eV for the Ti and V oxides, indicating a larger hybridization than for the late TMOs
50
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 6.3. Theoretical Slater–Koster parameter pd versus d-electron number n (adapted from Bocquet et al., 1996).
(for example about 1 eV for MnO and FeO). While trends for pd are governed principally by the interatomic distances within the cluster, larger values are also found for compounds with small d-electron numbers (Bocquet et al., 1992; Saitoh et al., 1995). Trends for pd across the TM series can be estimated from the relative size of rd , the radial extent of the 3d orbital and dTM−O , the metal–oxygen (for TMOs) distance, using the relationship by Harrison (1980): pd ˙ rd1:5 =d3:5 TM−O :
(6.2)
In summary, it seems from these relatively few results obtained in early TMCs that the parameter values deduced for the charge transfer and Coulomb energy U somewhat continue the systematic trends established for the late TMCs. DeDnitively, the charge transfer mechanism cannot be neglected to analyze satellite structures of early TMCs. Those compounds are characterized by a large hybridization energy and a strong resulting covalency. Actually according to the values of ; U and pd many early TMCs should belong to a new category between the MH and CT regime (Uozumi et al., 1997). 7. Spectroscopic and elastic properties of substoichiometric TiCx , and TiNx compounds Titanium carbides and nitrides are considered as high technology materials often used in microelectronics, space technology, aeroplanes industry and biomaterials, due to their exceptional physical and chemical properties. The conductivity of these materials is of the same order
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
51
of magnitude as pure titanium metal and their melting point, higher than 3000 K, enables to classify them within refractory metals (Toth, 1971; Storms, 1967). At room temperature these compounds are chemically very stable (for example TiN is a good solid solution but CoN is not because of clustering of Co) and present excellent corrosion resistance; thus they can be used as biocompatible layers on orthopaedic and dental implants. Lastly, their hardness, among the highest after diamond, has contributed to the industrial use of titanium carbides as coating for cutting tools and besides, has designate them, as well as titanium nitrides, as good candidates for applications needing high wear resistance (Ohring, 1992; Bunshah and Deshpandey, 1989). On the other hand, titanium nitrides are widely used in semi-conductors technology as di1usion barriers (Kim et al., 1997; Wang and Allen, 1996; Faltermeier et al., 1997). Moreover, a characteristic property of these compounds is to exist on a large substoichiometric scale. As a consequence, the lattice can show an important proportion of vacancies while keeping the same crystallographic structure. This property is very interesting to study experimentally as well as theoretically, since the physical and chemical properties of these systems depend widely upon their vacancy concentration (Williams, 1971; Goldschmidt, 1967). Nevertheless, one should notice that most papers published presently are dealing only with stoichiometric or near stoichiometric titanium carbides and nitrides, due to the usual idea that properties of these materials are then most interesting. In this section we report studies on TiC0:49 ; TiC0:78 ; TiN0:45 and TiN0:61 compounds, i.e. containing vacancies with very di1erent and signiDcant concentrations. These compounds were synthesised by C+ or N+ multiple energy ion implantation (180, 100, 50, 20 keV) in polycrystalline titanium. This method is actually very convenient in order to synthesize well-deDned titanium carbides and nitrides. Layers, about 500 nm thick, were prepared by multiple energy (180, 100, 50 and 20 keV) ion implantation of C+ or N+ in polycrystalline titanium. The dose corresponding to each energy was deDned according to Ziegler et al. (1985). The implanted ion proDles were determined by combining RBS (Rutherford backscattering spectrometry) and SIMS (secondary ion mass spectroscopy) measurements and the crystallographic structure of the layers was obtained by glancing incidence X-ray di1raction (Guemmaz et al., 1996, 1997). The chemical bonds were studied by XPS, performed with an apparatus equipped with two chambers. We refer to Guemmaz et al. (1997a) for details of the experiment. The section is organized as follows: in Section 7.1, we recall a few core-level spectra of titanium carbides and nitrides; then in Section 7.2, we connect the electronic structure obtained by tight binding-linear muEn tin orbitals (TB-LMTO) calculations to the v-XPS and discuss the inJuence of the vacancies on chemical bonds, and, Dnally, in Section 7.3, we present the variation of the bulk modulus due to the changes of the chemical bonds for the whole range of vacancy concentration. 7.1. Core level XPS Fig. 7.1 shows the two spin–orbit components Ti 2p3=2 and Ti 2p1=2 corresponding to pure titanium and to the various titanium carbides (Fig. 7.1a) and nitrides (Fig. 7.1b) Ti 2p-XPS spectra. The Ti 2p peaks are shifted toward higher binding energies when the ligand concentration increases which is due to the charge transfer from titanium to metalloid atoms during the formation of Ti–C or Ti–N bonds (Johansson et al., 1977). As several authors have indicated (Porte et al., 1983; Hofmann, 1986; Strydom and Hofmann, 1990) the line shapes for titanium nitrides are rather complicated and there are, at least, two contributions: the Drst one,
52
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 7.1. XPS spectra of Ti 2p3=2 and Ti 2p1=2 lines recorded on: (a) pure Ti, TiC0:49 and TiC0:78 and (b) pure Ti, TiN0:45 and TiN0:61 .
due to actual titanium nitride and the second one, associated with titanium oxide located at the surface, as a consequence of gettering of residual oxygen. In their Ti 2p-XPS studies of 9-TiNx (0:50 6 x 6 1) titanium nitrides, Porte et al. (1983) reported the existence of a new line at 2:2 eV above the main peak for compositions near stoichiometry. This is related to a decreased screening e1ect of conduction electrons. On the other hand, the Ti 2p peak shape was shown to be a function of nitrogen concentration by Vasile et al. (1990) and also oxygen contributes signiDcantly to the background formation. Moreover, in a study of titanium nitride energy losses, Strydom and Hofmann (1990) pointed out that the losses due to intraband transitions change the line shapes of the Ti 2p transitions. For C1s XPS of TiCx as well as for N1s XPS of TiNx we refer to Guemmaz et al. (1997b). 7.2. Electronic band structure and valence band XPS of Ti carbides and nitrides In Section 7.2.1, we brieJy recall the case of stoichiometric compounds; then we compare v-XPS spectra with ab initio TB-LMTO band structure calculations (Section 7.2.2) in substoichiometric compounds. 7.2.1. Stoichiometric TiC and TiN The electronic structure of stoichiometric titanium carbide and nitride has been determined by many authors since the pioneering work of Ern and Switendick (1965) and various theoretical
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
53
Fig. 7.2. DOS curves for: (a) stoichiometric titanium carbide and (b) stoichiometric titanium nitride.
methods have been used afterwards: for example, EPM (empirical pseudo-potential method), LCAO (linear combination of atomic orbitals), APW (augmented plane wave) and MAPW (modiDed augmented plane wave) methods as well as cluster techniques (see Calais, 1977; Neckel, 1983 and refs. therein). From these works, it appears that the TiC electronic structure is composed of several bands in the following way: at the bottom, far from the Fermi level, the s band is mainly built of C 2s or N 2s states, with a small contribution of the Ti 3d states. Then, we Dnd a p band essentially formed by C 2p or N 2p states and also by Ti 3d states, just below the Fermi level. Finally, at higher energies, above the Fermi level, there are the Ti 3d bands, which are mostly mixed with C 2p or N 2p states. The electronic density of states (DOS) calculated by TB-LMTO method is shown for TiC and TiN in Fig. 7.2a and b, respectively (Guemmaz et al., 1997) and present a pseudo-gap between occupied and empty states. In the case of titanium carbide, the Fermi level is in the middle of the pseudo-gap at the DOS minimum, This allows to predict a very strong TiC bond (Ahuja et al., 1996). In the opposite, the Fermi level of titanium nitride is somewhat towards the edge of the pseudogap, due to an additional 2p electron in nitrogen. This situation gives rise to the metallic conductivity observed in TiN (as well as VN) nitrides. In stoichiometric TiC (as in TiN) we Dnd three typical
54
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
types of covalent bonds: (i) the Ti 3d orbitals of symmetry eg (dx2 −y2 ; d3z2 −r 2 ), which interacts with C 2p orbitals of the neighboring carbon atoms and form a pd bond; (ii) the Ti 3d orbitals of symmetry t2g (dxy ; dyz ; dxz ), which creates pd bonds with the C 2p orbitals of the neighboring carbon atoms. Both pd and pd bonds appear mostly in the p band region. The particularly large stability of these compounds is due to the Dlled metal 3d-ligand 2p bonding states; (iii) the Ti t2g orbitals also interact with neighboring titanium orbitals of the same symmetry to create dd bonds. These bonds appear mainly in the higher d band part, which remains unoccupied in the stoichiometric limit. From the experimental point of view, in most papers dealing with titanium carbides (or nitrides), the occupied DOS has been compared to the v-XPS recorded through ad hoc spectroscopic techniques. For example, Ihara et al. (1975) connected the v-XPS recorded on a monocrystalline TiC0:98 with the DOS calculated by the APW method. In the same way, photoelectron spectra measured with synchrotron radiation, as well as with HeI and HeII lines, on monocrystalline stoichiometric titanium carbides have been compared by Johansson et al. (1980) with the DOS calculated by the APW method. These and other works (Weaver et al., 1980; HagstrXom et al., 1976, 1977; Soriano et al., 1997) have allowed to conclude that the peak positions and band widths, obtained by ab initio calculations on these stoichiometric compounds, are in fairly good agreement with the experimental spectra. 7.2.2. Substoichiometric TiCx and TiNx In Figs. 7.3a–7.6a v-XPS spectra, recorded on our various substoichiometric titanium compounds TiC0:49 ; TiC0:78 ; TiN0:45 and TiN0:61 present a characteristic peak at about 10 eV for carbides or 15 eV for nitrides below the Fermi level, the relative intensity of which changes in the same way as the ligand concentration. In the following, we shall limit our discussion to the case of titanium carbides since it would be nearly the same in the case of nitrides. The carbide spectra present a broad structure located between 1.5 and 8 eV below the Fermi level, the shape of which also varies with the carbon amount. In the case of TiC0:78 , the structure is composed of only one intense peak, contrary to the other concentration which presents clearly two shoulders (Fig. 7.3a). Since v-XPS spectra directly reJect the main characteristics of the DOS in the stoichiometric case (see Section 7.2.1), the same type of comparison in the substoichiometric case will also help to identify the various peaks and relative positions of the bands. The DOS calculations were performed using the TB-LMTO method within the atomic sphere approximation (ASA) approximation (Guemmaz et al., 1997a). Although the vacancies (symbolized by in the text and in the Dgures) were statistically distributed in our titanium carbide samples, the calculations were done with completely ordered compounds of NaCl type, composed of two fcc sublattices, the Drst one containing titanium atoms and the second one, carbon atoms and ordered vacancies. In Figs. 7.3b and 7.4b, DOS curves are displayed, corresponding, respectively, to TiC0:50 0:50 and TiC0:75 0:25 substoichiometric carbides. Let us notice the following points on DOS: (i) the intensity of the structure at 10 eV below the Fermi level originates from the C 2s states, and varies in the same way as carbon concentration; (ii) the DOS intensity just below the Fermi level increases with the vacancy concentration; (iii) the substoichiometric carbides exhibit new structures in the vicinity of the Fermi level, which fall within the pseudogap of the TiC1:0 compound. In Figs. 7.3–7.6, the v-XPS spectra are presented above the corresponding DOS curves. To help comparison, one should remember the
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 7.3. (a) Experimental v-XPS spectrum for TiC0:49 , (b) Theoretical DOS curve for TiC0:50 and without (dashed line) convolution.
55
0:50
with (full line)
following points: (i) the synthesized titanium carbides have disordered vacancies in opposite to the calculated structures which are strictly ordered. Moreover, the theoretical stoichiometries do not correspond exactly to the experimental ones; (ii) the v-XPS spectra are more easily compared to DOS curves convoluted with the experimental apparatus resolution (1:4 eV). On one hand, this convolution help to smooth the DOS curves and, on the other hand, to broaden the peaks: see Figs. 7.3b–7.6b; (iii) a background increasing with binding energy is measured with the bare XPS signal. By taking into account all these points, we can conclude that the DOS reproduce the v-XPS and especially the structures near the Fermi level in a rather satisfactory manner. From the theoretical point of view, the e1ect of vacancies on the electronic structure of titanium carbides has been worked out by many authors. For example, Gubanov et al. (1984) used the Hartree–Fock–Slater method applied to clusters to study the changes of the TiO and TiC valence bands. With the help of the APW method, Redinger et al. (1985, 1986) calculated the modiDcations introduced by the substoichiometry in TiC0:75 0:25 carbides.
56
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 7.4. (a) Experimental v-XPS spectrum for TiC0:78 , (b) Theoretical DOS curve for TiC0:75 and without (dashed line) convolution.
0:25
with (full line)
Moreover, using the Korringa–Kohn–Rostoker (KKR) method, within the coherent potential approximation (CPA) and within the Green’s function (GF) method, Marksteiner et al. (1986) studied various titanium carbide compounds. The LMTO-GF method was applied by Ivanovsky et al. (1988, 1998) to analyze the e1ect of carbon and titanium vacancies on the electronic properties of titanium carbides. With the help of a LCAO method, Capkova and Skala (1992) described the rearrangement of inter-atomic interactions in TiCx and their e1ect on the DOS due to vacancies. Several authors studied titanium nitrides as well. In particular, Klima (1979, 1980) used a CPA-LCAO method to determine the DOS for TiNx (0:6¡x¡1:0) compounds. Besides, Marksteiner et al. (1986) exhibited KKR-CPA and GF methods to characterize the
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 7.5. (a) Experimental v-XPS spectrum for TiN0:45 , (b) Theoretical DOS curve for TiN0:50 and without (dashed line) convolution.
57
0:50
with (full line)
inJuence of substoichiometry on TiNx (0:5¡x¡1) nitrides. Also, Herzig et al. (1987) applied APW method to study TiN0:75 assuming long range order for vacancy distribution on the nitrogen sublattice. The e1ect of vacancies (both metallic and non-metallic sites) on the electronic structure of titanium nitrides as well as the inter-atomic bond rearrangements in the vicinity of a considered vacancy were studied by Ivanovsky et al. (1988) within a LMTO-GF method. Lastly, describing titanium nitrides by clusters within Hartree–Fock approximation, Capkova and Skala (1992) determined the inJuence of the deviation from stoichiometry upon chemical bonds and lattice relaxation. In summary, all these authors outline the important e1ect of vacancies on the electronic structure and the appearance of new structures in the DOS near the Fermi level. These new structures can clearly be seen on Figs. 7.3–7.6 and are called
58
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Fig. 7.6. (a) Experimental v-XPS spectrum for TiN0:61 , (b) Theoretical DOS curve for TiN0:75 and without (dashed line) convolution.
0:25
with (full line)
“vacancy state associated structures”. Their origin can be explained by symmetry changes resulting from the vacancy sites in the lattice. Titanium atoms which are completely equivalent in a perfect stoichiometric rocksalt structure, are no more so in substoichiometric structures. This is related to the formation of new bonds associated with the peaks in the vicinity of the Fermi level. In addition to the three covalent bonds pd; pd and dd present in the stoichiometric carbides, two new bonds are observed in the substoichiometric carbides (Redinger et al., 1986). Both Ti[4] d neighboring levels of (3z 2 − r 2 ) symmetry interact together through a vacancy in order to establish a Ti[4] (d3z2 −r 2 )–Ti[4] (d3z2 −r 2 ) covalent bond. The peaks observed near the Fermi level on the v-XPS spectra and on the DOS curves take their origin mainly from this
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
59
Table 7.1 Reduced modulus Er and Young’s modulus E a; b values obtained by nanoindentation: (a) with a constant Poisson coeEcient # = 0:17 for TiCx and # = 0:194 for TiNx ; (b) with a linear interpolated Poisson coeEcient, between # = 0:17 for TiC or # = 0:194 for TiN, and # = 0:34 for pure titanium. For stoichiometric titanium carbides, the values were obtained by linear extrapolation Compounds
Er (GPa)
E=(1 − #2 ) (GPa)
E (a) (GPa)
E (b) (GPa)
TiC0:26 TiC0:49 TiC0:78 TiN0:45 TiN0:61
163 218 290 214 241
192.5 274.3 399 268 311.8
187 265 386 258 300
177 257 383 248 281
type of orbital mixing. Thus, the existence of vacancies leads to the formation of new bonds between titanium atoms, absent in the stoichiometric titanium compounds. Moreover, this interpretation is in good agreement with Skala and Capkova (1990) on substoichiometric vanadium nitrides where there are also similar important V–V bonds, through vacancies. 7.3. Young’s modulus A nanoindenter apparatus was used to investigate the mechanical properties of the synthesized layers (Guemmaz et al., 1999). In this last section, we report (Section 7.3.1) our measurements of Young’s modulus by nanoindentation, then (Section 7.3.2) we discuss our data in terms of vacancy concentration (Guemmaz et al., 1999). 7.3.1. Determination by nanoindentation In order to determine the mechanical properties of our samples we carried out nanoindentation tests. From the unloading curves the reduced Young’s modulus Er is determined, by the following relation (Guemmaz et al., 1996, 1997b and refs. herein): 1 (1 − #2 ) (1 − #2i ) = + Er E Ei
(7.1)
where (E; #) and (Ei ; #i ) are the Young’s modulus and Poisson coeEcient of the sample and nanoindenter tip, respectively. Since the tip is made of diamond, its elastic constants are Ei = 1050 GPa and #i = 0:104 (Spear, 1989). Also the preceding relation allows us to calculate the E=(1 − #2 ) value for a considered sample. In Table 7.1 the Er values are given for three various carbides and two nitrides. To derive Young’s modulus we need to know the corresponding Poisson coeEcients. To our knowledge, there is no published work giving the evolution of Poisson coeEcient as a function of carbon or nitrogen concentrations for the systems we are interested in. To overcome this problem, we used two di1ering approaches: the Drst one considers the Poisson coeEcient as independent from the stoichiometry and equal to the value # = 0:17 for TiC1:0 (Chang and Graham, 1966) and # = 0:19 for TiN1:0 . In the second approach, we consider values interpolated linearly between # = 0:32 for the pure titanium and
60
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
the preceding values for the stoichiometric compounds. Linear interpolation is justiDed by the fact that the Poisson coeEcient is an elastic property of the matter as well as Young’s modulus. 7.3.2. Evolution as a function of vacancy concentration From Table 7.1, in the case of carbides, both previously considered approaches lead to Young’s modulus values close to each other but also very dependent on the vacancy concentration. The values evolve from 187 GPa for TiC0:26 to 386 GPa for TiC0:78 in the Drst approach and from 177 to 383 GPa in the second one. The extrapolation for the stoichiometric compound gives a value equal to 468 GPa in both cases. Young’s modulus values, found in the literature, mainly concern the titanium carbides at (or near) stoichiometry. Thus, Gilman and Roberts (1961) and Williams and Schaal (1962) reported values, respectively, equal to 458 and 447 GPa, for monocrystalline TiC0:94 . Chang and Graham (1966) estimated Young’s modulus at 438 GPa, for monocrystalline TiC0:91 and for temperatures ranging from 4.2 to 298 K. Measurements performed on titanium carbides deposited on quartz crystals gave a value of 200 Gpa (Kinbara and Baba, 1983), but the carbon concentration was not speciDed in this study. For TXorXok et al. (1987) Young’s modulus is most likely equal to 460 GPa which is very close to our extrapolated result. A few years ago, a value equal to 494 GPa was found by X-ray di1raction on titanium carbide Dlms deposited by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) on steel (Sawada et al., 1992). For titanium nitrides, Young’s modulus reported in literature depends upon the preparation mode, measurement techniques, grain magnitude, sample texture and of course stoichiometry: the intensity varies from 250 to 640 GPa (TXorXok et al., 1987). For example in the case of TiN prepared by physical vapor deposition (PVD) and with the help of X-ray di1raction, Sue (1992) measured values comprised between 408 and 447 GPa, whereas by nanoindentation, Wittling et al. (1995) found a value of 400 GPa for TiN. Let us report the bulk modulus evolution as a function of carbon concentration in TiCx compounds (Guemmaz et al., 1999, 2000). In Fig. 7.7 we show the bulk modulus values (i) derived from the nanoindentation experiments and (ii) obtained by the full potential LMTO method (FPLMTO), as a function of stoichiometry. Here let us point out that the “FP” version of the LMTO method, i.e. beyond the ASA option, is necessary to treat the elastic property (Guemmaz et al., 1999). Actually, the calculated bulk modulus evolves as a function of x, in a similar way as the corresponding experimental data. Moreover, the K values obtained from the linearly interpolated Poisson coeEcients give the best agreement with the calculated ones. This can be explained by the fact that both E and # are elastic constants and, since E changes with stoichiometry, # changes automatically too. Finally the agreement obtained between the experimental and calculated bulk modulus, indicates that the substoichiometric titanium carbide structure considered in the calculations, although completely ordered, is suEciently realistic to provide an agreement with experience. The observed variation of Young’s modulus as a function of the vacancy concentration is related to the evolution of chemical bonds (Table 7.1). We have seen above, that the electronic structure is deeply modiDed after the appearance of vacancy sites: new chemical bonds are then responsible of changes in the cohesion of the considered substoichiometric compounds. Thus, if Young’s modulus decreases as a function of the vacancy concentration, it is a consequence of the formation of Ti–Ti bonds. At high vacancy concentration, the lattice behaves like
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
61
Fig. 7.7. Bulk modulus K versus carbon atomic concentration. The triangles are the experimental values obtained from nanoindentation either with # = 0:17 (4) or with # depending linearly on carbon concentration (5). The circles are the theoretical values deduced from a FP-LMTO calculation: a FP version of the LMTO code is necessary to handle this type of problem (from Guemmaz et al., 1999).
a pure titanium rather than a carbide or nitride structure. Young’s modulus evolves to the pure titanium limit, which is equal to about 170 GPa. As a result, we can say that the elastic constants indirectly reJect the evolution of the chemical bonds due to substoichiometry and express the structure sti1ness. 8. Summary and outlook This review was intended to survey the present status of our knowledge of the electronic properties of early transition metal compounds, which depend essentially on the electron–electron correlations, i.e. many-body e1ects. The review is by no means a complete compilation. We hope, however, that we have complied with pointing out the nature of the generalization and limitations as well as the experimental and theoretical diEculties in the area of the electronic properties of these compounds. The subject is changing and still developing so rapidly at the present time that, despite the existence of excellent reviews (Adler, 1968; Brandow, 1977; Henrich, 1985; Davis, 1986; Kanamory and Kotani, 1988; Mott, 1990; Fulde, 1991; Hufner, 1994), it seemed worth trying to put some of the recent developments in a form accessible to non-specialists. Also, at least two major new developments have occurred in the last 15 years which seemed appropriate to be recalled, although the historical view (Mott compound) has not been challenged as yet. First, it was realized that NiO is not a Mott insulator in terms of the energy level diagram, but rather a more conventional substance, namely a charge transfer material in the sense of chemists (Pauling, 1960; Jorgensen, 1970). A second new event has been the discovery of the so-called high-temperature superconductors (Bednorz and Muller, 1986),
62
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
a class of compounds where copper–oxygen planes (CuO2 planes) give rise to superconductivity up to above 100 K. Further developments, which have added new and unexpected results, have been the reDnements of the technique of photoelectron spectroscopy, which has allowed to map the electronic band structure of a few of these materials such as TiO2 , NiO (Hufner, 1995), NiI2 (Stanberg et al., 1986), CoO (Brooks et al., 1989; Shen et al., 1990) and RuCl3 (Pollini, 1996). Also a new e1ort in the local density approximation and beyond LDA for the calculation of the band structures gives at least an ad hoc basis to include the electron–electron correlation and thereby to come to a more meaningful calculation of energy gap values. Especially, there have been recent attempts to incorporate the Mott–Hubbard type correlations into the standard LSDA formalism (Svane and Gunnarsson, 1990; Anisimov et al., 1991). One of the reasons why the extended LSDA and LSDA + U calculations have been rather successful, although the Hubbard type correlations are still not always adequately taken into account, stems from the physical concept of quasi-particle developed in Landau’s Fermi-liquid theory. There it was shown that one can treat a system of interacting electrons like one of the non-interacting ones provided the electron mass is renormalized (Ziman, 1969; Madelung, 1978; Nakajima et al., 1980). A new e1ort in the past decades to explain the electronic structure and electronic excitations in TMCs has been also made with single-ion models, most notably the cluster approaches based on the impurity Anderson Hamiltonian (Fujimori and Minami, 1984; Zaanen and Sawatzky, 1990; Okada and Kotani, 1992a and Sections 2.1, 3.2 and 4.3 of the present review). Also, many TMCs have been reclassiDed as intermediate compounds between MH and CT compounds. These e1orts have been very successful and have provided a considerable insight into the electronic structure of these systems. In particular in the present paper, we have put emphasis on the fairly good connection between: (i) v-XPS spectra and standard LMTO band calculations (Sections 3.1, 7.2), even in the case of substoichiometric compounds; (ii) c-XPS and CI-CT models (Sections 2.2, 3.2), including the case of localized magnetic moments (Section 4.3); (iii) the full potential LMTO band calculations and the analysis of elastic subtoichiometric properties (Section 7.3). Moreover, one of the aims of the article was to reconsider the Hubbard model (Austin and Mott, 1969; Mott and Zinamon, 1970) with today’s standard and also recall some of its developments. In spite of its simple deDnition, the Hubbard model is still believed to exhibit various interesting phenomena, including metal–insulator transitions, antiferromagnetism, ferrimagnetism, Tomonaga–Luttinger liquid and superconductivity (Tasaki, 1998; Lieb, 1998). Nevertheless, more generally, let us recall that the e1ects of electron correlation on spectroscopic properties, like XPS, electron scattering and XAS, are still treated today in a rather incomplete way (Hedin, 1999). Although transition metals and metallic alloys involving transition metals have not been studied in this review, the experimental and theoretical techniques described here are relevant to such materials as well (Bennett et al., 1983; Parlebas et al., 1990). BIS and inverse photoemission have become very useful and standard methods of studying the states above the Fermi energy (Speier et al., 1984). Auger photoelectron coincidence spectroscopy (Haak et al., 1978) is another technique which has kept the promises of interest raised at the outset. These measurements are diEcult, however several issues regarding the local atomic conDguration of satellites in XPS and Auger spectra have been resolved both for TMs and TMCs. Electron correlations are present in varied degrees in metals as well. In the Deld of metals and TMs, the simplest system is the free-electron metal (e.g. Na), where only small electron–electron
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
63
correlations are present (Jensen and Plummer, 1985; Whan and Plummer, 1988) and conductivity takes place because one has an only half-Dlled band. Conductivity can be described here by the creation of s2 conDgurations. In a typical TM, namely Ni, large correlations are present, however, the band-width can accomodate these correlations so that a conducting state is achieved. In the context of this review, this situation can be called a Mott–Hubbard metal. The metallic phases of TiO2 and VO2 probably fall into this category. Another class of materials, where highly correlated electrons take part in the conductivity are the mixed-valence compounds containing rare-earth or transition elements. A prototype in this class is metallic SmS, where the 4f 5 and 4f 6 conDgurations coincide at the Fermi energy. This makes a charge Juctuation of the type 5d 3 4f 5 → 5d 3 4f 6 possible and the occurrence of metallic conductivity. NiS is with respect to its electronic structure the case perhaps nearest to the high Tc superconductors (Hufner, 1994). A large number of TMCs are semiconductors, although few of them have been investigated in any detail. The great diEculties encountered in preparing single crystals of nearly all these compounds have greatly hampered the e1orts to understand their behavior in any fundamental way. The measurements of electrical properties on powders or sintered samples must always be regarded as an uncertain procedure, as these measurements are in suEcient disagreement with the single crystal measurements, because they are greatly inJuenced by interfacial e1ects between single crystal grains. Nevertheless, a general picture of the behavior of TMCs has been obtained. Many of these materials are of interest because of their magnetic properties and a great deal of information derived from studies of the latter is useful in interpreting the electrical behavior. Thus, information about structure, number of unpaired spins, the NZeel temperature for the transition to antiferromagnetic state can be studied in this way. The compounds whose electronic structure has been studied in most detail have been the 3d TMOs, although a number of studies of sulDdes and halides have been carried out and some 4d and 5d TMCs have been investigated. Rutile oxides show, in particular, an interesting range of physical properties which can be correlated with the number of free d electrons of the metal ion (Riga et al., 1977; Beatham and Orchard, 1979; Daniels et al., 1984; Xu et al., 1989). This interest derives from unresolved questions regarding the inJuence of the electron correlations and the associated magnetic structure, beside numerous technological applications of the materials. Electrically, the outstanding characteristic of the insulating TMCs is their very low carrier mobility. This has been generally interpreted as indicating a “hopping process” for the conduction mechanism, in which the carriers are localized on a particular cation within the activation energy required for the carrier transport to an adjacent cation because of a potential barrier betwen cations. Thus, for a hopping process, the mobility 7 increases with temperature, whereas in normal bands 7 decreases with increasing temperature due to increased lattice scattering. Also, some of these compounds are metals with mobilities in the range 10−2 to 1 cm2 V−1 s−1 . The mobilities for the compounds which are insulators are very low, below 10−5 cm2 V−1 s−1 . The large di1erences in the electrical properties of these compounds hinge upon the possibility that an energy band is formed by the d-type wave functions. The lower lying electronic levels are completely Dlled, but the valence d levels are either empty or partially Dlled and the possibility of electrical conduction in these levels exists. If they form a band of levels which is empty, then their behavior might be expected to resemble that of normal semiconductors, like germanium and silicon. On the other hand, if they form a band which is partially Dlled they should be metallic in character. Finally, if no band is formed, but the levels are partially Dlled, a hopping mechanism can be
64
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
expected to give rise to a very low conductivity, the compounds being properly classiDed as insulators in this case. Experimentally, many of these situations have been conDrmed for several of these materials (Rao and Rao, 1970; Tsuda et al., 1991). Let us mention quite a new Deld of research for those materials, i.e. the study of their properties when they can be prepared as reduced dimensional systems (i.e. by epitaxy; or as in Section 4.3) or systems containing a controlled number of defects as in Section 7. From the spectroscopic and electronic point of view, conDguration crossover in TMCs between sub-bands of the d-band manifold (i.e. the t2g and eg orbitals with octahedral coordination for high-spin=low-spin e1ects) can strongly a1ect the lattice parameter of the compounds and greatly alter the conduction characteristics. For example, in the 4d 5 low-spin semiconductor -RuCl3 (t 5 t2g ), the lattice parameter is actually smaller than in the high-spin FeCl3 (t 3 t2g e2g ) 3 e2 ) is an insulator, and the low-spin IrO2 (t5 t2g ) is metallic, whereas the high-spin MnTe (t2g g 3 e2 seems to be the key insulator. Adoption of the high spin in half-Dlled shell conDguration t2g g to the Mott-insulating character for many compounds, holding even for tellurides, such as MnTe and MnTe2 . Despite the considerable p–d hybridization in these tellurides through the proximity of ligand 5p and cation 3d energies, the resulting d-bandwidth still remains insuEcient to overcome the large exchange and correlation energies operative with the high-spin 3d 5 Hund’s rule groundstate 6 A1g (Wilson, 1972). Furthermore, TMOs and TMHs are ideal subjects for investigating the insulating and metallic states, because of the wide diversity of the electrical properties observed in apparently similar materials. For example, layered CrCl3 ; CrBr 3 and Cr 2 O3 materials are probably all Mott insulators, as the layered RuCl3 compound (Pollini, 1996), while cubic RuO2 is a metal (Mattheiss, 1976; Daniels et al., 1984; Xu et al., 1989; Glassford and Chelikowsky, 1992, 1994). Besides, -RuCl3 ; -TiCl3 , and -TiCl3 , are non-magnetic compounds at room temperature through cation interaction and once more they are non-standard semiconductors (Wilson, 1972; Pollini, 1983; Maule et al., 1988). As far as 4d TM compounds are concerned and, in connection with Sections 7.2 and 7.3, the electronic and elastic properties of substoichiometric ZrNx compounds are now under investigation and will be published in near future. In conclusion, this review has been purposely limited in scope, being mainly devoted to comments concerning the early 3d transition metal compounds with special emphasis on the experimental and theoretical v- and c-XPS spectra. However, that part of the photoemission Deld and theoretical models (band or cluster) covered seems now mature enough in many respects beyond the boundaries we have imposed to ourselves. The potential impact of knowledge gained in this and connected Delds seems rather near to be ready for some applications or, in a more fundamental way, for generalization in close research Delds, such as physical-chemistry (i.e. molecules). 9. Glossary of symbols and acronyms APW ARUPS ASA BIS CB
augmented plane wave angle resolved ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy atomic sphere approximation bremsstrahlung isochromat spectroscopy conducting band
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
CI CIAM CM CNDO CPA CT CVD c-XPS DFT DOS EELS EPM FLAPW FPLMTO GF GGA GWA KKR LB LCAO LDA LFT LMTO LSDA MAPW MH MO PAM PES PVD RBS RPES SIAM SIC SIMS SXES TB-LMTO TM TMC TMH TMO UPS VB VUV
conDguration interaction cluster impurity Anderson model cluster model complete neglect of di1erential overlap coherent potential approximation charge transfer chemical vapor deposition core level X-ray spectroscopy density functional theory density of states electron energy loss spectroscopy empirical pseudo-potential method full potential linearized augmented plane wave full potential linear muEn tin orbital Green’s function generalized gradient approximation one-electron Green function + W screened potential approximation Korringa–Kohn–Rostoker ligand band linear combination of atomic orbitals local density approximation ligand Deld theory linear muEn tin orbital local spin density approximation modiDed augmented plane wave Mott–Hubbard molecular orbital periodic Anderson model photoemission spectroscopy physical vapor deposition Rutherford backscattering spectroscopy resonant photoemission spectroscopy single impurity Anderson model self interaction correction secondary ion mass spectroscopy soft X-ray emission spectroscopy tight binding linear muEn tin orbital transition metal transition metal compound transition metal halides transition metal oxide ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy valence band vacuum ultraviolet
65
66
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
v-XPS valence band X-ray spectroscopy WSS Wigner–Seitz sphere XAS X-ray absorption spectroscopy XES X-ray emission spectroscopy XPS X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy ZSA Zaanen–Sawatsky–Allen Acknowledgements In the past years a great number of people have been helpful in discussing the various problems mentioned in the present paper. In particular the authors gratefully thank the following professors: M. Alouani, M. Avignon, L. Falicov, P. Fulde, F. Gautier, M. Guemmaz, J. Hugel, B. Johansson, J. Kanamori, A. Kotani, T. Jo, P. Rennert, S. Shin and doctors: R. Ahujab, A. Bocquet, E. Beaurepaire, C. Demangeat, J.P. Kappler, J.-J. Grob, M.A. Khan, P. Kruger, G. Moraitis, K. Okada, D. Raiser, A. Rakotomakevitra, M. Taguchi, T. Uozumi. This work has also much beneDted from past cooperation research program between JSPS and CNRS. Finally, we are greatly indebted to Prof. D.L. Mills for having encouraged us to write this review. References Adler, D., 1968. Solid State Physics, Vol. 21. In: Ehrenreich, H., Turnbull, D. (Eds.), Academic Press, New York, p. 1. Ahuja, R., Eriksson, O., Wills, J.M., Johannsson, B., 1996. Phys. Rev. B 53, 3072. Anderson, P.W., 1961. Phys. Rev. 124, 41. ∗ ∗ ∗ Anisimov, V.I., Zaanen, J., Andersen, O.K., 1991. Phys. Rev. B 44, 943. Antoci, S., Mihich, L., 1978. Phys. Rev. B 18, 5765. Aryasetiawan, F., Gunnarsson, O., 1995. Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3221; 1998. Rep. Prog. Phys. 61, 237. Asada, S., Sugano, S., 1976. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 41, 1291. Austin, I.G., Mott, N.F., 1969. Adv. Phys. 18, 41. Barth, J., Gerken, F., Kuntz, C., 1985. Phys. Rev. B 31, 2022. Beatham, N., Orchard, A.F., 1979. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 16, 77. Beaurepaire, E., Lewonczuk, S., Ringeissen, J., Parlebas, J.C., Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1993. Europhys. Lett. 22, 463. ∗∗ Becke, A.D., 1988. Phys. Rev. A 38, 3098. Bednorz, J.G., Muller, K.A., 1986. Z. Phys. 64, 189. Bengone, O., Alouani, M., BlXochl, P., Hugel, J., 2000. Comp. Mater. Sci. 17, 146; Phys. Rev. B 62, 16 392. ∗ Bennett, P.A., Fuggle, J.C., Hillebrecht, F.U., Lenselink, A., Sawatzky, G.A., 1983. Phys. Rev. B 27, 2194. Bethel, E., Stockbauer, R., Madey, T.E., 1983. Phys. Rev. B 27, 1939. Binns, C., Baker, S.H., Demangeat, C., Parlebas, J.C., 1999. Surf. Sci. Rep. 105. Binns, C., Derbyshire, H.S., Bayliss, S.C., Norris, C., 1992. Phys. Rev. B 45, 460. ∗∗ Blaka, B., Dufek, P., Sliwko, V., Swartz, K., 1996. J. Magn. Magn. Matter 140 –144, 173. Blaauw, C., Leenhouts, F., van der Woude, F., Sawatzky, G.A., 1975. J. Phys. C 8, 459. Bocquet, A.E., Mikozawa, T., Morikawa, K., Fujimori, A., Barman, S.R., Maiti, K., Sarma, D.D., Tokura, Y., Onada, M., 1996. Phys. Rev. B 53, 1161. ∗ ∗ ∗ Bocquet, A.E., Mizokawa, T., Saitoh, T., Namatame, H., Fujimori, A., 1992. Phys. Rev. B 46, 3771. ∗∗ Brandow, B.H., 1977. Adv. Phys. 26, 651. Brooks, N.B., Law, D.S., Warburton, D.R., Wincott, P.L., Thornton, G., 1989. J. Phys. Condens. Matter 1, 4267.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
67
Bunshah, R.F., Deshpandey, C.V., 1989. Vacuum 39, 955. Calais, J.L., 1977. Adv. Phys. 26, 847. Capkova, P., Skala, L., 1992. Phys. Stat. Sol. B 171, 85. Carricaburu, B., FerrZe, J., Mamy, R., Pollini, I., Thomas, J., 1986. J. Phys. C 19, 4995. ∗ Chang, R., Graham, L.J, 1966. J. Appl. Phys. 37, 3778. Chermette, H., Pertosa, P., Michel-Calendini, N., 1980. Chem. Phys. Lett. 69, 240. Daniels, R.R., Margaritondo, G., Georg, C.A., Levy, F., 1984. Phys. Rev. B 29, 1813. Davis, L.C., 1982. Phys. Rev. B 25, 2912; 1986. J. Appl. Phys. 59, R 25. de Boer, D.K.G., Haas, C., Sawatzky, G., 1984. Phys. Rev. B 29, 4401. ∗ ∗ ∗ de Groot, R.A., Mueller, F.M., van Engen, P.G., Buschow, K.H.J., 1983. Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 2024. Doniach, S., 1969. Adv. Phys. 18, 819. Dufek, P., Blaka, P., Sliwko, V., Swartz, K., 1994. Phys. Rev. B 49, 10 170. Du1y, D.M., Blackman, J.A., Mulheran, P.A., Williams, S.A., 1998. J. Magn. Mat. 177–181, 953. Eastman, D.E., Freeouf, J.L., 1975. Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, 395. ∗ Eastman, D.E., Himpsel, F.J., 1981. Conference on Transition Metals. Leeds, England, 1980, Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. 55, p. 115. Ederer, D.L., Mc Guire, J.H. (Eds.), 1996. Raman Emission by X-ray Scattering. World ScientiDc, Singapore. Ern, V., Switendick, A.C., 1965. Phys. Rev. A 137, 1927. Ezhov, S.Y., Anisimov, V.I., Khomskii, D.I., Sawatzky, G.A., 1999. Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 4136. Fadley, C.S., 1988. Recent developments in Photoelectron Di1raction. In: Kanamori, Kotani, (Eds.), Core-level spectroscopy in condensed systems. Springer, Berlin, p. 236. Fadley, C.S., Shirley, D.A., Freeman, A.J., Bagus, P.S., Mallow, J.V., 1969. Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 1397. ∗∗ Faltermeier, C., Goldberg, C., Jones, M., Upham, A., Manger, D., Peterson, G., Lau, J., Kaloyeros, A.E., 1997. J. Electrochem. Soc. 144, 1002. Fano, U., 1961. Phys Rev. 124, 1866. ∗∗ Feinleib, J., Adler, D., 1968. Phys. Rev. Lett. 21, 1010. ∗ Finkelstein, L.D., Zurmaev, E.Z., Korotin, M.A., Moewes, A., Schneider, B., Butorin, S.M., Guo, J.H., Nordgren, J., Hartmann, D., Neumann, M., Ederer, D.L., 1999. Phys. Rev. B 60, 2212. Fliyou, M., Parlebas, J.C., Khan, M.A., 1987. Philos. Mag. B 56, 501. Fujimori, A., Minami, F., 1984. Phys. Rev. B 30, 957. ∗∗ Fujimori, A., Kimizuka, N., Taniguchi, M., Suga, S., 1987. Phys. Rev. B 36, 6691. Fulde, P., 1991. Springer Series in Solid State Sciences. Vol. 100. Springer, Berlin. Georges, A., Kotliar, G., Krauth, W., Rozenberg, M.J., 1996. Rev. Mod. Phys. 68, 13. Gilman, J.J., Roberts, B.W., 1961. J. Appl. Phys. 32, 1405. Glassford, K.M., Chelikowsky, J.R., 1992. Phys. Rev. B 45, 3874. Glassford, K.M., Chelikowsky, J.R., 1994. Phys. Rev. B 49, 7107. Glassford, K.M., Troullier, N., Martin, J.L., Chelikowsky, J.R., 1990. Solid State Commun. 76, 635. Goldschmidt, H.J., 1967. Interstitial Alloys. Butterworth, London. Gubanov, V.A., Ivanovsky, A.L., Shveikin, G.P., Ellis, D.E., 1984. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 45, 719. Guemmaz, M., Moraitis, G., Mosser, A., Khan, M.A., Parlebas, J.C., 1997a. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 9, 8453; J. Electron. Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 83, 173. ∗ ∗ ∗ Guemmaz, M., Moraitis, G., Mosser, A., Khan, M.A., Parlebas, J.C., 1997b. J. Alloys Compounds 262–263, 397. Guemmaz, M., Mosser, A., Grob, J.J., 1997. Appl. Phys. A 64, 407. Guemmaz, M., Mosser, A., Parlebas, J.C., 2000. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 107, 91. Guemmaz, M., Mosser, A., Ahuja, R., Johansson, B., 1999. Solid State Commun. 110, 299. ∗ ∗ ∗ Guemmaz, M., Mosser, A., Boudoukha, L., Grob, J.J., Raiser, D., Sens, J.C., 1996. Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 111, 263. Guizzetti, G., Nosenzo, L., Pollini, I., Reguzzoni, E., Samoggia, G., Spinolo, G., 1976. Phys. Rev. B 14, 4622. Gunnarsson, O., Schonhammer, K., 1983. Phys. Rev. B 28, 4315. Gunnarsson, O., Schonhammer, K., 1985. Phys. Rev. B 31, 4815. ∗∗ Gunnarsson, O., Koch, E., Martin, R.M., 1996. Phys. Rev. B 54, R11 026. Gunnarsson, O., Koch, E., Martin, R.M., 1997. Phys. Rev. B 56, 1146.
68
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Gutzwiller, M.C., 1964. Phys. Rev. 134, A 923. Gutzwiller, M.C., 1963. Phys. Rev. Lett. 10, 159. ∗∗ Haak, H., Sawatzky, G.A., Thomas, T.D., 1978. Phys. Rev. Lett. 41, 1825. HagstrXom, A.L., Johansson, L.I., HagstrXom, S.B.M., Christensen, A., 1977. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 11, 75. HagstrXom, A.L., Johansson, L.I., Jacobson, B.E., HagstrXom, S.B.M., 1976. Solid State Commun. 19, 647. Harada, Y., Kinugasa, T., Eguchi, R., Matsubara, M., Kotani, A., Watanabe, M., Yagishita, A., Shin, S., 2000. Phys. Rev. B 61, 12 854. Hardman, P.J., Raikar, G.N., Muryn, C.A., van der Laan, G., Wincott, P.L., Thornton, G., Bullet, D.W., Dale, P.A.D.M.A., 1994. Phys. Rev. B 49, 7170. Harrison, W.A., 1980. Electronic Structure and Physical Properties of Solids. Freeman, San Francisco. Hedin, L., 1999. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 11, R 489. Hedin, L., 1965. Phys. Rev. A 139, 796. ∗ ∗ ∗ Henrich, V.E., 1985. Rep. Progr. Phys. 48, 1481. Hermsmeier, B., Fadley, C.S., Krause, M.O., Jimenez-Mier, J., Gerard, P., Manson, T.S., 1988. Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2592. ∗∗ Herring, G., 1966. Magnetism, Vol. IV. In: Rado, G., Suhl, H. (Eds.), Wiley, New York. Herzig, P., Redinger, J., Eibler, R., Neckel, A., 1987. J. Solid State Chem. 70, 281. Himpsel, F.J., 1983. Adv. Phys. 32, 1–51. Hohenberg, P., Kohn, W., 1964. Phys. Rev. 136, 13 864. Hofmann, S., 1986. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 4, 2789. Hubbard, J., 1963. Proc. Roy. Soc. A 276, 238. ∗ ∗ ∗ Hubbard, J., 1964a. Proc. Roy. Soc. A 277, 237. Hubbard, J., 1964b. Proc. Roy. Soc. A 281, 401. Hubbard, J., 1965. Proc. Roy. Soc. A 285, 542. Hubbard, J., 1966. Proc. Roy. Soc. A 296, 82. ∗ ∗ ∗ Hufner, S., Riesterer, T., 1986. Phys. Rev. B 33, 7267. Hufner, S., Wertheim, G.K., 1975. Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, 395. Hufner, S., 1994. Adv. Phys. 43, 183. Hufner, S., Hulliger, F., Osterwalder, J., Riesteder, T., 1984. Solid State Commun. 50, 83; ibidem 52, 793. ∗∗ Hufner, S., 1985. Solid State Commun. 53, 707. ∗ Hufner, S., 1995. Photoelectron Spectroscopy. Series in Solid-State Sciences, Vol. 82. Springer, Berlin. Ihara, H., Kumashiro, Y., Itoh, A., 1975. Phys. Rev. B 12, 5465. Ivanovsky, A.L., Anisimov, V.I., Novikov, D.L., Lichtenstein, A.I., Gubanov, V.A., 1988. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 49, 465; ibidem J. Phys.: 1998. Condens. Matter 10, 4081. Jensen, E., Plummer, E.W., 1985. Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 1912. Johansson, L.I., HagstrXom, A.L., Jacobson, B.E., HagstrXom, S.B.M., 1977. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 10, 259. Johansson, L.I., Stefan, P.M., Shek, M.L., Christensen, A.N., 1980. Phys. Rev. B 22, 1032. Joly, Y., Cabaret, D., Renevier, H., Natoli, C.R., 1999. Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2398. Jorgensen, C.K., 1970. In: Lipparrt, S.J. (Ed.), Progress in Inorganic Chemistry. Vol. 12. Interscience, New York. Kanamory, J., Kotani, A. (Eds.), 1988. Springer Series In Solid State Sciences, Vol. 81. Springer, Berlin. Kazowski, R.V., Tait, R.H., 1979. Phys. Rev. B 20, 5168. Khan, M.A., Callaway, J., 1980. Phys. Lett. A 76, 441. ∗ Khan, M.A., Kotani, A., Parlebas, J.C., 1991. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 3, 1763. ∗ ∗ ∗ Kim, K.S., 1974. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 3, 217. Kim, S.D., Jin, S.J., Hong, M.R., Kim, C.T., 1997. J. Electrochem. Soc. 144, 664. Kinbara, A., Baba, S., 1983. Thin Solid Films 107, 359. Kinsinger, V., Sander, I., Steiner, P., Zimmermann, R., Hufner, S., 1990. Solid State Commun. 73, 527. ∗ Kittel, C., 1963. Quantum Theory of Solids. Wiley, New York. Klima, J., 1980. Czech. J. Phys. B 30, 905. Klima, J., 1979. J. Phys. C 12, 3691.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
69
Kohn, W., Sham, L.J., 1965. Phys. Rev. 140, A 1133. Kotani, A., Toyozawa, Y., 1973. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 35, 1073; 35, 1082. Kotani, A., Toyozawa, Y., 1974. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 37, 912. ∗ ∗ ∗ Kotani, A., 1987. In: Marr, G.V. (Ed.), Handbook on Synchroton Radiation. Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, p. 611. Kotani, A., Jo, T., Parlebas, J.C., 1988. Adv. Phys. 37, 37. Kotani, A., Okada, M., Jo, T., Bianconi, A., Marcelli, A., Parlebas, J.C., 1987. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 56, 798. Kotani, A., 1999. Theory of core-level spectroscopy in f and d electron system. J. Electron Spectrosc Relat. Phenom. 100, 75. Kotani, A., Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Parlebas, J.C., 1995. In: Fujimori, A., Tokura, Y. (Eds.), Spectroscopy of Mott Insulators and Correlated Metals. Springer Series in Solid-State Sciences, Vol. 119, p. 139. ∗∗ Kruger, P., Parlebas, J.C., Kotani, A., 1999. Phys. Rev. B 59, 15 093. ∗∗ Kruger, P., Taguchi, M., Parlebas, J.C., Kotani, A., 1997. Phys. Rev. B 55, 16 466. ∗ ∗ ∗ Larsson, S., 1975. Chem. Phys. Lett. 32, 401; 1976. ibidem 40, 362. Lee, J.D., Gunnarsson, O., Hedin, L., 1999. Phys. Rev. B 60, 8034. Lewis, S.P., Allen, P.B., Sasaki, T., 1997. Phys. Rev. B 55, 10 253. Li, X., Liu, L., Henrich, V.E., 1992. Solid State Commun. 12, 1103. Lichtenstein, A.I., Katsnelson, M.I., 1998. Phys. Rev. B 57, 6884. Lieb, E.H., 1998. Proceedings 1995 NATO ASW: On the Physics and Mathematical Physics of the Hubbard Model. Plenum, New York. Lombardo, P., Avignon, M., Schmalian, J., Bennemann, K.H., 1998. In: Current Problems in Condensed Matter. Plenum Press, New York. Madelung, O., 1978. Introduction to Solid State Theory. Springer, Berlin. Marksteiner, P., Weinberger, P., Neckel, A., Zeller, R., Dederichs, P.H., 1986. Phys. Rev. B 33, 812. Mattheiss, L.F., 1972. Phys. Rev. B 5, 290; 5, 306; ibidem 1976 B 13, 2433. ∗∗ Matsubara, M., Uozumi, T., Kotani, A., Harada, Y., Shin, S., 2000. J. Phys. Soc. Japan. Maule, C.H., Tothhill, J.N., Strange, P., Wilson, J.A., 1988. J. Phys. C 21, 2153. Montero, T., Benzo, Z., Sierralta, A., Ruette, F., 1994. In: Calderon, H., Asomoza, R. (Eds.), Surfaces, Vacuum and their Applications. New York, p. 608. Mosser, A., Romeo, M.A., Parlebas, J.C., Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1991. Solid State Commun. 79, 641. Mott, N.F., Zinamon, Z., 1970. Rep. Progr. Phys. 33, 881. Mott, N.F., 1949. Proc. Phys. Soc. London A 62, 416. Mott, N.F., 1990. Metal–Insulator Transitions. Taylor & Francis, Philadelphia, PA. Nakajima, S., Toyozawa, Y., Abe, R., 1980. The Physics of Elementary Excitations. Springer, Berlin, p. 134. Neckel, A., 1983. Int. J. Quantum Chem. 23, 1317. Oh, S.J., 1988. In: Kanamori, J., Kotani, A. (Eds.) Core-Level Spectroscopy in Condensed Systems. Springer Series in Solid-State Sciences, Vol. 81, p. 125. Ohring, M., 1992. The Materials Science of Thin Films. Academic Press, San Diego, p. 547. Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1993. J. Electron Spectros. Relat. Phenom. 62, 131. Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1992a. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 61, 4619. Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1992b. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 61, 449. ∗ Okada, K., Kotani, A., Thole, B.T., 1992. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 58, 325. Okada, K., Uozumi, T., Kotani, A., 1994. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 63, 2410 and 3176. ∗ ∗ ∗ Okusawa, M., 1984. Phys. Stat. Sol. (b) 124, 673. Park, J., Ryu, S., Han, M., Oh, S.L., 1988. Phys. Rev. B 37, 10 867. ∗ Parlebas, J.C., Gautier, F., 1973. J. Phys. F3, L49. Parlebas, J.C., 1992. J. Phys. I. France 2, 1369. ∗∗ Parlebas, J.C., Khan, M.A., Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1995. J. Electron. Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 71, 117. Parlebas, J.C., Kruger, P., Taguchi, M., Demangeat, C., Kotani, A., 1997. Surf. Sci. 377–379, 177. ∗∗ Parlebas, J.C., 1990. Phys. Stat. Sol. (b) 160, 11; 178 (1993) 9. Parlebas, J.C., Mills, D.L., 1978. Phys. Rev. B 18, 3988. Parlebas, J.C., Kotani, A., Tanaka, S., 1990. Prog. Theor. Phys. (Suppl.) 101, 271.
70
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Pauling, L., 1960. The Nature of the Chemical Bond. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY. Peng, S.S., Cooper, B.R., Hao, Y.G., 1996. Philos. Mag. 73, 611. Perdew, J.P., 1986a. Phys. Rev. B 33, 8822. Perdew, J.P., Yue, W., 1986. Phys, Rev. B 33, 8800. Perdew, J.P., 1986b. Phys. Rev. B 34, 7406. Perdew, J.P., Chevary, J.A., Vosko, S.H., Jackson, K.A., Pederson, M.R., Singh, D.J., Fiolhais, C., 1992. Phys. Rev. B 46, 6671. Perdew, J.P., 1991. In: Ziesche, P., Esching, H. (Eds.), Electronic Structure of Solids. Academie, Berlin. Perdew, J.P., Burke, K., Ernzerhof, M., 1997. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865. Phillips, J.C., van Vechten, J.A., 1969. Phys. Rev. Lett. 22, 705. ∗ ∗ ∗ Pollini, I., 1994. Phys. Rev. B 50, 2095. ∗ Pollini, I., 1996. Phys. Rev. B 53, 12 769. ∗∗ Pollini, I., 1999. Phys. Rev. B 60, 16 170. ∗∗ Pollini, I., 1998. Solid State Commun. 106, 5495. Pollini, I., 2000. Solid State Commun. 113, 559. ∗ Pollini, I., 1983. Solid State Commun. 47, 403. Pollini, I., Thomas, J., Carricaburu, B., Mamy, R., 1989. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 1, 7695. Porte, L., Roux, L., Hanus, J., 1983. Phys. Rev. B 28, 321. Poumellec, B., Durham, P.J., Guo, G.Y., 1991. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 3, 8195. ∗∗ Priester, C., Allan, G., Conard, J., 1982. Phys. Rev. B 26, 4680. Rakotomakevitra, A., Garreau, G., Demangeat, C., Parlebas, J.C., 1995. Surf. Sci. 331=333, 741. Rao, C.N.R., Rao, G.V.S., 1970. Phys. Stat. Sol. A 1, 597. Redinger, J., Eibler, R., Herzig, P., Neckel, A., Podloucky, R., Wimmer, E., 1985. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 46, 383. Redinger, J., Eibler, R., Herzig, P., Neckel, A., Podloucky, R., Wimmer, E., 1986. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 47, 387. Riga, J., Tenet-Noel, C., Pireaux, J.J., Caudano, R., Verbist, J.J., Gobillon, Y., 1977. Phys. Scripta 16, 351. Ronda, C.R., Arends, G.J., Haas, C., 1987. Phys. Rev. B 35, 4038. ∗∗ Rosencwaig, A., Werrheim, G.K., Gugenheim, H.G., 1971. Phys. Rev. Lett. 27, 479. Rublo1, G.W., 1972. Phys. Rev. B 5, 662. Saitoh, T., Bocquet, A.E., Mizokawa, T., Fujimori, A., 1995. Phys. Rev. B 52, 7934. Sawada, Z., Hirose, Y., Kida, K., Tanaka, K., 1992. Nondestructive Test. Eval. 8–9, 989. Sawatzky, G.A., Allen, J.W., 1984. Phys. Rev. Lett. 53, 2339. ∗ ∗ ∗ Sawatzky, G.A., Post, D., 1979. Phys. Rev. B 20, 1546. Sawatzky, G.A., 1987. In: Kanamori, J., Kotani, A. (Eds.), Core-Level Spectroscopy in Condensed Systems. Springer Series in Solid-State Sciences, Vol. 81, p. 99. Schwarz, K., 1986. J. Phys. F16, L211. Sekiya, T., Igarashi, M., Kurita, S., Takekawa, S., Fujisawa, M., 1998. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 92, 247. Sen, S.K., Riga, J., Verbist, J., 1976. Chem. Phys. Lett. 39, 560. Shen, Z.X., Allen, J.W., Lindberg, P.A.P., Desseau, D.S., Wells, B.O., Borg, A., Ellis, W., Kang, J.S., Oh, J.S., Lindau, I., Spicer, W.E., 1990. Phys. Rev. B 42, 1817. Shin, S., Tezuka, Y., Ishii, T., Ueda, Y., 1993. Solid State Commun. 87, 1051. Shin, S., Tezuka, Y., Kinoshita, T., Ishii, T., Kashiwakura, T., Takahashi, M., Suda, Y., 1995. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 64, 1230. Shin, S., Agui, A., Watanabe, M., Fujisawa, M., Tezuka, Y., Ishii, T., 1996. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 79, 125. Shin, S., Fujisawa, M., Ishii, H., Harada, Y., Watanabe, M., Grush, M.M., Callcott, T.A., Perera, R.C.C., Kurmaev, E.Z., Moewes, A., Winarski, R., Stadler, S., Ederer, D.L.J., 1998. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 92, 197. Shin, S., Suga, S., Taniguchi, M., Fujisawa, M., Kanzaki, H., Fujimori, A., Daimon, H., Ueda, Y., Kosuge, K., Kachi, S., 1990. Phys. Rev. B 41, 4993. Shirley, D.A., 1978. Many-electron and Dnal-state e1ects: beyond the one-electron picture. In: Cardona Ley (Eds.), Photoemission in Solids Part 1. Springer, Berlin, p. 165. Skala, L., Capkova, P., 1990. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 2, 8293.
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
71
Smith, K.E., Henrich, V.E., 1988. Phys. Rev. B 38, 9571. ∗∗ Soriano, L., Abbate, M., Pen, H., Prieto, P., Sanz, J.M., 1997. Solid State Commun. 102, 291. Spear, K.E., 1989. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 72, 171. Speier, W., Fuggle, J.C., Zeller, R., Ackermann, B., Szot, K., Hillebrecht, F.U., Campagna, M., 1984. Phys. Rev. B 30, 6921. Stanberg, H.I., Jonhson, M.T., Hughes, H.P., 1986. J. Phys. C 19, 2689. Storms, E.K., 1967. The Refractory Carbides. Academic Press, New York. Strydom, I.R., Hofmann, S., 1990. Vacuum 41, 1619. Sue, J.A., 1992. Surf. Coat. Technol. 54=55, 154. Sugano, S., Tanabe, Y., Kamimura, H., 1970. Multiplets of Transition Metal Ions in Crystals. Academic Press, New York. Svane, A., Gunnarsson, O., 1990. Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1148. ∗ Svane, A., 1992. Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1900. Szotek, Z., Temmermann, W.M., Winter, H., 1993. Phys. Rev. B 47, 4029. Tasaki, H., 1998. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 10, 4353. ∗ Terakura, K., Williams, A.R., Oghuchi, T., Kubler, J., 1984. Phys. Rev. Lett. 52, 1830. Tezuka, Y., Shin, S., Agui, A., Fujsawa, M., Ishii, T., 1996. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 65, 312. Tezuka, Y., Shin, S., Ishii, T., Ejima, T., Suzuki, S., Sato, S., 1994. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 63, 347. Theil, C., van Elp, J., Folkmann, F., 1999. Phys. Rev. B 59, 7931. Thomas, G.A., Rapkine, D.H., Carter, S.A., Millis, A.J., Rosenbaum, T.F., Metcalf, P., Honig, J.M., 1994. Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1529. Thomas, J., Pollini, I., 1985. Phys. Rev. B 32, 2522. ∗ ∗ ∗ TXorXok, E., Perry, A.J., Chollet, L., Sproul, W.D., 1987. Thin Solid Films 153, 37. Toth, L.E., 1971. Transition Metal Carbides and Nitrides. Academic Press, New York. Tsuda, N., Nasu, K., Yanase, A., Siratori, K., 1991. Electronic Conduction in Oxides. Springer, Berlin. Tsujioka, T., Mizokawa, T., Okamoto, J., Fujimori, A., Nohara, M., Takagi, H., Yamaura, K., Takano, M., 1997. Phys. Rev. B 56, R15509. Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Kotani, A., Durmeyer, O., Kappler, J.P., Beaurepaire, E., Parlebas, J.C., 1992. Europhys. Lett. 18, 90. Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1993. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 62, 2595. ∗∗ Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Kotani, A., 1996. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 78, 103. ∗∗ Uozumi, T., Okada, K., Kotani, A., Zimmermann, R., Steiner, P., Hufner, S., Tezuka, Y., Shin, S., 1997. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 83, 9. ∗ ∗ ∗ Usuda, M., Hamada, N., 2000. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 69, 744. van Acker, J.F., Stadnik, Z.M., Fuggle, J.C., Hoekstra, H.J., Buschow, K.H., Stroink, G., 1988. Phys. Rev. B 37, 6827. van der Laan, G., Westra, C., Haas, C., Sawatzky, G.A., 1981. Phys. Rev. B 23, 4369. ∗ ∗ ∗ Vasile, M.J., Emerson, A.B., Baiocchi, F.A., 1990. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 8, 99. Veal, B.W., Paulikas, A.P., 1985. Phys. Rev. B 31, 5399. ∗∗ von Barth, U., Hedin, L., 1974. Nuovo Cimento B 23, 1. Wallbank, B., Johhnson, C.E., Main, I.G., 1973a. J. Phys. C 6, L340. Wallbank, B., Johhnson, C.E., Main, I.G., 1973b. J. Phys. C 6, L493. Wallbank, B., Perera, J.S.H.Q., Frost, D.C., McDowell, C.A., 1978. J. Chem. Phys. 69, 5405. Wang, S.Q., Allen, L.H., 1996. J. Appl. Phys. 79, 2446. Weaver, J.H., Bradshaw, A.M., van der Veen, J.F., Himpsel, F.J., Eastman, D.E., Politis, C., 1980. Phys. Rev. B 22, 4921. Wei, P., Qi, Z.Q., 1994. Phys. Rev. B 49, 10 864. ∗ Wertheim, G.K., Hufner, S., 1972. Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1028. Whan, I., Plummer, E.W., 1988. Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 1558. Williams, W.S., Schaal, R.D., 1962. J. Appl. Phys. 33, 955. Williams, W.S., 1971. In: Reiss, M., McCalden, J.D. (Eds.), Progress in Solid State Chemistry. Vol. 6. Pergamon, New York, p. 57.
72
I. Pollini et al. / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 1–72
Wilson, J.A., 1972. Adv. Phys. 21, 143. Wilson, J.A., 1985. Metallic and Non-metallic States of Matter. Taylor and Francis, London, p. 215. Wilson, J.A., 1973. Phase Transitions. Pergamon, New York. Wittling, M., Bendavid, A., Martin, P.J., Swain, P.J., 1995. Thin Solid Films 270, 283. Xu, J.H., Jarborg, J., Freeman, A.J., 1989. Phys. Rev. B 40, 7939. Zaanen, J., Sawatzky, G.A., 1990. Prog. Theor. Phys. (Suppl.) 101, 231. Zaanen, J., Sawatzky, G.A., Allen, J.W., 1985. Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 418. ∗ ∗ ∗ Zaanen, J., Westra, C., Sawatzky, G.A., 1986. Phys. Rev. B 33, 8060. ∗∗ Ziegler, J.F., Biersack, J.P., Littmark, U., 1985. In: Ziegler, J.F. (Ed.), The Stopping and Ranges of Ions in Solids. Pergamon Press, New York. Ziman, J.M., 1969. Elements of Advanced Quantum Theory. University Press, Cambridge. Zimmermann, R., Claessen, R., Reinert, F., Steiner, P., Hufner, S., 1998. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 10, 5697. ∗ Zimmermann, R., Steiner, P., Claessen, R., Reinert, F., Hufner, S., Blaha, P., 1999. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 11, 1657. ∗ ∗ ∗
PERTURBATIVE QUANTUM FIELD THEORY IN THE STRING-INSPIRED FORMALISM
Christian SCHUBERT Laboratoire d+Annecy-le-Vieux de Physique TheH orique LAPTH, Chemin de Bellevue, BP 110, F-74941 Annecy-le-Vieux CEDEX, France Instituto de Fisica y MathemaH ticas, Universidad Michoacana de San NicolaH s de Hidalgo, Apdo. Postal 2-82, C.P. 58040, Morelia, MichoacaH n, MeH xico California Institute for Physics and Astrophysics 366 Cambridge Ave, Palo Alto, Califormia, USA
AMSTERDAM } LONDON } NEW YORK } OXFORD } PARIS } SHANNON } TOKYO
Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Perturbative quantum eld theory in the string-inspired formalism Christian Schubert a; b; c a
Laboratoire d’Annecy-le-Vieux de Physique Theorique LAPTH, Chemin de Bellevue, BP 110, F-74941 Annecy-le-Vieux Cedex, France b Instituto de F'sica y Matematicas, Universidad Michoacana de San Nicolas de Hidalgo, Apdo. Postal 2-82, C.P. 58040, Morelia, Michoacan, Mexico c California Institute for Physics and Astrophysics, 366 Cambridge Ave., Palo Alto, CA, USA Received December 2000; editor: A: Schwimmer
Contents 1. Introduction: strings vs. particles, rst vs. second quantization 2. The Bern–Kosower formalism 2.1. The innite string tension limit 2.2. The Bern–Kosower rules for gluon scattering 3. Worldline path integral representations for e5ective actions 3.1. Scalar eld theory 3.2. Scalar quantum electrodynamics 3.3. Spinor quantum electrodynamics 3.4. Non-abelian gauge theory 4. Calculation of one-loop amplitudes 4.1. The N -point amplitude in scalar eld theory 4.2. Photon scattering in quantum electrodynamics 4.3. Example: QED vacuum polarization
75 87 87 90 92 93 94 95 98 104 104 108 111
4.4. Scalar loop contribution to gluon scattering 4.5. Spinor loop contribution to gluon scattering 4.6. Gluon loop contribution to gluon scattering 4.7. Example: QCD vacuum polarization 4.8. N photon=N gluon amplitudes 4.9. Example: gluon–gluon scattering 4.10. Boundary terms and gauge invariance 4.11. Relation to Feynman diagrams 5. QED in a constant external eld 5.1. Modied worldline Green’s functions and determinants 5.2. Example: one-loop Euler–Heisenberg– Schwinger Lagrangians 5.3. The N -photon amplitude in a constant eld
E-mail address:
[email protected] (C. Schubert). c 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. 0370-1573/01/$ - see front matter PII: S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 0 1 3 - 8
113 114 115 118 118 121 127 129 130 130 133 134
74
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
5.4. Explicit representations of the modied worldline Green’s functions 5.5. Example: the scalar=spinor QED vacuum polarization tensors in a constant eld 5.6. Example: photon splitting in a constant magnetic eld 6. Yukawa and axial couplings 6.1. Yukawa couplings from gauge theory 6.2. N scalar=N pseudoscalar amplitudes 6.3. The spinor loop in a vector and axialvector background 6.4. Master formula for the one-loop vector-axialvector amplitudes 6.5. The VVA anomaly 6.6. Inclusion of constant background elds 6.7. Example: vector–axialvector amplitude in a constant eld 7. E5ective actions and their inverse mass expansions 7.1. The inverse mass expansion for nonabelian gauge theory 7.2. Other backgrounds 8. Multiloop worldline Green’s functions 8.1. The 2-loop case 8.2. Comparison with Feynman diagrams 8.3. Higher loop orders
135 140 145 147 148 149 151 154 158 159 160 163 163 170 172 173 178 179
8.4. Connection to string theory 8.5. Example: three-loop vacuum amplitude 9. The QED photon S-matrix 9.1. The single scalar loop 9.2. The single electron loop 9.3. The general case 9.4. Example: the two-loop QED -functions 9.5. Quantum electrodynamics in a constant external eld 9.6. Example: The two-loop Euler– Heisenberg lagrangians 9.7. Some more remarks on the two-loop QED -functions 9.8. Beyond two loops 10. Conclusions and outlook Acknowledgements Appendix A. Summary of conventions Appendix B. Worldline Green’s functions Appendix C. Symmetric partial integration Appendix D. Proof of the cycle replacement rule Appendix E. Massless one-loop 4-point tensor integrals Appendix F. Some worldloop formulas References
181 182 185 185 186 187 188 194 195 208 209 210 213 213 214 218 222 224 226 228
Abstract We review the status and present range of applications of the “string-inspired” approach to perturbative quantum eld theory. This formalism o5ers the possibility of computing e5ective actions and S-matrix elements in a way which is similar in spirit to string perturbation theory, and bypasses much of the apparatus of standard second-quantized eld theory. Its development was initiated by Bern and Kosower, originally with the aim of simplifying the calculation of scattering amplitudes in quantum chromodynamics and quantum gravity. We give a short account of the original derivation of the Bern–Kosower rules from string theory. Strassler’s alternative approach in terms of rst-quantized particle path integrals is then used to generalize the formalism to more general eld theories, and, in the abelian case, also to higher loop orders. A considerable number of sample calculations are presented in detail, with an c 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. emphasis on quantum electrodynamics. PACS: 03.70.+k; 11.10.−z
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
75
1. Introduction: strings vs. particles, rst vs. second quantization One of the main motivations for the study of string theory is the fact that it reduces to quantum eld theory in the limit where the tension along the string becomes innite [1– 4]. In this limit all massive modes of the string get suppressed, and one remains with the massless modes. Those can be identied with ordinary massless particles such as gauge bosons, gravitons, or massless spin- 12 fermions. Moreover, the interactions taking place between those massless modes turn out to be familiar from quantum eld theory. In particular, it came as a pleasant surprise that a consistent theory of fundamental strings must by necessity include quantum gravity [5]. Regardless of whether string theory is realized in nature or not, those mathematical facts already lend us a new perspective on quantum eld theory, which we now nd embedded in a theory which is not only vastly more complex, but also structurally di5erent. In particular, a major di5erence between string theory and particle theory is that, in string theory, the full perturbative S-matrix is calculable in rst quantization using the Polyakov path integral, which describes the propagation of a single string in a given background. An adequate second quantized eld theory for strings was built after considerable e5orts [6,7], allowing one to dene o5-shell amplitudes with the correct factorization properties, and even to compute nonperturbative e5ects in string theory [8–10]. Nevertheless, so far the second quantized approach has not led to improvements over the rst quantized formalism as far as the calculation of perturbative string scattering amplitudes is concerned. In ordinary quantum eld theory, of course, perturbative calculations are usually performed using second quantization, and Feynman diagrams. First quantized alternatives have been developed already at the very inception of relativistic quantum eld theory [11], and will, in fact, be the main subject of the present review. However it appears that, until recently, they were hardly ever seriously considered as an eNcient tool for standard perturbative calculations. This discrepancy between string and particle theory becomes something of a puzzle as soon as one considers the latter as a limiting special case of the former. And we would like to convince the reader in the following that this apparent paradox owes more to historical development than to mathematical fact. If string theory reduces to eld theory in the innite string tension limit, then clearly it should be possible to obtain S-matrix elements in certain eld theory models by analyzing the corresponding string scattering amplitudes in this limit. It goes without saying that the calculation of string amplitudes is generally much more diNcult than the calculation of the corresponding eld theory amplitudes, so that the practical value of such a procedure may appear far from obvious. Nevertheless, it turns out to be suNciently motivated by the di5erent organization of both types of amplitudes, and by the di5erent methods available for their computation. As early as 1972 Gervais and Neveu observed that string theory generates Feynman rules for Yang–Mills theory in a special gauge that has certain calculational advantages [12]. At the loop level, the rst explicit calculation along these lines was performed in 1982 by Green, Schwarz and Brink, who obtained the one-loop 4-gluon amplitude in N = 4 super Yang–Mills theory from the low energy limit of superstring theory [13]. However, serious interest in this subject commenced only in 1988, when this limit was used by several authors to obtain eld
76
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Fig. 1. The loop expansion in string perturbation theory.
theory -functions from various string models [14–17]. In particular, in Ref. [16] the one-loop -function for Yang–Mills theory was extracted from the genus one partition function of an open string coupled to a background gauge eld. This calculation gives also some insight into the well known fact that this -function coeNcient vanishes for D = 26, the critical dimension of the bosonic string, when calculated in dimensional regularization [280,18]. A systematic investigation of the innite string tension limit was undertaken in the following years by Bern and Kosower [19 –21]. This was done again with a view on application to non-abelian gauge theory, however now to the computation of complete on-shell scattering amplitudes. Again the idea was to calculate, say, gauge boson scattering amplitudes in an appropriate string model containing SU (Nc ) gauge theory, up to the point where one has obtained an explicit parameter integral representation for the amplitude considered. At this stage one performs the innite string tension limit, which should eliminate all contributions due to propagating massive modes, and lead to a parameter integral representation for the corresponding eld theory amplitude. In the present work, we will concentrate on a di5erent and more elementary approach to this formalism, which does not rely on the calculation of string amplitudes any more, and uses string theory only as a guiding principle. Only a sketchy account will therefore be given of string perturbation theory, and the reader is referred to the literature for the details [5,22]. The basic tool for the calculation of string scattering amplitudes is the Polyakov path integral. In the simplest case, the closed bosonic string propagating in Pat spacetime, this integral is of the form Dh Dx( ; )V1 · · ·VN e−S[x; h] : V1 · · ·VN ∼ (1.1) top
This path integral corresponds to rst quantization in the sense that it describes a single string propagating in a given background. The parameters ; parametrize the world sheet surface swept out by the string in its motion, and the integral Dx( ; ) has to be performed over the space of all embeddings of the string world sheet with a xed topology into spacetime. The integral Dh is over the space of all world sheet metrics, and the sum over topologies top corresponds to the loop expansion in eld theory (Fig. 1). If the closed string is assumed to be oriented, there is only one topology at any xed order of loops. In the case that the background is simply Minkowski spacetime the world sheet action is given by √ 1 S[x; h] = − d d hh 9 x 9 x ; (1.2) 4
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
77
Fig. 2. Vertex operators inserted on the boundary of the annulus. Fig. 3. Innite string tension limit of a string diagram.
where 1=2 is the string tension. Note that in Polyakov’s formulation the action is quadratic in the coordinate eld x. The vertex operators V1 ; : : : ; VN represent the scattering string states. In the case of the open string, which is the more relevant one for our purpose, the world sheet has a boundary, and the vertex operators are inserted on this boundary. For instance, for the open oriented string at the one-loop level the world sheet is just an annulus, and a vertex operator may be integrated along either one of the two boundary components (Fig. 2). The vertex operators most relevant for us are of the form V [k] = d eik · x() ; (1.3) A ˙ eik · x() : (1.4) V [k; ; a] = d T a · x() They represent a scalar and a gauge boson particle with denite momentum k and polarization vector . T a is a generator of the gauge group in some representation. The integration variable parametrizes the boundary in question. Since the action is Gaussian, Dx can be performed by Wick contractions, x (1 )x (2 ) = G(1 ; 2 ) ;
(1.5)
where G denotes the Green’s function for the Laplacian on the annulus, restricted to its boundary, and the Lorentz metric. In D = 26, the critical dimension of the bosonic string, the Polyakov path integral is conformally invariant. The remaining path integral over the innite dimensional space of all world sheet metrics h can then be reduced to the space of conformal equivalence classes, which is nite dimensional. The actual integration domain, moduli space, is somewhat smaller, since a further discrete symmetry group has to be taken into account. At this stage, then, the amplitude is in a form suitable for performing the innite string tension limit. It turns out that, in this limit, only certain corners of the whole moduli space contribute. The amplitude thus splinters into a number of pieces, which individually are parameter integrals of the same type encountered in eld theory Feynman diagram calculations.
78
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
For illustration, consider the following two-point “Feynman diagram” for the closed string (Fig. 3). In the → 0 limit this Riemann surface gets squeezed to a Feynman graph, although not to a single one; two Feynman diagrams of di5erent topologies emerge. This proliferation becomes, of course, much worse at higher orders. Moreover, in gauge theory or gravity it is further enhanced by the existence of quartic and higher order vertices, which lead to many more possible topologies. The generating string theories thus have a much smaller number of “Feynman diagrams” then the limiting eld theories, which is another major motivation for the use of string techniques in eld theory. The uses of the Polyakov path integral are not restricted to the calculation of scattering amplitudes. As pointed out by Fradkin and Tseytlin [23], it is equally useful for the calculation of string e5ective actions. For instance, an open oriented string propagating in the background of a Yang–Mills eld A would generate an e5ective action for this background eld given by the following modication of the Polyakov path integral, [A]∼ Dh Dx( ; )e−S0 −SI ; top
√ 1 d d hh 9 x 9 x ; S0 = − 4 M d iex˙ A (x()) : SI = 9M
(1.6)
The sum now extends over all oriented bounded manifolds. The free term S0 is the same as above, Eq. (1.2), and the interaction term SI has to be integrated along all components of the boundary. For simplicity, we have written the interaction term for the abelian case; in the non-abelian case, a color trace and path ordering would have to be included. This will be discussed later on in the eld theory context. Metsaev and Tseytlin calculated the one-loop path integral exactly for the constant eld strength case [16], and veried that the → 0 limit coincides with the corresponding e5ective action in Yang–Mills theory. In particular, the correct -function coeNcient can be read o5 from 2 -term. This procedure is not completely rigorous, though, since the open bosonic string the F theory cannot be consistently truncated from 26 down to four dimensions. In their analysis of the N -gluon amplitude [21], Bern and Kosower therefore used, instead of the open string, a certain heterotic string model containing SU (Nc ) Yang–Mills theory in the innite string tension limit. This allows for a consistent reduction to four dimensions, at the price of a more complicated representation of this amplitude. By an explicit analysis of the innite string tension limit, they succeeded in deriving a novel type of parameter integral representation for the on-shell N -gluon amplitude in Yang–Mills theory, at the tree- and one-loop level. Moreover, they established a set of rules which allows one to construct this parameter integral, for any number of gluons and choice of helicities, without referring to string theory any more. While those rules are very di5erent from the corresponding eld theoretic Feynman rules, the precise connection and equivalence between both sets of rules were soon established [24]. Moreover, once an understanding of the rules had been reached, it emerged that the consistency requirements motivating the choice of the heterotic string were not really relevant in their
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
79
derivation. An alternative derivation using the naive truncated open string was given [25], and even yielded a somewhat simpler set of rules. This set of rules will be discussed in detail in Section 2. For the moment, let us just mention some advantages of the “Bern–Kosower rules” as compared to the Feynman rules: 1. Superior organization of gauge invariance. 2. Absence of loop momentum, which reduces the number of kinematic invariants from the beginning, and allows for a particularly eNcient use of the spinor helicity method. 3. The method combines nicely with spacetime supersymmetry. 4. Calculations of scattering amplitudes with the same external states but particles of di5erent spin circulating in the loop are more closely related than usual. The last two points are, of course, closely related. The eNciency of these rules has been demonstrated by the rst complete calculation of the one-loop ve-gluon amplitude [26]. A similar set of rules for graviton scattering was derived from closed string theory in [27]. Those have been used for the rst calculation of the complete one-loop four-graviton amplitude in quantum gravity [28]. Since the Bern–Kosower rules do not refer to string theory any more, the question naturally arises whether it should not be possible to re-derive them completely inside eld theory. Obviously, such a re-derivation should be attempted starting from a rst-quantized formulation of ordinary eld theory, rather than from standard quantum eld theory. As we mentioned in the beginning, such formulations have been known for decades, albeit only for a very limited number of models. Already in 1950, in Appendix A of his famous paper “Mathematical Formulation of the Quantum Theory of Electromagnetic Interaction” [11], Feynman presented such a formalism for the case of scalar quantum electrodynamics, “for its own interest as an alternative to the formulation of second quantization”. What he states here is that the amplitude for a charged scalar particle to move, under the inPuence of the external potential A , from point x to x in Minkowski space is given by s d x d x 2 1 2 i s ds Dx() exp − im s exp − d −i d A (x()) 2 2 0 d d x(0) = x 0 0 s i 2 s d x d x − e (1.7) d d ! (x() − x( )) : 2 d d + 0 0
∞
x(s) = x
That is, for a xed value of the variable s (which can be identied with Schwinger proper time) one can construct the amplitude as a certain quantum mechanical path integral. This path integral has to be performed on the set of all open trajectories running from x to x in the xed proper time s. The action consists of the familiar kinetic term, and two interaction terms. Of those the rst represents the interaction with the external eld, to all orders in the eld, while the second one describes an arbitrary number of virtual photons emitted and re-absorbed along the trajectory of the particle (!+ denotes the photon propagator). In second quantized eld theory, this amplitude would thus correspond to the innite sequence of Feynman diagrams shown in Fig. 4.
80
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Fig. 4. Sum of Feynman diagrams represented by a single path integral.
As Feynman proceeds to show, this representation extends in an obvious way to the case of an arbitrary xed number of scalar particles, moving in an external potential and exchanging internal photons, and thus to the complete S-matrix for scalar quantum electrodynamics. Every scalar line or loop is then separately described by a path integral such as the one above. The path integrals are coupled by an arbitrary number of photon insertions. The derivation of this type of path integral will be discussed in detail in Section 3. In the present work, we are mainly concerned with path integrals for closed loops. Let us therefore rewrite Feynman’s formula for the case of a single closed loop in the external eld, with no internal photon corrections. What we have at hand then is simply a representation of the one-loop e5ective action for the Maxwell eld, 1 T ∞ dT −m2 T 1 2 Dx exp − [A] = d : (1.8) e x˙ + ieA x˙ T 4 0 0 The path integral runs now over the space of closed trajectories with period T; x (T ) = x (0). The comparison of the Fradkin–Tseytlin path integral (1.6) with the path integral (1.8) shows that the former is clearly a string theoretic generalization of the latter. Conversely, at least at the one-loop level it is not diNcult to show that the Feynman path integral is precisely the innite string tension limit of the Fradkin–Tseytlin path integral. Naively, one can think of the annulus in Fig. 2 being squeezed to its boundary. The path integral representation Eq. (1.8) generalizes in various ways to spinor quantum electrodynamics. In the fermion loop case, one has a basic choice to make in the treatment of the spin degrees of freedom. Those can be incorporated either by explicit "-matrices [29,30], or by Grassmann variables [31–34], which carry the same algebraic properties. The rst, “bosonized”, version may be preferable for certain purposes such as the evaluation of path integrals by numerical or saddle point approximation. Nevertheless, we will generally use the second alternative, since it o5ers the possibility to use worldline supersymmetry in a computationally meaningful way. Supersymmetric worldline Lagrangians were constructed soon after the advent of supersymmetry. This led to an intensive study of eld theories in 1 + 0 dimensions, and to the discovery that the worldline Lagrangian appropriate for the description of a Dirac particle is precisely the one for N = 1 supergravity [35,36]. As a consequence of that work, the generalization of our path integral Eq. (1.8) for the one-loop e5ective action to spinor QED can be written as 1
The proper time parameter s has been rescaled and Wick rotated, s → − i2T . The spacetime metric will also be taken as Euclidean, except when stated otherwise (upper and lower indices will be used purely for typographical convenience). Moreover, we anticipate dimensional regularization and thus usually continue to D Euclidean dimensions.
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
a super path integral [31,37–39] 1 ∞ dT −m2 T [A] = − e 2 0 T × Dx D exp − P
A
0
T
1 2 1 d · ˙ + ieA x˙ − ie x˙ + 4 2
81
F
:
(1.9)
In addition to the integral over the periodic functions x (), we have now a second path integral over the functions (), which are Grassmann valued and antiperiodic (the periodicity properties are expressed by the subscripts P; A on the path integral). The global minus sign accounts for the Fermi statistics of the spinor loop. Comparing this formula with Eq. (1.8), it becomes immediately clear that one can think of this double path integral as breaking up the Dirac spinor into an “orbital part” and a “spin part”. The former is represented by the same coordinate path integral as the scalar particle, the latter by the additional Grassmann path integral. In writing this path integral, we have already gauge-xed the local one-dimensional supergravity. This leaves over a global supersymmetry, “worldline supersymmetry” !x = − 2 !
= x˙
; (1.10)
with a constant Grassmann parameter . As we will see later on, the existence of this symmetry has far-reaching calculational consequences. A vast amount of literature is available on this type of relativistic particle Lagrangians, and the corresponding path integrals. However, only a minor part of it is concerned with attempts to use them as a tool for actual calculations in quantum eld theory. Much of particularly the early literature emphasizes the one-dimensional over the spacetime point of view, or is concerned with the formal properties of such worldline eld theories. In particular, one-dimensional eld theories are often used for a comparative study of the various known quantization procedures (see, e.g., [40]). Of those applications which have come to this author’s notice, let us mention the work of Halpern et al. [41,42], who proposed to use rst quantized path integrals for a construction of the strong-coupling expansion in non-abelian gauge theory. More recently, various attempts have been made to apply worldline path integrals to nonperturbative calculations, using various approximation schemes for the path integral. See, e.g., [43] for scalar eld theory, [44] for heavy-meson theory, [45,46] for QCD, and [47] for meson–nucleon theory applications. Some applications to QED can be found in [48,49,38,50 –53], to statistical physics in [54]. Probably best known is, however, the application to the calculation of anomalies and index densities [55 – 62]. Here a number of special cases of the Atiyah–Singer index theorem could be reproduced in an elementary way by rewriting supertraces of heat kernels for the corresponding operators in terms of supersymmetric particle path integrals [56 –58]. Nevertheless, despite this remarkable success it seems that, until recently, the rst quantized formalism was never seriously considered as a competitor to the usual Feynman diagrammatic approach with regard to everyday life calculations of scattering amplitudes or e5ective actions.
82
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Fig. 5. Expanding the path integral in powers of the background eld.
The principle of how one might reproduce ordinary perturbation theory in the rst quantized formalism, simply by mimicking string perturbation theory, was already sketched in Section 9 of Polyakov’s book [63]. However it was only after the work of Bern and Kosower, when it had become clear that techniques from rst-quantized string perturbation theory do have the potential to improve on the eNciency of eld theory calculations, that such an approach was seriously investigated by Strassler [64,65]. Let us demonstrate the method for the example of the scalar loop, Eq. (1.8). The basic idea is simple: We will evaluate this path integral in precisely the same way as one calculates the Polyakov path integral in string theory, i.e. in a one-dimensional perturbation theory. If we expand the “interaction exponential”, T ∞ N (−ie)N T exp − d ieA x˙ = di [x˙ (i )A (x(i ))] ; (1.11) N ! 0 0 N =0
i=1
the individual terms correspond to Feynman diagrams describing a xed number of interactions of the scalar loop with the external eld (Fig. 5). By standard eld theory, the corresponding N -photon correlator is then obtained by specializing to a background consisting of a sum of plane waves with denite polarizations, A (x) =
N
i eiki · x
(1.12)
i=1
and picking out the term containing every i once (this also removes the 1=N ! in Eq. (1.11)). We nd thus exactly the same photon vertex operator used in string perturbation theory, Eq. (1.4), inserted on a circle instead on the boundary of the annulus. At this stage the path integral has become Gaussian, which reduces its evaluation to the task of Wick contracting the expression x˙1 1 eik1 · x1 · · ·x˙NN eikN · xN :
(1.13)
The Green’s function to be used is now simply the one for the second-derivative operator, acting on periodic functions. To derive this Green’s function, rst observe that Dx() contains the constant functions, which we must get rid of to obtain a well-dened inverse. Let us therefore restrict our integral over the space of all loops by xing the average or “center of mass” position x0 of the loop 1 T d x () : (1.14) x0 ≡ T 0
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
83
For e5ective action calculations this reduces the e5ective action to the e5ective Lagrangian. In scattering amplitude calculations, the integral over x0 just gives momentum conservation. The reduced path integral Dy() over y() ≡ x() − x0 has an invertible kinetic operator. The inverse is easily seen to be, up to an irrelevant constant, −2 d 21 | |2 = GB (1 ; 2 ) (1.15) d with the “bosonic” worldline Green’s function (1 − 2 )2 (1.16) T (a “fermionic” worldline Green’s function GF will be introduced later on). For the performance of the Wick contractions, it is convenient to formally exponentiate all the x˙i ’s, writing GB (1 ; 2 ) = |1 − 2 | −
i · x˙i eiki · xi = ei · x˙i +iki · xi |lin(i ) :
(1.17)
This allows one to rewrite the product of N photon vertex operators as an exponential. Then one needs only to “complete the square” to arrive at the following closed expression for the one-loop N -photon amplitude in scalar QED, scal [k1 ; 1 ; : : : ; kN ; N ] N D ki = (−ie) (2) !
0
×
N
i=1 0
T
∞
dT 2 (4T )−D=2 e−m T T
N 1 1 di exp GBij ki · kj − iG˙ Bij i · kj + GS Bij i · j 2 2 i; j = 1
: (1.18) multi-linear
Here it is understood that only the terms linear in all the 1 ; : : : ; N have to be taken. Besides the Green’s function GB also its rst and second derivatives appear, (1 − 2 ) G˙ B (1 ; 2 ) = sign(1 − 2 ) − 2 ; T 2 GS B (1 ; 2 ) = 2!(1 − 2 ) − : (1.19) T Dots generally denote a derivative acting on the rst variable, G˙ B (1 ; 2 ) ≡ 9= 91 GB (1 ; 2 ), and we abbreviate GBij ≡ GB (i ; j ), etc. The factor [4T ]−D=2 represents the free Gaussian path integral determinant factor. Expression (1.18) which we have arrived at in this quite elementary way is identical with the “Bern–Kosower master formula” for the special case considered [21,66]. We will discuss various generalizations and applications of this formula later on. For now, the important point to note is that we have at hand here a single unifying generating functional for the one-loop photon S-matrix—something for which no known analogue exists in standard eld theory. How does this master integrand relate to the integrals appearing in an ordinary Feynman parameter calculation of this amplitude? Note that in (1.18) every photon leg is integrated
84
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Fig. 6. Sum of one-loop diagrams with permuted legs.
Fig. 7. Sum of two-loop diagrams with di5erent topologies.
around the loop independently. As we will see in detail later on, once one restricts the integration domain to a xed ordering i1 ¿i2 ¿· · ·¿iN , it is not diNcult to identify the integrand with the corresponding Feynman parameter integral. In particular, there is an exact correspondence between the !-function appearing in the second derivative of GB , and the seagull vertex of scalar quantum electrodynamics. However the complete integral does not represent any particular Feynman diagram, with a xed ordering of the external legs, but the sum of them (Fig. 6): This fact may not seem particularly relevant at the one-loop level. However it is important to note that the path integral representation Eq. (1.8) and the resulting integral representation Eq. (1.18) are valid o5-shell. 2 We can therefore use this formula to sew together a pair of legs, say, legs number 1 and N , and obtain a parameter integral representing the complete two-loop (N − 2)-photon amplitude (Fig. 7): This is interesting, as we have at hand a single integral formula for a sum containing many diagrams of di5erent topologies. We may think of it as a remnant of the “less fragmented” nature of string perturbation theory mentioned before (Fig. 3). Moreover, it calls certain well-known cancellations to mind which happen in gauge theory due to the fact that the Feynman diagram calculation splits a gauge invariant amplitude into gauge non-invariant pieces. For instance, to obtain the 3-loop -function coeNcient for quenched (single spinor-loop) QED, one needs to calculate the sum of diagrams shown in Fig. 8. Performing this calculation in, say, dimensional regularization, one nds that 1. All poles of order higher than 1= cancel. 2
This fact was not obvious in the original string-theoretic derivation of (1.18), since before the innite string tension limit the requirement of conformal invariance forces the external states to be on-shell.
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
85
Fig. 8. Sum of diagrams contributing to the 3-loop QED -function.
2. Individual diagrams give contributions to the -function proportional to *(3) which cancel in the sum, leaving a rational coeNcient. The rst property is known to be a consequence of gauge invariance, and to hold true to all orders of perturbation theory [67]. The second one, i.e. the absence of irrational numbers in the quenched QED -function, has been explicitly veried to four-loop order in spinor QED [68,69], and to three-loop order in scalar QED [70]. Recently arguments from knot theory have been given which link both properties [70], indicating that this property should hold to all orders, too. As every practician in quantum eld theory knows, similar extensive cancellations abound in calculations in gauge theory. It seems therefore very natural to apply the Bern–Kosower formalism to this type of calculation. However, in its original version the Bern–Kosower formalism was conned to tree-level and one-loop amplitudes. The extension of this formalism beyond one loop is obviously desirable, and has already been attempted along quite di5erent lines: In the original approach of Bern and Kosower, going beyond one loop would imply nding the particle theory limits of higher genus string amplitudes, a formidable task considering the complicated structure of moduli space for genus higher than one. While a suitable representation of the N -gluon amplitude at arbitrary genus was already given in [71], and substantial progress was achieved in the analysis of the innite string tension limit [72–78], so far this line of work has not yet led to the formulation of multiloop Bern–Kosower type rules. Another, and in some sense opposite route has been taken by Lam [79], who sets out with the usual Feynman parameter integral representation of multiloop diagrams, and uses the electric circuit analog [80,81] to transform those into the Koba–Nielsen type representation which one would expect from a string-type calculation. Yet another approach has been followed by McKeon [82], who proposes to perform multiloop calculations by writing a separate worldline path integral for every internal propagator of a diagram. A Hamiltonian approach was considered in [83]. In principle one could, of course, also construct Bern–Kosower type multiloop formulae using the explicit sewing procedure indicated above. However, we will describe another multiloop formalism here, proposed by M.G. Schmidt and the author [84,85], which is based on a more eNcient way of inserting propagators into one-loop amplitudes. This approach is a direct generalization of Strassler’s one-loop formalism, and preserves its main properties. Its distinguishing features are the following: 1. We will generalize Eq. (1.16) for the one-loop Green’s function to the construction of Green’s functions dened on multiloop graphs. 2. The supereld formalism for the fermion loop will carry over to the multiloop level. 3. All eld theory vertices will be represented by worldline quantities.
86
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Though not explicitly referring to string theory any more, the resulting formalism may still be called “string-inspired” in the sense that it has a natural interpretation in terms of a onedimensional eld theory dened on graphs. As one would expect from a generalization of the Bern–Kosower method, it allows one to derive well-organized parameter integral representations for dimensionally regularized o5-shell amplitudes, without the need for computing momentum integrals or Dirac traces. At the multiloop level, this formalism has been worked out comprehensively for scalar eld theories [84,86 –90] as well as for scalar and spinor QED [85,91–93]. In those models, in principle it applies to the calculation of arbitrary o5-shell amplitudes involving only spin 0 and spin 1 scattering states, or of the corresponding e5ective Lagrangians. More recently along these lines preliminary results have been obtained also for Yang–Mills Theory at the two-loop level [94,95]. Our applications center around the photon S-matrix in quantum electrodynamics as our main paradigm. Here the formalism has been developed to a point where it shows some distinct advantages over the more standard methods, in particular for problems involving constant external elds. At the one-loop level, we present also a number of calculations involving Yukawa and axial couplings, as well as non-abelian gauge elds. The material is organized as follows. In Section 2 we state the Bern–Kosower rules for the case of gluon scattering, and shortly sketch their derivation from the open bosonic string. In Section 3 we give derivations for the most basic worldline Lagrangians used in this work, describing the coupling of particles with spin 0; 12 , and 1 to external gauge elds. The starting point in this derivation is always the proper-time representation of the one-loop e5ective action in terms of the one-loop functional determinant. We discuss in particular detail the path integral representation of spin-1 particles [64,92], since here the application of the string-inspired technique requires a non-standard approach. The principle of how to calculate such path integrals within the “string-inspired formalism” is then explained in Section 4. The advantages of the technique compared to the standard Feynman diagram technique are then demonstrated using the example of the QED and QCD vacuum polarizations, and QCD gluon–gluon scattering. We investigate the systematics of the Bern–Kosower partial integration procedure for the general N -photon=N gluon amplitudes, and determine the structure of the resulting integrand. We also clarify the relation of the worldline parameter integrals to the ones arising in standard Feynman parameter calculations of the same amplitudes. Section 5 is devoted to the treatment of QED amplitudes in a constant electromagnetic background eld. This case is given special attention since it provides a particularly natural application of the string-inspired technique [96 –100,92]. In Section 6 we consider more general eld theories. While worldline path integral representations have been known and investigated for decades for the case of spin-0 and spin- 12 particles minimally coupled to gauge and gravitational backgrounds, worldline Lagrangians describing the coupling of a Dirac fermion to a general background consisting of a scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, axialvector and antisymmetric tensor eld were obtained only recently [101–105]. In the present review we restrict ourselves to two special cases which admit particularly elegant formulations, namely the scalar–pseudoscalar and the vector–axialvector amplitudes.
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
87
Section 7 deals with the application of the formalism to the calculation of e5ective actions in the higher derivative or heat-kernel expansion [96,106,107]. While our discussion concentrates on the gauge theory case, we also shortly discuss some mathematical subtleties which arise in the generalization of the formalism to curved backgrounds, and which were claried only very recently. In Section 8 we generalize the worldline formalism to the calculation of multiloop amplitudes in scalar self-interacting eld theories. This generalization is based on the concept of Green’s functions dened on graphs, and follows the string analogy closely. We derive explicit expressions for those Green’s functions for a large class of graphs, the so-called “Hamiltonian graphs”, and verify for some simple two-loop examples that their application reproduces the same amplitudes as the corresponding Feynman diagram calculations. This formalism is then generalized to quantum electrodynamics in Section 9, where in principle it applies to the calculation of the whole photon S-matrix. At the two-loop level, we present a detailed recalculation [92,108] of the Euler–Heisenberg Lagrangians in scalar and spinor QED, including the -function coeNcients. An interesting cancellation which occurs in the spinor QED case is explained by an analysis of the renormalization procedure. In the conclusion we give a short overview over the present range of applicability of the worldline technique, and point out some possible future directions. There are several technical appendices. Appendix A contains a summary of the conventions used in the present work, 3 including the rules for continuation from Euclidean to Minkowski space. In Appendix B we give detailed calculations of the various worldline propagators which are used in the main text. Appendix C contains a more detailed discussion of the partial integration procedure introduced in Section 4.8, and a summary of the resulting worldline integrands up to the six-point case. The results are used in Appendix D for a simple proof of the basic fermionic replacement rule (2.15). In Appendix E we explain a technique for the calculation of four-point massless on-shell tensor parameter integrals, following [109]. Finally, Appendix F contains a collection of formulas which we have found useful, or at least amusing. 2. The Bern–Kosower formalism This section is devoted to a statement of the Bern–Kosower rules, and to a short account of their derivation from string theory. We follow not the original derivation from the heterotic string [19 –21] but the simpler one using the open bosonic string, as given in [25,66]. 2.1. The in
Those di5er in some points from previous work by this author.
88
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
spacetime, and the integral over moduli space. In the case of the annulus there is only one modular parameter [5] = − 12 ln(q) ;
(2.1)
where q can be interpreted as the square of the ratio of the two radii dening the annulus. Since the two-dimensional worldsheet theory is free, the path integral can be computed by a repeated application of Wick’s theorem, using the Green’s function GBann for the Laplacian on the annulus. If we assume all of the vertex operators to be on the same boundary, one has explicitly 212 2 ann y (1 )y (2 ) = g GB (1 ; 2 ) = − g ln |2 sinh(12 )| − − 4q sinh (12 ) + O(q2 ) ; (2.2) where denotes the length of the boundary, i the location of the ith vertex operator along the boundary, N = 0, and ij ≡ i − j . One obtains a parameter integral (compare Eq. (1.18)) ∞ N
−1 (N=2−2) −D=2 d Z() di /(i − i+1 ) [k1 ; 1 ; : : : ; kN ; N ]∼( ) 0
×exp
N
i¡j = 1
i=1
0
1 ann 1 √ ˙ ann ann GBij ki · kj + G Bij (ki · j − kj · i ) − GS Bij i · j 2 4
: (2.3) multi-linear
Here we have omitted the color trace and some global factors. Z() is essentially the string vacuum partition function, and given by Z = q−1
∞
(1 − q n )−2 = q−1 + 2 + O(q) :
(2.4)
n=1
The analysis of the innite string tension limit → 0 can be simplied by rst removing all ann second derivatives GS Bij by suitable partial integrations in the variables i . This is always possible [20], and will be discussed later on in the eld theory context. The integrand then becomes homogeneous in . The possible boundary terms appearing in the integration by parts can be made to vanish by a suitable analytic continuation in the external momenta. In the → 0 limit, rst one has to extract massless poles in the S-matrix, which can appear for regions where i → j . Those are of the form 1 1 → 0 di 1+ ki · kj → − (2.5) k i · kj ij and yield the so-called “tree” or “pinch” contributions. The limit itself is to be taken on the sum of the unpinched expression together with all pinch contributions. It is consumed by taking ; |ij | → ∞, which corresponds to the ratio of radii approaching 1, and thus to the annulus ann being squeezed to a eld theory loop. Analyzing GBann and G˙ B in this limit, one nds that they
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
can be replaced by
exp[GBann (12 )] → const:×exp
212 − |12 | ;
89
(2.6)
12 ann G˙ B (12 ) → − sign(12 ) + 2 (2.7) + 2 sign(12 )(qe2|12 | − e−2|12 | ) : Since this limit corresponds to q → 0, and the expansion of Z as a power series in q starts with a q−1 , there are again two types of contributions. The rst type arises by picking the next-to-leading constant term in Z. Then only the leading ann order terms from the integrand can survive the limit, so that G˙ B is further truncated to the rst two terms of Eq. (2.7). The second type is obtained by combining the leading order term from Z with a next-to-leading ann term in the integrand. Then subleading terms in the G˙ Bij can potentially contribute, however it turns out that a too strong suppression of the integrand for q → 0 can be avoided only for those ann terms in the integrand which contain a closed cycle of G˙ Bij ’s, i.e. a factor ann ann ann G˙ Bi1 i2 G˙ Bi2 i3 · · ·G˙ Bin i1 :
(2.8)
Even then, the cycle can only survive the limit if the indices follow the ordering of the external legs. Of course it is also possible to combine the leading order terms from both Z and the integrand. This produces terms which diverge in the limit. Those are discarded, since they can be identied as being due to an unphysical tachyonic scalar circulating in the loop. In this way one arrives at the Bern–Kosower rules for the gluon loop as given in [21,25]. In the following we will give those rules in a slightly di5erent version, which is more in line with the worldline path integral approach with respect to the treatment of the color algebra. The original string-based approach naturally yields the gluon amplitudes in color-decomposed form, i.e. with the group theory factors expressed in terms of the fundamental instead of the adjoint representation [110,111]. If in the above derivation the gluon vertex operators are taken to be in the fundamental representation, as it was done in [21,25], then the resulting eld theory amplitude represents the so-called “leading color partial amplitude”, where leading refers to the large Nc limit of SU (Nc ) gauge theory. (There is an extra overall factor of Nc in this approach, coming from a second index in the fundamental representation, which is untouched by all the gluon vertex operators, leading to tr(1) = Nc .) The missing subleading amplitudes would be obtained by the inclusion of string theory amplitudes with vertex operator insertions on both boundaries of the annulus, although it turns out that they can also be constructed directly as sums of permutations of the leading color amplitude [112,113]. The form of the spin 1 rules which we give here instead does not use color decomposition; in Eqs. (2.18), (2.19) below, as well as in the remainder of this review, a color matrix T a always refers to the adjoint representation in the gluon loop case. The equivalence of these rules to the original version of [21,25] follows from recent work on the color decomposition [113]. The analogous rules for the spin 12 loop can be derived by repeating the same analysis for the open superstring. Remarkably, this leads to a rule which allows one to infer all contributions from worldsheet fermions to the nal integrand from the purely bosonic terms. This “replacement rule” will play a prominent role in many of our applications. Its validity can be shown to be
90
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
a consequence of worldsheet supersymmetry [66]. For the spin 0 loop, one nds only the rst type of contributions above. 2.2. The Bern–Kosower rules for gluon scattering For the statement of the rules, we rewrite them in the conventions used throughout the remainder of this work. In particular, we work in the Euclidean. The Bern–Kosower rules give a prescription for the construction of integral representations for one-loop photon or gluon scattering amplitudes in non-abelian gauge theory [21]. We write them down here for the case of a non-abelian gauge theory with massless scalars and fermions. To obtain the one-loop on-shell amplitude for the scattering of N gluons, 4 with momenta ki and polarization vectors i , the following steps have to be taken: Step 1: Consider the following kinematic expression:
N
˙ S K= dui exp[GBij ki · kj + iG Bij (ki · j − kj · i ) + G Bij i · j ] ; (2.9) i¡j i=1 multi-linear where “multi-linear” means that only terms linear in each of the 1 ; : : : ; N are to be kept. Step 2: An on-shell gluon has only two physical polarizations, denoted by “+” and “−”. Consider one helicity amplitude at a time, and denote, for example, by A(+; +; −; · · ·; −) the amplitude for the process where the rst two gluons have the same helicity, and all remaining ones the opposite one. Each helicity amplitude is separately gauge invariant, i.e. insensitive to a redenition of any of the polarization vectors by a transformation i± → i± + 4ki :
(2.10)
This freedom can be used to choose—for given external momenta {k1 ; : : : ; kN }—a set of polarization vectors which makes a maximal number of the invariants ki · j and i · j vanish. A systematic way of nding such a set of polarization vectors for a given choice of helicities is provided by the Spinor helicity method (see, e.g., [66,114]). At the end, all surviving invariants are rewritten as functions of the external momenta alone. Step 3: Expand out the kinematic expression, and perform integrations by parts, till all double derivatives of GB are removed (ignore boundary terms). We have now an expression
N
dui Kred exp[GBij ki · kj ] ; (2.11) i=1
i¡j
where Kred , the “reduced kinematic factor”, is a sum of terms that are products of G˙ Bij ’s, and of dot products ki · kj ; ki · j ; i · j . Step 4: Draw all possible labelled 3 1-loop diagrams Di with N external legs (Fig. 9): but excluding tadpoles, and diagrams where the loop is isolated on an external leg (Fig. 10): The labels follow the cyclic ordering of the trace. One also attaches a label to every internal line in the tree part of a diagram; for deniteness, this is taken to be the smallest one of the labels of the two lines into which the line splits to the outward. 4
By “gluon” we denote any non-abelian gauge boson.
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
91
Fig. 9. Diagrams in 3 theory. Fig. 10. Diagrams to be omitted.
Fig. 11. Removal of trees.
Every diagram Di contributes a parameter integral 1 ui ui 1 m −2 D Pi (ui1 ; : : : ; uim ) Di = m − dui1 dui2 · · · duim−1 : m 2 [ − r¡s GBir is Kir · Kis ]m−(D=2) 0 0 0
(2.12)
Here D is the space-time dimension, m is the number of legs directly attached to the loop, and GBir is = GB (uir ; uis ) = |uir − uis | − (uir − uis )2 = (uir − uis ) − (uir − uis )2
(2.13)
(uim = 0): Kir denotes the sum of the external momenta Powing into the tree which enters the loop at the point carrying the label ir . Pi is a polynomial function of the loop parameters, and of the external momenta and polarization vectors; it will be determined in Steps 5 and 6. Step 5: tree replacement rules. Remove all trees, working from the outside of the diagram toward the loop. If the diagram contains a vertex as shown in Fig. 11 keep only those terms in Kred which contain exactly one G˙ Bij . In those, replace G˙ Bij , with i¡j, by 2=k 2 , and replace all remaining G˙ Bjr by G˙ Bir . Repeat this procedure, till only the naked loop is left. Step 6: loop replacement rules. It is only at this stage that one has to distinguish between the scalar, the fermion, and the gluon loop. Scalar loop: Simply write out Kred (i.e. what became of Kred in step 5) in terms of the integration variables, by substituting G˙ Bij → sign(ui − uj ) − 2(ui − uj ) :
(2.14)
Multiply by an overall factor of 2 if the scalar is complex. Spinor loop: Replace simultaneously every closed cycle G˙ Bi1 i2 G˙ Bi2 i3 · · ·G˙ Bik i1 appearing in Kred (which may or may not follow the ordering of the external legs) by G˙ Bi1 i2 G˙ Bi2 i3 · · ·G˙ Bik i1 − GFi1 i2 GFi2 i3 · · ·GFik i1 :
(2.15)
92
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
An expression is considered a cycle already if it can be put into cycle form using the antisymmetry of G˙ B (e.g. G˙ Bij G˙ Bij = − G˙ Bij G˙ Bji ). Then replace all G˙ B ’s as in the scalar case, and all GF ’s by GFij → sign(ui − uj ) :
(2.16)
Multiply by an overall factor of −4 for a Dirac fermion −2 for a Weyl fermion Gluon loop: In this case, there are two types of contributions, which have to be summed: type 1: Replace G˙ Bij as above. type 2: For every closed cycle of G˙ Bij ’s appearing in a term, with the ordering of the indices following the ordering of the external legs, write down one additional contribution, obtained in the following way: replace G˙ Bi1 i2 G˙ Bi2 i1 → 4 ; G˙ Bi1 i2 G˙ Bi2 i3 · · ·G˙ Bik i1 → 2k−1
(k¿2)
(2.17)
and all remaining G˙ B ’s—even those belonging to other cycles—as in the scalar case. Multiply by a factor of 2 for both types. The expression obtained from Kred in this way is the polynomial Pi above. Step 7: Perform the parameter integrations. Techniques for their calculation may be found in [109,115,116]. The four-point case is treated in Appendix E, following [109]. Step 8: Finally the amplitude is given by a sum over all diagrams, with an overall normalization factor (42 )−j=2 a1 ···aN [k1 ; 1 ; : : : ; kN ; N ] = (−ig)N tr(T a1 · · ·T aN ) Di : (2.18) 322 diagrams
Here j = D − 4, and is the usual unit of mass appearing in the dimensional continuation. T ai is a color matrix in the representation of the loop particle. We have specialized to a specic version of dimensional regularization, the so-called four-dimensional helicity scheme [21]. This is only the partial amplitude corresponding to the considered xed ordering of the external states. To obtain the complete amplitude one must still sum over all possible non-cyclic permutations of the states, so that ({ai ; ki ; i }) = a(1) ···a(N ) [k(1) ; (1) ; : : : ; k(N ) ; (N ) ] : (2.19) ∈ SN =ZN
In Section 4 we will explicitly apply these rules to the four-gluon case. See [27,28] for the analogous rules for graviton scattering in quantum gravity. 3. Worldline path integral representations for e&ective actions In this section, we derive worldline path integral representations for a number of one-loop e5ective actions involving some of the most basic interactions in quantum eld theory. Those
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
93
derivations are based on the fact that one-loop e5ective actions can generally be expressed in terms of the determinant of the kinetic operator in eld theory. Using the ln(det) = tr(ln)-formula and the Schwinger proper-time representation, one obtains an integral over the space of all closed trajectories of a quantum mechanical particle moving in spacetime. Generally, to every such closed loop path integral one nds associated a similar open-ended path integral, representing the eld theory propagator of the loop particle in the background eld. The propagator path integral has the same worldline Lagrangian, possibly with some boundary terms added. It is to be performed over the space of trajectories connecting two xed points in spacetime, with appropriate boundary conditions. In the present review we will concentrate on the e5ective action, or closed loop case, simply because almost all explicit calculations which have been done so far pertain to this case. By this we do not mean to imply that propagator path integrals may not play an important role in future extensions of this formalism. Our derivations are mostly formal. Only in the spin-1 loop case will we touch upon the subtle issues connected with the existence of di5erent discretization prescriptions, etc. Those have recently been investigated in much detail for the case of curved backgrounds, a subject which will be shortly discussed in Section 7.2. 3.1. Scalar <eld theory Let us begin with the simplest case of a real massive scalar eld with a self-interaction potential U (). According to standard quantum eld theory (see, e.g., [117]) the Euclidean one-loop e5ective action for this eld theory can be written as 5 − + m2 + U () 1 [] = − Tr ln : (3.1) 2 − + m2 We use the formula ∞ A dT −Tr ln = Tr(e−AT − e−BT ) B T 0
(3.2)
valid for positive denite operators A; B, delete the irrelevant -independent term, and perform the functional trace in x-space. This gives 1 ∞ dT [] = d D xx|exp{−T [ − + m2 + U ((x))]}|x : (3.3) 2 0 T Now compare this with Feynman’s path integral formula for the evolution operator in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. For a particle with mass m˜ moving in a time-independent potential V˜ (x) this formula reads (see, e.g., [118,119]), x(t ) = x t −i(t −t )H ˜ x˙2 −V˜ (x)] x |e |x = Dx(t) ei t dt[(m=2) : (3.4) x(t ) = x
5
We work with relativistic quantum eld theory conventions, ˝ = c = 1. Functional traces are denoted by Tr, nite dimensional traces by tr.
94
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
We can therefore interpret our kinetic operator above as the Hamilton operator H for a ctitious particle moving in D dimensions, p2 + V˜ (x) ; 2m˜ by identifying H=
(3.5)
V˜ (x) = m2 + U ((x)) ; m˜ = 12 ; i(t − t ) = T :
(3.6)
Without retracing the usual path integral discretization procedure [118,119] we can thus immediately write x(T ) = x T 2 2 x| exp{−T [ − + m2 + U ((x))]}|x = Dx()e− 0 d[1=4x˙ +m +U ((x()))] (3.7) x(0) = x
( = it). Taking into account that dD x Dx() = x(0) = x(T ) = x
x(0) = x(T )
Dx() ;
(3.8)
we obtain the desired path integral representation for the e5ective action, T 2 1 ∞ dT −m2 T [] = Dx()e− 0 d(1=4x˙ +U ((x()))) : e 2 0 T x(T ) = x(0)
(3.9)
In a completely analogous way one derives the path integral representation for the scalar propagator in the background eld , ∞ −1 2 x |[ − + m + U ((x))] |x = dT x | exp{−T [ − + m2 + U ((x))]}|x
=
0
∞
2
dT e−m T
0
x(T ) = x
x(0) = x
Dx()e−
T 0
d(1=4x˙2 +U ((x())))
:
(3.10)
3.2. Scalar quantum electrodynamics The path integral for a massive (complex) scalar eld minimally coupled to a background Maxwell eld can also be found simply by recurring to quantum mechanics. The eld theory kinetic operator now reads (9 + ieA)2 − m2
(3.11)
with a ctitious Hamiltonian H=
(p + eA)2 + m2 : 2m˜
(3.12)
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
This translates into −(9 + ieA)2 + m2 1 scal [A] = − Tr ln 2 − + m2 ∞ T 2 dT −m2 T = Dx() e− 0 d(1=4x˙ +iex˙ · A(x())) e T x(T ) = x(0) 0
95
(3.13)
and analogously for the propagator. Note that the global factor of 12 has disappeared, since in taking the trace we have to take the double number of degrees of freedom of the complex scalar into account. 3.3. Spinor quantum electrodynamics For the spin 12 -particle various worldline path integral representations can be found in the literature. The basic choice is between bosonic [29,30] and Grassmann [31– 40] representations. The latter can be derived using either coherent state methods [120,121,102,104] or the “Weyl symbol” method [34,122]. Our following treatment of the spin 12 -case uses the coherent state formalism. We would like to nd a path integral representation for the Euclidean e5ective action 6 spin [A] = ln Det[ p= + e A= − im] :
(3.14)
This time we will not be able to just take over results from quantum mechanics; we have to construct our path integral by brute force. Let us start with the well-known observation that we can rewrite i ( p= + e A=)2 = − (9 + ieA )2 − e F (3.15) 2 ( = 12 [" ; " ]). Using the usual argument that Det[( p= + e A=) − im] = Det[( p= + e A=) + im] = Det1=2 [( p= + e A=)2 + m2 ] ; we can then write the e5ective action in the following form: ∞ 1 dT i 2 2 spin [A] = − Tr : exp −T −(9 + ieA) − e F + m 2 T 2 0
(3.16) (3.17)
Up to the global sign, this is formally identical with the e5ective action for a scalar loop in a background containing, besides the gauge eld A, a potential term i V ≡ − e F : (3.18) 2 We will now use the formalism developed in [120] to transform this functional trace into a quantum mechanical path integral. Our treatment closely parallels the one in [102,104], except − that they work in six dimensions. Dene matrices a+ r and ar , r = 1; 2, by 1 a± 1 = 2 ("1 ± i"3 ); 6
1 a± 2 = 2 ("2 ± i"4 ) :
Our Euclidean Dirac matrix conventions are {" ; " } = 2g 5; "† = " ; "5 = "1 "2 "3 "4 .
(3.19)
96
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
Those satisfy Fermi–Dirac anticommutation rules − {a+ r ; as } = !rs ;
a+ r
Thus we can use vacuum dened by
+ − − {a+ r ; as } = {ar ; as } = 0 :
and
a− r
(3.20)
as creation and annihilation operators for a Hilbert space with a
+ a− r |0 = 0|ar = 0 :
(3.21)
Next we introduce Grassmann variables r and Xr , r = 1; 2, which anticommute with one another and with the operators a± r , and commute with the vacuum |0. The coherent states are then dened as − | ≡ i0|(1 − a− 1 )(2 − a2 )
+ | ≡ exp(−1 a+ 1 − 2 a2 )|0 ;
− X| ≡ 0| exp(−a− 1 X1 − a2 X2 )
+ | ≡ i(X1 − a+ 1 )(X2 − a2 )|0 :
(3.22)
It is easily veried that those satisfy the dening equations for coherent states, |a− r = |r
a− r | = r | |X = exp(1 X1 + 2 X2 ) ;
X|a+ r = X|Xr
a+ r |X = Xr |X X| = exp(X1 1 + X2 2 ) :
Also one introduces the corresponding Grassmann integrals, dened by i di = Xi d Xi = i :
(3.23) (3.24)
The dr ; d Xr commute with one another and with the vacuum, and anticommute with all Grassmann variables and the a± . This leads to the completeness relations r 5 = i || d 2 = − i d 2 X |XX| (3.25) (d 2 = d2 d1 ; d 2 X = d X1 d X2 ), and to the following representation for a trace in the Fock space generated by the a± , r Tr(U ) = i d 2 −|U | : (3.26) We can now apply these fermionic coherent states together with the usual complete sets of coordinate states to rewrite the functional trace in (3.17) in the following way: −T: 4 Tr e = i d x d 2 x; −|e−T: |x; =i
N
N
(d 4 xi d 2 i xi ; i |e−(T=N ): |xi+1 ; i+1 ) ;
(3.27)
i=1
where : = − (9 + ieA)2 + V . The boundary conditions on the x and integrations are (xN +1 ; N +1 ) = (x1 ; −1 ). For the evaluation of this matrix element it will be useful to look rst at the matrix elements of products of Dirac matrices. For the product of two "’s one nds i i+1 |" " | = − i d 2 Xi; i+1 i |Xi; i+1 Xi; i+1 |i+1 2 i i+1 ; = ; (3.28)
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
97
where i+1 1; 2 ≡
1 2
i; i+1 √ (i+1 1; 2 + X1; 2 );
i+1 3; 4 ≡
i
i; i+1 √ (i+1 1; 2 − X1; 2 ) ;
2
1 i i i; i+1 i (3.29) 3; 4 ≡ √ (1; 2 − X1; 2 ) : 2 2 To verify this equation one rewrites the Dirac matrices in terms of the a± r and then inserts a complete set of coherent states |Xi; i+1 in between them. With this information it is now easy to compute that i
1; 2 ≡
√ (i1; 2 + Xi;1;i+1 2 );
xi ; i |e−(T=N ):[p; A; " " ] |xi+1 ; i+1 i i; i+1 i i+1 i; i+1 i i+1 =− d 4 pi; i+1 d 2 Xi; i+1 ei(x −x )p +( − )r Xr 4
(2)
T × 1 − :[pi; i+1 ; Ai; i+1 ; 2i N
i+1 ]
T2 +O N2
:
(3.30)
Here the superscript i; i+1 on a eld denotes the average of the corresponding elds with superscripts i and i +1. Inserting this result back into Eq. (3.27) one obtains, after symmetrizing the positions of the Grassmann variables in the exponentials, Tr e−T: =
1 (2)4N ×exp
N i=1
2 T T d 4 xi d 4 pi; i+1 d 2 i d 2 Xi; i+1 1 − :i + O N N2
N
i
i(x − x
i=1
i+1
)p
i; i+1
1 i 1 i i−1; i i+1 i; i+1 i; i+1 + (r − r )Xr − r (Xr − Xr ) : 2 2
(3.31)
Introducing an interpolating proper-time such that 1 = T , N +1 = 0, and i − i+1 = T=N , and taking the limit N → ∞ in the usual naive way, we nally obtain the following path integral representation, T 1 ˙ 1 −T: Tr e = Dp Dx DDX exp d ix˙ · p + ˙r Xr − r Xr − :[p; A; 2 ] : 2 2 A 0 (3.32) The “A” denotes the antiperiodic boundary conditions which we have for ; . X The continuum limits of Eqs. (3.29) are 1 i (3.33) 1; 2 () = √ (1; 2 () + X1; 2 ()); 3; 4 () = √ (1; 2 () − X1; 2 ()) : 2 2 This suggests a change of variables from ; X to , which we complete by rewriting the fermionic kinetic term 1 ˙ X − 1 r X˙ = − 1 ˙ : (3.34) 2 r r
2
r
2
98
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
The boundary conditions are now (x(T ); (T )) = (x(0); − (0)). Finally, we note that the momentum path integral is Gaussian, and perform it by a naive completion of the square (for a less unscrupulous treatment of this point see again [102,104], as well as for the various normalization factors involved). This brings us to our following nal result: 7 T 1 ∞ dT −m2 T spin [A] = − Dx D e− 0 d Lspin ; (3.35) e 2 0 T P A Lspin = 1 x˙2 + 1 ˙ + iex˙ A − ie F ; (3.36) 4
2
which we already quoted in the introduction, Eq. (1.9). Although in the present review we will be exclusively concerned with four-dimensional eld theories, it should be mentioned that the obtained path integral representation is valid for all even spacetime dimensions. Note also that only the even subspace of the Cli5ord algebra came into play in the above. This is di5erent in the case of an open fermion line, and is the reason why the corresponding path integral representation for the electron propagator in a background eld is signicantly more complicated [38,123,121,39,40,92]. In the introduction it was also mentioned that the worldline Lagrangian (3.36) has a global supersymmetry, (1.10). One consequence of this is that we can make use of a one-dimensional supereld formalism. Introducing √ X = x + 2/ ; (3.37) Y = X − x0 ; 9 9 D= −/ ; 9/ 9 d/ / = 1 ;
(3.38) (3.39) (3.40)
we can combine the x- and -path integrals into the following super path integral [63,124,125,85]: T 1 ∞ dT −m2 T 3 DX e− 0 d d/[−1=4X · D X −ieDX · A(X )] : (3.41) spin [A] = − e 2 0 T Written in this way, the spinor path integral becomes formally analogous to the scalar one, and can be considered as its “supersymmetrization”. Note, however, that the supersymmetry is broken by the di5erent periodicity conditions which we have for the coordinate and the Grassmann path integrals. For a constant Grassmann parameter those are not respected by the supersymmetry transformations (1.10). 3.4. Non-abelian gauge theory 3.4.1. Scalar loop contribution to the gluon e@ective action The simplest non-abelian generalization which one can consider is the contribution to the gluon scattering amplitude due to a scalar loop. Retracing the above derivation of the scalar 7
Our denition of the Euclidean e5ective action di5ers by a sign from the one used in [102,104].
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
99
path integral for photon scattering, one nds that the non-abelian nature of the background eld leads to the following changes in Eq. (1.8): (1) The trace now includes a global color trace. (2) The corresponding quantum mechanical Hamilton operators at di5erent times need not commute any more, so that the exponential must be taken path-ordered. We have thus
scal [A] = tr
∞
0
dT −m2 T e T
Dx()Pe−
T
2 0 d(1=4x˙ +igx˙ · A(x()))
;
(3.42)
where now A = Aa T a . P denotes the path ordering operator, and tr the color trace. 3.4.2. Spinor loop contribution to the gluon e@ective action In addition to these two changes, in the spinor loop case the F appearing in the worldline Lagrangian (3.36) must now be taken to be the full non-abelian eld strength tensor, including the commutator term [A ; A ] [126,127]. One may wonder how this commutator term is to be accommodated in the supereld formalism. As was shown in [125], a very convenient way of doing so is to introduce a super path ordering. The ordinary path ordering can be dened by T 1 T N − 1 T N
−1 N T
P di ≡ N ! d1 d2 · · · dN = N ! d1 · · · dN /(i − i+1 ) : i=1 0
0
0
0
0
0
i=1
(3.43)
The super path ordering is obtained from this simply by replacing the proper-time di5erences in the arguments of the /-functions by super-di5erences, ˆij ≡ i − j + /i /j
(3.44)
so that Pˆ
N
i=1 0
T
di
d/i ≡ N !
0
T
d1
d/1 · · ·
0
T
dN
(here and in the following we use the convention that ing the /-functions one nds /(ˆi(i+1) ) = /(i − i+1 ) + /i /i+1 !(i − i+1 )
d/N
N
N
−1
/(ˆi(i+1) )
(3.45)
i=1
i = 1 d/i
≡ d/1 d/2 · · ·d/N ). Then expand-
(3.46)
and the !-function terms will generate precisely the commutator terms above. With this denition of Pˆ , we can thus generalize Eq. (3.41) to the non-abelian case as ∞ T 1 dT −m2 T 3 DX Pˆ e− 0 d d/[−1=4X · D X −igDX · A(X )] : (3.47) spin [A] = − tr e 2 0 T This remarkable interplay between worldline supersymmetry and spacetime gauge symmetry has recently attracted some attention [128].
100
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
3.4.3. Gluon loop contribution to the gluon e@ective action We proceed to the much more delicate case of the gluon loop, i.e. we wish now to derive a path integral describing a spin-1 particle coupled to a spin-1 background. Here one would expect to run into diNculties. It is well known how to construct free path integrals for particles of arbitrary spin (see, e.g., [129,130]). However, the quantization of those path integrals usually leads to inconsistencies as soon as one tries to couple a path integral with spin higher than 1 2 to a spin-1 background. In [64] this problem had been circumvented by the introduction of auxiliary degrees of freedom, and we will follow a similar approach here [92]. We employ the background gauge xing technique so that the e5ective action [Aa ] becomes a gauge invariant functional of Aa [131,132]. The gauge xed classical action reads, in D dimensions, 1 1 D a a S[a; A] = − d x F (A + a)F (A + a) − d D x(Dab [A]ab )2 : (3.48) 4 2 A priori, the background eld Aa is unrelated to the quantum eld aa . The kinetic operator of the gauge boson Puctuations is obtained as the second functional derivative of S[a; A] with respect to aa , at xed Aa . This leads to the inverse propagator ab ab D = − D?ac D?cb ! − 2igF
(3.49)
and the e5ective action 1 ∞ dT 1 glu [A] = − ln det(D) = (3.50) Tr(e−T D ) : 2 2 0 T In writing down Eq. (3.49) we have adopted the Feynman gauge = 1. The covariant derivative ab ≡ F c (T c )ab are matrices in the adjoint representation D ≡ 9 +igAa T a and the eld strength F 8 of the gauge group. The full e5ective action is obtained by adding the contribution of the Faddeev–Popov ghosts to Eq. (3.50). The evaluation of the ghost determinant proceeds along the same lines as scalar QED, and will be dealt with later on. In order to derive a path integral representation of the heat-kernel Tr(e−T D ) ;
(3.51)
we rst look at a slightly more general problem. We generalize the operator D to hˆ ≡ − D2 ! + M (x) ;
(3.52)
where M (x) is an arbitrary matrix in color space. In particular, we do not assume that the Lorentz trace M is zero. Given M , we construct the following one-particle Hamilton operator Hˆ = (pˆ + gA (x)) ˆ 2 − : X M (x) ˆ ˆ :: (3.53) The system under consideration has a graded phase-space coordinatized by x ; p and two sets of anti-commuting variables, and X , which obey canonical anti-commutation relations ˆ Xˆ + Xˆ ˆ = ! : (3.54)
8
Our denition for the non-abelian covariant derivative is D ≡ 9 + igAa T a , with [T a ; T b ] = ifabc T c . The adjoint representation is given by (T a )bc = − ifabc .
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
101
For a reason which will become obvious in a moment we have adopted the “anti-Wick” ordering in (3.53): all X ’s are on the right of all ’s, e.g. : ˆ Xˆ := ˆ Xˆ ; : Xˆ ˆ := − ˆ Xˆ :
(3.55)
We can represent the commutation relations on a space of wave functions A(x; ) depending on x and a set of classical Grassmann variables . The “position” operators xˆ = x ; ˆ = act multiplicatively on A, the conjugate momenta as derivatives pˆ = − i9 and Xˆ = 9= 9 . Thus the Hamiltonian becomes [133] 9 Hˆ = − D2 + M (x) : (3.56) 9 The wave functions A have a decomposition of the form A(x; ) =
D 1 p=0
p!
(x) (p) 1 ···p
1
···
p
:
(3.57)
This suggests the interpretation of A as an inhomogeneous di5erential form on RD with the fermions playing the role of the di5erentials d x [134,135]. The form-degree or, equivalently, the fermion number is measured by the operator 9 Fˆ = ˆ Xˆ = : (3.58) 9 We are particularly interested in one forms:
A(x; ) = ’ (x)
:
(3.59)
The Hamiltonian (3.56) acts on them according to (Hˆ A)(x; ) = (hˆ ’ )
:
(3.60)
We see that, when restricted to the one-form sector, the quantum system with the Hamiltonian (3.53) is equivalent to the one dened by the bosonic matrix Hamiltonian hˆ [133,135]. The Euclidean proper time evolution of the wave functions A is implemented by the kernel K(x2 ;
2 ; 2 |x1 ;
1 ; 1 ) = x2 ;
−(2 −1 )Hˆ |x1 ; 2 |e
which obeys the SchrSodinger equation 9 + Hˆ K(x; ; T |x0 ; 0 ; 0) = 0 9T
1
;
(3.61) (3.62)
with the initial condition K(x; ; 0|x0 ; 0 ; 0) = !(x − x0 )!( − 0 ). It is easy to write down a path integral solution to Eq. (3.62). For the trace of K one obtains T −T Hˆ W Tr(e )= Dx() D ()D X ()tr Pe− 0 d L (3.63) P
A
102
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
with
1 2 d X ! − M (3.64) L = x˙ + igx˙ A + 4 d (the subscript “W” for H will be explained in a moment). We have again periodic boundary conditions for x (), and anti-periodic ones for (). At this point we have to be careful. If we regard the Hamiltonian (3.53) as a function of the anti-commuting c-numbers and X it is related to the classical Lagrangian (3.64) by a standard Legendre transformation. As is well known, the information about the operator ordering is implicit in the discretization which is used for the denition of the path-integral. Di5erent operator orderings correspond to di5erent discretization prescriptions (see, e.g., [136]). In our derivation of the worldline path integral representation for the spinor loop e5ective action in the previous section we used the so-called midpoint prescription [137] for the discretization. The reason for this choice is that, by Sato’s theorem [138], only in this case the familiar path-integral manipulations are allowed. Those will be needed to justify the naive one-dimensional perturbation expansion which we have in mind. It is known [137–141] that, at the operator level, this is equivalent to using the Weyl ordered Hamiltonian Hˆ W . This is the reason why we wrote Hˆ W rather than Hˆ on the l.h.s. of Eq. (3.63). In order to arrive at relation (3.60) we had to assume that the fermion operators in Hˆ are “anti-Wick” ordered. Weyl ordering amounts to a symmetrization in X and so that Hˆ W = (pˆ + gA (x)) ˆ 2 + 12 M (x)( ˆ ˆ X − X ˆ )
ˆ : = Hˆ − 12 M (x)
(3.65)
In the second line of (3.65) we used (3.53) and (3.54). (With respect to xˆ and pˆ Weyl ordering is used throughout.) If we employ (3.65) in (3.63) we obtain the following representation for the partition function of the anti-Wick ordered exponential: T 1 −T Hˆ X Tr(e )= Dx() D ()D ()tr P exp − d L() + M (x()) : (3.66) 2 P A 0 ˆ which is a generalization of the Let us now calculate the partition function Tr(exp(−T h)) heat-kernel needed in Eq. (3.50). By virtue of Eq. (3.60) we may write ˆ
ˆ
Tr(e−T h ) = Tr 1 (e−T H ) ;
(3.67)
where “Tr 1 ” denotes the trace in the one-form sector of the theory which contains the worldline fermions. In order to perform the projection on the one-form sector we identify M with M = C! − 2igF ; where C is a real constant. As a consequence, Hˆ = Hˆ 0 + C Fˆ
(3.68) (3.69)
with Hˆ 0 ≡ (pˆ + gA (x)) ˆ 2 − 2igF (x) ˆ ˆ X ;
(3.70)
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
103
denoting the Hamiltonian which corresponds to the inverse propagator D. The fermion num ber operator Fˆ ≡ ˆ Xˆ is anti-Wick ordered by denition. Its spectrum consists of the integers p = 0; 1; 2; : : : ; D. Note that M = DC, and that because of the antisymmetry of F the Hamiltonian Hˆ 0 has no ordering ambiguity in its fermionic piece. It will prove useful to apply Eq. (3.66) not to Hˆ directly, but to Hˆ − C = Hˆ 0 + C(Fˆ − 1). This leads to T D ˆ −CT (F−1) −T Hˆ 0 Tr(e e ) = exp −CT −1 Dx() D ()D X ()tr Pe− 0 d Lglu (3.71) 2 P A with
1 d Lglu = x˙2 + igx˙ A + X ! − C − 2igF 4 d
:
(3.72)
After having performed the path integration in (3.71) we shall send C to innity. While this has no e5ect in the one-form sector, it leads to an exponential suppression factor exp[ − CT (p − 1)] in the sectors with fermion numbers p = 2; 3; : : : ; D. Hence only the zero and the one forms survive the limit C → ∞. In order to eliminate the contribution from the zero forms we insert the projector [1 − (−1)Fˆ ]=2 into the trace. It projects on the subspace of odd form degrees, and is easily implemented by combining periodic and anti-periodic boundary conditions for . In this way we arrive at the following representation of the partition function of Hˆ 0 , restricted to the one-form sector: 1 ˆ −T Hˆ 0 −T Hˆ 0 Fˆ −CT (F−1) Tr 1 [e ] = lim Tr (1 − (−1) )e e C →∞ 2 D = lim exp −CT −1 C →∞ 2 T 1 D ()D X ()tr Pe− 0 d Lglu : − (3.73) × Dx() 2 A P P Because Tr(exp(−T D)) = Tr 1 (exp(−T Hˆ 0 )), Eq. (3.73) implies for the e5ective action [64,92] ∞ 1 1 dT D glu [A] = D DX −1 Dx − lim exp −CT 2 C →∞ 0 T 2 2 A P P T 1 2 d X ×tr P exp − d ! − C − 2igF : x˙ + igx˙ A + 4 d 0 (3.74) Note that, from the point of view of the worldline fermions, C plays the role of a mass. The factor exp[ − CTD=2] in (3.74) is due to the di5erence between the Weyl and the anti-Wick-ordered Hamiltonian. It is crucial for obtaining a nite result in the limit C → ∞. In fact, for D = 4 it converts the prefactor eCT to a decaying exponential e−CT . 9 9
This reordering factor was missing in [64], where the change of the sign in D = 4 was instead erroneously attributed to a di5erence between Minkowski and Euclidean spacetime.
104
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
A similar worldline path integral representation can also be written down for the gluon propagator in a background Yang–Mills eld [92]. This may be useful for future extensions of the string-inspired formalism. 4. Calculation of one-loop amplitudes We proceed to the evaluation of worldline path integrals at the one-loop level. As was already mentioned the method used is a very specic one, and analogous to the techniques used in string perturbation theory. All path integrals will be manipulated into Gaussian form, which reduces their evaluation to the calculation of worldline propagators and determinants, and standard combinatorics. Of course there exist many alternatives to this procedure (see, e.g., [48,38,50,52,44,47,53,45]). Those will not be discussed here. While most of the formalism developed here applies to an arbitrary spacetime dimension, or at least to even dimensions, in this review all of our applications will be to four dimensional eld theories (for some calculations in D = 2 see [103], in D = 3 [142]). 4.1. The N -point amplitude in scalar <eld theory At the one-loop level, the worldline formalism has been used for a large variety of purposes. Let us begin with the simplest possible case, the one-loop N -point amplitude in massive 3 -theory. Choosing 4 3 ; 3! in Eq. (3.9), the path integral for the corresponding e5ective action reads T 2 1 ∞ dT −m2 T Dx()e− 0 d(1=4x˙ +4(x())) : [] = e 2 0 T x(T ) = x(0) U () =
We intend to calculate this path integral using the elementary Gauss formula −1 d x e−x · A · x+2b · x ∼(det(A))−1=2 eb · A · b :
(4.1)
(4.2)
(4.3)
As we already explained in the introduction, rst one has to deal with the zero-mode contained in the coordinate path integral Dx(), i.e. the constant loops. This is done by separating o5 the integration over the loop center of mass x0 , which reduces the coordinate path integral to an integral over the relative coordinate y: D x = d x0 D y ; x () = x0 + y () ; T d y () = 0 : 0
(4.4)
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
The e5ective action thereby gets expressed in terms of an e5ective Lagrangian Le5 , = d x0 Le5 (x0 )
105
(4.5)
and Le5 (x0 ) is represented as an integral over the space of all loops with xed common center of mass x0 . In the reduced Hilbert space without the zero mode, the kinetic operator is invertible, and the inverse is easily found using the eigenfunctions of the derivative operator on the circle with circumference T , {e2in =T ; n ∈ Z \ {0}}: −2 ∞ d e2in(1 −2 )=T (1 − 2 )2 T 21 | |2 = 2T = | − | − − (4.6) 1 2 2 d (2in) T 6 n = −∞ n = 0
(1 − 2 ∈ [ − T; T ]). It will be seen later on that the constant −T=6 drops out of all physical results, so that we can delete it at the beginning. The remainder is the “bosonic” Green’s function which we already introduced in Eq. (1.16), GB (1 ; 2 ) = |1 − 2 | −
(1 − 2 )2 : T
Note that it is continuous as a function on S 1 ×S 1 . Its value depends neither on the location of the zero on the circle, nor on the choice of orientation. This Green’s function we will always use as the correlator for the coordinate “eld”, y (1 )y (2 ) = − g GB (1 ; 2 ) :
(4.7)
The zero mode xing prescription, and consequently also the form of this worldline correlator, are not unique [106,107,143,144]. This ambiguity is of some technical importance, and will be discussed in Section 7 in connection with the calculation of the e5ective action itself. The only other information required for the execution of a Gaussian path integral is the free path integral determinant. With our conventions, the free coordinate path integral at xed proper-time T is T 1 Dy exp − d y˙ 2 = (4T )−D=2 : (4.8) 4 0 Here the T -dependence can be easily determined by, e.g., *-function regularization [121], while the factor [4]−D=2 corresponds to the usual loop-counting factor in quantum eld theory. How to continue now depends on whether we wish to compute the e5ective action itself, or the corresponding scattering amplitudes. For the calculation of the e5ective action, one way to proceed after the expansion of the interaction exponential is to Taylor-expand the external eld at the loop center of mass x0 , (x) = ey · 9 (x0 ) :
(4.9)
As we will see in Section 7, this leads to a highly eNcient algorithm [96,106,107,143] for calculating derivative expansions of e5ective actions.
106
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
At the moment we are interested in the calculation of the N -point amplitude, which proceeds somewhat di5erently. According to standard quantum eld theory (see, e.g., [117]), the (one-particle irreducible) N -point function can be obtained from the one-loop e5ective action [] by a N -fold functional di5erentiation with respect to . In x-space, we can implement this operation simply by expanding the interaction exponential to N th order, and inserting appropriate !-functions into the path integral [63]: ∞ T
N T 2 dT −m2 T 1 N 1PI [x1 ; : : : ; xN ] = (−4) Dx di !(x(i ) − xi )e− 0 d(1=4x˙ ) : e 2 T 0 0 i=1
(4.10)
Thus only trajectories running through the prescribed points x1 ; : : : ; xN will contribute to the amplitude. The subscript “1PI” stands for one-particle-irreducible, and needs to be introduced here since, in contrast to the N -photon amplitude treated in the introduction, the N -point function in 3 -theory has also one-particle-reducible contributions. Similarly, the N -point function in momentum space can be obtained by specializing the background to a sum of plane waves, N (x) = eipi · x : (4.11) i=1
Then one picks out the term containing every pi precisely once (compare Eqs. (1.11), (1.12)). This leads to ∞ N 1 dT −m2 T T
N 1PI [p1 ; : : : ; pN ] = (−4) di d x0 Dy e 2 T 0 0 ×exp i
N
pi · x(i ) e−
i=1
T
2 0 d(1=4x˙ )
:
(4.12)
i=1
Note that now every external leg is represented by a scalar vertex operator, Eq. (1.3). 10 Since xi ≡ x(i ) = x0 + y(i ), the x0 -integral just gives momentum conservation N N D d x0 exp ix0 · pi = (2) ! pi : (4.13) i=1
i=1
The y-path integral is now Gaussian, and can be simply calculated by “completing the square”. One obtains the following parameter integral, ∞ dT 1 2 N D 1PI [p1 ; : : : ; pN ] = (−4) (2) ! pi (4T )−D=2 e−m T 2 T 0 N T N
1 × di exp GB (i ; j )pi · pj : (4.14) 2 0 i=1
10
i; j = 1
In our present conventions momenta appearing in vertex operators are ingoing.
C. Schubert / Physics Reports 355 (2001) 73–234
107
Fig. 12. One-loop N -point diagram.
This representation of the one-loop N -point amplitude in 3 -theory appears, as far as is known to the author, rst in [63]. It is the simplest example of a Bern–Kosower type formula. Note that a constant added to GB would drop out immediately on account of momentum conservation. Using momentum conservation this parameter integral can, for any given ordering of the external legs along the loop, be readily transformed into the corresponding standard Feynman parameter integral [21,24,145,146]. To obtain the contribution of the Feynman diagram with the standard ordering of the momenta p1 ; : : : ; pN (Fig. 12), one simply restricts the -integrations