Page aa
Liquid Detergents
Page ab
SURFACTANT SCIENCE SERIES CONSULTING EDITORS MARTIN J. SCHICK Consultant F...
1540 downloads
7172 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Page aa
Liquid Detergents
Page ab
SURFACTANT SCIENCE SERIES CONSULTING EDITORS MARTIN J. SCHICK Consultant FREDERICK M. FOWKES (19151990) New York, New York 1. Nonionic Surfactants, edited by Martin J. Schick (see also Volumes 19, 23, and 60) 2. Solvent Properties of Surfactant Solutions, edited by Kozo Shinoda (see Volume 55) 3. Surfactant Biodegradation, R. D. Swisher (see Volume 18) 4. Cationic Surfactants, edited by Eric Jungermann (see also Volumes 34, 37, and 53) 5. Detergency: Theory and Test Methods (in three parts), edited by W. G. Cutler and R. C. Davis (see also Volume 20) 6. Emulsions and Emulsion Technology (in three parts), edited by Kenneth J. Lissant 7. Anionic Surfactants (in two parts), edited by Warner M. Linfield (see Volume 56) 8. Anionic Surfactants: Chemical Analysis, edited by John Cross (out of print) 9. Stabilization of Colloidal Dispersions by Polymer Adsorption, Tatsuo Sato and Richard Ruch (out of print) 10. Anionic Surfactants: Biochemistry, Toxicology, Dermatology, edited by Christian Gloxhuber (see Volume 43) 11. Anionic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry of Surfactant Action, edited by E. H. LucassenReynders (out of print) 12. Amphoteric Surfactants, edited by B. R. Bluestein and Clifford L. Hilton (see Volume 59) 13. Demulsification: Industrial Applications, Kenneth J. Lissant (out of print) 14. Surfactants in Textile Processing, Arved Datyner 15. Electrical Phenomena at Interfaces: Fundamentals, Measurements, and Applications, edited by Ayao Kitahara and Akira Watanabe 16. Surfactants in Cosmetics, edited by Martin M. Rieger (out of print) 17. Interfacial Phenomena: Equilibrium and Dynamic Effects, Clarence A. Miller and P. Neogi 18. Surfactant Biodegradation: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, R. D. Swisher 19. Nonionic Surfactants: Chemical Analysis, edited by John Cross
Page ac
20. Detergency: Theory and Technology, edited by W. Gale Cutler and Erik Kissa 21. Interfacial Phenomena in Apolar Media, edited by HansFriedrich Eicke and Geoffrey D. Parfitt 22. Surfactant Solutions: New Methods of Investigation, edited by Raoul Zana 23. Nonionic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry, edited by Martin J. Schick 24. Microemulsion Systems, edited by Henri L. Rosano and Marc Clausse 25. Biosurfactants and Biotechnology, edited by Naim Kosaric, W. L. Cairns, and Neil C. C. Gray 26. Surfactants in Emerging Technologies, edited by Milton J. Rosen 27. Reagents in Mineral Technology, edited by P. Somasundaran and Brij M. Moudgil 28. Surfactants in Chemical/Process Engineering, edited by Darsh T. Wasan, Martin E. Ginn, and Dinesh O. Shah 29. Thin Liquid Films, edited by I. B. Ivanov 30. Microemulsions and Related Systems: Formulation, Solvency, and Physical Properties, edited by Maurice Bourrel and Robert S. Schechter 31. Crystallization and Polymorphism of Fats and Fatty Acids, edited by Nissim Garti and Kiyotaka Sato 32. Interfacial Phenomena in Coal Technology, edited by Gregory D. Botsaris and Yuli M. Glazman 33. SurfactantBased Separation Processes, edited by John F. Scamehorn and Jeffrey H. Harwell 34. Cationic Surfactants: Organic Chemistry, edited by James M. Richmond 35. Alkylene Oxides and Their Polymers, F. E. Bailey, Jr., and Joseph V. Koleske 36. Interfacial Phenomena in Petroleum Recovery, edited by Norman R. Morrow 37. Cationic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry, edited by Donn N. Rubingh and Paul M. Holland 38. Kinetics and Catalysis in Microheterogeneous Systems, edited by M. Grätzel and K. Kalyanasundaram 39. Interfacial Phenomena in Biological Systems, edited by Max Bender 40. Analysis of Surfactants, Thomas M. Schmitt 41. Light Scattering by Liquid Surfaces and Complementary Techniques, edited by Dominique Langevin 42. Polymeric Surfactants, Irja Piirma 43. Anionic Surfactants: Biochemistry, Toxicology, Dermatology. Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Christian Gloxhuber and Klaus Künstler 44. Organized Solutions: Surfactants in Science and Technology, edited by Stig E. Friberg and Björn Lindman 45. Defoaming: Theory and Industrial Applications, edited by P. R. Garrett 46. Mixed Surfactant Systems, edited by Keizo Ogino and Masahiko Abe 47. Coagulation and Flocculation: Theory and Applications, edited by Bohuslav Dobiáš
Page ad
48. Biosurfactants: Production • Properties • Applications, edited by Naim Kosaric 49. Wettability, edited by John C. Berg 50. Fluorinated Surfactants: Synthesis • Properties • Applications, Erik Kissa 51. Surface and Colloid Chemistry in Advanced Ceramics Processing, edited by Robert J. Pugh and Lennart Bergström 52. Technological Applications of Dispersions, edited by Robert B. McKay 53. Cationic Surfactants: Analytical and Biological Evaluation, edited by John Cross and Edward J. Singer 54. Surfactants in Agrochemicals, Tharwat F. Tadros 55. Solubilization in Surfactant Aggregates, edited by Sherril D. Christian and John F. Scamehorn 56. Anionic Surfactants: Organic Chemistry, edited by Helmut W. Stache 57. Foams: Theory, Measurements, and Applications, edited by Robert K. Prud'homme and Saad A. Khan 58. The Preparation of Dispersions in Liquids, H. N. Stein 59. Amphoteric Surfactants: Second Edition, edited by Eric G. Lomax 60. Nonionic Surfactants: Polyoxyalkylene Block Copolymers, edited by Vaughn M. Nace 61. Emulsions and Emulsion Stability, edited by Johan Sjöblom 62. Vesicles, edited by Morton Rosoff 63. Applied Surface Thermodynamics, edited by A. W. Neumann and Jan K. Spelt 64. Surfactants in Solution, edited by Arun K. Chattopadhyay and K. L. Mittal 65. Detergents in the Environment, edited by Milan Johann Schwuger 66. Industrial Applications of Microemulsions, edited by Conxita Solans and Hironobu Kunieda 67. Liquid Detergents, edited by KuoYann Lai ADDITIONAL VOLUMES IN PREPARATION Surfactants in Cosmetics: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Martin M. Rieger and Linda Rhein Powdered Detergents, edited by Michael S. Showell Enzymes in Detergency, edited by Jan H. van Ee, Onno Misset, and Erik J. Baas
Page i
Liquid Detergents edited by KuoYann Lai ColgatePalmolive Company New York, New York
M ARCEL DEKKER, INC. N EW YORK • BASEL
Page ii
Library of Congress CataloginginPublication Data Liquid detergents / edited by KuoYann Lai. p. cm. — (Surfactant science series ; v. 67) Includes index. ISBN 0824793919 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Detergents. I. Lai, KuoYann. II. Series. TP992.5.L56 1996 668'.14—dc20 9644787 CIP The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the address below. This book is printed on acidfree paper. Copyright © 1997 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 Current printing (last digit): 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Page iii
Preface Liquid detergents play very important roles in our daily lives for personal care, household surface care, and fabric care. We use these products just about every day from washing our hands, hair, dishes, clothes to cleaning various surfaces in our homes. In the last three decades, liquid detergents have gained an increasing popularity largely due to the convenience they offer over other forms. During this period, there have been significant advances in both science and technology in this area. Numerous papers have been published in professional journals and trade magazines, thousands of patents have been granted, and large number of new products have been introduced to the marketplace. The objective of this volume is to provide a comprehensive review of these advances. This is the first book specifically devoted to the review and discussion of liquid detergents. It is intended primarily for scientists and engineers working in the detergent industry and the detergent raw materials industry around the world. Researchers in other industries—such as those in the petroleum industry who are involved in enhanced oil recovery and those in textile processing—as well as those in academia will also useful information in this volume. Consistent with the overall aim of the Surfactant Science Series, this volume covers both theoretical and applied aspects of liquid detergents. There are a total of 14 chapters. Chapter 1 gives a concise account of the past, present, and future of liquid detergents. The rest of the volume is structured into two parts—theories and applications. Chapters 2–6 present an indepth discussion of theories of common importance to most liquid detergent systems including hydrotropy, phase equilibria, rheology, polymeric stabilizers, and nonaqueous surfactant systems. Chapters 7–13 cover the technological aspects of liquid detergents in various practical applications from light and heavyduty liquid
Page iv
detergents, liquid automatic dishwasher detergents, liquid soaps, shampoos and conditioners, and fabric softeners to specialty liquid household surface cleaners. Chapter 14 focuses on the manufacturing aspects of liquid detergents. It is hoped that this volume will not only serve as a handy reference to researchers but also stimulate many new innovations in the detergent field. I want to take this opportunity to express my sincere thanks to Colgate Palmolive Company for permitting me to undertake this project and to the leadership team at its Global Technology Division for their strong support. Special thanks also go to all the contributors of this book not only for sharing their expertise and extensive experience but also for patiently enduring the unavoidable delays of a multiauthored book. I would also like to express my gratitude to Dr. Martin Schick, the consulting editor of this series, for his valuable suggestions, encouragement and patience; and to the publisher, Marcel Dekker Inc., in particular, Ms. Anita Lekhwani, Associate Acquisitions Editor, and Mr. Joseph Stubenrauch, Production Editor, for their patience and invaluable help. Finally, I want to thank my wife, Jane, and my children, Melody, Amy, and Peter for their endurance and support in the last several years. It was with their love and understanding that I was able to devote numerous evenings and weekends to complete this task. KUOYANN LAI
Contents Preface Contributors 1. Liquid Detergents: An Overview Arno Cahn 2. Hydrotropy Stig E. Friberg and Chris Brancewicz 3. Phase Equilibria Guy Broze 4. Rheology of Liquid Detergents R. S. Rounds 5. Polymeric Stabilizers for Liquid Detergents Madukkarai K. Nagarajan and Hal Ambuter 6. Nonaqueous Surfactant Systems Marie Sjöberg and Torbjörn Wärnheim 7. LightDuty Liquid Detergents KuoYann Lai, Elizabeth F. K. McCandlish, and Harry Aszman 8. HeavyDuty Liquid Detergents Amit Sachdev and Santhan Krishnan 9. Liquid Automatic Dishwasher Detergents Philip A. Gorlin, KuoYann Lai, and Nagaraj Dixit
10. Shampoos and Conditioners Clarence R. Robbins 11. Liquid Soaps Richard E. Reever 12. Fabric Softeners Alain Jacques and Charles J. Schramm, Jr. 13. Specialty Liquid Household Surface Cleaners Karen Wisniewski 14. Manufacture of Liquid Detergents R. S. Rounds Index
Page vii
Contributors Hal Ambuter Specialty Chemical Division—Product Development, The BFGoodrich Company, Brecksville, Ohio Harry Aszman Research and Development, Global Technology, Colgate Palmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey Chris Brancewicz Department of Chemistry and Center for Advanced Materials Processing, Clarkson University, Potsdam, New York Guy Broze Advanced Technology Department, ColgatePalmolive Research and Development, Inc., Milmort, Belgium Arno Cahn Arno Cahn Consulting Services, Inc., Pearl River, New York Nagaraj Dixit Research and Development, Global Technology, Colgate Palmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey Stig E. Friberg Department of Chemistry and Center for Advanced Materials Processing, Clarkson University, Potsdam, New York Philip A. Gorlin Research and Development, Global Technology, Colgate Palmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey Alain Jacques Fabric Care, ColgatePalmolive Research and Development, Inc., Milmort, Belgium Santhan Krishnan Research and Development, Global Technology, Colgate Palmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey
Page viii
KuoYann Lai Global Materials and Sourcing (AsiaPacific Division), Global Technology, ColgatePalmolive Company, New York, New York Elizabeth F. K. McCandlish Research and Development, Global Technology, ColgatePalmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey Madukkarai K. Nagarajan Specialty Chemical Division—Product Development, The BFGoodrich Company, Brecksville, Ohio Richard E. Reever Richard Reever and Associates, Inc., Minnetonka, Minnesota Clarence R. Robbins Research and Development, Global Technology, ColgatePalmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey R. S. Rounds Fluid Dynamics, Inc., Piscataway, New Jersey Amit Sachdev Research and Development, Global Technology, Colgate Palmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey Charles J. Schramm, Jr. Research and Development, Global Technology, ColgatePalmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey Marie Sjöberg Institute for Surface Chemistry, Stockholm, Sweden Torbjörn Wärnheim* Institute for Surface Chemistry, Stockholm, Sweden Karen Wisniewski Research and Development, Global Technology, ColgatePalmolive Company, Piscataway, New Jersey *Current affiliation: Pharmacia & Upjohn, Stockholm, Sweden
1 Liquid Detergents: An Overview ARNO CAHN Arno Cahn Consulting Services, Inc., Pearl River, New York I. Introduction II. LightDuty Liquids III. HeavyDuty Liquids IV. Liquid Automatic Dishwasher Detergents V. Shampoos and Conditioners VI. Liquid Soaps VII. Fabric Softeners VIII. Specialty Liquids IX. Manufacture and Raw Materials References
I. Introduction Liquid detergents are convenience products. Compared with powdered detergen dissolve more rapidly, particularly in cold water, they generate less dust, and they dose. It is not surprising, therefore, that liquid forms of household cleaning produ developed by manufacturers. With the exception of fabric softeners and shampoos, the solid form of cleaning p preceded the liquid form. This is true of manual and automatic dishwashing, laund general personal washing products. As a result,
Page 2
the technical history of liquid detergents is to a large extent one of emulating the performance features of the powder models. All other factors—soil, water hardness, and temperature—being equal, cleaning performance is a function of the concentration and type of the active ingredients that are delivered into the cleaning bath. Almost by definition, the liquid form involves a dilution of the active ingredients, that is, a given volume of a powdered detergent can generally deliver more active ingredients than an equal volume of a liquid detergent. The task to provide performance equality with powders is therefore not insignificant. It is made even more difficult when inorganic salts are used to provide certain specific performance features. These salts often pose problems of solubility and compatibility with the organic surfactants of the formulation. Finally, formulation problems are most severe when the active component is less stable in an aqueous environment than in a solid matrix. These considerations apply principally to the heavyduty liquids, the largest of the liquid detergent categories, but they also come into play with liquid automatic dishwasher detergents. The situation is different for products designed for lightduty, hand dishwashing and for softening fabrics. These liquids are generally superior in performance to their powdered counterparts to the extent that these existed in the first place. This is also true of shampoo formulations, for which there is no common solid equivalent. This chapter gives an essentially historical overview of the various categories. Historically, soapbased shampoos and the liquid potassium oleate formulations found in washroom dispensers were probably the earliest commercial liquid detergents. II. LightDuty Liquids On a truly commercial scale, the age of liquid detergents can be said to have begun in the late 1940s when the first liquid detergent for manual dishwashing was introduced. This liquid consisted essentially of a nonionic surfactant: alkylphenol ethoxylate. In use, it produced only a moderate amount of foam in the dishpan. This proved to be a serious detriment. To be successful, consumer product innovations must show a large measure of similarity to the conventional products they are intended to displace. In this case, copious foam was the essential performance attribute that needed to be as close to that which could be generated from powders and soap chips. The requirement for copious foam levels has a technical basis and is more than a mere emotional reaction to a visual phenomenon. With soapbased products, the appearance of a permanent foam signaled that all hard water ions had
Page 3
been removed by precipitation as calcium and magnesium carboxylates and that excess soap was now available to act as a surfactant. The foaming requirements for lightduty liquids were met by the next series of product introductions in the early 1950s. These formulations were based on highfoaming anionic surfactants. They were capable of maintaining adequate levels of foam throughout the dishwashing process and possessed sufficient emulsifying power to handle the load of grease in the dishpan to produce “squeaky clean” dishware. In practice, this was accomplished by a mixture of anionic surfactants— alkylbenzenesulfonate, alcohol ether sulfate, and alcohol sulfates—sometimes in combination with nonionic surfactants. To maintain foam stability, alkanolamides were incorporated. In some products, alkanolamides were subsequently replaced by longchain amine oxides. The formulation of lightduty liquids overcame a second major technical hurdle inherent in the formulation of all liquid detergents: to maintain homogeneity in the presence of significant levels, about 30% or more, of moderately soluble organic surfactants. Coupling agents or hydrotropes were introduced for this purpose, specifically the shortchain alkylbenzenesulfonates, such as xylene, cumene and toluenesulfonates, as well as ethanol. Lightduty liquids have maintained a significant market volume to this day. This is somewhat surprising because the primary function of these products is to wash dishes. In newer homes and apartments, this function has been taken over by automatic dishwashing machines and the special detergents developed for use in these machines. Both have expanded greatly since their introduction in the late 1950s. Some part of the persistence of lightduty liquids is no doubt a result of their use as finefabric detergents for washing delicate laundry items by hand. Over the years, minor additives have been incorporated into lightduty liquid formulations, principally to support marketing claims for special performance features. For a period of time in the 1960s, antimicrobials were incorporated into some products designed to prevent secondary infections of broken skin during dishwashing. After an absence of some 30 years, antimicrobials are again appearing in lightduty liquids. Their return is no doubt connected with increasing awareness of the possible presence of bacteria in foods, especially in chicken. Other commercial products contained protein as a skin benefit agent. Improving the condition of skin as a result of exposure to lightduty liquid solutions proved to be technically very difficult. Exposure times are relatively short, about 20 minutes, three times a day under the best of circumstances, and use concentrations are low, about 0.15%. The combination of low use levels and short exposure times makes it difficult to overcome the adverse effects of skin exposure to other inimical influences, such as dry air in heated homes and strong household chemicals.
Page 4
Generally speaking, lightduty liquid compositions are relatively nonirritating to skin. Mildness to skin could therefore be claimed by these products with reasonable justification. During the 1960s and 1970s, the cosmetic image was further enhanced by opacifying lightduty liquids and conferring upon them a lotionlike appearance. In more recent years, dishwashing efficacy—effective emulsification of grease—combined with persistent foam, has been the main objective of technical product improvement. In line with cleaning efficacy, solid particles have also been incorporated into some lightduty liquid formulations with the objective of raising the effectiveness of the products in removing solid cakedon soil from dishes. III. HeavyDuty Liquids Once lightduty liquid products had established an attractive market position, the development of heavyduty liquids could not be far behind. Here, too, the requirement of similarity to the existing products had to be met, in this case powdered laundry detergents. The powdered laundry detergents of the 1950s were characterized by the presence of high levels of builder, specifically pentasodium tripolyphosphate (STPP), and relatively low levels, about 15%, of surfactants. In formulating a heavyduty liquid, therefore, the major technical objective was to find ways of stably incorporating maximum levels of builder salts. The first commercially important heavyduty liquid was introduced into the U.S. market in 1958. The product was built with tetrapotassium pyrophosphate, which is more soluble than STPP. Even so, in the presence of a surfactant system of sodium alkylbenzenesulfonate and a mixture of alkanolamides, the formulation could tolerate only 15–20% of tetrapotassium pyrophosphate. Incorporation of an antiredeposition agent, another ingredient present in laundry powders, proved to be another major technical hurdle. Antiredeposition agents, generally carbohydrate derivatives, such as carboxymethylcellulose, had been introduced into laundry powders to prevent greying after a number of repeat wash cycles. In one product, the patented solution to this problem consisted of balancing two antiredeposition agents of different specific gravity such that the tendency of one to rise in the finished product was counterbalanced by the tendency of the second agent to settle out of the product [1]. Even though the first major commercial heavyduty liquid composition was formulated with a builder system, the concentrations of builders and surfactants it delivered into the washing solution were lower than those provided by the conventional detergent powders. As a liquid, however, the product possessed a unique convenience in use, particularly for fullstrength application to specific soiled areas of garments. Convenience was accompanied by effectiveness,
Page 5
because the concentration of individual ingredients in the neat form approached that of a nonaqueous system. This is illustrated by the following consideration. Recommended washing product use directions lead to washing solutions with a concentration of about 0.15% of the total product. At a surfactant level of about 15% in the product, the final concentration of surfactant in the wash liquor is about 0.0225%. The efficacy of surfactant in providing observable cleaning at such low concentration attests to the power of the interfacial phenomena that underlie the action of surfactants. By contrast, a heavyduty liquid containing 20% surfactant, applied full strength, leads to a surfactant concentration of 20%, some three orders of magnitude larger than in the earlier case. At these—almost nonaqueous— concentrations, solution phenomena, such as those operating in nonaqueous dry cleaning, are likely to be responsible for cleaning efficacy. The popularity of heavyduty liquids for pretreating stains was thus based not only on convenience but also on real performance. In the mid1960s, the branchedchain surfactants were replaced by more biodegradable analogs in all laundry products. In heavyduty liquids, sodium alkylbenzenesulfonate, derived from an alkylbenzene with a tetrapropylene side chain, was replaced by its straightchain analog, referred to as sodium linear alkylbenzenesulfonate (LAS). The conversion to more biodegradable surfactants was prompted by the appearance of foams on river. The appearance of excessive algal growth on stagnant lakes prompted a second environmental development that proved to be beneficial to the expansion of heavyduty liquids: the reduction or elimination of the sodium tripolyphosphate builder from laundry detergents. Restrictions on the use of phosphate in laundry detergents were imposed by a number of states and smaller administrative agencies beginning in 1970. Because no totally equivalent phosphate substitute was immediately available, the performance of heavyduty laundry powders was adversely affected. As the wholewash performance differential between powders and liquids narrowed, the usage of heavyduty liquids for the whole wash expanded, markedly so in areas where phosphate had been banned. In the first nonphosphate version of the commercial product, phosphate was replaced by NTA (trisodium nitrilotriacetate), a powerful builder, comparable to the condensed phosphates in its efficacy in sequestering calcium ions in the washing solution. Because of reports of adverse teratogenic effects in laboratory experiments, this builder was withdrawn from the market late in 1971. It was replaced by sodium citrate, an environmentally more acceptable but inherently less powerful calcium sequestrant. At the same time, surfactant levels were increased by a factor of about 3. What had happened in practice (if not in theory) was that higher levels of surfactants had been introduced to compensate
Page 6
for the loss in the building contribution to washing efficacy provided earlier by phosphate. The 1970s saw the introduction of several heavyduty liquids that carried this substitution to its ultimate, being totally unbuilt and consisting solely of surfactants at levels ranging from 35% to about 50%. These compositions were distinguished from lightduty liquids by the presence of surfactants with longer hydrophobes and, of course, by the presence of laundry auxilaries, such as fluorescent whiteners and antiredeposition agents. With the exception of a few products based on surfactants only, most heavyduty liquids are formulated with a mixture of anionic and nonionic surfactants, with anionics predominating. The steady expansion of phosphate bans across the United States, accompanied by an expanding perception of the convenience and efficacy of heavyduty liquids, led to an expansion of this product category in the two decades beginning 1970. This expansion was fueled not only by the publicity that normally accompanies the introduction of new brands but also by some significant product improvements. The first of these to appear late in the early 1980s was the incorporation of proteolytic and, later, amylolytic enzymes. In liquid detergents, with their relatively high level of water, proteolytic enzymes must be stabilized to prevent degradation during storage [2,3]. Enzymes make a significant and demonstrable contribution to washing efficacy, not only in the removal of enzymespecific stains, such as grass and blood, by proteinases, but also in an increase in the level of general cleanliness. The latter effect is the result of the ability of a proteolytic enzyme to act upon proteinaceous components of the matrix that binds soil to fabric. Enzymes had been used in detergent powders in the United States and Europe as early as 1960. They were subsequently withdrawn in the United States, but not in Europe, when the raw proteinase of the time proved to have an adverse effect on the health of plant workers. Improvements in the enzymes, specifically encapsulation, eliminated their dustiness and made it possible to use these materials in detergent plants without adverse health effects. The second product innovation was the incorporation of a fabricsoftening ingredient. Again, a powdered version of a “softergent” that had been on the market for some time served as the model product. In the powder, the mutually antagonistic anionic surfactants and cationic softening ingredients could be kept apart so that they would not neutralize their individual benefits in the wash cycle. In a liquid, this proved to be unattainable. As a result, the choice of surfactants in liquid softergents was restricted to nonionics. Although the incorporation of enzymes and fabric softeners strengthened the market position of heavyduty liquids, it did not solve the basic problem of limited general detergency performance in normal washing. As noted earlier, heavyduty liquids came close to the performance of the first nonphosphate laundry powders. With time, however, the performance of nonphosphate laundry
Page 7
powders improved as new surfactant systems and new nonphosphate builders, notably zeolite in combination with polycarboxylate polymers, were introduced. The last decade saw a partial conversion of some major brands from unbuilt to built compositions. The first of these products employed a builder system consisting of sodium citrate in combination with potassium laurate [2]. In the most recent versions, potassium laurate has been replaced by a smallmolecule ether polycarboxylate sequestrant, a mixture of sodium tartrate monosuccinate and sodium tartrate disuccinate [3]. In these built products, the stabilization of enzymes is technically more difficult than in unbuilt systems. A combination of lowmolecularweight fatty acids, lowmolecularweight alcohols, and very low levels of free calcium ions proved to be the solution to this problem. At the height of their popularity, heavyduty liquids accounted for 40–45% of the heavyduty laundry products category in the United States. Not unexpectedly, the market share of heavyduty liquids has declined somewhat as new developments in laundry powders, notably the introduction of a bleaching function and of concentrated, higher density detergent powders, has reinvigorated this product category. If the emulation of the performance of laundry powders is to continue in the future, and there is no reason to doubt this trend, the incorporation of a stain removal and bleaching function into heavyduty liquids should be the next technical improvement in these products. Indeed, the first product claiming a bleaching ingredient has made its appearance at this writing. In laundry powders, effective bleaching has been attained in the last decade by incorporating a combination of sodium perborate and an activator. In Europe, sodium perborate has been used for many decades as a major (about 20%) ingredient of laundry detergents. At temperatures near 100°C, sodium perborate alone provides effective bleaching. As washing temperatures have decreased over the past 15 years, a need has arisen for an activator that reacts with sodium perborate to form unstable peroxy intermediates, which in turn can effect bleaching at the lower temperatures. To prevent premature reaction with the oxygen source, usually sodium perborate, the activators can easily be encapsulated in powdered detergent products. In an aqueous environment, this is technically much more difficult. One approach toward the incorporation of activated perborate into heavyduty liquids is to remove the aqueous environment and formulate nonaqueous systems [5]. To attain product homogeneity, these formulations require significant levels, about 20%, of organic solvents, such as propylene glycol and/or ethanol. Nonaqueous systems have been patented extensively, particularly in Europe, but so far have not been reflected in major new product introductions. Nonaqueous liquids could be considered “superconcentrated” and as such are in tune with the recent trend to concentrated laundry powders. However, the
Page 8
need for organic solvents combined with the high level of surfactants present in these formulations represents a burden on the environment and adds to the cost of such products. In Europe, specifically in Germany, discharge into the environment is a serious problem that is likely to inhibit expansion of both aqueous and nonaqueous heavyduty liquids. Such superconcentrated, nonaqueous heavyduty liquids have not made an appearance in the marketplace, but “concentrated” products have been introduced, in consonance with a general trend toward compaction initiated by the introduction of compact or concentrated detergent powders. Two technical approaches toward more concentrated products have been followed. The first, originating in Europe, results in an opaque product containing relatively high levels of builder salts in suspension. A stable suspension is achieved by salting out the surfactant system by an excess of electrolyte (which includes the builder salts) to form lamellar or spherulitic surfactant aggregates that are capable of suspending builder in excess of its solubility in the formulation. The relatively high builder levels contribute to improved wholewash performance, especially in the European liquids, which contain sodium tripolyphosphate as the builder [4]. A second approach toward compaction yields clear, isotropic liquids that appear to be preferred by U.S. consumers. Technically, this involves a difficult balancing act because conventional hydrotroping agents, such as cumeneor xylenesulfonates, may lose their efficacy in a system enriched in organic components. As the system becomes more organic in nature, higher levels of solvents, such as ethanol, are required in combination with neutralization of acidic functionalities (LAS or citric acid) with alkanolamines, such as mono and triethanolamine. In general, the phase stability of the system becomes more sensitive to changes in active levels because the stable operating region of the phase diagram is narrowed relative to more dilute systems. IV. Liquid Automatic Dishwasher Detergents The development of liquid automatic dishwashing detergents continued the pattern of emulating the composition of solid products in a liquid form. Liquid automatic dishwashing detergents were first introduced in 1986 at a time when the market penetration of heavyduty liquid laundry detergents was on a pronounced upswing, without an upper limit in sight. A liquid version of the automatic dishwashing detergent powders therefore appeared to be attractive and timely. These liquid detergent products are suspensions rather than true solutions. Nonetheless, the technical problems of formulating thick but flowable suspensions are considerable. Again, the primary task was to incorporate as much of
Page 9
the important ingredients—principally builders in this case—as possible. Even approaching the levels of sodium tripolyphosphate and sodium carbonate present in the powdered versions gives rise to a very thick suspension that can be coaxed out of the container only with considerable difficulty. Making the suspension thixotropic by incorporation of the appropriate clay materials and, optionally, polycarboxylate polymers provides a solution to the flow problem [6]. Before use by the consumer, the product must be shaken to reduce viscosity and promote flow. Another major technical problem is the inadequate stability in an aqueous environment of chlorinated isocyanurates, the organic chlorine source used in powders. Sodium hypochlorite satisfies the stability requirements but, on the other hand, reacts with the surfactant types used in powder formulations. The specification of surfactants for use in liquid automatic dishwashing products therefore includes not only the universal requirement of low foam levels (and ideally the capability of destroying the foams generated during the dishwashing process by proteinaceous soil) but also stability to sodium hypochlorite. To a large extent, these requirements have been met by the alkyldiphenyl oxide disulfonate surfactants. In some commercial liquid automatic dishwashing formulations, the surfactant is omitted altogether. In practice, this is a possible solution because detergency in hard surface cleaning, such as dishwashing, is accomplished primarily by the phosphate builder. However, in the absence of surfactant there is little defoaming of natural soils and no contribution to the “sheeting” of water just before drying. Such sheeting minimizes the formation of water spots on dishes that have gone through the dishwashing process. V. Shampoos and Conditioners Shampoos are liquid detergents designed to clean a particular substrate, that is, hair and scalp. They bear some resemblance to hand dishwashing liquids in that they are essentially unbuilt surfactant solutions. Esthetic properties, such as appearance (clear or pearlescent), viscosity, and fragrance, are perhaps more important in this product group than in any other product category discussed in this book. Development and maintenance of an adequate foam level is at once a performance property and also a esthetic property in that it is noticed and evaluated by the user. Shampoos almost always contain additives with activity in areas other than cleaning and foaming, designed to provide specific performance attributes that confer such properties as luster, manageability to hair, and elimination of dandruff. The concentration in use of shampoos is estimated as near 8%. This is an order of magnitude greater than the use concentrations of laundry and dishwashing
Page 10
liquids. Mildness to skin and low irritation to eyes are therefore important requirements for shampoos. Salts, generally sodium but also triethanolammonium, of longchain alcohol sulfates and alcohol ether sulfates are the most widely used surfactants in shampoo formulations. Alkanolamides act as viscosity regulators as well as foam stabilizers. The most general benefits associated with the use of conditioners is a reduction in static charge on hair and hence a greater ease of combing, that is, improved manageability. Cationic, quaternary surfactants and cationic polymers provide these benefits as a result of electrostatic adsorption on hair. In analogy with “softergents,” the mutual antagonism of the cationic conditioners and the anionic surfactants that provide the primary shampoo function of removing oily soil presents a problem in the development of conditioning shampoos. Some anionic surfactants, notably carboxylated nonionics, have been found to be more tolerant toward cationic surfactants than the alcohol sulfates or alcohol ether sulfates. The history of shampoos is long, beginning well before the days of synthetic surfactants. The advent of the latter greatly expanded options for the formulator and at the same improved the esthetics of the products. VI. Liquid Soaps Liquid soaps is the popular description given to this product category. This definition is technically not quite accurate. These products may contain some fatty acid salts, but they are predominantly solutions of (synthetic) surfactants rather than of soap. Apart from the potassium oleate solutions mentioned earlier, the history of liquid soaps is relatively short. It offers a relatively representative illustration of the development of a product category or subcategory in the U.S. market. The first liquid soap was first introduced by a smallish U.S. company in the late 1970s. The product proved to be sufficiently attractive to U.S. consumers to capture a significant market share in the personal washing category. In short order, many competitive brands were introduced that saturated the field and, it seemed, stunted the growth of the category. In the most recent stage, the field reduced to fewer, larger brands and the category has reached a relatively firm level from which slow and steady growth can be anticipated. Liquid soaps can be stored and dispensed with the convenience characteristic of all liquids. Beyond these generic attractions, they possess an esthetic advantage over conventional personal washing bars in that during use, and particularly during occasional use, they are not subject to the visual and physical deterioration in appearance of personal washing bars. Stored in an aqueous
Page 11
matrix (residual water from washing), bars tend to slough and crack to various degrees. The cracks, in turn, can collect soil, which leads to a less than attractive appearance. Liquid soaps can be considered successors to the potassium oleate solutions noted earlier. Presentday products, however, are formulated principally with nonsoap surfactants, including olefinsulfonate, alkyl sulfates, and alkyl ether sulfates. Some products, however, still depend on potassium salts of fatty acids as the principal constituent. As in other personal products, specialty surfactants also find application in liquid soap formulations. These include alkyl phosphate esters, sarcosinates, and sulfosuccinates. As expected from consumer products that contact skin, a number of specialty ingredients can be found in products making specific marketing claims. These ingredients include glycerin, aloe vera, and antimicrobial phenolics. Small levels of calcium sequestrants, such as EDTA, and sodium citrate, are also present. VII. Fabric Softeners Fabric softeners or conditioners, as the name implies, are products that confer softness to washed textile goods. They first made their appearance in the U.S. market in the 1950s. The major active ingredient in fabric softening compositions is a cationic surfactant, a di(longchain)alkyldimethylammonium halide or methosulfate. The positive charge on the nitrogen atom, combined with the high molecular mass associated with the long alkyl chains, ensured adsorption of the compound on the substrate and a soft feel of the conditioned fabric. In contrast to most other liquid detergent categories, fabric softeners are not true solutions. The longchain quaternary salts do not dissolve to form an isotropic solution. Cotton is the primary target substrate for fabric softeners. On repeated washing, the fine structure of cotton at the surface of the fabric becomes dendritic, that is, many fine spikes of cotton fibers are formed that protrude from the surface of the textile. Electrostatic repulsion holds these spikes in place, but in the presence of the cationic softening agent, they are smoothed out. Synthetic fabrics, such as polyester and nylon, are not subject to this phenomenon. Much of the “softening” with these substrates is provided by the mechanical flexing action in the drier. However, the mechanical action causes a buildup of static electricity on synthetic fabrics, which can result in considerable sparking when garments made of synthetic fibers are withdrawn from a clothes drier. Fortunately, the agents that confer softening to cotton fibers also reduce the buildup of static charges on synthetics.
Page 12
In a conventional fabric softener formulation, the level of the quaternary surfactant is about 5%. Low concentrations of “leveling agents” can also be present. These materials, often nonionic surfactants, assist in uniform deposition of the softening quaternary. In addition, a buffering system is used to assure an acidic pH. Finally, a solvent, such as isopropanol, present at levels of about 10–15%, assures a viscosity range suitable for easy dispensing from the bottle. As an additive to improve ease of ironing and to reduce the wrinkling tendencies of the treated textile, silicone derivatives, such as polydimethyl siloxanes, have been incorporated into liquid fabric softener compositions [7]. As an alternative softening quaternary, imidazolinium compounds have been introduced with a claim of superior rewet performance. This can be a useful performance feature because with continuing usage and buildup of cationics on the substrate, the water absorption of the substrate can be adversely affected. The use of anionic detergents in the main wash can mitigate this phenomenon because the anionic surfactant can combine with the cationic fabric softener to form a combination that is removed as part of the oil on the fabric. Since the late 1970s, concentrated fabric softener products have been marketed in the United States and in Europe. In these products, the concentration of the softening cationic is about three times as high as in the conventional products. In the most recent past, the environmental acceptability of the dialkyldimethyl ammonium quaternary has been questioned, particularly in Western Europe. In response, the nature of the alkyl group has been modified and a moderately extensive patent literature has arisen covering these modifications. For the most part, the patented structures include an ester linkage, generally at the third carbon atom, which makes for a more rapid biological breakdown of the parent compound [8]. The liquid fabric softeners just described are also referred to as rinse cycle softeners. The reason is that these products are added to the rinse cycle of the wash when no or very little of any anionic residue from the detergent used in the main wash can be expected to be present. As in all textile treatments, fabric softening and conditioning are inherently more effective when they are carried out in a liquid bath, that is, when a rinse cycle softener is employed. Adding a product to the rinse cycle softener represents a measure of inconvenience to the user. Before special ports for the automatic addition of rinse cycle became a widespread feature of washing machines, the use of a rinse cycle softener usually required an appropriately timed second trip to the washing machine. It is not surprising, therefore, that alternative means of softening products were sought and developed. Here, however, the usual situation was reversed, in that now greater convenience rested with “solid” products, that is, flexible sheets treated with a fabric softening compositions that performed their softening
Page 13
and static reducing functions in the clothes drier rather than in the washing machine. Softergents, mentioned earlier in connection with heavyduty liquids, can be viewed as representing the ultimate in convenience. These products require no additional effort beyond laundering. As noted, this convenience is bought at some cost in both the washing and softening performance. VIII. Specialty Liquids In addition to the major liquid detergent categories discussed earlier, several more specialized liquid product categories have been marketed for a number of years. In terms of function, character, and formulation ingredients, this is the most fragmented group of products considered here. The largest group comprises the “general” hard surface cleaners. In addition, there is a large variety of specialties within specialty liquids, such as window cleaners, bathroom cleaners, and toilet bowl cleaners. The major category of general hard surface cleaners has evolved into two principal types: allpurpose cleaners and solvent cleaners. Allpurpose liquids are essentially dilute versions of heavyduty liquids. Again, a solid product that required dissolution before use was the model for the liquid cleaners. Early versions of the liquid cleaners were based on low levels of tetrapyrophosphate builder and surfactant and, additionally, auxiliaries, such as alkanolamide and a sufficient amount of hydrotrope, to keep the composition homogeneous. For sanitizing products, the auxiliaries include compounds with antimicrobial efficacy, such as pine oil or antimicrobial cationics. With the advent of phosphate bans, sodium citrate has emerged as the most common phosphate replacement in these products. For increased efficacy in removing particulate soil adhering to the substrate, some generalpurpose cleaners incorporate a soft abrasive, such as calcium carbonate. The resulting products are milky suspensions with about 40–50% of suspended calcium carbonate [9]. Keeping these compositions homogeneous through extended storage is a technical challenge. One approach to solving this problem is to provide “structure” to the liquid medium. Surfactants present as a lamellar phase are capable of structuring liquids. Most recently, a composition containing both soft abrasive and bleach has been introduced [10]. These hard surface cleaners have not escaped the recent trend toward compaction. Here, the approach toward “ultra” products is based on the use of shorter chain surfactants that combine the soil penetration efficacy of solvents with the grease emulsification of traditional surfactants. These surfactants are also said to require no builders because their performance is not affected by water hardness.
Page 14
Solvent cleaners are generally free of builder salts and depend for their efficacy on solventtype compounds, such as glycol ethers. Solvent cleaners are less effective on particulate soil, such as mud tracked into the house from the outside, but target their efficacy against oily soils, particularly on oily soil on modern plastic surfaces. Window cleaning products constitute a specialty within the solvent cleaner category. Because any residue left on glass after drying leads to streaking or an otherwise undesirable appearance, these products are highly dilute aqueous solutions containing extremely low surfactant levels—most often nonionic surfactants—and a combination of glycol ethers and isopropyl alcohol as the solvent system. Bathroom cleaners, sometimes referred to as tubtileandsink cleaners, represent “subspecialty” liquids that must be effective against a combination of sebum soil deposited from skin detritus during bathing or showering and the hardness deposits deriving from hard water itself or from its interaction with soap, that is, calcium salts of fatty acids. One subset in this group depends on acids for removing this combination. The acids contained in the products range from the strong hydrochloric and phosphoric acids to moderately strong organic acids, such as glycollic acid. Other products are formulated at a basic pH, incorporating an calcium sequestrants, such as the sodium salt of ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), surfactants, and, in the case of products with disinfecting action, antimicrobial quaternaries. Like bathroom cleaners, toilet bowl cleaners are formulated to remove mineral deposits, principally iron salts, that form an unsightly deposit at the water level. Again, acids ranging in strength from hydrochloric to citric are found in these products. Another subsegment of the specialty liquids is that of the drain cleaners. These are strongly basic products based on combinations of sodium hydroxide and sodium hypochlorite. IX. Manufacture and Raw Materials In principle, the manufacture of liquids is simple, involving only the formulation of a generally aqueous solution or suspension. For light and heavyduty liquids, which contain sodium salts of surfactant acids, neutralization can be carried out in situ, that is, as a first step in the mixing process. The heat of neutralization must be dissipated before addition of the more temperaturesensitive ingredients, such as the fragrance. Heat must also be dissipated in the production of products that require heat input to solubilize individual ingredients. The raw materials for the liquid household products discussed in this book are relatively few in number, including the “workhorse” surfactants, builders,
Page 15
hydrotropes, and a small number of special function ingredients. Cost constraints on the finished products are one of the important limiting factors. The situation is different for the personal liquid detergents and liquid soaps and especially so for shampoos and conditioners. Cost constraints are relaxed, and the range of performance claims based on specific and unique ingredients is now very much expanded. Although the variety of the essential surfactants is still manageable, the number of specialty surfactants and special function ingredients is very much greater. A detailed discussion of these ingredients is beyond the scope of this chapter. Details of the characteristics, properties, and manufacture of the raw materials can be found in other reference works [11]. In the following, the raw materials found in liquid detergent compositions are listed to provide a convenient summary for further reference. For the large scale categories of light and heavyduty liquids, for automatic dishwasher detergents, and for fabric softeners, the list is fairly complete. For specialty liquids, shampoos and conditioners, and to a lesser extent for liquid soaps, only limited examples of special functional ingredients have been selected. I. Lightduty liquids A. Surfactants 1. Alkylbenzenesulfonate (linear alkylate sulfonate, LAS) salts 2. Alkyl ether sulfate salts 3. Alkyl sulfate salts 4. Betaines 5. Alkylpolyglycosides B. Foam stabilizers 1. Fatty acid alkanolamides (mono and di) 2. Alkyldimethylamine oxides C. Hydrotropes 1. Shortchain alkylbenzenesulfonates (xylenesulfonate salts) 2. Ethanol II. Heavyduty liquids A. Surfactants 1. Alkylbenzenesulfonate salts 2. Alkyl ether sulfate salts 3. Alkyl sulfate salts
A. Surfactants 1. Alkylbenzenesulfonate salts 2. Alkyl ether sulfate salts 3. Alkyl sulfate salts 4. Alcohol ethoxylates 5. Nmethylglucamides
Page 16
B. Builders 1. Sodium citrate 2. Sodium salts of tartrate mono and disuccinate mixture C. Hydrotropes 1. Salts of shortchain alkylbenzenesulfonates (xylenesulfonate, cumenesulfonate, toluenesulfonate) 2. Ethanol D. Bases: Alkanolamines E. Other special functional ingredients 1. Enzymes (proteinase, amylase, lipase): stain remover 2. Borax (cleaning aid) 3. Sodium formate, calcium chloride (enzyme stabilizing system) 4. Hydrogen peroxide (bleach) 5. Propylene glycol (solvent) III. Liquid automatic dishwasher detergents A. Surfactants 1. Alkyldiphenyl oxide disulfonate salts 2. Hydroxyfatty acid salts B. Builders: 1. Pentasodium tripolyphosphate 2. Tetrasodium pyrophosphate 3. Sodium carbonate 4. Sodium silicate C. Bases: Sodium and potassium hydroxide D. Other special functional ingredients 1. Sodium hypochlorite (bleach) 2. Clay (smectite, bentonite): viscosity regulator, suspending agent 3. Polyacrylate sodium salts (viscosity regulator) 4. Monostearyl acid phosphate (suds depressant) IV. Shampoos and conditioners
2. Clay (smectite, bentonite): viscosity regulator, suspending agent 3. Polyacrylate sodium salts (viscosity regulator) 4. Monostearyl acid phosphate (suds depressant) IV. Shampoos and conditioners A. Surfactants 1. Alkyl sulfate salts 2. Alkyl ether sulfate salts 3. Acylaminopropyl betaines 4. Olefinsulfonate salts B. Foam stabilizers/viscosity regulators: Fatty acid alkanolamides
Page 17
C. Other special functional ingredients 1. Polyquaternium 7 (cationic conditioner) 2. Glycol monostearate (opacifier) 3. Aloe vera (luster promoter) 4. Jojoba (luster promoter) 5. Derivatives of hydrolyzed keratin (skin and hair conditioner) V. Liquid Soaps A. Surfactants 1. Alcohol sulfate salts 2. Alkyl ether sulfate salts 3. Olefinsulfonate salts 4. Fatty acid salts B. Sequestrants 1. EDTA 2. Sodium citrate C. Foam stabilizers/viscosity regulators: Fatty acid alkanolamides D. Other special functional ingredients 1. Phenolic antimicrobials 2. Glycerin VI. Fabric conditioners A. Surfactants 1. Dialkyldimethylammonium halide or methosulfate salts 2. Monoalkyltrimethylammonium halide salts 3. Alkylimidazolinium salts 4. Alcohol ethoxylates 5. Alkyl (ethylene oxide/propylene oxide) nonionics B. Solvents 1. Isopropanol 2. Ethanol C. Other special functional ingredients: Polydimethylsiloxanes (leveling agent)
B. Solvents 1. Isopropanol 2. Ethanol C. Other special functional ingredients: Polydimethylsiloxanes (leveling agent) VII. Specialty liquids A. Surfactants 1. Alkylbenzenesulfonate salts 2. Alcohol sulfate salts
Page 18
3. Alkanesulfonate salts 4. Alkyl ether sulfate salts 5. Alkylphenol ethoxylates 6. Alcohol ethoxylates B. Builders/sequestrants 1. Sodium carbonate 2. Sodium sesquicarbonate 3. Sodium citrate 4. EDTA C. Acids/alkalis 1. Hydrochloric acid 2. Phosphoric acid 3. Glycollic acid 4. Sodium hydroxide 5. Sodium metasilicate 6. Alkanolamines D. Hydrotropes: Shortchain alkylbenzenesulfonate salts (toluene, cumene) E. Bases: Alkanolamines F. Other special functional ingredients 1. Pine oil (disinfectant) 2. Benzalkonium cationics (antimicrobials) 3. Sodium hypochlorite (bleach) 4. Calcium carbonate (soft abrasive) 5. Alumina (suspending aid) 6. Alkyl glycol ethers (solvents) 7. Isopropanol (solvent) References 1. I. Reich and H. Dallenbach, U.S. Patent 2,994,665 to Lever Brothers Company (1963). 2. J. C. Letton and M. J. Yunker, U.S. Patent 4,318,818 to the Procter &
References 1. I. Reich and H. Dallenbach, U.S. Patent 2,994,665 to Lever Brothers Company (1963). 2. J. C. Letton and M. J. Yunker, U.S. Patent 4,318,818 to the Procter & Gamble Company (1982). 3. R. D. Bush, D. S. Connor, S. W. Heinzman, and L. N. Mackey, U.S. Patent 4,663,071 to the Procter & Gamble Company (1987). 4. B. J. Akred, E. T. Messenger, and W. T. Nicholson, British Patent 2,153,839 A to Albright & Wilson Limited (1985). 5. G. Broze, D. Bastin, and L. Laitem, U.S. Patent 4,749,512 to Colgate Palmolive Company (1988). 6. M. Julemont and M. Marchai, British Patent 2,116,119 A to Colgate Palmolive Company (1982).
Page 19
7. R. J. Dumbrell, J. P. Charles, I. M. Leclerq, R. M. A. de Bakker, P. C. E. Goffinet, B. A. Brown, R. E. Atkinson, and F. E. Hardy, British Patent 1,549,180 to the Procter & Gamble Company (1979). 8. J. C. Letton, U.S. Patent 4,228,042 to the Procter & Gamble Company (1980). 9. U.S. Patent 4,129,527, F. P. Clark, R. C. Johnson, and J. Topolewski to the Clorox Company (1978). 10. C. K. Choy, F. I. Keen, A. Garabedian, and C. J. Spurgeon, U.S. Patent 4,695,394 to the Clorox Company (1987). 11. G. Barker, in Surfactants in Cosmetics (M. M. Rieger, ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1985.
2 Hydrotropy STIG E. FRIBERG and CHRIS BRANCEWICZ Department of Chemistry and Center for Advanced Materials Processing, Clarks Potsdam, New York I. Introduction II. Historical Review III. Fundamentals IV. Cleaning and Washing V. Summary References
I. Introduction Liquid detergent concentrates commonly contain hydrotropes to avoid excessive the formulation and to improve their detergency. Both functions rely on the funda properties of hydrotropes. In this chapter, historical knowledge about the function of hydrotropic molecules i reviewed, followed by a description of hydrotropic action in liquid detergents usi commercial hydrotrope with an unusual structure. II. Historical Review The term “hydrotropy” was coined in 1916 by Neuberg [1,2], who found that aq solutions of certain salts possessed the ability to enhance the solubility in water of otherwise waterinsoluble substances. He found that the alkali metal salts of benz salicylic acid, benzenesulfonic acid and its
Page 22
many derivatives, naphthoic acid, and various other hydroaromatic acids displayed hydrotropic activity. In his study, Neuberg investigated a large number of organic solutes, such as carbohydrates, alcohols, aldehydes, ketones, hydrocarbons, esters, ethers, lipids, fats, and oils. The second phase or period of activity started 30 years later, with an emphasis on chemical engineering and industrial applications. McKee [3] showed that concentrated aqueous solutions of very soluble neutral salts of organic acids, such as sodium benzoate (NaB), salicylate (NaS), benzenesulfonate (NaBS), ptoluenesulfonate (NaPTS), xylenesulfonate (NaXS), cumenesulfonate (NaCS), and cymenesulfonate (NaCyS), increased the solubility of a wide variety of organic and some inorganic compounds in water. He noted that most hydrotropic solutions precipitated the solubilized solute on dilution with water and showed that this permits easy recovery of the hydrotrope for further use. Lumb [4] studied the ternary phase diagrams of systems consisting of water octanolpotassium alkanoates and, based on their similarities, postulated that the hydrotropy exhibited by the lower alkanoates (e.g., butyrate) and surfactant solubilization were essentially the same phenomenon. On the other hand, Licht and Wiener of the University of Cincinnati [5] agreed with McKee [3]. They attributed the increase in solubility to a “saltingin” effect rather than by a similarity in structure to surfactants. The final comparison with surfactant phase equilibria was made two decades later when Lawrence [6], Friberg and Rydhag [7], and Pearson and Smith [8] presented phase diagrams for hydrotropes. These phase diagrams demonstrated hydrotropic solubilization as an extension of surfactant solubilization into less ordered systems. In modern times, hydrotropes have found many applications. Their use includes the pharmaceutical field, with solubilization of drugs, specifically temazepam [9] and the coronary vasodilator nifedipine [10]. Hydrotropes have shown promise in enhancing the action of drugs with such combinations as theophylline with insulin [11] and have been utilized to improve transdermal delivery systems [12]. In chemical engineering, the original McGee [3] approach was recently continued in such processes as catalysis and extraction [13,14]. It is also used in the paper and pulp industry [15–19]. The application in liquid detergents is a direct consequence of the fundamentals of hydrotropic solubilization. Hence, in this chapter we first describe hydrotropic action in general, followed by a treatment of an unusual hydrotropic agent in the context of detergency. III. Fundamentals There are two essential features of hydrotrope solubilization: comparatively large concentrations of hydrotrope are required to initiate solubilization, and the
Page 23
maximum amount solubilized into the aqueous hydrotrope solution is large compared with what is found in an aqueous micellar solution of a surfactant. These two characteristics are illustrated in Fig. 1 [7]. The dashed line shows the strongly enhanced solubility of octanoic acid in a sodium xylene sulfonate solution at concentrations in excess of 20% by weight of the hydrotrope. The contrast between a solubility of less than 1% for concentrations at 15% of the hydrotrope and the rapid increase to more than 30% by weight of octanoic acid at higher concentrations illustrates the typical properties of hydrotrope mediated
Fig. 1 The solubility of octanoic acid into an aqueous solution of a hydrotrope sodium xylene sulfonate, dashed line, requires high concentrations of the hydrotrope to initiate solubilization (~20%), but the solubilization increases steeply to large values for small increases in hydrotrope concentrations above those values. The surfactant (sodium octanoate), on the other hand (solid line), requires lower concentrations to start the solubilization (~5%) but the maximum solubilization is limited.
Page 24
solubilization. The contrast between the values for the dashed and solid lines illustrates the distinction of hydrotrope solubilization from that by a surfactant, in this case sodium octanoate. The solubilization of the octanoic acid with the surfactant is initiated at a much lower concentration than with the hydrotrope, but the maximum amount of the acid solubilized remains at a modest level of less than 8%. The comparison with surfactant solubilization offers an immediate explanation for the high concentration of hydrotrope required to initiate the solubilization. It has been well known for many years [20] that a surfactant with a shorter hydrocarbon chain has an increased value of the critical micellization concentration (CMC). The CMC is the concentration at which solubilization begins. Hence, the high hydrotrope concentration for initial solubilization (Fig. 1) is reasonable and expected because the phenyl group is analogous to only three to four carbons in a straight chain. The very high hydrotrope concentration for initial association of the molecules and the accompanying solubilization are given a rational explanation. The much higher values of solubilized material for the hydrotrope in comparison with the values for the surfactant (Fig. 1) are understood first after a more complete phase diagram is considered for the two compounds. Figure 2 reveals the essential features of the two solubilized mechanisms. Increased amounts of octanoic acid in the surfactantwater solution give rise to several phases, four of which are illustrated in Fig. 2. Area a in Figure 2 consists of an aqueous solution of normal micelles, the structure of which is shown in Fig. 3a. At higher surfactant concentrations a liquid crystalline phase containing cylindrical surfactant associations stacked in a close packed hexagonal array is formed. This region is labeled area d in Fig. 2, and its structure is shown in Fig. 3d. At increasing concentrations of octanoic acid, a lamellar liquid crystal is formed, as shown in Fig. 2, region c. This phase has a structure of “infinite” bilayers of surfactant interlaced with layers of water, as shown in Fig. 3c. A further increase in the content of the solubilizate results in the formation of an octanoic acid solution of inverse micelles, which contain water solubilized in their cores. This region is shown as area b in Fig. 2, and the structure of an inverse micelle is depicted in Fig. 3b. The essential feature of the phase diagram is the presence of the lamellar liquid crystal region, which separates the normal micellar solution (Fig. 3a) from the solution of inverted micelles (Fig. 3b). This is in strong contrast to the conditions with hydrotrope (Fig. 2) for which only one solubility region (Fig. 2) of significance is found with increasing
Page 25
Fig. 2 When water and octanoic acid (solid lines) are combined with sodium octanoate, four phases are obtained: a and b are micellar solutions (Fig. 3a and b), and c and d are liquid crystals (Fig. 3c and d). The combination with a hydrotrope sodium xylene sulfonate, dashed line, gives a single area of an isotropic solution (e).
Fig. 3 The amphiphile organization in a normal micelle (a), in an inverse micelle (b), in a lamellar liquid crystal (c), and in a liquid crystal of hexagonally packed amphiphile cylinders (d).
Page 26
amounts of octanoic acid. As shown by the dashed line, a continuous isotropic liquid phase reaches from the aqueous corner to 80% octanoic acid without interruption. With this information, the reason for the “anomalously” high solubilization by the hydrotrope is obvious. Its solubility region is not interrupted by the formation of a liquid crystal; the shift from water continuous to octanoic acid continuous solution now takes place without a phase transition. It is essential to realize that the phase changes when octanoic acid is added to the watersodium octanoate combination are not a question of solubility. The octanoic acid is certainly soluble in the liquid crystalline phase, region c (Fig. 2) and infinitely so in its own solution, region b (Fig. 2). The different phases found in the surfactant system are only a matter of molecular organization of the system components, not of their mutual solubility. The similarity between the solubilization action of surfactant and hydrotrope (Fig. 4) is now immediately evident. The surfactant and hydrotrope solubility regions are analogous with the surfactant requiring lower concentrations because of its greater hydrophobic character. Hence, the difference between regions in Fig. 2 is not a distinction in solubility; numerous phases in the surfactant system in Fig. 2 are a result of packing restrictions imposed by the length of the hydrocarbon chains. The transition between normal and inverse micelles requires a lamellar packing for two hydrocarbons chains of eight carbons each. As the structures in Fig. 5 suggest, a combination of the bulky hydrotrope and the long hydrocarbon chain of a solubilizate does not stabilize a lamellar packing, and the transition from normal to inverse association structures takes place via disordered aggregates, as shown in Fig. 4b. IV. Cleaning and Washing These processes are mainly concerned with the removal of “oily dirt,” depending to a high degree on the complex phase equilibria encountered in the surfactantwater“oily dirt” system [21]. Two treatments have been published [22,23] on the action of a nontraditional hydrotrope structure in such systems. Instead of the usual bulky molecule (Fig. 5), this compound [24] is a dicarboxylic acid of considerable chain length (Fig. 6). The fundamental phenomena have been investigated of the action of this hydrotrope in a liquid cleaner. In such an application, the hydrotrope functions in the formulation concentrate by preventing gelation. In addition, under the dilute conditions in the washing process, the hydrotrope facilitates the removal of oily dirt from the fabric. In the following section these two functions are related to the phase equilibria of wateramphiphile systems. The formula for the dicarboxylic acid (Fig. 6) has a hydrophilic lipophilic balance similar to that of octanoic acid, but the influence of the two acids on
Page 27
Fig. 4 The total solubility region in the surfactant system (a) is similar to that of the hydrotrope (b); the only difference is that the change from normal to inverse association structures takes place via an ordered lamellar liquid crystal (a phase separation) in the surfactant case (a), and in the hydrotrope system the transition takes place over disordered aggregates within the solution (b).
amphiphilic association structures is entirely different, as can be seen in Fig. 7 [25]. The octanoic acid causes the formation of a liquid crystal when added to a solution of water in hexylamine. The size of the lamellar liquid crystalline region is large (Fig. 7a). Addition of the dicarboxylic acid, on the other hand, gives no liquid crystal, and it may be concluded that its action in con
Page 28
Fig. 5 The reason for the difference in transition structures, Fig. 4, is that the carboxylic acid and the surfactant (octanoic acid and sodium octanoate) are of similar chain length and a lamellar packing is easily stabilized. The difference in structure in the hydrotrope and fatty acid combination (sodium xylene sulfonate and octanoic acid), on the other hand, results in a disordered structure.
centrated systems is similar to that of the common shortchain hydrotropes despite its long hydrocarbon chain (Fig. 7b). Activity in dilute systems was investigated using a model system from Unilever [26] in which octanol mimicks the oily dirt. A lamellar liquid crystal was present at low concentration of the oily dirt [23], in the absence of the hydrotrope (Fig. 8). After addition of the hydrotrope, the amount of model oily dirt solubilized without liquid crystal formation was greatly enhanced. Clearly, this hydrotrope functions not only as a destabilizer of liquid crystals in the formulation concentrate but also as a destabilizer of liquid crystals under the dilute conditions of the washing process.
Fig. 6 The dicarboxylic acid hydrotrope has an elongated structure.
Page 29
Fig. 7 The combination of water and hexylamine with octanoic acid (a) gives a huge area of a lamellar liquid crystal (LC); the combination with the dicarboxylic acid in Fig. 6 results in an isotropic liquid solution only (b).
The molecular mechanism behind the destabilization of liquid crystals was clarified later [27]. The specific disordering brought forward by the hydrotrope in the watersurfactantoily dirt liquid crystal was first determined, followed by an investigation into the conformation of the diacid molecule itself [22]. The order of the hydrocarbon chains in a liquid crystal is directly obtained from nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra using amphiphiles with deuteriated chains. Each methylene group and the terminal methyl group give a NMR signal doublet, and the difference in frequency between the two signals is proportional to the order parameter [27]. Using a lamellar liquid crystal model system of “oily dirt,” surfactant, and water, the influence of the hydro
Page 30
Fig. 8 The solubilization of a model compound for oily dirt was small in a surfactant solution at concentrations below the CMC () because of the formation of a liquid crystal. A combination of hydrotrope and surfactant gave an increased solubilization (—) caused by the hydrotrope destabilization of the liquid crystal.
trope on the structure could be directly determined using NMR. Addition of the hydrotrope molecule resulted in a narrowing of the difference between the NMR signals due to a disordering of the liquid crystal, as shown in Fig. 9 [26]. It was assumed that this was the primary factor in the destabilization of the liquid crystal. Next, the diacid conformation was determined after it was added to the oily dirt liquid crystalline phase. Figure 10 shows two possibilities for the conformation of the hydrotrope in the liquid crystal. In one form of the diacid (Fig. 10b), both polar groups are located at the interface between the amphiphile polar groups and the water; the other possibility is that only the terminal carboxylic group is found at this site (Fig. 10a). The two conformations result in different interlayer spacing (Fig. 10), and a determination of this dimension was used to distinguish between the two alternatives. Lowangle xray diffraction gives the interlayer spacing directly from the maxima in the diffraction pattern. Interpretation of the results is straightforward; if addition of the diacid to a lamellar liquid crystal model dirt system did not increase the interlayer spacing, the conformation in Fig. 10b is correct; if an increase took place, then Fig. 10a would describe the structural organization of the diacid molecule. The interlayer spacing with the diacid added was very close to the host liquid crystal (Fig. 11), and the first conformation (Fig. 10b) is obviously the one encountered in the liquid crystal. As a comparison, the addition of oleic acid with one polar group located at the interface, gave the expected increase in interlayer spacing, as shown in Fig. 11. Destabilization of the lamellar liquid
Page 31
Fig. 9 Addition of a hydrotrope, Fig. 6, to a lamellar liquid crystal gave a reduction of the order parameter of the surfactant hydrocarbon chain ( ); addition of a surfactant gave no change in order ( ).
Fig. 10 A hydrotrope, Fig. 6, conformation with only one polar group at the water/amphiphile interface (left) results in an enhanced interlayer spacing d compared with the value d for a conformation with both polar 1
2
groups at the interface (right).
Page 32
Fig. 11 The lowangle xray values for interlayer spacing in a lamellar liquid crystal (×) was unchanged with the addition of a hydrotrope ( ), Fig. 6. Addition of a longchain compound, oleic acid, gave the expected increase ( ).
crystalline phase is not only affected by the diacid; it appears to be a general property shared by other hydrotropes, such as alkanols, shortchain quaternary ammonium salts, xylenesulfonates, and glycols, as shown by Pearson and Smith [8] and Darwish et al. [28]. In some cases, the oily dirt is less polar than the model system by Kielman and Van Steen [26]; for less polar fatty oils the concept of hydrotropic breakdown of a liquid crystal is also useful [29]. V. Summary The function of hydrotropes in the detergency is discussed against their interaction with lyotropic liquid crystals. The main activity of the hydrotrope as a part of a liquid detergent is to avoid gelation in both concentrated and dilute surfactant systems. This ability is directly related to a detergent's phase equilibria with hydrophobic amphiphiles. These phase equilibria illustrate and explain the two basic characteristics of hydrotropes: that is, their high association concentration and their pronounced solubilizing power.
Page 33
References 1. C. Neuberg, Biochem. Z., 76:107 (1916). 2. C. Neuberg, J. Chem. Soc., 110(II):555 (1916). 3. R. H. McKee, Ind. Eng. Chem. Ind. Ed., 38:382 (1946). 4. E. C. Lumb, Trans. Faraday Soc., 47:1049 (1951). 5. W. Licht and L. D. Wiener, Ind. Eng. Chem., 41:1528 (1949). 6. A. S. C. Lawrence, Nature (London), 183:1491 (1959). 7. S. E. Friberg and L. Rydhag, Tenside, 7:80 (1970). 8. J. T. Pearson and J. M. Smith, J. Pharm. Pharmacol., 26:123 (1974). 9. A. D. Woolfson, D. F. McCaffer, and A. P. Launchbu, Int. J. Pharm., 34:17 (1986). 10. N. K. Jain, W. Patel, and L. N. Taneja, Pharmazie, 43:254 (1988). 11. T. Nishihata, J. H. Rytting, and T. Higuchi, J. Pharm. Sci., 70:71 (1981). 12. D. W. Osborne, Colloids Surf., 30:13 (1988). 13. V. G. Gaikar and M. M. Sharma, Solvent Extr. Ion Exch., 4:839 (1986). 14. A. Mahapatra, V. G. Gaikar, and M. M. Sharma, Sep. Sci. Technol., 429:23 (1988). 15. G. E. Styan and A. E. Bramhall, Pulp Puu. Can., 80:725 (1979). 16. D. E. Bland, Res. Rev. Aust. CSIRO Chem. Technol., 27 (1976). 17. P. J. Nelson, Appita, 31:437 (1978). 18. D. E. Bland, J. Skicko, and M. Menshun, Appita, 31:374 (1978). 19. E. L. Springer and L. L. Zoch, Pap. 6:815 (1979). 20. K. Shinoda, Colloidal Surfactants, Academic Press, New York, (1963), pp. 9–15. 21. K. H. Raney and C. A. Miller, J. Coll. I. Sc., 119:539 (1987). 22. T. Flaim and S. E. Friberg, J. Coll. I. Sc., 97:26 (1984). 23. J. M. Cox and S. E. Friberg, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc., 58:743 (1981). 24. B. F. Ward, Jr., C. G. Force, A. M. Bills, and F. E. Woodward, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc., 52:219 (1975). 25. T. Flaim, S. E. Friberg, C. G. Force, and A. Bell, Tenside Detergents, 20:177 (1983). 26. H. S. Kielman and P. J. F. Van Steen, Faraday Disc., 191 (1979).
24. B. F. Ward, Jr., C. G. Force, A. M. Bills, and F. E. Woodward, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc., 52:219 (1975). 25. T. Flaim, S. E. Friberg, C. G. Force, and A. Bell, Tenside Detergents, 20:177 (1983). 26. H. S. Kielman and P. J. F. Van Steen, Faraday Disc., 191 (1979). 27. S. E. Friberg, S. B. Rananavare, and D. W. Osborne, J. Coll. I. Sc., 109:487 (1986). 28. I. A. Darwish, A. T. Florence, G. M. Ghaly, and A. M. Saleh, J. Pharm. Pharmacol., 40:25 (1988). 29. S. E. Friberg and L. Rydhag, J. Amer. Oil Chem. Soc., 48:113 (1971).
3 Phase Equilibria GUY BROZE Advanced Technology Department, ColgatePalmolive Research and Developm Milmort, Belgium I. Introduction II. What is a Phase Diagram? A. Twocomponent phase diagrams B. Threecomponent phase diagrams C. Recording phase diagrams III. Phase Diagrams for Ionic SurfactantContaining Systems A. Ionic surfactant: water B. Ionic surfactant, water, and organic material ternary systems C. Ionic surfactant, water, protondonating material, and hydrocarbon quaternary systems IV. Phase Diagrams for Nonionic SurfactantContaining Systems A. Nonionic surfactant and oil B. Nonionic surfactant and water C. Nonionic surfactant, water, and oil D. Effects of system parameters on phase behavior References
I. Introduction All liquid detergents contain at least one surfactant in the presence of other materi electrolytes, oily materials, and other impurities. Unlike academic research, the fo work with industrialgrade raw materials
Page 36
containing significant amounts of molecules, the properties of which differ from those of the main product. The understanding of how a given property of a give “pure” system is affected by “impurities” is accordingly of essential practical importance. Understanding the principles by which a given product behaves (as is or under use conditions) allows us to replace counterproductive trial anderror by more efficient methods with a broader range of potential applications. II. What Is a Phase Diagram? A phase diagram is a graphic representation of the phase behavior of a system studied. The solidliquidvapor behavior of a single compound as a function of temperature and pressure can be represented by a phase diagram. Phase diagrams usually involve more than one component. They are very useful tools for formulation, because they allow the formulator to define not only the acceptable composition of a product but also the order of addition of the different raw materials. A. TwoComponent Phase Diagrams 1. Temperature and Composition Whether a given proportion of two (liquid) compounds will mix is defined by thermodynamics. Although, in regular systems, the entropy of mixing is always positive and accordingly favorable to mixing, the enthalpy of mixing can be positive or negative depending on the energy of formation of the heterocontacts at the expense of the homocontacts. An exothermic mixture usually leads to mixing in all proportions. If the mixing is endothermic, the number of coexisting phases and their composition depend on temperature. Increasing temperature usually results in an increase in the mutual solubilities of the two compounds, eventually leading to complete miscibility above a critical temperature, the upper consolute temperature (UCT). Note that some abnormal systems can also present a lower consolute temperature (LCT). Both UCT and LCT are thermodynamic critical points. At a critical point, the compositions of the two phases in equilibrium become identical. Figure 1 is a schematic representation of a twocomponent phase diagram characterized by UCT. The left axis corresponds to pure A, and the right axis corresponds to pure B. the abscissa corresponds to different AB compositions. It is very common to express the compositions in weight fractions, although not compulsory. Mole fractions or volume fractions can also be used. The central, shaded area corresponds to the twophase domain. The clear zone around it is single phase.
Page 37
Fig. 1 Phase diagram of two substances that are only partly miscible at low temperature and become fully miscible above the “upper consulate temperature.”
2. Tie Lines and Lever Rule When a mixture separates in two phases, it is important to know the compositions and the amounts of the two phases in equilibrium. A tie line links the two compositions in equilibrium. This means that any composition located on the same tie line will separate in two phases, the compositions of which are defined by the points of contact of the tie line with the phase boundary. The relative amounts of the two phases is determined according to the lever rule (Figure 2). If the compositions are expressed in weight fractions, the weight fraction of phase A is CB/AB and the weight fraction of phase B is AC/AB. B. ThreeComponent Phase Diagrams Practical systems involve more than two components. A threecomponent system can be represented in an equilateral triangle (Figure 3). A corner of the triangle represents a pure component, a side represents binary mixtures of the components represented by the adjacent corners, and any point in the triangle represents one and only one tricomponent composition.
Fig. 2 Lever rule, allowing quantification of the proportion of the two coexisting phases in a twophase domain of a phase diagram.
Page 38
Fig. 3 Method of determining the composition of a threeingredient mixture.
The weight fraction of component A in the composition represented by P in the triangle is given by the ratio of the lengths of the segments perpendicular to the sides Pa/(P b + Pb + Pc). Similarly, the amount of B is given by Pb/(P a + Pb + Pc) and the amount of C by Pc/(P a + Pb + Pc). Of course, such a phase diagram is isothermal. The effect of temperature on a threecomponent phase diagram can be visualized in three dimensions, with temperature at the elevation axis. The phase diagram looks like a triangular prism, with every horizontal slice corresponding to one temperature. 1. Fields and Densities There is an important difference among the thermodynamic functions of state as far as phase equilibria are concerned. Some thermodynamic functions of state, such as temperature and pressure, have the same value in all the phases of a system at equilibrium. They are actually the forces driving a system to its equilibrium. Such functions are referred to as fields [1]. The other thermodynamic functions of state generally present different values in the different phases of a system at equilibrium. Typical examples are the volumes of the phases and their composition. Such functions are densities. A thermodynamic expression of functions of state can be expressed as a sum of field variables multiplied by their conjugated density. For example, G = U + PV TS + ini where U is the internal energy, PV is the product of the field variable pressure and the density variable volume, TS is the product of the field variable temperature and the density variable entropy; and ini is the product of the field variable chemical potential of i and the density variable number of moles of i.
Page 39
The chemical potentials are the field functions conjugated with the concentrations. 2. Phase Rule For a multicomponent system, the phase rule [2] allows us to know the number of independent variables necessary to define completely (from a compositional point of view) a system. This number is called the number of degrees of freedom or the variance of the system. The variance ƒ is given by the relation ƒ = C + 2 where C is the number of chemically independent ingredients in the system, is the number of coexisting phases at the equilibrium, and the last term takes care of temperature and pressure. For isobar systems, such as all systems under atmospheric pressure, the last term should be 1. Similarly, isobar and isotherm systems have 0 as the last term. A direct implication of the phase rule is that a threecomponent system in one phase at atmospheric pressure and at 25°C has a variance equal to 2. This means that two dimensions are necessary to describe such a system. Another implication is that such a system could show a maximum of three coexisting phases. A system based on five components will need, according to the phase rule, a fourdimension hyperspace to be completely described. To represent such a system, some variables are usually grouped. The accuracy of the representation is, of course, imperfect. A more accurate procedure is to set a variable to a constant value. This is impossible with a composition because it is a density and is different in each of the coexisting phases. The phase rule determines the number of independent variables a system needs to be represented but does not introduce any restriction on the choice of the independent variables. It is accordingly much better to fix a field variable to reduce a system of one dimension. Instead of using concentrations (density variables), a representation as a function of the chemical potentials is easier to read and is more accurate. The problem is that, in practice, it is very complicated to work at defined chemical potentials. 3. Tie Lines and Critical Points Let us consider two liquids A and B that are not very soluble in each other. Addition of liquid C increases the miscibility of B in A and of A in B. C behaves like increasing temperature in the binary phase diagram. The major difference is that the tie lines are no longer parallel to the baseline, and the critical end point is no longer at the maximum of the miscibility gap (Figure 4). This is because C does not partition evenly between the two coexisting phases.
Page 40
Fig. 4 A Winsor II ternary phase diagram.
In the present case, it goes preferably in B. The critical end point is located near the A corner. An isothermal critical end point is usually referred to as a plait point. 4. ThreePhase Domain In some cases a threephase region can be observed (Figure 5). The coexistence of three phases in equilibrium in an isothermal threecomponent phase diagram is a zerovariant situation. Of course, an infinity of different compo
Fig. 5 A Winsor III ternary phase diagram.
Page 41
sitions fall inside the threephase triangle, but the compositions of the three coexisting phases do not change with the initial composition. They are represented by the three corners of the threephase triangle. All that change are the relative amounts of the three phases. C. Recording Phase Diagrams There are basically two methods of recording phase diagrams: the titration technique and the constant composition method. Both have advantages and drawbacks. 1. Titration Method In the titration method, a mixture is titrated by another. Typically, a mixture of two of the ingredients is titrated by the third. The weight of titrant to reach a phase boundary is carefully recorded and plotted on the phase diagram. The process is then repeated to cover the whole domain to be investigated. Such a method is relatively quick and can give a good idea of the phase boundaries. There are nevertheless two major drawbacks to this method. First, this method gives the phase diagram at one temperature only. To determine the phase diagram at another temperature, the process must be repeated. The temperature domain practically available with the titration method is limited, because everything must be kept at the same temperature. The second drawback of the titration method is that it is usually used in an out ofequilibrium condition. In some systems, such as those involving lyotropic liquid crystals, the time needed to reach equilibrium can be very long; besides, metastable phases can also be encountered. A phase diagram recorded by the titration method should be used as a guide only and should never be applied to longterm stability prediction. 2. Constant Composition Method In the constant composition method, a series of compositions, covering the composition range to be studied, are prepared in test tubes, which are closed. The test tubes are shaken thoroughly and allowed to stand in a thermostatic bath. The test tubes containing turbid solutions are allowed to stand until they separate into two or more completely clear phases. The number of clear phases can be reported on the phase diagram, and the phase domains can be mapped. This method is very long, but it allows one to approach the true equilibrium conditions, and the tubes can be used at other temperatures. Another advantage of this method is that, when a system gives more than one phase, it is possible to analyze the phases and to know exactly where the phase boundaries are, as well as the orientation of the tie lines.
Page 42
III. Phase Diagrams for Ionic SurfactantContaining Systems A. Ionic Surfactant: Water 1. Krafft Point The Krafft point can be defined as the temperature Tk above which the amphiphile solubility in water greatly increases [3]. The reason is that the water solubility of the amphiphile, which increases with the temperature, reaches the amphiphile critical micelle concentration (CM in Figure 6). When the solubility curve is above CM, the dissolved amphiphile is forming micelles and the amphiphile activity in water solution no longer increases. There is accordingly no longer a limitation to solubilization. The Krafft point is a triple point because at this temperature, three “phases” coexist [4]: hydrated solid amphiphile, individual amphiphile molecules in solution (monomers), and amphiphile molecules involved in micelles. Tk increases as the hydrophobic chain length increases. The Krafft points of the sodium salts of the classic amphiphiles (alkyl sulfates, sulfonates, and benzenesulfonates) are below room temperature. The Krafft point is also a function of the counterion, the alkalineearth cations giving higher Krafft points: sodium laurylsulfate, Tk = 9°C; Ca salt, 50°C; Sr salt, 64°C; and Ba salt, 105° C. Because the Krafft point imposes a limitation in formulation processes, the following rules to reduce Tk can be of essential interest: Chain branching and polydispersity reduce Tk. Complexation of Mg and Ca reduces Tk.
Fig. 6 The Krafft point is the temperature at which the solubility of the amphiphile becomes higher than its critical micelle concentration.
Page 43
The presence of an unsaturation decreases Tk. A very efficient way to reduce Tk is to incorporate two or three oxyethylene monomers between the hydrophobic chain and the polar head group (alcohol ethoxy sulfates). Of course, in each case, other properties of the amphiphile, such as the surface activity, can be consequently be modified. 2. Phase Diagram The phase diagram of sodium dodecyl sulfate/water is representative of many ionic systems (Figure 7) [5]. Liquid (L1) is the aqueous micellar phase; Ha is the hexagonal lyotropic liquid crystal, sometimes called the middle phase; and La is the lamellar lyotopic liquid crystal, sometimes called the neat phase. On the surfactantrich side, several hydrated solid phases are present. As a general rule, in any (real) phase diagram, at any point representative of a region and on its boundaries, the number of phases and their nature are similar. A tie line is the line joining the points representative of two coexisting phases. If the total composition of a mixture C falls in a twophase region, it separates in the two phases located at both sides of the tie line that passes the formulation point (A and B). The weight distribution of the two phases is given by the lever rule.
Fig. 7 Typical phase diagram of a wateranionic surfactant system.
Page 44
B. Ionic Surfactant, Water and Organic Material Ternary Systems 1. Organic Material = Hydrocarbon Let us consider an isotherm of a waterionic amphiphile binary mixture above the Krafft point (for example, watersodium octanoate) [6]. At an amphiphile concentration of 7% (the critical micellar concentration), the micellar isotropic solution L1 appears and lasts up to 41%. Between 41 and 46% is the miscibility gap between L1 and H1, the hexagonal phase, which lasts up to 52%. Above 52% is the miscibility gap between H1 and the hydrated crystal. If a nonpolar component (aliphatic hydrocarbon or tetrachloromethane) is added, almost nothing happens (Figure 8a). The solubility of decane in either the micellar solution or the liquid crystal is very limited. This is true of any molecule exhibiting only dispersion cohesive forces. 2. Organic Material = Polar but Not ProtonDonating Material The solubility of a molecule exhibiting dipoledipole cohesive forces and low H bonding cohesive forces, such as methyl octanoate, is higher than that of a hydrocarbon, but nothing special happens in the center of the phase diagram. 3. Organic Material = ProtonDonating Material If the third component is a nonwatersoluble alcohol (five carbons or more), amine, carboxylic acid, or amide, the phase topography is profoundly modified. The phase diagram presented in Figure 8b [7] shows in addition to L1 and H1 a huge lamellar phase, a narrow reverse hexagonal phase H2, and, even more important, a “sectorlike” area of reverse micelles L2. This means that the solubility in ndecanol of a sodium octanoatewater mixture containing between 25 and 62% amphiphile is by far more important (30–36%) than pure water (4%) and pure sodium octanoate (almost nil). This phase is essential to obtain water in oil (w/o) microemulsions. The solubility of ndecanol in the L1 phase is also important (up to 12% at the “end” of the L1). The L1 phase is responsible for the observation of oilinwater (o/w) microemulsions. The La domain, generally located in the middle of the diagram, points toward the water side for a critical surfactant/cosurfactant ratio. (A 1:2 sodium octanoate to ndecanol ratio leads to a lamellar phase with as little as 17% surfactantcosurfactant.) In some cases, such as octyl trimethyl ammonium bromidehexanolwater, the lamellar phase already exists for 3% hexanol + 3% OTAB! The practical interest of a lamellar liquid crystal lies in its suspending capability. A lyotropic liquid crystal exhibits a viscoelastic behavior that allows
Page 45
Fig. 8 (a) Typical ternary phase diagram of water, an amphiphile (sodium octanoate), and a hydrocarbon (octane). (b) Typical ternary phase diagram of water, an amphiphile (sodium octanoate), and a coamphiphile (decanol). This phase diagram was established by Ekwall in 1975.
suspension of solid particles for a very long time. The lamellar phase is additionally characterized by an ideal critical strain to provide the suspension with good resistance to vibrations and convections, without impairing its flowability by a slimy aspect.
Page 46
C. Ionic Surfactant, Water, ProtonDonating Material, and Hydrocarbon Quaternary Systems The solubilization of an oil, such as decane, in the micellar isotropic solution L1 or in the reverse micellar isotropic solution L2 can be very important. L1 leads to water in oil (w/o) microemulsions and L2 to oilinwater (o/w) microemulsions. Note that the “cosurfactant” is an amphiphile with (generally) a lower molecular weight than the “main” amphiphile, the “surfactant.” 1. WaterinOil Systems As illustrated by Figure 9, the L2 phase is able to solubilize a very large amount of an hydrocarbon, such as decane or hexadecane. In fact, a composition containing up to 75% decane and water/surfactant/cosurfactant proportions corresponding to the L2 phase is still clear, fluid, and isotropic, forms spontaneously, and is thermodynamically stable. The structure of this microemulsion can be (to some extent) regarded as a dispersion of tiny water droplets (reverse micelles) in a continuous phase of the hydrocarbon. The surfactant and cosurfactant are at the water/oil interphase. This type of system is often referred to as a waterinoil microemulsion. The term “microemulsion” to qualify such systems is not well chosen: it conveys the idea of an actual emulsion characterized by submicrometer (below 0.1 m) droplets. As is well known, an emulsion is not thermodynamically stable and cannot be represented by a single phase domain in a thermodynamic phase diagram. On the other hand, the socalled microemulsions must be considered real micellar solutions containing oil in addition to water and surfactants.
Fig. 9 A “waterinoil” microemulsion.
Page 47
These solutions, although very far from “ideal” in the thermodynamic sense, are nevertheless always real in the thermodynamic sense. Another great difference between the microemulsions and the emulsions is that, in the very general case, a microemulsion requires significantly more surfactant than an emulsion. These waterinoil microemulsions exhibit other important characteristics: The domain of existence is large. Significant compositional changes can occur without crossing a phase boundary. Such behavior is particularly important for manufacturing processes, because it tolerates some “freedom” during formulation. They are very stable in a large temperature range, usually from the Krafft point up to the boiling point. Moreover, the phase boundaries are almost insensitive to temperature. The phase topography remains almost unchanged even up to 75% of the ionic amphiphile is replaced by a nonionic amphiphile. To obtain a wide waterinoil microemulsion, it is essential to adjust carefully the cosurfactant structure (usually its chain length) and its relative amount. Although trial and error is still the most commonly used method of obtaining microemulsions, a tentative rule is to combine a very hydrophobic cosurfactant (ndecanol; C10OH) with a very hydrophilic ionic surfactant (alcohol sulfates) and a less hydrophobic cosurfactant (C6OH) with a less hydrophilic ionic surfactant (octyl trimetyl ammonium bromide). For very hydrophobic ionic surfactants, such as dialkyl dimethyl ammonium chloride, even a watersoluble cosurfactant, such as butanol or isopropanol, is adequate (this rule derives at least partially from the fact that an important feature of the cosurfactant consists of readjusting the surfactant packing at the solvent/oil interface). 2. OilinWater Systems We stated earlier that the solubility of decane in the L1 phase is almost nil. For a welldefined surfactant/cosurfactant ratio, huge quantities of decane (or any hydrocarbon) can be solubilized from the L1. A thin, snakelike single phase domain develops toward the oil pole (Figure 10). This phase can be regarded as amphiphile micelles swollen with oil. Generally, the oilinwater microemulsion phases are only metastable systems. As every metastable system, o/w microemulsions need an activation energy to separate, and sometimes this activation energy is so large that the separation almost never occurs. Such systems are not thermodynamically stable and could accordingly not be considered in a phase diagram. On the other hand, they form spontaneously and are stable (because of the high activation energy for separation) for a very long time.
Page 48
Fig. 10 An “oilinwater” microemulsion.
A typical example of a very stable metastable system is a mixture of one volume of oxygen with two volumes of hydrogen. The mixture is spontaneous and stable for a very long time, without being thermodynamically stable. The final thermodynamically stable state is obtained by adding a catalyst (platinum foam) or a flame to the mixture. Although not thermodynamically stable, o/w microemulsions form spontaneously and are accordingly useful (ease of manufacture). Nonthermodynamic stability implies some constraints: The position of a o/w microemulsion can depend on the order of mixing of the raw materials and on the shear imposed on the system. Their domain of existence is generally narrow. The system can be sensitive to freeze and thaw cycles. IV. Phase Diagrams for Nonionic SurfactantContaining Systems The phase topography of a ternary system involving water, a hydrocarbon, and a polyethoxylated fatty alcohol depends on the hydrocarbon chain length, branching, degree of insaturation, aromaticity, and so on, on the amphiphile structure (hydrophobic and hydrophilic chain length), and also on temperature, which exerts a very strong influence on the configuration (and accordingly on the solubility) of the polyoxyethylene segments in water solution. A review has been presented by Kalhweit et al. in a series of papers [8–11].
Page 49
The phase topography is strongly influenced by the more elementary behavior of the binary amphiphileoil and amphiphilewater systems. A. Nonionic Surfactant and Oil Polyethylene oxide is not soluble in a hydrocarbon, such as hexane or decane. If a fatty chain is attached to a short segment of polyethylene oxide (4–8 EO units), the nonionic amphiphile obtained exhibits a solubility profile in oil depending on temperature. At low temperatures, a miscibility gap is obtained, translating the nonsolubility of the polyethylene oxide chain in the oil. At high temperatures, the effect of the energy is preponderant and the amphiphile is soluble in all proportions in the oil. As predicted by the FloryHuggins theory, such a system shows a lower miscibility gap characterized by an upper critical point, the temperature Ta which depends on both the oil and the amphiphile structure (Figure 11a). The critical composition is usually not far from the pure oil side. Figure 11b shows the lower miscibility gap between some nalkanes and C6E5 (nhexanol ethoxylated with 5ethylene oxide molecules). The upper critical temperature Ta rises with increasing the oil chain length (its hydrophobicity). The critical temperature Ta is often referred to as the haze point temperature, and the miscibility gap between oil and amphiphile plays an essential role in the ternary phase diagram.
Fig. 11 (a) The haze point temperature. (b) Set of phase diagrams showing how the haze point temperature is affected by the structure of the oil.
Page 50
B. Nonionic Surfactant and Water 1. Cloud Point The phase diagram of the binary system nonionic amphiphilewater is more complicated (see Figure 12). A “classic” upper critical point exists, but usually below 0°C. At higher temperatures, most nonionic amphiphiles show an upper miscibility gap, which is actually a closed loop with an upper as well as lower critical point. The lower critical point Tb is often referred to as the cloud point temperature. The upper critical point often lies above the boiling temperature of the mixture (at 0.1 MPa pressure). The position and the shape of the loop depend on the chemical nature of the amphiphile. The cloud point temperature Tb plays an essential role in three component phase diagram topography. The closed loop can be regarded as a vertical section through a “nose” in the concentrationtemperaturepressure space, at constant pressure (see Figure 13a). When the pressure rises, the surface covered in the temperature concentration phase by the phase separation loop decreases and vanishes at a critical pressure P*. The shrinking of the loop of the system waterC4E1 with increasing pressure is given in Figure 13b. The critical conditions for the loop to vanish are T* = 95° C, P* = 80 MPa, and C* = 28 wt%. To show the multidimensional nature of these phenomena, note that similar effects (shrinking of the loop, f.i.) can be achieved by the addition of “hydrotropic” electrolytes at constant pressure or by increasing the hydrophilicity of the amphiphile. Figure 13c exhibits the loop areas of butanol (C4EO), ethylene glycol butyl ether (C4E1), and diethylene glycol butyl ether (C4E2). The last does not exhibit a loop at 0.1 MPa (± 1 atm), but the system behaves actually as if the nose were “lurking.” Although no phase separation occurs in
Fig. 12 The phase behavior of a waternonionic amphiphile system.
Page 51
Fig. 13 (a) The effect of pressure on the size of the “closed loop.” (b) Closed loop of the system waterethylene glycol butyl ether at different pressures. (c) Effect of the hydrophilic group of the amphiphile on the shape of the closed loop. (From Ref. [16], with permission.)
water, the lurking nose exerts some influence on the threecomponent phase diagram. Another way to look at the same phenomenon is to consider that, in conditions close to T = 90°C and C = 30 wt%, the C4E2water system is such that the mixing entropy is just high enough to maintain the molecules in a single phase, the enthalpic term being positive (endothermic). As soon as a third incompatible ingredient (the oil f.i.) is incorporated, the entropy is no longer able to maintain the molecules in a single phase, and phase separation occurs.
Page 52 TABLE 1
Amphiphile
HLB
min (wt%)
C4E1
10.3
58.9
48.7
29.0
C6E3
12.7
47.4
45.4
13.5
C8E4
12.6
29.6
39.6
6.9
C10E5
12.5
19.7
40.3
3.5
C12E6
12.4
10.6
48.0
2.2
b
(°C)
Cb (wt%)
In Table 1, the HLB is calculated according to the empirical equation HLB = 20 MH/M where MH is the molar mass of the hydrophilic group and M the total molar mass of the product. g min is the minimum amphiphile concentration required for the homogenization of a 1:1 mixture of water and ndecane at around 40°C (wt%). Tb and Cb are the coordinates of the lower critical points (cloud point). Although the HLB seems to be correlated with the cloud point, it cannot give any information on the amphiphile efficacy (g min). Even if the HLB remains constant, increasing both the polar part and the nonpolar part of a surfactant molecule significantly improves its efficacy (at least its wateroil compatibilizing efficacy). 2. Liquid Crystals The closed loop is not the only characteristic of the nonionic surfactantwater binary phase diagram. Like the ionic surfactantwater mixture, the nonionic surfactants, at a higher concentration in water, exhibit lyotropic mesophases. Figure 14 shows a typical binary phase diagram exhibiting the full lyotropic mesophase sequence: I1: cubic, isotropic phase H1: direct hexagonal phase (middle phase) V1: special cubic (viscous phase) La: lamellar phase (neat phase) Note the presence of the twophase domains surrounding each mesophase, the critical point on top of each, and the zero variant threephase situation. Although very difficult to determine with accuracy, the miscibility gaps always exist, as well as the threephase situations. Of course, the critical temperatures and concentrations corresponding to each mesophase depend on the chemical nature of the amphiphile, the pressure, and the optional presence of an electrolyte.
critical point on top of each, and the zero variant threephase situation. Although very difficult to determine with accuracy, the miscibility gaps always exist, as well as the threephase situations. Of course, the critical temperatures and concentrations corresponding to each mesophase depend on the chemical nature of the amphiphile, the pressure, and the optional presence of an electrolyte.
Page 53
Fig. 14 Binary phase diagram of a waterethoxylated nonionic amphiphile phase diagram, including lyotropic liquid crystal domains. (From Ref. [11], with permission.)
Figure 15 shows some examples of nonionic amphiphilewater binary phase diagrams [10,12]. As a rule, amphiphiles with hydrocarbon chain length of 8 or fewer carbon atoms exhibit only the loop (in a domain depending on the ethoxylation) and no mesophase. Longer chain amphiphiles show one or more mesophases, one being preponderant. The type of main mesophase (the one exhibiting the highest critical temperature) depends on the relative volumes of the EO and hydrocarbon chains. If the volumes are similar, the lamellar phase is preponderant. This is the case with C12E6. If the volume of the EO chain is significantly higher than the volume of the hydrocarbon chain, the hexagonal phase will melt at higher temperature (C12E7); if the volume of the EO chain is much higher than the volume of the hydrocarbon chain, the cubic phase I1 may appear. In some cases, such as C12E5, the lamellar phase La (or the H1) interferes with the loop (with the cloud point curve) and induces the socalled critical phase, L3. L3 is an isotropic, often lactescent phase, exhibiting a zerovariant three phase critical point at its lower temperature of existence. The nature of the three phases in presence at the critical conditions are W (water with a minute amount of amphiphile), L3 and La. The L3 phase seems to have a beneficial action on cleaning performance, maybe because of the presence of the critical point. C. Nonionic Surfactant, Water, and Oil From the phase behavior of both binary mixtures (wateramphiphile and oil amphiphile), it is now possible to account, at least qualitatively, for the three component phase diagram as a function of temperature. The presence of a haze point on the oilamphiphile phase diagram (critical point a) at temperature Ta shows that the surfactant is more compatible with the oil at high temperature
Page 54
Fig. 15 Real examples of waterethoxylated nonionic amphiphile binary phase diagrams. (From Ref. [10], with permission.)
Page 55
than at low temperature. The presence of a cloud point on the water amphiphile phase diagram (the lower critical point ) at temperature Tb shows that (at least in the neighborhood temperature domain) the amphiphile is less compatible with water at high than at low temperatures. As a consequence (the other parameters being kept constant), the amphiphile behavior depends on temperature. At low temperature, these mixtures are more compatible with water than with oil. The phase diagram corresponding to this situation is illustrated in Figure 16, a1 or a2. The tie line orientation is directly deduced from the partitioning of the amphiphile between water and oil: because under the current conditions the surfactant is more compatible with water than with oil, the majority of the amphiphile is in the water phase and only a limited amount of amphiphile is present in the oil. Accordingly, the tie lines point in the direction of the oil corner. Diagrams a1 and a2 (Figure 16) are referred to as Winsor I (WI). If the temperature at which the phase diagram is recorded lies above Ta (the haze point), a critical point CPa is present near the oil corner (although pure amphiphile and pure oil are miscible, the presence of a small amount of water “recalls” the lack of compatibility between amphiphile and oil). On the other hand, if the temperature lies below Ta, no critical point appears in the three component phase diagram (it seems to lie for a negative water concentration). At high temperatures, these mixtures are more compatible with oil than with water. The phase diagram corresponding to this situation is c1 or c2 in Figure 16. The amphiphile partitioning now favors the oil, and the tie lines point in the direction of the water corner. c1 and c2 are referred to as Winsor II (WII). A critical point CPb is found if the temperature lies below the cloud point
Fig. 16 Evolution of waterethoxylated nonionic amphiphileoil ternary phase diagrams with temperature (rising from a to c).
Page 56
Tb but more often, the critical point lies outside the Gibbs triangle (T > Tb ). In WI and WII representations, the critical point CPb or CPa is called a plait point. If the temperature difference between the temperature T at which the phase diagram is recorded and the critical point of the binary mixture. Tb or Ta, increases, the distance from the plait point to the oilamphiphile axis for CPb and wateramphiphile for CPa increases, too. An important characteristic of a ternary system is the line that links the plait points as a function of temperature. The plait point curve is really the trace of the partitioning of the amphiphile between oil and water. The closer to the oil is the plait point, the amphiphile is more in the water, and vice versa. At low temperatures, the amphiphile is more compatible with water because water interacts strongly with the hydrophilic head group. Accordingly, the hydrodynamic volume of the head group is greater than the hydrodynamic volume of the hydrocarbon tail. At high temperatures, head group hydration is reduced and so is hydrodynamic volume, which becomes smaller than the hydrodynamic volume of the hydrocarbon tail. There is necessarily a temperature at which the hydrodynamic volumes of the two antagonistic parts of the amphiphile molecule are equal. This particular temperature, represented by , is the phase inversion temperature (also called the HLB temperature). The phase inversion temperature is a characteristic (and is accordingly a function) of the nature of the oil, the amphiphile, and the brine (if electrolytes are present). If the pressure can vary (as in oil recovery), it also changes . It is important to realize that can be higher than both CPb and CPa when the amphiphile solubility is very small in water and total in oil. The topography of the phase diagram at the phase inversion temperature depends on the mutual incompatibilities between oilamphiphile, water amphiphile, and wateroil. Even with a polar oil and water containing a chaotropic (hydrotropic) electrolyte, the wateroil incompatibility is high enough to guarantee a miscibility gap from 0 to 100°C. With the amphiphile, the situation is not as simple. We showed that, at , the amphiphile is equally compatible with water and oil, but no assumption is made about the degree of compatibility. Two limit cases can occur: 1. The amphiphile is either very compatible with both water and oil or not very incompatible. The phase diagram will look like Figure 16 b1, with a plait point only for an equal amount of oil and water and with the lines parallel to the wateroil side. (equal partitioning). This plait point corresponds to the merger of the CPa and CPb lines, and the projection of the plait point curves on the oil watertemperature phase diagram should look like Figure 17a or b. 2. The amphiphile is equally (and significantly) incompatible with both water and oil. The phase diagram will now look like Figure 14 b2. A threephase triangle (3PT) appears.
Page 57
Fig. 17 Transition from an infratricritical situation (a and b) to a supertricritical situation (d and e) through a tricritical point (c). (From Ref. [11], with permission.)
Three phases are now in equilibrium: 1. A waterrich phase (W) 2. An oilrich phase (O) 3. An amphiphilerich phase (S) The amphiphilerich phase is also called the surfactant phase or the middle phase. The last terms, due to Shinoda, results from the physical appearance of a threephase body: 1. A dense, waterrich phase at the bottom 2. A light, oilrich phase at the top 3. A phase containing most of the amphiphile in the middle It is worth noting that with higher molar volume amphiphiles, such as C12E4, a significant amount of the amphiphile can be present in the oil phase, even at . Here, too, the plait points CPa and CPb will be or will not be inside the Gibbs triangle depending on the relative positions of , Ta, and Tb . If the phase diagram exhibits a threephase triangle, it is called a Winsor III (WIII) system. In such a situation, the plait point curves do not merge but “cross” each other and stop at two terminal critical points (see Figure 17d or e). The sequence of the evolution of a threecomponent system when temperature has risen can be summarized as follows. If the amphiphile is strongly incompatible with oil and water, WI
WIII
WII
If the amphiphile is compatible or is weakly incompatible with oil and water, WI
WII
A way to modify amphiphile compatibility with oil and water is to change its molecular weight, keeping the proper balance between oleophobicity and hydro
Page 58
phobicity. A highmolecularweight amphiphile like C12E6 will show a WIWII WII sequence, although a lowmolecularweight amphiphile like C4E2 will show (with decanol acetate as the oil) a WIWII sequence. By varying the amphiphile (in)compatibility through its molecular weight, it is possible to pass from a WIWII to a WIWIIIWII sequence. At a certain point, a situation as illustrated in Figure 15c will occur: the plait point curves just merge critically and the threephasetriangle (3PT) collapses. This situation corresponds to a tricritical point, an essential concept in theoretical thermodynamics. When the system is such that a 3PT appears (by far the most common case), the 3PT exists from a temperature T1 lower than to a temperature Tu above . To some extent, the difference between T1 and Tu is a measure of how far the system is from the tricritical conditions. (Note that is not necessarily the average of Tu and T1.) The thermal evolution of a typical system, with broken critical lines (see Fig. 18), can be summarized as follows: At T < T1, the phase diagram is a typical WI. T1 is the temperature of the critical end point of the CPb curve. At T = T1, the phase diagram is still a WI, but with a critical tie line from which the three phase triangle will appear a fraction of Kelvin above. For T1 < T < , the corner of the threephase triangle corresponding to the amphiphile phase remains close to the water side but moves “clockwise” in the Gibbs triangle. For T = , the amphiphile corner of the threephase triangle reaches “12 o'clock” (phase inversion temperature). For < T < Tu the corner of the threephase triangle corresponding to the amphiphile phase keeps on “moving clockwise” to the oil phase. Tu is the temperature of the critical end point of the CPa curve. At T = Tu, the amphiphile corner of the threephase triangle merges with its oil corner and the threephase triangle collapses in a critical tie line of a WII phase topography. At T > Tu, the phase diagram is a typical WII. It is important to remark on the shape of the line joining the three corners of the threephase triangle (G lines). It is a single, gauche line, with a minimum at T1 on the water side of the critical tie line and a maximum at Tu on the oil side of the critical tie line. These branches can be identified (Ga, Gb , and Gg), each corresponding to the compositions of each corner of the threephase triangle. It is important to note that Ga has nothing to do with CPa and that Gb has nothing to do with CPb . Gi are composition curves, and CPi are critical point curves. At a critical end point, however, the critical point curve meets the extreme of
u
the critical tie line. These branches can be identified (Ga, Gb , and Gg), each corresponding to the compositions of each corner of the threephase triangle. It is important to note that Ga has nothing to do with CPa and that Gb has nothing to do with CPb . Gi are composition curves, and CPi are critical point curves. At a critical end point, however, the critical point curve meets the extreme of the composition curve (CPa meets Ga at Tu and CPb meets Gb at T1).
Page 59
Fig. 18 Detailed evolution of the phase diagram of a wateroilethoxylated nonionic amphiphile (low molecular weight) with temperature. (From Ref. [11], with permission.)
Another important characteristic of these systems is that the best compatibility capacity is achieved at T = , when the hydrodynamic volumes of both parts of the surfactant are equal. Under phase inversion conditions, the amount of amphiphile needed to compatibilize a mixture of equal amounts of oil and water is minimal. The phase inversion conditions are accordingly looked for to minimize the amphiphile quantity needed to achieve a given task. Winsor behavior is not the only characteristic of wateroilnonionic amphiphile systems. The lyotropic mesophases appearing on the wateramphiphile binary phase diagrams expand to some extent in the Gibbs triangle (Figure 19). Amphiphiles based on alcohols lower than C8 do not generate liquid crystal at all (amphiphiles based on C4 and less do not even give micelles). C10 and above alcoholbased nonionic amphiphiles exhibit lyotropic liquid crystals, at least usually up to Tu. Figure 19 shows the typical and general behavior of ternary system with an amphiphile giving liquid crystals. At temperature below T1, each lyotropic mesophase appearing on the wateramphiphile binary
Page 60
Fig. 19 Ternary phase diagrams involving nonionic amphiphiles generating lyotropic liquid crystals with water. (From Ref. [11], with permission.)
phase diagram expand in the Gibbs triangle. At a temperature close to , generally only the lamellar liquid crystal phase is present, and points toward the amphiphile corner of the threephase triangle. Above Tu, all the liquid crystals are molten. D. Effects of System Parameters on Phase Behavior 1. Nonionic Surfactant Structure Tu, T1, and increase if more and more hydrophilic amphiphiles are used. This is easily explained by the HLB concept: a more hydrophilic amphiphile will remain in water up to a higher temperature. Another fundamental effect of the amphiphile is a result of its molecular weight (or molar volume): increasing the molecular weight of an amphiphile at constant HLB results in the fact that much less amphiphile is required to compatibilize equal amounts of water and oil, as illustrated by Figure 20. 2. Effect of Oil (a) Molar Volume. Increasing the oil molar volume results in an increase in Tu, T1 (if they exist), and . This is illustrated in Figure 21 for aliphatic
Pag
Fig. 20 Effect of the molecular weight of the amphiphile on the shape of the ternary phase diagra (From Ref. [10], with permission.)
hydrocarbons, alkyl benzenes, and alkanol acetate mixtures with water and diethylene glycol monobutyl ether (C4E2). Increasing the oil molar volume corresponds to increasing the oilwater incompatibility: another result is the increase in the temperature difference betwee Tu and T1. This is illustrated by the alkyl benzene series, which presents a tricritica point for an alkyl chain length between 6 and 7. (b) Polarity. Because increasing the oil polarity (by shifting from aliphatic hydrocarbons to alkyl benzenes to alkanol acetates) decreases the wateroil incompatibility, it is not surprising that the Winsor transitions (Tu, T1, and ) occu at lower temperatures and the supertricriticality decreases. The polarity of the oil can be estimated from Hansen's threedimensional solubilit parameters. Hansen separated Hildebrand's solubility parameter into three independent components: d for the dispersion contribution, p for the polar contribution, and h for the H bonding contribution. As an estimation of the oil polarity, we define Dph as the square root of the square of the polar
Fig. 21 Effects of oil molar volume and polarity on the characteristics of ternary phase diagrams obtained with water and diethylene glycol butyl ether.
Page 62
component plus the square of the H bonding component of the solubility parameter, using the table published by Barton [13]. For ternary mixtures of alkanes, alkyl benzenes, or alkanol acetates with water and C4E2, the phase inversion temperature can be satisfactorily expressed as (°C) = 1.016V 0.00121V2 44.72Dph + 4.747D2ph 2.74 (1) V is the oil molar volume in ml/mol and Dph is the oil polar character in MPa½ . The effects of the molar volume and that of the polarity appears to be independent, at least in this specific case. 3. Effect of Electrolytes It is possible to modify the behavior of water by adding electrolytes. Electrolytes usually reduce the solubility of uncharged organic ingredients in water. Although the great majority of electrolytes exert a saltingout action, several exceptions exist, such as perchlorates and thiocynates. These salts are saltingin. The saltingout or in characteristics of electrolytes were discovered at the end of the nineteenth century by Hofmeister [14] and remain a mystery. It has been established that this effect has nothing to do with ionic strength: different salts at the same ionic strength present different saltingout or in characteristics. Besides, unlike a classic electrostatic effect, it is almost linear with salt concentration (at least in the low concentration range). In water, the effects of anions are much more pronounced than the effects of cations. The sequence of anions of increasing salting out character in aqueous solutions is as follows: Nitrate < chloride < carbonate < chromate < sulfate On the other hand, perchlorates and thiocyanates are saltingin electrolytes. A saltingout electrolyte strengthens the structure of water and makes it less available to hydrate organic molecules; saltingin electrolytes would, on the other hand, disrupt the structure of water, creating “holes.” It is noteworthy that saltingin electrolytes usually have a positive enthalpy of solubilization in water (endothermic solubilization). In practice, saltingout electrolytes make water even more incompatible with oil. The result is a decrease in the Winsor transition temperatures and an increase in the supertricritical character. The amount of amphiphile necessary to compatibilize water and oil generally increases in the presence of a salting out electrolyte. Of course, all these tendencies are inverted with a saltingin electrolyte. Figure 22 illustrates the effects of different electrolytes on a C4E2 C13 acetatewater system.
Page 63
Fig. 22 Effect of the nature of the electrolyte and its concentration on the characteristics of ternary phase diagrams obtained with water, diethylene glycol butyl ether, and tridecanol acetate.
4. Effect of LowMolecularMass, WaterSoluble Organic Molecules Water can be made less incompatible with oil by adding small, uncharged, watersoluble organic molecules, such as amides and substituted ureas [15]. High saltingin performance is obtained with organic molecules with the following characteristics: Amphiphilic structure Hydrophobic segment short enough to prevent aggregation Concentration well below the solubility limit Typical examples are urea derivatives, especially butyl urea. 5. Emulsions Unlike the systems described above, emulsions are not thermodynamically stable systems. They are dispersions of one liquid phase within another, helped with a surfactant. Oilinwater emulsions are dispersions of oil droplets in a continuous aqueous phase and waterinoil emulsions are dispersions of water in an oily continuous phase. Multiple emulsions may also exist: an aqueous core surrounded by an oil phase, itself dispersed in an aqueous continuous phase. The size of the dispersed droplets ranges from a fraction of a micron to 50 microns. Accordingly, emulsions are milky, nontransparent systems. They are also subject to phase separation on aging, and their behavior does not depend only on their composition, but also on the process of producing. To date, the formulation of emulsions remains highly empirical.
Page 64
The general principle behind emulsion formulation is that one must generate a large surface of contact between water and oil. It is easier to do this if the interfacial tension between water and oil is as low as possible. Surfactants are accordingly very helpful. The choice of the surfactant depends on the nature of the oil and the desired structure of the emulsion. Oilinwater emulsions should be formulated with surfactants exhibiting a hydrophilic head group larger than their lipophilic tail, and reciprocally. The physical stability of emulsions depends on a lot of internal and external factors. The size of the droplets is very important, as it directly conditions the rate of separation , according to Stokes' law 126290064a.gif
Where is the difference of density between the solid particle and the liquid, r is the radius of the droplet and is the viscosity of the continuous phase. It has to be pointed out that Stokes' law is valid only in the case of a single droplet not interacting with the continuous phase. The observed separation rate may be very different than the one predicted; nevertheless, it is important to keep it in mind. The dispersed droplets necessarily collide with each other. The collisions can be elastic (they just bounce) or inelastic. In such a case, they can just stick together and form a cluster. This is called “flocculation” and it usually induces viscosity modifications long before visible phase separation is observed. When two droplets stick together, the film separating them may break and the droplets can join to form a larger droplet. This is called “coalescence.” One may think that better emulsion stability would be obtained with higher surfactant quantity. This is not true. Optimum stability is obtained with an optimum amount of surfactant. One possible explanation of emulsion destabilization with too much surfactant is that the surfactant in excess forms micelles, which bombard emulsion droplets, due to Brownian motion. If two droplets happen to be close together, even if they do not attract each other, they are pushed into contact by the no longer balanced collisions, as there are less micelles between the two droplets than in the bulk. References 1. Griffiths, R. B., and Wheeler, J. C., Phys. Rev., A2, 1047–1064 (1970). 2. Ricci, J. E., The Phase Rule and Heterogeneous Equilibrium. Van Nostrand, New York, 1951. 3. Krafft, F., Ber. Deutsche Chem. Ges., 32, 1596–1608 (1899). 4. Shinoda, K., Solvent Properties of Surfactant Solutions, Vol. 2, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1967, pp. 12–16.
Page 65
5. Kekicheff, P., GabrielleMadelmont, C., and Ollivon, M., J. Colloid Int. Sci., 131, 112–132 (1989). 6. Ekwall, P., Mandell, L., and Fontell, K., Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst., 8, 157– 213 (1969). 7. Friman, R., Danielsson, I., and Stenius, P., J. Coll. Interface Sci., 86, 501–514 (1982). 8. Kalhweit, M., Lessner, E., and Strey, R., J. Phys. Chem., 87, 5032 (1983). 9. Kalhweit, M., Lessner, E., and Strey, R., J. Phys. Chem., 88, 1937 (1984). 10. Kalhweit, M., Strey, R., and Haase, D., J. Phys. Chem., 89, 163 (1985). 11. Kalhweit, M., and Strey, R., Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 24, 654 (1985). 12. Mitchell, D. J., Tiddy, G. J. T., Waring, L., Bostock, T., and McDonals, M. P., J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans., 1, 79, 975–1000 (1983). 13. Barton, A. F. M., Handbook of Solubility Parameters and Other Cohesion Parameters, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1983. 14. Hofmeister, F., Arch. Exp. Patol. Pharmackol., 24, 247 (1888). 15. Broze, G., Comm. J. Com. Esp. Deterg., Barcelona, 20, 133 (1989). 16. Schneider, G., J. Phys. Chem. (Munich), 37, 333 (1963).
4 Rheology of Liquid Detergents R. S. ROUNDS Fluid Dynamics, Inc., Piscataway, New Jersey I. Introduction II. Patent Survey of Liquid Detergent Formulations III. Rheological Measurements A. Steady Shear Viscometry B. Dynamic Mechanical Spectroscopy C. Extensional Viscometry IV. Product Delivery Vehicles A. Dispersed Systems B. Highly Concentrated Dispersions C. Gels and Microgels D. Stability V. Fundamental Research in Liquid Detergents A. Surfactant Solutions B. Surfactant Liquid Crystal Gels C. PolymerSurfactant Interactions VI. Conclusions References
Page 68
I. Introduction Common household liquid detergent products can exhibit remarkable rheological properties, depending on the structured or unstructured delivery system selected for a specific formulation. Whether solution, dispersion, or gel, these products can display rich rheological attributes, including solidlike properties in the quiescent state with transitions to fluid flow, allowing flow through dispensers, and facile application to intended organic and inorganic surfaces. Thixotropy is a commonplace property, as are yield stresses and pseudoplasticity, and dilatancy and rheopexy are also observed. The most general survey of the rheology of commercial liquid detergents shows clearly that these fluids span the entire range of the viscoelastic spectrum, including both personal and home care products. Consumers have a wide range of product selections within most product categories, ranging from low viscosity solutions to highly elastic gel compositions, depending on individual preferences. Rheology design and control is a difficult task, however, considering the complexity of many of these formulations, consisting of surfactants, surfactant mixtures, electrolytes, hydrotropes, polymers, various conditioners, builders, fragrances, pigments and dyes, and so on, with many potential associative interactions. Fundamental rheological research has provided insight into various mechanisms available to product formulators to regulate rheological attributes of these complex fluids. The complex nature of the rheology of surfactant systems has been known and studied for many decades. The elasticity of specific surfactants in the presence of electrolytes was deduced initially from simple observations of elastic recoil and steady shear viscosity measurements. In 1926, for example, Hatschek and Jane [1] determined ammonium oleate, in excess ammonia, to have a highly structured order, with both significant elastic and timedependent properties. Similar results were reported by Winsor for potassium oleate in the presence of potassium salts, such as potassium acetate or carbonate [2]. Research continued to determine the nature of this phenomena, exploring the morphology of the surfactant in aqueous solutions in the presence of various additives. The existence of viscoelastic surfactant systems in the dilute regime sparked interest in defining the organization of the micelles in these systems. In 1954, Pilpel speculated about the presence of long, interlinked cylindrical micelles forming coherent, yet transient network structures as the basis for the formation of viscoelastic surfactant gels [3,4]. His research was directed at gels formed from soaps in the presence of fatty alcohols, perfluoro compounds, and various simple electrolytes. Further, Nash [5,6] investigated conditions of gel formation in dilute, twocomponent, cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB)/naphthol solutions, also proposing the formation of long, cationic filaments resulting in polymerlike viscoelastic behavior.
Page 69
These early research efforts were a preface to the extensive rheology research of surfactant systems currently in progress. Interest in the rheology of surfactant systems and multicomponent liquid detergent products has continued to grow, playing a more comprehensive role in the characterization of these complex fluids and guiding product development research in the academic and industrial sectors. Both steady shear and dynamic mechanical measurements elucidate the structure and morphology of surfactant micelles and their corresponding mechanical properties, in concert with other characterization techniques, leading to fundamental structureproperty relationships. In addition, a considerable effort has been directed towards theoretical modeling of the observed rheological behavior. Much of the growing emphasis on the rheology of liquid detergents and their product components has been advanced by the development of sophisticated, programmable, rheological testing instrumentation with highsensitivity transducers, required for the characterization of these fluid systems. This chapter broadly summarizes the technical literature and reviews the fundamentals of rheological measurements relevant to detergent systems. Rheological profiles of various commercial liquid detergents and their components will also be presented from personal care and household care product categories, emphasizing product delivery vehicles and including both steady shear and dynamic mechanical and extensional properties. The principles of rheology, with definition of terms and derivation of appropriate mathematical expressions, are not included, however, because excellent references are available in these subject areas [7–26]. II. Patent Survey of Liquid Detergent Formulations The importance of the rheology of liquid detergents is well reflected in the patent literature. Frequently, mechanical properties such as viscosity, yield stresses, thixotropy, and various viscoelasticity parameters are the principle objects of the invention, reflecting the importance of these properties in defining product aesthetics and consumer experience in product usage. Rheology or, at least, consistency, is a dominant liquid detergent patent theme. Several examples include a thickened aqueous abrasive cleanser with “use favorable” rheology [27], a thickening colloidal suspension stabilized through association with surfactant for incorporating whitening agents in a bleach composition [28], stable, lowviscosity liquid detergents consisting of lamellar dispersions or vesicles within an aqueous continuous phase [29], and acrylic maleic acid builder copolymers as dispersion stabilizers and viscosity modifiers for structured and unstructured liquid detergents [30]. One patent
Page 70
discloses a liquid detergent composition that increases viscosity upon dilution to provide benefits to the consumer during use [31]; another presents viscosity improvers for aqueous solutions of nonionic surfactants for applications in shampoos, hand soaps, fabric care, and hard surface care detergents [32]. The patent literature teaches many methods of rheology modification and control throughout product shelf life, although full rheological characterizations are not typically provided. The recent patent literature has seen a new emphasis on the viscoelastic nature of liquid detergents. One example is a linear viscoelastic automatic dishwasher detergent composition with improved physical stability and flow properties incorporating a polymeric thickening agent [33,34], providing an alternative to claythickened dispersions. Whereas many previous patents describe viscosity or yield stress values within the product definition, this patent defines the viscoelastic nature of the liquid detergent product through dynamic mechanical properties, including the strain dependence of the storage and loss modulus. Viscoelastic gel detergent compositions are also the subject of a patent issued to Lever Brothers Co., with creep compliance data provided to support evidence of gel formation [35]. A lowfoaming automatic dishwashing detergent composition gel is also the subject of a patent issued to the Drackett Company. “Gel” characteristics are supported only by the presence of a yield stress, extrapolated from Brookfield viscosity data [36]. Gelled or thickened laundry detergents and hard surface cleaners containing bleach compounds have seen considerable growth during the past few years. Thickened aqueous bleach compositions formed through the addition of a viscoelastic surfactant system, comprised of surfactant ions and organic counterions, have also been proposed [37], suitable as hard surface cleaners, with delivery through manual spray nozzle dispensers. Advantages include reduced misting as a result of the viscoelastic nature of the solution, as well as suitable rheology for adherence to vertical surfaces [38], good phase stability, bleach stability, and stable viscosity. The Proctor and Gamble Company has patented liquid or gel laundry compositions containing amido peroxy acid bleach showing good stability in the presence of perfume ingredients [39], stable cleansers containing chlorine bleach and phytic acid [40], and a stable thickened aqueous bleach composition formulated with hypochlorite and a mixture of highmolecularweight polycarboxylate polymer and amine oxide surfactant, applicable to toilet bowl cleansers, bathroom tiles, and shower walls. Akzo Nobel NV has also been granted a patent for a stable yet pourable aqueous bleachcontaining composition with waterinsoluble peroxy acid suspended in a mixture of two or more polymers. The preferred organic peroxy acid is cited as 1,12diperoxydodecanedioic acid [41]. Additional patents have also been granted for various thickened hard surfaces cleaners and drain clearing compositions [42–45]. Viscoelasticity is highlighted,
Page 71
formed through association of quaternary ammonium compounds with suitable counterions, for example, providing consumeracceptable pour properties. Of particular interest is a patent issued to the Clorox Co. for viscoelastic formulations, citing a Trouton ratio of greater than 50 for select compositions [46]. An unusual gel delivery vehicle for a detergent composition based on the phase behavior of surfactant systems is described in another patent issued to Procter and Gamble, containing ethoxylated alkyl sulfate surfactant in hexagonal liquid crystal form [47]. We have reviewed only a small segment of the vast liquid detergent patent portfolio, yet the emphasis on product rheology, viscoelasticity, and extensional flow behavior is noteworthy. A significant industrial focus is directed toward the development of liquid detergents with tailored rheological attributes appropriate for the intended application. III. Rheological Measurements Rheological and viscometric measurements relevant to the study of commercial liquid detergent compositions and their many components are very diverse, and selection of the appropriate measurement tool is dependent on (1) the objective of the measurement and (2) the nature of the fluid under investigation. The nature of the liquid composition or the delivery system is an important consideration in the selection of rheological test methods, and this is addressed in greater detail in the following sections. A. Steady Shear Viscometry Viscosity is a very obvious material property requiring specification in the design of a liquid detergent product. It is one design element that directly influences the acceptability of the complete product formulation, its ease of manufacture, the package and dispenser orifice design, product appearance, and numerous consumerperceived product attributes. As such, it is necessary to complete viscosity measurements accurately within the appropriate shear rate or shear stress range of interest. Process engineers, for example, may require constitutive equations describing the steadystate viscosity function at shear rates and temperatures experienced during manufacture, for specification of process equipment and determination of process conditions and process simulations. These requirements are quite distinct from those concerned with transient viscosity behavior or the flow resistance of products encountered by the consumer throughout product usage, such as dispensing from a container, pouring, application to a surface, and drainage. If a product is being evaluated for dispensability through a packaging orifice, the shear rate to be used in the viscometric study must be estimated from
Page 72
the geometry of the orifice and the discharge rate or linear velocity of the fluid through the orifice. The objective of this measurement is very clearly to define fluid response, under conditions simulating product dispense. This is a transient, converging flow, occurring very rapidly, and flow resistance at the inception of flow, or + = ƒ(t), or during an accelerated flow, = ƒ(d /dt) for short flow durations, may be the most appropriate testing format. A creep measurement is a reasonable alternative if estimates of the forces involved are available. A summary of several viscometric tests commonly applied to the characterization of liquid detergents and their raw materials is provided in Figure 1, with examples of typical fluid responses. Viscosity measurements require a fundamental understanding of the definition of viscosity describing the proportionality between the stress tensor and the rate of deformation tensor : = Viscosity, a scalar, is a function of the invariants Ii of the rate of deformation tensor . For viscometric flow of incompressible fluids, = ƒ(I2) I2 = ( : ) =
i
j
ij ji
Viscometric measurements require simple, unidirectional flow in restricted geometries such that analytic solutions of the differential equations describing the flow exist, directly enabling viscosity calculations [48]. Rotation viscometers, especially those equipped with computer control and data acquisition firmware, can very effectively be used to generate flow curves or determine viscosity functions, = ƒ( ), for most fluid systems. Newtonian fluids can be readily distinguished from nonNewtonian fluids and time dependent shear effects can be easily quantified. Many liquid detergents and their components are not simple Newtonian or nonNewtonian fluids but exhibit either thixotropy or rheopexy. These timedependent shear effects can significantly complicate the generation of flow curves, because an additional variable, duration of shear, that is, = ƒ( ,t), must be considered. In addition to viscosity measurements of both Newtonian and nonNewtonian fluids, rotational viscometry is often used to evaluate yield stresses, normal stress differences, timedependent properties, and structural parameters. Steady shear viscometers are commercially available with normal force transducers, needed to calculate normal stress differences. These measurements are of critical importance in viscometry to define completely the rheological state of a fluid, because practical implications of normal stress effects can occur in processing liquid detergents. The Weissenberg effect in mixing, for example,
Page 73
FIG. 1 Experimental test methods frequently applied to the characterization of liquid detergents, with examples of typical fluid responses.
is perhaps the best known. These measurements, however, are difficult to complete for low viscosity fluids. If we assume simple unidirectional flow between a cone and plate testing geometry, as shown in Fig. 2, the expressions for viscosity and primary nor
Page 74
FIG. 2 Cone and plate viscometric fixture with derivation of equations for the calculation of viscosity and first normal stress coefficient.
mal stress coefficient, 1, in terms of experimental variables are provided. Normal force is the sole experimental parameter generally measured in commercial viscometric instruments, leaving the secondary normal stress coefficient, 2, undetermined. For liquid detergents that are simple, isotropic, Newtonian solutions, viscosity determinations are sufficient to fully characterize resistance to flow, if normal stresses are not present. Examples of such products include most liquid hand dishwashing detergents and certain personal care, hard surface cleaners and laundry detergent products. Linear Newtonian flow curves, = ƒ( ), for several commercial products, selected from household hard surfaces cleaners marketed in the United States, are shown in Fig. 3. We have included one concentrated detergent that shows obvious deviation from Newtonian behavior, in the shear rate range of 0–25 s1. Hard surface cleaners, hard surface cleaners containing bleach, liquid laundry detergents, and shampoos are among products that can occur as simple, isotropic, Newtonian fluids or as unstructured systems. It is interesting to note that products that are represented as “gels” are frequently viscous Newtonian fluids, although there are occasional exceptions. Many consumer products exhibit more complex flow behavior in viscometric evaluations, depending on the composition and physical form of the liquid composition and more rigorous rheological characterizations are required fully to
Page 7
FIG. 3 Viscosity as a function of shear rate for a representative sampling of U.S. home care liquid detergent products, determined at 25°C using the Rheometrics Scientific RFSII with parallel plate test geometry.
appreciate flow resistance in a manufacturing environment, flow behavior during product use, physical product appearance, and so on. These products, including dispersions and gellike fluids, are generally nonNewtonian, viscoelastic, and may also exhibit time dependent mechanical properties. Figure 4 contains representative flow curves, = ƒ( ), for several personal care products which exhibit nonlinear viscosity functions, that is, nonNewtonian fluids. Liquid detergent products fully embrace the full viscoelastic spectrum, as we see when representative commercial detergents are characterized in oscillatory measurements. Thixotropy, a decrease in viscosity occurring with increasing time of shear at constant shear rate, is a wellknown viscometric property often displayed by various structured liquid detergent products, especially dispersed systems; rheopexy is a more novel response. Figures 5 and 6, for example, show the viscosity as a function of time for two commercial personal care products during stress growth measurements at 0.05 s1, for a 60 s time interval. These two liquid detergents, both dispersions, exhibit very different responses to the same
Pa
FIG. 4 Viscosity as a function of shear rate for several randomly selected personal care cleansers, determined at 25°C using the Rheometrics Scientific RFSII with parallel plate tooling.
FIG. 5 Viscometric behavior, = ƒ(t) of a commercial skin cleanser in response to a constant shear rate of 0.05 s1 at 25°C. Data obtained using the Rheometrics Scientific RFSII with parallel plate tooling. +
Page 77
FIG. 6 Rheopectic behavior of a commercial conditioning shampoo, determined through stress growth measurements, + = ƒ(t) at 0.005 s1 and 25°C using the Rheometrics RFSII and parallel plate geometry.
applied deformation. In Fig. 5, we see thixotropy following a stress overshoot; while the second detergent (Fig. 6) appears to be thickening, or rheopectic, under identical experimental conditions. In further experimentation, the product exhibiting rheopexy showed no equilibration to an equilibrium shear stress following an increase in shear duration to 6000 s. The ease with which the internal physicochemical microstructure is eroded in shear and the kinetics of the structural reformation following shear are characteristics of structured fluids that can be investigated using rotational viscometry. Such products, for example, may appear to be very thick and rich in composition yet relatively easy to dispense. For these complex fluids, phenomenological characterizations have attempted to define structural parameters predictive of the timedependent viscosity functions [49–52]. A review of various models attempting to model thixotropic behavior is provided by Ultrecht et al. [53]. Thixotopy is a truly complex phenomenon, involving longrange interactions between product components yielding threedimensional network structures, or coagulation structures, with potential reversible transitions. In the structured state, such fluids may exhibit significant elasticity and timedependent inelastic flow when exposed to a sufficient external force. Equations predictive of time and
Page 78
sheardependent flow behavior for thixotropic fluids, with and without yield stress, are unavailable at this time, although limited empiricisms have been developed for specific dispersions. B. Dynamic Mechanical Spectroscopy When detergents are formulated as structured viscoelastic fluids, dynamic mechanical spectroscopy can be an essential tool in the definition of the strength and cohesiveness of the internal ordering, in addition to susceptibility to strain. Measurements of storage and loss modulus as a function of strain can easily quantify the facility with which the structure can be degraded, the ability of that internal microstructure to reform, and the extent of reformation. The same measurements, completed as a function of deformation period, define the “architecture” of the fluid in the most general sense. Dramatic differences occur between unstructured versus structured liquid detergents, solutions versus gels, dilute versus concentrated dispersions, and so on. Both measurements, G', G'' = ƒ( ) and G', G'' = ƒ( ), are valuable in defining the structured state. Oscillatory rheometers are now designed under controlled strain or controlled stress modalities, capable of applying a sinusoidal strain or stress to the fluid under test. Under controlled strain operating conditions, the two independent variables are the frequency and the amplitude of the applied deformation 0, shown in Fig. 7, with examples of typical responses of ideal fluids, both viscous, elastic, and a representative viscoelastic substance. There are two dependent variables: the amplitude 0 of the fluid response and the phase angle between the applied deformation and the measured oscillatory response. It is typically assumed that the oscillatory response is sinusoidal, similar to the applied deformation, although there are fluid systems for which this assumption may be incorrect. The harmonics associated with these measurements and the resulting errors have been discussed in the literature [54]. For structured fluids exhibiting yielding behaviors, nonlinear waveforms are frequently encountered [55,56]. Figure 8 com+pares the storage and loss modulus as a function of strain for two shampoo products, one which is unstructured in its commercial form A, a simple viscous solution, and the other, a structured viscoelastic gellike fluid B. As we would expect, for the unstructured shampoo, G " > G', and both parameters are independent of strain or deformation amplitude. The structured gel, however, exhibits a noticeably different response: G' > G " and G', G " = ƒ ( ). For structured elastic detergents, it is often observed that the elastic modulus, G', decreases appreciably with increasing strain, reflecting the sensitive nature of the internal structure. Figure 9 summarizes the dynamic mechanical properties of a gelled laundry spot remover. This product exhibits a clearly defined linear viscoelastic region and a retarded frequency dependence in the frequency range of 0.01–100 rad/s
Page
FIG. 7 Sinusoidal strain and the corresponding responses of a purely elastic, a viscous, and a viscoelastic fluid.
FIG. 8 Storage and loss modulus as a function of strain for two liquid detergent products determined at a frequency of 10 rad/s and 25°C.
Pag
FIG. 9 Viscoelasticity of gel laundry strain remover. (a) Complex moduli as a function of strain at 10 rad/s; (b) complex moduli as a function of frequency at a strain of 0.02. Measurements were completed at 25°C using the Rheometrics Scientific RFSII and parallel plate geometry: 50 mm diameter and 0.9 mm plate spacing.
Page 81
similar to the structured shampoo and reflecting gellike behavior. In this range, G' > G", or tan <1, where tan is defined as G "/G'. To demonstrate further the breadth of the viscoelastic spectrum embraced by liquid detergents, Fig. 10 summarizes tan = ƒ( ) and tan = ƒ( ) for body cleansing shower and bath personal care products. Although many of these products appear to be quite similar in their viscometric properties under certain shear conditions, many consumer perceived product attributes indicate significant differences, which are well captured in dynamic mechanical rheological characterizations [57]. C. Extensional Viscometry Very limited research has been published on the elongational flow properties of surfactant solutions, yet elongational or “stretching” flows are frequently encountered by liquid detergents in process environments and in use by the consumer. During manufacture, elongational flow may be experienced during spray drying or atomization, mixing, flowthrough pumps and pipeline transport, converging flows, filling, high shear dispersing, and other mechanisms. During consumer use, examples include the simple act of dispensing a liquid detergent from an orifice, application of a liquid detergent to a surface through a spray nozzle and rubbing or coating a surface with the detergent. Extensional flows represent a very important area of study for commercial liquid detergents and diluted aqueous solutions, representing consumer usage conditions. Research has shown that polymeric systems experience conformational changes in extensional flows. In certain cases, dilatancy and chain scission can occur [5863]. Recently, research has been extended to include surfactant systems. For example, relative elongational viscosity as a function of elongational rate has been determined for a cationic surfactant, C16TASal, in an aqueous solution at a concentration at 600 and 900 ppm, with evidence of a shearinduced structuring [64]. The effect of preshearing on the elongation viscosity is also determined at preshearing rates of 203600 s1. For example, preshearing at 80 s1 produces the greatest increase in elongational viscosity at a surfactant concentration of 900 ppm, attributed to the formation of a shear induced structured state. At the higher preshearing rates, the elongation viscosity is reduced and the relative elongation viscosity appears to be a decreasing function of elongation strain rates. Data are also presented for dilute polyethylene oxide solutions. Extensional viscosity measurements have been completed for dilute polyacrylamide and xanthan gum solutions in flowthrough opposing jets [65,66], showing the difference in flexible chain versus rigid rodlike polymer conformations. A commercial instrument based on this design is available from
Page 82
Page 83
FIG. 10 Comparison of the strain and frequency dependence of tan for a representative sampling of shower and bath body cleansers from the U.S. and European markets. Data obtained at 25°C using the Rheometrics Scientific RFSII and parallel plate test geometry. (a) Unstructured Newtonian or nearly Newtonian products. (b) Highly structured elastic formulations. (c) Comparison of the frequency dependence of both structured and unstructured products determined at = 0.02 and 25°C using the Rheometrics Scientific RFSII and parallel plate geometry.
Rheometrics Scientific, Inc. (Piscataway NJ), believed to be the only commercially available extensional viscometer. Other flow configurations for extensional viscosity measurements have been proposed in various academic communities [67–70]. Spinnability and viscoelasticity for aqueous solutions of alkyl and oleydimethylamine oxides and sodium alginate have also been investigated [71]. Both ductile failure and polymeric viscoelasticity are reported. Equally significant are interfacial elongational viscosities, also known as dilational viscosities, referring to the elongational viscosity of an interface. This is a critical parameter in foam stability, a very important characteristic for many liquid detergents [72,73]. A comprehensive theoretical review of surface rheology is provided by Edwards and Wason [74–77].
Page 84
IV. Product Delivery Vehicles Liquid detergent products can be broadly divided into three distinct delivery systems: (1) isotropic, clear, unstructured solutions, (2) structured opaque or translucent dispersion, and (3) structured transparent gels, as shown in Fig. 11. As we can see, there is overlap in this systems definition, as concentrated particulate dispersions can exhibit gellike behavior, although differentiation is provided by the clarity of the vehicle. Each of these three delivery systems has unique rheological characterization requirements to define effectively their rheological states in a process environment, throughout shelflife and during consumer use. In rheological measurements, the second classification, opaque or translucent dispersions, is the most difficult to characterize. Depending on the volume fraction of the immiscible phase(s), the particle size distribution, shape of particulates, surface charge, presence of adsorbed components, and degree of flocculation, such systems can be highly elastic fluids, with both time and sheardependent properties. The importance of the product delivery vehicle and its influence on rheology is summarized very effectively by Goodwin for dispersions in Fig. 12 [78]. From the perspective of the product development scientist, the product delivery vehicle, composition and internal ordering of product components, determines rheological behavior. Our discussions regarding the rheological properties of commercial liquid detergents is based on fundamental product delivery systems, that is, solutions, dispersions, or gels. Dispersions include both solid
FIG. 11 Representation of the three major product delivery systems used in liquid detergent formulations and corresponding rheological features.
Page 85
FIG. 12 Generalized structure/property diagram of dispersions. (From Ref. 78.)
inliquid colloidal and large particulate suspensions, in addition to liquidliquid emulsions. A. Dispersed Systems Fundamental rheological studies of controlled model systems provide an excellent overview of the rheological behavior of these complex systems. For dispersions, comprehensive theoretical and experimental studies have been completed, providing very basic evaluation of both material and process variables influencing product rheology. Although it is well beyond the scope of this chapter to provide a detailed review of the rheology of dispersions, a brief overview of the technology is provided. For liquid detergents, dispersions are a very common type of delivery system, because of insolubility or immiscibility of vital product components in aqueous solvents, such as inorganic solids used as builders in heavyduty liquid detergents and conditioning oils formulated into shampoos. It becomes a formidable task to the product development scientist to generate acceptable rheological properties of colloids, large particulate suspensions, or emulsions while ensuring longterm stability against phase separation or sedimentation. From a rheological and physicochemical perspective, the primary distinction between these dispersed systems is in the size, volume fraction, surface chemistry, and deformability of the dispersed phase. For example, foams, in fact, may also be considered dispersions, similar to emulsions, with a low density, gaseous dispersed phase [79–82].
Page 86
The introduction of an immiscible phase into a solvent system frequently alters the rheological characteristics of the solvent carrier fluid, the modification of properties being a function of the size and shape of the dispersed phase, its volume fraction, and the physical chemistry of both the continuous (solvent) and dispersed (particulate) medium. Flow of dispersions is governed by a multitude of thermodynamic and spatial steric factors, including Brownian, hydrodynamic, gravitation, van der Waals, and electrostatic forces [83,84]. The viscosity of a dispersion is frequently described in terms of the relative viscosity r, which is the ratio of the suspension viscosity, , to the viscosity of the continuous phase, 0, as a function of the volume fraction of the dispersed phase n:
The dramatic influence of the volume fraction of the dispersed phase on the relative viscosity of a dispersion is shown in Fig. 13. As one approaches the maximum packing fraction of the immiscible dispersed phase, the viscosity increase is appreciable, reflecting the solidlike behavior such highly concentrated systems can develop. To demonstrate further the influence of dispersion characteristics on the relative viscosity of dispersions, the effect of particle aspect ratio is well illustrated in Fig. 14 [85]. At constant volume fraction, particles with higher aspect ratio produce the highest relative viscosity. Similarly, the same relative viscosity can be obtained at lower volume fraction with higher aspect ratio particles. In detergent systems, anisotropic particulates are
FIG. 13 Functional representation of the dependence of the relative viscosity on the volume fraction of the dispersed phase.
Page 87
FIG. 14 Relative viscosity of suspensions as a function of particle aspect ratio at constant volume fraction. (From Ref. 85.)
common product components, influencing the flow characteristics of the full formulation. To control product viscosity, aspect ratio is clearly a most significant variable. The impact of median particle size on the critical shear rate at which thickening occurs, compiled from a survey of colloids and large particulate suspensions, is summarized in Fig. 15 [86]. Many semiempirical models have been derived expressing the dependence of the relative viscosity as a function of volume fraction. One example, suggested by Krieger and Dougherty [87], represents the relative viscosity as
where the reduced shear stress is r is given by
where d is the particle diameter and the subscripts refer to the relative viscosity in the zero shear and high shear rate limits, 0 and , respectively. In a further extension of the KriegerDoughtrty model, the relative viscosity function has been proposed as
Page 88
FIG. 15 Critical shear rate producing shear thickening of colloid and large particulate dispersed systems as a function of mean particle size. (From Ref. 86.)
where of m .
m
is maximum packing volume fraction and the exponent a is a function
Because of the prevalence of solidinliquid suspensions throughout many industries and the need to process and formulate these dispersions efficiently, particulate suspensions have been studied extensively [88–108]. For both colloidal dispersions and large particulate suspensions, the influence of many material variables has been studied, such as volume fraction of the dispersed phase, n, particle size distributions, particle geometry, particleparticle interactions, polymer additives, presence of surfaceactive agents, and the nature of the continuous phase. The emphasis of these studies has been very broad, capturing steady shear properties, dynamic mechanical properties, relaxation phenomena, and transient flow phenomena at flow inception and cessation. Timedependent shear effects have also been investigated, including shear thinning and shear thickening under numerous deformation conditions. Rheooptics has been also effectively applied to the evaluation of structural changes in dispersions during flow. For example, the dynamics of colloidal particles in sheared, nonNewtonian fluids and structured liquid detergent systems has been examined using birefringence and dichroism [109,110]. An introduction to the general rheological properties solidliquid dispersions is provided by Onogi and Matsumoto [111]. The existence of the second plateau in dynamic mechanical measurements, noted for dispersions but absent for
Page 89
polymer solutions and melts, is discussed, attributed to relaxation process as a result of internal particulate ordering, and is strongly dependent on particle content, and related to the presence of “apparent” yield stresses. This secondary plateau is apparent in numerous commercial liquid detergent products, with further decreases in dynamic moduli with decreasing frequency, bringing to question the existence of yield stress phenomena. Experimental data are reviewed for dispersions whose flow behavior is governed by attractive Londonvan der Waals forces and those with strong repulsive forces caused by particle surface charge. An extensive review of various rheological models proposed for twophase flows, including the composition of colloidal and large particle suspensions used in numerous studies, with experimental details, is provided by Utracki [112]. Although the compositions of the dispersions used in these studies are quite distinct from those used in detergent formulations, they provide fundamental knowledge and various empiricisms governing the flow characteristics of twophase composites. Although admittedly limited, studies have also been completed in systems more directly applicable to the detergent industry. In one example, the interaction of alcohol ethoxylates, sodium ether sulfate, sodium alcohol sulfate, and linear sodium alkylbenzene sulfonate with aluminabased thickening agents has been determined as a function of surfactant composition, surfactant concentration, pH, and temperature in 5 wt% alumina dispersions in steady shear viscometry [113]. Studies have also been completed showing the complex rheological features dispersions can exhibit, especially when polymer surface modification occurs [114–118]. Built heavyduty liquid detergents have also been evaluated, especially those containing particulate sequestration agents [119– 123]. In a further example, Papenhuijzen examines the influence of particle interactions in the rheology of dispersed liquid detergent systems, with models of the breakage and reformation of network chains [124]. Proposed is a chain like model of dispersed phase particles forming a network structure through the medium. A recent theoretical derivation of suspension relative viscosity functions in generalized Newtonian media has included liquid detergent suspensions in the data analysis of the proposed model for the Einstein coefficient [125,126]. Normal stress differences have also been determined for an anionic viscous isotropic detergent solutions in the presence of electrolyte [127]. The microstructure and viscosity of liquid detergents comprised of highly concentrated multilayered vesicles, or lamellar droplets, a novel suspension medium, has been described by Jurgens and van de Pas [128,129]. The effect of shear and shear history is addressed, with thixotropic and rheopectic shear effects evident and the effect of shear history on the dispersed phase photodocumented through electronic microscopy. Rheopexy is found for shear
Page 90
rates in excess of 1 s1, with no equilibration following a 24 h shearing interval. Good correlation of the viscosity behavior of these complex dispersions is cited with the following viscosity relationship:
assuming K
p
>> 1, such that
where the consistency index K' and the parameter p is as defined by Sisko [130]. Volume fractions were estimated from conductivity measurements using the Bruggeman equation for dispersions of spheres [131]. In concentrated dispersions, both dilatancy and rheopexy can occur. Because these are flow properties that can influence product performance and handling characteristics, there may be a need either to eliminate or further enhance these attributes in a product formulation. A broad review of shear thickening in nonaggregating solid particulate suspensions in Newtonian liquids is provided by Barnes [86], with a summary of parameters controlling shear thickening behavior. Shear thickening of concentrated colloidal dispersions is well documented [132–135]. Further, the influence of soluble polymers in the presence of surfactants on the rheology of suspensions has been evaluated, showing the effect of polymer adsorption, bridging, flocculation, depletion flocculation, and stability [136–141]. Although most commercial products in dispersion form are truly complex systems containing multiple solid components with dissimilar aspect ratios, one or more immiscible liquid elements, and perhaps, aeration, fundamental studies of the rheology of well defined systems provide mechanisms for optimization, when product rheology requires modification. Colloidal dispersions comprised of finely divided, submicron particulates in Newtonian and nonNewtonian fluids have been the subject of considerable research in theoretical and experimental rheology [142–149], including normal stress measurements [150–153]. Phase diagrams of colloidal dispersions determined from rheological measurements as a function of dispersed phase volume fraction detect distinct sol/gel transitions, which significantly impact overall rheological properties as a function of particle concentration and ionic strength [154]. For specific application to liquid detergents, the transitions from liquid to solid behavior of charged particle colloids are most critical [155]. Research has further evaluated the effect of dispersed phase geometry, including anisotropic rods and disks, applicable to the evaluation of various rheology modifiers, such as clays, in product formulations [156–161]. In one study, a correlation scaling model is proposed for the temperature dependence of the relative viscosity of colloids containing both electrically charged and neutral
Page 91
dispersed phases, as shown in Fig. 16, applied to unpurified and purified bentonite clays, in the temperature range of 20–40°C. A single master curve is obtained at each concentration for the unrefined clay, while the purified clay does not follow this scaling analysis at higher volume fraction, indicating a clear change in interactive forces driven by temperature and concentration [162]. Although the influence of particle anisotropy is not well understood or systematically investigated, the influence of particle size distribution is more recognized as a mechanism for modification of rheological behavior [163,164]. A
FIG. 16 Rheogram of (a) unpurified bentonite and (b) purified bentonite as a function of temperature. (From Ref. 108.)
Page 92
very broad overview of the rheology of clay dispersions, including dynamic mechanical and steady flow behavior, is provided by Amari and Watanabe [165]. A general overview of the physical chemistry of colloidal systems (d < 1 m) and large particulate suspensions (d > 1 m) is available in the following references, including stability [166], depletion stabilization and depletion flocculation [167], steric stabilization [168], chemical complexation at solid/liquid interfaces [169], interparticle van der Waals forces in concentrated suspensions [170], electrostatic stabilization [171], polymerically stabilized particles [172,173], and adsorbed highmolecularweight polyelectrolytes [174]. Liquidliquid suspensions, or emulsions, have not been neglected in rheological research studies [175–189], and comprehensive theoretical and experimental studies have been completed defining the shear modulus G, yield stress y , and effective viscosity e in concentrated systems [190]:
where is the interfacial tension, R32 the Sauter mean drop radius the volume fraction of dispersed phase, n the maximum packing volume fraction, and m the viscosity of the continuous phase, and Ca is the capillary number, defined as mR32g /s. For those formulating emulsified liquids for personal and household care detergents, volume fraction, particle size, surface chemistry and interfacial tensions determine rheological behavior. As in all dispersions, adsorbed species at the interface is an important factor, because this directly influences the volume fraction of the dispersed phase. For those faced with the technical challenge of developing liquid detergents with tailored rheological properties, a vast portfolio of research is available to support that activity. Many of the primary variables influencing the rheological behavior of dispersions have been determined, at least providing numerous options for product modification to effect the necessary changes in mechanical properties. Although many surfactantbased dispersions exhibit unique rheological properties, mechanical behavior nevertheless remain functionally dependent on the geometry of the dispersed phase, surface charge, volume fraction, the nature of the continuous phase, and associativity of all components and the nature of the applied flow field.
Page 93
B. Highly Concentrated Dispersions At volume fractions approaching the maximum packing fraction for mono and polydisperse solidliquid and liquidliquid dispersions, solidlike behavior is frequently observed in the quiescent state. The high viscosity of these systems, the ability to retain their shape under the influence of gravitational forces, and the ability to suspend particulates without sedimentation indicates the presence of a yield stress. Methods have been reviewed for the measurement of yield stresses in these complex fluids [193–200]. Fluids that exhibit yield stress values frequently display additional anomalous flow behavior, such as wall slippage. This significantly complicates all rheological measurements, and effective corrections must be applied [200,201]. Nonlinear torque waveforms in response to sinusoidal strain deformations have also been observed, and a model has been developed that predicts the response of an elastic Binghamtype fluid to oscillatory shear for high volume fraction ( = 0.92) oilinwater emulsions [202]. Other structural constitutive equations have been developed based on network theory [203– 205]. Of particular interest is the extension of the CoxMerz rule proposed for concentrated suspensions and gels exhibiting yield stress behavior [206]. A good correlation has been developed for steady shear viscosity and complex dynamic viscosity in terms of an effective shear rate. For the experimentalist, rheological measurements of concentrated and highly structured dispersions can be quite difficult. Reproducible measurements in even simple shearing flows are often complicated by the disturbance of fluid structure in normal handling, such as loading in the selected test fixture. As a result, various methods are applied either to preshear the test fluid before testing or to allow a restructuring interval before testing following sample loading, for example. The dependence of rheological profiles on fluid shear history is one of the overwhelming difficulties in effectively characterizing these structured materials. C. Gels and Microgels There has been a dramatic increase in the use of gels as the delivery vehicle of liquid detergent products, especially in the personal care category, because of an increased understanding of the viscoelasticity of various gelling and thickening agents. Gels can be formed by various mechanisms, including interactive solid particulates, physically or chemically crosslinked polymers, and ordered surfactants or anisotropic surfactant phases. The fundamental criterion is that connectivity through chemical or physical association occurs with sufficient strength, forming a continuously defined network structure. One of the best known is the
Page 94
electrostatically stabilized gels formed from refined clays, forming the “house of cards” structure. Others include polysaccharides, such as xanthan guns, strongly dependent upon the conformation of the polymer in solution and additional physical interactions through hydrogen bonding, for example [210]. Polymers are often used as rheology modifiers or gelling agents for liquid detergent systems, and understanding of the characteristics of these aqueous polymeric solutions, solutions versus gel behavior, in various ionic solution environments and in the presence of surfactants is easily obtained through rheological measurements. The steady shear and dynamic mechanical properties of numerous gelling and thickening agents frequently used in the formulation of liquid detergents are well documented in the literature under general conditions frequently occurring in product compositions [211]. The utility of dynamic mechanical measurements in defining the fundamental properties of solutions and gels is well illustrated in Fig. 17, describing the change in the frequency dependence of the storage modulus, G' and the loss modulus G'' during gelation as a function of temperature [212]. Beginning with a simple solution we see the influence of a growing crosslink density on both components of the complex modulus, with complete gelation at Fig. 17d. The transition from solution to a true gel network structure is most apparent.
FIG. 17 Gelation of polystyrene in carbon disulfide with G' and G'' as a function of frequency. (From Ref. 212.)
Page
The rheology of microgel solutions, frequently used in liquid detergent formulation comprised of carbomers, for example, has been determined, including dynamic mechanical characterizations as a function of polymer concentration, with an evaluation of creep behavior and steady shear viscosity [213]. The dynamic mod of Carbopol 941, as a function of concentration, is summarized in Fig. 18. Typic of many commercial gel structures, concentrated microgel rheology is compared t a cellular, deformable spheric model, equally applicable to emulsions and foams. These polyacrylate gelling agents are known to be tolerant to hypochlorite bleach lending their use to various household care liquid detergents [214]. As an example of an additional gelling mechanism, carboxymethylcellulose in free acid form (HCMC), less hydrophilic than sodium carboxymethylcellulose, can als form rheological gels as a result of quasicrystalline microaggregation of HCMC detected by electron microscopy and dependent on the degree of substitution of t NaCMC [215]. Gelation is observed for a degree of substitution (DS) of 0.8 as function of aging time, but none is found for DS = 2. Gelling for this system proceeds for a 60 day interval.
FIG. 18 Dynamic mechanical characterization of Carbopol 941 at concentrations of 0.53 to 6.16% as a function of frequency. (a) G' = ƒ( ). (b) G' = ƒ( ). (c) G" = ƒ( ). (d) G" = ƒ( ). (From Ref. 213.)
Page 96
Discussions of the gelation would be incomplete without reference to the relationship between the storage modulus of a gel G' and the crosslink density n [216]: G' = gnKT + Gen where: K = Boltzmann constant T = temperature K g = constant < 1 and Gen is the influence of entanglements on the elasticity. This expression has been used to determine gelation kinetics from measurement of time rate of change in the storage modulus G'/ t during the gel formation process, as shown in Fig. 19 [217]. Dynamic mechanical measurements are quite sensitive to the internal ordering within the fluid composition. Through carefully designed experiments, not only can the development of a continuous network structure be effectively monitored through measurements of the elastic modulus G' as a function of time, leading to an understanding of factors controlling gelation kinetics, but the integrity of the final state can be well represented by such determinations, related to the physics of the final gel. Both qualitative and quantitative measure, dynamic mechanical spectroscopy is an increasing effective probe of the rheology of liquid detergents and their various product components.
FIG. 19 Gelation kinetics determined from the change in storage modulus, G', as a function of gelling time. (From Ref. 217.)
Page 97
D. Stability Dispersion stability is a critical subject for those processing and formulating liquid detergents. Such formulations can be difficult to stabilize effectively throughout the shelf life of the product and shelf life monitoring can be labor and time consuming. Predictive methods and accelerated product aging studies are generally employed with varying degrees of success. This may include such techniques as thermal cycling, incubation, centrifugation, vibration or simulated shipping tests, in addition to rheological characterizations. Although progress has been made in the development of stability criteria for polydisperse model suspensions, accurate predictive tools for commercial formulations are generally unavailable. Recent developments have occurred in rheology, however, to assist in the prediction of product stability. The most significant contribution is the realization that the dynamic mechanical properties of these complex fluids may be indicative of long term stability [218]. Studies have shown that the strength of the internal microstructure as determined from the strain and frequency dependence of the storage and loss modulus as a function of temperature may be predictive of incipient product failure. Dynamic mechanical measurements as a function of strain, frequently used to identify the linear viscoelastic region, have been isolated as one potential indicator of dispersion stability. A review of the technical literature has been included in the following section demonstrating the importance of surfactant phase behavior, component interactions, and effect of electrolytes and total solution environment on the rheological properties of liquid detergent systems. Such fundamental studies can lead to a greater understanding of the rheology of commercial consumer products, expanding into new and more effective product delivery vehicles. V. Fundamental Research in Liquid Detergents In research, rheology is a very useful tool and highly effective probe of the internal microstructure of surfactant systems. Viscometric and oscillatory rheometry can explore the architecture of surfactant solutions, especially when coupled to other analyses, such as smallangle neutron scattering, microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and flow birefringence. Fundamental research of liquid detergents using dynamic mechanical measurements can probe the quiescent versus sheared physical state of the fluid as a function of many material variables determining the kinetics of structural formation or degradation and definition of the physical state of the fluid. Viscometric measurements have also been used to investigate micelle geometry and structural transitions. Another important industrial application of the rheological sciences is in the investigation of interactions between product components through appropriately
Page 98
designed rheological measurements, with counterions, polymers, cosurfactants, and so on, identified to modify or tailor rheology for a given consumer function. A. Surfactant Solutions Solution viscosity is a most basic structureproperty measurement as defined by the relationship between the stress tensor and the rate of deformation tensor . In surfactant solutions, the viscosity depends on the tensioactive agent concentration, solvent, presence of ionizable groups, surface charge density, ionic strength of the carrier fluid, pH, and temperature. In addition, viscosity behavior depends on surfactant molecular weight and geometry, showing a strong dependence on micelle shape and size. Critical primary transitions such as micellar spheretorod configurations can often be identified from viscosityconcentration determinations in the dilute regime. Table 1 summarizes common viscometric parameters generally used to describe solution behavior as a probe of surfactant micelle architecture. Hydration is an important factor in the viscosity behavior of dilute surfactant solutions because water bound to the micelles, forming the hydration layer, contributes to the size of the micelles. It also determines the effective concentration of surfactant partitioning the aqueous phase into the free and bound water of hydration. This is demonstrated by Mukerjee [219], for example, estimating the hydration of micelles of sodium lauryl sulfate and dodecyl, tetradecyl and trimethylammonium chlorides from reduced and intrinsic viscosity data, using appropriate corrections for electroviscous effects. The viscosity of dilute surfactant solutions in the spherical micelle region can be described by a modified form of the Einstein viscosity equation [220,221]:
where is the volume fraction of solvated micelles and c m c represents the viscosity of the solution at the CMC. This is accurate for uncharged, dilute, TABLE 1 Definition of Viscosity Functions Viscosity/function Reduced viscosity Relative viscosity Specific viscosity Intrinsic viscosity
Definition =
red
r
= /
/c
sp
0
= rl
sp
[ ] = [(ln r)/c] c = 0
Page 99
noninteractive dispersions. The viscosity of ionic surfactants is strongly dependent on the surface charge density. For micellar solutions, a modification of the Einstein equation for this first electroviscous effect [222] is given as
When hydrodynamic factors become relevant at higher concentrations, a second electroviscous effect becomes operative because of the electrostatic repulsion between micellar aggregates, creating an additional resistance to flow with further increases in bulk solution viscosity. The isotropic phase of any surfactant solution is typically Newtonian, although there are exceptions. Throughout the isotropic region, viscometric behavior is dependent on micelle size, micelle concentration, geometry, and various intra and intermicellar interactions, and in keeping with this functionality, viscosity is not constant throughout the isotropic phase. This is represented comprehensively by Schafheutle and Kinkelmann [223]. Lines of constant reduced viscosity within the isotropic phase of a novel surfactant with rigid rodlike hydrophobic moiety terminally substituted with monodisperse oligo (ethylene glycol) units is provided in Fig. 20. The reduced viscosity (ml/g) varies significantly throughout the isotropic phase and along the phase boundaries of the various phases. This shows quite definitively the complex dependence of viscometric behavior on micellar dimensions and dispersion characteristics within
FIG. 20 Reduced viscosity isocontours within the isotropic phase. (From Ref. 223.)
Page 100
the isotropic phase. This aqueous surfactant system exhibits Newtonian behavior at shear rates from 0 to 60 s1 at all temperatures and concentrations included in this study. In the following sections, various examples are provided of rheological studies of nonionic, anionic, cationic and mixed surfactant solutions. These studies were selected to exemplify the critical relationship between surfactant morphology and viscometric or rheological behavior. 1. Nonionic Surfactants Because the rheology of liquid detergents is inherently dependent on surfactant architecture, or phase, rheology can be a useful tool in developing phase diagrams. For example, the phase diagram of a ternary nonionic surfactant, [p (1,1,3,3tetramethylbutyl)phenyl]poly(oxyethylene) (Triton X100), dioctylphthalate, and water system has been determined by Otsubo and Prud'homme [224]. For this system, the isotropic phase is Newtonian within the broad shear rate range of 0.1250 s1 and pseudoplastic behavior occurs within the anisotropic phase. Viscosity measurements of the binary surfactant water system as a function of concentration identify three distinct regions. Below 33 wt% surfactant, a micellar microemulsion occurs and for concentrations greater than 58 wt% surfactant, an inverse microemulsion has been identified. At intermediate concentrations, rheological measurements identify a liquid crystalline phase with typical nonNewtonian viscosity behavior. This extensive study further documents the abrupt change in flow properties at phase boundaries. The reduced viscosity as a function of micellar concentration for polyoxyethylene alkyl ethers of the type CH2[CH2]m1[OCH2CH2]1.25mOH has been determined for several carbon chain lengths ranging from C8–C14 and from E10–E19 [225] and there is a linear increase in viscosity with increasing polyoxyethylene concentration. For the same surfactant, the intrinsic viscosity as a function of alkyl chain length for various ethylene oxide/carbon chain length ratios reveals an abrupt discontinuity between C16 and C18. It is speculated that this is a result of the intrusion of anhydrous polyoxyethylene into the micellar core, altering hydration within the micelle mantle. Many additional viscometric studies of surfactant solutions have addressed the dependence of bulk solution viscosity on micelle geometry. Robson and Dennis, for example, calculate the size, shape, and hydration of a commercial grade of the nonionic surfactant micelle, [p (1,1,3,3tetramethylbuytyl)phenyl] poly(oxyethylene), from intrinsic viscosity data [226]. Several of the major difficulties associated with these calculations are demonstrated: the coupling of both hydration and shape factors. Based on geometric considerations and viscosity data, they argue against the presence of spherical micelles and support the formation of an oblate micelle. A spherical micelle could occur, however,
Page 101
if several ethylene oxide groups are embedded into the hydrophobic core. The deviation from spherical micelle geometry is also suggested by Wright [227] from birefringence data, and Tanford et al. [228] also argue the nonspherical geometry of polyoxyethylene ethers in aqueous solutions from sedimentation and intrinsic viscosity data. Calculations indicate a disklike globular micelle with random coil polyethylene oxide chains in the outer micelle mantle. 2. Anionic Surfactants Alkylbenzene sulfonate is a very important industrial surfactant. It is a common lowcost surfactant in household detergents. With the increasing emphasis on concentrated liquid detergents, an awareness of the phase behavior of this surfactant and resulting rheology is critical. Sulfonation conditions, reaction pathways, byproducts, and impurities can have a significant impact on the rheology and phase behavior of linear (LAS) and branched (ABS) alkylbenzene sulfonate. Because this surfactant is frequently processed at high active ingredient concentrations, the relationship between specific reaction conditions and final surfactant rheology is important for processing and controlling product formulations. The viscosity of caustic sodaneutralized sodium linear alkylbenzene sulfonate is found to be strongly dependent on the molar ratio of SO3/alkylbenzene and also the sulfonation process, HF versus A1C13[229]. The tetralin content appears to control and actually reduce the viscosity of 25% active LAS solutions. Although this study includes very limited viscosity data, it demonstrates the influence of both process and material variables on surfactant viscosity at concentrations frequently encountered during the manufacture of this surfactant. Similarly, Rybicki investigated the dilute solution viscosity of sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate as a function of various commercial detergent builders, on the partial molar volume of hydrated micelles [230]. The relative viscosity of one commercial linear sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate, average molecular weight of 343.9 g/mol, is presented in Fig. 21, and two transitions are noted. The first CMC is the micellar monomersphere transition and the second attributed to a further, as yet unidentified, structural change in the micelle. Figure 22 summarizes micellar hydration volume as a function of temperature and sodium metasilicate concentration showing the influence of electrical doublelayer thickness on viscosity. It is also shown that the partial molar volume of hydrated micelles depends on ionic strength, independently of the type of electrolyte. Figure 23 shows the effect of electrolyte concentration for several salts, (NaPO3)6, Na2SiO3, and Na2SO4, on A3, a coefficient of the Vand equation, related to the partial molar hydrated micelle volume at 293 K [231]. The effect of salt on the double layer as a function of temperature is very clear. With increasing salt concentration, the electroviscous effect is reduced and partial
Page 102
FIG. 21 Reduced viscosity sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate as a function of surfactant concentration at 25°C. (From Ref. 230.)
molar volume of the hydrated micelle is similarly reduced for this anionic surfactant. This alters the effective volume fraction of the dispersed phase, consisting of spherical micelles, with a significant influence on solution viscosity. The alkyl sulfates are also important industrial surfactants used in a very broad range of consumer products. Similar to the sulfonates, reaction byprod
FIG. 22 Micelle hydration volume of sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate for several sodium metasilicate concentrations as a function of temperature. (From Ref. 230.)
Page 103
FIG. 23 Coefficient of the Vand equation, A3 as a function of electrolyte concentration at 25°C. (From Ref. 230.)
ucts of the alcohol sulfates, including sodium chloride and sodium sulfate, influence the viscosity behavior of sodium lauryl sulfate solutions [232]. Each of the salts and the free oil, primarily unreacted alcohol, has a very clear impact on surfactant viscosity. A micelle model illustrating the increase in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) viscosity with inorganic salts and free oil is also provided and in each case, the increase is attributed to the increase in effective volume fraction of the dispersed phase. With inorganic salts, this is caused by the sodium cation association with the sulfate groups through electrostatic interactions at the micelle surface; the free oil does not appear to interact at the surface. It is thought that the free oil acts as a “cosurfactant,” participating in the micelle itself. This increases the effective volume fraction of the micelles producing a similar increase in solution viscosity. This is, however, energetically unfavorable, and thought to be a precursor to the formation of a microemulsion. Akhtar and Alauddin [223] investigated the viscometric properties of sodium dodecyl sulfate in simple aqueous solutions and aqueous solutions containing cyclohexanol, investigating changes in micelle size and shape and also the micellar location of the solubilized alcohol. Viscosity measurements of the aqueous detergent as a function of SDS concentration identify a transition at 0.2 mol/kg, attributed to a postmicellar transition from spherical to rodshaped micelles. The temperature and concentration dependence of the average aggregation number of SDS have been investigated with smallangle neutron scatter
Page 104
ing experiments. The increase in SDS aggregation number, quantifying the number of monomers per micelle, at this transition concentration necessitates a change in shape [234]. The effect of simple electrolytes, both NaCl and HCl, on the relative viscosities of SDS as a function of concentration has been determined by Gamboa and Sepulveda [235]. Na+ counterions appear to produce a greater increase in viscosity than H+, because it is a more strongly bound counterion, and all solutions demonstrate highly nonlinear viscometric behavior. The lengths of the rodlike micelles are calculated from the viscosity data for both sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) and cetyltrimethylammonium salts. Soap solutions have long been known for their interesting viscometric behavior. This is evident from isoviscometric contours for potassium laurate and potassium carbonate solutions, further demonstrating the complexity of the isotropic phase [236]. Within the isotropic phase, there is a dramatic variation in viscosity values initially attributed to the formation of complex emulsions from dispersed anisotropic liquid crystalline surfactants in isotropic surfactant solution. Pilpel derives expressions from geometric and energy considerations of soap aggregation to support long interlinked rodlike or cylindrical micelle formation in soap gels in an attempt to clarify the observed rheological behavior [237]. The systems in this investigation include sodium oleate, elaidate and oleylsulfate and the introduction of longchain alcohols and other compounds. The development of viscoelastic effects is thought to occur through a cascade of intermediate micellar stages as suggested by Philippoff [238]. Pilpel estimates that the van der Waals energy per molecule decreases nearly 90% in the transition from spherical to cylindrical micelles for specific soap gels, with a corresponding Coulombic energy decrease of approximately 5%. This decrease in both van der Waals and Coulombic energy in the micellar transitions supports the stability of the rodlike micelles at higher salt concentrations. He proposes one geometry of a cylindrical micelle to be approximately 9 Å, with a length of 200 Å. Early xray diffraction studies of soap systems support the speculation that cylindrical elongated structures occur. 3. Mixed Surfactants: Anionic/Nonionic Systems The flow behavior of SDS and alkyl polyoxyethylene ethers, C12–18 and E10–40, has been determined by Uchiyama and Abe [239]. Although the relative viscosity of the alkyl polyoxyethylene ether is greater than that of SDS, for the mixed surfactant system there is a maximum in the relative viscosity at an SDS mole fraction of 0.3. Increasing the ethylene oxide content has a significant effect in both the single Cm En and mixed surfactant solutions. A maximum also occurs at the same molar ratio, 0.3, with the exception of the C16E40 system.
Page 105
In addition, the effect of sodium chloride on the relative viscosity of the SDS/C18E20 mixed surfactant system as a function of SDS mole fraction has also been investigated by Uchiyama and Abe. The relative viscosity is found to be a decreasing linear function of SDS mole fraction, and no effect is observed on the relative viscosity of the single nonionic surfactant solutions. In the mixed surfactant system, salt addition is presumed to decrease the electroviscous effect with a decrease in the CMC and an increase in aggregation number. Addition of the nonionic surfactant increases the degree of ionic dissociation of the mixed micelle. The degree of ionic dissociation also increased with increasing alkyl chain lengths and decreasing EO groups. The maximum in the relative viscosity is assumed to be a result of the electroviscous effect of the mixed micellar solution, which is greatest at the SDS molar ratio of 0.3. Zwitterionic surfactants, such as alkydimethylamine oxides, can exhibit complex viscometric properties individually and in the presence of ionic surfactants. At low concentrations, viscoelastic rodlike entangled networks are thought to occur [240]. The zero shear viscosity of the nonionic surfactant is very strongly dependent on concentration and surfactant molecular weight. For example, oleyldimethylamine oxides are known to form rodlike micelles and viscoelasticity is observed at concentrations as low as 1% by weight. The uncharged surfactant in aqueous solution appears to behave as a simple Maxwell fluid with a single shear modulus and structural relaxation time. The influence of both cationic and anionic surfactants has been determined from rheology, light scattering, and electric birefringence measurements. The zero shear viscosity of a mixed oleyldimethylamine oxide (ODMAO) system is strongly influenced by the amount of ionic surfactant. Both SDS and tetradeyltrimethylammonium bromide are evaluated for their influence on the flow behavior of the uncharged surfactant. A comparison of the C14DMAO and SDS influence on the zero shear viscosity of ODMAO is provided in Fig. 24. The anionic surfactant has a considerably greater influence in the surfactant mixture. In dynamic mechanical measurements, it is observed that SDS has the effect of decreasing the frequency dependence of the elastic modulus. A highly structured composition is evident at the 46:4 concentration, as shown in Fig. 25. In the concentration regime used in this study, the shear modulus remains fairly constant and is not affected by the anionic surfactant and the primary influence is through the structural relaxation time. It is suspected that the introduction of charge to the nonionic surfactant stiffens the rodlike network and that adhesive hydrophobic interaction occur at micellar interfaces. The zero shear viscosity and structural relaxation time are determined by the intermicellar bond energy, which is sensitive to charge density, surfactant chain length, and electrolyte concentration. This study also evaluates the effect of other cationic
Page 106
FIG. 24 Effect of SDS and tetradecyltrimethylammonium salt on the zero shear viscosity of oleyldimethylamine oxide at 25°C and surfactant concentrations of 50 mM. (From Ref. 240.)
surfactants, such as tetra and hexadecyldimethylamine oxide, on the viscoelasticity of the zwitterionic surfactant solutions. The rheology of a mixed zwitterionic and anionic surfactant, hexadecyldimethylammonioprophane sulfone, SDS, and water, has been studied by Saul et al. [241], including both isotropic and hexagonal phases. Rheological results
FIG.25 Storage modulus G' as a function of frequency for oleyldimethylamine oxide/SDS aqueous mixtures at overall concentrations of 50 mM and 25°C. (From Ref. 240.)
Page 107
are interpreted in terms of the coexistence of both spherical and cylindrical micelles. Both viscosity and first normal stress difference data are presented for various regions of the phase diagram and high shear rate viscosity data are also provided in the shear rate range of 428, 1235, and 2570 s1. The phase diagram of this surfactant mixture is provided as determined from both NMR and rheological measurements. 4. Cationic Surfactants Cationic surfactants in dilute solutions can form long rodlike micelles that produce very unusual rheological properties. These elongated micellar structures can mimic entangled polymers and crosslinked gellike systems, depending on the surfactant head group, concentration and electrolyte, additive environment. The dramatic elasticity of these very dilute solutions has been well documented, and research in the rheological behavior of dilute cationic surfactants spans a number of decades [242–253]. This includes comprehensive examples of dynamic mechanical characterizations, steady shear viscosity functions, stress growth and stress relaxation behavior, and modulus and normal stress measurements. For example, Nash investigates conditions whereby naphthol and cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) interact to form elastic gels using a simple qualitative rheological test and fluorescence technique [254]. The formation of very long filaments is identified as a plausible mechanism for elasticity, and estimates are given for a 1 mM solution forming a filament length of nearly 30,000 km. His detailed study investigating the micelle “polymerization” mechanism covers the effect of many additives to the cationic surfactant. Dilute aqueous solutions of specific cationic surfactants can develop sheared induced structures. This has been observed in stress growth steady shear viscometric measurements of dilute aqueous solutions of CTASal [255]. Within the shear rate range of 0.59–0.99s1, the viscosity is Newtonian and no time dependence is observed. At 1.35s1, however, following a considerable induction time period, we see dramatic rheopectic behavior. Equally remarkable is the very broad range of rheological properties exhibited in the dilute solutions. In a narrow concentration range, 3–5 mmol/dm3, Gravsholt identifies rheopectic, thixotropic, nonNewtonian power law, and Newtonian viscosity behavior. Although Newtonian in the unsheared quiescent state, these dilute cationic solutions develop a metastable supramolecular structure under mechanical stress, forming novel viscoelastic systems. The counterion or ion pair is critical in forming viscoelasticity in dilute cationic detergents and the development of longrange order. An example is provided by Gravsholt using CTAx ( = substituted benzoic acid) [256]. Salicylate, m chlorobenzoate, and p chlorobenzoate give rise to viscoelastic behavior, whereas ochlorobenzoate, mhydroxybenzoate, and p hydroxybenzoate
Page 1 TABLE 2 Viscoelastic Cationic Surfactant Systems Surfactant
Counterion
Cetylpyridinium chloride
Nasalicylate
Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide
Nasalicylate
Cetyltrimethylammonium chloride
NaSCN
Cetrytrimethylammonium chloride
2Amimobenzenesulfonate
C8F17SO3NA
(C2H5) 4NOH
C9F19CO2Na
(CH3) 4NOH Surfactant
Tetradecyldimethylaminoxide
Sodium dodecyl sulfate
Tetradecyldimethylaminoxide
C7H15CO2Na Uncharged compound
Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide
Chloroform
Cetylpyridinium chloride
4Propylphenol
Source: From Ref. 257.
have no apparent impact on micellar structure. The CMC and minimum or critical concentrations needed to develop viscoelasticity are noted as well. Table 2 summarizes several cationic surfactant systems exhibiting viscoelastic properties [257]. The unusual viscometric behavior of the cationic surfactants containing mainly pyridinium or trimethylammonium head groups at dilute concentrations has been attributed to the formation of rodlike micellar structures of length L and mean separation distance D, leading to a dynamic threedimensional network structure [258]. Simply stated, viscoelasticity occurs when L > D. The zero shear viscosity of dilute rodlike solutions can be calculated from Doi Edwards [259] as
where ˆc is the number of rods/unit volume and L represents rod length. The critical overlap condition occurs at
Table 3 summarizes length of rodshaped micelles for cetylpyridinium salicylate (CPySal) as a function of temperature and concentration [260].
critical overlap condition occurs at
Table 3 summarizes length of rodshaped micelles for cetylpyridinium salicylate (CPySal) as a function of temperature and concentration [260].
Page 1 TABLE 3 Length (Å) of Rodlike Micelles as a Function of Temperature and Concentratio for Cetylpyridinium Salicylate Solutions c (mmol/dm)
20°C
30°C
40°C
50°C
1
120
70
40
—
2
210
140
90
60
4
430
270
160
150
6
640
400
280
200
7
750
460
315
240
Source: From Ref. 260.
Surfactant systems are dynamic systems with constant redistribution of monomeri species. This exchange leads to a lack of permanence to any entanglement or crosslink site and the evolution of the “living network” model. The rodshaped micelles can undergo a continuous process of bond formation and cleavage, distinguishing long micellar rodshaped surfactants from polymers. It is known that anionic cosurfactants, specific organic counterions, and nonionic compounds, including esters and aromatic hydrocarbons, induce viscoelasticity in cationic solutions [261,262]. The efficiency of these compounds in favoring specific micellar aggregate structures, rodlike micelles, is critical in the development of supermolecular structures capable of significant viscoelastic effects. The specific architecture of the interactions between the micelle and additive and their orientation is also critical. Research has demonstrated, for example, the importance of molecular orientation in determining the overall rheological response. This is shown quite clearly through the influence of para, meta, and orthotoluic acid on the steadystate zero shear viscosity of CPyCl [257]. The largest increase in viscosity occurs with p toluic acid: it is suspected that the COO group orients perpendicularly to the micellar interface, providing a mechanism for micellemicelle linkage, or “micelle polymerization,” similar to the effect observed for sodium salicylate [263]. This study and others highlight the importance of surfactant architecture on rheological properties and a micellar chai model for the origin of viscoelasticity in cetyltrimethylammonium bromide solution has been presented, based on the premise that the counterions serve as “crosslin agents” capable of building micellar chain structures. The orientation of sodium salicylate, sodium mchlorobenzoate, and mhydroxylbenzoic acid has been investigated, and results from Fourier transform NMR studies suggest that the orientation of the COO carboxylic group is likely the key to the origin of viscoelasticity. Only when the COO projects out of the micellar surface are conditions favorable for chain formation and viscoelasticity favored. Cryo transmission electron microscopy (TEM)
Page 110
and both steady shear and dynamic rheological measurements of cetyltrimethylammonium chloride in the presence of sodium salicylate as the binding counterions support the premise that threadlike or wormlike elongated micellar structures occur [264]. In addition, polar and hydrophobic interactions are critical in the increased viscosity exhibited by cationic surfactants in the presence of salts and other surfactants. It has been proposed that the increased solution viscosity is a result of increased ion pair stability [265]. It has been speculated by Hoffmann and his colleagues that only two parameters are needed adequately to define the rheology of these cationic detergents. These are the shear modulus, representative of the structure of the detergent, and the relaxation time, representative of the dynamic nature of the system, both calculated from the zero shear viscosity. Using this hypothesis, four distinct zones as a function of detergent concentration are identified [266]. The nonlinear viscoelasticity of aqueous CTAB solutions with excess sodium salicylate has been determined by Shikata et al. [267,268]. The nonlinear properties were found to be dependent on the concentration of excess salicylate. A 1:1 complex of CTAB and NaSal molar ratio form rodlike micelles, and three behavior modes are described. When the NaSal concentration is significantly less than CTAB, dilute flexible polymer solution behavior is observed and the relaxation spectrum is found to follow the Rouse theory of polymer solutions without entanglement. At higher concentration of NaSal but still below the 1:1 ratio, full entanglement behavior typical of concentrated polymer solutions occurs. When NaSal concentration exceeds CTAB, the viscoelastic behavior is quite different. Unlike polymer systems, Maxwell behavior with the single relaxation time is evident. The relaxation time does not appear sensitive to CTAB concentration and temperature but is highly dependent on the free salicylate concentration in solution. It is speculated that the free salicylate ion is a prerequisite for scission reaction and that micellar relaxation occurs not through reptation but as a result of micellar monomer exchange kinetics. Although there are similarities to polymer solutions at lower ratios, the dynamic nature of the “living” network [269] becomes evident at higher mole ratios of salicylate. Stress growth measurements at the inception of flow completed by Shikata et al. indicate the presence of shearinduced structures for dilute CTAB/NaSal solutions at low shear rates. Dramatic rheopectic behavior is documented in Fig. 26 at a shear rate of 0.481. Viscometric measurements at various salt concentrations and shear rate ranges are summarized with evidence of damping oscillation. The long induction period for shearinduced structuring of cationic surfactants solutions in simple shearing flows appears to follow a simple scaling law for CTABsodium salicylate solutions in which the induction time is inversely proportional to the applied shear rate [270]. There also appears to be a critical shear rate at which shear thickening occurs for 2 mM CTAB sodium salicylate within the temperature range of 10–36°C. The critical shear rate for
Page 111
FIG. 26 Stress growth behavior of dilute aqueous CTAB/NaSal solutions at low shear rates and concentrations C = 0.1 and C = 0.15 M. D
s
(From Ref. 268.)
the development of the nonequilibrium metastable micellar shearinduced ordering increase with increasing temperature. One could conclude that there is a critical strain required to induce the reorganization of micelles in this surfactant system. 5. Mixed Surfactants: Anionic/Cationic Systems The effect of salts on the rheology of cationic surfactants has been actively investigated, yet little research on mixed surfactant systems has been completed to date. Tetradecyldimethylaminoxide (TDMAO) and sodium dodecyl sulfate do not individually exhibit timedependent nonNewtonian viscosity functions in solution, yet mixed solutions of these surfactants are known to show rheopectic and dilatant characteristics [271–273]. This is evident from the stress growth behavior of the TDMAO/SDS solution in the presence of sodium chloride at a shear rate of 50 s1 [274]. Following a lengthy induction interval, shear thickening occurs at a moderate shear rate of 50 s1, for this anionic/cationic surfactant pair containing sodium chloride. For this system, it appears that induction time follows a simple scaling law, inversely proportional to shear rate. For the same surfactant system, dilatancy is exhibited as well. The steadystate viscosity increases with increasing shear rate, reaching a maximum at approximately 60 s1, and timedependent and shear thickening behavior is attributed to the shear induced coagulation of rodlike micelles.
Page 112
Theoretical and experimental research has been extensive in cationic surfactant systems. This is undoubtedly a result of the complexity of these systems and the dynamic nature of the micellar matrix with a continuous exchange of surfactant monomers from solution to micelle and the shear induced structural states that can be achieved. Theoretical models have been proposed [275– 278] and there is good experimental evidence that relaxation processes are dominated by the kinetics related to micellar chain scission and reformation. This is seen from the exponential stress decay. If dominated by reptation, as noted by Cates, a nonexponential stress decay would be operative. Diffusion would be the ratecontrolling factor. B. Surfactant Liquid Crystal Gels Both isotropic and microemulsion phases of liquid detergent systems are typically Newtonian. Hexagonal, cubic, and lamellar phases, however, exhibit distinct nonNewtonian behavior. At these higher concentrations, within mesomorphic phases, mechanical properties can be nonlinear and time dependent. Gellike properties, similar to those of crosslinked polymers, may also occur with formation of yield stresses. In general, thixotropy, rheopexy, dilatancy, and pseudoplasticity have been demonstrated in the surfactant literature within the anisotropic phases. Lyotropic liquid crystals are particularly interesting surfactant phases because of the high fluidity of these systems, the apparent yield stresses they can exhibit and the various shear effects that can occur. These are also difficult systems to characterize because of the orientation of the micelles in the test geometry and the dependence of rheological properties on defects occurring within the liquid crystal matrix [279]. 1. Nonionic Surfactant Systems Repetitive flow curves for C12E4(60 wt%) demonstrate significant thixotropy in qualitative thixotropic loop measurements [280]. One might suspect that this thixotropy is associated with a loss of structure with shear at this shear rate. This obvious shear effect is most likely a result of realignment, orientation, and reduction of defects within the liquid crystal in simple shear. Disruption of the liquid crystal lamellar geometry in shear results in both dilatant and rheopectic behavior caused by the transition from twodimensional order to a highly irregular surfactant dispersion. Defects in the liquid crystalline morphology can significantly influence viscometric flow properties [281]. It has been shown that viscosity increases significantly with a high incidence of internal defects. This phenomenon complicates measurement and interpretation of the rheology of these systems. The rheology of ternary phosphated polyoxyethylene nhexane, and water lyotropic liquid crystals have been determined in qualitative thixotropic loop
Page 113
measurements using a FerrantiShirley cone and plate viscometer and a Deer variable stress rheometer [282], with measurements completed within the lamellar and hexagonal phases of both phosphated nonylphenol ethoxylate and phosphated fatty alcohol ethoxylate at 25°C. Qualitatively, thixotropic loop measurements within the considerable shear rate range show rheopectic hysteresis for specific segments of the lamellar liquid crystal phases and a thixotropic response within the hexagonal and intermediate amorphous gel phase. A comparison of the lamellar, hexagonal, and gel phases as a function of water content at a shear rate of 90.45 s1 shows the lamellar liquid crystal phase to be the most viscous under these experimental conditions, coupling both time and shear rate variables. The maximum exhibited by the hexagonal liquid crystal at 40% water represents a phase boundary. Such thixotropic loop measurements are difficult to interpret because of the combined effects of both time of shearing and shear rate and constant shear rate experiments, or stress growth measurements, are better suited to characterize these ordered systems. 2. Anionic Surfactants Lamellar liquid crystals can exhibit shear effects in various concentrations within this anisotropic phase. Stress growth measurement at 0.05 s1 for an alkyl ether sulfate, C12E7SO4Na, at a concentration of 70% by weight is presented in Fig. 27. Following a stress overshoot, significant viscosity reduction occurs with increasing time of shear. Note that following a shearing interval of 600 s, a shear steady viscosity has not been achieved. In simple shear, this lamellar liquid crys
FIG. 27 Stress growth behavior at 25°C and 0.5 s1 of aqueous C12E7SO4Na gels (70% weight active) using 25 mm parallel plate geometry.
Page 114
tal appears to be thixotropic. The cause of this time dependent shear effect, however, is not fully understood. This may be the result of reduction in liquid crystal defects, slippage along the twodimensional planar matrix, or other experimental anomalies. Dynamic mechanical properties for the same alkyl ether sulfate as a function of strain are summarized in Fig. 28. This liquid crystal appears to be highly elastic and gellike because the storage modulus is nearly frequency independent and exceeds the loss modulus by nearly an order of magnitude for strains greater than 0.1. The strain dependence of the storage and loss modulus indicates the presence of a yield stress. A comparative study of the thermotropic and lyotropic mesophases of ammonium dodecanoate at 30, 40, and 50°C shows both systems to be Bingham plastics with high yield stresses within the lamellar phases [283]. The activation energy for viscous flow for the thermotropic mesophase consisting of a ternary system of ammonium laurate, water, and noctanol was found to be more than an order of magnitude greater than that for lyotropic mesophase. Sodium soap mesophases also exhibit unusual behavior in thixotropic loop measurements [284]. Ternary sodium caprylate, decanol and water systems in various anisotropic phases were evaluated using a FerrantiShirley viscometer including both lamellar and hexagonal phases. The most unusual behavior was observed for the lamellar phases, strongly dependent upon water concentration. As in previous surfactant lamellar liquid crystal studies, the distribution of water within the liquid crystal matrix plays a key role in the overall rheological behavior of these aqueous surfactants. 3. Cationic Surfactants The ternary lamellar liquid crystal of hexadecyltlrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), hexanol, and water was determined in couette flow at 25°C and varying water concentration from 30–80% [285]. Viscometric measurements were obtained through constant shear rate experiments applied as a series of shear rate pulses with the shear stress response obtained for samples containing 30, 40, and 50% water. An increase in water content to 60% produces markedly differing results. This sample, also within the lamellar liquid crystal phase, exhibits rheopexy while subjected to a train of shear rate pulses at 77.5 s1. This is attributed to the formation of a nonequilibrium metastable microstructure. Xray diffraction shows no change in the repeat distance of the lamellar liquid crystal, and it is hypothesized that shearing creates large oriented domains as evidenced from polarized microscopy. In steady shearing flow, Newtonian behavior is observed at low shear rates and twofold cooperative coordination at higher shear rates.
Page 115
FIG. 28 (a) Storage and loss modulus at 25°C and 10 rad/s of aqueous C12E7SO4Na gels (70% weight active) at 25°C and a strain of 0.005 using 25 mm parallel plate geometry. (b) Storage and loss modulus of aqueous C12E7SO4Na lamellar liquid crystal gels (70% weight active) at 25°C and a strain of 0.005 using 25 mm parallel plate geometry.
Page 116
C. PolymerSurfactant Interactions Most commercial detergent preparations contain both polymers and surfactants and these components can be interactive [286]. Complexation can have a significant influence on rheological behavior, depending on the topology of the association, and several associative complexes are represented in Fig. 29 [287]. Type 3 contains a surfactant species, a divalent cationic surfactant capable of physically crosslinking the polymer chain. Depending on the concentration of
FIG. 29 Representation of polymersurfactant complexes. (From Ref. 287.)
Page 117
both surfactant and polymer, this can lead to gel formation, depending on the flexibility of the polymer backbone, the geometry of the micelle, and the polarity and charge distribution. Viscosity measurements provide an excellent tool to study polymersurfactant interactions. This is demonstrated very effectively for various polymer surfactant pairs [288–291]. Nagarajan and Kalpakci have studied polyethylene oxide and dextran in the presence of cationic, anionic, and nonionic surfactants [292]. Polyethylene oxide with a flexible backbone shows a significant interaction with anionic micelles, including sodium dodecyl sulfate, sodium dodecyl benzene sulfonate, and 8phenyl hexadecane benzene sulfonate, and minimal complexation with cationic systems, such as dodecyl amine hydrochloride, didodecyl dimethyl ammonium bromide, and ethyl hexadeyl dimethyl ammonium bromide. It appears that polymers with rigid backbones, such as dextran, do not favor complexation with either anionic or cationic surfactants. The absence of surface binding has also been confirmed through surface tension measurements. Hydrogels have been formed from nonionic surfaceactive graft copolymers and unmicellized anionic surfactants [293]. It is suspected that comicelles are formed between surfactant monomers and polymer hydrocarbon side chains for hydrophobically modified hydroxyethylcellulose and sodium dodecyl sulfate with gel formation at critical concentrations of the polymer and surfactant. Dynamic mechanical rheology properties are presented supporting the formation of a gel network structure. Further, Goddard et al. have studied the interaction of a cationic cellulosic ether polymer with anionic, cationic and nonionic surfactants [294]. Gelation occurs with anionic surfactants, especially SDS; higher chain length cationic surfactants, such as C12–C14 TAB, show no interaction with the polymer. In addition, interactions are not apparent with nonionic surfactants although surface tensions measurements indicate the contrary. Many other references are available to the reader to explore fully the implications of polymersurfactant interactions in liquid detergent systems [295–304]. Various physical and electrochemical methods, such as sedimentation, light scattering, viscometry, potentiometry, polarography, conductivity, and ultracentrifugation, are combined to evaluate hydrodynamic properties and conformation of the complexed pair. This includes both polymeric acids and bases and their salts and nonionic watersoluble polymer solutions, both dilute and concentrated systems. For example, the interaction of lowmodularweight polymers in concentrated aqueous surfactant systems has been reported by Mast and colleagues [305]. Their research, involving both polyethylene oxide and hydrophobically modified polyethylene oxide in high surfactant and salt concentrations, demonstrates the importance of viscometric measurements and rheological characterizations in exploring polymersurfactant complexation.
Page 118
VI. Conclusions The rheology of liquid detergents is a fascinating research area because of the breadth of rheological properties that can occur. Depending on the chemistry and morphology of the surfactant micelles, and the various interactions that can develop in the presence of additives, even dilute solutions well below the CMC, can exhibit nonNewtonian flow behavior. Many types of flow anomalies have been documented, including dilatancy, pseudoplasticity, rheopexy, and thixotropy, and yield stresses are also not uncommon. Further, rheological characterizations are complicated by the dependence of these flow anomalies on the magnitude of the applied external flow field. Systems that appear Newtonian can exhibit nonNewtonian behavior within relatively narrow ranges of shear rates and strains. This is further complicated by the time scales of these effects, because shearinduced structural transitions occur following induction periods that vary in duration depending on the composition of the surfactant system. Characterization of commercial liquid detergent products can be relatively straightforward. Interpretation of these rheological characterizations, however, is a challenge. Data analysis requires a more fundamental understanding of the internal mechanisms binding the surfactant system under investigation. Coupling of rheological characterizations with other analytical techniques such as microscopy, CryTEM, xray diffraction, SANS, NMR, and flow birefringence, a greater understanding of the morphology of the liquid detergent and resulting rheology can be obtained. There has been an increasing emphasis in this area, leading to greater insight into the structureproperty relations of liquid detergents. References 1. E. Hatschek and R. S. Janes, Kolloid Z.38:33(1926). 2. P. A. Winsor, Trans. Faraday Soc. 58:88 (1954). 3. N. Pilpel, Trans. Faraday Soc. 60:779 (1956). 4. N. Pilpel, Trans. Faraday Soc. 62:1015 (1966) 5. T. Nash, J. Appl. Chem. 6:300 (1956). 6. T. Nash, J. Appl. Chem. 6:539 (1956). 7. R. B. Bird, R.C. Armstrong, and O. Hassager, Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids, Vols. 1 and 2, John Wiley & Sons, New York 1977. 8. R. I. Tanner, Engineering Rheology, Oxford, New York, 1985. 9. R. G. Larson, Constructive Equations for Polymer Melts and Solutions, Butterworths Series in Chemical Engineering, Butterworths, Boston, 1988. 10. J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York 1980. 11. H.A. Barnes, Rheometry: Industrial Applications, Detergents, Mater Sci Res Stud Serl, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1980).
9. R. G. Larson, Constructive Equations for Polymer Melts and Solutions, Butterworths Series in Chemical Engineering, Butterworths, Boston, 1988. 10. J. D. Ferry, Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York 1980. 11. H.A. Barnes, Rheometry: Industrial Applications, Detergents, Mater Sci Res Stud Serl, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1980).
Page 119
12. A. A. Collyer and D. W. Clegg, Rheological Measurement, Elsevier Applied Science, New York, 1988. 13. R. W. Brodkey, Phenomena of Fluid Motions, AddisonWesley Series in Chemical Engineering, Reading, MA, 1967. 14. R. B. Bird, W. E. Stewart, and E. N. Lightfoot, Transport Pheonomena, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1960. 15. F. R. Eirich, ed., Rheology, Vols I–IV Academic Press, New York, 1960. 16. H. A. Barnes, Rheometry, Industrial Applications. Detergents, Mater Sci Res Stud Series 1 (Rheom and Appl), 1980, p. 38. 17. J. W. Goodwin, in Surfactants (T. Tadros, ed.), Academic Press, London, 1984. 18. H. Hoffman and H. Rehage, in Surfactant Solutions (R. Zana, ed.), Marcel Dekker, Surfactant Science Series Vol. 22. 19. F. R. Eirich, Rheology, Theory and Applications, Vols. 1–5, Academic Press, New York 1967. 20. R. B. Bird, R. C. Armstrong, and O. Hassager, Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids, Vol. 1, Fluid Mechanics, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1977. 21. R. B. Bird, R. C. Armstrong and O. Hassager, Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids, Vol. 2, Kinetic Theory. Wiley, New York, 1977. 22. B. D. Coleman, H. Markovitz, and W. Noll, Viscometric Flows of Non Newtonian Fluids, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1966. 23. A. S. Lodge, Elastic Liquids, Academic Press, New York, 1964. 24. J. Ferguson and Z. Kemblowski, Applied Fluid Rheology, Elsevier Applied Science, London, 1991. 25. R. E. Carter, ed. Rheology of Food, Pharmaceutical and Biological Materials with General Rheology, Elsevier Applied Science, London, 1990. 26. R. K. Prud'homme, Rheological measurements, in Polymers as Rheology Modifiers (D. N. Schulz, J. E. Glass, eds.), ACS Symp Ser 462, Washington, D.C., 1991. 27. J. M. Castro, U.S. Patent 4,788,005 to the Clorox Co. (1988). 28. J. P. Farr and D. T. Carty, U.S. Patent to the Clorox Co. (1990). 29. P. L. Dawson and J. C. Van de Pas, European Patent EP90/01885 to Unilever PLC. 30. C. J. Buytenhek, M. Meyer, C. J. Van de Pas, and J. H. M. Rek, European Patent EP414,285 to Unilever NV. 31. T. B. Neil and D. J. Wilson, European Patent EP314,232 to Unilever NV.
29. P. L. Dawson and J. C. Van de Pas, European Patent EP90/01885 to Unilever PLC. 30. C. J. Buytenhek, M. Meyer, C. J. Van de Pas, and J. H. M. Rek, European Patent EP414,285 to Unilever NV. 31. T. B. Neil and D. J. Wilson, European Patent EP314,232 to Unilever NV. 32. Japanese Patent JP62,010,197 assigned to Nippon Oils & Fats KK. 33. J. Dixit, M. Shevade and R. Rounds, U.S. Patnet 5,053,158 to the ColgatePalmolive Company (1991). 34. N. Dixit, M. Shevade and R. Rounds, U.S. Patent 5,064,553 to the ColgatePalmolive Company (1989). 35. R. Corring, U.S. Patent 4,836,948 to Lever Brothers Co. (1989). 36. W. G. Bush and D. Braun, U.S. Patnet 4,226, 736 to the Drackertt Co. (1980). 37. G. D. Rose, A. S. Teot and K. G. Seymour, U. S. Patent 4,800,036 to the Dow Chemical Company (1989). 38. G. D. Rose and A. S. Teot, Structure and Flow in Surfactant Solutions (C. A.
Page 120
Herb and R. K. Prud'homme, eds.) ACS Symp Ser 578. Washington, D.C., 1994. 39. W. J. Nicholson, U.S. Patent 5,248,434 to the Procter and Gamble Company (1993). 40. R. M. Wise, U.S. Patent 5,384,061 to the Procter and Gamble Company (1995). 41. R. Torenbeek, J. J. H. Ploumen, U.S. Patent to Akzo Nobel N.V. (1994). 42. R. Corring and R. Gabriel, U.S. Patent 1,441,664 to Lever Brothers Co. 43. W. L. Smith, U.S. Patent 5,389,157 to the Clorox Co. (1995). 44. W. L. Smith, U.S. Patent 5,055,219 to the Clorox Co. (1991). 45. B. Stoddart, U.S. Patent 4,783,283. 46. C. K. Choy and P. F. Reboa, European Patent EP594314A1 to the Clorox Co. 47. E. M. Marin, A. E. Sherry and K. D. Jones, U.S. Patent 5,320,783 (1994). 48. R. B. Bird, W. E. Stewart, E. N. Lightfoot, U.S. Patent 5,320,783, (1994). 49. D. C.H. Cheng and F. Evans Br. J. Appl. Phys. 16:1599 (1965). 50. H. A. Mercer and H. D. Heymann, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 1:199 (1974). 51. A. Zosel, Rheol. Acta 21:72 (1982). 52. I. M. Lyklema, T. van den Tempel and van Vliet, Rheol. Acta 17:525 (1978). 53. V. V. Chavan, A. K. Deysarkar and J. Ulbrecht, Che, Eng. J. 10:205 (1975). 54. S. Onogi and T. Matsumoto, Poly. Eng. Rev. 1:45 (1981). 55. T. Lim, J. T. Uhl and R. K. Prud'homme, J. Rheol. 28:367 (1984). 56. A. S. Yoshimura and R. K. Prud'homme, Rheol. Acta 26:428 (1987). 57. R. S. Rounds, Cosmetics & Toiletries 110, April 1995. 58. G. G. Fuller, and C. A. Cathey, ACS Symposium Seris 462 (D. N. Schulz and J. E. Glass, eds.) ACS, Washington, D.C., 1991. 59. J. A. Odell, A. Keller, and M. J. Miles, J. Poly. Commun. 24:7 (1983). 60. D. C. MacWilliams, J. H. Rogers and T. J. West, Polymer Science and Technology (N. Bikales, ed.) Plenum, New York, Vol. 2.
58. G. G. Fuller, and C. A. Cathey, ACS Symposium Seris 462 (D. N. Schulz and J. E. Glass, eds.) ACS, Washington, D.C., 1991. 59. J. A. Odell, A. Keller, and M. J. Miles, J. Poly. Commun. 24:7 (1983). 60. D. C. MacWilliams, J. H. Rogers and T. J. West, Polymer Science and Technology (N. Bikales, ed.) Plenum, New York, Vol. 2. 61. F. Durst, R. Haas and B. U. Kaczmar, J. Appl. Poly. Sci. 26:3125 (1981). 62. J. A. Odell, A. Keller and A. J. Muller, Polymers in Aqueous Media: Performance Through Association (J. E. Glass, ed.) ACS, Washington, D.C., 1989. 63. A. Keller, A. J. Muller and J. A. Odell, Progress Coll. Poly. Sci. 75:179 (1987). 64. K. Vissmann and H. Bewersdorff, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 34:289 (1990). 65. G. G. Fuller, C. A. Cathey, H. Brent and B. E. Zebrowski, J. Rheol. 31:235 (1987). 66. R. Clark, Sixth International Conference, “Gums and Stabilizers for the Food Industry,” July, Wrexham, Wales. 67. H. A. Barnes, J. F. Hutton and K. Walters, An Introduction to Rheology. Elsevier, Amsterdam. 68. D. F. James, B. D. McLean and J. H. Saringer, J. Rheol. 31:453 (1987). 69. A. B. Metzner and A. P. Metzner, Rheol. Acta 9:174 (1974). 70. D. H. Fruman and M. Barigah, Rheol. Acta 21:556 (1982). 71. K. Hashimoto and T. Imae, Langmiur 7:1734 (1991). 72. D. T. Wasan and V. Mohan, AIChe Symposium, Improved Oil Recovery Surfactant Polymer Flooding, 1976. 73. L. Gupta and D. T. Wasan, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fund. 13:26.
Page 121
74. D. A. Edwards and D. T. Wasan, J. Rheol. 32:429 (1988). 75. D. A. Edwards and D. T. Wasan, J. Rheol. 32:447 (1988). 76. D. A. Edwards and D. T. Wasan, J. Rheol. 32:473 (1988). 77. D. T. Wasan and V. Mohan, Improved Oil Recovery Surfactant Polymer Flooding, PAP AIChE Symp., 1977. 78. J. W. Goodwin, NATO ASI Series C 324, The Structure, Dynamics and Equilibrium Properties of Colloidal Systems (D. M. Bloor and E. WynJones, eds.) Kluewer Academic, Netherlands, 1990. 79. H. M. Princen, J. Coll. Interf Sci. 105:150 (1985). 80. H. M. Princen, J. Coll. Interf Sci. 91:160 (1983). 81. A. M. Kraynik, D. A. Reinelt, and H. M. Princen, J. Rheol. 35:1235 (1991). 82. D. A. Reinelt and A. M. Kraynik, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 132:491 (1989). 83. W. R. Schowalter, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 16:245 (1984). 84. W. J. Russel, J. Rheol. 24:287 (1980). 85. J. Ferguson and Z. Kemblowski, Applied Fluid Rheology, Elsevier, London, 1991. 86. H. A. Barnes, J. Rheol. 33:330 (1989). 87. I. M. Krieger and T. J. Dougherty, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 3:137 (1959). 88. J. Mewis and R. de Bleyser, Rheol. Acta 14:721 (1975). 89. W. B. Russel, D. A. Saville and W. R. Schowalter, Colloidal Dispersions, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989. 90. D. J. Jeffrey and A. Acrivos, AIChE J. 22:417 (1977). 91. J. Mewis and J. B. Spaull, Adv. Coll. Interf. Sci. 6:173 (1976). 92. C. Tsenoglou, J. Rheol. 34:15 (1990). 93. I. M. Krieger and T. J. Dougherty, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 3:137 (1959). 94. W. J. Boersma, J. Laven and H. N. M. Stein, AIChE J. 36:321 (1990). 95. D. C. Cheng and R. A. Richmond, Rheol. Acta 17:446 (1990). 96. A. L. Graham and R. B. Bird, Ind. Chem. Fund. 23:406 (1984). 97. R. L. Hoffman, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 46:491 (1974). 98. V. V. Jinescu, Int. Chem. Eng. 14:397 (1974). 99. J. C. Van der Werff and C. G. Kruif, J. Rheo. 33:421 (1989).
96. A. L. Graham and R. B. Bird, Ind. Chem. Fund. 23:406 (1984). 97. R. L. Hoffman, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 46:491 (1974). 98. V. V. Jinescu, Int. Chem. Eng. 14:397 (1974). 99. J. C. Van der Werff and C. G. Kruif, J. Rheo. 33:421 (1989). 100. J. Mewis, W. J. Frith, T. A. Strivens and W. B. Russel, AIChE J. 35:415 (1989). 101. I. M. Krieger and T. J. Dougherty, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 3:137 (1959). 102. W. B. Russel and A. P. Gast, J. Chem. Phys. 84:1815 (1986). 103. L. V. Woodcock, Chem. Phys. Lett. 11:455 (1984). 104. C. G. De Kruid, E. M. F. Iersel and W. B. Russel, J. Chem. Phys. 83:4717 (1985). 105. I. M. Krieger, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 7:101 (1963). 106. S. V. Kao, L. E. Liesen, C. T. Hill, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 53:367 (1875). 107. D. Chan, R. L. Powell, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 15:165 (1984). 108. A. Tsutsumi and K. Yoshida, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 26:175 (1987). 109. S. J. Johnson, A. J. Salem and G. G. Fuller, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 34:89 (1990). 110. JaneschitzKriegl and J. M. P. Papenhuigzen, Rheol. Acta 10:481 (1971).
Page 122
111. S. Onogi and T. Matsumoto, Polymer Engineering Reviews 1:46 (1981). 112. L. A. Utracki, The rheology of twophase flows., in Rheological Measurements (A. A. Collyer and D. W. Clegg, eds.) Elsevier, London, 1988. 113. D. L. Smithy and D. A. Barclay, JAOCS 65:101722 (1988). 114. D. Heath and T. F. Tadros, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 93:307 (1983). 115. B. Siffert and Y. Bocquenet, Coll. Surf. 11:137 (1984). 116. J. D. F. Ramsay, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 109:441 (1986). 117. Y. Otsubo, Langmiur 11:1893 (1995). 118. G. S. Grover and S. G. BIke, Langmiur 11:1807 (1995). 119. E. Popovici, M. Grecu, A. Popa, M. Alexandroaie, A. Vasile, M. Craceanu and N. Dumitru, Rev. Roum. Chim. 32:707 (1987). 120. S. Ainsworth, C&EN, January 20, p. 27 (1992). 121. H. JaneschitzKriegl and J. M. P. Papenhuijzen, Rheol. Acta 10:461 (1971). 122. J. B. Rosevear, J. Soc. Cosmetic Chem. 19:581 (1968). 123. B. Milwidsky, HAPPI, p. 49, October (1968). 124. J. M. P. Papenhuijzen, Rheol. Acta 11:73 (1972). 125. J. Laven and H. N. Stein, J. Rheol. 35:1523 (1991). 126. A. Jurgens, C. P. Pallvast and G. van der Voet, Materialen 7:21 (1988). 127. J. M. P. Papenjhuijzen and M. van den Tempel, Rheol. Acta 6:311 (1967). 128. A. Jurgens, Tenside Surf. Det. 26:22 (1989). 129. J. C. Van de Pas, Tenside Surf. Det. 28:158 (1991). 130. A. W. Sisko, Ind. Eng. Chem. 50:1789 (1958). 131. D. A. G. Bruggeman, Ann. Phys. 24:L636 (1935). 132. R. L. Hoffman, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 16:155 (1972). 133. V. V. Jinescu, Int. Chem. Eng. 14:397 (1974). 134. H. M. Laun, R. Bung and F. Schmidt, J. Rheol. 35:999 (1991). 135. W. H. Boersma, P. J. M. Baets, J. Laven and H. N. Stein, J. Rheol. 35:1093 (1991). 136. Y. Otsubo, Langmiur 11:1893–1898 (1995).
134. H. M. Laun, R. Bung and F. Schmidt, J. Rheol. 35:999 (1991). 135. W. H. Boersma, P. J. M. Baets, J. Laven and H. N. Stein, J. Rheol. 35:1093 (1991). 136. Y. Otsubo, Langmiur 11:1893–1898 (1995). 137. G. J. Fleer and J. J. Lyklema, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 46:1 (1974). 138. Y. Otsubo and K. Watanabe, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 24:265 (1987). 139. P. D. Patel and W. B. Russel, J. Rheol. 31:599 (1087). 140. B. Vincent, P. F. Luckham and F. A. Waite, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 73:508 (1980). 141. Y. Otsubo, Langmiur 10:1018 (1994). 142. J. C. Van der Werff and C. G. de Kruif, J. Rheol. 33:421 (1989). 143. J. C. Van der Werff, C. G. de Kruiif and J. K. G. Dhont, Phys. A 160:205 (1989). 144. K. Kawasaki, M. Tokuyanam and Kawakatsu, eds., Slow Dynamics in Condensed Matter, New York. 1992, pp. 391–400. 145. D. Ronis, Phys. Rev A, 29:1453 (1984). 146. T. S. R. AlHadithi, H. A. Barnes and K. Walter, Coll. Poly. Sci. 270:40 (1992). 147. G. Bossis and J. F. Brady, J. Chem. Phys. 87:5437 (1987). 148. J. F. Brady, J. Chem. Phys. 99:567 (1993). 149. S. Small and W. B. Russel, J. Rheol. 31:651 (1987). 150. H. M. Laun, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 54:87 (1994).
Page 123
151. A. I. Johma and P. A. Reynolds, Rheol. Acta 32:457 (1993). 152. J. F. Brady and M. Vicic, J. Rheol. 39:545 (1995). 153. M. M. Santore, W. B. Russel and R. K. Prud'homme, Macromolecules 23:3821 (1990). 154. A. Mourchild, A. Delville, J. Lambard, E. Lecolier and P. Levitz, Langmiur 11:6 (1995). 155. R. Buscall, J. W. Goodwin, M. W. Hawkins and R. J. Ottewill, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 78:2889 (1982). 156. P. A. Buining, A. P. Philpse and H. N. W. Lekkerkerker, Langmiur 10:2106 (1994). 157. B. Rand, E. Pekenc, J. W. Woodwin and R. W. Smith, J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. I 76:225 (1980). 158. H. Van Olphen, An Introduction to Clay Colloid Chemistry, Wiley, New York, 1977. 159. R. G. Avery and J. D. Ramay, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 109:448 (1986). 160. J. D. F. Ramsay, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 109:441 (1986). 161. A. F. Gabrysh, T. Ree, H. Eyring, N. McKee and I. Cutler, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 5:67 (1961). 162. A. Tsutsumi and K. Yoshida, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 26:175 (1987). 163. B. Clark, Trans. Inst. Chem. Eng. 45:251 (1967). 164. J. S. Chong, E. B. Christiansen and A. D. Baer, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 15:2007 (1971). 165. T. Amari and K. Watanabe, Polym. Eng. Rev. 3:277 (1983). 166. R. H. Ottewill, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 58:357 (1977). 167. F. I. Feigin and D. H. Napper, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 75:525 (1980). 168. D. H. Napper, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 58:390 (1977). 169. E. Matijevic, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 58:374 (1977). 170. S. C. Tsai and K. Zammouri, J. Rheol. 32:737 (1988). 171. N. De Rooy, P. L. de Bruyn and T. G. Overbeek, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 75:542 (1980). 172. J. Mewis, W. J. H. Frith, T. A. Strivens and W. B. Russel, AIChE J. 35:415 (1989). 173. F. R. Eirich, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 58:423 (1977). 174. Colloids and Surfaces 15:1 (1985).
75:542 (1980). 172. J. Mewis, W. J. H. Frith, T. A. Strivens and W. B. Russel, AIChE J. 35:415 (1989). 173. F. R. Eirich, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 58:423 (1977). 174. Colloids and Surfaces 15:1 (1985). 175. H. M. Princen, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 105:150 (1985). 176. J. P. Heller and M. S. Kuntamukkula, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 26:318 (1987). 177. A. M. Kraynik, D. A. Reinelt and H. M. Princen, J. Rheol. 35:1235 (1991). 178. S. A. Khan, RheolActa 26:78 (1987). 179. S. A. Khan and R. C. Armstrong, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 25:61 (1987). 180. A. M. Kraynik and Hansen, J. Rheol. 31:175 (1983). 181. D. A. Reinelt and A. M. Kraynik, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 132:491 (1989). 182. R. Pons, C. Solans and T. F. Tadros, Langmiur 11:1966 (1995). 183. D. Weaire, T.L. Fu, J. Rheol 32:271 (1988). 184. P.Sherman, ed. Rheology of Emulsions, Macmillan, New York, 1963. 185. R. Pal and E. Rhodes, JOR 33:1021 (1989).
Page 124
186. H. M. Princen, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 91:160 (1983). 187. H. M. Princen, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 105:150 (1985). 188. P. Sherman, Encylopedia of Emulsion Technology (P. Becher, ed.) Marcel Dekker, New York, 1983. 189. H. M. Princen, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 122:427 (1986). 190. H. M. Princen and A. D. Kiss, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 128:176 (1989). 191. R. Pal and E. Rhodes, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 107:301 (1985). 192. R. Pal and E. Rhodes, J. Rheol. 33:1021 (1989). 193. A. S. Yoshimura and R. K. Prud'homme, J. Rheol. 31:699 (1987). 194. K. Goodrich, A. Yoshimura and R. K. Prud'homme, J. Rheol. 33:317 (1989). 195. M. Keentok, Rheol. Acta 21:325 (1982). 196. N. J. Alderman, G. H. Meeten and J. D. Sherwood, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 39:291 (1991). 197. N. Q. Dzuy and D. V. Boger, J. Rheol. 27:321 (1983). 198. N. Q. Dzuy and D. V. boger, J. Rheol. 29:335 (1985). 199. M. Keentok, Rheol. Acta 21:325 (1982). 200. A. Yoshimua and R. K. Prud'homme, J. Rheol. 32:53 (1988). 201. A. S. Yoshimura and R. K. Prud'homme, SPE Res. Eng. May (1988). 202. A. S. Yoshimua and R. K. Prud'homme, Rheol. Acta 26:428 (1987). 203. P. Doremus and J. M. Piau, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 23:91 (1987). 204. A. Magnin and J. M. Piau, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 23:91 (1987). 205. H. Tanaka and J. L. White, Polym. Eng. Sci. 20:949 (1980). 206. D. Doraiswamy, A. N. Mujumdar, I. Rsao, A. N. Beris, S. C. Danforth and A. B. Metzner, J. Rheol. 35:647 (1991). 207. D. H. Everett, Basic Principles of Colloid Science, Royal Society of Chemistry, 1988. 208. I. C. M. Dea, E. R. Morris, D. A. Rees and E. J. Welsh, Carbohyd. Res. 57:249 (1977). 209. Add Microdomains in Polymer Solutions. 210. T. Lim, J. Ulh and R. K. Prud'homme, J. Rheol. 28:367 (1984).
208. I. C. M. Dea, E. R. Morris, D. A. Rees and E. J. Welsh, Carbohyd. Res. 57:249 (1977). 209. Add Microdomains in Polymer Solutions. 210. T. Lim, J. Ulh and R. K. Prud'homme, J. Rheol. 28:367 (1984). 211. K. C. Tam and C. Tiu, JOR 33:257 (1989). 212. D. Clark and W. Miller, Polym. Preprint 24:87 (1983). 213. R. J. Ketz, R. K. Prud'homme and W. W. Graeassley, Rheol Acta. 27:531 (1988). 214. R. Y. Lochhead, C. E. Sauer and R. K. Nagarajan, AOCS Annual Meeting, Baltimore, Md. April 23, 1990. 215. H. Hakert, T. Eckert and T. Muller, Coll. Polym. Sci. 267:226 (1989). 216. D. S. Pearson and W. W. Graessley, Macromolcules 13:1001 (1980). 217. R. K. Prud'homme, J. T. Uhl, J. P. Poinsatte and F. Halverson, Soc. Petrol. Eng. J. (October 1983). 218. P. F. Reboa and M. C. Fryan, JOACS 69:7 (1992). 219. P. Mukerjee, J. Coll. Sc. 19 (1964). 220. A. Einstein, Ann. Phys. 19:289 (1906). 221. A. Einstein, Ann. Phys. 24:591 (1911). 222. F. Booth, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. 203:533 (1950).
Page 125
223. M. A. Schafheutle and H. Finkelmann, Liquid Crystals 3:10 (1988). 224. Y. Otsubo and R. K. Prud'homme, Colloids and Surfaces 40 (1989). 225. P. H. Elworthy and M. S. Patel, J. Pharm. Pharmacol. 36 (1984). 226. R. J. Robson and E. A. Dennis, J. Phys. Chem. 81:11 (1977). 227. A. K. Wright, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 55:109 (1976). 228. C. Tanford, Y. Nozaki and M. F. Rohde, J. Phys. Chem. 81:16 (1977). 229. A. Moreno, J. Bravo and J. L. Berna, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 65:6 (1988). 230. E. Rybicki, Tenside Surf. Det. 27:5 (1990). 231. N. Kamenka, M. Chorro, H. Fabre, B. Lindman, J. Rouviere and C. Cabes, J. Coll. Polym. Sci. 257:757 (1979). 232. C. F. Putnik and S. E. McGuire, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 55:12 (1978). 233. T. Akhtar and M. Allauddin, J. Bangladesh Acad. Sci. 15:2 (1991). 234. V. Y. Bezzobotnov, S. Borbely, L. Cser, B. Barago, I. A. Gladkih, Y. M. Ostanevich and S. Vass, J. Phys. Chem,. 92:20 (1988). 235. C. Gamboa and L. Sepulveda, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 113:2 (1986). 236. P. A. Winsor, J. Coll. Sci. 54:88 (1954). 237. N. Pilpel, J. Coll. Sci. 54:285 (1954). 238. W. Philippoff, Disc. Faraday Soc. 11:96 (1951). 239. H. Uchiyama, M. Abe, and K. Ogini, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 138:1 (1990). 240. H. Hoffman, A. Rauscher and M. Gradzielski, Langmiur 8:9 (1992). 241. D. Saul, G. J. T. Tiddy, B. A. Wheeler, P. A. Wheeler and E. Willis, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1:70 (1974). 242. H. Hoffmann, G. Platz and W. Ulbricht, J. Phys. Chem. 85, (1981). 243. H. Hoffmann, G. Platz, H. Rehave and W. Schorr. Adv. Coll. Interf. Sci. 17 (1982). 244. H. Rehage and H. Hoffmann, Rheol. Acta 21 (1982). 245. J. Ulmius, H. Wennerstrom, L. Johansson, G. Lindblom and S. Gravsholt, J. Phys. Chem. 83:2232 (1979). 246. H. Rehage and H. Hoffman, Faraday Disc. Chem. Soc. 76: 363 (1983). 247. K. L. Mittal and B. Lindman, eds., Surfactant Solutions (Proc. Int. Symp.), 4th Meeting, Vol. 1, Plenum, New York, 1982). 248. H. Hoffmann, H. Hobl, H. Rehage and I. Wunderlich, Tenside
Gravsholt, J. Phys. Chem. 83:2232 (1979). 246. H. Rehage and H. Hoffman, Faraday Disc. Chem. Soc. 76: 363 (1983). 247. K. L. Mittal and B. Lindman, eds., Surfactant Solutions (Proc. Int. Symp.), 4th Meeting, Vol. 1, Plenum, New York, 1982). 248. H. Hoffmann, H. Hobl, H. Rehage and I. Wunderlich, Tenside Detergents 22:6 (1985). 249. H. Hoffmann, M. Lobl and H. Rehage, Proc. Int. Sch. Phys. Enrico Fermi 90 (1985). 250. H. Hoffman, Adv. Coll. Inter. Sci. 32:2 (1990). 251. S. J. Candau, E. Hirsch and R. Zana, J. Phys. 45 (1984). 252. M. E. Cates and M. S. Turner, Europhys. Lett. 11 (1990). 253. J. Ulmius, H. Wennerstrom, L. B. A. Johansson, G. Lindblom and S. J. Gravsholt, Phys. Chem. 83 (1979). 254. T. Nash, J. Appl. Chem. 6:539 (1956). 255. S. Gravsholt, Rheology (Proc. Int. Cong.) 83:3 (1980). 256. S. Gravholt, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 57:3 (1976). 257. H. Rehage and H. Hoffmann, Mol. Phys. 74:5 (1991). 258. H. Rehage and H. Hoffmann, Faraday Disc. Chem. Soc. 76:363 (1983).
Page 126
259. M. Doi and S. F. Edwards, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 2 (1978). 260. H. Rehage and H. Hoffmann, Faraday Disc. Chem. Sox. 76:363 (1983). 261. S. Gravsholt, Proc. Int. Cong. Surface Activity (6th), 1973. 262. A. J. Hyde and D. W. Johnstone, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 53 (1975). 263. U. R. Rao, C. Manohar, B. S. Valaulikar and R. M. Iyer, J. Phys. Chem. 91:12 (1987). 264. T. M. Clausen, P. K. Vinson, J. R. Minter, H. T. Davis, Y. Talmon and W. G. Miller, J. Phys. Chem. 96:1 (1992). 265. G. E. Totten, E. D. Goddard, G. H. Matteson and M. L. Wanchisen, JAOCS 63:12 (1986). 266. H. Hoffmann, H. Lobl, H. Rehage and I. Wunderlich, Tenside Detergents 22:6 (1985). 267. T. Shikata and T. Kotaka, J. NonCryst. Solids, 133, Part 2 (1991). 268. T. Shikata, H. Hirata, E. Takatori, and K. Osaki, J. NonNewtonian Fluid Mech. 28:2 (1988). 269. T. J. Drye and M. E. Cates, J. Chem. Phys. 96:1367 (1992). 270. Y. Hu, S. Q. Wang and A. M. Jamieson, J. Rheol. 37:531 (1993). 271. H. Rehage and H. Hoffmann, J. Phys. Chem. 92:4712 (1988). 272. I. Wunderlich, H. Hoffmann and H. Rehage, Rheol Acta 26:532 (1987). 273. S. Hoffmann, A. Rauscher and H. Hoffmann, Ber. Bunsenges Phys. Chem. 95:153 (1991). 274. Y. Hu, S. Wang and A. Jamieson, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 156:31 (1993). 275. M. Doi and S. F. Edwards, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday II. 74:179 (1978), Parts I–IV. 276. M. E. Cates, J. Phys. Chem. 96:371 (1990). 277. P. Terech, Croatica Chem. Acta 65:425 (1992). 278. P. J. Flory and G. Ronca, Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. 54f:289 (1979). 279. J. C. Eriksson and S. Ljunggren, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 81:1209 (1985). 280. S. Paasch, F. Schambil and M. J. Schwuger, Langmiur 5:1344 (1989). 281. R. Horn and M. Kleman, J. Phys. (December 1978). 282. M. J. Groves and A. B. Ahmad, Rheol. Acta 15:501 (1976). 283. T. Tamamushi, Y. Kodaira and M. Matsumura, Coll. Poly. Sci. 254:571 (1976).
280. S. Paasch, F. Schambil and M. J. Schwuger, Langmiur 5:1344 (1989). 281. R. Horn and M. Kleman, J. Phys. (December 1978). 282. M. J. Groves and A. B. Ahmad, Rheol. Acta 15:501 (1976). 283. T. Tamamushi, Y. Kodaira and M. Matsumura, Coll. Poly. Sci. 254:571 (1976). 284. V. P. Solyom and P. Ekwall, Rheol. Acta 8:316 (1969). 285. L. Bohlin and K. Fontell, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 67:272 (1978). 286. E. D. Goddard and K. P. Ananthapademanabhan, ed., Interactions of Surfactants with Polymers and Proteins, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1993. 287. R. Nagarajan and B. Kalpakci, in Microdomains in Polymer Solutions, (P. Dubin, ed.) Plenum, New York, 1985. 288. T. Gilanyi and E. Wolfram, in Microdomains in Polymer Solutions, (P. Dubin, ed.) Plenum, New York, 1985. 289. I. D. Robb, Anionic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry of Surfactant Action (E. H. Lucassen Reynders, ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1981. 290. T. Isemura and A. Imanishi, J. Polym. Sci. 33:337 (1958). 291. S. Saito, T. Taniguchi and K. Kitemura, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 30:211 (1969). 292. R. Nagarajan and B. Kalpakci, J. Coll. Interf. Sci. 30:211 (1969). 293. A. Dualeh and C. A. Steiner, Polyelectrolyte Gels (R. S. Harland and R. K. Prud'homme, eds.) ACS Symposium Series 480, 1992.
Page 127
294. E. D. Goddard and P. S. Leung, Coll. Surfaces 65:211. 295. E. A. Bekturov and Z. K. Bakauova, Synmthetic WaterSoluble Polymers in Solution, Huthic & Wepf Verlag, Basel, 1981. 296. P. Molyneux, WaterSoluble Synthetic Polymers: Properties and Behavior, Vol. I. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1985. 297. P. Moyneux, WaterSoluble Synthetic Polymers: Properties and Behavior, Vol. II, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1985. 298. D. N. Schulz, J. E. Glass, eds. Polymers as Rheology Modifiers, ACS Symposium Series 462, ACS, Washington, D.C., 1991. 299. J. E. Glass, ed. Polymers in Aqueous Media, Advances in Chemistry Series 223, ACS, Washington, D.C., 1989. 300. R. S. Harland and R. K. Prud'homme, eds. Polyelectrolyte Gels, ACS Symposium Series 480, ACS, Washington, D.C., 1992. 301. P. Dubin, ed. Microdomains in Polymer Solutions, Polymer Science and Technology, Vol. 30, Plenum Press, New York, 1985. 302. E. D. Goddard, Coll. Surfaces 19:255. 303. E. D. Goddard, Coll. Surfaces 65:211. 304. C. A. Steiner, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 42:6 (1993). 305. A. P. Mast, R. K. Prud'homme, and J. E. Glass, Langmiur 9:708 (1993).
5 Polymeric Stabilizers for Liquid Detergents MADUKKARAI K. NAGARAJAN and HAL AMBUTER Specialty Chemical Division—Product Development, The BFGoodrich Compan Ohio I. Introduction II. Carbomer Resin Usage History A. Automatic machine dishwashing gel B. Liquid cleaner with abrasives C. Liquid laundry detergents D. Specialty liquid cleaner products III. The Technology of Carbomer Resins A. Chemistry of carbomer resins B. Powder properties C. Dispersion properties D. Carbomer microstructure properties E. Carbomer thickening mechanisms IV. Handling Carbomer Resins A. Wetting time B. Dispersion viscosity C. Dispersion techniques D. Formulating with carbomer resins E. Stability evaluations References
Page 130
I. Introduction The market share of liquid detergents steadily increased during the 1980s and 1990s. Their consumer popularity is due in part to ease of handling and dispensing from the packaging container, better dissolution properties in comparison with powders, and perceived performance benefits. However, the conversion from a powder detergent to a liquid or a gel is not without its difficulties for the formulator. First, although the selection of the performance active materials remains more or less the same, the liquid formulator needs to achieve product phase stability over the trade life of the product. Second, the formulator must also consider the rheological behavior of the product (i.e., viscosity, flow characteristics, etc.) to meet the product's and customer's inuse application requirements. Much research and development effort has been spent in investigating and employing solvents, hydrotropes, and complex surfactant combinations to achieve these ends. However, these functional ingredients generally are not suitable for systems that require suspension of insoluble materials and do not deliver the appropriate rheological profile for some applications. For some of these applications, a rheological modifier or additive is required. The use of highly cost efficient polymeric resins in liquid detergents spurred much commercially fruitful formulation technology research in the 1980s and 1990s. Enhanced stability of liquid detergents and new application concepts were achieved and marketed with the incorporation of a small quantity of lightly crosslinked polyacrylic acid network polymers known to the industry as carbomers [1]. Due to their multifunctionality (they thicken, suspend, and provide emulsion stabilization), unique rheological profile, broad compatibility, and high weight efficiency, carbomer resins have become the predominant polymer used in the industry for stabilization of liquid detergents. The history of carbomer usage, carbomer resin chemistry, properties of carbomer powder and aqueous dispersions, carbomer microstructural properties, rheology of carbomercontaining systems, carbomer thickening mechanisms, influence of electrolytes on carbomer properties, and handling of carbomer resin in practical liquid detergent formulations are reviewed in this chapter. II. Carbomer Resin Usage History A. Automatic Machine Dishwashing Gel The automatic machine dishwashing gel (ADG) is a unique formulation in terms of its product requirements. The product requires the thickening of a high ionic strength continuous phase (silicates, carbonates, metal hydroxides) and the suspension of a significant level of insolubles (phosphates). It must also have
a rheological profile that will (1) allow the product to flow easily under normal dis pressures, (2) not splash or splatter upon dispensing, and (3) rapidly regain its str dispensing and exhibit a “yield value” such that the product will not leak out of th dishwasher cup. A typical recipe, with and without a polymeric stabilizing agent, f laboratory, is given below. Weight percent Ingredient
Control
Sodium hydroxide (dry basis) Carbopol 674 resin (BFGoodrich)
Exp
20.0 0
Sodium tripolyphosphate (anhydrous)
13.0
Fatty alcohol ethoxylate (HLB:10)
1.0
Demineralized water
67.0
100.0
The control formulation phase separated, with solids settling to the bottom of the container, within 1 day. On the other hand, the experimental formulation was ho stable for over 3 months, as illustrated in Fig. 1.
FIG. 1 Alkaline slurry detergent stabilized by carbomer resin. Left: Control; solids settled with phase separation. Right: Experimental; homogeneous emulsion, stable for over 3 months.
Page 132
During the early ADG formulation development, use was made of high levels (5–15%) of linear polyacrylic acid in the preferred molecular weight range of 85,000–95,000 [2]. The researchers discovered that high total solids levels (65–80%) could easily be stabilized in industrial warewashing machine slurry detergents through the use of linear polyacrylates. The linear polyacrylate also increased the water softening capacity, thus enabling the reduction of phosphate levels to comply with antieutrophication legislation. Subsequent patents disclosed similar high solids slurries or gels but with the incorporation of low (e.g., 0.5%) levels of carbomer resins for improved stability, improved aesthetics, and much greater formulation flexibility. Moreover, significantly higher (to 98%) cup retention was noticed for ADLs stabilized with carbomer resins than with the linear polyacrylic acid alone. Bush and Braun [3] were among the early researchers to note that gelled dishwashing detergents employing carbomer resin(s) as stabilizing agents leaked less from the dishwashing machine's dispenser cups than even granular solid dishwashing detergents and also described procedures for measuring “cup retention” values. Their investigations showed that the degree of cup retention was not dependent on the viscosity but more on the degree of cohesiveness of the gel, i.e., its ability to hold together or its gelatinousness. Such a property is “yield value,” which indicates the minimum shearing stress to produce continuous deformation or flow. They measured yield value of their gels as
where the viscosity is measured using a Brookfield viscometer. During the late 1980s and early 1990s, the research and patent activity in the use of carbomer resins to stabilize and modify the rheological profile of ADGs became intense. Gabriel and Roselle [4], for example, used a binary mixture of carbomer resins to adjust the yield value and hence the degree of stability of ADL formulations. On the other hand, Koring et al. [5] employed layered clays such as laponite XLS as costabilizers for carbomer resins to achieve improved product phase and active chlorine stability in bleachcontaining ADL systems. Elliot and Kiefer [6] recommended the use of specially synthesized carbomer thickeners wherein the crosslinking agent contained saturated hydrocarbon or aromatic structures to improve both the phase and active chlorine stability. Dixit et al. [7] suggest using, in addition to carbomer stabilizer, a potassium/sodium weight ratio of about 1 to minimize the amount of undissolved solid particles. They further recommend controlling the bulk density of the ADL formulation through the incorporation of air such that the bulk density of the entire composition is approximately equal to the bulk density of the continuous phase.
Page 133
B. Liquid Cleaner with Abrasives Another good example to illustrate the stabilization benefits from the use of carbomer resins in liquid detergents is the abrasivecontaining cleaner products used for cleaning hard surfaces such as washbasins and bathtubs. Commercially available powder abrasive cleaners are composed of finely divided mineral substances (such as silica, calcite, and pumice), surfactants, bleaching agents, and small amounts of optional specialpurpose ingredients such as defoamers. In the early liquid analogs of abrasive cleaner products, higher fatty acid alkanolamides and ethoxylated higher fatty acid alkanolamides were often used as dispersion stabilizers for the insoluble abrasives [8]. The viscosities of these liquid abrasive cleaner products were made extremely high, often higher than 5000 mPa. s, to maintain product phase stability over a long period of time. As a result, these products had poor fluidity and were difficult to dispense from a bottle. Moreover, the insoluble abrasive particles often settled to the bottom of the container, necessitating instructions to shake the bottle before use in order to achieve a homogeneous product during use. Imamura and Shiozaki, in their patent on liquid abrasivecontaining cleanser composition [9], describe the use of small amounts (0.3%) of carbomer resin to stabilize liquid cleaners containing abrasive, nonionic surfactant, and hydrotrope. The pH was adjusted to be between 5 and 9 using mono or triethanolamine as a pH regulator. The viscosity of such a composition was in the range of 1500 mPa. s, easily pourable and stable for long period of time under varied storage temperatures. In addition to providing dispersion stability, the liquid abrasivecontaining cleaner product with polymeric carbomer thickener also possessed vertical cling or antisag properties that are desirable in hard surface cleaning situations. C. Liquid Laundry Detergents 1. Industrial Liquid Laundry Detergent A highly concentrated heavy duty, built liquid laundry detergent product for mechanically metered industrial and institutional (I&I) use is described by Borgerding and Claus [10]. Its composition consists of alkali metal hydroxide, surfactants, sodium aluminosilicate (zeolite 4A) builder and/or complex phosphates, sodium (linear) polyacrylate of molecular weight 50,000–200,000 as a cobuilder, sodium carboxymethylcellulose as an antiredeposition agent, and small amounts of a carbomer resin as a suspending aid. Rek [11] describes the use of carbomer resins to stabilize high alkaline slurry detergents employing a mixture of complex phosphates and silicates and specially selected nonionic surfactants. Sodium salts of carbomer resins are also used to ensure phase stability in an interesting invention by Boskamp [12,13]. In his compositions,
Page 134
Boskamp recommends certain combinations of borax, polyols (such as glycerol), or dicarboxylic acid salts and an antioxidant (such as sodium sulfite) to achieve enzyme and physical stability. Stable, homogeneous, aqueous built laundry detergents stabilized by linear alkalisoluble (e.g., Acrysol ASE95 from Rohm and Haas Company) or crosslinked, alkaliswellable (e.g., Acrysol ASE108) acrylic emulsions are described by Jones and Brabant [14]. In general, an acrylic emulsion polymer is used at 3–10 times the concentration of a carbomer resin to obtain equivalent physical stability. 2. Consumer Liquid Laundry Detergent The industrial laundry detergents just discussed tend to employ high levels of either insoluble (e.g., zeolite) or only partly soluble (e.g., complex phosphate salts) builders, whereas consumer liquid laundry detergents employ water soluble detergent builders such as sodium citrate, sodium nitrilotriacetate, sodium laurate, alkali metal silicates, sodium (linear) polyacrylates, and sodium tetrapotassium pyrophosphate (to some extent). These formulas therefore have a higher ionic strength in the aqueous phase and present new challenges for the formulator. Structured liquid detergent formulations have been described [15] in which carbomertype resins were used to achieve product stability and, curiously enough, to provide a “viscositylowering” characteristic. The overall benefit from the use of carbomer stabilizers, in this instance, is that pourable liquid detergent compositions are obtained with viscosities in the range of 600–7500 mPa. s. Certain interesting formulating ideas useful for making concentrated liquid laundry detergents with total surfactant concentration as high as 60 wt% but with low viscosities (i.e., 40–200 mPa. s at room temperature) have been described by Nagarajan et al. [16]. In such formulating scenarios, carbomer resins incorporated at 0.1–2.0% enable the lowering of viscosities of highly concentrated surfactant solutions and also provide soil antiredeposition properties. The carbomer concentrations are generally lower in predominantly nonionic surfactant formulations (e.g., 0.