ISBN: 0-8247-0457-6 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Headquarters Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New Y...
54 downloads
1255 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ISBN: 0-8247-0457-6 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Headquarters Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016 tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540 Eastern Hemisphere Distribution Marcel Dekker AG Hutgasse 4, Postfach 812, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 41-61-261-8482; fax: 41-61-261-8896 World Wide Web http://www.dekker.com The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above. Copyright # 2001 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced on transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Current printing (last digit): 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Preface
Boundary membranes play a key role in the cells of all contemporary organisms, and simple models of membrane function are therefore of considerable interest. The interface of two immiscible liquids has been widely used for this purpose. For example, the fundamental processes of photosynthesis, biocatalysis, membrane fusion and interactions of cells, ion pumping, and electron transport have all been investigated in such interfacial systems. Processes occurring at the interface between two immiscible liquids present a challenge of great interest because heterogeneous structures of this kind are frequently encountered in Nature. In particular, the electrical double layer at the oil–water interface occurs in a heterogeneous interfacial region that separates different bulk regions of conductive polarized media with a spatial separation of charges. The electrical double layer at the interface between two immiscible liquids determines the kinetics of charge transfer across the phase boundaries, stability and electrokinetic properties of lyophobic colloids, mechanisms of phase transfer or interfacial catalysis, charge separation in biological energy transduction, and heterogeneous enzymatic catalysis. The elucidation of the structure of the interface between two immiscible liquids and the mechanism of charge separation is a fundamental problem of modern chemistry and chemical technology. The interface between two immiscible electrolyte solutions can be either polarizable or nonpolarizable, depending on its permeability to charged particles in the system. If the interface is impermeable to charged particles or the transfer between the phases is difficult, it is called polarizable. A completely nonpolarizable interface containing at least one common ion can pass a high current in either direction without giving rise to a deviation of the interfacial potential difference from the equilibrium value. Although in practice we encounter neither ideally polarizable nor completely nonpolarizable interfaces, under certain conditions the properties of some interfaces are close to ideal. Since any interface is permeable to ions to some extent, only an approximation of the limiting version of a polarizable interface can be realized experimentally. Michael Faraday first studied electron transfer reactions at oil–water interfaces to prepare colloidal metals by reducing metal salts at the ether–water or carbon disulfide– water interfaces. As the field progressed after Faraday’s pioneering observations, it iii
iv
Preface
became clear that vectorial charge transfer at the interface between two dielectric media is an important stage in many bioelectrochemical processes such as those mediated by energy-transducing membranes. Studies have been made on redox and hydrolysis reactions catalyzed by enzymes, photosynthetic pigments, metal complexes of porphyrins, bacteria, and submitochondrial particles, as well as in systems with an extended surface—in microemulsions, vesicles, and reversed micelles. Naturally immobilized enzymes and pigments embedded in a hydrophilic-hydrophobic interface have properties similar to their functional state in a membrane. For instance, certain enzymes can be highly active at the interface but virtually inactive in a homogeneous medium. The interface between two immiscible liquids with immobilized photosynthetic pigments can serve as a convenient model for investigating photoprocesses that are accompanied by spatial separation of charges. The efficiency of charge separation defines the quantum yield of any photochemical reaction. Heterogeneous sytems will be most effective in this regard, where the oxidants and the reductants are either in different phases or sterically separated. Different solubilities of the substrates and reaction products in the two phases of heterogeneous systems can alter the redox potential of reactants, making it possible to carry out reactions that cannot be performed in a homogeneous phase. Elucidation of photosynthetic mechanisms is also significant in designing artificial systems for solar energy utilization. The quantum yield of the photocatalytic reaction depends first of all on the efficiency of the photochemical charge separation. The most effective system should be a heterogeneous system in which the oxidant and the reductant are either in different phases or sterically separated. The difference in solubilities of the substrates and reaction products in both phases of such a heterogeneous structure as the octane–water interface can shift the reaction equilibrium. The redox potential scale is thereby altered, making it possible to carry out reactions that cannot be performed in a homogeneous phase. Extraction of the reaction products and adsorption of the reaction components determine high catalytic properties of the interface between two immiscible liquids, recognized recently as interfacial catalysis. Chemical models of photosynthesis have been used to investigate two types of reactions: photosynthesis and photocatalysis. In photosynthetic processes the standard Gibbs free energy of the reaction is positive, and solar energy is utilized to perform work. In photocatalytic processes the free energy is negative and solar energy is used to overcome the activation barrier. The processes of life have been found to generate electric fields in every organism that has been examined with suitable and sufficiently sensitive measuring techniques. The electrochemical conduction of electrochemical excitation over specialized structures must be regarded as one of the most universal properties of living organisms. It arose at the early stages of evolution in connection with the need for transmission of a signal about an external influence from one part of a biological system to another. Clearly, then, the chemical and physical properties of liquid interfaces represent a significant interdisciplinary research area for a broad range of investigators, such as those who have contributed to this book. The chapters are organized into three parts. The first deals with the chemical and physical structure of oil–water interfaces and membrane surfaces. Eighteen chapters present discussion of interfacial potentials, ion solvation, electrostatic instabilities in double layers, theory of adsorption, nonlinear optics, interfacial kinetics, microstructure effects, ultramicroelectrode techniques, catalysis, and extraction. The second part, on biological applications of interfacial phenomena, has ten chapters that deal successively with protein encapsulation, membranes, effects of phospholi-
Preface
v
pids, biocatalysis, oscillation of membrane potentials, and fundamentals of interfacial electrochemical phenomena in green plants. The final part, on pharmaceutical applications, consists of five chapters and includes topics such as drugs at liquid interfaces, NMR studies, and drugs and gene delivery. We thank the authors for the time they spent on this project and for teaching us about their work. Alexander G. Volkov
Contents
Preface iii Contributors Part I.
xi
Chemistry at Liquid Interfaces
1.
Interfacial Potentials and Cells Zbigniew Koczorowski
1
2.
Ion Solvation and Resolvation 23 Toshiyuki Osakai and Kuniyoshi Ebina
3.
Electroelastic Instabilities in Double Layers and Membranes Michael B. Partenskii and Peter C. Jordan
4.
The GvdW Theory: A Density Functional Theory of Adsorption, Surface Tension, and Screening 83 Sture Nordholm and Robert Penfold
5.
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces Takashi Kakiuchi
6.
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces Pierre-Francois Brevet
7.
The Lattice-Gas and Other Simple Models for Liquid–Liquid Interfaces Wolfgang Schmickler
8.
Dynamic Aspects of Heterogeneous Electron-Transfer Reactions at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces 179 David J. Fermı´n and Riikka Lahtinen
9.
Dynamic Behaviors of Molecules at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces Using the TimeResolved Quasi-Elastic Laser Scattering Method 229 Isao Tsuyumoto and Tsuguo Sawada
51
105
123 153
vii
viii
Contents
10.
Microstructure Effects on Transport in Reverse Microemulsions 241 John Texter
11.
Investigation of Oil–Water Interfaces by Spectroscopic Methods. Relations with Rheological Properties of Multiphasic Systems 257 Eric Dufour, C. Lopez, and S. Herbert
12.
Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy as a Local Probe of Chemical Processes at Liquid Interfaces 283 Anna L. Barker, Christopher J. Slevin, Patrick R. Unwin, and Jie Zhang
13.
Hydrodynamic Techniques for Investigating Reaction Kinetics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Historical Overview and Recent Developments 325 Christopher J. Slevin, Patrick R. Unwin, and Jie Zhang
14.
Catalytic Effect of the Liquid–Liquid Interface in Solvent Extraction Kinetics Hitoshi Watarai
15.
Voltammetry at Micro-ITIES 373 Biao Liu and Michael V. Mirkin
16.
Dynamics of Polar Solvent Motion at Liquid Interfaces Nancy E. Levinger and Ruth E. Riter
17.
Capacitance and Surface Tension Measurements of Liquid–Liquid Interfaces Zdeneˇk Samec
18.
Liquid Membrane Ion-Selective Electrodes: Response Mechanisms Studied by Optical Second Harmonic Generation and Photoswitchable Ionophores as a Molecular Probe 439 Yoshio Umezawa
Part II.
399
Liquid Interfaces in Biological Applications
19.
Water-in-Oil Microemulsions: Protein Encapsulation and Release Douglas G. Hayes
20.
Biomimetic Charge Transfers Through Artificial Membranes 487 Sorin Kihara, Hiroyuki Ohde, Kohji Maeda, Yumi Yoshida, and Osamu Shirai
21.
DNA-Modified Electrodes. Molecular Recognition of DNA and Biosensor Applications 515 Koji Nakano
22.
Phospholipids at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces and Their Effect on Charge Transfer 533 Lasse Murtoma¨ki, Jose´ A. Manzanares, Salvador Mafe´, and Kyo¨sti Kontturi
23.
Biocatalysis in Liquid–Liquid Biphasic Media: Coupled Mass Transfer and Chemical Reactions 553 Mohamed Gargouri
24.
Design of Biocompatible Ion Sensors Keiichi Kimura
585
355
469
415
Contents
ix
25.
The Oscillation of Membrane Potential or Membrane Current Kohji Maeda and Sorin Kihara
26.
Selective Ion Transfer of Alkali and Alkaline Earth Metal Ions Facilitated by Naphtho-15-Crown-5 Across Liquid–Liquid Interfaces and a Bilayer Lipid Membrane 629 Hidekazu Doe
27.
Langmuir and Langmuir–Blodgett Films of Chlorophyll a and Photosystem II Complex 641 Roger M. Leblanc and Veeranjaneyulu Konka
28.
Interfacial Electrical Phenomena in Green Plants: Action Potentials Alexander G. Volkov and John Mwesigwa
Part III.
609
649
Pharmaceutical Applications: Drugs at Liquid Interfaces
29.
Voltammetric Study of Drugs at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces Mitsugi Senda, Yuko Kubota, and Hajime Katano
30.
Electrical Potential Oscillation Across a Water–Oil–Water Liquid Membrane in the Presence of Drugs 699 Kensuke Arai and Fumiyo Kusu
31.
Transfer Mechanisms and Lipophilicity of Ionizable Drugs Fre´de´ric Reymond
32.
NMR Studies on Lipid Bilayer Interfaces Coupled with Anesthetics and Endocrine Disruptors 775 Emiko Okamura and Masaru Nakahara
33.
Lipid Bilayers in Cells: Implications in Drug and Gene Delivery T. Marjukka Suhonen, Pekka Suhonen, and Arto Urtti
Index
845
683
729
807
Contributors
Kensuke Arai Department of Analytical Chemistry, Tokyo University of Pharmacy and Life Science, Tokyo, Japan Anna L. Barker
Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry, England
Pierre-Francois Brevet Laboratoire d’Electrochimie, De´partement de Chimie, Ecole Polytechnique Fe´de´rale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland Hidekazu Doe
Department of Chemistry, Osaka City University, Osaka, Japan
Eric Dufour De´partement Qualite´ et Economie Alimentaires, ENITA ClermontFerrand, Lempdes, France Kuniyoshi Ebina Kobe, Japan
Division of Sciences for Natural Environment, Kobe University,
David J. Fermı´n Laboratoire d’Electrochimie, De´partement de Chimie, Ecole Polytechnique Fe´de´rale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland Mohamed Gargouri Department of Biological and Chemical Engineering, National Institute for Applied Science and Technology, Tunis, Tunisia Douglas G. Hayes Department of Chemical and Materials Engineering, University of Alabama in Huntsville, Huntsville, Alabama S. Herbert
INRA-LEIMA, Nantes, France
Peter C. Jordan Massachusetts
Department
of
Chemistry,
Brandeis
University,
Waltham,
Takashi Kakiuchi Department of Energy and Hydrocarbon Chemistry, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan Hajime Katano Sorin Kihara
Department of Bioscience, Fukui Prefectural University, Fukui, Japan Department of Chemistry, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Kyoto, Japan xi
xii
Contributors
Keiichi Kimura Department of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Systems Engineering, Wakayama University, Wakayama, Japan Zbigniew Koczorowski Poland
Department of Chemistry, University of Warsaw, Warsaw,
Veeranjaneyulu Konka Florida
Department of Chemistry, University of Miami, Coral Gables,
Kyo¨sti Kontturi Department of Chemical Technology, Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Finland Yuko Kubota
Department of Bioscience, Fukui Prefectural University, Fukui, Japan
Fumiyo Kusu Department of Analytical Chemistry, Tokyo University of Pharmacy and Life Science, Tokyo, Japan Riikka Lahtinen Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry, Department of Chemical Technology, Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Finland Roger M. Leblanc Florida
Department of Chemistry, University of Miami, Coral Gables,
Nancy E. Levinger Colorado
Department of Chemistry, Colorado State University, Fort Collins,
Biao Liu Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, City University of New York, Queens College, Flushing, New York C. Lopez
INRA-LEIMA, Nantes, France
Kohji Maeda
Department of Chemistry, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Kyoto, Japan
Salvador Mafe´ Valencia, Spain
Department of Thermodynamics, University of Valencia, Burjasot,
Jose´ A. Manzanares Department of Thermodynamics, University of Valencia, Burjasot, Valencia, Spain Michael V. Mirkin Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, City University of New York, Queens College, Flushing, New York Lasse Murtoma¨ki Department of Chemical Technology, Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Finland John Mwesigwa
Department of Chemistry, Oakwood College, Huntsville, Alabama
Masaru Nakahara
Institute for Chemical Research, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
Koji Nakano Department of Chemical Systems and Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan Sture Nordholm
Department of Chemistry, Go¨teborg University, Go¨teborg, Sweden
Hiroyuki Ohde Japan
Department of Chemistry, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Kyoto,
Emiko Okamura Toshiyuki Osakai
Institute for Chemical Research, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan Department of Chemistry, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan
Contributors
xiii
Michael B. Partenskii Massachusetts
Department of Chemistry, Brandeis University, Waltham,
Robert Penfold Food Materials Science Division, Institute of Food Research, Norwich, England Fre´de´ric Reymond Laboratoire d’Electrochimie, De´partement de Chimie, Ecole Polytechnique Fe´de´rale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland Ruth E. Riter
Department of Chemistry, Agnes Scott College, Decatur, Georgia
Zdeneˇk Samec J. Heyrovsky´ Institute of Physical Chemistry, Academy of Sciences of The Czech Republic, Prague, Czech Republic Tsuguo Sawada Tokyo, Japan
Department of Advanced Materials Science, University of Tokyo,
Wolfgang Schmickler Germany Mitsugi Senda
Department of Electrochemistry, University of Ulm, Ulm,
Department of Bioscience, Fukui Prefectural University, Fukui, Japan
Osamu Shirai Department of Nuclear Energy System, Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute, Ibaraki, Japan Christopher J. Slevin Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry, England Pekka Suhonen Finland
Department of Pharmaceutics, University of Kuopio, Kuopio,
T. Marjukka Suhonen Finland John Texter
Department of Pharmaceutics, University of Kuopio, Kuopio,
Strider Research Corporation, Rochester, New York
Isao Tsuyumoto Department of Environmental Systems Engineering, Kanazawa Institute of Technology, Ishikawa, Japan Yoshio Umezawa
Department of Chemistry, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
Patrick R. Unwin England Arto Urtti
Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry,
Department of Pharmaceutics, University of Kuopio, Kuopio, Finland
Alexander G. Volkov Alabama Hitoshi Watarai Yumi Yoshida Jie Zhang
Department of Chemistry, Oakwood College, Huntsville,
Department of Chemistry, Osaka University, Osaka, Japan Department of Chemistry, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Kyoto, Japan
Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry, England
Current affiliation: DiagnoSwiss, Monthey, Switzerland.
1 Interfacial Potentials and Cells ZBIGNIEW KOCZOROWSKI Warsaw, Poland
I.
Department of Chemistry, University of Warsaw,
INTRODUCTION
Liquid surfaces and liquid–liquid interfaces are very common and have tremendous significance in the real world. Especially important are the interfaces between two immiscible liquid electrolyte solutions (acronym ITIES), which occur in tissues and cells of all living organisms. The usual presence of aqueous electrolyte solution as one phase of ITIES is the main reason for the electrochemical nature of such interfaces. Every liquid interface is usually electrified by ion separation, dipole orientation, or both (Section II). It is convenient to distinguish two groups of immiscible liquid– liquid interfaces: water–polar solvent, such as nitrobenzene and 1,2-dichloroethane, and water–nonpolar solvent, e.g., octane or decane interfaces. For the second group it is impossible to investigate the interphase electrochemical equilibria and the Galvani potentials, whereas it is normal practice for the first group (Section III). On the other hand, these systems are very important as parts of the voltaic cells. They make it possible to measure the surface potential differences and the adsorption potentials (Section IV). Electrochemical studies of liquid–liquid interfaces brought very significant advances during the last quarter of the 20th century. Traditional electrochemical experiments and theoretical approaches of interfacial chemistry have contributed much to our present understanding of the phenomena occurring at the ITIES. The fast development of this discipline has been documented in many review articles. Among them should be mentioned some reviews published during the last several years [1–16]. The brief history of achievements, and references to them, can be found in a number of papers [1,3,4,8,11,17,18]. Liquid–liquid interfaces occur as macro- and also as micro- and nanoheterogenous systems (termed small systems), described in colloidal chemistry as, e.g., miscelles, vesicles, and microemulsions [14,19] (see also Section V). Up to now, fast progress concerns mainly the macrosystems (> 100 m), including all types of natural and artificial membranes.
1
2
II.
Koczorowski
ELECTRIFIED LIQUID–LIQUID INTERFACES AND THEIR ELECTRICAL POTENTIALS
At a phase boundary (or interface) the molecular species experience anisotropic forces, which vary with the distance from the interface. This causes a net orientation of solvent and other molecular dipoles and a net excess of ions near the phase boundary, on both sides of the solution. The term ‘‘electrified’’ interface means that there occur differences in potential, charge densities, dipole moments, and electric currents. The system and terminology of the thermodynamic and electrical interfacial potentials, recommended for description of all electrified phases and interfaces [18,20,21], is also very useful for the liquid–liquid boundaries [3,8,14,15–17,22–35], e.g., at the interfaces of two immiscible electrolyte solutions: water (w), and an organic solvent (s). The presence of an electrical potential drop, i.e., interfacial potential, across the boundary between two dissimilar phases, as well as at their surfaces exposed to a neutral gas phase, is the most characteristic feature of every interface and surface electrified due to the ion separation and dipole orientation. This charge separation is usually described as the formation of the ionic and dipolar double layers. The main interfacial potential is the Galvani potential (termed also by Trasatti the operative potential), ws ’, which is the difference of inner potentials ’2 and ’s of both phases. It is a function only of the chemical nature of the contacting phases in the equilibrium, but it is not a measurable quantity. In the equilibrium state, the electrochemical potentials of each i ion, present simultaneously in both phases are identical: wi ¼ si
ð1Þ
Using the definition of the electrochemical potential this can be rewritten in the following forms: ws ’ ¼ ’w ’s ¼ ð1=zi FÞws i
ð2Þ
s s 0;w þ RT ln awi þ zi F’w ¼ 0;s i i þ RT ln ai þ zi F’
ð3Þ
w s where i0;w , 0;s i stand for standard chemical potentials of ions, ai and ai represent their activities in both phases, and R, F, and T have their usual meanings, namely the gas constant, Faraday constant, and temperature (K). From Eq. (3) one can derive the dependence of the Nernst dependence of the Galvani potential at the single interface.
ws ’ ¼ ’w ’s ¼ ws ’0i þ
RT asi ln zi F awi
ð4Þ
It follows from Eq. (4) that the Galvani potential can be calculated from the values of the standard potential and the activity of any ion participating in the equilibrium distribution. The standard Galvani potential is defined as follows: ws ’0i ¼ sw G0i =zi F
ð5Þ
This dependence is fundamental for electrochemistry, but its key role for liquid–liquid interfaces was first recognized by Koryta [1–5,35]. The standard transfer energy of an ion 0;ws , denoted in abbreviated form from the aqueous phase to the nonaqueous phase, Gtr;i w 0 by the symbol s Gi is the difference of standard chemical potential of standard chemical potentials of the ions, i.e., of the standard Gibbs energies of solvation in both phases,
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
ws G0i ¼ 0;w i0;s i
3
ð6Þ
Equation (4) can be rewritten in the form: ws ’ ¼ ws ’0i þ
RT is csi ln zi F iw cwi
ð7Þ
where sw and iw represent the activity coefficients. Besides the Galvani potential, another important interfacial potential is the Volta potential, ws , sometimes called the contact potential. ws is the difference of the outer potentials of the phases, which are in electrochemical equilibrium with regard to the charged species, i.e., ions or electrons. As for any two-phase electrochemical system, including the w/s system, it may be characterized by the commonly known relation: ws ¼ zi Fðwi wi Þ
ð8Þ
s where M i and i are the real potentials of the charged species i, defined as the sum of its chemical potential and the electrical term containing the surface potential of the phase, e.g., for the solution:
si ¼ si þ zi Fs
ð9Þ
The electrical potentials assumed to exist at liquid–liquid interfaces, including inert gas or liquid dielectric environments are presented in Fig. 1. Equations (1) and (2) together with ws ¼ 2s ’ 2s
ð10Þ
make it possible to find some important electrochemical information. The Volta potential, in contradiction to the Galvani potential, has the advantage of being measurable but also the disadvantage that it is not determined only by the chemical nature of the phases which create the interface, but also by the state at their surfaces, represented by the surface potentials, Eqs. (8) and (9). In principle, the distribution of ions and dipoles at the w/s interface is different from that at the free w and s surfaces. Therefore, the Galvani potential may be also written, in the absence of specific adsorption, as the sum of the charge and dipole components [15,20– 22]: ws ’ ¼ gws ðionÞ þ gws ðdipÞ
FIG. 1 The electric potentials assumed to exist at liquid–liquid interfaces.
ð11Þ
4
Koczorowski
Usually gws ðionÞ 6¼ 2s and gws ðdipÞ 6¼ ws . This is caused by mutual influence of the contacting phases on the orientation of dipolar molecules in the interfacial zone. The situation that no charge transfer across the interface occurs is named the ideal polarized or blocked interface. Such interfaces do not permit, due to thermodynamic or kinetic reasons, either electron or ion transfer. They possess Galvani potentials fixed by the electrolyte and charge. Of course, the ideal polarizable interface is practically a limiting case of the interfaces with charge transfer, because any interface is always permeable to ions to some extent. Therefore, only an approximation of the ideal polarizable interface can be realized experimentally (Section III.D). If the interface is in the zero charge state, named also the point of zero charge (pzc), the Galvani potential should be equal to the dipolar term [19–21]: ws ’ðpzcÞ ¼ ws gðdipÞ
ð12Þ
The specific adsorption, which in the case of ITIES is usually the adsorption of ionic pairs [8], contributes to the Galvani potential, as well as changes the zero charge of this interface. The surface potential of a liquid solvent s, s , is defined as the difference of electrical potentials across the interface between this solvent and the gas phase, with the assumption that the outer potential of the solvent is zero [21,22]. The potential s of pure molecular liquid arises from a preferred orientation of the solvent dipoles in the free surface zone. At the surface of solution the electric field responsible for the surface potential may arise from a preferred orientation of the solvent and solute dipoles, and from the ionic double layer (Section IV). The potential s , as the difference of electrical potential across the interface between the phase and gas, is not measurable. But its relative changes caused by the change of solution composition can be determined using the proper voltaic cells (see Section IV). The name ‘‘surface potential’’ is unfortunately also often used for the description the ionic double layer potential (i.e., the ionic part of the Galvani potential) at the interfaces of membranes, microemulsion droplets and micelles, measured usually by the acid–base indicator technique (Section V).
III.
LIQUID GALVANIC CELLS AND THE GALVANI POTENTIALS
The interface separating two immiscible electrolyte solutions, e.g., one aqueous and the other based on a polar organic solvent, may be reversible with respect to one or many ions simultaneously, and also to electrons. Works by Nernst constitute a fundamental contribution to the electrochemical analysis of the phase equilibrium between two immiscible electrolyte solutions [1–3]. According to these works, in the above system electrical potentials originate from the difference of distribution coefficients of ions of the electrolyte present in the both phases. Nernst’s approach was supported by Verwey and Niessen’s interpretation [23], and by the experiments of Randles and Karpfen [24], and others, cited in Ref. 3. These authors, and in particular Davies and Rideal [17] consolidated the description of Galvani potential in the case of the 1 : 1 electrolyte distribution. As mentioned in the Introduction, in the discussion of liquid electrochemical cells it is necessary to distinguish two groups of immiscible liquid–liquid interfaces: water–polar organic solvent, e.g., nitrobenzene, and water–nonpolar organic solvent (water–oil or water–hydrocarbon), e.g., octane type systems. It is schematically presented as
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
5
j j
polar solvent (s) þ ions
water (w) þ ions
ws ’ SCHEME 1 and j j
nonpolar solvent (ns) + ions
water (w) + ions
w=ns SCHEME 2 The main difference is the presence of a dissociated electrolyte in the organic phase of the first group in contradiction to the second. As clearly shown by Davies and Rideal [17], this decides about the character of the interfacial potential to be measured. If the organic phase constitutes the solution of the dissociated electrolyte, the ionic double layer is created there, and the Galvani potential changes may be measured. In the opposite case, the voltaic cell allows one to measure the surface potential changes (see Section IV). Of course, in liquid galvanic cells only the water–polar solvent interfaces can be investigated. A.
Galvani Potential and Ionic Distribution Equilibria
Le Hung presented a general theoretical approach for calculating the Galvani potential ws ’ at the interface of two immiscible electrolyte solutions, e.g., aqueous (w) and organic solvent (s) [25]. Le Hung’s approach allows the calculation of ws ’ when the initial concentration (ci ), activity coefficients (i ) and standard energies of transfer of ions (ws G0i ) are known in both solutions. According to Le Hung, one deals, in general, with a system composed of two liquid immiscible phases containing Iizi ions; this can be described as follows: w
j
s
Iizi
j
Iizi
Vw
$ SCHEME 3
Vs
where zi represents the charge of the Iizi ion, and Vw and Vs are the volumes of phases w and s, respectively. In the equilibrium state the electrochemical potentials of each ion are the same in both phases, and the equations (1) to (7) are fulfilled. It is apparent from the mass conservation law that: Vw cwi þ Vs csi ¼ mi
ð13Þ
where mi represents the number of moles of condition of electroneutrality is still valid: j X 1
zi cwi ¼ 0
j X 1
zi csi ¼ 0
j X
Iizi
ions in both phases. For these phases the
zi mi ¼ 0
ð14Þ
1
Using Eqs. (7), (13), and (14), Le Hung derived the general dependence describing the difference of Galvani potentials between the phases w and s:
6
Koczorowski j X 1
iw zi F w w 0 ’ s ’i Vw þ Vs s exp ¼0 zm m i RT s i
ð15Þ
or in the form: h X
zi ci0;w
i
V w zF 1 þ s is exp i ws ’ ws ’0i þ RT V w i þ
j X
zi ci0;s
h
Vw iw zi F w w 0 ’ s ’i 1þ ¼0 exp RT s Vs is
ð16Þ
Ions having initial concentrations, i.e., not equilibrium conditions, c0;w and ci0;s , marked i with indices from 1 to h and from h to j, occur in the phases w and s, respectively. When 0;s w 0 w the values of zi , Vw , Vs , iw , is , c0;w i , ci , s ’i , and T are known, one can find s ’. The convenient form of Hung’s equation is the dependence [14] h X i¼1
h X zi ciw;0 rzi cis;0 ¼0 w s þ 1 þ rði =i Þ i¼1 1 þ rðiw =is Þei
ð17Þ
where r ¼ V s =V w
ð18Þ
ei ¼ exp ðzi F=RTÞðws ’eq ws ’0i Þ
ð19Þ
and
The above equation allows the calculation of Galvani potentials at the interfaces of immiscible electrolyte solutions in the presence of any number of ions with any valence, also including the cases of association or complexing in one of the phases. Makrlik [26] described the cases of association and formation of complexes with participation of one of the ions but in both phases. In a later work [27] Le Hung extended his approach and also considered any mutual interaction of ions and molecules present in both phases. Buck and Vanysek performed the detailed analysis of various practical cases, including membrane equilibria, of multi-ion distribution potential equations [28,29]. The few cases of Le Hung’s equation, for practically important and simple systems, are discussed below.
B.
Distribution Potentials for Binary Electrolytes
In the case of an electrolyte of the type Mm Xx , in the state distribution equilibrium, i.e., for the system: w
j
s
Mm Xx Vw
$ j
Mm X x Vs
SCHEME 4 Eq. (16) can be written as follows:
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
w M zM þ F w þ w 0 s ’ s ’ðM þ Þ Vw þ Vs s exp Zm ; mM þ RT M þ Xw ZX F w w 0 s ’ s ’ðX Þ Vw þ Vs s exp ¼0 þ ZX mX RT X
7
ð20Þ
From Eqs. (14) and (20) one can obtain: ws ’0 ¼
zM þ ws ’0M þ zX ws ’0X RT s þ Xw ln M þ w s ðzX þ zM þ ÞF M zX þ zM þ þ X
ð21Þ
When the distribution equilibrium refers to the 1 : 1 valent electrolyte, e.g., MX, where zX ¼ 1, i.e., for the system j $
w MþX
s MþX
SCHEME 5 Vw ¼ Vs Eq. (21) appears in the form: ws ’ðMXÞ ¼
s w ws ’0ðM þ Þ þ ws ’0ðX Þ RT M þ ln w Xs þ 2F M þ X 2
ð22Þ
The above dependence, which has been known for a long time, can be directly derived from Eq. (3) and the electroneutrality conditions of Eq. (14) which for that case are in the form: RT s ln aM þ =awM þ F RT lnðasX =awX Þ ws ’ ¼ ws ’0 ðX Þ F ws ’ ¼ ws ’0 ðM þ Þ þ
ð23Þ ð24Þ
and csM þ cwX ¼1 cwM þ csX
ð25Þ
The formal Galvani potential, described by Eq. (22), practically does not depend on the concentration of ions of the electrolyte MX. Since the term containing the activity coefficients of ions in both solutions is, as experimentally shown, equal to zero it may be neglected. This results predominantly from the cross-symmetry of this term and is even more evident when the ion activity coefficients are replaced by their mean values. A decrease of the difference in the activity coefficients in both phase is, in addition, favored by partial hydration of the ions in the organic phase [31–33]. Thus, a liquid interface is practically characterized by the standard Galvani potential, usually known as the distribution potential. For symmetrical electrolytes, of, e.g., type 1 : 1, such a liquid–liquid interface, in equilibrium, is described by the standard Galvani potential, usually called the distribution potential. This very important quantity can be expressed in the three equivalent forms, i.e., using the ionic standard potentials, or standard Gibbs energies of transfer, and employing the limiting ionic partition coefficients [3]:
8
Koczorowski
ws ’ðMXÞ ¼ 12 ws ’0 M þ þ ws ’0 ðX Þ
ð26Þ
ws ’0 ðMXÞ ¼
1 w 0 G þ ws G0X 2F s M
ð27Þ
ws ’0 ðMXÞ ¼
RT Bws;0 ðM þ Þ ln s;0 2F Bw ðX Þ
ð28Þ
It is obvious from Eq. (21) that Eqs. (22), (26), (27), and (28) apply to all symmetrical electrolytes, i.e., to electrolytes dissociating into the same number of cations and anions. According to Eq. (26), which directly ensues from Eq. (22), the distribution potential is the arithmetic mean of the Galvani potentials of cations and anions. These potentials are the ionic constituents of the distribution potential, and in fact, according to Eq. (5) they can be considered as electrical representations of the ionic transfer energies Gi , or limiting distribution coefficients of the ions, Bi [3]. Here, the reader is referred to the following equations: þ Fws ’0 ðM þ Þ ¼ ws G0M þ ¼ RT ln Bs;0 w ðM Þ
ð29Þ
Fws ’0 ðX Þ ¼ ws G0X ¼ RT ln Bws;0 ðX Þ
ð30Þ
It is noteworthy [3,31] that for the case where þ w;0 1 Bw;0 M ¼ Bs ðX Þ s
ð31Þ
it appears that ws ’0 ðMXÞ ¼ ws ’0 ðM þ Þ ¼ ws ’0 ðX Þ
ð32Þ
Equation (31) is true only when standard chemical potentials, i.e., chemical solvation energies, of cations and anions are identical in both phases. Indeed, this occurs when two solutions in the same solvent are separated by a membrane. Hence, the Donnan equilibrium expressed in the form of Eq. (32) can be considered as a particular case of the Nernst distribution equilibrium. The distribution coefficients or distribution constants of the ions, Bws;0 ðM þ Þ and Bws;0 ðX Þ, are related to the extraction constant KMX and to the distribution coefficient of the B0MX electrolyte in the manner described below [24]. The standard distribution constant describing the equilibrium in the system M þ ðwÞ þ X ðwÞ
$ SCHEME 6
M þ ðsÞ þ X ðsÞ
can be expressed, in the equilibrium state, as follows: as þ asX 0 ¼ exp G0MX =RT ¼ M KMX awM þ awX
ð33Þ
Expressing the distribution constant in terms of the mean electrolyte activities one obtains: s a KMX ¼ ð34Þ aw From the above dependence, and from the definition of the limiting or activity distribution coefficient of electrolyte, i.e., from the equation: Bs;0 wðMXÞ ¼
as aw
ð35Þ
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
9
a relationship between the above-mentioned functions is as follows: h i1=2 1=2 s;0 s;0 Bs;0 wðMXÞ ¼ KMX ¼ BwðM þ Þ BwðX Þ
ð36Þ
The transfer energies and distribution coefficients refer to two mutually saturated, i.e., in a sense, mixed solvents. It should be noted that this is a case where, under conditions of distribution equilibrium, the quantities in question can be experimentally measured; this would not be possible with mutually miscible solvents [34]. C.
Interfaces Reversible with Respect to Single Ions
The interface between w and s containing electrolytes of the MX1 and MX2 type, respectively, and represented in the form: w
j
s
M þ X1
j
M þ X2
SCHEME 7 constitutes an interface reversible with regard to the common cation M þ under the following conditions [1–3]: sw G0X1 0 sw G0X2 0
ð37Þ
sw G0X2 < sw G0M þ < sw G0X1 It is obvious from the above conditions that the transfer of strongly hydrophylic X1 anions from phase w to s and of strongly hydrophobic X2 anions from phase s to w is much more difficult compared to the transfer of the common hydrophylic–hydrophobic M þ cations. In the equilibrium state, the Galvani potential is defined in terms of the Nernst equation (4): ws ’ ¼ ws ’ðM þ Þ ¼ ws ’0ðM þ Þ þ
RT awM þ ln s F aM þ
ð38Þ
When the concentration of M þ ions is the same in both phases of the system of Scheme 7, the interface is characterized by the formal Galvani potential of the M þ ions, i.e. by the equation: ws ’fðM þ Þ ¼ ws ’0ðM þ Þ þ
w RT M þ ln s F M þ
ð39Þ
Equations (38) and (39) have been known and used for a long time as special relations describing Haber’s ion-selective systems. D.
Liquid Galvanic Cells
Measurement of electrical potential differences requires a complete electrical circuit, i.e., the electrochemical cell. An electrochemical galvanic cell consisting of all conducting phases, and among them at least one interface separating two immiscible electrolyte solutions is called for short a liquid galvanic cell. In contrast, the system composed of con-
10
Koczorowski
ducting, condensed phases in series, with a gas gap or dielectric liquid phase is called a liquid voltaic cell (see Section IV). It is known [3] that galvanic liquid cells, being in the state of complete equilibrium, i.e. containing reversible electrodes in both phases, cannot constitute any subject of research interest, because according to the second law of thermodynamics such systems would have a zero or constant value of EMF. Therefore, the application of salt bridges, providing practically constant or negligible diffusion potentials, constitutes a nonthermodynamic procedure usually necessary in many electrochemical experiments. Also in the case of investigation of interfaces between immiscible electrolyte solutions only a liquid galvanic cell with transport allows the characterization of the interface. Practically all liquid cells with reversible interfacial equilibria examined can be considered as liquid galvanic cells of the Nernst, Haber, or intermediate type [3]. Usually, a dashed vertical bar (j) is used to represent the junction between liquids. A double dashed vertical bar (k) represents a liquid junction in which the diffusion potential has been assumed to be eliminated. Galvanic cells of the Nerst type are also termed cells with ‘‘dissolution membranes’’ or ‘‘solvent type membranes’’ [3]. Such systems are defined by the distribution equilibria in which all ions, present in aqueous and in organic solvents, participate (Section III.A). The general examples of the liquid concentration and chemical galvanic cells of this type are presented in the form of Schemes 8 and 9. The concentration cells of the Nernst type can be represented in the form of the scheme
SCE
k
aqueous
j organic
j aqueous
k
k k
solution M þ A ; c1
j solution j M þ A
j solution j M þ A ; c2
k k
j j
j j
k k
k k
Bc1 Bc2 ðc1 6¼ c2 Þ
SCE
SCHEME 8 where the completely dissociated MA electrolyte, with the distribution coefficient B (concentrations c1 6¼ c2 ), generates an EMF practically equal to the diffusion potential in the organic phase. As predicted by Nernst, independently of concentration, the distribution potentials of both liquid interfaces should be identical (Section III.B). In the above scheme SCE represents a saturated calomel electrode. Chemical cells of the Nernst type can be represented by the following scheme:
SCE
k
aqueous
j organic
j aqueous
k
k k
solution M þ A ; c1
j solution j M þ A M þ L
j solution j M þ L ; c2
k k
j
j
k
k
Bc1 Bc2
SCE
SCHEME 9 In such cells, aqueous solutions contain electrolytes with a common cation M þ . The EMF of this cell is equal to the difference of distribution potentials of both electrolytes and to the diffusion potential in the organic phase. Under appropriate conditions the EMF depends only on the difference of distribution potentials. It should be noted that cells of this type can also contain many and various ions in both phases.
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
11
Liquid cells containing an ion exchanger in the organic phase, e.g., a salt with a highly hydrophobic anion or cation Rþ , could be considered [3] as concentration cells:
SCE
k k
aqueous solution
j organic j solution
k k
MþX ; c1
j j
j aqueous k j solution k
Rþ X c1 c2
j j
MþX ; c2
k k
SCE
SCHEME 10 or as chemical cells:
SCE
k
aqueous
j organic
j aqueous k
k k
solution MþX ;
j solution j Rþ X
j solution j M þ L
k k
k
c1
j
j
k
c2
SCE
SCHEME 11 There are large cations in these cells, e.g., tetra-alkylammonium cations in the organic phase; and the interfacial ion exchange involves only so-called critical ions, here X and L . M þ ions are practically not transferred through the organic phase. Both liquid interfaces are reversible with respect to the appropriate anion, X or L . EMF is, in practice, also influenced by the diffusion potential in the organic phase, and in the case of cells of the type in Scheme 11 – by the difference of standard transfer energies of both ions (Section III.A) Cells of the type in Scheme 10 represent the simplest case of an ion-selective liquid cell; its EMF is often called a membrane, or monoionic, potential [3]. The first term is too narrow due to the fact that the membrane potential corresponds to the behavior of a number of cells, including those of Schemes 8 to 11, and to the cells with solid membranes and with Donnan equilibrium. Cells of the type in Scheme 11 represent the simplest case of cells with a bi-ionic potential [3]. Hence, in the case of a larger number of ions transferred through the organic phase a multi- or polyionic potential should be considered. Liquid ion-selective electrodes operate on the basis of cells of the type in Scheme 10; their selectivity can be examined with the use of Scheme 11 and polyionic cells. In modern investigations of the electrochemical properties of immiscible electrolyte solutions mixed cells are used, i.e., cells containing one interface, e.g., that under investigation – Nernstian or polarizable, and a second reference interface of the Haber types (Scheme 7 or 10). The system usually in the form shown below: w TBAþ Cl
j j
n TBA TPhB
0:01 M
j SCHEME 12
0:01 M
þ
is a typical reference interface commonly used in the above investigations. It follows from Le Hung’s analysis [25] that in the presence of tetrabutylammonium chloride in water and tetraphenylborate (TBATPhB) in nitrobenzene (or 1,2-dichloroethane), the interface appears to be reversible with respect to TBAþ ions.
12
Koczorowski
Interfaces of the type in Scheme 8 are used as liquid ion-selective electrodes. It is apparent that they constitute a special case of distribution systems reversible in regard to two or more ions. Here, Le Hung’s equation, (16) and (17), allows quantitative evaluation of the influence of the presence of other ions on the selectivity of these systems. E.
Polarizable Interfaces
The interface between an aqueous solution containing a strongly hydrophilic electrolyte, e.g., LiCl, and a nitrobenzene solution containing a strongly hydrophobic salt, e.g., tetrabutylammonium tetraphenylborate (TBATPhB), schematically shown below: j j
w LiCl
n TBATPhB
SCHEME 13 constitutes a very important system in studies of immiscible electrolyte solutions. Since the distribution coefficients of the above electrolytes can be defined by the inequalities [1,2] Bn;0 w ðLiClÞ 1
and
Bwn;0 ðTBATPhBÞ 1
ð40Þ
the interface of Scheme 13, in certain potential limits, behaves nearly as ideally polarizable (see Section II). The degree of polarizability of system can be found from the data calculated by Le Hung [25] with the use of Eqs. (16) and (17). In the equilibrium state of the interphase between the solutions of 0.05 M LiCl in water and 0.05 M TBATPhB in nitrobenzene, the concentrations of Liþ and Cl in the organic phase lower than 107 M, and the concentrations of TBAþ and TPhB in the aqueous phase are about 3 107 M each [3]. These concentrations are too low to establish permanent reversible equilibria. They are, however, significantly higher compared to those of the components present in the mercury–aqueous KF solution system [20]. A detailed analysis of this behavior, as well as its analogy to the mercury–KF solution system, can be found in several papers [1–3,8,14]. The ions of both electrolytes, existing in the system of Scheme 13, are practically present only in one of the phases, respectively. This allows them to function as supporting electrolytes in both solvents. Hence, the above system is necessary to study electrical double layer structure, zero-charge potentials and the kinetics of ion and electron reactions at interface between immiscible electrolyte solutions. F. Redox Systems Heterogeneous electron reactions at liquid–liquid interfaces occur in many chemical and biological systems. The interfaces between two immiscible solutions in water–nitrobenzene and water–1,2-dichloroethane are broadly used for modeling studies of kinetics of electron transfer between redox couples present in both media. The basic scheme of such a reaction is Oxw1 þ Red2s
$ SCHEME 14
Red1w þ Oxs2
Red and Ox represent the components at the redox couples. Usually, the reactant in aqueous phase was the ½FeðCNÞ6 3=4 couple, and various couples in the organic phase
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
13
[30–35]. The Nernst equation for the electrochemical equilibrium of the type in Scheme 14 [30] is ws ¼ E2s;0 E1w;0 þ ws ’0Hþ þ ðRT=nFÞ ln
asox2 awRed1 asRed2 awox1
ð41Þ
where E1s;0 and E2w;0 are standard redox potentials of both couples related to the standard Hþ =H2 reference electrode in the respective phases, ws ’0H þ is the standard proton transfer potential, and n is the number of electrons transferred in th reaction of Scheme 14. Equation (41) is valid if none of the ionic components are transferable across the interface, and the only common charged components are electrons. However, some the redox species are necessarily charged components, and counterions of redox couples also exist in the two phases. All of these ionic components can essentially distribute over the two phases, depending on its w0 ’0i value. In this case, the equilibrium point is affected by the partition of ionic components and the value of the mixed Galvani potential occurs (see Section III.G). It is determined by two physically different system properties. The presence of supporting electrolytes also influences the point of equilibrium through the redistribution of constituent ions. This special type of mixed potential is important not only for defining the initial state of the electrochemical studies of electron transfer reactions but also for understanding other phenomena which involve free-energy coupling of electron and ion transfer reactions, e.g., energy transfer in biological systems and redox-reaction-driven uphill transport of ions across a liquid membrane [14,33,36,37]. A method of calculating equilibrium conditions for electron and ion transfer coupling has been proposed [14,31].
G.
Common Properties of ITIES
The investigations of interfacial phenomena of immiscible electrolyte solutions are very important from the theoretical point of view. They provide convenient approaches to the determination of various physciochemical parameters, such as transfer and solvation energy of ions, partition and diffusion coefficients, as well as interfacial potentials [1– 7,12–17]. Of course, it should be remembered that at equilibrium, either in the presence or absence of an electrolyte, the solvents forming the discussed system are saturated in each other. Therefore, these two phases, in a sense, constitute two mixed solvents. The electrochemisty of ITIES is developing mainly on the basis of the studies of the water–nitrobenzene and water-1,2-dichloroethane interfaces. The polarizability ranges of these interfaces in the presence of typical electrolytes (Scheme 13) are about 0.30 V. Extension of these ranges has been achieved using other organic ions or/and solvents [2,8]. For example, TBAþ ions may be substituted by tetraphenylarsonium crystal violet cations and TPhB ions by dicarbollyl cobaltate (III) anions [1,2]. Standard ionic potentials ws ’0 can be calculated from the ionic distribution coefficients or transfer energies; see Eq. (30). In order to perform such calculations, an appropriate nonthermodynamic assumption that allows division of the B0ðMXÞ or G electrolyte function into ionic constituents has to be made. At the present time, the assumption about the equality of the transfer energies of tetraphenylarsonium cations (TPhAsþ ) and tetraphenylborate anions (TPhB ) is considered as most appropriate [2,36]. It can be presented in the following form: 0 1 2 G ðTphAsTPhBÞ
¼ G0 ðTPhAsþ Þ ¼ G0 ðTPhB Þ
ð42Þ
14
Koczorowski
Another proposed procedure of finding the ionic data is the application of a special salt bridge, which provides practically constant or negligible liquid junction potentials. The water–nitrobenzene system, containing tetraethylammonium picrate (TEAPi) in the partition equilibrium state, has been proposed as a convenient liquid junction bridge for the liquid voltaic and galvanic cells. The distribution potential of this system, and the diffusion potential at the contact of nitrobenezene with many organic solvents, are close to zero [3,38–40]. The cell containing TEAPi–bridge can be represented by the following scheme: k SCE
w
k k
j
k
s
j MX
j
n
k MX
j
w
j
k SCHEME 15
TEAPi j
k k
TEAPi
SCE
k
Alternatively, it has been found that the Galvani potential of zero charge, in the absence of specific adsorption, equals zero. This means that there is no specific orientation of the molecules of both solvents, and the dipolar part of the Galvani potential, Eq. (12), is zero [8,22,41]. The observed discrepancies between the results of various measurements in different ITIES systems have been mainly caused by the specific adsorption [8]. Recently, the analysis of thermodynamic and free charge potentials at ITIES was performed by Volkov [42]. The ionic potentials ws ’0i can be experimentally determined either with the use of galvanic cells containing interfaces of the type in Scheme 7 or electroanalytically, using for instance, polarography, voltammetry, or chronopotentiometry. The values of ws G0i and ws ’0i , obtained with the use of electrochemical methods for the water–1,2-dichloroethane, water–dichloromethane, water–acetophenone, water–methyl-isobutyl ketone, o-nitrotoluene, and chloroform systems, and recently for 2-heptanone and 2-octanone [43] systems, have been published. These data are listed in many papers [1–10,14,37]. The most probable values for a few ions in water–nitrobenzene and water–1,2-dichloroethane systems are presented in Table 1. It is worthwhile mentioning that the interfacial potential created at the liquid–liquid interface is governed by single ionic or redox equilibrium only in the simple cases. The presence of various, often two, interfacial processes is a source of the steady-state potential, named also the mixed or the rest potential. Its value is situated between the two equilibrium potentials, near that one which corresponds to the higher exchange current
TABLE 1 The Recommended Standard Potentials of Ions in Water– Nitrobenzene (w/n) and Water–1,2-Dichloroethane (w/d) Systems [44] ws ’0 (mV) Ion Pi ClO 4 Me4 Nþ Et4 Nþ Bu4 Nþ Ph4 Asþ
w/n
w/d
38 95 30 66 275 375
57 170 160 19 225 365
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
15
density. The modern theory of liquid membrane ion-selective electrodes and their selectivity coefficients has been developed on the basis of the concept of mixed potentials [45–47]. The closeness of the values of the equilibrium and mixed state potentials, as well as the shape of the time-dependence of interfacial potential [48] during the ion partition process, are the reasons that sometimes it is difficult to find whether the examined system is in equilibrium or in the stationary state. As was observed and described by the theoretical model, after the fist several seconds, changes of potential occurring during the ion partition process become very slow [48]. It was shown that during the process, the ion first is transferred by a very fast interfacial step (the time of the ‘‘local interfacial equilibrium’’ formation [29]), followed by a mixed transfer–diffusion stage, and finally moved by slow diffusion.
IV.
LIQUID VOLTAIC CELLS
Liquid voltaic cells are systems composed of conducting, condensed phases in series, with a thin gap containing gas or liquid dielectric (e.g., decane) situated between two condensed phases. The liquid voltaic cells contain at least one liquid surface [2,15]. Due to the presence of a dielectric, special techniques for the investigation of voltaic cells are necessary. Usually, it is the dynamic condenser method, named also the vibrating plate method, the vibrating condenser method, or Kelvin–Zisman probe. In this method, the capacity of the condenser created by the investigated surface and the plate (vibrating plate), is continuously modulated by periodical vibration of the plate. The a.c. output is then amplified, and fed back to the condenser to obtain null-balance operation [49,50]. Recently, scanning Kelvin probes and microprobes, as high-resolution surface analysis devices, have been developed. They allow one to investigate the lateral distribution of the work functions of the surfaces of various phases, including the determination of the potential profiles of metals and semiconductors under very thin films of electrolytic solution, and also of the surface potential map of various polymer- and biomembranes [50–56]. The lateral resolution and the sensitivity are in the 100 nm and 1 mV ranges, respectively [54]. A.
Volta Potentials of ITIES
The liquid voltaic cell type ref
k k
w
el:
k
MþX
j j j gas j j
j
s MþX
j j
w
j MþX
k ref: j k j Ek ¼ ws k el:
j
SCHEME 16 contains the interface created at the contact of an aqueous and organic solutions of electrolyte MX being in the partition equilibrium. The compensating voltage, Ek , from a potentiometer is adjusted until the electric field strength in the gas space between the two condensed phases is zero. This state means that the Volta potential is zero, and simultaneously that the compensating voltage equals the sum of all Galvani potentials existing in the system plus the difference of surface potentials (instead of Galvani potential) between the liquid phases, which contact the gas space. The application of two identical reference electrodes and the elimination of the liquid junction potentials by proper salt bridges (k),
16
Koczorowski
removes their contributions to the compensation potential. Using Eq. (3), after simple rearrangement we have [15]: E ¼ sw ðMXÞ
ð43Þ
Thus, the Volta potential may be operationally defined as the compensating voltage of the cell of Scheme 16. However, it should be stressed that the compensating voltage of a voltaic cell is not always the direct measure of the Volta potential. The appropriate mutual arrangement of phases, as well as application of reversible electrodes or salt bridges in the systems, allows measurement of not only the Volta potential but also the surface and the Galvani potentials. These possibilities are schematically illustrated by [15] k
w
j gas
j
s
j
w
k
Ek ¼ ws
j
s
k
Ek ¼ ws
k
Ek ¼ ws ’
SCHEME 17 k
w
j gas
j
s SCHEME 18
k
w
j gas
j
w SCHEME 19
Practically, the Volta potential at the water–nonaqueous solvent interface, sw , is measured as the difference in the compensating voltages of the cells of Schemes 20 and 21 [57–59]. The vibrating plate is the mediatory electrode for both cells: s M
Vib:pl
gas Mþ þ X
j
w
j j Mþ þ X
SCE M; E20
SCHEME 20 M
Vib:pl
w
j j
Mþ þ X SCHEME 21
j
gas
2w ðMXÞ ¼ E20 E21
SCE
M; E21
ð44Þ
The reliability of the experimental ws ðMXÞ values was checked for systems containing nitrobenzene [57,58], nitromethane and 1,2-dichloroethane [59] as organic solvent, by comparing the differences in these values for various pairs of salts with the differences in the Galvani potentials, ws ’ðMXÞ for the same pairs [3]. The differences should be the same. The ws ’ or ws data can be used for the estimation of ion solvation energies in the water saturated solvent. The results are reliable if the influence of the electrolyte MX on the surface potential of solvent in the investigated concentration range, is negligibly small. The liquid–liquid partition systems discussed above are in fact very similar to various membrane-type interfaces and may serve as a model for them. A good example is, for instance, the distribution of a dissociated salt between aqueous solution and a permeable organic polymer [60].
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
B.
17
Adsorption Potentials of Dipolar Compounds
The adsorption of the dipolar organic compound B on the water surface can take place as the result of either spreading B from the appropriate solution over water, i.e. formation of a Langmuir monolayer, or expelling the molecules of the considered compound from the bulk aqueous solution, i.e. formation a Gibbs layer or monolayer [6,11,15,17,18]. The first way is used for relatively large, amphipathic molecules, i.e., molecules composed of hydrophobic parts, most commonly a flexible hydrocarbon chain, with the number of carbon atoms in the chain greater than ten. There is also a large number of such compounds, including molecules of biological interest, with aromatic hydrophobic groups. The total number of the adsorbed B molecules per, e.g., 1 m2 of the surface, NB , may be easily evaluated from the amount of the spread compound B. The second way is common for molecules easily soluble in water, and is called the adsorption from solution. Surface tension measurements make it possible to calculate, from the Gibbs isotherm, the surface excess of substance B, which is a relative quantity. Replacement of gas by the nonpolar, e.g., hydrocarbon phase (or oil phase) is used to modify the interactions between molecules in a spread film of investigated longchain substances [6,15,17,18]. The nonpolar solvent–water interface possesses the advantage over that between gas and water, that the cohesion (i.e., interactions between adsorbed molecules due to dipole and van der Waals forces) is negligible. Thus, at the oil–water interfaces behavior of adsorbates is much closer to ideal, but quantitative interpretation may be uncertain, in particular for the higher chains which are predominantly dissolved in the oil phase to an unknown activity. Adsorption of dipolar substances at the w/a and w/o interfaces changes surface tension and modifies the surface potential of water [15]: ref: k el:
k k
w
w
k
MX þ B
k k
gas MþX
ref: Ek ¼ w el:
SCHEME 22 As seen in this sketch, the change of compensation voltage E, due to adsorption is the surface potential difference, usually called shortly surface potential, or better the adsorption potential E ¼ w ¼ w W þB
ð45Þ
The experimental investigation of w may be performed directly as presented in the cell of Scheme 22, or by using two measuring cells (Schemes 23 and 24). In the first case, the voltaic cell with differential ionizing probe or jet method can be used. In the second case, the ionizing probe or vibrating plate method are applied (see Section IV). These probes are two versions of so-called air electrodes, which mediate in the measurement of voltaic cells. The air electrode, e.g., vibrating plate, creates in fact the two following cells:
18
Koczorowski
w M
Vib:pl
gas
Ref:el
M; E23
Ref:el
M; E24
MX SCHEME 23 w M
Vib:pl
gas MX þ B SCHEME 24
and E ¼ E23 E24 ¼ w
ð46Þ
The presence of supporting electrolyte MX in the aqueous phases secures the stability of the measurements. However, MX must not adsorb at the surface to avoid an influence on w potential. It is common in the literature to link w with the properties of the neutral adsorbate by means of the Helmholtz equation [6,11,15,17,18] w ¼ NB P? B =0
ð47Þ
where 0 and are the electrical permittivity of vacuum, and the relative permittivity of the interfacial region, respectively, and p? B is the normal component of the molecular dipole moment of the substance B. Either from the known value NB , or from the slope of the experimental relationship of w vs. NB , the quantity p ¼ p? B =0
ð48Þ
can be derived. It may be treated as the apparent surface dipole moment of the adsorbate. The effect of an electric field on the surface tension and surface excess of adsorbed solutes can be calculated from the experimental data of adsorption potential, using Maxwell relations found from a thermodynamic analysis of the Volta potential [61]. It is known that the p values derived from experimental w data, e.g., for insoluble monolayers, with the assumption e ¼ 1 are substantially different from the dipole moment for the same molecule in the bulk of the solution [17]. The reasons offered to explain this difference are manifold e.g. (1) inappropriate value of e, (2) reorientation of water molecules around the adsorbate, and (3) lateral interaction between adsorbed molecules in the monolayer. The various models of p have been described in a number of papers [61–67]. The very popular applications of the adsorption potential measurements are those dealing with the surface potential changes at the water–air and water–hydrocarbon interfaces when a monolayer film is formed by an adsorbed substance. Phospholipid monolayers, for instance, formed at such interfaces have been extensively used to study the surface properties of the monolayers, which are expected to represent, to some extent, the surface properties of bilayers, and biological, as well as various artificial membranes. An interest in a number of applications of the ordered thin organic films, e.g., Langmuir– Blodgett layers, dominated the insoluble monolayer research activity during the last decade. Equations (47) and (48) concern the case of neutral adsorbates, where there is no ionic double layer to contribute to the surface potential. In the case of charged, i.e., ionic adsorbates the measured potential w consists of two terms. The first term is due to dipoles oriented at the interface, which may be described by the above formulas, and the
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
19
second term presents the potential of the ionic double layer at the interface from aqueous side w ¼ p=AB þ gw ðionÞ
ð49Þ
w
where g (ion) is the electrical potential drop between the film of adsorbed long-chain ions and the bulk of aqueous solution. AB is the reciprocal value of NB and expresses the surface area per ion. The physical meaning of the gw (ion) potential depends on the accepted model of ionic double layer. The proposed models correspond to the Gouy–Chapman diffuse layer, with or without allowance for the Stern modification and/or the penetration of small counterions above the plane of the ionic heads of the adsorbed large ions [17,18]. The presence of adsorbed Langmuir monolayers may induce very high changes of the surface potential of water. For example, w shifts attaining ca. 0:9 (hexadecylamine hydrochloride), and ca. þ1:0 V (perfluorodecanoic acid) have been observed [68]. Studies of the adsorption of surface active electrolytes at the oil–water interface provide a convenient method for testing electrical double layer theory and for determining the state of water and ions in the neighborhood of an interface. The change in the surface amount of the large ions modifies the surface charge density. For instance, the surface ionic area of 100 A2 per ion corresponds to 16 ; C=cm2 . The measurement of the concentration dependence of the changes of surface potential were also applied to find the critical concentration of formation of the micellar solution [18]. The possibility of determination of the difference of surface potentials of solvents, see Scheme 18, among others, has been used for the investigation of ws between mutually saturated water and organic solvent: namely nitrobenzene [57,58], nitroethane and 1,2-dichloroethane (DCE) [59], and isobutyl methyl ketone (IB) [69]. The results show a very strong influence of the added organic solvent on the surface potential of water, while the presence of water in the nonaqueous phase has practically no effect on its s potential. The information resulting from the surface potential measurements may also be used in the analysis of the interfacial structure of liquid–liquid interfaces and their dipole and zero-charge potentials [3,15,22].
V.
SMALL LIQUID–LIQUID INTERFACES
The microheterogenous and nanoheterogenous (mesoscopic) liquid–liquid systems may be concisely called the small systems. They comprise the micro- and nanodomains, described in colloidal chemistry as a variety of structures, e.g., micelles, rods, disks, vesicles, microemulsions, monolayers, and Langmuir–Blodgett layers [6,17–19,70]. The properties of these systems depend strongly on the interfacial potentials created at the interface. They arise from oriented molecular dipoles, from ionization of the surfactant hydrophylic groups, and from the partition and adsorption of ions presented in the environment. Unfortunately, we do not have microinterface voltmeters, and we can use only indirect methods like various chemical probes and electrokinetic methods. These methods make it possible to estimate only part of the Galvani potential, denoted here ws ’ . The common method of estimation of the interfacial potential in microheterogeneous systems is to use pH indicators adsorbed at for instance charged micelles. The ‘‘local interfacial’’ proton activity is related to the bulk activity and to an interfacial potential by Boltzmann’s law according to the equation [17,70–72]
20
Koczorowski
pHa ¼ pH0a ðws ’ F=2:3RT Þ
ð50Þ
Changes of pH are about 3 pH units to the alkaline side for adsorbed acids and to the acidic side for adsorbed amines have been reported [17]. However, the equilibrium of the indicator adsorbed at an interface may also be affected by a lower dielectric constant as compared to bulk water. Therefore, it is better to use instead pH, the ‘‘interfacial’’ and ‘‘bulk’’ pK values in Eq. (50). The concept of the use at pH indicators for the evaluation of ws ’ is also basis of other methods, like spinlabeled EPR, optical and electrochemical probes [19,70]. The results of the determination of the ws ’ by means of these methods may be loaded with an error of up to 50 mV [19]. For some the potentials determined by these methods, ws ’ values are in a good agreement with the electrokinetic (zeta) potentials found using microelectrophoresis [73]. It is proof that, for small systems, there is lack of methods for finding the complete value of ws ’. Fortunately the microinterfaces between two immiscible electrolytes seem to be a very useful experimental model of small liquid–liquid systems. The formation and investigation of the micro-ITIES is continuously perfected [74–76]. The smallest diameter so far achieved was 5 m. The main utilization of micro-ITIES is developed, in parallel with application of ultramicroelectrodes. Kakiuchi performed a very important analysis of the distribution potential in the small systems [14,31]. Using the general Le Hung approach, he discussed the behavior of ws ’eq at its extreme, when r ! 0 or 1. When all ions are initially dissolved only in the w phase, Eq. (17) takes a simple form: X
zi ciw;0
Y
1 þ rðjw =js Þej ¼ 0
ð51Þ
j6¼i
i
where j 6¼ k under the product means that the product is taken over all ionic species except i. It can be further simplified when r ! 0: X i
" zi ciw;0
X
jw =js
# ej ¼ 0
ð52Þ
j6¼i
Using the equation, very strong concentration effects in small systems have been calculated. For instance, if the macroaqueous phase contains 1 M NaCl and 1 M NaTPB, the concentration of this electrolyte in the micro-organic phase at partition equilibrium is 1390 M [14]! This approach is valid if the phases in small systems are thick enough (> 1 m), in comparison to the Debye screening length, to fulfill the electroneutrality conditions.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author is pleased to acknowledge the financial support from the Polish Committee on Scientific Research (BST-623/19/99).
Interfacial Potentials and Cells
21
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3.
4.
5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34.
P. Vanysek, Lecture Notes in Electrochemistry, vol. 39, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1985, pp. 1–106. J. Koryta. Electrochim. Acta 32:419 (1987). Z. Koczorowski, in The Interface Structure and Electrochemical Processes at the Boundary Between Two Immiscible Liquids (V. E. Kazarinov, ed.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin–Heidelberg, 1987, pp. 143–178. L. I. Boguslavsky and A. G. Volkov, in The Interface Structure and Electrochemical Processes at the Boundary Between Two Immiscible Liquids (V. E. Kazarinov, ed.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin–Heidelberg, 1987, pp. 77–106. Z. Samec. Chem Rev. 88:617 (1988) K. S. Birdi, Lipid and Biopolymer Monolayer at Liquid Interface, Plenum Press, New York– London, 1988, chaps. 4 and 5. V. S. Martin and A. Volkov. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 131:382 (1989). H. H. Girault and D. Schiffrin, in Electroanalytical Chemistry (A. J. Bard, ed.), vol. 15, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1989, pp. 1–144. V. S. Markin and A. G. Volkov. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 31:111 (1990). M. Senda, T. Kakiuchi, and T. Osakai. Electrochim. Acta 36:253 (1991). A. Ulman, An Introduction to Ultrathin Organic Films: from Langmuir–Blodgett to SelfAssembly, Academic Press, Boston, 1991. P. Vanysek, in Electrochemistry and Dispersions (R. M. Mackay and T. Texter, eds.), VCH Publishers, New York, 1992, pp. 71–84. H. H. Girault, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’M. Bockris, B. E. Conway, and R. E. White, eds.), No. 25, 1993, pp. 1–62. T. Kakiuchi, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, pp. 1–18. Z. Koczorowski, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces. Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, pp. 19–37. A. G. Volkov, D. W. Deamer, D. L. Tanelian, and V. S. Markin, Liquid Interfaces in Chemistry and Biology, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1998, pp. 130–319. T. Davies and E. K. Rideal, Interfacial Phenomena, Academic Press, New York, 1963, chaps. 2–6. J. Llopis, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’M. Bockris and B. E. Conway, eds.), No. 6, Plenum Press, New York, 1971, pp. 91–159. N. A. Kotov and M. G. Kuzmin, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces. Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, pp. 213–224. R Parsons, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’M. Bockris and B. M. Conway, eds.), Butterworths, London, 1954, vol. 1, chap. 3. S. Trasatii and R. Parson. Pure Appl. Chem. 58:1251 (1986). Z. Koczorowski. J. Electroanal. Chem. 190:257 (1985). E. J. V. Verwey and K. F. Niessen. Phil. Mag. 28:435(1939). F. M. Karpfen and J. E. B. Randles. Trans. Faraday Soc. 49:823 (1953). L. Q. Hung. J. Electroanal. Chem. 149:1 (1985). E. Makrlik. Electrochim. Acta 28:573 (1995). L. Q. Hung. J. Electroanal. Chem. 149:1 (1985). R. P. Buck and P. Vanysek. J. Electroanal. Chem. 292:73 (1990). P. Vanysek and R. P. Buck. J. Electroanal. Chem. 297:19 (1991). Z. Samec. J. Electroanal. Chem. 99:197 (1979). T. Kakiuchi. Electrochim. Acta. 40:2999 (1995). A. G. Volkov, M. I. Gugeshashvili, and A. W. Deamer. Electrochim. Acta 40:2849 (1995). V. J. Cunnane, G. Geblewicz, and D. Schiffrin. Electrochim Acta 40:3005 (1995). V. J. Cunnane and L. Murtomaki, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces. Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, pp. 401–416.
22
Koczorowski
35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73 74. 75. 76.
A. G. Volkov and A. W. Deamer. Progr. Colloid Polym. Sci. 103:21 (1997). O. Popovych and R. G. Bates. Crit. Revs. Anal. Chem. 1:73 (1970). J. Koryta, P. Vanysek, and M Brezina. J. Electroanal. Chem. 75:211 (1977). Z. Koczorowski. J. Electroanal. Chem. 127:11 (1981). Z. Koczorowski and G. Geblewicz. J. Electroanal. Chem. 152:55 (1983). G. Geblewicz and Z. Koczorowski. J. Electroanal. Chem. 158:37 (1983). H. H. Girault and D. Schiffrin. Electrochim. Acta 31:1341 (1986). A. G. Volkov. Langmuir 12:3315 (1996). Y. Cheng and D. J. Schiffrin. J. Electroanal. Chem. 429:37 (1997). T. Wandlowski, V. Marecek, and Z. Samec. Electrochim. Acta 15:1173 (1990). T. Kakiuchi and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 57:1801 (1984). S. Kihara and Z. Yoshida. Talanta 31:789 (1984). T. Kakiuchi, I. Obi, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 57:1636 (1985). C. A. Chang, E. Wang, Z. Pang. J. Electroanal. Chem. 266:143 (1989). W. A. Zisman. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 3:367 (1932). J. M. Palau and J. Bonnet. J. Phys. E: Sci. Instrum. 21:674 (1988). M. Fujihira and K. Hirosuke. Thin Solid Films 242:163 (1994). M. T. Nguyen, K. K. Kanazawa, P. Brock, and A. F. Diaz. Langmuir 10:597 (1994). I. D. Baikie, P. J. S. Smith, D. M. Portfield, and P. J. Estrup. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 70:1842 (1999). W. Nabhan, B. Equer, A. Broniatowski, and G. De Rosny. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 68:3108 (1997). E. Moons, A. Goossens, and T. Savenije. J. Phys. Chem. B 101:8492 (1997). I. Frateur, E. Bayet, M. Keddam, and B. Tribollet. Electrochem. Commun. 1:336 (1999). Z. Koczorowski and I Zago´rska. J. Electroanal. Chem. 159:183 (1983). I. Zago´rska and Z. Koczorowski. J. Electroanal. Chem. 204:273 (1986). I. Zago´rska, Z. Koczorowski, and I. Paleska. J. Electroanal. Chem. 282:51 (1990). K Doblhofer and M. Cappadonia. Colloids Surfaces 41:211 (1989). A. N. Frumkin, B. B. Damaskin, and A. A. Survila. J. Electroanal. Chem. 16:493 (1968). B. B. Damaskin, A. N. Frumkin, and A. Chizhov. J. Electroanal. Chem. 28:93 (1970). R. J. Demchak and T. Fort Jr. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 46:191 (1974). V. Vogel and D. Mo¨bius. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 126:408 (1988). O. N. Oliveira Jr, A. Riul, and L. G. F. Fereira. Thin Solid Films 242:239 (1994). Z. Koczorowski, S. Kurowski, and S. Trasatti. J. Electroanal. Chem. 329:25 (1992). P. Nikitas and A. Pappa-Louisi. J. Electroanal. Chem. 385:257 (1995). A. N. Frumkin, X. A. Jofa, and M. A. Gerovich. Zh. Fiz. Khim. 30:1456 (1956). Z. Koczorowski, I. Zago´rska, and A. Kalin´ska. Electrochim. Acta 34:1857 (1989). R. B. Gennis, Biomembranes, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1989, pp. 235–269. M. S. Fernandez and P. Fromherz. J. Chem. Phys. 81:1755 (1977). C. J. Drummond, F. Grieser, and T. W. Healy. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 92:2604 (1988). A. M. Carmona-Ribeiro and B. R. Midmore. J. Phys. Chem. 96:3542 (1992). G. Taylor and H. H. Girault. J. Electroanal. Chem. 208:179 (1986). P. Vanysek. Electrochim. Acta 40:2841 (1995). V. J. Cunnane, D. J. Schiffrin, and D. E. Williams. Electrochim. Acta 40:2943 (1995).
2 Ion Solvation and Resolvation TOSHIYUKI OSAKAI
Department of Chemistry, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan
KUNIYOSHI EBINA Division of Sciences for Natural Environment, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan
I.
INTRODUCTION
Much attention has been directed since olden times towards ion solvation, which is a key concept for understanding various chemical processes with electrolyte solutions. In 1920, a theoretical equation of ion solvation energy (G0s ) was first proposed by Born [1], who considered the ion as a hard sphere of a given radius (r) immersed in a continuous medium of constant permittivity (), and then defined G0s as the electrostatic energy for charging the ion up to ze (z, the charge number of the ion; e, the elementary charge): N z2 e2 1 1 G0s ðBornÞ ¼ A ð1Þ 80 r where NA is the Avogadro constant, and 0 the permittivity of vacuum. Since the term ‘‘1’’ in the parentheses of the RHS of Eq. (1) is 1/[the relative permittivity of vacuum (¼ 1, by definition)], G0s (Born) can also be regarded as the electrostatic energy required for the transfer of the ion from vacuum to the medium having the permittivity of . Accordingly, the Gibbs free energy of ion transfer (G0;O!W ), i.e., the resolvation energy for the tr transfer of an ion from one medium (e.g., organic solvent, O) to another (e.g., water, W) can be expressed as N A z2 e2 1 1 0;O!W ðBornÞ ¼ Gtr ð2Þ 80 r O W where O and W are the relative permittivities of O and W, respectively. The Born equation thus derived is based on very simple assumptions that the ion is a sphere and that the solvents are homogeneous dielectrics. In practice, however, ions have certain chemical characters, and solvents consist of molecules of given sizes, which show various chemical properties. In the simple Born model, such chemical properties of ions as well as solvents are not taken into account. Such defects of the simple Born model have been well known for at least 60 years and some attempts have been made to modify this model. On the other hand, there has been another approach that focuses on short-range interactions of an ion with solvent molecules. The purpose of this chapter is to discuss mainly recent development in the theory of ion solvation energy. Because we allowed much space for introducing our new, non23
24
Osakai and Ebina
Bornian theory of the Gibbs free energy of ion resolvation, a vast amount of work dealing with ion solvation and resolvation could not fully be reviewed. The reader is referred to some books [2–5] and review articles [6–10] for a general survey.
II.
MODIFICATIONS OF THE BORN MODEL
The defects of the Born equation [1] may be put into two categories; one is for large ions and the other for small ions. The defect for large ions is concerned with the fact that the Born equation does not take account of the energy of the formation of a cavity for introducing an ion into the solvent. This energy, which corresponds to the so-called ‘‘solvophobic’’ interaction, is more noticeable for large ions. Consequently, a modification has generally been made by adding a nonelectrostatic term, G0s ðneÞ, to the Born equation: G0s ¼ G0s ðelÞ þ G0s ðneÞ
ð3Þ
where G0s ðel) is the electrostatic term which is given by the Born equation (or its modifications). As described by the previous authors [9], the division shown in Eq. (3) is somewhat arbitrary, because different effects may overlap. However, such a division is useful for evaluating the individual effects in a heuristic way. The evaluation of the nonelectrostatic term is usually empirical and multifarious. Based on a skillful argument, however, Volkov and coworkers [9,11,12] proposed that the nonelectrostatic term of the ion transfer energy, G0;O!W (ne), should be expressed by a tr semiempirical equation called the Uhlig equation [13], which is given by 0;O!W Gtr ðneÞ ¼ 4NA r2 O;W
ð4Þ
when the surface tension at the boundary of organic solvent (O) with air is smaller than that of water (W) with air. In this formula, the difference in the energies for forming a surface around an ion in O and in W is to be evaluated simply by using the interfacial tension (O;W ) between the two phases. The Uhlig formula is shown to be valid for O;W > 10 mN m1 and r > 0:2 nm [9]. The other defect of the Born equation is for relatively small ions and is concerned with the change in the solvent structure around an ion when it is inserted in the solvent; this change is caused by the high electric field formed by the ion. Many attempts have been made since long ago to mitigate this defect by modifying the Born equation in various ways: (1) by correcting the ionic radii (for example, see Ref. 14), (2) by taking account of the effect of dielectric saturation (i.e., the lowering of the permittivity of solvents adjacent to an ion due to the high electric field) [9,11,12,15–17], or (3) by doing both (1) and (2) [18]. In modification (1), a constant value (r) is added to the crystal ionic radius (r), and the value of r þ r is used in place of r in Eq. (1). By using the values of r þ r (dependent on the ionic valence) determined empirically, fairly good agreement was obtained between experimental and theoretical values for the ion hydration energy. An example [14] is shown in Fig. 1. The solid lines in the figure represent the plots obtained by using the crystal ionic radii for r in the Born equation. It should be noted that the plots for the cations showed a curved line inconsistent with the Born equation [See Eq. (1) again]. However, adding a constant rð¼ 0:85 A˚) to the crystal ionic radius for all the cations could make the curved line straight, as shown by a dashed line. But, the physical meaning
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
25
FIG. 1 Modification of the Born equation by correcting ionic radii. Solid curves for crystal radii, dotted for corrected radii (for cations, r ¼ 0:85 A˚; for anions, r ¼ 0:1 A˚). (From Ref. 14. Copyright 1939 the American Institute of Physics.)
of r still remains obscure. Such a modification seems unable to come to the essential solution to this problem. The modification by method 2 is more acceptable. Although several types of modifications have been reported, Abraham and Liszi [15] proposed one of the simplest and well-known modifications. Figure 2(b) shows the proposed ‘‘one-layer’’ model. In this model, an ion of radius r and charge ze is surrounded by a local solvent layer of thickness (b r) and dielectric constant 1 , immersed in the bulk solvent of dielectric constant b . The thickness (b r) of the solvent layer is taken as the solvent radius, and its dielectric constant 1 is supposed to become considerably lower than that of the bulk solvent owing to dielectric saturation. The electrostatic term of the ion solvation energy is then given by G0s ðelÞ
N z2 e2 ¼ A 80 r
1 1 1 1 1 1 þ 1 1 r b b b
ð5Þ
On the assumption that 2 ¼ 2, the theoretical values of the ion solvation energy were shown to agree well with the experimental values for univalent cations and anions in various solvents (e.g., 1,1- and 1,2-dichloroethane, tetrahydrofuran, 1,2-dimethoxyethane, ammonia, acetone, acetonitrile, nitromethane, 1-propanol, ethanol, methanol, and water). Abraham et al. [16,17] proposed an extended model in which the local solvent layer was further divided into two layers of different dielectric constants. The nonlocal electrostatic theory [9,11,12] was also presented, in which the permittivity of a medium was assumed to change continuously with the electric field around an ion. Combined with the abovementioned Uhlig formula, it was successfully employed to elucidate the ion transfer energy at the nitrobenzene–water and 1,2-dichloroethane–water interfaces. It should be noted that in the modified Born equation of Eq. (5), the value of 1 ð¼ 2Þ is extremely small compared with that of b ð¼ 78:54 for water). In the Born equation as well as its modifications, the reciprocal of the permittivity (1=) crucially determines the magnitude of the ion solvation energy. As b > 10 (i.e., 1=b < 0:1) for most polar sol-
26
Osakai and Ebina
FIG. 2 (a) The Born model [1]. (b) The one-layer model proposed by Abraham and Liszi [15]. (From Ref. 10. Copyright the Japan Society for Analytical Chemistry.)
vents, we see how great the modification is when we set 1 ¼ 2 (i.e., 1=1 ¼ 0:5). It seems far beyond the ‘‘modification.’’ What does the assumption ‘‘1 ¼ 2’’ really mean? Since the permittivity reflects the extent of the rotational fluctuation of molecular dipoles of the solvent, the low permittivity means that the solvent molecules are strongly restricted in their movements in the vicinity of the ion which has the high electric field at the surface. This suggests that the short-range ion–solvent interactions, including such chemical interactions as hydrogen bonds, should play the most significant role in the ion solvation energy. As mentioned above, the Born equation is essentially based on the long-range ion–solvent interaction. Ironically enough, however, its modifications insist on the importance of the short-range interactions rather than the long-range ones.
III.
EMPIRICAL APPROACHES TO SHORT-RANGE INTERACTIONS
In the Born equation, the ion–solvent interaction energy is determined only by one physical parameter of the solvent, i.e., the dielectric constant. However, since actual ion– solvent interactions include ‘‘specific’’ interactions such as the charge-transfer interaction or hydrogen bonds, it is natural to think that the Born equation should be insufficient. It is well known that the difference in the behavior of an ion in different solvents is not often elucidated in terms of the dielectric constant. Since around 1950, in studies of solvent effects for organic reactions, empirical solvent parameters have been used; these parameters represent the capabilities of solvents for the solute–solvent interactions (especially Lewis acid–base interactions). Though the solute–solvent interactions should depend on the solute as well as on the solvent, the empirical solvent parameters are considered to be irrelevant to solutes; in other words, the use of only these parameters enables us to evaluate the solvation energies. Strictly
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
27
speaking, this is not correct. In practice, however, good correlations of the empirical parameters with the solvent effects have been seen in a number of systems (for reviews, see Refs. 19 and 20). The best-known solvent parameters are the donor number [21] and acceptor number [22] proposed by Gutmann and coworkers. The donor number (DN) for a donor solvent D is defined as the positive value of the enthalpy difference H (kcal mol1 ) for the reaction of D with an acceptor-halide SbCl5 (D þ SbCl5 ! D SbCl5 ) in an inert medium such as 1,2-dichloroethane. DN is a fair measure for the donor properties of a solvent. The correlations of DN with the solvation energies are known to be good particularly for solvation of cations. A typical example [19] is shown in Fig. 3. The acceptor number (AN) for a solvent A is determined by comparing the electronpair accepting ability of the solvent with that of SbCl5 , from the oxygen atom of triethylphosphine oxide Et3 PO in 1,2-dichloroethane [22]. To put it concretely, the 31 P-NMR chemical shift of Et3 PO in solvent A, ðEt3 PO AÞ, which would reflect the electron density around the 31 P nucleus, was measured, and then its relative value against the chemical shift of Et3 PO SbCl5 in 1,2-dichloroethane was defined as AN: AN ¼
ðEt3 PO AÞ 100 ðEt3 PO SbCl5 Þ
ð6Þ
AN is known to show good correlations with the solvation energies of anions. Also, AN has good correlations with other solvent parameters defined in different reaction systems, e.g., Grunwald and Winstein’s Y-value [24], Kosower’s Z-value [25], Dimroth and Reichardt’s ET -value [26,27], etc. Taft et al. [28] proposed the solvatochromic parameters, , , and , which describe three solvent’s abilities, respectively, to stabilize a charge or a dipole by virtue of its dielectric effect, to donate a proton (or accept an electron pair), and to accept a proton (or donate an electron pair). It was shown that the AN for nonprotonic solvents correlates
FIG. 3 Correlation between the Gibbs free energy of transfer of Kþ from CH3 CN to a solvent and DN. The free energies of transfer were determined by EMF measurements [23] based on the assumption of negligible liquid junction in a cell: KðHgÞj0:01 M KClO4 (solvent) k0:1 M Et4 NPic ðCH3 CNÞk0:01 M KClO4 ðCH3 CNÞjKðHgÞ. NM: nitromethane; TMS: tetramethylene sulfonate; PDC: propanediol-1,2-carbonate; DMF: dimethylformamide; NMP; N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone, DMA: dimethylacetamide; DMSO: dimethyl sulfoxide; HMPA: hexamethylphosphoramide. (From Ref. 19. Copyright 1978 Plenum Press, New York.)
28
Osakai and Ebina
well with and for protonic solvents with a linear combination of and . It was therefore concluded that AN was, in fact, a combined measure of solvent polarity/polarizability and hydrogen bond donor ability. It was also shown that DN was linear to for oxygen bases and RCN nitrogen bases, though the correlation broke down for pyridine. In Taft et al.’s studies, the macroscopically defined solvent parameters were analyzed at a molecular level; therefore their conclusions are full of interesting suggestions for the understanding of solute–solvent interactions.
IV.
A VOLTAMMETRIC STUDY WITH POLYANIONS
The above-mentioned solvent parameters are the solvent-side measures for describing the solute–solvent interactions. Accordingly, they are useful for predicting the effects observed when the solvent is changed, but inadequate when the solute is changed. On the other hand, the Born equation includes the parameters for both the solvent and solute (ion), i.e., the dielectric constant () as a solvent parameter and the ionic charge and radius (z and r) as ion parameters. This is an advantage of the Born equation and therefore the reason why the Born equation has been widely used for many years notwithstanding a lot of criticisms. However, in theoretical studies with the Born equation or its modifications, the r-dependence of the solvation energy was generally examined for the ions with the common zvalue; the dependence on the z-value has not been elucidated successfully. Previously, Osakai and coworkers [29–31] employed ion-transfer voltammetry to 0 determine the standard ion-transfer potentials (W O ) of heteropoly- and isopolyoxometalate anions (in short, polyanions) at the nitrobenzene (NB)/W and 1,2-dichloroethane 0 (1,2-DCE)/W interfaces; W O is directly related to the transfer energy by G0;O!W tr ð7Þ zF 0 0;O!W The values of W , obtained for the NB/W interface, are summarO as well as Gtr 0 ized in Table 1. As seen, the value of W O for the polyanions, so their transfer energies as well, depend only on the ionic size and charge. Thus there was no indication that the iontransfer potential (or the energy) was significantly influenced by such ‘‘specific’’ solvation as due to electron localization in a polyanion. This seems to support the hypothesis that the surface charge of such a polyanion is nonlocalized. If we assume the polyanion to be a hard sphere with a uniform surface electric field strength (E), then E is a function only of z and r: ze E¼ ð8Þ 40 r2 0 W O ¼
0 In order to clarify the role of the surface field strength, we have plotted the values of W O
against E [see Fig. 4(A) [29]]. Surprisingly, all the data lie on a straight line despite the large differences in sizes, charges, and even structures, as seen in the figure. A similar linear plot was also obtained for the polyanion transfer at the 1,2-DCE/W interface [30]. Because polyanions are generally quite large, a contribution from the solvophobic interaction (i.e., the cavity formation energy) to its solvation energy should not be 0 neglected. Accordingly, from the observed W O -values, the contribution was subtracted with the help of the Uhlig equation [Eq. (4)]. Even after this subtraction, the linear 0 relationship still manifested itself in the resultant ‘‘electrostatic’’ term, W O ðelÞ 0;O!W ¼ ½Gtr ðelÞ=zF, as shown in Fig. 4(B) [33]. This excellent correlation strongly
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
29
0 0;O!W TABLE 1 Values of W of Polyanions for the NB/W System [29] and Their O and Gtr Values of r and E
No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Polyanion ; -[XM12 O40 4 (X ¼ Si; Ge; M ¼ Mo; WÞ ; -½XM12 O40 3 (X ¼ P; As; M ¼ Mo; WÞ -½X2 Mo18 O62 6 ðX ¼ P; AsÞ -½S2 Mo18 O62 4 ½S2 VMo17 O62 5 ½P2 Mo18 O61 4 (containing P2 O4 7 Þ ½Mo6 O19 2 ½VMo5 O19 3 -½Mo8 O26 4
r (nm)
Ea (10 V m1 )
0 W O
(V)
0.56b
1:84
0:067 0:003
25.9
0.56b
1:38
0:248 0:004
71.8
0.648c
2:06
0:005 0:000
2.9
0.648c 0:648c 0.644c
1:37 1:72 1:39
0.269 0.085 0.239
103.8 41.0 92.2
0.437c 0.437c 0.485c
1:51 2:26 2:45
0.164 0:119 0:137
31.6 34:4 52:9
10
G0;O!W tr (kJ mol1 )
a
Calculated from Eq. (8). Literature value [32]. c Evaluated using the simple relation r ðnmÞ ¼ 0:164n1=3 (with n the number of oxygen atoms in the polyanion) [30]. Source: From Ref. 33. b
0 W FIG. 4 Plots of (A) W O and (B) O (el) of polyanions at the NB/W interface against E. (From Ref. 33. Copyright 1996 Elsevier Science B.V., Amsterdam.)
30
Osakai and Ebina
suggests that the surface field strength E should play an important role in the resolvation energies of polyanions. 0 Then, what would the linear E-dependence of W O mean? If we suppose that the 0;O!W 0 Gtr for the polyanions is given by the Born equation, W O ðelÞ should be proportional to z=r [cf. Eqs. (2) and (7)]; this dependence would come from the overall inte0 gration of a function of the electric field. In actuality, however, W O ðel) depends on the 2 value of E at the surface, which is proportional to z=r . This suggests that the shortrange ion–solvent interactions, rather than the Born-type long-range electrostatic interaction, play a major role in the z-dependence of the resolvation energy of polyanions. 0 Thus it is unsuitable to refer to W O ðelÞ as the ‘‘electrostatic’’ term. Instead, the term 0 will be referred to as the charge (z)-dependent term, being written as W O ðz-dep) [cf. Eq. (26)].
V.
A MODEL HAMILTONIAN APPROACH TO ION–SOLVENT INTERACTIONS
0 The authors [33] have elucidated the linear dependence of W O ðz-depÞ on E for the polyanions by a quantum chemical consideration. A model Hamiltonian approach to the charge transfer (CT) interaction between a polyanion and solvents has been made on the basis of the Mulliken’s CT complex theory [34]. Let us consider a case in which an ion (donor, Dz ) and a solvent (acceptor, A) form a CT complex. The ground state energy WN (see Fig. 5) can be obtained as a solution of the secular equation: W0 X W01 S01 X ð9Þ ¼0 W01 S01 X W1 X
where W0 is the energy in a no-bond state, j 0 i ¼ j ðDz AÞi, in which Dz and A come into contact without changing their electronic configurations; W1 is the energy in a dative state, j 1 i ¼ j ðDzþ1 A Þi, corresponding to the transfer of an electron from Dz to A; and W01 and S01 are defined by W01 ¼ h 0 jHj 1 i (H being the Hamiltonian operator) and S01 ¼ h 0 j 1 i, respectively. The CT interaction energy W, i.e., the resonance energy in the ground state is given by W ¼ W0 WN
FIG. 5 The charge transfer between an ion (donor, Dz ) and a solvent (acceptor, A).
ð10Þ
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
31
In the previous paper [33], the effect of the ionic charge z on W was investigated for the CT interaction between a polyanion and water. The effect will come out through W1 and W01 . By using a simple model in which an electron in the surface atom of a polyanion is transferred to a solvent molecule, the effect of z on W through W1 is considered as follows: if the ionic radius r is much larger than the CT distance d and the radius of the surface atom rO , the z-dependence of W1 can be expressed in terms of the surface field strength E of the polyanion as ed W1 W~ 1 þ E ð11Þ r where the E-independent term will be approximated as W~ 1 ¼ W0 þ Ip0 Ea ðAÞ
e2 40 r d
ð12Þ
with Ip0 being the ionization potential of the surface atom, Ea ðAÞ the electron affinity of the solvent, and r the relative permittivity of the solvent in the first solvation shell (being assumed to be equal to the optical permittivity, op ¼ 1:8 for water). The last term has been introduced as a correction factor for electrostatic effects of the liquid medium. Next, the effect of z on W through the transition matrix element W01 is considered as follows: for rigorous determination of W01 , all electrons in the system should be treated. However, for the sake of simplicity, we devote our attention only to the transferring electron; the other electrons would be regarded as forming the ‘‘effective’’ potential Veff ðxÞ for the transferring electron (x the coordinate of the electron given from the ion center). This enables us to reduce the many-body problem to a one-body problem: D E H one-body LUMO ð13Þ W01 HOMO D A where HOMO is the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) of Dz , LUMO the lowest D A unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of A, and H one-body the one-body Hamiltonian being given by H one-body ¼
h2 r2 þ Veff ðxÞ 82 m
ð14Þ
In order to give a concrete expression for Veff ðxÞ, a simple model has been assumed (see Fig. 6). In this model, it is postulated that an electron in the HOMO (essentially the 2p orbital) of the surface oxygen atom (Osurg ) of the polyanion partially transfers to the LUMO of water (the 4a1 molecular orbital). Then Veff ðxÞ can be expressed as Veff ðxÞ ¼ Vcharge-electron ðxÞ þ Vcharge-hole þ Vps ðxÞ
ð15Þ
where Vcharge-electron ðxÞ and Vcharge-hole represent potential energies ascribed to the Coulomb interactions between the ionic charge and the transferring electron and between the ionic charge and a positive hole formed on the Osurf atom, respectively, and where Vps ðxÞ is the pseudopotential, i.e., the effective potential formed by the nucleus of the Osurf atom and its electrons other than the transferring electron. Although it is difficult to obtain an exact expression for Vps ðxÞ, its appropriate expression only in the overlapping region (shown in D in Fig. 6) will be necessary for evaluating the matrix element with Eq. (13). As seen in Fig. 6, the overlapping region located around the place where the electron density of the 2p (Osurf ) orbital is the highest. The pertinent potential around this place
32
Osakai and Ebina
FIG. 6 Quantum chemical model of the CT complex of a polyanion and water. (From Ref. 33. Copyright 1996 Elsevier Science B.V., Amsterdam.)
should be used; the Coulomb potential has been employed here, on assuming that a positive charge of 2 is located at the center of the Osurf atom. Thus, the corresponding jVps ðxÞj LUMO i can be calculated approximately. energy h HOMO D A Finally, under the condition that r rO , the z-dependence of W01 can be expressed as a function of E, as in the case of W1 [Eq. (11)]: W01 ¼ W~ 01 þ eE with
D E ¼ rO D ¼ rO HOMO j LUMO D A * + 2 D h HOMO 2 LUMO þ W~ 01 ¼ 2 r A D 8 m
ð16Þ
ð17Þ
HOMO Vps ðxÞ LUMO D A
E
ð18Þ
From the above analysis, it is found that both W1 and W01 are linear functions of the surface electric field strength E, so that W obtained from Eq. (9) is also a function of E. The important point is that the z-dependence of the matrix element can be expressed only through E. By actually solving the secular equation (9), it has been found that the Edependence of W is well represented by a quadratic equation: W ¼ 0 þ 1 E þ 2 E 2
ð19Þ
It should be noted, however, that this equation represents the energy for a one-to-one ion– solvent interaction. When the ion is much larger than the solvent, it can be assumed that the number (N) of solvent molecules adjacent to the ion is proportional to the surface area of the ion: N ¼ 4r2 (where is the number of solvent molecules per unit surface area of the ion). Accordingly, the contribution of the CT interaction to the ion solvation energy G0s is given by
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
33
G0s ðCTÞ ¼ N W ¼ 0 þ 1 E þ 2 E 2
ð20Þ
with n ¼ 4r n ðn ¼ 1; 2; 3Þ; note that n is proportional to r . The contribution of is then given by the CT interaction to the ion-transfer energy G0;O!W tr 2
2
2 G0;O!W ðCTÞ Gs0;W ðCTÞ G0;O s ðCTÞ ¼ 0 þ 1 E þ 2 E tr
ð21Þ
O with n ¼ W n n . Here, the superscripts ‘‘W’’ and ‘‘O’’ refer to water and organic phases. Accordingly, the contribution of the CT interaction to the ion-transfer potential [being given by Eq. (7)] can be expressed as 0 1 þ 1 þ 2 E W O ðCTÞ ¼ 0 E
ð22Þ
O O with n ¼ ðW W n n Þ=0 which depends neither on z nor r. In view of the necessity of knowing an approximate value of the coefficient 2 of the linear term in Eq. (22), we have (CT) consists of only the contribution from made a daring assumption that G0;O!W tr water, namely, G0;O!W ðCTÞ G0;W ðCTÞ. This leads to the following approximation: s tr 0 W 1 þ 1W þ 2W E W O ðCTÞ ¼ 0 E
ð23Þ
where nW ¼ W W n =0
ðn ¼ 1; 2; 3Þ 2W
ð24Þ
Thus the coefficient can be evaluated from and The approximate value of W 18 2 ð¼ 9:4 10 molecules m ) is obtained from the density of bulk water by assuming that the thickness of the first solvation shell equals the diameter (0.28 nm) of a water molecule, 22 ðeVÞ V2 m2 from the whereas the value of W 2 has been obtained to be 2:025 10 W estimation of the E-dependence of W. Finally, the coefficient 2 has been evaluated to be 3:5 1011 m. This value is close to the experimental value of 2:85 1011 m, which 0 comes from the slope of the W O ðelÞ vs. E plot in Fig. 4(B). From this result, the authors [33] have concluded that the CT interaction plays a major role in the observed linear 0 W 0 dependence of W O ðelÞ or O ðz-depÞ on E, though this conclusion seems to be overstated to some extent.
VI.
W
W 2 .
SELECTIVE HYDRATION OF IONS IN ORGANIC SOLVENTS
0;O!W In almost all theoretical studies of Gtr , it is postulated or tacitly understood that when an ion is transferred across the O/W interface, it strips off solvated molecules completely, and hence the crystal ionic radius is usually employed for the calculation of . Although Abraham and Liszi [17], in considering the transfer between mutually G0;O!W tr saturated solvents, were aware of the effects of hydration of ions in organic solvents in which water is quite soluble (e.g., 1-octanol, 1-pentanol, and methylisobutyl ketone), they concluded that in solvents such as NB and1,2-DCE, the solubility of water is rather small and most ions in the water-saturated solvent exist as unhydrated entities. However, even a water-immiscible organic solvent such as NB dissolves a considerable amount of water (e.g., ca. 170 mM H2 O in NB). In such a medium, hydrophilic ions such as Liþ , Naþ , Ca2þ , Ba2þ , Cl , and Br are selectively solvated by water. This phenomenon has become apparent since at least 1968 by solvent extraction studies with the Karl–Fischer method [35–45]. Rais et al. [35] and Iwachido and coworkers [36–39] determined hydration numbers, i.e., the number of coextracted water molecules, for alkali and alkaline earth metal
34
Osakai and Ebina
ions in NB. Some inorganic anions (Cl , Br ,, I , SCN , ClO 4 , and NO3 ) have also been found to coextract water into NB [40–42]. Similar phenomena have further been observed in solvents other than NB (e.g., 1,1- and 1,2-dichloroethane, 4-methyl-2-pentanone, chloroform, NB–benzene mixtures) [42–45]. If these observations are valid, we should reconsider the previous theories of G0;O!W in which the hydration of ions in O is not tr properly taken into account. From this point of view, Osakai et al. [46] reaffirmed the coextraction of water into NB for a variety of common ions and determined their accurate hydration numbers in NB. In the previous study [46], various kinds of cations and anions (listed in Table 2) were extracted from water to NB using several extractants: tetraphenylborate (TPB ) and dipicrylaminate (DPA ) for the cations; n-Bu4 Nþ , n-Pen4 Nþ , n-Hep4 Nþ , and tris(1,10phenanthroline)iron(II) ([Fe(phen)3 2þ Þ for the anions. The increase in the water concentration in the NB phase, ½H2 O, with extraction of an ion was evaluated as a function of equilibrium concentration of the ion in NB. A typical example, obtained in the DPA
TABLE 2 at 25 C
Numbers (n) of Coextracted Water Molecules in NB and Radii (rh ) of Hydrated Ions n
Cation Liþ Naþ Kþ Rbþ Csþ Ca2þ Ba2þ Me4 Nþ Et4 Nþ n-Bu4 Nþ Ph4 Asþ
TPB system 6.3 4.0
15 10 0 0 ( 0[42])
DPA system 5.7 (4.2[35]; 5.5[36]) 3.6 (3.6[35]; 3.5[36]) 1.0 (1.0[35]; 1.3[36]) 0.7 (0[35]; 0.7[36]) 0.4 (0[35]; 0.7[36]) 12 (13[36]) 11 (9.4[36]) 0 0 0
av
rh (nm)
ra (nm)
6:0 0:4 3:8 0:3 1.0 0.7 0.4 14 2 11 1 0 00 0 0
0.351 0.307 0.220 0.212 0.206 0.467 0.435
0.073 0.116 0.152 0.166 0.181 0.114 0.149 0.279 0.337 0.413 0.426
n
Anion Cl Br I SCN ClO 4 NO 3 TPB a
n-Bu4 Nþ system
2.1 (1.8[43]) 0.9 1.1 0.3 ( 1:4½42Þ 0ð 0[42])
n-Pen4 Nþ system 4.0 (3.3[43]) 2.1 0.8 1.1 0.2 0
n-Hep4 Nþ system
2.0 1.0 1.0 0.2 0
½FeðphenÞ3 2þ system —b (5.5[41]) 1.0c (2.1[41]) 1.1c (1.9[41]) 0.1c (0.64[41]) 1.7c 0c
av 4.0 2:1 0:1 0:9 0:1 1:1 0:1 0:2 0:1 1.7 0
rh (nm)
ra (nm)
0.322 0.276 0.248 0.260 0.244 0.267
0.167 0.182 0.206 0.213 0.236 0.189 0.421
Crystal (or bare) ionic radii (see Table 3). No reliable value could be obtained due to extremely low extractability (the distribution ratio D < 0:03). c Corrected for the contribution (n ¼ 0:3) from ½FeðphenÞ3 2þ . Source: From Ref. 46. b
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
35
system, is shown in Fig. 7. The hydrophobic organic cations (Me4 Nþ , Et4 Nþ , and TPAsþ ) showed no increase in water concentration, indicating that these cations as well as DPA had no ability to transport water to NB. In contrast, hydrophilic metal ions showed a distinguishing increase. The slope of each linear plot should correspond to the number (n) of water molecules coextracted to NB with a metal ion, which are listed in Table 2 together with those determined in other systems. As seen in the table, for both cations and anions, the n values determined were only slightly dependent on the nature of extractant (i.e., coion). This implies that ion-pair formation in NB is of less significance or that the ions are almost dissociated. Thus accurate numbers of water molecules, being certainly associated with individual ions, could be determined. Based on these measurements, a new model of the transfer of hydrophilic ions across the O/W interface was proposed (see Fig. 8). In this model, the hydrophilic ion transfers from W to O with some water molecules associated with the ion. A typical example in Fig. 8 shows that a sodium ion transfers across the NB/W interface with four water molecules. of such a hydrophilic ion, therefore, the transferring In theoretical treatment of G0;O!W tr species should be regarded as the ‘‘hydrated’’ ion. In accordance, the radii (rh Þ of hydrated ions in NB were estimated from the hydration numbers (n) and crystal ionic radii (r) by rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 3 3 n þ r3 ð25Þ rh ¼ 4 d where d is the density of water in the hydration shell (here, the value of d is assumed to be the same as that of bulk water, i.e., 3:33 1028 molecule m3 ). The estimated values of rh are also shown in Table 2. As seen in Table 2, the order of the magnitude of rh for alkali metal ions is the reverse of that of the magnitude of r. This means that a more hydrophilic ion has a larger rh . However, this fact does contradict the expectation from Bornian electrostatic theories. As can be seen in the Born equation [Eq. (2)], it is expected that the larger the radius an ion 0;O!W has, the more positive the Gtr value the ion has, that is, the more hydrophobic it
FIG. 7 Plots of the increase of water concentration in NB (½H2 OÞ with extraction of cations with DPA against the equilibrium cation concentration in NB. Each value in the parentheses shows the number (n) of coextracted water molecules per ion. (From Ref. 46. Copyright 1997 American Chemical Society.)
36
Osakai and Ebina
FIG. 8 Proposed model of the transfer of a hydrophilic ion across the O/W interface. The illustration shows the transfer of Naþ from W to NB as a typical example. (From Ref. 46. Copyright 1997 American Chemical Society.)
becomes. This would show that Liþ , as an example, is more hydrophobic than Csþ , but this is of course not the case. Thus, if hydrated radii of ions are used, Bornian electrostatic solvation models are invalid. Then we made a new approach that recognizes short-range interactions of a 0;O!W for hydrophilic ions could be hydrated ion with solvents. By this approach, Gtr elucidated on the basis of the proposed model in Fig. 8 (see Section VII). A similar model for some hydrophilic ions, was also employed by Sa´nchez et al. [47] to elucidate G0;O!W tr but using a Bornian electrostatic theory. Recently, the abilities of primary to tertiary alkylammonium ions with Me, Et, and n-Bu groups to transport water to NB have been studied [48]. As the result of careful consideration of the ion-pair formation, it has been shown that the hydration numbers (nh ) of the ammonium ions in NB, being little affected by the alkyl chain length, are simply dependent on the class of the ammonium ion: nh ¼ 1:64, 1.04, 0.66, respectively, for the primary, secondary, and tertiary ammonium ions.
VII. A.
NON-BORNIAN THEORY OF THE RESOLVATION ENERGY OF IONS Theoretical Model
Based on the above-mentioned experimental and theoretical findings, we have proposed a new, non-Bornian theory of G0;O!W of ions [49]. In this theory, it is assumed that a tr hydrophilic ion which is selectively hydrated in organic solvent transfers across the O/W interface as the hydrated ion, and a hydrophobic ion which is not hydrated in the O phase transfers as a bare ion, as depicted in Fig. 9. In a conventional manner we divide G0;O!W into two terms: tr 0;O!W 0;O!W Gtr ¼ Gtr ðz-indepÞ þ G0;O!W ðz-depÞ tr
ðz-indepÞ G0;O!W tr
ð26Þ
is the charge-independent term corresponding to the solvophowhere bic interaction or the energy of the formation of a cavity in solvents, and G0;O!W ðz-depÞ tr is the charge-dependent term, which has so far been considered mainly as describing
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
37
FIG. 9 Proposed model of the transfer of (a) a hydrophilic ion and (b) a hydrophobic ion across the O/W interface. (From Ref. 49. Copyright 1998 American Chemical Society.)
electrostatic (i.e., long-range) ion–solvent interaction, but is here treated as describing specific (short-range) interactions. ðz-indepÞ, we employed the Uhlig formula [Eq. (4)]. For the evaluation of G0;O!W tr This formula may be applicable to the NB/W interface (O;W ¼ 25:2 mN m1 [50]) and to all ions studied (see Table 3), which include the ‘‘hydrated’’ ions with a hydrated radius rh ð¼ rÞ larger than 0.20 nm as well as the ‘‘unhydrated’’ ions of r > 0:23 nm. 0;O!W ðz-dep) in Eq. (26) is here assumed to be govThe charge-dependent term Gtr erned by short-range ion–solvent interactions. The long-range interactions of an ion with the solvents in the second and further solvation shells are ignored in the present theory. Because the short-range (i.e., chemical) interactions recognize some overlap of the electron orbitals of the ion and the solvent molecule in its immediate vicinity, they should be explained on quantum chemical considerations. In ab initio molecular orbital studies [58], the self-consistent-field (SCF) energy of the ion–molecule interaction, USCF , is partitioned into several terms including Coulomb (COU), polarization (POL), charge-transfer (CT), and exchange (EX) terms: USCF ¼ UCOU þ UPOL þ UCT þ UEX
ð27Þ
The first two terms UCOU and UPOL correspond to the empirical energy of ion–dipole and ion–induced dipole interactions, being given by UCOU ¼ Ehcos i
ð28Þ
1 UPOL ¼ E 2 2
ð29Þ
and
where and are the dipole moment and electronic polarizability of the solvent molecule, respectively, is the angle between the dipole axis and the line connecting the point dipole and point charge, h i indicates the ensemble average, and E is the ‘‘effective’’ electrical field strength, which can be approximated by the surface field strength of the ion given by Eq. (8), when r is much larger than the radius of the dipole (i.e., solvent molecule).
38
Osakai and Ebina
TABLE 3 Charge Numbers and Radii of Ions and Their Hydration Numbers and Hydrated Radii in NB at 25 C Ion Hydrated cations Liþ Naþ Kþ Rbþ Csþ Ca2þ Ba2þ Nonhydrated cations Me4 Nþ Et4 Nþ n-Pr4 Nþ n-Bu4 Nþ Ph4 Asþ ðTPAsþ Þ ½NiðbpyÞ3 2þ ½NiðphenÞ3 2þ ½FeðphenÞ3 2þ Hydrated anions Cl Br I SCN NO 3 Nonhydrated anions ClO 4 IO 4 2,4-dinitrophenol 2,4,6-trinitrophenol Ph4 B ðTPB Þ Polyanions ; -½XM12 O40 4 ; -½XM12 O40 3 -½X2 Mo18 O62 6 -½S2 Mo18 O62 4 ½S2 VMo17 O62 5 ½P2 Mo18 O61 4 ½Mo6 O19 2 ½VMo5 O19 3 -½Mo8 O26 4
z
ra (nm)
nb
rh c (nm)
1 1 1 1 1 2 2
0.073 0.116 0.152 0.166 0.181 0.114 0.149
6.0 3.8 1.0 0.7 0.4 14 11
0.351 0.307 0.220 0.212 0.206 0.467 0.435
1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2
0.279d 0.337d 0.379d 0.413d 0.416f 0.527g 0.544g 0.541g
0 0 0e 0 0 0e 0e e 0 (0.3)
1 1 1 1 1
0.167 0.182 0.206 0.213h 0.189i
4.0 2.1 0.9 1.1 1.7
1 1 1 1 1
0.236i 0.249i 0.315j 0.332j 0.421f
0e (0.2) 0e 0e 0e 0
4 3 6 4 5 4 2 3 4
0.56k 0.56k 0.648k 0.648k 0.648k 0.644k 0.437k 0.437k 0.485k
0e 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e
0.322 0.276 0.248 0.260 0.267
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
39
The third term, UCT , in Eq. (27) is due to the partial electron transfer between an ion and solvents in its immediate vicinity. The model Hamiltonian approach [33], described in Section V, has shown that UCT ð¼ W in Ref. 33) per primary solvent molecule, for an ion such as the polyanion, can also be expressed as a function of E, approximately a quadratic equation: UCT ¼ 0 1 E 2 E 2
ð30Þ
The coefficients 0 , 1 , and 2 (denoted as 0 , 1 , and 2 in Ref. 33) are influenced by various molecular properties of the solvent and an ion, including their electron-donating or accepting abilities. Hence, these coefficients are specific to the ion. Nevertheless, they may be considered as common to a family of ions such as the polyanions whose surface atoms, directly interacting with solvents, are oxygens. This is the case for ‘‘hydrated’’ cations or anions whose surfaces are composed of some water molecules that interact with outer water molecules in the W phase or with organic solvents in the O phase. The remaining term, UEX , in Eq. (27) represents the nonclassical repulsion term, being inherently independent of E. By summarizing the above argument, we conclude that the short-range interaction energy, USR ð¼ USCF Þ, can be given by a quadratic function of E: USR ¼ A BE CE 2
ð31Þ
A ¼ 0 þ UEX
ð32Þ
B ¼ Ehcos i þ 1 C ¼ þ 2 2
ð33Þ
with
ð34Þ
The validity of Eq. (31) has been confirmed by an approach from redox potentials of heteropoly oxometalate anions as well [59]. In Eq. (31) we should note that USR represents the interaction energy per primary solvent molecule. Then the number of solvent molecules that can be interact directly with an ion in phase S ð¼ O or W) is denoted as N S . Accordingly, the contribution of the shortof the ion phase S (i.e., transfer range interactions to the solvation energy G0;vac!S tr energy from vacuum) is given from Eq. (31) as
Footnotes to Table 3 a Shannon’s crystal ionic radii [51], except where otherwise noted. b Ref. 46. c Estimated by Eq. (25). d van der Waals radii calculated from the partial molar ionic volumes [52]. e Assumed. f Ref. 6. g van der Waals radii calculated from the partial molar ionic volumes [53,54]. h Ref. 55. i Thermochemical radii [56]. j From van der Waals volumes calculated from atomic increments [57]. k See Table 1. Source: From Ref. 49.
40
Osakai and Ebina
G0;vac!S ðSRÞ ¼ N S USR ¼ AS N S BS N S E C S N S E 2 tr
ð35Þ
where the superscript S of A, B, and C represents the S phase. Because the transfer energy G0;O!W is the difference between G0;S s ’s in O and W, the contribution of short-range tr can be expressed as interactions to G0;O!W tr 0;O!W ðSRÞ ¼ 1 2 E 3 E 2 Gtr
ð36Þ
1 ¼ A W N W A O N O
ð37Þ
2 ¼ BW N W BO N O
ð38Þ
3 ¼ C W N W C O N O
ð39Þ
with
0;O!W (SR) Gtr
is given approximately by a quadratic equation of E. The In this manner coefficients 1 , 2 , and 3 are related to various molecular properties of the ion and solvents [see Eqs. (32)–(34) and Eqs. (37)–(39)]. To estimate theoretically these coefficients using an appropriate model may not be impossible, but rather difficult at the present stage, because there is insufficient information on the above-mentioned molecular properties (in particular, the charge-transfer properties). Consequently, coefficients 1 , 2 , and 3 in Eq. (36) have been determined empirically, as shown below. B.
Experimental Data
In the present analyses [49], 34 ions are classified into five groups: (1) hydrated cations, (2) nonhydrated cations, (3) hydrated anions, (4) nonhydrated anions, and (5) polyanions. Here, the term ‘‘hydrated’’ or ‘‘nonhydrated’’ means that the ion is associated with some water molecules in the O phase or not, respectively. 1. Ionic Radii All ions studied are assumed to be spherical, and radii (r) of the bare ions are listed in Table 3. Unless otherwise noted, authorized values of crystal ionic radii or van der Waals radii are adopted [51–57]. 2. Hydration Numbers of Ions in NB The numbers (n) of coextracted water molecules shown in Table 3 are from Table 2 [46]. In the case of n-Pr4 Nþ , metal complex cations, larger anions of r > 0:23 nm, and polyanions, it is assumed that n ¼ 0. Although the n value of ½FeðphenÞ3 2þ or ClO 4 was reported to be as small as 0.3 or 0.2 [46], these ions have been classified as ‘‘nonhydrated’’ (i.e., n ¼ 0) so that comparatively better results may be obtained. In Table 3 are also shown the hydrated radii (rh ) which are evaluated with n and r by Eq. (25). A good correlation of rh with the Stokes radius [60] (rs ) has been observed for hydrated cations (alkali and alkaline earth metal ions) [46]: rh ðnmÞ ¼ 1:310 rs ðnmÞ þ 0:055
ðR ¼ 0:997Þ
ð40Þ
In this equation and the following remarks, R shows the correlation coefficient. For the prediction of G0;O!W of a hydrophilic ion whose n value is unknown, it is tr desirable that the n value can be obtained with r and z only. Since the interactions of a small ion with water molecules in the hydration shell may be mostly electrostatic, the
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
41
dependence of n on (z=r) has been investigated for hydrophilic cations and anions. As a result, it has been found that the plots of n against (z=r) lie on a quadratic curve: For cations: ðR ¼ 0:966Þ n ¼ 0:566 þ 0:0091ðz=rÞ þ 0:04745ðz=rÞ2 For anions: n ¼ 5:844 þ 3:775ðz=rÞ þ 0:5661ðz=rÞ2 ðR ¼ 0:930Þ
ð41Þ ð42Þ
where r is in nanometers. Equations (41) and (42) are applicable in the range of ðz=rÞ > 5 and ðz=rÞ < 4, respectively. Using these equations, we can predict, though somewhat roughly, the n value of a hydrophilic ion. Regarding the cations, however, their n values could be obtained more accurately from the Stokes radii by using the relations of Eqs. (25) and (40). 3.
Gibbs Energies of Transfer of Ions
0;O!W In 1977 Koryta et al. [61] reported the Gtr values of several common ions at the NB/W interface, which were calculated from the extraction data using an extra thermodynamic assumption. Afterward, a newly developed electrochemical technique (so-called ion-transfer voltammetry) with a polarizable O/W interface was employed to determine G0trO!W for a variety of ions [33,62–71]. In Table 4 the reliable values of G0;O!W tr are compiled. Regarding the ions whose G0;O!W values are available for both electrotr chemical and extraction measurements, the electrochemical data, which seem to be more accurate, have been chosen preferentially. For several ions, somewhat different G0;O!W tr values from electrochemical measurements have been reported, as also seen in the database provided by Girault on a website [72]. In this study, however, we have carefully chosen reliable values for the respective ions, which were determined under well-defined conditions (reference electrodes, solution compositions, etc.).
C.
Data Analyses
1.
Calculation of Cavity Formation Energies
Using the Uhlig formula [Eq. (4)] the values of G0;O!W (z-indep) have been obtained tr from ionic radii, as shown in Table 4. For the hydrated cations and anions, their hydrated 0;O!W (zradii (rh Þ have been employed for r in Eq. (4). Table 4 also shows the values of Gtr 0;O!W (z-indep) from the total G0;O!W dep) which have been obtained by subtracting Gtr tr [see Eq. (26)]. 2. Regression Analyses for Hydrated Ions Unless noted otherwise, it has been assumed that the number of the solvent molecules N S (S ¼ O or W) that can interact directly with a hydrated ion in phase S is equal to the hydration number: NO ¼ NW ¼ n
ð43Þ
For Ca2þ and Ba2þ , whose n values are larger than 10, however, it is thought that some hydrated water molecules not only in the first hydration shell but also in the second hydration shell are cotransferred into NB. Accordingly, it can be supposed that some water molecules in the first hydration shell (i.e., in the vicinity of the ion) are covered with the second hydration shell, so that they cannot be associated with outer solvent
42
Osakai and Ebina
TABLE 4 Standard Gibbs Energies of Transfer of Ions from NB to W and Their ChargeIndependent and Charge-Dependent Components at 25 C
Ion Hydrated cations Liþ Naþ Kþ Rbþ Csþ Ca2þ Ba2þ Nonhydrated cations Me4 Nþ Et4 Nþ n-Pr4 Nþ n-Bu4 Nþ Ph4 Asþ ðTPAsþ Þ ½NiðbpyÞ3 2þ ½NiðphenÞ3 2þ ½FeðphenÞ3 2þ Hydrated anions Cl Br I SCN NO 3 Nonhydrated anions ClO 4 IO 4 2,4-dinitrophenol 2,4,6-trinitrophenol Ph4 B ðTPB Þ Polyanions ; -½XM12 O40 4 ; -½XM12 O40 3 -½X2 Mo18 O62 6 -½S2 Mo18 O62 4 ½S2 VMo17 O62 5 ½P2 Mo18 O61 4 ½Mo6 O19 2 ½VMo5 O19 3 -½Mo8 O26 4
G0;O!W tr (kJ mol1 )
G0;O!W (z-indep)a tr (kJ mol1 )
G0;O!W (z-dep)b tr (kJ mol1 )
38:2c;d 34:2c;d 23:5c;d 19:4c;d 15:4c;d 67:3d;e 61:8d;e
23.6 17.9 9.2 8.6 8.1 41.6 36.0
61:8 52:1 32:7 28:0 23:5 108:9 97:8
3:4c;d 5.3f 16:4g 26:5h 35:9c;d 30:5i 41:3i 44:0j
14.8 21.7 27.4 32.5 34.6 53.0 56.4 55.8
18:2 16:4 11:0 6:0 1.3 22:5 15:1 11:8
38:2k 27:8l 18:4l 15:8l 25:2l
19.8 14.6 11.7 12.9 13.5
58:0 42:4 30:1 28:7 38:7
7:9l 6m 5:7n 6:7n 35:9d
10.6 11.8 18.9 21.0 33.8
18:5 17:8 24:6 14:3 2.1
25:9o 71.8o 2:9o 103:8o 41:0o 92:2o 31:6o 34:4o 52:9o
59.8 59.8 80.1 80.1 80.1 79.1 36.4 36:4 44.9
33:9 12.0 77:2 23.7 39:1 13.1 4:8 70:8 97:8
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
43
molecules (W or NB). Such an effect is here called ‘‘shielding.’’ In these cases, N S cannot be equated simply to n and should be reduced to some extent. It has been found that for the above two cations, the subtraction of 4 from the net n values may lead to the best result in the following regression analysis. If we suppose that G0trO!W (z-dep) for the hydrated ions is ruled out by short-range interactions, a combination of Eqs. (36)–(39) and Eq. (43) yields G0trO!W ðz-depÞ=n ¼ A BE CE 2
ð44Þ
with A ¼ A A , B ¼ B B , and C ¼ C C . In Fig. 10 the values of G0;O!W (z-dep)=n for the hydrated cations (*) and anions (*) are plotted against E, tr being calculated by Eq. (8) with r ¼ rh . Note that the plots of Ca2þ and Ba2þ have been compensated for the ‘‘shielding’’ effect: the symbols () in Fig. 10 represent the plots with the net values of n ð¼ 14 or 11 for Ca2þ or Ba2þ , respectively). 0;O!W (z-dep) per hydrated water As seen in Fig. 10, in accordance with Eq. (44), Gtr becomes progressively greater as E is enhanced. Since the contribution from the interaction in W to G0;O!W (z-dep) is probably more significant than that from the interaction tr in NB, the dependences shown in Fig. 10 seem to suggest that the hydrogen bonds, which are formed around a hydrated ion in W and which must be broken in its transfer to NB, are strengthened by the surface field of the hydrated ion. The solid lines in Fig. 10 represent the quadratic curves obtained in regression analyses. W
O
W
O
W
O
For hydrated cations: G0;O!W ðz-depÞ=n ¼ 8:90 þ 4:506E 4:853E 2 tr For hydrated anions: G0;O!W ðz-depÞ=n ¼ 50:17 52:51E 19:33E 2 tr where
0;O!W (z-dep) Gtr
is in kJ mol
1
10
ðR ¼ 0:931Þ ðR ¼ 0:999Þ
ð45Þ ð46Þ
1
and E is in 10 V m .
3. Regression Analyses for Nonhydrated Ions As for the nonhydrated ions including the polyanions, it has been assumed that N S is proportional to the surface area of the ion:
Footnotes to Table 4 a Evaluated using Eq. (4) (note that r ¼ rh for the hydrated ions). b 0;O!W 0;O!W G0;O!W (z-depÞ ¼ Gtr Gtr (z-indep). tr c Ref. 61. d Determined using extraction data; the other values were determined by electrochemical measurements. e Ref. 62. f Ref. 63. The value is revised by employing Me4 Nþ as an internal reference in the place of n-Bu4 Nþ . g Unpublished data obtained by means of the former electrochemical technique [64]. h Ref. 65. i Ref. 66. j Ref. 67. k Ref. 68. l Ref. 69. m Ref. 70. n Ref. 71. o Calculated from the standard ion-transfer potentials compiled previously [33]. Source: From Ref. 49.
44
Osakai and Ebina
FIG. 10 Plots of G0;O!W (z-depÞ=n against E (with r ¼ rh ) for hydrated cations (*) and anions tr (*). Note that the n values for the plots of Ca2þ and Ba2þ have been corrected for the ‘‘shielding’’ effect (see text) by subtracting 4 from their net values of n; () represents the plots with the net values. Solid lines show the regression curves [Eqs. (45) and (46)]. (From Ref. 49. Copyright 1998 American Chemical Society.)
N S ¼ 4r2 S
ð47Þ
where is the number of solvent molecules per unit surface area of the ion in phase S (z-dep) is ruled only by short-range ð¼ O or W). We have also assumed that G0;O!W tr interactions in the same manner as the hydrated ions and then have obtained from Eqs. (36)–(39) and Eq. (47): S
0;O!W ðz-depÞ=ð4r2 Þ ¼ A 0 B 0 E C 0 E 2 Gtr 0
0
ð48Þ 0
with A ¼ A A , B ¼ B B , and C ¼ C C . (z-dep)/(4r2 ) have been plotted In accordance with Eq. (48), the values of G0;O!W tr against E in Fig. 11. The respective plots for the three ion groups have been found to lie on a single quadratic curve. W W
O O
W W
O O
W W
For nonhydrated cations: G0;O!W ðz-depÞ=ð4r2 Þ ¼ 28:19 43:08E þ 9:582E 2 tr For nonhydrated anions: G0;O!W ðz-depÞ=ð4r2 Þ ¼ 33:04 þ 47:53E þ 9:518E 2 tr For polyanions: G0;O!W ðz-depÞ=ð4r2 Þ ¼ 13:40 7:685E 11:08E 2 tr 0;O!W (z-dep) Gtr
1
10
O O
ðR ¼ 0:987Þ
ð49Þ
ðR ¼ 0:967Þ
ð50Þ
ðR ¼ 0:989Þ
ð51Þ
1
is in kJ mol , r in nm, and E in 10 V m . It is noteworthy that where the plots of the polyanions with a wide variety of charges (z ¼ 2 to 6) lie on a single curve. 4. Total Gibbs Energies of Transfer of Ions 0;O!W The values of Gtr have been calculated using the Uhlig formula [Eq. (4)] for the charge-independent part and the empirical equations [Eqs. (45), (46), (49), (50), and (51)] 0;O!W for the charge-dependent part. Table 5 gives the calculated values of Gtr for 34 ions, and the values are compared in Fig. 12 with the observed values shown in Table 4. As seen
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
45
FIG. 11 Plots of G0trO!W (z-depÞ=ð4r2 Þ against E for nonhydrated cations (~) and anions (~) and polyanions (&). Solid lines show the regression curves [Eqs. (49), (50), and (51)]. (From Ref. 49. Copyright 1998 American Chemical Society.)
FIG. 12 Comparison of the calculated and observed values of G0trO!W for 34 ions: (*) hydrated cations, (*) hydrated anions, (~) nonhydrated cations, (~) nonhydrated anions, and (&) polyanions. (From Ref. 49. Copyright 1998 American Chemical Society.)
46 TABLE 5
Osakai and Ebina Calculations of Standard Gibbs Energies of Transfer of Ions from NB to W (25 C)
Ion Hydrated cations Liþ Naþ Kþ Rbþ Csþ Ca2þ Ba2þ Nonhydrated cations Me4 Nþ Et4 Nþ n-Pr4 Nþ n-Bu4 Nþ Ph4 Asþ ðTPAsþ Þ ½NiðbpyÞ3 2þ ½NiðphenÞ3 2þ ½FeðphenÞ3 2þ Hydrated anions Cl Br I SCN NO 3 Nonhydrated anions ClO 4 IO 4 2,4-dinitrophenol 2,4,6-trinitrophenol Ph4 B ðTPB Þ Polyanions ; -½XM12 O40 4 ; -½XM12 O40 3 -½X2 Mo18 O62 6 -½S2 Mo18 O62 4 ½S2 VMo17 O62 5 ½P2 Mo18 O61 4 ½Mo6 O19 2 ½VMo5 O19 3 -½Mo8 O26 4 a
Ea (10 V m1 ) 10
(z-dep)b G0;O!W tr (kJ mol1 )
(calc)c G0;O!W tr (kJ mol1 )
61:5 50:9 38:3 30:7 19:6 114:1 93:1
37:9 33:0 29:0 22:1 11:5 72:5 57:1
ðþ0:3Þe ðþ1:2Þ ð5:5Þ ð2:7Þ ðþ3:9Þ ð5:2) ðþ4:7Þ
18:3 15:7 9:7 2:9 0.1 21:6 17:3 18:1
3:5 5.9 17.7 29.6 34.7 31.4 39.1 37.7
ð0:1Þ ðþ0:6Þ ðþ1:3Þ ðþ3:1Þ ð1:2Þ (þ0:9Þ (2:2) (6:3)
64:1 45:9 31:8 30:9 42:7
44:3 31:3 20:1 18:0 29:2
ð0:3Þ ðþ1:5Þ ðþ0:2Þ ð0:1Þ ð1:3Þ
2:59 2:32 1:45 1:31 0:81
18:4 20:3 19:8 17:7 1.6
7:7 8:9 0:9 3.3 35.4
ðþ1:4Þ ð2:4Þ ðþ4:8Þ ð3:4Þ ð0:5Þ
1:84 1:38 2:06 1:37 1:71 1:39 1:51 2:26 2:45
38:8 11.7 93:3 16.3 31:6 14.1 0:5 62:2 101:1
21.0 71.5 13:3 96.4 48.5 93.2 35.9 25:7 56:3
(4:9) ð0:3Þ ð16:2Þ ð7:4Þ ðþ7:5Þ ðþ1:0Þ ðþ4:3Þ ðþ8:7Þ (3:4)
1.17 1.53 2.97 3.19 3.38 1.32 1.52
(27.0)d (10.7) (6.23) (5.23) (4.39) (22.2) (13.0)
1.85 1.27 1.00 0.84 0.79 1.04 0.97 0.98 1:39 1:89 2:35 2:13 2:03
ð5:16Þd ð4:35Þ ð3:39Þ ð3:17Þ ð4:03)
Evaluated from Eq. (8). For the hydrated ions, their hydrated radii were employed for the value of r. Calculated using Eqs. (45), (49), (46), (50), and (51) for hydrated cations, nonhydrated cations, hydrated anions, nonhydrated anions, and polyanions, respectively. c 0;O!W Obtained by adding the calculated values of G0;O!W (z-dep) to the values of Gtr (z-indep) in Table 4. tr d The values in parentheses are surface field strengths of the bare ions. e The values in parentheses show the deviations from the observed values. Source: From Ref. 49. b
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
47
from the figure, satisfactory agreement has been observed (R ¼ 0:994; standard deviation, 0 0;O!W by Eq. (7), the correSD ¼ 4:63 kJ mol1 ). Also, for the W O being related to Gtr lation of the calculated and observed values has been found to be very good (R ¼ 0:995; SD ¼ 0:023 V). D.
Predictions
0 (and W Based on the proposed theory, the values of G0;O!W O ) have been predicted for tr þ 2þ 2þ 2þ 2þ 3þ hydrophilic ions (NH4 , Mg , Sr , Ni , Fe ; Fe , ClO3 , BrO 3 , CN , IO3 , HCO3 , 0;O!W values have been reported, but their hydration numbers are NO2 , OH ), whose Gtr unknown. In the predictions, the first decision on whether the ion is hydrated in NB is made by means of ðz=rÞ; as described above, if ðz=rÞ > 5 (r in nm) for a cation or ðz=rÞ < 4 for an anion (except polyanions), the ion should be hydrated in NB to a certain extent. For these hydrated ions, the hydration number and the hydrated radius are evaluated. 0;O!W Then the charge-independent and -dependent terms of Gtr are calculated using the Uhlig formula and the empirical equation, respectively. Finally, the summation of the two . terms yields the total value of G0;O!W tr (z-dep) for highly hydrated cations (Mg2þ , Sr2þ , Ni2þ , In the calculation of G0;O!W tr 2þ 3þ Fe , Fe ) with n > 10, the values of n for use in Eq. (45) have been corrected for the ‘‘shielding’’ effect, on the assumption that the corrected value of n is proportional to the surface area of the hydrated ion:
ncorr ¼ f ð4r2 Þ
ð52Þ
The factor f has been determined to be 42.05 by a regression analysis, so that the ncorr values of Ca2þ and Ba2þ may be approximated to n 4 (see above). Although the results of the predictions (see Table 5 in Ref. 49) are not shown here, it has been found that the proposed theory is promising not only for an understanding of but also for its prediction. G0;O!W tr E.
Discussion
In the proposed theory, short-range ion–solvent interaction energies are formulated as Eq. (31). the coefficients A, B, and C in the quadratic equation are related to coefficients 1 , [Eq. (36)]. The above-mentioned regression 2 , and 3 in the formula for G0;O!W tr analyses have clearly shown that these coefficients are common to a family of ions. This suggests that the surface chemical constitution of an ion should play a major role in its short-range interactions with solvents. For hydrated ions, their surfaces are composed of water molecules, which may prevent the inner ion from interacting directly with outer solvent molecules. Accordingly, the quantum chemical properties of the inner ion hardly influence direct interactions of the hydrated ion with solvents. The inner ion may function only as the origin of the surface electrical field of the hydrated ion, which should affect the short-range interaction energy, as shown in Eq. (31). As for the nonhydrated cations studied, their surfaces are mainly composed of C–H atomic groups, while the five nonhydrated anions, being forced to be classified into one group, have miscellaneous surfaces. As also described above, the surfaces of the polyanions are composed of oxygens without exception. Thus Eq. (31) turns out to be quite promising for an understanding of G0;O!W for ions with the common surface. tr The coefficients in Eq. (44) or (48) coming from those in Eq. (31) have been determined empirically in the present study. As shown above, these coefficients are related to
48
Osakai and Ebina
some molecular properties of the ion and the solvent. However, it seems premature to discuss these relations quantitatively, because the coefficients would be heavily affected by 0;O!W . It is desired to collect accurate and reliable values of the experimental errors in Gtr 0;O!W Gtr for many other kinds of ions. In the present non-Bornian theory it should be noted again that the long-range electrostatic interactions of an ion with solvents in the second and further solvation shells are ignored. However, the electrostatic energies should contribute to a considerable extent to the solvation energies of ions in each phase. Nevertheless, the proposed equations for G0;O!W , in which short-range interactions are only considered, have been found to be tr fitted very well to the experimental data. This may be understood by recognizing that is the difference in the solvation energy between the two phases. It is most G0;O!W tr probable that the long-range electrostatic solvation energies in the respective phases are 0;O!W for the most part canceled in Gtr . This will result in the predominant contribution of 0;O!W . Thus, our daring ignoring of the long-range electroshort-range interactions to Gtr than Bornian electrostatic models. static energies have given a better account of G0;O!W tr
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27.
M. Born. Z. Phys. 1: 45 (1920). Y. Marcus, Ion Solvation, Wiley, Chichester, 1985. Y. Marcus, Ion Properties, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1997. R. R. Dogonadze, E. Ka´lma´n, A. A. Kornyshev, and J. Ulstrup (eds.), The Chemical Physics of Solvation: Part A, Theory of Solvation, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985. P. Politzer and J. S. Murray (eds.), Quantitative Treatments of Solute/Solvent Interactions, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994. Y. Marcus. Rev. Anal. Chem. 5:53 (1980). Y. Marcus. Pure Appl. Chem. 62:899 (1990). Y. Marcus, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, pp. 39–61. V. S. Markin and A. G. Volkov. Electrochim. Acta 34:93 (1989). T. Osakai and K. Ebina. Bunseki 1998:589 (1998) (in Japanese). A. A. Kornyshev and A. G. Volkov. J. Electroanal. Chem. 180:363 (1984). A. A. Kornyshev, in Ref. 4, pp. 77–118. H. H. Uhlig. J. Phys. Chem. 41:1215 (1937). W. M. Latimer, K. S. Pitzer, and C. M. Slansky. J. Chem. Phys. 7:108 (1939). M. H. Abraham and J. Liszi. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1 74:1604; 2858 (1978). M. H. Abraham, J. Liszi, and L. Me´sza´ros. J. Chem. Phys. 70:2491 (1979). M. H. Abraham and J. Liszi. J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 43:143 (1981). Y. Marcus. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 87:2995 (1991). V. Gutmann, The Donor–Acceptor Approach to Molecular Interactions, Plenum Press, New York, 1978. K. Burger, Solvation, Ionic and Complex Formation Reactions in Non-Aqueous Solvents: Experimental Methods for Their Investigation, Akade´miai Kiado´, Budapest, 1983. V. Gutmann and E. Wychera. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. Lett. 2:257 (1966). U. Mayer, V. Gutmann, and W. Gerger. Monatsch. Chem. 106:1235 (1975). D. A. Owensby, A. J. Parker, and J. W. Diggle. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 96:2682 (1974). E. Grunwald and S. Winstein. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 70:846 (1948). E. M. Kosower. An Introduction to Physical Organic Chemistry, Wiley, New York, 1968, p. 259. K. Dimroth, C. Reichardt, T. Siepmann, and F. Bohlmann. Liebigs Ann. Chem. 661:1 (1963). C. Reichardt. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 4:29 (1965).
Ion Solvation and Resolvation
49
28. R. W. Taft, N. J. Pienta, M. J. Kamlet, and E. M. Arnett. J. Org. Chem. 46:661 (1981). 29. T. Osakai, H. Katano, K. Maeda, S. Himeno, and A. Saito. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 66:1111 (1993) and references therein. 30. T. Osakai, S. Himeno, A. Saito, K. Maeda, and H. Katano. J. Electroanal. Chem. 360:299 (1993). 31. T. Osakai, S. Himeno, and A. Saito. Bunseki Kagaku 43:1 (1994) (in Japanese with English abstract). 32. T. Kurucsev, A. M. Sargeson, and B. O. West. J. Phys. Chem. 61:1567 (1957). 33. T. Osakai and K. Ebina. J. Electroanal. Chem. 412:1 (1996). 34. R. S. Mulliken. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 74:811 (1952). 35. J. Rais, M. Kyrs˘ , and M. Pivon˘kova´. J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 30:611 (1968). 36. S. Motomizu, K. Toˆei, and T. Iwachido. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 42:1006 (1969). 37. M. Kawasaki, K. Toˆei, and T. Iwachido. Chem. Lett. 417 (1972). 38. T. Iwachido, M. Minami, A. Sadakane, and K. Toˆei. Chem. Lett. 1511 (1977). 39. T. Iwachido, M. Minami, M. Kimura, A. Sadakane, M. Kawasaki, and K. Toˆei. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 53:703 (1980). 40. Y. Yamamoto, T. Tarumoto, and T. Tarui. Chem. Lett. 459 (1972). 41. Y. Yamamoto, T. Tarumoto, and T. Tarui. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 46:1466 (1973). 42. T. Kenjo and R. M. Diamond. J. Phys. Chem. 76:2454 (1972). 43. T. Kenjo and R. M. Diamond. J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 36:183 (1974). 44. S. Kusakabe, M. Shinoda, and K. Kusafuka. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 62:333 (1989). 45. S. Kusakabe and M. Arai. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 69:581 (1996). 46. T. Osakai, A. Ogata, and K. Ebina. J. Phys. Chem. B. 101:8341 (1997). 47. C. Sa´nchez, E. Leiva, S. A. Dassie, and A. M. Baruzzi. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 71:549 (1998). 48. A. Ogata, Y. Tsujino, and T. Osakai. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2:247 (2000). 49. T. Osakai and K. Ebina. J. Phys. Chem. B 102:5691 (1998). 50. T. Kakiuchi, M. Nakanishi, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 61:1845 (1988). 51. R. D. Shannon. Acta Cryst. A32:751 (1976). 52. E. J. King. J. Phys. Chem. 74:4590 (1970). 53. H. Yokoyama, K. Shinozaki, S. Hattori, F. Miyazaki. and M. Goto. J. Mol. Lig. 65/66:357 (1995). 54. H. Yokoyama, K. Shinozaki, S. Hattori, and F. Miyazaki. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 70:2357 (1997). 55. H. D. B. Jenkins and K. P. Thakur. J. Chem. Educ. 56:576 (1979). 56. Y. Marcus, in Ref. 2, pp. 46–47; for IO 4 , see A. F. Kapustinskii. Quat. Rev. 10:283 (1956). 57. J. T. Edward. J. Chem. Educ. 47:261 (1970). 58. A. Karpfen and P. Schuster, in Ref. 4, pp. 265–312. 59. T. Osakai, K. Maeda, K. Ebina, H. Hayamizu, M. Hoshino, K. Muto, and S. Himeno. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 70:2473 (1997). 60. E. R. Nightingale, Jr. J Phys. Chem. 63:1381 (1959). 61. J. Koryta, P. Vanysek, and M. Br˘ ezina. J. Electroanal. Chem. 75:211 (1977). 62. V. Marec˘ek and Z. Samec. Anal. Chim. Acta 151:265 (1983). 63. T. Osakai, T. Kakutani, Y. Nishiwaki, and M. Senda. Bunseki Kagaku 32:E81 (1983). 64. T. Kakutani, T. Osakai, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 56:991 (1983). 65. Z. Samec, V. Marec˘ek, and D. Homolka. Faraday Discuss. Chem. Soc. 77:197 (1984). 66. D. Homolka and H. Wendt. Ber. Bunsen-Ges. Phys. Chem. 89:1075 (1985). 67. T. Kakutani, Y. Nishiwaki, and M. Senda. Bunseki Kagaku 33:E175 (1984). 68. B. Hundhammer and S. Wilke. J. Electroanal. Chem. 266:133 (1989). 69. T. Osakai and K. Muto. Anal. Sci. 14:157 (1998). 70. S. Kihara, M. Suzuki, K. Maeda, K. Ogura, and M. Matsui. J. Electroanal. Chem. 210:147 (1986). 71. T. Ohkouchi, T. Kakutani, and M. Senda. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 25:81 (1991). 72. http://dcwww.epfl.ch/cgi-bin/LE/DB/InterrDB.pl.
3 Electroelastic Instabilities in Double Layers and Membranes MICHAEL B. PARTENSKII and PETER C. JORDAN Department of Chemistry, Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts
I.
INTRODUCTION
Electrical double layers and membranes have certain common features. Both are quasitwo-dimensional structures. In both, variation of applied voltage influences the distribution of charge as well as the structural parameters (effective thickness). And in both cases coupling between the electric field and these parameters can lead to instabilities and phase transitions. These instabilities may be described and understood using an electroelastic metaphor first introduced in 1973 by Crowley [1] in relation to membrane breakdown (‘‘electroporation’’). Although this model failed to quantitatively describe the onset of instability at small voltage with little deformation, it generated significant interest in studies of the electroelasticity of membranes. In some aspects, the electrical response of membranes is similar to the action of an external pressure (such as osmotic stress). But it also has features with no direct analogy to mechanical effects, such as specific interaction of an applied voltage with surface undulations which can cause instabilities in membranes. Similar phenomena appear equally important in the behavior of electrochemical interfaces where electrical stress affects structural parameters of electrical double layers. These are most closely related to the question of whether, for electrical double layers, it is possible for the differential capacitance, C, to be negative. It has been shown that the prediction of C < 0 in some models of double layers has a direct analogy in the behavior of the elastic capacitors. And, as in membranes, it is also related to possible instabilities and interfacial phase transitions at the interfaces. This chapter is devoted to the behavior of double layers and inclusion-free membranes. Section II treats two simple models, the ‘‘elastic dimer’’ and the ‘‘elastic capacitor.’’ They help to demonstrate the origin of electroelastic instabilities. Section III considers electrochemical interfaces. We discuss theoretical predictions of negative capacitance and how they may be related to reality. For this purpose we introduce three sorts of electrical control and show that this anomaly is most likely to arise in models which assume that the charge density on the electrode is uniform and can be controlled. This ‘‘control’’ is a convenient theoretical construct, but in real applications only the total charge or the applied voltage can be fixed. We then show that predictions of C < 0 under control may indicate that in reality the symmetry breaks. Such interfaces undergo a transition to a nonuniform state; the initial uniformity assumption is erroneous. Most 51
52
Partenskii and Jordan
of this discussion is couched in terms of the electroelastic analogy. Section IV describes electroelastic phenomena in inclusion free membranes with possible relation to instabilities. We first treat the Crowley model (a rigid interface). We then consider the ‘‘hydrodynamic,’’ ‘‘electroporative,’’ and ‘‘smectic bilayer’’ perspectives on the initiation of an electroelastic instability. Finally, we describe some attempts to modify the smectic model to account for the basic experimental observation: membrane rupture occurs at low voltages with little electrostriction. These are based on the idea that nonlocality of the elastic moduli softens the symmetrical modes thus enhancing thickness fluctuations at short wavelengths. Possible consequences of this hypothesis for different membrane properties are discussed.
II.
ELECTROELASTIC INSTABILITIES. SIMPLE EXAMPLES
A.
Charges on a Spring (Elastic Dimer)
The nature of the instabilities related to coupling of electrical and elastic degrees of freedom can be illustrated by a very simple example. Consider two charges, q and q, separated by a spring. The corresponding Hamiltonian is H¼
q2 þ E0 ðlÞ 40 l
ð1Þ
where E0 is the bond energy. In an harmonic approximation we write E0 ¼
K ðl l0 Þ2 2
ð2Þ
where K is a ‘‘spring constant,’’ l is the distance between charges, and l0 is the length of the isolated spring. For the sake of convenience we use dimensionless units W¼
H Kl02
q Q ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 40 Kl03
z¼
l l0
ð3Þ
so that W ¼
Q2 1 þ ð1 zÞ2 2 z
ð4Þ
Global behavior of the system is determined by a single parameter, the reduced charge Q; relative distance z is the internal variable, defined by the equilibrium condition @W ¼0 @z
which follows from
@H ¼0 @l
ð5Þ
Before proceeding further we analyze the behavior of the system by viewing its energy surface WðQ; zÞ (Fig. 1). At short distances, z ! 0, the elastic force cannot compete with the electrostatic attraction and W ! 1 for any Q 6¼ 0. For sufficiently smallp jQj a local ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi minimum 0 < z 1 exists. It disappears when Q reaches its critical value Qc ¼ 4=27 and z has contracted to zc ¼ 2=3. Both Qc and zc can be defined by solving Eq. (5) together with the marginal equilibrium condition. As we see, ‘‘molecular equilibrium’’ at finite z, if its exists, is always local, while globally, charges are stable only in direct contact (the collapsed state). In reality, however, additional short-range repulsion would prevent the system from collapsing. Figure 2 incorporates this additional interaction. We see that the
Electroelastic Instabilities
FIG. 1 Energy of elastically coupled charges.
FIG. 2 Energy of elastically coupled charges with an additional short-range repulsion term.
53
54
Partenskii and Jordan
‘‘molecule’’ becomes bistable, and Qc now corresponds to charge at which the barrier between the two minima disappears. B.
Elastic Capacitors
Our elastic molecule illustrates the onset of instability. However, conditions when charges can be smoothly controlled by the observer are hard to achieve. In applications and studies of interfacial phenomena the controlled electrical variable is usually a voltage V across the interfaces rather than charges involved in their polarization. The distributions of charges composing electrical double layers of different origin can be approximated by ‘‘interfacial capacitors.’’ As we will see in Section III, the distributions of charges are flexible and strongly affected by the applied voltage. As a result, not only the charge q on the ‘‘plates’’ of interfacial capacitors, but also the effective ‘‘gap’’ between the plates depends on V. This naturally leads to ‘‘relaxing gap’’ capacitors, which in many cases can be described as ‘‘elastic capacitors’’ (ECs). The energy of an EC under fixed voltage is [2] H ¼ H0 ðq; lÞ qV
ð6Þ
where H0 ðq; lÞ ¼
q2 l þ AE0 ðlÞ 20 A
ð7Þ
is the energy of isolated capacitor with charge q, A is the surface area of its ‘‘plates,’’ and l are the effective dielectric constant and the gap width respectively, and E0 is the elastic energy per unit area. The contribution qV in Eq. (6) is responsible for charge exchange between the potentiostat (battery) and the capacitor. The equilibrium conditions @H ¼0 @l
@H ¼0 @q
@2 H >0 @2 l
ð8Þ ð9Þ
define the equilibrium gap lðVÞ and equilibrium charge qðVÞ. Notice that Eq. (7) assumes that charge distributions are uniform. The validity of this assumption will be discussed in Section III. In the uniform case all properties can be equally well described by the surface charge density q ð10Þ ¼ A In equilibrium, as follows from Eqs. (7) and (8) 2 @E þ 0¼0 20 @l
ð11Þ
l ¼V 0
ð12Þ
Equation (12) leads directly to an expression of H through V and l: ! 0 V 2 þ E0 ðlÞ A H¼ 2l
ð13Þ
Electroelastic Instabilities
55
Equation (13) becomes equivalent to Eq. (1) if q2 is replaced by V 2 =2. In the units of Eq. (3), introducing the dimensionless voltage, V ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Kl03 =0
ð14Þ
and using Eq. (2), we have H¼
2 1 þ ð1 zÞ2 2z 2
ð15Þ
From the previous analysis it follows that the harmonic elastic capacitor collapses when approaches its critical value rffiffiffi 2 2 and zc ¼ 2=3 ð16Þ c ¼ 3 3 C.
General Observations
Several questions must be addressed with respect to the simple examples just outlined. Despite their formal similarity, it is important to keep in mind that the first instability describes an isolated system, where charge is a controlled variable. In contrast, the EC as introduced becomes unstable only in contact with a potentiostat (battery), when V is fixed and charge can change. Thus, the collapse of an EC leads to infinite growth of q 1=l, accompanied by electric current from a battery to the EC. If isolated, the EC remains stable for all values of q corresponding to l > 0, as can be seen from Eq. (7). The major difference from the elastic dimer is that electrical energy of an isolated EC is positive and finite for all q and l while for the dimer it goes to 1 when l ! 0. In the next section we reexamine this result and show that the uniformity assumption for the charge distribution across the plates of a capacitor can fail, and this can influence the stability condition for an isolated EC. Another observation should be made with respect to the term ‘‘elastic’’ in describing interfacial capacitors. It was originally introduced by Crowley [1] for membranes and reflects the compressibility of lipid layers which behave in some respects like an elastic film. Its relation to electrochemical interfaces is less obvious. Consider an interface between a metal electrode and an electrolyte. As we will see in Section III, the effective gap of the interfacial capacitor is the distance between the centers of mass of the electronic, ‘‘e,’’ and ionic, ‘‘i,’’ charge density distributions ne;i : l ¼ x i xe Ð þ1 xe;i ¼
1
ð17Þ ni;e ðxÞx dx e;i
ð18Þ
where e ¼ i ¼ , the surface density of electron charge. Both distributions depend on (and V) and l usually changes with charging. Consequently, the interface may be represented as a ‘‘relaxing gap’’ capacitor. Consider a hypothetical attempt to alter the equilibrium electron and ion density profiles, causing the displacement of xe and xi from their equilibrium positions. The corresponding increase in free energy can be expressed through the effective restoring force opposing the variation of l from its equilibrium value. In turn, the restoring force can usually be expressed in terms of an effective elastic constant. This is where the analogy with the EC comes into play.
56
Partenskii and Jordan
The ‘‘elasticity’’ can be related to very different contributions to the energy of the interface. It includes classical and nonclassical (exchange, correlation) electrostatic interactions in ion–electron systems, entropic effects, Lennard–Jones and van der Waals-type interactions between solvent molecules and electrode, etc. Therefore, use of the macroscopic term should not hide its relation to ‘‘microscopic’’ reality. On the other hand, microscopic behavior could be much richer than the predictions of such simplified electroelastic models. Some of these differences will be discussed below.
III.
NEGATIVE DIFFERENTIAL CAPACITANCE AND ELECTRICAL DOUBLE LAYER STABILITY
A.
Historical Review
The traditional treatment of a double layer at electrode–electrolyte interfaces is based on its separation into two series contributions: the compact (‘‘Helmholtz’’) layer and the diffusive (‘‘dif’’) layer, so that the inverse capacitance is 1 1 1 Cdl ¼ CH þ Cdif
ð19Þ
Both terms affect whether the double layer capacitance can become negative. 1. ‘‘Molecular Capacitor’’ (MC) and the Cooper–Harrison Catastrophe The problem of negative capacitance first arose in theoretical studies of CH based on socalled ‘‘molecular models.’’ Molecular or ‘‘dipolar capacitor’’ models treat the layer of water molecules adjacent to a metal electrode as a lattice of point or finite-size dipoles [3,4]. Many studies have focused on the response of such a layer to electrode charging and comparison with the measurements of the compact layer capacitance, CH ðÞ using the technique suggested by Grahame [5,6]. Much of this work has been inspired by the ‘‘Cooper–Harrison (CH) catastrophe,’’ the prediction of negative CH ðÞ in molecular models of the compact layer. Here we only briefly discuss the origin of this anomaly (see Ref. 7 for more details and references). (a) General Characteristics of an MC. Consider the isolated MC with a charge density on its plates. Focusing on the capacitance C (the index ‘‘H’’ is omitted), we first introduce the potential drop across the MC as
¼ F0 d þ d
ð20Þ
where* F0 ¼ 4
ð21Þ
is the external field created by the plates of MC, and
d ¼ 4Px
Px ¼ Ns hpx i
ð22Þ
in which hpx i is the average normal-to-plane projection of the dipolar moment, and Ns is the number of dipoles per unit area. Using the definition of differential capacitance (per unit area),
* Unlike the rest of the chapter, here we adopt Gaussian electrostatic units which are typically used in the literature devoted to molecular capacitors and double layer theory.
Electroelastic Instabilities
C¼
d
d
57
ð23Þ
we find 1 ¼ 4ðd 4 Þ 4C
ð24Þ
where ¼ Ns
dhpx i dF0
ð25Þ
is the susceptibility of the dipolar lattice. It follows from Eq. (24) that if it were possible that d=4
ð26Þ
then it would be possible for C to become negative. (b) The MC in a Mean Field Approximation (MFA). In the majority of papers including the original CH paper [8], the MC was treated in Ising-type n-state models with dipoles perpendicular to the plates: px ¼ psx where the vector sx is limited to equally spaced values between 1 and 1. We consider the simplest ‘‘spin 1/2’’ model n ¼ 2 (Fig. 3), a choice justified by the fact that the appearance of the CH catastrophe is independent of n. The local field acting on a specific dipole in a lattice is F ¼ F0 þ Fd þ F 0
ð27Þ
0
where the field F describes interaction between a dipole and its own images. Interaction with this field does not depend on the dipolar orientation and can be omitted [7]. The field Fd created by the rest of the dipolar lattice has been a subject of considerable controversy. Following most authors, we restrict analysis to the MFA assuming that all dipoles except one have moments equal to their mean value hpx i. Then, Fd ¼
nL Jhsx i p
ð28Þ
where J ¼ p2 =a3 is the interaction energy between antiparallel nearest neighbors, a is the lattice constant, and nL is the effective number of nearest neighbors. For a bare lattice where dipolar fields are not shielded by the plates of capacitor, nL equals X 3 n0L ¼ a3 r1i ð29Þ i
is 9 and 11 for square and hexagonal lattices respectively. Focusing on the CH catastrophe we notice from Eq. (26) that the most ‘‘dangerous’’ point is where is largest. In the MC models considered this obviously corresponds to ¼ 0; increasing orients dipoles and makes them less susceptible to variation of the n0L
FIG. 3 Molecular capacitor in ‘‘spin 1/2’’ model.
58
Partenskii and Jordan
external field (in the limit ! 1 the lattice is totally frozen and ! 0). In this ‘‘zero charge’’ point for ‘‘spin 1/2’’ [8] we have ¼
Ja3 Ns kT þ JnL
ð30Þ
from which is clear that two factors oppose the orientation of dipoles in the MC: temperature and dipolar interactions. The latter occurs because in the Ising model considered, the interaction energy between two lattice dipoles is minimal when dipoles are opposed. Equation (30) emphasizes the importance of the effective number of nearest neighbors; with p, Ns , and T fixed, the susceptibility becomes larger for smaller nL . (c) Effective Number of Nearest Neighbors and the CH Catastrophe. It follows from Eqs. (30) and (26) that C becomes negative if nL <
4a3 Ns kT J d
ð31Þ
pffiffiffi For a hexagonal lattice, Nshex ¼ 2= 3a2 ; choosing for water dipoles at room temperature J 2kT [3], and assuming a ¼ d, this leads (see Ref. 3) to nhex L < 14:2
ð32Þ
As mentioned before, for a bare lattice nhex L 11. CH made the apparently reasonable assumption that screening of the dipolar field by the conductive plates of the MC should below this value, thus insuring that Eq. (32) is satisfied, leading to the decrease nhex L catastrophe. (d) Summation Over the Dipolar Images and Resolution of the CH Catastrophe. To account for the screening of the dipolar lattice by the plates of the MC it is convenient to use the method of images. Every original dipole in this approach creates an infinite chain of similarly oriented image dipoles, with period d. As a result, calculation of local fields in MFA requires summation over the infinite lattice of equal dipoles, hpx i, excluding the images corresponding to the ‘‘original’’ dipole. Due to the conditional convergence of the corresponding series* [9], the result depends on the order in which the sums are calculated. This ambiguity is the cause of the CH catastrophe. Two ways of carrying out the summation have been discussed [10]. 1.
2.
The ‘‘chain’’ (or c-) approach starts with the chain of dipoles normal to the original plane, including an original dipole located in a lattice site and the infinite set of its images. The field of each chain decays exponentially with distance , much faster than the 1=3 law corresponding to the bare lattice. It leads to a decrease in the effective number of nearest neighbors and seemingly gives rise to the CH catastrophe. It also seems to justify a suggestion that if the lattice constant a is large enough, the CH catastrophe becomes inevitable [11]. The ‘‘plane’’ (p-) approach starts with the infinite plane of dipoles, with further summation over the infinite stack of these planes (including the original lattice and all its images). As a result,
* The dipolar contributions to the local field diverges if the terms are replaced by their absolute values.
Electroelastic Instabilities
F pl ¼ F ch þ Fu
59
Fu ¼
d d
ð33Þ
Surprisingly, in addition to the ‘‘chain’’ contribution, F ch , the local field calculated in the p-approach also contains the uniform part, Fu ¼ 4Px =d. This last term noticeably increases the effective number of nearest neighbors so that the CH catastrophe disappears. But does the catastrophe really exist in the chain approach? To underline the problem we used the word ‘‘seemingly’’ with respect to the appearance of the CH anomaly. We now consider this more carefully. Notice that in the chain summation each dipole is treated as if it were inserted between the infinite plates of capacitor. No matter how many dipoles we have, they do not affect the potential drop across the gap of the MC. It can only mean that the average polarization, Px , in Eqs. (20) and (22) equals zero. In its turn, Px is proportional to Ns Ad =A, where A and Ad are the areas of the plate and of the dipolar array respectively. This means that the chain approach is valid when Ad =A ! 0. In other words, even for the infinitely large dipolar lattice, its size is infinitesimally small in comparison to A. Since in this picture Px ! 0, according to Eq. (24) the capacitance C ! 4=d > 0 and the CH catastrophe disappears. The p-approach corresponds to Ad =A ! 1 with both A and Ad ! 1. In this case the CH catastrophe disappears because of the uniform contribution which increases the effective number of nearest neighbors. In other words, both summation procedures are valid.* They describe different physical situations. In the c-summation the size of the dipolar array is much smaller than the size of the capacitor, while in the p-approach both are equal. One can imagine an infinite number of different summation orders corresponding to different relations between A and Ad , leading to results between the p- and c-limits. To solve the problem unambiguously, one must consider a finite dipolar lattice between finite plates, which requires accounting for edge effects and makes the whole problem much more complicated. (e) Conclusion, and a Further Question. We have seen that the CH catastrophe arises as a result of inconsistencies in the treatment of the electric field and the potential in the molecular capacitor. Were they analyzed consistently, then, at least in the framework of Ising models and the MFA, a catastrophe would not appear and the capacitance of an MC would always be positive. But another question arises. Does this imply that the capacitance of a double layer can never become negative? Before addressing this question we will analyze some other occurrences of the C < 0 problem in the theory of electrified interfaces. 2.
Diffuse Electron and Ionic Distributions in a Double Layer and the Problem of C < 0 Statistical mechanical and microscopic theories of the double layer have often been intensively reviewed. Our focus is only on features related to the problem of negative C.
* The following example helps in visualization of the difference between the two ways of summation. Consider the potential difference ðL; RÞ ¼ ðLÞ ðLÞ between points L and L on the axis of a uniform dipolar disk (where Px is the surface dipole moment density) in the limit of infinite R and L. Since ðL; RÞ ¼ 4Px ½1 L2 =ðL2 þ R2 Þ, limR!1 limL!1 ðL; RÞ ¼ 0, while limL!1 limR!1 ðL; RÞ ¼ 4Px . The first result obviously corresponds to the c-approach, while the second one corresponds to the p-approach.
60
Partenskii and Jordan
(a) Diffuse Models of Ionic Distributions in Electrolytes. The first model of the diffuse ionic distribution in electrolytes was developed by Gouy and Chapman (GC) many years ago. In this and similar ‘‘local models’’ the charge density is considered to be a local function of the potential ðxÞ, nlocal ðxÞ ¼ f ½ ðxÞ
ð34Þ
In such models capacitance can never become negative [12]. The GC model for a 1 : 1 electrolyte is illustrative: Cdif ¼ aðb þ 2 Þ
ð35Þ
where a and b are positive and depend on temperature, ionic concentration, and bulk dielectric constant. However, the question of C < 0 inevitably emerges in theoretical studies of the diffuse layer that go beyond the local approach (see, e.g., Refs. 13–18). This anomaly is related to some specific properties of ionic distributions. (b) Properties of the Ionic Distribution Which Can Cause a Capacitance Anomaly. Let us examine the features of an ionic distribution that can lead to Cdif < 0. Quite generally, the potential drop across the double layer, ð1Þ ð1Þ (where x ¼ 1 and x ¼ 1 correspond to the bulk electrode and electrolyte respectively) can be represented as ¼ 4 ½xi ðÞ xe ðÞ 4Px
ð36Þ
Then, using Eq. (23) we find 1 dl dPx ¼ lðÞ þ 4C d d
ð37Þ
where the effective gap of the interfacial capacitor, l, is defined by Eq. (17). Focusing on the effect of the ionic distribution, we consider the so-called primitive model where ions occupy a region of uniform dielectric constant . In addition we temporarily ignore the diffuseness of the electronic distribution (the perfect conductor model) assuming xe ¼ const: ¼ 0. Then for the diffuse layer capacitance ð1 ð 1 @ 1 ð0Þ ð38Þ ¼ n ðxÞx dx n ðxÞx dx=
4Cdif ðÞ @ 0 0 Here we assume ð1Þ ¼ 0 and choose > 0. It is now clear that differential capacitance becomes negative at some value of if the centroid of the ionic distribution induced by a small variation becomes negative. Given that ions do not penetrate the region x < 0, this can only happen if nðxÞ is a nonmonotonic function of variable polarity. However, the total electrolyte charge density, nðxÞ, is not necessarily oscillating, and it can even be monotonic. Figures 4–6 illustrate the various possibilities. nðxÞ represents a nonmonotonous charge density corresponding to some variation of . It is a function constructed to reflect two features of the ionic shielding of the electrode charge. Ð1 1. Neutrality condition (required): 0 nðxÞ dx ¼ . 2. ‘‘Charge condensation’’ near the electrode (quite a typical feature, which is necessary but not sufficient for attaining C < 0): charging is accompanied by increased charge density near the electrode at the expense of some depletion in the tail regions of the ionic distribution. Figure 4 depicts a generalized Raleigh [19] model originally designed to explain extremely high values of interfacial capacitance in contacts of metals and solid electrolytes, silver-ion conductors (such as AgCl). This is a two-layer model satisfying conditions 1 and
Electroelastic Instabilities
61
FIG. 4 Induced potential drop ðxÞ in the Raleigh model of the ionic distribution. k ¼ 0:2 (curve 1), 0.33 (curve 2), and 0.4 (curve 3). Gray area shows the Raleigh distribution of the induced charge with a ¼ 0:3 nm and k ¼ 0:33 (see text) which corresponds to curve 2. The total induced charge is normalized
2. Charge densities in the layers are n1 at x < a and kn1 at a < x < 2a; the layer thickness a and the dimensionless constant k < 1 are the parameters of the model. Using this to mimic the distribution induced by , we find that n1 ¼ =að1 kÞ. The center of mass of this distribution is ¼ xRaleigh i
n1 a2 að1 3kÞ ð1 3kÞ ¼ 2 1k
ð39Þ
xi becomes negative for k > 1=3. Figure 4 demonstrates that C becomes negative when xi is negative. This transition is obvious from the behavior of ðxÞ [see Eq. (38)]. For curve 1 (k ¼ 0:2) the additional barrier ð0Þ ð 0:75Þ has a ‘‘normal’’ positive sign; for curve 2 (k ¼ 1=3) this barrier disappears, and for curve 3 ðk ¼ 0:4) it becomes negative ( 0:5). Figure 5 presents a more realistic picture where nðxÞ is continuous. QðxÞ is the total ionic charge accumulated between x ¼ 0 and the point x:
FIG. 5 Model-induced charge density profile nðxÞ (curve 1), QðxÞ (curve 2), and ðxÞ (curve 3) in the diffuse layer ( ¼ 0:2, dimensionless units).
62
Partenskii and Jordan
QðxÞ ¼
ðx
nðx 0 Þ dx 0
0
and ðxÞ ¼ 4½ þ QðxÞx þ
ðx
x 0 nðx 0 Þ dx 0
ð40Þ
0
It demonstrates an important feature promoting negative C: ‘‘overshielding’’ of the electrode charge in the adjacent region of electrolyte. This is the cause of depletion in the more distant parts of the double layer causing effective displacement of the charge centroid towards the electrode.* Figure 6 demonstrates the possibility that if the initial potential profile 0 ðxÞ corresponding to some 0 is monotonic (GC-type), then a small additional nonmonotonic variation in ðxÞ arising from the additional charge density of Fig. 5 and leading to C < 0 may still leave the total potential profile ðxÞ monotonic. The same is true for the total charge density nðxÞ. This speculation mimics the results of numerical experiments described in Refs. 17 and 18. The same can be true for charge density profiles. It demonstrates that charge density oscillations are neither necessary nor sufficient to give rise to negative C. 3. Negative Capacitance in Primitive Models of Electrolyte A possible reason that the problem of C < 0 did not receive much attention was the assertion [15] (BLH) that such an anomaly was forbidden. The proof was based on the statistical mechanical analysis of the primitive model of electrolytes between two oppositely charged planes, and . It was noticed in Ref. 10 that the BLH analysis missed a very simple contribution to the Hamiltonian, direct interaction between the charged walls, 2L 2 (L is the distance between the walls). With proper choice of the Hamiltonian the condition on the capacitance would be C > 2=L. It simply means that due to ionic shielding of the electric field, the capacitance exceeded its ‘‘geometrical’’ value corresponding to the electrolyte-free dielectric gap.
FIG. 6 Potential profile for 0 (curve 1) and 0 þ (curve 2).
* Such a behavior can represent, for instance, condensation near an electrode of a monotonous charge density n ðxÞ following a variation of [18].
Electroelastic Instabilities
63
This analysis has been developed further [20–22]. At the same time attention focused on the analogous anomaly in the theory and simulations of the double layer [17,18]. Progress was, however, slightly misdirected by the assertion [21] that there are no restrictions on the sign of C, regardless of the model considered or the choice of experimental conditions. In what follows we will show that there are severe restrictions strongly limiting the possibility of capacitance anomalies. But here we only stress that it has never been proven that negative capacitance is forbidden for any model of an electrolyte at a uniformly charged interface. 4. Contribution of Metal Electrons and the Negative Capacitance Problem In the early 1980s it became clear that metal electrons play an important role in the electrical response at metal–electrolyte interfaces. Different aspects have been extensively reviewed [23–27]. Here we only briefly discuss the problem of negative capacitance, and how it arose in these studies. Although it was clear that separation of an interface into ‘‘surface’’ and ‘‘bulk’’ components as in Eq. (19) is artificial and must disappear in a consistent microscopic analysis, electronic effects were initially discussed in terms of a ‘‘compact layer’’ and its capacitance CH . It was apparent early on that the electrons strongly influence double layer properties [28–33]. In traditional models of an electrified interface, metal electrons are artificially localized within the electrode. This leads to misinterpretation of the electronic influences on the compact layer. CH in those models would always be smaller than its ‘‘ideal conductor’’ limit (with electrode charge spread over an infinitesimally thin region at the electrode surface x ¼ 0) IC ¼ H ð41Þ 4CH xH where xH is the effective width of the compact layer, and H is the effective permittivity. Self-consistent analysis of electronic effects altered this simple view substantially. By analogy to Eqs. (36) and (37), compact layer capacitance in the simplest model, accounting only for electronic effects, is now defined by 1 dx ¼ xH xe e 4CH d
ð42Þ
It was first noticed in Ref. 31 that at moderate negative the condition xe
dxe xH d
ð43Þ
may be fulfilled for contacts of metals with solid electrolytes (silver-ion conductors), so that CH ðÞ can become negative. Similar anomalies have been found in contacts of metals with solvents [34,35], results which have not been easily accepted. Moreover, in some calculations they have been carefully avoided, partially in the belief that they are prohibited by the BLH theorem (for a discussion see Refs. 7 and 36). 5.
Electroelastic Models. Proof that Negative Capacitance is Admissible for Uniformly Charged Interface Models Elastic capacitors (Section II) are very useful as ‘‘electromechanical’’ analogs of microscopic interfacial capacitors [22,31,34]. But most importantly, they demonstrate that nega-
64
Partenskii and Jordan
tive capacitance can coexist with interfacial equilibrium and stability as long as the total charge is fixed and the charge density is kept uniform. Under these conditions, corresponding to so-called -control [37], the elastic capacitor is described by the Hamiltonian, Eq. (7). In dimensionless units this becomes 1 W ¼ s2 z þ ð1 zÞ2 2
ð44Þ
where s ¼ ð4=kl0 Þ2 , the dimensionless charge density. Other units are the same as in Eq. (3). From the equilibrium conditions for fixed s it follows that [37]: zðsÞ ¼ 1
s2 2
vðsÞ ¼ s
s2 3
3 C 1 ¼ 1 s2 2
ð45Þ
and C1 0 for jsj > s0 ¼ ð2=3Þ1=2 . At the same time, @2 W=@l 2 ¼ 1 > 0, and in this region the system is stable. Thus capacitance under -control can be negative. And as this is possible for one simple model, it should also be possible for some other models obeying the same conditions of -control.
B.
The Sign of C and Different Types of Electrical Control
In the analysis of molecular capacitors, the diffuse layer and elastic capacitors, we have always assumed that the electrode charge density could be controlled. Under such conditions it is generally possible for C to become negative while the system remains stable. For example, contraction of the gap z in an elastic capacitor proceeds smoothly with growing until the plates come in contact, while C becomes negative for z < 2=3. At the same time, as shown in Section II for an EC connected to a battery, the EC collapses after z 0:6 is reached. How can these seemingly contradictory results be reconciled? And how can -control be related to reality? Is C < 0 observable? These questions are addressed in this section. 1. Three Types of Control (a) -Control. In the vast majority of studies in double layer theory, the charge density is considered an independent control variable. This forms the framework where the question of negative C originated. But this assumption must be treated very carefully. In practice there is no way to control . Therefore, -control is a purely theoretical construct. It works perfectly well only if an interface ‘‘chooses’’ to remain uniform.* (b) Isolated Capacitor, q-Control. In real experiments with ‘‘ideally polarizable’’{ interfaces there are basically two options: either the cell is isolated, or it is connected to a potentiostat (battery). For an isolated capacitor the total charge on the electrode is fixed (‘‘q-control’’). If the system remains uniform, then - and q-controls are equivalent, being defined by Eq. (10). However, when for any reason a uniform distribution becomes unstable, then only q-control is a valid description of the isolated interface.
* We are not describing microscopic structural nonuniformity, which is discussed in another chapter of this book, and assume that the electrode surface is uniform. { We exclude situations where there is electric current across the interface which would cause some additional complications.
Electroelastic Instabilities
65
(c) Global System, -Control. Now consider a cell connected to a battery. Usually, the subsystem is immersed between two metal electrodes. Here electrical control of the cell is maintained via the electronic subsystems of the electrodes [38]. The real controlled variable is the difference between the electrochemical potentials of electrons of both electrodes, 1 and 2 . To avoid the complexities due to contact phenomena (‘‘Volta potential’’) we assume both electrodes are made of the same metal and therefore have the same chemical potentials (Fermi energies). The difference between chemical potentials equals the voltage:
¼
1 2 e
ð46Þ
In this case the voltage across the interface is the actual controlled variable and we deal with -control. 2.
Stability Conditions
(a) C is Nonnegative Under -Control. The transition from an isolated to a global system is accompanied by transformation of the Hamiltonian [see Eq. (6)]: H ¼ H0 q
ð47Þ
It is generally true (for a discussion see Ref. 39) that for Hamiltonians of the form H ¼ H0 XF the susceptibility is 2 1 ðX hXiÞ 0 @X=@F ¼ kT
ð48Þ
ð49Þ
where h i denotes a statistical average with the Hamiltonian, Eq. (48). The transition from isolated ðH0 Þ to global ðHÞ belongs to this class [see Eq. (6)], which is why capacitance under -control is defined as 2 @hi A ¼ ð hiÞ C¼ ð50Þ @
kT [40–43] and is strictly nonnegative. (b) Isolated Capacitor. Suppose now that the charge q is fixed. As mentioned, if could be kept uniform, then C can unconditionally become negative. The elastic capacitors we have studied are examples of systems for which - and q-controls are equivalent. Indeed, with plates rigid, any nonuniform redistribution of charge density can only increase the EC’s energy, and therefore cannot become stable. It would be different if the plates of an EC were somewhat deformable. Transition to a nonuniform state could then occur due to coupling between the electrical and ‘‘elastic’’ degrees of freedom. In reality, the electronic and ionic ‘‘plates’’ of an interfacial capacitor are never absolutely rigid. Therefore, a uniform distribution should always be tested with respect to its stability under some nonuniform perturbations. Recently [7] we constructed an example showing that interfacial flexibility can cause instability of the uniform state. Two elastic capacitors, C1 and C2 , were connected in parallel. The total charge was fixed, but it was allowed to redistribute between C1 and C2 . It was shown that if the interface was absolutely ‘‘soft’’, i.e., contraction of the two gaps was not coupled, the uniform distribution became unstable at precisely the point where the dimensionless charge density s reached the critical value, s0 ¼ ð2=3Þ1=2 . In other words, the uniform distribution became unstable at the point where, under control, C 1
66
Partenskii and Jordan
would have changed sign, so that the region with C < 0 is unacceptable for such interfaces. If, however, the Ci are coupled by a spring, then the stability region expands towards larger . We can also use another argument similar to one suggested by Nikitas [44]. Consider a small area of the interface. Given that this area is much smaller than the total area of contact, we may consider the rest of the interface a potentiostat which keeps the potential in the chosen area fixed. Then, the selected area can be considered under -control and its local capacitance cannot be negative. Therefore, the selected area is likely to undergo a transition simultaneously accepting some charge from the rest of the interface. As this reasoning can be applied to any area of the interface, it strongly suggests that in the isolated system, the uniform state becomes unstable in a region where -control predicts C < 0. C.
Summary
The question of the allowed sign of C was and remains a topic of discussion with significant contradictions. We suggest here that a major reason for these contradictions is that theoretical calculations for electrified interfaces are more easily carried out assuming a uniform electrode charge. Most studies have used this condition and, on some occasions, the restriction of -control took its toll. And those were exactly the situations where negative capacitance was predicted. The conviction that C should be strictly positive was so compelling that it has been typically believed to also apply under -control conditions (see Refs. 7 and 36 for a review). In some other cases, confusion was caused by an opposite extreme, dropping the restrictions on C < 0 even for -control. The discussion in Refs. 17 and 18 is illustrative. Torrie [17] presented very important results for grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations of an electrical double layer in 2 : 1 electrolytes. Those results provide very convincing evidence that C < 0 can occur under control. However, instead of analyzing the consequences of this fact for real systems, the author simply quotes the statement [21] that sign of C is not restricted, even for -control. Reliance on this result (see a critique in Ref. 22) simply ignored the problem and discouraged closer study of this system. Similarly, Wei et al. [18] made analogous predictions of C < 0 using hypernettedchain theory and incorporating molecular polarizability. However, the discussion was again restricted to the plausibility of negative C under -control. We suggest that results yielding C < 0 under -control have considerable importance, even though this type of control is unrealistic. They provide an important indication that in a system studied under q-control there is a range of where the plane uniform state is unstable, and the system undergoes a transition to a nonuniform state with charge density varying along the plane of electrode. Therefore, a computational paradigm could be formulated as follows: ‘‘If C becomes negative under -control, study the stability of this state towards ‘charge density’ perturbations. It is very possible that a phase transition to a nonuniform state appears.’’ The same system treated under -control becomes unstable in the vicinity of c (which corresponds to C ! 1) and can also undergo a phase transition (see Refs. 7 and 24 for discussion). But, unlike the isolated system under q-control, it can acquire some additional charge from the battery, so that the initial and final states would correspond to different values of q. The relation of transitions under q- and -control is another prospective area of research.
Electroelastic Instabilities
IV.
67
ELECTROELASTIC INTERACTIONS, STABILITY, AND BREAKDOWN IN MEMBRANES
Study of the mechanisms of membranes’ interaction with electric fields and the consequences for membrane stability and electroporation are very important both for better understanding of membranes’ properties and for different applications involving electrical manipulation of their behavior [45–48]. By controlling the electrical setup it is possible to influence transmembrane permeability and thus gain some control over processes such as targeted drug delivery, DNA transport into cells, etc. This is also important for development of ‘‘bioelectrochemical’’ sensors, where membranes are in contact with electrodes and applied voltage is used for monitoring changes caused by the interaction with the environment [49–52]. A.
Some Perspectives on Membrane Instability
1.
Crowley’s Model
The first model of membrane electroporation was suggested by Crowley [1]. In Crowley’s model the membrane is viewed as the isotropic elastic material. The necessary background for understanding its voltage-induced instability was discussed in Section II. Crowley’s approximation for the elasticity energy term in Eq. (7) is E0 ðhÞ ¼ Bh0 z½lnðzÞ 1 ¼ Ez½lnðzÞ 1
ð51Þ
where h ¼ hðÞ is the local thickness of the membrane ( is a two-dimensional radius vector in the membrane plane), h0 is its unperturbed value, B and E are the Young’s and ‘‘stretching’’ moduli, respectively. Using Eq. (51) with Eqs. (7) and (8), we find a relation between the membrane ‘‘contraction’’ factor, z ¼ h=h0 (h is the equilibrium thickness) and the voltage V [53]: E lnðzÞ ¼ pE h0
ð52Þ
where pE ðV; hÞ ¼
m 0 V 2 2h2
ð53Þ
is the electrical pressure as a function of the applied voltage and membrane thickness, and m is the membrane dielectric constant. sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ffi 2Eh0 1 ð54Þ ln V ¼ z z m 0 The critical membrane contraction can be derived in the manner outlined in Section II: zc ¼ expð0:5Þ 0:61
ð55Þ
which corresponds to critical membrane thinning 39%. The corresponding critical voltage, derived from Eq. (54), is sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Eh0 ð56Þ Vc 0:61 0 Equation (55) illustrates the major shortcoming of the original electroelastic model; it predicts membrane thinning of almost 40%, a result vastly different from the experimental
68
Partenskii and Jordan
finding that critical thinning never exceeds 2–3%. The computed critical voltage Vc equals 3:4 V and 5:9 V for representative ‘‘soft’’ [stearoyloleoylphosphatidyl-choline (SOPC)] and rigid [SOPC-cholesterol]) (SOPC:CHOL, 1 : 1)] membranes respectively (see Table 1 for the membrane parameters). Experimentally, the characteristic critical voltage Vexper depends on the duration of the applied electrical pulse. For brief pulses, 0:01 0:1 S, Vexper 1 V, and for longer ones ( 1 S) Vexper < 0:5 V. As a result, both the extent of the membrane contraction and the breakdown voltage predicted by Crowley’s model greatly exceed the experimental values.*
2. Hydrodynamic Models An alternative description of membrane stability has been based on hydrodynamic models, originally developed for liquid films in various environments [54–56]. Rupture of the film was rationalized by the instability of symmetrical ‘‘squeezing modes’’ (SQM) related to the thickness fluctuations. In the simplest form it can be described by a condition [54] ðd 2 Vdis =dh2 Þ0 < 22 =a2 where Vdis is the interaction contribution related to the ‘‘disjoining pressure,’’y is the surface tension and a is the characteristic size of the film. At the critical film thickness h0 , defined by this condition, the free energy cost of fluctuation due to the disjoining pressure is negative and overwhelms the positive contribution due to the surface tension at the wavelength ¼ a. When this happens, there is flow in the film from the thinner to the thicker regions leading to spontaneous growth of interfacial perturbations [57]. Similar instability is caused by the electrostatic attraction due to the applied voltage [56]. Subsequently the hydrodynamic approach was extended to viscoelastic films apparently designed to imitate membranes (see Refs. 58–60, and references therein). A number of studies [58, 61–64] concluded that the SQM could be unstable in such models at small voltages with low associated thinning, consistent with the experimental results. However, as has been shown [60, 65–67], the viscoelastic models leading to instability of the SQM did not account for the elastic force normal to the membrane plane which opposes thickness
TABLE 1 Elastic Parameters for Representative Soft (SOPC) and Rigid (SOPC : CHOL, 1 : 1) Membranes (Parameters E, Kc , and H0 are Taken from Refs. 117–119, , k1 and r1 from Ref. 53) Membrane ‘‘Soft’’ ‘‘Rigid’’
E (N/m)
Kc (J)
h0 (nm)
k1
r1
0.002 0.006
0:9 1017 2:4 1017
2.8 3.4
0.014 0.0087
0.1 0.1
0.06 0.04
* The values of stretching constant E that Crowley quoted in his original paper were substantially underestimated. As a result, his estimates of Vc were in better agreement with experiment. However, zc did not depend on E and reached the same subnormal value. It must be noted that critical thinning 1 zc almost universally reaches 30–40% for various models of the elastic energy [7]. y Disjoining pressure was attributed in Ref. 54 to the combined effect of van der Waals attraction and long-range electrostatic repulsion between similarly charged membrane surfaces.
Electroelastic Instabilities
69
fluctuations. The most obvious manifestation of this neglect is the prediction of zero breakdown voltage for vanishing surface tension [61]. Thus, this approach is more appropriate for liquid systems where thickness fluctuations arise from redistribution of molecules between surface and inner regions of the film. In addition, this model is also descriptive of ‘‘colored’’ lipid films. But it is hardly appropriate for lipid bilayers where steric interaction between the hydrocarbon tails of lipid molecules provides the quasielastic force opposing the thickness fluctuations, a force which stabilizes the bilayer. After the viscoelastic model is modified to account for this force [66], the original Crowley model problem recurs; breakdown requires extensive thinning (see reference 32 in Partenskii et al. [53]). 3. The Pore Formation Model The most developed and widely used approach to electroporation and membrane rupture views pore formation as a result of large nonlinear fluctuations, rather than loss of stability for small (linear) fluctuations. This theory of electroporation has been intensively reviewed [68–70], and we will discuss it only briefly. The approach is similar to the theory of crystal defect formation or to the phenomenology of nucleation in first-order phase transitions. The idea of applying this approach to pore formation in bimolecular free films can be traced back to the work of Deryagin and Gutop [71]. It was extended to describe spontaneous rupture of lipid bilayers [72,73] and electroporation [74] (see also Ref. 70 and references therein). The energy of the membrane with a virtual water-filled pore of a radius r subject to an applied voltage V is [70,74] Wp ¼ 2r r2 0:5 CV 2 r2
ð57Þ
where is the energy per unit length along the circumference needed to form the pore, is the energy per unit area of the flat, pore-free membrane, and p 1 C0 ð58Þ C ¼ m is the approximate change of the capacitance due to the presence of the pore; C0 is the capacitance per unit area of a pore-free membrane, p and m are the permittivity of water inside the pore and of the membrane respectively. The critical pore radius, rc , and critical barrier, Wp , are both defined by minimizing Eq. (57) with respect to r: rc ¼
þ 0:5C V 2
Wp;c ¼
2 þ 0:5C V 2
ð59Þ
As has been described in Ref. 70, this approach can reasonably account for membrane electroporation, reversible and irreversible. On the other hand, a theory of the processes leading to formation of the initial (hydrophobic) pores has not yet been developed. Existing approaches to the description of the probability of pore formation, in addition to the barrier parameters , , and some others (accounting, e.g., for the possible dependence of on r), also involve parameters such as the ‘‘diffusion constant in r-space,’’ Dp , or the ‘‘attempt rate density,’’ 0 . These parameters are hard to establish from first principles. For instance, the rate of critical pore appearance, c , is described in Ref. 75 through an Arrhenius equation: c ¼ 0 Vm expðWp;c =kTÞ where Vm is the total volume of the membrane. Nucleation of a hydrophobic pore requires cooperative motion of 8 lipid molecules and 8–10 water molecules. Given that lipid
70
Partenskii and Jordan
molecules are not rigid, the corresponding entropy contribution (or the ‘‘attempt rate’’ density 0 ) is hard to quantify with precision. Estimates [75] of 0 are very approximate and vary over 9–10 orders of magnitude. Estimates of Wp;c vary from 30 to 50 kT. It is basically assumed [75] that the uncertainty in 0 is balanced by the uncertainty in the barrier, so that taken together they result in a reasonable concentration of pores. These assumptions are difficult to verify. Another concern is related to the fact that this approach ignores the role of membrane undulations. These are known to be important in membranes’ macroscopic behavior (stretching diagram, adhesion, capacitance) and as they noticeably interact with the electric field, they are likely to also contribute in the processes related to electroporation. At least one such relation is well known: at small surface tension the bending modes of membrane undulations become unstable at low voltages. In the next section we describe the membrane undulations and present a hypothesis as to their role in membrane instability. B.
The Smectic Bilayer Model (SBM) in an Electric Field
The most successful continuum description of membrane elasticity, dynamics, and thermodynamics is based on the smectic bilayer model (for examples of different versions and applications of this approach see Ref. 76–82 and references therein). We introduce this model in conjunction with the question of membrane undulations. 1. Membrane Undulations in the SBM Let U þ ðÞ and U ðÞ be z-components of the displacement of the upper (þ) and lower () membrane surfaces; is a two-dimensional radius vector in the XY plane. We express these as U ¼ u0 þ u
ð60Þ
where u0 is the displacement caused by external forces (such as electrical or mechanical stress) while u describes a nonuniform fluctuation of the membrane surface. For further analysis we decompose membrane fluctuations into a Fourier series, X u ðÞ ¼ u ðqÞ expðiqÞ ð61Þ q
(a) Elastic energy. We now treat separately the peristaltic (symmetrical, s-) and bending (antisymmetrical, a-) modes of membrane undulations, uþ s ¼ us ¼ u
uþ a ¼ ua ¼ u
ð62Þ
The elastic energy (per unit area) consists of three contributions [78–80]: 1.
Compression (stretching) energy, W1 , for which we choose Crowley’s form, Eq. (51). For small undulations this becomes W1 ¼
E ðz zÞ2 2h20 z
ð63Þ
with z z ¼ uþ u : 2. Splay (‘‘bending’’ or ‘‘curvature’’) defined by a splay constant K1 , or by a curvature elastic modulus Kc ¼ K1 h [76],
Electroelastic Instabilities
W2 ¼
3.
71
Kc 2 2 ðr uÞ 2 ?
ð64Þ
where r? ¼ @=@ is the gradient operator in the plane of the membrane. Surface tension contribution defined by a stress applied to a membrane, typically expressed as [77] W3 ¼ ðr? uÞ2 =2 þ 2 =2E
ð65Þ
where the first contribution is related to undulations and the second to elastic stretching.* (b) Interaction with the Electric Field. In most studies of the effect of an applied voltage on membranes, the model of ideal conductor ( ¼ 1) is used for the surrounding solvent. Then the membrane surface can be considered an equipotential. The solution of the Laplace equation leads to following results for the electrostatic energies of membrane undulations [56,78,88]: ( Welectr ¼ 2qjuq j pE 2
tanhðqh=2Þ
ða-modeÞ
cothðqh=2Þ
ðs-modeÞ
ð66Þ
The ‘‘ideal conductor’’ model does not account for diffuseness of the ionic distribution in the electrolyte and the corresponding ‘‘spreading’’ of the electric field with a potential drop outside the membrane. To account approximately for these effects we apply Poisson–Boltzmann theory. The results for the modes’ energies can be summarized as follows [89]: W
s;a
¼ m þ s
B2 F 2 a0 a1 h þ a0 Bs;a þ s;a s;a 2q
!
2 2 2 þ q2 2 c0 þ 2c0 c1 þ c0 Ds;a þ Ds;a 2 4
!
ð67Þ
where
* The origin of the ‘‘surface tension’’ in membranes recently became a subject of intensive discussion (see, e.g., Refs. 83–87, and references therein). To outline the problem, we note that thermodynamic ‘‘surface tension’’ in liquids is a result of molecular exchange between surface and inner volumes when a new surface is created. The corresponding free energy contribution is a result of the different surroundings of a molecule in the bulk and on the surface. In isolated bilayers, however, such exchange is impossible. Area (projected) can only change due to unfolding the bilayer’s undulations and elastically stretching the bilayer. The tension at equilibrium is zero. However, the situation can be different if area can grow due to molecular exchange with an environment. Such a situation can occur, for instance, in experiments with black lipid films, where exchange between the bilayer and the rim is possible.
72
Partenskii and Jordan
Bs;a ¼ a0 r a1 ¼ s;a
ðr 1Þ þ s;a
Ds;a ¼
Fs;a =q þ 1 1=r s;a
a0 ¼
r 1þ
r c 2 B þ Ds;a ð þ Þ ð ÞDs;a þ Bs;a c1 ¼ 0 s;a 2ð1 þ Þ 2ð1 þ Þ 4 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi r ¼ m =s ¼ 1 þ rFs;a =q ¼ 2 þ q 2 ¼ rh=2
and Fs ¼ tanhðqh=2Þ
Fa ¼ cothðqh=2Þ
lD1 is the reciprocal Debye length and s is the dielectric constant of the solvent. Through most of what follows we use the ideal conductor approximation, Eq. (66). Ionic effects will be considered in Section IV.D. 2. Dispersion Equations Using Eqs. (61) and (54), and combining Eqs. (63), (64), and (65), we find ws;a ¼
Ejuq j2 fs;a ðx; zÞ h20
ð68Þ
1 xz fs ðx; zÞ ¼ þ b1 x2 þ b2 x4 þ x lnðzÞ coth z 2 xz fa ðx; zÞ ¼ x2 þ x4 þ x lnðzÞ tanh 2
ð69Þ ð70Þ
where ¼
Kc 4Eh20
¼
4E
x ¼ qh0
ð71Þ
The dimensionless constants b1 and b2 were introduced by Leikin [78]; they account for the fact that contributions from each monolayer to the bending modulus and the surface tension can differ for the two modes considered. Such effects are probably small so that b1 b2 1 [78]. We note that the electrical potential enters Eqs. (69) and (70) only through the parameter z. 3. Instability of Membrane Undulations Under an Applied Voltage (a) Bending Modes. In some sense, the bending modes of membrane undulations at long wavelengths (small x) are similar to those in simple fluids. The curvature contribution is x4 and can be neglected in this limit, while the stretching moduli (another important peculiarity of the double layers) does not manifest itself in bending. As a result, the stability condition for a-modes is similar to results for free liquid films (see, e.g., Refs. 56,65). It can be derived from Eq. (70). In the limit of small x where the membrane is especially ‘‘soft’’ and the instability is most likely to occur, fa ðx; zÞ x2 ð þ z lnðzÞ=2Þ The bending mode is stable if
ð72Þ
Electroelastic Instabilities
1 þ z lnðzÞ > 0 2
73
ð73Þ
For the physical interesting region, z 1, we find z > 1 2. Combining the last condition with Eq. (52) and using Eq. (71) we find that the a-mode becomes unstable at sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi h0 a V Vc
ð74Þ m 0 It follows from Eqs. (73) and (74) that the only stabilizing force for a-modes at long is the membrane tension, and critical voltage vanishes as ! 0. In experiments with black lipid membranes the surface tension arises from the contact of the bilayer with the bulk phase contained in the surrounding rim and is typically 0:002 N=m. Then choosing h0 3 109 m, we find Vca 0:6 V. Experimentally, the characteristic critical voltage Vexper depends on the duration of the applied electrical pulse. For brief pulses, 0:01 0:1 s, Vexper 1 V, and for longer ones ( 1 sÞ Vexper 0:5 V [90]. Further increase of leads to even smaller Vexper [see Refs. 70 and 91 for liquid membranes and Ref. 92 for bilayers with inclusions (fluid mosaic cell membranes) and references therein]. Thus the onset of BM instability is likely related to the long pulse instability. The increase of the electroporation threshold [91] is also in qualitative agreement with Eq. (74). The long- instability of bending modes does not lead directly to formation of pores because it does not affect the internal structure of the membrane. But it can possibly lead to ripping the membrane off the rim and resulting‘‘permeabilization.’’ From our viewpoint, neglect of such an instability is one of the shortcomings of the pore formation models (see the previous discussion). (b) Squeezing Modes. We now analyze Eq. (69). In the limit x ! 0, fs ! 1 þ 2 lnðzÞ. As a result, the condition of instability, fs ¼ 0, leads to Crowley’s results, Eqs. (55) and (56), derived for a plane membrane. Some softening of this condition can be expected at x 6¼ 0 because the stabilization due to electric field grows with x [the function x cothðxz=2Þ in Eq. (69) is essentially a linearly increasing function of x for x 1]. Indeed, instability is first lost at finite (for SOPC it corresponds to x 1:25 [53]). However, the corresponding reduction of Vc and zc is insignificant (for instance, Vc drops by only 5 mV [53]). C.
Nonlocal Model of Membrane Instability
It follows from previous discussion that the destabilizing electrostatic contribution grows in absolute value with x (with increasing ). But the influence of the nonuniform electrical force is overwhelmed by the stabilizing bending and stretching contributions. As a result, the traditional smectic model cannot explain how a small transmembrane voltage can lead to membrane breakdown. The obvious solution is to abandon this approach and to develop an alternative, such as the ‘‘pore formation model.’’ However, as we noticed before, this approach postulates rather than proves the appearance of hydrophobic pores. Another option is to try to modify the smectic model in order to account for the lowvoltage, low-thinning instability. It was suggested in Ref. 53 that the instability could be explained as due to s-modes if (1) the membrane moduli depended on the wavelength of fluctuations, and (2) this dependence resulted in substantial softening of s-modes at short . Condition (1) is quite common and normally is described as ‘‘nonlocality.’’ In general, nonlocality of constitutive equations means that forces acting at a point r and conjugate to a fluctuating variable s, depend not only on the value sðrÞ at r, but also on its behavior in
74
Partenskii and Jordan
more distant regions. This leads directly to a two-point integral for the energy W so that (in an harmonic approximation) ð ð75Þ W ¼ Kðr; r 0 ÞsðrÞsðr 0 Þ dr dr 0 where, depending on the property considered, the kernel Kðr; r 0 Þ depends on a nonlocal susceptibility or a nonlocal modulus. For instance, in nonlocal electrostatics, the role of K is played by ðr; r 0 Þ, the nonlocal dielectric constant, while electric field strength, EðrÞ, corresponds to sðrÞ [93–95]. In nonlocal elastic theory K is the elastic modulus Dðr; r 0 Þ and s describes displacements uðrÞ [93,96]. The local limit in a uniform systemÐcorresponds to Kðr; r 0 Þ ¼ K ðr r 0 Þ where ðrÞ is a delta-function in which case W ¼ K s2 ðrÞ dr. As long as K is a function of r r 0 (the uniformity condition), the Fourier transform of Eq. (75) is X KðqÞjsq j2 ð76Þ W¼ q
Ð where KðqÞ ¼ expðiqrÞKðrÞ dr. Thus, nonlocality can be either described through the spatial dependence of the generalized susceptibility, Kðr; r 0 Þ, or through the dependence of its Fourier transform on wave vector q. Condition (2) is also quite common. For instance, in crystals it results in a reduced sound velocity, vs ðqÞ when q approaches a boundary of the Brillouin zone [93,96], a direct result of the periodicity of a crystal lattice. In addition, interaction between modes can lead to creation of ‘‘soft mode’’ with q 6¼ 0 and corresponding structural transitions [97,98]. The importance of nonlocality at fluid interfaces and the corresponding softening of surface modes has been demonstrated recently, both theoretically [99] and experimentally [100]. In a phenomenological treatment [53] the parameters describing the nonlocal softening of the s-mode were chosen to fit the conditions that the membrane becomes unstable at voltages corresponding to low thinning, z < 3% It was also assumed that at long (small x) the mode energy approaches Eq. (69). Two approximations for the mode energies in the short- limit were suggested in Ref. 53; their effects on membrane undulations are almost identical. Here we use only one of them (see also Refs. 89,101): fsNL ðx; zÞ ¼ ½1 tðxÞ4 ðk1 þ r1 x4 Þ þ tðxÞ4 fs ðx; zÞ
ð77Þ
where tðxÞ ¼
expðsaÞ þ 1 exp½sða xÞ þ 1
ð78Þ
The parameters a and s were chosen to satisfy the conditions that the transition to the short- behavior occurs at 1:5h0 and that it is steep enough so that by ð2 3Þh0 the long- limit is quite reliable. Given that membrane thinning does not exceed 2–3%, the model parameters r1 and k1 have been selected so that the s-mode energy approaches 0 as z ! zcr ¼ 0:97. In addition, it was required that the corresponding critical wavelength, cr is of the order of h0 . This procedure is illustrated in Fig. 7. The thick curve corresponds to V ¼ 0. The thinner curve illustrates the case where the applied voltage leads to instability at cr ðx 2Þ. The membrane parameters for the local and nonlocal approximations are presented in Table 1.
Electroelastic Instabilities
75
FIG. 7 Nonlocal (dimensionless) energy fsNL ðx; zÞ of the s-mode for the transitional and short- regions at V ¼ 0 ðz ¼ 1, upper curve) and V ¼ 1:3 V (z ¼ 0:97, lower curve). (Reprinted from Ref. 53, by permission, Journal of Chemical Physics.)
D.
Elastic Nonlocality and Equilibrium Membrane Properties
It the previous section we suggested a possibility of effective softening of the s-mode as a mechanism leading to membrane breakdown. However, this phenomenological assumption requires microscopic justification. But before proceeding further, it is important to check if this assumption is consistent with the description of such equilibrium membrane properties as the membrane stretching diagram, thickness fluctuations, and the low-voltage membrane capacitance. These properties are well described in the local approximation and introduction of nonlocality should lead to similar predictions. 1. Membrane Stretching Diagram and Thickness Fluctuations It is well known that surface undulations strongly influence the stretching diagram of membranes. They are responsible for the ‘‘entropic’’ behavior, the extremely steep increase of projected area A? at small tensions. In the analysis of these phenomena based on the local model the contribution of the s-modes to A? can be neglected as it is strongly reduced due to the high values of membrane stretching constant, E. As a result, the major contribution comes from the soft long- bending modes [76]. However, the assumption of softening of the symmetrical modes made in the nonlocal model may enhance their contribution to the projected area at short and thus alter the stretching diagram. Such a possibility has been analyzed in Ref. 53. Analysis very similar to that of Ref. 77 leads to the following expression for the fractional variation ¼ A? =A of the projected area: ¼
kT 16Eh20
ð xmax xmin
x3
1 1 þ dx f2 ðx; zÞ fa ðx; zÞ
ð79Þ
Stretching diagrams calculated in local (L) [Eqs (69) and (70)] and nonlocal (NL) [with Eq. (77) instead of Eq. (69)] approximations are contrasted in Fig. 8. It can be seen from Fig. 8 that nonlocal results are in good agreement with the local approximation and, consequently, with experiment. At small tensions ( 2 104 N=m) the slope of the stretching diagram is very steep. This domain corresponds to the ‘‘nonelastic’’ or ‘‘entropic’’ region of membrane stretching. For 0ð3 4Þ103 N=m the slope is practically constant. In the intermediate region there is a sharp transition between these two regimes. Unlike local calculations, nonlocal results depend on the choice of min (or
76
Partenskii and Jordan
FIG. 8 Stretching diagram for soft (S) and rigid (R) membranes for (a) min ¼ 1:5 nm and (b) min ¼ 1:2 nm. ‘‘L’’ corresponds to the local model, while ‘‘NL’’ describes the nonlocal calculations (see text). The parameters of Table 1 are used (1 dyne=cm ¼ 103 N=m). (Reprinted from Ref. 53, by permission, Journal of Chemical Physics.)
xmax ). As a result, for the cut-off min 1 nm, close to the size of the lipid headgroups, the differences may reach 10–15%, being more significant for soft membranes. However, as noted in Ref. 53, this discrepancy might be an artifact due to the same expression, 1 A? ðqÞ ¼ A½quðqÞ2 2
ð80Þ
being used for the mode contributions in the variation of the projected area. In fact, this expression is based on the assumption that there is tilting of the lipids such that headgroups are always aligned parallel to the membrane–water interface, which is only valid at long . At short wavelengths, 1:0–2.0 nm, this condition is harder to achieve and up and down displacements of the lipids, which may consume less projected area than the parallel alignment, are the natural ones. In other words, Eq. (80) should be modified to account for the short dispersion of the projected area. Effectively, it is equivalent to an increase of min . The value 1:5–2.0 nm is a reasonable limit for the validity of the macroscopic expression, Eq. (80). Membrane thickness fluctuations were initially discussed in the local approach by Hladky and Gruen (HG) [102] in conjunction with their possible effect on membrane capacitance. They are directly related to the spectrum of s-modes: ð 2 kT xmax x dx ð81Þ ðh h0 Þ ¼ 2E xmin fs ðx; zÞ In Ref. 53 these calculations were reproduced using the nonlocal approach. Following HG, the results were contrasted for two cutoffs, min ¼ 1 nm and min ¼ 10 nm. The nonlocal results for RMS thickness fluctuations h~ ¼ hðh h0 Þ2 i1=2 are comparable in magnitude, but slightly smaller than those found by HG. However, the nonlocal model predicts that the fluctuation spectrum should peak at wavelengths 2–5 nm. Thus a
Electroelastic Instabilities
77
valuable test of the nonlocal hypothesis can come from investigating this range of fluctuations, either by means of molecular dynamics simulation or directly, by soft x-ray scattering from real membranes. 2.
Effect of Undulations on Membrane Capacitance
Initially the effect of applied voltage on membrane capacitance was attributed to the uniform electrostriction, in the manner of the elastic capacitor model [1,103]. The effect of undulations was first considered by Leikin [78]. In Ref. 89 the combined effect of undulations and uniform compression is studied, including the possible influence of nonlocality. The differential capacitance Cd is presented as C d ¼ C0d þ Cud where C0d
@h ¼ m2 0 h V @V h
ð82Þ ! ð83Þ
is the capacitance of the uniform membrane compressed by the electric field and " # ð kT X xmax 1 @2 fl ðx; zÞ @fl ðx; zÞ2 d Cu ¼ fl ðx; zÞ dx @V Ah20 l¼s;a xmin fl ðx; zÞ2 @V 2
ð84Þ
is the contribution from undulations. At comparatively small voltages (91 V) it is sufficient to use the approximation h h0 ð1 bV 2 Þ b¼ m 0 ð85Þ 2Eh0 which follows from Eq. (52). The differential capacitance can be expressed as C d ðVÞ C d ð0Þð1 þ V 2 Þ where C d ð0Þ corresponds to V ¼ 0 and parameter characterizes the effect of voltage. To compare with experiment, the integral membrane capacitance C must be defined. It is [89] 2 CðVÞ ¼ Cð0Þ 1 þ V 3 The results are presented in Table 2. TABLE 2 Voltage Variation Factor as a Function of Tension () for the Uniform Membrane, and with Undulation Included in both Local (L) and Nonlocal (NL) Approximations, for Soft/ Rigid Membranes in the Metallic Approximation, Eq. (66) ð103 N=mÞ 2 3 4 5 10
Uniform
Undulations (L)
Undulations (NL)
0.016/0.005 0.016/0.005 0.016/0.005
0.024/0.007 0.021/0.006 0.020/0.005 0.020/0.005 0.017/0.005
0.028/0.008 0.023/0.007 0.021/0.006 0.020/0.006 0.018/0.005
78
Partenskii and Jordan
In addition, the effect of ionic screening was analyzed [89] using Eqs. (67). The ionic concentrations considered (1.0 M, 0.1 M, 0.01 M) correspond to Debye lengths lD ¼ 0:3; 1 and 3 nm. The results for lD ¼ 3 nm, the most dilute electrolyte, where ionic screening is least effective, are presented in Table 3. The results can be summarized as follows: 1.
2.
3. 4.
The nonlocal results for CðVÞ are consistent with local calculations. Introducing softening of the s-modes at short only changes the undulative contribution to C by 10–15%. Electrostriction dominates the voltage dependence of membrane capacitance. However, at low tensions (94 103 N=m) the contribution of undulations is also important. The latter is in good agreement with the results of [78] if the same membrane parameters are chosen. At higher tension undulations are damped and their role becomes less significant. In rigid membranes is small; however, the relative undulatory contribution is still significant. Ionic screening has only a minor effect on the voltage dependence of the capacitance for the ionic strengths considered, 0:01 M.
Results at 0:002–0.004 N/m are found to be in good qualitative agreement with the ‘‘short pulse’’ experiments [104] with exper ranging from 0.018 to 0.036. E.
Summary
We have shown that postulating short- softening of the s-modes of membrane undulations, which can explain the low-voltage low-thinning instability, is consistent with observed equilibrium properties of membranes. This finding supports the hypothesis but obviously does not prove it. Although partially hidden in averaged thermodynamic properties such as the stretching diagram or the voltage dependence of capacitance, nonlocality can play a more important role when the influence of short-scale perturbations is significant. It can have a direct relation to the anomalous roughness of a membrane surface suggested to account for the discrepancy between calculations of the adhesion energy based on the Young equation and on the conventional (local) theory of entropic forces between the membranes [105]. Mode softening could be a reason for this roughness and for the corresponding hidden projected area [105]. This suggestion complements the hypothesis of special types of structural defects (hats and saddles) [106]. It may also be related to the finding of ‘‘remarkable out-of-plane vibrational motion’’ of lipid molecules [107] which can contribute strongly to short-range repulsive forces between membranes [108]. Another group of phenomena where short- behavior could be important is related to peptide insertion into membranes. TABLE 3 Effect of Ionic screening on the Capacitance at V ¼ 0, Cð0Þ, and on the Factor , Describing the Voltage Dependence of C, for Two Tensions, 1 ¼ 0:002 and 2 ¼ 0:01 N/m, for the Representative Soft Membranes (SOPC)
‘‘Metallic,’’ Eq. (66) lD ¼ 3 nm, Eq. (67)
C(0) (F/m)
ð1 Þ
ð2 Þ
6:4 103 5:9 103
0.028 0.028
0.018 0.017
Electroelastic Instabilities
79
Typically, the insertion induces sharp variation of the membrane profile at the distances 0.5–1.0 nm from the membrane–peptide interface [79–82]. The steepness of this perturbation indicates that the short- behavior of membrane moduli must be important in the estimates of the elastic energy. In addition, a peptide inserted in a membrane almost certainly perturbs the membrane’s elastic moduli in the immediate vicinity of the inclusion. Both these effects, membrane nonlocality and nonuniform modification of elastic properties by insertions, might play an important role in resolving the contradiction between the local calculations [80] and the experimental data for the mean lifetime of a gramicidin channel [81,109,110].* In our approach to membrane breakdown we have only taken preliminary steps. Among the phenomena still to be understood is the combined effect of electrical and mechanical stress. From the ‘‘undulational’’ point of view it is not clear how mechanical tension, which suppresses the undulations, can enhance the approach to membrane instability. Notice that pore formation models, where the release of mechanical and electrical energy is considered a driving force for the transition, provide a natural explanation for these effects [70]. The linear approach requires some modification to describe such phenomena. One suggestion is that membrane moduli should depend on both electrical and mechanical stress, which would cause an additional mode softening [111]. We hope that combining this effect with nonlocality will be illuminating. Further progress in understanding membrane instability and nonlocality requires development of microscopic theory and modeling. Analysis of membrane thickness fluctuations derived from molecular dynamics simulations can serve such a purpose. A possible difficulty with such analysis must be mentioned. In a natural environment isolated membranes assume a stressless state. However, MD modeling requires imposition of special boundary conditions corresponding to a stressed state of the membrane (see Refs. 84,87,112). This stress can interfere with the fluctuations of membrane shape and thickness, an effect that must be accounted for in analyzing data extracted from computer experiments. Other possible direct probes are optical experiments similar to studies [113] of vesicles but expanded towards shorter (20–30 A˚). Alternatively neutron spin-echo studies of stacked bilayer arrays, which can probe the 10–30 A˚ range [114], might possibly be applicable here. Finally, the x-ray grazing-incidence technique has been shown to be a powerful tool for studying short wavelength fluctuations at fluid interfaces [100]. The application of this technique to the investigation of membrane surface fluctuations can reasonably be expected in the near future [115,116].
ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was supported by a grant from the National Institutes of Health, GM-28643.
* An assumption that continuum parameters are inappropriate at the short length scale was introduced in Ref. 109.
80
Partenskii and Jordan
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44.
J. Crowley. Biophys. J. 13:711 (1973) L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Electrodynamics of Continuous Media, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1960. W. R. Fawcett. Israel J. Chem. 18:3 (1979). R. J. Watts-Tobin. Philos. Mag. 6:133 (1961). D. C. Grahame. Chem. Rev. 41:441 (1947). D. C. Grahame. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 76:4819 (1954). M. B. Partenskii, V. Dorman, and P. C. Jordan. Int. Rev. Phys. Chem. 11:153 (1996). I. L. Cooper and J. A. Harrison. J. Electroanal. Chem. 66: 85 (1975). S. L. Marshall and B. E. Conway. J. Electroanal. Chem. 337:67 (1992). M. B. Partenskii and V. J. Feldman. J. Electroanal. Chem. 273:57 (1989). W. Schmickler. J. Electroanal. Chem. 149:15 (1983). M. B. Partenskii, Z. B. Kim, and V. J. Feldman. Sov. Phys. J. 30:907 (1987). L. Blum. J. Phys. Chem. 81:136 (1977). D. Henderson, L. Blum, and W. R. Smith. Chem. Phys. Lett. 63:381 (1979). L. Blum, J. L. Lebovitz, and D. Henderson. J. Chem. Phys. 72:4249 (1980). S. L. Carnie, D. Y. G. Chan, D. J. Mitchell, and B. W. Ninham. J. Chem. Phys. 74:1472 (1981). G. M. Torrie. J. Chem. Phys. 96:3772 (1992). D. Wei, G. M. Torrie, and G. N. Patey. J. Chem. Phys. 99:3990 (1993). D. O. Raleigh, in Electrode Processes in Solid State Iionics, Reidel Publ. Co., Dordrecht, Holland, 1976, pp. 119–146. M. B. Partenskii and L. Blum. Unpublished results, 1990. P. Attard, D. Wei, and G. N. Patey. J. Chem. Phys. 96:3767 (1992). M. B. Partenskii and P. C. Jordan. J. Chem. Phys. 99:2992 (1993). W. Schmickler and D. Henderson. Progr. Surf. Sci 22:323 (1986). V. J. Feldman, M. B. Partenskii, and M. M. Vorobjev. Prog. Surf. Sci. 23:3 (1986). A. A. Kornyshev. Electrochim. Acta 34:1829 (1989). S. Amokrane and J. P. Badiali, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (B. E. Conway, J. O’M. Bockris, and R. E. White, eds.), vol. 22, Plenum Press, New York, London, 1993, pp. 1–96. S. Walbran, A. Mazzolo, J. W. Halley, and D. L. Price. J. Chem. Phys. 109: 8076 (1998). J. P. Badiali, M. Rosinberg, and J. Goodisman. J. Electroanal Chem. 143:73 (1983). J. P. Badiali, M. Rosinberg, and J. Goodisman. J. Electroanal. Chem. 150:25 (1983). J. P. Badiali, M. Rosinberg, F. Vericat, and L. Blum. J. Electroanal. Chem. 158:253 (1983). M. B. Partenskii and M. M. Vorobjev. Sov. Phys. Dokl. 29:746 (1984). V. J. Feldman, A. A. Kornyshev, and M. B. Partenskii. Solid State Commun. 53:157 (1985). J. W. Halley, B. Johnson, D. Price, and M. Schwalm. Phys. Rev. B 31:7695 (1985). V. J. Feldman, M. B., Partenskii, and A. A. Kornyshev. J. Electroanal. Chem. 237:1 (1987). J. W. Halley and D. Price. Phys. Rev. B 35:9095 (1987). Z. B. Kim, A. A. Kornyshev, and M. B. Partenskii. J. Electroanal. Chem. 265:1 (1989). V. J. Feldman, M. B. Partenskii, and M. M. Vorobjev. Electrochim. Acta 31:291 (1986). R. Parsons, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’M. Bockris and B. Conway, eds.), vol. 1, Academic Press, New York, 1954, pp. 103–179. R. J. Baxter, Exactly Solved Models in Statistical Mechanics, Academic Press, London, New York, 1982, Ch. 1. C. W. McCombie, Problems in Thermodynamics and Statistical Physics (P. T. Landsberg, ed.), Pion, London, 1971, p. 459 (from [43]). P. Nikitas. J. Electroanal. Chem. 300:607 (1991). P. Nikitas. Electrochim. Acta 37:81 (1992). J. Stafiej. J. Electroanal. Chem. 351:1–27 (1993). P. Nikitas. J. Electroanal. Chem. 306:13 (1991).
Electroelastic Instabilities 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83.
84. 85. 86. 87.
81
T. Y. Tsong. Biophys. J. 41:135 (1991). S. A. Freeman, M. A. Wang, and J. C. Weaver. Biophys. J. 67:42 (1994). U. Zimmerman and G. Neil (eds.), Electromanipulation of Cells, CRC Press, 1996. A. G. Volkov, D. W. Deamer, D. L. Tanelian, and V. S. Markin, Liquid Interfaces in Chemistry and Biology, J. Wiley & Sons, New York, 1998. H. T. Tien. Adv. Mater. 2:316 (1990). M. Stelze, G. Weissmuller, and E. Sackmann. J. Phys. Chem. 97:2974 (1993). E. Sackmann. Science 271:43 (1996). B. A. Cornell, V. L. Braach-Maksvytis, L. G. King, P. D. J. Osman, B. Raguse, L. Wieczorek, and R. J. Pace. Nature 387:580 (1997). M. B. Partenskii, V. L. Dorman, and P. C. Jordan. J. Chem. Phys. 109:10361 (1998). A. Vrij. Discuss. Faraday Soc. 42:23 (1966). A. Sheludko. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci 1:391 (1967). D. H. Michael and M. E. O’Neill. J. Fluid. Mech. 41:571 (1970). C. S. Kishore, S. Salaniwal, and A. Sharma. Phys. Fluids 7:1832 (1995). D. S. Dimitrov and K. R. Jain. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 779:438 (1984). P. M. Bisch and H. Wendel. J. Chem. Phys. 83:5953 (1985). P. M. Bisch and H. Wendel. J. Chem. Phys. 83:5962 (1985). D. S. Dimitrov. J. Membr. Biol. 78:53 (1984). C. Maldarelli, R. K. Jain, I. B. Ivanov, and E. Ruckenstein. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 78:118 (1980). C. Maldarelli and R. K. Jain. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 90:233 (1982). C. Maldarelli and R. K. Jain. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 90:263 (1982). A. Steinchen, D. Gallez, and A. Sanfeld. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 85:5 (1982). D. Gallez. Biophys. Chem. 18:165 (1983). D. Gallez and A. Steinchen. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 94:296 (1983). J. C. Weaver and A. Barnett, in Guide to Electroporation and Electrofusion (D. C. Chang, B. M. Chassy, J. A. Sanders, and A. E. Sowrs, eds.), Academic Press, 1992, pp. 91–117. Y. Chizmadzhev, in Electrified Interfaces in Physics, Chemistry and Biology (R. Guidelli, ed.), Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands, 1992, pp. 491–507. J. C. Weaver and Yu. A. Chizmadzhev. Biolectrochem. Bioenerg. 41:135 (1996). B. V. Deryagin and Yu. V. Gutop. Colloid J. 370 (1962). J. D. Lister. Phys. Lett. 193 (1975). C. Tsupin, M. Dvolaitzky, and C. Sauterey. Biochemistry 14:4771 (1975). I. Abidor, V. Arakelyan, L. Chernomordik, Y. A. Chizmadzhev, V. Pastushenko, and M. Tarasevich. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 6:37 (1979). J. C. Weaver and R. A. Mintzer. Phys. Lett. 86A:57 (1981). W. Helfrich. Z. Naturforsch. 28c:693 (1973). W. Helfrich. Z. Naturforsch. 30c:841 (1975). S. Leikin. Biologicheskie Membrani (in Russian) 2(8):820 (1985). H. W. Huang. Biophys. J. 50:1061 (1986). P. Helfrich and E. Jakobsson. Biophys. J. 57:1075 (1990). T. A. Harroun, W. T. Heller, T. M. Weiss, L. Yang, and H. W. Huang. Biophys. J. 76:3176 (1999). S. May and A. Ben-Shaul. Biophys. J. 76:751 (1999). D. Sornette and N. Ostrowsky, in Micelles, Membranes, Microemulsions, and Monolayers (W. Gelbart, A. Ben-Shaul, and D. Roux, eds.) Springer-Verlag, New York, 1994, pp. 251–302. S.-W. Chiu, M. Clark, V. Balaji, S. Subramaniam, H. L. Scott, and E. Jakobsson. Biophys. J. 69:1230 (1995). F. Jahning. Biophys. J. 71:1348 (1996). B. Roux. Biophys. J. 71:1346 (1996). S. E. Feller and R. Pastor. Biophys. J. 71:1350 (1996).
82
Partenskii and Jordan
88. D. Andelman, in Handbook of Biological Physics (R. Lipowsky and E. Sackmann, eds.), vol. 1, Elsevier Science, Washington, D.C., 1995, pp. 603–642. 89. M. Partensky and P. Jordan. Mol. Phys. 98:193 (2000). 90. R. Benz and U. Zimmermann. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 597:637 (1980). 91. G. Troiano, L. Tung, V. Sharma, and K. Stebe. Biophys. J. 75:880 (1998). 92. J. Akinlaja and F. Sachs. Biophys. J. 75:247 (1998). 93. W. Harrison, Solid State Theory, Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA, 1984. 94. A. Kornyshev, in Chemical Physics of Solvation (R. Dogonadze, E. Kalman, A. Kornyshev, and J. Ulstrup, eds.), vol. C, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985, ch. 6. 95. P. Bopp, A. Kornyshev, and G. Sutmann. J. Chem. Phys. 109:1939 (1998). 96. N. Ashcroft and N. Mermin, Solid State Physics, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York, 1977. 97. M. Kaplan and B. Vekhter, Cooperative Phenomena in Jahn–Teller Crystals, Plenum Press, New York, 1995. 98. B. Strukov and A. Levaniuk, Ferroelectric Phenomena in Crystals: Physical Foundations, Springer, Berlin, New York, 1998. 99. K. Mecke and S. Dietrich. Phys. Rev. E59:6766 (1999). 100. C. Fradin, A. Braslau, D. Luzet, D. Smilgies, M. Alba, N. Boudet, K. Mecke, and J. Daillant. Nature 403:871 (2000) 101. M. Partenskii and P. Jordan. Biophys. J. A54 (1999). 102. S. Hladky and D. Gruen. Biophys. J. 38:251 (1982). 103. S. White and T. Thompson. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 323:7 (1973). 104. O. Alvarez and R. Latorre. Biophys. J. 21:1 (1978) 105. W. Helfrich, in Handbook of Biological Physics. (R. Lipowsky and E. Sackmann, eds.), vol. 1, Elsevier Science, New York, 1995, pp. 691–721. 106. W. Helfrich. Liq. Crys. 5:1647 (1989). 107. E. Sackmann, in Handbook of Biological Physics (R. Lipowsky and E. Sackmann, eds.), vol. 1, Elsevier Science, Washington, DC, 1995, pp. 213–304. 108. J. N. Israelachvili and H. Wennerstroem. Langmuir 6:873 (1990). 109. C. Nielsen, M. Goulian, and O. Andersen. Biophys. J. 74:1966 (1998). 110. J. A. Lundbæk and O. Andersen. Biophys. 76:889 (1999). 111. V. Dorman, M. Partenskii, and P. Jordan. Biophys J. 72:A69 (1997). 112. R. Goetz and R. Lipowsky. J. Chem. Phys. 108:7397 (1998). 113. H. Engelhart, H. Duwe, and E. Sackmann. J. Phys. Lett. 46:395 (1985). 114. W. Pfeifer, S. Konig, L. J. F., T. Bayerl, D. Richter, and E. Sackmann. Europhys. Lett. 23:457 (1993). 115. C. Fradin, D. Luzet, A. Braslau, M. Alba, F. Muller, J. Daillant, J. Petit, and F. Rieutord. Langmuir 14:7327 (1998). 116. L. Perino-Gallice, B. Amalric, E. A. Braslau, T. Charitat, J. Daillant, G. Fragneto, and F. Graner, Colloids and Polymers (2000) (submitted). 117. D. Needham and R. M. Hochmuth. Biophys. J. 55:1001 (1989). 118. D. Needham and R. Nunn. Biophys. J. 58:997 (1990). 119. E. A. Evans and W. Rawicz. Phys. Rev. Lett. 64:2094 (1990).
4 The GvdW Theory: A Density Functional Theory of Adsorption, Surface Tension, and Screening STURE NORDHOLM Department of Chemistry, Go¨teborg University, Go¨teborg, Sweden ROBERT PENFOLD Food Materials Science Division, Institute of Food Research, Norwich, England
I.
INTRODUCTION
The debt owed to J. van der Waals for revealing the essence of fluid behavior in his famous analysis of the binding energy and excluded volume mechanisms [1,2] is widely recognized as enormous. Less known is the fact that van der Waals also extended his theory to nonuniform fluids [3]. This work was a beginning of the development of so-called density functional theories which have only recently gained prominence in both quantum chemistry [4,5] and statistical mechanics [6,7]. Here we shall review the origin of the generalized van der Waals (GvdW) theory with the aim to show that the remarkable accuracy of simple mechanistic analysis applies also to a wide range of nonuniform fluid phenomena such as adsorption, surface tension, and electrolyte screening. Thus the traditional equation of state of van der Waals as well as the Debye–Hu¨ckel and Poisson–Boltzmann theories of electrolyte screening are simple special cases of the GvdW theory which unify and considerably extend these well-known traditional approximations to account, in particular, for nonlocal entropy and short-range packing structure. The key idea of the GvdW theory is a greatly simplified treatment of correlations in the fluid. Note that if there were no interactions then the ideal gas partition function would be a sum over all possible configurations of the fluid. In a realistic interacting fluid these configurations would occur with a weighting factor for each. This weighting factor would reflect the potential energy VðRÞ associated with the configuration R through the Boltzmann factor exp½VðRÞ. This innocent-looking weighting factor introduces enormous complexity which will continue to be the subject of analysis and approximation in liquid state theory for all the foreseeable future. van der Waals introduced the idea that for bulk fluids the weighting factor be allowed only two possible values, 0 or 1. In this way the ensemble of configurations and weights was dramatically simplified. The configurations which showed overlap between hard repulsive parts of the pair potentials acting between the particles were simply eliminated by the so-called ‘‘excluded volume effect.’’ The average potential energy was then calculated by the mean field approximation, i.e., over the truncated but otherwise unweighted ensemble of configurations. In this way entropy, internal energy, and free energy could be obtained by greatly simplified calculations. 83
84
Nordholm and Penfold
This approach certainly does not always yield thermodynamic properties of high accuracy. It is, however, uniquely well suited to the treatment of simple fluids. We shall see that it works very well for Lennard–Jones models of simple fluids which have quite shortrange interactions. It also works very well, in principle better, for primitive models of electrolyte solutions. We are able by this GvdW theory to resolve both short-range packing structure at hard walls and long-range screening mechanisms in electrolyte solutions. We feel therefore that this theory should be of great utility in the field of electrochemistry where both short-range fluid properties and long-range electrolyte screening mechanisms meet and mingle. Perhaps the greatest advantage of the theory is that it retains great simplicity, while offering generality and numerical efficiency through the variational nature of the density functional formulation. Thus, it need not remain in the hands of a few specialists but will, hopefully, be useful for nearly any practitioner of chemistry.
II.
THE VAN DER WAALS LEGACY: GENERALIZED
Every chemist knows the van der Waals equation of state, P¼
kB T a 2 v v0 v
ð1Þ
In it the pressure P is found in terms of temperature T and volume per particle v. The interactions enter through two parameters: v0 , the excluded volume per particle, and a, the binding energy per particle at unity density in a bulk fluid. The equation of state arose as an extension of the ideal gas law, P¼
kB T v
ð2Þ
It was assumed that the volume V was reduced by the presence of ‘‘other particles’’ to the free volume V Nv0 where N is the number of particles. In arriving at the binding energy effect the mean field approximation was used, which says that the soft (negative) part of the pair potential was sampled in an uncorrelated manner as if the system was an ideal gas. The corresponding free energy per particle in the bulk fluid is n ð3Þ f ¼ 3kB T ln þ kB T ln kB T an 1 nv0 where is the thermal wavelength which does not depend on volume and n is the particle density N=V. The third term on the RHS, kB T, is the so-called communal entropy term which reflects the large density fluctuations in the bulk ideal gas. If we instead restrict the ideal gas particles to singly occupied cells, each of volume v ¼ V=N, then the communal entropy term disappears and we get n fc ¼ kB T ln an ð4Þ 1 nv0 Here we have limited ourselves to the configurational free energy per particle fc , i.e., we have omitted the kinetic part which in classical statistical mechanics just yields the first term 3kB T ln . The first minor generalization of van der Waals’ original derivation is the omission of the communal entropy. We will be dealing with interacting, often dense, fluids which do not display the same density fluctuations as do the corresponding ideal gases.
The GvdW Theory
85
Thus we prefer to make the cell model our reference for density fluctuations. Density fluctuations are thereby truncated but in a well-defined way open to correction. The second generalization is the reinterpretation of the excluded volume per particle v0 . Realizing that only binary collisions are likely in a low-density gas, van der Waals suggested the value 2 3 =2 for hard spheres of diameter and for particles which were modeled as hard spheres with attractive tails. Thus, for the Lennard–Jones fluid where the pair potential actually is " # 12 6 ð5Þ
ðrÞ ¼ 4 12 6 r r the interaction is typically approximated as a hard sphere potential for r < . The estimate of van der Waals is chosen to give the correct second virial coefficient B2 ðTÞ at low densities. At higher densities the excluded volume per particle decreases due to the overlap of excluded volume spheres centered on each particle. Thus the effective excluded volume v0 is density dependent and it decreases monotonically with density. If we are to treat a wide range of fluid densities it is then better to determine a constant excluded volume v0 in the high-density limit. In fact, in the simplest form of GvdW theory denoted GvdW(S) [8], v0 is taken to be 3 to give the pressure divergence at the close packing limit in the simple cubic crystal structure. We shall use the Lennard–Jones fluid as the illustrative example as we review the GvdW theory. In the GvdW(S) theory the equation of state is just like the vdW equation of state above with the parameters given by v0 ¼ 3 and a ¼ 16 3 =9. This equation of state works moderately well. However, we do not wish to deal only with bulk thermodynamic properties. We wish to treat surface tension and adsorption, screening phenomena in electrolyte solutions, etc. To do this we need a free energy density functional, i.e., an expression for the configurational free energy as a function of the particle density which is now considered to be a function of position. If all particle–particle interactions were local in the fluid then the functional would have been of the form ð ð ð6Þ Fc ¼ drnðrÞfc ðnðrÞÞ þ drnðrÞVext ðrÞ where fc ðnÞ is the free energy per particle in the corresponding bulk fluid. Here Vext ðrÞ is an external potential. This type of fully local potential has some limited use, e.g., to consider adsorption in a slowly varying external potential. It fails, however, to describe the most important phenomena such as surface tension and adsorption at most types of interfaces. These phenomena reflect in a fundamental way the nonlocal interactions in the fluid. The most obvious nonlocality of the free energy arises due to the range of the attractive or soft interactions represented by the second term in the equation of state, a=v2 . The corresponding potential energy can be obtained by the functional ð ð 1 drnðrÞ dr 0 nðr 0 Þ s ðr; r 0 Þ EV ¼ ð7Þ 2 Here s is the soft and normally attractive part of the pair potential. This simple bilinear form of functional lacks correlation effects except that which is introduced by the truncation of the integral at the onset of the inner hard part of the potential. We are then using an extended form of the mean field approximation as did van der Waals in his original
86
Nordholm and Penfold
work. We can now write down the first truly useful free energy density functional in the form ð ð ð ð nðrÞ 1 drnðrÞ dr 0 nðr 0 Þ s ðr; r 0 Þ þ drVext ðrÞ þ ð8Þ Fc ¼ kB T drnðrÞ ln 1 nðrÞv0 2 This type of functional, which we refer to as ‘‘coarse-grained,’’ can be used to calculate both surface tension and adsorption isotherms to quite good accuracy for many fluids and interfaces. It can also be used for screening problems in the theory of electrolytes. We shall illustrate the applicability of the GvdW(S) functional above by considering the case of gas–liquid surface tension for the Lennard–Jones fluid. This will also introduce the variational principle by which equilibrium properties are most efficiently found in a density functional theory. Suppose we assume the profile to be of step function shape, i.e., changing abruptly from liquid to gas density at a plane. In this case the binding energy integrals in EV can be done analytically and we get for the surface tension [9] ¼
3 4 27 ðnl ng Þ2 ¼ aðnl ng Þ2 4 64
ð9Þ
This expression is not particularly accurate, as shown in Fig. 1, but it tells a large part of the story of surface tension. It arises predominantly due to the loss of binding energy of the liquid-phase particles at the interface. It is roughly proportional to the product of the binding energy constant a and the range of the attractions . It is also in this approximation proportional to the square of the density difference nl ng . We shall see, however, that this proportionality is more nearly to the fourth power of the density difference. A more accurate result can be obtained by allowing the density profile at the interface to relax. The optimal profile is the one which minimizes the free energy. The surface tension is computed by first calculating the free energy for the interface (over a sufficiently wide slice of the liquid and gas phases) and then subtracting the corresponding free energy obtained from the fully local functional. The fully optimized profile can be obtained by iteratively refining it point by point to yield the best possible shape, i.e., that corresponding to the lowest free energy. More conveniently, and very nearly as accurately, we can
FIG. 1 The calculated surface tension of an argon fluid represented as a Lennard–Jones fluid is shown as a function of temperature. The GvdW(HS-B2 )-functional is used in all cases. The filled squares correspond to step function profile and local entropy, the filled circles to tanh profile with local entropy, and the open circles to tanh profile with nonlocal entropy. The latter data are in good agreement with experiment.
The GvdW Theory
87
choose a plausible profile shape with a width parameter and then find the optimal value. A favored profile shape is the tanh profile, n l ng nðxÞ ¼ ng þ ð10Þ 1 þ expðxÞ The corresponding result for the surface tension [9] provides quite reasonable accuracy for a Lennard–Jones fluid or an inert gas fluid, except helium which displays large quantum effects. Thus we can conclude that the leading mechanisms of surface tension in a simple fluid is the loss of binding energy of the liquid phase at the gas–liquid interface and the second most important mechanism is likely to be the adsorption–depletion at the interface which creates a molecularly smooth density profile instead of an abrupt step in the density. The next most important mechanism affecting the surface tension at a single component simple fluid gas–liquid interface is, we believe, associated with the nonlocality of the repulsive interactions. To account for this mechanism, observe that it enters by way of the excluded volume effect. In the coarse-grained GvdW(S) theory above, the free volume factor ðrÞ is given by ðrÞ ¼ 1 nðrÞ 3
ð11Þ
for a Lennard–Jones fluid. The role of the density in this expression is to describe the number of other particles within repulsive range. If the particle density is varying significantly on the length scale then the local particle density nðrÞ should clearly be replaced by some nonlocal average. The natural domain for such an average is the sphere of radius , the range of the hard repulsion, centered on the location of our test particle at r. Thus, we get in the so-called ‘‘fine-grained’’ GvdW(S) theory [10] ðrÞ ¼ 1 n ðrÞ 3 where n ðrÞ is the coarse-grained particle density defined by ð 3 dsn ðsÞ n ðrÞ ¼ 4 3 jrsj<
ð12Þ
ð13Þ
This is clearly only the simplest of possible nonlocal density averages which accounts for the range of the repulsion. Within the GvdW theory we have adhered to this simplest form which works very well as it stands. There are, however, a number of different suggestions available in the density functional literature which arise from matching the GvdW approach to the modern liquid state theory based on pair-correlation analysis. The functionals obtained this way are generally referred to as ‘‘weighted-density functionals’’ [6,7]. As can be seen in Fig. 1 the nonlocal entropy in the form of a nonlocal excluded volume effect systematically reduces the surfaces tension of a Lennard–Jones or inert gas fluid and brings the GvdW result close to corresponding simulation or experimental results. One can understand this in terms of the easing of excluded volume constraints on the dominant liquid phase close the interface. The nonlocal entropy also brings the possibility of describing the characteristic packing structure of a simple fluid around one of its own particles or at a hard wall. In the ‘‘fine-grained’’ GvdW theory (because it distinguishes between the fine-grained particle density nðrÞ and the coarse grained n ðrÞ entering the free volume factor) these ubiquitous oscillations can be understood as a consequence of the ‘‘overlapping excluded volume’’ mechanism. At a hard wall the excluded volume spheres of neighboring hard spheres are partially buried in the already excluded volume associated with the wall [10–12]. This provides excess free volume for the rest of the fluid and thereby attracts the first shell of particles towards the wall. They then
88
Nordholm and Penfold
make up a structured wall for a second layer to be attracted to, thus forming another wall attracting a third layer, and so on. In order to accurately describe such oscillations, which have been the center of attention of modern liquid state theory, two major requirements need be fulfilled. The first has already been discussed above, i.e., the need to accurately resolve the nonlocal interactions, in particular the repulsive interactions. The second is the need to accurately resolve the mechanisms of the equation of state of the bulk fluid. Thus we need a mechanistically accurate bulk equation of state in order to create a free energy functional which can accurately resolve nonuniform fluid phenomena related to the nonlocality of interactions. So far we have only discussed the original van der Waals form of equation of state and its slight modification by choosing a high-density estimate for the excluded volume, v0 ¼ 3 for a fluid with effective hard sphere diameter , instead of the low-density estimate v0 ¼ 2 3 =3 suggested by van der Waals. These two estimates really suggest that the excluded volume per particle is density dependent. Several different forms of equations of state have been developed within the GvdW effort which account for this density dependence of the excluded volume [13,14]. Here we shall describe only one simple extension of this type which nevertheless produces substantial improvements in the treatment of surface tension. We call it the GvdW(HS-B2 ) equation of state [14] because it is designed to reproduce the hard sphere second virial coefficient B2 in the low-density limit while retaining close packing at the simple cubic limiting density of n ¼ 3 . Its form is as follows:
2 1 3 k T a B k T 3 P¼ B 3 2 v v
ð14Þ
Here the correction to obtain the exact hard sphere B2 is added linearly while at high density v0 acts nonlinearly and defines the close-packing limit. The corresponding free energy density functional is nðrÞ 2 3 1 n ðrÞ þ Fc ¼ kB T drnðrÞ ln 3 1 nðrÞ 3 Z ð ð 1 drnðrÞ dr 0 nðr 0 Þ s ðr; r 0 Þ þ drVext ðrÞ þ 2 ð
ð15Þ
This functional gives a good account of both the equation of state and the surface tension of a Lennard–Jones fluid. The surface tension is shown in Fig. 1. The critical parameters obtained from the equation of state are shown in Table 1.
TABLE 1 Critical Parameters for the Lennard–Jones Model are Given in Reduced Units such that ¼ 1 and ¼ 1 Source GvdW(HS-B2 ) Simulation Argon (experiment)
Pc
nc
Tc
0.156 0.13–0.17 0.116
0.333 0.32–0.36 0.316
1.25 1.32–1.36 1.26
The simulation results have been extracted from the literature: see, e.g., B. Smit. J. Chem. Phys. 96:8639 (1992).
The GvdW Theory
III.
89
SURFACE TENSION IN MIXTURES
The GvdW theory has been applied also to mixtures of Lennard–Jones fluids [15,16]. The extension to mixtures is straightforward with respect to the binding energy and interaction with an external field but not quite so straightforward with respect to the excluded volume effect. The GvdW(S) theory produces for a mixture of c components an equation of state of the form P¼
c c X c X X aij kB T v v0i i¼1 j¼1 v2i i¼1 i
ð16Þ
Here we have taken the pair potential acting between particles of species i and j, respectively, to be ! ij12 ij6
sij ðrÞ ¼ 4ij 12 6 ð17Þ r r The choice of appropriate potential parameters to use in the study of a certain mixture can be a significant problem. Traditionally the Lorentz–Berthelot rules, 1 ij ¼ ðii þ jj Þ 2 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ij ¼ ii jj
ð18Þ ð19Þ
are frequently used to allow between-species Lennard–Jones potentials to be found from within-species potentials which are better known. The former (Lorentz) rule is generally found adequate but the latter (Berthelot) rule is often found to overestimate the strength of between species attraction. Thus one often introduces a correction factor kij pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ij ¼ kij ii jj ð20Þ where kij is typically 0.95 or so, i.e., a little below unity. The form of the free volume factor ðrÞ is so far generally taken to be i ðrÞ ¼ 1
c X
n i ðrÞii3
ð21Þ
i¼1
This form is particularly simple, since ðrÞ is independent of the type of species i. It behaves as if each particle excluded a volume equal to the smallest cube into which its effective hard sphere shape could be placed. The alternative form i ðrÞ ¼ 1
c X
n i ðrÞij3
ð22Þ
i¼1
may seem more realistic, since it refers the excluded volume to the type of particle. Thus a large particle will be more squeezed by its neighbors than a small particle. Reasonable as this may sound, it also brings some less physical features, such as total exclusion of large particles from a solvent of small particles still not at close packing. As a result the former linear mixture rule for the free volume factor has most often been preferred in the GvdW applications. In the GvdW(HS-B2 ) form of the theory the correction term brings in the binary type of excluded volume mixing rule. The free energy density functional becomes
90
Nordholm and Penfold
Fc ¼ kB T
c ð X i¼1
"
# ! c X ni ðrÞ 2 3 3 P jj nj ðrÞ drni ðrÞ ln þ 3 ij 1 cj¼1 nj ðrÞjj3 j¼1
ð c X c ð 1X þ drni ðrÞ dsnj ðsÞ sij ðjr sjÞ 2 i¼1 j¼1
ð23Þ
The corresponding GvdW(S) functional is obtained by dropping the second term in the square brackets of the entropy part of the functional above. The minimization of this functional presents a problem which for many component mixtures can be quite timeconsuming if the truly optimal form of the interface and free energy is to be found. One may use an iterative method of solution much like the famous scheme used to solve for the Hartree–Fock wave function in electronic structure calculations [4]. An alternative, much to be preferred when sufficiently accurate, is to use a simple parametrized form for the particle densities through the interface and then determine the optimal values of these parameters. The simplest possible scheme is, of course, to take the profile to be a step function, ni ðxÞ ¼ nli
for x < 0
¼ ngi
for x 0
ð24Þ
This will be the form of the profile if we used a fully local free energy density functional in our calculation. In the case of the HS-B2 -approximation the fully local functional would be " # ! c ð c X X ni ðrÞ 2 3 3 P jj nj ðrÞ drni ðrÞ ln þ Fc;loc ¼ kB T 3 ij 1 cj¼1 nj ðrÞjj3 i¼1 j¼1 ð25Þ ð c X c c ð X X drni ðrÞVext ðrÞ aij drni ðrÞnj ðrÞ þ i¼1 j¼1
i¼1
Note that the external field Vext vanishes in the normal surface tension calculation. In the fully local approximation there is no surface tension. Thus we can obtain the surface tension associated with a planar interface of area A by the expression ð26Þ ¼ Fc ðn1;opt ; . . . ; nc;opt Þ Fc;loc ðn1;B ; . . . ; nc;B Þ =A Here n1;opt ; . . . ; nc;opt are the correct particle densities obtained by optimizing the nonlocal free energy, while n1;B ; . . . ; nc;B imply that bulk particle densities have been used on both sides of a step function interface. The main problem is to find the free energy of the real interface with nonlocal energetic and entropic effects. For a general multicomponent interface the minimization of the nonlocal HS-B2 -functional is a nontrivial numerical problem. Fortunately, the variational nature of the problem lends itself to a stepwise solution where simple parametrization of the density profiles through the interface upon integration of the functional yields the free energy as a function of the parameters. In fact, if we take the profile to be a step function as in the case of local free energy then with local entropy we get the result ¼
c X c 27 X a ðn nig Þðnjl njg Þ 64 i¼1 j¼1 ij il
ð27Þ
The GvdW Theory
91
which is the simplest estimate of the surface tension of a mixture. It will be an overestimate, since nonlocal entropy, smooth interfacial profiles and adsorption to the interface are all surface-tension-reducing mechanisms. In order to approach the true surface tension but keep the calculation simple we can use an extension to mixtures of the tanh profile applied with great success to single component fluids. It may seem then that we could take each component to be of tanh shape but this will not be recommended here. It turns out that it is better to take the total particle density ntot and the mole fraction of each component xi ðzÞ ¼ ni ðzÞ=ntot ðzÞ to be of tanh shape, i.e., ntot;l ntot;g 1 þ expðzÞ xi;l xi;g xi ðzÞ ¼ xi;g þ 1 þ expðzÞ
ð28Þ
ntot ðzÞ ¼ ntot;g þ
i ¼ 1; . . . ; c
ð29Þ
The reason for this is subtle and subject to verification in specific cases but related to the more fundamental nature of relative concentrations than component particle densities in mixtures. If we use this tanhðn; xÞ scheme then we find, for example, that the volatile component will naturally show adsorption to the interface. This is illustrated in Fig. 2. A study of the surface tension of Lennard–Jones mixtures has recently been completed [17]. Very good agreement was obtained in comparison with both experiment and simulation. In Fig. 3 we show results obtained by this tanhðn; xÞ scheme for an Ar– methane mixture in comparison with simulation. We note that if we make the comparison at the same reduced temperature T ¼ T=Tc , then there is quite reasonable agreement with the surface tension obtained by simulation. The slight but significant deviation between the critical temperatures in the simulation and in the HS-B2 approximation will otherwise give rise to a similar deviation in surface tension. In the study of the Ar–Kr mixture we found that neither the simulation nor the GvdW theory appear to be able to reproduce a slight dip in the surface tension below linear interpolation as a function of composition unless it is assumed that the Berthelot rule should be corrected by a factor slightly less than unity, i.e., 0.97 in the case of the GvdW theory, which lowers the surface tension most for
FIG. 2 The tanhðn; xÞ profiles for a liquid–gas interface in a binary mixture are illustrated. The full and dashed lines correspond to mole fractions x1 ðzÞ and x2 ðzÞ, while dash–dotted and dotted lines correspond to particle densities n1 ðzÞ and n2 ðzÞ of a nonvolatile (1) and volatile (2) component. Note that there is adsorption of the volatile component to the interface.
92
Nordholm and Penfold
FIG. 3 The calculated surface tension of an argon–methane mixture as function of composition (mole fraction of argon) is shown as open circles in comparison with corresponding simulation results obtained by Mecke, Winkelmann, and Fischer [J. Chem. Phys. 110:1188 (1999)]. The GvdW(HS-B2 ) functional was used with tanhðn; xÞ profiles.
x ¼ 0:5 or so. Such corrections are commonly found in many other applications of the Lorentz–Berthelot mixing rules.
IV.
GVDW THEORY OF ELECTROLYTE SOLUTIONS
Electrolyte solutions have a theoretical description which is quite distinct from that of Lennard–Jones fluids. The reason is that the latter are short-range simple fluids for which the virial equation of state provides a good description of the onset of nonideality. The ionic interactions are long-range and as a consequence electrolyte solutions are predominantly correlated fluids for which the virial equation of state is inapplicable. The second virial coefficient is not definable for the Coulomb interaction, since its falloff with 1=r gives it essentially infinite range. Instead the electrolyte solutions are governed by the screening mechanism which neutralizes every charge by adsorption of counterions and desorption of coions. The screening mechanism is a correlation mechanism. Thus the GvdW theory in its very simplest form fails to capture the essence of a bulk electrolyte solution. Let us consider first the primitive restricted model of an electrolyte solution wherein the ions are hard spheres of equal size in which are embedded charges q1 and q2 , respectively, and the solvent is accounted for only by a relative dielectric permittivity . If we were to apply the HS-B2 -functional to the bulk electrolyte solution in this model we would simply end up with a hard sphere fluid, since the uncorrelated motion of counterions and coions would leave the charge density ðrÞ equal to zero everywhere around any one of the ions. Thus the mean-field approximation, which ignores correlations among the ions and therefore neglects charge screening, is not appropriate for bulk electrolytes. It may seem that the prospects are bleak for the GvdW approach to electrolytes but, in fact, the reverse is the case. We need only follow Debye and Hu¨ckel [18] into their analysis of the screening mechanism, almost as successful as the van der Waals analysis of short-range fluids, to see that the mean-field approximation can be applied to the correlation mechanism with great advantage. In fact, we can then add finite ion size effects to the analysis and thereby unify these two most successful traditional theories.
The GvdW Theory
A.
93
Recovering the Poisson–Boltzmann Equation
The GvdW density functional for a binary primitive electrolyte with the hard sphere diameters set to zero will have the form ð Fðn1 ; n2 Þ ¼ kB T dr½n1 ðrÞ ln n1 ðrÞ þ n2 ðrÞ ln n2 ðrÞ ð30Þ ð ð ð 1 1 þ drðrÞ dsðsÞ þ drext ðrÞðrÞ 2 40 jr sj Here the charge density is defined as ðrÞ ¼ q1 n1 ðrÞ þ q2 n2 ðrÞ
ð31Þ
and ext is an external electric field which is to be screened. This functional can be minimized by the Lagrange multiplier method which readily yields the result n1 ðrÞ ¼ n1B expðq1 ðrÞ=kB T Þ n2 ðrÞ ¼ n2B expðq2 ðrÞ=kB T Þ
ð32Þ
The electrostatic field is now the sum of the external field ext and an internal field created by the ions, ð 1 ð33Þ ðrÞ ¼ ext ðrÞ þ dsðsÞ 40 jr sj Recalling now the Poisson equation relating a charge density and a corresponding field we get r2 ðrÞ ¼ ðrÞ=0
ð34Þ
in the part of space where the ions make up the only charges. Finally, inserting the results for the ion densities in ðrÞ on the right we get r2 ðrÞ ¼
1 ½q n expðq1 ðrÞ=kB T Þ þ q2 n2B expðq2 ðrÞ=kB T Þ 0 1 1B
ð35Þ
This is the famous Poisson–Boltzmann equation. B.
. . . and the Debye–Hu¨ckel Theory
In their analysis of electrolyte screening Debye and Hu¨ckel assumed that the screening mechanism was weak, i.e., qi ðrÞ=kB T 1 ð36Þ for all ions i and positions r. Then the exponentials in the Poisson–Boltzmann equation can be expanded as expðqi ðrÞ=kB T Þ ’ 1 qi ðrÞ=kB T and the Poisson–Boltzmann equation takes the form " # 1 q21 n1B þ q22 n2B 2 r ðrÞ ¼ ðrÞ 0 kB T Defining the inverse screening length 0 by
ð37Þ
ð38Þ
94
Nordholm and Penfold
20 ¼¼
q21 n1B þ q22 n2B 0 kB T
ð39Þ
we have r2 ðrÞ ¼ 20 ðrÞ
ð40Þ
which is the basic equation of the Debye–Hu¨ckel theory of electrolyte screening. C.
Hole-Corrected Debye–Hu¨ckel Theory
We have seen above that GvdW theory yields Poisson–Boltzmann and Debye–Hu¨ckel theory by neglect of ion size and excluded volume effects. Let us now consider how such effects might be brought into a corrected form of Debye–Hu¨ckel theory. We note that the ion size enters in two fundamentally different ways: (1) reducing the entropy by the introduction of excluded volume and (2) altering the electrostatic energy by keeping the ions from approaching closer than the relevant hard sphere diameter ij . We shall show first that if we retain the restricted primitive model and take the charges to be symmetrical, q1 ¼ q2 , then the excluded volume effect vanishes in the linearized Debye–Hu¨ckel limit. This follows by reformulating the free energy in terms of total ion density nðrÞ ¼ n1 ðrÞ þ n2 ðrÞ and charge density ðrÞ ¼ q1 n1 ðrÞ þ q2 n2 ðrÞ, which in the symmetrical case is equal to q½n1 ðrÞ n2 ðrÞ. In the linearized theory ðrÞ is decoupled from nðrÞ, since a linear response to an electric field will preserve nðrÞ, changing the ion densities in opposite directions to the same extent. Thus the excluded volume effect is absent. This is a great simplification and undoubtedly a reason for the considerable success of the simple Debye–Hu¨ckel theory. 1. Local Hole Correction of the Electrostatic Energy While the excluded volume effect does not affect the screening mechanism in the linearized theory for symmetrical primitive electrolyte models, there is still an effect on the electrostatic energy. Note that in the Poisson–Boltzmann or Debye–Hu¨ckel theories the ions are point particles without size. The Coulomb integrals do not account for the truncation at r ¼ which is essential in the van der Waals calculation of binding energy. Putting this truncation in the Coulomb integrals turns out to be a nontrivial task so we shall approach it stepwise by first considering a local approximation [19] which is justified if 0 1, i.e., if the Debye length 1=0 is much greater than the ion size . In this limit the charge density ðrÞ is essentially constant on the length scale of and the hole correction to the electrostatic energy can be approximated as ð ð ð ð 1 1 1 1 2 drðrÞ dr ðrÞ ’ dsðsÞ ds 2 4 2 4 jr sj jr sj 0 0 s< s< ð41Þ ð 2 2 ¼ dr ðrÞ 40 This is the electrostatic energy arising from ions approaching within of each other. When subtracted from the free energy functional above the corrected Debye–Hu¨ckel equation becomes r2 ðrÞ ¼ 2 ðrÞ with defined by
ð42Þ
The GvdW Theory
95
2 ¼ 20 = 1 20 2 =2
ð43Þ
Thus we have found that the screening should be moreqefficient than in the Debye–Hu¨ckel ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi theory. The Debye length 1= is shorter by the factor 1 20 2 =2 due to the hard sphere holes cut in the Coulomb integrals which reduce the repulsion associated with counterion accumulation. A comparison with Monte Carlo simulation results [20] bears out this view of the ion size effect [19]. 2.
Nonlocal Hole Correction of the Electrostatic Energy: CDH Theory
The hole correction of the electrostatic energy is a nonlocal mechanism just like the excluded volume effect in the GvdW theory of simple fluids. We shall now consider the charge density around a hard sphere ion in an electrolyte solution still represented in the symmetrical primitive model. In order to account for this fact in the simplest way we shall assume that the charge density i ðrÞ around an ion of type i maintains its simple exponential form as obtained in the usual Debye–Hu¨ckel theory, i.e., 8 2 q i < 1 exp½ðr Þ r > 4ð1 þ Þ r ð44Þ i ðrÞ ¼ : 0 r The -value is, however, now to be determined by minimizing the free energy including nonlocal corrections of the electrostatic energy. The integrals required are elementary but large in number and one obtains finally a free energy Fc;i ðÞ ¼ TS0 þ
kB T 3 qi ½2 þ 3 þ expðÞ 2 16nB ð1 þ Þ 160 ð1 þ Þ2
ð45Þ
wherein the first term is a background free energy of the bulk electrolyte solution, the second term is related to the cost in entropy to create an exponential screening charge density, and the third term is the electrostatic energy. The total particle density is denoted nB , i.e., nB ¼ n1B þ n2B . The minimization yields a -value, which in turn allows the internal electrostatic energy to be calculated, and by Debye charging over coupling parameter one can readily obtain the osmotic coefficient ,
¼ P=nB kB T ¼ ðPð ¼ 0Þ þ PÞ=nB kB T and the activity coefficient defined by the relation X X ln ¼ xi ln i ¼ xi ði ð ¼ 0Þ þ Di Þ=kB T i
ð46Þ
ð47Þ
i
Here i ð ¼ 0Þ is the change in chemical potential of an ion of type i due to its hard sphere size and Di is the corresponding change due to its electrostatic interactions. The results are compared with Monte Carlo results for 1-1 or 2-2 salt solutions by Van Megen and Snook [20] in Figs. 4–9 and discussed in the original publication [21]. We note that the 1-1 data are very well reproduced up to more than 2M solutions. The 2-2 results show significant deviations due mainly to a nonlinear response to strong electrostatic coupling but the trends and magnitudes are well reproduced. The upturn in osmotic pressure and activity are related mainly to the hard sphere excluded volume effect which in these calculations by both the DH and the CDH theories was accounted for by the GvdW(I) equation of state for hard spheres which yields
96
Nordholm and Penfold
FIG. 4 The calculated internal energy of a 1-1 salt (line) is compared with the corresponding simulation results (open circles) obtained by Van Megen and Snook (Ref. 20). The Debye–Hu¨ckel (DH, dashed line) and corrected Debye–Hu¨ckel (CDH, full line) theory were used together with a GvdW(I) treatment of the uncharged hard-sphere mixture. The ion diameter was 4.25 A˚, the temperature was 298 K and the dielectric constant was 78.36.
FIG. 5 As in Fig. 4 but the osmotic coefficient is shown.
The GvdW Theory
FIG. 6 As in Fig. 4 but the logarithm of the mean activity coefficient is shown.
FIG. 7 As in Fig. 4 but the internal energy of a 2-2 salt is shown.
97
98
Nordholm and Penfold
FIG. 8 As in Fig. 4 but the osmotic coefficient of a 2-2 salt is shown.
FIG. 9 As in Fig. 4 but the logarithm of the mean activity coefficient for a 2-2 salt is shown.
The GvdW Theory
99
X
2 lnð1 niB 3 Þ ln niB Fc ð ¼ 0Þ ¼ kB T Ni 3 i " # 2 nB 3 Pð ¼ 0Þ ¼ nB kB T 1 þ 3 1 nB 3 " # 2 nB 3 3 k T lnð1 nB Þ 1 ð ¼ 0Þ ¼ 3 B 1 nB 3
ð48Þ ð49Þ
ð50Þ
Thus we can see that a combination of van der Waals treatment of hard sphere excluded volume and Debye–Hu¨ckel treatment of screening with a minor generalization to account for hole correction of electrostatic interactions yields quite accurate bulk thermodynamic data for symmetrical salt solutions. 3. Hole Correction of the Debye–Hu¨ckel Coion Density Profile: The DHH Theory So far in our revision of the Debye–Hu¨ckel theory we have focused our attention on the truncation of Coulomb integrals due to hard sphere holes formed around the ions. The corresponding corrections have redefined the inverse Debye length but not altered the exponential form of the charge density. Now we shall take note of the fact that the exponential form of the charge density cannot be maintained at high -values, since this would imply a negative coion density for small separations. Recall that in the linear theory for symmetrical primitive electrolyte models we have ðrÞ ¼ q1 n1 ðrÞ þ q2 n2 ðrÞ ¼ q½n1 ðrÞ n2 ðrÞ and, if the central ion is of type 1 and q1 ¼ q > 0, then 8 2 1 exp½ðr Þ < n 1 ðrÞ ¼ n 1B 1B 2q 8ð1 þ Þ r n1 ðrÞ ¼ : 0
ð51Þ
r>
ð52Þ
r
Now we see that if is large enough and small enough then n1 ðrÞ will become negative for small r before the truncation arises at r ¼ . This is, of course, impossible and we must either abandon the use of the linearized DH (Debye–Hu¨ckel) approach altogether or eliminate the negative portion of the coion density profile. It turns out that nature, as usual, is benign and allows us to retain the simple DH form of profile and still get good accuracy for many strongly coupled electrolytes as long as we remove the unphysical negative particle densities [22]. A particularly illustrative case is offered by the so-called one-component plasma (OCP) model wherein one component is made up of charged point particles and the other is a uniform neutralizing background charge density. The Debye–Hu¨ckel theory now leads to the charge density ðrÞ ¼
q20 1 expðrÞ 4 r
ð53Þ
which will always produce an unphysical ion density nðrÞ ¼ nB
20 1 expð0 rÞ 4 r
for sufficiently small r. Here the DH -value is given by
ð54Þ
100
Nordholm and Penfold
20 ¼
nB q2 3 ¼ 2 0 kB T a
ð55Þ
where a ¼ ð3=4nB Þ1=3 and the coupling strength is defined as q2 =ð40 kB TaÞ. The DH theory then leads to the result for the electrostatic potential energy per ion u u^ ¼
u ð3Þ3=2 ¼ kB T 6
ð56Þ
the electrostatic contribution to the free energy 2 ð3Þ f^ ¼ F=NkB T ¼ u^ ¼ 3 9
3=2
ð57Þ
and the osmotic coefficient
0 ¼
P 1 ð3Þ3=2 ¼ 1 þ u^ ¼ 1 nB kB T 3 18
ð58Þ
The accuracy of the DH results for u^ , f^, and 0 is good for low coupling strength, < 1, but for higher coupling strength the errors become very large. By correcting the ion density so that it vanishes rather than going negative for small r while maintaining full neutralization, i.e., 8
< n 1 h exp½ ðr hÞ r>h B 0 r nðrÞ ¼ ð59Þ : 0 r h we get a greatly improved representation of the screening and the thermodynamic properties. The hole can be found to have the size h given by 1=3 i ! 1 1 h 1 þ ð3Þ3=2 1 ¼ ð60Þ h¼ 0 0 where we have introduced the auxiliary variable ! ¼ ð1 þ ð3Þ3=2 Þ1=3 . The thermodynamic properties can then be readily found to be 1 u^ ¼ ð!2 1Þ 4 " ! # 2 1 ! þ ! þ 1 2 ! 1 2 f^ ¼ ! 1 ln þ pffiffiffi arctan pffiffiffi 4 3 3 3ð! þ 1Þ
¼1
1 2 ð! 1Þ 12
ð61Þ ð62Þ ð63Þ
The results of the simple DHH theory outlined here are shown compared with DH results and corresponding Monte Carlo results in Figs. 10–12. Clearly, the major error of the DH theory has been accounted for. The OCP model is greatly idealized but the same hole correction method can be applied to more realistic electrolyte models. In a series of articles the DHH theory has been applied to a one-component plasma composed of charged hard spheres [23], to local correlation correction of the screening of macroions by counterions [24], and to the generation of correlated free energy density functionals for electrolyte solutions [25,26]. The extensive results obtained bear out the hopeful view of the DHH approximation provided by the OCP results shown here. It is noteworthy that in
The GvdW Theory
101
FIG. 10 The calculated internal energy of a one-component plasma as a function of coupling strength is compared with corresponding simulation results (open circles) by Brush, Sahlin, and Teller (J. Chem. Phys. 45:2102 (1966). The Debye–Hu¨ckel (DH) and hole-corrected Debye– Hu¨ckel (DHH) theories were used with results as shown (indicated lines).
FIG. 11 As in Fig. 10 but the osmotic coefficient is shown.
102
Nordholm and Penfold
FIG. 12
As in Fig. 10 but the reduced free energy is shown.
the case of hard sphere ions the electrostatic hole is at high coion density and weak coupling preempted by the hard sphere hole. The latter were accounted for in the CDH theory above as a general reduction of Coulomb interactions due to hard sphere exclusion. The DHH theory brings in electrostatic hole formation between ions of the same charge. In both cases we have applied simple correlation mechanisms in the spirit of the original van der Waals analysis which applies, with some generalization, as well to electrolytes as to simple fluids.
V.
CONCLUSION
Our review of the generalized van der Waals theory has taken us from the simple cubic equation of state, which is known to all chemists, to the surface tension problem, which can be regarded as the most important nonuniform fluid property, to the electrolyte screening mechanism in salt solutions. Along this route we went from bulk behavior through the interfacial properties to the correlation dominated Coulomb fluids retaining the simple physical van der Waals approach to fluids. We thereby hope to have demonstrated that this analysis combining volume exclusion correlations with mean-field neglect of correlations is capable of very fruitful generalization and extension to widespread phenomena and very useful accuracy. Thus we have found within the confines of the variational formulation of the GvdW theory not only the traditional van der Waals theory but also the Poisson–Boltzmann and Debye–Hu¨ckel theories and all the applications of these theories to fluids of both short range and long range interactions. Bulk thermodynamic properties, adsorption, surface tension and screening phenomena can be simply and efficiently addressed. A key role in the efficiency is played by the variational density functional approach which permits simple parametrized density profiles to be used. This is particularly well illustrated by the tanh profiles in the surface tension applications and
The GvdW Theory
103
by the use of Debye–Hu¨ckel charge densities with optimized -values in the electrolyte applications. Electrochemistry is, with its combination of simple fluids and ions, a natural area of application for the GvdW theory. Here there is an obvious need to understand both the short-range fluids, the long-range electrolyte solutions and their properties in bulk and at interfaces. We hope this review can provide a useful tool for electrochemists and many others with communal interests and stimulate further progress in a field rich in fluid phenomena and mechanisms.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT We would like to thank S. Sarman for help in the preparation of this review and the Swedish Natural Science Research Council for financial support.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26.
J. D. van der Waals, Dissertation, Leiden, 1873. A. Ya. Kipnis, B. E. Yavelov, and J. S. Rowlinson, Van der Waals and Molecular Science, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1996. J. D. van der Waals. Z. Phys. Chem. (Leipzig) 13:657 (1894). R. G. Parr and W. Yang, Density-Functional Methods of Atoms and Molecules, Oxford University Press, New York, 1989. A. D. Becke. J. Chem. Phys. 88:1053 (1988); ibid. 98:5648 (1993). P. Tarazona. Mol. Phys. 52:81 (1984); Phys. Rev. A 31:2672 (1985). W. A. Curtin and N. W. Ashcroft. Phys. Rev. A 32:2909 (1985). S. Nordholm and A. D. J. Haymet. Aust. J. Chem. 30:2013 (1980). S. Nordholm and J. Gibson. Aust. J. Chem. 34:2263 (1981). S. Nordholm, M. Johnson, and B. C. Freasier. Aust. J. Chem. 33:2139 (1980). B. C. Freasier, C. E. Woodward, and S. Nordholm. J. Chem. Phys. 90:5657 (1989). S. Nordholm and R. Penfold. J. Chem. Phys. 96:3022 (1992). M. A. Hooper and S. Nordholm. Aust. J. Chem. 34:1809 (1981). S. Abbas and S. Nordholm. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 166:481 (1994). S. Nordholm, P. R. Harrowell, and K. Cheung. Aust. J. Chem. 35:247 (1982). P. R. Harrowell and S. Nordholm. Aust. J. Chem. 35:673 (1982). H. Greberg, G. Paolini, J. Satherley, R. Penfold, and S. Nordholm. J. Colloid Interface Sci. (submitted). P. Debye and E. Hu¨ckel. Phys. Z. 24:185 (1923). S. Nordholm. J. Chem. Phys. 78:5759 (1983). W. Van Megen and I. Snook. Mol. Phys. 39:1043 (1980). S. Nordholm. Aust. J. Chem. 37:1 (1984). S. Nordholm. Chem. Phys. Lett. 105:302 (1984). R. Penfold, S. Nordholm, B Jo¨nsson, and C. E. Woodward. J. Chem. Phys. 92:1915 (1990). R. Penfold, S. Nordholm, B. Jo¨nsson, and C. E. Woodward. J. Chem. Phys. 95:2055 (1991). R. Penfold and S. Nordholm. J. Chem. Phys. 96:3102 (1992). R. Penfold, B. Jo¨nsson, S. Nordholm, and N. Nichols. Phys. Rev. E (to appear).
5 Adsorption at Polarized Liquid^Liquid Interfaces TAKASHI KAKIUCHI Department of Energy and Hydrocarbon Chemistry, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
I.
INTRODUCTION
Adsorption is the term used to describe the state of a system, composed of two phases in contact, in which the concentration of a certain substance is enriched or depleted at the interface where the phases meet, e.g., air–water, liquid–liquid, solid–liquid, or solid–solid interfaces. So far as our life is concerned, liquid interfaces are much more important than other interfaces. First, the sum of the areas of various liquid interfaces relevant to us would definitely be much larger than that of other types of interfaces, as can be envisaged by thinking of various membranes in biological cells. Second, liquid interfaces, in particular, liquid–liquid interfaces are replenishable and adaptive to their environment down to the nanometer scale. This flexibility is indispensable in developing biological functions as well as in homeostasis. Furthermore, the fact that the facile mass transfer is possible on both sides of the liquid–liquid interface between the two solution phases of different solvation characters allows intricate designing of chemical reactions unique to biological systems. Recent advances in biochemistry and molecular biology have elucidated numerous intriguing mechanisms of specific recognition of molecules and its functioning in biological systems, e.g., antigen–antibody interactions and various receptors on cell membranes which can be energized in response to even a single molecule [1,2]. The concept of adsorption thus seems to have been replaced by more specific interactions between physiologically active molecules and their specific receptors, which may be better described by intermolecular interactions than surface phenomena. The term adsorption tacitly assumes the averaging of intermolecular interactions over a certain ensemble in a heterogeneous environment, as does the concept of ‘‘interface’’ which implies a boundary between the two statistically meaningful and macroscopically distinguishable phases. Adsorption is thus a macroscopic concept in that the interaction between adsorbate molecules and a heterogeneous environment created by a large number of other molecules and atoms plays a decisive role. All specific interactions between physiologically active molecules and its receptors actually take place in such many-body environments. The physicochemical properties of liquid interfaces are therefore worth paying continuing and increasing attention in biochemistry, biophysics, and pharmacological science. 105
106
Kakiuchi
The appreciation of the importance of adsorption phenomena at liquid interfaces is probably as old as human history, since it is easily recognized in many facets of everyday life. It is not surprising that liquid interfaces have been a favorite subject of scientific interest since as early as the eighteenth century [3,4]. From an experimental point of view, one obvious virtue of the liquid interfaces for studying adsorption phenomena is that we can use surface tension or interfacial tension for thermodynamic analysis of the surface properties. The interfacial tension is related to the adsorbed amount of surface active substances through the Gibbs adsorption equation, X i di at T; P ¼ const: ð1Þ d ¼ i
where is the interfacial tension, i is the relative surface excess of the component i, and i is the chemical potential of i in the adjacent solution phase. Thanks to its fluid character, the interfacial tension can be accurately determined using a variety of methods. The measurement of the interfacial tension at the solid surface is, on the contrary, not straightforward, because of the contribution of the strain term to the deformation of the interface [5]. X d ¼ i di þ ð gÞ de at T; P ¼ const: ð2Þ i
where g is the stress and e is the equilibrium strain, both of which are tensor quantities. The development of thermodynamic analysis of solid surfaces lagged behind the study of liquid surfaces by about a century due to these stress and strain terms [5]. The meaning of experimentally obtained macroscopic properties is still a subject of discussion, especially in relation to microscopic information about the interface in the atomic or molecular scale now compiled [6,7]. The availability of thermodynamically reliable quantities at liquid interfaces is advantageous as a reference in examining data obtained by other surface specific techniques. The model-independent solid information about thermodynamics of adsorption can be used as a norm in microscopic interpretation and understanding of currently available surface specific experimental techniques and theoretical approaches such as molecular dynamics simulations. This chapter will focus on the adsorption at the polarized liquid– liquid interfaces, which enable us to externally control the phase-boundary potential, providing an additional degree of freedom in studying the adsorption of electrified interfaces. A main emphasis will be on some aspects that have not been fully dealt with in previous reviews and monographs [8–21].
II.
THERMODYNAMIC REFLECTIONS ON LIQUID–LIQUID INTERFACES
Thermodynamics of adsorption at liquid interfaces has been well established [22–24]. Of particular interest in view of biochemical and pharmaceutical applications is the adsorption of ionic substances, as many of biologically active compounds are ionic under the physiological conditions. For studying the adsorption of ionic components at the liquid– liquid interface, the polarized liquid–liquid interface is advantageous in that the adsorption of ionic components can be examined by strictly controlling the electrical state of the interface, which is in contrast to the adsorption studies at the air–water or nonpolar oil– water interfaces [25].
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
A.
107
Thermodynamics of Electrocapillarity
Every interface is more or less electrically charged, unless special care is exercised experimentally [26]. The energy of the system containing the interface hence depends on its electrical state. The thermodynamics of interfaces that explicitly takes account of the contribution of the phase-boundary potential is called the thermodynamics of electrocapillarity [27]. Thermodynamic treatments of the electrocapillary phenomena at the electrode–solution interface have been generalized to the polarized as well as nonpolarized liquid–liquid interface by Kakiuchi [28] and further by Markin and Volkov [29]. We summarize the essential idea of the electrocapillary equation, so far as it will be required in the following. The electrocapillary equation for a polarized liquid–liquid interface has the form X d ¼ qW dE þ i0 di at T; P ¼ const: ð3Þ i
where qW is the excess surface charge density on the aqueous side of the interface, E is the phase-boundary potential referred to the potential of the oil phase and is measured using appropriate reference electrodes, each of which reversibly responds to the activity of an ionic species in the corresponding phase, and i0 is the relative surface excess of a component i. The sum is taken over all chemical potentials, in both phases, which are independently altered. In the case of polarized interface where no ionic species are in common to both phases, E can be changed independently keeping the chemical composition of the two phases constant. If the system contains at least one common ionic species, E becomes dependent on the composition of ionic species in the system, i.e., nonpolarized interface. One important advantage of the polarized interface is that one can determine the relative surface excess of an ionic species whose counterions are reversible to a reference electrode. The adsorption properties of an ionic component, e.g., ionic surfactant, can thus be studied independently, i.e., without being disturbed by the presence of counterionic species, unlike the case of ionic surfactant adsorption at nonpolar oil–water and air–water interfaces [25]. The merits of the polarized interface are not available at nonpolarized liquid–liquid interfaces, because of the dependency of the phase-boundary potential on the solution composition.
B.
Surface Excess
The meaning of the surface excess is illustrated in Fig. 1, in which the solid line represents the actual concentration profile of an adsorbate i, when the bulk concentration of i in the phase ( ¼ O or W) is ci . The hatched area corresponds to be the surface excess of i, i . This quantity depends on the location of the dividing surface. On the other hand, the experimentally accessible quantity should not depend on the location of the artificially introduced dividing surface. The relative surface excess, which is independent of the location of the dividing surface, is defined by relativizing it with respect to those of certain reference components. In oil–water interfaces, the mutual solubility of solvents can be significant. The relative surface excess in Eq. (3) is then related to the surface excesses through W i0 ¼ i JxO i Kxi
for the component i which itself is miscible between the two phases, and
ð4Þ
108
Kakiuchi
FIG. 1 An illustration of the meaning of surface excess.
j0 ¼ j KxW j
ð5Þ
j0 ¼ j JxO j
ð6Þ
or
for the component j which is present only in W [Eq. (5)] or O [Eq. (6)], where J¼
W l 00 xW l 0 l 0 xl 00 O O W xW l 0 xl 00 xl 0 xl 00
ð7Þ
K¼
O l 0 xO l 00 l 00 xl 0 O O W xW l 0 xl 00 xl 0 xl 00
ð8Þ
and the subscripts l 0 and l 00 designate the solvent species. Thermodynamically available is the relative surface excess defined by one of Eqs. (4)–(6). The necessity of this relativization comes from the Gibbs–Duhem equation, which imposes the restriction of the change in chemical potentials in one phase. When a component of interest is considerably surface active, its adsorbed amount is high even when its bulk concentration is low. The second terms on the right-hand side of Eqs. (4)–(6) are then small and the relative surface excesses are simply taken as the surface excesses, which, in turn, may be seen as the surface concentration. For example, dilauroylphosphatidylcholine forms a saturated monolayer in the liquid-expanded state at the nitrobenzene–water interface when its concentration in nitrobenzene is 105 mol dm3 [30]. Then the experimentally obtained value, 1:76 1010 mol cm2 , can be considered to be the surface concentration. The second terms on the right-hand side of Eqs. (4)–(6), however, are not always negligible. The negative adsorption, i.e., the depletion, of nonsurface active ions is associated with the contribution of the second term, making the value on the left-hand side negative [31]. In this case, the interfacial tension at the potential of zero charge, pzc,
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
109
increases with the increase in the chemical potential of a salt composed of nonspecifically adsorbed ions. The magnitude of the increase can be estimated through Eq. (3) ð ln a2 pzc ¼ 2RT i0 dðln aÞ ð9Þ ln a1
where a is the mean ionic activity of the ion i. The increase in surface tension is observed also at the air–electrolyte solution interface [32].
C.
Adsorption Isotherms
In its broad sense, an adsorption isotherm is an experimental or theoretical functional relationship between the adsorbed amount of a component and its amount in the bulk phase adjacent to the interface. Usually, the adsorption isotherm of a component i has the form Bi ci ¼ f ð i Þ
ð10Þ
where Bi is the adsorption coefficient of i for the adsorption from the phase ð ¼ O or W), ci is the concentration of i, and f ð i Þ is the fugacity of i at the interface and is a certain function of the surface coverage of i, i . Bi is related to the standard adsorption free energy of adsorption of i from the phase through G;0 ads;i ¼ RT ln Bi . The standard ;0 3 1 states for this Gads;i are a unit concentration (mol dm , mol kg , etc.) of i in the phase referred to the infinite dilution and i ¼ 1 in the adsorbed state. Most frequently found to experimentally describe observed adsorption isotherms are the Langmuir adsorption isotherm, f ð i Þ ¼
i 1 i
ð11Þ
and the Frumkin isotherm, f ð i Þ ¼
i expð2a i Þ 1 i
ð12Þ
where a is the interaction parameter, which represents the intermolecular interaction between adsorbed molecules and is negative in the case of the presence of repulsion and is positive in the case of attraction. However, care must be exercised in interpreting the physical meaning of the parameters obtained from fitting experimental data to those isotherms, because theoretically distant adsorption isotherms can be phenomenologically very similar. One can further elaborate a model to have a concrete form of f ð i Þ, depending on which aspect of the adsorption one wants to describe more precisely, e.g., a more rigorous treatment of intermolecular interactions between adsorbed species, the activity instead of the concentration of adsorbates, the competitive adsorption of multiple species, or the difference in the size of the molecule between the solvent and the adsorbate. An extension that may be particularly pertinent to liquid interfaces has been made by Markin and Volkov, who allowed for the replacement of solvent molecules and adsorbate molecules based on the surface solution model [33,34]. Their isotherm, the amphiphilic isotherm takes the form
110
Kakiuchi
BxrA ¼
½ p ðp 1Þ p1 expð2a Þ pp ð1 Þp
ð13Þ
where xA is the mole fraction of the adsorbate A, r is the number of aggregates of surfactant at the interface and p is the number of solvent molecules replaced by one surfactant molecule. One may further generalize this amphiphilic isotherm to accommodate the difference in the size of two solvent species or to use higher approximations to allow for the intermolecular interactions. The adsorption free energy and other parameters may be determined, provided that a proper adsorption isotherm is identified and is fitted to experimental data. However, it is usually difficult to unequivocally choose an appropriate isotherm; an experimental isotherm may well be fitted to a multitude of theoretical isotherms having several adjustable parameters. If the adsorption isotherm at a very small surface coverage is accessible experimentally, the adsorption free energy can be determined from the limiting slope of the isotherm, as all isotherms reduce to Henry’s law when ! 0: Bi ci ¼ i
ð14Þ
Experimentally, may not be directly available. Then, Henry’s law of the form 0
Bi ci ¼ i
ð15Þ 0
is more practical. The standard state of for the adsorption free energy, RT ln Bi , is then i ¼ 1, instead of i ¼ 1. D.
Adsorption and Partitioning of Ionic Components in Liquid–Liquid Two-Phase Systems
1. Correlation Between Adsorption and Partition In the case of the adsorption at a liquid–liquid interface, the adsorption is possible from both sides of the interface and hence the adsorption of an adsorbate at the interface is not independent of its partitioning between the two phases. This link between the adsorption and partition is unique to liquid–liquid interfaces and is of particular importance in the case of the adsorption of ionic components, since both adsorption and partition of ionic components strongly depend on the phase-boundary potential [23]. Suppose that an ionic component i is in a distribution equilibrium between an oil phase O and an aqueous phase W and also adsorbs at the interface between O and W. At equilibrium, the condition of distribution equilibrium is W O i ¼ i
ð16Þ
If the adsorption equilibrium is also established, S O i ¼ i
ð17Þ
S W i ¼ i
ð18Þ
and
where S stands for the interface. Hence, Eqs. (16), (17), and (18) are not independent of each other. This means that the adsorption free energies of i vary with the phase-boundary potential, since from Eq. (16) the Nernst equation holds for ion partitioning,
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces W W O ¼ O i þ
RT cO ln i zi F cW i
111
ð19Þ
where W O is the phase-boundary potential, that is, the difference in the inner potentials in O and W, W O [35]. W O i is the standard ion-transfer potential of ion i, which is related to the standard free energy of the transfer of ion i from O to W through [8] GO!W; ¼ zi FW O i tr;i
Remembering Eq. (10), from Eqs. (17)–(19), we obtain W O;0 W GW;0 ads;i Gads;i ¼ zi F O O i
ð20Þ
ð21Þ
where G;0 ads;i is the standard adsorption free energy for the adsorption of i from the phase ( ¼ W or O). Figure 2 illustrates that the change in the phase-boundary potential is O;0 proportioned to GW;0 ads;i and Gads;i with a coefficient . The difference in the adsorption at the O/W interface of a substance from O and from W expresses the hydrophilic– lipophilic balance (HLB) of the substance and should be related to the HLB used for predicting the type of emulsion [36]. Equation (21) and hence Eq. (19), show how the HLB of an ionic component varies with the phase-boundary potential (cf. Fig. 2). In other words, the right-hand side of Eq. (21) defines the electrochemical HLB for this twophase system. O;0 When the two adsorption free energies is equal, e.g., GW;0 ads;i ¼ Gads;i ; W W O balance ¼ O i
ð22Þ
Thus, the HLB of an ionic surface-active substance is balanced at the standard ion-trans fer potential. This is simply a reinterpretation of the definition of W O i , but is a very important relation, which is valid no matter what the actual form of the adsorption
FIG. 2 A schematic representation of the relationship between adsorption free energy for the adsorption from the phase ( ¼ O or W), G;0 ads;i , and the phase and phase-boundary potential, O;0 ;0 W;0 ;0; ;0; W is G;0 O , where Gads;i ¼ Gads;i þ RT y, Gads;i ¼ Gads;i RTð1 Þy, Gads;i ads;i at
W W W W O ¼ O i , and y ¼ ðz; F=RTÞ½O O i :
112
Kakiuchi
isotherm is. The intrinsic surface activity of a series of ionic surfactants at the liquid–liquid W ;0; interface should be defined in two ways. One is the values of G;0 ads;i at O i , Gads;i . ;0 The other is Gads;i at the potential of zero charge (PZC), where no direct electrostatic effect is expected. The former reflects the affinity to the interfacial region when the driving forces toward the interface from W and from O are balanced, notwithstanding that the surface activity at W O i is exhibited under the influence of the phase-boundary potential W as O i is usually different from the PZC. G;0 ads;i values at the PZC are, however, useful in comparing the ‘‘intrinsic’’ or ‘‘chemical’’ surface activities of ionic compounds. 2. Effect of Phase-Boundary Potential on Adsorption Free Energy In the case of the adsorption of ions, the adsorption free energy is proportional to the excess surface charge density [37], or the phase-boundary potential, W O . The latter proportionality stems from the experimental linear relationship between qW and W O
[31]. On the other hand, the adsorption free energy is quadratically dependent on W O
in the case of the adsorption of neutral compounds [38]. It seems that within the experimentally available range of the potential window, ca. 300 mV the linear term prevails in the adsorption of ionic surfactants [39,40]. Therefore, W O; W GO;0 ads;i ¼ Gads;i þ zi F O O i
ð23Þ
where is the constant that does not vary with W O . From Eqs. (16–18) and (23), we can derive for GW;0 ads;i W W;0; W GW;0 ads;i ¼ Gads;i zi Fð1 Þ O O i
ð24Þ
In Eqs. (23) and (24), 0 1, because otherwise they contradict with the Nernst equaW;0 tion, which is a thermodynamic requirement. Thus GO;0 rds;i and Gads;i vary with the phase-boundary potential oppositely, as illustrated in Fig. 3. The parallelism between W the above dependence of G;0 ads;i on O and the Butler–Volmer relationship in electron
FIG. 3 An illustration of the change in adsorption free energy with phase-boundary potential.
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
113
transfer reactions or ion transfer reactions [19] illustrates the simplest way of dividing the electrochemical driving force into two complementary and counteracting subprocesses. 3.
Dependence of Adsorptivity on Phase-Boundary Potential
We have seen that when a cationic (anionic) surfactant adsorbs from W, GW;0 ads;i becomes increasingly negative (positive) with the positive (negative) shift of W O , leading to the stronger adsorption from the W (O) side of the interface. However, simultaneously, the bulk concentration of the cationic (anionic) surfactant in W becomes extremely small as the positive (negative) shift of W O . It is therefore interesting to examine the dependence of adsorptivity, that is, the product of the adsorption coefficient and the concentration [cf. Eq. (10)], on the phase-boundary potential [73]. We consider an oil–water two-phase system, which contains an ionic surfactant i. If we vary the phase-boundary potential either by externally applying the voltage using two electrodes or by adjusting the solution composition of potential determining ions, the concentration of i in each phase varies accordingly, keeping the total amount of i in the system, mi , constant. The condition of the latter is O O V W cW i þ V ci ¼ m i
ð25Þ
where V is the volume of the phase . By combining this equation with Eqs. (10) and (23), we obtain for the adsorption from the O phase, B i mi ¼ f ð Þ
ð26Þ
where B is the adsorption coefficient at W O i . The only potential-dependent term, , is given by
i ¼
eð1 Þy 1 þ rey
ð27Þ
zi F W O W O i RT
ð28Þ
where y¼
and r is V O =V W . Figure 4 illustrates the dependence of i on W O for the case when r ¼ 1 at several different values of i [Fig. 4(a)] and when i ¼ 0:5 and at several different values of r [Fig. 4(b)]. From Fig. 4(a), one can see that i takes a maximum around y ¼ 0, i.e., W O i . The volume ratio affects strongly the value of i as shown in Fig. 4(b), which is ascribed to the dependence of the equilibrium concentration on r through Eq. (25). This simple example illustrates the necessity of taking into account the variation of the phase-boundary potential, and hence the adsorption of i, when one tries to measure the adsorption properties of a certain ionic species in the oil–water two-phase systems by changing the concentration of i in one of the phases. A similar situation exists also in voltammetric measurements of the transfer of surface-active ions across the polarized O/W interface. In this case, the timevarying thickness of the diffusion layers plays the role of the fixed volume in the above partition example. The adsorption of surface-active ions is hence expected to reach a maximum around the half-wave potential of the ion transfer.
114
Kakiuchi
FIG. 4 (a) Dependence of i on W O at r ¼ 1 when i ¼ 0:1 (curve 1), 0.3 (curve 2), 0.5 (curve 3), 0.7 (curve 4), and 0.9 (curve 5). (b) Dependence of i on W O at i ¼ 0:5 and when r ¼ 0:01 (curve 1), 0.1 (curve 2), 1 (curve 3), 10 (curve 4), and 100 (curve 5).
III.
INTERPHASE INTERACTIONS AT LIQUID–LIQUID INTERFACES
One notable feature of the liquid–liquid interface is that molecules in one phase can interact at the interface with other molecules dissolved in the other phase. This subject has not been treated in depth in previous review articles on electrochemical studies of liquid–liquid interfaces. A.
Interfacial Tension Measurements
Electrocapillary curves, i.e., the interfacial tension vs. the applied potential curves are well known for the mercury–solution interface and have been utilized also for interpreting the
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
115
surface properties of nonmetallic electrified interfaces, e.g., colloid surfaces, although the mercury–solution interface is considerably different from oil–solution interfaces. The establishment of the polarized oil–water interfaces has widened the applicability of the concept of electrocapillarity and has elucidated new electrochemical aspects of oil–water interfaces [19]. A first attempt to analyze the double layer structure at the polarized nitrobenzene– water interface was made by Kakiuchi and Senda based on the electrocapillary curves and the Gouy–Chapman theory [31]. It was shown that the thermodynamic study of the ion adsorption is possible using the framework of the approach developed in studying the mercury–solution interface. The main conclusion was that the modified Verway–Niessen model [41] of the electrical double layer, i.e., the ion free inner layer is interposed between two diffuse double layers which are well described by the Gouy–Chapman theory. They later applied the same approach for studying the adsorption of ionic and nonionic surfactants at the nitrobenzene–water interface. Figure 5 shows the electrocapillary curves when hexadecyltrimethylammonium ions (HTMAþ ) are present in the nitrobenzene phase. Interestingly, the interfacial tension decreased only when the potential E EPZC is negative. In other words, HTMAþ ions adsorb at the interface only when W O is negative and
> 0. Even in the absence of externally applied potential, are not surface active when W O
0:4 V, depending on the ionic the distribution potential can vary between 0:4 W O
FIG. 5 Electrocapillary curves for the interface between aqueous solution of 0.05 mol dm3 LiCl and nitrobenzene solution of 0:1 x mol dm3 tetrapentylammonium tetraphenylborate þ x mol dm3 hexadecyltrimethylammonium tetraphenylborate at 25 C: x ¼ 0 (*), 0.005 (~), 0.02 (&), 0.05 (*), and 0.1 (~). (From Ref. 39, reproduced by permission. The Chemical Society of Japan.)
116
Kakiuchi
species involved [42]. The observed marked dependence of the surface activity on W O
may therefore be of considerable importance in understanding the surface activity of ionic components in actual systems, e.g., microemulsion and vesicles. The interaction between the adsorbed molecules and a chemical species present in the opposite side of the interface is clearly seen in the effect of the counterion species on the HTMAþ adsorption. Electrocapillary curves in Fig. 6 show that the interfacial tension at a given potential in the presence of the HTMAþ ion adsorption depends on the anionic species in the aqueous side of the interface and decreases in the order, F , Cl , and Br [40]. By changing the counterions from F to Cl or Br , the adsorption free energy of HTMAþ increase by 1.2 or 4.6 kJ mol1 . This greater effect of Br ions is in harmony with the results obtained at the air–water interface [43]. We note that this effect of the counterion species from the opposite side of the interface does not necessarily mean the interfacial ion-pair formation, which seems to suppose the presence of salt formation at the boundary layer [44–46]. A thermodynamic criterion of the interfacial ion-pair formation has been discussed in detail [40]. Another interesting example of the interaction of adsorbates with ions belonging to the opposite side of the interface is the adsorption of nonionic surfactants having an oligo(ethylene glycol) unit as a hydrophilic group. Figure 7 shows the electrocapillary curves for the adsorption of tetra(ethylene glycol) mono-n-dodecyl ether (C12E4) at the nitrobenzene–water interface [47]. Unlike ionic surfactants, the interfacial tension is lowered over the entire range of the potential window. However, the adsorbed amount of this
FIG. 6 Comparison of electrocapillary curves for the interface between nitrobenzene solution of 0.1 mol dm3 hexadecyltrimethylammonium tetraphenylborate and aqueous solution of 0.05 mol dm3 LiF (*), LiCl (~), and LiBr (&). (From Ref. 40, reproduced by permission. The Chemical Society of Japan.)
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
117
FIG. 7 Electrocapillary curves at 25 C for the interface between nitrobenzene solution of 0.1 mol dm3 tetrapentylammonium tetraphenylborate and aqueous solution of 0.5 mol dm3 LiCl in the presence of x mmol dm3 C12E4: x ¼ 0 (curve 1), 1 (curve 2), 2 (curve 3), 5 (curve 4), 7 (curve 5), 10 (curve 6), 15 (curve 7), 20 (curve 8), 30 (curve 9), 40 (curve 10), 50 (curve 11), 70 (curve 12), 80 (curve 13), and 100 (curve 14). (From Ref. 47, reproduced by permission. The Chemical Society of Japan.)
surfactant shows a pronounced dependence on the phase-boundary potential as shown in Fig. 8. This dependence is caused by the interaction of the tetraethylene glycol unit of adsorbed C12E4 from the nitrobenzene side with Liþ ions at the interface. As W O is made more positive, the surface concentration of Liþ ions in the aqueous solution side of the interface increases, which favors the interaction of the tetraethylene glycol unit and Liþ ions. By using the Gouy–Chapman theory for the dependence of the surface concentration of Liþ ions, the observed dependence of the adsorption of C12E4 is satisfactorily explained [48]. Recent studies of complex formation reactions between calix[4]arene in 1,2-dichroloethane and divalent cations in water using a pendant drop method [49] and a Langmuir–Blodgett monolayers [50] have shown the importance of the surface process in the heterogeneous environment. Since poly(oxyethylene)-type nonionic surfactants have a capability of facilitating the transfer of cations [51,52], the above interphase complexation may be seen as an example of precomplex formation before the bulk transfer of ions, which is seen when W O
is sufficiently positive. The presence of such precomplex formation at the interface, which is detectable voltammetrically [53], may have significance in the rate of complex formation and the selectivity in the bulk facilitated transfer. B.
Electrochemical Techniques
Among a few electrochemical techniques available for studying the adsorption, the AC impedance technique has been most widely employed. Its high sensitivity to the physico-
118
Kakiuchi
FIG. 8 Dependence of the adsorbed amount of C12E4 on the applied potential. Concentration of C12E4 in nitrobenzene is 50 (curve 1), 20 (curve 2), 10 (curve 3), and 5 (curve 4) mmol dm3 . (From Ref. 47, reproduced by permission. The Chemical Society of Japan.)
chemical state of the liquid–liquid interface in addition to its ease of measurements, makes the double layer capacitance a particularly attractive probe for studying the adsorption at polarized liquid–liquid interfaces. The capacitance measurements have been employed for studying the adsorption of phospholipids [54–54] and other surfactants [57] at the polarized oil–water interface. The capacitance is sensitive enough to detect the phase transition of adsorbed phospholipid monolayers [58,59]. Cyclic voltammetry can also be employed to assess the magnitude of double layer capacitance [60]. Potential-step measurements using a micropipet have been used for evaluating the capacitance of and the transfer across a phospholipid monolayer [61]. Phospholipids are adsorbed at the nitrobenzene–water interface from the nitrobenzene solution side. The interaction of adsorbed dipalmitoylphosphatidylserine and Ca2þ or Mg2þ causes a dramatic effect in the state of the monolayer; the critical concentration was found to be 2 mmol dm3 for both Ca2þ and Mr2þ ions to cause the phase transition of the monolayer from a liquid-expanded to a condensed state, demonstrating the importance of the interphase electrostatic interactions [56]. This phase transition caused by the interphase interaction was utilized for detecting the interfacial enzymatic hydrolysis of phosphatidylcholine monolayer by phospholipase D at the nitrobenzene–water interface, using the fact that adsorbed phosphatidates, a product of hydrolysis, form a solid monolayer in the presence of divalent cations in W [62,63]. Interfacial hydrolysis itself is a good example of the interphase reaction, or a liquid–liquid two-phase biocatalysis, where the heterogeneous environment created by the interface plays a significant role in characterizing the chemical processes. For example, the effect of the surface charge density on the rate of hydrolysis has been quantitatively estimated [63,64].
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
IV.
119
CONCLUSIONS
The interphase interactions inferred from macroscopic approaches introduced above have raised many intriguing questions, which wait microscopic interpretation and evidence at a molecular level. Among several possible techniques, e.g., FT-IR, x-ray and neutron scattering, surface second-harmonic generation and sum-frequency generation are promising [65–68] and have already provided valuable information about molecular orientation at liquid–liquid interfaces [69–72]. Such microscopic studies and theoretical modeling in parallel with thermodynamic approaches will allow us to have an integrated view and understanding of interfacial properties and processes at liquid–liquid interfaces.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24.
R. B. Gennis, Biomembranes – Molecular Structure and Function, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1994. B. Alberts, D. Bray, J. Lewis, M. Raff, K. Roberts, and J. D. Watson, Molecular Biology of the Cell, 3rd edn, Garland, New York, 1994. C. Tanford, Ben Franklin Stilled the Waves, Duke University Press, Durham, 1989. K. J. Laidler, The World of Physical Chemistry, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1993. R. G. Linford. Chem. Rev. 78:81 (1978). J. Lipkowski, W. Schmickler, D. M. Kolb, and R. Parsons. J. Electroanal. Chem. 452:193 (1998). J. Lipkowski and P. N. Ross (eds.), Imaging of Surfaces and Interfaces, Wiley-VCH, New York, 1999. J. Koryta. Electrochim. Acta 24:293 (1979). J Koryta. Ion-Selective Electrode Rev. 5:131 (1983). J. Koryta. Electrochim. Acta 29:445 (1984). P. Vanysck, Electrochemistry at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1985. J. Koryta. Electrochim. Acta 32:419 (1987). V. E. Kazarinov (ed.), The Interface Structure and Electrochemical Processes at the Boundary Between Two Immiscible Liquids, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1987. J. Koryta. Electrochim. Acta 33:189 (1988). Z. Samec. Chem. Rev. 88:617 (1988). H. H. Girault and D. J. Schiffrin, in Electroanalytical Chemistry (A. J. Bard, ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1989, vol. 15, ch. 1. M. Senda, T. Kakiuchi, and T. Osakai. Electrochim. Acta 36:253 (1991). H. H. Girault, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (R. E. White, B. E. Conway, and J. O. Bockris, eds.), Plenum, New York, 1993, vol. 25, p. 1. Z. Samec and T. Kakiuchi, in Advances in Electrochemistry and Electrochemical Science (H. Gerischer and C. W. Tobias, eds.), VCH, Weinheim, 1995, vol. 4, pp. 297–361. A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Theory and Methods, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996. A. G. Volkov, D. W. Deamer, D. L. Tanelian, and V. S. Markin, Liquid Interfaces in Chemistry and Biology, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1998. F. C. Goodrich and A. I. Rusanov (eds.), The Modern Theory of Capillarity, Akademie-Verlag, Berlin, 1981. V. S. Markin and A. G. Volkov, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, p. 63. A. G. Volkov, D. W. Deamer, D. L. Tanelian, and V. S. Markin, in Liquid Interfaces in Chemistry and Biology, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1998, ch. 3.
120
Kakiuchi
25. J. T. Davies and E. K. Rideal, in Interfacial Phenomena, 2nd edn, Academic Press, New York, 1963, ch. 2. 26. R. Parsons, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’M Bockris and B. Conway, eds.), Butterworths, London, 1954, vol. 1, p. 103. 27. D. M. Mohilner, in Electroanalytical Chemistry (A. J. Bard, ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1966, vol. 1, p. 331. 28. T. Kakiuchi and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 56:1753 (1983). 29. A. G. Volkov, D. W. Deamer, D. L. Tanelian, and V. S. Markin, in Progress in Surface Science (S. G. Davison, ed.), Pergamon, Oxford, 1996, vol. 53, pp. 1–134. 30. T. Kakiuchi, M. Nakanishi, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 62:403 (1989). 31. T. Kakiuchi and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 56:1322 (1983). 32. J. E. B. Randles, in Advances in Electrochemistry and Electrochemical Engineering (P. Delahay and C. W. Tobias, eds.), Interscience, New York, 1963, vol. 3, p. 1. 33. Markin, V. S. and A. G. Volkov, in Liquid–Liquid Interface: Theory and Methods, (A. G. Volkov and D. Deamer, Eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, ch. 4. 34. A. G. Volkov, D. W. Deamer, D. L. Tanelian, and V. S. Markin, in Liquid Interfaces in Chemistry and Biology, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1998, ch. 7. 35. T. Kakiuchi, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996. 36. J. T. Davies and E. K. Rideal, in Interfacial Phenomena, 2nd edn, Academic Press, New York, 1963, ch. 8. 37. D. C. Grahame. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 80:4201 (1958). 38. B. B. Damaskin, O. A. Petrii, and V. V. Batrakov, Adsorption of Organic Compounds on Electrodes. Plenum Press, New York, 1971. 39. T. Kakiuchi, T. Kobayashi, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 60:3109 (1987). 40. T. Kakiuchi, T. Kobayashi, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 61:1545 (1988). 41. C. Gavach, P. Seta, and B. d’Epenoux. J. Electroanal. Chem. 83:225 (1977). 42. L. Q. Hung. J. Electroanal. Chem. Interfacial Electrochem. 115:159 (1980). 43. E. D. Goddard, O. Kao, and H. C. Kung. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 27:616 (1968). 44. H. H. Girault and D. J. Schiffrin. J. Electroanal. Chem. 170:127 (1984). 45. C. M. Pereira, A. Martins, M. Rocha, C. J. Silva, and F. Silva. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 90:143 (1994). 46. A. K. Kontturi, K. Kontturi, J. A. Manzanares, S. Mafe´, and L. Murtoma¨ki. Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 99:1131 (1995). 47. T. Kakiuchi, T. Usui, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 63:2044 (1990). 48. T. Kakiuchi, T. Usui, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 63:3264 (1990). 49. V. Marec˘ek, A. Lhotsky´, and. Electrochim. Acta 44:155 (1998). 50. H. Ja¨nchenova, A. Lhotsky´, K. Holub, and I. Stibor. Electrochim. Acta 44:155 (1998). 51. Z. Yoshida, and S. Kihara. J. Electroanal. Chem. 227:171 (1987). 52. T. Kakiuchi. J. Electroanal. Chem. 345:191 (1993). 53. T. Kakiuchi. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 156:406 (1993). 54. T. Kakiuchi, M. Yamane, T. Osakai, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 60:4223 (1987). 55. T. Wandlowski, S. Rac˘insky´,, V. Marec˘ek, and Z. Samec. J. Electroanal. Chem. 227:281 (1987). 56. T. Kakiuchi, T. Kondo, and M. Senda. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 63:3270 (1990). 57. T. Kakiuchi, Y. Teranishi, and K. Niki. Electrochim. Acta 40:2869 (1995). 58. T. Kakiuchi, M. Kotani, J. Noguchi, M. Nakanishi, and M. Senda. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 149:279 (1992). 59. T. Kakiuchi, T. Kondo, M. Kotani, and M. Senda. Langmuir 8:169 (1992). 60. V. Cunnane, D. J. Schiffrin, M. Fleischmann, G. Geblewicz, and D. Williams. J. Electroanal. Chem. 243:455 (1988). 61. A. K. Kontturi, K. Kontturi, L. Murtoma¨ki, B. Quinn, and V. Cunnane. J. Electroanal. Chem. 424:69 (1997). 62. T. Kondo, T. Kakiuchi, and M. Senda. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1124:1 (1992).
Adsorption at Polarized Liquid–Liquid Interfaces 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73.
121
T. Kondo and T. Kakiuchi. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 34:93 (1994). T. Kondo and T. Kakiuchi. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 36:53 (1995). K. B. Eisenthal. Acc. Chem. Res. 26:636 (1993). R. M. Corn and D. A. Higgins. Chem. Rev. 94:107 (1994). P. F. Brevet and H. H. Girault, in Liquid–Liquid Interfaces: Theory and Methods (A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer, eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996, p. 103. P. F. Brevet. Surface Second Harmonic Generation, Press Polytech. Univ. Romandes, Lausanne, 1997. D. A. Higgins and R. M. Corn. J. Phys. Chem. 97:489 (1993). J. C. Conboy and G. L. Richmond. J. Phys. Chem. B. 101:983 (1997). R. A. Walker, J. A. Gruetzmacher, and G. L. Richmond. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120:6991 (1998). P. B. Miranda and Y. R. Shen. J. Phys. Chem. B. 103:3293 (1999). T. Kakiuchi, in preparation.
6 Nonlinear Optics at Liquid^Liquid Interfaces PIERRE-FRANCOIS BREVET Laboratoire d’Electrochimie, De´partement de Chimie, Ecole Polytechnique Fe´de´rale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland
I.
INTRODUCTION
Processes at interfaces are ubiquitous in nature. They occur in respiration or photosynthesis reactions, for example, and one of the elementary steps in these mechanisms often involves the transfer of charged species across the interface. As a result, any experimental studies attached to the investigation of these transfer reactions entail the development of a surface sensitive technique. For charged species transfer reactions, the methodology of choice has long been derived from standard electrochemistry, since the transfer of a charged particle across an interface gives rise to a current which is amenable to detection by conventional electrochemical techniques [1]. The field of liquid–liquid electrochemistry has greatly benefited from these general ideas [2–4]. A major drawback of this approach, though, is that the distinction between the different transferring species is not an easy matter. This is an important problem in many aspects relevant to biological processes, as the transfer of an electron across the interface is often coupled to the simultaneous transfer of an ion. More selective techniques have been devised, and the most successful rely on spectroscopy principles. Indeed, the signature of a transferring species may be obtained from its absorption or emission spectrum and therefore UV-visible absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy have been employed extensively [5–10]. The use of other techniques like resonance Raman spectroscopy has also been reported [11,12]. Nevertheless, linear optical techniques have no intrinsic surface specificity and therefore require an optimized optical configuration to gain surface specificity. The geometry of choice in this case is the total internal reflection (TIR) geometry whereby the light impinges onto the interface from the medium of highest refractive index n1 , usually the organic phase, with an angle of incidence larger than the critical angle given by arcsinðn2 =n1 Þ. The electromagnetic wave present in the low-index phase (index n2 ) is thus an evanescent wave for which the penetration depth is only of the order of 100 nm. This depth is only a fraction of the diffusion layer in mass transport limited processes but is still far greater than the Debye screening length and therefore precludes any studies addressing the problem of adsorption or double layer effects at interfaces. This is clearly a major limitation, circumvented only on rare occasions [13,14]. This problem has led to the development of nonlinear optical techniques that do have a much more reduced probing depth at the interface owing to symmetry rules. The simplest nonlinear techniques are the three wave mixing techniques, namely sum 123
124
Brevet
frequency and difference frequency generation (respectively SFG and DFG) whereby two fundamental photons of frequency !1 and !2 are converted into one photon at the frequency !1 þ !2 in SFG or !1 !2 in DFG [15]. In the simple case where a single fundamental frequency is used, two photons at the frequency ! are converted into one photon at the frequency 2!. The technique is called second harmonic generation (SHG) and is probably the one that is the most widely used because of the simplicity of the experimental arrangement. Although originally applied in surface science to study molecular adsorption on clean surfaces under high-vacuum conditions, the field has rapidly expanded to other domains [16,17]. The first study of liquid–liquid interfaces has been reported by S. G. Grubb et al. in 1988 for the orientation of compounds at the water–carbon tetrachloride interface [18]. Subsequently, the structure and the dynamics of liquid interfaces have been the focus of interest and the problem of charge transfer reactions across the polarized liquid–liquid interfaces has only been addressed recently [19,20]. The present review intends to cover the work reported on nonlinear optics at liquid– liquid interface since the first report of S. G. Grubb et al. [18]. The theoretical aspects of nonlinear optics are first introduced in Section II. The experimental results covering the molecular structure of liquid interfaces are presented in Section III, followed by a section devoted to the dynamics and the reactivity at these interfaces. Section V focuses on new aspects where spherical interfaces with radii of curvature of the order of the wavelength of light are investigated. Section VI presents the field of SFG.
II.
THEORETICAL APPROACHES
A.
General Theoretical Framework
The problem is restricted in this section to SHG only and hence to a single monochromatic electromagnetic wave impinging at the interface between two dielectric media. This is the general framework describing SHG at both air–liquid and liquid–liquid interfaces. The light source is taken as a well-defined monochromatic harmonic plane wave and is characterized by its wave vector kð!Þ and its electric field vector Eð!Þ. On impinging at the interface between the two media from medium 1, the wave is refracted into medium 2 and reflected back into medium 1 according to the usual laws of linear optics (see Fig. 1) [21]. In particular, the Snell–Descartes law holds for the angles of incidence, reflection, and refraction at the fundamental frequency. The fundamental electromagnetic wave induces a polarization wave in the medium while traveling, as a result of the action of the electric field Eð!Þ on all the particles constituting the dielectric medium. At optical frequencies ranging between 1013 and 1015 Hz, only the electronic motion is of interest and the polarization is reduced to its electronic part. In most cases, one can assume that the polarization oscillates at the exciting frequency. However, for large field amplitudes, one has to include the nonlinear components oscillating at harmonic frequencies owing to the nonlinear response of the electrons of the material to the excitation field. The first-order nonlinear contribution varies quadratically with the excitation field and therefore contains a contribution oscillating at the second harmonic frequency of the exciting field. Introducing the electronic susceptibility tensor ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ characterizing the materials, this component is given by [15,22]: P NL ð2!Þ ¼ 0 K ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ : Eð!ÞEð!Þ
ð1Þ
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
125
FIG. 1 Geometry for the SHG process at the interface between two centrosymmetrical materials. The nonlinear polarization is a sheet of polarization in the plane of the interface located at the origin of the Z axis.
where 0 is the vacuum permittivity. The quantity K ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ arises from the definition of the polarization and accounts in particular for the degeneration of the fundamental electric field. For SHG, K ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ ¼ 1=4, but for SFG, K ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ ¼ 1=2 [22,23]. Solving the wave equation in the medium, it appears that the component of the nonlinear polarization as given in Eq. (1) acts as a source for an electromagnetic wave propagating at twice the fundamental frequency within the medium. The properties of the nonlinear polarization source induced in the medium are found in the susceptibility tensor ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ that possesses the symmetry properties of the material it describes. In particular, for liquids, the susceptibility tensor possesses the property of inversion symmetry. This symmetry operation transforms the co-ordinates (x; y; z) of any point in the medium into the co-ordinates (x; y; z). As a result, dropping the frequency dependencies for clarity, the nonlinear polarization is transformed as: P NL ¼ 0 K ð2Þ ð2Þ EE ¼ 0 K ð2Þ ð2Þ ðEÞðEÞ ¼ P NL
ð2Þ
using the inversion symmetry operation on the vectors, a relationship only fulfilled if the susceptibility tensor ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ vanishes altogether. This property for the susceptibility tensor describing liquids is the origin of the surface specificity of the SHG process at the interface between two centrosymmetrical media [24–26]. For liquids, the susceptibility tensor vanishes except at interfaces where the inversion symmetry operation transforms any point in Liquid 1 into a point in Liquid 2. The nonvanishing surface tensor, written as ð2Þ S ð2!; !; !Þ with a subscript, still possesses the remaining symmetry properties of the interface and in particular the isotropy within the surface plane. As a result, from the ð2Þ initial 27 S;IJK components, only four survive, three only being independent: ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ , and S;ZZZ , the normal to the interface being taken along the S;XZX ¼ S;XXZ , S;ZXX ^ ^ Z axis with the X axis in the interface plane. The surface nonlinear polarization P NL S ð2!Þ is localized at the interface and is usually described as a nonlinear polarization sheet. This approximation holds because the thickness corresponding to the physical region of the
126
Brevet
interface where the bulk properties of one liquid change to the bulk properties of the other liquid is much smaller than the wavelength of light. Within this formalism, the problem can be treated with the help of the laws of linear optics yielding for the SH intensity I SHG [15,22,27,28]: qffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Re 2! 1 !2 SHG 2 ! 2 ¼ ð3Þ I 2 jj ðI Þ 80 c3 2 pffiffiffiffi!ffipffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2! 2! Re 1 m cos m where !1 and 2! 1 are the relative optical dielectric constants of Liquid 1 at the fundamental and the harmonic frequency, and I ! is the fundamental wave intensity. 2! m is the optical dielectric constant of the interfacial region, which may be taken as the average of the constant of both adjacent liquid phases [29,30]. The factor is given by:
ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ 2 sin 2 sin þ a2 S;XZX þ a3 ð2Þ þ a ¼ a1 S;XZX 4 S;ZZZ cos cos S;ZXX ð4Þ 2 þ a5 ð2Þ sin cos S;ZXX where the coefficients ai , i ¼ 1; . . . ; 5 contain all the geometrical parameters and the optical linear dielectric constants [22]. and are respectively the fundamental and the harmonic light polarization angle. For example, with ¼ 0 the fundamental wave is ppolarized, whereas with ¼ 90 the fundamental wave is s-polarized. Equations (3) and (4) fully express the output SH intensity in terms of the linear and the nonlinear properties of the interface and the geometrical angles. They are the basic equations for the analysis of the data obtained from SHG experiments. Equations (3) and (4) give the SH intensity obtained in reflection mode. Although this is usually the most convenient experimental arrangement, the interfacial nonlinear polarization radiates both in the upward and the downward direction and therefore a transmitted wave does also emerge from Liquid 2, allowing a detection in transmission mode (see Fig. 1) [2]. A feature of interest is the possibility of obtaining the condition of total internal reflection (TIR). Under this condition, the fundamental beam impinges on the interface from the liquid with the highest index of refraction yielding a SH intensity enhancement of more than a hundred times. Two TIR angles exist, given by the following relationships: n!1 sin 1! ¼ n!2
and
n!1 sin 1! ¼ n2! 2
ð5Þ
nji
is the optical index of medium i at frequency j, derived from the generalized where Snell–Descartes law [31]. B.
The Case of Pure Solvents
The theoretical framework developed above is valid in the electric dipole approximation. In this context, it is assumed that the nonlinear polarization P NL S ð2!Þ is reduced to the electric dipole contribution as given in Eq. (1). This assumption is only valid if the surface susceptibility tensor ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ is large enough to dwarf the contribution from higher orders of the multipole expansion like the electric quadrupole contribution and is therefore the simplest approximation for the nonlinear polarization. At pure solvent interfaces, this may not be the case, since the nonlinear optical activity of solvent molecules like water, 1,2-dichloroethane (DCE), alcohols, or alkanes is rather low. The magnitude of the molecular hyperpolarizability of water, measured by DC electric field induced second harmonic
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
127
generation (EFISH), has been found to be about 0:56 1031 esu [32,33], that of 1,2dichloroethane to be about 0:42 1030 esu, and of nitrobenzene 2:3 1030 esu [34]. Conversely, the magnitude of the molecular hyperpolarizability of very efficient nonlinear optical compounds may reach values in excess of 1000 1030 esu, as for donor–acceptor polyenes [35]. Hence Eq. (1) fails to fully describe the nonlinear polarization of neat liquid interfaces and higher orders of the multipole expansion have to be introduced [22,27,36,37]. This problem severely hinders the surface specificity of the SHG process, since the next contribution to take into account is the electric quadrupole contribution, neglecting any effects of magnetic origin. The nonlinear polarization is then given by: NL P NL ð2!Þ ¼ P NL DE ð2!Þ þ P QE ð2!Þ
ð6Þ
where the electric quadrupole term is given by [22,27,38]: P NL QE ð2!Þ ¼ r Qð2!Þ
ð7Þ
The electric quadrupole Qð2!Þ involves both the gradient of the electromagnetic incident electric field Eð!Þ and the gradient of the electric quadrupole susceptibility tensor ð2Þ Q ð2!; !; !Þ. This problem is nonetheless solved by the mere addition of supplementary terms in the surface susceptibility tensor. As a result, the surface susceptibility tensor becomes an effective tensor instead of a purely surface specific one [27,38]: ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ eff ;XZX ¼ S;XZX þ rQ;XZXZ ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ eff ;ZXX ¼ S;ZXX þ rQ;ZZXX þ fg;ZXX
ð8Þ
ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ eff ;ZZZ ¼ S;ZZZ þ rQ;ZZZZ þ fg;ZZZ
Interestingly, the contributions from the gradient of the electromagnetic field across the interface, fg;ZXX and fg;ZZZ , which scale with the mismatch in the optical dielectric constants of the media forming the interface [37], only appear in the susceptibility tensor ð2Þ components ð2Þ eff ;ZXX and eff ;ZZZ . Therefore, these contributions may be rejected with a proper selection of the light polarization of the SH wave. Indeed, with ¼ 90 , the SH wave is s-polarized and only depends on the susceptibility tensor element ð2Þ eff ;XZX . Nevertheless, the contribution from the gradient of the electric quadrupole susceptibility tensor is still measured with the surface contribution. As mentioned above, the major drawback of this situation is the loss of the surface specificity of the technique because the gradient of the electromagnetic field extends over the scale of a wavelength on both sides of the interface. This problem can turn out to be a severe impediment at air–liquid interfaces where the electromagnetic field gradients are large, owing to the optical dielectric constant mismatch between air and liquids. This has been clearly emphasized at the air–water interface, whereas at liquid–liquid interfaces, the field gradients are much smaller owing to the better matching of the optical dielectric constants. The loss of surface specificity at the latter interfaces is not as dramatic [39]. Absolute magnitudes for the effective susceptibility tensor have been reported for several interfaces and show a rather large spread (see Table 1) [40]. The air–water interface ð2Þ has a susceptibility value of 6:04 1018 esu for the eff ;XZX susceptibility component [26,40,41]. This large magnitude arises from the overwhelming contribution of the electric quadrupole contribution, the gradient of the electromagnetic field in particular. The same observation can be made for the air–alcohol interfaces although some surface specificity may be obtained when the s-polarized output SHG signal is collected. Conversely, liquid– liquid interfaces present much more reduced values, in particular the water–DCE inter-
128
Brevet
TABLE 1 Absolute Magnitude of the Nonvanishing Susceptibility Tensor Component at Several Air–Liquid and Liquid–Liquid Interfaces [40]. All units are in esu but Transformation into SI Units is Obtained Using the Relationship 1 esu ¼ 3:72 1021 C3 m3 J2 1018 ð2Þ eff ;XZX
Interface Air–water Air–octanol Water–octanol Water–hexane Water–DCE
6.04 4.11 2.46 0.095 0.55
1018 ð2Þ eff ; ZXX 3.38 3.01 2.43 0.104 0.60
1018 ð2Þ eff ; ZZZ 12.58 11.89 7.39 0.39 1.88
ð2Þ face, with a magnitude of 0:5 1018 esu only for the eff ;XZX component, or the water– alkane interface [39]. This is in line with the picture of water molecules lying rather flat at the interface with the dipole moment oriented parallel to the interface [42,43]. Surprisingly, water–alcohol interfaces yield absolute magnitude similar to the air–alcohol ones; see the case of octanol in Table 1, for example. This feature may stem from a strong surface contribution originating from the molecular alignment at the interface subsequent to the interaction of the polar hydroxyl headgroup of the alcohol with water molecules [40].
C.
The Molecular Description
If the electric dipole contribution dominates in the total SH response, the macroscopic response can be related to the presence of optically nonlinear active compounds at the interface. In this case, the susceptibility tensor is the sum of the contribution of each single molecule, all of them coherently radiating. For a collection of compounds, it yields: ð2Þ S ¼
X
NS;i hT i i i
ð9Þ
i
where NS;i is the number of molecules of type i per unit surface and i the hyperpolarizability tensor of a single molecule. The transformation tensor T i links the macroscopic surface susceptibility tensor to the molecular hyperpolarizability tensor. The brackets therefore emphasize that an ensemble average must be performed over all the possible molecular configurations of a molecule sitting at the interface (see Fig. 2). As expected, the quantity hT i i vanishes if the averaging is performed over all the possible orientations, irrespective of the amphiphilic character of the moiety. This indicates that a nonoriented distribution of molecules at the interface does not lead to any SH signal as required by the rule of centrosymmetry. However, if a preferential orientation does exist owing to the amphiphilic character of the surface species, the quantity hT i i does not vanish. Complete expressions for the quantity hT i i have been given in the literature for many different systems [22,44]. In most experiments, the SH wavelength is tuned near an electronic resonance of the surface compounds, thereby reducing the number of nonvanishing elements of the hyperpolarizability tensor i . A resonance at the second harmonic frequency is usually preferred, since this configuration avoids the spurious effects coming from one photon absorption process with the intense fundamental beam. A two-state model involving the ground and the first excited electronic states S0 and S1 is then adequate to
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
129
FIG. 2 Molecular orientation angles at liquid interfaces for rodlike molecules. The out-of-plane motion is a rotation away from the OZ axis, whereas the in-plane motion is performed with the (OX, OY) plane.
describe the nonlinear optical activity of the molecule, the tensor elements ð2Þ ijk taking the following form [45]: ð2Þ ijk ¼ "
e3 ð0Þ g ð0Þ e 2 2h
# ri rj rk !2eg þ 2!2 þ ri rj rk þ rk rj !2eg !2 ½!2eg !2 ½!2eg 4!2
ð10Þ
ð0Þ where ð0Þ g and e are the ground and the excited state population respectively, !eg is the transition frequency between the ground and the excited state, ri is the transition moment along the molecular axis i and ri is the change in the dipole moment along the axis i ð2Þ is obtained when both the transiundergone during the transition. The maximum of ijk tion moment and the change in dipole during the transition are maximized. This explains why compounds undergoing large charge transfer during the transition from the ground to the excited state are good candidates as nonlinear optical probes. If the transition moment and the change in dipole occur along the same axis of the molecule, only one tensor element dominates, the expression of which is: ð2Þ;NR þ ð2Þ zzz ¼ zzz
!2eg
A 4!2 4i!
ð11Þ
where A is a constant and the width of the resonance. The hyperpolarizability element is the sum of a resonant and a nonresonant contribution. As a consequence, the set of equations (9) can be vastly reduced for a single component monolayer at the interface, namely: ð2Þ 2 ð2Þ 20 ð2Þ S;XZX ¼ 20 S;ZXX ¼ Ns hcos sin i zzz 3 ð2Þ 0 ð2Þ S;ZZZ ¼ Ns hcos i zzz
if random distributions are assumed for the two other and equations set, the orientational parameter D given by:
ð12Þ Euler angles. From this
130
Brevet
D¼
hcos3 i hcos i
ð13Þ
is usually extracted but the knowledge of a distribution function has to be assumed beforehand to get the angle of orientation. Although a Gaussian distribution function would be more adequate, albeit with the disadvantage of introducing as an extra parameter the width of the distribution, a Dirac distribution function is often used. This implies the assumption of an infinitely sharp distribution for the molecular angle . In absence of a distribution of angles determined by an independent method, the angle of orientation must only be used as a convenient parameter to describe the interface angular distribution [46,47]. Before closing this section, it is worth mentioning that the hyperpolarizability tensors are complex quantities usually given in the old cgs system of units of esu (electrostatic units). The transformation into the International System is readily obtained with the relationship: ð2Þ ðSIÞ ¼ 3:71 1021 ð2Þ ðesuÞ
ð14Þ
where the SI units are C3 m3 J3 . D.
Polarized Interfaces
The case of polarized interfaces is usually described within the context of the metal– electrolyte interface where the metal charge dependence of the SH intensity is dramatic because of the strong interfacial electric field present at the interface [16]. It has long been a real challenge at the polarized liquid–liquid interface but has, however, been observed at charged air–water interfaces [48]. At polarized interfaces, the static DC electric field established across the interface couples to the electromagnetic field impinging onto the surface. This process is described with the following nonlinear polarization: 1 P ð2Þ ð2!Þ ¼ 0 K ð3Þ ð3Þ ð2!; !; !; 0ÞEð!ÞEð!ÞEð0Þ 6
ð15Þ
with K ð3Þ ¼ 1=4. Although it is a third-order nonlinear optical process mixing four waves, the nonlinear polarization only oscillates at the harmonic frequency owing to the coupling to a static electric field. Because the magnitude of the third-order susceptibility tensor ð3Þ ð2!; !; !; 0Þ is much smaller than the magnitude of the second-order susceptibility tensor ð2Þ ð2!; !; !Þ, coupling to strong electric fields only gives rise to a nonnegligible contribution. This is the reason why the observation of this DC-field-induced SHG contribution has been mainly restricted to the metal–electrolyte interface. As opposed to second-order nonlinear processes, this contribution does not possess the symmetry cancellation in media with inversion symmetry and therefore the surface specificity of this contribution finds its origin in the confinement to the region where the static electric field is nonvanishing. This means that, in principle, this contribution extends over the whole double layer region. E.
Circular Dichroism
In order to describe the problems of the nonlinear optical response from biological systems, the question of chirality must be addressed. Linear circular dichroism (CD) has been investigated extensively for biological compounds and a wealth of data are available on
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
131
this topic [49]. Inversely, in nonlinear optics, this problem has been barely touched on and only few reports have appeared so far [50,51]. The surface susceptibility tensor of a chiral surface possesses different symmetry properties as compared to the surface susceptibility tensor of an isotropic surface. The main difference for a chiral surface arises from the axes OX and the OY, the two axes in the plane of the surface, which are no longer indistinguishable. The nonvanishing elements of the susceptibility tensor are then [52]: ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ S;XZX ¼ S;XXZ ¼ S;YYZ ¼ S;YYZ ð2Þ ð2Þ S;ZXX ¼ S;ZYY
ð2Þ S;ZZZ
ð16Þ
ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ ð2Þ S;XYZ ¼ S;XZY ¼ S;YXZ ¼ S;YZX
Only for achiral surfaces does the last tensor element vanish altogether. Equation (4) retains a similar form but now accommodates a new tensor element. To date, very few experimental works have been reported on chiral surfaces, although the nonlinear effects are expected to be rather large [51].
III.
MOLECULAR STRUCTURE
A.
Surface Coverage
The SH signal directly scales as the square of the surface concentration of the optically active compounds, as deduced from Eqs. (3), (4), and (9). Hence, the SHG technique can be used as a determination of the surface coverage. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to obtain an absolute calibration of the SH intensity and therefore to determine the absolute number for the surface density of molecules at the interface. This determination also entails the separate measurement of the hyperpolarizability tensor i , another difficult task because of local fields effects as the coverage increases [53]. However, with a proper normalization of the SH intensity with the one obtained at full monolayer coverage, the adsorption isotherm can still be extracted through the square root of the SH intensity. Such a procedure has been followed at the polarized water–DCE interface, for example, see Fig. 3 in the case of 2-(n-octadecylamino)-naphthalene-6-sulfonate (ONS) [54]. The surface coverage takes the form:
a G0Ads zbF w c o ð17Þ þ ln ¼ ln i 1 RT RT asol RT where ai and asol are respectively the solute and the solvent bulk activities and G0Ads is the Gibbs energy of adsorption. The electrostatic contribution to the adsorption energy has been made explicit and a plot of ln½ =ð1 Þ with the applied potential wo across the interface yields the value of b, the extent of the potential drop actually felt by the adsorbing species. This introduces a discussion on the molecular arrangement of the monolayer at the interface and in particular on the exact location of the plane of adsorption [54]. In the case of ONS, the adsorption was taking place from the organic phase and the polar head of ONS species was found to significantly protrude into the aqueous phase. The last term in Eq. (17) accounts for the intermolecular interactions within the monolayer through the Frumkin parameter c.
132
Brevet
FIG. 3 Adsorption isotherm of ONS at the polarized water–DCE interface: (square) experimental, (dotted) Langmuir isotherm, and (solid) Frumkin isotherm. (From Ref. 55, copyright American Chemical Society.)
The relationship between the square root of the SH intensity and the surface coverage of the surface active species only holds provided the bare interface does not give rise to any significant background SH signal. If this assumption is not true, interference between the signal from the background and the monolayer occurs, yielding a perturbed isotherm at low coverage. This has been clearly demonstrated at the quartz–air interface for the adsorption of rhodamine 110 in the case of a destructive interference [55]. Nevertheless, with compounds of very high hyperpolarizability like the donor–acceptor polyenes for example, fractions of monolayers as low as 0.001% should readily be detected. Another source for erroneous conclusions is the possibility of intralayer rearrangements or reorientation processes leading to a change in the susceptibility tensor element while the surface density of the active compounds remains unchanged. This has been observed at the air–water interface for a monolayer of the protein glucose oxidase (GOx) [56]. A change of the polarization configuration is usually enough to disentangle adsorption from intralayer rearrangement processes. Besides these effects, interfacial measurements have demonstrated the ability of the nonlinear technique to investigate biological membranes. Polypeptides have also received attention. Clear evidence for coadsorption as the result of multipoint electrostatic interaction has been observed for the synthetic poly-L-glutamic acid polypeptide [57].
B.
Molecular Orientation
One question addressed in the literature is the relationship between the angle of orientation of the adsorbed species within the monolayer and their amphiphilic character. The case of surfactants like fatty acids or phospholipids is deferred until Section VI, since the technique of choice is SFG in order to perform a surface vibrational study. Phenol deri-
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
133
vatives have been extensively studied at the air–water interface and a light polarization analysis shows a preferential orientation [47,58–61]. The angle of orientation has been related to the surface activity of the moiety for a series of simple phenol derivatives, namely p-nitrophenol, phenol, and p-propylphenol. At full monolayer coverage, for a hydrophilic substituent as in the case of p-nitrophenol, the molecule is shown to lie with a rather flat position at the air–water interface and to take a position more perpendicular to the interface as the substituent’s hydrophobicity is increased. Hence phenol was shown to take a position more tilted towards the surface normal and p-propylphenol to take an even straighter position. Furthermore, the effect of the change of the polarity of the nonpolar solvent, hexane replacing air, was shown to screen these hydrophilic–hydrophobic interactions with the aqueous surface yielding an identical orientation for all compounds [47]. These results are in line with molecular dynamics calculations [62,63]. One major assumption at the basis of these works is the absolute orientation of the moiety at the interface, whether pointing up with the hydroxyl group in the aqueous phase or down. For the phenol derivatives, the hydroxyl group was always assumed to point into the aqueous phase. However, only absolute phase measurements can yield such a determination, an experiment realized through interference between the SH signal from the monolayer and a quartz reference [64]. In a recent experimental work, the reference was obtained from another compound coadsorbed at the interface with the molecule of interest [65]. Other classes of compounds investigated include the rhodamine and the eosin dye families involving a xanthene ring. With rhodamine 6G for example, two different resonant configurations were used: either resonant with the fundamental wave or with the harmonic wave [66,67]. The orientation of the long axis of the xanthene ring was found to be oriented with an angle of about 55 with the surface plane. The role of the carboxylic group in the process of adsorption at the hydrophilic air-fused silica surface was also emphasized. SHG has been used extensively for the determination of the structure of surfactant monolayers to address the question of the role of long-tail chains in intermolecular repulsion interactions. The orientation of the surfactants was thus monitored for soluble and insoluble naphthalene sulfonate derivatives, with an alkyl chain containing respectively 6 and 18 carbon atoms. They were shown to exhibit a similar angle of orientation irrespective of the surface coverage and to present an identical surface density at full monolayer coverage. This results supports the view that a soluble surfactant forms a saturated monolayer by adsorption very much identical in its structure to an insoluble monolayer formed by the spreading of the compound on the surface [68]. Reorientation as a function of surface coverage is usually very weak but was nevertheless observed for dodecylnaphthalene sulfonate or 1-(3 0 ; 5 0 -di-t-butyl)phenyl-3-glycero-rac-glycerin at the air–water interface [69,70]. The kinetics of adsorption, phase transition from the liquid expanded to the liquid condensed state, and surface diffusion were also observed [43,71–76]. Finally, it is worth adding that very small molecules are amenable to detection at interfaces. This has been proven for compounds like SO2 at the air–water interface or for the more environmentally relevant stratospheric ozone reaction products like HOCl at the surface of ice [77,78]. C.
Interfacial Solvation
The heterogeneity of the solvent at the interface introduces another degree of complexity in the problem. Molecular dynamics calculations have been able to give a molecular picture of the interfacial solvation of adsorbates but experiments have long been a chal-
134
Brevet
lenge [79]. The problem has though recently been addressed by SHG with the recording of surface SHG spectra and the comparison with the corresponding UV-visible bulk phase spectra. The maximum of the nonlinear and the linear optical spectra usually differ but the exact location of the resonance must be carefully extracted from the nonlinear optical measurements because of the contribution of the nonresonant term in the hyperpolarizability tensor, see Eq. (11) [80]. The general scheme underlying the experimental approach is to extend the polarity scale of homogeneous media to interfacial regions with the use of an appropriate molecular probe. The compound usually taken as the reference compound is 4-(2,4,6-triphenylpyridinium)-2,6-diphenylphenoxide, ET ð30Þ, which belongs to the family of the betaine dyes. It possesses a large solvatochromic shift and this shift, when renormalized on a general solvent scale, defines the polarity of the medium. The solvatochromic shift of ET ð30Þ arises from the charge transfer band and is defined as 0 for tetramethylsilane (TMS) and 1 for water [81]. The scale is defined with the normalized parameter ETN ð30Þ as: ETN ð30Þ ¼
ET ðsolventÞ ET ðTMSÞ ET ðwaterÞ ET ðTMSÞ
ð18Þ
where ET (solvent) is the location of the charge transfer absorption band maximum. The air–water polarity thus has a polarity of 0.01 in this scale and the n-heptane–water interface 0.52, bulk phase n-heptane having itself a value of 0.01 on this polarity scale [30]. The ETN (30) scale was confirmed with another compound, N,N-diethyl-p-nitroaniline (DEPNA), yielding a scale consistent with the ETN (30) one. In a rather general manner, the polarity of the interface is deduced from the average of the polarity Pi of the two adjacent bulk media: Pw=o ¼
Pw þ Po 2
ð19Þ
This indicates that the polarity of a medium is a long-range property that goes much further than the first solvation shell and therefore involves the two adjacent bulk media properties. This result is, however, valid for compounds the solvation of which is not determined by specific interactions with the first solvent shell, but rather by long-range forces like dipole interactions. The solvation of DEPNA was determined by molecular dynamics too and similar conclusions were drawn [82]. D.
Surface Equilibrium
As a consequence of the change of the polarity of the interface as compared to the bulk solution, chemical equilibrium may be shifted towards the reactants or the products if changes in the charges or the dipoles are involved. A thermodynamic cycle between the surface and the bulk phase can thus be defined with the Gibbs energies of adsorption and the different equilibrium constants. The energy of adsorption contains two contributions, a chemical part G0Ads assumed unaffected by changes in the charge, and an electrostatic part WBorn the magnitude of which, evaluated with the Born model [83,84], emphasizes the dependence of WBorn with the charge z. Hence, neutral species are much more favored at interfaces than charged species owing to the reduced polarity of water next to a hydrophobic wall. This observation is of great relevance in surface chemistry for the acid–base equilibrium for example. The protonation–deprotonation reaction will involve a change in the charge of the species and therefore a change in the surface equilibrium constant, assuming that the chemical term is constant. The pKaS observed at the interface is thus:
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
pKaS ¼ pKa
1 ½WBorn ðAHÞ WBorn ðAÞ 2:3RT
135
ð20Þ
provided the proton equilibrium between the surface and the bulk phase follows a Boltzmann equilibrium: pHS ¼ pH
Fsb
2:3RT
ð21Þ
where sb is the potential drop between the bulk phase and the surface. In Eq. (20), WBorn ðAHÞ vanishes if the form AH is neutral. A surface equilibrium has been reported for several compounds at the air–water interface: anilinium, phenolates, hemicyanine, or eosin B and the observed shift of the surface pKaS is usually of several units [75,85–87]. For the equilibrium between p-nitrophenol and its anion, the surface pKaS is 7.9 as compared to a value of 7.15 in the bulk aqueous phase. Similarly, for the dye eosin B, which has two protonation sites and therefore presents a neutral acid, a singly charged and a doubly charged anionic form at the interface presents two surface pKaS of 4.0 and 4.2 at the air– water interface as compared to 2.2 and 3.7 in bulk aqueous solution. The location of the adsorption plane for the different forms at the interface was inferred from the different shift observed for the two equilibrium constants. The doubly charged form of eosin B was thus found to lie further into the aqueous phase as compared to the singly charged form. The case of 4-(4 0 -dodecyloxyazobenzene)-benzoic acid (DBA) has been studied at the water–DCE interface [88]. At liquid–liquid interfaces though, the problem is complicated by the possible transfer of species across the interface. The SH signal may be used as a surface titration tool (see Fig. 4). Yet, the midpoint of the titration curve is not the point where the surface concentrations of the acid and the base are equal. Indeed, a proper account of the ratio of the hyperpolarizability tensor of the two forms has to be taken and consequently the point of equal surface concentration may lie far away from the midpoint.
FIG. 4 SHG intensity from the dye eosin B adsorbed at the air–water interface as a function of the pH of the bulk aqueous solution. The aqueous dye concentration is 30 M and the fundamental wavelength is 532 nm.
136
Brevet
Different orientations for the protonated and deprotonated species as well as a change of the surface coverage with the bulk aqueous pH can further complicate the problem. Another determination of the surface equilibrium entails the use of the coupling of the DC electric field present at charged interfaces with the electromagnetic field, as described in the theoretical section. Integration of the nonlinear polarization over the whole double layer leads to the following expression of the effective susceptibility tensor: ð2Þ eff ¼ A þ B ð0Þ
ð22Þ
where the surface potential ð0Þ can be separately calculated from a Gouy–Chapman model. This method has been used for the determination of the surface pKaS of p-hexadecylaniline at the air–water interface, the surface pKaS of which was found to be 3.6 at the interface and 5.3 in the bulk aqueous phase. These results confirm that neutral forms are favored at the interface [89]. E.
Polarized Interfaces
Interfaces between two immiscible electrolyte solutions (ITIES) have scarcely been investigated by nonlinear optics. Some literature is available on adsorption and orientation at ITIES and was covered in the sections above [54,88,90]. No reorientation of the adsorbates as a function of the applied potential was observed in the course of these experiments, a feature probably due to the weak interaction energy between the molecular dipole and the DC electric field. The influence of the ion transfer reaction across the interface in the thermodynamic equilibrium between the bulk phases and the interface was, however, underlined [88]. At ITIES, the origin of the second harmonic signal may stem from the change in surface concentration of the active species with the externally applied potential or from the coupling of the DC electric field with the electromagnetic fields. This matter is still a question of debate but in an attempt to address it, the SH intensity was measured at the water–DCE interface as a function of the applied potential in presence of the supporting electrolytes only [91]. The aqueous electrolyte was LiCl and different organic supporting electrolytes were used. In particular, the organic cation was either tetrabutylammonium (TBAþ ), which possesses only four alkyl chains and therefore has a weak hyperpolarizability tensor, or tetraphenylarsonium (TPhAsþ ) which has four phenyl rings and thus a much larger hyperpolarizability. The organic anion was tetraphenylborate (TPhB ). The SH response exhibited a parabolic shape similar to the one observed at the metal–electrolyte interface for TPhAsþ . However, for the cation TBAþ , the SH intensity vanished at the negative end of the potential window where the organic cation is accumulated at the interface. The authors were thus led to the conclusion that the SH signal finds its origin in the potential-dependent concentration of the organic supporting electrolytes. In all cases, the influence of the aqueous supporting electrolyte was negligible.
IV.
INTERFACIAL DYNAMICS AND REACTIVITY
A.
Interfacial Dynamics
Molecules adsorbed at interfaces are in constant motion, both from the point of view of their orientation and of the dynamic exchange with the bulk solution. The distribution of orientation angle is characterized by the parameter D, see Eq. (13), or the angle of orientation . Complete randomness for the angle , the angle of rotation around the principal
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
137
molecular axis, is assumed hereafter. The two angles and define the in-plane and the out-of-plane motion of the molecule at the surface and are readily accessed by experiment. The anisotropy of the rotation motion of compounds at interfaces has been clearly evidenced in the case of the dye coumarin C314 [92]. The strategy operating to separate the two in-plane and out-of-plane motions relies on the selective preparation of the excitedstate distribution of molecules with a pump pulse of well-defined state. Indeed, the perturbation of the initial distribution is produced by a pump pulse photoexciting the molecules form their ground state to their excited state. The probe pulse, which is actually performing the SHG process at the interface, subsequently samples the relaxing molecular distribution at fixed time intervals. With the use of a selective excitation according to the polarization state of the pump pulse with respect to the polarization state of the probe pulse, the two motions have different weights and can be deconvoluted. One of the major caveats of these experiments is the clear separation of the orientation processes from other processes like radiative and nonradiative decays of the excited population. Population effects are usually observed a time scales of a few nanoseconds and correspond to processes like fluorescence emission, for example. Orientation processes occur on the picosecond time scale. For coumarin C314, the out-of-plane motion was found to have a relaxation time of about 350 ps, whereas the in-plane motion had a relaxation time of about 600 ps. Such a difference was attributed to the restoring force acting on the molecules for the out-of-plane motion, whereas no such force is acting in the case of the inplane motion. The time scale of the two different motions reported for C314 at the air–water interface can also be compared to the rotation motion in the bulk phase. As has also been reported for rhodamine 6G at the same interface, the relaxation time is longer than the rotational diffusion time in bulk water at the interface for the out-of-plane motion [92,93]. These longer time scales are explained by rotational motions at the interface chiefly controlled by the friction on the aqueous side of the air–water interface. These results are at odds with the experimental findings observed for the dye eosin B at the same interface (see Fig. 5) [94]. The relaxation time of the out-of-plane motion of the doubly charged anionic form of this dye was observed after a complete randomization of the orientation distribution corresponding to the angle . The time scale at the interface was found to be 90 ps, a relaxation time much shorter than the one observed in the bulk aqueous phase at about 350 ps. This was explained by the reduced hydrogen bonding at the interface between the dye and the water molecules, owing to an increased competition with other water molecules. Population and orientation decays are not the fastest events in the dynamics of solutes at interfaces. Solvation processes indeed occur on the femtosecond time scale. In the ground state of a molecule, the electronic distribution, and therefore the charge distribution in the molecular volume, is such that a polar solvent is specifically oriented around the molecule in the bulk phase to minimize the energy of the state. In the excited state, the electronic distribution is often rearranged and this process may be quite extensive in a charge transfer excited state where the change in dipole moment from the ground to the excited state is rather large. As a result, the solvation properties of the excited state are the ones pertaining in the ground state, since the electronic excitation is a much faster event than the solvent reorganization. This configuration is highly unfavorable. The solvent thus undergoes a reorganization in order to minimize the energy of the excited state. This feature, known as the Stoke shift, is usually observed through the time evolution of emission spectra [95]. At the interface, this effect is observed as a shift of the SH spectrum at early times subsequently to the photoexcitation. Conversely, and because this phenom-
138
Brevet
FIG. 5 Time-resolved SHG intensity from the doubly charged eosin B at the air–water interface after randomization of the orientation distribution. (a) Square root of the SH signal recorded for the s-polarized SHG output intensity and the fundamental beam 45 -polarized. (b) Square root of the SH signal recorded for the p-polarized SHG output intensity and the fundamental beam s-polarized. (From Ref. 96, copyright Elsevier Science BV.)
enon occurs on a fast time scale, the solvent reorganization process can be observed as the early time evolution of the SHG signal at a single frequency. This technique has been used at the air–water interface for coumarin C314, which possesses a large change in dipole during the excitation from the ground to the excited state. The time scale of the solvent reorganization was measured to be 790 fs, a value close to the longitudinal dielectric relaxation of bulk water, the value of which is only 590 fs [96]. This is attributed to the long-range effects of solvation and in particular of the solute–solvent interactions, in accordance with the polarity scale, which describes the similar long-range effects.
B.
Photoisomerization
The photoisomerization reaction gives a valuable tool to investigate the molecular friction at the interface. Depending on the exact location of the reaction path, whether predominantly in one or the other phase, the time scale of the rate of the reaction is severely modified. The photoisomerization reaction of the dyes malachite green and 3,3 0 -diethyloxadicarbocyanine iodide (DODCI) has been reported at several interfaces, the air–
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
139
water and different alkane–water interfaces, to illustrate this phenomenon [97,98]. Malachite green is present at the interface with its phenyl ring protruding out of the aqueous phase, whereas the two dimethylaniline groups are anchored into the aqueous phase. The isomerization reaction rate is found insensitive to the phase adjacent to the aqueous phase, the relaxation rate being 3.5 ps at the air–water interface and 3.6 ps at the pentadecane–water interface. Both rates are slower than the rate in the bulk aqueous phase, i.e., 0.7 ps. They are also faster than the rate observed at the silica–water interface, which is 6.2 ps. Inversely, the isomerization rate of DODCI is measured to be 220 ps at the air–water interface, whereas it is 520 ps in the bulk phase water. These differences were attributed to the exact location of the path of the isomerization reaction. In the case of malachite green, the isomerization is thought to occur through rotation around the two carbophenyl bonds protruding into the aqueous phase without involving the phenyl group sticking into the other phase. As a result, the motion is slowed down because the molecular friction on the aqueous side of the interface is increased. For DODCI, the isomerization reaction is thought to occur through the one of the methylene bonds protruding out of the aqueous phase into the air. Thus, the two different behaviors of malachite green and DODCI may be reconciled by assuming that the isomerization path involves the part of the molecule in the aqueous phase for malachite green and the part in the air for DODCI at the air–water interface. This assumption implies that the influence of molecular friction on reaction rates at interfaces is path-dependent. On the aqueous side of the air–water interface, the molecular friction appears stronger than the bulk phase one. Photoisomerization was also reported at the water–DCE interface for the organic dye 4-(4 0 -dodecyloxyazobenzene)-benzoic acid (DBA) [99]. This dye is under the trans form in its ground state but can be converted into its cis isomer when illuminated with UV light. In the bulk DCE phase, the thermally driven back-conversion from the cis isomer to the trans isomer is rather slow as a result of the high energy barrier of nearly 100 kJ mol1 . At the water–DCE interface, the conversion from the trans to the cis isomer with UV light is also efficient, however, no significant thermally driven relaxation to the trans isomer is observed. This surprising result is attributed to intermolecular interactions within the dye monolayer at the interface, like hydrogen bonding through the azo nitrogens of the azobenzene DBA either with other DBA molecules or with the aqueous solvent. C.
Electron Transfer Reactions
Electron transfer reactions constitute an ubiquitous class of chemical reactions. This is particularly true in biological systems where these reactions often occur at interfaces, in photosynthesis for instance. It is therefore challenging to use the surface specificity and the time resolution of the SHG technique to investigate these processes. At liquid–liquid interfaces, these processes are mimicked through the following scheme: Dorg þ Aaq
hv D þ Aaq !Dþ org þ Aaq ! org SCHEME 1
where the two redox couples are located in the organic and the aqueous phase during the whole duration of the experiment. Hence, Scheme 1 describes a true heterogeneous electron transfer (ET) reaction across the interface. One of the major problems usually arising during this reaction scheme is the simultaneous transfer of one of the reactants or products across the interface as this process is difficult to uncouple from the ET reaction. Several systems have been devised and one of the most efficient ones so far is formed by zinc
140
Brevet
porphyrins located in the aqueous phase and ferrocene derivatives in the organic phase [100]. The SHG technique is an adequate technique to follow these ET reactions and the experiment has been performed on a system constituted by tris-(2,2 0 -bipyridinyl) ruthenium (II) RuðbpyÞ2þ 3 dissolved in the aqueous phase as the sensitizer and trans-1-ferrocenyl-2-(4-(trimethylammonio)phenyl)ethylene (1þ ) located in the organic phase as the donor species [101]. The RuðbpyÞ2þ 3 species were first photoexcited by light at 488 nm and the time evolution of the donor 1þ at the water–DCE interface was followed by SHG (see Fig. 6). The heterogeneous ET reaction was clearly observed and its rate limited by the diffusion rate of the excited RuðbpyÞ2þ 3 species to the interface. This experiment clearly demonstrated the advantages of nonlinear optics over linear optical techniques like fluorescence in total internal reflection (TIR) or transient absorption owing to its surface specificity [102,103].
D.
Ion Transfer Reactions
Charge transfer reactions at ITIES include both ET reactions and ion transfer (IT) reactions. One question that may be addressed by nonlinear optics is the problem of the surface excess concentration during the IT reaction. Preliminary experiments have been reported for the IT reaction of sodium assisted by the crown ether ligand 4-nitro-benzo-15crown-5 [104]. In the absence of sodium, the adsorption from the organic phase and the reorientation of the neutral crown ether at the interface has been observed. In the presence of the sodium ion, the problem is complicated by the complex formation between the crown ether and sodium. The SH response observed as a function of the applied potential clearly exhibited features related to the different steps in the mechanisms of the assisted ion transfer reaction although a clear relationship is difficult to establish as the ion transfer itself may be convoluted with monolayer rearrangements like reorientation.
FIG. 6 SHG intensity as a function of time (ON) with and (OFF) without illumination of the interface by a probe UV pulse. The increased SHG intensity during illumination arises from the production of the species 1þ at the interface by photoinduced electron transfer, see text for more details. (From Ref. 103, copyright American Chemical Society.)
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
141
Other studies involved the measurements of the SHG response from ion selective electrodes (ISE) [105,106] but one of the difficulties lies in the reabsorption of the SH signal generated at the interface in the bulk of one phase as the active species transfer.
V.
SHG FROM CENTROSYMMETRICAL PARTICLES
In the sections above, only infinite planar interfaces between air and an aqueous phase or two immiscible liquids like water and DCE were considered. Reducing the question to this class of surfaces only would be a severe limitation in the scope of the review as more reports appear in the literature debating on the SH response from small centrosymmetrical particles [107–110]. It is the purpose of this section to discuss the SHG response from interfaces having a radius of curvature of the order of the wavelength of light. In the theoretical section above, the nonlinear polarization induced by the fundamental wave incident on a planar interface for a system made of two centrosymmetrical materials in contact was described. However, if one considers small spheres of a centrosymmetrical material embedded in another centrosymmetrical material, like bubbles of a liquid in another liquid, the nonlinear polarization at the interface of a single sphere is a spherical sheet instead of the planar one obtained at planar surfaces. When the radius of curvature is much smaller than the wavelength of light, the electric field amplitude of the fundamental electromagnetic wave can be taken as constant over the whole sphere (see Fig. 7). Hence, one can always find for any infinitely small surface element of the surface
FIG. 7 Schematics of the SHG process at the surface of a sphere of a centrosymmetrical medium with a radius much smaller and of the order of the wavelength of light. The cancellation or the addition of the nonlinear polarization contribution is given explicitly and underlines the effect of the electromagnetic field and the surface orientation.
142
Brevet
another infinitely small surface element on the other side of the sphere with a corresponding nonlinear polarization of equal amplitude pointing in the opposite direction. The net result of this finding is that the overall surface nonlinear polarization of the particle vanishes altogether and no SHG signal may be observed from such a particle. This case would be observed for small nanoparticles the diameter of which is in the range of 1 to 20 nm. In fact, in the case of metallic nanoparticles, this case is nearly reached, although an SHG signal can still be collected from the contribution arising from the electromagnetic field gradients [111–113]. Since all particles in the solution radiate at the harmonic frequency without any phase relationship, the SH signal collected from a monodispersed solution of particles is incoherent [114]. This process is known as hyper-Rayleigh scattering (HRS). For particles with a radius of curvature of the order of, or larger than, the wavelength of light, the incoming fundamental electric field cannot be assumed constant over the particle diameter any longer. Hence, the compensation of the nonlinear polarization from two opposite surface elements is incomplete and an SHG signal from the particle is collected. This phase matching condition is given as [115]: ¼ 1 expðikLÞ
ð23Þ
where L is the coherence length and k ¼ k2! 2k! is the wave vector mismatch. The maximum SH intensity is therefore obtained when ¼ 2 or similarly for kL ¼ . This condition defines a coherence length of about a few microns. The problem of particles having a diameter of the order of the wavelength of light has been recently discussed for the dye malachite green adsorbed on polystyrene particles of about 1 m diameter [115]. The SH intensity was shown to depend on the square of the number of adsorbed malachite green molecules per particle, indicating that the adsorbed dye molecules of a single polystyrene particle were coherently radiating at the harmonic frequency. The SH intensity was, however, shown to depend linearly with the number density of the polystyrene particles, underlining a noncoherent SH generation from the assembly of particles. The most striking advantage of this configuration is the possibility of investigating liposome bilayers and transport processes across these layers. Protein monolayers have already been investigated at planar surfaces [56] but liposome spherical bilayers are also accessible by nonlinear optics in bulk solution. The transport of the dye malachite green across a phospholipid bilayer membrane has thus been reported [116], the experiment relying on the adsorption of malachite green at the aqueous media–bilayer membrane on both the internal and the external side (see Fig. 8). Because the two sides of the membrane have an opposite orientation, the two opposite contributions of the nonlinear polarization are expected to cancel each other. As a result, the initial point of the experiment was obtained with the malachite green only adsorbed on the external membrane side of the dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (DOPG) liposome bilayer by adding the dye after the liposome preparation. The transport of the dye across the membrane to the internal side was then followed through the loss of the SH signal as the internal side contribution to the signal increased, therefore compensating the external side contribution. The loss of the SHG intensity was occurring on time scales of about 100 s but the transport could be blocked for a bilayer of dipalmitoylphosphatidylglycerol (DPPG). The difference between DOPG and DPPG were interpreted in terms of the structure of the bilayer, DPPG being in a gel state where the restricted arrangement prevents the transport of the dye. These results undoubtedly will raise a strong interest in the biological sciences.
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
143
FIG. 8 SHG intensity as a function of time for a solution of DOPG and DPPG liposomes in presence of the dye malachite green in the solution and adsorbed at the liposome surface. The effect of transport across the bilayer is observed through the decay of the SHG intensity at short times. (From Ref. 117, copyright Elsevier Science BV.)
VI.
SUM FREQUENCY GENERATION
A.
Theoretical Background
Equation (1) has been set above in the case of the SHG process. This process entails the mixing of two identical frequency electromagnetic waves and therefore constitutes a particular case of the general problem of the mixing of two different frequency waves. The general form of Eq. (1) is therefore [15,22]: P NL ð!3 Þ ¼ 0 K ð2Þ ð!3 ; !1 ; !2 Þð2Þ ð!3 ; !1 ; !2 Þ : Eð!1 ÞEð!2 Þ
ð24Þ
where we have either the condition !3 ¼ !1 þ !2 , the process known as sum frequency generation (SFG), or !3 ¼ !1 !2 , this process being known as difference frequency mixing (DFG). Although experiments may be readily performed with two visible frequencies, one interesting configuration lies in the possibility of using one visible frequency and one infrared frequency, which can be tuned over vibrational resonances of the molecular adsorbates. In this case, a surface vibrational spectrum is recorded, the surface specificity arising from the three-wave mixing process. This possibility has been widely used in recent years to investigate surfactants and phospholipids at liquid interfaces [117]. These species are present at liquid surfaces in a wide range of phenomena but it was very difficult to get a clear molecular picture of the interface. SFG IR Vis Generalization of the Snell–Descartes law yields nSFG ¼ nIR 1 w3 sin1 1 w1 sin 1 þ n1 Vis SFG w2 sin 1 defining an outgoing SFG wave angle 1 close to the outgoing fundamental
144
Brevet
visible wave angle 1Vis . Similarly, the outgoing angle 1DFG is determined through the Vis IR IR w3 sin 1DFG ¼ nVis relation nDFG 1 1 w2 sin 1 n1 w1 sin 1 . With a collinear configuration of the two incoming beams, the SFG wave has usually a smaller angle than the visible outgoing fundamental wave and the DFG one a larger angle, although the experimental apparatus requires a careful rejection of the fundamental waves. For this reason, the counterpropagating configuration is sometimes preferred. The SFG intensity takes a form similar to the one given in Eq. (3), although the SFG intensity depends linearly on both fundamental wave intensities [22]. The hyperpolarizability tensor is obtained in a way similar to the case of SHG. However, the selection rules for an SFG resonance at the IR frequency implies that the vibrational mode is both IR and Raman active, as the SF hyperpolarizability tensor elements involve both an IR absorption and a Raman–anti-Stokes cross-section. Conversely, the DFG hyperpolarizability tensor elements involve an IR absorption and a Raman–Stokes cross-section. The hyperpolarizability tensor elements can be written in a rather compact form involving several vibrational excitations as [117]: X Aq ð2Þ ð2Þ ð25Þ S ¼ S;NR þ !IR !q þ iq q where the summation is made over the vibrational modes. The appearance of the nonresonant contribution ð2Þ S;NR in the hyperpolarizability tensor is the source for interference in the SFG spectra. Interestingly, Eq. (25) must be slightly modified for the case of DFG: X Aq ð2Þ ð2Þ ð26Þ S ¼ S;NR þ ! !q iq IR q this simple change in phase allowing one to disentangle the nonresonant from the resonant contribution if the SFG and the DFG spectra are collected [118]. B.
Vibrational Surface Spectrum of Solvents
The first vibrational surface spectrum recorded was that of the CH stretch region of methanol at the air–methanol interface [119]. It yielded a molecular picture of the interface where the end CH3 group is pointing into the air in agreement with the theoretical predictions [120]. This work initiated the studies on the surface vibrational spectrum of water, since water surfaces represent by far the most widely used system. The spectral region of interest is the OH stretching region extending from 3000 cm1 to 3800 cm1 (see Fig. 9) [121]. Three vibrational modes dominate: the OH stretching mode at 3680 cm1 , the OH stretch at 3400 cm1 , and the OH stretch at 3200 cm1 . The first mode characterizes the free OH bonds pointing out of the water phase. The second one corresponds to bonded O and H atoms within a disordered network, and therefore characterizes the waterlike structure, whereas the third one corresponds to the bonded O and H atoms in a more regular network hence characterizing the icelike structure. The relative magnitude of these modes is indicative of the hydrogen bonding network prevailing at the surface. It was deduced from different sets of experiments involving water–alcohol mixtures and temperature dependence measurements, that the water hydrogen bonding network resembles that of ice next to the interface [122]. The molecular network is formed at the interface by water molecules tetrahedrally coordinated through hydrogen bonds. In this structure, about 25% of the water molecules have a dangling OH bond protruding in the hydrophobic phase. This icelike network is, however, severely distorted, since the peak at 3400 cm1
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
145
FIG. 9 Vibrational sum frequency spectrum in the OH mode region of the neat air–water interface at different temperature for the fundamental visible and infrared beams respectively s- and p-polarized and the SFG beam s-polarized. (From Ref. 120, copyright American Physical Society.)
characterizing liquid water is still rather large. A molecular dynamics study has led to similar surface vibrational spectra [123]. These results suggest that liquid surfaces are more ordered than their bulk phase, owing to the strong hydrogen bonding network. This has also been observed at air–alcohol surfaces [124] and also at the water–hexane [122] and the water–CCl4 interfaces [125]. In the CH2 stretching spectral region between 2800 cm1 and 3000 cm1 , information on the alkyl chain conformation can be inferred. For symmetry reasons, the CH2 stretching mode should not be nonlinear optically active in all-trans chains because of the cancellation of the contribution from CH2 groups on both sides of the alkyl chain. Hence, this mode is a nice tool to measure the extent of gauche defects in these chains. Experimentally, at the air–alcohol interface, the weak magnitude of the CH2 stretching mode indicated that the alkyl chains remain almost all-trans with very few gauche defects. The number of defects is rather insensitive to the length of alkyl chain. These results suggest that chain–chain interactions are highly effective in ordering the chains at the interface. At water–alkane interfaces a similar observation can be made, although an increase in the temperature introduces defects in the chain [126,127]. In fact, according to the weak magnitude of the CH3 antisymmetrical stretching mode, the alkyl chains are oriented perpendicular to the surface [126]. The molecular order at the interface can be severely disrupted as it has been demonstrated when methanol is added to an aqueous solution [122]. Inversely, adsorption can lead to an enhancement of the order as is the case
146
Brevet
with small additions of sulfuric acid at the air–water interface [128]. At high acid concentrations, the aqueous surface resembles that of sulfuric acid. Other mixtures have been studied, in particular glycerol–water [129], acetonitrile–water [130], and aqueous salt solutions [131]. C.
Surfactants and Phospholipids
Liquid interfaces have been also investigated in the presence of cationic and anionic surfactants. In the CH2 and the CH3 regions between 2800 and 3000 cm1 , information on the chain–chain interactions can be obtained, whereas in the OH region, information on the water hydrogen bonding network is obtained. The vibrational spectrum of pentadecanoic acid (PDA) at the air–water interface at full coverage for example is dominated by the CH3 symmetrical stretch and the CH3 Fermi resonance modes [127]. The absence of the CH2 modes clearly indicates the high degree of order of the alkyl chains, which take a predominantly all-trans configuration. It also appears that as the surface coverage is reduced, the constraints are released and the number of gauche defects increases, as seen from the increase of the ratio of the intensity of the CH2 mode intensity to the CH3 mode intensity. Interestingly, the headgroup of the surfactant seems to play a nonnegligible role in the ordering process. For a polar cationic head, in the case of dodecylammonium chloride or dodecyltrimethylammonium chloride, the number of gauche defects was lower as compared to the case of sodium dodecylsulfate or sodium dodecylsulfonate for the same alkyl chain length [132]. This was explained in terms of the penetration depth of the polar cationic heads into the aqueous phase, the number of gauche defects being reduced as a result of the shorter length of the alkyl chain protruding outside the aqueous phase. The general picture emerging from these studies can be even more refined if complementary information from other techniques like neutron reflection experiments are included [133]. In the spectral region of the OH modes, the structure of water itself is obtained in the presence of the surfactant monolayer. In the case of pentadecanoic acid at the air–water interface, the OH peak at 3200 cm1 was found to dominate over the one at 3450 cm1 , underlining the tetrahedral arrangement of the hydrogen bonding network of the water molecules in an icelike structure [127]. More strikingly, it has been possible to observe the orientation flip of the water molecules with the sign of the surface charge introduced by the surfactants polar heads. A constructive interference in the region of 2970 cm1 between the CH3 Fermi resonance mode and the OH stretching mode lying at 3200 cm1 has been observed for the cationic surfactant dodecylammonium chloride. Conversely, a destructive interference between these two modes was reported for the anonic surfactant sodium dodecylsulfonate [134,135]. The interference arises from the reversal of the alignment direction of the water dipoles in the vicinity of the interface upon the change of the sign of the surface charge. With a cationic surfactant, the water molecules are preponderantly oriented with the oxygen pointing towards the surface, whereas in the presence of the anionic surfactant, the hydrogen atoms point towards the surface. At neutral surfaces, where a mixed monolayer of cationic and anionic surfactants was spread, the alignment of the water molecules was lost and the corresponding signal of the OH stretching mode at 3200 cm1 was negligible. One major interest in vibrational surface spectroscopy is the ability to directly probe lipid layers. Similarly to the previous case, the structure of the alkyl chains of phospholipids is readily determined from the ratio of the magnitude of the CH2 and CH3 symmetrical stretching modes [136,137]. At the D2 O–CCl4 interface, a layer of
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces
147
dilauroylphosphatidylcholine (DLPC) at a coverage of 50 A2 /molecule was found to possess a high degree of order (see Fig. 10) [138]. Indeed, the ratio of the two CH2 and CH3 symmetrical stretching modes indicated the dominance of the CH3 symmetrical stretching mode as a result of the cancellation of the contribution of the different CH2 groups along the chains. This is the result of nearly gauche defect free chains, indicative of high chain order. The alkyl chain of DLPC is 12 carbons long and these results were compared to longer alkyl chain length phosphatidylcholines, like dimyristoyl (DMPC), dipalmitoyl(DPPC), and distearoyl- (DSPC) phosphatidylcholines with alkyl chains 14, 16, and 18 carbons long, respectively. Surprisingly, it is observed that, at odds with the results obtained at the air–water interface, at the D2 O–CCl4 interface the longer the alkyl chain length is, the larger is the disorder [138]. A similar behavior has been observed at the solid–liquid interface [139]. The reason is that the organic solvent screens the chain– chain interactions leading to the reduction of the constraints within the chains. As opposed to the air–water interface, long alkyl chains at oil–water interfaces are more readily permeable to the organic solvent.
VII.
CONCLUSIONS
Liquid interfaces are widely found in nature as a substrate for chemical reactions. This is rather obvious in biology, but even in the diluted stratospheric conditions, many reactions occur at interfaces like the surface of ice crystallites. The number of techniques available to carry out these studies is, however, limited and this is particularly true in optics, since linear optical methods do not possess the ultimate molecular resolution. This resolution is inherent to nonlinear optical processes of even order. For liquid–liquid systems, optics turns out to be rather powerful owing to the possibility of nondestructively investigating buried interfaces. Furthermore, it appears that planar interfaces are not the only config-
FIG. 10 Vibrational sum frequency spectrum of saturated monolayers of dilauroyl- (DLPC), dimyristoyl- (DMPC), dipalmitoyl- (DPPC), and distearoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DSPC) at the D2 O–CCl4 interface at ambient temperature in the region of the methylene and methyl symmetrical stretches. (From Ref. 139, copyright American Chemical Society.)
148
Brevet
uration accessible to the experiment as recently demonstrated for spherical microscopic particles. The molecular resolution obtained by spectroscopy, combined with the surface specificity of nonlinear optics, has brought to light a detailed picture of interfaces in good agreement with the data obtained by other techniques like neutron reflection, for example, or calculations, molecular dynamics, or continuum models. One parameter of great interest has been the possibility of determining an angle of orientation for the compounds sitting at the interface. Unfortunately, information on the distribution function for this angle is difficult to obtain by independent measurements. Nevertheless, this is of real interest for interfacial reactions involving light absorption like photosynthesis or interfacial ET reactions. This is probably the reason for the large predominance of reports appearing in the literature on this topic as compared to dynamics or reactivity at interfaces. The latter two fields will certainly emerge as two new directions as new laser sources with better time resolution appear on the market. SFG will certainly benefit too from these technological advances as long wavelengths become easier to produce.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author acknowledges the generous support of the Fond national Suisse and fruitful discussions at the Laboratoire d’Electrochimie of the Ecole Polytechnique Fe´de´rale de Lausanne with J. Rinuy, A. Piron, P. Galletto, D. J. Fermin, and H. H. Girault. The Laboratoire d’Electrochimie is part of the European Network on Training and Mobility of Researchers ‘‘Organization, Dynamics and Reactivity of Electrified Liquid–Liquid Interfaces (ODRELLI).’’
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
A. J. Bard and L. R. Faulkner, in Electrochemical Methods, Fundamentals and Applications, Wiley, New York, 1980. A. G. Volkov and D. W. Deamer (eds.), Liquid–Liquid Interfaces, Theory and Methods, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996. H. H. Girault, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’Bockris et al., eds.), vol. 25, Plenum Press, New York, 1993. H. H. Girault and D. J. Schiffrin, in Electroanalytical Chemistry (A. J. Bard, ed.), vol. 15, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1989. Z. Ding, R. G. Wellington, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Electroanal. Chem. 420:35 (1997). T. Kakiuchi, Y. Takasu, and M. Senda. Anal. Chem. 64:3096 (1992). T. Kakiuchi and Y. Takasu. Anal. Chem. 66:1853 (1994). T. Kakiuchi and Y. Takasu. J. Phys. Chem. B. 101:5963 (1997). H. Duong, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Photochem. Photobiol. A: Chemistry 117:27 (1998). D. J. Fermin, Z. Ding, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Electroanal. Chem. 447:125 (1998). T. Takenaka and T. Nakanaga. J. Phys. Chem. 80:475 (1976). T. Takenaka. Chem. Phys. Lett. 55:515 (1978). J. M. Perera, J. K. McCulloch, B. S. Murray, F. Grieser, and G. W. Stevens. Langmuir 8:366 (1992). M. J. Wirth and J. D. Burbage. J. Phys. Chem. 96:9022 (1992).
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53.
149
Y. R. Shen, The Principles of Nonlinear Optics, Wiley, New York, 1986. G. L. Richmond, in Electroanalytical Chemistry (A. J. Bard, ed.), vol. 17, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1991, p. 87. Y. R. Shen. Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci. 16:69 (1986). S. G. Grubb, M. W. Kim, T. Rasing, and Y. R. Shen. Langmuir 4:452 (1988). K. B. Eisenthal. Chem. Rev. 96:1343 (1996). R. M. Corn and D. A. Higgins. Chem. Rev. 94:107 (1994). M. Born and E. Wolf, The Principles of Optics, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1980. P. F. Brevet, Surface Second Harmonic Generation, Presses Polytechniques Universitaires Romandes, Lausanne, 1997. P. N. Butcher and D. Cotter, The Elements of Nonlinear Optics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1992. N. Bloembergen and P. S. Pershan. Phys. Rev. 128:606 (1962). N. Bloembergen, R. K. Chang, S. S. Jha, and C. H. Lee. Phys. Rev. 174:813 (1968). C. C. Wang. Phys. Rev. 178:1457 (1969). T. F. Heinz, in Nonlinear Surface Electromagnetic Phenomena (V. M. Agranovich and A. A. Maradudin, eds.), vol. 29, North-Holland, New York, 1991. V. Mizrahi and J. E. Sipe. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 5:660 (1988). I. Benjamin. J. Phys. Chem. A 102:9500 (1998). H. Wang, E. Borguet, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. B. 102:4927 (1998). J. C. Conboy, J. L. Daschbach, and G. L. Richmond. J. Phys. Chem. 98:9688 (1994). J. F. Ward and C. K. Miller. Phys. Rev. A 19:826 (1979). B. F. Levine and C. G. Bethea. J. Chem. Phys. 65:2429 (1976). J. L. Oudar, D. S. Chemla, and E. Batifol. J. Chem. Phys. 67:1626 (1977). M. Blanchard-Desce, V. Alain. P. V. Bedworth, S. R. Marder, A. Fort, C. Runser, M. Barzoukas, S. Lebus, and R. Wortmann. Chem. Eur. J. 3:1091 (1997). P. Guyot-Sionnest and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. B 38:7985 (1988). P. Guyot-Sionnest and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. B 35:4420 (1985). P. F. Brevet. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 92:4547 (1996). A. A. Tamburello-Luca, P. He´bert, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 91:1763 (1995). R. Antoine, F. Bianchi, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 93:3833 (1997). T. Raising, G. Berkovic, Y. R. Shen, S. G. Grubb, and M. W. Kim. Chem. Phys. Lett. 130:1 (1986). M. C. Goh, J. M. Hicks, K. Kemnitz, G. R. Pinto, K. Bhattacharyya, K. B. Eisenthal, and T. F. Heinz. J. Phys. Chem. 92:5074 (1988). M. C. Goh and K. B. Eisenthal. Chem. Phys. Lett. 157:101 (1989). R. M. Corn and D. A. Higgins, in Molecular Orientation in Thin Films as Probed by Optical Second Harmonic Generation, vol. 6, Manning Publishers, Greenwich, 1994. J. L. Oudar and J. Zyss. Phys. Rev. A. 26:2016 (1982). G. J. Simpson and K. L. Rowlen. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121:2635 (1999). A. A. Tamburello-Luca, P. He´bert, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 92:3079 (1996). A. Castro, K. Bhattacharyya, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Chem. Phys. 95:1310 (1991). L. D. Barron, Molecular Light Scattering and Optical Activity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1982. T. Petralli-Mallow, T. M. Wong, J. D. Byers, H. I. Yee, and J. M. Hicks. J. Phys. Chem. 97:1383 (1993). T. Verbiest, S. V. Elshocht, M. Kauranen, L. Hellemans, J. Snauwaert, C. Nuckolls, T. J. Katz, and A. Persoons. Science 282:913 (1998). L. Hecht and L. D. Barron. Mol. Phys. 89:61 (1996). P. Ye and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. B 28:4288 (1983).
150
Brevet
54. 55. 56. 57. 58.
D. A. Higgins and R. M. Corn. J. Phys. Chem. 97:489 (1993). G. Berkovic, Y. R. Shen, G. Marowsky, and R. Steinhoff. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 6:205 (1989). J. Rinuy, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. Biophys. J. 77:3350 (1999). H. Paul and R. Corn. J. Phys. Chem. B 101:4494 (1997). K. Das, N. Sarkar, S. Das, A. Datta, D. Nath, and K. Bhattacharyya. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 92:4993 (1996). N. Sarkar, K. Das, S. Das, D. Nath, and K. Bhattacharyya. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 91:1769 (1995). J. M. Hicks, K. Kemnitz, K. B. Eisenthal, and T. F. Heinz. J. Phys. Chem. 90:560 (1986). A. J. Bell, J. G. Frey, and T. J. VanderNoot. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 88:2027 (1992). A. Pohorille and I. Benjamin. J. Chem. Phys. 94:5599 (1991). A. Pohorille and I. Benjamin. J. Phys. Chem. 97:2664 (1993). K. Kemnitz, K. Bhattacharyya, J. M. Hicks, G. R. Pinto, K. B. Eisenthal, and T. F. Heinz. Chem. Phys. Lett. 131:285 (1986). J. Rinuy, A. Piron, P. F. Brevet, H. H. Girault, and M. Blanchard-Desce, Chem. Eur. J, in press. T. F. Heinz, C. K. Chen, D. Ricard, and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. Lett. 48:478 (1982). P. D. Lazzaro, P. Mataloni, and F. D. Martini. Chem. Phys. Lett. 114:103 (1985) V. Vogel, C. S. Mullin, and Y. R. Shen. Langmuir 7:1222 (1991). T. Rasing, Y. R. Shen, M. W. Kim, P. Valint, and J. Bock. Phys. Rev. A 31:537 (1985). U. Elstner, G. Marowsky, G. Busse, and M. Kahlweit. Anal. Sci. 14:31 (1998). T. Rasing, T. Stehlin, Y. R. Shen, M W. Kim, and P. Valint. J. Chem. Phys. 89:3386 (1988). T. Rasing, Y. R. Shen. M. W. Kim, and S. G. Grubb. Phys. Rev. Lett. 55:2903 (1985). X. Zhao, M. C. Goh, S. Subrahmanyan, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. 94:3370 (1990). O. N. Slyadneva, M. N. Slyadnev, V. M. Tsukanova, T. Inoue, A. Harata, and T. Ogawa. Langmuir 15:8651 (1999). X. Zhao, M. C. Goh, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. 94:2222 (1990). T. Nakano, Y. Yamada, T. Matsuo, and S. Yamada. J. Phys. Chem. B. 102:8569 (1998). D. J. Donaldson, J. A. Guest, and M. C. Goh. J. Phys. Chem. 99:9313 (1995). F. M. Geiger, A. C. Tridico, and J. M. Hicks. J. Phys. Chem. B 103:8205 (1999). I. Benjamin. J. Chem. Phys. 95:3698 (1991). H. Wang, E. Borguet, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. A 101:713 (1997). C. Reichardt, Solvent and Solvent Effects in Organic Chemistry, VCH Publishers, Weinheim, 1988. D. Michael and I. Benjamin. J. Phys. Chem. B. 102:5145 (1998). Y. Kharkats and J. Ulstrup. J. Electroanal. Chem. 308:17 (1991). A. A. Tamburello-Luca, P. He´bert, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. Langmuir 13:4428 (1997). K. Bhattacharyya, E. V. Sitzman, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Chem. Phys. 87:1442 (1987). X. D. Xiao, V. Vogel, and Y. R. Shen. Chem. Phys. Lett. 163:555 (1989). X. Xiao, V. Vogel, Y. R. Shen, and G. Marowsky. J. Chem. Phys. 94:2315 (1991). R. R. Naujok, D. A. Higgins, D. G. Hanken, and R. M. Corn. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 91:1411 (1995). X. Zhao, S. Subrahmanyan, and K. B. Eisenthal. Chem. Phys. Lett. 171:558 (1990). D. A. Higgins, R. R. Naujok, and R. M. Corn. Chem. Phys. Lett 213:485 (1993). J. Conboy and G. Richmond. J. Phys. Chem. B 101:983 (1997). D. Zimdars, J. I. Dadap, K. B. Eisenthal, and T. F. Heinz. J. Phys. Chem. B. 103:3425 (1999). A. Castro, E. V. Sitzmann, D. Zhang, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. 95:6752 (1991). R. Antoine, A. A. Tamburello-Luca, P. He´bert, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. Chem. Phys. Lett. 288:138 (1998). G. R. Fleming, Chemical Applications of Ultrafast Spectroscopy, International Series of Monographs on Chemistry, vol. 13, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1986. I. Benjamin. Chem. Rev. 96:1449 (1996). E. Borguet, X. Shi, and K. B. Eisenthal. Springer Series in Chemical Physics 60:304 (1994).
59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97.
Nonlinear Optics at Liquid–Liquid Interfaces 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126. 127. 128. 129. 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139.
151
E. V. Sitzmann and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. 92:4579 (1988). R. R. Naujok, H. J. Paul, and R. M. Corn. J. Phys. Chem. 100:10497 (1996). D. J. Fermin, H. D. Duong, Z. Ding, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121:10203 (1999). K. L. Kott, D. A. Higgins, R. J. McMahon, and R. M. Corn. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115:5342 (1993). R. A. W. Dryfe, Z. Ding, R. G. Wellington, P. F. Brevet, A. M. Kuznetzov, and H. H. Girault. J. Phys. Chem. 101:2519 (1997). H. D. Duong, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Photochem. Photobiol. A: Chemistry 107:27 (1998). M. J. Crawford, J. G. Frey, T. J. vanderNoot, and Y. Zhao. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 92:1369 (1996). K. Tohda, Y. Umezawa, S. Yoshiyagawa, S. Hashimoto, and M. Kawasaki. Anal. Chem. 67:570 (1995). S. Yajima, K. Tohda, P. Buhlmann, and Y. Umezawa. Anal. Chem. 69:1919 (1997). R. Antoine, M. Pellarin, B. Prevel, B. Palpant, M. Broyer, P. Galletto, P. F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Appl. Phys. 84:4532 (1998). P. Galletto, P. F. Brevet, H. H. Girault, R. Antoine, and M. Broyer. J. Phys. Chem. B 103:8706 (1999). E. C. Y. Yan, Y. Liu, and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. B 102:6331 (1998). E. C. Y. Yan and K. B. Eisenthal. J. Phys. Chem. B 103:6056 (1999). G. S. Agarwal and S. S. Jha. Solid State Commun. 41:499 (1982). P. Galletto, P. F. Brevet, H. H. Girault, R. Antoine, and M. Broyer. Chem. Commun. 581 (1999). J. I. Dadap, J. Shan, K. B. Eisenthal, and T. F. Heinz. Phys. Rev. Lett. 83:4045 (1999). K. Clays, E. Hendrikx, M. Triest, and A. Persoons. J. Mol. Liq. 67:133 (1995). H. Wang, E. C. Y. Yan, E. Borguet, and K. B. Eisenthal. Chem. Phys. Lett. 259:15 (1996). A. Srivastava and K. B. Eisenthal. Chem. Phys. Lett. 292:345 (1998). P. B. Miranda and Y. R. Shen. J. Phys. Chem. B 103:3292 (1999). P. He´bert, A. le Rille, W. Q. Zheng, and A. Tadjeddine. J. Electroanal. Chem. 447:5 (1998). R. Superfine, J. Y. Huang, and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. Lett. 66:1066 (1991). M. Matsumoto and Y. Kataoka. J. Phys. Chem. 90:2398 (1988). Q. Du, R. Superfine, E. Freysz, and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. Lett. 70:2313 (1993). Q. Du. E. Freysz, and Y. R. Shen. Science 264:826 (1994). I. Benjamin. Phys. Rev. Lett. 73:2083 (1994). C. D. Stanners, Q. Du, R. P. Chin, P. Cremer, G. A. Samorjai, and Y. R. Shen. Chem. Phys. Lett. 232:407 (1995). D. E. Gragson and G. L. Richmond. Langmuir 13:4804 (1997). G. A. Sefler, Q. Du, P. B. Miranda, and Y. R. Shen. Chem. Phys. Lett. 235:347 (1995). P. Guyot-Sionnest, J. H. Hunt, and Y. R. Shen. Phys. Rev. Lett. 59:1597 (1987). C. Raduge, V. Pflumio, and Y. R. Shen. Chem. Phys. Lett. 274:140 (1997). S. Baldelli, C. Schnitzer, M. Shultz, and D. Campbell. J. Phys. Chem. B 101:4607 (1997). D. Zhang, J. H. Gutow, K. B. Eisenthal, and T. F. Heinz. J. Chem. Phys. 98:5099 (1993). S. Baldelli, C. Schnitzer, M. J. Schultz, and D. J. Campbell. Chem. Phys. Lett. 287:143 (1998). J. C. Conboy, M. C. Messmer, and G. L. Richmond. J. Phys. Chem. B 101:6724 (1997). G. R. Bell, C. D. Bain, Z. X. Li, R. K. Thomas, D. C. Duffy, and J. Penfold. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119:10227 (1997). D. E. Gragson, B. M. McCarthy, and G. L. Richmond. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119:6144 (1997). D. E. Gragson and G. L. Richmond. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120:366 (1998). R. A. Walker, J. A. Gruetzmacher, and G. L. Richmond. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120:6991 (1998). B. L. Smiley and G. L. Richmond. J. Phys. Chem. B 103:653 (1999). R. A. Walker, J. C. Conboy, and G. L. Richmond. Langmuir 13:3070 (1997). P. B. Miranda, V. Pflumio, H. Saijo, and Y. R. Shen. Chem. Phys. Lett. 267:387 (1997).
7 The Lattice-Gas and Other Simple Models for Liquid^Liquid Interfaces WOLFGANG SCHMICKLER Ulm, Ulm, Germany
I.
Department of Electrochemistry, University of
INTRODUCTION
The lattice gas has been used as a model for a variety of physical and chemical systems. Its application to simple mixtures is routinely treated in textbooks on statistical mechanics, so it is natural to use it as a starting point for the modeling of liquid–liquid interfaces. In the simplest case the system contains two kinds of solvent particles that occupy positions on a lattice, and with an appropriate choice of the interaction parameters it separates into two phases. This simple version is mainly of didactical value [1], since molecular dynamics allows the study of much more realistic models of the interface between two pure liquids [2,3]. However, even with the fastest computers available today, molecular dynamics is limited to comparatively small ensembles, too small to contain more than a few ions, so that the space-charge regions cannot be included. In contrast, Monte Carlo simulations for the lattice gas can be performed with 105 to 106 particles, so that modeling of the space charge poses no problem. In addition, analytical methods such as the quasichemical approximation allow the treatment of infinite ensembles. Therefore the lattice-gas model has proved most useful for the study of those processes in which the ionic double layer plays a major role, and there are quite a few. So it has been used to investigate the interfacial capacity, electron and ion-transfer reactions, and even such complex processes as ion pairing and assisted ion transfer. Because of its simplicity we cannot expect this model to give quantitative results for particular systems, but it is ideally suited to qualitative investigations such as the prediction of trends and orders of magnitude for various effects. In the following we will review recent applications of the lattice-gas model to liquid– liquid interfaces. We will start by presenting the basics of the model and various ways of treating its statistical mechanics. Then we will present model calculations for interfacial properties and for electron- and ion-transfer reactions. It is one of the virtues of the latticegas model that it is sufficiently flexible to serve as a framework for practically all processes at these interfaces. Of course, the lattice gas is not the only simple model that has been proposed for liquid–liquid interfaces. So we will conclude this review by a survey of several other models, which have usually been devised for certain aspects such as the interfacial capacity or ion transfer. Some of these models give a similar view of the interface, while others are radically different. 153
154
II.
Schmickler
THE BASICS OF THE LATTICE-GAS MODEL
All applications of the lattice-gas model to liquid–liquid interfaces have been based upon a three-dimensional, typically simple cubic lattice. Each lattice site is occupied by one of a variety of particles. In the simplest case the system contains two kinds of solvent molecules, and the interactions are restricted to nearest neighbors. If we label the two types of solvents molecules S1 and S2 , the interaction is specified by a symmetrical 2 2 matrix wij , where each element specifies the interaction between two neighboring molecules of type Si and Sj . Whether the system separates into two phases or forms a homogeneous mixture, depends on the relative strength of the cross-interaction w12 with respect to the self-interaction terms w11 and w22 , which can be expressed through the combination: w ¼ w12 ðw11 þ w22 Þ=2
ð1Þ
If w=kT is large, the system separates into two phases: phase 1 contains mainly solvent molecules S1 and has only a low concentration of S2 , and phase 2 is mainly composed of S2 . If w is small, entropy wins and the systems forms one phase. Details will be discussed below. If the system separates, it can be extended to a model for the interface between two solutions by introducing ions. In the basic case the system contains a salt composed of cations K1þ and anions A 1 which is preferentially solvated by the solvent S1 , but badly solvable in solution 2, and a salt K2þ A 2 that is preferentially dissolved in solvent 2. This can be achieved by choosing suitable interaction parameters between the ions and the two solvents. In addition to the nearest-neighbor interaction, each ion experiences the electrostatic potential generated by the other ions. In the literature this has generally been equated with the macroscopic potential calculated from the Poisson–Boltzmann equation. This corresponds to a mean-field approximation (vide infra), in which correlations between the ions are neglected. This approximation should be the better the low the concentrations of the ions.
III.
METHODS FOR TREATING THE LATTICE GAS
A.
The Mean-Field Approximation
The simplest treatment of the lattice-gas model is through the mean-field or randommixing approximation, which is treated in a number of textbooks (see, e.g., Refs. 1 and 4). We give a short summary of its application to liquid–liquid interfaces, since it nicely illustrates under what conditions the phases separate. We consider a system composed of N1 solvent molecules S1 and N2 molecules S2 ; by Nij , i; j ¼ 1; 2 we denote the numbers of nearest-neighbor pairs fi; jg. The energy E of the mixture is then: E ¼ N11 w11 þ N22 w22 þ N12 w12
ð2Þ
The numbers of pairs are related to the numbers of molecules and the number m of nearest neighbours: mN1 ¼ 2N11 þ N12
ð3Þ
mN2 ¼ 2N22 þ N12
ð4Þ
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
155
These relations can be used to introduce the quantities: E11 ¼ mN1 w11 =2
ð5Þ
E22 ¼ mN2 w22 =2
ð6Þ
and to rewrite the energy in the form: E ¼ E11 þ E22 þ N12 w
ð7Þ
where w has been defined in the previous section. So far the treatment has been exact. The mean-field approximation consists in assuming that the particles are randomly mixed, so that: N12 ¼ mNx1 x2
with
x1 ¼ N1 =N; x2 ¼ N2 =N
ð8Þ
where N is the total number of molecules, and the two mole fractions are related by x1 þ x2 ¼ 1. The Helmholtz free energy is obtained by adding the entropy term; this equals the Gibbs free energy, since the lattice is fixed and does not change with pressure. Hence we obtain: G ¼ E11 þ E22 þ mNx1 x2 w þ NkT ðx1 ln x1 þ x2 ln x2 Þ
ð9Þ
The last two terms give the free energy of mixing, which we rewrite in the compact form: Gmix ¼ x1 ð1 x1 Þ þ x1 ln x1 þ ð1 x1 Þ lnð1 x1 Þ NkT
ð10Þ
where ¼ mw=kT. Figure 1 shows the Gibbs energy of mixing as a function of the composition x1 for various values of . All curves are symmetrical with respect to the line x1 ¼ 1=2. For > 2 the curve has a maximum at x1 ¼ 1=2 and two symmetrically placed minima. In this case the mixture will separate into two phases, each corresponding
FIG. 1 Gibbs energy of mixing as a function of the composition in the mean-field approximation; the values of are from top to bottom: 3.0, 2.5, 2.0 (critical value), 1.0, 0.0, 0:5. (After Ref. 1 with permission from the author.)
156
Schmickler
to a minimum. For < 2 there is only one minimum at x1 ¼ 1=2, and the mixture will not separate. While these results are qualitatively correct, in an exact treatment of the model the critical interaction is generally not at ¼ 2, but lies at a different value, which will depend on the geometry of the lattice and not only on the number of nearest neighbors. Also, this treatment says nothing about the structure of the interface. It can be extended by introducing gradient terms, which allow the calculation of density profiles for the two solvents [1,5]. Since there are more accurate methods available for this purpose we refer to the cited literature. B.
The Quasichemical Approximation
The mean-field approximation neglects correlations between the particles and is therefore not very accurate. The quasichemical approximation improves upon this by accounting for the correlations between pairs of neighboring particles. We briefly give the essence of this method, since it will be used in a few studies reported below. Detailed accounts can be found in the literature [6]. We consider the basic case in which the system is composed of two solvents. The formation of pairs (1,2) is supposed to be in equilibrium with pairs (1; 1) and (2; 2), and considered to be a reaction of the type: 2ð1; 2Þ Ð ð1; 1Þ þ ð2; 2Þ
ð11Þ
The equilibrium condition is expressed through the partition functions qij per pair of particles: q11 / expðw11 =kT Þ
q22 / expðw22 =kT Þ
q12 / 2 expðw12 =kT Þ
ð12Þ
all with the same proportionality constant; the extra factor of 2 in the last term is due to the twofold degeneracy. This gives: 1 N12 ¼ ðN11 N22 Þ1=2 expðw=kTÞ 2
ð13Þ
From this equation and Eqs. (2) and (4) the energy of the system can be obtained. The entropy is more difficult to derive, and we refer to the literature [4,6]. Generally, the quasichemical gives better results than the mean-field approximation, since it allows for local order. We note that for the three-dimensional lattice gas no exact analytical solution exists. C.
Monte Carlo Simulations
Monte Carlo simulations offer a convenient way of obtaining numerically exact results. If the short-range interactions are restricted to nearest neighbors, and the Coulomb interaction effected through the average macroscopic potential, quite large ensembles can be handled, and the incorporation of the space-charge regions poses no problems. The simulations are typically performed on a three-dimensional lattice, each site being numbered by a triple ðl; m; nÞ of integers. Let the region l < 0 be occupied by solution 1, l > 0 by solution 2. The simulations usually start with the particles pertaining to solution 1, i.e., the solvent S1 and, if present, the ions K1þ and A 1 , distributed randomly in l < 0; similarly, the particles of solution 2 are in the region l > 0. Equilibrium is attained through a Metropolis [7] algorithm, which can be implemented in the following way:
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
157
During one Monte Carlo step each particle is sampled in turn; a nearest neighbor is chosen at random, and the energy E for an exchange of the two particles is calculated. If E < 0, the two particles are always exchanged. If E > 0, a random number r 2 ð0; 1Þ is chosen, and the exchange is effected if expðE=kTÞ > r. The first N steps, with N being of the order of 104 –105 , are discarded, and in the subsequent steps the distributions of the particles and of the electrostatic potential, and other properties of the system are sampled. The interface can be charged by adding an excess number of cations to one phase, and an equal number of anions to the other phase. For certain purposes extra particles may be added to the basic setup. The Monte Carlo method is quite flexible, and for reasonable ensemble sizes such as 100 20 20 particles, it is also quite fast, a typical run taking no more than a few hours on a decent computer.
IV.
RESULTS OF MODEL CALCULATIONS FOR THE LATTICE GAS
A.
Structure of the Interface
We first consider the simplest system consisting of two pure, immiscible solvents. Within the lattice-gas model the energetics of the system on a particular lattice are governed by the single parameter w [see Eq. (1)], which determines the structure of the interface and the particle profiles. The results presented in this section are for a simple cubic lattice. Monte Carlo simulation shows [8] that at a given instance the interface is rough on a molecular scale (see Fig. 2); this agrees well with results from molecular-dynamics studies performed with more realistic models [2,3]. When the particle densities are averaged parallel to the interface, i.e., over n and m, and over time, one obtains one-dimensional particle profiles f1 ðlÞ and f2 ðlÞ ¼ 1 f1 ðlÞ for the two solvents S1 and S2 , which are conveniently normalized to unity for a lattice that is completely filled with one species. Figure 3 shows two examples for such profiles. Note that the two solvents are to some extent soluble in each other, so that there is always a finite concentration of solvent 1 in the phase
FIG. 2 Snapshot of the interface of a gas on a simple cubic lattice with dimensions 100 16 16 for w=kT ¼ 0:6; the average position of the interface is between l ¼ 50 and l ¼ 51.
158
Schmickler
FIG. 3 Fig. 2.
Density profile f2 ðlÞ of the solvent S2 for two different values q=kT; other parameters as in
that consists mainly of solvent 2, and vice versa. The smaller w, the larger this solubility – remember that for sufficiently small values of w the two solvents mix completely. The width of the interface can be defined by fitting these profiles to a suitable function; a possible choice is: f ðxÞ ¼ fb þ
1 2fb ð1 þ tanhðx xs Þ=Þ 2
ð14Þ
where fb is the bulk concentration of solvent S1 in phase 1, xs is the position of the interface, and measures the width of the interface. There is a simple correlation between the width of the interface, the surface energy, and the miscibility of the solvents (see Table 1): the lower the surface energy, the wider is the interface, and the greater the miscibility of the solvents. This relation, which is intuitively expected, has also been observed in a density-functional study of an ensemble of dipoles [5], on which we will report below (see Section V.B). In the simple systems discussed so far the particle profiles are necessarily symmetrical with respect to the interface. This need no longer be the case for more complicated systems with several particles. As an example we show in Fig. 4 the particle profiles at the interface between an aqueous solution and a PVC-based membrane. B.
The Interfacial Capacity
The simplest model for the ionic distribution at liquid–liquid interfaces is the Verwey– Niessen model [10], which consists of two Gouy–Chapman space-charge layers back to TABLE 1 Interaction Parameter w, Decay Length (in Lattice Constants), and Bulk Composition fb for a Lattice Gas. Other System Parameters as in Fig. 2 w 0.5 0.6 0.7
fb
2.1 1.2 0.8
0.885 0.956 0.979
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
159
FIG. 4 Particle profile at the interface between an aqueous solution (open triangles) and a PVCbased membrane (full squares). Data taken from [9].
back. One would expect this model to work well at low ionic concentrations, however, there one often finds that the interfacial capacity is higher than that predicted by Verwey and Niessen. This is illustrated in Fig. 5, which shows the interfacial capacity at the potential of zero charge for several 10 mM solutions in contact with an aqueous solution. In contrast, at metal–solution interfaces the capacity is typically lower than predicted by the Gouy–Chapman theory.
FIG. 5 Comparison of the experimental capacity Cexp and the Verwey–Niessen capacity CVN at the potential of zero charge for 10 mM ionic solutions in various solvents. Details of these systems can be found in Ref. 11.
160
Schmickler
An explanation of this fact was offered by Pereira et al. [11] and by Huber et al. [12]: the overlap of the two solvents at the interface entails an overlap of the two space-charge regions. Thus the average separation between the opposing charges is reduced, and the capacity enhanced. Both groups performed explicit calculations; the former employed the quasichemical approximation, while the latter performed Monte Carlo simulations. To some extent these two techniques complement each other: the quasichemical approximation should be good at low electrolyte concentrations, while the Monte Carlo simulations, because of the finite ensemble size, are performed for more concentrated solutions. We first summarize the work of Pereira et al. [11]. The authors assume that the distribution of the two solvents is fixed, and given by: ( 1 12 expðx=Þ for x < 0 f1 ðxÞ ¼ ð15Þ 1 for x > 0 2 expðx=Þ where measures the width of the interface. The nearest-neighbor interactions of the ions with the solvents have to be chosen þ such that the ions K1þ and A 1 are preferentially solvated in solvent 1, K2 and A2 in solvent þ 2. The simplest choice is to set the interaction of K1 and A1 with S1 equal u, and with solvent S2 equal to u, where u < 0. Similarly, the interactions of K2þ and A 2 with S1 and S2 are u and u, respectively. Of course, nonsymmetrical choices are also possible, and are discussed in the original paper. The interaction parameter u determines the energy of transfer of the ion between the two pure solvents, which is 2mu. The energy of the cations K1þ can be written as: þ þ E1þ ¼ uN11 uN12
ð16Þ
where N1jþ ði ¼ 1; 2Þ denotes the number of pairs of ions K1þ and solvent molecules i. Within the quasichemical approximation the number of pairs can be expressed through the numbers N1þ of cations K1þ and solvent molecules N1 and N2 : þ N11 / N1þ N1 exp u
ð17Þ
þ N12 / N1þ N2 exp u
ð18Þ
with the same constant of proportionality. For low ionic concentrations: þ þ N11 þ N12 ¼ mN1þ
ð19Þ
From Eqs. (18) and (19) the numbers of pairs are easily calculated: þ N11 ¼ mN1þ þ ¼ mN1þ N12
f1
f1 e u u e þf
f1 e
f2 e u
2e
u
u
þ f2 e u
ð20Þ ð21Þ
where ¼ 1=kT. The electrochemical potential of the ion is obtained by taking the energy per particle, and by adding an entropy term and the electrostatic interaction per particle; for the entropy Pereira et al. take the expression for an ideal solution. This gives: ~ þ 1 ¼ mu
f1 e u f2 e u þ kT ln cþ 1 þ e0
f1 e u þ f2 e u
ð22Þ
where cþ 1 denotes the concentration, and the electrostatic potential. All ions are assumed to be monovalent. The distribution of the cation K1þ near the interface is obtained from
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
161
the condition that its electrochemical potential must be the same as in the bulk of solvent S1 , where it has the value: ~ þ 1 ð1Þ ¼ mu þ kT ln c0 þ e0 ð1Þ
ð23Þ
A short calculation gives: þ cþ 1 ðxÞ ¼ c0 exp e0 ½ ðxÞ ð1Þ g1 ðxÞ
ð24Þ
where ðxÞ ¼ exp 2 mu gþ 1
f2 e u f1 e u þ f 2 e u
ð25Þ
Similar equations can be derived for the other ions. The charge density ðxÞ is then obtained by adding the charge densities pertaining to all four kinds of ions. Both ðxÞ and the electrostatic potential ðxÞ are calculated by solving the Poisson equation selfconsistently, and the particle distributions then follow by substituting ðxÞ into Eq. (25) and the respective equations for the other ions. As an example Fig. 6 shows the distribution of the ions for a potential difference of ¼ ð1Þ ð1Þ ¼ kT=e0 between the two bulk phases. In these calculations the dielectric constant was taken as ¼ 80 for both phases, and the bulk concentrations of all ions were assumed to be equal. This simplifies the calculations, and the Debye length LD , which is the same for both solutions, can be used to scale the x axis. The most important feature of these distributions is the overlap of the space-charge regions at the interface, which is clearly visible in the figure.
FIG. 6 Normalized distribution cðxÞ=c0 of the ions for a potential drop of 0 =kT ¼ 1. The full lines give the distribution of the majority ions; in the region x < 0 these are the anions, in x > 0 these are the cations. The dashed lines give the distributions of the counterions. System parameters: m ¼ 4, u ¼ 3kT.
162
Schmickler
The charge density that is stored at the interface is obtained from the particle profiles: ð1 ð1 e0 cþ ðxÞ c ðxÞ ¼ e0 cþ ð26Þ ¼ 1 1 2 ðxÞ c2 ðxÞ 1
1
The interfacial capacity is then obtained by calculating the profiles for various potential drops and subsequent differentiation. Figure 7 shows several examples of capacity– potential characteristics for several widths of the interface. Obviously, the wider the interface, the higher the capacity. In all cases investigated it was higher than that calculated from the Verwey–Niessen model, in which: 1 e
CVN ¼ C0 cosh 0 2 4kT
(Verwey--Niessen)
ð27Þ
with C0 ¼ 0 =LD . In the figure, all capacities have been normalized by dividing through C0 . Huber et al. [12] investigated the same model by Monte Carlo simulations; however, they focused on a different aspect: the dependence of the interfacial capacity on the nature of the ions, which in this model is characterized by the interaction constant u. Samec et al. [13] have observed the following experimental trend: the wider the potential window in which no reactions take place, the lower the interfacial capacity. Since the width of the window is determined by the free energy of transfer of the ions, which is 2mu in this model, the capacity should be lower, the higher juj. In order to check this prediction, Huber et al. performed simulations on a lattice of dimensions 200 20 20; the lattice constant was taken as 4 A˚, and a dielectric constant of ¼ 80 was assumed throughout the system. Since a fair number of ions is needed to obtain good statistics, the ionic concentrations in this study are of the order of 0.1 M. Figure 8 shows the distribution of the ions K1þ and A 1 for two different values of the interactions constant u. The smaller juj, the lower is the repulsion of these ions from phase
FIG. 7 Normalized interfacial capacity versus the potential drop for various widths of the interface. (1) =LD ¼ 0:2; (2) =LD ¼ 0:1; (3) =LD ¼ 0:05; (4) Verwey–Niessen capacity.
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
163
FIG. 8 Distribution of the cations Kþ 1 and anions A1 at the interface for an excess-charge density of 0.0225 C m2 ; the full symbols are for u ¼ 3kT, the open symbols for u ¼ 1kT. The Debye length was LD ¼ 13:9 A˚, the solvent interaction w ¼ 0:55kT. The lines are meant as guides for the eye.
2, and the larger is the overlap of the space-charge regions; this entails a higher capacity, as can be seen from Fig. 9. These capacity curves illustrate also another effect that becomes important at higher ionic concentrations: when the lattice spacing is of the same order of magnitude as the Debye length, the size of the ions can no longer be neglected, as is usually done in the quasichemical and similar approximations. This finite-size effect reduces the interfacial capacity; therefore, depending on the other system parameters, the capacity can be either higher or lower than predicted by the Verwey–Niessen model. Thermodynamics show that the surface tension becomes lower when the interface is charged; this should lead to a widening of the interface. This has indeed been observed by
FIG. 9 Interfacial capacity for various ion–solvent interactions. System parameters: (1) u ¼ 3kT, (2) u ¼ 2kT; (3) u ¼ 1kT. The crosses denote the Gouy–Chapman capacity. Other parameters as in Fig. 8.
164
Schmickler
TABLE 2 Interfacial Width for Various Energies of Transfer of the Ions; the Other Parameters Are the Same as in Fig. 8 u ðkTÞ 1 1 2 2 3 3
ðVÞ
(A˚)
0 0.091 0 0.1 0 0.1
7.03 8.85 7.03 7.42 7.03 7.16
Huber et al. [12] (see Table 2). Another way of explaining this effect is the following: when the interface is charged the ions experience a stronger field that pulls them toward the other side. Thus they penetrate further into the other solution, and pull a few of their surrounding molecules with them. As expected, this effect is more marked when the free energy of transfer of the ions is small, because then the energy barrier at the interface is lower. C.
Interfacial Ion Pairing
As noted above, the capacity of liquid–liquid interfaces depends on the nature of the ions dissolved in the two adjoining phases. In some cases the capacity is related o the free energy of transfer of the ions involved, but in other cases quite strong dependencies are observed which can be explained by a tendency to form ion pairs at the interface. Evidence for this effect, which was first discussed by Hajkova et al. [14], was obtained in a paper by Cheng et al. [15], who observed marked changes in the capacity when they varied the composition of the aqueous phase. Further examples were provided by Pereira et al. [16], who also performed explicit calculations for ion pairing based on the lattice-gas model. Indeed, ion pairing can be introduced quite easily into the lattice gas by letting one pair of ions pertaining to different phases, e.g., K1þ and A 2 , interact through an attractive potential v < 0. The resulting model can be treated within the quasichemical approximation [16] by calculating the number of pairs of K1þ and A 2 along the line of Eqs. (16) to (21), or by Monte Carlo simulations [17]. Both approaches give qualitatively quite similar results. We review the results of the simulations, which are more recent. Technically, these simulations are very similar to those of Huber et al. [12]; the major difference is the introduction of the attractive potential between the pairing ions. In addition, these authors introduce different dielectric constants 1 and 2 for the two solutions. Near the interface the dielectric constant varies locally according to the simple prescription: x ¼ 1 f1 ðxÞ þ 2 f2 ðxÞ
ð28Þ
In the simulation the values 1 ¼ 80 and 2 ¼ 10 were taken. When phase 1 is negatively charged, the ions K1þ and A 2 are repelled from the interface, and the particle distribution is the same as in the absence of ion pairing. However, when phase 1 is positively charged, these ions are driven towards the surface, where they may form pairs. Hence their concentration at the interface is enhanced (see Fig. 10). This effect is the larger, the higher the excess-charge density, since the probability of
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
165
FIG. 10 Distribution of the ions Kþ 1 and A2 in the presence (full lines) and in the absence (dashed lines) of ion pairing. In the former case, the ionic interaction parameter was taken as v ¼ 9kT. The surface-charge density was taken as ¼ 2:34 C cm2 in phase 1.
ion pairing depends on the product of the concentrations of K1þ and A 2 , and hence roughly on the square of the excess charge. Ion pairing increases the charge that is stored at a given potential, and hence the interfacial capacity. The capacity characteristics in Fig. 11 show the asymmetry that is quite typical for ion pairing [15].
D.
Ion-Transfer Reactions
In Section IV.B the energy of an ion was calculated by a simple version of the quasichemical approximation. The same procedure can be used to calculate the potential of mean force pmf ðxÞ of an ion [18], which is the average potential that the ion experiences as a function of its position x in the direction perpendicular to the surface. This consists of two
FIG. 11 Interfacial capacity as a function of the total potential drop in the presence and in the absence (solid line) of ion pairing. Dotted line: v ¼ 9kT; dashed line: v ¼ 10kT.
166
Schmickler
components: the chemical part, which in the lattice-gas model is due to the interaction with the nearest neighbors, and the electrostatic part. From Eqs. (20) and (21) we obtain:
pmf ðxÞ ¼ mu
f1 e u f2 e u þ ze0 ðxÞ f1 e u þ f2 e u
ð29Þ
where the first term is the chemical part; z is the charge number of the ion. The potential of mean force is similar to the electrochemical potential, but it does not depend on the concentration; it is the potential that a single ion experiences as it moves toward, and possibly across, the interface. In the two bulk phases the potential of mean force is constant, but it may vary near the interface. The difference in the bulk values of the chemical part is the free energy of transfer of the ion, which in our model is 2mu (we assume u < 0). Let us consider the situation in which the ion-transfer reaction is in equilibrium, and the concentration of the transferring ion is the same in both phases; the system is then at the standard equilibrium potential 00 . In this case the potential of mean force is the same in the bulk of both phases; the chemical and the electrostatic parts must balance: 0 ¼ 2mu
at equilibrium
ð30Þ
Both terms vary near the interface: the chemical term rises by an amount 2mu over a region of width 2, while the electrostatic term drops by the same amount over a region, whose width is given by the two Debye lengths. Figure 12 shows the case where the Debye lengths are the same in both phases. Unless the concentration of the background electrolyte is very high, LD > . Therefore the potential of mean force first decreases as the ion moves from the bulk of phase 1 towards the interface, reaches a minimum, and rises rapidly in the region where the two solvents mix. It attains its maximum when the ion is mostly surrounded by solvent 2, and then decreases towards the bulk value. On application of an overpotential the free energy of the reaction is changed, and so is the potential of mean force. A positive overpotential lowers the maximum and deepens the minimum; the reverse is true for negative overpotentials (see Fig. 13). For very high overpotentials the two extrema disappear. Thus a very high positive overpoten-
FIG. 12 The potential of mean force for an ion-transfer reaction at equilibrium: (1) chemical term; (2) electrostatic term; (3) total potential. System parameters: u ¼ 0:5kT, n ¼ 4, =LD ¼ 0:1.
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
167
FIG. 13 The potential of mean force for various overpotentials. (1) 0 ¼ 2kT; (2) 0 ¼ kT; (3) 0 ¼ 0; (4) 0 ¼ 2kT; (5) 0 ¼ 2kT. The system parameters are the same as in Fig. 12.
tial leads to a barrierless transition; in this case ion transport is likely to be rate determining. Conversely, at high negative overpotentials the transition occurs without activation. From the potential of mean force the rate constant can be calculated. We first assume that transition-state theory is valid, and approximate the potential near the minimum and near the maximum by parabolas. The rate of escape of a particle from the well over the barrier is then [19]: ¼
! v vmin exp max 2 kT
ð31Þ
where ! is the frequency at the bottom of the well, and vmin and vmax are the values of the potential at the minimum and at the maximum, respectively. The reaction rate is given by the product of with the concentration cs of the ions in the bulk. The latter are in equilibrium with the well – otherwise the rate is determined by mass transport. Setting the chemical potential in the well equal to that in the bulk gives: rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 2kT v cs ¼ c0 ð32Þ exp min 2 kT m! where c0 is the concentration in the bulk, and m the effective mass. The rate constant is then: rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi kT v v ð33Þ k¼ exp max k0 exp max 2m kT kT Both the frequency of the well and its depth cancel, so that the free energy of activation is determined by the height of the maximum in the potential of mean force. The height of this maximum varies with the applied overpotential (see Fig. 13). To a first approximation this dependence is linear, and a Butler–Volmer type relation should hold over a limited range of potentials. Explicit model calculation gives transfer coefficients between zero and unity; there is no reason why they should be close to 1=2. For large overpotentials the barrier disappears, and the rate will then be determined by ion transport.
168
Schmickler
If friction plays a role in the crossing of the energy barrier, the reaction is slower than predicted by transition-state theory. According to Kramers’ theory [20] the preexponential factor must then be replaced by: k00 ¼
k ; !b 0
with
¼
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi !2b þ 2 =2
ð34Þ
where k0 is the preexponential factor in the transition-state theory [see Eq. (33)], !b is the barrier frequency, and the coefficient of friction on the barrier. In the overdamped case, when !b , the preexponential factor simplifies to: k00 ¼
!b k 0
ð35Þ
The rate constant is then inversely proportional to the coefficient of friction. Unfortunately, at the present time the experimental results for ion-transfer reactions are contradictory, so that it is not possible to verify the predictions of this model. Also, this model is only valid if the rate is determined by the ion-transfer step, and not by transport, and if the concentration of the supporting electrolyte is sufficiently low so that the extension of the space-charge regions is less than the width of the region where the two solvents mix. These conditions are not always fulfilled in experiments. The above model can be extended to assisted ion transfer, in which the ion forms a complex with a suitable ionophore. The various mechanisms for such reactions have been classified by Shao et al. [21] and reviewed by Girault [22]. Schmickler [23] has examined the case of transfer by interfacial complexation, which is marked by the following reaction sequence (see Fig. 14): The transferring ion moves from the bulk of solution 1 towards the interface with solution 2, in which it is poorly soluble. At the interface it reacts with an ionophore from solution 2, and then the complexed ion is transferred towards the bulk of solution 2. The reaction is again governed by the potentials of mean force for the participating particles. A typical situation is shown in Fig. 15: the reacting ion has a large energy of transfer from solution 1 to solution 2, so that the transfer of the uncomplexed ion is highly unfavorable. In contrast, the ionophore and the complexed ion are highly soluble in solution 2, but poorly soluble in solution 1. The most favorable reaction path is therefore along the potential of mean force of the ion towards the interface; there the ion reacts with
FIG. 14
Ion transfer assisted by interfacial complexation (schematic).
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
169
FIG. 15 Potential of mean force for the ion, the ionphore, and the complexed ion [23]. The Debye lengths for the two solutions have been taken as LD ¼ 30 A˚, and width of the interface as 3 A˚. The absolute value of the free energy of transfer was taken as 6kT for all particles, and the potential drop across the interface as 0 ¼ 3kT.
the ionophore, and the complexed particle can then move with little or no energy of activation to the bulk of phase 2. The rate of the ion transfer is governed by the complexation reaction, whose rate constant should not depend on potential since it is a purely chemical reaction. However, the concentrations of the reactant change with potential. Typically, the ionophore is uncharged, so that a change in the potential drop affects only the concentration of the ions at the interface. If the thickness of the interface is neglected, the concentration of the ion at the interface is given by: 0 z s cs ¼ c0 exp ð36Þ kT where the potential s at the interface can, to a first approximation, be calculated from the Verwey–Niessen theory. Explicit calculations within the lattice-gas model [23] show some quantitative corrections to these simple relations, but they also support the assertion that the change of the rate with potential is governed by changes in the ionic concentration at the interface.
E.
Electron-Transfer Reactions
Electron-transfer reactions at liquid–liquid interfaces have the form: ð2Þ ð1Þ ð2Þ Oxð1Þ 1 þ Red2 Ð Red1 þ Ox2
ð37Þ
where the subscript labels the chemical species, and the superscript indicates the solution in which it is situated. They are just a special case of electron transfer in solutions, and should therefore, to a first approximation, obey the theories of Marcus [24] and Hush [25]. So the rate of electron transfer from a reduced species labeled , situated at r , and an oxidized species at r can be written in the form:
170
Schmickler
ðE FÞ2 r ¼ A r r exp s 4kT
ð38Þ
where the preexponential factor A depends on the electronic overlap, Es is the energy of reorganization, and F the reaction free energy. The latter contains a chemical and an electrostatic term: F ¼ F 0 0 ðz Þ ðz Þ ð39Þ and thus depends on the position of the reactants. In principle, the energy of reorganization could also vary with position, but this dependence is expected to be small [26]. The preexponential factor usually decays exponentially with the separation of the reactants: A ¼ B exp r r ð40Þ where the inverse decay length is of the order of 1 A˚1 . In order to obtain an expression for the rate constant, we introduce the normalized red ox red particle densities ox ðzÞ and ðzÞ, which obey the conditions ð1Þ ¼ ð1Þ ¼ 1. They are related to the potential of mean force through: ðzÞ ¼ exp
pmf ðzÞ kT
ð41Þ
and can therefore be calculated from the lattice-gas model. With the aid of these quantities the rate constant for electron transfer from solution 2 to solution 1 can be written in the form: ð ð red 0 0 ket ¼ B dz dr 0 ox ðzÞ ðz Þ exp ðjr r jÞ ð42Þ fEs F 0 þ e0 ½ ðzÞ ðz 0 Þg2 exp 4kT The integrals have to be performed over the region in which the two reactants do not overlap. Equation (42) can serve as a basis for the calculation of the reaction rate and of current–potential curves. However, some basic features can be obtained by simple considerations. The two reactants meet at the interface in the region where the two solvents mix. Typically, the width of this region will be much smaller than the Debye lengths of the two solutions. Therefore the potential drop between the two reactants is small, and does not change much with the total potential . So a change of affects mainly the concentration of the reactants at the interface, and not the driving force for the reaction [22,26]. In this respect electron-transfer reactions at liquid–liquid interfaces resemble those at the interface between a semiconductor and an electrolyte solution. If the variation of the reactants’ concentration at the interface is calculated from the Verwey–Niessen theory, the following expression for the transfer coefficient results:
red ¼ zox 1 þ z2
þ coshð =2Þ zred 2 1 þ 2 þ 2 coshð =2Þ
with
¼
2 L1D 1 L2d
ð43Þ
red In the symmetrical case, where ¼ 1, this simplifies to ¼ ðzox 1 z2 Þ=2, and the transfer coefficient is independent of the potential. In the general case the transfer coefficient varies, and Tafel plots are expected to exhibit some curvature. These considerations are borne out by explicit model calculations (see Fig. 16), which give results close to those predicted by simple application of the Verwey–Niessen
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
171
FIG. 16 Current–potential curves for various charge numbers of the reactants. System parameters: red ox red for curves (1)–(3) Debye lengths L1 ¼ L2 ¼ 40 A˚, 1 ¼ 2 ; (1) zox 1 ¼ 1, z2 ¼ 1; (2) z1 ¼ 1, z2 ¼ 0; ox red ox red ˚ (3) z1 ¼ z2 ¼ 0; (4) L1 ¼ L2 ¼ 10 A, 1 ¼ 2 , z1 ¼ z2 ¼ 0.
model. The deviations are larger, the greater the width of the interface, the smaller the Debye lengths, and the larger the reactants. Experimental results for electron-transfer reactions are contradictory at the present time: investigations by Ding et al. [27] indicate that a change in the potential drop affects mainly the reactants’ concentration and only to a minor extent the driving force. This is in contrast to results by Tsionsky et al. [28] which suggest that only the driving force and not the concentration is changed. Very recently Liu and Mirkin [29] studied electron transfer from neutral zinc porphyrin molecules to an aqueous phase and found a potential-independent rate constant; this indicates that in this system neither the driving force nor the concentration for the neutral reactant is changed, which is in line with the model presented above. Perhaps this important issue will have been clarified by the time this book appears.
V.
OTHER MODELS FOR LIQUID–LIQUID INTERFACES
So far, the lattice gas has been the only model that makes predictions both about structure and reactions at liquid–liquid interfaces. There are however, various other models for particular features of these interfaces. Some of them give similar, others give contradictory results. In the following, we briefly review a few of these models. A.
The Modified Verwey–Niessen Model
The Gouy–Chapman theory for metal–solution interfaces predicts interfacial capacities which are too high for more concentrated electrolyte solutions. It has therefore been amended by introducing an ion-free layer, the so-called Helmholtz layer, in contract with the metal surface. Although the resulting model has been somewhat discredited [30], it has been transferred to liquid–liquid interfaces [31] by postulating a double layer of solvent molecules into which the ions cannot penetrate (see Fig. 17); this is known as the modified Verwey–Niessen model. Since the interfacial capacity of liquid–liquid interfaces is
172
Schmickler
FIG. 17
The modified Verwey–Niessen model.
often higher than predicted by the simple Verwey–Niessen model, there is little reason to introduce such an ion-free layer; nevertheless, this model is still quite popular. In itself, the modified Verwey–Niessen model has little predictive value, since the properties of the dividing layer are not known, and its thickness and dielectric constant can be fitted to any experimental data. It has been combined with the modified Poisson–Boltzmann theory [32], in particular with the version known as MPB4 [33,34]. However, even the combined model still has an adjustable parameter, so that its validity is difficult to assess. B.
Density-Functional Theory
Density-functional theory is best known as the basis for electronic structure calculations. A variant of this theory can be used to calculate the structure of inhomogeneous fluids [35]: the free energy of the fluid is expressed as a functional of the density of the various components; a theorem asserts that this functional attains its minimum for the true density profiles. Henderson and Schmickler [5] applied this formalism to the interface between two liquids. They considered an ensemble containing two kinds of spherical molecules which interact through their dipole moments and through a Yukawa potential. The free energy for the homogeneous system was calculated from perturbation theory, and the phase diagram was determined. Whether a separation into two phases occurs or not depends on the system parameters. Roughly speaking, phase separation is favored when the two dipole moments differ greatly, and when the cross-interaction between different molecules is much smaller than the self-interaction between identical molecules. When the two phases separate the distribution of the solvent molecules is inhomogeneous at the interface; this gives rise to an additional contribution to the free energy, which Henderson and Schmickler treated in the square gradient approximation [36]. Using simple trial functions, they calculated the density profiles at the interface for a number of system parameters. The results show the same qualitative behavior as those obtained by Monte Carlo simulations for the lattice gas: the lower the interfacial tension, the wider is the interfacial region in which the two solvents mix (see Table 3). It would be desirable to extend this model to electrolyte solutions, but it is extremely difficult to calculate a free-energy functional that accounts for the presence of ions. C.
Capillary Waves
Both the lattice-gas model and computer simulations predict that the interface is rough on a molecular scale. If this roughness is not too large, the interface can be represented by a
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
173
TABLE 3 Interfacial Widths, Bulk Composition, and Interfacial Tension Es in erg cm2 at the Interface Between Two Dipolar Liquids [5]. x01 Denotes the Mole Fraction of Solvent Si in Phase i (A)
x01
x02
Es
3.24 5.23 7.40 13.80
1.00 0.96 0.91 0.85
1.00 0.96 0.92 0.84
153.0 44.0 20.0 6.5
function Sðx; yÞ at a particular moment of time. The two-dimensional Fourier components AðqÞ of this surface function are known as capillary waves; q is a two-dimensional wave vector. Thus, a rough surface can be considered as a superposition of capillary waves, which are present at all wavelengths. Of course, they cannot be observed as traveling waves, but only as a fluctuating surface roughness. The energy stored in a capillary wave is proportional to the surface area it creates. This entails a prediction for the distribution of the amplitudes:
AðqÞA ðqÞ ¼
kT Es jqj2
ð44Þ
where the angular brackets denote thermal expectation values. This relation has indeed been observed in computer simulations of liquid–liquid interfaces [2,3]. The concepts of capillary waves and surface roughness can also be used to explain how the surface roughness increases the interfacial capacity beyond the Verwey–Niessen value. For this purpose Pecina and Badiali [37] have solved the linear Poisson–Boltzmann equation across the interface between two solutions with different dielectric constants and Debye lengths separated by a corrugated surface. A major difficulty is the boundary condition at the rough interface, which these authors handle by a perturbation expansion treating the roughness as a small parameter. Following Daikhin et al. [38], who had considered a similar problem for rough metal electrodes, Pecina and Badiali express the deviation from the Verwey–Niessen theory through a roughness function R~ ði ; i Þ, which depends on the dielectric constants of the two solutions and on their Debye inverse lengths i ¼ 1=Li . So the interfacial capacity per area is written as: C ¼ CVN R~ ði ; i Þ
ð45Þ
Obviously, if the two Debye lengths are much larger than the average height of the surface corrugation, the roughness plays no role, so that the roughness function tends to unity in that limit. On the other hand, when the two Debye lengths are much smaller than the corrugation – a case which should be difficult to obtain in practice – the roughness function is the ratio of the geometrical area to the area of the flat surface. As an illustration Pecina and Badiali consider a simple one-dimensional corrugation of the form: SðxÞ ¼ h cos kx
ð46Þ
Figure 18 shows the dependence of the roughness function on the two dimensionless parameters 1 h and 2 h. In accord with the limits considered above, the roughness function increases monotonically with both variables.
174
Schmickler
FIG. 18 Roughness function in dependence of the dimensionless parameters 1 h and 2 h. The dielectric constants have been taken as 1 ¼ 80, 2 ¼ 10. The ratio of the geometrical area to that of the flat surface was taken as 1.62 [37].
Recently, these authors have treated specific adsorption at corrugated liquid–liquid interfaces [39]; however, because of the complicated mathematics involved this work does not fall under the heading ‘‘simple models.’’ Also, Urbakh et al. [40] have extended the results for the interfacial capacity to the nonlinear region. D.
Kakiuchi’s Model for Ion Transfer
In the lattice-gas model, as treated in Section IV.D above, ion transfer is viewed as an activated process. In an alternative view it is considered as a transport governed by the Nernst–Planck or the Langevin equation. These two models are not necessarily contradictive: for high ionic concentrations the space-charge regions and the interface have similar widths, and then the barrier for ion transfer may vanish. So the activated mechanism may operate at low and the transport mechanism at high ionic concentrations. Kakiuchi [41] has examined the transport mechanism in some detail. He considers the interface as a region of thickness in which friction is considerably larger than in the bulk. The transferring ion has different electrochemical potentials ~ i ði ¼ 1; 2Þ in the two bulk phases; as usual, they can be decomposed into their chemical and their electrostatic parts: ~ i ¼ i þ ze0 i , where z is the charge number of the ion. When the system is in equilibrium, and the concentration of the ion is the same in the two solutions, then the difference in the inner potential is given by: ¼ ð47Þ 1 2 =z0 where the superscript denotes the standard state. serves as the reference potential drop. When the actual potential drop differs from this value, the electrostatic driving force is given by: f ¼
ð48Þ
The drop in the electrochemical potential across the boundary layer is assumed to be linear, and the diffusion coefficient D taken as constant. Following the work of
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
175
FIG. 19 Normalized current density jn ¼ j=Dc1 as a function of the normalized driving force y according to Kakiuchi [41]. Full line: c2 ¼ c1 ; dashed line: c2 ¼ c1 =2; dotted line: c2 ¼ c1 =10:
Goldman [42], Kakiuchi derives the following approximate solution to the Nernst–Planck equation for the ion transport across the interface and the concomitant current density: D yey yey c c j ¼ zF ð49Þ sinh y 1 sinh y 2 where ci is the concentration of the ion in the indicated phase, and zF f ð50Þ 2RT is the normalized electrostatic driving force. The two terms in the square brackets in Eq. (49) denote the difference between a forward and a backward current. The current–potential relationship predicted by Eqs. (49) and (50) differs strongly from the Butler–Volmer law. For y 1 the current density is proportional to the electrostatic driving force. Further, the shape of the current–potential curves depends on the ratio c1 =c2 ; the curve is symmetrical only when the two bulk concentrations are equal (see Fig. 19), otherwise it can be quite unsymmetrical, so that the interface can have rectifying properties. Obviously, these current–potential curves are quite different from those obtained from the lattice-gas model. As we have noted in Section IV.D, there are no reliable experimental data for iontransfer reactions, so that a comparison with experiment is not possible at this time. y¼
VI.
CONCLUSIONS
The simple models that we have reviewed here help in visualizing the structure of liquid– liquid interfaces and the reactions that occur at them. In addition, they predict trends and orders of magnitudes. So far, the lattice gas has been unique in that it can serve as a unifying model for practically all processes at the interface. The other models that we have discussed aim to explain particular features. Several models are just different ways of representing the same physical phenomenon. For example, the lattice-gas model, capillary waves, and the density functional calculations presented above basically have the same view of the interface. However,
176
Schmickler
other models are not compatible with each other; for example, the modified Verwey– Niessen theory cannot be reconciled with the lattice-gas model for the interfacial capacity. Unfortunately the development of models is hindered by a lack of reliable experimental data. For example, the rates of ion-transfer reactions measured at different times and by different groups vary widely. Also, it has been suggested that the high interfacial capacities that are measured in certain systems are an experimental artifact [13]. While this is frustrating for the researcher who wants to decide between competing models, it can also be viewed as a sign that the electrochemistry of liquid–liquid interfaces is an active field, where fundamental issues are just being explored.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Financial support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29.
W. Schmickler, Interfacial Electrochemistry, Oxford University Press, Oxford, New York, 1996. I. Benjamin. Chem. Rev. 96:1449 (1996). I. Benjamin. Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 48:407 (1997). T. L. Hill, Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass., 1960. D. Henderson, and W. Schmickler. JCS Faraday 92:3839 (1996). R. H. Fowler and E. A. Guggenheim, Statistical Thermodynamics, Cambridge, 1939. N. Metropolis, A. W. Rosenbluth, A. H. Teller, and E. Teller. J. Chem. Phys. 21:1087 (1953). W. Schmickler, unpublished results. A. Vinze, G. Horvai, F. A. M. Leermaker, and J. M. H. M. Sheutjens. Sensors Actuators 18– 19:42 (1994). E. J. W. Verwey and K. F. Niessen. Philos. Mag. 28:435 (1939). C. M. Pereira, W. Schmickler, A. F. Silva, and M. J. Sousa. Chem. Phys. Lett. 268:13 (1997). T. Huber, O. Pecina, and W. Schmickler. J. Electroanal. Chem. 467:203 (1999). Z. Samec, A. Troja´nek, and J. Langmeier. J. Electroanal. Chem. 444:1 (1998). P. Hajkova, D. Homolka, V. Marecek, and Z. Samec. J. Electroanal. Chem. 151:277 (1983). Y. Cheng, V. J. Cunnane, D. J. Schiffrin, and L. Mutoma¨ki. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 81:107 (1991). C. M. Pereira, W. Schmickler, F. Silva, and M. J. Sousa. J. Electroanal. Chem. 436:9 (1997). S. Frank and W. Schmickler, submitted to J. Electroanal. Chem. W. Schmickler. J. Electroanal. Chem. 426:5 (1997). R. Landauer and J. A. Swanson. Chem. Rev. 121:1668 (1961). H. A. Kramers. Physica 7:284 (1940). Y. Shao, M. Osborne, and H. Girault. J. Electroanal. Chem. 318:101 (1991). H. Girault, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (J. O’M. Bockris, B. E. Conway, and R. E. White, eds.), vol. 25, Plenum Press, New York, 1993. W. Schmickler. J. Electroanal. Chem. 460:144 (1999). R. A. Marcus. J. Chem. Phys. 24:966 (1956). N. S. Hush. J. Chem. Phys. 28:962 (1958). W. Schmickler. J. Electroanal. Chem. 428:123 (1997). Z. Ding, D. J. Fermı´ n, P.-F. Brevet, and H. H. Girault. J. Electroanal. Chem. 458:139 (1998). M. Tsionsky, A. J. Bard, and M. V. Mirkin. J. Phys. Chem. 100:17881 (1996). B. Liu and M. V. Mirkin. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121:8352 (1999).
The Lattice-Gas and Other Models
177
30. W. Schmickler. Chem. Rev. 96:3177 (1996). 31. P. Vanysek, Electrochemistry on Liquid–Liquid Interfaces, Lecture Notes in Chemistry, vol. 39, Springer, New York, 1985. 32. C. W. Outhwaite, L. B. Bhuyiyan, and S. Levine. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. II 76:1388 (1980). 33. Q. Cui, G. Zhu, and E. Wang. J. Electroanal. Chem. 372:15 (1994); 383:7 (1995). 34. T. Wandlowski, K. Holub, V. Marecek, and Z. Samec. Electrochim. Acta 40:2887 (1996). 35. D. Henderson (ed.), Fundamentals of Inhomogenous Fluids, Dekker, New York, 1992. 36. F. F. Abraham. J. Chem. Phys. 63:157 (1975). 37. O. Pecina and J. P. Badiali. Phys. Rev. E 58:6041 (1998). 38. L. I. Daikin, A. A. Kornyshev, and M. Urbakh. Phys. Rev. E 53:6192 (1996). 39. O. Pecina and J. P. Badiali. J. Electroanal. Chem. 475:46 (1999). 40. M. Urbakh, A. A. Kornyshev, and L. I. Daikin, submitted to J. Electroanal. Chem. 41. T. Kakiuchi. J. Electroanal. Chem. 322:55 (1992). 42. D. E. Goldman. J. Gen Physiol. 27:37 (1943)
8 Dynamic Aspects of Heterogeneous Electron-Transfer Reactions at Liquid^ Liquid Interfaces DAVID J. FERMI´N Laboratoire d’Electrochimie, De´partement de Chimie, Ecole Polytechnique Fe´de´rale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland RIIKKA LAHTINEN Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry, Department of Chemical Technology, Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Finland
I.
INTRODUCTION
The molecular nature of interfaces between two immiscible electrolyte solutions (ITIES) provides a well-defined framework for fundamental studies of heterogeneous electrontransfer processes (ET). The potential impact of this topic has been recognized even before carrying out comprehensive work. Outstanding contributions by Samec [1], Kharkats and Volkov [2], and Marcus [3–6] delivered basic descriptions of the ET dynamics involving two redox couples separated by a polarized liquid–liquid junction. Further developments including lattice-gas [7] and molecular dynamics modeling [8,9] have complemented these initial steps. By contrast, experimental studies have been able to address electron-transfer kinetics across ITIES only in the last few years. Among these recent advances, photoinduced heterogeneous ET has provided some exciting insights into the elementary processes at dye-sensitized liquid–liquid interfaces. The present chapter reviews these contributions, not only highlighting the experimental aspects and establishing comparisons with existing ET models, but also analyzing new perspectives for areas of practical interest such as twophase catalysis and solar energy conversion.
II.
FUNDAMENTAL CHALLENGES SURROUNDING ELECTRON-TRANSFER REACTIONS
The interpretation of phenomenological electron-transfer kinetics in terms of fundamental models based on transition state theory [1,3–6,10] has been hindered by our primitive understanding of the interfacial structure and potential distribution across ITIES. The structure of ITIES was initially studied by electrochemical and thermodynamic analyses, and more recently by computer simulations and interfacial spectroscopy. Classical electrochemical analysis based on differential capacitance and surface tension measurements has been extensively discussed in the literature [11–18]. The picture that emerged from 179
180
Fermı´n and Lahtinen
these studies described the interface as two diffuse layers separated by an ‘‘inner layer.’’ This approach, commonly referred to as the modified Verwey–Niessen model (MVN), has raised a great number of controversies, especially in connection to the nature of the ‘‘inner layer.’’ Molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo computer simulations have provided detailed microscopic pictures of liquid–liquid junctions [19–21]. One of the most interesting features underlined by these studies is that the interface is molecularly sharp, featuring ‘‘fingering’’ phenomena between both solvents. At the picosecond time scale, this phenomenon introduces a degree of roughness to the junction within a region of 10 A˚. Time averaging of these events defines a region in which dielectric, solvation, and transport properties depend on the position along the axis perpendicular to the interface. However, it is not clear yet how these phenomena would affect the kinetics of charge transfer process. These theoretical calculations are based on a collection of a few hundred solvent molecules where no electrolyte species are taken into account. Considering that homogeneous and heterogeneous ion–ion interactions play important roles on interfacial processes, only limited comparison with experimental data can be performed. The lattice-gas model has proved to be a rather useful theoretical approach to the study of ionic interactions at liquid–liquid interfaces [7,22]. By contrast to quantitative molecular dynamics, where Newton’s equations of motion are solved for all particles in the system over a certain period of time, the lattice-gas model considers only interactions between nearest neighbors in a cubic lattice arrangement. Basic aspects regarding this type of calculation have been described in recent publications [22,23]. Ionic distributions in the absence [7,22] and presence of ion-pairing interaction [24–27] have been considered as a function of the Galvani potential difference. The potential dependence of the heterogeneous ET rate constant is one of the most important outputs of this work. Simulations suggested that if the Debye lengths in each electrolyte solution are larger than the width of the interface, the potential drop across the reactants is very small, therefore any potential perturbation will manifest itself by changes in the interfacial concentration of reactants [7]. From the experimental point of view, structural aspects have been addressed by interfacial spectroscopic methods such as neutron reflectivity [28–32] and quasielastic laser scattering [33–36]. The latter technique has provided valuable information on the frequency of capillary waves generated by thermal fluctuations at the liquid–liquid junction. Although this technique has been employed for adsorption studies at nonpolarized interfaces, it is also expected to provide useful information on the interfacial structure during charge-transfer processes. Important advances have also emerged from nonlinear optics, in particular second harmonic generation (SHG). The noncentrosymmetrical nature of the liquid–liquid junctions allows SHG responses as well as sum frequency generation (SFG) signals from species at the interface, providing information on the excess concentration, molecular orientation, and structure. Basic aspects of these powerful techniques have been comprehensively described [37,38] and more recent contributions are reviewed in this book (Chapter 6). These spectroscopic and theoretical developments have stimulated the recent advances on electron-transfer dynamics at ITIES. In addition to the correlation between structure and dynamics of charge transfer, fundamental problems in connection with the energetics of ET reactions remain to be fully addressed. We shall consider these problems primarily before discussing kinetic aspects in full detail.
Dynamic Aspects of Electron-Transfer Reactions
A.
181
Energetics of ET and Photoinduced ET Reactions
From the thermodynamic point of view, the occurrence of a heterogeneous ET event at a liquid–liquid interface is determined not only by the relation of redox potentials between reactants in each phase, but also by the Galvani potential difference. Let us consider the general reaction, o w o Ow 1 þ R2 Ð R1 þ O2
ð1Þ
where the superscripts ‘‘w’’ and ‘‘o’’ correspond to the aqueous and organic phases. The Nernst equation associated with the equilibrium conditions is given by w o RT aO1 aR2 w 0 ln ð2Þ
¼
w o o et o nF aw R1 aO2 0 where the standard potential w o et is determined by 0 0;o 0;w w o et ¼ EO2=R2 EO1=R1
ð3Þ
In order to express the standard redox potentials of the two couples located in different 0;o can be expressed in terms of solvents on a same potential scale, e.g., SHE in water, EO2=R2 0;w the corresponding redox potential in water ðEO2=R2 Þ and the Gibbs energies of transfer of the species R2 and O2 , 0;o 0;w EO2=R2 ¼ EO2=R2 þ
G0;w!o G0;w!o R2 O2 nF
ð4Þ
So far, the experimentally obtained formal electron-transfer potentials have not been rationalized in terms of Eqs. (3) and(4). In view of the lack of a suitable redox reference for organic electrolytes, we have recently studied the oxidation of ferrocene (Fc) by the hexacyanoferrate redox couple at the water–1,2-dichloroethane (DCE) interface. Figure 1(a) displays a typical cyclic voltammogram recorded on a four-electrode potentiostat for the cell configuration represented in Fig. 1(b). The Galvani potential scale was estimated considering the so-called TATB assumption [39,40]. Under this approximation the transfer potentials of several standard ions such as tetrapropylammonium (TPAþ ) and tetramethylammonium (TMAþ ) are documented (see database at www.epf.ch/le). Unless otherwise indicated, the convention adopted throughout this review defines positive currents to the transfer of positive charges from water to DCE. The voltammogram in Fig. 1(a) shows the electron-transfer signal in comparison with the transfer wave of TPAþ . From the difference in the half wave transfer potentials, it can be estimated that the formal electron0 transfer potential is w o et ¼ 0:160 0:010 V. Taking into account that the concentration of the hexacyanoferrate couple is in large excess with respect to ferrocene, the observed formal ET potential can be effectively expressed as ! RT FeðCNÞ3 w 00 0;DCE 0;w 6 ln o et ¼ EðFcþ =FcÞ EðFeðCNÞ3 =FeðCNÞ4 Þ ð5Þ 6 6 F FeðCNÞ4 6 Under similar conditions, the formal redox potential of the aqueous couple has been estimated as 0:358 0:005 ; V vs SHE. From Eq. (5), it is obtained that the formal 0 0 ;DCE redox potential of Fc in DCE is EFc þ =Fc ¼ 0:635 0:015 V vs SHE. The redox potential of Fc obtained from the cyclic voltammetry experiments at the water–DCE interface can be verified by evaluating the thermodynamic cycle given by Eq. (4). It follows that
Fermı´n and Lahtinen
182
FIG. 1 (a) Cyclic voltammogram of the heterogeneous oxidation of ferrocene by the hexacyanoferrate redox couple at the water–DCE interface at 10 mV s1 . The convention adopted throughout the review defines positive currents as the transfer of a positive charge from water to DCE. (b) The composition of the cell schematically represented. BTPPA and TPBCl stand for bis(triphenylphosphoranylidene)-ammonium and tetrakis(4-chlorophenyl) borate respectively. The current was measured through two platinum counterelectrodes located in each phase. The surface area of the liquid– liquid junction was 1:53 cm2 . The cation tetrapropylammonium (TPAþ Þ was also present in the aqueous phase as a reference for the Galvani potential scale.
0
0 ;DCE o;w w 0 0;w!o EFc =F þ =Fc ¼ EðFcþ =FcÞ þ o Fcþ GFc
ð6Þ
corresponds to the Fc Gibbs energy of transfer from water where the parameter G0;w!o Fc 0 0 ;w to the DCE phase. An average value for the Fc redox potential of EFc þ =Fc ¼ 0:381 0:006 V was derived from voltammetry at ultramicroelectrodes [41], while the parameter ¼ 24:3 0:2 kJ mol1 has been estimated from extraction methods. The third G0;w!o Fc parameter required in Eq. (6) was obtained by monitoring the transfer of Fcþ accumulated during the oxidation of Fc by CuSO4 at the water–DCE interface. Figure 2 shows cyclic voltammograms featuring the 0transfers of Fcþ and the standard