Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46 www.elsevier.com/locate/physrep
Light-ion-induced multifragmentation: The ISiS project V.E. Violaa,∗ , K. Kwiatkowskia,1 , L. Beaulieua,2 , D.S. Brackena,1 , H. Breuerb , J. Brzychczyka, c , R.T. de Souzaa , D.S. Gingera,3 , W-C. Hsia , R.G. Kortelingd , T. Leforta,4 , W.G. Lynche , K.B. Morleya,1 , R. Legrainf , , L. Pienkowskig , E.C. Pollaccof , E. Renshawa,5 , A. Ruangmah,6 , M.B. Tsange , C. Volantf , G. Wanga,7 , S.J. Yennelloh , N.R. Yodera a Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA b University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20740, USA c Jagellonian University, Krakow, Poland d Simon Fraser University, Burnaby BC, Canada V5A IS6 e National Superconducting Laboratory, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA f CEA Saclay, Saclay, France gWarsaw University, Warsaw, Poland h Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA
Accepted 18 July 2006 Available online 28 September 2006 editor: G.E. Brown
Abstract An extensive study of GeV light-ion-induced multifragmentation and its possible interpretation in terms of a nuclear liquid–gas phase transition has been performed with the Indiana Silicon Sphere (ISiS) 4 detector array. Measurements were performed with 5–15 GeV/c p, p, and − beams incident on 197Au and 2–5 GeV 3 He incident on natAg and 197Au targets. Both the reaction dynamics and the subsequent decay of the heavy residues have been explored. The data provide evidence for a dramatic change in the reaction observables near an excitation energy of E ∗/A = 4.5 MeV/residue nucleon. In this region, fragment multiplicities and energy spectra indicate emission from an expanded/dilute source on a very short time scale (20–50 fm/c). These properties, along with caloric curve and scaling-law behavior, yield a pattern that is consistent with a nuclear liquid–gas phase transition. © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 25.70.Pq; 25.55.−e Keywords: 4 detector array; Multifragmentation; Reaction dynamics; Nuclear density; Reaction time scale; Caloric curve; Scaling laws; Liquid–gas phase transition
∗ Corresponding author.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (V.E. Viola). Deceased. 1 Present address: Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545, USA. 2 Present address: Laval University, Quebec City, Canada G1K 7P4. 3 Present address: University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA. 4 Present address: University of Caen, Caen, France. 5 Present address: Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA 98052, USA. 6 Present address: Siriraj Hospital, Bangkok 10700, Thailand. 7 Present address: Epsilon Corp., Irving, TX, USA. 0370-1573/$ - see front matter © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2006.07.005
2
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Contents 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. The ISiS experimental program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Reaction dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Excitation energy deposition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. BUU simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Sideways peaking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Statistical decay: multifragmentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. Calorimetry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Thermal observables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.1. Fragment spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.2. Multiplicities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.3. IMF charge distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.4. Cross sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.5. Source charge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. Breakup density and expansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. Breakup time scale . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Thermodynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. The caloric curve: isotope-ratio temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. The caloric curve: density-dependent Fermi-gas temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. Heat capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. The liquid–gas phase transition: scaling-law behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Summary and conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 3 6 6 10 11 12 12 17 18 18 20 20 21 22 26 30 30 33 34 36 41 43 44
1. Introduction One of the most important signals of the formation of hot nuclear matter is the emission of nuclear clusters, or intermediate-mass fragments (IMF: 3 Z20). From studies of the IMF yields in energetic nuclear reactions one hopes to gain greater insight into the thermodynamics of highly-excited nuclei and the nuclear equation-of-state at low densities. An important aspect of such studies is the identification of a possible nuclear liquid–gas phase transition [1–3]. IMF emission was first observed in the 1950s, when beams of protons and alpha particles with energies in the GeV range became available. Emulsion and radiochemical measurements of the reaction products showed that the probability for cluster emission increased strongly with beam energy, suggesting their association with the decay of highly excited nuclei. The emulsion measurements also provided evidence for multiple fragment emission, or multifragmentation. These data led to the concept that the reaction mechanism could be schematically viewed in terms of a two-step intranuclear cascade/statistical emission model, with IMFs emitted primarily in the evaporation stage. One complication with this model was the observation that lighter clusters exhibited forward-peaked angular distributions, indicating that a prompt non-statistical mechanism must also be present. Another perceptive proposal was that pion production and reabsorbtion could be a major mechanism for excitation-energy deposition in the heavy residual nucleus [4,5]. These studies, carried out at Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, Brookhaven National Laboratory and in Russia, laid the groundwork for future studies and are reviewed in [6–9]. The development of silicon semiconductor detectors in the 1960s made it possible to perform measurements of inclusive IMF yields and kinetic energy spectra. Bombardments of heavy targets with 5 GeV protons provided a more systematic understanding of the earlier work, and showed clearly the existence of two mechanisms for IMF production—one equilibrium-like and the other a fast nonequilibrium process [10,11]. An important aspect of the spectra was a downward shift in the apparent Coulomb barrier relative to lower energy reactions. It was suggested that this shift was due to a modified density distribution, perhaps due to an expanded source. Later, similar inclusive measurements with protons up to 350 GeV [12] confirmed radiochemical studies that indicated the IMF emission probability reaches a maximum near 10 GeV and remains constant thereafter [13]. These later measurements also tracked the evolution of the Coulomb peak displacement with beam energy, and found its onset to be near 4 GeV.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
3
This result was interpreted as a possible sign of critical behavior [1,14], and stimulated widespread interest in this possibility. To search for more conclusive evidence of a phase transition and critical behavior, it was necessary to develop largesolid-angle detector arrays to provide fragment kinetic energy spectra, multiplicity information, event topology and calorimetry. Among the most important features of such a device are: (1) nuclide (Z and A) identification of all products, including neutrons; (2) spatial characterization with good granularity; (3) low detection thresholds; (4) good energy resolution over a large dynamic range; and (5) efficient, reliable detector calibration techniques. Another important factor in detector design is the geometry imposed by reaction kinematics; e.g. IMF fragment distributions are nearly isotropic in light-ion-induced reactions, with a small component in the beam direction, whereas they are strongly forward-focused in heavy-ion reactions. With improvements in detector and data-acquisition techniques, it became possible to construct complex detector arrays for performing exclusive measurements that met most, but not all, of the above conditions for complex fragments. The first such array was the LBL Plastic Ball/Wall [15], which demonstrated the existence of events with high multiplicities of IMFs and light-charged particles (LCP: Z = 1, 2) [16]. Later measurements at LNS Saclay confirmed the high IMF multiplicities and yield dependence on bombarding energy [17]. These measurements also showed that the IMF spectral peak energies decreased as a function of increasing multiplicity, consistent with the expansion scenario. Subsequently, several 4 detector arrays were constructed for the study of light-ion induced multifragmentation: the EOS TPC [18], the Berlin Silicon/Neutron Ball [19], the Dubna FASA array [20] and the Indiana Silicon Sphere (ISiS) [21]. At the same time heavy-ion accelerator technology, had advanced to the stage where it became possible to study multifragmentation in A + A reactions, which lead to the construction of several additional detectors [22–27]. At the outset it should be stressed that there is general concordance among the results of all of these projects with those from ISiS, as can be found in [27]. In the following sections, we survey the salient results of the ISiS program with GeV light-ion projectiles, and address the question: is there evidence for a nuclear liquid–gas phase transition? 2. The ISiS experimental program The Indiana Silicon Sphere project was initiated in the late 1980s with a specific focus on GeV light-ion-induced reactions on heavy nuclei. Light ions bring a unique perspective to multifragmentation studies in that they emphasize the thermal properties of the disintegrating residue, with minimal distortions of the spectra due to rotational and compressional effects. Experimentally, GeV light ion beams form only one emitting source, which decays in a reference frame that is very close to that of the center-of-mass (source velocities ∼ 0.01c). In addition, the energy-deposition mechanism produces a continuous distribution of excitation energies, permitting broad coverage of the excitation energy distribution in a single reaction. Based upon previous inclusive and semi-exclusive studies [17], the ISiS 4 array was designed in a spherical geometry, with very low detector thresholds and a large dynamic range for LCPs and IMFs [21]. Particle identification was based on triple telescopes composed of an ion-implanted silicon detector, preceded by a gas-ion chamber for low energy fragments and followed by a CsI(T) crystal for the most energetic particles, primarily LCPs. An overall schematic diagram of ISiS is shown in Fig. 1, accompanied by a photo in Fig. 2. The array consists of 162 particle-identification telescopes, 90 covering the angles 14.86.4◦ and 72 spanning 93.6.166◦ . The telescopes are arranged in eight rings, each of which is composed of 18 truncated ion-chamber housings. In the forward-most ring, the Si and CsI detectors were divided into two segments to increase granularity. The geometric acceptance of the ISiS array was modeled with the program GEANT, which yielded a solid-angle coverage of 74% for the silicon elements and 80% for CsI(21). The geometry, detector properties, energy loss in components and trigger conditions were included in construction of the detector filter that was used to convert the measured data to physics distributions. The reliability of the filter was tested with multifragmentation model results as input. Good agreement was found between the initial and reconstructed distributions. A schematic drawing of the detector telescopes is shown in Fig. 3. The detectors are mounted in gold-plated, highconductivity copper cans. The first element in each telescope (E) is an axial-field gas-ionization chamber (GIC), operated at ∼ 200 V and a pressure of 15–20 Torr of C3 F8 gas. These conditions permitted identification of fragments with energies as low as ∼ 0.8 MeV/nucleon. All detectors operate in a common gas volume in each hemisphere, with vacuum isolation provided by a ∼120.150 g/cm2 stretched polypropylene window covered with a thin graphite
4
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 1. Assembly drawing of the ISiS detector array. Components are as follows: (1) center support ring; (2) gas–vacuum separation window; (3) arc support bars; (4) partition disks; (5) beamline support cones; (6) target ladder assembly; (7) steel rails for opening housing cans; and (8) vacuum chamber.
coating. The ion chambers are followed by an ion-implanted silicon detector of thickness 500 m, which is sufficient to stop E/A ∼ 8 MeV LCPs and IMFs. The GIC–Si telescopes provided Z resolution for Z = 1–16 fragments in the energy interval from E/A ∼ 0.8–8.0 MeV. Due to the GIC energy resolution, mass identification was not possible in the GIC/Si pair. The final element of each telescope was a 28 mm-thick CsI(T) crystal, read out by a photodiode. These crystals provided an energy acceptance of 1 MeV E/A 92 MeV. The Si–CsI(Tl) pair provided Z and A identification for 8 MeV E/A92 MeV particles and “grey particle” detection for fast protons and pions up to ∼ 350 MeV. The ISiS telescopes did not detect neutrons or Z-identify heavy residues and fission fragments. Detector signals were shaped and amplified by means of charge-sensing preamplifier/linear shaper NIM units, with gains custom-designed for each detector type. Analog signals were digitized by 12-bit 16-channel peak-sensing ADCs and fast signal discrimination and multiplicity sensing was accomplished with 16-channel discriminators and timeto-digital converters. Voltages for each detector type were supplied by in-house-designed, computer-controlled bias supply units. The event hardware trigger was generated from the fast outputs of the discriminators and required a minimum of three detected particles. This criterion was imposed by the high backgrounds associated with synchrotrom accelerators and biased the data against low-excitation energy events (E ∗ A1 MeV). In software, only events with three thermal particles, one of which with Z 2, were accepted. More complete details for the ISiS array can be found in [21]. Three multifragmentation campaigns were carried out with ISiS: (1) E228 with 1.8–4.8 GeV 3 He ions at the Laboratoire National Saturne in Saclay, France; (2) E900 at the Brookhaven AGS accelerator with 5.0–14.6 GeV/c proton
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
5
Fig. 2. Photograph of the ISiS detector loaded with detector telescopes.
Fig. 3. Drawing of an ISiS arc bar segment for the forward hemisphere with the angular coverage of each telescope labeled. Each segment is part of an 18-member ring; the forward-most element is divided into two segments. Forward-angle rings are identified as follows: 14.22◦ ; 22.33◦ ; 33.52◦ ; 52.69◦ ; 69.86.4◦ . Backward-angle rings are: 93.6.111◦ ; 111.128◦ ; 128.147◦ ; and 147.166◦ .
and − beams; and (3) E900a at AGS with tagged 8.0 GeV/c antiproton and − beams. The number of events with each beam is summarized in Table 1. In the following sections, we present the results obtained with ISiS. We first examine the collision dynamics, then the thermal observables, and finally the thermodynamics and scaling-law behavior of the data.
6
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Table 1 Number of events analyzed for each system (in parentheses). Event acceptance requires at least three thermal charged particles in silicon detectors, one of which must have Z 2 Beam
Target
−
197Au
p
197Au
p¯
197Au
3 He
natAg 197Au
a Tagged
Energy/momentum 5.0 GeV/c (1.0 × 106 ) 6.2 GeV/c (2.4 × 105 )
1.8 GeV (4.9 × 106 ) 1.8 GeV (4.0 × 105 )
8.0 GeV/ca (2.5 × 106 ) 9.2 GeV/c (1.7 × 106 ) 8.0 GeV/ca (5.5 × 104 ) 3.6 GeV (3.0 × 106 )
8.2 GeV/c (2.4 × 106 ) 12.8 GeV/c (1.4 × 106 )
9.2 GeV/c (1.4 × 106 ) 14.6 GeV/c (1.1 × 106 )
4.8 GeV (1.9 × 106 ) 4.8 GeV (2.9 × 106 )
beam.
3. Reaction dynamics 3.1. Excitation energy deposition In GeV light-ion-induced reactions the dissipation of radial beam energy into internal excitation of the target-like residue proceeds through a complex fast cascade of nucleon–nucleon collisions. This mechanism is abetted by the excitation of and higher resonances, followed by the reabsorbtion of some of the decay pions [28–32]. For antiproton beams, excitation-energy deposition is further enhanced by the reabsorbtion of some fraction of the 4–5 annihilation pions [33]. Although the energy dissipation process is relatively inefficient, the cascade step is capable of imparting up to ∼ 2 GeV of excitation energy in heavy nuclei. Equally important, randomized/equilibrated residues are produced with a continuous distribution of excitation energies, essentially providing nearly a complete excitation function in a single reaction. Fig. 4 depicts the predictions of a BUU (Boltzmann–Uehling–Uhlenbeck) calculation [34,35] that traces the time and density evolution of a central (b = 2.0 fm) collision between a 14.6 GeV/c proton and a 197Au nucleus. Initially, a local density depletion develops along the projectile trajectory as forward-focused nucleons are ejected on a fast time scale. After about 30 fm/c the nuclear matter density becomes more uniform, indicating a random distribution of nucleons. However, the average density is observed to be significantly lower than that of the original target, creating a hot, dilute nucleus. As the reaction time increases, the angular distribution of the emitted particles becomes more isotropic. At this point the distinction between low-energy cascade nucleons (nonequilibrium) and evaporative nucleons becomes blurred. Also, it is significant to notice that the heavy residue trajectory has a component transverse to the beam direction. In Fig. 5 the effect of entrance-channel beam momentum on excitation energy per nucleon (E ∗/A), average density (/0 ), entropy per nucleon (S/A) and residue mass (A) is explored as a function of time. Calculations are for an impact parameter b = 2.0 fm for the p+197 Au reaction at momenta of 6.2, 10.2, 12.8 and 14.6 GeV/c. It is observed that the excitation energy and entropy per nucleon increase with beam momenta, while the source mass and average density decrease. At long reaction times there is little change in E ∗/A and /0 indicating a saturation in these variables. Also, in all cases the entropy per nucleon remains nearly constant beyond 30–40 fm/c, consistent with the existence of a randomized system. The most significant dependence on increasing beam momentum is the systematic decrease in residue mass, or in terms of the emitted particles, a greater contribution to the cascade/nonequilibrium yield. All p + A reaction dynamics calculations predict that the excitation energy probability decreases exponentially with increasing excitation energy. For this reason, it is of interest to investigate the relative efficiency of different hadron probes in depositing excitation energy. Fig. 6 shows results of an intranuclear cascade calculation [31,36,37] for the average excitation energy (E ∗ > 50 MeV) as a function of beam momentum for proton, negative pion and antiproton beams. For the p and − cases there is little difference, since the cascades follow similar paths. On the other hand, the annihilation pions from the p¯ interaction enhance E ∗ significantly. The inset in Fig. 6 demonstrates that the excitation-energy distribution for antiprotons is expected to extend to higher values than for protons and pions.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
7
14.6 GeV/c, (σin,Up), b=2 fm 15
t = 0 fm/c
t = 10 fm/c
t = 20 fm/c
t = 30 fm/c
t = 40 fm/c
t = 50 fm/c
10 5 0
X (fm)
-5 -10 -15
1
10
0
10-1
ρ /ρ0
5
-5 -10 -15
10-2 -15 -10 -5
0
5
10 -15 -10 -5 0 Z (fm)
5
10 -15 -10 -5
0
5
10
Fig. 4. Nuclear density within the reaction plane XZ around the position coordinate Y = 0, where Z is along the beam axis, at different times in the p+197 Au reaction at 14.6 GeV/c. Calculation is for b = 2 fm, with the (in , U p ) transport simulations discussed in Section 3.2 [35].
Fig. 5. Excitation energy per nucleon of the source, mean density, entropy per nucleon and residue mass number, as a function of time in the p + Au reaction at b = 2 fm and different incident momenta, from the (in , U p ) transport simulations [35], discussed in Section 3.2.
8
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 6. Intranuclear cascade predictions [31] of the average excitation energy for events with E ∗ > 50 MeV are shown as a function of beam momentum for p, − and p¯ beams incident on 197Au. Inset compares the excitation energy probability distributions for 8 GeV/c − and p¯ beams.
Fig. 7. Measured excitation (left frame) and residue mass (right frame) probabilities for several of the systems studied in this work, as energy indicated on the figure. P (E ∗ ) = 1. Data for 6.2 and 12.8 GeV are not shown but are consistent. Values < 250 MeV are uncertain because of missing neutrons in the calorimetry procedure.
In comparing the predictions of the dynamics codes with experimental data, the primary quantities of interest are the energy deposited in the statistical residue E ∗ and its mass A. To do so, however, requires separation of cascade/preequilibrium emissions from those associated with the equilibrium-like heavy residue prior to event reconstruction. This calorimetry procedure is described in Section 4.1. In Fig. 7 we show the reconstructed probability distributions for excitation energy and residue mass for several systems studied in this work. The reconstructed E ∗ distributions shown in the left panel of Fig. 7 demonstrate that
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
9
Fig. 8. Bottom: the probability for observing events with excitation energy greater than E ∗ 400 MeV relative to the probability for events with E ∗ = 400 MeV. Systems are indicated on the figure. Top: average mass loss A in the fast cascade as a function of excitation energy. Systems are defined in bottom frame.
the largest population of high excitation-energy events is achieved with the 8.0 GeV/c p¯ beam and the lowest with the 5.0 GeV -beam. Thus, the data are qualitatively in agreement with the INC calculations (intranuclear cascade) shown in Fig. 6, although the calculations extend to somewhat higher energies than the data. The residue mass distributions in the right panel of Fig. 7 show a different pattern. In this case the 14.6 GeV/c proton beam produces the lightest residues and the 5.0 GeV/c -beam the heaviest, a result relatively well reproduced by the calculations. This mass dependence on beam momentum can be understood as a consequence of the fast cascade, which produces an increasing number of fast knock-out particles as the beam momentum increases [28,32]. This process produces the saturation in excitation energy observed for hadrons with momenta greater than ∼ 8 GeV/c. That is, the increase in total beam energy available for E ∗ deposition is counter-balanced by the loss of energy due to mass loss A during the fast cascade. The relative effectiveness of various beams in depositing high excitation energies (Fig. 7) is emphasized in the bottom panel of Fig. 8. Included here are comparable data from the 4.8 GeV 3 He+197 Au reaction [38] and from the 1.2 GeV p+ ¯ 197 Au reaction [39]. In order to emphazise the probability for forming highly excited systems, all data are normalized to probability P (E ∗ ) = 1 at E ∗ = 400 MeV. Fig. 8 confirms that the 8.0 GeV/c p¯ beam produces a significant enhancement of high excitation energy events, particularly in the multifragmentation region above E ∗ 800 MeV. This figure further supports the predictions of the cascade code; i.e., enhanced E ∗ with p¯ beams, saturation above ∼ 8 GeV/c beam momentum, and exponentiallydecreasing probabilities for high E ∗/A values. The behavior of the 3 He beam can be understood as due to its average beam momentum of 2.6 GeV/c/ nucleon. Another perspective on the influence of reaction dynamics is provided by studies with 3 He beams [40,41]. Fig. 9 shows the probability distribution of the total observed thermalized energy and the correlation with the transverse fragment kinetic energies for the 3 He+nat Ag and 197Au reactions. The thermal energy, which is strongly correlated with excitation energy, is significantly lower for the lighter nat Ag target. However, when source mass corrections are made,
10
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 9. Transverse energy (upper) and probability distributions (lower) as a function of observed thermal energy for 3 He-induced reactions on 197 Au (left) and nat Ag (right). Beam energies are indicated as follows: 1.8 GeV (circles and dot-dashed lines); 3.6 GeV (triangles and dashed lines), and 4.8 GeV (squares and solid lines). Error bars indicate standard deviations of distribution widths (±) and are representative of data.
the energy per nucleon distributions are very similar for both targets [40]. The projectile-target effect on the saturation of excitation energy with beam energy is in good agreement with INC calculations [30,41] for this lower momentum complex projectile. The lower right-hand frame of Fig. 9 shows that the probability distributions are identical for the 3 He+nat Ag at 3.6 and 4.8 GeV, indicating the onset of deposition energy saturation near 3.6 GeV. The slight difference at 3.6 and 4.8 GeV for the transverse energy correlations is due to the difficulty in removing nonequilibrium events from this sum, which illustrates the uncertainties involved with the use of transverse energy as a gauge of excitation energy deposition. 3.2. BUU simulations While the equilibrium-like events are of primary interest for multifragmentation studies, the nonequilibrium component of the spectrum is important for understanding the reaction dynamics. In order to investigate this facet of the data, predictions of a BUU code that includes d, t and 3 He cluster formation have been compared with cascade/preequilibrium d/p, t/p and 3 He/p ratios for the p+197 Au reaction between 6.2 and 14.6 GeV/c [34,35]. BUU calculations were performed for various reaction times with and without a momentum-dependent potential and with both free and in-medium cross-section options. Results for the 14.6 GeV/c p+197 Au reaction are shown in Fig. 10. From examination of the LCP ratios for all four bombarding energies, the best agreement with all the data is found when both a momentum-dependent potential and in-medium cross-sections are employed in the BUU code, with a most probable reaction time of t ∼ 65 fm/c. From comparison with Fig. 5, entropy considerations suggest that randomization of the nucleon momenta in the heavy residue occurs after about t ∼ 30 fm/c, indicating an additional 30–40 fm/c is required to reach a state of quasiequilibrium, after which the residue undergoes statistical decay.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
11
Fig. 10. Normalized yields of nonequilibrium light charged particles as a function of the source excitation energy for the p+Au reaction at 14.6 GeV/c. Circles represent data and lines represent filtered ratios from different versions of the transport calculations, at different reaction times.
Further, the BUU calculation that incorporates clusters, a momentum-dependent potential, in-medium cross sections and a time scale of t ∼ 65 fm/c is able to describe the excitation-energy probability distribution and the average source Z and A as a function of E ∗/A. One important aspect of this code is that the inclusion of clusters serves to enhance energy deposition in the heavy residue. This feature is missing in other codes designed for transport calculations with GeV hadron beams. 3.3. Sideways peaking Finally, the ISiS data demonstrate the important role that reaction dynamics exert on the statistical decay properties of hot residues. Earlier inclusive studies [42–44] showed the existence of sideways peaking of IMF angular distributions for p + A reactions above ∼ 10 GeV. This result was interpreted as possible evidence for dynamical IMF emission during the initial phases of the cascade, possibly signaling the existence of nuclear shock wave effects. Exclusive IMF angular distributions obtained with ISiS support a more mundane origin for the sideways peaking. In [45] it is confirmed that the sideways peaking develops only above beam momenta of 8–10 GeV/c and that degree of peaking increases as IMF multiplicity and charge increase. This result indicates that the peaking is associated with high deposition energy collisions, where multifragmentation is the major decay mode. In Fig. 11 relative angular distributions for Z = 5–9 fragments produced in MIMF 4 events are compared for reactions with 5.0 GeV/c − (left panel) and 14.6 GeV/c p (center panel) beams on a 197Au target. Fragment kinetic energy cuts of E/A = 1.2–3.0, 3.0–5.0 and 5.0–10.0 MeV are imposed on the spectra and all angular distributions are normalized to unity at 160◦ . (In this regard it should be stressed that most of the cross section is concentrated in the kinetic energy bins below
12
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 11. Dependence of relative angular distributions on IMF kinetic energy for Z = 5–9 fragments formed in events with IMF multiplicity M 4 for 5.0 GeV/c (left) and 14.6 GeV/c proton (center) beams incident on 197Au [45]. Angular distributions are normalized to 1.0 at 160◦ . IMF kinetic energy bins are indicated in the figure. Solid lines in the left and center panels are results of moving-source fits. Right-hand panel shows prediction of an INC/SMM calculation [31,46] for the 14 GeV/c p+197 Au reaction, binned the same as the data.
E/A = 5 MeV.) It is observed that as the IMF kinetic energy decreases, the angular distributions become increasingly isotropic for both energies. However, whereas for the − beam the angular distributions remain forward-peaked, for the 14.6 GeV/c proton case sideways peaking is observed—and the maximum differential cross section evolves to larger angles as the IMF velocity decreases. The observation that sideways emission is favored by high beam momentum, high IMF charge and low IMF kinetic energy suggests a possible origin in the kinematics of the residue rather than in dynamical emission. The diffractive nature of the initial N–N collision at GeV momenta preferentially produces a secondary nucleon or N ∗ that recoils 70.90◦ to the beam axis, with the angle growing as the beam momentum increases. Subsequent dissipation during the cascade imparts a transverse velocity component to the heavy residue. The net result is that statistical fragment emission from the residue is focused non-axial to the beam direction—which affects the lowest energy IMFs most strongly. This conjecture is reinforced by INC/SMM (statistical multifragmentation model) calculations [31,46], shown in the righthand frame of Fig. 11 and is also illustrated in Fig. 4. Thus, these results, coupled with IMF–IMF angular correlations and sphericity and coplanarity distributions, described in [47], do not support arguments for dynamical effects such as shock waves as a source of sideways-peaking observed in inclusive angular distribution studies. 4. Statistical decay: multifragmentation 4.1. Calorimetry In any attempt to describe a system in terms of thermodynamics, a knowledge of the heat content is fundamental. For hot nuclei, this energetic factor is expressed in terms of the excitation energy per residue nucleon, E ∗/A. In this section we examine the procedures for determining E ∗ and A for the ISiS data [40,48,49]. For each reconstructed event, the excitation energy of the emitting source is calculated as follows: ∗ Esource =
Mcp i
Kcp (i) + Mn Kn + E − Q,
(4.1)
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
13
Z=1
10-1
Z=2 10-1
dσ/dE (arb. units)
10-2
10-3 Z=3
10-2
10-3 Z=6
10-2
10-3
0
20 40 60 80 Kinetic Energy (MeV)
100
Fig. 12. Angle-integrated kinetic energy spectra in the laboratory frame for Z = 1, 2, 3 and 6, as indicated in each panel, emitted in the 8.0 GeV/c − +197 Au reaction. Open points correspond to data. Dashed (dotted) lines represent the thermal-like (nonequilibrated) component of a moving-source fit. The solid line is the sum of the two fits. Upper cutoff energies [41] are shown by vertical arrows.
here Kcp is the kinetic energy for all thermal charged particles, Mn is the multiplicity of thermal neutrons with average kinetic energy Kn , E is the total energy emitted by gammas, and −Q is the removal energy (the negative of the reaction Q-value). Each of these terms requires assumptions, as described in the following. In calculating the charged particle contribution to E ∗ in Eq. (4.1), cascade/preequilibrium emissions prior to thermalization must be removed from the sum. Separation on an event-by-event basis is not fully transparent due to the time evolution of the cooling process. Fig. 12 presents angle-integrated spectra for Z = 1, 2, 3 and 6 nuclei from the
14
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 13. Angle-dependent spectra for Z = 1. Reaction is 8.0 GeV/c − +197 Au.
8.0 GeV/c − +197 Au reaction. Because source velocities are low (∼ 0.01c), kinematic effects are small. The principal features of the spectra are a Maxwellian low-energy component, which we attribute to thermal events, and an exponentially-decreasing high-energy tail due to nonequilibrium processes. The spectra have been decomposed [41,48,49] with a two-component moving-source model [50]. In Fig. 12 the thermal source [51,52] is described by the dashed lines, the nonequilibrium source [50] by dotted lines and the total by the solid line. The nonequilibrium component is most important for the hydrogen isotopes, but is also a significant fraction of the He yield. In the proton case the two-component model is insufficient to account for the high-energy portion of the spectrum, suggesting evidence for three components: thermal at low energies, preequilibrium at intermediate energies, and fast cascade particles at the highest energies. Such a picture is consistent with the BUU transport calculations in Section 3. As seen in Fig. 13, nonequilibrium emission persists, even at the most backward angles. Fig. 13 also illustrates the weak-angular dependence of the spectra. For IMFs, the nonequilibrium component decreases in yield as the IMF charge increases. For carbon and heavier IMFs, the angle-integrated preequilibrium yield is negligible. Since H and He isotopes constitute most of the charged-particle yield, calorimetry requires a systematic procedure for distinguishing between thermal and nonequilibrium emissions on an event-by-event basis. This need was a primary motivation for the moving-source fits to the spectra. From moving-source analyses of all the spectra from the 1.8–4.8 GeV 3 He+197 Au reaction [41], it was concluded that a sharp cutoff approximation gave a satisfactory account of the fraction of thermal events in the spectra. The thermal cutoff values were: Kcp (Z = 1) 30 MeV
and
Kcp (Z 2)(9Z + 40) MeV.
(4.2) (4.3)
These cutoffs are indicated by the arrows in Fig. 12, and correspond approximately to the break in the slope of the spectral tails. This method of determining the thermal yield was also compared with the integrated yield from the
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
15
Fig. 14. Excitation-energy distributions for sharp cutoff assumptions of Eqs. (4.2) and (4.3) compared with a cutoff value of Kcp < 30 A MeV.
two-component fits, which led to slightly lower E ∗ values [48]. For the calculation of excitation energy in this work, the cutoff values of Eqs. (4.2) and (4.3) were employed. The resulting thermal yields are isotropic in the center-of-mass frame [48]. In contrast, the E ∗ analysis of the EOS 1 GeV 197 Au+12 C data [53] used a sharp cutoff assumption of E/A 30 MeV for all fragments. This approach yields significantly higher E ∗ values, as shown in Fig. 14, largely due to the inclusion of preequilibrium He ions in the sum of Eq. (4.1). When this difference is taken into account, the ISiS and EOS experiments are in good agreement in those areas where they overlap. While the EOS calibration may lead to high E ∗ values, the ISiS sharp cutoff approximation may underestimate E ∗ for high excitation energies. This problem is illustrated in Fig. 15 where the LCP kinetic energy spectra are plotted for several E ∗/A bins. The sharp cutoff distinction is clear at low excitation energies, but the two components blend into one as E ∗/A increases, blurring the separation. The second major uncertainty in determining E ∗/A for the ISiS data is the unmeasured neutron contribution to both the thermal sum in Eq. (4.1) and the cascade/preequilibrium multiplicity as it affects the source mass [40,48]. In order to estimate the thermal-like neutron component, we have normalized the neutron charged-particle correlations reported by [39] to the ISiS charged-particle results. The measured correlations, shown in Fig. 16, are reasonably well described for charged-particle multiplicity M 4 by model simulations [46,54] and show the same qualitative behavior as has been observed in heavy-ion reactions [55]. A mass-balance procedure [56] does not work well for the ISiS data. The rapid rise in neutron multiplicity at low energies, where charged-particle multiplicities are low, makes the ISiS E ∗ values increasingly uncertain below E ∗ 200 MeV. Several assumptions have been employed in order to estimate the average neutron kinetic energy as a function of E ∗/A. For the 4.8 GeV 3 He reactions Kn was estimated from Coulomb-corrected proton spectra and then iterated to obtain a consistent value Kn =2Tth , where Tth =(E ∗/a)1/2 and a=A/11 MeV−1 [40]. For the hadron-induced reactions several relationships were explored, including Fermi-gas and Maxwell-gas assumptions with level density parameters a = A/8 MeV−1 and A/13 MeV−1 [48]. Comparisons were also made with SMM [46] and SIMON [54] evaporation codes. Based on this analysis, the SMM predictions were used as a conservative estimate of the neutron kinetic energy contribution to E ∗ . Eq. (4.1) is then iterated to obtain self-consistency. This procedure produced a somewhat lower neutron kinetic energy contribution than in [40]. For both the neutron multiplicities and kinetic energies, the use of averages leads to loss of fluctuation information in the final excitation energies. The sharp-cutoff and neutron assumptions, and the detector geometry, are included in the detector filter, along with those properties discussed in Section 2. The minor contribution to Eq. (4.1) from gamma emission is assumed to be E = 2(Mcp + Mn ) MeV in [40] and E = M(Z 3) MeV [48]. In order to calculate the removal energy (−Q), the charge and mass of the source must be reconstructed. The source charge is determined from
Mneq
Zsource = Ztgt −
i
Zi (neq),
(4.4)
16
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Z=1 103
E*/A 2-4
dσ/dE (arb. units)
4-6 102
6-9
Z=2 103
102
10 0
20 40 60 80 Kinetic Energy (MeV)
100
Fig. 15. Angle-integrated kinetic-energy spectra in the laboratory for Z = 1 and 2 as indicated in each panel, and for three bins in E ∗/A calculated with the cutoff assumptions of Eqs. (4.2) and (4.3) [41]. The symbols correspond to bins of E ∗/A = 2–4 (open circles), E ∗/A = 4–6 (filled triangles), and E ∗/A = 6–9 MeV (open triangles). Reaction is 8.0 GeV/c − +197 Au.
and the mass from
Mneq
Asource = Atgt −
Zi (neq) − Mn (neq),
(4.5)
i
where Ztgt and Atgt are the charge and mass of the target, Zi (neq) is the charge of the measured cascade/preequilibrium (neq) particles, and the nonequilibrium neutron multiplicity is related to the nonequilibrium proton multiplicity by Mn = (neq) (neq) 1.93Mp . The assumption for Mn is consistent with BUU calculations [35] and experimental results [59], and is intermediate between the A/Z of the target and experimental systematics [60]. The unmeasured IMF mass is based on the isotopically-resolved data of [61]. In the calculation of E ∗/A the resultant Q values and neutron multiplicities partially offset one another in Eq. (4.1); e.g., if the neutron term is over-estimated, then the removal energy is reduced, and vice versa. Several second-order corrections have been investigated and found to have no significant effects, among them: the source velocity (∼ 0.01c), source emission angle [58], and detector threshold effects. Since ISiS does not measure heavy residues, the additional assumption is made that all missing mass and charge are contained in a single residue. The residue mass distribution obtained in this way is in good agreement with measured results from [53]. The consistency of the ISiS calorimetry filter has been tested with SMM [46] and SIMON [54] calculations that use the measured source mass, charge and excitation energy as inputs to the codes [48]. One final consideration is the effect of the exponential decrease in the E ∗/A probability with increasing E ∗/A, which serves to decrease the excitation energy relative to the bin average. This effect is most significant for the highest excitation energy bins when the measured distribution is deconvoluted.
Mean neutron multiplicity
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
17
_
Charged-particle multiplicity (Z=1-16) Fig. 16. Relation between the mean neutron multiplicity and the charged-particle multiplicity. Solid line corresponds to data points reported for LEAR data by Ref. [39]; dotted line shows the SMM calculation [46], and the SIMON [54] evaporation result is given by the dashed line. The open squares give the mean multiplicities estimated with the mass conservation assumption [56,57].
The relative fractions of the excitation energy for the LCP, IMF and neutron kinetic energy contributions to Eq. (4.1) are plotted in the top frame of Fig. 17. Over the full range of E ∗/A the LCP fraction ranges from 25 to 30%, and that for neutrons from 20 to 25%, accounting for over half of the total E ∗ . The IMF kinetic energy fraction is relatively small, ranging from negligible values at low excitation energies to a near-constant value of ∼ 10–12% above E ∗/A ≈ 6 MeV. In the bottom frame of Fig. 17 the excitation energy fraction due to removal energy (−Q) is compared with the fraction for total kinetic energy. Except for low E ∗/A, where the calorimetry is most uncertain, the total kinetic energy sum is a near-constant factor of two greater than the removal energy. Overall we estimate that the values chosen for the ISiS E ∗/A data and associated assumptions could reasonably be lowered by ∼ 5% or increased by ∼ 15%. In the following sections we examine the data as a function of the calorimetric E ∗/A procedure described in this section. 4.2. Thermal observables Of the many experimental signals for thermal behavior in hot nuclei, the most transparent are found in the evolution of the spectra as a function of excitation energy. Two fundamental tests that a statistically-decaying system must face are: (1) is particle emission isotropic? and (2) are the kinetic energy spectra Maxwellian? In Fig. 18 invariant cross sections (parallel v versus perpendicular v⊥ ) velocity components are shown as a function of excitation-energy bins for hydrogen and carbon ions measured for the 8.0 GeV/c − +197 Au reaction. For energetic hydrogen ions (v0.2c) at all E ∗/A one observes a spray of forward-emitted particles that originates in cascade/preequilibrium processes. The low-energy part of these plots is nearly symmetric about zero velocity, indicating emission from a randomized source moving with an average velocity of ∼ 0.01c. The ISiS acceptance for thermal-like particles is defined by the dashed line in Fig. 18, i.e., the sharp cutoff assumption of [41]. The isotropy of the projected angular distributions for thermal LCP and IMF emission, as well as the relative insensitivity to excitation energy, has been demonstrated in [47,48]. In addition, an event-shape analysis for the thermal IMFs from the 4.8 GeV 3 He+197 Au reaction is found to be consistent with the existence of a randomized system that disintegrates on a very short time scale [47].
18
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
0.5 K.E. LCP K.E. neutron K.E. IMF
0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25
Excitation energy shares
0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 0.9
Kinetic energy Qvalue
0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
0
2
4
6 8 10 E* / A (MeV)
12
Fig. 17. Relative share of excitation energy for various components of the reconstruction procedure of Eq. (4.1) as a function of E ∗/A for the 8.0 GeV − +197 Au reaction. Top frame: light-charged particle kinetic energy (solid squares), neutron kinetic energy (open circles), and IMF kinetic energy (open triangles). Bottom frame: total particle kinetic energy (open circles) and Q values (solid squares).
4.2.1. Fragment spectra The Maxwellian character of the LCP and IMF kinetic-energy spectra is illustrated in Figs. 12, 13, and 15. Figs. 12, 13 and 18 show the systematic Coulomb shift in the spectral peaks due to kinematic behavior and fragment charge. Fig. 15 reveals two opposing trends that become apparent when the LCP spectra are gated on E ∗/A. First, the thermal slopes become flatter as E ∗/A increases, the expected result of the increasing temperatures. In contrast, instead of showing the expected temperature-dependent increase in the spectral (Coulomb) peak energies for a system at normal nuclear density, the spectral peak energies decrease. The net effect of these opposing effects is that the average mean kinetic energy for thermal particles is essentially independent of excitation energy, as shown in Fig. 19. This figure also shows the expected increase in the average kinetic energy as a function of fragment charge. Within the context of Figs. 15 and 19, the observed fragment mean kinetic energies can be interpreted in terms of a compensation between two competing factors: an increase in temperature offset by a decrease in the source density as the excitation energy increases. This behavior is explored in greater detail in Section 4.3. 4.2.2. Multiplicities An important signature of multifragmentation, and its possible relation to a nuclear liquid–gas phase transition [3,62,63], is the multiplicity of IMFs in an event. The models predict that above E ∗/A ∼ 4–5 MeV, multiple IMF emission should appear. Fig. 20 examines this prediction, presenting the average IMF multiplicity (top frame), emission probabilities for a fixed multiplicity (middle frame) and the probability for emitting three or more IMFs relative to two or less (bottom frame). The unmeasured heavy residue is not included in these probabilities and M is derived from a Monte Carlo reconstruction of the measured fragment multiplicity N that accounts for detector geometry and thresholds.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
19
0.2
(Perpendicular Velocity) /c
0.6
Z = 1
0.4
0.1
0.2
0.05
0
0 0.2
0.6
6 ≥ E*/A> 4
0.15
0.4
0.1
0.2
0.05
0
0 0.2
0.6
E*/A ≥ 8 MeV/A
0.15
0.4
0.1
0.2
0.05
0
4 ≥ E*/A > 2
Z = 6 0.15
-0.5
0 0.5 -0.2 (Parallel Velocity)/c
0
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
Fig. 18. Contour plot of longitudinal v vs. transverse v⊥ velocity of hydrogen (left) and carbon (right) fragments from the 8.0-MeV/c − +197 Au reaction for several bins in E ∗/A. Solid lines indicate geometrical acceptance of the ISiS array; dashed line gives the thermal cutoff velocity [48], not corrected for source velocity.
80
Mean kinetic energy (MeV)
70 60 50 40 30 E*/A ≥ 8 MeV 8 ≥ E*/A > 6 6 ≥ E*/A > 4 4 ≥ E*/A > 2
20 10 0
0
2
4
6
8 10 12 Fragment charge
14
16
18
Fig. 19. Fragment mean kinetic energy as a function of IMF charge calculated in the source frame for four bins of excitation energy, as indicated on the figure. Data are from the 8.0-GeV/c − -induced reaction on 197Au.
20
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
< N imf >
6
Correction II Correction I Experimental
4 2
P (Nimf)
0 1
10-1
P (Mimf)
10-2 1 P (Mimf ≥ 3)
0.75 0.5
P (Mimf = 0,1,2)
0.25 0 0
1
2
3
4
5 6 7 E*/A (MeV)
8
9
10
11
Fig. 20. Top: average number of IMFs for the observed yield (closed circles), the yield corrected for geometry (solid triangles), and the yield corrected for both geometry and fragment energy thresholds (open triangles) as a function of E ∗/A for the 8 GeV/c − +197 Au reaction. Middle: probability for given number of detected IMFs as a function of E ∗/A. Bottom: probability for IMF multiplicity M 3 (circles) and M < 3 (triangles).
In the top frame the IMF multiplicity is shown to increase monotonically, with no apparent deviation near E ∗/A ≈ 5 MeV. However, when the averages are decomposed into specific probabilities (middle frame), it is observed that as E ∗/A increases, the probability for increasing NIMF opens up systematically with increasing excitation energy. The probability for emitting three or more IMFs (the classical definition of multifragmentation [3]) is seen to grow rapidly near E ∗/A ∼ 4 MeV, so that above E ∗/A ∼ 5 MeVmultifragmentation becomes the dominant decay channel. This growth in IMF multiplicity is accompanied by a corresponding growth in the thermal LCP multiplicity. 4.2.3. IMF charge distributions Another important aspect of the multifragmentation mechanism is the distribution of fragment sizes (Z), of relevance to the question of critical phenomena and the liquid–gas phase transition. The ISiS charge distributions have been analyzed in terms of a power-law function, (Z) ∝ Z − , shown in Fig. 21. The results are nearly identical for all of the hadron-induced reactions and behave similarly for the 3 He+197 Au data [47]. At the lowest excitation energies, the large values of the power-law exponent imply that small fragments dominate the charge distribution, consistent with lower-energy proton-induced reactions [61,64,65]. As the system is heated, values decrease, signifying the increasing tendency to form larger clusters. A minimum in is reached near E ∗/A ≈ 5–6 MeV, corresponding to the rapid increase in IMF multiplicities. The tendency to form lighter clusters at high excitation energy is most likely due to the dissolution of the larger clusters in the heat bath and/or the formation of highly-excited clusters that undergo secondary decay. The average variances of the Z distributions have also been measured [66] and the relation of both and the average variance is discussed in Section 6 with regard to phase transition arguments. 4.2.4. Cross sections Comparison of the excitation-energy distribution in Figs. 7 and 14 and the IMF multiplicity probabilities in Fig. 20 demonstrates that multifragmentation is a small fraction ( 10%) of the total cross section in these light-ion reactions, most likely originating in the lowest impact-parameter collisions. For the 3 He beams the calculated total reaction cross section is approximately 2000 mb for the 197Au target and 1400 mb for natAg [67,68]. For the hadron-induced reactions, the reaction cross section is about 1900 mb [67,68]. The multifragmentation (MIMF 3) cross section ranges from about 50 mb for the 5 GeV/c − beam to 100–125 mb at the higher energies, where excitation-energy saturation occurs.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
21
Fig. 21. Top: average ratio of observed and geometry-corrected IMFs per residue nucleon as a function of E ∗/A; symbols are defined in the bottom frame. Bottom: power law parameters from fits to the charge distributions as a function of E ∗/A of the residue.
Table 2 Cross sections for the 3 He-induced reactions Ebeam (GeV)
MIMF 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 – (MIMF 3) IMF (M 1) IMF (total)
3 He+nat Ag
3 He+197 Au
1.8
3.6
4.8
1.8
4.8
Cross section (mb) 140 28 7.4 1.3 0.2 0.03 – – – – – 8.9 170 220
160 77 26 6.4 1.2 0.2 – – – – – 34 270 430
190 98 28 6.5 1.2 0.2 – – – – – 36 320 490
270 66 14 2.9 0.5 0.1 – – – – – 18 350 460
300 170 110 54 20 6.6 1.8 0.4 0.1 0.02 – 190 660 1300
In Table 2, the cross section dependence on target, beam energy and IMF multiplicity is presented for the 3 He-induced reactions. The yields clearly increase with target mass and projectile energy, with cross sections that range from 9 mb for the 1.8 GeV 3 He+nat Ag case to 190 mb for the 197Au target at 4.8 GeV. The effect of excitation-energy saturation in the natAg system near 3.5 GeV bombarding energy is evident. 4.2.5. Source charge Determination of the Z and A of the emitting source, as well as the unmeasured heavy residue(s), is also an important component of the reconstruction process described in Section 4.1. In the top frame of Fig. 22 the average fraction of the source charge relative to the target charge is shown as a function of E ∗/A. As the excitation energy increases, the effect of nonthermal particle emission becomes quite strong, leading to average source charges of Z ∼ 60 at E ∗/A ∼ 8 MeV.
22
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
< Zs / Zt >
1 0.75 0.5 0.25
ZMissing (Zmax 1)
80
Missing charge data Missing charge SMM Zmax SMM
60 40 20
Zmax 2, 3
0 8 6 4 2 0
0
1
2
3
4
5 6 7 E*/A (MeV)
8
9
10
11
Fig. 22. Dependence of source charge and IMF charges as a function of E ∗/A for the 8 GeV/c − +197 Au reaction. Top: fractional source charge. Middle: missing charge in ISiS, assumed to be the largest fragment, and SMM prediction for missing charge (solid line) and for largest fragment (dashed line), both passed through the ISiS filter. Bottom: charge of two largest observed fragments, solid line is the SMM prediction for second largest fragment (Zmax 2 ) and dashed line for third largest fragment (Zmax 3 ).
The middle frame of Fig. 22 shows the average missing charge in our reconstruction procedure, assumed here to be a single fragment. Comparison with the SMM model [46] gives good agreement and these values closely correspond to the largest fragment distribution observed in the EOS 1 GeV 197 Au+12 C reaction (when corrected for differences in thermal excitation energy) [53]. Beyond E ∗/A6 MeV the assumed fragment corresponding to the missing charge (Zmax 1 ) is an IMF (Z20). Finally, in the bottom frame of Fig. 22 the average charges of the second (Zmax 2 ) and third (Zmax 3 ) largest fragments are shown as a function of excitation energy. The sizes of the second and third largest fragments remain nearly constant above E ∗/A ∼ 5–6 MeV, in line with the results of Fig. 21, and are also in relative accord with SMM predictions up to E ∗/A ∼ 7–8 MeV. At higher excitation energies the data and SMM diverge, most likely due to the storage of excess excitation energy in fragments in the model, leading to secondary decay. This divergence suggests that the fragments are emitted relatively cold, as argued in [69]. In summary, the thermal observables from the ISiS data present a picture of a system that decays isotropically from a source with velocity ∼ 0.01c. Above E ∗/A ∼ 5 MeV multifragmentation (MIMF 3) becomes the dominant decay mode and the spectra suggest emission from a dilute/expanded source. Near this energy the largest fragments are formed. Thus, these signals are qualitatively consistent with expected observables from a liquid–gas phase transition and in the following sections we examine this question in greater depth. 4.3. Breakup density and expansion A knowledge of the dependence of nuclear density on thermal excitation is of central importance to our understanding of nuclear compressibility and the equation-of-state of finite nuclear matter. In addition, the breakup density is particularly relevant to models of multifragmentation phenomena, which assume that at sufficiently high temperatures, thermal pressure and Coulomb forces drive nuclear expansion and subsequent disintegration of the system [3,46,54,62,63]. Perhaps the most direct experimental signal of the breakup density is provided by the centroids of the peaks of the IMF kinetic energy spectra as a function of E ∗/A, as mentioned in previous sections and in [10,13,47,48,64,70].
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
23
Fig. 23. Energy spectra at 43◦ and 137◦ for carbon fragments emitted from the 4.8 GeV 3 He+197 Au reaction as a function of excitation energy. Symbols are as follows: E ∗/A = 3.4 MeV (•); 4.6 MeV (); 5.7 MeV ( ); 6.8 MeV (); 7.9 MeV ().
Breakup densities have been derived from the systematic Coulomb shifts of the spectral peaks for a series of IMF data sets that span the excitation-energy range E ∗/A = 0.9–7.9 MeV. Inclusive data were analyzed for the 200-MeV 4 He+197 Au [71] and E/A = 20–100 MeV 14 N+197 Au [70] reactions. Exclusive data were based on the 4.8 GeV 3 He + 197Au reaction [72]. The spectra for each system were measured with low kinetic-energy thresholds and covered nearly the entire 180 degree angular range. The threshold/angle criteria are essential for obtaining stable moving-source fits, which require very good definition of the low-energy component of the spectra. Details of the analysis are discussed in greater detail in [72,73]. Representative IMF kinetic-energy spectra for carbon fragments from the 4.8 GeV 3 He+197 Au system are shown in Fig. 23 as a function of E ∗/A. The decrease in the peak centroids with increasing excitation, opposite of expectations for a thermal source at normal density, is evident. The spectra were analyzed in terms of a two-component (three for 14 N) moving-source model [50] consisting of a thermal-source described by a transition-state formalism [51,52], a nonequilibrium source that assumes a Maxwellian shape, and for 14 N, a projectile-breakup source. The thermal source, of primary interest for this analysis, included the following parameters: the source velocity, a fractional Coulomb term kC , a spectral slope temperature and a barrier fluctuation variable. The decreasing Z of the source with E ∗/A was also taken into account. This formalism is designed primarily for binary breakups. For multifragmentation events, it is assumed that this procedure provides a first-order approximation to the Coulomb field that exists between a given IMF and the average of the residual nucleons. For density determinations the average fractional Coulomb parameter kC for IMFs is the sensitive parameter and is determined relative to fission fragment kinetic energy systematics [72,73]. In the top frame of Fig. 24 values of the Coulomb parameter are plotted versus E ∗/A, where kC = 1 corresponds to nuclei at normal density 0 . Most striking about Fig. 24 is the sharp decrease in kC in the excitation-energy interval E ∗/A ≈ 2–4 MeV, suggesting emission from a source with a modified Coulomb field. It is also of note that this decrease matches the major changes in other reaction variables, as shown in Section 4.2. In order to obtain the breakup density, it is assumed that for these light-ion-induced reactions the thermal source is spherical and expansion is radially symmetric. In this case, from Coulomb’s law the density expression reduces to /0 = kC3 ,
(4.6)
24
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 24. Top: dependence of the average fractional Coulomb parameter kC as a function of excitation energy. Symbols are as follows: 200 MeV 4 He (solid square); 14 N (solid triangle); 4.8 GeV 3 He (open square). Bottom: average density / as a function of E ∗/A derived from the k C 0 values in the top panel.
since kC ∝ rC −3 , where rC is the mean separation distance at breakup. The result is shown in Fig. 24 where /0 is plotted as a function of E ∗/A. Up to E ∗/A ≈ 2 MeV the density appears to correspond to normal density. Between E ∗/A ≈ 2 and 5 MeV, Fig. 24 indicates a systematic decrease in density from /0 ≈ 1.0 to /0 ≈ 0.3. Above E ∗/A4 MeV, a nearly constant value of /0 0.30 is found within experimental error. In summary, this spectral-shape analysis indicates that above E ∗/A2 MeV, nuclear breakup occurs from an increasingly expanded/dilute configuration. Beyond E ∗/A4 MeV, a value of /0 ≈ 0.3 is found, consistent with the predictions of multifragmentation models [46,62]. Finally, the relative constancy of /0 at high excitation energies suggests that a limiting breakup density has been reached [74,75]. The energy that drives expansion and subsequent multifragmentation is usually attributed to either internal thermal pressure [76] or the response to compressional forces produced in the early stages of the target-projectile interaction [77]. As discussed in Section 3, model calculations of the reaction dynamics for the systems studied in this work provide little or no evidence for compression-decompression effects. Instead, the fast cascade creates an initial residue with lower than normal nuclear density and high thermal energy. Thus, in highly asymmetric collisions at GeV energies, only the thermal pressure and Coulomb field are of primary relevance to the subsequent expansion process. Two stages of thermal expansion leading to multifragmentation can be schematically defined. The first drives the nucleus to the breakup configuration, where repulsive Coulomb forces exceed the restoring nuclear force. Although the breakup density beyond this point may remain nearly constant, as in Fig. 24, the increasing heat content of the source may lead to an additional source of radial expansion energy (or flow); i.e., the thermal energy that exceeds the minimum necessary to reach the breakup density, defined here as excess expansion energy, th . The impact of the excess expansion energy on the spectra will be an increased flattening of the high-energy spectral slope, over and beyond that expected for the freezeout density and temperature [78].
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
80
SIMON-evaporation
60
9 ≥ E*/A > 6 6 ≥ E*/A > 4
25
40 9 ≥ E*/A > 6 6 ≥ E*/A > 4
Mean kinetic energy (MeV)
20 0 80
SIMON-explosion
9 ≥ E*/A > 6 6 ≥ E*/A > 4
60 40 20 0 80
SMM
9 ≥ E*/A > 6 6 ≥ E*/A > 4
60 40 20 0
0
2
4
6
8 10 12 Fragment charge
14
16
18
Fig. 25. Comparison between experimental and simulated fragment mean kinetic energies calculated for two bins in excitation energy. In each panel, data are shown with open and solid circles and simulations with dashed and solid lines. The corresponding bins of excitation energy are indicated on the figure. SMM and SIMON-explosion calculations have been performed without additional expansion energy.
In order to investigate the possible contribution of th , it is necessary to choose a reference point that accounts for thermal and Coulomb contributions to the fragment kinetic energies. For this purpose, three statistical models have been employed: SMM [46,79], SIMON-explosion and SIMON-evaporation [56]. In order to minimize any contamination from possible preequilibrium emissions in the data, we compare the calculations with the measured average fragment kinetic energy, for which preequilibrium contributions to the tails of the spectra are negligible. The inputs to all three models were the same, using the source charge, mass, velocity and excitation-energy distributions for the reconstructed data (Section 4.1), and then passed through the ISiS filter. In Fig. 25 the calculations are compared with mean fragment kinetic energies as a function of fragment charge for excitation-energy bins, E ∗/A = 4.6 and 6–9 MeV. The evaporative model underpredicts the data substantially, although it does give reasonable agreement for E ∗/A3 MeV. Both of the simultaneous multifragmentation models describe the mean kinetic energies, as well as the multiplicity and charge distributions, for E ∗/A = 4.6 MeV bin. However, for the E ∗/A = 6.9 MeV bin both models fall below the data. This shortfall is attributed to the existence of excess thermal expansion energy. Using the SMM model as a reference point, the excess expansion energy is extracted from the difference between the model and the data. In Fig. 26 the results are plotted versus E ∗/A. This analysis indicates that the th threshold occurs near E ∗/A 4 MeV and then gradually increases to 0.5 AIMF MeV at E ∗/A = 9 MeV. This amount of energy, while small, must be taken into account when performing the calorimetry (Section 2). In contrast, central heavy-ion reactions show a much more dramatic increase in the excess expansion energy, also shown in Fig. 26, suggesting that the excess expansion energy observed in heavy-ion collisions may be related to the dynamical stage, perhaps due to initial compression.
26
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Channel probability
1 0.8
P (Mimf ≥ 3)
0.6 0.4 P (Mimf = 0,1,2)
0.2 0 MULTICS, MINIBALL, Au+Au (15) MINIBALL, Kr+Au (14) INDRA, Gd + U (5) INDRA, Xe+Sn (6)
Expansion Energy (A MeV)
2
1.5
ISIS
1
0.5
0 0
2 4 6 8 Excitation energy at freeze-out (A MeV)
10
Fig. 26. Upper panel: see Fig. 20. Lower panel: comparison between 8 GeV/c − +197 Au reactions and central heavy-ion collisions [78]. The shaded area corresponds to the ISiS excess expansion energies extracted with SMM at 3V0 (upper limit) and 2V0 (lower limit). The dashed line summarizes the excess expansion energies extracted in central heavy-ion collisions with various assumptions regarding the source characteristics.
To summarize, moving-source analyses of the IMF spectra show a systematic downward shift in the Coulomb peaks, supporting a picture in which the breakup density decreases as a function of excitation energy, even after correcting for nonequilibrium charge loss. While the density remains nearly constant above E ∗/A = 5 MeV, the flattening of the spectral slopes suggests a small, but measurable excess breakup energy that increases nearly linearly as th /AIMF = (0.1 E ∗/A) − 0.4 MeV. 4.4. Breakup time scale Central to any interpretation of multifragmentation events in terms of a liquid–gas phase transition is the question of time scale. For evaporative cluster emission from the liquid phase at low excitation energies, fragments are produced from the surface via a binary sequential decay mechanism. This process requires relatively long emission times of order 1000 fm/c at low excitation energies [80]. In contrast, when the spinodal boundary of the phase diagram is crossed, the system falls apart on a near-simultaneous time scale via bulk emission from the entire nuclear volume. Information about the emission time scale can be extracted by means of the intensity-interferometry technique, which probes the mutual Coulomb repulsion between fragment pairs emitted in proximity to one another in space and time [81–84]. This technique constructs the correlation function R for fragment pairs of reduced velocity vred , R(vred ) + 1 = C
Ncorr (vred ) . Nuncorr (vred )
(4.7)
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
27
Fig. 27. Reduced-velocity correlation functions generated for four different excitation energy per nucleon bins for 8.0–11.2 GeV/c hadron +197 Au reactions. IMF kinetic energy acceptance in the source frame is EIMF /A = 1.10 MeV.
Fig. 28. Correlation function for Z = 4.9 IMFs as a function of reduced velocity (open circles) for 8.0–11.2 GeV/c hadron +197 Au reactions. IMF kinetic energy acceptance in the source frame is EIMF /A = 2.10 MeV. Data are gated on source E ∗/A = 2.0.2.5 MeV (top), 4.5–5.5 MeV (center) and 8.5–8.5 MeV (bottom). Solid and dashed lines are results of a Coulomb trajectory calculation for fit parameters indicated on the figure.
Ncorr is the measured coincidence yield, while Nuncorr is the uncorrelated yield calculated with the event-mixing technique [83], and the normalization C is performed relative to the integral yields of each [85]. The reduced velocity is given by |v1 − v2 | vred = √ , Z1 + Z 2
(4.8)
28
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 29. Reduced-velocity correlations as a function of reduced velocity for the 4.8 GeV 3 He + 197 Au reaction (points) [89]. Data were selected for pairs of events in which Nth 11 and kinetic energy (E/A)IMF = 0.7.3.0 MeV and are shown for Z = 3, 4 fragments (upper frame) and Z = 5.9 fragments (lower frame). Lines are results of an N-body simulation with /0 =0.25 and maximum residue size, Zres =12. Time scales are indicated in the figure.
where vi and Zi are the laboratory velocity and charge of the fragments, respectively. The denominator permits comparison of different IMF Z values. Experimental IMF–IMF (4 Z 9) correlation functions from hadron-induced reactions on 197Au between 8.0 and 11.2 GeV/c are shown in Fig. 27 for several excitation-energy bins. Pairs emitted in close proximity to one another in space and time (low vred ) experience a supression in yield due to their mutual Coulomb interaction (Coulomb hole). Between E ∗/A = 2.25 and 5.0 MeV the Coulomb hole increases, followed by a nearly constant supression at higher excitation energies. This effect is in qualitative agreement with heavy-ion studies [86,87]. In order to extract the emission time scale, an N -body Coulomb trajectory calculation [84,88] has been performed, using the experimental source and final product properties as input [85]. The only adjustable parameters in the simulation are the source volume, or separation distance between the residue and the fragments. The filtered output of the simulation must reproduce both the small- and large-angle correlation data, as well as the fragment charge distribution and kinetic energy spectra. These conditions impose a significant constraint on space-time ambiguities in the simulation. For purposes of calculating the Coulomb energy, the separation distance is defined as 1/3
R12 = r0 (A1/3 res + AIMF ) + d, where r0 = 1.22 fm. Values of d between 2–6 fm provide the best fits to the data and are consistent with the density results described in the previous section. The emission time t is assigned via an exponential probability distribution, et/t0 , where t0 is the decay lifetime.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
29
Fig. 30. Upper frame: IMF probability as a function of E ∗/A. Bottom frame: emission time as a function of E ∗/A. Open points are ISiS data under two extremes of fitting procedure. Solid points are heavy-ion data from [90]. Parameters for exponential fits to the data are given on the figure.
In Fig. 28 the experimental correlation functions are compared with simulations for a range of d and time values that yield minimum chi-squared values. Between E ∗/A = 2.0.2.5 and 4.5–5.5 MeV the emission time decreases by an order of magnitude, from ∼ 500 fm/c to 20.50 fm/c. Above E ∗/A ∼ 5 MeV the emission time becomes very short and nearly independent of excitation energy, consistent with a near-instantaneous breakup scenario. Similar results have been shown for the 4.8 GeV 3 He + 197 Au reaction, as shown in Fig. 29 [89]. Here the experimental gating is performed for all fragments from events with E ∗/A 5 MeV. Again the results are consistent with breakup times between 20.50 fm/c for that fraction of the yield that falls in the multifragmentation regime. The lower panel of Fig. 30 presents the best-fit decay times for events in which two or more IMFs are emitted in hadron-induced thermal multifragmentation of 197Au nuclei. For reference the individual IMF multiplicities are shown in the upper panel. The decay lifetimes at low excitation energy are consistent with an evaporative mechanism, while at higher energies the very short lifetimes support a near-simultaneous breakup. The shaded band in Fig. 30 covers the range of space-time values that provide a consistent fit to all of the observables. Also shown in Fig. 30 are results for heavy-ion reactions [90], which yield similar results, but somewhat longer lifetimes at low energies. In summary, the time scales derived from the intensity-interferometry analysis demonstrates the evolution from the evaporative to near-simultaneous breakup regime. As with the multiplicity, spectra and density evolution discussed in Sections 4.1–4.3, the time scale determinations provide a strong case for an interpretation in terms of a transition from surface to bulk emission in the excitation energy interval between E ∗/A ∼ 3.5 MeV.
30
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
5. Thermodynamics 5.1. The caloric curve: isotope-ratio temperatures One of the most stimulating early results of multifragmentation studies was the excitation energy versus temperature curve, or caloric curve, proposed by the ALADiN group [91]. By plotting temperatures derived from double-isotope ratios [92] as a function of excitation energy, a result was obtained that resembles the heating of liquid water to the vaporization phase. Subsequent experiments, including those described in this section, produced similar results [75]. From the systematic behavior of these data, Natowitz has derived a value of the critical temperature of 16 ± 1 MeV for infinite nuclear matter and a nuclear compressibility constant K = 232 ± 30 MeV [93]. In order to construct the heating curve for the ISiS data, the heat content was based on the calorimetry described in Section 4.1. The double-isotope-ratio technique for defining temperature is limited for the ISiS data due to the high thresholds for isotope identification. The isotope-ratio temperatures T were calculated according to the prescription of Albergo [92], with correction factors proposed by Tsang [94], ln(aR) − ln . (5.1) B Here B is a binding-energy parameter, a is a statistical factor dependent on ground-state spins, and R is the doubleisotope ratio. For ISiS, useful isotope identification is restricted to LCPs so that the relevant ratios are 1/T =
Rpd -He = (p/d)/(3 He/4 He)
(5.2)
Rdt -He = (d/t)/(3 He/4 He),
(5.3)
and
where all ratios involve only thermal LCPs. The definition of thermal LCPs, as discussed in Section 4.1, can lead to variability in the value of T that is obtained. For p/d and d/t ratios, there is only a small sensitivity to particle kinetic energy [49,72], so the distinction between thermal and preequilibrium particles is of minor significance due to the logarithmic nature of Eq. (5.1). In contrast, as shown in Fig. 31, the 3 He/4 He ratio increases strongly with kinetic energy [40,49,72]. Thus the controlling factor in determining T is the 3 He/4 He ratio, which is dependent on the thermal cutoffs assumed in the calorimetry. In Figs. 32 and 33 the temperature versus E ∗/A curves are shown for the 4.8 GeV3 He + 197 Au system [40] and the 8.0 GeV/c − + 197 Au system [49], respectively. For the 3 He-induced reaction, which uses only the dt-He ratio, there is no plateau, but a slope change is observed above E ∗/A ≈ 2 MeV. While the temperature increases from about T = 5.7 MeV in the E ∗/A ≈ 2.10 MeV range, it deviates markedly from a simple Fermi gas prediction (dotted curves in Fig. 32). Also shown in Fig. 32 are comparisons with INC/EES (expanding, emitting source) [62,95] and INC/SMM [46,95] models. SMM comparisons assume the fragments are emitted cold; comparisons with model parameters that produce hot fragments deviate strongly from the data [49]. For both model comparisons the solid lines are predictions with the experimental cuts defined in Section 4.1 imposed on the model spectra. The results provide fair agreement with the data. With the experimental cuts removed (dashed curves), the caloric curves are lowered by ∼ 1.1.5 MeV per nucleon, yielding better agreement with other caloric curves. The difference between the results with and without the experimental cuts on the model is traced to the fact that the thresholds for isotope identification in ISiS fall above the spectral peaks, where the 3 He/4 He ratio is much lower [96,61] (i.e., R is larger and T is smaller). Also shown in the right frame of Fig. 32 is the thermodynamic temperature predicted by the SMM model. In Fig. 33, the caloric curves for the − + 197 Au reaction are compared for the pd-He and dt-He thermometers. The top frame shows the results without the Tsang [94] corrections. With the correction applied, both thermometers demonstrate a break in the curve above E ∗/A ≈ 3.4 MeV, with the pd-He ratio yielding a more distinct plateau. At the highest excitation energies for the dt-He case there is an indication of an upturn in the caloric curve above E ∗/A ≈ 10 MeV, suggestive of possible entrance into the vaporization regime. Similar results have been observed in other experiments and are also seen in the 4.8 GeV 3 He data, although the effect occurs at excitations where statistics are low and fluctuations large. However, this behavior is absent with the pd-He thermometer. Thus, while the high E ∗/A dt-He results are intriguing, they are not convincing.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
31
Fig. 31. He isotope ratios [40] as a function of He energy observed at 43◦ and 137◦ for the 4.8 GeV 3 He reaction on Ag (left panel) and Au (right panel). Lines are INC/EES model predictions [62,95] for 137◦ (solid) and 43◦ (dashed). Error bars are statistical only.
Fig. 32. (d/t)/(3 He/4 He) isotope-ratio temperature vs. reconstructed E ∗/A for the 4.8 GeV 3 He + 197 Au reaction. Left frame compares data with the INC/EES model [62,95] and right frame compares with the INC/SMM model [46,95]. Solid curves are model predictions with experimental cuts imposed on H and He kinetic energy spectra. Dashed curves show the effect of removing the experimental cuts. Dotted curves show Fermi gas behavior with a = 11 MeV−1 . For the SMM case the dot–dashed curve gives the thermodynamic temperature of the source.
32
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 33. Caloric curve for the 8 GeV/c − + 197 Au reaction from (p/d)/(3 He/4 He) and (d/t)/(3 He/4 He) thermometers using measured yields to calculate temperature (top panel) and temperatures corrected for secondary decay (bottom panel).
The differences in temperature between the slope/plateau regions for the 4.8 GeV 3 He and 8.0 GeV/c − reactions can be traced to two factors. First, the kinetic-energy thresholds were lower in the former case and second, the energy acceptance bins were not quite the same. The net effect is that the 3 He/4 He ratio is lower for the 4.8 GeV 3 He measurements; i.e., R is larger and T lower. The temperature dependences on 3 He/4 He ratio can be used to track the evolution of the de-excitation process leading up to thermalization, under the assumption that the most energetic emissions are emitted earliest [97–99]. Such a “cooling curve” is shown in Fig. 34 for the 8.0 GeV/c − + 197 Au reaction, where Coulomb-corrected 10-MeVwide bins have been placed on LCP spectra [49]. Note that the higher energy bins correspond to the hard exponential tails of the spectra in Fig. 12. The corresponding T vs. E ∗/A calculation reveals a systematic decrease in the isotoperatio temperatures as the kinetic energy bin for the LCPs decreases. The observed sequence of caloric curves can be interpreted as evidence for the preequilibrium cooling stage between the initial cascade and thermalization stages. An alternative explanation is provided by time-dependent EES model, for which particles are emitted sequentially from an expanding, cooling source [62].
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
33
Fig. 34. The caloric curves for the 8 GeV/c − + 197 Au reaction from the (d/t)/(3 He/4 He) thermometer, corrected for secondary decay, using four different kinetic energy acceptances as given in the graph. The shaded area represents the caloric curve region extrapolated to the evaporative region of the H and He spectral peaks.
Due to the systematic trends of Fig. 34 and the lack of mass-resolved data in ISiS in the Coulomb-peak kinetic energy region below E/A = 8 MeV, the isotope-ratio temperatures would be lower if extrapolated to the thermal LCP peak yields. To examine this correction, a linear fit was performed on the cooling curves of Fig. 34 and then extrapolated to the Coulomb peak region for element-identified LCPs, shown in Fig. 12. The shaded area in Fig. 34 shows this extrapolation. Fig. 35 compares the caloric curves from similar systems with the ISiS data. The left-hand frame shows the difference between the observed and corrected ISiS results and emphasizes the sensitivity of the isotope-ratio thermometer to the energy acceptance for the LCPs. The center- and right-hand frames compare the ISiS results with the ALADiN peripheral Au + Au [91] and EOS Au + 12 C results [18,53], respectively. Reasonable consistency is observed with the corrected ISiS caloric curve and the systematics of Natowitz [75]. 5.2. The caloric curve: density-dependent Fermi-gas temperatures The density determinations described in Section 4.3 suggest an alternative approach to measuring the nuclear temperature. Inherent in the Fermi gas model is the first-order relationship E ∗/A =
2/3 ∗ m (0 ) T2 , K() 0 m∗ ()
(5.4)
34
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 35. Left: summary of caloric curves from the ISiS data in Figs. 32–34, compared with ALADiN data [91] (center) and EOS data [18,53] right.
where K() is the density-dependent inverse level density parameter (1/a) and m∗ is the effective mass. This predicted dependence of temperature on density provides a method for determining nuclear temperatures, independent of isotope ratios. If one assumes that the effective mass ratio is near unity at these high excitation energies, then K() becomes K() = K0 (/0 )2/3 = T 2 /(E ∗/A).
(5.5)
From fits to data below E ∗/A 2.0 MeV, an empirical inverse level density parameter of K0 = 11.3 MeV for a densityindependent Fermi gas is obtained, shown as a dashed curve in Fig. 36. Using this value, Eq. (5.5) becomes T (MeV) = [11.3(/0 )2/3 (E ∗/A)]1/2 .
(5.6)
When the average densities derived from the IMF spectra [Section 4.3 and Fig. 24] are inserted into Eq. (5.6), the resultant temperatures produce the caloric curve shown in Fig. 36. Up to E ∗/A ≈ 2 MeV the temperature rises according to Fermi gas predictions for nuclei at normal density. In the region E ∗/A = 2.5 MeV a distinct slope change occurs, corresponding to the decrease in breakup density of the emitting source. Above E ∗/A ≈ 5 MeV, √ Eq. (5.6) with a constant value of /0 ≈ 0.30 predicts a simple gradual increase in temperatures given by T = 2.2 E ∗/A. Overall, the density-dependent Fermi gas model yields a caloric curve that is strikingly similar to caloric curve measurements for other reactions [91,53], as well as the corrected caloric curves from ISiS, shown in Fig. 34. This result is consistent with statistical model calculations that assume /0 ≈ 1/3 at breakup [3,46,63] and in qualitative agreement with the metastable mononucleus model of Sobotka [100]. A second-order analysis [73] of the density data, in which expansion energy is taken into account, shows a 1–2 MeV dip in the plateau near E ∗/A ≈ 5 MeV, but is otherwise similar. Overall, the temperatures derived from the density-dependent Fermi gas model and those from double isotope ratios [93] are in agreement, lending additional support to the concept of caloric curve behavior for hot nuclei. 5.3. Heat capacity In heavy-ion studies evidence for a negative excursion in the heat-capacity versus excitation-energy curve has been presented by the MULTICS-MINIBALL Collaboration [101]. Based on thermodynamic considerations, this result
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
35
Fig. 36. First-order density-dependent Fermi-gas temperatures as a function of excitation energy. The dashed line is the normal-density Fermi-gas √ prediction, with T = 11.3(E ∗/A) MeV. Symbols are the same as in Fig. 24.
Fig. 37. Panel shows Cv and 2 calculated from data. The minimum of 2 and the maximum of Cv coincide within experimental uncertainty.
provides possible evidence for a first-order phase transition [102]. The ISiS data have been examined for such an effect [103] and the results are shown in Fig. 37. A sharp negative deviation in the heat capacity Cv is observed near E ∗/A ≈ 4.5 MeV, consistent with the heavy-ion results [101]. Within experimental uncertainties the minimum in the -squared distribution coincides with the maximum in the Cv curve. The first-order phase transition argument is reflected in the observations in earlier sections that show near E ∗/A ≈ 4.5 MeV there is a sharp increase in the IMF multiplicity, a rapidly decreasing emission time and density, the onset of excess expansion energy, and a distinct slope change in the caloric curve. The order of the phase transition is discussed further in the following section.
36
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
In summary, both the corrected isotope-ratio and density-dependent Fermi-gas temperature versus excitation energy plots show quasi-caloric curve behavior with a transition in the region E ∗/A ≈ 3.5 MeV. Rather than a plateau, the resultant caloric curves show a gradual increase in temperature with added heat, but are well below normal Fermigas expectations. By gating on LCP kinetic energies, it is also possible to construct a “cooling curve” that describes the evolution of the reaction mechanism from the cascade step to thermalization. In addition, a signal for a negative excursion in the heat capacity curve supports heavy-ion data [101] that are interpreted in terms of a first-order phase transition [102]. 6. The liquid–gas phase transition: scaling-law behavior Given the overall agreement of the ISiS data with the qualitative expectations for a liquid–gas phase transition, several further questions of a more quantitative nature arise. For example, do the cluster size distributions behave according to statistical expectations? How well do the data conform to scaling laws for a phase transition? If so, what are the critical parameters and what is the order of the phase transition? Statistical behavior is an important question, not a priori obvious for systems that evolve as rapidly as those formed in GeV hadron-induced reactions. At lower energies, where statistical concepts are more appropriate, cluster emission probability distributions can be well-described in terms of a binomial distribution [104], Pmn (E ∗ ) =
m! P n (1 − p)m−n . n!(m − n)!
(6.1)
Here, n is the IMF multiplicity, m is the number of chances to emit an IMF, and p is the binary elementary probability. The values of p and m can be extracted from the experimental average multiplicity N and its variance, N = mp
and
2n = N (1 − p).
(6.2)
At lower energies it has been found that p is a function of excitation energy, giving rise to the concept of thermal scaling [104]. In order to test whether the ISiS results follow this same statistical pattern, the 8.0 GeV/c − + 197 Au data have been fit with Eqs. (6.1) and (6.2) [38]. The binomial distribution analysis gives very good agreement with the data up to NIMF = 5, as shown in the multiplicity distributions in Fig. 38. Some deviations appear for NIMF 6, where statistics become increasingly poor. To investigate the possible dependence of the binomial parameters on collision violence, the reciprocal of the probability factor p was plotted versus the total transverse energy, thermal transverse energy and E ∗/A. The total transverse energy Et diverges strongly at high energies, reflecting the contribution of preequilibrium processes to the yield. Removal of the preequilibrium component yields an improved scaling fit to the data for the thermal transverse energy. The strongest correlation is found when scaled as a function of E ∗/A, where a nearly linear dependence is observed, supporting an interpretation in terms of thermal scaling [38]. The evolution of the parameter m with excitation energy is shown in Table 3, where correlations with the size of the source Zsrc , total observed charge Zobs and the removal energy (−Q) are shown. The one variable that tracks most closely with m is the removal energy, suggesting that m represents an energy constraint that allows only certain partitions. The agreement with the thermal scaling concept indicates that p can be expressed by a partial decay width p=
= e−B/T , 2 0
(6.3)
where 0 is interpreted as the frequency of assault on the barrier B at temperatures T [38,104]. Defining the intrinsic emission time as t0 = 1/ 0 , the emission time is given by t = t0 eB/T
or
p = t0 /t.
(6.4)
Using the emission times derived in Section 4.4, a plot as a function of the thermal scaling variable (E ∗/A)1/2 shows nearly linear behavior, as seen in the top frame of Fig. 39. The bottom frame of Fig. 39 shows the relation between the lifetime t and 1/p. A linear relationship is observed down to emission times of 20 fm/c near E ∗/A ≈ 6 MeV. The evolution of the inverse probability 1/p at higher energies appears to be independent of time, indicating a mechanism change that favors a space-like (bulk) emission scenario, rather than one that is sequential, as is the case at lower excitations.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
37
Fig. 38. The experimental (symbols) and calculated (lines) n-fold IMF probability distributions as a function of E ∗/A for the 8.0 GeV − +197 Au reaction. The lines assume a binomial probability distribution according to Eq. (6.1) and p and m were extracted from Eq. (6.2).
Table 3 Values of the binomial parameter m, the primary source size Zsrc , the observed charge Zobs , and the Qvalue for various E ∗/A bins E ∗/A (MeV) m Zsrc Zobs Qvalue (MeV)
2.0 3.36 74.3 8.75 −160
3.0 4.82 71.2 15.2 −204
4.0 5.61 68.4 21.9 −249
5.0 6.29 65.8 28.1 −295
6.0 6.72 63.5 33.5 −341
7.0 7.67 61.1 38.1 −383
8.0 8.31 59.0 42.2 −420
9.0 7.79 57.1 45.4 −451
The apparent statistical nature of the thermal component of the data justifies further investigation of expected liquid–gas phase transition properties. One method for extracting information relevant to this issue is through a moment analysis of the fragment charge distributions [1,105]. Calculations with both percolation and statistical multifragmentation models predict that the relative variance 2 of the charge distributions will exhibit maxima of 2 ≈ 2.1.2.3 near the critical point. Brzychczyk [66] analyzed the relative moments of the 4.8 GeV 3 He + 197 Au reaction and found a variance of 2 = 2.3 ± 0.1 near E ∗/A ≈ 5.5 MeV. Thus, the ISiS data are in good agreement with phase transition models and provide further consistency with arguments for a liquid–gas phase transition and possible critical behavior in hot nuclei. Berkenbusch et al. [106] carried out a global percolation analysis on the 10.2 GeV/c p + 197 Au data from ISiS. The bond-breaking probability for the model is determined from the excitation energy via the relation [107] 2 ∗ Eb (E ) = 1 − (6.5) (3/2, 0, B/T (E ∗ )), where is the generalized incomplete gamma function, B is the binding energy per nucleon of the source and T is √ the source temperature, determined from the excitation energy T = E ∗/A and a = A/13 MeV−1 . Input to the model utilized experimental values for the excitation energy and source size, with the lattice size fixed by the size of the thermal residue. An important feature of the calculation is that account is taken of the secondary decay of the excited primary fragments, which is particularly important for the fragile Z = 3.5 fragments that comprise most of the IMF cross section.
38
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 39. Top panel: IMF emission time t as a function of (E ∗/A)−1/2 , from Fig. 30. The line corresponds to a fit using Eq. (6.4). Bottom panel: plot of 1/p vs. time. The solid line is a linear fit to the data. The dotted line indicates the “apparent” saturation in emission time.
Fig. 40 compares the charge distributions from the data with both filtered and unfiltered percolation values. The discontinuity just above Z = 16 is a consequence of the discrete charge-identification limit in ISiS and the assumption that all unmeasured charge resides in a single fragment. Overall, the filtered percolation yields are in excellent agreement with the data. For values of the control parameter p near the critical value, pc , the cluster number ns is predicted to scale as ns (p) = s − f [(p − pc )S ]
(for p ≈ pc ),
(6.6)
where s is the size of the cluster (Z) and and are the two critical exponents of percolation theory. The scaling function f has the property that f (0) = 1; i.e., the power-law dependence is valid only near p = pc . By associating the bond-breaking probability with the temperature and assuming an exponential function for f, the fractional IMF yield nz becomes (T − Tc )Z − nz = q0 Z exp , (6.7) T where q0 is a normalization parameter and Tc is the critical temperature. Thus, one expects a plot of nz /q0 Z − to scale exponentially with (T − Tc )Z /T for all fragment sizes. The result of a 2 optimization procedure for the theoretical percolation charge distributions for this system yields values of the critical parameters = 0.5 ± 0.1 and = 2.18 ± 0.01, in good agreement with percolation analysis for an
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
39
Fig. 40. Inclusive charge yield spectra for the reaction p + 197 Au Au at 10.2 GeV. The round symbols represent the ISiS data. The dotted histogram is the result of the corresponding percolation model calculation. The thick histogram represents the output of the calculations, filtered through the detector acceptance.
Fig. 41. Scaled fragment yields as a function of the scaled control parameter for Z = 3, 4, 5 and 6. The left-hand side shows the results of inclusion of secondary decay corrections and the right-hand side shows the fit when omitting these corrections.
infinite lattice, = 0.45 and = 2.18. A similar analysis of the ZIMF = 3.6 data from ISiS produces the results shown in Fig. 41. The right frame shows the inability to achieve scaling when sequential-decay corrections are omitted from the analysis. When corrected for sequential decay, as shown in the left frame of Fig. 41, much better scaling behavior is found. The critical exponents for this finite system, derived from the data, are = 0.5 ± 0.1, = 2.35 ± 0.05 and (E ∗/A)c = 5.3 MeV (or Tc = 8.3 MeV for a simple Fermi gas with a = A/13 MeV−1 ). Since the infinite size limit of the model contains a continuous phase transition for the range of excitation energies covered by the present data set, the scaling agreement between the data and percolation theory can be interpreted as evidence for a continuous phase transition in nuclear matter. The Fisher Droplet Model [108] provides another avenue for examining the correspondence between IMF emission and a liquid–gas phase transition. Fisher’s model describes the aggregation of molecules in a vapor into clusters. The abundance of a given cluster size A can be written as nA = q0 A− exp[(A − CoA )/T ],
(6.8)
where in addition to the critical exponents and of Eq. (6.7), nA = NA /A0 , the number of droplets of mass A normalized to the system size A0 ; the difference between the actual and liquid chemical potentials is = − ; C0 is the zero temperature surface energy coefficient, and = (Tc − T )/Tc . This equation reduces to Eq. (6.7) if = 0.
40
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 42. The scaled yield distribution versus the scaled temperature for the ISiS data (upper) and d = 3 Ising model calculation (lower). For the Ising model, the quantity nZ /q0 A− /10 is plotted against the quantity A /1.435T . Data for T > Tc are scaled only as nA /q0 A− .
One approach taken by Elliott et al. [109] is to modify Eq. (6.8) to take into account the Coulomb energy release when a particle moves from the liquid to the vapor phase, which assumes nA = q0 A− exp[(A + ECoul − C0 A )/T ],
(6.9)
where ECoul is defined as follows: ECoul =
1.44(Zsrc − ZIMF )ZIMF 1/3
r0 [(Asrc − AIMF )1/3 + AIMF ]
× (1 − e− )fm-MeV.
(6.10)
Here r0 = 1.22 fm and the exponent insures that the Coulomb energy disappears at the critical point. Since IMF masses are not measured in ISiS, it was assumed that A/Z = 2. Temperatures were determined by the Fermi gas approximation of Raduta [110]. IMF acceptance was for IMFs with 5 Z 15, for which preequilibrium effects are small [109]. Subsequent modifications of the Fisher model can be found in [111,112]. The results of scaling the data according to Eq. (6.9) are shown in Fig. 42, where the fragment mass yield is scaled by the power-law prefactor, the chemical potential term and the Coulomb energy versus the temperature and the surface energy parameter A /T . The scaled data follow Fisher scaling over six orders of magnitude, which suggests that this line represents the liquid–vapor coexistence line. As supporting evidence, also shown in Fig. 42 is the scaled cluster distribution from a d = 3 Ising model calculation [113] for a system that undergoes a phase transition. The values of the critical parameters from the -squared minimization routine are summarized in Table 4 for both the percolation and Fisher scaling analyses. Within errors, the Fisher model values of =2.28±0.14 and =0.54±0.01 are in good agreement with those from percolation as well as with earlier work [114,115]. The surface-energy coefficient C0 =18.3±0.5 MeV is in general accord with the liquid drop value of 16.8 MeV. An important result relevant to previous
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
41
Table 4 Comparison of percolation and Fisher scaling results Parameter
Percolation
Fisher
2.35 ± 0.05 0.5 ± 0.1 8.3 ± 0.2 MeV 5.3 ± 0.3 MeV – – –
2.18 ± 0.14 0.54 ± 0.01 6.7 ± 0.2 MeV 3.8 ± 0.3 MeV 18.3 ± 0.5 MeV 0.06 ± 0.03 MeV/A 1.00 ± 0.06
Tcrit (E ∗/A)crit C0
scaling analyses is that for the first time it has been possible to measure . The measured value of = 0.06 ± 0.03 substantiates the assumption that 0 in previous analyses. Similarly, the value of = 1.0 ± 0.06 insures that the Coulomb energy is small and does not affect the scaling significantly. Based on this analysis, the phase transition is first order up to the critical point of excitation energy Ec∗ /A = 3.8 ± 0.3 MeV, above which it becomes continuous. Analysis of the EOS data [18] yielded a value of Ec∗ /A = 4.75 MeV. However, as discussed in Section 3, when the excitation energies are calculated with the same assumptions for elimination of preequilibrium particles, the ISiS and EOS critical energies are the same. The critical temperature for finite nuclei derived from the Fisher scaling analysis is Tc = 6.7 ± 0.2 MeV. Based on the Fisher scaling parameters derived from the data, it is then possible to construct the two-phase (liquid–gas) coexistence line over a large energy/temperature interval, extending up to the critical point, from which the full phase diagram of nuclear matter can be defined [108]. In summary, the ISiS data are well-described by binomial reducibility and thermal scaling analyses, providing a strong argument for the statistical nature of multifragmentation. Further, scaling with the Fisher model can be used to define the liquid–gas coexistence line, while a percolation analysis supports a continuous phase transition at higher excitation energies. 7. Summary and conclusions Both the reaction dynamics and the subsequent decay of hot residues formed in GeV light-ion-induced reactions on heavy nuclei have been investigated with the ISiS detector array. Of primary concern in this effort has been the isolation and characterization of multifragmentation events, believed to be the possible signature of a nuclear liquid–gas phase transition in finite nuclei. Bombardments with proton, antiproton, pion and 3 He beams produce an exponentially-decreasing distribution of excitation energies that extend up to ∼ 2 GeV in reactions on 197Au nuclei. The deposition of excitation energy is found to increase as a function of beam energy up to a momentum of about 8 GeV/c for reactions of hadrons with 197Au and an energy of ∼ 4 GeV for the 3 He + nat Ag system. For higher beam energies there is little additional increase in deposition energy, presumably due to a tradeoff between beam energy and target transparency. Relative to other hadron beams, the optimum projectile for achieving high excitation energies is found for 8 GeV/c antiprotons, for which the reabsorbtion of some fraction of the decay pions can produce enhanced excitation of the residue. For the same beam momentum, proton and pion beams are nearly identical in their excitation-energy distributions. The fast LCP component of the spectra has been analyzed with a BUU model that incorporates A = 2 and 3 nuclei in the scattering matrix. Best fits to the data are obtained with a version that includes modified in-medium scattering cross sections and a momentum-dependent potential. As shown in Figs. 4 and 5, the BUU calculations indicate that for central collisions the hot residues are formed in a state of depleted density—due to fast knockout followed by preequilibrium processes that occur on a time scale much faster that the relaxation time. Simulation of the time evolution of the collision dynamics predicts that the entropy per nucleon becomes nearly constant after about 30 fm/c, suggesting a randomized, but not necessarily thermalized system. From comparison of the BUU code with the fast LCP spectra, it is inferred that a total time of about 60 fm/c is required to reach a state of quasi-thermalization. The most fundamental signature of a liquid–gas phase transition is the observation of events in which an equilibrated hot nucleus disintegrates into multiple LCPs and IMFs. For this purpose, thermal events have been selected that
42
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
Fig. 43. From top to bottom: the probability distribution for individual IMF multiplicities, the power-law exponent that describes the IMF charge distributions, the breakup density, excess expansion energy and time scale as a function of excitation energy for the reaction of 8.0 GeV/c pions with gold nuclei.
are shown to decay isotropically in the center-of-mass system with Maxwellian kinetic energy spectra from which nonequilibrium components have been removed. The cross section for these events is of order 100 mb. Fig. 43 summarizes several important features of the data that demonstrate a distinct change in reaction mechanism at an excitation energy of E ∗/A 4.5 MeV—all of which support a phase-transition interpretation. In the E ∗/A 4.5 MeV interval the emission of two or more IMFs (accompanied by multiple thermal LCPs) becomes the dominant disintegration mode. From a power-law fit to the charge distributions, it is found that the fraction of large clusters in an average event is a maximum just above the transition excitation energy, as predicted by theory. Evidence for the conversion of extra thermal energy into enhanced IMF kinetic energy appears near E ∗/A ∼ 5 MeV, although the effect is small relative to heavy-ion studies, where compressional heating may contribute. Two unique results derived from ISiS are the evolution of the breakup density and the disintegration time scale as a function of excitation energy. The breakup density derived from analyses of the IMF kinetic-energy spectra, provides evidence for emission from an expanded/dilute source. The derived breakup densities evolve from normal density at low E ∗/A to a nearly constant value of /0 ∼ 0.3 near E ∗/A = 5 MeV and above, again consistent with the theoretical predictions based on phase transition assumptions. The time scale for events with MIMF > 2 evolves from values characteristic of sequential statistical decay at low excitation energy to times of the order of 20.50 fm/c for events at E ∗/A ∼ 4 MeV and above, indicative of a near-simultaneous decomposition mechanism. Similar to previous reports, the data also show evidence for a slope change in the dependence of temperature on heat content, suggestive of caloric curve behavior, although a distinct plateau is not observed. Using a density-dependent Fermi-gas model to derive temperatures, instead of the conventional isotope-ratio thermometer, a caloric curve is obtained that is in good agreement with other results [75]. By gating on bins of the preequilibrium spectra, it has also been possible to derive a cooling curve for these hot systems.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
43
Fig. 44. The reduced density-temperature phase diagram: the thick line is the calculated low density branch of the coexistence curve, the points are selected calculated errors, and the lines above the critical point are a fit to the reflection of Guggenheim’s equation.
Finally, scaling-law fits to the IMF yield distributions provide important confirmation of the statistical nature of the thermal events observed in these studies. A Fisher model analysis reveals excellent scaling behavior up to E ∗/A ∼ 4 MeV, where sequential evaporative emission dominates. This result has been used to define the two-phase coexistence line for nuclear matter and serves as the basis for derivation of the nuclear phase diagram shown in Fig. 44. A percolation model analysis that includes IMF secondary decay corrections also describes the data well and indicates that at higher excitation energies, the data are described by a continuous phase transition. In summary, all of the experimental evidence obtained in these studies is consistent with the concept of a nuclear liquid–gas phase transition. However, the caveat must be added that given the finite system size and very short time scales involved, the classical picture of a phase transition must be invoked with caution. It is perhaps better to say that if a nuclear phase transition exists in nuclei of a few hundred particles, this is what it looks like.
Acknowledgments Over the 15 year lifetime of the ISiS project numerous individuals have provided invaluable support. We wish to express our sincere gratitude to the following for their help: ISiS design and construction: Andy Alexander, Kenny Bastin, John Dorsett, Jack Ottarson, John Poehlman, Larry Sexton and Lai Wan Woo; theoretical support: Alexandre Botvina, Wolfgang Bauer, Pawel Danielewicz, C.B. Das, Jim Elliott, Bill Friedman, Subal das Gupta, M. Kleine Berkenbusch, L.G. Moretto, and Viktor Toneev; and undergraduates: Chris Powell and Greg Porter. We also thank the following for their advice and counsel: Joe Natowitz, Brian Serot and Wolfgang Trautmann. We thank John Vanderwerp, Kevin Komisarcik, Sylvie Hudan, Steve Gushue, Lou Remsberg and Birger Back for their help in various aspects of this project. Diana McGovern played an indispensible role in coordinating many aspects of the ISiS program and in manuscript preparation. We also express our appreciation to the accelerator staffs at the Indiana University Cyclotron Facility, LNS Saclay and Brookhaven AGS. We are indebted to the U.S. Department of Energy, which provided primary support for this project under grant DE.FG02-88ER 40404 and its University Research Instrumentation Program. Indiana University contributed major construction funds and additional support was provided by the National Science Foundation, the National Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada, the Robert A. Welch Foundation, CEA Saclay and the Polish State Committee for Scientific Research.
44
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
J.E. Finn, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 49 (1982) 1321. G.F. Bertsch, P.J. Siemens, Phys. Lett. 126B (1983) 9. J.P. Bondorf, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 443 (1985) 221. G. Friedlander, et al., Phys. Rev. 94 (1954) 727. R. Wolfgang, et al., Phys. Rev. 103 (1956) 394. N.A. Perfilov, O.V. Lozhkin, V.P. Shamov, Sov. Phys. Usp. 3 (1960) 1. V.P. Crespo, et al., Phys. Rev. 131 (1963) 1765. G. Hudis, in: L. Yaffe (Ed.), Nuclear Chemistry, Academic Press, New York, 1968. W.G. Lynch, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 37 (1987) 493. A.M. Poskanzer, G.W. Butler, E.K. Hyde, Phys. Rev. C 3 (1971) 882; A.M. Poskanzer, G.W. Butler, E.K. Hyde, Phys. Rev. C 4 (1971) 1759. [11] R.G. Korteling, C.R. Toren, E.K. Hyde, Phys. Rev. C 7 (1973) 1611. [12] A. Hirsch, et al., Phys. Rev. C 29 (1984) 508. [13] N.T. Porile, et al., Phys. Rev. C 39 (1989) 1914. [14] A.D. Panagiotou, M.W. Curtin, H. Toki, D.K. Scott, P.J. Siemens, Phys. Rev. Lett. 52 (1984) 496. [15] A. Baden, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods 203 (1982) 189. [16] A.I. Warwick, H.H. Wieman, H.H. Gutbrod, M.R. Maier, J. Peter, H.G. Ritter, H. Stelzer, F. Welk, Phys. Rev. C 27 (1983) 1083; K.G.R. Doss, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 2720. [17] S.J. Yennello, et al., Phys. Rev. C 48 (1993) 1092. [18] J. Hauger, et al., Phys. Rev. C 57 (1998) 764; J. Hauger, et al., Phys. Rev. C 62 (2000) 024616. [19] J. Galin, U. Jahnke, J. Phys. G; Nucl. Part. Phys. 20 (1994) 1105; P. Figuera, et al., Z. Phys. A 352 (1995) 315. [20] S.P. Avdeyev, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 332 (1993) 149. [21] K. Kwiatkowski, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 360 (1995) 571. [22] D.A. Cebra, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 300 (1991) 518. [23] R.T. de Souza, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 295 (1993) 29. [24] J. Pouthas, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 357 (1995) 418; J. Pouthas, et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 369 (1996) 222. [25] NIMROD http://cyclotron.tamu.edu/nimrod. [26] U. Lynen, ALADiN Collaboration, GSI no. GSI-02-89 (1989). [27] F. Gulminelli, W. Trautmann, S.J. Yennello (Eds.), Dynamics and Thermodynamics with Nucleonic Degrees of Freedom, Springer, Berlin, to be published. See also www.kp3.gsi.de/www.kp3/aladinhome; S.P. Avadeyev, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 709 (2002) 392 (and [18,39]). [28] J. Cugnon, T. Mizutani, J. Vandermuelen, Nucl. Phys. A 352 (1981) 505. [29] L.W. Woo, K. Kwiatkowski, V.E. Viola, Phys. Lett. B 132 (1983) 283. [30] Y. Yariv, Z. Fraenkel, Phys. Rev. C 20 (1979) 2227; Y. Yariv, Z. Fraenkel, Phys. Rev. C 24 (1981) 488; Y. Yariv, Z. Fraenkel, Phys. Rev. C 41 (1990). [31] V. Toneev, N.S. Amelin, K.K. Gudima, S. Yu, Sivoklokov, Nucl. Phys. A 519 (1990) 463c. [32] G. Wang, K. Kwiatkowski, V.E. Viola, W. Bauer, P. Danielewicz, Phys. Rev. C 53 (1996) 1811. [33] D. Strottman, W.R. Gibbs, Phys. Lett. B 149 (1984) 288. [34] P. Danielewicz, G.F. Bertsch, Nucl. Phys. A 533 (1991) 712; P. Danielewicz, Nucl. Phys. A 673 (2000) 375. [35] S. Turbide, et al., Phys. Rev. C 70 (2004) 014608. [36] T. Lefort, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 (1999) 4033. [37] L. Beaulieu, et al., Phys. Lett. B 463 (1999) 159. [38] L. Beaulieu, et al., Phys. Rev. C 63 (2001) 031302. [39] F. Goldenbaum, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 1230. [40] K. Kwiatkowski, et al., Phys. Lett. B 423 (1998) 21. [41] K.B. Morley, et al., Phys. Rev. C 54 (1996) 737. [42] J.B. Cumming, J. Hudis, A.M. Poskanzer, S. Kaufman, Phys. Rev. B 134 (1964) 167; J.B. Cumming, J. Hudis, A.M. Poskanzer, S. Kaufman, Phys. Rev. B 132 (1964) 1262. [43] L.P. Remsberg, D.G. Perry, Phys. Rev. Lett. 35 (1975) 361. [44] D.R. Forney, N.T. Porile, Phys. Lett. B 76 (1978) 553. [45] W.-C. Hsi, et al., Phys. Rev. C 60 (1999) 034609. [46] A. Botvina, A.S. Iljinov, I.N. Mishustin, Nucl. Phys. A 507 (1990) 649. [47] E. Renshaw Foxford, et al., Phys. Rev. C 54 (1996) 749. [48] T. Lefort, et al., Phys. Rev. C 64 (2001) 064603. [49] A. Ruangma, et al., Phys. Rev. C 66 (2002) 044603.
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46 [50] G.D. Westfall, R.G. Sextro, A.M. Poskanzer, A.M. Zebelman, G.W. Butler, E. Hyde, Phys. Rev. C 17 (1978) 1368. [51] L.G. Moretto, Nucl. Phys. A 247 (1975) 211. [52] K. Kwiatkowski, J. Bashkin, H. Karwowski, M. Fatyga, V.E. Viola, Phys. Lett. B 171 (1986) 41. [53] B. Hauger, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 235. [54] D. Durand, Nucl. Phys. A 541 (1992) 266. [55] J. Toke, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 292. [56] Y.G. Ma, et al., Phys. Lett. B (1997) 41. [57] L. Beaulieu, et al., Phys. Rev. C 54 (1995) R973. [58] W.-C. Hsi, et al., Phys. Rev. C 58 (1998) R13. [59] T. von Egidy, et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 8 (2000) 197. [60] D. Polster, et al., Phys. Rev. C 51 (1995) 1167. [61] R.E.L. Green, R.G. Korteling, K.P. Jackson, Phys. Rev. C 29 (1984) 1806. [62] W.A. Friedman, Phys. Rev. C 42 (1990) 667. [63] D.H.E. Gross, Rep. Prog. Phys. 53 (1990) 605. [64] S.J. Yennello, et al., Phys. Rev. C 41 (1990) 79. [65] E. Renshaw, et al., Phys. Rev. C 44 (1991) 2618. [66] J. Brzychczyk, et al., Phys. Rev. C 58 (1998) R1372. [67] P. Karol, Phys. Rev. C 11 (1975) 1203. [68] S. Kox, A. Gamp, I. Cherkoani, A.J. Cole, N. Longequeue, J. Menet, C. Perrin, J.B. Viano, Nucl. Phys. 420 (1984) 162. [69] S. Hudan, et al., Phys. Rev. C 70 (2004) 031601R. [70] J.L. Wile, et al., Phys. Rev. C 45 (1992) 2300. [71] J. Zhang, et al., Phys. Rev. C 56 (1997) 1918. [72] D.S. Bracken, et al., Phys. Rev. C 69 (2004) 034612. [73] V.E. Viola, K. Kwiatkowski, J.B. Natowitz, S.J. Yennello, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 132701. [74] P. Bonche, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 427 (1984) 278; P. Bonche, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 436 (1986) 265. [75] J.B. Natowitz, et al., Phys. Rev. C 65 (2002) 034618. [76] R.T. de Souza, et al., Phys. Lett. B 300 (1993) 29. [77] W. Reisdorf, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 612 (1997) 493. [78] T. Lefort, et al., Phys. Rev. C 62 (2000) 031604(R). [79] J.P. Bondorf, A.S. Botvina, A.S. Iljinov, I.N. Mishustin, K. Sneppen, Phys. Rep. 257 (1995) 133. [80] R.J. Charity, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 483 (1988) 371. [81] D.H. Boal, C.K. Gelbke, K.B. Jennings, Rev. Mod. Phys. 62 (1990) 553. [82] R. Trockel, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 2844. [83] Y.D. Kim, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 14; Y.D. Kim, et al., Phys. Rev. C 45 (1992) 338; Y.D. Kim, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 45 (1992) 387. [84] T. Glasmacher, et al., Phys. Rev. C 50 (1994) 952. [85] L. Beaulieu, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 84 (2000) 5971. [86] E. Bauge, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 3705. [87] M. Louvel, et al., Phys. Lett. B 320 (1994) 221. [88] R. Popescu, et al., Phys. Rev. C 58 (1998) 270. [89] G. Wang, et al., Phys. Rev. C 57 (1998) R2786; G. Wang, et al., Phys. Rev. C 59 (1998) 014603. [90] D. Durand, Nucl. Phys. A 630 (1998) 52c and references therein. [91] J. Pochodzalla, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 1040; see also http://www-kp3.gsi.de/www/kp3/aladin.html. [92] J. Albergo, S. Costa, E. Costanzo, A. Rubbino, Nuovo Cim. 89A (1985) 1. [93] J.B. Natowitz, et al., Phys. Rev. C 66 (2002) 031601(R). [94] M.B. Tsang, W.G. Lynch, H. Xi, W.A. Friedman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997) 3836. [95] Y. Yariv, Z. Fraenkel, Phys. Rev. C 26 (1982) 2138. [96] J.R. Wu, C.C. Chang, H.D. Holmgren, Phys. Rev. C 19 (1979) 370; J.R. Wu, C.C. Chang, H.D. Holmgren, Phys. Rev. C 19 (1979) 659. [97] K. Kwiatkowski, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 630 (1998) 168c. [98] T.X. Liu, et al., arxiv.nucl.-ex/0602020 (2006). [99] H. Gutbrod, et al., in: D.M. Sheppard (Ed.), Winter School on Relativistic Heavy Ions, BANF, Canada, 1992, p. 1. [100] L.G. Sobotka, R. Charity, U. Schroeder, J. Toke, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 132702. [101] M.D. D’Agostino, et al., Phys. Lett. B 473 (2000) 219. [102] F. Gulminelli, P. Chomaz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1999) 1402. [103] C.B. Das, et al., Phys. Rev. C 66 (2002) 044602. [104] L.G. Moretto, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 (1995) 1530. [105] X. Campi, J. Phys. A 19 (1986) L917; X. Campi, Phys. Lett. B 208 (1988) 351.
45
46
V.E. Viola et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 1 – 46
[106] M. Kleine Berkenbusch, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 (2002) 022701. [107] W. Bauer, et al., Phys. Lett. B 150 (1985) 53; W. Bauer, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 452 (1986) 699; W. Bauer, et al., Phys. Rev. C 38 (1988) 1297. [108] M.E. Fisher, Physics 3 (1967) 255. [109] J.B. Elliott, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 (2002) 042701. [110] A.H. Raduta, et al., Phys. Rev. C 55 (1997) 1344. [111] J.B. Elliott, et al., Phys. Rev. C 71 (2005) 024607. [112] L.G. Moretto, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 202701. [113] C.M. Mader, et al., Phys. Rev. C 68 (2003) 064601. [114] M. D’Agostino, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 650 (1999) 328. [115] J.B. Elliott, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 (2000) 1194.
Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111 www.elsevier.com/locate/physrep
The high intensity frontier D. Bettonia , S. Biancob , F. Bossib , M.G. Catanesic , A. Ceccuccid , F. Cervellie,∗ , M. Dell’Orsof , U. Dossellig , F. Ferronih , M. Grassie , A. Guglielmig , E. Iacopinii , M. Incaglie , G. Isidorib , S. Malvezzij , M. Mezzettog , P. Migliozzik , R. Mussal , V. Palladinom , M. Ripanin , W. Scandaled , M. Sozzio , F. Terranovab , F. Tessarottop , A. Zoccoliq a INFN-Ferrara, Italy b INFN-LNF, Italy c INFN-Bari, Italy d CERN, Switzerland e INFN-Pisa, Italy f Università di Pisa and INFN-Pisa, Italy g INFN-Padova, Italy h Università di Roma “La Sapienza” and INFN-Romal, Italy i Università di Firenze and INFN-Firenze, Italy j INFN-Milano, Italy k INFN-Napoli, Italy l INFN-Torino, Italy m Università di Napoli and INFN-Napoli, Italy n INFN-Genova, Italy o SNS-Pisa and INFN-Pisa, Italy p INFN-Trieste, Italy q INFN-Bologna, Italy
Accepted 20 July 2006 editor: J. V. Allaby
Abstract In these last years, there is an unprecedented world-wide consensus on the next steps to be taken in the construction of major “energy frontier” accelerator facilities. The main threads for the future of world particle physics seem clear: the first priority is the completion and commissioning of the large hadron collider (LHC), the next priority is the construction of the TeV-energy LC, with a significant period of overlap with LHC running. If the “energy frontier” for the future activities in particle physics seems to be well defined, it is becoming more and more relevant and urgent to underline the importance of other facilities for particle physics. This Report focuses the importance of a diversified experimental program in flavour physics during the LHC era. In particular this Report presents the great opportunities, offered by flavour physics, on a number of fronts within the quark flavour sector, K and charm physics, as well as within neutral
∗ Corresponding author.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (F. Cervelli). 0370-1573/$ - see front matter © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2006.07.003
48
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
and charged-lepton sector, neutrino physics and physics of lepton flavour violation. Finally it is briefly illustrated how future high intensity facilities may also offer an opportunity to perform frontier experiment in nuclear physics. © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. PACS: 11.30.Hv; 11.30.Er; 13.25.Es; 13.20.Eb; 11.30.Pb; 11.30.Fs; 14.60.Pq; 29.20.−c; 29.17.+w; 13.85.−t; 13.75.−n; 14.20.−c; 14.40.−n; 29.25.Rm; 21.60.−n
Contents 0. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Kaon physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. Kaon beams and “ultimate” experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. An example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5. Other physics with kaons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Lepton flavour violation in rare muon decays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Theoretical motivations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. The LFV muon decays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1. The + → e+ e− e+ process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2. The + → e+ process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.3. The − → e− conversion process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. Beams and conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Muon electric and magnetic dipole moments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Muon dipole moments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.1. Muon magnetic dipole moment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.2. Muon Electric Dipole Moment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Measurement of three-family neutrino mixing and search for CP violation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. Neutrino oscillations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Present generation of long baseline experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. The future experimental challenge: the sub-leading → oscillations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. Massive neutrino detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1. Water Cerenkov detector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2. Magnetized iron calorimeter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.3. Low Z calorimeter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.4. Hybrid emulsion detector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.5. Liquid argon time projection chamber . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5. New facilities for next generation of neutrino oscillation experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.1. Near-term long-baseline experiments with SuperBeams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.2. BetaBeams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.3. Neutrino factories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Hadronic physics at the high intensity frontier . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. Standard techniques for the study of hadronic matter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. Spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.1. Light mesons and exotic searches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.2. Charmonium spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.3. Bottomonium spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4. Transversity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.2. The experimental scenario . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.3. Measurements with the Drell–Yan process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.4. Production and storage of polarized antiprotons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5. Antiproton physics at GSI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. High intensity radioactive beams: a new frontier in nuclear physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
49 51 51 52 53 55 56 56 56 56 57 58 58 58 60 61 63 63 63 66 68 68 70 71 74 74 75 75 75 76 77 78 82 84 86 87 87 88 89 89 91 93 93 93 94 95 95 97 98 98
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111 6.2. Scientific case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.1. Nuclear structure at the extremes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.2. Nuclear astrophysics and nucleosynthesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.3. Fundamental interactions and symmetry laws . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.4. Potential of RIBs in other branches of science . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3. The need for new high intensity facilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4. Comparison of RIB production techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5. Next-generation beams and facilities in Europe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.6. Main options for the EURISOL facility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.7. State-of-the-art of specific components for a high-energy proton driver . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.7.1. Injector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.7.2. Low energy section . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.7.3. Intermediate energy section . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.7.4. High energy section . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8. Instrumentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.1. From eV up to 100 keV . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.2. Up to 1 MeV/u . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.3. From 1 to 10 MeV/u . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.4. 100 MeV/u . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.9. Research facilities offering possibilities of synergy with EURISOL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.10. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
49 99 99 100 100 100 100 101 103 104 104 104 104 105 105 105 105 105 105 106 106 106 107 107
0. Introduction Over the last few decades, particle physics has witnessed the extraordinary success of the Standard Model, which explains most observed phenomena in terms of gauge theories. However, the Standard Model, is not able to answer fundamental physics questions, like: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
what is the origin of widely different masses of elementary particles, including neutrinos; what are the origins of the different fundamental forces; why is the proton stable; what is the origin of matter–antimatter asymmetry in the universe; what is the composition of dark matter and the nature of dark energy in the universe.
However, reliable experimental observations (neutrino oscillations, WMAP results, etc.) suggest that extensions to the Standard Model are required. This begs the question, how should we look for new physics beyond the Standard Model? Laboratory exploration in particle physics has traditionally progressed along different but complementary lines. One has been striving for higher energies to access new degrees of freedom directly, the other aiming for higher precision in the study of rare processes. The forthcoming large hadron collider (LHC) at CERN will open a new domain of energies, thus providing answers to a number of previous questions, in particular exploring the domain of the electroweak symmetry breaking, and investigating the existence and nature of the Higgs boson and supersymmetric particles. Nevertheless, many of the unanswered questions require different means of investigation with very detailed studies of the properties of already known particles. Well-controlled experimental conditions as well as high statistics will be the characteristic features of this alternative and complementary way of exploration. This strategic view is leading a substantial and increasing interest in a High Intensity Complex, based on a multi-MW proton driver. The studies of rare decays and precise properties of kaons and muons, the precise measurements of neutrino oscillations, the studies of hadronic spectroscopy and related properties, and also of nuclear physics, could greatly profit by a high intensity proton driver. In October 2003, the National Scientific Panel #1 of INFN (Gruppo 1) appointed a Study Group to investigate Physics opportunities at the High Sensitivity Frontier. The results of this Study Group are the content of this Report.
50
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
The High Sensitivity Frontier gives deep insights into the domain of high precision measurements testing Standard Model validity, and into the almost unknown world of rare decays. The usefulness of high precision measurements at low energy is effectively exemplified by the detailed study of kaon decays, which proved to be of the utmost importance for the development of particle physics. Rare processes with kaons can provide indirect and yet crucial information on fundamental physics that is difficult to access in any other way. The fact that kaons can be copiously produced and have rather long lifetimes, with a large hierarchy between KL and KS , are key elements in offering clear perspectives for future progress. More specifically the rare decays KL → 0 ¯, KL → 0 l + l − (l = e, ) or K + → + ¯ permit us to perform high precision tests of flavour physics within the Standard Model, and they also constitute very sensitive probes of New Physics. The first section of this report details how future high intensity proton beams at intermediate energy may allow direct searches for New Physics in the kaon sector. At the same time, these beams are critical for the study of flavour dynamics from b physics and similar fields. As in kaon physics, muon physics has not yet exhausted its potential. As reported in the second section, muon physics played a fundamental role in establishing the V–A structure of weak interactions and the validity of quantum electrodynamics. For the future, muons may provide crucial information regarding one of the most fundamental quests in modern physics: the structure of the theory which lies beyond the Standard Model of particle physics. Indeed one of the main interests in muon physics lies in the search for processes violating the muon number. The discovery of decays such as + → e+ and + → e+ e− e+ or of -e conversion in nuclei would be an indisputable proof of new dynamics beyond the Standard Model. New lepton-number violating dynamics at a scale M∼109 –1014 GeV cannot yield observable rates for rare muon processes, since the corresponding effects are suppressed by (m /M)4 . The observation of muon number violation in muon decays would thus require new physics. Furthermore, the information that can be extracted from the study of rare muon processes is, in many cases, not accessible to high-energy colliders. For example, even if LHC will find the supersymmetric “sleptons” and measure their masses, it would not be able to compete with muon decay experiments in constraining the “sleptons” mixing angles. Along with searches for lepton flavour violating decays, muons may provide another path to the high-energy frontier through precision measurements of its electric dipole moment (EDM). In the Standard Model framework, the predicted EDMs for the leptons are extremely small and lie orders of magnitude below the present experimental limits. In any case, neutrino oscillations prove that lepton flavour has been violated, and this violation may be enhanced by new dynamics at the TeV scale. This same new physics could also generate measurable effects in the electric (and magnetic) dipole moments of the muon. A -EDM at a measurable level would signify physics beyond the Standard Model. Indeed SUSY models or other dynamics at the TeV scale do predict EDMs at measurable levels. If SUSY or other dynamics at the TeV scale are not found at LHC, then precision experiments, like EDM and (g − 2) searches, become even more important because their values are sensitive (through virtual loops), to much higher mass scales than direct searches for new physics. As described in the third section, these precision measurements can be pursued at future high-intensity facilities, given that EDM and (g − 2) searches will continue to be a topic of great importance in the first decades of this century. Section 4 of this Report is devoted to future neutrino experiments. For almost 70 years neutrinos have played a crucial role in the quest to understand elementary particles and their interactions. The recent discoveries and revolutionary breakthroughs in the study of neutrino properties are motivating a new generation of experimental efforts aimed at resolving the remaining issues and establishing new launching points for future explorations. Neutrino oscillation studies are planned to measure the mixing between the first and the third generation neutrino mass eigenstates. This mixing (ϑ13 ), is pivotal in terms of phenomenological consequences. In fact, CP violation and matter–antimatter asymmetry in the universe depend on the mixing angle between these two states. Consequently, the establishment of non-vanishing mixing (i.e. ϑ13 different from 0) is of fundamental importance. The measurements of ϑ13, together with the studies of the neutrino mass hierarchy and the role of CP violation, will require mounting new long baseline accelerator experiments. In the fourth Chapter, the main features of future experiments are carefully described. These features must include: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
the ability to detect the → e process as the major goal; L/E ∼500 km/GeV to optimize the oscillation probability for m223 ∼2 × 10−3 eV2 ; the propagation of -beams through the earth, resulting in sensitivity to matter effects; the possibility of varying L/E adjusting the focusing horn, target position and/or detector location; the possibility of switching to anti- .
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
51
Section 5 of this collection summarizes the opportunities offered by intense hadron beams to investigate the questions left open in the field of strong interactions. The main objectives of Hadronic Physics are to determine the degrees of freedom governing the hadronic phenomena and to connect them to fundamental parameters and fields of Quantum Chromo Dynamics (QCD). Using high intensity facilities, and in particular low energy antiproton beams, p–pbar annihilation reactions can be studied in order to investigate the field of light meson spectroscopy and search for light exotic states. Intense proton beams, polarized and/or up to ∼1 TeV energy, also allow investigation of the internal structure of hadrons. However in Section 5, a large number of research projects, which stand to gain from high intensity facilities, are presented. Finally, it is worth stressing that the high intensity frontier has many points in common with other fields of research. In particular, in Nuclear Physics high power accelerators are necessary to build intense radioactive ion beams (RIB). RIB facilities offer the right tools to investigate nuclear structures which are far from stability. Beyond known nuclei, more than 6000 nuclei are predicted to exist and their properties are essentially unknown. To explore this “Terra Incognita”, intense secondary beams of radioactive ions are needed. There are two methods to produce secondary RIB. The first is the “in flight” method, which takes advantage of the high incident velocity of high-energy (50–1000 MeV/n) heavy ion stable beams hitting a thin target. The second “ISOL” method is characterized by an intense primary beam incident on a thick target where the exotic nuclei produced by the reaction are ionized on line before an isotopic selection. A MW proton driver could be a powerful tool to exploit this second method. As is reported in the sixth Chapter, the main motivation for building the next-generation of ISOL RIB facilities is the study of the nuclear structure (which is the basis for an understanding of both Nuclear Astrophysics and Fundamental Interactions). In addition, high intensity RIBs could be useful in other fields, such as Solid State Physics and Medical Applications. 1. Kaon physics 1.1. Physics The next frontier in the exploration of fundamental physics with kaons lies in the detection of very rare decays of K + and KL (see e.g. [1]). For some remarkable decay modes, the theoretical uncertainties arising from hadronic non-perturbative physics can be kept under control, as happens in those few “golden” decay modes of B mesons studied at B-factories. These modes fall into the class of those rare decays induced by flavour-changing neutral currents. In the Standard Model, these decays are suppressed by the GIM mechanism and the CKM mixing hierarchy, proceeding through second order ¯ where = e, , . In this case, the hadronic matrix element can be extracted weak loops, of the type K → , from the well-known semileptonic K → decays, and the branching ratio measurement can be directly translated into a measurement of the underlying parameters of the theory, i.e. the CKM matrix elements in the case of the Standard Model. In this respect, the decays K + → + ¯ and KL → 0 ¯ are the best ones, since they are dominated by the interesting (calculable) short-distance physics, with very small theoretical errors. The non-parametric uncertainties in the Standard Model branching ratio predictions are at the level of ∼5% for the former [2] and ∼2% for the latter (CP-violating). These “golden” decay modes have been extensively discussed in the literature (a recent review can be found in [3] and references therein). For the cases of decays with charged leptons in the final state, while K + → + e+ e− and K + → + + − are dominated by long-distance physics, in the more interesting KL → 0 e+ e− and KL → 0 + − modes the CPconserving and the indirect CP-violating long-distance contributions can be controlled by ancillary measurements of other KL and KS decay modes. These measurements have only recently become available, thus allowing the uncovering of the short-distance (CP-violating) part directly related to CKM matrix elements [4]. Given theoretical control of the above decays, the measurement of their branching ratios would allow strong constraints to be put on the CKM unitarity triangle. In fact, it can be shown that such a triangle would be constrained by measuring rare K decays in a way that is independent of B meson measurements. This would provide a strong consistency check on the CKM picture. Actually, the combination of the two K → ¯ measurements would result in a constraint on the apex of the triangle, which could be compared with that obtained solely from B measurements (md /ms and sin(2)). A detailed comparison of the relative sensitivity of K and B measurements to constrain the CKM triangle has already been performed in [5]. While the precision which can be achieved on the measurement of
52
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 1 Summary of K → ¯ decays status and expectations Mode
BR (theory and experiments)
Notes
K L → 0 e + e −
Theory (SM): (3.7 ± 1.0) × 10−11
CPC + CPVind + CPVdir [CPV dir = 30.50%] Theor. discrete ambiguities Exp. bkg from e+ e− CPC + CPVind + CPVdir [CPVdir = 10.30%], Theor. discrete ambiguities, long-distance → BR∼10% Not CP violating Charm contrib. → BR∼5%
K L → 0 + −
K + → + ¯
KL → 0 ¯
[or (1.7 ± 0.6) × 10−11 -disfavoured] Exp: < 2.8 × 10−10 (FNAL KTeV [8], 3 events, 2.05 bkg) Theory (SM): (1.5 ± 0.3) × 10−11 [or (1.0 ± 0.2) × 10−11 -disfavoured] Exp: < 3.8 × 10−10 (FNAL KTeV [9], 2 events, 0.87 bkg) Theory (SM):(8.0 ± 1.0) × 10−11 +1.30 Exp: (1.47−0.89 ) × 10−10 (BNL E787 + E949 [11], 3 events, 0.45 bkg) Theory (SM): (3.0 ± 0.6) × 10−11 Exp: < 5.9 × 10−7 (FNAL KTeV [12], 0 events, 0.12 bkg)
Pure CPV dir BR∼2%
the Wolfenstein parameter is better in B decays, that on is comparable in both systems, and the error on t = Vtd Vts∗ is always better in K. The K and the B meson sectors are thus seen to be rather similar and complementary in terms of revealing any inconsistency in the Standard Model. Moreover, most of the current constraints on the unitarity triangle (and all the CP-violating ones), originate from neutral meson mixing processes (εK , sin(2) and ms /md ). Decay processes, changing by one unit, have in general a different sensitivity to new physics, and therefore represent qualitatively different probes of the flavour structure. One should also recall that very rare decays can have a large sensitivity to new physics particles in the loops. If and when such new particles are discovered at LHC, the study of rare decays should provide unique information on their couplings, information which cannot be obtained elsewhere and which is crucial for the understanding of CP violation. To this end, a precise measurement of all the four decay modes in Table 1 would be extremely useful, since they are sensitive to different short-distance structures. If the new physics (somewhat surprisingly) has the same couplings as the Standard Model, effects of the order 10–30% on the branching ratios are possible, while if its structure is different, effects could be very large. If, on the contrary, new physics is not found directly at the energy frontier, ultra-rare decays will remain the best place to probe very high scales which are out of reach of direct searches. From an experimental point of view, the detection of the above rare decays is an extremely challenging enterprise. Branching ratios are predicted in the Standard Model at the level of 10−11 and—particularly for the modes with two undetected neutrinos—the huge backgrounds from other K decays cannot be easily constrained by kinematics. Redundancy of measurements and hermetic vetoing of both charged particles and photons are the key issues in every experimental design. 1.2. Experiments Table 1 summarizes the current status and expectations for the most interesting decay modes mentioned above. Theoretical predictions for the KL → 0 + − modes suffer from an intrinsic ambiguity related to the (experimentally inaccessible) sign of the interference between direct and indirect CP-violating components, although constructive interference (larger branching ratios) is favoured. Among the very rare decays of high theoretical interest listed above, the only one to have been experimentally detected so far isK + → + ¯, with three events from the dedicated BNL experiments E787 and E949 [10,11]. Current experimental limits for the KL modes are at least one order of magnitude above the Standard Model predictions for the cases with charged leptons, while for the cleanest mode KL → 0 ¯, the experimental limits are four orders of magnitude above the Standard Model level, exceeding a model-independent upper bound derived from the measured mode K + → + ¯ [13].
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
53
This clearly indicates that a campaign of dedicated measurements is required to accurately measure these decays. In some cases, new techniques have to be tested or pushed beyond the present standards in order to be able to fight against background. Concerning KL → 0 + − , no dedicated new proposals exist at the moment, but the interest in this mode has been revamped recently by the availability of new ancillary measurements from NA48 on the corresponding KS decays [6]. This allows theoretical control of the indirect CP-violating contributions, while the long-distance contributions are constrained by other KL decay measurements from NA48 and KTeV [7]. Focusing on the K + → + modes, the BNL experiments E787 and E949 used low-energy K + stopped in an active target. The detection of the full → → e decay chain allowed reduction of backgrounds at the price of a small acceptance. The E949 experiment ran for only 11 weeks in 2002 (20% of its goal), and has since been stopped due to lack of AGS funding. A letter of intent [17] for an upgraded experiment with the same approach has been presented for the J-PARC machine (beam expected in 2008). The experiment plans to collect about 50 Standard Model events, but new techniques would have to be adopted to reach such a level. A new alternative approach, using kaon decays in flight from a RF-separated 22 GeV/c charged K beam, was proposed at FNAL: the CKM experiment [18], planned to collect 100 events (with signal-to-background ratio S/B∼10) using some innovative detectors. This proposal was not ratified by a review committee in 2003 due to its high cost, and the collaboration has been studying a cheaper approach in order to reach the same goal (P940), which has also been turned down. A working group, composed mainly of the NA48 collaboration at CERN, presented a Proposal [14] for an experiment using the SPS and a substantially upgraded NA48 detector. The aim is to collect about 40 Standard Model events per year, using an unseparated beam of higher energy (75 GeV/c). This choice relieves somewhat the requirements on the photon veto efficiency needed to suppress the dominating + 0 background. Concerning the KL → 0 ¯ mode, two projects have been studied recently: the first is KOPIO [21], which aimed to collect 40 SM events (S/B∼2) with an innovative technique using a micro-bunched low energy neutral beam. The second is the pilot project E391a at KEK: this experiment, while not achieving the Standard Model sensitivity, is currently taking data to validate a technique using a higher energy beam and a strong kinematic cut to suppress background. A Proposal for an experiment at J-PARC [20] using the same technique with the goal of collecting more than 100 SM events has been presented. The possibility of exploiting a very high intensity e+ e− collider working as a -factory (such as a super-DANE) to measure the very rare decays mentioned above was also discussed in a recent workshop [19]. The luminosity required for such experiments would be of the order 1035 cm−2 s−1 , while at the present time reasonable extrapolations from the current peak DANE luminosity reach around 1034 cm−2 s−1 . As the figures themselves together with the brief overview show, the path to precision measurements of these rare decay modes is a long and challenging one, and needs to be performed in well-planned incremental steps. The known experimental challenges, and the difficulties of the experiments (only partially predictable in advance), strongly suggest carrying out these measurements in at least two experiments with alternative approaches. 1.3. Kaon beams and “ultimate” experiments Table 2 lists some proposed rare kaon experiments to give an idea of the expected fluxes. Both the beams and experimental techniques are different, and so the experiments cannot be directly compared. Experience teaches us that extrapolations are difficult in this field, but one might hope that after the next round of experiments (at the beginning of the next decade), some tens of events of the rare K → ¯ decay modes will have been experimentally measured. This would already be a major achievement, but would not exhaust the physics potential of such decays in terms of allowing a precise challenge to this sector of the Standard Model. If the measured branching ratios were found to be in agreement with the Standard Model predictions within ∼10%, at least ten times the amount of data would be required to exhaust the potential of this test. In the case of a significant disagreement with the Standard Model, the case would become even more compelling, both to reach higher precision in the branching ratio measurement and to extract further information and/or access different kinematical regions for the decays. A study of the impact of such high precision future measurements on the knowledge of the CKM unitarity triangle was performed in [3]. Intense kaon beams can be produced by hadronic machines, since both neutral and charged kaons are readily produced in high energy pp collisions with comparable cross sections.
54
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 2 Comparison of some proposed rare decay kaon experiments, in terms of beam parameters Experiment
Beam
p momentum (GeV/c)
K momentum (GeV/c)
Starting date
p flux (Tp/s)
K flux (MK/s)
KAMI (FNAL) E391a (KEK) KOPIO (BNL) Prop (J-PARC) KLOD (Protvino) P326 (CERN) CKM (FNAL) P940 (FNAL) EoI (J-PARC) OKA (Protvino)
KL KL KL KL KL K+ K+ K+ K+ K+
120 12 24 30 60 400 120 120 30 70
10 2 0.7 ∼2 6.5 75 22 ∼45 0.6 ∼1.5
Cancelled 2004 Cancelled 2009 2007 2011 Cancelled Cancelled 2009 2007
1.0 0.8 14 60 1.1 0.2 1.4 0.7 23 1.1
38 0.6 33 320 7 9 9 3.5 2.3 0.4
(unsep.) (sep.) (unsep.) (sep.) (sep.)
While neutral kaon beams contain the same amount of KS and KL at production, the need for charged particle sweeping and target shielding makes the study of KS close to the target more difficult, while intense KL beams can be readily obtained. The use of regeneration to produce KS has different advantages and disadvantages, but is not competitive in terms of flux. Several important measurements of rare KS decays were made using hadron machines, but the cleaner environment of -factories and, more importantly, their unique coherent production mechanism make them, in principle, the ideal instrument for the study of rare KS decays (a high-luminosity -factory would be the best machine for precision study of rare KS decays). This point will not be discussed further here. Future high intensity proton drivers (above 1014 protons/pulse) are being discussed as possible sources for producing intense neutrino beams, or as injectors for higher energy hadron machines. Such accelerators might of course be very interesting for kaon rare decays experiments, provided their beam energy is significantly above the K production threshold (i.e. a few tens of GeV or above). Besides proton energy, the other important feature for most high-energy physics experiments is slow (ideally DC) extraction. These two issues conflict somewhat with the requirements for neutrino physics, but satisfactory compromises and arrangements could be devised to exploit the important synergies of experiments requiring very high proton fluxes. Conventional kaon beams produced by hadronic machines are usually either wide band neutral (KL ) beams, or charged (usually K + ) kaon beams. Neutral kaon beams are obtained by selecting an appropriately large solid angle and applying magnetic sweeping of charged particles. These beams contain mostly n and (several times the kaon flux). The targeting angle can be chosen to optimize the beam composition and reduce the neutron flux. Such beams have been exploited by many experiments in the past (e.g. KTeV and NA48). Charged kaon beams may be either unseparated, thus containing mostly charged pions (e.g. a factor 10 more than kaons, depending on energy), or separated, to enhance the relative amount of kaons. For beam momenta below a few GeV/c, electrostatic separation is feasible and purities up to K/∼3–4 are achieved (e.g. the stopped kaon experiments at BNL). At higher beam energies, RF separation can be used for charged beams. Two distant RF kickers are set up so that a fraction of charged particles is deflected in the transverse direction twice, the distance between the two stations being chosen so that the net deflection of unwanted particles is zero, while a fraction of kaons undergo a non-zero displacement and therefore miss a beam dump. While the experimental advantages of working with a separated beam are evident, some limitations are also present in this case. The required length of the beam line scales with the square of the beam momentum and the inverse of the RF frequency, so that for practically achievable frequencies the available space constrains the maximum beam momentum. Depending on the incident proton energy, this limitation might make it difficult or impossible to exploit the energy range with the most favourable kaon yield. Also, the fraction of kaons lost due to decay along the beam line before entering the fiducial region decreases at higher momenta (where a longer fiducial decay region is required to collect the same number of decays).
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
55
Moreover, the RF phase relation required for separation is only valid at a single beam energy, and therefore the momentum range of a separated beam must be kept relatively small (i.e. 1%, compared with 10–15% which is common for unseparated beams), thus limiting the kaon flux for the same primary proton intensity. Such a separated charged kaon beam could also be used to produce an intense, high purity tertiary K 0 beam of wellconstrained energy by exploiting charge exchange. This would open up other possibilities for precise measurements of other decay modes, as well as for ultimate precision tests of CPT up to the Planck scale using KL /KS interference as was proposed for the CP/T experiment [22] at FNAL. It should be noted that the beam power required to obtain a given kaon yield is minimum at proton energies of 30–100 GeV [23], so that range would be optimal for a machine in terms of efficiency for kaon production. There is one important point concerning flux which cannot be overemphasized. Very high kaon fluxes are not only required for sheer production rate reasons, but would allow the search for very rare events in different, more powerful ways. This would mean applying more stringent cuts to the data to suppress the backgrounds, thus restricting the phase space while still retaining a significant sensitivity to the signal. It would also restrict the possibility of exploiting other discriminating properties of the signal, such as time evolution patterns, Dalitz plot distributions or polarization. As already described in the literature, the determination of these properties would help in not only extracting the signal but also obtaining more physics information. Therefore, the study of more intense beams is of high importance for future progress. Alongside this, however, detector and trigger systems able to withstand the new range of intensities will have to be developed. Adequate controls of systematic effects would also be a crucial issue in such experiments. It would be wrong to assume that kaon flux is the only limitation. In fact, each specific experiment requires a careful case-by-case assessment of the issues relevant to that experiment, being careful making extrapolations from previous experiments. 1.4. An example In this section, we focus on the K + → + ¯ mode (here the extrapolations are relatively easy), to give an idea of how a high intensity proton machine (in the tens of GeV energy range) could provide an RF-separated K + beam capable of measuring the branching ratio with an experimental precision commensurate to the theoretical precision. At the first Workshop on the High Intensity Frontier [15], the construction of a 4 MW, 50 GeV/c proton synchrotron was considered. Such a machine, if completed with a stretcher ring to provide a DC-like time structure, could be used to provide intense charged kaon beams. In Table 3, we illustrate the potential rate capability of such a kaon factory by putting in some typical numbers. It should be stressed, however, that in absence of detailed studies, the numbers should be considered as ballpark numbers only. A 4 MW 50 GeV/c proton machine provides a proton flux of 5 × 1014 protons/s that could be extracted and aimed towards a target. According to the empirical formula frequently used at CERN for secondary particle production from p-Be interactions, one expects the K + production rate to reach a maximum at 12 GeV/c. At that momentum the K + production rate amounts to approximately 0.48 K + /GeV/c/steradian per interacting proton [16]. Even though it is unlikely that the target for such an intense proton beam would be made of beryllium, and considering that the formula was based on measurements at higher momenta, we used this number as a guideline (In actual fact, this formula is known to underestimate the production rates at low momenta, since rescattering inside the target is neglected). A typical target efficiency is 40%, and we assume a RF-separated beam with an angular acceptance of 5 mrad in each plane, i.e. 75 sr, which is conservative compared with the 128 sr proposed at 22 GeV/c by the CKM experiment (see Table 3 for the full list of parameters). Even if a fully debunched (DC) beam is the optimum for experiments, the duty cycle of the accelerating machine (and its uptime) has to be taken into account as far as integrated luminosity is concerned. For this estimate, it was taken to be 30%. Using these numbers one finds a K + rate of about 0.40×5×1014 ×0.48×0.24×75×10−6 ×0.50×0.3=2.6×108 /s at production. For a typical one-year run of 107 s/yr, the K + yield could thus be as high as 2.6 × 1015 K + . The RF separated beam at CKM had a length of about 90 m. As the length between separators scales with p 2 , one may assume a length slightly exceeding 30 m. The K + decay length at 12 GeV/c is about 90 m. Supposing some two thirds of the K + arrive at the start of the fiducial volume, and of those a third decay in the fiducial volume, some 6 × 1014 K + decays occur in the fiducial volume per running year. For a branching ratio of 10−10 and an acceptance × efficiency of 2%, this leads to more than 1000 good events per year, well matching the anticipated theoretical accuracy. This is a good number, showing that a 4 MW 50 GeV/c proton machine should be competitive in kaon physics.
56
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 3 Summary of assumed machine parameters for a possible high intensity extracted RF-separated kaon beam Parameter
Value
Proton beam energy Target efficiency Nominal K + momentum Momentum spread Beam acceptance Separator acceptance
50 GeV 40% 12 GeV/c ±1% (0.24 GeV/c) 75 sr 50%
1.5. Other physics with kaons While the above discussed rare kaon decay measurements are considered the most relevant and urgent measurements (because they allow accurate comparison with theoretical predictions), the scope of physics research using kaons is much wider than that described within this short document. One should also consider the highly-interesting experiments aimed to constrain the chiral perturbation approach to low-energy hadron dynamics. From a number of measurements of branching ratios and form factors, one is able to improve the predictability at higher loop orders. Several other first rate physics issues could also be studied making use of intense kaon production facilities. With these facilities one could envisage having access to New Physics, like direct CP- violating asymmetries in several KL or K + hadronic decay modes, and T-violation signals. Generally speaking, the SM predictions for these quantities are below (in some cases significantly below) the current experimental limits. The same is, of course, true for decays which are “forbidden” in the SM, such as lepton-violating decays (e.g. KL → e, K ± → ± e). Experimental progress on these measurements in the past decade contributed to disproving several New Physics models, and while further progress would most likely require new experimental approaches and an even more accurate control of systematic issues, kaon is both a requirement and an asset for further progress in the field. Other issues which could be studied making use of intense kaon beams span from the previously-mentioned CPT test based on accurate comparison of K → 2 decay phases, to probing low-energy pion interactions and the related parameters accurately predicted by QCD, to other very high precision tests of CPT and quantum mechanics. While some of these measurements require dedicated experiments, others could be performed as by-products of high-intensity searches for rare decay modes. Moreover, it should be noted that other sectors of microscopic physics research beyond particle physics—not covered here—could profit from intense kaon beams, one example being the study of hyper-nuclei which is an active field of research in nuclear physics (see e.g. [19]). 1.6. Conclusions The investigation of fundamental physics issues and the testing of the Standard Model in search for New Physics have still to gain from the investigations with kaons. The study of very rare (and very sensitive) decays of neutral and charged kaons are among the most interesting probes for the structure of any physics beyond the Standard Model. The experiments (which are expected to start this decade), although extremely challenging, will not be able to produce definitive results. The success of this line of experiments will require higher statistics. The availability of very high kaon fluxes, which can be provided only by high-intensity proton drivers, are a crucial need. A proton energy of at least a few tens of GeV and a DC beam with a high duty cycle are a must for the ultimate pursuit of these investigations. 2. Lepton flavour violation in rare muon decays 2.1. Introduction In the past, muon physics has played a fundamental role in the construction of the Standard Model of particle physics. Nowadays muon physics has not yet exhausted its potential. Precise measurements of the muon lifetime and of the Michel parameters provide indications of the Lorentz structure of the weak interaction, a test of CPT and of QED, and
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
57
measurements of fundamental constants. The determination of the muon anomalous magnetic moment and the search for the muon electric dipole moment may provide hints for new physics beyond the Standard Model. Low energy muons are widely used probes in condensed matter sciences. The discovery of lepton flavour violation (LFV) in muon decays, such as + → e+ , + → e+ e− e+ and − → e− conversion in nuclei, would be an indisputable proof of the existence of new dynamics beyond the Standard Model. Muon storage rings are currently being considered as options for future machines hosted in international laboratories. The primary aim of these machines is the study of neutrino properties, but they are also an ideal place to study muon properties, since they provide muon fluxes two to four orders of magnitude larger than that obtained at present, and offer a wider span of choice for the momentum. In this chapter the status of the experimental searches for LFV is presented. The benefit that future searches could gain from new high intensity muon beams is also discussed. A more complete review can be found in [24]. 2.2. Theoretical motivations In the pure Standard Model (SM), the muon number is exactly conserved. In any simple extension of the SM obtained with the introduction of Dirac neutrino masses and neutrino mixing, muon-number violating processes with charged leptons become possible as well. However, because of the small size of neutrino masses, the rates for these processes are immeasurably small, for instance B(+ → e+ ) ≈ 10−54 . On the other hand, super-symmetric unification theories (SUSY-GUT) generically predict LFV processes in the charged sector at measurable levels. There are two distinct supersymmetric sources of lepton-flavour number violation. The first source is related to the slepton mixing due to radiative corrections [25], and the second one is due to the inclusion of a see-saw mechanism for the neutrino masses [26]. We observe that these two sources of LFV are independent and always present in all SUSY-GUT models. Muon-number violating processes are therefore not contaminated by the background of any simple extension of the Standard Model and constitute unambiguous and clean signals of profound new physics. The predicted branching ratios (BR) of the various muon number violating processes vary according to the chosen grand unification model. Even within a selected model, the expected BRs span more than three orders of magnitude depending on the model parameters. Generally, in SUSY-GUT the relative amplitudes of the three processes, always with + → e+ as reference, are more stable, and we expect, indicatively, B(+ → e+ e− e+ ) ≈ 10−2 B(+ → e+ ) B(− → e− ) ≈ 10−2 B(+ → e+ ) for − → e− conversion on high Z targets. In SUSY-GUT SU(5) models the expected B(+ → e+ ) ranges from 10−15 to 10−13 , apart from accidental cancellation, while for SO(10) models the predictions are even larger, i.e. from 10−13 to 10−11 . The phenomenon of neutrino oscillations has been well established by experimental observation of atmospheric [27], solar [28] and reactor [29] neutrinos. The measured neutrino mixing parameters (LMA solution of the solar neutrino mixing), when included in SUSY models, restrict the possible branching ratio for + → e+ to values well exceeding 10−14 . Other grand unification models have been proposed, including R-violating super-symmetry and extra dimensions. In these models, the absolute and the relative amplitudes of the LFV processes may give completely different results from the values provided in the case of SUSY-GUT models. One can conclude that new measurements of all LFV channels in the charged sector, including → , but also new measurements of g − 2 and -EDM, have solid theoretical motivations. Furthermore, the predicted BRs are not far from present experimental upper limits. It is necessary to emphasize that experimental searches in all channels should be pursued. In fact the comparison of the different channels constitutes, even in the presence of a single positive result, a powerful tool to discriminate between the various grand unification models.
58
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 4 Summary of the SINDRUM detector performances relevant for the + → e+ e− e+ decay search Parameter
SINDRUM
Stop rate Muon momentum Magnetic field Ang. acceptance Momentum resolution Vertex resolution Timig resolution Target length Target density
0.6 × 107 + /s 25 MeV/c 0.33 T 24% 10% FWHM ≈ 2 mm2 ≈ 1 ns 220 mm 11 mg/cm2
2.3. The LFV muon decays The experimental searches for LFV processes have a long history, which began in 1946. These searches were limited by the detector itself, and also often by the muon beam intensity. In this paper we discuss the possible benefits that the experimental searches could obtain from muon beams with intensities that are two or three orders of magnitude higher than the ones presently available. 2.3.1. The + → e+ e− e+ process The present experimental limit on the + → e+ e− e+ decay branching ratio [30] is B < 1 × 10−12 at 90% C.L., obtained by the SINDRUM experiment [31] in 1988. Since then, no other experimental searches have been proposed so the SINDRUM experiment has to be taken as reference. From the experimental point of view, this decay produces only charged particles in the final state, simplifying the detector layout. However, the energy spectrum of the decay products reaches low energy. This requires a tracking system capable of sustaining the entire flux of Michel positron from the normal muon decay. The SINDRUM detector was a solenoidal spectrometer equipped with MWPCs coaxial with the beam. Threedimensional hit positions were determined by means of cathode strips oriented at ±45◦ relative to the sense wires. The angular acceptance was 24% of 4 with a momentum resolution of ∼10%. A continuous muon beam of 25 MeV/c was stopped on a low-density target, 11 mg/cm2 , at a rate of 6 × 106 + /s. The candidate event selection was based on kinematical criteria. The three final particles had to have the muon invariant mass, zero total momentum, a common vertex and had to be emitted at the same time. The event background was subdivided into two classes, the correlated background and the uncorrelated one. The first class was generated by the internal conversion of radiative muon decays, + → e+ e− ¯ e . The uncorrelated background was produced by the accidental coincidence of a normal Michel positron with an e+ e− pair produced by the Bhabha scattering in the target of another Michel positron. We noted that the correlated background scaled linearly with the muon stop rate in the target, while the uncorrelated one scaled quadratically. The data sample collected by SINDRUM was background free, meaning that the background equivalent Branching Ratio was Bunc ∼10−13 for a beam intensity of 0.6 × 107 + /s. Since 1988 there have been no new experimental proposals for + → e+ e− e+ . Any future proposal should aim at a single-event sensitivity of the order of 10−16 and would therefore require a beam of 1010 + /s. At this stop rate, the background would scale up to Bunc ∼10−10 . The quadratic dependence of the uncorrelated background rate on the muon stop rate would require, even on best assumptions, substantial detector improvements. Table 4 lists the SINDRUM detector parameters. To reach the stated sensitivity, a background suppression factor of ≈6 orders of magnitude has to be obtained. Such a huge factor is probably not achievable, even with improved present-day experimental techniques. The + → e+ e− e+ search demands innovative detectors. 2.3.2. The + → e+ process The present experimental limit on the + → e+ decay branching ratio [32] is B < 1.2 × 10−11 at 90% C.L., obtained by the MEGA experiment in 1998. From the experimental point of view, this decay has two different particles in the final state.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
59
Liq. Xe Scintillation Detector
Liq. Xe Scintillation Detector
Muon Beam
γ e+
Drift Chamber
Thin Superconducting Coil Stopping Target
γ e+
Timing Counter
Drift Chamber
1m Fig. 1. The schematic view of longitudinal and transverse sections of the MEG detector.
Thus the optimization of the detector resolutions requires diverse sub-detectors for the photon and the positron, resulting in a more elaborate layout with respect to the + → e+ e− e+ case. The MEG collaboration is presently building a new detector to search for + → e+ decay with a sensitivity of ∼5 × 10−14 . The experiment is planned to start in 2006, and is expected to be completed by 2008, before the results of LHC experiments. The experiment [33] will be conducted at the Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI), Switzerland, using the e5 beam line, the most intense continuous muon beam presently available. The signature of a + → e+ event is given by a coincidence of a 52.8 MeV photon with a 52.8 MeV positron in space, time and direction. A schematic view of the MEG detector layout is shown in Fig. 1. The positive muon beam is brought to stop in a thin target after passing a stage in which most of the contaminating positrons are eliminated. Depending on the ultimate resolutions of the individual sub-detectors, the beam intensity can be optimized in order to give the lowest accidental background rate. A muon stop rate of the order of 108 /s in a ∼0.5 cm radius spot has been achieved. The momentum and the emission direction of the e+ are measured by a magnetic spectrometer, composed of a quasisolenoidal magnetic field and a set of ultra-thin drift chambers. The field is shaped so that monochromatic e+ s from the target follow trajectories with constant projected bending radius, independent of the emission angle over a wide angular range. The sweeping capability of the non-uniform magnetic field reduces the persistence of low longitudinal momentum e+ s in the tracking volume. Both features greatly reduce the accidental pile-up of the Michel e+ , decrease the pattern recognition problems and enhance the system efficiency. Simulation shows the expected FWHM resolution ranges between 0.7% and 0.9% for the positron momentum, and from 9 to 12 mrad for the angle. An array of plastic scintillators is placed on each side of the spectrometer to measure the e+ emission time with a FWHM resolution of 0.1 ns. While all e+ are confined inside the magnet, the -rays penetrate through the thin superconducting coil of the spectrometer ( 80% transmission probability) and are detected by a liquid Xenon scintillation calorimeter. This consists of a single volume of liquid Xenon viewed from all sides by about 800 photomultipliers (PMT). All the kinematical variables of the impinging photons can be reconstructed from the PMT signals only. Tests on a large scale prototype, as well as a full simulation, show that one can expect FWHM resolutions of 4% for the energy, 10.5 mm for the position of the interaction point and 0.1 ns for the timing measurements for 52.8 MeV -rays. The two major background classes are the physical, or correlated, background from radiative muon decays, + → e+ e ¯ , and the uncorrelated background given by a positron in the high energy part of the Michel spectrum accidentally overlapping with a high energy photon from a different source, for instance, a radiative muon decay or a positron annihilation-in-flight.
60
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 5 Expected MEG detector performances FWHM
E e E e t e
0.8% 4% 19 mrad 0.15 ns
The background crucially depends on detector performances. The current estimates, defined using the FWHM, are summarized in Table 5. The physical background (Bphys ) was calculated by numerical integration over the selection cuts chosen at 1.4 FWHM for each selection variable. This background is expected to contribute with ≈ 3.1 × 10−15 events per muon decay, with the resolution values shown in Table 5. The uncorrelated background poses a greater threat than the physical one. The uncorrelated background rate Runc contribution scales accordingly with the following formula [33]: Runc ∝ R2 · Ee · te · (E )2 · ( e )2 where the dependences on the detector resolutions are explicitly indicated. Assuming a 1.4 FWHM cut for each selection variable, this background would contribute at Bunc ≈ 3 × 10−14 events per muon decay for a muon stop rate R = 0.3 × 108 + /s, and the already-mentioned detector resolutions. Observing that the beam line could deliver a larger muon flux of up to 2 × 108 + /s, one can conclude that the beam is not the limiting factor. The MEG collaboration is currently assembling a detector with a sensitivity of two orders of magnitude better than the present upper limit on the branching ratio. The experiment sensitivity could be pushed down to < 10−14 depending ‘only’ on the improvements on the detector performances. 2.3.3. The − → e− conversion process When − are brought at rest in matter, muonic atoms in the ground state are quickly formed. These atoms decay by either muon decay in orbit (MDIO) − NZ → e− ¯ e NZ or nuclear muon capture (MC) ∗ . The amplitude of the latter decay mode increases with the atomic number, thus reducing the − NZ → NZ−1 muonic atom lifetime to less than 100 ns for atoms heavier than lead. The − → e− conversion occurs in the nucleus field with a branching ratio which can vary by one order of magnitude depending on the atomic number Z. The coherent conversion, which occurs when the recoiling nucleus remains in the ground state is expected to be enhanced. In this case, the emitted electrons have the MDIO-decay end-point energy. The signature is a single electron emerging from the target with an energy of ≈ 100 MeV. The present experimental limits on the − → e− conversion on different materials were obtained by the SINDRUMII experiment operated in different configurations: B(− → e− on Ti) < 1.7 × 10−12 at 90% C.L. [34], B(− → e− on Au) < 3 × 10−13 at 90% C.L. [35]. From the experimental point of view, this decay has only one detectable particle in the final state. This has the consequence that only physical processes contribute to the background. The accidental coincidence of events in the target, which was the source of the uncorrelated background in the previous two LFV processes, has no influence in this case. The background rate is expected to increase only linearly with the muon stopping rate, thus offering better perspectives to the − → e− conversion searches than for the other two. High energy electrons may originate from the MDIO or from the radiative muon capture (RMC, − N → N∗ ), often called muon-decay related background. The radiative pion capture (RPC, − N → X), and the beam contamination by electrons are examples of beam related background. The first background class can be reduced mainly by improving the detector resolution, while the second has to be prevented by searching for the signal in a high purity environment. The electron momentum spectra, measured by the SINDRUM-II detector during the − → e− conversion search on gold, is shown in Fig. 2 for three different beam configurations.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
61
Fig. 2. The electron momentum spectra measured with: + to measure the detector resolution, − to evaluate the RPC background and − for the − → e− search. Data were collected with different lifetimes. The expected momentum distribution for signal events is also shown.
The MECO project at BNL [36] has been proposed to search for − → e− conversion with a single event sensitivity on the Branching ratio of 2×10−17 . This would correspond to an improvement of four orders of magnitude improvement with respect to the SINDRUM-II experiment. The project requires a high-intensity muon beam (1011 /s), operated in pulsed mode. A curved superconducting solenoid is used to select the muon momentum and to reduce the beam contamination. Muons are stopped in a series of thin targets and the e− momentum is measured with a resolution of 900 KeV/c, dominated by the multiple scattering in the target. A schematic drawing of the MECO project is presented in Fig. 3. The primary proton beam has to be operated in a pulsed mode with a challenging extinction factor of 109 between the beam “off” and the beam “on” periods. The − → e− conversion can be searched for only during the beam “off” periods to ensure the adequate beam related background suppression. Letters of intent for an even more ambitious project have been presented to the J-PARC scientific committee in Japan. The PRISM beam line [37] coupled to the PRIME [38] detector will aim at a sensitivity of 5×10−19 on the branching ratio. PRISM is designed to deliver a high intensity muon beam of 1011 –1012 /s, with a narrow momentum spread of ±2%, a kinetic energy of ≈ 20 MeV and a negligible contamination. The layout of the PRISM beam line is presented in Fig. 4. It is planned to achieve the aforementioned features by using a fixed field alternating gradient (FFAG) accelerator ring. The FFAG will operate a rotation of the muon energy-time phase space, thus reducing the momentum-spread down to the quoted value. With such a performing beam, the PRIME muon target could be made thinner by a factor of ten with respect to that used in the MECO experiment. The resulting electron multiple scattering in the target is estimated to contribute to the momentum resolution only for ≈ 100 KeV/c, thus helping to reduce the MDIO background. The full PRISM beam line at J-PARC is not yet approved, but the PRISM FFAG was granted funding by Osaka University in 2003. The ring construction will last 5 years, and technical issues related to the FFAG operation will be addressed. 2.4. Beams and conclusions A concise summary of the beam requirements for the next generation of experiments aiming at high sensitivity searches for rare muon decays is presented in Table 6.
62
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Straw Tracker
Muon Stopping Target
Muon Beam Stop
Superconducting Transport Solenoid (2.5 T – 2.1 T)
Crystal Calorimeter
Superconducting Detector Solenoid (2.0 T – 1.0 T)
Superconducting Production Solenoid (5.0 T – 2.5 T)
Collimators Primary proton beam
Fig. 3. The schematic view of the MECO project.
PRODUCTION TARGET PRIMARY PROTON
MATCHING
PROTON BEAM DUMP
CAPTURE SOLENOID
SECTION SOLENOID
INJECTION SYSTEM
5M
FFAG RING RF CAVITY
EJECTION SYSTEM
Fig. 4. The layout of the PRISM muon source.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
63
Table 6 Beam requirement for the next generation of high-sensitivity searches for muon lepton number violating processes Experiment
N
+ → + →
1017
e+ e− e+
e+ − → e− pulsed − → e− continuos
1017 1021 1020
p < 30 < 30 < 80 < 80
p /p
BR
Ioff /Ion
T
T
< 10 < 10 <5 <5
10−15
DC beam DC beam 10−10 DC beam
n/a n/a < 100 ns n/a
n/a n/a > 1 s n/a
10−15 10−19 10−19
N is the time-integrated number of stopped . In pulsed beams, T is the burst duration, while T is the beam repetition period. Ioff /Ion is the proton extinction factor between the measurement period (∼T /2) and the burst.
The main conclusion of this summary is that the physics potential of new high-intensity low energy muon beams is very promising. Muon physics may provide us with crucial information regarding the theory that lies beyond the Standard Model. In particular, rare processes that violate muon number conservation in many extensions of the Standard Model may occur at rates close to the current experimental bounds. Furthermore, these searches are free from any possible background induced by the Standard Model so that any signal would be an unambiguous evidence of new physics. We also emphasise that all the different processes + → e+ e− e+ , + → e+ and − → e− in nuclei, should be pursued. Indeed, the relative rates of the different modes provide a powerful tool to single out the physics beyond the Standard Models. A future high-sensitivity + → e+ e− e+ search would be limited by background due to accidentals. A substantial detector improvement is needed to exploit future high-intensity beams. No new experimental searches have been proposed so far. A new + → e+ search with a Single Event Sensitivity of ∼5 × 10−14 has been approved, and the MEG detector is currently under construction. The collaboration is planning to start the data collection in 2006. This experiment is making use of the most intense -beam presently available. The main limitation to the improvements in sensitivity comes from the background of uncorrelated events. However, the − → e− conversion in nuclei is not limited by this kind of background, which is why the search for this channel may benefit from new high-intensity pulsed beams. The MECO collaboration is planning to build a dedicated beam line and a detector at BNL to search for − → e− conversion in nuclei with a sensitivity of ∼10−16 . The key feature of this project is the pulsed beam with a large proton extinction factor in between the pulses. A more ambitious project, named PRISM/PRIME, of even larger sensitivity, has been proposed at the J-PARC accelerator complex. 3. Muon electric and magnetic dipole moments 3.1. Muon dipole moments The muon dipole moments have historically been important tools for shedding light on the fine structure of QED and on the Standard Model in general, as well as relevant benchmarks for possible extensions of the Model itself. The recent discrepancy between the theoretical value of the magnetic dipole moment (g − 2), and the experimental value (measured with an impressive precision of 0.5 ppm at the Brookhaven storage ring), has raised new interest in the field. The current status of the experimental situation is reviewed and the possible benefits of increasing the muon source intensity is examined, both for the magnetic and for the electric dipole moment. 3.1.1. Muon magnetic dipole moment The muon magnetic dipole moment is expressed in terms of the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon a , or simply the anomaly, as dM () ≡ =
g e2 e2 ≡ (1 + a ) . 2 2m 2m
The Dirac equation tells us that for spin one-half point-like particles, g ≡ 2, therefore a = 0.
(3.1)
64
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
γ
+
g=2
µ
α π
Dirac
γ ∗ µ µ
µ∗ γ
+
c
α 2 2( π )
Schwinger
µ
γ ∗ µ e− µ∗
+ ..
γ e+ γ
Fig. 5. A schematic of the first few terms in the QED expansion for the muon. The vacuum polarization term shown is one of the five contributing to the ( /)2 order.
γ
γ
µ
γ
µ H
µ e H
(a)
(c)
H
µ H
(b)
γ
γ
H H
(d)
(e)
µ
Fig. 6. The hadronic contributions to the muon anomaly. The dominant contribution comes from (a). The hadronic light-by-light contribution is shown in (e).
Radiative corrections, like the ones shown in Fig. 5, modify this value. The dominant contribution comes from QED, QED and a is written as an expansion of /, with one diagram for the first order correction, (second order in the electric charge) five diagrams for the second order, 40 for the third order and 891 for the fourth order: aQED = C1
+ C2
2
+ C3
3
+ ···.
(3.2)
Contributions up to fourth order have been evaluated, both for the muon and for the electron anomaly, while the fifth order term has only been estimated [39]. QED QED A recent evaluation [40] of a is a = 116 584 718.8 (0.3) (0.4) × 10−11 . Additional contributions to a include hadronic loops and electroweak terms: a (SM) = a (QED) + a (Had) + a (Weak).
(3.3)
The dominant theoretical error comes from the evaluation of the hadronic loops shown in Fig. 6. In particular, the largest contribution is from loop (a) in Fig. 6, which cannot be determined directly from the theory, but has to rely on the experimental measurement of the hadronic cross section to which it is linked by the dispersion integral: ∞ 1 aHAD,LO = 3 dsK(s)(0) (s) (3.4) 4 4m2 where (0) (s) is the total cross section for the e+ e− annihilation into any hadronic state. Here careful treatment of final state radiative corrections has to be considered. Ref. [40] reports a compilation of values for a evaluated with different prescriptions for the integral. They are all in agreement, and a typical value is a = 116 591 845 (69) × 10−10 (0.6 ppm). Somewhat higher values are obtained if data are used in the evaluation of the hadronic contribution. However, there is a standard agreement not to use data until the discrepancy with the more direct method using e+ e− cross section has been settled. A significant difference between the experimental value and this Standard Model prediction would signal the presence of New Physics, like lepton substructure or supersymmetry. The technique used to measure a with a precision below
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
65
4 Billion Positrons with E> 2 GeV 107 45-100 µs
Number of Positrons/149ns
106
100-200 µs 200-300 µs
10 5
300-400 µs
104
400-500 µs 500-600 µs
10 3
600-700 µs
10 2
700-800 µs 800-850 µs
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Time µs
Fig. 7. The time spectrum of positrons with energy greater than 2.0 GeV from the year 2000 run. The endpoint energy is 3.1 GeV. The time interval for each of the diagonal “wiggles” is given on the right.
the ppb level is well known and is based on the fact that, if a > 0, the spin precesses faster than the momentum vector when a muon travels transversely to a magnetic field. The difference between the two precession frequencies is given by a = −
e 1 × E . a B − a − 2 mc −1
(3.5)
The term proportional to the electric field vanishes if = 29.3, which defines the muon momentum p = 3.094 GeV/c in the storage ring. As can be seen from the previous equation, both a and B must be known to a precision better than 0.5 ppb in order to evaluate a with the required precision. The state of the art in this technique has been reached by the BNL E821 experiment which has measured the value of a with impressive precision [41]. Polarized muons were obtained from the end point decay of pions produced by the AGS beam. The AGS operated at 24 GeV/c, and provided eight proton bunches per 2.6-s cycle, each with 5 × 1012 protons. The proton bunches were directed onto a nickel target, and a secondary pion beam (108 particles per bunch with p 3.1 GeV/c), was transported along a 116 m beam line to the muon storage ring. The ring had a radius of 7 m and the electrons (positrons) from the muon decay were collected in 24 lead/scintillating fibre calorimeters on the inside of the storage ring. The positron arrival time was fitted in the time interval 50–600 s, corresponding to six muon lifetimes (the first half lifetime is not used because of the background induced by captured pions). The resulting plot for the year 2000 run using positive muons, is shown in Fig. 7. The systematic error in the measurement of the spin precession frequency a is at the level of 0.2 ppm. It is dominated by beam effects (betatron oscillations, muon loss, AGS background, . . .) and also by pile-up. The magnetic field value was obtained from NMR measurements of the free proton resonance frequency p . A trolley with 17 NMR probes was used to measure the field throughout the muon storage ring. The trolley probes were calibrated to an accuracy of 0.15 ppm with respect to a standard spherical H2 O probe. The total systematic error on the measurement of p was 0.24 ppm, dominated by the probe calibration and by temperature effects. The final value
66
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
published by the experiment is: a = 11659208(6) × 10−10 (0.5 ppm), where positive and negative muons are combined together. This value can be used as a benchmark for the Standard Model and for physics beyond the Standard Model. In particular, the effect of a possible supersymmetric particle can easily be at the level of 0.1–1 ppm, for smuon masses of the order of the TeV. Interestingly, the predicted value of a is 2.7, that is 2 ppm smaller than the observed value, where the theoretical and experimental errors are comparable. This result has regenerated great interest in both the experimental measurements and in the theoretical predictions. Given this situation, a new experiment which aims to measure the muon anomaly at the 0.1 ppm level would be very useful. The current indetermination in the hadronic contribution does not, apparently, further reduce experimental error. In order to improve the current measurement of a by a factor of 5–7, an increase by a factor 25–50 in statistics is required. The flux of protons in the AGS ring at BNL was at the level of few Tp (Teraprotons)/s producing a beam (50% are muons), injected in the storage ring with an efficiency of 7%. In a new machine, all these parameters need to be improved in order to improve statistics and to lower the systematic error related to the background rejection. These requirements, although challenging, can be reasonably met in a high intensity proton machine. For this reason, a letter of intent has been submitted to J-PARC, in which a new g − 2 experiment is proposed. As an intermediate step, in August 2004 a new proposal (P969) was submitted to BNL as an update of the current E821 experiment. The key to the new measurement is the increase in the observed muon flux. Part of the gain in statistics can be obtained by increasing the number of quadrupoles in the straight decay section. Further gains, both in statistics and in systematics, can be obtained by using pions of momentum 5.32 GeV/c, which produce muons of the magic momentum of 3.094 GeV/c through their backward decay. The main advantage with respect to the E821 approach is that the mismatch in momentum is so large that no pions will make the final bend into the storage ring. In E821, the hadrons background at injection resulted in the first 50 s of the time spectrum of electrons from muon decay not being used in the fit (see Fig. 7). As stated above, the residual pion background was also one of the major sources of the systematic error on a . This background is eliminated with the new approach. In order to eliminate an important systematic effect in the field determination, the storage magnet needs to be kept at a constant temperature, within a few degrees. The P969 proposal aims to half the current experimental error on a . 3.1.2. Muon Electric Dipole Moment The existence of an EDM for an elementary particle would violate parity and time reversal symmetry. In the Standard Model, the EDM is strongly suppressed by the fact that there is only one CP violating phase in the CKM matrix. The value of the electron EDM in the framework of the SM has been evaluated in [42] to be de − 1.5 × 10−38 e cm, 11 orders of magnitude smaller than the current limit. No evaluation exists for the muon EDM, but it should scale linearly with the lepton mass. So it is expected to be d − 1.5 × 10−36 e cm, which is 17 orders of magnitude smaller than the current experimental bound. Although this is only an estimate of order of magnitude, it is safe to say that any detection of an EDM, and in particular a EDM, different from zero, would be a signal for new physics. This signal is indeed expected in many extensions of the Standard Model, some of which also predict possible large deviations from the simple scaling law [43]. In particular, as noted in the above section, the recent result from the BNL g − 2 experiment has also raised new interest in the EDM measurement. To measure the EDM experimentally, the particle must be in an electric field which exerts a torque on the electric dipole, thus inducing an observable precession. Due to Schiff’s theorem, a charged particle cannot rest in equilibrium in a stable electric field whose average value is not zero. Thus the EDM has been tested for neutral particles (neutrons) and for electrons immerged in the nuclear field of heavy paramagnetic atoms, like Tl [44], or in heavy diatomic molecules, like YbF [45] or PbO [46]. A particularly elegant approach to a direct measurement of the EDM, which exploits the ideas that drove the g − 2 in a vertical magnetic field measurements, is to exploit a muon storage ring in which the muons rotate with velocity B. The electric field in the muon rest frame is given by E = c × B and the EDM precesses around the radial electric field.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
67
This technique has already been used both in the CERN [47] and in the BNL [48] g − 2 experiments to set limits on the EDM, which combine to: |d | < 2.7 × 10−19 e cm (95%C.L.). This limit is far from the limit on the electron EDM, which is 1.6 × 10−27 e cm (95%C.L.) [44], although it must be said that, in order to extract the electron EDM, a deep understanding of the atomic and molecular levels is required. A competitive measurement of the EDM requires an improvement of at least four orders of magnitude over the current limit. The measurements performed at the CERN and BNL storage rings suffered from a major systematic effect due to the overlap of the EDM with the standard g − 2 precession. The g − 2 precession vector a is oriented perpendicularly to the orbit plane, while the d precession is radial. Therefore, the effect of the EDM is to tilt the precession plane with respect to the orbit plane and it results in a vertical oscillation of the emitted electrons. However, the maximum vertical displacement occurs when the muon spin points radially outward or inward. In these two extremes, the decay electrons follow completely different decay paths to reach the detectors, and it is impossible to push down the systematics to a level lower than one percent. The limit on EDM corresponds to e /a 10−2 , where e is the precession due to the EDM. This major limitation could be overcome if a dedicated experiment for the EDM were to be setup. In this case, the g − 2 “background” could be avoided by working in a configuration of E and B, which would freeze the precession due to a . the angular In the presence of both electric and magnetic fields oriented orthogonally to the muon velocity , frequency of muon spin precession relative to the momentum is given by
e × E 1 f E =− − a a B + 2 + +×B , (3.6) m c 2 c −1 e2 where a = (g − 2)/2 and f is, in analogy to g, the EDM expressed in units e2/4mc, i.e. d E = f 2mc 2. In the “standard” g − 2 experiments, the term proportional to f is neglected and the muon energy is fixed at the “magic” ( = 29.3), so that the coefficient of the ˆ × Eˆ term vanishes out. In a dedicated EDM experiment, however, E, is chosen so that the angular frequency due to the magnetic moment is zero, namely: a combination of B, 1 × E a B + 2 − a = 0. (3.7) c −1
This implies the choice of a radial E field of magnitude: E aBc2 . With this choice, the spin precession is
e f E e f =−
− +×B × B, m 2 c m 2
(3.8)
(3.9)
where the last approximation is justified by the fact that, for any reasonable value of the radial electric field E and of × B term. The net effect is a the muon energy, the applied E-Field is far smaller than the motional E-field from the precession around a radial axis which results in a vertical asymmetry in the observed number of decay electrons. The statistical precision with which this asymmetry can be measured is [49] √ 2 = √ , (e/m)BAP N where B is the magnitude of the magnetic field, A is the decay asymmetry of the electrons from the muon decay, P is the muon polarization and N = εd N is the number of detected electrons, which is the number of muons decaying in the storage ring times the detection efficiency. To minimize the statistical error one should maximize the product B and,
68
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
of course, the number of detected electrons. The boost factor and B are limited by the radial electric field practically achievable, as expressed in Eq. (3.8). With this limit, a possible choice of parameters is E = 2 MV/m, B = 0.25T, = 5. This results in a muon storage ring with a radius of curvature of 7 m. To reach a sensitivity of 10−24 e cm in the EDM, assuming A = 0.3 and a detection efficiency εd = 1, the number of muons injected in the storage ring must be N P 2 1016 . This requires a facility with large, high-energy, pulsed proton flux that is required along with a high repetition rate. This driver should be used in connection to a high flux muon source, which should produce sufficient numbers of polarized muons to reach the proposed sensitivity in a one-year run. An example of such facility is the proposed PRISM muon source at J-PARC. Recently a similar technique has been proposed to measure the EDM of the deuteron with a storage ring. The main difference with the technique described above is that, instead of using a fixed radial electric field to freeze the (g − 2) procession, the radiofrequency is modulated in phase with this procession. The technique is currently under development, and it seems promising also for muon EDM measurements. The Sorage Ring EDM Collaboration home page is: http://www.bnl.gov/edu/ 4. Measurement of three-family neutrino mixing and search for CP violation 4.1. Neutrino oscillations The experimental evidence for neutrino oscillations collected in the last six years represents a major discovery in modern particle physics. The oscillation phenomenon allows the measurements of fundamental parameters of the Standard Model, and provides the first insight beyond the electroweak scale [50]. In addition, they are important for many fields of astrophysics and cosmology, and they open the possibility of studying CP violation in the leptonic sector. Neutrino flavour oscillations can be described in terms of three mass eigenstates 1 ,2 , 3 with mass values m1 , m2 and m3 that are connected to the flavour eigenstates e , and by a mixing matrix U, usually parameterized as ⎞ ⎛ c13 s12 s13 e−iCP c13 c12 ⎟ ⎜ (4.1) U ( 12 , 23 , 13 , CP ) = ⎝ −c23 s12 − s13 s23 c12 eiCP c23 c12 − s13 s23 s12 eiCP c13 s23 ⎠ s23 s12 − s13 c23 c12 eiCP
−s23 c12 − s13 c23 s12 eiCP
c13 c13
where the short-form notation sij ≡ sin ij , cij ≡ cos ij is used. As a result, the neutrino oscillation probability depends on: • 3 mixing angles, 12 , 23 , 13 , • 2 mass differences: m212 = m22 − m21 , m223 = m23 − m22 , • 1 CP violating phase CP . Additional phases would be present in case neutrinos were Majorana particles, but this fact does not influence neutrino flavour oscillations. Furthermore, the neutrino mass hierarchy and the ordering in the coupling of mass eigenstates with flavour eigenstates, can be fixed by measuring the sign of m223 . In a vacuum, the oscillation probability between two neutrino flavours , is P ( → ) = −4
k>j
jk
Re[W ]sin2
m2j k L 4E
±2
k>j
jk
Im[W ]sin2
m2j k L 2E
,
(4.2)
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
69
where = e, , , j = 1, 2, 3 and W = U j U∗j U ∗k Uk . In the case of only two neutrino flavour oscillations, it can be written as jk
P ( → ) = sin2 2 sin2
1.27m2 (eV2 ) · L(km) . E (GeV)
(4.3)
Therefore two experimental parameters are relevant for neutrino oscillations: the neutrino energy E and the baseline L (distance of the neutrino source from the detector). In the oscillation formula they are combined into the L/E ratio. When neutrinos pass through matter, the oscillation probability is perturbed [51] depending on sign(m223 ) [52]. Three claims of having observed neutrino flavour oscillations come from atmospheric neutrinos, solar neutrinos and beam dump experiments. Clear evidence of disappearance of atmospheric neutrinos through a strong zenithal modulation and an anomalous value of the ratio of electron to muon neutrino events is reported by the Super-Kamiokande experiment [53], a result well supported by the Soudan2 [54] and Macro [55] experiments. Furthermore, Super-Kamiokande reported an oscillation signature by directly measuring the L/E parameter [56], and detected indirect evidence of appearance, ruling out at 99% C.L. possible pure oscillations into sterile neutrinos [57]. It follows that the most likely channel is an almost pure → transition, connected with the m2 and m3 mass eigenstates. Central values are m223 = 2.1 × 10−3 eV2 , sin2 2 23 = 1 and at 90% C.L. 1.5 × 10−3 eV2 < m223 < 3.4 × 10−3 eV2 , sin2 2 23 > 0.92 [58]. Mechanisms other than neutrino oscillations, such as neutrino decay or decoherence [59], are almost completely ruled out by the experimental data. The long-baseline experiment K2K published evidence for disappearance in a neutrino beam with a mean energy E 1.2 GeV sent to the Super-Kamiokande detector at a baseline of 250 km [60]. The experimental result: (sin2 2 23 , m223 ) = (1.0, 2.8 × 10−3 eV2 ), 1.9 × 10−3 < m223 < 3.5 × 10−3 eV2 at 90% C.L., is in agreement with the atmospheric data. In Solar neutrino studies, a counting deficit with respect to the Solar Model predictions is observed in four experiments which took data at different thresholds: Homestake [61], Gallex-GNO [62], Sage [63] and Super-Kamiokande [64,65]. The latter experiment also measured the energy shape distortions and the day-night effects. The spectacular comparison of the charged current, elastic scattering and neutral current rates in the SNO experiment [66] allowed convincing evidence for , appearance, and a first determination of the oscillation parameters. The reactor experiment KamLAND, running at the solar m2 scale, reported evidence for ¯ e disappearance [67] in perfect agreement with the solar data. A combined analysis of solar plus reactor data shows that the most likely channel is a transition of e into other active flavours ( and ) whose oscillation probability is modulated by m212 , central values are [68]: −5 2 m212 = 7.9+0.6 −0.5 × 10 eV
tan2 12 = 0.40+0.10 −0.07 . A further indication of ¯ → ¯ e oscillations with a m2 of 0.3–20 eV2 comes from the beam dump LSND experiment detecting a 4 excess of ¯ e interactions in a neutrino beam produced by + decays at rest where the ¯ e component is strongly suppressed (∼7.8 × 10−4 ) [69]. The KARMEN experiment [70], with a very similar technique but with a lower sensitivity (a factor 10 less for the lower m2 ), and the NOMAD experiment at WANF of CERN SPS [71] (for m2 > 10 eV2 ) do not confirm the result, excluding a large part of the allowed region of the oscillation parameters. The LSND result doesn’t fit the overall picture of neutrino oscillation and several non-standard explanations, for instance sterile neutrinos, have been put forward to solve this experimental conflict. The MiniBooNE experiment at FNAL, presently taking data, is designed to settle this puzzle with a 5 sensitivity [72]. The 13 mixing angle represents the link between the solar and the atmospheric neutrino oscillations. Both solar and atmospheric neutrino data are compatible with 13 = 0 within the experimental sensitivity. The best experimental constraint to 13 comes from the reactor experiment Chooz [73]: sin2 2 13 0.14 at 90 % C.L. for m223 =2.5×10−3 eV2 . The measurement of the mixing angle parameters can be performed in long baseline oscillation experiments with suitable neutrino beams produced at accelerators, since this technique offers a better control over the neutrino flux. In particular, three parameters which are still to be measured, the mixing angle 13, the CP phase CP and sign(m223 ) can be determined by detecting sub-leading → e oscillations, as discussed in Section 4.3.
70
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 7 Main parameters for present long baseline neutrino beams Proton momentum (GeV/c)
L (km)
E (GeV)
pot/yr (1019 )
KEK PS FNAL NUMI CERN CNGS
12 120 400
250 735 732
1.5 3 17.4
2 20–34 4.5–7.6
νe / 5 GeV / 10 p.o.t.
10 3 10
7
7
νµ / 2 GeV / 10 p.o.t.
Neutrino facility
10 2
1 10 0
25
50
75
Neutrino energy (GeV)
100
0
25
50
75
100
Neutrino energy (GeV)
Fig. 8. Muon and electron neutrino flux spectra of the CNGS beam at the Gran Sasso Laboratories.
4.2. Present generation of long baseline experiments Over the next 5 years, the present generation of oscillation experiments at accelerators with long-baseline beams (Table 7), K2K at KEK [60], MINOS [74] at the NUMI beam from FNAL [75] and ICARUS [76] and OPERA [77] at the CNGS beam from CERN [78], are expected to confirm the atmospheric evidence of oscillations, and measure sin2 2 23 and |m223 | within 10–15% of accuracy if |m223 | > 10−3 eV2 . K2K and MINOS are looking for neutrino disappearance, by measuring the survival probability as a function of neutrino energy while ICARUS and OPERA will search for evidence of interactions in a beam, the final proof of → oscillations. K2K completed the collection of data at the end of 2004, while MINOS started taking data at the beginning of 2005. Recently the Minos Collaboration confirmed the atmospheric oscillation and reported a mean m223 = 3.05 × 10−3 eV2 in agreement with the K2K result. CNGS is expected to start operations by the second half of 2006. In all these facilities, conventional muon neutrino beams are produced through the decay of and K mesons generated by a high energy proton beam hitting needle-shaped light targets. Positive (negative) mesons are sign-selected and focused (defocused) by large acceptance magnetic lenses into a long evacuated decay tunnel where ’s (¯ ’s) are generated. In the case of positive charge selection, the beam has typically a contamination of ¯ at a few percent level (from the decay of the residual − , K − and K 0 ) and ∼1% of e and ¯ e coming from three-body K ± , K 0 decays and decays. The precision on the evaluation of the intrinsic e to contamination is limited by the knowledge of the and K production in the primary proton beam target. Hadroproduction measurements at 400 and 450 GeV/c performed with the NA20 [79] and SPY [80] experiments at the CERN SPS provided results with 5–7% intrinsic systematic uncertainties. The CNGS beam has been optimized for the → appearance search. The beam-line design was accomplished on the basis of previous experience with the WANF beam at CERN SPS [81]. The expected muon neutrino flux at the Gran Sasso site will have an average energy of 17.4 GeV and ∼0.6% e contamination for E < 40 GeV (Fig. 8). Due to the long baseline (L = 732 km), the contribution to neutrino beam from the K 0 and mesons produced in the reinteraction processes will be strongly reduced with respect to the WANF [82].
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
71
The e / ratio is expected to be known within ∼3% systematic uncertainty [83]. Current long-baseline experiments with conventional neutrino beams can look for → e even if they are not optimized for 13 studies. MINOS at NuMI is expected to reach a sensitivity of sin2 2 13 = 0.08 [74] integrating 14 × 1020 protons on target (pot) in five years according to the FNAL proton plan evolution [84]. The main limitation of MINOS is the poor electron identification efficiency of the detector. ICARUS and OPERA [76,77] can reach a 90% C.L. combined sensitivity sin2 2 13 = 0.030 (m223 ) = 2.5 × 10−3 eV2 , convoluted to CP and matter effects), a factor ∼5 better than Chooz. This sensitivity can be obtained with a five year exposure to the CNGS beam at a nominal intensity for shared operation 4.5× 1019 pot/yr [85]. Depending on the CP value and matter effects (sign(m223 )), these sensitivities can be reduced by a factor ∼1.5 [86]. According to the CERN PS and SPS upgrade studies [87], the CNGS beam intensity could be improved by a factor 1.5, allowing for more sensitive neutrino oscillation searches for ICARUS and OPERA experiments. It is worth mentioning that the sensitivity on 13 measurement of the current long-baseline experiments with conventional neutrino beams, like NUMI and CNGS, will be limited by the power of the proton source which determines the neutrino flux and the event statistics, by the not optimized value of L/E and by the presence of the e intrinsic beam contamination and its related systematics. This is particularly true for CNGS where the neutrino energy, optimized to overcome the kinematic threshold for production and to detect the decay products, is about ten times higher than the optimal value for 13 searches. Another approach to search for non-vanishing 13 is to look at ¯ e disappearance using nuclear reactors as neutrino sources. A follow-up of Chooz, Double Chooz [88], has been proposed for commencement in 2008. It will have a two detector setup capable of pushing systematic error down to 0.6% and reaching a sensitivity on sin2 2 13 0.024 (90% C.L., m223 = 2.5 × 10−3 ) in a three-year run. A summary of 13 sensitivities for the present generation of experiments is reported in Table 8 and in Fig. 9. The same data are reported in Fig. 14 as a function of time, as predicted by the schedule reported in the experimental proposals. 4.3. The future experimental challenge: the sub-leading → oscillations The parameters 13 , CP and sign(m223 ) can be extracted by measuring sub-leading → e oscillations. The e disappearance experiments, like reactor experiments, can address 13 searches but are not sensitive to CP and sign(m223 ), while e → transitions could provide similar information of → e transitions but they are experimentally very challenging. The → e transition probability can be parameterized as [89]: 2 2a 2 2 2 2 m13 L 2 × 1± (1 − 2s13 ) P ( → e ) = 4c13 s13 s23 sin 4E m213 2 + 8c13 s12 s13 s23 (c12 c23 cos CP − s12 s13 s23 ) cos 2 ∓ 8c13 c12 c23 s12 s13 s23 sin CP sin
m223 L m213 L m212 L sin sin 4E 4E 4E
m223 L m213 L m212 L sin sin 4E 4E 4E
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 + 4s12 c13 {c13 c23 + s12 s23 s13 − 2c12 c23 s12 s23 s13 cos CP } sin 2 2 2 ∓ 8c12 s13 s23 cos
m223 L m213 L aL 2 sin (1 − 2s13 ). 4E 4E 4E
m212 L 4E (4.4)
The first part of this parameterization contains terms driven by 13 , the second and third contain CP even and odd terms, respectively, and the fourth is driven by √ the solar parameters. The last addendum parameterizes matter effects developed at the first order where a[eV2 ] = ±2 2GF ne E = 7.6 × 10−5 [g/cm3 ] E [GeV]. The CP odd term and matter effects change sign by changing neutrinos with antineutrinos. The → e transitions are dominated by the solar term. At the distance defined by the m223 parameter, they are driven by the 13 term which is proportional to sin2 2 13 . For sin2 2 13 ≈ 10−3 , the “solar neutrino oscillation regime” once more becomes the dominant transition mechanism, limiting further improvements of the experimental
72
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 8 The expected 90% C.L. sensitivity on 13 measurements for the present and next generation long-baseline experiments with conventional beams for m223 ∼2.5 × 10−3 eV2 (CP = 0) Experiment
fid. mass (kt)
sin2 2 13
13
MINOS ICARUS OPERA Chooz
5.0 2.4 1.8 0.012
0.080 0.04 0.06 0.140
8.1◦ 5.8◦ 7.8◦ 11◦
2 23
2
MINOS
The result of the reactor experiment Chooz is also shown as a comparison.
2.5
CN
GS
T2K
Co
mb
ine
d
2
sin 2θ13 Fig. 9. Expected sensitivity on 13 mixing angle (matter effects and CP violation effects not included) for MINOS, ICARUS (2.4 kt fiducial mass) and OPERA combined at nominal CNGS and for the next T2K experiment, compared to the Chooz exclusion plot.
sensitivity to 13 . Moreover, P ( → e ) could be strongly influenced by the unknown value of CP and sign(m223 ). The contribution of the different terms of Eq. (4.4) is shown in Fig. 10 as a function of the baseline length for 1 GeV neutrinos in the solar oscillation region (left), and in the atmospheric oscillation region (right). The measurement of 13 represents the first mandatory ingredient for investigation of the CP leptonic violation in the → e transitions and for the mass hierarchy determination. The detection of the CP phase will require a major experimental effort because of its intrinsic difficulty, relying on the need of disentangling several contributions to → e oscillation probability. Leptonic CP violation searches look for different behavior of neutrino and antineutrino appearance probabilities through the asymmetry: ACP =
P ( → e ) − P (¯ → ¯ e ) P ( → e ) + P (¯ → ¯ e )
(4.5)
The effect of the CP violation will be proportional to 1/ sin 13 , while P ( → e ) is proportional to sin2 2 13 . For large values of 13 , ACP will be small even if characterized by a large number of oscillated events. Systematic errors would limit the experimental sensitivity. For small values of 13 , event statistics and background rates would be the ultimate limitation to the search.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
73
Total
0.01 0.7
0.5
p (νµνe )
p (νµνe )
0.008 0.006
θ13 CPodd
0.004
0.3
θ13
0.002
Solar
0.1 5000
10000
15000 L (km)
20000
25000
0
CPeven 0
100
200
300 L (km)
400
500
600
Fig. 10. Sketch of P ( → e ) as function of the baseline computed for monochromatic neutrinos of 1 GeV in the solar baseline regime for CP = 0 (left) and in the atmospheric baseline regime for CP = −/2 (right), where the different terms of Eq. (4) are displayed. The following oscillation parameters were used in both cases: sin2 2 13 = 0.01, sin2 2 12 = 0.8, m223 = 2.5 × 10−3 eV2 , m212 = 7 × 10−5 eV2 .
Matter effects also produce differences between P ( → e ) and P (¯ → ¯ e ). They depend on the baseline and the neutrino energy, and could increase or decrease the overall probabilities depending on sign(m223 ). At baselines of ∼100 km, these effects are negligible while at ∼700 km they can be up to ∼30% of the probabilities in vacuum. The richness of the → e transition is also its weakness. It will be very difficult for pioneering experiments to extract all the genuine parameters unambiguously. Correlations are present between 13 and CP [90]. Furthermore, in the absence of information about the sign of m223 [91,92] and because of the approximate [ 23 , /2 − 23 ] symmetry for the atmospheric angle [93], additional clone solutions arise. In general, the measurement of P ( → e ) and P (¯ → ¯ e ) will result in eight allowed regions of the parameter space, the so-called eightfold-degeneracy [92]. The 13 searches look for experimental evidence of e in excess of what is expected from the solar terms. These measurements will be experimentally difficult because the Chooz limit on the ¯ e disappearance, 13 < 11◦ for m223 2.5 × 10−3 eV2 , translates into a → e appearance probability less than 10%. This happens at the appearance maximum in a high-energy muon neutrino beam. Furthermore, as already pointed out, the → e experimental sensitivity with conventional beams is limited by an unavoidable e beam contamination of about 1%. The to oscillations, with E above the mass production threshold, generate background due to a significant number of charged current interactions where about 20% of ’s decay into electrons. Finally, neutral pions in both neutral current or charged current interactions can fake an electron providing also a possible background for the e ’s. Therefore the measurement of 13 mixing angle and the investigation of the leptonic CP violation will require: • neutrino beams with high performance in terms of intensity, purity and low associated systematics. Event statistics, background rates and systematic errors will play a decisive role in detecting e appearance; • the use of detectors of unprecedent mass, granularity and resolution. Again event statistics is the main concern, while high detector performances are necessary to keep the event backgrounds (as 0 from neutral current interactions, misidentified as e events) at a rate as low as possible; • ancillary experiments to measure the meson production (for the neutrino beam knowledge), the neutrino cross sections, the particle identification capability. The optimization of proton driver characteristics and the best possible estimate of the systematic errors will require this kind of dedicated experiment. The Harp hadroproduction experiment at CERN PS [94] took data for primary protons between 3 and 14.5 GeV in 2001 and 2002 with different target materials. These data contribute to the proton driver optimization, the determination of the K2K and MiniBooNE neutrino beam fluxes, and to the study of atmospheric neutrino interaction rates. The intrinsic limitations of conventional neutrino beams are overcome if the neutrino parents can be fully selected, collimated and accelerated to a given energy. This can be attempted within the lifetimes of the muon or of a
74
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 9 Comparison of the main features of the experimental techniques Detector technology
Water Cerenkov Magnetic iron calorimeter Nuclear emulsions (ECC) Liquid argon TPC Low Z calorimeter
Mass (kt)
50 5.4 1.8 0.6 → 3.0 30 (project)
Event by event id
e
OK
OK OK OK OK OK
OK OK OK
Magnetic field
energy (GeV)
OK External External
0.005–10 > 0.5 1–100 0.001–100 0.1–10
OK
beta- decaying ion. The resulting neutrino beams from the decays would then be pure and perfectly predictable. The first method will find application in Neutrino Factories [95,96], the second in BetaBeams [97]. However, the technical difficulties associated with developing and building these neutrino beams of novel conception, strongly suggest a middle term option. Such an option consists in optimizing the conventional beams produced by the new high-intensity proton machines, for → e oscillation searches. These optimized beams are called SuperBeams [89]. Different detection techniques of neutrino interactions based on water Cerenkov (WC), liquid Argon (LAr), Nuclear emulsions and calorimetry are available to build massive detectors according to the intrinsic neutrino beam characteristics, energy and composition as discussed in a following section. 4.4. Massive neutrino detectors Several experimental techniques have recently been exploited in high-energy neutrino detection, and new set-ups are under consideration to cope with the challenges of precision neutrino physics using accelerators. Compared with other high-energy detectors, they must offer unprecedented fiducial masses, instrumented with cheap and reliable active detector technologies that guarantee high granularity, good energy resolution and excellent particle identification capability. The most relevant technologies developed so far are discussed in the following section and summarized in Table 9. 4.4.1. Water Cerenkov detector Besides the observation of solar and supernovae neutrinos, the discovery of neutrino oscillations in the atmospheric sector represents another great success of the Cerenkov technique. The target material and the possibility of instrumenting only the surface of the vessel make these detectors relatively cheap, so that huge fiducial masses are conceivable. Charged tracks above the Cerenkov threshold emit about 390 photons/cm with a wavelength between 300 and 700 nm. Light attenuation in water, as measured in Super-Kamiokande, is 98 m [98]. Charged leptons are identified through the detection of their Cerenkov light. The identification of particles relies on the identification of the different features of the Cerenkov rings. A muon, which crosses the detector, scatters very little. Therefore, the associated ring has very sharp edges. Conversely, an electron scatters (showers) much more, producing rings with “fuzzy” edges. The total measured light gives an estimate of the lepton energy, while the time measurement provided by each photomultiplier determines the outgoing lepton direction and the position of the neutrino interaction vertex. By combining all this information, it is possible to fully reconstruct the energy, direction and flavour of the incoming neutrino. It is worth noting that the procedure discussed above is suitable only for quasi-elastic events (l n → l − p). Indeed, for non-quasi-elastic events there are other particles in the final state that carry a large energy fraction, which are either below the Cerenkov threshold or neutrals, resulting in a poor measurement of the total event energy. Furthermore, the presence of more than one particle above threshold produces more than one ring, spoiling the particle identification capability of the detector. In the SNO experiment, a Cerenkov detector using heavy water as target is employed for the detection of solar neutrinos. Besides the features discussed above, the SNO detector is also able to identify neutral current neutrino interactions [99] through the detection of the neutron produced in the reaction l d → l pn. Water Cerenkov is a mature technology that has already shown cost effectiveness and excellent performances at low neutrino energies. A detector with a fiducial mass as large as 20 times Super-Kamiokande [100,101] could be built and would be an optimal detector for neutrino beams with energies around or below 1 GeV. Furthermore, such a device
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
75
could represent the ultimate tool for proton decay searches, and for atmospheric neutrinos and supernovae neutrinos detection. 4.4.2. Magnetized iron calorimeter Magnetized iron calorimeters have been used since the 1970s when the HPWF experiment discovered neutrino induced charm-production [102]. Calorimeters consist of magnetized iron slabs and tracking detectors that act both as target and muon spectrometer. The main feature of these detectors is their excellent muon reconstruction (charge and momentum) and their high density (short interaction length) that minimizes the background due to pion and kaon decays, and to punch-through hadrons. The MINOS Collaboration has built a magnetized iron calorimeter to study neutrino oscillations at the atmospheric scale by using the NuMI long-baseline beam [74]. The detector is composed of 2.54 cm-thick steel planes interleaved with planes of 1 cm-thick and 4.1 cm-wide scintillator strips. The iron is magnetized to an average field of about 1.5 T. Simulations, as well as√test beam results, show that the energy resolution E/E of this tracking calorimeter √ is 55%/ E(GeV) and 23%/ E(GeV) for hadronic and electromagnetic showers respectively. This technology is particularly suited for the measurement of CC events, while the electron identification is rather poor. Therefore, magnetized iron calorimeters are planned for use in studying either appearance in a pure e beam or disappearance in a well known -beam. It is worth noting that the presence of the magnetic field is essential in order to tag the (antineutrino) in the final state when such a detector is exploited in a non-pure beam, i.e. conventional neutrino beams and neutrino factories (see Section 4.5.3). This technology has been proposed as a detector for atmospheric neutrinos, Monolith [103], and to study the so-called “golden channels” [104] e → and ¯ e → ¯ at a Neutrino Factory [105]. 4.4.3. Low Z calorimeter Unlike the iron calorimeters discussed in Section 4.2, low Z calorimeters allow a good identification and energy measurement of electrons produced in e charged current interactions. In fact, for this purpose one must sample showers more frequently than 1 X0 , and a magnetic field is not necessary. Another advantage of a low Z calorimeter is that, for a given sampling in units of radiation length, one can have up to a factor 3 more mass per readout plane with respect to iron calorimeters. This detector can discriminate between NC and e induced charged current events by looking at the longitudinal profile of the neutrino interaction, as neutral current events are likely to be much more spread out in the detector than e CC. Several active detectors (resistive plate chambers, streamer tubes, plastic and liquid scintillators) have been considered and are currently under investigation. The liquid scintillator technique has been proposed by the NOA experiment to search for → e oscillations in the NUMI Off-Axis beam-line [106]. The far detector will be composed solely of liquid scintillator encased in 15.7 m long cells. Each cell is 3.9 cm wide and 6 cm deep and it consists of a titanium dioxide-loaded PVC extrusion. 4.4.4. Hybrid emulsion detector The emulsion cloud chamber (ECC) concept (see references quoted in [77]), a modular structure made of a sandwich of passive material plates interspersed with emulsion layers, combines the high precision tracking capabilities of nuclear emulsions and the large mass achievable by employing metal plates as a target. By assembling a large quantity of such modules, it is possible to conceive and realize O(kt) fine-grained vertex detector optimized for the study of appearance. It has been adopted by the OPERA Collaboration for a long-baseline search of → oscillations at the CNGS beam through the direct detection of the ’s produced in charged current interactions. As an example of detection with ECC, we show in Fig. 11 one of the events observed in the DONUT experiment [107]. The basic element of the OPERA ECC is a “cell” made of a 1 mm thick lead plate followed by a thin emulsion film, which consists of 44 m-thick emulsion layers on either side of a 200 m plastic base. The number of activated grains in each emulsion layer (15–20) ensures redundancy in the measurement of particle trajectories, and allows the measurement of their energy loss that, in the non-relativistic regime, can help to distinguish between different mass hypotheses. Owing to the dense ECC structure and to the high granularity provided by the nuclear emulsions, the detector is also suited for electron and detection. The energy resolution for an electromagnetic shower is about 20%. Nuclear emulsions are able to measure the number of grains associated with each track. This allows a two-track separation at ∼1 m or even better. It is possible, therefore, to disentangle single-electron tracks from electron pairs coming from conversion in lead. This outstanding position resolution can also be used to measure the angle between different
76
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
F.L. = 4535 µm θkink = 93 mrad p > 2.9+1.5 GeV/c -0.8
F.L. = 280 µm θkink = 90 mrad p = 4.6+1.6 -0.4 GeV/c
pT > 0.27 +0.14 -0.07 GeV/c
pT = 0.41+0.14 -0.08 GeV/c
F.L. = 1800 µm θkink = 130 mrad p = 1.9+2.2 GeV/c -0.7
F.L. = 540 µm θkink = 13 mrad p > 21 +14 - 6 GeV/c
pT = 0.25 +0.29 -0.09 GeV/c
pT > 0.28 +0.19 -0.08 GeV/c
Fig. 11. Schematic view of a decay candidate observed in the ECC of the DONUT experiment. The neutrinos are incident from the left. The scales are indicated by the two perpendicular segments, which are depicted in the graphs. The vertical segment corresponds to 0.1 mm and the horizontal corresponds to 1.0 mm. The target material is shown by the bar at the bottom of each part of the figure representing steel (dashed), emulsion (cross-hatched) and plastic (no fill, no shading). Top left: candidate → ee ; top right: candidate → h X; bottom left: candidate → h X; bottom right: candidate → ee .
track segments with an accuracy of about 1 mrad. This allows the use of Coulomb scattering to evaluate the particle momentum with a resolution of about 20%, and to reconstruct the kinematical event variables. A lead-emulsion detector has been also proposed for operation in a Neutrino Factory to study the silver channel e → [108,109] (see Section 4.5.3). 4.4.5. Liquid argon time projection chamber The technology of the liquid argon time projection chamber (LAr TPC), first proposed by C. Rubbia in 1977 [110], was conceived as a new tool for a completely uniform imaging with high accuracy of very massive volumes, continuously sensitive and self-triggering. The operating principle of this kind of detector is rather simple. Any ionizing event (from a particle decay or interaction) taking place in the active LAr volume, which is maintained at a temperature T ∼89 K, produces ion-electron pairs. In the presence of a strong electric field (∼0.5 kV/cm), the ions and electrons drift. The (faster) electrons, are collected by the anode wires, which are arranged to form planes of different orientations located near the end of the sensitive volume. The space positions of the wires and the drift times provide the three-dimensional image of the track, while the charge collected on the wires provides precise information on the deposited energy. The detector developed by the ICARUS Collaboration [76], consists of a large vessel of liquid argon filled with three planes of wires strung along the different orientations. The device allows tracking, dE/dx measurements and
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
77
θ=158° 300 280
x (cm)
260
µ (E=329 MeV, range=1.3m)
240 220 200 θ =103°
180
e (E=30.5 MeV, range=11.5cm)
60 y
γ (E=5.7 MeV)
40
(c
m )
20 01000
990
970 980 z (cm)
960
950
Fig. 12. Muon stopping in the ICARUS 600 tons detector and decaying into an electron.
a full-sampling electromagnetic and hadronic calorimetry. Furthermore, the imaging provides excellent electron and photon identification and electron/hadron separation. √ The E(MeV), E < 50 MeV [111], √ energy resolution E/E is excellent for electromagnetic showers (∼11%/ √ 3%/ E(GeV)1% [76]) and also very good for contained hadronic showers (30%/ E(GeV)). Furthermore, it is possible to measure the momentum of muons with a resolution better than 20% by using multiple Coulomb scattering (3% for stopping muons where momentum is measured from range). The most important milestone for this technique has been the successful operation of the ICARUS 600 prototype [112], which operated during the summer of 2001, and it is now installed in the Gran Sasso laboratories to operate with the CNGS beam. An event recorded with the 600 detector is shown in Fig. 12. Larger liquid argon detectors are under project. Given its excellent electron identification capabilities, it has also been proposed for use on other new neutrino beams to search for → e appearance. A 100 kt LAr detector has been proposed [113] for a further future generation experiment, which would deliver excellent physics output in rare event search and neutrino physics. However, new concepts and R&D studies are required to extrapolate this technology further. The proposed detector would be composed of a single “boiling” cryogenic tanker, with external dimensions of 40 m in height and 70 m in diameter. Charge imaging, scintillation and Cerenkov light readout furnish (redundant) information, which permit a complete event reconstruction. The detector will run in biphase mode, liquid plus gas, in order to allow for drift lengths as long as ∼20 m along a drift electric field of ∼1 kV/cm. The drift electrons produced in the liquid phase will be extracted from the liquid into the gas by a suitable electric field and then amplified near the anodes. 4.5. New facilities for next generation of neutrino oscillation experiments As pointed out above, different options for neutrino beams of novel conception are presently under study for the next generation of the long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments. Different time scales can be envisaged according to the technical difficulties associated with developing and building these facilities.
78
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
The first facility will probably be a neutrino SuperBeam: conventional neutrino beams characterized by megawatt power proton drivers (Section 4.5.1). Neutrino SuperBeams will require the development of high power proton Linacs or Rapid Cycling Synchrotrons, anticipated for the next decade, and the development of proton targets able to survive to megawatt power proton beams, whose R&D studies have already started [114]. Neutrino SuperBeams can be seen as the injector stage of Neutrino Factories (Section 4.5.3), where the other daughters of pion decays, the muons, are collected, cooled down, accelerated and stored in a decay ring where neutrinos are produced. The muon manipulation, acceleration and storage will require the development of novel machines in high energy physics accelerators with a consequent timescale of the order of about 20 years [115]. In BetaBeams (Section 4.5.2), neutrinos are produced by the decay of radioactive heavy ions after proper acceleration. In principle, all the machinery for ion production and acceleration has already been developed at CERN for the heavy ion physics program at Isolde and SPS. The required improvement by about 3 orders of magnitude of the presently available ion fluxes will require sub-megawatt, 1–2 GeV Linacs, new target developments for heavy ion production, ion collection and acceleration systems including the CERN PS and SPS, and a novel decay ring. Accounting for the technical challenges involved in the above facilities, the expected timescale of BetaBeams could be intermediate between SuperBeams and Neutrino Factories. A design study of BetaBeam has just started within the European project Eurisol [116] aimed at a very intense source of heavy ions.
4.5.1. Near-term long-baseline experiments with SuperBeams Conventional neutrino beams can be improved and optimized for the → e searches, continuing the line of the present experiments. The design of a new SuperBeam facility for a very high intensity and low energy flux will demand: • new higher power proton drivers, exceeding one megawatt, able to deliver more intense proton beams on target; • tunable L/E in order to explore the m223 parameter region as indicated by the previous experiments with neutrino beams and atmospheric neutrinos; • narrow-band beams with E ∼1–2 GeV; • lower intrinsic e beam contamination, which can be obtained by suppressing the K + and K 0 production by the primary proton beam in the target. An interesting option for the SuperBeams is the possibility of tilting the beam axis a few degrees with respect to the position of the far detector (off-axis beams) [101,117]. According to the two body -decay kinematics, all the pions above a given momentum produce neutrinos of similar energy at a given angle = 0 with respect to the direction of parent pion (contrary to the =0 case where the neutrino energy is proportional to the pion momentum). These neutrino beams have several advantages with respect to the corresponding on-axis ones. They are narrower, their energy is lower and the e contamination is smaller (since e mainly come from three body decays), although the neutrino flux can be significantly smaller. In the J-PARC project Phase I (T2K experiment [101]), a 50 GeV/c proton beam of 0.75 MW from a PS will produce a very intense and K beam tilted by = 2◦ with respect to the direction which aims at the Super-Kamiokande detector, 295 km away. The experiment is approved, and data taking is scheduled to start in 2009 (10% of the project’s pot intensity is expected during the first year of running). The resulting 700 MeV beam (Fig. 13) with 0.4% e contamination will achieve a 90% C.L. sensitivity sin2 2 13 ∼0.006 in 5 years assuming CP = 0, a factor 20 better than the current limit set by Chooz (see Fig. 15). T2K will also measure |m223 | and sin2 2 23 with ∼2% precision detecting disappearance and will perform a sensitive search for sterile neutrinos through the detection of neutral current event disappearance. The T2K sensitivity compared with that of the present generation experiments is reported in Fig. 14 as a function of time. The proposed machine upgrade to 4 MW, in conjunction with the construction of a very large (0.54 M fiducial volume) water Cerenkov detector (Hyper-Kamiokande) will allow investigation of the CP violation phase (J-Parc II). In a 5 year run with the beam, the experiment could reach a 90% C.L. 13 sensitivity sin2 2 13 > 6 × 10−4 , while in two years of and six years of ¯ operation, it will discover a non-vanishing CP at a 3 level or better if |CP | > 20◦ and sin2 2 13 ∼0.01 [132] (see also Fig. 19).
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
79
400 350 ON AXIS
νµ NCC (/100MeV/22.5kt/yr)
300
OA 2°
250 200 OA 3°
150 100 50 0
0
1
2
3
4
5
Eν (GeV)
Fig. 13. T2K neutrino beam energy spectrum for different off-axis angle .
Chooz excluded
10 -1
Sin 2 θ13 (90%CL)
Minos
CNGS
2
Double Chooz
10-2
T2K World Limit
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
Year Fig. 14. Expected evolution of sensitivities on sin2 2 13 . The sensitivity for each future experiment (solid line) and the world sensitivity computed without that experiment (dashed line) are displayed as functions of time. The comparison of the two curves shows the discovery potential of the experiment along its period of data taking. The world overall sensitivity against time is also displayed. The comparison of the overall world sensitivity with the world sensitivity computed without a single experiment shows the impact of the results of that experiment. It was assumed that the experiments would start producing results after one year of data taking.
The NOA experiment with an upgraded NuMI off-axis neutrino beam [105] (E ∼2 GeV and a e contamination less than 0.5%) and with a baseline of 810 km (12 km off-axis), was recently proposed at FNAL with the aim of exploring → e oscillations with a sensitivity 10 times better than MINOS. If it gains approval in 2007, the experiment could start taking data in 2011. The NuMI target will receive a 120 GeV/c proton flux with an expected
80
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Table 10 Summary table of different -beam options
p-driver p beam energy E L OFF-axis CC (no osc.) contamination Detect. fid. mass Material Signal efficiency 0 /e (p/ ) sin2 2 13 × 104
(MW) (GeV) (GeV) (km) (kt −1 /yr) (%) (kt) (%) (%) (90% C.L.)
T2K
J-Parc II
NOA
BNL
PS + +
SPL (3.5)
B (B100,100 )
0.75 50 0.7 295 2◦ 100 0.4
4 50 0.7 295 2◦ 500 0.4
0.8 (2) 120 2 810 0.8◦ 80 (200) 0.5
1 28 1.5 2540 – 11 0.5
4 20 1.6 732 – 450 1.2
4 2.2 (3.5) 0.27 (0.29) 130 – 37 (122) 0.4 (0.7)
0.4 1–2.2 0.3 (0.4) 130 – 38 (56) 0
22.5 H2 O 40 80 60
540 H2 O 40 80 6
30 LScint 24 60 38 (24)
440 H2 O 25 100 30
3.8 LAr 100 0 50
440 H2 O 70 30 18 (8)
440 H2 O 60 (70) – 7 (2)
J-Parc II sin2 2 13 sensitivity is extrapolated from T2K phase I. All the experiments are normalized to 5 years data taking and considering a neutrino beam time operation of 107 s/yr. Numbers quoted for NoA refer to the standard and the proton driver options (see text). SPL numbers are for the 2.2 GeV option (the 3.5 GeV performances are in parentheses). The B column is computed for the =60, 100 option (the =100, 100 performances are in parentheses), the CC line indicates the sum of e CC and ¯ e CC rates. The 0 /e line indicates the fraction of the neutral current background normalized to intrinsic e background. Once fixed L/E to well match the m223 value, the figure of merit of the neutrino beam is determined by the -CC/k/yr event rate and also by the e / natural beam contamination.
intensity of 6.5 × 1020 pot/yr (2 × 107 s/yr are considered available to NuMI operations while the other beams are normalized to 107 s/yr). The experiment will use one near-detector and one far-detector, both making use of liquid scintillators. In five years of data taking with a 30 k active mass far-detector, it is envisaged that a sensitivity on sin2 2 13 , which is slightly better than T2K, together with a precise measurement of |m223 | and sin2 2 23 , will be achieved. NOA may be able to solve the mass hierarchy problem for a limited range of the CP and sign(m223 ) parameters [106]. In the second phase, a new proton driver of 8 GeV/c and 2 MW, could increase the NuMI beam intensity to 17.2–25.2× 1020 protons/yr, allowing improvements to the experimental sensitivity by a factor of two, and initiating an experimental search for the CP violation. A longer-term experiment has been proposed at BNL for a different long-baseline neutrino beam [118]. In this proposal, the AGS 28 GeV PS would be upgraded to 1 MW and a neutrino beam with E 1.5 GeV would be fired into a megaton water Cerenkov detector at a baseline of 2540 km. The detector would be at the second oscillation maxima and the comparison of disappearance and e appearance at the first and second oscillation maximum should allow better control of degeneracies. However, it should be noted that background rates and signal efficiency of a water Cerenkov detector in this energy range are not optimal and not constant between the first and the second maximum. In a 5-year run, this experiment could reach a 90% C.L. sensitivity sin2 2 13 0.003 (CP = 0). The performances of future neutrino oscillation experiments are summarized in Table 10 (see also Refs. [119]). 4.5.1.1. European Superbeam projects. Many different ideas and approaches have been developed for neutrino longbaseline experiments in Europe following the CNGS appearance phase. These projects aim to improve and develop existing infrastructures and detectors, or consider new neutrino beams and detectors. The possibility of improving the CERN to Gran Sasso neutrino beam performances for 13 searches even with the present proton beam, Ep = 400 GeV and 4.5 × 1019 pot/yr has been investigated (CNGS-L.E.) [120]. The low energy neutrino flux can be increased by a factor of 5 with respect to the current CNGS beam by an appropriate optimization of the target (a compact 1 m carbon rod), and the focusing system. The decay tunnel will be reduced to 350 m allowing for a near detector useful for determining beam composition. This intense low energy muon neutrino flux, E 1.8 GeV, will produce a 4.5 -CC/1019 pot/k event rate with a 0.9% e / -CC event contamination. With the CNGS-L.E. neutrino beam, the sensitivity to sin2 2 13 can be increased by a factor of 7 with respect to Chooz, sin2 2 13 < 0.02 (not accounting for CP violation and matter effects) in five years with a 2.4 k fiducial mass liquid argon detector (m223 = 2.5 × 10−3 eV2 , as shown in Fig. 15).
81
Chooz excluded
2
∆m223 (eV )
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
2.5
T2K CN
GS
PS
IC ++
AR US
CO
MB
CN
GS
IN
ED
L.E
.
sin2 2θ13 Fig. 15. Expected sensitivity to the 13 mixing angle (CP violation and matter effects not included in the calculation) for a 20 GeV/c high intensity PS proton beam from CERN to Gran Sasso (PS + +) and for the ICARUS 2.4 k at the CNGS-L.E. compared with the T2K experiment.
The preparation of a such a low energy neutrino facility would not, however, be compatible with the CNGS beam for program. In fact, a suitable interval of time after the CNGS -phase running would be required for the “radioactive cooling” of the target and of the decay tunnel, cooling which is necessary in order to change the target geometry, and shorten and enlarge the decay tunnel in a safe environment. Alternatively, a new beam line could be built. A second study considered a low energy neutrino beam (1.5 GeV mean energy) fired into a detector made of 44,000 phototubes equipping 2 M of water, at 1000 m depth in the Golfo di Taranto, 1200 km from CERN (CNGT), 2◦ OffAxis, [121]. In this case, the detector would be placed at the second oscillation maximum and if movable it could take data at the two positions of minimum and maximum oscillation probability. Over 5 years of data taking, sensitivity would be marginally worse than T2K, [121]. A proton driver with a new generation of low energy and high intensity SuperBeams to optimize the search for the → e oscillations has also been recently studied [122]. In terms of proton economics, the optimum beam energy turns out to be around 20 GeV, well matched to a 732 km baseline (i.e. CERN—Gran Sasso, average neutrino energy E 1.6 GeV). An approximate sensitivity sin2 2 13 0.005 for m223 ∼2.5 × 10−3 eV2 can be obtained (CP = 0 and no matter effects) for 2 × 1022 pot/yr, (approximately two orders of magnitude higher than the intensity deliverable by the current CERN-PS) and 5 years exposure of ICARUS. The performance of this facility, indicated as PS++, has been computed for a power source corresponding to 6.5 MW, for a useful beam time operation of 107 s/yr and a 2.35 k detector. However, the same sensitivity can be reached with 4 MW power if a LNGS hall is fully occupied by ICARUS (about 4 kt). In the CERN-SPL SuperBeam project [123–125], the planned 4 MW SPL (Superconducting Proton Linac) would deliver a 2.2 GeV proton beam onto a Hg target which would generate an intense + (− ) beam focused by a suitable magnetic horn in a short decay tunnel. As a result, an intense beam, would be produced mainly via the -decay, + → + , providing a flux ∼3.6 × 1011 /yr/m2 at 130 km distance, and an average energy of 0.27 GeV (Fig. 16). The e contamination from K would be suppressed by threshold effects, and the resulting e / ratio (∼0.4%) would be known within 2% error. The use of a near and far detector (the latter at L = 130 km distance in the Frejus area) (Fig. 17) would allow for both -disappearance and → e appearance studies. The physics potential of the 2.2 GeV SPL SuperBeam (SPL-SB) with a water Cerenkov far-detector fiducial mass of 440 kt [100]
82
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111 x 10 7
x 10 7 SPL νµ
2500
−
SPL νµ
6
1000
ν/m2 /20 MeV/yr
−
Beta νe (He )
1500
SPL νµ
7000
SPL νµ
6000
Beta νe (Ne )
−
18
18
Beta νe (Ne )
2
ν/m /20 MeV/yr
2000
8000
−
6
Beta νe (He )
5000 4000 3000 2000
500 1000 0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6 Eν (GeV)
0.8
0
1
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Eν (GeV)
Fig. 16. Left: neutrino flux of -Beam (6He = 60, 18Ne = 100) and CERN-SPL SuperBeam, 2.2 GeV, at 130 km distance. Right: the same for 6He = 100, 18Ne = 100, (non-shared mode, that is just one ion circulating in the decay ring) and a 3.5 GeV SPL SuperBeam.
EURISOL
Existing at CERN DECAY RING
SPL SPS
Isol target & Ion source
B = 5T L = 6880 m
New RFQ Linac PSB
PS
Fig. 17. A schematic layout of the BetaBeam complex. On the left the low energy part is similar to the EURISOL project [116]. The central part (PS and SPS) already exists. On the right, the decay ring which has yet to be built.
has been extensively studied [124]. The experimental sensitivity is displayed in the ( 13 –CP ) plane due to the strong 13 –CP correlation, having fixed m223 =2.5×10−3 eV2 (Fig. 18). The 90% C.L. 13 sensitivity (CP =0) is 13 =0.002 (five years beam), see Table 10. The corresponding 3 CP violation discovery potential (2 years with the beam and 8 years with the reversed polarity ¯ beam) is shown in Fig. 19. Recent developments show that the potential of the SPL-SB could be improved by raising the SPL energy to 3.5 GeV [126], in order to produce more copious secondary mesons and to focus them more efficiently. This seems feasible if state-of-the-art RF cavities are used in place of the old LEP cavities, which had previously been planned [127]. In this upgraded configuration, neutrino flux could be increased by a factor of three with respect to the 2.2 GeV configuration, reaching a sensitivity to sin2 2 13 eight times better than T2K, suitable for discovering CP violation (at 3 level) if CP 25◦ and 13 1.4◦ [128]. The expected performances are shown in Figs. 18 and 19. 4.5.2. BetaBeams BetaBeams (B) were introduced by Zucchelli in 2001 [97]. The idea was to generate pure, well collimated and intense e (¯e ) beams by producing, collecting, accelerating radioactive ions and storing them in a decay ring in 10 ns
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
10
83
CHOOZ excluded
-1
CNGS combined Double Chooz
Sin2 2θ13
10
-2
T2K SPL-SB 3.5 GeV
SPL-SB βB
10-3
βB100,100
10
-4
SPL-SB 3.5 GeV+ βB 100,100 B
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
δCP (deg.) Fig. 18. 13 90% C.L. sensitivity as function of CP for m223 = 2.5 × 10−3 eV2 , sign(m223 ) = 1, 2% systematic errors. CNGS and T2K curves are taken from [38], BNL from [69], Double Chooz from [40]. SPL-SB sensitivities have been computed for a five-year run, B and B100,100 for a five-year e + ¯ e run.
90
SPL-SB 3.5 GeV βB
80
SPL-SB
70 T2K Phase II
δCP (deg)
60 50 βB 100,100
40 30
βB100,100 +SPL-SB 3.5 GeV
20 10 0
-4
10
-3
-2
10
10 2
sin (θ13 ) Fig. 19. CP discovery potential at 3 level (see text) computed for 10 years running time. The SPL-SB 2.2 and 3.5 GeV, BetaBeam with = 60, 100 and = 100, 100 J-Parc II [132] and SPL-SB combined with BetaBeam are shown. All the curves are computed with a 2% systematic error, 10 years of data taking.
long bunches so as to suppress the atmospheric neutrino background. The resulting B would be virtually background free, and fluxes could be easily computed by the properties of the beta decay of the parent ion and by its Lorentz boost factor gamma. The best ion candidates so far are 18 Ne and 6 He for e and ¯ e , respectively. Summarizing, the main
84
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
features of a neutrino beam based on the BetaBeam concept are: • the beam energy depends on the factor. The ion accelerator can be tuned to optimize the sensitivity of the experiment; • the neutrino beam contains a single flavour with an energy spectrum and intensity known a priori. Therefore, unlike conventional neutrino beams, near-detectors are not necessary to normalize the fluxes; • neutrino and anti-neutrino beams can be produced with a comparable flux; • contrary to SuperBeams, BetaBeam experiments search for e → transitions, requiring a detector capable of distinguishing muons from electrons. Moreover, as the beam does not contain or ¯ in the initial state, magnetized detectors are not needed. This is in contrast to the neutrino factories (see below) where the determination of the muon sign is mandatory. A baseline study for a BetaBeam complex (Fig. 17) has been carried out at CERN [129]. The SPS could accelerate 6 He ions at a maximum value of 6He = 150 and 18 Ne ions up to 18Ne = 250. In this scenario, the two ions circulate together in the decay ring. This is a feasible option, provided that the s are in the ratio 6 He /18 Ne =3/5. The reference B fluxes are 2.9 × 1018 6 He useful decays/yr and 1.1 × 1018 18 Ne decays/yr if the two ions are run in the complex at the same time. The resulting neutrino fluxes are displayed in Fig. 16. The water Cerenkov could be a suitable technology for a large detector. The physics potential has been computed in [130] for 6He = 60, 18Ne = 100 and with a 440 k detector at 130 km, and the corresponding sensitivities are displayed in Figs. 18 and 19. Sensitivities taking into account all the parameter degeneracies and ambiguities have been computed in [131]. Recent developments suggesting the possibility of running the two ions separately at their optimal [133], have recently triggered a new optimal scheme for the BetaBeam. In this scheme, both ions are accelerated at = 100. The expected performances are displayed (B100,100 ) in Figs. 18 and 19. A sensitivity to sin2 2 13 30 times better than T2K may be reached, and lepton CP violation could be discovered at 3 if CP 25◦ and 13 1.0◦ [128,134]. BetaBeams require a proton driver in the energy range of 1–2 GeV, 0.5 MW power. As an injector, the SPL uses at most 10% of its protons. This allows a simultaneous B and SPL-SB run, the two neutrino beams having similar neutrino energies (see also Fig. 16). The same detector could then be exposed to 2 × 2 beams ( and ¯ × e and ¯ e ), having access to CP, T and CPT violation searches in the same run. With this combination of neutrino beams, a sensitivity to sin2 2 13 35 times better than T2K could be reached exploiting a CP violation discovery potential at 3 if CP 18◦ and 13 0.55◦ [128] (Figs. 18 and 19). BetaBeam capabilities have been computed in [134–136] for ions accelerated at higher energies than those allowed by SPS. All these studies assume that the same ion fluxes of the baseline scenario can be maintained. However, this is not the case if the number of stored bunches is kept constant in the storage ring. On the other hand, by increasing (i.e. the neutrino energy) the atmospheric neutrinos background constraint on the total bunch length [97] tends to vanish. Consequently, the total number of bunches could be increased. Studies are in progress at CERN in order to define realistic neutrino fluxes as a function of [133]. It is worth noting that if a high intensity Beta Beam with ∼300.500 (requiring a higher energy accelerator than SPS, like the Super-SPS [137]) can be built, a 40 kt iron calorimeter located at Gran Sasso Laboratory would have the possibility of discovering a non-vanishing CP if CP > 20◦ for 13 2◦ (99% C.L.), and measure the sign of m223 [134]. 4.5.3. Neutrino factories The neutrino production by muon decay from a pure muon beam has been considered since 1998 [95]. This is indeed a perfectly well known weak process and the beam can be monitored with good precision in momentum and intensity. In the CERN present layout for a neutrino factory (F) [96] a 4 MW proton beam is accelerated up to 2.2 GeV/c by the Super Conducting Proton Linac (SPL) to produce low energy ’s in a liquid mercury target, which are collected by a solenoid. Muons produced from the -decay are then cooled and phase rotated before acceleration through a recirculating Linac system up to 50 GeV/c. These muons of well-defined charge and momentum are injected in the accumulator where they circulate until they decay, delivering along the two main straight sections two pure beams whose intensity is expected to be more than 100 times that of conventional beams. Both muon signs can be selected. The decay + → e+ e ¯ (− → e− ¯ e ) produces a pure, well-collimated neutrino beam with equal numbers of ¯ , e ( , ¯ e ) and their energy allows extension of the baseline to several thousand kilometers. The optimal beam energy at the F will be as large as possible. One has to take into account the technical challenges and other difficulties associated with the construction of this type of muon acceleration complex. E = 50 GeV
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
85
Fig. 20. Expected layout for a neutrino factory at CERN.
(E ∼34 GeV) represents a limit value for this new machine (Fig. 20). In fact, the neutrino flux grows in proportion to E (in the conventional neutrino beams is proportional to E ), with the number of charged current neutrino events from the oscillations (Nosc ), measured by a detector at a distance L, which will be proportional to E : L E3 Nosc ∝ · · Posc ∝ 2 · sin2 E , E L where ∝ E is the corresponding neutrino interaction cross section and Posc is the oscillation probability. Furthermore, the intensity can be precisely determined from the measurement of the monochromatic current circulating in the storage ring (absolute normalization at 1% level). An accurate determination of momentum allows the measurement of the neutrino energy spectra at the detector site. The F lends itself naturally to the exploration of neutrino oscillations between flavours with high sensitivity to small mixing angles and small mass differences. The detector should be able to perform both appearance and disappearance experiments, providing lepton identification and charge discrimination which is a tag for the initial flavour and for the oscillation. In particular, the search for e → transitions (“golden channel”) appears to be very attractive at F, because this transition can be studied in appearance mode looking for − (appearance of wrong-sign ) in neutrino beams where the neutrino type that is searched for is totally absent (+ beam in F). With a 40 k magnetic detector (MINOS like) exposed to both polarity beams and 1021 muon decays, it will be possible to explore the 13 angle down to 0.1◦ , creating the possibility of measuring the CP phase if |m212 | 5 × 10−4 eV2 (systematic errors not accounted for) [90,104]. Unfortunately, as discussed in Section 4.3, the determination of ( 13 , CP ) is not free of ambiguities and up to eight different regions of the parameter space can fit the same experimental result. In order to solve these ambiguities, a single experiment on a single neutrino beam is not sufficient. An optimal combination of Betabeams, SuperBeams and neutrino factories has to be considered to deal with the eightfold degeneracy. Several investigations on how to solve this problem have been carried out, as reported in [138] and references therein. As an example, the result of an analysis combining the golden and the silver (e → ) F channels with the SPL-SB (taken from reference [109]), is shown in Fig. 21. More details on the physics performances of a F towards a precision measurement of neutrino oscillation parameters can be found in Ref. [115].
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
δ (°)
δ (°)
86
Golden (2810 km)
Golden (2810 km) + SPL-SB (2.2 GeV)
∆θ (°)
(a)
(b)
∆θ (°) 13
δ (°)
δ (°)
13
Golden + Silver + SPL-SB
Golden (2810 km) + Silver (732 km)
(c)
∆θ (°) 13
(d)
∆θ (°) 13
Fig. 21. The results of a 2 fit for 13 = 2◦ , CP = 90◦ . Four different combinations of experimental data are presented: (a) magnetized iron detector (MID) at a F; (b) MID plus SPL-SB; (c) MID plus hybrid emulsion (HE) at F; (d) the three detectors together. Notice how in case (d) the eightfold-degeneracy is solved and a good reconstruction of the physical 13 , CP values is achieved.
4.6. Conclusions Neutrino oscillations are certainly one of the most important discoveries of recent years. They allow us to measure fundamental parameters of the Standard Model, provide the first insight beyond the electroweak scale, play a decisive role in many fields of astrophysics and cosmology and allow us to explore CP violation in the leptonic sector. In particular, precise measurements of the oscillation parameters and of the still unknown parameters 13 , sign(m223 ) and CP in the subleading → e oscillations are of paramount importance. Due to the complexity and intrinsic difficulties associated with the three flavour neutrino oscillations, a single world facility would probably not be sufficient to measure all these parameters.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
87
The present generation of neutrino beams at accelerators like NuMI and CNGS can start the exploration of the 13 angle beyond the Chooz limit. However, the power and purity of these conventional neutrino beams, where neutrinos are generated mainly by pion and kaon decays in a wide range of momenta, seem to intrinsically limit the experimental sensitivity. New high intensity proton accelerator facilities (in the MW regime) are required to produce neutrino beams with an intensity and purity much higher than the conventional neutrino beams. Novel concept neutrino beams like beams and neutrino factories, where neutrinos are produced in the decay of radioactive ions and muons which were previously accelerated to a selected momentum, can open up interesting and promising scenarios, given the possibility of exploring the neutrino oscillation world with high accuracy. These new facilities are currently being studied. They will, however, require a long R&D phase and different time-scales due to the various intrinsic difficulties involved in both the construction and the projects. The most physics-ambitious road-map is still to be clarified, particularly because no predictions exist for the 13 parameter below the Chooz limit 13 < 11◦ , which drives all the new phenomena. For the future, SuperBeam facilities where conventional neutrino beams are improved for flux and purity and tuned to → e transitions, would appear to be the most suitable. The T2K experiment in Japan at the J-Parc accelerator complex, which uses Super-Kamiokande as the far detector, has to be considered as a reference. This experiment has also the possibility of a second phase with a more intense beam and a larger detector of about one megaton mass. The CERN to Gran Sasso neutrino SuperBeam option, based on an improved synchrotron, seems to be equivalent to J-Parc II, as far as neutrino fluxes are concerned. The level of contamination of e is nevertheless better in J-Parc thanks to the off-axis alignment of this experiment. However, it would be mandatory to complement the European option with a detector in excess of 100 k mass in order to exploit its physics potential well beyond the sensitivity of the T2K experiment. The SPL-SuperBeam project at CERN, complemented with a megaton water Cerenkov detector, seems to require a too big an effort compared with its physics output, even if the 3.5 GeV SPL option greatly improves its discovery potential. A gigantic water Cerenkov detector would be better exploited if fired by a BetaBeam, and it should also be stressed that a combination of the SPL-SB with a BetaBeam would result in the most powerful facility in anticipation of the advent of the neutrino factories era. Smaller and denser detectors could only be used with BetaBeams of higher energies than those obtainable with the CERN SPS or, over a longer timescale, with the neutrino factories. In this case magnetized iron calorimeters or magnetized liquid argon detectors, having masses exceeding 40 kt, could reach excellent sensitivities in neutrino oscillation physics.
5. Hadronic physics at the high intensity frontier 5.1. Introduction The field of hadronic physics is the study of strongly interacting matter in all its manifestations in order to understand its properties in terms of the underlying fundamental theory, Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). The major aim of hadronic physics is to determine the degrees of freedom governing hadronic phenomena at all scales, to connect them to the fundamental parameters and fields of QCD, and then to use QCD to describe quantitatively all the phenomena ranging from the physics of the nucleus to the behaviour of matter in the early Universe. The bulk of strong interactions are governed by the long-distance regime, where the strong interaction is indeed strong. It is this regime, with a scale of lengths of the order of one fermi, that determines the light-hadron spectrum and its properties. The calculation of these properties requires an understanding of non-perturbative QCD, of confinement and of chiral-symmetry breaking. Quark and gluon confinement means that it is the femto-universe that determines the experimental phenomenology that we have to understand. One can say that GeV physics controls the outcome of every hadronic interaction at almost all energies. Low-energy hadron dynamics are determined by the structure of the QCD vacuum and it is precisely the nature of the vacuum that makes QCD more interesting than QED. The QED vacuum, with its low density of particle–antiparticle pairs, is essentially empty. In contrast, since QCD interactions are stronger and richer in structure, not only is the vacuum a denser sea of q q¯ pairs and gluon clouds, but it also contains condensates of quarks, antiquarks and gluons. The vacuum determines the spectrum of hadrons and its scale.
88
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
Experimental exploration of the full spectrum of states composed of quarks and gluons is required if one wants to understand the structure and dynamics of hadrons. Deep-inelastic scattering (DIS) measurements complement the experimental scenario through a picture of the nucleon at the desired level of resolution. QCD is an essential ingredient of the Standard Model. Precise calculations based on QCD are necessary to understand a variety of phenomena in the high-energy regime. At present, the largest uncertainties in the interpretation of measurements for physics beyond the Standard Model come from the incalculable strong-interaction matrix elements. A good understanding of the hadronic effects is preliminary to solving several still unresolved problems like the dark matter puzzle (is any supersymmetric neutralino necessary?) or the (g − 2) discrepancy with the Standard Model (is it a real discrepancy?). Moreover, the study of weak-interaction phenomena and the extraction of quark-mixing matrix parameters remain limited by our capacity to deal with non-perturbative strong-interaction dynamics. This is the major hurdle in the quest to understand the origin of CP violation. Complications in the determination of CP phases due to strong final-state interaction (FSI) have been uncovered. Studies of charm-meson decays, mainly through Dalitz-plot analyses, have experimentally confirmed the relevance of FSI phases. Similarly, the determination of Cabibbo-suppressed CKM matrix elements and D D¯ mixing parameters require an understanding of the strong interactions among the light hadrons produced in the decays of the heavy mesons. The same complications are present in the beauty sector, and they have to be controlled if one wants to fully exploit the potentialities of searching for New Physics, which are offered by heavy-flavour studies. Standard Model extensions are likely to be strongly coupled, or have strongly coupled sectors. Prime examples are Technicolor, which is modeled on QCD and is ab initio strongly coupled, and Supersymmetry, which employs stronglycoupled sectors to break the symmetry. Techniques (such as lattice QCD (LQCD)) exist that are able to address strongly coupled theories. With the progress in computational resources, these techniques—which still need to be validated—are expected to make the calculations of hadronic observables possible. 5.2. Standard techniques for the study of hadronic matter The hadron physics program stretches in opposite directions. By looking at the high-energy frontier, it aims to unveil the existence of new physics at very short distances, and by looking at the confinement regime, it pursues the ultimate goal of understanding the static properties of hadrons, such as masses and magnetic moments. After 40 years of study of the nucleon structure with electroweak probes, we can claim to understand the probes, but not yet the proton. We can describe the density of momentum and (less precisely) the helicity of its constituents. We can formalize the symmetry principles of its binding force, but we cannot deduce from basic principles the static properties of the bound states. A wide variety of effective field theories, which are approaching maturity, seem to be able to adapt the use of QCD to each energy scale. Baryons account for most of the visible matter in the universe, and in the last 50 years a wide range of approaches has been adopted to study the nature of baryons in depth. These studies can be classified as: • static: aiming at measuring the properties of each baryon such as mass, magnetic moment, spin and parity. A new perspective has been opened up by the unveiling of the patterns of narrow bound states of heavy quarks. • dynamic: trying to isolate the intrinsic properties of their constituents, and to measure their wave function and spin orientation inside the nucleon. This field has recently been widened with the inclusion of the transversity spin structure functions and of the generalized parton distributions. The understanding of the internal structure of hadrons has deep implications for our capability to extract SM parameters or to gain evidence of new physics from the study of light and heavy meson decays. In the context of the “high intensity frontier” we have identified a few relevant topics, which will be discussed in detail: • Light and heavy hadron spectroscopy. • Direct measurement of quark transversity distributions. While the main subject of this Report is the investigation of the opportunities offered by a low/intermediate energy multi-MW proton driver, the possibilities presented by a high-energy (1 TeV) intense (1014 protons/pulse every 10 s)
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
89
machine have also to be considered. The main advantage of a high-energy machine complex would be the ability to provide many different secondary beams. A variety of fixed-target experiments could then be carried on simultaneously, thus permitting competitive investigations for Physics beyond the Standard Model and for novel measurements of the structure of hadrons. The observation in the charm sector of mixing effects at the level of 10−4 –10−5 or CP-violation of 10−3 , which could reasonably be probed by high-sensitivity photo/hadroproduction experiments from such an intense primary proton source, would represent searches for New Physics comparative with those at collider facilities like CLEO-c, the B factories, and the Tevatron [139–141]. Unexpected larger rates for rare decays would imply non-Standard Model tree-level FCNC diagrams, or non-standard model contributions to higher-order loop diagrams. This would mean sensitivity to high-mass gauge bosons and fermions, which would open up the possibility of probing particle states and mass scales that are not directly accessible [142,143]. Such a “charm” program could be complemented by a vast campaign of spectroscopic measurements. With very accurate measurements of the parameters of the ground states of charmed mesons, and in the wake of the surprising discoveries of recent years in the D sector, interest has shifted to the study of excited charm meson states. The availability of secondary intense high-energy lepton beams should permit precise measurements of low crosssection reactions like deeply virtual compton scattering and hard exclusive meson production in a wide kinematical range, thus providing the first possibility of model-independent determination of the generalized parton distributions (GPD). A deeper insight into the hadron structure is indeed expected in this novel, unified framework of description. A new element has recently been added to the puzzle of nucleon spin decomposition into parton spin and orbital contributions. Preliminary data from COMPASS indicate that the gluon helicity G is small around xg = 0.1. The role of the axial anomaly in the nucleon spin could be further investigated by a high-statistics measurement of the polarization of the gluons. Precise parton helicity distributions for the sea quarks could also be obtained from the same measurements, and accurate values of the Bjorken integral could permit a high-precision determination of S . In order to obtain the parton transversity distributions a set of dedicated high-statistics measurements are needed. These could be obtained using the high-intensity secondary beams. Information on parton orbital angular momentum could possibly be extracted from the measurement of the transverse momentum dependent distribution functions as well as from the GPD. 5.3. Spectroscopy 5.3.1. Light mesons and exotic searches The study of the light hadron spectrum is fundamental for the understanding of the non-perturbative QCD, confinement, and chiral symmetry breaking. In fact, sorting out the meson and baryon spectra led us to the quark model and finally to the current QCD theory. Light mesons are q q¯ combinations containing the u, d and s quarks and are usually grouped in octets and singlets. They are classified in JPC multiplets. The l = 0 states are the pseudoscalars (0−+ ) and the vectors (1−− ), while the orbital excitations are the scalars (0++ ) the axial-vectors (1++ ) and (1+− ), and the tensors (2++ ). The corresponding mass range extends up to 2 GeV. The gluonic degrees of freedom in mesons are expected to be manifest precisely in this mass region (at masses above 1.5 GeV). In fact QCD predicts the existence of non-q q¯ states like glueballs (gg, ggg), which are mesons made of bound gluons, hybrids (q qg), ¯ which are q q¯ pairs bound by excited gluons, and multiquark states (qq q¯ q, ¯ qqqq q, ¯ qqq q¯ q¯ q). ¯ Predictions for the mass spectra of glueballs and hybrids are made within the framework of various theoretical models. As an example, Fig. 22 shows a set of predictions based on various Lattice QCD calculations [144]. In recent decades, the study of this non-perturbative realm of QCD has been carried out through a variety of experiments in which ± , K ± , p or p¯ particles interact with nucleons or nuclei to produce the excited mesons. However, at present the general picture of this field is far from clear. For this reason, a new class of more modern, high-statistics experiments has been proposed. These measurements should allow the study of the production of mesons and exotics via p, Kp, pp and pp ¯ interactions (see the new projects at GSI, JHF and IHEP/Protvino), as well as via double-Pomeron, photon-Pomeron and two-photon mechanisms (for example, the G-TeV, HERA-g and the STAR-RHIC proposals).
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111 2S+1
LJ
1
S0
3
S1
1
P1
3
P0
3
P1
3
P2
1
D2
3
D2
3
D3
1
F3
3
F 3 n.a.
12
0
+-
11
9 m r0
1-+
2+-
10
hc 8
ηc
7
χc
χc
1
0
4.5 4 3.5
χc
2
3
J/Ψ experiment ** DD DD CP-PACS Columbia hybrids glueballs
6 5 4 J
0
5 +-
m/GeV
90
2.5 2 1.5
PC
0
-+
1
--
1
+-
0
++
1
++
2
++
2
-+
2
--
3
--
3
+-
3
++exotic
Fig. 22. The experimental charmonium spectrum together with calculations from lattice QCD [144].
The experimental strategy in this field mainly addresses two highly correlated items: • the definition of the standard q q¯ nonets, with assignment of the corresponding mesons; • the identification of exotic states, like for example, glueballs and hybrids. The exotic states can be identified in different ways. First of all, exotic quantum numbers, for example J PC quantum numbers forbidden in the q q¯ states (like 0+− , 1−+ , 2+− , etc.), are a clear signature. In addition, one can identify as exotics those states with standard J PC , which cannot be fitted into a nonet (extrastates), or with a decay pattern not compatible with the QCD prediction for q q¯ states. Finally, the glueball production must be enhanced in gluon rich environments and suppressed in collisions. The most interesting fields of investigation are briefly reviewed in the following subsections. 5.3.1.1. Scalar mesons. The scalar sector is one of the most interesting cases. The PDG classification of the 0++ mesons is tentative, being the number of states greater than nine. Currently the states assigned to the scalar nonet are the a0 (1450), K0∗ (1430), f0 (1370) and f0 (1710). On the other hand, the light scalars f0 (600), f0 (980), a0 (980) and the f0 (1500) are excluded and considered exotic candidates. In particular, the first three states are considered meson–meson resonances or four-quark states, and the f0 (1500) is one of the most solid candidates for a glueball. 5.3.1.2. Glueball states. The lattice QCD predicts the glueball ground state to be a scalar, and the first excited state to be a tensor with masses respectively around 1600 and 2400 MeV, as shown in Fig. 22. In addition, the mass of the lightest glueball with exotic numbers (2+− ) is predicted to be ∼ 4 GeV. The detection of these states is not trivial, because glueballs are expected to mix with the nearby q q¯ states carrying the same quantum numbers. For example, the scalar mesons 0++ will mix with the glueball ground state thus modifying the expected decay pattern. In this case, the most solid candidate is the f0 (1500) state, where the experimental evidence is its affinity with glue, being for example produced in pp ¯ reactions and not in interactions. On the other hand, other candidates like the f0 (1370) and the f0 (1710) states have large uu¯ + d d¯ and s s¯ components. No prominent candidates are currently available for the 2++ and 2+− states. Finally, we note that the search for glueballs in the higher mass range will not suffer from the problem of mixing with nearby q q¯ states, as shown in Fig. 22.
D. Bettoni et al. / Physics Reports 434 (2006) 47 – 111
91
5.3.1.3. Hybrid states. Predictions for hybrids come mainly from calculations based on the bag model, on the flux tube model, on the constituent gluon model and, more recently and with ever increasing precisions, from the lattice QCD calculations (LQCD) [145]. ¯ states. For these calculations, the parameters are fixed according to the properties of the known QQ QCD predicts the lightest hybrid state with the exotic quantum number 1−+ , to lie in the mass region around 1900 MeV. Most hybrid states are expected to be quite broad but some narrow states, whose identification is easier, are also foreseen. Two narrow candidates with a mass in the region around 1400 MeV and width below 100 MeV have been observed through the spin parity analysis of large samples of data taken in different experiments. In this case, the mass seems to be too low with respect to the QCD predictions and further investigations are clearly needed. All model predictions and LQCD calculations agree that the masses of the lowest-lying charmonium hybrids should have values between 3.9 and 4.5 GeV/c2 and that the state with the lowest mass has J PC = 1−+ [146]. Some of the charmonium hybrids have exotic quantum numbers so that the absence of mixing effects with nearby cc¯ states makes their experimental identification easier. Cross sections for the formation and production of charmonium hybrids are estimated to be similar to those of normal charmonium states. 5.3.1.4. P