Instructions to authors Aims and scope Physics Reports keeps the active physicist up-to-date on developments in a wide range of topics by publishing timely reviews which are more extensive than just literature surveys but normally less than a full monograph. Each Report deals with one specific subject. These reviews are specialist in nature but contain enough introductory material to make the main points intelligible to a non-specialist. The reader will not only be able to distinguish important developments and trends but will also find a sufficient number of references to the original literature. Submission In principle, papers are written and submitted on the invitation of one of the Editors, although the Editors would be glad to receive suggestions. Proposals for review articles (approximately 500–1000 words) should be sent by the authors to one of the Editors listed below. The Editor will evaluate proposals on the basis of timeliness and relevance and inform the authors as soon as possible. All submitted papers are subject to a refereeing process. Editors J.V. ALLABY (Experimental high-energy physics), EP Division, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland. E-mail:
[email protected] D.D. AWSCHALOM (Experimental condensed matter physics), Department of Physics, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] J.A. BAGGER (High-energy physics), Department of Physics & Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, 3400 North Charles Street, Baltimore MD 21218, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] C.W.J. BEENAKKER (Mesoscopic physics), Instituut–Lorentz, Universiteit Leiden, P.O. Box 9506, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands. E-mail:
[email protected] E. BREZIN (Statistical physics and field theory), Laboratoire de Physique The´orique, Ecole Normale Superieure, 24 rue Lhomond, 75231 Paris Cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected] G.E. BROWN (Nuclear physics), Institute for Theoretical Physics, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, NY 11974, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] D.K. CAMPBELL (Non-linear dynamics), Dean, College of Engineering, Boston University, 44 Cummington Street, Boston, MA 02215, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] G. COMSA (Surfaces and thin films), Institut fur . Physikalische und Theoretische Chemie, Universit.at Bonn, Wegelerstrasse 12, D-53115 Bonn, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] J. EICHLER (Atomic and molecular physics), Hahn-Meitner-Institut Berlin, Abteilung Theoretische Physik, Glienicker Strasse 100, 14109 Berlin, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] M.P. KAMIONKOWSKI (Astrophysics), Theoretical Astrophysics 130-33, California Institute of Technology, 1200 East California Blvd., Pasadena, CA 91125, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
vi
Instructions to authors
M.L. KLEIN (Soft condensed matter physics), Department of Chemistry, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6323, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] A.A. MARADUDIN (Condensed matter physics), Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697-4575, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] D.L. MILLS (Condensed matter physics), Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697-4575, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] R. PETRONZIO (High-energy physics), Dipartimento di Fisica, Universita" di Roma – Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 1, I-00133 Rome, Italy. E-mail:
[email protected] S. PEYERIMHOFF (Molecular physics), Institute of Physical and Theoretical Chemistry, Wegelerstrasse 12, D-53115 Bonn, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] I. PROCACCIA (Statistical mechanics), Department of Chemical Physics, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel. E-mail:
[email protected] E. SACKMANN (Biological physics), Physik-Department E22 (Biophysics Lab.), Technische Universit.at Munchen, . D-85747 Garching, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] A. SCHWIMMER (High-energy physics), Department of Physics of Complex Systems, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel. E-mail:
[email protected] R.N. SUDAN (Plasma physics), Laboratory of Plasma Studies, Cornell University, 369 Upson Hall, Ithaca, NY 14853-7501, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] W. WEISE (Physics of hadrons and nuclei), Institut fur . Theoretische Physik, Physik Department, Technische Universit.at Munchen, . James Franck Strae, D-85748 Garching, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected] Manuscript style guidelines Papers should be written in correct English. Authors with insufficient command of the English language should seek linguistic advice. Manuscripts should be typed on one side of the paper, with double line spacing and a wide margin. The character size should be sufficiently large that all subscripts and superscripts in mathematical expressions are clearly legible. Please note that manuscripts should be accompanied by separate sheets containing: the title, authors’ names and addresses, abstract, PACS codes and keywords, a table of contents, and a list of figure captions and tables. – Address: The name, complete postal address, e-mail address, telephone and fax number of the corresponding author should be indicated on the manuscript. – Abstract: A short informative abstract not exceeding approximately 150 words is required. – PACS codes/keywords: Please supply one or more PACS-1999 classification codes and up to 4 keywords of your own choice for indexing purposes. PACS is available online from our homepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/physrep). References. The list of references may be organized according to the number system or the nameyear (Harvard) system. Number system: [1] M.J. Ablowitz, D.J. Kaup, A.C. Newell and H. Segur, The inverse scattering transform – Fourier analysis for nonlinear problems, Studies in Applied Mathematics 53 (1974) 249–315. [2] M. Abramowitz and I. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions (Dover, New York, 1965).
Instructions to authors
vii
[3] B. Ziegler, in: New Vistas in Electro-nuclear Physics, eds E.L. Tomusiak, H.S. Kaplan and E.T. Dressler (Plenum, New York, 1986) p. 293. A reference should not contain more than one article. Harvard system:
Ablowitz, M.J., D.J. Kaup, A.C. Newell and H. Segur, 1974. The inverse scattering transform – Fourier analysis for nonlinear problems, Studies in Applied Mathematics 53, 249–315. Abramowitz, M. and I. Stegun, 1965, Handbook of Mathematical Functions (Dover, New York). Ziegler, B., 1986, in: New Vistas in Electro-nuclear Physics, eds E.L. Tomusiak, H.S. Kaplan and E.T. Dressler (Plenum, New York) p. 293. Ranking of references. The references in Physics Reports are ranked: crucial references are indicated by three asterisks, very important ones with two, and important references with one. Please indicate in your final version the ranking of the references with the asterisk system. Please use the asterisks sparingly: certainly not more than 15% of all references should be placed in either of the three categories. Formulas. Formulas should be typed or unambiguously written. Special care should be taken of those symbols which might cause confusion. Unusual symbols should be identified in the margin the first time they occur.
Equations should be numbered consecutively throughout the paper or per section, e.g., Eq. (15) or Eq. (2.5). Equations which are referred to should have a number; it is not necessary to number all equations. Figures and tables may be numbered the same way. Footnotes. Footnotes may be typed at the foot of the page where they are alluded to, or collected at the end of the paper on a separate sheet. Please do not mix footnotes with references. Figures. Each figure should be submitted on a separate sheet labeled with the figure number. Line diagrams should be original drawings or laser prints. Photographs should be contrasted originals, or high-resolution laserprints on glossy paper. Photocopies usually do not give good results. The size of the lettering should be proportionate to the details of the figure so as to be legible after reduction. Original figures will be returned to the author only if this is explicitly requested. Colour illustrations. Colour illustrations will be accepted if the use of colour is judged by the Editor to be essential for the presentation. Upon acceptance, the author will be asked to bear part of the extra cost involved in colour reproduction and printing. After acceptance – Proofs: Proofs will be sent to the author by e-mail, 6–8 weeks after receipt of the manuscript. Please note that the proofs have been proofread by the Publisher and only a cursory check by the author is needed; we are unable to accept changes in, or additions to, the edited manuscript at this stage. Your proof corrections should be returned as soon as possible, preferably within two days of receipt by fax, courier or airmail. The Publisher may proceed with publication of no response is received. – Copyright transfer: The author(s) will receive a form with which they can transfer copyright of the article to the Publisher. This transfer will ensure the widest possible dissemination of information. LaTeX manuscripts The Publisher welcomes the receipt of an electronic version of your accepted manuscript (encoded in LATEX). If you have not already supplied the final, revised version of your article (on diskette) to the Journal Editor, you are requested herewith to send a file with the text of the manuscript (after acceptance) by e-mail to the address provided by the Publisher. Please note that no deviations
viii
Instructions to authors
from the version accepted by the Editor of the journal are permissible without the prior and explicit approval by the Editor. Such changes should be clearly indicated on an accompanying printout of the file.
Files sent via electronic mail should be accompanied by a clear identification of the article (name of journal, editor’s reference number) in the ‘‘subject field’’ of the e-mail message. LATEX articles should use the Elsevier document class ‘‘elsart’’, or alternatively the standard document class ‘‘article’’. The Elsevier package (including detailed instructions for LATEX preparation) can be obtained from http://www.elsevier.com/locate/latex. The elsart package consists of the files: ascii.tab (ASCII table), elsart.cls (use this file if you are using LATEX2e, the current version of LATEX), elsart.sty and elsart12.sty (use these two files if you are using LATEX2.09, the previous version of LATEX), instraut.dvi and/or instraut.ps (instruction booklet), readme. Author benefits – Free offprints. For regular articles, the joint authors will receive 25 offprints free of charge of the journal issue containing their contribution; additional copies may be ordered at a reduced rate. – Discount. Contributors to Elsevier Science journals are entitled to a 30% discount on all Elsevier Science books. – Contents Alert. Physics Reports is included in Elsevier’s pre-publication service Contents Alert. Author enquiries For enquiries relating to the submission of articles (including electronic submission), the status of accepted articles through our Online Article Status Information System (OASIS), author Frequently Asked Questions and any other enquiries relating to Elsevier Science, please consult http://www.elsevier.com/locate/authors/ For specific enquiries on the preparation of electronic artwork, consult http://www.elsevier.com/ locate/authorartwork/ Contact details for questions arising after acceptance of an article, especially those relating to proofs, are provided when an article is accepted for publication.
Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Transverse polarisation of quarks in hadrons Vincenzo Baronea; b; ∗ , Alessandro Dragoc , Philip G. Ratcli,ed a Di.S.T.A., Universita del Piemonte Orientale “A. Avogadro”, 15100 Alessandria, Italy Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Universita di Torino, and INFN—Sezione di Torino, 10125 Torino, Italy c Dipartimento di Fisica, Universita di Ferrara and INFN—Sezione di Ferrara, 44100 Ferrara, Italy d Dipartimento di Scienze CC.FF.MM., Universita degli Studi dell’Insubria, sede di Como, 22100 Como, and INFN—Sezione di Milano, 20133 Milano, Italy b
Received May 2001; editor: W: Weise Contents 1. Introduction 1.1. History 1.2. Notation and terminology 1.3. Conventions 2. Longitudinal and transverse polarisation 2.1. Longitudinal polarisation 2.2. Transverse polarisation 2.3. Spin density matrix 3. Quark distributions in DIS 3.1. Deeply inelastic scattering 3.2. The parton model 3.3. Polarised DIS in the parton model 3.4. Transversely polarised targets 3.5. Transverse polarisation distributions of quarks in DIS 4. Systematics of quark distribution functions 4.1. The quark–quark correlation matrix 4.2. Leading-twist distribution functions 4.3. Probabilistic interpretation of distribution functions 4.4. Vector, axial and tensor charges
3 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 13 19 23 23 25 27 27 28 31 33
4.5. Quark–nucleon helicity amplitudes 4.6. The So,er inequality 4.7. Transverse motion of quarks 4.8. T -odd distributions 4.9. Twist-three distributions 4.10. Sum rules for the transversity distributions 5. Transversity distributions in quantum chromodynamics 5.1. The renormalisation group equations 5.2. QCD evolution at leading order 5.3. QCD evolution at next-to-leading order 5.4. Evolution of the transversity distributions 5.5. Evolution of the So,er inequality and general positivity constraints 6. Transversity in semi-inclusive leptoproduction 6.1. De?nitions and kinematics 6.2. The parton model 6.3. Systematics of fragmentation functions
34 36 37 40 42 45 45 46 48 52 57 61 64 64 67 69
∗ Corresponding author. Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, UniversitBa di Torino and INFN, Sezione di Torino, 10125 Torino, Italy. E-mail address:
[email protected] (V. Barone).
c 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. 0370-1573/02/$ - see front matter PII: S 0 3 7 0 - 1 5 7 3 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 0 5 1 - 5
2
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168 6.4. T -dependent fragmentation functions 6.5. Cross-sections and asymmetries in semi-inclusive leptoproduction 6.6. Semi-inclusive leptoproduction at twist-three 6.7. Factorisation in semi-inclusive leptoproduction 6.8. Two-hadron leptoproduction 6.9. Leptoproduction of spin-1 hadrons 6.10. Transversity in exclusive leptoproduction processes 7. Transversity in hadronic reactions 7.1. Double-spin transverse asymmetries 7.2. The Drell–Yan process 7.3. Factorisation in Drell–Yan processes 7.4. Single-spin transverse asymmetries 8. Model calculations of transverse polarisation distributions 8.1. Bag-like models 8.2. Chiral models 8.3. Light-cone models
73 77 82 83 90 96 97 98 98 99 104 113 118 119 127 133
8.4. Spectator models 8.5. Non-perturbative QCD calculations 8.6. Tensor charges: summary of results 9. Phenomenology of transversity 9.1. Transverse polarisation in hadron– hadron collisions 9.2. Transverse polarisation in lepton– nucleon collisions 9.3. Transverse polarisation in e+ e− collisions 10. Experimental perspectives 10.1. ‘N experiments 10.2. pp experiments 11. Conclusions Acknowledgements Appendix A. Sudakov decomposition of vectors Appendix B. Reference frames B.1. The ∗ N collinear frames B.2. The hN collinear frames Appendix C. Mellin moment identities References
137 137 139 141 141 147 154 155 155 156 157 158 158 159 159 160 161 161
Abstract We review the present state of knowledge regarding the transverse polarisation (or transversity) distributions of quarks. After some generalities on transverse polarisation, we formally de?ne the transversity distributions within the framework of a classi?cation of all leading-twist distribution functions. We describe the QCD evolution of transversity at leading and next-to-leading order. A comprehensive treatment of non-perturbative calculations of transversity distributions (within the framework of quark models, lattice QCD and QCD sum rules) is presented. The phenomenology of transversity (in particular, in Drell–Yan processes and semi-inclusive leptoproduction) is discussed in some detail. Finally, the prospects c 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. for future measurements are outlined. PACS: 13.85.Qk; 12.38.Bx; 13.88.+e; 14.20.Dh Keywords: Transversity; Polarisation; Spin; QCD; Scattering
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
3
1. Introduction There has been, in the past, a common prejudice that all transverse spin e,ects should be suppressed at high energies. While there is some basis to such a belief, it is far from the entire truth and is certainly misleading as a general statement. The main point to bear in mind is the distinction between transverse polarisation itself and its measurable e>ects. As well-known, even the ultra-relativistic electrons and positrons of the LEP storage ring are signi?cantly polarised in the transverse plane [1] due to the Sokolov–Ternov e,ect [2]. Thus, the real problem is to identify processes sensitive to such polarisation: while this is not always easy, it is certainly not impossible. Historically, the ?rst extensive discussion of transverse spin e,ects in high-energy hadronic physics followed the discovery in 1976 that hyperons produced in pN interactions even at relatively high pT exhibit an anomalously large transverse polarisation [3]. 1 This result implies a non-zero imaginary part of the o,-diagonal elements of the fragmentation matrix of quarks into hyperons. It was soon pointed out that this is forbidden in leading-twist quantum chromodynamics (QCD), and arises only as a O(1=pT ) e,ect [6 –8]. It thus took a while to fully realise that transverse spin phenomena are sometimes unsuppressed and observable. 2 The subject of this report is the transverse polarisation of quarks. This is an elusive and diKcult to observe property that has escaped the attention of physicists for many years. Transverse polarisation of quarks is not, in fact, probed in the cleanest hard process, namely deeply inelastic scattering (DIS), but is measurable in other hard reactions, such as semi-inclusive leptoproduction or Drell–Yan dimuon production. At leading-twist level, the quark structure of hadrons is described by three distribution functions: the number density, or unpolarised distribution, f(x); the longitudinal polarisation, or helicity, distribution Lf(x); and the transverse polarisation, or transversity, distribution LT f(x). The ?rst two are well-known quantities: f(x) is the probability of ?nding a quark with a fraction x of the longitudinal momentum of the parent hadron, regardless of its spin orientation; Lf(x) measures the net helicity of a quark in a longitudinally polarised hadron, that is, the number density of quarks with momentum fraction x and spin parallel to that of the hadron minus the number density of quarks with the same momentum fraction but spin antiparallel. If we call f± (x) the number densities of quarks with helicity ±1, then we have f(x) = f+ (x) + f− (x);
(1.0.1a)
Lf(x) = f+ (x) − f− (x):
(1.0.1b)
The third distribution function, LT f(x), although less familiar, also has a very simple meaning. In a transversely polarised hadron LT f(x) is the number density of quarks with momentum fraction x and polarisation parallel to that of the hadron, minus the number density of quarks 1
An issue related to hadronic transverse spin, and investigated theoretically in the same period, is the g2 spin structure function [4,5]; we shall discuss its relation to transversity later. 2 This was pointed out in the pioneering paper of Ralston and Soper [9] on longitudinally and transversely polarised Drell–Yan processes, but the idea remained almost unnoticed for a decade, see below.
4
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
with the same momentum fraction and antiparallel polarisation, i.e., 3 LT f(x) = f↑ (x) − f↓ (x):
(1.0.2)
In a basis of transverse polarisation states LT f too has a probabilistic interpretation. In the helicity basis, in contrast, it has no simple meaning, being related to an o,-diagonal quark-hadron amplitude. Formally, quark distribution functions are light-cone Fourier transforms of connected matrix elements of certain quark-?eld bilinears. In particular, as we shall see in detail (see Section 4.2), LT f is given by (we take a hadron moving in the z direction and polarised along the x-axis) d− ixP+ − LT f(x) = PS | N (0)i1+ 5 (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS : (1.0.3) e 4 In the parton model the quark ?elds appearing in (1.0.3) are free ?elds. In QCD they must be renormalised (see Section 5.1). This introduces a renormalisation-scale dependence into the parton distributions: f(x); Lf(x); LT f(x) → f(x; 2 ); Lf(x; 2 ); LT f(x; 2 );
(1.0.4)
which is governed by the Dokshitzer–Gribov–Lipatov–Altarelli–Parisi [10 –13] (DGLAP) equations (see Section 5). It is important to appreciate that LT f(x) is a leading-twist quantity. Hence it enjoys the same status as f(x) and Lf(x) and, a priori, there is no reason that it should be much smaller than its helicity counterpart. In fact, model calculations show that LT f(x) and Lf(x) are typically of the same order of magnitude, at least at low Q2 , where model pictures hold (see Section 8). The QCD evolution of LT f(x) and Lf(x) is, however, quite di,erent (see Section 5.4). In particular, at low x; LT f(x) turns out to be suppressed with respect to Lf(x). As we shall see, this behaviour has important consequences for some observables. Another peculiarity of LT f(x) is that it has no gluonic counterpart (in spin- 12 hadrons): gluon transversity distributions for nucleons do not exist (Section 4.5). Thus LT f(x) does not mix with gluons in its evolution, and evolves as a non-singlet quantity. One may wonder why the transverse polarisation distributions are so little known, if they are quantitatively comparable to the helicity distributions. No experimental information on LT f(x) is indeed available at present (see, however, Section 9.2.2, where mention is made of some preliminary data on pion leptoproduction that might involve LT f(x)). The reason has already been mentioned: transversity distributions are not observable in fully inclusive DIS, the process that has provided most of the information on the other distributions. Examining the operator structure in (1.0.3) one can see that LT f(x), in contrast to f(x) and Lf(x), which contain + and + 5 instead of i1+ 5 , is a chirally-odd quantity (see Fig. 1a). Now, fully inclusive DIS proceeds via the so-called handbag diagram which cannot Pip the chirality of the probed quark 3
Throughout this paper the subscripts ± will denote helicity whereas the subscripts ↑↓ will denote transverse polarisation.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
5
Fig. 1. (a) Representation of the chirally odd distribution LT f(x). (b) A handbag diagram forbidden by chirality conservation.
(see Fig. 1b). In order to measure LT f the chirality must be Pipped twice, so one needs either two hadrons in the initial state (hadron–hadron collisions), or one hadron in the initial state and one in the ?nal state (semi-inclusive leptoproduction), and at least one of these two hadrons must be transversely polarised. The experimental study of these processes has just started and will provide in the near future a great wealth of data (Section 9). So far we have discussed the distributions f(x); Lf(x) and LT f(x). If quarks are perfectly collinear, these three quantities exhaust the information on the internal dynamics of hadrons. If we admit instead a ?nite quark transverse momentum k⊥ , the number of distribution functions increases (Section 4.7). At leading twist, assuming time-reversal invariance, there are six k⊥ -dependent distributions. Three of them, called in the Ja,e–Ji–Mulders clas2 ), g (x; k2 ) and h (x; k2 ), upon integration over k2 , yield si?cation scheme [14,15] f1 (x; k⊥ 1L 1 ⊥ ⊥ ⊥ f(x), Lf(x) and LT f(x), respectively. The remaining three distributions are new and disappear when the hadronic tensor is integrated over k⊥ , as is the case in DIS. Mulders has called 2 ), h⊥ (x; k2 ) and h⊥ (x; k2 ). If time-reversal invariance is not applied (for the them g1T (x; k⊥ 1L 1T ⊥ ⊥ physical motivation behind this, see Section 4.8), two more, T -odd, k⊥ -dependent distribution ⊥ (x; k2 ) and h⊥ (x; k2 ). At present the existence of these distributions functions appear [16]: f1T 1 ⊥ ⊥ is merely conjectural. To summarise, here is an overall list of the leading-twist quark distribution functions: k⊥ -dependent no k⊥ ⊥ ⊥ ⊥ ⊥ f; Lf; LT f; g1T ; h1L ; h1T ; f1T ;h : 1 T -odd At higher twist the proliferation of distribution functions continues [14,15]. Although, for the sake of completeness, we shall also briePy discuss the k⊥ -dependent and the twist-three distributions, most of our attention will be directed to LT f(x). Less space will be dedicated to the other transverse polarisation distributions, many of which have, at present, only an academic interest. In hadron production processes, which, as mentioned above, play an important rˆole in the study of transversity, there appear other dynamical quantities: fragmentation functions. These are in a sense specular to distribution functions, and represent the probability for a quark in a given polarisation state to fragment into a hadron carrying some momentum fraction z. When
6
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
the quark is transversely polarised and so too is the produced hadron, the process is described by the leading-twist fragmentation function LT D(z), which is the analogue of LT f(x) (see Section 6.3). A T -odd fragmentation function, usually called H1⊥ (z), describes instead the production of unpolarised (or spinless) hadrons from transversely polarised quarks, and couples to LT f(x) in certain semi-inclusive processes of great relevance for the phenomenology of transversity (the emergence of LT f via its coupling to H1⊥ is known as the Collins effect [17]). The fragmentation of transversely polarised quarks will be described in detail in Sections 6 and 7. 1.1. History The transverse polarisation distributions were ?rst introduced in 1979 by Ralston and Soper in their seminal work on Drell–Yan production with polarised beams [9]. In that paper LT f(x) was called hT (x). This quantity was apparently forgotten for about a decade, until the beginning of nineties, when it was rediscovered by Artru and Mekh? [18], who called it L1 q(x) and studied its QCD evolution, and also by Ja,e and Ji [14,19], who renamed it h1 (x) in the framework of a general classi?cation of all leading-twist and higher-twist parton distribution functions. At about the same time, other important studies of the transverse polarisation distributions exploring the possibility of measuring them in hadron–hadron or lepton–hadron collisions were carried out by Cortes et al. [20], and by Ji [21]. The last few years have witnessed a great revival of interest in the transverse polarisation distributions. A major e,ort has been devoted to investigating their structure using more and more sophisticated model calculations and other non-perturbative tools (QCD sum rules, lattice QCD, etc.). Their QCD evolution has been calculated up to next-to-leading order (NLO). The related phenomenology has been explored in detail: many suggestions for measuring (or at least detecting) transverse polarisation distributions have been put forward and a number of predictions for observables containing LT f are now available. We can say that our theoretical knowledge of the transversity distributions is by now nearly comparable to that of the helicity distributions. What is really called for is an experimental study of the subject. On the experimental side, in fact, the history of transverse polarisation distributions is readily summarised: (almost) no measurements of LT f have been performed as yet. Probing quark transverse polarisation is among the goals of a number of ongoing or future experiments. At the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) LT f can be extracted from the measurement of the double-spin transverse asymmetry in Drell–Yan dimuon production with two transversely polarised hadron beams [22] (Section 10.2). Another important class of reactions that can probe transverse polarisation distributions is semi-inclusive DIS. The HERMES collaboration at HERA [23] and the SMC collaboration at CERN [24] have recently presented results on single-spin transverse asymmetries, which could be related to the transverse polarisation distributions via the hypothetical Collins mechanism [17] (Section 9.2.2). The study of transversity in semi-inclusive DIS is one of the aims of the upgraded HERMES experiment and of the COMPASS experiment at the CERN SPS collider, which started taking data in 2001 [25]. It also represents a signi?cant part of other projects (see Section 10.1). We may therefore say that the experimental study of transverse polarisation distributions, which is right now only at the very beginning, promises to have an exciting future.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
7
1.2. Notation and terminology Transverse polarisation of quarks is a relatively young and still unsettled subject, hence it is not surprising that the terminology is rather confused. Notation that has been used in the past for the transverse polarisation of quarks comprises hT (x) L1 q(x)
(Ralston and Soper); (Artru and Mekh?);
h1 (x) (Ja,e and Ji); The ?rst two forms are now obsolete while the third is still widely employed. This last was introduced by Ja,e and Ji in their classi?cation of all twist-two, twist-three and twist-four parton distribution functions. In the Ja,e–Ji scheme, f1 (x); g1 (x) and h1 (x) are the unpolarised, longitudinally polarised and transversely polarised distribution functions, respectively, with the subscript 1 denoting leading-twist quantities. The main disadvantage of this nomenclature is the use of g1 to denote a leading-twist distribution function whereas the same notation is universally adopted for one of the two polarised structure functions. This is a serious source of confusion. In the most recent literature the transverse polarisation distributions are often called q(x) or LT q(x): Both forms appear quite natural, as they emphasise the parallel between the longitudinal and the transverse polarisation distributions. In this report we shall use LT f, or LT q, to denote the transverse polarisation distributions, reserving q for the tensor charge (the ?rst moment of LT q). The Ja,e–Ji classi?cation scheme has been extended by Mulders and collaborators [15,16] to all twist-two and twist-three k⊥ -dependent distribution functions. The letters f, g and h denote unpolarised, longitudinally polarised, and transversely polarised quark distributions, respectively. A subscript 1 labels the leading-twist quantities. Subscripts L and T indicate that the parent hadron is longitudinally or transversely polarised. Finally, a superscript ⊥ signals the presence of transverse momenta with uncontracted Lorentz indices. In the present paper we adopt a hybrid terminology. We use the traditional notation for the k⊥ -integrated distribution functions: f(x), or q(x), for the number density, Lf(x), or Lq(x), for the helicity distributions, LT f(x), or LT q(x), for the transverse polarisation distributions, ⊥ ⊥ and Mulders’ notation for the additional k⊥ -dependent distribution functions: g1T , h⊥ 1L , h1T , f1T ⊥ and h1 . We make the same choice for the fragmentation functions. We call the ⊥ -integrated fragmentation functions D(z) (unpolarised), LD(z) (longitudinally polarised) and LT D(z) (transversely polarised). For the ⊥ -dependent functions we use Mulders’ terminology. Occasionally, other notation will be introduced, for the sake of clarity, or to maintain contact with the literature on the subject. In particular, we shall follow these rules: • the subscripts 0; L; T in the distribution and fragmentation functions denote the polarisation
state of the quark (0 indicates unpolarised, and the subscript L is actually omitted in the familiar helicity distribution and fragmentation functions); • the superscripts 0; L; T denote the polarisation state of the parent hadron.
8
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168 Table 1 Notation for the distribution and the fragmentation functions (JJM denotes the Ja,e– Ji–Mulders classi?cation Distribution functions
Fragmentation functions
JJM
This paper
JJM
This paper
f1 g1 h1 g1T
f; q Lf; Lq LT f; LT q g1T
D1 G1 H1 G1T
D LD LT D G1T
h⊥ 1L
h⊥ 1L
⊥ H1L
⊥ H1L
h⊥ 1T
h⊥ 1T
⊥ H1T
⊥ H1T
f1T⊥
f1T⊥ ; LT0 f
⊥ D1T
⊥ D1T
h⊥ 1
0 h⊥ 1 ; LT f
H1⊥
H1⊥ ; L0T D
Thus, for instance, LLT f represents the distribution function of transversely polarised quarks in a longitudinally polarised hadron (it is related to Mulders’ h⊥ 1L ). The Ja,e–Ji–Mulders terminology is compared to ours in Table 1. The correspondence with other notation encountered in the literature [26,27] is LN fq=N ↑ ≡ LT0 f; LN fq↑ =N ≡ L0T f; LN Dh=q↑ ≡ 2L0T Dh=q : Finally, we recall that the name transversity, as a synonym for transverse polarisation, was proposed by Ja,e and Ji [19]. In [28,29] it was noted that “transversity” is a pre-existing term in spin physics, with a di,erent meaning, and that its use therefore in a di,erent context might cause confusion. In this report we shall ignore this problem, and use both terms, “transverse polarisation distributions” and “transversity distributions” with the same meaning. 1.3. Conventions We now list some further conventions adopted throughout the paper. The metric tensor is g = g = diag(+1; −1; −1; −1): The totally antisymmetric tensor 0123
=−
0123 =
A generic four-vector
!
(1.3.1) is normalised so that
+ 1: A
(1.3.2)
is written, in Cartesian contravariant components, as
A = (A0 ; A1 ; A2 ; A3 ) = (A0 ; A):
(1.3.3)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
The light-cone components of A are de?ned as 1 A± = √ (A0 ± A3 ); 2 and in these components A is written as
9
(1.3.4)
A = (A+ ; A− ; A⊥ ):
(1.3.5)
The norm of A is given by A2 = (A0 )2 − A2 = 2A+ A− − A2⊥ and the scalar product of two four-vectors
(1.3.6) A
and
B
is
A · B = A0 B0 − A · B = A+ B− + A− B+ − A⊥ · B⊥ :
(1.3.7)
Our fermionic states are normalised as p|p = (2)3 2E3 (p − p ) = (2)3 2p+ (p+ − p+ )(p⊥ − p⊥ );
(1.3.8)
u(p; s) u(p; s ) = 2p ss
(1.3.9)
with E = (p2 +m2 )1=2 . The creation and annihilation operators satisfy the anticommutator relations {b(p; s); b† (p ; s )} = {d(p; s); d† (p ; s )} = (2)3 2Ess 3 (p − p ):
(1.3.10)
2. Longitudinal and transverse polarisation The representations of the PoincarVe group are labelled by the eigenvalues of two Casimir operators, P 2 and W 2 (see e.g., [30]). P is the energy-momentum operator, W is the Pauli– Lubanski operator, constructed from P and the angular-momentum operator J W = −
1 ! J! P : 2 eigenvalues of P 2 and
(2.0.1)
W 2 are m2 and −m2 s(s + 1) respectively, where m is the mass of The the particle and s its spin. The states of a Dirac particle (s = 1=2) are eigenvectors of P and of the polarisation operator , ≡ −W · s=m P |p; s = p |p; s; W ·s 1 |p; s = ± |p; s; m 2 where s is the spin (or polarisation) vector of the particle, with the properties −
s2 = − 1; In general,
s · p = 0:
(2.0.2) (2.0.3) (2.0.4)
s
may be written as p·n (p · n)p ; s = ;n + m m(m + p0 ) where n is a unit vector identifying a generic space direction.
(2.0.5)
10
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
The polarisation operator , can be re-expressed as 1 ,= 5 s=p= 2m and if we write the plane-wave solutions of the free Dirac equation in the form e−ip·x u(p) (positive energy); (x) = e+ip·x v(p) (negative energy);
(2.0.6)
(2.0.7)
with the condition p0 ¿0, , becomes , = + 12 5 s=
(positive-energy states);
(2.0.8a)
when acting on positive-energy states, (p= − m)u(p) = 0, and , = − 12 5 s=
(negative-energy states);
(2.0.8b)
when acting on negative-energy states, (p= + m)v(p) = 0. Thus the eigenvalue equations for the polarisation operator read (/ = 1; 2) ,u(/) = + 12 5 s=u(/) = ± 12 u(/)
(positive energy);
,v(/) = − 12 5 s=v(/) = ± 12 v(/)
(negative energy):
(2.0.9)
Let us consider now particles which are at rest in a given frame. The spin s is then (set p = 0 in Eq. (2.0.5)) s = (0; n)
(2.0.10)
and in the Dirac representation we have the operator 0 ·n 1 5 s= = 2 0 − · n acting on u(/) =
’(/) 0
;
v(/) =
0 1(/)
(2.0.11)
:
(2.0.12)
Hence the spinors u(1) and v(1) represent particles with spin 12 · n = + 12 in their rest frame whereas the spinors u(2) and v(2) represent particles with spin 12 ·n = − 12 in their rest frame. Note that the polarisation operator in the form (2.0.8a), (2.0.8b), is also well de?ned for massless particles. 2.1. Longitudinal polarisation For a longitudinally polarised particle (n = p= |p|), the spin vector reads |p| p0 p s = ; m m |p|
(2.1.1)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
11
and the polarisation operator becomes the helicity operator ,=
·p ; 2|p|
(2.1.2)
with = 5 0 . Consistently with Eq. (2.0.7), the helicity states satisfy the equations ·p u± (p) = ± u± (p); |p| ·p v± (p) = ∓ v± (p): |p|
(2.1.3)
Here the subscript + indicates positive helicity, that is spin parallel to the momentum ( · p¿0 for positive-energy states, ·p¡0 for negative-energy states); the subscript − indicates negative helicity, that is spin antiparallel to the momentum (·p¡0 for positive-energy states, ·p¿0 for negative-energy states). The correspondence with the spinors u(/) and v(/) previously introduced is: u+ = u(1) , u− = u(2) , v+ = v(2) , v− = v(1) . In the case of massless particles one has ,=
·p 1 = 5 : 2|p| 2
(2.1.4)
Denoting again by u± ; v± the helicity eigenstates, Eqs. (2.1.3) become for zero-mass particles 5 u± (p) = ± u± (p); 5 v± (p) = ∓ v± (p):
(2.1.5)
Thus helicity coincides with chirality for positive-energy states, while it is opposite to chirality for negative-energy states. The helicity projectors for massless particles are then 1 (1 ± 5 ) positive-energy states; (2.1.6) P± = 21 2 (1 ∓ 5 ) negative-energy states: 2.2. Transverse polarisation Let us come now to the case of transversely polarised particles. With n · p = 0 and assuming that the particle moves along the z direction, the spin vector (2.0.5) becomes, in Cartesian components s = s⊥ = (0; n⊥ ; 0);
where n⊥ is a transverse two-vector. The polarisation operator takes the form 1 − 2 5 ⊥ · n⊥ = 12 0 ⊥ · n⊥ (positive-energy states); ,= 1 1 (negative-energy states) 2 5 ⊥ · n⊥ = − 2 0 ⊥ · n⊥
(2.2.1)
(2.2.2)
12
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
and its eigenvalue equations are 1 =⊥ u↑↓ = 2 5 s
± 12 u↑↓ ;
1 =⊥ v↑↓ = 2 5 s
∓ 12 v↑↓ :
(2.2.3)
The transverse polarisation projectors along the directions x and y are (x)
P↑↓ = 12 (1 ± 1 5 ); (y)
P↑↓ = 12 (1 ± 2 5 )
(2.2.4)
for positive-energy states, and (x)
P↑↓ = 12 (1 ∓ 1 5 ); (y)
P↑↓ = 12 (1 ∓ 2 5 )
for negative-energy states. The relations between transverse wave functions) u(x) = (1= √2)(u+ + u− ); ↑ u(x) = (1= √2)(u+ − u− ); ↓
(2.2.5) polarisation states and helicity states are (for positive-energy u(y) = (1= √2)(u+ + iu− ); ↑ u(y) = (1= √2)(u+ − iu− ): ↓
(2.2.6)
2.3. Spin density matrix The spinor u(p; s) of a particle with polarisation vector s satis?es u(p; s)u(p; s) = (p= + m) 12 (1 + 5 s=): If the particle is at rest then s = (0; s) = (0; s⊥ ; 5) and (2.3.1) gives 1
1 2 (1 + · s) 0 : u(p; s)u(p; s) = 2m 0 0
(2.3.1)
(2.3.2)
Here one recognises the spin density matrix for a spin-half particle ! = 12 (1 + · s):
(2.3.3)
This matrix provides a general description of the spin structure of a system, that is also valid when the system is not in a pure state. The polarisation vector s = (5; s⊥ ) is, in general, such that s2 6 1: in particular it is s2 = 1 for pure states, s2 ¡1 for mixtures. Explicitly, ! reads 1 + 5 sx − isy 1 != : (2.3.4) 2 sx + isy 1 − 5
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
13
The entries of the spin density matrix have an obvious probabilistic interpretation. If we call Pm (nˆ) the probability that the spin component in the nˆ direction is m, we can write 5 = P1=2 (z) ˆ − P−1=2 (z); ˆ sx = P1=2 (x) ˆ − P−1=2 (x); ˆ sy = P1=2 (y) ˆ − P−1=2 (y): ˆ In the high-energy limit the polarisation vector is p ; s = 5 + s⊥ m where 5 is (twice) the helicity of the particle. Thus we have
(2.3.5) (2.3.6)
(1 + 5 s=)(p= + m) = (1 + 5 5 + 5 s=⊥ )(p= + m); (1 + 5 s=)(m − p=) = (1 − 5 5 + 5 s=⊥ )(m − p=)
(2.3.7)
and the projector (2.3.1) becomes (with m → 0) u(p; s)u(p; s) = 12 p=(1 − 5 5 + 5 s=⊥ ):
(2.3.8)
If u5 (p) are helicity spinors, calling !55 the elements of the spin density matrix, one has 1 =(1 2p
− 5 5 + 5 s=⊥ ) = !55 u5 (p)u 5 (p);
(2.3.9)
where the r.h.s. is a trace in helicity space. 3. Quark distributions in DIS Although the transverse polarisation distributions cannot be probed in fully inclusive DIS for the reasons mentioned in the Introduction, it is convenient to start from this process to illustrate the ?eld-theoretical de?nitions of quark (and antiquark) distribution functions. In this manner, we shall see why the transversity distributions LT f decouple from DIS even when quark masses are taken into account (which would in principle allow chirality-Pip distributions). We start by reviewing some well-known features of DIS (for an exhaustive treatment of the subject see e.g., [31]). 3.1. Deeply inelastic scattering Consider the inclusive lepton–nucleon scattering (see Fig. 2, where the dominance of onephoton exchange is assumed) l(‘) + N (P) → l (‘ ) + X (PX );
(3.1.1)
where X is an undetected hadronic system (in brackets we put the four-momenta of the particles). Our notation is as follows: M is the nucleon mass, m‘ the lepton mass, s‘ (s‘ ) the spin
14
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 2. Deeply inelastic scattering.
four-vector of the incoming (outgoing) lepton, S the spin four-vector of the nucleon, ‘ = (E; ‘), and ‘ = (E ; ‘ ) the lepton four-momenta. Two kinematic variables (besides the centre-of mass energy s = (‘ + P)2 , or, alternatively, the lepton beam energy E) are needed to describe reaction (3.1.1). They can be chosen among the following invariants (unless otherwise stated, we neglect lepton masses): q2 = (‘ − ‘ )2 = − 2EE (1 − cos #); =
P·q ; M
Q2 Q2 = (the Bjorken x); 2P · q 2M P·q y= ; P·‘ where # is the scattering angle. The photon momentum q is a spacelike four-vector and one usually introduces the quantity Q2 ≡ −q2 , which is positive. Both the Bjorken variable x and the inelasticity y take on values between 0 and 1. They are related to Q2 by xy = Q2 =(s − M 2 ). The DIS cross-section is x=
d =
d 3 ‘ 1 e4 L W 2 ; 4‘ · P Q4 (2)3 2E
(3.1.2)
where the leptonic tensor L is de?ned as (lepton masses are retained here) L = [ul (‘ ; sl ) ul (‘; sl )]∗ [u l (‘ ; sl ) ul (‘; sl )] sl
= Tr[(‘= + ml ) 12 (1 + 5 s=l ) (‘= + ml ) ]
(3.1.3)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
and the hadronic tensor W is d 3 PX 1 W = (2)4 4 (P + q − PX )PS |J (0)|X X |J (0)|PS : 2 X (2)3 2EX Using translational invariance this can be also written as 1 W = d 4 eiq· PS |J ()J (0)|PS : 2
15
(3.1.4)
(3.1.5)
It is important to recall that the matrix elements in (3.1.5) are connected. Therefore, vacuum transitions of the form 0|J ()J (0)|0PS |PS are excluded. Note that in (3.1.3) and (3.1.4) we summed over the ?nal lepton spin but did not average over the initial lepton spin, nor sum over the hadron spin. Thus we are describing, in general, the scattering of polarised leptons on a polarised target, with no measurement of the outgoing lepton polarisation (for comprehensive reviews on polarised DIS see [29,32,33]). In the target rest frame, where ‘ · P = ME, (3.1.2) reads 2 E d /em = L W ; dE d: 2MQ4 E
(3.1.6)
where d: = d cos # d’. The leptonic tensor L can be decomposed into a symmetric and an antisymmetric part under ↔ interchange (A) L = L(S) (‘; ‘ ) + iL (‘; sl ; ‘ );
(3.1.7)
and, computing the trace in (3.1.3), we obtain L(S) = 2(‘ ‘ + ‘ ‘ − g ‘ · ‘ );
L(A) = 2ml
! ! s‘ (‘
− ‘ ) :
(3.1.8a) (3.1.8b)
If the incoming lepton is longitudinally polarised, its spin vector is sl =
5l ‘ ; ml
5l = ± 1
(3.1.9)
and (3.1.8b) becomes L(A) = 25l
! ‘
!
q :
(3.1.10)
Note that the lepton mass ml appearing in (3.1.8b) has been cancelled by the denominator of (3.1.9). In contrast, if the lepton is transversely polarised, that is sl = sl⊥ , no such cancellation occurs and the process is suppressed by a factor ml =E. In what follows we shall consider only unpolarised or longitudinally polarised lepton beams. The hadronic tensor W can be split as W = W(S) (q; P) + iW(A) (q; P; S);
(3.1.11)
16
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where the symmetric and the antisymmetric parts are expressed in terms of two pairs of structure functions, F1 ; F2 and G1 ; G2 , as q q 1 (S) W = −g + 2 W1 (P · q; q2 ) 2M q 1 P·q P·q P − 2 q P − 2 q W2 (P · q; q2 ); (3.1.12a) + 2 M q q 1 1 (3.1.12b) W(A) = ! q! MS G1 (P · q; q2 ) + [P · qS − S · qP ] G2 (P · q; q2 ) : 2M M Eqs. (3:1:12a; b) are the most general expressions compatible with the requirement of gauge invariance, which implies q W = 0 = q W :
(3.1.13)
Using (3.1.7), (3.1.11) the cross-section (3.1.6) becomes 2 /em E (S) (S) d (A) − L(A) ]: = [L W W dE d: 2MQ4 E
(3.1.14)
The unpolarised cross-section is then obtained by averaging over the spins of the incoming lepton (sl ) and of the nucleon (S) and reads 2 E (S) (S) 1 1 d /em dunp : (3.1.15) = = L W dE d: 2 s 2 dE d: 2MQ4 E l
S
Inserting Eqs. (3.1.8a) and (3.1.12a) into (3.1.15) one obtains the well-known expression 2 E 2 4/em dunp 2 # 2 # 2W1 sin : (3.1.16) = + W2 cos dE d: Q4 2 2 Di,erences of cross-sections with opposite target spin probe the antisymmetric part of the leptonic and hadronic tensors 2 d(+S) d(−S) /em E (A) (A) − − : = 2L W dE d: dE d: 2MQ4 E
(3.1.17)
In the target rest frame the spin of the nucleon can be parametrised as (assuming |S| = 1) S = (0; S ) = (0; sin / cos <; sin / sin <; cos /):
(3.1.18)
Taking the direction of the incoming lepton to be the z-axis, we have ‘ = E(1; 0; 0; 1); ‘ = E (1; sin # cos ’; sin # sin ’; cos #):
(3.1.19)
Inserting (3.1.8b) and (3.1.12b) into Eq. (3.1.17), with the above parametrisations for the spin and the momentum four-vectors, for the cross-section asymmetry in the target rest frame we
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
17
Fig. 3. Lepton and spin planes. The lepton plane is taken here to coincide with the xz plane, i.e., ’ = 0.
now obtain 2 E d(+S) d(−S) 4/em − − {[E cos / + E (sin # sin / cos = + cos # cos /)]MG1 = dE d: dE d: Q2 E
+ 2EE [sin # sin / cos = + cos # cos / − cos /]G2 };
(3.1.20)
where = = < − ’ is the azimuthal angle between the lepton plane and the (‘ˆ; Sˆ ) plane. (See Fig. 3.) In particular, when the target nucleon is longitudinally polarised (that is, polarised along the incoming lepton direction), one has / = 0 and the spin asymmetry becomes 2 E d⇒ d⇐ 4/em − − = [(E + E cos #)MG1 − Q2 G2 ]: dE d: dE d: Q2 E
(3.1.21a)
When the target nucleon is transversely polarised (that is, polarised orthogonally to the incoming lepton direction), one has / = =2 and the spin asymmetry is 2 E 2 d⇑ d⇓ 4/em − − = sin #[MG1 + 2EG2 ]: dE d: dE d: Q2 E
(3.1.21b)
A remark on the terminology is in order here. The terms “longitudinal” and “transverse” are somewhat ambiguous, insofar as a reference axis is not speci?ed. From an experimental point of view, the “longitudinal” and “transverse” polarisations of the nucleon are in reference to the lepton beam axis. Thus “longitudinal” (“transverse”) indicates parallel (orthogonal) to this axis. We use the large arrows ⇒ and ⇑ to denote these two cases, respectively. From a theoretical point of view, it is simpler to refer to the direction of motion of the virtual photon. One then speaks of the “longitudinal” (S|| ) and “transverse” (S⊥ ) spin of the nucleon, meaning by this spin parallel and perpendicular, respectively, to the photon axis. When the target is “longitudinally” or “transversely” polarised in this sense, we shall make explicit reference to S|| and S⊥ in the cross-section. Later, it will be shown how to pass from d⇒ − d⇐ and d⇑ − d⇓ to d(+S|| ) − d(−S|| ) and d(+S⊥ ) − d(−S⊥ ). Note that, in general, d⇒ is a combination of d(S|| ) and d(S⊥ ). We shall return to this point in Section 9.2.
18
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
It is customary to introduce the dimensionless structure functions F1 (x; Q2 ) ≡ MW1 (; Q2 ); F2 (x; Q2 ) ≡ W2 (; Q2 ); g1 (x; Q2 ) ≡ M 2 G1 (; Q2 ); g2 (x; Q2 ) ≡ M2 G2 (; Q2 ):
(3.1.22)
In the Bjorken limit Q2 ?xed; (3.1.23) 2M F1 , F2 , g1 and g2 are expected to scale approximately, that is, to depend only on x. In terms of F1 , F2 , g1 and g2 , the hadronic tensor reads q q 2 P·q P·q (S) 2 P − 2 q P − 2 q F2 (x; Q2 ); W = 2 −g + 2 F1 (x; Q ) + q P·q q q (3.1.24a) 2M ! q! S ·q (A) 2 2 W = S g1 (x; Q ) + S − (3.1.24b) P g2 (x; Q ) : P·q P·q ; Q2 → ∞;
x=
The unpolarised cross-section then becomes (as a function of x and y) 2 s xym2N d 4/em 2 2 2 xy F1 (x; Q ) + 1 − y − F2 (x; Q ) ; = d x dy Q4 s
(3.1.25)
whereas the spin asymmetry (3.1.20), in terms of g1 and g2 , takes on the form d(+S) d(−S) − d x dy d’ d x dy d’ 2 2Mx 4/em 2 2 2 1 − y[yg1 (x; Q ) + 2g2 (x; Q )] sin / cos = ; = 2 (2 − y)g1 (x; Q ) cos / + Q Q (3.1.26) where we have neglected contributions of order M 2 =Q2 . Note that the term containing g2 is suppressed by one power of Q. This makes the measurement of g2 quite a diKcult task. It is useful at this point to re-express the cross-section asymmetry (3.1.26) in terms of the angle > between the spin of the nucleon S and the photon momentum q = l − l . The relation between /, = and >, ignoring terms O(M 2 =Q2 ), is 2Mx 1 − y cos = sin >; cos / = cos > + Q 2Mx sin / = sin > − 1 − y cos = cos > (3.1.27) Q
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
19
and hence we obtain
2 d(−S) 4/em 4Mx d(+S) − 1 − y(g1 + g2 ) sin > cos = ; = − 2 (2 − y)g1 cos > + d x dy d’ d x dy d’ Q Q (3.1.28a)
which demonstrates that when the target spin is perpendicular to the photon momentum (>==2) DIS probes the combination g1 + g2 ; and d(+S⊥ ) d(−S⊥ ) 4/2 4Mx − 1 − y(g + g ) cos =: (3.1.28b) = − em 1 2 d x dy d’ d x dy d’ Q2 Q This result can be obtained in another, more direct, manner. Splitting the spin vector of the nucleon into a longitudinal and transverse part (with respect to the photon axis): S = S|| + S⊥ ;
(3.1.29)
where 5N = ± 1 is (twice) the helicity of the nucleon, the antisymmetric part of the hadronic tensor becomes W(A) =
2M ! q! (g1 + g2 )]: [S|| g1 + S⊥ P·q
(3.1.30)
Thus, if the nucleon is longitudinally polarised the DIS cross-section depends only on g1 ; if it is transversely polarised (with respect to the photon axis) what is measured is the sum of g1 and g2 . We shall use expression (3.1.30) when studying the quark content of structure functions in the parton model, to which we now turn. 3.2. The parton model In the parton model the virtual photon is assumed to scatter incoherently o, the constituents of the nucleon (quarks and antiquarks). Currents are treated as in free ?eld theory and any interaction between the struck quark and the target remnant is ignored. The hadronic tensor W is then represented by the handbag diagram shown in Fig. 4 and reads (to simplify the presentation, for the moment we consider only quarks, the extension to antiquarks being rather straightforward) 1 2 d 3 PX d4 k d4 W = ea (2 ) 3 4 4 (2) a (2) 2E (2) (2) X X ×[u() =(k; P; S)]∗ [u() =(k; P; S)](2)4 4 (P − k − PX )(2)4 4 (k + q − );
(3.2.1)
where a is a sum over the Pavours, ea is the quark charge in units of e, and we have introduced the matrix elements of the quark ?eld between the nucleon and its remnant
=i (k; P; S) = X | i (0)|PS :
(3.2.2)
20
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 4. The so-called handbag diagram. Fig. 5. The ∗ N collinear frame. Note our convention for the axes.
We de?ne the quark–quark correlation matrix Aij (k; P; S) as d 3 PX (2)4 4 (P − k − PX )PS | j (0)|X X | i (0)|PS : Aij (k; P; S) = 3 2E (2) X X
(3.2.3)
Using translational invariance and the completeness of the |X states this matrix can be reexpressed in the more synthetic form Aij (k; P; S) = d 4 eik· PS | N j (0) i ()|PS : (3.2.4) With the de?nition (3.2.3) the hadronic tensor becomes d4 k d4 ea2 (2 )(2)4 4 (k + q − ) Tr[A = ] W = 4 4 (2) (2) a d4 k = ea2 ((k + q)2 ) Tr[A (k= + q=) ]: 4 (2) a
(3.2.5)
In order to calculate W , it is convenient to use a Sudakov parametrisation of the fourmomenta at hand (the Sudakov decomposition of vectors is described in Appendix A). We introduce the null vectors p and n , satisfying p2 = 0 = n2 ;
p · n = 1;
n+ = 0 = p−
(3.2.6)
and we work in a frame where the virtual photon and the proton are collinear. As is customary, the proton is taken to be directed along the positive z direction (see Fig. 5). In terms of p and n the proton momentum can be parametrised as M2 (3.2.7) n p : 2 Note that, neglecting the mass M , P coincides with the Sudakov vector p . The momentum q of the virtual photon can be written as P = p +
q P · qn − xp ;
(3.2.8)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
21
where we are implicitly ignoring terms O(M 2 =Q2 ). Finally, the Sudakov decomposition of the quark momentum is 2) (k 2 + k⊥ : (3.2.9) n + k⊥ 2/ In the parton model one assumes that the handbag-diagram contribution to the hadronic tensor 2 . This means that we can write k approximately as is dominated by small values of k 2 and k⊥
k = /p +
k /p :
(3.2.10)
The on-shell condition of the outgoing quark then implies 1 ((k + q)2 ) (−Q2 + 2/P · q) = (/ − x); 2P · q
(3.2.11)
that is, k xP . Thus the Bjorken variable x ≡ Q2 =(2P · q) is the fraction of the longitudinal momentum of the nucleon carried by the struck quark: x = k + =P + . (In the following we shall also consider the possibility of retaining the quark transverse momentum; in this case (3.2.9) will be approximated as k xP + k⊥ .) Returning to the hadronic tensor (3.2.5), the identity ! = [g! g + g g! − g g! − i
!
] 5
(3.2.12)
allows us to split W into symmetric (S) and antisymmetric (A) parts under ↔ interchange. Let us ?rst consider W(S) (i.e., unpolarised DIS): 1 2 d4 k k+ (S) W = e x − + [(k + q ) Tr(A ) + (k + q ) Tr(A ) 2P · q a a (2)4 P −g (k ! + q! )Tr(A ! )]:
(3.2.13)
From (3.2.8) and (3.2.9) we have k + q (P · q)n and (3.2.13) becomes 1 2 d4 k k+ (S) W = e x − + [n Tr(A ) + n Tr(A ) − g n! Tr(A ! )]: (3.2.14) 2 a a (2)4 P Introducing the notation d4 k k+ D ≡ x − + Tr(DA) (2)4 P d− ixP+ − PS | N (0)D (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS = P+ e 2 dE iEx = e PS | N (0)D (En)|PS ; 2 where D is a Dirac matrix, W(S) is written as 1 2 e [n + n − g n! ! ]: W(S) = 2 a a
(3.2.15)
(3.2.16)
22
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
We have now to parametrise , which is a vector quantity containing information on the quark dynamics. At leading twist, i.e., considering contributions O(P + ) in the in?nite momentum frame, the only vector at our disposal is p P (recall that n = O(1=P + ) and k xP ). Thus we can write d4 k k+ ≡ x − + Tr( A) (2)4 P dE iEx = (3.2.17) e PS | N (0) (En)|PS = 2f(x)P ; 2 where the coeKcient of P , which we called f(x), is the quark number density, as will become clear later on (see Sections 4.2 and 4.3). From (3.2.17) we obtain the following expression for f(x): d− ixP+ − f(x) = PS | N (0) + (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS : (3.2.18) e 4 Inserting (3.2.17) into (3.2.16) yields W(S) = ea2 (n P + n P − g )fa (x):
(3.2.19)
a
The structure functions F1 and F2 can be extracted from W by means of two projectors (terms of relative order 1=Q2 are neglected) 1 4x2 F1 = P1 W = P P − g W ; (3.2.20a) 4 Q2 x 12x2 F2 = P2 W = P P −g W : (3.2.20b) 2 Q2 Since (P P =Q2 )W = O(M 2 =Q2 ) we ?nd that F1 and F2 are proportional to each other (the so-called Callan–Gross relation) and are given by x F2 (x) = 2xF1 (x) = − g W(S) = ea2 xfa (x); (3.2.21) 2 a which is the well-known parton model expression for the unpolarised structure functions, restricted to quarks. To obtain the full expressions for F1 and F2 , one must simply add to (3.2.20b) the antiquark distributions fNa , which were left aside in the above discussion. They read (the rˆole of and N is interchanged with respect to the quark distributions: see Section 4.2 for a detailed discussion) d− ixP+ − N f(x) = PS |Tr[ + (0) N (0; − ; 0⊥ )]|PS (3.2.22) e 4 and the structure functions F1 and F2 are F2 (x) = 2xF1 (x) = ea2 x[fa (x) + fNa (x)]: a
(3.2.23)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
23
3.3. Polarised DIS in the parton model Let us turn now to polarised DIS. The parton-model expression of the antisymmetric part of the hadronic tensor is 1 2 d4 k k+ (A) W = e x − + ! (k + q)! Tr( 5 A): (3.3.1) 2P · q a a (2)4 P With k = xP this becomes, using the notation (3.2.15) e2 a 5 : W(A) = ! n! 2 a
(3.3.2)
= O(1)) At leading twist the only pseudovector at hand is S|| (recall that S|| = O(P + ) and S⊥ and 5 is parametrised as (a factor M is inserted for dimensional reasons)
5 = 2M Lf(x)S|| = 25N Lf(x)P :
(3.3.3)
Here Lf(x), given explicitly by d− ixP+ − Lf(x) = PS | N (0) + 5 (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS ; (3.3.4) e 4 is the longitudinal polarisation (i.e., helicity) distribution of quarks. In fact, inserting (3.3.3) in (3.3.2), we ?nd e2 a W(A) = 25N ! n! p (3.3.5) Lfa (x): 2 a Comparing with the longitudinal part of the hadronic tensor (3.1.30), which can be rewritten as (A) W; long = 25N
! n
!
p g1 ;
we obtain the usual parton model expression for the polarised structure function g1 1 2 g1 (x) = e Lfa (x): 2 a a
(3.3.6)
(3.3.7)
Again, antiquark distributions LfqN should be added to (3.3.7) to obtain the full parton model expression for g1 1 2 g1 (x) = e [Lfa (x) + LfNa (x)]: (3.3.8) 2 a a The important lesson we learned is that, at leading twist, only longitudinal polarisation contributes to DIS. 3.4. Transversely polarised targets Since S⊥ is suppressed by a power of P + with respect to its longitudinal counterpart S|| , transverse polarisation e,ects in DIS manifest themselves at twist-three level. Including subdominant
24
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
contributions, Eq. (3.3.3) becomes 5 = 2M Lf(x)S|| + 2MgT (x)S⊥ ;
(3.4.1)
where we have introduced a new, twist-three, distribution function gT , de?ned as (we take the nucleon spin to be directed along the x-axis) P+ i P+ d− ixP+ − gT (x) = 5 = PS | N (0) i 5 (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS : (3.4.2) e 2M M 4 As we are working at twist-three (that is, with quantities suppressed by 1=P + ) we take into account the transverse components of the quark momentum, k xp + k⊥ . Moreover, quark mass terms cannot be ignored. Reinstating these terms in the hadronic tensor, we have 1 2 d4 k k+ 1 ! ! W(A) = ea x − (k + q) Tr[ A] − Tr[i A] : m ! 5 q 5 2P · q a (2)4 P+ 2
(3.4.3)
Notice that now we cannot simply set k ! + q! P · qn , as we did in the case of longitudinal polarisation. Let us rewrite Eq. (3.4.3) as 1 ! W(A) = ea2 5 + LW(A) ; (3.4.4) ! q 2P · q a where LW(A) =
1 2P · q
! a
ea2
1 ! i 5 @ − mq i 5 : 2
!
(3.4.5)
If we could neglect the term LW(A) then, for a transversely polarised target, we should have, using Eq. (3.4.1) 2 2M ! q! S⊥ ea a W(A) = (3.4.6) g (x): P·q 2 T a Comparing with Eq. (3.1.30) yields the parton-model expression for the polarised structure function combination g1 + g2 : 1 2 a g1 (x) + g2 (x) = e g (x): (3.4.7) 2 a a T This result has been obtained by ignoring the term LW(A) in the hadronic tensor, rather a strong assumption, which seems lacking in justi?cation. Surprisingly enough, however, Eq. (3.4.5) turns out to be correct. The reason is that at twist-three one has to add an extra term W(A)g into (3.4.4), arising from non-handbag diagrams with gluon exchange (see Fig. 6) and which exactly cancel out LW(A) . Referring the reader to the original papers [34] (see also [35]) for a detailed proof, we limit ourselves to presenting the main steps.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
25
Fig. 6. Higher-twist contribution to DIS involving quark–gluon correlation.
For the sum LW(A) + W(A)g one obtains 1 2 1 (A) (A)g ! ! e LW + W = mq i 5 ! i 5 D (En) − 4P · q a a 2 − D (En) − D (En) + · · · ;
(3.4.8)
where D = @ − igA and the ellipsis denotes terms with the covariant derivative acting to the left and the gluon ?eld evaluated at the space–time point 0. We now resort to the identity E 1 2 E 5 ! = g!
− g! − i
! 5 :
(3.4.9)
Multiplying by D! and using the equations of motion (iD= − mq ) = 0 we ultimately obtain E 1 2 mq E 5 = D
− D +
! ! i 5 D ;
(3.4.10)
which implies the vanishing of (3.4.8). Concluding, DIS with transversely polarised nucleon (where transverse refers to the photon axis) probes a twist-three distribution function, gT (x), which, as we shall see, has no probabilistic meaning and is not related in a simple manner to transverse quark polarisation. 3.5. Transverse polarisation distributions of quarks in DIS Let us focus now on the quark mass term appearing in the antisymmetric hadronic tensor— see Eqs. (3.4.5) and (3.4.8). We have shown that actually it cancels out and does not contribute to DIS. Its structure, however, is quite interesting. It contains, in fact, the transverse polarisation distribution of quarks, LT f, which is the main subject of this report. The decoupling of the quark mass term thus entails the absence of LT f from DIS, even at higher-twist level. The matrix element i! 5 admits a unique leading-twist parametrisation in terms of a tensor structure containing the transverse spin vector of the target S⊥ and the dominant Sudakov vector p ! i! 5 = 2(p S⊥ − p! S⊥ )LT f(x):
(3.5.1)
26
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
The coeKcient LT f(x) is indeed the transverse polarisation distribution. It can be singled out by contracting (3.5.1) with n! , which gives (for de?niteness, we take the spin vector directed along x) d− ixP+ − 1! 1 LT f(x) = 2 in! 5 = PS | N (0)i1+ 5 (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS : (3.5.2) e 4 Eq. (3.4.10) can be put in the form of a constraint between LT f(x) and other twist-three distributions embodied in D and i 5 D! . Let us consider the partonic content of the last two quantities. The gluonic (non-handbag) contribution W(A)g to the hadronic tensor involves traces of a quark–gluon–quark correlation matrix. We introduce the following two quantities: dE1 dE2 iE1 x2 iE2 (x1 −x2 ) D (E2 n) ≡ PS | N (0) D (E2 n) (E1 n)|PS ; (3.5.3a) e e 2 2 dE1 dE2 iE1 x2 iE2 (x1 −x2 ) i 5 D (E2 n) ≡ e PS | N (0)i 5 D (E2 n) (E1 n)|PS : e 2 2 (3.5.3b) These matrix elements are related to those appearing in (3.4.8) by d x2 D (E2 n) = D (E2 n); d x2 i 5 D (E1 n) = i 5 D (E1 n):
(3.5.4a) (3.5.4b)
At leading order (which for the quark–gluon–quark correlation functions means twist-three) the possible Lorentzian structures of D and i 5 D are D = 2MGD (x1 ; x2 )p
/
p/ n< S⊥! ;
(3.5.5a)
i 5 D = 2M G˜ D (x1 ; x2 )p S⊥ + 2M G˜ D (x1 ; x2 )p S⊥ :
(3.5.5b)
Here three multiparton distributions, GD (x1 ; x2 ), G˜ D (x1 ; x2 ) and G˜ D (x1 ; x2 ), have been introduced. One of them, G˜ (x1 ; x2 ), is only apparently a new quantity. Multiplying Eq. (3.5.5b) by n and exploiting the gauge choice A+ = 0, it is not diKcult to derive a simple connection between G˜ (x1 ; x2 ) and the twist-three distribution function gT (x2 ) [34] G˜ D (x1 ; x2 ) = x2 (x1 − x2 )gT (x2 ):
(3.5.6)
G˜ D (x1 ; x2 )
can be eliminated in favour of the more familiar gT (x2 ). We are now in Hence the position to translate Eq. (3.4.10) into a relation between quark and multiparton distribution functions. Using (3.5.1) and (3:5:4a)–(3:5:6) in (3.4.10) we ?nd mq dy[GD (x; y) + G˜ D (x; y)] = xgT (x) − (3.5.7) LT f(x): M By virtue of this constraint, the transverse polarisation distributions of quarks, that one could naYZvely expect to be probed by DIS at a subleading level, turn out to be completely absent from this process.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
27
Fig. 7. The quark–quark correlation matrix A.
4. Systematics of quark distribution functions In this section we present in detail the systematics of quark and antiquark distribution functions. Our focus will be on leading-twist distributions. For the sake of completeness, however, we shall also sketch some information on the higher-twist distributions. 4.1. The quark–quark correlation matrix Let us consider the quark–quark correlation matrix introduced in Section 3.2 and represented in Fig. 7, Aij (k; P; S) = d 4 eik· PS | N j (0) i ()|PS : (4.1.1) Here, we recall, i and j are Dirac indices and a summation over colour is implicit. The quark distribution functions are essentially integrals over k of traces of the form Tr(DA) = d 4 eik· PS | N (0)D ()|PS ; (4.1.2) where D is a Dirac matrix structure. In Section 3.2, A was de?ned within the naYZve parton model. In QCD, in order to make A gauge invariant, a path-dependent link operator
L(0; ) = P exp −ig ds A (s) ; (4.1.3) 0
where P denotes path-ordering, must be inserted between the quark ?elds. It turns out that the distribution functions involve separations of the form [0; − ; 0⊥ ], or [0; − ; ⊥ ]. Thus, by working in the axial gauge A+ = 0 and choosing an appropriate path, L can be reduced to unity. Hereafter we shall simply assume that the link operator is unity, and just omit it. The A matrix satis?es certain relations arising from hermiticity, parity invariance and timereversal invariance [15]: A† (k; P; S) = 0 A(k; P; S) 0 ˜ P; ˜ 0 ˜ −S) A(k; P; S) = 0 A(k;
(hermiticity); (parity);
˜ P; ˜ † 5 ˜ S)C A∗ (k; P; S) = 5 CA(k;
(time-reversal);
(4.1.4a) (4.1.4b) (4.1.4c)
28
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where C = i 2 0 and the tilde four-vectors are de?ned as k˜ = (k 0 ; −k). As we shall see, the time-reversal condition (4.1.4c) plays an important rˆole in the phenomenology of transverse polarisation distributions. It is derived in a straightforward manner by using T () T † = ˜ and T |PS = (−1)S−Sz |P; ˜ S˜ , where T is the time-reversal operator. The crucial − i 5 C (−) point, to be kept in mind, is the transformation of the nucleon state, which is a free particle state. Under T , this goes into the same state with reversed P and S . The most general decomposition of A in a basis of Dirac matrices,
D = {5; ; 5 ; i 5 ; i 5 }; 1 2
is (we introduce a factor
(4.1.5)
for later convenience)
A(k; P; S) = 12 {S5 + V + A 5 + iP5 5 + 12 iT 5 }:
(4.1.6)
The quantities S, V , A , P5 and T are constructed with the vectors k , P and the pseudovector S . Imposing the constraints (4:1:4a), (4.1.4c) we have, in general, S = 12 Tr(A) = C1 ;
(4.1.7a)
V = 12 Tr( A) = C2 P + C3 k ;
(4.1.7b)
A = 12 Tr( 5 A) = C4 S + C5 k · SP + C6 k · Sk ;
(4.1.7c)
1 (4.1.7d) Tr( 5 A) = 0; 2i 1 T = Tr( 5 A) = C7 P [ S ] + C8 k [ S ] + C9 k · SP [ k ] ; (4.1.7e) 2i where the coeKcients Ci = Ci (k 2 ; k · P) are real functions, owing to hermiticity. If we relax the constraint (4.1.4c) of time-reversal invariance (for the physical relevance of this, see Section 4.8 below) three more terms appear: P5 =
V = · · · + C10
!
S P! k ;
(4.1.7d )
P5 = C11 k · S; T = · · · + C12
(4.1.7b )
!
P! k :
(4.1.7e )
4.2. Leading-twist distribution functions We are mainly interested in the leading-twist contributions, that is the terms in Eqs. (4:1:7a)– (4.1.7e) that are of order O(P + ) in the in?nite momentum frame. The vectors at our disposal are P , k xP , and S 5N P =M + S⊥ , where the approximate + equality signs indicate that we are neglecting terms suppressed by (P )−2 . Remember that the transverse spin vector S⊥ is of order (P + )0 . For the time being we ignore quark transverse momentum k⊥ (which in DIS is integrated over). We shall see later on how the situation becomes more complicated when k⊥ enters the game.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
29
At leading order in P + only the vector, axial, and tensor terms in (4.1.6) survive and Eqs. (4:1:7b, c, e) become 1 V = d 4 eik· PS | N (0) ()|PS = A1 P ; (4.2.1a) 2 1 A = d 4 eik· PS | N (0) 5 ()|PS = 5N A2 P ; (4.2.1b) 2 1 ] T = d 4 eik· PS | N (0) 5 ()|PS = A3 P [ S⊥ ; (4.2.1c) 2i where we have introduced new real functions Ai (k 2 ; k · P). The leading-twist quark correlation ] matrix (4.1.6) is then (we use P [ S⊥ = 2iP= S=⊥ ) A(k; P; S) = 12 {A1 P= + A2 5N 5 P= + A3 P= 5 S=⊥ }:
(4.2.2)
From (4:2:1a)–(4.2.1c) we obtain A1 =
1 Tr( + A); 2P +
(4.2.3a)
5N A2 =
1 Tr( + 5 A); 2P +
(4.2.3b)
i S⊥ A3 =
1 1 Tr(ii+ 5 A) = + Tr( + i 5 A): + 2P 2P
(4.2.3c)
The leading-twist distribution functions f(x), Lf(x) and LT f(x) are obtained by integrating A1 , A2 and A3 , respectively, over k, with the constraint x = k + =P + , that is, 2 f(x) d4 k A1 (k ; k · P) k+ 2 Lf(x) = (4.2.4) A2 (k ; k · P) x − + ; (2)4 P L f(x) 2 A3 (k ; k · P) T i = (1; 0) that is, using (4:2:3a)–(4.2.3c) and setting for de?niteness 5N = + 1 and S⊥ 1 d4 k f(x) = Tr( + A)(k + − xP + ); 2 (2)4 1 d4 k Lf(x) = Tr( + 5 A)(k + − xP + ); 2 (2)4 1 d4 k LT f(x) = Tr( + 1 5 A)(k + − xP + ): 2 (2)4
(4.2.5a) (4.2.5b) (4.2.5c)
Finally, inserting the de?nition (4.1.1) of A in (4:2:5a)–(4.2.5c), we obtain the three leading-twist distribution functions as light-cone Fourier transforms of expectation values of quark-?eld
30
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
bilinears [36]: d− ixP+ − f(x) = PS | N (0) + (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS ; e 4 d− ixP+ − e Lf(x) = PS | N (0) + 5 (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS ; 4 d− ixP+ − PS | N (0) + 1 5 (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS : LT f(x) = e 4
(4.2.6a) (4.2.6b) (4.2.6c)
The quark–quark correlation matrix A integrated over k with the constraint x = k + =P + d4 k Aij (x) = Aij (k; P; S)(x − k + =P + ) (2)4 dE iEx = (4.2.7) e PS | N j (0) i (En)|PS ; 2 in terms of the three leading-twist distribution functions, reads A(x) = 12 {f(x)P= + 5N Lf(x) 5 P= + LT f(x)P= 5 S=⊥ }:
(4.2.8)
Let us now complete the discussion introducing the antiquarks. Their distribution functions are obtained from the correlation matrix N Aij (k; P; S) = d 4 eik· PS | i (0) N j ()|PS : (4.2.9) Tracing AN with the Dirac matrices D gives Tr(DA) = d 4 eik· PS |Tr[D (0) N ()]|PS :
(4.2.10)
N Lf, N LT fN care is needed with the signs. By charge conjuIn deriving the expressions for f, gation, the ?eld bilinears in (4.1.4a) transform as N (0)D () → ±Tr[D (0) N ()]; (4.2.11) where the + sign is for D = , i 5 and the − sign for D = 5 . We thus obtain the antiquark density number: 1 d4 k + N N f(x) = Tr( + A)(k − xP + ) 2 (2)4 d− ixP+ − = PS |Tr[ + (0) N (0; − ; 0⊥ )]|PS ; (4.2.12) e 4 the antiquark helicity distribution 1 d4 k + N N Lf(x) = − Tr( + 5 A)(k − xP + ) 2 (2)4 d− ixP+ − = PS |Tr[ + 5 (0) N (0; − ; 0⊥ )]|PS (4.2.13) e 4
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
and the antiquark transversity distribution d4 k 1 + N N LT f(x) Tr( + 1 5 A)(k − xP + ) = 2 (2)4 d− ixP+ − = PS |Tr[ + 1 5 (0) N (0; − ; 0⊥ )]|PS : e 4
31
(4.2.14)
Note the minus sign in the de?nition of the antiquark helicity distribution. If we adhere to the de?nitions of quark and antiquark distributions, Eqs. (4:2:6a)–(4.2.6c) and (4:2:12)–(4:2:14), the variable x ≡ k + =P + is not a priori constrained to be positive and to range from 0 to 1 (we shall see in Section 4.3 how the correct support for x comes out, hence justifying its identi?cation with the Bjorken variable). It turns out that there is a set of symmetry relations connecting quark and antiquark distribution functions, which are obtained by continuing x to negative values. Using anticommutation relations for the fermion ?elds in the connected matrix elements PS | N () (0)|PS c = − PS | (0) N ()|PS c ;
(4.2.15)
one easily obtains the following relations for the three distribution functions: N f(x) = − f(−x);
(4.2.16a)
N Lf(x) = Lf(−x);
(4.2.16b)
N = − LT f(−x): LT f(x)
(4.2.16c)
Therefore, antiquark distributions are given by the continuation of the corresponding quark distributions into the negative x region. 4.3. Probabilistic interpretation of distribution functions Distribution functions are essentially the probability densities for ?nding partons with a given momentum fraction and a given polarisation inside a hadron. We shall now see how this interpretation comes about from the ?eld-theoretical de?nitions of quark (and antiquark) distribution functions presented above. Let us ?rst of all decompose the quark ?elds into “good” and “bad” components: =
(+)
+
(−) ;
(4.3.1)
where 1 ∓ ± (±) = 2
:
(4.3.2)
The usefulness of this procedure lies in the fact that “bad” components are not dynamically independent: using the equations of motion, they can be eliminated in favour of “good” components and terms containing quark masses and gluon ?elds. Since in the P + → ∞ limit (+) dominates over (−) , the presence of “bad” components in a parton distribution function signals
32
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 8. (a) A connected matrix element with the insertion of a complete set of intermediate states and (b) a semiconnected matrix element.
higher twists. Using the relations √ N + = 2 † (+) ; (+) √ N + 5 = 2
† (+) 5 (+) ;
√ N ii+ 5 = 2
† i (+) 5 (+)
the leading-twist distributions (4:2:6a)–(4.2.6c) can be re-expressed as [36] d− ixP+ − † √ e f(x) = PS | (+) (0) + (+) (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS ; 2 2 d− ixP+ − † √ e Lf(x) = PS | (+) (0) 5 (+) (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS ; 2 2 d− ixP+ − † √ e LT f(x) = PS | (+) (0) 1 5 (+) (0; − ; 0⊥ )|PS : 2 2
(4.3.3a) (4.3.3b) (4.3.3c)
(4.3.4a) (4.3.4b) (4.3.4c)
Note that, as anticipated, only “good” components appear. It is the peculiar structure of the quark-?eld bilinears in Eqs. (4:3:4a)–(4.3.4c) that allows us to put the distributions in a form that renders their probabilistic nature transparent. A remark on the support of the distribution functions is now in order. We already mentioned that, according to the de?nitions of the quark distributions, nothing constrains the ratio x ≡ k + =P + to take on values between 0 and 1. The correct support of the distributions emerges, along with their probabilistic content, if one inserts into (4:3:4a)–(4.3.4c) a complete set of intermediate states {|n} [37] (see Fig. 8). Considering, for instance, the unpolarised distribution we obtain from (4.3.4a) 1 f(x) = √ ((1 − x)P + − Pn+ )|PS | (+) (0)|n|2 ; (4.3.5) 2 n where n incorporates the integration over the phase space of the intermediate states. Eq. (4.3.5) clearly gives the probability of ?nding inside the nucleon a quark with longitudinal momentum k + =P + , irrespective of its polarisation. Since the states |n are physical we must have Pn+ ¿ 0, that is En ¿ |Pn |, and therefore x 6 1. Moreover, if we exclude semiconnected diagrams like
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
33
that in Fig. 8b, which correspond to x¡0, we are left with the connected diagram of Fig. 8a and with the correct support 0 6 x 6 1. A similar reasoning applies to antiquarks. Let us turn now to the polarised distributions. Using the Pauli–Lubanski projectors P± = 1 1 1 2 (1 ± 5 ) (for helicity) and P↑↓ = 2 (1 ± 5 ) (for transverse polarisation), we obtain 1 ((1 − x)P + − Pn+ ){|PS |P+ (+) (0)|n|2 − |PS |P− (+) (0)|n|2 }; Lf(x) = √ 2 n (4.3.6a) 1 LT f(x) = √ ((1 − x)P + − Pn+ ){|PS |P↑ 2 n
2 (+) (0)|n|
− |PS |P↓
2 (+) (0)|n| }:
(4.3.6b)
These expressions exhibit the probabilistic content of the leading-twist polarised distributions Lf(x) and LT f(x): Lf(x) is the number density of quarks with helicity + minus the number density of quarks with helicity − (assuming the parent nucleon to have helicity +); LT f(x) is the number density of quarks with transverse polarisation ↑ minus the number density of quarks with transverse polarisation ↓ (assuming the parent nucleon to have transverse polarisation ↑). It is important to notice that LT f admits an interpretation in terms of probability densities only in the transverse polarisation basis. The three leading-twist quark distribution functions are contained in the entries of the spin density matrix of quarks in the nucleon (5(x) is the quark helicity density, s⊥ (x) is the quark transverse spin density): !++ !+− 1 + 5(x) sx (x) − isy (x) 1 !55 = = : (4.3.7) 2 sx (x) + isy (x) !−+ !− − 1 − 5(x) Recalling the probabilistic interpretation of the spin density matrix elements discussed in Section 2.3, one ?nds that the spin components s⊥ ; 5 of the quark appearing in (4.3.7) are related to the spin components S⊥ ; 5N of the parent nucleon by 5q (x)f(x) = 5N Lf(x);
(4.3.8a)
s⊥ (x)f(x) = S⊥ LT f(x):
(4.3.8b)
4.4. Vector, axial and tensor charges If we integrate the correlation matrix A(k; P; S) over k, or equivalently A(x) over x, we obtain a local matrix element (which we call A, with no arguments) Aij = d 4 k Aij (k; P; S) = d x Aij (x) = PS | N j (0) i (0)|PS ; (4.4.1) which, in view of (4.2.2), can be parametrised as A = 12 [gV P= + gA 5N 5 P= + gT P= 5 S=⊥ ]:
(4.4.2)
34
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Here gV ; gA and gT are the vector, axial and tensor charge, respectively. They are given by the following matrix elements, recall (4:2:1a)–(4.2.1c): PS | N (0) i (0)|PS = 2gV P ;
(4.4.3a)
PS | N (0) 5 i (0)|PS = 2gA MS ;
(4.4.3b)
PS | N (0)i 5 i (0)|PS = 2gT (S P − S P ):
(4.4.3c)
Warning: the tensor charge gT should not be confused with the twist-three distribution function gT (x) encountered in Section 3.4. Integrating Eqs. (4:2:6a)–(4.2.6c) and using the symmetry relations (4:2:16a)–(4.2.16c) yields +1 1 N d x f(x) = d x[f(x) − f(x)] (4.4.4a) = gV ; −1 0 +1 1 N d x Lf(x) = d x[Lf(x) + Lf(x)] = gA ; (4.4.4b) −1 0 +1 1 N d x LT f(x) = d x[LT f(x) − LT f(x)] (4.4.4c) = gT : −1
0
Note that gV is simply the valence number. As a consequence of the charge conjugation properties of the ?eld bilinears N , N 5 and N i 5 , the vector and tensor charges are the ?rst moments of Pavour non-singlet combinations (quarks minus antiquarks) whereas the axial charge is the ?rst moment of a Pavour singlet combination (quarks plus antiquarks). 4.5. Quark–nucleon helicity amplitudes The DIS hadronic tensor is related to forward virtual Compton scattering amplitudes. Thus, leading-twist quark distribution functions can be expressed in terms of quark–nucleon forward amplitudes. In the helicity basis these amplitudes have the form A5; 5 , where 5; 5 (; ) are quark (nucleon) helicities. There are in general 16 amplitudes. Imposing helicity conservation, − 5 = − 5;
i:e:; + 5 = + 5 ;
(4.5.1)
only 6 amplitudes survive: A++; ++ ;
A− −; − − ;
A+−; +− ;
A−+; −+ ;
A+−; −+ ;
A−+; +− :
(4.5.2)
Parity invariance implies A5; 5 = A−−5; − −5
(4.5.3)
and gives the following 3 constraints on the amplitudes: A++; ++ = A− −; − − ; A++; − − = A− −; ++ ; A+−; −+ = A−+; +− :
(4.5.4)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
35
Fig. 9. The three quark–nucleon helicity amplitudes.
Time-reversal invariance, A5; 5 = A 5 ; 5 ;
(4.5.5)
adds no further constraints. Hence, we are left with three independent amplitudes (see Fig. 9) A++; ++ ;
A+−; +− ;
A+−; −+ :
(4.5.6)
Two of the amplitudes in (4.5.6), A++; ++ and A+−; +− , are diagonal in the helicity basis (the quark does not Pip its helicity: 5 = 5 ), the third, A+−; −+ , is o,-diagonal (helicity Pip: 5 = − 5 ). Using the optical theorem we can relate these quark–nucleon helicity amplitudes to the three leading-twist quark distribution functions, according to the scheme f(x) = f+ (x) + f− (x)∼Im(A++; ++ + A+−; +− );
(4.5.7a)
Lf(x) = f+ (x) − f− (x)∼Im(A++; ++ − A+−; +− );
(4.5.7b)
LT f(x) = f↑ (x) − f↓ (x)∼Im A+−; −+ :
(4.5.7c)
In a transversity basis (with ↑ directed along y) | ↑ = √12 [|+ + i|−]; | ↓ = √12 [|+ − i|−];
(4.5.8)
the transverse polarisation distributions LT f is related to a diagonal amplitude LT f(x) = f↑ (x) − f↓ (x)∼Im(A↑↑; ↑↑ − A↑↓; ↑↓ ):
(4.5.9)
Reasoning in terms of parton–nucleon forward helicity amplitudes, it is easy to understand why there is no such thing as leading-twist transverse polarisation of gluons. A hypothetical LT g would imply an helicity Pip gluon–nucleon amplitude, which cannot exist owing to helicity conservation. In fact, gluons have helicity ±1 but the nucleon cannot undergo an helicity change L = ± 2. Targets with higher spin may have an helicity-Pip gluon distribution. If transverse momenta of quarks are not neglected, the situation becomes more complicated and the number of independent helicity amplitudes increases. These amplitudes combine to form six k⊥ -dependent distribution functions (three of which reduce to f(x), Lf(x) and LT f(x) when integrated over k⊥ ).
36
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
4.6. The So>er inequality From the de?nitions of f, Lf and LT f, that is, Lf(x) = f+ (x) − f− (x), LT f(x) = f↑ (x) − f↓ (x) and f(x) = f+ (x) + f− (x) = f↑ (x) + f↓ (x), two bounds on Lf and LT f immediately follow: |Lf(x)| 6 f(x);
(4.6.1a)
|LT f(x)| 6 f(x):
(4.6.1b)
Similar inequalities are satis?ed by the antiquark distributions. Another, more subtle, bound, simultaneously involving f, Lf and LT f, was discovered by So,er [38]. It can be derived from the expressions (4:5:7a)–(4.5.7c) of the distribution functions in terms of quark–nucleon forward amplitudes. Let us introduce the quark–nucleon vertices a5 :
and rewrite Eqs. (4:5:7a)–(4.5.7c) in the form f(x)∼Im(A++; ++ + A+−; +− )∼ (a∗++ a++ + a∗+− a+− ); X Lf(x)∼Im(A++; ++ − A+−; +− )∼ (a∗++ a++ − a∗+− a+− ); X ∗ LT f(x)∼Im A+−; −+ ∼ a− − a++ :
(4.6.2a) (4.6.2b) (4.6.2c)
X
From
|a++ ± a− − |2 ¿ 0;
(4.6.3)
using parity invariance, we obtain a∗++ a++ ± a∗− − a++ ¿ 0;
(4.6.4)
X
X
X
that is f+ (x) ¿ |LT f(x)|;
(4.6.5)
which is equivalent to f(x) + Lf(x) ¿ 2|LT f(x)|:
(4.6.6)
An analogous relation holds for the antiquark distributions. Eq. (4.6.6) is known as the So,er inequality. It is an important bound, which must be satis?ed by the leading-twist distribution functions. The reason it escaped attention until a relatively late discovery in [38] is that it involves three quantities that are not diagonal in the same basis. Thus, to be derived, So,er’s
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
37
Fig. 10. The So,er bound on the leading-twist distributions [38] (note that there LT q(x) was called q(x)).
inequality requires consideration of probability amplitudes, not of probabilities themselves. The constraint (4.6.6) is represented in Fig. 10. We shall see in Section 5.5 that the So,er bound, like the other two—more obvious— inequalities (4:6:1a), (4.6.1b), is preserved by QCD evolution, as it should be. 4.7. Transverse motion of quarks Let us now account for the transverse motion of quarks. This is necessary in semi-inclusive DIS, when one wants to study the Ph⊥ distribution of the produced hadron. Therefore, in this section we shall prepare the ?eld for later applications. The quark momentum is now given by k xP + k⊥ ;
(4.7.1) , k⊥
which is zeroth order in P + and thus suppressed by one power of where we have retained + P with respect to the longitudinal momentum. At leading twist, again, only the vector, axial and tensor terms in (4.1.6) appear and Eqs. (4:1:7b), (4.1.7c), (4.1.7e) become V = A1 P ;
1 ˜ A 1 k⊥ · S ⊥ P ; M 5N ˜ [ ] 1 ] ] T = A3 P [ S⊥ + ; A2 P k⊥ + 2 A˜ 3 k⊥ · S⊥ P [ k⊥ M M A = 5N A2 P +
(4.7.2a) (4.7.2b) (4.7.2c)
38
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where we have de?ned new real functions A˜ i (k 2 ; k · P) (the tilde signals the presence of k⊥ ) and introduced powers of M , so that all coeKcients have the same dimension. The quark–quark correlation matrix (4.1.6) then reads 1 1 A(k; P; S) = A1 P= + A2 5N 5 P= + A3 P= 5 S=⊥ + A˜ 1 k⊥ · S⊥ 5 P= 2 M 1 ˜ 5N ˜ (4.7.3) + A2 P= 5 k=⊥ + 2 A3 k⊥ · S⊥ P= 5 k=⊥ : M M We can project out the Ai ’s and A˜ i ’s, as we did in Section 4.2 1 Tr( + A) = A1 ; 2P + 1 1 Tr( + 5 A) = 5N A2 + k⊥ · S⊥ A˜ 1 ; + 2P M 1 5N i ˜ 1 i i ˜ Tr(ii+ 5 A) = S⊥ A3 + A3 : k⊥ A2 + 2 k⊥ · S⊥ k⊥ + 2P M M Let us rearrange the r.h.s. of the last expression in the following manner: 2 k⊥ 1 i i ˜ i ˜ S⊥ A3 + 2 k⊥ · S⊥ k⊥ A3 = S⊥ A3 + A3 M 2M 2 1 2 ij 1 i j k⊥ + k⊥ g⊥ S⊥j A˜ 3 : − 2 k⊥ M 2
(4.7.4a) (4.7.4b) (4.7.4c)
(4.7.5)
If we integrate Eqs. (4:7:4a)–(4:7:4c) over k with the constraint x = k + =P + , the terms proportional to A˜ 1 , A˜ 2 and A˜ 3 in (4:7:4b)–(4:7:5) vanish. We are left with the three terms proportional 2 =2M 2 )A ˜ 3 , which give, upon integration, the three to A1 , A2 and to the combination A3 + (k⊥ distribution functions f(x), Lf(x) and LT f(x), respectively. The only di,erence from the pre2 =2M 2 ) A ˜3 vious case of no quark transverse momentum is that LT f(x) is now related to A3 +(k⊥ and not to A3 alone 2 k⊥ d4 k ˜ A3 + (4.7.6) A3 (x − k + =P + ): LT f(x) ≡ (2)4 2M 2 Three of If we do not integrate over k⊥ , we obtain six k⊥ -dependent distribution functions. 2 ), Lf(x; k2 ) and L f(x; k2 ), are such that f(x) = d 2 k f(x; k2 ), them, which we call f(x; k⊥ ⊥ T ⊥ ⊥ ⊥ etc. The other three are completely new and are related to the terms of the correlation matrix containing the A˜ i ’s. We shall adopt Mulders’ terminology for them [15,16]. Introducing the notation 1 d k+ d k− [D] A ≡ Tr(DA)(k + − xP + ) 2 (2)4 d− d 2 ⊥ i(xP+ − −k⊥ ·⊥ ) = e PS | N (0)D (0; − ; ⊥ )|PS ; (4.7.7) 2(2)3
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
39
we have +
2 A[ ] = Pq=N (x; k⊥ ) = f(x; k⊥ );
A[
+
A[i
5 ]
i+
(4.7.8a)
2 = Pq=N (x; k⊥ )5(x; k⊥ ) = 5N Lf(x; k⊥ )+
5 ]
k⊥ · S ⊥
i = Pq=N (x; k⊥ )s⊥ (x; k⊥ ) i 2 LT f(x; k⊥ ) = S⊥
5N i ⊥ 1 2 + )− 2 k h (x; k⊥ M ⊥ 1L M
M
2 ); g1T (x; k⊥
i j k⊥ k⊥
(4.7.8b)
1 2 ij 2 + k⊥ g⊥ S⊥j h⊥ 1T (x; k⊥ ); 2 (4.7.8c)
where Pq=N (x; k⊥ ) is the probability of ?nding a quark with longitudinal momentum fraction x and transverse momentum k⊥ , and 5(x; k⊥ ), s⊥ (x; k⊥ ) are the quark helicity and transverse spin densities, respectively. The spin density matrix of quarks now reads 1 + 5(x; k⊥ ) sx (x; k⊥ ) − isy (x; k⊥ ) 1 !55 = (4.7.9) 2 sx (x; k⊥ ) + isy (x; k⊥ ) 1 − 5(x; k⊥ ) and its entries incorporate the six distributions listed above, according to Eqs. (4:7:8a) and (4:7:8b). Let us now try to understand the partonic content of the k⊥ -dependent distributions. If the 2 ), which coincides with target nucleon is unpolarised, the only measurable quantity is f(x; k⊥ Pq (x; k⊥ ), the number density of quarks with longitudinal momentum fraction x and transverse 2. momentum squared k⊥ If the target nucleon is transversely polarised, there is some probability of ?nding the quarks transversely polarised along the same direction as the nucleon, along a di,erent direction, or longitudinally polarised. This variety of situations is allowed by the presence of k⊥ . Integrating over k⊥ , the transverse polarisation asymmetry of quarks along a di,erent direction with respect to the nucleon polarisation, and the longitudinal polarisation asymmetry of quarks in a transversely polarised nucleon disappear: only the case s⊥ ||S⊥ survives. Referring to Fig. 11 for the geometry in the azimuthal plane and using the following parametrisations for the vectors at hand (we assume full polarisation of the nucleon): k⊥ = (|k⊥ | cos =k ; −|k⊥ | sin =k );
(4.7.10)
S⊥ = (cos =S ; −sin =S );
(4.7.11)
s⊥ = (|s⊥ | cos =s ; −|s⊥ | sin =s );
(4.7.12)
we ?nd for the k⊥ -dependent transverse polarisation distributions of quarks in a transversely polarised nucleon (± denote, as usual, longitudinal polarisation whereas ↑↓ denote transverse polarisation) 2 Pq↑=N ↑ (x; k⊥ ) − Pq↓=N ↑ (x; k⊥ ) = cos(=S − =s )LT f(x; k⊥ )
+
2 k⊥
2M 2
2 cos(2=k − =S − =s )h⊥ 1T (x; k⊥ )
(4.7.13a)
40
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 11. Our de?nition of the azimuthal angles in the plane orthogonal to the ∗ N axis. The photon momentum, which is directed along the positive z axis, points inwards. For our choice of the axes see Fig. 5.
and for the longitudinal polarisation distribution of quarks in a transversely polarised nucleon |k⊥ | 2 Pq+=N ↑ (x; k⊥ ) − Pq−=N ↑ (x; k⊥ ) = ): (4.7.13b) cos(=S − =k )g1T (x; k⊥ M Due to transverse motion, quarks can also be transversely polarised in a longitudinally polarised nucleon. Their polarisation asymmetry is |k⊥ | 2 Pq↑=N + (x; k⊥ ) − Pq↓=N + (x; k⊥ ) = (4.7.13c) cos(=k − =s )h⊥ 1L (x; k⊥ ): M As we shall see in Section 6.5, the k⊥ -dependent distribution function h⊥ 1L plays a role in the azimuthal asymmetries of semi-inclusive leptoproduction. 4.8. T -odd distributions Relaxing the time-reversal invariance condition (4:1:4c)—we postpone the discussion of the physical relevance of this until the end of this subsection—two additional terms in the vector and tensor components of A arise 1 V = · · · + A1 ! P k⊥! S⊥ ; (4.1.7b ) M 1 T = · · · + A2 ! P! k⊥ ; (4.1.7e ) M ⊥ and h⊥ which give rise to two k⊥ -dependent T -odd distribution functions, f1T 1 [ + ]
ij ⊥ k⊥i S⊥j
⊥ 2 (x; k⊥ ); f1T M ij [ii+ 5 ] 2 ⊥ k⊥j ⊥ A =··· − ): h (x; k⊥ M 1
A
=··· −
(4.8.1a) (4.8.1b)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
41
⊥ , is Let us see the partonic interpretation of the new distributions. The ?rst of them, f1T related to the number density of unpolarised quarks in a transversely polarised nucleon. More precisely, it is given by
Pq=N ↑ (x; k⊥ ) − Pq=N ↓ (x; k⊥ ) = Pq=N ↑ (x; k⊥ ) − Pq=N ↑ (x; −k⊥ )
= −2
|k⊥ |
M
⊥ 2 (x; k⊥ ): sin(=k − =S )f1T
(4.8.2a)
The other T -odd distribution, h⊥ 1 , measures quark transverse polarisation in an unpolarised hadron [16] and is de?ned via |k⊥ |
2 (4.8.2b) sin(=k − =s )h⊥ 1 (x; k⊥ ): M We shall encounter again these distributions in the analysis of hadron production (Section ⊥ and h⊥ , 7.4). For later convenience we de?ne two quantities LT0 f and L0T f, related to f1T 1 respectively, by (for the notation see Section 1.2)
Pq↑=N (x; k⊥ ) − Pq↓=N (x; k⊥ ) = −
2 LT0 f(x; k⊥ ) ≡ −2 2 )≡− L0T f(x; k⊥
|k⊥ |
M
⊥ 2 (x; k⊥ ); f1T
|k⊥ |
(4.8.3a)
2 ): (4.8.3b) h⊥ (x; k⊥ M 1 It is now time to comment on the physical meaning of the quantities we have introduced in ⊥ and this section. One may legitimately wonder whether T -odd quark distributions, such as f1T ⊥ h1 that violate the time-reversal condition (4.1.4c) make any sense at all. In order to justify the existence of T -odd distribution functions, their proponents [39] advocate initial-state e,ects, which prevent implementation of time-reversal invariance by naYZvely imposing the condition (4.1.4c). The idea, similar to that which leads to admitting T -odd fragmentation functions as a result of ?nal-state e,ects (see Section 6.4), is that the colliding particles interact strongly with non-trivial relative phases. As a consequence, time reversal no longer implies the constraint ⊥ (4.1.4c). 4 If hadronic interactions in the initial state are crucial to explain the existence of f1T ⊥ and h1 , these distributions should only be observable in reactions involving two initial hadrons (Drell–Yan processes, hadron production in proton–proton collisions, etc.). This mechanism is known as the Sivers e,ect [40,41]. Clearly, it should be absent in leptoproduction. A di,erent way of looking at the T -odd distributions has been proposed in [42– 44]. By relying on a general argument using time reversal, originally due to Wigner and recently revisited by ⊥ and Weinberg [45], the authors of [44] show that time reversal does not necessarily forbid f1T ⊥ h1 . In particular, an explicit realisation of Weinberg’s mechanism, based on chiral Lagrangians, ⊥ and h⊥ may emerge from the time-reversal preserving chiral dynamics of quarks shows that f1T 1 in the nucleon, with no need for initial-state interaction e,ects. If this idea is correct, the T -odd distributions should also be observable in semi-inclusive leptoproduction. A conclusive statement on the matter will only be made by experiments.
4
Thus “T -odd” means that condition (4.1.4c) is not satis?ed, not that time reversal is violated.
42
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
4.9. Twist-three distributions At twist-three the quark–quark correlation matrix, integrated over k, has the structure [14] M 5N e(x) + gT (x) 5 S=⊥ + (4.9.1) hL (x) 5 [p=; n=] ; A(x) = · · · + 2 2 where the dots represent the twist-two contribution, Eq. (4.2.8), and p; n are the Sudakov vectors (see Appendix A). Three more distributions appear in (4.9.1): e(x), gT (x) and hL (x). We already encountered gT (x), which is the twist-three partner of Lf(x): dE iEx + twist-4 terms: e PS | N (0) 5 (En)|PS = 25N Lf(x)p + 2MgT (x)S⊥ 2 (4.9.2a) Analogously, hL (x) is the twist-three partner of LT f(x) and appears in the tensor term of the quark–quark correlation matrix: dE iEx ] + 2MhL (x)p[ n] + twist-4 terms: e PS | N (0)i 5 (En)|PS = 2LT f(x)p[ S⊥ 2 (4.9.2b) The third distribution, e(x), has no counterpart at leading twist. It appears in the expansion of the scalar ?eld bilinear: dE iEx (4.9.2c) e PS | N (0) (En)|PS = 2Me(x) + twist-4 terms: 2 The higher-twist distributions do not admit any probabilistic interpretation. To see this, consider for instance gT (x). Upon separation of into good and bad components, it turns out to be P+ d− ixP+ − † gT (x) = PS | (+) (0) 0 1 5 (−) (0; − ; 0⊥ ) e M 4 −
† 0 1 − (−) (0) 5 (+) (0; ; 0⊥ )|PS :
(4.9.3)
This distribution cannot be put into a form such as (4.3.6a), (4.3.6b). Thus gT cannot be regarded as a probability density. Like all higher-twist distributions, it involves quark–quark– gluon correlations and hence has no simple partonic meaning. It is precisely this fact that makes gT (x) and the structure function that contains gT (x), i.e., g2 (x; Q2 ), quite subtle and diKcult to handle within the framework of parton model. It should be borne in mind that the twist-three distributions in (4.9.1) are, in a sense, “e,ective” quantities, which incorporate various kinematical and dynamical e,ects that contribute to higher twist: quark masses, intrinsic transverse motion and gluon interactions. It can be shown [15] that e(x), hL (x) and gT (x) admit the decomposition e(x) =
mq f(x) + e(x); ˜ M x
(4.9.4a)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
43
Fig. 12. The quark–quark–gluon correlation matrix AA .
hL (x) =
mq Lf(x) 2 ⊥(1) − h1L (x) + h˜L (x); M x x
mq LT f(x) 1 (1) + g1T (x) + g˜T (x); M x x where we have introduced the weighted distributions k2 2 h⊥(1) (x) ≡ d 2 k⊥ ⊥2 h⊥ (x; k⊥ ); 1L 2M 1L gT (x) =
(1) g1T (x) ≡
d 2 k⊥
2 k⊥
2M 2
2 g1T (x; k⊥ ):
(4.9.4b) (4.9.4c)
(4.9.5a) (4.9.5b)
The three tilde functions e(x), ˜ h˜L (x) and g˜T (x) are the genuine interaction-dependent twist-three parts of the subleading distributions, arising from non-handbag diagrams like that of Fig. 6. To understand the origin of such quantities, let us de?ne the quark correlation matrix with a gluon insertion (see Fig. 12) ˜ ˜ 4 ˜ P; S) = d d 4 z eik· AAij (k; k; ei(k−k)·z PS |=N j (0)gA (z)=i ()|PS : (4.9.6) Note that in the diagram of Fig. 12 the momenta of the quarks on the left and on the right of the unitarity cut are di,erent. We call x and y the two momentum fractions, i.e., k = xP; k˜ = yP (4.9.7) and integrate (4.9.6) over k and k˜ with the constraints (4.9.7) + d4 k d 4 k˜ ˜ AAij (x; y) = AA (k; k; P; S)(x − k + =P + )(y − k˜ =P + ) 4 4 (2) (2) dE dJ iEy iJ(x−y) = PS |=N j (0)gA (Jn)=i (En)|PS ; (4.9.8) e e 2 2 where in the last equality we set E = P + − and J = P + z − , and n is the usual Sudakov vector. If a further integration over y is performed, one obtains a quark–quark–gluon correlation matrix where one of the quark ?elds and the gluon ?eld are evaluated at the same space–time
44
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168 Table 2 The quark distributions at twist 2 and 3a Quark distributions S
0
L
T
Twist 2
f(x)
Lf(x)
LT f(x)
Twist 3 (∗)
e(x) h(x)
hL (x) eL (x)
gT (x) fT (x)
a
S denotes the polarisation state of the parent hadron (0 indicates unpolarised). The asterisk indicates T -odd quantities.
point: AAij (x) =
dE iEx e PS |=N j (0)gA (En)=i (En)|PS : 2
(4.9.9)
The matrix AA (x; y) makes its appearance in the calculation of the hadronic tensor at the twist-three level. It contains four multiparton distributions GA , G˜ A , HA and EA ; and has the following structure: M AA (x; y) = {iGA (x; y) ⊥ S⊥ P= + G˜ A (x; y)S⊥ 5 P= 2 +HA (x; y)5N 5 ⊥ P= + EA (x; y) ⊥ P= }:
(4.9.10)
Time-reversal invariance implies that GA , G˜ A , HA and EA are real functions. By hermiticity G˜ A and HA are symmetric whereas GA and EA are antisymmetric under interchange of x and y. ˜ are indeed related to GA , G˜ A , HA and EA , in particular It turns out that g˜T (x); h˜L (x) and e(x) to the integrals over y of these functions. One ?nds, in fact, [46] xg˜T (x) = dy [GA (x; y) + G˜ A (x; y)]; (4.9.11a) ˜ (4.9.11b) xhL (x) = 2 dy HA (x; y); (4.9.11c) xe(x) ˜ = 2 dy EA (x; y): For future reference we give in conclusion the T -odd twist-three quark–quark correlation matrix, which contains three more distribution functions [16,47] M i A(x)|T -odd = fT (x) ⊥ S⊥ − i5N eL (x) 5 + h(x)[p=; n=] : (4.9.12) 2 2 We shall ?nd these distributions again in Section 7.3.1. The quark (and antiquark) distribution functions at leading twist and twist-three are collected in Table 2.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
45
4.10. Sum rules for the transversity distributions A noteworthy relation between the twist-three distribution hL and LT f, arising from Lorentz covariance, is [48] d ⊥(1) hL (x) = LT f(x) − (x); (4.10.1) h d x 1L where h⊥(1) 1L (x) has been de?ned in (4.9.5a). Combining (4.10.1) with (4.9.4b) and solving for we obtain [14] (quark mass terms are neglected) h⊥(1) 1L 1 1 dy dy ˜ ˜ LT f(y) + hL (x) − 2x (4.10.2) h (y): hL (x) = 2x 2 2 L y x x y On the other hand, solving for hL leads to
h⊥(1) 3 d 1L = xLT f(x) − xh˜L (x): (4.10.3) x dx x2 If the twist 3 interaction dependent distribution h˜L (x) is set to zero one obtains from (4.10.2) 1 dy LT f(y) (4.10.4) hL (x) = 2x 2 x y and from (4.10.3) and (4.10.1) 1 1 dy ⊥(1) 2 LT f(y): (4.10.5) h1L (x) = − xhL (x) = − x 2 2 x y Eq. (4.10.4) is the transversity analogue of the Wandzura–Wilczek (WW) sum rule [49] for the g1 and g2 structure functions, which reads 1 dy WW 2 2 (4.10.6) g2 (x; Q ) = − g1 (x; Q ) + g1 (y; Q2 ); x y where g2WW is the twist-two part of g2 . In partonic terms, in fact, the WW sum rule can be rewritten as (see (3.4.7)) 1 dy gT (x) = Lf(y); (4.10.7) x y which is analogous to (4.10.5) and can be derived from (4.9.4a) and from a relation for gT (x) similar to (4.10.1). 5. Transversity distributions in quantum chromodynamics As well-known, the principal e,ect of QCD on the naYZve parton model is to induce, via renormalisation, a (logarithmic) dependence on Q2 [50 –52], the energy scale at which the distributions are de?ned or (in other words) the resolution with which they are measured. The two techniques with which we shall exemplify the following discussions of this dependence and of the general calculational framework are the renormalisation group equations [53,54] (RGE)
46
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
applied to the operator–product expansion [55] (OPE) (providing a solid formal basis) and the ladder-diagram summation approach [56,57] (providing a physically more intuitive picture). The variation of the distributions as a function of energy scale may be expressed in the form of the standard DGLAP so-called evolution equations. Further consequences of higher-order QCD are mixing and, beyond the leading logarithmic (LL) approximation, eventual scheme ambiguity in the de?nitions of the various quark and gluon distributions; i.e., the densities lose their precise meaning in terms of real physical probability and require further conventional de?nition. In this section we shall examine the Q2 evolution of the transversity distribution at LO and NLO. In particular, we shall compare its evolution with that of both the unpolarised and helicity-dependent distributions. Such a comparison is especially relevant to the so-called So,er inequality [38], which involves all three types of distribution. The section closes with a detailed examination of the question of parton density positivity and the generalised so-called positivity bounds (of which So,er’s is then just one example). 5.1. The renormalisation group equations In order to establish our conventions for the de?nition of operators and their renormalisation, etc., it will be useful to briePy recall the RGE as applied to the OPE in QCD. Before doing so let us make two remarks related to the problem of scheme dependence. Firstly, in order to lighten the notation, where applicable and unless otherwise stated, all expressions will be understood to refer to the so-called minimal modi?ed subtraction (MS) scheme. A further complication that arises in the case of polarisation at NLO is the extension of 5 to d = 4 dimensions [58– 60]. An in-depth discussion of this problem is beyond the scope of the present review and the interested reader is referred to [61], where it is also considered in the context of transverse polarisation. For a generic composite operator O, the scale independent so-called bare (OB ) and renormalised (O(2 )) operators are related via a renormalisation constant Z(2 ), where is then the renormalisation scale: O(2 ) = Z −1 (2 )OB :
(5.1.1)
The scale dependence of O(2 ) is obtained by solving the RGE, which expressed in terms of the QCD coupling constant, /s = g2 =4, is 2
@O(2 ) + (/s (2 ))O(2 ) = 0; @2
(5.1.2)
where (/s (2 )), the anomalous dimension for the operator O(2 ), is de?ned by (/s (2 )) = 2
@ ln Z(2 ): @2
The formal solution is simply 2 2 O(Q ) = O( ) exp −
/s (Q2 )
/s (2 )
(5.1.3) (/s ) d/s ; <(/s )
(5.1.4)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
47
where <(/s ) is the RGE function governing the renormalisation scale dependence of the e,ective QCD coupling constant /s (2 ): <(/s ) = 2
@/s (2 ) : @2
(5.1.5)
At NLO the anomalous dimension (2 ) and the QCD <-function <(/s ) can then be expanded perturbatively as /s (0) /s 2 (1) (/s ) = + + O(/s3 ); (5.1.6) 2 2 / 2 /s s <1 + O(/s3 ) : (5.1.7) <(/s ) = − /s <0 + 4 4 4 2 2 2 The ?rst two coeKcients of the <-function are: <0 = 11 3 CG − 3 TF = 11 − 3 Nf and <1 = 3 (17CG − 2 10CG TF − 6CF TF ) = 102 − 38 3 Nf , where CG = Nc and CF = (Nc − 1)=2Nc are the usual Casimirs related, respectively, to the gluon and the fermion representations of the colour symmetry group, SU(Nc ), and TF = 12 Nf , for active quark Pavour number Nf . This leads to the following NLO expression for the QCD coupling constant: /s (Q2 ) 1 <1 ln ln Q2 =2 1− 2 ; (5.1.8) 4 <0 ln Q2 =2 <0 ln Q2 =2
where is the QCD scale parameter. A generic observable derived from the operator O may be de?ned by f(Q2 )∼PS |O(Q2 )|PS . Inserting the above expansions into (5.1.4), the NLO evolution equation for f(Q2 ) = O is then obtained (note that the equations apply directly to O if it already represents a physical observable): −2 (0) =<0 −(4 (1) =<1 −2 (0) =<0 ) f(Q2 ) /s (Q2 ) <0 + <1 /s (Q2 )=4 ; = f(2 ) /s (2 ) <0 + <1 /s (2 )=4
(5.1.9)
which, to NLO accuracy, may be expanded thus
/s (Q2 ) /s (2 )
−2 (0) =<0
/s (2 ) − /s (Q2 ) (1) <1 (0) 1+ − : <0 2<0
(5.1.9 )
In order to obtain physical hadronic cross-sections at NLO level, the NLO contribution to f has then to be combined with the NLO contribution to the relevant hard partonic cross-section; indeed, it is only this combination that is fully scheme independent. It turns out that the quantities typically measured experimentally (i.e., cross-sections, DIS structure functions or, more simply, quark distributions) are related via Mellin-moment transforms to expectation values of composite quark and gluon ?eld operators. The de?nition we adopt for the Mellin transform of structure functions, anomalous dimension, etc. is as
48
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
follows: 5 ; 6 f(n) =
0
1
d x xn−1 f(x):
(5.1.10)
We may also de?ne the Altarelli–Parisi [12] (AP) splitting function, P(x), as precisely the function of which the Mellin moments, Eq. (5.1.10), are just the anomalous dimensions, (n). Note that P(x) may be expanded in powers of the QCD coupling constant in a manner analogous to and therefore also depends on Q2 . In x-space the evolution equations may be written in the following schematic form: d f(x; Q2 ) = P(x; Q2 ) ⊗ f(x; Q2 ); (5.1.11) d ln Q2 where the symbol ⊗ stands for a convolution in x, 1 dy x g(x) ⊗ f(x) = f(y); g y y x
(5.1.12)
which becomes a simple product in Mellin-moment space. With these expressions it is then possible to perform numerical evolution either via direct integration of (5.1.11) using suitable parametric forms to ?t data, or in the form of (5:1:9 ) via inversion of the Mellin moments. The operators governing the twist-two 7 evolution of moments of the f1 ; g1 and h1 structure functions (in this section we shall use f1 , g1 and h1 to generically indicated unpolarised, helicity and transversity weighted parton densities respectively) are 8 Of1 (n) = S N 1 iD2 : : : iDn ;
(5.1.13a)
Og1 (n) = S N 5 1 iD2 : : : iDn ;
(5.1.13b)
Oh1 (n) = S N 5 1 2 iD3 : : : iDn :
(5.1.13c)
where the symbol S conventionally indicates symmetrisation over the indices 1 ; 2 ; : : : ; n while the symbol S indicates simultaneous antisymmetrisation over the indices 1 and 2 and symmetrisation over the indices 2 ; 3 ; : : : ; n . 5.2. QCD evolution at leading order The Q2 evolution coeKcients for f1 and g1 at LO have long been known while the LO Q2 evolution for h1 was ?rst speci?cally presented in [18]. However, the ?rst calculations of the one-loop anomalous dimensions related to the operators governing the evolution of LT q(x; Q2 ) date back, in fact, to early (though incomplete) work on the evolution of the transverse-spin DIS 5
The de?nition with n − 1 replaced by n is also found in the literature. We choose to write n as an argument to avoid confusion with the label indicating perturbation order. 7 There are, of course, possible higher-twist contributions too, but we shall ignore these here. 8 All composite operators appearing herein are to be considered implicitly traceless. 6
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
49
Fig. 13. Example one-loop diagrams contributing to the O(/s ) anomalous dimensions of LT q.
structure function g2 [62], which, albeit in an indirect manner, involves the operators of interest here. Mention (though again incomplete) may also be found in [63]. Following this, and with various approaches, the complete derivation of the complex system of evolution equations for the twist-three operators governing g2 was presented [35,64,65]. Among the operators mixing with the leading contributions one ?nds the following: O(n) = S m N 5 1 2 iD3 : : : iDn ;
(5.2.1)
where m is the (current) quark mass. It is immediately apparent that this is none other than the twist-two operator responsible for LT q(x), multiplied here however by a quark mass and thereby rendered twist three—its evolution is, of course, identical to the twist-two version. For reasons already mentioned, see for example Eq. (4.5.9) and the discussion following, calculation of the anomalous dimensions governing LT q(x) turns out to be surprisingly simpler than for the other twist-two structure functions, owing to its peculiar chiral-odd properties. Indeed, as we have seen, the gluon ?eld cannot contribute at LO in the case of spin-half hadrons as it would require helicity Pip of two units in the corresponding hadron–parton amplitude. Thus, in the case of baryons the evolution is of a purely non-singlet type. Note that this is no longer the case for targets of spin greater than one half and, as pointed out in [18], a separate contribution due to linear gluon polarisation is possible; we shall also consider the situation for spin-1 mesons and=or indeed photons in what follows. In dimensional regularisation (d = 4 − j dimensions) calculation of the anomalous dimensions requires evaluation of the 1= j poles in the diagrams depicted in Fig. 13 (recall that at this order there is no scheme dependence). Although not present in baryon scattering, the linearly polarised gluon distribution, LT g, can contribute to scattering involving polarised spin-1 mesons. Thus, to complete the discussion of leading-order evolution, we include here too the anomalous dimensions for this density. For the four cases that are diagonal in parton type (spin-averaged and helicity-weighted [12]; transversity and linear gluon polarisation [18]) one ?nds in Mellin-moment space: n 3 1 1 qq (n) = CF + −2 ; (5.2.2a) 2 n(n + 1) j j=1
L qq (n) = qq (n);
(5.2.2b)
50
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
3 LT qq (n) = CF − 2 2
LT gg (n) = CG
n 1 j=1
11 −2 6n
j
= qq (n) − CF
n 1 j=1
j
1 ; n(n + 1)
(5.2.2c)
− 2 TF :
3
(5.2.2d)
The equality expressed in Eq. (5.2.2b) is a direct consequence of fermion-helicity conservation by purely vector interactions in the limit of negligible fermion mass. The ?rst point to stress is the commonly growing negative value, for increasing n, indicative of the tendency of all the x-space distributions to migrate towards x = 0 with increasing Q2 . In other words, evolution has a degrading e,ect on the densities. Secondly, in contrast to the behaviour of both q and Lq, the anomalous dimensions governing LT q do not vanish for n = 0 and hence there is no sum rule associated with the tensor charge [14]. Moreover, comparison to Lq reveals that LT qq (n)¡L qq (n) for all n. This implies that for (hypothetically) identical starting distributions (i.e., LT q(x; Q02 ) = Lq(x; Q02 )), LT q(x; Q2 ) everywhere in x will fall more rapidly than Lq(x; Q2 ) with increasing Q2 . We shall return in more detail to this point in Section 5.5. For completeness, we also present the AP splitting functions (i.e., the x-space version of the 1 anomalous dimensions) (n) = 0 d x xn−1 P(x), for the pure fermion sector: 1 + x2 (0) = CF ; (5.2.3a) Pqq 1−x + (0) (0) = Pqq ; LPqq 1 + x2 (0) (0) − 1 + x = Pqq (z) − CF (1 − z); LT Pqq = CF 1−x +
(5.2.3b) (5.2.3c)
where the “plus” regularisation prescription is de?ned in Appendix C in Eq. (C.1) and we also have made use of the identity given in Eq. (C.2). Naturally, the plus prescription is to be ignored (0) (0) ¡LPqq is when multiplying functions that vanish at x = 1. Once again, the inequality LT Pqq manifest for all x¡1, indeed, one has (0) 1 2 [Pqq (x)
(0) (0) + LPqq (x)] − LT Pqq (x) = CF (1 − x) ¿ 0:
(5.2.4)
The non-mixing of the transversity distributions for quarks, LT q, and gluons, LT g, is a,orded a physical demonstration via the ladder-diagram summation technique. In Fig. 14 the general leading-order one-particle irreducible (1PI) kernels are displayed. If the four external lines are all quarks (i.e., a gluon rung, see Fig. 14a), the kernel is clearly diagonal (in parton type) and therefore contributes to the evolution of LT q. For the case in which one pair of external lines are quarks and the other gluons (i.e., a quark rung, see Figs. 14b and c), helicity conservation along the quark line in the chiral limit implies a vanishing contribution to transversity evolution. Likewise, the known properties of four-body amplitudes, namely t-channel helicity conservation, preclude any contribution that might mix the evolution of LT q and LT g.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
51
Fig. 14. The 1PI kernels contributing to the O(/s ) evolution of LT q in the axial gauge.
The same reasoning clearly holds at higher orders since the only manner for gluon and quark ladders to mix is via diagrams in which an incoming quark line connects to its Hermitianconjugate partner. Thus, quark-helicity conservation in the chiral limit will always protect against such contributions. Before continuing to NLO, a comment is in order here on the recent debate carried out in the literature [66 – 68] regarding the calculation of the anomalous dimensions for h1 and the validity of certain approaches. The authors of [66] attempt to calculate the anomalous dimensions relevant to h1 exploiting a method based on [69]. The motivation is that use of so-called time-ordered or old-fashioned perturbation theory in the WeizsYacker–Williams approximation [70,71] (as adopted in, e.g., [18]) encounters a serious diKculty: it is only applicable to the region x¡1 while the end-point (x = 1) contribution cannot be evaluated directly. Where there is some conservation law (e.g., quark number), then appeal to the resulting sum rule allows indirect extraction of this point (the usual -function contribution). In the case of transversity no such conserved quantum number exists and one might doubt the validity of such calculations. Indeed, the claim in [66] was that a direct calculation, based on a dispersion relation approach, yields a di,erent result to that reported in Eq. (5.2.3c) above. A priori, from a purely theoretical point of view, this apparent discrepancy is hard to credit: were it real, then it would imply precisely the type of ambiguity to which the singularity structure of the theory on the light-cone is supposedly immune. In [66] the anomalous dimensions are calculated via the one-loop corrections to the classic handbag diagram (see, e.g., Fig. 4) with, however, on-shell external quark states and no lower hadronic blob. In order to mimic the required chiral structure, one of the upper vertices is taken to be 5 and the other or 5 for g1 or h1 respectively. The results for g1 are in agreement with other approaches while the anomalous dimensions for h1 di,er in the coeKcient of the -function contribution. As the authors themselves point out, a careful examination of the calculation then reveals that, in the Feynman gauge they adopt, the single contribution leading to the di,erence arises owing to the scalar vertex (i.e., spin-Pip) correction. What casts doubt on such ?ndings is the fact that in a physical gauge, as used for example in the ladder-diagram summation approach [56,57] mentioned earlier, precisely all such vertex corrections are in fact absent (to this order in QCD). Moreover, it is just this property that gives rise, in that approach, to the universal short-distance behaviour, independent of the particular nature of the vertices involved. Various cross checks of these potentially disturbing ?ndings have been performed [67,68] with the conclusion that the original calculations are after all correct. In particular, BlYumlein
52
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
[68] has produced a very thorough appraisal of the situation. Moreover, he has uncovered a fatal conceptual oversight: the scalar current is not conserved. 9 To appreciate the relevance of this observation let us briePy recall the salient points of the RGE approach (for more detail the reader is referred to [68]). A product of two currents (as in the peculiar Compton amplitude under consideration) may be expanded as j1 (z)j2 (0) = C(n; z)O(n; 0); n
where typically then ji = jV; A (i.e., vector or axial vector currents) but here a scalar current jS must be introduced. The RGE for the Wilson coeKcients C(n; z) is D + j1 (g) + j2 (g) − O (n; g)]C(n; z) = 0;
where ji (g) and O (n; g) are the anomalous dimensions of the currents ji and the composite operators O(n) respectively, and (neglecting quark masses) the RG operator is de?ned as @ @ D = 2 2 + <(g) : @ @g Thus, the LL corrections to the Compton amplitude have coeKcients C (n; g) = j1 (g) + j2 (g) − O (n; g): The point then is that while in the better-known spin-averaged and helicity-weighted cases ji = 0 for both currents (axial and=or vector), the scalar current necessary for the transversity case is not conserved and jS = 0. Thus, in contrast to the former, C and − O do not coincide in the calculation for h1 . The discrepancy in [66] is due precisely to the neglect of jS . 5.3. QCD evolution at next-to-leading order Reliable QCD analysis of the sort of data samples we have come to expect in modern experiments requires full NLO accuracy. For this it is necessary to calculate both the anomalous dimensions to two-loop level and the constant terms (i.e., the part independent of ln Q2 ) of the so-called coeKcient function (or hard-scattering process) at the one-loop level, together, of course, with the two-loop <-function. The two-loop anomalous-dimension calculation for h1 has now been presented in three papers: [72,73] using the MS scheme in the Feynman gauge and [74] using the MS scheme in the light-cone gauge. These complement the earlier two-loop calculations for the better-known twist-two structure functions: f1 [75 –81] and g1 [82–84]. Such knowledge has been exploited in the past for the phenomenological parametrisation of f1 [85 –87] and g1 [88–90] in order to perform global analyses of the experimental data; and will certainly be of value when the time comes to analyse data on transversity. The situation at NLO is still relatively simple, as compared to the unpolarised or helicityweighted cases. Examples of the relevant two-loop diagrams are shown in Fig. 15. It remains impossible for the gluon to contribute, for the reasons already given. The only complication is the usual mixing, possible at this level, between quark and antiquark distributions, for which 9
We are particularly grateful to Johannes BlYumlein for illuminating discussion on this point
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
53
Fig. 15. Example two-loop diagrams contributing at O(/s2 ) to the anomalous dimensions of LT q.
quark helicity conservation poses no restriction since the quark and antiquark lines do not connect directly to one another, see Fig. 15d. It is convenient to introduce the following combinations of quark transversity distributions (the ± subscript is not to be confused with helicity): LT q± (n) = LT q(n) ± LT q(n); N
(5.3.1a)
(n); LT q˜+ (n) = LT q+ (n) − LT q+
(5.3.1b)
LT M(n) =
LT q+ (n);
(5.3.1c)
q
where q and q represent quarks of di,ering Pavours. The speci?c evolution equations may then be written as (e.g., see [91]) d LT q− (n; Q2 ) = LT qq; − (n; /s (Q2 ))LT q− (n; Q2 ); d ln Q2
(5.3.2a)
d LT q˜+ (n; Q2 ) = LT qq; + (n; /s (Q2 ))LT q˜+ (n; Q2 ); d ln Q2
(5.3.2b)
d LT M(n; Q2 ) = LT MM (n; /s (Q2 ))LT M(n; Q2 ): d ln Q2
(5.3.2c)
Note that the ?rst moment (n = 1) in Eq. (5.3.2a) corresponds to evolution of the nucleon’s tensor charge [14,19,92]. The splitting functions LT qq; ± and LT MM have expansions in powers
54
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
of the coupling constant that take the following form: / / 2 s s LT ii (n; /s ) = LT (0) LT (1) (5.3.3) qq (n) + ii (n) + · · · ; 2 2 where {ii} = {qq; ±}; {MM} and we have taken into account the fact that LT qq; + , LT qq; − and LT MM are all equal at LO. It is convenient then to introduce [91] (1) (1) LT (1) qq; ± (n) = LT qq (n) ± LT qqN (n);
(5.3.4a)
(1) (1) LT (1) MM (n) = LT qq; + (n) + LT qq; PS (n):
(5.3.4b)
Since it turns out that LT (1) qq; PS (n) = 0, the two evolution equations (5.3.2b), (5.3.2c) may be replaced by a single equation: d LT q+ (n; Q2 ) = LT qq; + (n; /s (Q2 ))LT q+ (n; Q2 ): (5.3.2b ) d ln Q2 The formal solution to Eqs. (5.3.2a) and (5.3.2b ) is well-known (e.g., see [93]) and reads /s (Q02 ) − /s (Q2 ) <1 (1) 2 (0) LT qq; ± (n) − LT qq (n) LT q± (n; Q ) = 1 + <0 2<0 ×
(0)
(Q2 )
/s /s (Q02 )
−2LT< qq (n) 0
LT q± (n; Q02 );
(5.3.5)
with the input distributions LT q± (n; Q02 ) given at the input scale Q0 . Of course, the corresponding LO expressions may be recovered from the above expressions by setting the NLO quantities, LT (1) ij; ± and <1 , to zero. In the MS scheme the (1) (n) relevant to h1 are as follows: 10 2 3 LT (1) qq; J (n) = CF { 8 +
2 n(n+1) J−
˜ − 3S2 (n) − 4S1 (n)[S2 (n) − S2 (n=2)] − 8S(n) + S3 (n=2)}
134 22 + 12 CF Nc { 17 12 − (2=m(n + 1))J− − 9 S1 (n)+ 3 S2 (n)+4S1 (n)[2S2 (n) − S2 (n=2)]
˜ − S3 (n=2)} + 23 CF TF {− 14 + + 8S(n)
10 3 S1 (n)
− 2S2 (n)};
where J = ± and the S functions are de?ned by n j −k ; Sk (n) = j=1
Sk ( n2 ) = 2k ˜ = S(n)
n
n
j −k ;
(5.3.7a) (5.3.7b)
j=2;even
(−1)j S1 (j)j −2 :
j=1 10
(5.3.6)
Note that 23 S1 (n) in the second line of (A:8) in [77] should read 23 S3 (n).
(5.3.7c)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
55
Fig. 16. Comparison between f1 and h1 of the variation with n of (a) the two-loop anomalous dimensions (1) n for Nf = 3 (circles) and 5 (triangles), and (b) the combination (1) (n)=2<1 − (0) (n)=2<0 for Nf = 3 and 5; from [72].
Fig. 17. The LO and NLO Q2 -evolution of (a) the tensor charge and (b) the second moments of h1 (x; Q2 ) and f1 (x; Q2 ) (both are normalised at Q2 = 1 GeV2 ), from [72].
In Fig. 16 we show the n dependence of the two-loop anomalous dimensions (as presented in [72] 11 ). From the ?gure, one clearly sees that for n small, LT (1) (n) is signi?cantly larger than (1) (n) but, with growing n, very quickly approaches (1) (n) while maintaining the inequality LT (1) (n)¿ (1) (n). For the speci?c moments n = 1 (corresponding to the tensor charge) and n = 2, we display the Q2 variation in Fig. 17. To express the corresponding results in x space it is convenient to introduce the following de?nitions: 12 2x ; (1 − x)+ 1+x 1 dz 1−z 1 = − 2Li2 (−x) − 2 ln x ln(1 + x) + ln2 x − 2 ; S2 (x) = x ln z z 2 6 LT R(0) (x) =
(5.3.8) (5.3.9)
1+x
11
According to the convention adopted for the moments in [72], n = 0 there corresponds to n = 1 in the present report. 12 In order to avoid confusion with the tensor-charge anomalous dimensions, the notation adopted here corresponding to LT R(0) (x) is di,erent than that commonly adopted.
56
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where Li2 (x) is the usual dilogarithm function. In the MS scheme, de?ning (1) (1) (1) LT Pqq; ± (x) = LT Pqq (x) ± LT PqqN (x);
(5.3.10)
cf. Eq. (5.3.4a), one then has (1) LT Pqq (x) = CF2 {1 − x − [ 32 + 2 ln(1 − x)] ln xLT R(0) (x) + [ 38 − 12 2 + 6O(3)](1 − x)}
+ 12 CF CG {−(1 − x) + [ 67 9 + + [ 17 12 +
11 2 9
11 3
ln x + ln2 x − 13 2 ]LT R(0) (x)
− 6O(3)](1 − x)}
+ 23 CF TF {[ − ln x − 53 ]LT R(0) (x) − [ 14 + 13 2 ](1 − x)}; (0) 1 LT Pq(1) qN (x) = CF [CF − 2 CG ]{−(1 − x) + 2S2 (x)LT R (−x)};
(5.3.11a) (5.3.11b)
where O(3) ≈ 1:202057 is the usual Riemann Zeta function. Note that the plus prescription is to be ignored in LT R(0) (−x). To complete this section we also report on the corresponding NLO calculation for linear (transverse) gluon polarisation [94]. As already noted, LT g is precluded in the case of spin-half hadrons—it may, however, be present in objects of spin one, such as the deuteron or indeed even the photon [95]. " 2 (1) (0) 1 1 2 LT Pgg (x) = CG2 ( 67 18 + 2 ln x − 2 ln x ln(1 − x) − 6 )LT R (x) 1 − x3 (0) 8 + + S2 (x)LT R (−x) + ( 3 + 3O(3))(1 − x) 6x 1 − x3 4 (0) 10 + CG TF − 9 LT R (x) + − 3 (1 − x) 3x 2(1 − x3 ) − CF TF + (1 − x) : 3x
(5.3.12)
The corresponding expression in Mellin-moment space for the anomalous dimensions is 13 1 1 n 67 (1) 2 8 n ˜ LT gg (n) = CG + + S1 (n)(2S2 ( ) − ) + S3 ( ) − 4S(n) 3 2(n − 1)(n + 2) 2 9 2 2 1 4 20 n(n + 1) − CF TF + CG TF − + S1 (n) + : (5.3.13) 3 9 (n − 1)(n + 2) (n − 1)(n + 2) As noted in [94] the result for the part ∼CF TF in (5.3.12) was presented in [95] for the region x¡1 (corresponding to the two-loop splitting function for linearly polarised gluons into photons). However, the two calculations appear to be at variance: the results of [95] imply a small-x behaviour of O(1=x2 ) for the relevant splitting function, which would then be more singular than the unpolarised case. 13
We are very grateful to Werner Vogelsang for providing us with the exact expression.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
57
There are two aspects of the splitting function (5.3.12) that warrant particular comment. Firstly, the small-x behaviour changes signi?cantly on going from LO to NLO. At LO, the splitting function is O(x) for x → 0 whereas at NLO there are O(1=x) terms (as in the unpolarised case): we have (1) LT Pgg (x) ≈
1 (N 2 + 2Nc TF − 4CF TF ) + O(x) 6x c
(x → 0):
(5.3.14)
Notice that all logarithmic terms ∼x ln2 x cancel in this limiting region. The second comment regards the so-called supersymmetric limit: namely CF = Nc = 2TF [65], which was investigated for the unpolarised and longitudinally polarised NLO splitting functions in [82–84,96], for the time-like case in [97] and for the case of transversity in [94]. In the supersymmetric limit the LO splitting functions for quark transversity and for linearly polarised gluons are equal [18,95]: 3 2x (0) (0) LT Pqq (x) = Nc + (1 − x) = LPgg (x): (5.3.15) (1 − x)+ 2 Hence, we may consider linear polarisation of the gluon as the supersymmetric partner to transversity (see also [65]). Indeed, as was natural, we have already applied the terminology without distinction to spin-half and spin-one. In [94] the check was performed that the supersymmetric relation still holds at NLO. To do so it is necessary to transform to a regularisation scheme that respects supersymmetry, namely dimensional reduction. As noted in [94] the transformation is rendered essentially trivial owing to the absence of O(j) terms in the d-dimensional LO splitting functions for transversity or linearly polarised gluons at x¡1; such terms are always absent in dimensional reduction but may be present in dimensional regularisation. Thus, at NLO the results for the splitting functions for quark transversity—see Eqs. (5.3.11a), (5.3.11b)—and for linearly polarised gluons, Eq. (5.3.12), automatically coincide for x¡1 with their respective MS expressions in dimensional reduction. These expressions may therefore be immediately compared in the supersymmetric limit and indeed for CF = Nc = 2TF (1) (1) LT Pqq; + (x) ≡ LT Pgg (x)
(x¡1):
(5.3.16)
Note, in addition, that the supersymmetric relation is trivially satis?ed for x = 1; see [83,84], where the appropriate factorisation-scheme transformation to dimensional reduction for x = 1 is given. 5.4. Evolution of the transversity distributions The interest in the e,ects of evolution in the case of transversity is two-fold: ?rst, there is the obvious question of the relative magnitude of the distributions at high energies given some low-energy starting point (e.g., a non-perturbative model calculation, for a detailed discussion and examples see Section 8) and second is the problem raised by the So,er inequality. It is to the ?rst that we now address our attention while we shall deal with latter shortly.
58
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Let us for the moment simply pose the question of the e,ect of QCD evolution [72,74,94, 98–112] on the overall magnitude of the transversity densities that might be constructed at some low-energy scale. As already noted above, there is no conservation rule associated with the tensor charge of the nucleon (cf. the vector and axial-vector charges) and, indeed, the sign of the anomalous dimensions at both LO and NLO is such that the ?rst moment of h1 falls with increasing Q2 . Thus, one immediately deduces that the tensor charge will eventually disappear in comparison to the vector and axial charges. Such behaviour could have a dramatic impact on the feasibility of high-energy measurement of h1 and thus requires careful study. A analytic functional form for the LO anomalous dimensions governing the evolution of h1 is LT (0) (n) = 43 { 32 − 2[ (n + 1) + E ]};
(5.4.1)
where (z) = d ln D(z)=d z is the digamma function and E = 0:5772157 is the Euler–Mascheroni constant. Since LT (0) (1) =− 23 , the ?rst moment of h1 and the tensor charges, q = 01 d x(LT q− LT q), N decrease with Q2 as
/s (Q2 ) q(Q ) = /s (Q02 ) 2
−2LT (0) qq (1)=<0
q(Q02 ) =
/s (Q02 ) /s (Q2 )
−4=27
q(Q02 );
(5.4.2)
where, to obtain the second equality, we have set Nf = 3. Despite the smallness of the exponent,
−4=27, we shall see that the evolution of LT q(x; Q2 ) is rather di,erent from that of the helicity
distributions Lq(x; Q2 ), especially for small x. At NLO this becomes
−2LT (0) qq (1)=<0 /s (Q2 ) q(Q ) = /s (Q02 ) /s (Q02 ) − /s (Q2 ) <1 (1) (0) × 1+ LT qq; − (1) − LT qq (1) q(Q02 ) <0 2<0 2
/s (Q2 ) = /s (Q02 )
4 27
337 2 2 1− (/s (Q0 ) − /s (Q )) ; 486
(5.4.3)
where in the second equality we have used LT (1) qq; − (1) =
19 2 257 13 181 13 CF − CF Nc + CF TF = − + Nf ; 8 72 18 18 27
(5.4.4)
and we have once again set Nf = 3. Recall that the ?rst moments of the q → qg polarised and unpolarised splitting functions, vanish to all orders in perturbation theory and that the g → qqN polarised anomalous dimension L qg (1) is zero at LO; thus, Lq(Q2 ) is constant. This can be seen analytically by the following argument [99] based on the double-log approximation. The leading behaviour of the parton distributions for small x is governed by the rightmost singularity of their anomalous dimensions in Mellin-moment space. From Eq. (5.4.1) we see that this singularity is located at n = − 1 for
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
59
Fig. 18. Evolution of the helicity and transversity distributions for the u Pavour [99]. The dashed curve is the input LT u = Lu at Q02 = 0:23 GeV2 taken from the GRV [114] parametrisation. The solid (dotted) curve is LT u (Lu) at Q2 = 25 GeV2 . The dot-dashed curve is the result of the evolution of LT u at Q2 = 25 GeV2 driven by Pqq , i.e., with the term LT P in Ph turned o,.
LT q at LO. Expanding LT (n) around this point gives 8 LT (n)∼ + O(1): 3(n + 1)
(5.4.5)
Equivalently, in x-space, expanding the splitting function LT P in powers of x yields 8 LT P(x)∼ x + O(x2 ): (5.4.6) 3 In contrast, the rightmost singularity for Lq in moment space is located at n = 0 and the splitting functions LPqq and LPqg behave as constants as x → 0. Therefore, owing to QCD evolution, LT q acquires and an extra suppression factor of one power of x with respect to Lq at small x. We note too that at NLO the rightmost singularity for LT q is located at n = 0, so that NLO evolution renders the DGLAP asymptotics for x → 0 in the case of transversity compatible with Regge theory [113]. As mentioned earlier, this problem may be investigated numerically by integrating the DGLAP equations (5.1.11) with suitable starting input for h1 and g1 . As a reasonable trial model one may assume the various LT q and Lq to be equal at some small scale Q02 and then allow the two types of distributions to evolve separately, each according to its own evolution equations. The input hypothesis LT q(x; Q02 ) = Lq(x; Q02 ) is suggested by various quark-model calculations of LT q and Lq [14,98] (see also Section 8 here), in which these two distributions are found to be very similar at a scale Q02 . 0:5 GeV2 . For Lq(x; Q02 ), we then use the leading-order GlYuck–Reya–Vogelsang (GRV) parametrisation [114], whose input scale is Q02 = 0:23 GeV2 . The result for the u-quark distributions is shown in Fig. 18 (the situation is similar for the other Pavours). The dashed line is the input, the solid line and the dotted line are the results of the evolution of LT u and Lu, respectively, at Q2 = 25 GeV2 . For completeness, the evolution of LT u when driven only by Pqq —i.e., with the LT P term turned o,, see Eq. (5:2:3c)—is also shown (dot-dashed line). The large di,erence in the evolution of LT u (solid curve) and Lu
60
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 19. Comparison of the Q2 -evolution of LT u(x; Q2 ) and Lu(x; Q2 ) at (a) LO and (b) NLO, from [72].
N Q2 ) and Lu(x; Fig. 20. Comparison of the NLO Q2 -evolution of LT u(x; N Q2 ), LT d(x; N Q2 ), from [72].
(dotted curve) at small x is evident. Note also the di,erence between the correct evolution of LT u and the evolution driven purely by Pqq (dot-dashed curve). As a further comparison of the behaviour of h1 and g1 , in Figs. 19(a) and (b) we display the LO and NLO Q2 -evolution of LT u and Lu, starting, respectively, from the LO and NLO input function for Lu given in [88] for Q2 = 0:23 and 0:34 GeV2 . Although LO evolution leads to a signi?cant divergence between LT u and Lu at Q2 = 20 GeV2 , 14 this tendency is strengthened by the NLO evolution, in particular, in the small-x region. Although the evolution of Lu shown in Fig. 19 is a,ected by mixing with the gluon distribution, the non-singlet quark distributions also show the same trend. In Fig. 20, we compare the NLO Q2 -evolution of LT u, N LT dN and Lu, N starting from the same input distribution function (the NLO input function for the sea-quark distribution to g1 given in 14
Such a di,erence was also pointed out in [100].
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
61
[88]). The di,erence between LT uN and LuN is again signi?cant. Although the input sea-quark distribution is taken to be Pavour symmetric (LT uN = LT dN at Q2 = 0:34 GeV2 ), NLO evolution violates this symmetry owing to the appearance of LT Pq(1) qN —see (5.3.11b). However, this e,ect is very small, as is evident from Fig. 20 and discussed in [105]. 5.5. Evolution of the So>er inequality and general positivity constraints Particular interest in the e,ects of evolution arises in connection with the So,er inequality [38], Eq. (4.6.6). It has been argued [115] that this inequality, which was derived within a parton model framework, may be spoilt by radiative corrections, much as the Callan–Gross relation. Such an analogy, however, is somewhat misleading, since the So,er inequality is actually very similar to the more familiar positivity bound |Lq(x)| 6 q(x). The LO evolution of the inequality is governed by Eq. (5.2.4) and hence it is not endangered, as pointed out in [99]. At NLO the situation is complicated by the well-known problems of scheme dependence, etc. Indeed, it is perhaps worth remarking that the entire question of positivity is ill-de?ned beyond LO, inasmuch as the parton distributions themselves as physical quantities become ill-de?ned: a priori there is no guarantee in a given scheme that any form of positivity will survive higher-order corrections. This observation may, of course, be turned on its head and used to impose conditions on the scheme choice such that positivity will be guaranteed [116]. At any rate, if this is possible then at the hadronic level any natural positivity bounds should be respected, independently of the regularisation scheme applied. An instructive and rather general manner to examine the problem is to recast the system of evolution equations into a form analogous to the Boltzmann equation [101]. First of all, let us rewrite Eq. (5.1.11) in a slightly more suggestive form for the non-singlet case: 1 dq(x; t) dy x (5.5.1) = P ; t q(y; t); dt y x y where t = ln Q2 . One may thus interpret the equation as describing the time, t, evolution of densities, f(x; t), in a one-dimensional x space. The Pow is constrained to run from large to small x owing to the ordering x¡y under the integral. Such an interpretation facilitates dealing with the infrared (IR) singularities present in the expressions for P(x). Indeed, a key element is provided by consideration of precisely the IR singularities [117,118]. Let us now rewrite the plus regularisation in the following form: 1 dy P+ (x; t) = P(x; t) − (1 − x) P(y; t); (5.5.2) 0 y which then permits the evolution equations to be rewritten as 1 1 dy x dq(x; t) dy P(y; t): = q(y; t)P ; t − q(x; t) dt y x y 0
(5.5.3)
Reading the second term as describing the Pow of partons at the point x [117], the kinetic interpretation is immediate. It is useful to render the analogy more direct by the change of variables
62
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
y → y=x in the second term, leading to the following more symmetric form: x 1 y dq(x; t) dy x dy = q(y; t)P ;t − q(x; t)P ;t : dt y x x y 0 x
(5.5.4)
In this fashion the equation has been translated into a form analogous to the Boltzmann equation: namely, 1 dq(x; t) dy[(y → x; t)q(y; t) − (x → y; t)q(x; t)]; (5.5.5) = dt 0 where the one-dimensional analogue of the Boltzmann “scattering probability” may be de?ned as 1 x (y → x; t) = Q(y − x) P (5.5.6) ;t : y y Cancellation of the IR divergencies between contributions involving real and virtual gluons is therefore seen to occur as a consequence of the continuity condition on “particle number”; i.e., the equality of Pow in and out in the neighbourhood of y = x in both terms of Eq. (5.5.5). In the spin-averaged case the particle density (at some initialisation point) is positive by definition. Now, the negative second term in Eq. (5.5.5) cannot change the sign of the distribution because it is “diagonal” in x, i.e., it is proportional to the function at the same point x. When the distribution is suKciently close to zero, it stops decreasing. This is true for both “plus” and (1 − x) terms, for any value of their coeKcients (if positive, it only reinforces positivity of the distribution). Turning next to the spin-dependent case, for simplicity we consider ?rst the Pavour non-singlet and allow the spin-dependent and spin-independent kernels to be di,erent, as they indeed are at NLO. Rather than the usual helicity sums and di,erences, it turns out to be convenient to cast the equations in terms of de?nite parton helicities. Although such a form mixes contributions of di,erent helicities, the positivity properties emerge more clearly. We thus have dq+ (x; t) = P++ (x; t) ⊗ q+ (x; t) + P+− (x; t) ⊗ q− (x; t); dt
(5.5.7a)
dq− (x; t) = P+− (x; t) ⊗ q+ (x; t) + P++ (x; t) ⊗ q− (x; t); dt
(5.5.7b)
where P+± (z; t) = 12 [P(z; t) ± LP(z; t)] are the evolution kernels for helicity non-Pip and Pip, respectively. For x¡y, positivity of the initial distributions, q± (x; t0 ) ¿ 0 or |Lq(x; t0 )| 6 q(x; t0 ), is preserved if both kernels P+± are positive, which is true if |LP(z; t)| 6 P(z; t)
(z¡1):
(5.5.8)
Terms that are singular at z = 1 cannot alter positivity as they only appear in the diagonal (in helicity) kernel, P++ ; non-forward scattering is completely IR safe. Once again in the kinetic interpretation, the distributions q+ and q− stop decreasing on approaching zero.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
63
To extend the proof to include the case in which there is quark–gluon mixing is trivial—we need the full expressions for the evolutions of quark and gluon distributions of each helicity: dq+ (x; t) qq qq (x; t) ⊗ q+ (x; t) + P+− (x; t) ⊗ q− (x; t) = P++ dt qg qg + P++ (x; t) ⊗ g+ (x; t) + P+− (x; t) ⊗ g− (x; t);
(5.5.9a)
dq− (x; t) qg qg (x; t) ⊗ q+ (x; t) + P++ (x; t) ⊗ q− (x; t) = P+− dt qg qg + P+− (x; t) ⊗ g+ (x; t) + P++ (x; t) ⊗ g− (x; t);
(5.5.9b)
dg+ (x; t) gq gq (x; t) ⊗ q+ (x; t) + P+− (x; t) ⊗ q− (x; t) = P++ dt gg gg (x; t) ⊗ g+ (x; t) + P+− (x; t) ⊗ g− (x; t); + P++
(5.5.9c)
dg− (x; t) gq gq (x; t) ⊗ q+ (x; t) + P++ (x; t) ⊗ q− (x; t) = P+− dt gg gg (x; t) ⊗ g+ (x; t) + P++ (x; t) ⊗ g− (x; t): + P+−
(5.5.9d)
Since inequality (5.5.8) is clearly valid separately for each type of parton [116], |LPij (z; t)| 6 Pij (z; t)
(z¡1; i; j = q; g);
(5.5.10)
all the kernels appearing on the r.h.s. of this system, are positive. With regard to the singular terms, they are again diagonal (in parton type here) and hence cannot a,ect positivity. The validity of the equations at LO is guaranteed via their derivation, just as the (positive) helicity-dependent kernels were in fact ?rst calculated in [12]. At NLO, the situation is more complex [116]. To conclude, the maintenance of positivity under Q2 evolution has two sources: (a) inequalities (5.5.10), leading to the increase of distributions and (b) the kinetic interpretation of the decreasing terms. For the latter, it is crucial that they are diagonal in x, helicity and also parton type, which is a prerequisite for their IR nature. We now ?nally return to the So,er inequality: in analogy with the previous analysis, it is convenient to de?ne the following “super” distributions: Q+ (x) = q+ (x) + LT q(x);
(5.5.11a)
Q− (x) = q+ (x) − LT q(x):
(5.5.11b)
According to the So,er inequality, both distributions are positive at some scale (say Q02 ) and the evolution equations for the non-singlet case take the form (henceforth the argument t will be suppressed) dQ+ (x) Q Q (x) ⊗ Q+ (x) + P+− (x) ⊗ Q− (x); (5.5.12a) = P++ dt dQ− (x) Q Q (x) ⊗ Q+ (x) + P++ (x) ⊗ Q− (x); (5.5.12b) = P+− dt
64
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where the “super” kernels at LO are just Q (0) (z) = 12 [Pqq (z) P++
+
Ph(0) (z)] =
1 (1 + z)2 + 3(1 − z) ; CF 2 (1 − z)+
Q (0) P+− (z) = 12 [Pqq (z) − Ph(0) (z)] = 12 CF (1 − z):
(5.5.13a) (5.5.13b)
One can easily see, that the inequalities analogous to (5.5.10) are satis?ed, so that both Q Q (z) and P+− (z) are positive for z¡1, while the singular term appears only in the diagonal P++ kernel. Thus, both requirements are ful?lled and the So,er inequality is maintained under LO evolution. The extension to the singlet case is trivial owing to the exclusion of gluon mixing. Therefore, only evolution of quarks is a,ected, leading to the presence of the same extra terms on the r.h.s., as in Eq. (5.5.9a): dQ+ (x) qG qG Q Q (x) ⊗ Q+ (x) + P+− (x) ⊗ Q− (x) + P+− (x) ⊗ G+ (x) + P++ (x) ⊗ G− (x); = P++ dt (5.5.14a) dQ− (x) qG qG Q Q (x) ⊗ Q+ (x) + P++ (x) ⊗ Q− (x) + P+− (x) ⊗ G+ (x) + P++ (x) ⊗ G− (x); = P+− dt (5.5.14b) which are all positive and singularity free; this concludes the demonstration that positivity is indeed preserved. 6. Transversity in semi-inclusive leptoproduction While it is usual to adopt DIS as the de?ning process and point of reference when discussing distribution functions, as repeatedly noted and explicitly shown in Section 3, the case of transversity is somewhat special in that it does not appear in DIS. However, owing to the topology of the contributing Feynman diagrams, transversity does play a rˆole in semi-inclusive DIS, owing to the presence of two hadrons: one in the initial state and the other in the ?nal state [17,18,20,119 –122]. This process is the subject of the present section. 6.1. DeFnitions and kinematics Semi-inclusive—or, to be more precise, single-particle inclusive—leptoproduction (see Fig. 21) is a DIS reaction in which a hadron h, produced in the current fragmentation region, is detected in the ?nal state (for the general formalism see [15,123]) l(‘) + N (P) → l (‘ ) + h(Ph ) + X (PX ):
(6.1.1)
With a transversely polarised target, one can measure quark transverse polarisation at leading twist either by looking at a possible asymmetry in the Ph⊥ distribution of the produced hadron (the so-called Collins e,ect [15 –17,124]), or by polarimetry of a transversely polarised ?nal hadron (for instance, a 0 hyperon) [15,18,125,126]. Transversity distributions also appear in the Ph⊥ -integrated cross-section at higher twist [15,120].
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
65
Fig. 21. Semi-inclusive deeply inelastic scattering.
Fig. 22. Lepton and hadron planes in semi-inclusive leptoproduction.
We de?ne the invariants x=
Q2 ; 2P · q
y=
P·q ; P·‘
z=
P · Ph : P·q
(6.1.2)
We shall be interested in the limit where Q2 ≡ −q2 ; P · q; Ph · q and Ph · P become large while x and z remain ?nite. The geometry of the process is shown in Fig. 22. The lepton scattering plane is identi?ed by l and l . The virtual photon is taken to move along the z-axis. The three-momenta of the virtual photon q and of the produced hadron Ph de?ne a second plane, which we call the hadron plane. The spin S of the nucleon and the spin Sh of the produced hadron satisfy S 2 = Sh2 = − 1 and S · P = Sh · Ph = 0. The cross-section for the reaction (6:1:1) is 1 d 3 PX d = 4‘ · P s X (2)3 2EX l
×(2)4 4 (P + ‘ − PX − Ph − ‘ )|M|2
d 3 l d 3 Ph ; (2)3 2E (2)3 2Eh
(6.1.3)
66
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where we have summed over the spin sl of the outgoing lepton. The squared matrix element in (6:1:3) is |M|2 =
e4 [u (‘ ; sl ) ul (‘; sl )]∗ [ul (‘ ; sl ) ul (‘; sl )] q4 l ×X; Ph Sh |J (0)|PS ∗ X; Ph Sh |J (0)|PS :
(6.1.4)
Introducing the leptonic tensor [ul (‘ ; sl ) ul (‘; sl )]∗ [ul (‘ ; sl ) ul (‘; sl )] L = sl
= 2(‘ ‘ + ‘ ‘ − g ‘ · ‘ ) + 2i5l
! ‘
!
q
(6.1.5)
and the hadronic tensor d 3 PX 1 W = (2)4 4 (P + q − PX − Ph ) (2)4 X (2)3 2EX ×PS |J (0)|X; Ph Sh X; Ph Sh |J (0)|PS
(6.1.6)
the cross-section becomes d =
1 e4 d 3 l d 3 Ph 4 L W (2) : 4‘ · P Q4 (2)3 2E (2)3 2Eh
(6.1.7)
In the target rest frame (‘ · P = ME) one has 2Eh
2 d /em E = L W : d 3 Ph dE d\ 2MQ4 E
(6.1.8)
In terms of the invariants x, y and z, Eq. (6.1.8) reads 2Eh
2 y /em d L W : = d 3 Ph d x dy Q4
(6.1.9)
If we decompose the momentum Ph of the produced hadron into a longitudinal (Ph|| ) and a transverse (Ph⊥ ) component with respect to the ∗ N axis and if |Ph⊥ | is small compared to the energy Eh , then we can write approximately 1 d 3 Ph = d z d 2 Ph⊥ ; 2Eh 2z
(6.1.10)
and re-express Eq. (6.1.9) as 2 y d /em = L W : d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ 2Q4 z
(6.1.11)
Instead of working in a ∗ N collinear frame, it is often convenient to work in a frame where the target nucleon and the produced hadron move collinearly (the hN collinear frame, see Appendix B.2). In this frame the virtual photon has a transverse momentum qT , which is related to Ph⊥ , up to 1=Q2 corrections, by qT −Ph⊥ =z. Thus Eq. (6.1.11) can be
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
67
written as 2 d /em = yzL W : d x dy d z d 2 qT 2Q4
(6.1.12)
Let us now evaluate the leptonic tensor. In the ∗ N collinear frame the lepton momenta can be parametrised in terms of the Sudakov vectors p and n as x Q2 ‘ = (1 − y)p + ; n + ‘⊥ y 2xy
(6.1.13a)
x Q2 (1 − y) ‘ = p + n + ‘⊥ y 2xy
(6.1.13b)
2 = ((1 − y)=y 2 ) Q 2 . The symmetric part of the leptonic tensor then becomes with l⊥
L(S) = −
Q2 4(1 − y) [1 + (1 − y)2 ]g⊥ + t t y2 y2
4Q2 (1 − y) 2(2 − y) + )+ (t ‘⊥ + t ‘⊥ y y2
‘⊥ ‘⊥ 1 + g⊥ ; 2 2 l⊥
where t = 2xp + q ; the antisymmetric part reads 2 Q (2 − y) ! Q2 ! ! (A) = 5l ! L p n + ‘ n − 2x‘⊥ p : y x ⊥
(6.1.14a)
(6.1.14b)
At leading-twist level, only semi-inclusive DIS processes with an unpolarised lepton beam probe the transverse polarisation distributions of quarks [15]. Therefore, in what follows, we shall focus on this case and take only the target nucleon (and, possibly, the outgoing hadron) to be polarised. At twist-three there are also semi-inclusive DIS reactions with polarised leptons, which allow extracting LT f. For these higher-twist processes we shall limit ourselves to presenting the cross-sections without derivation. 6.2. The parton model In the parton model the virtual photon strikes a quark (or antiquark), which later fragments into a hadron h. The process is depicted in Fig. 23. The relevant diagram is the handbag diagram with an upper blob representing the fragmentation process. Referring to Fig. 23 for the notation, the hadronic tensor is given by (for simplicity we consider only the quark contribution) 1 2 d 3 PX d4 k d4 W = e (2)4 a a X (2)3 2EX (2)4 (2)4 ×(2)4 4 (P − k − PX )(2)4 4 (k + q − )(2)4 4 ( − Ph − PX ) ×[1(; N Ph ; Sh ) =(k; P; S)]∗ [1(; N Ph ; Sh ) =(k; P; S)];
(6.2.1)
68
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 23. Diagram contributing to semi-inclusive DIS at LO.
where =(k; P; S) and 1(; Ph ; Sh ) are matrix elements of the quark ?eld
, de?ned as
=(k; P; S) = X | (0)|PS ;
(6.2.2)
1(; Ph ; Sh ) = 0| (0)|Ph Sh ; X :
(6.2.3)
We now introduce the quark–quark correlation matrices d 3 PX (2)4 4 (PX + k − P)=i (k; P; S)=N j (k; P; S) Aij (k; P; S) = 3 2E (2) X X = d 4 eik· PS | N j (0) i ()|PS and Rij (; Ph ; Sh ) = =
X
d 3 PX (2)4 4 (Ph + PX − )1i (; Ph ; Sh )1Nj (; Ph ; Sh ) (2)3 2EX
X
d 3 PX (2)3 2EX
d 4 ei· 0| i ()|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N j (0)|0:
(6.2.4)
(6.2.5)
Here A is the matrix already encountered in inclusive DIS, see Sections 3.2 and 4.1, which incorporates the quark distribution functions. R is a new quark–quark correlation matrix (sometimes called decay matrix), which contains the fragmentation functions of quarks into a hadron h. An average over colours is included in R. Inserting Eqs. (6:2:4); (6:2:5) into (6:2:1) yields d4 k d4 W = ea2 4 (k + q − ) Tr[A R ]: (6.2.6) 4 4 (2) (2) a
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
69
It is an assumption of the parton model that k 2 , k · P, 2 and · Ph are much smaller than Stated di,erently: when these quantities become large, A and R are strongly suppressed. Let us work in the hN collinear frame (see Appendix B.2), the photon momentum is 1 1 q −xP + Ph + qT = −xP + ; Ph− ; qT : (6.2.7) z z
Q2 .
We recall that Ph⊥ −z qT . The quark momenta are k /P + kT = (P + ; 0; 0T );
(6.2.8a)
(6.2.8b)
Thus the delta function in (6.2.6) can be decomposed as 4 (k + q − ) = (k + + q+ − + )(k − + q− − − )2 (kT + qT − T ) (k + − xP + )(k − − Ph− =z)2 (kT + qT − T ):
(6.2.9)
which implies / = x and < = 1=z, that is k xP + kT ;
(6.2.10a)
1 Ph + T : z The hadronic tensor (6.2.6) then becomes d k + d k − d 2 kT d+ d− d 2 T W = ea2 (2)4 (2)4 a
(6.2.10b)
×(k + − xP + )(k − − Ph− =z)2 (kT + qT − T ) Tr[A R ]:
(6.2.11)
Exploiting the delta functions in the longitudinal momenta, we obtain d k − d 2 kT d+ d 2 T W = ea2 (2)4 (2)4 a ×2 (kT + qT − T ) Tr[A R ]k + =xP+ ; − =P− =z : h
(6.2.12)
To obtain the ?nal form of W , we must insert the explicit expressions for A and R into (6.2.12). The former has been already discussed in Section 4.1. In the following we shall concentrate on the structure of R. 6.3. Systematics of fragmentation functions The fragmentation functions are contained in the decay matrix R, which we rewrite here for convenience (from now on X incorporates the integration over PX ) Rij (; Ph ; Sh ) = d 4 ei· 0| i ()|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N j (0)|0: (6.3.1) X
70
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
We have omitted the path-ordered exponential L = P exp(−ig ds A (s)), needed to make (6.3.1) gauge invariant, since in the A+ = 0 gauge a proper path may be chosen such that L = 1. Hereafter the formalism will be similar to that developed in Section 4.1 for A and, therefore, much detail will be suppressed. The quark fragmentation functions are related to traces of the form Tr[DR] = d 4 ei· Tr 0| i ()|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N j (0)D|0; (6.3.2) X
where D is a Dirac matrix. R can be decomposed over a Dirac matrix basis as 1 i R(; Ph ; Sh ) = S5 + V + A 5 + iP5 5 + T 5 ; 2 2
(6.3.3)
where the quantities S, V , A , P5 , T , constructed with the momentum of the fragmenting quark , the momentum of the produced hadron Ph and its spin Sh , have the general form 15 [15,121,127–129] S=
1 Tr(R) = C1 ; 2
(6.3.4a)
V =
1 Tr( R) = C2 Ph + C3 + C10 2
Sh Ph! ;
(6.3.4b)
A =
1 Tr( 5 R) = C4 Sh + C5 · Sh Ph + C6 · Sh ; 2
(6.3.4c)
P5 =
1 Tr( 5 R) = C11 · Sh ; 2i
(6.3.4d)
T =
!
1 Tr( 5 R) = C7 Ph[ Sh] + C8 [ Sh] + C9 · Sh Ph[ ] + C12 2i
!
Ph! :
(6.3.4e)
The quantities Ci = Ci (2 ; · Ph ) are real functions of their arguments, owing to the hermiticity property of R. The presence of the terms with coeKcients C10 , C11 and C12 , which were forbidden in the expansion of the A matrix by time-reversal invariance, is justi?ed by the fact that in the fragmentation case we cannot naYZvely impose a condition similar to (4.1.4c), that is R∗ (; Ph ; Sh ) = 5 CR(; ˜ P˜ h ; S˜ h )C † 5 :
(6.3.5)
In the derivation of (4.1.4c) the simple transformation property of the nucleon state |PS under T is crucial. However, R contains the states |Ph Sh ; X which are out-states with possible ?nal-state interactions between the hadron and the remnants. Under time reversal they do not simply invert their momenta and spin but transform into in-states T |Ph Sh ; X ; out ˙ |P˜ h S˜ h ; X˜ ; in: 15
(6.3.6)
We consider here spin- 12 (or spin-0) hadrons. For the production of spin-1 hadrons see below, Section 6:9.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
71
Fig. 24. A hypothetical mechanism giving rise to a T -odd fragmentation function.
These may di,er non-trivially from |P˜ h S˜ h ; X˜ ; out owing to ?nal-state interactions, which can generate relative phases between the various channels open in the |in → |out transition. Thus, the terms containing C10 , C11 and C12 are allowed in principle. The fragmentation functions related to these terms are called T -odd fragmentation functions [15,128,129]. One of them, called H1⊥ , gives rise to the so-called Collins e,ect [15,17,129]. A generic mechanism giving rise to T -odd fragmentation functions is shown diagrammatically in Fig. 24. What is needed, in order to produce such fragmentation functions, is an interference diagram in which the ?nal-state interaction (represented in ?gure by the dark blob) between the produced hadron and the residual fragments cannot be reabsorbed into the quark–hadron vertex [130]. It has been argued in [131] that the relative phases between the hadron and the X system might actually cancel in the sum over X . This would cause the T -odd distributions to disappear. Only experiments will settle the question. Working in a hN collinear frame, the vectors (or pseudovectors) appearing in (6:3:4a)– (6.3.4e) are Ph ;
1 Ph + T z
and
Sh
5h P + ShT ; Mh h
(6.3.7)
where we have to remember that the transverse components are suppressed by a factor 1=Ph− (that is, 1=Q) compared to the longitudinal ones. To start with, consider the case of collinear kinematics. If we ignore T , at leading twist (that is at order O(Ph− )) the terms contributing to (6.3.3) are V =
1 Tr( R) = B1 Ph ; 2
(6.3.8a)
A =
1 Tr( 5 R) = 5h B2 Ph ; 2
(6.3.8b)
T =
1 ] ; Tr( 5 R) = B3 Ph[ ShT 2i
(6.3.8c)
where we introduced the functions Bi (2 ; · Ph ). The decay matrix then reads R(; Ph ; Sh ) = 12 {B1 P=h + 5h B2 5 P=h + B3 P=h 5 S=hT }:
(6.3.9)
72
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Recalling that Ph has only a Ph− component, Eqs. (6:3:8a)–(6:3:8c) become 1 − − Tr( R) = B1 ; 2Ph
(6.3.10a)
1 − − Tr( 5 R) = 5h B2 ; 2Ph
(6.3.10b)
1 i− i − Tr(i 5 R) = ShT B3 : 2Ph
(6.3.10c)
The three leading-twist fragmentation functions: the unpolarised fragmentation function Dq (x), the longitudinally polarised fragmentation function LDq (x), and the transversely polarised fragmentation function LT Dq (x), are obtained by integrating B1 , B2 and B3 , respectively, over , with the constraint 1=z = − =Ph− . For instance z d4 D(z) = B1 (2 ; · Ph )(1=z − − Ph− ) 2 (2)4 z d4 = Tr( − R)(− − Ph− =z) 4 (2)4 z d+ iPh− + =z 0| (+ ; 0; 0⊥ )|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N (0) − |0: (6.3.11) = e 4 X 2 The normalisation of D(z) is such that d z z D(z) = 1; h
(6.3.12)
Sh
where h is a sum over all produced hadrons. Hence, D(z) is the number density of hadrons of type h with longitudinal momentum fraction z in the fragmenting quark. Analogously, we have for LD(z) (with 5h = 1) z d4 LD(z) = B2 (2 ; · Ph )(1=z − − =Ph− ) 2 (2)4 z d+ iPh− + =z 0| (+ ; 0; 0⊥ )|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N (0) − 5 |0 (6.3.13) = e 4 X 2 i = (1; 0) for de?niteness) and for LT D(z) (with ShT z d4 LT D(z) = B3 (2 ; · Ph )(1=z − − =Ph− ) 2 (2)4 z d+ iPh− + =z 0| (+ ; 0; 0⊥ )|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N (0)i1− 5 |0: = e 4 X 2
(6.3.14)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
73
Fig. 25. Kinematics in (a) the ∗ N frame and (b) the hN frame.
Note that LT D(z) is the fragmentation function analogous to the transverse polarisation distribution function LT f(x). In the literature LT D is often called H1 (z) [15]. Introducing the -integrated matrix z d4 R(z) = R(; Ph ; Sh )(1=z − − =Ph− ); (6.3.15) 2 (2)4 the leading-twist structure of the fragmentation process is summarised in the expression of R(z), which is R(z) = 12 {D(z)P=h + 5h LD(z) 5 P=h + LT D(z)P=h 5 S=hT }:
(6.3.16)
The probabilistic interpretation of D(z), LD(z) and LT D(z) is analogous to that of the corresponding distribution functions (see Section 4.3). If we denote by Nh=q (z) the probability of ?nding a hadron with longitudinal momentum fraction z inside a quark q, then we have (using ± to label longitudinal polarisation states and ↑↓ to label transverse polarisation states) D(z) = Nh=q (z);
(6.3.17a)
LD(z) = Nh=q+ (z) − Nh=q− (z);
(6.3.17b)
LT D(z) = Nh=q↑ (z) − Nh=q↓ (z):
(6.3.17c)
6.4. T -dependent fragmentation functions In the collinear case (kT = T = 0) the produced hadron is constrained to have zero transverse momentum (Ph⊥ = − z qT = 0). Therefore, in order to investigate its Ph⊥ distribution within the parton model, one has to account for the transverse motion of quarks (in QCD transverse momenta of quarks emerge at NLO owing to gluon emission). The kinematics in the ∗ N and hN frames is depicted in Fig. 25 (for simplicity the case of no transverse motion of quarks inside the target is illustrated).
74
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Reintroducing T , we have at leading twist [15,121,127–129] V =
1 1 B Tr( R) = B1 Ph + 2 Mh 1
Ph T! ShT ;
(6.4.1a)
A =
1 1 ˜ B1 T · ShT Ph ; Tr( 5 R) = 5h B2 Ph + 2 Mh
(6.4.1b)
T =
!
1 5 1 ] + h B˜ 2 Ph[ T] + 2 B˜ 3 T · ShT Ph[ T] Tr( 5 R) = B3 Ph[ ShT 2i Mh Mh +
1 B Mh 2
!
Ph! T ;
(6.4.1c)
where we have introduced new functions B˜ i (2 ; · Ph ) (the tilde signals the presence of T ), Bi (2 ; · Ph ) (the prime labels the T -odd terms) and inserted powers of Mh so that all coeKcients have the same dimension. Multiplying Eqs. (6:4:1a)–(6:4:1c) by P yields 1 ij 1 − − Tr( R) = B1 + M B1 T Ti ShTj ; 2Ph h 1 1 Tr( − 5 R) = 5h B2 + T · ShT B˜ 1 ; 2P − Mh 5 1 2T ˜ i− i B3 ShT Tr(i 5 R) = B3 + + h B˜ 2 Ti 2 − 2P Mh 2Mh 1 1 ij 1 j ij − 2 B˜ 3 Ti T + 2T g⊥ ShTj + B Tj : 2 Mh 2 T Mh
(6.4.2a) (6.4.2b)
(6.4.2c)
The eight T -dependent fragmentation functions are obtained from the B coeKcients as follows: 1 d+ d− ) = B1 (2 ; · Ph )(1=z − − =Ph− ); (6.4.3) D(z; 2 T 2z (2)4 etc., where T ≡ −z T is the transverse momentum of the hadron h with respect to the fragmenting quark, see Eq. (6.2.10b). If the transverse motion of quarks inside the target is ignored, then T coincides with Ph⊥ . De?ning the integrated trace 1 d+ d− [D] R ≡ Tr(DR)(− − Ph− =z) 4z (2)4 1 d+ d 2 T i(Ph− + =z−T ·T ) e Tr 0| (+ ; 0; ⊥ )|Ph Sh ; X Ph Sh ; X | N (0)D|0; = 4z X (2)3 (6.4.4)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
75
we obtain from (6.4.2a)–(6.4.2c) −
R[ ] = Nh=q (z; T ) = D(z; 2 T)+ R[
−
5]
1 Mh
ij ⊥ 2 T Ti ShTj D1T (z; T );
= Nh=q (z; T )5 (z; T ) = 5h LD(z; 2 T)+
R[i
i−
(6.4.5a)
5 ]
1 T · ShT G1T (z; 2 T ); Mh
(6.4.5b)
= Nh=q (z; T )s i⊥ (z; T ) 5h i ⊥ H (z; 2 T) Mh T 1L 1 2 ij 1 1 i j ⊥ − 2 T T + T g⊥ ShTj H1T (z; 2 T)+ 2 M Mh h
i = ShT LT D(z; 2 T)+
ij ⊥ 2 T Tj H1 (z; T );
(6.4.5c)
; 5 ) is the spin of the quark and N (z; ) is the probability of ?nding a hadron where s = (s⊥ h=q T with longitudinal momentum fraction z and transverse momentum T = − z T , with respect to the quark momentum, inside a quark q. In (6:4:5a)–(6:4:5c) we have adopted a more traditional notation for the three fragmentation functions, D, LD and LT D, that survive upon integration over T whereas we have resorted ⊥, G , to Mulders’ terminology [15] for the other, less familiar, fragmentation functions, D1T 1T ⊥ ⊥ ⊥ H1L , H1T and H1 (note that in Mulders’ scheme D, LD and LT D are called D1 , G1L and H1T , respectively, and D1 , G1 and H1 , once integrated over T ). The integrated fragmentation 2 functions D(z) and LD(z), are obtained from D(z; 2 T ) and LD(z; T ), via (6.4.6a) D(z) = d 2 T D(z; 2 T );
LD(z) =
d 2 T LD(z; 2 T );
(6.4.6b)
whereas LT D(z) is given by 2 2 2 ⊥ 2 T LT D(z) = d T LT D(z; T ) + H (z; T ) : 2Mh2 1T
(6.4.6c)
Among the unintegrated fragmentation functions, the T -odd quantity H1⊥ (z; 2 T ) plays an important rˆole in the phenomenology of transversity as it is related to the Collins e,ect, i.e., the observation of azimuthal asymmetries in single-inclusive production of unpolarised hadrons at leading twist. In partonic terms, H1⊥ is de?ned—see Eq. (4.8.2b) for the corresponding distribution function h⊥ 1 —via Nh=q↑ (z; T ) − Nh=q↓ (z; T ) =
|T |
Mh
sin(= − =s )H1⊥ (z; 2 T );
(6.4.7)
76
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 26. Toy model for fragmentation.
where = and =s are the azimuthal angles of the quark momentum and polarisation, respectively, de?ned in a plane perpendicular to Ph . The angular factor in (6.4.7), that is (recall that Ph is directed along −z) sin(= − =s ) =
( ∧ Ph ) · s ; | ∧ Ph | |s |
(6.4.8)
is related to the so-called Collins angle (see Section 6.5), as we now show. First of all, note that on neglecting O(1=Q) e,ects, azimuthal angles in the plane perpendicular to the hN axis coincide with the azimuthal angles de?ned in the plane perpendicular to the ∗ N axis. Then, if we ignore the intrinsic motion of quarks inside the target, we have T = − Ph⊥ =z and = = =h − :
(6.4.9)
The angle in (6.4.8) is therefore = − =s = =h − =s − = − AC − ;
(6.4.10)
so that sin(= − =s ) = sin AC ;
(6.4.11)
where AC , the azimuthal angle between the spin vector of the fragmenting quark and the momentum of the produced hadron, is what is known as the Collins angle [17]. Just to show how the T -odd fragmentation function H1⊥ may arise from non-trivial ?nal-state interactions, as discussed in Section 6.3, let us consider a toy model [130] (see Fig. 26) that provides a simple example of the mechanism symbolically presented in Fig. 24. Thus, we assume that the quark, with momentum and mass m, fragments into an unpolarised hadron, leaving a remnant which is a point-like scalar diquark. The fragmentation function H1⊥ is contained in the tensor component of the matrix R 1 i R(; Ph ) = · · · + T 5 ; (6.4.12) 2 2 where—see Eq. (6.4.1c), T = · · · +
1 B Mh 2
!
! Ph ;
(6.4.13)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
so that, using 5 = 12 i /< /< , 1 1 R(; Ph ) = ··· + B Ph : 2 Mh 2
77
(6.4.14)
If we describe the hadron h by a plane wave iPh ·x h (x)∼u(Ph )e
(6.4.15)
it is easy to show that the fragmentation matrix R is i −i R(; Ph ) ∼ u(Ph )u(Ph ) =−m =−m =+m =+m (P=h + Mh ) 2 ; (6.4.16) 2 2 −m − m2 where we have omitted inessential factors. We cannot extract a factor proportional to Ph (hence, producing H1⊥ ) from (6.4.16). Let us now suppose that a residual interaction of h with the intermediate state generates a phase in the hadron wave function. If, for instance, in (6.4.16) we make the replacement (assuming only two fragmentation channels) ∼
u(Ph ) → u(Ph ) + ei1 =u(Ph )
(6.4.17)
by a little algebra one can show that a term of the type (6.4.14) emerges in R, with M B2 ∼ 2 h 2 sin 1: (6.4.18) −m Therefore, if the interference between the fragmentation channels produces a non-zero phase 1, T -odd contributions may appear. The proliferation of channels, however, might lead, as suggested in [131], to the vanishing of such phases and of the resulting T -odd fragmentation functions. Another microscopic mechanism that may give rise to a T -odd fragmentation function has been recently investigated in [132]. Using a simple pseudoscalar coupling between pions and quarks to model the fragmentation process, these authors show that the inclusion of one-loop self-energy and vertex corrections generates a non-vanishing H1⊥ . 6.5. Cross-sections and asymmetries in semi-inclusive leptoproduction We shall now calculate the trace in (6.2.12). At leading twist, as already mentioned, transverse polarisation distributions are probed by unpolarised lepton beams. In this case, the leptonic tensor is symmetric and couples to the symmetric part of W , that is 1 2 d k − d 2 kT d+ d 2 T W (S) = ea 2 a (2)4 (2)4 ×2 (kT + qT − T ) Tr[A { R } ]k + =xP+ ; − =P− =z : h
(6.5.1)
78
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Using the Fierz identity we can decompose the trace in (6.5.1) as Tr[A { R } ] = 12 {Tr[A]Tr[R] + Tr[iA 5 ]Tr[iR 5 ] − Tr[A / ]Tr[R / ] − Tr[A / 5 ]Tr[R / 5 ] + 12 Tr[iA/< 5 ]Tr[iR/< 5 ]}g
+ 12 Tr[A { ]Tr[R } ] + 12 Tr[A { 5 ]Tr[R } 5 ] }
+ 12 Tr[iA/{ 5 ]Tr[iR/ 5 ]:
(6.5.2)
If we insert Eqs. (4:7:2a)–(4.7.2c) and (6:4:1a)–(6.4.1c) into (6.5.1) and integrate over k − and + making use of Eqs. (4:7:8a)–(4.7.8c) and (6:4:5a)–(6.4.5c), after some algebra we obtain [15,121,127,128] (S) 2 2 W =2 ea z d T d 2 kT 2 (kT + qT − T ) a
×
−gT
f(x; kT2 )D(z; 2 T)
1 + Mh
! 2 ⊥ 2 T T! ShT f(x; kT ) D1T (z; T )
{ }
−[ST ShT + ST · ShT gT ]LT f(x; kT2 )LT D(z; 2 T) { }
[ST T + ST · T gT ]T · ShT ⊥ LT f(x; kT2 ) H1T (z; 2 T) Mh2 # { }! { }! ST T T! + T T ST! − LT f(x; kT2 ) H1⊥ (z; 2 T) + ··· : 2Mh
−
(6.5.3)
In (6.5.3) we have considered only unpolarised and transversely polarised terms, and we have omitted the kT -dependent contributions (in the following we shall assume that transverse motion of quarks inside the target can be neglected). Neglecting higher-twist (i.e., O(1=Q)) contributions, the transverse (T ) vectors and tensors appearing in (6.5.3) coincide with the corresponding perpendicular (⊥) vectors and tensors. The (S) is performed by means of the identities [15] contraction of W (S) with the leptonic tensor L 2Q2 [1 + (1 − y)2 ]; y2 4Q2 (1 − y) { } (S) [a⊥ b⊥ + a⊥ · b⊥ g⊥ ]L = |a⊥ ||b⊥ | cos(=a + =b ); y2 4Q2 (1 − y) 1 { }! { }! (S) =− |a⊥ ||b⊥ |sin(=a + =b ); [a⊥ ⊥ b⊥! + b⊥ ⊥ a⊥! ]L 2 y2 (S) g⊥ L = −
(6.5.4a) (6.5.4b) (6.5.4c)
where =a and =b are the azimuthal angles in the plane perpendicular to the photon–nucleon axis. Combining Eq. (6.5.3) with Eqs. (6:5:4a)–(6.5.4b) leads quite straightforwardly to the parton-model formul^ for the cross-sections. To obtain the leading-order QCD expressions, one must simply insert the Q2 dependence into the distribution and fragmentation functions.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
79
6.5.1. Integrated cross-sections Consider, ?rst of all, the cross-sections integrated over Ph⊥ . In this case, the kT and T integrals decouple and can be performed, yielding the integrated distribution and fragmentation functions. Hence we obtain 2 s d 1 4/em 2 ea x = [1 + (1 − y)2 ]fa (x)Da (z) 4 d x dy d z Q 2 a −(1 − y)|S⊥ | |Sh⊥ | cos(=S + =Sh )LT fa (x)LT Da (z) : (6.5.5) As one can see, at leading twist, the transversity distributions are probed only when both the target and the produced hadron are transversely polarised. From (6.5.5) we can extract the transverse polarisation Ph of the detected hadron, de?ned so that (‘unp’ = unpolarised) d = dunp (1 + Ph · Sh ):
(6.5.6)
↑ If we denote by Phy the transverse polarisation of h along y, when the target nucleon is → the transverse polarisation of h along x, when the target polarised along y (↑), and by Phx nucleon is polarised along x (→), we ?nd 2 ea LT fa (x)LT Da (z) 2(1 − y) ↑ → a Phy = − Phx = : (6.5.7) 2 2 1 + (1 − y) a ea fa (x)Da (z)
If the hadron h is not transversely polarised, or—a fortiori—is spinless, the leading-twist
Ph⊥ -integrated cross-section does not contain LT f. In this case, in order to probe the transversity distributions, one has to observe the Ph⊥ distributions, or consider higher-twist contributions
(Section 6.6). In the next section we shall discuss the former possibility.
6.5.2. Azimuthal asymmetries We now study the (leading-twist) Ph⊥ distributions in semi-inclusive DIS and the resulting azimuthal asymmetries. We shall assume that the detected hadron is spinless, or that its polarisation is not observed. For simplicity, we also neglect (at the beginning, at least) the transverse motion of quarks inside the target. Thus (6.5.3) simpli?es as follows (recall that only the unpolarised and the transversely polarised terms are considered) W (S) = 2 ea2 z d 2 T 2 (T + Ph⊥ =z) a
×
−g⊥ f(x)D(z; 2 T)
−
{ }! T T!
(ST
{ }! T ST! )
+ T 2Mh
#
LT f(x)H1⊥ (z; 2 T) + ··· : (6.5.8)
80
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Contracting W (S) with the leptonic tensor (6.1.14a) and inserting the result into (6.1.11) gives the cross-section 2 s 4/em d 1 2 2 = ea x ) [1 + (1 − y)2 ]fa (x)Da (z; Ph⊥ 2 4 d x dy d z d Ph⊥ Q 2 a |Ph⊥ | ⊥ 2 + (1 − y) |S |sin(=S + =h )LT fa (x)H1a (z; Ph⊥ ) : (6.5.9) zMh ⊥ From this we obtain the transverse single-spin asymmetry d(S⊥ ) − d(−S⊥ ) d(S⊥ ) + d(−S⊥ ) 2 0 2 2(1 − y) a ea LT fa (x)LT Da (z; Ph⊥ ) |S⊥ | sin(=S + =h ): = 2 2 1 + (1 − y)2 a ea fa (x)Da (z; Ph⊥ )
AhT ≡
(6.5.10)
2 ) as—see (6.4.7) Here we have de?ned the T -odd fragmentation function L0T D(z; Ph⊥ 2 L0T D(z; Ph⊥ )=
|Ph⊥ |
zMh
2 H1⊥ (z; Ph⊥ ):
(6.5.11)
Note that our L0T D is related to LN D of [26] by L0T D = LN D=2 (our notation is explained in Section 1.2). The existence of an azimuthal asymmetry in transversely polarised leptoproduction of spinless hadrons at leading twist, which depends on the T -odd fragmentation function H1⊥ and arises from ?nal-state interaction e,ects, was predicted by Collins [17] and is now known as the Collins e,ect. The Collins angle AC was originally de?ned in [17] as the angle between the transverse spin vector of the fragmenting quark and the transverse momentum of the outgoing hadron, i.e., AC = =s − =h :
(6.5.12)
Thus, one has sin AC =
(q ∧ P h ) · s : |q ∧ Ph | |s |
(6.5.13)
Since, as dictated by QED (see Section 6.7), the directions of the ?nal and initial quark spins are related to each other by (see Fig. 27) =s = − =s ;
(6.5.14)
(6.5.13) becomes AC = − =s − =h . Ignoring the transverse motion of quarks in the target, the initial quark spin is parallel to the target spin (i.e., =s = =S ) and AC can ?nally be expressed in terms of measurable angles as AC = − =S − =h :
(6.5.15)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
81
Fig. 27. The transverse spin vectors and the transverse momentum of the outgoing hadron in the plane perpendicular to the ∗ N axis. AC is the Collins angle.
If the transverse motion of quarks in the target is taken into account the cross-sections become more complicated. We limit ourselves to a brief overview of them. Let us start from the unpolarised cross-section, which reads 2 s e2 dunp 4/em a = (6.5.16) x[1 + (1 − y)2 ]I [fa Da ]; d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ Q4 2 a where we have introduced the integral I , de?ned as [15] I [f D](x; z) ≡ d 2 kT d 2 T 2 (kT + qT − T ) f(x; kT2 ) D(z; 2 T)
=
d 2 kT f(x; kT2 )D(z; |Ph⊥ − z kT |2 ):
The cross-section for a transversely polarised target takes the form 2 s d(S⊥ ) 4/em = |S | ea2 x(1 − y) ⊥ Q4 d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ a hˆ · ⊥ ⊥ ×I LT fa H1a sin(=S + =h ) + · · · ; Mh
(6.5.17)
(6.5.18)
where hˆ ≡ Ph⊥ = |Ph⊥ | and a term giving rise to a sin(3=h − =S ) asymmetry, but not involving LT f, has been omitted. As we shall see in Section 9.2.2 there are presently some data on semi-inclusive DIS o, nucleons polarised along the scattering axis, that are of a certain interest
82
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
for the study of transversity. It is therefore convenient, in view of the phenomenological analysis of those measurements, to give also the unintegrated cross-section for a longitudinally polarised target, which, although not containing LT f, depends on the Collins fragmentation function H1⊥ , a crucial ingredient in the phenomenology of transversity. One ?nds 2 s d(5N ) 4/em =− 5N ea2 x(1 − y) 2 4 d x dy d z d Ph⊥ Q a 2(hˆ · ⊥ )(hˆ · k⊥ ) − ⊥ · k⊥ ⊥ ⊥ ×I h1La H1a sin(2=h ): (6.5.19) MMh Note the characteristic sin(2=h ) dependence of (6.5.18) and the appearance of the k⊥ -dependent distribution function h⊥ 1L . One can factorise the x and z dependence in the above expressions by properly weighting the cross-sections with some function that depends on the azimuthal angles [16,133]. This procedure also singles out the di,erent contributions to the cross-section for a given spin con?guration of the target (and of the incoming lepton). To see how it works let us consider the case of a transversely polarised target. We rede?ne the azimuthal angles so that the orientation of the lepton plane is given by a generic angle =‘ in the transverse space. Eq. (6.5.18) then becomes 2 s d(S⊥ ) hˆ · ⊥ 2/em 2 ⊥ = |S⊥ | ea x(1 − y)I LT fa H1a sin(=S + =h − 2=‘ ) d x dy d z d=‘ d 2 Ph⊥ Q4 M h a (6.5.20) + sin(3=h − =S − 2=‘ ) term The weighted cross-section that projects the ?rst term of (6.5.20) out, and leads to a factorised expression in x and z, is d(S⊥ ) |P | d=‘ d 2 Ph⊥ h⊥ sin(=S + =h − 2=‘ ) Mh z d x dy d z d=‘ d 2 Ph⊥ =
2 s 4/em ⊥(1) |S | ea2 x(1 − y)LT fa (x)H1a (z); ⊥ Q4 a
(6.5.21)
where the weighted fragmentation function H1⊥(1) is de?ned as 2 T ⊥(1) 2 2 H1 (z) = z d T H1⊥ (z; z 2 2T ): (6.5.22) 2Mh2 For a more complete discussion of transversely polarised semi-inclusive leptoproduction, with or without intrinsic quark motion, we refer the reader to the vast literature on the subject [15,16,48,121,126,127,133–138]. In Section 9.2 we shall present some predictions and some preliminary experimental results on AhT . 6.6. Semi-inclusive leptoproduction at twist-three Let us now see how transversity distributions appear at the higher-twist level. We shall consider only twist-three contributions and limit ourselves to quoting the main results without derivation (which may be found in [15]).
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
83
If the lepton beam is unpolarised, the cross-section for leptoproduction of unpolarised (or spinless) hadrons with a transversely polarised target is 2 s d(S⊥ ) M 2 4/em |S | e 2(2 − y) 1−y = ⊥ a d x dy d z Q4 Q a Mh H˜ a (z) × sin =S xLT fa (x) M z # a ˜ M (z) H h L − 5h cos =S x2 gTa (x)LDa (z) + ; (6.6.1) xLT fa (x) M z where the factor M=Q signals that (6.6.1) is a twist-three quantity. Adding (6.6.1) to the transverse component of (6.5.5) gives the complete Ph⊥ -integrated cross-section of semi-inclusive DIS o, a transversely polarised target up to twist-three. Note that in (6.6.1) the leading-twist transversity distributions LT f(x) are coupled to the twist-three fragmentation functions H˜ (z) and H˜ L (z), while the leading-twist helicity fragmentation function LD(z) is coupled to the twist-three distribution gT (x). H˜ (z) is a T -odd fragmentation function. At twist-three, the transversity distributions also contribute to the scattering of a longitudinally polarised lepton beam. The corresponding cross-section is 2 s d(5l ; S⊥ ) 4/em M 2 5 |S | e 2y 1 − y =− ⊥ l d x dy d z Q4 Q a a ˜ M (z) E a h × cos =S x2 gTa (x)Da (z) + xLT fa (x) M z # a E˜ L (z) Mh + 5h sin =S : (6.6.2) xLT f(x) M z Here, again, the leading-twist transversity distributions LT f(x) are coupled to the twist-three ˜ fragmentation functions E(z) and E˜ L (z), and the leading-twist unpolarised fragmentation function D(z) is coupled to the twist-three distribution gT (x). E˜ L (z) is a T -odd fragmentation function. Up to order O(1=Q), there are no other observables in semi-inclusive leptoproduction involving transversity distributions. The twist-two and twist-three contributions to semi-inclusive leptoproduction involving the transversity distributions LT f are collected in Tables 3 and 4. 6.7. Factorisation in semi-inclusive leptoproduction It is instructive to use a di,erent approach, based on QCD factorisation, to rederive the results on semi-inclusive DIS presented in Section 6.5. We start by considering the collinear case, that is ignoring the transverse motion of quarks both in the target and in the produced hadron. In this case a factorisation theorem is known to hold. This theorem was originally demonstrated for the production of unpolarised particles [139 –143] and then also shown to apply if the detected
84
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168 Table 3 The contributions to the Ph⊥ -integrated cross-section involving the transversity distributionsa Cross-section integrated over Ph⊥ ‘
N
h
observable
Twist-two
0
T
T
LT f(x)LT D(z)
Twist-three
0 0 L L
T T T T
0 L 0 L
LT f(x)H˜ (z)(∗) LT f(x)H˜ L (z) ˜ LT f(x)E(z) LT f(x)E˜ L (z)(∗)
a
T; L and 0 denote transverse, longitudinal and no polarisation, respectively. The asterisk labels T -odd observables. Table 4 Contributions to the Ph⊥ distributions involving transversity. The produced hadron h is taken to be unpolariseda Ph⊥ distribution (h unpolarised) ‘
N
observable
Twist-two
0
T
LT f ⊗ H1⊥ (∗)
Twist-three
0 0 L
T T T
LT f ⊗ H˜ (∗) LT f ⊗ H1⊥ (∗) LT f ⊗ E˜
a
The notation is as in Table 3.
particles are polarised [144]. In contrast, when the transverse motion of quarks is taken into account, factorisation is not proven and can only be regarded as a reasonable assumption. 6.7.1. Collinear case The QCD factorisation theorem states that the cross-section for semi-inclusive DIS can be written, to all orders of perturbation theory, as J J d = d dO fa (; )!5 5 d ˆ 55 JJ (x=; Q=; /s ())Dh=b (O; ); (6.7.1) ab 55 JJ
where ab is a sum over initial (a) and ?nal (b) partons, !55 is the spin density matrix of parton a in the nucleon, and d ˆ is the perturbatively calculable cross-section of the hard subprocesses that contribute to the reaction. In (6.7.1) is the fraction of the proton momentum carried by the parton a; O is the fraction of the momentum of parton b carried by the produced hadron, and is the factorisation scale. Lastly, Dh=b (z) is the fragmentation matrix of parton b
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
85
Fig. 28. Lepton–quark (antiquark) scattering.
into the hadron h ++ Dh=b Dh=b = −+ Dh=b
+− Dh=b −− Dh=b
:
(6.7.2)
It is de?ned in such a manner that 1 JJ 1 ++ −− D (z) = [Dh=b (z) + Dh=b (z)] = Dh=b (z); 2 J h=b 2
(6.7.3)
where Dh=b (z) is the usual unpolarised fragmentation function, that is the probability of ?nding a hadron h with longitudinal momentum fraction z inside a parton b. The di,erence of the diagonal elements of Dh=b (z) gives the longitudinal polarisation fragmentation function ++ 1 2 [Dh=b (z)
−− − Dh=b (z)] = 5h LDh=b (z);
(6.7.4a)
whereas the o,-diagonal elements are related to transverse polarisation +− 1 2 [Dh=b (z)
−+ + Dh=b (z)] = Shx LT Dh=b (z);
(6.7.4b)
+− 1 2 [Dh=b (z)
−+ − Dh=b (z)] = Shy LT Dh=b (z):
(6.7.4c)
Note that Dh=b is normalised such that for an unpolarised hadron it reduces to the unit matrix. At lowest order the only N → lq(q) N (see elementary process contributing to d ˆ is lq(q) Fig. 28). Thus, the sum runs only over quarks and antiquarks, and a = b. Eq. (6.7.1) ab then becomes (omitting energy scales) dO d d ˆ J J E Eh 3 3 = d 2 fa ()!5 5 E E Dh=a (O): (6.7.5) 3 3 d l d Ph O d l d 55 JJ a 55 JJ
86
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
The elementary cross-section in (6.7.5) is (sˆ = xs is the centre-of-mass energy squared of the partonic scattering, with the hat labelling quantities de?ned at the subprocess level) d ˆ 1 1 E E = M5/J< M5∗ /J < 4 (‘ + k − ‘ − ) 3 3 d l d 55 JJ 322 sˆ 2 = where
d ˆ dy
55 JJ
=
sy ˆ 2
/<
d ˆ dy
55 JJ
4 (‘ + k − ‘ − );
1 1 M5/J< M5∗ /J < ; 16sˆ 2
(6.7.6)
(6.7.7)
/<
with the sum being performed over the helicities of the incoming and outgoing leptons. Working in the hN collinear frame, where the photon momentum is q −xP + z −1 Ph + qT , that is, in light-cone components, q (−xP + ; z −1 Ph− ; qT ), the energy–momentum conservation delta function may be written as 4 (‘ + k − ‘ − ) = 4 (q + k − ) (q+ + k + )(q− − − )2 (qT ) =
2xz ( − x)(O − z) 2 (qT ): Q2
(6.7.8)
The integrations over and O in (6.7.5) can now be performed and the cross-section for semi-inclusive DIS (expressed in terms of the invariants x; y; z and of the transverse momentum of the outgoing hadron Ph⊥ ) reads d ˆ d J J = fa ()!5 5 Dh=a (z)2 (Ph⊥ ): (6.7.9) 2 d x dy d z d Ph⊥ dy 55 JJ a 55 JJ
Note the 2 (Ph⊥ ) factor coming from the kinematics of the hard subprocess at lowest order. Integrating the cross-section over the hadron transverse momentum we obtain d d ˆ JJ fa ()!55 Dh=a (z): (6.7.10) = d x dy d z dy 55 JJ a 55 JJ
Let us now look at the helicity structure of the lq scattering process. By helicity conservation, the only non-vanishing scattering amplitudes are (y = − tˆ= sˆ = 12 (1 − cos Q)) M++++ = M− − − − = 4i e2 ea M+−+− = M−+−+ = 2i e2 ea
1 1 = 2i e2 ea ; cos Q y
1 + cos Q 1−y = 2i e2 ea ; 1 − cos Q y
(6.7.11a) (6.7.11b)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
87
where Q is the scattering angle in the lq centre-of-mass frame. The elementary cross-sections contributing to (6.7.10) are % 1 1$ d ˆ d ˆ |M++++ |2 + |M+−+− |2 = = dy ++++ dy − − − − 16sˆ 2 =
d ˆ dy
d ˆ = dy +−+−
−+−+
=
' 4/2 xs ea2 & 1 + (1 − y)2 ; 4 Q 2
1 4/2 xs 2 ∗ = e (1 − y) Re M++++ M+−+− 16sˆ Q4 a
and the cross-section (6.7.10) then reads d ˆ d −− ++ fa (x) (!++ Dh=a + !− − Dh=a ) = d x dy d z dy ++++ a d ˆ +− −+ + !+− Dh=a + !−+ Dh=a : dy +−+−
(6.7.12a) (6.7.12b)
(6.7.13)
Inserting (6:7:12a), (6.7.12b) into (6.7.13) and using (4:3:7)–(4:3:8b) and (6:7:3)–(6:7:4c), we obtain 2 s d 4/em ea2 x = d x dy d z Q4 a 1 × [1 + (1 − y)2 ][fa (x)Dh=a (z) + 5N 5h Lfa (x)LDh=a (z)] 2 + (1 − y)|S⊥ ||Sh⊥ | cos(=S + =Sh )LT fa (x)LT Dh=a (z) (6.7.14) which coincides with the result already obtained in Section 6.5. In the light of the present derivation of (6.7.14), we understand the origin of the y-dependent factor in (6.5.7) and (6.5.10). This factor, aˆT ≡
2(1 − y) d ˆ +−+− = d ˆ ++++ 1 + (1 − y)2
(6.7.15)
is a spin transfer coeKcient, i.e., the transverse polarisation of the ?nal quark generated by an initial transversely polarised quark in the lq → lq process. To see this, let us call HJJ the quantity d ˆ HJJ ≡ !5 5 (6.7.16) dy 55 JJ and introduce the spin density matrix of the ?nal quark, de?ned via HJJ = Hunp !JJ ;
(6.7.17)
88
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where Hunp = H++ + H− − = (d ) ˆ ++++ : We ?nd explicitly !++ ! = aˆT !+−
aˆT !−+ !− −
(6.7.18)
;
(6.7.19)
and, recalling that the ?nal quark travels along −z, we ?nally obtain for its spin vector s sx = − aˆT sx ;
sy = aˆT sy :
(6.7.20)
Thus, the initial and ?nal quark spin directions are specular with respect to the y axis. The factor aˆT is also known as the depolarisation factor. It decreases with y, being unity at y = 0 and zero at y = 1. 6.7.2. Non-collinear case If quarks are allowed to have transverse momenta, QCD factorisation is no longer a proven property, but only an assumption. In this case we write, in analogy with (6.7.5), d dO 2 E Eh 3 3 = d d k d 2 T Pa (; kT )!5 5 T 2 d l d Ph O a 55 JJ
×E E
d ˆ 3 d l d 3
55 JJ
JJ Dh=a (O; T );
(6.7.21)
where Pa (; kT ) is the probability of ?nding a quark a with momentum fraction x and transverse momentum kT inside the target nucleon, and Dh=a (O; T ) is the fragmentation matrix of quark a into the hadron h, having transverse momentum T ≡ = − z T with respect to the quark momentum. Evaluating Eq. (6.7.21), as we did with Eq. (6.7.5), we obtain the cross-section in 2 terms of the invariants x; y; z and of Ph⊥ d 2 = d kT d 2 T Pa (; kT )!5 5 d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ a 55 JJ
d ˆ × dy
55 JJ
JJ Dh=a (z; T )2 (z kT − T − Ph⊥ ):
(6.7.22)
Inserting the elementary cross-sections (6:7:12a), (6.7.12b) in (6.7.22) and writing explicitly the sum over the helicities, we obtain 2 s 4/em d 2 2 = ea x d kT d 2 T Pa (x; kT ) d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ Q4 a 1 −− ++ × + !− − Dh=a ] [1 + (1 − y)2 ][!++ Dh=a 2
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168 +− −+ + (1 − y)[!+− Dh=a + !−+ Dh=a ]
89
×2 (z kT − T − Ph⊥ ):
(6.7.23)
Let us suppose now that the hadron h is unpolarised. Using the correspondence (4.3.7) between the spin density matrix elements and the spin of the initial quark, and the analogous relations for the fragmentation matrix obtained from (6:4:5a)–(6.4.5c), that is 1 ++ 1 ij −− ⊥ ) = D(z; 2 Ti ShTj D1T (z; 2 (6.7.24a) (D + Dh=a T)+ T ); 2 h=a Mh T 1 1 ++ −− ) = 5h LD(z; 2 T · ShT G1T (z; 2 (6.7.24b) (Dh=a − Dh=a T)+ T ); 2 Mh 1 +− 5h 1 ⊥ −+ 1 ) = ShT LT D(z; 2 H (z; 2 (Dh=a + Dh=a T)+ T) 2 Mh T 1L 1 1 1j 1 j 1j ⊥ − 2 T1 T + 2T g⊥ ShTj H1T (z; 2 Tj H1⊥ (z; 2 T)+ T ); 2 Mh T Mh (6.7.24c) −
1 +− 5h 2 ⊥ −+ 2 ) = ShT LT D(z; 2 H (z; 2 (D − Dh=a T)+ T) 2i h=a Mh T 1L 1 2 2j 1 1 1 j ⊥ − 2 T T + T g⊥ ShTj H1T (z; 2 T)+ 2 Mh Mh
2j ⊥ 2 T Tj H1 (z; T );
(6.7.24d)
the transverse polarisation contribution to the cross-section turns out to be 2 s d(S⊥ ) 4/em 2 2 = − e x(1 − y) d k d 2 T Pa (x; kT ) T a d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ Q4 a 1 ⊥ 2 (sx Ty + sy Tx )H1a (z; 2 (6.7.25) T ) (z kT − T − Ph⊥ ): Mh If, for simplicity, we neglect the transverse momentum of the quarks inside the target, then s⊥ Pa (x) = S⊥ LT fa (x). The integration over T can be performed giving the constraint T ≡ −z T = Ph⊥ , and Eq. (6.7.25) becomes, with our convention for the axes and azimuthal angles 2 s d(S⊥ ) 4/em |P | ⊥ 2 = |S | ea2 x(1 − y)LT fa (x) h⊥ H1a (z; Ph⊥ ) sin(= + =S ): ⊥ 2 4 d x dy d z d Ph⊥ Q zM h a ×
(6.7.26)
Since T = − Ph⊥ =z, we have = + =S = =h − + =S = AC − and (6.7.26) reduces to the transverse polarisation term of (6.5.9).
(6.7.27)
90
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 29. Two-particle leptoproduction.
6.8. Two-hadron leptoproduction Another partially inclusive DIS reaction that may provide important information about transversity is two-particle leptoproduction (see Fig. 29): l(‘) + N (P) → l (‘ ) + h1 (P1 ) + h2 (P2 ) + X (PX )
(6.8.1)
with the target transversely polarised. In this reaction two hadrons (for instance, two pions) are detected in the ?nal state. Two-hadron leptoproduction has been proposed and studied by various authors [124,130,131, 145] as a process that can probe the transverse polarisation distributions of the nucleon, coupled to some interference fragmentation functions. The idea is to look at angular correlations of the form (P1 ∧ P2 ) · s , where P1 and P2 are the momenta of the two produced hadrons is the transverse spin vector of the fragmenting quark. These correlations are not forand s⊥ bidden by time-reversal invariance owing to ?nal-state interactions between the two hadrons. To our knowledge, the ?rst authors who suggested resonance interference as a way to produce non-diagonal fragmentation matrices of quarks were Cea et al. [146] in their attempt to explain the observed transverse polarisation of hyperons produced in pN interactions [3]. Hereafter we shall consider an unpolarised lepton beam and unpolarised hadrons in the ?nal state. The cross-section for the reaction (6.8.1) reads, cf. Eq. (6.1.7) 1 e4 d 3 l d 3 P1 d 3 P2 4 d = L W (2) ; (6.8.2) 4‘ · P Q4 (2)3 2E (2)3 2E1 (2)3 2E2 where L is the usual leptonic tensor, Eq. (6.1.5), and W is the hadronic tensor 1 d 3 PX (2)4 4 (P + q − PX − P1 − P2 ) W = 4 (2) X (2)3 2EX ×PS |J (0)|X; P1 P2 X; P1 P2 |J (0)|PS :
(6.8.3)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
91
Fig. 30. Diagram contributing to two-hadron leptoproduction at lowest order.
Following [130], we introduce the combinations Ph ≡ P1 + P2 ; and the invariants P · P1 z1 = ; P·q
R ≡ 12 (P1 − P2 )
(6.8.4)
P · P2 ; P·q
(6.8.5)
z2 =
P · Ph z2 z1 P · P1 =1 − ; = = P·q z P · Ph z in terms of which the cross-section becomes 2 /em d y = L W : 2 2 3 4 d x dy d z d d Ph⊥ d R⊥ 4(2) Q (1 − )z Using z = z1 + z2 =
2 d 2 R⊥ = 12 d R⊥ d=R = 12 (1 − ) dMh2 d=R ;
(6.8.6)
(6.8.7)
(6.8.8)
where Mh2 = Ph2 = (P1 + P2 )2 is the invariant-mass squared of the two hadrons and =R is the azimuthal angle of R in the plane perpendicular to the ∗ N axis, the cross-section can then be re-expressed as 2 y d /em = (6.8.9) L W : d x dy d z d d 2 Ph⊥ dMh2 d=R 2(2)3 Q4 z In the parton model (see Fig. 30) the hadronic tensor has a form similar to that of the single-particle case d k − d 2 kT d+ d 2 T W = eq2 (2)4 (2)4 q ×2 (kT + qT − T ) Tr[A > ]k + =xP+ ; − =P− =z ; h
(6.8.10)
92
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
except that there appears now a decay matrix for the production of a pair of hadrons d 4 O ei·O 0| i (O)|P1 P2 ; X P1 P2 ; X | N j (0)|0: (6.8.11) >ij (; P1 ; P2 ) = X
Working in a frame where P and Ph are collinear (transverse vectors in this frame are denoted, as usual, by a T subscript), the matrix (6.8.11) can be decomposed as was (6.3.3). At leading twist the contributing terms are (remember that hadrons h1 and h2 are unpolarised) V = 12 Tr( >) = B1 Ph ;
1 2
A = Tr( 5 >) = T =
1 B M1 M2 1
(6.8.12a) !
Ph R! T ;
1 1 [B Tr( 5 >) = 2i M1 + M2 2
!
Ph! T + B3
(6.8.12b) !
Ph! R ];
(6.8.12c)
where M1 and M2 are the masses of h1 and h2 , respectively. In (6.8.12c) Bi and Bi are functions of the invariants constructed with , P, Ph and R. The prime labels the so-called T -odd terms (but one should bear in mind that T -invariance is not actually broken). Multiplying Eqs. (6:8:12a)–(6.8.12c) by P results in 1 Tr( − >) = B1 ; 2Ph−
(6.8.13a)
1 1 − ij − Tr( 5 >) = M M B1 T RTi Tj ; 2Ph 1 2
(6.8.13b)
1 1 i− ij ij − Tr(i 5 >) = M + M [B2 T Tj + B3 T RTj ]: 2Ph 1 2
(6.8.13c)
Introducing the integrated trace 1 d+ d− 1 − [D] − Tr(D>) − Ph > = 4z (2)4 z 1 dO+ d 2 T i(Ph− O+ =z−T ·T ) = e 4z X (2)3 ×Tr 0| (O+ ; 0; 0⊥ )|P1 P2 ; X P1 P2 ; X | N (0)D|0;
(6.8.14)
we can rewrite Eqs. (6:8:13a)–(6.8.13c) as [130] −
2 >[ ] = Nh1 h2 =q (z; ; T ; RT ) = D(z; ; 2 T ; RT ; T · RT );
>[
−
5]
= Nh1 h2 =q (z; ; T ; RT )5q =
1 M1 M2
ij ⊥ 2 2 T RTi Tj G1 (z; ; T ; RT ; T
(6.8.15a) · RT );
(6.8.15b)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
>[i
i−
5 ]
93
i = Nh1 h2 =q (z; ; T ; RT )s⊥
=
1 2 [ ij Tj H1⊥ (z; ; 2 T ; RT ; T · RT ) M1 + M2 T
ij 2 2 ˜⊥ (6.8.15c) T RTj H 1 (z; ; T ; RT ; T · RT )]; where Nh1 h2 =q (z; ; T ; RT ) is the probability for a quark q to produce two hadrons h1 ; h2 . ⊥ In Eq. (6.8.15c), D, G1⊥ , H1⊥ and H˜ 1 are interference fragmentation functions of quarks ⊥ into a pair of unpolarised hadrons. In particular, H1⊥ and H˜ 1 are related to quark transverse polarisation in the target. H1⊥ has an analogue in the case of single-hadron production (where it ⊥ has been denoted by the same symbol), while H˜ 1 is a genuinely new function. It is important ⊥ to notice that H˜ 1 is the only fragmentation function, besides D, that survives when the quark
+
transverse momentum is integrated over. The symmetric part W (S) of the hadronic tensor, the component contributing to the crosssection when the lepton beam is unpolarised (as in our case), is given by (with the same notation as in Section 6.5 and retaining only the unpolarised and the transverse polarisation terms) W (S) = 2 ea2 z d 2 T d 2 kT 2 (kT + qT − T ) a
×
−gT f(x; kT2 )D(z; 2 T)
−
{ }! T T!
ST
{ }!
+ T T ST! 2(M1 + M2 )
2 ×LT f(x; kT2 )H1⊥ (z; ; 2 T ; RT ; T · RT ) −
{ }! T RT!
ST
# ×
⊥ 2 LT f(x; kT2 )H˜ 1 (z; ; 2 T ; RT ; T
{ }!
+ RT T ST! 2(M1 + M2 )
· RT ) + · · · :
(6.8.16)
Let us now neglect the intrinsic motion of quarks inside the target. This implies that (S)
T =−Ph⊥ =z. Contracting W (S) with the leptonic tensor L by means of the relations (6.5.4a)– (6.5.4c) and integrating over Ph⊥ , we obtain the cross-section (limited to the unpolarised and
transverse polarisation contributions) d d x dy d z d dMh2 d=R 2 s 1 4/em 2 = ea x [1 + (1 − y)2 ]fa (x)Da (z; ; Mh2 ) 3 4 (2) Q a 2 + (1 − y)
|S⊥ ||R⊥ |
M1 + M2
⊥ 2 ˜ sin(=S + =R )LT fa (x)H 1a (z; ; R⊥ ) :
2 . The fragmentation functions appearing here are integrated over Ph⊥
(6.8.17)
94
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
We de?ne now the interference fragmentation function LT I (z; ; Mh2 ) as |R⊥ | ˜ ⊥ H (z; ; Mh2 ) ˙ Nh1 h2 =q↑ (z; ; R⊥ ) − Nh1 h2 =q↓ (z; ; R⊥ ); LT I (z; ; Mh2 ) = M1 + M2 1 where, we recall, 2 R⊥ = (1 − )Mh2 − (1 − )M12 − M22 :
Integrating (6.8.17) over , we ?nally obtain 2 s d 1 4/em 2 = ea x [1 + (1 − y)2 ]fa (x)Da (z; Mh2 ) 2 3 4 2 d x dy d z dMh d=R (2) Q a 2 + (1 − y)|S⊥ | sin(=S + =R )LT fa (x)LT Ia (z; Mh ) : From (6.8.20) we obtain the transverse single-spin asymmetry d(S⊥ ) − d(−S⊥ ) AhT1 h2 ≡ d(S⊥ ) + d(−S⊥ ) 2 2 2(1 − y) a ea LT fa (x)LT Ia (z; Mh ) |S⊥ | sin(=S + =R ); = 2 2 1 + (1 − y)2 a ea fa (x)Da (z; Mh )
(6.8.18)
(6.8.19)
(6.8.20)
(6.8.21)
which probes the transversity distributions along with the interference fragmentation function LT I . We can introduce, into two-hadron leptoproduction, the analogue of the Collins angle AC of single-hadron leptoproduction, which we call AC . We de?ne AC as the angle between the ?nal and R , i.e., quark transverse spin s⊥ ⊥ AC ≡ =s − =R :
(6.8.22)
We have sin AC ≡
(P h ∧ R ) · s ( P 2 ∧ P 1 ) · s = : |Ph ∧ R||s | |P2 ∧ P1 ||s |
(6.8.23)
Since =s = − =s , where =s is the azimuthal angle of the initial quark transverse spin, we can also write AC = − =s − =R :
(6.8.24)
If the initial quark has no transverse momentum with respect to the nucleon, then =s = =S and AC is given, in terms of measurable angles, by AC = − =S − =R :
(6.8.24 )
In the language of QCD factorisation the cross-section for two-hadron leptoproduction is written as d D(z; Mh2 ; =R ) d d = fa (x)!5 5 : (6.8.25) dy 55 JJ d x dy d z dMh2 d=R dMh2 d=R J J a 55 JJ
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
95
Fig. 31. Leptoproduction of two hadrons h1 and h2 via resonance (h; h ) formation. Fig. 32. The factor sin 0 sin 1 sin(0 − 1 ) obtained from phase shifts (?gure from [131]).
What we have found above is that the fragmentation matrix d D=dMh2 d=R factorises into z- and Mh2 -dependent fragmentation functions and certain angular coeKcients. For the case at hand, the angular dependence is given by the factor sin(=S + =R ) in (6.8.20). An explicit mechanism giving rise to an interference fragmentation function like LT I has been suggested by Ja,e et al. [131,147] (a similar mechanism was considered earlier in a di,erent but related context [146]). The process considered in [131,147] and shown diagrammatically in Fig. 31 is the production of a + − pair, via formation of a (I = 0, L = 0) and ! (I = 1, L = 1) resonance. The single-spin asymmetry then arises from interference between the s- and p-wave of the pion system. Similar processes are K production near to the K ∗ resonance, and K KN production near to the =. In all these cases two mesons, h1 and h2 , are generated from the decay of two resonances h (L = 0) and h (L = 1). The ?nal state can be written as a superposition of two resonant states with di,erent relative phases |h1 h2 ; X = ei0 |h; X + ei1 |h ; X :
(6.8.26)
The interference between the two resonances is proportional to sin(0 − 1 ). The values of 0 and 1 depend on the invariant mass Mh of the two-meson system. It turns out that the interference fragmentation function LT I has the following structure LT I (z; Mh2 )∼ sin 0 sin 1 sin(0 − 1 )LT Iˆ(z; Mh2 );
(6.8.27)
2 where the phase factor √ sin 0 sin 1 sin(0 − 1 ) depends on Mh . The maximal value that this factor can attain is 3 3=8.
96
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
The two-hadron spin-averaged fragmentation function Dh1 h2 (z; Mh2 ) is the superposition of the unpolarised fragmentation functions of the two resonances weighted by their phases Dh1 h2 (z; Mh2 ) = sin 2 0 Dh (z) + sin 2 1 Dh (z):
(6.8.28)
The resulting single-spin asymmetry is then d(S⊥ ) − d(−S⊥ ) AhT1 h2 ≡ d(S⊥ ) + d(−S⊥ ) ˙
2(1 − y) |S | sin 0 sin 1 sin(0 − 1 )sin(=S + =R ) 1 + (1 − y)2 ⊥ 2 2 ˆ a ea LT fa (x)LT I a (z; Mh ) : × 2 2 f (x)[sin 2 D ˆ ˆ =a (z)] D e (z) + sin a 0 1 h=a h a a
(6.8.29)
We remark that the angle = de?ned in [131] corresponds to our =S − =R − =2. In the case of two-pion production, 0 and 1 can be obtained from the data on phase shifts [148]. The factor sin 0 sin 1 sin(0 − 1 ) is shown in Fig. 32. It is interesting to observe that the experimental value of this quantity reaches 75% of its theoretical maximum. 6.9. Leptoproduction of spin-1 hadrons As ?rst suggested by Ji [149] (see also [150]) the transversity distribution can be also probed in leptoproduction of vector mesons (e.g., !; K ∗ ; =). The fragmentation process into spin-1 hadrons has been fully analysed, from a formal viewpoint, in [151,152]. The polarisation state of a spin-1 particle is described by a spin vector S and by a rank-2 spin tensor T ij . The latter x ; S y ; S xy ; S xx [151]. The transversity distribution contains ?ve parameters, usually called SLL ; SLT LT TT TT LT f emerges when an unpolarised beam strikes a transversely polarised target. The cross-section in this case is [151] (we retain only the terms containing LT f and we use the notation of Section 6.5.2) 2 s 4/em d(S⊥ ) = |S | ea2 x(1 − y) ⊥ d x dy d z d 2 Ph⊥ Q4 a a × |SLT | sin (=LT + =S )I [LT fa H1LT ]
+ |STT | sin (2=TT + =S − =h )I
+ SLL sin(=S + =h )I
hˆ · ⊥
Mh
Mh
a LT fa H1TT
⊥a LT fa H1LL
+ |SLT | sin(=LT
hˆ · ⊥
2(hˆ · ⊥ )2 − 2⊥ ⊥a − =S − 2=h )I LT fa H1LT 2Mh2
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
− |STT | sin(2=TT − =S − 3=h ) # (hˆ · ⊥ )[2(hˆ · ⊥ )2 − 32⊥ =2] ⊥a ×I LT fa H1TT + ···: 3
Mh
97
(6.9.1)
For simplicity, we omitted the subscript h in the tensor spin parameters (which are understood to pertain to the produced hadron). The azimuthal angles =LT and =TT are de?ned by xy Sy STT tan =LT = LT ; tan = = (6.9.2) TT x xx SLT STT and ( ( x )2 + (S y )2 ; xx )2 + (S xy )2 : |SLT | = (SLT | S | = (STT (6.9.3) TT LT TT ⊥ ; Note that LT f couples in (6.9.1) to ?ve di,erent fragmentation functions: H1LT ; H1TT ; H1LL All these functions are T -odd. If we integrate the cross-section over Ph⊥ only one term survives, namely 2 s d(S⊥ ) 4/em a |S || S | sin(= + = ) ea2 x(1 − y)LT fa (x)H1LT (z): (6.9.4) = LT LT S ⊥ d x dy d z Q4 a ⊥ ; H⊥ . H1LT 1TT
The fragmentation function appearing here, H1LT , is called hˆ1N by Ji [149]. It is a T -odd and chirally odd function which can be measured at leading twist and without considering intrinsic transverse momenta. Probing the transversity by (6.9.4) requires polarimetry on the produced meson. For a self-analysing particle this can be done by studying the angular distribution of its decay products (e.g., !0 → + − ). Thus, the vector-meson fragmentation function H1LT represents a speci?c contribution to two-particle production near the vector-meson mass. 6.10. Transversity in exclusive leptoproduction processes Let us now consider the possibility of observing the transversity distributions in exclusive leptoproduction processes. Collins et al. [153] remarked that the exclusive production of a transversely polarised vector meson in DIS, that is lp → lVp, involves the chirally odd o,-diagonal parton distributions in the proton. These distributions (also called “skewed” or “o,-forward” distributions) depend on two variables x and x since the incoming and outgoing proton states have di,erent momenta P and P , with (P − P)2 = t (the reader may consult [154 –156] on skewed distributions). For instance, the o,-forward transversity distribution (represented in Fig. 33a) contains a matrix element of the form PS | N (0) + ⊥ 5 (− )|P S . At low x the difference between x and x is small and the o,-diagonal distributions are completely determined by the corresponding diagonal ones. In [157] it was shown that the chirally odd contribution to vector-meson production (see Fig. 33b) is actually zero at LO in /s . This result was later extended in [158], where it was observed that the vanishing of the chirally odd contribution is due to angular momentum and chirality conservation in the hard scattering and hence holds at leading twist to all orders in the strong coupling. Thus, the (o,-diagonal) transversity distributions cannot be probed in exclusive vector-meson leptoproduction.
98
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 33. The o,-diagonal transversity distribution (a) and its contribution to exclusive vector-meson production (b).
7. Transversity in hadronic reactions The second class of reactions probing quark transversity is hadron scattering with at least one of the two colliding particles in a transverse polarisation state. We shall ?rst consider the case where both initial hadrons are transversely polarised. In particular, Drell–Yan production with two transversely polarised hadrons turns out to be the most favourable reaction for studying the transversity distributions. Indeed, the pioneering work of Ralston and Soper [9] and Pire and Ralston [159] concentrated precisely on this process. We shall then see how transversity may emerge even when only one of the colliding hadrons is transversely polarised. This possibility, however, is more uncertain. 7.1. Double-spin transverse asymmetries When both hadrons are transversely polarised, the typical observables are double-spin transverse asymmetries of the form d(ST ; ST ) − d(ST ; −ST ) ATT = : (7.1.1) d(ST ; ST ) + d(ST ; −ST ) Since there is no gluon transversity distribution for spin-half hadrons, transversely polarised pp reactions which are dominated at the partonic level by qg or gg scattering are expected to yield a very small ATT [21,160]. Thus, direct-photon production (with lowest-order subprocesses N and two-gluon-jet gq → q and qqN → g), heavy-quark production (qqN → QQN and gg → QQ), production (gg → gg and qqN → gg) do not seem to be promising reactions to detect quark transverse polarisation. The only good candidate process for measuring transversity in doubly polarised pp (or pp) N DY collisions is Drell–Yan lepton pair production [9,14,28]. We shall see that at lowest order ATT contains combinations of the products N B ): LT f(xA )LT f(x The advantage of studying quark transverse polarisation via Drell–Yan is twofold: (i) transversity distributions appear at leading-twist level; (ii) the cross-section contains no unknown quantities, besides the transversity distributions themselves. This makes theoretical predictions relatively easier, with respect to other reactions.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
99
7.2. The Drell–Yan process Drell–Yan lepton-pair production is the process A(P1 ) + B(P2 ) → l+ (‘) + l− (‘ ) + X;
(7.2.1)
where A and B are protons or antiprotons and X is the undetected hadronic system. The centre-of-mass energy squared of this reaction is s = (P1 + P2 )2 2P1 · P2 (in the following, the hadron masses M1 and M2 will be systematically neglected, unless otherwise stated). The lepton pair originates from a virtual photon (or from a Z 0 ) with four-momentum q = ‘ + ‘ . Note that, in contrast to DIS, q is a time-like vector: Q2 = q2 ¿0. This is also the invariant mass of the lepton pair. We shall consider the deeply inelastic limit where Q2 ; s → ∞, while the ratio E = Q2 =s is ?xed and ?nite. The Drell–Yan (DY) cross-section is d =
2 82 /em d 3 ‘ d3 ‘ 4 2L W (2) ; sQ4 (2)3 2E (2)3 2E
(7.2.2)
where the leptonic tensor, neglecting lepton masses and ignoring their polarisation, is given by Q2 L = 2 ‘ ‘ + ‘ ‘ − (7.2.3) g 2 and the hadronic tensor is de?ned as 1 d 3 PX (2)4 4 (P1 + P2 − q − PX ) W = (2)4 X (2)3 2EX ×P1 S1 ; P2 S2 |J (0)|X X |J (0)|P1 S1 ; P2 S2 1 = d 4 eiq· P1 S1 ; P2 S2 |J (z)J (0)|P1 S1 ; P2 S2 : 4
(2)
(7.2.4)
The phase space in (7.2.2) can be rewritten as d3 ‘ d: d 4 q d 3 ‘ = ; (2)3 2E (2)3 2E 8(2)6
(7.2.5)
where : is the solid angle identifying the direction of the leptons in their rest frame. Using (7.2.5) the DY cross-section takes the form 2 d /em L W : = d 4 q d: 2sQ4
(7.2.6)
We de?ne now the two invariants x1 =
Q2 ; 2P1 · q
x2 =
Q2 : 2P2 · q
(7.2.7)
100
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
In the parton model x1 and x2 will be interpreted as the fractions of the longitudinal momenta of the hadrons A and B carried by the quark and the antiquark which annihilate into the virtual photon. In a frame where the two colliding hadrons are collinear (A is taken to move in the positive z direction), the photon momentum can be parametrised as q =
Q2 Q2 P + P + qT : x2 s 1 x1 s 2
(7.2.8)
Neglecting terms of order O(1=Q2 ), one ?nds Q2 =x1 x2 s 1, that is E = Q2 =s = x1 x2 , and therefore q = x1 P1 + x2 P2 + qT = (x1 P1+ ; x2 P2− ; qT ):
(7.2.9)
Note that x1
P2 · q ; P1 · P2
x2
P1 · q : P1 · P2
(7.2.10)
In terms of x1 , x2 and qT the DY cross-section reads 2 d /em L W : = d x1 d x2 d 2 qT d: 4Q4
(7.2.11)
It is customary [9,161] to introduce three vectors Z , X and Y de?ned as P1 · q P2 · q P1 − P ; Z = P1 · P2 P1 · P2 2 1 [P2 · Z P˜ 1 − P1 · Z P˜ 2 ]; X = − P1 · P2 1 ! P1 P2! q : Y = P1 · P2
(7.2.12a) (7.2.12b) (7.2.12c)
where P˜ 1; 2 = P1; 2 − (P1; 2 · q=q2 )q . These vectors are mutually orthogonal and orthogonal to q , and satisfy Z 2 −Q2 ;
X 2 Y 2 −qT2 :
(7.2.13)
Thus, they form a set of spacelike axes and have only spatial components in the dilepton rest frame. Using (7.2.9), Z , X and Y can be expressed as Z = x1 P1 − x2 P2 ;
X = qT ;
Y =
T qT ;
(7.2.14)
where T
≡
1 P1 · P2
!
P1 P2! :
In terms of the unit vectors X Y ; yˆ = √ ; xˆ = √ −X 2 −Y 2
(7.2.15) Z zˆ = √ ; −Z 2
q qˆ = ; Q2
(7.2.16)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
101
Fig. 34. Drell–Yan dilepton production.
Fig. 35. The geometry of Drell–Yan production in the rest frame of the lepton pair.
the lepton momenta can be expanded as ‘ = 12 q + 12 Q(sin Q cos = xˆ + sin Q sin = yˆ + cos Q zˆ );
(7.2.17a)
‘ = 12 q − 12 Q(sin Q cos = xˆ + sin Q sin = yˆ + cos Q zˆ ):
(7.2.17b)
The geometry of the process in the dilepton rest frame is shown in Figs. 34 and 35. The leptonic tensor then reads L = − 1 Q2 [(1 + cos2 Q)g − 2 sin2 Q zˆ Oˆ 2
⊥
+ 2 sin2 Q cos 2=(xˆ xˆ + 12 g⊥ ) + sin2 Q sin 2= xˆ{ yˆ }
+ sin 2Q cos = zˆ{ xˆ} + sin 2Q sin = zˆ{ yˆ } ];
(7.2.18)
where = g − qˆ qˆ + zˆ zˆ : g⊥
(7.2.19)
102
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 36. The parton-model diagram for the Drell–Yan hadronic tensor.
In the parton model, calling k and k the momenta of the quark (or antiquark) coming from hadron A and B, respectively, the hadronic tensor is (see Fig. 36) 1 2 d4 k d4 k 4 W = ea (k + k − q)Tr[A1 AN 2 ]: (7.2.20) 3 a (2)4 (2)4 Here A1 is the quark correlation matrix for hadron A, Eq. (4.1.1), AN 2 is the antiquark correlation matrix for hadron B, Eq. (4.2.9), and the factor 1=3 has been added since in A1 and AN 2 summations over colours are implicit. It is understood that, in order to obtain the complete expression of the hadronic tensor, one must add to (7.2.20) a term with A1 replaced by A2 and AN 2 replaced by AN 1 , which accounts for the case where a quark is extracted from B and an antiquark is extracted from A. In the following formul^ we shall denote this term symbolically by [1 ↔ 2]. Hereafter the quark transverse motion (which is discussed at length in [161]) will be ignored and only the ordinary collinear con?guration will be considered. We now evaluate the hadronic tensor in a frame where A and B move collinearly, with large longitudinal momentum. Setting k 1 P1 , k 2 P2 and using (7.2.9), the delta function in (7.2.20) gives 4 (k + k − ) = (k + + k + − q+ )(k − + k − − q− )2 (qT ) (1 P1+ − x1 P1+ )(2 P2− − x2 P2− )2 (qT )
=
1
(1 P1+ P2−
− x1 )(2 − x2 )2 (qT ):
(7.2.21)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
103
The hadronic tensor then becomes 1 2 d k − d 2 kT d k + d 2 kT 2 W = ea (q T ) 3 a (2)4 (2)4 ×Tr[A1 AN 2 ]k + =x1 P+ ;k − =x2 P− + [1 ↔ 2]: 1
(7.2.22)
2
Since the leptonic tensor is symmetric, only the symmetric part of W contributes to the cross-section. For Tr[A1 { AN 2 } ] we resort to the Fierz decomposition (6.5.2), with the replacements A → A1 , R → AN 2 . Using (4:2:5a)–(4.2.5c) and (4:2:12)–(4:2:14), we then obtain (the spins of the two hadrons are S1 = (S1T ; 51 ) and S2 = (S2T ; 52 )) 1 2 d 2 qT W = e {−gT [fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + 51 52 Lfa (x1 )LfNa (x2 )] 3 a a − [S1T S2T + S1T · S2T gT ]LT fa (x1 )LT fNa (x2 )} + [1 ↔ 2]: { }
(7.2.23)
In contracting the leptonic and the hadronic tensors, it is convenient to pass from the AB collinear frame to the ∗ A collinear frame. We recall that, at leading twist, the transverse (T ) vectors approximately coincide with the vectors perpendicular to the photon direction (denoted by a subscript ⊥): S1T S1⊥ , S2T S2⊥ , gT g⊥ . Therefore, the contraction L W can be performed by means of the following identities: −g⊥ L = Q2 (1 + cos2 Q); {
(7.2.24a)
}
[S1⊥ S2⊥ + S1⊥ · S2⊥ g⊥ ]L = − Q2 sin2 Q|S1⊥ ||S2⊥ |cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 );
(7.2.24b)
where Q is the polar angle of the lepton pair in the dilepton rest frame and =S1 (=S2 ) is the azimuthal angle of S1⊥ (S2⊥ ), measured with respect to the lepton plane. For the Drell–Yan cross-section we ?nally obtain /2 ea2 d = em2 {[fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + 51 52 Lfa (x1 )LfNa (x2 )](1 + cos2 Q) d: d x1 d x2 4Q a 3 + |S1⊥ ||S2⊥ |cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 )LT fa (x1 )LT fNa (x2 ) sin2 Q} + [1 ↔ 2]:
(7.2.25)
From this we derive the parton-model expression for the double transverse asymmetry: ADY TT =
d(S1⊥ ; S2⊥ ) − d(S1⊥ ; −S2⊥ ) d(S1⊥ ; S2⊥ ) + d(S1⊥ ; −S2⊥ )
sin2 Q cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 ) = |S1⊥ | |S2⊥ | 1 + cos2 Q
2 N a ea LT fa (x1 )LT fa (x2 ) + [1 2 N a ea fa (x1 )fa (x2 ) + [1 ↔
↔ 2]
2]
; (7.2.26)
104
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
and we see that a measurement of ADY TT directly provides the product of quark and antiquark transverse polarisation distributions LT f(x1 )LT f(x2 ), with no mixing with other unknown quantities. Thus, the Drell–Yan process seems to be, at least in principle, a very good reaction to probe transversity. Note that in leading-order QCD, Eq. (7.2.26) is still valid, with Q2 dependent distribution functions, namely ADY TT = |S1⊥ | |S2⊥ | ×
sin2 Q cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 ) 1 + cos2 Q
ea2 LT fa (x1 ; Q2 )LT fNa (x2 ; Q2 ) + [1 ↔ 2] : 2 2 N 2 a ea fa (x1 ; Q )fa (x2 ; Q ) + [1 ↔ 2]
a
(7.2.27)
Here LT f(x; Q2 ) are the transversity distributions evolved at LO. In Section 9.1 we shall see some predictions for ADY TT . 7.2.1. Z 0 -mediated Drell–Yan process If Drell–Yan dilepton production is mediated by the exchange of a Z 0 boson, the vertex ei , where ei is the electric charge of particle i (quark or lepton), is replaced by (Vi + Ai 5 ) , where the vector and axial-vector couplings are Vi = T3i − 2ei sin2 #W ; Ai = T3i :
(7.2.28)
The weak isospin T3i is + 12 for i = u and − 12 for i = l− ; d; s. The resulting double transverse asymmetry has a form similar to (7.2.26), with the necessary changes in the couplings. Omitting the interference contributions, it reads Z ADY; = |S1⊥ | |S2⊥ | TT
×
2 a (Va
sin2 Q cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 ) 1 + cos2 Q
− A2a )LT fa (x1 )LT fNa (x2 ) + [1 ↔ 2]
2 a (Va
+ A2a )fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + [1 ↔ 2]
:
(7.2.29)
7.3. Factorisation in Drell–Yan processes With a view to extending the results previously obtained to NLO in QCD, we now rederive them in the framework of QCD factorisation [144]. The Drell–Yan cross-section is written in a factorised form as (hereafter we omit the exchanged term [1 ↔ 2]) 2 (2) N 2 d1 d2 !(1) ˆ 2 =2 ; /s (2 ))]// << ; (7.3.1) d = / / fa (1 ; )!< < fa (2 ; )[d (Q a // <<
where 1 and 2 are the momentum fractions of the quark (from hadron A) and antiquark (from B), !(1) and !(2) are the quark and antiquark spin density matrices, and (d ) ˆ // << is the cross-section matrix (in the quark and antiquark spin space) of the elementary subprocesses. As usual, denotes the factorisation scale.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
105
Fig. 37. The qqN → l+ l− process contributing to Drell–Yan production at LO.
At LO d ˆ incorporates a delta function of energy–momentum conservation, namely 4 (k + k − q), which sets 1 = x1 , 2 = x2 and qT = 0. Thus Eq. (7.3.1) becomes (omitting the scales) (1) (2) d ˆ d = !/ / !< < fa (1 )fNa (2 ); (7.3.2) d: d x1 d x2 d: << // a // <<
where the only subprocess is qqN → l+ l− (see Fig. 37) and its cross-section is 1 ∗ d ˆ = M/< M/ < : d: // << 642 sˆ
(7.3.3)
The contributing scattering amplitudes are M++++ = M− − − − ;
M++− − = M− −++
and the cross-section (7.3.2) reduces to (1) (2) d ˆ d (1) (2) = (!++ !++ + !− − !− − ) d: d x1 d x2 d: ++++ a d ˆ (1) (2) (1) (2) + (!+− !+− + !−+ !−+ ) fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ): d: +−+−
(7.3.4)
(7.3.5)
Here the spin density matrix elements are, for the quark 1 !(1) ++ = 2 (1 + 5); 1 !(1) +− = 2 (sx − isy );
1 !(1) − − = 2 (1 − 5); 1 !(1) −+ = 2 (sx + isy )
(7.3.6a)
and for the antiquark 1 N !(2) ++ = 2 (1 + 5); 1 !(2) +− = 2 (sNx − isNy );
1 N !(2) − − = 2 (1 − 5); 1 !(2) −+ = 2 (sNx + isNy );
(7.3.6b)
106
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
so that (7.3.5) becomes d 1 d ˆ d ˆ N = (1 + 55) + (sx sNx − sy sNy ) fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ): d: d x1 d x2 2 a d: ++++ d: +−+−
(7.3.7)
At LO, the scattering amplitudes for the qqN annihilation process are M++++ = M− − − − = e2 ea (1 − cos Q);
(7.3.8a)
M++− − = M− −++ = e2 ea (1 + cos Q)
(7.3.8b)
and the elementary cross-sections then read d ˆ d ˆ 1 = = (|M++++ |2 + |M++− − |2 ) d: ++++ d: − − − − 642 sˆ 2 e2 1 /em a (1 + cos2 Q); 2sˆ 3 d ˆ d ˆ 1 /2 e 2 1 ∗ = = M++− − ) = em a sin2 Q: 2 Re(M++++ 2 d: +−+− d: −+−+ 64 sˆ 2sˆ 3
(7.3.9a)
=
(7.3.9b)
Inserting (7:3:9a, b) into (7.3.7) we obtain d /2 ea2 N = em2 {(1 + 55)(1 + cos2 Q) + (sx sNx − sy sNy )sin2 Q}fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ): d: d x1 d x2 4Q a 3
(7.3.10)
Using 5fa (x1 ) = 51 Lfa (x1 );
s⊥ fa (x1 ) = S1⊥ LT fa (x1 );
(7.3.11a)
5NfNa (x2 ) = 52 LfNa (x2 );
sN⊥ fNa (x2 ) = S2⊥ LT fNa (x2 )
(7.3.11b)
we obtain /2 ea2 d = em2 {[fa (x1 ) fNa (x2 ) + 51 52 Lfa (x1 )LfNa (x2 )](1 + cos2 Q) d: d x1 d x2 4Q a 3 + |S1⊥ | |S2⊥ |cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 )LT fa (x1 )LT fNa (x2 )sin2 Q};
(7.3.12)
which is what we obtained in Section 7.2 in a di,erent manner (see Eq. (7.2.25)). Note that the angular factor appearing in ADY TT —Eq. (7.2.26)—is the elementary double-spin transverse asymmetry of the qqN scattering process, namely d ( ˆ s⊥ ; sN⊥ ) − d ( ˆ s⊥ ; −sN⊥ ) aˆTT ≡ d ( ˆ s⊥ ; sN⊥ ) + d ( ˆ s⊥ ; −sN⊥ ) =
sin2 Q d ˆ +−+− cos(2= − =s − =sN): (sx sNx − sy sNy ) = d ˆ ++++ 1 + cos2 Q
(7.3.13)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
107
The Drell–Yan cross-section is most often expressed as a function of the rapidity of the virtual photon y de?ned as y≡
1 q + 1 x1 = ln : ln 2 q− 2 x2
In the lepton c.m. frame y = 12 (1 + cos Q). From x1 x2 ≡ E = Q2 =s, we obtain √ √ x1 = Eey ; x2 = Ee−y
(7.3.14)
(7.3.15)
and (7.3.12) becomes (dy dQ2 = s d x1 d x2 ) 2 e2 d /em a = {[fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + 51 52 Lfa (x1 )LfNa (x2 )](1 + cos2 Q) d: dy dQ2 4Q2 s a 3 + |S1⊥ | |S2⊥ |cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 )LT fa (x1 )LT fNa (x2 )sin2 Q}:
(7.3.16)
If we integrate over cos Q, we obtain 2 d 2/em e2 {[fa (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + 51 52 Lfa (x1 )LfNa (x2 )] = dy dQ2 d= 9Q2 s a a + 12 |S1⊥ | |S2⊥ |cos(2= − =S1 − =S2 )LT fa (x1 )LT fNa (x2 )}:
(7.3.17)
Let us now extend the previous results to NLO. Here we are interested in the transverse polarisation contribution to the Drell–Yan cross-section, which can be written as (reintroducing the scales) dT d ˆ T (Q2 =2 ; /s ) 2 e d d (7.3.18) = LT fa (1 ; 2 )LT fa (2 ; 2 ): 1 2 a 2 d= dy dQ2 d= dy dQ a We have seen that at LO, i.e., O(/s0 ), the elementary cross-section is LO :
d ˆ T /2 = em2 cos(2= − =s − =sN)(1 − x1 )(2 − x2 ); 2 dy dQ d= 9Q s
(7.3.19)
where =s (=sN) is the azimuthal angle of the quark (antiquark) spin, with respect to the lepton plane. Integrating over y we obtain LO :
2 d ˆ T /em = cos(2= − =s − =sN) (1 − z) dQ2 d= 9Q2 sˆ
(7.3.20)
with z ≡ E=1 2 = Q2 =1 2 s. At NLO, i.e., O(/s ), the subprocesses contributing to Drell–Yan production are those shown in Fig. 38: virtual-gluon corrections and real-gluon emission. The NLO cross-section d ˆ T =dy dQ2 d= exhibits ultraviolet singularities (arising from loop integrations), infrared singularities (due to soft gluons), and collinear singularities (when the gluon is emitted parallel to the quark or the antiquark). Summing virtual and real diagrams, only the collinear divergences survive. Working in d = 4 − 2j they are of the type 1= j. These singularities are subtracted and absorbed in the de?nition of the parton distributions.
108
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 38. Elementary processes contributing to the transverse Drell–Yan cross-section at NLO: (a, b) virtual-gluon corrections and (c) real-gluon emission.
The NLO elementary cross-sections have been computed by several authors with di,erent methods [61,74,108,162]. 16 Vogelsang and Weber [108] were the ?rst to perform this calculation using massive gluons to regularise the divergences. Soon after the authors of [162] presented a calculation based on dimensional reduction. The result was then translated into dimensional regularisation in [61]. As a check of the expression given in [61], Vogelsang [74] has shown how to exploit the earlier result obtained in [108]. From the detailed structure of the collinear singularities for both dimensional and o,-shell regularisation, it is straightforward to translate results from one scheme to another. The expression for d ˆ T =dy dQ2 d= is rather cumbersome and we do not repeat it here (instead, we refer the reader to the original papers). The y-integrated cross-section is more legible and N scheme [74] reads, in the MS 2 d ˆ T /em NLO : = cos(2= − =s − =sN) dQ2 d= 9Q2 sˆ ln(1 − z) 4z ln z 6z ln2 z ×CF 8z − − 1−z + 1−z 1−z # 2 2 + 4(1 − z) + − 8 (1 − z) : (7.3.21) 3 (1) The quantity in curly brackets is the NLO Wilson coeKcient LT CDY for Drell–Yan. If we call ˜ LT C the quantity to be added to the Wilson coeKcient in order to pass from the scheme of [61] to MS, the result (7.3.21) coincides with that of [61] for the choice LT C˜ = − (1 − z). On the other hand, the expression for LT C˜ claimed in [61] as providing the translation to the MS scheme (in dimensional regularisation) is LT C˜ = − (1 − z)+2(1 − z). In [74] it is noted that the reason for this di,erence lies in the discrepancy between the calculation presented there and that of [61] for the (4 − 2j)-dimensional LO splitting function, where extra O(j) terms were found. The correctness of the result in [74] for this quantity is supported by the observation that the d-dimensional 2 → 3 squared matrix element for the process qqN → + − g (with transversely polarised incoming (anti)quarks) given there factorises into the product of the d-dimensional 16
We recall that NLO corrections to unpolarised Drell–Yan were presented in [163,164], and to longitudinally polarised Drell–Yan in [165].
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
109
(0) 2 → 2 squared matrix element for qqN → + − multiplied by the splitting function LT Pqq in d = 4 − 2j dimensions, when the collinear limit of the gluon aligning parallel to one of the incoming quarks is correctly performed. It is thus claimed that the result of [61] for the NLO transversely polarised Drell–Yan cross-section (in dimensional regularisation) corresponds to a di,erent (non-MS) factorisation scheme. Finally, a ?rst step towards a next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) calculation of the transversely polarised Drell–Yan cross-section was taken in [166].
7.3.1. Twist-three contributions to the Drell–Yan process At twist-three, transversity distributions are also probed in Drell–Yan processes when one of the two hadrons is transversely polarised and the other is longitudinally polarised. In this case, ignoring subtleties related to quark masses and transverse motion (so that hL (x) = h˜L (x) and gT (x) = g˜T (x), see Section 4.9), the cross-section is [14,46,61] (the transversely polarised hadron is A) 2 e2 d /em a · · · + |S1⊥ |52 sin 2Q cos(= − =S1 ) = d: d x1 d x2 4Q2 a 3 # 2M 2M1 a a 2 × (7.3.22) x1 gT (x1 )LfNa (x2 ) + x2 LT fa (x1 )hNL (x2 ) ; Q Q where the dots denote the leading-twist contributions presented in Eq. (7.2.25). The transversity distribution of quarks in hadron A is coupled to the twist-three antiquark distribution hNL . The longitudinal–transverse asymmetry resulting from (7.3.2) is (we assume the masses of the two hadrons to be equal, i.e., M1 = M2 ≡ M ) ADY LT = |S1⊥ |52 ×
a
2 sin 2Q cos(= − =S1 ) M 1 + cos2 Q Q a
ea2 [x1 gTa (x1 )LfNa (x2 ) + x2 LT fa (x1 )hNL (x2 )] : 2 N a ea fa (x1 )fa (x2 )
(7.3.23)
Let us now consider the case where one of the two hadrons is unpolarised while the other is transversely polarised. Time-reversal invariance implies the absence of single-spin asymmetries, even at twist-three. Such asymmetries might arise as a result of initial-state interactions that generate T -odd distribution functions. If such a mechanism occurs, relaxing the naive time-reversal invariance condition (see Section 4.8), the Drell–Yan cross-section acquires extra terms and (7.3.22) becomes 2 e2 d /em a · · · + |S1⊥ | sin 2Q sin(= − =S1 ) = d: d x1 d x2 4Q2 a 3 # 2M 2M1 ˜ a 2 × (7.3.24) x1 fT (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + x2 LT fa (x1 )h˜Na (x2 ) : Q Q
110
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 39. One of the diagrams contributing to the Drell–Yan cross-section at twist-three.
˜N Here f˜T (x) and h(x) are the twist-three T -odd distribution functions introduced in Section 4.8. From (7.3.24) we obtain the single-spin asymmetry ADY T = |S1⊥ | ×
2 sin 2Q sin(= − =S1 ) M 1 + cos2 Q Q
a
ea2 [x1 fTa (x1 )fNa (x2 ) + x2 LT fa (x1 )hNa (x2 )] : 2 N a ea fa (x1 )fa (x2 )
(7.3.25)
The existence of T -odd distribution functions has also been advocated by Boer [47] to explain, at leading-twist level, an anomalously large cos 2= term in the unpolarised Drell–Yan cross-section [167–169], which cannot be accounted for by LO or NLO QCD [170] (it can however be attributed to higher-twist e,ects [171–173]). Boer has shown that, on introducing initial-state T -odd e,ects, the unpolarised Drell–Yan cross-section indeed acquires a cos 2= con2 2 N⊥ tribution involving the product h⊥ 1 (x1 ; k⊥ )h1 (x2 ; k⊥ ). If hadron A is transversely polarised, the 2 )hN⊥ (x ; k 2 ). same mechanism generates a sin(= + =S1 ) term, which depends on LT f(x1 ; k⊥ 2 ⊥ 1 It must be stressed once again that the mechanism based on initial-state interactions is highly hypothetical, if not at all unlikely. However, it was shown in [46,174] that single-spin asymmetries might arise in Drell–Yan processes owing to the so-called gluonic poles in twist-three multiparton correlation functions [175 –177]. Let us briePy address this issue (for a general discussion of higher twists in hadron scattering see [34,35,178–180]). At twist-three the Drell–Yan process is governed by diagrams such as that in Fig. 39. The hadronic tensor is then (we drop the subscripts 1 and 2 from the quark correlation matrices for simplicity) 1 d4 k d4 k 2 N ] W = ea (k + k − q)Tr[A A 3 a (2)4 (2)4
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
−
d4 k (2)4
× Tr
d4 k (2)4
111
k=˜ − q= (k˜ − q)2 + ij
d 4 k˜ (k + k − q) (2)4 # N AA A + · · · ;
(7.3.26)
where we have retained only one of the twist-three contributions, and AA is the quark–quark– gluon correlation matrix de?ned in (4.9.6). Neglecting 1=Q2 terms, the quark propagator in (7.3.26) gives (k˜ = y1 P1 ) − x1 − y1 k=˜ − q= →− : (7.3.27) − 2x2 P2 x1 − y1 + ij (k˜ − q)2 + ij Let us now introduce another quark–quark–gluon correlator dE dJ iEy iJ(x−y) AFij (x; y) = PS |=N j (0)F + (Jn)=i (En)|PS ; e e 2 2
(7.3.28)
which can be parametrised as, see the analogous decomposition of AA (x; y) Eq. (4.9.10), M AF (x; y) = {iGF (x; y) ⊥ S⊥ P= + G˜ F (x; y)S⊥ 5 P= 2 + HF (x; y)5N 5 ⊥ P= + EF (x; y) ⊥ P= }:
In the A+ = 0 gauge one has F + = @+ A⊥ and relation between AA (x; y) and AF (x; y) (x − y)AA (x; y) = − iAF (x; y): Thus, if some projection of AF (x; x) is non-zero,
(7.3.29)
by partial integration one ?nds the following (7.3.30) AA (x; x)
the corresponding projection of must have a pole (the “gluonic pole”). From (7.3.27) and (7.3.30), we see that the trace in the twist-three term of (7.3.26) contains the quantity (P.V. stands for principal value) x1 − y1 −i AA (x1 ; y1 ) = A (x1 ; y1 ) x1 − y1 + ij x1 − y1 + ij F = P:V:
−i AF (x; y) − (x1 − y1 )AF (x1 ; x1 ): x−y
(7.3.31)
Keeping the real term in (7.3.31) one ultimately ?nds that the Drell–Yan cross-section with one transversely polarised hadron and one unpolarised hadron involves, at twist-three, the multiparton distributions GF (x1 ; x1 ) and EF (x1 ; x1 ) (the former is proportional to the distribution T (x1 ; x1 ) introduced in [174,176]). The single-spin asymmetry is then expressed as 2 sin 2Q sin(= − =S1 ) M ADY T ˙ |S1⊥ | 1 + cos2 Q Q 2 a e [G (x1 ; x1 )fNa (x2 ) + LT fa (x1 )EFa (x2 ; x2 )] : (7.3.32) × a a F 2 N a ea fa (x1 )fa (x2 )
112
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168 Table 5 Contributions to the Drell–Yan cross-section involving transversitya Drell–Yan cross-section A
B
Observable
Twist-two
T
T
N 2) LT f(x1 )LT f(x
Twist-three
T
0
T
L
N 2 )(∗) LT f(x1 )h(x LT f(x1 )hNL (x2 )
a
The asterisk denotes T -odd terms.
To establish a connection between (7.3.32) and (7.3.25), let us now invert F + = @+ A⊥ , hence obtaining 1 −i AA (x; y) = (x − y)[AA(∞) (x) + AA(−∞) (x)] + P:V: (7.3.33) AF (x; y): 2 x−y If we impose antisymmetric boundary conditions [46], i.e., AA(∞) (x) = − AA(−∞) (x);
then (7.3.33) reduces to −i AA (x; y) = P:V: A (x; y): x−y F
(7.3.34)
(7.3.35)
and (7.3.31) becomes (“e, ” stands for “e,ective”) x1 − y1 AAe, ≡ A (x1 ; y1 ) x1 − y1 + ij A = AA (x1 ; y1 ) − (x1 − y1 )AF (x1 ; x1 ):
(7.3.36)
Now, the important observation is that AA and AF have opposite behaviour with respect to time reversal and hence AAe, has no de?nite behaviour under this transformation. Consequently, the T -even functions of AF can be identi?ed with T -odd functions in the e,ective correlation matrix e, e, AAe, . This mechanism gives rise to two e,ective T -odd distributions f˜T (x) and h˜ (x), which are related to the multiparton distribution functions by [46] (omitting some factors) e, f˜ T (x)∼ dy Im GAe, (x; y)∼GF (x; x); (7.3.37a) ˜he, (x)∼ dy Im EAe, (x; y)∼EF (x; x): (7.3.37b) In the light of this correspondence one can see that Eq. (7.3.25), based on T -odd distributions, and Eq. (7.3.32), based on multiparton distributions, translate into each other. Thus, at least in the case in which the T -odd functions appear at twist-three, there is an explanation for them in terms of quark–gluon interactions, with no need for initial-state e,ects. In conclusion, let us summarise the various contributions of transversity to the Drell–Yan cross-section in Table 5.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
113
Fig. 40. Hadron–hadron scattering with inclusive production of a particle h.
7.4. Single-spin transverse asymmetries Consider now inclusive hadron production, A + B → h + X . If only one of the initial-state hadrons is transversely polarised and the ?nal-state hadron is spinless (or its polarisation is unobserved), what is measured is the single-spin asymmetry d(ST ) − d(−ST ) AhT = : (7.4.1) d(ST ) + d(−ST ) As we shall see, single-spin asymmetries are expected to vanish in leading-twist in perturbative QCD (this observation is originally due to Kane et al. [6]). They can arise, however, as a consequence of intrinsic e,ects of quark transverse motion [17,40,124] and=or higher-twist contributions [7,8,175,176]. In the former case, one probes the following quantities related to transversity: • Distribution functions: LT f(x) (transversely polarised quarks in a transversely polarised ⊥ (x; k2 ) (unpolarised quarks in a transversely polarised hadron), h⊥ (x; k2 ) (transhadron), f1T T T 1
versely polarised quarks in an unpolarised hadron).
• Fragmentation functions: H1⊥ (z; 2T ) (transversely polarised quarks fragmenting into an un⊥ (z; 2 ) (unpolarised quarks fragmenting into a transversely polarised polarised hadron), D1T T
hadron).
The twist-three single-spin asymmetries involving the transversity distributions contain, besides the familiar unpolarised quantities, the quark–gluon correlation function EF (x; y) of the incoming unpolarised hadron and a twist-three fragmentation function of the outgoing hadron (see below, Section 7.4.2). Let us now enter into some detail. We consider the following reaction (see Fig. 40): A↑ (PA ) + B(PB ) → h(Ph ) + X;
(7.4.2)
114
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where A is transversely polarised and the hadron h is produced with a large transverse momentum PhT , so that perturbative QCD is applicable. In typical experiments A and B are protons while h is a pion. 2 and of the Feynman The cross-section for (7.4.2) is usually expressed as a function of PhT variable t−u 2P xF ≡ √hL = ; (7.4.3) s s where PhL is the longitudinal momentum of h, and s; t; u are the Mandelstam variables s = (PA + PB )2 ;
t = (PA − Ph )2 ;
u = (PB − Ph )2 :
(7.4.4)
The elementary processes at lowest order in QCD are two-body partonic processes a(ka ) + b(kb ) → c(kc ) + d(kd ):
(7.4.5)
In the collinear case we set 1 kc = Ph : z and the partonic Mandelstam invariants are ka = xa PA ;
kb = xb PB ;
sˆ = (ka + kb )2 xa xb s;
(7.4.6) (7.4.7a)
xa t ; z xu uˆ = (kb − kc )2 b : z Thus the condition sˆ + tˆ + uˆ = 0 implies xa t − xb u z=− : xa xb s tˆ = (ka − kc )2
(7.4.7b) (7.4.7c)
(7.4.8)
According to the QCD factorisation theorem the di,erential cross-section for the reaction (7.4.2) can formally be written as d = !a/ / fa (xa ) ⊗ fb (xb ) ⊗ d ˆ // ⊗ Dh=c (z): (7.4.9) abc //
Here fa (fb ) is the distribution of parton a (b) inside the hadron A (B), !a// is the spin density matrix of parton a, Dh=c is the fragmentation matrix of parton c into hadron h, and d =d ˆ tˆ is the elementary cross-section: 1 1 d ˆ = M/< M/∗ < ; (7.4.10) d tˆ // 16sˆ2 2 <
where M/< is the scattering amplitude for the elementary partonic process (see Fig. 41). If the produced hadron is unpolarised, or spinless, as will always be the case hereafter, only the diagonal elements of Dh=c are non-vanishing, i.e., Dh=c = Dh=c , where Dh=c is the
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
115
Fig. 41. Elementary processes contributing to hadron–hadron scattering.
unpolarised fragmentation function. Together with helicity conservation in the partonic subprocess, this implies / = / . Therefore, in (7.4.10) there is no dependence on the spin of hadron A and all single-spin asymmetries are zero. To escape such a conclusion we must consider either the intrinsic transverse motion of quarks, or higher-twist e,ects. 7.4.1. Transverse motion of quarks and single-spin asymmetries Let us ?rst of all see how the transverse motion of quarks can generate single-spin asymmetries. This can happen in three di,erent ways:
(1) Intrinsic T in hadron h implies that Dh=c is not necessarily diagonal (owing to T -odd e,ects at level of fragmentation functions). (2) Intrinsic kT in hadron A implies that fa (xa ) in (7.4.9) should be replaced by the probability density Pa (xa ; kT ), which may depend on the spin of hadron A (again, owing to T -odd e,ects but at the level of distribution functions). (3) Intrinsic kT in hadron B implies that fb (xb ) in (7.4.9) should be replaced by Pb (xb ; kT ). The transverse spin of parton b inside the unpolarised hadron B may then couple to the transverse spin of parton a inside A (this too is a T -odd e,ect at the level of distribution functions).
E,ect 1 is the Collins e,ect [17], e,ect 2 is the Sivers e,ect [40], and e,ect 3 is the e,ect studied by Boer [47] in the context of Drell–Yan processes (Section 7.3.1). We stress that all these intrinsic T ; kT , or kT e,ects are T -odd. When the intrinsic transverse motion of quarks is taken into account, the QCD factorisation theorem is not proven. We assume, however, its validity and write a factorisation formula similar to (7.4.9), that is explicitly d 1 2 2 Eh 3 = d xa d xb d kT d kT d 2 T d Ph z abc // <<
×Pa (xa ; kT )!a/ / Pb (xb ; kT )!b< <
d ˆ d tˆ
// <<
Dh=c (z; T );
(7.4.11)
116
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where
d ˆ d tˆ
// <<
=
1 M/< M/∗ < : 2 16sˆ <
(7.4.12)
To start with, let us consider the Collins mechanism for single-spin asymmetries [17,26]. We take into account the intrinsic transverse motion of quarks inside the produced hadron h (which is responsible for the e,ect), and we neglect the transverse momenta of all other quarks. Thus Eq. (7.4.11) becomes d 1 Eh 3 = d xa d xb d 2 T d Ph z abc //
×fa (xa )!a/ / fb (xb )
d ˆ d tˆ
//
Dh=c (z; T );
(7.4.13)
and the elementary cross-sections are given by (7.4.10), with T retained. We are interested in transverse spin asymmetries d(ST ) − d(−ST ). Therefore, since we are neglecting the intrinsic kT motion inside A, the spin density matrix elements of our concern are !a+− and !a−+ , and the contributing elementary cross-sections are d ˆ +−+− = d ˆ −+−+ and d ˆ +−−+ = d ˆ −++− . Using Eqs. (4:3:7) and (6:7:24a–d) we ?nd, with our choices of axes Eh
d(ST ) d(−ST ) − Eh 3 d Ph d 3 Ph 1 = − 2|ST | d xa d xb d 2 T LT fa (xa )fb (xb ) z abc d ˆ d ˆ × sin(= + =S ) + sin(= − =S ) L0T Dh=c (z; 2T ); d tˆ +−+− d tˆ +−−+
(7.4.14)
where = and =S are the azimuthal angles of T and ST , respectively, and L0T Dh=c is the T -odd fragmentation function related to H1⊥ , see (6.5.11). In particular, if the spin of hadron A is directed along y, Eq. (7.4.14) takes the form d(ST ) d(−ST ) d xb Eh 3 − Eh = −2|ST | d xa d 2 T LT fa (xa )fb (xb ) d Ph d 3 Ph z abc
×LTT (x ˆ a ; xb ; T )L0T Dh=c (z; 2T );
where the elementary double-spin asymmetry LTT ˆ is given by d ˆ d ˆ ˆ ↑ b → c↓ d) d (a ˆ ↑ b → c↑ d) d (a : LTT ˆ = − = − d tˆ +−+− d tˆ +−−+ d tˆ d tˆ
(7.4.15)
(7.4.16)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
117
Eq. (7.4.15) gives the single-spin asymmetry under the hypothesis that only the Collins mechanism (based on the existence of the T -odd fragmentation functions L0T Dh=c or H1⊥ ) is at work. Another source of single-spin asymmetries in hadron-hadron scattering is the Sivers e,ect [26,39,40,81], which relies on T -odd distribution functions. This mechanism predicts a single-spin asymmetry of the form d(ST ) d(−ST ) d xb Eh 3 − Eh = |S | d x d 2 kT LT0 fa (xa ; kT2 )fb (xb ) T a d Ph d 3 Ph z abc
×
d ˆ (xa ; xb ; kT )Dh=c (z); d tˆ
(7.4.17)
⊥ ) is the T -odd distribution de?ned in (4.8.3a). where LT0 f, (related to f1T Finally, the e,ect studied by Boer in [47] gives rise to an asymmetry involving the other T -odd distribution, L0T f (or h⊥ 1 ), de?ned in (4.8.3b). This asymmetry reads d(ST ) d(−ST ) d xb − Eh = −2|ST | d xa d 2 kT LT fa (xa )L0T fb (xb ; kT2 ) Eh 3 d Ph d 3 Ph z abc
×LTT ˆ (xa ; xb ; kT )Dh=c (z);
(7.4.18)
where the elementary asymmetry is LTT ˆ =
d (a ˆ ↑ b↑ → cd) d (a ˆ ↑ b↓ → cd) : − d tˆ d tˆ
(7.4.19)
The caveat of Section 4.8 with regard to initial-state interaction e,ects, which are assumed to generate the T -odd distributions, clearly applies here and makes both the Sivers and the Boer mechanisms highly conjectural. In the next section we shall see how single-spin asymmetries emerge at higher twist. 7.4.2. Single-spin asymmetries at twist three In the 1980s Efremov and Teryaev [7,8] pointed out that non-vanishing single-spin asymmetries can be obtained in perturbative QCD if one resorts to higher twist. These asymmetries were later evaluated in the context of QCD factorisation by Qiu and Sterman, who studied direct photon production [175,176] and, more recently, hadron production [177]. This program has been extended to cover the chirally odd contributions by Kanazawa and Koike [182,183]. Here we limit ourselves to quoting the main general results of these works (for a phenomenological analysis see Section 9.1). At “twist-three” the cross-section for the reaction (7.4.2) can be formally written as d = {GFa (xa ; ya ) ⊗ fb (xb ) ⊗ d ˆ ⊗ Dh=c (z) abc
+ LT fa (xa ) ⊗ EFb (xb ; yb ) ⊗ d ˆ ⊗ Dh=c (z) (3) + LT fa (xa ) ⊗ fb (xb ) ⊗ d ˆ ⊗ Dh=c (z)};
(7.4.20)
118
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
where GF (xa ; xb ) and EF (xa ; xb ) are the quark–gluon correlation functions introduced in Section (3) is a twist-three fragmentation function (that we do not specify further), and d , ˆ d ˆ 7.3.1, Dh=c and d ˆ are cross-sections of hard partonic subprocesses. The ?rst line in (7.4.20), which does not contain the transversity distributions, corresponds to the chirally-even mechanism studied in [177]. The second term in (7.4.20) is the chirally-odd contribution analysed in [182]. The elementary cross-sections can be found in the original papers. In Section 9.1 we shall see how the predictions based on Eq. (7.4.20) compare with the available data on single-spin asymmetries in hadron production. In practice, it turns out that the transversity-dependent term is negligible [183]. 8. Model calculations of transverse polarisation distributions As we have no experimental information on the transversity distributions yet, model calculations are presently the only way to acquire knowledge of these quantities. This section is devoted to such calculations. We shall see how the transverse polarisation distributions have been computed using various models of the nucleon and other non-perturbative tools. In particular, three classes of models will be discussed in detail: (1) relativistic bag-like models, such as the MIT bag model and the colour dielectric model, which are dominated by the valence component; (2) chiral soliton models, in which the sea plays a more important rˆole and contributes significantly to various observables; (3) light-cone models, based on the Melosh rotation. Results obtained in other models, not included in the above list (for instance, diquark spectator models), via QCD sum rules and from lattice calculations will also be reported. Quite obviously, the presentation of all models will be rather sketchy, our interest being essentially in their predictions for the quark and antiquark transversity distributions. 17 What models provide is the nucleon state (i.e., the wave functions and energy spectrum), which appears in the ?eld-theoretical expressions (4:2:5a)–(4.2.5c) of quark distributions. In general, however, it is impossible to solve the equations of motion exactly for any realistic model. Hence, one must resort to various approximations, which clearly a,ect the results of the calculation. In order to test the validity of the approximations (and of the models) one may check that the computed distributions ful?ll the valence-number sum rules 1 1 N d x[u(x) − u(x)] = 2; d x[d(x) − d(x)] =1 (8.0.1) 0
0
and that they satisfy other theoretical constraints, such as the So,er inequality (see Section 4.6) q(x) + Lq(x) ¿ 2|LT q(x)|: 17
(8.0.2)
Throughout this section the transversity distributions will be denoted by LT q and the tensor charges will be called q.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
119
As seen in Section 5, the renormalisation of the operators in the matrix elements of Eqs. (4:2:5a)–(4.2.5c) introduces a scale dependence into the parton distributions. In contrast, when computed in any model, the matrix elements of (4:2:5a)–(4.2.5c) are just numbers, with no scale dependence. The problem thus arises as to how to reconcile QCD perturbation theory with quark models. Since the early days of QCD various authors [184 –186] have proposed the answer to this question: the twist-two matrix elements computed in quark models should be interpreted as representing the nucleon at some Fxed, low scale Q02 (we shall call it the model scale). In other terms, quark models provide the initial condition for QCD evolution. The experience accumulated with the radiative generation models [187–189] has taught us that, in order to obtain a picture of the nucleon at large Q2 in agreement with experiment (at least in the unpolarised case), the nucleon must contain a relatively large fraction of sea and glue, even at low momentum scales. Purely valence models are usually unable to ?t the data at all well. Although the model scale has the same order of magnitude in all models (Q0 ∼ 0:3–0:8 GeV), its precise value depends on the details of the model and on the procedure adopted to determine it. The smallness of Q02 clearly raises another problem, namely to what extent one can apply perturbative evolution to extrapolate the quark distributions from such low scales to large Q2 . This problem is still unresolved (for an attempt to model a non-perturbative evolution mechanism in an e,ective theory see [190,191]) although the success of ?ts based on radiatively generated parton distributions [187,192–194] inspires some con?dence that the realm of perturbative QCD may extend to fairly small scales. 8.1. Bag-like models In bag-like models (the MIT bag model [195 –197] and the colour dielectric model [198– 200] (CDM)) con?nement is implemented by situating the quarks in a region characterised by a value of the colour dielectric constant of order unity. The value of the dielectric is zero outside the nucleon, that is, in the true vacuum, from which the coloured degrees of freedom are expelled. A certain amount of energy is associated with the excitation of non-perturbative gluonic degrees of freedom. This energy is described by the so-called vacuum pressure in the MIT bag model and by excitations of a phenomenological scalar ?eld in the CDM. The two models (MIT bag and CDM) di,er in the following points. In the MIT bag model the interior of the bag is supposedly described by perturbative QCD and quarks have current masses; con?nement is imposed by special boundary conditions at the surface of the bag and the bag itself has no associated dynamics. In contrast, in the CDM chiral symmetry is broken both inside and outside the nucleon, in a manner somewhat similar to the -model [201,202]. Quark con?nement is due to interaction with the phenomenological scalar ?eld which describes the non-perturbative gluonic degrees of freedom. There is no rigid separation between “inside” and “outside”, and con?nement is implemented dynamically. 8.1.1. Centre-of-mass motion A problem arising in many model calculations is the removal of spurious contributions to physical observables due to the centre-of-mass motion (for a comprehensive discussion of this matter, see the book by Ring and Schuck [203]). The origin of the problem lies in the fact
120
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
that the solution of classical equations of motion (i.e., the mean-?eld approximation) breaks translational invariance. A way to restore this invariance is to ?rst de?ne the quantum state of the nucleon at rest, and then minimise the normally ordered Hamiltonian in this state. In the evaluation of speci?c operators, boosted states of the nucleon are also required. The diKculty of boosting the states makes the procedure hard to fully implement. A (non-relativistic) method frequently used to construct momentum eigenstates is the so-called Peierls–Yoccoz projection [203]. Writing |R; 3q to denote a three-quark state centred at R: |R; 3q = b†1 (R)b†2 (R)b†3 (R)|R; 0q;
(8.1.1)
where |R; 0q is the quantum state of the empty bag, a generic nucleon eigenstate of momentum P may be written as 1 |P = d 3 ReiP·R |R; 3q (8.1.2) N3 (P 0 ; P ) with normalisation 1 0 2 |N3 (P ; P )| = 0 d 3 R eiP·R R; 3q|0; 3q: (8.1.3) 2P The expectation value of the normally ordered Hamiltonian in the projected zero-momentum eigenstate is P = 0| : Hˆ : |P = 0 E= : (8.1.4) P = 0|P = 0 Minimisation of this quantity amounts to solving a set of integro-di,erential equations, for which a variational approach is generally adopted. In the literature this procedure is known as “variation after projection” (VAP), to be distinguished from the simpler “variation before projection” (VBP), which consists of minimising the unprojected Hamiltonian ?rst and then using the solutions in the Peierls–Yoccoz projection (8.1.2). For a detailed discussion of these techniques see [204,205]. 8.1.2. The quark distributions in bag models In the (projected) mean-?eld approximation, the matrix elements de?ning the distribution functions can be rewritten in terms of single-particle (quark or antiquark) wave functions, after inserting a complete set of states between the two fermionic ?elds and N [206,207]. The intermediate states that contribute are 2q and 3q1qN states for the quark distributions, and 4q states for the antiquark distributions (see Fig. 42). The leading-twist quark distribution functions read (f is the Pavour) qf (x) = P(f; /; m)F/ (x); (8.1.5a) /
Lqf (x) =
m
/
LT qf (x) =
m
/
m
3
P(f; /; m)(−1)(m+ 2 +i/ ) G/ (x); 3
P(f; /; m)(−1)(m+ 2 +i/ ) H/ (x);
(8.1.5b) (8.1.5c)
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
121
Fig. 42. Intermediate states in the parton model: (a) 2q, (b) 3q1qN and (c) 4q.
where
F/ (x) d 3 p/ G/ (x) = A/ (p/ )((1 − x)P + − p/+ ) (2)3 (2p/0 ) H/ (x) p/z 2 u (p ) + 2u(p )v(p ) + v2 (p/ ); / / / |p/ | z z 2 p p / 1 u2 (p/ ) + 2u(p/ )v(p/ ) / + v2 (p/ ) 2 −1 ; × |p | |p | / / 2 p/⊥ 2 p/z 2 2 + v (p/ ) 1 − : u (p/ ) + 2u(p/ ) v(p/ ) |p/ | |p/ |
(8.1.6)
In (8.1.6) u and v are, respectively, the upper and lower components of the single-quark wave functions, m is the projection of the quark spin along the direction of the nucleon spin, and P(f; /; m) is the probability of extracting a quark (or inserting an antiquark) of Pavour f and spin m, leaving a state generically labelled by the quantum number /. The index i/ takes the value 0 when a quark is extracted and 1 when an antiquark is inserted. The overlap function A/ (p/ ) contains the details of the intermediate states. The antiquark distributions are obtained in a similar manner (the index i/ is 1 for the 4q states). When a quark (or an antiquark) is inserted, it can give rise to an in?nite number of states. Among all four-particle intermediate states, only that corresponding to a quark or an antiquark inserted into the ground state is usually considered because excited intermediate states have larger masses and, as will be clear in the following, give a negligible contribution to the distribution functions. Concerning the antiquark distributions, we recall from Section 4.2 that the following formal expressions hold: q(x) N = − q(−x);
(8.1.7a)
Lq(x) N = Lq(−x);
(8.1.7b)
LT q(x) N = − LT q(−x):
(8.1.7c)
Although some authors use these relations to calculate the antiquark distributions by extending to negative x the quark distributions, it should be recalled that this is an incorrect procedure. The reason, explained in Section 4.3, is that for x ¡ 0 there are semiconnected diagrams that
122
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
contribute to the distributions whereas in computing the quark distribution functions in the physical region one considers only connected diagrams (as stressed by Ja,e [37], this indeed deFnes the parton model). It is important to note that, in the non-relativistic limit, where the lower components of the quark wave functions are neglected, the three currents in Eq. (8.1.6) coincide. This implies, in the light of (8:1:5b), (8.1.5c), that ignoring relativistic e,ects the helicity distributions are equal to the transversity distributions. This is obviously only valid at the model scale (i.e., at very low Q2 ) since, as shown in Section 5.4, QCD evolution discriminates between the two distributions, in particular at small x. In Eqs. (8.1.6) energy–momentum conservation is enforced by the delta function. This is also responsible for the correct support of the distributions, which vanish for x ¿ 1. In fact, rewriting the integral in (8.1.6) as ∞ 3 + + d p/ ((1 − x)P − p/ ) = 2 dp/ p/ ; (8.1.8) p/ ¡
where (m/ is the mass of the intermediate state) ) 2 ) ) M (1 − x)2 − m2/ ) ); p/¡ = )) 2M (1 − x) )
(8.1.9)
one sees that for x → 1 the lower limit of integration p/¡ tends to in?nity and (8.1.8) gives zero. The distributions are centred at the point xN = 1 − (m/ =M ), which is positive for the 2q term and negative for the 4q and 3q1qN terms. In the latter case only the tails of the distributions (which are centred in the non-physical region x ¡ 0) contribute to the physical region 0 6 x 6 1. More massive intermediate states would lead to distributions shifted to more negative x values, and hence are negligible. Let us now address the problem of the saturation of the So,er inequality. First of all, note that the three quantities F/ ; G/ and H/ de?ned in (8.1.6) satisfy F/ (x) + G/ (x) = 2H/ (x):
(8.1.10)
This has led to the erroneous conclusion [38] that the inequality is saturated for a relativistic quark model, such as the MIT bag model. It is clear from Eqs. (8:1:5a)–(8.1.5c) that the spin-Pavour structure of the proton, which results in the appearance of the probabilities P(f; /; m), spoils this argument and prevents in general the saturation of the inequality. So,er’s inequality is only saturated in very speci?c (and quite unrealistic) cases. For instance, it is saturated when P(f; /; − 12 ) = 0, which happens if the proton is modelled as a bound state of a quark and scalar diquark. It is interesting to note that in SU(6) the hyperon is indeed a bound state of a scalar–isoscalar ud diquark and an s quark: thus the transversity distribution of the latter attains the maximal value compatible with the inequality. Another instance of saturation occurs when F/ = G/ = H/ and P(f; /; − 12 ) = 2 P(f; /; 21 ). It is easy to verify that this happens for the d quark distribution in a non-relativistic model of the proton with an SU(6) wavefunction. Apart from these two special cases, So,er’s inequality should not generally be expected to be saturated.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
123
8.1.3. Transversity distributions in the MIT bag model Calculations of structure functions within the MIT bag model have been performed by various authors, using di,erent versions of the model [206 –210]. The transversity distributions, however, have been evaluated only in the simplest non-chiral version of the MIT bag. In the ?rst calculation of LT q [14], the distributions were estimated using the formalism developed in [208], with no attempt to restore translational invariance. The single-quark wave functions of the non-translationally invariant bag are directly used in the evaluation of the matrix elements. The single-quark contribution to the transversity distributions, corresponding to H/ (x) in (8.1.6), is then 2 ∞ !n MR ymin 2 2 ymin H (x) = dyy t0 + 2t0 t1 ; (8.1.11) + t1 y y 2(!n − 1)j02 (!n ) |ymin| where !n is the nth root of the equation tan !n = − !n =(!n − 1) and ymin = xRM − !n . R and M are the bag radius and nucleon mass, respectively, and RM = 4 !n . The functions t0 and t1 are de?ned as 1 tl (!n ; y) = du u2 jl (u !n )jl (uy); (8.1.12) 0
where jl is the lth order spherical Bessel function. For completeness, we also give the unpolarised and helicity contributions ∞ ymin !n MR 2 2 F(x) = dyy t0 + 2t0 t1 (8.1.13a) + t1 ; y 2(!n − 1)j02 (!n ) |ymin | G(x) =
!n MR 2(!n − 1)j02 (!n )
∞ ymin ymin 2 2 2 dyy t0 + 2t0 t1 −1 : × + t1 2 y y |ymin|
(8.1.13b)
To obtain the quark distributions one must insert F(x); G(x) and H (x) into Eqs. (8:1:5a)– (8.1.5c), along with the probabilities P(f; /; n). In [14,208] only valence quarks were assumed to contribute to the distributions, hence the intermediate states |/ reduce to the diquark state alone. Therefore, the quark distributions are just proportional to F(x); G(x) and H (x). In particular, with an SU(6) spin-Pavour wave function one has simply 4 Lu(x) = G(x); 3
1 Ld(x) = − G(x) 3
(8.1.14)
and analogous relations for LT u and LT d with G(x) replaced by H (x). The quantities F(x); G(x) and H (x) are plotted in Fig. 43. As one can see, the transversity distributions are not so di,erent from those for helicity. Since translational invariance is lost, the distributions do not have the correct support. Thus, the integral of F(x) over x between 0 1 and 1 is not unity, as it should be. In particular, one has 0 F(x) d x = 0:90. This normalisation
124
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 43. Single-quark contributions to the distribution functions in the MIT bag model of [14]. Table 6 Axial and tensor charges in various models. Tensor charges evolved in LO QCD from the intrinsic scale of the model (Q02 ) to Q2 = 10 GeV2 are also shown. See the text for details Model [Ref.]
Lu
Ld
LM
u
d
|u=d|
Q0 [GeV]
u(Q2 )
d(Q2 )
NRQM ? MIT [14] ♦ CDM [98] ⊕ CQSM1 [235] × CQSM2 [238] + CQM [243] ⊗ LC [92] ◦ Spect. [264] ∗ Latt. [270,275] .
1.33 0.87 1.08 0.90 0.88 0.65 1.00 1.10 0.64
−0:33 −0:22 −0:29 −0:48 −0:53 −0:22 −0:25 −0:18 −0:35
1 0.65 0.79 0.37 0.35 0.43 0.75 0.92 0.29
1.33 1.09 1.22 1.12 0.89 0.80 1.17 1.22 0.84
−0:33 −0:27 −0:31 −0:42 −0:33 −0:15 −0:29 −0:25 −0:23
4.03 4.04 3.94 2.67 2.70 5.33 4.03 4.88 3.65
0.28 0.87 0.40 0.60 0.60 0.80 0.28 0.25 1.40
0.97 0.99 0.99 0.97 0.77 0.72 0.85 0.83 0.80
−0:24 −0:25 −0:25 −0:37 −0:29 −0:13 −0:21 −0:17 −0:22
problem can ∞ be overcome (although in a very ad hoc manner) by integrating between −∞ and ∞, since −∞ F(x) d x = 1. Proceeding in this manner, for the tensor charges one obtains 4 ∞ 1 ∞ H (x) d x = 1:09; d ≡ − H (x) d x = − 0:27 (8.1.15) u ≡ 3 −∞ 3 −∞ to be compared with the axial charges obtained similarly: Lu = 0:87 and Ld = − 0:22 (see Table 6). Stratmann [211] recomputed q(x); Lq(x) and LT q(x) in the MIT bag model, introducing a Peierls–Yoccoz projection to partially restore the translational invariance. However, he did not perform a VAP calculation. Since the masses of the intermediate states were not computed within the model, the number sum rules turned out to be violated. Another problem of the approach of [211] is that the antiquark distribution functions were evaluated using Eqs. (8:1:7a)–(8.1.7c) (we have already commented on the inconsistency of such a procedure in Section 8.1.2).
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
125
Fig. 44. The transversity distribution h1 (x; Q02 ) (continuous line) and the spin distribution function g1 (x; Q02 ) (dashed line) for the MIT bag model at the initial scale Q02 . The corresponding evolved distributions h1 (x; Q2 ) (dotted line) and g1 (x; Q2 ) (dot-dashed line) are obtained starting from (a) Q02 = 0:079 GeV2 and (b) Q02 = 0:75 GeV2 . From [212].
The MIT bag model was also used to compute the transversity distributions in [212]. The technique adopted in this work is rather di,erent from that discussed above and is based on a non-relativistic reduction of the relativistic wave function (for a discussion of this non-covariant approach see also [213]). The results of [212] for h1 = 12 f ef2 LT qf and g1 = 12 f ef2 Lqf are shown in Fig. 44. 8.1.4. Transversity distributions in the CDM The transversity distributions were calculated in the colour dielectric model in [98]. In particular, the chiral version of the CDM was used, in which the splitting between the masses of the nucleon and the delta resonance, or between the scalar and the vector diquark, is due to the exchange of pions, instead of perturbative gluons. Although this model su,ers a number of drawbacks, its main technical advantage with respect to the MIT bag model is that it allows a full VAP procedure to be performed, since con?nement is implemented by a dynamical ?eld, not by a static bag surface. For the same reason, the valence-number sum rules turn out to be ful?lled (to within a few percent) if the masses of the intermediate states are consistently computed within the model. As we shall see, the So,er inequalities are also satis?ed, for both quarks and antiquarks. The Lagrangian of the chiral CDM is g L = i N @ + N ( + i 5 · ) 1 + 12 (@ 1)2 − 12 M 2 12 + 12 (@ )2 + 12 (@ )2 − U (; );
(8.1.16)
where U (; ) is the usual Mexican-hat potential, see e.g., [214]. L describes a system of interacting quarks, pions, sigma and a scalar–isoscalar chiral singlet ?eld 1. The chromodielectric ?eld 1 incorporates non-perturbative gluonic degrees of freedom. Through their interaction with
126
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
Fig. 45. The transversity distributions xLT q(x) in the colour dielectric model (from [98]). Left: the quark distriN The distributions are shown at the butions xLT u and xLT d. Right: the antiquark distributions xLT uN and xLT d. model scale Q02 = 0:16 GeV2 and at Q2 = 25 GeV2 .
the 1 ?eld, the quarks acquire a mass that increases strongly at the boundary of the bag, hence leading to absolute con?nement. The parameters of the model are: the chiral meson masses m = 0:14 GeV, m = 1:2 GeV (the precise value of this parameter is actually irrelevant), the pion decay constant f = 93 MeV, the quark–meson coupling constant g, and the mass M of the 1 ?eld. The parameters g and M , which are the only free parameters of the model, can be uniquely ?xed by reproducing the average nucleon-delta mass and the isoscalar radius of the proton. The chiral CDM Lagrangian (8.1.16) contains a single-minimum potential for the chromodielectric ?eld 1: V (1) = 12 M 2 12 . A double-minimum version of the CDM is also widely studied and used (see for instance [215]). The structure functions computed in the two versions of the chiral CDM do not di,er sensibly. 18 The solution of the ?eld equations for the chiral CDM proceeds through the introduction of the so-called hedgehog ansatz, which corresponds to a mean-?eld approximation [217]. The technique used to compute the physical nucleon state is based on a double projection of the mean-?eld solution onto linear- and angular-momentum eigenstates. This technique has also been used to compute the static properties of the nucleon [214], the unpolarised and the longitudinally polarised distribution functions [215], and the nucleon electromagnetic form factors [218]. We refer the reader to these papers for more detail. A di,erent technique to obtain states of de?nite angular momentum and isospin, based on the quantisation of the collective degrees of freedom associated with the rotation of the hedgehog state, will be mentioned in Section 8.2.1. Let us simply remark that in the chiral CDM the chiral ?eld cannot develop a non-zero winding number and its value is always very small. Thus, the choice of a speci?c technique to obtain physical states from the hedgehog is less critical in the chiral CDM than in other models. In Fig. 45 we show the results of the calculation in [98]. One of the features of the distributions computed in the CDM is their rapid fallo, and vanishing for x ¿ 0:6. This is due 18
The single-minimum CDM seems to be preferable in the light of quark matter calculations [216].
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
127
to the soft con?nement of the quarks, which do not carry large momenta. It should also be stressed that the Peierls–Yoccoz procedure, which is a non-relativistic approximation, becomes unreliable at large x. Note also that the sea contribution is rather small. As for the model scale Q02 , in [98,215,219] it was determined by matching the value of the momentum fraction carried by the valence, as computed in the model, with that obtained by evolving backward the value experimentally determined at large Q2 . The result is Q02 = 0:16 GeV2 . Proceeding in a similar manner, Stratmann found Q02 = 0:08 GeV2 [211] in the MIT bag. The CDM distributions evolved from Q02 = 0:16 GeV2 to Q2 = 25 GeV2 are also shown in Fig. 45. Needless to say, perturbative evolution from such low Q02 values should be taken with some caution. The tensor charges computed in the CDM are (at Q02 = 0:16 GeV2 ) u = 1:22;
d = − 0:31;
(8.1.17)
whereas the axial charges are Lu = 1:08 and Ld = − 0:29 (see Table 6). 8.2. Chiral models In chiral models the qqN excitations are described in terms of e,ective degrees of freedom represented by chiral ?elds. There is now a huge variety of models of this type and, as already seen in Section 8.1, bag-like models also admit chiral versions. In this section we shall focus on two models: the chiral quark soliton model (CQSM) [220,221], which can be also derived from the Nambu–Jona–Lasinio model by imposing non-linear constraints on the chiral ?elds [222–228], and the chiral quark model (CQM) [229]. The main di,erence between these two models is that in the CQSM chiral symmetry is dynamically broken within the model itself, while in the CQM quarks have large dynamical masses arising from a process of spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking which is not described by the model. Another important di,erence, rePected in the name of the two models, is that in the CQSM a non-trivial topology is introduced, which is crucial for stabilising the soliton whereas in the CQM chiral ?elds are treated as a perturbation. Finally, while the CQSM is a non-con?ning model, con?nement may be introduced into the CQM, starting from a non-chiral con?ning model and dressing the quarks with chiral ?elds. As for the spin structure of the nucleon, chiral models are characterised by a depolarisation of valence quarks, due to a transfer of total angular momentum of the nucleon into the orbital angular momentum of the sea, described by the chiral ?elds. This feature has made the chiral models quite popular for the study of the spin structure of the nucleon. 8.2.1. Chiral quark soliton model The basic idea of the chiral quark soliton model is to describe the low-energy behaviour of QCD by two e,ective degrees of freedom, Nambu–Goldstone pions and quarks with a dynamical mass. The model is described by the following vacuum functional [220,221] 4 N 5 N exp{iSe, [(x)]} = D D exp i d x (i @ − mU ) (8.2.1)
128
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
with U = exp[ia (x)E a ];
(8.2.2a)
U 5 = exp[ia (x)E a 5 ] = 12 (1 + 5 )U + 12 (1 − 5 )U † :
(8.2.2b)
Here is the quark ?eld, m is the e,ective quark mass arising from the spontaneous breakdown of chiral symmetry, and U is the SU(2) chiral pion ?eld. A possible derivation of the e,ective action (8.2.1) is based on the instanton model of QCD vacuum [220]. The CQSM describes the nucleon as a state of Nc valence quarks bound by a self-consistent hedgehog-like pion ?eld whose energy, in fact, coincides with the aggregate energy of quarks from the negative-energy Dirac continuum. This model di,ers from the -model [201,202] in that no kinetic energy is associated to the chiral ?elds, which are e,ective degrees of freedom, totally equivalent to the qqN excitations of the Dirac sea (the problem of double-counting does not arise). The CQSM ?eld equations are solved as follows. For a given time-independent pion ?eld U = exp(ia (x)E a ), one ?nds the spectrum of the Dirac Hamiltonian: HAn = En An ;
(8.2.3)
which contains the upper and lower Dirac continua (distorted by the presence of the external pion ?eld), and may also contain discrete bound-state levels, if the pion ?eld is strong enough. If the pion ?eld has winding number 1, there is exactly one bound-state level which travels all the way from the upper to the lower Dirac continuum as one increases the spatial size of the pion ?eld from zero to in?nity. This level must be ?lled to obtain a non-zero baryon-number state. Since the pion ?eld is colour blind, in the discrete level one may place Nc quarks in a state that is antisymmetric in colour. Calling Elev (with −M 6 Elev 6 M ) the energy of the discrete level, the nucleon mass is obtained by adding Nc Elev to the energy of the pion ?eld (which coincides exactly with the overall energy of the lower Dirac continuum) and subtracting the free continuum. The self-consistent pion ?eld is thus found by minimising the functional # M = min Nc Elev [U ] + (En [U ] − En(0) ) : (8.2.4) U
En ¡0
From symmetry considerations one looks for the minimum in a hedgehog con?guration x Uc (x) = exp[ia (x)E a ] = exp[i(n · )P(r)]; r = |x|; n = ; (8.2.5) r where P(r) is the pro?le of the soliton. The latter is then obtained using a variational procedure. At lowest order in 1=Nc , the CQSM essentially corresponds to a mean-?eld picture. Some observables, however, vanish at zeroth order in 1=Nc (this is the case, as we shall see, of unpolarised isovector and polarised isoscalar distribution functions) and for these quantities a calculation at ?rst order in 1=Nc is clearly needed.
V. Barone et al. / Physics Reports 359 (2002) 1–168
129
Within the CQSM several calculations of distribution functions have been performed [230 – 234]. In particular, the transversity distributions were computed in [235 –238]. The calculations mainly di,er in the order of 1=Nc expansion considered. We shall see that this expansion is related to the expansion in the collective angular velocity : of the hedgehog solution, and hence to the collective quantisation of the hedgehog solitons. The ?rst application of the CQSM to transversity is contained in [235], where only the tensor charges were computed. In that paper the CQSM was extended from two to three Pavours with a chiral SU (3)R ⊗ SU (3)L symmetry (for a review see [239]). Corrections of order 1=Nc were taken into account in building the quantised soliton. The procedure adopted in [235] for constructing states with de?nite spin and Pavour out of the hedgehog is the so-called cranking procedure [203,240]. The parameters of the model are the constituent mass of the u and d quarks, the explicit