Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 1–17 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010001-17, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1513-1
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces H´el`ene Bommier-Hato and El Hassan Youssfi Abstract. We consider Hankel operators Hf¯ with antiholomorphic symbol f¯ on the generalized Fock space A 2 (µm ), where µm is the measure with weight m e−|z| , m > 0 with respect to the Lebesgue measure in Cn . We prove that . We show Hf¯ is bounded if and only if f is a polynomial of degree at most m 2 that Hf¯ is compact if and only if f is a polynomial of degree strictly smaller . We also establish that Hf¯ is in the Schatten class Sp if and only if that m 2 p > 2n and f is a polynomial of degree strictly smaller than m (p−2n) . 2p Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35, 32A36, 32A37. Keywords. Hankel operator, Fock space, Bergman kernel.
1. Introduction and statement of the main results We consider the Fock type space A2 (µm ) consisting of those holomorphic functions m which are square integrable with respect to the measure dµm (z) = e−|z| dV (z), where dV (z) is the Lebesgue measure on Cn and m > 0 is a positive parameter. When m = 2 the space A2 (µ2 ) is the Fock space, called also the SegalBargmann space. Let I be the identity operator and P2 is the orthogonal projection from L2 (µ2 ) onto A2 (µ2 ). Let T(Cn ) be the subspace of L2 (µ2 ) consisting of those functions f that satisfy f (·+a) ∈ L2 (µ2 ) for all a ∈ Cn . We recall that if f ∈ T(Cn ), then the Hankel operator Hf with symbol f is defined by Hf (ϕ) = (I − P2 )(f ϕ), for all ϕ in the dense subspace of A2 (µ2 ) spanned by {K2 (·, a), a ∈ Cn } where K2 (z, a) := ez,a , z, a ∈ Cn , is the Bergman kernel. In this case, the study of compactness of Hankel operators with bounded symbols was considered in the works of Berger and Coburn [3] and Stroethoff [14]. In the more general case f ∈ T(Cn ), the simultaneous membership of Hf and Hf¯ to the Schatten classes was characterized by Xia and Zheng [15] and by Bauer [1] in the Hilbert-Schmidt setting. A necessary and sufficient condition for simultaneous boundedness of Hf and Hf¯ was given recently by Bauer [2]. The tools used in these works use heavily
2
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
the translation action of the group Cn and related properties to the Bergman kernel. We also mention that in the one dimensional case n = 1 the study of Hankel operators in the setting m > 0 was considered by Schneider [Sc] when the symbol is a monomial. His method is direct and relies on an approximation process. In this paper we consider the general case m > 0. We begin by clarifying the appropriate definition of densely defined Hankel operators. Indeed, if f ∈ L2 (µm ) is a function of polynomial growth, then the Hankel operator Hf with symbol f is defined by Hf (ϕ) = (I − Pm )(f ϕ), where Pm is the orthogonal projection from L2 (µm ) onto A2 (µm ) given by Km (z, w)g(w)dµm (w), for g ∈ L2 (µm ) Pm (g)(z) := Cn
where Km is the Bergman kernel given in Section 5 below. We shall show in Section 5 that the righthand side of the latter equality is well-defined for functions g of the form g = f ϕ for all f ∈ L2 (µm ) and ϕ in the space P of holomorphic polynomials. This allows us to extend the definition of Pm on such functions and, using this, we see that Hf is defined on holomorphic polynomials. In particular, it is densely defined. We first point out that the techniques used the case m = 2 to study Hankel operators do not apply to the case m = 2. Our goal herein is to develop new methods which are adequate to the setting m > 0 in the case of anti-analytic symbols f. Our first main result is the following Theorem A. Let f be an entire function in A2 (µm ), where m is a positive real number. 1) Then the Hankel operator Hf¯ is bounded on the Fock space A2 (µm ) if and only if f is a polynomial of degree at most m 2. 2) The Hankel operator Hf¯ is compact on the Fock space A2 (µm ) if and only if f is a polynomial of degree smaller than m 2. We observe that when m is odd, then all bounded Hankel operators with anti-analytic symbols are also compact. This is not the case for m even. In the particular case m = 2, Theorem A was established in a recent work by [2] using a technique which does not work at all when m = 2. We recall that an operator T is in the Schatten class Sp (A2 (µm ), L2 (µm )) p ∗ if (T T ) 2 is in the trace class of A2 (µm ). Our second result characterizes such a class of operators. Theorem B. Let f be an entire function in A2 (µm ), where m is a positive real number. Then the Hankel operator Hf is in the Schatten class Sp (A2 (µm ), L2 (µm )) if and only if p > 2n and f is a polynomial of degree smaller than
m(p−2n) . 2p
We discovered recently that a weaker version of our results was established by Knirsch and Schneider [8] in the one dimensional particular case.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
3
We finally mention in passing that Hankel operators with antiholomorphic symbols are intimately related to the ∂-canonical solution operator (see [5], [6] and [7]).
2. Preparatory lemmas We recall some facts about Hankel operators with respect to certain rotation invariant measures, see [10]. Let Ω be a rotation invariant open set in Cn and let µ be a rotation invariant measure on Ω. We suppose that µ has moments of every order; that is, mk =
Ω
|z|2k dµ(z) < +∞,
for all k ∈ N0 .
We consider the Hilbert space L2 (Ω, µ) of square integrable complex-valued functions on Ω with respect to the measure µ and A2 (Ω, µ) its subspace consisting of holomorphic elements. We assume that for each set compact K ⊂ Ω there exists C = C(K) > 0 such that supz∈K |f (z)| ≤ C f L2 (Ω,µ) 2
for all f ∈ A (Ω, µ). Thus A2 (Ω, µ) is a closed space of L2 (Ω, µ). The corresponding orthogonal projection Pµ will be called the Bergman projection. We also assume that the subspace consisting of all holomorphic polynomials is dense in A2 (Ω, µ). Therefore, if f ∈ A2 (Ω, µ) has polynomial growth, then the Hankel operator Hf given by Hf (ϕ) = (I − Pµ )(f ϕ) is well defined for all holomorphic polynomials ϕ. In particular, Hf is densely defined. We first fix some notations. Let Nn0 denote the set of all n-tuples with components in the set N0 of all nonnegative integers. If α = (α1 , · · · , αn ) ∈ Nn0 , we let |α| := α1 + · · · + αn denote the length of α. If β = (β1 , · · · , βn ) ∈ Nn0 satisfies αj ≥ βj for all j = 1, · · · , n, then we write α ≥ β. Otherwise, set α ≥ β. The space of polynomials P is endowed with the Fischer inner product [12] , F , defined on the monomials by α! if α = β α β z , z F = 0 if α = β. Finally, if A and B are two quantities, we use the symbol A ≈ B whenever A ≤ C1 B and B ≤ C2 A, where C1 and C2 are positive constants independent of the varying parameters. In this section we shall express the operators Hzk and Hzk Hzl on holomorphic homogeneous polynomials. Lemma 2.1. Suppose that β, k ∈ Nn0 and d ∈ N0 . Then k
(Hzk f ) (ξ) = ξ f (ξ) −
md Γ(n + d − |k|) ∂ |k| f (ξ) md−|k| Γ(n + d) ∂ξ k
4
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
for all holomorphic polynomials f of degree d. In particular, if f = ξ α , then m|α| Γ(n + |α| − |k|) α! k ξ ξα − ξ α−k , if α ≥ k m Γ(n + |α|) (α − k)! |α|−|k| (Hz k f )(ξ) = k α ξ ξ , otherwise. Proof. It suffices to prove the lemma for f (ξ) = ξ α , where α ∈ Nn0 . Let g be a homogeneous polynomial in P. If g is a monomial of the form g(ξ) = ξ β , where β ∈ Nn0 , then using the properties of Pµ , we see that Pµ (z k f ), g L2 (Ω,µ) = f, z k g L2 (Ω,µ) and hence Pµ (z k f ), g L2 (Ω,µ) = 0 as long as α = k + β. Now let α = k + β. By Lemma 2.1 in [10], we have the following identities (n − 1)! m|α| α! z α z α dµ(z) = (2.1) and z α , z α F = α! , (n + |α| − 1)! Ω from which we obtain Pµ (z k f ), g L2 (Ω,µ) =
(n − 1)!m|α| f, z k g F . (n + |α| − 1)!
Since the multiplication operator and the corresponding differentiation operator are adjoint to each other with respect to the Fischer inner product, this implies that Pµ (z k f ), g L2 (Ω,µ) =
m|β|+|k| ∂ |k| (n − 1 + |β|)! k f, g L2 (Ω,µ) m|β| (n − 1 + |β| + |k|)! ∂z
for all holomorphic homogeneous polynomials g of degree |β|. Therefore, if f is a holomorphic homogeneous polynomial of degree d, we have Pµ (z k f ) =
md (n − 1 + d − |k|)! ∂ |k| f. md−|k| (n − 1 + d)! ∂z k
This completes the proof of the lemma.
Lemma 2.2. The domain Dom(Hz∗k ) of Hz∗k contains all polynomials in w and w. ¯ Proof. It suffices to show that, if α and β are fixed in Nn0 , then the linear functional g → Hzk (g), z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) is bounded on A2 (Ω, µ). To do so, choose an integer d ≥ |α|+|β|+2|k| and consider the subspace Nd of A2 (Ω, µ) consisting of polynomials with degree smaller than or equal to d. We denote by πd the orthogonal projection from A2 (Ω, µ) onto Nd . If g ∈ P, then (I − πd )g is a sum of holomorphic homogeneous polynomials in P with degree at least d + 1. In view of Lemma 2.1, we can write Hzk ◦ (I − πd )g = z k f + h
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
5
where f is a sum of holomorphic homogeneous polynomials of degree at least d + 1 and h is a sum of holomorphic homogeneous polynomials of degree at least d + 1 − |k|. Therefore, Hzk ◦ (I − πd )g, z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) = z k f, z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) + h, z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) = f z β , z α+k L2 (Ω,µ) + z β h, z α L2 (Ω,µ) . Since d+1+|β| ≥ 1+|α|+2|β|+2|k| > |α|+|k|, it follows that f z β , z α+k L2 (Ω,µ) = 0. Also, due to the fact that the degree of z β f is greater than |α| we see that z β f, z α L2 (Ω,µ) = 0. Thus Hzk ◦ (I − πd )g, z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) = 0 for all g ∈ P and consequently Hzk (g), z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) = Hzk ◦ πd (g), z α z β L2 (Ω,µ) . The lemma now follows from the fact that Hzk ◦ πd is of finite rank and hence bounded. We observe by Lemmas 2.1 and 2.2 that P is contained in the domain of the operator Hv∗ Hu for all holomorphic polynomials u and v. Lemma 2.3. Suppose that u, v and f are holomorphic polynomials. Then Hv∗ Hu f = Pµ (vuf ) − vPµ (uf ). Proof. A little computing shows that for all g ∈ A2 (Ω, µ) Hu f, Hv g L2 (Ω,µ) = uf − Pµ (uf ), vg − Pµ (vg) L2 (Ω,µ) = vuf, g L2 (Ω,µ) − Pµ (uf ), vg L2 (Ω,µ) + (Pµ − I)(uf ), Pµ (vg) L2 (Ω,µ) = vuf, g L2 (Ω,µ) − Pµ (uf ), vg L2 (Ω,µ) where the latter equality holds since Pµ (vg) ∈ A2 (Ω, µ) and (Pµ − I)(uf ) is or thogonal to A2 (Ω, µ). This completes the proof. Lemma 2.4. Assume that k and l are elements of Nn0 . If f is a holomorphic homogeneous polynomial of degree d, then Pµ (z l z k f ) =
md+|l| Γ(d + n − |k| + |l|) ∂ |k| f. md−|k|+|l| Γ(d + n + |l|) ∂z k
Proof. It is sufficient to establish the lemma for monomials f (z) = z α . If β is an arbitrary element of Nn0 , then, due to the properties of the Fischer product and (2.1), we have Pµ (z l z k f ), z β L2 (Ω,µ) = z l+α , z k+β L2 (Ω,µ) (n − 1)! m|α|+|l| ∂ |k| l+α β (z ), z F (n + |α| + |l| − 1)! ∂z k m|α|+|l| Γ(n + |α| + |l| − |k|) ∂ |k| l k (z f ), z β L2 (Ω,µ) = m|α|+|l|−|k| Γ(n + |α| + |l|) ∂z =
6
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
This completes the proof.
In what follows we shall compute Hz∗l Hzk f for a holomorphic homogeneous polynomial f . Lemma 2.5. Suppose that k and l are in Nn0 . If f is a holomorphic homogeneous polynomial of degree d, then Hz∗l Hzk f =
md+|l| Γ(n + d + |l| − |k|) ∂ |k| l md Γ(d + n − |k|) l ∂ |k| z (z f )− f md+|l|−|k| Γ(n + d + |l|) ∂z k md−|k| Γ(d + n) ∂z k
In particular, Hz∗l Hzk f is a holomorphic homogeneous polynomial of degree d + |l| − |k|. Proof. Follows from Lemmas 2.1 and 2.4.
An immediate consequence of Lemma 2.5 gives the following Proposition 2.6. For each α in Nn0 , the monomial z α is an eigenvector for the operator Hz∗k Hzk and the corresponding eigenvalue λα is given by λα =
m|α| Γ(|α| + n − |k|) m|α|+|k| Γ(n + |α|) (α + k)! α! − m|α| Γ(n + |α| + |k|) α! m|α|−|k| Γ(|α| + n) (α − k)!
if α ≥ k and λα =
m|α|+|k| Γ(n + |α|) (α + k)! , m|α| Γ(n + |α| + |k|) α!
otherwise.
3. The Fock space In this section, we consider the Fock space A2 (µm ), for m > 0. In this case, the m moments of the measure dµm (z) := e−|z| dν(z) are given by 1 2s + 2n m 2s ). (3.1) ms = Cn |z| e−|z| dν(z) = Γ( m m If k is a multi-index we set T = Hz∗k Hz k . Then T is defined on the dense subspace P of A2 (µm ). For each multi-index α, the eigenvalue λα of T corresponding to the eigenvector ξ α is given by Proposition 2.6. In what follows we shall study the asymptotic of these eigenvalues. We distinguish the two cases m = 2 and m = 2. Lemma 3.1. Suppose m = 2. Then for each j = 1, · · · , n, the operator Hzj is bounded but not compact on A2 (µm ). If |k| ≥ 2, Hzk is unbounded on A2 (µm ). Proof. In this case, µ2 is the Gaussian measure on Cn . Its moments reduce to ms = Γ(s + n). Moreover, if α ∈ Nn0 , (α + k)! α! − if α ≥ k, α! (α − k)! λα = (α + k)! if α ≥ k. α!
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
7
We first observe that if |k| = 1, then the eigenvalues of T are all equal to 1. Therefore, T is bounded but not compact on A2 (µm ). This proves the first part of the lemma. Suppose now that |k| ≥ 2. Choose j0 in [1, n] so that kj0 = maxj kj . If d is a nonnegative integer, set α(k, d) = (k1 , · · · , kj0 −1 , kj0 + d, kj0 +1 , · · · , kn ). Then n
(2kj )! λα(k,d) = [(d + kj0 + 1) · · · (d + 2kj0 )] − (d + 1) · · · (d + kj0 ) (kj )! j=j0
Therefore, lim λα(k,d) = +∞, showing that T is unbounded on A2 (µm ). This d→+∞
implies that Hzk is also unbounded.
Henceforth, we assume that m = 2, m > 0. From Proposition 2.6 and (3.1) we see that if α ∈ Nn0 , then the eigenvalue λα can be written in the form (α + k)! α! − B|α| if α ≥ k A|α| α! (α − k)! λα = (3.2) A|α| (α + k)! if α ≥ k α! where, for a nonnegative integer d, 2d + 2n 2|k| + ) Γ(d + n) Γ( m m Ad := ), 2d + 2n Γ(d + n + |k| ) Γ( m (3.3) 2d + 2n ) Γ( Γ(d + n − |k|) m Bd := . 2d + 2n 2|k| Γ(d + n) − ) Γ( m m The asymptotic behaviour of the eigenvalues {λα } when |α| = d → +∞ is given by the following Lemma 3.2. The sequences (Ad ) and (Bd ) given by (3.3) have the asymptotic behavior 2
2|k| |k| −1 1 2 |k|2 (m − 2) m m (d + n) +O 1− Ad = m 2m(d + n) (d + n)2 2
2|k| 2 |k| −1 1 2 (m − 2) |k| m m (d + n) Bd = +O 1+ , m 2m(d + n) (d + n)2 as d → +∞. Proof. Follows from the property of the Gamma function [11]
1 (y − z)(y + z − 1) Γ(x + y) y−z =x + O( 2 ) as x → +∞, 1+ Γ(x + z) 2x x
(3.4)
8
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
where y and z are real numbers. Lemma 3.3. The eigenvalues λα have the form
2 |k| m |k| αn + 1 2 α1 + 1 ,··· , λα = (d + n)2 m −1 fn + ε(α) , m d+n d+n 1 where ε(α) = O d and tk |k|2 k t + kj2 m tj j=1 n
fn (t1 , · · · , tn ) := −(m − 2) when α ≥ k and d = |α| → +∞. Proof. We recall by (3.2) that if α ≥ k, then λα = A|α|
(α + k)! α! − B|α| , α! (α − k)!
where (Ad ) and (Bd ) are given by (3.3). On the other hand, by (3.4) we see that (αj + kj )! = (1 + αj )kj + kj (kj − 1)(1 + αj )kj −1 + qj (1 + αj ) αj ! αj ! = (1 + αj )kj − kj (kj + 1)(1 + αj )kj −1 + rj (1 + αj ) (αj − kj )! where qj and rj are one variable polynomials of degree at most kj − 2. This implies that n n
(α + k)! kj = (1 + αj ) + kj (kj − 1)(1 + αj )kj −1 (1 + αl )kl + q(α) α! j=1 j=1 l=j
n
n
α! = (1 + αj )kj − (α − k)! j=1 j=1
kj (kj + 1)(1 + αj )kj −1 (1 + αl )kl + r(α) l=j
where q and r are polynomials of degree at most |k|−2. These equalities, combined with Lemma 3.2, give the lemma. Lemma 3.4. The eigenvalues λα have the estimate |k| λα = O (d + n)2 m −kj0 , as long as αj0 < kj0 and d = |α| → +∞. Proof. Let j0 = 1, . . . , n and suppose that kj0 ≥ 1. We recall by (3.2) that if αj0 < kj0 , then (α + k)! , λα = A|α| α!
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
9
where (Ad ) is as before. Set α = (α1 , · · · , αj0 −1 , 0, αj0 +1 , · · · , αn ) and k = (k1 , · · · , kj0 −1 0, kj0 +1 , · · · , kn ). Arguing as in the proof of Lemma 3.3 we have (α + k)! α! ≤ (2kj0 )!
(α + k )! α!
= (2kj0 )!
n
(1 + αj )kj +
j=1,j=j0
n
kj (kj − 1)(1 + αj )kj −1
j=1,j=j0
(1 + αs )ks
s=j,l
+ q(α ), where q is a polynomial of degree at most |k | − 2. These estimates, combined with Lemma 3.2, give the lemma.
4. Spectral properties of the operator Hz k Theorem 4.1. The operator Hzk ∗ Hzk is bounded if and only if 2 compact if and only if 2
|k| − 1 < 0. m
|k| − 1 ≤ 0 and m
Proof. Let Σn be the simplex consisting of those t = (t1 , · · · , tn ) ∈ Rn such tj ≥ 0 and t1 + · · · + tn = 1. By Lemmas 3.3 and 3.4 we see that |k| α1 + 1 αn + 1 2 m −1 ,··· , sup fn sup |λα | ≈ (d + n) d+n d+n |α|=d
|α|=d
2 |k| m −1
≈ (d + n)
sup |fn (t)|
t∈Σn
as d = |α| → +∞. Now the lemma follows since the operator Hzk ∗ Hzk is bounded if and only if the sequence sup|α|=d |λα | is bounded and Hzk ∗ Hzk is compact if and only if the sequence sup|α|=d |λα | tends to 0 as d = |α| → +∞. Theorem 4.2. Let k ∈ Nn0 and m be a positive real number. 1) The Hankel operator Hzk is bounded on the Fock space A2 (µm ) if and only if m ≥ 2|k|. 2) The Hankel operator Hzk is compact on the Fock space A2 (µm ) if and only if m > 2|k|. Proof. We use that the operator Hz k is bounded if and only if T = Hzk ∗ Hzk is bounded and Hzk is compact if and only if T = Hzk ∗ Hz k is compact. |k| − 1 < 0 and let p > 0. We shall investigate the Next, assume that 2 m membership of the T to a Schatten class Sp . Recall that T is in Sp if and operator only if the series λpα is convergent.
10
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
Let d be an integer. We shall estimate the sum sd = |α|=d λpα, when d → +∞. The calculations above lead to study the cases α ≥ k and its opposite case separately. Let Bd := { α ∈ Nn0 , |α| = d}. We partition Bd = B d ∪ Bd , where B d = { α ∈ B : α ≥ k} and Bd = Bd \ Bd . Thus sd can be written in the form sd = sd + sd , where sd = α∈B d λpα and sd = α∈B λpα . d We need to compare the cardinalities Bd , Bd , and Bd of these sets. Lemma 4.3. We have the estimates Bd ≈ B d ≈ d → +∞.
dn−1 and B d ≈ dn−2 as (n − 1)!
Proof. Let Pn,d the space of n variables holomorphic polynomials of degree d. We (d + n − 1)! 1 have Bd = dim Pn,d = n−1+d . Therefore, Bd ∼ dn−1 = d (n − 1)!d! (n − 1)! as d → +∞. On the other hand, for j = 1, · · · , n, let Bd,j = {α ∈ Bd , αj < kj }. Since Bd = ∪1≤j≤n Bd,j , we see that Bd ≤ nj=1 Bd,j . If kj ≥ 1, then k −1
j Bd,j = ∪l=0 { α = (α1 , · · · , αj−1 , l, αj+1 , · · · , αn ), |α| = d } kj −1 = ∪l=0 {α = (α1 , · · · , αj−1 , l, αj+1 , · · · , αn ), αi = d − l}.
i=j
Therefore, Bd,j =
kj −1 l=0
dn−2 . (n − 2)! as d → +∞. The lemma now follows from the
dim Pn−1,d−l , and when d → +∞, Bd,j ∼ kj
This shows that, when Bd ≈ dn−2 observation Bd = Bd + Bd .
Lemma 4.4. Suppose that n ≥ 2 and g is a continuous function on Rn−1 . Consider n−1 the open set Ω := {(t1 , · · · , tn−1 ) ∈ Rn−1 + , j=1 tj < 1 }. For a multi-index n−1 γ = (γ1 , · · · , γn−1 ) in N0 , set
γ1 + 1 γn−1 + 1 cγ,d := ,··· , d d n−1
γj γj + 1 , . : Jd := γ ∈ Nn−1 ⊂ Ω 0 d d j=1 1 Then lim n−1 g(cγ,d ) = g(t)dt. d→+∞ d Ω γ∈Jd
#n−1 γj γj + 1 , . It is clear that Ωd ⊂ Ω. j=1 d d Next, we show that limd→+∞ χΩd = χΩ . If s is a real number, let [s] denote the largest integer smaller than or equal to s. If t = (t1 , · · · , tn−1 ) ∈ Ω and
Proof. For d ∈ N0 , let Ωd = ∪γ∈Jd
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
1 ≤ j ≤ n − 1, then
[dtj ] [dtj ] 1 ≤ tj < + . Therefore, d d d n−1 j=1
11
n−1 n−1 [dtj ] n − 1 [dtj ] ≤ + . tj < d d d j=1 j=1
n−1
Since all d > d0 we have j=1 tj < 1, there is an integer d0 such that for n−1 [dtj ] #n−1 [dtj ] [dtj ] + 1 n−1 + < 1. Thus, t ∈ j=1 , and hence t ∈ Ωd j=1 d d d d for all d > d0 . Thus lim χΩd = χΩ . Therefore, d→+∞
1 dn−1
g(cγ,d ) −
γ∈Jd
g(t)dt = Ω
1 n−1 g(cγ,d) − d
γ∈Jd
+ Ωd
g(t)dt −
# n−1 j=1
γj γj + 1 g(t)dt , d d
g(t)dt. Ω
Since g is a bounded continuous function on the compact set Ω, we have, by Lebesgue’s theorem, limd→+∞ Ωd g(t)dt = Ω g(t)dt. On the other hand, by continuity of g on the compact set Ω, we see that 1 n−1 g(cγ,d ) − # γj γj + 1 g(t)dt n−1 d , γ∈Jd j=1 d d [g(c = γ,d ) − g(t)] dt # n−1 γj γj + 1 , γ∈Jd j=1 d d also tends to 0 as d → +∞. This shows that 1 lim g(cγ,d ) = g(t)dt. d→+∞ dn−1 Ω
γ∈Jd
The above result enables us to estimate sd when d = |α| → +∞. Lemma 4.5. If p ≥ 1, then |k|
sd ≈ dn−1 dp(2 m −1) .
Proof. Recall that sd = α∈B λpα . By Lemma 3.3, we know that the sequence d {λα }α∈Bd has the following expansion when d → +∞
λα =
2 m
2 |k| m
2
(d + n)
|k| m −1
α1 + 1 αn + 1 ,··· , fn + ε(α) , d+n d+n
12
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
where ε(α) = O
1 d
IEOT
and tk |k|2 k t + kj2 m tj j=1 n
fn (t1 , · · · , tn ) := −(m − 2)
Using the properties of the function x → xp , we see that there exists a constant M > 0, such that p p fn α1 + 1 , · · · , αn + 1 + ε(α) − fn α1 + 1 , · · · , αn + 1 d+n d+n d+n d+n M . d Therefore, ≤
λα ≈
2 m
2 |k| m
|k| α1 + 1 αn + 1 ,··· , (d + n)2 m −1 fn , d+n d+n
as d = |α| → +∞. Applying Lemmas 4.3 we see that
2p |k| p m α1 + 1 αn + 1 2 p(2 |k| −1 ) fn , · · · , d m sd ≈ m d+n d+n
≈
2 m
2p |k| m
α∈Bd
|k|
dn−1 dp(2 m −1)
Ω
|fn (t)|p dt
so that the lemma follows from Lemma 4.4.
We recall that an operator T is in the Schatten class Sp (A2 (µm ), L2 (µm )) p if (T T ) 2 is in the trace class of A2 (µm ). Our second result characterizes such a class of operators. ∗
Theorem 4.6. Let k ∈ Nn0 and m be a positive real number. Then the Hankel operator Hzk is in the Schatten class Sp (A2 (µm ), L2 (µm )) if and only if p > 2n and m(p − 2n) > 2p|k|. Proof. We use that the operator Hzk is in Sp (A2 (µm ), L2 (µm )) if and only if T = Hzk ∗ Hzk is S p2 (A2 (µm )). Therefore, the theorem follows from Lemma 4.5
5. Boundedness of Hankel operators on the Fock space We first study the behavior of the Bergman kernel Km (z, w) corresponding to A2 (µm ). Let E m2 , 2n be the generalized Mittag-Leffler’s function. This is the entire m function defined by E
2 2n m, m
(λ) :=
+∞
λd +
Γ( 2d m d=0
2n m)
, λ ∈ C.
We shall express the Bergman kernel in terms of this function. Namely,
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
13
Lemma 5.1. The Bergman kernel Km (z, w) of A2 (µm ) is given by m (n−1) E 2 2n (z, w ) , Km (z, w) = (n − 1)! m , m (n−1)
where E 2 , 2n is the derivatives of E m2 , 2n with order n − 1. m m
m
Proof. The monomials z α , α ∈ Nn0 , form an orthogonal basis of A2 (µm ). Since
2|α| + 2n α! (n − 1)! α 2 z L2 (µm ) = Γ m (|α| + n − 1)! m it follows that the Bergman kernel is zα wα Km (z, w) = z α L2 (µm ) wα L2 (µm ) n α∈N0
+∞
(d + n − 1)! m d (z, w ) 2d 2n (n − 1)! d!Γ( + ) m m d=0 m (n−1) E 2 2n (z, w ) . = (n − 1)! m , m =
This completes the proof of the lemma. The Bergman projection Pm is given by Pm (f )(z) := Cn Km (z, w)f (w)dµm (w), for f ∈ L2 (µm ).
(5.1)
This definition can be extended to functions of the form f g where f ∈ L2 (µm ) and g ∈ P. Indeed, Lemma 5.2. If g ∈ P and z ∈ Cn , then gKm (z, ·) is in L2 (µm ). Proof. It follows from Theorem 2, p. 6 in [9] that the generalized Mittag-Leffler’s function is E m2 , 2n is an entire function of finite order m 2 and type 1. Therefore m (n−1)
E 2 , 2n is also an entire function of finite order m 2 and type 1 and hence for any m m
> 0, there is a positive constant C that m+ (n−1) 2 , λ ∈ C. E 2 , 2n (λ) ≤ Ce|λ| m
m
This shows that for all z, w ∈ Cn , |Km (z, w)| ≤ Ce|z,w|
m+ 2
≤ Ce(|z||w|)
m+ 2
,
showing that for all g ∈ P and z fixed in C , the function w → g(w)Km (z, w) is in L2 (µm ) as long as 0 < < m. n
It follows from Lemma 5.2 that if f ∈ L2 (µm ), then the Hankel operator Hf¯ with symbol f¯ is well-defined on P by Hf (g)(z) := (f (z) − f (w)) Km (z, w)g(w)dµm (w), g ∈ P. Cn
14
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
We point out that the measurable function z → Hf¯(g)(z) is not necessarly an element of L2 (µm ). Denote by M the subspace of those functions f ∈ A2 (µm ) such that Hf¯(g) ∈ 2 L (µm ) for all g ∈ P, and the densely defined operator Hf¯ is bounded on A2 (µm ). We equip M with seminorm f := Hf¯ + |f (0)|. The subspace of M consisting of functions f such that Hf¯ is a compact operator will be denoted by M∞ . Then is not hard to see that M∞ is a closed subspace of M. If p ≥ 1, we denote by Mp the subspace of those functions f ∈ M such that the Hankel operator Hf¯ is the Schatten class Sp (A2 (µm ), L2 (µm )). We equip Mp with seminorm f := Hf¯Sp + |f (0)|. Lemma 5.3. The spaces M and Mp are Banach spaces. Proof. We prove the lemma for M, the proof for Mp is similar. Let (fn )n∈N0 be a Cauchy sequence in M. Without loss of generality we may assume that fn (0) = 0 for all n. The sequence (Hf n )n∈N0 is a Cauchy sequence of bounded operators on A2 (µm ). Therefore, there is an operator T in A2 (µm ) such that (Hf )n∈N0 n
converges to T in the norm operator. Let f := T (1) be the conjugate of the image T (1) of the constant function 1 under T . Since Hf n (1) = f n , it follows that fn − f L2 (µm ) = f¯n − T (1)L2(µm ) = Hf n (1) − T (1)L2(µm ) ≤ Hf n − T showing that lim fn − f L2 (µm ) = 0.
n→∞
(5.2)
Thus f ∈ A2 (µm ). We shall show that the Hankel operator Hf with symbol f is bounded. It is well defined on P. We shall prove that Hf is equal to T on P. Let g be a holomorphic polynomial. We first observe by (5.1), (5.2) and Lemma 5.2 that for all z ∈ Cn we have P (f − fn )g (z) ≤ fn − f L2 (µ ) gKm (z, ·)L2 (µ ) m m showing that limn→+∞ P (f − fn )g (z) = 0. Since again by (5.2) we have that limn→+∞ f − fn g(z) = 0, it follows that lim Hfn − Hf (g)(z) = 0. n→+∞
This proves that T g = Hf (g) and hence T = Hf . Therefore M is a Banach space. The proof of that Mp is a Banach space is similar.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
15
For θ = (θ1 , · · · , θn ) ∈ Rn , let Rθ be the unitary linear transformation in Cn defined by Rθ (z) = (eiθ1 z1 , · · · , eiθn zn ), for all z = (z1 , · · · , zn ) ∈ Cn . Lemma 5.4. Let θ ∈ Rn . Then the operator Rθ f := f ◦ Rθ is a unitary isometry from L2 (µm ) onto itself and from A2 (µm ) onto itself. Moreover the following assertions hold. 1) If f ∈ M, then Rθ f ∈ M and Rθ f M = f M . 2) If f ∈ M∞ , then Rθ f ∈ M∞ . 3) If f ∈ Mp , then Rθ f ∈ Mp and Rθ f Mp = f Mp . Proof. It is clear that the operator Rθ is a unitary isometry from L2 (µm ) onto itself and from A2 (µm ) onto itself. Let f be in M and θ ∈ Rn . Then Rθ f is clearly in A2 (µm ). Moveover, if g is an element of P, then by a change of variable we see that & ' HRθ f (g)(z) = Km (Rθ z, w)g(R−θ w) Rθ f (z) − f (w) dµm (w) n C & ' = Km (Rθ z, w)(R−θ g)(w) f (Rθ z) − f (w) dµm (w) Cn
= Hf (R−θ g)(Rθ z) = (Rθ Hf R−θ )(g)(z). ∗ Since the adjoint of R−θ is R−θ = Rθ , it follows that
HRθ f = Hf , showing that f ◦ Rθ M = f M . This proves part (1) of the lemma. The proof of parts (2) and (3) of the lemma are similar. Lemma 5.5. Let f ∈ A2 (µm ). k
1) If f ∈ M, then for any multi-index k that satisfies ∂∂zfk (0) = 0, the monomial z k is in M. k 2) If f ∈ M∞ , then for any multi-index k that satisfies ∂∂zkf (0) = 0, the monomial z k is in M∞ . k 3) If p ≥ 1 and f ∈ Mp , then for any multi-index k that satisfies ∂∂zfk (0) = 0, the monomial z k is in Mp . Proof. To prove (1), suppose that f ∈ M. By the Cauchy formula we have 2π 2π f (Rθ z) ∂kf 1 k (0)z = ··· dθ, k n ik θ 1 ∂z (2π) 0 e 1 · · · eikn θn 0 where dθ := dθ1 · · · dθn for θ = (θ1 , · · · , θn ). By Lemmas 5.3 and 5.4 we see k k that ∂∂zkf (0)z k ∈ M. Therefore, z k ∈ M as long as ∂∂zfk (0) = 0. The proof of the remaining statements of the lemma is similar.
16
Bommier-Hato and Youssfi
IEOT
Proof of Theorems A and B. We first prove Theorem A. Let f ∈ A2 (µm ). Suppose k that Hf is bounded and let k be a multi-index that satisfies ∂∂zkf (0) = 0. By Lemma 5.5 we see that the monomial z k is in M. Now Theorem 4.2 implies that m ≥ 2|k|. Hence f is a polynomial of degree at most m 2. If Hf is compact then a similar argument shows that f is a polynomial of degree strictly smaller than m 2 . The converse follows from Theorem 4.2. The proof of Theorem B is similar to that of Theorem A.
References [1] W. Bauer, Mean oscillation and Hankel operators on the Segal-Bargmann space Integral Equations and Operator Theory 52 (2005), 1–15. [2] W. Bauer, Hilbert-Schmidt Hankel operators on the Segal-Bargmann space Proc. Amer. Math. Soc 132 (2005), 2989–2996. [3] C. A. Berger and L. Coburn Toeplitz operators on the Segal-Bargmann space Trans. Amer. math. Soc. 301 (1987), 813–829 [4] C. A. Berger, L. Coburn and K. Zhu Toeplitz operators and function theory in ndimensions, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1256, Springer, 1987. [5] F. Haslinger, The canonical solution operator to ∂ restricted to Bergman spaces and spaces of entire functions Annales de la Facult´e des Sci. Toulouse Math. 11 (2002), 57–70. [6] F. Haslinger, Schr¨ odinger operators with magnetic fields and the canonical solution operator to ∂ J. Math. Kyoto Univ.46 (2006), 249–257. [7] F. Haslinger and B. Helfer, Compactness of the solution operator to ∂ in weighted L2 -spaces ESRI-preprint ( 2006). [8] W. Knirsch and G. Schneider, Continuity and Schatten-von Neumann p-class membership of Hankel operators with antiholomorphic symbols on (generalized) Fock spaces J. Math. Anal. Appl. 320 (2006), 403–414. [9] B. Y. Levin, Lectures on entire functions Translations of Math. Monographs 150, American Math. Soc., Providence, Rhode Island, 1996. [10] S. Lovera and E. H. Youssfi, Spectral properties of the ∂-canonical solution operator Journal of Functional Analysis 208 (2004), 360–376. [11] W. Magnus, F. Oberhettinger and R. P. Soni, Formulas and Theorems for the Special Functions of Mathemetical Physics, Springer Verlag, 1966. [12] D. J. Newman and H. S Shapiro, Fischer spaces of entire functions Proc. Symp. Pure Math. II (1968), 360–369. [13] G. Schneider, Hankel operators with antiholomorphic symbols on the Fock space Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 132 (2004), 2399–2409. [14] K. Stroethoff, Hankel operators in the Fock space Michigan Math. J. 39 (1992), 3–16. [15] Jingbo Xi and Dechao Zheng, Standard deviation and Schatten class Hankel operators on the Segal-Bargmann space Indiana University Math. J. 53 (2004), 1381–1399. [16] K. H. Zhu, Schatten class Hankel operators on the Bergman space of the unit ball Amer. J. Math. 113 (1991), 147–167.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Hankel Operators on Weighted Fock Spaces
17
[17] K. H. Zhu, Hilbert-Schmidt Hankel operators on the Bergman space Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 109 (1990), 721–730 H´el`ene Bommier-Hato and El Hassan Youssfi LATP, U.M.R. C.N.R.S. 6632 CMI, Universit´e de Provence 39, Rue F. Joliot-Curie F-13453 Marseille Cedex 13 France e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] Submitted: July 10, 2006 Revised: January 31, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 19–34 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010019-16, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1511-3
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators V. A. Khatskevich, M. I. Ostrovskii and V. S. Shulman Abstract. Properties of sets of solutions to inequalities of the form X ∗ AX + B ∗ X + X ∗ B + C ≤ 0 are studied, where A, B, C are bounded Hilbert space operators, A and C are self-adjoint. Properties under consideration: closeness and interior points in standard operator topologies, convexity, non-emptiness. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A56; Secondary 47B50. Keywords. Hilbert space, bounded linear operator, weak operator topology, operator inequalities.
1. Introduction We shall use the terminology from [2], [5], [6], where the reader can also find basic facts about the strong operator topology (SOT) and the weak operator topology (WOT), see [2, §8] and [5, Chapter VI]. Let H1 and H2 be separable Hilbert spaces, B ∈ L(H1 , H2 ), A ∈ L(H2 ), A = A∗ , C ∈ L(H1 ), C = C ∗ (where L(H1 , H2 ), L(H1 ), and L(H2 ) are the corresponding spaces of bounded linear operators). There is a simple, popular and useful theory of linear operator equations of the form AX = B or XC = B which describes the properties of the sets of solutions X ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) and, in particular, the conditions for solvability (existence of such X). On the other hand, many problems from different areas (extensions of operators [16], indefinite metric spaces [12], linear fractional relations [10], operator The second named author was supported by St. John’s University Summer 2006 Support of Research Program. The authors thank the referee for helping them to make this paper more readable and error-free.
20
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
functional equations [3], control theory and systems theory [4], [8], [13], [14], [15], and others) lead to quadratic equations and inequalities of the forms: X ∗ AX = C,
(1)
X ∗ AX ≤ C,
(2)
X ∗ AX + B ∗ X + X ∗ B + C = 0,
(3)
and, more generally,
X ∗ AX + B ∗ X + X ∗ B + C ≤ 0.
(4) ∗
∗
The equation (3) is very close to the equation XAX + B X + X B + C = 0 with self-adjoint A and C, which is usually called a continuous algebraic Riccati equation. It is clear that a self-adjoint solution of (3) is also a solution of the corresponding continuous algebraic Riccati equation. Since self-adjoint solutions are the most important in systems theory, our study can be of interest for infinitedimensional systems theory. In control theory and systems theory there are many results stating that under certain assumptions the continuous algebraic Riccati equation has a non-negative solution (see, e.g. [15, Theorem 2.2.1], [4, Theorem 6.2.7]). Many other results on continuous algebraic Riccati equations can be found in [4], [8], and [14]. Another object studied in systems theory is an inequality of the form XAX + B ∗ X + X ∗ B + C ≤ 0 (A ≥ 0), called a Riccati inequality, see [7], [14, Section 9.1], [17]. The mentioned sources contain results on conditions of solvability of Riccati inequality and comparison of the sets of self-adjoint solutions of the continuous algebraic Riccati equation and the corresponding Riccati inequality. Scalar versions of the inequality (4) for an infinite dimensional Hilbert space were studied in [19]. This survey of the literature shows that information about properties of sets M (A, B, C) can be of interest from different points of view. Our interest in this topic was motivated by the fact that such sets appear in the study of linear fractional relations (LFR), and we consider the present paper as a continuation of [9], in which we started systematic study of properties of LFR. Namely, in terms of M (A, B, C) one can express the domains of LFR and the images of balls under LFR. The applications of the results of the present paper to LFR will be published in a separate paper. Relatively few results are known on topological and geometric properties of sets of solutions of the inequalities (2) and (4). We will denote by E(A, C), N (A, C) and M (A, B, C) the sets of all solutions for (1), (2) and (4), respectively. It is known, that M (A, B, C) = L(H1 , H2 ) if and only if A, C are non-positive and B = (−A)1/2 T (−C)1/2 for some operator T ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) with T ≤ 1. If the operators A, C are invertible, this condition is equivalent to C − B ∗ A−1 B ≤ 0. It is the so-called generalized Sylvester criterion (see [1, p. 321], [11, pp. 732– 733], and [18, §1]). If A is invertible and positive, then the sets E(A, C) and N (A, C) are non-void only for C ≥ 0 and in this case E(A, C) = A−1/2 UC 1/2 , N (A, C) = A−1/2 RC 1/2 where U is the set of all isometric operators from CH1
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
21
into H2 , and R is the unit ball of L(CH1 , H2 ). Hence N (A, C) is convex and WOTcompact. If A is non-negative but not invertible, then N (A, C) is still convex (see, for example, [10]), and hence WOT-closed, because it is always SOT-closed. The analysis of M (A, B, C), and even of N (A, C) for an arbitrary self-adjoint operator A, is much more complicated. The purpose of this paper is to find conditions under which the sets N (A, C) and M (A, B, C) are non-empty, closed, or convex, and to characterize their interior points. In Section 3 we consider conditions under which M (A, B, C) and N (A, C) are closed and sequentially closed in the weak operator topology. They turned out to be different. Removing trivial exceptions one can say that M (A, B, C) is sequentially closed in WOT if and only if A is essentially non-negative (Theorem 1). For N (A, C) to be closed in WOT the condition rank(A− ) < ∞ is necessary and sufficient (Theorem 2), where A− is the negative part of A, see the definition below. The condition is also sufficient for WOT-closeness of M (A, B, C), but we do not know if it is necessary in this case. In Section 4 we show (Theorem 3 and Corollary 4) that N (A, C) is convex if and only if A ≥ 0. For M (A, B, C) the same is proved under the condition that the spectrum of A does not intersect some interval (−ε, 0), ε > 0. In Section 5 of the paper we obtain some conditions under which the sets M (A, B, C) and N (A, C) are non-empty. We give only a partial answer for sets M (A, B, C) and a complete answer for N (A, C) (see Theorem 4). Note on separability assumption. We consider only separable Hilbert spaces. In the general case some of our results (for example, Theorem 4 and Lemma 2) must be stated differently, while some others (e.g., Lemma 4) remain valid without modifications in formulation and proof.
2. Notation Throughout the paper inner products will be denoted by ·, ·. We consider G(X) = X ∗ AX + B ∗ X + X ∗ B + C
(5)
as a function of X ∈ L(H1 , H2 ). So M (A, B, C) = {X : G(X) ≤ 0} (and N (A, C) = M (A, 0, −C)). Let E C be the spectral measure of C. Set H1+ = E C (0, ∞)H1 , H10 = E ({0})H1 , H1− = E C (−∞, 0)H1 , then C
H1 = H1+ ⊕ H10 ⊕ H1− .
(6)
22
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
Let H2 = H2+ ⊕ H20 ⊕ H2−
(7)
be the similar decomposition of H2 , corresponding to A. Let C+ , C0 and C− be the restrictions of C to the subspaces H1+ , H10 , and H1− ; A+ , A0 , and A− be the restrictions of A to the subspaces H2+ , H20 , and H2− . If H1− = 0 (H1+ = 0), we say that C is non-negative (non-positive). We say that C is essentially non-negative if C− is compact (this is equivalent to the condition that C is a sum of a non-negative operator and a compact operator). Similar terminology is used for A. Let P+ , P0 , and P− be the orthogonal projections on H2 corresponding to the decomposition (7). If X is an operator with range in H2 , then by X+ , X0 , X− , and X∼ we denote the operators P+ X, P0 X, P− X, and (P+ + P0 )X, respectively. Some of the results of this paper are proved for sets of the form N (A, C) rather than for M (A, B, C). The following observation shows that in the case, when B can be factored through A, such results have immediate consequences for sets of the form M (A, B, C). We leave exact statements of such consequences as exercises for interested readers. Observation. If B = AD for some D ∈ L(H1 , H2 ), then G(X) = X ∗ AX + D∗ AX + X ∗ AD + C = (X + D)∗ A(X + D) + (C − D∗ AD), and hence M (A, B, C) = N (A, D∗ AD − C) − D. In particular, if A is invertible, then M (A, B, C) = N (A, B ∗ A−1 B − C) − A−1 B.
3. Topological Properties It should be mentioned that the set M (A, B, C) (hence N (A, C) and E(A, C) = N (A, C) ∩ N (−A, −C) as well) is always closed in the strong operator topology (SOT). In fact, let {Xα }α ⊂ M (A, B, C) be a strongly convergent net, Xα → X. Then, for all x ∈ H1 , 0 ≥ G(Xα )x, x = AXα x, Xα x+Xα x, Bx+Bx, Xα x+ Cx, x → G(X)x, x, hence X ∈ M (A, B, C).
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
23
3.1. Weak operator topology, sequential properties Theorem 1. The set M = M (A, B, C) is sequentially closed in WOT if and only if one of the following conditions is satisfied. (a) A is essentially non-negative; (b) A, C are non-positive and B = (−A)1/2 T (−C)1/2 for some operator T ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) with T ≤ 1. In the case (b) the set M (A, B, C) coincides with L(H1 , H2 ). The theorem immediately follows from the generalized Sylvester criterion (see the introduction) and the following two lemmas. Lemma 1. If A− is compact, then M (A, B, C) is sequentially closed in WOT. Proof. As is well-known (and easy to check), the map X → X ∗ A+ Xx, x (x ∈ H1 ) is lower semi-continuous in the WOT, in the sense that lim infXα∗ A+ Xα x, x ≥ X0∗ A+ X0 x, x as Xα → X0 in the WOT. The map X → (B ∗ X + X ∗ B)x+ Cx, x is clearly WOT-continuous. Hence it suffices to prove that if K is compact, then the map X → X ∗ KX is sequentially continuous in WOT. Let {Xn }∞ n=1 be a sequence converging to X in the WOT, then, by compactness of K, the sequence ∗ {KXn }∞ n=1 is convergent to KX in the SOT. Hence Xn (KXn − KX) → 0 in ∗ ∗ the SOT (because {Xn } is bounded) and (Xn − X) KX → 0 in the WOT, so Xn∗ KXn − X ∗ KX → 0 in the WOT. Lemma 2. If A− is non-compact and M (A, B, C) = L(H1 , H2 ), then M (A, B, C) is not sequentially closed in WOT. Proof. Let X ∈ / M (A, B, C). It suffices to find a sequence {Xn } ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) such that Xn WOT-converges to X and Xn ∈ M (A, B, C). Since A− is non-compact, then there exists a subspace N ⊂ H2− and ε > 0 such that N is infinite dimensional and Ax, x ≤ −ε||x||2 for each x ∈ N . Let Un : H1 → N be a sequence of isometries which WOT-converges to 0 (we can claim the existence of such isometries because H1 is assumed to be separable). We let Xn = X + kUn , the real number k ≥ 1 will be specified later. It is clear that Xn WOT-converges to X. It remains to show that we can select k in such a way that Xn ∈ M (A, B, C) for each n ∈ N. We have G(Xn ) = k 2 Un∗ AUn + Yn , where Yn ≤ ck for some c > 0 which does not depend on k or n. Therefore G(Xn )x, x ≤ −k 2 εx2 + ck||x||2 . Hence, if k is chosen large enough, Xn ∈ M (A, B, C) for each n ∈ N. Remark. Our proof of Theorem 1 implies that non-weakly-sequentially-closed sets of the form M (A, B, C) are weakly sequentially dense in L(H1 , H2 ).
24
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
3.2. Weak operator topology Theorem 2. (a) If A− has finite rank, then M = M (A, B, C) is WOT-closed; (b) N (A, C) is WOT-closed if and only if either it is empty, or it coincides with L(H1 , H2 ), or A− has finite rank. Combining Theorem 2 with the observation from Section 2 we get Corollary 1. If B = AD for some D ∈ L(H1 , H2 ), then M (A, B, C) is WOTclosed if and only if either it is empty, or it coincides with L(H1 , H2 ), or A− has finite rank. Proof of (a). If we analyze our proof of Lemma 1, we see that it is enough to prove that if K has finite rank, then the map X → X ∗ KX is WOT-continuous. Decomposing K into a sum of rank-one operators we see that X ∗ KXx, y is the sum of functions of the form X → Xx, f · e, Xy. Since such functions are WOT-continuous, we are done. To prove part (b) we need several auxiliary results, which can be of independent interest. Lemma 3. If A is a positive operator of infinite rank and C is a self-adjoint operator of finite rank, then the WOT-closure of the set L of all operators X satisfying X ∗ AX ≥ C
(8)
contains 0. Proof. Indeed, if 0 is not in the WOT-closure of L, then there is a WOT-neighborhood U = {X : |Xxi , yi | ≤ ε, i = 1, . . . , n} of 0, which does not intersect L. Let Y be the linear span of {yi }ni=1 . Since E A (0, ∞)(H2 ) = A(H2 ), we have dim E A [λ, ∞)(H2 ) = ∞ λ>0
(we use the notation introduced in Section 2). Hence there exists λ > 0 such that the dimension of the subspace E A [λ, ∞)(H2 ) exceeds (n + rankC). It follows that dim(E A [λ, ∞)(H2 ) ∩ Y ⊥ ) ≥ rankC. Since C is a self-adjoint operator of finite rank, it is representable in the k k k form Cx = i=1 βi x, zi zi , where {βi }i=1 are real numbers and {zi }i=1 is an orthonormal basis in Z = CH1 . We introduce X ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) as an operator satisfying X|Z ⊥ = 0 and Xzi = ui , where {ui }ki=1 is an orthonormal set in E A [λ, ∞)(H2 ) ∩ Y ⊥ . Then, for each z ∈ Z we have ||Xz|| = ||z|| and Xz ∈ E A [λ, ∞)(H2 ), therefore X ∗ AXz, z = AXz, Xz ≥ λ||Xz||2 = λ||z||2 .
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
25
Now let x ∈ H1 , then x = z + v, where z ∈ Z and v ∈ Z ⊥ . We have Cx, x =
k i=1
βi |x, zi |2 ≤ max |βi |||z||2 i
and X ∗ AXx, x = AXx, Xx = AXz, Xz ≥ λ||z||2 ≥ where
1 Cx, x, t2
1 λ = t2 maxi |βi | (of course, we may assume that maxi |βi | > 0). Thus t2 X ∗ AX ≥ C. On the other hand, the definition of X implies that X(H1 ) ⊂ Y ⊥ , therefore tX ∈ U . This is a contradiction.
Lemma 4. Let P be a finite dimensional projection on a Hilbert space H. Let S ∈ L(H) be a non-negative operator with an infinite dimensional range. Then, for each ε > 0, there exists an operator E ∈ L(H), such that ||P EP || ≤ ε and E ∗ SE ≥ S. Proof. First we suppose that S is injective. For λ > 0 let Cλ be the spectral measure of the interval [λ, ∞) (see [2, 9.1 and 10.2] or [6, Section X.1]). Since S is injective and non-negative, then the limit limλ→0 Cλ in the strong operator topology is the identity operator (see [6, Corollary X.2.3 and Lemma X.3.3]). Therefore there exists λ = λ(ε) > 0 such that the orthogonal projection Cλ ∈ L(H) satisfies SCλ = Cλ S, √ ||(I − Cλ )P || ≤ ε, √ ||(I − Cλ )P ∗ || ≤ ε, (9) dim(im(Cλ )) ≥ 2 dim(im(P )). Also, the spectral measure Cλ satisfies Sx, x ≥ λ||x||2 ∀x ∈ im(Cλ ).
(10)
The condition (9) implies that there exists an orthogonal (unitary) operator U on im(Cλ ) such that im(U Cλ P ∗ ) is orthogonal to im(Cλ P ). Let E ∈ L(H) be defined by Ex = αU Cλ x + (I − Cλ )x, where α > 0 is chosen in such a way that E ∗ SE ≥ S. To see that such α exists, observe that E ∗ SEx, x = SEx, Ex = αSU Cλ x + S(I − Cλ )x, αU Cλ x + (I − Cλ )x = since S commutes with Cλ α2 SU Cλ x, U Cλ x + S(I − Cλ )x, (I − Cλ )x. On the other hand, Sx, x = SCλ , Cλ x + S(I − Cλ )x, (I − Cλ )x.
26
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
Hence the only condition which has to be satisfied by α is α2 SU Cλ x, U Cλ x ≥ SCλ x, Cλ x. This condition is satisfied by sufficiently large α because of (10). To show that ||P EP || ≤ ε observe that ||P EP || = sup{P EP x, y : x, y ∈ H, ||x|| = ||y|| = 1}. Let ||x|| = ||y|| = 1. We have P EP x, y = EP x, P ∗ y = Cλ EP x, Cλ P ∗ y + (I − Cλ )EP x, (I − Cλ )P ∗ y = αU Cλ P x, Cλ P ∗ y + (I − Cλ )P x, (I − Cλ )P ∗ y = 0 + (I − Cλ )P x, (I − Cλ )P ∗ y ≤ ||(I − Cλ )P || · ||(I − Cλ )P ∗ || ≤ ε. Now suppose that S has a kernel L. Decompose H into an orthogonal direct sum H = H1 ⊕L and let Q be the orthogonal projection onto H1 . Denote by S1 the restriction of S to H1 . Let Y = lin(QP H ∪ QP ∗ H) and let P1 be the orthogonal projection in H1 onto Y . Applying the first part of the proof to the operator S1 and the projection P1 we find an operator E1 ∈ L(H1 ) with ||P1 E1 P1 || ≤ ε/(||P ||2 ) and E1∗ S1 E1 ≥ S1 . Let E = E1 ⊕ 0, so E = QEQ. Then E ∗ SE ≥ S. It remains to show that ||P EP || ≤ ε. We have ||P EP || = =
sup
P EP x, y =
||x||=||y||=1
sup
sup
QEQP x, P ∗ y =
||x||=||y||=1
≤
sup
E1 x, y ≤ ||P ||2
||x||,||y||≤||P || x,y∈Y
EP x, P ∗ y
||x||=||y||=1
sup
EQP x, QP ∗ y
||x||=||y||=1
sup
E1 P1 x, P1 y
||x||=||y||=1 x,y∈H1
= ||P ||2 ||P1 E1 P1 || ≤ ε, where we used the fact that Q and P1 are self-adjoint.
Lemma 5. If S is a positive operator of infinite rank on a Hilbert space H, then there is a net Eλ of operators such that Eλ → 0 in WOT and Eλ∗ SEλ ≥ S for all λ. Proof. We take as an index set the set of all pairs λ = (P, ε) where P is a finite dimensional orthogonal projection on H, ε > 0. Set (P1 , ε1 ) ≺ (P2 , ε2 ) if P1 ≤ P2 and ε1 > ε2 . By Lemma 4, for each λ there exists Eλ ∈ L(H), such that ||P Eλ P || ≤ ε and Eλ∗ SEλ ≥ S. Each λ defines a WOT-neighborhood of 0 by Uλ = {X ∈ L(H) : P XP < ε}, and it is clear that we obtain in this way a basis of WOT-neighborhoods of 0. It remains to note that for each λ0 , all operators Eλ with λ0 < λ belong to Uλ0 .
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
27
Proposition 1. If A is a positive operator of infinite rank and C is a self-adjoint operator, then the WOT-closure of the set L of all operators X ∈ L(H1 , H2 ), for which X ∗ AX ≥ C, (11) either is empty or contains 0. Proof. Let C = C+ + C− be the decomposition of C described in Section 2, and let R+ be the orthogonal projection onto H1+ . Let us consider also the condition Y ∗ AY ≥ C+ ,
(12)
If X satisfies (11) then Y = XR+ satisfies (12). On the other hand any solution of (12) satisfies also (11). Therefore it is enough to consider the case C ≥ 0. Due to Lemma 3 we may suppose that C has infinite rank. Let X satisfy (11). Then the operator S = X ∗ AX has infinite rank. Applying Lemma 5 to it, we find a WOT-convergent to 0 net {Eλ }λ such that Eλ∗ SEλ ≥ S. It follows that XEλ satisfies (11). Since the net {Eλ }λ is WOT-convergent to 0, we are done. Proof of Theorem 2(b). We have to establish that if N = N (A, C) is WOT-closed, then either rankA− < ∞, or N = ∅ or N = L(H1 , H2 ). (The last possibility corresponds to the case A+ = 0, C ≥ 0). We use the decomposition (7) from Section 2 and the notation introduced there. The inequality X ∗ AX ≤ C can be rewritten as (X+ )∗ A+ X+ + (X− )∗ A− X− ≤ C.
(13)
By Lemma 2, it is enough to show that the assumptions • A− is a compact operator of infinite rank; • N = ∅; imply that N = L(H1 , H2 ). It is clear that X ∈ N implies X− ∈ N . Since N is WOT-closed, then the set L = {X− : X ∈ N } is also WOT-closed. Observe that each Z ∈ L satisfies Z ∗ (−A− )Z ≥ (−C). By Proposition 1, the set L contains 0. Hence 0 ≥ −C or C ≥ 0. If A+ = 0, then, clearly, N = L(H1 , H2 ). So in what follows we assume that A+ = 0. Let us show that X+ ∈ N for X ∈ N , that is, ∗ A+ X+ − C ≤ 0. X+
Since N is WOT-closed, it is easy to check that the set of all operators Z ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) satisfying ∗ A+ X+ − C ≤ Z ∗ (−A− )Z X+
is also WOT-closed. It is also non-empty (it contains X− ). By Proposition 1 it contains 0. Hence X+ ∈ N .
28
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
Let {en } be a (finite or infinite) basis in H1 . Let {fn }∞ n=0 be a basis in H2− consisting of eigenvectors for −A− . We denote the corresponding eigenvalues by an (so an > 0). Choose y ∈ H2+ with A+ y, y = λ > C, and set Y = e1 ⊗y (this means that Y x = e1 , xy for all x ∈ H1 ). Then Y ∗ A+ Y − C = λe1 ⊗e1 − C is not ≤ 0, therefore Y ∈ / N. Let t be a number with t2 > λ/a1 . Define Z ∈ L(H1 , H2− ) by Ze1 = tf1 , Zei = fi for 2 ≤ i ≤ dim(H1 ). Then Z ∗ (A− )Ze1 = −t2 a1 e1 , Z ∗ (A− )Zei = −ai ei for i ≥ 2. Therefore Z ∗ A− Z + Y ∗ A+ Y ≤ 0. Since C ≤ 0, then Z + Y ∈ N . By the observation above Y ∈ N . We get a contradiction. Problem 1. Whether the set M (A, B, C) is WOT-closed if and only if it is either empty, or coincides with L(H1 , H2 ), or A− has finite rank? Another natural problem about the topological properties of M (A, B, C) is the characterization of its inner points. Since a point of M (A, B, C) can be “shifted” by changing the coefficients in (4), it suffices to find conditions under which 0 is an interior point. For r > 0, denote by K(r) the cone of all x⊕y ∈ H1 ⊕H2 such that x ≤ ry. Proposition 2. The point 0 is interior for M (A, B, C) if and only if the matrix A B B∗ C is non-positive on some cone K(r). Proof. Denote the matrix
A B B∗ C by T . It is easy to check that G(X)y, y = T (Xy⊕y), Xy⊕y. If X ≤ r, then Xy⊕y ∈ K(r). Hence if T is non-positive on K(r), then G(X)y, y ≤ 0 for each y, so M (A, B, C) contains the ball of radius r centered at 0. Conversely, if M (A, B, C) contains the ball of radius r, then T is non-positive on K(r) because each vector in K(r) can be written in the form Xy⊕y for some y and X with X ≤ r. We write C < 0 if Cy, y < 0 for all y = 0. We write C 0 if there is ε > 0 with C + εIH1 ≤ 0. Corollary 2. Suppose that M (A, B, C) = L(H1 , H2 ). (i) If C 0, then 0 is an interior point of M (A, B, C).
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
29
(ii) If 0 is an interior point of M (A, B, C), then C < 0. Proof. Since C = G(0), part (i) follows from the continuity of G in norm topology. Suppose that 0 is an interior point for M (A, B, C). By Proposition 2 there is r > 0 such that (14) t2 Ax, x + 2tRex, By + Cy, y ≤ 0 for all x, y with x = y = 1 and |t| ≤ r. Letting t = 0, we get C ≤ 0. Hence, if there is a unit vector v such that Cv, v = 0, then Cv = 0. Setting y = v in (14), we obtain that Bv = 0 and A ≤ 0. Let now y = λv + µz, where z is an arbitrary unit vector, and µ, λ are such that y = 1. We get from (14): t2 Ax, x + 2tµRex, Bz + µ2 Cz, z ≤ 0.
(15)
This holds for all t ∈ (−r, r) and all sufficiently small µ. Setting s = t/µ we see that s2 Ax, x + 2sRex, Bz + Cz, z ≤ 0 (16) for all s ∈ (−∞, ∞). Hence |x, Bz|2 ≤ −Ax, x−Cz, z.
(17)
Since x, z are arbitrary unit vectors, this is a contradiction because (17), as is easy to see, is equivalent to M (A, B, C) = L(H1 , H2 ). Corollary 3. Suppose that the space H1 is finite dimensional and M = L(H1 , H2 ). A point X0 is in the interior of M (A, B, C) if and only if G(X0 ) < 0. Proof. Substituting X − X0 for X, we see that it suffices to consider the case X0 = 0. Since for an operator in a finite dimensional space the conditions C < 0 and C 0 are equivalent, the result follows from the previous corollary.
4. Convexity We begin with an auxiliary result on operator quadratic forms with non-negative leading coefficients. Lemma 6. Let G(X) be given by (5). Suppose that G(X) is non-constant, A ≥ 0, and that there is an operator X0 with G(X0 ) ≤ 0. Then there is an operator X1 such that G(X1 ) is not ≤ 0 but G(X1 ) ≤ K for some rank one operator K. Proof. Changing X by X0 + Y we may assume that X0 = 0, and hence C ≤ 0. Suppose that B = 0. Choose a positive rank-one orthogonal projection P ∈ L(H2 ) with P B = 0 and set X1 = tP B for t > 0. Since P AP = λP for some λ ≥ 0, we have G(X1 ) = C + (λt2 + 2t)B ∗ P B. For sufficiently large t > 0, the operator G(X1 ) will not be ≤ 0. On the other hand, since C ≤ 0, then G(X1 ) ≤ (λt2 + 2t)B ∗ P B, which is of rank one. If B = 0 then A = 0 (otherwise G(X) is constant). Let P be a positive one-dimensional orthogonal projection, such that P AP = 0 (so λ > 0) and set
30
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
X1 = tP . Then G(X1 ) = C + λt2 P and again F (X1 ) is not ≤ 0 for sufficiently large t, but is ≤ λt2 P . Now we consider the conditions under which the set M = M (A, B, C) is convex. A well-known sufficient condition is A ≥ 0 (see, e.g. [10, Lemma 1.1]. It appears that under mild spectral assumptions this condition is also necessary. Theorem 3. Let M = M (A, B, C) be non-empty, convex, and not equal to the space L(H1 , H2 ). If there exists ε > 0, such that σ(A) does not contain points of an interval (−ε, 0), then A ≥ 0. Proof. Suppose the contrary, then A− is invertible. We use the notation introduced in Section 2. Let A∼ be the restriction of A to H2+ ⊕ H20 . We have X ∈ M if and only if ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ X− A− X− + X∼ A∼ X∼ + B∼ X∼ + B− X− + X∼ B∼ + X− B− + C ≤ 0.
Let Y = (−A− )1/2 X− and D = (−A− )−1/2 B− . We get: X ∈ M if and only if
∗ ∗ ∗ −Y ∗ Y + D∗ Y + Y ∗ D + X∼ A∼ X∼ + B∼ X∼ + X∼ B∼ + C ≤ 0. Let Z = Y − D. The inequality (18) can be rewritten in the form
(18)
∗ ∗ ∗ −Z ∗ Z + X∼ A∼ X∼ + B∼ X∼ + X∼ B∼ + (C + D∗ D) ≤ 0.
Let
∗ ∗ ∗ F (X∼ ) = X∼ A∼ X∼ + B∼ X∼ + X∼ B∼ + (C + D∗ D). Then M (A, B, C) is equal to
{(−A− )−1/2 (Z + D) + X∼ : X∼ ∈ L(H1 , (H2+ ⊕ H20 )) and Z ∗ Z ≥ F (X∼ )}. If F (X∼ ) is constant (that is, if A∼ = 0 and B∼ = 0), then M = {(−A− )−1/2 (Z+D)+X∼ : X∼ ∈ L(H1 , (H2+ ⊕H20 )) and Z ∗ Z ≥ C+D∗ D}. It is easy to see that this set is convex if and only if C + D∗ D ≤ 0, and in such a case M = L(H1 , H2 ). Consider the case when F (X∼ ) is not constant. Since M is non-empty, then 0 0 there exists a pair Z 0 , X∼ , such that (−A− )−1/2 (Z 0 + D) + X∼ ∈ M . It is clear 0 that this implies (−A− )−1/2 (−Z 0 + D) + X∼ ∈ M . Hence, by convexity of M , we 0 ∈ M . Hence have (−A− )−1/2 D + X∼ 0 ) ≤ 0. F (X∼
(19)
Applying Lemma 6 to the function F (X∼ ) we get that there exists an operator X∼ such that F (X∼ ) ≤ K, where K is an operator of rank one, but F (X∼ ) is not ≤ 0. It is clear that there exists Z ∈ L(H1 , H2− ) with Z ∗ Z ≥ K. Hence (−A− )−1/2 (Z + D) + X∼ ∈ M and (−A− )−1/2 D + X∼ ∈ / M . This contradicts the observation above. Corollary 4. The set N (A, C) is convex if and only if it is either empty, or coincides with L(H1 , H2 ), or A ≥ 0.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
31
Proof. Since N (A, C) is SOT-closed and convex it is WOT-closed. By Theorem 2(b), A− is of finite rank. Hence the assumptions of Theorem 3 are satisfied. Remark. If the answer to Problem 1 is positive, then the restriction on σ(A) in Theorem 3 can be removed. Indeed, if M (A, B, C) is convex then, being SOTclosed, it is WOT-closed. So (under our assumptions) A− has finite rank and σ(A) ∩ R− is finite.
5. Non-triviality The purpose of this section is to describe the conditions under which the sets N (A, C) and M (A, B, C) are non-empty. We use the decompositions (6) and (7), and the notation introduced in Section 2. The dimension of a subspace can be a non-negative integer or ∞. (i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
Consider the following (pairwise exclusive) conditions: dim H1+ < dim H2− . dim H1+ = dim H2− < ∞. dim H1+ = dim H2− = ∞ and A− is non-compact. dim H1+ = dim H2− = ∞, both A− and C+ are compact, and ci sup < ∞, 1≤i<∞ ai ∞ where {ci }∞ i=1 are the eigenvalues of C+ in non-increasing order, and {ai }i=1 are the eigenvalues of (−A− ) in non-increasing order.
Theorem 4. N (A, −C) = ∅ if and only if one of the conditions (i)–(iv) is satisfied. Proof. Suppose N (A, −C) = ∅. Let X ∈ N (A, −C). Then (X ∗ AX + C)x, x ≤ 0 ∀x ∈ H1 , that is, AXx, Xx ≤ −Cx, x ∀x ∈ H1 . The inequality (20) can be rewritten as AX+ x, X+ x + AX0 x, X0 x + AX− x, X− x ≤ −Cx, x.
(20) (21)
The inequality (21) implies AX− x, X− x ≤ −Cx, x.
(22)
Therefore the restriction of the operator X− to H1+ is injective, and it maps H1+ into H2− . Hence dim H2− ≥ dim H1+ . Hence either we are in cases (i) or (ii), or dim H1+ = dim H2− = ∞. In the latter case, if A− is compact, the inequality (22) implies that the condition (iv) is
32
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
satisfied. In fact, let R be the restriction of X− to H1+ . Then, for each x in H1+ , we have (−A− )Rx, Rx ≥ Cx, x.
(23)
By the minimax principle (see [6, Theorem X.4.3]) there exists an i-codimensional subspace Li ⊂ H2 such that ai+1 = max (−A− )x, x ≥ x∈Li ||x||=1
(−A− )Rx, Rx Cx, x ≥ max 2 2 −1 ||R|| (Li ) x∈R (Li ) ||R||
max −1
x∈R ||x||=1
1 ≥ ||R||2
||x||=1
min
max Cx, x =
Mi ⊂H1 x∈Mi codim(Mi )=i ||x||=1
1 ci+1 . ||R||2
The last inequality follows from the minimax principle, in this chain of inequalities we also used the fact that codimR−1 (Li ) ≤ i. Hence the condition (iv) is satisfied. If one of the conditions (i)–(iii) is satisfied, then there exists ε > 0 and a subspace N ⊂ H2− such that dim N = dim H1+ and Ax, x ≤ −ε2 ||x||2 for x ∈ N . We use the existence of such ε and N to find X ∈ L(H1 , H2 ) such that G(X) ≤ 0. We write X as a 3 × 3 matrix according to the decompositions (6) and (7): X++ X+0 X+− X = X0+ X00 X0− . X−+ X−0 X−− Let U : H1+ → H2− be an isometry between H1+ and N . Let 0 0 0 0 0 . X= 0 1 ||C||U 0 0 ε
(24)
For x ∈ H1 let x = x+ + x0 + x− be the decomposition of x according to (6). Then (X ∗ AX + C)x, x = AXx, Xx + Cx+ , x+ + Cx− , x− + Cx0 , x0 1
1
||C||U x+ , ||C||U x+ + ||C||||x+ ||2 ≤ A ε ε 1 ≤ −ε2 2 ||C||||x+ ||2 + ||C||||x+ ||2 ≤ 0. ε Suppose that the condition (iv) is satisfied. Observe that the following is an equivalent form of the condition (iv): there exists an operator Z : H1+ → H2− such that C+ = −Z ∗ A− Z. Set 0 0 0 X = 0 0 0 . (25) Z 0 0
Vol. 59 (2007)
Quadratic Inequalities for Hilbert Space Operators
33
We get (X ∗ AX + C)x, x = AXx, Xx + Cx+ , x+ + Cx− , x− + Cx0 , x0 ≤ Z ∗ A− Zx+ , x+ + Cx+ , x+ = 0.
Combining Theorem 4 and the observation from Section 2 we get a criterion for non-emptiness of M (A, B, C) in the case, when B = AD for some D.
References [1] T. Andˆ o, Truncated moment problems for operators, Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged), 31 (1970), 319–334. [2] J. B. Conway, A course in operator theory, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R. I., 2000. [3] C. C. Cowen, Iteration and the solution of functional equations for functions analytic in the unit disk, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 265 (1981), no. 1, 69–95. [4] R. Curtain and H. Zwart, An introduction to infinite-dimensional linear systems theory, Texts in Applied Mathematics, 21, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1995. [5] N. Dunford and J. T. Schwartz, Linear Operators. Part I: General Theory, New York, Interscience Publishers, 1958. [6] N. Dunford and J. T. Schwartz, Linear Operators. Part II: Spectral Theory, Wiley Classics Library, New York, Wiley Interscience, 1988. [7] L. E. Faybusovich, Matrix Riccati inequality: existence of solutions, Systems Control Lett. 9 (1987), no. 1, 59–64. [8] V. Ionescu, C. Oar˘ a, and M. Weiss, Generalized Riccati theory and robust control, Chichester, Wiley, 1999. [9] V. Khatskevich, M. I. Ostrovskii, and V. Shulman, Linear fractional relations for Hilbert space operators, Math. Nachrichten, 279 (2006), 875–890. [10] V. Khatskevich and V. Shulman, Operator fractional-linear transformations: convexity and compactness of image; applications, Studia Math., 116 (1995), 189–195. [11] M. G. Krein and I. E. Ovcharenko, Q-functions and sc-resolvents of nondensely defined Hermitian contractions (Russian), Sibirsk. Mat. Zh., 18 (1977), no. 5, 1032– 1056; English transl.: Siberian Math. J., 18 (1977), 728–746. [12] M. G. Krein and Yu. L. Shmulyan, On linear-fractional transformations with operator coefficients (Russian), Matem. Issled. (Kishinev), 2 (1967), no. 3, 64–96; English transl. in Amer. Math. Soc. Transl., Ser. 2, 103 (1974), 125–152. [13] G. A. Kurina, Control of a descriptor system in an infinite interval (Russian), Izv. Ross. Akad. Nauk Tekhn. Kibernet. (1993), no. 6, 33–38, English transl.: J. Comput. Systems Sci. Internat., 32 (1994), no. 6, 30–35. [14] P. Lancaster and L. Rodman, Algebraic Riccati equations, New York, Oxford University Press, 1995. [15] I. Lasiecka and R. Triggiani, Control theory for partial differential equations: continuous and approximation theories. I. Abstract parabolic systems, Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, 74, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2000.
34
Khatskevich, Ostrovskii and Shulman
IEOT
[16] M. M. Malamud, On some classes of extensions of sectorial operators and dual pairs of contractions, in: Recent advances in operator theory, 401–449, Operator Theory: Advances and Applications, 124, Birkh¨ auser, Basel, 2001. [17] C. Scherer, The solution set of the algebraic Riccati equation and the algebraic Riccati inequality, Linear Algebra Appl., 153 (1991), 99–122. [18] Yu. L. Shmulyan, A Hellinger operator integral (Russian), Mat. Sb. (N.S.) 49 (91) (1959), 381–430; English transl. in Amer. Math. Soc. Transl., Ser. 2, vol. 22 (1962), 289-337. [19] V. A. Yakubovich, Conditions for semiboundedness of a quadratic functional on a subspace of a Hilbert space, Vestn. Leningr. Univ., Math. 14 (1982), 321–325. V. A. Khatskevich Department of Mathematics ORT Braude College College Campus, P.O. Box 78 Karmiel 21982 Israel e-mail: victor
[email protected] M. I. Ostrovskii Department of Mathematics and Computer Science St. John’s University 8000 Utopia Parkway Queens, NY 11439 USA e-mail:
[email protected] V. S. Shulman Department of Mathematics Vologda State Technical University 15 Lenina str. Vologda 160000 Russia e-mail: shulman
[email protected] Submitted: June 6, 2006 Revised: April 4, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 35–51 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010035-17, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1507-z
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
On the Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Several Commuting Operators R. Levy Abstract. In the paper the local structure of the Fredholm joint spectrum of commuting n-tuples of operators is considered. A connection between the spatial characteristics of operators and the algebraic invariants of the corresponding coherent sheaves is investigated. A new notion of Weyl joint spectrum of commuting n-tuple is introduced. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 47A13, 47A11. Keywords. Essential spectrum, Fredholm spectrum, commuting operators, coherent sheaf.
0. Introduction Let T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ), where T1 , . . . , Tn are mutually commuting linear bounded n operators acting in the Banach space X. By σ(T ) ⊂ C we denote the joint Taylor n spectrum of T . Recall that σ(T ) consist of all points λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ) in C such that the Koszul complex K∗ (T − λ, X) of the operators (T1 − λ1 , . . . , Tn − λn ) is not exact. Suppose that for given λ ∈ σ(T ) all the homology spaces Hi (T, λ) := Hi (K∗ (T − λ, X)) are finite-dimensional: we call such a point Fredholm point for T and write λ ∈ σF (T ), the Fredholm spectrum of T . The remaining part is called essential spectrum and is denoted by σe (T ) := σ(T )\σF (T ). It is a simple observation (see [15]) that any finite Fredholm complex of Banach spaces with differentials, holomorphically depending on the parameters, is locally holomorphically quasi-isomorphic to a holomorphic complex of finitedimensional spaces. Therefore, the homology sheaves Hi (T ) of the complex of germs of holomorphic functions with values in K∗ (T − λ, X) are coherent on Cn \σe (T ). Fixing a point λ0 ∈ σF (T ), one can consider the stalk of the homology sheaf Hi (T )λ0 as a module over the Noetherian local ring Oλ0 of germs of The author was partially supported by the contract MM-1401/04 with the Bulgarian Ministry of Science and Education and by the contract 22/2006 with Sofia University.
36
Levy
IEOT
holomorphic functions at this point. The Fredholm spectrum σF (T ) is a complexn analytic subspace of C \σe (T ), its dimension near λ0 is well defined, and it is an n integer not exceeding the dimension of the ambient space C . The existing results investigate mainly the case when the Fredholm spectrum is of maximal dimension, especially for sub- and factor-modules of spaces of analytic functions – see [4], [11], [9], [10], [6], [7], [8] etc. In the present paper we are interested mainly in the case when this dimension is strictly less than n. To every coherent sheaf, or finitely generated Oλ0 -module, one can attach an element of the cycle group of Oλ0 , i.e. a formal sum of prime ideals of Oλ0 . Taking the alternated sum of cycles of the modules Hi (T )λ0 for i = 0, . . . , n, one obtains the cycle of the Koszul complex of the n-tuple. Roughly speaking, all irreducible component of σF (T ) containing λ0 ”participate” in the homology sheaves multiplied by corresponding integer coefficients, and we obtain a set of integers characterizing the homology sheaves of the Koszul complex of T . (In the case of a single operator T the corresponding invariant is the index of T − λ0 .) One of the purposes of the paper is to establish some connections between the algebraic characteristics of the homology sheaves, and the action of then operators of T in X. In the first section of the paper we recall some necessary facts from the commutative algebra and the theory of analytic local rings. As a source, we use the books [17], [12] and [5]. Especially, we recall notions as isolated prime ideals in the support of a module, cycle of a module, and functoriality of the cycle map under finite morphisms. We recall also the notions of Hilbert-Samuel polynomial and multiplicity of a module with respect to a prime ideal. The second and third sections contain the main results of the paper. In the subsection 2.1 we define the cycle zλ0 (T ) in a point λ0 of the Fredholm spectrum of T as a formal linear combination with integer coefficients of the irreducible components of σF (T ) passing through λ0 . More precisely, to every irreducible with corresponding prime ideal pP we attach component P of σF (T ) containing λ0 an integer lP (T ) such that zλ0 (T ) = lP (T ) pP . In the case of Fredholm spectrum of maximal dimension, this is simply the index of the n-tuple T near λ0 (multiplied by the zero ideal). Theorem 2.3 proves the functoriality of the maximal component of the cycle under the holomorphic functional calculus (in particular, the projection property for it). The subsection 2.4 is devoted to the connection between the algebraic invariant zλ0 (T ) introduced above and some index-type characteristics of the n-tuple T which in some particular cases can be used for the calculation of this invariant. The usual definition of the index of a commuting n-tuple is the Euler characteristic of the corresponding Koszul complex. However, in the case when the dimension of the Fredholm spectrum is strictly less than n this index is automatically zero. In order to obtain a non-trivial invariant, it is natural to choose a suitable k-sub-tuple of T , where k is the dimension of the Fredholm spectrum, and to investigate its index. Unfortunately, this is not always possible which can be seen in the following
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
37
simple example. Suppose that the essential spectrum of T coincides with the unit n sphere of C and its Fredholm spectrum is contained in the interior of this sphere. Then every sub-tuple of T has empty Fredholm spectrum. This follows by the projection property and by the fact that any fiber of the corresponding coordinate projection, if non-empty, meets the essential spectrum. To avoid this situation, in [15] it was introduced the notion of local Euler characteristic (with respect to a given point in σF (T ) and a suitable coordinate projection) – see proposition 2.4 below. The main result of subsection 2.4 – theorem 2.5 – states that the local Euler characteristic coincides with the alternated multiplicity of homology sheaves of T in the given point with respect to the corresponding coordinate projection. We note that the connection between the index and the algebraic properties of the corresponding analytic modules, especially in the case of sub- and factor-modules of free Hilbert modules, has been studied in several papers, but mainly in the case of maximal dimension – see the recent papers [9] and [10]. In the non-maximal case, the connection between the analytic and index invariants has been studied in dimensions 2 and 3 in the second part of the paper [14]. In the subsection we are dealing with the highest homology sheaf Hn (T ). 2.5 n In the case when X/ i=1 Ti − λ0i X is finite-dimensional, this sheaf is coherent near the point λ0 . Under this condition in [4] R. Douglas and K. Yan defined the notion of Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of the corresponding Hilbert module. The connection between the generic dimension of X/ ni=1 Ti − λ0i X and the HilbertSamuel polynomial, was studied in the above mentioned papers of Fang, as well as in the series of preprints [6], [7], [8]. Again, the results of the cited papers relies to the case when the Fredholm spectrum contains a neighborhood of the given point, i.e. is of dimension n. In this case, the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial is of dimension n as well, and the authors investigate the so called Hilbert-Samuel multiplicity – its coefficient ito the power n, multiplied by n!. We prove a similar result in the case of Fredholm spectrum of arbitrary dimension. Namely, theorem 2.8 shows that the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial, defined by Douglas and Yan, coincides with the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of the local module Hn (T )λ0 , and therefore its degree is equal to the dimension of σF (T ) near λ0 . In subsection 2.6 this result is applied to the theory of multidimensional row contractions, developed by Arveson ([1], [2]). In particular, we prove that the degree of a graded finite-rank row contraction is equal to the dimension of its Fredholm spectrum near the origin (proposition 2.15). The connection between the characteristics of a multidimensional contraction and the geometry of its Fredholm spectrum will be considered in more details elsewhere. The third section of the paper is devoted to the Weyl spectrum of the commuting n-tuple T of operators. In [16], M. Putinar defines the Weyl spectrum ω(T ) of T as the complement in σ(T ) of the set of points λ ∈ σF (T ) such that ind (T − λ) = 0. However, in the case when dim σF (T ) < n, it is easy to see that ind (T − λ) = 0 for any λ ∈ / σe (T ), and therefore the Weyl spectrum will coincide with the essential spectrum of the n-tuple. We propose here an alternative
38
Levy
IEOT
definition: a Fredholm point λ is not in the Weyl spectrum iff the cycle zλ (T ) is zero, i.e. all lP (T ) = 0. In the case when all the components of σF (T ) are of (maximal) dimension n, this definition coincides with the definition adopted in [16]. Note that even in the case of a single operator there is a certain discrepancy between our approach and the standard one: in our definition, all the isolated point of the Fredholm spectrum of T belong to its Weyl spectrum. Further we give some basic properties of the newly introduced notion of Weyl spectrum: any ntuple with SVEP (Single Value Extension Property) has the ”Weyl property” (the Weyl spectrum coincides with the essential spectrum). We prove also the property of spectral inclusion under holomorphic functional calculus for this spectrum. In some particular cases we get a stronger result – the spectral mapping theorem (see propositions 3.4 and 3.5). The present paper continues the investigations on the structure of the Fredholm spectrum of a commuting n-tuple of operators started in [15], and systematically uses some basic result of that paper.
1. Some basic facts from the commutative algebra n
Consider a coherent analytic sheaf L, defined on an open subset of C . Recall that its (geometric) support supp L consists of all points where L is non-zero; supp L n is a complex-analytic subset of C . If λ0 ∈ supp L, then the stalk of L at λ0 is a finitely generated module over the local Noetherian ring Oλ0 . Below we recall some basic notions from the commutative local algebra, concerning Noeterian rings and modules, necessary for our considerations. Let A be a commutative local Noetherian ring, and M be a finitely generated A-module with annihilator Ann(M). Let P rime (A) be the set of prime ideals of A. Denote by Supp (M) the (algebraic) support of M – the set of all prime ideals in A, containing Ann(M). The set Supp(M) has a natural ordering by inclusion and the minimal elements with respect of this ordering (called isolated associated primes) play a special role. They correspond to the irreducible components of the geometric support of M. The set Iso(M) of all such prime ideals is finite (see [5], chap. 3). For p ∈ P rim (A), denote by Mp the localization of the A-module M with respect to p. Then p ∈ Supp (M) if and only if Mp = 0. Moreover, p ∈ Iso (M) iff lp (M) = dimAp Mp is finite and nonzero. Suppose that 0 = M0 ⊂ . . . ⊂ Mk = M is a composition series for M, i.e. Mi /Mi−1 = A/pi with pi ∈ P rim (A) for all i. If p ∈ Iso (M), then p appears exactly lp (M) times in the sequence {p1 , . . . , pk }. By Isomax (M) we denote the set of elements of Iso (M) of maximal dimension (equal to the dimension of M). Let M and A be as above, and let q be an ideal in A such that M/qM is of finite dimension. Then there exists a polynomial Pq,M (called the HilbertSamuel polynomial of the pair q, M) of degree r = dimA M such that for n sufficiently big one has dim (M/q n M) = Pq,M (n). The leading term of Pq,M has the
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
39
e (M)
form q r! nr , where eq (M) is a positive integer, called a multiplicity of q at M. If q = m, where m is the maximal ideal of A, then the corresponding integer is called multiplicity of M and is denoted by e (M). The formula (∗) in the page 1 on the book [17] shows how eq (M) can be calculated in homological terms. Suppose now that M = {M0 , . . . , M n } is an nordered finite set of finitely generated modules over A. Denote Ann M = i=0 Ann (M). Let Supp M be the set of all prime ideals of A, containing Ann M , Iso M – the set of minimal elements of Supp M , and Isomax M – the set of elements of Iso M of maximal dimension. Take i ∈ {0, . . . , n} and a prime ideal p ∈ Supp (Mi ). Since Supp (Mi ) ⊂ Supp M , then if p is not minimal in Supp (Mi ), it will be not minimal in Supp M as well. So, one obtains Proposition 1.1. For any p ∈ Iso M and i ∈ {0, . . . , n} one has one of the following two possibilities: 1) p ∈ Iso (Mi ), or 2) p ∈ / Supp (Mi ). Therefore for any prime p ∈ Iso M and integer i lp (Mi ) = dimAp (Mi )p is well-defined (it is positive in the case 1) and zero in the case 2)). So for such a p one can define: n lp M := (−1)i lp (Mi ) . i=0
Let q be an ideal in A such that Mi /qMi is finite-dimensional for all i. One can introduce the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of M : n Pq,M (n) := (−1)i Pq,M (n). i=0
If one denotes by r = dimA M the maximal dimension of the A-modules Mi , i = 0, . . . , n, then Pq,M (n) is a polynomial of dimension r and with leading term eq (M) r n , where r! n eq M := (−1)i eq (Mi ) . i=0
Denote by Z (A) the group of the cycles of A, i.e. of all formal linear combinations of elements of P rime (A) with integer coefficients. to any tuple of Then max M of Z (A), defined A-modules M one can attach the elements z M and z by the formulae z M = lp M p , z max M = lp M p p∈Iso(M) p∈Isomax (M) and one has
eq M =
p∈Isomax (M)
lp M eq (A/p)
40
Levy
IEOT
(see [17], p. 125-126). Finally, we will need a functoriality result. Let B be a subring of the analytic local ring A such that the monomorphism ϕ : B → A is finite in the sense of [12], II.2.2, i.e. A is finitely generated as a B-module. For any finitely generated A-module M, denote by MB the underlying B-module. Then MB is a finitely generated B-module again. For any p ∈ P rime (A), denote by ϕ∗ p the element z max (pB ) of Z (B). By linearity one can extend this mapping up to a morphism ϕ∗ : Z (A) → Z (B). Proposition 1.2. For any finitely generated A-module M one has z max (MB ) = ϕ∗ z max (M). Proof. Indeed, theorem 2 of [12], II.5.1 asserts that dimA L = dimB LB for any finitely generated A-module L. In particular, this is true for the modules of the type A/p, p ∈ P rime (A). Taking the composition series for M and using the additivity of the mapping z max (see [17], p. 125), we obtain z max (MB ) = max (M). p∈Isomax (M) lp (M) pB = ϕ∗ z
2. Local structure of the Fredholm spectrum of commuting n-tuple 2.1. Main definitions Consider a commuting n-tuple T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) of operators acting in the Banach space X, and denote by K∗ (T − λ, X) = {Xk , dk (λ)}k=0,1,...,n the Koszul complex n of T in the point λ ∈ C . Recall that Xk is a direct sum of nk copies of the space X, and dk (λ) depend linearly on λ. Denote by OX the sheaf of germs of n X-valued holomorphic functions on C and the complex OK∗ (T −λ, X) of sheaves n of holomorphic sections on C of the complex K∗ (T − λ, X). Denote by Hi (T, λ) the i-th homology space of the complex K∗ (T − λ, X), and by Hi (T ) the i-th sheaf of homologies of the complex of sheaves OK∗ (T − λ, X). Let Hi (T )λ0 be the stalk of Hi (T ) at λ0 , considered as a local Oλ0 -module. Since the operators Ti commute with the differentials dk (λ) of the parameterized Koszul complex, one can define the action of operators Tk , k = 1, . . . , n on the spaces Hi (T, λ0 ) and Hi (T ). It is easy to see that the operator Tk acts on the space Hi (T, λ0 ) as multiplication by the number λ0k , and on the sheaf Hi (T ) – as multiplication by the variable λk . Fix a point λ0 ∈ σF (T ); this means that all the spaces Hi (T, λ0 ) are finitedimensional. As it was noted in [15], there exists a holomorphic complex of finitedimensional spaces, defined near λ0 and holomorphically quasi-isomorphic to K∗ (T − λ, X). Therefore, all the sheaves Hi (T ) are coherent in a neighborhood of λ0 , and the stalks Hi (T )λ0 at λ0 are finitely generated modules over the local Noetherian ring Oλ0 . Denote by H(T )λ0 the n + 1-tuple {Hi (T )λ0 }i=0,...,n . Then of the the prime ideals in Iso H(T )λ0 correspond to the irreducible components complex set σF (T ), containing the point λ0 . Denote by r = r λ0 the maximal dimension of these components.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
41
Definition 2.1. Define
zλ0 (T ) = z H(T )λ0 , zλmax (T ) = z max H(T )λ0 . 0
The element zλ0 (T ) has the form zλ0 (T ) =
lp (T ) p
p∈Iso(H(T )λ0 )
where lp (T ) = lp H(T )λ0 are integers. This definition can be considered from the geometric point of view. Let P be an irreducible component of the complex set σF (T ); then in any point λ ∈ P it determines a prime ideal pλ in the ring Oλ . Proposition 2.2. The integer lpλ (T ) does not depend on the choice of the point λ ∈ P. Proof. It is sufficient to proof that the integers lpλ (T ) are locally constant on P. Choose λ0 ∈ P and a sufficiently small ball U , centered at λ0 , such that U does not intersect any irreducible component of σF (T ), not containing λ0 . Then for any i ∈ {0, . . . , n} the OU -module Hi (T )U has the same set of isolated primes, and the same composition series, as Hi (T )λ0 . The irreducible complex set P determines a prime ideal pU in OU . For any λ ∈ U consider the Oλ -module Hi (T )λ . If λ ∈ P, the localization of pU at λ is a nontrivial prime ideal in Oλ coinciding with the ideal pλ . The invariance of the composition series under localization shows that lpλ0 (T ) = lpU (T ) = lpλ (T ). Now, we can attach to any irreducible component its local index lP (T ). The set of all irreducible components and the corresponding local indexes contains certain information about the homology sheaves of the Koszul complex of T and will be called a spectral picture of the commuting n-tuple T . In the rest of the paper we will turn back to the algebraic point of view on the local indexes and will give some facts allowing to compute it in some cases. 2.2. Particular cases: dimensions 1 and n Suppose that the dimension of σF (T ) at λ0 is the maximal one, i.e. equal to n. This means that the Fredholm spectrum σF (T ) contains a neighborhood U of λ0 . It is easy to see (or to derive from theorem 2.5 below) that in this case Iso H(T )λ0 = {[0]} and n z (T )λ0 = z max (T )λ0 = (−1) ind T − λ0 . [0] , where ind T − λ0 is the Euler characteristic of the complex K∗ T − λ0 , X and [0] is the zero ideal in Oλ0 . Recall that the n-tuple T has the single value extension property (SVEP) at λ0 if Hi (T )λ0 = 0 for all i = n. Suppose in addition that the n-tuple T has SVEP. Then from the theory of coherent sheaves it follows that the sheaf Hn (T ) is a free of U . (In fact, U is the complement of a O-module on the open dense subset U
42
Levy
IEOT
one complex subset of U of dimension < n.) Then for any λ = (λ1 , . . . , λn ) ∈ U has n 0 n (Ti − λi ) X . ind T − λ = ind (T − λ) = (−1) dim X/ i=1
Now consider the case when σF (T ) is one-dimensional near λ0 . In [15] it was proved that the modules Hi (T )λ0 are nonzero only for i = n, n − 1. Moreover, prop. 3.6 of [15] shows that Hn−1 (T ) ∼ Hn (T ∗ ) , where T ∗ is the n-tuple (T1∗ , . . . , Tn∗ ) acting in the dual space X ∗ and ∼ denotes the equivalence modulo sheaves with zero-dimensional support, i.e. concentrated in the point λ0 . So we get the equality z max (T )λ0 = (−1)n (z max (Hn (T )λ0 ) − z max (Hn (T ∗ )λ0 )) . Finally, note that if σF (T ) is of dimension zero at λ0 (i.e. λ0 is an isolated point of the Fredholm spectrum), then l{λ0 } (T ) coincides with the dimension of the spectral subspace of T corresponding to the point λ0 . 2.3. Functoriality Let f (λ) = (f1 (λ) , . . . , fk (λ)) be a k-tuple of holomorphic functions, defined n in a neighborhood of the spectrum σ(T ) ⊂ C of the commuting n-tuple T of operators. It is well-known that σ(f (T )) = f (σ(T )) and σe (f (T )) = f (σe (T )) The first equality (the functoriality of the Taylor spectrum) was proved in the Taylor‘s fundamental paper [18]. Its modification for the essential spectrum was proved by several authors (see for example [15]). k Take the point µ0 ∈ C belonging to the Fredholm spectrum σF (f (T )) of the operator k-tuple f (T ). Then its preimage f −1 µ0 ∩ σ(T ) is a finite subset {λ1 , . . . , λp } of the Fredholm spectrum σF (T ) of T . For any λ ∈ f −1 µ0 ∩ σ(T ) the inverse image f ∗ by f provides an embedding Oµk 0 → Oλn and the induced monomorphism Oµk 0 → Oλn /Ann H(T )λ is finite. Denote by
f∗ : Z Oλn /Ann H(T )λ → Z Oµk 0 the morphism used in prop. 1.2. Theorem 2.3. The following equality holds: z max H(f (T ))µ0 =
f∗ z max H(T )λ
λ∈f −1 (µ0 )∩σ(T )
Proof. In proposition 3.2 of [15], the equality Hi (f (T ))µ0 =
Hi+n−k (T )λ ,
λ∈f −1 (µ0 )∩σ(T )
is established, where both sides are considered as Oµk 0 -modules. Applying the functor z max and taking into account the equality z max (MB ) = ϕ∗ z max (M) proved in the previous section, we get the theorem.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
43
2.4. zλmax (T ) and local Euler characteristics 0 max We will try to extract (T )λ0 , i.e. on the integers some information on the cycle z lp (T ) := lp H(T )λ0 for p ∈ Isomax H(T )λ0 , by using some properties of operators of T . Suppose that the coordinates λ = (λ1 , . . . , λr ) form a coordinate system for σF (T ) at λ0 . This means that λ0 is an isolated point of Π−1 λ0 ∩ σF (T ), where Π is thecoordinate projection onto the first r coordinates, and λ0 = λ01 , . . . , λ0r , λ0 = λ0r+1 , . . . , λ0n . This can always be achieved by a small perturbation of the coordinate system. We will denote T = (T , T ), where T = (T1 , . . . , Tr ), T = (Tr+1 , . . . , Tn ). Consider the Koszul complex K∗ (T −λ0 , X) of the operators T1 −λ01 , . . . , Tr − 0 λr in X. In general its homology spaces Hi (T , λ0 ), i = 0, . . . , r are not Hausdorff spaces, but due to the commutativity of T the action of the operators from T on it is correctly defined. Moreover, one can form the parameterized Koszul complex of / Π−1 λ0 σ(T ). operators of T − λ in Hi (T , λ0 ); this complex is exact for λ ∈ The following proposition was proved in [15]: Proposition 2.4. In the conditions from above there exists a decomposition Hi (T , λ0 ) = Hi (T , λ0 ) Hi (T , λ0 ) into subspaces, invariant under T , such that: a) Hi (T , λ0 ) is finite-dimensional (or empty) and the joint spectrum of operators of T in Hi (T , λ0 ) (in the non-empty case) consists of the point λ0 . b) The joint spectrum of T in Hi (T , λ0 ) does not contain the point λ0 . ) of c) There exists a finite-dimensional subcomplex L holomorphic 0 ∗ (λ L λ coincides with H T K∗ (T − λ , X), such that H − λ0 , X and ∗ ∗ i H∗ K∗ T − λ0 , X /L∗ λ0 – with Hi T − λ0 , X . d) Suppose that Π−1 λ0 is contained in σF (T ) and therefore consists of finitely many points λj = λ0 , λj , j = 1, . . . , k. Denote by Hij (T , λ0 ) the joint root space of the operators T − λj in Hi (T , λ0 ). Then Hi (T , λ0 ) = j 0 j Hi (T , λ ). In other words, Hi (T , λ0 ) is finite-dimensional and coincides with the joint root space of the operators Tr+1 − λ0r+1 , . . . , Tn − λ0n acting in the linear space Hi (T , λ0 ). Note that in the case of essentially normal tuple T the results of [15] provide also a connection between the K-theory of the holomorphic complexes from above and the Brown-Douglas-Fillmore invariant of T . Denote r (−1)i dim Hi (T , λ0 ). χ T , λ0 = i=0
Let q be the ideal in Oλ0 , generated by the functions λ1 − λ01 , . . . , λr − λ0r . Then the following statement holds true: Theorem 2.5. χ T , λ0 = eq H(T )λ0 .
44
Levy
IEOT
Proof. Let Oλ0 X be, as above, the stalk at λ0 of the sheaf of germs of X-valued holomorphic functions, and let Oλ0 K∗ (T − λ, X) be the Koszul complex of the operators of T − λ in Oλ0 X. This is a complex of Oλ0 -modules. Consider, in any stage Oλ0 Xk , k = 0, .. . , n, of this complex, the action of the operators T − λ0 = T1 − λ01 , . . . , Tr − λ0r . This action commutes with the differential of the complex. One can form the Koszul complexes of the operators of T −λ0 in Oλ0 Xk , obtaining a bicomplex of sheaves with r + 1 rows and n + 1 columns. As it is shown below, the cohomology sheaves of its total complex are in fact supported at λ0 and finitedimensional. The Euler characteristic of the total complex of this bicomplex can be computed in two ways. One may consider the homologies Hi (T )λ0 , i = 0, . . . , n of the initial complex, and take the alternated sum of dimensions of the homologies of the Koszul complex of operators T −λ0 in it. The alternated sum of these integers for i = 0, . . . , n is equal to the alternated sum of the dimensions of the homologies of the total complex. Since the action of the operators Tj on Hi (T )λ0 coincides with the multiplication by the variable λj , we arrive to the Koszul complex of λ1 − λ01 , . . . , λr − λ0r in Hi (T )λ0 , and the formula (∗) on page 1 of [17] can be applied. It shows that r
(−1)j dim Hj λ − λ0 , Hi (T )λ0 = eq (Hi (T )λ0 )
j=0
for any i = 0, . . . , n. Therefore the Euler characteristic of the total complex is equal to eq H(T )λ0 . 0 On the other hand, take the complex K − λ , X with stages Xk and T ∗ 0 differentials dk = dk λ : Xk → Xk+1 , k = 0, . . . , r. The Euler characteristic of the total complex is equal to the alternated sum on j, j = 1, . . . , r of the integers cj =
n (−1)i dim Hi (T − λ, Oλ0 Hj (T − λ , X)) i=1
0 Hj (T − λ , X) we denote the factor Oλ0 -module where by O λ0 0 Oλ0 ker dj λ /dj−1 λ (Oλ0 Xj−1 ). Take the finite-dimensional subcomplex L∗ λ0 = {Lj , aj } as in point c) of prop. 3.2 of [15]; then the action of the operators T − λ on the module Oλ0 (Xj /Lj ) is regular for any j, and therefore in the formula above we can replace Oλ0 Hj (T − λ , X) by Oλ0 Lj /aj (Oλ0 Lj−1 ) = 0 Oλ0 Hi T − λ , X . It is easy to prove the following:
Lemma 2.6. Let H be a finite-dimensional space, Oλ0 H – the Oλ0 -module of germs n of H-valued holomorphic functions in the point λ0 ∈ C . Let T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) be an n-tuple of operators acting in H of the form Ti = λ0i I + Ki , i = 1, . . . , n, where Ki are nilpotent operators in H. Then
0 if i < n dim Hi (T − λ, Oλ0 H) = dim H for i = n.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
45
Indeed, if all Ki are zero operators, one obtains the Koszul complex of the germs λ0i − λi in Oλ0 H exact in all terms except in the last one, where the module of homology is Oλ0 H/mλ0 H, and mλ0 is the maximal ideal in Oλ0 . The general case can be reduced to the case of zero operators by taking a filtration of the linear space H such that all Ki are zero on the corresponding graduate space. Applying the assertion of the lemma to the space Hi (T , λ0 ) and the operators λ01 , . . . , λ0r , Tr+1 , . . . , Tn , we get cj = dim Hi (T , λ0 ) for j = 1, . . . , r, which proves the theorem. Corollary 2.7. Suppose that Isomax H(T )λ0 consists of a single prime ideal p, (i.e. there is only one irreducible component P of σF (T ) containing λ0 ), and the coordinates λ = (λ1 , . . . , λr ) form a coordinate system for σF (T ) at λ0 . Then χ T , λ0 = eq (Oλ0 /p) lp (T ) , where q is, as above, the ideal generated by λ1 − λ01 , . . . , λr − λ0r . 2.5. The highest homology sheaf Hn (T )λ0
n
In this section we assume that the point λ0 ∈ C satisfies the regularity n following condition: the linear subspace of all elements of the type i=1 Ti − λ0i xi with x1 , . . . , xn ∈ X is of finite codimension in X. Then, following the arguments used e.g. in [15], 4.3., it is easy to see that the last homology sheaf Hn (T ) of the Koszul complex of T is coherent near λ0 . For simplicity, denote by Hλ0 X the Oλ0 -module Hn (T )λ0 . Let m be the maximal ideal in the local ring Oλ0 . As above, one can form the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial Pm,Hλ0 X (k) with leading term e (Hn (T )λ0 ) k r /r!, where r = dim supp Hn (T )λ0 . On the other hand, in [4] R. Douglas and K. Yan defined the notion of HilbertSamuel polynomial of a given Hilbert module (see also chapter 2 of [3]). More precisely, consider the operator algebra A = C [T1 , . . . , Tn ] ⊂ L(X) and denote by m(T ) the operator ideal in A generated by the operators T1 − λ01 , . . . , Tn − λ0n . Then, under the regularity assumption from above, Douglas and Yan proved that for any natural k the subspace mk (T )X is of finite codimension in X. For k large enough the codimension of mk (T )X is a polynomial of k of degree not exceeding n. This polynomial is called by Douglas and Yan the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of the Hilbert C [λ1 , . . . , λn ]-module, determined by the space X and the operators T1 , . . . , Tn . The following assertion shows that the Hilbert-Samuel polynomials of the Hilbert module and of the last homology sheaf coincide: Theorem 2.8. Under the condition from above, dim X/mk (T )X = dim Hn (T )λ0 /mk Hn (T )λ0 and therefore for k large enough it is a polynomial of k with leading term e (Hn (T )λ0 ) k r /r!, where r = dim supp Hn (T )λ0 . Proof. Denote Y = mk (T )X and Z = X/Y . Then Z is finite-dimensional and the joint spectrum of the operators induced by T in Z coincides with the point λ0 . Therefore Hi (T − λ, Z)λ0 = 0 for all i < n. Denote, as above, by Hλ0 X the
46
Levy
IEOT
Oλ0 -module Hn (T )λ0 = Oλ0 X/ i (Ti − λi ) Oλ0 X, and by Hλ0 Y , Hλ0 Z – the corresponding homology modules for Y and Z respectively. The exact sequence 0 → Y → X → Z → 0 determines an exact sequence of the corresponding Koszul complexes, and therefore a long exact sequence of the corresponding homology sheaves, ending with the sequence 0 → Hλ0 Y → Hλ0 X → Hλ0 Z → 0. The next assertion shows that the image of Hλ0 Y in Hλ0 X coincides with mk Hλ0 X. Lemma 2.9. Let J be a finitely generated ideal in the algebra of polynomials
C [λ1 , . . . , λn ], and let J (T ) be the corresponding ideal in the operator algebra C [T1 , . . . , Tn ]. Suppose that Y = J (T )X is of finite codimension in X. Then the image of Hλ0 Y in Hλ0 X under the natural inclusion coincides with the module J Hλ0 X.
Proof. Note that for any germ x(λ) of a X-valued holomorphic function and for any polynomial p(λ) the germs of the functions p(T )x(λ) and p(λ)x(λ) define the same class in the factor-sheaf Hλ0 X. Now choose the polynomials gl (λ), l = 1, . . . , L, generating the ideal J . Then the row operator g(T ) = (g1 (T ), . . . , gL (T )) gives L an epimorphism ∈ Hλ0 Y can be represented by l=1 Xl → Y . Any element y a germ of an Y -valued holomorphic function y(λ), which can be lifted through the epimorphism g(T ). In other words, there exist germs of X-valued holomorphic gl (T )xl (λ). Then the class of the functions x1 (λ), . . . , xL (λ) such that y(λ) = gl (T )xl (λ) ∈ function y(λ) in Hλ0 X coincides with the class of the function J Hλ0 X. Thus the image of Hλ0 Y in Hλ0 X under the natural inclusion is contained in J Hλ0 X. Conversely, take an element x = l gl (λ) xl ∈ J Hλ0 X. Representing x l by of holomorphic X-valued functions, and denoting x(λ) = l gl (λ)xl (λ) germs xl (λ) and y(λ) = l gl (T )xl (λ), we obtain that both x(λ) and y(λ) represent the class x . However, y(λ) is Y -valued function, and therefore x belongs to the image of Hλ0 Y . To complete the proof of the theorem, it is sufficient to apply the lema in the case J = mk which yields that Hλ0 Y and mk Hλ0 X are isomorphic submodules of Hλ0 X. Taking the corresponding factor-modules we obtain an isomorphism between Hλ0 Z and Hλ0 X/mk Hλ0 X. Applying lemma 2.6, we get dim Z = dim Hn (T )λ0 /mk Hn (T )λ0 . A similar equality can be proved in a more general situation. Suppose that, as in th. 2.3, f (λ) = (f1 (λ) , . . . , fp (λ)) is a k-tuple of holomorphic functions, defined in the neighborhood of σ(T ), µ0 ∈ σF (f (T )), and therefore the intersection f −1 µ0 ∩ σ(T ) is a finite subset λ1 , . . . , λJ of σF (T ). Let q be the ideal, generated by f1 (λ)−µ01 , . . . , fp (λ)−µ0k , and q(T ) – the operator ideal in L(X) generated by f1 (T ) − µ01, . . . , fk (T ) − µ0k . Let r = max dimOλ0 (Hn (T )λj ), j = 1, . . . , J. Then, applying the above theorem for the p-tuple f (T ) − µ0 and using the functoriality stated in 2.3, we get
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
47
Corollary 2.10. In the conditions from above dim X/q k (T )X =
J
dim Hn (T )λj /q k Hn (T )λj
j=1
and therefore for k sufficiently large it is a polynomial of degree r. In particular, the following corollary holds true: Corollary 2.11. Suppose that, under the conditions of 2.10, the n-tuple T has SVEP at the points λ1 , . . . , λJ (or, equivalently, f (T ) has SVEP at µ0 ). Then for k sufficiently large dim X/q k (T )X is a polynomial of k with leading term (−1)n eq (T )k r /r!, where r is the maximal dimension of the modules Hn (T )λj for j = 1, . . . , J. 2.6. Application to Arveson‘s row contraction theory Suppose that the operators of T act in the Hilbert space H. as above, a nChoose, point λ0 such that the subspace of elements of the type i=1 Ti − λ0i xi is of finite codimension in H, and denote, as in the previous section, by m the maximal ideal in the local ring Oλ0 . Take the polynomials gl (λ), l = 1, . . . , L, generating the ideal mk , and denote by g(T ) : H L → H the row operator with entries gl (T ), l = 1, . . . , L. Then the factor-space Z = H/mk (T )H from the previous section is isomorphic to the kernel of the operator g(T ) ◦ g(T )∗ = l=1 gl (T ) ◦ gl (T )∗ . In particular, consider the case when T is a commuting n-contraction with n finite rank in the sense of Arveson (see [1]), i.e. the operator 1 − i=1 Ti Ti∗ is finite-dimensional and positive. Then the Fredholm spectrum of T is contained in the open unit ball Bn . Suppose in addition that that the essential spectrum σe (T ) does not contains the origin, i.e. one can take λ0 = 0 (this is obviously satisfied if all the operators Ti are essentially normal; in this case the essential spectrum n is contained in the unit sphere in C ). Let φ : B(H) → nB(H) be the Arveson completely positive map defined by the formula φ(A) = i=1 Ti ATi∗ (see [2]). In the Arveson‘s theory an important role is played by the expression k! T k1 . . . Tnkn T1∗k1 . . . Tn∗kn . φk (1) = k1 ! . . . kn ! 1 k1 +...+kn =k
Since the functions λk11 . . . λknn with k1 + . . . + kn = k form a system of generators for the k-th power of the maximal ideal in the local ring O0 of germs n of holomorphic functions in the point 0 ∈ C , then from the the results of the previous section it follows that: Proposition 2.12. Let T be a commuting n-contraction of finite rank. Then one has dim ker φk (1) = dim H/mk (T )H = dim Hn (T )0 /mk Hn (T )0 and therefore dim ker φk (1) is a polynomial on k of degree, equal to the dimension of the O0 -module Hn (T )0 (i.e. to the dimension of σF (T ) near the origine).
48
Levy
IEOT
In [2], prop. 7.2, it is proved that rank 1 − φk (1) is a polynomial of k of degree ≤ n. The degree of this polynomial is called the degree of the module H and is denoted by deg H. Since dim ker φk (1) ≤ rank 1 − φk (1) , we get the following Corollary 2.13. Under the assumptions of prop. 2.12 deg H ≥ dim Hn (T )0 . Remark 2.14. Suppose that the essential spectrum of T is contained in the unit n sphere in C . Applying an appropriate M¨ obius transform to the contraction T (see [13]), we can replace in the statement above the point 0 by an arbitrary point in the open ball Bn . One can conjecture that the degree of a pure finite-rank contraction coincides with the maximal degree of the corresponding analytic modules, i.e. with the dimension of the support of Hn (T ); this problem is to be considered elsewhere. In [2] Arveson introduced the notion of a graded n-contraction as a contraction endowed with a suitable action of the circle group (for the precise definition see section 6 of [2]). Then, roughly speaking, the Fredholm spectrum and the corn responding homology sheaves are determined by homogeneous polynomials in C . In this case the inequality of the proposition above becomes an equality: Proposition 2.15. Let T be a pure graded finite-rank contraction in the Hilbert space H. Then deg H = dimO0 Hn (T )0 , and the leading terms of the polynomial rank 1 − φk (1) and the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of Hn (T )0 coincide. Proof. The assertion follows almost immediately from the proof of theorem B of [2]. Indeed, Arveson constructs a submodule H0 of finite codimension in H such that 1H0 − φk0 (1H0 ) is a (finite-dimensional) projection for any k, φk0 (A) being the Arveson‘s completely positive map for the submodule H0 . Therefore rank 1H0 − φk0 (1H0 ) = dim ker φk0 (1H0 ) and the equality above is satisfied for the submodule H0 . On the other hand, corollary 1 of theorem C of [2] shows that for k sufficiently big the polynomials rank 1H0 − φk0 (1H0 ) and rank 1H − φk (1H ) differ by a polynomial of degree strictly less than deg H. (Formally, this is stated only in the case when deg H = n, but it is easy to see that the proof works in the general case as well.) A similar statement is true for the right hand side. Indeed, the arguments used in the proof of 2.8 lead to the exact sequence 0 → Hn (H0 )0 → Hn (H)0 → Hn (H/H0 )0 → 0. Since H/H0 is finite-dimensional, then the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of Hn (H/H0 )0 is of degree zero and the additivity property (see prop. II.10 of [17])
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
49
shows that the Hilbert-Samuel polynomials of Hn (H0 ) and Hn (H) differ by a polynomial of lower degree and therefore have identical leading terms. Now, since the statement of the proposition is valid for H0 , then it is valid for H also.
3. Weyl spectrum for commuting n-tuples of operators Proposition 3.1. Let λ0 ∈ σF (T ). Then the following assertions are equivalent: 1) zλ0 (T ) = 0, 2) zλmax (T ) = 0 for λ sufficiently close to λ0 . Proof. Suppose that zλ0 (T ) = 0, i.e. lp (T ) = 0 for any ideal p ∈ Iso H(T )λ0 . Then, as in the proof of 2.2, one can show that lP (T ) = 0 for any irreducible component of σF (T ), containing λ0 . Conversely, suppose that 2) is satisfied in a neighborhood U of λ0 and P is an arbitrary irreducible component of σF (T ) containing λ0 . One can choose a point λ ∈ P ∩ U such that no other irreducible component of σF (T ) contains λ. Then the condition 2) in the point λ implies that lP (T ) = 0, and 1) holds true. Definition 3.2. We call the point λ0 ∈ σF (T ) a Weyl point for the n-tuple of commuting operators T if the conditions of the proposition above are fulfilled. We will denote by ρω (T ) the set of all Weyl points of T , and by ω(T ) – the Weyl spectrum of T , i.e. the complement of ρω (T ) in σ(T ). Note that in this definition, unlike in the standard one, in the case of a single operator the isolated points of the Fredholm spectrum are not Weyl points. If the n-tuple T possesses SVEP, then zλ0 (T ) = (−1)n z (Hn (T )λ0 ) and therefore (−1)n lP (T ) = 0 for any irreducible components P of σF (T ). In this case ω(T ) = σe (T ) and T has ”Weyl property”. One can derive a criterion for Weyl points using the Banach-space characteristics of the tuple T considered above. Let λ0 ∈ σF (T ), and let P1 , . . . , Ps be the irreducible components of σF (T ) containing λ0 , with dimensions r1 , . . . , rs corr. Let U be a neighborhood of λ0 not intersecting other irreducible components. Take / Pj for j = i. Choose coordinate sysλ1 , . . . , λs ∈ U such that λi ∈ Pi and λi ∈ n tem in C such that the set of coordinates contains local coordinate systems for any of the components Pi , i = 1, . . . , s in U . Now from propositions 2.5 and 3.1 we obtain the following characterization of the Weyl points using the local Euler characteristics: Proposition 3.3. λ0 is a Weyl point iff all χ T , λi = 0, i = 1, . . . , s. The functoriality of z(T ), stated in theorem 2.3, implies the functorial properties of ω(T ). Proposition 3.4. Let f (λ) = (f1 (λ) , . . . , fk (λ)) be a k-tuple of holomorphic functions, defined in the neighborhood of the spectrum σ(T ) of T . Then ω (f (T )) ⊂ f (ω(T )).
50
Levy
IEOT
Proof. Take a point µ0 ∈ / f (ω(T )). Then f −1 µ0 , if non-empty, is a finite subset of ρω (T ) and the same is true for the points µ in a sufficiently small neighborhood of µ0 . Then from theorems 2.3 and 3.1 it follows that µ0 ∈ ρω (f (T )). In some particular cases the spectral inclusion in the proposition above can be replaced by equality. Indeed, the following proposition follows immediately from 2.3 in the same way as above: Proposition 3.5. Suppose that one of the following two conditions is satisfied: a) f (z) is monomorphic on σ(T ), or b) the operator T has SVEP. Then ω(f (T )) = f (ω(T )).
References [1] W. Arveson, Subalgebras of C ∗ -algebras III – Multivariate operator theory, Acta Math. 181(2) (1998), 159–228. [2] W. Arveson, The curvature invariant of a Hilbert module over C [z1 , . . . , zd ], J. Reine Angew. Math. 522 (2000), 173–236. [3] X. Chen, K. Guo Analytic Hilbert modules, Chapman& Hall/CRC, 2003. [4] R.G.Douglas, K. Yan, Hilbert-Samuel polynomials for Hilbert modules, Indiana Univ. Math. J., 42(3) (1993), 811–820. [5] D. Eisenbud, Commutative algebra, with a view toward algebraic geometry, Graduate texts in mathematics 150, Springer-Verlag. 1998. [6] J. Eschmeier, On the Hilbert-Samuel multiplicity of Fredholm tuples, Preprint Nr. 163, Universit¨ at des Saarlandes, Saarbr¨ ucken 2006. [7] J. Eschmeier, Samuel multiplicity for several commuting operators, Preprint Nr. 171, Universit¨ at des Saarlandes, Saarbr¨ ucken 2006. [8] J. Eschmeier, Fredholm spectrum and growth of cohomoly groups, Preprint Nr. 181, Universit¨ at des Saarlandes, Saarbr¨ ucken 2006. [9] X. Fang, The Fredholm index of quotient Hilbert modules, Math. Res. Letters, 12 (2005), 911–920. [10] X. Fang, The Fredholm index of a pair of commuting operators, Geometric And Functional Analysis, 16 (2) (2006), 367–402. [11] J. Gleason, S. Richter, C. Sundberg, On the index of invariant subspaces in spaces of analytic functions of several complex variables, J. Reine Angew. Math. 587 (2005), 49–76. [12] H. Grauert, R. Remmert, Analytic Local Algebras, Springer-Verlag, 1971. [13] D. Greene, Free resolutions in multivariate operator theory, J. Funct. An., 200(2)(2003), 429–450. [14] K. Guo, K. Wang, Essentially normal Hilbert modules and K-homology, Preprint. [15] R. Levy, Algebraic and topological K-functors of commuting n-tuple of operators, J. Operator Theory 21 (1989), 219–253.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Fredholm and Weyl Spectra of Commuting Operators
51
[16] M. Putinar, On Weyl spectrum in several variables, Math. Japon. 50, n.3 (1999),335– 357. [17] J.-P. Serre, Algebre Locale et Multiplicites, Springer-Verlag, 1975. [18] J.L. Taylor, The analytic functional calculus for several commuting operators, Acta Math., 125 (1970), 1–48 R. Levy Sofia University Faculty of Mathematics and Informatics Bd. J. Bourchier 5 Sofia 1164 Bulgaria e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: May 4, 2006 Revised: January 5, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 53–65 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010053-13, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1508-y
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Schatten Class Hankel Operators on the Harmonic Bergman Space of the Unit Ball Jie Miao Abstract. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for Hankel operators Hf on the harmonic Bergman space of the unit ball to be in the Schatten p-class for 2 ≤ p < ∞. A special case when symbol f is a harmonic function is also considered. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35; Secondary 47B32. Keywords. Hankel operator, Toeplitz operator, commutator, Schatten class operator.
1. Introduction Let Bn denote the open unit ball in Rn for n ≥ 2 and let V denote the usual Lebesgue measure on Bn , normalized so that V (Bn ) = 1. Let L2 (Bn ) denote the set of all measurable functions f on Bn such that 1/2 2 |f (x)| dV (x) < ∞. f = Bn
The harmonic Bergman space L2h (Bn ) is the set of all harmonic functions on Bn that are also in L2 (Bn ). It is easy to see that L2h (Bn ) is a closed subspace of L2 (Bn ). We denote the orthogonal projection from L2 (Bn ) onto L2h (Bn ) by Q. Let R(x, y) denote the reproducing kernel for L2h (Bn ). Thus for any f ∈ L2 (Bn ) Q(f )(x) = f (y)R(x, y) dV (y), x ∈ Bn . Bn
There is a formula in closed form for R(x, y) (see [2]). The reproducing kernel R is real valued, but it can vanish on Bn × Bn . For f ∈ L2 (Bn ), let Mf denote the multiplication operator defined by Mf (g) = f g. The Hankel operator Hf is defined I am thankful to the referee for references [5] and [6].
54
Miao
IEOT
on L2 (Bn ) by Hf = (I − Q)Mf Q, the Topeplitz operator Tf is defined on L2h (Bn ) by Tf = QMf , and the commutator Cf is defined on L2 (Bn ) by Cf = Mf Q−QMf . Boundedness, compactness, and trace ideal criteria for Hankel operators on the analytic Bergman space of the unit ball in Cn have been well studied. Because of similarities between the analytic and harmonic Bergman spaces, it is natural to ask whether similar criteria can be established for Hankel operators Hf on the harmonic Bergman space L2h (Bn ). Some analogous results have been established in [13], and in [17] for the case n = 2. In [13], a necessary and sufficient condition is given for Hf to be bounded or compact on L2 (Bn ), and a question is raised about a necessary and sufficient condition for Hf to belong to the Schatten p-class. In this paper, we answer that question for 2 ≤ p < ∞. We also consider the special case when f ∈ L2h (Bn ). This paper is organized as follows. The main results are introduced in this section. We will also compare our results with those from [6] and [18]. Most of the necessary lemmas are given in Section 2, and the proof for the main results is given in Section 3. For r ∈ (0, 1) and x ∈ Bn , let Br (x) = {y ∈ Bn : |y − x| < r(1 − |x|)}. Let |Br (x)| denote V (Br (x)). There is a constant Cn > 0 depending on n only such that |Br (x)| = Cn rn (1 − |x|)n . For f ∈ L2 (Bn ), let 1 |f (y)|2 dV (y) MVr (f, x) = |Br (x)| Br (x) 2 1 1 f (z) dV (z) dV (y). MOr (f, x) = f (y) − |Br (x)| Br (x) |Br (x)| Br (x) Let f˜ denote the Berezin transform of f with respect to the reproducing kernel R: f˜(x) = R(x, x)−1 f (y)|R(x, y)|2 dV (y) B
and let MO(f, x) = (|f |2 )˜(x) − |f˜(x)|2 . For 0 < p < ∞ and a Hilbert space H, let Sp (H) (it will be simply denoted by Sp later) denote the Schatten p-class that consists of all compact operators T on H such that the sequence of the singular numbers sn (T ) = inf{T − K : rank K ≤ n} p
belongs to l . As is well known, Sp (H) is a two-sided ideal in the set of all bounded linearoperators on H. If T ∈ S1 (H) and {ek }∞ k=1 is an orthonormal basis for H, ∞ then k=1 T ek , ek converges absolutely and is independent of the choice of {ek }. This value is called the trace of T and is denoted tr(T ). If T is a compact operator on H, then Tp ∈ Sp (H) if and only if (T ∗ T )p/2 ∈ S1 (H). Before introducing our main results, we should mention some related results from [6] and [18]. Let B2n denote the unit ball in Cn (i.e. B2n is the unit ball in R2n ) and let P denote the orthogonal projection from L2 (B2n ) onto the analytic
Vol. 59 (2007)
Schatten Class Hankel Operators
55
Bergman space L2a (B2n ) (which is the set of all analytic functions on B2n that are in L2 (B2n )). The Hankel operator Hfa is defined on L2 (B2n ) by Hfa = (I − P )Mf P and let MOa (f, z) (for z ∈ B2n ) be defined exactly like MO(f, x) except using the reproducing kernel 1 K(z, w) = (1 − z, w)n+1 instead of R(x, y). The main results of [18] are the following two theorems. Theorem A. Suppose f ∈ L2 (B2n ) and 2 ≤ p < ∞. Then both Hfa and Hfa¯ are in Sp if and only if MOa (f, z)p/2 dV (z) < ∞. n+1 B2n (1 − |z|) Theorem B. Suppose f ∈ L2a (B2n ) and n ≥ 2. Then (1) For 0 < p ≤ 2n, Hfa¯ ∈ Sp if and only if f is a constant. (2) For 2n < p < ∞, Hfa¯ ∈ Sp if and only if ˜ |2 (z)|p/2 ||f dV (z) < ∞, n+1 B2n (1 − |z|) ˜ denotes the invariant Lapacian on B2n . where We point out that when n = 1, a result similar to Theorem B is given in [3], and in that case, the largest p such that Sp contains only zero Hankel operators Hf¯, if f is analytic, is 1 (instead of 2). With our results, it is more understandable why this gap occurs. Beatrous and Li [6] extend Theorem A from the unit ball to more general strictly pseudoconvex domains in Cn . In fact they obtain a sufficient condition for commutators to be in Sp for p ≥ 2 when the underlying domain can be identified as X × (0, ∞) via a diffeomorphism (assuming that X has a homogeneous structure). The unit ball Bn is clearly such a domain. If the underlying domain is Bn and if the kernel function is the reproducing kernel R(x, y) in Theorem 1.5 of [6], then their result becomes the following: Theorem C. Suppose f ∈ L2 (Bn ) and 2 ≤ p < ∞. If MO(f, x)p/2 dV (x) < ∞, n Bn (1 − |x|)
(1.1)
then Hf ∈ Sp . The following are our main results. Theorem 1.1. Suppose f ∈ L2 (Bn ), 2 ≤ p < ∞, and 0 < r < 1. Then Hf ∈ Sp if and only if MOr (f, x)p/2 dV (x) < ∞. (1.2) (1 − |x|)n Bn
56
Miao
IEOT
Theorem 1.2. Suppose f ∈ L2h (Bn ) and n ≥ 3. Then (1) For 0 < p ≤ n − 1, Hf ∈ Sp if and only if f is a constant. (2) For n − 1 < p < ∞, Hf ∈ Sp if and only if | f (x)|p (1 − |x|)p dV (x) < ∞. (1 − |x|)n Bn When n = 2, both (1) and (2) of Theorem 1.2 are also true according to Theorems 4.2 and 5.1 in [17]. Now we make some comments on the relevance of conditions (1.1) and (1.2). Since 1 |f (y) − f (z)|2 |R(x, y)|2 |R(x, z)|2 dV (y) dV (z), MO(f, x) = 2R(x, x)2 Bn Bn for each r ∈ (0, 1), by Lemmas 1 and 2 in [11], there is a constant C > 0 (depending on r) such that C MO(f, x) ≥ |f (y) − f (x)|2 dV (z) dV (y) = 2C MOr (f, x). |Br (x)|2 Br (x) Br (x) This shows that (1.1) implies (1.2). Unfortunately, we are not able to give a proof that (1.2) implies (1.1) for 2 < p < ∞. The case p = 2 (the case for Hilbert-Schmidt operators) is of course well known. In other words, we can not prove that (1.1) is also necessary for Hf ∈ Sp in general. A similar question was raised in [18] (see page 166). Zhu asked, if MOa (f, z) is replaced by MOar (f, z) (which is defined in the same way as MOr (f, x) except using the Bergman metric balls instead of the usual Euclidean balls), whether the condition in Theorem A is also sufficient for both Hfa and Hfa¯ to be in Sp .
2. Preparations In this section, we introduce a variety of lemmas in order to prove Theorems 1.1 and 1.2. From now on, we use B to denote the unit ball Bn for simplicity. For f , g ∈ L2 (B), let f, g denote B f g¯ dV . Let (L2h (B))⊥ denote the set {f ∈ L2 (B) : f, g = 0 for all g ∈ L2h (B)} and let Cc2 (B) denote the set of all C 2 functions on B with compact support. We note that the range of Hf is in (L2h (B))⊥ . The following two lemmas are given in Section 4 of [11]. Lemma 2.1. (L2h (B))⊥ = L2 -closure of {h, h ∈ Cc2 (B)}. Lemma 2.2. There are constants C1 , C2 > 0 such that |h(x)|2 | h(x)|2 dV (x) ≤ C dV (x) ≤ C | h(x)|2 dV (x) 1 2 4 2 (1 − |x|) (1 − |x|) B B B for all h ∈ Cc2 (B). The following lemma comes from Green’s identity easily.
(2.1)
Vol. 59 (2007)
Schatten Class Hankel Operators
57
Lemma 2.3. Suppose f ∈ C 1 (B), h ∈ Cc2 (B), and u ∈ L2h (B). Then f u, h = −u, f · h + f · u, h. Based on the identity Cf = Hf ⊕ (−Hf¯)∗ and the fact that the reproducing kernel R(x, y) is real valued, we have the following lemma. Lemma 2.4. Let p ∈ (0, ∞) and f ∈ L2 (B). Then Cf ∈ Sp if and only if Hf ∈ Sp . The following lemma is stated as Lemma 5 in [13]. Lemma 2.5. Let r ∈ (0, 1) and x ∈ B. If y ∈ Br/3 (x), then Br/3 (y) ⊂ Br (x) and Br/3 (x) ⊂ Br (y). In fact the proof of Lemma 5 in [13] indicates that if y ∈ Br/3 (x), then Br/3 (y) ⊂ Br (x) and Br/3 (x) ⊂ Br (y). Now we introduce some properties on MOr (f, x). If y ∈ Br (x), then it is easy to see that (1 − r)(1 − |x|) < 1 − |y| < (1 + r)(1 − |x|). Throughout the paper, all constants that do not depend on variables will be simply denoted by C, whose value may change from one place to another. Lemma 2.6. Let f ∈ L2 (B) and r, s ∈ (0, 1). Then there is a constant C > 0 such that MOr (f, x) ≤ C MOs (f, y) for all x, y ∈ B satisfying Br (x) ⊂ Bs (y). Proof. If Br (x) ⊂ Bs (y), then 1 − |x| ≥ (1 − s)(1 − |y|), hence |Br (x)| ≥ C|Bs (y)|. The following identity 1 MOr (f, x) = |f (y) − f (z)|2 dV (y) dV (z) 2|Br (x)|2 Br (x) Br (x) gives the conclusion of the lemma immediately.
In particular, Lemma 2.6 implies that MOr (f, x) ≤ C MOs (f, x) if r < s. The following lemma comes from inequality (4.2) in [13]. Lemma 2.7. Let f ∈ L2 (B). Then there are some small r ∈ (0, 1) and a constant C > 0 such that 2 χBr (x) , x ∈ B. MOr (f, x) ≤ C Cf 1/2 |Br (x)| The following lemma is given in the proof for Lemma 6 in [13]. Lemma 2.8. Let f ∈ L2 (B) and r ∈ (0, 1). Then (1) There are a constant C > 0 and functions f1 and f2 with f2 ∈ C 1 (B) such that f = f1 + f2 , and MVr/3 (f1 , x) ≤ C MOr (f, x), | f2 (x)|(1 − |x|) ≤ C MOr (f, x)1/2 , x ∈ B. (2) MOr (f, x) ≤ 4 MVr (f, x) for all x ∈ B.
58
Miao
IEOT
(3) MOr (f, x)1/2 ≤ (2r/(1 − r)) supz∈Br (x) | f (z)(1 − |z|) for all x ∈ B if f ∈ C 1 (B). Lemma 2.9. Let r ∈ (0, 1). Then there is a constant C > 0 such that |f (x)|2 | u(x)|2 (1 − |x|)2 dV (x) ≤ C MVr (f, x) |u(x)|2 dV (x) B
(2.2)
B
for all u ∈ L2h (B) and f ∈ L2 (B). Proof. If u is harmonic on B, then for y ∈ B C 2 |u(y)| ≤ |u(z)|2 dV (z). (1 − |y|)n Br/9 (y) If y ∈ Br/9 (x), then Br/9 (y) ⊂ Br/3 (x) by Lemma 2.5. Cauchy’s Estimate for harmonic functions gives C C 2 2 | u(x)| ≤ sup |u(y)| ≤ |u(z)|2 dV (z). (1 − |x|)2 y∈Br/9 (x) (1 − |x|)n+2 Br/3 (x) Let U (x) denote | u(x)|2 (1 − |x|)2 . Then by Fubini’s Theorem χBr/3 (x) (z)|f (x)|2 2 |f (x)| U (x) dV (x) ≤ C dV (x) |u(z)|2 dV (z). n (1 − |x|) B B B Lemma 2.5 implies that χBr/3 (x) (z) ≤ χBr (z) (x). Thus |f (x)|2 2 |f (x)| U (x) dV (x) ≤ C dV (x) |u(z)|2 dV (z). n (1 − |x|) B B Br (z) Since (1 − |x|)n ≥ C|Br (z)| for x ∈ Br (z), inequality (2.2) now follows.
2
Lemma 2.10. Let p ∈ [2, ∞). Suppose T1 , T2 ∈ Sp (L (B)) and T3 is a bounded linear operator on L2 (B). If there is a constant C > 0 such that T3 f ≤ C[T1 f + T2 f ] 2
for all f ∈ L (B), then T3 ∈ Sp (L2 (B)). Proof. It is easy to see that T3 is a compact operator on L2 (B). Let {ek }∞ k=1 be an orthonormal set in L2 (B). Then by Minkowski’s inequality ∞ 1/p 1/p ∞ 1/p ∞
. T3 ek p ≤C T1 ek p + T2 ek p k=1
k=1
k=1 2
It follows from Theorem 1.4.9 in [19] that T3 ∈ Sp (L (B)).
We will need to establish a discrete version of Theorem 1.1. In order to do that, we introduce a terminology that has been used in [7]. A sequence of points {xk }∞ k=1 in B is said to be a lattice if there is some δ ∈ (0, 1) such that (i) Bδ/3 (xk ) Bδ/3 (xj ) = ∅ when k = j (in this case, the sequence {xk } is said to be separated);
Vol. 59 (2007)
Schatten Class Hankel Operators
59
(ii) ∞ k=1 Bδ (xk ) = B. We state the following fact as a lemma whose proof is similar to that given for Lemma on Coverings in [14] and will be omitted. Lemma 2.11. If {xk } is a lattice, then for each r ∈ (0, 1), there is a positive integer N that depends on r such that every Br (xj ) intersects at most N balls of {Br (xk )}. Let µ be a positive Borel measure on B and f ∈ L1 (B, µ). Lemma 2.11 has the following implication. If {xk } is a lattice (hence there is some δ ∈ (0, 1) such B (x that ∞ k=1 δ k ) = B), then for each r ∈ (0, 1), there is a constant C > 0 such that ∞ ∞
C |f (x)| dµ(x) ≤ |f (x)| dµ(x) ≤ |f (x)| dµ(x). k=1
Br (xk )
B
k=1
Bδ (xk )
Now we introduce a trace ideal criterion on the multiplication operator Mf |L2h (B) . Our approach here is analogous to that used in [10]. According to Theorem 1.4.6 in [19] and the following identity Mf∗ Mf = T|f |2 : L2h (B) → L2h (B) we see that Mf |L2h (B) ∈ Sp if and only if T|f |2 ∈ Sp/2 . Thus we can formulate Theorem 11 in [11] as the following lemma with a minor change in the statement. Lemma 2.12. Let p ∈ [2, ∞) and r ∈ (0, 1). Then Mf |L2h (B) ∈ Sp if and only if ∞
MVr (f, xk )p/2 < ∞ for all lattices {xk }. k=1
The lemma above indicates that the convergence of independent of r ∈ (0, 1).
∞
k=1
MVr (f, xk )p/2 is
3. Proof of Theorems In order to prove Theorem 1.1, we first establish the following result. Theorem 3.1. Let 2 ≤ p < ∞. Then Hf ∈ Sp if and only if there is some r ∈ (0, 1) ∞
such that MOr (f, xk )p/2 < ∞ for all lattices {xk }. k=1
Proof. We first assume Hf ∈ Sp . Then by Lemma 2.4, Cf ∈ Sp . According to Lemma 2.7, there is some r ∈ (0, 1) such that 2 χBr (x) . C MOr (f, x) ≤ C (3.1) f 1/2 |Br (x)| 2 Let {xk } be a lattice and let {ek }∞ k=1 be an orthonormal basis for L (B). Let A 2 be a linear operator defined on L (B) by χBr (xk ) . A(ek ) = |Br (xk )|1/2
60
Miao
IEOT
For any sequence of numbers {αk } ∈ l2 , Lemma 2.11 implies that there is a positive 1/2 integer N such that for every x ∈ B, ∞ has at most k=1 αk χBr (xk ) (x)/|Br (xk )| N nonzero terms in the sum. Thus by Schwarz inequality, 2 ∞ 2 ∞ ∞
χBr (xk ) χBr (xk ) A . α e = α ≤ N |αk |2 k k k |Br (xk )| |Br (xk )|1/2 k=1
k=1
k=1
This implies that A(g) ≤ N 1/2 g for all g ∈ L2 (B), hence A is a bounded operator on L2 (B). Therefore A∗ (Cf∗ Cf )p/2 A ∈ S1 and tr(A∗ (Cf∗ Cf )p/2 A) =
∞
A∗ (Cf∗ Cf )p/2 A(ek ), ek < ∞.
k=1
Since p/2 ≥ 1, by inequality (6.4) in [3] we have tr(A∗ (Cf∗ Cf )p/2 A) ≥
∞
Cf∗ Cf A(ek ), A(ek )p/2 =
k=1
∞
Cf A(ek )p .
k=1
Now it follows from (3.1) that ∞
MOr (f, xk )p/2 ≤ C
k=1
∞
Cf A(ek )p ≤ C tr(A∗ (Cf∗ Cf )p/2 A) < ∞.
k=1
This proves one implication of the theorem. the other implication. Assume there is a r ∈ (0, 1) such that ∞ Next we prove p/2 MO (f, x ) < ∞ for any lattice {xk }. By Lemma 2.8 (1), there are funcr k k=1 tions f1 and f2 such that f = f1 + f2 (f2 ∈ C 1 (B)), and MVr/9 (f1 , x) ≤ C MOr/3 (f, x), | f2 (x)|(1 − |x|) ≤ C MOr/3 (f, x)1/2 .
(3.2)
It follows that for any lattice {xk } ∞
k=1
MVr/9 (f1 , xk )p/2 ≤ C
∞
MOr/3 (f, xk )p/2 ≤ C
k=1
∞
MOr (f, xk )p/2 < ∞,
k=1
where the second inequality comes from Lemma 2.6. Therefore by Lemma 2.12, Mf1 |L2h (B) ∈ Sp , hence Hf1 = (I − Q)Mf1 Q ∈ Sp . We now need to show that Hf2 ∈ Sp . For h ∈ Cc2 (B) and u ∈ L2h (B), it follows from Lemma 2.3 that |Hf2 (u), h| ≤ |u, f2 · h| + | f2 · u, h|. Let f3 (x) denote | f2 (x)|(1 − |x|) and let f4 (x) denote MVr/9 (f3 , x)1/2 . By Schwarz inequality, we have | f2 · h| ≤ | f2 | | h|, and H¨ older’s inequality now gives |u, f2 · h| ≤ Mf3 (u) h/(1 − |x|).
Vol. 59 (2007)
Schatten Class Hankel Operators
61
Thus by (2.1), we have |u, f2 · h| ≤ CMf3 (u) h. By a similar argument, we can get | f2 · u, h| ≤ f3 u(1 − |x|) h/(1 − |x|)2 . Now applying Lemma 2.9 to the first factor and (2.1) to the second one on the right-hand side of the inequality above, we obtain | f2 · u, h| ≤ CMf4 (u) h. By Lemma 2.1 and the inequalities above, we have Hf2 (u) ≤ C[Mf3 (u) + Mf4 (u)],
u ∈ L2h (B).
According to Lemma 2.10, our proof will be complete if we can show both Mf3 |L2h (B) and Mf4 |L2h (B) belong to Sp . For z ∈ Br/3 (x), by Lemma 2.5, Br/3 (z) ⊂ Br (x), thus by (3.2) f3 (z) ≤ C MOr/3 (f, z)1/2 ≤ C MOr (f, x)1/2 . This implies that MVr/3 (f3 , x) =
1
|Br/3 (x)|
Br/3 (x)
(3.3)
[f3 (z)]2 dV (z) ≤ C MOr (f, x).
Furthermore if y ∈ Br/9 (x), then Br/9 (y) ⊂ Br/3 (x) (again by Lemma 2.5), hence according to (3.3) 1 [f4 (y)]2 = [f3 (z)]2 dV (z) ≤ C MOr (f, x). |Br/9 (y)| Br/9 (y) This gives MVr/9 (f4 , x) =
1 |Br/9 (x)|
Br/9 (x)
[f4 (y)]2 dV (y) ≤ C MOr (f, x).
We now conclude that for any lattice {xk }, ∞
MVr/3 (f3 , xk )p/2 ≤ C
k=1 ∞
∞
MOr (f, xk )p/2 < ∞,
k=1
MVr/9 (f4 , xk )p/2 ≤ C
k=1
∞
MOr (f, xk )p/2 < ∞.
k=1
According to Lemma 2.12, both M | of the theorem is complete.
f3 L2h (B)
and Mf4 |L2h (B) are in Sp , and the proof
The proof of Theorem 1.1 will be complete after the following lemma is established. Throughout the rest of the paper, let dλ(x) denote (1 − |x|)−n dV (x).
62
Miao
Lemma 3.2. Let 2 ≤ p < ∞. Then and only if
∞
p/2
MOr (f, xk )
B
IEOT
MOr (f, x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞ for all r ∈ (0, 1) if
< ∞ for some r ∈ (0, 1) and for all lattices {xk }.
k=1
Proof. One implication of the lemma is easy to prove. Suppose MO1/2 (f, x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞. B
Let {xk } be a lattice. If x ∈ B1/6 (xk ), then B1/6 (xk ) ⊂ B1/2 (x) (by Lemma 2.5), thus MO1/6 (f, xk ) ≤ C MO1/2 (f, x) (by Lemma 2.6). Therefore ∞ ∞
p/2 MO1/6 (f, xk ) ≤C MO1/2 (f, x)p/2 dλ(x) B1/6 (xk )
k=1
k=1 ≤C MO1/2 (f, x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞. B
Now we prove the other implication. Suppose there is some r0 ∈ (0, 1) such ∞ that k=1 MOr0 (f, xk )p/2 < ∞ for all lattices {xk }. By Lemma 2.8 (1), there are f1 and f2 such that f = f1 + f2 , and MVr0 /3 (f1 , x) ≤ C MOr0 (f, x),
| f2 (x)|(1 − |x|) ≤ C MOr0 (f, x)1/2 .
Thus for any lattice {xk }, ∞
k=1
MVr0 /3 (f1 , xk )p/2 ≤ C
∞
MOr0 (f1 , xk )p/2 < ∞,
k=1
∞
hence by Lemma 2.12, k=1 MVr (f1 , xk )p/2 < ∞ for any r ∈ (0, 1). Now Lemma 11 of [11] gives B MVr (f1 , x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞, therefore according to Lemma 2.8 (2) MOr (f1 , x)p/2 dλ(x) ≤ 2p MVr (f1 , x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞. B Thus we only need to show that B MOr (f2 , x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞ for any r ∈ (0, 1) because of the inequality B
MOr (f, x)1/2 ≤ MOr (f1 , x)1/2 + MOr (f2 , x)1/2 . For each r ∈ (0, 1), there is a s ∈ (0, 1) small enough so that y∈Bs (x) Br (y) ⊂ Bt (x) for some t ∈ (0, 1). Hence MOr (f2 , y)p/2 dλ(y) ≤ C MOt (f2 , x)p/2 . Bs (x)
Now let {xk } be a lattice such that ∪∞ k=1 Bs (xk ) = B. Then ∞ ∞
MOr (f2 , x)p/2 dλ(x) ≤ MOr (f2 , x)p/2 dλ(x) ≤ C MOt (f2 , xk )p/2 . B
k=1
Bs (xk )
k=1
Vol. 59 (2007)
Schatten Class Hankel Operators
63
By Lemma 2.8 (3), for each xk , there is some yk ∈ Bt (xk ) such that MOt (f2 , xk )1/2 ≤ C| f2 (yk )|(1 − |yk |). By Lemma 2.11, it is easy to see that {yk } is a finite union of separated sequences, hence ∞ ∞ ∞
MOt (f2 , xk )p/2 ≤ C | f2 (yk )|p (1 − |yk |)p ≤ MOr0 (f, yk )p/2 < ∞. k=1
This proves that lemma.
k=1
B
k=1 p/2
MOr (f2 , x)
dλ(x) < ∞ and completes the proof of the
Part (2) of Theorem 1.2 follows from Theorem 1.1 and the following lemma. Lemma 3.3. Let f ∈ L2h (B), 2 ≤ p < ∞, and 0 < r < 1. Then the following conditions are equivalent: MOr (f, x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞. (1) B (2) | f (x)|p (1 − |x|)p dλ(x) < ∞. B
Proof. (1) ⇒ (2). This direction follows immediately from the following inequality | f (x)|(1 − |x|) ≤ C MOr (f, x)1/2 , x ∈ B. (This inequality can be easily proved. See for example the proof of Lemma 7 in [13]). (2) ⇒ (1). Suppose f ∈ L2h (B) and B | f (x)|p (1 − |x|)p dλ(x) < ∞. By the mean-value inequality for harmonic functions, we have for each k = 1, 2, . . . , n, p p |fxk (y)| dλ(y) ≤ C | f (y)|p dλ(y) |fxk (x)| ≤ C Br (x)
Br (x)
for all x ∈ B. Therefore
p/2 | f (x)|p = |fx1 (x)|2 + |fx2 (x)|2 + · · · + |fxn (x)|2 ≤ np/2−1 (|fx1 (x)|p + |fx2 (x)|p + · · · + |fxn (x)|p ) ≤C | f (y)|p dλ(y). Br (x)
Thus for any separated sequence {xk }, ∞
| f (xk )|p (1 − |xk |)p ≤ C
k=1
k=1
hence ∞
k=1
∞
p
p
| f (xk )| (1 − |xk |) ≤ C
B
Br (xk )
| f (y)|p (1 − |y|)p dλ(y),
| f (y)|p (1 − |y|)p dλ(y) < ∞.
(3.4)
64
Miao
IEOT
Now let {yk } be a sequence in B such that B1/3 (yk ) ∩ B1/3 (yj ) = ∅ (k = j). By Lemma 2.8 (3), there is some xk ∈ B1/9 (yk ) such that MO1/9 (f, yk )p/2 ≤ C| f (xk )|p (1 − |xk |)p . The remark following Lemma 2.5 indicates that B1/9 (xk ) ⊂ B1/3 (yk ), thus {xk } is also separated. It follows from (3.4) that ∞
MO1/9 (f, yk )p/2 ≤ C
k=1
∞
| f (xk )|p (1 − |xk |)p < ∞.
k=1
It is easy to see that the inequality above holds for any lattice {yk } because it is a finite union of such sequences according to Lemma 2.11. Now Lemma 3.2 immediately implies that B MOr (f, x)p/2 dλ(x) < ∞. Finally let us prove part (1) of Theorem 1.2. Suppose n ≥ 3 and 0 < p ≤ n−1. We only need to show that if Hf ∈ Sp , then f is a constant. If Hf ∈ Sp and 0 < p ≤ n − 1, then Hf ∈ Sn−1 because Sp ⊂ Sn−1 for p < n − 1. Since n − 1 ≥ 2, according to Theorem 1.1 and Lemma 3.3, | f (x)|n−1 (1 − |x|)−1 dλ(x) < ∞. B
Let S denote the unit sphere and let σ denote the normalized surface-area measure on S. The polar coordinates formula now gives 1 n−1 r n−1 | f (rζ)| dσ(ζ) dr < ∞. (3.5) 0 1−r S Let M (r) = S | f (rζ)|n−1 dσ(ζ). Since f ∈ L2h (B), then | f (x)|2 =
n
|fxk (x)|2
k=1
is subharmonic on B. This implies that | f (x)|n−1 = (| f (x)|2 )(n−1)/2 is subharmonic on B (because (n−1)/2 ≥ 1). It follows that M (r) is a nondecreasing function of r ∈ [0, 1). Therefore (3.5) implies that M (r) = 0 for all r ∈ [0, 1), hence 1 | f (x)|n−1 dV (x) = n rn−1 M (r) dr = 0. B
0
This show that | f | = 0 on B, thus f is a constant, and we finally complete the proof of Theorem 1.2.
References [1] S. Axler, The Bergman space, the Bloch space, and commutators of multiplication operators, Duke Math. J. 53 (1986), 315–332. [2] S. Axler, P. Bourdon, and W. Ramey, Harmonic function theory, Second Edition, Springer-Verlag, New York, 2001.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Schatten Class Hankel Operators
65
[3] J. Arazy, S. Fisher, J. Peetre, Hankel operators on weighted Bergman spaces, Amer. J. Math. 110 (1988), 989–1054. [4] D. B´ekoll´e, C. A. Berger, L. A. Coburn, and K. H. Zhu, BMO and the Bergman metric on bounded symmetric domains, J. Funct. Anal. 93 (1990), 310–350. [5] F. Beatrous and S. Li, On the Boundedness and compactness of operators of Hankel type, J. Funct. Anal. 111 (1993), 350–379. [6] F. Beatrous and S. Li, Trace ideal creteria for operators of Hankel Type, Illinois J. Math. 39 (1995), 723–754. [7] R.R. Coifman and R. Rochberg, Representation theorems for holomorphic and harmonic functions, Ast´ erisque 77 (1980), 11–65. [8] M. Jovovi´c, Compact Hankel operators on harmonic Bergman spaces, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 22 (1995), 295–304. [9] D. Luecking, Trace Ideal Criteria for Toeplitz Operators, J. Funct. Anal. 73 (1987), 345–368. [10] D. Luecking, Characterizations of certain classes of Hankel operators on the Bergman spaces of the unit disc, J. Funct. Anal. 110 (1992), 247–271. [11] J. Miao, Toeplitz operators on harmonic Bergman spaces, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 27 (1997), 426–438. [12] J. Miao, Hankel type operators on the unit disk, Studia Mathematica 146 (2001), 55–67. [13] J. Miao, Hankel operators on harmonic Bergman spaces of the unit ball, Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 69 (2003), 391–408. [14] V.L. Oleinik, Embedding theorems for weighted classes of harmonic and analytic functions, J. Soviet Math. 2 (1974), 135–142. [15] K. Stroethoff, Compact Hankel operators on weighted harmonic Bergman spaces, Glasgow Math. J. 39 (1997), 77–84. [16] K. Stroethoff and D. Zheng, Toeplitz and Hankel operators on Bergman spaces, Trans. Amer. Soc. 329, (1992), 773–794. [17] Z. Wu, Operators on harmonic Bergman spaces, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 24 (1996), 352–371. [18] K. Zhu, Schatten class Hankel operators on the Bergman space of the unit ball, Amer. J. Math. 113 (1991), 147–167. [19] K. Zhu, Operator Theory in Function Spaces, Marcell-Dekker, New York, 1990. Jie Miao Department of Mathematics and Statistics P.O. Box 70 State University, AR 72467 U.S.A. e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: May 11, 2006 Revised: May 21, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 67–98 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010067-32, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1520-2
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Commutative Algebras of Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains Raul Quiroga-Barranco and Nikolai Vasilevski Abstract. Let D be a bounded logarithmically convex complete Reinhardt domain in Cn centered at the origin. Generalizing a result for the one-dimensional case of the unit disk, we prove that the C ∗ -algebra generated by Toeplitz operators with bounded measurable separately radial symbols (i.e., symbols depending only on |z1 |, |z2 |, . . . , |zn |) is commutative. We show that the natural action of the n-dimensional torus Tn defines (on a certain open full measure subset of D) a foliation which carries a transverse Riemannian structure having distinguished geometric features. Its leaves are equidistant with respect to the Bergman metric, and the orthogonal complement to the tangent bundle of such leaves is integrable to a totally geodesic foliation. Furthermore, these two foliations are proved to be Lagrangian. We specify then the obtained results for the unit ball. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35; Secondary 32A07, 32A36. Keywords. Toeplitz operator, Bergman space, separately radial symbol, Reinhardt domain, commutative C ∗ -algebra.
1. Introduction A family of recently discovered commutative C ∗ -algebras of Toeplitz operators on the unit disk (see for details [12, 13]) can be classified as follows. Each pencil of hyperbolic geodesics determines a set of symbols consisting of functions which are constant on the corresponding cycles, the orthogonal trajectories to geodesics forming a pencil. The C ∗ -algebra generated by Toeplitz operators with such symbols turns out to be commutative. Moreover, these commutative properties do not depend at all on smoothness properties of symbols: the corresponding symbols can be merely measurable. The prime cause appears to be the geometric configuration of level lines of symbols. Further it has been proved in [4] that, assuming some This work was partially supported by CONACYT Projects 46936 and 44620, M´exico.
68
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
natural conditions on the “richness” of the symbol set, the above symbol sets are the only possible which gnerate commutative Toeplitz operator algebras on each (commonly considered) weighted Bergman space on the unit disk. Recall that there are three different types of pencils of hyperbolic geodesics: an elliptic pencil, which is formed by geodesics intersecting in a single point, a parabolic pencil, which is formed by parallel geodesics, and a hyperbolic pencil, which is formed by disjoint geodesics, i.e., by all geodesics orthogonal to a given one. Note, that in all cases the cycles are equidistant in the hyperbolic metric. The model case for elliptic pencils is when the geodesics intersect at the origin. In this case the geodesics are diameters and the cycles are the concentric circles centered at the origin. All other elliptic pencils can be obtained from this model by means of M¨ obius transformations. The commutative Toeplitz C ∗ -algebra for the elliptic model case is generated by Toeplitz operators with radial symbols. As proved in [3], the C ∗ -algebras generated by Toeplitz operators with radial symbols, acting on the weighted Bergman spaces over the unit ball Bn , are commutative as well. In the present paper, we consider a more deep and natural multidimensional analog of the elliptic model pencil on the unit disk. We study Toeplitz operators on weighted Bergman spaces over bounded Reinhardt domains in Cn , and prove, in particular, that the C ∗ -algebra generated by Toeplitz operators with bounded measurable separately radial symbols (i.e., symbols depending only on |z1 |, |z2 |, . . . , |zn |) is commutative. Note that this single result can be also obtained directly by just calculating the matrix elements Ta z p , z q , but we deliberately follow a more general procedure used in all model cases on the unit disk (see, for example, in [12]). This permits us to construct an analog of the Bargman transform (the operator R restricted on the (weighted) Bergman space), obtain the decomposition of the Bergman projection by means of R∗ and R, and prepare these operators for the future use. The second important question treated in the paper is the understanding of an adequate geometric description which generalizes geodesics and cycles of the unit disk to a multidimensional case. Each complete bounded Reinhardt domain D in Cn centered at the origin admits a natural action of the n-dimensional torus Tn , and this action is isometric with respect to the Bergman metric in D. On a certain open full measure subset of D this action defines a foliation whose leaves are all diffeomorphic to Tn . Furthermore, such foliation carries a transverse Riemannian structure having distinguished geometric features. First, the leaves are equidistant with respect to the Bergman metric, and second, the direction perpendicular to the leaves is totally geodesic, every geodesic which starts in the perpendicular direction to a leaf stays perpendicular to all other leaves. Now geometrically: the C ∗ -algebra generated by Toeplitz operators with bounded measurable symbols, which are constant on the leaves of the above foliation, is commutative. We prove also that the orthogonal complement to the tangent bundle of the Tn -orbits is integrable, thus providing a pair of natural orthogonal foliations to a Reinhardt domain. Moreover, it turns out that both foliations are Lagrangian.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
69
It is worth mentioning that the above geometric properties hold for each pencil of geodesics on the unit disk, but do not hold, for example, for the case of Toeplitz operators on the unit ball with radial symbols (the corresponding foliations are not Lagrangian). We show that the unit ball Bn in Cn is the only Reinhardt domain which is, at the same time, bounded symmetric and irreducible. Then, we provide a detailed description of the extrinsic geometry of the foliation by Tn -orbits in the unit ball. In particular, it is shown, through a computation of its second fundamental form, that certain geodesics in this foliation have geodesic curvatures with the same behavior found in the elliptic pencil of the unit disk. We then consider oneparameter families of weighted Bergman spaces in Bn , commonly used in operator theory, and specify the results obtained to this special case. Finally, using C. Fefferman’s expression for the Bergman kernel of strictly pseudoconvex domains, we show that for any bounded complete Reinhardt domain with such pseudoconvexity property, the extrinsic curvature of the foliation coming from the Tn -action has the same asymptotic behavior at (suitable) boundary points as the one observed in the unit ball.
2. Bergman space on the Reinhardt domains Denote by P (0, r), where r = (r1 , . . . , rn ) and each rk > 0, the closed polydisk in Cn centered at the origin: P (0, r) = {z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) : |zk | ≤ rk , k = 1, . . . , n}. Recall (see, for example, [11]) that an open domain D in Cn is called the complete Reinhardt domain centered at the origin if for every its point z the polydisk P (0, τ (z)), where τ (z) = (|z1 |, . . . , |zn |), belongs to D. The set τ (D) = {r = (r1 , . . . , rn ) = (|z1 |, . . . , |zn |) : z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) ∈ D}, which belongs to Rn+ = R+ × · · · × R+ , is called the base of the Reinhardt domain D. The Reinhardt domain D is called logarithmically convex if the set log τ (D) is convex. It is well known (see, for example, [11]) that the Reinhardt domain is logarithmically convex if and only if it is a domain of holomorphy, or if and only if it is a region of convergence of a power series. Let now D be a bounded logarithmically convex complete Reinhardt domain in Cn centered at the origin. Consider a positive measurable function (weight) µ(r) = µ(r1 , . . . , rn ), r ∈ τ (D), such that n µ(|z|)dv(z) = (2π) µ(r)rdr < ∞, D
τ (D)
where dv(z) = dx1 dy1 · · · dxn dyn is the usual Lebesgue measure in Cn , |z| = n (|z1 |, . . . , |zn |), and rdr = k=1 rk drk . We assume as well that the weight-function
70
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
µ(r) is bounded in some neighborhood of the origin and does not vanish in this neighborhood. Introduce the weighted Hilbert space L2 (D, µ) with the scalar product f (z) g(z) µ(|z|) dv(z), f, g = D
and its subspace, the weighted Bergman space A2µ (D), which consists of all functions analytic in D. We denote as well by BD,µ the (orthogonal) Bergman projection of L2 (D, µ) onto A2µ (D). Passing to the polar coordinates zk = tk rk , where tk ∈ T = S 1 , k = 1, . . . , n, and under the identification z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) = (t1 r1 , . . . , tn rn ) = (t, r), where t = (t1 , . . . , tn ) ∈ Tn = T × · · · × T, r = (r1 , . . . , rn ) ∈ τ (D), we have D = Tn × τ (D) and n n dtk dv(z) = rk drk . itk k=1
k=1
That is we have the following decomposition L2 (D, µ) = L2 (Tn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ), where n
L2 (T ) =
n
L2 (T,
k=1
dtk ) itk
and the measure dµ in L2 (τ (D), µ) is given by dµ = µ(r1 , . . . , rn )
n
rk drk .
k=1
We note that the Bergman space A2µ (D) can be alternatively defined as the (closed) subspace of L2 (D, µ) which consists of all functions satisfying the equations ∂ ∂ 1 ∂ ϕ= +i ϕ = 0, k = 1, . . . , n, ∂z k 2 ∂xk ∂yk or, in the polar coordinates, ∂ tk tk ∂ ∂ ϕ= − ϕ = 0, ∂z k 2 ∂rk rk ∂tk
k = 1, . . . , n.
Define the discrete Fourier transform F : L2 (T) → l2 = l2 (Z) by dt 1 f (t) t−n , n ∈ Z. F : f −→ cn = √ it 2π S 1 The operator F is unitary and
1 F −1 = F ∗ : {cn }n∈Z −→ f = √ c n tn . 2π n∈Z
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
71
It is easy to check (see, for example, [12], Subsection 4.1) that the operator t ∂ t ∂ − u = (F ⊗ I) (F −1 ⊗ I) : l2 ⊗ L2 ((0, 1), rdr) −→ l2 ⊗ L2 ((0, 1), rdr) 2 ∂r r ∂t acts as follows u : {ck (r)}k∈Z −→
1 ∂ k−1 − . ck−1 (r) 2 ∂r r k∈Z
Introduce the unitary operator U = F(n) ⊗ I : L2 (Tn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ) −→ l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ), where F(n) = F ⊗ · · · ⊗ F . Then the image A21 = U (A2µ (D)) of the Bergman space is the closed subspace of l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2(τ (D), µ) which consists of all sequences {cp (r)}p∈Zn , r = (r1 , . . . , rn ) ∈ τ (D), satisfying the equations 1 ∂ pk − k = 1, . . . , n. c(p1 ,...,pk ) (r1 , . . . , rn ) = 0, 2 ∂rk rk These equations are easy to solve, and their general solutions have the form cp (r) = αp cp rp ,
p = (p1 , . . . , pn ) ∈ Zn ,
where cp ∈ C, rp = r1p1 · · · · · rnpn , and αp = α|p| ( |p| = (|p1 |, . . . , |pn |), in this occurrence) is given by
− 12 αp
r2|p| µ(r) rdr
= τ (D)
=
τ (D)
2|p | r1 1
· · · · · rn2|pn | µ(r1 , . . . , rn )
n
− 12 rk drk
.
(2.1)
k=1
Recall that each function cp (r) = αp cp rp has to be in L2 (τ (D), µ), which implies that cp = 0 for each p = (p1 , . . . , pn ) such that at least one of pk < 0, k = 1, . . . , n. That is the space A21 ⊂ l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ) coincides with the space of all sequences αp cp rp , p ∈ Zn+ = Z+ × · · · × Z+ , cp (r) = 0, p ∈ Zn \ Zn+ and furthermore {cp (r)}p∈Zn+ l2 (Zn )⊗L2 (τ (D),µ) = {cp }p∈Zn+ l2 (Zn ) . Introduce now the isometric embedding R0 : l2 (Zn+ ) −→ l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ) as follows
R0 : {cp }
p∈Zn +
−→ cp (r) =
αp cp rp , p ∈ Zn+ . 0, p ∈ Zn \ Zn+
72
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
Then the adjoint operator R0∗ : l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ) −→ l2 (Zn ) is defined by
n rp fp (r) µ(r1 , . . . , rn ) rk drk , R0∗ : {fp (r)}p∈Zn −→ αp τ (D)
k=1
p∈Zn +
and it is easy to check that R0∗ R0 = I R0 R0∗ = P1
: l2 (Zn+ ) −→ l2 (Zn+ ), : l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ) −→ A21 ,
where P1 is the orthogonal projection of l2 (Zn ) ⊗ L2 (τ (D), µ) onto A21 . Summarizing the above we have Theorem 2.1. The operator R = R0 U maps L2 (D, µ) onto l2 (Zn+ ), and the restriction R|A2µ (D) : A2µ (D) −→ l2 (Zn+ ) is an isometric isomorphism. The adjoint operator R∗ = U ∗ R0 : l2 (Zn+ ) −→ A2µ (D) ⊂ L2 (D, µ) is the isometrical isomorphism of l2 (Zn+ ) onto the subspace A2µ (D) of L2 (D, µ). Furthermore RR∗ = I R∗ R = BD,µ
: l2 (Zn+ ) −→ l2 (Zn+ ), : L2 (D, µ) −→ A2µ (D),
where BD,µ is the Bergman projection of L2 (D, µ) onto A2µ (D). Theorem 2.2. The isometric isomorphism R∗ = U ∗ R0 : l2 (Zn+ ) −→ A2µ (D) is given by n
R∗ : {cp }p∈Zn+ −→ (2π)− 2
αp cp z p .
(2.2)
p∈Zn +
Proof. Calculate R∗ = U ∗ R0
: =
{cp }p∈Zn+ −→ U ∗ ({αp cp rp }p∈Zn+ ) n n αp cp (tr)p = (2π)− 2 αp cp z p . (2π)− 2 p∈Zn +
p∈Zn +
Corollary 2.3. The inverse isomorphism R : A2µ (D) −→ l2 (Zn+ ) is given by
−n p 2 R : ϕ(z) −→ (2π) αp ϕ(z) z µ(|z|) dv(z) D
p∈Zn +
.
(2.3)
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
73
3. Toeplitz operators with separately radial symbols We will call a function a(z), z ∈ D, separately radial if a(z) = a(r) = a(r1 , . . . , rn ), i.e., a depends only on the radial components of z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) = (t1 r1 , . . . , tn rn ). Theorem 3.1. Let a = a(r) be a bounded measurable separately radial function. Then the Toeplitz operator Ta acting on A2µ (D) is unitary equivalent to the multiplication operator γa I = R Ta R∗ acting on l2 (Zn+ ), where R and R∗ are given by (2.3) and (2.2) respectively. The sequence γa = {γa (p)}p∈Zn+ is as follows n a(r) r2p µ(r1 , . . . , rn ) rk drk , p ∈ Zn+ , (3.1) γa (p) = α2p τ (D)
k=1
where αp is given by (2.1). Proof. The operator Ta is obviously unitary equivalent to the operator R Ta R ∗
= R BD,µ aBD,µ R∗ = R(R∗ R)a(R∗ R)R∗ = (RR∗ )RaR∗ (RR∗ ) = RaR∗ = R0∗ U a(r)U −1 R0
−1 = R0∗ (F(n) ⊗ I)a(r)(F(n) ⊗ I)R0
= R0∗ a(r)R0 . Now R0∗ a(r)R0 {cp }p∈Zn+
= R0∗ {a(r) αp cp rp }p∈Zn + =
αp
p
τ (D)
p
r a(r) αp cp r µ(r1 , . . . , rn )
n
rk drk
k=1
p∈Zn +
= {γa (p) · cp }p∈Zn+ , where γa (p) = α2p
τ (D)
a(r) r2p µ(r1 , . . . , rn )
n
rk drk ,
p ∈ Zn+ .
k=1
It is easy to see that the system of functions {ep }p∈Zn+ , where ep (z) = n (2π)− 2 αp z p , forms an orthonormal base in A2µ (D). Corollary 3.2. The Toeplitz operator Ta with bounded measurable separately radial symbol a(r) is diagonal with respect to the above orthonormal base: Ta ep = γa (p) · ep ,
p ∈ Zn+ .
(3.2)
We can easily extend the notion of the Toeplitz operator for measurable unbounded separately radial symbols. Indeed, given a symbol a = a(r) ∈ L1 (τ (D), µ), we still have equality (3.2). Then the densely defined (on the finite linear combinations of the above base elements) Toeplitz operator can be extended to a
74
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
bounded operator on a whole A2µ (D) if and only if the sequence γa = {γa (p)}p∈Zn+ is bounded. That is we have Corollary 3.3. The Toeplitz operator Ta with separately radial symbol a = a(r) ∈ L1 (τ (D), µ) is bounded on A2µ (D) if and only if γa = {γa (p)}p∈Zn+ ∈ l∞ , and Ta = sup |γa (p)|. p∈Zn +
The Toeplitz operator Ta is compact if and only if γa ∈ c0 that is lim γa (p) = 0.
p→∞
The spectrum of the bounded Toeplitz operator Ta is given by sp Ta = {γa (p) : p ∈ Zn+ }, and its essential spectrum ess − sp Ta coincides with the set of all limit points of the sequence {γa (p)}p∈Zn+ . Corollary 3.4. The C ∗ -algebra generated by Toeplitz operators with separately radial L∞ -symbols is commutative.
4. Foliations, transverse Riemannian structures, and bundle-like metrics In this section we will briefly summarize some notions of foliations and their geometry. We refer to [8] for further details. A foliation on a manifold M is a partition of M into connected submanifolds of the same dimension that locally looks like a partition given by the fibers of a submersion. The local picture is given by considering foliated charts and the partition as a global object is obtained by imposing a compatibility condition between the foliated charts. We make more precise this notion through the following definitions. Definition 4.1. On a smooth manifold M a codimension q foliated chart is a pair (ϕ, U ) given by an open subset U of M and a smooth submersion ϕ : U → V , where V is an open subset of Rq . For a foliated chart (ϕ, U ) the connected components of the fibers of ϕ are called the plaques of the foliated chart. Two codimension q foliated charts (ϕ1 , U1 ) and (ϕ2 , U2 ) are called compatible if there exists a diffeomorphism ψ12 : ϕ1 (U1 ∩ U2 ) → ϕ2 (U1 ∩ U2 ) such that the following diagram commutes: U1 ∩ U2N NNN pp p NNϕN2 p pp NNN p p p N& p xp ψ12 / ϕ2 (U1 ∩ U2 ) ϕ1 (U1 ∩ U2 ) ϕ1
(4.1)
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
75
A foliated atlas on a manifold M is a collection {(ϕ α , Uα )}α of foliated charts which are mutually compatible and that satisfy M = α Uα . It is straightforward to check that the compatibility of two foliated charts (ϕ1 , U1 ) and (ϕ2 , U2 ) ensures that, when restricted to U1 ∩ U2 , both submersions ϕ1 and ϕ2 have the same plaques. This in turn implies that, for any given foliated atlas, the following is an equivalence relation in M . x∼y
⇐⇒
there is a sequence of plaques (Pk )lk=0 for foliated charts
(ϕk , Uk )lk=0 of the foliated atlas, such that x ∈ P0 , y ∈ Pl , and Pk−1 ∩ Pk = φ for every k = 1, . . . , l We will refer to the latter as the equivalence relation of the foliated atlas. It is a simple matter to show that the equivalence classes are in fact submanifolds of M of dimension dim(M ) − q, where q is the (common) codimension of the foliated charts. Definition 4.2. A foliation F on a manifold M is a partition of M which can be described as the classes of the equivalence relation of a foliated atlas. The classes are called the leaves of the foliation. Suppose that M is a manifold carrying a smooth foliation F. We will denote with T F the vector subbundle of T M that consists of elements tangent to the leaves of F. We can consider the quotient bundle T M/T F which we will denote by T t F. The latter will be referred to as the transverse vector bundle of the foliation F. Since T t F is a smooth vector bundle, we can consider the associated linear frame bundle which we will denote with LT (F). More precisely, we have as a set: LT (F) = {A : A : Rq → Txt F = Tx M/TxF is an isomorphism and x ∈ M }, where q is the codimension of F in M . It is easily seen that LT (F) is a principal fiber bundle with structure group GLq (R), we refer to [8] for the details of the proof. The principal bundle LT (F) is called the transverse frame bundle since it allows us to study the geometry transverse to the foliation F. When studying the transverse geometry of a foliation F it is useful to consider a certain natural foliation in LT (F), which is defined as follows. Suppose that for a foliation F on a manifold M we choose a foliated atlas {(ϕα , Uα )}α that determines the foliation as in Definition 4.2. For any foliated chart (ϕα , Uα ) and every x ∈ Uα we have a linear map d(ϕα )x : Tx M → Rq whose kernel is Tx F. This induces a linear isomorphism d(ϕα )tx : Txt F = Tx M/Tx F → Rq . The latter allows us to define the smooth map: ϕ(1) α : LT (F|Uα ) → L(Vα )
A → d(ϕα )tx ◦ A,
where LT (F|Uα ) is the open subset of LT (F) given by inverse image of Uα under the natural projection LT (F) → M , A is mapped to x under such projection and Vα is the target of ϕα . Next we observe that, since Vα is open in Rq , the manifold
76
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT 2
L(Vα ) is open in Rq × GLq (R) and so it is open in Rq+q as well. Furthermore, from our choices it is easy to check that the commutative diagram (4.1) and the compatibility of charts in a foliated atlas induce a corresponding commutative diagram given by: LT (F|U1 ∩U2 ) QQQ mm QQQϕ(1) m m m QQαQ2 m m m QQQ m m m Q( (1) vmm ψα 1 α2 / L(ϕα2 (U1 ∩ U2 )) L(ϕα1 (U1 ∩ U2 )) ϕ(1) α1
(1)
where ψα1 α2 is defined as above for the diffeomorphism ψα1 α2 for which we have (1) ϕα2 = ψα1 α2 ◦ϕα1 , as in diagram (4.1). This shows that the set {(ϕα , LT (F|Uα ))}α defines a foliated atlas. The corresponding foliation in LT (F) is called the lifted foliation. We state without proof the following result which can be found in [8]. Theorem 4.3. Let F be a foliation on a smooth manifold M . Then, the natural projection LT (F) → M maps the leaves of the lifted foliation of LT (F) locally diffeomorphically onto the leaves of F. From its construction, the principal fiber bundle LT (F) → M models some aspects of the transverse geometry of the foliation F. At the same time, Theorem 4.3 shows that the lifted foliation in LT (F) is needed to fully capture the foliated nature of the transverse geometry of F. In order to define transverse geometric structures for a given foliation F we consider now reductions of LT (F) compatible with the lifted foliation. More precisely, we have the following definition which also introduces the notion of a Riemannian foliation. Definition 4.4. Let M be a manifold carrying a smooth foliation F of codimension q, and let H be a Lie subgroup of GLq (R). A transverse geometric H-structure is a reduction Q of LT (F) to the subgroup H which is saturated with respect to the lifted foliation, i.e. such that Q ∩ L = φ implies L ⊂ Q for every leaf L of the lifted foliation. A transverse geometric O(q)-structure is also called a transverse Riemannian structure. A foliation endowed with a transverse Riemannian structure is called a Riemannian foliation. From the definition, it is easy to see that a transverse Riemannian structure defines a Riemannian metric on the bundle T M/T F = T t F. However, a transverse Riemannian structure is more than a simple Riemannian metric on T t F. By requiring the O(q)-reduction that defines a transverse Riemannian structure to be saturated with respect to the lifted foliation, as in Definition 4.4, we ensure the invariance of the metric as we move along the leaves in M . This is a well known property of Riemannian foliations whose further discussion can be found in [8] and other books on the subject. Here we observe that, since a Riemannian metric on a manifold defines a distance, the invariance of a transverse Riemannian structure as we move along the leaves can be interpreted as the leaves of the foliation in M to be equidistant while we move along them. Again, this sort of remark is
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
77
well known in the theory of foliations and shows that a Riemannian foliation has a distinguished geometry. In particular, not every foliation admits a Riemannian structure, a standard example is given by the Reeb foliation of the sphere S 3 (see [8]). A fundamental way to construct transverse Riemannian structures for a foliation is to consider suitable Riemannian metrics on the manifold that carries the foliation. To describe such construction we will need some additional notions. Definition 4.5. Let F be a smooth foliation on a manifold M . A vector field X on M is called foliate if for every vector field Y tangent to the leaves of F the vector field [X, Y ] is tangent to the leaves as well. From the previous definition, we observe that the set of foliate vector fields is the normalizer of the fields tangent to the leaves of F in the Lie algebra of all vector fields on M . Definition 4.6. Let F be a smooth foliation on a manifold M . A Riemannian metric h in M is called bundle-like for the foliation F if the real-valued function h(X, Y ) is constant along the leaves of F for every pair of vector fields X, Y which are foliate and perpendicular to T F with respect to h. Suppose that h is a Riemannian metric on a manifold M and that F is a foliation on M . Then, the canonical projection T M → T t F allows us to induce a Riemannian metric on the bundle T t F, which in turn provides an O(q)-reduction of the transverse frame bundle LT (F) (where q is the codimension of F). Nevertheless, such reduction does not necessarily defines a transverse Riemannian structure. The next result states that bundle-like metrics are precisely those that define transverse Riemannian structures. The proof of this theorem can be found in [8]. Theorem 4.7. Let M be a manifold carrying a smooth foliation F of codimension q. For every Riemannian metric h on M , denote by OT (M, h) the O(q)-reduction of LT (F) given by the Riemannian metric on T t (F) coming from h and the natural projection T M → T t F. If h is a bundle-like metric, then OT (M, h) defines a transverse Riemannian structure on F. Conversely, for every transverse Riemannian structure given by a reduction Q as in Definition 4.4, there is a bundle-like metric h on M such that Q = OT (M, h). Based on this result, we give the following definition. Definition 4.8. Let F be a Riemannian foliation on a manifold M . We will say that a bundle-like metric h on M is compatible with the Riemannian foliation if OT (M, h) is the reduction which defines the corresponding transverse Riemannian structure. A fundamental property of Riemannian foliations is that, with respect to compatible bundle-like metrics, geodesics which start perpendicular to a leaf of the foliation stay perpendicular to all leaves.
78
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
Theorem 4.9. Let F be a Riemannian foliation on a manifold M and let h be a compatible bundle-like metric. If γ is a geodesic of h such that γ (t0 ) ∈ (Tγ(t0 ) F)⊥ , for some t0 , then γ (t) ∈ (Tγ(t) F)⊥ for every t. This theorem is fundamental in the theory of Riemannian foliations and its proof can be found in [8]. We can provide its geometric interpretation as follows. Let M , F and h be as in Theorem 4.9, and denote with T F⊥ the orthogonal complement of T F in T M ; in particular, T M = T F ⊕ T F⊥ . Hence, Theorem 4.9 states that every geodesic with an initial velocity vector in T F⊥ has velocity vector contained in T F⊥ for all time. In a sense, the above states that the orthogonal complement T F⊥ contains all geodesics perpendicular to T F. If the codimension of F is 1, then T F⊥ is onedimensional and it can be integrated to a smooth one-dimensional foliation F⊥ whose leaves are perpendicular to those of F. In such case, Theorem 4.9 ensures that the leaves of F⊥ are geodesics with respect to the bundle-like metric h. If F has codimension greater than 1, then we can still consider the possibility of T F⊥ to be integrable, e.g. to satisfy the hypothesis of Frobenius theorem (see [14]). In such case, we do have a foliation F⊥ whose leaves are orthogonal to those of F. Again, in this case, Theorem 4.9 implies that the leaves of F⊥ are totally geodesic. At the same time, the vector bundle T F⊥ is not always integrable. Nevertheless, the above discussion shows that T F⊥ can be thought of as being totally geodesic from a broader viewpoint. Alternatively, we can say that, from a geometric point of view, the foliation F is transversely totally geodesic. It is worth mentioning that the integrability of the bundle T F⊥ given by a Riemannian foliation and a bundle-like metric is not at all trivial and requires strong restrictions on the geometry of the foliation or its leaves. As an example, we refer to [10], where the integrability of the corresponding T F⊥ is only obtained for leaves carrying a suitable nonpositively curved Riemannian metric. At the same time, we will prove in the following sections that the orthogonal complement to the tangent bundle of the Tn -orbits in a Reinhardt domain is integrable, which will then imply the presence of strong geometric features on such domains.
5. Extrinsic geometry of foliations For a submanifold of any Riemannian manifold one can measure the obstruction for the submanifold to be a totally geodesic in the ambient. This also measures the extrinsic curvature of the submanifold, which is determined by the particular embedding and not just the inherited metric. We now briefly discuss some well known methods to study this extrinsic curvature and refer to [7] and [9] for further details. For our purposes it will be convenient and natural to discuss these notions for foliations. be a Riemannian manifold and F be a foliation of M having codiLet M mension q and with p-dimensional leaves. We will denote by ∇ the Levi-Civita and by ∇ the connection of the bundle T F obtained by pasting connection of M
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
79
together the Levi-Civita connections of the leaves of F for the metric inherited . Let us also denote by V and H the orthogonal projections of from that of M T M onto T F and T F⊥ , respectively. These projections are respectively called the vertical and horizontal projections with respect to F. Then the following holds (see [7]): More precisely, we Lemma 5.1. The connection ∇ is the vertical projection of ∇. have: X Y ), ∇X Y = V(∇ everywhere tangent to the leaves of F. for every pair of vector fields in M We recall that the Levi-Civita connection is the differential operator that allows to define geodesics. Hence, the previous result shows that the obstruction and for the leaves of F to be totally geodesic is precisely the difference between ∇ its vertical projection as above, in other words, the horizontal projection of ∇. This suggests to introduce the following classical definition (see [7]). . The second Definition 5.2. Let F be a foliation of a Riemannian manifold M fundamental form II of the leaves of F is given at every x ∈ M by: II x : Tx F × Tx F → (u, v) →
T x F⊥ X Y )x , H(∇
everywhere where X, Y are vector fields defined in a neighborhood of x in M tangent to F and such that Xx = v and Yx = v. It is very well known that the definition of II x as above does not depend on the choice of the vector fields X and Y . It is also known that the second fundamental form at every every point is a symmetric bilinear form that defines a tensor which is a section of the bundle T F∗ ⊗ T F∗ ⊗ T F⊥. As it occurs with any tensor, it is easier to describe some of the properties of II by introducing local bases for the bundles involved and computing the components with respect to such bases. This is particularly useful if one has global bases for the bundles. These are defined more precisely as follows. be a subbundle of the tangent bundle of the RiemannDefinition 5.3. Let E → M . Then, a collection (V1 , . . . , Vk ) of sections of E defined on all of ian manifold M , the set of tangent vectors M is called a global framing of E if for every x ∈ M (V1 (x), . . . , Vk (x)) is a basis for the fiber Ex . The next result is an obvious consequence of the symmetry of II . It will allow us to simplify the computation of the values for II . be a Riemannian manifold with a foliation F as above. Proposition 5.4. Let M Suppose that (Vk )pk=1 is a global framing of T F. Then II as a tensor is completely determined by the vector fields II (Vk + Vl , Vk + Vl ) for k, l = 1, . . . , p.
80
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
Proof. It is enough to use the relation: 1 II (Vk , Vl ) = (II (Vk + Vl , Vk + Vl ) − II (Vk , Vk ) − II (Vl , Vl )) 2 which is satisfied by the symmetry of II .
IEOT
6. Isometric actions of Lie groups In this section we will consider some general notions about actions of Lie on a manifold preserving a Riemannian metric. In what follows M will a smooth manifold and G a connected Lie group acting smoothly on the M . For the next definition, we recall that the stabilizer of a point x ∈ M G-action is the set Gx = {g ∈ G : gx = x}.
groups denote left on for the
Definition 6.1. The action of G on M is called free (locally free) if for every x ∈ M the stabilizer Gx is trivial (respectively discrete). A straightforward application of Frobenius theorem on the integrability of vector subbundles of a tangent bundle (see [14]) allows us to obtain the following result. Proposition 6.2. If G acts locally freely on M , then the G-orbits define a smooth foliation on M . Proof. Denote by g the Lie algebra of G. Then for every X ∈ g we can define the transformations of M given by the maps: ϕt : M x
→ M → exp(tX)x
for every t ∈ R. This family of maps is in fact a one-parameter group of diffeomorphism of M , in other words, we have: ϕt1 +t2 = ϕt1 ◦ ϕt2 for every t1 , t2 ∈ R. Hence, there is a smooth vector field X ∗ on M given by: d Xx∗ = (exp(tX)x). dt t=0 Also, it is easy to check that the global flow of X ∗ is given by (ϕt )t . Furthermore, since the Lie group G acts locally freely, the condition Xx∗ = 0 for some x ∈ M implies X = 0; otherwise the subgroup (exp(tX))t would be nondiscrete and contained in Gx for some x ∈ M . From the above remarks it follows that the map: M × g → TM (x, X) → Xx∗ is a smooth vector bundle inclusion which thus defines a subbundle T O of T M .
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
81
On the other hand, by using the results in [6], the following relation holds for every X, Y ∈ g: [X ∗ , Y ∗ ] = −[X, Y ]∗ From this it is easy to conclude that the smooth sections of T O are closed under the Lie brackets of smooth vector fields. By Frobenius theorem (see [14]) the vector subbundle T O induces a smooth foliation whose leaves have the fibers of T O as tangent spaces. Since G is connected it is generated by the set exp g, and so one can conclude that the leaves of such foliation are precisely the G-orbits. In the proof of the previous result it is shown that the tangent bundle of the foliation by G-orbits is T O. Whenever G acts locally freely we will use T O to denote such tangent bundle. We will now consider the case where G acts locally freely preserving a Riemannian metric on M . Theorem 6.3. If G acts locally freely on M preserving a Riemannian metric h, then the G-orbits define a smooth Riemannian foliation for which h is a compatible bundle-like metric. Proof. By Theorem 4.7 it is enough to show that h is bundle-like with respect to the foliation by G-orbits given by Proposition 6.2. Choose X and Y foliate vector fields perpendicular to the G-orbits. We need to prove that v(h(X, Y )) = 0, for every v ∈ T O. By the proof of Proposition 6.2 there exists Z ∈ g, the Lie algebra of G, such that Zx∗ = v, where x is the basepoint of v. Hence, it suffices to prove that Z ∗ (h(X, Y )) = 0 for every Z ∈ g. For any Z ∗ as above, we denote with LZ ∗ the Lie derivative with respect to ∗ Z and refer to [6] for the definition. In fact, from [6] it follows that LZ ∗ when applied to h yields a bilinear form that satisfies: (LZ ∗ h)(X, Y ) = Z ∗ (h(X, Y )) − h([Z ∗ , X], Y ) − h(X, [Z ∗ , Y ]).
(6.1)
On the other hand, since the one-parameter group (exp(tX))t acts by isometries on (M, h), i.e. preserving h, it follows that Z ∗ is a Killing field for h and so it satisfies: (LZ ∗ h)(X, Y ) = 0, (6.2) we refer to [6] for this fact and the definitions involved. From equations (6.1) and (6.2) we obtain: Z ∗ (h(X, Y )) = h([Z ∗ , X], Y ) + h(X, [Z ∗ , Y ]). Then we observe that, since X and Y are foliate, the vector fields [Z ∗ , X] and [Z ∗ , Y ] are tangent to the G-orbits, and so the terms on the right-hand side of the last equation vanish since X and Y are also perpendicular to the G-orbits. This shows that Z ∗ (h(X, Y )) = 0 thus concluding the proof. From the last result and Theorem 4.9 we obtain the following consequence.
82
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
Theorem 6.4. If G acts locally freely on M preserving a Riemannian metric h and γ is a geodesic (with respect to h) perpendicular at some point to a G-orbit, then γ intersects every G-orbit perpendicularly. The previous result and the remarks following Theorem 4.9 allows us to say that, from a geometric point of view, every locally free action of a group G preserving a Riemannian metric h defines (through its orbits) a foliation which is transversely totally geodesic.
7. Lagrangian foliations associated with a Reinhardt domain We now proceed to study the geometry of Reinhardt domains. For this we will obtain some properties of its Bergman metric and apply the foliation theory considered in the previous sections. As before, in this section D ⊂ Cn denotes a bounded logarithmically convex complete Reinhardt domain centered at the origin. Using the monomial orthonormal base {ep }p∈Zn+ of A2µ (D), mentioned in Section 3, we have obviously Lemma 7.1. The Bergman kernel KD of the domain D admits the following representation KD (z, ζ) = (2π)−n α2p z p ζ¯p , p∈Zn +
where the coefficients αp , p ∈ Zn+ , are given by (2.1). In particular, the function KD (z, z) depends only on r. In this section we will use the polar coordinates zk = rk tk = rk eiθk , k = 1, . . . , n, for points z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) ∈ D. Theorem 7.2. Let ds2D be the Bergman metric of D considered as a Hermitian metric and hD = Re (ds2D ) the associated Riemannian metric. Then: hD =
n
Fkl (r)(drk ⊗ drl + rk rl dθk ⊗ dθl ),
k,l=1
where the functions Fkl are given by: ∂2 1 δkl ∂ Fkl (r) = + log KD (z, z), 4 ∂rk ∂rl rk ∂rk and depend only on r. Proof. For the Bergman kernel KD , the associated Bergman metric considered as a Hermitian metric is given by: ds2D =
n ∂ 2 log KD (z, z) k dz ⊗ d¯ zl. ∂z k ∂ z¯l
k,l=1
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
83
Let F (r) = F (z) = log KD (z, z), which by Lemma 7.1 depends only on r. Then a straightforward computation shows that: ∂2F 1 z¯k zl ∂ 2 F δkl ∂F (z) = (z) + (z) . ∂zk ∂ z¯l 4 rk rl ∂rk ∂rl rk ∂rk The required identity is then obtained by replacing these expressions into that of ds2D , using the relations zk = rk eiθk and computing the real part of the expression thus obtained. Consider the following action of the n-dimensional torus Tn on D Tn × D
→ D
(t, z) → tz, which being biholomorphic yields the following immediate consequence. Theorem 7.3. Let hD be the Riemannian metric of D defined by its Bergman metric. Then Tn acts isometrically on (D, hD ). Note that the action of Tn is not locally free at all points of an n-dimensional Reinhardt domain, but it is almost so as the following obvious result states. We recall that in a measure space, a subset is called conull if its complement has zero measure. Lemma 7.4. For D as before, the set: = {z ∈ D : zk = 0 for every k = 1, . . . , n} D is the set of points whose stabilizers with respect to the action of Tn are discrete. is an open conull subset of D on which Tn acts freely. Furthermore, D As a consequence of Theorems 6.3 and 7.3 and Lemma 7.4 we obtain the following. the subset of D defined in Lemma 7.4 and hD Theorem 7.5. Let D be as before, D the Riemannian metric defined by the Bergman metric of D. Then, the Tn -orbits define a Riemannian foliation O for which h is a compatible bundle-like in D metric. Given such result we now obtain the following statement which makes use of Theorem 6.4 as well. the subset of D defined in Lemma 7.4 and hD Theorem 7.6. Let D be as before, D the Riemannian metric defined by the Bergman metric of D. If γ is a geodesic in (with respect to h) perpendicular at some point to a Tn -orbit, then γ intersects D every Tn -orbit perpendicularly. We now prove that the Riemannian foliation O obtained in the previous result is Lagrangian.
84
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
the subset of D defined in Lemma 7.4, ds2 Theorem 7.7. Let D be as before, D D the Bergman metric of D as a Hermitian metric and O the Riemannian foliation Then O is Lagrangian with respect to the Riemannian metric of Tn -orbits in D. 2 are Lagrangian with respect to hD = Re (dsD ), in other words, the Tn -orbits in D hD . Proof. We need to prove that Tz O and iTz O are perpendicular with respect to Since such condition is the Riemannian metric hD = Re (ds2D ) at every z ∈ D. invariant under the Tn -action we can assume that z = x ∈ Rn+ . we have Tx O = iRn . Hence the result follows We observe that for every x ∈ D by using Theorem 7.2 together with the fact that iRn and Rn are perpendicular with respect to the elements drk ⊗ drl + rk rl dθk ⊗ dθl for every k, l. We now prove that the normal bundle to O is integrable. the subset of D defined in Lemma 7.4 and Theorem 7.8. Let D be as before, D hD the Riemannian metric defined by the Bergman metric of D. If we denote of tangent vectors perpendicular to O, then with T O⊥ the vector subbundle of T D ⊥ T O is integrable to a foliation P. Furthermore, P is a Lagrangian totally geodesic foliation of D. Proof. If we let M0 = D∩Rn+ , then by the proof of Theorem 7.7 the tangent bundle to M0 coincides with T O⊥ restricted to M0 , and so M0 is an integral submanifold of T O⊥ . Since T O⊥ is invariant under the Tn -action and such action preserves the metric, it follows that for every t ∈ Tn the manifold: Mt = tM0 ⊥
is an integral submanifold of T O , thus showing the integrability of such bundle to some foliation P. By Lemma 7.1 we have T P = T O⊥ = iT O which implies that P is Lagrangian. Finally P is totally geodesic by Theorem 7.6. We now state the following easy corollary of the previous discussion. Corollary 7.9. The sets of vector fields: n ∂ and ∂θk k=1
∂ ∂rk
n , k=1
define global framings for the bundles T O and T O⊥ = T P, respectively, on D.
8. The unit ball An important class of domains in complex analysis is given by those which are bounded and symmetric. The next result shows that each irreducible bounded symmetric domain which is also Reinhardt has to be a unit ball. As usual, we will denote by Bn the unit ball in Cn .
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
85
Theorem 8.1. Let D be an irreducible bounded symmetric domain. Then D is also a Reinhardt domain if and only if D = Bn for some n ∈ Z+ . Proof. First, the unit ball centered at the origin in a complex vector space is obviously a Reinhardt domain. Conversely, let us assume that D is an irreducible bounded symmetric domain which is also Reinhardt. We show that it is a unit ball centered at the origin of some complex vector space. For this we use Cartan’s classification of irreducible bounded symmetric domains and the description of their biholomorphisms as found in [5]. We present the needed basic properties in Table 1, which recollects some of the information found in Table V in page 518 from [5]. Every irreducible bounded symmetric domain D in Table 1 is identified by its type in the first column (following the notation from [5]) and is explicitly given as the quotient G0 /K for the groups in the second and third column. The group G0 is, up to a finite covering, the group of biholomorphisms of D and K is the subgroup of G0 consisting of those transformations that fix the origin. For the exceptional bounded symmetric domains of type EIII and EVII we write down the Lie algebras of the corresponding groups, which is enough for our purposes; again, we follow here the notation from [5] to identify real forms of exceptional complex Lie algebras. The last two columns permit us to compare the complex dimension of D and the dimension of a maximal torus T in K. This last dimension is well known from the basic properties of the compact groups K that appear in Table 1. We recall from the basic theory of symmetric spaces that the universal covering of the group G0 completely determines the bounded symmetric domain: in other words, two bounded symmetric domains whose corresponding groups G0 in Table 1 have the same universal covering group are biholomorphic. Through out Table 1, the symbols p, q and n are assumed to be positive integers. The additional conditions on the types BDI(2,q) and DIII are required for the corresponding quotient G0 /K to actually define an irreducible bounded symmetric domain. Table 1. Irreducible bounded symmetric domains D
G0
K
AIII
SU (p, q)
S(U (p) × U (q)) pq
BDI(2,q) (q = 2) SO0 (2, q) SO(2) × SO(q)
dimC (D) q n(n−1) 2 n(n+1) 2
dim(T ) p+q−1 q 2 +1
DIII (n ≥ 2)
∗
SO (2n)
U (n)
CI
Sp(n, R)
U (n)
EIII
e6(−14)
so(10) ⊕ R
16
6
EVII
e7(−25)
e6 ⊕ R
27
7
n n
For D in Table 1 to be a Reinhardt domain, we clearly have as a necessary condition the inequality: dim(T ) ≥ dimC (D). (8.1)
86
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
Let us now consider the cases where this might occur in Table 1. AIII. The condition (8.1) holds if and only if min(p, q) = 1, which clearly corresponds to the unit ball of dimension max(p, q). BDI(2,q). In this case the condition (8.1) holds if and only if q = 1. This corresponds to the bounded symmetric domain whose group of biholomorphisms is, up to a finite covering, SO0 (2, 1). Since the Lie algebras so(2, 1) and su(1, 1) are isomorphic, the bounded symmetric domain of type BDI(2,1) is the unit disc in the complex plane. DIII. In this case the condition (8.1) holds only for n = 2 or 3. The Lie algebras of the corresponding groups G0 are so∗ (4) and so∗ (6). There are well known isomorphisms so∗ (4) ∼ = su(2) × su(1, 1) and so∗ (6) ∼ = su(3, 1) (see [5]). We ∼ also recall that u(n) = su(n) ⊕ R, for every n. Hence, we conclude that type DIII for n = 2 and 3 defines the unit disc in the complex plane and the unit ball in C3 , respectively. CI. In this case the condition (8.1) holds only for n = 1, which yields the unit disk with an argument as above using the fact that sp(1, R) is isomorphic to su(1, 1) (see [5]). EIII, EVII. A simple inspection shows that in these cases the condition (8.1) cannot hold.
This completes the proof of Theorem 8.1.
Now the results of the previous sections lead directly to the following statements: n the Tn -action defines a Lagrangian foliation O. 1. On the subset B n to a foliation totally 2. The orthogonal complement T O⊥ is integrable in B geodesic Lagrangian foliation P. n , which in 3. The pair of foliations O and P define the polar coordinates in B ∗ turn yields the commutative C - algebra of Toeplitz operators whose symbols are constant on the leaves of O. In what follows we will normalize the (Hermitian) Bergman metric on the unit ball to the following expression: n n l k z z dz ⊗ dz 4 k l . n n dz k ⊗ dz k + ds2 = 1 − k=1 |zk |2 1 − k=1 |zk |2 k=1
k,l=1
which differs from the usual Bergman metric as considered in the proof of Theorem 7.2 by a factor of (n+1)/4. The advantage of this normalization is that the sectional curvature varies in the interval [−1, −1/4], while with the metric as defined in the proof of Theorem 7.2 the sectional curvature varies in the interval [−4/(n + 1), −1/(n + 1)]. We will now compute some values of the second fundamental form for the foliation O of the unit ball. First, we recall the notion of complex geodesic and some of its properties.
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
87
Definition 8.2. A complex geodesic in Bn is a biholomorphic map ϕ : D → D where D is the unit disc and D = Bn ∩ L for some complex affine line L in Cn . It is well known that complex geodesics are always totally geodesic maps. Furthermore, the images of complex geodesics are precisely the closed totally geodesic complex submanifolds of (complex) dimension 1 in Bn (see [2]). n The next result shows that some of the orbits ofn the T -action on the unit ∂ ball integrate the vector fields of the framing ∂θk from Corollary 7.9. Its k=1 proof is a straightforward computation. Lemma 8.3. For every k, 1 = 1, . . . , n with k = l, the curves: γz,k (s)
= (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , eis zk , zk+1 , . . . , zn )
γz,kl (s)
= (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , eis zk , zk+1 , . . . , zl−1 , eis zl , zl+1 , . . . , zn )
are integral curves of the vector fields
∂ ∂θk
and
∂ ∂θk
+
∂ ∂θl ,
respectively.
Proof. By the definition of polar coordinates it is clear that the flows that integrate ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂θk and ∂θk + ∂θl are given by: z
→ (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , eis zk , zk+1 , . . . , zn ),
z
→ (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , eis zk , zk+1 , . . . , zl−1 , eis zl , zl+1 , . . . , zn )
from which the conclusion is clear. n: Let us define the following vector fields on B ∂ ∂ , Qk = II ∂θk ∂θk ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ Qkl = II + , + , ∂θk ∂θl ∂θk ∂θl
then, by Proposition 5.4 and Corollary 7.9, such vector fields completely determine the second fundamental form II . We will compute Qk and Qkl using the curves n we define the following defined in Lemma 8.3. To achieve this, for every z ∈ B complex geodesics: φz,k (w)
= (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , Rk w, zk+1 , . . . , zn )
φz,kl (w)
= (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , Rkl w, zk+1 , . . . , zl−1 ,
Rkl zl w, zl+1 , . . . , zn ) zk
where k, l = 1, . . . , n with k = l and: 1− |zj |2 Rk = j =k
Rkl
=
|zk | 1 − j =k,l |zj |2 . |zk |2 + |zl |2
Then we have the following easy to prove result.
88
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
n the complex geodesics φz,k , φz,kl satisfy: Lemma 8.4. For every z ∈ B 1. φz,k (zk /Rk ) = φz,kl (zk /Rkl ) = z for every k, l = 1, . . . , n with k = l, 2. γz,k (R) ⊂ φz,k (D) and γz,kl (R) ⊂ φz,kl (D), in other words, they pass through z and contain the curves from Lemma 8.3 with the same indices. We now use the above to compute the value of the vector fields Qk and Qkl . n and k, l = 1, . . . , n with k = l we have the following Lemma 8.5. For every z ∈ B relations: 1. Qk (z) = γz,k (0) and Qkl (z) = γz,kl (0), where the acceleration is computed for the complex hyperbolic geometry of Bn , 2. γz,k (s) ∈ Riγz,k (s) and γz,kl (s) ∈ Riγz,kl (s) for every s ∈ R; in particular: ∂ ∂ ∂ Qk (z) ∈ R , Qkl (z) ∈ R + , ∂rk z ∂rk z ∂rl z 3. the norms of Qk and Qkl are given by: Qk (z) = Ck (z)γz,k (0)2 ,
Qkl (z) = Ckl (z)γz,kl (0)2 ,
where Ck (z) and Ckl (z) are the geodesic curvatures of γz,k and γz,kl , respectively, considered as curves in the images of the complex geodesics φz,k and φz,kl , respectively, endowed with the metric inherited from Bn . n the leaves of the foliation O by Tn -orbits are Proof. First we observe that in B n diffeomorphic to T under the action map. In particular, with respect to such diffeomorphisms, the metric of Bn restricted to any such Tn -orbit is left invariant. For such metrics on abelian Lie groups it is well known that the geodesics are precisely the one parameter subgroups and their translations (see [5]). Since the curves γz,k , γz,kl correspond to one parameter groups in Tn it follows that they define geodesics in the leaf of O through z. Then, by well known results on the geometry of Riemannian submanifolds (see [9]) it follows that the accelerations , γz,kl as computed in Bn are everywhere perpendicular to the leaves of O, in γz,k other words they are everywhere horizontal. By the remarks in Section 5 and the definition of Qk and Qkl we have: γ (0) γ ) = H(γ (0)) = γ (0) Qk (z) = H(∇ z,k
z,k
z,k
z,k
γ (0) γz,kl ) = H(γz,kl (0)) = γz,kl (0), Qkl (z) = H(∇ z,kl
the connection of Bn , and where the last identities follow from the remarks for ∇ in the previous paragraph. This proves (1). Next observe that since the curves γz,k , γz,kl are geodesics in some leaf of O it follows that they are up to a constant parameterized by arc-length. On the other hand, by Lemma 8.4 the curves γz,k , γz,kl lie in complex geodesics which, as we observed before, define totally geodesic submanifolds of Bn . In particular, their accelerations γz,k , γz,kl as computed in Bn are the same as computed in
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
89
the (images) of the complex geodesics that contain them. Complex geodesics are isometric to the unit disk, and for the latter any curve γ which is parameterized up to a constant by arc length satisfies γ (s) ∈ Riγ (s). This implies the first part of (2). For the second part of (2) it is enough to note that: ∂ ∂ (s) = i ∈R iγz,k ∂θk γz,k (s) ∂rk γz,k (s) ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ iγz,kl (s) = i + + ∈R , ∂θk γz,kl (s) ∂θl γz,kl (s) ∂rk γz,kl (s) ∂rl γz,kl (s) and so we obtain (2) by applying (1). By the definition of the geodesic curvature (see [4] and its references) we have: Ck (z) = Ckl (z) =
(0) γz,k γz,k (0)2 (0) γz,kl , γz,kl (0)2
where we have used the fact that the norm of vectors and the acceleration of curves in a (image of a) complex geodesic in Bn computed in Bn or the complex geodesic yield the same result. Given the above identities, (3) follows from (1). The next result computes specific values for the second fundamental form of the foliation O for the unit ball. By Proposition 5.4 such values completely determine the second fundamental form. We observe that in the first two parts of the statement we obtain a very explicit expression for the second fundamental form of the foliation O. Note that by part (3) of Lemma 8.5, the geodesic curvatures Ck and Ckl correspond to the norms of the values of Qk and Qkl , respectively, ∂ , renormalized so that they only depend on the direction of ∂θ∂k and ∂θ∂k + ∂θ l spectively. In view of this, the last part of the statement allows us to understand the asymptotic behavior of the curvature of the leaves of O as they move towards n . We observe as well that this result generalizes the origin or the boundary of B our geometric description of the elliptic model case in the unit disk found in [4]. n , let r = (r1 , . . . , rn ) = (|z1 |, . . . , |zn |), and consider Theorem 8.6. For every z ∈ B the curves γz,k , γz,kl and the complex geodesics φz,k , φz,kl defined above. Then: 1. The vector fields Qk and Qkl are given by: ∂ 2 ∂ −1 ∂ Qk (z) = −Ck (z) ∂θk z ∂rk z ∂rk z 2 −1 ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ Qkl (z) = −Ckl (z) + + + . ∂θk z ∂θl z ∂rk z ∂rl z ∂rk z ∂rl z
90
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
2. The geodesic curvatures Ck (z) and Ckl (z) at z defined in Lemma 8.5 are given by: rk2 + 1 − j =k rj2 Ck (z) = 2rk 1 − j =k rj2 rk2 + rl2 + 1 − j =k,l rj2 Ckl (z) = , 2 rk2 + rl2 1 − j =k,l rj2 in particular, such geodesic curvatures lie in the interval (1, +∞) and achieve all values therein. 3. The geodesic curvatures Ck (z) and Ckl (z) have the following asymptotic behavior: as |z| → 0, Ck (z), Ckl (z) → +∞, as z → u, Ck (z) → 1, Ckl (z) → 1,
as z → v,
n
for any u, v ∈ ∂B such that uk = 0 and |vk |2 + |vl |2 = 0, respectively. Proof. Up to a sign, (1) essentially follows from (2) and (3) in Lemma 8.5. The negative sign comes from the fact that, in the proof of Lemma 8.5, the accelerations of γz,k , γz,kl point towards the origin in the complex geodesics that contain them and the vector fields ∂ ∂ ∂ , + ∂rk ∂rk ∂rl point away from the origin. To prove (2), let φz,k , φz,kl be the complex geodesics considered before. Then the inverse images of the curves γz,k , γz,kl with respect to such maps are easily seen to be circles in D centered at the origin with Euclidean radius: rk2 + rl2 rk rk rk sk = = and s = = , kl Rk Rkl 1− r2 1− r2 j =k j
j =k,l j
respectively. Next, we observe that the geodesic curvature C(s) of the circle with Euclidean radius s in the unit disk D with the metric: 4(dx2 + dy 2 ) (1 − (x2 + y 2 ))2 is given by the formula:
1 + s2 . 2s This follows from two facts found in [2]. The hyperbolic radius ρ of a circle centered at the origin satisfies cosh2 (ρ/2) = 1/(1 − s2 ), where s is the Euclidean radius. And the geodesic curvature of such a circle is given by coth(ρ). The first can be C(s) =
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
91
deduce from the expression for the hyperbolic distance found in subsection 1.4.1 of [2] and the second is stated in subsection 1.4.2 of the same reference. Given the above formula for C(s) a simple substitution provides the required expressions for Ck and Ckl . Finally, (3) is a consequence of these expressions. We recall that the velocity and acceleration of curves in a manifold do not change when we renormalize the metric of the manifold by a constant multiple. More generally, the second fundamental form of a submanifold does not change either by such renormalizations (see [9]). However, the geodesic curvatures as defined above involve the metric and so they are rescaled when we renormalize the metric by a constant. In particular, for the Bergman metric on Bn (i.e. without normalizing to have sectional curvature in the interval [−1, −1/4]) which is given by n n l k z z dz ⊗ dz n + 1 k l . n n ds2Bn = dz k ⊗ dz k + 1 − k=1 |zk |2 1 − k=1 |zk |2 k=1 k,l=1 (0), γz,k (0) and Qk (z) = II ∂θ∂k , ∂θ∂k as defined above the tangent vectors γz,k z z have the same values, but computing the geodesic curvatures of γz,k involve applying a renormalized metric and the corresponding values are rescaled. In the next result we write down the geodesic curvatures of the curves γz,k for the Bergman metric and describe its asymptotic behavior. We also express such curvatures in terms of the second fundamental form II . These facts will allow us to compare our present situation with a more general asymptotic behavior discussed in the next section. Theorem 8.7. Let hBn be the Riemannian metric associated to the Bergman metric of Bn given as above and denote with · Bn the norm that it defines on tangent k (z) of the curve γz,k at n the geodesic curvature C vectors. Then, for every z ∈ B z for the metric hBn satisfies the relations: −2 −1 k (z) = − 1. C ∂θ∂k ∂r∂k hBn Qk (z), ∂r∂k , k (z) = 2. C
z Bn √ 2 Ck (z), n+1
z Bn
z
where Ck is given as in Theorem 8.6.
(z) is, up to a sign, the norm of the orthogonal projection of the In particular, C −2k vector ∂θ∂k Qk (z) onto ∂r∂k with respect to hBn . And we also have: z Bn
z
k (z) → √ 2 , C n+1 n for any u ∈ ∂B such that uk = 0.
as z → u.
Proof. The first relation follows from the definition of the geodesic curvature as above applied to the new metric hBn , the fact that: ∂ ∂ Qk (z) = II , ∂θk z ∂θk z
92
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
k . and the corresponding relation of (1) in Theorem 8.6 for C The second relation is a consequence of the fact that hBn = n+1 4 h for h the Riemannian metric on Bn rescaled so that its sectional curvature lies in [−1, −1/4]. We specify now the results obtained in Sections 2 and 3 for the unit ball Bn . The base τ (Bn ) of Bn has obviously the form τ (Bn ) = {r = (r1 , . . . , rn ) : r2 = r12 + · · · + rn2 ∈ [0, 1)}. As a custom in operator theory (see, for example, [15]), introduce the family of weights µλ (|z|) = cλ (1 − |z|2 )λ , where the normalizing constant cλ =
Γ(n + λ + 1) π n Γ(λ + 1)
is chosen so that µλ (|z|)dv(z) is a probability measure in Bn . Introduce L2 (Bn , µλ ) and its Bergman subspace A2λ (Bn ) = A2µλ (Bn ). It is well known (see, for example, [15]), that the Bergman projection Bλ of L2 (Bn , µλ ) onto A2λ (Bn ) has the form (Bλ ϕ)(z) = ϕ(ζ) Kλ (z, ζ) µλ (|ζ|)dv(ζ), Bn
where the (weighted) Bergman kernel is given by Kλ (z, ζ) =
(1 −
1 . n+1+λ k=1 zk ζ k )
n
To calculate the constant αp , p = (p1 , . . . , pn ) ∈ Zn+ , see (2.1), consider the integral p 2 |z | µλ (|z|)dv(z) = |z1 |2p1 · · · · · |zn |2pn µλ (r)dv(z) Bn
Bn
= =
n n dtk r12p1 · · · · · rn2pn µλ (r) rk drk itk τ (Bn)
Tn k=1 (2π)n α−2 p .
From the other hand side, by [15], Lemma 1.11, we have p! Γ(n + λ + 1) , |z p |2 µλ (|z|)dv(z) = Γ(n + |p| + λ + 1) n B that is,
1/2 (2π)n Γ(n + |p| + λ + 1) αp = . p! Γ(n + λ + 1) Now Theorem 3.1 for the case of the unit ball reads as follows.
k=1
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
93
Theorem 8.8. Let a = a(r) be a bounded measurable separately radial function. Then the Toeplitz operator Ta acting on A2λ (Bn ) is unitary equivalent to the multiplication operator γa I = R Ta R∗ acting on l2 (Zn+ ), where R and R∗ are given by (2.3) and (2.2) respectively. The sequence γa,λ = {γa,λ (p)}p∈Zn+ is given by γa,λ (p) = =
n 2n Γ(n + |p| + λ + 1) 2p 2 λ a(r) r (1 − r ) rk drk p! Γ(λ + 1) τ (Bn ) k=1 √ Γ(n + |p| + λ + 1) a( r) rp (1 − (r1 + · · · + rn ))λ dr, p ∈ Zn+ , p! Γ(λ + 1) ∆(Bn )
where ∆(Bn ) = {r = √ (r1 , . . . , rn ) : r1 + · · · + rn ∈ [0, 1), rk ≥ 0, k = 1, . . . , n}, √ √ dr = dr1 · · · drn , and r = ( r1 , . . . , rn ).
9. Asymptotic geometric behavior of the Tn -orbits in Reinhardt domains As before, let D be a bounded logarithmically convex complete Reinhardt domain with Bergman metric ds2D , associated Riemannian metric hD and with · D denoting the norm defined by hD on tangent vectors. Also, we will continue denoting with II the second fundamental form of the As in the case of the unit ball, by Proposition 5.4, foliation O by Tn -orbits in D. II is completely determined by the vector fields: ∂ ∂ , Qk = II ∂θk ∂θk ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ Qkl = II + , + . ∂θk ∂θl ∂θk ∂θl The norm of such vector fields was computed in the previous section for the unit ball and such norm was related to the geodesic curvature of suitable circles contained in complex geodesics. In this section we will study the asymptotic behavior towards the boundary of similar values for a more general Reinhardt domain. As in the case of the unit ball, on our given Reinhardt domain, we will and k = 1, . . . , n the curve: consider for every z ∈ D γz,k (s) = (z1 , . . . , zk−1 , eis zk , zk+1 , . . . , zn ). Then, the proofs of Lemmas 8.3 and 8.5 apply to our current more general setup without change to conclude that γz,k is an integral curve of ∂θ∂k and that we can write: Qk (z) = II (γz,k (0), γz,k (0)) = γz,k (0).
As in the case of the unit ball, to better understand the asymptotic behavior of the values of Qk one considers its normalized value obtained by dividing by
94
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
γz,k (0)2D = ∂θ∂k |z 2D , i.e.: −2 ∂ −2 (0) γz,k ∂ ∂ Qk (z) = ∂ II , , = ∂θk z ∂θk z ∂θk z ∂θk z γz,k (0)2D D D (0) = ∂θ∂k |z and not on which now depends only on the direction associated to γz,k −2 its magnitude. Moreover, the above identities show that ∂θ∂k Qk (z) measures z D both the extrinsic curvature of the foliation O, given by II , and the curvature of γz,k , given by its acceleration. For the unit ball it was proved that such vector field is collinear with ∂r∂k , and so to measure its magnitude in that case it was enough to consider the norm of its orthogonal projection onto ∂r∂k . In our more general −2 setup, ∂θ∂k Qk may not be collinear with ∂r∂k , but we can still consider the D properties of the orthogonal projection of the first onto the latter. and k = 1, . . . , n: The previous discussion suggests to define for every z ∈ D ∂ −2 ∂ −1 ∂ Ck (z) = − hD Qk (z), , ∂θk z ∂rk z ∂rk z D
D
which thus provides a measure of both the extrinsic curvature of the foliation O and the curvature of γz,k . on D Note that for the unit ball endowed with the Bergman metric, Theorem 8.7 k (z) is precisely the geodesic curvature of γz,k in the complex geodesic shows that C φz,k considered in the previous section. Moreover, such Theorem 8.7 describes the k towards the boundary in the case of the unit ball. The asymptotic behavior of C main goal of this section is to prove that such asymptotic behavior remains valid for suitable domains. More precisely, we have the following result. We recall that D is said to have δ as a defining function if D = {z ∈ Cn : δ(z) < 0}. Theorem 9.1. Let D be a bounded strictly pseudoconvex complete Reinhardt domain with smooth boundary and with a smooth defining function δ. Then: k (z) → √ 2 , C as z → u, n+1 for any u ∈ ∂D such that uk = 0 and
∂δ ∂rk (u)
= 0.
We observe that for the unit ball we can take δ(z) = −1 + nj=1 |zj |2 = n ∂δ −1 + j=1 rj2 , and so the conditions uk = 0 and ∂r (u) = 0 are equivalent in this k case. Note that Theorems 9.1 and 8.7 together show that, under suitable convexity and smoothness conditions on the domain D, the extrinsic geometry of the foliation has exactly the same asymptotic behavior towards the boundary as the O in D one found for the unit ball, at least with respect to the values of Qk . To prove Theorem 9.1 we will use the expression of the metric hD in terms of the Bergman kernel KD from Theorem 7.2 and the following celebrated result by
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
95
C. Fefferman that describes the Bergman kernel of strictly pseudoconvex domains with smooth boundary. This result appears as a Corollary in page 45 of [1]. Theorem 9.2 (C. Fefferman). If D is a strictly pseudoconvex domain with smooth boundary and smooth defining function δ, then there exists ϕ, ψ ∈ C ∞ (D) with ϕ nonvanishing in ∂D, such that: KD (z, z) = ϕ(z)(−δ(z))−(n+1) + ψ(z) log(−δ(z)) for every z ∈ D. k in terms of the Bergman kernel KD . We first express the value of C Lemma 9.3. Let D be a bounded logarithmically convex complete Reinhardt domain with Bergman kernel KD . Then: k = C , C C
where C
= +
C
=
2
∂KD ∂rk
3 − 3KD
3 ∂KD ∂ 2 KD 3KD 2 ∂ KD + KD − 2 ∂rk ∂rk ∂rk3 rk
∂KD ∂rk
2
2 ∂ 2 KD 3KD K 2 ∂KD + 2D , 2 rk ∂rk rk ∂rk
32 2 ∂KD ∂ 2 KD KD ∂KD − + KD + , ∂rk ∂rk2 rk ∂rk
and where KD and its partial derivatives are computed for the function z → KD (z, z). r
Proof. Let us denote with Γθjk θl , . . . , the Schwarz-Christoffel symbols for the LeviCivita connection of the Riemannian manifold (D, hD ) and with hθk θl , . . . , the coordinate functions of the metric. By Corollary 7.9 and the definition of II it follows that: n ∂ Γrθlk θk . Qk (z) = ∂rl l=1
By using the well known formula that expresses the Schwarz-Christoffel symbols in terms of the functions hθk θl , . . . , and its partial derivatives (see [9]) we have: Γrθlk θk = −
n
1 rl rj ∂hθk θk h , 2 j=1 ∂rj
where, as usual, hrl rj denotes the entries of the inverse of the matrix (hrl rj )lj . We have used here that, by Theorem 7.2, the functions hθk rl = 0. Hence, it follows
96
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
that: k C
IEOT
∂ −2 ∂ −1 hD Qk (z), ∂ = − ∂θk z ∂rk z ∂rk z D D n 1 −1 −1/2 ∂hθk θk = h h hrk rl hrl rj 2 θ k θ k rk rk ∂rj l,j=1
1 −1 −1/2 ∂hθk θk h . h 2 θk θk rk rk ∂rk
=
Again by Theorem 7.2 we have hrk rk = Fkk and hθk θk = rk2 Fkk , where: 1 ∂2 1 ∂ log KD (z, z), + Fkk (z) = 4 ∂rk2 rk ∂rk from which we obtain: k = C
1 3/2
2Fkk
∂Fkk 2 + Fkk . ∂rk rk
(9.1)
(9.2)
kk Then the result follows by computing Fkk and ∂F ∂rk in terms of KD with the use of equation (9.1) and replacing into equation (9.2).
The following result can be proved easily using induction. Lemma 9.4. Let D be a strictly pseudoconvex domain with smooth boundary and smooth defining function δ. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ C ∞ (D) be the smooth functions from Theorem 9.2. Then, for every k = 1, . . . , n and j ≥ 0 we have: ∂ j KD ∂rkj
=
j
−(n+1+l)
ϕjl (−δ)
l=0
+
j
ψjl δ −l + ψj0 log(−δ),
l=1
where the partial derivatives are computed for the function z → KD (z, z), and the functions ϕjl , ψjl are given inductively by the following conditions: 1. ϕ00 = ϕ, ψ00 = ψ, 2. ϕjl = ψjl = 0 if either j or l is negative, 3. for j ≥ 1: ϕjj ψjj
∂δ ∂rk ∂δ = −(j − 1)ψj−1,j−1 , ∂rk = (n + j)ϕj−1,j−1
4. for 0 ≤ l < j: ϕjl
=
ψjl
=
∂δ ∂ϕj−1,l + (n + l)ϕj−1,l−1 ∂rk ∂rk ∂δ ∂ψj−1,l − (l − 1)ψj−1,l−1 , ∂rk ∂rk
Vol. 59 (2007)
Toeplitz Operators on the Reinhardt Domains
97
k in terms of the defining function The next result provides an expression of C δ. We observe that Theorem 9.1 is now an easy consequence of such expression. Theorem 9.5. Let D be a bounded strictly pseudoconvex complete Reinhardt domain with smooth boundary and with a smooth defining function δ. If ϕ is the function given by Theorem 9.2, then: k = C
a(−δ)−(3n+6) + bδ −(3n+5) (c(−δ)−(2n+4) + dδ −(2n+3) )3/2
where a, b, c, d ∈ C ∞ (D) satisfy: on D, 3 ∂δ 1. a = 2(n + 1)ϕ3 ∂r , k 2 ∂δ , 2. c = (n + 1)ϕ2 ∂r k 3. b, d extend continuously to {z ∈ D : zk = 0}. k in terms of log(−δ) and powers of Proof. We use Lemmas 9.3 and 9.4 to express C Then the result is simply a matter of identifying δ with smooth coefficients in D. the coefficients in such expression. The functions a, c correspond to the lowest powers of δ in the numerator and the denominator, respectively. The functions b, d involve terms of the form δ l and δ l log(−δ) with l ≥ 1 and powers of 1/rk , all of which can be extended continuously to {z ∈ D : zk = 0}.
References [1] C. Fefferman. The Bergman kernel and biholomorphic mappings of pseudoconvex domains. Invent. Math., 26:1–65, 1974. [2] W.M. Goldman. Complex hyperbolic geometry. Oxford Mathematical Monographs. Oxford Science Publications. The Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press, New York, 1999. [3] S. Grudsky, A. Karapetyants, and N. Vasilevski. Toeplitz operators on the unit ball in Cn with radial symbols. J. Operator Theory, 49:325–346, 2003. [4] S. Grudsky, R. Quiroga-Barranco, and N. Vasilevski. Commutative C ∗ -algebras of Toeplitz operators and quantization on the unit disk. J. Funct. Anal., 234(1):1–44, 2006. [5] S. Helgason. Differential geometry, Lie groups, and symmetric spaces. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2001. [6] S. Kobayashi and K. Nomizu. Foundation of Differential Geometry, volume I. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1996. [7] S. Kobayashi and K. Nomizu. Foundations of differential Geometry, volume II. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1996. [8] P. Molino. Riemannian foliations. Birkhauser Boston, Inc., Boston, MA, 1988. [9] B. O’Neill. Semi-Riemannian geometry. With applications to relativity. Academic Press, Inc., New York, 1983.
98
Quiroga-Barranco and Vasilevski
IEOT
[10] R. Quiroga-Barranco. Isometric actions of simple Lie groups on pseudoRiemannian manifolds. Ann. of Math., 164:941-969, 2006. [11] R. M. Range. Holomorphic functions and integral representations in several complex variables. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1986. [12] N. L. Vasilevski. Toeplitz operators on the Bergman spaces: Inside-the-domain effects. Contemp. Math., 289:79–146, 2001. [13] N. L. Vasilevski. Bergman space structure, commutative algebras of Toeplitz operators and hyperbolic geometry. Integr. Equat. Oper. Th., 46:235–251, 2003. [14] F. W. Warner. Foundations of differentiable manifolds and Lie groups. SpringerVerlag, New York-Berlin, 1983. [15] K. Zhu. Spaces of Holomorphic Functions in the Unit Ball. Springer Verlag, 2005. Raul Quiroga-Barranco Centro de Investigaci´ on en Matem´ aticas Apartado Postal 402 36000, Guanajuato, Gto. M´exico e-mail:
[email protected] Nikolai Vasilevski Departamento de Matem´ aticas CINVESTAV Apartado Postal 14-740 07000, M´exico, D.F. M´exico e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: March 14, 2006 Revised: March 3, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 99–128 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010099-30, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1504-2
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators with Operator-valued Symbols Patrik Wahlberg Abstract. We study the short-time Fourier transformation, modulation spaces, Gabor representations and time-frequency localization operators, for functions and tempered distributions that have as range space a Banach or a Hilbert space. In the Banach space case the theory of modulation spaces contains some modifications of the scalar-valued theory, depending on the Banach space. In the Hilbert space case the modulation spaces have properties similar to the scalar-valued case and the Gabor frame theory essentially works. For localization operators in this context symbols are operator-valued. We generalize two results from the scalar-valued theory on continuity on certain modulation spaces when the symbol belongs to an Lp,q space and M ∞ , respectively. The first result is true for any Banach space as range space, and the second result is true for any Hilbert space as range space. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47G30, 42B35; Secondary 47B38, 35S99. Keywords. Time-frequency analysis, vector-valued modulation spaces, localization operators, pseudodifferential operators.
1. Introduction The theory of the short-time Fourier transform (STFT) and modulation spaces of scalar-valued functions and tempered distributions is a very well developed theory of representation of tempered distibutions in the time-frequency (phase) space [22]. Define the modulation and translation operators by (Mξ f )(x) := ei2πξx f (x) and (Tt f )(x) := f (x− t), respectively. For a fixed so called window function g ∈ S(Rd ), the STFT f → Vg f is the localized Fourier transform defined by Vg f (t, ξ) = f, Mξ Tt g = f (x)ei2πxξ g(x − t)dx. (1.1) Rd
100
Wahlberg
IEOT
The STFT is unitary L2 (Rd ) → L2 (R2d ) provided gL2 = 1, a topological isomorphism S(Rd ) → S(R2d ), and extends to a topological isomorphism S (Rd ) → S (R2d ). The inverse mapping is given by ∗ Vγ h = h(t, ξ)Mξ Tt γdtdξ, γ ∈ S(Rd ), γ, g = 1, (1.2) R2d
where Vγ∗ h in general is interpreted as the functional h(t, ξ)Mξ Tt γ, ϕdtdξ, ϕ ∈ S(Rd ). Vγ∗ h, ϕ = R2d
p,q The map (1.1) is also invertible on the family of modulation spaces Mm (Rd ), 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞, which were invented and developed 1983 by Feichtinger [12]. p,q (Rd ) = {f ∈ The weighted modulation spaces are Banach spaces defined by Mm d p,q 2d p,q 2d S (R ); Vg f ∈ Lm (R )} where Lm (R ) is the weighted mix-normed space of all measurable h : R2d → C such that q/p 1/q hLp,q = |h(t, ξ)m(t, ξ)|p dt dξ < ∞. m Rd
Rd
The modulation spaces thus quantifies the asymptotic decay of f ∈ S (Rd ) in the time and frequency variables. For the family of modulation spaces a discretized version of the map Vg is also invertible and there exists a so called Gabor frame expansion [6, 22] p,q f, Mβn Tαk gMβn Tαk γ, f ∈ Mm (Rd ), (1.3) f= k∈Zd n∈Zd
under certain conditions on the functions g, γ and the time-frequency lattice parameters α, β > 0 discovered by Feichtinger, Gr¨ ochenig, Leinert [15, 22, 24] and others. The inversion formula (1.2) suggests operators of the form g,γ (Aa f )(x) = a(t, ξ)Vg f (t, ξ)Mξ Tt γ(x)dtdξ R2d
which performs a multiplicative modification in the time-frequency domain, using a symbol a, before the distribution is reconstructed by integration. Such operators are called (time-frequency) localization operators, sometimes also Toeplitz or Anti-Wick operators, and they are a special case of pseudodifferential operators. The different names reflect that they have been studied in the signal analysis, mathematical and physical literature, as signal filtering operators [8, 45], pseudodifferential operators [17, 45], and quantization rules [17], respectively. They have recently attracted much attention [5, 7, 43, 44, 45], not least with respect to continuity when they act on modulation spaces. Cordero, Gr¨ochenig [7] and Toft [43] have proved that the large space of symbols M ∞ (R2d ) corresponds to operators that are bounded on all modulation spaces M p,q (Rd ), 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞. Also the discrete expansion (1.3) can be used to define localization operators, using discrete symbols, called Gabor multiplier operators [16]. More information on the theory
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
101
and applications (eg in pseudodifferential calculus) of modulation spaces can be found in [14, 22, 23, 43, 44]. In this paper we generalize some of these results and replace scalar-valued functions and tempered distributions by vector-valued functions and tempered distributions taking values in a Banach space B or a Hilbert space H. First we discuss STFT and modulation space theory for vector-valued tempered distributions. It turns out that a large part of the theory of scalar-valued modulation spaces is possible to generalize to the H valued case, with certain modification in the B valued case depending on the Banach space B. This is essentially due to the fact that Parseval’s formula is true for B-valued L2 spaces if and only if B is isomorphic to a Hilbert space. The identity L2 = M 2 which is true in the scalar-valued case generalizes to the vector-valued case if and only if the vector space is a Hilbert space. In the general Banach space case this identity is replaced by the embeddings Lp ∩ FLp → M p , 1 ≤ p ≤ r, which depends on the Fourier type r ≤ 2 of the Banach space B. There is a generalization of the duality result (M p,q ) = M p ,q , 1 ≤ p, q < ∞ ([22, Thm. 11.3.6]), which is true when B is a reflexive Banach space and p = q = 1 or 1 < p < ∞ and 1 ≤ q < ∞. For a corresponding discussion, of greater depth, on the properties of vector-valued Sobolev and Besov spaces we refer to [38]. Furthermore we state that vector-valued modulation spaces can be characterized as the Fourier transform of Wiener amalgam spaces with discrete global component [10, 12, 13], similarly to the scalar-valued case. We discuss the concept of weak stationarity (with application eg to stochastic processes) in the Hvalued case and obtain the result that each weakly stationary H-valued tempered ∞,1 . distribution belongs to a weighted modulation space of the type M1⊗m We also discuss Gabor frame expansions for H-valued functions and tempered distributions and conclude that the Gabor frame theory for scalar-valued modulation spaces is possible to generalize to H-valued modulation spaces almost without modification. Finally we treat localization, Weyl and Gabor multiplier operators in this context, using an operator-valued symbol. We formulate generalizations of recent results on continuity of localization operators acting on modulation spaces, developed in the context of scalar-valued distributions and symbols. First we state that a result of Boggiatto’s [5] on continuity between certain modulation spaces of a localization operator, if the symbol belongs to Lp,q , generalizes to B-valued modulation spaces, regardless of B. By an example we show that there exists Banach spaces B1 , B2 and a symbol in L∞ such that the localization operator is not bounded from the B1 -valued L2 space to the B2 -valued L2 space, which can not happen in the scalar-valued case. Secondly we generalize the above mentioned result by Cordero and Gr¨ ochenig [7] on continuity of a localization operator, acting on any modulation space, provided the symbol belongs to M ∞ . We prove that the result is valid for H-valued modulation spaces. We also obtain a generalization of a result of Gr¨ ochenig and Heil [22, 23] on continuity of Weyl operators on all
102
Wahlberg
IEOT
modulation spaces provided the symbol belongs to the Sj¨ ostrand space M ∞,1 , to the context of H-valued modulation spaces and operator-valued symbols. The motivating background of this work consists of two directions is contemporary analysis. On the one hand, pseudodifferential calculus for scalar-valued functions, which classically is studied with symbols in Fr´echet spaces of smooth functions [17, 27, 40], has since the work of Sj¨ostrand [41] been extended to symbols in modulation spaces, which are Banach spaces of limited regularity (see eg [5, 7, 22, 23, 41, 43, 44]). One of Sj¨ostrand’s results says that symbols in M ∞,1 give rise to bounded operators on L2 , which was extended by Gr¨ ochenig and Heil who proved boundedness on all modulation spaces M p,q , 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞, for the same class of symbols. On the other hand, there has independently of this trend appeared several papers dealing with new versions of classical Fourier multiplier theorems, where the operator act on scalar-valued function spaces, to vector-valued function spaces and operator-valued symbols [2, 19, 20, 29]. For example, versions of Mihlin’s multiplier theorem on conditions on a symbol that are sufficient for continuity on Lp spaces, have been proved for vector-valued Besov spaces by Amann, Girardi, Weis and Hyt¨onen [2, 20, 29]. Fourier multiplier operators are a special case of pseudodifferential operators, which also have been studied in the vector-valued context [30, 36]. These results have applications eg in PDE. Embeddings between scalar-valued Besov and modulation spaces have been proved by Toft [43]. It is natural to combine the above mentioned research directions and investigate pseudodifferential operators with operator-valued symbols in modulation spaces, acting on vector-valued modulation spaces, which is the topic of the present study. For this purpose we first need to examine the properties of vector-valued modulation spaces. There is also a motivation from the point of view of certain applications in engineering. In fact, pseudodifferential operators are used as mathematical models of mobile radio channels [42]. Such channels are often assumed to be stochastic [34]. If one assumes that the signals to be transmitted also are stochastic processes, then the framework presented here may be a candidate for a model of signal transmission, since stochastic processes may be seen as vector-valued functions where the vector space is a space of stochastic variables. 1.1. Definitions and notation We denote Lebesgue measure by µ, the Schwartz space by S(Rd ) and the smooth functions of compact support by Cc∞ (Rd ). The Fourier transformation of f ∈ S(Rd ) is defined by F f (ξ) = f(ξ) = f (t)e−i2πtξ dt. Rd
Partial Fourier transformation with respect to variable j is denoted Fj . The joint modulation-translation operator is sometimes denoted π(z) = Mξ Tt , z = (t, ξ) ∈ R2d . Discrete subgroups (lattices) of R2d of the form {(αk, βn)}k,n∈Zd , α, β > 0,
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
103
will be denoted Λ. The (extended) Wigner distribution [17, 22] of a function f ∈ S(R2d ) is defined by f (t + τ /2, t − τ /2)e−i2πξτ dτ = F2 (f ◦ κ)(t, ξ) (1.4) W (f )(t, ξ) = Rd
with κ(t, τ ) = (t+τ /2, t−τ /2). When f = g⊗g we write W (g⊗g) = W (g) (ambiguous but clear from context) which is the proper Wigner distribution [17, 22]. We denote coordinate reflection by f(x) = f (−x). In estimates we denote by C a positive constant which may change value over inequalities. The tempered distributions are denoted S (Rd ), and are in this paper assumed to be antilinear (ie conjugate linear), in order to be compatible with the L2 (Rd ) inner product. The bracket ·, · will denote, depending on context, (i) action of an antilinear scalar-valued tempered distribution, (ii) action of an antilinear Banach space valued tempered distribution, or (iii) the Lebesgue or Bochner integral f, g = Rd f (x)g(x)dx where in general f is vector-valued and g is scalar-valued. The consistent definition of the := f, ϕ, ϕ ∈ S(Rd ). SomeFourier transformation of f ∈ S (Rd ) is then f, ϕ times we emphasize the space on which a distribution acts by writing eg ·, ·S(Rd ) . The map (1.4) extends by duality to a continuous map W : S (R2d ) → S (R2d ). For the range space of vector-valued distributions we use B to denote a Banach space and H to denote a Hilbert space. The topological dual of a Banach (or more generally a linear topological) space B is denoted B , the duality (·, ·)B ,B = (·, ·)B , and the Hilbert space inner product (·, ·)H , linear in the first and antilinear in the second argument. In order to be compatible with the Hilbert space inner product, (·, ·)B is defined to be linear in the first and antilinear in the second argument. For an exponent p, 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, we denote the conjugate exponent p , which fulfills 1/p + 1/p = 1. The set of bounded linear transformations from a Banach space B1 to another Banach space B2 is denoted L(B1 , B2 ) and L(B, B) := L(B). Capital letters will often denote Banach space valued
functions or distributions. A function F is simple if it is a finite sum F = j xj χAj where xj ∈ B, χA denotes indicator function, Aj ∈ B(Rd ) (the Borel σ-algebra) and µ(Aj ) < ∞ for all j. A function F is strongly measurable if there exists a sequence of simple functions Fn such that limn→∞ Fn (t) − F (t)B = 0 for almost all t ∈ Rd . It is weakly measurable if t → (x , F (t))B is measurable for each x ∈ B , and it is almost separably valued if there exists a null set NF ⊂ Rd such that the range space F (Rd \ NF ) ⊂ B is separable. According to Pettis’s measurability theorem [9] F is strongly measurable if and only if F is weakly measurable and almost separably valued. The Bochner integral of a B-valued function F is well defined provided it is strongly measurable and Rd F (t)B dt < ∞ [9]. For each 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞ the Lebesgue-Bochner space Lp (Rd , B) [9] is defined as the set of strongly measurable functions F : Rd → B such that F Lp(Rd ,B) := ( Rd F (t)pB dt)1/p < ∞, with the standard modification when p = ∞. For F : Rd → B and G : Rd → B one defines the covariance function by (1.5) σF G (t, s) = F (t), G(s) B , t, s ∈ Rd .
104
Wahlberg
IEOT
The Schwartz space of functions F : Rd → B such that supt∈Rd tα ∂ β F (t)B < ∞ for all multi-indices α and β is denoted S(Rd , B). There exists a theory of distributions which take values in a locally convex topological vector space, developed by L. Schwartz [39]. We will however restrict to tempered distributions taking values in a Banach space [1, 18, 28, 31, 32]. Such a distribution, denoted F ∈ S (Rd , B), is here defined as a bounded antilinear map F : S(Rd ) → B, ie there exists positive constants C, N, M such that F, ϕB ≤ C ϕα,β (1.6) |α|≤N
|β|≤M
where α, β are multi-indices and ϕα,β := supt∈Rd |∂ α (tβ ϕ(t))| are seminorms on S(Rd ). We have the duality result S(Rd , B) = S (Rd , B ), where the duality is induced by f ⊗ x , ϕ ⊗ x := f, ϕ(x , x)B , f ∈ S (Rd ), ϕ ∈ S(Rd ), x ∈ B , x ∈ B [1]. If B is reflexive then S(Rd , B) is reflexive as well [1]. For F ∈ S (Rd , B ) and G ∈ S (Rd , B) the covariance distribution σF G is defined by (1.7) σF G , ϕ ⊗ ψ = F, ϕ, G, ψ B , ϕ, ψ ∈ S(Rd ), for rank-one elements ϕ ⊗ ψ ∈ S(R2d ). According to the Schwartz kernel theorem [18, 37] one can extend σF G to a distribution σ ∈ S (R2d ). A function d F ∈ Lp (Rd , B), 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, defines an element in S (R , B) by the Bochner integral F, ϕ = Rd F (t)ϕ(t)dt, which admits consistency between (1.5) and (1.7). The Fourier transform of a function F ∈ L1 (Rd , B) is defined by a Bochner Fourier integral and the Fourier transform F ∈ L∞ (Rd , B). The Hausdorff-Young inequality is however in general not valid [19, 20, 35]. A Banach space B is said to be of Fourier type r, 1 ≤ r ≤ 2, if the Fourier transform F : Lr (Rd , B) → Lr (Rd , B). This notion was introduced by Peetre [35]. It follows by interpolation that if B is of Fourier type r then it is also of Fourier type p for all p in the interval 1 ≤ p ≤ r. Every Banach space has Fourier type at least one. By a result of Kwapie´ n [33] a Banach space B has Fourier type 2 if and only if it is isomorphic to a Hilbert space. Hence Parseval’s formula holds for L2 (Rd , B) if and only if B is isomorphic to a Hilbert space.
2. The STFT of vector-valued tempered distributions
The STFT of F ∈ Lp (Rd , B) with respect to a window function g ∈ Lp (Rd ) is defined by the Bochner integral F (s)ei2πξs g(s − t)ds = F (F Tt g)(ξ) = F, Mξ Tt g. (2.1) Vg F (t, ξ) = Rd
Following the definition of the STFT of scalar-valued tempered distributions [22], the STFT of a vector valued F ∈ S (Rd , B) is for g ∈ S(Rd ) defined by the right hand side of (2.1) where ·, · denotes distribution action instead of Bochner
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
105
integral. The following two lemmas generalize results for scalar-valued tempered distributions and will be useful in later sections. Lemma 2.1. If F ∈ S (Rd , B) and g ∈ S(Rd ) then Vg F ∈ C ∞ (R2d , B), Vg F is strongly measurable, and there exists an integer N > 0 and C > 0 such that Vg F (t, ξ)B ≤ C(1 + |t| + |ξ|)N , (t, ξ) ∈ R2d .
(2.2)
Proof. By [26, Thm. 2.1.3] (slightly modified) Vg F ∈ C ∞ (R2d , B), which implies that Vg F is strongly measurable. By (1.6) there exists positive C, M1 and M2 such that F, Mξ Tt gB ≤ C Mξ Tt gα,β . (2.3) |α|≤M1
|β|≤M2
Lemma 11.2.1 in [22] gives the bound Mξ Tt gα,β ≤ C(1 + |t| + |ξ|)2 max(|α|,|β|) , which in combination with (2.3) gives (2.2). Lemma 2.2. If F1 ∈ S(Rd , B ), F2 ∈ S(Rd , B) and g1 , g2 ∈ S(Rd ) then (F1 (x), F2 (x))B dx g1 , g2 L2 (Rd ) . Vg1 F1 (z), Vg2 F2 (z) B dz = R2d
Rd
Proof. We obtain from (2.1), since σF1 F2 ∈ S(R2d ), Vg1 F1 (z), Vg2 F2 (z) B dz R2d = ··· σF1 F2 (x, y)e−i2πξ(x−y) g1 (x − t)g2 (y − t)dxdydtdξ R4d = σF1 F2 (x, x)dx g1 , g2 L2 (Rd ) . Rd
Density arguments [1] now gives the following generalization of the orthogonality relations of the STFT [22] from scalar-valued L2 functions to H-valued L2 functions. The inner product in the Hilbert space L2 (Rd , H) is (F, G)L2 (Rd ,H) = Rd (F (t), G(t))H dt. Corollary 2.3. If F1 , F2 ∈ L2 (Rd , H) and g1 , g2 ∈ L2 (Rd ) then (Vg1 F1 , Vg2 F2 )L2 (R2d ,H) = (F1 , F2 )L2 (Rd ,H) g1 , g2 L2 (Rd ) . Given F ∈ L2 (R2d , H) and γ ∈ L2 (Rd ) we define for G ∈ L2 (Rd , H) (Uγ F, G) := (F (z), Vγ G(z))H dz. R2d
Then Uγ F is a continuous antilinear functional on L2 (Rd , H), since by Cor. 2.3 |(Uγ F, G)| ≤ F L2 (R2d ,H) GL2 (Rd ,H) γL2 (Rd ) . Since L2 (Rd , H) is a Hilbert space there exists an element, denoted R2d F (z)π(z)γdz ∈ L2 (Rd , H), such that (Uγ F, G) = F (z)π(z)γdz, G L2 (Rd ,H) . R2d
106
Wahlberg
IEOT
The next result generalizes [22, Cor. 3.2.3] and says that F ∈ L2 (Rd , H) can be reconstructed from Vg F . Proposition 2.4. If g, γ ∈ L2 (Rd ) fulfill γ, g = 0 then −1 F = γ, g Vg F (z)π(z)γdz, F ∈ L2 (Rd , H).
(2.4)
R2d
Proof. Let G ∈ L2 (Rd , H). Then γ, g−1 Vg F (z)π(z)γdz, G L2 (Rd ,H) R2d = γ, g−1 (Vg F (z), Vγ G(z))H dz = (F, G)L2 (Rd ,H) R2d
2
by Cor. 2.3. Since G ∈ L (Rd , H) is arbitrary (2.4) follows.
Next we extend Prop. 2.4 and show that the STFT is invertible on S (Rd , B). The proof is similar to the corresponding result for S (Rd ) [22]. Define for a strongly measurable F : R2d → B and γ ∈ S(Rd ) the B-valued map F (z)π(z)γ, ϕdz, ϕ ∈ S(Rd ), (2.5) Vγ∗ F, ϕ := R2d
and denote this Vγ∗ F =
F (z)π(z)γdz. R2d
We can define F0 := γ, g−1 Vγ∗ Vg F , ie F0 , ϕ = γ, g−1 R2d Vg F (z)π(z)γ, ϕdz, since Vg F is strongly measurable by Lemma 2.1. In order to show that F0 ∈ S (Rd , B) we estimate using (2.2) Vg F (z)B |Vγ ϕ(z)| dz F0 , ϕB ≤ |γ, g|−1 R2d (2.6) ≤ C sup (1 + |z|)N +2d+1 |Vγ ϕ(z)| . z
According to [22, Cor. 11.2.6] the last expression is a seminorm on ϕ ∈ S(Rd ), and hence F0 ∈ S (Rd , B). Proposition 2.5. If g, γ ∈ S(Rd ) fulfill γ, g = 0 then F = F0 := γ, g−1 Vγ∗ Vg F, F ∈ S (Rd , B). (2.7) Proof. For ϕ ∈ S(Rd ) we have ϕ = g, γ−1 R2d Vγ ϕ(z)π(z)gdz. Thus, by a generalization of the tensor product rule f ⊗ 1 = 1 ⊗ f for f ∈ S (Rd ) [26] to f ∈ S (Rd , B) [38], we have −1 F, π(z)gVγ ϕ(z)dz F, ϕ = g, γ R2d = γ, g−1 Vg F (z)π(z)γ, ϕdz = F0 , ϕ. R2d
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
107
p,q 3. Modulation spaces Mm (Rd , B)
The concept of weighted mix-normed spaces of scalar-valued functions [3] can be generalized to weighted mix-normed spaces of vector-valued functions F : R2d → 2d B. For 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞, F ∈ Lp,q m (R , B) if F is strongly measurable and q/p 1/q F Lp,q = F (t, ξ)pB m(t, ξ)p dt dξ < ∞, 2d ,B) m (R Rd
Rd
with the standard modification when p or q equals infinity. Here m is a positive weight function which is assumed to be v-moderate [22], ie m fulfills m(x + y) ≤ Cv(x)m(y), x, y ∈ R2d , for a positive function v which is submultiplicative, ie v(x + y) ≤ v(x)v(y), x, y ∈ R2d . In this paper we restrict to polynomially bounded functions v. A standard class of polynomially increasing submultiplicative functions is vs (x) = (1 + |x|2 )s/2 , x ∈ R2d , s ≥ 0. In Section 4 we need also the corresponding class where the weight is constant in the first variable, denoted τs (x) = (1 + |x2 |2 )s/2 , s ≥ 0, x1 ∈ Rd , x2 ∈ Rd , x = (x1 , x2 ). Analogously to the case of scalar-valued distributions [12, 22] we define modulation spaces, p,q 2d 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞, by F ∈ Mm,g (Rd , B), if F ∈ S (Rd , B) and Vg F ∈ Lp,q m (R , B) where g ∈ S. By Lemma 2.1 Vg F is always strongly measurable. The modulation space norm is d p,q F Mm,g 2d ,B) , g ∈ S(R ). (Rd ,B) := Vg F Lp,q m (R
(3.1)
Modulation spaces of Banach space valued distributions have already been considered by Toft [44]. 3.1. Retract property, admissible windows, Wiener amalgam space characterization, properties Prop. 2.5 says that γ, g−1 Vγ∗ Vg = idS (Rd ,B) . The following result corresponds to [22, Prop. 11.3.2] and [14, Cor. 4.6], has a similar proof, and shows that 2d p,q d p,q d Vγ∗ : Lp,q m (R , B) → Mm,g (R , B), ie Mm,g (R , B) is a Banach space retract of p,q 2d Lm (R , B) [4]. Proposition 3.1. Suppose g, γ ∈ S(Rd ) fulfill γ, g = 0, m is a v-moderate weight p,q p,q function, and 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞. Then Mm,g (Rd , B) → S (Rd , B), and Mm,g (Rd , B) is p,q 2d −1 ∗ p,q a Banach space retract of Lm (R , B), ie γ, g Vγ Vg = idMm,g (Rd ,B) and p,q 2d Vg : Mm,g (Rd , B) → Lp,q m (R , B), 2d p,q d Vγ∗ : Lp,q m (R , B) → Mm,g (R , B). p,q 2d Proof. By (3.1) Vg is an isometric linear map from Mm,g (Rd , B) to Lp,q m (R , B), −1 ∗ −1 ∗ p,q Vγ Vg = idS (Rd ,B) . If G ∈ and γ, g Vγ Vg = idMm,g (Rd ,B) follows from γ, g 2d (R , B) then G is strongly measurable and by H¨ o lder’s inequality Lp,q m Vγ∗ G, ϕB ≤ G(z)B |Vγ ϕ(z)| dz R2d (3.2) ≤ GLp,q sup (v (z) |V ϕ(z)|) , 2d ,B) v−N p ,q N γ (R 2d m L (R ) 1/m
z
108
Wahlberg
IEOT
,q where N is chosen large enough to guarantee v−N ∈ Lp1/m (R2d ), which is possible since 1/m ≤ Cv [22] and v is polynomially bounded. Thus Vγ∗ G ∈ S (R2d , B). By Lemma 2.1 Vg (Vγ∗ G) is strongly measurable. By the commutation rule Tx My f = e−i2πxy My Tx f G(s, η)Vγ (Mξ Tt g)(s, η)dsdη Vg (Vγ∗ G)(t, ξ) = Vγ∗ G, Mξ Tt g = R2d (3.3) −i2πs(ξ−η) = G(s, η)Vg γ(t − s, ξ − η)e dsdη. R2d
Hence
Vg (Vγ∗ G)(z)B ≤ G(·)B ∗ |Vg γ| (z)
(3.4)
which, using an inequality of Young type for mix-normed spaces, [22, Prop. 11.1.3], admits the estimate ∗ p,q Vγ∗ GMm,g (Rd ,B) = Vg (Vγ G)(z)B Lp,q 2d ) m (R (3.5) ≤ C G(·)B Lp,q (R2d ) Vg γL1v (R2d ) . m
2d p,q d Thus Vγ∗ defines a bounded linear map from Lp,q m (R , B) to Mm,g (R , B). If we p,q put G = Vg F with F ∈ Mm,g (Rd , B) and use Prop. 2.5, we can also conclude from d p,q (3.2) that F, ϕB ≤ C(ϕ)F Mm,g (Rd ,B) where C(ϕ) is a seminorm on S(R ), p,q d d ie Mm,g (R , B) → S (R , B).
For later use we specialize the inequality (3.4) to G = Vγ F where F ∈ S (Rd , B), ie Vg F (z)B = γ−2 Vg Vγ∗ Vγ F (z)B ≤ γ−2 Vγ F (·)B ∗ |Vg γ| (z).
(3.6)
Likewise, with arguments similar to the proof of the corresponding result for scalar-valued modulation spaces [22, Thm. 11.3.7] (we omit the details), one can prove the following result. Proposition 3.2. Let m be a v-moderate weight function. p,q p,q (i) If g, γ ∈ S(Rd ) then · Mm,γ (Rd ,B) and · Mm,g (Rd ,B) are equivalent norms. d 1 d p,q p,q (ii) If g ∈ S(R ) and γ ∈ Mv (R ) then · Mm,γ (Rd ,B) and · Mm,g (Rd ,B) are equivalent norms. (iii) Prop. 3.1 holds with g, γ ∈ Mv1 (Rd ). p,q (Rd , B) are independent of g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ), and Consequently the spaces Mm,g for a fixed but arbitrary 0 = g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ) and a v-moderate weight function p,q m we can define the modulation space Mm (Rd , B) ⊂ S (Rd , B) as the set of d p,q F ∈ S (R , B) such that F Mm,g (Rd ,B) < ∞. We follow the conventional notation p p,p (Rd , B) = Mm (Rd , B) and M p,q (Rd , B) for the unweighted case, ie m ≡ 1. Mm The fact that the Fourier transform of the modulation spaces of scalarvalued distributions equals certain Wiener amalgam spaces [12] is true also in
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
109
the Banach space valued case. In fact, if F F ∈ M p,q (Rd , B) and g ∈ Cc∞ (Rd ), then F, Mξ T−t g = F (F T−t g)(ξ) by a generalization to the vector-valued case of a result valid for scalar-valued distributions of compact support [26, 38]. From gB = F, Mξ T−t gB = F (F T−t g)(ξ)B we obtain FF, Mt Tξ 1/q , F F M p,q (Rd ,B) = F T−t gqF Lp (Rd ,B) dt = F p d q d W F L (R ,B),L (R )
Rd
where W F Lp (Rd , B), Lq (Rd ) is the Wiener amalgam space of B-valued tempered distributions with local component F Lp (Rd , B) and global component Lq (Rd ) [10, 12]. The norm of a Wiener amalgam space is equivalent to a discrete norm defined by a so called BUPU (bounded uniform partition of unity) [10, 12, 13]. A BUPU Ψ = {ψj }j∈J is a set of nonnegative functions required to fulfill, for a discrete set {xj }j∈J and a relatively compact set U with nonempty interior, ψj (x) ≡ 1, (i) j∈J
(ii) sup ψj F L1 (Rd ) < ∞, j∈J
(iii) supp ψj ⊂ xj + U ∀j ∈ J, (iv) sup |{j; (xi + U ) ∩ (xj + U ) = ∅}| < ∞. i∈J
Then if ψj ∈ M 1 (Rd ) for all j we have the norm equivalence for all 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞ [10, 13] 1/q F W (F Lp(Rd ,B),Lq (Rd )) F ψj qF Lp(Rd ,B) . j∈J
The proof of this result in the scalar-valued case [10, 13] extends to the Banach space valued case. The proof of the completeness of Wiener amalgam spaces W (X, Y ) under quite general hypotheses on the local norm X and the global p,q (Rd , B) are norm Y [10] also extends to W F Lp (Rd , B), Lq (Rd ) , and hence Mm Banach spaces for all 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞. The following proposition treats more generalizations of results valid for scalar-valued modulation spaces. We omit the proofs since they are almost identical to the proofs in [22], again after replacement of | · | with · B in the obvious places. Proposition 3.3. Suppose m is a v-moderate weight function. (i) If |m(z)| ≤ CvN (z), z ∈ R2d , for some N > 0 and 1 ≤ p, q < ∞, then p,q (Rd , B). S(Rd , B) is dense in Mm p1 ,q1 p2 ,q2 (ii) If p1 ≤ p2 , q1 ≤ q2 and m2 ≤ Cm1 then Mm (Rd , B) → Mm (Rd , B). 1 2 d ∞ d (iii) S (R , B) = s≥0 Mv−s (R , B). (iv) If m(ξ, −t) ≤ Cm(t, ξ) then the Fourier transformation is continuous on p (Rd , B). Mm
110
Wahlberg
IEOT
(v) Let H be a Hilbert space. 2 If m depends only on t then L2m (Rd , H) = Mm (Rd , H) with equivalent norms. 2 d 2 If m depends only on ξ then F Lm (R , H) = Mm (Rd , H) with equivalent norms. In the following proposition we use the Fourier type of the Banach space B. It can be seen as a modification of (v) in the last proposition. Proposition 3.4. Suppose B has Fourier type r, 1 ≤ r ≤ 2, let 1 ≤ p ≤ r and let m be a v-moderate weight function.
p (i) If m depends only on t then Lpm (Rd , B) → Mm (Rd , B). p d p (ii) If m depends only on ξ then F Lm (R , B) → Mm (Rd , B). p d p d p d (iii) Thus L (R , B) ∩ FL (R , B) → M (R , B).
Proof. (i). Let F ∈ S (Rd , B) and ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R2d ). If p > 1, using the restricted Hausdorff-Young inequality which is true by the definition of the Fourier type, p /p ≥ 1, Minkowski’s inequality and m(s − x) ≤ Cm(s)v(−x), we have F p p d = F (F Tt ϕ)(ξ)pB dξ m(t)p dt Mm (R ,B) d Rd R p /p ≤C (F Tt ϕ)(s)pB ds m(t)p dt d d R R p /p =C F (s)pB |ϕ(s − t)|p m(t)p ds dt Rd Rd (3.7) p/p p /p p p p ≤C F (s)B |ϕ(s − t)| m(t) dt ds d Rd R p /p ≤C F (s)pB m(s)p ds |ϕ(x)|p v(−x)p dx =
Rd CF pLpm (Rd ,B) .
Rd
The case p = 1 follows similarly. Result (ii) follows from the estimate (3.7) and B. F, Mξ Tt ϕB = FF, M−t Tξ ϕ p,q (Rd , B) when B is reflexive 3.2. The dual of Mm The following three lemmas have statements and proofs that are slight adaptations of results in [3] where B is a space of scalars.
Lemma 3.5. If 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞ and F : R2d → B is strongly measurable then
F Lp,q (R2d ,B) = sup G(z), F (z) B dz R2d
where the supremum is taken over all G : R2d → B such that: (i) z → G(z), F (z) B is measurable, (ii) z → G(z)B is measurable, and (iii) GLp ,q (R2d ,B ) = 1.
(3.8)
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
111
If B = H is a Hilbert space then the supremum can be taken over G ∈ Lp ,q (R2d , H) such that GLp ,q (R2d ,H) = 1. Note that in the case of a general Banach space B the requirements (i)–(iii) do not imply G ∈ Lp ,q (R2d , B ) since G is not necessarily strongly measurable. Proof. Inequality ≥ in (3.8) follows from H¨ older’s inequality. To prove inequality ≤ we first restrict to F Lp,q (R2d ,B) < ∞. For all (x, y) ∈ R2d there exists by the Hahn-Banach theorem a functional P (x, y) ∈ B such that P (x, y)B = 1 and P (x, y), F (x, y) B = F (x, y)B . When F (x, y) = 0 we define P (x, y) = 0. If p, q < ∞ we define q−p · F (x, y)p−1 · F (·, y)B Lp (Rd ) . G(x, y) := P (x, y) · F 1−q B Lp,q (R2d ,B) Then (i)–(iii) are fulfilled and R2d G(z), F (z) B dz = F Lp,q (R2d ,B) . Next suppose p = ∞, q < ∞ and supp(F ) is compact. Let > 0 and define q−1 G (x, y) := P (x, y) · F 1−q · F (·, y)B Lp (Rd ) · χU (x, y)/µ(U (·, y)) Lp,q (R2d ,B) if µ(U (·, y)) > 0 and G (x, y) := 0 otherwise, where U = {(x, y) ∈ R2d : F (x, y)B > (1 + )−1 F (·, y)B Lp (Rd ) } ⊂ supp(F ). Then (i)–(iii) are again fulfilled, and G (z), F (z) B dz ≥ (1 + )−1 F Lp,q (R2d ,B) . R2d
Also if supp(F ) is not compact the result follows since F Lp,q (R2d ,B) = lim F χKj Lp,q (R2d ,B) j→∞
for an exhausting nested sequence of compact sets Kj ⊂ R2d . The cases p < ∞, q = ∞ and p = q = ∞ are proved in a way similar to p = ∞, q < ∞ [3]. If F Lp,q (R2d ,B) = ∞ we define Fj := F χKj if F (z)B ≤ j and Fj := 0 otherwise. Then Fj ∈ Lp,q (R2d , B) and Fj (z)B → F (z)B monotoneously as j → ∞ for all z ∈ R2d . Hence ∞ = F Lp,q (R2d ,B) = lim Fj Lp,q (R2d ,B) j→∞
= lim sup G(z), Fj (z) B dz j→∞ G R2d
≤ sup G(z), F (z) dz . G
R2d
B
Finally, in the case B = H, P (z) = F (z)/F (z)H which means that P , and therefore also G, is strongly measurable.
112
Wahlberg
IEOT
Remark 3.6. Not only in the Hilbert space case B = H the supremum in (3.8) can be taken over all (strongly measurable) G ∈ Lp ,q (R2d , B ) such that GLp ,q (R2d ,B ) = 1. In fact it can be checked that this is also true when B = lr (Z), 1 < r < ∞. Lemma 3.7. The mix–normed space Lp,q (R2d , B) is complete for 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞. Proof. Let {Fn }n≥1 be a Cauchy sequence in Lp,q (R2d , B) and let {Kj }j≥1 be an exhaustive nested sequence of compact sets in R2d . By H¨older’s inequality Fn (z) − Fm (z)B dz ≤ Fn − Fm Lp,q (R2d ,B) χKj Lp ,q (R2d ) . Kj
There exists F such that limn→∞ (F − Fn )χKj L1 (R2d ,B) = 0 for every j, by the completeness of L1 (R2d , B). F is strongly measurable since F χKj ∈ L1 (R2d , B) for each Kj . By a Cantor diagonal procedure we can extract a subsequence {Fnk } such that limk→∞ Fnk = F almost everywhere. Lemma 3.5 and Fatou’s lemma gives F − Fnk Lp,q (R2d ,B) ≤ sup lim G(z)B Fnj (z) − Fnk (z)B dz G R2d j→∞ G(z)B Fnj (z) − Fnk (z)B dz ≤ sup lim inf G
j→∞
R2d
≤ lim inf Fnj − Fnk Lp,q (R2d ,B) . j→∞
By the following lemma most mix–normed spaces may be looked upon as Lq –spaces of functions taking values in Lp (Rd , B). Lemma 3.8. If 1 ≤ p, q < ∞ then Lq (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)) ⊃ Lp,q (R2d , B) with equal norms. If 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞ then Lq (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)) ⊂ Lp,q (R2d , B) with equal norms. Proof. Suppose F ∈ Lp,q (R2d , B) and 1 ≤ p, q < ∞. Then there exists a sequence of simple functions ank χAnk (x)χBnk (y), ank ∈ B, Fn (x, y) = k
such that limn→∞ F − Fn Lp,q (R2d ,B) = 0 [3, 25]. Thus for a subsequence Fnk we have limk→∞ F (·, y) − Fnk (·, y)Lp (Rd ,B) = 0 for a.a. y. Hence y → F (·, y) ∈ Lp (Rd , B) is strongly measurable and F Lp,q (R2d ,B) = F Lq (Rd ,Lp (Rd ,B)) . Suppose on the other hand that F ∈ Lq (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)) and 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞. Since F is strongly measurable there exists a sequence of functions ∞ Fn (x, y) = fnk (x)χBnk (y), fnk ∈ Lp (Rd , B), Bnk ∈ B(Rd ), k=1
{Bnk }∞ k=1
where are pairwise disjoint, such that for a.a. y, limn→∞ Fn (·, y) − F (·, y)Lp (Rd ,B) = 0 uniformly [9]. Since fnk are almost separably valued in B for
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
113
all k, Fn is almost separably valued in B, and since fnk is weakly measurable in B for all k, Fn is weakly measurable in B. Hence Fn is strongly measurable by Pettis’s theorem. Let Kj ⊂ Rd be a nested exhausting sequence of compact sets. Then χKj (y)(Fn (·, y) − Fm (·, y))Lp (Rd ,B) q d −→ 0, n, m −→ ∞, L (R )
and hence χ1×Kj Fn is a Cauchy sequence in L (R2d , B) for all j. By an argument borrowed from the proof of Lemma 3.7 there exists a strongly measurable function G : R2d → B such that Fnk → G for a.a. (x, y) for a subsequence Fnk . Thus we have for a.a. y, G(·, y) = limk→∞ Fnk (·, y) = F (·, y) in Lp (Rd , B). Therefore F = G in Lq (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)) and F Lq (Rd ,Lp (Rd ,B)) = GLp,q (R2d ,B) . p,q
If p or q is infinite, the inclusion Lq (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)) ⊂ Lp,q (R2d , B) may be strict, since for F ∈ Lp,q (R2d , B) the function y → F (·, y) ∈ Lp (Rd , B) may fail to be strongly measurable [3]. Next we use the previous lemma to give a characterization of the dual of p,q Mm (Rd , B) when B is reflexive. In contrast to the corresponding result for scalar– valued modulation spaces, Thm. 11.3.6 in [22], we exclude the cases (p = 1, 1 < q < ∞). Here Lqm (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)) denotes the set of strongly measurable F : R2d → B such that F m ∈ Lq (Rd , Lp (Rd , B)). Proposition 3.9. Suppose p = q = 1 or 1 < p < ∞ and 1 ≤ q < ∞, B is a reflexive p,q Banach space, and let ϕ ∈ S(Rd ) fulfill ϕL2 (Rd ) = 1. Then (Mm (Rd , B)) =
p ,q p ,q (Rd , B ), in the sense that every G ∈ M1/m (Rd , B ) defines an element in M1/m p,q d p,q (Mm (R , B)) under the sesquilinear form (3.9), and for every u ∈ (Mm (Rd , B)) p ,q there is a G ∈ M1/m (Rd , B ) such that p,q p,q (u, F ) = (G, F )Mm (Rd ,B) = (Rd , B). (3.9) Vϕ G(z), Vϕ F (z) B dz, F ∈ Mm R2d
p ,q Proof. H¨ older’s inequality in Lp,q (R2d ) implies that every G ∈ M1/m (Rd , B ) p,q d defines an element in (Mm (R , B)) by (3.9). Suppose on the other hand that p,q p,q 2d u ∈ (Mm (Rd , B)) . The fact that Vϕ is isometric Mm (Rd , B) → Lp,q m (R , B) justifies the factorization (u, F ) = (u1 , Vϕ F ) where u1 is an induced linear func2d tional which acts boundedly on a closed linear subspace of Lp,q m (R , B). By the p,q Hahn-Banach theorem u1 can be extended to the whole space Lm (R2d , B). In the next step we use the duality theory of the Lebesgue-Bochner spaces Lp (Rd , X) where X is a Banach space [1, 9, 21]. If 1 ≤ p < ∞ and X is reflexive, then to each ∈ (Lp (Rd , X)) there exists an F ∈ Lp (Rd , X ) such that (, Z) = (F (x), Z(x))X dx and = F Lp (Rd ,X ) . By identification of and F we Rd
thus have (Lp (Rd , B)) = Lp (Rd , B ), and hence the reflexivity of B implies that X = Lp (Rd , B) is a reflexive Banach space if 1 < p < ∞. Thus for 1 < p < ∞ and 2d q d p d 1 ≤ q < ∞ we have, using Lemma 3.8, (Lp,q m (R , B)) = (Lm (R , L (R , B)) = q p ,q L1/m (Rd , Lp (Rd , B )) ⊂ L1/m (R2d , B ). Hence if 1 < p < ∞ and 1 ≤ q < ∞, u1
114
Wahlberg
IEOT
,q 2d can be represented by an element Hu1 ∈ Lp1/m (R2d , B ) and acts on Lp,q m (R , B) by 2d (u1 , P )Lp,q 2d = Hu1 (z), P (z) B dz, P ∈ Lp,q ,B) m (R , B). m (R R2d
Use of (3.3) in the form Vϕ F (z) = Vϕ Vϕ∗ Vϕ F (z) = and Fubini’s theorem finally gives
R2d
Vϕ F (w)Vϕ (π(z)ϕ)(w)dw
2d ,B) (u, F ) = (u1 , Vϕ F )Lp,q m (R p,q Vϕ Vϕ∗ Hu1 (z), Vϕ F (z) B dz, F ∈ Mm = (Rd , B).
(3.10)
R2d
p ,q Thus we obtain (3.9) with G = Vϕ∗ Hu1 ∈ M1/m (Rd , B ) by Prop. 3.1. Concerning 1 2d 2d the case p = q = 1, the dual of Lm (R , B) is L∞ 1/m (R , B ). Thus in this case 2d ∗ ∞ d Hu1 ∈ L∞ 1/m (R , B ). Hence G = Vϕ Hu1 ∈ M1/m (R , B ) and (3.10) holds also in this case.
Remark 3.10. In the Hilbert space case B = H the sesquilinear form (3.9) is by Cor. 2.3 an extension of the L2 (Rd , H) inner product from S(Rd , H) × S(Rd , H) p ,q p,q (Rd , H) × Mm (Rd , H). It is independent of ϕ and unique except in the to M1/m cases (p, q) = (1, ∞) and (p, q) = (∞, 1) [43]. In Section 4 we will need the following lemma. We restrict to the Hilbert space valued case and denote M p ,q := M p ,q (Rd , H). Lemma 3.11. For any 1 ≤ p, q ≤ ∞ we have the norm equivalence
(G, F )M p,q (Rd ,H) . F M p,q (Rd ,H) sup G M p ,q ≤1
older’s inequality implies Proof. Let ϕ ∈ S fulfill ϕL2 (Rd ) = 1. If GM p ,q ≤ 1 H¨ that
(G, F )M p,q (Rd ,H) = Vϕ G(z), Vϕ F (z) H dz ≤ F M p,q (Rd ,H) . R2d
On the other hand, using Lemma 3.5 and Vϕ∗ P M p ,q ≤ CP Lp,q where Lp ,q := Lp ,q (R2d , H),
sup (Vϕ Vϕ∗ P (z), Vϕ F (z))H dz F M p,q (Rd ,H) = Vϕ F Lp,q (R2d ,H) = ≤C
sup G M p ,q ≤1
R2d
P Lp ,q ≤1
R2d
Vϕ G(z), Vϕ F (z) H dz .
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
115
3.3. Weakly stationary Hilbert space valued tempered distributions In this subsection we discuss tempered distributions taking values in a Hilbert space H. Such a distribution F is said to be weakly stationary (with a term borrowed from generalized stochastic processes) if the covariance distribution σF F := σ is translation invariant in the sense of [18, 28, 31, 32] σ, ϕ ⊗ ψ = σ, Tx ϕ ⊗ Tx ψ, x ∈ Rd , ϕ, ψ ∈ S(Rd ). We denote the set of weakly stationary elements of S (Rd , H) by Ss (Rd , H). It can be shown that the covariance distribution of a weakly stationary distribution acting on a separable function ϕ ⊗ ψ equals σ, ϕ ⊗ ψ = σs , ϕ ∗ ψ ∗
(3.11)
where σs ∈ S (Rd ) and ψ ∗ (x) := ψ(−x) [18, 26]. Since σs is positive definite it has a Fourier transform which is a tempered, non-negative measure σ s [18], ie there exists u ≥ 0 such that v−u (ξ) σs (dξ) < ∞. Rd
2 Proposition 3.12. If F ∈ Ss (Rd , H) then Vϕ F (t, ξ)2H = σ s ∗ ϕ (ξ) and ∞,1 M1⊗v−u (Rd , H). Ss (Rd , H) ⊂ u≥0
Proof. Combination of (1.7) and (3.11) gives Vϕ F (t, ξ)2H = σs , Mξ Tt ϕ ∗ (Mξ Tt ϕ)∗
2 2 = σ s , |F (Mξ Tt ϕ)| = σ s , Tξ M−t ϕ
2 2 = σ s , s ∗ ϕ (ξ − ·) = σ ϕ (ξ). Thus Vϕ F (t, ξ)H is independent of t and by Lemma 2.1 there exists N > 0 such that Vϕ F (t, ξ)H ≤ CvN (ξ). Thus with u = N + d + 1 F M ∞,1 (Rd ,H) ≤ C vN −N −d−1 (ξ)dξ < ∞. 1⊗v−u
Rd
3.4. Gabor frame theory for Hilbert space valued modulation spaces A frame for L2 (Rd ) [6, 22] is a countable set {hk }k∈I ⊂ L2 (Rd ) such that for constants 0 < A ≤ B < ∞ |f, hk |2 ≤ Bf 2L2 (Rd ) , f ∈ L2 (Rd ). (3.12) Af 2L2 (Rd ) ≤ k∈I 2 d The frame
operator is a positive and invertible operator on L (R ) defined by Sf = k∈I f, hk hk .
116
Wahlberg
IEOT
Lemma 3.13. Let H be a Hilbert space and let {hk }k∈I be a frame for L2 (Rd ) with frame constants A and B. Then AF 2L2 (Rd ,H) ≤ F, hk 2H ≤ BF 2L2 (Rd ,H) , F ∈ L2 (Rd , H), (3.13) k∈I
where F, hk is a Bochner integral, and we have F = F, hk S −1 hk , F ∈ L2 (Rd , H),
(3.14)
k∈I
with unconditional convergence in L2 (Rd , H). Proof. For a given F ∈ L2 (Rd , H) there exists by Pettis’s theorem a null set NF such that {F (t); t ∈ Rd \ NF } ⊂ H is separable. Let {ej }∞ j=1 be an ONB for this space. Since fj (t) := (F (t), ej )H ∈ L2 (Rd ) for all j, we have ∞ ∞ F 2L2 (Rd ,H) = F (t)2H dt = |fj (t)|2 dt = fj 2L2 (Rd ) . Rd \NF
Rd \NF j=1
Likewise F, hk 2H =
Rd \NF
F (t)hk (t)dt2H
∞
= j=1
j=1
Rd \NF
∞
2 fj (t)hk (t)dt = |fj , hk |2 , j=1
and hence we obtain using the upper frame bound (3.12) k∈I
F, hk 2H ≤ B
∞
fj 2L2 (Rd ) = BF 2L2 (Rd ,H) ,
j=1
and likewise we obtain the lower bound in (3.13). If we define the Hilbert space
2 1/2 valued sequence norm cl2 (I,H) := , the right inequality (3.13) k∈I ck H says that the coefficient operator CF = {F, hk }k∈I is bounded from L2 (Rd , H)
2 to l (I, H), and implies that the synthesis operator Dc = k∈I ck hk is bounded S can be extended to from l2 (I, H) to L2 (Rd , H) [22]. Thus the frame operator
act on L2 (Rd , H), by (Se F )(t) := (DCF )(t) = F, hk hk (t). By a slight k∈I modification of the proof of [22, Cor. 5.1.2], replacing sequences in l2 (I, C) by
2 sequences in l (I, H), the synthesis operator Dc = k∈I ck hk can be proved to be unconditionally convergent in L2 (Rd , H) when c ∈ l2 (I, H). Since bounded operators acting on unconditionally convergent series can be applied inside the sum [22], we obtain F, hk hk , F = F, hk 2H . Se F, F L2 (Rd ,H) = k∈I
k∈I
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
117
By condition (3.13) Se is a positive invertible operator on L2 (Rd , H). Finally we prove (3.14). If x ∈ H then by [22, Cor. 5.1.3] we have for all k Se (S −1 hk ⊗ x) =
∞ S −1 hk , h h ⊗ x = hk ⊗ x
(3.15)
=1
with unconditional convergence in L2 (Rd , H). Again by the commutativity of bounded linear operators and unconditionally convergent series summation, we obtain Se−1 F, hk hk = F, hk S −1 hk F = Se−1 Se F = k∈I
k∈I −1
in the last equality using (3.15). Since S hk is a frame for L2 (Rd ) [22] and {F, hk }k∈I ∈ l2 (I, H) the convergence is unconditional in L2 (Rd , H). p,q By a Gabor frame [15, 22] for the Banach space Mm (Rd , H) we understand a discrete set of functions {MβnTαk g}n,k∈Zd = {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ , where g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ) and α, β > 0, such that for constants 0 < A ≤ B < ∞ q/p 1/q p,q F, Mβn Tαk gpH m(αk, βn)p AF Mm (Rd ,H) ≤ (3.16) n∈Zd k∈Zd p,q ≤ BF Mm (Rd ,H) .
In the proof of the next proposition we need the amalgam space W (Lp,q m ) [22] which p,q (Z2d ), is defined as the set of measurable functions f : R2d → C such that a ∈ lm where akn = ess supt,ξ∈[0,1]d |f (t + k, ξ + n)|, k, n ∈ Zd . Proposition 3.14. Let H be a Hilbert space, and suppose g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ), α, β > 0 and {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ is a Gabor frame for L2 (Rd ) with frame operator S. Then {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ p,q is also a Gabor frame for Mm (Rd , H), for all 1 ≤ p, q < ∞, and the expansion p,q F = F, π(λ)gπ(λ)γ, F ∈ Mm (Rd , H), (3.17) λ∈Λ
where γ = S −1 g, holds with unconditional convergence. Proof. By a fundamental result of Gr¨ ochenig and Leinert γ = S −1 g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ) [24]. By Lemma 3.13 {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ is a frame for L2 (Rd , H) and Dγ Cg = idL2 (R2 ,H) , where Cg is the coefficient operator defined by {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ and Dγ is the synthesis operator defined by {S −1 π(λ)g}λ∈Λ = {π(λ)γ}λ∈Λ [22]. In the following we adapt p,q p,q → lm , where the proof of [22, Thm. 12.2.3] on the boundedness of Cg : Mm s p,q ms (k, n) = m(αk, βn), to the Hilbert space valued case. If F ∈ Mm (Rd , H) we have by (3.6) with γ = g Vg F (z)H ≤ g−2 |Vg g| ∗ Vg F (·)H (z), hence by an inequality of Young type for amalgam spaces [13], [22, Thm. 11.1.5], Vg F (·)H p,q 2d . (3.18) p,q ≤ CVg gW (L1 ) Vg F (·)H v W (L ) L (R ) m
m
118
Wahlberg
IEOT
By [22, Prop. 12.1.11] Vg g ∈ W (L1v ) and thus Vg F (·)H ∈ W (Lp,q m ). Next we need to prove that Vg F is continuous. From the formula (3.3) and Prop. 2.5 with ϕ ∈ S(Rd ) and ϕL2 = 1 we get ∗ Vg F (t, ξ) = Vg (Vϕ Vϕ F )(t, ξ) = Vϕ F (s, η)Vϕ g(s − t, η − ξ)ei2πt(η−ξ) dsdη R2d
which gives Vg F (t + t1 , ξ + ξ1 ) − Vg F (t, ξ)H
≤ Vϕ F (s, η)H Vϕ g(s − t − t1 , η − ξ − ξ1 )ei2π(t1 (η−ξ−ξ1 )−tξ1 ) R2d
− Vϕ g(s − t, η − ξ) dsdη. Let (t, ξ) ∈ R2d be fixed arbitrary. The integrand approaches zero everywhere as |t1 |, |ξ1 | → 0 since Vϕ g is continuous [22]. If we prove that the integrand is also bounded by an L1 (R2d ) function uniformly over t1 , ξ1 ∈ U where U ⊂ Rd is a compact neighbourhood of zero, then by the dominated convergence theorem Vg F is continuous at (t, ξ), and hence everywhere. Since Vϕ F (·)H m ∈ L∞ (R2d ), 1/m(s, η) ≤ Cv(s, η) ≤ Cv(s − t, η − ξ)v(t, ξ) [22] and (Vϕ g)v ∈ L1 (R2d ), it is by H¨older’s inequality enough to prove
sup Vϕ g(· − t1 , · − ξ1 ) v ∈ L1 (R2d ). (3.19) t ,ξ ∈U 1
1
The integral of (3.19) can be estimated from above, using the submultiplicativity of v and Q := [0, 1]d , by
sup v(s, η) sup Vϕ g(s − t1 , η − ξ1 ) t1 ,ξ1 ∈U
s∈k+Q
k,n∈Zd η∈n+Q
≤C
v(k, n) sup Vϕ g(k + t1 , n + ξ1 ) t1 ,ξ1 ∈K
k,n∈Zd
where K ⊂ Rd is a compact neighbourhood of zero. The inclusion K ⊂ where J is finite, implies the estimate of (3.20)
C v(k, n) sup Vϕ g(k + l + t1 , n + p + ξ1 ) k,n∈Zd
≤C
k,n∈Zd
(3.20)
|l|,|p|≤J
|l|≤J
l+Q
t1 ,ξ1 ∈Q
v(k, n) sup Vϕ g(k + t1 , n + ξ1 ) < ∞, t1 ,ξ1 ∈Q
where the last expression is finite due to Vϕ g ∈ W (L1v ) [22]. Thus by the dominated convergence theorem Vg F is continuous everywhere. Now we obtain by [22, Prop. 11.1.4] and (3.18)
Vg F H p,q Cg F lp,q 2d ,H) = ms (Z Λ lms ≤ C Vg F (·)H W (Lp,q ) m
p,q ≤ CF Mm (Rd ,H) .
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
119
p,q p,q Thus Cg is continuous from Mm (Rd , H) to lm (Z2d , H). s We can also modify the proof of [22, Thm. 12.2.4] to prove that the synthep,q p,q sis operator Dγ : lm (Z2d , H) → Mm (Rd , H) is continuous, by replacement of s scalar-valued sequences by Hilbert space valued sequences and the sequence norm p,q p,q (Z2d , C) by lm (Z2d , H). Since p, q < ∞ the convergence is unconditional in lm s s p,q (Rd , H) [22]. As Dγ and Cg are bounded operators and Dγ Cg = idL2 (Rd ,H) Mm p,q we obtain by Prop. 3.3 (i) Dγ Cg = idMm (Rd ,H) , ie (3.17) and also (3.16), since p,q p,q p,q F Mm (Rd ,H) ≤ Dγ Cg F lms (Z2d ,H) ≤ Dγ Cg F Mm (Rd ,H) .
4. Localization operators, Weyl operators and Gabor multipliers with operator-valued symbols 4.1. Operators on Banach space valued function spaces with symbols in Lp,q The formula (2.7) of Prop. 2.5 suggests the definition of localization operators [5, 7, 8, 43, 44, 45], ie operators from B1 -valued distributions to B2 -valued distributions (B1 , B2 Banach spaces) of the form F )(s) := a(z)Vg F (z)(π(z)γ)(s)dz, F ∈ S (Rd , B1 ), (4.1) (Ag,γ a R2d
2d
where the symbol a : R → L(B1 , B2 ) is assumed to be strongly measurable. With an estimate similar to (2.6) in Section 2 one confirms that Ag,γ a , defined as before by action under the integral, is a bounded operator from S (Rd , B1 ) to S (Rd , B2 ) provided g, γ ∈ S(Rd ) and a is strongly measurable and polynomially bounded. First we notice that if we replace |a(z)Vg F (z)| by a(z)Vg F (z)B2 ≤ a(z) Vg F (z)B1 in the proof of [5, Prop. 3.2], then one obtains the following generalization of this result for scalar-valued modulation spaces to vector-valued spaces and operator-valued symbols. Proposition 4.1. Suppose g, γ ∈ Mv1 (Rd ), p0 , p1 , p2 , q0 , q1 , q2 ∈ [1, ∞] fulfill 1/p0 + 1/p1 = 1/p2 , 1/q0 + 1/q1 = 1/q2 , m1 and m2 are v-moderate weight functions, and 0 a ∈ Lpm02,q/m (R2d , L(B1 , B2 )). 1 p1 ,q1 d p2 ,q2 d Then Ag,γ a : Mm1 (R , B1 ) → Mm2 (R , B2 ) with operator norm bound p ,q Ag,γ a ≤ CgMv1 γMv1 aL 0 0
m2 /m1
(R2d ,L(B1 ,B2 )) .
The following two corollaries of Prop. 4.1, the second of which is proved with interpolation techniques, are stated and proved in [5]. Corollary 4.2. Suppose p0 , p1 , q0 , q1 ∈ [1, ∞] fulfill 1/p0 +1/p1 ≤ 1, 1/q0 +1/q1 ≤ 1, suppose a ∈ Lp0 ,q0 (R2d , L(B)) and m is v-moderate. Then Ag,γ is bounded on a p1 ,q1 (Rd , B) with operator norm bound Mm Ag,γ a ≤ CgMv1 γMv1 aLp0,q0 (R2d ,L(B)) .
120
Wahlberg
IEOT
Corollary 4.3. Suppose 1 ≤ p, q, r ≤ ∞, m1 and m2 are v-moderate, and a ∈ p,q p,q Lrm2 (R2d , L(B1 , B2 )). Then Ag,γ : Mm (Rd , B1 ) → Mm (Rd , B2 ) with operator a 1 1 m2 g,γ norm bound Aa ≤ CgMv1 γMv1 aLrm (R2d ,L(B1 ,B2 )) . 2
Corollary 4.3 is not true if we replace the modulation spaces between which acts by L2 spaces. The following example shows that Ag,γ is not necessarAg,γ a a ily bounded from L2 (Rd , B1 ) to L2 (Rd , B2 ) when a ∈ L∞ (R2d , L(B1 , B2 )). This phenomenon can not occur in the theory of scalar-valued modulation spaces since L2 = M 2 then.
Example 4.4. Let the dimension d = 1, 1 < r < 2, B1 = lr (Z), B2 = lr (Z). Note that B1 and B2 both have Fourier type r [35]. Define the operator a0 acting on
ek where ek denotes the vector of zeros in all lr by a0 (β) = k βk |βk |r −2 β2−r lr positions except position k where it equals one. Then a0 L(lr ,lr ) = 1 and hence g ⊂ (−1/4, 1/4) a(z) ≡ a0 ∈ L∞ (R2 , L(lr , lr )). Let f, g ∈ S(R) fulfill supp f, supp and f L2 = gL2 = 1, let N > 0 be a given number, choose K such that
(2K + 1)1−2/r ≥ N . Define F (x) = |k|≤K Mk f (x)ek . Then F 2L2 (R,lr ) = (2K +
1)2/r and Vg F (t, ξ) = f ∗ M−t g∗ (ξ − k)ek , ie for fixed t the summands |k|≤K
have non-overlapping support in the ξ variable due to supp g, f ⊂ (−1/4, 1/4).
Hence Vg F (t, ξ)2ls = |k|≤K |F((Mk f )(Tt g))(ξ)|2 independently of s ∈ [1, ∞). Parseval’s formula gives R2 Vg F (t, ξ)2ls dz = 2K + 1. Thus g,g Vg F (z)2lr dz ≥ N F 2L2(R,lr ) , (F, Aa F )L2 (R,lr ) = R2
which by Lemma 3.5 implies that Ag,g / L L2 (R, lr ), L2 (R, lr ) . a ∈ Large parts of the Weyl and the Kohn-Nirenberg pseudo-differential calculi can be modified to treat the case of functions taking values in a separable Hilbert space H and symbols with values in L(H) as outlined in [17, pp 135–37]. Many results are true also when B1 , B2 are reflexive Banach spaces and the symbol takes values in L(B1 , B2 ) [27, p 79]. If B1 , B2 are perfectly general Banach spaces and a ∈ S(R2d , L(B1 , B2 )) the localization operator Ag,γ can be formulated as a Weyl a operator [17, 27] s + t g,γ , ξ F (t)ei2πξ(s−t) dtdξ Aa F (s) = Lρ F (s) := ρ (4.2) 2 2d R provided g, γ ∈ M 1 (Rd ), where the Weyl symbol is [17, 40] ρ = a ∗ W (γ ⊗ g).
(4.3)
4.2. Operators on Hilbert space valued function spaces with symbols in M ∞ In this subsection we shall prove a version of one of the main results of [7] (see also [43]) for Hilbert space valued modulation spaces. This result says that Ag,γ a can be extended to a uniformly bounded operator on M µ1 ,µ2 (Rd ) for all 1 ≤ µ1 , µ2 ≤ ∞, ∞ (R2d ), g, γ ∈ Mv1s (Rd ) and s ≥ 0. provided the symbol a ∈ M1/τ s
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
121
If F, G ∈ L2 (Rd , H) then, following [17], an operator-valued Wigner distribution can be defined by (WF G (t, ξ)u, v)H = (F (t + τ /2), v)H (G(t − τ /2), u)H e−i2πτ ξ dτ, u, v ∈ H. Rd
Then WF G (t, ξ) ∈ L(H) for all (t, ξ) ∈ R2d follows from F, G ∈ L2 (Rd , H). It is also true that WF G (t, ξ) ∈ S1 (H) which denotes the set of trace-class operators, with norm [18, 37] ∞ T S1(H) = sup |(T ej , fj )H | j=1
where the supremum is taken over all pairs of orthonormal sequences {ej }j≥1 and {fj }j≥1 in H. In fact, ∞ ∞ |(WF G (t, ξ)ej , fj )H | ≤ |(F (t + τ /2), fj )H | |(G(t − τ /2), ej )H | dτ Rd j=1
j=1
≤
Rd d
F (t + τ /2)H G(t − τ /2)H dτ
≤ 2 F L2(Rd ,H) GL2 (Rd ,H) . If ψ1 , ψ2 ∈ S(Rd ) we have WF G (t, ξ)W (ψ1 ⊗ ψ2 )(t, ξ)dtdξ u, v)H R2d = (F (t + τ /2), v)H (G(t − τ /2), u)H ψ1 (t + τ /2)ψ2 (t − τ /2)dtdτ
(4.4)
R2d
= F, ψ1 , v H G, ψ2 , u H , u, v ∈ H, where F, ψ1 denotes a Bochner integral. The formula (4.4) can be generalized to F, G ∈ S (Rd , H) by the definition WF G , Φu, v H := F, ψ1 , v H G, ψ2 , u H , u, v ∈ H, if Φ = W (ψ1 ⊗ψ2 ). Thus WF G , W (ψ1 ⊗ψ2 ) is a rank-one operator with trace-class norm WF G , W (ψ1 ⊗ ψ2 )S1 (H) = F, ψ1 H G, ψ2 H (4.5) ≤C ψ1 α,β ψ2 α,β , |α|≤N1
|β|≤M1
|α|≤N2
|β|≤M2
where · α,β are seminorms on S(Rd ). The estimate (4.5) says that (ψ1 , ψ2 ) → WF G , W (ψ1 ⊗ ψ2 ) is a bilinear continuous map S(Rd ) × S(Rd ) → S1 (H). By the Schwartz kernel theorem [37] it can be extended to a continuous linear map S(R2d ) Ψ → WF G , W (Ψ) ∈ S1 (H). Since the partial Fourier transformation and the coordinate transformation which defines the Wigner distribution (1.4) are continuous operations on S(R2d ), we have WF G ∈ S (R2d , S1 (H)).
122
Wahlberg
IEOT
The following lemma is needed in the main proposition. Its statement is analogous to [7, Lemma 2.2]. Lemma 4.5. Let H be a Hilbert space. If F, G ∈ S (Rd , H), ϕ ∈ S(Rd ) and Φ = W (ϕ), then with z = (z1 , z2 ), ζ = (ζ1 , ζ2 ) ∈ R2d , VΦ WF G (z, ζ)S1 (H) = Vϕ F (z1 − ζ2 /2, z2 + ζ1 /2)H Vϕ G(z1 + ζ2 /2, z2 − ζ1 /2)H . Proof. Using W (ϕ)(t − z1 , ξ − z2 ) = W (Mz2 Tz1 ϕ)(t, ξ) it can be verified that Mζ Tz Φ(t, ξ) = W (ψ1 ⊗ ψ2 )(t, ξ) where ψ1 = eiπz2 ζ2 Mz2 +ζ1 /2 Tz1 −ζ2 /2 ϕ, ψ2 = e−iπz2 ζ2 Mz2 −ζ1 /2 Tz1 +ζ2 /2 ϕ.
(4.6)
Thus the result follows from VΦ WF G (z, ζ) = WF G , Mζ Tz Φ and insertion of (4.6) into (4.5). The definition of a Weyl operator (4.2) works for symbols ρ ∈ S(R2d , L(H)) but we need to extend the definition to more general symbols. Weyl operators can be defined for ρ ∈ S (R2d , L(H)) as follows. Given any continuous bilinear multiplication with norm bounded by one, B1 × B2 (x, y) → x · y ∈ B3 , where Bj , j = 1, 2, 3 are Banach spaces, there exists according to [1, Thm. 1.7.2] a unique natural continuous bilinear extension of S(Rd , B1 ) × S(Rd , B2 ) (ρ, F ) → ρ(x) · F (x)dx ∈ B3 Rd
to (ρ, F ) ∈ S (Rd , B1 ) × S(Rd , B2 ). We use three such bilinear multiplications, (i) multiplication with scalars H × C → H, (ii) operator evaluation L(H) × H → H, and (iii) the inner product (·, ·)H H × H → C (which in fact is sesquilinear). Multiplication (i), modified with a conjugation in the second argument, has been used in the definition of S (Rd , H) in Section 1.1. Let now ρ ∈ S (R2d , L(H)) and F ∈ S(Rd , H) be fixed. By Thm. 1.3.3 (op. cit.) there exists a sequence ρn ∈ S(R2d , L(H)) such that ρn −→ ρ in S (R2d , L(H)) as n −→ ∞. Then by (4.2) Lρn F ∈ S(Rd , H) and we define the H-valued functional Lρ F by Lρ F, ϕ := ρ, W (F ⊗ ϕ)SR (R2d ,H) , ϕ ∈ S(Rd ),
(4.7)
where the multiplication of the right hand side distribution action is extended from multiplication (ii). Here SR (R2d , H) indicates that the distribution ρ acts linearly (in contrast to the antilinear convention of this paper) on S(R2d , H). It is clear that (4.7)
extends (4.2) as a definition of Lρ F and it can be verified that Lρ F, ϕH ≤ C α,β ϕα,β , ie Lρ F ∈ S (Rd , H). The definition (4.1) can be extended to symbols a ∈ S (R2d , L(H)) by Ag,γ a F := Lρ F where ρ = a ∗ W (γ ⊗ g). By the continuity asserted by Thm. 1.7.2 (op. cit.) applied to the multiplication
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
123
(ii), limn→∞ Lρn F = Lρ F in S (Rd , H). The same result can then be applied once again, with multiplication (iii), which yields Lρ F, GS(Rd ,H) = lim (Lρn F, G)L2 (Rd ,H) ∀G ∈ S(Rd , H). n→∞
(4.8)
Since F , G and Lρn F are strongly measurable there exists a closed separable subspace H0 ⊂ H such that the range spaces of F, G, Lρn F are contained in H0 for all n a.e. Since WF G (x) : H → H0 for a.a. x ∈ R2d , and x → ρn (x) is continuous for each n, we can enlarge H0 to a closed separable subspace, still denoted H0 , such that ρn (x)WF G (x) : H0 → H0 for all n and a.a. x. If {ej }∞ j=1 ⊂ H0 is an ONB for H0 we have ∞ Lρn F, G L2 (Rd ,H) = (Lρn F (s), ej )H (G(s), ej )H ds =
j=1
=
j=1
∞
∞ j=1
R3d
R2d
Rd
(F (t + τ /2), ρn (t, ξ)∗ ej )H (G(t − τ /2), ej )H e−i2πξτ dτ dtdξ
WF G (t, ξ)ej , ρn (t, ξ)∗ ej H dtdξ =
R2d
tr ρn (x)WF G (x) H0 dx. (4.9)
Let Φ ∈ S(R2d ) be real-valued and fulfill ΦL2(R2d ) = 1. By Lemma 2.1 (z, ζ) → VΦ ρ(z, ζ) is continuous, thus we can again enlarge H0 to a closed separable subspace still denoted H0 , such that VΦ ρ(z, ζ)VΦ WF G (z, −ζ) : H0 → H0 . Finally we obtain from (4.8), (4.9), the duality S1 (H0 ) = L(H0 ) and |tr(AB)| ≤ AL(H0 ) ·BS1 (H0 ) [37], Lemma 2.2, and the dominated convergence theorem
tr ρn (x)WF G (x) H0 dx Lρ F, GS(Rd ,H) = lim n→∞ R2d
tr VΦ ρn (z, ζ)VΦ WF G (z, −ζ) H0 dzdζ = lim (4.10) n→∞ R4d
= tr VΦ ρ(z, ζ)VΦ WF G (z, −ζ) H dzdζ. 0
R4d
We are now prepared to prove the main theorem. Proposition 4.6. Let H be a Hilbert space, s ≥ 0, γ ∈ Mvrs (Rd ) where 1 ≤ r < ∞, and g ∈ Mv1s (Rd ). Suppose 1 ≤ q ≤ p ≤ ∞, q ≤ r, t = qr/(r − q), µj , νj ∈ [1, ∞], vj ≤ p, p ≤ µj , 1/µj − 1/νj = 1/q − 1/p, for j = 1, 2, (ν1 , ν2 ) = (1, ∞), p,t (ν1 , ν2 ) = (∞, 1), and a ∈ M1/τ (R2d , L(H)). Then Ag,γ can be extended to a a s µ1 ,µ2 d ν1 ,ν2 d (R , H) to M (R , H) with operator norm depending bounded map from M only on g, γ and a. p,t (R2d , L(H)) and g, γ ∈ S(Rd ). Let Φ = W (ϕ), where Proof. Suppose a ∈ M1/τ s ϕ ∈ S(Rd ), fulfill ΦL2 (R2d ) = 1. By [7, Prop. 2.5]
W (γ ⊗ g)Mτ1,r (R2d ) ≤ CgMv1s (Rd ) γMvrs (Rd ) , s
(4.11)
124
Wahlberg
IEOT
and by Prop. 2.4 (op. cit.), with integrals interpreted as Bochner integrals, ρM p,q (R2d ,L(H)) ≤ CaM p,t
1/τs
(R2d ,L(H)) W (γ
⊗ g)Mτ1,r (R2d ) .
(4.12)
s
Now we extend (4.10) from F, G ∈ S(Rd , H) to a sesquilinear form, still denoted µ1 ,µ2 (Ag,γ (Rd , H) × M ν1 ,ν2 (Rd , H). Since a F, G) = (Lρ F, G), acting on (F, G) ∈ M the range spaces of Vϕ F and Vϕ G are separable subspaces of H [37], there still exists a closed separable subspace H0 ⊂ H such that VΦ ρ(z, ζ)VΦ WF G (z, −ζ) : H0 → H0 . This H0 is used in the extension of (4.10). Next we use |tr(AB)| ≤ AL(H0 ) BS1 (H0 ) , H¨ older’s inequality for mix-normed spaces, Lemma 4.5, q /p ≥ 1 (which is a consequence of q ≤ p), p /µj + p /νj = 1 + p /q for j = 1, 2 (which follows from the assumption 1/µj − 1/νj = 1/q − 1/p), and Young’s inequality for mix-normed spaces [3]. Thus
g,γ
Aa F, G = Lρ F, G ≤ VΦ ρLp,q (R4d ,L(H)) ζ2 ζ1 ζ2 ζ1 q /p 1/q · Vϕ F (z1 + , z2 − )pH Vϕ G(z1 − , z2 + )pH dz dζ 2 2 2 2 R2d R2d q /p 1/q p Vϕ F (·)pH ∗ V = ρM p,q (R2d ,L(H)) dζ ϕ G(·)H (ζ2 , −ζ1 ) R2d
1/p 1/p ≤ ρM p,q (R2d ,L(H)) Vϕ F (·)pH Lµ1 /p ,µ2 /p (R2d ) Vϕ G(·)pH ν1 /p ,ν2 /p 2d L (R ) = ρM p,q (R2d ,L(H)) Vϕ F (·)H Lµ1 ,µ2 (R2d ) Vϕ G(·)H Lν1 ,ν2 (R2d ) ≤ CaM p,t
1/τs
(R2d ,L(H)) gMv1s (Rd ) γMvrs (Rd ) F M µ1 ,µ2 (Rd ,H) GM ν1 ,ν2 (Rd ,H) ,
where (4.11). Hence last inequality we have inserted the estimates (4.12) and g,γ in the Aa F, G defines a bounded sesquilinear form on M µ1 ,µ2 × M ν1 ,ν2 , where we denote M µ1 ,µ2 := M µ1 ,µ2 (Rd , H) for brevity, which extends the canonical sesquilinear form on S(Rd , H) × S(Rd , H) defined by (·, ·)L2 (Rd ,H) . Since there is a unique extension of the latter form to M ν1 ,ν2 × M ν1 ,ν2 except in the given exceptional cases of ν1 , ν2 [43] (see Rem. 3.10), Ag,γ a F, G must equal this extended form (restricted if µj < νj ), denoted (·, ·)M p,q (Rd ,H) and defined in (3.9). Now the result follows from Lemma 3.11. The operator norm is bounded according to Ag,γ a ≤ CaM p,t
1/τs
(R2d ,L(H)) gMv1s (Rd ) γMvrs (Rd ) .
Finally we extend the last inequality by the density of S(Rd ) in Mvrs (Rd ) to g ∈ Mv1s (Rd ) and γ ∈ Mvrs (Rd ). Remark 4.7. It seems to be an open question whether Prop. 4.6 is true when H is replaced by a Banach space of a suitable kind. If we choose r = q = 1 and p = ∞ we obtain the announced generalization of [7, Thm. 3.2].
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
125
∞ Corollary 4.8. If a ∈ M1/τ (R2d , L(H)) and g, γ ∈ Mv1s (Rd ), then Ag,γ can be a s ν1 ,ν2 d (R , H) for all 1 ≤ ν1 , ν2 ≤ ∞ except extended to a bounded map on M (ν1 , ν2 ) = (1, ∞) and (ν1 , ν2 ) = (∞, 1).
We also obtain a result for Weyl operators which is a generalization of [22, Thm. 14.5.2], see also [23, 43]. The original, restricted (continuity on L2 ) theorem was proved by Sj¨ ostrand [41]. Corollary 4.9. If ρ ∈ M ∞,1 (R2d , L(H)) then Lρ can be extended to a bounded map on M ν1 ,ν2 (Rd , H) for all 1 ≤ ν1 , ν1 ≤ ∞ except (ν1 , ν2 ) = (1, ∞) and (ν1 , ν2 ) = (∞, 1). p,q (Rd , H) by The formula (3.17) suggests the definition of operators on Mm p,q (Ag,γ a(λ)Vg F (λ)(π(λ)γ)(s), F ∈ Mm (Rd , H), a F )(s) := λ∈Λ 2d
for a : Z → L(H). Such an operator is called a Gabor multiplier, and the scalarvalued case is treated in [16]. If g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ) and {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ is a Gabor frame 2d for L2 (Rd ), then one can prove (we omit the details), replacing Lp,q m (R ) norms p,q 2d by sequence norms lms (Z ) and using Prop. 3.14, the following discrete version. Here we again denote ms (k, n) = m(αk, βn). Proposition 4.10. Let H be a Hilbert space, g ∈ Mv1 (Rd ) and let {π(λ)g}λ∈Λ be a Gabor frame for L2 (Rd ). Suppose furthermore p1 , p2 , q1 , q2 ∈ [1, ∞) and p0 , q0 ∈ [1, ∞] fulfill 1/p0 + 1/p1 = 1/p2 , 1/q0 + 1/q1 = 1/q2 , m1 and m2 are v-moderate weight functions, m = m2 /m1 and p0 ,q0 (Z2d , L(H)). a ∈ lm s p1 ,q1 d p2 ,q2 d Then Ag,γ a : Mm1 (R , H) → Mm2 (R , H) with operator norm bound g,γ p ,q Aa ≤ CgMv1 γMv1 alm0s 0 (Z2d ,L(H)) .
Acknowledgment The author would like to thank Hartmut F¨ uhr, Franz Luef, Ghassem Narimani and in particular Hans Feichtinger for nice discussions, suggestions and useful remarks which have improved the paper. He would also like to express his gratitude to the organizers of the Special Semester on Modern Methods for Time-Frequency Analysis at the Erwin Schr¨odinger Institute in Vienna, spring 2005, H. G. Feichtinger and K. Gr¨ ochenig, for a very nice and stimulating event. The paper was worked out in the hospital environment of NuHAG, Faculty of Mathematics, University of Vienna, for which again H. Feichtinger is acknowledged. This project is supported by STINT, The Swedish Foundation for International Cooperation in Research and Higher Education.
126
Wahlberg
IEOT
References [1] H. Amann, Vector-valued distributions and Fourier multipliers. Unpublished manuscript, 2003. [2] H. Amann, Operator-valued Fourier multipliers, vector-valued Besov spaces, and applications, Math. Nachr. 186 (1997), 5–56. [3] A. Benedek and R. Panzone, The space Lp , with mixed norm, Duke Math. J. 28 (1961), 301–24. [4] J. Bergh and J. L¨ ofstr¨ om, Interpolation spaces – an introduction. Springer, 1976. [5] P. Boggiatto, Localization operators with Lp symbols on modulation spaces. In: Advances in pseudo-differential operators, Birkh¨ auser (2004), 149–163, Eds. R. Ashino, P. Boggiatto, M. W. Wong. [6] O. Christensen, An introduction to frames and Riesz bases. Birkh¨ auser, 2003. [7] E. Cordero and K. Gr¨ ochenig, Time-frequency analysis of localization operators, J. Func. Anal. 205 (2003), 107–131. [8] I. Daubechies, Time-frequency localization operators: a geometric phase space approach, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 34 (1988), 605–612. [9] J. Diestel and J. J. Uhl, Jr, Vector measures. Math. Surveys 15, AMS, 1977. [10] T. Dobler, Wienertypr¨ aume auf lokalkompakten Gruppen. Diplomarbeit, Universit¨ at Wien, 1989. [11] N. Dunford and J. T. Schwartz, Linear operators, Part I. Interscience, New York and London, 1958. [12] H. G. Feichtinger, Modulation spaces on locally compact abelian groups. Technical report, University of Vienna, 1983; also in: Wavelets and their applications, Allied Publishers Pvt. Ltd. (2003), 99–140, Eds. M. Krishna, R. Radha and S. Thangavelu. [13] H. G. Feichtinger, Banach convolution algebras of Wiener type, Proc. Conf. “Functions, Series, Operators”, Budapest 1980, Coll. Math. Soc. Bolyai, North-Holland (1983), 509–23. [14] H. G. Feichtinger and K. Gr¨ ochenig, Banach spaces related to integrable group representations and their atomic decompositions – I, J. Func. Anal. 86 (1989), 307–340. [15] H. G. Feichtinger and K. Gr¨ ochenig, Gabor frames and time-frequency analysis of distributions, J. Func. Anal. 146 (1997), 464–495. [16] H. G. Feichtinger and K. Nowak, A first survey of Gabor multipliers. In: Advances in Gabor analysis, Birkh¨ auser (2003), 99–128, Eds. H. G. Feichtinger, T. Strohmer. [17] G. B. Folland, Harmonic analysis in phase space. Princeton University Press, 1989. [18] I. M. Gel’fand and N. Ya. Vilenkin, Generalized functions, vol. 4. Applications of harmonic analysis. Academic Press, 1964. [19] M. Girardi and L. Weis, Vector-valued extensions of some classical theorems in Harmonic Analysis. In: Proc. of the 3rd international ISAAC Congress, Berlin 2001, (2003), 171–185. [20] M. Girardi and L. Weis, Operator-valued Fourier multiplier theorems on Besov spaces, Math. Nachr. 251 (2003), 34–51. [21] N. E. Gretsky and J. J. Uhl, Jr, Bounded linear operators on Banach function spaces of vector-valued functions, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 167 (1972), 263–277.
Vol. 59 (2007) Vector-valued Modulation Spaces and Localization Operators
127
[22] K. Gr¨ ochenig, Foundations of time-frequency analysis. Birkh¨ auser, 2001. [23] K. Gr¨ ochenig and C. Heil, Modulation spaces as symbol classes for pseudodifferential operators. In: Wavelets and their applications, Allied Publishers Pvt. Ltd. (2003), 151–170, Eds. M. Krishna, R. Radha and S. Thangavelu. [24] K. Gr¨ ochenig and M. Leinert, Wiener’s lemma for twisted convolution and Gabor frames, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 17 (2004), 1–18. [25] P. R. Halmos, Measure theory. Van Nostrand, 1950. [26] L. H¨ ormander, The analysis of linear partial differential operators I. 2nd Edition, Springer-Verlag, 1990. [27] L. H¨ ormander, The analysis of linear partial differential operators III. SpringerVerlag, 1985. [28] W. H¨ ormann, Generalized stochastic processes and Wigner distribution. PhD thesis, Universit¨ at Wien, 1989. [29] T. Hyt¨ onen, Fourier embeddings and Mihlin-type multiplier theorems, Math. Nachr. 274–275 (2004), 74–103. [30] T. Hyt¨ onen and P. Portal, Vector-valued multiparameter singular integrals and pseudodifferential operators, preprint, October 2005. [31] K. Itˆ o, Stationary random distributions, Memoirs of the College of Science, Univ. Kyoto, Ser. A, XXVIII (1953), Math. No. 3, 209–223. [32] B. Keville, Multidimensional second order generalised stochastic processes on locally compact abelian groups. PhD thesis, University of Dublin, 2003. [33] S. Kwapie´ n, Isomorphic characterizations of inner product spaces by orthogonal series with vector-valued coefficients, Studia Math. 44 (1972), 583–595. [34] G. Matz, On non-WSSUS wireless fading channels, IEEE Trans. Wireless Comm. 4 (2005), 2465–78. [35] J. Peetre, Sur la transformation de Fourier des fonctions a ` valeurs vectorielles, Rend. Sem. Mat. Univ. Padova 42 (1969), 15–26. ˇ Strkalj, ˇ [36] P. Portal and Z. Pseudodifferential operators on Bochner spaces and an application, Math. Z. 253 (2006), 805–819. [37] M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of modern mathematical physics I. Wiley, 1975. [38] H.-J. Schmeisser, Vector-valued Sobolev and Besov spaces. In: Sem. Analysis of the Karl-Weierstrass-Institute 1985/86, Teubner Texte Math 96 (1987), 4–44. [39] L. Schwartz, Distributions a ` valeurs vectorielles, Ann. Inst Fourier I. 7 (1957), 1–141, II. 8 (1958), 1–209. [40] M. A. Shubin, Pseudodifferential operators and spectral theory. 2nd Edition, Springer, 2001. [41] J. Sj¨ ostrand, An algebra of pseudodifferential operators, Math. Res. L. 1 (1994), 185–192. [42] T. Strohmer, Pseudodifferential operators and Banach algebras in mobile communications, Appl. Comput. Harmon. Anal. 20 (2006), 237–249. [43] J. Toft, Continuity properties for modulation spaces, with applications to pseudodifferential calculus – I, J. Func. Anal. 207 (2004), 399–429.
128
Wahlberg
IEOT
[44] J. Toft, Continuity properties for modulation spaces, with applications to pseudodifferential calculus, – II, Annals of Global Analysis and Geometry 26 (2004), 73– 106. [45] M. W. Wong, Wavelet transforms and localization operators. Birkh¨ auser, 2002. Patrik Wahlberg School of Electrical Engineering & Computer Science The University of Newcastle Callaghan, NSW 2308 Australia e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: January 30, 2006 Revised: March 26, 2007
Integr. equ. oper. theory 59 (2007), 129–147 c 2007 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010129-19, published online June 27, 2007 DOI 10.1007/s00020-007-1506-0
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Noncommuting Domination in Krein Spaces Via Commutators of Block Operator Matrices Michal Wojtylak Abstract. The commutators of 2×2 block operator matrices with (unbounded) operator entries are investigated. The matrix representation of a symmetric operator in a Krein space is exploited. As a consequence, the domination result due to Cicho´ n, Stochel and Szafraniec is extended to the case of Krein spaces. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B50; Secondary 47B25, 47B47. Keywords. Symmetric operator, selfadjoint operator, Krein space, block operator matrix.
Introduction The idea of domination of operators in Hilbert spaces is due to Nelson (see [16]). The topic was investigated many times, see e.g. [17, 18, 19, 3] for general theory and [18, 20, 4] for applications. The matter is closely related to the perturbation theory (cf. [9, 7]). So far the results concerned symmetric and selfadjoint operators [16, 18, 3, 4] or formally normal and normal operators [17, 19] in Hilbert spaces. In the present paper we deal with symmetric and selfadjoint operators in Krein spaces. The stimulant for the research was Theorem 3 of [3] (quoted below as Theorem 2.2). The authors of [3] gave criteria for a symmetric operator in a Hilbert space to be selfadjoint. On the other hand, it is a well known fact that a symmetric operator in a Pontriagin space admits a block operator matrix representation ∗ S00 −S10 , (0.1) S= S10 S11 The author was supported by the Stanislaw Estreicher grant out of the Jagiellonian University funds.
130
Wojtylak
IEOT
where the operator S11 is unbounded and the remaining three are bounded. Selfadjointness (in the Pontriagin space sense) of S reduces to selfadjointness (in the Hilbert space sense) of S11 . It appears, that using the above representation one can prove an analogue of Theorem 2.2 in Pontriagin spaces. Moreover, the assump∗ tions that the operators S00 and S10 are finite dimensional and that S01 = −S10 are not essential in the calculations. Therefore we prove first a more general result in Krein spaces (Theorem 8.2) and the Pontriagin space case is its simple consequence. Using the same methods we are also able to prove the invariance of the assumptions of Theorem 2.2 on some bounded perturbations of the dominating operator (Proposition 8.4). As was already mentioned, our main tool are 2 × 2 block operator matrices with three bounded and one unbounded entry. Such operators were considered by many authors (cf. [11, 1, 12, 13]). In the present paper we will usually assume that S00 , S01 and S10 are bounded and that ρ(S) = ∅. Such context is more general than is required for our purposes. The paper is organized as follows. Most of the paper (Sections 2–7) is devoted to block operator matrices. The main result of this part is Theorem 2.3, which is formulated in Section 2. In Sections 3–7 we develop the theory of commutators and sets of type ΩS for block operator matrices and we successively complete the proof of Theorem 2.3. The last section contains the main result of this paper – a domination result in Krein spaces.
1. Preliminaries If E and F are linear spaces (in practice, we consider only Hilbert and Krein spaces), then by an operator from E to F we understand a linear mapping A from a linear subspace D (A) of E, called the domain of A, to F . Denote by R (A) and N (A) the range and the kernel of A, respectively. If E = F then we will say that A is an operator in E. If H, K and L are linear spaces and A and B are operators from H to K and K to L respectively, then we define as usually the operator BA: D (BA) = {f ∈ D (A) : Af ∈ D (B)} ,
(BA)(f ) := B(Af ), f ∈ D (BA) . (1.1)
If, moreover, A is an operator from H to K (B is an operator from K to L), then the following remarkable property hold: (A + A )B = AB + A B,
A(B + B ) ⊇ AB + AB .
(1.2)
We also have C(BA) = (CB)A
(1.3)
for all operators A, B and C from H to K, K to L and L to L˜ respectively. For an operator A in H and m ∈ N := {0, 1, . . . } we define Am by induction: A0 := IH ,
Vol. 59 (2007)
Noncommuting Domination in Krein Spaces
131
Am+1 := AAm = Am A. We also put D∞ (A) :=
∞
D Ak .
k=0
By [A, B] we mean AB − BA (defined on the maximal possible domain D (AB) ∩ D (BA)). Let K be a Hilbert space and let X be an operator in K. We say that X is densely defined if its domain is dense in K. X is said to be bounded if Xf ≤ c f for some c ≥ 0 and for all f ∈ D (X). We would like to stress here that a bounded operator is not necessarily densely defined. We write B(K, L) for the space of all bounded operators with domain equal K and range contained in a Hilbert space L. We abbreviate B(K) to B(K, K). As usual, σ(X) and ρ(X) stand for the spectrum and the resolvent set of an operator X in K, respectively. If X and Y are operators then the relation X ⊆ Y is understood as the inclusion of the graphs. We say that E ⊆ D (X) is a core for X if the graph of X is contained in the closure of the graph X|E . X ∗ stands for the adjoint of an operator X. We say that a symmetric operator X in K is essentially selfadjoint on E if E is a dense linear subspace of D (X) and (X|E )∗ = X|E . By maximality of selfadjoint operators, a symmetric operator X is selfadjoint on E if and only if X is selfadjoint and E is a core for X. Recall two important properties, the first can be found in [3] as formula (2), the latter was communicated to me by D. Cicho´ n and J. Stochel. If N is a densely defined, closed operator in K and ρ(N ) = ∅ then (1.4) (N − z)−1 D (N m ) ⊆ D N m+1 for all m ∈ N, z ∈ ρ(N ); D∞ (N ) is a core for N m for every m ∈ N.
(1.5)
2. Noncommuting domination in Hilbert spaces Let us consider two closed operators N, X in a Hilbert space K. We say that N dominates X (cf. [19]), or that X is N -bounded (e.g. [7], see also there for a stronger notion of N -completely boundedness) if D (N ) ⊆ D (X). Remark 2.1. By the closed graph theorem, if N and X are closed operators in K and N dominates X, then Xf ≤ c(f + N f )
(2.1)
for all f ∈ D (N ) and for some c ≥ 0. Observe, that if N and X are closable, E is a core for N and the inequality (2.1) holds for some c ≥ 0 and for all f ∈ E then N dominates X. Very often it is much easier to verify the inequality (2.1) on a core than to check the inclusion of the domains (see [19]).
132
Wojtylak
IEOT
Let K be a Hilbert space and X be a densely defined, closable operator in K. In [3] Cicho´ n, Stochel and Szafraniec introduced the sets Ωc,d (X) := {z ∈ C : |z| > d, dist(z, σ(X)) ≥ c|z|} ,
(2.2)
where c > 0, d ≥ 0. If X is selfadjoint then the set above is equal to Ωc,d (X) = z ∈ ρ(S) : |z| > d, |z| (X − z)−1 ≤ c−1 .
(2.3)
A set U ⊆ ρ(X) is called of type ΩX if it is unbounded and −1 ∃t>0,d≥0 ∀z∈U : |z| > d and |z| (X − z) ≤ t.
(2.4)
In other words, for X selfadjoint, U is of type ΩX if it is an unbounded subset of some Ωt−1 ,d (X). If X is selfadjoint and U is of type ΩX then the constant t in (2.4) must be greater than or equal to one; moreover, the set i[d, +∞) (d > 0) is always of type ΩX , see [3, Rem.6] for more on that. Of particular interest to us is the following theorem ([3, Thm.3], see also [6]). In [4] one can find many examples showing its usefulness. For consistency we use here the definition of type ΩS and not the sets Ωc,d (S) as originally stated in [3]. Theorem 2.2. Assume that A is a symmetric operator in a Hilbert space K, S is a selfadjoint operator in K and U is a set of type ΩS . (i) Let m ∈ N. If D (S m ) ⊆ D (A) and (2.5) sup |z| [(S − z)−1 , A] < +∞ z∈U
then A is selfadjoint on any core of S m . (ii) If D∞ (S) ⊆ D (A), (2.5) holds and E is a core of S m for every m ∈ N, then A is essentially selfadjoint on E. Let N be an operator in the orthogonal sum H0 ⊕ H1 of two Hilbert spaces. We say that N is H0 -bounded if H0 ⊆ D (N ) and N00 := P0 N|H0 ∈ B(H0 ),
N01 := P0 N|H1 ∈ B(H1 , H0 ),
(2.6)
N10 := P1 N|H0 ∈ B(H0 , H1 ), N11 := P1 N|H1 is densely defined, (2.7) where P0 (P1 ) denotes the orthogonal projection from H0 ⊕ H1 onto H0 (H1 ). Observe that in such case N is uniquely determined by the operators N00 ,N10 ,N01 ,N11 and can be identified with a block operator matrix N00 N01 N10 N11 in the sense that D (N ) = H0 ⊕ D (N11 ) ,
N
f0 f1
=
N00 f0 + N01 f1 N10 f0 + N11 f1
for
f0 f1
∈ D (N )
(we will not distinguish between the orthogonal sum H0 ⊕ H1 and the product H0 × H1 ). This identification will be always used for all H0 -bounded operators. m Nij∗ (i, j = 0, 1