Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 1–19 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010001-19, published online March 13, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1569-6
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
The Local Form of Doubly Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization in II1 Factors Mart´ın Argerami and Pedro Massey Abstract. We find a description of the restriction of doubly stochastic maps to separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebras of a II1 factor M. We use this local form of doubly stochastic maps to develop a notion of joint majorization between n-tuples of mutually commuting self-adjoint operators that extends those of Kamei (for single self-adjoint operators) and Hiai (for single normal operators) in the II1 factor case. Several characterizations of this joint majorization are obtained. As a byproduct we prove that any separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebra of M can be embedded into a separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebra of M with diffuse spectral measure. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 46L51; Secondary 46L10. Keywords. Joint majorization, doubly stochastic map, convex hull, unitary orbit.
1. Introduction Majorization between self-adjoint operators in finite factors was introduced by Kamei [21] as an extension of Ando’s definition of majorization between selfadjoint matrices [4]. Later on, Hiai considered majorization in semifinite factors between self-adjoint and normal operators [15, 16]. The reason why majorization has attracted the attention of many researchers (see the discussion in [16] and the references therein) is that it provides a rather subtle way to compare operators that occurs naturally in many contexts (for example [5, 13, 14]). Recently, majorization has regained interest because of its relation with norm-closed unitary orbits of self-adjoint operators and conditional expectations onto abelian subalgebras [5, 6, 10, 14, 18, 19, 24, 26]. Supported in part by NSERC of Canada, CONICET (PIP 5272) and UNLP (11 X472) of Argentina .
2
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
In this paper we define an extension of the notion of majorization between normal operators to that of joint majorization between n-tuples of commuting self-adjoint operators in a II1 factor (such extension is achieved in [22] for finitedimensional factors). Given a II1 factor M with faithful normalized trace τ , and a1 , . . . , an , b1 , . . . , bn ∈ Msa such that ai aj = aj ai , bi bj = bj bi for every i,j, we define the joint majorization (a1 , . . . , an ) ≺ (b1 , . . . , bn ) in terms of doubly stochastic maps between abelian von Neumann algebras (see Definition 4.4). The main result of the paper (Theorem 4.5) is a series of characterizations of joint majorization. In particular, we prove that the following statements are equivalent: (a1 , . . . , an ) ≺ (b1 , . . . , bn ); (a1 , . . . , an ) ∈ conv(UM (b1 , . . . , bn )); (a1 , . . . , an ) ∈ conv w (UM (b1 , . . . , bn )); There exists a unital trace-preserving completely positive map T such that ai = T (bi ), 1 ≤ i ≤ n; 5. There exists a unital trace-preserving positive map T such that ai = T (bi ) for every i ∈ {1, . . . , n}; 6. τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )) ≤ τ (f (b1 , . . . , bn )) for every continuous convex function f : Rn → R. 1. 2. 3. 4.
A key concept for obtaining these characterizations is what we call the “local form” of a doubly stochastic (DS) map (Theorem 3.7): for any DS map T on a II1 factor M and abelian C∗ subalgebras A and B such that T (B) ⊂ A, there exists a sequence ρr of maps approximating T pointwise in norm, i.e. lim T (b) − ρr (b) = 0, b ∈ B, r
αi ui · u∗i , αi ≥ 0, αi = 1, ui ∈ UM . where ρr = This local form of a DS map is obtained as the consequence of several results developed in Sections 3 and 6. The main two technical tools are results on convex combinations of partitions with constant trace (Proposition 3.3 and Lemmas 3.5 and 3.6), and the construction of separable abelian diffuse refinements of separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebras of a II1 factor M. This last construction could have interest on its own; it has been further developed in [23], and similar ideas have been used in [7, 8]. Some of the techniques we use appear to be new, even in the single element case. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we recall some facts about abelian C ∗ -subalgebras of a II1 factor. In Section 3, after describing some technical results, we obtain a description of the local structure of doubly stochastic maps. In Section 4 we introduce and develop the notion of joint majorization between finite abelian families of self-adjoint operators in a II1 factor and we obtain several characterizations of this relation. Section 5 deals with joint unitary orbits of abelian families. Finally, in Section 6 we prove the results described in Section 3.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
3
2. Preliminaries Throughout the paper M will be a II1 factor with normalized faithful normal trace τ . The C ∗ -subalgebras of M are always assumed unital. The subspace of self-adjoint elements of M will be denoted by Msa , the unitary group by UM . As is customary we will denote conjugation by u ∈ UM as Adu , i.e. Adu (x) = uxu∗ . An abelian family (ai )ni=1 in Msa , is a finite family of mutually commuting selfadjoint operators in M. If (ai )ni=1 ⊆ Msa is an abelian family then C ∗ (a1 , . . . , an ) denotes the (unital) separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebra of M generated by a1 , . . . , an . If A is an arbitrary abelian C ∗ -subalgebra of M then Γ(A) denotes its space of characters, i.e. the set of nonzero *-homomorphisms γ : A → C endowed with the weak∗ -topology. It is well-known that the set Γ(A) is a compact Hausdorff space and that A C(Γ(A)), where C(Γ(A)) denotes the C ∗ -algebra of continuous functions on Γ(A). We will use 1 to denote the constant function and πi : Rn → R to denote the projection onto the ith coordinate. 2.1. Joint spectral measures and joint spectral distributions As we will consider a several-variable extension of continuous functional calculus, we state a few facts about it (a different description can be found in [27]). Let ∗ a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 be an then Γ(A) can nabelian familyn in Msa . If A = C (a1 , . . . , an ), be embedded in i=1 σ(ai ) ⊆ R . Indeed, the map Φ : Γ(A) → ni=1 σ(ai ) ⊆ Rn given by Φ(γ) = (γ(a1 ), . . . , γ(an )) is a continuous injection and therefore Γ(A) is homeomorphic to its image under this map; this image is called the joint spectrum of the family and we denote it by σ(¯ a). Note that A C(σ(¯ a)) as C ∗ -algebras, and so for each f ∈ C(σ(¯ a)) there exists a normal operator, denoted f (a1 , . . . , an ), that corresponds to f under the isomorphism. If A ⊆ M is a separable C ∗ -subalgebra then Γ(A) is metrizable and the representation C(Γ(A)) A ⊆ M induces a spectral measure EA [12, IX.1.14] that takes values on the lattice P(M) of projections of M. Let µA be the (scalar) regular Borel measure on Γ(A) defined by µA (∆) = τ (EA (∆)). The regularity of µA follows from the fact that every open set is σ-compact [25, 2.18]. The map Λ : L∞ (Γ(A), µA ) → M given by Λ(h) = Γ(A) h dEA is a normal ∗ -monomorphism (note that in this case the weak∗ topology of L∞ (Γ(A), µA ), restricted to the unit ball, is metrizable) and we have τ (Λ(h)) = h dµA , ∀h ∈ L∞ (Γ(A), µA ). (1) Γ(A)
We will consider the von Neumann algebra L∞ (A) := Λ(L∞ (Γ(A), µA )) ⊆ M. When a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 and A = C ∗ (a1 , . . . , an ), we call Ea¯ := EA and µa¯ := µA the joint spectral measure and joint spectral distribution of the abelian family a ¯ a), µa¯ ) → L∞ (A) the normal isomorphism defined and we denote by Λa¯ : L∞ (Γ(¯ above. It is straightforward to verify that Λa¯ (πi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. Recall that for each h ∈ L∞ (Γ(¯ a), µa¯ ) we write h(a1 , . . . , an ) for the operator Λa¯ (h) ∈ A. In the
4
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
case of a single self-adjoint operator a ∈ Msa the measure µa is the usual spectral distribution of a [10]. In the particular case when x ∈ M is a normal operator, the real and imaginary parts of x are mutually commuting self-adjoint elements of M. Identifying the complex plane with R2 in the usual way, the spectrum of x coincides with the joint spectrum of the abelian pair (Re(x), Im(x)), and that the spectral measure of x coincides with the joint spectral measure of (Re(x), Im(x)). 2.2. Comparison of measures and diffuse measures ∼ (Rn ) the set of all regular finite positive Borel measures ν on We denote by M+ ∼ Rn with ζ dν(ζ) < ∞. We write ν(f ) = Rn f dν, for every ν ∈ M+ (Rn ) and every ν-integrable function f . ∼ (Rn ). Definition 2.1. Let µ, ν ∈ M+ 1. We write ν ∼ µ whenever ν(1) = µ(1) and ν(πj ) = µ(πj ) for every 1 ≤ j ≤ n; 2. we say that µ is majorized by ν, and we write µ ≺ ν, if for every µ1 , . . . , µm ∈ m ∼ n ∼ n (R ) with M i=1 µi = µ there exist ν1 , . . . , νm ∈ M+ (R ) such that + m i=1 νi = ν, and νi ∼ µi , 1 ≤ j ≤ n. .
The relation ≺ in Definition 2.1 does not seem to be called “majorization” in the literature, but it will be a suitable name for us in the light of Theorem 4.5. ∼ Theorem 2.2. [3, I.3.2] Let µ, ν ∈ M+ (Rn ). Then µ ≺ ν if and only if µ(f ) ≤ ν(f ) for every continuous convex function f : Rn → R.
The next corollary is an immediate consequence of Theorem 2.2 and the identity (1). Corollary 2.3. Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊂ Msa be two abelian families. Then µa¯ ≺ µ¯b if and only if τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )) ≤ τ (f (b1 , . . . , bn )) for every continuous convex function f : Rn → R. We end this section with the following elementary fact about diffuse (scalar) measures, i.e. measures where µ({x}) = 0 for every x. Lemma 2.4. Let K ⊂ Rn be compact and let µ be a regular diffuse Borel probability measure on K. Then for every α ∈ (0, 1) there exists a measurable set S ⊂ K such that µ(S) = α.
3. The local form of doubly stochastic maps This section deals with doubly stochastic maps (see Definition 3.1 below). These maps play an important role in the theory of majorization between self-adjoint operators (see for instance [1, 2, 15, 16]); they will also play a central role in majorization between abelian families in Section 4. For the sake of clarity, several proofs of technical results will be delayed until Section 6. Let A ⊆ M be an abelian C ∗ -subalgebra, and let EA and µA denote the spectral measure and the spectral distribution of A as defined in Section 2.1.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
5
Definition 3.1. 1. A linear map Φ : M → M is said to be doubly stochastic [15] if it is unital, positive, and trace preserving. The set of all doubly stochastic maps on M is denoted by DS(M); 2. if x ∈ Γ(A) is such that EA ({x}) = 0, we say that x is an atom for EA ; 3. the set of atoms of EA is denoted At(EA ); 4. we say that A is diffuse if At(EA ) = ∅; 5. the set D(M) is the convex semigroup D(M) = conv{Adu : u ∈ U(M)}. We will make use of the fact that DS(M) is compact in the BW topology [9], i.e. under pointwise strong convergence. Since µA = τ ◦EA , the faithfulness of the trace implies that At(µA ) =At(EA ). The following theorem states that spectral measures of a separable A can be refined in a coherent way. Theorem 3.2. Let A ⊆ M be a separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebra. Then there exists a ∈ Msa such that C ∗ (A, a) is abelian and diffuse.
Proof. (see Section 6).
Since the atoms of EA are in correspondence with the set of minimal projections of L∞ (A), Theorem 3.2 provides a way to embed A into a separable ˜ has no minimal projections (see C ∗ -subalgebra A˜ = C ∗ (A, a) such that L∞ (A) Remark 6.3 for further discussion). Any operator in a von Neumann algebra can be approximated in norm by linear combinations of projections. In the case of a II1 factor, an added requirement could be for the projections to have equal trace; with such requirement, the norm approximation is usually lost, and only norm-1 and norm-2 approximation can be achieved. What Proposition 3.3 shows is that norm approximation can still be obtained by taking convex combinations of linear combinations of orthogonal families of projections with equal trace. Proposition 3.3. Let B ⊂ M be a separable, diffuse, abelian C ∗ -subalgebra. Then there is an unbounded set M ⊆ N such that for every m ∈ M there exist k = k(m) t,m ) = 1/m (1 ≤ i ≤ partitions of unity {qit,m }m i=1 ⊆ B ∩ M, 1 ≤ t ≤ k, with τ (qi m, 1 ≤ t ≤ k), and such that for each b ∈ B, m k 1 t,m t,m (2) mτ (b qi ) qi lim b − = 0. m→∞ k t=1
i=1
Proof. (see Section 6).
Remark 3.4. For fixed m and partitions of unity {qit }m i=1 , 1 ≤ t ≤ k, the linear map m k 1 t t m τ (b qi ) qi b → k t=1 i=1 is a contraction with respect to the operator norm.
6
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
m Lemma 3.5. Let {pi }m i=1 , {qi }i=1 ⊆ M be partitions of unity such that τ (pi ) = 1 τ (qi ) = m , and let T ∈ DS(M). Let β1 , . . . , βm ∈ R. Then there exists ρ ∈ D(M) such that m m αi pi = ρ βi qi , (3)
where αi = m
i=1
m j=1
i=1
βj τ (T (qj ) pi ), 1 ≤ i ≤ m.
verify that Proof. Let γi,j = m τ (T (qj ) pi ) ≥ 0; it is then straightforward to m γ = (γi,j ) ∈ Rm×m is a doubly stochastic matrix and that αi = j=1 γi,j βj for every i = 1, . . . , m. By Birkhoff’s Theorem [11] the doubly stochastic matrix (γi,j ) can be written as a convexcombination of permutation matrices, i.e. (γi,j ) = σ∈Sm ησ Pσ , where ησ ≥ 0, σ∈Sm ησ = 1 and Pσ is the m × m permutation matrix induced by σ ∈ Sm . Then we have m αi = γi,j βj = (γ · β)i = ησ Pσ · β = ησ βσ(i) , 1 ≤ i ≤ m. (4) j=1
σ∈Sm
i
σ∈Sm
The fact that M is a II1 factor and that the elements of the partitions {pi }i , {qi }i have the same trace guarantees the existence of unitaries uσ such that uσ qσ(i) u∗σ = pi , 1 ≤ i ≤ m, for every σ ∈ Sm . Indeed, if σ ∈ Sm , the equalities, τ (qσ(i) ) = τ (pi ) ∗ imply that there exist partial isometries vi,σ ∈ M such that vi,σ vi,σ = pi and m ∗ vi,σ vi,σ = qσ(i) for i = 1, . . . , m. Thus uσ = i=1 vi,σ ∈ M are the required unitaries. Using equation (4), and letting ρ(· ) = σ∈Sm ησ uσ (· ) u∗σ ∈ D(M), m m m ∗ αi pi = ησ βσ(i) pi = ησ βσ(i) uσ qσ(i) uσ i=1
i=1
=
σ∈Sm
σ∈Sm
ησ uσ
m
σ∈Sm
βi qi
i=1
u∗σ
=ρ
m i=1
i=1
βi qi
.
Lemma 3.6. Let B ⊂ M be a separable C ∗ -subalgebra, and let {pi }m i=1 ⊆ B ∩ M be a partition of unity. Then there exists a sequence {ρi }i∈N ⊂ D(M) such that for every b ∈ B, if we let βi (b) = τ (b pi )/τ (pi ), then m lim ρj (b) − βi (b)pi = 0. j→∞ i=1
Proof. (see Section 6).
Theorem 3.7 (The Local Form). Let A, B ⊆ M be separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebras and let T ∈ DS(M). Let S be the operator subsystem of B given by S = T −1 (A) ∩ B. Then there exists a sequence (ρr )r∈N ⊆ D(M) such that lim T (b) − ρr (b) = 0 r→∞ for every b ∈ S.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
7
Proof. First, note that we just have to prove the theorem for separable diffuse abelian C ∗ -subalgebras of M; indeed, assume it holds for such algebras and let A, B ⊆ M be arbitrary separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebras. Then, by Theorem 3.2 there exist separable diffuse abelian subalgebras A˜ and B˜ of M such that A ⊆ A˜ ˜ Thus we get a sequence {ρr }r∈N ⊆ D such that limr→∞ T (b) − and B ⊆ B. ˜ ∩ B. ˜ So we assume that A and B ρr (b) = 0, for every b ∈ T −1 (A) ∩ B ⊆ T −1 (A) are diffuse. By Proposition 3.3, there exists an unbounded set M ⊆ N and, for each j,m m m ∈ M, k(m) partitions of unity {qij,m }m i=1 ⊆ B ∩ M and {pi }i=1 ⊆ A ∩ M (in order to simplify the notation we suppress the supra-index m and write qij , pji ), 1 ≤ j ≤ k, such that for every b ∈ T (A)−1 ∩ B and every r ∈ N, there exists m0 (r, b) ∈ M such that if m ≥ m0 we have m k j j 1 1 b − (5) β q < k j=1 i=1 i i r m k j j 1 1 T (b) − αi pi < r k j=1 i=1
and
(6)
where βij = m τ (b qij ), αji = m τ (T (b) pji ), τ (pji ) = τ (qij ) = 1/m, (from the construction of such partitions it is evident that we can assume that both have the same unbounded set M and the same k(m) for every m ∈ M). Fix b ∈ B. Since T = 1, it follows from (5) that m k j 1 1 j T (b) − (7) βi T (qi ) ≤ r. k j=1 i=1 Applying to (7) the fact that the linear map in Remark 3.4 is linear and contractive (with {pji }i as the partitions of unity), we get k m k m k j, t 1 j j 1 1 t αi pi − 2 αi pi ≤ , (8) k k j=1 i=1 r t=1 i=1 j=1 m t where αj, = m l=1 βlj τ (T (qlj )pit ), and αji are as defined above. By Lemma 3.5 i there exists ρm j, t ∈ D(M) such that m m j j j, t t m αi pi = ρj, t βl ql , 1 ≤ j, t ≤ k. (9) i=1
l=1
Using (6), (8), and (9) we get m k k j j 2 1 T (b) − ρm βl ql j, t ≤ r, 2 k j=1 t=1 l=1
(10)
8
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
By Lemma 3.6 there exist sequences (˜ ρjn )n∈N ⊆ D(M), 1 ≤ j ≤ k, independent of b, such that for every r ∈ N there exists n0 = n0 (r, b) such that if n ≥ n0 then m 1 j j j (11) βl ql − ρ˜n (b) ≤ , 1 ≤ j ≤ k. r l=1
From (10) and (11), together with the fact that each ρ ∈ D(M) is contractive we get, for every n ≥ n0 (r, b) k k 3 m j ≤ , T (b) − 1 (12) ρ (˜ ρ (b)) j, t n r 2 k j=1 t=1 Consider a dense countable subset {b1 , b2 , . . .} of B. Now define n(r), m(r) as n(r) = max{n0 (r, b1 ), . . . , n0 (r, br )}, m(r) = max{m0 (r, b1 ), . . . , m0 (r, br )} m(r) and let ρr := k12 kj=1 kt=1 ρj, t ◦ ρ˜jn(r) ∈ D(M), where k = k(m(r)). Then, from the previous calculations, we see that T (bj ) − ρr (bj ) < 3/r whenever 1 ≤ j ≤ r. Let b ∈ B, and > 0. Then there exists l ∈ N such that b − bl < /3. If r > max{l, 9/}, then T (bl ) − ρr (bl ) < /3, and so T (b) − ρr (b) ≤ . Corollary 3.8. Let T ∈ DS(M) and let (ai )ni=1 , (bi )ni=1 ⊆ Msa be abelian families such that T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. Then there exists a sequence (ρr )r∈N ⊆ D(M) such that for 1 ≤ i ≤ n limr→∞ ai − ρr (bi ) = 0. Proof. Consider A = C ∗ (a1 , . . . , an ) and B = C ∗ (b1 , . . . , bn ), which are separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebras of M. Applying Theorem 3.7 to these algebras we get a sequence (ρr )r∈N ⊆ D(M) such that limr→∞ T (b) − ρr (b) = 0 for every b ∈ T −1 (A) ∩ B. By hypothesis bi ∈ T −1 (A) ∩ B and so T (bi ) − ρr (bi ) = ai − r → 0. ρr (bi ) −
4. Doubly stochastic kernels and joint majorization We begin by introducing doubly stochastic kernels, which are a natural generalization of doubly stochastic matrices (see Example 4.2). We shall use them to define joint majorization in analogy with [22]. Definition 4.1. Let (X, µX ), (Y, µY ) be two probability spaces. A positive unital ∞ ∞ linear map ν : L (Y, µY ) → L (X, µX ) is said to be a doubly stochastic kernel if X ν(1∆ ) dµX = µY (∆), for every µY -measurable set ∆ ⊆ Y . Doubly stochastic kernels between probability spaces are norm continuous and normal. Example 4.2. Let X and Y be compact spaces and let µX and µY be regular Borel probability measures in X and Y respectively. Consider D ∈ L1 (µX × µY ) and let
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
9
ν(f )(x) = Y D(x, y) f (y) dµY (y). Then ν : L∞ (X, µX ) → L∞ (Y, µY ) is a doubly stochastic kernel if and only if D(x, y) ≥ 0 (µX × µY )-a.e. and D(x, y) dµX (x) = 1, µY -a.e., D(x, y) dµY (y) = 1, µX -a.e. X
Y
In particular, if µX = µY is a measure with finite support {xi }m i=1 and such that 1 µX ({xi }) = m for 1 ≤ i ≤ m then D is a doubly stochastic kernel if and only if the matrix (D(xi , xj ))i, j is an m × m doubly stochastic matrix. Proposition 4.3. Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊆ Msa be abelian families. Then the following statements are equivalent: 1. There exists T ∈ DS(M) such that T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. 2. There exists a doubly stochastic kernel ν : L∞ (σ(¯b), µ¯b ) → L∞ (σ(¯ a), µa¯ ) such that ν(πi ) = πi , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. Proof. Assume first that T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n, with T ∈ DS(M). Let A = C ∗ (a1 , . . . , an ) and B = C ∗ (b1 , . . . , bn ). As M is a finite von Neumann algebra, there exists a conditional expectation PA : M → L∞ (A) that commutes with τ . Then ν = Λ−1 a ¯ ◦ PA ◦ T ◦ Λ¯ b is the desired doubly stochastic kernel. Conversely, let us assume the existence of ν as in (2). Let PB : M → L∞ (B) be the conditional ◦ PB ∈ expectation onto L∞ (B) that commutes with τ . Define T = Λa¯ ◦ ν ◦ Λ¯−1 b DS(M). Clearly T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. Definition 4.4. Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 be two abelian families in Msa . We say that a ¯ is jointly majorized by ¯b (and we write a ¯ ≺ ¯b) if there exists a doubly stochastic kernel ν : L∞ (σ(¯b), µ¯b ) → L∞ (σ(¯ a), µa¯ ) such that ν(πi ) = πi , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. If (x1 , . . . , xn ) is a finite family in M, let UM (x1 , . . . , xn ) denote the joint unitary orbit of the family with respect to the unitary group UM of M, i.e. UM (x1 , . . . , xn ) = {(u∗ x1 u, . . . , u∗ xn u) : u ∈ UM }. We shall also consider the convex hull of the unitary orbit of a family (xi )ni=1 , conv(UM (xi )ni=1 ) = {(ρ(xi ))ni=1 , ρ ∈ D}. We denote by conv(UM (xi )ni=1 ), convw (UM (xi )ni=1 ) and conv1 (UM (xi )ni=1 ) the respective closures in the coordinate-wise norm topology, coordinate-wise weak operator topology, and coordinate-wise L1 topology. Theorem 4.5. Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 be abelian families in Msa . Then the following statements are equivalent: 1. a ¯ ≺ ¯b. 2. a ¯ ∈ conv(UM (¯b)). 3. a ¯ ∈ conv 1 (UM (¯b)). 4. a ¯ ∈ conv w (UM (¯b)). 5. µa¯ ≺ µ¯b . 6. There exists a completely positive T ∈ DS(M) such that ai = T (bi ), 1 ≤ i ≤ n.
10
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
7. There exists T ∈ DS(M) such that ai = T (bi ), 1 ≤ i ≤ n. 8. τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )) ≤ τ (f (b1 , . . . , bn )) for every continuous convex function f : Rn → R. The proof of Theorem 4.5 will be split into several lemmas, and all the pieces will be put together at the end of the section. Remark 4.6. Let x ∈ M be a normal operator. Recall (see the last paragraph of Section 2.1) that there is a natural way to identify the usual spectral measure of x with that of the abelian pair (Re(x), Im(x)). If T ∈ DS(M), then since T is positive T (x) = y if and only if T (Re(x)) = Re(y) and T (Im(x)) = Im(y). Using Theorem 4.5, we see that if x, y ∈ M are normal operators then x ≺ y in the sense of [16] if and only if (Re(x), Im(x)) ≺ (Re(y), Im(y)) in the sense of Definition 4.4. Let PN denote the trace preserving conditional expectation onto the abelian von Neumann subalgebra N ⊆ M. Using Theorem 4.5 we can then obtain a generalization of Theorem 7.2 in [10]. Corollary 4.7. Let N ⊆ M be an abelian von Neumann subalgebra and let (bi )ni=1 ⊆ Msa be an abelian family. Then (PN (bi ))ni=1 ≺ (bi )ni=1 . In the remainder of this section we prove the implications needed to prove Theorem 4.5. The single variable case of the following lemma can be found in [16]. Lemma 4.8 ((4)⇒(6) in Theorem 4.5). Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊆ Msa be abelian families and assume that a ¯ ∈ conv w (UM (¯b)). Then there exists a completely positive T ∈ DS(M) such that ai = T (bi ), 1 ≤ i ≤ n. weakly
Proof. Let {(bj1 , . . . , bjn )}j∈J ⊆ conv(UM (b1 , . . . , bn )) such that bji −−−−→ ai , 1 ≤ j
i ≤ n. Then there exists a sequence (ρj )j∈J ⊆ D(M) such that (bj1 , . . . , bjn ) = (ρj (b1 ), . . . , ρj (bn )), for every j ∈ J. Note that each ρj is a completely positive doubly stochastic map. Since the net {ρj }j∈J is norm bounded, it has an accumulation point in the BW topology [9], i.e. there exists a subnet (which we still call weakly
{ρj }j∈J ) and a completely positive map T : M → M such that ρj (x) −−−−→ T (x) j
if x ∈ M. By normality of the trace, T is trace preserving, positive and unital. weakly Since ρj (bi ) = bji −−−−→ ai , we have T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. j
Lemma 4.9 ((1)⇒(5) in Theorem 4.5). Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊆ Msa be ¯ abelian families. If a ¯ ≺ b, then µa¯ ≺ µ¯b . Proof. The hypothesis a ¯ ≺ ¯b means that there exists a doubly stochastic kernel ∞ ∞ ¯ ) → L (σ(¯ a), µa¯ ) such that ν(πi ) = πi , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. Let ν1 , . . . , νm ∈ ν : L (σ(b), µ¯b m ∼ M+ (Rn ) with j=1 νj = µa¯ . Define measures ν j by νj (∆) = νj (ν(1∆ )). By continuity of ν, νj (f ) = νj (ν(f )) for every f ∈ L∞ (σ(¯b), µ¯b ). So ν j (πi ) = νj (ν(πi )) = νj (πi ), 1 ≤ i ≤ n and 1 ≤ j ≤ m, and similarly νj (1) = ν j (1), so that νj ∼ ν j , m for 1 ≤ j ≤ m. Finally, m ¯ (ν(1∆ )) = µ¯ b (∆). So j=1 ν j (∆) = j=1 νj (ν(1∆ )) = µa m ν = µ . We conclude that µ ≺ µ . ¯ ¯ a ¯ b b j=1 j
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
11
Lemma 4.10 ((5)⇒(1) in Theorem 4.5). Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊂ Msa be abelian families. If µa¯ ≺ µ¯b , then there exists T ∈ DS(M) such that T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. m(r)
a) with diam(∆rj ) Proof. By compactness we can consider partitions {∆rj }j=1 of σ(¯ r r less than 1/r for every 1 ≤ j ≤ m. Fix points x1 , . . . , xm(r) with xrj ∈ ∆rj and define measures µrj by µrj (· ) = µa¯ (· ∩ ∆rj ). Then clearly j µrj = µa¯ . As µa¯ ≺ µ¯b by hypothesis, there exist measures νjr with νjr ∼ µrj and j νjr = µ¯b . Let gjr be the Radon-Nikodym derivatives gjr = dνjr /dµ¯b . Note that j gjr = 1 (µ¯b − a.e.). a) × σ(¯b) → R by Define a function Dr : σ(¯
m(r)
Dr (s, t) =
j=1
gjr (t) 1∆r (s). µa (∆rj ) j
We will use the kernels Dr to approximate T in the BW topology. Let us define a), µa¯ ) by νr : L∞ (σ(¯b), µ¯b ) → L∞ (σ(¯ b(t) Dr (s, t) dµ¯b (t). νr (b)(s) = σ(¯ b)
The map νr can be seen to be doubly stochastic using the equivalence µrj ∼ νjr . By Proposition 4.3 there is an associated sequence {Tr }r ⊂ DS(M) such that Tr (bi ) = σ(¯a) νr (πi ) dEa¯ ∈ L∞ (A), 1 ≤ i ≤ n. The bounded net {Tr }r∈N has a subnet {Tk }k∈K that converges to a cluster point T ∈ DS(M) in the BW topology. Since this subnet is bounded, T (bi ) = w- limk∈K Tk (bi ) ∈ L∞ (A). We claim that T (bi ) = ai , 1 ≤ i ≤ n. To see this, since the net {Tk (bi )}k∈K is bounded, we just have to prove that lim τ (x Tk (bi )) = τ (x ai ), 1 ≤ i ≤ n, ∀x ∈ A. k
Equivalently, we have to show that for every continuous function f ∈ C(σ(¯ a)) and every i = 1, . . . , n, f (s) Dk (s, t) πi (t) dµ¯b (t) dµa¯ (s) = f (s) πi (s) dµa¯ (s). lim k
σ(¯ a)
σ(¯ b)
σ(¯ a)
This can be seen by a standard approximation argument, using the uniform continuity of f , the fact that the diameters of ∆rj tend to 0 as r increases, and the equivalence µrj ∼ νjr . Proof of Theorem 4.5. Proposition 4.3 shows the equivalence (7)⇔(1) and Corollary 3.8 is (7)⇒(2). The implication (2)⇒ (3)⇒(4) is trivial. Lemma 4.8 shows that (4)⇒(6), and it is clear that (6)⇒(7). Lemmas 4.9, 4.10 and Proposition 4.3 prove the equivalence (5)⇔(1). So we have that (1)-(7) are equivalent. Finally, Corollary 2.3 shows that (5)⇔(8).
12
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
5. Joint unitary orbits of abelian families in Msa Given families a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 , ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊆ M, we say that a ¯ and ¯b are jointly approximately unitarily equivalent in M if a ¯ ∈ UM (¯b), that is if there exists a sequence of unitary operators (un )n∈N ⊆ M such that limn→∞ un bi u∗n − ai = 0 for every i = 1 . . . , n. It is clear that this is an equivalence relation. Moreover, if a ¯ and ¯b are jointly approximately unitarily equivalent in M then a ¯ is an abelian family if and only if ¯b is. In [10] a characterization of approximately unitarily equivalence between selfadjoint operators is obtained in terms of the spectral distributions. The main result of this section, Theorem 5.1, characterizes this relation for abelian families in Msa . Theorem 5.1. Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 and ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ⊂ Msa be abelian families. Then the following statements are equivalent: 1. a ¯ and ¯b are jointly approximately unitary equivalent in M. 2. a ¯ ≺ ¯b and ¯b ≺ a ¯ 3. µa¯ = µ¯b 4. τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )) = τ (f (b1 , . . . , bn )) for every continuous convex function f : Rn → R. 5. τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )) = τ (f (b1 , . . . , bn )) for every continuous function f : Rn → R. Proof. By Theorem 4.5 we have (1)⇒(2) and (2)⇔(4). Moreover, (4) is equivalent to µa¯ (f ) = µ¯b (f ) for every convex function f . Then µa¯ (f ) = µ¯b (f ) for every continuous function f [3, Proposition I.1.1], and so µa¯ = µ¯b . Therefore (4)⇒(5)⇒(3). Again, by Theorem 4.5 (3)⇒(2) and so (2)-(5) are equivalent. Finally, we prove a) = supp µa¯ = supp µ¯b = σ(¯b) that (3)⇒(1). If we assume that µa¯ = µ¯b then σ(¯ and for every Borel set ∆ in σ(¯ a) we have τ (Ea¯ (∆)) = µa¯ (1∆ ) = µ¯b (1∆ ) = τ (E¯b (∆)).
(13)
Let > 0. By compactness, choose Borel sets B1 , . . . , Bm to be a finite disjoint covering of σ(¯ a) = σ(¯b) such that there are points xj ∈ Bj with the property that |πi (λ) − πi (xj )| < /2 for every λ ∈ Bj , 1 ≤ i ≤ n, 1 ≤ j ≤ m. Then we get, using the Spectral Theorem, m m ai − πi (xj )Ea¯ (Bj ) < , bi − πi (xj )E¯b (Bj ) < 2 2 j=1 j=1 for i = 1, . . . , n. From equation (13) we get that τ (Ea¯ (Bj )) = τ (E¯b (Bj )) for every j = 1, . . . , m. As in the proof of Lemma 3.5, we get a unitary w ∈ U(M) such that w∗ E¯b (Bj )w = Ea¯ (Bj ) for every j. Then m m πi (xj )E¯b (Bj ) w = πi (xj )Ea¯ (Bj ). w∗ j=1
j=1
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
13
Finally, for every i we have
m ∗ ∗ w bi w − ai ≤ w bi − πi (xj )E¯b (Bj ) w + 2 < . j=1
Corollary 5.2. Let Θ be a ∗-automorphism of M. Then Θ|A is approximately inner for each separable abelian C ∗ subalgebra A ⊂ M. Proof. The uniqueness of the trace guarantees that Θ is trace-preserving. Being multiplicative, the range of an abelian set will be again abelian. So Θ is a DS map that takes an abelian family in M into another. Consider a countable dense subset {ai } of A, and use Theorem 5.1 to obtain unitaries un for each finite subset {a1 , . . . , an }. An /3 argument shows then that the sequence {Ad un } approximates Θ in all of A. s
x) the closure in the coordinateGiven x ¯ = (xi )ni=1 ⊆ M we denote by UM (¯ wise strong operator topology. An immediate consequence of Theorem 5.1 is that the norm closure of the unitary orbit of a selfadjoint abelian family in a II1 factor is strongly closed. This generalizes [10, Theorem 5.4] and [26, Theorem 8.12(1)]:
Corollary 5.3. Let a ¯ = (ai )ni=1 ⊆ Msa be an abelian family. Then UM (¯ a) s UM (¯ a) .
=
s Proof. Let ¯b = (bi )ni=1 ∈ UM (¯ a) . There exists a net (bj1 , . . . , bjn )j∈J ⊆ UM (¯ a) such that bji converges strongly to bi for each i = 1, . . . , n. Let f : Rn → R be a continuous function. Then τ (f (bj1 , . . . , bjn )) = τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )) for every j. Using [27, Lemma II.4.3] we conclude that τ (f (b1 , . . . , bn )) = τ (f (a1 , . . . , an )). So (5) of a). The other inclusion is trivial. Theorem 5.1 implies that ¯b ∈ UM (¯
6. Some technical results In this section we prove several results presented in Section 3. First we show that any separable abelian C ∗ -subalgebra of M can be embedded into a separable diffuse abelian C ∗ -subalgebra. Then we prove some approximation results that hold for separable diffuse abelian C ∗ subalgebras of M. 6.1. Refinements of spectral measures We begin by recalling some elementary facts about inclusions of abelian C ∗ algebras. If A ⊆ B are unital abelian C ∗ -algebras, then the function Φ : Γ(B) → Γ(A) given by Φ(γ) = γ|A is a continuous surjection onto Γ(A). If we assume further that A ⊆ B ⊆ M are separable and that EA , EB denote their spectral measures, then EA = EB ◦ Φ−1 and µA = µB ◦ Φ−1 . Note that At(µA ) =At(EA ) where At(EA ) is the set of atoms of the spectral measure EA (see the beginning of Section 3). Let x∈At(EA ) µA ({x}) be the total
14
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
atomic mass of EA . Since µA is finite, the total atomic mass is bounded and thus the set of atoms is a countable set. The two results below lead to the proof of Theorem 3.2. Lemma 6.1. With the notations above, if x ∈ At (EB ) then Φ(x) ∈ At (EA ), and the total atomic mass of B is smaller that the total atomic mass of A. Proof. Let x ∈ At(EB ) and note that 0 < µB ({x}) ≤ µB (Φ−1 (Φ({x}))) = µA (Φ({x})), so Φ(x) ∈ At(EA ) = At(µA ). We consider the equivalence relation in At(EB ) induced by Φ, i.e. x ∼ y if Φ(x) = Φ(y). If Q ∈ Q := At(EB )/ ∼ is such that Φ(x) = xQ for every x ∈ Q, then using that Q is countable we get x∈Q µB ({x}) = µB (Q) ≤ µB (Φ−1 ({xQ })) = µA ({xQ }). Therefore µB ({x}) = µB ({x}) ≤ µA ({xQ }) ≤ µA ({x}). x∈At(EB )
Q∈Q x∈Q
Q∈Q
x∈At(EA )
Proposition 6.2. With the notations above, let x0 ∈ Γ(A) be an atom of EA and let α, β ∈ R with 0 < α < β. Then there exists a ∈ A ∩ Msa with [α, β] ⊆ σ(a) ⊆ [α, β] ∪ {0}, PR(a) = EA ({x0 }), and such that if B = C ∗ (A, a) ⊂ M, then EB has no atoms in the fibre Φ−1 (x0 ). ˜ Then pA˜ Proof. Let p = EA ({x0 }) and consider a masa A˜ ⊂ M such that A ⊂ A. 1 τ . It is well known that is a masa in the II1 factor pMp, where the trace is τp = τ (p) there exists a countably generated, non-atomic von Neumann subalgebra A˜0 of pA˜ such that there is a von Neumann algebra isomorphism Φ : L∞ ([0, 1], m) → A˜0 , 1 ˜ = Φ(id); with m the Lebesgue measure on [0, 1], and τp (Φ(f )) = 0 f dm. Put a it is clear that a ˜ has no atoms in its spectrum with the exception of 0, and that a +α p, so [α, β] ⊆ σ(a) ⊆ [α, β]∪{0}, Ea˜ ({0}) = 1−p, σ(a) = [0, 1]. Let a = (β −α)˜ PR(a) = p = EA ({x0 }). As p is a minimal projection in L∞ (A), for every b ∈ A we have pb = pbp = λb p and so ab = apb = λb pa = bpa = ba. Thus a ∈ A ∩ M. Let B = C ∗ (A, a) and let Φ : Γ(B) → Γ(A), Ψ : Γ(B) → Γ(C ∗ (a)) be the continuous surjections induced by the inclusions A ⊆ B and C ∗ (a) ⊆ B. Note that the restriction Ψ|Φ−1 (x0 ) is injective. Indeed, let x, y ∈ Φ−1 (x0 ) be such that Ψ(x) = Ψ(y), i.e. the restriction of the characters to C ∗ (a) coincide. Since Φ(x) = Φ(y) (= x0 ), the characters also coincide on A and therefore are equal as characters in B, since B is generated by A and C ∗ (a). On the other hand, if x ∈ Γ(B) is such that x(a) = 0, then Φ(x) = x0 . Indeed, assume that Φ(x) = x0 . Let f ∈ C(Γ(A)) with f (Φ(x)) = 0 and f (x0 ) = 1. So f ◦ Φ ≥ 1Φ−1 (x0 ) . But then f ◦ Φ dEB ≥ 1Φ−1 (x0 ) dEB = EB (Φ−1 (x0 )) = EA ({x0 }) = p. Γ(B)
Γ(B)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
15
Note that if 0 ∈ σ(a) then it is an isolated point, and so in any case we have p ∈ C ∗ (a) ⊆ B. Then 0 = f ◦ Φ(x) ≥ x(p) ≥ 0, so x(p) = 0. Since 0 ≤ a ≤ β p, x(a) = 0 and the claim follows. Now let z ∈ Φ−1 (x0 ). If z(a) = 0, from the first part of the proof we deduce that Ψ−1 (Ψ(z)) = {z}. Therefore EB ({z}) = EA ({Ψ(z})) = 0, since Ψ(z)(a) = 0 and At(EA ) ⊆ {0}. If z(a) = 0, then {z} = =
Φ−1 (x0 ) \ {x ∈ Φ−1 (x0 ) : x(a) = 0} Φ−1 (x0 ) \ Ψ−1 ({x ∈ Γ(C ∗ (a)) : x(a) = 0})
and EB (Ψ−1 ({x ∈ Γ(C ∗ (a)) : x(a) = 0})) = = From this we conclude that EB ({z}) = 0.
EA ({x ∈ Γ(C ∗ (a)) : x(a) = 0}) EA ({x0 }) = EB (Φ−1 (x0 )).
Proof of Theorem 3.2. Recall that the set At(EA ) of atoms of EA is a (possibly infinite) countable set. If At(EA ) = ∅ then EA is already diffuse and we are done. Otherwise, let us enumerate At(EA ) = {xi : 1 ≤ i ≤ r}, where r ∈ N ∪ {∞}. For
1 1 , 1+ 2n−1 ]. Then Ii ∩ 1≤i =j≤r Ij = ∅ and ri=1 Ii ⊆ [1, 2]. 1 ≤ i ≤ r, let Ii = [1+ 2n For each i = 1, . . . , r there exists, by Proposition 6.2, ai ∈ A ∩ Msa such that PR(ai ) = EA ({xi }), Ii ⊆ σ(ai ) ⊆ Ii ∪ {0}, and such that EAi has no atoms
in the fibre Φ−1 the continuous surjection i (xi ), where Φi : Γ(Ai ) → A denotes induced by the inclusion A ⊆ Ai := C ∗ (A, ai ). Let a = ri=1 ai ∈ A ∩ Msa (this sum converges strongly because the ranges of the operators ai are orthogonal and ai ≤ 2 for every i). Then B = C ∗ (A, a) is an abelian subalgebra of M. We claim that the spectral measure EB of B has no atoms. Indeed, first note that 1Ii ∈ C(∪1≤j≤r Ij ) is a continuous function (because the distance between the sets Ii and ∪i =j Ij is positive); then, since 1Ii (a) = ai , it follows that Ai ⊂ B for every i = 1, . . . , r. Assume now that x ∈ At(Γ(B)) and let Φ : Γ(B) → Γ(A) be as before. By Lemma 6.1 there exists i ∈ {1, . . . , r} such that Φ(x) = xi ∈ At(EA ) . Since Φ = Φi ◦ Ψi , where Ψi : Γ(B) → Γ(Ai ) is the surjection induced by the inclusion Ai ⊆ B, we conclude that Ψi (x) ∈ Φ−1 i (xi ) is an atom of the measure EAi , again by Lemma 6.1. But this last assertion is a contradiction because by construction there are no atoms in the fibre Φ−1 i (xi ).
Remark 6.3. Given an abelian C ∗ subalgebra A ⊂ M, a direct way to find an abelian C ∗ -subalgebra A ⊆ A˜ ⊂ M with diffuse spectral measure is to consider a masa in M that contains A. Theorem 3.2 shows that A˜ can be chosen separable (as a C ∗ -algebra) whenever A is separable. When this is the case, the character space of A˜ is metrizable, a fact that is crucial for our calculations. 6.2. Discrete approximations in separable diffuse abelian algebras Given a compact metric space it is always possible to find, using uniform continuity, discrete uniform approximations of continuous functions by linear combinations of characteristic functions of certain sets {Qi }m i=1 . But if we consider a measure on
16
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
this space and we require equal measures for these sets, there might not be any good uniform approximation based on characteristic functions (even for measures of compact support in the real line). Proposition 3.3 is an intermediate solution to this problem. It was inspired by the proof of [16, Lemma 4.1]. The idea is to use convex combinations to “distribute” the part of the projections that does not fit in an equal measure partition. Proof of Proposition 3.3. As the space Γ(B) is a metrizable compact topological space, we consider a metric d in Γ(B) inducing its topology. Let r ∈ N; by ˜ i ) < 1 and ˜ i }k0 of Γ(B) with diamd (Q compactness, there exists a partition {Q i=1 r k0 ˜ i ) = 1. Let m = m(r) be such that 1/m ≤ min{µB (Q ˜ j )2 : 1 ≤ j ≤ k0 }. µ ( Q B i=1 ˜ j ) = kj /m + δj with 0 ≤ Then for 1 ≤ j ≤ k0 there exists kj ∈ N such that µB (Q ˜ ˜ j )−1 , 1 ≤ j ≤ k0 }. δj < 1/m. If we let k˜ = k(r) = minj {kj } then k˜ ≥ max{µB (Q k j t ˜ ˜ } ˜ For t = 1, . . . , k0 , choose k˜ partitions {Q j,s s=0 of each Qj (1 ≤ t ≤ k), with t t t ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜1 , µB (Qj,s ) = 1/m if 1 ≤ s ≤ kj and µB (Qj,0 ) = δj , in such a way that Qj,0 ⊂ Q j, t ˜ Note that we can always make such a choice: using Lemma 2.4 choose 2 ≤ t ≤ k. ˜ 1 with µB (Q ˜ t ) = δj < 1/m, and then take a partition {Q ˜ t }kj of ˜t ⊆ Q Q j,0 j, t j,0 j,s s=1 ˜j \ Q ˜ t using again Lemma 2.4 (note that µB (Q ˜j \ Q ˜ t ) = kj /m). By this choice, Q j,0 j,0 ˜t ∩ Q ˜ t = ∅ if t = t . Q j,0 j,0 ˜ let Q ˜ t . Then ˜ t0,0 = ∪k0 Q For each t = 1, . . . , k, j,0
j=1
˜t ) = 1 − µB (Q 0,0
kj j
m
=
k0 1 (m − kj ). m j=1
˜ t into n1 = m − kj subsets {Q ˜ t }n1 of Finally, make partitions of each set Q 0,0 i i=1 j ˜ t }i , we end up with k˜ ˜ t }j, s ∪ {Q measure 1/m. By re-labeling the k˜ partitions {Q j,s i m m ˜ such that: }i=1 , for 1 ≤ t ≤ k, partitions {Qt, i t, m ˜ 1. µB (Q ) = 1/m, for every i ∈ {1, . . . , m}, t ∈ {1, . . . , k}; i
m 2. diamd (Qt, ) ≤ 1/r, if i > n1 ; i m 3. if 1 ≤ i, i ≤ n1 then Qt, ∩ Qti , m = ∅ if i = i or t = t . i
m m }i=1 was done in such Note that the construction of the k partitions {Qt, i a way that the subsets that do not have small diameters are disjoint, even for different partitions. ˜ Let M = {m(r), r ≥ 1} and for every m = m(r) ∈ M let k(m) = k(r) as det,m t, m fined above and, for i, t, m, let qi = EB (Qi ). The set M is unbounded because ˜ the measure µB being diffuse makes limr→∞ m(r) = ∞, and so limr→∞ k(r) = ∞. For each t = 1, . . . , k, {qit,m }m ⊂ B ∩ M is a partition of unity. i=1 Let b ∈ B, > 0, and let f ∈ C(Γ(B)) be such that b = Γ(B) f dEB . Then, by compactness, there exists δ > 0 such that if Q ⊆ Γ(B) with diamd (Q) < δ then diam(f (Q)) < . Let r ∈ N be such that 1/r < δ and 2b/k(r) ≤ ; let
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
m = m(r) ∈ M, and let βit,m = m τ (b qit,m ) = m translate into
Qt,m i
17
f dµB . Properties 1-3
1’. τ (qit,m ) = 1/m, for every i ∈ {1, . . . , m}, t ∈ {1, . . . , k}; 2’. if i > n1 , then |f (x) − βit,m | ≤ , ∀x ∈ Qt,m i ; t,m t ,m 3’. if 1 ≤ i, i ≤ n1 then qi ⊥ qi if i = i or t = t . Therefore we have k m 1 t,m t,m βi qi = b − k t=1 i=1
=
k m 1 t,m t,m b− βi qi k t=1
i=1
k m 1 t,m (f − βi ) dEB k Qt,m i t=1 i=1
≤
n1 k 1 (f − βit,m ) dEB + t,m k Qi t=1 i=1
≤
n1 k 2 b t,m qi + k t=1 i=1
=
2b + ≤ 2, k
where the first inequality is a consequence of 2’ and the last equality follows from 3’. Proof of Lemma 3.6. Fix a norm dense subset B = (bj )j∈N ⊆ B. In the construction leading to Dixmier’s Theorem, a previous result [20, 8.3.4] asserts that for each j, there exists a sequence {ρnj }n∈N ⊆ D(M) such that for every 1 ≤ h ≤ j, n ρnj (bh ) − τ (bh ) I − → 0. For each j ∈ N, let n0 = n0 (j) ∈ N be such that if n ≥ n0 n (j)
then ρnj (bh ) − τ (bh ) I ≤ 1/j for 1 ≤ h ≤ j. If we let ρj = ρj 0 j
for j ∈ N, we
get ρj (bh ) − τ (bh ) I − → 0 for every h ∈ N. Since (bj )j∈N is norm dense in B we have limj ρj (b) − τ (b) I = 0 for every b ∈ B. For every i = 1, . . . , m, consider the factor pi Mpi with (normalized) trace τi (pi x) = τ (xpi )/τ (pi ) . By the Dixmier approximation property mentioned in the first paragraph, applied to the separable C ∗ -subalgebra pi B of the finite factor pi Mpi , there exists a sequence {ρij }j∈N ∈ D(pi Mpi ) such that limj→∞ ρij (pi b) − τi (pi b)pi = 0, for every b ∈ B. For each ρ ∈ D(pi Mpi ), we can consider an extension ρ˜ ∈ D(M) as follows: if ρ(pi b) = kh=1 λh uh b u∗h , with uh ∈ U(pi Mpi ), define ρ˜ ∈ D(M) by ρ˜(b) = k m ˜h b u ˜∗h , where u ˜h = uh + (1 − pi ) ∈ U(M). If 1 ≤ i ≤ m set ρj = i=1 ρ˜ji h=1 λh u for j ≥ 1. It is easy to verify that if 1 ≤ i ≤ m then ρj (b pi ) = ρ˜ji (b pi ) for every
18
Argerami and Massey
IEOT
b ∈ B. Thus, if b ∈ B, then m m βi (b)pi = ρ˜ji (b pi ) − τi (b pi )pi −−−→ 0. ρj (b) − j→∞ i=1
i=1
Ackowledgements. We wish to thank Professors D. Farenick and D. Stojanoff for their support and useful discussions regarding the material in this paper.
References [1] P.M. Alberti and A. Uhlmann, Stochasticity and partial order. Doubly stochastic maps and unitary mixing. Mathematische Monographien, 18. VEB Deutscher Verlag der Wissenschaften, Berlin, 1981. [2] P.M. Alberti, and A. Uhlmann, Dissipative motion in state spaces. Teubner-Texte zur Mathematik, 33. BSB B. G. Teubner Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig, 1981. [3] E.M. Alfsen, Compact Convex Sets and Boundary Integrals, Springer-Verlag, New York, NY 1971. [4] T. Ando, Majorization, doubly stochastic matrices and comparison of eigenvalues, Lecture Notes, Hokkaido Univ., 1982. [5] J. Antezana, P. Massey, and D. Stojanoff, Jensen’s Inequality and Majorization, J. Math. Anal. App. 331 1 (2007), 297–307. [6] J. Antezana, P. Massey, M. Ruiz and D. Stojanoff, The Schur-Horn theorem for operators and frames with prescribed norms and frame operator, Illinois J. of Math. 51 2 (2007), 537–560. [7] M. Argerami and P. Massey, A Schur-Horn Theorem in II1 factors, Indiana Univ. Math. J., 56, 5 (2007), 2051–2060. [8] M. Argerami and P. Massey, A contractive version of a Schur-Horn theorem in II1 factors, J. Math. Anal. App., 337, 1 (2008), 231–238. [9] W. Arveson, Subalgebras of C ∗ -algebras Acta Math. 123 (1969), 141–224. [10] W. Arveson and R. Kadison, Diagonals of self-adjoint operators, In D. R. Larson D. Han, P. E. T. Jorgensen, editor, Operator theory, operator algebras and applications, Contemp. Math. Amer. Math. Soc., 2006. [11] G. Birkhoff, Three observations on linear algebra. (Spanish) Univ. Nac. Tucum´ an. Revista A. 5 (1946), 147–151. [12] J.B. Conway, A course in functional analysis, Springer-Verlag, New York, NY 1990. [13] T. Fack, Sur la notion de valeur caract´eristique, J. Operator Theory (1982), 307–333. [14] D.R. Farenick and S.M. Manjegani, Young’s Inequality in Operator Algebras, J. Ramanujan Math. Soc. 20, 2 (2005), 107–124. [15] F. Hiai, Majorization and Stochastic maps in von Neumann algebras, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 127, 1 (1987), 18–48. [16] F. Hiai, Spectral majorization between normal operators in von Neumann algebras, Operator algebras and operator theory (Craiova, 1989), 78–115, Pitman Res. Notes Math. Ser., 271, Longman Sci. Tech., Harlow, 1992.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Local Form of Stochastic Maps and Joint Majorization
19
[17] F. Hiai and Y. Nakamura, Closed Convex Hulls of Unitary Orbits in von Neumann Algebras, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 323 (1991), 1–38. [18] R. Kadison, The Pythagorean theorem I: the finite case, Proc. N.A.S. (USA), 99, 7 (2002), 4178–4184. [19] R. Kadison, The Pythagorean theorem II: the infinite discrete case, Proc. N.A.S. (USA), 99, 8 (2002), 5217–5222. [20] R. Kadison and J. Ringrose, Fundamentals of the Theory of Operator Algebras, Vol. II, Academic Press, Orlando, Florida, 1986. [21] E. Kamei, Majorization in finite factors, Math. Japonica 28, 4 (1983), 495–499. [22] F.D. Mart´ınez Per´ıa, P. Massey, L. Silvestre, Weak matrix majorization. Linear Algebra Appl. 403 (2005), 343–368. [23] P. Massey, Refinements of spectral resolutions and modelling of o perators in II1 factors, J. Operator Theory, to appear. [24] A. Neumann, An infinite-dimensional version of the Schur-Horn convexity theorem, J. Funct. Anal. 161 (1999), 418–451. [25] W. Rudin, Real and complex analysis. Third edition. McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York, 1987. [26] D. Sherman, Unitary orbits of normal operators in von Neumann algebras, Journal fur die Reine und Angewandte Mathematik 605 (2007), 95–132. [27] M. Takesaki, Theory of Operator Algebras I, Encyclopaedia of Mathematical Sciences V, Springer Verlag, 2nd printing of the First Edition 1979. Mart´ın Argerami Department of Mathematics and Statistics University of Regina Saskatchewan, S4S 0A2 Canada e-mail:
[email protected] Pedro Massey Departamento de Matem´ atica Facultad de Ciencias Exactas Universidad Nacional de La Plata Argentina e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: October 29, 2006 Revised: December 22, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 21–43 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010021-23, published online March 13, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1571-z
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Resolvent Estimates for Operators Belonging to Exponential Classes Oscar F. Bandtlow Abstract. For a, α > 0 let E(a, α) be the set of all compact operators A on a separable Hilbert space such that sn (A) = O(exp(−anα )), where sn (A) denotes the n-th singular number of A. We provide upper bounds for the norm of the resolvent (zI − A)−1 of A in terms of a quantity describing the departure from normality of A and the distance of z to the spectrum of A. As a consequence we obtain upper bounds for the Hausdorff distance of the spectra of two operators in E(a, α). Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A10; Secondary 47B06, 47B07. Keywords. Resolvent growth, exponential class, departure from normality, bounds for spectral distance.
1. Introduction Let A and B be compact operators on a Hilbert space. It is known that if A − B is small then the spectra of A and B are close in a suitable sense (for example, with respect to the Hausdorff metric on the space of compact subsets of C). Just how close are they? Standard perturbation theory gives bounds in terms of quantities that require a rather detailed knowledge of the spectral properties of both operators, for example the norms of the resolvents of A and B along contours in the complex plane, which are difficult to obtain in practice. The main concern of this article is to derive an upper bound for the norm of the resolvent (zI − A)−1 of an operator A belonging to certain subclasses of compact operators in terms of simple, readily computable quantities, typically involving the distance of z to the spectrum of A and a number measuring the departure from normality of A. As a result, we obtain simple upper bounds for the Hausdorff distance of the spectra of two operators in these subclasses. Estimates of this type have previously been obtained for operators in the Schatten classes
22
Bandtlow
IEOT
(see [Gil, Ban]) and more generally (but less sharp), for operators belonging to Φ-ideals (see [Pok]). These subclasses, termed exponential classes, are constructed as follows. For a, α > 0 let E(a, α) denote the collection of all compact operators on a separable Hilbert space for which sn (A) = O(exp(−anα )), where sn (A) denotes the n-th singular number of A. As we shall see, E(a, α) is not a linear space (see Remark 2.9), hence a fortiori not an operator ideal, and may thus be viewed as a slightly pathological object in this context. There is nevertheless compelling reason to consider these classes: on the one hand, the resolvent bounds given in [Ban, Gil, Pok], while applicable to operators in E(a, α), can be improved significantly (see Remark 3.2), the lack of linear structure posing almost no problem for the derivation of these improvements. On the other hand, operators belonging to exponential classes arise naturally in a number of different ways. For example, if A is an integral operator with real analytic kernel given as a function on [0, 1]d × [0, 1]d , then A ∈ E(a, 1/d) for some a > 0 (see [KR]). Other examples of operators in the exponential class E(a, 1/d) for some a > 0 include composition operators on Bergman spaces over domains in Cd whose symbols are strict contractions, or more generally transfer operators corresponding to holomorphic map-weight systems on Cd , the latter providing one of the motivations to look more closely into the properties of operators belonging to exponential classes (see Example 2.3 (iv) and [BanJ1, BanJ2, BanJ3]). This article is organised as follows. In Section 2 we define the exponential classes and study some of their properties. In particular, we shall give a sharp description of the behaviour of exponential classes under addition (see Proposition 2.8), and a sharp characterisation of the eigenvalue asymptotics of an operator in a given exponential class (see Proposition 2.10). Some of the arguments in this section rely on results concerning monotonic arrangements of sequences, which are presented in the Appendix. In Section 3 we will use techniques similar to those already employed in [Ban] to obtain resolvent estimates for operators in E(a, α) (see Theorem 3.13). In particular we shall give a sharp estimate for the growth of the resolvent of a quasi-nilpotent operator in E(a, α) (see Proposition 3.1). These estimates will then be used in the final section to deduce Theorem 4.2, which provides spectral variation and spectral distance formulae for operators in E(a, α). Notation 1.1. Throughout this article H and Hi will be assumed to be separable Hilbert spaces. We use L(H1 , H2 ) to denote the Banach space of bounded linear operators from H1 to H2 equipped with the usual norm and S∞ (H1 , H2 ) ⊂ L(H1 , H2 ) to denote the closed subspace of compact operators from H1 to H2 . We shall often write L or S∞ if the Hilbert spaces H1 and H2 are understood. For A ∈ S∞ (H1 , H2 ) we use sk (A) := inf { A − F : F ∈ L(H1 , H2 ), rank(F ) < k }
(k ∈ N)
to denote the k-th approximation number of A, and s(A) to denote the sequence {sk (A)}∞ k=1 . The spectrum and the resolvent set of A ∈ L(H, H) will be denoted by σ(A) ∞ and (A), respectively. For A ∈ S∞ (H, H) we let λ(A) = {λk (A)}k=1 denote the
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
23
sequence of eigenvalues of A, each eigenvalue repeated according to its algebraic multiplicity, and ordered by magnitude, so that |λ1 (A)| ≥ |λ2 (A)| ≥ . . .. Similarly, ∞ we write |λ(A)| for the sequence {|λk (A)|}k=1 . We note that the approximation numbers coincide with the singular numbers, that is, sk (A) = λk (A∗ A) (k ∈ N) , where A∗ ∈ L(H2 , H1 ) denotes the adjoint of A ∈ L(H1 , H2 ). For more information about these notions see, for example, [Pie, GK, DS, Rin].
2. Exponential classes Exponential classes arise by grouping together all operators A whose singular numbers sn (A) decay at a given (stretched) exponential rate, that is, sn (A) = O(exp(−anα )) for fixed a > 0 and α > 0. Our main concern in this section will be to investigate how these classes behave under addition and multiplication, and to determine the rate of decay of the eigenvalue sequence of an operator in a given class. Some of the arguments in this section depend on results concerning monotonic arrangements of sequences, which are discussed in the Appendix. Definition 2.1. Let a > 0 and α > 0. Then E(a, α) := x ∈ CN : |x|a,α := sup |xn | exp(anα ) < ∞ , n∈N
and E(a, α; H1 , H2 ) :=
A ∈ S∞ (H1 , H2 ) : |A|a,α := sup sn (A) exp(an ) < ∞ α
.
n∈N
are called exponential classes of type (a, α) of sequences and operators, respectively. The numbers |x|a,α and |A|a,α are called (a, α)-gauge or simply gauge of x and A, respectively. Whenever the Hilbert spaces are clear from the context, we suppress reference to them and simply write E(a, α) instead of E(a, α; H1 , H2 ). Remark 2.2. Note that E(a, α) is a Banach space when equipped with the gauge |·|a,α . On the other hand, the set E(a, α), the non-commutative analogue of E(a, α), is not even a linear space in general (see Proposition 2.8 and Remark 2.9 below). The reason for this is that if a sequence lies in E(a, α) then a rearrangement of this sequence need not; in particular E(a, α) is not a Calkin space in the sense of [Sim2, p. 26] (cf. also [Cal]). However, E(a, α; H, H) turns out to be a pre-ideal (see Remark 2.6). Operators belonging to exponential classes arise naturally in a number of different contexts.
24
Bandtlow
IEOT
Example 2.3. (i) Let σ be a complex measure on the circle group T such that its Fourier transform satisfies | σ (n)| ≤ exp(−a|n|) (n ∈ Z) . It is not difficult to see that this is the case if and only if σ is absolutely continuous with respect to Haar measure on T and the corresponding Radon-Nikod´ ym derivative is holomorphic on T . Let L2 (T ) be the complex Hilbert space of square-integrable functions on T , with respect to Haar measure on T . Let A : L2 (T ) −→ L2 (T ) be the convolution operator Af = f ∗ σ . ∗σ (Z) ∪ {0} = The spectrum of A is σ (Z) ∪ {0} and the spectrum of A∗ A equals σ | σ (Z)| ∪ {0}, where d σ (t) = dσ(t−1 ) (cf. [BerF, p. 87]). Moreover, A is a compact operator and the non-zero eigenvalues of A are precisely the numbers σ (n) for n ∈ Z. In order to locate A in the scale of exponential classes, we enumerate the eigenvalues of A as follows (−1)n (2n + (−1)n − 1) (n ∈ N). xn = σ 4 Then the sequence x belongs to the class E(a/2, 1) with |x|1/2,1 ≤ exp(a/2) since (−1)n n σ (2n + (−1) − 1) 4 (−1)n n ≤ exp −a (2n + (−1) − 1) 4 a
a
a
≤ exp − (n − 1) = exp exp − n . 2 2 2 By Corollary 5.4 the decreasing arrangement x(+) of x also belongs to E(a/2, 1) with |x(+) |1/2,1 ≤ exp(a/2). Thus s(A) = |λ(A)| ∈ E(a/2, 1) and it follows that A ∈ E(a/2, 1) with |A|a/2,1 ≤ exp(a/2). (ii) A variant of the above example is discussed by K¨onig and Richter [KR], who showed that if A is an integral operator on the space of Lebesgue squareintegrable functions on the d-dimensional unit-cube [0, 1]d whose kernel is real analytic on [0, 1]d × [0, 1]d , then A ∈ E(1/d). (iii) For a domain Ω ⊂ Rd with d > 1 let h2 (Ω) be the Bergman space of Lebesgue square-integrable harmonic functions on Ω. If Ω1 , Ω2 ⊂ Rd are two domains such that Ω2 is compactly contained in Ω1 , that is Ω2 is a compact subset of Ω1 , then the canonical embedding J : h2 (Ω1 ) → h2 (Ω2 ) given by Jf = f |Ω2 belongs to the exponential class E(1/(d − 1)). Moreover, for domains Ω1 and Ω2 with simple geometries it is possible to sharply locate J in an exponential class E(a, 1/(d − 1)) and calculate the corresponding (a, 1/(d − 1))-gauge of J exactly. See [BanC].
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
25
(iv) For Ω ⊂ Cd a bounded domain, let L2Hol (Ω) denote the Bergman space of holomorphic functions which are square-integrable with respect to 2d-dimensional Lebesgue measure on Ω. Given a collection {φ1 , . . . , φK } of holomorphic maps φk : Ω → Ω and a collection {w1 , . . . , wK } of bounded holomorphic functions wk : Ω → C consider the corresponding linear operator A on L2Hol (Ω) given by Af :=
K
wk · f ◦ φk .
k=1
If ∪k φk (Ω) is compactly contained in Ω (see the previous example for the definition) then A is a compact endomorphism of L2Hol (Ω) and A ∈ E(a, 1/d), where a depends on the geometry of Ω and ∪k φk (Ω) (see [BanJ3]). Operators of this type, known as transfer operators, play an important role in the ergodic theory of expanding dynamical systems due to the remarkable fact that their spectral data can be used to gain insight into geometric and dynamic invariants of a given expanding dynamical system (see [Rue]). As a consequence, it is of interest to determine spectral properties of these operators exactly, or at least to a given accuracy. The latter problem, namely that of calculating rigorous error bounds for spectral approximation procedures for these operators provided one of the main motivations to study operators in exponential classes (see [BanJ3]). We shall now study some of the properties of the classes E(a, α). First we note that if we order the indices (a, α) reverse lexicographically, that is, by defining (a, α) ≺ (a , α ) :⇔ (α < α ) or (α = α and a < a ), then we obtain the following inclusions. Proposition 2.4. Let a, a > 0 and α, α > 0. Then (i) (a, α) ≺ (a , α ) ⇔ E(a , α ) E(a, α); (ii) (a, α) ≺ (a , α ) ⇔ E(a , α ) E(a, α). Proof. The proof of (i) is straightforward and will be omitted. Assertion (ii) follows from (i) together with the observation that A ∈ E(a, α) iff s(A) ∈ E(a, α) and the fact that for every monotonically decreasing x ∈ E(a, α) there is a compact A with s(A) = x. While E(a, α) is not, in general, a linear space, it does enjoy the following closure properties. Proposition 2.5. Let a, α > 0. If A ∈ L(H2 , H1 ), B ∈ E(a, α; H3 , H2 ), and C ∈ L(H4 , H3 ), then |ABC|a,α ≤ A |B|a,α C. In particular, L(H2 , H1 ) E(a, α; H3 , H2 ) L(H4 , H2 ) ⊂ E(a, α; H4 , H1 ). Proof. Follows from sk (ABC) ≤ A sk (B) C for k ∈ N (see [Pie, 2.2]).
26
Bandtlow
IEOT
Remark 2.6. The proposition implies that L(H, H) E(a, α; H, H) L(H, H) ⊂ E(a, α; H, H) . Thus the classes E(a, α; H, H), while lacking linear structure, satisfy part of the definition of an operator ideal. In other words, E(a, α; H, H) is what is sometimes referred to as a pre-ideal (see, for example, [Nel]). We now consider in more detail the relation between different exponential classes under addition. We start with a general result concerning the singular numbers of a sum of operators. Proposition 2.7. Let Ak ∈ S∞ (H1 , H2 ) for 1 ≤ k ≤ K. Then K
sn Ak ≤ Kσn (n ∈ N), k=1
where σ denotes the decreasing arrangement (see the Appendix) of the K singular number sequences s(A1 ), . . . , s(AK ). Proof. Set A := representations
K k=1
Ak . The compactness of the Ak means they have Schmidt
Ak =
∞
(k)
sl (Ak )al
(k)
⊗ bl ,
l=1 (k)
(k)
where {al }l∈N and {bl }l∈N are suitable orthonormal systems in H1 and H2 respectively. Here a ⊗ b, where a ∈ H1 and b ∈ H2 , denotes the rank-1 operator H1 → H2 given by (a ⊗ b)x = (x, a)H1 b . Let ν : N → N and κ : N → N be functions that effect the decreasing arrangement of the singular numbers of the Ak in the sense that σn = sν(n) (Aκ(n) ) (n ∈ N). Then A=
∞
(κ(n))
(κ(n))
σn aν(n) ⊗ bν(n) ,
n=1
which suggests defining, for each m ∈ N0 , the rank-m operator Fm : H1 → H2 by F0 := 0 , Fm :=
m n=1
(κ(n))
(κ(n))
σn aν(n) ⊗ bν(n)
(m ∈ N).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
27
If x ∈ H1 and y ∈ H2 then |((A − Fm−1 )x, y)H2 | ≤
∞
(κ(n)) (κ(n)) σn (x, aν(n) )H1 (bν(n) , y)H2
n=m
≤ σm
∞ (κ(n)) (κ(n)) (x, aν(n) )H1 (bν(n) , y)H2
n=1
= σm
∞ K (k) (k) (x, al )H1 (bl , y)H2 k=1 l=1
∞ K 2 2 ∞ (k) (k) ≤ σm (x, al )H1 (bl , y)H2 k=1
≤ σm
K
l=1
l=1
xH1 yH2
k=1
= σm K xH1 yH2 . This estimate justifies the rearrangements (since the series are absolutely convergent) and also yields A − Fm−1 ≤ Kσm , from which the assertion follows. Proposition 2.8. Suppose that An ∈ E(an , α; H1 , H2 ) for 1 ≤ n ≤ K. Let A := K K −1/α −α ) . Then n=1 An and a := ( n=1 an (i) A ∈ E(a , α) with |A|a ,α ≤ K max1≤n≤K |An |an ,α . In particular E(a1 , α) + · · · + E(aK , α) ⊂ E(a , α) . (ii) If both H1 and H2 are infinite-dimensional then the inclusion above is sharp in the sense that E(a1 , α) + · · · + E(aK , α) ⊂ E(b, α) , whenever b > a . Proof. Assertion (i) follows from Proposition 2.7 and Corollary 5.4 (i), which gives an upper bound on the rate of decay of the decreasing arrangement of the sequences s(A1 ), . . . , s(AK ). For the proof of (ii) define K sequences s(1) , . . . , s(K) by α s(k) n := exp(−ak n ) (n ∈ N) . (k)
It turns out that it suffices to exhibit K compact operators Ak with sn (Ak ) = sn such that s(A) is the decreasing arrangement of the sequences s(1) , . . . , s(K) . To see this, note that then Ak ∈ E(ak , α) for k ∈ {1, · · · , K}. At the same time sn (A) ≥ exp(−a (n + K)α ) by Corollary 5.4 (ii), so that A ∈ E(b, α) whenever b > a . In order to construct these operators we proceed as follows. Since each Hi was (i) assumed to be infinite-dimensional we can choose an orthonormal basis {hn }n∈N
28
Bandtlow
IEOT
for each of them. For each k = 1, . . . , K, we now define a compact operator Ak : H1 → H2 by (k) (2) s(n+(k−1))/K hn for n ∈ KN − (k − 1), (1) Ak hn := 0 for n ∈ KN − (k − 1). (k)
It is not difficult to see that sn (Ak ) = sn . Moreover, it is easily verified that (k) the singular numbers of A are precisely the numbers of the form sn with n ∈ N and k = 1, . . . , K. Thus, s(A) is the decreasing arrangement of the sequences s(1) , . . . , s(K) as required. Remark 2.9. The proposition implies that E(a, α) + E(a, α) ⊂ E(2−α a, α), but E(a, α) + E(a, α) ⊂ E(a, α), because 2−α a < a. In particular, E(a, α) is not a linear space. The following result establishes a sharp bound on the eigenvalue decay rate in each exponential class. Proposition 2.10. Let a, α > 0 and A ∈ E(a, α; H, H). Then λ(A) ∈ E(a/(1 + α), α) with |λ(A)|a/(1+α),α ≤ |A|a,α . If H is infinite-dimensional, the result is sharp in the sense that there is an operator A ∈ E(a, α; H, H) such that λ(A) ∈ E(b, α) whenever b > a/(1 + α). Proof. If A ∈ E(a, α) then sk (A) ≤ |A|a,α exp(−ak α ). Using the multiplicative Weyl inequality [Pie, 3.5.1] we have |λk (A)|k ≤
k
|λl (A)| ≤
l=1
k
sl (A) ≤
l=1
k
|A|a,α exp(−alα )
l=1 k
= |A|a,α exp(−a But
k l=1
lα ≥
k 0
k
lα ).
(1)
l=1
xα dx =
1 α+1 , 1+α k
which combined with (1) yields
|λk (A)| ≤ |A|a,α exp(−ak α /(1 + α)). Sharpness is proved in several steps. We start with the following observation. Let τ1 ≥ . . . ≥ τN ≥ 0 be positive real numbers. Consider the matrix C(τ1 , . . . , τN ) ∈ L(CN , CN ) given by 0 0 τ1 . . . 0 0 0 ... 0 0 .. . . .. . .. .. C(τ1 , . . . , τN ) := . . 0 0 . . . 0 τN −1 τN 0 . . . 0 0 It easy to see that sn (C(τ1 , . . . , τN )) = τn
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
29
and |λ1 (C(τ1 , . . . , τN ))| = · · · = |λN (C(τ1 , . . . , τN ))| = (τ1 · · · τN )1/N . The desired operator is constructed as follows. Fix a > 0 and α > 0. Next choose a super-exponentially increasing sequence Nn , that is, Nn is increasing and limn→∞ Nn−1 /Nn = 0. For definiteness we could set Nn = exp(n2 ). Put N0 = 0 and define dn := Nn − Nn−1
(n ∈ N).
Define matrices An ∈ L(C , C ) by dn
dn
An = C(exp(−a(Nn−1 + 1)α ), . . . , exp(−a(Nn )α )). Then sk (An ) = exp(−a(Nn−1 + k)α ) (1 ≤ k ≤ dn ) and |λk (An )| = exp(−apα n ) (1 ≤ k ≤ dn ), where pn :=
1 dn
Put H :=
Nn
lα.
l=Nn−1 +1 ∞
Cd n ,
n=1
and let A : H → H be the block-diagonal operator (Ax)n = An xn . Clearly, the singular numbers of A are given by sk (A) = exp(−ak α ) and the moduli of the eigenvalues are the numbers exp(−apα n ) occurring with multiplicity dn . Before checking that A has the desired properties we observe that pα n
1 = dn
Nn
1 l ≤ dn α
l=Nn−1 +1
Nn +1
xα
Nn−1 +1
1 1 1 N α δn , (2) ((Nn + 1)α+1 − (Nn−1 + 1)α+1 ) = α + 1 dn α+1 n with limn→∞ δn = 1. The latter follows from the fact that the sequence Nn was chosen to be super-exponentially increasing. Suppose now that b > a/(α + 1). Since |λNn (A)| = exp(−apα n ) we have a a Nnα δn + bNnα ) = exp(Nnα (b − δn )). |λNn (A)| exp(bNnα ) ≥ exp(− α+1 α+1 Thus |λNn (A)| exp(bNnα ) → +∞ as n → ∞, =
which means that λ(A) ∈ E(b, α).
30
Bandtlow
IEOT
Remark 2.11. Similar results have been obtained by K¨ onig and Richter [KR, Proposition 1], though without estimates on the gauge of λ(A).
3. Resolvent estimates In this section we shall derive an upper bound for the norm of the resolvent (zI − A)−1 of A ∈ E(a, α) in terms of the distance of z to the spectrum of A and the departure from normality of A, a number quantifying the non-normality of A. We shall employ a technique originally due to Henrici [Hen], who used it in a finite-dimensional context. The basic idea is to write A as a perturbation of a normal operator having the same spectrum as A by a quasi-nilpotent operator. A similar argument can be used to derive resolvent estimates for operators belonging to Schatten classes (see [Gil] (and references therein) and [Ban]). Following the idea outlined above we start with bounds for quasi-nilpotent operators. Proposition 3.1. Let a, α > 0. (i) If A ∈ E(a, α; H, H) is quasi-nilpotent, that is, σ(A) = {0}, then (I − A)−1 ≤ fa,α (|A|a,α ),
(3)
+ where fa,α : R+ 0 → R0 is defined by
fa,α (r) =
∞
(1 + r exp(−anα )).
n=1
Moreover, fa,α has the following asymptoticss: log fa,α (r) ∼ a−1/α
α (log r)1+1/α as r → ∞. 1+α
(4)
(ii) If H is infinite-dimensional the estimate (3) is sharp in the sense that there is a quasi-nilpotent B ∈ E(a, α; H, H) such that (5) log (I − zB)−1 ∼ log fa,α (|zB|a,α ) as |z| → ∞. Proof. Fix a, α > 0. (i) Since A is trace class and quasi-nilpotent a standard estimate (see, for example, [GGK, Chapter X, Theorem 1.1]) shows that ∞ (I − A)−1 ≤ (1 + sn (A)) . n=1
Thus
∞ (I − A)−1 ≤ (1 + |A|a,α exp(−anα )) = fa,α (|A|a,α ). n=1
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
31
It remains to prove the growth estimate (4). We proceed by noting that fa,α extends to an entire function of genus zero with fa,α (0) = 1. Moreover, the maximum modulus of fa,α (z) for |z| = r equals fa,α (r). The growth of fa,α can thus be estimated by (6) N (r) ≤ log fa,α (r) ≤ N (r) + Q(r) , r −1 ∞ −2 where N (r) = 0 t n(t) dt, Q(r) = r r t n(t) dt and n(r) denotes the number of zeros of fa,α lying in the closed disk with radius r centred at 0 (see [Boa, p. 47]). Since n(r) = a−1/α (log+ r)1/α , where log+ (r) = max {0, log r} and · denotes the floor-function, we have, for r ≥ 1, r −1/α N (r) = a t−1 (log t)1/α dt + O(log r) 1
=a while Q satisfies
−1/α
α (log r)1+1/α + O(log r) ; 1+α
Q(r) = O((log r)1/α ) as r → ∞ .
To see this, note that Q(r) ≤ a−1/α r
∞
t−2 (log t)1/α dt = a−1/α r
(7) (8)
∞
e−u u1/α du ;
(9)
log r
r
putting r = es it thus suffices to show that ∞ e−u u1/α du = O(s1/α ) as s → ∞. es s
This, however, is the case since ∞ ∞ s−1/α es e−u u1/α du = e−(u−s) (u/s)1/α du = s
∞
0
s
e−t (1 + t/s)1/α dt → 1
as s → ∞. Combining (8), (7) and (6) the growth estimate (4) follows. (ii) Since H is infinite-dimensional, we may choose an orthonormal basis {hn }n∈N . Define the operator B ∈ L(H, H) by Bhn := exp(−anα )hn+1
(n ∈ N).
It is not difficult to see that sn (B) = exp(−anα ) for n ∈ N, so that B ∈ E(a, α; H, H). Before we proceed let cn := and note that since
n 0
n
kα
k=1
xα dx ≤
n
k=1
kα ≤
(n ∈ N0 ), n+1 1
xα dx, we have
1 1 nα+1 ≤ cn ≤ (n + 1)α+1 (n ∈ N0 ). α+1 α+1 The operator B is quasi-nilpotent, since a B n = exp(−acn ) ≤ exp(− nα+1 ) , α+1
32
Bandtlow
IEOT
1/n
which implies B n → 0 as n → ∞. In order to determine the asymptotics of log (I − zB)−1 we start by noting that ∞ (I − zB)−1 2 ≥ (I − zB)−1 h1 2 = (zB)n h1 2 =
∞
|z|2n exp(−2acn ) ≥
n=0
∞
|z|2n exp(−2
n=0
where g(r) :=
∞ n=1
Thus
n=0
r2n exp(−2
a (n + 1)α+1 ) ≥ |z|−2 g(|z|), (10) α+1
a nα+1 ) (r ∈ R+ 0 ). α+1
2 log fa,α (|zB|a,α ) ≥ 2 log (I − zB)−1 ≥ −2 log |z| + log g(|z|) ,
(11)
which shows that in order to obtain the desired asymptotics (5) it suffices to prove that α (12) (log r)1+1/α as r → ∞. log g(r) ∼ 2a−1/α α+1 In order to establish the asymptotics above we introduce the maximum term a nα+1 ) (r ∈ R+ µ(r) := max r2n exp(−2 (13) 0 ). 1≤n<∞ α+1 Since g extends to an entire function of finite order we have (see, for example, [PS, Problem 54]) log µ(r) ∼ log g(r) as r → ∞ , which implies that it now suffices to show that µ has the desired asymptotics α (log r)1+1/α as r → ∞. log µ(r) ∼ 2a−1/α (14) α+1 + We now estimate µ(r) for fixed r. Define the function mr : R+ 0 → R0 by a xα+1 + 2x log r). mr (x) = exp(−2 α+1
It turns out that mr has a maximum at xr = a−1/α (log r)1/α and that mr is monotonically increasing on (0, xr ) and monotonically decreasing on (xr , ∞). Thus log mr (xr − 1) ≤ log µ(r) ≤ log mr (xr ) .
(15)
Write xr − 1 = δr xr and note that δr → 1 as r → ∞. Observing that log mr (xr ) α = 2a−1/α α+1 (log r)1+1/α while δrα+1 log mr (δr xr ) α log mr (xr − 1) −1/α + δr → 2a−1/α − = = 2a α+1 α+1 (log r)1+1/α (log r)1+1/α
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
33
as r → ∞ we conclude, using (15), that (14) holds. This implies (12), which yields (5), as required. Remark 3.2. (i) The bound for the growth of the resolvent of a quasi-nilpotent A ∈ E(a, α) given in the above proposition is an improvement compared to those obtainable from the usual estimates for operators in the Schatten classes. Indeed, if A belongs to the Schatten p-class (i.e. s(A) is p-summable) for some p > 0, then (I − A)−1 ≤ fp (A ) p
+ where Ap denotes the Schatten p-(quasi) norm of A. Here, fp : R+ 0 → R0 is given by fp (r) = exp(ap rp + bp ) , where ap and bp are positive numbers depending on p, but not on A (see, for example, [Sim1] or [Ban, Theorem 2.1], where a discussion of the constants ap and bp can be found). (ii) Closer inspection of the proof yields the following explicit upper bound for fa,α α log fa,α (r) ≤ a−1/α (log+ r)1+1/α + rΓ(1 + 1/α, log+ r) , 1+α
where Γ(β, s) denotes the incomplete gamma function ∞ Γ(β, s) = exp(−t) tβ−1 dt . s
This follows from (6) together with the estimate n(r) ≤ a−1/α (log+ r)1/α . A simple consequence of the proposition is the following estimate for the growth of the resolvent of a quasi-nilpotent A ∈ E(a, α). Corollary 3.3. If A ∈ E(a, α) is quasi-nilpotent, then (zI − A)−1 ≤ |z|−1 fa,α (|z|−1 |A|a,α ) for z = 0. The proposition above can be used to obtain growth estimates for the resolvents of any A ∈ E(a, α) by means of the following device. Theorem 3.4. Let A ∈ S∞ . Then A can be written as a sum A = D + N, such (i) (ii) (iii)
that D ∈ S∞ , N ∈ S∞ ; D is normal and λ(D) = λ(A); N and (zI − D)−1 N are quasi-nilpotent for every z ∈ (D) = (A).
Proof. See [Ban, Theorem 3.2]. This result motivates the following definition.
34
Bandtlow
IEOT
Definition 3.5. Let A ∈ S∞ . A decomposition A=D+N with D and N enjoying properties (i–iii) of the previous theorem is called a Schur decomposition of A. The operators D and N will be referred to as the normal and the quasi-nilpotent part of the Schur decomposition of A, respectively. Remark 3.6. (i) The terminology stems from the fact that in the finite dimensional setting the decomposition in Theorem 3.4 can be obtained as follows: since any matrix is unitarily equivalent to an upper-triangular matrix by a classical result due to Schur, it suffices to establish the result for matrices of this form. In this case, simply choose D to be the diagonal part, and N the off-diagonal part of the matrix. (ii) The decomposition is not unique, not even modulo unitary equivalence: there is a matrix A with two Schur decompositions A = D1 + N1 and A = D2 + N2 such that N1 is not unitarily equivalent to N2 (see [Ban, Remark 3.5 (i)]). Note, however, that the normal parts of any two Schur decompositions of a given compact operator are always unitarily equivalent. Using the results in the previous section we are able to locate the position of the normal part and the quasi-nilpotent part of an operator A ∈ E(a, α) in the scale of exponential classes. Proposition 3.7. Let A ∈ E(a, α). If A = D + N is a Schur decomposition of A with normal part D and quasi-nilpotent part N , then (i) D ∈ E(a/(1 + α), α) with |D|a/(1+α),α ≤ |A|a,α ; (ii) N ∈ E(a , α) with |N |a ,α ≤ 2|A|a,α , where a = a(1 + (1 + α)1/α )−α . Proof. Since D is normal, its singular numbers coincide with its eigenvalues, which in turn coincide with the eigenvalues of A. Assertion (i) is thus a consequence of Proposition 2.10, while assertion (ii) follows from (i) and Proposition 2.8 by taking N = A − D. Remark 3.8. Assertion (i) above is sharp in the following sense: there is A ∈ E(a, α) such that for any normal part D of A we have D ∈ E(b, α) whenever b > a/(1+α). This follows from the corresponding statement in Proposition 2.10 and the fact that all normal parts of A are unitarily equivalent. For later use we define the following quantities, originally introduced by Henrici [Hen]. Definition 3.9. Let a, α > 0 and define νa,α : S∞ → R+ 0 ∪ {∞} by νa,α (A) := inf { |N |a,α : N is a quasi-nilpotent part of A } . We call νa,α (A) the (a, α)-departure from normality of A.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
35
Remark 3.10. Henrici originally introduced this quantity for matrices and with the (a, α)-gauge of N replaced by the Hilbert-Schmidt norm. For a discussion of the case where the (a, α)-gauge is replaced by a Schatten norm and its uses to obtain resolvent estimates for Schatten class operators see [Ban]. The term ‘departure from normality’ is justified in view of the following characterisation. Proposition 3.11. Let A ∈ E(a, α). Then νa,α (A) = 0 ⇔ A is normal. Proof. Let νa,α (A) = 0. Then there exists a sequence of Schur decompositions with quasi-nilpotent parts Nn such that |Nn |a,α → 0. Thus A − Dn = Nn = s1 (Nn ) ≤ exp(−a)|N |a,α → 0, where Dn are the corresponding normal parts. Thus A is a limit of normal operators converging in the uniform operator topology and is therefore normal. The converse is trivial. For a given A ∈ E(a, α) the departure from normality is difficult to calculate. The following simple but somewhat crude bound is useful in practice. Proposition 3.12. Let A ∈ E(a, α). Then νb,α (A) ≤ 2|A|a,α whenever b ≤ a(1 + (1 + α)1/α )−α . Proof. Follows from Proposition 3.7 together with the fact that |N |b,α ≤ |N |a ,α whenever b ≤ a . We are now ready to deduce resolvent estimates for arbitrary A ∈ E(a, α). Using a Schur decomposition A = D + N with D normal and N quasi-nilpotent we consider A as a perturbation of D by N . Since D is normal we have 1 (zI − D)−1 = (z ∈ (D)), (16) d(z, σ(D)) where for z ∈ C and σ ⊂ C closed, d(z, σ) := inf |z − λ| λ∈σ
denotes the distance of z to σ. The influence of the perturbation N on the other hand, is controlled by Proposition 3.1. All in all, we have the following. Theorem 3.13. Let A ∈ E(a, α). If b ≤ a(1 + (1 + α)1/α )−α , then 1 νb,α (A) (zI − A)−1 ≤ fb,α . d(z, σ(A)) d(z, σ(A))
(17)
36
Bandtlow
IEOT
Proof. Fix b ≤ a(1 + (1 + α)1/α )−α . Then there is a Schur decomposition of A with normal part D and quasi-nilpotent part N ∈ E(b, α) by Proposition 3.7. Since the bound above is trivial for z ∈ σ(A) we may assume z ∈ (A). As D and N stem from a Schur decomposition of A we see that (zI − D)−1 exists (because σ(A) = σ(D)) and that (zI − D)−1 N is quasi-nilpotent. Moreover |N |b,α , |(zI − D)−1 N |b,α ≤ (zI − D)−1 |N |b,α = d(z, σ(D)) by (16) and Proposition 2.5. Thus (I − (zI − D)−1 N ) is invertible in L and |N |b,α (I − (zI − D)−1 N )−1 ≤ fb,α , d(z, σ(D)) by Proposition 3.1. Now, since (zI − A) = (zI − D)(I − (zI − D)−1 N ), we conclude that (zI − A) is invertible in L and (z − A)−1 ≤ (I − (zI − D)−1 N )−1 (zI − D)−1 1 |N |b,α ≤ fb,α . d(z, σ(D)) d(z, σ(D)) Taking the infimum over all Schur decompositions while using σ(A) = σ(D) once again the result follows. Remark 3.14. (i) The estimate remains valid if νb,α (A) is replaced by something larger, for example by the upper bound given in Proposition 3.12. (ii) The estimate is sharp in the sense that if A is normal then (17) reduces to the sharp estimate (16).
4. Bounds for the spectral distance Using the resolvent estimates obtained in the previous section it is possible to give upper bounds for the Hausdorff distance of the spectra of operators in E(a, α). Recall that the Hausdorff distance Hdist (., .) is the following metric defined on the space of compact subsets of C ˆ 1 , σ2 ), d(σ ˆ 2 , σ1 )}, Hdist (σ1 , σ2 ) := max {d(σ where ˆ 1 , σ2 ) := sup d(λ, σ2 ) d(σ λ∈σ1
and σ1 and σ2 are two compact subsets of C. For A, B ∈ L we borrow terminology ˆ from matrix perturbation theory and call d(σ(A), σ(B)) the spectral variation of A with respect to B and Hdist (σ(A), σ(B)) the spectral distance of A and B. The main tool to bound the spectral variation is the following result, which is based on a simple but powerful argument usually credited to Bauer and Fike [BauF] who first employed it in a finite-dimensional context.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
37
Proposition 4.1. Let A ∈ S∞ . Suppose that there is a strictly monotonically in+ creasing surjection g : R+ 0 → R0 such that (zI − A)−1 ≤ g(d(z, σ(A))−1 ) (∀z ∈ (A)). Then for any B ∈ L, the spectral variation of B with respect to A satisfies ˆ d(σ(B), σ(A)) ≤ h(A − B), + where h : R+ 0 → R0 is the function defined by
h(r) = (˜ g (r−1 ))−1 + and g˜ : R+ 0 → R0 is the inverse of the function g.
Proof. Let B ∈ L. In what follows we shall use the abbreviations d := d(z, σ(A)),
E := B − A.
Without loss of generality we may assume that E = 0. We shall first establish the following implication: −1 (18) z ∈ σ(B) ∩ (A) ⇒ E ≤ (zI − A)−1 . To see this let z ∈ σ(B) ∩ (A) and suppose to the contrary that (zI − A)−1 E < 1. Then I −(zI −A)−1 E is invertible in L, so (zI −B) = (zI −A) I −(zI −A)−1 E is invertible in L. Hence z ∈ (B) which contradicts z ∈ σ(B). Thus the implication (18) holds. In order to prove the proposition it suffices to show that z ∈ σ(B) ⇒ d(z, σ(A)) ≤ h(E) ,
(19)
which is proved as follows. Let z ∈ σ(B). If z ∈ σ(A) there is nothing to prove. We may thus assume that z ∈ (A). Hence, by (18), −1 E ≤ (zI − A)−1 ≤ g(d−1 ). Since g is strictly monotonically increasing, so is g˜. Thus g˜(E−1 ) ≤ d−1 , and hence −1
d(z, σ(A)) = d ≤ (˜ g (E
))−1 = h(E) = h(A − B).
Using the proposition above together with the resolvent estimates in Theorem 3.13 we now obtain the following spectral variation and spectral distance formulae. Theorem 4.2. Let A ∈ E(a, α) and define a := a(1 + (1 + α)1/α )−α . (i) If B ∈ L and b > a , then A − B ˆ d(σ(B), σ(A)) ≤ ν(A)b,α hb,α . νb,α (A)
(20)
38
Bandtlow
IEOT
(ii) If B ∈ E(a, α) and b > a , then
Hdist (σ(A), σ(B)) ≤ mhb,α
A − B m
,
(21)
where m := max {ν(A)b,α , ν(B)b,α }. + Here, the function hb,α : R+ 0 → R0 is given by
gb,α (r−1 ))−1 , hb,α (r) := (˜ + + + where g˜ : R+ 0 → R0 is the inverse of the function gb,α : R0 → R0 defined by
gb,α (r) := rfb,α (r) , and fa,α is the function defined in Proposition 3.1. Proof. To prove (i) fix b ≥ a . The assertion now follows from the previous proposition by noting that 1 νb,α (A) (zI − A)−1 ≤ gb,α νb,α (A) d(z, σ(A)) by Theorem 3.13. To prove (ii) fix b ≥ a . Then it is not difficult see that m (zI − A)−1 ≤ 1 gb,α , m d(z, σ(A)) and
(zI − B)−1 ≤ 1 gb,α m
m d(z, σ(B))
and the assertion follows as in the proof of (i).
,
Remark 4.3. (i) Note that limr↓0 hb,α (r) = 0, so the estimate for the spectral distance becomes small when A − B is small. In fact, it can be shown that α/(1+α) 1+α log hb,α (r) ∼ −b1/(1+α) | log r|α/(1+α) as r ↓ 0. α This follows from the asymptotics in Proposition 3.1 together with the fact that if log f (r) ∼ a(log r)β , then log f˜(r) ∼ a−1/β (log r)1/β where f˜ is the inverse of f . (ii) It is not difficult to see, for example by arguing as in the proof of part (ii) of the theorem, that the inequalities (20) and (21) above remain valid if νb,α (A) or νb,α (B) is replaced by something larger — for example, by the upper bounds given in Proposition 3.12. (iii) Assertion (ii) of the theorem is sharp in the sense that if both operators are normal, then (ii) reduces to Hdist (σ(A), σ(B)) ≤ A − B .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates
39
5. Appendix: Monotone arrangements In this appendix we present a number of results concerning sequences and their arrangements used in Section 2. Let a : N → R be a sequence. Define a+ := sup an , n∈N
a− := inf an . n∈N
For u : N → R call rank (u) := card { n ∈ N : un = 0 } . Definition 5.1. Let a : N → R be a sequence. Let extended real-valued sequences a(+) and a(−) be defined by ! := inf a − u+ : rank u < n , a(+) : N → R ∪ {−∞, ∞}, a(+) n a(−) : N → R ∪ {−∞, ∞},
! a(−) := sup a − u− : rank u < n . n
We call a(+) the decreasing arrangement of a, and a(−) the increasing arrangement of a. This terminology is justified in view of the fact that a(+) (respectively a(−) ) is a decreasing (respectively increasing) sequence. Moreover, if a is monotonically decreasing, then a(+) = a, and similarly for monotonically increasing sequences. More generally, we will consider monotone arrangements of collections of sequences by first amalgamating them into one sequence and then regarding the resulting monotone arrangement. A more precise definition is the following. (1)
(K)
Definition 5.2. Given K real-valued sequences {an }n∈N , . . . , {an }n∈N , define a new sequence a : N → R by (i)
a(k−1)K+i = ak
for k ∈ N and 1 ≤ i ≤ K .
We then call a(+) (a(−) ) the decreasing (increasing) arrangement of the K sequences a(1) , · · · , a(K) . Our application of decreasing arrangements will typically be to singular number sequences, all of which converge to zero at some stretched exponential rate. Technically and notationally it is preferable to work with the logarithms of reciprocals of such sequences, that is, increasing sequences converging to +∞ at some polynomial rate. The following is the main result of this appendix. Proposition 5.3. Let α > 0 and K ∈ N. Suppose that for each k ∈ {1, . . . , K} we are given a real sequence a(k) , a positive constant ak > 0, and a real number Ak .
40
Bandtlow
IEOT
Let a(−) denote the increasing arrangement of the K sequences a(1) , . . . , a(K) , and define K
−α −1/α c= ak . k=1
(i) If α a(k) n ≥ ak n + Ak
(∀n ∈ N, k ∈ {1, . . . , K}) ,
then a(−) ≥ cnα + min {A1 , . . . , AK } n
(∀n ∈ N) .
(ii) If α a(k) n ≤ ak n + Ak
(∀n ∈ N, k ∈ {1, . . . , K}) ,
then a(−) ≤ c(n + K)α + max {A1 , . . . , AK } n (k)
Proof. For k ∈ {1, . . . , K} set a0 functions
µk (r) := card
(∀n ∈ N) .
= −∞ and, for r ∈ R, define the counting " "
µ(r) := card
n ∈ N : a(k) n ≤ r ≤r n ∈ N : a(−) n
# # .
The following relations are easily verified. We have µ(r) =
K
µk (r) ,
(22)
(∀r ∈ R) ,
(23)
(∀n ∈ N0 ) .
(24)
k=1
and (−)
aµ(r) ≤ r µ(a(−) n )
≥n
(i) Set C = min {A1 , . . . , AK }. Since for each k ∈ {1, . . . , K}, " # n ∈ N : a(k) ⊂ { n ∈ N : ak n α + C ≤ r } , n ≤r we have, for r ≥ C,
$
µk (r) ≤ card { n ∈ N : ak nα + C ≤ r } =
r−C ak
1/α % ,
where · denotes the floor function. Thus, using (22), we have µ(r) =
K k=1
µk (r) ≤ (r − C)1/α
K k=1
−1/α
ak
.
(25)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Resolvent Estimates (−)
If n ∈ N then an
41
≥ C, so combining (25) with (24) gives 1/α (a(−) n − C)
K
−1/α
≥ µ(a(−) n ) ≥ n,
ak
k=1
from which (i) follows. (ii) Set C = max {A1 , . . . , AK }. Since for each k ∈ {1, . . . , K}, " # , { n ∈ N : ak nα + C ≤ r } ⊂ n ∈ N : a(k) n ≤ r we have, for r ≥ C, $ 1/α % r−C = card { n ∈ N : ak nα + C ≤ r } ≤ µk (r) . ak Thus, using (22), we have µ(r) =
K
µk (r) ≥
1/α
(r − C)
k=1
−1/α ak
−K.
(26)
k=1
Now fix n0 ∈ N. Choose r0 ≥ C such that n0 =
K
1/α
(r0 − C)
K
−1/α ak
−K.
(27)
k=1
From (26) and (27) we see that n0 ≤ µ(r0 ). Using (23), together with the fact that (−) n → an is monotonically increasing, now yields (−)
α a(−) n0 ≤ aµ(r0 ) ≤ r0 = c(n0 + K) + C .
Since n0 was arbitrary, (ii) follows.
Corollary 5.4. Let α > 0 and K ∈ N. Suppose that for each k ∈ {1, . . . , K} we are given a real sequence b(k) , a positive constant ak > 0, and a real number Bk . Let b(+) denote the decreasing arrangement of the K sequences b(1) , . . . , b(K) and define K
−α −1/α c := ak . k=1
(i) If α b(k) n ≤ Bk exp(−ak n )
(∀n ∈ N, k ∈ {1, . . . , K}) ,
then ≤ B exp(−cnα ) b(+) n where B = max {B1 , . . . , BK }.
(∀n ∈ N) ,
42
Bandtlow
IEOT
(ii) If α b(k) n ≥ Bk exp(−ak n )
(∀n ∈ N, k ∈ {1, . . . , K}) ,
then
b(+) ≥ B exp(−c(n + K)α ) n where B = min {B1 , . . . , BK }.
(∀n ∈ N) ,
Acknowledgements I would like to thank Oliver Jenkinson for the many discussions that helped to shape this article, in particular the results in Section 2 and in the Appendix. The research described in this article was partly supported by EPSRC Grant GR/R64650/01.
References [Ban]
O.F. Bandtlow (2004) Estimates for norms of resolvents and an application to the perturbation of spectra; Math. Nachr. 267, 3–11 [BanC] O.F. Bandtlow and C.-H. Chu (2006) Eigenvalue decay of operators on harmonic function spaces; preprint [BanJ1] O.F. Bandtlow and O. Jenkinson (2007) Explicit a priori bounds on transfer operator eigenvalues; Commun. Math. Phys. 276, 901–905 [BanJ2] O.F. Bandtlow and O. Jenkinson (2007) On the Ruelle eigenvalue sequence; to appear in Ergod. Th. & Dynam. Sys. [BanJ3] O.F. Bandtlow and O. Jenkinson (2007) Explicit eigenvalue estimates for transfer operators acting on spaces of holomorphic functions; to appear in Adv. Math. [BauF] F.L. Bauer and C.T. Fike (1960) Norms and exclusion theorems; Num. Math. 2, 42–53 [BerF] G. Bery and G. Forst (1975) Potential Theory on Locally Compact Groups; Heidelberg, Springer [Boa] R.P. Boas (1954) Entire Functions; New York, Academic Press [Cal] J.W. Calkin (1941) Two sided ideals and congruences in the ring of bounded operators in Hilbert space; Ann. Math. 42, 839–873 [DS] N. Dunford and J.T. Schwartz (1963) Linear Operators, Vol. 2; New York, Interscience [Gil] M.I. Gil’ (2003) Operator Functions and Localization of Spectra; Berlin, Springer [GGK] I. Gohberg, S. Goldberg and M.A. Kaashoek (1990) Classes of Linear Operators Vol. 1; Basel, Birkh¨ auser [GK] I. Gohberg and M.G. Krein (1969) Introduction to the Theory of Linear NonSelfadjoint Operators; Providence, AMS [Hen] P. Henrici (1962) Bounds for iterates, inverses, spectral variation and fields of values of non-normal matrices; Num. Math. 4, 24–40 [KR] H. K¨ onig and S. Richter (1984) Eigenvalues of integral operators defined by analytic kernels; Math. Nachr. 119, 141–155
Vol. 61 (2008) [Nel] [Pie] [Pok] [PS] [Rin] [Rue] [Sim1] [Sim2]
Resolvent Estimates
43
E. Nelimarkka (1982) On λ(P, N )-nuclearity and operator ideals; Math. Nachr. 99, 231–237 A. Pietsch (1988) Eigenvalues and s-Numbers; Cambridge, CUP A. Pokrzywa (1985) On continuity of spectra in norm ideals; Lin. Alg. Appl. 69, 121–130 G. P´ olya and G. Szeg¨ o (1976) Problems and Theorems in Analysis, Volume 2; Berlin, Springer J.R. Ringrose (1971) Compact Non-Self-Adjoint Operators; London, van Nostrand D. Ruelle (2004) Thermodynamic formalism: the mathematical structures of equilibrium statistical mechanics; Cambridge CUP B. Simon (1977) Notes on infinite determinants of Hilbert space operators; Adv. in Math., 24, 244–273 B. Simon (1979) Trace ideals and their applications; Cambridge, CUP
Oscar F. Bandtlow School of Mathematical Sciences Queen Mary, University of London London E3 4NS UK e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: December 20, 2006 Revised: December 17, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 45–62 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010045-18, published online March 13, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1568-7
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Semigroups of Composition Operators in BMOA and the Extension of a Theorem of Sarason O. Blasco, M.D. Contreras, S. D´ıaz-Madrigal, J. Mart´ınez and A.G. Siskakis Abstract. In this paper we deal with the maximal subspace in BM OA where a general semigroup of analytic functions on the unit disk generates a strongly continuous semigroup of composition operators. Particular cases of this question are related to a well-known theorem of Sarason about V M OA. Our results describe analytically that maximal subspace and provide a condition which is sufficient for the maximal subspace to be exactly V M OA. A related necessary condition is also proved in the case when the semigroup has an inner Denjoy-Wolff point. As a byproduct we provide a generalization of the theorem of Sarason. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 30H05, 32A37, 47B33, 47D06; Secondary 46E15. Keywords. Semigroups, composition operators, BMOA, VMOA.
1. Introduction Let H(D) be the Fr´echet space of all analytic functions in the unit disk endowed with the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of D. A (one-parameter) semigroup of analytic functions is any continuous homomorphism Φ : t → Φ(t) = ϕt from the additive semigroup of nonnegative real numbers into the composition semigroup of all analytic functions which map D into D. In other words, Φ = (ϕt ) consists of analytic functions on D with ϕt (D) ⊂ D and for which the following three conditions hold: 1. ϕ0 is the identity in D, This research has been partially supported by the Ministerio de Educaci´ on y Ciencia projects n. MTM2006-14449-C02-01 and MTM2005-08350-C03-03 and by La Consejer´ıa de Educaci´ on y Ciencia de la Junta de Andaluc´ıa.
46
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
2. ϕt+s = ϕt ◦ ϕs , for all t, s ≥ 0, 3. ϕt → ϕ0 , as t → 0, uniformly on compact subsets of D. It is well known that condition (3) above can be replaced by (3 ) For each z ∈ D, ϕt (z) → z, as t → 0. Each such semigroup gives rise to a semigroup (Ct ) consisting of composition operators on H(D), f ∈ H(D). Ct (f ) := f ◦ ϕt , We are going to be interested in the restriction of (Ct ) to certain linear subspaces H(D). Given a Banach space X consisting of functions of H(D) and a semigroup (ϕt ), we say that (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators on X if (Ct ) is a well-defined strongly continuous semigroup of bounded operators in X. This exactly means that for every f ∈ X, we have Ct (f ) ∈ X for all t ≥ 0 and lim Ct (f ) − f X = 0.
t→0+
Thus the crucial step to showing that (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators in X is to pass from the pointwise convergence limt→0+ f ◦ ϕt (z) = f (z) on D to the convergence in the norm of X. This connection between composition operators and semigroups opens the possibility of studying spectral properties, operator ideal properties or dynamical properties of the semigroup of operators (Ct ) in terms of the theory of functions. Papers [1] and [12] can be considered as the starting points in this direction. Classical choices of X treated in the literature are the Hardy spaces H p , the disk algebra A(D), the Bergman spaces Ap , the Dirichlet space D and the chain of spaces Qp and Qp,0 which have been introduced recently and which include the spaces BM OA, Bloch as well as their “little oh” analogues. See [21] and [22] for definitions and basic facts of the spaces and [17], [18], and [20] for composition semigroups on these spaces. Very briefly, the state of the art is the following: (i) Every semigroup of analytic functions generates a semigroup of operators on the Hardy spaces H p (1 ≤ p < ∞), the Bergman spaces Ap (1 ≤ p < ∞), the Dirichlet space, and on the spaces VMOA and little Bloch. (ii) No non-trivial semigroup generates a semigroup of operators in the space H ∞ of bounded analytic functions. (iii) There are plenty of semigroups (but not all) which generate semigroups of operators in the disk algebra. Indeed, they can be well characterized in several analytical terms [4]. In this paper we concentrate on the space BM OA. As we will see, the strong continuity behavior differs notably from other known cases, since it depends heavily on the particular semigroup. This has led us to introduce the following notation: Given a semigroup (ϕt ) we denote by [ϕt , BM OA] the maximal closed linear subspace of BM OA such that (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators on it. The existence of such a maximal subspace, as well as analytical descriptions of it will be discussed in section two. In that section, we also present an alternative self-contained proof of the fact that
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
47
every semigroup generates a semigroup of operators on V M OA. This in particular means that in our notation V M OA ⊆ [ϕt , BM OA] for every semigroup (ϕt ). It is important to underline that, in general, this inclusion can be proper. The chain of inclusions V M OA ⊆ [ϕt , BM OA] ⊆ BM OA leads us to wonder about those semigroups with an extreme character, that is, those giving equality V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]
or
[ϕt , BM OA] = BM OA.
In section three we deal with the left hand equality V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA], and present a sufficient condition on the semigroup for this equality to hold. A different but closely related condition is shown to be necessary for semigroups with inner Denjoy-Wolff point. The conditions are in terms of the growth of the infinitesimal generator of (ϕt ) near the boundary of D. There is an important connection of the above results with a well-known theorem of D. Sarason which characterizes the space V M OA. Namely, Sarason [14], [15] proved Theorem A. (Sarason [14]) Suppose f ∈ BM OA; then the following are equivalent: 1. f ∈ V M OA. 2. limt→0+ f (eit z) − f BMOA = 0. 3. limt→0+ f (e−t z) − f BMOA = 0. In our notation this theorem can be written as V M OA = [eit z, BM OA] = [e−t z, BM OA]. In other words, the semigroups ϕt (z) = eit z of rotations and ϕt (z) = e−t z of dilatations with respect to the origin are left-extreme in the above sense. Our results provide many more nontrivial examples of semigroups of this type. We end this introduction by presenting a quick review of basic facts about a general semigroup of analytic functions (see [18]). The basic material about operator semigroups on Banach spaces can be found in [9, Chapter VIII]. If (ϕt ) is a semigroup, then each map ϕt is univalent. The infinitesimal generator of (ϕt ) is the function G(z) := lim
t→0+
ϕt (z) − z , z ∈ D. t
This convergence holds uniformly on compact subsets of D so G ∈ H(D). Moreover G satisfies ∂ϕt (z) ∂ϕt (z) G(ϕt (z)) = = G(z) , z ∈ D, t ≥ 0. (1.1) ∂t ∂z Further G has a unique representation G(z) = (bz − 1)(z − b)P (z), z ∈ D
48
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
where b ∈ D and P ∈ H(D) with Re P (z) ≥ 0 for all z ∈ D. If G is not identically null, the couple (b, P ) is uniquely determined from (ϕt ) and the point b is called the Denjoy-Wolff point of the semigroup. We want to mention that this point plays a crucial role in the dynamical behavior of the semigroup (see [18], [5]). Note that for r sufficiently near to one, it is clear from the above representation of G that G has no zeros in the annulus r < |z| < 1, so 1/G is analytic on that annulus. This remark will be implicitly used throughout the paper.
2. Semigroups in BMOA For the sake of completeness and to fix notations, we begin with a quick review of basic properties of V M OA and BM OA. BM OA is the Banach space of all analytic functions in the Hardy space H 2 whose boundary values have bounded mean oscillation. There are many characterizations of this space but we will use the one in terms of Carleson measures (see [22, 11]). Namely, a function f ∈ H 2 belongs to BM OA if and only if there exists a constant C > 0 such that |f (z)|2 (1 − |z|2 )dA(z) ≤ C|I|, R(I)
for any arc I ⊂ ∂D, where R(I) is the Carleson rectangle determined by I, that is, |I| iθ iθ R(I) := re ∈ D : 1 − < r < 1 and e ∈ I . 2π As usual, |I| denotes the length of I and dA(z) the normalized Lebesgue measure on D. The corresponding BM OA norm is 1/2 1 2 2 f BMOA := |f (0)| + sup |f (z)| (1 − |z| )dA(z) . |I| R(I) I⊂∂D Trivially, each polynomial belongs to BM OA. The closure of all polynomials in BM OA is denoted by V M OA. Alternatively, V M OA is the subspace of BM OA formed by those f ∈ BM OA such that 1 |f (z)|2 (1 − |z|2 )dA(z) = 0. lim |I|→0 |I| R(I) Particular and quite interesting examples of members of V M OA are provided by functions in the Dirichlet space D, which is the space of those functions f ∈ H(D) such that f ∈ L2 (D, dA). In fact, for every f ∈ D, 1 2 2 |f (z)| (1 − |z| )dA(z) ≤ 2 |f (z)|2 dA(z) → 0 as |I| → 0. (2.1) |I| R(I) R(I) For more information on these Banach spaces, we refer the reader to the excellent monographs or [11] or [22].
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
49
In our first result, we confirm the existence of a maximal closed linear subspace of BM OA on which a semigroup (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators. In this context, we recall that any analytic self map ϕ of the disk induces a bounded composition operator Cϕ (f ) = f ◦ ϕ on BM OA and there is a constant C > 0, not depending on ϕ, such that 1 Cϕ BMOA ≤ C 1 + log . (2.2) 1 − |ϕ(0)| Moreover Cϕ is bounded on V M OA if and only if ϕ ∈ V M OA, see [2] for details. Proposition 2.1. Let (ϕt ) be a semigroup of analytic functions. Then there exists a closed subspace Y of BM OA such that (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators on Y and such that any other subspace of BM OA with this property is contained in Y . Proof. Consider the linear subspace of BM OA defined by Y := f ∈ BM OA : lim f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA = 0 . t→0+
Notice that supt∈[0,1] |ϕt (0)| = M < 1. Hence from (2.2), sup Ct BMOA ≤ C (1 − log(1 − M )) < +∞.
t∈[0,1]
This and the triangle inequality for norms shows that Y is a closed subspace of BM OA. Thus in order to prove that (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators in Y , it remains to check that if f ∈ Y , then Cs (f ) ∈ Y for all s ≥ 0. To see this let s, t ≥ 0, then 1 Cs (f ) ◦ ϕt − Cs (f )BMOA ≤ C 1 + log f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA → 0 1 − |ϕs (0)| as t → 0+ . Finally, if W is a subspace of BM OA such that (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators on W , then for any f ∈ W we have in particular lim f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA = 0,
t→0+
thus f ∈ Y and we conclude W ⊂ Y .
In what follows, this maximal subspace Y will be denoted as [ϕt , BM OA]. It is easy to see that if Z is any closed subspace of [ϕt , BM OA] which is invariant under (Ct ) (i.e. Ct (Z) ⊂ Z for every t ≥ 0), then (ϕt ) generates a semigroups of operators on Z. This maximal subspace can be also described directly in terms of the infinitesimal generator. Theorem 2.2. Let G be the infinitesimal generator of (ϕt ). Then, [ϕt , BM OA] = {f ∈ BM OA : Gf ∈ BM OA}.
50
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
Proof. We may assume that (ϕt ) is not trivial. Denote by Γ the infinitesimal generator of the operator semigroup (Ct ) acting on the Banach space [ϕt , BM OA], and by D (Γ) its domain. We will show that if f ∈ D (Γ), then Gf ∈ BM OA. Indeed if f ∈ D (Γ), then Γ(f ) ∈ BM OA and 1 = 0. lim (Ct (f ) − f ) − Γ(f ) t→0+ t BMOA Since convergence in the BM OA norm implies uniform convergence on compact subsets of D and therefore in particular pointwise convergence, for each z ∈ D we have f (ϕt (z)) − f (z) f (ϕt (z)) − f (ϕ0 (z)) = lim+ t t t→0 ∂f ◦ ϕt (z) ∂ϕ (z) t = = f (ϕ0 (z)) = f (z)G(z), ∂t ∂t
Γ(f )(z) = lim+ t→0
t=0
t=0
that is, Gf = Γ(f ) ∈ BM OA, and thus D (Γ) ⊂ {f ∈ BM OA : Gf ∈ BM OA}. Taking closures and bearing in mind the fact from the general theory of operator semigroups that D (Γ) is dense in [ϕt , BM OA] we conclude [ϕt , BM OA] ⊆ {f ∈ BM OA : Gf ∈ BM OA}. Conversely, let f ∈ BM OA such that m := Gf ∈ BM OA. First of all, we assert that
(f ◦ ϕt ) (z) − f (z) =
0
t
(m ◦ ϕs ) (z)ds; for t ≥ 0, z ∈ D.
Indeed, G(z) ((f ◦ ϕt ) (z) − f (z)) = f (ϕt (z))G(z)ϕt (z) − m(z) ∂ϕt (z) − m(z) ∂t t ∂(m ◦ ϕs )(z) ds = m(ϕt (z)) − m(z) = ∂s 0 t = G(z)m (ϕs (z))ϕs (z)ds 0 t (m ◦ ϕs ) (z)ds. = G(z)
= f (ϕt (z))
0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
51
Since G is not identically null this verifies our assertion. Next let I be an interval in ∂D and R(I) the corresponding Carleson rectangle. For 0 ≤ t ≤ 1 we have 2 |(f ◦ ϕt ) (z) − f (z)| (1 − |z|2 )dA(z) R(I)
t 2 2 = (m ◦ ϕs ) (z)ds (1 − |z| )dA(z) 0 R(I) 1 2 t |(m ◦ ϕs ) (z)| ds (1 − |z|2 )dA(z) ≤
R(I)
0
where we have applied Cauchy-Schwarz in the inside integral. Dividing by |I|, taking sup and interchanging the integrals we have 12 1 2 2 |(f ◦ ϕt ) (z) − f (z)| (1 − |z| )dA(z) sup |I| R(I) I⊆∂D 12 1 1 2 2 ≤ sup t |(m ◦ ϕs ) (z)| ds (1 − |z| )dA(z) |I| R(I) I⊆∂D 0 12 1 1 2 ≤ sup t |(m ◦ ϕs ) (z)| (1 − |z|2 )dA(z) ds |I| R(I) I⊆∂D 0 1 12 2 ≤ t m ◦ ϕs BMOA ds 0 √ ≤ t sup m ◦ ϕs BMOA s∈[0,1]
√ ≤ tCmBMOA sup (1 − log(1 − |ϕs (0)|)) ≤C
√
s∈[0,1]
t,
where C > 0 is a certain constant not depending on t. Hence, √ Ct f − f BMOA ≤ |f (ϕt (0)) − f (0)| + C t. Since limt→0+ ϕt (0) = 0 we find that limt→0+ Ct f − f BMOA = 0, hence f ∈ [ϕt , BM OA]. We have shown {f ∈ BM OA : Gf ∈ BM OA} ⊂ [ϕt , BM OA], and the desired inclusion follows by taking closures. If (ϕt ) is a semigroup of analytic functions, then every composition operator Ct (f ) = f ◦ ϕt is bounded on V M OA. This is because each ϕt belongs to the Dirichlet space D (recall that ϕt is univalent) and therefore also in V M OA. Thus the composition semigroup (Ct ) consists of bounded operators on V M OA. Moreover (Ct ) is strongly continuous on V M OA for every semigroup (ϕt ). This was stated in [18] without proof, and is contained as a special case among the Qp,0 spaces in [20, Theorem 4.1]. A short proof goes as follows. Strong continuity
52
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
requires that limt→0 f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA = 0 for each f ∈ V M OA. For a polynomial P we can write f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA ≤ f ◦ ϕt − P ◦ ϕt BMOA + P ◦ ϕt − P BMOA + P − f BMOA ≤ (Ct V MOA + 1)P − f BMOA + P ◦ ϕt − P BMOA . Since V M OA contains the polynomials as a dense set and since sup Ct V MOA < ∞,
0≤t<1
it suffices to show limt→0 P ◦ ϕt − P BMOA = 0 for each polynomial. This now follows from the inequality gBMOA ≤ gD between the V M OA-norm and the Dirichlet space norm which is valid for all g ∈ D, see (2.1), along with the fact that every semigroup generates a semigroup of operators on the Dirichlet space [17, Theorem 1]. We proceed however to provide an alternative direct proof of this result which does not use [17, Theorem 1] and which is based on the V M OA−H 1 duality. Recall that this duality is realized by the pairing, f, g := lim
r→1
2π
0
f (reiθ )g(reiθ )
dθ , 2π
f ∈ V M OA, g ∈ H 1 .
If we restrict the choice of f and g, for example if both are chosen to lie in H 2 , then the pairing can be expressed by the Littlewood-Paley identity (see [22, 8.1.9]): 1 (2.3) f, g = f (0)g(0) + 2 f (z)g (z) log dA(z). |z| D Now, we present another formulation of this dual pair involving functions in spaces which will be more convenient for our purposes. Lemma 2.3. If f ∈ D and g ∈ H 1 , then 1 f, g = f (0)g(0) + 2 f (z)g (z) log dA(z). |z| D Proof. Select a sequence (gn ) in H 2 converging to g in H 1 . Using the LittewoodPaley identity, we have 1 f, gn = f (0)gn (0) + 2 f (z)gn (z) log dA(z) |z| D and f, g = limn→∞ f, gn .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Now,
Semigroups in BMOA
53
1 dA(z) |z| D 1 ≤ |f (z)(gn (z) − g (z))| log dA(z) |z| |z|>1/2 1 + |f (z)(gn (z) − g (z))| log dA(z) |z| |z|≤1/2 12 12 2 2 2 ≤ C1 |f (z)| dA(z) |gn (z) − g (z)| (1 − |z|) dA(z) D D 1 + |f (z)(gn (z) − g (z))| log dA(z) |z| |z|≤1/2
n 1 For any function h = ∞ n=0 an z ∈ H , we obtain from Hardy’s inequality (see [10, Theorem 6.2]) that |f (z)(gn (z) − g (z))| log
D
Hence,
|h (z)|2 (1 − |z|)2 dA(z) ≤ C2
D
∞ |an |2 ≤ C2 h2H 1 . n n=0
(2.4)
2
|gn (z) − g (z)| (1 − |z|)2 dA(z) ≤ C2 gn − g2H 1 .
1 ∈ L1 (dA) and Lebesgue’s dominated Finally, applying the inclusion f (z) log |z| convergence theorem, one also has 1 |f (z)(gn (z) − g (z))| log dA(z) = 0. lim n→∞ |z|≤1/2 |z|
Theorem 2.4. Every semigroup (ϕt ) generates a semigroup of operators on V M OA. Proof. From the general theory of operator semigroups, a semigroup which is weakly continuous on a Banach space is in fact strongly continuous [19, p. 233]). Thus it suffices to prove that for each f ∈ V M OA we have w − lim+ Ct (f ) = f, t→0
where w− denotes the weak limit. In other words for each fixed f ∈ V M OA we want to prove lim+ Ct (f ), g = f, g t→0
for every g ∈ H 1 . Arguing as before about the density of polynomials in V M OA and the fact that sup0≤t<1 Ct V MOA < ∞ we see that it suffices to prove this for f = P a polynomial. Now, using again the Area Theorem (ϕt is univalent), we find 2 2 |P (ϕt (z))ϕt (z)| dA(z) ≤ P ∞ |ϕt (z)|2 dA(z) ≤ P 2∞ , D
D
54
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
so we can apply Lemma 2.3. Therefore, if P a polynomial and g ∈ H 1 we deduce 1 P ◦ ϕt − P, g = (P (ϕt (0))−P (0))g(0) + 2 (P ◦ ϕt − P ) (z)g (z) log |dA(z). |z| D For each δ > 0, we split the integral 1 |(P ◦ ϕt − P ) (z)| |g (z) | log dA(z) |z| D 1 ≤ |(P ◦ ϕt ) − P ) (z)||g (z) | log dA(z) |z| |z|>δ 1 + |(P ◦ ϕt − P ) (z)||g (z) | log dA(z) = (1) + (2). |z| |z|≤δ 1 To estimate the first integral, we use the estimate log |z| ≈ 1 − |z| and apply Cauchy-Schwarz to obtain (1) ≤ CP ∞ (|ϕt (z)| + 1)|g (z)|(1 − |z|)dA(z) |z|>δ 1 1 2 ≤ CP ∞ (( |ϕt (z)| dA(z)) 2 + 1)( |g (z)|2 (1 − |z|)2 dA(z)) 2 D |z|>δ 1 ≤ 2CP ∞ ( |g (z)|2 (1 − |z|)2 dA(z)) 2 . |z|>δ
Now using (2.4) one has that g (z)(1 − |z|) ∈ L2 (dA), which shows that given ε > 0 and, for all t > 0, there exists 0 < δ0 < 1 such that 1 (2.5) |(P ◦ ϕt ) − P ) (z)| |g (z) | log |dA(z) < ε . |z| |z|>δ0 At the same time, for every z ∈ D, lim (P ◦ ϕt − P ) (z) = 0.
t→0
1 ∈ L1 (dA) (note that L2 (dA) ⊂ L1 (dA) Therefore, using the inclusion g (z) log |z| 1 and again log |z| ≈ 1 − |z|) and the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem, one concludes that 1 (2.6) lim |(P (ϕt ) − P ) (z)||g (z) | log dA(z) = 0. t→0 |z|≤δ |z| 0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
55
3. VMOA and Maximal Subspaces This section is devoted to analyzing those semigroups of analytic functions (ϕt ) such that V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]. Since V M OA is always contained in the subspace [ϕt , BM OA] we see that V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA] is equivalent to the following statement: if f ∈ BM OA, then f ∈ V M OA
if and only if
lim f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA = 0.
t→0+
It is easy to see that the inclusion V M OA ⊂ [ϕt , BM OA] can be proper. The easiest example of this type is the semigroup ϕt (z) = e−t z + 1 − e−t ,
t ≥ 0, z ∈ D.
For this semigroup the function f (z) = log(1 − z) ∈ BM OA \ V M OA satisfies f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA = log(e−t (1 − z)) − log(1 − z)BMOA = log e−t −→ 0, thus f ∈ [ϕt , BM OA]. In fact it is easy to construct general examples of semigroups with this behavior. For instance take any starlike univalent function h : D → C with h(0) = 0 and h ∈ BM OA \ V M OA and define ϕt (z) = h−1 (e−t h(z)). Then h ◦ ϕt − hBMOA = |e−t − 1|hBMOA −→ 0, so that h ∈ [ϕt , BM OA] while h ∈ V M OA. The following theorem gives a sufficient condition on the infinitesimal generator which assures that V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]. Theorem 3.1. Let (ϕt ) be a semigroup with infinitesimal generator G. Assume that for some 0 < α < 1, (1 − |z|)α = O (1) as |z| → 1. (3.1) G(z) Then V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]. Proof. Since [ϕt , BM OA] = {f ∈ BM OA : Gf ∈ BM OA}, it suffices to show {f ∈ BM OA : Gf ∈ BM OA} ⊂ V M OA. Let g ∈ BM OA with Gg ∈ BM OA. First we choose indices p, p such that 1/p + 1/p = 1, 2 < p < ∞, and such that α < p1 < α + 12 . Hence α = p1 − ε with 0 < ε < 1/2. We use the usual notation 2π 1/p iθ p dθ Mp (f, r) = |f (re )| 2π 0 and we have, taking into account that BM OA ⊂ H p , for 0 < δ ≤ r < 1, Mp (g , r) = Mp (Gg
Cp 1 1 , r) ≤ Mp (Gg , r)M∞ ( , r) ≤ , G G (1 − r)1/p −ε
where Cp is a constant depending only on p.
56
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
In order to show that g ∈ V M OA we will use the characterization of V M OA in terms of Carleson measures (see [22, 8.2.5 and 8.4.2]); it suffices to prove 2 2 2 (1 − |w| )(1 − |z| ) lim |g (w)| dA(w) = 0. 2 |z|→1 D |1 − zw| Now let q = p/2 > 1 and apply H¨ older’s inequality for the pair of indices q, q , that is, p2 + q1 = 1 to obtain D
|g (w)|2
1 2π 2 2 (1 − |w|2 )(1 − |z|2 ) iθ 2 (1 − r )(1 − |z| ) dA(w) = |g (re )| dθrdr |1 − zw|2 |1 − zre−iθ |2 0 0 q1 1 2π 2 q 2 q (1 − r ) (1 − |z| ) ≤ Mp2 (g , r) dθ dr |1 − zre−iθ |2q 0 0 1 (1 − r) Mp2 (g , r) dr = C(1 − |z|)Q(|z|), ≤ C(1 − |z|) 2− 1 0 (1 − |z|r) q
where the last inequality follows from the standard estimate (c > 0) 2π dθ 1 ≈ as |w| → 1 −iθ |1+c |1 − we (1 − |w|2 )c 0 (see, for example, [8, Exercise 2.1.4]) and Q(|z|) denotes the last integral. We now have δ 1 (1 − r) (1 − r) 2 Q(|z|) = Mp (g , r) dr + Mp2 (g , r) dr 2− q1 2− 1 0 δ (1 − |z|r) (1 − |z|r) q δ 1 1 (1 − r)1−2/p +2ε 2 2 ≤ Mp (g , δ) dr 1 dr + Cp 2− 1 0 (1 − |z|r) q δ (1 − |z|r) q 1 1 1 (1 − r)1−2/p +2ε dr + C dr ≤ C1 2 1 2− 1 0 (1 − r) q 0 (1 − |z|r) q 1 (1 − r)1−2/p +2ε = C1 + C2 dr 2− 1 0 (1 − |z|r) q ≤ C1 + C2 (1 − |z|)−1+2ε where the last integral was calculated by integration by parts as in [16, Lemma 6]. For the sake of clearness, we recall that such an estimate is exactly 1 (1 − r)γ dr ≤ C(1 − ρ)1+γ−m , ρ ∈ (0, 1), m 0 (1 − ρr) where γ = 1 −
2 p
+ 2ε > −1, m = 2 −
1 q
> 1 + γ, and ρ = r|z|.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
57
Putting all these together we find
D
|g (w)|
2
(1 − |w|2 )(1 − |z|2 ) dA(w) ≤ C(1 − |z|)Q(|z|) |1 − zw|2 ≤ C(1 − |z|)(C1 + C2 (1 − |z|)−1+2ε ) ≤ C max{(1 − |z|), (1 − |z|)2ε },
and the proof is complete. As an immediate corollary we have
Corollary 3.2. Suppose (ϕt ) is a semigroup whose infinitesimal generator G satisfies condition (3.1) of Theorem 3.1. Then for a function f ∈ BM OA the following are equivalent 1. f ∈ V M OA. 2. limt→0+ f ◦ ϕt − f BMOA = 0. Clearly the semigroups ϕt (z) = e−t z and ϕt (z) = eit z satisfy the condition (3.1) since, in both cases, the infinitesimal generator is G(z) = cz for a certain nonzero constant c. Thus Theorem 3.1 gives an alternative proof (with entirely different techniques, see also [22]) of Sarason’s result. But there is a plethora of different semigroups (ϕt ) for which V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]. A specific class of examples of this type are given by the semigroups associated with the generators G(z) = −z(1 − z)α ,
0 < α < 1.
To appreciate the breadth of the theorem recall that infinitesimal generators of semigroups with Denjoy-Wolff point b = 0 have the form G(z) = −zP (z) where Re P (z) ≥ 0. By Schwarz’s lemma applied to 1/P which also has nonnegative real part, P (z) satisfies the growth condition 1 1 + |z| P (z) ≤ C2 1 − |z| as |z| → 1. Thus the most general infinitesimal generator of semigroups with inner DenjoyWolff point, fulfills the condition 1−|z| G(z) = O(1). Remark. Clearly, our O(1) condition is intimately related to the number and location of the zeros (in the angular sense) of the infinitesimal generator on the boundary of the unit disk. This topic has been partly analyzed in [6]. Another sufficient condition of the same nature which implies the conclusion of the theorem is dA(z) < ∞, p |G(z)| |z|≥δ for some 0 < δ < 1 and p > 2. Indeed for δ < r < 1 we have 1 p (1 − r)Mp (1/G, r) ≤ Mpp (1/G, s)ds, r
58
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
so by the finiteness of the integral we have Mp (1/G, r) = o
IEOT
1 1
(1 − r) p
.
Now, using the Hardy-Littlewood estimates (see [10, 5.9]) one has CMp (1/G, r) 1 M∞ (1/G, r) ≤ =o , 1 2 (1 − r) p (1 − r) p and this little-oh condition implies our big-Oh condition. We now present a necessary condition for semigroups with inner Denjoy-Wolff point for V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA] to hold. Observe that this necessary condition is quite close to the sufficient condition of Theorem 3.1. Theorem 3.3. Let (ϕt ) be a semigroup with infinitesimal generator G and DenjoyWolff point b ∈ D. If V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA], then 1 − |z| = 0. |z|→1 G(z) lim
Proof. Without loss of generality, we may assume that b = 0. The infinitesimal generator then is G(z) = −zP (z), where P is analytic with Re P ≥ 0. If P is constant, the result is clear. Otherwise consider the function z z u 1 du = − du. m(z) = G(u) P (u) 0 0 Since Re(1/P ) ≥ 0 we have m is univalent (see [13, Proposition 1.10]) so, according to [11, Chap. IV, Exercise 25], we see that m ∈ BM OA if and only if m belongs to the Bloch space. Moreover, using [7, Chap. 17, Proposition 1.5], we deduce that m belongs to the Bloch space and thus m ∈ BM OA. Now observe that z ϕt (z) − z ϕt (z)ϕt (z) − = G(ϕt (z)) G(z) G(z) t t ∂ϕs (z) 1 ds = ϕs (z) ds, = G(z) 0 ∂s 0
(m ◦ ϕt ) (z) − m (z) =
where we have used (1.1) twice. Hence t 2 t 2 |(m ◦ ϕt ) (z) − m (z)| = ϕs (z) ds ≤ t |ϕs (z)|2 ds. 0
0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
59
Now let I ⊂ ∂D be an interval and R(I) the corresponding Carleson rectangle. We have 1 |(m ◦ ϕt ) (z) − m (z)|2 (1 − |z|2 ) dA(z) |I| R(I) t 1 2 ≤ |ϕs (z)| ds (1 − |z|2 ) dA(z) t |I| R(I) 0 t 1 =t |ϕs (z)|2 (1 − |z|2 ) dA(z)ds |I| 0 R(I) t ≤ Ct |ϕs (z)|2 dA(z) ds 0
≤ Ct
R(I)
t 0
= Ct
0
t
D
|ϕs (z)|2 dA(z) ds
[Area(ϕs (D))]2 ds ≤ C1 t2 .
Now the norm m ◦ ϕt − mBMOA equals 1/2 1 2 2 |(m ◦ ϕt ) (z) − m (z)| (1 − |z| ) dA(z) |m(ϕt (0)) − m(0)| + sup |I| R(I) I⊂∂D ≤ |m(ϕt (0)) − m(0)| + C2 t, so limt→0 m ◦ ϕt − mBMOA = 0. Thus m ∈ [ϕt , BM OA] and by the hypothesis m ∈ V M OA. The following standard argument for functions in V M OA completes a−z the proof. For a ∈ D write φa (z) = 1−¯ az , then (1 − |a|2 )2 |m (a)|2 = |(m ◦ φa ) (0)|2 ≤ m ◦ φa 2H 2 ≤C |(m ◦ φa (z)) |2 (1 − |z|2 ) dA(z) D
(by the change of variables w = φa (z)) =C |m (w)|2 (1 − |φa (w)|2 ) dA(w) D (1 − |a|2 )(1 − |w|2 ) =C |m (w)|2 dA(w) |1 − a ¯w|2 D and this last integral tends to 0 as |a| → 1 because m ∈ V M OA. It follows that 1 − |a| (1 − |a|)m (a) = lim = 0. |a|→1 G(a) |a|→1 a lim
We end this paper by characterizing those semigroups (ϕt ) of linear fractional maps such that V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]. Roughly speaking, we show that, when
60
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
IEOT
dealing with semigroups of linear fractional maps, those found by Sarason are the unique ones for which his theorem is true. For a detailed analysis of these types of semigroups in one and several variables we refer the reader to [3]. Proposition 3.4. Let (ϕt ) be a semigroup such that each iterate is a linear fractional map. Then, V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA] if and only if (ϕt ) has a fixed point in the unit disk but is without fixed points in the boundary of the unit disk. Proof. We freely use some results from [3]. In particular, we use that the infinitesimal generator of a semigroup of linear fractional maps is a polynomial of degree two. Assume that V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA]. First of all, we are going to prove that the Denjoy-Wolff point of the semigroup (ϕt ) must be in the unit disk. Let σ be the Koenigs or univalent map of the semigroup (see [17]). It is known that σ satisfies σ ◦ ϕt = σ + t, for all t ≥ 0. If the semigroup is hyperbolic, using [5, Theorem 2.1], [11, page 283] and [13, page 78], we conclude that σ ∈ BM OA \ V M OA. Moreover, we observe that t→0
σ ◦ ϕt − σBMOA = t −→ 0, and, therefore, σ ∈ [ϕt , BM OA]. Hence, the equality we are dealing with is impossible for this type of semigroup (we want to mention that this argument is indeed completely general, not only valid in the framework of semigroups of linear fractional maps). If the semigroup is parabolic, then σ is the Riemann map of a half-plane. In this case, taking c ∈ C\σ(D), we see that f (z) = Log(σ(z)−c) ∈ BM OA\V M OA and, arguing as in the hyperbolic case, we obtain f ∈ [ϕt , BM OA]. Therefore, for this type of semigroup the equality is also impossible and we conclude that the semigroup is necessarily elliptic (it has a fixed point in D). Therefore, we may assume in our proof that the semigroup has Denjoy-Wolff point in D. Now, since V M OA = [ϕt , BM OA], using Theorem 3.3, we have 1 − |z| = 0. |z|→1 G(z) lim
If the other fixed point is in the boundary, then the infinitesimal generator has the form G(z) = λ(z − a)(z − b), with a ∈ ∂D, b ∈ D and λ = 0. Taking limits, we obtain a contradiction. Likewise, assume now that (ϕt ) has no fixed point in the boundary of D. In this case, the infinitesimal generator fits the following scheme: G(z) = or G(z) =
λ(z − a)(z − b), with a ∈ C \ D, b ∈ D and λ = 0 λ(z − b), with b ∈ D and λ = 0.
Finally, apply Theorem 3.1
Vol. 61 (2008)
Semigroups in BMOA
61
References [1] E. Berkson and H. Porta, Semigroups of analytic functions and composition operators, Michigan Math. J. 25 (1978) 101–115. [2] P.S. Bourdon, J.A. Cima, and A.L. Matheson, Compact composition operators on BM OA, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 351 (1999) 2183–2196. [3] F. Bracci, M.D. Contreras, and S. D´ıaz-Madrigal, Infinitesimal generators associated with semigroups of linear fractional maps. J. Analyse Math. 102 (2007) 119–142. [4] M.D. Contreras and S. D´ıaz-Madrigal, Fractional iteration in the disk algebra: prime ends and composition operators, Revista Mat. Iberoamericana 21 (2005) 911–928. [5] M.D. Contreras and S. D´ıaz-Madrigal, Analytic flows in the unit disk: angular derivatives and boundary fixed points, Pacific J. Math. 222 (2005) 253–286. [6] M.D. Contreras, S. D´ıaz-Madrigal, and Ch. Pommerenke, On boundary critical points for semigroups of analytic functions, Math. Scand. 98 (2006) 125–142. [7] J.B. Conway, Functions of One Complex Variable II, Graduated Texts in Mathematics, vol. 159, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1995. [8] C. Cowen and B. MacCluer, Composition Operators on Spaces of Analytic Functions, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1995. [9] N. Dunford and J. T. Schwartz, Linear operators, Part I. Wiley Classics Library, John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York, 1988. [10] P.L. Duren, Theory of H p -spaces, Academic Press, New York, 1970. [11] J.B. Garnett, Bounded Analytic Functions, Pure and Applied Mathematics, Vol. 96, Academic Press, New York, 1981. ¨ [12] Ch. Pommerenke, Uber die subordination analytischer Funktionen, J. Reine Angew. Math. 218 (1965) 159–173. [13] Ch. Pommerenke, Boundary Behaviour of Conformal Maps, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1992. [14] D. Sarason, Function of vanishing mean oscillation, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 207 (1975) 391–405. [15] D. Sarason, Function Theory on the Unit Circle, Virginia Poly. Inst. and State Univ. Blacksburg, Virginia, 1979. [16] A. L. Shields and D. L. Williams, Bounded projections, duality and multipliers in spaces of analytic functions, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 162 (1971), 287–302. [17] A. G. Siskakis, Semigroups of composition operators on the Dirichlet space, Results Math. 30 (1996), 165–173. [18] A. G. Siskakis, Semigroups of composition operators on spaces of analytic functions, a review, Contemp. Math. 213 (1998) 229–252. [19] K. Yosida, Functional Analysis, Springer-Verlag, Sixth Edition, Fundamental Principles of Mathematical Sciences, vol. 123, Springer-Verlag, Berlin-New York, 1980. [20] K. J. Wirths and J. Xiao, Recognizing Qp,0 functions as per Dirichlet space structure, Bull. Belg. Math. Soc. 8 (2001), 47–59. [21] J. Xiao, Holomorphic Q Classes, Lecture Notes in Math. 1767, Springer-Verlag 2001. [22] K. Zhu, Operator Theory in Function spaces, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York and Basel, 1990.
62
Blasco, Contreras, D´ıaz-Madrigal, Mart´ınez and Siskakis
O. Blasco Departamento de An´ alisis Matem´ atico Universidad de Valencia 46100 Burjassot Valencia Spain e-mail:
[email protected] M.D. Contreras and S. D´ıaz-Madrigal Departamento de Matem´ atica Aplicada II Escuela T´ecnica Superior de Ingenieros Universidad de Sevilla Camino de los Descubrimientos, s/n 41092, Sevilla Spain e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] J. Mart´ınez Departamento de An´ alisis Matem´ atico Universidad de Valencia 46100 Burjassot Valencia Spain e-mail:
[email protected] A.G. Siskakis Department of Mathematics Aristotle University of Thessaloniki 54006 Thessaloniki Greece e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: July 28, 2006 Revised: January 14, 2008
IEOT
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 63–75 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010063-13, published online April 18, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1583-8
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Spectra of Toeplitz Operators and Compositions of Muckenhoupt Weights with Blaschke Products Sergei Grudsky and Eugene Shargorodsky Abstract. We discuss the optimality of a sufficient condition from [12] for a point to belong to the essential spectrum of a Toeplitz operator with a bounded measurable coefficient. Our approach is based on a new sufficient condition for a composition of a Muckenhoupt weight with a Blaschke product to belong to the same Muckenhoupt class. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 47B35, 45E10, 30D50. Keywords. Toeplitz operators, cluster values, Blaschke products, Muckenhoupt weights.
1. Introduction and main results Let T = {ζ ∈ C : |ζ| = 1} be the unit circle. A number c ∈ C is called a (left, right) cluster value of a measurable function a : T → C at a point ζ ∈ T if 1/(a − c) ∈ L∞ (W ) for every neighbourhood (left semi-neighbourhood, right semi-neighbourhood) W ⊂ T of ζ. Cluster values are invariant under changes of the function on measure zero sets. We denote the set of all left (right) cluster values of a at ζ by a(ζ − 0) (by a(ζ + 0)), and use also the following notation a(ζ) = a(ζ − 0) ∪ a(ζ + 0), a(T) = ∪ζ∈T a(ζ). It is easy to see that a(ζ − 0), a(ζ + 0), a(ζ) and a(T) are closed sets. Hence they are all compact if a ∈ L∞ (T). Let H p (T), 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞ denote the Hardy space, that is H p (T) := {f ∈ Lp (T) : fn = 0 for n < 0}, where fn is the nth Fourier coefficient of f . Let T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T), 1 < p < ∞ denote the Toeplitz operator generated by a function a ∈ L∞ (T), i.e. T (a)f = P (af ), f ∈ H p (T), where P is the Riesz The first author was partially supported by CONACYT project U46936-F, Mexico.
64
Grudsky and Shargorodsky
IEOT
projection:
1 g(w) 1 dw, ζ ∈ T. P g(ζ) = g(ζ) + 2 2πi T w − ζ P : Lp (T) → H p (T), 1 < p < ∞ is a bounded projection and +∞ +∞ n gn ζ gn ζ n . = P n=−∞
n=0
If a(ζ) consists of at most two points for each ζ ∈ T, in particular if a is continuous or piecewise continuous, then the spectrum of T (a) can be described in terms of a(ζ ± 0), ζ ∈ T (see [3, 4, 13]). This is no longer possible if a(ζ) is allowed to contain more than two points (see [2, 4.71–4.78] and [10]). It is no longer sufficient to know the values of a in this case, it is important to know “how these values are attained” by a. Since a complete description of the essential spectrum of T (a) in terms of the cluster values of a ∈ L∞ (T) is impossible, it is natural to try finding “optimal” sufficient conditions for a point λ to belong to the essential spectrum. Results of this sort were obtained in [11, 12]. In order to state them we need the following notation. Let K ⊂ C be an arbitrary compact set and λ ∈ C \ K. Then the set w − λ σ(K; λ) = w∈K ⊆T |w − λ| is compact as a continuous image of a compact set. Hence the set ∆λ (K) := T \ σ(K; λ) is open in T. So, ∆λ (K) is the union of an at most countable family of open arcs. We call an open arc of T p–large if its length is greater than or equal to p 2π max{p,q} , where q = p−1 , 1 < p < ∞. The following result has been proved in [12]. Theorem 1.1. Let 1 < p < ∞, a ∈ L∞ (T), λ ∈ C \ a(T) and suppose that, for some ζ ∈ T, (i) ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) (or ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) ) contains at least two p–large arcs, (ii) ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) (or ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) respectively ) contains at least one p–large arc. Then λ belongs to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T). A weaker result (with ∆λ (a(ζ)) in place of ∆λ (a(ζ ± 0)) in condition (ii)) was proved in [11] where it was also shown that condition (i) is optimal in the following sense: for any compact K ⊂ C and λ ∈ C \ K such that ∆λ (K) contains at most one p–large arc there exists a ∈ L∞ (T) such that a(−1 ± 0) = a(T) = K and T (a) − λI : H r (T) → H r (T) is invertible for any r ∈ [min{p, q}, max{p, q}]. A question that has been open since [11] is whether or not condition (ii) can be dropped, i.e. whether condition (i) alone is sufficient for λ to belong to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T). The following result gives a negative answer to this question.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Toeplitz Operators and Blaschke Products
65
Theorem 1.2. There exists a ∈ L∞ (T) such that a(1 − 0) = {±1}, |a| ≡ 1, T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible for any p ∈ (1, 2), and T (1/a) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible for any p ∈ (2, +∞). The proof of Theorem 1.2 relies on an argument which is related to the following question. Suppose v is an inner function, i.e. v is a nonconstant function in H ∞ (T) such that |v| = 1 almost everywhere on T. If b ∈ L∞ (T), then b◦v ∈ L∞ (T) and the question is whether or not the invertibility of T (b) : H p (T) → H p (T) implies that of T (b ◦ v) : H p (T) → H p (T). An equivalent form of this question is in terms Ap classes (see [1, Section 1]). We say that a measurable function ρ : T → [0, +∞] satisfies the Ap condition if p1 q1 1 1 sup ρp (ζ)|dζ| ρ−q (ζ)|dζ| = Cp < ∞, (1.1) |I| I |I| I I where I ⊂ T is an arbitrary arc and |I| denotes its length. The question is whether or not ρ ∈ Ap implies ρ ◦ v ∈ Ap . Although the answer is positive in the case p = 2 (see, e.g., [1, Section 2]), it turns out that for every p ∈ (1, +∞) \ {2} there exist a Blaschke product B and ρ ∈ Ap such that ρ ◦ B ∈ Ap (see [1, Theorem 9]). Equivalently, there exists b ∈ L∞ (T) such that T (b) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible, but T (b ◦ B) : H p (T) → H p (T) is not invertible (see [1, Theorem 12]). We prove a result in the opposite direction, namely we describe a class of Blaschke products for which the implications ρ ∈ Ap =⇒ ρ ◦ B ∈ Ap , T (b) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible =⇒ T (b ◦ B) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible do hold. Consider the Blaschke product ∞
rk − eiθ B eiθ = , 1 − rk eiθ k=1
where rk ∈ (0, 1) and ∞ k=1 (1 − rk ) < 1.
θ ∈ [−π, π],
Theorem 1.3. Suppose r1 ≤ r2 ≤ · · · ≤ rn ≤ · · · , and 1 − rk+1 inf > 0. k≥1 1 − rk If ρ satisfies the Ap condition, then ρ ◦ B also satisfies the Ap condition.
(1.2)
(1.3)
Corollary 1.4. Let 1 < p < ∞, a ∈ L∞ (T), and let a Blaschke product B satisfy the conditions of Theorem 1.3. Then T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible if and only if T (a ◦ B) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible. Proof. The invertibility of T (a ◦ B) implies that of T (a) according to [1, Theorem 12]. The opposite implication follows from Theorem 1.3 (see [1, Section 1]).
66
Grudsky and Shargorodsky
IEOT
2. Auxiliary results on inner and outer functions According to the canonical factorisation theorem (see, e.g., [5, Theorem 2.8]), any function from H p (T) \ {0} has a unique, modulo a constant factor, representation as the product of an outer function from H p (T) and an inner function. A function F ∈ H p (T) is called an outer function if π it 1 e +z F (z) = eic exp log φ(t) dt , |z| < 1, (2.1) 2π −π eit − z where c is a real number, φ ≥ 0, log φ ∈ L1 ([−π, π]), and φ ∈ Lp ([−π, π]). A function v ∈ H ∞ (T) is called an inner function if |v| = 1 almost everywhere on T. Any inner function v admits a unique factorisation of the form v(z) = eic B(z)S(z), where c is a real number, B is a Blaschke product zk zk − z B(z) = z m |zk | 1 − zk z k
with m ∈ N∪{0}, zk = rk exp(iθk ) = 0, θk ∈ (−π, π], rk = |zk | < 1, 1, and S is a singular inner function π it e +z S(z) = exp − dµ(t) it −π e − z
k (1−rk )
<
with a nonnegative measure µ which is singular with respect to the standard Lebesgue measure on [−π, π]. We are particularly interested in the case where v has a unique discontinuity at z = 1 and infinitely many zeros zk . In this case, limk→∞ zk = 1, the singular measure µ is supported by the point t = 0, and z+1 S(z) = exp κ , κ = const > 0 z−1 (see [7, Ch. II, Theorems 6.1 and 6.2]). We will also assume that B(0) = 0. Then ∞
zk zk − eiθ , θ ∈ [−π, π]. (2.2) B eiθ = |zk | 1 − zk eiθ k=1
Theorem 2.1. ([6, Theorem 2.8]) Suppose B has the form (2.2) and limk→∞ zk = 1. Then one can choose a branch of arg B eiτ which is continuous and increasing on (0, 2π), and which satisfies the following condition
lim arg B eiτ =: A+ < 0, lim arg B eiτ =: A− > 0. τ →0+0
τ →2π−0
Moreover, at lest one of these limits is infinite and
−2 (π + ϕ (θ)) + ϕ (θ) , θ ∈ (0, π], k k θk ≥θ θk <θ
iθ arg B e =
2 θk ≤θ (π − ϕk (θ)) − θk >θ ϕk (θ) , θ ∈ [−π, 0),
(2.3)
Vol. 61 (2008)
where
Toeplitz Operators and Blaschke Products
θ − θk ϕk (θ) = arctan εk cot , 2
εk =
1 − rk . 1 + rk
67
(2.4)
Theorem 2.2. (See [6, Theorem 2.10 and the end of the proof of Theorem 5.9].) Suppose a real valued function η is continuous on [−π, π] \ {0} and lim (η(t) ∓ π log |t|) = 0.
t→0±0
Then the function eiη admits the following representation
eiη(t) = B eit g B eit d eit , t ∈ [−π, π], where g, d ∈ C(T), the index of g is 0, and B is the infinite Blaschke product with the zeros 2 − exp(−k + 1/2) . zk = 2 + exp(−k + 1/2) We finish this section with an example of an outer function which is used in the proof of Theorem 1.2. Example 2.3. Consider the function 1−z h(z) = exp −i c log i , 2 where c > 0 and log denotes the branch of logarithm which is analytic in the complex plane cut along (−∞, 0] and real valued on (0, +∞). It is clear that h is analytic inside the unit disk, and since 1−z > 0, |z| < 1, Im i 2 h satisfies the following estimate 1 < |h(z)| < ecπ ,
|z| < 1.
Hence h, 1/h ∈ H ∞ (T) and h is an outer function (see [7, Ch. II, Corollary 4.7]). It is also clear that h ∈ C ∞ (T \ {1}), and since i we have |h(eiθ )| =
θ θ 1 − eiθ = ei 2 sin , 2 2
exp c θ2 ,
θ ∈ (0, π],
exp c θ2 + π , θ ∈ [−π, 0), θ iθ arg h(e ) = −c log sin . 2
(2.5)
68
Grudsky and Shargorodsky
IEOT
3. Proof of Theorem 1.3 Suppose the conditions of Theorem 1.3 are satisfied and let
A(θ) := arg B eiθ , A(±π) = 0. The proof of Theorem 1.3 relies upon analysis of the properties of A. The corresponding results are collected in the following two lemmas. Since A admits the representation (2.3), (2.4) (with θk = 0 for all k = 1, 2, . . . ), it is convenient to rewrite (1.3) in the following equivalent form εk+1 inf =: c0 > 0. (3.1) k≥1 εk Lemma 3.1. a) The derivative A is increasing on [−π, 0) and decreasing on (0, π]. b)1 c1 |A(θ)| , ∀θ ∈ [−π, π] \ {0}, ≤ A (θ) ≤ | sin θ| 4| sin θ2 | c)
A (θ/c) < c2 , ∀θ ∈ [−π, π] \ {0}, A (θ)
Proof. Let
c1 := min{c0 , ε1 }.
∀c > 1.
θ Ak (θ) := arctan εk cot . 2
Then A(θ) = −2
∞
Ak (θ),
A (θ) = −2
k=1
∞
Ak (θ)
k=1
(see (2.3), (2.4)). a) Since −Ak (θ)
= =
1 2 = 2
1 + εk cot θ2 2 sin εk
, 2 (1 − ε2k ) sin2 θ2 + ε2k εk 2 sin2
θ 2
θ 2
εk
2 + εk cos θ2
A is increasing on [−π, 0) and decreasing on (0, π]. b) The equality −Ak (θ) = implies
1 We
εk 2 sin2
θ 2
εk cot θ2 1 1 =
2 sin θ 1 + εk cot θ 2 1 + εk cot θ2 2
Ak (θ) 1 uk Ak (θ) = | sin θ| (1 + u2 ) arctan uk , k
will not use the upper estimate for A (θ).
uk = εk cot
|θ| . 2
Vol. 61 (2008)
Since
Toeplitz Operators and Blaschke Products
69
u u = lim = 1, 2 ) arctan u 2 ) arctan u u→0+0 (1 + u (1 + u u∈(0,+∞) sup
we get the second inequality in b). Let us prove the first one. It is clear that εk0 cot θ2 uk0 1 1 |θ| , uk0 = εk0 cot A (θ) ≥ =
sin θ 1 + εk cot θ 2 | sin θ| 1 + u2k0 2 0
2
for any k0 ∈ N. Let k0 be the smallest natural number such that uk0 ≤ 1. If k0 > 1, then (3.1) implies εk0 uk0 = ≤ uk0 ≤ 1. c0 ≤ εk0 −1 uk0 −1 Hence uk0 c0 ≥ 2 1 + uk0 2 and c0 c0 ≥ A (θ) ≥ . 2| sin θ| 4| sin θ2 | If k0 = 1, then ε1 ε1 ε1 1 . A (θ) ≥ 2 ≥
2 θ 2 θ ≥ θ 2 sin 2 1 + ε1 cot 4 sin 2 4| sin θ2 | 2
This proves the first inequality in b). c) Since sin ϑ ≤ c sin ϑc and cot ϑc > cot ϑ, ∀ϑ ∈ (0, π/2], we have 2
sin2 θ2 1 + εk cot θ2 Ak (θ/c) 2 = 2 < c .
θ Ak (θ) sin2 2c 1 + εk cot θ
2c
Lemma 3.2. Suppose ϑ0 , ϑ1 , ϑ2 ∈ [−π, π] \ {0}, signϑ0 = signϑ1 = signϑ2 , |ϑ0 | > |ϑ1 | > |ϑ2 |, and |A(ϑ1 ) − A(ϑ0 )| = 2π = |A(ϑ2 ) − A(ϑ1 )|. Then a) |ϑ0 − ϑ1 | ≤ c2 |ϑ0 |, where the constant c2 ∈ (0, 1) depends only on c1 from Lemma 3.1-b); b) |ϑ0 − ϑ1 | ≤ c3 , 1≤ |ϑ1 − ϑ2 | where c3 depends only on c1 . Proof. a) Let ϑ˜ ∈ (ϑ1 , ϑ0 ) be such that c1 . 4 ˜ ϑ0 ) such that Then, according to the mean value theorem, there exists ϑ∗ ∈ (ϑ, c ∗ ˜ 1 . A (ϑ ) ϑ − ϑ0 = 4 ˜ − A(ϑ0 )| = |A(ϑ)
70
Grudsky and Shargorodsky
IEOT
It follows from Lemma 3.1-b) that c ϑ |ϑ | ϑ∗ c 1 ϑ∗ ϑ0 − ϑ˜ ≤ 1 =⇒ ϑ0 − ϑ˜ ≤ sin ≤ sin 0 ≤ 0 . 4 2 2 2 4 sin 2 Since ϑ0 − ϑ˜ ≤ |ϑ0 |/2, the monotonicity of A implies |A(ϑ0 /2) − A(ϑ0 )| ≥
c1 . 4
Similarly |A(ϑ0 /2j ) − A(ϑ0 /2j−1 )| ≥
c1 , 4
j ∈ N.
Let M = [8π/c1 ] + 1. Then |A(ϑ0 /2M ) − A(ϑ0 )| =
M
|A(ϑ0 /2j ) − A(ϑ0 /2j−1 )| ≥ M
j=1
8π c1 c1 > = 2π. 4 c1 4
M
Hence ϑ1 ∈ (ϑ0 /2 , ϑ0 ) and
|ϑ0 − ϑ1 | < |ϑ0 − ϑ0 /2M | = 1 − 2−M |ϑ0 |.
This proves a) with c2 = 1 − 2−M = 1 − 2−([8π/c1 ]+1) . b) According to the mean value theorem, there exist ϕ1 ∈ (ϑ1 , ϑ0 ) and ϕ2 ∈ (ϑ2 , ϑ1 ) such that |ϑ0 − ϑ1 | |A (ϕ2 )| = . |ϑ1 − ϑ2 | |A (ϕ1 )| It follows from part a) that 1≥
ϕ2 ϑ2 ϑ2 ϑ1 > = ≥ (1 − c2 )2 = 2−2([8π/c1 ]+1) . ϕ1 ϑ0 ϑ1 ϑ0
It is now left to use Lemma 3.1-a), c). One can take c3 = 24([8π/c1 ]+1) .
Proof of Theorem 1.3. Let θj ∈ (−π, π] be the points such that A(θj ) = −2πj,
j = 0, ±1, ±2, . . .
(3.2)
and let Ij = γ (exp(iθj+1 ), exp(iθj )) ,
j = 0, ±1, ±2, . . . ,
where γ(ζ, ζ ) ⊂ T is the arc described by a point moving from ζ to ζ in the counterclockwise direction. Any arc I ⊂ T admits the representation: I˜j , Ij I = j∈J
j∈J˜
Vol. 61 (2008)
Toeplitz Operators and Blaschke Products
71
where the set J is finite or infinite, the set J˜ contains at most two elements, and the arcs I˜j have one of the following forms: a) if J = ∅, then J˜ contains one element and I˜j = γ exp(iθ˜j+1 ), exp(iθ˜j ) , where |A(θ˜j+1 ) − A(θ˜j )| < 4π; b) if J = ∅, then
I˜j = γ exp(iθj ), exp(iθ˜j ) or γ exp(iθ˜j ), exp(iθj )
and |A(θj ) − A(θ˜j )| < 2π. Case a). Suppose J = ∅, I = I˜j = γ exp(iθ˜j+1 ), exp(iθ˜j ) ,
|A(θ˜j+1 ) − A(θ˜j )| < 4π.
Since I may contain the point −1, but does not contain in our case the point 1, it is convenient to switch from the function A defined on [−π, π]\{0} to the following function defined on (0, 2π): A(ψ), if ψ ∈ (0, π], A(ψ) = (3.3) A(ψ − 2π), if ψ ∈ (π, 2π). Let ψ0 < ψ1 be such that A(ψ0 ) = A(θ˜j+1 ) and A(ψ1 ) = A(θ˜j ). Using the change of variable u = A(ψ) we get ψ1
1 1 p ρ (B(ζ))|dζ| = ρp exp(iA(ψ)) dψ ∆p := |I| I ψ1 − ψ0 ψ0 A(ψ1 ) 1 du = ρp (exp(iu)) ψ1 − ψ0 A(ψ0 ) A (ψ(u)) maxψ∈[ψ0 ,ψ1 ] (A (ψ))−1 A(ψ1 ) p ≤ ρ (exp(iu))du. ψ1 − ψ0 A(ψ0 ) According to the mean value theorem there exists ψ ∗ ∈ (ψ0 , ψ1 ) such that A (ψ ∗ )(ψ1 − ψ0 ) = A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ). It is now easy to derive from Lemmas 3.1 and 3.2 that A(ψ1 ) A (ψ ∗ ) 1 p ∆p ≤ ρ (exp(iu))du minψ∈[ψ0 ,ψ1 ] A (ψ) A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ) A(ψ0 ) A(ψ1 ) c4 ρp (exp(iu))du, ≤ A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ) A(ψ0 )
72
Grudsky and Shargorodsky
IEOT
where the constant c4 depends only on c1 from Lemma 3.1-b). Similarly, A(ψ1 ) 1 c4 −q ρ (B(ζ))|dζ| ≤ ρ−q (exp(iu))du. |I| I A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ) A(ψ0 ) Hence
p1 1q 1 −q ρ (B(ζ))|dζ| ρ (B(ζ))|dζ| ≤ |I| I I p1 A(ψ1 ) 1 p ρ (exp(iu))du × c4 A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ) A(ψ0 ) q1 A(ψ1 ) 1 ρ−q (exp(iu))du ≤ 2c4 Cp A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ) A(ψ0 ) 1 |I|
p
(see (1.1)). The factor 2 appears in the right-hand side because A(ψ1 ) − A(ψ0 ) may be larger than 2π but is less than 2 × 2π. Case b). Let J0 ⊂ Z be the smallest set such that Ij . I⊆ j∈J0
It follows from Lemma 3.2-b) that |Ij | ≤ c5 |Ij | ≤ c5 |I|, j∈J0
(3.4)
j∈J
where the constant c5 depends only on c1 from Lemma 3.1-b). Let us estimate ρp (B(ζ))|dζ|. Λj,p = Ij
This is similar to but easier than the estimate for ∆p in the case a), because we do not need to deal with the function (3.3) now. Since A(θj ) − A(θj+1 ) = 2π, we have c4 |Ij | −2πj c4 |Ij | ρpLp (T) . Λj,p ≤ ρp (exp(iu))du = 2π −2π(j+1) 2π Hence
I
ρp (B(ζ))|dζ| ≤
ρp (B(ζ))|dζ| =
j∈J0
Ij
j∈J0
ρp (B(ζ))|dζ|
Ij
c4 |Ij | c4 c4 c5 ≤ |Ij | ≤ ρpLp(T) = ρpLp (T) ρpLp(T) |I| 2π 2π 2π j∈J0
(see (3.4)). Similarly
j∈J0
I
ρ−q (B(ζ))|dζ| ≤
c4 c5 −1 q ρ Lq (T) |I|. 2π
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hence
1 |I|
Toeplitz Operators and Blaschke Products
73
p1 1q 1 ρp (B(ζ))|dζ| ρ−q (B(ζ))|dζ| ≤ |I| I I c4 c5 ρLp (T) ρ−1 Lq (T) ≤ c4 c5 Cp . 2π
Remark 3.3. The proof of Theorem 1.3 can be easily extended to any inner function v such that arg v(eiτ ) has a continuous and increasing branch on (0, 2π), and A(θ) := arg v(eiθ ) has the following property maxθ∈[θj+1 ,θj−1 ] A (θ) ≤ m < +∞, minθ∈[θj+1 ,θj−1 ] A (θ)
∀j ∈ Z,
(3.5)
where θj ’s are defined by (3.2). Indeed, (3.5) is exactly what is needed for the case a) in the proof of Theorem 1.3. The case b) relies also on Lemma 3.2-b) which in turn follows from (3.5). The above applies for example to the singular inner function ζ +1 S(ζ) = exp κ , κ = const > 0. ζ −1 Indeed, θ 2 and it is not difficult to see that (3.5) holds in this case. This corresponds to the case of the so-called periodic discontinuity which was considered in [9]. A(θ) = arg S(eiθ ) = −κ cot
4. Proof of Theorem 1.2 Proof. Let a0 ∈ L∞ (T) be defined by τ a0 (eiτ ) = exp i , τ ∈ (0, 2π). 2 Then a0 is continuous on T \ {1}, a0 (1 ± 0) = ±1, T (a0 ) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible for any p ∈ (1, 2), and T (1/a0 ) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible for any p ∈ (2, +∞) (see [8, 9.3, 9.8] or [2, 5.39]). Let h0 = h exp −i π2 log 2 , where h is the function from Example 2.3 with π c = 2 . Then h0 (eit ) = |h(eit )| eiϕ(t) , t ∈ [−π, π], where π t ϕ(t) = − log 2 sin 2 2 (see (2.5)). Let f be a 2π-periodic function such that f ∈ C ∞ ([−π, π] \ {0}), f (t) = ϕ(t) if −π/2 ≤ t < 0, and f (t) = −f (−t) if 0 < t ≤ π/2. Then
(4.1) e2if (t) = B eit g B eit d eit , t ∈ [−π, π],
74
Grudsky and Shargorodsky
IEOT
where g, d ∈ C(T), the index of g is 0, and B is the infinite Blaschke product with the zeros 2 − exp(−k + 1/2) zk = 2 + exp(−k + 1/2) (see Theorem 2.2). Since the index of g is 0, there exists g0 ∈ C(T) such that g02 = g. Let d0 ∈ C(T) be such that d20 (eit ) = d(eit ) for t ∈ [−π/2, π/2], d0 (eit ) = 0 for t ∈ [−π, π] and the index of d0 is 0. Consider the function a ∈ L∞ (T) defined by it it it
g B e d e |h (e )| 0 0 0 . (4.2) a(eit ) = a0 B eit h0 (eit ) It follows from (4.1) and from the definition of the function f that a2 (eit ) = 1 if −π/2 ≤ t < 0. It is clear that the second factor in the right-hand side of (4.2) is continuous on {eit | − π/2 ≤ t < 0}, whereas the first one has infinitely many discontinuities in any left semi-neighbourhood of 1. Hence a takes values 1 and −1 in any left semi-neighbourhood of 1. So, a(1 − 0) = {±1}. The operator T (a±1 ) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible if and only if T (a±1 0 ◦B) : p H (T) → H p (T) is invertible (see, e.g., [6, Theorem 2.1, Propositions 2.3, 4.1 and p p 5.4]). The latter operator is indeed invertible because T (a±1 0 ) : H (T) → H (T) is invertible and B satisfies (1.3) (see Corollary 1.4).
References [1] A. B¨ ottcher and S. Grudsky, On the composition of Muckenhoupt weights and inner functions. J. Lond. Math. Soc., II. Ser. 58, No.1 (1998), 172-184. [2] A. B¨ ottcher and B. Silbermann, Analysis of Toeplitz Operators. Springer-Verlag, 1990. [3] K.F. Clancey, One dimensional singular integral operators on Lp . J. Math. Anal. Appl. 54 (1976), 522-529. [4] K.F. Clancey, Corrigendum for the article “One dimensional singular integral operators on Lp ”. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 99 (1984), 527-529. [5] P.L. Duren, Theory of H p Spaces. Academic Press, 1970, and Dover, 2000. [6] V. Dybin and S.M. Grudsky, Introduction to the theory of Toeplitz operators with infinite index. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, 2002. [7] J.B. Garnett, Bounded Analytic Functions. Academic Press, 1981. [8] I. Gohberg and N. Krupnik, One-Dimensional Linear Singular Integral Equations I & II. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, 1992. [9] S.M. Grudskij and A.B. Khevelev, On invertibility in L2 (R) of singular integral operators with periodic coefficients and a shift. Sov. Math. Dokl. 27 (1983), 486-489. [10] E. Shargorodsky, On singular integral operators with coefficients from Pn C. Tr. Tbilis. Mat. Inst. Razmadze 93 (1990), 52-66 (Russian).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Toeplitz Operators and Blaschke Products
75
[11] E. Shargorodsky, On some geometric conditions of Fredholmity of one-dimensional singular integral operators. Integral Equations Oper. Theory 20, No.1 (1994), 119123. [12] E. Shargorodsky, A remark on the essential spectra of Toeplitz operators with bounded measurable coefficients. Integr. Equ. Oper. Theory 57 (2007), 127-132. [13] I. M. Spitkovskij, Factorization of matrix-functions belonging to the classes A˜n (p) and TL. Ukr. Math. J. 35 (1983), 383-388 (translation from Ukr. Mat. Zh. 35, No.4 (1983), 455-460). Sergei Grudsky Departamento de Matematicas CINVESTAV del I.P.N. Apartado Postal 14-740 07000, Mexico, D.F. Mexico e-mail:
[email protected] Eugene Shargorodsky Department of Mathematics King’s College London Strand, London WC2R 2LS UK e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: July 9, 2007 Revised: March 3, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 77–102 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010077-26, published online April 18, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1581-x
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials J. William Helton, Daniel P. McAllaster and Joshua A. Hernandez Dedicated to Israel Gohberg on the occasion of his 80th birthday.
Abstract. The paper introduces a notion of the Laplace operator of a polynomial p in noncommutative variables x = (x1 , . . . , xg ). The Laplacian Lap[p, h] of p is a polynomial in x and in a noncommuting variable h. When all variables commute we have Lap[p, h] = h2 ∆x p where ∆x p is the usual Laplacian. A symmetric polynomial in symmetric variables will be called harmonic if Lap[p, h] = 0 and subharmonic if the polynomial q(x, h) := Lap[p, h] takes positive semidefinite matrix values whenever matrices X1 , . . . , Xg , H are substituted for the variables x1 , . . . , xg , h. In this paper we classify all homogeneous symmetric harmonic and subharmonic polynomials in two symmetric variables. We find there are not many of them: for example, the span of all such subharmonics of any degree higher than 4 has dimension 2 (if odd degree) and 3 (if even degree). Hopefully, the approach here will suggest ways of defining and analyzing other partial differential equations and inequalities. Keywords. Non-commutative polynomials, Laplace operator.
1. Introduction In the introduction we shall make essential definitions, then state our main results. The rest of the paper proves them. 1.1. Definitions 1.1.1. Non-Commutative Polynomials. A non-commutative monomial m of degree d on the free variables (x1 , . . . , xg ) is a product xa1 xa2 · · · xad of these variables, corresponding to a unique sequence of ai of nonnegative integers, 1 ≤ ai ≤ g. We abbreviate this m = xw , where w is the d-tuple (a1 , . . . , ad ). The set of all All authors were partially supported by J.W. Helton’s grants from the NSF and the Ford Motor Co.. and J. A. Hernandez was supported by a McNair Fellowship.
78
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
monomials in (x1 , . . . , xg ) is denoted as M and the set of indexes w is denoted W. Some notation is: |w| = d the length of w (w)i = ai the ith entry of w T w = (ad , . . . , a1 ) the transpose of w φ = () the empty word (word of length zero) The space of non-commutative polynomials p(x) = p(x1 , . . . , xg ) with real coefficients is denoted Rx and we express p as p(x) = Am m. m∈M
An example of a non-commutative polynomial is p(x) = p(x1 , x2 ) = x21 x2 x1 + x1 x2 x21 + x1 x2 − x2 x1 + 7 (in commutative variables, this would be equivalent to 2x31 x2 + 7). T The transpose of a monomial m = xw is defined to be mT = xw . The transpose of a polynomial p, denoted pT , is defined by p(x) = Am mT and m∈M
has the following properties: (1) (pT )T = p (2) (p1 + p2 )T = pT1 + pT2 (3) (αp)T = αpT (α ∈ R) (4) (p1 p2 )T = pT2 pT1 . In this paper, we shall consider primarily polynomials in symmetric variables. That is, we consider variables xi where xTi = xi . Then monomials satisfy (xa1 . . . xad−1 )T T = xad−1 . . . xa1 , which in other notation is (xw )T = xw . Symmetric (or selfadjoint) polynomials are those that are equal to their transposes. g 1.1.2. Evaluating Noncommutative Polynomials. Let (Rn×n sym ) denote the set of g-tuples (X1 , . . . , Xg ) of real symmetric n × n matrices. We shall be interested in evaluating a polynomial p(x) = p(x1 , . . . , xg ) that belongs to Rx at a tuple X = g (X1 , . . . , Xg ) ∈ (Rn×n sym ) . In this case p(X) is also an n×n matrix and the involution on Rx that was introduced earlier is compatible with matrix transposition, i.e.,
pT (X) = p(X)T , g where p(X)T denotes the transpose of the matrix p(X). When X ∈ (Rn×n sym ) is substituted into p the constant term p(0) of p(x) becomes p(0)In . Thus, for example, p(x) = 3 + x21 + 5x32 =⇒ p(X) = 3In + X12 + 5X23 .
A symmetric polynomial p ∈ Rx is matrix positive if p(X) is a positive g semidefinite matrix for each tuple X = (X1 , . . . , Xg ) ∈ (Rn×n sym ) . We emphasize that throughout this paper, unless otherwise noted, x1 , x2 , . . . , xn stand for variables and X1 , X2 , . . . , Xn stand for matrices (usually symmetric).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
79
1.1.3. Non-Commutative Differentiation. For our non-commutative purposes, we take directional derivatives in xi with regard to an indeterminate direction parameter h. d D[p(x1 , . . . , xg ), xi , h] := [p(x1 , . . . , (xi + th), . . . , xg )]|t=0 . (1) dt We say that this is the directional derivative of p(x) = p(x1 , . . . , xg ) in xi in the direction h. Note it is linear in h. For a detailed formal definition see [5], for more examples see [1]. Example 1.1. The directional derivative D[x21 x2 , x1 , h] d [(x1 + th)2 x2 ]|t=0 dt d = [x21 x2 + th x1 x2 + tx1 h x2 + t2 h2 x2 ]|t=0 dt = [h x1 x2 + x1 h x2 + 2th2 x2 ]|t=0 =
= h x1 x2 + x1 h x2 . As this example shows, the directional derivative of p on xi in the direction h is the sum of the terms produced by replacing one instance of xi with h. Lemma 1.1. The directional derivative of NC polynomials is linear, D[a p(x) + b q(x), xi , h] = a D[p(x), xi , h] + b D[q(x), xi , h] and respects transposes D[p(x)T , xi , h] = D[p(x), xi , h]T .
Proof. Straighforward.
1.1.4. Non-Commutative Laplacian and Subharmonicity. The Laplacian of a NC polynomial p(x) is defined as: Lap[p, h] := =
g
D[D[p(x), xi , h], xi , h]
i=1 g 2
d [p(x1 , . . . , (xi + th), . . . , xg )]|t=0 . 2 dt i=1
(2) (3)
Our notation is slightly inconsistent (but has advantages) in that the single letter x stands for g variables x1 , . . . , xg while h is a single variable. Note that Lap is linear in h. An NC polynomial is called harmonic if its Laplacian is zero, and subharmonic if its Laplacian is matrix-positive and purely subharmonic is used to describe a polynomial which is subharmonic but not harmonic - that is, having a nonzero, matrix-positive Laplacian. Specialization of Lap[p, h], to commutative variables, is h2 ∆ p where ∆ p g ∂xi xi p(x). Here p : Rn → R. is the standard Laplacian, namely, ∆ p := i=1
80
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
1.2. Classification of Harmonics and Subharmonics in Two Variables For our special homogeneous polynomials on two variables, define γ := x1 + i x2
(4)
where i is the imaginary number. Theorem 1. The homogeneous noncommutative polynomials in two symmetric variables which are (1a) harmonic of degree d > 2 are exactly the linear combinations of Re(γ d )
and
Im(γ d ),
(1b) harmonic of degree d = 2 are exactly the linear combinations of Re(γ d )
and
Im(γ d )
and
x1 x2 ,
(note this includes x2 x1 ), (2a) subharmonic of degree 2d with d > 2 , are exactly the linear combinations: c0 [Re(γ d )]2 + c1 Re(γ 2d ) + c2 Im(γ 2d ) = c0 [Im(γ d )]2 + (c0 + c1 ) Re(γ 2d ) + c2 Im(γ 2d )
(5)
where c0 ≥ 0, (2b) symmetric subharmonics of degree 4, are exactly the linear combinations: f
= B1 (x41 − x21 x22 − x22 x21 + x42 ) + B2 (x31 x2 + x2 x31 − x2 x1 x22 − x22 x1 x2 ) (6) +B3 (x21 x2 x1 + x1 x2 x21 − x1 x32 − x32 x1 ) + B4 (x1 x2 x1 x2 + x2 x1 x2 x1 )
+B5 x1 x22 x1 + B6 x2 x21 x2
with coefficients satisfying the inequalities: (B1 + B6 )(B1 + B5 ) > (B3 − B2 )2 + (B1 + B4 )2 and
(7)
B1 + B6 > 0
(8)
(or, equivalently
B1 + B5 > 0).
(2c) All subharmonics of degree 2 are, A1 x21 + A2 x22 + A3 x1 x2 + A4 x2 x1 with A1 + A2 ≥ 0. (3) Pure subharmonics of odd degree do not exist. Note: all of these functions except for x1 x2 and x2 x1 in (1b) and in (2c) are symmetric. Proof. Most of the remainder of this paper is focused on proving this theorem. The proofs for the parts of the theorem are as follows:
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
81
Part of theorem Section of the proof (1a.) 4.2.1 (1b.) 4.2.2 (2a.) 2.4 (2b.) 3.3 also Remark 2 (2c.) 4.2.2 (3.) 2.4 Remark 1. The following degree 3 polynomial p is unusual in that there is a region of X1 , X2 where Lap(p) is positive, but Lap(p) is not positive everywhere: A1 (x31 − x1 x22 − x2 x21 ) + A2 x2 x1 x2 + A3 x1 x2 x1 + A4 (x32 − x21 x2 − x2 x21 ) For this the region of subharmonicity is (A1 + A2 )x1 + (A3 + A4 )x2 > 0 and the region of harmonicity is A1 + A2 = A3 + A4 = 0. Of course, there is no homogeneous polynomial of degree three which is subharmonic over all values of x1 and x2 . 1.3. Subharmonics are All Built from Harmonics Our second main result is a general fact which holds in any number of variables: Theorem 2. Assume the harmonic polynomials homogeneous of degree d2 have a basis γ1 , . . . , γk with the independence property: there is a monomial wj in γj which does not occur in the other γ1 , . . . , γk . If p is a homogeneous symmetric subharmonic polynomial of degree even d, then p has the form p=
f inite
ci RiT Ri
i
for some homogeneous harmonic functions Rj of degree
d 2
and real numbers cj .
Because of this, knowing all homogeneous subharmonics will likely occur once the harmonics are classified. Proof. The proof is found in §4.1.1.
1.4. Comparison with Commutative Subharmonic Polynomials The study of harmonic and subharmonic polynomials in commuting variables is classical. Harmonic commuting polynomials are classified in any number of variables and the have a close correspondence to spherical harmonics. A good reference on this is [7] §2.4, pp. 110–113. For two commuting variables, the homogeneous harmonic polynomials are those of the form, Re(x1 + Ix2 )n
and Im(x1 + Ix2 )n ,
so the commuting and noncommuting case are exactly parallel.
82
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
1.5. Related Topics and Motivation Non-Commutative Convexity The non-commutative Hessian is defined as: d2 [p(x1 + tη1 , . . . , xg + tg ηg )]|t=0 . dt2 Note that this is composed of several independent direction parameters, ηi and that if p is a polynomial, then its Hessian is a polynomial in x and η which is homogeneous of degree 2 in η. A non-commutative polynomial is considered convex wherever its Hessian is matrix-positive. A polynomial p(x) = p(x1 , . . . , xd ) is geometrically convex if and only if, for g every X, Y ∈ (Rn×n sym ) , X +Y 1 p(X) + p(Y ) − p 2 2 NCHes[p(x1 , . . . , xg ), {x1 , η1 }, . . . , {xg , ηg }] :=
is positive-semidefinite. It is proved in [3] that convexity is equivalent to geometric convexity. A crucial fact regarding these polynomials (see [4]) is that they are all of degree two or less. Some excellent papers on noncommutative convexity are [8] [2]. The commutative analog of this “directional” Hessian is the quadratic function η1 η1 . . . (9) H p . · .. where H p is the Hessian matrix: ∂x1 x1 p(x) .. .
ηg
··· .. . ∂xg x1 p(x) · · ·
ηg ∂x1 xg p(x) .. . .
(10)
∂xg xg p(x)
If this Hessian is positive semidefinite at all (x1 , . . . , xg ), then f is said to be convex. Non-Commutative Algebra in Engineering. Inequalities, involving polynomials in matrices and their inverses, and associated optimization problems have become very important in engineering. When such polynomials are matrix convex, local minima are global. This is extremely important in applications. Also, interior point numerical methods apply well to these. In the last few years, the approaches that have been proposed in the field of optimization and control theory based on linear matrix inequalities and semidefinite programming have become very important and promising, since the same framework can be used for a large set of problems. Matrix inequalities provide a nice setup for many engineering and related problems, and if they are convex the optimization problem is well behaved and interior point methods provide efficient algorithms which are effective on moderate sized
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
83
problems. Unfortunately, the class of matrix convex noncommutative polynomials is very small; as already mentioned they are all of degree two or less [4]. Our original interest in subharmonic polynomials was to analyze conditions similar to convexity, though not as restrictive, in the hopes of finding much broader classes which still had nice properties. What we found (as reported here) was that subharmonic polynomials are (in two) variables a highly restricted class. Noncommutative Analysis. This article would come under the general heading of “free analysis”, since the setting is a noncommutative algebra whose generators are “free” of relations. This is a burdgeoning area, of which free probability is currently the largest component. The interested reader is referred to the web site [10] of American Institute of Mathematics, in particular it gives the findings of the AIM workshop in 2006 on free analysis. A fairly expository article describing noncommutative convexity, noncommutative semialgebraic geometry and relations to engineering is [6].
2. Existence Proofs Now we set about to prove Theorem 1. In this section, we show that the polynomials claimed to be harmonic and subharmonic are indeed. In section 4, we show that these are the only posibilities. 2.1. Product Rules for Derivatives To begin with, we will build up facts about derivatives. 2.1.1. Product Rule for First Derivatives. Lemma 2.1. The product rule for the directional derivative of NC polynomials is D[p1 p2 , xi , h] = D[p1 , xi , h] p2 + p1 D[p2 , xi , h].
(11)
Proof. The directional derivative D[m, xi , h] of a product m = m1 m2 of noncommutative monomials m1 and m2 is the sum of terms produced by replacing one instance of xi in m by h. This sum can be divided into two parts: µ1 , the sum of terms whose h lie in the first |m1 | letters, i.e. D[m1 , xi , h]m2 µ2 , the sum of terms whose h lie in the last |m2 | letters, i.e. m1 D[m2 , xi , h]. Therefore D[m1 m2 , xi , h] = D[m1 , xi , h]m2 + m1 D[m2 , xi , h]. We can extend this product rule to the product of any two non-commutative polynomials p1 and p2 as follows.
84
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
D[p1 p2 , xi , h] = D
=
Am1 m1
m1 ∈Wp1
IEOT
Am2 m2 , xi , h
m2 ∈Wp2
Am1 Am2 D[m1 m2 , xi , h]
m1 ∈Wp1 m2 ∈Wp2
=
Am1 Am2 D[m1 , xi , h] m2 + Am1 Am2 m1 D[m2 xi , h]
m1 ∈Wp1 m2 ∈Wp2
=D
Am1 m1 , xi , h
m1 ∈Wp1
Am2 m2 +
m2 ∈Wp2
Am1 m1 D
m1 ∈Wp1
Am2 m2 , xi , h
m2 ∈Wp2
= D[p1 , xi , h] p2 + p1 D[p2 , xi , h].
(12)
2.1.2. The Laplacian of a Product. We now prove Theorem 1 part (2b). Lemma 2.2. The product rule for the Laplacian of NC polynomials is Lap[p1 p2 , h] = Lap[p1 , h] p2 + p1 Lap[p2 , h] + 2
g D[p1 , xi , h] D[p2 , xi , h] . i=1
As a consequence if p is harmonic, then Lap[pT p, h] = 2
g D[p, xi , h]T D[p, xi , h] .
(13)
i=1
Proof. Lap[p1 p2 , h] = =
g i=1 g
D[D[p1 p2 , xi , h], xi , h] D[p1 D[p2 , xi , h] + D[p1 , xi , h] p2 , xi , h]
i=1 g p1 D[D[p2 , xi , h], xi , h] + D[D[p1 , xi , h], xi , h] p2 = i=1
+ 2D[p1 , xi , h], D[p2 , xi , h]
= Lap[p1 , h] p2 + p1 Lap[p2 , h] + 2
g D[p1 , xi , h] D[p2 , xi , h] . i=1
2.2. Formulas Involving γ d and its Derivatives Recall from (4) that γ := x1 + ix2 . Note that γ = γ T and therefore that γ d = (γ d )T . So T T Im(γ d ) = Im((γ d )T ) = Im(γ d ). Re(γ d ) = Re((γ d )T ) = Re(γ d ) and
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
85
This proves the (last) assertion in Theorem 1 that all but a few subharmonics on our list are symmetric. Lemma 2.3. The derivatives of of γ d exhibit the following symmetries. D[Re(γ d ), x1 , h] = D[Im(γ d ), x2 , h] and D[Re(γ d ), x2 , h] = −D[Im(γ d ), x1 , h]. Proof. The proof proceeds by induction. To begin, it is easily seen that D[Re(γ), x1 , h] = D[Im(γ), x2 , h] = h D[Im(γ), x1 , h] = −D[Re(γ), x2 , h] = 0. Assume that D[Re(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] = D[Im(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] D[Im(γ d−1 ), x1 , 1] = −D[Re(γ d−1 ), x2 , h]. Then D[ Re(γ d ), x1 , h] = D[x1 Re(γ d−1 ) − x2 Im(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] = x1 D[Re(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] + h Re(γ d−1 ) − x2 D[Im(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] D[Im(γ d ), x2 , h] = D[x1 Im(γ d−1 ) + x2 Re(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] = x1 D[Im(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] + x2 D[Re(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] + h Re(γ d−1 ), so D[Re(γ d ), x1 , h] = D[Im(γ d ), x2 , h] which satisfies the first half of our inductive hypothesis. For the next half compute D[ Re(γ d ), x2 , h] = D[x1 Re(γ d−1 ) − x2 Im(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] = x1 D[Re(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] − x2 D[Im(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] − h Im(γ d−1 ) D[Im(γ d ), x1 , h] = D[x1 Im(γ d−1 ) + x2 Re(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] = x1 D[Im(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] + h Im(γ d−1 ) + x2 D[Re(γ d−1 ), x2 , h], so D[Re(γ d ), x2 , h] = −D[Im(γ d ), x1 , h].
86
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
2.3. Harmonics degree > 2: Proof of Theorem 1 part (1) Proof. Our proof will proceed by induction. Since the Laplacian of words of length 1 is zero, Lap[Re(γ), h] = Lap[x1 , h] = 0 and Lap[Im(γ), h] = Lap[x2 , h] = 0.
(14)
Now, assume that Lap[Re(γ d−1 ), h] = Lap[Im(γ d−1 ), h] = 0.
(15)
Re(γ d ) = Re((x1 + ix2 ) γ d−1 ) = x1 Re(γ d−1 ) − x2 Im(γ d−1 )
(16)
Im(γ d ) = Im((x1 + ix2 ) γ d−1 ) = x1 Im(γ d−1 ) + x2 Re(γ d−1 ).
(17)
Pushing ahead,
Applying our product rule to (16): Lap[Re(γ d ), h] = Lap[x1 Re(γ d−1 ), h] − Lap[x2 Im(γ d−1 ), h] = x1 Lap[Re(γ d−1 ), h] + Lap[x1 , h] Re(γ d−1 ) + 2D[x1 , x1 , h] D[Re(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] + 2D[x1 , x2 , h] D[Re(γ d−1 ), x2 , h] − x2 Lap[Im(γ d−1 ), h] − Lap[x2 , h] Im(γ d−1 ) − 2D[x2 , x1 , h] D[Im(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] − 2D[x2 , x2 , h] D[Im(γ d−1 ), x2 , h]. Use (14) and (15) to obtain that the Lap[] terms are 0, and that “cross partials are 0” to get Lap[Re(γ d ), h] = h D[Re(γ d−1 ), x1 , h] − h D[Im(γ d−1 ), x2 , h]. By symmetry Lemma 2.3, this means Re(Lap[γ d , h]) = Lap[Re(γ d ), h] = 0. By a similar argument, applying the product rule to (17), Im(Lap[γ d , h]) = Lap[Im(γ d ), h] = 0.
2.4. Subharmonics degree > 4: Proof of Theorem 1 (2a.) Proof. The product rule for the Laplacian of harmonics in Lemma 2.2 says 2 2 Lap[ Re(γ d ) , h] is a sum of squares. Thus we have shown Re(γ d ) is subharmonic. Now we prove the formula (5) relating subharmonics. We use γ 2d = (Re(γ d ) + i Im(γ d ))2 = (Re(γ d ))2 − (Im(γ d ))2 + i(Re(γ d )Im(γ d ) + Im(γ d ) Re(γ d )). Therefore
2 2 Re(γ 2d ) = Re(γ d ) − Im(γ d ) .
Vol. 61 (2008)
So
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
87
2 c0 Re(γ d ) + c1 Re(γ 2d ) + c2 Im(γ 2d ) 2 = c0 Im(γ d ) + (c0 + c1 ) (Re(γ 2d )) + c2 Im(γ 2d ),
which is (5).
Up to this point we have handled subharmonics of even degree. To see that there are no pure subharmonics of odd degree, note that the Laplacian L(x) of an odd degree polynomial is itself an odd degree polynomial which is matrix-positive. Consider L(tx) as t ∈ R approaches ±∞. Since the highest order terms dominate, the signs of these limits are opposite. Thus the highest order terms are 0.
3. Classification when Degree is Four or Less We handle now what appear to be special cases which are exceptions to the general degree > 4 theorem. 3.1. The Matrix Representation Important in our proofs for polynomials of low degree is a representation for polynomials q(x1 , . . . , xg )[h] which are homogeneous of degree 2 in h. Recall that often x stands for (x1 , . . . , xg ) and h is a single variable. In our notation q(x)[h] we use [ ] to distinguish the variable which is of degree 2. Any NC symmetric polynomial q in symmetric variables quadratic in h can be written n n n n q(x)[h] = (h mi )T Zij (x) (h mj ) = (mi T h) Zij (h mj ) i=1 j=1
i=1 j=1
where mi are monomials in x and Zij (x) are polynomials in x. Define Z(x) as the N -by-N matrix of polynomials in x whose i, j th element is Zij , and define V (x)[h] as V (x)[h]T = h(m1 , m2 , . . . , mN ). We call Z the middle matrix for q and V its border vector. In this notation our representation is q(x, h) = V (x)[h]T Z(x)V (x)[h] We can and typically do take Z(x) to be symmetric. If the monomials mi in V (x)[h] do not repeat, then Z(x) is uniquely determined and is symmetric. Example 3.1. A “middle matrix” representation g = 2 3 x1 hx22 hx1 + hx1 x2 x1 h − hx1 hx22 − x22 hx1 h + 5 x1 x2 hx2 hx2 x1 T 0 0 −x1 x1 x2 x1 h h hx1 0 3 x22 0 0 hx1 . = hx2 x1 0 0 hx2 x1 0 5 x2 −x1 hx22 0 0 0 hx22
88
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
3.1.1. Positivity of q vs. Positivity of its Middle Matrix. A key fact is that positivity of q is equivalent to positivity of its middle matrix in the following sense. Lemma 3.1. Suppose q(x)[h] a symmetric NC polynomial in noncommuting varig ables pure quadratic in h and Z(x) is its middle matrix. If X ∈ (Rn×n sym ) and n×n g Z(X) 0, then q(X)[H] 0 for all H ∈ (Rsym ) . Conversely, if q(x)[h] is matrix positive; i.e., q(X)[H] 0, for every n and g X, H ∈ (Rn×n sym ) in the (non empty) positivity domain {X : f (X) 0} of some g polynomial f , then for each n and X ∈ (Rn×n sym ) , we have Z(X) 0 on {X : f (X) 0}. Proof. The first statement is evident. The converse is proved in [1] in Lemma 9.5 and Theorem 10.10 in [1]. for a cleaner proofs see [5] in particular Proposition 6.1. 3.2. The Zeroes Lemma The following is useful in our analysis of subharmonics. Lemma 3.2. Let S be any N × N symmetric matrix with entries in Rx. If there exists some diagonal entry Sii = 0 and corresponding off-diagonal entries T Sij = Sji = 0, then S is not matrix-positive semidefinite. Proof. Let ei and ej be standard basis vectors for RN (i.e. eTi A ej = aij ) and define v := β1 ei + β2 ej where β1 , β2 ∈ R. Then, v T S(x)v = ((Sij + Sji ) β1 + Sjj β2 ) β2 = (2 Sij β1 + Sjj β2 ) β2 Given β2 > 0, we can choose β1 such that 2 β1 Sij (X)β2 + β2 Sjj (X) β2 is neither a positive nor negative matrix.
This lemma is useful when applied to our matrix representation of the Laplacian of a symmetric NC polynomial . 3.3. The Laplacian of a Degree 4 Polynomial Proof. We begin with a parameterization the set of degree 4 homogeneous polynomials in symmetric free variables p = A1 x41 x21 + A2 (x31 x2 + x2 x31 ) + A3 (x21 x2 x1 + x1 x2 x21 ) + A4 (x21 x22 + x22 x21 ) + A5 (x1 x2 x1 x2 + x2 x1 x2 x1 ) + A6 x1 x22 x1 + A7 (x1 x32 + x32 x1 ) + A8 x2 x21 x2 + A9 (x2 x1 x22 + x22 x1 x2 ) + A10 x42 .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
89
We calculate the Laplacian of p: 2A1 (h2 x21 + h x1 h x1 + h x21 h + x1 h2 x1 + x1 h x1 h + x21 h2 )
+2A2 (h2 x1 x2 + h x1 h x2 + x1 h2 x2 + x2 h2 x1 + x2 h x1 h + x2 x1 h2 ) + 2 A3 (h2 x2 x1 + h x1 x2 h + h x2 h x1 + h x2 x1 h + x1 h x2 h + x1 x2 h2 )
+ 2 A4 (h2 x21 + h2 x22 + x21 h2 + x22 h2 ) + 2 A5 (h x1 h x1 + h x2 h x2 + x1 h x1 h + x2 h x2 h) + 2 A6 (h x22 h + x1 h2 x1 )
+ 2 A7 (h2 x2 x1 + h x2 h x1 + x1 h2 x2 + x1 h x2 h + x1 x2 h2 + x2 h2 x1 ) + 2 A8 (h x21 h + x2 h2 x2 )
+ 2 A9 (h2 x1 x2 + h x1 h x2 + h x1 x2 h + h x2 x1 h + x2 h x1 h + x2 x1 h2 ) + 2 A10 (h2 x22 + h x2 h x2 + h x22 h + x2 h2 x2 + x2 h x2 h + x22 h2 ). The directional Laplacian is quadratic in h, and so can be represented by border vector T V (x)[h]T = h x1 h x2 h x21 h x1 x2 h x2 x1 h x22 h and middle matrix Z(x) which is 2 2 (A1+A8 )x1 +(A6+A10 )x2 +(A3+A9 )(x1 x2 +x2 x1 )
(A1 +A5 )x1 +(A3 +A7 )x2
(A2 +A9 )x1 +(A5 +A10 )x2
(A1 + A5 ) x1 + (A3 + A7 ) x2
A1 + A6
A2 + A7
(A2 + A9 ) x1 + (A5 + A10 ) x2
A2 + A7
A1 + A4
A1+A4
A3+A7
A2+A9
A4+A10
0
0
0
0
A8 + A10
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
A3 + A7
0
0
0
0
0
0
A2 + A9
0
0
0
0
0
0
A4 + A10
0
0
0
0
0
0
.
g Assume that Z(X) is a positive semidefinite matrix for X ∈ (Rn×n sym ) . By the Zeroes Lemma, the zeroes on the last four diagonals force all entries in the last four rows or columns to be zero, that is:
A4 = −A1 ,
A10 = A1 ,
A9 = −A2 ,
A7 = −A3 .
(18)
Applying these conditions to the matrix above, and ignoring the rows and columns which are zero, we have: 2 2 (A1 + A8 ) x1 + (A1 + A6 ) x2 x2 )
+ (A2 − A3 )(x2 x1 − x1 (A1 +A5 )x1 (A1 +A5 )x2
(A1 +A5 )x1
(A1 +A5 )x2
A1 +A6
A2 −A3
A2 −A3
A1 +A8
.
90
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
This matrix can be simplified by substitution of reoccurring pairs by single letters: G = A1 + A6 ,
J = A2 − A3 ,
H = A1 + A8
to obtain
Hx21 − J(x1 x2 + x2 x1 ) + Gx22 Kx1 Kx2
K = A1 + A5 . Kx2 J . H
Kx1 G J
We now find its noncommutative LDLT (Cholesky) decomposition to have D term equal to G 0 0 2 0 H− J 0 G . 0
0
Hx21 +J(x1 x2 + x2 x1 )+Gx22 −
K 2 x21 G
−
(
JKx1 G
+Kx2 ) (
JKx1 G 2
+Kx2 )
H− JG
A reference is [1] which describes the NCAlgebra command, NCLDUDecomposition, we used to do this. We see there are three inequalities, which must be satisfied for Z(X) to be positive semidefinite. J2 G > 0, H − > 0, G 1 1 + KX2 ) ( JKX + KX2 ) K 2 X12 ( JKX G G − HX12 +J(X1 X2 +X2 X1 )+GX22 − > 0. 2 J G H− G The last condition is purely quadratic in X1 and X2 , and therefore has a middle matrix representation which we compute to be 2 2 2 2 G − H HK2 2 − KJ H + HK H2 (G− J )J (G− J )J . 2 2 H + HK J − KH 2 H2 (G−
J
)J
G−
J
T
Again we perform the LDL decomposition: 2 0 G − K J2 H− JG 2 2 . J− JK J 2 )G 2 2 2 (H− G 0 H − J JK2 2 − KG − 2 K (H−
G
)G
G−
2 H− J G
Although the inequality
2 2 J − JKJ 2 J 2K 2 K2 (H− G )G − H− − >0 2 2 G (H − JG )G2 G − K J2 H−
(19)
G
is quite complicated, we can simplify it some by multiplying it by expressions which are known to be positive, such as: G,
H−
J2 , G
and G −
K2 2 H − JG
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
91
which we encountered earlier. This gives a polynomial inequality equivalent to (19), which, after some simplification, gives us: (GH − J 2 − K 2 )2 > 0. Which, considering only the case of all real coefficients, is rather vacuous, informing us only that GH − J 2 − K 2 = 0. Bringing all our inequalities together (simplifying each as we did above), we obtain (I) G > 0,
(II) GH > J 2 ,
(III) GH > J 2 + K 2 ,
(IV ) GH = H 2 + K 2 .
Notice (III) implies (II) and (IV), thus reducing to (I) and (II). Therefore, we conclude that the set of polynomials making the Laplacian matrix “positive” is exactly those of the form: f
=
A1 (x41 − x21 x22 − x22 x21 + x42 ) + A2 (x31 x2 + x2 x31 − x2 x1 x22 − x22 x1 x2 )(20) +A3 (x21 x2 x1 + x1 x2 x21 − x1 x32 − x32 x1 ) + A5 (x1 x2 x1 x2 + x2 x1 x2 x1 )
+A6 x1 x22 x1 + A8 x2 x21 x2
with coefficients satisfying the inequalities: (III) =⇒ (A1 + A8 )(A1 + A6 ) > (A3 − A2 )2 + (A1 + A5 )2 and
(21)
(I) =⇒
(22)
A1 + A8 > 0
(or, equivalently A1 + A6 > 0).
For neatness, and to more clearly see the dimension of the space of subharmonics,we set B1 = A1 , B2 = A2 , B3 = A3 , B4 = A5 , B5 = A6 , B6 = A8 .
4. Uniqueness Proofs Now we set about to prove that the list of subharmonic and harmonic polynomials in Theorem 1 is complete. We do this, as is required, only for two variables but in the course of our proof we discover some promising recursions valid in any number of variables. 4.1. Even Degree Homogeneous p Given 0 < m < d a noncommutative polynomial p of degree d decompose it as p= xt pt (x) + Λ (23) |t|=m
where deg Λ < m. Call the polynomial pt (x) the right neighbor of xt Lemma 4.1. If p is harmonic in any number of variables consider the right neighbor representation of p for any m; the right neighbor pt of each monomial xt of degree m is harmonic, that is, Lap(pt ) = 0. If p is subharmonic in any number of variables, if p is homogeneous of degree d then the right neighbor pt of each monomial xt of degree d2 is harmonic, that is, Lap(pt ) = 0.
92
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
Proof. Apply the Laplacian to the right neighbor decomposition (23) of p and get from the product rule for the Laplacian (Lemma 2.2): Lap[p, h] =
xt Lap[pt (x), h]
(24)
|t|=m
+
Lap[xt , h]pt (x)
(25)
D(xt )[h]D(pt )[h]
(26)
|t|=m
+2
|t|=m
+Lap[Λ, h]. Suppose Lap[p, h] = 0. We shall now show that polynomial (24) is 0, (25) is 0, and (26) is 0. All terms of the polynomials (24), (25), and (26) have degree at least m, while deg Λ < m. Since the Laplacian of a polynomial respects degree, we have Lap(Λ) = 0. Next factor a given degree ≥ m monomial r into its m−front and back: namely, r = rf rb where rf has degree m. Consider the polynomial (24): the m−back of each monomial in it contains two h’s. Likewise the m−back of each monomial in (25) and (26) contains no h’s and one h respectively. Thus polynomials (24), (25), and (26) contain no monomials which cancel and since their sum is zero they must be zero. From (24) is 0 we immediately get Lap(pt ) = 0. This proves the first part of the lemma. Now to the subharmonic part. That Lap[p, h] is matrix positive implies that it is a sum of squares: LTj (x)[h]Lj (x)[h] (27) Lap(p) = j
First observe that each Lj is linear in h. This is true since the highest degree in h monomial λ(x)[h] of Lj (x)[h] contributes a λ(x)[h]T λ(x)[h] to LTj (x)[h]Lj (x)[h] monomial which holds because its coefficient is positive and can not be cancelled out; likewise λ(x)[h]T λ(x)[h] appears in Lap(p). Thus the monomial λ(x)[h] has degree one in h. Because of equation (27) we can refer to each term of Lap(p) as having a first half and second half; each half has degree d2 . Also every term of Lap(p) has an h in its first half and also in its second half. However, if m = d2 all terms in (24) have two h’s in their second half and none in their first half. This contradicts the previous sentence; thus equation (24) is 0. Since we have factored out xt in the representation (24), their coefficients Lap(pt ) are 0 for all |t| = d2 . 4.1.1. Homogeneous Subharmonics are Sums of Products of Harmonics. In this section we prove under weak hypotheses that homogeneous subharmonics are sums of products of harmonics. A subharmonic polynomial of odd degree is harmonic, so is the product of itself and 1. Thus we restrict to even degree and prove the following.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
93
Proposition 4.1. Assume the harmonic polynomials homogeneous of degree d2 are the span of γ1 , . . . , γk . Assume there is a monomial wj in γj which does not occur in the other γ1 , . . . , γk . If p is subharmonic homogeneous of even degree d, then it has the form k
p=
φij γi γj
(28)
i,j=1
where each φij is a real number. Note further that for symmetric p we may take φij = φji . Let S denote the span of these symmetric subharmonics. . For example, This implies that S is a space of at most dimension k(k+1) 2 in two variables there are two independent homogeneous harmonic polynomials of degree other than 2, so dim S is at most 3 for all d = 4. For d = 4 we have dim S ≤ 6. Proof. Assume p is subharmonic homogeneous of degree d. Write down its right neighbor representation with m = d2 and use Lemma 4.1 to get Lap(pt ) = 0 for |t| = d2 . Thus pt =
k
µj (t)γj
j
for some numbers µj (t). Plug this into the decomposition p= xt pt (x) = µj (t)xt γj |t|= d 2
to get p=
j
|t|= d 2
|t|= d 2
(29)
j
µj (t)xt γj =
k
pj (x)γj .
j
Now make a left neighbor decomposition of p which by the definition of the monomial w1 has the form p1 (x)w1 + G where all terms of G are without w1 on the right. The left neighbor version of Lemma 4.1 implies Lap(p1 (x)) = 0. Likewise each pj (x) is harmonic of degree d2 . This proves representation (28) for p. Next we prove our representation of subharmonics stated in the introduction as Theorem 2. Proof. (Theorem 2) Now suppose p is symmetric. Proposition 4.1 says we can represent p as in equation (28). Note if u is harmonic then uT is harmonic and relabel and possibly expand (by taking transposes) the set γ1 , . . . , γk as s1 , . . . , sα , u1 , . . . , uβ , uT1 , . . . , uTβ
94
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
α+2β where the si are symmetric polynomials. Set Ψ := {φ˜ij }i,j=1 where φ˜ij = φij for u1 s1 .. .. i, j corresponding to an original γ and 0 otherwise. Now let s = . , u = .
T s s . and v = .. . Then p = u Ψ u and v v uTβ T s s p + pT = u Φ u p= 2 v v uT1
sα
uβ
Ψ + ΨT , a symmetric matrix as required. 2 Decompose the symmetric matrix Φ as Φ = N JN T where J is a diagonal matrix with ±1 or 0on the diagonal and N has real numbers as entries. Now, let s us put R = N T u. Then v T T s s s s p = u Φ u = u N JN T u = RT JR = ci RiT Ri . i v v v v where Φ =
where cj is ±1 or 0. The si , ui , uTi are harmonic, so their linear combinations Ri are harmonic. An appealing, easily proved, formula is Lap(p) = 2
g
D[R, xj , h]T JD[R, xj , h].
j α+2β Clearly, if the matrix Φ := {φij }i,j=1 is positive semidefinite (or equivalently J has nonnegative entries), Lap(p) will be positive, so then p is subharmonic. Also we get even degree harmonics are sums and differences of squares of harmonics. It is not clear which differences make p harmonic or subharmonic. However, we conjecture A homogeneous symmetric subharmonic polynomial p of even degree d is a finite sum f inite f inite RiT Ri + H p= i
for some homogeneous harmonic functions Ri , H with Ri of degree degree d.
d 2
and H of
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
95
At this point, we have finished discussing subharmonics, and will now turn our full attention to harmonic polynomials. 4.2. Uniqueness of Harmonics in Two Variables 4.2.1. Polynomials of degree Three and Larger. At this point, we have proved that there are harmonic polynomials of arbitrary degree. Working in two variables, we will now show that the polynomials Re γ d and Im γ d span all of the harmonics. This can be a helpful result, which, as yet, we have been unable to show for any higher number of variables. In fact, McAllaster has found, experimentally, that in three variables, the size of the basis of harmonic polynomials increases on the order of d2 (See [9]). Proposition 4.2. Let γ = x1 +ix2 , and Bd = {Re γ d , Im γ d }. Then Bd forms a basis for all harmonic polynomials which are homogeneous of degree d for any d > 2. To prove the proposition we need two lemmas. Lemma 4.2. In degree three, there are two linearly independent homogeneous harmonic polynomials whose span is all harmonic polynomials which are homogeneous of degree three. Lemma 4.3. Let β(x1 , x2 ) be harmonic and homogeneous of degree d. Then we may uniquely represent β as β(x1 , x2 ) = x1 f (x1 , x2 ) + x2 g(x1 , x2 ), where f and g are harmonic and homogeneous of degree d − 1 and D[f (x1 , x2 ), x1 , h] = −D[g(x1 , x2 ), x2 , h]. Proof. (Lemma 4.2) Every homogeneous polynomial of degree three has the form a1 x31 + a2 x21 x2 + a3 x1 x2 x1 + a4 x1 x22 + a5 x2 x21 + a6 x2 x1 x2 + a7 x22 x1 + a8 x32 and the Laplacian of this is a1 h2 x1 + a7 h2 x1 + a2 h2 x2 + a8 h2 x2 + a1 x1 h2 + a4 x1 h2 + a5 x2 h2 + a8 x2 h2 + a1 hx1 h + a6 hx1 h + a3 hx2 h + a8 hx2 h = (a1 + a7 )h2 x1 + (a2 + a8 )h2 x2 + (a1 + a4 )x1 h2 + (a5 + a8 )x2 h2 + (a1 + a6 )hx1 h + (a3 + a8 )hx2 h, so if we want the polynomial to be harmonic, we need each monomial of the Laplacian to be zero, so we need the equations a1 + a7 = 0, a2 + a8 = 0, a1 + a4 = 0, a5 + a8 = 0, a1 + a6 = 0, a3 + a8 = 0 to hold. This amounts to having the vector (a1 , a2 , a3 , a4 , a5 , a6 , a7 , a8 ) in the nullspace of the matrix 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 , 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
96
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
which has the basis {(0, −1, −1, 0, −1, 0, 0, 1), (−1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0)}, corresponding to polynomials x32 − x21 x2 − x2 x21 − x1 x2 x1 and −x31 + x1 x22 + x22 x1 + x2 x1 x2 . Hence there are exactly two linearly independent harmonic polynomials which are homogeneous of degree three. Proof. (Lemma 4.3) Now, suppose that we are given a polynomial function β(x1 , x2 ) which is harmonic, homogeneous, and of degree d. Then, every monomial of β begins with either x1 or x2 , so we may uniquely represent β by the neighbor decomposition β(x1 , x2 ) = x1 f (x1 , x2 )+x2 g(x1 , x2 ). Now, by Lemma 4.1, we know that f and g are harmonic, and using the product rule for the Laplacian, we find: Lap[β, h] =Lap[x1 f (x1 , x2 ) + x2 g(x1 , x2 ), h] =(Lap[x1 , h]f (x1 , x2 ) + x1 Lap[f (x1 , x2 ), h] + 2(D[x1 , x1 , h]D[f (x1 , x2 ), x1 , h] + D[x1 , x2 , h]D[f (x1 , x2 ), x2 , h])) + (Lap[x2 , h]g(x1 , x2 ) + x2 Lap[g(x1 , x2 ), h] + 2(D[x2 , x1 , h]D[g(x1 , x2 ), x1 , h] + D[x2 , x2 , h]D[g(x1 , x2 ), x2 , h])) =2h(D[f (x1 , x2 ), x1 , h] + D[g(x1 , x2 ), x2 , h]) and since β is harmonic, this is zero, which gives: 0 = 2h(D[f (x1 , x2 ), x1 , h] + D[g(x1 , x2 ), x2 , h]). or more specifically, D[f (x1 , x2 ), x1 , h] = −D[g(x1 , x2 ), x2 , h].
(30)
Proof. (Prop. 4.2) First of all, we show that Re γ d and Im γ d are linearly independent: Suppose they are linearly dependent. Then a Re γ d = b Im γ d , where a = 0, b = 0, a, b ∈ R. But then, γ d = (x1 +ix2 )(R+iI), where R = Re γ d−1 , I = Im γ d−1 , so that a(x1 R − x2 I) = b(x1 I + x2 R). Now, we equate the terms starting with x1 and x2 , respectively, to get that aR = bI and −aI = bR. Then, we get that R = (b/a)I and I = (−b/a)R from the first and second equations, repectively. Puting this together, we get R = (b/a)I = (b/a)(−b/a)R, so that cancelling R, we get b2 /a2 = −1, or b2 = −a2 , which can happen only if a = b = 0, a contradiction. Now, we are going to prove the proposition by induction. First of all, Lemma 4.2 begins the induction. To prove the rest of the proposition, suppose that for degree d − 1 ≥ 3, we know that there are exactly two linearly independent polynomials which are harmonic and homogeneous. Then for degree d, we suppose that β is harmonic and homogeneous. Then β(x1 , x2 ) = x1 ϕ(x1 , x2 ) + x2 ψ(x1 , x2 ), where ϕ and ψ are both harmonic, and homogeneous of degree d − 1 (Lemma 4.3). Then by the induction hypothesis β(x1 , x2 ) = x1 (aϕ Re γ d−1 + bϕ Im γ d−1 ) + x2 (aψ Re γ d−1 + bψ Im γ d−1 ),
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
97
but from Lemma 4.3, we know that we must have D[ϕ, x1 , h] + D[ψ, x2 , h] = 0 which is equivalent to saying that aϕ D[Re γ d−1 , x1 , h] + bϕ D[Im γ d−1 , x1 , h] + aψ D[Re γ d−1 , x2 , h] + bψ D[Im γ d−1 , x2 , h] = 0. Now, by applying the identities for the derivatives of Re γ d and Im γ d (see Lemma 2.3), we get the following: aϕ D[Re γ d−1 , x1 , h] + bϕ D[Im γ d−1 , x1 , h] − aψ D[Im γ d−1 , x1 , h] + bψ D[Re γ d−1 , x1 , h] = 0, so (aϕ + bψ )D[Re γ d−1 , x1 , h] + (bϕ − aψ )D[Im γ d−1 , x1 , h] = 0, which gives that 0=
D[(aϕ + bψ ) Re γ d−1 + (bϕ − aψ ) Im γ d−1 , x1 , h],
but if the derivative of a function with respect to x1 is zero, that function must be a polynomial in x2 , but we know that Re γ d−1 and Im γ d−1 are homogeneous of degree d − 1, so the function of x2 can only be cxd−1 for some constant c. That 2 is to say (aϕ + bψ ) Re γ d−1 + (bϕ − aψ ) Im γ d−1 = cxd−1 . 2 is not harmonic, it is not in the span of Re γ d−1 and Im γ d−1 , so Now since xd−1 2 c = 0. Therefore, 0 = (aϕ + bψ ) Re γ d−1 + (bϕ − aψ ) Im γ d−1 , which means that 0 = aϕ + bψ and 0 = bϕ − aψ , so aϕ = −bψ and aψ = bϕ . Using this, we get β(x1 , x2 )
= x1 (aϕ Re γ d−1 + bϕ Im γ d−1 ) + x2 (aψ Re γ d−1 + bψ Im γ d−1 ) = x1 (aϕ Re γ d−1 + aψ Im γ d−1 ) + x2 (aψ Re γ d−1 − aϕ Im γ d−1 ) = aϕ x1 Re γ d−1 + aψ x1 Im γ d−1 + aψ x2 Re γ d−1 − aϕ x2 Im γ d−1 = aϕ (x1 Re γ d−1 − x2 Im γ d−1 ) + aψ (x1 Im γ d−1 + x2 Re γ d−1 ) = aϕ Re γ d + aψ Im γ d ,
which implies that β is linearly dependent upon Re γ d and Im γ d . Hence Re γ d and Im γ d form a basis for all of the harmonic polynomials which are homogeneous of degree d.
98
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
IEOT
4.2.2. Degree Two Polynomials. The polynomials of degree two are a special case. This is because some terms of polynomials will vanish when the Laplacian is taken. Specifically, if we are given the general polynomial p = A1 x21 + A2 x22 + A3 x1 x2 + A4 x2 x1 , we find that the Laplacian is Lap(p) = A1 h2 + A2 h2 , meaning that the polynomial will be harmonic provided that A1 + A2 = 0 and subharmonic provided that A1 + A2 ≥ 0. This is the one case where the harmonic polynomial is not symmetric. Also, because the subharmonic polynomials are built up of harmonic polynomials of one half the degree, this means that it may be possible, in the degree four case alone, to create nonsymmetric subharmonic polynomials. Remark 2. We now show that this gives a 6 dimensional spanning set for the symmetric subharmonics of degree 4; denote these by S4 . We use Proposition 4.1 which says S4 is spanned by symmetrized products of the basis s =: x21 − x22 , u := x1 x2 , uT := x2 x1 . Thus we obtain s2 , su + uT s, suT + us, uu + uT uT , uT u, uuT . Note this is consistent with Theorem 1 part (2b) which implies the span of the degree 6 symmetric subharmonics has dimension. 4.3. Homogeneous Harmonics of Odd Degree The remainder of this section is not used in the rest of the paper, but Proposition 4.3 may be useful in further research on harmonics in many variables. What does the argument in Section 4.1.1 say about harmonics of odd degree? As we have already stated in §2.4, any subharmonic polynomial of odd degree is required to be harmonic. Given NC polynomial p decompose it as p=
g |t|= d−1 2
xt xi pt,i (x)
(31)
i=1
and call the polynomial pt,i (x) the right neighbor of xt xi . Here we are assuming all terms of p have degree d−1 2 . Apply Lap to the right neighbor decomposition (31) of harmonic p and from the Laplacian Product Rule get 0 = Lap[p, h] = g Lap[xt xi , h]pt,i (x) (32) i=1 |t|= d−1 2
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
+
g
99
xt xi Lap[pt,i (x), h]
(33)
i=1 |t|= d−1 2
+2
g g |t|= d−1 2
which is g
D[xt xi , xj , h]D[pt,i (x), xj , h]
(34)
i=1 j=1
Lap[xt , h]xi + xt Lap[xi , h] + 2
i=1 |t|= d−1 2
g
D[xt , xj , h]D[xi , xj , h] pt,i (x)
j=1
(35) +
g
xt xi Lap[pt,i (x), h]
(36)
i=1 |t|= d−1 2 g g D[xt , xj , h]xi + xt D[xi , xj , h] D[pt,i (x), xj , h]
+2
(37)
i=1 j=1 |t|= d−1 2
Finally it becomes g Lap[xt , h]xi + 2D[xt , xi , h]h pt,i (x)
(38)
i=1 |t|= d−1 2
+
+2
g |t|= d−1 2
g
xt xi Lap[pt,i (x), h]
i=1 |t|= d−1 2
xt hD[pt,i (x), xi , h] +
i
g
(39)
D[xt , xj , h]xi D[pt,i (x), xj , h] ,
(40)
j=1
which must be 0. The right half of each monomial in (38) contains no h’s, while in (39) and (40) each right half does; thus no term of (38) can be cancelled. We conclude (38) is 0. Similarly the right halves in (39) are the only right halves monomials which contain two h’s and so cannot be cancelled. Thus (39) is 0 and so we get Lap[pt,i , h] = 0 for each |t| = d−1 2 , i = 1, . . . , g. Use k pt,i = µj (t, i)γj j
as before. Plug this into the decomposition xt xi pt,i (x) = p=
|t|= d−1 2 ,i
j
|t|= d−1 2 ,i
µj (t, i)xt xi γj .
(41)
100
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
to get p=
j
µj (t, i)xt xi γj =
j
|t|= d−1 2 ,i
=
k j=1
µj (t, i)xt xi γj i
j,i
IEOT
p (x)xi
|t|= d−1 2
γj
i
Now make a left neighbor decomposition of p which by the definition γ1 has the form 1,i p (x)xi γ1 + G i
where all terms of G are without γ1 on the right. The left handed version of Lemma 4.1 implies Lap(p1,i ) = 0 for each i = 1, . . . , g. We have proved the following: Proposition 4.3. Assume the harmonic polynomials homogeneous of degree d−1 2 are the span of γ1 , . . . , γk . Assume there is a monomial wj in γj which does not occur in the other γ1 , . . . , γk . If p is subharmonic homogeneous of odd degree d, then it is harmonic and has the form g k p= φmij γm xi γj (42) i=1 m,j=1
where each φmij is a number. Question 1. What φmij make it 0? That is to say, what properties must φmij satisfy in order for p to be harmonic? We do a few calculations which might someday help with this question. Note the Laplacian of such a p is: Lap[p, h] =
g k
φmij Lap[γm xi γj , h]
i=1 m,j=1
=
φmij Lap[γm , h]xi γj + γm Lap[xi , h]γj + γm xi Lap[γj , h]
g k i=1 m,j=1
+2
g l=1
=2
g k
(γm D[xi , xl , h]D[γj , xl , h] + D[γm , xl , h]xi D[γj , xl , h] +D[γm , xl , h]D[xi , xl , h]γj )
g φmij γm hD[γj , xi , h]+D[γm , xi , h]hγj + D[γm , xl , h]xi D[γj , xl , h]
i=1 m,j=1
l=1
Vol. 61 (2008)
Non-Commutative Harmonic and Subharmonic Polynomials
101
As before cancellation cannot occur between terms with right halves containing two h’s, one h and no h’s. Thus, Lap[p, h] = 0 is equivalent to g k k γm h D φmij γj , xi , h = 0, and m=1 g k
i=1
D
k
=1 i=1 j=1
φmij γm , xi , h
hγj = 0
and
m=1
j=1 i=1 g g k
j=1
D
k
φmij γm , xl , h xi D γj , xl , h = 0.
m
Acknowledgments Thanks to Nick Slinglend and John Shopple for help with computations. Thanks to Professor Roger Howe for very helpful conversations about the classical commutative analog of the noncommutative results here.
References [1] Juan F. Camino, J.W. Helton, R.E. Skelton, and Jieping Ye. Matrix inequalities: a symbolic procedure to determine convexity automatically. Integral Equations Operator Theory, 46(4):399–454, 2003. [2] Frank Hansen. Operator convex functions of several variables. Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci., 33(3):443–463, 1997. [3] J.W. Helton and Orlando Merino. Sufficient Conditions for Optimization of Matrix Functions. CDC, 1998. pp. 1–5. [4] J.W. Helton and Scott A. McCullough. Convex noncommutative polynomials have degree two or less. Siam J. Matrix Anal. Appl, 25(4):1124–1139, 2004. [5] J.W. Helton, Scott A. McCullough, and Victor Vinnikov. Noncommutative convexity arises from linear matrix inequalities. J. Funct. Anal., 240(1):105–191, 2006. [6] J.W. Helton and M. Putinar. Positive polynomials in scalar and matrix variables, the spectral theorem and optimization. To appear (see arXiv: http://arxiv.org/abs/math.FA/0612103), 2006. p. 106. [7] Roger Howe and Eng-Chye Tan. Nonabelian harmonic analysis. Applications of SL(2, R). Universitext. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1992. [8] Frank Hansen and Jun Tomiyama. Differential analysis of matrix convex functions. Linear Algebra and its Applications, 2006. [9] Daniel P. McAllaster. Homogeneous harmonic noncommutative polynomials from degree 3 to 7 (includes a recurrence relation for higher degrees). http://math.ucsd.edu/~dmcallas/papers/, July 2004. [10] Dimitri Shlyakhtenko and Dan Voiculescu. Free analysis workshop summary: American institute of mathematics. http://www.aimath.org/pastworkshops/freeanalysis.html, 2006.
102
Helton, McAllaster and Hernandez
J. William Helton, Daniel P. McAllaster and Joshua A. Hernandez University of California, San Diego Department of Mathematics La Jolla, CA, 92093-0112 USA e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] Submitted: May 24, 2007
IEOT
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 103–120 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010103-18, published online April 18, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1575-8
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem for Quasinilpotent Operators Hyoung Joon Kim Abstract. In this paper we consider the hyperinvariant subspace problem for quasinilpotent operators. Let (CRQ) denote the class of quasinilpotent quasiaffinities Q in L(H) such that Q∗ Q has an infinite dimensional reducing subspace M with Q∗ Q|M compact. It was known that if every quasinilpotent operator in (CRQ) has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace, then every quasinilpotent operator has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Thus it suffices to solve the hyperinvariant subspace problem for elements in (CRQ). The purpose of this paper is to provide sufficient conditions for elements in (CRQ) to have nontrivial hyperinvariant subspaces. We also introduce the notion of “stability” of extremal vectors to give partial solutions to the hyperinvariant subspace problem. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A15. Keywords. Hyperinvariant subspace problem, quasinilpotent operators, extremal vectors.
1. Introduction Let H be a separable infinite dimensional complex Hilbert space and L(H) be the algebra of all bounded linear operators acting on H. The commutant of T , denoted by {T }, is the algebra of all operators X in L(H) such that XT = T X. A closed subspace M ⊂ H is called a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace for T if {0} = M = H and XM ⊆ M for each X ∈ {T }. The hyperinvariant subspace problem is the question whether every operator in L(H)\C has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. This problem remains still open, especially for quasinilpotent operators in L(H) i.e., operators Q such that σ(Q) = {0}, where σ(·) means spectrum. In this paper we consider the hyperinvariant subspace problem for quasinilpotent operators. We write (Q) for the class of quasinilpotent operators in L(H).
104
Kim
IEOT
We begin with: Definition 1.1. A quasinilpotent operator Q is called a universal quasinilpotent operator if there exists a sequence {Sm } of invertible operators such that −1 − Q → 0 for each Q ∈ (Q). Sm QSm −1
Let Sm = cSm /Sm for c ≥ 0. Then Sm QSm − Q → 0 and Sm = c. So in Definition 1.1, we can choose each Sm with arbitrary norm. Let N(H) and K(H) denote the set of all nilpotent operators and the ideal of compact operators, respectively. The following theorem asserts that if Q is a quasinilpotent operator / K(H) for all n ≥ 1, then Q is universal. By the well known such that Qn ∈ Lomonosov’s theorem, we know that every polynomially compact operator has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Thus it suffices to solve the hyperinvariant subspace problem for universal quasinilpotent operators.
Theorem 1.2. ([8, Theorem 1]) A quasinilpotent operator Q is a universal quasinilpotent operator if and only if it belongs to (Q)\[N(H) + K(H)]. Consequently if Q ∈ (Q) is not a universal quasinilpotent operator, then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. On the other hand, in [1], S. Ansari and P. Enflo introduced extremal vectors as a method of constructing hyperinvariant subspaces for a certain class of linear operators. As consequence of this technique, P. Enflo [5] gave the “two sequence” theorem which provided a contribution to the hyperinvariant subspace problem for quasinilpotent operators. In [9], I. Jung, E. Ko, and C. Pearcy obtained a better version of the above theorem modifying Enflo’s technique mentioned in [1]. By defining a subclass (CRQ) of quasinilpotent operators, the authors of [6] obtained a reduction theory of these operators aided by the theory of D. Herrero mentioned in [8]. An operator T ∈ L(H) is called quasiaffinity if it is a one-one mapping having dense range. Write (CRQ) for the class of quasinilpotent quasiaffinities Q in L(H) such that Q∗ Q has an infinite dimensional reducing subspace M with Q∗ Q|M compact. Theorem 1.3. ([6, Theorem 5.6]) If every element in (CRQ) has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace, then every quasinilpotent operator has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. If we want to emphasize the subspace M in the definition of (CRQ), we write (CRQ)M for (CRQ). The compactness of Q∗ Q|M in the class (CRQ)M will be a core property of this paper. In Section 2, we use P. Enflo’s “extremal vectors” to obtain partial solutions for the hyperinvariant subspace problem. In Section 3, we define the notion of “stability” for extremal vectors and then give connections between this property and hyperinvariant subspaces of quasinilpotent operators and then prove that quasinilpotent operators with some stability conditions have nontrivial hyperinvariant subspaces.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
105
2. Extremal Vectors of (CRQ)M The following lemma plays an important role in the sequel. Lemma 2.1. Let M be a closed subspace of H and T ∈ L(H) be an operator such that T ∗ T = K ⊕ R on M ⊕ M ⊥ , where T = 1 and K is a compact operator. If there exist sequences {sk } and {tk } satisfying (i) sk −→ s0 (= 0) weakly, tk −→ t0 (= 0) weakly and sk ∈ M for all k ≥ k0 (ii) Xsk , tk → 0 for all X ∈ {T }, then T has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. Observe that xk x if −→ weakly, then xk −→ x weakly and yk −→ y weakly. y yk Suppose that X is a contraction. Since XT ≤ T , we have XT ∈ {T }. Therefore XT sk , tk → 0. Let T = U |T | be the polar decomposition. Since x0 xk ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ := U X tk −→ U X t0 =: weakly, yk y0 it follows that xk −→ x0 weakly. Since sk ∈ M and M reduces |T |, it follows that 1 XT sk , tk = sk , |T |U ∗ X ∗ tk = sk , |T |xk . Since |T |M = K 2 is compact, |T |xk converges to |T |x0 in norm. Therefore sk , |T |xk → s0 , |T |x0 = s0 , |T |U ∗ X ∗ t0 = XT s0 , t0 , so that XT sk , tk → XT s0 , t0 . Since XT sk , tk → 0, we have XT s0, t0 = 0. But since s0 and t0 are nonzero, N ≡ cl{T }T s0 is a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace for T . The notion of extremal vectors was introduced by S. Ansari and P. Enflo [1]. Extremal vectors provide a tool to find hyperinvariant subspaces for compact and normal operators on Hilbert spaces. In this section, we introduce Enflo’s extremal vectors and consider the behavior of them for the class (CRQ)M . Assume that T has dense range and choose a unit vector x0 ∈ H and 0 < ε < 1. If F = {y ∈ H : T y − x0 ≤ ε}, then F is a nonempty, norm closed and convex set. So there exists a unique minimal vector y0 = y0 (x0 , ε) ∈ F. We say that y0 is the extremal(minimal) vector for T . In this case, T y0 − x0 = ε. Let yn = yn (x0 , ε) be the extremal vector for T n and for a notational convenience, write y0 := y1 . In [1], Enflo established an important equation on extremal vectors so called “Orthogonality Equation”: if T has dense range, then there exists a constant r < 0 satisfying T ∗ (T y0 − x0 ) = ry0 .
(2.1)
106
Kim
IEOT
Also it was shown in [1, Lemma 1] that if T is a quasinilpotent operator with dense range, then there exists a subsequence {ynk } such that lim
k→∞
ynk = 0. ynk +1
(2.2)
By using (2.1) and (2.2), Enflo constructed the following “two sequence” theorem. Lemma 2.2. ([5, Theorem 4.8], [9, Theorem 1.3]) Suppose T is a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity. Then there exist two sequences {sk } and {tk } that converge weakly to nonzero vectors s0 and t0 respectively, and Xsk , tk → 0 for all X ∈ {T }. On the other hand, V. G. Troitsky [11] and I. Chalendar, J. Partington [3] introduced a notion of λ-extremal vectors which is a generalization of a notion of Enflo’s extremal vectors to arbitrary Banach spaces. Let X be a Banach space and T be a bounded linear operator on X. Assume that T has dense range and choose a unit vector x0 ∈ X and 0 < ε < 1. For λ ≥ 1, a vector y0 = y0 (x0 , ε, T ) is called a λ-extremal(minimal) vector if T y0 − x0 ≤ ε
and y0 ≤ λ inf{y : T y − x0 ≤ ε}.
For λ > 1, the existence of λ-extremal vectors is clear and obviously they are not unique. If λ = 1, then the λ-extremal vector in the Hilbert space setting is exactly the Enflo’s extremal vector. We now introduce a weak notion of a reducing subspace. Definition 2.3. We say that T ∈ L(H) has a weakly reducing subspace N if for some polynomial p satisfying p(0) = 0, p(T ) can be written as A B N , p(T ) = 0 C N⊥ where A, B and C satisfy: (1) ABX = BC for some strict contraction X ∈ {C} . (2) B ∗ x ≤ cA∗ x for all x ∈ N and for some c > 0. We can easily find a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity which has a weakly reducing subspace. 2A A Example 2.4. Let T = ∈ L(H H), where A is a quasinilpotent 0 A quasiaffinity. Then H has a weakly reducing subspace for T because Definition 2.3 is satisfied with X = 12 I, c = 1 and p(t) = t. We also see that T is a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity. We now have:
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
107
Theorem 2.5. Suppose Q ∈ (CRQ)M . If either Q or Q∗ has a weakly reducing subspace N ⊆ M , then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. We first suppose that Q has a weakly reducing subspace N . Write A B N Q1 := p(Q) = . 0 C N⊥ Then Q1 n =
An 0
Bn Cn
N , N⊥
where Bn =
n
An−i BC i−1 .
i=1
Since Q1 is also a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity, it follows that A is quasinilpotent and one-one. Furthermore, A has dense range because if x ∈ ker A∗ then, since B ∗ x ≤ cA∗ x, x ∈ ker B ∗ , and hence x ∈ ker Q∗1 , which forces x = 0 since Q1 is one-one. Choose a unit vector x0 ∈ N . Given 0 < ε < 1, let yn = yn (x0 , ε) be the extremal vector for An . By a similar argument to the proof in Lemma 2.2, we can choose {nk } such that {Ank ynk } and {Ank +1 ynk +1 } converge weakly and ynk = 0. k→∞ ynk +1 lim
Let sk := Q1 nk +1 ynk ∈ N ⊆ M and tk := Q1 nk +1 ynk +1 − x0 ∈ N . Then {sk } and {tk } converge weakly to nonzero vectors s0 , t0 , respectively. If we can show Xsk , tk → 0 for all X ∈ {Q},
(2.3)
then the proof is complete because all assumptions of Lemma 2.1 are satisfied. For (2.3) we first argue that Bn∗ x ≤ dA∗ n x
(2.4)
for all x ∈ N , n ≥ 1 and for some d > 0. Indeed, since by assumption, ABX = BC for some strict contraction X ∈ {C} , we have Bn =
n
An−i BC i−1 = An−1 B
i=1
n
X i−1 .
i=1
c Writing h := A∗ n−1 x ∈ N and d := , we can get, using the second 1 − X ∗ ∗ condition B h ≤ cA h, Bn∗ x ≤
1 − Xn ∗ B h ≤ dA∗ h = dA∗ n x. 1 − X
By the orthogonality equation (2.1), we have A∗ nk +1 (Ank +1 ynk +1 − x0 ) = rnk +1 ynk +1 . Define vnk +1 :=
1 B∗ (Ank +1 ynk +1 − x0 ) rnk +1 nk +1
(k = 1, 2, . . .).
108
Kim
IEOT
Then a straightforward calculation shows Q∗1 nk +1 tk
= rnk +1
For X ∈ {Q} which is a contraction, let ynk +1 + wk , Xynk := αk vnk +1 Then
ynk +1 . vnk +1
(2.5)
where wk ⊥
ynk +1 . vnk +1
ynk 2 ≥ Xynk 2 = |αk |2 (ynk +1 2 + vnk +1 2 ) + wk 2 ,
which gives |αk | ≤
ynk −→ 0. ynk +1
(2.6)
Since XQ1 = Q1 X, we have
ynk +1 , tk + Q1 nk +1 wk , tk . vnk +1 ynk +1 nk +1 wk , tk = rnk +1 wk , By (2.5), we have Q1
= 0. Therefore vnk +1 Xsk , tk = αk Q1 nk +1
Xsk , tk = αk { Q1 nk +1 ynk +1 , tk + Q1 nk +1 vnk +1 , tk }. Now apply (2.4) with rn 1+1 (Ank +1 ynk +1 − x0 ) and nk + 1 in place of x and n, k respectively. Then we get vnk +1 ≤ dynk +1 . Thus by (2.5), | Q1 nk +1 vnk +1 , tk | = =
|rnk +1 |vnk +1 2 ≤ d2 |rnk +1 |ynk +1 2 d2 | Q1 nk +1 ynk +1 , tk |.
Therefore we have | Xsk , tk | ≤ |αk |(1 + d2 )Q1 nk +1 ynk +1 tk . But since Q1 nk +1 ynk +1 ≤ x0 + ε and tk = ε, it follows from (2.6) that Xsk , tk → 0 for all X ∈ {Q}, which proves (2.3). Therefore Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Similarly if Q∗ has a weakly reducing subspace M , then Q∗ has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace, and so does Q. Corollary 2.6. Let Q ∈ (CRQ)M and N ⊆ M . If N reduces p(Q) for some polynomial p such that p(0) = 0, then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. Immediate from Theorem 2.5.
If p(Q) is of an upper triangular form, what can we say about a nontrivial A B N hyperinvariant subspace? Suppose Q ∈ (CRQ)M and p(Q) = 0 C N⊥ (N ⊆ M ) for some polynomial p satisfying p(0) = 0. Write Bn := PN p(Q)n (1 − PN ), where PN is the orthogonal projection onto N . Then we get:
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
109
Corollary 2.7. With the above notation, if Bn∗ x ≤ dA∗ n x, where d > 0 for all x ∈ N and all n, then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. This follows at once from an analysis of the proof of Theorem 2.5.
In some sense, Corollary 2.7 says that if the upper-right entry Bn of the upper triangular form p(Q)n is sufficiently “small” then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. The following theorem extends Corollary 2.7 in the sense that if the skew diagonal entries of a four block form p(Q)n are sufficiently “small” then the conclusion remains still true. Theorem 2.8. Let Q ∈ (CRQ)M and N ⊆ M . Suppose p(Q) is of the form A B N p(Q) = C D N⊥ for some polynomial p satisfying p(0) = 0 and write N An Bn p(Q)n := . Cn Dn N⊥ If Cn x ≤ cAn x and Bn∗ x ≤ dA∗n x, where c > 0 and d > 0 for all x ∈ N and all n, then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. Write Q1 := p(Q). Since Bn∗ x ≤ dA∗n x, the same argument as the proof of Theorem 2.5 shows that An has dense range for all n. Choose a unit
1 1 − δ2 ) be c2 +1 . Let yn = yn (x0 , zn (x0 , √δ2 ) be the extremal vector for An .
vector x0 ∈ N and let x0 = δx0 with δ =
the extremal vector for Q1 n and zn = Then we claim that zn ≥ yn for all n ≥ 1. 1 c2 +1 ,
Since Cn zn ≤ cAn zn and δ = 2 n zn − x0 ≤ Q1 0 = Since An zn − x0 =
(2.7)
by a straightforward calculation, we have An zn − x0 2 + c2 An zn 2 1 An zn − x0 2 + 1 − δ. δ
√δ , 2
it follows that δ n zn − x0 ≤ 1 − Q1 0 2
for all c > 0.
But since yn is a minimal vector, we have yn ≤ zn . This proves (2.7). In a similar manner used in the proof of Theorem 2.5, we can choose {nk } such that {Q1 nk ynk } and {Ank +1 znk +1 } converge weakly, nk+1 = nk + 1, and ynk = 0. k→∞ ynk +1 lim
110
Kim
Put
yn :=
IEOT
z n , n = nk + 1 yn , otherwise
Then by (2.7), we have ynk +1 ≤ znk +1 = ynk +1 and hence
ynk = 0. k→∞ ynk +1 lim
Let sk := Q1 nk +1 ynk and tk := Ank +1 ynk +1 − x0 ∈ N ⊆ M . Then {sk } and {tk } converge weakly to nonzero vectors s0 and t0 , respectively. By the same argument as the proof of Theorem 2.5, since Ank +1 ynk +1 ≤ (1 + √12 )δ and tk = √δ2 , we can see that Xsk , tk → 0 for all X ∈ {Q}. Hence Y tk , sk → 0 for all Y ∈ {Q∗ }
and tk ∈ M.
This satisfies the assumptions of Lemma 2.1. Therefore Q∗ has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace, and so does Q. A trivial example of Theorem 2.8 is the operator Q := A ⊕ A with a compact quasinilpotent quasiaffinity A. We would here give a nontrivial example of Theorem 2.8 which is not, in particular, applied by [4, Theorem 1.4]. Example 2.9. Let T ≡ Wα be the bilateral weighted shift on 2 (Z) with weight sequence α ≡ {2−|k| }. Then T is a compact quasinilpotent quasiaffinity. Write M := 2 (Z) and H := ⊕M . Define an operator Q on H by 1 ( 12 )2 T ( 12 )3 T · · · −T 2T 1T T 0 0 ··· 12 2 ( ) T 0 T 0 ··· 2 Q := .. ( 1 )3 T . 0 0 T 2 .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . Then Q is a bounded linear operator. We now claim that Q is a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity. Indeed, 2 T 0 0 ··· 0 T2 0 ··· 4 2 2 .. Q = T ⊕ (IM ⊥ + S) · 2 , . 0 0 T 3 .. .. .. .. . . . . where S ∈ L(⊕M ) is a block Hankel matrix which (i, j)-block entry is ( 12 )i+j IM . Since S ≤ 12 , we know that IM ⊥ + S is invertible. Thus Q2 is a quasinilpotent
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
111
quasiaffinity, and hence so is Q. Moreover, 4 ∗ M T T 0 ∗ 3 Q Q= , 0 ∗ M⊥ so that Q∗ Q|M = 43 T ∗ T is compact. Therefore Q ∈ (CRQ)M . With the notations in Theorem 2.8, put p(t) = t and N = M . Since n−1 √1 ( 4 ) 2 T ∗ n x if n is odd ∗ 3 3 Bn x = 0 if n is even and n
A∗n x = ( 43 )[ 2 ] T ∗ n x it follows that Bn∗ x ≤ √13 A∗n x for all x ∈ M we can see that Cn x ≤ √13 An x for all x ∈
(x ∈ M ), and all n. By the same argument M and all n. Therefore Q has a
nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace.
The remaining part of this section devotes to answer the question: when does Q have a weakly reducing subspace? We here find an interesting answer. To do so we need the following observation. Proposition 2.10. Suppose T and S are positive operators. If T + S is compact, then T and S are compact. Proof. Let K = T + S and assume K = 1. Then K is a compact positive operator. By the spectral theorem, there exists a finite dimensional subspace M such that for any ε > 0 K1 0 M K := , where K1 = 1, K2 ≤ ε. 0 K2 M⊥ D −C M M A C and S := . Since B and E Write T := −C ∗ E M⊥ M⊥ C∗ B are positive, we have 1
B 2 2 = sup Bx, x ≤ sup ( Bx, x + Ex, x ) = K2 ≤ ε. x=1
x=1
1 2
Similarly, we have A 2 ≤ 1. Since T is positive, there exists a contraction 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 F such that C = A F B . Then C ≤ A SB ≤ ε . Write T1 := 1 A 0 M . Then since B = B 2 2 ≤ ε, we have 0 0 M⊥ 0 C 2 T − T1 = 2 ≤ 2C2 + B2 ≤ ε(2 + ε). C∗ B Since T1 is a finite rank operator, it follows that T is compact, and so does S.
112
Kim
IEOT
Suppose N and N ⊥ are infinite dimensional subspaces of H. Let X ∈ L(N ⊥ ) be a universal quasinilpotent operator and Y ∈ L(N ) be any quasinilpotent operator. Then for any ε > 0, there exists an invertible operator S ∈ L(N ⊥ , N ) such that SXS −1 − Y < ε. For each 0 < r < 1 and m ≥ 1, define 1 for 0 < |α| ≤ r}. Trm (X, Y ) := {Sα ∈ L(N ⊥ , N ) : Sα XSα−1 − αY < m Evidently, Trm (X, Y ) is nonempty. Suppose that Q and p(Q) are of the form A D ∗ M and 0 E ∗ M⊥
B C
N , N⊥
respectively, for some polynomial p such that p(0) = 0 and N ⊆ M . Then since Q ∈ (CRQ)M , we have D∗ D + E ∗ E = K for some compact operator K. By Proposition 2.10, D∗ D and E ∗ E are compact, so are D and E. Let T ∈ L(M ) be the compression of p(Q) to M . Then by a direct calculation, we can see that T is a compact operator. Moreover, since N ⊆ M , A is a part of T and hence A is also a compact operator. Suppose C is not a universal quasinilpotent operator. Then by Theorem 1.2, C n is also a compact operator for some n ≥ 1. An operator p(Q)n+1 is of the form n+1 n−1 A Bn+1 N n+1 p(Q) = , where B = An−i BC i + BC n . n+1 0 C n+1 N⊥ i=0
Since A and C n are compact, it follows that Bn+1 is compact. It means that p(Q)n+1 is compact and hence Q is polynomially compact. Therefore Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. So we can assume that C is a universal quasinilpotent operator. In this case, Trm (C, A) is a nonempty set. Theorem 2.11. With the above notation, if there exists a uniformly bounded sequence {Sm } in Trm (C, A) such that {ASm } converges to B in the weak operator topology, then Q has a weakly reducing subspace N . Proof. Let En ∈ L(N ⊥ , N ) (n = 1, 2, . . .), P ∈ L(N ) and Q ∈ L(N ⊥ ). If {En } converges to zero in the weak operator topology, then {En∗ }, {P En }, and {En Q} ∗ converge to zero in the weak operator topology. Write Tm := Sm . Then Tm A∗ → B ∗ in the weak operator topology by the above observation. Since Tm ≤ c for some c > 0, we have cA∗ xB ∗ x ≥ | Tm A∗ x, B ∗ x | −→ B ∗ x2 ,
x ∈ N.
It follows that for all x ∈ N , A x ≥ dB x, where d = 1c . On the other −1 − hand, since Sm ∈ Tm r (C, A), there exists a sequence {αm } such that Sm CSm 1 αm A < m . Since Sm is uniformly bounded, αm ASm − Sm C → 0 in norm. So by assumption we have Sm C − αm B → 0 in the weak operator topology and hence ∗
∗
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
113
ASm C − αm AB → 0 in the weak operator topology. Choose a subsequence {mk } such that αmk converges to α with |α| ≤ r < 1. Then ASmk C → αAB in the weak operator topology. Moreover, by assumption, ASm C → BC in the weak operator topology. So we conclude that αAB = BC for |α| < 1. Therefore Q satisfies the conditions of Definition 2.3, so that Q has a weakly reducing subspace N .
3. The Stability of Extremal Vectors In this section, we study the behavior of extremal vectors. Suppose T has dense range and let yn = yn (x0 , ε) be the extremal vector for T n . Write zn := T n yn . Then zn lies in the boundary of the ball B(x0 , ε). If T is a quasinilpotent operator, a stability of zn can be used for solving the hyperinvariant subspace problem for T . we first define the strong stability for extremal vectors. Definition 3.1. Suppose T has dense range. Then T is said to be strongly stable (for x0 ) if there exist a unit vector x0 in H and 0 < ε < 1 such that T n yn ∈ ∨{x0 } for all n ≥ n0 , where the yn = yn (x0 , ε) are extremal vectors for T n . Also T is said to be strongly hyperstable if T is strongly stable for every unit vector in H. The following observation is elementary: Proposition 3.2. Suppose T has dense range. If y0 = y0 (x0 , ε) is an extremal vector for T and z := T y0 , then z ≥ x0 , z > z2 . Proof. By the orthogonality equation (2.1), T ∗ (T y0 − x0 ) = ry0 (r < 0). We thus have T T ∗ (x0 − z) = sz (s = −r > 0), (3.1) ∗ so that (x0 − z), T T (x0 − z) = s( x0 , z − z2 ) > 0 since x0 − z is nonzero and T ∗ is one-one. Hence x0 z ≥ x0 , z > z2 . We would remark that if T n yn = cn x0 (n ≥ n0 ) with extremal vectors yn = yn (x0 , ε) for T n , then cn can be chosen as a unique value c regardless of n. Indeed, if zn := T n yn = cn x0 , then x0 , zn = c¯n > 0, and hence 0 < cn < 1 by Proposition 3.2. Since x0 − zn = ε, we have cn = 1 − ε. Therefore if T is strongly stable, then T n yn = (1 − ε)x0 for all n ≥ n0 , i.e., T n yn are fixed. More generally, n0 yn0 . Then T n yn = cn z suppose ∨{T n yn }∞ n=n0 is one dimensional. Write z := T for some cn ∈ R. Consider a quadratic equation of t ∈ R: tz − x0 2 = ε2 . By Proposition 3.2, z, x0 > z2 > 0, so that the equation t2 z2 − 2t z, x0 + 1 − ε2 = 0 has distinct positive roots 1, α (1 < α). Since yn are minimal vectors, we conclude cn = 1, i.e., T n yn = z for all n ≥ n0 . Lemma 3.3. Let x0 ∈ N ⊆ H and z0 = z0 (x0 , ε) be an extremal vector for T . If N reduces T , then z0 ∈ N .
114
Kim
IEOT
x N A 0 and let z := be an extremal vector for 0 0 B N⊥ y T . Suppose y = 0. Then z0 > x0 . Observe
Proof. Write T :=
T z0 − x0 2 = Ax − x0 2 + By2 = ε2 , and hence
x − x0 = Ax − x0 = ε2 − By2 ≤ ε. T 0 Since z0 is minimal, we have z0 ≤ x0 , a contradiction. Therefore we conclude y = 0. The following theorem is a characterization of strongly stable operators. Theorem 3.4. Suppose T has dense range. Then T is strongly stable for x0 if and only if the operators in the family {T n T ∗ n }∞ n=n0 (some n0 ∈ N) have a common eigenvector x0 . Proof. If T is strongly stable, then T n yn = (1 − ε)x0 by the remark above Lemma 3.3. Using the equation (3.1), we have T n T ∗ n (x0 − (1 − ε)x0 ) = sn (1 − ε)x0
(sn = −rn > 0)
and hence T n T ∗ n x0 = λn x0 (λn = sn (1−ε) ). Conversely, suppose T n T ∗ n have a ε ∗n ∗n common eigenvector x0 . Let T = Un |T | be the polar decomposition of T ∗ n . Then T n = |T ∗ n |Un∗ . Choose 0 < ε < 1 and let zn = zn (x0 , ε) be the extremal vector for |T ∗ n |. Since ∨{x0 } reduces T n T ∗ n for all n ≥ n0 , zn = cn x0 for some cn by Lemma 3.3. So |T ∗ n |zn = cn λn x0 for some λn . Write yn := Un zn . Then we obtain that T n yn = |T ∗ n |zn ∈ ∨{x0 }. On the other hand, note that T n yn − x0 = |T ∗ n |zn − x0 = ε.
(3.2)
Since Un is an isometry for each n, we have yn = zn . This implies that yn is the minimal vector satisfying (3.2) for each n, and hence yn is the extremal vector for T n . Therefore T is strongly stable for x0 . Example 3.5. Let Q be the backward weighted shift with weights {αn } such that αn > 0 and αn is strictly decreasing to zero. Then Q is a quasinilpotent operator with dense range. Moreover, Q is strongly stable because Qn Q∗ n are diagonal operators, so every vector in the standard orthonormal basis of H is a common eigenvector of Qn Q∗ n . The above example is a typical example of a strongly stable quasinilpotent operator. In fact, diagonal operators and weighted shifts with dense range are strongly stable operators. The following corollary is a characterization of strongly hyperstable operators.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
115
Corollary 3.6. Suppose T = 1. If T has dense range, then T is strongly hyperstable if and only if T ∗ is an isometry. In particular, if T is a quasiaffinity, then T is strongly hyperstable if and only if T is a unitary operator. Proof. Suppose T is strongly hyperstable and choose a unit vector x in H. Then by Theorem 3.4, x and T ∗ x are eigenvectors of T n T ∗ n for all n ≥ n0 (some n0 ∈ N). Then for some m ≥ n0 , we have T m+1 T ∗ m+1 x = νx (ν > 0) and T m T ∗ m (T ∗ x) = µT ∗ x (µ > 0). Therefore T m+1 T ∗ m+1 x = νx = µT T ∗ x, and hence T T ∗x = λx (λ = µν ). But since x ∈ H is arbitrary and T = 1, it follows that T T ∗ = I and hence T ∗ is an isometry. Conversely, if T ∗ is an isometry, then T ∗ n is also an isometry for all n. Since T n T ∗ n = I, it follows from Theorem 3.4 that T is strongly stable for any unit vector in H, and hence T is strongly hyperstable. This proves the first assertion. The second assertion follows at once from the first. Corollary 3.6 implies that quasinilpotent operators cannot be strongly hyperstable. On the other hand, we can find some equivalent condition of strong hyperstability. Suppose T has dense range and T = 1. Let y0 = y0 (x0 , ε) be an extremal vector for T . Then by the orthogonality equation (2.1) we can easily show that T T ∗ = I ⇐⇒ T y0 ∈ ∨{x0 } for all x0 ∈ H So T is strongly hyperstable if and only if T y0 ∈ ∨{x0 } for each unit vector x0 in H, where y0 = y0 (x0 , ε) be the extremal vector for T . In [2], I. Chalendar and J. Partington found some stability of extremal vectors for certain operators. In particular, [2, Proposition 2.1] states that if T is a normal operator with dense range, then {T n yn } converges in norm for any x0 and ε. On the other hand, if we add a spectral condition to normal operators, we have some more for some fixed x0 and ε. Proposition 3.7. Suppose T is injective and σp (T ∗ T ) = ∅. If T is a quasinormal operator, then T ∗ is strongly stable. In particular, if T is normal then T and T ∗ are strongly stable. Proof. Let T = U |T | be the polar decomposition of T . We can see that T is quasinormal if and only if U and |T | commute. Since U is an isometry, it follows that T ∗ n T n = (T ∗ T )n for all n ≥ 1. Let λ ∈ σp (T ∗ T ) and x0 be an eigenvector for λ. Then λ = 0 by hypothesis and T ∗ n T n x0 = (T ∗ T )n x0 = λn x0 , that is, x0 is a common eigenvector of T ∗ n T n for all n ≥ 1. Therefore by Theorem 3.4, T ∗ is strongly stable. If T is normal then T ∗ n T n = T n T ∗ n for all n, so it follows that T is strongly stable if and only if T ∗ is strongly stable. The spectral condition of Proposition 3.7 is essential. Suppose T is normal and σp (T ∗ T ) = ∅. Clearly, T is a quasiaffinity because T ∗ T = T T ∗ is one-one. Moreover, by the spectral mapping theorem for all n, we have σp (T ∗ n T n ) = σp ((T ∗ T )n ) = {λn : λ ∈ σp (T ∗ T )} = ∅ for all n.
116
Kim
IEOT
By Theorem 3.4, T ∗ is not strongly stable, and hence T is not. Moreover, there exists a hermitian operator which is not strongly stable as we see in the following example. Example 3.8. Let A be a multiplication operator on L2 [0, 1] by Aϕ(t) = tϕ(t). Clearly A is a hermitian operator. Also A∗ A = A2 has no eigenvalue because if A2 ϕ = λϕ, then (t2 − λ)ϕ = 0 a.e., so that ϕ = 0 a.e. Therefore A is a quasiaffinity but not strongly stable. From the proof of Proposition 3.7, we can see that the adjoint of a strongly stable normal operator is also strongly stable. On the other hand, we can easily construct a strongly stable operator whose adjoint is not. Let U be the backward shift. Since U n U ∗ n = I, U is clearly strongly stable. But U ∗ does not have dense range, thus we cannot consider the strong stability of U . However, with some condition, we meet a nontrivial question: If a quasiaffinity T is strongly stable, is T ∗ strongly stable? For example, if a quasiaffinity operator is strongly hyperstable, then its adjoint is also strongly hyperstable by Corollary 3.6. Definition 3.9. Suppose T has dense range. Then T is said to be stable (for N ) if there exists a unit vector x0 in H and 0 < ε < 1 such that N := {x0 }∨{T n yn }∞ n=n0 is a proper subspace in H for some n0 , where the yn = yn (x0 , ε) are extremal vectors for T n . In this case, we say that N is a stable space of T . Further, if N is finite dimensional then T is said to be finitely stable (for N ). If T is strongly stable then N = ∨{x0 }, so T is finitely stable. Now we try to obtain a characterization of stability as in Theorem 3.4. The following proposition is a sufficient condition for stability. Proposition 3.10. Suppose T has dense range. If the operators in the family {T n T ∗ n }∞ n=n0 (some n0 ∈ N) have a common reducing subspace M , then T is stable for N ⊆ M . Proof. Let T ∗ n = Un |T ∗ n | be the polar decomposition of T ∗ n . Choose x0 ∈ M and 0 < ε < 1. Let zn = zn (x0 , ε) be extremal vectors for |T ∗ n |. Since M reduces T n T ∗ n for each n, it follows from Lemma 3.3 zn ∈ M , and hence |T ∗ n |zn ∈ M . Write yn := Un zn . By the same argument as the proof of Theorem 3.4, we know that the yn are extremal vectors for T n . Moreover, since T n y n = |T ∗ n |zn ∈ M , we have N := {x0 } ∨ {T n yn }∞ n=n0 ⊆ M . The following definition is a weakened version of the stability in Definition 3.9. Definition 3.11. Suppose T has dense range. Then T is said to be quasi-stable (for N ) if there exist a unit vector x0 in H, 0 < ε < 1 and a proper subspace N of H containing x0 such that d(T n yn , N ) := inf z∈N T n yn − z → 0, where the yn = yn (x0 , ε) are extremal vectors for T n . In this case, we say that N is a
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
117
quasi-stable space of T . Furthermore, if N is finite dimensional, then T is said to be finitely quasi-stable (for N ). Evidently, if T is (finitely) stable, then T is (finitely) quasi-stable. It was known [6, Theorem 3.3] that if T is a quasinilpotent operator and there exists a finite dimensional subspace which reduces T n T ∗ n for all n ≥ 1, then T has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. By Proposition 3.10, if the operators in the family {T nT ∗ n }∞ n=n0 (some n0 ∈ N) have a finite dimensional common reducing subspace, then T is finitely stable and hence T is finitely quasi-stable. However, the converse does not hold even for a hermitian operator. For example, let A be a multiplication operator in Example 3.8. By [2, Proposition 2.1], the operator A is finitely quasi-stable. Suppose for a fixed n, An A∗ n = A2n has a finite dimensional common reducing subspace N . Since A|N is a compact hermitian operator, A2n has an eigenvalue. However, in Example 3.8, Ak has no eigenvalue for all k, a contradiction. In this sense, the following theorem is a generalization of [6, Theorem 3.3]. Theorem 3.12. Suppose Q is a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity. If Q is finitely quasistable, then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. Since Q is a quasinilpotent quasiaffinity, we can find a subsequence {ynk } of {yn } satisfying ynk =0 (3.3) lim k→∞ ynk +1 and both {T nk ynk } and {T nk +1 ynk +1 } converge weakly to some nonzero vectors. Write sk := Qnk ynk and tk := Q∗ (Qnk +1 ynk +1 − x0 ). Then {sk } and {tk } converge weakly to nonzero s0 and t0 , respectively. By (2.1) and (3.3), we have Xsk , tk → 0 for all X ∈ {Q}. Since Q is finitely quasi-stable, there exists a finite dimensional space N such that sk − zk −→ 0
for some zk ∈ N.
(3.4)
Since {sk } converges weakly to s0 , it follows that so does {zk }. Write Xsk , tk = Xzk , tk + X(sk − zk ), tk . Then by (3.4), X(sk − zk ), tk → 0 and hence Xzk , tk → 0. Moreover, since N is finite dimensional, {zk } converges to s0 in norm. So we can see that Xs0 , t0 = 0. Therefore M ≡ cl{Q}s0 is a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace for Q. Corollary 3.13. If Q ∈ (CRQ)M is quasi-stable for N ⊆ M , then Q has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Proof. Immediate from a slight variation of the proof of Theorem 3.12.
118
Kim
IEOT
Next, we study a part of a strongly stable quasinilpotent operator. In general, we can find a strongly stable operator whose part is not strongly stable. However, we can ask an interesting question about strong stability: Suppose T ∈ L(H) has an invariant subspace M and let A := T |M . If T is strongly stable for x0 ∈ M , is A strongly stable for x0 ? For example, if T is hermitian, then the answer is affirmative. The above question is closely related to the model of quasinilpotent operators due to C. Foias and C. Pearcy ([7], [10]). Let k = {kn } be a positive sequence decreasing to zero. Define K ≡ Kk ∈ L(⊕H) by 0 k1 1H 0 k2 1H . . Kk := . . 0 .. . Then evidently Kk is a strongly stable quasinilpotent operator. The following is the model theory for quasinilpotent operators. Lemma 3.14. ([7, Theorem 1], [10, Theorem 9.6]) If T is a quasinilpotent operator, then there exists a decreasing sequence k = {kn } of nonnegative numbers converging to zero, an invariant subspace M of the operator Kk , and an invertible operator S : H → M such that ST S −1 = Kk |M . The above lemma says that every quasinilpotent operator is a part of some quasinilpotent backward weighted shift with infinite multiplicity. In other words, if M A B ˜= Q ∈ (Q) then there exists an extension Q such that A is sim0 C M⊥ ˜ is unitarily equivalent to Kk . Since the strong stability is invariant ilar to Q and Q ˜ is strongly stable. Now the following under unitary equivalence, it follows that Q question arises: Is A or A∗ strongly stable? If the answer is affirmative, then every quasinilpotent operator has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace. Unfortunately, ˜ is unitarily equivalent to we were unable to answer this question. However if Q Kk∗ , then we can get an affirmative answer with an additional condition on the norm. We conclude with: Theorem 3.15. Suppose T ∈ L(H) is of the form A B M T = , 0 C M⊥ where T is unitarily equivalent to Kk∗ . If A = T , then A∗ is strongly stable. Proof. Without loss of generality, suppose T = k1 = 1 > k2 . Since T ∗ n T n is unitarily equivalent to Kkn Kk∗ n which is a diagonal operator, we can see that the operators in the family {T ∗n T n }∞ n=1 have common eigenspace L corresponding to
Vol. 61 (2008)
Hyperinvariant Subspace Problem
119
the eigenvalue T n 2 for all n ≥ 1, that is, L = ∨{y ∈ H : T ∗ n T n y = T n 2 y, n = 1, 2, . . .}. We now claim that L ∩ M = {0}. (3.5) Indeed, since A = T = 1, we can choose a unit vector x in M such that T x2 > 1 − ε for any ε > 0. Write x := sx0 + ty0 , where x0 and y0 are unit vectors in L and L⊥ , respectively and |s|2 + |t|2 = 1. Since x0 ∈ L and T = 1, we have T ∗ T x0 = x0 , and hence T x0 , T y0 = x0 , y0 = 0. And since T x0 2 = x0 2 = 1 and T |L⊥ = k2 < 1, we have T x2 = |s|2 T x0 2 + |t|2 T y0 2 ≤ 1 − |t|2 (1 − k2 ). Therefore
1 − ε < T x2 ≤ 1 − |t|2 (1 − k2 ), which forces t = 0, and hence x = sx0 ∈ L ∩ M . This proves (3.5). Then for a unit vector x0 ∈ L ∩ M , we have ∗n n A A x0 ∗n n T T x0 = = T n 2 x0 ∈ M. ∗
Thus x0 is a common eigenvector for A∗ n An for all n ≥ 1, and therefore A∗ is strongly stable. Acknowledgment The author is thankful to the referee for many helpful comments.
References [1] S. Ansari and P. Enflo, Extremal vectors and invariant subspaces, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 350 (1998), 539-558. [2] I. Chalendar and J. Partington, Convergence properties of minimal vectors for normal operators and weighted shifts, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 133 (2005), 501-510. [3] I. Chalendar and J. Partington, Variations on Lomonosov’s theorem via the technique of minimal vectors, Acta. Sci. Math. (Szeged) 71 (2005), no. 3-4, 603-617. [4] R.G. Douglas and C. Pearcy, Hyperinvariant subspaces and transitive algebras, Michigan Math. J. 19 (1972), 1-12. [5] P. Enflo and V. Lomonosov, Some aspects of the invariant subspace problem, Handbook of the geometry of Banach spaces. v.1 (2001), 533-559. [6] C. Foias, I. Jung, E. Ko, and C. Pearcy, On quasinilpotent operators III, J. Operator Theory 54 (2005), 401-414. [7] C. Foias and C. Pearcy, A model for quasinilpotent operators, Michigan Math. J. 21 (1974), 399-404. [8] D. Herrero, Almost every quasinilpotent Hilbert space operator is a universal quasinilpotent, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 71 (1978), 212-216. [9] I. Jung, E. Ko, and C. Pearcy, On quasinilpotent operators, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 131 (2003), 2121-2127.
120
Kim
IEOT
[10] C. Pearcy, Some recent developments in operator theory, C.B.M.S. Regional Conference Series in Mathematics No. 36, Amer. Math. Soc., providence, 1978. [11] V.G. Troitsky, Minimal vectors in arbitrary Banach spaces, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 132 (2004), 1177-1180. Hyoung Joon Kim Department of Mathematics Seoul National University Seoul 151-742 Korea e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: March 27, 2007 Revised: January 8, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 121–145 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010121-25, published online April 18, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1580-y
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Approximate Factorization in Generalized Hardy Spaces Bebe Prunaru Abstract. In this paper we establish a connection between the approximate factorization property appearing in the theory of dual algebras and the spectral inclusion property for a class of Toeplitz operators on Hilbert spaces of vector valued square integrable functions. As an application, it follows that a wide range of dual algebras of subnormal Toeplitz operators on various Hardy spaces associated to function algebras have property (A1 (1)). It is also proved that the dual algebra generated by a spherical isometry (with a possibly infinite number of components) has the same property. One particular application is given to the existence of unimodular functions sitting in cyclic invariant subspaces of weak* Dirichlet algebras. Moreover, by this method we provide a unified approach to several Toeplitz spectral inclusion theorems. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47L45, 47B35; Secondary 47B20, 46E40, 46J10, 46J15, 46E30. Keywords. Dual algebra, function algebra, Hardy space, Toeplitz operator, spectral inclusion, spherical isometry.
1. Introduction Let {Ω, B, µ} be a σ-finite measure space and let D be a complex separable Hilbert space. Let L2 (µ.D) be the Hilbert space of all classes of D-valued, Bochner mea surable functions x : Ω → D with Ω x(ζ)2 dµ(ζ) < ∞. If x, y ∈ L2 (µ.D) one denotes by x · y the integrable function defined by (x · y)(ζ) = x(ζ), y(ζ)D for ζ ∈ Ω, where ·, ·D stands for the scalar product in D. In the theory of dual algebras initiated by S. Brown in [14] it is often very useful to approximate functions in L1 (µ) by elements of the form x · y where x, y are vectors in a given subspace H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) (see Definition 2.1 below). The approximate factorization method initially devised in [15] has been developed in Research partially supported by grant CNCSIS GR202/2006 (cod 813).
122
Prunaru
IEOT
an abstract setting in [5] subsequently yielding spectacular results on the existence of invariant subspaces and the structure of contraction operators (see [4], [16], [17], [18]). The approximate factorization method has been also applied to other classes of operators associated to planar or n-dimensional domains (see [9], [11], [12], [26], [27]) and to algebras generated by commuting isometries [6]. In this paper, we establish and then exploit a connection between the approximate factorization property for a given subspace H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) and the spectral inclusion property for a class of Toeplitz-type operators Tφ on H with symbol φ ∈ L∞ (µ) defined in a natural way (see Definition 2.7) similar to that of the classical case of the Hardy space H 2 of the unit circle. More precisely, in the second section we show (cf. Lemma 2.8) that the spectral inclusion property R(φ) ⊂ σ(Tφ ) holds true for every φ ∈ L∞ (µ) (equivalently, the map φ → Tφ is isometric on L∞ (µ)) if and only if H has a certain localization property (see Definition 2.3) which in many cases is known to be, at its turn, equivalent to the approximate factorization property. On the other hand, the mapping φ → Tφ is shown to be isometric on L∞ (µ) precisely whenever the convex hull of the set {x · x : x ∈ H} is dense in the positive cone of L1 (µ) and this is most useful in concrete applications. This enables us to show in the third section that for large classes of function algebras A ⊂ C(X) on compact Hausdorff spaces their 2 (µ) with respect to suitably chosen measures on X do associated Hardy spaces HA have both the approximate factorization property and the spectral inclusion property for Toeplitz operators with symbol in L∞ (µ). As a consequence of these facts coupled with results from the theory of dual algebras, it will be shown that various types of nonselfadjoint dual operator algebras of Toeplitz operators have property (A1 ) that is every element in the predual is induced by a rank-one operator. As a particular application, we prove that if A ⊂ L∞ (µ) is a weak* Dirichlet algebra, then every cyclic A-invariant subspace H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) generated by a non-vanishing vector contains a vector u with u(ζ) = 1 a.e. This result is related to a well known theorem of H. Helson [32]. The fourth section contains applications to the case of a single subnormal operator S ∈ B(H) and to spherical isometries as well. Let N ∈ B(K) be its minimal normal extension and let µ be a scalar valued spectral measure for N . It is first observed that the Toeplitz operators associated to S (which have been previously studied by several authors) are, up to unitary equivalence, of the type introduced in the second section. It is then proved that the image of the restriction algebra R(N, H) through the Conway-Olin functional calculus has property (A1 ) provided the Toeplitz map φ → Tφ is isometric on L∞ (µ). For instance, this happens whenever the convex hull of the set {|f |2 : f ∈ R(N, H)} is weak* dense in the positive cone of L∞ (µ). We also show in this section that the dual algebra generated by a spherical isometry with a possibly infinite number of components has the property (A1 (1)). The proof is based on results obtained in the previous sections together with those obtained in [50]. The corresponding result for spherical isometries with a finite number of terms was proved in [26].
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
123
In the fifth section we provide an equivalent characterization of planar measures µ for which the convex hull of the set {|f |2 : f ∈ P ∞ (µ)} is weak* dense in the positive cone of L∞ (µ) (P ∞ (µ) stands for the weak* closure in L∞ (µ) of all analytic polynomials). More precisely we show that µ has this property iff it vanishes on its Sarason hull Σ(µ). The proof makes use in an essential way of the D. Sarason’s analytic description of of P ∞ (µ). The last section contains a characterization of those compactly supported planar measures µ for which the space P 2 (µ), that is the closure in L2 (µ) of all analytic polynomials, has the approximate factorization property. It says that µ has this property if and only if it vanishes on the set of analytic bounded point evaluations of P 2 (µ). The proof relies heavily on J. Thomson’s analytic description of the spaces P 2 (µ). A common feature of the various lines of research in dual algebras theory has been the strong interplay between diverse areas of analysis and operator theory. For the first category, one should mention measure theory, analytic functions, function algebras and rational approximation. As for the second one, here we have, among others, dilation theory, functional models, functional calculus, representation theory and local spectral theory. The present paper has been intended to emphasize some of these connections, especially those related to function algebras and representation theory. We close this introductory section with a short list of abbreviations used in the text: • (AFP)=the approximate factorization property (Definition 2.1); • (ALP)=the approximate localization property (Definition 2.3); • (WDP)=the weak* denseness property (Definition 2.10).
2. Factorization and spectral inclusion In this section {Ω, B, µ} will be a fixed σ-finite measure space and D will be a complex separable Hilbert space. We shall denote by L∞ (µ, D) the space of all classes of D-valued Bochner measurable and essentially bounded functions defined on Ω. If σ ⊂ Ω then χσ will denote the characteristic function of σ. Definition 2.1. Let H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) be a closed subspace. Then H is said to have the approximate factorization property (AFP) if for each function f ∈ L1 (µ) and each ε > 0 there exist vectors x, y ∈ H such that f − x · y1 < ε and moreover 1/2 1/2 x ≤ f 1 and y ≤ f 1 . Remark 2.2. One can easily see that if H has this property and if f ∈ L1 (µ) is nonnegative, then one can find vectors x, y ∈ H as above such that x = y. Definition 2.3. We shall say that a closed subspace H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) has the approximate localization property (ALP) if for every measurable subset ω ⊂ Ω with 0 < µ(ω) < ∞ and for every ε > 0 there exists a vector x ∈ H such that χΩ\ω x < εχω x.
124
Prunaru
IEOT
It is not difficult to see that if H has the (AFP) then it has the (ALP) as well. Under some extra assumptions, the converse is also true but a lot more difficult to prove. This implication was initially proved in [5] under the assumption that the localizing vector x ∈ H appearing in Definition 2.3 can be chosen to be essentially bounded and to belong to any given finite codimensional subspace of H. In this case the resulting approximating vectors appearing in Definition 2.3 can be found so that they belong to any given finite codimensional subspace. This result was basic in the proofs of one of the main conjectures in the theory of dual algebras, namely that the dual algebra generated by an absolutely continuous Hilbert space contraction with isometric H ∞ -calculus has property (A1 ) (see [4] and [18]). On the same line, it was subsequently proved that every such operator is reflexive (see [16]). The essentially boundedness condition appearing in [5] was removed in [8], under the condition that H is separable. Now, even if one is not able to find the localizing vectors sitting in arbitrary finite codimensional subspaces one still can get approximating vectors, as the following result from [11] shows: Theorem 2.4 (cf. [11]). Suppose that the measure space {Ω, B, µ} is separable and that H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) is a closed subspace. If H has the (ALP) then it has the (AFP) as well. (Recall that {Ω, B, µ} is called separable if there exists a countable subfamily B ⊂ B such that for every ω ∈ B there exists a sequence {ωn }n≥1 ⊂ B with µ(ω ωn ) → 0. This is equivalent to saying that, the space L2 (µ) is separable.) A closer look at the proof of this theorem given in [11] reveals the fact that the separability assumption on the measure space {Ω, B, µ} is used only to reduce the problem, via the above mentioned theorem from [8], to the case when the bounded functions are dense in H. Therefore we can drop the separability condition, assuming instead the denseness of bounded functions and we get the following result which will be useful in cases when the underlying measure space may not be separable: Theorem 2.5. Let H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) be a closed subspace such that H ∩ L∞ (µ.D) is dense in H. If H has the (ALP) then it has the (AFP) as well. We also recall the following basic result from [6]. Theorem 2.6. Suppose H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) is a closed subspace with (AFP) and let ε > 0. Then for each nonnegative function f ∈ L1 (µ) there exists x ∈ H such that x(ζ)2 ≥ f (ζ) a.e. on Ω and moreover such that x2 ≤ f 1 + ε. Consequently, for each f ∈ L1 (µ) there are vectors x ∈ H and y ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that f = x · y and x2 ≤ f 1 + ε and similarly y2 ≤ f 1 + ε. Before going further, let us fix some notations. If K is any Hilbert space then B(K) will denote the space of all bounded linear operators on K. If ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) we denote by R(ϕ) its essential range. We also denote by Mϕ the multiplication operator on L2 (µ.D) induced by ϕ. Let L1 (µ)+ denote the cone {f ∈ L1 (µ) : f ≥
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
125
0 a.e. on Ω} and similarly for L∞ (µ)+ . We also denote by L1R (µ) the set of real 2 functions in L1 (µ) and similarly for L∞ R (µ). If x ∈ L (µ.D) we denote by Z(x) the zero set of x i.e. the largest set ω ∈ B (determined up to a set of measure zero) on which x vanishes almost everywhere. If E ⊂ L∞ (µ) is a linear subspace and x ∈ L2 (µ.D) we denote by [Ex] the closure in L2 (µ.D) of the linear manifold {f x : f ∈ E}. If x ∈ L2 (µ.D) we shall write |x|2 for the function ζ → x(ζ)2 . If C ⊂ V is a subset in some vector space V then convC will stand for the convex hull of C. If V is a Banach space then convC stands for the norm closure of convC. We now define the Toeplitz operators that will be relevant in our characterization of the spaces H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) with (ALP). Definition 2.7. If H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) is a closed subspace and ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ), we shall define the Toeplitz operator Tϕ on H by Tϕ x = PH (ϕx)
x∈H
where PH denotes the orthogonal projection of L2 (µ.D) onto H. It is obvious that the mapping ϕ → Tϕ is unital and positive hence contractive on L∞ (µ). The following lemma shows that this mapping is isometric precisely when H has the (ALP). Lemma 2.8. Let H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) be a closed subspace. Then the following are equivalent: (1) The space H has the (ALP). (2) For every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) we have R(ϕ) ⊂ σ(Tϕ ). (3) For every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) we have Tϕ = ϕ∞ . (4) conv{|x|2 : x ∈ H} = L1 (µ)+ . Proof. (1) ⇒ (2). Assume first that H has the (ALP) and let ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) such that Tϕ is invertible and let δ > 0 such that Tϕ x ≥ δx for all x ∈ H. It then follows that |ϕ|2 |x|2 dµ ≥ δ 2 |x|2 dµ Ω
Ω
for every x ∈ H. We shall prove that |ϕ| ≥ δ µ-almost everywhere on Ω. Suppose on the contrary that there exist 0 < δ0 < δ and ω ⊂ Ω measurable such that 0 < µ(ω) < ∞, and |ϕ| ≤ δ0 almost everywhere on ω. Since H has the (ALP), there exists a sequence of unit vectors {xn } in H such that xn − χω xn → 0. This, together with the fact that |ϕ| ≤ δ0 on ω implies that 2 δ ≤ lim sup |ϕ|2 |xn |2 dµ ≤ δ02 n→∞
ω
a contradiction. (2) ⇒ (3) is obvious. (3) ⇒ (1). Suppose that (3) holds true and let ω ⊂ Ω be a measurable set such that 0 < µ(ω) < ∞ and let ϕ = χω . It then follows from (3) that
126
Prunaru
IEOT
Tϕ = ϕ∞ = 1. Therefore, there exists a sequence of unit vectors {xn } in H such that (χω xn , xn ) → 1 hence χΩ\ω xn → 0. This proves that (1) holds true. (4) ⇒ (2). Let ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) such that Tϕ is invertible and let δ > 0 such that Tϕ x ≥ δx for all x ∈ H. It then follows that |ϕ|2 |x|2 dµ ≥ δ 2 |x|2 dµ Ω
Ω
2
1
for every x ∈ H. Since conv{|x| : x ∈ H} = L (µ)+ it follows that 2 2 |ϕ| gdµ ≥ δ gdµ Ω
Ω
1
for every g ∈ L (µ)+ therefore |ϕ| ≥ δ µ-almost everywhere on Ω. (2) ⇒ (4). Let ϕ ∈ L∞ R (µ) such that ϕ|x|2 dµ ≥ 0 Ω
for every x ∈ H. It then follows that (Tϕ x, x) ≥ 0 for all x ∈ H. It then follows from (2) that R(φ) ⊂ [0, ∞) therefore ϕ ≥ 0 a.e. on Ω. The proof of this lemma is finished. The following lemma shows that for cyclic subspaces of L2 (µ.D) the (ALP) is always equivalent to the (AFP). Lemma 2.9. Let E ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a linear subspace. If x ∈ L2 (µ.D) is a vector such that [Ex] has the (ALP) then [Ex] has the (AFP) as well. Proof. First of all, it is obvious that µ(Z(x)) = 0. For each ω ∈ B define ν(ω) = |x|2 dµ. ω
Then {Ω, B, ν} is a finite measure space and we consider the unitary operator V : L2 (µ, D) → L2 (ν, D) defined by (V h)(ζ) = h(ζ)/x(ζ),
ζ ∈ Ω.
It is obvious that H has (AFP) if and only if G = V H has and similarly for (ALP). In addition, we see that the essentially bounded functions are norm dense in G because V (f x) ∈ L∞ (ν, D) for every f ∈ E. We can now apply Theorem 2.5 to infer that the space G has indeed the (AFP) hence H has (AFP) as well. Definition 2.10. A linear subspace E ⊂ L∞ (µ) will be said to have the weak* denseness property (WDP) if conv{|f |2 : f ∈ E} is weak* dense in L∞ (µ)+ . We are now able to provide the following characterization of those subspaces E ⊂ L∞ (µ) for which every E-cyclic subspace of L2 (µ.D) with a non-vanishing generator has the (AFP).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
127
Proposition 2.11. Let E ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a linear subspace. The following assertions are equivalent; (1) E has the (WDP); (2) For every x ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that µ(Z(x)) = 0 the space [Ex] has the (ALP); (3) For every x ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that µ(Z(x)) = 0 the space [Ex] has the (AFP). Proof. (1) ⇒ (2). Let x ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that µ(Z(x)). It suffices, by Lemma 2.8 to show that conv{|f x|2 : f ∈ E} = L1 (µ)+ . Let ϕ ∈ L∞ R (µ) such that ϕ|f |2 |x|2 dµ ≥ 0, f ∈ E. Ω
It then follows from (1) that ϕh|x|2 dµ ≥ 0, Ω
h ∈ L∞ (µ)+ .
Since µ(Z(x)) = 0 this shows that ϕ(ζ) ≥ 0 a.e. (2) ⇒ (3) Follows from Lemma 2.9. (3) ⇒ (2) Obvious. (2) ⇒ (1). Let ϕ ∈ L1R (µ) such that ϕ|f |2 dµ ≥ 0, f ∈ E. Ω
1 Then ϕ can be written as a product ϕ = ψu where ψ ∈ L∞ R (µ) and u ∈ L (µ)+ and we may also assume that the set {ζ ∈ Ω : u(ζ) = 0} has null measure. Let x ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that x(ζ)2 = u(ζ) a.e. on Ω. By assumption, the space [Ex] has the (ALP). It then follows from Lemma 2.8 that conv{|f x|2 : f ∈ E} = L1 (µ)+ . Since ψ|f |2 |x|2 dµ ≥ 0, f ∈ E Ω
we get
Ω
ψhdµ ≥ 0,
h ∈ L∞ (µ)+ ,
therefore ψ(ζ) ≥ 0 a.e. on Ω hence ϕ(ζ) ≥ 0 a.e. on Ω as well. This shows that (1) holds true. The proof is finished. If E ⊂ L∞ (µ) is a linear subspace, then we shall say that a subspace H ⊂ L (µ.D) is E-invariant if ϕx ∈ H for every ϕ ∈ E and x ∈ H. The following result for the noncyclic case will be used in the next section. Its proof is similar to that of Proposition 2.11. 2
Proposition 2.12. Let E ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a linear subspace having the (WDP). Let H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) be a closed E-invariant subspace such that the map ϕ → Tϕ is faithful on L∞ (µ) (i.e. ϕ ≥ 0 and Tϕ = 0 implies ϕ = 0). Then this map is isometric on L∞ (µ) hence H has the (ALP). If moreover, the measure space is separable then H has the (AFP) as well.
128
Prunaru
IEOT
Proof. As in the proof of Proposition 2.11, it suffices to show that conv{|x|2 : x ∈ H} = L1 (µ)+ . Let ϕ ∈ L∞ R (µ) such that ϕ|x|2 dµ ≥ 0, x ∈ H. Ω
Since H is E-invariant we get ϕ|f |2 |x|2 dµ ≥ 0,
f ∈ E, x ∈ H.
Ω
Since E has the (WDP) we get ϕg|x|2 dµ ≥ 0, Ω
g ∈ L∞ (µ)+ , x ∈ H.
Suppose now there exists ω ⊂ Ω measurable subset such that ϕ(ζ) < 0 a.e. on ω. It then follows from the above that x(ζ) = 0 a.e. on ω for all x ∈ H therefore Tψ = 0 for ψ = χω . This contradicts the hypothesis that the map ψ → Tψ is faithful on L∞ (µ). For the rest of this section we shall assume that {Ω, B, µ} is a probability space and that D is a complex separable Hilbert space. We shall recall several definitions from the theory of dual algebras (see [7]). Suppose K is a complex Hilbert space. It is well known that B(K) can be identified with the dual space of the space C1 (K) of all trace-class operators on K via the pairing < T, L >= tr(T L),
T ∈ B(K), L ∈ C1 (K).
If x, y ∈ K let x ⊗ y ∈ C1 (K) denote the rank one operator defined by (x ⊗ y)(h) = (h, y)x,
h ∈ K.
If M ⊂ B(K) is a weak* closed subspace, then it follows from general principles that M can be identified with the dual space of the quotient space QM = C1 (K)/M⊥ where M⊥ is the preannihilator of M in C1 (K). If L ∈ C1 (K) we shall denote by [L]M its class in QM . Therefore the duality between M and QM is implemented via the pairing < T, [L]M >= tr(T L),
T ∈ M, [L]M ∈ QM .
It then follows that < T, [x ⊗ y]M >= (T x, y) for every T ∈ M. The space M is said to have property (A1 (r)) for some r ≥ 1, if for each [L]M ∈ QM and for each ε > 0 there exist vectors x, y ∈ K such that [L]M = [x ⊗ y]M and moreover, x · y ≤ (r + ε)[L]M . Recall also that M is called a dual algebra if it is closed under multiplication and contains the identity operator. The following easy lemma is well known and we omit its proof. Lemma 2.13. Suppose A ⊂ B(K) is a dual algebra and ρ : A → C is a multiplicative linear functional. Suppose moreover that there are vectors x, y ∈ K such that ρ(T ) = (T x, y),
T ∈ A.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
129
Then there exists a vector u ∈ K such that ρ(T ) = (T u, u),
T ∈ A.
If A ⊂ L∞ (µ) is a subalgebra and H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) is a closed subspace we denote T (A) = {Tφ : φ ∈ A} ⊂ B(H). Proposition 2.14. Let H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) be a closed subspace with the (AFP). Let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a weak* closed unital subalgebra such that H is A-invariant. Then the mapping ϕ → Tϕ implements a weak* continuous isometry from A onto a dual subalgebra of B(H) that has property (A1 (1)). Moreover if ρ : A → C is a weak* continuous multiplicative functional then there exists a vector x ∈ H such that ϕ|x|2 dµ ρ(ϕ) = Ω
for every ϕ ∈ A. Proof. Since H has the (AFP) it has obviously the (ALP) therefore, according to Lemma 2.8 the mapping ϕ → Tϕ is an isometry on L∞ (µ). Moreover, since H is A-invariant, this mapping is multiplicative on A, therefore its image T (A) is a dual algebra on H. Let [L] ∈ QT (A) with [L] = 1 and let ε > 0. Then there exists f ∈ L1 (µ) such that tr(Tφ L) = φf dµ for every φ ∈ A and moreover, f 1 ≤ 1 + ε/2. Since H has the (AFP) it follows from Theorem 2.6 that there exist vectors x ∈ H and y ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that f = x · y and moreover, such that x2 ≤ 1 + ε and y2 ≤ 1 + ε. Let z = PH y where PH is the orthogonal projection of L2 (µ.D) onto H. Since H is A-invariant and f = x · y we see that φf dµ = φ(x · z)dµ for every φ ∈ A therefore [L] = [x ⊗ z] in QT (A) . This shows that the space T (A) has property (A1 (1)). The last assertion follows from the previous ones and Lemma 2.13. Propositions 2.11, 2.12 and 2.14 yield the following: Theorem 2.15. Let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a unital weak* closed subalgebra. (1) If A has the (WDP) and x ∈ L2 (µ.D) such that µ(Z(x)) = 0 then the dual algebra T (A) acting on H = [Ax] has property (A1 (1)). (2) Suppose now that {Ω, B, µ} is separable and that A has the (WDP). Let H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) be a closed A-invariant subspace such that the map ϕ → Tϕ from L∞ (µ) to B(H) is faithful. Then this map is isometric on L∞ (µ) and the dual algebra T (A) ⊂ B(H) has property (A1 (1)).
130
Prunaru
IEOT
(3) If ρ : A → C is a weak* continuous multiplicative functional on A then in either case (1) or (2) there exists u ∈ H such that ρ(ϕ) = ϕ|u|2 dµ for every ϕ ∈ A. Definition 2.16. Let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a subalgebra containing the constants. One 2 denotes by HA (µ) ⊂ L2 (µ) the norm closure of A in L2 (µ). This is usually called the Hardy space associated to A w.r.t. the measure µ. 2 (µ) is the cyclic A-invariant subspace of L2 (µ) generIt is obvious that HA ated by the constant function ϕ = 1. The following theorem gives a characterization of those Hardy spaces having the (AFP). Its proof follows immediately from Lemma 2.8 together with Theorem 2.6 and Proposition 2.14. We mention that the equivalence between (4) and (5) has been previously proved in [39].
Theorem 2.17. Let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a subalgebra containing the constants and let 2 (µ) be the Hardy space associated to A w.r.t. the measure µ. For each ϕ ∈ HA ∞ 2 L (µ) we denote by Tϕ the corresponding Toeplitz operator on HA (µ). Then the following are equivalent: 2 (1) The space HA (µ) has the (ALP). 2 (2) The space HA (µ) has the (AFP). (3) For every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) we have Tϕ = ϕ∞ . (4) For every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) we have R(ϕ) ⊂ σ(Tϕ ). 2 (5) The set conv{|x|2 : x ∈ HA (µ)} is norm dense in L1 (µ)+ . If any of the above hold true then for each f ∈ L1 (µ)+ and each ε > 0 there 2 (µ) such that |x(ζ)|2 ≥ f (ζ) a.e. on Ω and x2 < f 1 +ε. Moreover, exists x ∈ HA in this case, the mapping ϕ → Tϕ implements a weak* continuous isometry from 2 (µ)) that has the weak* closure of A in L∞ (µ) onto a dual subalgebra of B(HA property (A1 (1)). Remark 2.18. It is easy to see that if A ⊂ L∞ (µ) is a unital subalgebra with the 2 (µ) satisfies condition (5) hence all the other in Theorem 2.17. (WDP) then HA Proposition 2.19. Let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a unital subalgebra. The following are equivalent: (1) A has the (WDP); (2) For every probability measure ν on B which is mutually absolutely continuous 2 w.r.t. µ the Hardy space HA (ν) has the (AFP). Proof. (1) ⇒ (2) Follows immediately from Theorem 2.17. (2) ⇒ (1) We shall use for this purpose Proposition 2.11. Let x ∈ L2 (µ) such that µ(Z(x)) = 0. Let us define the following measure |x(ζ)|2 dµ(ζ), ω ∈ B. ν(ω) = ω
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
131
Then ν is equivalent to µ and U : L2 (ν) → L2 (µ) defined as U (h) = hx is a 2 unitary operator that takes HA (ν) onto [Ax]. As in the the proof of Lemma 2.9 2 the space [Ax] has the (ALP) (or (AFP)) iff HA (ν) has the same property. Since by assumption, the latter has the (AFP) it follows that the former has it too. We can now apply Proposition 2.11 to deduce that A has the (WDP). This completes the proof.
3. Applications to function algebras There is a large array of examples of probability spaces {Ω, B, µ} and subalgebras A ⊂ L∞ (µ) for which one or the other properties appearing in the statements of Theorems 2.15 and 2.17 hold true. In order to describe some examples, we need to recall some definitions from the theory of uniform algebras. We refer to T. Gamelin s book [29] for (i)-(iii) below. Consider a compact Hausdorff space X and let C(X) be the Banach algebra of all continuous complex valued functions on X. Let also CR (X) be the real part of C(X) and C(X)+ be the cone of all nonnegative functions in C(X). Let A ⊂ C(X) be a closed subalgebra containing the constants. Denote by A−1 the group of all invertible elements of A and let ReA = {Ref : f ∈ A}. Let us point out that all the examples that follow are uniform algebras on X in the sense that they separate the points of X. However, there is no need to assume this fact a priori because it follows directly from their definitions. (i) A is a Dirichlet algebra (on X) if ReA is uniformly dense in CR (X). The standard example is the disc algebra, i.e. the algebra A(D) of all continuous functions on the closed unit disc that are analytic on its interior. It is wellknown that this algebra is Dirichlet when restricted to the unit circle. (ii) A is hypo-Dirichlet on X if the closure of ReA has finite codimension in CR (X) and moreover the real linear span of the set {log |φ| : φ ∈ A−1 } is dense in CR (X). For example, let K ⊂ C be a compact subset in the complex plane and let R(K) be the uniform closure in C(K) of the space of all rational functions with poles off K. If C\K has a finite number of components then R(K) is hypo- Dirichlet when restricted to ∂K. If C\K is connected then R(K) is even a Dirichlet algebra (the Walsh-Lebesgue Theorem). (iii) A is said to be logmodular if the set {log |φ| : φ ∈ A−1 } is uniformly dense in CR (X). Every Dirichlet algebra is logmodular. If m is the Lebesgue measure on the unit circle T and H ∞ (m) is the weak* closure in L∞ (m) of the analytic polynomials then it is known that this algebra is logmodular on the maximal ideal space of L∞ (m) and it is not a Dirichlet algebra on this space. More generally, it is known that the algebra H ∞ (G) of all bounded analytic functions on a bounded planar domain is logmodular on its Shilov boundary (see [30]). (iv) A is said to be approximating in modulus (cf. [31]) if the set {|f |2 : f ∈ A} is uniformly dense in C(X)+ . Every logmodular algebra, in particular
132
Prunaru
IEOT
every Dirichlet algebra (for instance the disc algebra) is approximating in modulus. According to [31] every unital subalgebra A ⊂ C(X) for which the set of unimodular functions in A (i.e. functions of constant modulus one) separates the points of X is approximating in modulus. For instance, the polydisk algebra A(Dk ) that is the uniform closure of all analytic polynomials is approximating in modulus when restricted to the k-torus Tk because its unimodular elements separate the points of Tk . Also it is known that if G ⊂ C is a bounded finitely connected domain with analytic boundary, then the algebra R(G) is approximating in modulus on ∂G ( see [28]). (v) A is said to be convexly approximating in modulus (see Def. 2.18 in [25]) if conv{|f |2 : f ∈ A} is uniformly dense in C(X)+ . It will be seen below that if K ⊂ C is a compact set such that R(K) is hypo-Dirichlet on ∂K then it is also convexly approximating in modulus. We do not know any example of a function algebra which is convexly approximating in modulus and is not approximating in modulus. Example 3.1. It is obvious that if A ⊂ C(X) is a convexly approximating in modulus subalgebra and if µ is any regular probability Borel measure on X then 2 (µ) A has the (WDP). Therefore Theorem 2.17 applies in this case, hence HA has the (AFP). Toeplitz spectral inclusion theorems for such algebras have been previously proved in [36] and [37]. Also it was shown in [39] that if a uniform algebra A ⊂ C(X) satisfies the Toeplitz spectral inclusion appearing in Theorem 2.17 for every Borel regular probability measure µ on X then it is convexly approximating in modulus. Remark 3.2. Consider a function algebra A ⊂ C(X) on some compact Hausdorff space and suppose that µ is the unique representing measure for some character of A. Let H ∞ (µ) be the weak* closure of A in L∞ (µ). It then follows from [35] that the image of H ∞ (µ) through the Gelfand transform of L∞ (µ) is logmodular on the maximal ideal space of L∞ (µ) and this implies that H ∞ (µ) has the (WDP). 2 In particular this shows that Toeplitz operators on HA (µ) with symbol in L∞ (µ) have the spectral inclusion property. This fact has been previously proved in [44]. Remark 3.3. In the case when m is the Lebesgue measure on the unit circle T and A is the disc algebra, assertion (4) in Theorem 2.17 is known as the HartmanWintner Theorem (see [24] for basics on Toeplitz operators on the unit circle). Example 3.4. In the case when A is the polydisk algebra, and mk is the Lebesgue 2 measure on Tk the fact that the corresponding Hardy space HA (mk ) has the (AFP) was proved in [12]. Theorem 2.17 together with the above remark that 2 (µ) has the (AFP) for every Borel A is approximating in modulus show that HA k probability measure µ on T . Example 3.5. It was shown in [22] that the ball algebra, i.e. the uniform closure of analytic polynomials restricted to the unit sphere S 2n−1 in Cn satisfies the Toeplitz spectral inclusion appearing in Theorem 2.17 for every Borel probability
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
133
measure on the sphere. It then follows from the above mentioned result from [39] that this algebra is convexly approximating in modulus, therefore it also has the (WDP) with respect to any Borel probability measure µ on the sphere. This also 2 (µ) has the (AFP) for any such measure. In the particular shows that the space HA 2 case when µ is the area measure on S 2n−1 the fact that HA (µ) has the (AFP) was 2 proved in [12]. Since no nonzero vector in HA (µ) vanishes on a set of positive measure, it follows from Theorem 2.15 that in this particular case every closed 2 (µ) has the (AFP). This result has been previously A-invariant subspace of HA proved in [6]. Example 3.6. In order to describe a class of subalgebras A ⊂ L∞ (µ) with the (WDP), we need to recall the following definition (see [29]). If A ⊂ C(X) is a uniform algebra on a compact Hausdorff space then its Shilov boundary is the smallest compact subset K ⊂ X such that sup |f (λ)| = sup |f (λ)|
λ∈X
λ∈K
for every f ∈ A. For instance, it is well known that if A ⊂ C(X) is logmodular and more generally if it is convexly approximating in modulus then Sh(A) = X. Let {Ω, B, µ} be a probability space and let Y = M(L∞ (µ)) be the maximal ideal space of L∞ (µ). Let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a norm closed unital subalgebra. Suppose that A separates Y and that Sh(A) = Y where we identify A with its image through the Gelfand transform of L∞ (µ). Under these conditions, it turns out that A has the (WDP). For this purpose, let ν be a probability measure defined on B which is equivalent to µ. Since the assumption that Sh(A) = M(L∞ (µ)) is invariant under *-isomorphisms it follows that the same holds true with ν instead of µ. Now, an easy adaptation of the proof of Theorem 2.4 from [58] shows that the mapping 2 (ν)) is isometric on L∞ (ν). We can now apply Proposition 2.19 ϕ → Tϕ ∈ B(HA therefore A has the (WDP). Example 3.7. Let A ⊂ C(X) be a hypo-Dirichlet algebra and let ρ be a nonzero character of A. Then there exists a unique representing measure µ for ρ such that log |ρ(f )| = log |f |dµ for every f ∈ A−1 (such measures are called Arens-Singer ∞ or logmodular representing measures). In this case, it is known that Sh(HA (µ)) = ∞ (µ) stands for the weak* closure of A in L∞ (µ) (see SecM(L∞ (µ)) where HA ∞ tion IV.8 in [29]). It then follows from the previous example that HA (µ) has the (WDP). Toeplitz spectral inclusion for hypo-Dirichlet algebras have been previously proved proved in [38]. Example 3.8. Suppose now that K ⊂ C is a compact set such that R(K) is hypoDirichlet on ∂K. In this case, it was proved in [11] that for every Borel probability 2 (µ) (usually denoted measure µ on ∂K and for A = R(K) the Hardy space HA 2 by R (K, µ)) has the (AFP). It then follows from Theorem 2.17 that the Toeplitz spectral inclusion holds true on this space. As a consequence, it turns out that the algebra R(K) is convexly approximating in modulus when restricted to ∂K. This result holds true in particular when the complement of K has a finite number
134
Prunaru
IEOT
of components. This has been previously proved by W. Mlak (see [2] and the references therein). In the case when K is the closure of a bounded domain D ⊂ C whose boundary consists of a finite number of non-intersecting analytic Jordan curves and µ is the harmonic measure on ∂D, the Toeplitz spectral inclusion was proved in [1]. Example 3.9. Here follows another class of function algebras for which Theorem 2.17 applies, as we shall see below. Recall (see [54]) that if {Ω, B, µ} is a probability space, then a subalgebra A ⊂ L∞ (µ) is said to be a weak* Dirichlet algebra if it satisfies the following conditions: (a) A functions; containsthe constant (b) ϕψdµ = ϕdµ · ψdµ for every ϕ, ψ ∈ A; (c) The space {ϕ + ψ : ϕ, ψ ∈ A} is weak* dense in L∞ (µ). It is known (cf. [34]) that every logmodular algebra is a weak* Diriclet subalgebra of L∞ (µ) whenever µ is the (unique) representing measure for an arbitrary character. Most of the basic results of the classical theory of Hardy spaces on the unit circle can be extended in the framework of the weak* Dirichlet algebras (see [29], [35], [34], [54]). Some remarkable examples of weak* Dirichlet algebras are provided by the algebras of bounded analytic functions associated to ergodic flows on probability spaces (see [43], [33], [59]). These include in particular the algebras of generalized analytic functions ([3]). In the latter case, it was proved by H. Helson [32] that every non-reducing invariant subspace contains a unimodular function. Some versions of this theorem have been subsequently obtained for arbitrary weak* Dirichlet algebras (see [45], [56]). Proposition 3.10. Let {Ω, B, µ} be a probability space and let A ⊂ L∞ (µ) be a weak* Dirichlet algebra. If D is a separable Hilbert space and H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) is a closed A- invariant subspace such that the mapping φ → Tφ is faithful on L∞ (µ) then there exists a vector u ∈ H such that u(ζ) = 1 µ-almost everywhere on Ω. In particular this holds true whenever H = [Ax] where x ∈ L2 (µ.D) is a vector such that µ(Z(x)) = 0. ∞ Proof. According to a result from [35] the weak* closure HA (µ) of A in L∞ (µ) is a logmodular algebra on the maximal ideal space of L∞ (µ) which in turn implies ∞ that the set {|ϕ|2 : ϕ ∈ HA (µ)} is uniformly dense in L∞ (µ)+ . This implies, via Theorem 2.15 that H has the (AFP). Moreover by the same theorem there exists a vector u ∈ H such that 2 ϕ|u| dµ = ϕdµ, ϕ ∈ A.
Since {ϕ+ ψ : ϕ, ψ ∈ A} is weak* dense in L∞ (µ) we see that the previous identity holds true for every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ). This implies that u(ζ) = 1 a.e. In the case when H is cyclic and dimD = 1 the above result was proved in [56].
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
135
Corollary 3.11. If A ⊂ L∞ (µ) is a weak* Dirichlet algebra then its associated Hardy 2 space HA (µ) has the (AFP) therefore any of the assertions in Theorem 2.17 holds true.
4. Applications to subnormal operators The following result that will be useful in the sequel, is by no means new, however for completeness we include a proof. Lemma 4.1. Let {Ω, B, µ} be a separable probability space, let H be a separable Hilbert space and let Φ : L∞ (µ) → B(H) be a unital, weak* continuous and positive linear mapping. Then there exist a separable Hilbert space D and an isometry V : H → L2 (µ.D) such that Φ(ϕ) = V ∗ Mϕ V for every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ), where Mϕ stands for the multiplication operator on L2 (µ.D) with symbol ϕ. Proof. Let π : L∞ (µ) → B(K) be the minimal Stinespring dilation of Φ (cf. [55]). This means that K is a Hilbert space such that H ⊂ K, π : L∞ (µ) → B(K) is a *-representation and Φ(ϕ) = PH π(ϕ)PH ∞ for every ϕ ∈ L (µ). Moreover, K is the smallest π(L∞ (µ))-invariant subspace containing H. Since the measure space is separable and H is separable and since π is minimal, it follows that K is a separable Hilbert space. Moreover, π is clearly weak* continuous, a fact that follows from minimality. It now follows from Proposition 2.7.4 in [51] that there exist a separable Hilbert space D and an isometry U : K → L2 (µ.D) such that Mϕ U = U π(ϕ) for every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ). If V : H → L2 (µ.D) denotes the restriction of U to H then obviously Φ(ϕ) = V ∗ Mϕ V for every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ). We are now ready to prove the following result: Proposition 4.2. Let {Ω, B, µ} be a separable probability space, let H be a separable Hilbert space and let Φ : L∞ (µ) → B(H) be a unital, weak* continuous and positive linear mapping. Let A = {ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) : Φ(ϕ)∗ Φ(ϕ) = Φ(|ϕ|2 )}. If Φ is isometric on L∞ (µ) then Φ(A) ⊂ B(H) is a dual algebra with property (A1 (1)). Proof. First, we recall (see [19]) that A can be equivalently described as A = {ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) : Φ(ψϕ) = Φ(ψ)Φ(ϕ) for every ψ ∈ L∞ (µ)}. This shows that A is a weak* closed subalgebra of L∞ (µ) and that Φ is multiplicative on A. From Lemma 4.1 it follows that we can assume that there exists a separable Hilbert space D such that H ⊂ L2 (µ.D) and such that Φ(ϕ) = Tϕ for every ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) where Tϕ is the Toeplitz operator on H (see Definition 2.7). Since Φ is isometric on L∞ (µ), it follows from Lemma 2.8 that the space H has the (ALP). Since the measure space is separable, H has also the (AFP) by Theorem 2.4. Now it can be easily seen that H is invariant for all operators T on L2 (µ.D) of the form T = Mϕ with ϕ ∈ A. Since the space H has the (AFP) it follows from Lemma 2.14
136
Prunaru
IEOT
that Φ(A) is a weak* closed algebra with property (A1 (1)). This finishes the proof of this proposition. The following is an immediate consequence of Lemma 4.1, Theorem 2.15 an Proposition 4.2. Corollary 4.3. Let {Ω, B, µ} be a separable probability space, let H be a separable Hilbert space and let Φ : L∞ (µ) → B(H) be a unital, weak* continuous and positive linear mapping. Let A = {ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) : Φ(ϕ)∗ Φ(ϕ) = Φ(|ϕ|2 )}. If Φ is faithful on L∞ (µ) and if A has the (WDP) then Φ is isometric on L∞ (µ) and the dual algebra Φ(A) has property (A1 (1)). Suppose now that S is a subnormal operator acting on a separable Hilbert space H (see [20] for a comprehensive treatment of these operators). Let N ∈ B(K) be its minimal normal extension. Let also µ be a scalar valued spectral measure for N and let π : L∞ (µ) → B(K) be the functional calculus for N . Then it can be easily shown that the map Φ : L∞ (µ) → B(H) defined by Φ(ϕ) = PH π(ϕ)PH for ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) is faithful. This mapping has been studied before (see for instance [40] and [48]). In particular, [40] contains some equivalent characterizations of the cases in which this mapping is isometric. It can be easily seen that one of these conditions is precisely the approximate localization property (in a different formulation). Let R(N, H) = {ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) : π(ϕ)H ⊂ H}. This is a weak* closed subalgebra of L∞ (µ) and it is called the restriction algebra. Moreover, Φ is isometric on R(N, H) (cf. [20]). It is also easy to see that R(N, H) = {ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ) : Φ(ϕ)∗ Φ(ϕ) = Φ(|ϕ|2 )}. The restriction algebra contains the space R∞ (σ(S), µ) that is the weak* closure in L∞ (µ) of R(σ(S)). In particular it contains the space P ∞ (µ) which is the weak* closure in L∞ (µ) of analytic polynomials. The following result is an immediate consequence of Corollary 4.3: Corollary 4.4. Suppose that S is a subnormal operator acting on a separable Hilbert space H and let N ∈ B(K) be its minimal normal extension and let µ be a scalar valued spectral measure for N . Let π : L∞ (µ) → B(K) be the functional calculus for N . Let Φ : L∞ (µ) → B(H) be the mapping defined by Φ(ϕ) = PH π(ϕ)PH for ϕ ∈ L∞ (µ). If Φ is isometric on L∞ (µ) (in particular if the restriction algebra R(N, H) ⊂ L∞ (µ) has the (WDP)) then Φ(R(N, H)) is a dual algebra with property (A1 (1)). The fact that the dual algebra generated by a subnormal operator has property (A1 (r)) for some r ≥ 1 was proved in [47].
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
137
Definition 4.5. A sequence {Tn }n≥1 of commuting bounded operators on some complex Hilbert space H is said to be a spherical isometry if ∞
Tn∗ Tn = IH
n=1
in the weak operator topology, where IH stands for the identity operator on H. The following result, which is a particular case of a more general theorem from [50] will be used in the proof of Theorem 4.7 below. Lemma 4.6. Let {Tn }n≥1 be a spherical isometry on a complex Hilbert space H. There exist a Hilbert space K ⊃ H and a sequence {Nn }n≥1 of commuting normal operators on K such that {Nn }n≥1 is a spherical isometry and such that Nn H ⊂ H and Nn h = Tn h for all h ∈ H and all n ≥ 1. Moreover, if the normal extension is minimal, then the mapping Y → PH Y PH is an isometric isomorphism from the commutant of {Nn }n≥1 onto the set {X ∈ B(H) :
∞
Tn∗ XTn = X}.
n=1
Here PH denotes the orthogonal projection of K onto H. In particular the above mapping induces a dual algebras isomorphism between the dual algebra AN generated by {Nn }n≥1 and the dual algebra AT generated by {Tn }n≥1 . Theorem 4.7. Let {Tn }n≥1 be a spherical isometry on a separable Hilbert space H. Then the dual algebra generated by the set {Tn }n≥1 has property (A1 (1)). Proof. Let {Nn }n≥1 on K be the minimal normal extension of {Tn }n≥1 as in Lemma 4.6. Since K is a separable Hilbert space, there exist a separable probability measure space {Ω, B, µ} and a normal and isometric *-representation π : L∞ (µ) → B(K) whose image coincides with the von Neumann algebra W ∗ (N ) generated by {Nn }n≥1 in B(K). Let Φ : L∞ (µ) → B(H) be defined as Φ(f ) = PH π(f )PH for all f ∈ L∞ (µ). Then Φ is isometric, unital and weak* continuous. Moreover, if f ∈ L∞ (µ) is such that π(f ) ∈ AN then Φ(f )∗ Φ(f ) = Φ(|f |2 ). This is because H is invariant for π(f ). It then follows from Proposition 4.2 that AT is a subalgebra of a dual algebra with property (A1 (1)) hence AT itself has indeed the property (A1 (1)). This completes the proof. For spherical isometries with a finite number of components, the result in Theorem 4.7 was proved in [26], see also [27]. It was also proved in [23] that for this class of spherical isometries the dual algebra AT is reflexive. As far as we know, it is an open question whether the latter result can be extended to spherical isometries with an infinite number of components.
138
Prunaru
IEOT
5. P ∞ (µ) spaces with the weak* denseness property In this section, by a measure we shall mean a compactly supported positive finite Borel measure in the complex plane. In what follows we shall provide an equivalent characterization of measures µ for which the algebra P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP). For this purpose we shall make use of the analytic structure of the space P ∞ (µ) that has been uncovered by D. Sarason in [53]. Suppose that µ is a positive, finite Borel measure in the complex plane with compact support supp(µ). It is then constructed in [53], by means of a transfinite ˜ µ ˜ (possibly induction process, a pair {K, ˜ } consisting of a compact planar set K ˜ having the following properties: empty) and a measure µ ˜ supported on K (1) µ − µ ˜⊥µ ˜; (2) P ∞ (µ) = L∞ (µ − µ ˜) ⊕ P ∞ (˜ µ); ˜ ˜ ˜ equals the closure of its (3) If K is nonempty then R(K) is a Dirichlet algebra, K ∞ ˜ interior, R(K) ⊂ P (˜ µ), and µ ˜ is the sum between µ|IntK˜ and the absolutely ˜ continuous part of µ|∂ K˜ w.r.t. the harmonic measure on ∂ K; ˜ = ∅ then IntK ˜ = ∅ and there exists a Banach (4) Assuming again that K ˜ → P ∞ (˜ µ) such that Φ(f ) = f for algebras isomorphism Φ : H ∞ (IntK) ˜ every f ∈ R(K). Moreover Φ is also a homeomorphism when both algebras are endowed with their weak* topologies. ˜ is called the Sarason hull of µ. Since R(K) ˜ is Dirichlet, The set Σ(µ) = IntK ˜ one knows that every component U of IntK is simply connected. Moreover, any conformal mapping φ of the unit disc onto U is a weak* generator of H ∞ (D) in the sense that the polynomials in φ are weak* dense in H ∞ (D). Simply connected regions that are images of weak* generators of H ∞ (D) have been described in [52]. For our purposes, we also need to recall two more results about the algebra P ∞ (µ). The first one provides a decomposition into antisymmetric summands: Theorem 5.1 (see [21] and [20]). Let µ be a measure, and let U1 , U2 , . . . be the connected components of its Sarason hull Σ(µ) (provided the latter is nonempty). Then µ can be decomposed as µ = µ0 + µ1 + . . . where µj are mutually singular measures with the following properties: (1) For every j ≥ 1 µ0 (Uj ) = 0, supp(µj ) ⊂ U j and µj restricted to ∂Uj is absolutely continuous w.r.t. the harmonic measure of Uj ; (2) P ∞ (µ) = L∞ (µ0 ) ⊕ (⊕j≥1 P ∞ (µj )); (3) For each j ≥ 1 the identity map extends to a dual algebras isomorphism between P ∞ (µj ) and H ∞ (Uj ); (4) If φj : D → Uj is any conformal mapping then φj is a weak* generator of H ∞ (D).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
139
Theorem 5.2 ([46]). Let µ be a measure such that P ∞ (µ) is antisymmetric (that is it does not contain non constant real functions) and let G = Σ(µ) be its Sarason hull. Then the following are equivalent: (1) µ(G) = 0; (2) If N is a normal operator on a separable Hilbert space K such that µ is a scalar valued spectral measure for N and if S is a subnormal operator for which N is the minimal normal extension, then every operator commuting with S can be extended to an operator commuting with N . In order to use these results we also need the following: Proposition 5.3. Let S ∈ B(H) be a subnormal operator on a separable Hilbert space and let N ∈ B(K) be its minimal normal extension. Let µ be a scalarvalued spectral measure for N . Suppose that the space P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP). Let X ∈ B(H) such that XS = SX. Then there exists a unique operator Y ∈ B(K) such that Y N = N Y , Y H ⊂ H and Y |H = X. Proof. For each h ∈ H let gh,h ∈ L1 (µ) such that (f (N )h, h) = f gh,hdµ for every f ∈ L∞ (µ). Assume that X = 1. We will show first that f (N )Xh ≤ f (N )h for every f ∈ L∞ (µ) and every h ∈ H. Indeed this holds true for all f ∈ P ∞ (µ) which means that 2 |f | gXh,Xh dµ ≤ |f |2 gh,h dµ, f ∈ P ∞ (µ), h ∈ H. Since P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP) the above holds true for all f ∈ L∞ (µ). Now the rest of the proof is quite straightforward and goes as that of Lemma 4.1 in [42] (see also [41] for the case of subnormal representations of approximating in modulus function algebras). The uniqueness of the extension follows from the minimality together with the Fuglede-Putnam Theorem. The main result of this section is the following: Theorem 5.4. Let µ be a compactly supported positive finite Borel measure in the plane and let G be its Sarason hull. Then the following are equivalent: (1) The space P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP); (2) µ(G) = 0. Proof. (1) ⇒ (2) In the case when P ∞ (µ) is antisymmetric this implication follows immediately from Theorem 5.2 together with Proposition 5.3. The general case follows now from the antisymmetric one and Theorem 5.1 and the fact that P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP) if and only if all its antisymmetric summands have the (WDP). ˜ be ˜. Let K (2) ⇒ (1) We may assume that P ∞ (µ) is pure, that is µ = µ ˜ the compact set appearing in Sarason’s Theorem for which G = Int(K). Since ˜ Because R(K) ˜ is Dirichlet on ∂ K ˜ it is in µ(G) = 0 we see that supp(µ) ⊂ ∂ K.
140
Prunaru
IEOT
particular approximating in modulus, therefore its weak* closure in L∞ (µ) has the ˜ ⊂ P ∞ (µ) we see that P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP) as well. (WDP). Since R(K) The following result is proved in [13], see also [46] for a different proof: Theorem 5.5 (cf. [13]). Suppose µ is a measure such that P ∞ (µ) is antisymmetric and let G = Σ(µ). Then the following are equivalent: (1) The space {p + q : p, q analytic polynomials} is weak* dense in L∞ (µ); (2) µ(G) = 0. Using this theorem together with Theorem 5.4 and Theorem 5.1 one can now easily prove the following: Theorem 5.6. Let µ be a measure. Then P ∞ (µ) has the (WDP) if and only if the linear manifold {p + q : p, q polynomials} is weak* dense in L∞ (µ). Proof. We leave this proof to the reader.
6. P 2 (µ) spaces with the approximate factorization property Let µ be a positive finite Borel measure in the complex plane with compact support. Let P 2 (µ) denote the closure in L2 (µ) of all analytic polynomials. In this section we give an equivalent description of those measures µ for which the space P 2 (µ) has the (AFP). The fundamental result on the analytic structure of the spaces P 2 (µ) has been obtained by J.E. Thomson in [57]. We first recall a couple of definitions related to bounded point evaluations (see Sec. II.7 in [20]). A point λ ∈ C is said to be a bounded point evaluation for P 2 (µ) if the mapping p → p(λ) defined on polynomials extends to a continuous linear functional on P 2 (µ). In this case, for each f ∈ P 2 (µ) one denotes by fˆ(λ) the value of this extension applied to f . The set of all bounded point evaluations for P 2 (µ) is denoted by bpe(P 2 (µ)). A point λ ∈ C is called an analytic bounded point evaluation for P 2 (µ) if there exists an open disc U around λ such that U ⊂ bpe(P 2 (µ)) and moreover such that for each f ∈ P 2 (µ) the mapping ζ → fˆ(ζ) is analytic on U . The set of all analytic bounded point evaluations for P 2 (µ) is denoted by abpe(P 2 (µ)). Let Nµ denote the multiplication by z on L2 (µ) and let Sµ denote its restriction to P 2 (µ). The space P 2 (µ) is pure if it does not contain nontrivial L2 summand. The space P 2 (µ) is said to be irreducible if it does not contain nontrivial characteristic functions or, equivalently, if Sµ does not have nontrivial reducing subspaces. If G ⊂ C is a bounded open set then H ∞ (G) denotes the Banach algebra of all bounded analytic functions on G. The following theorem summarizes some of the basic results from [57] that will be needed in the sequel. These results hold true for any exponent t ∈ [1, ∞). Here we only consider the case t = 2.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
141
Theorem 6.1 (cf. [57]). Let µ be a compactly supported positive finite Borel measure in the complex plane and let supp(µ) denote its support. Then there exists a Borel partition {∆n }n≥0 of supp(µ) such that the space P 2 (µ) admits the direct sum decomposition P 2 (µ) = L2 (µ0 ) ⊕ (⊕n≥1 P 2 (µn )) (where µn is the restriction of µ to ∆n ) such that for each n ≥ 1 the space P 2 (µn ) has the following properties: (1) P 2 (µn ) is irreducible; (2) If Wn = abpe(P 2 (µn )) then Wn is a simply connected region and its closure contains ∆n ; (3) The mapping f → fˆ is one-to-one on P 2 (µn ). Moreover, f = fˆ µn -a.e. on Wn for every f ∈ P 2 (µn ); (4) The mapping f → fˆ implements an isometric isomorphism and a weak* homeomorphism between the Banach algebras P 2 (µn )∩L∞ (µn ) and H ∞ (Wn ). The next lemma reduces the study of (AFP) to irreducible P 2 (µ) spaces. Lemma 6.2. Let µ be a measure and let P 2 (µ) = L2 (µ0 ) ⊕ (⊕n≥1 P 2 (µn )) be its decomposition as in Theorem 6.1. Then the following are equivalent: (1) P 2 (µ) has the (AFP); (2) P 2 (µn ) has the (AFP) for every n ≥ 1.
f |p|2 dµn ≥ 0 for every Proof. (1) ⇒ (2) Let n ≥ 1 and let f ∈ L∞ R (µn ) such that polynomial p. Extend f with 0 on the complement of ∆n . Call g this extension. Then g|p|2 dµ ≥ 0 for every polynomial p. Since P 2 (µ) has the (AFP) it follows from Theorem 2.17 that g ≥ 0 µ-a.e. therefore f ≥ 0 µn -a.e. It now follows again from the same theorem that the space P 2 (µn ) has the (AFP). (2) ⇒ (1) Suppose now that every space P 2 (µn ) has the (AFP). Let ∆ = supp(µ) and let ω ⊂ ∆ with µ(ω) > 0. Let ωn = ω ∩ ∆n for n ≥ 0. Let ε > 0. For each n ≥ 1 choose a nonzero vector xn ∈ P 2 (µn ) with xn < 2−n such that |xn |2 dµn ≤ ε |xn |2 dµn . ∆n \ωn
ωn
Since L2 (µ0 ) has obviously the (AFP) we may also find (provided L2 (µ0 ) = 0) a nonzero vector x0 ∈ L2 (µ0 ) having the same property above for n = 0. Let x = ⊕n≥0 xn . Then x ∈ P 2 (µ) and it is clear that 2 |x| dµ ≤ ε |x|2 dµ. ∆\ω
ω
This finishes the proof of this lemma. Our main result on P 2 (µ) spaces with the (AFP) is the following:
142
Prunaru
IEOT
Theorem 6.3. Let µ be a compactly supported Borel probability measure in the plane. Let G be the set of all analytic bounded point evaluations for the space P 2 (µ). Then the following are equivalent: (1) The space P 2 (µ) has the (AFP); (2) µ(G) = 0. Proof. We first assume that P 2 (µ) is irreducible. (1) ⇒ (2). Assume on the contrary that µ(G) > 0. Let K ⊂ G be a compact subset such that µ(K) > 0 and let χK ∈ L1 (µ) be the characteristic function of K. Then it follows from Theorem 2.6 that for each n ≥ 1 there exists xn ∈ P 2 (µ) such that |xn (ζ)|2 ≥ χK (ζ) µ-a.e. and moreover xn 2 ≤ µ(K) + 1/n. In particular it follows that |xn (ζ)| ≥ 1 a.e. on K and G\K |xn (ζ)|2 dµ(ζ) ≤ 1/n for n ≥ 1. We may assume by passing to a subsequence that xn → y weakly in P 2 (µ(. It then follows easily that G\K |y(ζ)|2 dµ(ζ) = 0 therefore y(ζ) = 0 µ-a.e. on G\K therefore yˆ = 0 µ-a.e. on G\K. On the other hand, since K ⊂ abpe(P 2 (µ)) we have that | xn (ζ)| ≥ 1 µ-a.e. on K. Since xn → y weakly in P 2 (µ) we have that limn→∞ xˆn (ζ) = yˆ(ζ) for every ζ ∈ G therefore | y (ζ)| ≥ 1 µ-a.e. on K. Since yˆ is analytic on G it follows that µ restricted to G\K is discrete. Since this holds true for every compact subset K ⊂ G with µ(K) > 0 we see that µ restricted to G is a discrete measure. In particular if K is a singleton, the previous argument shows that P 2 (µ) contains a nontrivial characteristic function, and this contradicts the fact that P 2 (µ) is irreducible. The conclusion is that µ(G) = 0. (2) ⇒ (1). Suppose now that µ(G) = 0. Let ψ : G → D be a conformal mapping onto the unit disc. Denote by ψ˜ ∈ P 2 (µ) ∩ L∞ (µ) the preimage of ψ under the isomorphism appearing in Theorem 6.1. It then follows from Lemma ˜ 2.2 in [49] that |ψ(ζ)| = 1 µ-a.e. on ∂G. Since the polynomials are weak* dense in H ∞ (D) it follows that the unital subalgebra generated by ψ is weak* dense in H ∞ (G). It then follows that the selfadjoint subalgebra A of L∞ (µ) generated by ψ˜ is weak* dense in L∞ (µ) hence also dense in L∞ (µ) with respect to the strong operator topology on B(L2 (µ)). Now every element h ∈ A can be written as h = uf where u, f ∈ P 2 (µ) ∩ L∞ (µ) and |u| = 1 µ-a.e. on ∂G. Since A is strongly dense in L∞ (µ) it then follows that the set {|f |2 : f ∈ P 2 (µ) ∩ L∞ (µ)} is weak* dense in L∞ (µ)+ . This shows that the algebra P 2 (µ) ∩ L∞ (µ) has the (WDP) hence the space P 2 (µ) has the (AFP) by Proposition 2.19. The proof of this theorem is thus completed in the case when P 2 (µ) is irreducible. The general case follows using Lemma 6.2 and the fact (see [57]) that abpe(P 2 (µ)) = ∪n≥1 abpe(P 2 (µn )).
References [1] M.B. Abrahamse, Toeplitz operators on multiply connected regions, Amer. J. Math. 96 (1974), 261–297. [2] M.B. Abrahamse, Commuting subnormal operators, Illinois J. Math. 22 (1978), 171– 176.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
143
[3] R. Arens and I.M. Singer, Generalized analytic functions, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 81 (1956), 379–393. [4] H. Bercovici, Factorization theorems and the structure of operators on Hilbert space. Annals of Math. 128 (1988), 399–413. [5] H. Bercovici, Factorization theorems for integrable functions. Analysis at Urbana, Vol. II (Urbana, IL, 1986–1987), 9–21, London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser., 138, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, (1989). [6] H. Bercovici, A factorization theorem with applications to invariant subspaces and the reflexivity of isometries. Math. Res. Lett. 1 (1994), no. 4, 511–518. [7] H. Bercovici, C. Foia¸s and C. Pearcy, Dual Algebras with Applications to Invariant Subspaces and Dilation Theory. C.B.M.S. Regional Conf. Ser. in Math. 56, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R.I., 1985. [8] H. Bercovici and W.S. Li, A near-factorization theorem for integrable functions. Integral Equations Operator Theory 17 (1993), no. 3, 440–442. [9] H. Bercovici and W.S. Li, Isometric functional calculus on the bidisk and invariant subspaces. Bull. London Math. Soc. 25 (1993), no. 6, 582–590. [10] H. Bercovici and W.S. Li, Normal boundary dilations and rationally invariant subspaces. Integral Equations Operator Theory 15 (1992), no. 5, 709–721. [11] H. Bercovici and B. Prunaru, An improved factorization theorem with applications to subnormal operators. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 63 (1997), no. 3–4, 647–655. [12] H. Bercovici and D. Westwood, The factorization of functions in the polydisc. Houston J. Math. 18 (1992), no. 1, 1–6. [13] L. de Branges, The Riemann mapping theorem. J. Math. Anal. Appl., 66(1) (1978) 60–81. [14] S. Brown, Some invariant subspaces for subnormal operators, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, 1 (1978), no. 3, 310–333. [15] S. Brown, C00 contractions with spectral boundary, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, 11 (1988), 49–63. [16] S. Brown and B. Chevreau Toute contraction a calcul fonctionnel isometrique est reflexive. C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris, Serie I, 307 (1988), 185–188. [17] S. Brown, B. Chevreau and C.M. Pearcy, On the structure of contraction operators. II, J. Functional Analysis, 76 (1988), no. 1, 30–55. [18] B. Chevreau, Sur les contractions a calcul fonctionnel isometrique. J. Operator Theory, 20 (1988), 269–293. [19] M.D. Choi, A Schwarz inequality for positive linear maps on C ∗ -algebras, Illinois J. Math. 18 (1974), 565–574. [20] J.B. Conway, The Theory of Subnormal Operators, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1991. [21] J.B. Conway and R.F. Olin, A functional calculus for subnormal operators. II, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. No. 184 (1977). [22] A.M. Davie and N.P. Jewell, Toeplitz operators in several complex variables, J. Functional Analysis 26 (1977), no. 4, 355–368. [23] M. Didas, Spherical isometries are reflexive, Integral Equations Operator Theory, 52 (2005), 599–604.
144
Prunaru
IEOT
[24] R.G. Douglas, Banach Algebra Techniques in Operator Theory, Second edition. Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 179. Springer-Verlag, New York 1998. [25] R.G. Douglas and V.I. Paulsen, Hilbert modules over function algebras, Pitman Research Notes in Mathematics Series, 217 1989. [26] J. Eschmeier, Algebras of subnormal operators on the unit ball, J. Operator Theory, 42 (1999), 37–76. [27] J. Eschmeier, On the structure of spherical contractions, Recent advances in operator theory and related topics (eds. L. Kerchy, C. Foias, I. Gohberg, M. Langer), pp. 211– 242, Birkh¨ auser, Basel 2001. [28] S. Fisher, Function theory on planar domains, Wiley, New York, 1983. [29] T.W. Gamelin, Uniform Algebras , Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J. 1969. [30] T.W. Gamelin, The Shilov boundary of H ∞ (U ), Amer. J. Math. 96 (1974), 79–103. [31] I. Glicksberg, Measures orthogonal to algebras and sets of antisymmetry, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 105 (1962), 415–435. [32] H. Helson, Compact groups with ordered duals. IV. Bull. London Math. Soc. 5 (1973), 67–69. [33] H. Helson, Analyticity on flows. Aspects of mathematics and its applications, 387– 395, North-Holland Math. Library, 34, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1986. [34] K. Hoffman, Analytic functions and logmodular Banach algebras, Acta Math. 108 (1962), 271–317. [35] K. Hoffman and H. Rossi, Function algebras and multiplicative linear functionals, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 116 (1965), 536–543. [36] J. Janas, Toeplitz operators for a certain class of function algebras, Studia Math. 55 (1975), 157–161. [37] J. Janas, Note on the spectral inclusion theorem for Toeplitz operators, Ann. Polon. Math. 35 (1977), 111–115. [38] J. Janas, Toeplitz operators for hypo-Durichlet algebras, Ann. Polon. Math., 37 (1980), no. 3, 249–254. [39] J. Janas, Toeplitz spectral inclusion and generalized in modulus property, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 104 (1988) 231–234. [40] G.E. Keough, Subnormal operators, Toeplitz operators and spectral inclusion, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 283, (1981) 125–135. [41] W. Mlak, Commutants of subnormal operators, Bull. Acad. Polon. Sci. 19 (1971) 837–842. [42] W. Mlak, Intertwining operators, Studia. Math. 43 (1972) 219–233. [43] P.S. Muhly, Function algebras and flows. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 35 (1973), 111– 121. [44] G.J. Murphy, Toeplitz operators on generalised H 2 spaces, Integral Equations Operator Theory 15 (1992), no. 5, 825–852. [45] T. Nakazi, Helson’s existence theorem of function algebras. Arch. Math. (Basel), 32 (1979), no. 4, 385–390. [46] R. Olin and J. Thomson, Lifting the commutant of a subnormal operator, Canad. J. Math., 31 (1979), 148–156.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Approximate Factorization
145
[47] R. Olin and J. Thomson, Algebras of subnormal operators, J. Functional Anal., 37 (1980), 271–301. [48] R. Olin and J. Thomson, Algebras generated by a subnormal operator, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 271 (1982) 299–311. [49] R. Olin and L. Yang, The commutant of multiplication by z on the closure of polynomials in Lt (µ), J. Functional Analysis, 134 (1995), 297–320. [50] B. Prunaru, Some exact sequences for Toeplitz algebras of spherical isometries. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., 135 (2007), no. 11, 3621–3630. [51] S. Sakai, C ∗ -algebras and W ∗ -algebras, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete, Band 60, Springer-Verlag, New York-Heidelberg 1971. [52] D. Sarason, Weak-star generators of H ∞ , Pacific J. Math. 17 (1966), 519–528. [53] D. Sarason, Weak-star density of polynomials, J. Reine Angew. Math. 252 (1972), 1–15. [54] T.P. Srinivasan and J. Wang, Weak ∗ -Dirichlet algebras. 1966 Function Algebras (Proc. Internat. Sympos. on Function Algebras, Tulane Univ., 1965) pp. 216–249 Scott-Foresman, Chicago, IL. [55] W.F. Stinespring, Positive functions on C ∗ -algebras, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 6 (1955) 211-216. [56] J. Tanaka, A note on Helson’s existence theorem. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 69 (1978), no. 1, 87–90. [57] J. Thomson, Approximation in the mean by polynomials, Annals of Math. 133 (1991), 477-507. [58] J. Tomiyama and K. Yabuta, Toeplitz operators for uniform algebras, Tohoku Math. J. (2) 30 (1978), no. 1, 117-129. [59] G. Weiss, Weak∗ -Dirichlet algebras induced by the ergodic Hilbert transform. L’analyse harmonique dans le domaine complexe (Actes Table Ronde Internat., Centre Nat. Recherche Sci., Montpellier, 1972), pp. 20–27. Lecture Notes in Math., Vol. 336, Springer, Berlin, 1973. Bebe Prunaru Institute of Mathematics “Simion Stoilow” of the Romanian Academy P.O. Box 1-764 RO-014700 Bucharest Romania e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: February 28, 2007 Revised: February 25, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 147–148 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010147-2, published online April 18, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1591-8
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Addendum to “The Extremal Truncated Moment Problem” Ra´ ul E. Curto, Lawrence A. Fialkow and H. Michael M¨oller Abstract. Due to a technical problem, we accidentally omitted a paragraph from the proof of one of the main results in [1]. In this Addendum we provide the portion of the proof that did not appear in [1]. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A57, 44A60, 42A70, 30E05; Secondary 15A57, 15-04, 47N40, 47A20. Keywords. Extremal truncated moment problems, moment matrix extension, Riesz functional, real ideals, affine Hilbert function, Hilbert polynomial of a real ideal.
Due to a technical problem, we accidentally omitted a paragraph from the proof of one of the main results. In this Addendum we provide the portion of the proof that did not appear in [1]. For the sake of completeness, we restate Theorem 2.8. Theorem 2.8. For β ≡ β (2n) extremal, the following are equivalent: (i) β has a representing measure; (ii) β has a unique representing measure, which is rank M(n)-atomic; (iii) For some (respectively, for every) basis B of CM(n) , V ≡ VB [V] is invertible and µB is a representing measure for β; (iv) M(n) ≥ 0 and for some (respectively, for every) basis B of CM(n) , V ≡ VB [V] is invertible and µB is an interpolating measure for β; (v) β is consistent and M(n) ≥ 0; (vi) M(n) ≥ 0 has a flat extension M(n + 1); (vii) M(n) ≥ 0 has a unique flat extension M(n + 1). Proof of (iv) =⇒ (iii). We need to establish that the interpolating measure µB is a representing measure. To do this, it suffices to show that µB ≥ 0. For 1 ≤ k ≤ r, let Vk ≡ Vk (x) denote the matrix obtained from V by replacing wk (in column k) by the variable x, and let fk ∈ Pn be defined by fk (x) := det Vk (x). Clearly,
148
Curto, Fialkow and M¨ oller
IEOT
fk (wj ) = δkj det V (1 ≤ k, j ≤ r). Now 2 ˆ ˆ 0 ≤ M(n)fk , fk = Λβ (fk ) = fk2 dµB (since µB is interpolating) =
r
ρj fk2 (wj ) = ρk (det V )2 ,
j=1
and since det V = 0, it follows that ρk ≥ 0. (Since card supp µB = r, it then follows that ρk > 0 (1 ≤ k ≤ r).) This establishes (iii).
References [1] R. Curto, L. Fialkow and M. M¨ oller, The extremal truncated moment problem, Integral Equations Operator Theory 60 (2008), 177–200. Ra´ ul E. Curto Department of Mathematics The University of Iowa Iowa City, IA 52242-1419 USA e-mail:
[email protected] Lawrence A. Fialkow Department of Computer Science State University of New York New Paltz, NY 12561 USA e-mail:
[email protected] H. Michael M¨ oller FB Mathematik der Universit¨ at Dortmund 44221 Dortmund Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 149–158 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020149-10, published online March 11, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1578-5
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Doubly-Invariant Subspaces for the Shift on the Vector-Valued Sobolev Spaces of the Disc and Annulus I. Chalendar and J. R. Partington Abstract. This paper characterizes the closed doubly shift-invariant subspaces of the Sobolev space of vector-valued functions defined on the unit circle. Partial results are obtained on the analogous problem for the Sobolev space on the boundary of the annulus. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 46E20, 47B38; Secondary 30D55, 47A15. Keywords. Shift operator, Sobolev space.
1. Introduction The purpose of this paper is to study the shift operator S (multiplication by the independent variable) on certain Sobolev spaces, of which formal definitions will be given later in the paper. These spaces consist of vector-valued functions on the boundary of the annulus A = {z ∈ C : r0 < |z| < 1}, where r0 is a positive real number less than unity. In particular, we are interested in the invariant subspaces of S. We consider also the Hardy–Sobolev spaces of vector-valued functions on the annulus. In the case of scalar-valued Hardy spaces on the annulus there has been much significant work [14, 6, 12, 15, 1], and some extensions to the vector-valued case were recently obtained in [2]. However, as a preliminary step, we need also to study certain spaces of functions defined on the unit disc in C. The function space W 1,2 (T) denotes the set of functions f defined on T = {z ∈ C : |z| = 1} for which there exists a sequence (an )n∈Z in C satisfying f (eit ) = n∈Z an eint and f 2W 1,2 (T) := |a0 |2 + n∈Z n2 |an |2 < ∞. The functions f in W 1,2 (T) have their derivatives with respect to t, denoted by ft , in L2 (T) and
150
Chalendar and Partington
IEOT
W 1,2 (T) is a Hilbert space endowed with the scalar product defined by 2π 1 f, gW 1,2 (T) = ft (eit )gt (eit ) dt + f(0) g(0). 2π 0 The Hardy–Sobolev space H 1,2 (D) is the subspace of W 1,2 (T) consisting of functions whose Poisson extension to the disc D = {z ∈ C : |z| < 1} is analytic; ∞ n equivalently, it may be regarded as the space of Taylor series f : z → n=0 an z ∞ 2 2 2 2 for which the norm given by f = |a0 | + n=1 n |an | is finite. For 0 < r0 < 1 we \ r0 D), consisting of functions with an shall also be interested in the space H 1,2 (C 0 analytic extension to C\r0 D, represented by a Laurent series f : z → n=−∞ an z n with finite norm given by f 2 = |a0 |2 +
−1 n=−∞
n2 r02n |an |2 .
Denote by S the operator of multiplication by z on W 1,2 (T). Clearly S is invertible and S −1 f (eit ) = e−it f (eit ) for f ∈ W 1,2 (T). A closed subspace M in W 1,2 (T) is said to be invariant for S if SM ⊂ M, doubly invariant for S if M is both invariant for S and S −1 and reducing for S if M is both invariant for S and S ∗ . For f ∈ W 1,2 (T), 1. IS [f ] will denote the smallest closed subspace M in W 1,2 (T) containing f and invariant for S. 2. DS [f ] will denote the smallest closed subspace M in W 1,2 (T) containing f and doubly invariant for S. 3. RS [f ] will denote the smallest closed subspace M in W 1,2 (T) containing f and reducing for S. Let E be a closed subset of T. Denote by MW 1,2 (T) (E) the closed doubly-invariant subspace of W 1,2 (T) defined by MW 1,2 (T) (E) = {f ∈ W 1,2 (T) : f|E = 0}. Such subspaces are called spectral. It can happen that spectral subspaces completely characterize the doubly-invariant subspaces, as in the Wiener theorem asserting that a every doubly-invariant subspace of L2 (T) has the form χE L2 (T) for some measurable set E ⊂ T (see [5, 10, 11]). We employ an analogous notation for subspaces of W 1,2 (T, Cm ); in general we use lower case letters for scalar functions and capital letters for vector-valued functions. In particular, (f1 )t f1 for F = ... in W 1,2 (∂A, Cm ), (F )t denotes ... . fm
(fm )t
The structure of this paper is as follows. In Section 2 we characterize the doubly-invariant subspaces of W 1,2 (T, Cm ), first in the known case m = 1, and
Vol. 61 (2008)
Doubly-Invariant Subspaces for the Shift
151
then for general m. The case when m = 2 and the subspace is the graph of an operator is of particular importance, as this enables a characterization of unbounded shift-invariant operators. The Sobolev space (and Hardy–Sobolev space) of the annulus are much harder to analyse: in Section 3 we show that under some circumstances the doubly-invariant subspaces are spectral as in the case of the disc (i.e., determined by the set on which the functions in the subspace vanish), although in general this is not the case.
2. Doubly-invariant subspaces in W 1,2 (T, Cm ) 2.1. Scalar case The next result was announced in [8], having been obtained by a different method based on the approximation of the functions in the Sobolev space defined on the real axis. We give a direct proof, which we later apply to the vectorial case. Some related results, in the context of spectral synthesis, have been given by Netrusov (see [9, 4]). Proposition 2.1. Let K be a closed doubly-invariant subspace in W 1,2 (T). Then there exists a function φ ∈ W 1,2 (T) such that K = DS (φ) and moreover K = {f ∈ W 1,2 (T) : f|Z(φ) = 0}, where Z(φ) = {eit ∈ T : φ(eit ) = 0}. In other words the closed doubly-invariant subspace in W 1,2 (T) are spectral. Proof. Let PK denote the orthogonal projection from W 1,2 (T) onto K, and take φ = PK 1, where 1 is the function identically equal to 1 on T. Obviously, if φ = 1, then K = W 1,2 (T). Suppose now that φ = 1. Then it follows that φW 1,2 (T) = 1 and thus = 0. 1 − φ(0) (2.1) Since φ = PK 1, φ ∈ K and 1 − φ is orthogonal to K. Since K is doubly-invariant it follows that (2.2) S n φ, 1 − φW 1,2 (T) = 0, n ∈ Z. Now, (2.2) means that 2π int it int it it (ine φ(e ) + e φt (e ))(−φt (e )) dt + 0
0
2π
φ(eit )eint (1 − φ(0)) dt = 0,
for all n ∈ Z, and then we get: 0
2π
−ine
int
it
φ(e )φt
(eit ) dt
=
2π
e 0
int
it
φt (e )φt
(eit ) dt−
2π
φ(eit )eint (1− φ(0)) dt
0
for all n ∈ Z. It follows that φφt is absolutely continuous and (φφt )t = φt φt − φ(1 − φ(0).
152
Chalendar and Partington
IEOT
Since (φt )t = −φtt , we then obtain, −φφtt = −φ(1 − φ(0)).
(2.3)
= 0 on T \ Z(φ). Combining (2.3) and (2.1) we have φtt = 1 − φ(0) Thus the circle can be written as the union of a closed set on which φ = 0 and a countable union of intervals, on each of which φ has constant second derivative. In order to check that K = DS (φ), take f ∈ K orthogonal to DS (φ). Then S n φ, f W 1,2 (T) = 0, n ∈ Z.
(2.4)
Moreover, since f ∈ K, it follows that S n f, 1 − φW 1,2 (T) = 0, n ∈ Z.
(2.5)
1,2
In the sequel we will show that if f ∈ W (T) satisfies (2.4) and (2.5), then f is identically equal to 0. Using (2.4) we get: 2π 2π (ineint φ(eit ) + eint φt (eit ))ft (eit ) dt + φ(eit )eint f(0) dt = 0, n ∈ Z, 0
0
and then, for all n ∈ Z, we get: 2π −ineint φ(eit )ft (eit ) dt = 0
2π 0
eint (φt (eit )ft (eit ) + φ(eit )f(0)) dt.
It follows that φft is absolutely continuous and (φft )t = φt ft + φf(0). We then obtain, φftt = φf(0), which means that ftt = f(0) on T \ Z(φ).
(2.6)
Using a similar calculation, (2.5) implies that f φt is absolutely continuous and = 0. f (φtt − (1 − φ(0)))
(2.7)
We claim now that f = 0 on Z(φ). Recall that on each “component interval”, = (a, b), forming a component of the open set T\Z(φ), we may write φtt = 1− φ(0) c = 0, say (a.e.), and so, integrating and recalling that φ vanishes at the end points, we find that c for a ≤ t ≤ b. φ(eit ) = (t − a)(t − b) 2 Note that φt (a+) = −c(b − a)/2 and φt (b−) = c(b − a)/2. Take z ∈ Z(φ). If z ∈ int Zφ , then φtt = 0 on an interval including z and so f (z) = 0 by continuity and (2.7). Otherwise, suppose now that z ∈ ∂Z(φ) and f (z) = 0, so f (eit ) = 0 on some nontrivial interval (z − δ, z + δ). Now f φt is known to be absolutely continuous, and the condition on f implies that φt must be continuous on (z − δ, z + δ). But this is absurd, since there is either a lefthand endpoint a of a component interval (a, b) lying in [z, z + δ) or a right-hand endpoint b lying in (z − δ, z]. Suppose the first case (the second is similar): then
Vol. 61 (2008)
Doubly-Invariant Subspaces for the Shift
153
φt (a+) = −c(b − a)/2; on the other hand, either there is an interval (a − η, a] ⊆ Z(φ) (so that φt (a−) = 0 and φt is discontinuous at a) or there is a sequence of component intervals (an , bn ) with bn → a− (possibly bn = a for each n). In this case φt (bn −) = c(bn − an )/2, which cannot converge to −c(b − a)/2. Moreover, by (2.6), ftt equals a unique constant on T\Z(φ), and since φtt has the same property, there exists λ ∈ C such that f = λφ. Finally φ, λφW 1,2 (T) = 0 so λ = 0. Therefore f is identically equal to 0 and thus K = DS (φ). It remains to check that K = M(Z(φ))(= {f ∈ W 1,2 (T) : f|Z(φ) = 0}). Obviously, K is a subset of M(Z(φ)). In order to prove the converse inclusion, take f ∈ M(Z(φ)) satisfying (2.4). Then f|Z(φ) = 0 and ftt = f(0) on T \ Z(φ) (see (2.6). It follows that there exists λ ∈ C such that f = λφ and as previously φ, λφW 1,2 (T) = 0 implies that λ = 0. Therefore f is identically equal to 0 and thus K = M(DS (φ)). 2.2. Vectorial case Let m be a positive integer. Theorem 2.2. Let K be a closed doubly-invariant subspace in W 1,2 (T, Cm ). Then, for almost all eiw ∈ T, there exists a subspace I(eiw ) of Cm such that K = {F ∈ W 1,2 (T, Cm ) : F (eiw ) ∈ I(eiw )}. Proof. Let PK : W 1,2 (T, Cm ) → K denote the orthogonal projection onto K. Let {e1 , . . . , em } denote the canonical basis of Cm . For r ∈ Z and 1 ≤ k ≤ m, let Ψr,k denote the vector-valued function defined on T by z −→ PK z r ek . For each w ∈ T, let I(eiw ) denote the linear span of the set of vectors {Ψr,k (eiw ) : r ∈ Z, 1 ≤ k ≤ m}. Note that I(eiw ) is closed as a subspace of finite dimension. Define P (eiw ) to be the orthogonal projection from Cm onto I(eiw ). It is clear that K ⊂ {F ∈ W 1,2 (T, Cm ) : F (eiw ) ∈ I(eiw )} and that {F ∈ W 1,2 (T, Cm ) : F (eiw ) ∈ I(eiw )} is both closed and doublyinvariant. If the two spaces were unequal, then there would exist F ∈ W 1,2 (T, Cm ) such that F (eiw ) ∈ I(eiw ) and with F orthogonal to S n Ψr,k for all n, r ∈ Z and k ∈ {1, . . . , m}. Thus we get, for all n, r ∈ Z and k ∈ {1, . . . , m}: 2π 2π (eint Ψr,k (eit ))t , Ft (eit )Cm dt + (eint Ψr,k (eit )), F(0)Cm dt = 0. 0
0
It follows that for all n, r ∈ Z and k ∈ {1, . . . , m}: 2π eint (inΨr,k (eit ), Ft (eit )Cm + (Ψr,k (eit ))t , Ft (eit )Cm 0
+ Ψr,k (eit ), F(0)Cm ) dt = 0.
154
Chalendar and Partington
IEOT
So Ψr,k , Ft is absolutely continuous and (Ψr,k , Ft )t = (Ψr,k )t , Ft + Ψr,k , F (0). Or, writing G = Ft − tF (0), we have Ψr,k , Gt = (Ψr,k )t , G, implying that the the directional derivative Ψr,k , Gt exists and is zero almost everywhere; hence F, Gt also exists and is zero a.e. So 2π F (eit ), Gt (eit ) dt = 0. 0
That is,
0
2π
F, Ftt − F (0) dt
=
[F, Ft ]2π 0
=
−
0
2π
−
0
2π
|Ft |2 dt − 2π|F (0)|2
|Ft |2 dt − 2π|F(0)|2 = 0.
Thus F is constant and F (0) = 0. Hence, F is identically equal to 0 and K = {F ∈ W 1,2 (T, Cm ) : F (eiw ) ∈ I(eiw )}.
Remark 2.3. If we define P (eiw ) to be the orthogonal projection from Cm onto I(eiw ), P is a measurable function of eiw but it does not even need to be continuous. Indeed, let m ≥ 2 and consider I(eiw ) to be the linear span of the set of vectors e1 and e1 + (eiw − 1)e2 , where {e1 , . . . , em } denote the canonical basis of Cm . Then clearly P (eiw ) is the identity map whenever eiw = 1 and P (eiw ) is the projection onto e1 otherwise. Note that eiw −→ e1 and eiw −→ e1 + (eiw − 1)e2 belong to W 1,2 (T, Cm ). One application of these results is to the graphs of operators. We recall that, for Banach spaces X and Y the graph of a (possibly unbounded) operator T : D(T ) → Y , with domain D(T ) ⊂ X , is the subspace G(T ) = {(x, y) : x ∈ D(T ), y = T x} ⊂ X × Y. Theorem 2.2 can be used to obtain information on the structure of doublyinvariant graphs; however, this does not seem to give the full analogue of the known result for L2 (T, C2 ), which may be found in [7] and [11, Sec. 3.2].
3. Doubly-invariant subspaces in the Sobolev space in the annulus Let r0 be a positive real number less than unity and let A be the annulus defined by A = {z ∈ C : r0 < |z| < 1}. The boundary ∂A of A consists of two circles T and r0 T.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Doubly-Invariant Subspaces for the Shift
155
Define W 1,2 (rT) as the set of functions f defined on rT satisfying f (reit ) = n int and n∈Z bn r e f 2W 1,2 (rT) := |b0 |2 + n2 r2n |bn |2 < ∞. n∈Z 1,2
Define W (∂A) as the set of functions f on ∂A of the form f = f1 ⊕ f0 with f1 ∈ W 1,2 (T) and f0 ∈ W 1,2 (r0 T). The subspace H 1,2 (∂A) set of functions f0 in W 1,2 (T) ⊕ is theint f = f1 n⊕int 1,2 it it W (rT) where f1 (e ) = n∈Z an e , f0 (r0 e ) = n∈Z an r0 e and f 2H 1,2 (∂A) := 2|a0 |2 + n2 (1 + r02n )|an |2 < ∞. n∈Z
Note that H 1,2 (∂A) can be isometrically with the set H 1,2 (A) of func identified n tions analytic in A of the form f (z) = n∈Z an z with 2|a0 |2 + n2 (1 + r02n )|an |2 < ∞. n∈Z
We shall start with a factorization theorem for functions in H 1,2 (A). Similar formulae have been found useful in H 2 (A) (see for example [6], [3], [1, Thm. 2.1]), and our method of proof is similar to that of [3]. Theorem 3.1. Let f ∈ H 1,2 (A). Then there exist m ∈ Z,f1 ∈ H 1,2 (D) and f0 ∈ \ r0 D) such that f (z) = z m f0 (z)f1 (z). Moreover, the zeros of f0 and f1 H 1,2 (C can be taken to lie in A. \ r0 D) be the Blaschke product associated Proof. Let r1 ∈ (r0 , 1) and B0 ∈ H ∞ (C with the zeros of f in {z ∈ C : r0 < |z| ≤ r1 } and B1 ∈ H ∞ (D) be the Blaschke product associated with the zeros of f in {z ∈ C : r1 < |z| < 1}. Then B1fB0 ∈ H 2 (A) and B1fB0 has no zero. Now, there exists m ∈ Z such that h := log B1 Bf0 zm is single-valued. Note
h(z) +∞ 1 n that h ∈ H 1 (A), and h(z) = n=−∞ an z , where an = 2iπ Γ z n+1 dz for any circle Γ lying in A. Moreover, there exists C > 0 such that |an | ≤ C forn ≥ 0 and |an | ≤ rCn for n ≤ 0. It follows that h(z) = h1 (z)+h0 (z) where h1 (z) := n≥0 an z n 0 \ r0 D. is holomorphic in D, and h0 (z) := an z n is holomorphic in C n<0
Set f1 (z) = B1 (z)eh1 (z) and f0 (z) = B0 (z)eh0 (z) . Note that f1 is holomorphic in D and z −m f (z)e−h0 (z) . f1 (z) = B0 (z) Since f ∈ W 1,2 (T), and since z → z −m , z → e−h0 (z) and z → B11(z) are holomorphic in a neighbourhood of T, it is clear that f1 ∈ H 1,2 (D). \ r0 D and Moreover, f0 is holomorphic in C f0 (z) =
z −m f (z)e−h1 (z) . B1 (z)
156
Chalendar and Partington
\ r0 D). Similar arguments on r0 T show that f0 ∈ H 1,2 (C
IEOT
Let us return to the analysis of the structure of the doubly-invariant subspaces. In general the doubly-invariant subspaces are not spectral. Indeed, for example DS (1) = H 1,2 (A) and thus DS (1) is not spectral. In order to present our next result, we introduce the following definition. Definition 3.2. A function F ∈ W 1,2 (∂A, Cm ) is bounded below if there exists δ > 0 such that F (ξ)Cm ≥ δ almost everywhere on ∂A. Proposition 3.3. Suppose that F ∈ W 1,2 (∂A, Cm ) satisfies Ft ∞ < ∞ and F is essentially bounded below. Then DS (F ) = H 1,2 (∂A)F . Proof. We need to show that H 1,2 (∂A)F is closed, in which case it will be DS (F ), N being limits of expressions of the form −N an z n F (z). Suppose that {gn F } is a Cauchy sequence in W 1,2 (∂A, Cm ), where gn ∈ H (∂A). Now (gn F )t = (gn )t F + gn Ft , in the sense that gn F is absolutely continuous and is the integral of the L2 (∂A, Cm ) function (gn )t F + gn Ft . 1,2
Since {gn F } converges in L2 (∂A, Cm ) and F is bounded below, we get convergence of {gn } in L2 (∂A, Cm ). Hence we have L2 (∂A, Cm ) convergence of {gn Ft } as Ft is in L∞ (∂A, Cm ). By subtraction, we have L2 (∂A, Cm ) convergence of {(gn )t F }, and hence of {(gn )t }. Hence {gn } is Cauchy in H 1,2 (∂A), which is enough to show that H 1,2 (∂A)F is closed. One circumstance under which a subspace DS (f ) will be spectral is given by the following result. Theorem 3.4. Take f = f1 ⊕f0 in W 1,2 (∂A), and suppose that f1 = 0 or f0 = 0 on an interval of positive measure. Then DS (f ) = DS (f1 ) ⊕ DS (f0 ) and thus DS (f ) is spectral. Proof. Clearly DS (f ) ⊂ DS (f1 ) ⊕ DS (f0 ), so we need to show that if g = g1 ⊕ g0 ∈ DS (f1 ) ⊕ DS (f0 ) then it is in DS (f ). Suppose to fix ideas that f = 0 on an arc Z = {r0 eit : π − α ≤ t ≤ π + α} with 0 < α < π. It will be clear how the proof can be adapted in general. We have a sequence of pairs of trigonometric polynomials {pn ⊕ qn } with pn f1 − g1 W 1,2 (T) → 0, and qn f2 − g2 W 1,2 (r0 T) → 0. If we can find a sequence of polynomials in z and 1/z, say {rn (z)} with rn − pn W 1,∞ (T) → 0 and rn − qn W 1,∞ (r0 T\Z) → 0, then we shall also have rn f − gW 1,2 (∂A) → 0, and the result follows. We are grateful to the referee for the following conclusion to the proof, which is somewhat simpler than our original argument using Mergelyan’s theorem. We apply Runge’s theorem [13, Thm. 13.6] to a small neighbourhood U of ∂A \ Z with two components, not containing 0. This gives us a sequence {rn } such
Vol. 61 (2008)
Doubly-Invariant Subspaces for the Shift
157
that rn − pn → 0 uniformly on an open subset containing T and rn − qn → 0 uniformly on an open subset containing r0 T \ Z. By an easy estimate involving Cauchy’s integral formula, this implies also that rn − pn → 0 uniformly on T and rn − qn → 0 uniformly on r0 T \ Z. Same arguments imply the following result. Corollary 3.5. Take F = F1 ⊕ F0 ∈ W 1,2 (∂A, Cm ) and suppose that F1 = 0 or F0 = 0 on an interval of positive measure. Then DS (F ) = DS (F1 ) ⊕ DS (F0 ) and thus DS (F ) is spectral. We conclude with the following question: in [14], it was shown that if f = f1 ⊕ f0 ∈ L2 (∂A) satisfies f1 is not log-integrable on T or f0 is not log-integrable on r0 T, then DS (f ) = DS (f1 ) ⊕ DS (f0 ). Is a similar property still true in analytic Sobolev spaces? Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to the EPSRC for financial support, and they thank Janyne and Claude Charlier for providing such a pleasant environment in which to do research. They also wish to express their gratitude to the referee for reading the manuscript very carefully and helping them to remove a number of errors.
References [1] A. Aleman and S. Richter. Simply invariant subspaces of H 2 of some multiply connected regions. Integral Equations Operator Theory, 24(2):127–155, 1996. Erratum. Ibid, 29(4):501–504, 1997. [2] I. Chalendar, N. Chevrot, and J. R. Partington. Invariant subspaces for the shift on the vector-valued L2 space of an annulus. Journal of Operator Theory, to appear, 2007. [3] K. C. Chan and A. L. Shields. Zero sets, interpolating sequences, and cyclic vectors for Dirichlet spaces. Michigan Math. J., 39(2):289–307, 1992. [4] L. I. Hedberg and Yu. Netrusov. An axiomatic approach to function spaces, spectral synthesis, and Luzin approximation. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc., 188(882), 2007. [5] H. Helson. Lectures on invariant subspaces. Academic Press, New York, 1964. [6] D. Hitt. Invariant subspaces of H2 of an annulus. Pacific J. Math., 134(1):101–120, 1988. [7] B. Jacob and J. R. Partington. Graphs, closability, and causality of linear timeinvariant discrete-time systems. Internat. J. Control, 73(11):1051–1060, 2000. [8] L. Khanin. Spectral synthesis of ideals in algebras of functions having generalized derivatives. Russian Math. Surveys, 39:167–168, 1984. [9] Yu. V. Netrusov. Spectral synthesis in a Sobolev space generated by an integral metric. Zap. Nauchn. Sem. S.-Peterburg. Otdel. Mat. Inst. Steklov. (POMI), 217(Issled. po Linein. Oper. i Teor. Funktsii. 22):92–111, 221, 1994. Translation in J. Math. Sci. (New York) 85 (1997), no. 2, 1814–1826.
158
Chalendar and Partington
IEOT
[10] N. K. Nikolski. Operators, functions, and systems: an easy reading. Vol. 1, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, Vol. 92. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2002. Translated from the French by A. Hartmann. [11] J. R. Partington. Linear Operators and Linear Systems. Cambridge University Press, 2004. London Math. Soc. Student Texts 60. [12] H. L. Royden. Invariant subspaces of H p for multiply connected regions. Pacific J. Math., 134(1):151–172, 1988. [13] W. Rudin. Real and complex analysis. McGraw–Hill, third edition, 1986. [14] D. Sarason. The H p spaces of an annulus. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc., 56, 1965. [15] D. V. Yakubovich. Invariant subspaces of the operator of multiplication by z in the space E p in a multiply connected domain. J. Soviet Math., 61(2):2046–2056, 1992. I. Chalendar Institut Girard Desargues UFR de Math´ematiques Universit´e Lyon 1 69622 Villeurbanne Cedex France e-mail:
[email protected] J. R. Partington School of Mathematics University of Leeds Leeds LS2 9JT U.K. e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: February 12, 2007 Revised: February 6, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 159–165 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020159-7, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1584-7
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Xia Spectrum for Some Class of Operators Muneo Ch¯o, Tadasi Huruya and Kˆotarˆo Tanahashi Dedicated to Professor Robin Harte on his seventieth birthday
Abstract. In this paper, we introduce Xia spectra of n-tuples of operators satisfying |T 2 | ≥ U |T 2 |U ∗ for the polar decomposition of T = U |T | and we extend Putnam’s inequality to these tuples [7]. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B20; Secondary 47A10. Keywords. Hilbert space, operator, Putnam’s inequality, Taylor spectrum, Xia spectrum, joint approximate point spectrum.
1. Introduction Let H be a complex separable Hilbert space and B(H) be the set of all bounded linear operators on H. For an operator T ∈ B(H) is called p-hyponormal if (T ∗ T )p ≥ (T T ∗ )p . If p = 1, T is called hyponormal, and p = 12 , T is called semi-hyponormal. For an operator T ∈ B(H), we denote the spectrum of T by σ(T ). D. Xia, in [6], introduced semi-hyponormal tuples and extended the Putnam’s inequality to semi-hyponormal tuples. In this paper, we introduce an operator T such that |T 2 | ≥ U |T 2 |U ∗ = (|T ∗ ||T |2 |T ∗ |)1/2 , where T = U |T | is the polar decomposition of T . By Lemma 1 (iii) of [4](p.159), it holds that U |T 2 |U ∗ = (|T ∗ ||T |2 |T ∗ |)1/2 for any operator T = U |T |. If an operator T = U |T | satisfies T 2 = 0 and |T 2 | ≥ U |T 2 |U ∗ , then we say it power pusedo-semihyponormal and extend the Putnam’s inequality to these operators. In section 3, we give a power pusedo-semihyponormal operator T which is not paranormal. Let U = (U1 , . . . , Un ) be an commuting n-tuple of unitary operators and, for an operator T ∈ B(H), we denote the (n + 1)-tuple (U1 , . . . , Un , T ) by (U, T ). An operator Qj (j = 1, . . . , n) on B(H) is defined by Qj T = T − Uj T Uj∗
(T ∈ B(H)).
This research is partially supported by Grant-in-Aid Research No.17540176.
160
Ch¯ o, Huruya and Tanahashi
IEOT
Let A ∈ B(H) and A ≥ 0. (U, A) is called a semi-hyponormal tuple if Qj1 · · · Qjm A ≥ 0 for all 1 ≤ j1 < · · · < jm ≤ n. If (U, A) is a semi-hyponormal tuple, then Uj A is semi-hyponormal for every j (j = 1, . . . , n). For an operator T ∈ B(H), if Sj± (T ) = s - lim (Uj−n T Ujn ) n→±∞
Sj± (T )
exist, then the operators are called the polar symbols of T . If Uj A is semi± hyponormal, then Sj (A) exist (cf.[8]). For 0 ≤ k ≤ 1, we denote (kSj+ + (1 − k)Sj− )T = kSj+ (T ) + (1 − k)Sj− (T ). Let k = (k1 , . . . , kn ) ∈ [0, 1]n and (U, A) be a semi-hyponormal tuple. Then the generalized polar symbols Ak of A are defined by Ak =
n j=1
(kj Sj+ + (1 − kj )Sj− )A.
Then we have the following theorem. Theorem 1.1. (Proposition, [1]) With the above notations, (U, Ak ) is a commuting (n + 1)-tuple for every k ∈ [0, 1]n . We denote the Taylor spectrum of a commuting m-tuple S = (S1 , . . . , Sm ) of operators by σT (S). For an m-tuple S = (S1 , . . . , Sm ), let σja (S) be the joint approximate point spectrum of S, i.e., the set of all points (z1 , . . . , zm ) for which there exits a sequence {xk } of unit vectors such that lim (Sj − zj )xk = 0 (j = 1, . . . , m).
k→∞
It is well known that σT (S) = σja (S) if S is a commuting m-tuple of normal operators. Hence, from Theorem A, it holds that σT (U, Ak ) = σja (U, Ak ) for every k ∈ [0, 1]n (cf. [2],[6]). Next, D. Xia in [7] defined the joint spectrum for a non-commuting (n+1)-tuple (U, A) = (U1 , . . . , Un , A) as follows: Let T = {z ∈ C : |z| = 1} and let E(·) be the spectral measure of U. For z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) ∈ σT (U), the set of all products ∆ = γ1 × · · · × γn of open arcs γj ⊂ T, containing zj (j = 1, . . . , n), is denoted by Γ(z). The set σ(E(∆)AE(∆))} {(z, r) : z ∈ σT (U), r ∈ ∆∈Γ(z)
is called the Xia spectrum of (U, A) and we denote it by σX (U, A). And D. Xia proved the following Theorem 1.2. (Theorem 2, [7]) Let (U, A) be a semi-hyponormal tuple. Then σX (U, A) = σja (U, Ak ). k∈[0,1]n
Vol. 61 (2008)
Xia Spectrum for Some Class of Operators
161
Let mj (j = 1, . . . , n) be the normalized Haar measure in the unit circle T, i.e., 1 dθj (eiθj ∈ T) 2π and m = m1 × · · · × mn × dr, where dr is the Lebesgue measure on R. Then also D. Xia proved the following dmj =
Theorem 1.3. (Theorem 5, [7]) Let (U, A) be a semi-hyponormal tuple. Then 1 Q1 · · · Qn A ≤ m(σX (U, A)) = dθ1 · · · dθn dr. · · · (2π)n σX (U,A)
2. Xia spectrum for new class of operator Let T = (T1 , T2 , . . . , Tn ) be a doubly commuting n-tuple of operators Tj = Uj |Tj | with unitary Uj which satisfies |Tj2 | ≥ Uj |Tj2 |Uj∗ for every j (j = 1, 2, . . . , n). Let A = |T12 | · · · |Tn2 |. Then A ≥ 0 since (|T12 |, . . . , |Tn2 |) is a commuting n-tuple of positive operators. Let U = (U1 , . . . , Un ). Since U = (U1 , . . . , Un ) is a commuting n-tuple of unitary operators and Qj A = ( |Ti2 | )( |Tj2 | − Uj |Tj2 |Uj∗ ), i=j
we have Qj1 · · · Qjm A =
|Ti2 |
(|Ti2 |
−
Ui |Ti2 |Ui∗ )
≥0
i=j1 ,...,jm
i=j1 ,...,jm
for all 1 ≤ j1 < · · · < jm ≤ n. Therefore, we have that (U, A) is a semi-hyponormal tuple and n Q1 · · · Qn A = (|Tj2 | − Uj |Tj2 |Uj∗ ). j=1
Therefore, we have the following theorems. Theorem 2.1. Let T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) be a doubly commuting n-tuple of power pusedo-semihyponormal operators Tj = Uj |Tj | with unitary Uj (j = 1, . . . , n). Let U = (U1 , . . . , Un ) and A = |T12 | · · · |Tn2 |. Then σja (U, Ak ). σX (U, A) = k∈[0,1]n
Theorem 2.2. Let T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) be a doubly commuting n-tuple of power pusedo-semihyponormal operators Tj = Uj |Tj | with unitary Uj (j = 1, . . . , n). Let U = (U1 , . . . , Un ) and A = |T12 | · · · |Tn2 |. Then n 1 || (|Tj2 | − Uj |Tj2 |Uj∗ )|| ≤ dθ1 · · · dθn dr. · · · (2π)n σX (U,A) j=1
162
Ch¯ o, Huruya and Tanahashi
IEOT
3. Examples Let A, B, C ≥ 0 be 2 × 2 defined by 0 B 0 0 T = .. . 0 .. . Then
√ |T 2 | =
2 ∞ 2 matrices. Let T be an operator on (⊕∞ 0 C ) ⊕ (⊕0 C )
BA2 B 0 0 0 .. . 0 0 .. .
B 0 0 0 . |T | = .. 0 0 .. . and
C 0 0 0 ∗ . |T | = .. 0 0 .. .
0 0 A 0 .. .
0 0 0 A .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
··· ··· ··· ···
C 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 .. .
0 .. .
0 .. .
···
0 .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0
0 A2 0 0 .. .
0 0 A2 0 .. .
0 0 0 A2 .. .
··· ··· ··· ··· .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0
0 0
··· ··· .. .
0 A 0 0 .. .
0 0 A 0
0 0 0 A
··· ··· ··· ··· .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0
0 0 .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0
··· ··· .. .
C 0 .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0 .. . 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
√ CB 2 C 0 .. .
0 B 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 A 0 0 A
··· ··· ··· ··· .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0
··· ··· .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0
··· ··· ··· ··· . .. . 0 ··· .. . 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 .. .
··· ··· ··· ··· .. , . 0 ··· 0 ··· .. .
0 0 0 0
··· ··· ··· ··· .. . 0 ··· 0 ··· .. . 0 0 0 0
··· ··· ··· ··· .. . . 0 ··· 0 ··· .. . 0 0 0 0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Now, let A=
3 2
Xia Spectrum for Some Class of Operators
0
0
3 4
, Q = 1 2
1 1
1 1
163
, B = b · Q and C = c · Q (0 < b, c).
Then (1) |T 2 | ≥ |T ∗ |2 implies √ √ 3 2 · b · Q = BA2 B ≥ C 2 = c2 · Q and A2 ≥ B 2 = b2 · Q. 4 √
Hence 0 < b ≤ 1 and 0 < c2 ≤ 3 4 2 · b. Also, (2) |T | ≥ |T ∗ | implies A ≥ B = b · Q ≥ C = c · Q. √ √ Hence 0 < c ≤ b ≤ 6( 2 − 1) = 1.0146 . . . . Since √ CB 2 C √ 0 0 0 ··· 2B 0 BA 0 0 ··· 2 0 ··· 0 0 A 2 0 0 0 A ··· ∗ 2 ∗ 12 . . .. (|T ||T | |T |) = .. .. . 0 0 0 0 · · · 0 0 0 0 ··· .. .. .. . . .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0
0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
··· ··· ··· ··· .. , . 0 ··· 0 ··· .. .
0 0 0 0
1
(3) |T 2 | ≥ (|T ∗ ||T |2 |T ∗ |) 2 implies √ √ √ 2 3 2 A ≥ BA2 B = · b · Q ≥ CB 2 C = bc · Q. 4 √
√
Hence 0 < b ≤ 2 3 2 = 0.943 . . . and 0 < c ≤ 3 4 2 . This example shows that there is no inclusional relation for (1), (2), (3). √ 2 2 For example, let b = 3 . Then T satisfies (1), (3) and does not satisfy (2) if √ √ 2 2 3 2 3 < c ≤ 1, and T satisfies (3) and does not satisfy (1), (2) if 1 < c ≤ 4 . Next, let vectors 0 and x be where x1 =
0 = (0, 0, . . .) and x = (x1 , 0, 0, . . .), √ 1 . Then 0 ⊕ x = 2 and 1 T (0 ⊕ x) = (Cx1 , 0, 0, . . .) ⊕ (0, 0, 0, . . .).
164
Ch¯ o, Huruya and Tanahashi
Since
0 0 AB 0 2 . T = .. 0 0 .. . we have
0 0 0 A2 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0 .. .
··· ··· ··· ··· .. .
0 BC 0 0 .. .
0 0 .. .
0 0
0 0
··· ··· .. .
0 0 .. .
IEOT
0 0 0 0 .. .
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 .. .
··· ··· ··· ··· .. , . 0 ··· 0 ··· .. . 0 0 0 0
T 2 (0 ⊕ x) = (0, BCx1 , 0, 0, . . .) ⊕ (0, 0, 0, . . .).
Since Cx1 = c
1 1
and BCx1 = bc
1 1
,
hence C2c2 = T (0 ⊕ x)2 ≤ T 2 (0 ⊕ x) · 0 ⊕ x = 2bc implies c ≤ b. √ √ Therefore, T is not paranormal if b < c. Let b = 2 3 2 and c = 3 4 2 . Then since b < c, the operator T is a power pusedo-semihyponormal operator which is not paranormal.
References [1] M. Ch¯ o and T. Huruya, Putnam’s inequality for p-hyponormal n-tuples, Glasgow Math. J. 41(1999), 13-17. [2] R. Curto, On the connectedness of invertible n-tuples, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 29(1980), 393-406. [3] R. Curto, P. Muhly and D. Xia, A trace estimate for p-hyponormal operators, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 6(1983), 507-514. [4] T. Furuta, Invitation to linear operators, Taylor and Francis, 2001. [5] C. R. Putnam, Commutation properties of Hilbert space operators, Springer-Verlag, 1967. [6] J. L. Taylor, A joint spectrum for several commuting operators, J. Funct. Anal. 6(1970), 172-191. [7] D. Xia, On the semi-hyponormal n-tuple of operators, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 6(1983), 879-898. [8] D. Xia, Spectral Theory of Hyponormal Operators, Birkh¨ auser 1983. Muneo Ch¯ o Department of Mathematics Kanagawa University Yokohama, 221-8686 Japan e-mail:
[email protected]
Vol. 61 (2008)
Xia Spectrum for Some Class of Operators
Tadasi Huruya Faculty of Education and Human Sciences Niigata University Niigata 950-2181 Japan e-mail:
[email protected] Kˆ otarˆ o Tanahashi Department of Mathematics Tohoku College of Pharmacy Sendai 981-8558 Japan e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: August 28, 2007 Revised: March 3, 2008
165
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 167–186 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020167-20, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1579-4
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Composition Operators on the Space of Bounded Harmonic Functions Jun Soo Choa, Kei Ji Izuchi and Shˆ uichi Ohno Abstract. We study composition operators on the space of bounded harmonic functions on the open unit disk. The principal goal of this paper is to provide criteria for determining the essential norm of difference of two composition operators. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B33; Secondary 46J15. Keywords. Composition operators, the space of harmonic functions, essential norm, difference of composition operators.
1. Introduction Throughout this paper h∞ denotes the Banach space of all bounded harmonic functions f on the open unit disk D := {z ∈ C : |z| < 1}, with the supremum norm f ∞ = sup{|f (z)| : z ∈ D}. We denote by S(D) the set of analytic self-maps of D. For every ϕ ∈ S(D), the composition operator Cϕ , defined by Cϕ f = f ◦ ϕ, is easily seen to be bounded on h∞ as well as on the space H ∞ of bounded analytic functions on D. Composition operators have been investigated mainly in spaces of analytic functions to characterize the operator-theoretic behavior of Cϕ in terms of the function-theoretic properties of the symbol ϕ ; see the books [2], [11] and [13] for a thorough treatment on such classical settings. In a recent paper, MacCluer, Zhao and the third author [10] have obtained results concerning the topological structure of composition operators on H ∞ . After this work, H ∞ has attracted much attention in the The first author is partially supported by KRF-2002-070-C00004. The second author is partially supported by Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No.16340037), Japan Society for the Promotion of Science. The third author is partially supported by Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No.17540169), Japan Society for the Promotion of Science.
168
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
study of this area; see, for example, [5], [8], [9] and [12]. In particular, Gorkin, Mortini and Su´ arez [5, Theorem 6] gave upper and lower bounds for the essential norm of difference of two composition operators on H ∞ , where the setting is the unit ball of Cn (n ≥ 1). A refined partial result on the essential norm of the composition difference on H ∞ has recently obtained by Hosokawa and the second author [7]. It seems difficult to compute the exact value of the essential norm of the composition difference on H ∞ . In this paper we study properties of composition operators on h∞ , and provide the exact value of the essential norm of difference of any two composition operators on h∞ . The next section outlines the prerequisites, and in Section 3 we give elementary results of composition operators on h∞ . In Sections 4 and 5 we give lower and upper bounds for the essential norm Cϕ − Cψ e of the difference Cϕ − Cψ on h∞ whenever ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). Summing these estimates, in Section 6, we completely describe Cϕ − Cψ e and present some examples of analytic self-maps ϕ, ψ attaining the essential norm.
2. Prerequisites In this section, we collect some materials and facts that will be needed in the sequel. 2.1. Harmonic functions For f ∈ h∞ , there exists a boundary function f ∗ on the unit circle ∂D := {|z| = 1} defined by f ∗ (eiθ ) = lim f (reiθ ) a.e.. ∗
∞
r→1 ∞
It is well known that {f ; f ∈ h } = L (∂D) and 2π dθ f ∗ (eiθ )Pz (eiθ ) f (z) = 2π 0 where Pz is the Poisson kernel for the point z in D. We denote by B(H ∞ ) and B(h∞ ) the closed unit balls of H ∞ and h∞ , respectively. It is known (e.g., see [4, p. 42]) that if we define ρ(z, w) = |z − w|/|1 − zw|, the pseudo-hyperbolic distance between z and w in D, then sup f ∈B(H ∞ )
|f (z) − f (w)| =
2ρ(z, w) . 1 + 1 − ρ(z, w)2
Write 2t √ , 0 ≤ t ≤ 1. 1 + 1 − t2 Then λ is an increasing function on [0, 1], λ(0) = 0, λ(1) = 2, and λ(t) =
sup f ∈B(H ∞ )
|f (z) − f (w)| = λ(ρ(z, w)).
(2.1)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
169
In what follows, we use the usual notation 2π dθ |f (eiθ )| f 1 = 2π 0 for f ∈ L1 (∂D). The next identity, which will be useful in our approach, is also taken from [4, p. 42]. Lemma 2.1. Pz − Pw 1 = 2 − (4/π) cos−1 ρ(z, w). Lemma 2.2.
sup |f (z) − f (w)| = Pz − Pw 1 ≥ λ(ρ(z, w)) for z, w ∈ D.
f ∈B(h∞ )
Proof. If f ∈ B(h∞ ), it is clear that 2π f ∗ (Pz − Pw )dθ/2π ≤ Pz − Pw 1 . |f (z) − f (w)| = 0
On the other hand, there exists a function g ∈ B(h∞ ) with g ∗ (Pz −Pw ) = |Pz −Pw | a.e. on ∂D. Thus g(z) − g(w) = Pz − Pw 1 . As a consequence, we get sup f ∈B(h∞ )
|f (z) − f (w)| = Pz − Pw 1 .
The second assertion follows from (2.1) and the containment relation B(H ∞ ) ⊂ B(h∞ ). 2.2. The maximal ideal space of H ∞ We denote by M (H ∞ ) and M (L∞ ) the set of nonzero multiplicative linear functionals on H ∞ and L∞ , respectively. We consider the weak∗ -topology for M (H ∞ ) and M (L∞ ). It is well known that with the weak∗ -topology, M (H ∞ ) and M (L∞ ) are compact Hausdorff spaces and D ⊂ M (H ∞ ). Usually we call M (H ∞ ) and M (L∞ ) with the weak∗ -topology the maximal ideal spaces of H ∞ and L∞ (∂D). The famous “corona theorem” due to Carleson [1] states that D is a dense subset of M (H ∞ ), which will be used for our developments. We identify a function f in H ∞ and L∞ (∂D) with its Gelfand transform, that is, f (m) = m(f ) for m ∈ M (H ∞ ) or m ∈ M (L∞ ). Therefore we regard f as a continuous function on M (H ∞ ) and M (L∞ ), respectively. We may think of M (L∞ ) as a closed subset of M (H ∞ ), and M (L∞ ) is the Shilov boundary for H ∞ . For each x ∈ M (H ∞ ), there exists a unique probability measure µx on M (L∞ ) satisfying f (x) = f dµx M(L∞ )
for every f ∈ H ∞ . See [3, 6] for these subjects. For g ∈ L∞ (∂D), define gˆ on M (H ∞ ) by gˆ(x) = gdµx , x ∈ M (H ∞ ). M(L∞ )
(2.2)
170
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
Then gˆ is a continuous function on M (H ∞ ), see Garnett [4, p. 375]. In case f ∈ H ∞ , we easily see that f∗ coincides with the Gelfand transform of f . Let m be the probability measure on M (L∞ ) satisfying
2π
gdm = M(L∞ )
0
g(eiθ )
dθ , 2π
g ∈ L∞ (∂D).
The following three lemmas will be used in the proof of Theorem 5.1. Lemma 2.3. Let f ∈ h∞ . Then f∗ = f on D, and f∗ on M (H ∞ ) is a continuous extension of f on D. Proof. We need only verify the first assertion. When z ∈ D, we know that Pz dm = dµz . Hence 2π ∗ iθ iθ dθ = f (e )Pz (e ) f ∗ Pz dm f (z) = 2π 0 M(L∞ ) = f ∗ dµz = f∗ (z). M(L∞ )
Let x ∈ M (H ∞ ) and ϕ ∈ S(D). It is easy to see that H ∞ f → (f ◦ ϕ)(x) is a nonzero multiplicative linear functional of H ∞ . Hence there exists a point ϕ(x) ˜ ∈ M (H ∞ ) such that (f ◦ ϕ)(x) = f (ϕ(x)) ˜
(2.3)
for every f ∈ H ∞ . Lemma 2.4. Let ϕ ∈ S(D) and x ∈ M (H ∞ ). Then ϕ, ˜ defined by (2.3), is a continuous map from M (H ∞ ) to M (H ∞ ). Moreover if |ϕ(x)| < 1, we have ϕ(x) ˜ = ϕ(x). Proof. Let f ∈ H ∞ and {ζα }α be a net in M (H ∞ ) such that ζα → ζ ∈ M (H ∞ ). Then it is immediate that f (ϕ(ζ ˜ α )) = (f ◦ ϕ)(ζα ) → (f ◦ ϕ)(ζ) = f (ϕ(ζ)). ˜ ˜ in M (H ∞ ). This shows ϕ(ζ ˜ α ) → ϕ(ζ) Suppose that |ϕ(x)| < 1. By the corona theorem, there exists a net {zα }α in D such that zα → x in M (H ∞ ). It follows that ϕ(zα ) → ϕ(x) ∈ D. But it is obvious that ϕ(z) ˜ = ϕ(z) for z ∈ D. Therefore ϕ(zα ) = ϕ(z ˜ α ) → ϕ(x) ˜ and ϕ(x) ˜ = ϕ(x). Lemma 2.5. Let f ∈ h∞ and ϕ ∈ S(D). Then ((f ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ= f∗ ◦ ϕ˜ on M (H ∞ ).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
171
Proof. Let z ∈ D. Then we see that ((f ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ(z) = = =
(f ◦ ϕ)(z)
=
f (ϕ(z)) f (ϕ(z)) ˜ ∗ f (ϕ(z)) ˜
=
˜ (f∗ ◦ ϕ)(z).
by Lemma 2.3 by Lemma 2.4 by Lemma 2.3
Hence ((f ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ= f∗ ◦ ϕ˜ on D. By the continuity of functions we are considering, this shows that ((f ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ= f∗ ◦ ϕ˜ on M (H ∞ ).
3. Elementary properties In this section we gather elementary properties concerning the space h∞ and composition operators on h∞ . The following is easy to check. Lemma 3.1. Every uniformly bounded subset of h∞ is a normal family. Using this, we can have a characterization of compactness of composition operators on h∞ . Proposition 3.2. Let ϕ ∈ S(D). Then the following are equivalent: (i) Cϕ is compact on h∞ . (ii) Cϕ is compact on H ∞ . (iii) ϕ∞ < 1. Proof. The implication (i)⇒(ii) is clear, and the equivalence of (ii) and (iii) is well known. Also we can get the implication (iii)⇒(i) by an easy application of Lemma 3.1. The next result is often called the weak convergence theorem, which can be easily proved by a standard argument. Lemma 3.3. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). Then Cϕ − Cψ is compact on h∞ if and only if (Cϕ − Cψ )fn ∞ → 0 for every bounded sequence {fn }n in h∞ which converges to zero uniformly on every compact subset of D. The following is a more concrete characterization of compact difference of two composition operators on h∞ . Proposition 3.4. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ following are equivalent: (i) Cϕ − Cψ is compact on (ii) Cϕ − Cψ is compact on (iii) lim ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) = |ϕ(z)|→1
S(D), ϕ = ψ and ϕ∞ = ψ∞ = 1. Then the h∞ . H ∞. lim ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) = 0.
|ψ(z)|→1
172
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
Proof. The implication (i)⇒(ii) is clear, and the equivalence of (ii) and (iii) is shown in [9, p.1767] (see also Theorem 6 of [5]). We now use Lemma 3.3 to prove the implication (iii)⇒(i). To verify this, we let {fn }n be a sequence in B(h∞ ) such that fn converges to zero uniformly on every compact subset of D. Then 2π dθ |(Cϕ − Cψ )fn (z)| ≤ |fn∗ (eiθ )||Pϕ(z) (eiθ ) − Pψ(z) (eiθ )| 2π 0 ≤ fn∗ ∞ Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 ≤ 2 − (4/π) cos−1 ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z))
by Lemma 2.1.
By the condition (iii), for any ε > 0, there is a number δ, 0 < δ < 1, such that |ϕ(z)| > δ ⇒ ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) < ε and |ψ(z)| > δ ⇒ ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) < ε. Since {fn }n converges to zero uniformly on compact subsets of D, for all n sufficiently large we have |(Cϕ − Cψ )fn (z)| < ε for all z with |ϕ(z)| ≤ δ and |ψ(z)| ≤ δ. Thus (Cϕ − Cψ )fn ∞ < ε for sufficiently large n. Therefore (i) holds by Lemma 3.3. We make a comment on a connection between compact difference and the maximal ideal space M (H ∞ ). For this, we let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D) with ϕ∞ = 1. If Cϕ − Cψ is compact on h∞ , then ψ∞ = 1 and by Proposition 3.4 lim ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) =
|ϕ(z)|→1
lim ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) = 0.
|ψ(z)|→1
By an application of the corona theorem, together with the fact |ϕ(z) − ψ(z)| ≤ 2ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)), one can then easily show that {x ∈ M (H ∞ ) : |ϕ(x)| = 1} = {x ∈ M (H ∞ ) : |ψ(x)| = 1} and ϕ = ψ on {x ∈ M (H ∞ ) : |ϕ(x)| = 1}. We give, with few preliminaries, some observations on the component problem of composition operators on h∞ . For ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D), the operator Cϕ − Cψ has two norms Cϕ − Cψ h∞ and Cϕ − Cψ H ∞ on h∞ and H ∞ , respectively. By Lemmas 2.1 and 2.2, we obtain the following identities of the norm of composition difference: Cϕ − Cψ h∞ = sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 z∈D
and
4 cos−1 ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)) π z∈D The above identities motivate the following definitions: Cϕ − Cψ h∞ = sup
2−
.
(3.1)
λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1
(3.2)
σ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = lim sup ρ(ϕ(z), ψ(z)).
(3.3)
|(ϕψ)(z)|→1
and |(ϕψ)(z)|→1
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
173
The quantity σ∞ (ϕ, ψ) is recently used by Hosokawa and the second author [7] to give upper and lower bounds for the essential norm of composition difference on H ∞ . In this paper, we use the quantity λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) to estimate the essential norm of composition difference on h∞ . We remark that Lemma 2.2 immediately provides a relationship between the quantities λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) and σ∞ (ϕ, ψ). Lemma 3.5. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D) with ϕψ∞ = 1. Then 4 cos−1 σ∞ (ϕ, ψ) , π λ(σ∞ (ϕ, ψ)) ≤ λ∞ (ϕ, ψ), and σ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 1 if and only if λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 2. λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 2 −
We now show that path components are the same in each other in the sets C(H ∞ ) and C(h∞ ) of composition operators on H ∞ and h∞ , respectively. Theorem 3.6. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). Then Cϕ and Cψ are in the same path component of C(H ∞ ) if and only if both are in the same path component of C(h∞ ). Proof. The “only if” part needs proof. Assume that Cϕ and Cψ are in the same path component of C(H ∞ ). Let [0, 1] t → Cϕt denote a continuous arc in C(H ∞ ) joining Cϕ and Cψ , such that Cϕ0 = Cϕ and Cϕ1 = Cψ . Then, given ε > 0, there exists δ > 0 such that Cϕs − Cϕt H ∞ < ε
whenever |s − t| < δ.
By (2.1), Cϕs − Cϕt H ∞
= sup λ(ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z))) z∈D
2ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z)) 1 + 1 − ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z))2 z∈D ≥ sup ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z)),
= sup z∈D
so that sup ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z)) < ε z∈D
if |s − t| < δ.
On the other hand, the formula (3.1) yields 4 cos−1 ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z)) Cϕs − Cϕt h∞ = sup 2 − π z∈D 4 = 2 − cos−1 (sup ρ(ϕs (z), ϕt (z))). π z∈D These observations insure that the map t → Cϕt is also a continuous arc joining Cϕ to Cψ in C(h∞ ). This finishes the proof. The above theorem, combined to Theorem 4.1 in [9], yields the following.
174
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
Corollary 3.7. Let ϕ ∈ S(D). Then the following are equivalent: (i) Cϕ is not isolated in C(h∞ ). (ii) Cϕ is not isolated in C(H ∞ ). 2π (iii) 0 log(1 − |ϕ∗ (eiθ )|)dθ/2π > −∞.
4. Lower bounds for essential norms In this section, we will explore lower bounds for the essential norm of difference of two composition operators on h∞ . Recall that the essential norm of a bounded linear operator T on h∞ is defined as T e = inf{T + K : K is compact on h∞ }. We start with a technical lemma, which follows easily from basic properties of Poisson kernels. Lemma 4.1. Let {zj }j and {wj }j be sequences in D such that zj → α and wj → β and |α| = |β| = 1. Let U be an open subset of ∂D such that {α, β} ⊂ U . Then 2π dθ = 0. χ(∂D\U) |Pzj − Pwj | lim j→∞ 0 2π Consequently, if lim Pzj − Pwj 1 exists, then j→∞
lim
j→∞
0
2π
χU |Pzj − Pwj |
dθ = lim Pzj − Pwj 1 . 2π j→∞
Theorem 4.2. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). If ϕψ∞ = 1, then Cϕ − Cψ e ≥ λ∞ (ϕ, ψ). Proof. The assertion is trivial if λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 0, so we assume that λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) > 0. By the definition of λ∞ (ϕ, ψ), there exists a sequence {zj }j in D such that |zj | → 1, |(ϕψ)(zj )| → 1, and Pϕ(zj ) − Pψ(zj ) 1 → λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) as j → ∞. We may assume that ϕ(zj ) = ψ(zj ) for every j, ϕ(zj ) → α, |α| = 1, and ψ(zj ) → β, |β| = 1. We now use induction to show that we can obtain a subsequence {zjn }n of {zj }j and a sequence of open subsets {Un }n of the unit circle ∂D satisfying the following conditions: {α, β} ⊂ Un+1 ⊂ Un ,
2π
0
and
2π
χUn |Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) |
dθ 1 > λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ), 2π n
(4.1) (4.2)
dθ 1 > λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ) (4.3) 2π n 0 for every n. It is clear that (4.2) is implied by (4.3), but we added the condition (4.2) here to understand the argument below more clearly. χ(Un \Un+1 ) |Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) |
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
175
Let U1 = ∂D and j1 = 1. Since ϕ(zj1 ) = ψ(zj1 ),
2π
0
χU1 |Pϕ(zj1 ) − Pψ(zj1 ) |
dθ 1 > 0 = λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ). 2π 1
We can take an open subset U2 of ∂D such that {α, β} ⊂ U2 ⊂ U1 and
2π 0
χU1 \U2 |Pϕ(zj1 ) − Pψ(zj1 ) |
dθ 1 > λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ). 2π 1
Let N be an integer greater than 1. We assume that {zjn }1≤n≤N and {Un }1≤n≤N satisfy the conditions (4.1)–(4.3). Then by (4.2) for n = N , we get
2π
0
χUN |Pϕ(zjN ) − Pψ(zjN ) |
dθ 1 > λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ). 2π N
Also, by (4.1) and (4.3) for n = N , there is an open subset UN +1 of ∂D such that {α, β} ⊂ UN +1 ⊂ UN and
2π
0
χ(UN \UN +1 ) |Pϕ(zjN ) − Pψ(zjN ) |
dθ 1 > λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ). 2π N
By Lemma 4.1, 0
2π
χUN +1 |Pϕ(zj ) − Pψ(zj ) |
dθ → λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) 2π
as j → ∞. Hence there exists a positive integer jN +1 such that 0
2π
χUN +1 |Pϕ(zjN +1 ) − Pψ(zjN +1 ) |
dθ 1 > λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)(1 − ). 2π N +1
This completes the induction. For each positive integer n, there exists a function gn in L∞ (∂D) with gn (Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) ) = |Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) |
(4.4)
a.e. on ∂D. Note that |gn | = 1 a.e. on ∂D. Now we define the new functions hn by hn = gn χ(Un \Un+1 ) .
(4.5)
It is then clear that hn ∞ = 1 and hn → 0 weakly in L∞ (∂D), and hence ˆ n → 0 weakly in h∞ . Now let K be an arbitrary compact operator on h∞ . Then h
176
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
ˆ n ∞ → 0. Therefore K h ˆ n ∞ Cϕ − Cψ + K ≥ lim sup (Cϕ − Cψ + K)h n→∞
ˆ n ∞ = lim sup (Cϕ − Cψ )h n→∞
ˆ n (ϕ(zj )) − h ˆ n (ψ(zj ))| ≥ lim sup |h n n n→∞ 2π dθ hn (Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) ) = lim sup 2π n→∞ 0 2π dθ = lim sup χ(Un \Un+1 ) |Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) | 2π n→∞ 0 ≥ λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) by (4.3), where the last equality follows from (4.4) and (4.5). This shows that Cϕ − Cψ e ≥ λ∞ (ϕ, ψ). Theorem 4.3. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). If there is a sequence {zj } in D such that |ϕ(zj )| → 1 and lim sup|ψ(zj )| < 1, then Cϕ − Cψ e ≥ 1. j→∞
Proof. The idea of the proof is the same as the one of Theorem 4.2, so we give only its outline. By our assumption, there exists a sequence {zj }j in D such that ϕ(zj ) → α with |α| = 1 and ψ(zj ) → β with |β| < 1. Then by Lemma 4.1, there exists a sequence of open subsets {Ui }i of ∂D such that α ∈ Ui+1 ⊂ Ui , 2π dθ → 1 as j → ∞ for each i, χUi Pϕ(zj ) 2π 0
2π
χ∂D\Ui Pϕ(zj )
0
and
0
2π
χUi Pψ(zj )
dθ → 0 as j → ∞ for each i, 2π
dθ → 0 as i → ∞ for each j. 2π
By considering subsequences {zjn }n of {zj }j and {Uin }n of {Ui }i , we may assume that 2π dθ → 1, (4.6) χ(Uin \Uin+1 ) Pϕ(zjn ) 2π 0 and
0
2π
χ(Uin \Uin+1 ) Pψ(zjn )
dθ → 0, 2π
as n → ∞. Also, there is a sequence {gn } in L∞ (∂D) satisfying gn (Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) ) = |Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) |
(4.7)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
177
ˆ n → 0 weakly in h∞ . Thus, for any a.e. on ∂D. Let hn = gn χ(Uin \Uin+1 ) . Then h compact operator K on h∞ , we have ˆ n ∞ Cϕ − Cψ + K ≥ lim sup (Cϕ − Cψ + K)h n→∞ 2π dθ ≥ lim sup χ(Uin \Uin+1 ) |Pϕ(zjn ) − Pψ(zjn ) | 2π n→∞ 0 =1 by (4.6) and (4.7). This proves Cϕ − Cψ e ≥ 1.
5. Upper bounds for essential norms For g ∈ L∞ (∂D), we define a bounded linear operator Mg on h∞ as 2π dθ (Mg f )(z) = g(eiθ )f ∗ (eiθ )Pz (eiθ ) 2π 0 for f ∈ h∞ and z ∈ D, that is, Mg f is the harmonic extension of gf ∗ into D. If we identify a function f in h∞ with its boundary function f ∗ in L∞ (∂D), the operator Mg is just a multiplication operator on L∞ (∂D). For ϕ ∈ S(D), we define EL∞ (|ϕ|) = {x ∈ M (L∞ ) : |ϕ(x)| = 1}. For each x ∈ M (H ∞ ), we recall that there exists a unique probability measure µx on M (L∞ ) satisfying f (x) = f dµx M(L∞ )
for every f ∈ H ∞ . We denote by supp µx the closed support set of µx . For a subset E of M (H ∞ ), we denote by E the closure of E in M (H ∞ ). Theorem 5.1. Let ϕ ∈ S(D) and g ∈ L∞ (∂D). Then the following conditions are equivalent: (i) Mg Cϕ is a compact operator on h∞ . (ii) lim gˆ(z) = 0. |ϕ(z)|→1
(iii) g = 0 on EL∞ (|ϕ|). Proof. We write K = Mg Cϕ for notational simplicity. At first we show the implication (i)⇒(ii). We shall prove this by a contradiction argument. Assume that there is a sequence {zk }k in D satisfying |ϕ(zk )| → 1 and gˆ(zk ) → c = 0. Further we may assume that ϕ(zk ) → a ∈ ∂D. Let fn (z) =
(z + a)n . (2a)n
Then fn ∈ H ∞ ⊂ h∞ , fn ∞ = 1, fn (a) = 1, and fn → 0 uniformly on every compact subset of D. Let ζ be a cluster point of {zk }k in M (H ∞ ), and choose a
178
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
net {zkα }α in {zk }k with zkα → ζ. Then kα → ∞, gˆ(ζ) = c, and by (2.3) and Lemma 2.4, (fn ◦ ϕ)(ζ) = fn (ϕ(ζ)) ˜ = lim fn (ϕ(zkα )) = fn (a) = 1. kα →∞
This shows
M(L∞ )
(fn ◦ ϕ)(ξ)dµζ (ξ) = 1.
Using fn ◦ ϕ∞ ≤ 1, we obtain fn ◦ ϕ = 1
on supp µζ .
∞
∗
(5.1) ∞
Since fn ◦ ϕ ∈ H , we note that fn ◦ ϕ = (fn ◦ ϕ) on M (L ). Hence Kfn ∞
≥ |((Kfn )∗ )ˆ(ζ)| = g(ξ)(fn ◦ ϕ)(ξ)dµζ (ξ) M(L∞ ) = g(ξ)dµζ (ξ) by (5.1)
by (2.2)
M(L∞ )
= |ˆ g (ζ)| = |c|. Thus Kfn ∞ ≥ |c| > 0 for every n. On the other hand, since K is compact, there exists a subsequence {fm }m of {fn }n satisfying Kfm −f ∞ → 0 for some f ∈ h∞ . Note that (ϕ∗ +a)m /(2a)m → 0 a.e. on ∂D. Hence, for each z ∈ D, we have by the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem 2π g(eiθ )(fm ◦ ϕ)∗ (eiθ )Pz (eiθ )dθ/2π (Kfm )(z) = 0
= → 0
0
2π
g(eiθ )(ϕ∗ (eiθ ) + a)m /(2a)m Pz (eiθ )dθ/2π as m → ∞.
As a consequence, we get f = 0 and Kfm ∞ → 0. This is a contradiction. Secondly we shall also prove the implication (ii)⇒(iii) by contradiction. Assume that g ≡ 0 on EL∞ (|ϕ|), and choose a y ∈ M (L∞ ) satisfying |ϕ(y)| = 1 and g(y) = 0. By the corona theorem, there is a net {zα }α in D with zα → y. We then see that ϕ(zα ) → ϕ(y) and gˆ(zα ) → gˆ(y) = g(y). This contradicts (ii). Lastly we show the implication (iii)⇒(i). Suppose that g = 0 on EL∞ (|ϕ|). To prove that K is compact on h∞ , suppose {fj }j is a sequence of functions in B(h∞ ) such that fj → 0 uniformly on each compact subset of D. It suffices to show that Kfj ∞ → 0 as j → ∞. If EL∞ (|ϕ|) = M (L∞ ), then g = 0, so that Mg Cϕ = 0. Hence we may assume that EL∞ (|ϕ|) = M (L∞ ). Let x ∈ M (L∞ ) with |ϕ(x)| < 1. Then by Lemmas 2.3–2.5, ((fj ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ(x) = fj (ϕ(x)) for every j. Hence ((fj ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ(x) → 0 as j → ∞. This, combined with the fact that ((fj ◦ ϕ)∗ )ˆ = (fj ◦ ϕ)∗ on M (L∞ ), shows that (fj ◦ ϕ)∗ converges uniformly to zero on every
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
179
compact subset of M (L∞ ) \ EL∞ (|ϕ|). Now using g = 0 on EL∞ (|ϕ|), it is not difficult to show that Kfj ∞ = g(fj ◦ ϕ)∗ ∞ → 0 as j → ∞, which is what we wanted.
In the rest of this section, we will write f U = sup |f (ζ)| ζ∈U
∞
whenever f ∈ L (∂D) and U is a subset of M (L∞ ). We now turn to the upper estimate of Cϕ −Cψ e . We first handle a relatively easy case. Theorem 5.2. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). If ϕψ∞ < 1, then Cϕ − Cψ e ≤ 1. Proof. If ϕ∞ < 1 or ψ∞ < 1, the assertion is immediate from Proposition 3.2. Hence we may assume that ϕ∞ = ψ∞ = 1. Also, noting that EL∞ (|ϕ|) ∩ EL∞ (|ψ|) = ∅ since ϕψ∞ < 1, we can take open and closed subsets Uϕ and Uψ of M (L∞ ) such that EL∞ (|ϕ|) ⊂ Uϕ ,
EL∞ (|ψ|) ⊂ Uψ ,
and (5.2) Uϕ ∩ Uψ = ∅. Here we used the well-known fact (e.g., see [6, p. 170]) that M (L∞ ) is extremely disconnected, that is, the closure of every open subset of M (L∞ ) is also open. By Theorem 5.1, Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uϕ ) Cϕ − Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uψ ) Cψ
is compact. So, for any f ∈ B(h∞ ), we have
(Cϕ − Cψ − Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uϕ ) Cϕ + Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uψ ) Cψ )f ∞ =
(I − Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uϕ ) )Cϕ f − (I − Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uψ ) )Cψ f ∞
=
MχUϕ Cϕ f − MχUψ Cψ f ∞
≤
max{(f ◦ ϕ)∗ Uϕ , (f ◦ ψ)∗ Uψ }
≤
1,
by (5.2)
where I is the identity operator. This proves Cϕ − Cψ e ≤ 1.
Next, we prove the following. Theorem 5.3. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D) with ϕψ∞ = 1. Then we have the following: (i) If EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = EL∞ (|ϕ|), then Cϕ − Cψ e ≤ max {1, λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)}. (ii) If EL∞ (|ϕ|) = EL∞ (|ψ|), then Cϕ − Cψ e ≤ λ∞ (ϕ, ψ). To prove this, we need some lemmas. Lemma 5.4. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D) with ϕψ∞ = 1. If EL∞ (|ϕψ|) is not an open and closed subset of EL∞ (|ϕ|), then λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 2.
180
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
Proof. Note that EL∞ (|ϕψ|) is a closed Gδ -subset of M (L∞ ). By our assumption, we can choose a sequence {xn }n in EL∞ (|ϕ|) \ EL∞ (|ϕψ|) satisfying {xn }n \ {xn }n ⊂ EL∞ (|ϕψ|). Then |ψ(xn )| < 1 and |ψ(xn )| → 1 as n → ∞. For each xn , there exists a net {zn,α }α in D satisfying zn,α → xn as α → ∞. Hence |ϕ(zn,α )| → 1 and |ψ(zn,α )| → |ψ(xn )| < 1, and so Pϕ(zn,α) − Pψ(zn,α ) 1 → 2 as α → ∞. It follows that for each n, there exists αn such that |ϕ(zn,αn )| > 1 − 1/n,
|ψ(zn,αn )| > |ψ(xn )| − 1/n,
and Pϕ(zn,αn ) − Pψ(zn,αn ) 1 > 2 − 1/n. These show that |ϕ(zn,αn )| → 1, |ψ(zn,αn )| → 1, and Pϕ(zn,αn ) − Pψ(zn,αn ) 1 → 2.
Therefore, by (3.2) we get λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 2.
Lemma 5.5. Let f ∈ h∞ and U be an open and closed subset of M (L∞ ). Then f ∗ U = lim sup |f (z)|. χ ˆU (z)→1
Proof. Let f and U be as in the hypothesis, and let x ∈ U . By the corona theorem there is a net {zα }α in D such that zα → x in M (H ∞ ). Noting that f∗ = f ∗ on M (L∞ ), we then have f (zα ) = f∗ (zα ) → f∗ (x) = f ∗ (x). Meanwhile, using the fact that a set is open and closed if and only if its characteristic function is continuous, we get ˆU (x) = χU (x) = 1. χ ˆU (zα ) → χ Combining these yields
f ∗ U ≤ lim sup |f (z)|. χ ˆU (z)→1
ˆU (zn ) → To obtain the reverse inequality, we take a sequence {zn }n in D satisfying χ 1 and f (zn ) → a. Let ζ be a cluster point of {zn }n in M (H ∞ ). Then χ ˆU (ζ) = 1 and f∗ (ζ) = a. Since f ∗ dµζ , a = f∗ (ζ) = M(L∞ )
∗
we get |a| ≤ f supp µζ . Since 1=χ ˆU (ζ) =
M(L∞ )
χU dµζ ,
we must have supp µζ ⊂ U . Hence |a| ≤ f ∗ U , so that lim sup |f (z)| ≤ f ∗ U .
χ ˆU (z)→1
Therefore the lemma follows.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
181
Lemma 5.6. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D) with ϕψ∞ = 1, and let U be the family of open and closed subsets U of M (L∞ ) with EL∞ (|ϕψ|) ⊂ U . Then λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = inf lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 . U∈U χ ˆU (z)→1
Proof. Let U ∈ U. By (3.2), λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 ,
(5.3)
|(ϕψ)(z)|→1
so we can choose a sequence {zn }n in D such that |(ϕψ)(zn )| → 1 and Pϕ(zn ) − Pψ(zn ) 1 → λ∞ (ϕ, ψ).
(5.4)
Let ζ be a cluster point of {zn }n in M (H ∞ ). Then |(ϕψ)(ζ)| = 1 and 1= ϕψ dµζ ≤ |ϕψ| dµζ ≤ 1, M(L∞ )
M(L∞ )
so that supp µζ ⊂ EL∞ (|ϕψ|) ⊂ U . Hence χ ˆU (ζ) = 1. This implies that χ ˆU (zn ) → 1. Therefore, it follows from (5.4) that λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) ≤ inf lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 . U∈U χ ˆU (z)→1
(5.5)
If λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 2, this inequality yields the desired assertion. So we assume that λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) < 2, and we prove the reverse inequality of (5.5). Fix a point ζ in M (H ∞ ) \ D and choose a net {zα }α in D with zα → ζ. Since EL∞ (|ϕψ|) is a closed Gδ -subset of M (L∞ ), there exists a function F in L∞ (∂D) such that F = 1 on EL∞ (|ϕψ|)
and 0 < F < 1 on M (L∞ ) \ EL∞ (|ϕψ|).
If Fˆ (zα ) → 1, then Fˆ (ζ) = 1 and supp µζ ⊂ EL∞ (|ϕψ|). Since λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) < 2, we have σ∞ (ϕ, ψ) < 1 by Lemma 3.5. This shows that ϕ = ψ on EL∞ (|ϕψ|). For, if ϕ(x) = ψ(x) for some x ∈ EL∞ (|ϕψ|), there exists a net {wα }α in D satisfying wα → x, and then ρ(ϕ(wα ), ψ(wα )) → 1. This contradicts σ∞ (ϕ, ψ) < 1. Since supp µζ ⊂ EL∞ (|ϕψ|), ϕ(ζ) = ψ(ζ). If |ϕ(ζ)| < 1, then we have Pϕ(zα ) − Pψ(zα ) 1 → 0. Accordingly, by recalling (5.3), we get lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 ≤ lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 = λ∞ (ϕ, ψ). Fˆ (z)→1
(5.6)
|(ϕψ)(z)|→1
∞ Since EL∞ (|ϕψ|) is a Gδ -subset ∞ of M (L ), there is a sequence of open and closed subsets {Un }n in U with n=1 Un = EL∞ (|ϕψ|). Here we shall prove that Fˆ (zα ) → 1 if and only if χ ˆUn (zα ) → 1 as α → ∞ for each n. To show this, suppose that Fˆ (zα ) → 1. Then Fˆ (ζ) = 1, so that supp µζ ⊂ EL∞ (|ϕψ|) ⊂ Un . Hence χ ˆUn (ζ) = 1. This implies that χ ˆUn (zα ) → 1 as α → ∞. Suppose that Fˆ (zα ) → 1. Then 0 < Fˆ (ζ) < 1, so that supp µζ ⊂ EL∞ (|ϕψ|). It follows that
182
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
there exists a positive integer n with supp µζ ⊂ Un . Hence χ ˆUn (ζ) < 1, so that χ ˆUn (zα ) → χ ˆUn (ζ) = 1 as α → ∞. Thus we get lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 = inf lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 . n χ ˆUn (z)→1
Fˆ (z)→1
Therefore, we have by (5.6) inf lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 ≤ λ∞ (ϕ, ψ).
U∈U χ ˆU (z)→1
This, combined with (5.5), proves our assertion.
Proof of Theorem 5.3. If λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) = 2, each assertion is trivial, so we assume that λ∞ (ϕ, ψ) < 2. Then by Lemma 5.4, EL∞ (|ϕψ|) is an open and closed subset of EL∞ (|ϕ|) and EL∞ (|ψ|), respectively. (i) Suppose that EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = EL∞ (|ϕ|). Then there exist open and closed subsets Uϕ and Uψ of M (L∞ ) such that
(5.7) EL∞ (|ϕ|) ⊂ Uϕ , Uϕ ∩ EL∞ (|ψ|) \ EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = ∅, and
EL∞ (|ψ|) ⊂ Uψ , Uψ ∩ EL∞ (|ϕ|) \ EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = ∅. (5.8) By Theorem 5.1, both Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uϕ ) Cϕ and Mχ(M (L∞ )\Uψ ) Cψ are compact. Write U = Uϕ ∩Uψ . Then, as in the proof of Theorem 5.2, we find that for any f ∈ B(h∞ ),
Cϕ − Cψ − Mχ Cϕ + Mχ Cψ f ∞ ∞ (M (L
)\Uϕ )
(M (L
)\Uψ )
∞
≤ MχUϕ Cϕ f − MχUψ Cψ f ∞ = χUϕ (f ◦ ϕ)∗ − χUψ (f ◦ ψ)∗ L∞ (∂D)
≤ max 1, (f ◦ ϕ)∗ − (f ◦ ψ)∗ U = max 1, lim sup |f (ϕ(z)) − f (ψ(z))|
by Lemma 5.5
χ ˆU (z)→1
≤ max
1, lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 . χ ˆU (z)→1
Hence Cϕ − Cψ e ≤ max
1, lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 .
(5.9)
χ ˆU (z)→1
This holds for U = Uϕ ∩ Uψ for every Uϕ and Uψ satisfying (5.7) and (5.8). Therefore (5.9) holds as well for every open and closed subset U ∈ U, where U is the family of open and closed subsets of M (L∞ ) containing EL∞ (|ϕψ|). The estimate (i) follows now from Lemma 5.6. (ii) Suppose that EL∞ (|ϕ|) = EL∞ (|ψ|) (and hence EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = EL∞ (|ϕ|)). In this case, using the same reasoning as done in the proof of (i), both operators Mχ(M (L∞ )\U ) Cϕ are shown to be compact and Cϕ − Cψ − Mχ
and Mχ(M (L∞ )\U ) Cψ
(M (L∞ )\U )
Cϕ + Mχ(M (L∞ )\U ) Cψ f ∞
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
183
≤ lim sup Pϕ(z) − Pψ(z) 1 χ ˆU (z)→1
for every U ∈ U, provided f ∈ B(h∞ ). Therefore the estimate (ii) also follows from Lemma 5.6.
6. The main theorem Combining the estimates given in Sections 4 and 5, we obtain the following complete characterization of Cϕ − Cψ e on h∞ . Theorem 6.1. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ S(D). (i) If max{ϕ∞ , ψ∞ } < 1, then Cϕ − Cψ e = 0. (ii) If max {ϕ∞ , ψ∞ } = 1 and ϕψ∞ < 1, then Cϕ − Cψ e = 1. (iii) If ϕψ∞ = 1 and EL∞ (|ϕ|) = EL∞ (|ψ|), then Cϕ − Cψ e = λ∞ (ϕ, ψ). (iv) If ϕψ∞ = 1 and EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = EL∞ (|ϕ|), then Cϕ − Cψ e = max{1, λ∞ (ϕ, ψ)}. Proof. (i) follows from Proposition 3.2. (ii) follows from Theorems 4.3 and 5.2. (iii) follows from Theorems 4.2 and 5.3(ii). (iv) follows from Theorems 4.2, 4.3 and 5.3(i).
Remark. The case (iv) above actually covers the case EL∞ (|ψ|) = EL∞ (|ϕ|) (with ϕψ∞ = 1); for the latter case can only happen if EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = EL∞ (|ϕ|)
or EL∞ (|ϕψ|) = EL∞ (|ψ|).
We here present some examples concerning (iii) and (iv) of Theorem 6.1. Example 6.2. This example comes from [9, pp. 1770–1771]. Let ϕ ∈ B(H ∞ ) be such that ϕ∞ = 1, and that 2π dθ > −∞. log(1 − |ϕ(eiθ )|) 2π 0 There exists an outer function ω ∈ H ∞ such that |ω| = 1 − |ϕ| a.e. on ∂D, see [6]. Let t be a number with 0 < t < 1. There exists a sequence {zn }n in D satisfying 1≤
1 − |ϕ(zn )| 1 < |ω(zn )| t
and |ϕ(zn )| → 1.
We may assume that 1 − |ϕ(zn )| → Reiθ1 , ω(zn )
1≤R≤
1 t
and ϕ(zn ) → eiθ2 .
Letting θ3 = θ1 + θ2
and ψt (z) = ϕ(z) + teiθ3 ω(z),
184
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
IEOT
we have ϕψt ∞ = 1 and EL∞ (|ϕ|) = EL∞ (|ψt |). By [9, p. 1771], we also have
t ≤t<1 ρ ϕ(z), ψt (z) ≤ 1 + |ϕ(z)| − |tϕ(z)| and
ρ ϕ(zn ), ψt (zn ) ≥
t2 . 2 − t2
By (3.3), it follows that t2 ≤ σ∞ (ϕ, ψt ) ≤ t < 1 2 − t2 which, by Lemma 3.5, yields 2
t 4 cos−1 2−t 4 cos−1 t 2 2− ≤ λ∞ (ϕ, ψt ) ≤ 2 − . π π Therefore, we obtain by Theorem 6.1(iii)
2−
4 cos−1 π
t2 2−t2
≤ Cϕ − Cψt e = λ∞ (ϕ, ψt ) ≤ 2 −
4 cos−1 t . π
Example 6.3. Let Ω be the simply connected domain defined by
Ω = D ∩ z = x + iy : y < (x − 1)2 and y > −(x − 1)2 which has a cusp at the point 1. Consider a Riemann map ψ from D onto Ω, with ψ(1) = 1. Clearly ψ ∈ B(H ∞ ). For each t > 0, define ϕt ∈ B(H ∞ ) by ϕt (z) =
ψ(z) + t . 1+t
Then ϕt ψ∞ = 1, EL∞ (|ϕt |) EL∞ (|ψ|), and ψ = ϕt on EL∞ (|ϕt |). Also, we have (ϕt ψ)(z) → 1 if and only if z → 1. A manipulation shows
ϕt (z) − ψ(z) t . (6.1) ρ ϕt (z), ψ(z) = = 1−ψ(z) 1 − ψ(z)ϕt (z) 1 + t + ψ(z) 1−ψ(z)
From the definitions of Ω and ψ, we can see that lim ψ(z)
(6.2)
z→1
1 − ψ(z) = 1. 1 − ψ(z)
Combining (6.1), (6.2) and (3.3), we get
σ∞ (ϕt , ψ) = lim ρ ϕt (z), ψ(z) =
t 2+t
z→1
which, by Lemma 3.5, gives λ∞ (ϕt , ψ) = 2 −
4 cos−1 π
t 2+t
.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Composition Operators
185
√ Note that λ∞ (ϕt , ψ) ≥ 1 if and only if t ≥ 2/( 2 − 1). Therefore, we finally use Theorem 6.1(iv) to conclude that √ Cϕt − Cψ e = 1 if and only if 0 < t ≤ 2/( 2 − 1) and Cϕt − Cψ e = 2 − √ for t ≥ 2/( 2 − 1).
4 cos−1
t 2+t
π
Acknowledgments The first and the third authors thank Professor K. J. Izuchi for his hospitality while they visited Department of Mathematics, Niigata University, where the work for part of this paper was done.
References [1] L. Carleson, Interpolation by bounded analytic functions and the corona problem, Ann. of Math. 76 (1962), 547–559. [2] C.C. Cowen and B.D. MacCluer, Composition Operators on Spaces of Analytic Functions, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1995. [3] T.W. Gamelin, Uniform Algebras, Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1969. [4] J.B. Garnett, Bounded Analytic Functions, Academic Press, New York, 1981. [5] P. Gorkin, R. Mortini and D. Su´ arez, Homotopic composition operators on H ∞ (B n ), Contemp. Math. 328 (2003), 177–188. [6] K. Hoffman, Banach Spaces of Analytic Functions, Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1962. [7] T. Hosokawa and K. Izuchi, Essential norms of differences of composition operators on H ∞ , J. Math. Soc. Japan 57 (2005), 669–690. [8] T. Hosokawa, K. Izuchi and S. Ohno, Topological structure of the space of weighted composition operators on H ∞ , Integral Equations Operator Theory 53 (2005), 509– 526. [9] T. Hosokawa, K. Izuchi and D. Zheng, Isolated points and essential components of composition operators on H ∞ , Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 130 (2002), 1765–1773. [10] B.D. MacCluer, S. Ohno and R. Zhao, Topological structure of the space of composition operators on H ∞ , Integral Equations Operator Theory 40 (2001), 481–494. [11] J.H. Shapiro, Composition Operators and Classical Function Theory, SpringerVerlag, New York, 1993. [12] L. Zheng, The essential norms and spectra of composition operators on H ∞ , Pacific J. Math. 203 (2002), 503–510. [13] K. Zhu, Operator Theory in Function Spaces, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1990.
186
Choa, Izuchi and Ohno
Jun Soo Choa Department of Mathematics Education Sungkyunkwan University Jongro-gu, Seoul 110-745 Korea e-mail:
[email protected] Kei Ji Izuchi Department of Mathematics Niigata University Niigata 950-2181 Japan e-mail:
[email protected] Shˆ uichi Ohno Nippon Institute of Technology Miyashiro, Minami-Saitama 345-8501 Japan e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: January 22, 2007 Revised: February 25, 2008
IEOT
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 187–210 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020187-24, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1586-5
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Transitive Spaces of Operators Kenneth R. Davidson, Laurent W. Marcoux and Heydar Radjavi Abstract. We investigate algebraic and topological transitivity and, more generally, k-transitivity for linear spaces of operators. In finite dimensions, we determine minimal dimensions of k-transitive spaces for every k, and find relations between the degree of transitivity of a product or tensor product on the one hand and those of the factors on the other. We present counterexamples to some natural conjectures. Some infinite dimensional analogues are discussed. A simple proof is given of Arveson’s result on the weak-operator density of transitive spaces that are masa bimodules. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 15A04, 47A15, 47A16, 47L05. Keywords. Transitive subspace, k-transitive, k-separating.
A collection E of operators from a vector space X to another vector space Y is said to be transitive if, given nonzero x ∈ X and y ∈ Y, there is an element A ∈ E such that Ax = y. If E has some additional structure imposed on it, for example, if it is a ring or an algebra with X = Y, then a great deal is implied by the transitivity assumption. This paper represents an effort to extract as much information as possible from transitivity (and its strengthening given below) from the linear structure on E alone. This paper could well have been written twenty years ago. Indeed, it is in the spirit of Azoff’s paper [2] which explores transitive, reflexive, and elementary spaces and the relations between these properties. When we examine infinite dimensional analogues, the Toeplitz operators are a natural source of examples. The paper of Azoff and Ptak [3] contains some related results about the space of Toeplitz operators. Let H and K be Hilbert spaces. A subspace L of B(H, K) is k-transitive provided that for every choice of k linearly independent vectors x1 , . . . , xk in H and arbitrary vectors y1 , . . . , yk in K, there is an A ∈ M so that Axi = yi for 1 ≤ i ≤ k. Thus transitivity coincides with 1- transitivity. L is topologically ktransitive if this can be done approximately; that is, for each ε > 0 there exists A ∈ L such that Axi − yi < ε, 1 ≤ i ≤ k. In the finite dimensional setting, Authors partially supported by NSERC grants.
188
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
the two notions coincide. As with transitivity, if k = 1, we shall abbreviate the notation and refer to a space as being topologically transitive. Starting with finite dimensions, we present a number of positive results and a lot of counterexamples to natural conjectures. Among other things, we determine the minimal dimension of k-transitive subspaces of B(H, K) in terms of the dimensions of H and K. We consider spans of products as well as tensor products of spaces, and study the relations between their degree of transitivity and those of their constituent spaces. We investigate the relations between the minimal and maximal ranks present in a transitive subspace of Mn . In particular, we show that such a subspace must contain invertible elements. In the infinite dimensional setting, there are fewer positive results and more counterexamples. We are able to extend some of the finite dimensional results. We provide a simple proof of a result of Arveson [1] that a topologically transitive subspace of B(H, K) which is a masa bimodule is wot-dense in B(H, K). Any transitive subalgebra of Mn = B(Hn ), the space of n × n complex matrices, is equal to all of Mn by Burnside’s Theorem. The situation is completely different for subspaces. For every 0 ≤ k < min{m, n}, there are k- transitive subspaces of Mmn which are not (k + 1)-transitive (see Example 1.4). In infinite dimensions, a topologically transitive operator algebra has no proper invariant subspaces. Whether it is wot-dense in B(H) is the famous Transitive Algebra Problem, a generalization of the Invariant Subspace Problem. Again, if we consider subspaces, there are many proper k-transitive wot-closed subspaces. It is a well-known result of Azoff [2] that a subspace L of Mmn = B(Hn , Hm ) is k-transitive if and only if the pre-annihilator L⊥ contains no non-zero elements of rank at most k. Here (Mmn )∗ is identified with Mnm equipped with the trace norm via the bilinear pairing A, T = Tr(AT ). k ∗ Indeed suppose that 0 = T = i=1 xi yi belongs to L⊥ , where the vectors xi are linearly independent. Then the k-tuple (Ax1 , . . . , Axk ) is orthogonal to (y1 , . . . , yk ) for all A ∈ L. Thus L is not k-transitive. Conversely, if L is not k-transitive, then for some linearly independent set x1 , . . . , xn , the k-tuples k (Ax1 , . . . , Axk ) span a proper subspace of Hm , and thus is orthogonal to a non-zero k vector (y1 , . . . , yk ). Reversing the argument shows that T = i=1 xi yi∗ belongs to L⊥ . In the infinite-dimensional setting, we identify (B(H, K))∗ with the space C1 (K, H) of trace class operators from K to H via the same bilinear pairing. The above Theorem of Azoff then applies to topological k-transitivity, and shows that a subspace L of B(H, K) is topologically k-transitive if and only if the pre-annihilator L⊥ of L contains no non-zero elements of rank less than or equal to k. We end this introduction with a simple but handy observation which will be used implicitly throughout this paper, namely: if L ⊆ B(H, K) is topologically k-transitive, and if P ∈ B(H) and Q ∈ B(K) are projections which satisfy min(rank P, rank Q) ≥ k, then QLP ⊆ B(P H, QK) is also topologically
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
189
k-transitive. (This follows immediately from Azoff’s Theorem.) If, furthermore, P and Q are finite rank, then QLP is in fact k-transitive. We are indebted to the referee for providing us with a number of very useful references and helpful comments – in particular, the argument of Theorem 2.4.
1. Dimension In this section, we find the minimal dimension of a k-transitive subspace of Mmn . By Azoff’s Theorem as outlined above, if k ≥ min(m, n), then L⊥ = 0 and hence L = Mmn . As such, we always assume that k < min(m, n). Lemma 1.1. For every p ≥ 1 and every 0 ≤ k ≤ p, the diagonal subalgebra Dp of Mp contains a subspace of dimension p − k containing no non-zero element of rank at most k. Proof. It suffices to choose p − k diagonal operators with the property that when restricted to any p − k diagonal entries, they are linearly independent. For then a linear combination which has p − k zeros must be zero. An example of such a sequence is Dj = diag(1j , 2j , . . . , pj ) for 0 ≤ j < p − k. The special case of the following result for k = 1 was established by Azoff [2]. Theorem 1.2. The minimal dimension of a k-transitive subspace of Mmn is k(m + n − k). Proof. Using Azoff’s Theorem, we search instead for the maximal dimension of the pre-annihilator of a k-transitive subspace L. This subspace L⊥ cannot intersect the closed variety Rk of matrices of rank at most k except in {0}. This variety has dimension k(m+n−k) (see [7, Prop. 12.2]). It follows that dim L⊥ +dim Rk ≤ mn. Hence dim L ≥ dim Rk = k(m + n − k). On the other hand, consider the subspace N of Mnm which has zeros on diagonals of length p ≤ k and has dimension p − k on the diagonals with p > k entries such that the rank of any non-zero element on one such diagonal is always at least k + 1. This is possible by Lemma 1.1. There are m + n − 1 diagonals, and 2k of them have length at most k. So the dimension of N is mn − (m+n−1−2k)k − 2
k
p = mn − (m+n−1−2k)k − (k+1)k
p=1
= mn − k(m + n − k) Thus L = N ⊥ , the annihilator of N , has dimension k(m + n − k). Consider a non-zero element N of N . It must be non-zero on some diagonal. Let p0 be the shortest non-zero diagonal. Consider the square submatrix containing the p0 th diagonal as its main diagonal. This submatrix is triangular, and hence its rank is at least as great as the rank of the diagonal, which is at least k+1. Hence N contains no non-zero elements of rank at most k. Therefore L is k-transitive.
190
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
Example 1.3. By the above theorem, any proper (n − 1)-transitive subspace L of Mn necessarily has dimension n2 − 1. It is then not hard to see that we can find invertible elements S, T ∈ Mn so that SLT = sln , the space of trace zero matrices in Mn . Since multiplying a k-transitive subspace M of B(H, K) by invertibles S ∈ B(K, K ) and T ∈ B(H , H) yields a k-transitive subspace of B(H , K ), we shall think of M and SMT as being equivalent insofar as transitivity is concerned. A similar statement holds for topologically k-transitive spaces. Example 1.4. As mentioned in the introduction, there are k-transitive subspaces of B(H, K) which are not (k + 1)-transitive provided that k < min{dim H, dim K}. For example, if H = Hn and K = Hm , then it suffices to consider R ∈ Mnm of rank k + 1. With M = span{R}, L = M⊥ ⊆ Mmn is such an example. This example can easily be adapted to the infinite-dimensional setting to produce subspaces L ⊆ B(H, K) which are topologically k-transitive but not topologically (k + 1)-transitive. Example As shown in Example 3.4 of [2], the space Tn of all Toeplitz matrices 1.5. T = ti−j in Mn is a transitive subspace of dimension 2n − 1. It is routine to verify that the pre-annihilator of Tn consists of those matrices in Mn whose entries along any diagonal sum to zero. The rank of such a matrix is at least as big as the length of the smallest non-zero diagonal, which is at least two if the matrix is non-zero. By Theorem 1.2, this is the minimal possible dimension of a transitive subspace of Mn . As pointed out by the referee, there are a number of other papers which investigate the relationship between the dimension of a linear subspace S of matrices and the ranks of its members. For example, H. Flanders [6] has shon that if S ⊆ Mn is a linear space and the rank of every element of S is at most k, then dim S ≤ kn, and he classified those spaces S of maximal dimension. More recently, R. Meshuˇ lam and P. Semrl [8] have shown that if min {rankS : 0 = S ∈ S} > dim S, then S is reflexive as a space of operators. In other words, S⊥ is spanned by its rank one elements.
2. Dually Transitive In finite dimensions, we can consider both L and L⊥ as spaces of matrices. So we can ask whether both can be k-transitive. Dimension arguments show that this requires the space to be sufficiently large. Proposition 2.1. There is a subspace L of M4 such that both L and L⊥ are transitive.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
191
Proof. It suffices to exhibit a transitive subspace L so that neither L nor L⊥ contains a rank one element. Let Φ be a linear bijection of M2 onto itself with four distinct eigenvalues whose corresponding eigenvectors all have rank 2. Define A Φ(B) L= : A, B ∈ M2 . B A ∗ xu xv ∗ Suppose that L contains a rank 1 element , where x, y, u, v are yu∗ yv ∗ vectors in C2 . Then comparing the diagonal entries shows that xu∗ = yv ∗ , so that xv ∗ is a multiple of yu∗ , say xv ∗ = λyu∗ . So now a comparison of the off-diagonal entries shows that Φ(yu∗ ) = λyu∗ , contrary to fact. Therefore L contains no rank 1 elements. The analysis of L⊥ is similar since Φt has the same eigenvector property. a b d 2c Example 2.2. For example, let Φ = . Then b a c d a b −h −g a b h 2g c c d f e d −f −e . L= e f a b and L⊥ = e f −a −b g/2 h −c −d g h c d Here is a general technique modelled on the previous example. √ Theorem 2.3. If 1 ≤ k < n/(2 + 2), then M2n contains a subspace L such that both L and L⊥ are k-transitive. Proof. The proof of Theorem 1.2 shows that there is a subspace N of Mn with dimension√(n − k)2 which contains no non-zero elements of rank k or less. Since n > (2 + 2)k, it is easy to check that (n − k)2 ≥ n2 /2. Thus there is an injective linear map T : Mn /N → N . Let Φ = JT Q, where Q is the quotient map of Mn onto Mn /N and J is the injection of N into Mn . Observe that for A ∈ Mn , rank A ≥ k + 1
or
rank Φ(A) ≥ k + 1.
Indeed, if Φ(A) = 0, then it has rank at least k + 1. If Φ(A) = 0, then A ∈ N ; so it has rank at least k + 1. Define a subspace L of M2n consisting of all elements of the form A B Φ(B) Φ(A) where A, B ∈ Mn are arbitrary. A non-zero element of L has either A or B nonzero. So at least one of the four matrix entries has rank at least k +1. In particular, L⊥ is k transitive. t Φ (X) −Y Note that L⊥ consists of all matrices of the form where X, Y ∈ Φt (Y ) −X Mn are arbitrary. So the same argument shows that L⊥ contains no non-zero elements of rank at most k. Therefore L is k-transitive.
192
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
We thank the referee for the following argument which significantly sharpens the above result. Theorem 2.4. There is a subspace L of Mmn such that if L is k-transitive and L⊥ is l- transitive if and only if k, l ≤ min{m, n} and k(m+n−k)+l(m+n−l) ≤ mn. Proof. Recall that for 1 ≤ t ≤ min {m, n}, Rt denotes the variety of m×n matrices whose rank does not exceed t, and that dim Rt = t(m+ n− t). The subspace L has the property that L ∩ Rl = {0} and L⊥ ∩ Rk = {0}. Thus dim L + dim Rl ≤ mn, and dim L⊥ + dim Rk ≤ mn. Therefore mn = dim L + dim L⊥ ≤ 2mn − dim Rl − dim Rk . Hence we require dim Rk + dim Rl ≤ mn. Conversely, suppose that dim Rk + dim Rl ≤ mn. Let d = dim Rk = k(m + n−k); and look for a subspace L of dimension d as above. Among the Grassmanian space Gd of d- dimensional subspaces of Mmn , the subset of subspaces L with L ∩ Rl = {0} is Zariski open and non-empty. In particular, it is a dense open subset in the usual topology. (We postpone this argument to the end of the proof.) Similarly, L⊥ belongs to Gmn−d , the space of (mn − d)-dimensional subspaces of Mnm . Since (mn − d) + dim Rk = mn, the properaty that L⊥ ∩ Rk = {0} is also generic. So this also corresponds to a dense open set of subspaces L of Gd . Thus generically, both properties hold and many such subspaces exist. Finally, we give the geometric argument to explain the genericity. Consider the projective variety Rl in the projective space Pmn−1 = Mmn . Form the space Gd × Pmn−1 and consider the subset Σ = {(G, P ) : P ∈ G}. Then Σ is Zariski closed because it is the set of elements of rank (at most) d. (Here we may consider Gd and Pmn−1 as the spaces of projections in L(Mmn ) of ranks d and 1, respectively. Then the rank of (G, P ) is just its bona fide rank in M12 (L(Mmn )). ) Now Gd × Rl is a subset of Gd × Pmn−1 , and thus (Gd × Rl ) ∩ Σ is Zariski closed in Gd × Rl . Project onto the first coordinate, and note that this is precisely {G ∈ Gd : G ∩ Rl = ∅}; i.e., the set of subspaces L containing a non-zero element of rank at most l. This is therefore Zariski closed and clearly it is a proper subspace (see Theorem 1.2). So the complement is Zariski open. Since Gd is an irreducible variety, it is open and dense. Corollary 2.5. There exists√a subspace L ⊆ Mn such that L and L⊥ are k-transitive if and only if k < n/(2 + 2). Proof. When m = n and k = l, the inequality of Theorem 2.4 reduces to n2 − 4kn + 2k 2 ≥ 0,
√ √ or 2(k − n)2 ≥ n2 . Since k ≤ n/2, we obtain k ≤ n(1 − 1/ 2) = n/(2 + 2). This is never an equality.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
193
Example 2.6. Theorem 2.4 above implies in particular that there should exist a subspace L ⊆ M3,4 of dimension 6 so that L and L⊥ are transitive. Let us exhibit such an example. Consider a b c 2d L = e f a b : a, b, c, d, e, f ∈ C . d c f e Observe that if L contains a rank one matrix L, then the compression P LQ of that matrix to any 2 × 2 block must have determinant equal to zero. We consider two cases: f a b 2d = 0 yields Case 0: a = 0. From = 0, we get f = 0. Then c f f b a 2d e b b c =0 = 0, gives e = 0; and = 0 gives c = 0; b = 0. So d e d e c f shows that d = 0. Thus L = 0. a c = 0, we get ec = 1; and e f = 0 yields Case 1: a = 1. From d c e a c 2d = 0 leads to the erroneous conclusion 1 = ec = 2df = df = 1. Therefore f e 2, a contradiction. Thus L does not contain a rank one operator. A similar analysis may be applied to u y −x v z −w L⊥ = , : u, v, w, x, y, z ∈ C w −u −z 1 −y 2 x −v to prove that L⊥ does not contain any rank one matrices. From this we conclude that L and L⊥ are both transitive.
3. Tensor Products In this section, we consider tensor products of k-transitive subspaces. The first lemma is well known, but is included for the convenience of the reader. Lemma 3.1. Let L and M be subspaces of Mlp and Mmn respectively. Then (L ⊗ M)⊥ = L⊥ ⊗ Mnm + Mpl ⊗ M⊥ . Proof. Clearly L⊥ ⊗ Mnm + Mpl ⊗ M⊥ is contained in (L ⊗ M)⊥ . The other containment follows from a simple dimension argument. Indeed, let dim L = d1 and dim M = d2 . Then dim L ⊗ M = d1 d2 , from which we deduce that dim(L ⊗ M)⊥ = lpmn − d1 d2 . Now dim(L⊥ ⊗ Mnm ) = (lp − d1 )mn and dim(Mpl ⊗ M⊥ ) = lp(mn − d2 ). Since L⊥ ⊗ Mnm ∩ Mpl ⊗ M⊥ = L⊥ ⊗ M⊥
194
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
has dimension (lp − d1 )(mn − d2 ), it follows that dim(L⊥ ⊗ Mnm + Mpl ⊗ M⊥ ) = (lp − d1 )mn + lp(mn − d2 ) − (lp − d1 )(mn − d2 ) = lpmn − d1 d2 .
From this the result follows easily.
The main theorem of this section shows that under additional hypotheses, tensoring preserves some level of transitivity. Theorem 3.2. Suppose that a subspace L ⊂ Mlp is k-transitive and is spanned by its elements of rank at most r. If a subspace M ⊂ Mmn is rk-transitive, then L ⊗ M is k-transitive. Proof. Let T = Tji ∈ Mpl ⊗ Mnm , considered as a p × l matrix with coefficients Tji ∈ Mnm. Itfollows from Lemma 3.1 that (L ⊗ M)⊥ = L⊥ ⊗ Mnm + Mpl ⊗ M⊥ . Now T = Tji ∈ L⊥ ⊗ Mnm = (L ⊗ Mnm )⊥ if and only if p l
lij Tji = 0 for all L = lij ∈ L,
i=1 j=1
while T ∈ Mpl ⊗ M⊥ = (Mpl ⊗ M)⊥ if and only if each Tji ∈ M⊥ . We may decompose T = R + S where R = Rji ∈ L⊥ ⊗ Mnm and S = Sji ∈ Mpl ⊗ M⊥ . For L = lij ∈ L, consider p l
lij Tji =
i=1 j=1
p l
lij (Rji + Sji ) =
i=1 j=1
p l
lij Sji ∈ M⊥ .
(1)
i=1 j=1
Suppose that rank T = 1. Then there are vectors uj and vi for 1 ≤ j ≤ p and 1 ≤ i ≤ l so that Tji = uj vi∗ . Now if L is rank one, then there are scalars xi and yj so that lij = xi yj . In this case, p l i=1 j=1
lij Tji =
p l i=1 j=1
xi yj uj vi∗ =
p j=1
yj u j
l
xi vi
∗
i=1
is a rank one matrix. (As pointed out by the referee, this step is similar to the proof that the set of operators of rank 1 is stable under Schur multiplication.) It is then easy to see that if rank T ≤ k and rank L ≤ r, then this sum has rank at most rk. Clearly it suffices to satisfy equation (1) for a spanning subset of L. So we may suppose that each L has rank at most r. Consider an element T ∈ (L ⊗ M)⊥ with rank at most k. The analysis of the previous paragraph yields an element of
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
195
M⊥ with rank at most rk. As M is rk-transitive, this means that these sums are all zero: p l lij Sji = 0 for all L = lij ∈ L. i=1 j=1
Consequently, S ∈ L⊥ ⊗ Mnm . Since R is also in this set, we conclude that T ∈ L⊥ ⊗ Mnm . But L⊥ admits no non-zero operators of rank at most k, and thus neither does L⊥ ⊗ Mnm . To see this, think of such matrices as n × m matrices with coefficients in L⊥ . Any non-zero coefficient results in rank at least k + 1. Hence (L ⊗ M)⊥ contains no non-zero elements of rank at most k, and therefore L ⊗ M is k-transitive. We shall revisit this result in the infinite-dimensional setting in Section 6 (see Theorem 6.12). Definition 3.3. A subspace L ⊂ Mmn is fully k-transitive if L ⊗ M is k-transitive whenever M is k-transitive. It is clear that the tensor product of fully k-transitive spaces is again fully k-transitive. The following corollary yields a large class of fully k-transitive subspaces. This is an immediate application of Theorem 3.2 taking r = 1. Corollary 3.4. If L ⊂ Mlp is a k-transitive subspace which is spanned by its rank one elements, then L is fully k-transitive. Another easy consequence uses the fact that L ⊂ Mlp is always spanned by elements of rank at most min{l, p}. Corollary 3.5. If L ⊂ Mlp is a k-transitive subspace and M ⊂ Mmn is min{kl, kp}transitive, then L ⊗ M is k-transitive. Fully k-transitive spaces have a certain permanence. Proposition 3.6. If L ⊂ Mlp is fully k-transitive, and P, Q are idempotents in Ml and Mp respectively, then P LQ ⊂ B(QHp , P Hl ) is fully k-transitive. Proof. Let M ⊂ Mmn be a k-transitive space. If A ∈ (P LQ)⊥ , then 0 = Tr(P LQA) = Tr(LQAP ) for all L ∈ L. So QAP ∈ L⊥ , where QAP is just A considered as an element of Mlp rather than B(P Hl , QHp ). Therefore (P LQ ⊗ M)⊥ = (P LQ)⊥ ⊗ Mnm + QMpl P ⊗ M⊥ ⊂ L⊥ ⊗ Mnm + Mpl ⊗ M⊥ = (L ⊗ M)⊥ The right hand side contains no rank k matrices, and so neither does the left side. Therefore P LQ is fully k-transitive.
196
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
Example 3.7. The space of Toeplitz matrices Tm is fully transitive because the rank one matrices ai−j for a ∈ C span Tm . To see this, just observe that the entries on the first row and column determine T , and that this may be any vector in C2m−1 . The rank one matrices mentioned above correspond to the vectors (ak )|k|<m . Any choice of 2m − 1 distinct non-zero values of a yields a basis. Example 3.8. The space sld ⊂ Md from Example 1.3 is fully (d−1)- transitive since it is spanned by the rank one matrices {Eij : i = j} and {E11 + E1j − Ej1 − Ejj : 2 ≤ j ≤ m}. this space as those Example 3.9. Consider L= sld ⊗ Mm ⊂ Mdm . We may think of d d × d matrices A = Aij with coefficients in Mm such that i=1 Aii = 0. Then L⊥ = (sld )⊥ ⊗ Mm = CId ⊗ Mm . Thus the minimum rank of a non-zero element of L⊥ is d. Therefore L is (d − 1)-transitive. It is spanned by its rank one elements since both sld and Mm are. Hence L is fully (d − 1)-transitive. Example 3.10. There are transitive spaces which are not fully transitive. Consider the space L from Example 2.2. Evidently, the smallest rank of a non-zero element of L is 2. We will show that (L⊥ ⊗ L⊥ )⊥ contains a rank one. By symmetry, it follows that neither L ⊗ L nor L⊥ ⊗ L⊥ is transitive. By Lemma 3.1, (L⊥ ⊗ L⊥ )⊥ = L ⊗ M4 + M4 ⊗ L. To find a rank 1 in this space, we look for matrices A, . . . , H in M4 , Xij ∈ L and vectors ui , vj ∈ C4 for 1 ≤ i, j ≤ 4 so that A B H 2G C D F E Xij + ui vj∗ E F A B = G H C D This is equivalent to solving the system u1 v1∗ − u3 v3∗ = X33 − X11 ∈ L
u2 v4∗ − u3 v1∗ = X31 − X24 ∈ L
u2 v1∗ − u4 v3∗ = X43 − X21 ∈ L
u1 v3∗ − u4 v2∗ = X42 − X13 ∈ L
u1 v2∗ − u3 v4∗ = X34 − X12 ∈ L u2 v2∗ − u4 v4∗ = X44 − X22 ∈ L
u2 v3∗ − u3 v2∗ = X32 − X23 ∈ L u1 v4∗ − 2u4 v1∗ = 2X41 − X14 ∈ L
Let e1 , . . . , e4 be the standard basis for C4 . One can check that e4 v1 e4 u1 u2 e3 = and v2 = e3 v3 −e2 u3 e2 u4 e1 v4 −e1 is a non-trivial solution.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
197
4. Spans of products While transitive subspaces are not algebras, an algebra can be obtained by taking spans of products. Thus in the matrix case, one eventually obtains Mn . In many cases, this happens very quickly. In particular, the order of transitivity increases quickly. Proposition 4.1. If L ⊂ Ml is a transitive subspace which is spanned by its rank one elements, then span L2 = Ml . Proof. L has no kernel; so we may select l non-zero rank one elements Ri = xi yi∗ in L such that {y1 , . . . , yl } forms a basis for Hl . Every matrix in Ml may be written as l l T = i=1 ui yi∗ . Choose Ai ∈ L so that Ai xi = ui . Then T = i=1 Ai Ri belongs to span L2 . Example 4.2. Consider the space L from Example 2.2. a1 b1 h1 2g1 a2 c1 d1 f1 e1 c2 X = e1 f1 a1 b1 and Y = e2 g1 h1 c1 d1 g2
Let b2 d2 f2 h2
h2 f2 a2 c2
2g2 e2 b2 d2
be arbitrary elements of L. Let Z = XY , and consider the diagonal elements zii of Z, 1 ≤ i ≤ 4. Then z11 = a1 a2 + b1 c2 + h1 e2 + 2g1 g2 z22 = c1 b2 + d1 d2 + f1 f2 + e1 h2 z33 = e1 h2 + f1 f2 + a1 a2 + b1 c2 z44 = 2g1 g2 + h1 e2 + c1 b2 + d1 d2 . Thus z11 + z22 = z33 + z44 for all Z = [zij ] ∈ L2 . Since I ∈ L, span{L, L2 } = span L2 = M4 . and D3 , while Note that span{L, L2 , L3 } = span L3 = M4 . The following concept is a substantial weakening of the notion of k-transitivity. Definition 4.3. A subspace L ⊂ B(H, K) is k-separating if for every set x1 , . . . , xk of independent vectors in H, there is an L ∈ L so that Lxi = 0 for 1 ≤ i ≤ k − 1 and Lxk = 0. The simple result below shows why the property of being k-separating is nice to have when considering products of spaces. Lemma 4.4. Suppose that L1 , L2 are subspaces of Mn with L1 transitive and L2 k-separating. Then span L1 L2 is k-transitive. Proof. Let x1 , . . . , xk be independent vectors, and let vectors y1 , . . . , yk be given. Use the k-separating property to select elements B1 , . . . , Bk in L2 such that Bi xj = δij zi , where zi are non-zero vectors. By the transitivity of L1 , select elements
198
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
A1 , . . . , Ak in L1 so that Ai zi = yi . Then ki=1 Ai Bi belongs to span L1 L2 and takes xi to yi for 1 ≤ i ≤ k. Therefore this space is k-transitive. Since Mn is the unique n-transitive subspace of itself, we obtain: Corollary 4.5. Suppose that L1 , L2 are subspaces of Mn with L1 transitive and L2 n-separating. Then span L1 L2 = Mn . Lemma 4.6. Let 1 ≤ k < min{m, n}. Then a k-transitive subspace L of Mmn is (k + 1)-separating. Proof. Let x1 , . . . , xk+1 be linearly independent in Cn ; and set X = span{x1 , . . . , xk+1 }. Then the restriction M = L|X ⊂ Mm,k+1 is k-transitive. By Theorem 1.2, dim M ≥ k(m + 1). The subspace of M which vanishes on span{x1 , . . . , xk } has km linear conditions imposed, and hence it has dimension at least k. Thus there are elements of M which annihilate x1 , . . . , xk and are non-zero on xk+1 . Example 4.7. The set Tn of n × n Toeplitz matrices (n ≥ 3) is an example of a space which is 2-separating but not 3-separating. Indeed, the fact that Tn is 1-transitive implies that it is 2-separating by the above result. On the other hand, if the first and last columns of a matrix T in Tn are both zero, then all entries of T are zero, so that Tn is not 3-separating. Example 4.8. The converse of Lemma 4.6 is false. If M is a k-transitive but not (k + 1)-transitive subspace of Mmn , consider x where x is an arbitrary row vector the subspace L of Mm+1,n of the form L = M in Cn and M ∈ M. Then this is an n-separating space which is k-transitive but not (k + 1)-transitive. In particular, if we take M = {0}, then L is n-separating but is not even 1-transitive. Theorem 4.9. Suppose that subspaces K ⊂ Mmn and L ⊂ Mnp are k-transitive and l-transitive respectively. Then the product span KL is min{k + l, m, p}-transitive. Proof. We know that K⊥ contains no non-zero element of rank at most k; and L⊥ contains no non-zero element of rank at most l. Assume first that l < min{n, p}. Suppose that A ∈ (KL)⊥ satisfies 1 ≤ rank A ≤ k + l. Then 0 = Tr(KLA) for all K ∈ K and L ∈ L. Hence LA ∈ K⊥ for all L ∈ L. As L is (l + 1)-separating by Lemma 4.6, select L ∈ L which is non-zero on some vector in the range of A and annihilates min{l, rank A − 1} independent vectors in the range of A. Then 1 ≤ rank LA ≤ (k + l) − l = k. This contradicts the k-transitivity of K. Thus span KL is (k+l)-transitive if k+l < min{m, p}. But if k + l ≥ min{m, p}, then this shows that (KL)⊥ = {0}. Hence span KL = Mmp is min{m, p}-transitive.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
199
We obtain a similar conclusion if k < min{m, n}. If k = min{m, n} and l = min{n, p}, then K = Mmn and L = Mnp . Thus span KL = Mmp is min{m, p} transitive. For M a subspace of Mn , let M∗ = {M ∗ : M ∈ M}, again considered as a subspace of Mn . Proposition 4.10. If L ⊂ Mn is transitive and spanned by its rank r elements and M∗ ⊂ Mn is r-separating, then span LM = Mn . Proof. If L ∈ L has rank at most r, then for any vector u ∈ LH and 0 = x ∈ H, we will show that ux∗ ∈ LM. Indeed, we may write L = si=1 ui vi∗ where u1 = u, s ≤ r and {v1 , . . . , vs } are linearly independent. Select M ∈ M so that M ∗ v1 = x and M ∗ vi = 0 for 2 ≤ i ≤ s. Then s s LM = ui vi∗ M = ui (M ∗ vi )∗ = ux∗ . i=1
i=1
As the ranges of elements (of rank at most r) of L span H, the result follows. If M ⊆ Mn is r-transitive for some r ≥ 1, then so is M∗ . This is easily seen by considering Azoff’s characterisation of r-transitivity in terms of the preannihilator of M. It then follows from Lemma 4.6 that M∗ is (r + 1)-separating. When r = 0, no such statement holds. So we obtain: Corollary 4.11. If L ⊂ Mn is transitive and spanned by its rank r elements and M ⊂ Mn is max{r − 1, 1}-transitive, then span LM = Mn . This allows an extension of Proposition 4.1 and Example 4.2. Corollary 4.12. If L ⊂ Mn is transitive and is spanned by its rank r elements, then span Lr+1 = Mn . Proof. By Theorem 4.9, span Lr is r-transitive. So by the previous lemma, span Lr+1 = Mn .
5. Invertibles Proposition 5.1. If L ⊂ Mn is a subspace consisting of singular matrices, then L is not transitive. Proof. Let k be the largest rank of an element of L, and fix A ∈ L with rank A = k. Transitivity is unchanged if L is multiplied on either side by invertible operators. So after such a change, we may suppose that A = A2 = A∗ is a projection. Decompose H = AH ⊕ (I − A)H. With thisdecomposition, each element L0 E L0 + tIk E L ∈ L has the form L . Since L + tA = , the 1, 1 entry F L1 F L1 is invertible for large t, and so it factors as L0 +tIk 0 0 Ik (L0 +tIk )−1 E Ik . F In−k 0 L1 −F (L0 +tIk )−1 E 0 In−k
200
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
From this, it follows that k ≥ rank(L + tA) = k + rank(L1 − F (L0 + tIk )−1 E). Therefore L1 = F (L0 + tIk )−1 E. As the right side tends to 0 as t → ∞, L1 = 0 for all L ∈ L. This shows that (I − A)L(I − A) = 0 and so L is not transitive. Proposition 5.2. If L ⊂ Mn is transitive, let r be the minimal rank of non-zero elements of L and let s be the largest rank of singular elements of L. Then r+s ≥ n. Proof. Let F ∈ L with rank F = r. Suppose first that there is an invertible element A ∈ L such that 0 = λ ∈ σ(A−1 F ). Then 0 = det(λI − A−1 F ) = det(A−1 ) det(λA − F ). As det(A−1 ) = 0, λA − F is singular and thus has rank at most s. But clearly it has rank at least n − r. So r + s ≥ n. Otherwise, for every invertible A in L, A−1 F is nilpotent. By our Proposition 5.1, L contains invertible elements. Select an invertible B ∈ L so that among the elements of the form A−1 F for invertible A in L, the operator F0 = B −1 F is nilpotent of the greatest index, say m+ 1. That is, F0m = 0 = F0m+1 = (A−1 F )m+1 for all A ∈ L which are invertible. For any L ∈ L, and sufficiently small µ, the operator B − µL is invertible. So m+1 m 0 = (B − µL)−1 F0 = (I − µB −1 L)−1 F0 (I − µB −1 L)−1 F0 Therefore expanding (I − µB −1 L)−1 = k≥0 µk (B −1 L)k , m k = µ Xk . 0 = F0 (I − µB −1 L)−1 F0 k≥0
All coefficients of this power series must vanish, and in particular 0 = X1 = F0 B −1 LF0m + F02 B −1 LF0m−1 + · · · + F0m B −1 LF0 . Multiply on the left by F0m−1 to obtain F0m B −1 LF0m = 0 for all L ∈ L. This means that L Ran F0m ⊂ ker F0m B −1 . Both Ran F0m and ker F0m B −1 = B ker F0m are proper subspaces, so this contradicts the transitivity of L. This contradiction establishes the result.
6. Infinite dimensional results In this section we examine to what degree the results of the previous sections extend to the infinite dimensional setting. As we shall see, there are more negative results than positive results. We begin with an infinite dimensional version of Proposition 5.1. Recall that if T ∈ B(H), then an element λ of the spectrum σ(T ) of T is called a Riesz point if λ is an isolated point of σ(T ), and if k≥1 ker(λI − T )k is finite dimensional. In particular, λ is not an element of the essential spectrum σe (T ) of T .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
201
Theorem 6.1. Let L be a subspace of B(H) consisting of singular operators. If L contains an operator A with 0 as a Riesz point of its spectrum, then L is not topologically transitive. A0 0 Proof. After a similarity, A where H = M ⊕ M⊥ and M is the 0 A1 p ⊥ spectral subspace ker A for all sufficiently large p. So A1 is invertible in B(M ), 0 0 and Ap . 0 Ap1 L0 E Any L ∈ L has the form L . As in the proof of Proposition 5.1, F L1 p the 2, 2 entry of Lt := L + tA is invertible for all t sufficiently large. Thus Lt is Fredholm of index 0. Since 0 ∈ σ(Lt ), it must have non-trivial kernel. However, Lt factors as above as IM E(L1 +tAp1 )−1 L0 −E(L1 +tAp1 )−1 F 0 0 IM . 0 IM⊥ F L1 +tAp1 0 IM⊥ The middle factor must have kernel. Letting t → ∞ shows that L0 is singular. This shows that PM LPM consists of singular matrices. Hence it is not transitive by Proposition 5.1. Since the rank of PM is finite, L is not topologically transitive, as observed in the last paragraph of the introduction. Example 6.2. The set K of compact operators is transitive and singular. To get even closer to the hypotheses of Theorem 6.1, consider the set L = CS ∗ + K, where S ∗ is the backward shift. Every element is singular, and there are elements A ∈ L such that 0 ∈ σe (A) and ker A = 0. Nevertheless, this is a transitive space. The spaces T and H of Toeplitz and of Hankel operators appear frequently as counterexamples to possible extensions of our finite dimensional results. Let dm denote normalized Lebesgue measure on the unit circle T = {z ∈ C : |z| = 1}. The set {en = einθ }n∈Z forms an orthonormal basis for the Hilbert space L2 (T) = L2 (T, dm). Let us denote by M∞ (T) the space {Mf : f ∈ L∞ (T, dm)} of multiplication operators on L2 (T). It is well-known and routine to verify that T = [tij ] ∈ M∞ (T) if and only if T ∈ B(L2 (T)) and tij = ti+k j+k for all i, j, k ∈ Z. We denote by H 2 (T) the Hardy space span{en }∞ n=0 of analytic functions in L2 (T). If P denotes the orthogonal projection of L2 (T) onto H 2 (T), then the Toeplitz operators are the elements of T = P M∞ |H 2 (T) , and with Q = (I − P ), the set of Hankel operators is H = QM∞ |H 2 (T) . That the Toeplitz operators are topologically transitive may be found in [3]. We include a slightly different proof to that found there. Example 6.3. The spaces H and T of Hankel and Toeplitz operators are topologically transitive.
202
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
We show that the space M∞ P is topologically transitive. Since T and H are compressions of M∞ P , it immediately follows that they too are topologically transitive. Consider A ∈ (M∞ P )⊥ with rank A = 1. Then A = f g ∗ for some f ∈ H 2 (T) and g ∈ L2 (T). Since A = 0, neither f nor g is zero. The condition A ∈ (M∞ P )⊥ implies that tr(Mh P A) = tr(Mh f g ∗ ) = hf, g = 0 for all h ∈ L∞ (T). That is, ∞ 1 ∞ T hf g = 0 for all h ∈ L (T). Since f g ∈ L (T) = (L (T))⊥ , it follows that f g = 0 a.e.. The classical F. and M. Riesz Theorem (see [5, Theorem 6.13]) asserts that as 0 = f ∈ H 2 (T), the set {z ∈ T : f (z) = 0} has measure 0. From this it follows that g = 0 a.e., a contradiciton. Thus M∞ P is topologically transitive. We observe that an analogous argument may be used to establish the fact that QM∞ is also topologically transitive. Note also that Te0 = {Th e0 = P h : h ∈ L∞ (T)} is dense in H 2 (T), but is not everything. Thus T is an example of a topologically transitive space which is not transitive. Definition 6.4. A subspace L ⊆ B(H1 , H2 ) is said to be totally separating if L is k-separating for all k ≥ 2. There is no point in defining totally topologically transitive in the analogous way, because this would just say that L is sot-dense in B(H). A natural modification of Example 4.8 shows that for each k ≥ 1 there are totally separating spaces which are topologically k-transitive but not topologically (k + 1)-transitive. Proposition 6.5. Let L1 and L2 be subspaces of B(H), and suppose that L1 is topologically transitive. (a) If L2 is k-separating for some k ≥ 1, then span L1 L2 is topologically ktransitive. (b) If L2 is totally separating, then span L1 L2 is dense in the strong operator topology on B(H). Proof. (a) Choose x1 , x2 , ..., xk ∈ H linearly independent. Let ε > 0, and choose y1 , y2 , ..., yk ∈ H arbitrary. Since L2 is k-separating, we can find operators L1 , L2 , ..., Lk ∈ L2 so that Li xi = 0, but Li xj = 0 for all 1 ≤ i = j ≤ k. Since L1 is topologically transitive, we can find K1 , K2 , ..., Kk ∈ L1 with Kj (Lj xj ) − yj < ε/k, 1 ≤ j ≤ k. Let T = kj=1 Kj Lj ∈ L1 L2 . Then n Ki Li )xj − yj = Kj Lj xj − yj < ε/k, T xj − yj = ( i=1
for each 1 ≤ j ≤ k. Since {xj }kj=1 linearly independent and {yj }kj=1 are arbitrary, span L1 L2 is topologically k-transitive. (b) By part (a), span L1 L2 is topologically k-transitive for all k ≥ 1. By the comments preceding the proposition, this says that span L1 L2 is dense in the strong operator topology in B(H).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
203
Example 6.6. The Hankel operators H and the Toeplitz operators T are products of two topologically 1-transitive spaces, but they are not topologically 2-transitive nor even 2-separating. Indeed, H = (QM∞ )(M∞ P ) and T = (P M∞ )(M∞ P ). In finite dimensions, we have seen that the product of two transitive spaces is 2-transitive. We have also seen that in the finite dimensional setting, 1-transitive spaces are automatically 2-separating. A typical operator in H admits an infinite matrix representation of the form a1 a2 a3 ... a2 a3 ... H = a3 ... ... ... .. . 2 ∞ 2 ⊥ relative to the bases {en }∞ n=0 for H (T) and {en }n=−1 for (H (T)) . Therefore He0 = 0 implies H = 0, and hence H is neither 2-separating nor topologically 2-transitive. Similarly, if T ∈ T and T en = 0, then T ei = 0 for 0 ≤ i < n. So T is also neither 2-separating nor topologically 2-transitive. This can be contrasted with Example 4.7 where it is shown that Tn is 2-separating but not 3-separating.
The following technical result will be used in the proof of Proposition 6.8. Lemma 6.7. Suppose L2 ⊆ B(H) contains a sequence (Fm )∞ m=1 of operators with 1) rank Fm = m, m ≥ 1; 2) ker Fm+1 ⊆ ker Fm for all m ≥ 1; and 3) m≥1 ker Fm = {0}. If L1 is topologically transitive, then span L1 L2 is dense in the weak operator topology on B(H). Proof. Choose a sequence (Fm )∞ m=1 ⊆ L2 as in the statement of the Lemma. For each m ≥ 1, let Hm = (ker Fm )⊥ , so that Hm ⊆ Hm+1 , and dim Hm = m for all m. Fix e1 ∈ H1 with e1 = 1, and for m ≥ 2, choose em ∈ Hm Hm−1 with em = 1. The third hypothesis above guarantees that {em }∞ m=1 spans H, and thus forms an orthonormal basis for H. Our goal is to show that if Pm is the wot orthogonal projection of H onto Hm , then span L1 L2 contains B(H)Pm for all m ≥ 1. Since the latter set is clearly dense in the weak operator topology, so is the former. Let T ∈ B(H) be arbitrary, and set ε > 0. Now em ∈ Hm , so zm := Fm em = 0. Fix Rm ∈ L1 so that Rm Fm em − T em < ε/m. Next, em−1 ∈ Hm−1 , so Fm−1 em−1 = 0. Fix Rm−1 ∈ L so that Rm−1 zm−1 − (T em−1 − Rm Fm em−1 ) < ε/m. Observe that Rm−1 Fm−1 em = 0, so that (Rm−1 Fm−1 + Rm Fm )em − T em < ε/m.
204
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
More generally, having chosen Rm , Rm−1 , ..., Rm−k , we can choose Rm−(k+1) in L1 so that m Rm−(k+1) Fm−(k+1) em−(k+1) − T − Rj Fj em−(k+1) < ε/m. j=m−k
m
It follows that Qm = j=1 Rj Fj satisfies Qm er −T er < ε/m for 1 ≤ r ≤ m. Since Qm = Qm Pm , Qm −T Pm < ε. Finally, since Qm belongs to span L1 L2 and wot ε > 0 is arbitrary, B(H)Pm ⊂ span L1 L2 . Therefore span L1 L2 = B(H). Proposition 6.8. Suppose that L ⊆ B(H) is topologically transitive, and let H ⊆ B(H) denote the space of Hankel operators. Then span LH
wot
wot
= span HL
= B(H).
2
In particular, span H is weak operator dense in B(H). Proof. For each n ≥ 1, the rank n operators 1 1 1 ... 1 1 1 ... 1 0 .. Fn = . 1 1 ... 1 0 0 ...
0 0 0 ...
... ... ...
lie in H and satisfy the conditions of Lemma 6.7. Thus we may conclude that wot span LH = B(H). Now L topologically transitive implies that Lt is topologically transitive. Since H = Ht , it follows that (HL)t = Lt H is weak operator dense in B(H), wot whence span HL = B(H). Let us next consider span T2 . Let Eij = ei e∗j , i, j ≥ 0 denote the matrix units of B(H 2 (T)). Letting S = P Mz |H 2 (T) ∈ T, S is unitarily equivalent to the unilateral forward shift, and a routine calculation reveals that for i, j ≥ 0, Ei,j = S i (I − SS ∗ )(S ∗ )j = S i (S ∗ )j − S i+1 (S ∗ )j+1 . Since S k , (S ∗ )l ∈ T for all k, l ≥ 0, Eij ∈ span T2 for all i, j ≥ 0. Thus the norm closure of span T2 contains all compact operators, and is therefore transitive. So far we have not been able to determine whether L ⊆ B(H 2 (T)) topologiwot cally transitive implies that span LT = B(H). As we have seen in Section 4, if L ⊆ Mn is transitive, then span Lr = Mn for some 1 ≤ r ≤ n. It would be interesting to find estimates for κn := min{1 ≤ r ≤ n : span Lr = Mn for all L ⊆ Mn transitive}. In particular, is (κn )∞ n=1 bounded? In the infinite dimensional setting, does there always exist some r ≥ 1 so that
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
205 wot
L ⊆ B(H) topologically transitive implies that span Lr = B(H)? More generally, does there exist s ≥ 1 so that if L1 , L2 , ..., Ls are topologically transitive wot subspaces of B(H), then span L1 L2 · · · Ls = B(H)? Observe that iif L is a unital subalgebra of B(H), then Ls = L for all s ≥ 1, and so an affirmative answer to this question would resolve the Transitive Algebra Problem. However, since we are only asking for each Lj to be a topologically transitive subspace, it seems plausible that one might be able to find a counterxample for each s ≥ 1. Finally, by Example 6.6, if such an s exists, then s ≥ 3. Example 6.9. A subspace of B(H) can be topologically (n − 1)-transitive, but not n-separating. Let {en = z n : n ∈ Z} be the standard orthonormal basis for L2 (T), and the space Ln ⊆ B(Wn , L2 (T)) of operators set Wn = span{e1 , e2 , ..., en }. Consider n of the form A = [aij ] where k=1 ai+k,k = 0, i ∈ Z. To see that Ln is not nseparating, it suffices to observe that if the first (n − 1) columns of Ln are zero, then the last column of Ln is necessarily zero as well. The proof that Ln is topologically (n − 1)-transitive relies upon the structure of (Ln )⊥ . We may, in a manner analogous to that used in our analysis of the finite dimensional setting, identify (L with the set of trace class operators B = nn)⊥ [bij ] ⊆ B(Wn , L2 (T)) which satisfy i=1 j∈Z aij bji = 0 for all A = [aij ] ∈ Ln . A routine calculation then shows that B ∈ (Ln )⊥ implies that bk,i+k = b1,i+1 for all 2 ≤ k ≤ n. If we think of the rows L2 (T), then this says that B ∈ of B as 2vectors inn−1 t f for some f ∈ L2 (T). If Ln (Ln )⊥ if and only if B = f zf z f ... z were not topologically (n − 1)-transitive, then we could find such a B = 0 with rank B ≤ n − 1. In particular, rank B t = rank B ≤ n − 1 and so ker B t = 0. Choose n t a vector 0 = i=1 αi ei ∈ ker B . Then ( ni=1 αi z i−1 )f = 0 a.e. Since ni=1 αi z i−1 is a non-trivial polynomial, it has at most finitely many zeroes. Therefore f = 0 a.e., contradicting B = 0. Hence Ln is topologically (n − 1)-transitive. Example 6.10. The intersection of a descending sequence of wot-closed transitive spaces need not be topologically transitive. As before, we let {en : n ∈ Z} be the standard basis for L2 (T). Let Rn denote the orthogonal projection of L2 (T) onto span{ek : |k| ≤ n}. Then Rn M∞ |Rn L2 (T) ⊆ B(Rn L2 (T)) is clearly unitarily equivalent to the Toeplitz matrices on H2n+1 , and so it is transitive (see Example 1.5). Let Rn = {X ∈ B(L2 (T)) : Rn XRn ∈ Rn M∞ Rn }. Then Rn is transitive and wot-closed. Indeed, with respect to the L2 (T) = Rn L2 (T) ⊕ decomposition X1 X2 (Rn L2 (T))⊥ , an element of Rn looks like where X1 ∈ Rn M∞ |Rn L2 (T) X3 X4 and the other entries are arbitrary. As the matrix entries are independent and each corner is transitive, it followseasily that Rn is transitive. ∞ ∞ Observe, however, that ∞ n=1 Rn = M (T). Since M (T) has many proper closed invariant subspaces, it is not topologically transitive. So the intersection of a descending sequence of transitive spaces need not be topologically transitive.
206
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
Note that there are limits to the decreasing intersection of transitive spaces L = n≥1 Ln . For if P and Q are rank n projections, then P Ln Q is a transitive subspace of B(QH, P H) for all n, and so has dimension at least 2n − 1. Thus the same is true for the intersection. Moreover since a decreasing sequence of subspaces of a finite dimensional space is eventually constant, we see that P LQ is transitive whenever P and Q are finite rank. Our example shows that this estimate is sharp because the compression using P H = QH = span{ei : 0 ≤ i < n} yields Tn as the intersection; and it has dimension exactly 2n − 1. Theorem 6.11. Suppose that L, M ⊂ B(H) are topologically transitive. If L is contained in the wot-closed span of its rank one elements, then the norm closure of span LM is transitive. Proof. For each rank one element uv ∗ ∈ L, LM contains uv ∗ M = u(M ∗ v)∗ for all M ∈ M. By the topological transitivity of M, the norm closure of LM contains ue∗j where {ej } is an orthonormal basis for H. As L is topologically transitive and wot-spanned by rank ones, the collection of such vectors u densely spans H, from which it follows that the norm closure of span LM contains the compact operators. We now give the infinite dimensional analogue of Theorem 3.2. The proof is different, and provides an alternate proof in the finite dimensional case. Theorem 6.12. Let L ⊂ B(H1 , H2 ) and M ⊂ B(K1 , K2 ). Suppose that L is topologically k-transitive, that it is contained in the wot-closed span of its elements of rank at most r, and that M is topologically rk-transitive. Then the spatial tensor product L ⊗ M is topologically k-transitive. Proof. Let {Lp : p ∈ P} be elements of L of rank at most r with wot-closed span containing all of L. Suppose that R ∈ B(H2 ⊗ K2 , H1 ⊗ K1 ) has rank at most k and is orthogonal to L ⊗ M in the trace pairing. This is equivalent to Lp ⊗ M, R = 0 for all p ∈ P and all M ∈ M. r Fix p ∈ P and write Lp = s=1 us vs∗ . Also let e be any fixed unit vector in H1 . We calculate 0 = Lp ⊗ M, R =
r
(us vs∗ ⊗ I)(I ⊗ M ), R
s=1
=
r
(us e∗ ⊗ I)(I ⊗ M )(evs∗ ⊗ I), R
s=1
=
r
I ⊗ M, (evs∗ ⊗ I)R(us e∗ ⊗ I)
s=1
= I ⊗ M, ee∗ ⊗
r s=1
Rs
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
= ee∗ ⊗ M, ee∗ ⊗
r
Rs = M,
s=1
r
207
Rs
s=1
where Rs ∈ B(K2 , K1 ) is given by ee∗ ⊗ Rs := (evs∗ ⊗ I)R(us e∗ ⊗ I); and therefore r is an operator of rank at k. Thus s=1 Rs has rank at most rk and is most r orthogonal to M. Hence s=1 Rs = 0. Now let P ∈ B(K1 ) and Q ∈ B(K2 ) and observe that r 0 = (I ⊗ P ) ee∗ ⊗ Rs (I ⊗ Q) s=1
=
r
(evs∗ ⊗ I)(I ⊗ P )Rs (I ⊗ Q)(us e∗ ⊗ I)
s=1
Therefore reversing the computation above using (I ⊗ P )R(I ⊗ Q) in place of R yields for all p ∈ P and M ∈ M that 0 = Lp ⊗ M, (I ⊗ P )R(I ⊗ Q) = Lp ⊗ I, (I ⊗ M P )R(I ⊗ Q). For convenience, we assume that K1 and K2 have the same dimension, so that there is a unitary operator U in B(K1 , K2 ). Now take P and Q to be rank one projections P = f f ∗ and Q = gg ∗ . Choose Mn ∈ M so that Mn f → U f . Then 0 = Lp ⊗ I, (I ⊗ Mn P )R(I ⊗ Q) = Lp ⊗ I, (I ⊗ Mn f f ∗ )R(I ⊗ gg ∗ ) → Lp ⊗ I, (I ⊗ U f f ∗ )R(I ⊗ gg ∗ ) = Lp ⊗ g(g ∗ U f )(U f )∗ , (I ⊗ U f f ∗ )R(I ⊗ gg ∗ ) = (g ∗ U f )Lp ⊗ gf ∗ , (I ⊗ f f ∗ )R(I ⊗ gg ∗ ) = (g ∗ U f )Lp ⊗ gf ∗ , Rf,g ⊗ f g ∗ = (g ∗ U f )Lp , Rf,g where Rf,g ⊗ f g ∗ := (I ⊗ f f ∗ )R(I ⊗ gg ∗ ) defines Rf,g ∈ B(K2 , K1 ). The pairs f, g with g ∗ U f = 0 are dense in K1 × K2 ; so we conclude that Lp , Rf,g = 0 for all pairs. Evidently rank Rf,g ≤ rank R ≤ k, and it is orthogonal to L. Hence Rf,g = 0 for all pairs. That is, (I ⊗ f f ∗ )R(I ⊗ gg ∗ ) = 0 for all unit vectors f and g. This clearly implies that R = 0. Hence L ⊗ M is topologically k-transitive. As we did in the finite-dimensional setting, we may define a subspace L ⊆ B(H1 , H2 ) to be fully k-transitive if the spatial tensor product L⊗M is k-transitive for all k-transitive subspaces M of B(K1 , K2 ). The analogue of Corollary 3.4 follows as before. Corollary 6.13. If L ⊆ B(H1 , H2 ) is a k-transitive subspace which is contained in the wot−closed span of its rank one elements, then L is fully k-transitive.
208
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
If the subspace has additional structure, such as being a module over a masa, then stronger results may hold. For example, a non-trivial result of Arveson [1] (see also [4, Theorem 15.9]) shows: Theorem 6.14. Let Di be masas in B(Hi ). A topologically transitive subspace L of B(H1 , H2 ) which is a D2 –D1 bimodule is wot-dense in B(H1 , H2 ). We provide a new, more elementary proof. Actually Arveson’s proof works for the weak-∗ topology, whereas this proof is only valid for the wot-topology. m Lemma 6.15. Let (Xi , µi ) be regular Borel measures. Let k(x, y) = i=1 αi (x)βi (y) ∈ L2 (µ1 ×µ2 ) where αi ∈ L2 (µ1 ) and βi ∈ L2 (µ2 ). For any a in the essential range of k and any ε > 0, there is a measurable rectangle A1 × A2 with 0 < µi (Ai ) < ∞ such that |k(x, y) − a| < ε for all (x, y) ∈ A1 × A2 . Proof. Choose a measurable rectangle Y1 × Y2 of finite positive measure on which k is bounded and still has a in its essential range. It is a standard argument to approximate each αi and βi uniformly (and in L2 ) by simple functions on Y1 and Y2 respectively. Combining these simple functions allows us to approximate k χY1 ×Y2 uniformly by a finite linear combination of characteristic functions of measurable rectangles. We may then pick a rectangle on which k takes values close to a. Remark 6.16. The lemma fails for arbitrary functions in L2 (µ1 × µ2 ). For example. take µ1 = µ2 to be Lebesgue measure on [0, 1]. Let A be a compact nowhere dense subset of [0, 1] with positive measure. Then k(x, y) = χA (x−y) has 1 in its essential range. However if k = 1 on a measurable rectangle A1 × A2 , then A1 − A2 ⊂ A is nowhere dense. It is a well known fact that the difference of two measurable sets of positive measure has interior. So A1 × A2 has measure 0. Proof of Theorem 6.14. By the spectral theorem for masas, we may suppose that there are regular Borel spaces (Xi , µi ) so that Di are unitarily equivalent to L∞ (µi ) acting by multiplication on Hi = L2 (µi ). If L is not wot-dense, then there is a finite rank operator F ∈ L⊥ . Moreover, it is evident that L⊥ is a D1 –D2 bimodule. Our goal is to show that using F and the bimodule property, we may find a rank one element of L⊥ . This will contradict topological transitivity. as an integral operator with kernel k(x, y) = m Observe that F may be written 2 2 i=1 αi (x)βi (y) where αi ∈ L (µ1 ) and βi ∈ L (µ2 ). Since F = 0, there is a non-zero value a in the essential range of k. By Lemma 6.15, there is a measurable rectangle A1 × A2 of finite non-zero measure so that |k(x, y) − a| < |a|/2 for all (x, y) ∈ A1 × A2 . Let h(x, y) = χA1 ×A2 k(x, y)−1 . Then h ∈ L∞ (µ1 × µ2 ). Hence k h is a limit in ∞ L (µ1 ×µ2 ) of a sequence of simple functions of the form hk = m j=1 fkj (x)gkj (y). It follows by routine calculations that mk j=1
Mfkj χA1 F Mgkj χA2
has kernel
mk j=1
fkj (x)k χA1 ×A2 gkj (y).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Transitive Spaces of Operators
209
This converges in L2 (µ1 × µ2 ) to χA1 ×A2 , and thus the corresponding operators converge in norm to the rank one integral operator with kernel χA1 ×A2 . This produces a rank one element of L⊥ . The following result is very easy. Recall that a masa is atomic if it consist of all diagonal operators with respect to some orthonormal basis. Proposition 6.17. Suppose that a topologically transitive subspace L ⊆ B(H) is a wot = B(H). left or right module over an atomic masa D. Then L Proof. First we suppose that L is a right D-module. Let D be diagonal with respect to {en : n ≥ 1}; and let Pn = en e∗n . Since L is topologically transitive, LPn = B(H)Pn . Summing over n yields a wot-dense subspace. By considering Lt which is also topologically transitive, we obtain the left D-module case. Example 6.18. A right or left module over a non-atomic masa need not be wotdense. Example 6.3 showed that M∞ P ⊂ B(H 2 , L2 (T)) is topologically transitive. It is evidently a left M∞ module, and a proper wot-closed subspace. The adjoint P M∞ ⊂ B(L2 (T), H 2 ) is similarly a right M∞ module, and a proper wot-closed subspace. Proposition 6.19. Suppose that L is a left module over a masa D, and that L is wot wot = span L2 = B(H). topologically transitive. Then span LD Proof. Evidently span LD is a D-bimodule. So it is wot-dense by Arveson’s Theorem. Therefore span L2
wot
= span LDL
wot
wot
= span B(H)L
= B(H).
References [1] W.B. Arveson, Operator algebras and invariant subspaces, Ann. Math. 100 (1974), 433–532. [2] E.A. Azoff, On finite rank operators and preannihilators, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 64 (1986), no. 357. [3] E.A. Azoff and M. Ptak, A dichotomy for linear spaces of Toeplitz operators, J. Funct. Anal. 156 (1998), 411–428. [4] K.R. Davidson, Nest Algebras, Pitman Research Notes in Mathematics Series 191, Longman Scientific and Technical Pub. Co., London, New York, 1988. [5] R.G. Douglas, Banach algebra techniques in operator theory, Academic Press, New York, 1972. [6] H. Flanders, On spaces of linear transformations with bounded rank, J. London Math. Soc. 37 (1962), 10–16. [7] J. Harris, Algebraic Geometry, A First Course, Springer–Verlag, New York, 1992.
210
Davidson, Marcoux and Radjavi
IEOT
ˇ [8] R. Meshulam and Peter Semrl, Minimal rank and reflexivity of operator spaces, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 135 (2007), 1839–1842. [9] H. Radjavi and P. Rosenthal, Invariant Subspaces, Second Edition, Dover Publications, Inc., Mineola, New York, 2003. Kenneth R. Davidson, Laurent W. Marcoux and Heydar Radjavi Department of Pure Mathematics University of Waterloo Waterloo, ON N2L–3G1 Canada e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Submitted: February 21, 2007 Revised: January 25, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 211–239 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020211-29, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1582-9
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces Christian Hellings Abstract. A model for a class of cyclic analytic 2-isometries acting on Pontryagin spaces is given, generalizing a Hilbert space version given by S. Richter. Furthermore, an example is constructed showing that, unlike in the Hilbert space case, a cyclic analytic 2-isometry need not have a cyclic vector in the orthogonal complement of its range. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B50; Secondary 47A45, 47B32, 46C20, 30H05, 31C25. Keywords. 2-isometry, Pontryagin space, Kre˘ın space, Dirichlet space.
1. Introduction A 2-isometry is a continuous linear operator T on a Kre˘ın space satisfying the identity (1) T ∗2 T 2 − 2T ∗T + I = 0. First studied by J. Agler on Hilbert spaces (see Agler and Stankus [1, 2, 3]), this class of operators generalizes the concept of an isometry in a certain sense. The shift operator on the Dirichlet space is an important example of a 2-isometry. In an analysis of the invariant subspaces of this operator, S. Richter [20] developed a model for all cyclic analytic 2-isometries acting on Hilbert spaces as multiplication by the independent variable on the D(µ) spaces, a family of Dirichlet-like spaces of analytic functions on the unit disk. S. McCullough and L. Rodman [17] have considered 2-isometries in indefinite inner product spaces. (See related work in [16], [18].) Additionally, certain Pontryagin space generalizations of the Dirichlet space appear in the de Branges theory of coefficient estimates of univalent functions, and the shift operator is a cyclic analytic 2-isometry on those spaces as well. (See L. de Branges [8, 9], and also G. Christner, Kin Y. Li, and J. Rovnyak [11] and M. Rosenblum and J. Rovnyak [22].) In this paper, we investigate the extent to which Richter’s model can be generalized to the Pontryagin space setting.
212
Hellings
IEOT
A key property of cyclic analytic 2-isometries that Richter used in his Hilbert space model is that they always have a cyclic vector in the orthogonal complement of the range. In Section 6, we give an example showing that this is not necessarily true on Pontryagin spaces. Thus, the structure of these operators may be richer in the indefinite setting. If we take this property as hypothesis, however, then a model theorem like that of Richter’s can be established. In Sections 3 and 4, we consider a family of Pontryagin spaces that generalizes Richter’s D(µ) spaces and includes the spaces in de Branges’ work. In these spaces, the operation of multiplication by the independent variable is a cyclic analytic 2-isometry (with a cyclic vector in the orthogonal complement of the range.) We show in Section 5 that these operators account for all cyclic analytic 2-isometries (with the additional hypothesis) acting on Pontryagin spaces. Definitions For terminology and definitions concerning Kre˘ın spaces, we follow Dritschel and Rovnyak [13]. Recall that a Kre˘ın space is an indefinite inner product space (K, ·, ·) that admits a decomposition of the form K = K+ ⊕K− , where (K± , ± ·, ·) are Hilbert spaces. Such a decomposition is called a fundamental decomposition of K, and it is in general not unique. Given any particular decomposition, we can form an associated Hilbert space, which we denote by |K|, which is defined to be (K+ , ·, ·) ⊕ (K− , − ·, ·). Although different decompositions yield different associated Hilbert spaces, they all induce the same topology on K, and this is the topology we use. A Kre˘ın space K is a Pontryagin space if dim K− is finite in some fundamental decomposition. When it is, dim K− is the same for all decompositions, and this dimension is called the negative index of K. n An operator T ∈ L(K) is said to be analytic if ∩∞ n=0 T K = {0}. T ∈ L(K) is cyclic if there exists a v ∈ K such that {v, T v, T 2v, . . .} spans a dense subspace of K.
2. Some Basic Properties of 2-Isometries Let K be a Kre˘ın space, and suppose that T ∈ L(K) is a 2-isometry. Using (1), we see that 2 (2) T x, T 2 x − 2 T x, T x + x, x = 0 for each x ∈ K. In fact, by polarization, this inner product characterization is a sufficient condition for an operator to be a 2-isometry. We define T = T ∗ T − I. Equation (1) can be factored to arrive at another characterization of 2-isometries T ∗ T T = T .
(3)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
213
Additionally, one can verify by induction that T ∗n T n − I = n T .
(4)
Agler and Stankus [1] have shown that 2-isometries on Hilbert spaces are always expansive (T x, T x ≥ x, x for all x). This is not generally true in an indefinite setting. (For example, any 2-isometry on the antispace of a Hilbert space is contractive.) However, the Agler/Stankus proof carries through under an additional condition. Theorem 1. Suppose K is a Kre˘ın space, and T ∈ L(K) is a 2-isometry. If there is a non-negative integer N such that T N K is a non-negative subspace (i.e., x, x ≥ 0 for all x ∈ T N K), then T is expansive. Proof. Suppose x ∈ K. By (4), T n x, T n x − x, x = n (T x, T x − x, x) . Rearranging terms, we have n−1 1 n T x, T n x + x, x = T x, T x . n n Suppose that for all n ≥ N , T n x, T n x ≥ 0. Then T x, T x ≥ n−1 n x, x for big enough n. Letting n approach infinity then gives the desired result. The next result shows that, on a Pontryagin space, the condition of the previous theorem is always satisfied when the 2-isometry is analytic. The proof uses Pontryagin’s Theorem: Given a dense subspace M of a Pontryagin space K, one can always find a fundamental decomposition K = K+ ⊕K− such that K− ⊂ M. (See p.164 of [13].) Theorem 2. Suppose K is a Pontryagin space, and T ∈ L(K) is an analytic 2-isometry. Then there is a non-negative integer N and a fundamental decomposition K = K+ ⊕ K− such that T N K ⊂ K+ . Therefore, T N K is a Hilbert space, and T is expansive. Proof. Equation (1) can be factored as (2T ∗ − T ∗2 T )T = I. So T has a left inverse. Therefore, {T n K} is a nested sequence of closed subspaces. Since T is analytic, n ⊥ ∞ n ⊥ K = (∩∞ n=0 T K) = ∪n=0 (T K) . n ⊥ is a dense subspace. By Pontryagin’s Theorem, (See [13].) Thus, ∪∞ n=0 (T K) there exists a fundamental decomposition K = K+ ⊕ K− such that K− is a subset n ⊥ of ∪∞ n=0 (T K) . n ⊥ ∞ {(T K) }n=0 is an increasing sequence of subspaces. Since K− has finite dimension, there must be an N such that K− ⊂ (T N K)⊥ . Consequently, T N K ⊂ K+ . Thus T N K is a closed subspace of a Hilbert space, so it is Hilbert as well. By Theorem 1, T is expansive.
The extension of Richter’s model to the Pontryagin space setting will require that we establish some properties of the subspace ker T .
214
Hellings
IEOT
Theorem 3. Suppose that K is a Pontryagin space and T ∈ L(K) is an analytic 2-isometry. Then ker T is a Hilbert space and is invariant under T . Furthermore, T acts isometrically on every vector of ker T . Proof. The operator T = T ∗ T − I is selfadjoint, so it has a Bogn´ar-Kr´ amli factorization T = DD∗ for some Kre˘ın space D and some injective operator D ∈ L(D, K). Since T is expansive by Theorem 2, D is a Hilbert space. (See Theorem 2.1 of [13], or [12].) Now suppose x ∈ ker T . Then, by (3), D∗ T x, D∗ T xD = T T x, T xK = T ∗ T T x, xK = T x, xK = 0. Thus, D∗ T x = 0. But T = DD∗ and D is injective, so ker T = ker D∗ . Therefore, T x ∈ ker T . So ker T is invariant under T . For any x ∈ ker T , T x, T x−x, x = T x, x = 0. So T acts isometrically on this subspace. By Theorem 2, there is an N and a fundamental K = K+ ⊕ K− decomposition such that T N K ⊂ K+ . So if x ∈ ker T , x, x = T N x, T N x ≥ 0. Thus, ker T is a non-negative closed subspace. Let |K| be the Hilbert space associated with the above decomposition. Now T is expansive, so T N is too. So there is a δ > 0 such that T N x |K| ≥ δ x |K| for all non-negative vectors x. (See Theorem VII.5.2 of [6].) Thus we have, for every x ∈ ker T , x, x = T N x, T N x = T N x 2|K| ≥ δ 2 x 2|K| . This shows that ker T is actually uniformly positive. This suffices to conclude that it is a Hilbert space. (See Definition 1.4 of [13].)
3. Indefinite Local Dirichlet Spaces Let D denote the open unit disk in the complex plane. For any f ∈ H 2 and ζ ∈ ∂D, we let f (ζ) denote the non-tangential limit of f (z) as z approaches ζ, if it exists. For a fixed ζ ∈ ∂D, the local Dirichlet space at ζ is defined to be the set of (ζ) functions f in H 2 such that f (ζ) exists and f (·)−f also belongs to H 2 . Note ·−ζ that this includes all polynomials, indeed all functions analytic on D. For any α ∈ R, we will refer to this space as Dζ,α when it is equipped with the (possibly indefinite) inner product f (·) − f (ζ) g(·) − g(ζ) , . f, gDζ,α = α f, gH 2 + ·−ζ ·−ζ H2 2 (ζ) Let us write Dζ (f ) = f (·)−f 2 . Then the self-inner product of a function ·−ζ H f ∈ Dζ,α is f, f Dζ,α = α f 2H 2 + Dζ (f ). (5)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
215
When α is negative, the inner product of Dζ,α is indeed indefinite. The constant functions, for example, have negative self-inner product. When α > 0, the inner product is positive definite. In the α = 1 case, these spaces can be viewed as the building blocks from which Richter’s D(µ) spaces are constructed. Sarason has also studied them in [23]. Similarly, we will construct an indefinite generalization of the D(µ) spaces from these Dζ,α spaces in Section 4. Also, the example in Section 6 of new 2-isometry behavior on a Pontryagin space will be constructed on a variant of Dζ,α . Lemma 4. Suppose ζ ∈ ∂D. If fn → f and fn (ζ) → f (ζ).
fn (·)−fn (ζ) ·−ζ
→
f (·)−f (ζ) ·−ζ
in H 2 , then
Proof. Let S denote the shift operator on H 2 . Then fn (ζ) = fn − (S − ζI)
f − f (ζ) fn − fn (ζ) → f − (S − ζI) = f (ζ). ·−ζ ·−ζ
Lemma 5. Suppose ζ ∈ ∂D. If f (z) is a function analytic on D, and if zf (z) ∈ Dζ,α , then f (z) ∈ Dζ,α . Proof. If zf (z) belongs to Dζ,α , then it belongs to H 2 , and therefore so does f (z). (ζ) is an H 2 function. Then But also, zf (z)−ζf z−ζ zf (z) − ζf (ζ) f (z) − f (ζ) ¯ =ζ − f (z) ∈ H 2 . z−ζ z−ζ Thus, f ∈ Dζ,α .
In Theorem 8, we will determine the values of α for which the space Dζ,α is actually a Pontryagin space. We will make use of the following lemma, which gives a formula for Dζ (f ) for functions analytic on D in terms of the Fourier coefficients of f . It is essentially the same calculation as that found in Proposition 2.2 of [21]. Lemma 6. If f (z) =
∞
n=0
an z n is analytic on D, then
Dζ (f ) =
∞ ∞
min(m, n)am an ζ m−n .
m=1 n=1 (ζ) Proof. The function g(z) = f (z)−f is analytic on D if f is, so its Maclaurin z−ζ series converges absolutely and uniformly there. This justifies the interchange of sum and integral in the following calculation.
216
Hellings
IEOT
∞ n=0 an (eint − ζ n ) 2 dt 2π eit − ζ 0 −int
∞ 2π eimt − ζ m e − ζ −n dt = am an eit − ζ e−it − ζ −1 2π 0 m,n=1 n −int
2π −m imt ∞ ζ e ζ e −1 − 1 dt am an ζ m−n = ζ −1 eit − 1 ζe−it − 1 2π 0 m,n=1
2π
Dζ (f ) =
=
∞
am an ζ m−n
0
m,n=1
=
∞
am an ζ m−n
m,n=1
=
∞
=
=
m,n=1 ∞
2π m−1
eikt ζ −k
k=0
m−1 n−1
ζ l−k
am an ζ m−n
m−1 n−1
n−1
e−ilt ζ l
l=0 2π
ei(k−l)t
0
k=0 l=0
m,n=1 ∞
dt 2π
dt 2π
ζ l−k δk,l
k=0 l=0
min(m,n)−1
am an ζ m−n
1
k=0
am an ζ m−n min(m, n).
m,n=1
In light of this formula, we define, for any positive integer n and ζ ∈ ∂D, the hermitian matrix 1 ζ ζ2 ζ3 ··· ζ n−2 ζ n−1 ζ 2 2ζ 2ζ 2 ··· 2ζ n−3 2ζ n−2 2 2ζ 3 3ζ ··· 3ζ n−4 3ζ n−3 ζ 3 2 2ζ 3ζ 4 ··· 4ζ n−5 4ζ n−4 (6) Aζn = ζ . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . n−3 n−4 n−5 n−2 2ζ 3ζ 4ζ ··· n−1 (n − 1)ζ ζ n−1 n−2 n−3 n−4 ζ 2ζ 3ζ 4ζ · · · (n − 1)ζ n In general, the entry of Aζn in the i-th row and j-th column is (Aζn )i,j = min(i, j)ζ i−j .
(7)
Lemma 7. For any ζ ∈ ∂D, the set of eigenvalues of Aζn is πj 1 2 1 + tan : j = 1, 2, . . . , n . 4 2n + 1 Proof. Fix ζ ∈ ∂D, and let pn (z) be the characteristic polynomial of Aζn . We will derive a recurrence relation for pn (z). Let W be the n × n elementary matrix
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
217
consisting of ones on the main diagonal, −ζ in the (n − 1)st row, nth column entry, and zeros elsewhere. Then det W = 1. So the characteristic polynomial of Aζn is pn (z) = det(Aζn − zI) = det(W ∗ (Aζn − zI)W ) 1−z ζ ζ2 ζ3 ··· ζ n−2 0 2 n−3 ζ 2−z 2ζ 2ζ ··· 2ζ 0 2 ζ n−4 2ζ 3−z 3ζ ··· 3ζ 0 2 3 n−5 2ζ 3ζ 4 − z ··· 4ζ 0 = det ζ .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . n−2 n−3 n−4 n−5 ζ 2ζ 3ζ 4ζ ··· n − 1− z ζz ζz 1 − 2z 0 0 0 0 ··· 2 ··· ζ n−3 1−z ζ ζ ζ 2−z 2ζ ··· 2ζ n−4 2 ζ 2ζ 3 − z ··· 3ζ n−5 = (1 − 2z)pn−1 (z) − ζz det .. . . . .. .. .. .. . . n−3 n−4 n−5 ζ 2ζ 3ζ ··· n − 2 − z n−2 n−3 n−4 ζ 2ζ 3ζ · · · (n − 2)ζ
0 0 0 .. . 0 ζz
= (1 − 2z)pn−1 (z) − z pn−2 (z). 2
The determinant in the third line is calculated by expanding along the bottom row, and the determinant of the resulting submatrix in the fourth line is found by expanding along the last column. We claim that n 1 2n + 1 Pn (z) = n (8) (1 − 4z)k 2k + 1 4 k=0
satisfies this recurrence relation. We compute (1 − 2z)Pn−1 (z) − z 2 Pn−2 (z) n−1 n−2 1 2n − 3 1 2n − 1 = (1 − 2z) n−1 (1 − 4z)k − z 2 n−2 (1 − 4z)k 2k + 1 2k + 1 4 4 k=0 k=0 n−1 1 2n − 1 1 1 + (1 − 4z) = (1 − 4z)k n−1 2k + 1 2 2 4 k=0 n−2 1 1 1 1 2n − 3 2 − (1 − 4z) + (1 − 4z) − (1 − 4z)k 2k + 1 16 8 16 4n−2 k=0
218
Hellings
IEOT
n−1 n 2n − 1 2n − 1 1 1 k + (1 − 4z) (1 − 4z)k 2k + 1 2k − 1 2 · 4n−1 2 · 4n−1 k=0 k=1 n−2 n−1 2n − 3 1 2n − 3 1 − n (1 − 4z)k + (1 − 4z)k 2k + 1 2k − 1 4 2 · 4n−1 k=0 k=1 n 2n − 3 1 − n (1 − 4z)k 2k − 3 4 k=2 1 1 2n + 1 = n (2n + 1) + n (1 − 4z) 3 4 4 n−2 2n − 1 2n − 1 2n − 3 1 + n 2 +2 − 2k + 1 2k − 1 2k + 1 4 k=2 2n − 3 2n − 3 +2 − (1 − 4z)k 2k − 1 2k − 3 1 2n + 1 + n (1 − 4z)n−1 + (1 − 4z)n 4 2n − 1 n 1 2n + 1 = n (1 − 4z)k 2k + 1 4 =
k=0
= Pn (z). It is straightforward to verify that P1 (z) and P2 (z) are the characteristic polynomials for Aζ1 and Aζ2 , respectively: P1 (z) = 1 − z = det(Aζ1 − zI) = p1 (z), P2 (z) = 1 − 3z + z 2 = det(Aζ2 − zI) = p2 (z). Therefore, Pn (z) is the characteristic polynomial for Aζn for every n. (j) πj 1 is a zero of Pn (z). The Finally, we will show that ξn = 4 1 + tan2 2n+1 (1)
(2)
(n)
n numbers ξn , ξn , . . . , ξn are distinct, and so they will account for all n eigenvalues of Aζn . πij ω −1 πj Fix n. Let tj = i tan 2n+1 . By noting that tj = ωjj +1 , where ωj = e 2n+1 , one finds that 2n+1 tj + 1 = −1. tj − 1 Then we have 1 (1 − t2j ) Pn (ξn(j) ) = Pn 4 n 1 2n + 1 2k = n t 2k + 1 j 4 k=0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
=
=
2n+1
1 22n tj 1
219
2n + 1 k tj k
k=0 k odd 2n+1
22n+1 tj
k=0
2n+1 2n + 1 2n + 1 k 2n−k+1 k tj tj + (−1) k k k=0
(tj + 1)2n+1 + (tj − 1)2n+1 = 2n+1 2 tj 2n+1 tj + 1 1 2n+1 +1 = 2n+1 (tj − 1) 2 tj tj − 1 1
= 0.
In private communications, Stefan Maurer has observed that the characteristic polynomials (8) can be written in terms of Jacobi polynomials: −1 n − 12 ( 1 ,− 1 ) pn (z) = (4z)n Pn 2 2 ((2z)−1 − 1). n See Chihara [10], for example, for definitions and notation. Notice that all the eigenvalues of Aζn are greater than 14 . Furthermore, one can find arbitrarily many of them close to the value 14 by choosing n big enough. More precisely, for any fixed positive integer M , the M th smallest eigenvalue (M) πM converges to 14 as n goes to infinity. ξn = 14 1 + tan2 2n+1 N Consider a polynomial p(z) = n=0 an z n . Let vp be the column vector whose nth entry is an . Using Lemma 6 and equations (5) and (7), it is evident that αI1×1 0 p, pDζ,α = vp∗ (9) vp . 0 αIN ×N + AζN Theorem 8. Suppose ζ ∈ ∂D. When α > 0, Dζ,α is a Hilbert space. When − 41 < α < 0, Dζ,α is a Pontryagin space of negative index 1, and a fundamental decomposition is Dζ,α = zDζ,α ⊕span{1}. In both cases, the polynomials are dense, and the operation of evaluation at any w ∈ D ∪ {ζ} is continuous. When α < − 41 , Dζ,α is not a Pontryagin space. (Whether or not Dζ,α is a Kre˘ın space when α < − 14 is an open question.) Proof. First assume α > − 41 . We will show that zDζ,α is a Hilbert space. Suppose g ∈ zDζ,α , g = 0. We write g(z) = zf (z) for some f ∈ Dζ,α . There is a sequence {pn } of polynomials converging to f in H 2 such that f (z) − f (ζ) pn (z) − pn (ζ) → z−ζ z−ζ in H 2 . (This follows from the fact that polynomials are dense in the Hilbert space Dζ,1 . See [20].) Let qn (z) = zpn (z). Then {qn } is a sequence of polynomials in
220
Hellings
IEOT
zDζ,α converging to g in H 2 . Also, zpn (z) − ζpn (ζ) pn (z) − pn (ζ) qn (z) − qn (ζ) = =z + pn (ζ). z−ζ z−ζ z−ζ So, by Lemma 4, qn (z) − qn (ζ) f (z) − f (ζ) f (z) − f (ζ) →z + f (ζ) = z−ζ z−ζ z−ζ in H 2 . Thus, qn , qn Dζ,α → g, gDζ,α .
Since all the eigenvalues of αIN ×N +AζN are greater than α+1/4 by Lemma 7, equation (9) yields 1 qn , qn Dζ,α ≥ α +
qn 2H 2 . 4
Letting n go to infinity, we find that g, gDζ,α ≥ (α + 14 ) g 2H 2 > 0. This holds for all g ∈ zDζ,α . Therefore zDζ,α is a strictly positive subspace. Now suppose that {gn } is a Cauchy sequence in zDζ,α . Then
gm − gn 2H 2 ≤ (α + 1/4)−1 gm − gn , gm − gn Dζ,α → 0 as m and n increase. So the sequence converges in H 2 to some g ∈ zH 2 . Now Dζ (gm − gn ) = gm − gn , gm − gn Dζ,α − α gm − gn 2H 2 must be Cauchy as well. Thus, {gn } is actually Cauchy in Dζ,1 , a known Hilbert space. So the sequence in fact converges in Dζ,1 , and the limit must be g, which evidently is in Dζ . Lemma 5 implies that g ∈ zDζ,α . Thus, gn → g in zDζ,α as well. It has therefore been shown that zDζ,α is complete. If g ∈ zDζ,α , then g(z) − g(ζ) ,0 = 0. g, 1Dζ,α = α g, 1H 2 + z−ζ H2 So if α = 0, Dζ,α = zDζ,α ⊕ span{1}. Also, 1, 1Dζ,α = α 1 2H 2 + Dζ (1) = α. So Dζ,α is a Hilbert space if α > 0, and it is a Pontryagin space of negative index one if − 14 < α < 0. The above argument shows that the polynomials in zDζ,α are in fact dense in zDζ,α . The same is trivially true for the subspace of constants. So if we consider the Hilbert space structure on Dζ,α associated with this particular fundamental decomposition, it is evident that polynomials are dense in Dζ,α . Finally, the above arguments also show that any convergent sequence in zDζ,α is also convergent in H 2 . Thus, evaluation at any given w ∈ D is continuous on zDζ,α It follows that it is continuous on all of Dζ,α . Similarly, it has been shown that any convergent sequence in zDζ,α satisfies the hypotheses of Lemma 4, and so evaluation at ζ is continuous on zDζ,α , and hence on Dζ,α . Now suppose α < − 14 . Let > 0 be small enough so that α + 1/4 + < 0. Let M be an arbitrary positive integer. Using Lemma 7, we can choose an N such that
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
at least M distinct eigenvalues of the matrix AζN are in the interval Thus there are at least M distinct eigenvalues of the matrix αI1×1 0 BN = 0 αIN ×N + AζN
221
1
1 4, 4
+ .
less than α+1/4+. Label these eigenvalues a1 , a2 , . . . , aM , and choose corresponding eigenvectors u1 , u2 , . . . , uM . The eigenvalues are distinct, so these vectors are pairwise orthogonal. For each j = 1, 2, . . . , M , let qj be the polynomial whose coefficients are the components of uj . Then for j = k, qj , qk Dζ,α = u∗k · (BN uj ) = aj u∗k · uj = 0, qj , qj Dζ,α = u∗j · (BN uj ) = aj |uj |2 < 0. Thus, the span of {q1 , q2 , . . . , qM } is a negative subspace of dimension M . Since M can be chosen arbitrarily large here, the inner product does not have a finite number of negative squares, and Dζ,α can not be Pontryagin. We denote the operation of multiplication by the independent variable on Dζ,α by Mz : (Mz f )(z) = zf (z). The calculations that show that this is a 2-isometry are essentially the same as in the α = 1 case in [21]. The identity f (z) − f (ζ) zf (z) − ζf (ζ) =z + f (ζ). z−ζ z−ζ shows that Mz f belongs to Dζ,α if f does. So the Closed Graph Theorem implies that Mz ∈ L(Dζ,α ). Furthermore, since Mz is an isometry on H 2 , we see that Dζ (Mz f ) = Dζ (f ) + |f (ζ)|2 ,
(10)
Mz f, Mz f Dζ,α = f, f Dζ,α + |f (ζ)|2 .
(11)
which immediately yields In fact, a similar calculation gives Mz f, Mz gDζ,α = f, gDζ,α + f (ζ)g(ζ).
(12)
Theorem 9. Suppose that α ∈ (−1/4, 0) ∪ (0, ∞). Then Mz ∈ L(Dζ,α ) is a cyclic, analytic 2-isometry. Proof. For any f ∈ Dζ,α , 2 Mz f, Mz2 f D − 2 Mz f, Mz f Dζ,α + f, f Dζ,α ζ,α = Mz (Mz f ), Mz (Mz f )Dζ,α − Mz f, Mz f Dζ,α − Mz f, Mz f Dζ,α − f, f Dζ,α = |ζf (ζ)|2 − |f (ζ)|2 = 0.
222
Hellings
IEOT
In this computation, we have used (11) twice. Thus, Mz is a 2-isometry. It is clearly analytic. By Theorem 8, polynomials are dense in Dζ,α , so Mz is cyclic, with the constant functions as cyclic vectors. Sarason [23, Proposition 2] has identified Dζ,1 as an instance of a de BrangesRovnyak space H(b); that is, a reproducing kernel Hilbert space of analytic functions on the unit disk for which the kernel functions take the form K(w, z) =
1 − b(w)b(z) 1 − wz ¯
for w, z ∈ D and for some function b in the closed unit ball of H ∞ . In this case, the function b is bζ (z) = where γ =
¯ (1 − γ)ζz , ¯ 1 − γ ζz
√ 3− 5 2 .
(α)
We can generalize this result to Dζ,α for any α ∈ (−1/4, 0) ∪ (0, ∞). Let γ0 (α) be the root of the equation z = α(z − 1)2 that lies in the unit disk, and let γ1 (α) (α) be the other root. (Both roots are real, and γ0 γ1 = 1. They are negative when α is negative.) Define (α) ¯ (1 − γ0 )ζz (α) bζ (z) = . (13) (α) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζz This function is always bounded for α > − 14 . When α is positive, it is actually in the closed unit ball of H ∞ , but when α is negative, it is only bounded by 1 (4α + 1)− 2 . Theorem 10. Suppose ζ ∈ ∂D, and α ∈ (− 14 , 0) ∪ (0, ∞). Then the reproducing kernel for Dζ,α is (α)
(α)
Qζ (w, z) =
(α) Also, for any f ∈ Dζ,α , f (ζ) = f, qζ (α)
(α)
(α)
1 − bζ (w) bζ (z) α(1 − wz) ¯ Dζ,α
qζ (z) = Qζ (ζ, z) =
.
(14)
, where 1 (α) ¯ α(1 − γ0 ζz)
.
(α)
(15)
Proof. Let Qζ (w, z) be the reproducing kernel of Dζ,α at w ∈ D. We will show that it is in fact equal to the expression in (14). Note that if we let k(w, z) = 1−1wz ¯ , 2 the reproducing kernel of H , then w ¯ k(w, z) − k(w, ζ) = k(w, z) ∈ H 2 . z−ζ 1 − wζ ¯
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
223
So k(w, ·) ∈ Dζ,α . Thus we compute, for any w, z ∈ D, (α) k(z, w) = Qζ (w, ·), k(z, ·) Dζ,α (α) (α) Qζ (w, ·) − Qζ (w, ζ) 1 z (α) = α Qζ (w, ·), k(z, ·) , k(z, ·) + ¯ 1 − wz ¯ ·−ζ H2 1 − ζz H2 (α) (α) Qζ (w, z) − Qζ (w, ζ) z 1 (α) = αQζ (w, z) + . ¯ 1 − wz ¯ z−ζ 1 − ζz (α)
Solving for Qζ (w, z), we get (α) Qζ (w, z)
(α) ¯ ¯ − 1)2 − ζz(1 − wz)Q ¯ (ζz ζ (w, ζ) = . ¯ − 1)2 − ζz) ¯ (1 − wz)(α( ¯ ζz
(α)
(16) (α)
The number Qζ (w, ζ) is determined by the requirement that Qζ (w, ·) have no (α)
poles in the unit disk. The denominator of (16) has a zero at z = ζγ0 ∈ D, and (α) (α) so we choose Qζ (w, ζ) so that the numerator has a zero at z = ζγ0 too. This gives 2 (α) γ0 − 1 1 (α) = . Qζ (w, ζ) = (α) (α) (α) 1 − γ0 ζ w γ0 ¯ α 1 − γ0 ζ w ¯ We replace this into (16) and use the factorization (α) ¯ ¯ − 1 2 − ζz ¯ = α 1 − γ (α) ζz ¯ α ζz 1 − γ ζz 0
1
to arrive at ¯ − 1)2 − (ζz (α)
Qζ (w, z) = =
=
=
=
¯ ¯ ζz(1−wz) (α) α 1−γ0 ζ w ¯
¯ − 1)2 − ζz) ¯ (1 − wz)(α( ¯ ζz 2 (α) ¯ −1 ¯ 1 − γ0 ζ w α ζz ¯ − ζz(1 − wz) ¯ (α) (α) ¯ (α) ¯ α2 (1 − wz) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζ w¯ 1 − γ0 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz (α) ¯ + γ (α) wz ¯ − 1 2 1 − γ (α) ζ w¯ − ζz ¯ + ζ¯wz ¯ 2 α ζz 0 0 ¯ − γ0 wz (α) (α) ¯ (α) ¯ α2 (1 − wz) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζ w ¯ 1 − γ0 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz (α) ¯ ¯ − 1 2 1 − γ (α) ζ w¯ − ζz ¯ 1 − γ (α) ζ w¯ − γ (α) wz α ζz 1 − γ1 ζz 0 0 0 ¯ (α) (α) ¯ (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz α2 (1 − wz) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζ w¯ 1 − γ0 ζz (α) (α) ¯ ¯ − 1 2 − ζz ¯ − γ (α) wz 1 − γ0 ζ w¯ α ζz ¯ 1 − γ ζz 0 1 (α) (α) (α) ¯ ¯ α2 (1 − wz) ¯ 1 − γ ζ w¯ 1 − γ ζz 1 − γ ζz 0
0
1
224
Hellings
IEOT
(α) (α) ¯ (α) ¯ (α) (α) ¯ α 1 − γ0 ζ w¯ 1 − γ0 ζz ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz − γ0 wz = (α) (α) ¯ (α) ¯ α2 (1 − wz) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζ w ¯ 1 − γ0 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz (α) (α) ¯ (α) ¯ − γ0 wz α 1 − γ0 ζ w¯ 1 − γ0 ζz = (α) (α) ¯ α2 (1 − wz) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζ w ¯ 1 − γ0 ζz 1− =
(α)
γ0 wz ¯ (α) (α) ¯ α 1−γ0 ζ w ¯ 1−γ0 ζz
α(1 − wz) ¯
1−
=
(α) 2 wz ¯ 1−γ0 (α) (α) ¯ ¯ 1−γ0 ζz 1−γ0 ζ w
α(1 − wz) ¯
1−
ζw ¯
(α) 1−γ0 ζ w ¯
=
=
(α)
1−γ0
(α)
1−γ0
·
¯ ζz
(α) ¯ 1−γ0 ζz
α(1 − wz) ¯
1−
(α) (α) bζ (w)bζ (z)
α(1 − wz) ¯
.
Now by Theorem at ζ is continuous, so there must be some 8, evaluation (α) (α) vector qζ such that f, qζ = f (ζ) for every f ∈ Dζ,α . Then Dζ,α
(α)
f, qζ
Dζ,α
(α) = f (ζ) = lim f (w) = lim f, Qζ (w, ·) w→ζ
w→ζ
(α)
for all f ∈ Dζ,α , if w approaches ζ non-tangentially. So qζ and therefore the pointwise limit, every z ∈ D, it is easily seen that
Dζ,α
is the weak limit,
(α) of Qζ (w, ·) as w → ζ non-tangentially. (α) (α) 1 Qζ (w, z) → Qζ (ζ, z) = . (α) ¯ ζz) α(1−γ 0
But for
4. The D(µ, α) and P(µ, α) Spaces Now suppose µ is a positive finite Borel measure on ∂D. We define
D(µ) = f ∈ H 2 : Dζ (f ) dµ(ζ) < ∞ .
(17)
∂D
Non-tangential limits of functions in D(µ) exist at [µ]-almost every point of ∂D. In fact, Richter and Sundberg [21, Corollary 2.3] have shown that the boundary function f (ζ) belongs to L2 (µ).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
225
D(µ) is a vector space, and it can be given one of a family of (possibly indefinite) inner products. For any α ∈ R, define
f (·) − f (ζ) g(·) − g(ζ) , f, gµ,α = α f, gH 2 + dµ(ζ) (18) ·−ζ ·−ζ ∂D H2 for f, g ∈ D(µ). When D(µ) is equipped with this inner product, we will refer to it as D(µ, α). If µ is taken to be a unit point mass at some ζ ∈ ∂D, then D(µ, α) reduces to the local Dirichlet space Dζ,α . When µ is taken to be Lebesgue measure, D(µ, 1) can be identified with the classical Dirichlet space. (See [21].) When α is positive, D(µ, α) is a Hilbert space. The α = 1 case gives exactly the D(µ) spaces of Richter. (Of course, when α > 0, D(µ, α) is just a scaled version of D(µ/α, 1).) When α is negative, the inner product is indefinite. A complete description of which measures µ and real numbers α result in D(µ, α) being a Pontryagin space (or a Kre˘ın space) is not yet known; however, some partial results can be established. (See [14] for details.) • Every measure µ has a range of negative values of α for which D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space. In particular, Theorem 8 can be used to show that if −µ(∂D)/4 < α < 0, then D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space with negative index one. • When µ is Lebesgue measure, D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space for all negative non-integer values of α. (When α is a negative integer, the inner product is degenerate.) In this case, D(µ, α) can be naturally identified with the generalized Dirichlet spaces Dν of de Branges ([8, 9]). • If µ is greater than a constant multiple of Lebesgue measure, D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space for all values of α for which the inner product is nondegenerate. Equation (10) can be integrated with respect to µ to give
Dζ (Mz f ) dµ(ζ) = Dζ (f ) dµ(ζ) + f 2L2(µ) . ∂D
(19)
∂D
For any f ∈ D(µ), the terms on the right side of this equation are finite, so Mz f ∈ D(µ). This equation then gives Mz f, Mz f µ,α = f, f µ,α + f 2L2(µ) .
(20)
Theorem 11. Suppose µ and α are such that D(µ, α) is a Kre˘ın space. Then Mz ∈ L(D(µ, α)) is an expansive analytic 2-isometry. Proof. It has been pointed out that D(µ, α) is closed under Mz . By the Closed Graph Theorem, then, Mz is a continuous operator on D(µ, α). It is clearly an
226
Hellings
IEOT
analytic operator. Equation (20) shows that Mz is expansive, and we have 2 Mz f, Mz2 f µ,α − 2 Mz f, Mz f µ,α + f, f µ,α = (Mz (Mz f ), Mz (Mz f )µ,α − Mz f, Mz f µ,α ) − (Mz f, Mz f µ,α − f, f µ,α ) =
ζf (ζ) 2L2 (µ)
−
f (ζ) 2L2 (µ)
= 0.
Thus, Mz is a 2-isometry.
In the main theorem of Section 5, an isomorphism is constructed on the set of polynomials. In order that this isomorphism might be lifted to the entire D(µ, α) space, it is desired that the polynomials form a dense subspace. When µ and α are such that D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space, this is indeed the case. Theorem 12. Suppose µ and α are such that D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space. Then the polynomials are dense in D(µ, α). Proof. Let f ∈ D(µ, α). It must be shown that f can be approximated by polynomials in the unique strong topology induced by any of the associated fundamental decompositions of D(µ, α). The operator Mz is an expansive analytic 2-isometry on this Pontryagin space, so by Theorem 2, there exists a non-negative integer N and a fundamental decomposition D(µ, α) = K+ ⊕ K− (where K+ is a Hilbert space and K− is the anti-space of a Hilbert space) such that MzN D(µ, α) ⊂ K+ . Thus, we write f = q + k, where q is a polynomial of degree less than N , and k ∈ MzN D(µ, α). ∈ H 2 }. Since k ∈ D(µ), µ(∂D − Z) = 0. Let Z = {ζ ∈ ∂D : k(z)−k(ζ) z−ζ For 0 < r < 1, let kr be defined by kr (z) = k(rz). By a theorem of Sarason [23, Proposition 3], Dζ (kr ) ≤ Dζ (k) and Dζ (kr − k) → 0 for each ζ ∈ Z. Thus, by Dominated Convergence,
Dζ (kr − k) dµ(ζ) → 0. ∂D
Both k and kr belong to the Hilbert space MzN D(µ, α) ⊂ K+ . We have
Dζ (kr − k) dµ(ζ) → 0.
kr − k 2K+ = kr − k, kr − kµ,α = α kr − k 2H 2 + ∂D
Let > 0 be given. Then there is an r ∈ (0, 1) such that kr − k K+ < /2. The function kr is analytic on the closed unit disk. Let pM be the M th partial sum of its power series. By Lemma 6, Dζ (kr − pM ) → 0 as M → ∞, for every ζ ∈ ∂D. Again by Dominated Convergence,
Dζ (kr − pM ) dµ(ζ) → 0. ∂D
But all the partial sums pM are in MzN D(µ, α) ⊂ K+ as well. Thus
kr − pM 2K+ = kr − pM , kr − pM µ,α → 0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
227
as M → ∞. So there exists a particular M such that kr − pM K+ < /2. So set p = q + pM . Then p is a polynomial, and
f − p |D(µ,α)| = k − pM K+ ≤ k − kr K+ + kr − pM K+ < . Thus, the polynomials are dense in D(µ, α).
Corollary 13. Suppose µ and α are such that D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space. Then Mz ∈ L(D(µ, α)) is a cyclic analytic 2-isometry. Any nonzero constant function is a cyclic vector. It is currently unknown whether polynomials are dense in D(µ, α) when it is only a Kre˘ın space, even if the inner product has only finitely many negative squares on the polynomials. For this reason, we make the following definition. Definition 14. Let P(µ, α) denote the completion of the polynomials in the inner product of D(µ, α), whenever that inner product is non-degenerate and has a finite number of negative squares on the polynomials. We note that such a completion always exists; see Theorem 2.5 of [15]. A complete characterization of the P(µ, α) spaces is unknown. However, by Theorem 12, whenever D(µ, α) is a Pontryagin space, it can be identified with P(µ, α). The Mz operator will still be an expansive cyclic 2-isometry on P(µ, α), provided that it can be extended continuously from the polynomials to all of P(µ, α). The necessary condition for such an extension is that, in some associated Hilbert norm, there be a constant C > 0, depending on µ and α, such that zp ≤ C p
for every polynomial p.
5. A Model for a Class of 2-Isometries We now proceed with the Pontryagin space generalization of Richter’s model for cyclic analytic 2-isometries. Theorem 15. Suppose T is a cyclic analytic 2-isometry on a Pontryagin space K, with the range of T a Kre˘ın subspace, and with a cyclic vector in K T K. Then there is a positive finite Borel measure µ on ∂D, and a real non-zero α, such that Mz is a continuous analytic operator on P(µ, α), and T is unitarily equivalent to Mz . The proof follows the same outline as in the original Hilbert space model. The 2-isometry induces a certain cyclic subnormal operator (actually an isometry), and then an appeal to Bram’s Theorem is made. Bram’s Theorem states that every cyclic subnormal operator is unitarily equivalent to multiplication by the variable on the closure of the polynomials in some L2 (µ) space (with the cyclic vector corresponding to the constant function 1.) (See [7].) It has been established in Section 2 that an analytic 2-isometry on a Pontryagin space is expansive and that ker T is a Hilbert space. These facts are needed in the proof.
228
Hellings
IEOT
In addition, two other conditions are taken as hypothesis in Theorem 15. First, although the range of T is always closed, we require that it be a Kre˘ın subspace. In general, a linear subspace M of a Kre˘ın space K is a Kre˘ın subspace if and only if K = M ⊕ M⊥ . This is also equivalent to the existence of an orthogonal projection whose range is M. (See Theorem 1.3 of [13].) It is known that the range of a (continuous) isometry on any Kre˘ın space is a Kre˘ın subspace (see Corollary 1.9 of [13]). Whether or not this is true for 2-isometries is unknown, but it turns out to be equivalent to the invertibility of T ∗ T , as shown in the more general Lemma 16 below. This is useful, because we then have a specific left inverse for T , L = (T ∗ T )−1 T ∗ , which plays a special role. Note that the invertibility of T ∗ T is automatic if K is Hilbert, because T ∗ T ≥ I. (In a Pontryagin space, though, a non-negative operator may have spectra on the negative real axis.) The second condition hypothesized in Theorem 15 is that the cyclic analytic 2-isometry have a cyclic vector in the orthogonal complement of the range. Richter ([19, Theorem 1]) was able to prove that this is always true when T acts on a Hilbert space. It turns out that this is not always the case on a Pontryagin space, and we give an example of this in Section 6. However, on the D(µ, α) and P(µ, α) Pontryagin spaces, the orthogonal complement of the range of Mz is the set of constant functions, which are cyclic vectors. Thus, this hypothesis is a necessary one. Lemma 16. Suppose K is a Kre˘ın space and T ∈ L(K) is injective. Then the range of T is a Kre˘ın subspace of K if and only if T ∗ T is invertible. When this holds, the orthogonal projection onto the range of T is given by T L, where L = (T ∗ T )−1 T ∗ . Proof. Let M be the range of T , and suppose that M is a Kre˘ın subspace. Then K = M ⊕ M⊥ , where M⊥ = ker T ∗ . Now if T ∗ T y = 0 for some y ∈ K, then T y ∈ M⊥ . But T y belongs to M also. Thus, T y = 0. Since T is injective, y = 0. Therefore, T ∗ T is injective. Now T ∗ T is selfadjoint, so (T ∗ T K)⊥ = ker T ∗ T = {0}. Thus T ∗ T is also surjective. Therefore, T ∗ T is invertible. Now suppose that T ∗ T is invertible. Let L = (T ∗ T )−1 T ∗ . T L is a selfadjoint idempotent, and its range is contained in the range of T . Also, if x = T y for some y ∈ K, then T Lx = T LT y = T y = x. So the ranges of T and T L are the same. Hence, T L is an orthogonal projection onto the range of T . Therefore, the range of T is a Kre˘ın subspace. The following two lemmas provide the connection between 2-isometries and the D(µ, α) inner product. The calculations are essentially the same as those used by Richter in the Hilbert space case. Lemma 17 is proved in Theorem 4.1 of [20] using a different but equivalent formula for the integral of Dζ (f ). We provide a direct proof here. Lemma 18 is a slight generalization of Lemma 2.1 of [20].
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
For any polynomial p(z) =
N
n=0
229
an z n , we define
p(k) (z) =
N
an z n .
n=k
Lemma 17. For any polynomial p,
∞ Dζ (p) dµ(ζ) = p(k) , p(k) L2 (µ) .
∂D
Proof. Let p(z) =
M
n=0
k=1
an z n . Then
it p(e ) − p(ζ) 2 dt Dζ (p) dµ(ζ) = eit − ζ 2π dµ(ζ) ∂D ∂D 0 2
2π M ijt j j=0 aj (e − ζ ) dt dµ(ζ) = 2π eit − ζ ∂D 0 2
2π j−1 M ilt j−l−1 dt = aj e ζ 2π dµ(ζ) ∂D 0 j=1
2π
l=0
=
j−1 M i−1
ai aj
∂D
i,j=1 k=0 l=0
=
j−1 M i−1
δk,l ai aj
=
δk,l
k,l=0
=
M
ai aj
ζ i−k−j+l dµ(ζ)
∂D
ζ i−j dµ(ζ)
∂D
M 2 m am ζ dµ(ζ) ∂D
M
k=1
=
ζ i−k−j+l dµ(ζ)
ai aj
dt dµ(ζ) 2π
∂D
i=k+1 j=l+1 M
M−1
k=0 i,j=k+1
=
M
ei(k−l)t ζ i−k−j+l
0
i,j=1 k=0 l=0 M−1
2π
M k=1
m=k
p(k) , p(k) L2 (µ) .
230
Hellings
IEOT
Lemma 18. Suppose that T is a 2-isometry on a Pontryagin space K, and the range of T is a Kre˘ın subspace. If x ∈ K T K and p is any polynomial, then p(T )x, p(T )x = QLk p(T )x, QLk p(T )x + T p(k) (T )x, p(k) (T )x k≥0
=
k≥1
x, x p 2H 2
+ T p(k) (T )x, p(k) (T )x ,
(21) (22)
k≥1
where L = (T ∗ T )−1 T ∗ and Q = I − T L. Proof. By Lemma 16, L exists, and Q and T L are complementary projections. Then p(T )x, p(T )x = Qp(T )x, Qp(T )x + T Lp(T )x, T Lp(T )x = Qp(T )x, Qp(T )x T Lk p(T )x, T Lk p(T )x − T Lk+1 p(T )x, T Lk+1 p(T )x + k≥1
= Qp(T )x, Qp(T )x + (I − T L)Lk p(T )x, (I − T L)Lk p(T )x k≥1
+ T Lk p(T )x, T Lk p(T )x − Lk p(T )x, Lk p(T )x
= Qp(T )x, Qp(T )x QLk p(T )x, QLk p(T )x + T Lk p(T )x, Lk p(T )x + k≥1
= QLk p(T )x, QLk p(T )x + T Lk p(T )x, Lk p(T )x k≥0
k≥1
k≥0
k≥1
= QLk p(T )x, QLk p(T )x + T T k Lk p(T )x, T k Lk p(T )x . The last equality follows from (3). Note that Lk T n x = 0 if k > n, since LT = I and x ∈ ker T ∗ = ker L. If k ≤ n, then T k Lk T n x = T n x. Therefore, T k Lk p(T )x = p(k) (T )x. Equation (21) then follows. Furthermore, if k < n, then QLk T n x = QT n−k x = 0, since Q is the projection onto the orthogonal complement of the range of T . Also, QLk T k x = Qx = x. n k Therefore, if p(z) = N n=0 an z , then QL p(T )x = ak x. Thus, |ak |2 x, x = p 2H 2 x, x . QLk p(T )x, QLk p(T )x = k≥0
Equation (22) follows from this.
k≥0
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
231
Corollary 19. Suppose T is an analytic 2-isometry on a Pontryagin space K, with the range of T a Kre˘ın subspace, and with a cyclic vector in K T K. Then K T K is a one-dimensional subspace, and it is negative if the negative index of K is at least one. Proof. Let x ∈ K T K be a cyclic vector for T . Then K is the closed linear span of {x, T x, T 2x, . . .}. Let M be the closed linear span of {T x, T 2x, . . .}. It has codimension no more than one. But M is contained in the range of T , so K T K ⊂ M⊥ . Thus, K T K has dimension at most one. But the range of T is not all of K, since T is analytic. Thus, K T K is one-dimensional. Suppose x were not a negative vector. In (21), Q is the projection onto KT K, and so p(T )x, p(T )x ≥ T p(k) (T )x, p(k) (T )x ≥ 0 k≥1
for all polynomials p, since T ≥ 0 (Theorem 2). But vectors of this form are dense in K, since x is cyclic. This contradicts the assumption that K has negative index at least one. Proof of Theorem 15. By Theorem 3, ker T is a Hilbert space, and it is closed in K, so it is a Kre˘ın subspace of K. Let M0 be the orthogonal complement of ker T , and equip it with the inner product f, gM0 = T f, gK for all f, g ∈ M0 . By Theorem 2, this is a strictly positive inner product space, so we form the Hilbert space completion M. Let P denote the orthogonal projection of K onto M0 , and let T be the operator on M which agrees with P T on the dense subspace M0 . Let x ∈ M0 . Using the fact that P T = T P = T , we have T x, T x = T P T x, P T xK M0
= T ∗ T T x, xK = T x, xK = x, xM0 .
Therefore, T ∈ L(M) is an isometry. Let x be a cyclic vector of T in K T K. It will be shown that P x is cyclic for T . Note that since ker T is invariant under T (by Theorem 3), P T P = P T . So for any polynomial q, q(T )P x = P q(T )P x = P q(T )x. Therefore, if y ∈ M0 ,
y − q(T )P x 2M = T (y − P q(T )x), y − P q(T )xK = T (y − q(T )x), y − q(T )xK (since T (I − P ) = 0). As in the proof of Theorem 3, we factor T = DD∗ , where D ∈ L(D, K) for some Hilbert space D. Thus, y−q(T )P x M = D∗ (y−q(T )x) D ≤ D∗
y−q(T )x |K|. Since x is cyclic for T , this can be made arbitrarily small by choosing the right
232
Hellings
IEOT
! polynomial q. Thus, y ∈ T n P x. Since M0 is dense in M, this proves that P x is cyclic for T . Being an isometry, T is subnormal. Therefore, Bram’s Theorem [7] implies the existence of a positive finite Borel measure µ on the spectrum of T ’s minimal normal extension (which, since T is an isometry, is contained in ∂D), such that T is unitarily equivalent to Mz on P 2 (µ). In this equivalence, the cyclic vector P x corresponds to the constant function 1. Therefore, for any polynomial q,
q(T )P x M = q L2 (µ) . Thus, T q(T )x, q(T )xK = T P q(T )x, P q(T )xK = T P q(T )P x, P q(T )P xK = q(T )P x 2M = q L2 (µ) . Using this in conjunction with (22) and Lemma 17, we get T p(k) (T )x, p(k) (T )x K p(T )x, p(T )xK = x, x p 2H 2 + k≥1
=
x, x p 2H 2
+
p(k) L2 (µ) (23)
k≥1
= x, x p 2H 2 + = p, pµ,α ,
∂D
Dζ (p(k) ) dµ(ζ)
where α = x, x. Note that α is positive if K is actually a Hilbert space, and it is strictly negative otherwise by Corollary 19. Let κ be the negative index of K. The subspace {p(T )x} is dense in K, so it has κ negative squares. By (23), then, the polynomials have κ negative squares in the D(µ, α) inner product. Therefore, P(µ, α) is defined, and it has the same number of negative squares as K. The linear relation {(p, p(T )x) : p polynomial} ⊂ P(µ, α)×K is isometric by (23). So the closure of this linear relation is the graph of a unitary operator U ∈ L(P(µ, α), K) (see Theorem 1.4.2 (3) of [4]). So U p = p(T )x for all polynomials p. Using Theorem 2, K can be fundamentally decomposed as K = K+ ⊕ K− , such that T N K ⊂ K+ for some N . This induces a fundamental decomposition P(µ, α) = (U −1 K+ ) ⊕ (U −1 K− ). If p(z) = z N g(z) for some polynomial g, then p(T )x ∈ K+ , so p ∈ U −1 K+ . Using Hilbert norms associated with these decompositions, we have
p 2|P(µ,α)| = p, pµ,α = p(T )x, p(T )xK = T p(T )x 2|K| for all such polynomials p. Therefore,
zp 2|P(µ,α)| = T p(T )x 2|K| ≤ T 2 p(T )x 2|K| = T 2 p 2|P(µ,α)| .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
233
Now T N K has finite codimension, and {p(T )x : p = z N g, gpolynomial} is dense in T N K. Thus the orthogonal complement of {p : p = z N g, g polynomial} in P(µ, α) is finite dimensional. It is clear, then, that there is a constant C > 0 such that
zp 2|P(µ,α)| ≤ C p 2|P(µ,α)| for all polynomials. Therefore, since polynomials are dense in P(µ, α), Mz is a continuous operator on all of P(µ, α). Furthermore, for any polyomial p, U Mz p = U (zp) = T p(T )x = T U (p). Thus, U Mz = T U . Finally, Mz must be analytic, because T is.
6. A Variation on the Local Dirichlet Spaces In Theorem 1 of [19], Richter proved the nontrivial result that every cyclic analytic 2-isometry on a Hilbert space has a cyclic vector in the orthogonal complement of its range. This property had to be taken as an explicit hypothesis in Theorem 15. In this section, it is shown that there is no way around this. We give an example of a cyclic analytic 2-isometry on a Pontryagin space with no cyclic vector in the orthogonal complement of the range. We consider a Pontryagin space with a reproducing kernel that is a variation of the kernel in the local Dirichlet space Dζ,α . Define (α)
(α)
bζ (z) =
¯ (1 − γ1 )ζz , (α) ¯ 1 − γ ζz
(24)
1
(α)
(α)
Qζ (w, z) = (α)
(α)
1 − bζ (w) bζ (z) α(1 − wz) ¯
.
(25)
(α)
The difference between bζ here and bζ in (13) is that we have replaced the root of the equation z = α(z − 1)2 that lies inside the unit disk with the one that lies (α) (α) outside of it. This means that bζ has a simple pole in the unit disk at z = ζγ0 . (α)
Actually, bζ
(α)
(α)
= bζ /Bζ , where (α)
Bζ
(α)
= ζ¯
z − ζγ0
(α)
is a single Blaschke factor. Thus, Qζ
(26)
(α) ¯ 1 − γ0 ζz
is the reproducing kernel for a unique
Pontryagin space Dζ,α , which consists of functions analytic on the unit disk except (α) (α) for possibly a pole at z = ζγ0 . Furthermore, due to this factorization of bζ (z), Dζ,α decomposes as where Cζ,α
Dζ,α = Dζ,α ⊕ Cζ,α , is the unique Pontryagin space having reproducing kernel (α)
(α) Cζ (w, z)
=
(α) bζ (w)
1 − Bζ (w)
−1
Bζ (z)−1 (α)
α(1 − wz) ¯
(α)
bζ (z).
(27)
234
Hellings
IEOT
See Chapter 4 of Alpay, Dijksma, Rovnyak, and de Snoo [4], and in particular Theorem 4.2.3, for details on such factorizations of reproducing kernel Pontryagin spaces. Moreover, using Theorem 10 of [5], one sees that Cζ,α is just the one-dimensional space of multiples of the function (α)
bζ (z) , (α) ¯ 1 − γ ζz 1
and we have
(α)
(α)
bζ (z) bζ (z) s , t (α) ¯ (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz
Cζ,α
α = st¯ 2 . (α) 1 − γ1
(28) (α)
Thus, if α is positive, then Cζ,α is a negative space, since |γ1 | > 1. But if α is negative (but still greater than −1/4), then it is a positive space. Recall that the negative index of Dζ,α is zero if α > 0, and one if −1/4 < α < 0. But Cζ,α ∩ Dζ,α = {0}, so by Theorem 8 of [5], the negative index of Dζ,α is the sum of the negative indices of Cζ,α and Dζ,α . Thus, the negative index of Dζ,α is one in all cases. Proposition 20.Evaluation at ζ ∈ ∂D is continuous on Dζ,α , and for all f ∈ Dζ,α , (α) f (ζ) = f, qζ , where Dζ,α
1
(α)
qζ (z) =
(α) ¯ α(1 − γ1 ζz)
.
(29)
Proof. By Theorem 8, evaluation at ζ is continuous on Dζ,α . The space Cζ,α is (α) (α) ¯ are one-dimensional, and functions which are multiples of bζ (z)/(1 − γ1 ζz) certainly defined at ζ. Thus, continuity holds on all of Dζ,α . Just as in the proof of Theorem 10, the Riesz vector for evaluation at ζ must be the pointwise limit of (α) Qζ (w, z) as w approaches ζ nontangentially. This gives (29). In order to show that Mz is a well-defined operator on Dζ,α , we must show that it maps Cζ,α back into Dζ,α . This follows from the calculation (α)
zbζ (z) (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz
(α)
=
(α)
(z − ζγ0 )bζ (z) (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz
(α) (α)
+
ζγ0 bζ (z) (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz (α)
=
(α) (α) −ζγ0 bζ (z)
+
(α) ζγ0
(30)
bζ (z) . (α) ¯ 1 − γ ζz 1
which belongs to Dζ,α . (The first term is analytic on D and so belongs to Dζ,α , and the second term clearly belongs to Cζ,α .) We can conclude that Mz ∈ L(Dζ,α ) by the Closed Graph Theorem.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
235
It turns out that the formula (11), which allowed us to conclude that Mz was a 2-isometry on Dζ,α , still holds true in Dζ,α . Lemma 21. For all f ∈ Dζ,α , Mz f, Mz f Dζ,α = f, f Dζ,α + |f (ζ)|2 . Proof. In the subsequent calculations, we use (12) several times. We also repeat(α) (α) edly use the fact that γ0 and γ1 are roots of the equation α(1 − z)2 = z, as well as these two easily verifiable identities: (α) (α) (α) (α) γ0 γ1 = 1 1 − γ1 = −1 α 1 − γ0 (α) (α) (α) First, note that bζ (z) = αζ¯ 1 − γ0 zqζ (z). So (α) (α) bζ , bζ
Dζ,α
2 (α) (α) (α) Mz qζ , Mz qζ = α2 1 − γ0 Dζ,α 2 (α) (α) (α) (α) qζ , qζ = α2 1 − γ0 − |qζ (ζ)|2 Dζ,α (α) (α) (α) 2 qζ (ζ) + |qζ (ζ)| = αγ0 2 (α) (α) (α) γ1 − 1 + γ1 − 1 = αγ0 (α) (α) (α) = αγ0 γ1 γ1 − 1 (α) = α γ1 − 1 .
For any f ∈ Dζ,α , write (α)
f (z) = t
bζ (z) (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz
+ g(z),
where t is a scalar and g ∈ Dζ,α . We then have, using (28), (α) (α) bζ (z) bζ (z) ,t f, f Dζ,α = t + g, gDζ,α (α) ¯ (α) ¯ 1 − γ ζz 1 − γ ζz 1
2
=
α|t|
(α)2
1 − γ1
Cζ,α
1
+ g, gDζ,α .
Also, using (30), (α)
(α)
zf (z) = tζγ0
bζ (z) (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz
(α) (α)
− tζγ0 bζ (z) + zg(z),
(31)
236
Hellings
IEOT
and so we have (α) (α) bζ (z) (α) bζ (z) , tζγ0 (α) ¯ (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz Cζ,α (α) (α) (α) (α) + zg − tζγ0 bζ (z), zg − tζγ0 bζ (z)
(α) tζγ0
zf, zf Dζ,α =
=
(α)2 α|t|2 γ0 (α)2 1 − γ1
− But notice that (α) bζ , zg
Dζ,α
+ zg, zgDζ,α
¯ (α) t¯ζγ 0
(α) zg, bζ
(α) (α) bζ , zg − tζγ0
Dζ,α
Dζ,α
Dζ,α
+
(α)2 α|t|2 γ0
(α) γ1 − 1 .
(α) (α) zqζ , zg = αζ¯ 1 − γ0 Dζ,α (α) (α) (α) ¯ qζ , g = αζ 1 − γ0 + qζ (ζ) g(ζ) Dζ,α (α) (α) = αζ¯ 1 − γ0 g(ζ) + γ1 − 1 g(ζ) (α) (α) γ1 g(ζ) = αζ¯ 1 − γ0 (α) = αζ¯ γ1 − 1 g(ζ).
So we have zf, zf Dζ,α =
(α)2
α|t|2 γ0 1−
(α)2 γ1
(α)
+ zg, zgDζ,α − αtγ0 (α)
− αt¯γ0
(α)
γ1
=
(α)2
1 − γ1
(α)
γ1
− 1 g(ζ)
(α)2 (α) γ1 − 1 − 1 g(ζ) + α|t|2 γ0
(α)2
α|t|2 γ0
+ g, gDζ,α + |g(ζ)| − αt 1 − 2
(α) γ0
(32)
g(ζ)
(α) (α)2 (α) g(ζ) + α|t|2 γ0 γ1 − 1 . − αt¯ 1 − γ0
Subtracting (31) from (32), we get zf, zf Dζ,α − f, f Dζ,α (α)2
=
α|t|2 γ0
(α)2
1 − γ1
(α) + |g(ζ)|2 − αt 1 − γ0 g(ζ)
(α) (α)2 (α) g(ζ) + α|t|2 γ0 γ1 − 1 − − αt¯ 1 − γ0
α|t|2 (α)2
1 − γ1
.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
237
Comparing this to 2 t 2 + g(ζ) |f (ζ)| = 1 − γ (α) 1 2 (α) + g(ζ) = −αt 1 − γ0 2 (α) (α) (α) g(ζ) + |g(ζ)|2 = α2 |t|2 1 − γ0 − αt 1 − γ0 g(ζ) − αt¯ 1 − γ0 (α) (α) (α) g(ζ) + |g(ζ)|2 , = αγ0 |t|2 − αt 1 − γ0 g(ζ) − αt¯ 1 − γ0 we see that the claim will be proved if (α)
(α)2
=
αγ0
(α)2
(α)
γ1
−1 −
α
(33)
This is verified algebraically using the above mentioned identities.
1−
(α)2 γ1
+ αγ0
.
αγ0
(α)2
1 − γ1
Theorem 22. Mz ∈ L(Dζ,α ) is a cyclic, analytic 2-isometry, and its range is a Kre˘ın subspace. However, Dζ,α Mz Dζ,α contains no cyclic vector. Proof. With the result of Lemma 21 in hand, the proof that Mz is a 2-isometry is identical to that in Theorem 9. Moreover, Dζ,α consists of functions which are analytic in a neighborhood of zero. No such function could be in the range of Mzn for every n. Thus, Mz is analytic. (α) We claim that qζ is a cyclic vector for Mz . First, observe that (α) (α) ¯ (α) αqζ (z) − αγ1 ζz qζ (z) = 1.
!∞
Mzn qζ . Hence all polynomials are in this closed span as well. Since !∞ (α) polynomials are dense in Dζ,α , we have Dζ,α ⊂ n=0 Mzn qζ . However, equality So 1 ∈
n=0
(α)
(α)
∈ / Dζ,α since it has a pole in the disk. But the dimension of ! (α) n (α) Dζ,α Dζ,α = Cζ,α is one. Thus, Dζ,α = ∞ is cyclic. n=0 Mz qζ , and so qζ The calculation does not hold, for qζ
(α) bζ (z) (α) (α) (α) ¯ ¯ zqζ (z) + γ1 ζz = αζ 1 − γ0 (α) ¯ (α) ¯ 1 − γ1 ζz 1 − γ1 ζz (α)
bζ (z)
shows that Cζ,α is contained in the range of Mz . Thus the range of Mz is Mz Dζ,α ⊕ Cζ,α , which is a Kre˘ın subspace. The orthogonal complement of the range, then, is the one-dimensional space of constant functions. These can not be cyclic vectors, for they only generate Dζ,α , not all of Dζ,α .
238
Hellings
IEOT
References [1] J. Agler and M. Stankus, m-isometric transformations of Hilbert space. I, Integral Equations Operator Theory 21 (1995), no. 4, 383–429. MR 96j:47008a [2]
, m-isometric transformations of Hilbert space. II, Integral Equations Operator Theory 23 (1995), no. 1, 1–48. MR 96j:47008b
[3]
, m-isometric transformations of Hilbert space. III, Integral Equations Operator Theory 24 (1996), no. 4, 379–421. MR 96j:47008c
[4] D. Alpay, A. Dijksma, J. Rovnyak, and H. S. V. de Snoo, Schur functions, operator colligations, and reproducing kernel Pontryagin spaces, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel, 1997. MR 2000a:47024 [5]
, Reproducing kernel Pontryagin spaces, Holomorphic spaces (Berkeley, CA, 1995), Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., vol. 96, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1998, pp. 425–444. MR 99g:46028
[6] J. Bogn´ ar, Indefinite inner product spaces, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1974, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete, Band 78. MR 57 #7125 [7] J. Bram, Subnormal operators, Duke Math. J. 22 (1955), 75–94. MR 16,835a [8] L. de Branges, Unitary linear systems whose transfer functions are Riemann mapping functions, Operator theory and systems (Amsterdam, 1985), Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., vol. 19, Birkh¨ auser, Basel, 1986, pp. 105–124. [9]
, Underlying concepts in the proof of the Bieberbach conjecture, Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians (Berkeley, California, 1986), Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1988, pp. 25–42.
[10] T. S. Chihara, An introduction to orthogonal polynomials, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, New York, 1978, Mathematics and its Applications, Vol. 13. MR 58 #1979 [11] G. Christner, Kin Y. Li, and J. Rovnyak, Julia operators and coefficient problems, Nonselfadjoint operators and related topics (Beer Sheva, 1992), Birkh¨ auser, Basel, 1994, Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., vol. 73, pp. 138–181. MR 95m:47058 [12] T. Constantinescu and A. Gheondea, Representations of Hermitian kernels by means of Kre˘ın spaces, Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. 33 (1997), no. 6, 917–951. [13] M. A. Dritschel and J. Rovnyak, Operators on indefinite inner product spaces, Lectures on operator theory and its applications (Waterloo, ON, 1994), Fields Institute Monographs, vol. 3, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1996, pp. 141–232. MR 96k:47001 [14] C. Hellings, Two-isometries on Pontryagin spaces, Ph.D. thesis, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, August 2000. [15] I. S. Iokhvidov, M. G. Kre˘ın, and H. Langer, Introduction to the spectral theory of operators in spaces with an indefinite metric, Akademie-Verlag, Berlin, 1982. MR 85g:47050 [16] S. A. McCullough and L. Rodman, Two-selfadjoint operators in Kre˘ın spaces, Integral Equations Operator Theory 26 (1996), no. 2, 202–209. MR 98b:47047 [17]
, Hereditary classes of operators and matrices, Amer. Math. Monthly 104 (1997), no. 5, 415–430. MR 98g:47021
Vol. 61 (2008) [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
Two-Isometries on Pontryagin Spaces
239
, Normal generalized selfadjoint operators in Krein spaces, Linear Algebra Appl. 283 (1998), no. 1-3, 239–245. MR 2000a:47077 S. Richter, Invariant subspaces of the Dirichlet shift, J. Reine Angew. Math. 386 (1988), 205–220. MR 89e:47048 , A representation theorem for cyclic analytic two-isometries, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 328 (1991), no. 1, 325–349. MR 92e:47052 S. Richter and C. Sundberg, A formula for the local Dirichlet integral, Michigan Math. J. 38 (1991), no. 3, 355–379. MR 92i:47035 M. Rosenblum and J. Rovnyak, Topics in Hardy classes and univalent functions, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel, 1994. D. Sarason, Local Dirichlet spaces as de Branges-Rovnyak spaces, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 125 (1997), no. 7, 2133–2139. MR 98h:46023
Christian Hellings Gwynedd-Mercy College 1325 Sumneytown Pike P.O. Box 901 Gwynedd Valley, PA 19437 U.S.A. e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: June 26, 2007 Revised: February 25, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 241–279 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020241-39, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1589-2
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions on a Manifold with Edges D. Kapanadze, B.-W. Schulze and J. Seiler Abstract. We establish a new calculus of pseudodifferential operators on a manifold with smooth edges and study ellipticity with extra trace and potential conditions (as well as Green operators) at the edge. In contrast to the known scenario with conditions of that kind in integral form we admit in this paper ‘singular’ trace and Green operators. In contrast to standard conditions in the theory of elliptic boundary value problems (like Dirichlet or Neumann conditions) our singular trace conditions, in general, do not act on functions that are smooth up to the boundary, but admit a more general asymptotic structure. Their action is now associated with the Laurent coefficients of the meromorphic Mellin transforms of functions with respect to the half-axis variable, the distance to the edge. Keywords. Pseudodifferential operator, ellipticity, Green operator, singular trace condition, manifold with edge.
1. Introduction The construction of a pseudodifferential algebra containing both the classical boundary value problems (such as the Dirichlet or Neumann problem for the Laplacian) as well as their parametrices leads in case of a (compact) manifold M with smooth boundary to Boutet de Monvel’s algebra [1] (see also the work of Vishik and Eskin [4], [9]). The operators in this calculus have block-matrix form, A K : T Q
C ∞ (M, F ) C ∞ (M, E) ⊕ ⊕ −→ , C ∞ (∂M, J− ) C ∞ (∂M, J+ )
(1.1)
(which continuously extend to Sobolev spaces), where E, F and J− , J+ are vector bundles over M and the boundary ∂M , respectively. Classical boundary value problems correspond to operators
A T
and dim J− = 0, where A is a differential
242
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
operator and T the boundary condition, now called a trace operator. ShapiroLopatinskij elliptic problems have a parametrix of the form (A K), where K is a potential operator and A = r+ P e+ + G with a (singular) Green operator G and a classical pseudodifferential operator P on the double 2M of M that has the transmission property with respect to the boundary of M (moreover, e+ denotes the operator of extension by zero from M to 2M , while r+ denotes restriction from 2M to int M ). Elements of Boutet de Monvel’s algebra are filtered by their order µ ∈ Z (which is simply the usual order of the (pseudo)differential part in the upper left corner) and posses a so-called type, which is a non-negative integer d ∈ N0 . The type can be different from zero only for trace operators and (singular) Green operators. For example, taking k-times the derivative in normal direction followed by restriction to the boundary and application of a pseudodifferential operator on the boundary yields a trace operator of type d = k + 1. Another more complicated task is that of developing an elliptic theory for differential operators on a manifold M with edges. Roughly speaking, outside a lower dimensional smooth stratum Y (the edge), M is a smooth manifold, while each point of Y has a neighbourhood homeomorphic to U × X ∆ , where U is an open subset of Y and X ∆ is a cone with smooth closed cross section X. Note that a manifold with boundary is a particular case of a manifold with edge, namely one with X being a point and thus X ∆ = R+ , the normal to the boundary. Typical differential operators on M are edge degenerate, i.e. they have a specific singular structure close to the edge (see Section 3 for more details). As it turns out, elliptic edge degenerate differential operators in general do not have the Fredholm property (in suitable edge Sobolev spaces), but one has to impose additional trace and potential conditions over the edge, possibly even simultaneously. In other words, developing a Fredholm theory for edge degenerate operators leads to a pseudodifferential calculus of operators in block-matrix form similarly as in (1.1), the so-called edge algebra. This calculus has been developed by the second author in [10], [11], [12]. A detailed exposition may be found in [3]; a short overview we provide in Section 8 of this paper. As is known from the authors’ joint works [13] or [14] the analogy between the respective calculi for boundary value problems and ‘edge problems’ goes very far. But there are also essential differences: While Boutet de Monvel’s calculus requires the transmission property, the edge calculus admits general pseudodifferential symbols smooth up to the boundary. In contrast to standard elliptic trace conditions (e.g. of Dirichlet or Neumann type) at the boundary which make sense on solutions of sufficiently high Sobolev regularity, the solutions to edge problems generally do not admit traces of that kind. On the other hand, solutions to edge problems may have asymptotics at the edge, that can be regarded as a substitute of Taylor asymptotics at the boundary (i.e., smoothness up to the boundary). It is now natural and desirable to organise a calculus of edge degenerate operators with trace conditions based on those general asymptotics (called singular trace conditions) rather than Taylor asymptotics.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
243
In the present paper we just establish such an extension of the edge algebra by our new singular trace and Green operators. We study compositions of the corresponding edge operators, formulate ellipticity with singular trace, etc., conditions at the edge, and obtain parametrices within the calculus.
2. Symbols of Boutet de Monvel’s algebra As noted in the introduction, boundary value problems with the transmission property may be regarded as a model for calculi with singular trace (and also Green) operators. Let us describe this on the level of boundary symbols in a halfspace Ω × R+ with an open set Ω ⊂ Rq . The variable in Ω we will denote by y, the one of R+ by t. Let p(y, t, η, τ ) be a (classical) symbol of integer order µ with the transmission µ property at t = 0 (the symbols of that kind form a closed subspace Str (Ω × µ µ q+1 ∞ q+1 q+1 R+ × R ) of C (Ω × R+ , Scl (R )) with Scl (R ) being the space of classical symbols of order µ with constant coefficients). Assume that p is independent of t for t > T for some T > 0. Let us set (2.1) op+ (p)(y, η) = r+ op(p)(y, η)e+ i(t−t )τ p(y, t, η, τ )u(t ) dt d¯τ, d¯τ = (2π)−1 dτ, where e+ for op(p)(y, η)u (t) = e denotes the operator of extension by zero from R+ to R and r+ the restriction from R to R+ of distributions (in (2.1) on the right hand side we tacitly insert a symbol p on Ω × R × Rq+1 with p = p|Ω×R+ ×Rq+1 ; however, since the operator is independent of the choice of p we simply write p). As is known, (2.1) defines a family of continuous operators op+ (p)(y, η) : H s (R+ ) −→ H s−µ (R+ ),
s > − 12 ,
where H s (R+ ) := H s (R)|R+ with H s (R) being the standard Sobolev space of smoothness s on R. Defining for λ > 0 κλ : H s (R+ ) −→ H s (R+ ),
1
(κλ u)(t) = λ 2 u(λt),
(2.2)
we obtain a strongly continuous group of isomorphisms on the space H s (R+ ), i.e., i) κ1 = 1 and κλ κδ = κλδ for all λ, δ > 0, ii) λ → κλ u : [0, ∞) → H s (R+ ) is continuous for any u ∈ H s (R+ ). In particular, these operators are unitary on L2 (R+ ) (with the standard scalar product). An essential observation is that op+ (p)(y, η) is an operator-valued symbol in the following sense. If E is a Hilbert space and {κλ }λ∈R+ a strongly continuous group of isomorphisms on E, we say that E is endowed with a group action. Let us set η = (1 + |η|2 )1/2 . with group actions {κλ }λ∈R+ and Definition 2.1. Given Hilbert spaces E and E {˜ κλ }λ∈R+ , respectively, (2.3) S µ (Ω × Rq ; E, E)
244
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
such that will denote the space of all functions a(y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × Rq , L (E, E)) sup
y∈K,η∈Rq
α β η−µ+|α| ˜ κ−1 < ∞ η Dη Dy a(y, η)κη L (E,E)
for every compact K ⊂ Ω and all multi-indices α, β ∈ Nq . Note that we obtain an equivalent definition of (2.3) when we replace η by, for instance, a smooth function η → [η] that is strictly positive and satisfies [η] = |η| for |η| > C for a C > 0. In the sequel, for convenience, we assume C = 1. Remark 2.2. By standard estimates of strongly continuous semi-groups, a group action {κλ }λ∈R+ on E satisfies κλ L (E) ≤ C max(λ, λ−1 )K
for all λ > 0
with suitable constants C, K ≥ 0. Consequently,
(1) → S µ (Ω × Rq ; E, E) → S µ+K+K (Ω × Rq ; E, E) (1) , S µ−K−K (Ω × Rq ; E, E) are equipped with the where the subscript (1) here indicates that both E and E trivial group action κ ≡ 1. is called (twisted) homoA function a(µ) (y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × (Rq \{0}), L (E, E)) geneous in η = 0 of order µ if ˜λ a(µ) (y, η)κ−1 a(µ) (y, λη) = λµ κ λ
for all (y, η) ∈ Ω × (Rq \{0}),
λ > 0. (2.4)
Note that when χ(η) is an arbitrary zero-excision function on R (i.e., χ is smooth, vanishes in a neighbourhood of the origin, and equals 1 for |η| > R for some R > 0) if a(µ) is homogeneous in the former we have χ(η)a(µ) (y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; E, E) sense. This gives rise to µ Scl (Ω × Rq ; E, E), (2.5) q
the subspace of (2.3) of all elements a(y, η) which admit an asymptotic expansion into terms of the kind χ(η)a(µ−j) (y, η), with homogeneous functions a(µ−j) (y, η) of order µ − j, j ∈ N. In this case we let σ∧ (a)(y, η) = a(µ) (y, η) denote the homogeneous principal symbol. is a Remark 2.3. In view of Remark 2.2, a function a ∈ C ∞ (Ω × Rq , L (E, E)) µ if and only if there exists a sequence a(µ−j) symbol in the class Scl (Ω × Rq ; E, E) of homogeneous components such that to any given M ≥ 0 there exists an L ∈ N such that a(y, η) −
L
(1) , χ(η)a(µ−j) (y, η) ∈ S −M (Ω × Rq ; E, E)
j=0
where the subscript (1) has the same meaning as in Remark 2.2.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
245
The concept of operator-valued symbols in the above sense is very close to the = C and the group actions are trivial (i.e., identity opscalar case where E = E erators for all λ > 0). Nevertheless there are beautiful (and sometimes surprising) examples of such operator-valued symbols, as we shall see below. µ (Ω × R+ × Rq+1 ) (independent of t for large Example. For every p(y, t, η, τ ) ∈ Str t) we have
1 s>− . 2 denotes the homogeneous principal part of p of order µ in
op+ (p)(y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; H s (R+ ), H s−µ (R+ )), Moreover, if p(µ) (η, τ ) = 0, then
p(µ) (y, η) := op+ (p(µ) |t=0 )(y, η),
(y, η) ∈ Ω × (Rq \{0})
is homogeneous in the sense of the relation (2.4). to be a Fr´echet space with It is also necessary for our purposes to admit E group action: Let = lim j E E ←−j∈N j with continuous embeddings E j+1 → be a projective limit of Hilbert spaces E j 0 0 E → . . . → E such that E is endowed with a group action {κλ }λ∈R+ that j for every j. Then E is said to be restricts to a group action {κλ |E j }λ∈R+ on E µ j ) endowed with the group action {κλ }λ∈R+ . We have the spaces S (Ω × Rq ; E, E (cl)
for all j, and µ = lim S µ (Ω × Rq ; E, E j ) S(cl) (Ω × Rq ; E, E) ←− (cl) j∈N
is, by definition, the projective limit of these spaces (subscript ‘(cl)’ means that we are talking about the classical or the general case). A As is known, the parametrix of an elliptic boundary value problem T in the half-space Ω × R+ , with an elliptic differential operator A and a trace operator T which satisfies the Shapiro-Lopatinskij condition with respect to A (for instance, the Dirichlet or the Neumann problem for the Laplacian), can be expressed within Boutet de Monvel’s calculus of pseudodifferential boundary value problems. Besides the symbols of Example 2, this calculus also contains so-called Green symbols. Such symbols have an order µ ∈ R and a so-called type d ∈ N. They have the form of 2 × 2 block matrices l d ∂t 0 gl (y, η) (2.6) g(y, η) = g0 (y, η) + 0 0 l=1
where ∂t indicates differentiation in the direction normal to the boundary, and, with suitable j+ , j− ∈ N0 , ν gl (y, η) ∈ Scl (Ω × Rq ; L2 (R+ ) ⊕ Cj− , S (R+ ) ⊕ Cj+ ),
ν = µ − l,
246
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
is a 2 × 2 block matrix symbol of order ν, whose pointwise adjoint satisfies ν gl (y, η)∗ ∈ Scl (Ω × Rq ; L2 (R+ ) ⊕ Cj+ , S (R+ ) ⊕ Cj− ).
Here, S (R+ ) = limk∈N t−k H k (R+ ) and L2 (R+ ) are endowed with the group ←− action {κλ }λ∈R+ from (2.2), while the spaces L2 (R+ ) ⊕ CN and S (R+ ) ⊕ CN are endowed with {κλ ⊕ idCN }λ∈R+ . Writing g(y, η) = (gij (y, η))i,j=1,2 , the component g21 (the left lower corner) is a so-called trace symbol of order µ and type d, while g12 is a potential symbol of order µ. The associated operators Op(g) (the pseudodifferential operator with respect to the Fourier transform in the y-variables), occasionally also denoted by Opy (g), are generated in the parametrix construction of elliptic boundary value problems. For example, Green’s function of the Dirichlet problem for the Laplacian ∆ is, locally near the boundary, of the form E + Op(g11 ) for a fundamental solution E of ∆ and a Green symbol g11 (y, η) of type 0. Moreover, the potential operator in the solution of the Dirichlet problem is, locally near the boundary, of the form Op(g12 ) (clearly, these relations are true modulo smoothing operators in Boutet de Monvel’s calculus, cf. [1]). Remark 2.4. The amplitude functions of boundary value problems in Ω × R+ have the form + op (p)(y, η) 0 a(y, η) = + g(y, η) (2.7) 0 0 where op+ (p) is as in Remark 2, and the second summand, given by (2.6) belongs to µ Scl (Ω × Rq ; H s (R+ ) ⊕ Cj− , S (R+ ) ⊕ Cj+ ), for all s > d − 12 . From (2.6) we see that trace and Green operators of type 0 are of integral form (in contrast to operators of positive type that are combined with differentiations in normal direction and the restriction to the boundary). As noted in the introduction, the calculus of edge problems of [12] has a similar structure, but the corresponding analogues of trace and Green operators of positive type are still missing. In the present paper we introduce them as so-called singular operators while the former ones from the edge calculus are of integral form and regarded as regular operators.
3. Symbolic structure of edge-degenerate differential operators We now start discussing a category of operator-valued symbols that contribute to the symbolic calculus of operators on a manifold with edge. By definition (cf. Section 6.1 below) such a manifold is locally, near the edge, represented by a wedge X × Ω,
X = (R+ × X)/({0} × X),
with an edge Ω (an open set in Rq ) and a model cone X for a closed smooth Riemannian manifold X. The half-space case just corresponds to dim X = 0.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
247
An edge-degenerate differential operator A on an open stretched wedge X ∧ × Ω,
X ∧ = R+ × X,
in the splitting of variables (r, x, y) has the form ajα (r, y)(−r∂r )j (rDy )α A = r−µ
(3.1)
j+|α|≤µ
with coefficients ajα ∈ C ∞ (R+ × Ω, Diff µ−(j+|α|) (X)), where Diff ν (X) is the space of all differential operators of order ν with smooth coefficients on X. Since the main aspects concern a neighbourhood of r = 0 we assume that the coefficients ajα are independent of r for r > R for some R > 0. We have A = Opy (a) for the operator-valued amplitude function a(y, η) = r−µ ajα (r, y)(−r∂r )j (rη)α . (3.2) j+|α|≤µ
We now fix an adequate scale of spaces such that (3.2) is an operator-valued symbol in the sense of (2.3). To this end we let ω denote a cut-off function on the half-axis, i.e. ω ∈ C0∞ (R+ ) and ω ≡ 1 near r = 0. Definition 3.1. Let s ∈ N, γ ∈ R, and n := dim X. We denote by Ks,γ (X ∧ ) the space of all u(r, x) ∈ L2loc (R+ × X, drdx) such that n
r 2 −γ (r∂r )k Dxα (ωu)(r, x) ∈ L2 (R+ × X, drdx)
for all k + |α| ≤ s,
where Dxα for α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) denotes any composition v1α1 . . . vnαn of vector fields vj on X, and s (1 − ω)u ∈ Hcone (X ∧ ), the standard Sobolev space of smoothness s ∈ R on the infinite cone X ∧ (cf. [11], p. 151, for details). Note that for X = S n (the unit sphere in Rn+1 ) we have s (1 − ω)Hcone (X ∧ ) = (1 − ω)H s (Rn+1 ).
The definition of Ks,γ (X ∧ ) for general s ∈ R follows by duality (with respect to the K0,0 -scalar product) and interpolation. The spaces Ks,γ (X ∧ ) can be equipped with norms in terms of Hilbert space scalar products. In particular, we have n K0,0 (X ∧ ) = r− 2 L2 (R+ × X, drdx). We shall endow each Ks,γ (X ∧ ) with the group action defined by (κλ u)(r, x) = λ
n+1 2
u(λr, x),
λ > 0.
(3.3)
For references below we also form the Fr´echet spaces S γ (X ∧ ) = {u ∈ K∞,γ (X ∧ ) : (1 − ω)u ∈ S (R+ , C ∞ (X))}, endowed with the same group action.
(3.4)
248
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
Remark 3.2. For purposes below we also consider the spaces Ks,γ;g (X ∧ ) := [r]−g Ks,γ (X ∧ ),
g ∈ R,
endowed with the group action (κgλ u)(r, x) = λg+
n+1 2
u(λr, x),
λ > 0.
Setting K s,γ (X ∧ ) = Ks,γ;s−γ (X ∧ ), we have that K s,γ (X ∧ ) = rγ K s,0 (X ∧ ) for every s, γ ∈ R.
(3.5)
Proposition 3.3. Given an edge-degenerate differential operator A, the associated operator family (3.2) represents an operator-valued symbol a(y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ ), Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ )) for every s, γ ∈ R. The family of operators σ∧ (A)(y, η) = r−µ ajα (0, y)(−r∂r )j (rη)α
(3.6)
j+|α|≤µ
is (twisted) homogeneous of order µ, i.e., σ∧ (A)(y, λη) = λµ κλ σ∧ (A)(y, η)κ−1 λ for all λ > 0. Remark 3.4. The operator family (3.2) also represents an operator-valued symbol a(y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ;g (X ∧ ), Ks−µ,γ−µ;g (X ∧ )) for every s, γ, g ∈ R, where we now refer to the group action {κgλ }λ∈R+ in both spaces, cf. Remark 3.2. In particular, we have a(y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; K s,γ (X ∧ ), K s−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ )) for every s, γ ∈ R. For convenience, we shall formulate most of our results for the case g = 0 but already mention here that they extend to the case of arbitrary weight g ∈ R. Let σψ (A)(r, x, y, , ξ, η) denote the usual homogeneous principal symbol of the operator (3.1) of order µ. Together with (3.6) we then have the principal symbol of A, (3.7) σ(A) := (σψ (A), σ∧ (A)), which controls the ellipticity in the edge calculus. The operator A is called σψ -elliptic if it is elliptic as usual and if, in addition, its rescaled symbol σ ψ (A)(x, y, , ξ, η) := rµ σψ (A)(r, x, y, r−1 , ξ, r−1 η) r=0
does not vanish for (, ξ, η) = 0. The ellipticity of A with respect to both components of (3.7) also requires the bijectivity of σ∧ (A)(y, η) : Ks,γ (X ∧ ) −→ Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ )
(3.8)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
249
for all (y, η) ∈ Ω×(Rq \{0}). However, this cannot be expected to hold true without additional information. It is known that the σψ -ellipticity of A entails the Fredholm property of (3.8) for all weights γ ∈ R \ D, for a discrete set D = D(y) ⊂ R. The (necessary and sufficient) condition for the Fredholm property is that the subordinate principal conormal symbol σM (A)(y, z) =
µ
aj0 (0, y)z j : H s (X) −→ H s−µ (X)
j=0
is invertible for all z with Re z = n+1 2 − γ. Similarly as for boundary value problems, the idea of ellipticity of edge problems (in the ‘usual’ sense, cf. [12], [3]) is to fill up the Fredholm family (3.8) by finite rank operators to a 2 × 2 block matrix family of isomorphisms Ks,γ (X ∧ ) Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ ) ⊕ ⊕ −→ (3.9) σ∧ (A)(y, η) : Cj− Cj+ A K with σ∧ (A)(y, η) as the upper left corner, where A = is a corresponding T Q edge problem with the homogeneous principal edge symbol (3.9). Edge symbols are then 2 × 2 block matrix symbols a(y, η) + m(y, η) 0 a(y, η) = + g(y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; E, E) 0 0 = Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ ) ⊕ Cj+ , where g(y, η) is a sowith E = Ks,γ (X ∧ ) ⊕ Cj− and E called Green symbol and m(y, η) a smoothing Mellin symbol, such that A = Op(a). For details see the appendix, Section 8.
4. Spaces with asymptotics 4.1. Cone Sobolev spaces Beside the spaces Ks,γ (X ∧ ) that we defined in Definition 3.1, we are also interested in subspaces consisting of functions that have asymptotics for r → 0. In this connection let P = {(pj , mj , Lj ) : j = 0, . . . , N } for (pj , mj , Lj ) ∈ C × N × C ∞ (X),
(4.1)
∞
with N ∈ N ∪ {∞} and each Lj is a finite dimensional subspace of C (X). We
l and, in case N = ∞, that Re pj → −∞ for also assume that pk = pl for k = j → ∞. Definition 4.1. Let γ ∈ R and 0 < θ ∈ R ∪ {∞}. A discrete asymptotic type associated with the weight data (γ, θ) is a set P as in (4.1) that satisfies
n+1 πC P := {pj : j = 0, . . . , N } ⊂ z : n+1 2 − γ − θ < Re z < 2 − γ . The set of all such P we shall denote by As(γ, θ).
250
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
For P ∈ As(γ, θ) with θ < ∞ we form the space mj N EP (X ∧ ) = u(r, x) = ω(r) cjk (x)r−pj logk r : cjk ∈ Lj for all j, k , (4.2) j=0 k=0
which is of finite dimension and contained in S γ (X ∧ ). We equip EP (X ∧ ) with a norm by fixing an isomorphism EP (X ∧ ) ∼ = L0 ⊕ . . . ⊕ L0 ⊕ . . . ⊕ LN ⊕ . . . ⊕ LN ∼ = Cι(P ) ,
(m0 +1)-times
ι(P ) =
(mN +1)-times
(4.3)
N
(mj + 1) dim Lj .
j=0
For θ < ∞ and s ∈ R let us set 1
Kθs,γ (X ∧ ) = limj∈N Ks,γ+θ− 1+j (X ∧ ). (4.4) ←− This Fr´echet space is regarded as the subspace of functions which are flat of order θ with respect to the reference weight γ. Definition 4.2. Let s, γ ∈ R and P ∈ As(γ, θ) with θ < ∞. Then we define KPs,γ (X ∧ ) = Kθs,γ (X ∧ ) + EP (X ∧ ). Note that the sum in the previous definition is a direct sum. In the case P ∈ As(γ, ∞), we set Pk = {(p, m, L) ∈ P :
n+1 2
− γ − k < Re p} ∈ As(γ, k),
k ∈ N,
and then define (X ∧ ), SPγ (X ∧ ) = S γ (X ∧ ) ∩ KP∞,γ (X ∧ ). (4.5) KPs,γ (X ∧ ) = limk∈N KPs,γ k ←− All these spaces with asymptotics we endow with the group action {κλ }λ∈R+ from (3.3). Note that in the previous constructions, we also allow P ∈ As(γ, θ) to be the empty set. In this case, obviously, KPs,γ (X ∧ ) = Kθs,γ (X ∧ ). To unify notation, in this case we write Sθγ (X ∧ ) := SPγ (X ∧ ). 4.2. Edge Sobolev spaces We shall now introduce Sobolev spaces on Rq × X ∧ that will serve as the local models for corresponding Sobolev spaces on a manifold with edge. Definition 4.3. Let E be a Hilbert space with group action {κλ }λ∈R+ . Then the socalled abstract edge Sobolev space W s (Rq , E), s ∈ R, is defined as the completion of S (Rq , E) with respect to the norm 12 2 dη [η]2s κ−1 u (η) , u W s(Rq ,E) = [η] E where u (η) = (F u)(η) is the Fourier transform of u.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
251
The space W s (Rq , E) is then a Hilbert space with scalar product u, vW s (Rq ,E) = [η]2s κ−1 (η), κ−1 (η) E dη. [η] u [η] v In the special case of κλ = idE for all λ > 0, the edge Sobolev space W s (Rq , E) coincides with H s (Rq , E), the usual E-valued Sobolev space on Rq . Note that replacing in the previous definition [η] by η yields an equivalent norm on the space W s (Rq , E) and that s q s q L := F −1 κ−1 [η] F : W (R , E) −→ H (R , E)
(4.6)
is an isomorphism for each real s. Remark 4.4. If {κλ }λ∈R+ is a group action on E and κλ L (E) ≤ C max(λ−1 , λ)K for all λ > 0, cf. Remark 2.2, then W s+K (Rq , E) → H s (Rq , E) → W s−K (Rq , E). Analogous constructions make sense for a Fr´echet space E = limj∈N E j with ←− group action, cf. the notation after Remark 2. In this case we have the spaces W s (Rq , E) = lim W s (Rq , E j ) ←− j∈N
and a corresponding isomorphism (4.6). Example. Choosing E = Ks,γ (X ∧ ) or E = KPs,γ (X ∧ ) with the group action from (3.3), we obtain so-called weighted edge Sobolev spaces (with asymptotics) W s,γ (Rq × X ∧ ) := W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )), WPs,γ (Rq × X ∧ ) := W s (Rq , KPs,γ (X ∧ )). Remark 4.5. We can also form W s (Rq , Ks,γ;g (X ∧ )) with the spaces Ks,γ;g (X ∧ ) and the corresponding group action from Remark 3.2. In particular, for the case g = s − γ we obtain the spaces W s,γ (Rq × X ∧ ) := W s (Rq , K s,γ (X ∧ )). It then can be proved (cf. [16], [6]) that, for any cut-off function ω(r) ∈ C ∞ (R+ ), ω W s,γ (Rq × X ∧ ) = rγ ω W s,0 (Rq × X ∧ ). In our calculus we assume from now on, for convenience, that g = 0. However, note that the (analogous) results remain true for arbitrary g, especially, for the case g = s − γ. For purposes below we recall a continuity result of operators between abstract edge Sobolev spaces. be spaces endowed with group actions {κλ }λ∈R+ and Proposition 4.6. Let E and E for Ω = Rq be {˜ κλ }λ∈R+ , respectively. Moreover, let a(y, η) ∈ S µ (Ω × Rq ; E, E) independent of y for large |y|. Then Op(a) : S (Rq , E) −→ S (Rq , E),
252
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
and Op(a) extends for each s ∈ R to a continuous operator Op(a) : W s (Rq , E) −→ W s−µ (Rq , E). If E is the direct sum E = E0 + E1 of two closed subspaces, where {κλ }λ∈R+ restricts to a group action on E0 but E1 is not necessarily invariant under the group action, we obtain by (4.6) W s (Rq , E) = W s (Rq , E0 ) + V s (Rq , E1 ), V s (Rq , E1 ) := L−1 H s (Rq , E1 ).
(4.7)
This is also a direct decomposition into closed subspaces. If E0 is orthogonal to E1 , (4.7) is also an orthogonal decomposition. In fact, if b1 is the (orthogonal) projection in E onto E1 , then −1 (κ[η] b1 κ−1 P1 := Fη→y [η] )F = Op(p1 ),
p1 (η) = κ[η] b1 κ−1 [η] ,
(4.8)
is the (orthogonal) projection onto V s (Rq , E1 ) along W s (Rq , E0 ). Example. Let 0 < σ < ∞ and S ∈ As(γ − σ, σ) a finite asymptotic type. Then E1 := ES (X ∧ ) is not invariant under κλ from (3.3). Taking either E0 = Ks,γ (X ∧ ) or E0 = KPs,γ (X ∧ ) and E = E0 + E1 , the above construction yields spaces W s,γ (Rq × X ∧ )S = W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )) + V s (Rq , ES (X ∧ )), WPs,γ (Rq × X ∧ )S = W s (Rq , KPs,γ (X ∧ )) + V s (Rq , ES (X ∧ )).
(4.9)
Since ES (X ∧ ) ⊂ K∞,γ−σ (X ∧ ), these are both subspaces of W s,γ−σ (Rq × X ∧ ). In the situation of the previous example, we shall derive in Proposition 5.9 more precise information about the structure of the corresponding projection P1 from (4.8) and its symbol p1 (η). Remark 4.7. In our formalism we also want to admit the choice σ = 0. Then S is s,γ s,γ q ∧ q ∧ the empty set and we simply have W(P ) (R × X )S = W(P ) (R × X ). Let us stress that the difference between the regular and singular part P and S, respectively, of the asymptotic data is only determined by the position of the weight line, i.e., the choice of the reference weight γ such that Γ n+1 −γ has empty 2 intersection with both πC P and πC S. Changing γ amounts to changing the regular q ∧ and singular part, for example, WPs,γ (Rq × X ∧ )S = WPs,γ−σ ∪S (R × X ) when we replace γ by γ − σ. However, once the choice of γ is fixed, the regular and singular part are treated in our calculus in a completely different way.
5. The class of edge symbols of non-trivial type The aim of the present section is to introduce our new calculus with singular trace and Green operators, locally on a stretched wedge Ω × X ∧ . The global situation of a manifold with edges is studied in Section 6.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
253
Throughout the section we fix a weight γ ∈ R, real numbers µ and σ, τ ≥ 0, and endow C with the trivial group action, κλ ≡ 1 for all λ > 0, while all spaces on X ∧ carry the group action from (3.3). Also, we fix asymptotic types S = {(pj , mj , Lj )}j=0,...,N , πC S ⊂ z : n+1 2 − γ < Re z <
n+1 2
− (γ − σ) ,
T = {(pj , mj , Lj )}j=0,...,N , πC T ⊂ z : n+1 2 − (γ − µ) < Re z <
n+1 2
(5.1)
− (γ − µ − τ ) .
We write Ks,γ (X ∧ )S := Ks,γ (X ∧ ) + ES (X ∧ ), and set, for each η ∈ Rq , p1,S (η) = κ[η] bS κ−1 [η] ,
p0,S (η) = 1 − p1,S (η),
(5.2)
with bS being the projection in Ks,γ (X ∧ )S on ES (X ∧ ) along Ks,γ (X ∧ ), cf. (4.8). Analogous notation we use for spaces and projections associated with T and γ − µ. Maybe it would be more precise to include in the notation of p0,S (η) and p1,S (η) the smoothness-parameter s ∈ R. However, we shall not do so, since we may consider bS as the restriction to Ks,γ (X ∧ )S of the map u + v → v : K−∞,γ (X ∧ ) ⊕ ES (X ∧ ) → ES (X ∧ ). Hence pj,S (η) for small s restricts to the corresponding pj,S (η) for larger s. 5.1. Trace and potential symbols We begin with the intoduction and analysis of so-called singular trace symbols. Definition 5.1. A singular trace symbol of order ν (with respect to S and the weight datum γ) is an element t1 (y, η) ∈
∩ Sclν (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧)S , C)
s∈R
with the property that t1 (y, η) vanishes on Ks,γ (X ∧ ) for all (y, η). Note that when t1 (y, η) vanishes on Ks,γ (X ∧ ) for all (y, η), then also the homogeneous components t1,(ν−l) (y, η) vanish on Ks,γ (X ∧ ) for all l ∈ N. In fact, we have t1,(ν) (y, η) = lim λ−ν t1 (y, λη)κλ λ→∞
which yields the result for l = 0. In a similar manner we can argue for arbitrary l ∈ N. Singular trace symbols can be characterised in a more explicit way. But before we derive this description (cf. Proposition 5.4, below), let us first illustrate how the standard trace symbols of positive type in Boutet de Monvel’s algebra can be interpreted in this context.
254
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
Example. Consider the case X ∧ = R+ (i.e., dim X = 0) such that Ω × R+ (y, r) may be interpreted as the local model of a smooth manifold with boundary. It is known that for any γ > 12 with γ ∈ / 12 + N we have the identity S = {(j, 0) : j = 0, . . . , [γ − 12 ]};
H γ (R+ ) = Kγ,γ (R+ ) + ES (R+ ),
here we write [t] = max{m ∈ Z : m ≤ t} if t is a real number. ES (R+ ) consists of all finite Taylor polynomials [γ− 12 ]
u(r) = ω(r)
cj r j ,
cj ∈ C,
j=0
and has dimension [s − 12 ] + 1. Let us now fix 0 ≤ k ≤ [γ − 12 ] and define dk t1 : H γ (R+ ) −→ C, t1 u = k u. dr r=0 Obviously, t1 vanishes on Kγ,γ (R+ ). We consider t1 as a symbol independent of (y, η). It then satisfies the homogeneity relation 1
t1 u = λk+ 2 t1 κ−1 λ u k+ 12
which shows that t1 ∈ Scl
for all λ > 0,
(Ω × Rq ; Kγ,γ (R+ )S , C). Even more,
t1 ∈
∩ S k+ s∈R cl
1 2
(Rq ; Ks,γ (R+ )S , C),
(5.3)
by extending (for s < γ) t1 by vanishing on Ks,γ (R+ ). Thus we are in the above situation, here for σ = γ. Let us assume for the moment that the asymptotic type S only consists of a single triple (p, m, L) with p ∈ C satisfying Re p < n+1 2 − (γ − σ). Then m j ϕj (x) log r : ϕj ∈ L . ES (X ∧ ) = ω(r) r−p j=0
We shall now make use of the Mellin transform. It is defined by ∞ dr rz v(r) (M v)(z) = r 0 for v ∈ C0∞ (R+ ) and can be extended to various other spaces (for the basic properties of the Mellin transform we refer to [3]). For example, if ω1 is an arbitrary cut-off function then
s M ω1 : Ks,γ (X ∧ )S −→ A Re z > n+1 (5.4) 2 − γ \{p}, H (X) , where A(U, F ) denotes the holomorphic functions on U with values in F . In fact, if u ∈ Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , then v := M (ω1 u) has a pole in p of multiplicity m + 1. More precisely, if u(r, x) = ω(r) r−p ϕ(x) logk r, then the principal part of v is (−1)k k!ϕ(x)(z − p)−(k+1) . This allows us to compose (5.4) with the map 1 (z − p)k v(z) dz, 0≤k≤m (5.5) Bp,k : v → 2πi |z−p|<ε
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
255
where ε > 0 is chosen sufficiently small. The map Bp,k computes the Laurent coefficient of v at (z − p)−(k+1) which belongs to the space L. Now the following observation is obvious: Lemma 5.2. Let S be as in (5.1). Then any function t(y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × Rq , L (Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , C)) with t(y, η)|Ks,γ (X ∧ ) ≡ 0 has a unique representation as t(y, η) =
mj N
djk (y, η) ◦ Bpj ,k ◦ M ω1
j=0 k=0
with djk (y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × Rq , L∗j ), where L∗j denotes the dual space of Lj . In fact, given t(y, η), then (−1)k djk (y, η) ϕ = ϕ ∈ Lj . t(y, η) ω(r) r−pj ϕ logk r , k! Of course, the previous lemma has a corresponding formulation if we replace the parameter-space Ω × Rq by another one. A direct consequence of Lemma 5.2 is that singular trace symbols of order −∞ associated with the asymptotic type S are precisely of the form mj N 1 djk (y, η) (z − pj )k [M (ω1 u)](z) dz (5.6) t(y, η)u = 2πi |z−pj |=ε j=0 k=0
π S (Rq , L∗j ). Moreover, if t1 (y, η) is as in Definition 5.1 with djk (y, η) ∈ C (Ω) ⊗ and t1,(α) (y, η) is a homogeneous component, then ∞
α− n+1 2
t1,(α) (y, η)u =|η|
mj N
(α)
η djk (y, |η| )×
j=0 k=0
1 r (z − pj )k Mr→z (ω1 u)( |η| ) (z) dz × 2πi |z−pj |=ε α− n+1 2
=|η|
mj N
(5.7)
(α)
η djk (y, |η| )×
j=0 k=0
1 |η|z (z − pj )k [M (ω1 u)](z) dz × 2πi |z−p|=ε (α)
for functions djk (y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × S q−1 , L∗j ), where S q−1 denotes the unit-sphere in Rq . This follows by using the homogeneity relation η t1,(α) (y, η) = |η|α t1,(α) (y, |η| ) κ−1 |η|
together with the formula from Lemma 5.2 in the version for the unit-sphere. In fact, it is also true that if we define t1,(α) (y, η) by (5.7) with arbitrary functions (α) djk (y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω×S q−1 , L∗j ), then we obtain that t1,(α) (y, η) is a smooth function
256
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
on Ω×(Rq \{0}) with values in L (Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , C) that vanishes on Ks,γ (X ∧ ) and is twisted homogeneous of order α. The homogeneity is clear, the smoothness follows from the next result. Lemma 5.3. Let S be as in (5.1) and t : Ω × (Rq \ {0}) → L (Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , C) such that t(y, η)|Ks,γ (X ∧ ) ≡ 0. Then t(y, η) is a smooth function if and only if so is s(y, η) = t(y, η)κ−1 |η| . Proof. Let bS : Ks,γ (X ∧ )S → ES (X ∧ ) be the canonical projection along Ks,γ (X ∧ ). By the vanishing condition and the κλ -invariance of Ks,γ (X ∧ ) it is straightforward to verify that t(y, η) = t(y, η)κ−1 |η| bS κ|η| = s(y, η)(bS κ|η| ),
s(y, η) = t(y, η) κ−1 |η| .
So it remains to show that bS κλ ∈ L (ES (X ∧ )) depends smoothly on λ > 0, since from this it follows its smoothness as a function with values in L (Ks,γ (X ∧ )S ). However, if u(r, x) = ω(r)r−p ϕ(x) logj r, then (bS κλ u)(r, x) = ω(r)(λr)−p ϕ(x) logj (λr) = ω(r) r−p
j
cl (λ)ϕ(x) log l r
(5.8)
l=0
with cl (λ) = jl λ−p logj−l λ. This at once implies the requested smoothness.
There is an obvious analogous version of Lemma 5.3 by replacing Ω×(Rq \{0}) by Ω × Rq and κ|η| by κ[η] or κη . The above observations together with Remark 2.3 now lead to the announced explicit description of singular trace symbols. For this, let χ(η) be a zero excision function on Rq . Proposition 5.4. A function t1 (y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω×Rq , L (Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , C)) is a singular trace symbol of order ν in the sense of Definition 5.1, if and only if there exists a sequence of homogeneous components t1,(ν−l) , l ∈ N, of the form (5.7) (with α replaced by ν − l) such that for each given M ≥ 0 there exists an L ∈ N such that L the difference t1 (y, η) − χ(η)t1,(ν−l) (y, η) is of the form (5.6) with all djk (y, η) l=0
belonging to S −M (Ω × Rq ). Before defining our new class of trace symbols let us recall the structure of a trace symbol from the standard edge algebra: It is a symbol t0 (y, η) ∈
∩
s∈R
ν Scl (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ ), C),
such that the (pointwise) formal adjoint symbol satisfies, for some ε > 0, ν t0 (y, η)∗ ∈ Scl (Ω × Rq ; C, Sε−γ (X ∧ )).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
257
Definition 5.5. A trace symbol of order ν in the local edge calculus on X ∧ × Ω (with respect to S and the weight-datum γ) is an operator family t(y, η) such that t(y, η) ∈
∩
s∈R
ν Scl (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , C),
and t(y, η) has a representation t(y, η) = t0 (y, η) p0,S (η) + t1 (y, η) with a ν-th order singular trace symbol t1 (y, η) and a t0 (y, η) being a trace symbol in the standard edge symbol algebra as described above. If t1 (y, η) ≡ 0, we call t(y, η) also a regular trace symbol. Theorem 5.6. Let t(y, η) be a trace symbol as in Definition 5.5 for Ω = Rq , and let t(y, η) be independent of y for large |y|. Then Op(t) induces continuous operators Op(t) : W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )S ) → H s−ν (Rq ),
s ∈ R,
(5.9)
and we have
Op(t1 )u = 0 for all u ∈ W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )). (5.10) Moreover, the singular trace operators are localised at the edges (in contrast to the regular trace operators), i.e., if v ∈ W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )S ) vanishes in a neighbourhood of r = 0 then Op(t1 )v = 0.
Proof. Property (5.9) follows from Proposition 5.9 (see below) and Proposition 4.6, noting that W s (Rq , C) = H s (Rq ). Relation (5.10) holds true, since t1 (y, η) u(η) ≡ 0 for any u ∈ S (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )). For the latter statement note that the vanishing of v near r = 0 implies that, in fact, v ∈ W s (Ω, Ks,γ (X ∧ )). Then apply (5.10). We finish this section by defining potential symbols. For their definition it will be convenient to use the notation Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T = Sεγ−µ (X ∧ ) ⊕ ET (X ∧ ),
ε > 0.
(5.11)
Definition 5.7. A potential symbol of order ν (with respect to T and the weightdatum γ − µ) is a symbol ν (Ω × Rq ; C, Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T ) k(y, η) ∈ Scl
(5.12)
for some ε = ε(k) > 0. If we write k(y, η) = p0,T (η)k(y, η) + p1,T (η)k(y, η) then the first summand is a potential symbol from the usual edge-algebra associated with the weight-datum γ − µ. Also potential symbols can be characterized in a more explicit way. In fact, symbols (5.12) are precisely those of the form C c → [η]
n+1 2
k(y, η; r[η], x) c ∈ Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T
with a symbol kernel ν ∧ π Sεγ−µ (X(r,x) k(y, η; r, x) ∈ Scl (Ω × Rq ) ⊗ )T .
258
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
5.2. Parameter-dependent families of projections We now investigate more deeply the pseudodifferential structure of the family of projections p1,S (η), cf. (5.2). Let us define, for 0 ≤ j ≤ N and 0 ≤ k ≤ mj , zero order symbols by k n+1 (−1) 1 tjk (η)u = [η]− 2 (z − pj )k M (ω1 u(r/[η]))(z) dz. k! 2πi |z−pj |=ε Using the unitary isomorphism ES (X ∧ ) ∼ = Cι(S) , see (4.3), this gives rise to a map t(η) = tS (η) := (tjk (η)) 0≤j≤N, : Ks,γ (X ∧ )S −→ Cι(S) . 0≤k≤mj
0 q s,γ We have t(λη) = t(η)κ−1 (X ∧ )S , Cι(S) ) λ for λ ≥ 1, |η| ≥ 1, hence t(η) ∈ Scl (R ; K (in fact, each component of t(η) is a singular trace symbol). Moreover, let us define a (system of) potential symbols
k(η) = kS (η) : Cι(S) −→ Ks,γ (X ∧ )S by setting, for each c = (cjk ) 0≤j≤N, ∈ Cι(S) , 0≤k≤mj
k(η)c = [η]
n+1 2
ω(r[η])
mj N
cjk (r[η])−pj logk (r[η])
j=0 k=0
(on the right-hand side we have identified cjk with an element in Lj , using the identification (4.3)). We then have k(λη) = κλ k(η) for λ ≥ 1, |η| ≥ 1 which entails 0 k(η) ∈ Scl (Rq ; Cι(S) , Ks,γ (X ∧ )S ). By construction, t(η)k(η) = idCι(S) for all η ∈ Rq , hence k(η)t(η) : Ks,γ (X ∧ )S −→ Ks,γ (X ∧ )S
(5.13)
is a family of continuous projections. Lemma 5.8. If k(η) and t(η) are constructed as above, then p0,S (η) = 1 − k(η) t(η)
for all η ∈ Rq .
(5.14)
Proof. By conjugation with κ[η] the claim is equivalent to showing that bS = (κ−1 [η] k(η))(t(η)κ[η] ) for each η. However, this is true, since the first factor on the right-hand side is the map mj N c = (cjk ) → ω(r) cjk r−pj logk r, j=0 k=0
while the second factor equals (tjk ) with (−1)k 1 (z − pj )k M (ω1 u)(z) dz. tjk u = k! 2πi |z−pj |=ε
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
259
By straightforward calculation, for any u ∈ Ks,γ (X ∧ ), mj N p0,S (η) u + ω(r) cjk r−pj logk r j=0 k=0 mj N cjk r−pj logk r. = u + ω(r) − ω(r[η])
(5.15)
j=0 k=0
From this formula and by Lemma 5.8 we deduce the following: 0 Proposition 5.9. Let s ∈ R. Then p0,S (η) ∈ Scl (Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , Ks,γ (X ∧ )) and
Op(p0,S ) : W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )S ) −→ W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )S ) is the projection onto W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ )) along V s (Rq , ES (X ∧ )). Moreover, −|α|
Dηα p0,S (η) ∈ Scl (cf. (3.4)), and
(Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , S ∞ (X ∧ ))
Dηα p0,S (η)
vanishes on K
s,γ
for all |α| ≥ 1
(5.16)
∧
(X ) for each η.
In the terminology introduced in the next section, (5.16) means that Dηα p0,S (η) is a singular Green symbol of order −|α| whenever |α| ≥ 1. 5.3. Regular and singular Green symbols Besides trace and potential symbols there is another category of so-called Green symbols needed for our new calculus. They are build up from regular and singular Green symbols. Definition 5.10. A singular Green symbol of order ν (with respect to S, T , and the weight-datum (γ, γ − µ, θ)) is a symbol g1 (y, η) ∈
∩
s∈R
ν Scl (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T )
(see (5.11) for the notation) that vanishes on Ks,γ (X ∧ ) for all (y, η), and where ε = ε(g1 ) > 0. Along the lines of the material from Section 5.1, singular Green symbols have a more explicit representation: If g1 (y, η) is as in Definition 5.10, all homogeneous components g1,(ν−j) , j ∈ N, pointwise vanish on Ks,γ (X ∧ ). If S is as in (5.1) then g1,(ν−j) (y, η) = |η|
ν−j
mj N
η κ|η| ◦ ejk (y, |η| ) ◦ Bpj ,k ◦ Mγ−σ− n2 ◦ κ−1 |η| ◦ ω1
j=0 k=0
: Ks,γ (X ∧ )S → Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T , where Bp,k is as in the formula (5.5) and with uniquely determined functions ejk (y, η) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × S q−1 , L (Lj , Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T )). Identifying ejk (y, η) with an
L∗j -valued
function
∗ π Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T ⊗ π L∗j , (y, η; r, x) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × S q−1 ) ⊗ ljk
(5.17)
260
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
we obtain [g1,(ν−j) (y, η)u](r, x) =|η|
n+1 2 +ν−j
mj N
η ∗ ljk (y, |η| ; r|η|, x)×
j=0 k=0
1 (z − pj )k Mr →z (κ−1 ω1 u) (z)dz . × |η| 2πi |z−pj |=ε (5.18) In other words, each homogeneous component of a singular Green symbol has a unique representation as a finite linear combination of summands that are the (pointwise) composition of homogeneous components of a singular trace symbol and a potential symbol. Definition 5.11. A Green symbol of order ν (with respect to S, T , and the weightdatum (γ, γ − µ, θ)) in the local edge calculus on X ∧ × Ω is any operator function
∩ Sclν (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , K∞,γ−µ (X ∧ )T )
g(y, η) ∈
s∈R
which has a representation g(y, η) = g0 (y, η) p0,S (η) + g1 (y, η), where g1 (y, η) is a singular Green symbol and, for some ε = ε(g0 ) > 0, g0 (y, η) ∈ g0 (y, η)∗ ∈
∩ Sclν (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ ), Sεγ−µ (X ∧ )T ),
s∈R
∩ Sclν (Ω × Rq ; Ks,−γ+µ+τ (X ∧ ), Sε−γ (X ∧ )),
s∈R
where ∗ refers to the pointwise adjoint with respect to the K0,0 (X ∧ ) scalar product. If g1 (y, η) ≡ 0, we call g(y, η) a regular Green symbol. Note that if g0 (y, η) is as in the previous definition, then p0,T (η) g0 (y, η) ∈ RνG (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)) is a Green symbol from the standard edge algebra, cf. Section 8. Example. The pointwise composition g(y, η) := k(y, η) t(y, η) of a ν0 -th order trace symbol and a ν1 -th order potential symbol in the sense of Definitions 5.5 and 5.7, respectively, is a Green symbol of order ν = ν0 + ν1 in the sense of the Definition 5.11. We shall also consider vector-valued variants of trace, potential, and Green symbols, i.e. t(y, η) : Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S −→ Cj+ , k(y, η) : Cj− −→ Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T , g(y, η) : Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S −→ Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
261
k
where Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck ) = ⊕ Ks,γ (X ∧ ), and analogously for the other spaces. This is j=1
achieved by considering matrices of corresponding size, whose entries are all trace, potential, or Green symbols of same order and with respect to the same data. Definition 5.12. Let 1 ≤ k, l ∈ N and j+ , j− ∈ N (possibly also 0). Then RνG (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T denotes the space of all (2 × 2)-block matrix symbols g (y, η) g(y, η) = 11 g21 (y, η)
Ks−ν,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S ⊕ −→ ⊕ , : Cj− Cj+ (5.19) where g11 (y, η) is an (l × k)-matrix of ν-th order Green symbols, g21 (y, η) is an (j+ × k)-matrix of ν-th order trace symbols, g12 (y, η) is an (l × j− )-matrix of ν-th order potential symbols (all with respect to S, T and the weight-datum (γ, γ − µ), ν (Ω × Rq ). and g22 (y, η) is an (j+ × j− )-matrix of scalar symbols from Scl g12 (y, η) g22 (y, η)
To have a convenient terminology at hand, we shall call symbols (5.19) again Green symbols. Note that they are particular operator-valued symbols ν g(y, η) ∈ Scl (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S ⊕ Cj− , S γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T ⊕ Cj+ ).
(5.20)
5.4. The full symbol class and its calculus For the following recall that Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ ) is a subspace of Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ )T . Definition 5.13. Let ν ∈ R with µ − ν ∈ N. The space Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T consists of all symbols a(y, η) of the form a0 (y, η) p0,S (η) a(y, η) = 0
Ks−ν,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S 0 ⊕ ⊕ −→ + g(y, η) : 0 Cj− Cj+ (5.21) with an arbitrary standard edge symbol a0 (y, η) ∈ Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)) (cf. Section 8), and some Green symbol g(y, η) ∈ RνG (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l, j− , j+ ))S,T . Observe that then, for every s ∈ R, Rν (Ω × Rq ;(γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T ⊂ ⊂ S ν (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S ⊕ Cj− , Ks−ν,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T ⊕ Cj+ ).
262
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
Thus if Ω = Rq and a(y, η) as in (5.21) is independent of y for large |y|, then it induces, for each s ∈ R, continuous operators W s−ν (Rq , Ks−ν,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T ) W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S ) −→ . ⊕ ⊕ Op(a) : H s (Rq , Cj− ) H s−ν (Rq , Cj+ ) Definition 5.14. For a(y, η) ∈ Rµ (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T we set σ∧ (a0 )(y, η) σ∧ (p0,S )(η) 0 σ∧ (a)(y, η) = + σ∧ (g)(y, η), 0 0 where σ∧ (a0 ) is the standard principal edge symbol (cf. Section 8) and σ∧ (p0,S )(η) := 1 − κ|η| bS κ−1 |η| . Moreover, σ∧ (g)(y, η) denotes the homogeneous principal symbol of g(y, η) as a classical symbol of order µ, cf. (5.20). We call σ∧ (a)(y, η) the principal edge symbol of a(y, η). From this definition if follows that σ∧ (a)(y, λη) = λµ diag(κλ , idCj+ ) σ∧ (a)(y, η) diag(κ−1 λ , idCj− ) as a family of operators Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S ⊕ Cj+ → Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T ⊕ Cj− with n+1 the usual group action defined by (κλ u)(r, x) = λ 2 u(λr, x) for λ ∈ R+ . Definition 5.15. Let a(y, η) ∈ Rµ (Ω×Rq ; (γ, γ −µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T be as in (5.21) (with ν = µ). Then we define the conormal symbol of a as σM (a)(y, z) = σM (a0 )(y, z), where σM (a0 ) denotes the standard conormal symbol, cf. Section 8. Proposition 5.16. If a(y, η) ∈ Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T then ∂ηα ∂yβ a(y, η) ∈ Rν−|α| (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T for any multi-indices α, β ∈ Nq . Theorem 5.17. For j ∈ N let aj (y, η) ∈ Rν−j (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T such that the ε-weights involved in the Green symbol parts of each aj are independent of j. Then there exists a symbol a(y, η) ∈ Rν (Ω×Rq ; (γ, γ−µ), (k, l; j−, j+ ))S,T such that, for all N ∈ N, a(y, η) −
N −1
aj (y, η) ∈ Rν−N (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T .
j=0
Proposition 5.18. The pointwise composition of l; j− , j+ ))S,R a(y, η) ∈ Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, and
(y, η) ∈ Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ − µ, γ − µ − µ a ), ( l, l; j+ , j+ ))R,T
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
263
yields a symbol (y, η)a(y, η) ∈ Rν+ν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ − µ a ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T . Theorem 5.19. Let the notation be as in the previous Proposition 5.18 with Ω = Rq (y, η) and a(y, η) be independent of y for large |y|. Then there exists a and both a symbol ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T , ( a#a)(y, η) ∈ Rν+ν (Rq × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ − µ and a, such that Op( the so-called Leibniz-product of a a)Op(a) = Op( a#a). If ν = µ and ν = µ then a#a)(y, η) = σ∧ ( a)(y, η)σ∧ (a)(y, η), σ∧ ( σM ( a#a)(y, z) = (T µ σM ( a))(y, z) σM (a)(y, z), where T σ acts on functions by shifting the argument, (T σ f )(z) = f (z + σ). The proofs of Propositions 5.16, 5.18 and Theorems 5.17, 5.19 are somewhat lengthy and laborious, nevertheless elementary in the sense that they only rely on the correponding properties of standard edge symbols and general operator-valued symbols (and (5.16) for Proposition 5.16). Therefore we omit these proofs.
6. Operators of non-trivial type on manifolds with edges Let us begin this section by introducing a useful notation that we shall use frequently throughout the sequel: If u, v are real-valued, continuous functions on a topological space, we shall write u ≺ v if v ≡ 1 on an open neighborhood containing the support of u. 6.1. Manifolds with edges and Sobolev spaces The analysis of our classes of edge-pseudodifferential operators takes place on (the interior of) a smooth manifold with boundary M, that near the boundary has the structure of a fibre bundle over a smooth closed base space and where the fibre is a cone over a smooth closed manifold (both base space and cross section of the cone without boundary). For simplicity, we shall assume in this paper that this bundle is trivial. In case of trivial cross section (i.e., a point) we obtain a usual manifold with smooth boundary. More precisely, there exists a homeomorphism of a neighborhood V of ∂M to Y × [0, 1) × X, where X and Y are smooth closed manifolds, that restricts to a diffeomorphism between V \ ∂M and Y × (0, 1) × X. This gives rise to a splitting of coordinates that we shall keep fixed from now on. By identifying points (y, 0, x) and (y, 0, x ) for any x, x ∈ X, we may obtain from M a topological space M which is regarded as a manifold with edge Y and model-cone X ∧ . In order to emphasise this geometric structure, we shall often write M instead of M. We shall now define weighted edge Sobolev spaces with and without asymptotics. To this end we assume that the asymptotic type S is as in (5.1) but,
264
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
additionally satisfies the so-called shadow condition: If (p, m, L) ∈ S and Re p−1 ≥ n+1 ∈ S with p = p − 1, m ≤ m This p, m, L) and L ⊂ L. 2 − γ then there exists ( property ensures, in particular, that the operator of multiplication by any function ϕ ∈ S (R+ ) maps Ks,γ (X ∧ )S into itself. Let us fix a covering of Y by coordinate systems χj : U j ⊂ Y → Ω j ⊂ R q ,
j = 1, . . . , N,
C0∞ (Uj )
such that ϕ1 , . . . , ϕN form a partition and a system of functions ϕj , ψj ∈ of unity, and ϕj ≺ ψj for each 1 ≤ j ≤ N . Moreover, ω ∈ C0∞ ([0, 1[) is a cutoff function, and we consider (1 − ω) as a function on M that vanishes near the boundary as well as a function on the double 2M (by extension by 0). Definition 6.1. The space W s,γ;g (M ) for g, s, γ ∈ R consists of all distributions u on M \ ∂M such that (1 − ω)u ∈ H s (2M) and χj∗ (ϕj ωu) ∈ W s (Rq , Ks,γ;g (X ∧ ))
for all 1 ≤ j ≤ N
(6.1)
(cf. Remark 4.5), where χj∗ denotes the push-forward of distributions from Uj × (0, 1) × X to Ωj × (0, 1) × X under the map (y, r, x) → (χj (y), r, x). In an analogous manner we define W s,γ;g (M )S and subspaces Wεs,γ;g (M )(S) for some ε > 0. Up to equivalence of norms, the previous definitions are independent of the involved data (cut-off function, partition of unity, etc.), see Theorems 4 and 19 in Section 3.2.5 of [11]. Clearly Definition 6.1 has a straightforward extension to sections of vector-bundles E over M , yielding a scale W s,γ;g (M, E). For simplicity of the presentation, however, we shall restrict ourselves to trivial bundles, i.e., k
W s,γ;g (M, Ck )(S) = ⊕ W s,γ;g (M )(S) j=1
and analogously subspaces with asymptotics Q ∈ As(γ, θ). In the following, we again restrict ourselves to the case g = 0, having in mind that the (analogous) results remain valid also for arbitrary g, in particular, for g = s − γ. 6.2. Global projections in edge Sobolev spaces with asymptotics In the construction of our new symbol algebra we made often use of the canonical splitting W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S ) = W s (Rq , Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )) ⊕ V s (Rq , ES (X ∧ , Ck )) and the corresponding projection Op(p0,S ). Passing to the manifold with edges W , we canonically can speak of W s,γ (M, Ck )S and its subspace W s,γ (M, Ck ), but there is not such a canonical choice of a complementing space. To overcome this problem, we shall prove in this subsection the following Theorem 6.2. Theorem 6.2. There exists an operator P0,S = P0,S (k) having the following properties, simultaneously for all s ∈ R:
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
265
a) P0,S ∈ L (W s,γ (M, Ck )S ) is a projection onto W s,γ (M, Ck ). Moreover, P0,S is a pseudodifferential operator in the following sense: b) If ϕ, ψ ∈ C ∞ (M) are located in a chart U × [0, 1) × X with coordinate map χ : U → Ω ⊂ Rq , then ϕ P0,S ψ = ϕ χ∗ Op(p0,S + r) ψ, where p0,S (η) is as in (5.2) (with [η] now referring to the local expression for a smoothed norm function on the cotangent bundle of the edge Y ), −1 r(y, η) ∈ Scl (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S , S ∞ (X ∧ , Ck )),
and r(y, η) ≡ 0 on Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck ). c) If ω1 , ω2 ∈ C ∞ ([0, 1[) are cut-off functions with ω2 ≺ ω1 then (1 − ω1 ) P0,S ω2 , ω2 P0,S (1 − ω1 ) : W s,γ (M, Ck )S −→ W ∞,∞ (M, Ck ), both vanishing on W s,γ (M, Ck ). d) If ω1 , ω2 ∈ C ∞ ([0, 1[) are cut-off functions and ϕ1 , ϕ2 ∈ C ∞ (Y ) have disjoint support, then (ω1 ϕ1 ) P0,S (ω2 ϕ2 ) : W s,γ (M, Ck )S −→ W ∞,∞ (M, Ck ), vanishing on W s,γ (M, Ck ). In b), χ∗ denotes the operator pull-back under the map (y, r, x) → (χ(y), r, x). By virtue of property a), we have that P0,S ϕ = ϕ whenever ϕ ∈ C ∞ (M) vanishes to infinite order at the boundary (respectively to sufficiently high order, depending on the asymptotic type S). Property b) of the previous theorem says that locally, near the edge, P0,S coincides with Op(p0,S ), cf. Proposition 5.9, modulo a singular Green operator of order −1, that additionally generates infinite flatness. In particular, the local edge symbols σ∧ (p0,S )(y, η) globally lead to a vector-bundle homomorphism σ∧ (P0,S ) : (T ∗ Y \ 0) × Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S −→ (T ∗ Y \ 0) × Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S .
(6.2)
Note that different choices of projections, say P0,S and P0,S , having the properties stated in the theorem give rise to the same principal edge symbol (6.2). Moreover, P0,S − P0,S : W s,γ (M, Ck )S −→ W s−1,∞ (M, Ck ), vanishing on W s,γ (M, Ck ). Proof of Theorem 6.2. Without loss of generality we assume k = 1. Recall that we have identified a collar neighbourhood of ∂M in M with Y × N
[0, 1[×X. Let us fix a covering Y = ∪ Ui with coordinate charts χi : Ui → Ωi ⊂ Rq i=1
and a subordinate partition of unity {ϕi ∈ C0∞ (Ui ) : i = 1, . . . , N }. Moreover choose ψi ∈ C0∞ (Ui ) with ϕi ≺ ψi , and let ω, ω ∈ C0∞ ([0, 1[) be cut-off functions
266
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
(viewed as functions on M, supported near the boundary) with ω ≺ ω . Then we set N P0,S = (ωϕi ) χi∗ Op(p0,i ) (ψi ω ) + (1−ω), p0,i (y, η) = 1−κ[η] bS κ−1 [η] , (6.3) i=1
with [η] denoting the expression in local coordinates y ∈ Ωi of a smoothed norm function on the cotangent-bundle over Y , and bS being the projection in Ks,γ (X ∧ )S onto ES (X ∧ ) along Ks,γ (X ∧ ), cf. (5.2). By construction, it is clear that P0,S = 1 on W s,γ (M ) and that P0,S from s,γ W (M )S to W s,γ (M ) is onto. Since W s,γ (M ) is a closed subspace of W s,γ (M )S , we obtain a). For b) we first have a look how an operator of the form Op(p0,i ) behaves under coordinate changes (in the edge variable). By the standard formula of expressing a pseudodifferential operator in new coordinates, 1 (Dηα p)(y, t χ (y)ξ) Dzα eiκ(y,z)ξ z=y (χ∗ p)(x, ξ)x=χ(y) ∼ α! α with κ(y, z) = χ(z)−χ(y)−χ (y)(z −y), applied to p0,i and using (5.16), we obtain that Op(p0,i ) on (Ωi ∩ Ω) × X ∧ under the coordinate change χi ◦ χ transforms to Op(p0,S + r) with p0,S and r as described in the statement. Thus, choosing a cut-off function ω0 with ω0 ≺ ω and using P0,S (1 − ω0 ) = (1 − ω0 ), we find ϕ P0,S ψ = ϕ P0,S ω0 ψ + ϕ (1 − ω0 ) ψ = ϕ χ∗ Op(p0,S + r) ω0 ψ + ϕ (1 − ω0 ) ψ. By the properties of p0,S and r we find ϕ χ∗ Op(p0,S +r) (ω0 −1) ψ = −ϕ (1−ω0 ) ψ and this obviously yields ϕ P0,S ψ = ϕ χ∗ Op(p0,S + r) ψ. c), d) First of all, observe that all operators in question vanish on W s,γ (M ), since on that space P0,S coincides with the identity operator. For the same reason, we even have ω2 P0,S (1 − ω1 ) = 0 on W s,γ (M )S . By definition of P0,S in (6.3), the statement will follow if we verify corresponding properties for the local operators R1 := (1 − ω1 ) Op(p0,i ) ω2 and R2 := ϕ 1 Op(p0,i ) ϕ 2 , where ϕ 1 , ϕ 2 ∈ C ∞ (Ωi ) have disjoint support. To show this let, without loss of generality, Ωi = Rq and [·] be independent of y for large |y|. By using the explicit representation (5.15), and writing (1 − ω1 ) = tN (t−N (1 − ω1 )) for arbitrary N ∈ N, it is straightforward to see that R1 = Op(r1 ) with a symbol r1 ∈ S −N (Rq × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ )S , S ∞ (X ∧ )). This yields R1 : W s,γ (Rq × X ∧ )S → W ∞,∞ (Rq × X ∧ ). The same is true for R2 , using integration by parts and (5.16).
Remark 6.3. Adapting methods and results of [2] that show that, for a smooth com1 pact manifold Ω with boundary, H s (Ω)/H0s (Ω) is isomorphic to H s (∂Ω, C[s− 2 ] ), where H0s (Ω) denotes the closure of C0∞ (int Ω) in H s (Ω), one can show that ∼ H s (Y, Ck ⊗ Cι(S) ), ∼ W s,γ (M, Ck )S W s,γ (M, Ck ) = ker P0,S = where ι(S) is the dimension of ES (X ∧ ), cf. (4.3).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
267
6.3. Global regular and singular Green operators The full algebra of operators on a manifold with edges will consist, roughly speaking, of pseudodifferential operators that locally near the edge can be represented as an operator with symbol from the edge symbol algebra introduced in Definition 5.13. There are also non-local operators in this algebra which we shall introduce first. Definition 6.4. A smoothing operator (associated with asymptotic types S, T , vector bundles Ck , Cl , J− , J+ , and with weight-data (γ, γ − µ)) is an operator C such that, for all s ∈ R, C = C0
P0,S 0
0 C11 + 1 C21
W s,γ (M, Ck )S W ∞,γ−µ (M, Cl )T 0 ⊕ ⊕ −→ : 0 H s (Y, J− ) H ∞ (Y, J+ )
(6.4)
where a) P0,S is a projection as in Theorem 6.2, b) both C11 and C21 vanish on W s,γ (M, Ck ), and there exists an ε = ε(C11 ) > 0 such that C11 : W s,γ (M, Ck ) → Wε∞,γ−µ (M, Cl )T , c) for any r ∈ R W r,γ (M, Ck ) Wε∞,γ−µ (M, Cl )T ⊕ C0 : ⊕ −→ H r (Y, J− ) H ∞ (Y, J+ ) for some ε = ε(C0 ) > 0, while its adjoint C0∗ induces maps C0∗
Wε∞,−γ (M, Ck ) W r,−γ+µ+τ (M, Cl ) ⊕ ⊕ −→ . : H r (Y, J+ ) H ∞ (Y, J− )
The space of all such operators we shall denote by Y −∞ (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T . If in (6.4) we can choose C11 = 0 and C21 = 0, we call C0 a regular smoothing 0 C11 C12 operator. If C0 is represented as a block matrix, C0 = , and we can 0 0 C21 C22 0 0 = 0 and C21 = 0, we call C a singular smoothing operator. choose in (6.4) both C11 Let us remark that – after fixing the choice of P0,S – the decomposition (6.4) uniquely determines C0 , C11 , and C21 . N
For the definition of global Green operators let Y = ∪ Ui with coordinate i=1
charts χi : Ui → Ωi ⊂ Rq over which J± is trivial with corresponding trivializations χi,± : J± Ui −→ Ωi × Cj± . Let ϕ1 , . . . , ϕN be a corresponding partition of unity on Y and ψi ∈ C0∞ (Ui ) such that ϕi ≺ ψi . Moreover, let ω, ω ∈ C0∞ ([0, 1)) be cut-off functions with ω ≺ ω .
268
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
Definition 6.5. A Green operator of order ν ∈ R (associated with asymptotic types S, T , vector bundles Ck , Cl , J− , J+ , and with weight-data (γ, γ − µ)) is any operator G of the form N ωϕi ◦ χ∗i 0 (χi )∗ ◦ ωψi 0 G= Op(gi ) + C (6.5) 0 ϕi ◦ χ∗i,+ 0 (χi,− )∗ ◦ ψi i=1
(χ∗ and χ∗ denote the pull-back and push-forward, respectively, of sections under χ), where C is a smoothing operator in the sense of Definition 6.4 and each gi is a ν-th order Green symbol as in Definition 5.12, gi ∈ RνG (Ωi × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T . The space of all such operators is denoted by ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T YG
6.4. The algebra of edge operators on W Definition 6.6. Let µ, ν ∈ R with µ − ν ∈ N. The space Y ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T consists of all operators W s−µ,γ−µ (M, Cl )T W s,γ (M, Ck )S A P0,S 0 −→ A= ⊕ ⊕ + G: 0 0 H s (Y, J− ) H s−µ (Y, J+ )
(6.6)
ν where P0,S is as in Theorem 6.2, G ∈ YG (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T , and A is an operator from the standard edge algebra Y ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)), cf. Section 8.
Remark 6.7. Throughout the paper we admit also the case σ = τ = 0, i.e., that the asymptotic types S and T disappear, cf. Remark 4.7. In that case we recover the standard edge algebra Y ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ )). Similarly as in (6.5), each operator A ∈ Y ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T can be expressed locally near the edge in terms of edge symbols belonging to Rν (Ωi × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; j− , j+ ))S,T . Definition 6.8. Let A ∈ Y µ (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T be as in (6.6) with ν = µ. Let us denote by πY : T ∗ Y \ 0 → Y the canonical projection. Then the principal edge symbol of A is the vector-bundle homomorphism σ∧ (A) σ∧ (P0,S ) 0 σ∧ (A) = + σ∧ (G) : 0 0 s,γ ∧ k s−µ,γ−µ ∧ l (6.7) (X , C )T K (X , C )S K ∗ ∗ ⊕ ⊕ πY −→ πY , s ∈ R, J− J+ where σ∧ (A) is the principal edge symbol of standard edge operators, cf. Section 8, and σ∧ (P0,S ) is as in (6.2). Moreover, the conormal symbol of A is, by definition, σM (A)(y, z) = σM (A)(y, z) : H s (X) −→ H s−µ (X), where y ∈ Y and z ∈ C with Re z =
n+1 2
− γ, cf. Section 8.
s ∈ R,
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
269
Occasionally, we prefer to write the action of the principal edge symbol in each fibre, i.e., Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )T ⊕ −→ ⊕ , σ∧ (A)(y, η) : J−,y J+,y
(y, η) ∈ T ∗ Y \0. (6.8)
Besides principal edge and conormal symbol we have the standard interior pseudodifferential symbol σψ (A) := σψ (A) ∈ C ∞ T ∗ (M \ Y ) \ 0 , cf. (8.8), and the rescaled symbol
σ ψ (A) := σ ψ (A) ∈ C ∞ (T ∗ ∂M × R) \ 0 ,
cf. (8.9). Based on the algebra property of the standard edge algebra and the composition result Theorem 5.19, one can show the following: l; J− , J+ ))S,R and A ∈ Y ν (M ; (γ − Theorem 6.9. Let A ∈ Y ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, µ, γ − µ − µ ), ( l, l; J+ , J+ ))R,T . Then ∈ Y ν+ν (M ; (γ, γ − µ − µ AA ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T . Moreover, in case ν = µ and ν = µ , σ∧ (AA)(y, η) = σ∧ (A)(y, η)σ∧ (A)(y, η), z) = (T µ σM (A))(y, z)σM (A)(y, z), σM (AA)(y, where T σ is the shift operator, (T σ f )(z) = f (z + σ). Similarly, using Theorem 5.17, we have: ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T such Theorem 6.10. For j ∈ N let Aj ∈ Y µ−j (M ; (γ, γ − µ − µ that the ε-weights involved in the Green parts of each Aj do not dependent on j. Then there exists an operator A ∈ Y µ (M ; (γ, γ − µ − µ ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T such that, for all N ∈ N, A−
N −1
Aj ∈ Y µ−N (M ; (γ, γ − µ − µ ), (k, l; J− , J+ ))S,T .
j=0
7. Ellipticity and parametrix In this section we introduce the notion of ellipticity in the edge calculus with singular trace and Green operators and show that elliptic operators possess a parametrix within the calculus. As a preliminary step, we consider in Section 7.1 the subalgebra of operators which coincide with the identity modulo Green operators. The general case is then treated in the subsequent Section 7.2.
270
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
Definition 7.1. An operator A ∈ Y µ (M, (γ, γ−µ), (k, k; J− , J+ ))S,T is called elliptic if ψ (A) are pointwise invertible on T ∗ (M \Y )\0 and (T ∗ ∂M×R)\0, (i) σψ (A) and σ respectively, (ii) σ∧ (A)(y, η) defines isomorphisms (6.8) for all (y, η) ∈ T ∗ Y \0 and some s ∈ R. A11 A12 Note that if A = is elliptic, then A21 A22 σ∧ (A11 )(y, η) : Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck )S −→ Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ , Ck )T
(7.1)
is a family of Fredholm operators of index j+ − j− , where j± denotes the fibre dimensions of J± . Under the ellipticity assumption (i), the Fredholm property of (7.1) in turn is equivalent to the bijectivity of the subordinate conormal symbol σM (A)(y, z) : H s (X) → H s−µ (X),
s ∈ R,
for all y ∈ Y and z ∈ Γ n+1 −γ . In particular, it does not depend on the choice of S 2 and T , and the conormal symbol might have non-bijectivity points on the weight line Γ n+1 −(γ−σ) (with σ corresponding to the type S). 2
7.1. The inverse of identity plus Green symbol For the following statement we use the notation I = diag(1, 1). 0 Proposition 7.2. Let G ∈ YG (M, (γ, γ), (k, k; J, J))S,S such that σ∧ (I + G)(y, η) = I + σ∧ (G)(y, η) is an isomorphism for each y and η = 0. Then there exists a 0 (M, (γ, γ), (k, k; J, J))S,S such that C ∈ YG
(I + σ∧ (G)(y, η))−1 = I + σ∧ (C)(y, η)
for all (y, η) ∈ T ∗ Y \0.
Proof. For notational simplicity let k = 1. Without loss of generality, we may assume γ = 0. Let us write 1 + G11 I + σ∧ (G)(y, η) =: G21
K0,0 (X ∧ )S K0,0 (X ∧ )S G12 ⊕ ⊕ (y, η) : −→ G22 J J
(7.2)
and let us suppress (y, η) from the notation for a while. Since the following considerations are local in (y, η), we assume that J = Cj for some j ∈ N. Let bS be the projection in K0,0 (X ∧ )S onto ES (X ∧ ) along K0,0 (X ∧ ), cf. (5.2) K0,0 (X ∧ ) 1 − bS 0,0 ∧ ⊕ is an isomorphism with : K (X )S → and (5.14). Then bS ∧ E (X ) S 1 − bS 0 0 and form the isomorphism the inverse (l0 l1 ). We then set B := bS 0 1
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
271
B(I + σ∧ (G))B−1 which equals
b0 (1 + G11 )l0 b1 G21 l0 G21 l0
b0 (1 + G11 )l1 b1 G21 l1 G21 l1
K0,0 (X ∧ ) K0,0 (X ∧ ) ⊕ ⊕ b0 G12 b1 G12 : ES (X ∧ ) −→ ES (X ∧ ) . G22 ⊕ ⊕ Cj Cj
(7.3)
Using an isomorphism ES (X ∧ ) ∼ = Cι(S) , cf. (4.3), and writing G := b0 G11 l0 , we transform (7.3) to the form K0,0 (X ∧ ) K0,0 (X ∧ ) 1 + G H12 ⊕ ⊕ −→ . (7.4) : H21 H22 Cι(S)+j Cι(S)+j Now let (y0 , η0 ) ∈ S ∗ Y (the unit cosphere bundle) be fixed. Since isomorphisms form an open set and each matrix can be approximated arbitrarily well by an 22 such invertible one, there exists an invertible (ι(S) + j) × (ι(S) + j)-matrix H that K0,0 (X ∧ ) K0,0 (X ∧ ) 1 + G H12 ⊕ ⊕ −→ (7.5) 22 : H21 H Cι(S)+j Cι(S)+j is pointwise invertible in an open neighborhood of (y0 , η0 ) in S ∗ Y . From the decomposition −1 H21 −1 1 + G H12 1 0 0 (1 + G) − H12 H 1 H12 H 22 22 −1 H21 1 22 = 0 ˜ 22 H H21 H 1 0 H 22 we deduce that the second term on the right-hand side is invertible, since all the other block-matrices are. In particular, ˜ −1 H21 , D := G − H12 H 1 + D : K0,0 (X ∧ ) −→ K0,0 (X ∧ ), 22
is invertible. But now D is (the symbol of) a regular Green operator, i.e. a Green operator from the standard edge calculus. Then it is known that (1+D)−1 = 1+M with a (symbol of a) regular Green operator. This yields # −1 " −1 1 + G H12 1+M −(1 + M )H12 H 22 = 22 −1 H21 (1 + M ) −1 H21 H −H H 22 22 1 + M N12 =: . N21 N22 1 + G H12 1 + M N12 1 0 = H21 H22 N21 N22 B R with an invertible matrix R, and it follows that −1 1 + M N12 1 0 1+K 1 + G H12 = =: H21 H22 N21 N22 L21 −R−1 B R−1 Then
L12 , L22 (7.6)
272
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
where the functions K and Lij are smooth near (y0 , η0 ), and have the properties that K(y, η), K(y, η)∗ : K0,0 (X ∧ ) −→ Sε0 (X ∧ ), L12 (y, η), L21 (y, η)∗ : Cι(S)+j −→ Sε0 (X ∧ ) for some ε > 0. Since the local inverses are unique, we thus obtain an inverse of the form (7.6) globally on S ∗ Y , having the mapping properties just described. It then remains to set 1 + K L12 1 + C11 C12 = B−1 B C21 C22 L21 L22 and to define σ∧ (C)(y, η) by 1 + C11 C12 I + σ∧ (C)(y, η) = diag(κ|η| , 1) (y, η/|η|) diag(κ−1 |η| , 1). C21 C22 By using a zero excision function χ(η), we then find a corresponding operator C having the constructed principal edge symbol. 7.2. The parametrix construction Theorem 7.3. Let A ∈ Y µ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, k, J− , J+ ))S,T be elliptic. Then A has a parametrix P ∈ Y −µ (M, (γ − µ, γ), (k, k, J+ , J− ))T,S , i.e., AP − I ∈ Y −∞ (M, (γ − µ, γ − µ), (k, k, J+ , J+ ))T,T , PA − I ∈ Y −∞ (M, (γ, γ), (k, k, J− , J− ))S,S , where I = diag(1, 1) is the identity operator. In particular, A induces Fredholm operators W s−µ,γ−µ (M, Ck )T W s,γ (M, Ck )S ⊕ ⊕ −→ , A: H s (Y, J− ) H s−µ (Y, J+ )
s ∈ R.
Proof. Let us construct a left parametrix P; the construction of a right-parametrix is similar. Then P is a two-sided parametrix, and we obtain the Fredholm property of A, since the remainders are compact operators in the respective Sobolev spaces. For the construction of P we assume for simplicity that k = 1 (the general case is completely analogous). Writing A as a block-matrix A = (Aij )i,j=1,2 with A11 = AP0,S , cf. the formulas (6.6) and (7.1), condition (ii) of Definition 7.1 yields a family of Fredholm operators σ∧ (A)(y, η) : Ks,γ (X ∧ ) −→ Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ ),
(y, η) ∈ T ∗ Y \ 0,
of index l+ − l− for l+ = j+ + ι(T ) and l− = j− + ι(S). Using the technique of constructing a parametrix in the standard edge calculus, we find an elliptic operator B ∈ Y −µ (M, (γ − µ, γ), (1, 1; L+ , L− )) for L+ = J+ ⊕ Cι(T ) and L− = J− ⊕ Cι(S) , which has the following properties: The upper left corner B of B, viewed as an
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
273
element of L−µ (M \ Y ), is a parametrix of the elliptic operator A ∈ Lµ (M \ Y ), and (T µ σM (B))σM (A) = 1. Moreover, the operator B is Fredholm as a map W s−µ,γ−µ (M ) W s,γ (M ) ⊕ ⊕ B: −→ . H s−µ (Y, J+ ) ⊕ H s−µ (Y, Cι(T ) ) H s (Y, J− ) ⊕ H s (Y, Cι(S) ) A simple algebraic argument, using the isomorphisms ∼ W s,γ (M )S , W s,γ (M ) ⊕ H s (Y, Cι(S) ) = W s−µ,γ−µ (M ) ⊕ H s−µ (Y, Cι(T ) ) ∼ = W s−µ,γ−µ (M )T , cf. Remark 6.3, allows us to reorganise the operator B to an operator W s,γ (M )S W s−µ,γ−µ (M )T ⊕ ⊕ −→ P0 : H s−µ (Y, J+ ) H s (Y, J− ) with P0 ∈ Y −µ (M, (γ − µ, γ), (1, 1; J− , J+ ))T,S and such that 0 G := P0 A − I ∈ YG (M, (γ, γ), (1, 1; J− , J− ))S,S .
Both P0 and A are elliptic; thus also I + G is elliptic. By Proposition 7.2 we find 0 an operator C ∈ YG (M, (γ, γ), (1, 1; J− , J− ))S,S such that (I + C)(I + G) = I + K
for a
−1 K ∈ YG (M, (γ, γ), (1, 1; J− , J− ))S,S .
Setting P1 = (I + C)P0 we thus obtain P1 A = I + K. Applying Theorem 6.10, we can form the asymptotic sum L :=
∞
−1 (−1)j Kj ∈ YG (M, (γ, γ), (1, 1; J−, J− ))S,S .
j=1
Then P := (I+L )P1 is the desired left parametrix. In the latter steps we employed Theorem 6.9 several times. 7.3. Concluding remarks Comparing the spaces Y µ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l, J− , J+ ))S,T and Y µ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l, J− , J+ )), the additional ingredients of the new calculus are Green operators (in block-matrix sense) associated with discrete asymptotic data in the weight strips n+1 n+1 − γ < Re z < −γ+σ z: 2 2 and n+1 n+1 − (γ − µ) < Re z < − (γ − µ) + τ , z: 2 2 respectively. Such operators are able to ‘reproduce’ non-smoothing Mellin operators in the upper left corner when they are given on the line Re z = n+1 2 −γ+σ instead of Re z = n+1 − γ (the latter is the case in both variants of the edge 2 calculus). This is due to the fact that differences of Mellin operators for different
274
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
weight lines (and with specific meromorphic symbols) generate Green operators of the singular category, cf. [3]. It would be interesting to study subalgebras of our calculus with meromorphic Mellin symbols in which the Mellin operators refer to Re z = n+1 2 − γ + σ instead of Re z = n+1 − γ. This would require a careful choice of admitted Mellin symbols 2 and a detailed analysis of the asymptotic data. The paper [8] of Liu and Witt can be interpreted in this spirit. One may expect many other interesting examples of such subcalculi of edge problems, for instance, algebras generated by boundary value problems without the transmission property at the boundary, with (principal) interior symbols of / 2Z (the case µ ∈ 2Z corresponds to the case with the form |ξ|µ for some µ ∈ transmission property). An edge algebra interpretation of boundary value problems (without transmission property) is given in [13]. Such investigations could deepen the insight into the structure of parametrices of mixed elliptic problems, but the details might be quite voluminous (see, for instance, [7] or [6]).
8. Appendix: The standard calculus for manifolds with edges In this appendix we shall give a brief summary of the so-called edge algebra. For a reference of the here presented material we refer the reader to [3],[5], and [15]. In the following Ω ⊂ Rq denotes an open set, and X is a closed smooth manifold of dimension n ∈ N0 . We shall denote by Lµcl (X) the Fr´echet space of classical pseudodifferential operators on X, and by Lµcl (X; Λ) the space of parameterdependent operators, where Λ = Rl for some l ∈ N. More precisely, the local symbols of parameter-dependent operators satisfy estimates of the form |∂xβ ∂ξα ∂λγ a(x, ξ, λ)| ≤ C (1 + |ξ| + |λ|)µ−|α|−|γ| , and they have asymptotic expansions in components that are positively homogeneous in (ξ, λ). In short, (ξ, λ) is treated as a covariable. 8.1. Mellin symbols and Mellin pseudodifferential operators For γ ∈ R and ε > 0 let us set
S(γ,) = {z ∈ C : 12 − γ − Re z < ε},
i.e. S(γ,ε) is the open, vertical strip of width ε around the line Re z =
1 2
− γ.
µ Definition 8.1. Let γ ∈ R, µ ∈ R ∪ {−∞} and ε > 0. The space M(γ,ε) (X; Λ) µ consists of all holomorphic functions h : S(γ− n2 ,ε) → Lcl (X; Λ) such that
hδ (λ, ) := h(λ,
n+1 2
− γ + δ + i) ∈ Lµcl (X; Λ × R )
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
275
uniformly in δ ∈ (−ε, ε). Since this is a Fr´echet space in a canonical way, it is µ meaningful to speak of C ∞ (Ω × R+ , M(γ,ε) (X; Λ)). We set Mγµ (X; Λ) = C ∞ (Ω × R+ , Mγµ (X; Λ)) =
µ ∪ M(γ,ε) (X; Λ),
ε>0
µ ∪ C ∞ (Ω × R+ , M(γ,ε) (X; Λ)),
ε>0
and µ ∩ M(γ,ε) (X; Λ),
MOµ (X; Λ) =
ε>0
C ∞ (Ω × R+ , MOµ (X; Λ)) =
ε>0
µ ∩ C ∞ (Ω × R+ , M(γ,ε) (X; Λ)).
The definitions are analogous for the spaces depending only on Ω × R+ and those independent of the parameter λ ∈ Λ. A symbol h(y, r, λ, z) belonging to C ∞ (Ω × R+ , Mγµ (X; Λ)) induces a family of Mellin pseudodifferential operators on the infinite cone X ∧ = R+ × X by 1 γ− n 2 [opM (h)(y, λ)u](r) := r−z h(y, r, λ, z)(M u)(z) dz 2πi Re z= n+1 2 −γ for u ∈ C0∞ (X ∧ ). Here, we have identified C0∞ (X ∧ ) with C0∞ (R+ , C ∞ (X)), and M denotes the Mellin transform. 8.2. Green and smoothing Mellin symbols For the following definition recall the definition of cone Sobolev spaces Ks,γ (X ∧ ) from Section 2 and its group action κλ . µ (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ )) Definition 8.2. Let γ, γ ∈ R and µ ∈ R ∪ {−∞}. The space RG consists of all operator-valued symbols (cf. Section 2)
µ (Ω × Rq ; K0,γ (X ∧ ), K0,γ (X ∧ )) g(y, η) ∈ Scl
such that there exists an ε > 0 with g(y, η) ∈ ∗
g(y, η) ∈
∩ Sclµ (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ ), S γ +ε (X ∧ )),
s∈R
∩ Sclµ (Ω × Rq ; Ks,−γ (X ∧ ), S −γ+ε (X ∧ )).
s∈R
In the previous definition, ∗ refers to the pointwise adjoint with respect to the scalar product of K0,0 (X ∧ ) = L2 (X ∧ , r−n drdx), which allows an identification of K−s,−γ (X ∧ ) and the dual space of Ks,γ (X ∧ ). µ Definition 8.3. Let γ ∈ R and µ ∈ R ∪ {−∞}. The space RM+G (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)) consists of all operator-valued symbols of the form γ− n 2
m(y, η) + g(y, η) = ω0 (r[η]) r−µ opM µ (Ω ∈ RG ∞
(h)(y) ω1 (r[η]) + g(y, η), ∞
(8.1)
(Ω, Mγ−∞ (X)),
× R ; (γ, γ − µ)) is a Green symbol, h ∈ C where g(y, η) and ω0 , ω1 ∈ C ([0, 1[) are arbitrary cut-off functions. For a real number ν ∈ R with 1 ≤ µ − ν ∈ N we set q
ν ν RM+G (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)) = RG (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)).
276
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
It can be shown that then, for each s ∈ R, ν ν RM+G (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)) ⊂ Scl (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ ), K∞,γ−µ (X ∧ )).
If (m + g)(y, η) is as in (8.1), its homogeneous principal symbol is defined as γ− n 2
σ∧ (m + g)(y, η) = ω0 (r|η|) r−µ opM
η = 0, (8.2) where σ∧ (g)(y, η) denotes the homogeneous principal symbol of g(y, η). This symbol we shall refer to as the principal edge symbol of (m + g)(y, η). The (principal) conormal symbol of (m + g)(y, η) is, by definition, (h)(y) ω1 (r|η|) + σ∧ (g)(y, η),
σM (m + g)(y, z) = h(y, z) ∈ C ∞ (Ω, Mγ−∞ (X)).
(8.3)
8.3. Edge amplitude functions Definition 8.4. Let γ ∈ R and µ, ν ∈ R with µ− ν ∈ N. Then Rν (Ω× Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)) denotes the space of so-called edge symbols γ−n/2 a(y, η) = σ r−ν opM (h)(y, η) + m(y, η) + g(y, η) σ0 + + (1 − σ) op(p)(y, η) (1 − σ1 ), where the notation has the following meaning: a) b) c) d)
σ, σ0 , σ1 ∈ C0∞ ([0, 1[) are cut-off functions with σ1 ≺ σ ≺ σ0 , h(y, r, η, z) = h(y, r, rη, z) with h ∈ C ∞ (Ω × R+ , MOν (X; Rqη )), ν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)), (m + g)(y, η) ∈ RM+G p(y, r, η, ) ∈ C ∞ (Ω × R+ , Lνcl (X; Rqη × R )), independent of r for large r. Edge symbols are particular operator-valued symbols, namely Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ)) ⊂ S ν (Ω × Rq ; Ks,γ (X ∧ ), Ks−ν,γ−µ (X ∧ )).
In case ν = µ we define the principal edge symbol of a(y, η) by σ∧ (a)(y, η) = r−µ opM
γ−n/2
(h∧ )(y, η) + σ∧ (m + g)(y, η),
h∧ (y, r, z, η) = h(y, 0, rη, z),
(8.4)
cf. (8.2), and the conormal symbol of a(y, η) by σM (a)(y, z) = h(y, 0, z, 0) + σM (m + g)(y, z),
(8.5)
cf. (8.3). There is an obvious generalization to (l × k)-matrices of such edge symbols, yielding the space Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
277
8.4. The algebra of edge pseudodifferential operators on M In the following we let M be a manifold with edge Y and model cone X ∧ as it is described in Section 6. For γ ∈ R and µ, ν ∈ R with µ − ν ∈ N, Y ν (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l))
(8.6)
denotes the space of ν-th order edge operators (with respect to (k, l) and the weight-data (γ, γ − µ)). Modulo global smoothing operators they are obtained by pasting together (using a partition of unity on M ) usual pseudodifferential operators of order ν on the interior of M with operators that are localized near the edge and that are defined locally by means of pseudodifferential operators with operator-valued symbols from Rν (Ω × Rq ; (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)). We shall omit the details here. The space of global smoothing operators, Y −∞ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)), consists of all operators G : W 0,γ (M, Ck ) → W 0,γ−µ (M, Cl ) such that there exists an ε > 0 with G : W s,γ (M, Ck ) −→ W ∞,γ−µ+ε (M, Cl ), G∗ : W s,−γ+µ (M, Cl ) −→ W ∞,−γ+ε (M, Ck ),
(8.7)
for each s ∈ R, where ∗ refers to the adjoint with respect to the scalar product of W 0,0 (M ) that admits an identification of the dual space of W s,σ (M ) with W −s,−σ (M ). Each A ∈ Y ν (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)) induces continuous operators W s,γ (M, Ck ) −→ W s−ν,γ−µ (M, Cl ),
s ∈ R.
8.5. Principal symbols As a matter of fact, Y ν (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)) ⊂ Lνcl (int M ; Ck , Cl ) for int M := M \ Y , i.e., any edge operator is a usual pseudodifferential operator on the interior of M . In particular, with each A ∈ Y µ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, l)) we can associate the standard homogeneous principal symbol σψ (A) ∈ C ∞ (T ∗ int M \ 0, L (Ck , Cl )).
(8.8)
In local coordinates, corresponding to the splitting of coordinates (y, r, x) near the edge, the homogeneous principal symbol has a special ‘degenerate’ form namely σψ (A)(y, r, x, η, , ξ) = r−µ p(µ) (y, r, x, rη, r, ξ), with a symbol p(µ) (y, r, x, η, , ξ) homogeneous in ( η , , ξ). Removing this degeneracy leads to σ ψ (A)(y, x, η, , ξ) = p(µ) (y, 0, x, η, , ξ) = lim rµ σψ (A)(y, r, x, r−1 η, r−1 , ξ). r→0+
Globally, this yields the so-called rescaled symbol σ ψ (A) ∈ C ∞ ((T ∗ (Y × X) × R) \ 0, L (Ck , Cl )).
(8.9)
278
Kapanadze, Schulze and Seiler
IEOT
Moreover, induced by the local amplitude functions of Definition 8.4, we have the principal edge symbol σ∧ (A) ∈ C ∞ (T ∗ Y \ 0, L (Ks,γ (X ∧ , Ck ), Ks−µ,γ−µ (X ∧ , Cl )).
(8.10)
8.6. Ellipticity An operator A ∈ Y µ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, k; J− , J+ )) (cf. the notation of Remark 6.7) is said to be elliptic, if σψ (A), σ ψ (A), and σ∧ (A) satisfy the conditions of Definition 7.1. Theorem 8.5. An elliptic operator A ∈ Y µ (M, (γ, γ − µ), (k, k; J− , J+ )) possesses a parametrix P ∈ Y −µ (M, (γ − µ, γ), (k, k; J+ , J− )), i.e. AP − I and PA − I are of order −∞ in the spaces belonging to the data ((γ − µ, γ − µ), (k, k; J+ , J+ )) and ((γ, γ), (k, k; J− , J− )), respectively. For a proof of this theorem see [3], for example.
References [1] L. Boutet de Monvel. Boundary problems for pseudo-differential operators. Acta Math. 126 (1971), 11-51. [2] N. Dines, B.-W. Schulze. Mellin-edge-representations of elliptic operators. Math. Methods Appl. Sci. 28 (2005), 2133-2172. [3] Ju.V. Egorov, B.-W. Schulze. Pseudo-differential operators, singularities, applications. Operator Theory: Advances and Applications 93, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, 1997. [4] G.I. Eskin. Boundary value problems for elliptic pseudodifferential equations. Math. Monographs 52, Amer. Math. Soc., 1980. [5] J.B. Gil, B.-W. Schulze, and J. Seiler. Cone pseudodifferential operators in the edge symbolic calculus. Osaka J. Math. 37 (2000), 221-260. [6] G. Harutjunjan, B.-W. Schulze. Elliptic Mixed, Transmission, and Singular Crack Problems. Tracts in Math. 4, World Scientific, 2008. [7] D. Kapanadze, B.-W. Schulze. Crack theory and edge singularities. Mathematics and its Applications 561, Kluwer Academic Publishing, 2003. [8] X. Liu, I. Witt. Pseudodifferential calculi on the half-line respecting prescribed asymptotic types. Integral Equations Opeartor Theory 49 (2004), 473-497. [9] M.I. Vishik, G.I. Eskin, Convolution equations in a bounded region, Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 20 (1965), 89-152. [10] S. Rempel, B.-W. Schulze. Parametrices and boundary symbolic calculus for elliptic boundary problems without the transmission property. Math. Nachr. 105 (1982), 45-149. [11] B.-W. Schulze. Pseudo-differential operators on manifolds with singularities. NorthHolland, 1991. [12] B.-W. Schulze. Pseudo-differential operators on manifolds with edges. In Symp. “Partial Differential Equations”, Holzhau 1988. Teubner-Texte Math. 112, pp. 259-287. Teubner Verlag, 1989.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Operators with Singular Trace Conditions
279
[13] B.-W. Schulze, J. Seiler. The edge algebra structure of boundary value problems. Ann. Global Anal. Geom. 22 (2002), 197-265. [14] B.-W. Schulze, J. Seiler. Pseudodifferential boundary value problems with global projection conditions. J. Funct. Anal. 206 (2004), 449-498. [15] J. Seiler. Pseudodifferential calculus on manifolds with non-compact edges. Dissertation, University of Potsdam, 1997. [16] N. Tarkhanov. Harmonic integrals on domains with edges. Preprint 2002/02, University of Potsdam. D. Kapanadze A. Razmadze Mathematical Institute Academy of Sciences of Georgia M. Alexidze Str. 1 Tbilisi 0193 Georgia e-mail:
[email protected] B.-W. Schulze Universit¨ at Potsdam Institut f¨ ur Mathematik Postfach 601553 14415 Potsdam Germany e-mail:
[email protected] J. Seiler Leibniz Universit¨ at Hannover Institut f¨ ur Angewandte Mathematik Welfengarten 1 30167 Hannover Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: August 28, 2007 Revised: February 23, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 281–298 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020281-18, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1588-3
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators Donald Sarason In memory of Paul R. Halmos
Abstract. This partly expository article develops the basic theory of unbounded Toeplitz operators on the Hardy space H 2 , with emphasis on operators whose symbols are not square integrable. Unbounded truncated Toeplitz operators on coinvariant subspaces of H 2 are also studied. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35; Secondary 30D50. Keywords. Toeplitz operator, truncated Toeplitz operator, Smirnov class, de Branges–Rovnyak space.
1. Introduction Unbounded Toeplitz operators on the Hardy space H 2 of the unit disk D arise often, usually with symbols belonging to L2 of ∂D. There are natural questions, though, which lead to Toeplitz operators having more general symbols — I mention in particular interesting work of Henry Helson [4], Daniel Su´ arez [10], and Steven Seubert [9]. This being so, it seems worthwhile to gather the basic properties of these more general unbounded Toeplitz operators in a single source. That is the aim of the present paper. Section 2 is a short review of unbounded Toeplitz operators with L2 symbols, which are conveniently defined by means of the Cauchy integral. Sections 3 and 4 contain preliminary material on, respectively, the Smirnov class and de Branges– Rovnyak spaces. Section 5 is devoted to analytic Toeplitz operators, the case of interest to Helson, and Section 6 to coanalytic Toeplitz operators, the case of interest to Su´ arez and Seubert. I have not attempted here to go substantially beyond those two cases, as far as symbols outside of L2 are concerned, because I am not aware of any study in which that has been necessary. Nevertheless, one can ask just how much generality is possible. The question is posed in the concluding Section 8.
282
Sarason
IEOT
Section 7 concerns compressions of unbounded Toeplitz operators to invariant subspaces of the backward shift on H 2 , which were of interest to Su´ arez and Seubert. There is a large overlap between this exposition and the cited papers of Helson, Su´arez and Seubert. Some of the results of those authors will be mentioned in the course of this study. I am grateful to Israel Gohberg for suggesting that I submit a paper in memory of Paul Halmos to IEOT. Halmos was responsible for my first encounter with Toeplitz operators, when I was his student in Ann Arbor, a mathematical lifetime ago. The Halmos influence permeates my entire mathematical life. Gohberg’s pioneering work and incisive questions have been a continual source of inspiration in the Toeplitz community. Notations • • • • • • • • •
The inner product and norm in L2 will be denoted by ·, · and · 2 . The orthogonal projection of L2 onto H 2 will be denoted by P+ . The unilateral shift operator on H 2 will be denoted by S. A function defined in D will be identified notationally with its boundary function. The mth Fourier coefficient of a function f in L1 will be denoted by f(m). The identity operator will be denoted by I; the space on which it acts will be clear from the context. The domain and graph of an operator T will be denoted by D(T ) and G(T ), respectfully. The standard tensor notation will be used for operators of rank one: for v and w vectors in a Hilbert space H, the operator v ⊗ w is defined by (v ⊗ w)x = x, wH v. H(D) denotes the space of functions holomorphic in D, H(D) the space of functions holomorphic in neighborhoods of D.
2. L2 Symbols The Cauchy integral of a function f in L1 of ∂D is the function Kf defined in D by 1 f (eiθ ) dθ. (Kf )(z) = 2π ∂D 1 − e−iθ z If f is in L2 , then Kf equals P+ f , the projection of f onto H 2 . The map f → Kf is continuous relative to the weak topology of L1 and the topology of locally uniform convergence of H(D). For ϕ a function in L2 , the Toeplitz operator Tϕ on H 2 is defined by Tϕ f = K(ϕf ), with domain D(Tϕ ) = {f ∈ H 2 : K(ϕf ) ∈ H 2 }. It is a closed, densely defined operator, bounded if and only if ϕ is bounded. The domain D(Tϕ ) always contains H ∞ .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
283
One place Toeplitz operators with L2 symbols arise is in the invertibility criterion of A. Devinatz and H. Widom (see, e.g., [6], p. 250). The Devinatz– Widom analysis shows that if a bounded Toeplitz operator is invertible then its inverse, while not in general a Toeplitz operator, can be written as the product of an analytic Toeplitz operator times a coanalytic Toeplitz operator, both factors having L2 symbols, but possibly being unbounded.
3. The Smirnov Class We recall that the Nevanlinna class N consists of the holomorphic functions in D that are quotients of functions in H ∞ , and the Smirnov class N + consists of such quotients in which the denominators are outer functions. The representation of Smirnov-class functions given by the following proposition underlies much of what follows. Proposition 3.1. A nonzero function ϕ of Smirnov class can be written uniquely as ϕ = b/a, where a and b are in the unit ball of H ∞ , a is an outer function, a(0) > 0, and |a|2 + |b|2 = 1 on ∂D. The representation ϕ = b/a of the proposition will be termed the canonical representation of ϕ. It would not be surprising if the proposition could be found somewhere in the literature, because pairs a, b satisfying the given conditions arise in several connections. However, I have no recollection of seeing it stated explicitly. At any rate, the proposition is easy to prove. Proof. Suppose ϕ = ψ/χ, where ψ and χ are in H ∞ , ψ = 0, and χ is outer. If the required pair a, b exists then, because of the condition that |a|2 + |b|2 = 1 on ∂D, the function a must satisfy |χ|2 (3.1) |a|2 = |ψ|2 + |χ|2 on ∂D. The function |χ|2 is log-integrable because χ is in H ∞ , and hence |ψ|2 +|χ|2 is also log-integrable. The function on the right side of equality (3.1) is thus logintegrable, so there is a unique outer function a that satisfies (3.1) on ∂D and is positive at the origin. For the function b = aϕ we then have, on ∂D, |ψ|2 |χ|2 1 + = 1, |a|2 + |b|2 = |ψ|2 + |χ|2 |χ|2 and the existence of the representation ϕ = b/a is established. Uniqueness holds because a is uniquely determined by (3.1). Remark 3.2. If the Smirnov function ϕ is rational, then the functions a and b in the representation of ϕ are rational. In fact, suppose ϕ = p/q, where p and q are relatively prime polynomials, q has no roots in D, and q(0) > 0. As in the preceding proof, we have |q|2 |a|2 = 2 |p| + |q|2
284
Sarason
IEOT
on ∂D. The function |p|2 + |q|2 is, on ∂D, a nonnegative trigonometric polynomial. By the well-known Fej´er–Riesz theorem, there is a polynomial r without roots in D, and with r(0) > 0, such that |r|2 = |p|2 + |q|2 on ∂D. We get a = q/r, a rational function. The functions a and b can be determined explicitly in simple cases. In the following examples, the functions a corresponding to several choices of ϕ are listed, but the computational details are omitted.
ϕ(z)
a(z)
1+z 1−z
1−z 2
1+z 1−z
2
1 1−z z (1 − z)2 1 γ =1+ √ 2 2
(1 − z)2 1 √ 1+ √ 2 (z 2 + 3 + 2 2) √ z−1 1+ 5 √ 2 z − 3+ 5 2
2
|γ|(1 − z) (γ defined below) (γ − 2)(γ − z) √ √ 1 1 + √ 17 − 1 − i 17 + 1 2 2 2
4. De Branges–Rovnyak Spaces The needed information on these spaces can be found in [7]; the spaces were first studied by L. de Branges and J. Rovnyak [2]. They are associated with functions in the unit ball of H ∞ . Of interest here is the case where those functions are not extreme points of the unit ball. Let b be a nonconstant function in the unit ball of H ∞ , but not an extreme point. The de Branges–Rovnyak space H(b) is by definition the range of the operator (I − Tb T¯b )1/2 with the range norm, i.e., the norm that makes (I − Tb T¯b )1/2 an isometry of H 2 onto H(b). (Note that (I − Tb T¯b )1/2 is injective.) The norm and inner product in H(b) will be denoted by · b and ·, ·b . Since b is not an extreme point of the unit ball of H ∞ , there is a unique outer function a in H ∞ such that a(0) > 0 and |a|2 + |b|2 = 1 on ∂D. The function b/a is in the Smirnov class N + ; according to Proposition 3.1, the general nonconstant function in N + arises in this way. The following proposition gives an alternative description of H(b).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
285
Proposition 4.1 ([7], p. 24). The H 2 function f belongs to H(b) if and only if there is a function g in H 2 such that T¯b f = Ta¯ g. In that case f 2b = f 22 + g22 . Note that the function g in the proposition is unique, because Ta¯ has a trivial kernel (a being an outer function). The inclusion Ta¯ H 2 ⊂ H(b) is a consequence of Proposition 4.1 since, for h in H 2 , T¯b Ta¯ h = Ta¯ T¯b h. (In fact, Ta¯ H 2 is dense in H(b) ([7], p. 25).) One also has the inclusion aH 2 ⊂ Ta¯ H 2 : for h in H 2 , Ta h = Ta¯ Ta/¯a h.
5. Analytic Toeplitz Operators We start with a function ϕ that is holomorphic in D and define Tϕ to be the operator of multiplication by ϕ on the domain D(Tϕ ) = {f ∈ H 2 : ϕf ∈ H 2 }. Clearly, Tϕ is a closed operator. Lemma 5.1. If D(Tϕ ) is nontrivial then ϕ is in the Nevanlinna class N . Proof. In fact, suppose D(Tϕ ) contains the nonzero function f . Then ϕ = ϕf /f is the ratio of two H 2 functions, hence the ratio of two functions in N , hence in N. Lemma 5.2. If D(Tϕ ) is dense in H 2 then ϕ is in the Smirnov class N + . Proof. Let ϕ = ψ/χ be in N , where ψ and χ are functions in H ∞ whose inner factors are relatively prime. Suppose f is in D(Tϕ ) and let g = ϕf . Then ψf = χg. Let ψ0 be the outer factor of ψ and χ1 the inner factor of χ. Because χ1 and the inner factor of ψ are relatively prime, the equality ψf = χg implies that ψ0 f is in χ1 H 2 , and hence that f is in χ1 H 2 . Thus D(Tϕ ) ⊂ χ1 H 2 , and since D(Tϕ ) is dense in H 2 we can conclude that χ1 is constant. So χ is an outer function, i.e., ϕ is in N + . The converse of Lemma 5.2 is immediate: If ϕ = ψ/χ is as above, with χ outer, then D(Tϕ ) contains χH 2 and so is dense in H 2 . Proposition 5.3. Let ϕ be a nonzero function in N + , with canonical representation ϕ = b/a. Then D(Tϕ ) = aH 2 . Proof. In fact, the inclusion aH 2 ⊂ D(Tϕ ) is clear (as just noted). Suppose f is in D(Tϕ ). We have, on ∂D, 2 f |b|2 |f |2 2 − |f |2 , |ϕf | = = a |a|2 implying that f /a is in L2 . Since f /a is in N + it follows that f /a is in H 2 , giving the inclusion D(Tϕ ) ⊂ aH 2 . Tϕ∗
Since for ϕ in N + the operator Tϕ is densely defined and closed, its adjoint is densely defined and closed.
286
Sarason
IEOT
Proposition 5.4. Let ϕ be a nonzero function in N + with canonical representation ϕ = b/a. Then D(Tϕ∗ ) = H(b), and the projection of G(Tϕ∗ ) onto H(b) is an isometry relative to the norms · 2 and · b . Proof. In fact, by Proposition 5.3 we have G(Tϕ ) = {ah ⊕ bh : h ∈ H 2 }, which we can write in operator form as Ta H 2. G(Tϕ ) = Tb Therefore G(Tϕ )⊥ = ker(Ta¯ T¯b ) = {g ⊕ f ∈ H 2 ⊕ H 2 : Ta¯ g + T¯b f = 0}. It follows that G(Tϕ∗ ) = {f ⊕ g ∈ H 2 ⊕ H 2 : (−g) ⊕ f ∈ G(T )⊥ } = {f ⊕ g ∈ H 2 ⊕ H 2 : T¯b f = Ta¯ g}, and the desired conclusions follow immediately from Proposition 4.1.
Let ϕ be as in the preceding proposition. From the inclusion aH 2 ⊂ H(b) noted in Section 4 one sees that D(Tϕ ) ⊂ D(Tϕ∗ ). Also D(Tϕ∗ ) contains H(D), the space of functions holomorphic in neighborhoods of D ([7], p. 26). The space H(b) is S ∗ -invariant, as one can see from Proposition 4.1. (The ∗ S -invariance is in fact a property of general de Branges–Rovnyak spaces ([7], p. 11). From the description of G(Tϕ∗ ) obtained in the preceding proof, one sees arez proved in [10] that Tϕ∗ with ϕ that if f is in D(Tϕ∗ ) then Tϕ∗ S ∗ f = S ∗ Tϕ∗ f . Su´ + in N is the general closed densely defined operator that commutes with S ∗ . If T is such an operator then the subspace G(T )⊥ of H 2 ⊕ H 2 is invariant under S ⊕ S. Su´ arez’s proof relies on the generalization of Beurling’s theorem to shift-invariant subspaces of H 2 ⊕ H 2 . Proposition 5.4 suggests that, for ϕ in N + , the conjugate-analytic Toeplitz operator Tϕ should be defined by Tϕ = Tϕ∗ . Rather than adopting this definition at this point, we take up coanalytic Toeplitz operators ab initio in the next section.
6. Coanalytic Toeplitz Operators
∞ As in Section 5, we start with a function ϕ that is holomorphic in D. Let n=0 γn z n be the power series of ϕ centered at the origin. The Toeplitz matrix associated with Tϕ is the lower-triangular Toeplitz matrix built from the coefficients of the power series; its (m, n)th entry for m ≥ n is γm−n . Given a function f in D(Tϕ ), one obtains the column representing Tϕ f with respect to the standard basis for H 2 through multiplication of the column representing f by the Toeplitz matrix. Because of lower triangularity, the preceding multiplication makes perfect sense for any f in H 2 (and of course more generally).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
287
We consider now the adjoint of the Toeplitz matrix associated with ϕ, the upper-triangular Toeplitz matrix whose (m, n)th entry for m ≤ n is γ n−m . Unless ϕ is in H 2 , the product of this matrix with the column representing an arbitrary ∞ function f in H 2 , whose mth entry is given formally by the series n=0 γ n f(m+n) (m = 0, 1, . . . ), need not be well defined. It is well defined, though, if the function f is a polynomial, hence for a dense set of functions in H 2 . More is true. Lemma 6.1. If f is in H(D), then each series ∞ n=0 γ n f (m + n) (m = 0, 1, . . . ) converges absolutely, and the function represented by the power series ∞ ∞ m is in H(D). m=0 n=0 γ n f (m + n) z Proof. To prove the lemma, suppose the function f is in H(RD), where R > 1. Fix > 0 such that (1 + )2 /R < 1. Since lim sup |f(m)|1/m ≤ 1/R, we have
m |f(m)| ≤ const. 1+ . Since lim sup |γn |1/n ≤ 1, we also have |γn | ≤ const.(1 + R n ) . Therefore m+n ∞ ∞ 1+ |γ n f(m + n)| ≤ const. (1 + )n R n=0 n=0 m n ∞ 1+ (1 + )2 = const. R R n=0 ≤ const. The series
∞
n=0 |γ n f (m m m
(1 + )m . Rm
+ n)| thus converge absolutely, with sums bounded by ∞ ∞ (m + n) z m f γ m=0 n=0 n
const.(1 + ) /R , implying that the power series
has radius of convergence at least R/(1 + ). Since can be taken arbitrarily small, the radius of convergence is at least R. We let Tϕ0 be the operator with domain H(D) that maps the function f in
∞ (m + n) z m , which is also in H(D) by γ f H(D) to the function ∞ m=0 n=0 n
the last lemma. Thus D(Tϕ0 ) is dense in H 2 . The kernel function in H 2 for the evaluation functional at the point λ of D will be denoted, as usual, by kλ : kλ (z) = 1/(1 − λz). Lemma 6.2. Tϕ0 kλ = ϕ(λ)kλ .
n Proof. In fact, since kλ (n) = λ , the mth power series coefficient of Tϕ0 kλ equals ∞ n=0
m+n
γnλ
=λ
m
∞
n γ n λ = ϕ(λ) kλ (m).
n=0
Since D(Tϕ0 ) is dense in H 2 , the adjoint (Tϕ0 )∗ is defined. Lemma 6.3. If D((Tϕ0 )∗ ) is nontrivial, then ϕ is in the Nevanlinna class N .
288
Sarason
IEOT
Proof. Suppose the nonzero function f belongs to D((Tϕ0 )∗ ), and let g = (Tϕ0 )∗ f . Then, by Lemma 6.2, for λ in D, g(λ) = g, kλ = f, Tϕ0 kλ = f, ϕ(λ)kλ = ϕ(λ)f (λ). Hence ϕ = g/f , showing that ϕ is in N .
Lemma 6.4. If Tϕ0 is closable, then ϕ is in the Smirnov class N + . In that case Tϕ∗ is the closure of Tϕ0 . Proof. In fact, if Tϕ0 is closable then its adjoint (Tϕ0 )∗ is densely defined, and of course closed. By the proof of Lemma 6.3, (Tϕ0 )∗ = Tϕ , so ϕ is in N + by Lemma 5.2. Let ϕ be in N + . To prove Tϕ∗ is the closure of Tϕ0 , it suffices to prove the graphs G(Tϕ∗ ) and G(Tϕ0 ) have the same orthogonal complement. The argument here is again the same as in the proof of Lemma 6.3. The orthogonal complement of G(Tϕ∗ ) is {(−ϕf ) ⊕ f : f ∈ D(Tϕ )}. Suppose g ⊕ f is orthogonal to G(Tϕ0 ). Then for λ in D, by Lemma 6.2, 0 = g ⊕ f, kλ ⊕ Tϕ0 kλ = g(λ) + ϕ(λ)f (λ). Hence g = −ϕf .
With the preceding lemmas in mind, for ϕ in N + we now define Tϕ to be Tϕ∗ . The inclusion D(Tϕ ) ⊂ D(Tϕ ) was noted in Section 5. We note also that, for g in D(Tϕ ), we have Tϕ g = P+ (ϕg). In fact, for any f in D(Tϕ ), Tϕ g, f = g, ϕf = ϕg, f = P+ (ϕg), f , from which the asserted equality follows. Having defined Tϕ and Tϕ for ϕ in N + , we can go slightly beyond the cases of analytic and conjugate-analytic symbols by defining the operator Tϕ+ϕ as: D(Tϕ+ϕ ) = D(Tϕ ), Tϕ+ϕ f = Tϕ f + Tϕ f for f in D(Tϕ ). We have Tϕ+ϕ f = P+ ((ϕ + ϕ)f ) for f in D(Tϕ ), according to remarks in the last paragraph. Hence Tϕ+ϕ is bounded if and only if Re ϕ is bounded. In any case the operator Tϕ+ϕ is symmetric. Helson in his paper [4] studied Tϕ for ϕ a nonconstant function in N + that is real valued on ∂D. In this case Tϕ is by itself symmetric. Examples of such functions ϕ are i(1 + z)/(1 − z), z/(1 − z)2 (the Koebe function), positive powers of the preceding functions, and the composite of such a function with a nonconstant inner function. Helson proved that Tϕ has finite deficiency indices if and only if ϕ is a rational function, and that all pairs of deficiency indices arise. If ϕ is a nonconstant function in N + that is real valued on ∂D, then ϕ = ϕ on ∂D, but Tϕ = Tϕ . For a Toeplitz operator whose symbol is not in L2 , the operator need not be determined by the behavior of its symbol on ∂D. We note for future use the following property. Proposition 6.5. If ϕ is in N + , ψ is in H ∞ , and f is in D(Tϕ ), then Tϕ Tψ f = Tϕψ f = Tψ Tϕ f .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
289
Proof. In fact, the domain D(Tϕ ), being a de Branges–Rovnyak space, is invariant under (bounded) conjugate-analytic Toeplitz operators (see, for example, [7], p. 11). Hence Tψ f is in D(Tϕ ). For g in D(Tϕ ), Tϕ Tψ f, g = Tψ f, ϕg = f, ψϕg = Tψϕ f, g, which shows that Tϕ Tψ f = Tϕψ f . Moreover, if g is in D(Tϕ ) then so is ψg, so that Tψ Tϕ f, g = Tϕ f, ψg = f, ϕψg = Tϕψ f, g implying that Tψ Tϕ f = Tψϕ f .
7. Truncations Let u be a nonconstant inner function. The S ∗ -invariant subspace H 2 uH 2 will be denoted, as is commonly done, by Ku2 . In the paper [8] the author studied truncations (i.e., compressions) of Toeplitz operators to Ku2 , concentrating on the case of bounded truncations. Here it will be shown how one can truncate Tϕ and Tϕ to Ku2 , for ϕ in N + . Some preliminaries are needed. They are presented in greater detail in [8]. The kernel function in Ku2 for the evaluation functional at the point λ of D will be denoted by kλu ; it is given by kλu (z) = (1 − u(λ)u(z))/(1 − λz). The space Ku2 carries a natural symmetry (i.e., an antiunitary involution) C, defined by (Cf )(z) = u(z)¯ zf (z) (z ∈ ∂D). The function Cf will be denoted, when convenient, by f. In particular, kλu (z) = (u(z) − u(λ))/(z − λ). The compression of the shift operator S to Ku2 will be denoted by Su . Its adjoint Su∗ is the restriction of S ∗ to Ku2 . One has the relation I − Su Su∗ = k0u ⊗ k0u . The orthogonal projection on L2 with range Ku2 will be denoted by Pu . Like P+ , it can be extended to a map from L1 into H(D), continuous with respect to the weak topology of L1 and the topology of locally uniform convergence of H(D). In fact, as was the case with P+ , the projection Pu is an integral operator, its kernel being the reproducing kernel for Ku2 : 1 1 − u(eiθ )u(z) iθ dθ, f ∈ L2 , z ∈ D. (Pu f )(z) = f (e ) 2π ∂D 1 − e−iθ z For f in L1 , we define Ku f to be the function in H(D) given by the expression on the right side of the preceding equality. For ϕ a function in L2 , the truncated Toeplitz operator Aϕ with symbol ϕ is defined by Aϕ = Ku (ϕf ) with domain D(Aϕ ) = {f ∈ Ku2 : Ku f ∈ Ku2 }. The operator Aϕ is closed (by a standard argument) and densely defined (since Ku2 ∩ H ∞ ⊂ D(Aϕ )).
290
Sarason
IEOT
In contrast to the Toeplitz case, the symbol of a truncated Toeplitz operator is highly nonunique. It is proved in [8] (Theorem 3.1) that Aϕ = 0 if and only if 2 ¯H (a result originating with K. Izuchi [5]). It is an open ϕ belongs to uH 2 + u question whether every bounded truncated Toeplitz operator possesses a bounded symbol. If ϕ is in L2 and Aϕ is bounded, then A∗ϕ = Aϕ , and Aϕ is C-symmetric: CAϕ C = A∗ϕ (Lemma 2.1 of [8], originally due to S. R. Garcia and M. Putinar [3]). For the remainder of this section we let ϕ denote a function in N + , with canonical representation ϕ = b/a. We define the truncation Aϕ of Tϕ to be the restriction Tϕ | D(Tϕ ) ∩ Ku2 . Proposition 7.1. Aϕ is closed and densely defined. It maps its domain into Ku2 . Proof. We know from Proposition 5.4 that D(Tϕ ) is the de Branges–Rovnyak space H(b). The proof of Proposition 7.1 relies on the description of H(b) given by Proposition 4.1. We first assume f is a function in H(b) ∩ Ku2 and show that then Tϕ f is in 2 Ku . This will prove Aϕ maps its domain into Ku2 . By Proposition 4.1 there is a function g in H 2 such that T¯b f = Ta¯ g. The proof of Proposition 5.4 shows that Tϕ f = g, so it only remains to show that g is in Ku2 , which amounts to showing that Tu¯ g = 0. We have Ta¯ Tu¯ g = Tu¯ Ta¯ g = Tu¯ T¯b f = T¯b Tu¯ f, and Tu¯ f = 0 because f is in Ku2 . Since a is an outer function, the operator Ta¯ has a trivial kernel, so Tu¯ g = 0, as desired. Next we show that D(Aϕ ) is dense in Ku2 . The inclusion Ta¯ H 2 ⊂ H(b) was noted in Section 4, so, since Ku2 is Ta¯ -invariant, it will suffice to prove that Ta¯ Ku2 is dense in Ku2 . But Ta¯ Ku2 = Aa¯ Ku2 , and A∗a¯ = Aa , the compression of Ta to Ku2 . The orthogonal complement of Aa¯ Ku2 in Ku2 is thus the kernel of Aa , which is trivial because a is outer (any function in the kernel must be in Ku2 and in uH 2 ). Thus D(Aϕ ) is dense in Ku2 . Finally, we show that Aϕ is closed. Let the sequence (fn )∞ 1 in D(Aϕ ) converge converge in norm to the in norm to the function f , and let the sequence (Aϕ fn )∞ 1 function g. Letting gn = Aϕ fn , we have, by Proposition 5.4 and its proof, T¯b fn = Ta¯ gn , which in the limit as n → ∞ gives T¯b f = Ta¯ g. Thus f is in H(b) ∩ Ku2 = D(Aϕ ) and Tϕ f = g (again by Proposition 5.4 and its proof). Su´ arez in his paper [10] characterized the closed densely defined operators on Ku2 that commute with Su∗ . The characterization is somewhat indirect. The graph of such an operator is an invariant subspace of the backward shift on H 2 ⊕ H 2 . By the extension to multiple shifts of Beurling’s theorem, the orthogonal complement of the graph is determined by a two-by-two matrix inner function. Su´ arez’s basic theorem describes the inner functions that arise.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
291
Su´ arez showed that not all of his operators have the form Aϕ with ϕ in H 2 . Similarly, one can show that not all of them have the form Aϕ with ϕ in N + . I hope to return to these matters in a subsequent publication. Seubert in his paper [9] examined closed, densely defined, dissipative operators on Ku2 that commute with Su∗ . (By a dissipative operator is meant here an operator A on a Hilbert space H satisfying ImAf, f H ≥ 0 for all f in D(A).) Such an operator is the infinitesimal generator of a contractive C0 -semigroup of operators on Ku2 that commutes with Su∗ . Using Su´arez’s characterization and the semigroup connection, Seubert proved that his operators are the operators Aϕ for functions ϕ in N + satisfying Im ϕ ≤ 0. As preparation he showed how to define Aϕ and Aϕ for the general function ϕ in N + , ground we are in the process of retrodding, along a modified course. We define Aϕ to be the transform of Aϕ under the symmetry C. Thus, D(Aϕ ) = CD(Aϕ ) = {f : Cf ∈ H(b) ∩ Ku2 }, and Aϕ f = CAϕ Cf for f in D(Aϕ ). Because Aϕ is closed and densely defined, so is Aϕ . We shall show that Aϕ and Aϕ are adjoints of each other. For this we recall the inclusion Aa¯ Ku2 ⊂ D(Aϕ ) (see the proof of Proposition 7.1) and define the restriction operators A0ϕ = Aϕ | Aa¯ Ku2 and A0ϕ = Aϕ | Aa Ku2 . Lemma 7.2. Aϕ = (A0ϕ )∗ , Aϕ = (A0ϕ )∗ . Proof. It will suffice to establish the first equality, because an application of the symmetry C reduces the second equality to the first one. We show first that (A0ϕ )∗ is an extension of Aϕ . For f in D(Aϕ ) and h in Ku2 , Aϕ f, Aa¯ h = CAϕ Cf, Aa¯ h = CAa¯ h, Aϕ Cf = Aa Ch, Aϕ Cf = Ch, Aa¯ Aϕ Cf = Ch, A¯b Cf = CA¯b Cf, h = Ab f, h = f, A¯b h = f, A0ϕ Aa¯ h. (Note that by Proposition 6.5, Aa¯ Aϕ = A¯b |D(Aϕ ) and Aϕ Aa¯ = A¯b .) This establishes the inclusion Aϕ ⊂ (A0ϕ )∗ . To establish the reverse inclusion, suppose f is in D(A0ϕ )∗ , and let g = (A0ϕ )∗ f . Then for h in Ku2 , g, Aa¯ h = (A0ϕ )∗ f, Aa¯ h = f, A0ϕ Aa¯ h = f, A¯b h. It follows that Ab f = Aa g, and hence that A¯b Cf = Aa¯ Cg. The last equality tells us that Cf is in H(b), and so is in D(Aϕ ), with Aϕ Cf = Cg. Therefore f is in D(Aϕ ) and g = Aϕ f , which gives the inclusion (A0ϕ )∗ ⊂ Aϕ . Proposition 7.3. The operators Aϕ and Aϕ are adjoints of each other. They are the respective closures of A0ϕ and A0ϕ .
292
Sarason
IEOT
Proof. Define the operator W on Ku2 ⊕ Ku2 by W (f ⊕ g) = g ⊕ −f . Thus, the graph of the adjoint of a densely defined operator on Ku2 is the image under W of the orthogonal complement of the graph of the operator. By Lemma 7.2, we have the decompositions Ku2 ⊕ Ku2 = G(A0ϕ ) ⊕ W G(Aϕ ) = G(Aϕ ) ⊕ W G(A0ϕ ), as well as the orthogonality of the subspaces G(A0ϕ ) and W G(A0ϕ ). Suppose the vector f ⊕ g in Ku2 ⊕ Ku2 is orthogonal to the span of the last two subspaces. Then f ⊕ g belongs to W G(Aϕ ) ∩ G(Aϕ ), so f is in D(Aϕ ) with g = Aϕ f , and g is in D(Aϕ ) with f = −Aϕ g. Therefore (see Proposition 6.5) Aa¯ g = Aa¯ Aϕ f = A¯b f, Aa f = −Aa Aϕ g = −Ab g. From the equality Aa f = −Ab g we conclude that the function af + bg is in uH 2 . g = Ab f, so the function a g − bf Applying C to the equality Aa¯ g = A¯b f , we get Aa 2 is also in uH . Therefore the function f(af + bg) + g(a g − bf) = a(f f + g g) g must also be in uH 1 . is in uH 1 . Since a is an outer function, the function f f + g On ∂D we have z |g(z)|2 . f (z)f(z) + g(z) g(z) = u(z)¯ z |f (z)|2 + u(z)¯ So for f f + g g to belong to uH 1 the function |f |2 + |g|2 must belong to H01 , and so must be the zero function. Hence f = g = 0, and we can conclude that the mutually orthogonal subspaces G(A0ϕ ) and W G(A0ϕ ) span Ku2 ⊕ Ku2 .
The equalities G(Aϕ ) = G(A0ϕ ) and G(Aϕ ) = G(A0ϕ ) are now immediate, as is the equality Aϕ = A∗ϕ .
Under what conditions is the operator Aϕ (or equivalently Aϕ ) bounded? An obvious sufficient condition for boundedness is that ϕ be bounded, but of course that is not a necessary condition. Because Aϕ is closed and densely defined, a necessary and sufficient condition is that D(Tϕ ) = Ku2 , in other words, that Ku2 ⊂ H(b). Proposition 7.4. The operator Aϕ is bounded if and only if dist(b, uH ∞ ) < 1. Proof. By a well-known range inclusion criterion of R. G. Douglas (see, for example, [7], p. 2), the inclusion Ku2 ⊂ H(b) is equivalent to the existence of a constant c ≥ 1 such that I − Tu Tu¯ ≤ c(I − Tb T¯b ). The last inequality holds if and only if, for all f in Ku2 , f 22 ≤ c(I − Tb T¯b )f, f = cf 22 − cA¯b f 22 ,
which can be rewritten A¯b f 22
≤
c−1 c
f 22 .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
293
Hence Aϕ is bounded if and only if A¯b < 1, which by the (scalar) commutant lifting theorem happens if and only if dist(b, uH ∞ ) < 1. The next result is a sufficient condition for boundedness. Proposition 7.5. If the functions a and u form a corona pair then Aϕ is bounded. Proof. Two functions in H ∞ are said to form a corona pair if they satisfy the hypothesis in L. Carleson’s corona theorem, which in the case of interest here says that |a| + |u| is bounded away from 0 in D. Assuming this is so, Carleson’s theorem says there exist functions ψ and χ in H ∞ such that ψa + χu = 1. Then Aψ Aa = I, so Aa is invertible, and hence so is Aa¯ . Since Aa¯ Ku2 ⊂ H(b), the equality D(Aϕ ) = Ku2 follows, and with it the boundedness of Aϕ . To conclude this section I’ll present a pair of examples which expose an anomaly one encounters in trying to go beyond the analytic and coanalytic cases of unbounded truncated Toeplitz operators on Ku2 . The anomaly is related to the notion of angular derivative, a brief discussion of which is in order. Further details, including proofs, can be found, for example, in [7] and [8]. The function u is said to have an angular derivative in the sense of Carath´eodory (an ADC) at the point η of ∂D if u has a unimodular nontangential limit u(η) at η, and u has a nontangential limit u (η) at η (equivalently, (u(z) − u(η))/(z − η) → u (η) as z → η nontangentially). In that case u (η) = 0, and ηu (η)/u(η) > 0. A necessary and sufficient condition for u to have an ADC at η is that every function in Ku2 have a nontangential limit at η. When that happens, the evaluation functional on Ku2 induced by the nontangential limit at η is bounded; the corresponding kernel function is the function kηu (z) = (1 − u(η)u(z))/(1 − ηz). The kηu (z) = (u(z) − u(η))/(z − η) transform of kηu under the symmetry C is given by (from which one sees that kηu = ηu(η)kηu ). One has the relation Su kηu = ηkηu − ηk0u ([8], p. 496). Another necessary and sufficient condition for u to have an ADC at η is that u(η) exist as a nontangential limit and be of unit modulus, and that the function (u(z) − u(η))/(z − η) belong to H 2 . A closely related criterion due to P. R. Ahern and D. N. Clark [1] is needed for the first example below. Lemma 7.6. The function u has an ADC at the point η of ∂D if and only if the function k0u lies in the range of the operator Su − ηI. Proof. In fact, if u has an ADC at η then, by the relation mentioned at the end of the paragraph prior to the preceding one, (Su − ηI)kηu = −ηk0u . The condition is thus necessary. To prove the condition is sufficient, suppose there is a function f in Ku2 such that Su f − ηf = k0u . Since SKu2 is contained in the span of u and Ku2 , we then have (z − η)f (z) = 1 + cu(z) with c a constant. In this equality, the function on the left side has the nontangential limit 0 at η, so c = 0, and u has the nontangential limit −1/c at η. Thus |c| ≥ 1. But the strict inequality |c| > 1 is impossible, because
294
Sarason
IEOT
the function (1 + cu(z))/(z − η) = f (z) is in L2 on ∂D. Hence |c| = 1, so that also |u(η)| = 1. We can now write f (z) = −u(η)(u(z) − u(η))/(z − η), and it follows by the criterion mentioned in the paragraph preceding the statement of the lemma that u has an ADC at η. Example 1. We fix a point η in ∂D and let ϕ(z) = 1/(1 − ηz). On ∂D we have 1 1 + 1 − ηz 1 − η¯ z z 2 − ηz − η¯ = 1. = |1 − ηz|2
ϕ(z) + ϕ(z) =
Hence Aϕ+ϕ is the identity operator on Ku2 . It will be shown that D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) is dense in Ku2 , in other words, the operator Aϕ + Aϕ is densely defined. We shall see, however, that the equality Aϕ + Aϕ = Aϕ+ϕ | D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) fails when u has an ADC at η. For the case η = 1, the function a in the canonical representation ϕ = b/a is written down in Section 3. For general η one has √ √ 1+ 5 1+ 5 z−η −η √ √ a(z) = , b(z) = . 2 2 z − 3+ 5 z − 3+ 5 2
2
As the function b is bounded away from 0 in D, the functions a and b, in a trivial way, form a corona pair. This is known to imply that H(b) = Ta¯ H 2 (see [7], p. 62). We thus have D(Aϕ ) = H(b) ∩ Ku2 = Ta¯ H 2 ∩ Ku2 . But if h is a function in H 2 such that Ta¯ h is in Ku2 , then 0 = Tu¯ Ta¯ h = Ta¯ Tu¯ h, which because Ta¯ has a trivial kernel implies Tu¯ h = 0, i.e., h is in Ku2 . We thus have D(Aϕ ) = Aa¯ Ku2 , and so also D(Aϕ ) = Aa Ku2 . (In the present case, Aϕ = A0ϕ and Aϕ = A0ϕ .) Moreover, the function a(z)/(z − η) is an invertible function in H ∞ , so Aa equals Su − ηI times an invertible operator. Thus D(Aϕ ) = (Su − ηI)Ku2 , and so also D(Aϕ ) = (Su∗ − ηI)Ku2 . The argument that D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) is dense in Ku2 will use the fact that the operator Su − ηI is injective, which can be seen as follows. If f is a function in Ku2 such that Su f = ηf , then f 2 = Su f 2 = Pu Sf 2 ≤ Sf 2 = f 2 . The inequality above is strict unless Sf is in Ku2 , which forces Su f to equal Sf , and hence forces f to be 0 (since S − ηI is obviously injective). Consider now two nonzero functions g and h in Ku2 satisfying Su g − ηg = Su∗ h − ηh.
(7.1)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
295
Applying Su to the preceding equality, and using the relation Su Su∗ = I −(k0u ⊗k0u ), we get (Su − ηI)Su g = Su Su∗ h − ηSu h
= h − h(0)k0u − ηSu h
= −η(Su h − ηh) − h(0)k0u .
It follows that
(Su − ηI)(Su g + ηh) = −h(0)k0u . (7.2) From this point the reasoning depends on whether or not u has an ADC at
η. Case 1. u does not have an ADC at η. In this case we conclude from (7.2) and Lemma 7.2 that h(0) = 0. Since (7.2) in the present case then reduces to (Su − ηI)(Su g + ηh) = 0, it follows by the injectivity of Su − ηI that Su g + ηh = 0, which with (7.1) tells us that also Su∗ h + ηg = 0. Consider now any function h in Ku2 satisfying h(0) = 0, and define the function g to be −ηSu∗ h. Then 0 = Su (Su∗ h + ηg) = h − h(0)k0u + ηSu g = η(Su g + ηh). The pair of equalities Su∗ h + ηg = 0, Su g + ηh = 0 combine to give Su g − ηg = Su∗ h − ηh. We can conclude that D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) = {S ∗ h − ηh : h ∈ Ku2 , h(0) = 0}. Suppose the function h0 in Ku2 is orthogonal to D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ). Then for all h in Ku2 satisfying h(0) = 0, 0 = h0 , Su∗ h − ηh = (Su − ηI)h0 , h, implying that (Su − ηI)h0 is a scalar multiple of k0u . By Lemma 7.2 and the injectivity of Su − ηI, then, h0 = 0. We can conclude that D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) is dense in Ku2 . Now let the function f belong to D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ), say f = (Su − ηI)g = (Su∗ − ηI)h, where h and g are as in the preceding discussion. Rewriting the last equalities as f = −η(I − ηSu )g = −η(I − ηSu∗ )h, we see that Aϕ f = −ηg, Aϕ f = −ηh. Hence Aϕ f + Aϕ f = −ηg − ηh. As noted above, Su g + ηh = 0, so we have in fact Aϕ f + Aϕ f = Su g − ηg = f . In the case at hand, where u does not have an ADC at η, the operator Aϕ+ϕ agrees with Aϕ + Aϕ on D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ), as expected. Case 2. u has an ADC at η. In this case (7.2), together with the injectivity of Su − ηI and the equality Su kηu − ηkηu = −ηk0u , gives Su g + ηh = ηh(0)kηu , and hence also Su∗ h+ ηg = ηh(0)kηu (by (7.1)).
296
Sarason
IEOT
Consider now any function h in Ku2 , and define the function g by ηg = −Su∗ h + ηh(0)kηu .
(7.3)
It is asserted that then Su g − ηg = Su∗ h − ηh. In fact, applying Su to (7.3), we obtain ηSu g = −Su Su∗ h − nh(0)Su kηu
= −h + h(0)k0u − ηh(0)(ηkηu − ηk0u ) = −h + h(0)kηu ,
so that Su g +ηh = ηh(0)kηu = Su∗ h+ηg. The asserted equality Su g −ηg = Su∗ h−ηh, follows. We can conclude that D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) = (Su∗ − ηI)Ku2 = D(Aϕ ). Conjugation of the last equality gives D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) = D(Aϕ ). So in fact we have D(Aϕ ) = D(Aϕ ). In particular, D(Aϕ ) ∩ D(Aϕ ) is dense in Ku2 . Let f belong to D(Aϕ ) = D(Aϕ ), say f = Su g − ηg = Su∗ h − ηh. As in Case 1, we have Aϕ f + Aϕ f = −ηg − ηh. Combining this with the equality Su g + ηh = ηh(0)kηu , we get Aϕ f + Aϕ f = Su g − ηg − ηh(0)kηu = f − ηh(0)kηu .
(7.4)
We also have f (η) = f, kηu = Su∗ h − ηh, kηu = h, Su kηu − ηh(η)
= h, ηkηu − ηk0u − ηh(η) = −ηh(0).
Hence (7.4) can be written Aϕ f + Aϕ f = f − f (η)kηu . We see that Aϕ + Aϕ coincides in its domain with the operator I − (kηu ⊗ kηu ). In particular, it does not coincide there with Aϕ+ϕ . Example 2. This example is closely related to Example 1. We assume the function u has an ADC at the point η of ∂D, and we let ϕ(z) = −u(η)u(z)/(1 − ηz). The function a in the canonical representation ϕ = b/a is the same as in Example 1, while b here equals −u(η)u times the b from Example 1. Since b is divisible by u we have D(Tϕ ) = H(b) ⊃ Ku2 ([7], p. 10), so D(Aϕ ) = Ku2 , and also D(Aϕ ) = Ku2 . In fact, because u divides ϕ, Aϕ = Aϕ = 0.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Unbounded Toeplitz Operators
297
On the other hand, on ∂D, ϕ(z) + ϕ(z) = − =
u(η)u(z) u(η)u(z) − 1 − ηz 1 − η¯ z
1 − u(η)u(z) 1 − u(η)u(z) 1 1 + − − 1 − ηz 1 − η¯ z 1 − ηz 1 − η¯ z
= kηu (z) + kηu (z) − 1. It is proved in [8] (p. 502) that Aku +ku −1 = kηu ⊗ kηu . In the present case, therefore, η η Aϕ+ϕ = Aϕ + Aϕ .
8. A Problem Characterize the closed densely defined operators T on H 2 with the properties (i) D(T ) is S-invariant, and S ∗ T S = T | SD(T ), and (ii) if f is in D(T ) and f (0) = 0, then S ∗ f is in D(T ). Properties (i) and (ii) are possessed by Tϕ for ϕ in L2 , as well as by Tϕ and Tϕ for ϕ in N + . These Toeplitz operators are determined by their symbols. Is every closed densely defined operator on H 2 satisfying (i) and (ii) determined in some sense by a symbol? Can one characterize the infinite Toeplitz matrices that represent closed densely defined operators on H 2 satisfying (i) and (ii)?
References [1] P. R. Ahern and D. N. Clark, Radial limits and invariant subspaces. Amer. J. Math. 92 (1970), 332–342; MR 0262511 (41#7117). [2] L. de Branges and J. Rovnyak, Square Summable Power Series. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York–Toronto. Ont.–London, 1966; MR 0215065 (35#5909) [3] S. R. Garcia and M. Putinar, Complex symmetric operators and applications. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 358 (2006), 1285–1315; MR 2187654 (2006j;47036) [4] H. Helson, Large analytic functions. Linear Operators in Function Spaces (Timi¸soara, 1988), 209–216, Oper. Theory Adv. Appl. 43 Birkh¨ auser, Basel, 1990; MR 1090128 (92c:30038). [5] K. Izuchi, Personal communication. [6] N. K. Nikolski, Operators, functions, and systems: an easy reading. Vol. 1, Hardy, Hankel, and Toeplitz. Mathematical Sureys and Monographs, 92. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2002; MR 1864396 (2003i:47001a). [7] D. Sarason, Sub-Hardy Hilbert spaces in the unit disk. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1994; MR 1289670 (96k:46039). [8] D. Sarason, Algebraic properties of truncated Toeplitz operators. Operators and Matrices 1 (2007), 491–526. [9] S. M. Seubert, Unbounded dissipative compressed Toeplitz operators. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 290 (2004), 132–146; MR 2032231 (2004i:47053).
298
Sarason
IEOT
[10] D. Su´ arez, Closed commutants of the backward shift operator. Pacific J. Math. 179 (1997), 371–396; MR 1452540 (99a:47050). Donald Sarason Department of Mathematics University of California Berkeley, CA 94720-3840 U.S.A. e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: February 13, 2008
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 299–323 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/030299-25, published online April 17, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1590-9
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces in Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces Christoph Barbian Abstract. By Beurling’s theorem, the orthogonal projection onto an invariant subspace M of the Hardy space H 2 (D) on the unit disk can be represented as PM = Mφ Mφ∗ where φ is an inner multiplier of H 2 (D). This concept can be carried over to arbitrary Nevanlinna-Pick spaces but fails in more general settings. This paper introduces the notion of Beurling decomposable subspaces. An invariant subspace M of a reproducing kernel Hilbert space will be called Beurling decomposable if there exist (operator-valued) multipliers φ1 , φ2 such that PM = Mφ1 Mφ∗1 −Mφ2 Mφ∗2 and M = ran Mφ1 . We characterize the finitecodimensional and the finite-rank Beurling decomposable subspaces by means of their core function and core operator. As an application, we show that in many analytic Hilbert modules H, every finite-codimensional submodule M can be written as M = ri=1 pi · H with suitable polynomials pi . Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B32; Secondary 47A13, 47A15. Keywords. Reproducing kernel Hilbert space, invariant subspace, core function, core operator, analytic Hilbert module.
1. Introduction In many areas of analysis, reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces and their multipliers play an important role. Probably the best understood reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces are the Hardy space H 2 (D) and the Bergman space L2a (D) over the open unit disk in C. The unilateral shift on H 2 (D), that is, the multiplication by the independent variable z, is one of the few operators whose lattice of invariant subspaces is completely known. By Beurling’s theorem, a subspace M of H 2 (D) is invariant
300
Barbian
IEOT
for Mz precisely if it is of the form φ · H 2 (D) for some inner function φ, or equivalently, if the orthogonal projection on M can be represented as PM = Mφ Mφ∗ with some function φ ∈ H ∞ (D). Similar results in the more general setting of Nevanlinna-Pick (NP) spaces were proved by McCullough and Trent [28], and Greene, Richter and Sundberg [21]. Recall that a reproducing kernel Hilbert space over an arbitrary set D is by definition a Nevanlinna-Pick space if its reproducing kernel K has no zeroes and 1 if the function 1 − K is positive definite. Clearly, the Hardy space H 2 (D) and also the Arveson-Drury space H(Bd ) over the complex unit ball Bd are examples of NP spaces (see [8] for details). Theorem 1 (McCullough, Trent; Greene, Richter, Sundberg). Suppose that H is an NP space and that M ⊂ H is an invariant subspace (that is, M is closed and invariant for all multipliers). Then there exist a Hilbert space E and a multiplier φ : D → L(E, C) of H such that PM = Mφ Mφ∗
(and, in particular, M = ran Mφ )
(1.1)
holds. In the classical case H = H 2 (D), one can choose E = C, and the multiplier φ automatically is an inner function in H ∞ (D). Therefore, the above theorem contains Beurling’s invariant subspace theorem as a particular case. While the strategy of looking for factorizations of the form (1.1) is perfect for the representation of invariant subspaces in NP spaces, it fails in more general spaces such as the Bergman space L2a (D) over the complex disk or the multivariable Hardy and Bergman spaces on the open unit ball or polydisk in Cd . This becomes clear by the following result, which can be obtained by inspecting the proof of Theorem 1. Theorem 2. Suppose that H is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space over an arbitrary set D and that the reproducing kernel K of H has no zeroes. Suppose that M is an invariant subspace of H and let KM denote the reproducing kernel of M . Then PM can be factorized as in (1.1) if and only if the core function GM = KKM of M is positive definite. In this case, every factorization GM (z, w) = φ(z)φ(w)∗ (1) yields a multiplier φ : D → L(E, C) with PM = Mφ Mφ∗ . Note that the core function used in the preceding theorem is nothing but the Berezin transform of the orthogonal projection PM (cf. [12], [13]). Core functions were studied by Guo in [22], [23], and also appear as the root function in [32]. The above Beurling-type result for NP spaces then can be rephrased by saying that in NP spaces, every invariant subspace automatically has a positive definite core function. This behaviour essentially characterizes the class of NP spaces: if H is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space, which is normalized at some point z0 ∈ D in the sense that K(·, z0 ) ≡ 1, then the core function of the invariant subspace 1 Mz0 = {f ∈ H ; f (z0 ) = 0} is given by GMz0 = 1 − K . Hence, if all invariant
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
301
subspaces of H have a positive core function, then H necessarily is a NevanlinnaPick space. So in non-NP spaces, we cannot expect all invariant subspaces to have a positive core function. As observed by Guo [22], the extreme case occurs in the Bergman space setting, where no non-trivial invariant subspace has a positive definite core function. Motivated by these observations, we consider in the present paper invariant subspaces M of reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces with the property that the orthogonal projection onto M allows a more general representation of the form PM = Mφ1 Mφ∗1 − Mφ2 Mφ∗2 with suitable multipliers φi : D → L(Ei , C) such that in addition M = ran Mφ1 holds. Such spaces will be called Beurling decomposable. From the definition, it is immediately clear that the class of Beurling decomposable subspaces contains all subspaces with a positive definite core function, and it is the aim of this paper to show that many non-NP spaces arising in applications have a rich supply of Beurling decomposable subspaces. To use the concept of the core function, we shall require in the sequel that the kernel of the underlying reproducing kernel Hilbert space H ⊂ CD has no zeroes. Furthermore, we shall always assume that the functions K(·, w), w ∈ D, are multipliers of H. Finally, we suppose that the inverse kernel admits a representation of the form 1 = β(z)β(w)∗ (1) − γ(z)γ(w)∗ (1) K(z, w) with suitable multipliers β : D → L(B, C) and γ : D → L(C, C). We shall see that Nevanlinna-Pick spaces as well as the standard reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces on bounded symmetric domains in Cd (which form our basic examples) fulfill these conditions. The first main result of this paper (Theorem 3.1) gives a characterization of Beurling decomposable subspaces by means of their core function. Theorem 3. A closed subspace M of H is Beurling decomposable if and only if its core function can be written as GM (z, w) = φ1 (z)φ1 (w)∗ (1) − φ2 (z)φ2 (w)∗ (1) with multipliers φi ∈ M(H ⊗ Ei , H). The non-trivial ’if’ part of the preceding theorem will be used to show (Theorem 4.4) that, for a large class of examples, all finite-codimensional invariant subspaces are Beurling decomposable. Theorem 4. Suppose that D ⊂ Cd is a bounded symmetric domain with rank r and characteristic multiplicities a, b. Let H = Hν be one of the standard reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces, with ν ≥ r−1 2 a + 1. Then all finite-codimensional invariant subspaces of H are Beurling decomposable.
302
Barbian
IEOT
We shall see in Section 3 that in general not all invariant subspaces are Beurling decomposable. In fact, every Beurling decomposable subspace contains non-trivial multipliers and hence, well-known examples in [23] and [30] imply that even in very familiar spaces not all invariant subspaces are Beurling decomposable. In the particular case of the Bergman space on the unit disk, we give a complete characterization of the Beurling decomposable subspaces: We show (Theorem 5.1) that an invariant subspace M of L2a (D) is Beurling decomposable precisely if its extremal function is bounded. This implies in particular that L2a (D) contains infinite-codimensional invariant subspaces which are Beurling decomposable. Using the Beurling decomposability of finite-codimensional invariant subspaces, together with a technique going back to Douglas, Paulsen, Sah and Yan [16], which was extended by Guo [15], we prove that for a natural class of analytic reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces on domains D ⊂ Cd , the right essential spectrum σre (Mz ) of the multiplication tuple Mz = (Mz1 , . . . , Mzd ) coincides with the topological boundary of D (Proposition 4.5). As an application, we show that for the same class of reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces, every finite-codimensional invariant subspace is algebraically generated by finitely many polynomials (Corollary 4.6). These results apply in particular to the standard reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces Hν (with ν ≥ r−1 2 a + 1 and ν integer) on bounded symmetric domains. Theorem 5. Suppose that D ⊂ Cd is a bounded symmetric domain of rank r, with characteristic multiplicites a, b. Let H = Hν be one of the standard reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces Hν , with ν ≥ r−1 2 a + 1 and ν integer. Then the finite-codimensional invariant subspaces of H are exactly the closed subspaces M r of the form i=1 pi · H, where r ∈ N and p = (p1 , . . . , pr ) is a tuple of polynomials with Z(p) ⊂ D. Furthermore, if M is a finite-codimensional invariant subspace of H, then the polynomials p1 , . . . , pr can always be chosen as a generating set of the ideal M ∩ C[z] ⊂ C[z]. Similar results are due to Axler and Bourdon [9] in the setting of Bergman spaces over certain domains in the complex plane, and to Putinar for Bergman spaces over strictly pseudoconvex domains with smooth boundary (cf. Theorem 8.3.1 in [18]). Our result also extends the well-known Ahern-Clark-type result of Douglas, Paulsen, Sah and Yan (Corollary 2.8 in [16]), which states that (for a more general class of function spaces H) every finite-codimensional subspace of H r is of the form M = i=1 pi · H, where p = (p1 , . . . , pr ) is a tuple of polynomials with Z(p) ⊂ D. Different representation results for finite-codimensional invariant subspaces of Bergman spaces over certain domains in Cd can also be found in [9] and [11].
2. Preliminaries A Hilbert space H of complex-valued functions on an arbitrary set D is called a reproducing kernel Hilbert space if all evaluation functionals
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
303
δz : H → C , f → f (z) (z ∈ D) are continuous. In this case there exists a unique function (the reproducing kernel of H) K : D × D → C such that the function K(·, z) belongs to H for all z ∈ D and satisfies f, K(·, z) = f (z) (f ∈ H). It is easy to see that K is a positive definite function in the sense that, for all finite sequences z1 , . . . , zn in D, the matrices [K(zi , zj )]i,j are positive semidefinite. It is a well-known fact (see [7] for more information) that, for every positive definite function F , one can construct a unique reproducing kernel Hilbert space F ⊂ CD whose reproducing kernel is given by F . We call F the reproducing kernel Hilbert space associated to F . We shall write F ≤ G to indicate that G − F is positive definite. In this way we obtain a partial ordering on the set of all positive definite functions on D. Suppose that F1 , F2 : D × D → C are positive definite functions. Then F1 and F2 are said to be disjoint if the only positive definite function F which satisfies F ≤ F1 and F ≤ F2 is F = 0. It can be shown (see [31] for details) that F1 and F2 are disjoint if and only if the associated reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces F1 and F2 have trivial intersection, that is, F1 ∩ F2 = {0}. The following lemma provides a useful tool to decide whether or not a given function f : D → C belongs to a reproducing kernel Hilbert space. Lemma 2.1. Let H ⊂ CD denote a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with reproducing kernel K. For a function f : D → C, the following assertions are equivalent: (i) f belongs to H. (ii) There exists a real number c ≥ 0 such that the function D × D → C , (z, w) → c2 K(z, w) − f (z)f (w) is positive definite. In this case, f is the minimum of all constants c satisfying (ii). A proof of this well-known result can be found in [14]. A Kolmogorov factorization of a positive definite function F is a pair (E, d) consisting of a Hilbert space E and a function d : D → L(E, C) such that E = {d(w)∗ (1) ; w ∈ D} and F (z, w) = d(z)d(w)∗ (1) holds for all z, w ∈ D. Obviously, the reproducing kernel Hilbert space F associated to F and the mapping d : D → L(F , C) , z → δz , define a possible Kolmogorov factorization of F . If E is a Hilbert space and H is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with kernel K, then HE will denote the Hilbert space of all functions f : D → E such that for every x ∈ E the function fx : D → C , fx (z) = f (z), x
304
Barbian
belongs to H and such that f 2 =
IEOT
fei 2 < ∞
i
holds for some (equivalently every) orthonormal basis (ei )i of E. One easily verifies that the above norm · on HE does not depend on the choice of the orthonormal basis. The space HE can also be thought of as the reproducing kernel Hilbert space with operator-valued kernel K · 1E . We refer to [14] for further treatment of vectorvalued reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. It is quite standard to show that there exists a unique isometric isomorphism U : H ⊗ E → HE
with
U (f ⊗ x) = f · x (f ∈ H, x ∈ E)
between the Hilbertian tensor product H ⊗ E and HE . In the sequel, we will use this identification without further mentioning. Assume now that H is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with kernel K and that E, E∗ are arbitrary Hilbert spaces. In this setting, a function φ : D → L(E, E∗ ) is called an L(E, E∗ )-valued multiplier of H if for every function f ∈ H ⊗ E, the pointwise product φ · f belongs to H ⊗ E∗ . The collection of all such multipliers will be denoted by M(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ) and of course, we use the abbreviation M(H) = M(H, H). A standard application of the closed graph theorem shows that each φ ∈ M(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ) defines a bounded linear operator Mφ : H ⊗ E → H ⊗ E∗ , f → φ · f. Obviously, the operator norm of L(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ) induces a (semi-) norm · M on the space M(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ), the so-called multiplier norm. It is not hard to see that, if · M happens to be a norm (which is the case if K(z, z) > 0 for all z ∈ D), then M(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ) is a Banach space. It is a well-known fact that the functions K(·, w) (w ∈ D) are eigenfunctions for the adjoints of multiplication operators. More generally, if φ belongs to M(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ), then the equality Mφ∗ (K(·, w)x) = K(·, w)(φ(w)∗ x) holds for all x ∈ E∗ and w ∈ D. For a multiplier φ ∈ M(H ⊗ E, H), we obtain the formula Mφ Mφ∗ K(·, w) (z) = φ(z)φ(w)∗ (1) K(z, w) (z, w ∈ D) which will be frequently used in this paper. Lemma 2.2. Let H be a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with kernel K and let E, E∗ be arbitrary Hilbert spaces. For a function φ : D → L(E, E∗ ), the following are equivalent: (i) φ belongs to M(H ⊗ E, H ⊗ E∗ ). (ii) There exists a real number c ≥ 0 such that D × D → L(E∗ ) , (z, w) → K(z, w)(c2 − φ(z)φ(w)∗ ) is an operator-valued positive definite function. In this case Mφ is the minimum of all constants c satisfying (ii).
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
305
Analogously to the scalar definition, a function F : D × D → L(E) is called positive definite if, for all finite sequences z1 , . . . , zn , the matrix [F (zi , zj )]i,j is a positive operator on E n . A more general form of this result treating the case of arbitrary vector-valued reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces and their multipliers can be found in [14]. Next we recall the concept of subordinate kernels which was introduced in [7] and refined in [10]. In this context, a kernel simply is a complex-valued function on D × D. A kernel is called positive, if it is a positive definite function. A kernel L is said to be hermitian if L(z, w) = L(w, z) holds for all z, w ∈ D. Now let K : D × D → C denote a positive kernel and let H be the associated reproducing kernel Hilbert space. A kernel L : D × D → C is said to be subordinate to K (L ≺ K) if there exists a (necessarily unique) operator T ∈ L(H) such that L(z, w) = T K(·, w), K(·, z) (z, w ∈ D). In this case, T is called the representing operator for L. We write S(K) for the set of all kernels that are subordinate to K. Note that a subordinate kernel is hermitian (positive) if and only if its representing operator is self-adjoint (positive). Furthermore, every hermitian kernel in S(K) can be written as a difference of two positive kernels in S(K), and S(K) is the linear span of its positive kernels. To prove this, observe that the analogous statements are true in L(H). If L ≺ K is a positive kernel, one may ask for the relation between the associated reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. The following lemma answers this question. Lemma 2.3. Let K, L : D × D → C denote positive kernels and let H, L be the associated reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. Then the following are equivalent: (i) L is subordinate to K. (ii) There exists a real number c ≥ 0 such that cK − L is a positive kernel. (iii) L is continuously embedded in H. (iv) L is a linear subspace of H. If in this case, T ∈ L(H) is the the (positive) representing operator of L, then 1 L = ran T 2 . Proof. For the sake of completeness, we include a proof of this well-known fact. Suppose that L is subordinate to K with representing operator T . Then we can choose c ≥ 0 such that c1H − T is a positive operator. Consequently, cK − L is a positive kernel. Now fix a function f ∈ L with f L = 1. By Lemma 2.1, the kernel cK(z, w) − f (z)f (w) = (cK(z, w) − L(z, w)) + (L(z, w) − f (z)f (w)) is positive, √ and another application of Lemma 2.1 yields that f belongs to H with f H √ ≤ c. Therefore, L is contained in H and the inclusion mapping has norm at most c. If L is contained in H and the inclusion mapping i : L → H is bounded, then it is easy to verify that i∗ K(·, w) = L(·, w)
306
Barbian
IEOT
holds for all w ∈ D and therefore L is subordinate to K and is represented by the operator ii∗ ∈ L(H). This settles the equivalence of (i)–(iii). A simple application of the closed graph theorem furnishes the equivalence of (iii) and (iv). Now let T ∈ L(H) denote the (positive) representing operator for L. The identity 1 1 L(·, w), L(·, z) L = L(z, w) = T 2 K(·, w), T 2 K(·, z) H , valid for all z, w ∈ D, implies that there exists a unitary operator 1
1
α : L → ran T 2 with αL(·, w) = T 2 K(·, w). The calculation 1
T 2 αL(·, w), K(·, z) = = =
T K(·, w), K(·, z)
L(z, w) iL(·, w), K(·, z) (z, w ∈ D)
1 2
proves that i = T α. Finally, the observation that 1
1
1
1
i(L) = T 2 α(L) = T 2 (ran T 2 ) = ran T 2 completes the proof.
Of central importance for this paper are those positive kernels which can be factorized by multipliers. Lemma 2.4. Let K : D × D → C be a positive kernel and let H be the associated reproducing kernel Hilbert space. For a positive kernel G : D×D → C, the following assertions are equivalent: (i) G · K ∈ S(K). (ii) G · L ∈ S(K) for all L ∈ S(K). (iii) There exists a Hilbert space E and a multiplier φ ∈ M(H ⊗ E, H) such that G(z, w) = φ(z)φ(w)∗ (1) holds for all z, w ∈ D. In this case, if G denotes the reproducing kernel Hilbert space associated to G, then G is contained in M(H). Furthermore, the set of all positive kernels G satisfying the equivalent conditions above, is closed under pointwise addition and multiplication. Proof. By choosing a Kolmogorov factorization (E, φ) of G and using Lemma 2.3, the equivalence of (i) and (iii) becomes a reformulation of Lemma 2.2. Now suppose that (i) holds. Since every kernel S(K) can be written as a linear combination of positive kernels in S(K), it suffices to show that G · L ∈ S(K) holds for all positive L ∈ S(K). To this end, let c, c be positive constants such that cK − G · K and c K − L are positive. Then cc K − G · L = c (cK − G · K) + G · (c K − L) is positive definite as a sum and product of positive definite functions. Hence G · L belongs to S(K). The implication (ii) to (i) is obvious.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
307
We are now going to prove the inclusion G ⊂ M(H). Choose a positive number c such that cK − G · K is positive and let φ be a function in G with φ G = 1. Since by Lemma 2.1, the kernel K(z, w)(c − φ(z)φ(w)) = (cK(z, w) − K(z, w)G(z, w)) + K(z, w)(G(z, w) − φ(z)φ(w)) is positive, Lemma 2.2 ensures that φ is a multiplier of H. To prove the final assertion, fix two positive kernels G1 , G2 satisfying (i). Obviously (G1 + G2 ) · K = G1 · K + G2 · K belongs to S(K), since S(K) is a linear space. Now choose positive constants ci such that ci K − Gi · K are positive. Then c1 c2 K − G1 · G2 · K = c1 (c2 K − G2 · K) + G2 · (c1 K − G1 · K) is positive as well. Hence (G1 · G2 ) · K ∈ S(K).
3. Beurling decomposition of subspaces Throughout this section, let H ⊂ CD be a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with reproducing kernel K such that K has no zeroes. Furthermore, we suppose that the inverse kernel admits a representation of the form 1 = β(z)β(w)∗ (1) − γ(z)γ(w)∗ (1) (z, w ∈ D) (3.1) K(z, w) with multipliers β ∈ M(H ⊗ B, H) and γ ∈ M(H ⊗ C, H), where B, C are appropriate Hilbert spaces. Since the functions β(·)β(w)∗ (1) and γ(·)γ(w)∗ (1) are 1 complex-valued multipliers, the functions K(·,w) belong to M(H) for all w ∈ D. 1 In particular, since 1 = K(·,w) · K(·, w) for some w ∈ D, the space H contains the constant functions. Finally, we require that also the functions K(·, w) are multipliers. We will now discuss three classes of spaces which fulfill these requirements. Example 1. (a) Suppose that K is a Nevanlinna-Pick kernel. This means by definition that 1 is positive definite. Choose a K has no zeroes and that the kernel 1 − K 1 Kolmogorov factorization (C, γ) of 1 − K . Since the kernel D × D → L(C) , (z, w) → K(z, w)(1 − γ(z)γ(w)∗ ) = 1 is positive, Lemma 2.2 implies that γ is a multiplier with multiplier norm less or equal to 1. Since 1 = 1 − γ(z)γ(w)∗ (1) K(z, w) holds for all z, w ∈ D, the inverse kernel has a representation of the form 1 < 1 holds for all w ∈ D, we conclude that (3.1). Since γ(w) 2 = 1 − K(w,w) for w ∈ D, the function φw : D → C , φw (z) = γ(z)γ(w)∗ (1)
308
Barbian
IEOT
belongsto M(H), with multiplier norm strictly less than 1. Therefore the ∞ n series n=0 φw converges (absolutely) in M(H). On the other hand, the series converges pointwise to K(·, w). Consequently, the functions K(·, w) are multipliers for all w ∈ D. A simple argument shows that the class of kernels we consider is closed under pointwise multiplication. Hence products of Nevanlinna-Pick kernels belong to this class as well. (b) Assume that D is a bounded domain in Cd and that K is sesquianalytic on D × D, or equivalently, that H consists of holomorphic functions on D. Let us suppose further that the coordinate functions zi (1 ≤ i ≤ d)) are multipliers on H such that the Taylor spectrum of the commuting tuple Mz = (Mz1 , . . . , Mzd ) ∈ L(H)d is contained in D. Finally, we suppose that 1 K is defined and sesquianalytic on an open neighbourhood of D × D. In [10] (proof of Theorem 3.3) it is shown that every sesquianalytic kernel on a domain is subordinate to the reproducing kernel of some weighted Bergman 1 is sesquianalytic space. Since we can find a domain U ⊃ D such that K 1 on U × U , the hermitian kernel K can be written as a difference of two positive definite sesquianalytic kernels defined on U × U . Taking Kolmogorov factorizations of these positive kernels, we obtain functions β and γ which satisfy the identity (3.1) and, in addition, are analytic on U . The assumption on the spectrum of Mz guarantees that every operator-valued function which is analytic on a neighbourhood of D, belongs to M(H) (see for example [5] for a proof). Thus, the functions β, γ are in fact multipliers of H. Therefore a decomposition of the form (3.1) automatically exists in this situation. The condition that the functions K(·, w) are multipliers of H probably is not automatically fulfilled in this situation. The following example suggests that this condition depends in an intimate way on symmetry properties of D. (c) We now focus on reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces over bounded symmetric domains in Cd . To this end, we fix a Cartain domain in Cd of rank r and characteristic multiplicities a, b. Let us denote by h the Jordan triple determinant of D and let H = Hν be the reproducing kernel Hilbert space associated to the kernel K(z, w) = Kν (z, w) = h(z, w)−ν , where ν is in the Wallach set of D. It is well known that K has no zeroes and H contains the constant functions. It is shown in [17] that, under the additional hypothesis that ν ≥ r−1 2 a + 1, the inverse kernel admits a representation of the form (3.1). For ν in the continuous Wallach set (this means ν > r−1 2 a), the functions K(·, w) are multipliers for all w ∈ D. In fact, it is proved in [6] that the Taylor spectrum of the tuple Mz is D. Therefore, by the same argument as in the previous example, it suffices to show that K(·, w) is analytic on an open neighbourhood of D. To see this, fix w ∈ D and choose a real number 0 < ρ < 1 such that wρ ∈ D. By homogeneous expansion, it can easily be checked that K satisfies the equation K(z, w) = K(ρz, wρ ) for all
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
309
z ∈ D. Obviously the right-hand side defines an analytic extension of K(·, w) on the set ρ1 D which is an open neighbourhood of D. Hence (at least for ν ≥ r−1 2 a + 1), the spaces Hν fulfill the conditions at the beginning of this section. Following [22] we define the core function and the core operator of a closed subspace of H. To this end, note first that every closed subspace M of H is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space itself. In the following, the reproducing kernel of M will be denoted by KM , and it is very easy to see that KM (z, w) = PM K(·, w), K(·, z)
holds for all z, w ∈ D. The quotient GM = KKM is called the core function of M . The representing operator of GM is called the core operator of GM , and denoted 1 by ∆M ∈ L(H) (note that by Lemma 2.4, GM = K · L ≺ K holds for all kernels L ≺ K and, in particular, for KM ). The rank of M is defined to be the rank of ∆M , that is, rank M = rank ∆M = dim ran ∆M . In many cases, the core operator can be expressed in a very concrete form. Example 2. 1 is a polynomial in z and w, (a) Suppose that D is an open set in Cd and that K 1 (z, w) = cα,β z α w β . K α,β
Assume further that the coordinate functions zi (1 ≤ i ≤ d) are multipliers of H. Let Mz denote the commuting tuple (Mz1 , . . . , Mzd ). Then cα,β Mzα PM Mz∗ β ∆M = α,β
is the core operator of a given subspace M of H. Note that the identity GM + GM ⊥ = 1 holds for every closed subspace M of H, and let PC denote the orthogonal projection onto the one-dimensional subspace of all constant functions in H. Since the constant kernel 1 is represented by the operator 1 2 PC , we infer that ∆M + ∆M ⊥ = 1 2 PC . This observation and the above formula for ∆M show that the finite dimension of M or M ⊥ implies that both ∆M and ∆M ⊥ have finite rank. (b) Suppose that D is a bounded symmetric domain in Cd and adopt the notations of Example 1. In view of the Faraut-Koranyi formula 1 = (−ν)m Km (z, w) (z, w ∈ D) K(z, w) m (see [19] for details), we show that ∆M = (−ν)m Km (LMz , RMz∗ )(PM ) m
310
Barbian
IEOT
∗ (at least if ν ≥ r−1 2 a + 1). In the above expression, LMz and RMz denote the tuples of left and right multiplications with the operators Mzi and Mz∗i , respectively. Since the kernels Km are polynomials in z and w, the terms of the series are well defined. Moreover, Km is positive definite and hence
0 ≤ Km (LMz , RMz∗ )(PM ) ≤ Km (LMz , RMz∗ )(1H ). The convergence of the series above now follows directly by a result in [17], where it is shown that the series |(−ν)m | Km (LMz , RMz∗ )(1H ) m
converges (for ν ≥
r−1 2 a
+ 1).
We now turn to the study of invariant subspaces of H. A closed subspace M of H will be called K-invariant if it is invariant under multiplication by all 1 . As usual, M is said to be invariant if φ · M ⊂ M for functions K(·, w) and K(·,w) all φ ∈ M(H). As indicated in the introduction, an invariant subspace M of H is called Beurling decomposable if there exist Hilbert spaces E1 , E2 and multipliers φ1 ∈ M(H ⊗ E1 , H), φ2 ∈ M(H ⊗ E2 , H) such that PM = Mφ1 Mφ∗1 − Mφ2 Mφ∗2
and
ran Mφ1 = M.
In this case, the pair (φ1 , φ2 ) is called a Beurling decomposition of M . Let M be a Beurling decomposable subspace of H. The obvious identity KM (z, w) = (φ1 (z)φ1 (w)∗ (1) − φ2 (z)φ2 (w)∗ (1))K(z, w)
(3.2)
valid for all z, w ∈ D, shows that the functions KM (·, w) are multipliers of H, since we supposed K(·, w) ∈ M(H) for all w ∈ D. Hence the set M ∩ M(H) is dense in M . An example given by Rudin (cf. [30], Theorem 4.1.1) shows that there exists an invariant subspace of the Hardy space H 2 (D2 ) over the bidisk which does not contain any nonzero multiplier φ ∈ M(H 2 (D2 )) = H ∞ (D2 ). So in general, we cannot expect all invariant subspaces to be Beurling decomposable. From (3.2), we see immediately that GM (z, w) = φ1 (z)φ1 (w)∗ (1) − φ2 (z)φ2 (w)∗ (1) holds for all z, w ∈ D. Equivalently, GM can be written as the difference of two positive kernels G1 , G2 satisfying K · Gi ≺ K for i = 1, 2. As we shall see in the following theorem, the existence of such a decomposition is basically sufficient for the Beurling decomposability of M . Theorem 3.1. Let M be a closed subspace of H which is K-invariant. Then M is Beurling decomposable if and only if there exist positive kernels G1 , G2 on D such that (i) GM = G1 − G2 (ii) K · Gi ≺ K for i = 1, 2.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
311
Furthermore, G1 and G2 can always be chosen disjoint. If G1 , G2 are disjoint, then any pair of Kolmogorov factorizations φ1 : D → L(E1 , C)
,
φ2 : D → L(E2 , C)
of G1 and G2 defines a Beurling decomposition of M . Proof. Suppose that M is Beurling decomposable. Then the above discussion proves the existence of positive kernels G1 , G2 satisfying conditions (i) and (ii). In order to prove the opposite direction, let us first point out that we may assume G1 , G2 to be disjoint. In fact, one can show that the set {G : D × D → C ; 0 ≤ G ≤ G1 , G2 } is inductively ordered (see [4] or [31] for details). Let Gmax be a maximal element in this set and write G1 = G1 − Gmax
G2 = G2 − Gmax .
and
By construction, G1 , G2 are disjoint positive kernels which satisfy condition (i). Since K · Gi ≺ K · Gi ≺ K holds for i = 1, 2, condition (ii) is fulfilled as well. Thus let us suppose that G1 and G2 are disjoint. Choose functions φ1 : D → L(E1 , C) ,
φ2 : D → L(E2 , C)
such that G1 (z, w) = φ1 (z)φ1 (w)∗ (1)
G2 (z, w) = φ2 (z)φ2 (w)∗ (1)
and
holds for all z, w ∈ D. Condition (ii) guarantees that φ1 , φ2 are in fact multipliers. It follows that Mφ1 Mφ∗1 − Mφ2 Mφ∗2 K(·, w), K(·, z) = (G1 (z, w) − G2 (z, w))K(z, w) =
KM (z, w)
=
PM K(·, w), K(·, z) (z, w ∈ D),
and therefore that
Mφ1 Mφ∗1 − Mφ2 Mφ∗2 = PM . It remains to show that ran Mφ1 = M . To this end, we note that G1 , G2 belong 1 · K belongs to S(K). to S(K) by Lemma 2.4, since the constant kernel 1 = K Let ∆1 , ∆2 ∈ L(H) denote the (positive) representing operators for G1 , G2 . Since G1 , G2 are disjoint, the associated reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces G1 and G2 have trivial intersection. By Lemma 2.3 we obtain that 1
1
ran ∆12 ∩ ran ∆22 = {0} and hence that ran ∆1 ∩ ran ∆2 = {0}. Now it is an elementary exercise to verify that the ranges of ∆1 , ∆2 must necessarily be contained in the closure of the range of ∆M = ∆1 − ∆2 . Since all the functions 1 · KM (·, w) (w ∈ D) ∆M K(·, w) = GM (·, w) = K(·, w)
312
Barbian
IEOT
are contained in M , it follows that ran ∆M ⊂ M and hence that ran ∆1 ⊂ ran ∆M ⊂ M. Therefore also the functions G1 (·, w) = ∆1 K(·, w) are contained in M for all w ∈ D. Using the K-invariance of M , we see that Mφ1 Mφ∗1 K(·, w) = G1 (·, w)K(·, w) ∈ M for every w ∈ D. Thus ran Mφ1 ⊂ M . The opposite inclusion is easier to prove. First, it is elementary to show and well known that for Hilbert spaces H1 , H2 , H and operators A1 ∈ L(H1 , H), A2 ∈ L(H2 , H) with A1 A∗1 ≥ A2 A∗2 , there exists a contraction C ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) with CA∗1 = A∗2 . In view of A1 A∗1 − A2 A∗2 = A1 (1H1 − C ∗ C)A∗1 , it is obvious that ran A1 A∗1 − A2 A∗2 ⊂ ran A1 . To prove that M ⊂ ran Mφ1 , it suffices to apply this remark with A1 = Mφ1 and A2 = Mφ2 . Corollary 3.2. For every λ ∈ D, the invariant subspace Mλ = {f ∈ H ; f (λ) = 0} = {K(·, λ)}⊥ is Beurling decomposable. Proof. An easy calculation shows that K(z, λ)K(w, λ) GMλ (z, w) = 1 − K(λ, λ)K(z, w) K(z, λ)K(w, λ) K(z, λ)K(w, λ) ∗ ∗ γ(z)γ(w) (1) − β(z)β(w) (1) = 1+ K(λ, λ) K(λ, λ) holds for all z, w ∈ D. Since the function K(·, λ) is a multiplier of H, this furnishes the desired decomposition of GMλ . The spaces Mλ considered above have codimension one and form, in some sense, the simplest type of invariant subspaces of H. Now is natural to examine arbitrary subspaces of finite codimension. Proposition 3.3. If M ⊂ H is a finite-codimensional subspace of H which is Kinvariant, then the following assertions are equivalent: (i) M ⊥ ⊂ M(H). (ii) M is Beurling decomposable. Proof. Let M be Beurling decomposable. As we have observed earlier, KM (·, w) is a multiplier for every w ∈ D. As the functions K(·, w) are supposed to belong to M(H), the functions KM ⊥ (·, w) = K(·, w) − KM (·, w)
(w ∈ D)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
313
define multipliers as well. Thus M ⊥ , being the linear span of the KM ⊥ (·, w), is a subset of M(H). Suppose conversely that M ⊥ ⊂ M(H). Choose an orthonormal ⊥ basis (ui )m i=1 of M , and note that KM ⊥ (z, w) = PM ⊥ K(·, w), K(·, z) =
m
ui (z)ui (w)
(z, w ∈ D).
i=1
As the functions ui are all multipliers, Lemma 2.4 yields K · KM ⊥ ∈ S(K). We define B(z, w) = β(z)β(w)∗ (1) and C(z, w) = γ(z)γ(w)∗ (1). As B and C are positive kernels with K · B, K · C ∈ S(K), another application of Lemma 2.4 proves that the decomposition KM ⊥ = (1 + KM ⊥ · C) − (KM ⊥ · B). K fulfills the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1. GM = 1 −
Later we shall see that in many cases of practical interest, condition (i) of the above proposition is automatically fulfilled for all finite-codimensional invariant subspaces. We conclude this section by giving a characterization of Beurling decomposability for finite-rank subspaces. Let M be a Beurling decomposable subspace. From the definitions, it is clear that all functions GM (·, w) = ∆M K(·, w) (w ∈ D) belong to M(H). Moreover, the range of the core operator ∆M consists of multipliers. In order to prove this, we choose G1 , G2 as in Theorem 3.1 and operators ∆1 , ∆2 ∈ L(H) representing G1 , G2 . Let G1 , G2 denote the associated kernel spaces and note that by Lemma 2.4 and Lemma 2.3, 1
ran ∆i ⊂ ran ∆i2 = Gi ⊂ M(H)
(i = 1, 2).
Hence ran ∆M ⊂ ran ∆1 + ran ∆2 ⊂ M(H). For finite-rank invariant subspaces M , the condition ran ∆M ⊂ M(H) is also sufficient for the Beurling decomposability of M . Proposition 3.4. Let M be a closed subspace of H which is K-invariant. Suppose that M has finite rank. Then M is Beurling decomposable if and only if ran ∆M is contained in M(H). In this case, for every decomposition GM = G1 − G2 with disjoint positive kernels G1 , G2 ∈ S(K), it follows that K · Gi ≺ K for i = 1, 2. In particular, there exist multipliers φ1 , . . . , φs , ψ1 , . . . , ψt ∈ ran ∆M (s + t = rank M ) such that s t Mφi Mφ∗i − Mψj Mψ∗j PM = i=1
and M=
j=1 s i=1
φi · H.
314
Barbian
IEOT
Proof. Suppose that the inclusion ran ∆M ⊂ M(H) holds. Fix an arbitrary decomposition GM = G1 − G2 with disjoint positive kernels G1 , G2 ∈ S(K). Let ∆M = ∆1 − ∆2 denote the corresponding decomposition of ∆M . As seen in the proof of Theorem 3.1, the disjointness of G1 , G2 and the finite rank of ∆M imply that ran ∆1 ∩ ran ∆2 = {0} and ran ∆M = ran ∆1 + ran ∆2 . Since in particular ran ∆i ⊂ M(H), there exist multipliers φ1 , . . . , φs and ψ1 , . . . , ψt (s + t = rank M ) with s t φi ⊗ φi and ∆2 = ψj ⊗ ψj . ∆1 = i=1
j=1
Since G1 (z, w) = ∆1 K(·, w), K(·, z) =
s
φi (z)φi (w),
i=1
and analogously G2 (z, w) = tj=1 ψj (z)ψj (w), an application of Lemma 2.4 shows that K · Gi ∈ S(K) for i = 1, 2. Hence G1 and G2 are disjoint kernels satisfying the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1. But then the Beurling decomposability of M and all remaining assertions follow directly from Theorem 3.1.
4. Application to analytic Hilbert modules Throughout this section, we fix a bounded open set D ⊂ Cd and suppose that H ⊂ O(D) is an analytic Hilbert module in the sense of [15] having some additional properties which allow us to apply the results of the preceding section. To be more precise, we shall suppose that (A) H is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space containing the constant functions; (B) H is a C[z]-module, or equivalently, the coordinate functions zi (1 ≤ i ≤ d) are multipliers of H; (C) the polynomials are dense in H; (D) there are no points z ∈ Cd \D for which the mapping C[z] → C , p → p(z) extends to a continuous linear form on all of H. In the language of [15] this means that the set of virtual points of H coincides with D. In [15] a Hilbert space H ⊂ O(D) satisfying the above conditions is called an analytic Hilbert module. To be able to apply the results of Section 3 we require in addition that: 1 admits (E) the reproducing kernel K of H has no zeroes and the inverse kernel K a decomposition of the form (3.1) with suitable multipliers β, γ. (F) the Taylor spectrum σ(Mz ) of the tuple Mz = (Mz1 , . . . , Mzd ) ∈ L(H)d is contained in D; (G) for all z ∈ D, there exist open neighbourhoods U ⊂ D of z and V of D such that K|U×D admits a zero-free sesquianalytic extension to U × V .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
315
Although these conditions seem to be rather technical, they are general enough to cover in particular the standard reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces on bounded symmetric domains. Example 3. Suppose that D is a bounded symmetric domain with rank r and characteristic multiplicities a, b and that ν is in the continuous Wallach set of D, that is, ν > r−1 2 a. It is well known that the reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces Hν contain the polynomials as a dense subset. By a recent result of Arazy and Zhang [6], the coordinate functions are multipliers of Hν . For the special case that Hν is the Bergman space on D, it is shown in [24] that there are no virtual points outside D. But it is easy to see that the given proof remains valid for all ν > r−1 2 a. That condition (E) is satisfied (at least if ν ≥ r−1 a + 1) was observed earlier in Example 2 1. According to [6], the Taylor spectrum of Mz is D. To show that condition (G) is fulfilled, we fix z ∈ D and a positive number 0 < ρ < 1 such that zρ ∈ D. If Kν : D × D → C denotes the reproducing kernel of Hν , then the function 1 ζ ρD × D → C , (ζ, ω) → Kν ( , ρω) ρ ρ is a zero-free sesquianalytic extension of Kν |ρD×D . This can be seen by use of the Faraut-Koranyi expansion Kν (z, w) = (ν)m Km (z, w) (z, w ∈ D), m
where the sum ranges over all signatures m of length r, the numbers (ν)m are the generalized Pochhammer symbols and the functions Km are the reproducing kernels of the homogeneous spaces Pm of the Peter-Weyl decomposition Hν = Pm . m
Hence, the spaces Hν (for ν ≥
r−1 2 a
+ 1) satisfy the conditions (A)-(G).
We collect some consequences of our hypotheses. As mentioned earlier, every function φ ∈ O(D) automatically is a multiplier of H and the equality Mφ = φ(Mz ) holds, where the right-hand side is formed with the help of Taylor’s functional calculus. A proof of this fact can be found in [5]. When dealing with analytic Hilbert modules, there is a natural notion of submodules. A linear subspace M of H is called a submodule of H if it is closed in H and a submodule of H as a C[z]-module (in other words, a common invariant subspace of the tuple Mz ). Of course, this concept differs from the definition of invariant subspaces as given before. Obviously, every invariant subspace is a submodule, but the converse is not necessarily true. However, because of condition (F ) every finite-codimensional submodule M of H automatically is an O(D)-submodule of H and hence K-invariant by conditions (G) and (E). To see this, first note that by Theorem 2.2.5 in [15], the canonical mapping C[z]/(M ∩ C[z]) → H/M , [p] → [p]
316
Barbian
IEOT
is an isomorphism of (finite dimensional) linear spaces and the inclusion σp (Mz , C[z]/(M ∩ C[z])) ⊂ D holds. Therefore we have σ(Mz , H/M ) = σ(Mz , C[z]/(M ∩ C[z])) = σp (Mz , C[z]/(M ∩ C[z])) ⊂ D and, by Lemma 2.2.3 in [18], we obtain σ(Mz |M ) ⊂ σ(Mz ) ∪ σ(Mz , H/M ) = D = σ(Mz ). It is a well-known property of the analytic functional calculus (see Lemma 2.5.8 in [18]) that in this case, M is invariant for φ(Mz ), whenever φ is analytic on an open neighbourhood of σ(Mz ). Before we proceed, we formulate the concept of ’higher order kernels’. Lemma 4.1. For every multiindex α ∈ Nd0 and every w ∈ D, there exists a unique (α) function Kw ∈ O(D) satisfying (α)
Dα f (w) = f, Kw
for all f ∈ H. If ((w1 , α1 ), . . . , (wm , αm )) are pairwise different, then the functions (α ) (α ) Kw11 , . . . , Kwmm are linearly independent in H. Proof. Since the inclusion mapping H → O(D) is continuous, the higher order point evaluation (α) : H → C , f → Dα f (w) δw defines a continuous linear functional for every α ∈ Nd0 and w ∈ D. Hence (α) (α) ∗ Kw = δw (1) is the unique function in H with (α)
Dα f (w) = f, Kw
for all functions f ∈ H. Let us observe that ∗
(α) (α) (α) (z) = δw (1), K(·, z) = 1, δw K(·, z) = (Dα K(·, z))(w) Kw (α)
for all z, w ∈ D and α ∈ Nd0 . It remains to show that the functions Kw belong to O(D). By assumption (G), there exist open neighbourhoods V of D and U ⊂ D of w such that K|U×D extends to a sesquianalytic function H : U × V → C. But then h : V˜ → O(U ) , z → H(·, z), defined on the set V˜ = {z ; z ∈ V }, is analytic as a function with values in the Fr´echet space O(U ). Since continuous linear maps preserve analyticity, it follows that the function V → C , z → (Dα H(·, z))(w) (α)
is analytic again and, as seen above, extends the function Kw .
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
317
(α )
To see that the functions Kwi i (1 ≤ i ≤ m) are linearly independent, choose polynomials p1 , . . . , pm such that 1 if i=j . Dαi pj (wi ) = 0 else The observation that m m αi (αi ) cj = ci D pj (wi ) = pj , ci K w
(1 ≤ j ≤ m) i i=1
i=1
holds for any choice of complex numbers c1 , . . . , cm , completes the proof.
The following definitions are, up to a slight reformulation, taken from [15]. Let w ∈ D be arbitrary. For a polynomial p = α cα z α ∈ C[z] set (p) (α) Kw = cα K w . α
Then (p)
= f, Kw
cα Dα f (w)
α
for f ∈ H, and the mapping (p) γw : C[z] → H , p → Kw
is antilinear and one-to-one by the preceding lemma. Let M be a submodule of H. Then −1 (M ⊥ ) ⊂ C[z] Mw = γw is a linear subspace and the enveloping space of M defined by Mwe = (γw (Mw ))⊥ ⊂ H is a submodule containing M . We refer to [15] for more details. For an arbitrary subspace N of H, we denote by Z(N ) the zero variety of N , that is, Z(N ) = {z ∈ D ; f (z) = 0 for all f ∈ N }. Now consider a finite-codimensional submodule M of H. Then the zero sets of the enveloping spaces Mwe have a very simple structure. More precisely, we observe that {w} if w ∈ Z(M ) e Z(Mw ) = ∅ else holds for all w ∈ D. To prove this, we suppose first that z ∈ Z(Mwe ). Then the function K(·, z) is contained in γw (Mw ) = γw (Mw ) since Mw has finite dimension (α) by hypothesis. Therefore K(·, z) is a linear combination of the elements Kw and e hence z = w. This proves the inclusion Z(Mw ) ⊂ {w}. For obvious reasons, we have Z(Mwe ) ⊂ Z(M ). So it remains to show that w ∈ Z(Mwe ) whenever w ∈ Z(M ). But w ∈ Z(M ) is equivalent to 1 ∈ Mw which implies K(·, w) ∈ γw (Mw ). Hence w ∈ Z(Mwe ).
318
Barbian
IEOT
The following result completely describes the finite-codimensional submodules of H by means of the enveloping spaces Mwe and appears as Corollary 2.2.6 in [15] . Lemma 4.2. Suppose M is a finite-codimensional submodule of H. Then we have 1. Z(M ) is a finite subset of D. 2. M = w∈Z(M) Mwe . 3. dim M ⊥ = w∈Z(M) dim Mw . This enables us to prove that, for every finite-codimensional submodule of M , the orthogonal complement of M consists entirely of multipliers. Other variants of this result have been proved by Guo and Zheng (cf. [24], or Corollaries 2.5.3 and 2.5.4 in [15]). Proposition 4.3. Assume that M is a finite-codimensional submodule of H. Then the inclusions M ⊥ ⊂ O(D) ⊂ M(H) hold. Proof. Assume first that Z(M ) = {w} for some w ∈ D. By Lemma 4.2, we obtain (p) M = Mwe = (γw (Mw ))⊥ , and therefore M ⊥ = γw (Mw ). Since every Kw belongs to O(D) by Lemma 4.1, it follows that ran γw ⊂ O(D), . If Z(M ) is arbitrary, then for every w ∈ Z(M ), the subspace Mwe is a finite-codimensional submodule with Z(Mwe ) = {w}, and thus (Mwe )⊥ ⊂ O(D). Another application of Lemma 4.2 yields (Mwe )⊥ ⊂ O(D). M⊥ = w∈Z(M)
The main result of this section can now be stated. Theorem 4.4. Suppose that M is a finite-codimensional submodule of H. Then M is Beurling decomposable. If in addition M has finite rank, then there exist multipliers φ1 , . . . , φs and ψ1 , . . . , ψt (s + t = rank M ) such that PM =
s
Mφi Mφ∗i −
i=1
and M=
t
Mψj Mψ∗j
j=1 s
φi · H.
i=1
The functions φ1 , . . . , φs and ψ1 , . . . , ψt can be chosen in O(D). Proof. By Propositions 4.3 and 3.3, the space M is Beurling decomposable. Choose an orthonormal basis e1 , . . . , er of M ⊥ . Since KM ⊥ (z, w) =
r i=1
ei (z)ei (w)
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
319
holds for all z, w ∈ D, it is clear that the functions KM ⊥ (·, w) belong to O(D) 1 for all w ∈ D. Since by condition (G) the functions K(·,w) belong to O(D) for all w ∈ D, we infer that GM (·, w) = 1 −
1 · KM ⊥ (·, w) K(·, w)
belongs to O(D) for all w ∈ D. Now suppose in addition that M has finite rank. Then ran ∆M , being the linear span of the functions GM (·, w), is contained in O(D). By Proposition 3.4, there are multipliers φ1 , . . . , φs and ψ1 , . . . , ψt in ran ∆M allowing the claimed representations of PM and M . As an application, we compute the right essential spectrum σre (Mz ) of the commuting tuple Mz . Recall that the right essential spectrum of a commuting tuple T ∈ L(H)d is the set of all λ ∈ Cd for which the last cohomology group in the Koszul complex of λ − T has infinite dimension. Equivalently, λ ∈ Cd is not in the right essential spectrum of T exactly if the row operator (T1 , . . . , Td ) ∈ L(H d , H) has finite-codimensional range. Proposition 4.5. Suppose that the inverse kernel σre (Mz ) = ∂D.
1 K
is a polynomial in z, w. Then
Proof. First of all, observe that σre (Mz ) ⊂ σ(Mz ) ⊂ D. We are now going to prove that σre (Mz ) ∩ D = ∅. To this end, fix λ ∈ D and let Mλ be the finite-codimensional submodule Mλ = {f ∈ H ; f (λ) = 0} = {K(·, λ)}⊥ . By Example 2, the submodule Mλ has finite rank, and Theorem 4.4 shows that there exist multipliers φ1 , . . . , φs ∈ O(D), such that Mλ =
s
φi · H.
i=1
The row operator (Mφ1 , . . . , Mφs ) ∈ L(Hs , H) consequently has finite-codimensional range. This means that 0 is not in the right essential spectrum of the commuting tuple Mφ = (Mφ1 , . . . , Mφs ) ∈ L(H)s . By the spectral mapping theorem for the right essential spectrum (Corollary 2.6.9 in [18]), we have σre (Mφ ) = φ(σre (Mz )). Since φ(λ) = 0, it follows that λ ∈ / σre (Mz ). This proves that σre (Mz ) ⊂ ∂D. Suppose conversely that λ is in the boundary of D. Then λ is not a virtual point of H. As observed in [15], this is equivalent to the fact that the maximal
320
Barbian
IEOT
ideal of C[z] at λ is dense in H, in other words d
(λi − Mzi )H =
i=1
d (λi − Mzi )C[z] = H. i=1
Assume now that λ ∈ / σre (Mz ). Then the space d
(λi − Mzi )H ⊂ H
i=1
is closed and therefore equals H. Since the surjectivity spectrum is closed, there exists some r > 0 such that d
(µi − Mzi )H = H
i=1
holds for all µ ∈ Cd with |µ − λ| < r. Hence there would have to be a point µ ∈ D with 1 ∈ di=1 (µi − Mzi )H. This contradiction completes the proof. 1 We point out that the condition that K is a polynomial in z and w is fulfilled by many spaces arising in applications. In the case that H = Hν is one of the standard reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces over a bounded symmetric domain in Cd , it can easily be verified that the inverse kernel is a polynomial in z and w if and only if ν is an integer. As an application of Proposition 4.5, we prove the following supplement to the Ahern-Clark type result stated in [16] and [15] (Theorem 2.2.3). 1 Corollary 4.6. Suppose that K is a polynomial in z and w. Then the finitecodimensional submodules of H are exactly the closed subspaces M of the form r M = i=1 pi · H, where p = (p1 , . . . , pr ) is a tuple of polynomials with Z(p) ⊂ D.
Proof. Suppose that M is a finite-codimensional submodule of H. By Theorem 2.2.3 in [15], the intersection M ∩ C[z] is a finite-codimensional ideal in C[z] with Z(I) ⊂ D and M= I. Now we choose a generating set p = (p1 , . . . , pr ) of I and r claim that M = i=1 pi · H. Since M =I=
r i=1
pi · C[z] =
r
pi · H,
i=1
it suffices to show that the row operator (Mp1 , . . . , Mpr ) ∈ L(Hr , H) has closed range. But this is obvious, because Z(p) = Z(I) ⊂ D and σre (Mz ) = ∂D, and hence 0∈ / σre (Mp1 , . . . , Mpr ) = p(σre (Mz )). The proof shows that the polynomials p1 , . . . , pr can be chosen as a generating set of the Ideal M ∩ C[z]. If in particular d = 1, then we can achieve that r = 1.
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
321
Note also that, under the same hypotheses, Gleason’s problem can be solved in H. Recall that Gleason’s problem is, for a given function f ∈ H and λ ∈ D, to find functions g1 , . . . , gd ∈ H satisfying f (z) − f (λ) =
d
(zi − λi )gi (z) (z ∈ D).
i=1
To solve Gleason’s problem, it is therefore sufficient to apply Corollary 4.6 to the submodule Mλ = {h ∈ H ; h(λ) = 0}.
5. Beurling decomposable subspaces of the Bergman space In this final section, we characterize the Beurling decomposable subspaces of the Bergman space L2a (D). Recall that, given an invariant subspace M of L2a (D), there exists a unique solution gM of the extremal problem sup{Re f (n) (0) ; f ∈ M, f ≤ 1}, known as the extremal function of M . It is easy to see that gM is always a unit vector in M zM . For further details on the extremal function, the reader is referred to [25]. Theorem 5.1. Suppose that M is an invariant subspace of L2a (D). Then M is Beurling decomposable if and only if gM ∈ H ∞ (D). In this case, M = ran gM . Proof. We start with the following two observations: First, for every invariant subspace M of L2a (D), we have PMzM = (∆M )+ , where ∆M = (∆M )+ − (∆M )− is the canonical spectral decomposition of ∆M . In fact, this follows easily from Theorem 0.6 in [27]. Secondly, if an invariant subspace M of L2a (D) contains a nonzero bounded holomorphic function, then the index of M , defined as dim M zM , equals one. This follows immediately from Theorem 1.1 in [20] and the fact that, for invariant subspaces M of L2a (D), the function D → N0 , λ → dim M (z − λ)M is constant. Now suppose that M is Beurling decomposable. As we observed earlier, this implies that M ∩ H ∞ (D) is dense in M . By the preceding remarks, M has index one. Therefore, (∆M )+ = PMzM = gM ⊗ gM . Since M is Beurling decomposable, we have ran ∆M ⊂ H ∞ (D). Hence, gM ∈ ran(∆M )+ ⊂ ran ∆M ⊂ H ∞ (D). Conversely, if gM is bounded, then M has index one due to our initial observations. Hence (∆M )+ = gM ⊗ gM . Write G1 (z, w) = gM (z)gM (w) and let G2 be the positive kernel represented by (∆M )− . Then clearly GM = G1 −G2 is a disjoint decomposition of GM . Since K ·G1 ≺ K, we infer that also K ·G2 = K ·G1 −KM ≺ K. By Theorem 3.1, we conclude that M is Beurling decomposable. Since the chosen kernels G1 , G2 are disjoint, they induce a Beurling decomposition of M . This means in particular that M = ran gM .
322
Barbian
IEOT
This result allows us to give examples of Beurling decomposable subspaces of infinite codimension. To this end, it suffices to exhibit an invariant subspace M with infinite zero set Z(M ) and bounded extremal function gM . In view of Corollary 2.4 in [2], every subspace of the form MA = {f ∈ L2a (D) ; f (an ) = 0 for all n ∈ N}, where A = (an )n is a Frostman sequence (see [26] for the definition and properties of Frostman sequences), certainly satisfies these conditions.
References [1] P. Ahern and D.N. Clark, Invariant subspaces and analytic continuations in several variables, J. Math. Mech. 19 (1969), 963-969 [2] A. Aleman and S. Richter, Single point extremal functions in Bergman-type spaces, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 51 (2002), 581-605 [3] A. Aleman, S. Richter and C. Sundberg, Beurling’s theorem for the Bergman space, Acta Math. 177 (1996), 275-310 [4] D. Alpay, Some remarks on reproducing kernel Krein spaces, Rocky Mt. J. Math. 21 (1991), 1189-1205 [5] C. Ambrozie and J. Eschmeier, A commutant lifting theorem on analytic polyhedra, Warsaw: Polish Academy of Sciences, Institute of Mathematics. Banach Center Publications 67 (2005), 83-108 [6] J. Arazy and G. Zhang, Homogeneous multiplication operators on bounded symmetric domains, J. Funct. Anal. 202 (2003), 44-66 [7] N. Aronszajn, Theory of reproducing kernels, Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 68 (1950), 337404 [8] W. Arveson, Subalgebras of C ∗ -algebras. III. Multivariable operator theory, Acta Math. 181 (1998), 159-228 [9] S. Axler and P. Bourdon, Finite-codimensional invariant subspaces of Bergman spaces, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 306 (1988), 805-817 [10] F. Beatrous Jr. and J. Burbea, Positive Definiteness and its Applications to Interpolation Problems for Holomorphic Functions, Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 284 (1984), 247-270 [11] H. Bercovici, A question on invariant subspaces of Bergman spaces, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 103 (1988), 759-760 [12] F.A. Berezin, Covariant and contravariant symbols of operators, Math. USSR Izv. 6 (1972), 1117-1151 [13] F.A. Berezin, Quantization, Math. USSR Izv. 8 (1974), 1109-1163 [14] J. Burbea and P. Masani, Banach and Hilbert spaces of vector-valued functions. Their general theory and applications to holomorphy, Research Notes in Mathematics 90, Boston-London-Melbourne, Pitman Advanced Publishing Program (1984) [15] X. Chen and K. Guo, Analytic Hilbert Modules, Chapman & Hall/CRC (2003) [16] R.G. Douglas, V.I. Paulsen, C.H. Sah and K. Yan, Algebraic reduction and rigidity for Hilbert modules, Amer. J. Math. 117 (1995), 75-92
Vol. 61 (2008)
Beurling-type Representation of Invariant Subspaces
323
[17] M. Englis, Some Problems in Operator Theory on Bounded Symmetric Domains, Act. Appl. Math. 81 (2004), 51-71 [18] J. Eschmeier and M. Putinar, Spectral decompositions and analytic sheaves, London Mathematical Society Monographs, Clarendon Press, Oxford (1996) [19] J. Faraut and A. Koranyi, Function spaces and reproducing kernels on bounded symmetric domains, J. Funct. Anal. 88 (1990), 64-89 [20] J. Gleason, S. Richter and C. Sundberg, On the index of invariant subspaces in spaces of analytic functions of several complex variables, J. Reine Angew. Math. 587 (2005), 49-76 [21] D. Greene, S. Richter and C. Sundberg, The structure of inner multipiers on spaces with complete Nevanlinna Pick kernels, J. Funct. Anal. 194 (2002), 311-331 [22] K. Guo, Defect operators, defect functions and defect indices for analytic submodules, J. Funct. Anal. 213 (2000), 380-411 [23] K. Guo and R. Yang, The core function of submodules over the bidisk, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 53 (2004), 205-222 [24] K. Guo and D. Zheng, Invariant subspaces, quasi-invariant subspaces, and Hankel operators, J. Funct. Anal. 187 (2001), 308-342 [25] H. Hedenmalm, B. Korenblum and K. Zhu, Theory of Bergman spaces, Graduate Texts in Math. 199, Springer Verlag, New York (2000) [26] S.V Khrushch¨ev and S.A. Vinogradov, Inner functions and multipliers of Cauchy type integrals, Ark. Mat. 19 (1981), 23-42 [27] S. McCullough and S. Richter, Bergman-type reproducing kernels, contractive divisors, and dilations, J. Funct. Anal. 190 (2002), 447-480 [28] S. McCullough and T.T. Trent, Invariant Subspaces and Nevanlinna-Pick Kernels, J. Funct. Anal. 178 (2000), 226-249 [29] P. Quiggin, For which reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces is Pick’s theorem true?, Integral Equations Oper. Theory 16 (1993), 244-266 [30] W. Rudin, Function theory in polydiscs, Mathematics Lecture Notes Series. New York – Amsterdam, W.A. Benjamin, Inc.(1969) [31] L. Schwartz, Sous-espaces d’espaces vectoriels topologiques et noyaux associ´es. (Noyaux reproduisants.), J. Anal. Math. 13 (1964), 115-256; J. Funct. Anal. 178 (2000), 226-249 [32] R. Yang and K. Zhu, The root operator on invariant subspaces of the Bergman space, Illinois J. Math. 47 (2003), 1227-1242 Christoph Barbian Fachrichtung Mathematik Universit¨ at des Saarlandes Postfach 15 11 50 D-66041 Saarbr¨ ucken Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: September 19, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 61 (2008), 325–340 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/030325-16, published online June 20, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00020-008-1592-7
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
On Uniform Exponential Stability of Exponentially Bounded Evolution Families C. Bu¸se, A.D.R. Choudary, S.S. Dragomir and M.S. Prajea Abstract. A result of Barbashin ([1], [15]) states that an exponentially bounded evolution family {U (t, s)}t≥s≥0 defined on a Banach space and satisfying some measurability conditions is uniformly exponentially stable if and only if for some 1 ≤ p < ∞, we have that: t ||U (t, s)||p ds < ∞. sup t≥0
0
Actually the Barbashin result was formulated for non-autonomous differential equations in the framework of finite dimensional spaces. Here we replace the above ”uniform” condition be a ”strong” one. Among others we shall prove that the evolution family {U (t, s)}t≥s≥0 is uniformly exponentially stable if there exists a non-decreasing function φ : R+ → R+ with φ(r) > 0 for all r > 0 such that for each x∗ ∈ X ∗ , one has: t sup φ(||U (t, s)∗ x∗ ||)ds < ∞. t≥0
0
In particular, the family U is uniformly exponentially stable if and only if for some 0 < p < ∞ and each x∗ ∈ X ∗ , the inequality t sup ||U (t, s)∗ x∗ ||p ds < ∞ t≥0
0
is fulfilled. The latter result extends a similar one from the recent paper [4]. Related results for periodic evolution families are also obtained. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47D06, Secondary 35B35. Keywords. Operator semigroups, rearrangement function space, evolution families of bounded linear operators, uniform exponential stability.
326
C. Bu¸se, A.D.R. Choudary, S.S. Dragomir and M.S. Prajea
IEOT
1. Introduction The uniform exponential stability of an evolution family U = {U (t, s) : t ≥ s} of bounded linear operators acting on a Banach space X has been intensively investigated and several important characterizations in terms of integral conditions with respect to the first variable are known. See [9], [10], [16], [17], [8], [19] and the references therein. See also [7], [6], for recent developments. In particular, a result like this pointed out that the family U is uniformly exponentially stable if the norm of each its trajectory (t → U (t, s)x, t ≥ s, x ∈ X) belongs to a Banach function space E having some natural properties. Next we remind some characterizations of uniform exponential stability in terms of integral conditions with respect to the second variable. Recall here Barbashin’s result: Let X(·) be the unique solution of the Cauchy Problem U˙ (t) = A(t)U (t), t ≥ 0 (A(t), 0, I) U (0) = I. where A(t) and U (t) are quadratic matrixes, I is the identity matrix of the same order as A(t) and the map t → A(t) is continuous. If t ||X(t)X −1 (ξ)||dξ < ∞, sup t≥0
0
then there exist the positive constants N and ν such that ||X(t)X −1 (s)|| ≤ N e−ν(t−s) for all t ≥ s ≥ 0. See [[1], Theorem 5.1]. As was noticed in [15], this can be reformulated in terms of evolution families as follows: Let U = {U (t, s) : t ≥ s ≥ 0} be an exponentially bounded evolution family of bounded linear operators acting on a Banach space X such that for each t > 0 the map s → ||U (t, s)|| : [0, t] → R is measurable. The following two statements are equivalent: (i) The family U is uniformly exponentially stable. (ii) U satisfies the uniform Barbashin condition, that is, 1/p t p sup ||U (t, s)|| ds < ∞. t≥0
0
for some 1 ≤ p < ∞. We remark that in this context U (t, s) needs not be an invertible operator. The following result of Rolewicz’s type for evolution families defined on the entire real line can be found in [5], Theorem 4.1: Let φ : R + → R + be a nondecreasing function such that φ(t) > 0 for all t > 0 and U = {U (t, s) : t ≥ s} be an exponentially bounded evolution family of bounded linear operators on X. We assume that the function s → ||U (t, s)|| : (−∞, t] → R+ ,
Vol. 61 (2008)
On Uniform Exponential Stability
is measurable for all t ∈ R . If sup t∈R
t
−∞
327
φ(||U (t, s)||)ds < ∞,
then the family U is uniformly exponentially stable. Under similar assumptions it is shown that a q-periodic evolution family U is uniformly exponentially stable if ∞ φ(||U (0, −t)||)dt < ∞. 0
See [5], Theorem 4.2, for details. All the discussion above refer to the case where the topology of B(X) is generated by the operatorial norm. In the reversible case the solution of the Cauchy Problem (−A(t)∗ , 0, I ∗ ) is [(X(·))∗ ]−1 and the elements of the evolution family associated to (−A(t)∗ )t∈R are defined by V (t, s) = [(X(t)X −1 (s))∗ ]−1 , t ≥ s. On the other hand it is clear that the finite dimensional autonomous system x(t) ˙ = Ax(t)
t∈R
(A)
is asymptotically stable or equivalently uniformly exponentially stable if and only if the system (−A∗ ) is uniformly exponentially unstable. At least formally, such result can be also stated in the non-autonomous case, so it is naturally to ask if the integral conditions t sup t≥0
||U (t, s)∗ x∗ ||ds < ∞,
for all x∗ ∈ X ∗
0
imply the uniform exponential stability of the family U. Results of this type has been stated in [4]. This paper is an attempt to prove generalized Rolewicz conditions for stability to non-autonomous systems.
2. Notations and preliminary results Let X be a real or complex Banach space and X ∗ its dual space. By B(X) will denote the Banach algebra of all linear bounded operators acting on X. The norms on X, X ∗ and B(X) will be denoted by the symbol || · ||. Let R+ := [0, ∞) and J either of R or R+ . By ∆J will denote the set of all pairs (t, s) ∈ J × J with t ≥ s, and let ∆∗J := ∆J \ {(t, t) : t ∈ J}. By an evolution family of bounded linear operators acting on X we will mean a family U = {U (t, s) : (t, s) ∈ ∆J } ⊂ B(X) which verifies the following two conditions: 1. U (t, t) = I the identity of B(X)- for all t ∈ J; and 2. U (t, s)U (s, r) = U (t, r) for all t, s, r ∈ J with t ≥ s ≥ r.
328
C. Bu¸se, A.D.R. Choudary, S.S. Dragomir and M.S. Prajea
IEOT
We make the convention that U (t, τ ) = 0 whenever t < τ. Let q > 0. We say that an evolution family is q-periodic if U (t, s) = U (t + q, s + q) for all (t, s) ∈ ∆J . An evolution family is called strongly continuous if for each x ∈ X the maps τ → U (τ, s)x : [s, t] → X and s → U (t, s)x : [s, t] → X are continuous for any pair (t, s) ∈ ∆J . An evolution family is exponentially bounded if there exist ω ∈ R and Mω ≥ 1 such that ||U (t, s)|| ≤ Mω eω(t−s) for all (t, s) ∈ ∆J .
(2.1)
If the evolution family U is exponentially bounded then we may choose a positive ω such that (2.1) holds. An evolution family is uniformly exponentially stable if there exists a negative ω such that the relation (2.1) is fulfilled. If an evolution family U satisfies the convolution condition U (t, s) = U (t − s, 0) for all (t, s) ∈ ∆J then the one parameter evolution family T := {U (t, 0), t ≥ 0} is a semigroup of operators on X. If T is strongly continuous then it is exponentially bounded, that is there exist a real numbers ω and Mω ≥ 1 such that ||T (t)|| ≤ Mω eωt for all t ≥ 0. The converse statement is not true but the exponentially bounded semigroups possess a certain type of measurability. Precisely we shall use the following well-known proposition whose proof may be found for example in [19]. Proposition 1. If a one parameter semigroup {T (t)}t≥0 is exponentially bounded then for each x ∈ X, the map t → ||T (t)x|| is measurable. Let {T (t)}t≥0 be a strongly continuous one parameter semigroup on a Banach space X and T∗ = {T (t)∗ }t≥0 the associated one parameter dual semigroup on X ∗ . It is known that the dual semigroup T∗ may be not strongly continuous but it is exponentially bounded because ||T (t)|| = ||T (t)∗ || for all t ≥ 0. Then for each x∗ ∈ X ∗ the map t → ||T (t)∗ x∗ || is measurable. In the next we give some details about Banach function spaces over J. Let (J, L, m) be the Lebesgue measure space and let M(J) be the linear space of all measurable functions f : J → R identifying the functions which are equal almost everywhere on J. Let ρ : M(J) → [0, ∞] with the following properties: (N1) ρ(f ) = 0 if and only if f = 0. (N2) ρ(af ) = |a|ρ(f ) for any real scalar a and any function f ∈ M(J) with ρ(f ) < ∞. (N3) ρ(f + g) ≤ ρ(f ) + ρ(g) for all f, g ∈ M(J). Let E = Eρ = E(J) be the set of all f ∈ M(J) for which ||f ||E := ρ(f ) < ∞. It is clear that (E, || · ||) is a normed linear space which has nondecreasing norm, that is (N4) If f ∈ E, g ∈ E and |f | ≤ |g| almost everywhere then ||f ||E ≤ ||g||E .
Vol. 61 (2008)
On Uniform Exponential Stability
329
Such a norm is called function norm. The associate function norm ρ : M(J) → [0, ∞] of the function norm ρ is given by ρ (g) := sup{ f (t)g(t)dt : f ∈ M(J), ρ(f ) ≤ 1} J
and the associate function space is E (J) = {g ∈ M : ρ (g) < ∞}. In particular, we have the H¨ older inequality, that is: f (t)g(t)dt ≤ ||f ||E(J) ||g||E (J) . J
When (E, || · ||) is complete we say that it is a Banach function space over J. As is usually by χA (·) shall denote the characteristic function of the Lebesgue measurable set A ⊂ J and assume that each Banach function space over J contains the characteristic functions of the finite subintervals of J. Two positive functions defined on J are called equal-measurable if for each t > 0 the sets {f > t} and {g > t} have the same measure. A Banach function space E(J) is called rearrangement invariant if its function norm is rearrangement invariant, i.e. if ρ(f ) = ρ(g) for every two equal-measurable functions in E(J). For more details about the function spaces and the rearrangement invariant Banach spaces we refer to [13], [2]. We recall some well-known facts about Orlicz spaces as Banach function space over J. For more details, see [11], [12], [14], [2] and the references therein. Let Φ : [0, ∞) → [0, ∞] be a convex, non-decreasing function such that Φ(0) = Φ(0+) = 0, and Φ is not identically with 0 or with ∞ on (0, ∞). We denote by LΦ (R+ ) the set of all functions f for which there exists a positive real scalar k such ∞ that 0 Φ(k|f (t)|)dt < ∞. It is easily to see that LΦ becomes linear space with the usual operations. The Luxemburg norm of a function f ∈ LΦ (R+ ) is defined by ∞
ρΦ (f ) := inf{k > 0 :
0
Φ(k −1 |f (t)|)dt ≤ 1}.
Similar definitions may be given for Orlicz spaces over R. Every Orlicz space is a rearrangement invariant function space. Its dual space is a rearrangement invariant function space as well. The dual space E of an Orlicz space LΦ need not be an Orlicz space, but if the function Φ satisfies the ∆2 - condition, that is there exists a positive constant C such that Φ(2t) ≤ CΦ(t) for all t ≥ 0,
then the dual space (LΦ ) (J) is also an Orlicz space over J. Moreover, (LΦ (J)) can be identified by LΦ (J), where
Φ (t) := sup(ts − Φ(s)) s∈J
is the Legendre transform of Φ.
330
C. Bu¸se, A.D.R. Choudary, S.S. Dragomir and M.S. Prajea
IEOT
3. Uniform Boundedness Theorem 1. Let E(J) be a rearrangement invariant Banach function space over J and let U = {U (t, s) : (t, s) ∈ ∆J } be an evolution family such that the functions χ[s,t] (·)||U (·, s)x|| and χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ || are measurable for each pair (t, s) ∈ ∆J each x ∈ X and each x∗ ∈ X ∗ . The following two statements are equivalent: (i) The evolution family U is uniformly bounded, that is sup (t,s)∈∆J
||U (t, s)|| = MJ < ∞.
(3.1)
(ii) There exist positive constants ME and ME such that χ[s,t](·) ||U (·, s)x|| E(J) sup ≤ ME ||x||, ∀x ∈ X χ[s,t] (·) (t,s)∈∆∗ E(J)
J
and sup
(t,s)∈∆∗ J
χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ || E (J) ≤ ME ||x||, χ[s,t] (·)
∀x∗ ∈ X ∗ .
E (J)
Proof. The implication (i)⇒(ii) is an obvious consequence of the fact that ||U (t, s)|| = ||U (t, s)∗ ||. We can choose ME = ME = MJ in order to finish the proof. The our next goal is to prove the implication (ii)⇒(i). Let x ∈ X, x∗ ∈ X ∗ and (t, s) ∈ ∆∗J . Using the H¨older inequality we get: t ∗ (t − s)| x , U (t, s)x| = | x∗ , U (t, τ )U (τ, s)x|dτ s ≤ χ[s,t] (τ )||U (t, τ )∗ x∗ ||χ[s,t] (τ )||U (τ, s)x||dτ J ≤ χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ ||E (J) χ[s,t] (·)||U (·, τ )x||E(J) χ[s,t] (·)||U (·, τ )x|| χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ || E(J) E (J) = (t − s) · χ[s,t] (·) χ[s,t] (·) E(J) E (J) ≤ (t − s)M M ||x||||x∗ ||, where the identity
χ[s,t] (·) · χ[s,t] (·) = t − s, E (J) E(J)
which is fulfilled in rearrangement invariant function space, was used. We can conclude that sup ||U (t, s)|| ≤ ME ME < ∞. (t,s)∈∆J
Remark 1. The assumption that E(J) is a rearrangement invariant Banach function space over J, in the Theorem 1 above, may be replaced with the more general
Vol. 61 (2008)
On Uniform Exponential Stability
331
assumption that the dual pair (E(J), E (J)) of Banach function spaces has the property that for each (t, s) ∈ ∆J the following inequality is fulfilled: χ[s,t] (·) · χ[s,t] ≤ (t − s). (3.2) E (J) E(J) A concrete example for such a situation is described as follows. Let 1 < p < ∞ and let E1,p be the set of all (classes) of complex-valued measurable functions f defined almost everywhere on R+ for which 1/p t+1 |f (τ )|p dτ < ∞. ||f ||1,p := sup t≥0
t
It is well-known that E1,p endowed with || · ||1,p is a Banach function space whose dual space is E1,q with 1/p + 1/q = 1. Moreover after a simple calculus we obtain: 1 (t − s) p if t − s < 1 ||χ[s,t] (·)||(1,p) = 1, if t − s ≥ 1. Now it is clear that the space E1,p is not rearrangement invariant while that the condition (3.2) is fulfilled. Thus the following result is stated. If an exponentially bounded evolution family U = {U (t, s) : t ≥ s ≥ 0} satisfies the measurability conditions from Theorem 1 and if for each x ∈ X and each x∗ ∈ X ∗ the two inequalities τ +1 χ[s,t] (ρ)||U (ρ, s)x||p dρ < ∞ sup sup t≥s≥0 τ ≥0
and
τ
τ +1
sup sup
t≥s≥0 τ ≥0
τ
χ[s,t] (ρ)||U (t, ρ)∗ x∗ ||q dρ < ∞
hold true, then the family U is uniformly bounded. In the case of semigroups Theorem 1 yields the following result: Corollary 1. Let T = {T (t)}t≥0 be an exponentially bounded one parameter semigroup on a Banach space X. The following two statements are equivalent: (i) The semigroup T is uniformly bounded, that is sup ||T (t)|| = M < ∞; t≥0
(ii) There exist a rearrangement invariant space E(J) and positive constants ME and ME such that χ[0,t] (·)||T (·)x|| E(J) sup ≤ M ||x||, ∀x ∈ X (3.3) χ[0,t] (·) t>0 E(J)
and
χ[0,t] ||T (·)∗ x∗ || E (J) sup ≤ ME ||x∗ ||, χ (·) t>0 [0,t] E (J)
∀x∗ ∈ X ∗ .
(3.4)
332
C. Bu¸se, A.D.R. Choudary, S.S. Dragomir and M.S. Prajea
IEOT
Proof. The measurability of the maps τ → ||T (τ )x|| and τ → ||T (τ )∗ x∗ || follows from Proposition 1. This makes possible to apply Theorem 1. It is worth to notice that the implication (ii) ⇒ (i) in Corollary 1 fails if one of the relations (3.3) and (3.4) is dropped. Here is an example adapted from [18]. Let X = L2 (R) and g : R → R+ be the function given by g(s) = (1 + |s|)1/4 . For each t ≥ 0 and each f ∈ X let us consider the bounded linear operator T (t) defined by: g(t + s) f (t + s), s ∈ R, t ≥ 0. (T (t)f )(s) = g(s) The family T = {T (t)}t≥0 is a strongly continuous semigroup of bounded linear operators on X and ||T (t)|| = (1 + t)1/4 , so that T is unbounded. However, the semigroup T verifies the relation (3.3) for E(J) := L2 (J).
4. Uniform exponential stability In this section we use only Banach function space E(J) whose dual space E (J) verifies the condition lim χ[0,t] (·)E (J) = ∞. t→∞
In order to prove the first result of this section we need a preparation: Lemma 1. Let U = {U (t, s), (t, s) ∈ ∆J } be an exponentially bounded evolution family of bounded linear operators on a Banach space X. If there exists a function g : R+ → R+ such that inf g(t) < 1 and ||U (t, s)|| ≤ g(t − s), for all t ≥ s ∈ J,
t>0
then the family U is uniformly exponentially stable. For a proof of the above lemma we refer to [[3], Lemma 4]. Theorem 2. Let U = {U (t, s) : (t, s) ∈ ∆J } be an exponentially bounded evolution family on a Banach space X and E(J) be a rearrangement invariant Banach function space over J, such that lim χ[0,r] (·)E (J) = ∞. r→∞
The following statements are equivalent: (i) The family U is uniformly exponentially stable. (ii) There exists a positive constant M (J) such that for each (s, t) ∈ ∆J and each x∗ ∈ X ∗ the map χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ || defines an element of the space E (J) and (4.1) sup χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ ||E (J) ≤ M (J)||x∗ ||. (t,s)∈∆J
Vol. 61 (2008)
On Uniform Exponential Stability
333
Proof. (i)⇒(ii). Let N > 0 and ν > 0 such that ||U (t, s)∗ x∗ || ≤ N e−ν(t−s) ||x∗ || ∀(t, s) ∈ ∆J ,
∀x∗ ∈ X ∗ .
The dual space E (J) is rearrangement invariant function space as well. Then it contains the set L1 (J) ∩ L∞ (J). In particular, the function χ[0,∞) (·)e−ν· belongs to E (J). A simple calculus points out that the functions χ[s,t] (·)e−ν(t−·) and χ[s,t] (t − ·)χ[0,∞) (·)e−ν· are equal-measurable in E (J). Then for each (s, t) ∈ ∆J we have successively: ∗ −ν(t−·) χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ || ≤ N ||x || (·)e χ [s,t] E (J) E (J) ∗ = N ||x || χ[s,t] (t − ·)χ[0,∞) (·)e−ν· E (J) ≤ N ||x∗ || χ[0,∞) (·)e−ν· E (J) . The proof of the implication (ii) ⇒ (i) will be divided in two steps. Step 1. Let s ≥ 0 and x∗ ∈ X ∗ be fixed, t ≥ s + 1 and let ω > 0 and Mω ≥ 1 such that (2.1) is fulfilled. For each τ ∈ [s, t] one has: e−ω χ[s,s+1] (τ )| x∗ , U (t, s)x| ≤
e−ω(τ −s) | U (t, τ )∗ x∗ , U (τ, s)x|
≤
e−ω(τ −s) ||U (τ, s)||||x||||U (t, τ )∗ x∗ ||
≤
Mω ||x||||U (t, τ )∗ x∗ ||.
As consequence, for each u ∈ J, it follows: e−ω χ[s,s+1] (u)| x∗ , U (t, s)x| ≤ Mω χ[s,t] (u)||U (t, u)∗ x∗ ||. Passing to the norms into E (J) and using the assumptions, we get: e−ω |χ[0,1] (·)|E (J) | x∗ , U (t, s)x| = e−ω χ[s,s+1] (·)E (J) | x∗ , U (t, s)x| ≤ Mω χ[s,t] (·)||U (t, ·)∗ x∗ ||E (J) ≤ Mω M (J)||x∗ ||. We can conclude that the evolution family is bounded. Step 2. Let MJ := sup ||U (t, s)|| < ∞, u ∈ J and (s, t) ∈ ∆J . Successively (t,s)∈∆J
one has: χ[s,t] (u)| x∗ , U (t, s)x|
χ[s,t] (u)||U (t, u)∗ x∗ ||||U (t, s)x|| MJ ||x||χ[s,t] (u)||U (t, u)∗ x∗ ||.
≤ ≤
Passing again to the norms obtain: χ[s,t] (·) | x∗ , U (t, s)x| E (J)
≤
MJ ||x|| χ[s,t] (·)U (t, ·)∗ x∗ ||E (J)
≤
MJ M (J)||x||||x∗ ||.
Finally we obtain the estimation: | x∗ U (t, s)x| ≤
MJ (M (J)||x||||x∗ || + 1) . 1 + χ[s,t] (·)E (J)
334
C. Bu¸se, A.D.R. Choudary, S.S. Dragomir and M.S. Prajea
IEOT
Now we can use the Lemma 1 above, to finish the proof.
Sufficiency of the Theorem 2 above, can be stated also for Banach spaces E(J) with the property that for each s ∈ J the map h → χ[s,s+h] (·)E (J) : R+ → R+ is nondecreasing. The following example describes this situation. Let a > 0, 1 < p < ∞ and 1 < q < ∞ such that 1/p + 1/q = 1. With E1,p,a shall denote the set of all (classes) of complex-valued measurable functions defined almost everywhere on R+ such that 1/p t+1 −pas p e |f (s)| ds < ∞. ||f ||1,p,a := sup t≥0
t
Then (E1,p,a ) = E1,q,−a . With these notations the next result reads as follows: Proposition 2. Any exponentially bounded evolution family U = {U (t, s)}t≥s≥0 which verifies the inequality τ +1 sup sup eqaρ χ[s,t] (ρ)||U (t, ρ)∗ x∗ ||q dρ < ∞ for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ t≥s≥0 τ ≥0
τ
is uniformly exponentially stable. Corollary 2. Let T = {T (t)}t≥0 be an exponentially bounded semigroup of linear operators on a Banach space X and let E(R+ ) be a rearrangement invariant Banach function space over R+ whose dual space has the property that lim χ[0,t] (·)E (R ) = ∞. t→∞
+
The following two statements are equivalent: 1. The semigroup T is uniformly exponentially stable. 2. There exists a positive constant M such that
||T (·)∗ x∗ || E (R+ ) ≤ M ||x∗ ||,
for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ .
Proof. The measurability of the map ||T (·)∗ x∗ || follows by the Proposition 1 above. For each positive s and every t ≥ s, one has: χ[s,t] (·)||T (t − ·)∗ x∗ || ≤ χ[0,t] (·)||T (t − ·)∗ x∗ ||E (R+ ) E (R+ ) = χ[0,t] (t − ·)||T (·)∗ x∗ || ≤
||T (·)∗ x∗ || E (R+ ) .
E (R+ )
Therefore the map χ[s,t] (·)||T (t − ·)∗ x∗ || defines an element of the space E (R+ ). Now we can apply Theorem 2 above, to prove that the semigroup T is uniformly exponentially stable.
Vol. 61 (2008)
On Uniform Exponential Stability
335
The next result is an extension to dual evolution families of a well-known Barbashin-Rolewicz’s theorem. The last part of