Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 1–17 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010001-17, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1446-0
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Amenability, Completely Bounded Projections, Dynamical Systems and Smooth Orbits Daniel Beltit¸˘a and Bebe Prunaru Abstract. We describe a general method to construct completely bounded idempotent mappings on operator spaces, starting from amenable semigroups of completely bounded mappings. We then explore several applications of that method to injective operator spaces, fixed points of completely contractive mappings, Toeplitz operators, dynamical systems and similarity orbits of group representations. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47L25; Secondary 46L07, 43A07. Keywords. Operator space, completely bounded map, amenable semigroup.
1. Introduction If an injective von Neumann algebra is acted on by an amenable group then the corresponding fixed point algebra is in turn injective (Theorem 3.16 in Chapter XV in [28]). This fact turns out to play a key role in several proofs in the theory of operator algebras. In the present paper we investigate what versions that fact might have in the more general framework of operator spaces (see Corollary 3.2 below). Our initial motivation was that it might be useful to have a very general setting where completely bounded projections are associated with actions of semigroups. With the general result at hand (see Theorem 3.1 below) we soon realized that a lot of seemingly unrelated structures in operator theory can now be understood in a unifying manner. Thus such different things as dynamical systems, generalized Toeplitz operators or homogeneous spaces of Lie groups can be looked at from a unique point of view. We should point out that the technique of averaging over amenable groups has a long history in functional analysis and related areas. Its applications range from representation theory of finite and compact groups (see the so-called Weyl’s unitary trick) to ergodic theory (see [17]) and cohomology of von Neumann algebras (see
2
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
the papers [26] and [27]). From this point of view, what we are doing in the present paper is to investigate the relationship between that technique and the idea of completely bounded map. The structure of the paper is as follows: In Section 2 we introduce the notion of operator S-space, which is roughly speaking an operator space X equipped with a semigroup S of completely bounded maps. To each S-invariant subspace Y ⊆ X ∗ and any left invariant mean on the corresponding space of coefficients CX,Y (S) we associate a completely bounded mapping X → Y ∗ and we study some basic properties of that construction. In Section 3 we prove our main result on the existence of completely bounded projections on fixed point subspaces (Theorem 3.1) and then we explore some of the consequences of that theorem (see Theorems 3.4–3.5 and Corollaries 3.6 through 3.10). Preliminaries Our basic references for the theory of operator spaces and completely bounded maps are the monographs [11], [22] and [7]. We shall now recall several basic facts that will be needed in the sequel. If X is a vector space and p, q ≥ 1 then Mp,q (X) is the space of all p by q matrices with entries in X and Mp (X) = Mp,p (X). If X and Y are vector spaces, ϕ : X → Y is a linear mapping and n ≥ 1 then ϕn : Mn (X) → Mn (Y ) is defined by ϕn ([xij ]) = [ϕ(xij )] for every [xij ] ∈ Mn (X). Let H be a complex Hilbert space and B(H) the C ∗ -algebra of all bounded linear operators on H. Then Mn (B(H)) has a unique C ∗ -algebra norm ·n induced by its identification with B(H(n) ) where H(n) is the orthogonal sum of n copies of H. An operator space is a complex vector space X endowed with a complete norm · n on every space Mn (X) and with the property that there exists a linear mapping ϕ : X → B(H) for some Hilbert space H such that ϕn : (Mn (X), · n) → (Mn (B(H)), · n ) is isometric for all n ≥ 1. Any closed subspace of B(H) inherits a canonical structure of operator space. In particular this holds true for C ∗ -algebras. More precisely, if A is a C ∗ -algebra and n ≥ 1 then Mn (A) has a unique C ∗ -algebra norm that is induced by an arbitrary faithful representation of A on a Hilbert space. If A and B are C ∗ algebras and ϕ : A → B is linear then ϕ is said to be completely positive if ϕn is a positive map for all n ≥ 1. If X and Y are operator spaces and ϕ : X → Y is linear then ϕ is said def to be completely bounded if ϕcb = sup{ϕn | n ≥ 1} < ∞, and completely contractive if ϕcb ≤ 1. Moreover ϕ is completely isometric if ϕn is isometric for all n ≥ 1. For X and Y operator spaces the space CB(X, Y ) of all completely bounded maps between X and Y is a Banach space when endowed with the norm · cb . Moreover it has an operator space structure given by the isomorphisms Mn (CB(X, Y )) CB(X, Mn (Y )). We shall always denote CB(X, X) = CB(X). When Y = C the space X ∗ = CB(X, C) is called the operator space dual of X. Now let us consider the operator space X ∗∗ = (X ∗ )∗ . Then it can be shown that the canonical injection J : X → X ∗∗ is a complete isometry.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
3
If X, Y and Z are operator spaces and ϕ : X × Y → Z is a bilinear map then for all p, q ≥ 1 one denotes ϕp;q : Mp (X) × Mq (Y ) → Mpq (Z),
ϕp;q ([uij ], [vkl ]) = [ϕ(uij , vkl )](i,k),(j,l) .
Then ϕ is said to be completely bounded if ϕcb = sup{ϕp;q | p, q ≥ 1} < ∞. As in the case of completely bounded linear maps, the space CB(X × Y, Z) of all completely bounded bilinear maps ϕ : X × Y → Z has an operator space structure; see [11] for details. Y of two We shall also use the operator space projective tensor product X ⊗ operator spaces X and Y (see [11] for the precise definition). All we need to know is that it is an operator space structure on a certain completion of the algebraic tensor product X ⊗Y so that for any operator space Z there is a canonical complete Y, Z) CB(X × Y, Z). Moreover these spaces are completely isometry CB(X ⊗ isometric to CB(X, CB(Y, Z)). For a given Banach space X there are two distinguished operator space structures on X, the maximal operator space max X = (X, { · max,n }n≥1 ) and the minimal operator space min X = (X, { · min,n }n≥1 ) such that for any other operator space structure (X, { · n }n≥1 ) one has · min,n ≤ · n ≤ · max,n for all n ≥ 1. It can be shown that (max X)∗ min(X ∗ ) and (min X)∗ max(X ∗ ) as operator spaces (see (3.3.13) and (3.3.15) in [11]). An operator algebra is an associative algebra A endowed with an operator space structure so that there exists a completely isometric homomorphism ϕ : A → B(H) for some Hilbert space H. If moreover A is an operator space dual and ϕ can be chosen so that it is, additionally, weak∗ -continuous, then A is said to be a dual operator algebra. (See Chapter 2 in [7] for details.) We now recall a few basic definitions in differential geometry that will be needed in Corollary 3.10. A good reference for the differential geometry of Banach manifolds and homogeneous spaces is [29]. Let M be a Hausdorff topological space. A local chart of M is a homeomorphism ϕ : U → V , where U is an open subset of M and V is an open subset of some real Banach space. A smooth atlas of Uj = M and M is any family of local charts {ϕj : Uj → Vj }j∈J such that j∈J
ϕj ◦ ϕ−1 k : ϕk (Uj ∩ Uk ) → ϕj (Uj ∩ Uk ) is a smooth mapping (between open subsets of Banach spaces) whenever Uj ∩ Uk = ∅. A Banach manifold is a topological space is another Banach manifold with a M equipped with a maximal smooth atlas. If M is smooth smooth atlas {ϕ ej : Uej → Vej }ej∈Je then a continuous mapping f : M → M if ϕ e ◦ f ◦ ϕ−1 : ϕj (f −1 (Ve)) → Vj is smooth whenever f −1 (Ve) ∩ Vj = ∅. j
j
j
j
A Banach-Lie group is a group G which is also a Banach manifold such that the group operations (i.e., multiplication and inversion) are smooth. For instance, if A is a unital associative Banach algebra then its group of invertible elements, denoted by A× , is a Banach-Lie group. Now let G be a Banach-Lie group and H a subgroup of G. We say that H is a Banach-Lie subgroup if there exists a local chart ϕ : U → V of G such that ϕ(U ∩ H) = V ∩ W, where U is an open neighborhood
4
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
of 1 ∈ G, V is an open subset of the Banach space Z, and W is a split subspace of Z (that is, there exists a bounded linear operator E : Z → Z such that E 2 = E and Ran E = W). If this is the case, then G/H with the quotient topology has a structure of Banach manifold such that the natural projection π : G → G/H is smooth and has smooth local cross-sections on a neighborhood of each point of G/H (see e.g., Theorem 8.19 and Corollary 8.3 in [29]). In this case we say that G/H is a homogeneous space of G, and the natural transitive action G × G/H → G/H,
(g1 , g2 H) → g1 g2 H
is a smooth mapping. Now assume that G = A× for some unital associative Banach algebra A and that H is an algebraic subgroup of G (of degree ≤ d) in the sense that there exist an integer d ≥ 1 and a family F of polynomial functions on A × A of degree ≤ d such that H = {g ∈ A× | (∀f ∈ F) f (g, g −1 ) = 0}. Denote L (H) = {a ∈ A | (∀t ∈ R) exp(ta) ∈ H}. Then H with the topology inherited from A is a Banach-Lie group and L (H) (the Lie algebra of H) is a closed subspace of A such that [a, b] := ab − ba ∈ L (H) whenever a, b ∈ L (H). If it happens that L (H) is a split subspace of A, then H is a Banach-Lie subgroup of A× . (See the main theorem in [14] or Theorem 7.14 in [29].)
2. Operator S-spaces We begin this section by introducing some terminology on semitopological semigroups; we refer to [4] and [5] for more details. Definition 2.1. For any semigroup S we denote by Fb (S) the commutative unital C ∗ -algebra of all complex bounded functions on S with the sup norm · ∞ . For each t ∈ S we define Lt : Fb (S) → Fb (S) and Rt : Fb (S) → Fb (S) by (Lt f )(s) = f (ts) and (Rt f )(s) = f (st) whenever s ∈ S and f ∈ Fb (S). Now assume that the semigroup S is equipped with a topology. We say that S is a right (respectively, left) topological semigroup if for each s ∈ S the mapping S → S, t → ts (respectively, t → st) is continuous. Moreover S is a semitopological semigroup if it is both left and right topological. If the semigroup S is equipped with a topology then we denote by Cb (S) the set of all continuous functions in Fb (S). When S is a right topological semigroup we denote L UCb (S) the set of all left uniformly continuous bounded complex functions on S. That is, f ∈ L UCb (S) if and only if f ∈ Cb (S) and the mapping S → Cb (S), s → Rs f , is continuous. Similarly, when S is a left topological semigroup we define the set R UCb (S) of all right uniformly continuous bounded complex functions on S by the above condition with Rs replaced by Ls . Moreover, when S is a
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
5
semitopological semigroup we shall need the set UCb (S) = L UCb (S) ∩ R UCb (S) consisting of all uniformly continuous bounded complex functions on S. It is clear that all of the sets L UCb (S), R UCb (S) and UCb (S) are unital C ∗ -subalgebras of Cb (S). Next assume again that S is an arbitrary semigroup and let T be any linear subspace of Fb (S). We say that T is unital if it contains the unit element 1 of Fb (S) (i.e., if each constant function belongs to T ). In this case, a state of T is a linear functional µ : T → C such that µ = µ(1) = 1. Now assume that T is a linear subspace of Fb (S) that is invariant under the operators Lt for each t ∈ S. We say that a linear functional µ : T → C is S-invariant if µ ◦ Lt = µ for all t ∈ S. The unital subspace T of Fb (S) is said to be amenable if it admits an S-invariant state. If the space Fb (S) is amenable, then the semigroup S is said to be amenable. A topological group S is amenable if the space R UCb (S) is amenable. For instance the unitary groups of all injective von Neumann algebras with the strong operator topology, and also the unitary groups of all nuclear unital C ∗ -algebras with the weak topology are amenable groups (see [13] and [21]). It is known that if S is an amenable locally compact group then even the larger space Cb (S) is amenable (see Theorem 2.2.1 in [12]). Definition 2.2. Let S be a semigroup and X an operator space. We say that X is an operator S-space if it is equipped with a mapping α : S × X → X,
(s, x) → α(s, x) = αs (x)
satisfying the following conditions: (i) for all s, t ∈ S we have αst = αs ◦ αt ; (ii) for all s ∈ S the mapping αs : X → X is completely bounded linear, and moreover sup αs cb < ∞. s∈S
We say that X is a dual operator S-space if moreover there exists an operator space X∗ such that X = (X∗ )∗ and (αs )∗ X∗ ⊆ X∗ (⊆ X ∗ ) for all s ∈ S. An equivalent condition is that αs : X → X is weak∗ -continuous for all s ∈ S. In this case, X∗ is said to be a predual of the operator S-space X. Let X be an operator S-space and let Y ⊆ X ∗ be a closed linear subspace such that (αs )∗ Y ⊆ Y for all ∈ S. We denote by CX,Y (S) the smallest unital closed subspace of Fb (S) that contains all the functions fx,ψ := ψ(α(·, x)) for x ∈ X and ψ ∈ Y . We always think of CX,Y (S) as an operator space with the unique operator space structure that makes the inclusion map CX,Y (S) → Fb (S) into a complete isometry. Note that for all s ∈ S, x ∈ X and ψ ∈ Y we have Ls (fx,ψ ) = fx,(αs )∗ ψ . Thus CX,Y (S) is invariant under Ls for all s ∈ S. Lemma 2.3. Let S be a semigroup, X an operator S-space, Y ⊆ X ∗ a closed linear subspace such that (αs )∗ Y ⊆ Y for all s ∈ S, and CX,Y (S) as above. Then the mapping E 0 : Y × X → CX,Y (S), (ψ, x) → (ψ ◦ α)(·, x)
6
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
is a completely bounded bilinear mapping and E 0 cb ≤ sup αs cb . s∈S
Proof. Let p, q be arbitrary integers, denote p = {1, 2, . . . , p} and q = {1, 2, . . . , q}, and consider the bilinear mapping (E 0 )p;q : Mp (Y ) × Mq (X) → Mpq (Fb (S)) defined by
(E 0 )p;q (ψ, x) = ψij (α(·, xkl )) (i,k),(j,l)∈p×q
for ψ = (ψi,j )i,j∈p ∈ Mp (Y ) ⊆ Mp (X ∗ ) CB(X, Mp ) and x = (xkl )k,l∈q ∈ Mq (X). What we have to prove is that the norm of the bilinear mapping (E 0 )p;q is at most sup αs cb . In fact, s∈S
(E 0 )p;q (ψ, x) = sup ψij (α(·, xkl )) (i,k),(j,l)∈p×q s∈S
= sup ψq ((αs )q (x))
(see (1.1.30) in [11])
s∈S
≤ sup ψcb · αs · x s∈S
= sup αs cb · ψ · x
(see (3.2.5) in [11])
s∈S
and we are done.
Definition 2.4. Let S be a semigroup, X an operator S-space with the semigroup action α : S × X → X, and Y ⊆ X ∗ a closed linear subspace such that (αs )∗ Y ⊆ Y for all ∈ S. Consider the bilinear map E 0 : Y × X → CX,Y (S),
(ψ, x) → (ψ ◦ α)(·, x)
from Lemma 2.3. Then for each bounded linear functional µ : CX,Y (S) → C we define the mapping Eµ : X → Y ∗ ,
(Eµ (x))(ψ) = µ(E(ψ, x)) = µ((ψ ◦ α)(·, x))
for all x ∈ X and ψ ∈ Y . Lemma 2.5. With the notation of Lemma 2.3 and Definition 2.4 the bilinear map → CX,Y (S) ping E 0 gives rise to a completely bounded linear mapping E : Y ⊗X such that E(ψ ⊗ x) = fx,ψ . Its dual is a completely bounded linear mapping E ∗ : CX,Y (S)∗ → CB(X, Y ∗ ) with E ∗ cb ≤ sup αs cb and E ∗ (µ) = Eµ for all µ ∈ CX,Y (S)∗ . In particular, s∈S
for each µ ∈ CX,Y (S)∗ we have Eµ cb ≤ sup αs cb · µ. s∈S
Proof. Denote M := sup αs cb . It follows by the above Lemma 2.3 along with s∈S
Proposition 7.1.2 in [11] that the bilinear mapping E 0 : Y ×X → CX,Y (S) naturally
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
7
→ CX,Y (S) with Ecb ≤ corresponds to a completely bounded mapping E : Y ⊗X M . Consequently, for the mapping dual to E : Y ⊗X → CX,Y (S) we have ∗ = CB(X, Y ∗ ) E ∗ : CX,Y (S)∗ → (Y ⊗X) (the last equality follows by Corollary 7.1.5 in [11]) and E ∗ cb = Ecb ≤ M . Moreover, we have by Corollary 2.2.3 in [11] that any continuous linear functional µ : CX,Y (S) → C is completely bounded and µcb = µ. Consequently Eµ cb = E ∗ (µ)cb ≤ E ∗ cb · µ ≤ M · µ, and the proof is finished. Lemma 2.6. Let S be a semigroup, X an operator S-space with the semigroup action α : S × X → X, and Y ⊆ X ∗ a closed linear subspace such that (αt )∗ Y ⊆ Y for all t ∈ S. Let E ∗ : CX,Y (S)∗ → CB(X, Y ∗ ) as in Lemma 2.5 and endow the operator space CB(X, Y ∗ ) with the semigroup action γ : S × CB(X, Y ∗ ) → CB(X, Y ∗ ),
(t, θ) → γ(t, θ) = γt (θ) := ((αt )∗ |Y )∗ ◦ θ.
Then for all t ∈ S the diagram γt
CB(X, Y ∗ ) −−−−→ CB(X, Y ∗ ) ∗ E∗ E L∗
t CX,Y (S)∗ −−−− → CX,Y (S)∗
is commutative. In particular, if we have a bounded linear functional µ : CX,Y (S) → C and an element t ∈ S satisfying µ ◦ Lt = µ, then ((αt )∗ |Y )∗ ◦ Eµ = Eµ . Proof. Let x ∈ X and ψ ∈ Y arbitrary. We have ((αt )∗ |Y )∗ (Eµ (x)), ψ = Eµ (x), (αt )∗ (ψ) = Eµ (x), ψ ◦ αt
= µ (ψ ◦ αt )(α(·, x))
= µ ψ(α(t·, x))
= µ Lt ((ψ ◦ α)(·, x))
= L∗t µ (ψ ◦ α)(·, x)
(since αt αs = αts )
= EL∗t µ (x), ψ,
and the proof is complete.
Notation 2.7. Let S be a semigroup and X an operator space such that there is a semigroup action α : S × X → X, (s, x) → α(s, x) = αs (x), with αs ∈ CB(X) for all s ∈ S. Assume that Y ⊆ X ∗ is a closed linear subspace such that (αs )∗ Y ⊆ Y for all s ∈ S. Then there exists a natural semigroup action S × Y ∗ → Y ∗, We denote
(s, z) → ((αs )∗ |Y )∗ (z).
X S := {x ∈ X | (∀s ∈ S) αs (x) = x},
8
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
and similarly (Y ∗ )S = {z ∈ Y ∗ | (∀s ∈ S) ((αs )∗ |Y )∗ (z) = z}.
Also we denote by ιY : X → Y ∗ the mapping defined by ιY (x) (y) = y, x for all x ∈ X and y ∈ Y ⊆ X ∗ . Thus ιY is the composition between the natural embedding X → X ∗∗ and the quotient mapping X ∗∗ → Y ∗ , ψ → ψ|Y . Proposition 2.8. Let S be a semigroup, X an operator S-space with the semigroup action α : S × X → X, and Y ⊆ X ∗ a closed linear subspace such that (αs )∗ Y ⊆ Y for all s ∈ S. Assume that the space CX,Y (S) is amenable and pick an S-invariant state µ ∈ CX,Y (S)∗ . Then (i) for all x ∈ X S we have Eµ (x) = ιY (x), and (ii) ιY (X S ) ⊆ Ran Eµ ⊆ (Y ∗ )S . In particular, if X is a dual operator S-space and Y ∗ = X, then ιY = idX , therefore Eµ (x) = x for all x ∈ X S and Ran Eµ = X S . On the other hand, if Y = X ∗ then ιY coincides with the canonical embedding X → X ∗∗ and, by this identification, it follows again that Eµ (x) = x for all x ∈ X S and X S ⊆ Ran Eµ ⊆ (X ∗∗ )S . Proof. Assertion (i) follows at once in view of the way Eµ was defined (see Definition 2.4) along with the fact that µ(1) = 1, where 1 ∈ Fb (S) is the function that is constant 1 on S. The first inclusion in assertion (ii) follows by (i). The second inclusion follows by S-invariance of µ along with Lemma 2.6. In the following example we show that in the setting of Proposition 2.8 it could happen that X S = Ran Eµ . Example 2.9. Let G be an amenable discrete infinite group, so that Cb (G) = ∞ (G) is the C ∗ -algebra of all bounded complex functions on G, and there exists a G-invariant state µ : ∞ (G) → C. Consider the Banach space of all absolutely summable complex functions on G,
|f (g)| < ∞ , 1 (G) = f : G → C | f := sup F ⊆G g∈F F finite
and for all g ∈ G define αg : 1 (G) → 1 (G) by (αg f )(h) = f (g −1 h) for h ∈ G and f ∈ 1 (G). Also for each f ∈ 1 (G) consider the convolution operator Cf : ∞ (G) → ∞ (G), (Cf b)(h) = b(g)f (g −1 h) for b ∈ ∞ (G) and h ∈ G. g∈G
Now define the operator G-space X = max 1 (G) (see Section 3.3 in [11] for the definition of the functors min and max from Banach spaces to operator spaces) with α : G × X → X, (g, f ) → αg f. Then X ∗ = min ∞ (G) and X ∗∗ = max( ∞ (G))∗ as operator spaces (see (3.3.13) and (3.3.15) in [11]).
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
9
Since G is infinite, it follows that the only absolutely summable constant function on G is 0, hence X G = {0} = (X ∗∗ )G , where (X ∗∗ )G is just the set of all G-invariant continuous linear functionals on the commutative C ∗ -algebra ∞ (G), and this set is different from {0} since G is amenable. Moreover, with the notation of Proposition 2.8 we claim that actually X G = {0} = Ran Eµ ⊆ (X ∗∗ )G . In fact it is easy to see that the mapping Eµ : 1 (G) → ( ∞ (G))∗ can be equivalently defined in terms of the convolution operators by (Eµ f )(b) = µ(Cf b) for b ∈ ∞ (G) and f ∈ 1 (G). Hence for f = δ1 (the characteristic function of {1} ⊆ G) we have Eµ δ1 = µ, whence 0 = µ ∈ Ran Eµ , and the above claim is proved.
3. The main results Theorem 3.1. Let S be a semigroup and X an operator S-space with the semigroup action α : S × X → X. Assume that one of the following hypotheses holds: (a) X is a dual operator S-space and S is amenable as a discrete semigroup, or (b) X is a dual operator S-space, S is an amenable locally compact topological group and for each x ∈ X the mapping α(·, x) is continuous with respect to the weak∗ -topology of X, or (c) X is a dual operator S-space, S is an amenable topological group and the natural action of S on the predual of X is strongly continuous, or (d) X is an operator S-space, S is a compact left topological semigroup which is amenable as a discrete semigroup, and for each x ∈ X the mapping α(·, x) is continuous with respect to the the norm topology of X, or (e) X is an operator S-space which is separable as a Banach space, S is a compact left topological semigroup which is amenable as a discrete semigroup, and for each x ∈ X the mapping α(·, x) is weakly continuous, or (f) S is a compact topological group and for each x ∈ X the mapping α(·, x) is weakly continuous. Then there exists a linear map P : X → X with the following properties: (i) P ∈ CB(X) and P cb ≤ sup αs cb, (ii) Ran P = X S , and (iii) P ◦ P = P .
s∈S
Proof. We first consider the conditions (a)–(c). Let X∗ be an operator space predual of X as in Definition 2.2. We are going to make use of Proposition 2.8 for Y = X∗ . To this end we first make sure that, if either of the conditions (a)– (c) is satisfied, then the function space CX,Y (S) is amenable. In the case (a), this is obvious since the space Fb (S) of all bounded complex functions on S
10
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
is amenable. In the case (b), we have CX,Y (S) ⊆ Cb (S) and the space Cb (S) is amenable since the group S is locally compact. Finally, in the case (c) recall that for all s ∈ S, x ∈ X and ψ ∈ Y we have Ls (fx,ψ ) = fx,(αs )∗ ψ . The hypothesis (c) means that the mapping S → Y , s → (αs )∗ ψ, is continuous for all ψ ∈ Y , hence we get CX,Y (S) ⊆ R UCb (S), while the latter space is amenable since G is an amenable group. Consequently the space CX,Y (S) is amenable in either of the cases (a)–(c). Now pick an S-invariant state µ : CX,Y (S) → C and denote P = Eµ : X → Y ∗ = X. Then we have by Proposition 2.8 that Ran P = X S and P is the identity map on X S , whence the desired properties (ii)–(iii) follow. As for property (i), it is a consequence of Lemma 2.5. We now address the conditions (d)–(f). We are going to apply Proposition 2.8 with Y = X ∗ . Again we first need to check that the space CX,Y (S) is amenable. In both cases (d) and (e) this is obvious since the whole space Fb (S) is amenable. In the case (f) note that CX,Y ⊆ Cb (S) and the latter space is amenable. Thus the space CX,Y (S) is amenable under either of the conditions (d)–(f), and then we can pick an S-invariant state µ : CX,Y (S) → C and denote P = Eµ : X → Y ∗ = X ∗∗ . We are going to prove that actually Ran Eµ ⊆ X, and then the desired properties (i)–(iii) will follow just as above, by Proposition 2.8 along with Lemma 2.5. Firstly assume that the condition (d) is satisfied and let x ∈ X arbitrary. In order to show that Eµ (x) ∈ X we have to check that Eµ (x) : X ∗ → C is weak∗ continuous. To this end, it is enough to check that Eµ (x) is weak∗ -continuous on the unit ball of X ∗ . (See e.g., Corollary 2 to Theorem 6.2 in Chapter IV of [25].) weak∗
Thus let {ψj }j∈J be a net in X ∗ such that ψj ≤ 1 for all j ∈ J and ψj −→ 0. j∈J
Then ψj −→ 0 uniformly on the compact subsets of X. On the other hand, since S j∈J
is compact, it follows that {α(s, x) | s ∈ S} is a compact subset of X, hence (ψj ◦ weak∗
α)(·, x) −→ 0 uniformly on S. Consequently (Eµ (x))(ψj ) = µ((ψj ◦ α)(·, x)) −→ 0, j∈J
j∈J
and thus Eµ (x) is weak∗ -continuous on the unit ball of X ∗ . In the case (e), first recall that µ actually extends to an S-invariant state of Fb (S), and in particular to an S-invariant state µ : Cb (S) → C. Thus µ actually defines a Radon measure on S. Next, as in the case (d), we let x ∈ X arbitrary and check that Eµ (x) : X → C is weak∗ -continuous on the unit ball of X ∗ . Since X is separable, the weak∗ -topology of the unit ball of X ∗ is metrizable, hence it is weak∗
enough to check that, if {ψj }j≥0 is a sequence in the unit ball of X ∗ with ψj −→ 0 j→∞
then lim Eµ (x) (ψj ) = 0. But this fact follows by Lebesgue’s dominated converj→∞
gence theorem, since Eµ (x) (ψj ) = µ((ψj ◦ α)(·, x)) and (ψj ◦ α)(·, x)∞ ≤ sup αs cb · x for all j ≥ 1. s∈S
In the case (f), since S is a compact group, it follows by Proposition 4.2.2.1 in [30] that for each x ∈ X the mapping α(·, x) is actually continuous, hence the conclusion follows by (d). Alternatively, note that the invariant state µ : Cb (S) → C is defined by a probability Haar measure on S, and use of Proposition 2 and
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
11
Remark 1 in Chapter III, §4, no. 1 in [8] to show that Ran Eµ (x) ∈ X for all x ∈ X. We note that, under the hypothesis (f) of Theorem 3.1, the mapping Eµ : X → X used in the proof shows up in several places in the existing literature. See e.g., Weyl’s unitary trick (that is, the fact that every representation of a compact group is similar to a unitary representation) or, more recently, [10] and [20]. For the first corollary of Theorem 3.1 we recall that an operator space Y is said to be injective if for any complete isometry ϕ : X0 → X and every ψ0 ∈ CB(X0 , Y ) there exists ψ ∈ CB(X, Y ) such that ψ ◦ ϕ = ψ0 and ψcb = ψ0 cb . (See [11] for details.) Corollary 3.2. Let X be a dual operator space and S an amenable semigroup of completely contractive, weak∗ -continuous linear mappings on X. If X is an injective operator space, then X S is in turn injective. Proof. It follows by Theorem 3.1 along with condition (a) in Definition 2.2 that there exists a completely contractive projection P : X → X with Ran P = X S . Now the desired conclusion follows by Proposition 4.1.6 in [11]. It is safe to say that most of the assertions contained in the following two theorems are parts of the folklore of operator algebras. However we would like to show how they follow directly from Theorem 3.1 and to emphasize that the idempotent mappings we construct here are completely bounded. Before going further, we recall that any ∗-homomorphism of C ∗ -algebras is completely contractive and any ∗-automorphism of a von Neumann algebra is weak∗ -continuous. Theorem 3.3. Let A be a C ∗ -algebra, G a topological group, and α : G → Aut (A) a group homomorphism such that for each x ∈ A the map g → αg (x) is continuous with respect to the norm topology of A. (When G is locally compact, the triple (A, G, α) with these properties is called in literature a C ∗ -dynamical system.) Then the following hold true: (a) If G is amenable then there exists a completely bounded idempotent mapping Q : A∗ → A∗ whose range consists of all linear forms φ ∈ A∗ which are αinvariant, i.e., φ(αg (x)) = φ(x) for all g ∈ G and all x ∈ A. Moreover, if A is unital, then Q(S(A)) ⊂ S(A) hence Q maps the set of all states of A onto the set of all α-invariant states. (b) If G is a compact group, then there exists a completely positive and completely contractive idempotent P : A → A with Ran P = {x ∈ A | αg (x) = x for all g ∈ G}. Proof. (a) Let us consider the action β of G on the dual space A∗ defined by β(g, φ)(x) = φ(αg−1 (x)) for all x ∈ A and all φ ∈ A∗ . It easy to see that A∗ becomes, via this action, a dual operator G-space satisfying Theorem 3.1 item (b) for the case when G is
12
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
locally compact or item (c) for the case when G is a topological group. Now the conclusion follows from that theorem. b) Follows immediately from Theorem 3.1(f) with X = A. Remark 3.4. We refer to [23] for general information on C ∗ -dynamical systems. In the case when G is an amenable locally compact group, the item (a) in Theorem 3.3 holds true under the weaker hypothesis that all the functions g → φ(αg (x)) are continuous on G for all x ∈ A and all φ ∈ A∗ . Indeed, in this case we can apply Theorem 3.1 item (b) to the operator G-space A. Theorem 3.5. Let M be a von Neumann algebra, G a topological group and α : G → Aut (M ) a group homomorphism such that for each x ∈ M and each φ ∈ M∗ (the predual of M ) the functions g → φ(αg (x)) are continuous on G. (When G is locally compact, the triple (M, G, α) as above is called a W ∗ -dynamical system.) Then the following hold true: (a) Suppose either G is an amenable locally compact group or G is an amenable (not necessarily locally compact) topological group with the additional hypothesis (in this general case) that for all φ ∈ M∗ the mapping g → α∗g (φ) is continuous with respect to the norm topology of the predual M∗ . Then there exists a completely positive unital (hence completely contractive too) idempotent mapping P : M → M whose range is the fixed point algebra of α. In particular, it follows that if M is injective, then the fixed point algebra is also injective. (b) If G is compact, then there exists a completely contractive idempotent mapping Q : M∗ → M∗ whose range is precisely the set of all α-invariant normal forms on M . Moreover, Q maps the set of all normal states of M onto the set of all normal and α-invariant states of M . The dual map Q∗ : M → M is a faithful completely positive and normal idempotent mapping whose range is the fixed point algebra of α (faithful means that Ker P ∩ M + = {0}). Proof. a) This follows from Theorem 3.1 item (b) for the case when G is locally compact or from item (c) when G is a topological group. b) Let us consider, in a similar way as in the proof of the preceding theorem, the action β : G × M∗ → M∗ defined by β(g, φ)(x) = φ(αg−1 (x)). Then M∗ becomes an operator G-space, and moreover, by Proposition 4.2.2.1 in [30], the action β is also continuous with respect to the norm topology on M∗ . Now the existence and other properties (except faithfulness) of Q∗ follows from item (f) in Theorem 3.1. The expression of Q as an integral with respect to the Haar measure on a compact group shows that Q∗ = P , where P is the one from (a). Thence the asserted properties of Q∗ follow.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
13
As another consequence of Theorem 3.1 we now get the following version of Theorem 16(b) in [15]. See [16] for more information on generalized Toeplitz operators. Corollary 3.6. Let (S, ·) be an amenable semigroup, H be a complex Hilbert space and ρ : S → B(H) a norm-continuous mapping such that ρ(st) = ρ(s)ρ(t), ρ(1) = idH and ρ(s) ≤ 1 for all s, t ∈ S. Now consider the space of ρ-Toeplitz operators T (ρ) = {C ∈ B(H) | (∀s ∈ S)
ρ(s)Cρ(s)∗ = C}.
Then there exists a completely positive, completely contractive mapping P : B(H) → B(H) with Ran P = T (ρ), P ◦ P = P and P (ADB ∗ ) = AP (D)B ∗ whenever D ∈ B(H) and A and B belong to the commutant of ρ(S). Proof. First note that condition (a) in Definition 2.2 is satisfied for X = B(H) with the structure of dual operator S-space defined by α : S × B(H) → B(H),
α(s, A) = ρ(s)Aρ(s)∗ .
Clearly B(H)S = T (ρ), hence Theorem 3.1 shows that there exists an idempotent completely contractive linear mapping P : B(H) → B(H) with Ran P = T (ρ). Now it follows by the very construction of P that P is completely positive and P (ADB ∗ ) = AP (D)B ∗ whenever D ∈ B(H) and A and B belong to the commutant of ρ(S). Corollary 3.7. Let T (T) be the space of all Toeplitz operators on the Hardy space H 2 (T) associated with the unit disk. Then there exists a completely positive, completely contractive linear mapping P : B(H 2 (T)) → B(H 2 (T)) such that P ◦ P = P and Ran P = T (T). In particular T (T) is an injective operator space. Proof. Let Mz : H 2 (T) → H 2 (T),
(Mz f )(eiθ ) = eiθ f (eiθ ),
the unilateral shift operator. It is well known that T (T) = {C ∈ B(H 2 (T)) | Mz∗ CMz = C}, hence the desired conclusion follows by Corollary 3.6 applied for the Abelian semigroup (S, ·) = (N, +) and ρ : N → B(H 2 (T)), ρ(n)C = (Mz∗ )n C(Mz )n for all n ∈ N. We note that (N, +) is amenable since it is Abelian (see Theorem 1.2.1 in [12]). As another consequence of Theorem 3.1 we now provide an alternative proof of Theorem 2.4(a) in [2]. In the special case when M = B(H), the next corollary shows that the set C= (ϕ) = {X ∈ B(H) | ϕ(X) = X} studied in [24] is an injective operator space provided ϕ : B(H) → B(H) is a weak∗ -continuous, completely positive, completely contractive map.
14
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
Corollary 3.8. Let M be a W ∗ -algebra, α : M → M a weak∗ -continuous completely positive, completely contractive linear mapping, and denote Mα = {x ∈ M | α(x) = x}. Then there exists an idempotent, completely positive, completely contractive, linear mapping P : M → M with Ran P = Mα . Proof. The existence of a completely contractive projection P from M onto Mα follows by Theorem 3.1 for X = M, S = (N, +) and α(n, x) = αn (x) whenever n ∈ N and x ∈ M. To conclude the proof, we only have to remark that the idempotent mapping P given by Theorem 3.1 is completely positive according to its construction, since α : M → M is completely positive (see also the construction of Eµ in Definition 2.4). We now arrive at a corollary that has interesting consequences in providing certain homogeneous spaces with structures of Banach manifolds. See [3] and also Corollary 3.10 below. Corollary 3.9. Let X be a complex Banach space, S a topological group and α : S → B(X ),
s → αs ,
a norm continuous representation of S by bounded linear operators on X such that α1 = idX and sup αs < ∞. Assume that one of the following hypotheses holds: s∈S
(a) S is an amenable topological group and X is a dual Banach space such that αs : X → X is weak∗ -continuous for all s ∈ S, or (b) S is a compact topological group. Next denote X S = {x ∈ X | (∀s ∈ S) αs (x) = x}. Then there exists a bounded linear operator P ∈ B(X ) such that P ≤ sup αs , Ran P = X S and P 2 = P .
s∈S
Proof. We are going to apply Theorem 3.1 for the operator space X = max X . According to (3.3.9) in [11] we have an isometric identification B(X ) CB(max X ), hence it follows at once that max X is an operator S-space. On the other hand, the above identification shows that the desired conclusion will follow as soon as we show that each of the present hypotheses implies one of the conditions of Theorem 3.1 for the operator space X = max X . Actually, it is obvious that the present hypothesis (b) implies that condition (f) in Theorem 3.1 is fulfilled. As for the present hypothesis (a), note that it implies that the condition (c) in Theorem 3.1 is satisfied. In fact, it follows by (3.3.15) in [11] that if Y is a Banach space such that X = Y ∗ then (min Y)∗ = max Y ∗ = max X , hence max X is the dual operator space of min Y, and we are done.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
15
The next result is a partial extension of Theorem 4.8 in [9] and is also related to Theorems 3.12 and 4.4 in [1]. We note that under hypothesis (a) of this corollary we do not require that the group G should be locally compact, and thus the result holds for infinite-dimensional Lie groups. Corollary 3.10. Let A be a unital operator algebra and denote by A× its group of invertible elements. Consider an amenable topological group G and denote R := {ρ : G → A× | ρ continuous group homomorphism and sup ρ(g) < ∞}. g∈G
Assume that one of the following conditions is satisfied: (i) A is a dual algebra, or (ii) G is compact. Then the orbits of the action A× × R → R,
(a, ρ) → a · ρ(·) · a−1 ,
have natural structures of Banach manifolds that are smoothly acted on by the Banach-Lie group A× . Proof. In the proof we need techniques and ideas from Lie theory that were recalled in the introduction. Fix ρ ∈ R and consider its isotropy group (A× )ρ = {a ∈ A× | (∀g ∈ G)
a · ρ(g) · a−1 = ρ(g)}.
We shall prove that (A× )ρ is a Banach-Lie subgroup of A× , and then the desired conclusion follows by Theorem 8.19 in [29] in view of the natural bijection that exists from A× /(A× )ρ onto the orbit of ρ. To show that (A× )ρ is a Banach-Lie subgroup of A× , we first note that it is an algebraic subgroup of A× of degree ≤ 1 in the sense explained in the introduction to the present paper. It then follows that (A× )ρ has a structure of Banach-Lie group with the topology inherited from A× , as a consequence of the main result of [14]. The Lie algebra of A× is L (A× ) = A, while the Lie algebra of (A× )ρ is L ((A× )ρ ) = {a ∈ A | (∀g ∈ G) a · ρ(g) = ρ(g) · a} = ρ(G) , hence it remains to prove that the commutant ρ(G) has a complement in A. To this end, consider the action of G on A defined by α : G × A → A,
α(g, a) = ρ(g)aρ(g)−1 .
This action makes A into an operator G-space, since α(g, ·) is completely bounded on A for all g ∈ G as an easy consequence of Theorem 17.1.2 in [11]. Moreover note that condition (b) in Definition 2.2 is satisfied. In case (i), it follows by Theorem 2.1 in [6] that the multiplication in A is separately weak∗ -continuous, hence A is actually a dual operator G-space. Now we see that in either of the cases (i) and (ii) it follows by Theorem 3.1 that there exists a completely bounded idempotent mapping P : A → A with Ran P = AG = ρ(G) , and we are done.
16
Beltit¸a ˘ and Prunaru
IEOT
We point out that some further smoothness properties of similarity orbits of group representations (in particular existence of complex structures on the unitary orbits) are discussed in [18] and [19].
References [1] E. Andruchow, G. Corach, D. Stojanoff, A geometric characterization of nuclearity and injectivity. J. Funct. Anal. 133 (1995), no. 2, 474–494. [2] A. Arias, A. Gheondea, S. Gudder, Fixed points of quantum operations. J. Math. Phys. 43 (2002), no. 12, 5872–5881. [3] D. Beltit¸a ˘, T.S. Ratiu, Symplectic leaves in real Banach Lie-Poisson spaces. Geom. Funct. Anal. 28 (2005), no. 1, 59-73. [4] J.F. Berglund, K.H. Hofmann, Compact Semitopological Semigroups and Weakly Almost Periodic Functions. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, No. 42, Springer-Verlag, Berlin-New York, 1967. [5] J.F. Berglund, H.D. Junghenn, P. Milnes, Compact Right Topological Semigroups and Generalizations of Almost Periodicity. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, No. 663, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1978. [6] D.P. Blecher, Multipliers and dual operator algebras. J. Funct. Anal. 183 (2001), no. 2, 498–525. [7] D.P. Blecher, C. Le Merdy, Operator Algebras and Their Modules. An Operator Space Approach. London Mathematical Society Monographs. New Series. The Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2004. ´ ements de Math´ematique. Fasc. XIII. Livre VI: Int´egration, [8] N. Bourbaki, El´ Chapitres 1–4. (Deuxi`eme ´edition revue et augment´ee) Actualit´es Scientifiques et Industrielles, No. 1175 Hermann, Paris, 1965. [9] G. Corach, J.E. Gal´e, On amenability and geometry of spaces of bounded representations. J. London Math. Soc. (2) 59 (1999), no. 1, 311–329. [10] S. Doplicher, R. Longo, J.E. Roberts, L. Zsid´ o, A remark on quantum group actions and nuclearity Rev. Math. Phys. 14 (2002), no. 7-8, 787–796. [11] E.G. Effros, Zh.-J. Ruan, Operator Spaces. London Mathematical Society Monographs. New Series, 23. The Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press, New York, 2000. [12] F.P. Greenleaf, Invariant Means on Topological Groups and Their Applications. Van Nostrand Mathematical Studies, No. 16, Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New YorkToronto, Ont.-London, 1969. [13] P. de la Harpe, Moyennabilit´e du groupe unitaire et propri´et´e P de Schwartz des alg`ebres de von Neumann. In: “Alg`ebres d’Op´erateurs (S´em., Les Plans-sur-Bex, 1978),” Lecture Notes in Math., 725, Springer Berlin, 1979, pp. 220–227. [14] L.A. Harris, W. Kaup, Linear algebraic groups in infinite dimensions. Illinois J. Math. 21 (1977), no. 3, 666–674. [15] L. K´erchy, Generalized Toeplitz operators. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 68 (2002), no. 1-2, 373–400.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Amenability and Completely Bounded Projections
17
[16] L. K´erchy, Elementary and reflexive hyperplanes of generalized Toeplitz operators. J. Operator Theory 51 (2004), no. 2, 387–409. [17] A. L uczak, Invariant states and ergodic dynamical systems on W ∗ -algebras. Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 111 (1992) no. 1, 181–192. [18] M. Martin, Projective representations of compact groups in C ∗ -algebras. In “Linear Operators in Function Spaces (Timi¸soara, 1988),” Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., Birkh¨ auser, 43, Basel, 1990, pp. 237–253. [19] M. Martin, N. Salinas, Differential geometry of generalized Grassmann manifolds in C ∗ -algebras. In: “Operator Theory and Boundary Eigenvalue Problems (Vienna, 1993),” Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., Birkh¨ auser, 80, Basel, 1995, pp. 206–243. [20] A. Odzijewicz, T.S. Ratiu, Banach Lie-Poisson spaces and reduction. Comm. Math. Phys. 243 (2003), no. 1, 1–54. [21] A.L.T. Paterson, Nuclear C ∗ -algebras have amenable unitary groups. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 114 (1992), no. 3, 719–721. [22] V. Paulsen, Completely Bounded Maps and Operator Algebras Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, 78. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2002. [23] G.K. Pedersen, C ∗ -algebras and Their Automorphism Groups. London Mathematical Society Monographs, 14. Academic Press, Inc., London-New York, 1979. [24] G. Popescu, Similarity and ergodic theory of positive linear maps. J. Reine Angew. Math. 561 (2003), 87–129. [25] H.H. Schaefer, Topological Vector Spaces. The Macmillan Co., Collier-Macmillan Ltd., New York-London, 1966. [26] A.M. Sinclair, R.R. Smith, The Hochschild cohomology problem for von Neumann algebras. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 95 (1998), no. 7, 3376–3379. [27] A.M. Sinclair, R.R. Smith, A survey of Hochschild cohomology for von Neumann algebras. In “Operator algebras, Quantization, and Noncommutative Geometry,” Contemp. Math., 365, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2004, pp. 383–400. [28] M. Takesaki, Theory of Operator Algebras III. Encyclopaedia of Mathematical Sciences, 127. Operator Algebras and Non-commutative Geometry, 8. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2003. [29] H. Upmeier, Symmetric Banach Manifolds and Jordan C ∗ -algebras. North-Holland Mathematics Studies, 104. Notas de Matem´ atica, 96. North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam, 1985. [30] G. Warner, Harmonic Analysis on Semi-Simple Lie Groups I. Die Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Band 188. Springer-Verlag, New York-Heidelberg, 1972. Daniel Beltit¸a ˘ and Bebe Prunaru Institute of Mathematics “Simion Stoilow” of the Romanian Academy P.O. Box 1-764, RO-014700 Bucharest Romania e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] Submitted: August 10, 2005
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 19–41 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010019-23, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1445-1
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Eigenvalue Distribution of Positive Definite Kernels on Unbounded Domains Jorge Buescu and A. C. Paix˜ao Abstract. We study eigenvalues of positive definite kernels of L2 integral operators on unbounded real intervals. Under the assumptions of integrability and uniform continuity of the kernel on the diagonal the operator is compact and trace class. We establish sharp results which determine the eigenvalue distribution as a function of the smoothness of the kernel and its decay rate at infinity along the diagonal. The main result deals at once with all possible orders of differentiability and all possible rates of decay of the kernel. The known optimal results for eigenvalue distribution of positive definite kernels in compact intervals are particular cases. These results depend critically on a 2-parameter differential family of inequalities for the kernel which is a consequence of positivity and is a differential generalization of diagonal dominance. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 45C05, 45P05. Keywords. Integral operators, positive definite kernels, eigenvalues.
1. Introduction and definitions Given an interval I ⊂ R, a linear operator K : L2 (I) → L2 (I) is integral if there exists a measurable function k(x, y) on I × I such that for all φ ∈ L2 (I) (1.1) φ −→ K(φ) = k(x, y) φ(y) dy I
almost everywhere. The function k(x, y) is called the kernel of K. If k(x, y) = k(y, x) a.e. in I 2 then K is self-adjoint. If in addition K satisfies the condition k(x, y) φ(y)φ(x) dx dy ≥ 0 (1.2) I
I
for all φ ∈ L2 (I), then it is a positive operator and the corresponding kernel k(x, y) is called a positive definite kernel . The first author acknowledges partial support by CAMGSD through FCT/POCI/FEDER.
20
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
This paper shall deal exclusively with positive integral operators and the corresponding positive definite kernels. Its purpose is the study of the asymptotic behavior of eigenvalues of K in the case where I is unbounded. The case where I is a compact interval has been thoroughly studied. We next describe what is known in this case. Integral operators with L2 (I 2 ) kernels are compact. For self-adjoint operators standard spectral methods yield the bilinear expansion for the kernel k(x, y) = λn φn (x) φn (y), (1.3) n≥1
where λn ∈ R are the eigenvalues of K repeated according to multiplicity, ordered non-increasingly by absolute value and accumulating only at 0. The {φn }n≥1 are the corresponding L2 (I)-orthonormal eigenfunctions spanning the range of K and equality is in the L2 (I) sense. If the operator is positive, k(x, y) is a positive definite kernel and λn ≥ 0, so the eigenvalue sequence {λn }n≥1 is non-increasing. The asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalue sequence {λn }n≥1 is closely related to smoothness properties of the kernel k(x, y). If k is continuous, the classical theorem of Mercer (see e.g. [22]) asserts that eigenfunctions are continuous, convergence of the series (1.3) is absolute and uniform and the operator K is trace class with λn (1.4) tr (K) = k(x, x) dx = I
n≥1
from which the basic eigenvalue estimate λn = o(1/n) is derived. For general (not necessarily positive definite) kernels it was shown by Weyl [23] that if k(x, y) is C 1 then λn = o(1/n3/2 ). This estimate may be improved when k is a positive definite kernel, as shown by Reade [16], to λn = o(1/n2 ). It may also be shown that if a positive definite kernel k, in addition to continuity, satisfies a Lipschitz condition of order α, 0 < α ≤ 1, then λn = O(1/n1+α ), and that this estimate is best possible as a power of n. More generally, positive In fact the optimal estimates are definite C p kernels satisfy λn = o(1/np+1 ) [18]. ∞ slightly sharper: λn = o(1/np+1 ) for odd p and 1 np λn < +∞ for even p; see Ha [10] and Reade [19]. Cochran and Lukas [8] and Chang and Ha [7] derive the corresponding results for the decay rate of eigenvalues when a suitable higher-order derivative is Lipα . Comparatively with the case where I is compact, little is known about eigenvalues of positive definite kernels in unbounded domains. There are fundamental reasons for this: integral operators in unbounded domains are in general noncompact, so there will be no pure eigenvalue spectrum but in general also a continuous part. The abstract theory of eigenvalue distribution for integral operators uses operator ideals and interpolation between Besov spaces; see e.g. Birman and Solomyak [1], Gohberg-Krein [9], K¨ onig [12], Pietsch [15] and references therein. While this approach allows for more precise estimation of eigenvalue asymptotics (determining Lorentz space summability of {λn }), its results are not directly applicable
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
21
to our context. In fact, most of the results are valid only in bounded domains; for unbounded domains compactness of the operators must be externally forced. Thus Pietsch [15] and Birman and Solomyak [1] achieve this with parametrically weighted kernels. If the weights are sufficiently strong to ensure that the resulting kernel and its derivatives decay sufficiently fast at ∞, eigenvalue estimates may be derived. It should however be noted that there are no results in this theory specifically for positive definite kernels in unbounded domains. From what has been described for the compact case, it is to be expected that restriction to this class of kernels yields results which improve on the general estimates. Indeed, although a straightforward comparison is much more delicate than in the compact case (see, e.g., Pietsch’s 10-parameter eigenvalue theorem in [15]), this paper shows that one can say much more in this case than follows from the general theory. For instance, we show below that under very mild assumptions (integrability on the diagonal), positivity is sufficient to ensure compactness of the operator, thus totally dispensing weight factors.
2. Preliminaries: classes Sn and An The purpose of this paper is the study of the eigenvalue distribution of positive integral operators in the case where I is an unbounded interval in R. For this purpose, it will be essential to restrict to the following classes of kernels. Note first of all that if k(x, y) is a continuous positive definite kernel then ∀x ∈ I k(x, x) ≥ 0 and ∀x, y ∈ I |k(x, y)|2 ≤ k(x, x)k(y, y); we refer to this property as the diagonal dominance inequality for positive definite kernels. In all this section I ⊂ R is only assumed to be a topologically closed interval; the definitions and results below apply whether I is bounded or not. Definition 2.1. A function k(x, y) : I 2 → C is said to belong to class A0 (I) if: 1. k(x, y) is continuous in I 2 ; 2. k(x, x) ∈ L1 (I); 3. k(x, x) is uniformly continuous in I. Remark 2.2. If I is compact, a kernel is in A0 (I) if and only if it is continuous in I 2 . Less obviously, if I is unbounded then a positive definite kernel k ∈ A0 (I) if and only if k(x, y) is continuous in I 2 , k(x, x) ∈ L1 (I) and k(x, x) → 0 as |x| → +∞; see [2]. The following summarizes the essential properties of A0 (I) positive definite kernels. For compact I these follow from the classical Mercer theorem (see e.g. [22]); for unbounded I they are proved in [2]. If k(x, y) is a positive definite kernel in class A0 (I), then the associated integral operator K defined by (1.1) is Hilbert-Schmidt, therefore compact, so it has a pure eigenvalue spectrum {λn }n≥1 with λn ≥ 0 forming a non-increasing sequence converging to 0. Eigenfunctions φn associated with nonzero eigenvalues
22
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
are uniformly continuous and so vanish at infinity in I is unbounded. Moreover, Mercer’s theorem holds in this wider context: the bilinear eigenseries (1.3) for the kernel is absolutely and uniformly convergent and the operator K : L2 (I) → L2 (I) is trace class with trace given by (1.4), whence the eigenvalue sequence satisfies λn = o(1/n). Class A0 (I) seems to be the most general class of positive definite kernels (in bounded or unbounded domains) for which Mercer’s theorem holds; see counterexamples in [2] as well as more general results in Novitskii [13]. It is therefore natural to adopt it as the starting point for the study of eigenvalue distribution of positive definite kernels in unbounded domains. Remark 2.3. Throughout this paper the diagonal {(x, y) ∈ I 2 : y = x} will play a prominent role in determining the behavior of k(x, y). We abbreviate reference to this set simply as “the diagonal”. The following definitions are useful in the study of properties arising from differentiability of the kernel k. If x is a boundary point of I, a limit at x will mean the one-sided limit as y → x with x ∈ I. Definition 2.4. Let I ⊂ R be an interval. A function k : I 2 → C is said to be of class Sn (I) if, for every m1 = 0, 1, . . . n and m2 = 0, 1, . . . n, the partial derivatives ∂ m1 +m2 k(x, y) exist and are continuous in I 2 . ∂y m2 ∂xm1 Definition 2.5. Let n ≥ 1 be an integer. A function k : R2 → C is said to belong to class An (I) if k ∈ Sn (I) and k(x, y),
∂2 ∂ 2n k(x, y), . . . n n k(x, y) ∂y∂x ∂y ∂x
are in class A0 (I). Remark 2.6. Observe, in analogy with Remark 2.2, that if I is compact Sn (I) ⊂ An (I). If I is compact the contents of Theorem 2.7 below are essentially proved by Kadota [11]; the extension to unbounded I is proved in [5]. Here H n (I) denotes the Sobolev Hilbert space W n,2 (I). Theorem 2.7. Let k(x, y) be a positive definite kernel in An (I) with eigenseries expansion (1.3). Then the following statements hold. 1. If λi = 0, φi is in C n (I) ∩ H n (I); 2. each km is a positive definite kernel in class An−m (I) and ∂ 2m k (m) (m) km (x, y) = (x, y) = λi φi (x)φi (y) ∂y m ∂xm i≥1
uniformly and absolutely in I 2 for each m = 0, 1, . . . , n;
(2.1)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
3. the L2 (I) integral operator Km with kernel km is trace class with tr(Km ) = Km = km (x, x) dx.
23
(2.2)
I
Particular attention will be devoted, in § 4, to positive definite kernels in class A0 (I) ∩ Sn (I). Observe that, trivially from the definitions, An (I) ⊂ A0 (I) ∩ Sn (I).
3. Preparatory results We next present methods introduced by Ha [10] and Reade [16]. Although adaptations of these methods have been developed in [6] to the context of integral operators defined in unbounded domains, in this paper we will only need results relative to operators defined in the compact interval [0, L]. Proofs may be found in these papers and will be omitted. 3.1. Best approximations Let k be a continuous positive definite kernel in [0, L]2 and K be the associated positive integral operator. It follows from the general theory of compact operators N in Hilbert space that, if R is the operator with kernel n=1 λn φn (x) φn (y), then R is the best approximation to K in the operator norm by symmetric operators of rank ≤ N , the minimum distance being K − Rop = λn+1 (see e.g. Gohberg and Krein [9], Theorem III.6.1). Also N n=1 λn φn (x) φn (y) is the best approximation to k(x, t) by L2 ([0, L]) symmetric kernels of rank ≤ N which generate compact ∞ integral operators, the minimum distance being ( n=N +1 λ2n )1/2 (see [22] for a version for integral operators or [9] for linear operators in Hilbert space). N Lemma 3.1. If k(x, y) is continuous in [0, L]2 , then n=1 λn φn (x) φn (y) is the best approximation in the trace norm by L2 ([0, L]) symmetric kernels of rank ≤ N . 3.2. Square roots Any positive operator K in Hilbert space has a unique positive square root S [21]. This fact implies that if K is a positive operator with continuous kernel k satisfying the bilinear eigenfunction expansion (1.3), the corresponding square root operator S is an L2 ([0, L]) positive integral operator. Since K is trace class, standard arguments imply that the positive definite kernel s(x, y) of S satisfies the bilinear expansion s(x, y) = λ1/2 (3.1) n φn (x) φn (y), n≥1
where the last equality is in the sense of L2 convergence. In general, of course, s(x, y) will not be continuous, so the corresponding operator S will not be trace class. However, the following holds.
24
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
Lemma 3.2. If k(x, y) is continuous in [0, L] and s(x, y) is the kernel of the corresponding positive square root operator, then for any f ∈ L2 ([0, L])
L
Sf (x) =
s(x, y)f (y) dy 0
is a continuous function of x. 3.3. A class of finite rank operators We now define a class of finite rank operators to be used in the approximation of a positive operator K with continuous kernel k defined in the interval [0, L], L > 0. Let N > 0 be an integer and L > 0 be a positive real number. We define RN,L to be the L2 ([0, L]) operator with kernel rN,L (u, v) = where ψnN,L(x) =
1 0
N N N,L ψ (u) ψnN,L(v), L n=1 n
L L < x ≤ nN if (n − 1) N otherwise.
Clearly, RN,L is an orthogonal projection in L2 ([0, L]). It is thus a positive operator of rank N with 0 ≤ RN,L ≤ I. Its spectrum is {0, 1}, the eigenvalue 1 having multiplicity N and the corresponding orthogonal (unnormalized) eigenfunctions being the ψnN,L. Given an operator K ∈ L2 ([0, L]) with continuous kernel k and square root S, it follows that 0 ≤ SRN,LS ≤ K; since by Lemma 3.2 ([16], Lemma 3) SRN,LS has a continuous kernel, it is trace class. It then follows (see [16], [6] for details) that n NL L N N nN (k(u, u) − k(u, v)) du dv (3.2) L (n−1) NL (n−1) NL n=1 L n NL N k(u, u) − k(u, v) − k(v, u) + k(v, v) N nN = du dv (3.3) L (n−1) NL (n−1) NL 2 n=1
K − SRN,LStr =
Equations (3.2) and (3.3) will be used in § 4 in the proof of our main results. Remark 3.3. Since self-adjointness of the operator K implies conjugate symmetry of the kernel, it is immediate to conclude that the contribution of the imaginary LL part of k to the integral 0 0 rN,L (u, v)k(v, u) du dv is zero. The same observation obviously applies to integration in any square symmetric with respect to the diagonal. Consequently, we may regard k(u, v) in (3.2) and (3.3) as being real-valued without any loss of generality.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
25
3.4. Eigenvalues of symmetric derivatives The evaluation of the rate of decay of eigenvalues of the operators Km , m a positive ∂ 2m k(x, y) integer, whose kernels are the symmetric derivatives km (x, y) = ∂y m ∂xm of the class Sm ([0, L]) positive definite kernel k plays a key role in the study of the eigenvalues of the operator K with kernel k (see e.g. [8], [10]). Recall that, according to Theorem 2.7, km is a continuous positive definite kernel defined on the compact set [0, L]2 . Conventions and properties, in particular Mercer’s theorem described in § 1, are thus applicable to km . A straightforward adaptation of a result of Ha [10] for positive definite kernels defined in [0, 1]2 yields the following upper bound for the eigenvalues of an operator K with positive definite kernel in Sm ([0, L]): Lemma 3.4. Let k : [0, L]2 → C be a positive definite kernel in class Sm ([0, L]), m ≥ 1. Let {λn (k)}n∈N (resp. {λn (km )}n∈N ) be the sequence of eigenvalues of the integral operator with kernel k (resp. km ). Then λ2n (k) ≤ L
2m
4 π2
λn (km ) (2n − 4m − 1)2m
for every n ≥ 2m + 1. Given a trace class kernel k, we define its N -tail Tk (N ) = We now state and prove a useful consequence of Lemma 3.4.
∞
n=N +1
λn (k).
Corollary 3.5. Let k : [0, L]2 → C be a positive definite kernel in class Sm ([0, L]), m ≥ 1. Then there exists N0 ∈ N and a real positive constant C such that Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C
L N
2m Tkm (N )
for N > N0 . Proof. According to Lemma 3.4 we may write, for every n > N0 = 2m + 1, 4 λn (km ) n2m L2m 2 (2n − 4m − 1)2m π n2m 2m L 4 1 ≤ m λn (km ) 4 n π2 2m C L λn (km ), = 2 n
λ2n (k) ≤
26
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
8 where C = m 2 depends only on m. Since λn (k) and λn (km ) are positive non4 π increasing sequences, using the above inequalities we obtain ∞
Tk (2N + 1) =
λn (k)
n=2N +2 ∞
=
λ2n (k) + λ2n+1 (k) ≤ 2
n=N +1 ∞
≤2
n=N +1
=CL
2m
2m
C 2
2m L λn (km ) n
∞
λ2n (k)
n=N +1
∞ λn (km ) n2m
n=N +1 ∞
L λn (km ) N 2m n=N +1 2m L =C Tkm (N ) N ≤C
for N > N0 . This finishes the proof.
4. Asymptotic distribution of eigenvalues This section is devoted to the proof of our main results. We take without loss of generality I = [0, +∞[ as our model unbounded interval; the adaptations to other types of unbounded intervals are trivial. We mention however that the case I = R is particularly significant in view of Fourier transforms, see Remark 4.19 and Corollary 4.20. We begin by establishing some basic lemmas and definitions. Suppose k is a positive definite kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[). Let L > 0 and consider the restriction k L of k to the compact square [0, L]2 . In view of the definition of class A0 (I), both k and k L are positive definite kernels associated with trace class operators on the corresponding intervals. Using the notation introduced in 3.4, we have: Lemma 4.1. Let k ∈ A0 ([0, +∞[) and k L be the restriction of k to [0, L]2 . Then there is N0 ∈ N such that, for N > N0 , we have Tk (N ) ≤ TkL (N ) +
∞
k(x, x) dx. L
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
27
Proof. Since both K and K L are trace class operators we have by (1.4) ∞ L ∞ ∞ λn (k) = k(x, x) dx = k(x, x) dx + k(x, x) dx 0
n=1
=
∞
L
λn (k ) +
n=1
0
L
∞
(4.1)
k(x, x) dx. L
∞ Suppose L k(x, x) dx = 0. Since k is continuous and non-negative along the diagonal it follows that k(x, x) ≡ 0 for x ≥ L. Since k is positive definite, we have by diagonal dominance |k(x, y)|2 ≤ k(x, x)k(y, y), and therefore the support of k is contained in [0, L]2 . Direct calculation then shows that the restriction to [0, L] determines a mapping ϕn → ϕL n from the set of eigenfunctions of k to the set of eigenfunctions of k L which is one-to-one and preserves the associated eigenvalues λn (k). Hence k and k L have the same spectrum (including multiplicities) and Tk (N ) = TkL (N ) for all N . The same conclusion may be derived using the principle of related operators ([12], [14]), since inclusion and truncation in this case act as a relation between the operators K : L2 ([0, ∞[) → L2 ([0, ∞[) and K L : L2 ([0, L]) → L2 ([0, L]), both of which ∞ are compact. ∞ Suppose now L k(x, x) dx > 0. Then (4.1) implies that n=1 λn (k) > ∞ L λ (k ). Thus there exists N ∈ N such that, for N > N , n 0 0 n=1 N n=1
λn (k) ≥
N
λn (k L ).
(4.2)
n=1
From (4.1) and (4.2) we conclude that for N > N0 ∞ Tk (N ) ≤ TkL (N ) + k(x, x) dx, L
finishing the proof. The following result is a central tool in the study of the decay rate of eigenvalues of a positive definite kernel k in class A0 ([0, +∞[) ∩ Sn ([0, +∞[). Lemma 4.2. Let β > 1, q > 0, A > 0, B > 0, x0 > 0, δ > 0 be real numbers. Suppose f : [0, +∞[→ [0, +∞[ is a continuous function satisfying the condition ∞ B L f (x) dx ≤ Lβ−1 for L ≥ x0 . Let R(L, N ) be defined by q ∞ L L+ f (x) dx (4.3) R(L, N ) = A N L L (q + 1)β < δ and write γ = . Then there exist N0 ∈ N, D > 0 and an N q+β increasing sequence L(N ) → +∞ such that L(N )/N is decreasing and convergent to zero and such that the inequality whenever
R(L(N ), N ) ≤
D N γ−1
(4.4)
28
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
holds for N ≥ N0 . q . Observe that, since 0 < θ < 1, L(N ) q+β L(N ) is a decreasing sequence in an increasing sequence converging to +∞ and N L(N0 ) converging to 0. Choose N0 such that N0θ = L(N0 ) > x0 and N0θ−1 = < δ. N0 ∞ L(N ) B < δ and L(N ) f (x) dx ≤ Then L(N ) > x0 , whenever N ≥ N0 . N L(N )β−1 Thus, according to (4.3) we may write q ∞ L(N ) L(N ) + f (x) dx (4.5) R(L(N ), N ) = A N L(N ) Proof. Define L(N ) = N θ with θ =
≤ AN (θ−1)q+θ + B N θ(1−β) .
(4.6)
Performing the corresponding calculations we derive from (4.6) that, for D = A + B, D R(L(N ), N ) ≤ γ−1 N for N ≥ N0 , proving the statement. The optimality of the estimate provided by Lemma 4.2 is the issue of the next result. ∞ Proposition 4.3. Suppose that L f (x) dx ∼ 1/Lβ−1 as L → +∞ while keeping the remaining hypotheses of Lemma 4.2. Then, for any positive sequence L(N ) such that L(N )/N < δ, there exists a subsequence L(N ) and constants N0 , C > 0 such C for N ≥ N0 . In particular, the exponent γ in (4.4) that R(L(N ), N ) ≥ (N )γ−1 cannot be improved for any such sequence L(N ). Proof. The assertion is trivially verified if L(N ) does not converge to ∞. In this case, L(N ) admits a bounded subsequence L(N ) < L0 for some L0 > 0 and we have q ∞ L(N ) L(N ) + f (x) dx R(L(N ), N ) = A N L(N ) ∞ ≥ f (x) dx ≡ C > 0 (4.7) L0
since f is, by hypothesis, a non-negative continuous function ∞ and C = 0 would imply f (x) = 0 for all x > L0 , contradicting the hypothesis L f (x) dx ∼ 1/Lβ−1 . Since γ > 1, from (4.7) we immediately derive C for N ≥ 1. R(L(N ), N ) ≥ (N )γ−1 Suppose now that L(N ) → +∞. From the hypothesis we derive, in particular, ∞ b that there exist constants b > 0, x0 > 0 such that L f (x) dx ≥ β−1 whenever L
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
29
L ≥ x0 . Since L(N ) → +∞, we have L(N ) > x0 for sufficiently large N and hence, from (4.3), q ∞ L(N ) R(L(N ), N ) = A L(N ) + f (x) dx N L(N ) q L(N ) b L(N ) + . (4.8) ≥A N L(N )β−1 Recalling the definition of θ and γ, we rewrite (4.8) in the form q+1 β−1 L(N ) Nθ + b . N γ−1 R(L(N ), N ) ≥ A Nθ L(N )
(4.9)
L(N ) converges either (N )θ γ−1 R(L(N ), N ) → +∞, to 0 or to +∞. Then from (4.9) we conclude that (N ) which implies the assertion of the proposition. On the other hand, if L(N ) does not L(N ) admit such a subsequence it follows that C1 < < C2 for some C1 , C2 > 0 Nθ and all sufficiently large N . From (4.9) we then derive that for sufficiently large N , β−1 1 C , which completes say N ≥ N0 , R(L(N ), N ) ≥ γ−1 for C = A C1q+1 +b N C2 the proof. ∞ B Remark 4.4. Notice that the condition L f (x) dx ≤ β−1 for some B > 0 and L B every L ≥ x0 > 0 is implied by the somewhat less general requirement f (x) ≤ β x for all x ≥ x0 with B = B (β − 1). The hypothesis of Lemma 4.2 may thus be seen as a generalized condition on the rate of decay of f (x) as x → +∞. A similar observation applies to the comparison of the hypothesis of Proposition 4.3 with 1 the condition f (x) ∼ β . x The following uniform continuity and Lipschitz conditions will be useful in the sequence. Suppose L(N ) is a subsequence of L(N ) such that
Definition 4.5. Let k : [0, +∞[→ C. We say that k(x, y) is uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal if for every > 0 there is δ > 0 such that |k(x, x) − k(x, y)| < whenever |x − y| < δ. Definition 4.6. Let k : [0, +∞[→ C and α ∈ ]0, 1]. We say that k(x, y) is α-Lipschitz (written Lipα ) with respect to y on the diagonal if there is a positive constant A such that |k(x, x) − k(x, y)| ≤ A|x − y|α for every (x, y) ∈ [0, +∞[2 . Remark 4.7. It is clear that if k is Lipα with respect to y on the diagonal then it is uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal. It is also clear that each of these conditions is implied by their respective counterpart on the plane. More specifically, uniform continuity on [0, +∞[2 implies the condition in definition 4.5 and Lipα on [0, +∞[2 implies the condition in definition 4.6.
30
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
Remark 4.8. If k is a positive definite kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[), standard arguments together with diagonal dominance and the fact that k(x, x) → 0 as x → +∞ easily show that k is uniformly continuous on the diagonal [2] and, in particular, satisfies the condition in definition 4.5. Remark 4.9. It is easily seen that functions satisfying conjugate symmetry k(x, y) = k(y, x) on [0, +∞[2 and the conditions of definitions 4.5 or 4.6 will automatically satisfy the analogues of these with respect to the variable x. Properties of this kind ∂k ∂k , can also be seen to arise from conjugate symfor the partial derivatives ∂x ∂y metry of k. Incidentally, none of these will play any relevant part in the sequence. We are now ready to prove our main results. They describe how, for a kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[) ∩ Sn ([0, +∞[) — and, in particular, in class An ([0, +∞[) — uniform continuity or Lipα continuity on the diagonal together with the rate of decay of k(x, x) at infinity allow us to control the rate of decay of the eigenvalues. Theorem 4.10. Let m ≥ 0 and suppose k(x, y) is a positive definite kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[) ∩ Sm ([0, +∞[). Let {λn }n∈N be the sequence of eigenvalues of the integral operator with kernel k. Then the following statements hold. 1.1 Suppose km (x, y) is uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal. Then: ∞ ∞ i) If β > 1, L k(x, x) dx = O 1/Lβ−1 (resp. L k(x, x)dx = o 1/Lβ−1 ) (2m + 1)β as L → +∞ and γ = , then λn = O (1/nγ ) (resp. λn = 2m + β γ o(1/n ∞ )). ii) If L k(x, x) dx = O 1/Lβ−1 as L → +∞ for all β > 1, then λn = o (1/nγ ) for all γ < 2m + 1. iii) If k(x, x) has compact support, then λn = o 1/n2m+1 . 1.2 Suppose km (x, y) is Lipα with respect to y on the diagonal. Then: ∞ (2m+α+1)β , i) If β > 1, L k(x, x)dx = O 1/Lβ−1 as L → ∞ and γ = 2m + α + β γ then ∞λn = O (1/n ). ii) If L k(x, x) dx = O 1/Lβ−1 as L → +∞ for all β > 1, then λn = o (1/nγ ) for all γ < 2m + α + 1. iii) If k(x, x) has compact support, then λn = O 1/n2m+α+1 . ∂km 2.1 Suppose km (x, y) is continuously differentiable with respect to x and that ∂x is uniformly continuous with respect to y on thediagonal. Then: ∞ ∞ i) If β > 1, L k(x, x)dx = o 1/Lβ−1 (resp. L k(x, x) dx = o 1/Lβ−1 ) (2m + 2)β , then λn = O (1/nγ ) (resp. λn = as L → +∞ and γ = 2m + 1 + β γ o(1/n ∞ )). ii) If L k(x, x) dx = O 1/Lβ−1 as L → +∞ for all β > 1, then λn = o (1/nγ ) for all γ < 2m + 2. iii) If k(x, x) has compact support, then λn = o 1/n2m+2 .
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
31
2.2 Suppose km (x, y) is continuously differentiable with respect to x and that
∂km ∂x
is Lipα with respect to y on the diagonal. Then: ∞ (2m+α+2)β i) If β > 1, L k(x, x)dx = O 1/Lβ−1 as L → ∞ and γ = , 2m+α+1+β γ then ∞λn = O (1/n ). ii) If L k(x, x) dx = O 1/Lβ−1 as L → +∞ for all β > 1, then λn = o (1/nγ ) for all γ < 2m + α + 2. iii) If k(x, x) has compact support, then λn = O 1/n2m+α+2 . Proof. Let m ≥ 0 and suppose k is a positive definite kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[) ∩ Sm ([0, +∞[). Let k L be the restriction of k to the interval [0, L]2 . By Lemma 4.1 there exists N0 ∈ N such that, for N > N0 , we have ∞ Tk (N ) ≤ TkL (N ) + k(x, x) dx. (4.10) L
In particular, we may write Tk (2N + 1) ≤ TkL (2N + 1) +
∞
k(x, x) dx.
(4.11)
L
According to Corollary 3.5, inequality (4.11) implies, for m ≥ 1, 2m ∞ L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C Tkm L (N ) + k(x, x) dx N L
(4.12)
for some C > 0 and sufficiently large N . For m ≥ 0 we now use the results of § 3 in the approximation of the operator L L L with kernel km by finite rank operators. Let S be the square root of Km . Km N,L Defining R as in § 3.3 and recalling (3.2) and (3.3), we have according to Lemma 3.1 L N,L L (N ) ≤ Km − SR Str Tkm L L N nN N nN L L km (u, u) − km = (u, v) du dv (4.13) L (n−1) NL (n−1) NL n=1 n NL L N L 1 N nN L L L = km (u, u) − km (u, v) − km (v, u) + km (v, v) du dv 2 n=1 L (n−1) NL (n−1) NL (4.14) L where, according to Remark 3.3, we may without loss of generality regard km as being real valued. We are now ready to prove statement 1.1 i). If m = 0 we have by hypothesis γ = 1 and the assertion reduces to the already known fact that, for a kernel k in class A0 , λn (k) = o(1/n). Suppose that m ≥ 1. Since by hypothesis km is in class A0 ([0, +∞[) ∩ Sm ([0, +∞[) and is uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal, for evL L ery > 0 there exists δ > 0, independent of L, such that |km (u, u) − km (u, v)| <
32
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
for all u, v ∈ [0, L] satisfying |v − u| < δ. For every positive L and every positive integer N such that L/N < δ we then have, after performing the relevant calculations from (4.13), 2 N L L N,L L (N ) ≤ K Str ≤ N · = L . (4.15) Tkm m − SR L N Therefore, according to (4.12), we derive for N sufficiently large that 2m ∞ L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C L+ k(x, x) dx. N L
(4.16)
We now use the hypothesis on the decayrate of k(x, x) at infinity. Suppose ∞ there exist β > 1, B > 0, x0 > 0 such that L k(x, x) dx ≤ B/Lβ−1 whenever L ≥ x0 . We recall Lemma 4.2 setting q = 2m and A = C and define a sequence of 2m . Recall, finite rank operators SRN,LS by setting L = L(N ) = N θ with θ = 2m+β from Lemma 4.2, that L(N ) is an increasing sequence with L(N ) → +∞ and such that L(N )/N is decreasing and convergent to 0. Therefore, there exists N0 such that L(N ) > x0 and L(N )/N < δ for every N > N0 . Therefore we derive from (4.16) and Lemma 4.2 that, for sufficiently large N , Tk (2N + 1) ≤
C +B D = γ−1 N γ−1 N
(2m + 1)β . 2m ∞+ β Now, if L k(x, x) dx ≤ B/Lβ−1 whenever L ≥ x0 , the above condition is ∞ verified for some fixed D > 0, which implies that λn = O(1/nγ ). If L k(x, x) dx = o(1/Lβ−1 ) as L → ∞, the same condition holds for arbitrary D > 0 and we derive in this case the stronger conclusion that λn = o(1/nγ ). This finishes the proof of statement 1.1 i). Consider now the hypothesis of statement 1.2 i). Suppose km is Lipα with respect to y on the diagonal. Choose L > 0 and N ∈ N. Then |u − v| < L/N for L L , nN ]. Since km is Lipα , (4.13) implies all u, v ∈ [(n − 1) N α L L N,L Tkm L (N ) ≤ K Str ≤ A L. (4.17) m − SR N
where γ =
In the case m = 0, we derive from (4.10) and (4.17) that, for sufficiently large N , ∞ k(x, x) dx Tk (N ) ≤ TkL (N ) + L α ∞ L ≤A L+ k(x, x) dx. (4.18) N L Similarly, if m ≥ 1, we derive from (4.11), (4.12) and (4.17), for sufficiently large N, 2m+α ∞ L L+ k(x, x) dx. (4.19) Tk (2N + 1) ≤ A C N L
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
33
To use the hypothesis on the decay rate of k(x, x) at infinity we suppose, as in the ∞ previous case, that there exist β > 1, B > 0 and x0 > 0 such that L k(x, x) dx ≤ B/Lβ−1 whenever L ≥ x0 . We recall Lemma 4.2 taking q = 2m + α, δ = ∞, and A replaced with A C in the case m > 1. As in the proof of 1.1 i), define a sequence of finite rank operators SRN,LS taking L ≡ L(N ) = N θ , where in this 2m+α case θ = 2m+α+β . According to Lemma 4.2 we then derive from (4.18) and (4.19) that, for sufficiently large N , Tk (N ) ≤
A+B if m = 0 N γ−1
and Tk (2N + 1) ≤
AC + B if m ≥ 1, N γ−1
(2m + α + 1)β for m ≥ 0. These conditions together imply λn = 2m + α + β γ O(1/n ), completing the proof of statement 1.2 i). To prove statements 2.1. i) and 2.2 i) we start by rewriting the integrand in (4.14) in a more convenient way. Suppose km is continuously differentiable with respect to x in [0, +∞[2 . We set where γ =
L L L L g(u, v) = km (u, u) − km (u, v) − km (v, u) + km (v, v).
(4.20)
L L (t, v) − km (t, u). Notice that ϕ is in C 1 ([0, L]) For u, v, t ∈ [0, L] define ϕ(t) = km and that g(u, v) = ϕ(v) − ϕ(u). Hence there exists t0 between u and v such that
g(u, v) = ϕ (t0 )(v − u) L ∂km ∂k L (t0 , v) − m (t0 , u) (v − u) = ∂x ∂x L L ∂km ∂km ∂k L ∂k L (t0 , v) − m (t0 , t0 ) (v − u) + (t0 , t0 ) − m (t0 , u) (v − u) = ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x (4.21) ∂km We now prove statement 2.1 i). Suppose is uniformly continuous with ∂x respect to y on the diagonal. Then, for every > 0 there exists δ > 0, independent of L, such that
L
L
∂km
∂km
∂x (t0 , v) − ∂x (t0 , t0 ) < for all t0 , v ∈ [0, L] satisfying |v − t0 | < δ. Then, for every positive L and every N ∈ N such that L/N < δ, we derive from (4.21) that if |v − u| < L/N we have g(u, v) ≤ 2 L/N , whence from (4.14) L (N ) ≤ Tkm
L2 . N
(4.22)
34
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
Therefore, it follows from (4.10), (4.11) and (4.22) that ∞ k(x, x) dx Tk (N ) ≤ TkL (N ) + L ∞ L2 k(x, x) dx, ≤ + N L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C ≤ C
L N
L N
2m
T
2m+1
L km
∞
(N ) +
k(x, x) dx L
∞
L+
(4.23)
(4.24)
k(x, x) dx L
for some C > 0, N sufficiently large and m ≥ 1. Using the hypothesis on the decay rate of k(x, x) we now proceed as in the proof i). Suppose there exist β > 1, B > 0, x0 > 0 such that ∞ of statement 1.1 β−1 k(x, x) dx ≤ B/L whenever L ≥ x0 . Recall Lemma 4.2 with q = 2m + 1, L A = if m = 0, A = C if m ≥ 1. Define a sequence of finite rank operators 2m+1 . According to Lemma 4.2 SRN,LS by setting L = L(N ) = N θ , where θ = 2m+1+β we then derive from (4.23) and (4.24) that, for sufficiently large N , Tk (N ) ≤
+B D1 = γ−1 if m = 0 N γ−1 N
and Tk (2N + 1) ≤
C +B D2 = γ−1 if m ≥ 1 γ−1 N N
(2m + 2)β . 2m + 1 + β ∞ Finally observe that if L k(x, x) dx = O(1/Lβ−1 ) as L → +∞, the above conditions are satisfied for fixed D1 and D2 , which implies λn = O(1/nγ ). If ∞ β−1 ) as L → +∞, the same conditions hold for arbitrary L k(x, x) dx = o(1/L D1 and D2 , implying λn = o(1/nγ ). This finishes the proof of statement 2.1 i). ∂km is continuous We now focus on the proof of statement 2.2 i). Suppose ∂x α 2 on [0, +∞[ and Lip with respect to y on the diagonal, α ∈ ]0, 1]. Choose L ∈ R+ L L and N ∈ N. Then |u − v| < L/N for all u, v in [(n − 1) N , nN ], n = 1, . . . , N . Since ∂km α is Lip with respect to y on the diagonal we derive from (4.20) and (4.21) ∂x that 1+α L g(u, v) ≤ A N where γ =
and, from (4.14),
Tkm L (N ) ≤ A
L N
1+α L.
(4.25)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
35
Therefore, according to (4.10), (4.12) and (4.25) we have ∞ k(x, x) dx Tk (N ) ≤ TkL (N ) + ≤A
L N
Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C ≤A
L N
1+α
L N
L
∞
L+
k(x, x) dx,
(4.26)
L
2m
Tkm L (N ) +
2m+α+1
∞
k(x, x) dx L
∞
L+
(4.27)
k(x, x) dx. L
We proceed as in the proof of the previous statements. Using the hipothesis on the decay rate of k(x, x) at infinity and taking q = 2m + α + 1 and replacing A by A C if m ≥ 1, δ = ∞ in Lemma 4.2, we define the sequence of finite rank 2m+1+α operators SRN,LS by setting L = L(N ) = N θ , where θ = 2m+1+α+β . Then, from Lemma 4.2, (4.26) and (4.27), it follows that for sufficiently large N Tk (N ) ≤
A+B if m = 0 N γ−1
and Tk (2N + 1) ≤
AC + B = if m ≥ 1 N γ−1
(2m + 1 + α)β . Both conditions imply λn = O(1/nγ ), completing the 2m + 1 + α + β proof of statement 2.2 i). We now prove statements 1.1 ii), 1.2 ii), 2.1 ii) and 2.2 ii). Notice that the ∞ hypothesis on the decay rate of k(x, x), namely L k(x, x) dx = O(1/Lβ−1 ) as L → +∞ for all β > 1, is common to these four statements. We concentrate on the proof of 1.1 ii), which is based on the contents of statement 1.1 i). Suppose km ∞ is uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal and that L k(x, x) dx = O(1/Lβ−1 ) as L → +∞ for all β > 1. Then, according to 1.1 i), λn = O(1/nγ ) for all γ < 2m+1. This fact actually implies the stronger statement that λn = o(1/nγ ) for every γ < 2m + 1. In fact, if there were γ0 < 2m + 1 such that nγ0 λn → C for some C > 0, then λn would not be O(1/nγ ) for γ0 < γ < 2m+ 1, contradicting the previous result. Thus under this hypothesis λn = o(1/nγ ) for every γ < 2m + 1, proving statement 1.1. ii). The proofs of statements 1.2 ii), 2.1 ii) and 2.2 ii) are derived in the exact same way respectively from 1.2 i), 2.1 i) and 2.2 i), so details are omitted. Finally, we prove statements 1.1 iii), 1.2 iii), 2.1 iii) and 2.2 iii). Notice that the hypothesis that k(x, x) has compact support is common to these four statements. We concentrate on the proof of 1.1 iii). For m = 0 we have γ = 1 and the common assertion reduces to the already known fact that for a positive definite kernel k in A0 ([0, +∞[), λn (k) = o(1/n). Let then m ≥ 1. Choose L > 0 such that where γ =
36
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
+∞ supp k(x, x) ⊂ [0, L]; with this choice we obviously have L k(x, x) dx = 0. Fix L and proceed as in the proof of 1.1 i), considering (4.11), (4.12), (4.13), (4.15), (4.16). From this last equation we derive in this case that 2m L L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C N for sufficiently large N . Since L and C are fixed and > 0 is arbitrary, this implies Tk (2N + 1) = o(1/N 2m ) as N → +∞. For m ≥ 0 it then follows that λn = o(1/n2m+1 ), as asserted. To prove 1.2 iii) we fix L as above and proceed as in the proof of 1.2 i), writing (4.10), (4.11), (4.12), (4.13), (4.17), (4.18) and (4.19). From the last two equations we derive in this case that α L Tk (N ) ≤ A L, N 2m+α L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ A C L N for N sufficiently large and m ≥ 1. Since A, C and L are fixed, it follows that λn = O(1/n2m+α+1 ) for m ≥ 0, as asserted. The proof of 2.1. iii) follows along the same lines. We fix L as above and proceed as in the proof of 2.1 i), considering (4.10), (4.11), (4.12),(4.14), (4.20), (4.21), (4.22), (4.23) and (4.24). The last two equations yield in this case L2 , N 2m+1 L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ C L N Tk (N )
≤
for N sufficiently large and m ≥ 1. Since C and L are fixed and is arbitrary this implies that λn = o(1/n2m+α+1 ), for m ≥ 0, as asserted. Finally, to prove 2.2.iii) we fix L as above and proceed as in the proof of 2.2.i), writing (4.10), (4.11), (4.12),(4.14), (4.20), (4.21), (4.25), (4.26) and (4.27). The last two equations yield 1+α L Tk (N ) ≤ A L, N 2m+α+1 L Tk (2N + 1) ≤ A C L N for N sufficiently large and m ≥ 1. Since A, C and L are fixed, it follows that λn = O(1/n2m+α+2 ) for m ≥ 0, as asserted. This finishes the proof. Corollary 4.11. Suppose k(x, y) is a positive definite kernel in A0 ([0, +∞[). Suppose furthermore that k is of class C∞ ([0, ∞[2 ) and that km is uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal for every m ∈ N. Let {λn }n∈N be
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
37
the of the integral operator with kernel k. If β > 1 and ∞ sequence of eigenvalues β−1 k(x, x) dx = O(1/L ) as L → +∞, then λn = o (1/nγ ) for all γ < β. L Proof. According to statement 1.1 i) of Theorem 4.10, λn = o (1/nγ ) for every γ (2m + 1)β (2m + 1)β with m ≥ 0. Since, for fixed β, lim = β, of the form γ = m→∞ 2m + β 2m + β an argument similar to the one used in the proof of statement 1.1 ii) implies that λn = o (1/nγ ) for all γ < β. Remark 4.12. Observe that Corollary 4.11 cannot be since its assertion improved, is not true for γ = β even in the weaker form λn = O 1/nβ , as the counterexample λn = log n/nγ shows. A similar observation can be applied to statements 1.1 ii), 1.2 ii), 2.1 ii) and 2.2 ii) of Theorem 4.10. Remark 4.13. As a consequence of Remark 4.8 it is immediate to recognize that the assertion of Corollary 4.11 is valid, in particular, for positive definite kernels lying in class Am for all m ≥ 0. Corollary 4.14. Let k(x, y) be a positive definite kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[). Suppose k is of class C p in [0, +∞[2 and that the partial derivatives up to order p are uniformly continuous with respect to y on the diagonal, and let {λn }n∈N be the of the integral operator with kernel k. If β > 1 and ∞ sequence of eigenvalues ∞ β−1 k(x, x) dx = O(1/L ) (resp. k(x, x) dx = o(1/Lβ−1 )) as L → +∞, then L L (p + 1)β . λn = O (1/nγ ) (resp. λn = o (1/nγ ) ) for γ = p+β Proof. For p even (resp. p odd) the hypotheses are easily seen to imply those of statement 1.1 i) (resp. 1.2.i)) of Theorem 4.10. Setting p = 2m (resp. p = 2m + 1) yields the result. Corollary 4.15. Let k(x, y) be a positive definite kernel in class A0 ([0, +∞[). Suppose k is of class C p in [0, +∞[2 and that the partial derivatives up to order p are satisfy an α-Lipschitz condition with respect to y on the diagonal and let {λn }n∈N be the sequence of eigenvalues of the integral operator with kernel k. If ∞ β > 1 and L k(x, x) dx = O(1/Lβ−1 ) as L → +∞, then λn = O (1/nγ ) for (p + 1 + α)β . γ= p+α+β Proof. For p even (resp. p odd) the hypotheses are easily seen to imply those of statements 2.1 i) and 2.2 i) in Theorem 4.10. Setting p = 2m (resp. p = 2m + 1) yields the result. Remark 4.16. A few interesting observations can be made from the study of limiting cases in the formulas for the exponent γ given by Theorem 4.10. Suppose m and α are fixed and consider the parameter β which controls the rate of decay of the kernel k along the diagonal for 1 < β < +∞. If β → +∞, the limiting values obtained for γ from formulas in items i) of statements 1.1, 1.2, 2.1 and 2.2 of Theorem 4.10 coincide with the exponent
38
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
IEOT
determining the bound for the decay rate of eigenvalues given in items ii) and iii) of the corresponding statements. These values ultimately reflect the fact that, in the case of kernels decaying rapidly on the diagonal and, in particular, in the case of kernels with compact support, the regularity assumed for k determines the upper bound for the decay rate exponent of eigenvalues. The limiting case m → +∞ is the subject of corollary 4.11 and is, in a way, symmetric to the case above. It shows that operators with indefinitely differentiable kernels have eigenvalue distributions whose decay rate exponent bound is determined by the decay rate exponent of k along the diagonal. For fixed m and β we finally observe that, in consonance with the interpretation of α as an index of intermediate differentiability, the limiting cases α = 0 and α = 1 in statements 1.2 and 2.2 produce the corresponding expected upper bounds for the decay rate exponent γ given by statements 1.1 and 2.1. Remark 4.17. Some observations are relevant to the discussion of the hypothesis of Theorem 4.10. We first note that, as indeed in the definition of class A0 , the essential requirements on the behavior of k in the hypothesis of Theorem 4.10 may be restricted to the diagonal with no consequence on the proofs, a fact which is not apparent in the previous literature. Secondly, observe that, in view of Remark 4.9 and conjugate symmetry of kernel k(x, y), the hypothesis on uniform and Lipschitz continuity with respect to y on the diagonal assumed for partial derivatives of k could have been replaced with similar hypothesis with respect to x on the diagonal for conveniently chosen partial derivatives of k. Stronger conditions not specifying the variable x or y can naturally be imposed but with no advantage to the proofs. Finally we note that uniform continuity requirements, which trivially derive from the Sn condition in the compact domain case, must be explicitly imposed in the case of unbounded domains. Remark 4.18. Clearly, the last assertions (items iii)) of statements 1.1, 1.2, 2.1 and 2.2 in Theorem 4.10 bear a direct connection to the formally identical results known for positive trace class operators defined on a compact interval, namely those which apply to C p or C p+α kernels described in § 1. In fact, if transcribed to the case of kernels defined on compact domains, these assertions require somewhat weaker (yet sufficient) versions of the above referred conditions (see Remark 4.17). The first part of the proof of Lemma 4.1 clarifies this connection by establishing the equivalence of the study of eigenvalues of the operator with compactly supported kernel k defined on [0, ∞[2 and the operator whose kernel is the restriction of k to a square [0, L]2 containing the support of k. The fact that the steps taken in our proofs of the referred assertions collapse into (a combination of) the proofs in [16], [8] and [7] can be seen as a consequence of this equivalence. On the other hand, the same authors show that the results obtained in this case are optimal. This is done by explicitly constructing kernels verifying the required assumptions of differentiability and Lipschitz continuity whose eigenvalues
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
39
attain the bounds for decay rate established by the theorems. The results in Theorem 4.10 are thus known to be optimal in the limit cases corresponding to compactly supported kernels. These facts and the contents of Proposition 4.3 strongly suggest that the remaining statements in Theorem 4.10 are also optimal. Remark 4.19. Our results are stated and proved for the unbounded interval I = [0, +∞[ for convenience only. They are valid, with the obvious rephrasing, for L2 (I) integral operators K and respective positive definite kernels k(x, y) for the other types of unbounded intervals in R. Of particular significance (see below) is the case where I = R. In this case we are dealing with L2 (R) positive definite kernels; class A0 (R) kernels are continuous in R2 , with k(x, x) ∈ L1 (R) and k(x, x) → 0 as |x| → +∞. All the results and proofs carry through simply by replacing the required asymptotic behavior of k(x, x) as x → +∞ by the corresponding requirement as |x| → +∞. There is a close connection between positive definiteness of a continuous ˆ 1 , ν2 ). More specifically, L2 (R) kernel k(x, y) and that of its Fourier transform k(ν it is possible to show that if k is in class A0 (R) as defined in Remark 4.19, then its ˜ 1 , ν2 ) = k(ν ˆ 1 , −ν2 ) is a positive definite kernel with “rotated” Fourier transform k(ν the same eigenvalues λn as k and whose associated eigenfunctions are the Fourier transforms of the corresponding eigenfunctions of k. Moreover, if k 1/2 (x, x) ∈ ˜ with kernel k˜ is trace class with the L1 (R) then the L2 (R) integral operator K same trace as K; see [3] for details. If k is in class A0 (R), a sufficient condition for k 1/2 (x, x) ∈ L1 (R) may be formulated in terms of the asymptotic behavior of k(x, x) as k(x, x) = O(1/xβ ) for some β > 2. The following result is an immediate consequence of Corollaries 4.14 and 4.15 and Remark 4.4. Corollary 4.20. Suppose k(x, y) is a positive definite kernel in class A0 (R) with k(x, x) = O(1/xβ ) as |x| → +∞ for some β > 1 and let {λn }n∈N be the sequence of eigenvalues of the integral operator with kernel k with associated eigenfunctions ˆ 1 , ν2 ) be the double Fourier transform of k(x, y), k(ν ˜ 1 , ν2 ) = k(ν ˆ 1 , −ν2 ) φn . Let k(ν and φˆn be the Fourier transform of φn . Then the following statements hold. (i) k˜ is a positive definite kernel with L2 (R) eigenfunction expansion ˜ 1 , ν2 ) = k(ν λn φˆn (ν1 ) φˆn (ν2 ). (4.28) n≥1
(ii) If k is of class C p (R) and the partial derivatives up to order p are uniformly (p + 1)β . continuous on the diagonal, then λn = O(1/nγ ), where γ = p+β p (iii) If k is of class C (R) and the partial derivatives up to order p satisfy an α(p+1+α)β . Lipschitz condition on the diagonal, then λn = O(1/nγ ) with γ = p+α+β If β > 2 we have, in addition, that k˜ is in class A0 (R), the series (4.28) is abso˜ : L2 (R) → L2 (R) with kernel lutely and uniformly convergent and the operator K
40
Buescu and Paix˜ ao
k˜ is trace class with ˜ = tr K = tr K
+∞
+∞
k(x, x) dx = −∞
−∞
IEOT
˜ ν) dν = k(ν,
λn .
n≥1
Proof. The hypothesis imply that k is a Mercer-like kernel. Then statements i), ii) and iii) follow, in view of remark 4.4, from corollaries 4.14 and 4.15 and propositions 4.1 and 4.2 in [3]. The hypothesis that k(x, x) = O(1/|x|β ) for some β > 2 implies, in addition, that k 1/2 (x, x) ∈ L1 (R), from which the last statement derives by direct application of theorem 4.4 in [3]. Remark 4.21. It is clearly seen that all conclusions in corollary 4.20 still hold if the hypothesis that k : R2 → C be a continuous positive definite kernel satisfying k(x, x) = O(1/|x|β ) as |x| → +∞ for some β > 1 is replaced with the assumption ∞ that k is a Mercer-like kernel defined on R2 satisfying L k(x, x) dx = O 1/Lβ−1 for some β > 1 and if condition β > 2 is replaced with the hypothesis that k 1/2 (x, x) ∈ L1 (R) or, more generally, that k(x, y) ∈ L1 (R2 ). Once again the version presented, although somewhat weaker, underlines how the behavior of the kernel on the diagonal controls events.
References [1] M. Birman, M. Solomyak, Estimates of singular numbers of integral operators. Russ. Math. Surv. 32 (1977), 15-89. [2] J. Buescu, Positive integral operators in unbounded domains. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 296 (2004), 244–255. [3] J. Buescu, F. Garcia, I. Lourtie, A. Paix˜ ao, Positive definiteness, integral equations and Fourier transforms. Jour. Int. Eq. Appl. 16, 1 (2004), 33–52. [4] J. Buescu, F. Garcia, I. Lourtie, L2 (R) nonstationary processes and the sampling theorem. IEEE Sign. Proc. Lett. 8, 4 (2001), 117–119. [5] J. Buescu, A. Paix˜ ao, Positive definite matrices and differentiable reproducing kernel inequalities. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 320 (2006), 279-292. [6] J. Buescu, A. Paix˜ ao, Eigenvalues of positive definite integral operators in unbounded intervals. Positivity, to appear. [7] C. Chang, C. Ha, On eigenvalues of differentiable positive definite kernels. Integr. Equ. Oper. Theory 33 (1999), 1–7. [8] J. Cochran, M. Lukas, Differentiable positive definite kernels and Lipschitz continuity. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 104 (1988), 361–369. [9] I. Gohberg, M. Krein, Introduction to the theory of linear nonselfadjoint operators in Hilbert space. A.M.S., Providence, 1969. [10] C. Ha, Eigenvalues of differentiable positive definite kernels. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 17 (1986), 2, 415–419. [11] T. Kadota, Term-by-term differentiability of Mercer’s expansion. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 18 (1967), 69–72.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Eigenvalues of PDKs on Unbounded Domains
41
[12] H. Konig, Eigenvalue distribution of compact operators. Operator Theory: Advances and Applications, vol. 16. Birkhuser, Basel, 1986. [13] I. M. Novitskii, Representation of kernels of integral operators by bilinear series. Siberian Math. J. 25 (1984), 3, 774–778. Translated form the Russian: Sibirsk. Mat. Zh. 25 (1984), 5, 114–118. [14] A. Pietsch, Zur Fredholmschen Theorie in lokalconvexen R¨ aumen. Stud. Math. 28 (1966/67), 161–179. [15] A. Pietsch, Eigenvalues of integral operators II. Math. Ann. 262 (1983), 343–376. [16] J. Reade, Eigenvalues of positive definite kernels. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 14 (1983), 1, 152–157. [17] J. Reade, Eigenvalues of Lipschitz kernels. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 93 (1983), 1, 135–140. [18] J. Reade, Eigenvalues of positive definite kernels II. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 15 (1984), 1, 137–142. [19] J. Reade, Positive definite C p kernels. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 17 (1986), 2, 420–421. [20] J. Reade, Eigenvalues of smooth positive definite kernels. Proc. Edimburgh Math. Soc. 35 (1990), 41–45. [21] M. Reed, B. Simon, Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics. I: Functional Analysis (revised and enlarged edition). Academic Press, San Diego, 1980. [22] F. Riesz, B. Nagy, Functional Analysis. Ungar, New York, 1952. [23] H. Weyl, Das Asymptotische Verteilunggesetz der Eigenwerte linearer partieller Differentialgleichungen. Math. Ann. 71 (1912), 2, 441–479. Jorge Buescu Departamento de Matem´ atica Instituto Superior T´ecnico Av. Rovisco Pais 1049-001 Lisbon Portugal e-mail:
[email protected] A. C. Paix˜ ao Departamento de Mecˆ anica Instituto Superior de Engenharia de Lisboa (ISEL) Lisbon Portugal e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: July 20, 2005
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 43–66 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010043-24, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1444-2
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators with n-Harmonic Symbols Boo Rim Choe, Hyungwoon Koo and Young Joo Lee Abstract. On the Bergman space of the unit polydisk in the complex n-space, we solve the zero-product problem for two Toeplitz operators with n-harmonic symbols that have local continuous extension property up to the distinguished boundary. In the case where symbols have additional Lipschitz continuity up to the whole distinguished boundary, we solve the zero-product problem for products with four factors. We also prove a local version of this result for products with three factors. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35; Secondary 32A36. Keywords. Zero product, Toeplitz operator, n-harmonic symbol, Bergman space, polydisk.
1. Introduction Let D be the unit disk in the complex plane. For a fixed positive integer n, the unit polydisk Dn is the cartesian product of n copies of D. Let L2 = L2 (Dn , V ) denote the usual Lebesgue space where V = Vn is the volume measure on Dn normalized to have total mass 1. We let A2 = A2 (Dn ) denote the Bergman space consisting of all holomorphic functions in L2 . Due to the mean value property of holomorphic functions, the Bergman space A2 is a closed subspace of L2 , and thus is a Hilbert space. Since every point evaluation is a bounded linear functional on A2 , there corresponds to every a ∈ Dn a unique function Ka ∈ A2 which has the following reproducing property: f (a) = f (z)Ka (z) dV (z) (1.1) Dn
This research was supported by KOSEF(R01-2003-000-10243-0).
44
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
for f ∈ A2 . The function Ka is the well-known Bergman kernel and its explicit formula is given by Ka (z) =
n j=1
1 , (1 − aj zj )2
z ∈ Dn ;
see, for example, Proposition 1.4.24 of [13]. Here, and elsewhere, zj denotes the j-th component of z. It follows from (1.1) that the Hilbert space orthogonal projection P from L2 onto A2 , called the Bergman projection, is realized as an integral operator ψ(z)Ka (z) dV (z) P ψ(a) = Dn
for ψ ∈ L . For a function u ∈ L∞ , the Toeplitz operator Tu with symbol u is defined by 2
Tu f = P (uf ) for f ∈ A . It is clear that Tu : A → A2 is a bounded linear operator. In this paper we study the zero-product problem of whether the zero-product of several Toeplitz operators has only the trivial solution. More explicitly, the problem we consider is 2
2
Does Tu1 · · · TuN = 0 imply that some uj is identically zero? This problem was first studied for Toeplitz operators on the Hardy space. In [5], Brown and Halmos actually studied a more general problem on the Hardy space of the unit disk and proved that Tu Tv = Tϕ if and only if either u¯ or v is holomorphic and ϕ = uv. As an immediate consequence of their result, they easily derived that the zero-product problem with two factors has only the trivial solution. Later, on the same context of Hardy space of the unit disk, the zeroproduct problem has been solved by Guo [12] for products with five factors and by Gu [11] for products with six factors. Recently, Ding [10] solved this problem for products with two factors on the Hardy space of the polydisk. There has been no progress on higher dimensional balls, as far as we know. For the Bergman space case, the study of the zero-product problem has begun only recently. On the setting of the Bergman space of the unit disk, Ahern ˘ ckovi´c [2] solved the zero-product problem for two factors with harmonic and Cu˘ symbols. More recently, Ahern [1] gave another more general approach to solve the same problem. Recall that bounded measurable functions on the unit circle can be identified with boundary values of bounded harmonic functions on the unit disk. So, it seems quite natural (to us) to work with harmonic symbols as in [2] as substitutes for general symbols in the Hardy space case. However, the work in [2] shows that the Bergman space case, even with such harmonic symbols, is much more subtle than the Hardy space case. Nevertheless, there have been a couple ˘ ckovi´c [9] obtained some of progresses for symbols other than harmonic ones. Cu˘ ˘ ckovi´c [3] partial results when only one symbol is harmonic. Also, Ahern and Cu˘
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
45
solved the zero-product problem for two factors with radial symbols. Of course, the zero-product problem with general symbols, even for two factors, remains still very far from its solution. The higher dimensional cases have been also studied on the ball and polydisk. Recently, the polydisk case was solved by Choe et al. [8] for two factors with pluriharmonic symbols by extending the method in [2]. More recently, on the setting of the unit ball, the first two authors of the present paper [7] used an entirely different method to solve the zero-product problem for two factors with harmonic symbols that have local continuous extension property up to the boundary. At the same paper, they also solved the problem for multiple products with number of factors depending on the dimension in the case where symbols have additional (global or local) Lipschitz continuity up to the boundary. In this paper, we study the same problem on the polydisk. Going from the ball to the polydisk, we need to adjust our setting suitable for the polydisk. According to our results below, it turns out that n-harmonic symbols on the polydisk are the right substitutes for harmonic symbols on the ball and the distinguished boundary of the polydisk is the right substitute for the boundary of the ball. Recall that a function u ∈ C 2 (Dn ) is called n-harmonic as in [14] if u is harmonic in each variable separately. More explicitly, u is n-harmonic if ∂j ∂ j u = 0,
j = 1, 2, . . . , n
where ∂j = ∂/∂zj denotes the complex differentiation with respect to zj . Also, recall that the distinguished boundary of Dn is T n , the cartesian product of n copies of the unit circle T = ∂D. First, we consider n-harmonic symbols with local continuous extension property up to the distinguished boundary T n and solve the zero-product problem for two factors. In what follows, we let h∞ denote the class of all bounded n-harmonic functions on Dn . Also, a “boundary open” set refers to a relatively open subset of T n . The following is our first result. In case of the disk, this result coincides with ˘ ckovi´c Theorem 1.1 of [7], which in turn is contained in the work of Ahern and Cu˘ [2] mentioned above. Theorem 1.1. Suppose that u1 , u2 ∈ h∞ are continuous on Dn ∪ W for some boundary open set W . If Tu1 Tu2 = 0, then u1 = 0 or u2 = 0. Next, we consider the case where symbols have additional Lipschitz continuity up to the whole or some part of the distinguished boundary. Such extra Lipschitz continuity enables us to extend our method to products with three or four factors. Given a subset X ⊂ Cn , recall that the Lipschitz class of order ∈ (0, 1], denoted by Lip (X), is the class of all functions f on X such that |f (z)−f (w)| = O(|z−w| ) for z, w ∈ X. Our second result solves the zero-product problem with four factors when symbols are n-harmonic and have global Lipschitz continuity up to the distinn = Dn ∪ T n . guished boundary. We let D
46
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
n ) ∩ h∞ for some > 0 and for some Theorem 1.2. Let u1 , u2 , u3 , u4 ∈ Lip (U ∩ D n open set U containing T . If Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 Tu4 = 0, then uj = 0 for some j. For n-harmonic symbols that have only local Lipschitz continuity up to the distinguished boundary, we can also apply the proof of Theorem 1.2 to solve the zero-product problem, but with only three factors. n ) ∩ h∞ for some > 0 and for some Theorem 1.3. Let u1 , u2 , u3 ∈ Lip (U ∩ D n open set U with U ∩ T = ∅. If Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 = 0, then uj = 0 for some j. While the main idea of our method of proofs is adapted from [7], substantial amount of unexpected analysis is required to overcome some different nature of the polydisks being product domains. For example, a uniqueness theorem (Proposition 2.2) and an example that follows reveal more involved nature of the polydisks compared with the balls. The whole part of later arguments is thus necessarily effected in a more complicated direction by such an unexpected uniqueness result. Boundary continuity and n-harmonicity hypotheses in the theorems above play key roles in our arguments of the present paper. First, boundary continuity ensures (Proposition 2.1) that the Berezin transform of products of Toeplitz operators under consideration recovers the products of corresponding symbols at every distinguished boundary point where the symbols have continuous extensions. Also, both hypotheses allow us to use a uniqueness theorem (Proposition 2.2) for n-harmonic functions, which can be viewed as a product version of the local Hopf lemma obtained in [6]. In addition, it provides us quite explicit information on local behavior of symbol functions near a distinguished boundary vanishing point (Lemma 3.1). We do not know whether either boundary regularity or n-harmonicity can be removed in the hypotheses of our theorems above when n ≥ 2. We do not know whether the number of factors are best possible under the given hypotheses, either. In Section 2, we collect a couple of key facts which play the role of the starting point of our proofs. In Section 3, we prove Theorems 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3.
2. Preliminaries In this section we prove two main ingredients of our arguments which might be of independent interests. One is a certain continuous extension property of the Berezin transform and the other is a uniqueness theorem for n-harmonic functions. These two propositions are what led us to require boundary regularity and nharmonicity hypotheses in our theorems. Let a ∈ Dn denote an arbitrary point, unless otherwise specified. Recall that the well-known Berezin transform of a bounded linear operator L on A2 is a on Dn defined by function L L(a) = Lka (z)ka (z) dV (z) Dn
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
where ka is the normalized kernel, namely, n 1 − |aj |2 , ka (z) = (1 − aj zj )2 j=1
47
z ∈ Dn .
is continuous on Dn . In our application L will be It is not hard to see that L the products of Toeplitz operators as in the hypotheses of theorems stated in the Introduction. Such operators L have additional properties useful for our purpose: has the same amount of boundary continuity as symbols and the boundary value L is precisely the product of symbols. In order to prove this, we first recall some of L well-known facts. obius We let ϕa (z) = φa1 (z1 ), . . . , φan (zn ) where each φaj is the usual M¨ map on D given by aj − z j , zj ∈ D. φaj (zj ) = 1 − aj z j The map ϕa is an automorphism on Dn such that ϕa ◦ ϕa = id. We define a linear operator Ua on A2 by Ua f = (f ◦ ϕa )ka n for f ∈ A2 . Since the real Jacobian of ϕa (z) is j=1 |φaj (zj )|2 = |ka (z)|2 , we see that each Ua is an isometry on A2 . Also, since Ua ka = (ka ◦ ϕa )ka = 1, we have Ua Ua = I and thus Ua−1 = Ua . Now, being an invertible linear isometry, Ua is unitary. Also, we have Ua Tu Ua = Tu◦ϕa ; (2.1) this is well known on the disk (see, for example, [4]) and the same proof works on the polydisk. Proposition 2.1. Suppose that functions u1 , . . . , uN ∈ h∞ are continuous on Dn ∪ continuously extends to Dn ∪{ζ} {ζ} for some ζ ∈ T n . Let L = TuN · · · Tu1 . Then L and L(ζ) = (u1 · · · uN )(ζ). The proof below is similar to that of the ball case (Proposition 2.1 of [7]) and is included here for reader’s convenience. Proof. Let a ∈ Dn . Note that ka = Ua 1. Also, by (2.1), we note that Ua LUa = (Ua TuN Ua ) · · · (Ua Tu1 Ua ) = TuN ◦ϕa · · · Tu1 ◦ϕa , because Ua Ua = I. Since Ua∗ = Ua−1 = Ua , it follows that L(a) = Ua LUa 1, 1 = TuN ◦ϕa · · · Tu1 ◦ϕa 1, 1
(2.2)
where , denotes the inner product on L2 . We claim that, as a → ζ, we have TuN ◦ϕa · · · Tu1 ◦ϕa 1 → (uN · · · u1 )(ζ)
in L2
(2.3)
which, together with (2.2), implies the proposition. Now, we prove the claim. Let a → ζ. Then, for a given function u continuous on Dn ∪ {ζ}, we observe that ϕa → ζ pointwise (in fact, uniformly on compact sets) and thus u ◦ ϕa → u(ζ) in L2 by the dominated convergence theorem. In
48
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
particular, we have P (u ◦ ϕa ) → u(ζ) in L2 . So, we see that the claim holds for N = 1. We now proceed by induction on N . Assume that (2.3) holds for some N ≥ 1 and consider the case of N + 1. Having (2.3) as induction hypothesis and denoting the Lp -norm by p , we have TuN +1◦ϕa TuN ◦ϕa · · · Tu1 ◦ϕa 1 − (uN +1 uN · · · u1 )(ζ) 2 ≤ TuN +1◦ϕa [TuN ◦ϕa · · · Tu1 ◦ϕa 1 − (uN · · · u1 )(ζ)] 2 + |(uN · · · u1 )(ζ)| TuN +1 ◦ϕa 1 − uN +1 (ζ) 2 ≤ uN +1 ∞ TuN ◦ϕa · · · Tu1 ◦ϕa 1 − (uN · · · u1 )(ζ)] 2 + |(uN · · · u1 )(ζ)| TuN +1 ◦ϕa 1 − uN +1 (ζ) 2 → 0 so that (2.3) also holds for N + 1. This completes the induction and the proof of the proposition. Now, we turn to a uniqueness property of bounded n-harmonic functions. We first recall a certain extension property of bounded n-harmonic functions across the boundary. So, let u ∈ h∞ be an arbitrary function. As is well known, the radial limit u∗ (ζ) = limr→1 u(rζ) exists at almost all points ζ ∈ T n and u is recovered by the Poisson integral of u∗ : n 1 − |zj |2 u(z) = u∗ (ζ) dσ(ζ), z ∈ Dn 2 n |1 − z ζ | T j j j=1 where dσ is the Haar measure on T n . See [14, p. 31] for details. Thus, if u is in addition continuous on Dn ∪ W and vanishes on W for some boundary open set W , then it is easily seen from the Poisson integral formula above that u extends n-harmonically across W . We also need various notation. Working with n-harmonic functions, it seems quite natural and necessary to consider relevant differential operators componentwise. Recall ∂j = ∂/∂zj . Now, given j = 1, . . . , n, we let Rj = zj ∂j + z j ∂ j √ Tj = −1(zj ∂j − z j ∂ j ) ∆j = 4∂j ∂ j denote the j-th radial differential operator, the j-th real tangential differential operator and the j-th Laplacian, respectively. Here, and elsewhere, we abuse the notation zj for the function z → zj . Then it is straightforward to see that Rj Ti = Ti Rj , R2j
+
Tj2
Rj Ri = Ri Rj
= |zj | ∆j 2
∆j Ri = (2δij + Ri )∆j
(2.4) (2.5)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
49
for each i, j (of course, when applied to sufficiently smooth functions) where δij is the Kronecker delta. Note that each Rj preserves n-harmonicity by (2.5). We also remark that each Rj has the invariance property Rj (u ◦ L) = (Rj u) ◦ L
(2.6)
for real linear transformations L on Cn of the form L(z) = (L1 (z1 ), . . . , Ln (zn )) where each Li is a real linear transformation on C. In our argument below it seems more convenient to use real notation for differential operators. So, we let √ Dxj = ∂j + ∂ j , Dyj = −1(∂j − ∂ j ) for j = 1, . . . , n. In terms of these real differential operators, note that Rj = zj Dxj + zj Dyj ,
Tj = zj Dyj − zj Dxj
for each j. Here, a and a denote the real and imaginary part of a ∈ C, respectively. By a multi-index we mean an n-tuple α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) of nonnegative integers. We use conventional multi-index notation. Given a multi-index α, we let |α| = α1 + · · · + αn and α! = α1 ! · · · αn !. Also, X α = X1α1 · · · Xnαn for X = (X1 , . . . , Xn ). We let Dx = (Dx1 , . . . , Dxn ), Dy = (Dy1 , . . . , Dyn ) and R = (R1 , . . . , Rn ), T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) for the purpose of multi-index notation. By a componentwise rotation ρ on Cn , we mean that ρ is a rotation of the form ρ(z) = (ζ1 z1 , . . . , ζn zn ), ζ ∈ T n . Note that each Rj is componentwise rotationinvariant by (2.6). The same invariance property for each Tj is also easily verified. As a consequence, we have componentwise rotation-invariance property for general mixed differential operators: Rα T β (u ◦ ρ) = (Rα T β u) ◦ ρ
(2.7)
for componentwise rotations ρ and multi-indices α, β. This property will be useful in normalizing our argument later. Finally, we use the notation Λ for the set of all multi-indices α such that each component of α is 0 or 1 and put e = (1, 1, . . . , 1) ∈ T n for simplicity. Proposition 2.2. Suppose that u ∈ h∞ is continuous on Dn ∪W for some boundary open set W . If both u and Rα u vanish on W for all α ∈ Λ, then u = 0 on Dn . Proof. Since u = 0 on W , u extends to an n-harmonic function across W , as mentioned above. We claim Rα u = 0 on W
(2.8)
50
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
for all multi-indices α. In order to see this, we introduce temporary notation. Given an integer m ≥ 1, let Λm be the set of all multi-indices α such that αi ≤ m for each i. Note that we have (2.8) for α ∈ Λ = Λ1 by assumption. We now proceed by induction on m. Suppose that (2.8) holds for all α ∈ Λm . Let α ∈ Λm and fix j. If αj ≤ m − 1, then Rj Rα u vanishes on W by induction hypothesis. Consider αj−1 m−1 αj+1 1 n the case αj = m. Put f = Rα Rj+1 · · · Rα n u for simplicity. Note 1 · · · Rj−1 Rj that f is n-harmonic across W , because u is. Thus, we have by (2.4) Rj Rα u = R2j f = −Tj2 f
on W.
(2.9)
Moreover, Tj2 f = 0 on W , because f = 0 on W by induction hypothesis. So, we see that (2.8) holds for all α ∈ Λm+1 and the induction is complete. Now, let ζ ∈ W be an arbitrary but fixed point. Then it follows from (2.8) that T β Rα u(ζ) = 0 for all multi-indices α and β. Note that we may assume ζ = e by using componentwise rotation-invariance (2.7). So, T β Rα u(e) = 0 for all α and β. On the other hand, we see by routine and straightforward calculations that T β Rα u(e) is of the form T β Rα u(e) = Dxα Dyβ u(e) +
cα β Dxα Dyβ u(e);
(2.10)
lower order
the sum is to be taken over all multi-indices α and β with |α | < |α| or |β | < |β|. Thus, by an inductive argument, we obtain Dxα Dyβ u(e) = 0 for all multi-indices α and β. So, by real-analyticity, we conclude u = 0 in some open subset of Dn and thus on the whole Dn . The proof is complete. Remark. (1) Compared with the ball version (Proposition 4.1 of [7]) of Proposition 2.2, the hypothesis that “ Rα u = 0 for all α ∈ Λ ” might seem too much at a glace. In the same context, one might expect that “ Rj u = 0 for all j ” would be enough. It turns out that such hypothesis requiring all α ∈ Λ is essential, which shows a quite different nature caused by the fact that the polydisk is a product domain. To see an example, let g be the harmonic extension on D of a nonzero function continuous on T and vanishing on some open subarc I. Define u(z) = g(z1 ) · · · g(zn ) for z ∈ Dn and put W = I n . Clearly, we have u = 0, u ∈ h∞ ∩ C(Dn ) and u = 0 on W . Moreover, Rα u = 0 on W for all α ∈ Λ with α = (1, . . . , 1). Thus, just one single missing α ∈ Λ does not guarantee the triviality of u. (2) In the proof of Proposition 2.2, note that the boundedness of given function is used only to ensure the smooth extension across W in each variable sepn for arately. Consider a function u n-harmonic on Dn and continuous on U ∩ D n some open set U with W := U ∩ T = ∅. If u = 0 on W , then one can use the reflection principle to see that u extends n-harmonically across W . So, Proposition 2.2 remains valid for such a function u.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
51
3. Zero products In this section we prove our theorems. We need several technical lemmas. First, we begin with an observation on how Taylor approximations near distinguished boundary points behave when a bounded n-harmonic function vanishes on some boundary open set. Given an integer 0 ≤ k ≤ n, we let Λ(k) be the set of all α ∈ Λ such that |α| = k. Also, for a multi-index β, we say β ∈ Λ∗ (k) if there exists α ∈ Λ(k) such that βi = αi + 1 for some i and βj = αj for all j = i. We let τ (z) = (1 − z1 , . . . , 1 − zn ) η(z) = (|1 − z1 |, . . . , |1 − zn |) for z ∈ C . n
Lemma 3.1. Let u ∈ h∞ ∩C(Dn ∪W ) for some boundary open set W . Suppose that u is not identically 0 on Dn and vanishes on W . Then there exist some ζ ∈ W and an integer 1 ≤ k ≤ n such that u(ζz) = (−1)|α| Rα u(ζ) τ (z)α + O η(z)β β∈Λ∗ (k)
α∈Λ(k)
for z ∈ Dn ∪ ζW near e where ζz = (ζ1 z1 , . . . , ζn zn ). Moreover, some coefficient Rα u(ζ) = 0. Proof. Since u = 0 on W , u extends to an n-harmonic function across W , as mentioned earlier. Since u|W = 0 and u ≡ 0 on Dn by assumption, we have Rα u|W ≡ 0 for some α ∈ Λ by Proposition 2.2. So, the following minimum is well defined and positive: k = min{|α| : Rα u|W ≡ 0, α ∈ Λ}.
(3.1)
Now, choose a point ζ ∈ W such that Rα u(ζ) = 0 for some α ∈ Λ that achieves the above minimum. Note that the function v(z) := u(ζz) is real-analytic near e. Let Dxα Dyβ v(e) τ (z)α Y β (−1)|α| (3.2) v(z) = α!β! α,β
be the Taylor series expansion of v at e. Here, Y = (z1 , . . . , zn ). For the coefficients above, note that Dxα v(e) = Rα v(e) = Rα u(ζ) for α ∈ Λ(k) by (2.7). Thus, we can rewrite the sum in (3.2) as (−1)|α| Rα u(ζ) τ (z)α + Error. (3.3) v(z) = α∈Λ(k)
We now estimate the error term. Consider an arbitrary multi-index α with N (α) ≤ k − 1 where N (α) denotes the number of nonzero components of α. Associated with such α is a multi-index β = (β1 , . . . , βn ) where βi = 0 if αi = 0
52
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
and βi = 1 otherwise. Then, since β ∈ Λ and |β| = N (α) ≤ k − 1, we have Rβ u|W = 0 by minimality of k. Suppose that there is some j such that αj > βj = 1. e Let β = (β1 , . . . , βj−1 , 0, βj+1 , . . . , βn ) and put f = Rβ u. Then we also have e Rβ u|W = 0 by minimality of k. So, we have Rj Rβ u = R2j f = −Tj2 f = 0
on W
by the same argument as in (2.9). Now, repeating the same reasoning as many times as needed, we obtain Rα u|W = 0. In addition, we claim Rα T β u(ζ) = 0
(3.4)
for all multi-indices β. To show this, we assume α = (α1 , . . . , αk−1 , 0, . . . , 0) for notational simplicity . Also, shrinking W if necessary, we may assume W = W1 × · · · × Wn where each Wj is an open arc in T containing ζj . Then it follows from Proposition 2.2 that each function u(·, ξ), ξ ∈ Wk × · · · × Wn , is identically zero on Dk−1 . Therefore, given a multi-index β, we have β
k−1 Rα T1β1 · · · Tk−1 u=0
on Dk−1 × Wk × · · · × Wn
and therefore β
k−1 Tkβk · · · Tnβn Rα T1β1 · · · Tk−1 u=0
on Dk−1 × Wk × · · · × Wn .
This yields (3.4) as a special case, because Ri Tj = Tj Ri for each i, j. Note that we have Rα T β v(e) = 0 by (3.4) and (2.7). So, by (2.10) and (3.4), we have Dxα Dyβ v(e) = 0 for all α with N (α) ≤ k − 1 and for all β. Note that |α| = N (α) = k if and only if α ∈ Λ(k). Therefore, the error term in (3.3) can be decomposed into three pieces Dxα Dyβ v(e) τ (z)α Y β . + + (−1)|α| α!β! |α|>N (α)=k β=0
N (α)=k |β|≥1
N (α)>k |β|≥0
α+β Note that |τ (z)α Y β | ≤ η(z) for all α and β. Hence, it is easily seen that each sum above is dominated by γ∈Λ∗ (k) η(z)γ , as desired. The proof is complete.
Remark. The proof above shows that the point ζ = ζu ∈ W can be chosen arbitrarily, once Rα u(ζ) = 0 for some α ∈ Λ that achieves the minimum (3.1). Thus, given a finite number of functions u1 , . . . , uN ∈ h∞ ∩ C(Dn ∪ W ) which are not identically 0 on Dn and vanishes on some boundary open set W , one may easily modify the proof above to choose points ζuj ∈ W so that ζu1 = · · · = ζuN . This fact will be used later in the proof of Theorem 1.2 and Theorem 1.3. Before proving our main results, we need some technical estimates which are essentially proved in [7]. First, we need an integral estimate. Given c, s and d real, we let s 1 + log(1 − |a|)(1 − |b|) Φc,s (a, b) = |1 − ab|2+c
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
53
and consider corresponding integral |1 − ξ|d Φc,s (ξ, b) Ic,s,d (a, b) = dV1 (ξ) |1 − aξ|2 D for a, b ∈ D. Lemma 3.2. Given d, s ≥ 0 and c ≥ d − 2, there is a constant C = C(c, s, d) such that if c > d (1 − t)d−c Φ0,s+1 (a, t) Ic,s,d (a, t) ≤ C × Φc−d,s+1 (a, t) if c ≤ d for a ∈ D and 0 < t < 1.
Proof. This follows from Proposition 3.8 of [7].
Next, we need a couple of estimates showing how a certain 1-dimensional Toeplitz operator behaves against test functions. Let Sσ be the 1-dimensional Toeplitz operator with symbol σ where σ(a) = 1 − a for a ∈ D, or more explicitly, Sσ f (a) = D
f (ξ)(1 − ξ) dV1 (ξ), (1 − aξ )2
a∈D
for f ∈ A2 (D). Also, we let µt (a) =
1 , 1 − ta
a∈D
for each 0 < t < 1. Lemma 3.3. Let m > 2 be an integer. Then there exists a polynomial P in two variables with no term of degree less than 2 such that Sσ µm t = for
1 2
1 −1 3 µm−1 + µm t P(1 − t, µt ) + O(|µt | ) m−1 t
< t < 1.
Proof. See the proof of Lemma 4.3 in [7].
Lemma 3.4. Let and m be positive integers such that m > + 1. Then Sσ µm t =
µm− t {1 + Et } (m − 1) · · · (m − )
for 12 < t < 1 where {Et } are some uniformly bounded functions such that Et (t) = o(1) as t → 1. Proof. See the proof of Theorem 1.2 in [7].
54
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
We are now ready to prove our theorems. As is seen in the proofs of Proposition 2.2 and Lemma 3.1, the componentwise rotation-invariance property (2.7) allows us to normalize our argument. We will do the same normalization in the proofs below. This time, however, such normalization effects not only symbol functions but also Toeplitz operators with those symbols. So, we need to make that point clear. Let ρ be a componentwise rotation and let Cρ denote the composition operator f → f ◦ ρ on A2 . Then it is straightforward to verify (for N = 1 and thus for general N ) Cρ (Tu1 · · · TuN )Cρ−1 = Tu1 ◦ρ · · · TuN ◦ρ , which in turn yields Tu1 · · · TuN = 0 ⇐⇒ Tu1 ◦ρ · · · TuN ◦ρ = 0
(3.5)
for any finite number of Toeplitz operators Tu1 , . . . , TuN . Given t = (t1 , . . . , tn ) where 0 < tj < 1, we let λt (z) = µt1 (z1 ) · · · µtn (zn )
z ∈ Dn ;
this will be the source for our test functions. Note on Constants. For two positive quantities X and Y , we often write X Y or Y X if X is dominated by Y times some inessential positive constant. Also, we write X ≈ Y if X Y X. We first prove Theorem 1.1. Proof of Theorem 1.1. Assume Tu1 Tu2 = 0. Then, since u1 and u2 are both continuous on D ∪ W by assumption, we have 0 = (Tu1 Tu2 )= u1 u2
on W
by Proposition 2.1. There are two cases to consider: (i) Both u1 and u2 vanish on W (ii) Either u1 or u2 does not vanish on some boundary open subset of W . In n ) for some open set U with case of (i) we have by Lemma 3.1 u1 , u2 ∈ Lip1 (U ∩ D n U ∩ T = ∅. Thus, the case (i) is contained in Theorem 1.3 to be proved below. So, we may assume (ii). Note that we may further assume that u1 does not vanish on some boundary open set, still denoted by W , because otherwise we can use the adjoint operator (Tu1 Tu2 )∗ = Tu2 Tu1 . We now have u2 = 0 on W . Assume that u2 is not identically 0 on Dn . This will lead us to a contradiction. In the rest of the proof, we let z = (z1 , . . . , zn ) ∈ Dn represent an arbitrary point. Since u2 = 0 on W and u2 is not identically 0 on Dn , we have a point ζ ∈ W and an integer k ≥ 1 provided by Lemma 3.1 (with u2 in place of u). By componentwise rotation-invariance (2.7) and (3.5), we may assume ζ = e without loss of generality. Also, put Cα = Rα u2 (e) for multi-indices α. Then, by Lemma 3.1, we have Cα τ (z)α + O η(z)β u2 (z) = α∈Λ(k)
β∈Λ∗ (k)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
55
for z ∈ Dn ∪ W near e where some coefficient Cα = 0. Put c1 = u1 (e) = 0 and m2 (z) = Cα τ (z)α α∈Λ(k)
for simplicity. Also, let e1 = u1 − c1 and e2 = u2 − m2 . Then we have 0 = Tu1 Tu2 = Tc1 +e1 Tm2 +e2 = c1 Tm2 + Te1 Tm2 + Tu1 Te2 and thus −c1 Tm2 = Te1 Tm2 + Tu1 Te2 . Now we apply each side of the above to the same test functions and derive a contradiction. Here, we will use test functions λm t where m > 4 is any fixed integer and t = (t1 , . . . , tn ) is chosen as follows. Choice of t: Put
F (x) =
Cα xα
α∈Λ(k)
for x ∈ R . Note that F is a non-zero polynomial on Rn , because some coefficient Cα is not zero. Thus, there is some y ∈ (0, 1)n such that F (y) = 0. Given t ∈ (0, 1), we now choose tj = tj (t) such that tj = 1 − yj (1 − t2 ), j = 1, . . . , n, n
and let t = t(t) = (t1 , . . . , tn ) for the rest of the proof. Note tj ∈ (0, 1) and 1 − t2j = yj (1 − t2 ) for each j so that n
(1 − t2j )αj = (1 − t2 )k y α
(3.6)
j=1
for each α ∈ Λ(k).
Estimate of Tm2 λm t (t): Note that τ (z) = σ(z1 ), . . . , σ(zn ) . Thus, we have n σ αj (wj )µm tj (wj ) Tm2 λm (z) = C dV1 (wj ) α t (1 − zj wj )2 j=1 D α∈Λ(k)
=
Cα
Tm2 λm t (t) =
(3.7)
Sσαj µm tj (zj )
j=1
α∈Λ(k)
so that
n
Cα
αj =1
α∈Λ(k)
Sσ µm tj (tj )
µm tj (tj ) .
αj =0
Note that, by Lemma 3.3, we have Sσ µm t (a) =
(a) µm−1 t {1 + O(|1 − ta|)} m−1
(3.8)
56
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
as t → 1 uniformly in a ∈ D and hence Sσ µm t (t) =
(t) µm−1 t {1 + O(1 − t)} m−1
as t → 1. It follows that Tm2 λm t (t) =
=
1 + o(1) (m − 1)k
Cα
µm−1 (tj ) tj
αj =1
α∈Λ(k)
µm tj (tj )
αj =0
+ o(1)} Cα (1 − t2j ) (m − 1)k α =1
λm t (t){1
α∈Λ(k)
j
λm (t){1 + o(1)} (1 − t2 )k F (y) = t (m − 1)k
by (3.6)
and thus m 2 k |Tm2 λm t (t)| λt (t)(1 − t ) |F (y)| =
|F (y)| (1 − t2 )mn−k
as t → 1. Since F (y) = 0, we finally get |Tm2 λm t (t)|
1 (1 − t2 )mn−k
(3.9)
as t → 1. Estimate of Tu1 Te2 λm t (t): First, recall that
|e2 (z)|
|1 − z1 |β1 · · · |1 − zn |βn .
β∈Λ∗ (k)
Also, for β ∈ Λ∗ (k), note βj ≤ 2 < m − 2 for each j and |β| = k + 1. Thus, by Lemma 3.2, we have |Te2 λm t (z)|
n
β∈Λ∗ (k) j=1
n
β∈Λ∗ (k) j=1
D
|1 − wj |βj dV1 (w) |1 − zj wj |2 |1 − tj w j |m
Φ0,1 (zj , tj ) (1 − tj )m−2−βj
1 (1 − t)mn−2n−k−1
n j=1
Φ0,1 (zj , tj )
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
57
and hence, again by Lemma 3.2, we obtain |Tu1 Te2 λm t (t)|
n
1 (1 −
t)nm−2n−k−1
1 (1 − t)nm−2n−k−1
j=1 n
D
|Φ0,1 (wj , tj )| dV1 (wj ) |1 − tj wj |2
Φ0,2 (tj , tj )
j=1
as t → 1. Note that
2 n 1 + log(1 − tj )2 1 + | log(1 − t)|2n Φ0,2 (tj , tj ) = ≈ (1 − t2j )2 (1 − t)2n j=1 j=1 n
as t → 1. Combining these estimates, we conclude |Tu1 Te2 λm t (t)|
1 + | log(1 − t)|2n o(1) = nm−k−1 (1 − t) (1 − t)nm−k
(3.10)
as t → 1. Estimate of Te1 Tm2 λm t (t): By (3.7), we first note m m m Cα Sσ µtj (zj ) µtj (zj ) Tm2 λt (z) = αj =1
α∈Λ(k)
and hence by (3.8) |Tm2 λm t (z)|
|Cα |
αj =1
α∈Λ(k)
|λm t (z)|
α∈Λ(k)
=
|λm t (z)|
αj =0
|µm−1 (zj )|O(1) tj
|Cα |
|µm tj (zj )|
αj =0
|1 − tj zj |
αj =1
|Cα ||1 − t1 z1 |α1 · · · |1 − tn zn |αn
α∈Λ(k)
for z ∈ Dn . Since coefficients Cα are bounded, it follows that n |e1 (w)| m |Te1 Tm2 λt (t)| dV (w). m+2−αj Dn j=1 |1 − tj wj | α∈Λ(k)
Given > 0 small, we let Dj () = {zj ∈ D : |zj − 1| < } for j = 1, . . . , n and put Ω = D1 () × D2 () × · · · × Dn ().
(3.11)
58
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
Corresponding to this region, we now decompose the sum in (3.11) into two pieces as follows: = and = 1
α∈Λ(k)
2
Dn \Ω
α∈Λ(k)
Ω
for convenience.
We first estimate 1 . Note that Dn \ Ω is the finite union of sets of the form J = J1 × J2 × · · · × Jn where each Jj is either Dj () or D \ Dj () and at least one Jj is D \ Dj (). Given such J, let = (J) be an index such that J = D \ D (). Since |1 − t w | ≥ |1 − w | − (1 − t ) ≥ − (1 − t ) − y (1 − t) for w ∈ J as t → 1, we have, for α ∈ Λ(k), dV1 (w ) 1 m+2−α [ − y (1 − t)]m+2−α J |1 − t w | 1 ≤ [ − |y|(1 − t)]m+2 as t → 1. On the other hand, we have dV1 (wj ) 1 ≈ , m+2−αj m−αj |1 − t w | (1 − t j j j) D
j = ;
(3.12)
see Lemma 4.2.2 of [15] for a proof of this well-known estimate. Note that 1 1 ≈ m−α j (1 − tj ) (1 − t)m−αj j=
j=
(1 − t)m−α (1 − t)mn−k (1 − t)m−1 ≤ (1 − t)mn−k =
because |α| = k. It follows that n 1 1 (1 − t)m−1 dV (w) · m+2−α mn−k j (1 − t) [ − |y|(1 − t)]m+2 J j=1 |1 − tj wj | as t → 1. Note that this estimate is uniform in J and α ∈ Λ(k) as t → 1. So, since e1 is bounded, we conclude ν(, t) (3.13) 1 (1 − t)mn−k as t → 1 where ν(, t) = (1 − t)m−1 /[ − |y|(1 − t)]m+2 . √ Next, we estimate 2 . Note that |w − e| < n for w ∈ Ω . Thus, setting √ ω() = sup{|u1 (w) − u1 (e)| : w ∈ Dn ∪ W, |e − w| < n},
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
we have 2
≤ ω()
Dn
α∈Λ(k)
α∈Λ(k)
≈
n
1 dV (w) m+2−αj |1 − t w j j| j=1
n
ω()
59
1 (1 − t )m−αj j j=1
(3.14)
ω() (1 − t)mn−k
where the second inequality holds by (3.12). In summary, with > 0 small and fixed, we have by (3.13) and (3.14) |Te1 Tm2 λm t (t)|
ω() + ν(, t) (1 − t)mn−k
(3.15)
as t → 1 and the estimate is uniform in . Finish of Proof : Setting M = −c1 Tm2 and R = Te1 Tm2 + Tu1 Te2 , we obtain from (3.9), (3.10) and (3.15) that 1=
|Rλm t (t)| ω() + ν(, t) + o(1), |M λm t (t)|
> 0 : fixed
as t → 1 and the estimate is uniform in small. So, now first taking the limit t → 1 and then → 0, we have 1 ω() → 0 by continuity of u at e, which is a contradiction. This completes the proof.
Next, we prove Theorem 1.2. Proof of Theorem 1.2. Assume Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 Tu4 = 0. Then, since each uj is continuous up to the distinguished boundary by assumption, we have (Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 Tu4 )= u1 u2 u3 u4 = 0
on T n
by Proposition 2.1. Since u1 u2 u3 u4 is continuous and vanishes everywhere on the distinguished boundary, there exists a boundary open set W ⊂ T n such that either or
uj never vanishes uj = 0 on W
on W,
holds for each j. Since there is nothing to prove if u1 ≡ 0, we may assume that u1 |W never vanishes. Now, assume that each uj is not identically 0 on Dn . We will get a contradiction. Since each uj is not identically 0 on Dn , we may shrink (if necessary) the set W to get a smaller boundary open set, still denoted by W , such that each uj
60
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
satisfies (i) uj |W never vanishes,
either
or (ii) uj |W = 0 but uj ≡ 0.
(3.16)
Given j for which the case (ii) holds, we have by Lemma 3.1 a point ζ ∈ W and a positive integer kj such that uj (ζz) = Rα uj (ζ) τ (z)α + O η(z)β (3.17) β∈Λ∗ (kj )
α∈Λ(kj )
for z ∈ Dn ∪ ζW near e where some coefficient Rα uj (ζ) = 0. Note that such a point ζ can be chosen independently of j by the remark mentioned right after Lemma 3.1. So, we may assume ζ = e; this causes no loss of generality by (2.7) and (3.5). Also, we let Cj,α = Rα uj (e) for each j and multi-index α. Using such notation, we rewrite (3.17) as Cj,α τ (z)α + O η(z)β uj (z) = β∈Λ∗ (kj )
α∈Λ(kj )
for z ∈ D ∪ W near e where some coefficient Cj,α = 0. We let kj = 0 if uj (e) = 0. Note k1 = 0, because u1 never vanishes on W . With such convention we have |1 − z1 |α1 · · · |1 − zn |αn (3.18) |uj (z)| n
α∈Λ(kj )
for each j, because Λ(0) consists of the zero multi-index in case kj = 0. Here, and in the rest of the proof, z ∈ Dn represents an arbitrary point. Now, we define the major part of uj by Cj,α τ (z)α (3.19) mj (z) := α∈Λ(kj )
for each j. More explicitly, we define (e) uj mj (z) = Cj,α τ (z)α
if uj (e) = 0 if uj (e) = 0
α∈Λ(kj )
for each j. Put ej = uj − mj for each j. Note that ej (e) = 0 for each j. Thus, we have n |1 − zi | if uj (e) = 0 i=1 |ej (z)| (3.20) β1 βn |1 − z | · · · |1 − z | if u (e) = 0 1 n j β∈Λ∗ (kj )
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
61
by the Lipschitz continuity hypothesis. We introduce further notation. Put M = Tm1 Tm2 Tm3 Tm4 and R = Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 Tu4 − M for notational convenience. Then, setting R1 = Te1 Tm2 Tm3 Tm4 , R2 = Tu1 Te2 Tm3 Tm4 , R3 = Tu1 Tu2 Te3 Tm4 , R4 = Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 Te4 , we have R = R1 + R2 + R3 + R4 . Note that R = −M , because Tu1 Tu2 Tu3 Tu4 = 0 m by assumption. Now we will estimate the same expression M λm t (t) = −Rλt (t) in two different ways and reach a contradiction as in the proof of Theorem 1.1. Here, m > 4 is any fixed integer and t = (t1 , . . . , tn ) is chosen below. Put k = k1 + k2 + k3 + k4 . Note that we have k ≥ 1, because (u1 u2 u3 u4 )(e) = 0. Also, recall that k1 = 0. Choice of t: First, we introduce some notation. Let (α, β, γ) denote an arbitrary triple of α ∈ Λ(k2 ), β ∈ Λ(k3 ) and γ ∈ Λ(k4 ). Given (α, β, γ), we let 1 Cα+β+γ = (m − 1) · · · (m − αi − βi − γi ) αi +βi +γi ≥1
be the set of all multi-indices of the form α + β + γ for simplicity. Also, let Λ where α ∈ Λ(k2 ), β ∈ Λ(k3 ) and γ ∈ Λ(k4 ). Using such notation, we consider two polynomials on Rn given by G(x) : = C2,α C3,β C4,γ xα+β+γ (α,β,γ)
=
e h∈Λ
C2,α C3,β C4,γ xh
(3.21)
α+β+γ=h
and F (x) : =
(α,β,γ)
=
e h∈Λ
C2,α C3,β C4,γ Cα+β+γ xα+β+γ
Ch
C2,α C3,β C4,γ xh
(3.22)
α+β+γ=h
for x ∈ Rn . It is clear from (3.21) and (3.22) that G is non-trivial if and only if F is. Note that G
is the product of non-trivial polynomials G2 , G3 and G4 defined by Gj (x) = α∈Λ(kj ) Cj,α xα for j = 2, 3, 4. The polynomial G is therefore non-trivial. So, we conclude that the polynomial F is also non-trivial.
62
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
Now, as in the proof of Theorem 1.1, we choose y ∈ (0, 1)n with F (y) = 0 and define 0 < t < 1, ti = ti (t) = 1 − yi (1 − t2 ), for i = 1, . . . , n. Let t = t(t) = (t1 , . . . , tn ) for the rest of the proof. Note ti ∈ (0, 1) and 1 − t2i = yi (1 − t2 ) for each i. Also, note that |α + β + γ| = k2 + k3 + k4 = k for all (α, β, γ). So, we have n
(1 − t2i )αi +βi +γi = (1 − t2 )k y α+β+γ
(3.23)
i=1
for each (α, β, γ). Estimate of M λm t (t): Note that M = cTm2 Tm3 Tm4 where c = u1 (e) = 0. Using (3.19) and repeating arguments similar to (3.7), we have n m αi +βi +γi m C2,α C3,β C4,γ Sσ µti (zi ) . Tm2 Tm3 Tm4 λt (z) = i=1
(α,β,γ)
Meanwhile, given (α, β, γ), we deduce from Lemma 3.4 that n
Sσαi +βi +γi µm ti (ti )
i=1
=
µm ti (ti )
αi +βi +γi =0
=
Sσαi +βi +γi µm ti (ti )
αi +βi +γi ≥1
µm ti (ti )
αi +βi +γi =0
αi +βi +γi ≥1
= Cα+β+γ λm t (t){1 + o(1)}
i −βi −γi µm−α (t ){1 + o(1)} i ti (m − 1) · · · (m − αi − βi − γi ) (1 − t2i )αi +βi +γi
αi +βi +γi ≥1
as t → 1 (hence all ti → 1). Also, note that we have
(1 − t2i )αi +βi +γi =
αi +βi +γi ≥1
n
(1 − t2i )αi +βi +γi = (1 − t2 )k y α+β+γ
i=1
by (3.23). Now, combining all the observations in the preceding paragraph, we have m 2 k M λm t (t) = cλt (t){1 + o(1)}(1 − t ) F (y)
and thus m 2 k |M λm t (t)| λt (t)(1 − t ) |cF (y)| =
|cF (y)| (1 − t2 )mn−k
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
63
as t → 1. Since cF (y) = 0, we finally conclude |M λm t (t)|
1 (1 − t2 )mn−k
(3.24)
as t → 1. Estimate of Rj λm t (t): Recall Rj = Tu1 · · · Tuj−1 Tej Tmj+1 · · · Tm4 for each j. Let j ≤ 3 for a moment. Using the same argument as in the course of the estimate of M λm t (t), we have |Tmj+1 · · · Tm4 λm t (z)|
n (j)
Sσαi +···+γi µm ti (zi )
i=1
(j)
where denote the sum over all α ∈ Λ(kj+1 ), . . . , γ ∈ Λ(k4 ). Thus we have by Lemma 3.4 |Tmj+1 · · · Tm4 λm t (z)|
n (j)
|µti (zi )|m−pi
i=1
where pi = pi (j; α, . . . , γ) = αi + · · · + γi . Hence by (3.20) we have (j) Θj,α,...,γ (z) |Tej Tmj+1 · · · Tm4 λm t (z)| where
n n |µti (wi )|m−pi |1 − w | dV (w) |1 − zi w i |2 n i=1 =1 D Θj,α,...,γ (z) = n |1 − wi |βi |µti (wi )|m−pi dV (w) |1 − z w |2 n β∈Λ∗ (kj )
D
i
i=1
i
if uj (e) = 0 if uj (e) = 0.
Recall 1 − tj ≈ 1 − t as t → 1. So, if uj (e) = 0, then we have by Lemma 3.2 n Φ0,1 (zi , ti ) Φ0,1 (z , t ) Θj,α,...,γ (z) (1 − ti )m−pi −2 (1 − t )m−p −2− =1
≈ =
i=
(1 − t) (1 − t)mn−2n−(p1 +···+pn ) (1 − t)
n
Φ0,1 (zi , ti )
i=1 n
(1 − t)mn−2n−(kj+1 +···+k4 )
Φ0,1 (zi , ti )
i=1
as t → 1. Similarly, if uj (e) = 0, then we have Θj,α,...,γ (z)
1 (1 − t)mn−2n−(kj+1 +···+k4 )−(kj +1)
n i=1
Φ0,1 (zi , ti )
64
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
as t → 1, because |β| = kj + 1 for β ∈ Λ∗ (kj ). Note that these estimates are uniform in α, . . . , γ. Thus, since ≤ 1, it follows that |Tej Tmj+1 · · · Tm4 λm t (z)|
(1 − t) (1 − t)mn−2n−(kj +···+k4 )
n
Φ0,1 (zi , ti )
(3.25)
i=1
as t → 1 and this estimate remains valid even for j = 4. Now, let j ≥ 2 for a moment. Continuing estimates by using (3.25), we deduce from (3.18) and Lemma 3.2 that |Tuj−1 Tej Tmj+1 · · · Tm4 λm t (z)| (1 − t)
(1 − t)mn−2n−(kj +···+k4 ) n |1 − wi |γi Φ0,1 (wi , ti ) × dV1 (wi ) |1 − zi wi |2 γ∈Λ(kj−1 ) i=1 D n (1 − t) Φ−γi ,2 (zi , ti ) (1 − t)mn−2n−(kj +···+k4 ) i=1 γ∈Λ(kj−1 )
because γi = 0, 1 for each i. Note that, for α ∈ Λ(k1 ), . . . , γ ∈ Λ(kj−1 ), we have 0 ≤ αi + · · · + γi ≤ 2
(3.26)
for each i, because α = 0 (recall k1 = 0); it is this step which requires the restriction on the number of factors in the product. Thus, by repeating the same argument using Lemma 3.2, we obtain n (1 − t) m Φ−qi ,j (zi , ti ) |Rj λt (z)| (j) (1 − t)mn−2n−(kj +···+k4 ) i=1
where qi = qi (j; α, . . . , γ) = αi + · · · + γi . Here, the sum (j) is taken over all α ∈ Λ(k1 ), . . . , γ ∈ Λ(kj−1 ). Since 1 − tj ≈ 1 − t as t → 1, each term of the sum above, when evaluated at ti , is estimated as follows: n
Φ−qi ,j (ti , ti ) =
i=1
n 1 + | log(1 − tj )2 |j i=1 n i=1
(1 − t2j )2−qi 1 + | log(1 − t)|4 (1 − t)2−qi
1 + | log(1 − t)|4n (1 − t)2n−(k1 +···+kj−1 )
and this estimate is uniform in α, . . . , γ. Combining these estimates, we obtain |Rj λm t (t)|
(1 − t) (1 + | log(1 − t)|4n ) , (1 − t)mn−k
t→1
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zero Products of Toeplitz Operators
65
for j ≥ 2 and the same estimate holds for j = 1 by a similar argument using (3.25). We thus conclude o(1) (3.27) |Rλm t (t)| (1 − t)mn−k as t → 1. Finish of Proof : We easily deduce from (3.24) and (3.27) that 1=
|Rλm t (t)| o(1), |M λm t (t)|
which is a contradiction. The proof is complete.
t → 1,
Finally, we prove Theorem 1.3. The proof is exactly the same as that of Theorem 1.2 except at one spot. We only indicate such a difference. Proof of Theorem 1.3. By a similar argument using Proposition 2.1, we can also have a boundary open set W where u1 u2 u3 vanishes and (3.16) holds. In the proof of Theorem 1.2 we were able to assume that u1 never vanishes on W (and thus k1 = 0) under the global Lipschitz hypothesis because the location of the boundary open set W was of no significance. However, we can not do the same under the present local Lipschitz hypothesis. That is, k1 ≥ 1 may well happen and the inequality (3.26) is no longer guaranteed. Namely, αi + βi + γi = 3 might hold for some i and for some α ∈ Λ(k1 ), β ∈ Λ(k2 ), γ ∈ Λ(k3 ) in case k1 , k2 , k3 ≥ 1. What matters here is the number of terms in the sum above which comes from the number of factors. So, if we are given only three factors, all the arguments in the proof of Theorem 1.2 work even in case k1 ≥ 1. This completes the proof.
References [1] P. Ahern, On the range of the Berezin transform, J. Funct. Anal. 215(2004), 206–216. ˇ Cuˇ ˇ ckovi´c, A theorem of Brown-Halmos type for Bergman space [2] P. Ahern and Z. Toeplitz operators, J. Funct. Anal. 187(2001), 200–210. ˇ Cuˇ ˇ ckovi´c, Some examples related to the Brown-Halmos theorem for [3] P. Ahern and Z. the Bergman space, Acta Sci. Math. 70(2004), 373–378. ˇ Cuˇ ˇ ckovi´c, Commuting Toeplitz operators with harmonic symbols, [4] S. Axler and Z. Integr. Equ. Oper. Theory 14(1991), 1–11. [5] A. Brown and P. Halmos, Algebraic properties of Toeplitz operators, J. Reine Angew. Math. 213(1964), 89–102. [6] Bouendi and Rothschild, A local Hopf lemma and unique continuation for harmonic functions, International Mathematics Research Notices, 1993, No. 8, 245-251. [7] B. R. Choe and H. Koo, Zero products of Toeplitz operators with harmonic symbols, J. Funct. Anal. 233(2006), No. 2, 307-334.
66
Choe, Koo and Lee
IEOT
[8] B. R. Choe, Y. J. Lee, K. Nam and D. Zheng, Products of Bergman space Toeplitz operators on the polydisk, Math. Ann., to appear. ˇ Cuˇ ˇ ckovi´c, Berezin versus Mellin, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 287(2003), 234–243. [9] Z. [10] X, Ding, Products of Toeplitz operators on the polydisk, Integr. Equ. Oper. Theory 45(2003), 398–403. [11] C. Gu, Products of several Toeplitz operators, J. Funct. Anal. 171(2000), 483–527. [12] K. Guo, A problem on products of Toeplitz operators, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 124(1996), 869–871. [13] S. Krantz, Function theory of several complex variables. Second edition., Graduate Studies in Mathematics, 40. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2002. [14] W. Rudin, Function theory in polydiscs, Benjamin, New York, 1969. [15] K. Zhu, Operator theory in function spaces, Marcel Dekker, New York and Basel, 1989. Boo Rim Choe and Hyungwoon Koo Department of Mathematics Korea University Seoul 136–713 Korea e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] Young Joo Lee Department of Mathematics Chonnam National University Gwangju 500-757 Korea e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: May 25, 2005 Revised: June 30, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 67–81 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010067-15, published online May 3, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1440-6
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Zeno Product Formula Revisited Pavel Exner, Takashi Ichinose, Hagen Neidhardt and Valentin A. Zagrebnov Abstract. We introduce a new product formula which combines an orthogonal projection with a complex function of a non-negative operator. Under certain assumptions on the complex function the strong convergence of the product formula is shown. Under more restrictive assumptions even operator-norm convergence is verified. The mentioned formula can be used to describe Zeno dynamics in the situation when the usual non-decay measurement is replaced by a particular generalized observables in the sense of Davies. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A55, 47D03, 81Q10; Secondary 47B25. Keywords. Zeno dynamics, product formulæ, resolvents, convergence, generalized observables.
1. Introduction Product formulæ are a traditional tool in various branches of mathematics; their use dates back to the time of Sophus Lie. Such formulæ are often of the form n (1.1) s- lim e−itA/n e−itB/n = e−itC , C := A + B, t ∈ R, n→∞
where A and B are bounded operators on some separable Hilbert space H and s-lim stands for the strong operator topology. A natural generalization to unbounded self-adjoint operators A and B is due to Trotter [23, 24] who showed that the limit exists and is equal to e−itC , t ∈ R, if the operator C, Cf := Af + Bf,
f ∈ dom(C) := dom(A) ∩ dom(B),
is essentially self-adjoint. In [16, 17] Kato focused his interest to products of the type n n s- lim (f (tA/n)g(tB/n)) and s- lim g(tB/n)1/2 f (tA/n)g(tB/n)1/2 (1.2) n→∞
n→∞
68
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
where A, B are non-negative self-adjoint operators and f, g are now so-called Kato functions. Recall that a Borel measurable function f (·) : [0, ∞) −→ R is usually called a Kato function if the conditions 0 ≤ f (x) ≤ 1,
f (0) = 1,
f (+0) = −1,
are satisfied. Under these conditions he was able to show that the limits (1.2) exist and are equal to e−tC , t ∈ R, where C is the form sum of A and B. Notice f (x) = e−x is a Kato-functions which yields the well-known Trotter-Kato product formulæ n n s- lim e−tA/n e−tB/n = s- lim e−tB/2n e−tA/n e−tB/2n = e−tC , t ≥ 0. n→∞
n→∞
Both products (1.1) and (1.2) are very useful and admit applications to functional integration, quantum statistical physics and other parts of physics – see, e.g., [8, Chap. V], [25] and references therein. The last decade brought a progress in understanding of the convergence properties of such formulæ in operator-norm and trace-class topology, for a review of these results we refer to the monograph [25]. In the last few years we have witnessed a surge of interest to another type of product formulæ, namely those where the left-hand side is replaced by an expression of the type s- lim
n→∞
P e−itH/n P
n
(1.3)
where H is a self-adjoint operator on some separable Hilbert space H and P is a orthogonal projection on some closed subspace h ⊆ H. Products of such type are motivated by the “quantum Zeno effect” (QZE). We call them therefore Zeno product formulæ. The fact that the limit, if it exists, may be unitary on h is a venerable problem known already to Alan Turing and formulated in the usual decay context of quantum mechanics for the first time by Beskow and Nilsson [2]: frequent measurements can slow down a decay of an unstable system, or even fully stop it in the limit of infinite measurement frequency. The effect was analyzed mathematically by Friedman [12] but became popular only after the authors of [21] invented the above stated name. Recent interest is motivated mainly by the fact that now the effect is within experimental reach; an up-to-date bibliography can be found, e.g., in [10] or [22]. The physical interpretation of this formula can be given in the context of particle decay, cf. [8, Chap. II]. The unstable system is characterized by a projection P to a subspace h of the state Hilbert space H of a larger, closed system, the dynamics of which is governed by a self-adjoint Hamiltonian H. Repeating the non-decay measurement experiment with the period t/n, we can describe the time evolution over the interval [0, t] of a state originally in the subspace P H by the interlaced product (P e−itH/n P )n ; the question is how this operator will behave as n → ∞. In [21, Theorem 1] it was shown that if the limit (1.3) exists and there is a conjugation J commuting with P and H, then the Zeno product formula defines a unitary group on the subspace h. Another simple example shows that this result is not valid generally: the limit (1.3) may exist without defining a unitary group.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
69
Let H = L2 (R) and H be the momentum operator, i.e H = −i∂x and let P = P[a,b] be the orthogonal projection on some subspace h = L2 ([a, b]), [a, b] ⊆ R. A straightforward calculation shows that P[a,b] e−isH P[a,b] = P[a,b] P[a+s,b+s] e−isH P[a,b] , Therefore, we get
T (t) := s- lim
n→∞
P e−itH/n P
n
= P e−itH h,
s ∈ R. t ∈ R,
(1.4)
which is neither unitary nor it satisfies the group property but defines a contraction semigroup for t ≥ 0. This example is covered by the following more general one. Let H be the minimal self-adjoint dilation of a maximal dissipative operator K defined on the subspace h. Since by definition of self-adjoint dilations, cf. [11], P e−isH P := e−isK = P e−isH h,
we find s- lim
n→∞
P e−itH/n P
n
= e−itK ,
s ≥ 0, t ≥ 0.
From now on the strong convergence in the product formula is considered only on h. Further examples can be found in [20]. However, in all of them the non-unitarity of the limit is related to the fact that H is not semibounded. So we restrict ourself in the following to the case that H is semi-bounded from below; it is clear that without loss of generality we may assume that H is non-negative. It has to be stressed that the last mentioned assumption does not ensure the √ existence of the limit (1.3). Indeed, if dom( H) ∩ h is not dense in h, then it can happen that the left-hand side in the Zeno product formula does not converge, cf. [8, Rem. 2.4.9] or [20]. With these facts in mind we assume in the following that H is a non-negative √ self-adjoint operator such that dom( H)∩h is dense in h. Under these assumptions we claim that a “natural” candidate for the limit of the Zeno product formula (1.3) is the unitary group e−itK , t ∈ R, on h, generated by the non-negative self-adjoint operator K associated with the closed sesquilinear form k, √ √ √ k(f, g) := ( Hf, Hg), f, g ∈ dom(k) = dom( H) ∩ h ⊆ h. (1.5) The claim rests upon the paper [9, Theorem 2.1] where it is shown that T n lim P e−itH/n P f − e−itK f 2 dt = 0, for each f ∈ h and T > 0 (1.6) n→∞
0
holds. This result yields the existence of the limit of the Zeno product formula for almost all t in the strong operator topology, along a subsequence {n } of natural numbers1 . The reason why this result is weaker than the natural conjecture is that the exponential function involved in the interlaced product gives rise to oscillations 1 This
fact that the proof in [9] yields convergence along a subsequence was omitted in the first version of the paper from which the claim was reproduced in the review [22]. A complete proof of this claim is known at present only in the case when P is finite-dimensional, cf. [9].
70
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
which are not easy to deal with. One of the main ingredients in the present paper is a simple observation that one can avoid the mentioned problem when φ(x) = e−ix is replaced by functions with an imaginary part of constant sign. In analogy with the Kato class of the product formula (1.2) it seems to be useful to introduce a class of admissible functions. Defintion 1. We call a Borel measurable function φ(·) : [0, ∞) −→ C admissible if the conditions |φ(x)| ≤ 1,
x ∈ [0, ∞),
φ(0) = 1,
and φ (+0) = −i,
(1.7)
are satisfied. Typical examples are φ(x) = (1 + ix/k)−k ,
k = 1, 2, . . . ,
and φ(x) = e−ix ,
x ∈ [0, ∞).
(1.8)
The main goal of this paper is to prove the following result. Theorem 2. Let H be a non-negative self-adjoint operator in H and let h be a closed subspace √ of H such that P : H −→ h is the orthogonal projection from H onto h. If dom( H) ∩ h is dense in h and φ is admissible function which obeys
m (φ(x)) ≤ 0,
x ∈ [0, ∞),
(1.9)
then for any t0 > 0 one has n
s- lim (P φ(tH/n)P ) = e−itK ,
(1.10)
n→∞
uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ], where the generator K is defined by (1.5) and the strong convergence is meant on h. One may consider formulæ of type (1.10) as modified Zeno product formulæ. Examples of admissible functions obeying (1.9) are φ(x) = (1 + ix)−1
and φ(x) = (1 + ix/2)−2 ,
x ∈ [0, ∞).
Unfortunately, not all admissible function do satisfy the condition (1.9). Indeed, the functions φ(x) = (1 + ix/3)−3 and φ(x) = e−ix , x ∈ [0, ∞), are admissible but do not obey (1.9). In particular this yields that the convergence problem for the original Zeno product formula (1.3) is not solved by Theorem 2 and remains open. However, Theorem (2) suggests the following regularizing procedure. We set ∆φ := {x ∈ [0, ∞) : m (φ(x)) ≤ 0}. By (1.7) the set ∆φ contains a neighbourhood of zero. If the subset ∆ ⊆ ∆φ contains also a neighbourhood of zero, then φ∆ (x) := φ(x)χ∆ (x),
x ∈ [0, ∞),
defines an admissible function obeying m (φ∆ (x)) ≤ 0, x ∈ [0, ∞). By Theorem 2 we obtain that for any t0 > 0 one has n
s- lim (P φ∆ (tH/n)P ) = e−itK n→∞
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
71
uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ]. Applying this procedure to φ(x) = e−ix , x ∈ [0, ∞), one has to choose a subset ∆ ⊆ ∆φ := ∪∞ m=0 [2mπ, (2m + 1)π] containing a neighbourhood of zero. From φ(x) = e−ix one can construct a “cutoff” admissible function φ∆ (x) := e−ix χ∆ (x), x ∈ [0, ∞), obeying (1.9). In particular for ∆ = [0, π), the function φ∆ (x) = e−ix χ∆ (x), x ∈ [0, ∞), is admissible and obeys (1.9). This leads immediately to the following corollary. Corollary 3. If the assumptions of Theorem 2 are satisfied, then for any t0 > 0 one has n n s- lim P (I + itH/n)−1 P = s- lim P (I + itH/2n)−2 P = e−itK , (1.11) n→∞
n→∞
and s- lim
n→∞
n P EH ([0, πn/t))e−itH/n P = e−itK
(1.12)
uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ] where EH (·) is the spectral measure of H, i.e. H = [0,∞) λ dEH (λ). The ideas to replace the unitary group e−itH by a resolvent, cf. (1.11), or to employ a spectral cut-off together with e−itH , cf. (1.12), are not new: they were used to derive a modification of the unitary Lie-Trotter formula in [14] and [18, 19], respectively, both for the form sum of two non-negative self-adjoint operators. See also [3]. Finally, let us note that formula (1.12) admits a physical interpretation in the context of the Zeno effect. To this end we note that the combination of the energy filtering and non-decay measurement following immediately one after another, see (1.12), can be regarded as a single generalized measurement. In fact, a product of two, in general non-commuting2 projections represents the simplest non-trivial example of generalized observables3 introduced by Davies which are realized as positive maps of the respective space of density matrices [6, Sec. 2.1]. Thus formula (1.12) corresponds to a modified Zeno situation with such generalized measurements, which depend on n and tend to the standard non-decay yes-no experiment as n → ∞. Let us describe briefly the contents of the paper. Section 2 is completely devoted to the proof of Theorem 2. In Section 3 we handle √ the general case of admissible functions under the stronger assumption h ⊆ dom( H). We show that under this assumption the modified Zeno product formula converges to e−itK for 2 We are primarily interested, of course, in the nontrivial case when the P does not commute with H, and thus also with the spectral projections EH ([0, πn/t)). 3 Since the spectral projections involved commute with the evolution operator, one can also replace the product P EH ([0, πt/n)) in our formulæ by EH ([0, πt/n))P EH ([0, πt/n)). Such generalized observables represented by symmetrized projection products have been recently studied as almost sharp quantum effects – cf. [1].
72
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
any admissible function not necessary satisfying the additional condition (1.9). In particular, one has n s-lim P e−itH/n P = e−itK , (1.13) uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ] for any t0 > 0. Moreover, we shall demonstrate there that under stronger assumptions, unfortunately too restrictive from the viewpoint of physical applications, even the operator-norm convergence can be obtained. We finish the paper with a conjecture which takes into account the results of [9] and the present paper.
2. Proof of Theorem 2 We set F (τ ) := P φ(τ H)P : h −→ h ,
τ ≥ 0,
(2.1)
and
Ih − F (τ ) : h −→ h , τ > 0 , (2.2) τ where Ih is the identity operator in the subspace h. In the following for an operator X in H we use the notation P XP for the operator P XP := P X h : h −→ h as well as for its extension by zero in h⊥ . Let us assume that √ (2.3) dom(T ) := dom( H) ∩ h S(τ ) :=
is dense in h. We define a linear operator T : h −→ H by √ (2.4) T f := Hf, f ∈ dom(T ). √ √ Since H is closed and dom( H) ∩ h is dense the operator T is closed and its domain dom(T ) is dense in h. Then T ∗ T : h −→ h is a self-adjoint operator which is identical with K defined by (1.5), i.e. K := T ∗ T : h −→ h
(2.5)
which defines a non-negative self-adjoint operator in h. Further, let us represent the function φ as φ(x) = ψ(x) − iω(x),
x ∈ [0, ∞),
where ψ, ω : [0, ∞) −→ R are real-valued, Borel measurable functions obeying |ψ(x)| ≤ 1,
ψ (+0) = 0
ψ(0) = 1,
(2.6)
and 0 ≤ ω(x) ≤ 1,
ω(0) = 0,
ω (+0) = 1.
Setting ϕ(x) := 1 − ω(x),
x ∈ [0, ∞),
one has 0 ≤ ϕ(x) ≤ 1,
ϕ(0) = 1,
ϕ (+0) = −1,
(2.7)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
73
which shows that ϕ is a Kato function. In terms of ψ, ϕ the function φ admits the representation φ(x) = ψ(x) − i(1 − ϕ(x)), x ∈ [0, ∞). We set
1, x = 0, inf (1 − ϕ(s))/s, x > 0, and s∈(0,x] 1, x = 0, p+ (x) := sups∈(0,x] (1 − ϕ(s))/s, x > 0.
p− (x) :=
(2.8)
Both functions are bounded on [0, ∞) and obey 0 ≤ p− (x) ≤ 1 ≤ p+ (x) < ∞,
x ∈ [0, ∞).
(2.9)
The function p− is decreasing, i.e. p− (x) ≥ p− (y), 0 ≤ x ≤ y, and p+ is increasing, i.e. p− (x) ≤ p− (y), 0 ≤ x ≤ y. We define the sesquilinear forms √ √ √ k− f, g ∈ dom(k− τ ≥ 0, τ (f, g) := (p− (τ H) Hf, Hg), τ ) := dom( H) ∩ h, and
√ √ k+ τ (f, g) := (p+ (τ H) Hf, Hg),
√ f, g ∈ dom(k+ τ ) := dom( H) ∩ h,
τ ≥ 0.
+ Notice that for τ = 0 one has k− 0 = k0 = k where the sesquilinear form k is defined ± by (1.5). Obviously, both forms kτ are non-negative for each τ ≥ 0. Moreover, the form k− τ is closable for each τ > 0 and its closure is a bounded form on h while ± the form k+ τ is already closed for each τ ≥ 0. By Kτ we denote the associated non-negative self-adjoint operators on h. We note that K0± = K. By (2.9) we get + k− τ (f, f ) ≤ k(f, f ) ≤ kτ (f, f ),
+ f ∈ dom(k− τ ) = dom(k) = dom(kτ ),
τ ≥ 0,
which yields Kτ− ≤ K ≤ Kτ+ ,
τ ≥ 0.
{Kτ− }τ ≥0
Since p− is decreasing the family is increasing as τ ↓ 0. Further, from (2.8) one gets that s-limτ →+0 p− (τ H) = IH . Since k− τ ≤ k and √ √ lim k− f, g ∈ dom(k− τ (f, g) = lim (p− (τ H) Hf, Hg) = k(f, g), τ ) = dom(k), τ →+0
τ →+0
we obtain from Theorem VIII.3.13 of [15] that s- lim (Ih + Kτ− )−1 = (Ih + K)−1 . τ →+0
(2.10)
Further, since p+ is increasing the family {Kτ+ }τ ≥0 is decreasing as τ ↓ 0. By s-limτ →+0 p+ (τ H) = IH we find √ √ lim k+ f, g ∈ dom(k+ τ (f, g) = lim (p+ (τ H) Hf, Hg) = k(f, g), τ ) = dom(k). τ →+0
τ →+0
Since k is closed we obtain from Theorem VIII.3.11 of [15] that s- lim (Ih + Kτ+ )−1 = (Ih + K)−1 . τ →+0
(2.11)
74
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
Lemma 4. Let {X(τ )}τ >0 , {Y (τ )}τ >0 , and {A(τ )}τ >0 be families of bounded nonnegative self-adjoint operators in h such that the condition 0 ≤ X(τ ) ≤ A(τ ) ≤ Y (τ ) ,
τ > 0,
is satisfied. If s − limτ →0 X(τ ) = s − limτ →0 Y (τ ) = A, where A is a bounded self-adjoint operator in h, then s−limτ →0 A(τ ) = A. Proof. Since for each f ∈ h we have (X(τ )f, f ) ≤ (A(τ )f, f ) ≤ (Y (τ )f, f ) ,
τ > 0,
we get limτ →0 (A(τ )f, f ) = (Af, f ), f ∈ h, or w−limτ →0 A(τ ) = A. Hence w − lim (Y (τ ) − A(τ )) = 0. τ →0
Since Y (τ ) − A(τ ) ≥ 0, τ > 0, we find s-lim (Y (τ ) − A(τ ))1/2 = 0 τ →0
which yields s-limτ →0 (Y (τ ) − A(τ )) = 0. Hence s-limτ →0 A(τ ) = A. From (2.2) we obtain 1 1 S(τ ) = P (IH − ψ(τ H))P + i P (IH − ϕ(τ H))P, τ τ
τ > 0.
(2.12)
Let
1 P (IH − ϕ(τ H))P : h −→ h, τ > 0. (2.13) τ Lemma 5. Let H be a non-negative self-adjoint operator in H and let h be a closed √ subspace of H. If dom( H) ∩ h is dense in h and ϕ is a Kato function, then we have s-lim (Ih + L0 (τ ))−1 = (Ih + K)−1 (2.14) L0 (τ ) :=
τ →0
Proof. Since k− τ (f, f )
≤
IH − ϕ(τ H) f, f τ
we find Kτ− ≤ P Hence X(τ ) := (Ih + Kτ+ )−1 ≤
≤ k+ τ (f, f ),
√ f ∈ dom( H) ∩ h,
IH − ϕ(τ H) P ≤ Kτ+ , τ
Ih + P
IH − ϕ(τ H) P τ
−1
τ > 0.
≤ (Ih + Kτ− )−1 =: Y (τ ),
τ > 0. Taking into account (2.10),(2.11) and applying Lemma 4 we prove (2.14). We set L(τ ) :=
1 1 P (I − ψ(τ H))P + P (I − ϕ(τ H))P : h −→ h, τ τ
τ > 0.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
75
Lemma 6. Let H be a non-negative self-adjoint operator in H and let h be a closed √ subspace of H. If dom( H) ∩ h is dense in h, the real-valued Borel measurable function ψ obeys (2.6) and ϕ is a Kato function, then s-lim (Ih + L(τ ))−1 = (Ih + K)−1 . τ →0
(2.15)
Proof. Let ψ(2x) + ϕ(2x) , x ∈ [0, ∞). 2 Notice that ζ is a Kato function. Setting
0 (τ ) := 1 P (IH − ζ(τ H))P, τ > 0, L τ
0 (τ ))−1 = (Ih + K)−1 . By we obtain from Lemma 5 that s-limτ →0 = (Ih + L
L(2τ ) = L0 (τ ) we prove (2.15). ζ(x) :=
We set I − ψ(τ H) P (Ih + L0 (τ ))−1/2 , τ > 0. τ Lemma 7. Let H be a non-negative self-adjoint operator in H and let h be a closed √ subspace of H. If dom( H) ∩ h is dense in h, the real-valued, Borel measurable functions ψ obeys (2.6) and ϕ is a Kato function, then we have M (τ ) := (Ih + L0 (τ ))−1/2 P
s-lim (Ih + M (τ ))
−1
τ →0
= Ih .
(2.16)
Proof. A straightforward computation proves the representation (Ih + L(τ ))−1 = (Ih + L0 (τ ))−1/2 (Ih + M (τ ))
−1
(Ih + L0 (τ ))−1/2 ,
τ > 0.
By (2.14) and (2.15) we get w − lim (Ih + M (τ ))−1 = Ih τ →0
which yields
1/2 −1 s-lim Ih − (Ih + M (τ )) = 0. τ →0
−1 =0 s-lim Ih − (Ih + M (τ ))
Hence
τ →0
which proves (2.16). From (2.16) one gets s-lim (iIh + M (τ )) τ →0
−1
= −iIh .
Hence s-lim (Ih + L0 (τ ))−1/2 (iIh + M (τ )) τ →0
or
−1
(Ih + L0 (τ ))−1/2 = −i(Ih + K)−1 .
−1 1 = (iIh + iK)−1 . s-lim iIh + P (Ih − ψ(τ H))P + iL0 (τ ) τ →0 τ
76
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
Using (2.12) and(2.13) we obtain s-lim (iIh + S(τ ))−1 = (iIh + iK)−1 τ →0
which yields s-lim (Ih + S(τ ))−1 = (Ih + iK)−1 τ →0
We finish the proof of Theorem 2 applying Chernoff’s theorem [5] or Lemma 3.29 of [7].
3. Arbitrary admissible functions Theorem 2 needs the additional assumption (1.9) and it is unclear whether this assumption can be dropped. In the following √ we are going to show that under stronger assumptions on the domain of H the condition (1.9) is indeed not necessary. Theorem 8. Let H be a non-negative self-adjoint operator on H and let h be a closed subspace of H√such that P : H −→ h is the orthogonal projection from H onto h. If h ⊆ dom( H) and φ is admissible, then s- lim (P φ(tH/n)P )n = e−itK
(3.1)
n→∞
uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ] for any t0 > 0 where K is defined by (1.5). √ √ Proof. We note that h ⊆ dom( H) implies that T = HP is a bounded operator, and consequently, K = T ∗ T is also bounded. We may employ the representation √ √ IH − φ(τ H) f, g = p(τ H) Hf, Hg , τ > 0, (3.2) τ √ for f ∈ dom(H) and g ∈ dom( H) where i, x=0 p(x) := . (1 − φ(x))/x, x > 0 Since Cp := supx∈[0,∞) |p(x)| < ∞ by (1.7) one gets p(τ H) B(H) ≤ Cp , τ > 0. √ Hence the equality (3.2) extends to f, g ∈ dom( H), in particular, to f, g ∈ h. This leads to the representation (Ih − F (τ ))f = T ∗ p(τ H)T f ,
τ > 0,
f ∈ h,
(3.3)
or S(τ )f − iKf = T ∗ (p(τ H) − iIH ) T f ,
τ > 0,
f ∈ h.
(3.4)
By assumption (1.7) we find s-limτ →0 p(τ H) = iIH which yields s-limτ →0 S(τ ) = iK. In this way we obtain the relation s-lim (Ih + S(τ ))−1 = (Ih + iK)−1 , τ →0
and using Chernoff’s theorem [5] one more time we have proved (3.1).
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
77
It turns out that the convergence (3.1) can be improved to operator-norm convergence under some stronger assumption. Corollary 9. Let the assumptions of Theorem 8 be satisfied. One has n lim (P φ(tH/n)P ) − e−itK B(h) = 0 n→∞
(3.5)
uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ] for any t0 > 0 if in addition (i) the operator T is compact or √ (ii) there is α > 0 such that h ⊆ dom( H 1+α ) and Cα := supx∈(0,∞) |pα (x)| < ∞ where 0, x=0 pα (x) := . (p(x) − i)/xα , x > 0 Proof. From (3.4) and the compactness of T we find lim S(τ ) − iK B(h) = 0.
(3.6)
τ →0
√ √ If h ⊆ dom( H 1+α ) for some α > 0, then we set Tα := H 1+α P and Kα = Tα∗ Tα . Notice that Tα is a bounded operator. From (3.4) we obtain the representation S(τ ) − iK = τ α Tα∗ pα (τ H) Tα ,
τ > 0.
Hence we find the estimate S(τ ) − iK B(h) ≤ τ α Cα Kα B(h) ,
τ > 0,
which yields (3.6). Using the representation t −itK −tS(t/n) e −e = e−(t−s)S(t/n) (S(t/n) − iK)e−isK ds 0
we get the estimate −itK − e−tS(t/n) e
B(h)
Using (3.6) we find
≤ t S(t/n) − iK B(h) ,
lim e−tS(t/n) − e−itK
n→∞
B(h)
t ≥ 0.
=0
(3.7)
holds for any t > 0, uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ]. We shall combine it with the telescopic estimate F (t/n)n − e−itK ≤ (3.8) B(h) ≤ F (t/n)n − e−tS(t/n) + e−tS(t/n) − e−itK , B(h)
B(h)
where the first term can be treated as in Lemma 2 of [4], see also [7, Lemma 3.27], √ (3.9) F (t/n)n − e−tS(t/n) f ≤ n (F (t/n) − Ih ) f , f ∈ h .
78
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
Using the representation (3.3) with τ = t/n, we can estimate the right-hand side of (3.9) by t (F (t/n) − Ih ) f ≤ T ∗ p(tH/n)T f , f ∈ h , t > 0 . n Since p(τ H) B(H) ≤ Cp , τ > 0, we find t (F (t/n) − Ih ) f ≤ Cp K B(h) f , f ∈ h . n Inserting this estimate into (3.9) we obtain t ≤ Cp √ K B(h) F (t/n)n − e−tS(t/n) n B(h) which yields lim F (t/n)n − e−tS(t/n) =0 (3.10) n→∞
B(h)
for any t > 0, uniformly in t ∈ [0, t0 ]. Taking into account (3.7), (3.8) and (3.10) we arrive at the sought relation (3.5). Remark 10. Since φ(x) = e−ix , x ∈ [0, ∞), √ is admissible we get from Theorem 8 that under the assumptions h ⊆ dom( H) the original √ Zeno product formula (1.13)√holds and that under the stronger assumptions HP is compact or h ⊆ dom( H 1+α ), α > 0, the original Zeno product formula (1.13) converges in the operator norm. √ Remark 11. Obviously, the conclusion (3.5) is valid if h ⊆ dom( H) and h is a finite dimensional subspace. Indeed, in this case the operator T is finite dimensional, and therefore compact. This gives an alternative proof of the result derived in Section 5 of [9] for the case φ(x) = e−ix . Remark 12. In connection with the previous remark let us mention that in the finite-dimensional case there is one more way to prove the claim suggested by G.M. Graf and A. Guekos [13] for the special case φ(x) = e−ix . The argument is based on the observation that lim t−1 P e−itH P − P e−itK P =0 (3.11) t→0
B(h)
implies (P e−itH/n P )n − e−itK B(h) = n o(t/n) as n → ∞ by means of a natural telescopic estimate. To establish (3.11) one first proves that
√ √ t−1 (f, P e−itH P g) − (f, g) − it( HP f, HP g) −→ 0 √ as t → 0 for all f, g from dom( HP ) which coincides in this case with h by assumption. The last expression is equal to −itH √ √ e −I −i HP f, HP g tH and the square bracket tends to zero strongly by the functional calculus, which yields the sought conclusion. We note that the operator in the square brackets is
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
79
well-defined by the functional calculus even if H is not invertible. In the same way we find that
√ √ t−1 (f, P e−itK P g) − (f, g) − it( Kf, Kg) −→ 0 √ √ holds as √ t → 0 for any vectors f, g ∈ h. Next we note that ( Kf, Kg) = √ ( HP f, HP g), and consequently, the expression contained in (3.11) tends to zero weakly as t → 0, however, in a finite dimensional h the weak and operatornorm topologies are equivalent. Conjecture 13. Comparing the results of the present paper with those ones of [9] we conjecture that if we drop the assumption (1.9) in Theorem 2, then at least the convergence T (φ(tH/n))n f − e−itK f 2 dt = 0 lim (3.12) n→∞
0
holds for for each f ∈ h, T > 0 and arbitrary admissible functions φ. The proofs of [9] rely heavily on the analytic properties of the exponential function φ(x) = e−ix . For admissible functions analytic properties are not required which yields the necessity to look for a different proof idea.
References [1] A. Arias, S. Gudder, Almost sharp quantum effects J. Math. Phys. 45 (2004), 41964206. [2] J. Beskow, J. Nilsson, The concept of wave function and the irreducible representations of the Poincar´e group, II. Unstable systems and the exponential decay law Arkiv Fys. 34 (1967), 561-569. [3] V. Cachia, On a product formula for unitary groups Bull. London Math. Soc. 37 (2005), no. 4, 621-626. [4] P. R. Chernoff, Note on product formulas for operator semigroups J. Funct. Anal. 2 (1968), 238-242. [5] P. R. Chernoff, Product Formulas, Nonlinear Semigroups and Addition of Unbounded Operators Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 140, Providence R.I, 1974. [6] E. B. Davies, Quantum Theory of Open Systems Academic Press, London, 1976. [7] E. B. Davies, One-Parameter Semigroups London Mathematical Society Monographs, Academic Press, London-New York, 1980. [8] P. Exner, Open Quantum Systems and Feynman Integrals D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, 1985. [9] P. Exner, T. Ichinose, A product formula related to quantum Zeno dynamics Ann. H. Poincar´e 6 (2005), 195-215. [10] P. Facchi, G. Marmo, S. Pascazio, A. Scardicchio, E. C. G. Sudarshan, Zeno’s dynamics and constraints J. Opt. B: Quantum Semiclass. Opt. 6 (2004), S492-S501.
80
Exner, Ichinose, Neidhardt and Zagrebnov
IEOT
[11] B. Sz.-Nagy, C. Foias, Harmonic analysis of operators on Hilbert space North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam-London; American Elsevier Publishing Co., Inc., New York; Akadmiai Kiad, Budapest, 1970. [12] C. Friedman, Semigroup product formulas, compressions, and continual observations in quantum mechanics Indiana Math. J. 21 (1971/72), 1001-1011. [13] G. M. Graf, A. Guekos, private communication. [14] T. Ichinose, A product formula and its application to the Schr¨ odinger equation Publ. RIMS, Kyoto Univ., 15 (1980), 585-600. [15] T. Kato, Perturbation Theory for Linear Operators Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York, 1966. [16] T. Kato, On the Trotter-Lie product formula Proc. Japan Acad. 50 (1974), 694–698. [17] T. Kato, Trotter’s product formula for an arbitrary pair of self-adjoint contraction semigroups Topics in functional analysis, Adv. in Math. Suppl. Stud., vol. 3, Academic Press, New York-London, 1978. [18] M. L. Lapidus, Generalization of the Trotter-Lie formula Int. Eq. Operator Theory 4 (1981), 366-415. [19] M. L. Lapidus, Product formula for imaginary resolvents with application to a modified Feynman integral J. Funct. Anal. 63 (1985), 261-275. [20] M. Matolcsi, R. Shvidkoy, Trotter’s product formula for projections Arch. Math. 81 (2003), 309-317. [21] B. Misra, E. C. G. Sudarshan, The Zeno’s paradox in quantum theory J. Math. Phys. 18 (1977), 756-763. [22] A. U. Schmidt, Mathematics of the quantum Zeno effect in Mathematical Physics Research on the Leading Edge, Ch. Benton ed., Nova Science Publ., Hauppauge NY, 2004; pp. 113-143. [23] H. F. Trotter, Approximation of semi-groups of operators Pacific J. Math. 8 (1958), 887–919. [24] H. F. Trotter, On the product of semi-groups of operators Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 10 (1959), 545–551. [25] V. A. Zagrebnov, Topics in the Theory of Gibbs Semigroups Leuven Notes in Mathematical and Theoretical Physics, vol. 10, Series A: Mathematical Physics; Leuven Univ. Press, 2003.
Acknowledgement This work was supported by Czech Academy of Sciences within the project K1010104 and the ASCR-CNRS exchange program, and by Ministry of Education of the Czech Republic within the project LC06002 and the French-Czech CNRS bilateral project. V. Z. and H. N. thanks the Department of Theoretical Physics ˇ z for hospitably and financial support. of the Czech Academy of Sciences in Reˇ P. E. and H. N. are grateful to the Universit´e de la M´editerran´ee and Centre de Physique Th´eorique-CNRS-Luminy, Marseille (France), for hospitality extended to them and financial support. V. Z. is also thankful the Weierstrass-Institut of
Vol. 57 (2007)
Zeno Product Formula
81
Berlin for hospitality and financial support in 2005 when the paper reached its final form. Pavel Exner Department of Theoretical Physics, NPI ˇ z Academy of Sciences, CZ-25068 Reˇ and Doppler Institute, Czech Technical University Bˇrehov´ a 7, CZ-11519 Prague Czech Republic e-mail:
[email protected] Takashi Ichinose Department of Mathematics Faculty of Science Kanazawa University Kanazawa 920-1192 Japan e-mail:
[email protected] Hagen Neidhardt WIAS Berlin Mohrenstr. 39 D-10117 Berlin Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Valentin A. Zagrebnov D´epartment de Physique Universit´e de la M´editerran´ee (Aix-Marseille II) and Centre de Physique Th´eorique Luminy, Case 907 F-13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: September 1, 2005 Revised: February 15, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 83–99 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010083-17, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1447-z
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Bivariate Function Spaces and the Embedding of Their Marginal Spaces J.J. Grobler Abstract. For a probability space (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) we denote the marginal measures of P, defined on Σ and Λ respectively, by P1 and P2 . If ρ is a function norm defined on L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P), marginal function norms ρ1 and ρ2 are defined on L0 (X, Σ, P1 ) and L0 (Y, Λ, P2 ). We find conditions which guarantee Lρ1 +Lρ2 to be embedded in Lρ as a closed subspace. The problem is encountered in Statistics when estimating a bivariate distribution with known marginals. We find a condition which, applied to the binormal distribution in L2 , improves some known conditions. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 46E30, 47G10, 47B34, 47B38; Secondary 47B80, 62H12. Keywords. Function spaces, bivariate distribution, marginal measures, marginal distributions, kernel operator, Hilbert-Schmidt operator, Hille-Tamarkin operator.
1. Introduction P.J. Bickel, Y. Ritov and J.A. Wellner [3] and H. Peng, A. Schick [9] considered a probability space (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P), and studied the question of estimating P from its marginals P1 and P2 , the latter defined by P1 (A) := P(A × Y ) for all A ∈ Σ and P2 (B) := P(X × B) for all B ∈ Λ. The marginal spaces L2 (X, Σ, P1 ) and L2 (Y, Λ, P2 ) embed into L2 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) via the natural embeddings g(x) → g(x)1Y (y) and h(y) → 1X (x)h(y). A question The author thanks B. de Pagter and J. Conradie for discussions about the problem and for their helpful remarks. He is also grateful to G. Buskes for his invitation to spend the fall semester of 2003 at the University of Mississippi at Oxford, USA.
84
Grobler
IEOT
raised by H. Peng (private communication) is to find conditions which guarantee L2 (X, Σ, P1 ) + L2 (Y, Λ, P2 ) to be a closed subset of L2 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). This question is related to a classical problem studied in Hilbert space, namely, to find the projection of a Hilbert space H onto the closure of the sum of two closed subspaces Hi (the alternating projection algorithm), see [3]. The basic result there was proven by J. Von Neumann [13] and [14] with contributions by N. Aronszajn [1], H. Nakano [8] and N. Wiener [15]. Our approach will be different and will hold in general Banach function spaces (for a definition and properties of Banach function spaces the reader is referred to A.C. Zaanen [17] and W.A.J. Luxemburg and A.C. Zaanen [7]). We will base our arguments on the fact that the projections onto the closed subspaces are conditional expectations. For a Banach function space of bivariate functions we define marginal spaces and marginal norms and show that the associate norms of Fatou marginal norms are again marginal if and only if the conditional expectations are contractive projections onto the marginal spaces. We then state a sufficient condition for the sum of two marginal spaces to be a closed subspace of the given function space. We derive that the condition used in [3] and in [9], and which is equivalent to the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P1 ⊗ P2 with respect to P to belong to L∞ (P), is also sufficient in the general case. We also prove a more general sufficient condition which, in the Lp -case, states that the kernel of a composite conditional expectation operator should be Hille-Tamarkin (Hilbert-Schmidt if p = 2). This kernel is a product of Radon-Nikodym derivatives of P1 ⊗ P2 with respect to P and of P with respect to P1 ⊗ P2 . As in [3] and [9] we therefore assume P and P1 ⊗ P2 to be equivalent measures. In the final section we consider the case in which the density functions of the measures are known and show that the condition used in [3] and in [9] is never satisfied by the binormal distribution whereas the improved condition is satisfied for certain values of the correlation coefficient.
2. Preliminaries Let (X, Σ) and (Y, Λ) be measurable spaces and consider the probability space (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). The marginal measures P1 and P2 of P are defined on (X, Σ) and (Y, Λ) respectively by P1 (A) := P(A × Y ), A ∈ Σ
and
P2 (B) := P(X × B), B ∈ Λ.
We denote by M + (X×Y, Σ⊗Λ, P) the set of all equivalence classes of P-almost everywhere non-negative P-measurable functions and by L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) the vector space of all equivalence classes of P-almost everywhere finite P-measurable functions. Let ρ be a function norm defined on M + (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) and denote the function space Lρ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) by Lρ (see [17, Chapter 15]). If we consider the lattice isomorhisms φ : g(x) → g(x)1Y (y) and ψ : h(y) → 1X (x)h(y) from M + (X, Σ, P1 ) and M + (Y, Λ, P2 ) into M + (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P), we define function
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
85
norms on M + (X, Σ, P1 ) and M + (Y, Λ, P2 ) by putting ρ1 (f ) = ρ(φ(f )),
f ∈ M + (X, Σ, P1 )
ρ2 (g) = ρ(ψ(g)),
g ∈ M + (Y, Λ, P2 ).
We call the norms ρi the marginal norms of ρ and the spaces Lρ1 (X, Σ, P1 ) = Lρ1 and Lρ2 (Y, Λ, P2 ) = Lρ2 the marginal spaces of Lρ . Lemma 2.1. If Lρ is a Banach function space, then the marginal spaces Lρ1 (P1 ) and Lρ2 (P2 ) are also Banach function spaces. Proof. It is easy to check that the lattice isomorphisms φ and ψ are order continuous and that the norms ρ1 and ρ2 are function norms. ∞ To check the comsuch that pleteness, let (uk ) be a sequence in L+ ρ k=1 ρ1 (uk ) < ∞. Then 1 ∞ ρ(φ(u )) < ∞ and since L is complete we have by the Riesz-Fischer propk ρ k=1 n erty that φ(s ) = φ(u ) ↑ s ∈ L (see [17, Ch. 15, section 64, Theorem 2]). n k ρ k=1 n But sn := k=1 uk ↑ s in M + (X, Σ, P1 ) and the order continuity of φ implies that φ(sn ) =
n
φ(uk ) ↑ φ(s).
k=1
This shows that s = φ(s) and so ρ1 (s) = ρ(φ(s)) = ρ(s ) < ∞. The function norm ρ1 therefore has the Riesz-Fischer property and so Lρ1 is complete. Similarly, Lρ2 is complete. It follows that φ and ψ are isometric lattice isomorphisms of Lρ1 and Lρ2 ρi onto closed Riesz subspaces of Lρ . We shall denote these isometric images by L for i = 1, 2 and the induced norm on them by ρi respectively. If Lρ does not contain any non-zero function of the form φ(f ) or ψ(g), then Lρi = {0}. However, if L∞ ⊂ Lρ then also L∞ ⊂ Lρi for i = 1, 2. We tacitly assume throughout the paper that L∞ ⊂ Lρ , i.e., Lρ and therefore also the marginal spaces Lρ1 and Lρ2 contain the constant functions. := Σ × Y := We note that P1 is the restriction of P to the sub-σ-algebra Σ {A × Y : A ∈ Σ} of Σ and, similarly, P2 is the restriction of P to the sub-σ-algebra := X × Λ := {X × B : B ∈ Λ} of Σ × Λ. The maps φ and ψ are exactly mapping Λ the Σ-measurable functions onto the Σ-measurable functions and similarly for ψ. We state the following simple remark as a lemma. Lemma 2.2. For the P-integrable, Σ-measurable function f (x)1Y (y) we have f (x)1Y (y) dP = f (x) dP1 . X×Y
X
A similar formula holds for a Λ-measurable function.
86
Grobler
IEOT
n Then, Proof. Let f (x) = i=1αni 1Ai (x) be a step function. n f (x)1 (y) dP = α P(A × Y ) = α P Y i i=1 i i=1 i 1 (Ai ) = X f (x) dP1 . This X×Y shows that the result holds as stated. Let (Ω, F, P) be an arbitrary probability space and let G be a sub-σ-algebra of F. For f ∈ L1 (Ω, F, P), we denote by EP (f | G) the (P-a.e.) unique G-measurable function with the property that EP (f | G) dP = f dP for all A ∈ G. A
A
The existence of EP (f | G) is a consequence of the Radon-Nikodym theorem. The function EP (f | G) is called the conditional expectation of f with respect to G. If f ∈ L1 (Ω, F, P) and g ∈ L∞ (Ω, G, P), then EP (gf | G) = gEP (f | G). For a proof, and also for properties of EP (· | G) used without proof in this paper, we refer to [4], [12] and [5]. The conditional expectation EP (· | G) can be extended from a mapping of 1 L (Ω, F, P) into itself, to a mapping from M + (Ω, F, P) into itself. However, easy examples show that the extended map does not map L0 (Ω, F, P)+ into itself (see [5]). Hence we define dom EP (· | G) of EP (· | G) by dom EP (· | G) := {f ∈ L0 (Ω, F, P) : EP (|f | | G) ∈ L0 (Ω, G, P)}. Clearly, dom EP (· | G) is an ideal in L0 (Ω, F, P) which contains L1 (Ω, F, P) and is therefore order dense in L0 (Ω, F, P). For f ∈ dom EP (· | G), we define: EP (f | G) := EP (f + | G) − EP (f − | G). This defines a positive linear operator EP (· | G) : dom EP (· | G) → L0 (Ω, G, P) ⊂ L0 (Ω, F, P). Although the conditional expectation does not automatically map L0 (Ω, F, P) into itself, we have the result that if EP (|f | | G) ∈ L0 (Ω, G, P), then f ∈ L0 (Ω, F, P) (see [5, Proposition 2.3]). We need to consider the conditional expectation as a positive operator defined on Lρ = Lρ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) and therefore Lρ has to be contained in dom EP (· , Σ) P A condition which guarantees this is expressed in terms of the and dom E (· , Λ). associate norm of the function norm ρ. The associate norm ρ of a function norm ρ is defined by ρ (g) = sup{ |f g| dP : ρ(f ) ≤ 1}. X×Y
The associate norm is a Fatou function norm (see [17]) and gives rise to the Banach function space Lρ = Lρ which is called the associate space of Lρ . In the case under consideration we note that ρi ≤ (ρ )i . We call the function norm ρ defined on L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) fully marginal if ρi = (ρ )i , i = 1, 2.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
87
Proposition 2.3. Let ρ be a Fatou function norm. Then the conditional expectation is a contractive projection of Lρ onto L ρ1 if and only if for all g ∈ Lρ EP (f |Σ) 1 we have φ(g) ∈ Lρ and ρ1 (g) = ρ (φ(g)). A similar condition is necessary and to be a contractive projection of Lρ onto L ρ2 . In particular, sufficient for EP (f |Λ) the function norm ρ is fully marginal if and only if both the conditional expectations above are contractive projections. and Proof. Let f ∈ Lρ , and let ρ (φ(g)) = ρ1 (g). We show that f ∈ dom EP (· | Σ) P −1 P ≤ ρ(f ). For this it is sufficient to show that φ E (|f | |Σ) ∈ Lρ1 that ρ(E (|f | | Σ)) −1 P with ρ1 (φ E (|f | |Σ)) ≤ ρ(f ). Since ρ is a Fatou-norm, the same holds for ρ1 as can easily be checked. Hence, by Lemma 2.2, −1 P dP1 = ρ1 (φ E (|f | |Σ)) = sup |gφ−1 EP (|f | |Σ)| ρ1 (g)≤1
= sup
ρ1 (g)≤1
X×Y
X
|φ(g)|EP (|f | |Σ)dP = sup
ρ1 (g)≤1
= sup
ρ1 (g)≤1
X×Y
X×Y
EP (|φ(g)f | |Σ)dP =
|φ(g)f | |dP ≤ sup ρ (φ(g))ρ(f ) ≤ ρ(f ). ρ1 (g)≤1
Hence, if the condition holds, the conditional expectation is a contractive projec ρ1 . tion onto L Conversely, assume that the conditional expectation is a contractive projection defined on Lρ and let g ∈ Lρ1 . Then, for any f ∈ Lρ with ρ(f ) ≤ 1, |φ(g)f |dP = |g(x)f (x, y)|dP = X×Y X×Y dP = dP ≤ = EP (|g(x)f (x, y)| | Σ) |g(x)| EP (|f (x, y)| | Σ) X×Y
X×Y
≤ ρ1 (φ(g))ρ(f ) ≤ ρ1 (φ(g)). ρ1 (E (|f (x, y)| | Σ)) ≤ ρ1 (φ(g))
P
This shows that φ(g) ∈ Lρ and that ρ (φ(g)) ≤ ρ1 (φ(g)). On the other hand, ρ1 (φ(g)) ≤ ρ (φ(g)) follows from the fact that ρ1 is the restriction of ρ to the ρ1 . closed Riesz subspace L For a Σ ⊗ Λ-measurable function f we shall henceforth denote by EP1 (f ) and and EP (f | Λ). Hence, by EP2 (f ) respectively, the conditional expectations EP (f | Σ) P P E1 and E2 are contractive projections onto Lρ1 and Lρ2 respectively. Example 2.4. Let ρ be the Lp -norm. It follows from Lemma 1.2 that φ(f ) pp = |φ(f )|p dP = φ(|f |p ) dP = |f |p P1 = f pp X×Y
X×Y
X
It follows that the marginal norm ρ1 (f ) = f p and in the same way ρ2 (g) = g p . Hence, in this case Lρ1 = Lp (X, Σ, P1 ) and Lρ2 = Lp (Y, Λ, P2 ). The associate norm
88
Grobler
IEOT
for · p is · q with 1/p + 1/q = 1 and it follows that the conditional expectation p for 1 < p < ∞. It is trivial to see that is a contractive projection of Lp (P) into L it also holds for p = 1, ∞. We say the probability measure P on Σ ⊗ Λ, has a desintegration with respect to each of its marginal measures P1 and P2 if there exist random measures (see [6]) Q1 (x, ·) and Q2 (y, ·) such that for all A ∈ Σ and B ∈ Λ we have P(A × B) =
A
Q1 (x, B) P1 (dx) =
B
Q2 (y, A) P2 (dy).
In that case, we have for every P integrable function f (x, y) f dP = f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy)P1 (dx) = f (x, y)Q2 (y, dx)P2 (dy). X×Y
X
Y
Y
X
Note that for almost every x and y the random measures Q1 (x, ·) and Q2 (y, ·) are probability measures; for example, if A ∈ Σ we have 1(x) P1 (dx) = P1 (A) = P(A × Y ) = Q1 (x, Y )P1 (dx) A
A
and so Q1 (x, Y ) = 1(x) holds P1 -almost everywhere on X and the proof for Q2 is similar. We note the following fact and for the sake of completeness supply the proof. Lemma 2.5. If the measure P has desintegrations Q1 and Q2 then P P E1 (f ) = f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy) and E2 (f ) = f (x, y)Q2 (y, dx). Y
Hence, the operators (see [6]).
X
EPi ,
i = 1, 2, are operators generated by random measures
and f ∈ Lρ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) a direct calculation using the Proof. For A × Y ∈ Σ fact that Q1 (x, Y ) = 1X (x) holds P1 -almost everywhere, shows that f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy) dP = A×Y Y = f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy) Q1 (x, dη)P1 (dx) = A Y Y = f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy) Q1 (x, dη)P1 (dx) = A Y Y = f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy)P1 (dx) = f (x, y) dP. A
Y
A×Y
This proves the first assertion and the second one follows similarly.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
89
Remark. Note that the setting considered is a special case of a more general one. Suppose that (Ω, F , P) is a probability space and suppose that Fi , i = 1, 2, are sub-σ-algebras of F such that the σ-algebra generated by F1 and F2 equals F . If Pi denote the restriction of P to Fi then (Ω, Fi , Pi ) is again a probability space. If ρ is a function norm on L0 (Ω, F , P) then the restrictions of ρ to the spaces L0 (Ω, Fi , Pi ) yield marginal function spaces and the theory developed above can be extended to this more general case.
3. The main result ρ1 + L ρ2 being closed in Lρ , it is necessary to In order to study the problem of L know when a function of two variables can be written as a sum of two functions, each of which is a function of one variable. For the next simple observation, which plays a crucial role in the solution to our problem, the author is indebted to B. de Pagter. Lemma 3.1. Let f : X ×Y → R be a numerical function. Then f (x, y) = g(x)+h(y) with g : X → R and h : Y → R if and only if f (x, y) + f (ξ, η) = f (ξ, y) + f (x, η) for all (x, y),(ξ, η) ∈ X × Y . Proof. Let f (x, y) = g(x) + h(y); then, by rearranging the terms, f (x, y) + f (ξ, η) = g(ξ) + h(y) + g(x) + h(η) = f (ξ, y) + f (x, η). Conversely, If the condition holds, we can write f (x, y) = f (x, η) + f (ξ, y) − f (ξ, η). Taking ξ and η fixed, this is the required decomposition of f.
The immediate result following from this remark is: Corollary 3.2. If the sequence (fn (x, y))∞ n=1 converges pointwise to a function f (x, y) and if, for each n, we have fn (x, y) = gn (x) + hn (y) then there exist functions g(x) and h(y) such that f (x, y) = g(x) + h(y). Our main result depends on having this result available holding P-almost everywhere and this can be proved if P is the product of its marginal measures. Proposition 3.3. Let P = P1 ⊗ P2 be a product measure on X × Y. Let fn , gn , hn be P-almost everywhere finite functions such that fn (x, y) = gn (x) + hn (y) holds P-almost everywhere. If (fn (x, y))∞ n=1 converges pointwise almost everywhere to f (x, y) ∈ L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) then there exist functions g(x) ∈ L0 (X, Σ, P1 ) and h(y) ∈ L0 (Y, Λ, P2 ) such that f (x, y) = g(x) + h(y) holds P-almost everywhere. Proof. By defining fn (x, y), gn (x) and hn (y) to be zero on the common null set we may assume without loss of generality that fn (x, y) = gn (x) + hn (y) holds for all n and for all x and y. Hence, for all x, y, ξ and η, fn (x, y) + fn (ξ, η) = fn (x, η) + fn (ξ, y).
(1)
90
Grobler
IEOT
Let N0 be the null set such that for all (x, y) ∈ / N0we have fn (x, y) → f (x, y) and |f (x, y)| < ∞. By Fubini’s theorem 0 = P(N0 ) = X P2 (N0 (x)) dP1 and it follows that P2 (N0 (x)) = 0 holds for P1 -almost every x. Let N1 ⊂ X be the exceptional set and let ξ ∈ / N1 . Then N0 (ξ) is a P2 -null set such that fn (ξ, y) → f (ξ, y) and |f (ξ, y)| < ∞ for all y ∈ / N0 (ξ). / N2 . Let Similarly, there is a null set N2 ⊂ Y such that P1 (N0 (y)) = 0 for all y ∈ / N2 , we have that N0 (η) is a P1 -null set such that η∈ / N0 (ξ) ∪ N2 . Then, since η ∈ fn (x, η) → f (x, η) and |f (x, η)| < ∞ for all x ∈ / N0 (η). Since we also have that η ∈ / N0 (ξ), it follows that fn (ξ, η) → f (ξ, η) and |f (ξ, η)| < ∞. Therefore, in equality (1), we have for all (x, y) ∈ / N ∪(N0 (η)×Y )∪(X ×N0 (ξ)) that the left hand side converges to f (x, y) + f (ξ, η) and the right hand side converges to f (x, η) + f (ξ, y) and all the functions in the terms are finitely valued. Since this union is a P1 ⊗ P2 null set, we have that f (x, y) + f (ξ, η) = f (x, η) + f (ξ, y) P1 ⊗ P2 -almost everywhere and the proof is complete.
Corollary 3.4. Let P be probability measure on Σ ⊗ Λ with marginal measures P1 and P2 and let P be equivalent to P1 ⊗ P2 . Let fn , gn , hn be P-almost everywhere finite functions such that fn (x, y) = gn (x) + hn (y) holds P-almost everywhere. If 0 (fn (x, y))∞ n=1 converges pointwise almost everywhere to f (x, y) ∈ L (X × Y, Σ ⊗ 0 0 Λ, P) then there exist functions g(x) ∈ L (X, Σ, P1 ) and h(y) ∈ L (Y, Λ, P2 ) such that f (x, y) = g(x) + h(y) holds P-almost everywhere. Proof. Since P and P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent, a property holds P-almost everywhere if and only if it holds P1 ⊗ P2 -almost everywhere. Proposition 3.5. Let f ∈ L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) and suppose that P and P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent measures. If f has a decomposition f (x, y) = g(x) + h(y) which holds P-almost everywhere, then the decomposition is unique up to a constant. Proof. We may assume that P = P1 ⊗ P2 . If g(x) + h(y) = g (x) + h (y) then γ(x) := g(x) − g (x) = h (y) − h(y) =: η(y) holds P-a.e. Let N be the exceptional / N1 . If set and as before P2 (N (x)) = 0 holds for almost every x, say for all x ∈ x0 ∈ N1 we have (x0 , y) ∈ / N for almost every y, i.e., γ(x0 ) = η(y) for almost every y. Hence, η(y) is constant for almost every y. In a similar way γ(x) is constant for almost every x and this proves the assertion of the proposition. Easy examples can be constructed to show that this is false for general measures. Example 3.6. Consider the case of X = Y = [0, 1]. Consider a rectifiable curve of total length 1 in X × Y with equation y = ϕ(x), x ∈ [0, 1]. Let P be a measure defined on the half open intervals R = (a, b]×(c, d] by defining P(R) to be the length of the part of the curve contained in R. Extension to the Borel sets yields a measure
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
91
P which is concentrated on the curve. Let h(y) be any Borel measurable function which is not constant and put g(x) = h(ϕ(x)). Then g(x)1Y (y) = h(y)1X (x) P-almost everywhere and h is not constant. ρ1 + L ρ2 in Lρ in a special case. We now prove the closedness of L ρ1 + L ρ2 is Proposition 3.7. Let P = P1 ⊗ P2 and let ρ be fully marginal. Then L closed in Lρ . ρ1 + L ρ2 which converges to f ∈ Lρ . The Proof. Let fn = gn +hn be a sequence in L sequence then has a subsequence which converges pointwise P-almost everywhere to f and so, by Proposition 3.3 f can be written as g + h with g ∈ L0 (X, Σ, P1 ) = |g|1Y ∈ L0 (X × Y, Σ, P) and so g ∈ and h ∈ L0 (Y, Λ, P2 ). Note that EP (|g| | Σ) P P dom E (· | Σ). Since f ∈ Lρ , we also have f ∈ dom E (· | Σ) which implies that h = It is also easy to check that EP (h | Σ) = ( h(y) dP2 (y))1X . f − g ∈ dom EP (· | Σ). Y We now apply the conditional expectations The same arguments hold for EP (· | Λ). and EP (· | Λ)to both sides of the equation f = g + h and use the fact that EP (· | Σ) it is a contractive projection onto the marginal spaces. This yields ρ1 h(y) dP2 = EP (f ) ∈ L g(x) + Y
and
X
1
ρ2 g(x) dP1 + h(y) = EP2 (f ) ∈ L
and so, using the fact that the marginal spaces contain the constant functions, we ρ2 . ρ1 + L get f = g + h ∈ L For a general measure P the following condition (see [9] and [3]) is used in 2 + L 2 is closed in L2 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) : the L2 -case in order to prove that L For all A ∈ Σ, B ∈ Λ, P(A × B) ≥ γP1 (A)P2 (B), γ > 0.
(CS)
This condition implies that for every positive Σ ⊗ Λ-measurable function f (x, y) we have f (x, y)P(dx, dy) ≥ γ f (x, y)d(P1 ⊗ P2 ). (CS2) X×Y
X×Y
To see this, note that the class of sets for which condition (CS) is true includes the class F of all finite disjoint unions of sets of the form A × B ∈ Σ ⊗ Λ (which is an algebra) and that it is a monotone class. Hence, by Dynkin’s principle (see [2]) it contains the σ-algebra generated by F , which is Σ ⊗ Λ. It follows that P(C) ≥ γP1 ⊗ P2 (C) for all C ∈ Σ ⊗ Λ. But then (CS2) holds for positive step functions and the claim follows.
92
Grobler
IEOT
Condition (CS) thus implies that the measure P1 ⊗ P2 is P-absolutely continuous. If r(x, y) is the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P1 ⊗ P2 relative to P we have for all C ∈ Σ ⊗ Λ that P1 ⊗ P2 (C) = and so
r(x, y)dP C
γ C
So, for all C ∈ Σ ⊗ Λ,
r(x, y)dP = γP1 ⊗ P2 (C) ≤
dP C
C
(1 − γr)dP ≥ 0
This shows that condition (CS) implies that the Radon-Nikodym derivative r is an element of L∞ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) and r ∞ ≤ 1/γ. If the function r is strictly positive, the measures P and P1 ⊗P2 are equivalent. Let r (x, y) := 1/r(x, y) if r(x, y) = 0 and r (x, y) := 0 if r(x, y) = 0. Then r (x, y) derivative of P with respect to P1 ⊗ P2 , i.e., C f (x, y)dP = is the Radon-Nikodym f (x, y)r (x, y)d(P ⊗ P2 ). In this case we have, for every Σ ⊗ Λ-measurable set 1 C of the form A × B that r (x, y) dP2 (y) dP1 (x) P(A × B) = A
B
showing that P has the desintegration Q1 (x, B) = B r (x, y) dP2 (y) and by Fubini it also follows that Q2 (y, A) = A r (x, y) dP1 (x). By Lemma 2.5 it therefore follows that = EP (f | Σ) f (x, y)Q1 (x, dy) = f (x, y)r (x, y) dP2 (y) = EP1 ⊗P2 (r f | Σ) Y
and similarly = EP (f | Λ)
Y
X
f (x, y)Q2 (y, dx) =
X
f (x, y)r (x, y) dP1 (x) = EP1 ⊗P2 (r f | Λ).
Letting g = r f, we deduce that, in terms of r we get EP1 1 ⊗P2 (g) = EP1 (rg)
and
EP2 1 ⊗P2 (g) = EP2 (rg)
We use these remarks to prove the following theorem which is known in the L2 -case. Theorem 3.8. Let (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) be a probability space with marginal spaces (X, Σ, P1 ) and (Y, Λ, P2 ) and suppose that the measures P and P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent. Suppose moreover that condition (CS) holds, i.e., that there is a γ > 0 such that for all A ∈ Σ, B ∈ Λ we have P(A × B) ≥ γP1 (A)P2 (B) and that ρ is a fully ρ1 + L ρ2 is closed marginal function norm defined on M + (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). Then L in Lρ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P).
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
93
(1) (2) ρ1 + L ρ2 and suppose that (fn ) converges to f ∈ Lρ . Proof. Let fn = fn +fn ∈ L The sequence then has a subsequence which converges P-almost everywhere to f and since the measures P and P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent, the subsequence converges P1 ⊗ P2 -almost everywhere to f. By Corollary 2.4(b) the function f can be decomposed as f = f (1) + f (2) with f (i) almost everywhere finite. We need to prove that ρi for i = 1, 2. f (i) ∈ L Let r be the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P1 ⊗P2 with respect to P and recall that by condition (CS) we have r ∞ ≤ 1/γ < ∞. This implies that multiplication by r is a continuous operator Mr on Lρ and Mr ≤ 1/γ. By our remarks above we have, for i = 1, 2, that
ρi EPi 1 ⊗P2 (|f |) = EPi (r|f |) = EPi (Mr (|f |)) = (EPi ◦ Mr )(|f |) ∈ L ρi . The argument used in Proposition Hence, f ∈ dom(EPi 1 ⊗P2 ) and EPi 1 ⊗P2 (f ) ∈ L (i) 3.5 shows that it follows from this that f ∈ dom(EPi 1 ⊗P2 ) and so we have that EPi 1 ⊗P2 (f ) = EPi 1 ⊗P2 (f (1) + f (2) ) = f (i) + ci with ci ∈ R. It follows that f (i) ∈ ρi . L
Remark. The Lp -norm is fully marginal for all p, 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, and so the above theorem holds for all Lp spaces. Still assuming that P and the product of its marginal measures P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent measures with P = r (P1 ⊗P2 ) and P1 ⊗P2 = rP as before, we investigate which other conditions on these Radon-Nikodym derivatives will guarantee the ρ1 + L ρ2 in Lρ . closedness of L The proof of the preceding theorem provides a clue for a solution of the problem. Essential in the proof above is that EPi 1 ⊗P2 should be defined on Lρ , i.e., that Lρ ⊂ dom EPi 1 ⊗P2 . We have the following result Lemma 3.9. With the Radon-Nikodym derivatives r and r as above, let Q(ξ, η, x, y) =
r(x, y)1Y (η) = r(x, y)r (ξ, y)1Y (η). r(ξ, y)
If the kernel operator with kernel Q maps Lρ into itself, then Lρ ⊂ dom(EP2 1 ⊗P2 ), EP2 1 ⊗P2 (Lρ ) ⊂ dom(EP1 ) and Q is the kernel of the operator EP1 EP2 1 ⊗P2 . Similarly, if R(ξ, η, x, y) =
r(x, y)1X (ξ) = r(x, y)r (x, η)1X (ξ) r(x, η)
is the kernel of an operator which maps Lρ into itself, then Lρ ⊂ dom(EP1 2 ⊗P2 ), EP1 1 ⊗P2 (Lρ ) ⊂ dom(EP2 ) and R is the kernel of the operator EP2 EP1 1 ⊗P2 .
94
Grobler
IEOT
Proof. Let f ∈ Lρ . Then
EP1 (EP2 1 ⊗P2 (|f |))(ξ) = EP1 ( |f (x, y)| dP1 (x))(ξ) X = ( |f (x, y)| dP1 (x))r (ξ, y) dP2 (y) Y X = r (ξ, y)|f (x, y)| d(P1 ⊗ P2 )(x, y) X×Y r (ξ, y) = |f (x, y)| dP(x, y) r (x, y) X×Y r(x, y) ρ1 . = |f (x, y)| dP(x, y) ∈ L r(ξ, y) X×Y
Hence, EP1 (EP2 1 ⊗P2 (|f |)) ∈ L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) which implies by [5, Proposition 2.3] that EP2 1 ⊗P2 (|f |) ∈ L0 (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P), i.e., f ∈ dom EP2 1 ⊗P2 and that EP2 1 ⊗P2 (f ) ∈ dom EP1 . Thus, the operator EP1 EP2 1 ⊗P2 is well defined and maps Lρ into itself. Exactly the same argument holds in the second case. Theorem 3.10. Let (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) be a probability space with marginal spaces (X, Σ, P1 ) and (Y, Λ, P2 ) and suppose that the measures P and P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent. Let r be the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P1 ⊗ P2 with respect to P and r the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P with respect to P1 ⊗ P2 and let ρ be a fully marginal function norm defined on M + (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). If Q(ξ, η, x, y) =
r(x, y)1Y (η) r(ξ, y)
ρ1 + L ρ2 is closed in is the kernel of an operator which maps Lρ into itself, then L Lρ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). The same conclusion holds if R(ξ, η, x, y) =
r(x, y)1X (ξ) = r(x, y)r (x, η)1X (ξ) r(x, η)
is the kernel of an operator which maps Lρ into itself. Proof. We prove the assertion for Q. The assumption implies by the preceding lemma that the operator EP1 EP2 1 ⊗P2 is well defined and maps Lρ into itself and hence into Lρ1 . Again a repitition of the argument used before, yields for a sequence ρ1 + L ρ2 which converges to f ∈ Lρ that f can be written as f (1) (x) + (fn ) ⊂ L f (2) (y) with both terms functions which are almost everywhere finite and the functions f, f (1) and f (2) are all in dom EP1 . It follows that EP1 (f ) = f (1) + EP1 (f (2) ) ρ1 if and only if EP1 (f (2) ) ∈ L ρ1 . But, since and so, since ρ is fully marginal, f (1) ∈ L ρ2 is the decomposition of an element of Lρ into a sum of elements of Lρ1 and L
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
95
unique up to a constant (Proposition 3.5), we can assume that in the decomposition which we consider, f (2) = EP2 1 ⊗P2 (f ). Hence, EP1 (f (2) ) = EP1 (EP2 1 ⊗P2 (f )) ∈ Lρ1 . So f (1) ∈ Lρ1 and it follows that f (2) = f − f (1) ∈ Lρ2 . This completes the proof. A general condition which guarantees that a kernel operator maps Lρ into itself, is that the kernel should be of finite double norm (see [16] or [11]). In this case it means that Q(ξ, η, x, y) ∈ Lρ for fixed (ξ, η) and ρ (Q(ξ, η, x, y)) ∈ Lρ . Noting that Q is only a function of ξ, x and y, it follows that the second of the ρ1 . conditions translates to ρ (Q(ξ, η, x, y)) ∈ L We note this as a corollary. Corollary 3.11. Let (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P) be a probability space with marginal spaces (X, Σ, P1 ) and (Y, Λ, P2 ) and suppose that the measures P and P1 ⊗ P2 are equivalent. Let r be the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P1 ⊗ P2 with respect to P and r the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P with respect to P1 ⊗ P2 and let ρ be a fully marginal function norm defined on M + (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). If Q(ξ, η, x, y) =
r(x, y)1Y (η) r (ξ, y)1Y (η) = r (x, y) r(ξ, y)
ρ1 , then satisfies Q(ξ, η, x, y) ∈ Lρ for fixed (ξ, η) and ρ (Q(ξ, η, x, y)) ∈ L ρ1 + L ρ2 is closed in Lρ (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). L In particular, if for some p, 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, we have p/q |r(x, y)r (ξ, y)|q dP(x, y) dP1 (ξ) < ∞, p−1 + q −1 = 1. X
X×Y
p (P1 ) + L p (P2 ) is closed in Lp (X × Y, Σ ⊗ Λ, P). Then L Remark. 1. The kernel Q satisfying the condition stated here for the case 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞ is also known as a Hille-Tamarkin kernel and in the case of p = 2 as a Hilbert-Schmidt kernel. 2. As remarked earlier, the theorem also holds under the condition which ρ2 . The condition here will be that the kernel guarantees that EP2 (f (1) )(η) ∈ L r (x, η)1X (ξ) is of finite double norm and in the case of Lp space R(ξ, η, x, y) = r (x, y) will translate to p/q |r(x, y)r (x, η)|q dP(x, y) dP2 (η) < ∞, p−1 + q −1 = 1. Y
X×Y
96
Grobler
IEOT
4. Density functions In order to apply the result above we consider the case X = Y = R with the Borel σ-algebra B(R). Suppose that the probability measure P on R2 is defined by the bivariate density function p(x1 , x2 ) with p(x1 , x2 ) > 0 for all x1 and x2 . As is well known and easy to check, the marginal measures Pi , i = 1, 2, then have “marginal densities” ∞ p(x1 , x2 )dxj , j = i. pi (xi ) = −∞
The desintegrations Qi can then be checked to be given by p(x1 , x2 )dx2 Q1 (x1 , B) = B , B ∈ B(R) p1 (x1 ) p(x1 , x2 )dx1 Q2 (x2 , A) = A , A ∈ B(R). p2 (x2 ) From this it follows that the conditional expectations satisfy ∞ f (x1 , x2 )p(x1 , x2 )dxj P Ei (f, B(R)) = −∞ , j = i pi (xi )
and EPi 1 ⊗P2 (f, B(R))
∞
∞
= −∞
−∞
p(ξ, x2 )f (x1 , x2 )dξ dxj , j = i.
Now, since P1 ⊗ P2 has density function p1 (x1 )p2 (x2 ), we have p1 (x1 )p2 (x2 ) dP P1 ⊗ P2 (C) = p1 (x1 )p2 (x2 )dx1 dx2 = p(x1 , x2 ) C C which shows that the Radon-Nikodym derivative r(x1 , x2 ) of P1 ⊗ P2 relative to P satisfies p1 (x1 )p2 (x2 ) . r(x1 , x2 ) = p(x1 , x2 ) Thus the kernel Q(ξ, η, x1 , x2 ) satisfies Q(ξ, η, x1 , x2 ) =
p1 (x1 )p(ξ, x2 ) r(x1 , x2 ) = . r(ξ, x2 ) p1 (ξ)p(x1 , x2 )
For Q to be a Hilbert-Schmidt kernel it should satisfy ∞ ∞ ∞ p1 (x1 )2 p(ξ, x2 )2 dP(x1 , x2 ) dP1 (ξ) 2 2 −∞ −∞ −∞ p1 (ξ) p(x1 , x2 ) ∞ ∞ ∞ p1 (x1 )2 p(ξ, x2 )2 dx1 , dx2 , dξ < ∞. (4.1) = −∞ −∞ −∞ p1 (ξ)p(x1 , x2 ) Example 4.1. The bivariate normal distribution. We consider the simplified bivariate normal density for the Hilbert space case.
1 1 (x21 − 2ρx1 x2 + x22 ) exp − p(x1 , x2 ) = 2 2(1 − ρ ) 2π 1 − ρ2
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
97
for which the marginal densities pi (xi ) (i = 1, 2) are x2
1 pi (xi ) = √ exp − i . 2 2π By (4.1) we have to show that the integral of the function 2
ξ2
1 1 2 2 2 κ exp −x21 − + x ξ + − 2ρξx + x − 2ρx x + x 2 1 2 2 2 1 − ρ2 2 2(1 − ρ2 ) 1 with κ :=
(2π)3/2
1 1 − ρ2
is finite. Using the formula ∞
2
exp(−ax + bx) dx = −∞
π exp a
b2 4a
, a > 0,
we find that the required integral equals 1 − ρ2 1 − 5ρ2 and so the Hilbert-Schmidt norm of the operator equals 1/4 1 − ρ2 . 1 − 5ρ2 The conclusion1 is that the sum of the marginal L2 -spaces is closed in L2 (P) if √ | ρ | < 1/ 5. But, the Radon-Nikodym derivative of P1 ⊗ P2 with respect to P satisfies 2 2 ρ x1 x22 p1 (x1 )p2 (x2 ) ρ 2 = 1 − ρ exp + r(x1 , x2 ) = x1 x2 − p(x1 , x2 ) 1 − ρ2 2 2 1 − ρ2 and so on the line x2 = x1 , r(x1 , x2 ) = r(x1 , x1 ) =
ρ(ρ − 1) 2 1 − ρ2 exp x 1 − ρ2 1
is bounded if and only if 0 ≤ ρ < 1; however, on the line x2 = −x1 this causes r to be unbounded except if ρ = 0. This means that r ∞ = ∞ except in the case that ρ = 0. Hence, the bivariate normal distribution satisfies (CS) only in the trivial case where P = P1 ⊗ P2 . 1 Added
in proof: This was improved by H. Peng and A. Schick [10] who showed that it holds for all |ρ| < 1, a result which is also proved by the author in a fortcoming paper entitled “Bivariate and marginal function spaces”
98
Grobler
IEOT
Example 4.2. The bivariate normal distribution: The Lp -case. In the sequel 1/p + 1/q = 1 In this case we first calculate p1 (x)q p(ξ, y)q dP(x, y) H(ξ) := p1 (ξ)q p(x, y)q and then show that H(ξ)p/q dP1 (ξ) < ∞. It turns out that 1 − ρ2
H(ξ) = exp 1 − ρ2 (q 2 − q + 1)
q(q − 1) ρ2 2 2 1 − ρ (q 2 − q + 1)
ξ2.
Note that the latter integral is convergent (exists) only if 1 − ρ2 (q 2 − q + 1) > 0. This means that it is convergent only if 1 |ρ| < 2 q −q+1 where we also note that q 2 − q + 1 is positive for all q. Hence, H(ξ)p/q dP1 (ξ) ∞ ξ2 1 H(ξ)p/q exp(− ) dξ = √ 2 2π −∞
1/2−p/2q
−1/2 2 p/2q 2 2 = 1−ρ 1 − ρ (q − q + 1) 1 − ρ2 (q 2 + 1) . We note that this is a well defined real number if 1 |ρ| < q2 + 1 The result was derived under the additional condition that 1 |ρ| < q2 − q + 1 which holds automatically if the first inequality holds true, because q 2 − q + 1 ≤ ∞ q 2 + 1. The best result is therefore √ obtained in L , for then q 1= 1 and we get a solution for all ρ with | ρ | < 1/ 2. However, in the case of L , with q = ∞ no ρ = 0 satisfies this condition and no result is obtained. In the case that p = q = 2, the result holds, as seen before, for 1 |ρ| < √ . 5
References [1] N. Aronszajn, Theory of reproducing kernels, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 68 (1950), 337–404.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Bivariate Function Spaces and Their Marginal Spaces
99
[2] R.B. Ash and C.A. Dol´ eans-Dade, Probability and measure theory, Second Edition, Academic Press, San Diego, 2000. [3] P.J. Bickel, Y. Ritov and J.A. Wellner, Efficient estimation of linear functionals of a probability measure P with known marginal distributions Ann. Statist.19 (1991), 1316–1346. [4] J.L. Doob, Measure theory, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, Springer-Verlag, New York, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1994. [5] J.J. Grobler and B. de Pagter, On operators representable as multiplication conditional expectation operators, J. of Operator theory 48 (2002), 15–40. [6] J.J. Grobler, B. de Pagter and D.T. Rambane, Lattice properties of operators defined by random measures, Quaestiones Mathematicae 26 (2003), 307–319. [7] W.A.J. Luxemburg and A.C. Zaanen Notes on Banach function spaces Indag. Math bf 25 (1963), Note I, 135–147; Note II, 148–153; Note III, 239–250; Note IV, 251–263; Note V, 496–504. [8] H. Nakano, Spectral theory in Hilbert space, Japanese Society for the promotion of science, Tokyo, 1953. [9] H. Peng and A. Schick, On efficient estimation of linear functionals of a bivariate distribution with known marginals, Statist. and Prob. Letters 59 (2002), 83–91. [10] H. Peng and A. Schick, Efficient estimation of linear functionals of a bivariate distribution with equal, but unknown marginals: the least squares approach. Journal of Multivariate Analysis 95 (2005), 385-409. [11] H.H. Schaefer, Positive operators, Springer Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, 1974. [12] K.R. Stromberg, Probability for analysts, Chapman and Hall, New York London, 1994. [13] J. von Neumann, On rings of operators. Reduction theory, Ann. of Math. 50 (1949), 401–485. [14] J. von Neumann, Functional operators, Volume II: The geometry of orthogonal spaces, Annals of Mathematics Studies, Volume 22, Princeton University Press, 1950. [15] N. Wiener, On the factorization of matrices, Comment. Math. Helv. 29 (1955), 97–110. [16] A.C. Zaanen, Linear Analysis, North-Holland, Amsterdam, Noordhoff, Groningen, 1964. [17] A.C. Zaanen, Integration, North-Holland, Amsterdam New York, 1967. J.J. Grobler Unit for Business Mathematics and Informatics North-West University Potchefstroom 2520 South Africa e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: August 11, 2005 Revised: June 15, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 101–126 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010101-26, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1450-4
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications Vyacheslav Pivovarchik and Harald Woracek Abstract. We investigate a particular subclass of so-called symmetric indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions and give a characterization of functions of this class in terms of the location of their zeros. For the proof we employ the theory of de Branges Pontryagin spaces of entire functions. We apply our results to obtain information on the eigenvalues of some boundary value problems. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 46E22, 46C20, 65L10; Secondary 30D99, 30D25. Keywords. Hermite-Biehler class, Pontryagin space, de Branges space, boundary value problem.
1. Introduction The Hermite-Biehler class is the set of all entire functions E which have no zeros in the open upper half-plane C+ and satisfy |E(z)| ≤ |E(z)|, z ∈ C+ ,
(1.1)
An indefinite generalization of this notion is obtained when these conditions are substituted by the conditions that E(z) and E # (z) := E(z) have no common nonreal zeros and that the kernel i E # (z) E # (w) S(w, z) := 1− (1.2) z−w E(z) E(w) has a finite number of negative squares. The fact that positive definiteness of the kernel (1.2) coincides with the condition (1.1) is thereby a classical result, cf. [Pi]. Functions of the Hermite-Biehler class appear in several contexts of complex– and functional analysis, see for example [dB], [B] or [L1], and are a classical object of analysis. The origin of this notion goes back to the investigation of polynomials V. Pivovarchik expresses his gratitude to the Vienna University of Technology for hospitality.
102
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
and their zeros, cf. [H]. The various definitions found in the literature often differ in some unessential details; for a comparison see Remark 2.2. In the present note we deal with two subclasses of indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions. The first one is defined by the requirement that the function E satisfies the functional equation E(−z) = E # (z), z ∈ C , (1.3) and we speak of symmetric indefinite Hermite-Biehler function, cf. Definition 2.7. The other one, the class of semibounded indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions, is defined by the requirement that the function A(z) := 12 (E(z) + E # (z)) has only finitely many zeros off the positive real axis, cf. Definition 2.9. These two classes are related via the transformation T : E(z) −→ A(z 2 ) − izB(z 2 ) , i 2 (E(z)
(1.4)
where A(z) := + E (z)) and B(z) := − E (z)), cf. Proposition 2.10. In the main result of this paper we characterize, in terms of the location of their zeros, those symmetric indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions which are Ttransforms of positive definite semibounded Hermite-Biehler functions. It turns out that all zeros in the upper half-plane must be simple, lie on the imaginary axis, and that their location restricts the freedom of zeros on the negative imaginary axis, cf. Theorem 3.1. Our method of proof relies heavily on the theory of symmetric and semibounded de Branges spaces as developed in [KWW3]. For the particular case of polynomials (note that T maps the set of all polynomials onto the set of all polynomials satisfying (1.3)) an analogous characterization was obtained by different methods in [P3]. Our motivation to investigate functions of this particular kind, namely Ttransforms of positive definite semibounded Hermite-Biehler functions, and to study the location of their zeros stems from two sources. First, the classes of semibounded and symmetric indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions readily appeared in several contexts, where also the connection (1.4) between them played a prominent role. For example in the theory of de Branges spaces of entire functions, cf. [dB, Theorems 47,54], [KW2], [KWW3], and in the study of strings and their indefinite generalizations, cf. [KK], [LW], [KWW2]. It turned out in [KWW2] that the Ttransforms of semibounded positive definite Hermite-Biehler functions correspond to what is called a generalized string in [LW]. From the viewpoint of complex analysis it is natural to ask for product representations and distribution as well as location of zeros. Secondly, T-transforms of positive definite semibounded HermiteBiehler functions appear in the study of various boundary value problems and there describe the eigenvalues of the problem. Hence, our results can be employed to describe the location of the eigenvalues of such problems, in particular one obtains information on the eigenvalues lying on the imaginary axis. Knowledge on their location has turned out to be of importance for solving the corresponding inverse problems. In concrete cases results of this type where obtained separately, e.g. in [MP1], [MP2], [Si], [PM] or [MoP]. Let us point out that our aim in the study 1 2 (E(z)
#
#
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
103
of the presently treated boundary value problems was not to obtain new knowledge on their resonances, but to show that the presented general results provide a structural and unified approach to the study of such questions. Let us summarize the contents of the present note. After this introduction, in Section 2, we set up some notation and provide some preliminary results on the mentioned classes of Hermite-Biehler functions. We deal with their product representations and the structure of the generated de Branges spaces of entire functions. Section 3 is devoted to the formulation and proof of our main result, namely Theorem 3.1. Finally, in Section 4, we apply Theorem 3.1 in four concrete cases; the following boundary value problems are investigated: I. The Regge problem: −y + q(x)y = λ2 y , y(0) = 0 ,
y (a) − iλy(a) = 0 . Here λ is the spectral parameter and the potential q is real-valued and belongs to L2 (0, a). This problem occurs in the theory of scattering when the potential is supposed to have finite support. It is certainly the most popular among the boundary value problems we deal with and was well-studied by a variety of authors, see e.g. [R1], [R2], [Kr], [Ko], [S], [Hr], [IP], [Si], [KaKo]. II. The generalized Regge problem, cf. [GP], [PM]: −y + q(x)y = λ2 y , y(0) = 0 ,
y (a) − iαλy(a) + βy(a) = 0 . with α > 0 and β ∈ R. III. Vibrations of a damped string. The problem of small transversal vibrations of a damped smooth inhomogeneous string with fixed left endpoint whose right end carries a point mass able to move with damping in the direction orthogonal to the equilibrium position of the string can be reduced to the following spectral problem, cf. [P2], [MP1], [MP2]: −y − ipλy + q(x)y = λ2 y , y(0) = 0 , y (a) + (β − iαλ − mλ2 )y(a) = 0 . Thereby the coefficient p > 0 is proportional to the damping along the length of the string, α > 0 is proportional to the coefficient of damping of the point mass m > 0 at the right end, and β is a real parameter.
104
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
IV. A fourth order problem which describes small transversal vibrations of an elastic beam, cf. [MoP]: y (4) − (g(x)y ) = λ2 y , y(0) = y (0) = 0 , y(a) = 0 ,
y (a) − iαλy (a) = 0 . Hereby g(x) is a continuously differentiable function describing the distributed stretching or compressing force. The left end of the beam is hinge connected and the right end is hinge connected with damping.
2. Some preliminaries on indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions If Ω ⊆ C is a domain and K(w, z) is a function defined on Ω × Ω, which is analytic in the variables z and w and has the property that K(w, z) = K(z, w), then K is called an analytic symmetric kernel (shortly kernel ) on Ω. Let κ ∈ N ∪ {0}. We say that the kernel K has κ negative squares, if for each choice of n ∈ N and z1 , . . . , zn ∈ Ω the quadratic form QK (ξ1 , . . . , ξn ) :=
n
K(zj , zi )ξi ξj
i,j=1
has at most κ negative squares, and if for some choice of n, z1 , . . . , zn this upper bound is actually attained. Recall that every kernel K with a finite number κ of negative squares on a domain Ω generates a reproducing kernel Pontryagin space P(K) whose elements are analytic function on Ω, cf. [ADRS]. In fact, P(K) is obtained as the Pontryagin space completion of span{K(w, .) : w ∈ Ω} with respect to the inner product given by [K(w, .), K(w , .)] = K(w, w ). In the present note kernels of a particular form play a crucial role. If Θ is a meromorphic function on the open upper half-plane C+ and Ω denotes its domain of holomorphy, define SΘ (w, z) := i
1 − Θ(z)Θ(w) , z, w ∈ Ω . z−w
Clearly, SΘ is a kernel on Ω in the above sense. For a function F , we denote by F # the function F # (z) := F (z). We call F real, if F = F # . Let κ ∈ N ∪ {0}. If E is meromorphic on the whole plane C, we write ind− E = κ in order to express the fact that the kernel S E# | has κ E C+ negative squares. 2.1. Definition. Let κ ∈ N ∪ {0}. The set HB κ of Hermite-Biehler functions with κ negative squares is defined to be the set of all entire functions E which satisfy
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
105
ind− E = κ and are such that E and E # have no common nonreal zeros. Moreover, we define the set of indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions as HB <∞ := HB κ . κ∈N∪{0}
2.2. Remark. The notion of Hermite-Biehler functions appeared frequently in the literature. However, the existing definitions do not completely coincide with each other. We would like to make this more explicit, and to state the relationship with the present Definition 2.1. (i) In the book [L1], one finds the following definitions: An entire function E belongs to HB, if it has no zeros in the closed lower half-plane C− ∪ R and if |E(z)| < |E # (z)|, Im z > 0 . Moreover, E is said to belong to HB, if E has no zeros in the open lower half-plane C− and |E(z)| ≤ |E # (z)|, Im z > 0. (ii) In [B] (originally in [L2]) a class P is defined as the set of all entire functions E of exponential type which have no zeros in C− and satisfy |E(z)| ≤ |E # (z)|, Im z > 0. (iii) In the book [dB] the class of all entire functions is considered which satisfy |E # (z)| < |E(z)|, Im z > 0. (iv) In the series [KWW1]-[KWW3] as well as in [KW1], [KW2], classes of indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions are defined by requiring the conditions of # Definition 2.1 and, additionally, that EE is not constant. The relationships among these various, in their essence equivalent but in their details different, notions can now be formulated as follows. – An entire function E belongs to P as in (ii) if and only if it belongs to HB, as in (i) and is of exponential type. – An entire function belongs to HB as in (i) if and only if it has no real zeros and the function E # (z) possesses the property stated in (iii). Thus (iii) in comparison to (i) allows real zeros and exchanges the roles of upper and lower half-plane. – We have E ∈ HB 0 as in Definition 2.1 if and only if E # ∈ HB. This follows from a classical result of G.Pick, cf. [Pi]. # – We have EE = const if and only if there exists a constant λ ∈ C with |λ| = 1 such that λE is real. Hence the definition mentioned in (iv) differs from Definition 2.1 only by, in our context, somewhat trivial functions. a. Zeros, product representation and limits In order to study the distribution of zeros of entire functions it is practical to use the language of divisors, see e.g. [R]: Put D := d : C → Z : supp d has no accumulation point in C , where supp d denotes the set of all points w where d assumes a nonzero value. To a function F which is meromorphic in the whole plane, there is associated a
106
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
divisor d(F ) which assigns to each point w the multiplicity of w as a zero of F . For example, for the function F (z) := z + 1z we have +1 , w = ±i . d(F )(w) = −1 , w = 0 0 , otherwise Clearly, a meromorphic function F is entire if and only d(F ) ≥ 0. In the particular instance of Hermite-Biehler functions, the following subset of D plays a distinguished role: 1 DHB := d ∈ D, d ≥ 0 : #(supp d ∩ C+ ) < ∞, d(w) Im < ∞ . w w=0
2.3. Remark. (i) The following is an immediate corollary of [KL, Satz 6.4] and basic H ∞ theory, see e.g. [RR]: Let E ∈ HB <∞ . Then E # (z) = γe−iaz B(z) · B1 (z) , E(z) where B is the Blaschke product associated with the zeros of E in the open lower half-plane C− , B1 is the (finite) Blaschke product associated with the zeros of E in C+ , the real number a is the mean type
E# 1 E#
, := lim sup log a = mt E E y→+∞ y and γ = e−2i arg E(0) . Moreover, d(E) ∈ DHB . (ii) We have E ∈ HB <∞ if and only if E can be factorized as E = p · E0 with a function E0 ∈ HB 0 and a polynomial p whose zeros lie in C+ and are different from the conjugates of the zeros of E0 . Thereby ind− E is equal to the number of zeros of p counted according to their multiplicities, i.e. ind− E = d(p)(w) = d(E)(w) . w∈C
w∈C+
(iii) If ind− E1 < ∞ and ind− E2 < ∞, then also ind− (E1 E2 ) < ∞. In fact, the inequality ind− (E1 E2 ) ≤ ind− E1 + ind− E2 (2.1) holds. Moreover, if E1 , E2 , E1 E2 ∈ HB <∞ , then in (2.1) actually equality prevails. (iv) Let E be an entire function, let D be meromorphic in the whole plane and # # assume that D = D# . Then (DE) = EE , and hence ind− DE = ind− E. If DE we assume moreover that supp d(D) ⊆ R and d(D)(w)+ d(E)(w) ≥ 0, w ∈ C, then E ∈ HB κ if and only if DE ∈ HB κ . A particular instance of this situation is frequently of good use: Let P be a real Weierstraß product to the real zeros of E and choose D = P −1 above.
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
107
This shows that in the investigation of indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions one can often restrict without loss of generality that no real zeros are present. From these facts we see that Krein’s factorization theorem, cf. [K] or [L1, Lehrsatz VII.3.6], immediately extends to the indefinite case. Its indefinite version can be formulated as follows. Krein’s Factorization Theorem: If E ∈ HB <∞ , then d(E) ∈ DHB and d(E)(w) > 0 ⇒ d(E)(w) = 0, w ∈ C \ R .
(2.2)
The function E admits a locally uniformly convergent product representation of the form E(z) = γD(z)e
−iaz
p(w) n z 1 z d(E)(w) Re n , exp d(E)(w) 1− w n w n=1
(2.3)
w∈R
where D is real, supp d(D) ⊆ R, |γ| = 1, a ≥ 0 and p : supp d(E) \ R → N ∪ {0} satisfies d(E)(w) < ∞. |w|p(w)+1 w∈R Conversely, every function of this form belongs to HB <∞ . 2.4. Remark. The above discussion shows that from the viewpoint of the asymptotic distribution of zeros, and hence also from the function theoretic viewpoint of growth etc., the classes of indefinite and positive definite Hermite-Biehler functions behave the same. However, in questions concerning the exact location of zeros, in the indefinite case essentially new questions and phenomena appear. The set HB 0 is closed with respect to locally uniform convergence. This follows e.g. from the fact that HB 0 = {E # : E ∈ HB}, cf. Remark 2.2, and that, clearly, HB is closed. However, note that none of the sets HB κ for κ > 0, κ≤N HB κ or HB <∞ is closed with respect to locally uniform convergence. In this context we would like to mention the following result: 2.5. Proposition. Let E be an entire function. (i) We have ind− E = κ if and only if there exists a real entire function D such that D−1 E ∈ HB κ . conver(ii) Let HB κ denote the closure of HB κ with respect to locally uniform gence. Assume that E does not vanish identically. Then E ∈ κ∈N∪{0} HB κ if and only if ind− E < ∞, #(supp d(E) ∩ C+ ) < ∞ . Proof. The necessity in (i) follows since for real functions D we have ind− DE = ind− E. To see the sufficiency assume that ind− E = κ < ∞. Let S := {w ∈ C \ R :
108
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
E(w) = E(w) = 0} and let D be a real entire function with min{d(E)(w), d(E)(w)} , w ∈ S . d(D)(w) = 0 , otherwise E . Then E1 is entire, ind− E1 = ind− E and E1 and E1# have no Put E1 := D common nonreal zeros. Thus E1 ∈ HB κ . We come to the proof of (ii). For sufficiency assume that E is the locally uniform limit of a sequence (En )n∈N of functions En ∈ HB κ . Then, by the continuity of the kernel S E# , E
ind− E ≤ lim inf ind− En = κ , n→∞
and, by the Theorem of Logarithmic Residues, #(supp d(E) ∩ C+ ) ≤ lim inf #(supp d(En ) ∩ C+ ) = κ . n→∞
To establish necessity in (ii), assume that ind− E < ∞ and #(supp d(E) ∩ C+ ) < ∞. Let p be a polynomial with d(E)(w) , w ∈ C+ d(p)(w) = , 0 , otherwise and put E1 := Ep . Then ind− E1 ≤ ind− E + deg p < ∞. Since, E1 and E1# have no common nonreal zeros, by [KL, Satz 6.4] the number ind− E1 coincides with the number of zeros of E1 in C+ . We see that ind− E1 = 0, and hence E1 ∈ HB 0 . Let S := {w ∈ C− : E1 (w) = p(w) = 0}. Then, for a > 0, z − w + ia E1 (z) ∈ HB 0 . z−w w∈S
Since this function has for sufficiently small values of a > 0 no common zeros with p# , we conclude that z − w + ia ∈ HB deg p . E a (z) := p(z)E1 (z) z−w w∈S
a
Clearly, lima0 E = E.
b. The de Branges space associated to E ∈ HB <∞ A function E ∈ HB <∞ generates a reproducing kernel Pontryagin space whose elements are entire functions. To this end consider the kernel i E(z)E(w) − E # (z)E # (w) , z, w ∈ C, z = w , 2π z−w (2.4) i ∂E ∂E # # (z)E (z) − E(z) (z) , z ∈ C . K(z, z) := 2π ∂z ∂z The reproducing kernel Pontryagin space generated by this kernel K will be called the de Branges space induced by E and denoted by P(E), cf. [KW1]. K(w, z) :=
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
109
Let E ∈ HB <∞ . A maximal negative subspace of P(E) can be determined explicitly. We do not show this in full generality; we restrict ourselves to the case of simple zeros, since this is enough for what is needed later on. 2.6. Lemma. Let E ∈ HB κ and assume that all zeros of E which lie in the open upper half-plane are simple. Denote these zeros by w1 , . . . , wκ . Then L := span K(wk , .) : k = 1, . . . , κ is a maximal negative subspace of P(E). Proof. Since each wk is a zero of E, we have i E # (z)E(wk ) , k = 1, . . . , κ . 2π z − wk κ It follows that for x, y ∈ L, x = k=1 λk K(wk , .), y = κj=1 µj K(wj , .), K(wk , z) = −
[x, y] =
κ
K(wk , wj )λk µj =
k,j=1
=−
κ i 1 E(wk )λk E(wj )µj . 2π wj − wk k,j=1
Since E(wk ) = 0, k = 1, . . . , κ, and the matrix κ i P := wj − wk j,k=1 is positive definite (e.g. as the Pick-matrix of the constant function f (z) := i, z ∈ C+ ), it follows that for (λ1 , . . . , λκ ) = 0, ∗ E(w1 )λ1 E(w1 )λ1 κ i 1 .. .. [x, x] = − < 0. . . 2π wj − wk j,k=1 E(wκ )λκ E(wκ )λκ We conclude that {K(w1 , .), . . . , K(wκ , .)} is linearly independent and that L is a negative subspace. Since ind− E = κ, it is a maximal negative subspace. c. Symmetric and semibounded Hermite-Biehler functions We are interested in the study of indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions which satisfy a certain functional equation: 2.7. Definition. Let κ ∈ N∪{0}. We define the set of all symmetric Hermite-Biehler functions with κ negative squares as := E ∈ HB κ : E # (z) = E(−z) . HB sym κ Again let us put HB sym <∞ :=
κ∈N∪{0}
HB sym = E ∈ HB <∞ : E # (z) = E(−z) . κ
110
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
A product representation of symmetric indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions can be deduced from Krein’s factorization theorem. sym Product Representation for HB sym <∞ : If E ∈ HB <∞ , then d(E) ∈ DHB , satisfies (2.2) and d(E)(−w) = d(E)(w), w ∈ C .
The function E admits a locally uniformly convergent product representation of the form z d(E)(w) 1− E(z) = γD(z)e−iaz · w w∈iR\{0}
p(w)
[ 2 ] z 2n z 2 d(E)(w) 1 Im w Re 2n , 1 + 2iz 2 − exp 2d(E)(w) · 2 |w | |w| 2n w n=1 Re w>0 w∈R
where D is real and even, i.e. D(z) = D# (z) = D(−z), supp d(D) ⊆ R, γ = ±1, a ≥ 0 and p : {w ∈ supp d(E) : Re w > 0, w ∈ R} → N ∪ {0} satisfies
d(E)(w) < ∞. |w|p(w)+1 Re w>0 w∈R
Conversely, every function of this form belongs to HB sym <∞ . Let us recall from [KWW3] that the de Branges space generated by a function E ∈ HB sym <∞ has an important symmetry property. In fact, the map M : F (z) → F (−z) induces an isometric involution of P(E) onto itself. Thus the space P(E) can be decomposed as the direct and orthogonal sum ˙ P(E) = P(E)e [+]P(E) o, where
P(E)e = ker(I − M ) = F ∈ P(E) : F even , P(E)o = ker(I + M ) = F ∈ P(E) : F odd .
The orthogonal projections Pe and Po of P(E) onto P(E)e or P(E)o , respectively, are given by I +M I −M , Po = . Pe = 2 2 For later use, let us recall that indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions are related to generalized Nevanlinna functions. Denote by Nκ the set of all functions q which are meromorphic in C \ R, satisfy q # = q, and are such that the Nevanlinna-kernel Qq (w, z) :=
q(z) − q(w) , z, w ∈ C+ z−w
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
111
has κ negative squares. Moreover, let us put Nκsym := q ∈ Nκ : q(−z) = −q(z) . If E is entire, write E = A − iB with A, B real, i.e. E − E# E + E# , B := i . (2.5) 2 2 Let us make the notational convention that, whenever E is an entire function, we denote by A and B the corresponding functions (2.5). A :=
2.8. Remark. Let E be an entire function. Then the following hold: (i) The common zeros of E and E # correspond to the common zeros of A and B. Since, for real points t, E(t) = 0 if and only if E # (t) = 0, we obtain in particular that real zeros of E correspond to real common zeros of A and B. and Nκsym , respectively) are closely related: (ii) The classes HB κ and Nκ (HB sym κ If E and E # do not have common nonreal zeros, then ind− E = κ if and only # if ind− B have no common A = κ. Hence, E ∈ HB κ if and only if E and E B sym # noreal zeros and A ∈ Nκ . Moreover, we have E (z) = E(−z), z ∈ C, if sym and only if A is even and B is odd. Thus, if E ∈ HB sym , we have B . κ A ∈ Nκ The class of symmetric Hermite-Biehler functions is related to another subclass of indefinite Hermite-Biehler functions as we shall now explain, cf. [KWW3]. 2.9. Definition. Let κ ∈ N ∪ {0} and let E be an entire function. Then E is called a semibounded Hermite-Biehler functions with κ negative squares, if E ∈ HB κ and the meromorphic function B A has only finitely many poles in C \ [0, ∞). The set of all semibounded Hermite-Biehler functions with κ negative squares will be denoted by HB sb κ , and again we put HB sb HB sb <∞ := κ . κ∈N∪{0}
Let us mention that, in terms of Nevanlinna functions, the corresponding notion is the following, cf. [KWW1]: We write q ∈ Nκep , if q ∈ Nκ and is analytic on C \ [0, ∞) with possible exception of finitely many poles. Clearly, E ∈ HB sb κ ep means that B A ∈ Nκ . sb The relation between HB sym <∞ and HB <∞ can now be stated as follows. Consider the transformation T which is defined by (TE)(z) := A(z 2 ) − izB(z 2 ) , and define the sets Bκ , B<∞ , as Bκ := {E ∈ HB sb κ : d(E)|(−∞,0) = 0}, κ ∈ N ∪ {0} , B<∞ := Bκ = {E ∈ HB sb <∞ : d(E)|(−∞,0) = 0} . κ∈N∪{0}
2.10. Proposition. The transformation T induces a bijection of B<∞ onto HB sym <∞ . Thereby ind− TE ≥ ind− E.
112
Pivovarchik and Woracek
Proof. Assume that E = A − iB ∈ HB sb <∞ , so that q := by [KWW1, Theorem 4.1], the function zq(z 2 ) =
IEOT B A
ep belongs to N<∞ . Then,
zB(z 2 ) A(z 2 )
sym belongs to N<∞ . Assume now moreover that E(t) = 0 for t ∈ (−∞, 0). Then A and B have no common zeros in C\[0, ∞), and hence the functions A1 (z) := A(z 2 ) and B1 (z) := zB(z 2 ) have no common nonreal zeros. Clearly, A1 is even and B1 is odd. We conclude that TE ∈ HB sym <∞ . The map T is clearly injective. To show that T(B<∞ ) = HB sym <∞ , let E = be given. We define entire functions A− and B− by A − iB ∈ HB sym κ
B(z) . (2.6) z Then A− and B− have no common zeros in C \ [0, ∞) since A and B have no common nonreal zeros. Put E− := A− − iB− , then, clearly, TE− = E. Again appealing to [KWW1, Theorem 4.1] we obtain E− ∈ HB sb ν for some ν ≤ κ. A− (z 2 ) := A(z), B− (z 2 ) :=
2.11. Remark. The transformation T is compatible with multiplication with real functions: Let E be entire and D meromorphic and real, then T(DE)(z) = D(z 2 )(TE)(z) .
(2.7)
This shows that the requirement in Proposition 2.10 that E has no real negative zeros is no essential restriction of generality, since we can always split off a real Weierstraß product to the real negative zeros of E. #
E 2.12. Remark. A function E ∈ HB sym <∞ satisfies E = const if and only if E either satisfies E # (z) = E(z) = E(−z) or E # (z) = −E(z) = E(−z), i.e. E# E# = const = E ∈ HB sym ∈ {+1, −1} . {E ∈ HB sym <∞ : <∞ : E E As a short computation shows, we have E# E# ∈ {+1, −1} = E ∈ HB sym ∈ {+1, −1} , T {E ∈ B<∞ : <∞ : E E whereas c−1 TE− (z) = A− (z 2 ) 1 + z c+1
when E− ∈ B<∞ ,
# E− E−
= c, c = ±1.
3. Zeros of symmetric Hermite-Biehler functions In the main result of this paper we give a characterization of the subset T(B0 ) of HB sym <∞ in terms of the location of their zeros. 3.1. Theorem. Let E ∈ HB sym <∞ . Then E ∈ T(B0 ) if and only if its zeros are distributed according to the following two rules:
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
113
(i) All zeros of E in C+ are simple and are located on the imaginary axis. (ii) Let supp d(E) ∩ C+ = {iy1 , . . . , iyκ } with 0 < y1 < . . . < yκ , where κ := ind− E. Then d(E)(w) is odd, k = 2, . . . , κ , w∈[−iyk−1 ,−iyk ]
d(E)(w) is
w∈(0,−iy1 ]
even , d(E)(0) is even odd , d(E)(0) is odd
The proof of this result will be carried out in several steps. The core of the result is to establish that, if E has the described distribution of zeros, it belongs to T(B0 ). Step 1: Removing real zeros. Let us show that without loss of generality we can make the assumption that E has no real zeros with possible exception of a simple zero at the origin. To see this note that, by the symmetry of the zeros of E, there exists an even and real entire function C which satisfies , w ∈ R \ {0} d(E)(w) d(E)(0) . d(C)(w) = 2 · , w=0 2 0 , w ∈ C\R Since C # (z) = C(z) = C(−z), this function assumes real values on R ∪ iR. Define # an entire function C− by C− (z 2 ) := C(z). Then C− (R) ⊆ R and thus C− = C− . Moreover, √ , w>0 d(E)( w) d(E)(0) d(C− )(w) = . , w=0 2 0 , w ∈ C \ [0, ∞) The conditions (i) and (ii) on the distribution of zeros clearly hold for E if and ˜ := C −1 E. Also, E belongs to T(B0 ) if and only only if they hold for the function E ˜ ˜− for some E ˜− ∈ B0 . Then C− E˜− if E does: To see this assume first that E˜ = TE ˜ ˜ also belongs to B0 , and, by (2.7), T(C− E− ) = C E = E. Conversely, assume that E = TE− for some E− ∈ B0 . Then √ t), t > 0 d(E)( d(E)(0) d(E− )(t) = = d(C− )(t), t ∈ R , ,t=0 2 0, t < 0 −1 −1 E− ∈ B0 . Moreover, again by (2.7), we have T(C− E− ) = and it follows that C− −1 ˜ C E = E. Hence, in all future steps of the proof of Theorem 3.1, we can assume that E has no real zeros with possible exception of a simple zero at the origin.
114
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
Step 2: Proof of necessity, absence of zeros in C+ \ iR. Assume that E = T(E− ) for some E− ∈ B0 . Note that we can write (E− = A− − iB− ) E(z) = A− (z 2 ) − izB− (z 2 ) =
# 2 # 2 E− (z 2 ) − E− (z ) (z ) E− (z 2 ) + E− − iz · i = 2 2 #
E (z 2 ) E− (z 2 ) (1 + z) + − (1 − z) . 2 2 Hence, if z ∈ C is such that Re z > 0 and Im z > 0, so that z 2 ∈ C+ and thus E− (z 2 ) = 0, we have E(z) = 0 if and only if =
# 2 (z ) E− z+1 = . 2 E− (z ) z−1 E#
However, the function E− maps the open upper half-plane into the open unit disk, − whereas the fractional linear transformation z+1 φ(z) := z−1 maps this region as indicated in the below picture:
φ(z) =
z+1 z−1
Thus E cannot have zeros with Re z > 0, Im z > 0, and, by symmetry, therefore also no zeros with Re z < 0, Im z > 0. Step 3: Proof of necessity, zeros on iR. Assume again that E ∈ T(B0 ), that is E(z) = A− (z 2 ) − izB− (z 2 ) with E− := A− − iB− ∈ B0 . We use a geometric idea similar, but more refined, as in the previous step. We show that the functions A− (z) and B− (z) do not have √ common zeros in C: If t ∈ R \ {0} were a common zero of A− and B− , then t ∈ (R ∪ iR) \ {0} would be a common zero of A(z) := A− (z 2 ) and B(z) := zB− (z 2 ), a contradiction. If A− (0) = B− (0) = 0, the function E would have a zero at the origin of order at least 2, again a contradiction. Finally, since E− ∈ HB <∞ , A− and B− cannot have common nonreal zeros.
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
115
The fact that A− and B− have no common zeros shows that the zeros of E, with exception of a possible zero at the origin, coincide with the zeros of the function B− (z 2 ) i + . A− (z 2 ) z
Q(z) :=
We shall deduce the desired distribution of zeros on the imaginary axis from the following statement. 3.2. Lemma. Let q ∈ N0ep be meromorphic in the whole plane and denote by ξn < ξn−1 < . . . < ξ1 < 0 its poles on the negative real axis. Put ξ0 := 0 and ηj :=
|ξj |, j = 0, . . . , n .
Consider the function qˆ(t) := q(−t2 ) + Then we have
1 . t
d(ˆ q )(w) = 1, j = 1, . . . , n ,
(3.1)
w∈(ηj−1 ,ηj )
and
d(ˆ q )(w) =
w∈(ηn ,∞)
0 , limt→−∞ q(t) ≥ 0 1 , limt→−∞ q(t) < 0
(3.2)
Denote by 0 < y1 < . . . < ym the zeros of of qˆ on the positive real axis. Then qˆ(−yj ) = 0, j = 1, . . . , m, and the formulas
d(ˆ q )(w) is odd, yj+1 < ηn ,
(3.3)
w∈[−yj+1 ,−yj ]
and
d(ˆ q )(w) is
w∈[−y1 ,0)
even , d(q)(0) ≥ 0 odd , d(q)(0) < 0
(3.4)
hold true. Proof. The proof of this lemma follows by elementary calculus inspecting the graphs of q(−t2 ) and − 1t :
116
Pivovarchik and Woracek
−y4
−y2
−y3 −η3
−η2
−y1
y2
y1
−η1
IEOT
η1
0
y3 η2
y4 η3
q(−t2 )
− 1t First of all note that the set of poles of qˆ on R equals {±η1 , . . .±ηn }∪{0}. Thereby d(ˆ q )(±ηj ) = −1, j = 1, . . . , n , d(ˆ q )(0) =
−1 , d(q)(0) ≥ 0 −2 , d(q)(0) < 0
Since q|R is nondecreasing between each pair of consecutive poles, the function q(−t2 ) is nonincreasing on each of the intervals (0, η1 ), (η1 , η2 ), . . . , (ηn−1 , ηn ), (ηn , ∞) . Since 1t is strictly decreasing on R+ , the function qˆ will be strictly decreasing on each of the above intervals. Since it tends to ±∞ at the poles 0, η1 , . . . , ηn , the formula (3.1) follows. Moreover, there is at most one zero on (ηn , ∞). Clearly, such a zero exists if and only if limt→∞ qˆ(t) < 0, which is nothing else than limu→−∞ q(u) < 0. This proves (3.2). For t ∈ [yi , ηi ), i = 1, . . . , n, we have qˆ(t) ≤ 0. Since qˆ(−t) = q(−t2 ) −
2 1 = qˆ(t) − , t t
it follows that qˆ(u) < 0, u ∈ (−ηi , −yi ], i = 1, . . . , n .
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
117
Since limu −ηj qˆ(u) = +∞, j = 1, . . . , n, it follows that (taking into account multiplicities) there is an odd number of zeros on the interval [−yi , −ηi−1 ), i = 2, . . . , n. This shows (3.3). To establish (3.4) it is enough to note that −∞ , d(q)(0) ≥ 0 lim qˆ(u) = u 0 +∞ , d(q)(0) < 0 An application of this lemma with the function q := information on the zeros of E of the form z = it, t ∈ R.
B− A−
now gives the desired
Step 4: Proof of sufficiency (E(0) = 0), geometric reformulation. Let E ∈ HB sym <∞ and assume that E has no real zeros. Since E(0) ∈ R \ {0} and multiplication with a real constant changes neither of the two conditions in the present theorem, we can assume without loss of generality that E(0) = 1. Let E− ∈ B<∞ be such that TE− = E, i.e. let E− = A− − iB− with A− , B− as in (2.6). Then, by [KWW3, Proposition 4.9], we have P(E)o ∼ = P(E− ). Thus we have to prove that ind− P(E)o = 0. Step 5: Proof of sufficiency (E(0) = 0), employing the hypothesis. Let E ∈ HB sym <∞ , E(0) = 1, have a zero distribution as described in (i) and (ii). If E(w) = 0, we see from (2.4) that i ∂E # K(w, w) = − E(w) (w) . 2π ∂z # ∂E Since E # (z) = E(−z), we have ∂E ∂z (z) = − ∂z (−z), and hence K(w, w) =
i ∂E E(w) (−w) . 2π ∂z
If w = iy, this formula reads as K(iy, −iy) =
∂E i E(−iy) (iy) . 2π ∂z
Consider the real-analytic function e:
R → R . x → E(ix)
1 e(−y)e (y). Then we can further rewrite K(iy, −iy) = 2π Let 0 < y1 < . . . < yκ be such that wk := iyk , k = 1, . . . , κ, are the zeros of E in the upper half-plane. Since these zeros are all simple and since e(0) = 1 > 0, we must have sgn e (yk ) = (−1)k , k = 1, . . . , κ. Since the (total) number of zeros of e on the interval (−y1 , 0) is even and on each of the intervals (−yk , −yk−1 ), k = 2, . . . , κ, odd, we must have sgn e(−yk ) = (−1)k+1 , k = 1, . . . , κ. Alltogether it follows that K(iyk , −iyk ) < 0, k = 1, . . . , κ .
118
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
Step 6: Proof of sufficiency (E(0) = 0), conclusion. Let w√ 1 , . . . , wκ be the zeros of E in the upper half-plane. Consider the map Φ := 2Pe |L where L := span{K(wk , .) : k = 1, . . . , κ}. Since K(w, −z) = K(−w, z), we have 1 ΦK(wk , .) = √ K(wk , .) + K(−wk , .) , 2 and hence can compute 1 ΦK(wk , .), ΦK(wj , .) = K(wk , .) + K(−wk , .), K(wj , .) + K(−wj , .) = 2 = K(wk , wj ) + K(wk , −wj ) = [K(wk , .), K(wj , .)] + K(wk , −wj ) . Note that, since wj ∈ iR, we have −wj = wj . For j = k, we obtain K(wk , −wj ) = K(wk , wj ) =
i E(wj )E(wk ) − E # (wj )E(wk ) = 0. 2π wj − wk
For j = k, we have proved the previous step that K(wk , −wk ) < 0. It follows in κ that for x ∈ L \ {0}, x = k=1 λk K(wk , .), we have [Φx, Φx] = [x, x] +
κ
|λk |2 K(wk , −wk ) < [x, x] ,
k=1
i.e. that Φ|L is a contraction in the Pontryagin space sense. Since L is a maximal negative subspace, Φ is injective and Φ(L) is again a maximal negative subspace of P(E). We conclude that P(E)e contains a maximal negative subspace, and thus that its orthogonal complement P(E)o is positive definite. Step 7: Proof of sufficiency (E(0) = 0). Let E = A − iB ∈ HB sym <∞ have the prescribed distribution of zeros and assume that E(0) = 0. Since, cf. Step 1, E has a simple zero at the origin and since A is even and B is odd, we must have B (0) = 0. Thus we can assume without loss of generality that B (0) = 1. Again define A− and B− by (2.6), so that A− − iB− ∈ B<∞ and E(z) = (TE− )(z) = A− (z 2 ) − izB− (z 2 ) . Note that A− (0) = 0 and B− (0) = 1. Our aim is to show that ind− E− = 0. Consider the function E+ := iE− = B− + iA− , then E+ ∈ B<∞ and ind− E+ = ind− E− . By [KWW3, Theorem 4.5] the function A− (z 2 ) ˜ E(z) := B− (z 2 ) + i z ∼ ˜ and we have P( E) ). P(E belongs to HB sym = e + <∞ ˜ ˜ has the same distribution of zeros as E Since E(z) = zi E(z), the function E ˜ with the exception that E(0) = 1. The same reasoning as in the above Steps 5 and ˜ e = 0, since this time the number of zeros between 0 6 will show that ind− P(E)
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
and −iy1 is odd, hence K(iy, −iy) will be positive and hence the map ˜ o . It follows that be a contraction of L into P(E) ˜ e = 0. ind− E− = ind− E+ = ind− P(E+ ) = ind− P(E) All assertions of Theorem 3.1 are proved.
119
√ 2Po will
✌
4. Application to some boundary value problems In this final section we apply Theorem 3.1 in order to describe the location of the pure imaginary eigenvalues of the boundary problems I–IV listed in the introduction. For the problems II–IV their location has been found separately in each case, see [PM] for II, [MP1] for III ([MP2] for a detailed version), and [MoP] for the problem IV. Let us note that in these papers the roles of the upper and lower half-planes were exchanged in comparison to the present paper, cf. the remark we made in the third paragraph of the introduction. I. The Regge problem. This is the problem (4.1) −y + q(x)y = λ2 y , y(0) = 0 , (4.2) y (a) − iλy(a) = 0 , (4.3) where λ is the spectral parameter and the potential q is real-valued and belongs to L2 (0, a). Denote s(ζ, x) the solution of equation −y + q(x)y = ζy,
(4.4)
which satisfies the conditions s(ζ, 0) = s (ζ, 0) − 1 = 0. Let us show following [KK] that the function ss(ζ,a) (ζ,a) belongs to the Nevanlinna class and has only a finite ep number of poles on (−∞, 0), i.e. ss(ζ,a) (ζ,a) ∈ N0 . Let us multiply (4.4) by y and subtract the equation complex-conjugate to (4.4) multiplied by y. Then we obtain
y y − y y = 2i Im ζ|y|2 , or
(y y − y y) = 2i Im ζ|y|2 , Integrating this equation we obtain ! a a y y − y y|0 = 2i Im ζ |y|2 dx, 0
If we take y = s(ζ, x) then we obtain s(ζ, a) Im |s (ζ, a)|2 = 2 Im ζ s (ζ, a)
! 0
a
|s(ζ, x)|2 dx, Im ζ > 0.
120
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
This means that the function ss(ζ,a) (ζ,a) belongs to the Nevanlinna class. It is well known (see e.g. [A]) that the set of zeros of s (ζ, a) is bounded below. That means s(ζ,a) s (ζ,a) is meromorphic and has finitely many poles in C\[0, ∞). It is also known that s (ζ, a) and s(ζ, a) cannot be zero simultanously. Therefore, the function ϕ(ζ) = s (ζ, a) − is(ζ, a) belongs to B0 . On the other hand, the set of zeros of the function ϕ(λ) = s (λ2 , a) − iλs(λ2 , a) coincides with the spectrum of problem (4.1)–(4.3) and the function ϕ(λ) ˜ belongs to T(B0 ). Therefore, we can apply Theorem 3.1 and obtain that (1) all (if any) eigenvalues of problem (4.1)–(4.3) in the closed upper half-plane are pure imaginary and simple (we denote them {iγj }, j = 1, 2, ..., κ in increasing order: γj < γj+1 ); (2) all the points −iγj , j = 1, 2, ..., κ do not belong to the spectrum of the problem except for iγ1 if γ1 = 0; (3) each interval (−iγj+1 , −iγj ), j = 1, 2, ..., κ − 1 contains an odd number (with account of multiplicities) of the eigenvalues; (4) if γ1 = 0, then the interval (−iγ1 , 0) contains an even number (with account of multiplicities) of the eigenvalues. II. The generalized Regge problem. This is the problem −y + q(x)y = λ2 y , y(0) = 0 ,
y (a) − iαλy(a) + βy(a) = 0 , with α > 0 and β ∈ R. Clearly, multiplying s(ζ, a) by a positive constant α does not change anything αs(ζ,a) (the function α ss(ζ,a) (ζ,a) is also Nevanlinna). To prove that s (ζ,a)+βs(ζ,a) belongs also to the Nevanlinna class, let us consider its imaginary part "# %
−2 $ (ζ, a)
s (ζ, a)
s αs(ζ, a) Im = α
+ β)
Im +β . s (ζ, a) + βs(ζ, a) s(ζ, a) s(ζ, a) (ζ,a) > 0 and consequently If Im ζ > 0, then Im ss(ζ,a) Im
αs(ζ, a) > 0, Im ζ > 0. + βs(ζ, a)
s (ζ, a)
αs(ζ,a) That means that s (ζ,a)+βs(ζ,a) is a Nevanlinna function. The set of zeros of its denominator is bounded below, see [A]. In the same way as for the Regge problem
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
121
we obtain that the above statements (1)-(4) are true, i.e. we obtain an alternative proof of [PM, Lemma 2.2, 3)] and [PM, Theorem 3.1, 1)-3)]. III. Vibrations of a damped string. We consider the spectral problem −y − ipλy + q(x)y = λ2 y ,
(4.5)
y(0) = 0 ,
(4.6)
y (a) + (β − iαλ − mλ2 )y(a) = 0 ,
(4.7)
where p > 0, α > 0, m > 0 and β is a real parameter. From the physical motivation of the problem it follows that q(x) and β are such that the spectrum of problem (4.5)–(4.7) lies in the open lower half-plane, see [P2]. Let us change the spectral parameter: z = λ + ip 2 . Then we obtain $ # 2 p − q(x) y = 0, (4.8) y + z 2 y + 4 y(0) = 0, $ # αp mp2 − + β y(a) = 0. y (a) + −mz 2 − i(α − mp)z + 4 2 If we denote by s(ζ, x) the solution of the equation $ # 2 p y + ζy + − q(x) y = 0, 4 which satisfies the conditions s(ζ, 0) = s (ζ, 0) − 1 = 0 then we obtain that belongs to N0ep .
(4.9) (4.10)
s(ζ,a) s (ζ,a)
We distinguish three cases: Case 1: mp−α = 0. In this case problem (4.8)–(4.10) is selfadjoint and its spectrum lies on the real axis and on a finite subinterval of the imaginary axis. The spectrum is symmetric with respect to the real axis and to the imaginary axis. Respectively, the spectrum of the problem (4.5)–(4.7) lies on the axis Im λ = − p2 and on a finite subinterval of the imaginary axis. The spectrum is symmetric with respect to the imaginary axis and to the axis Im λ = − p2 . is a Nevanlinna function. Let us show Case 2: α−mp > 0. Then again (α−mp)s(ζ,a) s (ζ,a) (α−mp)s(ζ,a) that s (ζ,a)+(β where β1 = β + 1 −mζ)s(ζ,a) First of all we notice that
Im
mp2 4
−
αp 2
is also a Nevanlinna function.
# $−1 s (ζ, a) (α − mp)s(ζ, a) = (α − mp) Im + (β − mζ) = 1 s (ζ, a) + (β1 − mζ)s(ζ, a) s(ζ, a) "# %
−2 $
s (ζ, a)
s (ζ, a)
= + (β1 − mζ) Im + β1 − mζ . s(ζ, a) s(ζ, a)
122
Pivovarchik and Woracek
If Im ζ > 0, then Im Im
s (ζ,a) s(ζ,a)
IEOT
> 0 and consequently
(α − mp)s(ζ, a) > 0, Im ζ > 0. s (ζ, a) + (β1 − mζ)s(ζ, a)
Let us now consider the denominator s (ζ, a) + (β1 − mζ)s(ζ, a). The set of its zeros coincides with the spectrum of the boundary value problem −y + q(x)y = ζy, y(0) = y (a) + (β1 − mζ)y = 0. The eigenvalues of this problem are real and bounded below, see e.g. [P1]. This means that the function s (z 2 , a) + (β1 − mz 2 )s(z 2 , a) − i(α − mp)zs(z 2, a) belongs to T(B0 ). Taking into account that λ = z − ip 2 and using Theorem 3.1 we obtain that (1) all (if any) eigenvalues of problem (4.5)–(4.7) in the closed half-plane Im λ ≥ − p2 (they all lie in the strip − p2 ≤ Im λ < 0) are pure imaginary and simple (we denote them {iγj }, j = 1, 2, ..., κ in increasing order: γj < γj+1 ); (2) all the points −ip + i|γj |, j = 1, 2, ..., κ do not belong to the spectrum of the problem except of iγ1 if γ1 = − ip 2; (3) each interval (−ip + i|γj+1 |, −ip + i|γj |), j = 1, 2, ..., κ − 1 contains an odd number (with account of multiplicities) of the eigenvalues; ip , then the interval − , −ip + i|γ1 | contains an even number (4) if γ1 = − ip 2 2 (with account of multiplicities) of the eigenvalues. Case 3: mp − α > 0. Then again (mp−α)s(ζ,a) s (ζ,a)+(β1 −mζ)s(ζ,a)
(mp−α)s(ζ,a) is s (ζ,a) mp2 αp 4 − 2 is also
a Nevanlinna function and
where β1 = β + a Nevanlinna function. It means that, if we set ξ = −z, then the function s (ξ 2 , a) + (β1 − mξ 2 )s(ξ 2 , a) − i(mp − α)ξs(ξ 2 , a)
belongs to T(B0 ). Taking into account that λ = −ξ − ip 2 and using Theorem 3.1 we obtain that (1) all (if any) eigenvalues of problem (4.5)–(4.7) in the closed half-plane Im λ ≤ − p2 are pure imaginary and simple (we denote them {iγj }, j = 1, 2, ..., κ in increasing order: |γj | < |γj+1 |); (2) all the points −ip + i|γj |, j = 1, 2, ..., κ do not belong to the spectrum of the problem except of iγ1 if γ1 = − ip 2; (3) each interval (−ip + i|γj |, −ip + i|γj+1 |), j = 1, 2, ..., κ − 1 contains an odd number (with account of multiplicities) of the eigenvalues; ip , then the interval − , −ip + i|γ1 | contains an even number (4) if γ1 = − ip 2 2 (with account of multiplicities) of the eigenvalues. Thus we have deduced [MP1, Theorem 4, 2] and [MP1, Theorem 5, 2’].
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
123
IV. A fourth order problem. We consider the problem y (4) − (g(x)y ) = λ2 y,
(4.11)
y(0) = y (0) = 0,
(4.12)
y(a) = 0,
(4.13)
y (a) − iαλy (a) = 0
(4.14)
where g(x) is a continuously differentiable function. Denote by sj (λ2 , x) (j = 0, 1, 2, 3) the solution of the equation (4.11) which satisfies the conditions (k)
sj (λ2 , 0) = δk,j , j = 0, 1, 2, 3, where δkj is the Kronecker delta. Let us introduce the function ϕ(λ2 , x) = s3 (λ2 , a)s1 (λ2 , x) − s1 (λ2 , a)s3 (λ2 , x) This function automatically satisfies the conditions (4.12), (4.13). It satisfies (4.14) if ϕ (λ2 a) − iαλϕ (λ2 a) = 0. Let us prove that the function the equation
ϕ (ζ,a) ϕ (ζ,a)
is a Nevanlinna function. To do it we multiply
y (4) − (g(x)y ) = ζy,
(4.15)
by y and subtract the equation complex-conjugate to (4.15) multiplied by y. Then we obtain y (4) y − y(4) y − ((g(x)y ) y − (g(x)y ) y) = 2i Im ζ|y|2 or (y (3) y − y (3) y) − (y (2) y − y(2) y ) − (g(x)y y − g(x)y y) = 2i Im ζ|y|2 . Integrating this equation we obtain
a
a a
(y (3) y − y (3) y) − (y (2) y − y(2) y ) − (g(x)y y − g(x)y y)|0 = 0 0 ! a |y|2 dx . = 2i Im ζ
(4.16)
0
Let us apply this result to ϕ(ζ, x). This solution satisfies the conditions (4.12), (4.13), and therefore we obtain from (4.16): ! a −(ϕ(2) (ζ, a)ϕ (ζ, a) − ϕ(2) (ζ, a)ϕ (ζ, a)) = 2i Im ζ |ϕ(ζ, x)|2 dx 0
or
ϕ (ζ, a) (2) Im (2) |ϕ (ζ, a)|2 = 2 Im ζ ϕ (ζ, a)
! 0
a
|ϕ(ζ, x)|2 dx, Im ζ > 0.
124
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
That means that after reducing the ratio ϕϕ(ζ,a) (ζ,a) is a Nevanlinna function. Moreover, it belongs to N0ep because the set of zeros of the denominator ϕ (ζ, a), being nothing else but the spectrum of the problem y (4) − (g(x)y ) = ζy, y(0) = y (0) = y(a) = y (a) = 0 , is real and bounded below. This in turn means that ϕ(2) (λ2 ) − iλϕ (λ2 ) = c(λ2 )ψ(λ) where c(ζ) is a real function bounded below and ψ(λ) ∈ T(B0 ). Therefore, we can apply Theorem 3.1 and obtain that the spectrum of problem (4.11)–(4.14) consists of two subsequences which can intersect. One of them consists of real and pure imaginary eigenvalue which are located symmetrically with respect to the real and to the imaginary axis. The eigenvalues of the second subsequence lie in the open lower half-plane and on the positive imaginary half-axis. The pure imaginary eigenvalues of the second subsequence satisfy the conditions (1)-(4) of I. Thus we have obtained [MoP, Theorem 6.5, 1-6].
References [ADRS] D.Alpay, A.Dijksma, J.Rovnyak, H.de Snoo: Schur functions, operator colligations, and reproducing kernel Pontryagin spaces, Oper. Theory Adv. Appl. 96, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel 1997. [A] F.V.Atkinson: Discrete and Continuous Boundary Problems, Academic Press, New-York-London, 1964. [B] R.Boas: Entire functions, Academic Press, New York 1954. [dB] L. de Branges: Hilbert spaces of entire functions, Prentice-Hall, London 1968. [GP] G.Gubreev, V.Pivovarchik: Spectral analysis of T. Regge problem with parameters, Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 31(1) (1997), 70-74. [H] C.Hermite: Oevres I, Paris, 1905. [Hr] S.Hrushev: The Regge problem for a string, unconditionally convergent eigenfunction expansions, and unconditional bases of exponentials in L2 (−T, T ),, J. Operator Theory 14 (1985), 67-85. [IP] S.A.Ivanov, B.S.Pavlov: Carleson resonance series in the Regge problem, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat. 42(1) (1978), 26-55. [KK] I.S.Kac, M.G.Krein: On spectral functions of a string, in F.V.Atkinson, Discrete and Continuous Boundary Problems (Russian translation), Moscow, Mir, 1968, 648-737 (Addition II). I.C.Kac, M.G.Krein, On the Spectral Function of the String. Amer. Math. Soc., Translations, Ser.2, 103 (1974), 19-102. ¨ ck, H.Winkler, H.Woracek: Generalized Nevanlinna func[KWW1] M.Kaltenba tions with essentially positive spectrum, J. Oper. Theory 55(1) (2006), 17-48. ¨ ck, H.Winkler, H.Woracek: Singularities of generalized [KWW2] M.Kaltenba strings, Operator Theory Adv. Appl. 163 (2006), 191-248.
Vol. 57 (2007) Shifted Hermite-Biehler Functions and Their Applications
125
¨ ck, H.Winkler, H.Woracek: De Branges spaces of entire func[KWW3] M.Kaltenba tions symmetric about the origin, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, to appear, DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1443-3. [KW1]
¨ ck, H.Woracek: Pontryagin spaces of entire functions I, InteM.Kaltenba gral Equations and Operator Theory 33 (1999), 34-97.
[KW2]
¨ ck, H.Woracek: Hermite-Biehler Functions with zeros close to M.Kaltenba the imaginary axis, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.133 (2005), 245-255.
[KaKo]
P.Kargaev, E.Korotyaev: Inverse resonance scattering and conformal mappings for Schr¨ odinger operators, unpublished manuscript.
[Ko]
V.M.Kogan: On double completeness of the set of eigen- and associated functions of the Regge problem, Functional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 5(3) (1971), 70-74 (in Russian).
[Kr]
A.O.Kravitskii: On Double Expansion into Series of Eigenfunctions of a Nonself-Adjoint Boundary Problem, Differentsialnye Uravneniya 4(N1) (1968), 165-177 (in Russian).
[K]
M.G.Krein: On a class of entire and meromorphic functions (Russian), published in: N.I.Achieser, M.G.Krein: Some problems in the theorie of moments (Russian), Charkov, 1938, 231-252. ¨ M.G.Krein, H.Langer: Uber einige Fortsetzungsprobleme, die eng mit der angen. I. Einige Theorie hermitescher Operatoren im Raume Πκ zusammenh¨ Funktionenklassen und ihre Darstellungen, Math. Nachr. 77 (1977), 187-236.
[KL]
[LW]
H.Langer, H.Winkler: Direct and inverse spectral problems for generalized strings, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 30 (1998), 409-431.
[L1]
B.Levin: Nullstellenverteilung ganzer Funktionen, Akademie Verlag, Berlin 1962.
[L2]
B.Levin: On a special class of entire functions and on extremal properties of entire functions of finite degree, Izvestija Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat. 14 (1950), 45-84.
[MP1]
C.van der Mee, V.Pivovarchik: A Sturm-Liouville Inverse Problem with Boundary Conditions Depending on the Spectral Parameter, Functional Analysis and Its Applications 36(4) (2002), 315-317; Translated from Funktsional’nyi Analiz i Ego Prilozheniya 36(4) (2002), 74-77.
[MP2]
C.van der Mee, V.Pivovarchik: The Sturm-Liouville Inverse Spectral Problem with Boundary Conditions Depending on the Spectral Parameter, Opuscula Mathematica 25(2) (2005), 243-260.
[MoP]
¨ ller, V.Pivovarchik: Spectral properties of a fourth order differential M.Mo equation, Zeitschrift f¨ ur Analysis und ihre Anwendungen, to appear.
[P1]
V.Pivovarchik: Inverse problem for a string with concentrated mass at one end, Methods of Functional Analysis and Topology 4(3) (1998), 61-71.
[P2]
V.Pivovarchik: Direct and Inverse Problems for a Damped String, J. Operator Theory 42 (1999), 189-220.
[P3]
V.Pivovarchik: Symmetric Hermite-Biehler polynomials with defect, Operator Theory Adv. Appl., to appear.
126 [PM] [Pi] [R1] [R2] [R] [RR] [S] [Si]
Pivovarchik and Woracek
IEOT
V.Pivovarchik, C.van der Mee: The inverse generalized Regge problem, Inverse Problems 17 (2001), 1831-1845. ¨ G.Pick: Uber die Beschr¨ ankungen analytischer Funktionen, welche durch vorgegebene Funktionswerte bewirkt werden, Math. Ann. 77 (1916), 7-23. T.Regge: Construction of potential from resonances, Nuovo Cimento 9(3) (1958), 491-503. T.Regge: Construction of potential from resonances, Nuovo Cimento 9(5) (1958), 671-679. R.Remmert: Funktionentheorie II, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg 1991. M.Rosenblum, J.Rovnyak: Topics in Hardy classes and univalent functions, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel 1994. A.G.Sergeev: Asymptotics of Jost-functions and eigenvalues of the Regge problem, Differentsialnye Uravneniya 8(5) (1972), 925-927 (in Russian). B.Simon: Resonances in one dimension and Fredholm determinants, J. Funct. Anal. 178(2) (2000), 396-420.
Vyacheslav Pivovarchik Department of Applied Mathematics and Informatics South-Ukrainian State Pedagogical University Staroportofrankovskaya str. 26 UA–65091 Odessa Ukraine e-mail:
[email protected] Harald Woracek Institut f¨ ur Analysis und Scientific Computing Technische Universit¨ at Wien Wiedner Hauptstr. 8–10/101 A–1040 Wien Austria e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: December 23, 2005 Revised: May 15, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 127–132 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010127-6, published online December 26, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1470-0
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
A Remark on the Essential Spectra of Toeplitz Operators with Bounded Measurable Coefficients Eugene Shargorodsky Abstract. We establish a sufficient condition for a point to belong to the essential spectrum of a Toeplitz operator with a bounded measurable coefficient. This condition uses geometric information on the cluster values of the coefficient. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35; Secondary 45E05. Keywords. Toeplitz operators, cluster values, Fredholm property.
1. Introduction Let T = {ζ ∈ C : |ζ| = 1} be the unit circle. A number c ∈ C is called a (left, right) cluster value of a measurable function a : T → C at a point ζ ∈ T if 1/(a − c) ∈ L∞ (W ) for every neighbourhood (left semi-neighbourhood, right semi-neighbourhood) W ⊂ T of ζ. Cluster values are invariant under changes of the function on measure zero sets. We denote the set of all left (right) cluster values of a at ζ by a(ζ − 0) (by a(ζ + 0)), and use also the following notation a(ζ) = a(ζ − 0) ∪ a(ζ + 0), a(T) = ∪ζ∈C a(ζ). It is easy to see that a(ζ − 0), a(ζ + 0), a(ζ) and a(T) are closed sets. Hence they are all compact if a ∈ L∞ (T). Let K ⊂ C be an arbitrary compact set and λ ∈ C \ K. Then the set w − λ σ(K; λ) = w∈K ⊆T |w − λ| is compact as a continuous image of a compact set. Hence the set ∆λ (K) := T \ σ(K; λ) is open in T. So, ∆λ (K) is the union of an at most countable family of open arcs. Supported by an EPSRC grant GR/R81749/02.
128
Shargorodsky
IEOT
We call an open arc of T p–large if its length is greater than or equal to p where p = p−1 , 1 < p < ∞. p Let T (a) : H (T) → H p (T) denote the Toeplitz operator generated by a function a ∈ L∞ (T), i.e. T (a)f = P (af ), f ∈ H p (T), where P is the Riesz projection: 1 g(w) 1 dw, ζ ∈ T, P g(ζ) = g(ζ) + 2 2πi T w − ζ and H p (T) := P Lp (T) is the Hardy space, 1 < p < ∞. A well known theorem of I. Gohberg and N. Krupnik describes the spectrum of T (a) with a piecewise continuous a in terms of a(ζ ±0), ζ ∈ T (see [5, 9.3, 9.8] or [1, 5.39]). It is still possible to describe the spectrum of T (a) in terms of a(ζ ± 0), ζ ∈ T if a is not piecewise continuous but a(ζ) consists of at most two points for each ζ ∈ T ([2, 3, 11]). The situation becomes considerably more complicated if a(ζ) is allowed to contain more than two points. Suppose, for example, that a(−1) consists of three points, a(−1 ± 0) = a(T) = {c1 , c2 , c3 } ⊂ C and the closed triangle (c1 , c2 , c3 ) with the vertices c1 , c2 , c3 is non-degenerate . Then the (essential) spectrum of T (a) : H 2 (T) → H 2 (T) is a connected set which contains {c1 , c2 , c3 } and is contained in (c1 , c2 , c3 ) (see, e.g., [1, 2.30, 2.33, 2.35]). It turns out however that this set is not determined solely by c1 , c2 , c3 . A. B¨ottcher has constructed examples where the spectrum of T (a) : H 2 (T) → H 2 (T) (i) does not contain any points of the boundary of the triangle (c1 , c2 , c3 ) other than c1 , c2 , c3 ; (ii) contains a side of (c1 , c2 , c3 ) and no other point of the boundary apart from c 1 , c2 , c3 ; (iii) coincides with the union of two sides of (c1 , c2 , c3 ); (iv) coincides with the boundary of (c1 , c2 , c3 ); (v) coincides with (c1 , c2 , c3 ) (see [1, 4.71–4.78]). These striking examples and the results obtained in [7, 8] imply that if a(ζ) is not required to contain at most two points for every ζ ∈ T, then it is no longer possible to describe the (essential) spectrum of T (a) in terms of the cluster values of a. In other words, it is no longer sufficient to know the values of a, it is important to know “how these values are attained” by a. This field seems to be wide open at present. Since a complete description of the essential spectrum of T (a) in terms of the cluster values of a ∈ L∞ (T) is out of the question, it is natural to try finding “good” sufficient conditions for a point λ to belong to the essential spectrum. It is well known that a(T) is a subset of the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T), 1 < p < ∞ ([10], see also [5, 7.4] or [1, 2.30]). Hence we will assume from now on that λ ∈ a(T). The following result was obtained in [8]. 2π max{p,p } ,
Theorem 1.1. Let 1 < p < ∞, a ∈ L∞ (T), λ ∈ C \ a(T) and suppose that, for some ζ ∈ T, (I) ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) (or ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) ) contains at least two p–large arcs, (II) ∆λ (a(ζ)) contains at least one p–large arc.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Essential Spectra of Toeplitz Operators
129
Then λ belongs to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T) (i.e. T (a)−λI : H p (T) → H p (T) is not Fredholm ). Note that if a(ζ) consists of two points, then (I) implies (II) because it implies that a(ζ − 0) (or a(ζ + 0) respectively) consist of the same two points. Moreover, (I) is in this case exactly the condition from [2, 3] (see also [1, 5.54-5.58] and, for the matrix-valued case, [11]). It was shown in [8] that condition (I) is optimal in the following sense: for any compact K ⊂ C and λ ∈ C \ K such that ∆λ (K) contains at most one p–large arc there exists a ∈ L∞ (T) such that a(−1 ± 0) = a(T) = K and T (a) − λI : H r (T) → H r (T) is invertible for any r ∈ [min{p, p }, max{p, p }]. It is unclear on the other hand whether condition (II) can be dropped. The aim of this paper is to show that (II) can be relaxed: ∆λ (a(ζ)) can be substituted with a larger set ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) (or ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) respectively). It follows from A. B¨ ottcher’s examples mentioned above that in general there is no point outside a(T) which will always belong to the spectrum of T (a) : H 2 (T) → H 2 (T), unless a(ζ − 0) (or a(ζ + 0)) lies on a straight line. Our theorems 1.1 and 2.1 show that this is not the case if p = 2. While the first condition in theorems 1.1 and 2.1 means in the case p = 2 that the convex hull of a(ζ − 0) (of a(ζ + 0)) is a straight line segment containing λ, the set of λ’s satisfying the conditions of our theorems increases as p moves away from 2. This phenomenon is well known in the case when a(ζ) and a(ζ − 0) (or a(ζ + 0)) consist of two points (see [2, 3, 11] and [1, 5.54-5.58]).
2. Main Result Theorem 2.1. Let 1 < p < ∞, a ∈ L∞ (T), λ ∈ C \ a(T) and suppose that, for some ζ ∈ T, (i) ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) (or ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) ) contains at least two p–large arcs, (ii) ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) (or ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) respectively ) contains at least one p–large arc. Then λ belongs to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T). Proof. If p = 2 then (i) means that the convex hull of a(ζ − 0) (of a(ζ + 0)) is a straight line segment containing λ. Then λ belongs to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H 2 (T) → H 2 (T) even if (ii) is not satisfied (see, e.g., [8, Theorem 3]). Let us assume that p = 2. Suppose ∆λ (a(ζ − 0)) contains at least two p–large arcs and ∆λ (a(ζ + 0)) contains at least one p–large arc. The case of the opposite choice of “+” and “-” can be treated similarly. The proof is by contradiction and is similar to those from [3, 8]. Suppose λ does not belong to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T), i.e T (a−λ) = T (a) − λI is Fredholm. It can be assumed that |a − λ| = 1 almost everywhere on T (see [5, 8.2] or [1, 2.32]) and that T (a − λ) is invertible (see [5, 7.7]). Further, a − λ can be approximated in the L∞ (T)–norm by a function a0 ∈ L∞ (T) which satisfies the following conditions
130
Shargorodsky
IEOT
• |a0 | = 1 almost everywhere on T and T (a0 ) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible, • there exist an open arc γ− ⊂ T with the right end equal toζ and an open arc γ+ with the left end equal to ζ such that ∆0 a0 (ζ − 0) ∪ a0 (γ− ) contains at least two 2π p–large arcs strictly longer than max{p,p and ∆0 a0 (ζ + 0) ∪ a0 (γ+ ) contains }
2π at least one p–large arc strictly longer than max{p,p } . ∞ Then a0 = exp(iψ) and the real-valued ψ ∈ L (T) can be chosen in such a way that π π = , (2.1) ψ − (ϑ± − π) L∞ (γ± ) < π − max {p, p } min {p, p } π π , sup , (2.2) inf ψ(η) − ϑ0 > ψ(η) − ϑ0 < − max {p, p } max {p, p } η∈E η∈γ− \E where eiϑ± is the centre of one of the p–large arcs from ∆0 a0 (ζ ± 0) ∪ a0 (γ± ) mentioned above, eiϑ0 is the centre of another p–large arc from ∆0 a0 (ζ − 0) ∪ a0 (γ− ) , and E is a measurable subset of γ− such that both E ∩V and (γ− \E)∩V have positive measure for any left semi-neighbourhood V ⊂ T of ζ. Since T (a0 ) : H p (T) → H p (T) is invertible, a0 admits a generalized factor−1 p ¯−1 ¯− ∈ H p (T) and ization in Lp (T): a0 = a− a+ , where a+ , a − ∈ H (T), a+ , a “bar” means complex conjugation (see [10] or [5, 8.1, 8.3], [1, 5.4-5.5]). On the other hand, a0 = exp(iψ) = u− u+ , where
u± = exp
˜ i(ψ ± iψ) 2
and ψ˜ denotes the conjugate function (the Hilbert transform) of ψ. Further, r u±1 ¯±1 + ,u − ∈ H (T) for any positive r < π/ ψ ∞ (see, e.g., [4, Ch. III, proof of Corollary 2.6]). Suppose p < 2 (the case p > 2 can be treated similarly or reduced to the case p < 2 by duality). Then min {p, p } = p,
max {p, p } = p .
−1 −1 p The equality a− a+ = u− u+ implies a+ u−1 + = a− u− . Since a+ , a− ∈ L (T), it is not difficult to deduce from (2.1) and Zygmund’s theorem (see [12, Ch. VII, −1 2.11] or [4, Ch. III, Corollary 2.6]) that the function h = a+ u−1 + = a− u− is integrable over each closed subarc of γ± . Hence h admits an analytic continuation to C \ T \ (γ− ∪ γ+ ) (see, e.g., [9, Lemma 4] or [6, Lemma 3]). The point ζ is an isolated singularity of this function and it follows from [9, Theorem 6] that ζ cannot be an essential singularity (cf. [9, proof of Corollary 7]). Since ζ is either a removable singularity or a pole of h, there exists a neighbourhood of ζ in C which does not contain zeros of h apart from, possibly, ζ. We can therefore choose an arc γ ⊆ γ− which intersects both E and γ− \ E in sets of positive measure that are not arcs (modulo sets of measure 0) and on which 1/h is bounded.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Essential Spectra of Toeplitz Operators
131
˜ is integrable on γ, which Then u+ = h−1 a+ ∈ Lp (γ), i.e. |u+ |p = exp(−p ψ/2) contradicts (2.2) according to [8, Lemma]. Hence T (a) − λI : H p (T) → H p (T) cannot be Fredholm. Example. Suppose a ∈ L∞ (T), a(−1 − 0) = {±i} and a(−1 + 0) = {±1}. Then ∆0 (a(−1 − 0)) consists of two open arcs of length π and the same is true for ∆0 (a(−1 + 0)). Hence it follows from Theorem 2.1 that 0 belongs to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T) for any p ∈ (1, +∞). On the other hand, ∆0 (a(−1)) consists of four open arcs of length π/2 and Theorem 1.1 implies only that 0 belongs to the essential spectrum of T (a) : H p (T) → H p (T) for p ∈ (1, 4/3) ∪ (4, +∞). Acknowledgement I am grateful to the referee for useful suggestions which have improved the paper.
References [1] A. B¨ ottcher and B. Silbermann, Analysis of Toeplitz Operators. Springer-Verlag, 1990. [2] K. F. Clancey, One dimensional singular integral operators on Lp . J. Math. Anal. Appl. 54 (1976), 522-529. [3] K. F. Clancey, Corrigendum for the article “One dimensional singular integral operators on Lp ”. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 99 (1984), 527–529. [4] J. B. Garnett, Bounded Analytic Functions. Academic Press, 1981. [5] I. Gohberg and N. Krupnik, One-Dimensional Linear Singular Integral Equations I & II. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, 1992. [6] M. I. Haikin, An exceptional case of the homogeneous Riemann problem with a finite index of the coefficient. Izv. Vyssh. Uchebn. Zaved., Mat., 5(120) (1972), 92–103 (Russian). [7] E. Shargorodsky, On singular integral operators with coefficients from Pn C. Tr. Tbilis. Mat. Inst. Razmadze 93 (1990), 52-66 (Russian). [8] E. Shargorodsky, On some geometric conditions of Fredholmity of one-dimensional singular integral operators. Integral Equations Oper. Theory 20, No.1 (1994), 119– 123. [9] E. Shargorodsky and J. F. Toland, Riemann-Hilbert theory for problems with vanishing coefficients that arise in nonlinear hydrodynamics. J. Funct. Anal. 197, No.1 (2003), 283–300. [10] I. B. Simonenko, Some general questions in the theory of the Riemann boundary problem. Math. USSR, Izv. 2 (1968), 1091-1099. [11] I. M. Spitkovskij, Factorization of matrix-functions belonging to the classes A˜n (p) and TL. Ukr. Math. J. 35 (1983), 383–388 (translation from Ukr. Mat. Zh. 35, No.4 (1983), 455–460). [12] A. Zygmund, Trigonometric Series I & II. Cambridge University Press, 1988.
132
Shargorodsky
Eugene Shargorodsky Department of Mathematics King’s College London Strand, London WC2R 2LS UK e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: February 21, 2006 Revised: October 22, 2006
IEOT
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 133–151 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/010133-19, published online December 26, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1476-7
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
On the Inverse and Determinant of Certain Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators Harold Widom Abstract. The solution of a problem arising in integrable systems requires sharp asymptotics for the inverses and determinants of truncated WienerHopf operators, both in the regular case (where the non-truncated WienerHopf operator is invertible) and in singular cases. This paper treats two cases where the symbol of the Wiener-Hopf operator has Fisher-Hartwig singularities, one double zero or two simple zeros. We find formulas for the inverse that hold uniformly throughout the underlying interval with very small error, and formulas for the determinant with very small error. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 47B35. Keywords. Wiener-Hopf operator, Wiener-Hopf determinant, Fisher-Hartwig symbol.
1. Introduction and statement of results The solution of a problem arising in integrable systems [10] requires the asymptotics as α → ∞, with very small error, of the inverses and determinants of truncated Wiener-Hopf operators Wα (σ) acting on L2 (0, α), both in the regular case (where the Wiener-Hopf operator W (σ) on L2 (R+ ) is invertible) and in singular cases. This paper treats two cases where σ has simple Fisher-Hartwig singularities, one double zero or two simple zeros. We first state a result for the regular case. Assume σ belongs to the Wiener algebra of functions of the form a + kˆ with k ∈ L1 (R),1 and that ∞ σ(ξ) = 0, ∆ arg σ(ξ) = 0. (1) −∞
R ∞ ixξ ˆ Fourier transform we use is k(ξ) = −∞ e k(x) dx. For the Toeplitz case with a weaker assumption see [5, Th. 2.14]. For (2) itself see footnote 5.
1 The
134
Widom
IEOT
Then Wα (σ)−1 = Pα W (σ)−1 Pα − Qα H(1/σ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα + o(1).
(2)
The notation here is the following. The operators Pα is multiplication by χ(0,α) or extension by zero from (0, α) to (0, ∞), depending on the context. For functions defined on (0, α) we define (Qα f )(x) = f (α − x), we use H to denote Hankel operators as usual, and for a function v we define v˜(ξ) = v(−ξ). The term o(1) denotes a family of operators whose operator norms tend to zero as α → ∞. The functions σ± are the Wiener-Hopf factors of σ: their product equals σ, and ±1 ±1 σ− resp. σ+ extend to bounded analytic functions in the lower resp. upper half plane. ∞ If in addition −∞ |x| |k(x)|2 dx < ∞ then the Kac-Achieser formula holds: det Wα (σ) ∼ G(σ)α E(σ),
(3)
∞ 1 G(σ) = exp log σ(ξ) dξ , 2π −∞ ∞ 1 (log σ+ (ξ)) log σ− (ξ) dξ . E(σ) = exp 2πi −∞ In the present paper we assume that
where
σ(ξ) = (ξ 2 − p2 ) τ (ξ), where p is real, and τ is nonzero, has index zero, and its Wiener-Hopf factors τ± are of the order ξ −1 as ξ → ∞. In order to minimize technical details we make a very strong assumption, namely that eδ |x| k(x) ∈ L1 (R) for some δ > 0.2 This will result in an exponentially small error in the approximation. We make a choice of which Wiener-Hopf factor of σ incorporates which zero, and take the factors to be σ− (ξ) = i(ξ − p) τ− (ξ),
σ+ (ξ) = −i(ξ + p) τ+ (ξ).
As functions, we have 1 τ− (p) = + u− (ξ), σ− (ξ) i(ξ − p)
1 τ+ (p) = + u+ (ξ), σ+ (ξ) −i(ξ + p)
where u± are bounded smooth functions. In fact we think of σ± (ξ)−1 as distributions defined by 1 τ− (p) = + u− (ξ), σ− (ξ) 0 + i(ξ − p)
1 τ+ (p) = + u+ (ξ). σ+ (ξ) 0 − i(ξ + p)
Observe that if we set ep (x) = eipx then (0 − i(ξ + p))−1 is the Fourier transform of χ+ ep and (0 + i(ξ − p))−1 is the Fourier transform of χ− ep . (We write χ± for χR± .) 2 We
shall consistently use δ to denote some positive quantity, different for each occurrence.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
135
To state our first result for p = 0 we define ζ = H(1/σ+ ) ep ,
η = H(1/σ − ) ep ,
(here ep is thought of as restricted to R+ ) and A=
2ip . τ− (p) τ+ (−p) e−iαp − τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp
Theorem 1 (p = 0). There is a δ > 0 such that if A = O(eδα ) then Wα (σ) is invertible for large α and Wα (σ)−1 ≡ Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα − Qα H(1/σ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα iαp +A [e τ+ (p) τ− (−p) Pα ζ ⊗ Pα η − τ+ (p) τ+ (−p) Pα ζ ⊗ Qα ζ −τ− (p) τ− (−p) Qα η ⊗ Pα η + eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p) Qα η ⊗ Qα ζ]. This requires lots of explanation. First, the sign ≡ between two operators indicates that the difference is an integral operator whose kernel is uniformly O(e−δα ) for some δ > 0. There are tensor products in the statement. For functions v, w we define v⊗w to be the operator taking a function f to v (w, f ). (The inner product is the integral of the product—no complex conjugate.) In general we have v1 ⊗ w1 · v2 ⊗ w2 = (w1 , v2 ) v1 ⊗ w2 and (v ⊗ w) · T = v ⊗ T w, where T is the transpose of T . Next, we define W ((0 − i(ξ + p))−1 ) to be convolution by χ+ ep on (0, ∞). This is defined on any locally integrable function since x ((χ+ ep ) ∗ f )(x) = eipx e−ipy f (y) dy. 0
Our assumption on σ implies that u+ is a constant plus the Fourier transform of an exponentially decaying function,3 so W (u+ ) is defined on any function of at most polynomial growth. This extends the domain of W (1/σ+ ) to any function of at most polynomial growth. Similarly we define W ((0 + i(ξ − p))−1 ) to be convolution by χ− ep . This is defined only for functions in L1 since ∞ − ipx χ e−ipy f (y) dy. (( ep ) ∗ f )(x) = e x
1
+
Thus W (1/σ− ) acts on L (R ). Finally, there appear Hankel operators whose symbols are distributions. The symbol of H(1/σ+ ) is the Fourier transform of a constant times χ+ ep plus a rapidly decreasing function. Thus the operator has a singular part which can be written as a constant times ep ⊗ ep . Similarly for H(1/σ − ). In the statement of the theorem 3 Our assumption implies that σ (ξ) extends analytically to a strip around the real line and + that σ+ (ξ − iδ)−1 is in the Wiener algebra for sufficiently small δ > 0. Therefore, since (0 − i(ξ − iδ))−1 = −(δ + iξ)−1 is in the Wiener algebra, so is u+ (ξ − iδ). This implies that u+ is a constant plus the Fourier transform of a function with bound O(e−δx ).
136
Widom
IEOT
we see the product of two of these, or one of them acting on ep . We interpret these by going to the Fourier transforms. For example, from the general identity ∞ 1 vˆ(−ξ) w(ξ) ˆ dξ (v, w) = 2π −∞ we obtain
1 1 1 1 dξ = − , 2π 0 + i(ξ − p) 0 − i(ξ + p) 2ip since by going into the upper half-plane we pass the pole of the first factor at p + 0i. Similarly we find that H((0 − i(ξ + p)−1 ) ep = −ep /2ip. (Everything can be computed by first giving p a small positive imaginary part and then passing to the limit.) Although we shall be using distributions throughout they will all be of a simple form: Fourier transforms of linear combinations of e±p (combinations of 1 and x when p = 0) and exponentially decaying functions, and their restrictions to R± . Thus the meaning of the operators v → v± in Fourier transform space is clear: take the inverse Fourier transform, multiply by χ± , and then take the Fourier transform. The statement for p = 0 is simpler since Hankel operators with distribution symbol do not appear. We define σ+ B =α+i (0), σ− (χ+ ep , χ+ ep ) =
where the factors are chosen so that τ− (0) = τ+ (0).4 Theorem 2 (p = 0). The operator Wα (σ) is invertible for sufficiently large α and Wα (σ)−1 ≡ Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα − Qα H(u − ) H(u+ ) Qα −1 −B [Qα H(u − )1 + Pα W (1/σ+ )1] ⊗ [Qα H(u+ )1 + Pα W (1/σ − )1]. (4) There are several results in the literature giving first-order asymptotic results for the inverse when the symbol has a single singularity or zero. The method of [9] gives a first-order result in terms of convergence in operator norm. Rambour and Seghier [8] considered the Toeplitz case for a symbol with a zero of arbitrary even order and obtained a stronger result in these cases. Ehrhardt [6] obtained results in the Toeplitz case for a general class of symbols with several Fisher-Hartwig singularities, with convergence in the operator norms of weighted 2 spaces, although they do not apply to symbols with two real zeros. In this work, too, distributions played an important role. None of these serves our present purpose, which is to find formulas that hold uniformly throughout (0, α) with very small error. An earlier and more involved derivation of (4) than the one we give here is in [11]. The present proof will use a uniformity in the lemma to Theorem 1 and then a passage to the limit. The computation would be tedious if done by hand and we 4 Without
this normalization the second term is to be multiplied by (τ− /τ+ )(0) = −(σ− /σ+ )(0).
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
137
resorted to computer computation. For the skeptical reader we give a direct proof in §7, along the lines of the proof of Theorem 1. For the determinants we assume that in addition log σ ∈ L1 . We use ≡ here to indicate that the difference of the two sides is O(e−δα ) for some δ > 0. Now we define ∞ 1 G(σ) = exp (log σ+ + log σ− ) dξ , 2π −∞ ∞ 1 (log σ+ ) log σ− dξ . E(σ) = exp 2πi −∞ In the integrals log σ+ is interpreted as log (ξ + p+ 0i) plus a regular function while log σ− is log (ξ − p − 0i) plus a regular function. These depend on our choice of factors σ± . For p = 0 the result is Theorem 3 (p = 0). We have as α → ∞ det Wα (σ) τ− (p) τ+ (−p) − τ+ (p) τ− (−p) e2iαp E(σ). ≡ α G(σ) τ+ (−p) τ− (p)
(5)
For p = 0 the result is Theorem 4 (p = 0). We have as α → ∞ det Wα (σ) ≡ B E(σ). G(σ)α This may be rewritten det Wα (σ) = α E(σ) + i G(σ)α
σ+ σ−
(6)
(0) E(σ) + O(e−δα ).
Thus it gives the second-order asymptotics with very small error. The first-order asymptotics were obtained by Mikaelyan [7]. In the special case σ0 (ξ) = ξ 2 /(1+ξ 2 ) one has Wα (σ0 ) = e−α (1 + α/2) exactly, as was also shown in [7]. Exact formulas for arbitrary rational symbols were obtained by B¨ ottcher [2] and used by him to obtain further asymptotic results in these cases. For the Toeplitz analogue the asymptotics are known for symbols with any number of zeros [3]. (Or see [4, §10.47].) For Wiener-Hopf operators the case of two simple zeros was considered in [1], but the result was obtained only for τ real and positive. In §6 we show that our formula agrees with the one obtained there. Here is how the approximate inverse in Theorem 1 is obtained. Since (2) holds for regular symbols we consider −1 −1 ) W (σ− ) Pα − Qα H(1/σ Pα W (σ+ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα
(7)
138
Widom
IEOT
a possible first approximation for singular symbols. So we see what happens when we multiply it by Wα (σ) on the left. We find that, with small error, the result is I plus an operator of rank two. The form of this operator suggests the ingredients of a rank two operator that should have been added to (7) to obtain I in the end. A simple computation tells us exactly which operator to take, and the rest is straightforward. For the determinants we introduce a parameter, use the formula for the logarithmic derivative in terms of the inverse, and apply the earlier results.
2. Proof of Theorem 1 Lemma. Define Tα = Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα − Qα H(1/σ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα +A eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p) Pα ζ ⊗ Pα η − τ+ (p) τ+ (−p) Pα ζ ⊗ Qα ζ
−τ− (p) τ− (−p) Qα η ⊗ Pα η + eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p) Qα ζ ⊗ Qα η .
(8)
Then if δ is small enough we have, uniformly in p, Wα (σ) Tα = I + O(A e−δα ),
Tα Wα (σ) = I + O(A e−δα ).
Proof. We shall use, innumerable times and without comment, the identities σ2 ) Pα − Qα H( σ1 ) H(σ2 ) Qα , W (σ1 ) Wα (σ2 ) = Wα (σ1 σ2 ) − Pα H(σ1 ) H( and H(σ1 σ2 ) = W (σ1 ) H(σ2 ) + H(σ1 ) W (σ˜2 ), and their familiar consequences. (For the Toeplitz analogues of the stated identities see [4, §2.17 and §7.8].) Let us multiply (7) by Wα (σ) on the left. We have −1 Wα (σ) Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα = Wα (σ) Wα (1/σ+ ) W (σ− ) Pα = [Wα (σ− ) − Qa H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα ] W (1/σ− ) Pα = I − Qa H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) Pα W (1/σ − ) Qα = I − Qa H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) W (1/σ ) Q − α
+Qa H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) (I − Pα ) W (σ −
−1
) Qα .
The first two terms combine as σ ) H(1/(σ+ σ− )) Qα . I − Qα H(˜ Similarly, σ ) Pα H(1/σ −Wα (σ) Qα H(1/σ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα = −Qα W (˜ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα = −Qα W (˜ σ ) H(1/σ ) H(1/σ ) Q + Q W (˜ σ ) (I − P ) H(1/ σ − + α α α − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα . The first term here is Qα H(˜ σ ) W (1/σ− ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα = Qα H(˜ σ ) H(1/(σ− σ+ )) Qα ,
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
139
cancelling the same term above. It follows that Wα (σ) times (7) equals I plus 5 Qa H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) (I−Pα ) W (1/σ σ ) (I−Pα ) H(1/σ − ) Qα +Qα W (˜ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα .
For convenience we set c− = τ− (p),
c+ = τ+ (−p).
The Hankel operator H(1/σ+ ) on the left above is the sum of two terms. One is c−1 + ep ⊗ ep while the other is H(u+ ). Consider the contribution of the latter. It has kernel O(e−δ (x+y) ), so H(u+ ) (I − Pα ) has kernel O(e−δ α e−δ (x+y) ). Since the kernels of both H(˜ σ ) and (I − Pα ) W (1/σ − ) Qα are bounded it follows that the contribution of the H(u+ ) summand of H(1/σ+ ) in the first term is O(e−δα ). Similarly so is the contribution of the H(u − ) summand of H(1/σ − ) in the second term. All this is uniform in p. Therefore with this error the above may be replaced by 1 1 Qa H(˜ σ )ep ⊗Qα W (1/σ− ) (I−Pα ) ep + Qα W (˜ σ )(I−Pα ) ep ⊗Qα H(1/σ+ ) ep . c+ c− v ) ep , which comes from Using the general fact Qα W (v) (I − Pα ) ep = eiαp Pα H(˜ ∞ ∞ V (α − x − y) eipy dy = V (−x − y) eip(α+y) dy, α
0
we see that the above equals eiαp eiαp Qa H(˜ σ )ep ⊗ Pα H(1/σ Pα H(σ) ep ⊗ Qα H(1/σ+ ) ep − ) ep + c+ c− eiαp eiαp = Qa H(˜ σ )ep ⊗ Pα η + Pα H(σ) ep ⊗ Qα ζ, c+ c− in our notation. This suggests that we add to our first guess a linear combination of tensor products with right factors Pα η and Qα ζ. By symmetry (or taking transposes of the above applied to σ ˜ ) the left factors should be Pα ζ and Qα η. So it should be of the form (a Pα ζ + b Qα η) ⊗ η + (c Pα ζ + d Qα η) ⊗ Qα ζ. To see if this works, we compute Wα (σ) Pα ζ and Wα (σ) Qα η. We have Wα (σ) Pα ζ
5 In
= = ≡
Pα W (σ) Pα H(1/σ+ ) ep −1 Pα W (σ) H(1/σ+ ) ep − Pα W (σ) (I − Pα ) H(σ+ ) ep 1 −Pα H(σ) W (1/σ + ) ep + 2ip c+ Pα W (σ) (I − Pα ) ep
=
− σ+1(p) Pα H(σ) ep +
eiαp 2ip c+
(9)
Qα H(˜ σ ) ep .
the regular case with the stated conditions the Hankel operators are all compact, so this operator is o(1). Similarly for the one obtained by multiplying by Wα (σ) on the right. This gives (2) almost immediately. With the stronger assumption on σ this operator is O(e−δα ).
140
Widom
IEOT
Similarly σ) η Wα (σ) Qα η = Qα Wα (˜ 1 Qα H(˜ σ ) ep + ≡ − σ− (−p)
eiαp 2ip c−
Pα H(σ) ep .
This will cancel the previous extra terms when we add, if our coefficients are such that in a Pα ζ + b Qα η the coefficient of Pα H(σ) ep is zero while the coefficient of Qα H(˜ σ ) ep is −eiαp /c+ , and in c Pα ζ + d Qα η the coefficient of Qα H(˜ σ ) ep is zero while that of Pα H(σ) ep is −eiαp /c− . We see that this does occur when 2ip σ− (−p) σ+ (p) e2iαp (2ip)3 τ− (−p) τ+ (p) e2iαp = , ∆ ∆
a=
(2ip)2 c− σ− (−p) eiαp (2ip)3 τ− (p) τ− (−p) eiαp =− , ∆ ∆ (2ip)2 c+ σ+ (p) eiαp (2ip)3 τ+ (p) τ+ (−p) eiαp c= =− , ∆ ∆ 2ip σ− (−p) σ+ (p) e2iαp (2ip)3 τ− (−p) τ+ (p) e2iαp d= = , ∆ ∆ b=
where ∆ = (2ip)2 c− c+ − e2iαp σ− (−p) σ+ (p) =
(2ip)3 eiαp . A
Thus a = τ− (−p) τ+ (p) eiαp A, c = −τ+ (p) τ+ (−p) A,
b = −τ− (p) τ− (−p) A,
d = τ− (−p) τ+ (p) eiαp A.
This tells us that when we define Tα by (8) then the first statement of the lemma holds. (The reason for the extra factor A in the statement is that the error inherent in (9) gets multiplied by a factor proportional to A.) The second is obtained by applying the first to σ ˜ and taking transposes. This completes the proof of the Lemma. Proof of Theorem 1. The theorem follows from the relations of the lemma by using the easily checked fact that Tα differs from I by an integral operator whose kernel is O(α).
3. Proof of Theorem 2 Since the statement of the lemma to Theorem 1 holds uniformly in p, we need only compute the p → 0 limit of Tα to obtain its analogue when p = 0. The computations simplify if we take τ± (0) = 1, which we may do since the theorem for the general case follows by applying the special case to the symbol σ(ξ)/τ (0). We easily compute that (0) − τ+ (0)))−1 + O(p) = −B −1 + O(p). A = −(α + i(τ−
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
141
For the rest, a tedious but straightforward computation6 shows that all terms of (8) except for the first combine as −B −1 times [Pα H(u+ )1−Qα H(u − )1−x+iτ+ (0)]⊗[Pα H(u − )1−Qα H(u+ )1−x−iτ− (0)]+O(p).
(All terms involving p−1 cancel.) Now W (1/σ+ )1 = x + W (u+ )1, while H(u+ )1 has Fourier transform u+ − u+ (0) u+ − u+ (0) =− , 0 + iξ 0 − iξ + + so H(u+ )1 = −W (u+ )1 + u+ (0) = −W (u+ )1 − iτ+ (0). (Observe that τ± (ξ) = 1 ∓ iξ u± (ξ).) Therefore W (1/σ+ )1 = x − H(u+ )1 − iτ+ (0),
and similarly for the right-hand side of the tensor product. Therefore the tensor product equals [Pα W (1/σ+ )1 + Qα H(u − )1] ⊗ [Pα W (1/σ − )1 + Qα H(u+ )1]. Thus if we set Tα0 = Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα − Qα H(u − ) H(u+ ) Qα −1 −B [Qα H(u − )1 + Pα W (1/σ+ )1] ⊗ [Qα H(u+ )1 + Pα W (1/σ − )1], (10) then we have Wα (σ) Tα0 = I + O(A e−δα ),
Tα0 Wα (σ) = I + O(A e−δα ).
This gives the statement of Theorem 2 when we check that an integral operator whose kernel is O(α).
Tα0
(11)
differs from I by
4. Proof of Theorem 3 Suppose we want to prove (5) for a symbol σ1 . If we take any other σ0 of the same form we can write σ1 = σ0 eρ , and we define the family σ = σλ = σ0 eλ ρ where λ ∈ [0, 1]. We assume first that A satisfies the bound in the statement of Theorem 1 for all λ ∈ [0, 1], so that we can use its conclusion and the relation d log det Wα (σ) = tr Wα (σ)−1 Wα (σρ). dλ The operator on the right is Wα (σ)−1 [Wα (σ) Wα (ρ) + Pα H(σ) H(˜ ρ) Pα + Qα H(˜ σ ) H(ρ) Qα ] ρ) Pα + Qα H(˜ σ ) H(ρ) Qα ]. = Wα (ρ) + Wα (σ)−1 [Pα H(σ) H(˜ 6 The
tedious computation was done by Maple.
(12)
142
Widom
IEOT
We look first at
ρ) Pα , tr Wα (σ)−1 Pα H(σ) H(˜ and in particular to the contribution to this of bracketed expression in (8) with its factor A. First, the factors Pα may be removed with error O(e−δα ). Then H(˜ ρ) may be moved around to the left, so the trace of the product ≡ A times that of eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p) H(˜ ρ) ζ ⊗ H(σ) η − τ+ (p) τ+ (−p) H(˜ ρ) ζ ⊗ H(σ) Qα ζ iαp −τ− (p) τ− (−p) H(˜ ρ) Qα η ⊗ H(σ) η + e τ+ (p) τ− (−p) H(˜ ρ) Qα ζ ⊗ H(σ) Qα η.
The function H(σ) Qα ζ contains as a summand H(σ) Qα H(u+ ) ep (the rest comes from the ep ⊗ ep part oh H(1/σ+ )), and this is O(e−δα ) since H(σ) and H(u+ ) have exponentially decaying kernels. Similarly for Qα η. Therefore with this error we may make the replacements Qα ζ → −
eiαp eiαp e−p , e−p = − 2ip c+ 2ip τ+ (−p)
eiαp eiαp e−p . e−p = − 2ipc− 2ip τ+ (p) Next, for any plus function v+ the Fourier transform of H(v+ )ep is v+ v+ (p) − v+ . = 0 + i(ξ − p) + 0 − i(ξ − p) Qα η → −
Therefore if we denote the Fourier transform by F we have in particular Fη=
−1 −1 −1 σ (2ip τ− (−p))−1 + σ − σ − (p) − − =− , 0 − i(ξ − p) 0 − i(ξ − p)
and similarly Fζ=
−1 −1 (2ip τ+ (p))−1 + σ+ σ+ (p)−1 − σ+ =− . 0 − i(ξ − p) 0 − i(ξ − p)
If we make these substitutions we find that we are left with four tensor products, only two of which have nonzero coefficients. We show them below with their coefficients. e2iαp A−1 , − (13) H(˜ ρ) e−p ⊗ H(σ) e−p , 2ip τ+ (−p) τ− (p) −1 −1 σ+ σ − ⊗ H(σ) F −1 , eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p). H(˜ ρ) F −1 0 − i(ξ − p) 0 − i(ξ − p) (14) Next we consider Pα H(σ) H(˜ ρ) Pα multiplied on the left by the −1 . Again, because of the Qα we may Qα H(1/σ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα part of Wα (σ) make the replacements −1 iαp e−p ⊗ ep , Qα H(1/σ − ) → c− e
iαp H(1/σ+ ) Qα → c−1 ep ⊗ e−p , + e
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
143
the product of these being −
e2iαp e−p ⊗ e−p , 2ip c− c+
and after bringing the H(˜ ρ) around, the corresponding tensor product is H(˜ ρ) e−p ⊗ H(σ) e−p with the factor e2iαp . − 2ip τ+ (−p) τ− (p) This cancels the term in (13) when we multiply it by A and subtract t his one. To compute the trace of the term in (14) we note that the factor on the right has Fourier transform −1 σ− σ+ σ =− 0 + i(ξ + p) 0 − i(ξ + p) +
since σ+ (−p) = 0. Therefore the inner product of the two factors is −1 σ+ σ+ 1 1 ρ− dξ = − dξ − ρ 2π 0 − i(ξ − p) 0 − i(ξ + p) 2π (0 − i(ξ − p)) (0 − i(ξ + p)) and so the trace with its factor (and the factor A) is A eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p)
ρ− (p) − ρ− (−p) . 2ip
(15)
As for the Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα part of the inverse, this is ≡ the trace of W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) H(σ) H(˜ ρ) = W (1/σ+ ) H(σ+ ) H(˜ ρ) = −H(1/σ+ ) W (σ ) H(˜ ρ ) = −H(1/σ ) H(˜ ρ σ ). + + + The trace (including the minus sign) equals 1 1 −1 (ρ σ+ ) σ+ ρ− (log σ+ ) dξ, dξ = (16) 2πi 2πi since ρ dξ = 0. So (15)+(16) is the contribution of the Pα H(σ) H(˜ ρ) Pα term in (12) to the σ ) H(ρ) Qα term, observe that trace. For the contribution of the Qα H(˜ σ ) H(ρ) Qα = Qα Wα (˜ σ ) −1 H(˜ σ ) H(ρ) Qα , Wα (σ) −1 Qα H(˜ which has the same trace as σ ) −1 H(˜ σ ) H(ρ) Pα . Wα (˜ Hence we need only replace σ by σ ˜ everywhere in what we derivated above. Then we add two and we get ρ− (p) − ρ− (−p) + ρ+ (−p) − ρ+ (p) A eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p) 2ip 1 + [ρ− (log σ+ ) − ρ+ (log σ− ) ] dξ. 2πi
144
Widom
And finally we have to add to this tr Wα (ρ) =
α 2π
IEOT
ρ(ξ) dξ.
What is this the derivative of? Since (d/dλ) log σ = ρ, for the last term the answer is α log σ(ξ) dξ. 2π Here we use our chosen factorization of σ to define the logarithm. For the next to last terms, since (d/dλ) log σ± = ρ± we have d (log σ+ ) log σ− dξ = [ρ+ log σ− + (log σ+ ) ρ− ] dξ, dλ so the middle term is d/dλ of 1 2πi
(log σ+ ) log σ− dξ.
For the first term we compute that since dτ± /dλ = ρ± τ± , d 1 d log A = log dλ dλ τ− (p) τ+ (−p) e−iαp − τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp −(ρ− (p) + ρ+ (−p)) τ− (p) τ+ (−p) e−iαp + (ρ+ (p) + ρ− (−p)) τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp = . τ− (p) τ+ (−p) e−iαp − τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp In the numerator we add (ρ− (p) + ρ+ (−p)) τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp to the first summand and subtract it from the first. Then the quotient becomes −ρ− (p) − ρ+ (−p) − A eiαp τ+ (p) τ− (−p)
ρ− (p) − ρ− (−p) + ρ+ (−p) − ρ+ (p) , 2ip
and so the first term is the logarithmic derivative of (τ+ (−p) τ− (p) A)−1 , which is the same as the logarithmic derivative of τ− (p) τ+ (−p) e−iαp − τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp . τ+ (−p) τ− (p) Putting this together gives the logarithmic derivative of det Wα (σ) with error O(e−δα ). Integrating and exponentiating gives 1 det Wα (σ) ≡ C exp ) log σ dξ (log σ + − G(σ)α 2πi (17) −iαp τ− (p) τ+ (−p) e − τ+ (p) τ− (−p) eiαp × , τ+ (−p) τ− (p) where C is a constant independent of λ.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
145
This was derived under the assumption that, for all λ, A = O(eδα ) for some small δ, which means that 2iαp is not exponentially close to any of the values of τ− (p) τ+ (−p) , (18) log τ+ (p) τ− (−p) in particular if 2iαp is bounded away from these values. Assume that this is so for our original σ1 , and suppose we had taken σ0 (ξ) =
ξ 2 − p2 , (q1 − iξ) (q2 + iξ)
with q1 , q2 in the right half-plane. The corresponding quotient in (18) is q1 − ip q2 − ip . q1 + ip q2 + ip Each factor maps the right half-plane to the lower half-plane, so with proper choice of qi the ratio can be made arbitrarily close to the ratio in (18) coming from σ1 . The values of (18) for σλ depend linearly on λ, so for this choice 2iαp will be bounded away from the values of (18) for all λ ∈ [0, 1]. Therefore (17) holds for some C. We have [2, Prop. 5.2] det Wα (σ0 ) =e
−α(q1 +q2 )
(q1 + ip) (q2 + ip) eiαp − (q1 − ip) (q2 − ip) e−α(p1 +p2 )/2 , 2ip (q1 + q2 )
and a computation shows that for this σ0 (17) holds when C = eiαp . This proves the theorem for our symbol σ1 under the condition that 2iαp is bounded away from the values of (18). To remove the condition, suppose that it is very close to one of these values. Replace σ1 by σ1 eλρ , with ρ now any symbol such that ρ− (p) ρ+ (−p) = 1, ρ+ (p) ρ− (−p) and let λ run over a little (but not too little) circle around zero. Then the corrrespoinding values of (18) will run over circles about the original ones, and so 2iαp will be bounded away from them, uniformly in λ. By analyticity of the two sides in our formula, their values at λ = 0 are obtained by integrating with respect to λ over the circle. We deduce that the difference of the two sides, which is exponentially small uniformly for λ on the circle, is also exponentially small for λ = 0.
5. Proof of Theorem 4 One can check that the right-hand side of (6) is the limit of the right-hand side of (5) as p → 0. Unfortunately it is not clear from our derivation that (5) holds uniformly in p, although it surely does. Fortunately the derivation of Theorem 4 from Theorem 2 is a lot easier than the derivation of Theorem 3 from Theorem 1, so we proceed with it.
146
Widom
IEOT
We start in the same way, with (12). As before, the first term has trace α ρ(ξ) dξ, 2π and we proceed to the contribution of tr Wα (σ)−1 Pα H(σ) H(˜ ρ) Pα . −1 −1 ) W (σ− ) Pα part of the inverse is The contribution of the Pα W (σ+ 1 ρ− (log σ+ ) dξ. 2πi
(19)
as before. The contribution of the rest of Wα (σ)−1 is the trace of −Qα H(u − ) H(u+ ) Qα −1
−1 −B [Qα H(u )1] − )1 + Pα W (σ+ )1] ⊗ [Qα H(u+ )1 + Pα W (σ − right-multiplied by Pα H(σ) H(˜ ρ) Pα . In computing the trace we may, as before, move the H(˜ ρ) Pα around to the left. As we saw earlier, any trace involving two Hankel operator with nonsingular symbol with the operator Qα between them will be O(e−δα ). With similar error we may remove the factors Pα . So with this error the trace reduces to that of −1
−1 ρ) W (σ+ )1 ⊗ H(σ) W (σ −B −1 H(˜ −
−1
)1.
The Fourier transform of the second factor is −1 σ− σ+ , = σ 0 + iξ iξ +
while the Fourier transform of the first factor is −1 σ + ρ˜ . 0 + iξ +
The ρ˜ may be replaced by ρ˜+ , and the result after replacing ξ by −ξ is −1 σ+ ρ− . 0 − iξ −
Notice that the expression in parenthesis has the singularity (0 − iξ)−2 . When we multiply by the preceding and integrate we may remove the minus subscript, and we see that the trace in question equals ρ− (ξ) 1 dξ = i ρ− (0). 2π (0 − iξ)2 So the contribution of the Pα H(σ) H(˜ ρ) Pα factor is −iB −1 ρ− (0), which is to be added to (19). Similarly (or by applying the preceding to σ ˜ ) we compute the contribution of the Qα H(˜ σ ) H(ρ) Qα term. Adding the two gives 1 1 ρ− (log σ+ ) dξ − ρ+ (log σ− ) dξ + iB −1 (ρ− (0) − ρ+ (0)). 2πi 2πi
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
147
Thus the logarithmic derivative of the determinant equals 1 α 1 ρ(ξ) dξ + ρ− (log σ+ ) dξ + ρ+ log σ− dξ 2π 2πi 2πi +iB −1 (ρ− (0) − ρ+ (0)) + O(e−δα ). The first term is the logarithmic derivative of G(σ)α , and the next two terms combine as the logarithmic derivative of 1 (log σ+ ) log σ− dξ , exp 2πi as we saw in the last section. Since (see footnote 4) σ+ B = α − i log + λ (ρ+ − ρ− ) (0), σ− the last term above is the logarithmic derivative of B. This proves the theorem with a constant factor C on the right-hand side. Taking the special case σ0 (ξ) = ξ 2 /(1 + ξ 2 ) shows that C = 1.
6. Comparison with the formula of [1] We show here that (5) agrees with the result of [1]. Take p > 0. We define two contours, both going from −∞ to ∞. Contour C1 has an indentation above −p and below p, while C2 has an indentation below −p and above p. Each has its own geometric mean Gi (σ) and constant Ei (σ). These are defined by integrals over Ci with integrands involving the associated factorizations. Our factorization σ = σ− σ+ is associated with C1 . Thus G(σ) = G1 (σ), E(σ) = E1 (σ), and if we think of the right-hand side of (5) as a sum then G(σ)α times the first summand is exactly G1 (σ)α E1 (σ). For the other terms we first express our exponential factor E1 (σ) in terms of E2 (σ). We have 1 log((ξ + p) τ+ ) log((ξ − p)τ− ) dξ log E1 (σ) = 2πi C1 =
1 2πi
∞−iδ
−∞−iδ
log((ξ + p) τ+ ) log((ξ − p)τ− ) dξ − log(−2p τ− (−p)),
1 log E2 (σ) = 2πi =
1 2πi
∞−iδ −∞−iδ
C2
log((ξ − p) τ+ ) log((ξ + p)τ− ) dξ
log((ξ − p) τ+ ) log((ξ + p)τ− ) dξ − log(2p τ− (p)),
148
Widom
IEOT
since for the first we pass the pole at ξ = −p and for the second the pole at ξ = −p. For the two resulting integrals, both over the contour in the lower half-plane, the first one minus the second equals 1 1 ξ−p ξ+p dξ + log((ξ − p) τ− ) dξ (log τ+ ) log log 2πi ξ+p 2πi ξ−p 1 =− 2πi
1 ξ−p ξ+p dξ + log((ξ − p) τ− ) dξ log τ+ log log ξ+p 2πi ξ−p = − log τ+ (p) + log τ+ (−p).
Putting these together shows that E1 (σ) = −
τ− (p) τ+ (−p) E2 (σ). τ− (−p) τ+ (p)
Finally, we compute that G1 (σ)/G2 (σ) = e−2ip . Thus e2iαp G(σ)α = G2 (σ)α , so G(σ)α times the second summand in our formula is exactly G2 (σ)α E2 (σ). Hence our result can be stated det Wα (σ) = G1 (σ)α (E1 (σ) + O(e−δα )) + G2 (σ)α (E2 (σ) + O(e−δα )), which, except for the size of the error terms, agrees with [1].
7. Another proof of Theorem 2 As before, we may assume τ− (0) = τ+ (0). We begin by multiplying Wα (σ) on the right by Tα0 , given by (10). For the product with Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα we obtain as before Wα (σ) Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα = I − Qa H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) Pα W (1/σ − ) Qα , but now we write H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) Pα W (1/σ −)
−1
σ ) H(u+ ) Pα W (σ = H(˜ σ ) (1 ⊗ 1) Pα W (1/σ − ) + H(˜ − σ ) H(u+ ) W (1/σ ≡ H(˜ σ ) (1 ⊗ 1) Pα W (1/σ − ) + H(˜ −) σ ) H(u+ /σ− ). = H(˜ σ ) (1 ⊗ 1) Pα W (1/σ − ) + H(˜
)
This is to be left- and right-multiplied by Qα . Next, for the product with Qα H(u − ) H(u+ ) Qα we have Wα (σ) Qα H(u σ ) Pα H(u − ) H(u+ ) Qα = Qα W (˜ − ) H(u+ ) Qα ≡ Qα W (˜ σ ) H(u − ) H(u+ ) Qα ,
(20)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
149
and we compute σ u σ ) W (u− )] H(u+ ) W (˜ σ ) H(u − ) H(u+ ) = [H(˜ − ) − H(˜ σ ) H(u− u+ ) = H(˜ σ u − ) H(u+ ) − H(˜ 1 1 1 1 − σ ) H u+ − =H σ ˜ H(u+ ) − H(˜ σ 0 − iξ σ− 0 + iξ − σ ˜ u+ =H σ) H H(u+ ) + H(˜ − H(˜ σ ) H(u+ /σ− ). 0 + iξ 0 + iξ Here we used the fact that σ ˜ (0) = 0. The last term here cancels the same term appearing in (20). The first two terms we may write as 1 1 H(˜ σ) W σ) W H(u+ ) + H(˜ H(u+ ). 0 − iξ 0 + iξ Since
1 1 + = 2πδ = ˆ1, 0 − iξ 0 − iξ
these terms combine as H(˜ σ ) (1 ⊗ 1) H(u+ ). Putting together what we have done gives Wα (σ) [Pα W (1/σ+ ) W (1/σ− ) Pα − Qα H(1/σ − ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα ] σ ) (1 ⊗ 1) Pα W (1/σ σ ) (1 ⊗ 1) H(u+ )] Qα . ≡ I − Qα [H(˜ − ) + H(˜ For the right-hand side of the first tensor product we use Qα 1 = Pα 1 to see that (Pα W (1/σ − ) Qα ) 1 = Qα W (1/σ− ) Pα 1 = Pα W (1/σ − ) Qα 1 = Pα W (1/σ − ) Pα 1 = Pα W (1/σ − ) 1.
Thus the right-hand side above equals I − Qα H(˜ σ )1 ⊗ [Pα W (1/σ − )1 + Qα H(u+ )1]. Next, we will not make a guess as we did in the proof of the lemma since we are sure know the answer. So let us just continue by computing −1 −1 Wα (σ) [Qα H(u σ ) H(u − )1+Pα W (σ+ )1] = Qα W (˜ − )1+Pα W (σ) Pα W (σ+ ) Pα 1.
The first summand equals 1 1 Qα H σ ˜ − σ ) W (u− )1 1 − Qα H(˜ σ 0 − iξ − σ ˜ σ) 1 = Qα H 1 − u− (0) Qα H(˜ 0 + iξ 1 = Qα H(˜ σ) W σ ) 1, 1 − u− (0) Qα H(˜ 0 − iξ The second summand equals Pα W (σ− ) Pα 1 − α Qα H(˜ σ ) H(1/σ+ ) Qα .
150
Widom
IEOT
Using H(1/σ+ ) = 1 ⊗ 1 + H(u+ ) and 1 ⊗ Pα 1 = α 1 ⊗ 1 we see that this is ≡ to σ )1 − Qα H(˜ σ ) H(u+ )1. Pα W (σ− ) Pα 1 − α Qα H(˜ Since H(u+ )1 = −W (u+ )1 + u+ (0) when we combine the terms we get −1 σ )1 + Qα H(˜ σ ) W (σ+ )1 − (u+ (0) + u− (0)) Qα H(˜ σ )1. Pα W (σ− ) Pα 1 − α Qα H(˜
Since, as already observed, u± (0) = ∓i τ± (0), the coefficient in the last term equals −i (τ+ /τ− ) (0) = i (σ+ /σ− ) (0). Therefore the above equals −1 σ ) W (σ+ ) 1 − B Qα H(˜ σ )1. Pα W (σ− ) Pα 1 + Qα H(˜ −1 Let us show that the first two terms cancel. We have H(˜ σ ) W (σ+ ) 1 = H(σ − ) 1. Since σ− (0) = 0 this has Fourier transform σ − /iξ, which is minus the Fourier transform of W (σ − ) 1. Therefore the second term above equals
−Qα W (σ − ) 1 = −Qα W (σ − ) Pα 1 = −Pα W (σ− ) Qα 1 = −Pα W (σ− ) Pα 1. We computed above what we obtain when we left-multiply the first two terms in (10) by Wα (σ). What we just computed shows that if we do the same with the last term and add, what results is I + O(e−δα ). Similarly for multiplication on the right. (Or apply the preceding to σ ˜ and take the transpose.) This gives (11) and hence the statement of the theorem. Acknowledgements We thank Albrecht B¨ ottcher for very helpful comments. This work was supported by National Science Foundation grant DMS-0552388.
References [1] S. Albeverio and K. A. Makarov, Extension of the Ahiezer-Kac determinnat formula to the case of real-valued symbols with two real zeros, Acta Applic. Math. 62 (2000) 155–186. [2] A. B¨ ottcher, Wiener-Hopf determinants with rational symbols, Math. Nachr. 144 (1989) 39–64. [3] A. B¨ ottcher and B. Silbermann, The asymptotic behavior of Toeplitz determinants for a generating function with zeros of integral order, Math. Nachr. 102 (1981) 79–105. [4] A. B¨ ottcher and B. Silbermann, Analysis of Toeplitz Operators, Akademie-Verlag Berlin (1989). [5] A. B¨ ottcher and B. Silbermann, Introduction to Large Truncated Toeplitz Matrices, Springer-Verlag New York (1998). [6] T. Ehrhardt, A status report on the asymptotic behavior of Toeplitz determinants with Fisher-Hartwig singularities, Oper. Th.: Adv. Appl. 124 (2001) 217–241. [7] L. V. Mikaelyan, Asymptotics of determinants of truncated Wiener-Hopf operators in a singular case, (Russian) Akad. Nauk Armyan. SSR Dokl. 82 (1986) 151–155. [8] P. Rambour and A. Seghier, Exact and asymptotic inverse of the Toeplitz matrix with polynomial singular symbol, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, Ser. I 335 (2002) 705–710.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Truncated Wiener-Hopf Operators
151
[9] H. Widom, Extreme eigenvalues of N-dimensional convolution operators, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 106 (1963) 391–414. [10] H. Widom, Asymptotics of a class of operator determinants with application to the cylindrical Toda equations, arXiv: nlin.SI/0605021. [11] H. Widom, On the inverse and determinant of a truncated Wiener-Hopf operator, arXiv: math.FA/0605076, v2. Harold Widom Department of Mathematics University of California Santa Cruz, CA 95064 USA e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: October 2, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 153–166 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020153–152, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1448-y
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Characteristic Functions for Multicontractions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball Chafiq Benhida and Dan Timotin Abstract. A multicontraction on a HilbertP space H is an n-tuple of operators ∗ T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) acting on H, such that n i=1 Ti Ti ≤ 1H . We obtain some results related to the characteristic function of a commuting multicontraction, most notably discussing its behaviour with respect to the action of the analytic automorphisms of the unit ball. Keywords. Characteristic function, multicontraction, analytic automorphism.
1. Introduction Let H be a Hilbert space; a multicontraction is an n-tuple of operators T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) acting on H, such that ni=1 Ti Ti∗ ≤ 1H . A theory of dilation and models for this type of operators has been developed by Gelu Popescu in [9, 10] and a series of subsequent papers. There is no commutativity assumed there, and the isometric dilation obtained is related to the Fock space and to representations of the Cuntz algebra. Starting mainly with [1], interest has developed around the case T is formed by commuting operators. In particular, in the recent paper [5], which is actually the starting point for this note, a notion of characteristic function is introduced for commuting tuples, and in a particular case it is shown that this is a complete unitary invariant. One computes also, in terms of the characteristic function, the curvature introduced by Arveson [2]. Some of the results therein follow from previous work of Popescu in the noncommuting case; moreover, one should note that a significantly more general theory (including an extension of the notion of characteristic function) has been developed independently in [12, 13]. However, the direct approach of the commuting case might still be instructive. This note investigates further the characteristic function of a multicontraction. In Section 2 we remind the main definitions and notations. Section 3 contains some variations around the results in [5]. In Section 4 we investigate a general form
154
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
of fractional transform, of which the characteristic function is a particular case. The main applications are obtained in Section 5, where one obtains the relation of the characteristic function to involutive automorphisms of the ball applied to a multicontraction. Here formulas similar to the Moebius transform of a single contraction are obtained. The case of the general automorphisms are discussed in Section 6; this is connected to the homogeneous operators considered by Misra et al [7, 3]. After this paper was completed, we have learnt that further work on closely related subjects has independently been done by Bhattacharyya, Eschmeier and Sarkar [6], and have also become aware of the recent work of Popescu [12, 13]. The connection to our results will be pointed out when the case appears.
2. Preliminaries and notations If E1 , E2 are two Hilbert spaces, and C : E1 → E2 is a contraction, one defines the defect operator DC = (1E1 − C ∗ C)1/2 ∈ L(E1 ) and the defect space DC = DC E1 ⊂ E1 . Suppose T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) ∈ L(H)n is a commuting multicontraction; that is, n Ti Ti∗ ≤ 1H . i=1
This is the same as requiring that the row operator T = (T1 · · · Tn ) : Hn → H is a contraction. (We will currently denote with the same letter T the multioperator and the associated row contraction.) Accordingly, we have the operators DT = (1Hn − T ∗ T )1/2 and DT ∗ = (1H − T T ∗)1/2 , and the spaces DT = DT Hn ⊂ Hn , DT ∗ = DT ∗ H ⊂ H. For further use, for a multiindex α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) ∈ Nn , we shall denote |α| = |α1 | + · · · + |αn |, and T α = T1α1 · · · Tnαn . If, for z ∈ Bn (the unit ball of Cn ), the operator z : Hn → H is given by z = (z1 1H · · · zn 1H ), then z is a strict contraction, and thus 1H − zT ∗ is invertible. We may then define θT (z) = −T + DT ∗ (1H − zT ∗ )−1 zDT : DT → DT ∗ .
(2.1) n
Thus θT (z) is an analytic contraction valued function defined on B , which is called the characteristic function of T ; it is a multiplier of the corresponding Hardy–Arveson spaces. According to a standard terminology introduced in [16] for the case of a single contraction, we say that two analytic functions Θ : Bn → L(E1 , E2 ), Θ : Bn → L(E1 , E2 ) coincide if there exist unitary operators Ωi : Ei → Ei , i = 1, 2, such that Ω2 Θ(z) = Θ (z)Ω1 for all z ∈ Bn . The Hardy-Arveson space H is equal to the Hilbert space of analytic functions 1 on Bn with reproducing kernel k(z, w) = 1−z,w . The monomials z α (z ∈ Bn , α ∈ n N ) form a complete orthogonal (but not orthonormal) family therein.
Vol. 57 (2007)Characteristic Functions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball
155
Also, for E a Hilbert space, we denote H(E) = H ⊗ E; thus H = H(C). The standard multishift S = (S1 , . . . , Sn ) on H is defined by Si f = zi f . Again in [1] one shows that S is a commuting multicontraction, and DS ∗ = P0 , where P0 denotes the orthogonal projection onto the constant functions. We will use the same notation S for the corresponding operators (Si ⊗ 1E ) acting on H(E). If A ∈ L(H(E), H(E ∗ )) is an operator that commutes with the standard multishift, then A is uniquely defined by its restriction a to E; we will denote then A = Ma . One can also view a as a function from Bn to L(E, E ∗ ), by writing a(z)(ξ) = a(ξ)(z). If T is an arbitrary multicontraction, we define a completely positive map ρT : L(H) → L(H) by n Ti XTi∗, (2.2) ρT (X) = i=1
and denote, as in [5], by A∞ (T ) ∈ L(H) the strong limit of the decreasing sequence of positive operators ρkT (1H ). The next theorem appears in [5]; most of its ingredients are already present in [1]. Theorem A. If T is a commuting contractive tuple of operators on H, then there exists a unique bounded linear operator L : H(DT ∗ ) → H satisfying L(f ⊗ ξ) = f (T )DT ∗ ξ
(2.3)
for all f polynomial, ξ ∈ E. The adjoint operator L∗ : H → H(DT ∗ ) is given by (L∗ h)(z) = DT ∗ (1H − zT ∗ )−1 h.
(2.4)
These operators satisfy LSi = Ti L,
Si∗ L∗ = L∗ Ti∗ .
(2.5)
We have the identities LL∗ + A∞ (T ) = 1H , ∗
L L+
MθT Mθ∗T
= 1H(DT ∗ ) .
(2.6) (2.7)
When no confusion is possible, we will usually denote simply A∞ instead of A∞ (T ). Finally, we remind a dilation result from [1]. A spherical operator Z = (Z1 , . . . , Zn ) is a commuting tuple of normal operators such that Z1 Z1∗ + · · · + Zn Zn∗ = 1. Theorem B. If T is a multicontraction, there is a (essentially uniquely defined) standard minimal dilation of T of the form S ⊕ Z, where S is a multishift on H(DT ∗ ), while Z is a spherical operator. We have Z = 0 iff A∞ (T ) = 0. A few words are in order concerning the relation to the noncommuting case considered by Popescu in [9, 10] and subsequent papers. When the contractions Ti
156
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
do not commute, it is necessary to introduce, instead of the Hardy–Arveson space H(E), the Fock space 2
m
Γ(E) = E ⊕ E n ⊕ (E n )⊗ ⊕ · · · ⊕ (E n )⊗ ⊕ · · · . One can identify then H(E) with the subspace of Γ(E) formed by the symmetric tensors; suppose then that πE is the orthonormal projection onto this subspace. The defect spaces of a noncommuting multicontraction are defined in a similar manner, and the characteristic function of T introduced by Popescu in [10] corresponds to an operator µT : Γ(DT ) → Γ(DT ∗ ) which commutes with the creation operators in the Fock space. The relation with the commuting case is then the formula MθT = πDT ∗ µT |H(DT ). Thus most of the results above concerning the space H(E) can be obtained by “compressing” to the symmetric tensors the corresponding facts in the Fock space Γ(E). This approach appears already in [11] (where one finds, among others, a noncommutative version of Theorem A); it has been pursued systematically (and in greater generality) in the recent papers [12, 13]. Other connections between the commuting and noncommuting cases can be found in [14].
3. Classes of multicontractions By means of the operator A∞ defined above, we can define some classes of multicontractions, similar to the ones that appear in [10] in the noncommutative case. Definition 3.1. The multicontraction T is called • pure (or C0 ) if A∞ = 0; • C1 if ker A∞ = {0}; • completely noncoisometric (c.n.c) if ker(1 − A∞ ) = {0}. The next result is an immediate consequence of Theorem A. Proposition 3.2. (i) [5] T is pure iff L∗ is an isometry. In this case T is unitarily equivalent to the commuting tuple T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) on HT = H(DT ∗ ) MθT (H(DT )) defined by Ti = PHT Si |HT . (ii) T is c.n.c. if and only if L∗ is one-to-one. In this case T ∗ is uniquely determined by the second equality in (2.5). The following lemma has been proved for the noncommuting case in [9] (see Remark 2.7 therein). Lemma 3.3. Suppose T is a commuting multicontraction. (i) ker A∞ is invariant with respect to T ∗ , and the compression of T to ker A∞ is pure. (ii) ker(1 − A∞ ) is invariant with respect to T ∗ and, if Tˆ is the compression to T to ker(1H − A∞ ), then DTˆ∗ = {0}. We can also characterize multishifts by means of their characteristic function.
Vol. 57 (2007)Characteristic Functions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball
157
Proposition 3.4. If T is pure, then T is unitarily equivalent to the multishift S iff θT ≡ 0. Proof. In Theorem A, if S is the multishift, then L in (2.3) becomes the identity. It follows then from (2.7) that MθT = 0, and thus θT ≡ 0. Conversely, if θT ≡ 0, then from Proposition 3.2 it follows that HT = H(DT ∗ ), Ti = Si , and T is unitarily equivalent to T. Definition 3.5. An analytic function Φ : Bn → L(F , E) is called: • inner if MΦ : H(F ) → H(E) is a partial isometry; • outer if MΦ : H(F ) → H(E) has dense range. The following characterizations of classes of commuting multicontractions, by means of their characteristic functions, are similar to those obtained in [16] for one contraction and in [10] for noncommuting contractions. Theorem 3.6. Suppose T is a c.n.c. multicontraction on H. Then: 1. T is pure iff θT is inner. 2. T is of class C1 iff θT is outer. Proof. (1) If T is pure, then L is a coisometry, and thus L∗ L is a projection. From (2.7) it follows that MθT Mθ∗T is also a projection; thus MθT is a partial isometry and θT is inner. Conversely, if MθT is a partial isometry, then (2.7) implies that L is a partial isometry, and then from (2.6) it follows that A∞ is a projection. Since T is c.n.c., we must have ker(1 − A∞ ) = {0}. Thus A∞ = 0, which means that T is pure. (2) Note that ker A∞ = {0}, is equivalent, by (2.6), to ker(1 − LL∗ ) = {0}. But it is easy to see (for any bounded operator L, actually) that this last relation is equivalent to ker(1 − L∗ L) = {0}. By (2.7), this is the same as ker(Mθ∗T ) = {0}, or θT outer. To end the section, let us note that the model provided by Proposition 3.2 (i) for pure contractions can be extended up to a certain point to c.n.c. multicontractions, in a manner similar to [16] (for a single contraction) or to [10] (for noncommuting multicontractions). We give only some indications in this direction, mostly in order to obtain an extension of Proposition 3.4. More details, including an investigation of the model space, can be found in [6], and in a more general context in [13]. Remember that DMθT = (I − Mθ∗T MθT )1/2 H(DT ) ⊂ H(DT ). Consider the space KT = H(DT ∗ ) ⊕ DMθT and the two mappings v : H(DT ) → KT , v∗ : H(DT ∗ ) → KT , defined by v(f ) = MθT f ⊕ DMθT f,
v∗ (f ) = f ⊕ 0.
(3.1)
It is easy to check that v, v∗ are isometries, that KT = v(H(DT )) ∨ v∗ (H(DT ∗ )), and that
v∗∗ v
∗
= MθT ; consequently v v∗ =
Mθ∗T .
(3.2)
Define HT = KT u(H(DT )).
158
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
If k ∈ HT , and k ⊥ v∗ (H(DT ∗ )), we must have k = 0 by (3.2). Thus the projection PHT onto HT has dense range when restricted to v∗ (H(DT ∗ )). Also, if f ∈ H(DT ∗ ), then v∗ f 2 = PHT v∗ f 2 + v ∗ v∗ f 2 = PHT v∗ f 2 + Mθ∗T f 2 . On the other hand, by (2.7) for any f ∈ H(DT ∗ ) we have Lf 2 +Mθ∗T f 2 = f . Therefore, the map Lf → PHT v∗ f is an isometry. We have just noticed that its range is dense in H; but its domain is also dense in HT by Corollary 3.2. We obtain then a unitary Φ : H → HT , defined by the formula 2
Φ(Lf ) = PHT v∗ f.
(3.3)
∗
Now, since 1K − PHT = vv , we have, using (2.7), v∗∗ (ΦLf ) = v∗∗ PHT v∗ = 1H(DT ∗ ) − v∗∗ (1K − PHT )v∗
= 1H(DT ∗ ) − v∗∗ vv ∗ v∗ = 1H(DT ∗ ) − MθT Mθ∗T = L∗ L.
Again, since the range of L is dense in H, it follows that v∗∗ Φ = L∗ . We may then define a multioperator T on HT by requiring that Si∗ v∗∗ k. Applying (3.4) and (2.5), we have
(3.4) v∗∗ T∗i k
=
v∗∗ T∗i Φh = Si∗ v∗∗ Φh = Si∗ L∗ h = L∗ Ti∗ h = v∗∗ ΦTi∗ h; since v∗∗ is one-to-one, this shows that T is a multicontraction unitarily equivalent to T . Using this unitary equivalence, one proves in [5] and in a more general context in [13], that the characteristic function is a complete unitary invariant for c.n.c. contractions. Theorem 3.7. Two c.n.c. contractions are unitarily equivalent if and only if their characteristic functions coincide. It followed already from results in [10] that the class of completely noncoisometric contractions is the natural one for which the characteristic function is a complete unitary invariant. As a consequence of Theorem 3.7, we can obtain a generalization of Proposition 3.4. Corollary 3.8. If T is c.n.c., then T is unitarily equivalent to the multishift S iff θT ≡ 0. Remark 3.9. The main drawback of Theorem 3.7 is that not all contractive multipliers coincide with characteristic functions of commuting multicontractions, and, contrary to the noncommuting case of [10], we do not know of a simple way to characterize those that do. A simple example is given by the null characteristic function: θ : Bn → L(E1 , E2 ) defined by θ(z) = 0 for all z coincides with a characteristic function if and only if dim E1 = ∞. Indeed, it is obvious that in this case coincidence is equivalent to equalities of the dimensions of the domain and of the range. On the other hand, Corollary 3.8 implies that, if θ coincides with θT ,
Vol. 57 (2007)Characteristic Functions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball
159
then T has to be the multishift S on some space H(E). But then dim DS ∗ = dim E (and is thus arbitrary), while (for n ≥ 2) dim DS = ∞. This follows immediately from for instance, all elements in n the fact that dim ker DS = ∞, since itcontains, n H(E) of the form (z f ) ⊕ (−z f ) ⊕ 0 (with f ∈ H(E)). 2 1 i=1 i=3
4. Fractional transforms It is useful to regard characteristic functions of multicontractions in a larger context, namely as a particular case of fractional transforms. This section is a development of some results in [4]. Let A, W ∈ L(E1 , E2 ) be contractions such that the inverse (I + W A∗ )−1 exists; define the operator ΨA (W ) ∈ L(E1 , E2 ) by the formula ΨA (W ) = A + DA∗ (I + W A∗ )−1 W DA
(4.1)
∗
The inverse exists if for example W A < 1. A related operator is ψA (W ) = ΨA (W )|DA : DA → DA∗ ; ⊥ ΨA (W )|DA
(4.2)
⊥ A|DA ,
note also that = and it maps this subspace unitarily onto DA∗ . We will use repeatedly the formulas Ψ−A (−W ) = −ΨA (W ),
ψ−A (−W ) = −ψA (W ).
(4.3)
Lemma 4.1. We have the relations I − ΨA (W )∗ ΨA (W ) = DA (I + W ∗ A)−1 (I − W ∗ W )(I + A∗ W )−1 DA , I − ΨA (W )ΨA (W )∗ = DA∗ (I + W A∗ )−1 (I − W W ∗ )(I + AW ∗ )−1 DA∗ . In particular, ΨA (W ) ≤ 1, and, if W is an isometry (or coisometry), then ΨA (W ) and ψA (W ) are isometries (or coisometries, respectively). The lemma is proved by straight computation. As a consequence, we can define isometric operators Ω : DΨA (W ) → DW and Ω∗ : DΨA (W )∗ → DW ∗ by ΩDΨA (W ) x = DW (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x, ∗ −1
Ω∗ DΨA (W )∗ x = DW ∗ (I + AW )
DA∗ x.
(4.4) (4.5)
Remark 4.2. There is an important case when we can strengthen these statements. Suppose that W0 : DA → DA∗ and I + W0 A∗ : DA∗ → DA∗ is invertible. (Note that A(DA ) ⊂ DA∗ and A∗ (DA∗ ) ⊂ DA .) Then, if W ∈ L(E1 , E2 ) is defined by W = W0 PDA + APDA⊥ , then I + W A∗ is invertible, DW ⊂ DA , DW ∗ ⊂ DA∗ , and Ω, Ω∗ are actually unitary. In this case formulas (4.4) and (4.5) yield identifications of the defect spaces of ΨA (W ). Proposition 4.3. Suppose the operators I + V A∗ , I + W A∗ , I + ΨA (V )W ∗ , I + V ΨA (W )∗ are all invertible. Then, if Ω, Ω∗ are defined by (4.4) and (4.5), we have Ω∗ ψΨA (W ) (V ) = ψW (ΨA (V ))Ω.
(4.6)
It should be noted that Ω and Ω∗ depend only on A and W (and not on V ).
160
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
Proof. Since the two terms of (4.6) act on DΨA (W ) , in order to check it we have to apply them to DΨA (W ) x. The proof is a rather tedious computation for which we give only some indications. One checks first the two formulas ΨA (W )DA = DA∗ (I + W A∗ )−1 (W + A) and DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 DA∗ (I + V A∗ )−1 ∗
= DW ∗ (I + AW ∗ )−1 DA∗ (I + V ΨA (W ) )−1 . Using them, one shows that Ω∗ ψΨA (W ) (V )DΨA (W ) x = DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 × ΨA (V )DA − DA∗ (I + V A∗ )−1 DA∗ W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA .
(4.7)
On the other hand, writing explicitely the left term in (4.6) yields ψW (ΨA (V ))ΩDΨA (W ) x = W DW (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x + DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 ΨA (V )(I + A∗ W )−1 DA x − DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 ΨA (V )W ∗ W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x. Since DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 ΨA (V )W ∗ W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x = −DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x + W DW (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x, it follows that ψW (ΨA (V ))ΩDΨA (W ) x = DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 [ΨA (V )(I + A∗ W )−1 DA x + W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x] = DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 [ΨA (V )DA x + (−ΨA (V )A∗ + I)W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA x] = DW ∗ (I + ΨA (V )W ∗ )−1 × [ΨA (V )DA − DA∗ (I + V A∗ )−1 DA∗ W (I + A∗ W )−1 DA ]x. Comparing this last equality with (4.7), one obtains the desired equality.
The relation with the characteristic function is obtained by noting first that, for z ∈ Bn , the operator z : Hn → H is a strict contraction, and thus 1H − zT ∗ is invertible. Then, by comparing (4.2) and (2.1), we see that θT (z) = ψ−T (z).
(4.8)
One should note that in the noncommuting case a similar relation has been used in [12].
Vol. 57 (2007)Characteristic Functions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball
161
5. Involutive automorphisms of the unit ball Formula (4.8) is of interest to us since it allows to make the connection between characteristic functions and automorphisms of the ball applied to multicontractions. The involutive automorphisms of the unit ball Bn are defined [15] by sλ (z − (1 − sλ )Pλ z), φλ (z) = λ − 1 − z, λ where λ ∈ Bn , sλ = (1 − |λ|2 )1/2 , and Pλ is the projection onto the space spanned by λ. Among the properties of these maps, we note that φλ is involutive, that is, φλ ◦ φλ = 1Bn , that it maps the unit ball onto the unit ball, and the unit sphere onto the unit sphere. The relation with the previous section is given by the next proposition, whose proof is a direct computation. Proposition 5.1. If we identify λ, z ∈ Bn with strict contractions in L(Cn , C), then φλ (z) = Ψλ (−z) = ψλ (−z). Denote λ = λ ⊗ 1H : Hn → H; then λ is a strict contraction. If T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ) is a multicontraction, then λ T ∗ is a strict contraction, and we may define Ψλ (−T ) = ψλ (−T ). In case T is commutative, φλ (T ) is defined by the analytic functional calculus, and it is in turn a commuting row contraction. Moreover φλ (T ) = Ψλ (−T ). There are several properties of the multicontraction T that are also inherited by φλ (T ). The first one can be proved directly. Proposition 5.2. With the above notations, ker(1−A∞ (T )) = ker(1−A∞ (φλ (T ))). In particular, T is c.n.c., if and only if φλ (T ) is c.n.c. Proof. Denote φλ (T ) = R = (R1 , . . . , Rn ). Since all Ri are analytic functions in T1 , . . . , Tn , all subspaces of H invariant to T are also invariant to R. But then the relation φλ (R) = T implies that R and T have the same invariant subspaces, and the same is true for T ∗ and R∗ . Suppose then that K = ker(1 − A∞ (T )) is not contained in ker(1 − A∞ (R)). Since the elements of this last subspace are characterized by the fact that ρkR (1) = 1 for all k (ρR as defined by (2.2)), there exists x ∈ ker(1−A∞ (T )) and a first index k K ≥ 1 for which ρK R (1)(x) = x. Since ρR (1) ≤ 1 for all k, and K is invariant to ∗ R , it follows that we can find y ∈ K, y = 0 (of the form y = Ri∗1 . . . Ri∗K−1 x), such n n that i=1 Ri∗ y2 < y2 . On the other side, y ∈ K implies i=1 Ti∗ y2 = y2 . Consider now the multioperators T , R , which are the compressions of T and R respectively to K. It is easy to see that R = φλ (T ) = Ψλ (−T ). But the definition of K implies that T , as a row contraction operator, is a coisometry. By Lemma 4.1, R should also be a coisometry, which contradicts the existence of y.
162
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
We have thus proved that ker(1 − A∞ (T )) ⊂ ker(1 − A∞ (R)). But then φλ (R) = T implies that we actually have equality. According to (4.4) and (4.5), we have operators Ω : Dφλ (T ) → DT and Ω∗ : Dφλ (T )∗ → DT ∗ ; moreover, since Remark 4.2 applies, Ω, Ω∗ are actually unitary maps. They provide identifications of the defect spaces of φλ (T ); what is more interesting, they can be used in order to obtain a formula for the characteristic function of φλ (T ). Theorem 5.3. (i) The operators Ω and Ω∗ are unitaries. (ii) θφλ (T ) coincides with θT (φλ (z)). Proof. (i) follows from the fact that we can apply Remark 4.2 (A = λ is a strict contraction). As for (ii), by Proposition 5.1, formulas (4.8) and (4.3), we have θφλ (T ) (z) = θΨλ (−T ) (z) = ψ−Ψλ (−T ) (z) = −ψΨλ (−T ) (−z). But Proposition 4.3 applied to the case A = λ , V = −z, W = −T says that ψΨλ (−T ) (−z) (and thus also −ψΨλ (−T ) (−z)) coincides with ψ−T (Ψλ (−z)). Note that the unitaries Ω, Ω∗ in Proposition 4.3 do not depend on V , and thus in our case the unitaries implementing the coincidence do not depend on z. Finally, applying again Proposition 5.1 and formula (4.8), we obtain ψ−T (Ψλ (−z)) = ψ−T (φλ (z) ⊗ 1H ) = θT (φλ (z)),
which ends the proof.
Theorem 5.3 is the generalization of the well known formula for the characteristic function of a Moebius transform of a single contraction [16, VI.1.3]. However, the definition of the automorphism of the ball makes φλ involutive, and thus φ−1 λ = φλ . The change of sign in the usual definition of the Moebius transforms accounts for the apparition in [16] of a slightly different formula. Note also that a weaker result along the lines of Theorem 5.3 appears in [6]. As a first application, we obtain a partial extension of the relation between the spectrum and the characteristic function that exists for single contractions [16]. Recall (see, for instance, [8]) that, for a commuting multioperator T = (T1 , . . . , Tn ), one can define its right spectrum by: n
σr (T ) = {λ ∈ C :
n
(Ti − λi )(Ti − λi )∗ is not invertible}.
i=1 n
Proposition 5.4. If λ ∈ B , then λ ∈ σr (T ) iff θT (−λ) is not surjective. n Proof. Note that, since i=1 Ti Ti∗ is invertible if and only if (T1 · · · Tn ) is surjective, we have σr (T ) = {λ ∈ Cn : (T1 − λ1 ) · · · (Tn − λn ) not surjective}.
Vol. 57 (2007)Characteristic Functions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball
163
Since T maps unitarily DT⊥ onto DT⊥∗ , it follows that 0 ∈ σr (T ) iff θT (0) is not surjective. Thus the claim is true for λ = 0. For other values of λ, since, by the spectral mapping theorem, σr (φλ (T )) = φλ (σr (T )), we have λ ∈ σr (T ) iff 0 ∈ σr (φλ (T )) (note that φλ (λ) = 0). This is equivalent to θφλ (T ) (0) not surjective. Since, by Theorem 5.3, θφλ (T ) (0) is unitarily equivalent to θT (φ−λ (0)), and φ−λ (0) = −λ, the proposition is proved. Remark 5.5. Naturally, a corresponding result can be proved for the left spectrum σl (T ) := σr (T ), where T = (T1∗ , . . . , Tn∗ ). This would however require the assumption that T is a multicontraction. If one would want to deduce a consequence about the Harte spectrum σH (T ) = σr (T ) ∪ σl (T ), one should assume both T and T multicontractions, which is a rather unnatural hypothesis (for instance, it is not satisfied by the multishift for n ≥ 2). The next consequence concerns the multishift. Proposition 5.6. If S is a multishift and λ ∈ Bn , then φλ (S) is also a multishift, of the same multiplicity. Proof. By Proposition 5.2 φλ (S) is a c.n.c. multicontraction, while Theorem 5.3 implies that its characteristic function is identically zero. We may then apply Corollary 3.8 to conclude that φλ (S) is a multishift. The equality of the multiplicities follows from the equality of the defect spaces of S and φλ (S), as given by Theorem 5.3, (i). We can also study the relation with the model spaces. Lemma 5.7. (i) If Z is spherical, then φλ (Z) is also spherical for all λ ∈ Bn . (ii) If the multicontraction V is a minimal dilation for T , then φλ (V ) is a minimal dilation for φλ (T ). Proof. (i) follows immediately from the functional calculus for commuting normal operators. As for (ii), one sees easily that φλ (V ) is a dilation for φλ (T ), and that the space spanned by the powers of φλ (V ) applied to H is contained in the one spanned by powers of V . On the other side, φλ is involutive, which gives the opposite relation. Proposition 5.8. (i) If the standard minimal dilation of T is S ⊕ Z, then the standard minimal dilation of φλ (T ) is φλ (S) ⊕ φλ (Z). (ii) If T is pure, then φλ (T ) is pure. (iii) If T is of class C1 , then φλ (T ) is of class C1 . Proof. (i) and (ii) follow immediately from Proposition 5.6 and Lemma 5.7. As for (iii), we will apply Theorem 3.6. If T is of class C1 , then θT is outer. To show that θφλ (T ) is also outer, note first that by Theorem 5.3 it is enough to show that
164
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
θT (φλ (z)) is outer. Denote by Cλ the operator f → f (φλ (z)); it is invertible, since Cλ2 = 1. Then MθT (φλ (z)) Cλ = Cλ MθT , whence it follows that, if MθT has dense range, then MθT (φλ (z)) also has.
6. General automorphisms The general form of an automorphism α of Bn is α = ω ◦ φλ , n
for λ ∈ B , and ω a unitary map of Cn (see, for instance, [15, Theorem 2.2.5]). We may then complete the results of the previous section by taking into account the action of the unitary ω; since we identify Cn with row 1 × n matrices, and regard T as a row operator, it is natural to consider the action of ω as matrix multiplication to the right. Remember that if T is a multicontraction, then the completely positive map ρT : L(H) → L(H) is defined by (2.2). Lemma 6.1. Suppose T = T (1H ⊗ ω). Then ρT = ρT , while θT (z) coincides with θT (zω ∗ ). Proof. We can write ρT (X) = T (X ⊗ 1Cn )T ∗ ; then ρT (X) = T (1H ⊗ ω)(X ⊗ 1Cn )(1H ⊗ ω ∗ )T ∗ = T (X ⊗ 1Cn )T ∗ = ρT (X). As concerns the defect spaces and operators, we have DT ∗ = DT ∗ and DT ∗ = DT ∗ , while DT = (1H ⊗ ω ∗ )DT (1H ⊗ ω) and DT = (1H ⊗ ω ∗ )DT . Consequently θT (z) = −T + DT ∗ (1H − zT ∗ )−1 zDT = −T (1H ⊗ ω) + DT ∗ (1H − z(1H ⊗ ω ∗ )T ∗ )−1 z(1H ⊗ ω ∗ )DT (1H ⊗ ω) = θT (zω ∗ )(1H ⊗ ω), and the lemma is proved.
Corollary 6.2. Suppose T = T (1H ⊗ ω). Then: (i) T is c.n.c. (C1 , C0 ) iff T is c.n.c. (C0 , C1 , respectively). (ii) If T is a multishift, then T is a multishift of the same multiplicity. Proof. The results in (i) are immediate consequences of the equality ρT = ρT , while for (ii) we have to use, besides Lemma 6.1, Corollary 3.8. Gathering the results in Propositions 5.2, 5.6, 5.8, Lemma 6.1, Corollary 6.2, and Theorem 5.3, we obtain a general result concerning the action of an analytic automorphism of the unit ball on a multicontraction. Theorem 6.3. Suppose α : Bn → Bn is an analytic automorphism, while T is a multicontraction. Then: (i) α(T ) is c.n.c. (C1 , C0 ) iff T is c.n.c. (C0 , C1 , respectively).
Vol. 57 (2007)Characteristic Functions and Automorphisms of the Unit Ball
165
(ii) θα(T ) coincides with θT ◦ α−1 . (iii) If T is a multishift, then α(T ) is a multishift of the same multiplicity. Remark 6.4. In [7] the notion of homogeneous n-tuples of operators is introduced in a general context. In our case, a multicontraction T is homogeneous if α(T ) is unitarily equivalent to T for all α automorphism of Bn . Consequently, Theorem 6.3(iii) says that the standard multishift is homogeneous. We thank J. Sarkar for useful discussions, and the referee for bringing to our attention some recent relevant results.
References [1] W. Arveson: Subalgebras of C ∗ -algebras. III. Multivariable operator theory. Acta Math. 181 (1998), 159–228. [2] W. Arveson: The curvature of a Hilbert module over C[z1 , · · · , zd ], Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 (1999), 11096–11099. [3] B. Bagchi, G. Misra: Homogeneous tuples of multiplication operators on twisted Bergman spaces, J. Functional Analysis 136 (1996), 171–213. [4] Ch. Benhida, D. Timotin: Finite rank perturbations of contractions, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 36 (2000), 253–268. [5] T. Bhattacharyya, J. Eschmeier and J. Sarkar: Characteristic function of a pure contractive tuple, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 53 (2005), 23–32. [6] T. Bhattacharyya, J. Eschmeier and J. Sarkar: On completely non coisometric tuples and their characteristic functions, preprint. [7] G. Misra, N.S. Narsimha Sastry: Homogeneous tuples of operators and representations of some classical groups, J. Operator Theory 24 (1990), 23–32. [8] V. M¨ uller: Spectral Theory of Linear Operators, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel–Boston– Berlin, 2003 [9] G. Popescu: Isometric dilations for infinite sequences of noncommuting operators, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 316 (1989), 523–536. [10] G. Popescu: Characteristic functions for infinite sequences of noncommuting operators, J. Operator Theory 22 (1989), 51–71. [11] G. Popescu: Poisson transforms on some C ∗ -algebras generated by isometries, J. Functional Analysis 161 (1999), 27–61. [12] G. Popescu: Operator theory on noncommutative varieties, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 56 (2006), 389–442. [13] G. Popescu: Operator theory on noncommutative varieties, II, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., to appear. [14] B.V. Rajarama Bhat, T. Bhattacharyya, S. Dey: Standard noncommuting and commuting dilations of commuting tuples, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 356 (2004), 1551– 1568. [15] W. Rudin: Function Theory in the Unit Ball of Cn , Springer-Verlag, New York– Berlin, 1980.
166
Benhida and Timotin
IEOT
[16] B. Sz.-Nagy, C. Foias: Harmonic analysis of operators on Hilbert space, NorthHolland Publishing Co, 1970. Chafiq Benhida UFR de Math´ematiques Universit´e des Sciences et Technologies de Lille F-59655 Villeneuve D’Ascq Cedex France e-mail:
[email protected] Dan Timotin Institute of Mathematics of the Romanian Academy P.O. Box 1-764 RO-014700 Bucharest Romania e-mail:
[email protected] Submitted: September 6, 2005 Revised: May 28, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 167–184 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020167-18, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1453-1
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse Michael Bolt Abstract. The skew-hermitian part of the Cauchy operator, defined with respect to arclength measure on the boundary, is known as the Kerzman-Stein operator. For an ellipse, the eigenvalues of this operator are shown to have multiplicity two. For an ellipse with small eccentricity, we compute the leading coefficient in the asymptotic expansion of the eigenvalues. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 45C05, 45E05, 30C40. Keywords. Kerzman-Stein operator, ellipse, eigenvalues.
1. Introduction In their study of Cauchy-Fantappi`e kernels and the Szeg˝ o kernel in higher dimensions, Kerzman and Stein discovered an elegant method for computing the Riemann map in one dimension. See [11, 12]. At the heart of their method is the fact that, for smooth, bounded domains, the Cauchy kernel and Szeg˝o kernel have the same principal singularity at the diagonal. In particular, the skew-hermitian part of the Cauchy operator, called the Kerzman-Stein operator, is compact. In a later article [10], Kerzman posed a number of problems concerning this operator, including the following. Problem (Kerzman, 1979). Relate the spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein operator to the geometry of the domain. In a sense, the spectrum measures the error when the Cauchy kernel is used to approximate the Szeg˝o kernel, and may be useful for estimating the rate of convergence of integral methods solutions to the Riemann map. Here we provide an answer to the problem for the case of an ellipse with small √ eccentricity. In the following theorem, the ellipse has eccentricity 2 ρ/(1 + ρ).
168
Bolt
IEOT
Theorem. The Kerzman-Stein operator for an ellipse has eigenvalues ±iλl where each ±iλl has multiplicity 2. If the ellipse is parameterized by t → eit + ρe−it with 0 < ρ < 1, and λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · ≥ 0, then as ρ ↓ 0, λl = βl · ρ2l−1 + o(ρ2l−1 ) where 0 < βl ≤ 1. The coefficients βl can be computed explicitly. Since the operator is compact and skew-hermitian, its spectrum will be discrete and imaginary, except for an accumulation point at zero. It is obvious that the Kerzman-Stein operator vanishes identically for a circle. The ellipse, however, is the first simply-connected, smooth, bounded domain to be considered for this problem after the disc. It is known as well that the Kerzman-Stein operator is invariant under M¨ obius transformations of the complex plane. So in a previous article [4] the author computed the spectrum for domains bounded by two circular arcs or two logarithmic spirals—logarithmic spirals are known to have constant inversive curvature. The ellipse, then, is the first example for which there is no apparent M¨obius symmetry. See Wilker [19] or Coffman and Frantz [6] for more on this topic. Formally, Kerzman’s problem is similar to Schiffer’s problem of computing the Fredholm eigenvalues of a plane domain [14, 15] which has been studied extensively. The similarity is explained by Burbea in [5], where he reduced Kerzman’s eigenvalue problem to a problem previously studied by Singh [17]. The connection between Singh’s problem and the Fredholm eigenvalue problem is apparent, for instance, in Bergman’s book [3, p.71]. Loosely, Singh’s problem can be interpreted as a boundary analogue of the Fredholm eigenvalue problem. For an ellipse, the Fredholm eigenvalues are known exactly—they are simply powers of the parameter ρ. For this fact, see [14, p.1195]. For more on the general problem, see also [2, 16]. The author thanks Professor Sidney Webster for supervising the work of his doctoral dissertation, of which this was a part.
2. Preliminaries We follow notation that Bell uses in his book [1]. Suppose Ω ⊂ C is a bounded domain with twice differentiable boundary, and let T = T (w) be the unit tangent vector at w ∈ ∂Ω, oriented positively with respect to Ω. If ds is arclength measure on ∂Ω, then the Kerzman-Stein operator is the operator defined by T (z) 1 T (w) − f (w) dsw , A(z, w)f (w) dsw = Af (z) = 2πi ∂Ω w − z w−z ∂Ω valid for f ∈ L2 (∂Ω) and z ∈ ∂Ω. In fact, the kernel A(z, w) is bounded at the diagonal—the apparent singularities cancel each other. The space L2 (∂Ω) is defined using the hermitian inner product (f, g)∂Ω = ∂Ω f g ds. Since A(z, w) is bounded and ∂Ω has finite length, it follows that A is HilbertSchmidt, and is therefore compact on L2 (∂Ω). Since A is also skew-hermitian, the
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
169
spectral theorem says that its spectrum is discrete and bounded, and will consist of imaginary eigenvalues whose only accumulation point is zero. If Ω is unbounded or if ∂Ω has a corner, however, this is not necessarily true. See [4] for specific examples when A is non-compact. We point out two general facts about A that will be helpful to our study of the ellipse. Let ∆ be the unit disc, ∆ = {z : |z| < 1}. Lemma 1. Suppose h : ∂∆ → ∂Ω is biholomorphic in a neighborhood of ∂∆ and √ h is single-valued near ∂∆. Then the Kerzman-Stein operator on L2 (∂Ω) is unitary equivalent to the operator on L2 (∂∆) with kernel iw h (w) h (z) iz h (w) h (z) 1 − A(z, w) = for w, z ∈ ∂∆. 2πi h(w) − h(z) h(w) − h(z) √ Proof. We first establish an isometry L2 (∂∆) ∼ = L2 (∂Ω) given by (f ◦ h) h ← f . Taking f, g ∈ L2 (∂Ω), this follows from √ √ f g ds = (f ◦ h) · (g ◦ h) |h | ds = (f ◦ h) h · (g ◦ h) h ds. ∂Ω
∂∆
∂∆
Next, write for f ∈ L2 (∂Ω), 1 A∂Ω f (z ) = 2πi
∂Ω
and replace w = h(w), T (w ) = z = h(z) and T (z ) =
h (z) |h (z)|
T (w ) T (z ) − w − z w − z
h (w) |h (w)|
f (w ) dsw ,
· iw, and dsw = |h (w)| dsw , and also
· iz. Then,
(A∂Ω f ) ◦ h(z) h (w) iz h (z) iw 1 − (f ◦ h)(w)|h (w)| dsw . = 2πi ∂∆ h(w) − h(z) |h (w)| h(w) − h(z) |h (z)| Multiplying both sides by h (z) gives (A∂Ω f ) ◦ h(z) h (z) iw h (w) h (z) iz h (w) h (z) 1 − = (f ◦ h)(w) h (w) dsw , 2πi ∂∆ h(w) − h(z) h(w) − h(z) and the lemma is proved.
Lemma 2. The Kerzman-Stein operator commutes with the involution Ψ on L2 (∂Ω) given by f → f T ; that is, AΨf = ΨAf . So the (imaginary) spectrum of A is symmetric with respect to 0.
170
Bolt
IEOT
Proof. Notice that T (w) 1 T (z) T (z) T (w) 1 − = − T (w)T (z) A(z, w) = 2πi w − z w−z 2πi w − z w−z T (w) 1 T (z) − + T (w)T (z) = A(z, w) T (w)T (z), = 2πi w−z w−z so
AΨf = ∂Ω
A(z, w)f (w)T (w) dsw =
∂Ω
A(z, w) f (w) dsw · T (z) = ΨAf.
So, if Af = iλf , then also AΨf = ΨAf = Ψ(iλf ) = −iλΨf , and the lemma is proved.
3. Approximation by Finite Rank Operators on the Unit Circle The theorem is proved as follows. Using Lemma 1, we transform the problem from the ellipse to an equivalent problem on the disc. We express the new kernel using a double Fourier series, and approximate the operator using finite rank operators with kernels that have rapidly decaying coefficients. We then estimate the eigenvalues of the approximating operators. Finally, we use the Cauchy interlace theorem and a previous estimate of Feldman, Krupnik, and Spitkovsky in order to bound the leading coefficients. 3.1. Pulling the Kerzman-Stein operator back to the unit disk. For the ellipse, take 0 < ρ < 1 and h(z) = z + ρ/z. Then, using the expansions ∞ 1 j ρ 2 (−1)j ρ h (z) = 1 − 2 = z j z 2j j=0 and
ρ ρ ρ ) − (z + ) = (w − z)(1 − ), w z wz and also the identities w = 1/w, z = 1/z, and h(w) − h(z) = (w +
−iw iz = z−w w−z for w, z ∈ ∂∆, we find by Lemma 1 that the Kerzman-Stein operator for the ellipse is unitary equivalent to the operator on L2 (∂∆) with kernel 1 1
−2j−l −2k−l 1 w 2 (−1)j+k ρj+k+l 2 z − w2j+l z 2k+l . A(z, w) = w 2π w − z j k j,k,l≥0
The order of summation can be taken symmetrically with respect to j, k, l; that is, the partial sums are sn = j+k+l≤n . We will see that these partial sums are each divisible by w − z in the ring of polynomials.
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
171
Next, identify ∂∆ with the interval √ [0, 2π] and use the standard basis {ψj }j∈Z 2 ijs for L ([0, 2π]) given by ψj (s) = e / 2π. In terms of this basis, the KerzmanStein operator has kernel eis 1 · 2π eis − eit
A(t, s) =
j+k j+k+l
(−1)
ρ
j,k,l≥0
1 1 2 2 e−i(2j+l)s e−i(2k+l)t − ei(2j+l)s ei(2k+l)t , j k
or alternately,
A(t, s) =
aj,k ψj (t) ψk (s)
j,k∈Z
for real coefficients aj,k that satisfy (i) aj,k = 0 if both j, k < 0, if both j, k ≥ 0, or if j +k is odd. −j+k 2
b−j,k if j < 0 ≤ k; the bj,k are determined by 1 1 w 2 w2j+l z 2k+l . bj,k wj z k = (−1)j+k 2 w − z j,k,l≥0 j k
(ii) aj,k = ρ
j>0, k≥0
j+k+l>0
(iii) aj,k = −ak,j for all j, k. (iv) aj,k = a−j−1,−k−1 for all j, k. As an operator, A then behaves as multiplication by the matrix (aj,k )j,k∈Z . Proof of (i)–(iv). To prove (i), rewrite A(z, w) using the expansion 1 1 w 1 1 1 n l l j+k 2 2 w2j z 2k ρ −1 wz (−1) 2π n>0 w2n z 2n w−z j k j,k≥0
1 n 1 1 = ρ −1 2π n>0 w2n z 2n
0≤l≤n
+
0≤l≤n−2 def
j+k=n−l
1 1 − w2 + wz − z 2 wn−1 z n−1 2 2 1 1 2 w2j z 2k . wl z l (−1)j+k 2 j k j,k≥0
w w−z
j+k=n−l
We have assumed n = j +k+l > 0 since the terms for n = 0 cancel; we have also interchanged indices j, k in the term w−2j−l z −2k−l and factored out the quantity (w−2n z −2n − 1). Since 1 1 2 (−1)j+k 2 = 0 j k j,k≥0 j+k=m
172
Bolt
IEOT
for m ≥ 2, as shown in the next section, we may divide the quantity in brackets by w − z (rather, we divide by w2 − z 2 , but w − z is a factor of this) and obtain 1 1 j −k n aj,k z w = ρ −1 wl z l cp,n−l wp z 2(n−l)−p 2n 2n w z n>0 j,k∈Z 0≤l≤n−1 1≤p≤2(n−l)
−2n+l+p −l−p n = ρ cp,n−l w z − wl+p z 2n−l−p , n>0
0≤l≤n 1≤p≤2(n−l)
for real coefficients cp,m , 1 ≤ p ≤ 2m, that can be given explicitly in terms of the binomial coefficients. The first terms on the right-hand side have the form z j w−k for integers j, k satisfying j < 0, k ≥ 0, and j + k even. The second terms have the form z j w−k for integers j, k satisfying j ≥ 0, k < 0, and j + k even. The coefficients aj,k for the remaining j, k must be zero, so (i) is proved. To prove (ii), start with the nth degree terms in the definition of the bj,k , 1 1 w j k j+k 2 2 w2j+l z 2k+l , bj,k w z = (−1) w − z j k j>0, k≥0 j,k,l≥0 j+k=n
2(j+k+l)=n
then multiply both sides by ρn/2 and sum on n ≥ 1. After substituting w = eis and z = eit , and replacing j → −j on the left-hand side we obtain 1 1 −j+k eis −ijs ikt j+k j+k+l 2 2 ei(2j+l)s ei(2k+l)t 2 ρ b−j,k e e = is (−1) ρ e − eit j,k,l≥0 j k j<0 k≥0
j+k+l>0
=−
k<0, j≥0
aj,k eijt e−iks =
ak,j eijt e−iks .
k<0, j≥0
The third equality uses (iii), which is proved next. Then, interchanging j, k in the −j+k last expression gives aj,k = ρ 2 b−j,k and (ii) is proved. To prove (iii), use the identity eis /(eis − eit ) = e−it /(e−it − e−is ) to verify that A(s, t) = −A(t, s). Then aj,k ψj (t) ψk (s), aj,k ψj (s) ψk (t) = − and after interchanging j, k, it follows that aj,k = −ak,j . To prove (iv), first verify that A(t, s) = A(t, s)e−is eit . Then aj,k ψj (t) ψk (s) = aj,k ψj+1 (t) ψk+1 (s) = aj−1,k−1 ψj (t) ψk (s) = a−j−1,−k−1 ψj (t) ψk (s). The second equality uses the replacements j → j − 1, k → k − 1, and the third equality uses the replacements j → −j, k → −k, and the fact that ψ−j = ψj . These properties enable us to show the eigenspaces of A are even-dimensional.
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
173
Lemma 3. If the Kerzman-Stein operator has an eigenvalue iλ that corresponds 1,+ with eigenvector v = v = vj ψj , then it has a second eigenvector v 2,+ = 1,− v−j−1 ψj that corresponds with iλ. There are also eigenvectors v = v j ψj and v 2,− = v −j−1 ψj that correspond with eigenvalue −iλ. 1,+ Proof. Suppose that v 1,+ = = A( j vj ψj ) = j vj ψj so Av j,k aj,k vk ψj and k aj,k vk = iλvj for each j. Then, using (iv), Av 2,+ = aj,k v−k−1 ψj = a−j−1,−k−1 v−k−1 ψj = iλv−j−1 ψj = iλv 2,+ . j,k
j
j,k
A parity argument shows that v another. To see this, decompose
1,+
and v def
v = vodd + veven =
2,+
can be made independent of one
vj ψj +
j odd
vj ψj .
j even
1,+ If vodd = 0, then replace v = v 1,+ = vodd ; else replace v 1,+ = veven . Then, = Av 1,+ 1,+ iλv still holds, since aj,k = 0 for j + k odd. Moreover, v = j vj ψj and v 2,+ = therefore be j v−j−1 ψj will have opposite odd/even parity, and will orthogonal. Finally, we describe the opposite eigenspace. If v 1,− = j v j ψj , we find aj,k v k ψj = aj,k v k ψj = −iλv j ψj = −iλv 1,− . Av 1,− = j,k
2,−
j
j,k
= v −j−1 ψj is an eigenvector corresponding with −iλ, since it is Then also v gotten from v 1,− in the same way that v 2,+ is gotten from v 1,+ . From now on, we associate the spectrum of A with a list of values λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · ≥ 0, so the eigenvalues of A are ±iλj , where each ±iλj has multiplicity 2. 3.2. Approximation by finite rank operators. We now pass to a set of finite rank operators An with degenerate kernel An (t, s) =
2n−1
aj,k ψj (t) ψk (s).
j,k=−2n
The rank of An is at most 4n. Furthermore, Lemma 3 also holds for the An since the span of ψ−2n , . . . , ψ2n−1 is unchanged under the transformation ψj → ψ−j−1 . We then associate the spectrum of An with a list of values λ1 ≥ · · · ≥ λn ≥ 0, so that the eigenvalues of An are ±iλj and each ±iλj has multiplicity 2. As an operator, An acts as multiplication by the matrix (aj,k )j,k=−2n,...,2n−1 . To illustrate this, we show the matrix for A3 in Figure 1. The columns and rows are indexed over −6, −5, . . . , +5. Notice that the matrix is skew-hermitian (in fact, real skew-symmetric) and the powers of ρ increase away from the diagonal. This illustrates properties (ii) and (iii) of the aj,k . Properties (i) and (iv) are also apparent. The innermost 4 × 4 and 8 × 8 submatrices correspond with A1 and A2 , respectively.
174
Bolt
0 0 0 0 0 0
3 ρ 16 0 25ρ4 128 0 81ρ5 128 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
3ρ3 16
0 81ρ4 128
0
−81ρ5 128
0 0 0 0 0 0 ρ2 8
0
5ρ3 8
0 −81ρ4 128
0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 ρ 2
5ρ2 8
0
−ρ 2
0
−ρ2 8
−5ρ2 8
0 −5ρ3 8
−3ρ3 16
0
−25ρ4 128
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0 0
−ρ3 16
IEOT
−ρ3 16
0 2
−ρ 8
0 −ρ 2
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 −3ρ3 16
0 −5ρ2 8
0 ρ 2
0 0 0 0 0 0
−25ρ4 128
0 3
−5ρ 8
0
5ρ2 8
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 −81ρ4 128
0 5ρ3 8
0 ρ2 8
0 0 0 0 0 0
−81ρ5 128
0 4
81ρ 128
0
3ρ3 16
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 81ρ5 128
0 25ρ4 128
0 ρ3 16
0 0 0 0 0 0
Figure 1. The matrix associated to A3 The next result assumes that ρ ↓ 0, so we are considering only ellipses with small eccentricity. Lemma 4. As described above, associate the spectrum of An with the list of values λ1 ≥ · · · ≥ λn ≥ 0. Then, for 1 ≤ l ≤ n, λl = βl · ρ2l−1 + o(ρ2l−1 ) for constants βl > 0. The coefficients βl can be computed explicitly. Proof. Consider first the characteristic polynomial of the matrix associated to An , p(λ) = det(An − λI) =
2n−1 σ
j=−2n
(−1)σ (aj,σj − λδj,σj ) =
4n
(−1)j αj λ4n−j ,
j=0
where δj,k = 1 if j = k and δj,k = 0 if j = k. The sum is taken over permutations of {−2n, . . . , 2n − 1} and (−1)σ indicates the signature of a permutation σ. The zeros of p(λ) are the eigenvalues of An , and the coefficients αj are the sums of products of eigenvalues taken j at a time. Consider specifically the coefficient α4l in the expression. A permutation contributes a term to this coefficient only if it acts identically on 4n − 4l entries. (There are zeros along the diagonal of matrix (aj,k ).) Of these permutations, only those that act identically away from 2 {−2l, . . . , 2l − 1} contribute a term with factor ρ4l . The others contribute higher powers of ρ; this uses (ii). In fact, the permutations that act identically away from 2 {−2l, . . . , 2l −1} contribute det Al to the coefficient α4l , and α4l = det Al +o(ρ4l ). Next, since Al is skew-symmetric and zero in its upper-left and lower-right quadrants, its determinant is the square of the determinant of its upper-right
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
quadrant. The entries in the upper-right quadrant are ρ 2 ρ4l (det Bl )2 where Bl is the matrix Bl = (bj,k ) j = 1,...,2l
−j+k 2
175
b−j,k , so det Al =
.
k = 0,...,2l−1
(This also involves interchanging an even number of rows, but this doesn’t affect 2 2 the determinant.) It follows that α4l = ρ4l (det Bl )2 + o(ρ4l ). Proposition 1, stated and proved in the next section, says that det Bl = 0 2 for each l. So then α4l is always comparable to ρ4l . In particular, when l = 1, the product of the four largest eigenvalues is comparable to ρ4 . That is, λ41 = (+iλ1 )(+iλ1 )(−iλ1 )(−iλ1 ) = β1 · ρ4 + o(ρ4 ),
(1)
β1
= 0. In general, the product of the 4l largest eigenvalues is comparable to for 2 ρ4l . That is, 2 2 (2) λ41 λ42 · · · λ4l = βl · ρ4l + o(ρ4l ), 2l−1 2l−1 for βl = 0. From (1) and (2) it follows inductively that λl = βl ρ + o(ρ ) for βl = 0. Next, since λl = O(ρ2l−1 ) for each l, we conclude that α4l and λ41 λ42 · · · λ4l 2 agree to order ρ4l , and 2
2
λ41 λ42 · · · λ4l = ρ4l (det Bl )2 + o(ρ4l ). 1/2
It now follows inductively from (3) that β1 = (det B1 ) (det Bl )1/2 · (det Bl−1 )−1/2 . So the lemma is proved.
(3)
, and for l > 1, βl =
Using a result of Hermann Weyl [18], we recover the same information for A that we now have for An . Weyl proved the result for the case of symmetric kernels; the proof is the same for the case of hermitian or skew-hermitian kernels. See also Porter and Stirling [13, p.146-147]. Lemma 5. Suppose K and K are symmetric kernels in L2 [(a, b) × (a, b)] and denote by χ1 , χ2 , . . ., the eigenvalues for any such kernel, repeated according to multiplicity, and arranged so that |χ1 | ≥ |χ2 | ≥ · · · . Then, |χj+k+1 (K + K )| ≤ |χj+1 (K )| + |χk+1 (K )|. Using the lemma, set K = An , K = A − An , j = l − 1, and k = 0. Then |χl (A)| ≤ |χl (An )| + |χ1 (A − An )|. Also, if K = A and K = An − A then |χl (An )| ≤ |χl (A)| + |χ1 (An − A)|. This means that the eigenvalues of A agree with the eigenvalues of An to within |χ1 (A − An )|. So by (ii), they agree to within O(ρn+1 ), since this is the HilbertSchmidt norm of A − An . Returning to the notation with eigenvalues ±iλl arranged with λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · , where each ±iλl has multiplicity 2, we now choose n ≥ 2l − 1 and find λl (A) = λl (An ) + O(ρ2l ) = βl · ρ2l−1 + o(ρ2l−1 ),
176
Bolt
IEOT
where the βl = 0 are specified in the proof of Lemma 4. Apart from Proposition 1, then, we have left to show only that the βl are bounded by 1. 3.3. Bounding the coefficients. We start with a variant of the Cauchy interlace theorem. Following our earlier convention, associate the spectra of Al and Al−1 with values λ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ · · · ≥ λl ≥ 0 and µ1 ≥ µ2 ≥ · · · ≥ µl−1 ≥ 0, respectively. Then, the relevant minimax formula for λj+1 is |(v, Al v)| λj+1 = min max , u1 ,...,uj v (v, v) where the maximum is taken over vectors v orthogonal to vectors u1 , . . . , uj and their images under the transformations vk ψk → v−k−1 ψk , v k ψk , v −k−1 ψk that occur in Lemma 3. Notice that Al is gotten from Al−1 by adding 4 rows and columns, but these rows and columns correspond with a single vector (for instance, v = ψ2l−1 + iψ2l−2 ) and its transformations. Then, following the usual proof of the interlace theorem as given by Franklin [8], for instance, it follows that λ1 ≥ µ1 ≥ λ2 ≥ µ2 ≥ · · · ≥ µl−1 ≥ λl > 0. Next, we use Feldman, Krupnik, and Spitkovsky’s estimate [7] that says A < 1 for any ellipse, and in particular, λ1 < 1. Then det Al = (λ1 λ2 · · · λl )4 < (1 · λ2 · · · λl )4 ≤ (1 · µ1 · · · µl−1 )4 = det Al−1 . This is true for any ρ, so letting ρ ↑ 1 gives (det Bl )2 = ( det (bj,k ) j = 1,...,2l
k = 0,...,2l−1
)2 ≤ ( det (bj,k ) j = 1,...,2l−2 )2 = (det Bl−1 )2 , k = 0,...,2l−3
and therefore, βl ≤ 1. Numerically, it seems that the coefficients βl increase with an upper limit of 1. Figure 2 illustrates this behavior for 1 ≤ l ≤ 40. The first few leading coefficients βl 1.0
0.5
l 10
20
30
40
Figure 2. Plot of the leading coefficients, βl , for 1 ≤ l ≤ 40.
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
177
are β1 = 1/2, β2 = 25/32, β3 = 441/512, and β4 = 184041/204800. The author determined these coefficients using Mathematica.
4. Proof of Proposition 1 The definition of the bj,k in the proposition below is slightly different from the previous section—we have multiplied the right-hand side by z. So the coefficients bj,k for 1 ≤ j, k ≤ 2m in this section correspond with the coefficients bj,k for 1 ≤ j ≤ 2m, 0 ≤ k ≤ 2m − 1 in the previous section. The order of summation can again be taken symmetrically with respect to w and z; for instance, use partial sums j+k≤n for the left-hand side, and partial sums j+k+l≤n for the right-hand side. Proposition 1. Let coefficients bj,k be determined by the equation 1 1 wz 2 w2j+l z 2k+l . bj,k wj z k = (−1)j+k 2 w − z j,k,l=0...∞ j k j,k=1...∞
j+k+l>0
If Bm is the matrix (bj,k )j,k=1...2m , then det Bm = 0 for m > 0. The proof is combinatorial in nature, and depends on the fact that the bj,k are dyadic rational; that is, they are either zero or they have the form r = 2n · u for u odd and n ∈ Z. We use the valuation | · |2 defined on all rationals according to −n 2 if r = 0 |r|2 = 0 if r = 0 where in the first case r = 2n · u/v for odd u, v. For example, |5/8|2 = 8. The valuation has the following properties (see Jacobson [9, p.211]): (a) |r1 r2 |2 = |r1 |2 · |r2 |2 (b) |r1 + r2 |2 ≤ max(|r1 |2 , |r2 |2 ), with equality only if |r1 |2 = |r2 |2 or r1 = r2 = 0 The proof of Proposition 1 is structured as follows. Let σ range over all permutations of {1, . . . , 2m}. Then, since det Bm = σ j=1...2m (−1)σ bj,σj , we have bj,σj |2 . | det Bm |2 ≤ max | σ
j=1...2m
This will be an equality provided there is a unique permutation σ for which the maximum is attained. We will find such a maximizing permutation, then | det Bm |2 = 0 and det Bm = 0. That is, we will show det Bm is nonzero dyadic rational. We begin by introducing intermediate coefficients dj,k defined by 1 1 2 w2j z 2k , dj,k wj z k = wz + (−1)j+k 2 j k j,k=0...∞ j,k=0...∞
j+k>0
178
Bolt
IEOT
and we claim that if n is fixed, then j+k=n dj,k = 0. For n = 2, it is easy to check that d0,2 + d1,1 + d2,0 = (−1/2) + 1 + (−1/2) = 0. For larger n, notice that dj,k = 0 if either j or k is odd. In particular, if n is odd then j+k=n dj,k = 0. There remains the case when n = 2p for p ≥ 2. We find that 1 1 j+k 2 2 , dj,k = (−1) j k j+k=n
j+k=p
and this is the coefficient of xp in the expansion 1 1 √ √ 2 xj+k , (−1)j+k 2 1−x= 1−x· 1−x= j k j,k≥0
which is evidently zero. So the claim is proved. We may then divide by w − z (rather, we divide by w2 − z 2 , but w − z is a factor of this) and obtain coefficients cj,k that satisfy wz cj,k wj z k = dj,k wj z k . w−z j,k=1...∞
j,k=0...∞
The cj,k and dj,k are related by cn,1 = dn,0 and cn−j,j+1 = dn−j,j + cn−j+1,j for 1 ≤ j < n.
(4)
Notice in particular that c2,1 = −1/2 and c1,2 = 1/2. Following Jacobson [9, p.211], define ν(r) = − log2 |r|2 and ν(0) = ∞. For example, ν(5/8) = − log2 8 = −3. Then the following properties of ν are equivalent to the corresponding properties of | · |2 ; we will use both repeatedly: (a) ν(r1 r2 ) = ν(r1 ) + ν(r2 ) (b) ν(r1 + r2 ) ≥ min(ν(r1 ), ν(r2 )), with equality only if ν(r1 ) = ν(r2 ) or r1 = r2 = 0 Observe that if x denotes the greatest integer less than or equal to x, then p ν( 1/2 p≥0 j/2 for j ≥ 0, since j )= − 1 ( 1 )(− 12 )(− 32 ) · · · ( 12 − j + 1) 2 . = 2 j j! On the right-hand side of this identity, the j multiplicative factors each contribute a factor of 1/2, and the j! contributes j/2 + j/4 + j/8 + · · · factors of 1/2 since j/2k is the number of multiples of 2k in 1, 2, . . . , j. Using this, we can compute the values ν(dj,k ) and obtain a lower estimate for the values ν(cj,k ). Lemma 6. If 1 ≤ j ≤ n, then ν(cj,n+1−j ) ≥ − p>0 n/2p . There is equality when n is a positive power of 2. Proof. If n is odd then dj,n−j ≡ 0, so cj,n+1−j ≡ 0 and ν(cj,n+1−j ) ≡ ∞, and if n = 2 we see directly that ν(c2,1 ) = ν(c1,2 ) = −1. So suppose n ≥ 4 is even, then
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
179
1/2 if j is even. So if j is dj,n−j = 0 if j is odd, and dj,n−j = (−1)n/2 1/2 j/2 (n−j)/2 even, n−j j n ν(dj,n−j ) = − ( 2p + 2p ) ≥ − p , 2 2 2 p>0 p≥0
and since the cj,n+1−j are combinations of the dj,n−j by (4) we have proved the first part of the lemma. If n = 2q for q ≥ 1, we show there is equality. First, notice that ν(dj,2q −j ) = ν(0) = ∞ if j is odd. Next, 2q 2q 0 ν(d2q ,0 ) = − ( 2p + p ) = − p , 2 2 2 p>0 p≥0
and for 0 < j < 2q , j even, q j 2 −j 2q 2q ν(d2q −j,j ) = − ( 2p + 2p ) > − 2p = − p . 2 2 2 2 p>0 p≥0
p≥0
Here the inequality is strict because when p = q − 1, then
2q −j 2 2p
+
j 2 2p
= 0+0 < 1=
2q 2 . 2p
Using (4), it then follows for 1 ≤ j ≤ 2q that |cj,2q +1−j |2 = − p>0 2q /2p , and the lemma is proved. Next we show that bj,k = l=0... min(j−1,k−1) cj−l,k−l . This follows from
min(j−1,k−1)
j,k=1...∞
l=0
cj−l,k−l wj z k =
∞
cj−l,k−l wj−l z k−l · wl z l
l=0 j,k=l+1...∞
=
∞
cj,k wj z k · wl z l
l=0 j,k=1...∞ ∞ wz = dj,k wj z k wl z l w−z l=0 j,k=0...∞ 1 1 ∞ wz 2 w2j z 2k wl z l = (−1)j+k 2 w z + w−z j k j,k=0...∞ l=0
j+k>0
=
wz w−z
(−1)j+k
j,k,l=0...∞ j+k+l>0
We now estimate the value of ν on the bj,k . Lemma 7. If 1 ≤ j ≤ n, then ν(bj,n+1−j ) ≥ − n is a positive power of 2.
p>0 n/2
p
1 1 2 2 w2j+l z 2k+l . j k
. There is equality when
180
Bolt
IEOT
Proof. Using Lemma 6 we compute min(j−1,n−j)
ν(bj,n+1−j ) = ν(
cj−l,n+1−j−l ) ≥
l=0
≥
min
l=0... min(j−1,n−j)
min
l=0... min(j−1,n−j))
−
ν(cj−l,n+1−j−l )
n − 2l n p =− p . 2 2 p>0 p>0
Furthermore, if n = 2q for q ≥ 1, then for l = 0, ν(cj−l,2q +1−j−l ) ≥ −
2q − 2l 2q > − p = ν(cj,2q +1−j ). 2p 2 p>0 p>0
So we find that min(j−1,2q −j)
ν(bj,2q +1−j ) = ν(
cj−l,2q +1−j−l )
l=0
=
min
l=0... min(j−1,2q −j)
ν(cj−l,2q +1−j−l ) = ν(cj,2q +1−j ) = −
2q p , 2 p>0
and the lemma is proved.
We come now to the proof of the proposition, and as a matter of notation ∗ set νn∗ = p>0 n/(2p ). Then the previous lemma says ν(bj,k ) ≥ −νj+k−1 for any j, k with equality provided j + k − 1 is a positive power of 2. We claim there is a ∗ unique permutation σ of {1, . . . , 2m} that maximizes 2m ν , and for this j=1 j+σj −1 permutation, j + σj − 1 is a positive power of 2 for all j. The proposition then follows since ∗ ∗ ν(bj,τj ) ≥ − νj+τ >− νj+σ = ν(bj,σj ) j −1 j −1 j=1...2m
j=1...2m
j=1...2m
j=1...2m
for any other permutation τ . In particular, ν(det Bm ) = j=1...2m ν(bj,σj ) = ∞, and det Bm = 0. We describe how σ is chosen. As j +k−1 increases through the even numbers, there is a significant drop in the value of ν(bj,k ) when j + k − 1 reaches a power of 2; in fact, the size of the drop increases with successive powers of 2. So working from the lower-right of the matrix, choose the permutation σ so that j + σj − 1 is the largest possible power of 2. This determines σj for the range 2q − 2m < j ≤ 2m, where 2q−1 < 2m ≤ 2q . In particular, σ restricts to a permutation of {2q − 2m + 1, . . . , 2m}. Now repeat the procedure for the remaining (2q − 2m) × uniquely determines (2q − 2m) upper-left submatrix and continue. This procedure a permutation σ and the claim says that σ uniquely minimizes j=1...2m ν(bj,σj ) = ∗ − j=1...2m νj+σ . j −1
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
181
To be precise, if σ 2m is the optimal permutation for {1, . . . , 2m} and if q is chosen so that 2q−1 < 2m ≤ 2q , we will find that q 2 − j + 1 if 2q − 2m < j ≤ 2m q σj2m = otherwise. σj2 −2m ∗ As an example, in Figure 3 we show the matrices with entries ν(bj,k ) and νj+k−1 for 1 ≤ j, k ≤ 2m, where m = 3. (See Figure 1 for the related matrix A3 .) The
∞ −1 ∞ −1 ∞ −3 ∞ −3 ∞ −3 ∞ −3 ∞ −4 ∞ −4 ∞ −7
−3 ∞ −4 ∞ −4 ∞ −3 ∞ −7 ∞ −7 ∞ −7 ∞ −7 ∞ −7 ∞
0 1 1 3 3 4
1 1 3 3 4 4
1 3 3 4 4 7
3 3 4 4 7 7
3 4 4 7 7 8
4 4 7 7 8 8
∗ Figure 3. The matrices (ν(bj,k ))j,k=1,...,6 and (νj+k−1 )j,k=1,...,6
permutation that produces the minimal value for j ν(bj,σj ) is indicated in bold typeface. We find that ν(det B6 ) = j ν(bj,σj ) = −30. The claim is proved using induction on m and requires two steps. The first step says that the optimal permutation must restrict to a permutation of {2q − 2m + 1, . . . , 2m}, and the second step specifies its values on this set. The second step establishes the base of the induction as a special case; the base of the induction occurs when 2m = 2q , q ≥ 1. q STEP 1: If τj ≤ 2q − 2m for 2 − 2m < j ≤ 2m, then there is a permutation τ ∗ ∗ ∗ such that l=1...2m νl+τ < l=1...2m νl+τ ∗ −1 . l −1 l
Proof of Step 1. The proof of this step is inductive on j, beginning with j = 2m. So suppose first that τ2m ≤ 2q − 2m and define q 2 − 2m + 1 if l = 2m def τl∗ = τ2m if l = j = τ2−1 q −2m+1 τl otherwise ∗ = τj = 2q − 2m + 1 and τj∗ = τ2m ; otherwise, τ ∗ and τ agree. Then, so that τ2m ∗ + νj∗ +τj −1 = ν2m+τ 2m −1
< =
2m + τ2m − 1 j + (2q − 2m + 1) − 1 + 2p 2p p>0
2q + j + τ2m − 1 2q j + τ2m − 1 = p + p 2 2 2p p>0 p>0
2m + τ ∗ − 1 j + τj∗ − 1 2m ∗ + = ν2m+τ + νj∗ +τ ∗ −1 . ∗ p p 2m −1 j 2 2 p>0
182
Bolt
IEOT
Here, the first and last equalities are by definition, the strict inequality occurs since both 2m + τ2m − 1 < 2q and j + 2q − 2m < 2q , and the second equality∗ occurs q q since j + τ − 1 ≤ 2m + (2 − 2m) − 1 < 2 . It follows that 2m l=1...2m νl+τl −1 < ∗ ν . l=1...2m l+τ ∗ −1 l
For the inductive step, pick the largest j such that τj ≤ 2q −2m and 2q −2m < j ≤ 2m. Like before, define τ by q 2 − j + 1 if l = j def τl = τj if l = j = τ2−1 q −j+1 τl otherwise so that τj = τj = 2q − j + 1 and τj = τj . Consider the two possible cases: ∗ ∗ Case 1: If j > j then l=1...2m νl+τ < l=1...2m νl+τ −1 , since as before, l −1 l
∗ νj+τ + νj∗ +τj −1 = j −1
< =
j + τj − 1 j + (2q − j + 1) − 1 + p 2 2p p>0
(5)
2q + j + τj − 1 2q j + τj − 1 = p + p 2 2 2p p>0 p>0
j + τj − 1 j + τj − 1 ∗ + = νj+τ + νj∗ +τ −1 . p p j −1 j 2 2 p>0
Here, the strict inequality occurs since j + τj − 1 ≤ 2m + (2q − 2m) − 1 < 2q and j + (2q − j + 1) − 1 < j + (2q − j) = 2q , and the second equality occurs since j + τj − 1 ≤ 2m + (2q − 2m) − 1 < 2q . Case 2: If j < j , then the weak since j + (2q − j + 1) − 1 > 2q . inequality∗ in (5) is ∗ Nevertheless, we recover l=1...2m νl+τl −1 ≤ l=1...2m νl+τ for the permutation l −1 q τ for which τj = τj ≤ 2 −2m and j > j. Inductively, then, there is a permutation τ ∗ so that ∗ ∗ ∗ νl+τ ≤ νl+τ νl+τ ∗ −1 < l −1 l −1 l=1...2m
l=1...2m
l
l=1...2m
and the proof of Step 1 is complete.
q q STEP 2: If τ j = 2 − j + 1 for some 2 − 2m ∗< j ≤ 2m then there is a permutation ∗ σ such that l=1...2m νl+τl −1 < l=1...2m νl+σl −1 .
Proof of Step 2. After Step 1 we may assume that 2q − 2m < τj ≤ 2m for all 2q − 2m < j ≤ 2m, and we compute p>0 2q −2m<j≤2m
j + τj − 1 = 2p
p=q 2q −2m<j≤2m
j + τj − 1 + 2p
0
j + τj − 1 , 2p
Vol. 57 (2007) Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein Operator for the Ellipse
183
since j + τj − 1 < 2q+1 for all j. The first sum on the right-hand side gives the number of j for which j + τj − 1 ≥ 2q , and since (j + τj − 1) = 2 · [(2q − 2m + 1) + · · · + (2m)] − [2m − (2q − 2m)] 2q −2m<j≤2m
= (4m − 2q )2q , the second sum is no larger than (4m − 2q )2q
= (4m − 2q ) · 2q−1 + · · · + 2 = (4m − 2q )(2q − 2). p 2 0
0 2q −2m<j≤2m
This completes the proof of Step 2, so the claim is also proved.
References [1] Steven R. Bell. The Cauchy transform, potential theory, and conformal mapping. Studies in Advanced Mathematics. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1992. [2] S. Bergman and M. Schiffer. Kernel functions and conformal mapping. Compositio Math., 8:205–249, 1951. [3] Stefan Bergman. The kernel function and conformal mapping. American Mathematical Society, Providence, R.I., 1970. [4] Michael Bolt. Spectrum of the Kerzman-Stein operator for model domains. Integral Equations Operator Theory, 50(3):305–315, 2004. [5] Jacob Burbea. The Cauchy and the Szeg˝ o kernels on multiply connected regions. Rend. Circ. Mat. Palermo (2), 31(1):105–118, 1982. [6] Adam Coffman and Mark Frantz. M¨ obius transformations and ellipses (preprint). [7] Israel Feldman, Naum Krupnik, and Ilya Spitkovsky. Norms of the singular integral operator with Cauchy kernel along certain contours. Integral Equations Operator Theory, 24(1):68–80, 1996. [8] Joel N. Franklin. Matrix theory. Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1968. [9] Nathan Jacobson. Lectures in abstract algebra. Vol III: Theory of fields and Galois theory. D. Van Nostrand Co., Inc., Princeton, N.J.-Toronto, Ont.-London-New York, 1964. [10] N. Kerzman. Singular integrals in complex analysis. In Harmonic analysis in Euclidean spaces (Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., Williams Coll., Williamstown, Mass., 1978), Part 2, Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., XXXV, Part, pages 3–41. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R.I., 1979.
184
Bolt
IEOT
[11] N. Kerzman and E. M. Stein. The Cauchy kernel, the Szeg¨ o kernel, and the Riemann mapping function. Math. Ann., 236(1):85–93, 1978. [12] N. Kerzman and E. M. Stein. The Szeg˝ o kernel in terms of Cauchy-Fantappi`e kernels. Duke Math. J., 45(2):197–224, 1978. [13] David Porter and David S. G. Stirling. Integral equations. Cambridge Texts in Applied Mathematics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1990. [14] M. Schiffer. The Fredholm eigen values of plane domains. Pacific J. Math., 7:1187– 1225, 1957. [15] M. Schiffer. Fredholm eigen values of multiply-connected domains. Pacific J. Math., 9:211–269, 1959. [16] Menahem Schiffer. Fredholm eigenvalues and conformal mappings. Rend. Mat. e Appl. (5), 22:447–468, 1963. [17] Vikramaditya Singh. An integral equation associated with the Szeg¨ o kernel function. Proc. London Math. Soc. (3), 10:376–394, 1960. [18] Hermann Weyl. Das asymptotische Verteilungsgesetz der Eigenwerte linearer partieller Differentialgleichungen (mit einer Anwendung auf die Theorie der Hohlraumstrahlung). Math. Ann., 71(4):441–479, 1912. [19] J. B. Wilker. When is the inverse of an ellipse convex? Utilitas Math., 17:45–50, 1980. Michael Bolt Department of Mathematics 1740 Knollcrest Circle SE Calvin College Grand Rapids, Michigan 49546 USA e-mail: [email protected] Submitted: February 21, 2006 Revised: July 13, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 185–207 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020185-23, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1451-3
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Calculation of the Defect Numbers of the Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Value Problems with Linear Fractional Carleman Shift Jorge Ferreira, Gueorgui S. Litvinchuk and Maur´ıcio D. L. Reis Abstract. The defect numbers of the generalized Hilbert and Carleman boundary value problems with a direct or an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2 (α (α (t)) ≡ t) on the unit circle are computed. The approach followed consists of the reduction of the mentioned problems to singular integral equations with linear fractional Carleman shift and of the factorization of Hermitian matrix functions with negative determinant. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47G10; Secondary 47A68. Keywords. Boundary value problems, singular integral operators, Carleman shift, factorization, Fredholm theory, solvability theory.
1. Introduction As it is well known, the problem of calculation of the defect numbers l, of linearly independent solutions, and ρ, of solvability conditions, for boundary value problems of analytic functions and the description of its defect subspaces are very important and very difficult as well. However, when we consider problems with binomial boundary conditions on a simply connected domain, they can be solved effectively without any complications. For example, we have a scalar Riemann (Riemann-Hilbert) boundary value problem, a Hasemann boundary value problem, a Carleman boundary value problem, etc (see [8]). For these problems the defect pair (l, ρ) is calculated by the Gakhov-Coburn formulas l = max (0, I)
, ρ = max (0, −I)
(1.1)
Gueorgui S. Litvinchuk was supported by European Social Fund (POPRAMIII) through CITMA (Centro de Ciˆencia e Tecnologia da Madeira).
186
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
where I is the index of a Fredholm boundary value problem. For boundary value problems with polynomial boundary conditions, the defect numbers depend not only on topological characteristics but also on conformal and metrical characteristics. As examples, we have the boundary value problems with the shift and the complex conjugation operators, which contain, in the boundary condition, more than two values of unknown functions. One of the most studied problems is the generalized Riemann boundary value problem Φ+ (t) = a (t) Φ− (t) + b (t) Φ− (t) + h (t) (1.2) on a simply connected contour Γ for a piecewise analytic function {Φ+ (z) , Φ− (z)}. This problem appeared in 1946, when the boundary condition (1.2) was considered in the paper of Markushevich [14]. There are a few hundred publications devoted to problem (1.2) and its generalizations and modifications, which has numerous applications, for example, in the elasticity theory, in the geometry of surfaces, in the distribution of physical fields, etc. The most complete result about the defect numbers of problem (1.2) on the unit circle was obtained twenty five years ago by G. Litvinchuk and I. Spitkovsky ([11], [12]), see also ([8],ch.4). The central idea of the papers [11], [12] consists in the establishment of a direct connection between the solvability theory of problem (1.2) and the factorization of the Hermitian matrix function with negative determinant 2 2 |b| − |a| tb , t∈ (1.3) tb 1 and also on finding an algorithm to compute the partial indices of the matrix (1.3). From the papers [11] and [12] we have l
=
max (0, 2κ) , ρ = max (0, −2κ) , if m ≤ |κ|
l
=
κ + m , ρ = κ − m, if m ≥ |κ|
where κ = IndΓ a (t), (m, −m) are the partial indices of the matrix (1.3). The purpose of this paper is to show that, in the case of a linear fractional Carleman shift on the unit circle, the defect numbers of a generalized Hilbert boundary value problem Re{a(t)Φ+ (t) + b(t)Φ+ (α(t))} = h(t)
(1.4)
and of a generalized Carleman boundary value problem Φ+ (α (t)) = a (t) Φ+ (t) + b (t) Φ+ (t) + h (t)
(1.5)
are also obtained from the factorization of Hermitian matrix functions with negative determinants. We also use the results of the papers [6], [1], on the factorization of singular integral operators with linear fractional Carleman shift. For simplicity we consider problems (1.4) and (1.5) in the H¨older space. However, for any decomposable Banach algebra of continuous functions on , containing the class of rational functions without poles on , the same results are valid.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
187
2. Auxiliary information and notation All the results of this section can be found in [8]. 2.1. Some results on singular integral operators with shift Let Γ be a Lyapunov curve and α : Γ → Γ be a direct or an inverse Carleman shift of order 2 (α (α (t)) = t), such that α (t) = 0 on Γ and α (t) ∈ Hµ (Γ). Let W be the corresponding shift operator. We consider the operator 1 (2.1) K = (aI + bW ) P+ + (cI + dW ) P− , P± = (I ± S) 2 in the H¨ older space Hµ (Γ) (a, b, c, d ∈ Hµ (Γ)), and its companion operator = (aI − bW ) P+ + (cI − dW ) P− . K These operators satisfy the following identity 1 K 0 I I I W = AP+ + BP− + D W −W I −W 0 K 2 where, for a direct shift on Γ (α = α+ (t)), a (t) b (t) c (t) d (t) A= , B= b (α (t)) a (α (t)) d (α (t)) c (α (t)) and, for an inverse shift on Γ (α = α− (t)), a (t) d (t) c (t) b (t) A= , B= b (α (t)) c (α (t)) d (α (t)) a (α (t))
(2.2)
(2.3)
(2.4)
and D is a compact operator given by D = (d (t) (W SW − γS) , c (α (t)) (W SW − γS)) with γ = ±1 if α = α± (t), respectively. The following theorem gives us the Fredholm condition of operator (2.1) and its index formula. Theorem 2.1. The operator (2.1) is a Fredholm operator if and only if ∆1 (t) = c (t) c (α (t)) − d (t) d (α (t)) = 0 ∆2 (t) = a (t) a (α (t)) − b (t) b (α (t)) = 0 when α = α+ (t) is a direct Carleman shift on Γ; and ∆ (t) = a (t) c (α (t)) − d (t) b (α (t)) = 0 when α = α− (t) is an inverse Carleman shift on Γ. The index of the Fredholm operator (2.1) is given by 1 ∆1 (t) if α = α+ (t) indK = arg 4π ∆2 (t) Γ 1 {arg ∆ (t)}Γ if α = α− (t) . indK = − 2π
188
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
2.2. Singular integral operators with linear fractional Carleman shift Now we consider the case of a linear fractional Carleman shift on the unit circle = {t ∈ C : |t| = 1}, t−β α (t) = , t∈ , |β| = 1 (2.5) βt − 1 which is a direct or an inverse shift if |β| < 1 or |β| > 1, respectively. The shift function (2.5) admits the following factorization α (t) = α+ (t) tµ α− (t)
(2.6)
−1 where α+ (t) = λ βt − 1 , α− (t) = λ−1 (t − β) t−1 , λ = 1 − |β|2 , µ = −1 −1 , λ = 1 if |β| < 1 and α+ (t) = (iλ) (t − β) , α− (t) = iλt βt − 1
2 |β| − 1 , µ = −1 if |β| > 1. We also have −1 α± (α (t)) = α± (t) if |β| < 1 α± (α (t))
= α∓ (t) if |β| > 1.
Let us introduce the weighted shift operators (U ϕ) (t) = kγ (t) (W ϕ) (t) , where the functions kγ (t), γ = ±1, are defined by the formulas k1 (t) = k−1 (t) =
−α+ (t) if |β| < 1 α− (t) t−1 if |β| > 1.
Then, kγ (t) kγ (α (t)) ≡ 1, γ = ±1 and U 2 = I , U S = γSU , γ = ±1. It is possible to obtain the defect numbers and also to construct the defect subpaces of the singular integral operator K = (aI + bU ) P+ + (cI + dU ) P− . In particular, it’s defect numbers can be computed using the following theorems, and Theorem 2.1. Theorem 2.2. Let α = α+ (t) be a linear fractional Carleman shift. Let κ1 ≥ κ2 be the partial indices of the matrix C = A−1 B and let ε ∈ {−1, 1}. Then if κ1 ≤ 0 0 κ1 1−ε if κ1 > 0, κ2 ≤ 0 . + dim ker K = κ12+κ2 4 = indK if κ2 > 0 2 This theorem can be found in [6]. In the same paper, Proposition 2.2 gives a formula to calculate the number ε, which is uniquely determined by the matrix function C. For the case of an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift we have the following result (see [1], [5]):
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
189
Theorem 2.3. Let α = α− (t) be a linear fractional Carleman shift. Let κ1 ≥ κ2 be the partial indices of the matrix C = A−1 B and let ε ∈ {−1, 1}. Then 0 if κ1 ≤ 0 κ1 if κ1 > 0 and κ2 ≤ 0 and κ1 is even 2 dim ker K = . κ1 −ε if κ1 > 0 and κ2 ≤ 0 and κ1 is odd 2 κ1 +κ2 = indK if κ2 > 0 2 Again, the number ε is uniquely determined by the matrix function C (see [1] or Theorem 1 of section 21.2 of [8]) 2.3. Factorization of Hermitian matrix functions We introduce the Hankel operator H (G) = P− GP+ . Together with this operator we shall consider the operator 1 ∗ H (G) H (G) 2 = |H (G)| ∗
where H (G) is the adjoint operator of H (G). Let s∞ (G) be the right-end of the condensation spectrum (i.e., the set of limit points of the spectrum and eigenvalues of infinite multiplicity) of operator |H (G)|. Let s0 (G) ≥ s1 (G) ≥ · · · be a sequence of eigenvalues of operator H (G), the so called s-numbers of H (G). When the number q of terms in this sequence is finite, then, by definition, we put sq (G) = sq+1 (G) = · · · = s∞ (G). We consider the non-singular Hermitian matrix function a (t) b (t) G (t) = b (t) d (t) ), a and d are real functions. Since det G (t) = 0, the function where a, b, d ∈ Hµ ( 2 ∆ (t) = ad − |b| preserves its sign on . If ∆ (t) > 0, then the partial indices of the matrix function G (t) are equal to zero. Let us assume that ∆ (t) < 0 and that one of the diagonal elements of the matrix function G (t) (for example, d) does not vanish on . Then, we have the representations 2 2 , d2 = |d+ | ∆ = − |∆+ | ±1 where ∆±1 + and d+ belong to the class of functions analytic on |z| < 1 and continuous on |z| ≤ 1. Now, we consider the Hankel operator
H (ω) = P− ωP+ b d+ . d ∆+ The following results can be found in [11].
where ω =
190
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
Theorem 2.4. The partial indices of the matrix function G (t), with ∆ (t) < 0, are equal to l and −l (l ≥ 0), where l is the multiplicity of 1 as an s-number of the operator H (ω). In particular, the partial indices are equal to zero if and only if the operator I − H (ω)∗ H (ω) is invertible. The following theorem gives another method for computing the partial indices of the matrix function G (t). Theorem 2.5. Let m be the smallest possible exact (i.e., calculated with multiplicity taken into account) number of coincidences in |z| < 1 of the rational functions r1 and r2 , having no poles in common in |z| < 1and satisfying on the inequalities |b (t) − d (t) r1 (t)| < −∆ (t) < |b (t) − d (t) r2 (t)| . Then partial indices of the matrix function G (t) are equal to ±m.
3. Generalized Hilbert boundary value problem with linear fractional Carleman shift Let Γ be a simple closed Lyapunov curve dividing the complex plane C in two parts D+ and D− , and let α be a direct or inverse shift on Γ, such that α (t) = 0, t ∈ Γ and α ∈ Hµ (Γ). The generalized Hilbert boundary value problem consists of finding a function Φ+ (z) = u(x, y) + iv(x, y) , z = x + iy , analytic in the domain D+ , so that the limit values of its real and imaginary parts belong to Hµ (Γ) and satisfy on Γ the condition a(t)u(t) + b(t)u(α(t)) + c(t)v(t) + d(t)v(α(t)) = h(t) ,
(3.1)
where a, b, c, d, h ∈ Hµ (Γ) are real functions. The boundary condition (3.1) can also be written in the form Re{A(t)Φ+ (t) + B(t)Φ+ (α(t))} = h(t) ,
(3.2)
with A (t) = a (t) − ic (t) and B (t) = b (t) − id (t). Notice that, if b (t) = d (t) ≡ 0 we obtain the classical Hilbert (RiemannHilbert) boundary value problem (see, e.g., Gakhov [2], Muskhelishvili [15]). Problem (3.1) (or (3.2)) was proposed by E.G. Khasabov and G.S. Litvinchuk [3]. In their papers [3] and [4], they obtained the Fredholm conditions and the index formula of problem (3.1), with a direct or an inverse Carleman shift α of order 2 (α (α (t)) ≡ t) on Γ. In this section we let γ = +1 or γ = −1 if α is a direct or an inverse shift, respectively. We start by introducing some identities. Put ∆ (t) =
A (t) A (α (t)) − B (t) B (α (t)) ,
θ (t) =
A (t)A (α (t)) − B (t) B (α (t)) ,
V (t) =
B (t) A (α (t)) − B (t)A (α (t)) ,
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
191
The following identities can be directly verified: 2
2
|θ (t)| − |∆ (t)| = V (t) V (α (t)) ,
(3.3)
θ (t) = θ (α (t)) , ∆ (t) = ∆ (α (t)) , V (t) + V (t) = 0 .
(3.4)
Let us note that from the last identity in (3.4) it follows that ReV = 0, consequently V = iV0 where V0 is a real function. We define Λ (t, γ) = (1 + γ) ∆ (t) + (1 − γ) θ (t) ,
t∈Γ
and κ = indΓ Λ (t, γ) .
The Fredholm condition and the index I of problem (3.2) are given by the the formulas ∆ (t) = 0, if γ = +1 (3.5) θ (t) = 0, if γ = −1 and I = κ + 1, (3.6) respectively. The defect numbers of problem (3.2) were obtained in the paper [3], but only for some particular cases, namely, when θ (t) ≡ 0 (in the case α = α+ ) or V (t) ≡ 0 (in the cases α = α± ). If α is a linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2 on the unit circle , then the defect numbers of problem (3.2) can be computed. 3.1. The case of a direct linear fractional Carleman shift In this subsection we consider α a direct linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2 on . We start by observing that for Γ = , the study of the solvability theory of problem (3.2) can be reduced to the study of the solvability theory of the singular integral operator with shift T = (AI + BW ) P+ − tAI + α (t) BW P− . (3.7) Indeed, we have 2Re AΦ+ + BΦ+ (α) = (AI + BW ) Φ+ + AI + BW CΦ+ , where CΦ+ = Φ+ Now, if we extend the function Φ+ (z) to D− by defining 1 1 Φ− (z) = Φ+ = Φ+ , for z ∈ D− , z z
(3.8)
on we have Φ+ = Φ− . Introducing a new unknown function Φ− 1 (z) defined by 1 − Φ− 1 (z) = Φ (z) , z we obtain (3.9) 2Re AΦ+ + BΦ+ (α) = (AI + BW ) Φ+ + tAI + α (t) BW Φ− 1 . Finally, as Φ− 1 (∞) = 0, we can write (3.9) in the form (3.7).
192
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
Throughout this subsection, we will consider a direct linear fractional Carleman shift α of the form (2.5) and the weighted shift operator, (U ϕ) (t) = u (t) ϕ (α (t)), with u (t) = −α+ (t), introduced in Subsection 2.2. The following conditions hold U 2 = I , U S = SU and u (t) u (α (t)) ≡ 1 . Hence, the singular integral operator (3.7) can be written in the form T = AI + u−1 BU P+ + aI + bU P− , with a (t) = −
α (t) u−1 (t) V (t) and b (t) = . ∆ (t)
tθ (t) ∆ (t)
From the Fredholm condition (3.5) we have ∆ (t) = 0 and, as u (t) u (α (t)) ≡ 1, the functional operator T1 = AI + u−1 BU is continuously invertible. So it remains to study the operator − , with A (t) = 1 T = P+ + AP −tθ (t) I + α (t) u−1 (t) V (t) U . ∆ (t) Now we can apply the results of Subsection 2.1 to the operator T. We note that, in this case, the compact operator D does not appear in (2.2), because we have U S = SU . Thus, the operator in identity (2.2) has the form 1 −tθ (t) α (t) u−1 (t) V (t) M = P+ + BP− , with B = . tu (t) V (α (t)) −α (t) θ (t) ∆ (t) (3.10) ∆(t) and Theorems 2.1 and Note that det B = tα (t) = 0. Therefore, using M ∆(t)
2.2, we obtain the defect numbers of problem (3.7). To this end, we rewrite matrix B in the form 1 −θ (t) u−1 (t) V (t) t B= 0 (t) u (t) V (α (t)) −θ ∆ (t)
0 α (t)
.
(3.11)
Bearing in mind that V = iV0 (where V0 is a real function), we obtain −1 1 iθ (t) u (t) V0 (t) 0 α (t) i 0 B= (3.12) t 0 0 −i iθ (t) −u (t) V0 (α (t)) ∆ (t) Note that −1 u (t) V0 (t) iθ (t)
iθ (t) −u (t) V0 (α (t))
=
u−1 (t) 0 0 1
B0
1 0 0 u (t)
, (3.13)
where
B0 =
V0 (t) iθ (t) iθ (t) −V0 (α (t))
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
193
is an Hermitian matrix function with negative determinant. Indeed, using (3.3), we have 2
2
2
Λ (t) = |B0 | = −V0 (t) V0 (α (t)) − |θ (t)| = V (t) V (α (t)) − |θ (t)| = − |∆ (t)| . Now, supposing V0 (α (t)) = 0 on , we can apply Theorem 2.5 to the matrix B0 . Hence, the partial indices of matrix B0 are ±m, where m is the smallest possible exact (i.e., calculated with multiplicity taken into account) number of and coincidences in |z| < 1 of the rational functions r1 and r2 , without poles on with no common poles in |z| < 1 which satisfy on the inequalities |iθ (t) + V0 (α (t)) r1 (t)| < −Λ (t) < |iθ (t) + V0 (α (t)) r2 (t)| . Then we have the following factorization of matrix B0 m 0 t + B0 = χ χ− , 0 t−m where the matrix functions χ+ and χ− are analytic in |z| < 1 and |z| > 1, respectively, and det χ± = 0. Let us compute the partial indices of the matrix function B. Using (3.12) and (3.13) we obtain −1 1 0 1 t 0 iu (t) 0 B= . B0 u (t) 0 0 α (t) 0 −i ∆ (t) Bearing in mind the factorization α (t) = α+ (t) tα− (t)(see (2.6)) and the identity u (t) = −α+ (t), it follows −1 t 1 0 1 0 0 1 iu (t) 0 B0 B = 0 −i 0 α+ (t) 0 α− (t) −α+ (t) 0 ∆ (t) + −1 t 0 0 1 1 0 α (t) iu (t) 0 = B0 0 −i 0 α+ (t) −1 0 0 α− (t) ∆ (t) −1 + t 0 1 1 0 0 iu (t) 0 α (t) B0 = −1 0 0 α− (t) 0 α+ (t) 0 −i ∆ (t) t R+ B0 R− , = ∆ (t) −i 0 + where the matrix function R = is analytic in |z| < 1 and 0 −iα+ (t) 0 α− (t) det R+ = 0 in |z| < 1 and the matrix function R− = is analytic −1 0 in |z| > 1 and det R− = 0 in |z| > 1. Finally we observe that the function ∆ admits the following factorization, ∆ (t) = ∆+ (t) t−κ ∆− (t) , where κ=
1 arg ∆ (t) = Ind ∆ (t) , 2π
194
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
and the matrix function B can be rewritten in the form 1 1 0 0 tκ 0 t 0 ∆+ (t) ∆− (t) + B= B R R− . 0 1 1 κ 0 t 0 t 0 0 + − ∆ (t) ∆ (t) From this last equality we conclude that the partial indices of B are κ1 = κ + m + 1 and κ2 = κ − m + 1 . Finally, using Theorem 2.2, we obtain the following result about the solvability theory of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.2) with a direct linear fractional Carleman shift on . Theorem 3.1. The defect numbers l and ρ, of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.2) with a direct linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2 on are given by: 1. l = max (0, κ + 1) 2. l = dim ker T = even; 3. l =
κ1 2
+
1−ε 4
κ1 2
, =
=
ρ = max (0, −κ − 1) , if κ1 ≤ 0 or κ2 > 0; κ+m+1 2 κ+m 2 κ+m 2
,
ρ=
−κ+m−1 2
if ε = 1
+ 1 if ε = −1 if κ1 > 0, κ2 ≤ 0 and κ1 is odd.
, if κ1 > 0, κ2 ≤ 0 and κ1 is
, ρ=
−κ+m 2 −κ+m 2
− 1 if ε = 1 if ε = −1
,
Now we consider two particular cases of problem (3.2) with α = α+ : the case ∆ (t) = 0 and θ (t) ≡ 0 and the case ∆ (t) = 0 and V (t) ≡ 0. Then, either 1 0 F (t) , with F (t) = α (t) u−1 (t) V (t) , B= F (α (t)) 0 ∆ (t) or 1 −tθ (t) 0 B= . 0 −α (t) θ (t) ∆ (t) From Ind F (t) = 1 and Ind θ (t) = 0 we conclude that in both cases l = max (0, κ + 1) and ρ = max (0, −κ − 1), i.e., the solvability theory is given by the Gakhov-Coburn formulas. We finish this Subsection with an example of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.2), whose defect numbers, l and ρ, do not always satisfy the Gakhov-Coburn formulas (1.1). Example 3.2. Let us consider the generalized Hilbert problem Re t−k [u (t) + iv (−t)] = h (t) on , with k ∈ Z .
(3.14)
First of all we note that, for t = eiϕ , with ϕ ∈ [0, 2π[, we have tk = cos (kϕ) + i sin (kϕ). Therefore problem (3.14) can be written in the form Re cos (kϕ) Φ+ (t) − i sin (kϕ) Φ+ (α (t)) = h (t) , t = eiϕ ∈ ,
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
195
where α (t) = −t is a particular case (β = 0) of a direct linear fractional Carleman shift and Φ+ (t) = u (t) + iv (t). Hence, comparing (3.14) and (3.2), we can see that A (t) = cos (kϕ) = Re t−k and B (t) = −i sin (kϕ) = iIm t−k . Then t2k + t−2k t2k − t−2k , V (t) = − (−1)k . 2 2 From this we can see that the Fredholm condition of problem (3.14) is fulfilled (∆ (t) = 0) and, as κ = Ind ∆ (t) = 0, its index is I = κ + 1 = 1. We note that, as condition V (t) = 0 is not satisfied, we can not apply Theorems 2.4 and 2.5 to obtain the partial indices of matrix B (see (3.11)). However, for this example, the matrix function B takes the form 2k 1 t 0 t + t−2k t2k − t−2k . B=− 0 −t t2k − t−2k t2k + t−2k 2 ∆ (t) = (−1)k , θ (t) = (−1)k
Since the first of these matrices is circulant (see e.g. [13], p. 159), we have 2k 2k t + t−2k t2k − t−2k 1 1 t 1 1 0 = . (3.15) 1 −1 1 −1 0 t−2k t2k − t−2k t2k + t−2k Thus, B
1 = − 2 1 = − 2
1 1 1 −1 1 1 1 −1
t2k 0
0
t−2k
t2k+1 0
0 t−2k+1
1 1 t 0 1 1 −1 0 t 0 1 −1 . 1 1
0 −1
(3.16)
Hence, the partial indices of the matrix function B are given by: κ1
= 2k + 1 and κ2 = −2k + 1 ,
if k ≥ 0
κ1
= −2k + 1
if k < 0 .
and κ2 = 2k + 1 ,
Finally we compute the number ε. It can be obtained from the following identity (see Proposition 2.2 of [6]) ε p (3.17) = (Λ+ )−1 (B + )−1 (α) eB + , 0 −ε κ κ where Λ+ = diag (α+ ) 1 , (α+ ) 2 , p is a polynomial of degree at most κ1 − κ2 . For the case k ≥ 0, we have 1 1 1 1 −1 + − B = and B = − , 1 −1 1 1 2 and it follows that ε = −1. Applying Theorem 3.1, we obtain that the number of linearly independent solutions of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.14) is given by l = k + 1 and this problem is solvable under the fulfillment of ρ = k solvability conditions. When k < 0, we need another factorization of matrix B. Observing that, −2k+1 2k+1 0 0 t 0 1 t =e e, with e = , 1 0 0 t−2k+1 0 t2k+1
196
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
from (3.16), we obtain −2k+1 1 1 1 0 1 1 t B=− . 1 −1 −1 1 0 t2k+1 2 1 1 1 1 1 + − , B = −2 , and from (3.17) we Now we have B = −1 1 1 −1 obtain ε = 1. Again as a result of Theorem 3.1, the defect numbers of problem (3.14) are given by l = −k and ρ = −k − 1. Remark 3.3. In the previous example, the Gakhov-Coburn formulas (1.1) hold only if k = 0 or k = −1. Moreover, only in those two cases the non-homogeneous problem (3.14) is unconditionally solvable. We note that problem (3.14) can be reduced to a system of two Schwartz problems, whose solutions are found in the class of even and odd analytic functions (see [4] and also [8], example 23.1). 3.2. The case of an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift Now we will study the solvability theory of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.2) when Γ = and α is an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2 (see formula (2.5)). Here the Fredholm condition takes the form θ (t) = 0. Besides, κ = Ind θ (t) and the index of problem (3.2) is given by the formula I = κ + 1. In this subsection we consider the operator U defined by (U ϕ) (t) = u (t) ϕ (α (t)) , with u (t) = α− (t) t−1 , which fulfills the following conditions U 2 = I , U S = −SU and u (t) u (α (t)) ≡ 1 . As we have seen in the previous subsection, the study of the solvability theory of problem (3.2) can be reduced to the study of the solvability theory of operator (3.7), which can be written in the form T = A (t) I + u−1 (t) B (t) U P+ − tA (t)I + α (t) u−1 (t) B (t)U P− . (3.18) Once again, the matricial identity (2.2) does not contain the compact operator D because of the fact that U S = −SU . Then the solvability theory of operator T can be obtained from the solvability theory of the singular integral operator without shift (see (2.2) and (2.4)) A=
M = AP+ + BP− , with u−1 (t) B (t) tA (t) A (t) α (t) u−1 (t) B (t) B= u (t) B (α (t)) α (t) A (α (t)) tu (t) B (α (t)) A (α (t))
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
197
From the Fredholm condition θ (t) = 0 we have det A = α (t) θ (t) = 0, therefore A is an invertible matrix and 1 α (t) A (α (t)) −α (t) u−1 (t) B (t) −1 A = . −u (t) B (α (t)) A (t) α (t) θ (t) Hence, it is enough to study = P+ + CP− , M with −1
C =A
B=
1 α (t) θ (t)
tα (t) ∆ (t) −tu (t) V (α (t))
u−1 (t) α (t) V (t) ∆ (t)
(3.19)
As det C = tθ(t) = 0, according to Theorems 2.1 and 2.3, the defect α(t)θ(t) numbers of the operator T can be obtained from a factorization of the matrix C. We start by rewriting the matrix C in the form 1 α (t) u−1 (t) 0 tu (t) 0 ∆ (t) V (t) C= . 0 1 0 1 −V (α (t)) ∆ (t) α (t) θ (t) Since V = iV0 (where V0 is a real function), we obtain 1 0 1 tu (t) 0 iα (t) u−1 (t) 0 C= C0 , 0 −i 1 0 0 1 α (t) θ (t) where
C0 =
V0 (t) i∆ (t)
i∆ (t) V0 (α (t))
(3.20)
is an Hermitian matrix function with negative determinant. In fact, using (3.3), we obtain |C0 | = V0 (t) V0 (α (t)) − |∆ (t)|2 = −V (t) V (α (t)) − |∆ (t)|2 = − |θ (t)|2 . If we impose the condition V0 (α (t)) = 0, t ∈ and apply Theorem 2.5 to the matrix C0 , arguments similar to those used in Subsection 3.1 (where we have considered matrix B0 ) allow us to conclude that the partial indices of C0 are ±m. Then m 0 t + (3.21) C0 = C0 C0− . 0 t−m Using the factorization α (t) = α+ (t) t−1 α− (t) and the fact that u (t) = α (t) t−1 , from (3.20) we obtain m + 1 0 t 0 1 iα (t) 0 + − C = C0 C0 0 −i 0 t−m α− (t) 0 α (t) θ (t) m 1 0 0 t α(t)θ(t) + = R R− , 1 0 t−m 0 −
α(t)θ(t)
198
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
iα+ (t) 0 0 −i
IEOT
C0+ is analytic in |z| < 1 with 0 1 − + − det R = 0 in |z| < 1, and the matrix function R = C0 is analytic α− (t) 0 − in |z| > 1 with det R = 0 in |z| > 1. We also observe that the first matrix admits the following factorization 1 0 α(t)θ(t) where the matrix function R+ =
0 =t
κ+1
1 α(t)θ(t) 1 α+ (t)θ + (t)
0
0 1 α+ (t)θ + (t)
1 α− (t)θ − (t)
0
0 1 α− (t)θ − (t)
+ κ − where κ = Ind θ (t), and θ (t) = θ (t) t θ (t). Finally we obtain κ+1+m 0 t + C=G G− , 0 tκ+1−m
where
+
G =
1 α+ (t)θ + (t)
0
0
+
−
R ,G =R
1 α+ (t)θ + (t)
−
1 α− (t)θ − (t)
0
(3.22)
0
1 α− (t)θ − (t)
.
From (3.22) we conclude that the partial indices of the matrix function C are κ1 = κ + 1 + m
and κ2 = κ + 1 − m .
Now we can apply Theorem 2.3 to obtain the following result on the defect numbers of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.2). Theorem 3.4. The defect numbers l and ρ, of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem (3.2) with an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2 of the form (2.5) on are given by: 1. l = max (0, κ + 1) 2. l =
κ1 2
=
κ1 −ε 2
3. l = is odd.
κ+1+m 2
=
and and
κ+1+m−ε 2
ρ = max (0, −κ − 1) , if κ1 ≤ 0 or κ2 > 0, ρ= and
−κ−1+m 2
ρ=
, if κ1 > 0 and κ2 ≤ 0 and κ1 is even,
−κ−1+m−ε 2
, if κ1 > 0 and κ2 ≤ 0 and κ1
If V (t) ≡ 0, we have a degenerate case for which the matrix C, introduced in (3.19), takes the form 1 tα (t) ∆ (t) 0 C= . 0 ∆ (t) α (t) θ (t) According to the second identity in (3.4), {arg ∆ (t)}Γ = 0. Therefore, the partial indices of the matrix C are κ1 = κ2 = κ + 1, with κ = Ind θ (t). Hence, as a result of Theorem 2.5, we get l = max (0, κ + 1) and ρ = max (0, −κ − 1).
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
199
In the rest of this subsection we will consider the shift α (t) = 1t . First of all, we note that this is an inverse Carleman shift (α (α (t)) ≡ t) on , but it is not a particular case of a linear fractional Carleman shift of the form (2.5). Together with this shift we consider the so called flip operator U , defined by (U ϕ) (t) = 1t ϕ 1t . It is easy to prove that all the previous results for the case of an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift of the form (2.5) remain valid in these conditions. In fact, it is enough to replace, in the above procedure, u (t) by t−1 and to observe that, since α (t) = t−1 , we have α+ (t) = α− (t) = 1 (see (2.6)). In this case, the defect numbers can be obtained with the aid of Theorem 3.4 and a factorization of the matrix (c.f. (3.19)) t ∆ (t) V (t) C= . (3.23) −V (α (t)) ∆ (t) θ (t) Finally we present an example of the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem with the shift α (t) = 1t , for which the defect numbers l and ρ do not always fulfill the Gakhov-Coburn formulas (1.1). Example 3.5. We consider the generalized Hilbert boundary value problem 1 −k Re t u (t) + iv = h (t) on , with k ∈ Z . (3.24) t As in Example 3.2, problem (3.24) can be written in the form (3.2) with α (t) = 1t , A (t) = cos (kϕ) = Re t−k and B (t) = −i sin (kϕ) = iIm t−k , where t = eiϕ , ϕ ∈ [0, 2π[. We have t2k − t−2k t2k + t−2k , V (t) = − . 2 2 In particular, since θ (t) = 1 = 0, the Fredholm condition of problem (3.24) is satisfied. Besides, κ = Ind θ (t) = 0 and, consequently, the index of this problem is I = κ + 1 = 1. As (U ϕ) (t) = 1t ϕ 1t , taking into account the remarks made before this example, we obtain (see (3.23)) t t2k + t−2k − t2k − t−2k C = = − t2k − t−2k t2k + t−2k 2 2k 1 −1 0 t 0 −1 0 t + t−2k t2k − t−2k = . 0 1 0 t 0 1 t2k − t−2k t2k + t−2k 2 θ (t) = 1 , ∆ (t) =
From factorization (3.15), we get 2k+1 1 −1 −1 t C= 1 −1 0 2
0
t−2k+1
−1 −1
1 −1
Hence, the partial indices of the matrix function C are: κ1
= 2k + 1 and κ2 = −2k + 1 ,
if k ≥ 0
κ1
= −2k + 1
if k < 0 .
and κ2 = 2k + 1 ,
.
200
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
It remains to find the number ε mentioned in Theorem 2.3. It can be obtained from the factorization of matrix C and the identity ε p Λ+ C − (α) eC + = , (3.25) 0 −ε κ1 κ2 κ κ t−β where Λ+ (t) = diag (α+ (t)) 1 , (α+ (t)) 2 = diag , e = , t−β iλ iλ 0 1 , and p is a polynomial of degree at most κ1 − κ2 (see [1] ). 1 0 −1 1 −1 −1 If k ≥ 0, putting C + = 12 and using and C − = −1 −1 1 −1 (3.25) (with α+ (t) = α− (t) = 1) we get ε = −1. Thus, applying Theorem 3.4, we conclude that the homogeneous problem corresponding to problem (3.24) has k +1 linearly independent solutions (l = κ + 1) and the non-homogeneous problem (3.24) is solvable if and only if k solvability conditions are fulfilled (ρ = κ). For k < 0, proceeding as in the corresponding case of Example 3.2 we get the following factorization of matrix C −2k+1 1 0 −1 −1 −1 −1 t C= 0 t2k+1 −1 1 −1 1 2 −1 −1 −1 −1 Therefore, C + = 12 and ε = 1. Hence, from , C− = −1 1 −1 1 Theorem 3.4, we obtain that problem (3.24) is solvable if and only if −k − 1 solvability conditions hold (ρ = −k − 1). Moreover, in this case, problem (3.24) has −k linearly independent solutions (l = −k). Remark 3.6. The non-homogeneous problem (3.24) is only unconditionally solvable if k = 0 or k = −1. These are also the only two cases for which the defect numbers l and ρ fulfil the Gakhov-Coburn formulas (1.1). Note that problem (3.24) can be reduced to a system of two Schwartz problems, whose solutions are found in the class of functions with real and imaginary coefficients of their expansions in Taylor series (see [4] and also [8], example 23.2).
4. Generalized Carleman boundary value problem with linear fractional shift A generalized Carleman boundary value problem can be formulated as follows (see, for example [8]): Let D+ be a simply connected domain bounded by a Lyapunov curve Γ. Find the function Φ+ (z) analytic in the domain D+ , whose limit values belong to the class Hµ (Γ) and satisfy on Γ the condition Φ+ (α (t)) = a (t) Φ+ (t) + b (t) Φ+ (t)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
201
(homogeneous problem) or Φ+ (α (t)) = a (t) Φ+ (t) + b (t) Φ+ (t) + h (t)
(4.1)
(non-homogeneous problem). Here α is a direct or an inverse Carleman shift of order 2 on Γ, α (t) = 0; α (t), a (t), b (t), h (t) ∈ Hµ (Γ). With this formulation, problem (4.1) is overdetermined (see, for example [8]), thus we suppose that the functions a, b and h satisfy the conditions a (t) a (α (t)) + b (t) b (α (t)) = 1,
(4.2)
a (t) b (α (t)) + a (α (t))b (t) = 0,
(4.3)
a (t) h (α (t)) + b (t) h (α (t)) + h (t) = 0.
(4.4)
From (4.2) and (4.3) it follows that, for all elements in Γ, the coefficients a, b ∈ Hµ (Γ) satisfy either the inequality |b (t)| > |a (t)| or the inequality |b (t)| < |a (t)|. Thus the function γ (t) = |a (t)| − |b (t)| preserves its sign on Γ. Note that, if f1 and f2 are linearly independent functions belonging to the space Hµ (Γ) such that f1 (t) f2 (t) F (t) = det = 0, f1 (t) f2 (t) then the functions f1 (α (t)) f2 (α (t)) det f1 (t) f2 (t) a (t) = F (t)
det ,
b (t) =
f1 (t) f2 (t) f1 (α (t)) f2 (α (t)) F (t)
,
satisfy conditions (4.2) and (4.3). The Fredholm theory of problem (4.1) was constructed by G. S. Litvinchuk and A. P. Nechaev [9], [10] (see also e.g. [8], Ch. 7). They proved that problem (4.1) is Fredholm only in the following four cases: (1) α is a direct Carleman shift and |b (t)| > |a (t)|; (2) α is a direct Carleman shift and |a (t)| > |b (t)| > 0; (3) α is an inverse Carleman shift and |b (t)| > |a (t)| > 0; (4) α is an inverse Carleman shift and |a (t)| > |b (t)|. For (1) and (2) the index of problem (4.1) is calculated by the formula 1 {arg b (t)}Γ + 1, I= 2π and, in cases (3) and (4) it is given by 1 1 {arg a (t)}Γ + 1 and I = 2 − {arg a (t)}Γ − m− , I=− 2π 2π respectively, where m− is the number of fixed points of α for which a (t) = −1. In [9], [10] it was also established that, in cases (1) and (4), the problem of obtaining the defect numbers, l and ρ, is solved for any Carleman shift α = α+ (t) or α = α− (t). Moreover, the Gakhov-Coburn formulas (1.1) are satisfied. For the remaining cases (2) and (3), this problem remained unsolved, until now.
202
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
Considering a direct or an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift on the unit circle , we can obtain the defect numbers for the boundary value problem (4.1) in all cases (1)-(4). 4.1. The case of a direct linear fractional Carleman shift Let α be a direct Carleman shift of the form (2.5). If we introduce a new unknown function Φ− (z), analytic in |z| > 1, by the formula 1 + 1 − Φ (z) = Φ , z z then the generalized Carleman boundary value problem (4.1) is reduced to the boundary value problem Φ+ (α (t)) = a (t) Φ+ (t) + tb (t) Φ− (t) + h (t) ,
(4.5)
for a piecewise analytic function {Φ+ (z) , Φ− (z)} vanishing at infinity. According to [7], problems (4.1) and (4.5) are equivalent, i.e., they are Fredholm boundary value problems simultaneously and they have the same defect numbers over the fields R and C, respectively. The boundary value problem (4.5) can be reduced to the singular integral operator with shift K ≡ u−1 (t) U P+ − a (t) P+ + tb (t) P− ,
(4.6)
where (U ϕ) (t) = u (t) ϕ (α (t)), u (t) = −α+ (t) and u (t) u (α (t)) = 1. Since U S = SU , the solvability theory of the singular integral operator (4.6) can be obtained by studying the singular integral operator without shift M = AP+ + BP− , where (see formulas (2.2) and (2.3) of Subsection 2.1) −a (t) u−1 (t) tb (t) 0 A= , B= . u−1 (α (t)) −a (α (t)) 0 α (t) b (α (t)) This operator can be rewritten in the form M = A−1 (P+ + CP− ) , with C = A−1 B. Thus, it is enough to consider the operator = P+ + CP− . M Let us determine the matrix function C explicitly. In fact, from conditions (4.2)-(4.4) and using the equality u (t) = u−1 (α (t)), we obtain a (α (t)) =
a (t)
2
2
|a (t)| − |b (t)|
,
b (α (t)) = −
b (t)
2
2
|a (t)| − |b (t)|
Vol. 57 (2007)
and
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
203
tb (t) 0 0 α (t) b (α (t)) b (t) b (α (t)) −1 1 t 0 a (α (t)) b (t) u (t) b (α (t)) = a (t) b (α (t)) 0 α (t) u−1 (α (t)) b (t) b (t) b (α (t)) u−1 (t) −a (t) −1 t 0 = b . 2 2 0 α (t) a (t) u (t) |b (t)| − |a (t)| 1
C=
a (α (t)) u−1 (t) −1 u (α (t)) a (t)
Hence, the matrix function C = A−1 B can be rewritten in the form −1 −t 0 0 1 |a (t)|2 − |b (t)|2 a (t) . C= b 0 u−1 (t) α (t) u (t) 0 a (t) 1 (4.7) We can see that the matrix function 2 2 |a (t)| − |b (t)| a (t) = C a (t) 1 2
is Hermitian with determinant − |b (t)| < 0. Therefore, applying Theorem 2.5 of are m Subsection 2.3, we obtain that the partial indices of the matrix function C and −m, where m is the smallest possible exact (i.e., calculated with multiplicity taken into account) number of coincidences in |z| < 1 of the rational functions r1 and r2 , having no poles in common in |z| < 1 and satisfying on the inequalities |a (t) − r1 (t)| < |b (t)| < |a (t) − r2 (t)| . Then,
0 tm − . C 0 t−m Using the formulas α (t) = α+ (t) tα− (t), u (t) = −α+ (t) and u−1 (t) = −1 − (α+ (t)) , we obtain m −1 0 1 t t 0 −1 0 0 + − C C C= b . −α+ (t) 0 0 t 0 −α− (t) 0 t−m =C + C
Thus, the partial indices of C are κ1 = κ + m + 1
and κ2 = κ − m + 1,
1 2π
{arg b (t)} where κ = . Now, as a result of Theorem 2.2, we obtain the defect numbers of the generalized Carleman boundary value problem (4.1) with a direct linear fractional Carleman shift. Theorem 4.1. If α is a direct linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2, then, for the defect numbers l and ρ of the generalized Carleman boundary value problem, we have the following possibilities: 1) If κ1 > 0 and κ2 > 0, then l = κ + 1
and
ρ = 0.
204
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
2) If κ1 > 0 and κ2 ≤ 0, then κ+1+m −κ − 1 + m and ρ = l= 2 2 l = κ + 1 + m − ε and ρ = −κ − 1 + m − ε 2 2 where ε ∈ {1, −1}. 3) If κ2 ≤ κ1 ≤ 0, then l = 0
and
, if κ1 is even , , if κ1 is odd
ρ = −κ − 1.
This theorem remains valid if either one of the inequalities |b (t)| > |a (t)| or 0 < |b (t)| < |a (t)| holds for all elements in . Note that when |b (t)| > |a (t)|, the partial indices of 2 2 −1 0 |b (t)| − |a (t)| a (t) = C 0 1 1 −a (t) are zero (see Theorem 1, chapter 4 of [8]), i.e., m = 0. Thus, from Theorem 4.1, we obtain, l = max (0, κ + 1) and ρ = max (0, −κ − 1), which was already known for problem (4.1), with any direct Carleman shift on any Lyapunov curve. 4.2. The case of an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift In this subsection we consider an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2. Now we have u (t) = α− (t) t−1 , where (U ϕ) (t) = α− (t) t−1 ϕ (α (t)). Proceeding as in the previous subsection, in order to obtain the defect numbers of operator (4.6) we consider the singular integral operator without shift M = AP+ + BP− , where
A=
−a (t) u−1 (α (t))
0 α (t) b (α (t))
, B=
tb (t) u−1 (t) 0 −a (α (t))
.
If a (t) b (t) = 0, then det A (t) = 0 and, as before, we just need to study the solvability theory of = P+ + CP− , M with C = A−1 B. Computing the matrix function C, we obtain 1 tb (t) α (t) b (α (t)) 0 C=− 0 −u−1 (α (t)) −a (t) α (t) a (t) b (α (t)) =
1 a (t)
0 −1 (α (t)) u (t)
−1 0
|b (t)|2 − |a (t)|2 b (t)
b (t) 1
u−1 (t) −a (α (t)) t 0
0
u−1 (t) (4.8)
Again, we can see that the matrix function 2 2 |b (t)| − |a (t)| = C b (t)
b (t) 1
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
205
is Hermitian with negative determinant. Once more, applying Theorem 2.5 we are m and −m (m ≥ 0). Therefore, the matrix obtain that the partial indices of C function C admits the following factorization m 1 0 0 1 1 0 t t 0 + − C C C= −1 −1 0 t−m 0 t 0 0 (α− (t)) (α+ (t)) a (t) and its partial indices are κ1 = −κ + m + 1 and κ2 = −κ − m + 1, 1 {arg a (t)} where κ = . Now, using Theorem 2.3 we have 2π Theorem 4.2. If α is an inverse linear fractional Carleman shift of order 2, then, for the defect numbers l and ρ of the generalized Carleman boundary value problem, we have the following possibilities: 1) If κ1 > 0 and κ2 > 0, then l = −κ + 1
and
ρ = 0.
2) If κ1 > 0 and κ2 ≤ 0, then −κ + 1 + m κ−1+m and ρ = l= 2 2 l = −κ + 1 + m − ε and ρ = κ − 1 + m − ε 2 2 where ε ∈ {1, −1}. 3) If κ2 ≤ κ1 ≤ 0, then l = 0
and
, if κ1 is even , , if κ1 is odd
ρ = κ − 1.
Note that this theorem remains valid, if we consider the flip operator which is given by (U ϕ) (t) = 1t ϕ 1t . In that case the matrix function C admits the following factorization m 0 0 −1 t 0 −1 + t C C C = (a (t)) . − 0 t−m 1 0 0 t We must notice that Theorem 4.2 is valid only if the condition a (t) b (t) = 0 is fulfilled. Thus, when |b (t)| > |a (t)| > 0, Theorem 4.2 holds. However, if |a (t)| > |b (t)|, then Theorem 4.2 is not valid. In fact, if we admitted that Theorem 4.2 was satisfied, we would have |a (t)| > |b (t)| > 0, which is contradictory. Indeed, if t0 is one of the fixed points of α, it follows from the conditions (4.2) and (4.3) that: (a (t0 ))2 + |b (t0 )|2 = 1, a (t0 ) + a (t0 ) b (t0 ) = 0.
(4.9) (4.10)
Since it is necessary that a (t) b (t) = 0, we have b (t0 ) = 0. Then, from equality (4.10), we get a (t0 )+a (t0 ) = 0, i.e., a (t0 ) = iβ, β = 0. Now, from the equality (4.9) 2 2 it follows that |b (t0 )| = 1−(a (t0 ))2 = 1+β 2 = 1+|a (t0 )| . Thus, |b (t0 )| > |a (t0 )|, which is a contradiction.
206
Ferreira, Litvinchuk and Reis
IEOT
Nevertheless, in the case |a (t)| > |b (t)|, it is already known (see [9], [10], and also [8], Ch. 7) that, for any shift α = α− (t) on any Lyapunov curve Γ, 1 l = max 0, 2 − {arg a (t)}Γ − m− 2π 1 {arg a (t)}Γ + m− , ρ = max 0, −2 + 2π where m− is the number of fixed points of α for which a (t) = −1.
References [1] Drekova, G. V., Kravchenko, V. G., Dimension and structure of the kernel and cokernel of a singular integral operator with linear-fractional Carleman shift and with conjugation. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 315(2), 271-274, 1990 (in Russian). English transl.: Soviet Math. Dokl., 42(3), 743-746, 1991. [2] Gakhov, F. D., Boundary value problems. Nauka: Moscow, 1977 (in Russian). English transl.: Perganion Press: Oxford, 1966. [3] Khasabov, E. G., Litvinchuk, G. S., On Hilbert boundary value problem with a shift. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 142(6), 274-277, 1962 (in Russian). [4] Khasabov, E. G., Litvinchuk, G. S., On the index of generalized Hilbert boundary value problem. Uspekhi matem. nauk, 20(2), 124-130, 1965 (in Russian). [5] Kovaliova (Drekova), G. V., Kravchenko, V. G., On solutions of singular integral equations with linear fractional Carleman shift and with conjugation. DEP. Odessk. injenerno-stroit. Inst., Odessa, 1-14, 1990 (in Russian). [6] Kravchenko, V. G., Lebre, A. B., Rodr´ıguez, J. S., Factorization of singular integral operators with a Carleman shift and spectral problems. Journal of Integral Equations and Applications, 13(4), 339-383, Winter 2001. [7] Latushkin, Yu. D., Litvinchuk, G. S., Spitkovsky, I. M., To the theory of boundary value problem of N. Vekua, Trudy Tbilissk. Univ., 259, 163-188, 1985 (in Russian). [8] Litvinchuk, G. S., Solvability Theory of Boundary Value Problems and Singular Integral Equations with Shift. Kluwer Academic Publishers: Dordrecht-Boston-London, 1-378, 2000. [9] Litvinchuk, G. S., Nechaev, A. P., On the theory of generalized Carleman boundary value problem. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 189(1), 38-41, 1969 (in Russian). [10] Litvinchuk, G. S., Nechaev, A. P., Generalized Carleman boundary value problem. Matem. Sb., 82(1), 30-54, 1970 (in Russian). [11] Litvinchuk, G. S., Spitkovsky, I. M., Sharp estimates of the defect numbers of a generalized Riemann boundary value problem. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 255(5), 10421046, 1980 (in Russian). English transl.: Soviet Math. Dokl. 22(3), 781-785, 1980. [12] Litvinchuk, G. S., Spitkovsky, I. M., Sharp estimates of the defect numbers of a generalized Riemann boundary value problem, factorization of Hermitian matrixvalued functions and some problems of approximation by meromorphic functions. Matem. Sb., 117(159), No 2, 196-215, 1982 (in Russian). English transl.: Math USSR Sbornik, Vol. 45, No 2, 205-224, 1983.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Generalized Hilbert and Carleman Boundary Problems
207
[13] Litvinchuk, G. S., Spitkovsky, I. M., Factorization of measurable matrix functions. Academie-Verlag: Berlin and Birkh¨ auser Verlag: Basel-Boston-Stuttgart, 1372, 1987. [14] Markushevich, A. I., On one boundary value problem of the theory of analytic functions. Uchen. Zapiski Moskovsk. Univer., 100, 20-30, 1946 (in Russian). [15] Muskhelishvili, N. I., Singular integral equations. Fizmatgiz: Moscow, 1962 (in Russian). English transl.: Groningen, Noordholf, 1953. Jorge Ferreira Departamento de Matem´ atica e Engenharias - Universidade da Madeira Campus Universit´ ario da Penteada, 9000-390 Funchal Portugal e-mail: [email protected] Gueorgui S. Litvinchuk Departamento de Matem´ atica e Engenharias - Universidade da Madeira Campus Universit´ ario da Penteada, 9000-390 Funchal Portugal and Ukrainian Academy of Sciences Marine Hydrophysical Institute - Hydroacoustic Department Preobrazhenskaya Street 3, 270 100 Odessa Ukraine e-mail: [email protected] Maur´ıcio D. L. Reis Departamento de Matem´ atica e Engenharias - Universidade da Madeira Campus Universit´ ario da Penteada, 9000-390 Funchal Portugal e-mail: m [email protected] Submitted: June 15, 2005 Revised: February 21, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 209–215 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020209-7, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1452-2
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
On the Range of the Aluthge Transform Guoxing Ji, Yongfeng Pang and Ze Li Abstract. Let B(H) be the algebra of all bounded linear operators on a com1 1 plex separable Hilbert space H. For an operator T ∈ B(H), let Te = |T | 2 U |T | 2 be the Aluthge transform of T and we define ∆(T ) = Te for all ∈ B(H), where T = U |T | is a polar decomposition of T . In this short note, we consider an elementary property of the range R(∆) = {Te : T ∈ B(H)} of ∆. We prove that R(∆) is neither closed nor dense in B(H). However R(∆) is strongly dense if H is infinite dimensional. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A15; Secondary 47B20. Keywords. Aluthge transform, polar decomposition, range.
Let H be a complex separable Hilbert space and let B(H) be the algebra of all bounded linear operators on H. Denoted by F (H) and K(H) the ideals of all finite rank and compact operators in B(H) respectively if H is infinite dimensional. I is the identity operator in B(H). If H = Cp for p < ∞, we identify B(H) with Mp and denote by Ip the identity. Let T = U |T | be a polar decomposition of T 1 with |T | = (T ∗ T ) 2 and U is a partial isometry with the initial space the closure of the range of |T | and the final space the closure of the range of T . The Aluthge 1 1 transform T is defined by T=|T | 2 U |T | 2 (cf.[1]). Note that T is independent of the choice of the partial isometry U in the polar decomposition of T . We define ∆(T ) = T for all T ∈ B(H). Then ∆ is a map defined on B(H). Recently, T and T have been studied by many authors (cf.[2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]). However we know very few properties on the range R(∆) = {T : T ∈ B(H)} of ∆. In this short note, we consider an elementary property of R(∆). We prove that R(∆) is neither closed nor dense in B(H). However R(∆) is strongly dense if H is infinite dimensional. We first consider finite dimensional case. Let dim H = p. We identify B(H) with the set of all p × p matrices Mp . Let d1 , d2 , . . . , dp be p complex numbers. We define diag(d1 , d2 , . . . , dp ) to be the diagonal matrix with diagonal {d1 , d2 , . . . , dp }. This research was supported in part by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 10571114) and the Natural Science Basic Research Plan in Shaanxi Province of China (Program No. 2005A1).
210
Ji, Pang and Li
IEOT
Let T ∈ Mp with the polar decomposition T = U |T |. We may assume that U is 1 a unitary matrix. For the positive matrix |T | 2 ∈ Mp , there are a diagonal matrix D = diag(d1 , d2 , . . . , dp ) and a unitary matrix V such that d1 ≥ d2 ≥ · · · ≥ dp and 1 V |T | 2 V ∗ = D. Then we have V TV ∗ = DW D, where W = V U V ∗ is unitary. For a matrix X we denote by rank(X) the rank of X. x y Lemma 1. Let p = 2 and A = , where x and y are any nonzero complex −y 0 numbers. Then A ∈ R(∆). Proof. Note that λR(∆) ⊆ R(∆) for any λ ∈ C. We may assume that y = 1 without loss of generality. Suppose there is a matrix T ∈ M2 such that A = ∆(T ). Let T = U |T | be the polar decomposition of T . Let {e1 , e2 } be the canonical 1 1 1 1 basis of C2 . Then we have (|T | 2 U |T | 2 e2 , e2 ) = (U |T | 2 e2 , |T | 2 e2 ) = 0. We know 1 1 1 that |T | 2 e2 = 0 since A is invertible. Put η = |T | 2 e2 −1 |T | 2 e2 and choose a unit vector ξ such that ξ⊥η. Then we have (U η, η) = 0, which implies that U η = aξ and U ξ = bη for some constants a and b in C such that |a| = |b| = 1 1 since U is unitary. Let |T | 2 e1 = cξ + dη for some constants c, d ∈ C. Then 1 1 1 1 1 (Ae2 , e1 ) = (U |T | 2 e2 , |T | 2 e1 ) = ac|T | 2 e2 = 1, (Ae1 , e2 ) = (U |T | 2 e1 , |T | 2 e2 ) = 1 1 1 bc|T | 2 e2 = −1 and (Ae1 , e1 ) = (U |T | 2 e1 , |T | 2 e1 ) = cbd + acd = dc(a + b) = x = 1 0, that is, c(a + b) = 0. However we have (Ae2 , e1 ) + (Ae1 , e2 ) = |T | 2 e2 c(a + b) = 0, which implies that c(a + b) = 0. This is a contradiction. Thus A ∈ R(∆). The proof is complete. Lemma 2. Assume p ≥ 2 and A ∈ Mp is an idempotent such that rank(A) = p − 1 and R(A) + R(A∗ ) = H. Then A is not in the closure R(∆) of R(∆). Proof. Let A ∈ Mp be an idempotent such that rank(A) = p − 1 and R(A) + R(A∗ ) = H. Then ker A ∩ ker A∗ = {0}. It is known that A ∈ R(∆) by Proposition 1.12 in [2]. Suppose A ∈ R(∆). Then there exists a sequence {Tn : n ∈ N} ⊂ Mp such that lim ∆(Tn ) = A. Without loss of generality, we may choose that Tn is n→∞
invertible for all n. Let Tn = Un |Tn | be the polar decomposition of Tn . Let Dn and 1 Vn be the diagonal and unitary matrices respectively such that Vn |Tn | 2 Vn∗ = Dn , where Dn = diag(d1 (n), d2 (n), . . . , dp (n)) for some positive real numbers di (n), i = n Vn∗ = Dn Wn Dn , where Wn = Vn Un Vn∗ is unitary 1, 2, . . . p and for all n. Then Vn T for all n. By choosing a subsequence if necessary, we may assume that lim Un = U,
n→∞
lim Vn = V and lim di (n) = di ,
n→∞
n→∞
where di is +∞ or a nonnegative real numbers for any i = 1, 2, . . . , p. Then both U and V are unitary and W = lim Wn = V U V ∗ is also unitary. Thus there are n→∞
nonnegative integers k, l and s such that p = k + l + s and lim di (n) = +∞ n→∞
for 1 ≤ i ≤ k, lim di (n) = di = 0 for k < i ≤ k + l and lim di (n) = 0 for n→∞
n→∞
Vol. 57 (2007)
On the Range of the Aluthge Transform
211
k + l < i ≤ p. We note that k, s ≥ 1 since A ∈ R(∆). If p = 2, then we have k = s = 1 and l = 0. By assumption, A = lim ∆(Tn ). Then we have n→∞
B = V AV ∗ = lim Vn ∆(Tn )Vn∗ ∈ R(∆) n→∞
and both A and B have the same properties. With the decomposition H = Cp = Ck ⊕ Cl ⊕ Cs , by an elementary calculation, we have B11 B12 B13 0 . (1) B = B21 B22 B31 0 0 Note that B 2 = B, then we easily have 2 B11 + B12 B21 + B13 B31 = B11 , B11 B12 + B12 B22 = B12 , B11 B13 = B13 , 2 B21 B11 + B22 B21 = B21 , B21 B12 + B22 = B22 , B21 B13 = 0, B31 B11 = B31 , B31 B12 = 0, B31 B13 = 0. (2) Note that rank(B) = rank(A) = p − 1. It follows that dim ker(B31 ) ≤ 1. Thus we have that (B12 B13 ) is of at most rank one, which implies that ker(B13 ) is at least s − 1 dimensional. We also have ker(B13 ) is at most 1 dimensional. It follows that s ≤ 2. By considering B ∗ , we similarly have that B31 is at most of rank one. That is, k ≤ 2. Since B = lim Dn Wn Dn , we easily have n→∞
0 W = 0 W31
0 W22 W32
W13 W23 . W33
(3)
∗ ∗ = Ik and W31 W31 = Ik , that is Note that W is unitary. It follows that W13 W13 ∗ both W13 and W31 are isometries. We thus have 1 ≤ k ≤ s ≤ 2. Case 1. k < s. Then k = 1 and s = 2. In this case, Cp = C ⊕ Cl ⊕ C ⊕ C and b11 B12 b13 b14 B21 B22 0 0 . B= (4) b31 0 0 0 b41 0 0 0
It now follows that b31 b13 = b31 b14 = b41 b13 = b41 b14 = 0 by B 2 = B again. If b41 = 0 then b31 = 0. Otherwise rank(B) ≤ p − 2. This contradicts with the assumption that rank(B) = p−1. However we must have b13 = b14 = 0, which also implies that rank(B) ≤ p − 2. This is a contradiction again. Similarly, if b41 = 0, we have b14 = 0 and a contradiction follows.
212
Ji, Pang and Li
IEOT
∗ Case 2. k = s. Since W31 and W13 are isometries, both W31 and W13 are unitary in this case. It follows that 0 0 W13 W22 0 . (5) W = 0 W31 0 0
(i) k = s = 1. In this case we have Cp = C ⊕ Cl ⊕ C, lim d1 (n) = +∞, n→∞
lim dp (n) = 0,
n→∞
b11 B = B21 b31
B12 B22 0
b13 0 0
(6)
and b31 b13 = 0. If b13 = 0, then b31 = 0 since ker B ∩ ker B ∗ = {0}. Let Wn = (wij (n)) for all n. By (5) and (6), we have lim w1p (n) = W13 = 0,
(7)
lim wp1 (n) = W31 = 0
(8)
n→∞
n→∞
and b13 = lim d1 (n)w1p (n)dp (n) = 0,
(9)
b31 = lim d1 (n)wp1 (n)dp (n) = 0.
(10)
n→∞ n→∞
This is a contradiction since we must have lim d1 (n)dp (n) = 0 from (7) and (9) and lim d1 (n)dp (n) = 0 from (8) and (10). n→∞
n→∞
(ii) k = s = 2. Then Cp = C2 ⊕ Cl ⊕ C2 . By (2), we have B21 B12 = 0 since B21 B12 B13 = 0, R(B12 ) = R(B13 ) and B21 B13 = 0. It follows that B31 2 which implies that B12 B21 + B13 B31 is a square zero matrix. Now B11 − B11 = B12 B21 + B13 B31 by (2). It follows that that σ(B11 ) ⊆ {0, 1}. If either B13 or B31 is 0, then rank(B) ≤ p − 2. This is a contradiction. We next assume that both B13 and B31 are not 0. Then they are of rank one. By (2) again we have B11 B12 = B12 since (B12 B13 ) is of rank one and B11 B13 = B13 . It follows that rank(B11 B12 B13 ) = rank(B11 ). If 0 ∈ σ(B11 ), then rank(B11 B12 B13 ) ≤ 1 and therefore rank(B) ≤ p − 2 since rank(B31 ) = 1. This contradicts with the assumption that rank(A) = rank(B) = p − 1. If B11 is invertible, then σ(B11 ) = {1} and B11 = I2 +X, where X is B11 B12 B13 a square zero matrix. We claim that rank = 2. We may B 0 0 31 α1 assume that (B12 B13 ) = , where αi is an 1 × (p − 2) matrix for i = 1, 2 α2 b(p−1)1 b(p−1)2 . and B31 = bp1 bp2
Vol. 57 (2007)
On the Range of the Aluthge Transform
213
In fact, if X = 0, that is, B11 = I2 , then by the facts that B11 B12 = 0, B31 B13 = 0 and rank(B12 B13 ) = 1, we have b(p−1)1 α1 +b(p−1)2 α2 = 0 and bp1 α1 + bp2 α2 = 0. It follows that (b(p−1)1 , b(p−1)2 , 0) = b(p−1)1 (1, 0, α1 ) + b(p−1)2 (1, 0,α2 ) B11 B12 B13 and (bp1 , bp2 , 0) = bp1 (1, 0, α1 )+ bp2 (1, 0, α2 ), that is, rank = B31 0 0 2. If X = 0, then there exist a 2 × 2 unitary matrix Y such that Y B11 Y ∗ = 1 x for some x = 0. Thus without loss of generality, we may assume that 0 1 B11 itself has this form. It follows that α2 = 0 and b(p−1)1 = bp1 = 0 since B11 (B12 B13 ) = (B12 B13 ) and B31 B11 = B31 . Then we have 1 x α1 0 B11 B12 B13 1 0 = 0 b(p−1)2 0 . B31 0 0 0 0 bp2 B11 B12 B13 = 2. Then rank B31 0 0 Consequently, we have rank(B) ≤ p−2, which contradicts with that rank(B) = p − 1 again. Thus by the proof above, we have A ∈ R(∆). The proof is complete. Theorem 3. Let H = Cp for p ≥ 2. Then R(∆) is neither closed nor dense in B(H). Proof. We firstly show that R(∆) is not closed. √ 1 1 n 0 1 − 2 n n Case 1. p = 2. Let Dn = , Un = , 1 1 1 0 − 1 − n2 n n 1 1 ∈ R(∆) by Lemma 1. then An = Dn Un Dn ∈ R(∆) and lim An = −1 0 n→∞ 0 1 0 Case 2. p = 3. Let B = 0 0 1 . Then B ∈ R(∆) by Proposition 1.12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 n in [2]. Put Pn = 0 n 0 and Vn = 0 0 1 . Then Bn = Pn Vn Pn ∈ 1 0 0 0 0 n1 R(∆) and lim Bn = B, that is B ∈ R(∆). n→∞
Case 3. p > 3. We have B ⊕ Ip−3 ∈ R(∆) by Proposition 1.12 in [2] again. However we have B ⊕ Ip−3 ∈ R(∆) by the proof as above. By Lemma 2 we know that R(∆) is not dense in B(H). The proof is complete. Next we consider infinite dimensional case.
214
Ji, Pang and Li
IEOT
Lemma 4. Let H be a complex separable infinite dimensional Hilbert space. Then F (H) ⊂ R(∆) but K(H) R(∆). Proof. Let A be a finite rank operator with A = 1. Put M = R(A) + R(A∗ ). ⊥ Then M is a finite dimensional subspace of H which reduces A. Let H = M ⊕ M . A1 0 Then we have A = . Let V be an isometry from M into M ⊥ and T = 0 0 0 A1 . Note that T is a partial isometry. By a simply calculation, 1 V (I − A∗1 A1 ) 2 0 we have ∆(T ) = A. On the other hand, let A be a compact operator with nontrivial kernel and dense range. For example, let {en : n ∈ N} be an orthogonal basis of H. Let {an : n ∈ N} be a decreasing sequence of positive numbers satisfying lim an = 0. n→∞
Let A be the backward weighted shift with weights {an : n ∈ N}. That is Ae1 = 0, Aen = an−1 en−1 for n ≥ 2. Then we have A is compact and A ∈ R(∆) by Proposition 1.12 in [2]. The proof is complete. Theorem 5. Let H be a complex separable infinite dimensional Hilbert space. Then R(∆) is neither closed nor dense in norm topology but strongly dense in B(H). Proof. By Lemma 4, we know that R(∆) is not closed but strongly dense in B(H). On the other hand, let Gr be the set of all right invertible but not invertible operators in B(H). Then we know Gr is a nonempty open subset of B(H). We have Gr ∩ R(∆) = ∅ by Proposition 1.12 in [2], that is, R(∆) is not dense in B(H). The proof is complete. Acknowledgments. The authors would like to thank the referee for his/her suggestions and comments.
References [1] A. Aluthge, On p-hyponormal operators for 0 < p < 1, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, 13(1990), 307-315. [2] I. B. Jung, E. Ko, and C. Pearcy, Aluthge transforms of operators, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, 37(2000), 437-448. [3] I. B. Jung, E. Ko, and C. Pearcy, Spectral pictures of Aluthge Tranforms of operators, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, (2001), 52-60. [4] X. Liu and G. Ji, Some properties of generalized Aluthge transform, Nihonkai Math. J., 15(2004), 101-107. [5] P. Y. Wu, Numerical range of Aluthge transform of operator, Linear Alg. Appl., 357(2002), 295-298. [6] T. Yamazaki, Parallelisms between Aluthge transformtion and powers of operators, Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged), 67(2001), 809-820.
Vol. 57 (2007)
On the Range of the Aluthge Transform
215
[7] T. Yamazaki, On numerical range of the Aluthge transformtion, Linear Alg. Appl., 341(2002), 111-117. Guoxing Ji, Yongfeng Pang and Ze Li College of Mathematics and Information Science Shaanxi Normal University Xian, 710062 People’s Republic of China e-mail: [email protected] Submitted: January 12, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 217–228 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020217-12, published online December 26, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1479-4
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
A Remark on Two Duality Relations Emanuel Milman Abstract. We remark that an easy combination of two known results yields a positive answer, up to log(n) terms, to a duality conjecture that goes back to Pietsch. In particular, we show that for any two symmetric convex bodies K, T in Rn , denoting by N (K, T ) the minimal number of translates of T needed to cover K, one has: N (K, T ) ≤ N (T ◦ , (C log(1 + n))−1 K ◦ )C log(1+n) log log(2+n) , where K ◦ , T ◦ are the polar bodies to K, T , respectively, and C ≥ 1 is a universal constant. As a corollary, we observe a new duality result (up to log(n) terms) for Talagrand’s γp functionals. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 46A, 46B, 47B. Keywords. Entropy, covering numbers, duality, convex bodies, compact operators.
1. Introduction Let K and T denote two convex bodies in Rn (i.e. convex compact sets with nonempty interior). Throughout this note we assume that all bodies in question are centrally symmetric w.r.t. to the origin (e.g. K = −K). For a convex body L, we denote by L◦ its polar body, defined as L◦ = {x ∈ Rn ; x, y ≤ 1 ∀y ∈ L}. The covering number of K by T , denoted N (K, T ), is defined as the minimal number of translates of T needed to cover K, i.e.: (xi + T ) . N (K, T ) = min N ; ∃x1 , . . . , xN ∈ Rn , K ⊂ 1≤i≤N
In this note, we address the following conjecture of Pietsch ([12, p. 38]) from 1972, originally formulated in operator-theoretic notations: Supported in part by BSF and ISF.
218
Milman
IEOT
Duality Conjecture for Covering Numbers. Do there exist numerical constants a, b ≥ 1 such that for any dimension n and for any two symmetric convex bodies K, T in Rn one has: b−1 log N (T ◦ , aK ◦ ) ≤ log N (K, T ) ≤ b log N (T ◦ , a−1 K ◦ ) ?
(1.1)
This problem may be equivalently formulated using the notion of entropy numbers. For a real number k ≥ 0, denote the k’th entropy number of K w.r.t. T as: ek (K, T ) = inf{ε > 0; N (K, εT ) ≤ 2k }. Then the duality conjecture may be equivalently formulated with (1.1) replaced by: (1.2) a−1 ebk (T ◦ , K ◦ ) ≤ ek (K, T ) ≤ aeb−1 k (T ◦ , K ◦ ) for all k ≥ 0 (and there is no loss in generality if we assume that k is an integer). As already mentioned, the duality conjecture originated from operator theory, where entropy numbers are used to quantify the compactness of an operator u : X → Y between two Banach spaces. Leaving the finite dimensional setting for a brief moment, if K = u(B(X)) and T = B(Y ), where B(Z) denotes the unit-ball of a Banach space Z, then it is easy to see that ek (K, T ) → 0 as k → ∞ iff the operator u is compact. Since u is compact iff its adjoint u∗ : Y ∗ → X ∗ is too, and since u∗ (B(Y ∗ )) = u∗ (T ◦ ) and B(X ∗ ) = u∗ (K ◦ ), it follows that ek (K, T ) → 0 iff ek (T ◦ , K ◦ ) → 0. Hence, it is natural to conjecture that the rate of convergence to 0 is asymptotically similar in both cases. A strong interpretation of this similarity is given by (1.2). We will mention other weaker interpretations below. Although the general problem is still not completely settled, there has been substantial progress in recent years, and the answer is known to be positive for a wide class of bodies. We begin by describing some results in this direction. We comment here that when the result imposes the same restrictions on K and T , it is obviously enough to specify only one side of the inequalities in (1.1) or (1.2). When both K and T are ellipsoids, it is easy to see that in fact N (K, T ) = N (T ◦ , K ◦ ). Other special cases were settled in [19],[5],[6], [9],[18]. In [7], it was shown that: C −n N (T ◦ , K ◦ ) ≤ N (K, T ) ≤ C n N (T ◦ , K ◦ ), for some universal constant C > 1. This implies that the tail behaviour of the entropy numbers satisfies the duality problem, i.e. eλk (K, T ) ≤ 2ek (T ◦ , K ◦ ) for some universal constant λ > 0 and all k ≥ n. This was subsequently generalized in [16]. Another variant of the problem, is to consider not the individual entropy numbers, but rather the entire sequences {ek (K, T )} and {ek (T ◦ , K ◦ )}. Then one may ask whether: C −1 {ek (T ◦ , K ◦ )} ≤ {ek (K, T )} ≤ C {ek (T ◦ , K ◦ )}
(1.3)
for some universal constant C > 1 and any symmetric (i.e. invariant to permutations) norm ·. When one of the bodies is an ellipsoid, this was positively settled in [25]. Later, in [4], this was extended to the case when one of the bodies is
Vol. 57 (2007)
A Remark on Two Duality Relations
219
uniformly convex or more generally K-convex (see [4] and [17] for definitions), in which case the constant C in (1.3) depends only on the K-convexity constant. The technique developed in [4] played a crucial role in some of the subsequent results on this problem, and one particular remark will play an essential role in this note. Returning to the duality problem of individual entropy numbers, it was shown in [11] that there exist universal constants a, b ≥ 1 such that when T = D is an ellipsoid: ebk (D◦ , K ◦ ) ≤ a(1 + log k)3 ek (K, D), for all k ≥ 0. In addition, the authors of [11] observed a connection between (one side of) the duality conjecture with T = D and a certain geometric lemma. Later, the case when one of the bodies is an ellipsoid was completely settled in [1], by showing that: b−1 log N (D◦ , aK ◦ ) ≤ log N (K, D) ≤ b log N (D◦ , a−1 K ◦ ). The main new tool developed in [1] was the so called “Reduction Lemma”, which roughly reduces the problem (1.1) for all K, T to the case K ⊂ 4T . This will be the second important tool in this note. Finally, in [2], the Reduction Lemma was combined with the techniques developed in [4], to transfer the results obtained there for the sequence of entropy numbers, to the individual ones. Thus, when one of the bodies K or T is Kconvex, (1.1) was shown to hold with the constants a, b depending solely on the K-convexity constant. The key ideological step in [2] was to separate the question of “complexity” from the question of duality, by explicitly introducing a new notion of convexified packing number, which was implicitly used in [4]. We will later refer to this new notion as well. Our first new observation in this note is in fact an immediate consequence of Theorem 6 in [4] and the Reduction Lemma in [1]. It settles the duality problem (1.1) (and (1.2)) up to log(n) terms, and in fact strengthens and generalizes all previously known results into a single statement. Because of the symmetry between K and T (as will be explained below), we formulate this as a one sided inequality: Theorem 1.1. Let K, T be two symmetric convex bodies in Rn . Then: log N (K, T ) ≤ V log(V ) log N (T ◦ , V −1 K ◦ ),
(1.4)
where V = min(V (K), V (T )) and V (L) is defined as: V (L) := inf {log(CdBM (L, B))f (K(XB )); B is a convex body in Rn } ,
(1.5)
where C > 0 is a universal constant, and f is a function depending solely on K(XB ), the K-convexity constant of the Banach space XB whose unit ball is B. For more information on the function f see Remark 2.3 below. Recall that the Banach-Mazur distance dBM (L, B) of two symmetric convex bodies L, B is defined as: dBM (L, B) := inf {γ ≥ 1; B ⊂ T (L) ⊂ γB} ,
220
Milman
IEOT
where the infimum runs over all linear transformations T . Since V (L) = V (L◦ ) because dBM (L, B) = dBM (L◦ , B ◦ ) and K(XB ◦ ) = K(XB ), applying the Theorem to K = T ◦ and T = K ◦ gives the opposite inequality (with the same V ): (V log(V ))−1 log N (T ◦ , V K ◦ ) ≤ log N (K, T ).
(1.6)
In addition, since by John’s Theorem, the Banach-Mazur distance √ of any symmetric convex body in Rn from the Euclidean ball D is at most n, and since K(D) = 1, we immediately have: Corollary 1.2. With the same notations as in Theorem 1.1: log N (K, T ) ≤ C log(1 + n) log log(2 + n) log N (T ◦ , (C log(1 + n))−1 K ◦ ), where C > 0 is a universal constant. This should be compared with the previously known best estimate (to the best of our knowledge) for general symmetric convex bodies K, T : log N (K, T ) ≤ C log N (T ◦ , (Cn)−1/2 K ◦ ), which is derived by comparing K with its John ellipsoid and using the duality result of [1] for ellipsoids. The novelty here in comparison to the results of [2] lies in the logarithmic dependence in the Banach-Mazur distance. Although there has been much progress in recent years towards a positive answer to the duality conjecture, it is still not clear that a positive answer should hold in full generality. In view of the Corollary 1.2, and Pisier’s well known estimate K(XB ) ≤ C log(1 + n) for any symmetric convex body B in Rn , we conjecture a weaker form of the duality problem: Weak Duality Conjecture for Covering Numbers. Does there exist a numerical constant C ≥ 1 such that for any dimension n and for any two symmetric convex bodies K, T in Rn one has: log N (K, T ) ≤ V log N (T ◦ , V −1 K ◦ ), where V = C min(K(XK ), K(XT )) ? We present the proof of Theorem 1.1 and several other connections to previously mentioned notions in Section 2. In Section 3, we give an application of Corollary 1.2 for Talagrand’s celebrated γp functionals, which was in fact our motivation for seeking a result in the spirit of Corollary 1.2. Recall that for a metric space (M, d) and p > 0, γp (M, d) is defined as: 2j/p d(x, Mj ) γp (M, d) := inf sup x∈M
j≥0
where the infimum runs over all admissible sets {Mj }, meaning that Mj ⊂ M j and |Mj | = 22 (we refer to [24, Theorem 1.3.5] and [23] for the connection to equivalent definitions). For two symmetric convex bodies K, T , let us denote γp (K, T ) := γp (K, dT ), where dT is the metric corresponding to the norm induced by T . The γ2 (·, D) functional, when D is an ellipsoid, was introduced to study
Vol. 57 (2007)
A Remark on Two Duality Relations
221
the boundedness of Gaussian processes (see [24] for an historical account on this topic). It was shown by Talagrand in his celebrated “Majorizing Measures Theorem” ([21], see also [22],[23]), that in fact γ2 (K, D) and E supx∈K x, G, where G is a Gaussian r.v. (with covariance corresponding to D in an appropriate manner), are equivalent to within universal constants. This was later extended to various other classes of stochastic processes, where the naturally arising metric d is not the l2 norm (again we refer to [24] for an account). Our second observation in this note is the following duality relation for the γp functionals: Theorem 1.3. Let K, T be two symmetric convex bodies in Rn . Then for any p > 0: γp (K, T ) ≤ Cp log(1 + n)2+1/p log log(2 + n)1/p γp (T ◦ , K ◦ ), where Cp > 0 depends solely on p. Although we strongly feel that this is unlikely, one could conjecture that the log(n) terms are not required in the last Theorem (at least for some values of p). In that case, as will be evident from the proof, we mention that such a conjecture is independent of the duality conjecture for covering numbers, in the sense that neither one implies the other. Acknowledgments. I would like to sincerely thank my supervisor Prof. Gideon Schechtman for motivating me to prove Proposition 3.3, sharing his knowledge, and for reading this manuscript.
2. Duality of Entropy As emphasized in the Introduction, the proof of Theorem 1.1 is immediate once we recall two previously known results. The first is the recently observed “Reduction Lemma” ([1, Proposition 12]), which uses a clever iteration procedure to telescopically expand and reduce the appearing terms. We carefully formulate it below: Theorem 2.1 ([1]). Let T be a convex symmetric body in a Euclidean space such that, for some constants a, b ≥ 1, for any convex symmetric body K ⊂ 4T , one has: log N (K, T ) ≤ b log N (T ◦ , a−1 K ◦ ). Then for any convex symmetric body K: log N (K, T ) ≤ b log2 (48a) log N (T ◦ , (8a)−1 K ◦ ). Dually, if K is fixed and the hypothesis holds for all T verifying K ⊂ 4T , then the conclusion holds for any T . The second known result goes back to the work of [4]. It uses the so called Maurey’s Lemma, which (roughly speaking) estimates the covering number of the convex hull of m points by the unit-ball of a K-convex space. We combine Theorem 6 and the subsequent remark from [4] into the following:
222
Milman
IEOT
Theorem 2.2 ([4]). Let K, T be two symmetric convex bodies in Rn , such that K ⊂ 4T . Then: log N (K, T ) ≤ V log N (T ◦ , V −1 K ◦ ), where V = min(V (K), V (T )) and V (L) is given by (1.5). Combining these two results, we immediately deduce Theorem 1.1. Note that if V = V (T ) in Theorem 1.1, we proceed by fixing T , applying Theorem 2.2 for all K satisfying K ⊂ 4T and use the first part of the Reduction Lemma to deduce (1.4) for all K; if V = V (K), we fix K and repeat the argument by interchanging the roles of K and T and using the second part of the Reduction Lemma. Remark 2.3. The proof of Theorem 2.2 in fact gives an explicit expression for V , rather than the implicit one used in (1.5): V := C1 inf {log(C2 γ)(10Tp (XB ))q ; K ⊂ γB, B ⊂ 4T, γ ≥ 1} ,
(2.1)
where the infimum runs over all symmetric convex bodies B in Rn , Tp (XB ) is the type p (1 < p ≤ 2) constant of the Banach space XB whose unit-ball is B, q = p∗ = p/(p − 1) and C1 , C2 ≥ 1 are two universal constants (see [10] for the definition of type). Theorem 1.1 was formulated using an implicit function f of K(XB ), since by several important results of Pisier ([13],[14]), an infinite dimensional Banach Space is K-convex iff it has some non-trivial type p > 1. We comment that in [14], an explicit formula bounding K(XB ) as a function of Tp (XB ) and q was obtained. It is possible to obtain an explicit reverse bound using the results in [15], but it is much easier to use an abstract argument which infers the existence of a p > 1, depending solely on K(XB ), such that Tp (XB ) depends solely on K(XB ) (see, e.g. [8, Lemma 4.2]). The advantage of using the K-convexity constant K(XB ) (instead of Tp (XB ) and q), lies in the fact that we may use duality and deduce the other side of the duality inequality (1.6) with the same V , as explained in the Introduction. We also remark that once V in (2.1) is expressed using K(XB ), it is clear that V ≤ min(V (K), V (T )) where V (L) is given by (1.5). We need this “separable” estimate on V , so that we may apply the Reduction Lemma (where the estimate on one of the bodies must be fixed). It is important to note that the proof of Theorem 2.2 actually connects the notions of covering and convexified packing, mentioned in the Introduction. For two symmetric convex bodies K and T , the convexified packing number, or convex separation number, was defined in [2] as:
∃x1 , . . . , xN ∈ K such that ˆ (K, T ) = max N ; M . (xj + intT ) ∩ conv {xi ; i < j} = ∅ ˆ (K, T ) ≤ Here int(T ) denotes the interior of the set T . Note that we always have M N (K, T /2) by a standard argument (see [2]). Then the proof actually shows: Theorem 2.4 ([4]). Under the same conditions as in Theorem 2.2: ˆ (K, V −1 T ). log N (K, T ) ≤ V log M
Vol. 57 (2007)
A Remark on Two Duality Relations
223
Using John’s Theorem as in Corollary 1.2, we have: Corollary 2.5 ([4]). Let K, T be two symmetric convex bodies in Rn , such that K ⊂ 4T . Then: ˆ (K, (C log(1 + n))−1 T ). log N (K, T ) ≤ C log(1 + n) log M We mention these variants of Theorem 1.1 and Corollary 1.2 here, because the framework developed in [2] suggests that this is the correct way to understand the duality problem. The cost of transition from covering to convex separation, as given by Theorem 2.4 and Corollary 2.5, is a certain measure of the complexity of the bodies involved. Once the transition is achieved, the duality framework developed in [1] and [2] finishes the job. Indeed, it was shown in [2] that the convex separation numbers always satisfy a duality relation, for any pair of symmetric convex bodies K, T : ˆ (K, T ) ≤ M ˆ (T ◦ , K ◦ /2)2 . M Using Theorem 2.4, we conclude that when K ⊂ 4T : ˆ (K, V −1 T ) ≤ 2V log M ˆ (T ◦ , (2V )−1 K ◦ ) log N (K, T ) ≤ V log M ≤ 2V log N (T ◦ , (4V )−1 K ◦ ). The Reduction Lemma now immediately gives Theorem 1.1. To conclude this section, we mention that Theorem 2.4 is already stronger than all of the results in [2] connecting the covering and the convex separation numbers. The technique involving the use of Maurey’s Lemma, which was also used in [2] (see also [3]), is optimally exploited in the proof of Theorem 2.4 (Theorem 6 in [4]), by using a clever iteration procedure, producing the log factor in the various definitions (1.5) and (2.1) of V . All previous general results (with no restriction on K and T ) pay a linear penalty in the√Banach-Mazur distance from “low-complexity” bodies, which may be as large as n.
3. Duality of Talagrand’s γp Functionals Given Corollary 1.2, proving Theorem 1.3 is rather elementary, although we will need to collect several elementary observations which we have not been able to find a reference for. Before proceeding, we remark that for our purposes, it is totally immaterial whether the points {xi } in the definition of N (K, T ) are chosen to lie inside K or not. Indeed, denoting by N (K, T ) the variant where the points are required to lie inside K, it is elementary to check that: N (K, 2T ) ≤ N (K, T ) ≤ N (K, T ). Since throughout this note we allow the insertion of homothety constants in all expressions, or multiplying the entropy numbers by universal constants, this lack of distinction is well justified.
224
Milman
IEOT
First, recall that by Dudley’s entropy bound ([24]): γp (K, T ) ≤ Cp k 1/p−1 ek (K, T ),
(3.1)
k≥1
where Cp > 0 is some constant depending on p. The argument is elementary: γp (K, T ) := inf sup 2j/p dT (x, Kj ) ≤ inf 2j/p sup dT (x, Kj ). x∈K j≥0
x∈K
j≥0 j
Choosing Kj to be the set of 22 points (inside K) attaining the minimum in the definition of N (K, e2j (K, T )T ), we see that: γp (K, T ) ≤ 2j/p e2j (K, T ). j≥0
It is elementary to verify that for p ≥ 1 and j ≥ 1: 2
j/p
≤ Cp
j −1 2
k 1/p−1 ,
k=2j−1
where Cp = (p(1 − 2
−1/p
−1
))
. Since ek is a non-increasing sequence, we have: j
γp (K, T ) ≤ e1 (K, T ) + Cp ≤ e1 (K, T ) + Cp
−1 2
k 1/p−1 e2j (K, T )
j≥1 k=2j−1
k 1/p−1 ek (K, T ) ≤ (1 + Cp )
k≥1
k 1/p−1 ek (K, T ).
k≥1
A similar argument works for 0 < p < 1. Dudley’s entropy upper bound appears naturally when studying the supremum of Gaussian processes on a set K, e.g. E supx∈K x, G where G is a Gaussian r.v. As mentioned in the Introduction, a deep theorem of Talagrand asserts that the latter expectancy is in fact equivalent (to within universal constants) to γ2 (K, D) where D is an ellipsoid corresponding to the covariance of G. The corresponding lower bound on E supx∈K x, G is due to Sudakov ([20]): E sup x, G ≥ c sup k 1/2 ek (K, D). x∈K
k≥1
When the body T is not an ellipsoid or when p = 2, there is no direct connection between Gaussian processes and γp (K, T ). Nevertheless, we note that the analogue to Sudakov’s Minoration bound holds in full generality: Lemma 3.1.
γp (K, T ) ≥ 2−1/p sup k 1/p ek (K, T ). k≥1
Proof. Let k ≥ 1 be given, and let j ≥ 0 be such that 2j ≤ k < 2j+1 . Then: γp (K, T ) := inf sup 2l/p dT (x, Kl ) ≥ inf sup 2j/p dT (x, Kj ). x∈K
l≥0
x∈K
Vol. 57 (2007)
A Remark on Two Duality Relations
225
j
Since for any admissible set Kj we have |Kj | = 22 ≤ 2k , it follows by definition that supx∈K dT (x, Kj ) ≥ ek (K, T ). Hence: γp (K, T ) ≥ 2j/p ek (K, T ) ≥ 2−1/p k 1/p ek (K, T ). Since k ≥ 1 was arbitrary, the assertion follows.
We will need one last lemma for the proof of Theorem 1.3: Lemma 3.2. For all k ≥ 3n: ek (K, T ) ≤ 2en (K, T ) exp(−ck/n), where c > 0 is some universal constant. Proof. Denote ek = ek (K, T ) and en = en (K, T ) for short. W.l.o.g. we assume that N (K, ek T ) = 2k and N (K, en T ) = 2n . Obviously we have: N (K, ek T ) ≤ N (K, en T )N (en T, ek T ).
(3.2)
Also N (en T, ek T ) = N (T, eenk T ), and by a standard volume estimation argument, n n we can find an ek /en T -net of T with cardinality no greater than (1 + 2e ek ) . Plugging everything into (3.2), we see that: n 2en k n 2 ≤2 1+ , ek or equivalently:
k−n 2en exp log(2) . −1≤ n ek
Since k ≥ 3n, we can find a universal constant c > 0 such that: k−n k exp log(2) − 1 ≥ exp c . n n
The assertion now readily follows.
We can now deduce the following equivalence, up to a log(n) term, of the γp functional, Sudakov’s lower bound and Dudley’s upper bound. Although this is surely known, we did not find a reference for it, so we include a proof for completeness. Proposition 3.3. Let K, T denote two symmetric convex bodies in Rn , and denote ek = ek (K, T ) and γp = γp (K, T ) for short. Then for any p > 0: k 1/p−1 ek ≤ log(1 + n)Cp sup k 1/p ek , 2−1/p sup k 1/p ek ≤ γp ≤ Cp k≥1
k≥1
k≥1
where Cp , Cp > 0 are universal constants depending solely on p.
226
Milman
IEOT
Proof. The first inequality is Sudakov’s lower bound (Lemma 3.1) and the second one is Dudley’s upper bound (3.1). We will show the third inequality. Let us split
the sum k≥1 k 1/p−1 ek into two parts, up to and from k = 3n. For the first part, we obviously have: 3n−1
k 1/p−1 ek ≤
3n−1
k=1
k=1
1 sup k 1/p ek ≤ C log(1 + n) sup k 1/p ek . k k≥1 k≥1
We use Lemma 3.2 to evaluate the second sum: k 1/p−1 ek ≤ 2en k 1/p−1 exp(−ck/n). k≥3n
k≥3n
For p ≥ 1, k 1/p−1 is non-increasing, so we use: k 1/p−1 exp(−ck/n) ≤ (3n)1/p−1 exp(−ck/n) k≥3n
= (3n)1/p−1
k≥3n
exp(−3c) n ≤ (3n)1/p−1 exp(−3c) ≤ Cn1/p . 1 − exp(−c/n) c
For 0 < p < 1, we evaluate the sum with an integral (although the series may not be monotone, is has at most one extremal point, and this can be handled by a loose estimate): ∞ k 1/p−1 exp(−ck/n) ≤ 3 x1/p−1 exp(−cx/n)dx 3n−1
k≥3n
n 1/p
∞
x1/p−1 exp(−x)dx = 3c−1/p Γ(1/p)n1/p . c 0 We conclude that in both cases: k 1/p−1 ek ≤ Cp n1/p en ≤ Cp sup k 1/p ek . ≤3
k≥1
k≥3n
Summing the two parts together, we conclude the proof. Using Corollary 1.2, the proof of Theorem 1.3 is now clear: Proof of Theorem 1.3. Corollary 1.2 implies that: ek (K, T ) ≤ C log(1 + n)ek/(C log(1+n) log log(2+n)) (T ◦ , K ◦ ),
for some universal constant C ≥ 1 and all k ≥ 0. Using Proposition 3.3 twice, we conclude: γp (K, T ) ≤ Cp log(1 + n) sup k 1/p ek (K, T ) k≥1
≤
Cp
2
log(1 + n) (log(1 + n) log log(2 + n))1/p sup k 1/p ek (T ◦ , K ◦ ) k≥1
2+1/p
≤ Cp log(1 + n)
1/p
log log(2 + n)
◦
γp (T , K ◦ )
Vol. 57 (2007)
A Remark on Two Duality Relations
227
References [1] S. Artstein, V. Milman, and S. J. Szarek, Duality of metric entropy, Ann. of Math. (2) 159 (2004), no. 3, 1313–1328. [2] S. Artstein, V. Milman, S. Szarek, and N. Tomczak-Jaegermann, On convexified packing and entropy duality, Geom. Funct. Anal. 14 (2004), no. 5, 1134–1141. [3] S. Artstein, Entropy methods, Ph.D. thesis, Tel-Aviv University, 2004. [4] J. Bourgain, A. Pajor, S. J. Szarek, and N. Tomczak-Jaegermann, On the duality problem for entropy numbers of operators, Geometric aspects of functional analysis (1987–88), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 1376, Springer, Berlin, 1989, pp. 50–63. [5] B. Carl, Inequalities of Bernstein-Jackson-type and the degree of compactness of operators in Banach spaces, Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 35 (1985), no. 3, 79–118. [6] Y. Gordon, H. K¨ onig, and C. Sch¨ utt, Geometric and probabilistic estimates for entropy and approximation numbers of operators, J. Approx. Theory 49 (1987), no. 3, 219–239. [7] H. K¨ onig and V. D. Milman, On the covering numbers of convex bodies, Geometrical aspects of functional analysis (1985/86), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 1267, Springer, Berlin, 1987, pp. 82–95. [8] B. Klartag and E. Milman, On volume distribution in 2-convex bodies, to appear in Israel Journal of Mathematics, www.arxiv.org/math.FA/0604594, 2006. [9] H. K¨ onig, V. D. Milman, and N. Tomczak-Jaegermann, Entropy numbers and duality for operators with values in a Hilbert space, Probability in Banach spaces 6 (Sandbjerg, 1986), Progr. Probab., vol. 20, Birkh¨ auser Boston, Boston, MA, 1990, pp. 219–233. [10] V. D. Milman and G. Schechtman, Asymptotic theory of finite-dimensional normed spaces, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol. 1200, Springer, Berlin, 1986. [11] V. D. Milman and S. J. Szarek, A geometric lemma and duality of entropy numbers, Geometric aspects of functional analysis, Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 1745, Springer, Berlin, 2000, pp. 191–222. [12] A. Pietsch, Theorie der Operatorenideale (Zusammenfassung), Friedrich-SchillerUniversit¨ at, Jena, 1972. [13] G. Pisier, Sur les espaces de Banach qui ne contiennent pas uniform´ement de ln1 , C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris S´er. A-B 277 (1973), A991–A994. [14]
, Holomorphic semigroups and the geometry of Banach spaces, Ann. of Math. (2) 115 (1982), no. 2, 375–392.
[15]
, On the dimension of the lpn -subspaces of Banach spaces, for 1 ≤ p < 2, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 276 (1983), no. 1, 201–211.
[16]
, A new approach to several results of V. Milman, J. Reine Angew. Math. 393 (1989), 115–131.
[17]
, The volume of convex bodies and Banach space geometry, Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, vol. 94, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989.
[18] A. Pajor and N. Tomczak-Jaegermann, Volume ratio and other s-numbers of operators related to local properties of Banach spaces, J. Funct. Anal. 87 (1989), no. 2, 273–293.
228
Milman
IEOT
[19] C. Sch¨ utt, Entropy numbers of diagonal operators between symmetric Banach spaces, J. Approx. Theory 40 (1984), no. 2, 121–128. [20] V. N. Sudakov, Gaussian random processes, and measures of solid angles in Hilbert space, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 197 (1971), 43–45. [21] M. Talagrand, Regularity of Gaussian processes, Acta Math. 159 (1987), no. 1-2, 99–149. , Majorizing measures: the generic chaining, Ann. Probab. 24 (1996), no. 3, [22] 1049–1103. , Majorizing measures without measures, Ann. Probab. 29 (2001), no. 1, 411– [23] 417. , The generic chaining, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2005, Upper and lower [24] bounds of stochastic processes. [25] N. Tomczak-Jaegermann, Dualit´e des nombres d’entropie pour des op´erateurs ` a valeurs dans un espace de Hilbert, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris S´er. I Math. 305 (1987), no. 7, 299–301. Emanuel Milman Department of Mathematics The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot 76100 Israel e-mail: [email protected] Submitted: October 6, 2006 Revised: November 8, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 229–234 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020229-6, published online December 26, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1467-8
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
On Smooth Local Resolvents Vladim´ır M¨ uller Abstract. We exhibit an example of a bounded linear operator on a Banach space which admits an everywhere defined local resolvent with continuous derivatives of all orders. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A10; Secondary 47A11. Keywords. Local resolvent, C ∞ -functions.
Let T be a bounded linear operator acting on a complex Banach space X. It is well known that the resolvent z → (T − z)−1 defined on the complement of the spectrum σ(T ) is unbounded. More precisely, (T − z)−1 → ∞ whenever z approaches the spectrum σ(T ). Let x ∈ X be a nonzero vector. By a local resolvent of T at x we mean a function f : U → X defined on a set U ⊃ C \ σ(T ) such that (T − z)f (z) = x (z ∈ U ). Clearly the local resolvent is uniquely determined for all z ∈ C \ σ(T ) and f (z) = (T − z)−1 x. Thus any local resolvent is analytic on the complement of the spectrum. It was observed in [3] that a local resolvent can be bounded. Bounded local resolvents were further studied in [1], [4], [2] and it was shown that they are rather frequent. In [2], an example of a continuous everywhere defined local resolvent was given (such a local resolvent is necessarily bounded since each local resolvent vanishes for z → ∞). The aim of this note is to exhibit an example of an everywhere defined C ∞ local resolvent. Note that by a basic result of local spectral theory there are no analytic everywhere defined local resolvents. Denote by C, R and Z+ the sets of all complex numbers, real numbers and nonnegative integers, respectively. Let X be a complex Banach space and f : C → X a function. As usually we identify C with R2 and consider f to be a function of two real variables x and ∂ k+l f y. We say that f is a C ∞ -function if it has continuous derivatives ∂x k ∂y l of all orders. ˇ The research was supported by the grant No. 201/06/0128 of GA CR..
230
M¨ uller
IEOT
Theorem 1. There exist a Banach space X, an operator T ∈ B(X), a nonzero vector x ∈ X and a C ∞ -function f : C → X such that (T − z)f (z) = x
(z ∈ C).
Proof. Let ϕ : C → 0, 1 be a C ∞ -function such that ϕ(z) = 1 for |z| < 1/3 and f (z) = 0 for |z| > 2/3. (z = 0), g(0) = 0. Clearly g is a Let g : C → C be defined by g(z) = ϕ(z)−1 z ∞ C -function and g(z) = − z1 for |z| > 2/3. k+l
∂ g Write z = x + iy and let gkl = ∂x k ∂y l ; formally we write g00 = g. It is easy to show by induction that −1 k+l+1 gkl (z) = (k + l)! il z for all z, |z| > 2/3 and k, l ∈ Z+ . In particular, all derivatives gkl are bounded functions. For n = 0, 1, . . . choose positive constants Kn such that Kn ≥ nKn−1 (n ≥ 1) and max{|gkl (z)| : z ∈ C} ≤ Kk+l for all k, l ≥ 0. Clearly K0 ≥ 1 and Kn ≥ n! for all n. Denote by D = {z ∈ C : |z| < 1} the open unit disc in the complex plane.
ukl α
Let X0 be the vector space with a Hamel basis formed by the vectors u and (k, l ∈ Z+ , α ∈ D). k+l+1 − η1 (k + l)!il u. Note that ukl For |η| = 1 write for short ukl η = η =
gkl (η)u. Let M ⊂ X0 be the subset formed by the following elements: u, 1 ukl (α ∈ D, k, l ∈ Z+ ), Kk+l α 1 (αu00 (α ∈ D, 2/3 < |α|), α + u) K2 (1 − |α|)2 kl 1 k+1,l uα+t − ukl (α ∈ D, k, l ∈ Z+ , t ∈ R, |t| < 1/3, α + t ∈ D), α − tuα 2 t Kk+l+2 kl 1 k,l+1 u (α ∈ D, k, l ∈ Z+ , − ukl α − suα s2 Kk+l+2 α+is s ∈ R, |s| < 1/3, α + is ∈ D). Let U be the absolutely convex hull of M . Clearly U is absorbing. Let · be the Minkowski seminorm determined by U , i.e., for v ∈ X0 we have |γm | : v = γm m , v = inf m∈M
m∈M
where the coefficients γm are complex and only a finite number of them are nonzero.
Vol. 57 (2007)
On Smooth Local Resolvents
231
We show first that u = 1. Clearly u ≤ 1. Define the linear functional h : X0 → C by h(u) = 1 and h(ukl α ) = gkl (α) (α ∈ D, k, l ∈ Z+ ). We show that |h(v)| ≤ v for all v ∈ X0 . To this end, it is sufficient to show that |h(m)| ≤ 1 for all m ∈ M . For k, l ∈ Z+ , α ∈ D we have |h(ukl α )| = |gkl (α)| ≤ Kk+l , and for α ∈ D, |α| > 2/3, |h(αu00 α + u)| = αg(α) + 1 = 0. Further, for k, l ∈ Z+ , α ∈ D, t, s ∈ R, |t|, |s| < 1/3, α + t, α + is ∈ D we have kl k+1,l h(ukl ) = gkl (α + t) − gkl (α) − tgk+1,l (α) α+t − uα − tuα ≤ t2 max{|gk+2,l (z)| : z ∈ C} ≤ t2 Kk+l+2 and similarly, kl k,l+1 h(ukl ) = gkl (α + is) − gkl (α) − sgk,l+1 (α) ≤ s2 Kk+l+2 . α+is − uα − suα Thus |h(m)| ≤ 1 for all m ∈ M and consequently, |h(v)| ≤ v for all v ∈ X0 . In particular, u ≥ |h(u)| = 1, and so u = 1. Define now the linear mapping T0 : X0 → X0 by T0 u T0 u00 α T0 ukl α
= 0, = αu00 (α ∈ D), α +u k−1,l = αukl + ku + iluk,l−1 α α α
(α ∈ D, k, l ∈ Z+ , k + l ≥ 1)
(here we set formally ukl α = 0 if either k < 0 or l < 0). We show that T0 v ≤ 4v for all v ∈ X0 . To this end, it is again sufficient to show that T0 m ≤ 4 for all m ∈ M . We have 00 T0 u00 α = αuα + u ≤ |α|K0 + 1 ≤ 2K0 and, for k + l ≥ 1, kl k−1,l + iluk,l−1 ≤ |α|Kk+l + kKk+l−1 + lKk+l−1 ≤ 2Kk+l . T0 ukl α = αuα + kuα α
For 2/3 < |α| < 1 we have 00 00 T0 (αu00 α + u) = |α| · T0 uα ≤ αuα + u.
Let k, l ∈ Z+ , α ∈ D, t, s ∈ R, |t|, |s| < 1/3, α + t ∈ D, α + is ∈ D. Then kl kl kl k+1,l + |t| · uk+1,l ≤ t2 Kk+l+2 + |t| · Kk+l+1 (1) ukl α+t − uα ≤ uα+t − uα − tuα α and similarly, kl 2 ukl α+is − uα ≤ s Kk+l+2 + |s|Kk+l+1 .
For α ∈ D, α + t ∈ D and α + is ∈ D we have 00 1,0 00 1,0 00 T0 (u00 (α + t)u00 − u − tu ) = − αu − αtu − tu α+t α α α+t α α α 00 1,0 00 ≤ |α| · u00 + |t| · u00 α+t − uα − tuα α+t − uα ≤
t2 K2 + |t|3 K2 + t2 K1 ≤ 3t2 K2 .
(2)
232
M¨ uller
Similarly,
IEOT
00 0,1 2 T0 (u00 α+is − uα − suα ) ≤ 3s K2 .
For |η| = 1, |t| < 1/3, |η + t| < 1 we have 00 1,0 00 00 2 2 T0 (u00 η+t − uη − tuη ) = T0 uη+t = (η + t)uη+t + u ≤ (1 − |η + t|) K2 ≤ t K2 00 0,1 and analogous estimate holds for T0 (u00 η+is − uα − suα ) . Let k + l ≥ 1, α, α + t, α + is ∈ D. We have T0 (ukl − ukl − tuk+1,l ) α+t α α k−1,l k,l−1 kl k−1,l = (α + t)ukl − iluk,l−1 α+t + kuα+t + iluα+t − αuα − kuα α k+1,l k,l k+1,l−1 −tαuα − (k + 1)tuα − itluα kl k+1,l k−1,l + k uk−1,l ≤ |α| · ukl − tuk,l α+t − uα α+t − uα − tuα α k,l−1 k,l−1 k+1,l−1 kl + |t| · uα+t − ukl +l uα+t − uα − tuα α ≤ t2 Kk+l+2 + (k + l)t2 Kk+l+1 + |t|3 Kk+l+2 + t2 Kk+l+1 ≤ 4t2 Kk+l+2 .
Similarly, T0 (ukl − ukl − suk,l+1 ) α+is α α kl k−1,l k−1,l+1 ≤ |α| · ukl − suk,l+1 + k uk−1,l α+is − uα α+is − uα − suα k,l−1α kl + |s| · ukl ≤ 4s2 Kk+l+2 . +l uα+is − uk,l−1 − suk,l α α α+is − uα Let k + l ≥ 1, |η| = 1, t ∈ R, |t| < 1/3 and η + t ∈ D. We have kl kl k+1,l u ) ≤ t2 Kk+l+2 . η+t − (uη + tuη k+l+1 (k + l)!il u. Hence Recall that uη = − η1 T0 (ukl − ukl − tuk+1,l ) = T0 ukl η+t η η η+t 2 k−1,l k,l−1 kl = (η + t)uη+t + kuη+t + iluη+t ≤ 3t Kk+l+2 + k+1,l k,l−1 (η + t)ukl + kuk−1,l + ktukl + iltuk+1,l−1 η + (η + t)tuη η η + iluη η −1 k+l ≤ 3t2 Kk+l+2 + (k + l − 1)!il−1 u η −i (η + t)ti lti kti · (η + t) (k + l) + (k + l) + il − (k + l) (k + l)(k + l + 1) + ki − η η2 η η −1 k+l+1 (η + t)t = 3t2 Kk+l+2 + (k + l + 1) − η + kt + lt (k + l)!il u · η + t − η η t = 3t2 Kk+l+2 + (k + l)!|t| · 1 − (k + l + 1) − (k + l + 1) + k + l η = 32 Kk+l+2 + (k + l + 1)!t2 ≤ 4t2 Kk+l+2 . Similarly, for |η| = 1, s ∈ R, |s| < 1/3 and η + is ∈ D we have kl k,l+1 T0 (ukl ) ≤ 4s2 Kk+l+2 . η+is − uη − suη Hence T0 m ≤ 4 for all m ∈ M and consequently, T0 v ≤ 4v for all v ∈ X0 .
Vol. 57 (2007)
On Smooth Local Resolvents
233
Let X1 = {v ∈ X0 : v = 0}. Then T0 X1 ⊂ X1 . Let X be the completion of X0 /X1 . Then T0 induces the operator T : X → X and T ≤ 4. Define the function f : C → X by f (z) = u00 z + X1 for |z| < 1 and f (z) = − uz + X1 for |z| ≥ 1. Clearly (T − z)f (z) = u + X1 for all z ∈ C and u + X1 = 0. It remains to show that f is infinitely differentiable. Clearly f is even analytic for |z| > 1. For |z| < 1 we can show by induction ∂ k+l f kl that ∂x k ∂y l (z) = uz + X1 . Indeed, this follows from the estimates uk,l − uk,l z − uk+1,l lim z+t ≤ lim |t|Kk+l+2 = 0 z t→0 t→0 t and similarly,
uk,l − uk,l z − uk,l+1 lim z+is =0 z s→0 s
Finally, for |z| = 1 we show by induction that t→z,
∂ k+l f ∂xk ∂y l (z)
= ukl z + X1 . Clearly
kl ukl gkl (z + t) − gkl (z) z+t − uz = lim u = gk+1,l (z)u = uk+1,l z |z+t|>1 t t→z, |z+t|>1 t
lim
and t→z,
ukl − ukl z+t z − uk+1,l = 0. z t |z+t|<1
lim
Similar statements hold for derivatives in the imaginary direction y. Thus for all ∂ k+l f kl k, l ∈ Z+ and |z| = 1 we have ∂x k ∂y l (z) = uz + X1 . By (1) and (2), all the derivatives z → ukl z are continuous. Remark 2. In [2], there was constructed an example of an operator T ∈ B(X) and x = 0 such that int σ(T ) = ∅ and there is a continuous local resolvent f : C → X satisfying (T − z)f (z) = x (z ∈ C). It was raised a question whether there is a similar example with smooth local resolvent. As it was observed by J. Kol´aˇr, such an example with C1 -local resolvent cannot exist. Indeed, each local resolvent is analytic on the complement of the spectrum. Therefore it satisfies the Cauchy-Riemann conditions on C \ σ(T ). If the local resolvent is C1 and int σ(T ) = ∅, then the local resolvent satisfies the CauchyRiemann conditions everywhere, and so it is an entire function. It is well known (and an easy consequence of the Liouville theorem) that such a local resolvent cannot exist.
References [1] T. Bem´ udez, M. Gonz´ alez, On the boundedness of the local resolvent function, Int. Eq. Operator Theory 34 (1999), 1–8. [2] J. Braˇciˇc, V. M¨ uller, On bounded local resolvents, Int. Eq. Operator theory, to appear.
234
M¨ uller
IEOT
[3] M. Gonz´ alez, An example of a bounded local resolvent, Operator Theory, Operator algebras and related topics, Proc. 16th Int. Conf. on Operator Theory at Timisoira. The Theta Foundation (1997), 159–162. [4] M.M. Neumann, On local spectral properties of operators on Banach spaces, Rend. Circ. Mat. Palermo (2) Suppl. 56 (1998), 15–25. Vladim´ır M¨ uller Mathematical Institute Czech Academy of Sciences Zitna 25 115 67 Prague 1 Czech Republic e-mail: muller@@math.cas.cz Submitted: January 15, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 235–246 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020235-12, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1455-z
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Semisimplicity of Some Class of Operator Algebras on Banach Space H. S. Mustafayev Abstract. Let G be a locally compact abelian group and let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G by means of isometries on a Banach space. We define weak operator topology of the set W n T as the closure owith respect to the R fˆ (T) : f ∈ L1 (G) , where fˆ (T) = f (g)T (g) dg is the Fourier transform G
of f ∈ L1 (G) with respect to the group T. Then WT is a commutative Banach algebra. In this paper we study semisimlicity problem for such algebras. The main result is that if the Arveson spectrum sp (T) of T is scattered (i.e. it does not contain a nonempty perfect subset) then the algebra WT is semisimple. Some related problems are also discussed. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). 47Dxx, 46J05. Keywords. Representation (semi)group, Banach algebra, radical, semisimplicity.
1. Introduction Let A be a complex commutative Banach algebra. The radical of A, denoted by RadA is the set of all quasi-nilpotent elements in A. If RadA = {0}, then A is said to be semisimple. Let X be a complex Banach space and B (X) the algebra of all bounded, linear operators on X. As usual, we denote by σ (T ) the spectrum of + T ∈ B (X). If T in B (X), we let A+ T (resp. WT ) denote the closure in the uniform operator topology (resp. in the weak operator topology) of all polynomials in T . If T is invertible, then AT (resp. WT ) denotes the closure in the uniform operator topology (resp. in the weak operator topology) of all trigonometric polynomials + in T . The algebras A+ T and AT (resp. WT and WT ) are commutative Banach algebras. This research was supported by the YYUBAP Project No: 2006-FED-B12.
236
Mustafayev
IEOT
Let A be a closed commutative subalgebra of B(X). It follows from the spectral radius formula that RadA = {R ∈ A : σ (R) = {0}}. Hence, the algebra A is semisimple if and only if it does not contain a non-zero operator with zero spectrum. For example, if T is a bounded self-adjoint operator on a Hilbert space, then the algebra A+ T is isometrically isomorphic to the algebra of all continuous functions on σ (T ) and therefore, A+ T is semisimple. Recall that an operator T ∈ B (X) is said to be hermitian if exp (itT ) = 1 for all t ∈ R. As is well known, hermitians in a Hilbert space are exactly bounded self-adjoint operators. In contrast with self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space there is a hermitian operator that generates a non-semisimple algebra [16, Corollary 3.4]. Sinclair [16, Theorem 3.1] proved that if T is a hermitian operator with countable spectrum, then WT+ is semisimple. In [6] Feldman showed that if T is an invertible isometry on a Banach space with countable spectrum, then AT is semisimple. Note that if T is a hermitian operator (resp. invertible isometry) on a Banach space X, then T = {exp(itT )}t∈R (resp. T = {T n }n∈Z ) is a one-parameter (resp. discrete) group of isometries on X. Thus this raises the natural question of whether the similar results are valid for the algebras generated by the representations of an abelian (semi)groups. In this paper we generalize both Sinclair’s and Feldman’s results for the representation of a locally compact abelian group using the concept of spectrum of a representation introduced by Arveson in [2].
2. Arveson spectrum and semisimplicity ˆ A map T : G → Let G be a locally compact abelian group with dual group G. B (X) is a representation of G on a Banach space X, if T is a homomorphism of G into the group of invertible isometries in B(X) which is continuous, i.e. limg→0 T (g) x − x = 0 for all x ∈ X. ˆ the Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G on X. For each χ ∈ G, representation Tχ = {Tχ (g)}g∈G will be defined by Tχ (g) = χ (g)T (g). T∗ will denote the set {T (g)∗ }g∈G . Let L1 (G) be the group algebra of G. As usual, fˆ will denote the Fourier transform of f ∈ L1 (G): ˆ fˆ (χ) = f (g)χ (g)dg, χ ∈ G. G
If T = {T (g)}g∈G is a representation of G on X, then for each f ∈ L1 (G) we can define fˆ (T) ∈ B (X), by fˆ (T) = f (g)T (g) dg. G
Vol. 57 (2007)
Semisimplicity of Operator Algebras
237
The map f → fˆ (T) is a continuous homomorphism from L1 (G) into B (X). We define AT (resp. WT ) as the closure with respect to the uniform operator topology 1 ˆ (resp. weak operator topology) of the set f (T) : f ∈ L (G) . Then AT and WT are commutative Banach algebras. Let {U } be a net of compact neighborhoods of 0 contracting to {0} and eU , the non-negative function supported by U and satisfying eU (g) dg = 1. It is easy U
to verify that eˆU (T) → 1X -in the strong operator topology, as U → {0}; 1X is the identity operator on X. This shows that thealgebra WT has the unit element 1X . ˆ let J 0 = f ∈ L1 (G) : suppfˆ ∩ S =Ø }. As is For a closed subset S of G, S 1 0 known [10, p.182-183], JS := JS is the smallest closed ideal in L (G) whose hull is S; IS = f ∈ L1 (G) : fˆ (S) = {0} is the largest closed ideal in L1 (G) whose hull is S (in the case when S = {0}, instead of JS and IS we will write J0 and I0 , respectively). S is a set of synthesis if and only if IS = JS . It is a famous theorem ˆ contains a subset S of of Malliavin [10, p.199] that if G is not compact, then G non-synthesis. Example 2.1. Let G be a locally compact but non-compact abelian group. For a 1 ˆ let T = {T (g)} closed subset S of G, g∈G be the translation group on L (G) /JS ; T (g) : f + JS = fg + JS where, fg (s) = f (s − g). Then T is a representation of G on L1 (G)/JS and ˆ (T) (f + JS ) = h ∗ f + JS for every h ∈ L1 (G). Since L1 (G)/JS has a bounded h ˆ (T) = h + JS . It follows that AT is by one approximate identity, we have h isometrically isomorphic to L1 (G)/JS . Since RadL1 (G)/JS = IS /JS , in case S fails to be of spectral synthesis AT (resp. WT ) is not semisimple. Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G on X. The set IX = f ∈ L1 (G) : fˆ (T) = 0 is a closed ideal in L1 (G). The Arveson spectrum sp (T) of T is defined as the hull (IX ), i.e. ˆ : fˆ (χ) = 0, f ∈ IX . sp (T) = χ ∈ G ˆ and We see that sp (T) is a closed subset of G Jsp(T) ⊆ IX ⊆ Isp(T) .
(2.1)
As proved in [2, p.215, Corollary 1], sp (T) =Ø if and only if X = {0}. In [2, p.223, Corollary 2], it is also shown that sp (T) can be identified with the maximal ideal space of AT . Recall that a Hausdorff topological space S is said to be scattered if S does not contain a nonempty perfect subset. For example, the scattered subsets of the real line (or complex plane) are countable (Cantor-Bendixson Theorem). Note also
238
Mustafayev
IEOT
that if S is a scattered set, then every nonempty closed subset of S contains an isolated point. As is known [10, Corollary 8.5.1], scattered subsets of the dual ˆ of a a locally compact abelian group G are sets of synthesis. group G The main result of this section is the following theorem. Theorem 2.2. Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of a locally compact abelian group G on a Banach space X. If sp (T) is a scattered set, then the algebra WT is semisimple. For the proof of this theorem we need some preliminary results with which we now proceed. Let T = T (g)g∈G be a representation of G on X. Lemma 2.3. If sp(T) is a set of synthesis, then fˆ(T) = 0 if and only if fˆ = 0 on sp (T) . Proof. Since sp (T) is a set of synthesis, it follows from (2.1) that IX = Isp(T) . We define the kernel of T as the set KerT = {x ∈ X : T (g) x = x, g ∈ G}. The range of T is defined as RanT = span {T (g) x − x : x ∈ X, g ∈ G}. As is known [7, Theorem 3.8.4], KerT ∩ RanT = {0} . It can be deduced even more. Proposition 2.4. If T = {T (g)}g∈G is a representation of G on X, then for every x ∈ KerT, x = dist x, RanT . Proof. We put E = KerT and F = RanT. It is enough to show that x ≤ dist (x, F ) for every x ∈ E. We have F ⊥ = {ϕ ∈ X ∗ : T (g)∗ ϕ = ϕ, g ∈ G} . Let Cb (G) be the space of all bounded continuous functions on G. It is well known that G is amenable, namely there exists a Φ ∈ Cb (G)∗ such that: i) Φ (1) = 1, where 1 is the constant one function on G; ii) Φ (f ) ≥ 0 for every f ≥ 0; iii) Φ (f s ) = Φ (f ), where f s (g) = f (g + s). Let ϕ ∈ X ∗ be fixed. For x ∈ X, we define a function fϕ,x on G by fϕ,x (g) =< ϕ, T (g) x >. Clearly, fϕ,x ∈ Cb (G). Then we can define a ψ ∈ X ∗ by < ψ, x >= Φ(fϕ,x ). Since s ∗ < T (s) ψ, x >=< ψ, T (s) x >= Φ fϕ,x = Φ (fϕ,x ) =< ψ, x > (s ∈ G), the map ϕ → ψ is a projection from X ∗ onto F ⊥ . Taking into occount Φ = 1, we have ψ ≤ ϕ. Now, let x ∈ E be given. Since < ϕ, x >=< ψ, x >, we obtain x = sup {|ϕ (x)| : ϕ ∈ X ∗ : ϕ ≤ 1} ≤ sup |ψ (x)| : ψ ∈ F ⊥ , ψ ≤ 1 = dist (x, F ) .
Vol. 57 (2007)
Semisimplicity of Operator Algebras
239
Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G on X ant let E be a closed subspace of X invariant under T, i.e. T (g)E ⊆ E for all g ∈ G. Then we may define a subrepresentation T|E = {T |E (g)}g∈G of G on E by T |E (g) = T (g)|E , where T (g)|E is the restriction of T (g) to E. In this case IE = f ∈ L1 (G) : fˆ (T) x = 0, x ∈ E . Since IX ⊆ IE , we have hull(IE ) ⊆ hull(IX ), so that sp(T|E ) ⊆ sp(T). Lemma 2.5. Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G on X and let E be a closed subspace of X invariant under T. If sp(T|E ) = {0}, then E ⊆ KerT. Proof. Since hull (IE ) = {0} and {0} is a set of synthesis, we have IE = I0 . It follows that f (g)ϕ (T (g) x) dg = 0, G
for all f ∈ I0 , ϕ ∈ X ∗ and all x ∈ E. Thus ϕ (T (g) x) = const and hence T (g) x = x for all x ∈ E and all g ∈ G. Recall that x ∈ X\ {0} (resp. ϕ ∈ X ∗ \ {0}) is said to be an eigenvector of ˆ and T (resp. of T∗ ) if T (g) x = χ (g) x (resp. T (g)∗ ϕ = χ (g)ϕ ) for some χ ∈ G for all g ∈ G. Lemma 2.6. Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G on a Banach space X which satisfies one of the following conditions: a) The linear span of the set of eigenvectors of T∗ is weak ∗ dense in X ∗ . b) The linear span of the set of eigenvectors of T is weakly dense in X. Then the algebra WT is semisimple. Proof. a) Let ϕ be an eigenvector of T∗ and let R ∈ RadWT . It is sufficient to ∗ ˆ and for all g ∈ G. show that R∗ ϕ = 0. We have T (g) ϕ = χ (g)ϕ for some χ ∈ G ∗ 1 ˆ ˆ It follows that f (T) ϕ = f (−χ) ϕ for all f ∈ L (G). Since R ∈ WT , there exists a net (fλ )λ∈Λ in L1 (G) such that < ϕ, fˆλ (T) x >→< ϕ, Rx >, x ∈ X. If x ∈ Kerϕ, in particular we have ∗ 0 =< fˆλ (−χ) ϕ, x >=< fˆλ (T) ϕ, x >
=< ϕ, fˆλ (T) x >→< ϕ, Rx >=< R∗ ϕ, x > . Thus we obtain Kerϕ ⊆ KerR∗ ϕ, which implies that R∗ ϕ = λϕ for some λ ∈ C. Since σ (R) = {0}, we have λ = 0 and hence R∗ ϕ = 0. The proof of b) is similar to that of a).
240
Mustafayev
IEOT
It is not clear whether the condition b) is satisfied for the representations with scattered spectrum. However, the proof of Theorem 2.2 below, shows that for the representation T with scattered spectrum the set of eigenvectors of T∗ is weak ∗ dense in X ∗ . Proof of Theorem 2.2. Let M be the weak ∗ closure of the linear span of the set of ˆ eigenvectors of T∗ . Since (RanTχ )⊥ ⊂ M , we have ⊥ M ⊂ RanTχ for all χ ∈ G. Consequently, ⊥ M ⊂ E, where E = ∩χ∈sp(T) RanTχ . By Lemma 2.6 a) it is sufficient to prove that E = {0}. Suppose on the contrary that E = {0}. We see that E is a closed subspace of X invariant under T. Then sp (T |E ) is a nonempty closed subset of sp (T). Since sp (T) is a scattered set, sp (T |E ) has an isolated point or single point. We may assume that this isolated or single point is {0}. Assume that {0} is an isolated point of sp (T |E ). Let e ∈ L1 (G) be such that eˆ (0) = 1 and eˆ (χ) = 0 for all χ ∈ sp (T |E ) \ {0}. Since the Fourier 2 transform of e∗e−e vanishes on sp (T |E ), by Lemma 2.3 we have eˆ (T) x = eˆ (T) x for all x ∈ E. Hence eˆ (T) is a projection on E. We put F = eˆ (T) E. Let us show that sp (T |F ) = {0}. For this it is enough to show that IF = I0 , where IF = f ∈ L1 (G) : fˆ (T) eˆ (T) x = 0, x ∈ E . If f ∈ IF , then it follows from Lemma 2.3 that the Fourier transform of f ∗ e vanishes on sp (T |E ). Since {0} ∈ sp (T |E ) and eˆ (0) = 1 this implies fˆ (0) = 0, so that f ∈ I0 . If f ∈ I0 , then the Fourier transform of f ∗ e vanishes on sp (T |E ). By Lemma 2.3 we have fˆ (T) eˆ (T) x = 0 for all x ∈ E, so that f ∈ IF . Now, if {0} is an isolated point of sp (T |E ) we let Z = F , and if sp (T |E ) = {0} we let Z = E. Then Z is a non-null closed subspace of X and sp (T |Z ) = {0}. By Lemma 2.5 we have Z ⊆ KerT. On the other hand, Z ⊆ RanT. Since KerT ∩ RanT = {0}, we obtain Z = {0}. This is a contradiction. We do not know whether Theorem 2.2 true if sp(T) is a synthesis set. Let T = {T (g)}g∈G be a representation of G on X. A straightforward application of a separation theorem shows that the union of the ranges of the operators fˆ (T), f ∈ L1 (G) is dense in X. Theorem 2.2 can be reformulated as follows: Theorem 2.7. Let h : L1 (G) → B (X) be a continuous homomorphism such that the union of the ranges of the operators h(f ), f ∈ L1 (G) is dense in X. If W OT
hull(kerh) is a scattered set, then the algebra h (L1 (G))
is semisimple.
Proof. Under the hypotheses of the theorem there exists a representation T = {T (g)}g∈G of G on X such that h (f ) = f (g)T (g) dg G
Vol. 57 (2007)
Semisimplicity of Operator Algebras
[11, Theorem 32C]. It remains to apply Theorem 2.2.
241
3. C0 -semigroup and semisimplicity A family T = {T (t)}t≥0 in B (X) is called a C0 -semigroup if the following properties are satisfied: 1) T (0) = 1X ; 2) T (t + s) = T (t) T (s), for every t, s ≥ 0; 3) limt→0+ T (t) x − x = 0, for all x ∈ X. The generator of the C0 -semigroup T = {T (t)}t≥0 is the linear operator A with domain D (A) defined by Ax = lim
t→0+
1 (T (t) x − x) , t
x ∈ D (A) ;
1 D (A) = x ∈ X : lim (T (t) x − x) exists . t→0+ t The generator is always a closed, densely defined operator. The C0 -groups are defined analogously to C0 -semigroups, the only difference being that the role of the index family t ≥ 0 is replaced by t ∈ R. The generator of a C0 -group T = {T (t)}t∈R is defined as the generator of the associated C0 -semigroup. A C0 -semigroup T = {T (t)}t≥0 will be said to be bounded if supt≥0 T (t) < ∞. If T = {T (t)}t≥0 is a bounded C0 -semigroup with generator A, then the spectrum σ (A) of A belongs to the closed left half-plane. σ (A) ∩ iR is called the unitary spectrum of A. If T = {T (t)}t≥0 is a C0 -semigroup of contractions i.e., T (t) ≤ 1 (t ≥ 0) on a Banach space X, then for every x ∈ X the limit limt→∞ T (t) x exists and is equal to inft≥0 T (t) x. Note also that if T is a bounded C0 -semigroup on X, then |x| = supt≥0 T (t)x is an equivalent norm on X with respect to which T becomes a C0 -semigroup of contractions. Similarly, if T is a bounded C0 -group on X, then |x| = supt∈R T (t)x is an equivalent norm on X with respect to which T becomes a C0 -group of isometries. Let L1 (R+ ) be the space of all absolutely integrable measurable complex functions on the half-line R+ . L1 (R+ ) is a commutative Banach algebra when convolution is taken as the multiplication. L1 (R+ ) can be considered (in the natural way) as a subalgebra of L1 (R). For a function f ∈ L1 (R+ ), we put ∞ fˆ (T) =
f (t) T (t)dt. 0
Then the map f → fˆ (T) is a continuous homomorphism from L1 (R+ ) into B (X). + We define A+ T (resp. WT ) as the closure with respect to the uniform operator
242
Mustafayev
topology (resp. weak operator topology) of the set
IEOT
fˆ (T) : f ∈ L1 (R+ ) . Then
+ A+ T and WT are commutative Banach algebras. Note also that if T is a bounded + C0 -group then A+ T (resp. WT ) is a subalgebra of AT (resp. WT ). Let en (t) = 2nχ[0,1/n] (t) (n ∈ N), where χ[0,1/n] (t) is the characteristic function of the interval [0, 1/n]. It is easy to verify that eˆn (T) → 1X -in the strong operator topology, as n → ∞. This shows that WT+ has the unit element 1X . In [5] it is shown that if T is a bounded C0 -group with generator A, then sp (T) = σ (iA). As an immediate corollary of Theorem 2.2 we have the next result.
Corollary 3.1. Let T = {T (t)}t∈R be a bounded C0 -group on a Banach space with generator A. If σ (A) is at most countable, then WT (resp. WT+ ) is semisimple. Let T = {T (t)}t≥0 be a C0 -semigroup of contractions on X. Arendt-BattyLyubich-Vu (ABLV) theorem [13, Theorem 5.1.5] states that if the unitary spectrum of the generator of T is countable and contains no residual spectrum, then T is stable, i.e. limt→∞ T (t)x = 0 for all x ∈ X. The proof of the ABLV theorem uses essentially the following construction [13, Theorem 5.1.2]. Lemma 3.2. Let T = {T (t)}t≥0 be a C0 -semigroup of contractions on a Banach space X, with generator A. If inft≥0 T (t) x > 0 for some x ∈ X\ {0}, then there exist a Banach space Y = {0}, a bounded linear operator J : X → Y with dense range and a C0 -semigroup of isometries V = {V (t)}t≥0 on Y with generator B such that: i) Jx = limt→∞ T (t) x for all x ∈ X; ii) V (t) J = JT (t) for all t ≥ 0; iii) σ (B) ⊆ σ (A) . The triple (Y, J, V) will be called the isometric limit semigroup associated to T. As a consequence of Lemma 3.2 and Theorem 2.2 we have the following: Theorem 3.3. Let T = {T (t)}t≥0 be a C0 -semigroup of contractions on a Banach space X with generator A. If the unitary spectrum of A is at most countable, then for every R ∈ RadWT+ and x ∈ X, lim T (t) Rx = 0.
t→∞
Proof . If limt→∞ T (t) x = 0 for every x ∈ X\ {0}, then there is nothing to prove. Hence we may assume that inft≥0 T (t) x > 0 for some x ∈ X\ {0}. Let (Y, J, V) be the isometric limit semigroup associated to T. Any operator S ∈ WT+ generates an operator S0 on JX by S0 Jx = JSx, x ∈ X. Then we have S0 Jx = JSx = lim T (t) Sx = lim ST (t) x t→∞
t→∞
≤ S lim T (t) x = S Jx . t→∞
Vol. 57 (2007)
Semisimplicity of Operator Algebras
243
Since J has dense range, S0 can be extended continuously to whole Y . We will ˆ ˆ denote this extension by S. Then we have SJ = JS and Sˆ ≤ S for all S ∈ WT+ . Now, let us show that Sˆ ∈ WV+ . Since S ∈ WT+ , there exists a net (fλ )λ∈Λ in L1 (R+ ) such that < ϕ, fˆλ (T) x, >→< ϕ, Sx >, for all ϕ ∈ X ∗ and x ∈ X. By Lemma 3.2 ii) since fˆλ (V) J = J fˆλ (T) (λ ∈ Λ), we have < ψ, fˆλ (V) Jx >=< ψ, J fˆλ (T) x >=< J ∗ ψ, fˆλ (T) x >→ ˆ >, < J ∗ ψ, Sx >=< ψ, JSx >=< ψ, SJx for all ψ ∈ Y ∗ and x ∈ X. Since J has dense range we obtain that ˆ >, < ψ, fˆλ (V) y >→< ψ, Sy for all ψ ∈ Y ∗ and y ∈ Y . The mapping h : S → Sˆ is a contractive algebra-homomorphism from WT+ into WV+ . Since h is a unital algebra-homomorphism, we obtain the spectral incluˆ ⊆ σ(S) for all S ∈ W + . It follows that if σ(S) = 0 then σ(S) ˆ = 0. sion σ(S) T + We claim that the algebra WV is semisimple. As is known [13, Lemma 5.1.1], if V is an arbitrary C0 -semigroup of isometries with generator B, then either σ(B) = {z ∈ C : Rez ≤ 0} or σ(B) ⊆ iR. Since σ(A) ∩ iR is countable, by Lemma 3.2 iii) σ(B) ∩ iR is also countable. Consequently, σ(B) is a proper subset of iR. By [13, Corollary 5.1.3], V extends to a C0 -group of isometries U = {U (t)}t∈R on X with generator B. Since σ(B) is at most countable, by Corollary 3.1 WU is semisimple. Also since WV+ = WU+ , the algebra WV+ is semisimple. ˆ = {0}. Since the Now, let R ∈ WT+ be such that σ(R) = {0}. Then σ(R) + ˆ algebra WV is semisimple we have R = 0, so that JR = 0. By Lemma 3.2 i) this means that limt→∞ T (t) Rx = 0 for every x ∈ X. A C0 -semigroup T = {T (t)}t≥0 on a Banach space X is bounded away from zero if inft≥0 T (t)x > 0 for all x ∈ X\ {0} [13, p.180]. Corollary 3.4. Let T = {T (t)}t≥0 be a bounded C0 -semigroup on a Banach space which is bounded away from zero. If the unitary spectrum of the generator A is at most countable, then WT+ is semisimple. Example 3.5. Let V be the Volterra operator on the Hilbert space L2 [0, 1], defined t by (V f )(t) = f (s)ds and let T = e−tV t≥0 . Notice that the exponential formula 0 [14, Theorem 1.8.3] yields e−tV = 1 for all t ≥ 0. On the other hand, V is a + + non-zero quasinilpotent operator and V ∈ A+ V = AT . This shows that AT (resp. + WT ) is not semisimple.
244
Mustafayev
IEOT
4. C1 -contractions and semisimplicity An invertible operator T on a Banach space X is called double power bounded (d.p.b.) if supn∈Z T n < ∞. It is easy to see that if T is a d.p.b. operator, then σ (T ) ⊆ Γ; Γ = {z ∈ C : |z| = 1}. Every d.p.b. operator defines a bounded representation T = {T n }n∈Z of Z on X. In this case for an arbitrary f = {f (n)}n∈Z ∈ L1 (Z), fˆ (T) is defined by f (n) T n . fˆ (T) = n∈Z
Hence AT (resp. WT ) coincides with the AT (resp. WT ). Note that [10, Theorem −1 the joint 4.5.1] the maximal ideal space of AT can be identified with σAT T, T , −1 −1 with respect to A →ξ . Note also that the map ξ, ξ spectrum of T, T T homeomorphically identifies σAT T, T −1 with σAT (T ), the spectrum of T with respect to AT . On the other hand, since σAT (T ) ⊆ Γ, by the Shilov’s theorem [10, Corollary 2.3.2] we have σAT (T ) = σ (T ). Hence in this case sp(T) = σ(T ). The next corollary is an immediate consequence of Theorem 2.2. Corollary 4.1. If T is a d.p.b. operator on a Banach space with countable spectrum, then WT is semisimple. An operator T in B (X) is called power-bounded if supn∈N T n < ∞. Note that if T is a power-bounded operator then σ (T ) ⊆ D; D = {z ∈ C : |z| < 1}. σ (T ) ∩ Γ is called the unitary spectrum of T . Note also that if T is a contraction i.e., T ≤ 1, then for every x ∈ X the limit limn→∞ T n x exists and is equal to infn∈N T n x. The main result of this section is the following theorem. Theorem 4.2. If T is a contraction on a Banach space X with countable unitary spectrum, then for every R ∈ RadWT+ and x ∈ X, lim T n Rx = 0.
n→∞
For the proof we need the following lemma [15, Lemma 2.1]. Lemma 4.3. Let T be a contraction on a Banach space X. If infn∈N T n x > 0 for some x ∈ X \ {0}, then there exist a Banach space Y = {0}, a bounded linear operator J : X → Y with dense range and an isometry V on Y such that: i) Jx = limn→∞ T n x for all x ∈ X; ii) V J = JT ; iii) σ (V ) ⊆ σ (T ) . The triple (Y, J, V ) will be called the limit isometry of T . Proof of Theorem 4.2. If limn→∞ T n x = 0 for every x ∈ X, then there is nothing to prove. Hence we may assume that infn∈N T n x > 0 for some x ∈ X\{0}.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Semisimplicity of Operator Algebras
245
Let (Y, J, V ) be the limit isometry of T . Any operator S ∈ WT+ generates an operator S0 on JX by S0 Jx = JSx, x ∈ X. Then we have S0 Jx = JSx = lim T n Sx = lim ST n x ≤ S Jx . n→∞
n→∞
Since J has dense range, S0 can be extended continuously to whole Y . We will ˆ Then we have SJ ˆ = JS and denote this extension by S. Sˆ ≤ S for all S ∈ WT+ . Now, let us show that Sˆ ∈ WV+ . Since S ∈ WT+ , there exists a net of polynomials (Pλ )λ∈Λ such that < ϕ, Pλ (T ) x >→< ϕ, Sx >, ∗ for every ϕ ∈ X and x ∈ X. By Lemma 4.3 ii) since Pλ (V ) J = JPλ (T ) (λ ∈ Λ), we have < ψ, Pλ (V ) Jx >=< ψ, JPλ (T ) x >=< J ∗ ψ, Pλ (T ) x >→ for every ψ ∈ Y ∗
ˆ < J ∗ ψ, Sx >=< ψ, JSx >=< ψ, SJx >, and x ∈ X. Since J has dense range we obtain that ˆ >, < ψ, Pλ (V ) y >→< ψ, Sy
for every ψ ∈ Y ∗ and y ∈ Y . The mapping h : S → Sˆ is a contractive algebra-homomorphism from WT+ into WV+ . Since h is a unital algebra-homomorphism, we obtain the spectral incluˆ ⊆ σ(S) for all S ∈ W + . It follows that if σ(S) = 0 then σ(S) ˆ = 0. sion σ(S) T + Now, we claim that the algebra WV is semisimple. As is known [3, p.27, Proposition 1.15] if V is an arbitrary isometry on a Banach space, then either σ(V ) = D or σ(V ) ⊆ Γ. Since σ(T ) ∩ Γ is countable, by Lemma 4.3 iii) σ(V ) ∩ Γ is also countable, so that σ(V ) ⊂ Γ. Hence V is an invertible isometry with countable spectrum. By Corollary 4.1, WV is semisimple. It follows that the algebra WV+ is semisimple. ˆ = {0}. Since the alLet R ∈ WT+ be such that σ(R) = {0}. Then σ(R) + ˆ = 0 and hence JR = 0. This means that gebra WV is semisimple we have R limn→∞ T n Rx = 0 for every x ∈ X. An operator T in B(X) is said to be of class C1 if infn∈N T n x > 0 for all x ∈ X\{0} [3, p.249]. As a corollary of Theorem 4.2 we have the next result. Corollary 4.4. Let T be a power-bounded operator of class C1 on a Banach space. If the unitary spectrum of T is at most countable, then WT+ is semisimple. Example 4.5. Let V be the Volterra operator on H = L2 [0, 1] and let T = −1 (1H + V ) . Then T n = 1 for all n ∈ N [8, Problem 150]. We see that σ (T ) = + {1} but T = 1H . Hence A+ T (resp. WT ) is not semisimple. Acknowledgment The author is grateful to the referee for helpful comments and suggestions.
246
Mustafayev
IEOT
References [1] W. Arendt and C.J.K. Batty, Tauberian theorems for one-parameter semigroups, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 306(1988), 837-852. [2] W. Arveson, The harmonic analysis of automorphism groups of operator algebras, Proc. Symp. Pure Math., 38(1982), 199-269. [3] A. Beauzamy, Introduction to Operator Theory and Invariant Subspaces, NorthHolland, Amsterdam, 1988. [4] J. Esterle, E. Strouse and F. Zouakia, Stabilite asymptotique de cartains semigroupes d’operateurs et ideaux primaries, J. Operator Theory, 28(1992), 203-228. [5] D. E. Evans, On the spectrum of a one-parameter strongly continuous representation, Math. Scand., 39(1976), 80-82. [6] G. M. Feldman, The semisimplicity of an algebra generated by isometric operators, Funk. Anal. Prilozhen., 8(1974), 93-94 (Russian). [7] F. Greenleaf, Invariant Means on Topological Groups and their Application, Van Nostrand, New York, 1969. [8] P. R. Halmos, A Hilbert Space Problem Book, Von Nostrand, Princeton, 1967. [9] E. Hewitt and K. Ross, Abstract Harmonic Analysis-II., Springer-Verlag, New York, 1973. [10] R. Larsen, Banach Algebras, Marcel-Dekker Inc., New York 1973. [11] L. H. Loomis An Introduction to Abstract Harmonic Analysis, Van Nostrand, New York, 1953. [12] Yu. I. Lyubich and V. Q. Phong, Asymptotic stability of linear differential equations on Banach spaces, Studia Math., 88(1988), 37-42. [13] J. M. A. M. van Neerven, The Asymptotic Behavior of Semigroups of Linear Operators, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, 1996. [14] A. Pazy, Semigroup of Linear Operators and Applications to Partial Differential Equations, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1983. [15] V. Q. Phong, Theorems of Katznelson-Tzafriri type for semigroups of operators, J. Funct. Anal., 103(1992), 74-84. [16] A. M. Sinclair, The Banach algebra generated by a hermitian operator, Proc. London Math. Soc., 24(1972), 681-691. H. S. Mustafayev Yuzuncu Yil University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Mathematics 65080 Van, Turkey e-mail: [email protected] Submitted: February 3, 2006 Revised: April 8, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 247–261 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020247-15, published online December 26, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1468-7
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1-Functions in the Spaces with Trivial Boyd Indices Denis Potapov and Fyodor Sukochev Abstract. If E is a separable symmetric sequence space with trivial Boyd indices and SE is the corresponding ideal of compact operators, then there exists a C 1 -function fE , a self-adjoint element W ∈ SE and a densely defined / closed symmetric derivation δ on SE such that W ∈ Dom δ, but fE (W ) ∈ Dom δ. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A55; Secondary 47L20. Keywords. Commutator estimates, derivations.
1. Introduction This paper studies properties of infinitesimal generator δ S of a strongly continuous group α = {αt }t∈R in Banach algebras S ⊆ B(H), given by αt (y) = eitX ye−itX , y ∈ S, where X is an unbounded self-adjoint operator in the Hilbert space H. The generator δ S is a densely defined closed symmetric derivation on S and we are concerned with the question when its domain Dom δ S satisfies the following condition x = x∗ ∈ Dom δ S ⇒ f (x) ∈ Dom δ S , for every C 1 -function f : R → C? In the recent paper [3], it is shown that there are C ∗ -algebras S and operators X for which the implication above fails (see also [9]). In this paper, we consider the case when the Banach algebra S is a symmetrically normed ideal of compact operators on H. (see e.g. [4] and Section 3 below). It is immediately clear that for every self-adjoint operator X, the group α acts isometrically on such an ideal S and, in fact, is a C0 -group on S, provided that S is separable (see e.g. [2]). It is an interesting problem to determine the class of ideals S in which Dom δ S is closed with respect to the C 1 -functional calculus. Note, that the class of such ideals is non-empty. For example it contains the Hilbert-Schmidt ideal. The proof of the latter claim may be found in [10]. On the other hand, it is unclear whether this class contains the Schatten-von
248
Potapov and Sukochev
IEOT
Neumann ideals Sp when 1 < p < ∞, p = 2. In this paper, we however show that the class of all symmetrically normed ideals S whose Boyd indices are trivial fail the implication above. For various geometric characterizations of the latter class we refer to [1] (see also Section 3 below). Our methods are built upon and extend those of [3, 9]. Our results also contribute to the study of commutator bounded operator-functions initiated in [5–7].
2. Schur multipliers Let Mn (C) be the C ∗ -algebra of all n × n complex matrices, let B ∈ Mn (C) be a diagonal matrix diag{λ1 , λ2 , . . . , λn }. The Schur multiplier Mf (B) associated with the diagonal matrix B and the function f : R → C is defined as follows. For every matrix X = {ξjk }nj,k=1 ∈ Mn (C), the matrix Mf (B)(X) ∈ Mn (C) has (j, k) entry given by [Mf (B)(X)]jk = ψf (λj , λk )ξjk , 1 ≤ j, k ≤ n, where
f (λ) − f (µ) , λ = µ, λ−µ ψf (λ, µ) = 0, λ = µ.
Alternatively, if {Pj }nj=1 is the collection of one-dimensional spectral projections of the matrix B then B = nj=1 λj Pj , and Mf (B)X = ψf (λj , λk )Pj XPk . (2.1) 1≤j,k≤n
For every matrix X ∈ Mn (C) the following equation outlines the interplay between the Schur multiplier Mf (B) and the commutator [B, X] = BX − XB Mf (B)([B, X]) = [f (B), X]. Indeed, Mf (B)([B, X]) =
ψf (λj , λk )Pj
=
λs Ps , X Pk
s=1
1≤j,k≤n
n
ψf (λj , λk )(λj − λk )Pj XPk
1≤j,k≤n
=
(f (λj ) − f (λk ))Pj XPk
1≤j,k≤n
=
1≤j,k≤n
Pj
n s=1
f (λs )Ps , X Pk = [f (B), X].
(2.2)
Vol. 57 (2007)
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
249
3. Symmetric spaces with trivial Boyd indices Let E = E(0, ∞) be a symmetric Banach function space, i.e. E = E(0, ∞) is a rearrangement invariant Banach function space on (0, ∞) (see [8]) with the additional property that f, g ∈ E and g ≺≺ f imply that g E ≤ f E . Here g ≺≺ f denotes submajorization in the sense of Hardy, Littlewood and Polya, i.e. t t g ∗ (s) ds ≤ f ∗ (s) ds, t > 0, 0
0
where f ∗ (respectively, g ∗ ) stands for the decreasing rearrangement of the function f (respectively, g). Let us consider the group of dilations {στ }τ >0 defined on the space S = S(0, ∞) of all Lebesgue measurable functions on (0, ∞). The operator στ , τ > 0 is given by (στ f )(t) = f (τ −1 t), t > ∞. If E is a symmetric Banach function space, then the lower (respectively, upper) Boyd index αE (respectively, βE ) of the space E is defined by
log στ E→E log στ E→E αE := lim respectively, βE := lim . τ →+∞ τ →+0 log τ log τ We say that the space E has the trivial lower (resp. upper) Boyd index when αE = 0 (respectively, βE = 1). It is known that, if αE = 0 (respectively, βE = 1), then the space E is not an interpolation space in the pair (L1 , Lp ) for every p < ∞ (respectively, (Lq , L∞ ) for every 1 < q), [8, Section 2.b]. Proposition 3.1. ( [8, Proposition 2.b.7]) If E be a symmetric sequence space and αE = 0 (respectively, βE = 1), then for every ε > 0 and every n ∈ N there exist n disjointly supported vectors {xj }nj=1 in E, having the same distribution, such that for every scalars {aj }nj=1 the following holds n max |aj | ≤ aj xj ≤ (1 + ε) max |aj | 1≤j≤n
j=1
1≤j≤n
E
n n n respectively, (1 − ε) |aj | ≤ aj xj ≤ |aj | . j=1
j=1
E
j=1
(3.1) If E is separable then xj can be chosen finitely supported. SE denotes the corresponding symmetric ideal of compact operators on the Hilbert space 2 = 2 (N), i.e. the space of all compact operators x such that s(x) ∈ E, where s(x) is the step function such that s(x)(t) = sk , k < t ≤ k + 1, k ≥ 0 and {sk }k≥0 the sequence of singular numbers (counted with multiplicities) of the operator x (see e.g. [4]). The norm in the space SE is given by x SE := s(x) E . In particular, if E = Lp , then the ideal Sp = SLp , 1 ≤ p < ∞ stands for the
250
Potapov and Sukochev
IEOT
Schatten-von Neumann ideals of compact operators and S∞ stands for the ideal of all compact operators equipped with the operator norm, see [4]. Let n2 be the subspace in 2 spanned by the first n standard unit vector basis. If an element B ∈ SE is such that B = B|n2 , then we identify B with its matrix from Mn (C). Proposition 3.2. Let E be a separable symmetric function space and αE = 0 (respectively, βE = 1). For every scalar ε > 0 and every positive integer n ∈ N there exist linear operators Φn and Ψn such that (i) Φn , Ψn : Mn (C) → Mkn (C), where {kn }n≥1 is a sequence of positive integers; (ii) the operators Φn , Ψn map diagonal (respectively, self-adjoint) matrices to diagonal (respectively, self-adjoint) matrices; (iii) if Mf (B), Mf (Φn (B)) are the Schur multiplier associated with the diagonal matrices B ∈ Mn (C), Φn (B) ∈ Mkn (C) and the function f , then Ψn (Mf (B)X) = Mf (Φn (B))Ψn (X) for every matrix X ∈ Mn (C); (iv) X S∞ ≤ Ψn (X) SE ≤ (1 + ε) X S∞ (respectively, (1 − ε) X S1 ≤
Ψn (X) SE ≤ X S1 ) for every matrix X ∈ Mn (C). Proof. Let n be a fixed positive integer and ε > 0 be a fixed positive scalar. Let {xj }nj=1 be a sequence of finitely and disjointly supported vectors, having the same distribution such that (3.1) holds. Let X0 be the matrix given by X0 = diag{x∗1 (k)}k≥1 , i.e. X0 is the finite diagonal matrix in SE that corresponds to the decreasing rearrangement x∗1 in E. Let I be the identity matrix of the same size as X0 . We define the linear operators Φn and Ψn by Φn (X) := X ⊗ I, and Ψn (X) := X ⊗ X0 , X ∈ Mn (C). The claims (i), (ii), now, follow immediately from the definition of Φn and Ψn and the claim (iii) follows from (2.1). Let us prove (iv). For every matrix X ∈ Mn (C) there exist unitary matrices U, V such that U XV = diag{s1 , s2 , . . . , sn }. Now, it follows from elementary properties of tensors, that Φn (U )Ψn (X)Φn (V ) = (U ⊗ I)(X ⊗ X0 )(V ⊗ I) = (U XV ) ⊗ X0 = Ψn (U XV ) = diag{sj X0 }nj=1 , and so
Ψn (X) SE = Φn (U )Ψn (X)Φn (V ) SE n = diag{sj X0 }nj=1 SE = sj xj . j=1
E
Vol. 57 (2007)
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
251
Now, the claim in (iv) for αE = 0 (respectively, βE = 1) follows from combining the equality above with the first estimate in (3.1) (respectively, the second estimate in (3.1)). The operators Φn , Ψn are very similar to those, constructed in the proof of [1, Theorem 4.1].
4. Commutator estimates From now on let h : R → R be a function with the following properties (a) h(t) ∈ C 1 (R \ {0}); (b) h(t) = h(−t) when t = 0, h(0) ≥ 0; (c) h(·) is increasing function on (0, ∞); (d) h(±∞) = +∞; (e) 0 ≤ h (t)/h(t) ≤ 1 when t ∈ (0, ∞). Proposition 4.1. Let h(t) be a function that satisfies the conditions (a)–(e) above. If f is a function defined as follows |t|(h(log |t|))−1 , if |t| < 1, t = 0, f (t) = (4.1) 0, if t = 0. then f (t) ∈ C 1 (−1, 1) and f (t) ≥ 0 for every t ∈ (0, 1). Proof. The function given in (4.1) is even so it is sufficient to consider only the case t ≥ 0. It follows from the definition of the function f that for every t ∈ (0, 1) function f is continuously differentiable. To calculate the derivative at zero, we use the definition (d) f (t) − f (0) = lim (h(log t))−1 = 0. f (0) = lim t→0 t→0 t−0 In order to verify that f (t) → 0 when t → +0, we note first that
h (log t) −1 f (t) = (h(log t)) 1− , 0 < t < 1. h(log t) Since h(t) ≥ 0 for every t ∈ R, together with the property (e), it now follows that for every t ∈ (0, 1) 0 ≤ f (t) ≤ 2(h(log t))−1 → 0, as t → +0.
Let matrices D, V ∈ Mm (C) and A, B ∈ M2m (C) be defined as follows D = diag{e−1 , e−2 , . . . , e−m }, V = {vjk }m j,k=1 , (k − j)−1 (e−j + e−k )−1 , vjk = 0,
if j = k, , if j = k. (4.2)
252
Potapov and Sukochev
and
A=
0 −V
V , 0
B=
D 0
IEOT
0 . −D
(4.3)
The following proposition provides commutator estimates in the norm of the ideal of compact operators which are very similar to those established in [3] and [9]. Proposition 4.2. For any function f : R → R given by (4.1), there exists an absolute constant K0 such that for every m ≥ 3 and for every scalar 0 < p ≤ 1 the following estimates hold (i) [B, A] S∞ ≤ π, (ii) [f (pB), A] S∞ ≥
m pK0 log . h(m − log p) 2
Proof. The proof of the first claim is based on the norm estimates of the Hilbert matrix, see [3, the proof of Lemma 3.6]. Hence, we need to establish only the second one. Let us first note, since the function f is even, it follows from definition of matrices A, B that
0 f (pD)V − V f (pD) f (pB)A − Af (pB) = , f (pD)V − V f (pD) 0 so
[f (pB), A] S∞ = [f (pD), V ] S∞ . If S = {sjk }m j,k=1 = f (pD)V − V f (pD) ∈ Mm (C), then skj = sjk =
f (pe−j ) − f (pe−k ) ≥ 0, 1 ≤ j, k ≤ m. (e−j + e−k )(k − j)
If 1 ≤ j < k ≤ m, then, since functions h(t) and et are monotone, we have
pe−j pe−k − sjk = (e−j + e−k )−1 (k − j)−1 h(j − log p) h(k − log p) p(e−j − e−k ) −j (2e (k − j))−1 h(k − log p) p(1 − e−1 ) p(1 − e−1 ) ≥ . ≥ 2h(k − log p)(k − j) 2h(m − log p)(k − j) ≥
Now, using m j=1
k−1
1 j=1 j
sjk ≥
≥ log k, we have
k−1 j=1
k−1
sjk ≥
p(1 − e−1 ) p(1 − e−1 ) 1 ≥ log k. 2h(m − log p) j=1 k − j 2h(m − log p)
(4.4)
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
Vol. 57 (2007)
253
Finally, letting x = (m−1/2 , m−1/2 , . . . , m−1/2 ) ∈ Cm , we obtain
S S∞ ≥ Sx, x = ≥ ≥
m m 1 1 p(1 − e−1 ) sjk ≥ log k m m 2 h(m − log p)
−1
j,k=1 m
1 p(1 − e ) m 2 h(m − log p)
k=1
log k
k=[m/2]
1 p(1 − e−1 ) m m log . m 2 h(m − log p) 2 2
Setting K0 = (1 − e−1 )/4, we have
[f (pD), V ] S∞ = S S∞ ≥
m pK0 log . h(m − log p) 2
which, together with (4.4), completes the proof.
Together with (2.2), Proposition 4.2 provides a lower estimate for the operator norm of Schur multiplier associated with the function f , given by (4.1), and diagonal matrix pB given by (4.2) and (4.3) for every scalar 0 < p ≤ 1 and every integer m ≥ 3. Now we extend that lower estimate to a larger class of ideals. Proposition 4.3. Let E be a separable symmetric function space with trivial Boyd indices. For every m ≥ 3, let Am , Bm ∈ M2m (C) be given by (4.2) and (4.3), Φ2m , Ψ2m be the operators from the Proposition 3.2 for the ε = 1/2. There exists an absolute constant K1 such that for every scalar sequence 0 < pm ≤ 1, and for the sequence of the diagonal matrices Wm = Φ2m (pm Bm ) ∈ Mkm (C) the following estimate holds m K1 log , m ≥ 3,
Mf (Wm ) SE →SE ≥ h(m − log pm ) 2 where f : R → R is an arbitrary function given by (4.1). Proof. Letting ∞ Xm = [pm Bm ,
1 Am ], m ≥ 3, pm
we infer from Proposition 4.2 and from (2.2) that for every m ≥ 3 ∞
S∞ ≤ π,
Xm
1 Am ] S∞ pm m K0 log . ≥ h(m − log pm ) 2
∞ ) S∞ = [f (pm Bm ),
Mf (pm Bm )(Xm
254
Potapov and Sukochev
IEOT
It follows from the definition of Schur multiplication and duality that
Mf (pm Bm ) S1 →S1 = Mf (pm Bm ) S∞ →S∞ m K0 log , m ≥ 3. ≥ πh(m − log pm ) 2 1 The last estimate implies that there exists a sequence of Xm ∈ M2m (C) such that 1 m ) S1 K0
Mf (pm Bm )(Xm log , m ≥ 3. ≥ 1
Xm S1 2π h(m − log pm ) 2 ∞ Suppose now, that αE = 0 and set Xm = Ψ2m (Xm ) for every m ≥ 3. It follows from Proposition 3.2 that, for every m ≥ 3, Wm is a finite diagonal self-adjoint matrix such that ∞ )} SE
Mf (Wm )(Xm ) SE
Ψ2m {Mf (pm Bm )(Xm = ∞
Xm SE
Ψ2m (Xm ) SE ∞ m ) S∞ 2 Mf (pm Bm )(Xm 2K0 log . ≥ ≥ ∞ 3 Xm S∞ 3πh(m − log pm ) 2
Mf (Wm ) SE →SE ≥
If we put K1 = 2K0 /(3π), that completes the proof of the case αE = 0. The only 1 ∞ instead of Xm difference in treating the case βE = 1 is that we need to use Xm in the above estimates. The following proposition proves that if a function f : R → R is given by (4.1) and the multipliers Mf (Wm ) are not uniformly bounded in SE , then this function is not commutator bounded in the sense of [6]. Proposition 4.4. Let E be a separable symmetric function space. If f is a C 1 function and Wm ∈ Mkm (C) is a sequence of diagonal matrices (m ≥ 3) such that
Mf (Wm ) SE →SE → ∞,
(4.5)
then there exist self-adjoint operators W , X, acting on 2 , such that [W, X] ∈ SE ,
[f (W ), X] ∈ / SE .
If, in addition, the norms Wm S∞ are uniformly bounded, then W (Dom X) ⊆ Dom X, and if the following series converges
Wm SE , m≥3
then operator W belongs to S
E
and
W SE ≤
m≥3
Wm SE .
Vol. 57 (2007)
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
255
Proof. It follows from (4.5) that there exists a subsequence of positive integers mr (r ≥ 1) and a sequence of self-adjoint matrices Xr(1) ∈ Mkr (C) such that
Mf (Wr )(Xr(1) ) SE ≥ 2r3 Xr(1) SE , r ≥ 1, where we let, for brevity, kr {λj }j=1
kr
= kmr and
Wr
(4.6)
= Wmr ∈ Mkr (C). Let r ≥ 1 be fixed, k
r let be the sequence of eigenvalues of the matrix Wr , and let {Pj }j=1 be the collection of corresponding one-dimensional spectral projections. For λ ∈ R, we set Qλ = Pj .
1≤j≤kr λj =λ
There are only a finite number of non-zero projections among {Qλ }λ∈R , let us denote them as {Qj }sj=1 , 1 ≤ s ≤ kr and the corresponding sequence of eigenvalues as {λj }sj=1 , the scalars λj are mutually distinct. We consider the self-adjoint matrices s ˆr = ˆr . X Qj Xr(1) Qj , and Xr(2) = Xr(1) − X j=1
It follows from (2.1) that (recall that ψf (λ, λ) = 0) ˆ r Pl ˆr ) = ψf (λj , λl )Pj X Mf (Wr )(X 1≤j,l≤kr
=
=
s
t=1
1≤j,l≤kr
s
ψf (λj , λl )Pj Qt Xr(1) Qt Pl
ψf (λt , λt )Qt Xr(1) Qt = 0,
t=1 1≤j,l≤kr λj =λl =λt
and so Mf (Wr )(Xr(2) ) = Mf (Wr )(Xr(1) ).
(4.7)
ˆ r SE ≤ X SE (see [4, Theorem III.4.2]) and, hence Now, noting that X r
Xr(2) SE ≤ 2 Xr(1) SE , Xr(2) , we infer from (4.7) and (4.6) (1)
Mf (Wr )(Xr(2) ) SE ≥ r3 Xr(2) SE . We set Xr(3) =
λjl Pj Xr(2) Pl ,
1≤j,l≤kr
where
0, λjl =
λj = λl , −i , λj = λl . λj − λl
(4.8)
256
Potapov and Sukochev
The matrix Xr(3) is self-adjoint and Pj Xr(2) Pl = i Xr(2) = 1≤j,l≤kr
λjl (λj − λl )Pj Xr(2) Pl
1≤j,l≤kr
=i
IEOT
λjl Pj (Wr Xr(2) − Xr(2) Wr )Pl
1≤j,l≤kr
= i Wr ,
λjl Pj Xr Pl = i[Wr , Xr(3) ]. (2)
1≤j,l≤kr
(4.9) Finally, we let X (3) . Xr = r−2 Xr(2) −1 SE r
(4.10)
For every r ≥ 1 we have constructed so far the finite self-adjoint matrices Wr , Xr such that
[Wr , Xr ] S∞ ≤ [Wr , Xr ] SE
(4.10)
(3) E = r−2 Xr(2) −1 SE [Wr , Xr ] S
(4.9)
(2) E = r−2 Xr(2) −1 SE Xr S =
1 r2 (4.11)
and
[f (Wr ), Xr ] SE
(4.10)
= r−2 Xr(2) −1
[f (Wr ), Xr(3) ] SE SE
(2.2)
= r−2 Xr(2) −1
Mf (Wr )([Wr , Xr(3) ]) SE SE
(4.9)
= r−2 Xr(2) −1
Mf (Wr )(Xr(2) ) SE SE
(4.8)
≥ r Xr(2) −1
Xr(2) SE ≥ r. SE (4.12)
kr
Now, we set H = r≥1 C , X = the definition we have
r≥1
Xr and W =
H = {{ξr }r≥1 : ξr ∈ Ckr ,
r≥1 Wr .
Recall, that by
ξr 2 < ∞},
r≥1
Dom X = {ξ = {ξr }r≥1 ∈ H : X(ξ) = {Xr (ξr )}r≥1 ∈ H}, Dom W = {ξ = {ξr }r≥1 ∈ H : W (ξ) = {Wr (ξr )}r≥1 ∈ H}. W , X are self-adjoint operators, acting on the separable Hilbert space H and
[W, X] SE ≤
r≥1
[Wr , Xr ] SE
(4.11) 1
≤
r≥1
r2
< ∞,
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
Vol. 57 (2007)
[f (W ), X] SE ≥ max [f (Wr ), Xr ] SE
(4.12)
r≥1
If we assume that
257
= ∞.
Wm SE < ∞,
m≥3
then
W SE ≤
Wr SE ≤
r≥1
Wm SE < ∞.
m≥3
If we assume that supm≥1 Wm S∞ ≤ M < ∞, then, by (4.11), for every ξ = [ξr ]r≥1 ∈ Dom X,
12
12
Xr (Wr (ξr )) 2 =
Wr (Xr (ξr )) − [Wr , Xr ](ξr ) 2 r≥1
r≥1
≤M
Xr (ξr ) 2
r≥1
+ sup [Wr , Xr ] S∞ r≥1
12
ξr 2
12
< ∞.
r≥1
Hence W (ξ) ∈ Dom X. The claim is proved.
It follows from Propositions 4.3 and 4.4 that any function f : R → R given log(m/2) by (4.1) with the function h satisfying the condition h(m−log pm ) → ∞, as m → ∞ (here {pm }m≥0 is some scalar sequence satisfying 0 < pm ≤ 1) is not commutator bounded in any separable symmetrically normed ideal with trivial Boyd indices. In other words, there exist self-adjoint operators W , X, acting on a separable Hilbert / SE . We shall now show how space H, such that [W, X] ∈ SE but [f (W ), X] ∈ further adjustments to the choice of the function h and the sequence {pm }m≥0 can be made in order to guarantee that the operator W above belongs to SE . First, we need the following auxiliary results. Proposition 4.5. For every ε > 0 there exists a function χε such that (i) χε ∈ C 1 (R), (ii) χε (t) = 0, if t ≤ 0, (iii) χε (t) = 1, if t ≥ 1, (iv) 0 ≤ χε ≤ 1 + ε. Proof. Let ξε (t) be the continuous function such that ξ (t) = 0, if t ≤ 0 or t ≥ 1, ξ (t) = 1 + , if /(1 + ) ≤ t ≤ 1/(1 + ) and linear elsewhere. It then follows, that the function t
χε (t) = satisfies the assertion.
−∞
ξε (τ ) dτ, t ∈ R,
258
Potapov and Sukochev
IEOT
Proposition 4.6. Let sm , qm (m ≥ 0) be two increasing sequences such that (i) sm → +∞, s0 = 0, (ii) qm → +∞, q0 = 1, log qm − log qm−1 (iii) α = sup < 1. sm − sm−1 m≥1 Then there exists a function h that satisfies the conditions (a)–(e) (preceding Proposition 4.1) and such that h(sm ) = qm for every m ≥ 0. Proof. Let ε = 1/α − 1, and χε be the function from Proposition 4.5. For every t ≥ 0 we define H(t) =
χε
m≥1
t−s m−1 (log qm − log qm−1 ). sm − sm−1
(4.13)
We have that x ≥ sm−1 (respectively, x < sm ) if and only if x − sm−1 x − sm−1 ≥ 0 respectively, <1 . sm − sm−1 sm − sm−1 Now, it follows from above that for every fixed t ≥ 0 the sum (4.13) is finite, H(s0 ) = H(0) = 0 = log q0 , and for every k ≥ 1 H(sk ) =
χε
m≥1
=
k
s −s k m−1 (log qm − log qm−1 ) sm − sm−1
(log qm − log qm−1 ) = log qk .
m=1
We set h(t) := exp(H(t)) for every t ≥ 0 and h(t) = h(−t) for every t < 0, then h(sm ) = qm for every m ≥ 0. Let us check the conditions (a)–(e). (a) The function H is a C 1 -function as a finite sum of C 1 -functions, so h is a C 1 -function for every t = 0; (b) this item holds by the definition of h(t), and h(0) = exp(H(0)) = 1; (c) the function H(t) is increasing, for every t ≥ 0, as it is the sum of increasing functions, so the function h is increasing also; (d) since the sequence h(sm ) = qm tends to infinity and since h(·) is an increasing even function, we have h(±∞) = +∞;
Vol. 57 (2007)
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
259
(e) for every t ≥ 0 there exists an integer k ≥ 1 such that sk−1 ≤ t < sk , thus it follows from Proposition 4.5, that t − sm−1 log qm − log qm−1 H (t) = χε , sm − sm−1 sm − sm−1 m≥1 t−s log q − log q k−1 k k−1 = χε sk − sk−1 sk − sk−1 ≤ α(1 + ε) = 1, and so 0 ≤ H (t) =
h (t) ≤ 1. h(t)
Now, we are in a position to prove our main result. Theorem 4.7. For every separable symmetric function space E with trivial Boyd indices, there exists a C 1 -function fE , self-adjoint operators W , X, acting on a separable Hilbert space H such that / SE . W ∈ SE , [W, X] ∈ SE , W (Dom X) ⊆ Dom X, [fE (W ), X] ∈ Proof. Let m ≥ 0, qm := (log(m + e))1/2 , Bm be the diagonal matrices, given by (4.2) and (4.3), Φ2m , Ψ2m be the operators from Proposition 3.2 for ε = 1/2. Let {pm }m≥0 be a sequence that satisfies the following five conditions (i) pm is decreasing to zero; (ii) 0 < pm ≤ 1; (iii) p0 = 1; 1 ≥ m2 Φ2m (Bm ) SE , m ≥ 1; (iv) pm 1 q2 1 (v) ≥ 2m · , m ≥ 1. pm eqm−1 pm−1 We construct such a sequence by induction. If the numbers p0 , p1 , . . . , pm−1 satisfy the conditions above, then pm can be taken to be any positive number for which 2 1 1 qm 1 2 ≥ max 1, , m Φ2m (Bm ) SE , 2 · . pm pm−1 eqm−1 pm−1 It follows from (v) above, that q2 epm−1 ≥ 2m , pm qm−1 and, taking logarithms, 1 1 − log ≥ 2(log qm − log qm−1 ). pm pm−1 = m − log pm , we have log qm − log qm−1 1 0≤ ≤ , m ≥ 0. sm − sm−1 2 1 + log
Putting sm
260
Potapov and Sukochev
IEOT
Thus, we have verified that the sequences {qm }m≥0 and {sm }m≥0 satisfy the conditions of Proposition 4.6, and so there exists a function hE (t) such that hE (m − log pm ) = hE (sm ) = qm = (log(e + m))1/2 . If fE is the function, given by (4.1), with the above choice of hE , Wm:= Φ2m (pm Bm ) ∈ Mkm (C), where Bm given by (4.2) and (4.3), is the finite diagonal matrix then it follows from Proposition 4.3 m log (m/2) K1 log = K1 → ∞.
Mf (Wm ) SE →SE ≥ h(m − log pm ) 2 (log(m + e))1/2 On the other hand, by our choice of pm (see ((iv)) above) we have that 1
Wm S∞ ≤ Wm SE = pm Φ2m (Bm ) SE ≤ 2 , m ≥ 3. m Now the assertion of Theorem 4.7 follows from Proposition 4.4.
5. Domains of generators of automorphism flows Let E be a separable symmetric function space with trivial Boyd indices, let SE be the corresponding symmetrically normed ideal and let X be a self-adjoint operator (may be unbounded), acting on a separable Hilbert space H. We consider a group α = {αt }t∈R of automorphisms on SE given by α(t)T = eitX T e−itX , T ∈ SE , t ∈ R. It follows from separability of SE that α is a C0 -group, [2, Corollary 4.3]. The infinitesimal generator δ of α(t) is defined by α(t)T − T E Dom δ := T ∈ S : there exists · SE − lim , t→0 t α(t)T − T for every T ∈ Dom δ. δ(T ) := · SE − lim t→0 t δ is a closed densely defined symmetric derivation on SE , i.e. densely defined closed linear operator such that δ(T ∗ ) = δ(T )∗ and δ(T S) = δ(T ) S + T δ(S), for all T, S ∈ Dom δ, see e.g. [2, Proposition 4.5]. It is proved in [3, Proposition 2.2], that Dom δ = {T ∈ SE : T (Dom X) ⊆ Dom X, [T, X] ∈ SE } and δ(T ) = i[T, X], T ∈ Dom δ. Now, Theorem 4.7 yields Corollary 5.1. For every separable symmetric function space E with trivial Boyd indices, there exists a C 1 -function fE , a self-adjoint operator W ∈ SE and closed densely defined symmetric derivation δ on SE , such that W ∈ Dom δ but / Dom δ. fE (W ) ∈
Vol. 57 (2007)
Non- (Quantum) Differentiable C 1 -Functions
261
References [1] J. Arazy, Some remarks on interpolation theorems and the boundness of the triangular projection in unitary matrix spaces, Integral Equations Operator Theory 1 (1978), no. 4, 453–495. [2] B. de Pagter and F. A. Sukochev, Commutator estimates and R-flows in noncommutative operator spaces, Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc. (to appear). [3] B. de Pagter, F. A. Sukochev, and W. van Ackooij, Domains of infinitesimal generators of automorphism flows, J. Funct. Anal. 218 (2005), no. 2, 409–424. [4] I. C. Gohberg and M. G. Kre˘ın, Vvedenie v teoriyu lineinykh nesamosopryazhennykh operatorov v gilbertovom prostranstve, Izdat. “Nauka”, Moscow, 1965. [5] E. Kissin and V. S. Shulman, Classes of operator-smooth functions. II. Operatordifferentiable functions, Integral Equations Operator Theory 49 (2004), no. 2, 165– 210. , Classes of operator-smooth functions. I. Operator-Lipschitz functions, Proc. [6] Edinb. Math. Soc. (2) 48 (2005), no. 1, 151–173. , Classes of operator-smooth functions. III. Stable functions and Fuglede [7] ideals, Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc. (2) 48 (2005), no. 1, 175–197. [8] J. Lindenstrauss and L. Tzafriri, Classical Banach spaces. II, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete [Results in Mathematics and Related Areas], vol. 97, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1979. [9] A. McIntosh, Functions and derivations of C ∗ -algebras, J. Funct. Anal. 30 (1978), no. 2, 264–275. [10] D. S. Potapov and F. A. Sukochev, Lipschitz and commutator estimates in symmetric operator spaces, to appear in J. Operator Theory. Denis Potapov and Fyodor Sukochev School of Informatics and Engineering Faculty of Science and Engineering Flinders University of SA Bedford Park, 5042 Adelaide, SA Australia e-mail: [email protected] [email protected] Submitted: February 6, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 263–281 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020263-19, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1456-y
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
The Fredholm Index of Locally Compact Band-dominated Operators on Lp(R) Vladimir S. Rabinovich and Steffen Roch Abstract. We establish a necessary and sufficient criterion for the Fredholmness of a general locally compact band-dominated operator A on Lp (R) and solve the long-standing problem of computing its Fredholm index in terms of the limit operators of A. The results are applied to operators of convolution type with almost periodic symbol. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47A53; Secondary 47G10, 45E10. Keywords. Fredholm index, limit operators, band-dominated operators, Wiener-Hopf operators.
1. Introduction Throughout this paper, let 1 < p < ∞, and for each Banach space X, let L(X) stand for the Banach algebra of all bounded linear operators on X, K(X) for the closed ideal of the compact operators, BX for the closed unit ball of X, and X ∗ for the Banach dual space of X. For each function ϕ ∈ BU C, the algebra of the bounded and uniformly continuous functions on the real line R, and for each t > 0, set ϕt (x) := ϕ(tx) and write ϕI for the operator on Lp (R) of multiplication by ϕ. An operator A ∈ L(Lp (R)) is called band-dominated if lim Aϕt I − ϕt A = 0
t→0
for each function ϕ ∈ BU C. The set Bp of all band-dominated operators forms a closed subalgebra of L(Lp (R)). In this paper we will exclusively deal with banddominated operators of the form I + K where I is the identity operator and K is locally compact (which means that ϕA and AϕI are compact for each function ϕ ∈ BU C with bounded support). We write Lp for the set of all locally compact band-dominated operators on Lp (R).
264
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
The announced Fredholm criterion and the index formula will be formulated in terms of limit operators. To introduce this notion, we will need the shift operators Uk : Lp (R) → Lp (R), (Uk f )(x) := f (x − k) where k ∈ Z. Let h : N → Z be a sequence which tends to infinity in the sense that |h(n)| → ∞ as n → ∞. An operator Ah ∈ L(Lp (R)) is called a limit operator of A ∈ L(Lp (R)) with respect to the sequence h if lim (U−h(m) AUh(m) − Ah )ϕI = 0
m→∞
and lim ϕ(U−h(m) AUh(m) − Ah ) = 0
m→∞
for each function ϕ ∈ BU C with bounded support. If a limit operator Ah of A with respect to h exists, then it is uniquely determined. The set of all limit operators of a given operator A ∈ L(Lp (R)) is called the operator spectrum of A and denoted by σop (A). Clearly, the existence of Ah implies that Ah exists and that Ah = Ah for each subsequence h of h. Since each sequence h with |h(n)| → ∞ contains a subsequence h converging to +∞ or −∞, it follows that the operator spectrum of A splits into two components σ+ (A) ∪ σ− (A) which collect the limit operators of A with respect to sequences h tending to +∞ and to −∞, respectively. An operator A ∈ L(Lp (R)) is said to be rich or to possess a rich operator spectrum if every sequence h tending to infinity possesses a subsequence g for which the limit operator Ag exists. The sets of all rich operators in Bp and Lp will be denoted by Bp$ and L$p . Let χ+ and χ− stand for the characteristic functions of the sets R+ and R− of the non-negative and negative real numbers, respectively. The operators χ+ Kχ− I and χ− Kχ+ I are compact for each operator K ∈ Lp . Indeed, let ε > 0 be arbitrarily given. Since K is band-dominated, there is a continuous function f which is 1 on [0, ∞) and 0 on (−∞, −nε ] with sufficiently large nε such that f K − Kf I < ε. Thus, χ+ Kχ− I − χ+ Kf χ− I = χ+ (f K − Kf )χ− I < ε. The operator χ+ Kf χ− I is compact since f χ− has a bounded support and K is locally compact. Since further ε can be chosen arbitrarily small, the compactness of χ+ Kχ− I follows. The compactness of χ− Kχ+ I can be checked analogously. This simple observation implies that, for a Fredholm operator of the form A = I + K with K ∈ Lp , the operators χ+ Aχ+ I and χ− Aχ− I, considered as acting on Lp (R+ ) and Lp (R− ), are Fredholm operators again. We call ind+ A := ind (χ+ Aχ+ I) and ind− A := ind (χ− Aχ− I) the plus- and the minus-index of A. Clearly, ind A = ind+ A + ind− A.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
265
Recall in this connection that a bounded linear operator A on a Banach space X is said to be Fredholm if its kernel ker A and its cokernel coker A := X/im A are linear spaces of finite dimension, and that in this case the integer ind A := dim ker A − dim coker A is called the Fredholm index of A. Here is the main result of the present paper. Theorem 1. Let A = I + K with K ∈ L$p . (a) The operator A is Fredholm on Lp (R) if and only if all limit operators of A are invertible and if the norms of their inverses are uniformly bounded. (b) If A is Fredholm, then for arbitrary operators B+ ∈ σ+ (A) and B− ∈ σ− (A), ind+ B+ = ind+ A
and
ind− B− = ind− A
(1)
and, consequently, ind A = ind+ B+ + ind− B− .
(2)
This result has a series of predecessors. One of the simplest classes of banddominated and locally compact operators on Lp (R) is constituted by the operators of convolution by L1 (R)-functions and by the restrictions of these operators to the half line, the classical Wiener-Hopf operators. The theory of the convolution type operators on the half line originates from the fundamental papers by Krein and Gohberg/Krein [8, 5] where the Fredholm theory for these operators is established and an index formula is derived. See also the monograph [4] by Gohberg/Feldman for an axiomatic approach to this circle of questions. For convolution type operators with variable coefficients which stabilize at infinite, a Fredholm criterion and an index formula have been obtained by Karapetiants/Samko in [6]; see also their monograph [7]. In [13, 14], there is developed the limit operator approach to study Fredholm properties of general band-dominated operators on spaces lp of vector-valued sequences. In [11] we demonstrated that this approach also applies to operators of convolution type acting on Lp spaces if a suitable discretization reducing Lp - to lp -spaces is performed. (To be precisely: If the sequences in lp take their values in an infinite dimensional Banach space, then we derived in [14] a criterion for a generalized form of Fredholmness, called P-Fredholmness; see below. But the results of [11] refer to common Fredholmness.) The long standing problem to determine the Fredholm index of a band-dominated operator in terms of its limit operators, too, has been finally solved in [12] for band-dominated operators on the space l2 with scalar-valued sequences. All mentioned results can be also found in the monograph [15]. The index formula has been generalized to lp -spaces in [16]. In the present paper we will undertake a further generalization to banddominated operators with compact entries acting on lp -spaces of vector-valued functions. Thereby these results will get the right form to become applicable to locally compact band-dominated operators on Lp -spaces (and thus, to prove assertion (b) of the theorem).
266
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
The paper is organized as follows. We start with recalling some basic facts on sequences of compact operators. For the reader’s convenience, the proofs are included. The main work will be done in Section 3 where we will derive the Fredholm criterion and the index formula for band-dominated operators on lp with compact entries. In Section 4, these results will be applied to locally compact band-dominated operators on Lp which mainly requires to construct a suitable discretization mapping. Some applications will be discussed in the final section. This work was supported by the CONACYT project 43432. The authors are grateful for this support.
2. Sequences of compact operators Let X be a complex Banach space which enjoys the following symmetric approximation property (sap): There is a sequence (ΠN )N ≥1 of projections (= idempotents) ΠN ∈ L(X) of finite rank such that ΠN → I and Π∗N → I ∗ strongly as N → ∞. Evident examples of Banach spaces with sap are the separable Hilbert spaces, the spaces lp (ZK ) and the spaces Lp [a, b]. It is also clear that if X is a reflexive Banach space with sap, then X ∗ has sap, too, and the corresponding projections can be chosen as Π∗N . Definition 2. A sequence (Kn ) of operators in L(X) is said to be (a) relatively compact if the norm closure of {Kn : n ∈ N} is compact in L(X); (b) collectively compact if the set ∪n∈N Kn BX is relatively compact in X; (c) uniformly left (right, two-sided) approximable if, for each ε > 0 there is an N0 such that, for each n ∈ N and each N ≥ N0 , Kn − ΠN Kn < ε
(Kn − Kn ΠN < ε,
Kn − ΠN Kn ΠN < ε).
Note that the uniform left approximability of (Kn ) is equivalent to lim sup Kn − ΠN Kn = 0.
N →∞ n∈N
Proposition 3. Let X be a Banach space with sap. The following conditions are equivalent for a sequence (Kn ) of compact operators on X : (a) (Kn ) is relatively compact; (b) (Kn ) and (Kn∗ ) are collectively compact; (c) (Kn ) is uniformly left and uniformly right approximable; (d) (Kn ) is uniformly two-sided approximable. Proof. (a) ⇒ (b): Let (xn ) be a sequence in ∪n Kn BX . For each n ∈ N, choose r(n) ∈ N and yn ∈ BX such that xn = Kr(n) yn . By hypothesis (a), the sequence (Kr(n) ) has a convergent subsequence (Kr(nk ) ). Let K denote the limit of that subsequence. Then xnk − Kynk = Kr(nk ) ynk − Kynk ≤ Kr(nk ) − K → 0.
(3)
Since K is compact and ynk ≤ 1, the sequence (Kr(nk ) ) has a convergent subsequence. From (3) we conclude that then the sequence (xnk ) (hence, the sequence
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
267
(xn )) has a convergent subsequence, too. This yields the collective compactness of the sequence (Kn ). Since (Kn∗ ) is relatively compact whenever (Kn ) is relatively compact, the collective compactness of (Kn∗ ) follows in the same way. (b) ⇒ (c): We will show that the collective compactness of (Kn ) implies the uniform left approximability of that sequence. We will not make use of the strong convergence of ΠN to I ∗ in this part of the proof. So is becomes evident that then also the collective compactness of (Kn∗ ) implies the uniform left approximability of (Kn∗ ) with respect to the sequence (Π∗N ) which is equivalent to the uniform right approximability of (Kn ). Contrary to what we want to show, assume that (Kn ) is not uniformly left approximable. Then there are an ε > 0, a monotonically increasing sequence (N (r))r≥1 and operators Kn(r) ∈ {Kn : n ∈ N} such that (I − ΠN (r) )Kn(r) ≥ ε for all r ∈ N. Choose xn(r) ∈ BX such that (I − ΠN (r) )Kn(r) xn(r) ≥ ε/2 for all r ∈ N.
(4)
By hypothesis (b), the sequence (Kn(r) xn(r) ) has a convergent subsequence. Let x0 denote its limit. We conclude from (4) that (I − ΠN (r) )x0 ≥ ε/4 for all sufficiently large r. Letting r go to infinity, we arrive at a contradiction. (c) ⇒ (d): This implication follows immediately from Kn − ΠN Kn ΠN ≤ ≤
Kn − ΠN Kn + ΠN Kn − ΠN Kn ΠN Kn − ΠN Kn + ΠN Kn − Kn ΠN
and from the uniform boundedness of the projections ΠN due to the BanachSteinhaus theorem. (d) ⇒ (a): We consider a subsequence of (Kn ) which we write as (Kn )n∈N0 with an infinite subset N0 of N. Since the projections ΠN have finite rank, there are an infinite subset N1 of N0 such that the sequence (Π1 Kn Π1 )n∈N1 converges, an infinite subset N2 of N1 such that the sequence (Π2 Kn Π2 )n∈N2 converges, etc. Thus, for each N ≥ 1, one finds an infinite subset NN of NN −1 such that the sequence (ΠN Kn ΠN )n∈NN converges. Let k(n) denote the nth number in NN (ordered with ˆ n )n≥1 is a subsequence ˆ n := Kk(n) . Clearly, (K respect to the relation <) and set K of each of the sequences (Kn )n∈NN up to finitely many entries. Thus, for each ˆ n ΠN )n≥1 converges. Now we have N ∈ N, the sequence (ΠN K ˆ n ΠN ) − (K ˆ m ΠN ) + ΠN (K ˆn − K ˆ m = (K ˆ n − ΠN K ˆ m − ΠN K ˆn − K ˆ m )ΠN . K Let ε > 0. By hypothesis (d), there is an N such that ˆ n ΠN < ε/3 ˆ n − ΠN K K for all n ∈ N. Fix N , and choose n0 such that ˆn − K ˆ m )ΠN < ε/3 ΠN (K
268
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
ˆ n ΠN )n≥1 converges). for all m, n ≥ n0 (which can be done since the sequence (ΠN K ˆ ˆ Hence, Kn − Km < ε for all m, n ≥ n0 . This implies the convergence of the ˆ n ) and, thus, the relative compactness of (Kn ). sequence (K
3. The Fredholm index of discrete band-dominated operators with compact entries Let X be a complex Banach space with sap. By E := lp (Z, X) we denote the Banach space of all sequences x : Z → X with xn pX < ∞. xpE := n∈Z
For k ∈ Z, let Vk : l (Z, X) → l (Z, X) stand for the shift operator (Vk x)n := xn−k . In what follows, we will have to consider shift operators on different spaces lp (Z, X). In order to indicate the underlying space we will sometimes also write Vk, X for the shift operator Vk on lp (Z, X). Further, for each non-negative integer n, let the projection operators Pn : lp (Z, X) → lp (Z, X) be defined by xk if |k| ≤ n (Pn x)k := 0 if |k| > n, p
p
and set Qn := I − Pn and P := (Pn )n≥0 . Sometimes we will also write Pn, X in place of Pn in order to indicate the underlying space. Each operator A ∈ L(E) can be represented in the obvious way by a twosided infinite matrix with entries in L(X) (in analogy with the representation of an operator on lp (Z) := lp (Z, C) with respect to the standard basis). The operator A ∈ L(E) is called a band operator if its matrix representation (Aij ) is a band matrix, i.e., if there is a k ∈ N such that Aij = 0 if |i − j| ≥ k. The closure of the set of all band operators on E is a closed subalgebra of L(E) which we denote by AE . The elements of AE will be called band-dominated operators. By CE we denote the closed ideal of AE which consists of all band-dominated operators which have only compact entries in their matrix representation. Following the terminology introduced in [15], an operator K ∈ L(E) is called P-compact if lim KQn = lim Qn K = 0. n→∞
n→∞
We denote the set of all P-compact operators by K(E, P), and we write L(E, P) for the set of all operators A ∈ L(E) for which both AK and KA are P-compact whenever K is P-compact. Then L(E, P) is a closed subalgebra of L(E) which contains K(E, P) as a closed ideal. Definition 4. An operator A ∈ L(E, P) is called P-Fredholm if the coset A + K(E, P) is invertible in the quotient algebra L(E, P)/K(E, P), i.e., if there exist an operator B ∈ L(E, P) and operators K, L ∈ K(E, P) such that BA = I + K and AB = I + L.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
269
This definition is equivalent to the following one: An operator A ∈ L(E, P) is P-Fredholm if and only if there exist an m ∈ N and operators Lm , Rm ∈ L(E, P) such that Lm AQm = Qm ARm = Qm . Thus, P-Fredholmness is often referred to as local invertibility at infinity. If X has finite dimension, then the notions P-Fredholmness and Fredholmness are synonymous. All band-dominated operators belong to L(E, P). This can be easily checked for the two basic types of band-dominated operators: the shift operators and the operators of multiplication by a function in l∞ (Z, L(X)), and it follows for general band-dominated operators since L(E, P) is a closed algebra. Hence, it makes sense to speak about their P-Fredholmness. A criterion for the P-Fredholmness of a band-dominated operator A can be given in terms of the limit operators of A. These are, in analogy with the notions from Section 1, defined as follows. Let A ∈ L(E), and let h : N → Z be a sequence which tends to infinity. An operator Ah ∈ L(E) is called a limit operator of A with respect to the sequence h if lim Pk (V−h(n) AVh(n) − Ah ) = lim (V−h(n) AVh(n) − Ah )Pk = 0
n→∞
n→∞
for every k ∈ N. The set of all limit operators of A will be denoted by σop (A) and is called the operator spectrum of A again. An operator A ∈ L(E) is said to be rich or to possess a rich operator spectrum if each sequence h which tends to infinity possesses a subsequence g for which the limit operator Ag exists. We refer to the $ for rich operators in AE as rich band-dominated operators and write A$E and CE the Banach algebra of the rich band-dominated operators and for its closed ideal consisting of the rich operators in CE . The following is the main result on P-Fredholmness of rich band-dominated operators. Its proof is in [15], Theorem 2.2.1. Theorem 5. An operator A ∈ A$E is P-Fredholm if and only if each of its limit operators is invertible and if the norms of their inverses are uniformly bounded, i.e., sup{(Ah )−1 : Ah ∈ σop (A)} < ∞. In case X = C, P-Fredholmness coincides with common Fredholmness. In this case one can also express the Fredholm index of a Fredholm band-dominated operator in terms of the (local) indices of its limit operators. To cite these results from [12, 16], let P : lp (Z, X) → lp (Z, X) refer to the projection operator xk if k ≥ 0 (P x)k := 0 if k < 0, and set Q := I − P . If necessary, we will write also PX in place of P . Then, for each band-dominated operator on lp (Z, C), the operators P AQ and QAP are compact. This is obvious for band operators in which case P AQ and QAP are of finite rank, and it follows for general band-dominated operators by an obvious approximation argument. Consequently, the operators A − (P AP + Q)(P + QAQ)
270
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
and A− (P + QAQ)(P AP + Q) are compact, which implies that a band-dominated operator on lp (Z, C) is Fredholm if and only if both operators P AP + Q and P + QAQ are Fredholm and that ind A = ind (P AP + Q) + ind (P + QAQ). In this case we call ind+ A := ind (P AP + Q) and ind− A := ind (P + QAQ) the plus- and the minus-index of A. Finally, let σop (A) = σ+ (A)∪σ− (A), the latter components collecting the limit operators of A with respect to sequences h tending to +∞ and to −∞, respectively, and note that in case X = C all band-dominated operators are rich. Theorem 6. Let X = C, and let A be a Fredholm band-dominated operator on lp (Z). Then, for arbitrary operators B+ ∈ σ+ (A) and B− ∈ σ− (A), ind+ B+ = ind+ A
and
ind− B− = ind− A
(5)
and, consequently, ind A = ind+ B+ + ind− B− .
(6)
In particular, all operators in σ+ (A) have the same plus-index, and all operators in σ− (A) have the same minus-index. It is the goal of the present section to generalize the assertion of Theorem 6 to operators acting on E = lp (Z, X) with a general Banach space X with sap $ . A first observation is that for these which are of the form I + K with K ∈ CE operators P-Fredholmness and common Fredholmness coincide. Proposition 7. An operator in I + CE is Fredholm if and only if it is P-Fredholm. Proof. We claim that CE ∩ K(E, P) = K(E). (7) The inclusion K(E) ⊆ CE is evident, and the inclusion K(E) ⊆ K(E, P) holds since the projections Pn and Pn∗ converge strongly to the identity operators on E and E ∗ , respectively. Thus, K(E) ⊆ CE ∩ K(E, P). For the reverse inclusion, let K ∈ CE ∩ K(E, P). Since K ∈ CE , one has Pn K ∈ K(E) for every n, and since K ∈ K(E, P), one has K − Pn K → 0. Thus, K ∈ K(E), which verifies (7). Since K(E) ⊆ K(E, P) by (7), every Fredholm operator in L(E, P) is PFredholm. For the reverse implication, let A := I + K with K ∈ CE be a PFredholm operator. Then there are operators B ∈ L(E, P) and L ∈ K(E, P) such that BA = I − L. Set R := I − KB. Then RA − I = A − I − KBA = K − KBA = K(I − BA) = KL. Since KL ∈ CE ∩K(E, P) is compact by (7), the operator R is a left Fredholm regularizer for A. Similarly one checks that A possesses a right Fredholm regularizer. Thus, the operator A is Fredholm. Combining Proposition 7 with Theorem 5 one gets the following.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
271
$ Corollary 8. Let A := I + K with K ∈ CE . Then the operator A is Fredholm if and only if each of its limit operators is invertible and if the norms of their inverses are uniformly bounded.
We will make use of the following lemma several times. $ Lemma 9. Every band-dominated operator in CE (resp. in CE ) is the norm limit $ of a sequence of band operators CE (resp. in CE ).
This can be proved in exactly the way as we derived Theorem 2.1.18 in [15] which states that every rich band-dominated operators is the norm limit of a sequence of rich band operators. As a first consequence of the CE -version of Lemma 9 we conclude that P AQ and QAP are compact operators for each operator A ∈ I + CE . Indeed, this is obvious for A being a band operators in which case P AQ and QAP have only a finite number of non-vanishing entries, and these are compact. The case of general A follows by an obvious approximation argument. Consequently, the operators A − (P AP + Q)(P + QAQ) and A − (P + QAQ)(P AP + Q) are compact, which implies that an operator A ∈ I + CE is Fredholm if and only if both operators P AP + Q and P + QAQ are Fredholm. In this case, the integers ind+ A := ind (P AP + Q) and ind− A := ind (P + QAQ) are called the plus- and the minus-index of A. Clearly, ind A = ind+ A + ind− A.
(8)
Finally, let σop (A) = σ+ (A) ∪ σ− (A) in analogy with the case X = C. $ . Here is the announced result for the indices of Fredholm operators in I + CE $ Theorem 10. Let A ∈ I + CE be a Fredholm operator. Then, for arbitrary operators B+ ∈ σ+ (A) and B− ∈ σ− (A),
ind+ B+ = ind+ A
and
ind− B− = ind− A
(9)
and, consequently, ind A = ind+ B+ + ind− B− .
(10)
The remainder of this section is devoted to the proof of Theorem 10. We will verify this theorem by reducing its assertion step by step until we will arrive at operators on lp (Z, C) (with scalar entries) for which the result is known (Theorem 6). The first step of the reduction procedure is based on the following observation. Proposition 11. Let F be a dense subset of the set of all Fredholm operators in $ . If the assertion of Theorem 10 holds for all operators in F , then it holds I + CE $ for all Fredholm operators in I + CE . $ , and let B ∈ σ+ (A). We will show Proof. Let A be a Fredholm operator in I + CE that (11) ind+ B = ind+ A,
272
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
which settles the plus-assertion of (9). The minus-assertion follows similarly, and (9) implies (10) via (8). To prove (11), choose a sequence (An ) of operators in F which converges to A in the operator norm, and let h be a sequence tending to +∞ such that B = Ah . Employing Cantor’s diagonal method, we construct a subsequence g of h for which all limit operators (An )g exist. For the details of this construction, consult the proof of Proposition 1.2.6 in [15]. From Proposition 1.2.2 (e) in [15] we conclude that B − (An )g = Ag − (An )g → 0. Now one has ind+ (An )g = ind+ An
for all n ∈ N
and this implies (11) by letting n go to infinity due to the continuity of the index. $ -version of Lemma 9 allows one Our choice of the set F is as follows. The CE $ by a to approximate each band-dominated operator A = I + K with K ∈ CE $ sequence of band operators An := I + Kn with Kn ∈ CE . Each band operator Kn can be written as a sum Kn(k) Vk (12) Kn = k∈Z (k)
with only finitely many non-vanishing items. The coefficients Kn in (12) are operators of multiplication by sequences of compact operators on X, and these multiplication operators are rich whenever Kn is rich. From Theorem 2.1.16 in [15] we know that a multiplication operator is rich if and only if the set of its entries is relatively compact in L(X). So we conclude from the equivalence between (a) (k) and (d) in Proposition 3 that each coefficient Kn in (12) can be approximated as (k) closely as desired by a sequence (Kn, N )N ∈N of multiplication operators the entries of which map im ΠN into itself and act on im (IX − ΠN ) as the zero operator. Thus, one can approximate the operator A = I + K as closely as desired by band operators An, N = I + Kn, N where the entries of Kn, N map im ΠN into itself and act as the zero operator on im (IX − ΠN ). We denote the set of all operators Kn, N of this form by CE, N . Note that the operators in CE, N are automatically rich. Further, if A = I + K is a Fredholm operator, then the operators An, N = I + Kn, N are Fredholm for all sufficiently large n and N . Thus, we can choose F as the set of all Fredholm operators I + Kn, N with Kn, N ∈ CE, N . By Proposition 11, it remains to prove Theorem 10 for these operators. We agree upon writing XN in place of im ΠN if we want to consider im ΠN as a Banach space in its own right, not as a subspace of X. Further we introduce the mappings R : lp (Z, X) → lp (Z, XN ),
(xn ) → (ΠN xn )
where ΠN xn is considered as an element of XN , and L : lp (Z, XN ) → lp (Z, X),
(xn ) → (xn )
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
273
where the xn on the right-hand side are considered as elements of X. Clearly, RL is the identity operator on lp (Z, XN ), whereas LR is the projection Π : lp (Z, X) → lp (Z, X),
(xn ) → (ΠN xn ),
now with the ΠN xn being considered as elements of X. We are going to show that the operators A = I + Kn, N as well as their limit operators behave well under the mapping A → RAL. Proposition 12. Let A = I + Kn, N with Kn, N ∈ CE, N . (a) If A is a Fredholm operator on lp (Z, X), then RAL is a Fredholm operator on lp (Z, XN ), and the Fredholm indices of A and RAL coincide. (b) If the limit operator of A with respect to a sequence h : N → Z exists, then the limit operator of RAL with respect to h exists, too, and (RAL)h = RAh L. Proof. Since A is Fredholm, there are operators B, T on lp (Z, X) with T compact such that BA = I + T. (13) For x ∈ ker A one gets x + T x = 0, whence x ∈ im T . Hence, dim ker A ≤ rank T for each pair (B, T ) such that (13) holds. One can choose the pair (B, T ) even in such a way that dim ker A = rank T . For write X as a direct sum ker A ⊕ X0 and let Pker A refer to the projection from X onto ker A parallel to X0 . Then A(I − Pker A ) : im (I − Pker A ) → im A is an invertible operator. Let B denote its inverse. Then BA(I −Pker A ) = I −Pker A and BA = I − Pker A + BAPker A = I − (I − BA)Pker A . Clearly, rank (I − BA)Pker A ≤ dim ker A. Thus, one can indeed assume that (13) holds with dim ker A = rank T . From (13) we get RBAL = RL + RT L = I + RT L, and since L = ΠL and A commutes with Π, we obtain RBL RAL = I + RT L.
(14)
In the same way, AB = I +T with T compact implies that RAL RBL = I +RT L with RT L compact. Hence, RAL is Fredholm, and (14) moreover shows that dim ker RAL ≤ rank RT L ≤ rank T = dim ker A. For the reverse estimate, let B, T be operators on lp (Z, XN ) with BRAL = I + T and dim ker RAL = rank T . Then LBRALR = LR + LT R, whence (LBRΠ + I − Π)A = I + LT R (take into account that AΠ = ΠA = A − (I − Π)). This identity shows that dim ker A ≤ rank LT R ≤ rank T = dim ker RAL,
274
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
whence finally dim ker A = dim ker RAL. In the same way one gets dim ker A∗ = dim ker (RAL)∗ . Since dim ker A∗ = dim im A for each Fredholm operator A, we arrive at assertion (a). (b) Let Ah be a limit operator of A. Then, by definition, (Ah − V−h(n), X AVh(n), X )Pk, X → 0 for each k ∈ N. Thus, R(Ah − V−h(n), X AVh(n), X )Pk, X L → 0 for each k ∈ N. Since the projection Π commutes with each of the operators Pk, X , Vh(n), X and A, and since RVh(n), X L = Vh(n), XN and RPk, X L = Pk, XN , one concludes that (RAh L − V−h(n), XN RAL Vh(n), XN )Pk, XN → 0 for each k ∈ N. Similarly one obtains Pk, XN (RAh L − V−h(n), XN RAL Vh(n), XN ) → 0 for each k ∈ N. Thus, RAh L is the limit operator of RAL with respect to the sequence h.
Since the projections P and Π also commute, it is an immediate consequence of the preceding proposition and its proof that ind+ A = ind+ RAL and ind+ Ah = ind+ RAh L = ind+ (RAL)h for each limit operator Ah ∈ σ+ (A). Thus, the assertion of Theorem 6 will follow once we have proved this theorem for band-dominated operators on lp (Z, XN ) in place of lp (Z, X). Proposition 13. The assertion of Theorem 10 holds for all Fredholm band-dominated operators on lp (Z, XN ) (with fixed N ∈ N). Proof. Let d < ∞ be the dimension of XN , and let e1 , . . . , ed be a basis of XN . Then there are positive constants C1 , C2 such that C1 (x1 , . . . , xd )lp ≤ x1 e1 + . . . + xd ed XN ≤ C2 (x1 , . . . , xd )lp
(15)
for each vector (x1 , . . . , xd ) ∈ Cd . Define J : lp (Z, XN ) → lp (Z, C) by (Jx)nd+r := (xn )r ,
0≤ r ≤ d−1
where (xn )r refers to the rth coordinate of the nth entry xn ∈ XN of the sequence x. It follows from (15) that C1 Jxlp (Z, C) ≤ xlp (Z, XN ) ≤ C2 Jxlp (Z, C) , i.e., J is a topological isomorphism from lp (Z, XN ) onto lp (Z, C). The definition of J implies that if A is a Fredholm band operator on lp (Z, XN ), then JAJ −1
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
275
is a Fredholm band operator on lp (Z, C), and conversely. Moreover, ind A = ind JAJ −1 in this case. This identity holds for the plus- and minus-indices as well, since JPXN J −1 = PC . Moreover, one has JVn, XN J −1 = Vdn, C
and JPk, XN J −1 = Pdk, C
for all n ∈ Z and k ∈ N. These equalities imply that if Ah is the limit operator of the band-dominated operator A ∈ lp (Z, XN ) with respect to the sequence h, then JAh J −1 is the limit operator of JAJ −1 with respect to the sequence dh : N → Z, m → dh(m), i.e., (JAJ −1 )dh = JAh J −1 . Summarizing, we obtain ind+ A = ind+ JAJ −1 and ind+ Ah = ind+ JAh J −1 = ind+ (JAJ −1 )dh for each Fredholm band-dominated operator A on lp (Z, XN ) and for each of its limit operators Ah ∈ σ+ (A). Since dh tends to +∞ whenever h does, one has (JAJ −1 )dh ∈ σ+ (JAJ −1 ), and from Theorem 6 we infer that ind+ JAJ −1 = ind+ (JAJ −1 )dh . Thus, ind+ A = ind+ Ah for each Fredholm band-dominated operator A on lp (Z, XN ) and for each of its limit operators Ah ∈ σ+ (A). The minuscounterpart of this assertion follows analogously. This proves the proposition and finishes the proof of Theorem 10.
4. The Fredholm index of locally compact band-dominated operators on Lp (R) This section is devoted to the proof of Theorem 1. As in the discrete case, the ˆ limit operators approach provides us with a criterion for the P-Fredholmness of ˆ an operator rather than for its common Fredholmness. Here, P = (Pˆn )n≥0 where Pˆn : Lp (R) → Lp (R) is the operator of multiplication by the characteristic function of the interval [−n, n], i.e., f (x) if x ∈ [−n, n] ˆ (Pn f )(x) = 0 else, ˆ ˆ and P-compactness and P-Fredholmness are defined literally as in the discrete case. The following proposition can be proved as its discrete counterpart Proposition 7. Proposition 14. An operator A ∈ L(Lp (R)) of the form A = I + K with K ∈ Lp ˆ is Fredholm if and only if it is P-Fredholm.
276
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
We prove Theorem 1 via a suitable discretization. Let χ0 denote the characteristic function of the interval [0, 1]. The mapping G : Lp (R) → lp (Z, Lp [0, 1]) which sends the function f ∈ Lp (R) to the sequence Gf = ((Gf )n )n∈Z
where
(Gf )n := χ0 U−n f
is a bijective isometry the inverse of which maps the sequence x = (xn )n∈Z to the function G−1 x = Un xn χ0 , n∈Z
the series converging in Lp (R). Thus, the mapping Γ : L(Lp (R)) → L(lp (Z, Lp [0, 1])),
A → GAG−1
is an isometric algebra isomorphism. It is shown in Proposition 3.1.4 in [15] that Γ(Ah ) = (Γ(A))h for each limit operator Ah of an operator A ∈ Bp , whereas Proposition 3.1.6 in [15] states that Γ maps Bp$ onto A$E with E = lp (Z, Lp [0, 1]). Further, if A ∈ Lp (R) is a locally compact operator, then the entries of the matrix representation of its $ . Finally, discretization Γ(A) are compact operators. Thus, Γ maps L$p into I + CE one evidently has ind A = ind Γ(A) for each operator A ∈ L(Lp (R)), and the Banach space Lp [0, 1] has the sap as already mentioned. Thus, the assertions of Theorem 1 follow immediately from their discrete counterparts Corollary 8 and Theorem 10.
5. Applications As an application of Theorem 1, we are going to examine the Fredholm properties of operators of the form I + K with K ∈ Kp (BU C). The latter stands for the smallest closed subalgebra of L(Lp (R)) which contains all operators of the form aCbI where a, b ∈ BU C and where C is a Fourier convolution operator with L1 -kernel k. Thus, (Cf )(x) = (k ∗ f )(x) = k(x − y)f (y) dy, x ∈ R. R
In Proposition 3.3.6 in [15] it is verified that Kp (BU C) ⊆ L$p . Hence, Theorem 1 applies to operators in Kp (BU C), and it yields the following. Theorem 15. Let A ∈ L(Lp (R)) be a convolution type operator of the form I + K with K ∈ Kp (BU C). Then (a) A is Fredholm if and only if all of its limit operators are invertible, and if the norms of their inverses are uniformly bounded.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
277
(b) if A is Fredholm then, for arbitrary limit operators B± ∈ σ± (A), ind A = ind+ B+ + ind− B− . One cannot say much about the limit operators of a general operator A ∈ I + Kp (BU C). It is only clear that they belong to I + Kp (BU C) again. Thus, the computation of the plus- and minus indices of the limit operators of convolution type operators will remain a serious problem in general. In what follows we will discuss some instances where this computation can be easily done (slowly oscillating coefficients) or is at least manageable (slowly oscillating plus periodic coefficients). Let SO stand for the set of all functions f ∈ BU C which are slowly oscillating in the sense that lim
sup |f (t) − f (t + h)| = 0.
t→±∞ h∈[0, 1]
This set forms a C ∗ -subalgebra of BU C. Let Kp (SO) stand for the smallest closed subalgebra of Kp (BU C) which contains all operators of the form aCbI where a, b ∈ SO and where C is a Fourier convolution with L1 -kernel. Further, we write P ER for the C ∗ -subalgebra of BU C which consists of all continuous functions of period 1 on R. By Kp (P ER, SO) we denote the smallest closed subalgebra of Kp (BU C) which contains all operators of the form aCbI where now a, b ∈ P ER + SO and where C is again a Fourier convolution with L1 -kernel. Similarly, Kp (P ER) refers to the smallest closed subalgebra of Kp (BU C) which contains all operators aCbI with a, b ∈ P ER and with a Fourier convolution C with L1 -kernel. Lemma 16. The limit operators of operators in Kp (SO) are operators of Fourier convolution with L1 -kernel, and all limit operators of operators in Kp (P ER, SO) belong to Kp (P ER). Proof. Operators of convolution are shift invariant with respect to arbitrary shifts, and operators of multiplications by functions in P ER are invariant with respect to integer shifts. Hence, operators of this form as well as there sums and products possess exactly one limit operator, namely the operator itself. Further, as it has been pointed out in Proposition 3.3.9 in [15], all limit operators of operators of multiplication by slowly oscillating functions are constant multiples of the identity operator, whence the assertion. Hence, the determination of the index of a Fredholm operator in I + Kp (SO) requires the computation of the plus- and the minus index of an operator of the form I + C where C is a Fourier convolution with kernel k ∈ L1 (R). Equivalently, one has to determine the common Fredholm index of operators of the form I + χ± Cχ± I. The operator I + χ+ Cχ+ I is the Wiener-Hopf operator with generating function 1+a where a is the Fourier transform of the kernel k of C. After reflection at the origin, the operator I + χ− Cχ− I also becomes a Wiener-Hopf operator.
278
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
The Fredholm property of Wiener-Hopf operators of this type is well understood (see [2, 4, 8]). Since lim a(x) = lim a(x) = 0,
x→+∞
x→−∞
one can consider 1 + a as a continuous function on the one-point compactification ˙ of the real line, which is also called the symbol of the operator. It turns out R that the Wiener-Hopf operator with symbol 1 + a is Fredholm if and only if the ˙ and that in this case its Fredholm index is function 1 + a does not vanish on R, ˙ around the origin. This the negative winding number of the closed curve 1 + a(R) solves the problem of computing the Fredholm index of an operator in I + Kp (SO) completely and in an easy way. Let us now turn over to the setting of operators in I + Kp (P ER, SO). Here we are left with the problem to determine the Fredholm index of operators of the form χ+ (I + K)χ+ I on Lp (R+ ) where K ∈ Kp (P ER). The proofs of Theorems 1 and 10 given above offer a way to perform this calculation. The decisive point is that, due to the periodicity, the operator Γ(χ+ (I + K)χ+ I) ∈ L(lp (Z+ , Lp [0, 1]))
(16)
is a band-dominated Toeplitz operator the entries of which are of the form I + compact if they are located on the main diagonal, whereas they are compact when located outside the main diagonal. Recall that a Toeplitz operator on lp (Z+ , X) is an operator with matrix representation (Ai−j )i, j∈Z+ , i.e., the entries of the matrix are constant along each diagonal which is parallel to the main diagonal. If now I + K is Fredholm on Lp (R), then the Toeplitz operator (16) is Fredholm, too, and it has the same index. Employing the reduction procedure used in the proof of Theorem 10, one can further approximate the Toeplitz operator (16) by a Toeplitz operator on lp (Z+ , CN ) with band structure which is also Fredholm and has the same index as the original operator I + K. Thus, we are left with the determination of the index of a common Toeplitz operator T (g) on lp (Z+ , CN ) where each entry gij of the generating function g : T → CN ×N is a trigonometric polynomial. This operator can be identified with an operator matrix (T (gij ))N i, j=1 where each T (gij ) is a Toeplitz band operator on lp (Z+ , C) = lp (Z+ ). As it is well known (see, e.g., Theorem 6.12 in [2]), this operator is Fredholm if and only if the common Toeplitz operator (with scalar-valued polynomial generating function) T (det g) is Fredholm, and the indices of these operators coincide. Moreover, the index of T (det g) is equal to the negative winding number of the function det g with respect to the origin. For a general account on matrix functions and the Toeplitz and Wiener-Hopf operators generated by them, we refer to the monographs [3] and [10]. Convolution and Wiener-Hopf operators with almost periodic matrix-valued generating functions are thoroughly treated in the monograph [1]. For general results about relations between the Fredholmness of a block operator and its determinant one should consult Chapter 1 in [9].
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
279
A similar approach is possible for operators in I + Kp (P ERZ , SO) where P ERZ stands for the set of all functions with integer period. After discretization and approximation as above, one finally arrives at a block Toeplitz operator in place of (16) which again can be reduced to a matrix of Toeplitz operators on lp (Z+ ). The results of Theorems 1, 10 and 15 can be completed by an observation made in [16] for the case of band-dominated operators on lp (Z, C). This observation concerns the independence of the Fredholm index on p. To make this statement precise we have to explain what is meant by a band-dominated operator which acts on different lp -spaces (notice that the class of all band operators is independent of p whereas the algebra AE of all band-dominated operators depends on the parameter p of E = lp (Z, X) heavily). Every infinite matrix (aij )i, j∈Z induces an operator A on the linear space c00 (Z, X) of all functions x : Z → X with compact support by i → (Ax)i :=
aij xj .
j∈Z
We say that A extends to a bounded linear operator on lp (Z, X) or that A acts on lp (Z, X) if Ax ∈ lp (Z, X) for each x ∈ c00 (Z, X) and if there is a constant C such that Axp ≤ Cxp for each x ∈ c00 (Z, X). If A extends to a banddominated operator on both lp (Z, X) and lr (Z, X), then we say that A is a banddominated operator on lp (Z, X) and lr (Z, X). Otherwise stated: we consider two band-dominated operators B and C acting on lp (Z, X) and lr (Z, X), respectively, as identical, and we denote them by the same letter, if their matrix representations coincide. $ be a Fredholm band-dominated operator both Proposition 17. Let A ∈ I + CE p on E = l (Z, X) and on E = lr (Z, X) with 1 < r < p < ∞. Then A is a Fredholm band-dominated operator on each space ls (Z, X) with r < s < p, and the Fredholm index inds A of A, considered as an operator on ls (Z, X), is independent of s ∈ [r, p].
The proof follows exactly the line of the proof of Theorem 10, finally reducing the assertion of the proposition to the case X = C which is treated in [16]. It should be also mentioned that Proposition 17 remains valid for band-dominated operators on Lp (ZN , X) with N a positive integer which also follows from [16]. In combination with Theorems 1 and 15 one gets the following corollary. Corollary 18. (a) Let A ∈ I + L$q be a Fredholm band-dominated operator both for q = p and for q = r with 1 < r < p < ∞. Then A is a Fredholm banddominated operator on each space Ls (R) with r < s < p, and the Fredholm index inds A of A, considered as an operator on Ls (R), is independent of s ∈ [r, p].
280
Rabinovich and Roch
IEOT
(b) Let A ∈ I + Kq (BU C) be a Fredholm convolution type operator both for q = p and for q = r with 1 < r < p < ∞. Then A is a Fredholm convolution type operator on each space Ls (R) with r < s < p, and the Fredholm index inds A of A, considered as an operator on Ls (R), is independent of s ∈ [r, p].
References [1] A. B¨ ottcher, Yu. I. Karlovich, I. M. Spitkovsky, Convolution operators and Factorization of Almost Periodic Matrix Functions. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel 2002. [2] A. B¨ ottcher, B. Silbermann, Analysis of Toeplitz operators. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York 1990. [3] K. F. Clancey, I. Gohberg, Factorization of matrix functions and singular integral operators. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel 1981. [4] I. Gohberg, I. Feldman, Convolution Equations and Projection Methods for Their Solution. Nauka, Moskva 1971 (Russian, Engl. transl.: Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. of Math. Monographs, Vol. 41, Providence, Rhode Island, 1974). [5] I. Gohberg, M. Krein, Systems of integral equations on the semi-axis with kernels depending on the difference of the arguments. Usp. Mat. Nauk 13(1958), 5, 3 – 72 (Russian). [6] N. Karapetiants, S. Samko, A certain class of convolution type integral equations and its applications. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Mat. 35(1971), 3, 714 – 726 (Russian). [7] N. Karapetiants, S. Samko, Equations with Involutive Operators. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Boston, Basel, Berlin 2001. [8] M. G. Krein, Integral equations on the semi-axis with kernels depending on the difference of the arguments. Usp. Mat. Nauk 13(1958), 2, 3 – 120 (Russian). [9] N. Ya. Krupnik, Banach algebras with symbol and singular integral operators. Shtiintsa, Kishinev 1984 (Russian, English transl.: Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel 1987). [10] G. S. Litvinchuk, I. M. Spitkovski, Factorization of measurable matrix functions. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel 1987. [11] V. S. Rabinovich, S. Roch, Fredholmness of convolution type operators. In: Operator Theory: Advances and Applications 147, 423–455, Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel, Boston, Berlin 2004. [12] V. S. Rabinovich, S. Roch, J. Roe, Fredholm indices of band-dominated operators. Integral Equations Oper. Theory 49(2004), 2, 221 – 238. [13] V. S. Rabinovich, S. Roch, B. Silbermann, Fredholm theory and finite section method for band-dominated operators. Integral Equations Oper. Theory 30(1998), 4, 452 – 495. [14] V. S. Rabinovich, S. Roch, B. Silbermann, Band-dominated operators with operatorvalued coefficients, their Fredholm properties and finite sections. Integral Equations Oper. Theory 40(2001), 3, 342 – 381. [15] V. S. Rabinovich, S. Roch, B. Silbermann, Limit Operators and Their Applications in Operator Theory. Birkh¨ auser Verlag, Basel, Boston, Berlin, 2004.
Vol. 57 (2007)
Index of Locally Compact BDO
281
[16] S. Roch, Band-dominated operators on lp -spaces: Fredholm indices and finite sections. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 70(2004), 3 - 4, 783 – 797. Vladimir S. Rabinovich Instituto Politechnico National ESIME-Zacatenco, Ed.1, 2-do piso Av. IPN Mexico, D.F., 07738 Mexico e-mail: [email protected] Steffen Roch Technische Universit¨ at Darmstadt Fachbereich Mathematik Schlossgartenstrasse 7 D-64289 Darmstadt Germany e-mail: [email protected] Submitted: April 6, 2006
Integr. equ. oper. theory 57 (2007), 283–301 c 2006 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 0378-620X/020283-19, published online August 8, 2006 DOI 10.1007/s00020-006-1449-x
Integral Equations and Operator Theory
Norms of Moore-Penrose Inverses of Fredholm Toeplitz Operators A. Rogozhin Abstract. In this paper we estimate the norm of the Moore-Penrose inverse T (a)+ of a Fredholm Toeplitz operator T (a) with a matrix-valued symbol a ∈ L∞ N×N defined on the complex unit circle. In particular, we show that in the ”generic case” the strict inequality T (a)+ > a−1 ∞ holds. Moreover, we discuss the asymptotic behavior of T (tr a)+ for r ∈ Z. The results are illustrated by numerical experiments. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000). Primary 47B35; Secondary 47A30. Keywords. Moore-Penrose inverses, Toeplitz operators, singular values.
1. Introduction Let L∞ := L∞ (T) denote the usual Lebesgue space on the unit circle T = {t ∈ ∗ C : |t| = 1}, and let L∞ N ×N be the C -algebra of N × N – matrices with entries ∞ 2 from L . Further, we denote by N the Hilbert space of all sequences x : Z+ → CN , Z+ = {i ∈ Z : i ≥ 0}, such that ∞ 1/2 2 xi CN < ∞, x2N := i=0
xi 2CN
2 (x1i , x2i , . . . , xN i )CN
2 = = |x1i |2 + |x2i |2 + . . . + |xN where i | . 2 2 The block Toeplitz operator T (a) : N → N is defined by the matrix representation a0 a−1 a−2 · · · a1 a0 a−1 · · · ∞ , T (a) = ai−j i,j=0 = a2 a1 a0 · · · ... ... ... ...
where {ak }k∈Z is the sequence of the Fourier coefficients of a function a ∈ L∞ N ×N . This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, DFG project SI 474110-1.
284
Rogozhin
IEOT
It is well known (see e.g. [4]) that for all generating functions a ∈ L∞ N ×N the 2 Toeplitz operator T (a) is a bounded linear operator on N , i.e. T (a) ∈ L(2N ), and T (a)L(2N ) = a∞ . Here L(H) stands for the C ∗ − algebra of all bounded linear operators acting on a Hilbert space H. Moreover, if the Toeplitz operator T (a) ∈ L(2N ), a ∈ L∞ N ×N , is Fredholm (i.e. invertible modulo compact operators) then the generating function a is invertible in L∞ N ×N (see e.g. [4]). Further, we recall some basic facts concerning Moore-Penrose invertibility of linear operators. Let H be a Hilbert space. An operator A ∈ L(H) is called Moore-Penrose invertible if there is an operator A+ ∈ L(H) such that AA+ A = A
A+ AA+ = A+
(AA+ )∗ = AA+
(A+ A)∗ = A+ A.
If such an operator A+ exists, then it is uniquely determined. Clearly, if A is invertible then it is Moore-Penrose invertible and the operator A+ coincides with the inverse of A. It is well known that an operator is Moore-Penrose invertible if and only if its range is closed. In particular, if A is Fredholm, then it is MoorePenrose invertible. Clearly, the norm of the Moore-Penrose inverse of a Toeplitz operator T (a) is of great interest (for example, it plays a significant role for the determination of the least square solution of the equation T (a)x = y). Unfortunately, the norm T (a)+ is available in rare cases only and it is even difficult to estimate the norm of the usual inverse of T (a). Using the so-called k−splitting property of the singular values of truncated Toeplitz matrices we show in Section 2 that one can compute approximately the norm of the Moore-Penrose inverse of a Fredholm Toeplitz operators (see (3)). Note that, on the other hand, this result provides one reason more to estimate the norm of Moore-Penrose inverses (see the convergence speed estimate (2)). In Section 3 we present several simple estimates of the norm of Moore-Penrose inverses. In some special cases, e.g. for triangular Toeplitz matrices, we were able to get upper estimates of the norm T (a)+ (see Lemmas 3.2-3.4). The main result is obtained in Section 4. Let us denote by F L∞ N ×N the set of all functions a ∈ L∞ for which the Toeplitz operator T (a) is Fredholm. N ×N Theorem 1.1. The the set of all functions a ∈ F L∞ N ×N for which the strict inequality T (a)+ > a−1 ∞ holds is an open and dense subset of F L∞ N ×N . In Section 5 we discuss how the norm of the Moore-Penrose inverse of a Toeplitz operator changes when the generating function is multiplied by the diagonal matrix diag(tr , tr , . . . , tr ). Theorem 1.1 means that generically the norm of the Moore-Penrose inverse of a Fredholm Toeplitz operator is strictly greater than the norm of a−1 . However, for continuous generating functions a we have proved the following interesting result. Theorem 1.2. If a ∈ F L∞ N ×N is continuous, then lim T (tr a)+ = lim T (t−r a)+ = a−1 ∞ .
r→+∞
r→+∞
Vol. 57 (2007)
Norms of MPI’s of Toeplitz Operators
285
Finally, in Section 6 we illustrate the results of the paper by numerical experiments.
2. Truncated Toeplitz matrices First, we recall that the singular values of a matrix An ∈ CnN ×nN are defined as the nonnegative square roots of the spectrum points of A∗n An . We denote the (ordered) singular values of An by s1 (An ), s2 (An ), . . . snN (An ), i.e. we have 0 ≤ s1 (An ) ≤ s2 (An ) ≤ . . . ≤ snN (An ) = An . Further, given a function a ∈ L∞ N ×N and a number r ∈ {0, 1, . . .} let us denote by Tn,r (a) the following rectangular truncated Toeplitz matrices a−n+r a0 a−1 · · · · · · a1 a0 · · · · · · a−n+r+1 Tn,r (a) = . .. .. .. .. . . an
······
an−1
ar
If r equal zero, then we get the usual square finite sections. Note also that to evaluate the singular values of Tn,r (a) these matrices are extended to square nN × nN matrices by filling in zeros in the remaining places. A function a ∈ L∞ N ×N is called piecewise continuous if it has one-sided limits a(t ± 0) for all t ∈ T. Several years ago S. Roch and B. Silbermann proved the next result Theorem 2.1 (see [8], Theorem 3.1). If a ∈ F L∞ N ×N is piecewise continuous, then the singular values of Tn,r (a) have the k−splitting property, that is lim sk (Tn,r (a)) = 0
n→∞
and
lim inf sk+1 (Tn,r (a)) > 0 n→∞
with
k = dim ker T (a) + dim ker T (tr a ˜)T (t−r E), where E = diag(1, 1, . . . , 1) is the identity N × N matrix, and the function a ˜ is defined by a ˜(t) = a(1/t).
Further, it turns out that the sequence (sk+1 (Tn (a))) of the (k+1)-st singular values of Tn,r (a) even converges as n → ∞ and (see [7], Theorem 7.2) dr := lim sk+1 (Tn,r (a)) = n→∞
1 . max (T (a)+ , [T (tr a ˜)T (t−r E)]+ )
(1)
Moreover, one can estimate the speed of this convergence by the smoothness of the function a. For instance, Theorem 7.3 of [7] shows that if a is rational then √ −γ n dr < a−1 −1 O e ∞ dr − sk+1 Tn,r (a) = (2) O ln n otherwise. n
286
Rogozhin
IEOT
√ We remark that in a related but different context such O e−γ n and O (ln n/n) were first established by A. B¨ottcher, S. Grudsky, A. Kozak, and B. Silbermann in [3], [1]. Note also that in view of Lemma 5.1 below [T (tr a ˜)T (t−r E)]+ = T (tr a ˜)+ . ˜)+ Besides, if the generating function a is continuous, then the norms T (tr a −1 converge to the norm of the function a (see Theorem 1.2 or Theorem 5.4 below). Thus, at least for continuous functions a we have lim dr = T (a)+ −1 .
r→∞
(3)
Here we use the fact that the norm T (a)+ is always greater than or equal to the norm a−1 ∞ (see Theorem 3.1 below). Thus, if we know the splitting number k, then we can compute approximately the quantity dr (and consequently the norm T (a)+ ). But the problem is that, in general, we do not know the kernel dimensions of Toeplitz operators. However, if we would be able to decide whether the singular values converge to zero or not, then we would know the splitting number k. Consequently, it would be good to have some information about the size of dr . For instance, if dr ≈ 10−1 , then we perhaps have a possibility to decide whether the singular values converge to zero or to 10−1 . But if dr ≈ 10−6 , then one has no chance. Therefore, we want that the norm T (a)+ is not large. But, on the other hand, if the norm T (a)+ is strictly greater than the norm of a−1 then we get more quick convergence sk+1 (Tn,r (a)) → dr (see estimate (2)).
3. Simple estimates We need some additional information concerning Moore-Penrose invertibility of linear operators. Again, let H be a Hilbert space and let A be a bounded linear operator acting on H. An operator A(−1) ∈ L(H) satisfying only the condition AA(−1) A = A will be called generalized inverse of A ∈ L(H). One can