BIOMOLECULAR FILMS Design, Function, and Applications edited by James F. Rusling University of Connecticut Starrs, Conn...
312 downloads
2992 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
BIOMOLECULAR FILMS Design, Function, and Applications edited by James F. Rusling University of Connecticut Starrs, Connecticut, U.S.A.
MARCEL
MARCEL DEKKER, INC.
NEW YORK • BASEL
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. ISBN: 0-8247-0899-7 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Headquarters Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016 tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540 Eastern Hemisphere Distribution Marcel Dekker AG Hutgasse 4, Postfach 812, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 41-61-260-6300; fax: 41-61-260-6333 World Wide Web http://www.dekker.com The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above. Copyright # 2003 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Current printing (last digit): 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
SURFACTANT SCIENCE SERIES
FOUNDING EDITOR
MARTIN J. SCHICK 1918-1998 SERIES EDITOR
ARTHUR T. HUBBARD Santa Barbara Science Project Santa Barbara, California
ADVISORY BOARD
DANIEL BLANKSCHTEIN Department of Chemical Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, Massachusetts
ERICW KALER Department of Chemical Engineering University of Delaware Newark, Delaware
S. KARABORNI Shell International Petroleum Company Limited London, England
CLARENCE MILLER Department of Chemical Engineering Rice University Houston, Texas
LISAB QUENCER The Dow Chemical Company Midland, Michigan
DON RUBINGH The Procter & Gamble Company Cincinnati, Ohio
JOHN F SCAMEHORN Institute for Applied Surfactant Research University of Oklahoma Norman, Oklahoma
BEREND SMIT Shell International Oil Products B V Amsterdam, The Netherlands
P SOMASUNDARAN Henry Krumb School of Mines Columbia University New York, New York
JOHN TEXTER Strider Research Corporation Rochester, New York
1. Nonionic Surfactants, edited by Martin J. Schick (see also Volumes 19, 23, and 60) 2. Solvent Properties of Surfactant Solutions, edited by Kozo Shinoda (see Volume 55) 3. Surfactant Biodegradation, R. D. Sw/sAjer(see Volume 18) 4. Cationic Surfactants, edited by Eric Jungermann (see also Volumes 34, 37, and 53) 5. Detergency: Theory and Test Methods (in three parts), edited by W. G. Cutler and R. C. Davis (see also Volume 20) 6. Emulsions and Emulsion Technology (in three parts), edited by Kenneth J. Lissant 7. Anionic Surfactants (in two parts), edited by Warner M. Linfield (see Volume 56) 8. Anionic Surfactants: Chemical Analysis, edited by John Cross 9. Stabilization of Colloidal Dispersions by Polymer Adsorption, Tatsuo Sato and Richard Ruch 10. Anionic Surfactants: Biochemistry, Toxicology, Dermatology, edited by Christian Gloxhuber (see Volume 43) 11. Anionic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry of Surfactant Action, edited by E. H. Lucassen-Reynders 12. Amphoteric Surfactants, edited by B. R. Bluestein and Clifford L Hilton (see Volume 59) 13. Demulsification: Industrial Applications, Kenneth J. Lissant 14. Surfactants in Textile Processing, Arved Datyner 15. Electrical Phenomena at Interfaces: Fundamentals, Measurements, and Applications, edited byAyao Kitahara andAkira Watanabe 16. Surfactants in Cosmetics, edited by Martin M. Rieger (see Volume 68) 17. Interfacial Phenomena: Equilibrium and Dynamic Effects, Clarence A. Miller and P. Neogi 18. Surfactant Biodegradation: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, R. D. Swisher 19. Nonionic Surfactants: Chemical Analysis, edited by John Cross 20. Detergency: Theory and Technology, edited by W. Gale Cutler and Erik Kissa 21. Interfacial Phenomena in Apolar Media, edited by Hans-Friedrich Eicke and Geoffrey D. Parfitt 22. Surfactant Solutions: New Methods of Investigation, edited by Raoul Zana 23. Nonionic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry, edited by Martin J. Schick 24. Microemulsion Systems, edited by Henri L Rosano and Marc Clausse 25. Biosurfactants and Biotechnology, edited by Nairn Kosaric, W. L Cairns, and Neil C. C. Gray 26. Surfactants in Emerging Technologies, edited by Milton J. Rosen 27. Reagents in Mineral Technology, edited by P. Somasundaran and Brij M. Moudgil 28. Surfactants in Chemical/Process Engineering, edited by Darsh T. Wasan, Martin E. Ginn, and Dinesh O. Shah 29. Thin Liquid Films, edited by I. B. Ivanov 30. Microemulsions and Related Systems: Formulation, Solvency, and Physical Properties, edited by Maurice Bourrel and Robert S. Schechter 31. Crystallization and Polymorphism of Fats and Fatty Acids, edited by Nissim Garti and Kiyotaka Sato
32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65
Interfacial Phenomena in Coal Technology, edited by Gregory D Botsaris and Yuli M Glazman Surfactant-Based Separation Processes, edited by John F Scamehorn and Jeffrey H Harwell Cationic Surfactants Organic Chemistry, edited by James M Richmond Alkylene Oxides and Their Polymers, F E Bailey, Jr, and Joseph V Koleske Interfacial Phenomena in Petroleum Recovery, edited by Norman R Morrow Cationic Surfactants Physical Chemistry, edited by Donn N Rubmgh and PaulM Holland Kinetics and Catalysis in Microheterogeneous Systems, edited by M Gratzel and K Kalyanasundaram Interfacial Phenomena in Biological Systems, edited by Max Bender Analysis of Surfactants, Thomas M Schmitt (see Volume 96) Light Scattering by Liquid Surfaces and Complementary Techniques, edited by Dominique Langevin Polymeric Surfactants, Irja Piirma Anionic Surfactants Biochemistry, Toxicology, Dermatology Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Christian Gloxhuberand Klaus Kunstler Organized Solutions Surfactants in Science and Technology, edited by Stig E Fnberg and Bjorn bndman Defoammg Theory and Industrial Applications, edited by P R Garrett Mixed Surfactant Systems, edited by Keizo Ogino and Masahiko Abe Coagulation and Flocculation Theory and Applications, edited by Bohuslav Dobias Biosurfactants Production • Properties • Applications, edited by Nairn Kosanc Wettabihty, edited by John C Berg Fluonnated Surfactants Synthesis • Properties • Applications, Erik Kissa Surface and Colloid Chemistry in Advanced Ceramics Processing, edited by Robert J Pugh and Lennart Bergstrom Technological Applications of Dispersions, edited by Robert B McKay Cationic Surfactants Analytical and Biological Evaluation, edited by John Cross and Edward J Singer Surfactants in Agrochemicals, Tharwat F Tadros Solubihzation in Surfactant Aggregates edited by Shernl D Christian and John F Scamehorn Anionic Surfactants Organic Chemistry, edited by Helmut W Stache Foams Theory, Measurements, and Applications, edited by Robert K Prud'homme and Saad A Khan The Preparation of Dispersions in Liquids, H N Stein Amphotenc Surfactants Second Edition, edited by Eric G Lomax Nonionic Surfactants Polyoxyalkylene Block Copolymers, edited by Vaughn M A/ace Emulsions and Emulsion Stability, edited by Johan Sjoblom Vesicles, edited by Morton Rosoff Applied Surface Thermodynamics, edited by A W Neumann and Jan K Spelt Surfactants in Solution, edited by Arun K Chattopadhyay and K L Mittal Detergents in the Environment, edited by Milan Johann Schwuger
66. Industrial Applications of Microemulsions, edited by Conxita Solans and Hironobu Kunieda 67. Liquid Detergents, edited by Kuo-Yann Lai 68. Surfactants in Cosmetics: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Martin M. Rieger and Linda D. Rhein 69. Enzymes in Detergency, edited by Jan H. van Ee, Onno Misset, and Erik J. Baas 70. Structure-Performance Relationships in Surfactants, edited by Kunio Esumi and Minoru Ueno 71. Powdered Detergents, edited by Michael S. Showell 72. Nonionic Surfactants: Organic Chemistry, edited by Nico M. van Os 73. Anionic Surfactants: Analytical Chemistry, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by John Cross 74. Novel Surfactants: Preparation, Applications, and Biodegradability, edited by Krister Holmberg 75. Biopolymers at Interfaces, edited by Martin Malmsten 76. Electrical Phenomena at Interfaces: Fundamentals, Measurements, and Applications, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Hiroyuki Ohshima and Kunio Furusawa 77. Polymer-Surfactant Systems, edited by Jan C. T. Kwak 78. Surfaces of Nanoparticles and Porous Materials, edited by James A. Schwarz and Cristian I. Contescu 79. Surface Chemistry and Electrochemistry of Membranes, edited by Torben Smith S0rensen 80. Interfacial Phenomena in Chromatography, edited by Emile Pefferkom 81. Solid-Liquid Dispersions, Bohuslav Dobias, Xueping Qiu, and Wolfgang von Rybinski 82. Handbook of Detergents, editor in chief: Uri Zoller Part A: Properties, edited by Guy Braze 83. Modern Characterization Methods of Surfactant Systems, edited by Bernard P. Binks 84. Dispersions: Characterization, Testing, and Measurement, Erik Kissa 85. Interfacial Forces and Fields: Theory and Applications, edited by Jyh-Ping Hsu 86. Silicone Surfactants, edited by Randal M. Hill 87. Surface Characterization Methods: Principles, Techniques, and Applications, edited by Andrew J. Milling 88. Interfacial Dynamics, edited by Nikola Kallay 89. Computational Methods in Surface and Colloid Science, edited by Matgorzata Borowko 90. Adsorption on Silica Surfaces, edited by Eugene Papirer 91. Nonionic Surfactants: Alkyl Polyglucosides, edited by Dieter Balzer and Harald Luders 92. Fine Particles: Synthesis, Characterization, and Mechanisms of Growth, edited by Tadao Sugimoto 93. Thermal Behavior of Dispersed Systems, edited by Nissim Garti 94. Surface Characteristics of Fibers and Textiles, edited by Christopher M. Pastore and Paul Kiekens 95. Liquid Interfaces in Chemical, Biological, and Pharmaceutical Applications, edited by Alexander G. Volkov
96 Analysis of Surfactants Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Thomas M Schmitt 97 Fluormated Surfactants and Repellents Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Erik Kissa 98 Detergency of Specialty Surfactants, edited by Floyd E Fnedli 99 Physical Chemistry of Polyelectrolytes, ecWed by Tsetska Radeva 00 Reactions and Synthesis in Surfactant Systems, edited by John Texter 01 Protein-Based Surfactants Synthesis, Physicochemical Properties, and Applications, edited by Ifendu A Nnanna and Jiding Xia 02 Chemical Properties of Material Surfaces, Marek Kosmulski 03 Oxide Surfaces, edited by James A Wingrave 104 Polymers in Particulate Systems Properties and Applications edited by Vincent A Hackley, P Somasundaran, and Jennifer A Lewis 105 Colloid and Surface Properties of Clays and Related Minerals, Rossman F Giese and Care/ J van Oss 106 Interfacial Electrokinetics and Electrophoresis, edited by Angel V Delgado 107 Adsorption Theory, Modeling, and Analysis, edited by Jozsef Toth 108 Interfacial Applications in Environmental Engineering, edited by Mark A Keane 109 Adsorption and Aggregation of Surfactants in Solution, eoMed by K L Mittal and Dinesh O Shah 110 Biopolymers at Interfaces Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Martin Malmsten 111 Biomolecular Films Design, Function and Applications, edited by James F Rusling 112 Structure-Performance Relationships in Surfactants Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Kunio Esumi and Mmoru Ueno
ADDITIONAL VOLUMES IN PREPARATION Liquid Interfacial Systems Oscillations and Instability, Rudolph V Binkh, Vladimir A Bnskman, Manuel G Velarde, and Jean-Claude Legros Novel Surfactants Preparation, Applications, and Biodegradabihty Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Krister Holmberg Colloidal Polymers Preparation and Biomedical Applications, edited by Abdelhamid Elaissan
Preface
Modifying solid interfaces with purposely designed supramolecular structures has become one of the most vibrant and dynamic areas in the physical sciences, engineering, and biology. Films of biomolecules can be used to tailor the properties of interfaces, providing solid surfaces that can catalyze enzyme reactions, serve in biosensors and as biorecognition elements, mediate nanoparticle formation, and provide a basis for fundamental biochemical and biophysical studies. Present and future applications in biomedicine and biomedical devices abound. This volume provides a modern collection of unique biomolecular film methodologies and presents techniques to investigate their properties. These activities go hand in hand. Traditional methods of chemical analysis such as various spectroscopies, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and mass spectrometry need to be modified or redesigned altogether to address the special features of ultrathin biomolecular films. Reliable characterization methods are of critical importance to connect structure with the function of the films. The chapters in this book can be divided into four overlapping categories: 1) types and construction of biomolecular films, 2) methods of analyzing biomolecular films, 3) systems designed for chemical synthesis, and 4) design and function of biosensors. The first two categories are the most overlapped. Chapter 1 is from my lab and discusses stable multilayer protein and DNA films for electrochemical applications. Chapter 2, by iii
iv
Preface
Katsumi Niki and Brian Gregory, describes electrochemically active monolayer films of adsorbed proteins on self-assembled monolayers on electrode surfaces. In Chapter 3, Anne Plant and coworkers describe biomimetic lipid bilayer films on metals, often called supported bilayers, and many ways to characterize them. Paul Bohn discusses peptide- and protein-based biomolecular assemblies along with optical and other analysis methods in Chapter 4. Nongjian Tao and coworkers present a lucid treatise on the application of surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy to protein adsorption and electrochemistry in Chapter 5. Patrick Unwin’s group from the University of Warwick in England describes in Chapter 6 the use of the relatively new method of scanning electrochemical microscopy applied to samples ranging from monolayers to biological cell surfaces to tissues. In Chapter 7, Ernesto Calvo’s group from Argentina describes applications of quartz crystal microbalance frequency analysis to layered protein films. Katsuhiko Ariga and coworkers from Japan describe films designed for enzyme reactors in Chapter 8. Continuing with the synthetic theme, Janos Fendler of Clarkson University describes nanoparticle synthesis using biomimetic films in Chapter 9. The last three chapters cover applications to biosensors. Chapter 10, by Anthony Killard and Malcolm Smyth of Dublin City University, provides a broad overview of biosensors. In Chapter 11, Evelyne Simon and Philip Bartlett of the University of Southampton in England discuss films on electrodes designed for the important enzyme cofactor NADH, which can be employed for sensors designed with enzymes that use or generate NADH. Finally, Chapter 12, by Michael Tarlov and Adam Steel, describes the important and relatively new area of DNA sensors, which may become clinically important in the near future. We hope that these chapters together provide a broad, informative overview of the state of the art in research in biomolecular films.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I acknowledge the understanding and forbearance of my family, colleagues, and students during the editing and writing of this book. Special thanks are due to my wife, Penelope Williams, for her patience, kindness, and constant support. I am also indebted to the editorial staff of Marcel Dekker, Inc., for their excellent work on this project, and to Professor Arthur Hubbard for encouragement. The lion’s share of the book editing and the writing of Chapter 1 were completed while I was on sabbatical leave at the Irish National Center for Sensor Research (NCSR), School of Chemical Sciences, Dublin City
Preface
v
University (DCU). Special thanks go to Professor Malcolm Smyth, Dean and Chemical Sciences Head at DCU, for his stellar support and cheerful friendship during our stay in Dublin. Thanks also go to DCU faculty members Robert Forster and Han Vos for research collaboration and discussions that counterbalanced the sometimes tedious editing and writing duties, and to Dermot Diamond for excellent fiddle playing on many occasions. My wife and I also thank the entire staff and graduate/postdoctoral community of NCSR for making our stay in Dublin a very pleasant, friendly, and professionally satisfying experience. Kathleen Grennan deserves special mention for her friendship, and for organizing and participating in several weekend jaunts to her home county of Kilkenny, where I enjoyed playing traditional Irish tunes on an accordion with the friendly musicians at Mannion’s in New Ross. I would also be remiss not to mention the contributions of important local meeting places such as the Slipper and the Gravediggers near DCU, where the developing project and its intricacies were discussed with colleagues in a relaxed atmosphere. James F. Rusling
Contents
Preface Contributors
iii ix
1.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films on Electrodes James F. Rusling and Zhe Zhang
2.
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films Immobilized on Self-Assembled Monolayers of Organothiols Katsumi Niki and Brian W. Gregory
3.
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports John T. Elliott, Curtis W. Meuse, Vitalii Silin, Susan Krueger, John T. Woodward, Teresa Petralli-Mallow, and Anne L. Plant
4.
PeptidePhysical Optimal Paul W.
and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies: and Chemical Characterization for Function Bohn
1
65 99
163
vii
viii
5.
6.
7.
Contents
Surface Plasmon Resonance Spectroscopy: Applications in Protein Adsorption and Electrochemistry Shaopeng Wang, Salah Boussaad, and Nongjian J. Tao
213
Characterization of Biomolecular Interfaces with Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy: From Model Monolayers to Tissues and Cells Anna L. Barker, Catherine E. Gardner, Julie V. Macpherson, Patrick R. Unwin, and Jie Zhang
253
Layered Protein Films: Quartz Crystal Resonator Frequency and Admittance Analysis Ernesto J. Calvo, Claudia Danilowicz, Erica Forzani, Alejandro Wolosiuk, and Marcelo Otero
337
8.
Nano-Sized Thin Films for Enzyme Reactors Katsuhiko Ariga, Yoshihiro Sasaki, and Jun-ichi Kikuchi
381
9.
Biomimetic Nanoparticle Synthesis Janos H. Fendler
427
10.
Biosensors Anthony J. Killard and Malcolm R. Smyth
451
11.
Modified Electrodes for the Oxidation of NADH Evelyne Simon and Philip N. Bartlett
499
12.
DNA-Based Sensors Michael J. Tarlov and Adam B. Steel
545
Index
609
Contributors
Katsuhiko Ariga, Ph.D. ERATO Nanospace Project, Japan Science and Technology Corporation (JST), Tokyo, Japan Anna L. Barker, M.Chem., Ph.D. Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom Philip N. Bartlett, Ph.D. Department of Chemistry, University of Southampton, Southampton, United Kingdom Paul W. Bohn, Ph.D. Department of Chemistry and Beckman Institute for Advanced Science and Technology, University of Illinois at UrbanaChampaign, Urbana, Illinois, U.S.A. Salah Boussaad Department of Electrical Engineering, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, U.S.A. Ernesto J. Calvo, Ph.D. INQUIMAE (Department of Inorganic, Analytical and Physical Chemistry), University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina
ix
!" !" ! " # $ % &" '#'' * + <* '#'' !" !" = +* > # '#'' ! "# % " # # " # $ #$ ? $ " $% & & @' % + # # "&
"& ' " " X " # $ % &" '#'' ( ) ' = +* > ! " # $ % &" '#''
Z [ & " '#'' Z # ! & '#''
" *# # '#'' + !" !" !
! " # $ % &" '#'' $ / ! " # $ % &" '#'' 1 " # " '#'' 5 '# % " # # " # $ #$ ? ( 6 ' ! " # \ $ % &" '#'' ; ' #" #" > 1 ' ' '%<=& 66 1' # # "& "& $ ' " %] ' % \ &" '#'' * > ^ # $ ^ '#'' ; " # $ @ & " # $ % &" '#''
Z $ !* " " $ '#''
xii
Contributors
Patrick R. Unwin, B.Sc., M.A., D.Phil. Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom Shaopeng Wang Department of Electrical Engineering, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, U.S.A. Alejandro Wolosiuk INQUIMAE (Department of Inorganic, Analytical and Physical Chemistry), University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina John T. Woodward, Ph.D. Biotechnology Division, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland, U.S.A. Jie Zhang, B.Sc., Ph.D. Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom Zhe Zhang, Ph.D. Research and Development, Nature’s Sunshine Products, Spanish Fork, Utah, U.S.A.
1 Designing Functional Biomolecular Films on Electrodes James F. Rusling University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut, U.S.A.
Zhe Zhang Nature’s Sunshine Products, Spanish Fork, Utah, U.S.A.
1
INTRODUCTION
One of the major functions of highly developed biomolecular superstructures in living systems is to shuttle electrons to sites where they are required to support life processes. Nature has learned how to do this very e⁄ciently, often by designing supramolecular structures uniquely suited to the task. One example is the reaction center (RC) of the purple bacteria Rhodobacter sphaeroides, an integral membrane protein complex comprised of three protein subunits with multiple bound redox cofactors that are arranged to convert light into a transmembrane electrical potential [13]. This takes place via multiple electron transfers to drive photosynthesis and provide us with food and oxygen. Other examples include the membranebound liver cytochrome P450 (cyt P450) enzymes. One or more reductase enzymes bind to cyt P450s on membrane surfaces to deliver electrons from NAD(P)H for oxidative metabolism of lipophilic pollutans and drugs [4,5]. These examples illustrate the integral use of membranes by living systems for organizing supramolecular structures [6] that are utilized in electron transfer events. Such systems can be used to guide the design of ¢lms for arti¢cial
1
2
Rusling and Zhang
devices aimed at biomedical sensing as well as bioreactors for catalytic chemical synthesis. The combination of electrochemistry with ¢lms containing redox proteins and enzymes can facilitate driving biological electron transfer events with an electronic source or sink of electrons, by using a potentiostat to control the applied voltage. Indeed, direct exchange of electrons between native redox enzymes and electrodes has been a long-standing research goal [7]. Designing ¢lms that facilitate direct electron transfer is a maor focus of this chapter. Such ¢lms enable electrochemical studies of the redox chemistry of enzymes, may allow electrodes to replace natural redox partners, and simplify the design of biosensors. Over the past decade, a variety of ¢lm technologies have been developed to facilitate direct electron exchange between electrodes and proteins [7]. Yet there are many important enzymes, including those used in blood glucose sensors, for which direct electron transfer has not been achieved or is too slow. In such cases, small molecule or polymer mediators are used to deliver electrons between electrodes and enzymes [8]. This approach is of great practical importance, and will be treated in Chapter 10. The present chapter deals mainly with ¢lms that facilitate direct protein electron transfer without mediation. Genes are supramolecular aggregates of DNA and proteins. Hybridization of single strands of DNA with oligonucleotides of known sequences promises great utility in diagnosing genetic diseases [911], and is covered in Chapter 12. Applications of DNA ¢lms to damage analysis will be addressed in the present chapter. Electrochemical detection of damage using DNA ¢lms on electrodes could eventually be used as an in vitro measure of chemical toxicity, providing rapid toxicity screens for new chemicals [13]. Thus, this chapter highlights modern options for constructing biomolecular ¢lms for electrochemical biosensor and bioreactor development as well as for fundamental studies. It is not meant as a comprehensive review of biomolecular ¢lm electrochemistry, and so we have exercised our judgement in choosing methods and examples from the literature. We apologize in advance for the many ¢ne papers we have not been able to cite herein. To summarize what follows, the next section in this chapter presents capsule histories of protein and DNA electrochemistry, highlighting seminal discoveries that form the basis of modern progress in biomolecular ¢lm electrochemistry. Section 3 provides a brief overview of the various types of ¢lm methodologies available. Section 4 discusses the fundamentals of thin-¢lm voltammetry. Sections 58 describe various approaches to ¢lm construction using materials such as polyions, lipids, surfactants, and metal oxide nanoparticles. Section 9 describes progress in electrochemical DNA damage
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
3
detection based on DNA ¢lms. Finally, in Sec.10 we attempt to predict future research directions for this area.
2 2.1
RECENT HISTORY OF BIOMOLECULE FILM ELECTROCHEMISTRY Proteins
Construction of protein ¢lms featuring direct electron transfer for electrochemical studies, biosensors, and bioreactors is a relatively recent development. Voltammetry of proteins prior to the mid-1970s was a di⁄cult endeavor, usually attempted with dissolved species, and often plagued by adsorption and denaturation of biomacromolecules on electrode surfaces [14,15] and irreversible electrode reactions. Beginning in the late 1970s, landmark papers began to appear suggesting that control of electrode surface chemistry and protein purity was the key to obtaining reversible protein electrochemistry. Yeh and Kuwana found chemically reversible (i.e., quasireversible) cyclic voltammetry for horse cytochrome c (cyt c) on tin-doped indium oxide electrodes [16]. Eddowes and Hill reported chemically reversible voltammetry on gold coated with a monolayer of 4,40 -bipyridyl [17]. Hawkridge found that cyt c puri¢ed immediately before experiment gave quasi-reversible cyclic voltammograms on several types of electrodes [18,19]. Armstrong, Hill, and Oliver used edge-plane pyrolytic graphite electrodes containing a high population of carboxylate groups to obtain quasi-reversible cyclic voltammograms for cyt c [20]. During this period, researchers had yet to achieve direct electron transfer between electrodes and native proteins in stable surface ¢lms. Concurrent work on electrochemical biosensors in the 1970s and 1980s was aimed at immobilizing enzymes on electrodes in polymeric and other sorts of ¢lms [2124]. Amperometric biosensors were being developed with mediators to deliver electrons between electrodes and enzymes.While direct electron transfer was not a general feature, this research demonstrated that enzymes could be immobilized in ¢lms and retain high catalytic activity. Protein ¢lm voltammetry really got its start in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Key progress in this period involved the demonstration by Yokota et al. of direct, reversible voltammetry for cyt c on a phosphatidylcholine Langmuir-Blodgett ¢lm transferred onto an indium tin oxide (ITO) electrode [25]. Salamon and Tollin used adsorbed phosphatidylcholine ¢lms to reduce cyt c quasi-reversibly [26,27]. Armstrong’s ¢lm voltammetry, co-adsorbing proteins with aminocyclitols and polymixins to give monolayers with highly reversible voltammetry on edge-plane pyrolytic graphite electrodes, began in this period [28]. Bowden showed that
4
Rusling and Zhang
self-assembled monolayers of alkylthiolcarboxylates on gold electrodes adsorb monolayers of positively charged cyt c and give reversible electrochemistry [29]. These research e¡orts represent the beginnings of direct thin ¢lm voltammetry techniques for proteins, which we feel have evolved into methods of choice for fundamental electrochemical studies of protein redox chemistry. The various ¢lm approaches that have been developed are described in the later sections of this chapter. 2.2
Nucleic Acids
Biosensors made with nucleic acids immobilized on electrodes constitute a very active modern research area, as illustrated by recent reviews [912] and selected examples [3033]. The intrinsic electroactivity of DNA bases, for example, the oxidation of guanine and adenine on polynucleotide chains, provides one basis for electroanalysis. Sections on DNA in this chapter focus on ¢lms for the analysis of DNA damage. DNA hybridiation biosensors are treated in Chapter 12. Damage to DNA by chemicals and their metabolites is a major toxicity pathway (3437). Cytochrome P450 enzymes in mammalian liver catalyze the oxidation of lipophilic pollutants and drugs [4,5] to metabolites which can often react with and damage DNA, frequently forming covalent adducts with guanine and adenine bases. Electrochemical methods based on DNA ¢lms are being explored to detect chemical DNA damage from these metabolites as a basis for in-vitro toxicity screening of new chemicals. Prior to the 1990s, electrochemical analysis of DNA most often employed adsorption of the nucleic acids from solutions onto mercury electrodes [38]. Single-stranded (ss) DNA was found to be much more readily oxidized at guanine and adenine base sites than double-stranded (ds)DNA [39]. The ds-DNA structure does not allow ready access of the bases to the electrode, but unwinding of the double helix provides better access and faster reaction rates. Adsorptive voltammetry on mercury electrodes has been applied to detecting DNA damage from strong acid [40], methylating agents [41], and hydroxyl radicals [42,43]. Damage to DNA from ionizing radiation was detected with mercury electrodes by adsorptive linear sweep [44] and AC voltammetry [45]. In these methods, the DNA is present in solution and accumulated on the electrodes by adsorption prior to analysis. Mercury drop electrodes are probably unsuitable choices for widespread DNA damage or toxicity screening because of the safety issues in handling this toxic liquid. However, guanine and adenine bases in nucleic acids are readily oxidized on solid electrodes [46]. Sections below deal with immobilization of DNA ¢lms on solid electrodes, and the use of these ¢lms for voltammetric detection of DNA damage directly in the ¢lm.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
3
5
SUMMARY OF MODERN APPROACHES TO FILM DESIGN
Sections 58 discuss various modern strategies for making biomolecular ¢lms on electrodes. Table 1 summarizes major examples of these techniques, including conceptual drawings and advantages and disadvantages of each approach. 4 4.1
FUNDAMENTALS OF THIN-FILM ELECTROCHEMISTRY Cyclic Voltammetry
Voltammetric methods provide important modern techniques for analyzing electroactive ¢lms on electrode surfaces, as well as for analytical applications. The most popular method for studies of ¢lm electrochemistry is cyclic voltammetry (CV). The electrochemical cell typically includes a working electrode, coated for example with a protein ¢lm, a reference electrode, and a counter electrode (Fig. 1). Under control of the potentiostat, which is in turn under control of the experimenter, the potential (E in volts,V) applied to the cell is ¢rst scanned in a forward direction, stopped at a desired potential, then scanned in a reverse direction,usually returning to its initial value at the end of the experiment.The potential range of the voltammogram is chosen to encompass the reduction and oxidation potentials of the electroactive species in the ¢lm, and the data are output in a graph of current (I) versus potential (E). A peak in the I versus E output denotes a £ow of electrons between the protein in the ¢lm and the underlying electrode, leading to a change in the oxidation state of the protein’s electroactive site.The scan rate n ¼ DE=Dt can be varied from a few tenths of a millivolt per second to a million or more volts per second, providing a wide time-scale range for the investigation of kinetic events in electrode processes. A reversible electrochemical reaction such as O þ ne ¼ R
ð1Þ
is one in which the conversion of oxidation (O) to reductant (R) and of R back to O are both fast on the time scale of the voltammogram, as controlled by the scan rate. A feeling for these time scales can be obtained from the time required for a scan of 1 V, which is the inverse of the scan rate. Thus, a scan rate of 0.1 V=s occurs on the scale of 10 s,while 1000 V=s re£ects a time scale of ca. 1 ms. The ideal, reversible voltammogram from a monolayer of electroactive protein about 510 nm thick on an electrode following Eq. (1) (Fig. 2) features symmetric oxidation and reduction peaks of equal heights with both peak potentials at the formal potential ðE 00 Þ of the surface redox reaction [47,48]. The theoretical separation between oxidation and reduction peaks
6
Rusling and Zhang
TABLE 1 Thumbnail Sketches of Some Types of Biomolecule Films Advantages: Simplicity, only tiny amounts of protein and perhaps coadsorbate needed. Rapid, reversible electron transfer. Excellent for fundamental studies of proteins. Adsorbed protein films on edgeplane pyrolytic graphite (Section 5.1)
Disadvantages: Often lack longterm stability, CVs require accurate background subtraction. Advantages: SAMs easily formed, tiny amount of protein adsorbed from solution. Nearly reversible electron transfer. Excellent for fundamental studies of proteins. Can be applied to thiolated oligonucleotides.
Protein adsorbed on alkythiol-R SAM on Au, where R is opposite charge of protein (Chapter 2)
Disadvantages: May lack long-term stability for enzyme biosensors.
Advantages: Simply mix components and cast. Nearly reversible electron transfer for redox proteins.
Cast films of polyions-protein or DNA-protein on electrode (Section 6.1)
Disadvantages: Low fraction of electroactive protein, sometimes ‘‘leaks’’ proteins.
Advantages: Ease of preparation, nearly reversible electron transfer for redox proteins.
BLM on cleaved metal wire (Section 7.1).
Disadvantages: Proteins in solution may not enter BLM, low singal to background ratio. Limited stability.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
7
Advantages: Simply mix components and cast. Nearly reversible electron transfer for redox proteins in ordered mutibilayer films, stable for a month in quiet solutions. Excellent for fundamental studies of proteins.
Cast films of proteins and lipids or surfactants (Section 7.2)
Disadvantages: Slowly removed in hydrodynamic solutions (days).
Advantages: Nearly reversible electron transfer for redox proteins in ordered multibilayer films, improved stability over simple surfactant films.
Disadvantages: Must prepare polyion-surfactant complex before casting. Composite polyion-surfactantprotein films (Section 7.2) Advantages: Nearly reversible electron transfer for redox proteins, nm control of thickness, extended order, versatile architecture, good stability in hydrodynamic fluids. Disadvantages: Many layers require long prep. time ( 20 min=layer). Mass transport limitations for catalysis with thicker films. Polyion-protein films grown layerby-layer (Section 8) Advantages: Vectorial electron transfer chains, versatile architecture, good stability. Disadvantages: Multi-step synthesis; may require synthesis of linkers. Covalent bonding to gold (Section 4.2)
8
FIG. 1
Rusling and Zhang
Experimental setup for thin-film cyclic voltammetry.
ðDEp Þ is zero, and the peak width at half peak height is 90.6=n mV at 25 C. The integral under each peak is the charge Q, in coulombs, given by a form of Faraday’s law: ð2Þ Q ¼ nFAGT where GT is the total surface concentration of electroactive protein (mol=cm2), A is electrode area ðcm2 Þ, F is Faraday’s constant (96, 487 C=mol e’s), and n is the numer of electrons transferred in the electrochemical reaction. Thus, measurement of Q by CV provides a direct determination of the amount of electroactive protein in the ¢lm. The formal potential E 00 of the ¢lm redox process is simply the peak potential, or in practice the midpoint potential between the two peaks if there is a small separation between the reduction and oxidation peaks. Figure 2 also illustrates the graphic convention for voltammograms used in this chapter. This is the ‘‘American convention,’’ with reduction peaks positive on the y axis, and more negative potential presented to the right on the x axis. The IUPAC convention used extensively in Europe and
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
9
FIG. 2 Ideal thin-film cyclic voltammogram of a monolayer of protein on an electrode.
elsewhere has oxidation peaks positive on the y axis, and more positive potential going to the right on the x axis. The ideal, reversible peak current ðIp Þ is n2 F 2 AGT n ð3Þ 4RT where R is the gas constant and T is temperature in Kelvin, showing that Ip increases linearly as scan rate ðnÞ is increased. Equations (2) and (3) are similar to those in thin-layer electrochemistry, in which the electrochemical cell con¢nes a thin layer of solution containing the dissolved electroactive species next to the electrode [49]. Speci¢c interactions between the redox sites are ignored. Thus, this ideal case of ¢lm voltammetry is often called the ‘‘ideal thin-layer electrochemistry’’ model. Additional materials, such as polymers, surfactants, or other coadsorbed molecules are often used to immobilize proteins on electrodes.The e⁄ciency of protein redox conversion then depends on (1) the thermodynamics of redox chemistry in the ¢lm controlled by E 00 ; (2) the kinetics of electron transfer at the ¢lmelectrode interface; (3) the rate of charge transport within the ¢lm, which may depend on counterion entry and exit rates, and electron self-exchange between redox sites [48]; and (4) structural transformations coupled to electron transfer, such as conformational changes. Ip ¼
10
Rusling and Zhang
Films thicker than a monolayer of electroactive protein are often employed to obtain a larger enzyme loading per unit electrode area and consequently larger peak currents. When complete electrolytic conversion throughout these ¢lms is achieved on the CV time scale, the thin-layer electrochemistry model may describe the CVs approximately. Charge transport through these thicker ¢lms may involve physical di¡usion of the proteins through the ¢lm, and=or ‘‘electron hopping’’ between redox centers, utilizing electron self-exchange reactions [50]. Ion exchange with solution and counterion transport within ¢lms is required to provide overall charge balance during redox reactions, and the kinetics of these processes may be important factors in determining the e⁄ciency of charge transport. It is a rare protein ¢lm system that exhibits all the ideal CV characteristics. Shapes of cyclic voltammograms of protein ¢lms are often very different [7,47,48] from ideal thin-layer model predictions (Fig. 2). For example, a nonideal reversible CV for the heme Fe III=FeII redox couple of the KatG catalase-proxidase enzyme from Mycobacterium tuberculosis in a thin ¢lm (ca. 0.5 mm) [51] (Fig. 3) of the lipid dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) shows roughly symmetrical peaks with a ¢nite peak separation of about 55 mV, much grater than the predicted value of zero. In such cases, E 00 is taken as the midpoint potential between the two peaks. These protein ¢lms gave linear plots of Ip versus n in the low scan rate range ð< 1 V=sÞ in accord with Eq. (3). The width of the peaks at half-height is nearly 200 mV, much larger than the predicted ideal value of 90=n mV. Even though background has been partly subtracted in Fig. 3, there remains signi¢cant background current on either side of the peaks. This current results from charging the electrical double layer with possible contributions from surface processes on the electrode surface [49]. This experimental CV is typical of thin-¢lm CVs of redox proteins, although speci¢c details will certainly di¡er and depend on protein and ¢lm properties [7]. Broadening or narrowing of CVpeaks with respect to the ideal 90=n mV width for surface-bound species suggests a breakdown of the model assumptions of no interactions between redox sites in the ¢lm that all have the same E 00. Protein ¢lms are often ‘‘diluted’’ with electrochemicaly inert materials, proteins are on average relatively far apart, and interprotein interactions may be minimized. Consequently, peak widths are usually larger, rather than smaller, than the theoretical 90=n mV. Voltammograms of protein ¢lms have been modeled utilizing the concept of distributions in E 00 and electron-transfer rate constants to account for the peak broadening [5254]. Other factors, including counterion transport e⁄ciency, could also in£uence peak widths, but have not been investigated in detail for protein ¢lms.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
11
FIG. 3 Cyclic voltammogram (CV) at 100 mV=s and 25 C of Mycobacterium tuberculosis KatG catalase-peroxidase in a thin dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine film on basal-plane PG electrode, in anaerobic pH 6.0 buffer. Background has been partially substracted. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 51. Copyright 2001, Royal Society of Chemistry.)
An increasing DEp as the scan rate is increased for an electroactive thin ¢lm suggests kinetic limitations of the electrochemistry [47]. Possible causes include (1) slow electron transfer between the electrode and the protein redox sites, (2) slow transport of charge within the ¢lm limited by electron or counterion transport, (3) uncompensated voltage drop within the ¢lm, and (4) structural reorganization of the ¢lm or protein accompanying the redox reactions. These processes have been investigated in depth for electrodes coated with nonprotein redox polymers [48,50], but much less is known on this topic concerning protein ¢lms. The shapes of CVs will di¡er from the ideal thin-layer case when only partial electrolysis of the electroactive redox sites in the ¢lms occurs during a given linear branch of the scan. This occurs for thicker ¢lms at scan rates high enough to provide insu⁄cient time for complete electrolysis. In this case, only a fraction of the redox sites are electrolyzed during each linear scan, setting up concentraton gradients within the ¢lms. In the limit where only a small fraction of redox sites are electrolyzed, the peak shape is identical to that of a CV on an uncoated electrode for an ion or molecule in
12
Rusling and Zhang
solution under semi-in¢nite linear di¡usion conditions [49]. The resulting asymmetric shape is very di¡erent from that of the ideal CV for a monomolecular ¢lm, and DEp for a reversible di¡usion-controlled system at 25 C is predicted to be 59=n mV.When ¢lms show such‘‘di¡usion controlled’’ CVs, the integral under the peak is no longer proportional to the surface concentration of electroactive centers in the ¢lm, since only a fraction of the protein has been electrolyzed. A typical di¡usion-controlled protein ¢lm CV shape for the heme FeIII=FeII redox couple of myoglobin for a 40-mm-thick ¢lm of DNA (Fig. 4) shows an unsymmetric peak shape, and oxidation and reduction peaks of equal height. However, DEp is only about 40 mV, less than the predicted 59-mV value. The peak current for limiting di¡usion control for an n-electron reaction in a ¢lm is 1=2
Ip ¼ ð2:69 105 Þn3=2 ADct n1=2 Cf
ð4Þ
where the concentration of electroactive species Cf ¼ GT =d, d is ¢lm thickness, and Dct is the charge transport di¡usion coe⁄cient [47]. Equation (4) predicts a linear plot of Ip versus n1=2. This behavior is usually favored by
FIG. 4 Diffusion-controlled CV at 0.1 V=s for 40-mm-thick Mb-DNA film on a PG electrode in pH 5.5 buffer at 35 C. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 56. Copyright 1996, American Chemical Society.)
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
13
higher scan rates and thicker ¢lms. The movement of charge (electrons and counterions) through the ¢lm is characterized by Dct, which can be obtained from the slope of the linear Ip versus n1=2 plot. The slope of this plot is 1=2 1=2 ð2:69 105 Þn3=2 ADct Cf , and Dct can be estimated when all other parameters are known. Other transient electrochemical techniques can also be employed to estimate Dct [55]. Analysis of linear Ip versus n1=2 plots for the DNAMb ¢lm [56] in bu¡er gave Dct ¼ 1:2 107 cm2 =s. This value may re£ect physical di¡usion of the protein in the ¢lm, or ‘‘electron hopping’’ by electron self-exchange reactions between Mb redox sites in the ¢lm [50]. When a protein in solution can be taken up by a protein-free ¢lm, a breakthrough experiment can be done to give information about physical di¡usion of the protein in the ¢lm. A relatively thick protein-free ¢lm is placed into a protein solution, and the time of ¢rst appearance of the voltammetric peak is measured. The Einstein equation for molecular displacement D at time t is [49] D2 ¼ 2Dt
ð5Þ
where D is ¢lm thickness, and D is the protein di¡usion coe⁄cient in the ¢lm. Using Eq. (5) with the Dct found from voltammetry predicted a breakthrough time of 9 s for a 15-mm adsorbed DNA ¢lm. The measured value was 10 ms, suggesting that Mb di¡uses physically through the DNA ¢lms. Standard electrochemical rate constants can also be used to characterize electroactive ¢lms. They are denoted ks ðs1 Þ when determined under thin-¢lm conditions or k 00 (cm/s) when estimated under di¡usioncontrolled conditions. Electrochemical rate constants depend on applied potential, and ks and k 00 are de¢ned as the apparent values of the standard electrochemical rate constants at E ¼ E 00 . Also, k 00 dks , where d is ¢lm thickness in centimeters. Methods to determine ks and k 00 in polymer ¢lms [55] involve measurements on time scales short enough to observe kinetic limitations in transient electrochemical signals. As mentioned, peak widths of thin protein ¢lms under nonideal thinlayer conditions often exceed the theoretical 90=n mV, a consequence of the failure of the ideal model. In such cases, employment of simple thin-layer models to obtain ks from CV data can lead to considerable bias. However, models invoking a dispersion of E 00 and=or rate constant values can be used to obtain an average ks [5254].We feel that ks for proteins in ¢lms of ¢nite thickness are best interpreted as measures of the relative e⁄ciency of the electrochemical performance of the ¢lm. Clearly, ks may contain contributions from factors which may in£uence electrochemical reversibility other than electron transfer at the electrode¢lm interface. Kinetics of electron
14
Rusling and Zhang
transfer at interfaces between electroactive polymer ¢lms and electrodes are usually not rate-limiting [50]. 4.2
Square-Wave Voltammetry
The family of pulsed voltammetric methods can provide large improvements of resolution, sensitivity and signal=noise over CV. Square-wave voltammetry (SWV) is one of the most sensitive and rapid of these techniques. It gives peak-shaped currentpotential curves and sensitivities several orders of magnitude better than CV. In SWV, the input potential wavefrom consists of symmetric forward and backward square potential pulses superimposed on a potentialtime staircase [57]. Pulse frequencies range from about 1 Hz to several thousands of hertz, and control the experimental time window. Current is sampled at the end of the each forward and backward pulse, and plotted as forward, reverse, and di¡erence current versus step potential. Di¡erence square-wave voltammograms typically lead to symmetric peaks resulting from real-time subtraction of currents measured at the end of each forward and reverse pulse. An example of a reversible square-wave voltammogram is shown for a thin ¢lm of the electroactive polymer bis-bipyridylruthenium(II)-poly (vinylpyridine) [Ru(bpy)2 -PVP]2þ (Fig. 5), depicting the forward, reverse, and di¡erence current curves [58]. Typically, the forwardreverse traces are analogous to CV and valuable for diagnostic purposes, while the di¡erence current is more useful for analytical applications. For thin electroactive ¢lms, the SWV di¡erence peak current is directly proportional to the frequency. However, the integral under this curve has no direct relation to electroactive surface concentration GT , and this quantity is best determined by CV [cf. Eq. (2)]. A model for SWV of thin protein ¢lms has been developed invoking a dispersion of E 00 to explain peak broadness [53,54]. The method employs nonlinear regression analysis to ¢t the model simultaneously to forward and reverse SWV curves. The model combines E 00 dispersion with the SWV model for a single surface-bound electroactive species [59]. The SWV current (I) is p X Ij ð6Þ I¼ j¼1
where Ij is the contribution of the jth of p classes of redox centers with formal potentials Ej00 to the total current, given by Cj ð7Þ Ij ¼ ðnFAGj Þ tp
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
15
FIG. 5 Square-wave voltammogram showing forward, reverse, and difference current curves at 5 Hz of ½RuðbpyÞ2þ 2 PVP film on PG electrode in 20 mM acetate buffer, pH 5.5. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 58. Copyright 2001 Elsevier.)
where n is the number of electrons transferred per redox center, F is Faraday’s constant, A is electrode area ðcm2 Þ; Gj is the total surface concentration (mol=cm2) of the jth class, tp is the pulse width, and Cj is the dimensionless current: h i Cj ¼ ðkf ; j þ kb; j ÞG0o;j kb; j exp ðkf ; j þ kb; j Þ
ð8Þ
and G00o; j ¼
Cj þ kb; j ðkf ; j þ kb; j Þ
ð9Þ
where G0o;j is the jth surface concentration ratio Go;j =Gj at time t ¼ 0; G00o;j is the ratio Go;j =Gj at time t ¼ tp ; kf ;j ¼ kf ;j tp and kb;j ¼ kb;j tp . Forward and reverse electron-transfer rate constants kf and kb , respectively, are de¢ned as in the Butler-Volmer theory [49]:
16
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 6 Square-wave voltammograms (4-mV step, 75-mV pulse) showing forward and reverse currents for cyt P450cam-DMPC films in pH 7.0 buffer. Points represent background-subtracted experimental data, solid lines are the best fits by 0 nonlinear regression onto the E 0 -dispersion thin-layer model described in the text. Average parameter values obtained from the regression analysis are 0 E 0 ¼ 121 2 mV versus NHE;ks ¼ 25 5 s1 ; and a ¼ 0:53 0:03. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 60. Copyright 1997 Royal Society of Chemistry.)
nF 0 kf ;j ¼ ks tp exp a ðE Ej0 Þ RT and kb;j
nF 00 ¼ ks tp exp ð1 aÞ ðE Ej Þ RT
ð10Þ
ð11Þ
where ks is the apparent standard surface rate constant ðs1 Þ; a is the electrochemical transfer coe⁄cient, E is applied potential, R is the gas constant, and T is temperature in kelvin. Parameters used in the ¢tting are the average 0 ks , average a, the pEj0 values, and the pGj values. Use of this model to ¢t SWV data at several frequencies for the FeIII=FeII redox couple of cytochrome P450cam in lipid ¢lms [60] is depicted in Fig. 6.The goodness of ¢t is illustrated by the good agreement between 0 experimental and computed data. The average E 0 is within 8 mV of the CV midpoint potential, and good parameter reproducibility is illustrated by the
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
17
standard deviations. This method has been successfully applied to SWV of thin ¢lms of various polyions and lipids containing a number of di¡erent metalloproteins [7]. The distribution that falls out of these analyses is typically Gaussian. Note that the average ks is an apparent rate constant. The model neglects rate-limiting counterion entry or ejection, electron self-exchange, and molecular interactions, and assumes thin-layer SWV conditions. Thus, ks obtained by this method can be interpreted as a relative measure of the rate of the overall electron transfer process dependent on ¢lm and electrode properties. It is suitable for between-¢lm comparisons, but it is not an absolute electron transfer rate constant. 4.3
Marcus Electron Transfer Theory
Historically, theoretical descriptions of voltammetry have relied on ButlerVolmer electron transfer theory [49]. Butler-Volmer kinetics predict that the rate constants for heterogeneous electron exchange between a redox site and an electrode increase exponentially with increasing positive applied potential for oxidations and negative applied potential for reductions. This agrees with experiment at potentials near the formal potential, but predicts an in¢nite rate constant at extreme potentials, which is unrealistic. The Marcus theory of electron transfer correctly predicts the increase in the electrontransfer rate constant with increasing applied potential, with eventual attainment of an upper limit [61]. According to Marcus theory, the rate constant ks for outer-sphere electron transfer depends on activation free energy DG : DG ks ¼ kA exp ð12Þ RT where k is the electronic transmission coe⁄cient, A is collision frequency, R is the gas constant, and T is temperature in kelvin [61]. DG is related to the standard free energy DG0 and the reorganization energy l for the electron transfer: ðDG 0 þ lÞ2 4l The potential dependence of ks arises from the relation DG ¼
DG 0 nF Z
ð13Þ
ð14Þ 0
where the overpotential Z ¼ ðE E 0 Þ and E is the applied potential. From Eqs. (12) to (14), we can show that Marcus theory correctly predicts a sigmoidal increase in ks with increasing Z, with a plateau limiting value at high Z.Voltammetric models based on Butler-Volmer kinetics in thin
18
Rusling and Zhang
¢lms, while useful for comparisons between systems, may lead to biased estimates of kinetics at high Z [28]. Several research groups have applied Marcus kinetics to ¢lms of redox proteins. Bowden and co-workers used electrochemical methods to estimate a lower limit value of l of 0.28 eV for cyt c bound to carboxylalkythiol SAMs on Au electrodes [62]. This model was extended to include Gaussian distributions of all parameters and applied to SWVof myoglobin in thin ¢lms of didodecyldimethylammonium bromide on pyrolytic graphite electrodes [63]. Nonlinear regression analysis of SWV allowed direct estimation of electron-transfer rate constants and reorganization energies. Relatively large pulse heights, e.g., 100200 mV, were needed to extract reliably selfconsistent values of reorganization energies. An example of a ¢t is shown in Fig. 7. The mean values of reorganization energies for reduced and oxidized forms of Mb, respectively, found by this method were lRED ¼ 0:41 eV and lOX ¼ 0:21 eV.
FIG. 7 Experimental current (s)with model background current subtracted resulting from regression analysis of SWV data at 200-Hz frequency, 160-mV pulse height shown with the best-fit line from the Marcus model. The Marcus model was fitted to raw SWV data including background, and the model background was then subtracted. Average parameter values from the analysis of 22 voltammograms were standard rate constants log (knullRED,s1) ¼ 3.3 0.8, log(KnullOX,s1) of 3.0 0.6, reorganization energy lRED ¼ 0.41 0.02 eV, and lOX ¼ 0.21 0.01 eV. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 63. Copyright 2001, American Chemical Society.)
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
19
SCHEME 1 Electron-hopping charge transport in a redox protein film.
Marcus theory also relates kinetics to the distance of electron transfer. The relation between ks and distance, d, of electron transfer from the electrode surface to a ¢xed redox site relative to rate constant k0 at the distance of closest contact d0 is [61] ks ¼ k0 exp½bðd d0 Þ b is typically in the range 8.511.5 nm1, indicating a rapid decrease of ks with distance. This means that the farther a protein redox site is from the electrode, the slower is its rate of direct electron exchange with the electrode. However, ¢xed redox sites su⁄ciently far away from the electrode may participate in electron self-exchange by ‘‘electron hopping’’ involving neighboring sites. For example, a multiplayer ¢lm containing iron heme proteins in the PFeIII form at ¢xed sites could propagate charge from electrode-¢lm to solution-¢lm interfaces as shown in Scheme 1. 4.4
Enzyme Catalysis on Electrodes
Designers of catalysts have long been envious of enzymes with high selectivities and speci¢cities.We now possess the methodology to drive catalytic chemical reactions by redox conversion of enzymes (or proteins) on electrodes. Since many of the di¡erent types of ¢lms described in this chapter can support similar enzyme-like reactions [7],we provide here only a general summary of reactions that can be done in this way. Films on electrodes featuring direct electron transfer provide the means to do enzyme chemistry under the driving force of the applied electrical potential (Fig. 8). The process is similar to electrochemical catalysis using nonbiological redox centers, a simple example of which is shown in Scheme 2. Here, redox catalyst P in a ¢lm is reversibly reduced by the electrode to the activated catalyst Q, which reduces the reactant A to product B [49,64]. Typically, A is directly (noncatalytically) reduced irreversibly at an electrode 0 potential more negative than the E 0 of the P/Q catalyst couple. In the absence of A, the P/Q coupled in the ¢lm gives a reversible voltammogram,
20
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 8 Conceptual illustration of electrochemical catalysis with an enzyme film on an electrode.
SCHEME 2
Simple pathway for electrochemical catalysis.
such as in Fig. 3. Addition of the reactant A to the solution allows reaction between Q and A, changing the shape of the voltammogram. If the reaction of Q þ A is fast enough with respect to scan rate in CV, the reduction current for P increases and the oxidation current for Q vanishes. This is because Q reacts with A, producing P, which continues the catalytic cycle. An analogous scheme pertains for catalytic electrochemical oxidations. While the general concept of Scheme 2 holds, most enzyme or proteincatalyzed catalytic reactions on electrodes are more complex. They usually involve more than one electron, and may feature an enzymesubstrate complex. An example of a two-electron protein-catalyzed reduction is the dechlorination of trichloroacetic acid by iron heme protein in thin ¢lms [65]. The pathway involves sequential two-electron reductions of C ^ Cl bonds. Films of Mb and the lipid DMPC are used to illustrate CV behavior for the catalytic reactions. In the absence of reactant trichloroacetic acid (TCA), a reversible thin-¢lm CV is found for the heme FeIII /FeII couple of myoglobin
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
21
FIG. 9 Voltammograms showing effect of catalytic reduction of trichloroacetic acid (TCA) by Mb in DMPC films at 0.1 V=s and pH 5.5. Numbers on curves show millimolar TCA concentration in the buffer; dashed curve to the far right for TCA on a DMPC-coated electrode without Mb. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 53. Copyright 1997, Elsevier.)
(Fig. 9). Additons of TCA cause increases in the FeIII reduction peak with increasing concentration and decreases in the FeII oxidation peak. The general reaction is given in Scheme 3. At higher concentrations of TCA, the MbFeII oxidation peak disappears because it is completely used up in the second step of Scheme 3. Direct, uncatalyzed reduction of TCA on a DMPC-coated electrode begins to show a current at 1 V, whereas the catalytic reduction occurs at about 0.3 V (Fig. 6). This positive shift of 0.7 V in the reduction potential re£ects the decrease in activation free energy for the catalytic reduction.The increase in current with concentration of reactant is a general feature of electrochemical catalysis, and is the basis of applications to biosensors.
SCHEME 3 Electrochemical catalytic reduction of TCA with Mb.
22
Rusling and Zhang
Rotating-disk electrode voltammetry (RDV) employs an electrode which rotates at ¢xed speed to control mass transport to and from the electrode. In the absence of reactive substrate in solution, rotating the electrode has no e¡ect on the shape of a reversible thin protein ¢lm voltammogram because the electrochemistry is insensitive to mass transport external to the ¢lm. Addition of substrate to the solution provides catalytic steady-state voltammograms by RDV. The currentpotential curve now assumes a sigmoid shape (Fig. 10) with a steady-state plateau current. The Michaelis-Menton formulation of enzyme kinetics postulates an enzymesubstrate (reactant) complex with dissociation constant KM and turnover rate constant kcat for the conversion of this enzymesubstrate complex to product. If the electrochemistry of the enzyme in the ¢lm is reversible and mass transport of substrate in the solution is optimized using RDV, the steady-state catalytic current Icat is given approximately by a version of the Michaelis-Menton equation [66]: Icat ¼
nFAGkcat Cs Cs þ K M
ð16Þ
where G is the amount (or surface concentration) of enzyme in the ¢lm (mol=cm2), and Cs is the concentration of substrate. KM and kcat can be obtained by ¢tting Eq. (16) to Icat versus Cs data [67]. An important example of electrochemical catalytic oxidations employing iron heme enzymes can be achieved using oxygen. Films of myoglobin (Mb) and cyt P450cam on electrodes catalyze reduction of oxygen to hydrogen peroxide [6870]. Hydrogen peroxide then reacts with the FeIII form of the protein to yield the active oxidant. The process is thought to occur as shown in Scheme 4. Despite a more complex pathway, voltammograms for this catalytic reduction of oxygen are similar to that for reactions following Schemes1and 2. In the presence of oxygen, the reversible reduction peak for MbFeIII in ¢lms is converted to a reduction peak much larger than that in anaerobic solutions, while the FeII oxidation peak disappears (Fig. 11). The uncatalyzed reduction of oxygen occurs at 0.8 V versus SCE, but is shifted 0.55 V positive to about 0.25 V when the Mbpolyion ¢lm is used. Scheme 4 can be utilized for enzyme-like oxidative catalysis involving oxygen transfer from the active oxidant to a substrate, e.g., conversion of styrene to styrene oxide [6870]. Catalytic amperometric and voltammetric responses of peroxidase ¢lms to hydrogen peroxide are likely to be related to a pathway similar to Scheme 4 [71]. Stable ¢lms of DMPC containing M. tuberculosis catalaseperoxidase (KatG), several peroxidases, myoglobin, or catalase gave reversible FeIII=FeII voltammetry on pyrolytic graphite electrodes, and catalytic
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
23
FIG. 10 Idealized voltammograms computed from theory for a rotating disk electrode: (a) reversible thin enzyme film; (b) catalytic current for a thin enzyme film and substrate (reactant) in solution featuring a steady-state current beyond the protein reduction potential.
SCHEME 4 Pathway for electrochemical catalytic reduction of oxygen to hydrogen peroxide, leading to an oxyferryl radical that can oxidize organic substrates.
current for hydrogen peroxide and oxygen. The similarity of catalytic voltammograms and amperometric responses for these ¢lms to H 2O2 at 0 V suggests signi¢cant contributions from catalytic reduction of oxygen produced during the catalytic cycles. Oxygen is produced by catalase-like reaction of H2O2 with the oxyferryl radical PFeIV ¼ O, also giving water as a product and regenerating the PFeIII form of the enzyme. The presence of oxygen sets up the catalytic cycle in Scheme 4. Relative apparent turnover rates at pH 6 obtained from steady-state currents at 0 V versus SCE in *
24
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 11 Cyclic voltammograms at scan rate 0.3 V=s in pH 5.5 buffer illustrating protein-catalyzed reduction of oxygen: (a) reversible CV of a multilayer film on rough PG consisting of six alternating layers each of polystyrene sulfonate (PSS) and myoglobin (Mb) with no oxygen present; (b) catalytic CV of {PSS=Mb}6 film on PG after oxygen was injected into buffer; (c) PSS film without Mb after oxygen was injected into buffer, showing noncatalytic reduction of oxygen. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 182. Copyright 2000, American Chemical Society.)
response to H2O2 were in the order horseradish peroxidase > cytochrome c peroxidase > soybean peroxidase > myoglobin > KatG > catalase [71]. Lower currents for the very e⁄cient peroxide scavengers KatG and catalase may be related to the instability of their oxyferryl radicals in the presence of H2O2.
4.5
Oxidations of Nucleic Acid Bases
The most easily oxidized base in DNA is guanine, with a formal potential at pH 7 of about 1.3 V versus NHE (1.06 V versus SCE), while the other DNA bases have formal potentials up to 0.5 V more positive [72]. Detection of nucleic acid oxidation by direct electrochemistry depends on structure,with double-stranded (ds) DNA giving only minimal detectable oxidation, and single-stranded (ss) DNA giving oxidation peaks at about 1.01.2 V versus SCE on carbon. The key point seems to be access of the bases to the electrode. This access is poor in ds-DNA, but much better in ss-DNA and partly unraveled, damaged DNA. The direct electrochemical oxidations of guanines in DNA are chemically irreversible [12,38], and CV of ss-DNA ¢lms typically gives oxidation peaks with no accompanying reduction peaks.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
25
Catalytic electrochemical oxidation of DNA using transition metal complexes provides enhanced electrochemical signals [10]. Elegant work by Thorp et al. showed that Ru(bpy)2þ 3 is a very e⁄cient electrochemical catalyst that oxidizes only guanine bases in DNA and oligonucleotides [73,74]. The reaction follows the typical catalytic pathway in Scheme 5, and 3þ RuðbpyÞ2þ 3 ¼ RuðbpyÞ3 þ e 2þ þ RuðbpyÞ3þ 3 þ DNAðguanineÞ ! RuðbpyÞ3 þ DNAðguanine Þ
ð17Þ ð18Þ
SCHEME 5
DNA(guanineþ ) is subsequently further oxidized [75]. Ru(bpy)33þ is cycled back to Ru(bpy)2þ 3 by the fast chemical step in Eq. (18), which provides voltammetric current that is greatly enhanced over that of Ru(bpy)2þ 3 or DNA alone. The peak current depends on the rate of the chemical step. The same accessibility issues pertain as in direct electrochemical oxidation, i.e., guanine in ss-DNA reacts more rapidly with than ds-DNA, and the reaction rate is also sequence-dependent.
5 5.1
MONOMOLECULAR AND SUBMONOMOLECULAR PROTEIN FILMS Adsorbed Films
Fraser Armstrong and coworkers showed that polyamines such as aminocyclitols and polymixins give stable co-adsorbed ¢lms with a wide variety of ferredoxins and other redox proteins at the negative surface of edge-plane pyrolytic graphite electrodes [66]. Presumably, the stability of these ¢lms is controlled by interactions of carboxyl groups on the electrode surface and negative sites on the protein with ammonium groups on the co-adsorbate. Co-adsorption of proteins with aminocyclitols and polymixins often gives a monolayer or submonolayer of noninteracting protein molecules on edge-plane pyrolytic graphite surfaces. This provides a high concentration of electroactive centers close to the electrode, eliminates di¡usion from the voltammetry, often avoids surface denaturation, and inhibits adsorption of impurities which might otherwise block electron transfer. A key feature of these ¢lms is that electron transfer kinetics between electrode and protein are often quite fast, and for some metalloproteins reversibility persists to scan rates of 3000 V=s and higher [76]. This allows estimation of standard electron transfer rate constants up to 5000 s1, as well as studies of coupled chemical processes on the millisecond time scale. Detailed models have been presented for interpreting catalytic voltammetry of monolayer ¢lms of adsorbed electroactive enzymes [77].
26
Rusling and Zhang
Monolayer ¢lm voltammetry has been used for seminal studies of electron transfer properties, coupled chemical processes, and enzyme catalysis for a variety of proteins. For details,we refer the reader to recent reviews [66,78], and to the original literature cited therein. Some exciting examples of this work include demonstrations that transition metal ions can enter vacant subsites of iron clusters in [3Fe4S]0 ferredoxins directly in these monolayers to give [M3Fe4S]2þ clusters [79,80], mechanistic elucidation of proton-coupled electron transfer and long-range proton transfer involving ironsulfur cluster proteins [8183], and discovery of a tunnel diode e¡ect for monolayers of succinate dehydrogenase on electrodes [66,84] involving enzyme activity gated by electrode potential which controls the redox state of the enzyme.The method has been used for many kinetic, mechanistic, and H=D isotope studies of catalysis by native and mutant enzymes [66,8587]. The most recent studies of thin protein monolayers by voltammetry demonstrate increasingly sophisticated mechanistic resolving power. Examples include low-temperature protein ¢lm cryovoltammetry to resolve complex transformations in ferredoxin electron transfer [88], and elucidation of an atomically resolved long-range electron-coupled proton transfer in a buried protein redox center [89]. Catalytic electrochemical currents can sometimes be measured with enzyme-coated electrodes even when no voltammetric peaks are detected in the absence of the substrate [66,90]. Thus may suggest submonolayer coverage or partial blockage of the electrode.While lack of detection of the direct enzyme voltammetry limits kinetic analyses, catalytic responses may still ¢nd analytical or diagnostic uses. Many studies document that protein adsorption without co-adsorbates on solid metal, mercury, and carbon electrodes often results in denaturation that blocks electron transfer. However, there appear to be some interesting exceptions as summarized below. The use of antibody probes revealed three conformations of cyt c3 adsorbed on Hg that were all denatured, but the protein ¢lm remains electroactive [91]. The NiFeS enzyme hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio dusulfuricans Norway was adsorbed directly onto basal-plane pyrolytic graphite, allowing studies of its reaction with cyt c3 with a lifetime of the hydrogenase ¢lm of several hours [92]. Megasphaera elsdenii Fe hydrogenase was adsorbed from solution at submonolayer coverage onto rough glassy carbon electrodes [93]. Although no direct electron transfer peaks were found, electron transfer involving this enzyme was con¢rmed by catalytic currents for reduction of Hþ and oxidation of H2. In this case, addition of polyamine co-adsorbates did not help to form a stable ¢lm. Tao et al. adsorbed ¢lms of cyt c and myoglobin (Mb) on freshly cleaved highly ordered basal-plane pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) [94,95]. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) revealed a randomly distributed, adsorbed mono-
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
27
layer of cyt c after a few minutes, but complete formation of chainlike aggregates of adsorbed Mb on HOPG took 40 min. AFM pictures were consistent with native adsorbed protein in both cases. Mb ¢lms gave direct, reversible electron exchange between HOPG and the iron heme center. Cyt c gave reversible iron heme electron transfer in phosphate bu¡ers only after the electrode potential was ¢rst taken to 0.75 V. At this potential, phosphate adsorbs to HOPG and may facilitate the reversible electrochemistry [94]. An AFM-electrochemical study of Cys3Ser azurin on gold showed an electroinactive ¢lm of protein also featuring two-dimensional aggregates [96]. Cys3Ser azurin ¢lms gave an unstable, decaying redox peak on edge-plane pyrolytic graphite. Thus, direct adsorption of proteins on conductive (nonoxide) electrode surfaces can give electroactive ¢lms, but may result in problems with protein aggregation and limited stability. An alternative to constructing monolayers of proteins on electrodes is to employ coatings of charged, self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of alkanethiols on gold electrodes. For example, carboxy-alkanethiols on gold adsorbed positively charged cyt c and facilitated direct, reversible protein electrochemistry [97]. These ¢lms remain reasonably stable if extremes of applied voltage and pH are avoided. Chapter 2 reviews protein electrochemistry using SAMs.
5.2
Covalent Bonding of Proteins to Electrodes
Before the 1990s, methods involving covalent bonding of enzymes to electrodes did not generally result in direct electron exchange between the protein redox sites and electrodes [2123]. More recently, direct electron transfer to cyt c and other redox proteins has been achieved in ¢lms made by covalent bonding the proteins to functionalized SAMs as reviewed elsewhere [7], and in Chapter 2 in this book. A variation of the SAM approach involves attachment of thiol groups on the protein to gold. Thus, the redox protein azurin was mutated by replacing the serine with cysteine in position 118 [98]. The mutated azurin was chemisorbed to gold electrodes via the cysteine sulfurgold bond, and gave quasi-reversible voltammetry. Willner and co-workers at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem have devised elegantly constructed covalently bound protein layers on electrodes to obtain catalytic properties. In some cases, the coated electrode devices are photoswitchable [99]. A major strategic feature of their approach is to create covalent linkages that facilitate electron exchange from electrodes to redox sites in the protein.We discuss several of these systems below. One example involved design of a biocatalytic surface to produce maleic acid stereoselectively. Microperoxidase 11 (MP-11), an iron
28
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 12 Stepwise construction of MP-11=MbCoII monolayer film on a propylamino-SAM on a gold electrode. Electrons can be transferred from electrode to MP-11 to MbCoII to a substrate in a contacting solution.
hemepeptide fragment featuring the active site of cyt c, was linked with amide bonds to mercaptoethylamine SAMs using a water-soluble carbodiimide (EDC) promotor. The MP-11 ¢lms bind the heme protein myoglobin (Mb), which was subsequently cross-linked with glutaric aldehyde [100] (Fig.12).Vectorial electron transfer from electrodes to MP-11 iron heme gave the FeII MP-11that donated the electron to the CoIIMb to obtain CoIMb.The latter species reduced the triple bond in acetylene dicarboxylic acid to yield maleic acid. Reactions of a large number of redox enzymes depend on the cofactor nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD), which associates near the active site of the enzymes. In another example, NADþ ¢lms were constructed on mercaptoethylamine SAMs and the NADþ was bound to cross-linked enzymes. These ¢lms provided biocatalytic oxidation of substrates [101]. The approach involved the initial binding of carboxylate groups of pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ), a catalyst for the oxidation of NADþ , to the SAM by EDC-assisted amide formation. EDC was then used to attach N6-(2-aminoethyl)-NADþ to unreacted PQQ carboxylates. This
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
29
gave a Au-PQQ-NADþ electrode to which lactate dehydrogenase or alcohol dehydrogenase could be associated and then cross-linked. Substrate conversion from lactate to pyruvate and ethanol to acetic acid were accomplished. Catalytic currents obtained from these substrates increased linearly with concentration of the substrate, suggesting possible applications to biosensors. The above covalent bonding approach has been extended to sophisticated multibiomolecule devices. In one example, a four-helix bundle de novo-synthesized protein was attached as a monolayer to a gold electrode. Then, histidine residues on the helices were used to bind iron heme units that exchanged electrons with the electrode [102]. This monolayer coupled with a glutaric aldehyde-¢xed layer of nitrate reductase was used for catalytic reduction of nitrate ion. Biosynthetic applications were demonstrated using a coupled layer of CoII-reconstituted myoglobin. In other examples, a sequential Au-horseradish peroxidase (HRP) glucose oxidase electrode was designed to catalyzed oxidation of glucose by O2, producing H2O2. Catalytic oxidation of 1-chloro-1-napthol by the H2O2 HRP gave an insoluble product that precipitated on the electrode and was detected by Faradaic impedance changes, cyclic voltammetry, and quartz crystal microbalance frequency changes [103]. A similar strategy was used to detect acetylcholine with a three-enzyme layered electrode [104]. Covalent binding of proteins to electrodes that exhibit hinge-bending motions has allowed construction of nonenzymatic biosensors [105]. Genetically engineered periplasmic binding proteins tagged with an electroactive RuII complex at one end were attached at the other end to a functionalized SAM. Binding of speci¢c substrates (e.g., maltose, Zn2þ , glutamine) caused a bending of the protein such that the RuII complex was moved farther away from the electrode and gave smaller voltammetric oxidation peaks. Films of this type were used to successfully determine maltose in beer and glucose in rat blood serum.
6 6.1
CAST BIOMOLECULEPOLYION FILMS ProteinPolyion Films
Polymerprotein ¢lms have been utilized frequently for mediated enzyme electrochemistry [2123], but polymer ¢lms for direct electron transfer between proteins and electrodes have developed more slowly. The ¢rst report of direct, reversible electron transfer involving proteins in a polymer coating on an electrode seems to have been from Murray’s lab at the University of North Carolina, and involved cyt c in gel coatings of poly-
30
Rusling and Zhang
acrylamide and polyethylene oxide on a planar cell featuring an edge-plane pyrolytic graphite working electrode [106]. These gel coatings had a high water content, with salt added for ionic conduction. They gave reversible CVs for cyt c indistinguishable from those of the protein in aqueous solutions. Films of polyelectrolytes can support high water content and serve as suitable hosts for proteins. Extensive work with small electroactive ions has been done with ¢lms of Na¢on, a per£uosulfonate ionomer with less than 15% ionizable sulfonate groups per monomer. Na¢on’s structure results in a partly hydrophobic character leading to a high a⁄nity for hydrophobic cations [107109].
Structure of Na¢on Hill et al. studied ¢lms of proteins and Na¢on cast from aqueous mixtures onto basal-plane pyrolytic graphite [110], then coated after drying with a second layer of Na¢on. While cyt c gave no CV peaks, reversible voltammetry was observed for cyt c551, cyt b5, and azurin in these ¢lms. The charge on cyt c under the conditions used is about þ8, and it would be expected to interact electrostatically with negative charges on Na¢on. In contrast, charges for proteins that have good CV responses were 2 [cyt c551], 8 [cyt b5], and þ2 [azurin]. These results suggested that hydrophobic interactions may stabilize protein binding within the Na¢on ¢lms. In agreement with this view, Bianco and Haladjian found that electrodes coated with Na¢on did not incorporate positively charged protein cyt c3 [111]. If this protein was ¢rst cast onto the electrode, then coated with Na¢on, voltammetry could be observed but peaks decayed rapidly upon multiple scans. Negatively charged spinach ferredoxin deposited onto a PG electrode with the cationic polyion polylysine, dried, and then coated with Na¢on gave more stable, reversible CVs [111]. Polylysine has protonated amine groups at neutral pH. This soluble polycation can be added to solutions to facilitate co-adsorption of negatively charged proteins on electrodes. For example, proton reduction catalyzed by the negative hydrogenase was studied in this way at a pyroly¢c graphite (PG) electrode [112,113]. Catalytic peaks for the reduction of protons to hydrogen were found. Carboxyalkylthiol SAMs on Au were used to ¢rst adsorb poly(lysine), with subsequent adsorption of the negatively charged cytochrome b5 to obtain reversible voltammetry [114].
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
31
Poly(lysine) was added to solutions to achieve direct electron transfer from indium tin oxide (ITO) electrodes to spinach ferredoxin, which transferred this electron to cyt P450cam in solution [115]. This system of poly(lysine), spinach ferredoxin, and cyt P450cam was used to dehalogenate toxic organohalides, mimicking bacterial bioremediation. Eastman AQ ionomers,which are poly(ester sulfonic acids), can also be used for making protein ¢lms. AQ ionomers have sulfonate groups at 11% of monomer sites and a backbone with carbomethoxyphenyl groups. Positive proteins cyt c and cyt c3 could be taken up from their solutions into AQ ¢lms on electrodes [116], giving reversible voltammetry. In contrast, no uptake of these proteins by Na¢on ¢lms was observed. A big di¡erence between these two polymers is that AQ ¢lms in bu¡er contain about 90% water and are hydrogels, while Na¢on ¢lms contain only about 30% water [117].
Structure of Eastman AQ38 and AQ29 Ionomers Thin ¢lms cast from mixtures of ionomer Eastman AQ38 and positively charged myoglobin (Mb) formed stable hydrogel ¢lms on PG electrodes after immersion in water [117]. Coulombic interactions between Mb and the ionomer control retention of the protein, and Soret absorbance band positions suggested that Mb in the ¢lms has a conformation similar to native Mb. Reversible cyclic voltammograms were reproducible for several months when Mb-AQ38 ¢lms were stored dry or immersed in aqueous bu¡er. Oxygen and trichloroacetic acid were catalytically reduced by Mb in AQ ¢lms with signi¢cant decreases in the electrode potentials required. Stable ¢lms on PG electrodes were also made from Eastman AQ55 and hemoglobin (Hb) featuring reversible voltammetry for the four iron heme groups of the protein [118]. Soret absorption bands were consistent with a near-native conformation for Hb in AQ ¢lms in the medium pH range. Square-wave voltammograms of Hb-AQ ¢lms were successfully ¢tted by nonlinear regression analysis using the model featuring dispersion of formal potentials. An average ks of 62 s1 was obtained. Hemoglobin in these ¢lms catalyzed the reduction of trichloroacetic acid. AQ ¢lms containing c-type cytochromes were used to study reactions of soluble FeIII ammonium citrate [119]. c-Cytochromes from sulfate or sulfur-reducing bacteria acted as FeIII reductases, but mitochondrial
32
Rusling and Zhang
c-cytochromes did not.Films of AQ and Mb-poly(ethylene oxide) were stable in ethanolic solutions, and were used to reduce hexachloroethane [120]. A great advantage of cast polymerprotein ¢lms is ease of preparation, involving only mixing of protein and polymer, and spreading the mixture on an electrode surface. However, a disadvantage is that the protein may not be well retained in ¢lms in contact with solutions, causing electrochemical signals to decay with time. 6.2
DNAIonomer Films
Films of double-stranded (ds) DNA and ionomers were stable enough to be used for detecting DNA damage from incubation of the ¢lm with styrene oxide, which reacts with guanine bases and disrupts the double helix. Films were prepared on PG electrodes by casting mixtures of ds-DNA with Eastman AQ38S or with Na¢on [13,121]. Damage to these DNA ¢lms was detected by oxidation peaks that developed during reaction with styrene oxide at 37 C for 10 min to several hours using derivative square-wave voltammetry. Single electrodes can be used to measure relative damage rates. Damage of DNA by reaction with styrene oxide under the electrode incubation conditions was con¢rmed by capillary electrophoresis. Total integrals of oxidation peaks increased with time of incubation with styrene oxide. Relative peak heights depended on the type of DNA in the order calf thymus ds-DNA > salmon sperm ds-DNA > supercoiled ds-DNA > highly polymerized calf thymus ds-DNA. Films of Mb=DNA also showed oxidation peaks after short incubations with styrene oxide that may be attributable to DNA damage.
7 7.1
FILMS WITH SURFACTANTS AND LIPIDS ON ELECTRODES Bilayer Lipid Membranes (BLMs)
Living biomembranes contain roughly equal amounts of phospholipid and protein. Many enzymes function while they are attached to membranes [122]. Enzymes can be bound on the surface, partly inserted, or extend fully across the biomembrane (Fig. 13). Biomembrane-like structures of lipids or insoluble synthetic surfactants containing proteins have been constructed on electrodes in a number of ways. To mimic biological membranes, lipids or surfactants should reside on the electrode in bilayer structures such as in Fig. 13. Below, we brie£y review structural characteristics that cause lipid and surfactant molecules to form bilayers.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
33
FIG. 13 Conceptual model of a lipid bilayer membrane showing three modes of protein binding.
Surfactant or lipid molecules contain charged or polar head groups and one or more long hydrocarbon tails (Fig. 14). The term surfactant (from surface-active agent) is more general, and the name lipid is usually reserved for biological surfactants that help to make up biomembranes. Molecular structure can be connected with supramolecular nanostructure by the surfactant packing parameter, v=ao lc , where v is the volume of the hydrocarbon tail region of the surfactant, ao is the optimal area per head group, and lc is the critical chain length [123,124]. Chain length and volume can be estimated from lc ¼ 1:5 þ 1:26ðn 1Þ ð—Þ v ¼ 27:4 þ 26:9ðn 1Þ ð—3 Þ
ð19Þ ð20Þ
where n is the number of carbon atoms in the chain. Note that v for a doublechain surfactant is twice that of a single-chain surfactant with the same chain length. Molecules with values of the packing parameter between 0.5 and 1 are predicted to form bilayer structures, are usually insoluble in water, and are good candidates for bilayer ¢lm formation. Surfactants with v=ao lc < 0:5 are water-soluble and form micelles. Molecules with packing parameters >1 tend to form reversed micelles in organic solvents. Lipids and surfactants in Fig. 14 and are examples of molecules that have been used to make proteinsurfactant ¢lms. All have v=ao lc between 0.5 and 1. Such molecules tend to have two or three hydrocarbon tails. This increases the value of v compared to a single-chain surfactant, while not changing ao lc very much.
34
FIG. 14
Rusling and Zhang
Water-insoluble double-chain surfactants that form bilayer structures.
One approach to lipid bilayer structures on electrodes is LangmuirBlodgett (LB) membrane transfer. Here an LB lipid ¢lm is formed at the airwater interface in an LB ¢lm balance, and transferred to an electrode by controlled dipping and extraction. Yokoto et al. reported direct, chemically reversible voltammetry for cyt c on a phosphatidylcholine layer on an ITO electrode [125]. Multilayer ¢lms can also be constructed on electrodes by LB transfer methods. Reversible CV for Mb was found in multilayer ¢lms of a variety of synthetic insoluble lipids made in this way [126]. However, LB ¢lm transfer is tedious and impractical for biosensor or bioreactor development. Simpler, more general methods of making lipid membranes on electrodes have evolved. Tien et al. reported [127,128] adsorbing lipids in decane or squalane=butanol onto freshly cleaved active noble metal wires. This wire is transferred to an aqueous solution and the adsorbed ¢lm thins to a lipid bilayer that is stable for 36 h. Films are equivalent to bilayer lipid membranes (BLM) formed across a small hole in a barrier between two solutions, a technique developed 30 years earlier.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
35
Dipping a basal plane pyrolytic graphite electrode into a detergent was also found to provide coatings on electrodes which facilitated direct electron transfer [129]. Reversible CVof negatively charged cyt b5 was obtained on an electrode coated with dodecylamine, but positively charged proteins gave no electrochemical response. Reversible cyt c voltammetry was achieved with a coating of lauric acid (dodecylcarboxylic acid). The BLM electrode method was used with lecithin (mixed phosphatidylcholines) ¢lms to reduce cyt c [130]. Results suggested that binding of the protein to the BLM is strongly facilitated by electrostatic interactions between the cyt c and the BLM [131]. Studies of thioredoxins (MW ca. 12,000) featuring disul¢de=dithiol redox sites at BLM electrodes indicated voltammetry was controlled by di¡usion of the proteins [132]. Direct electrochemistry of [Fe2S2 ] ferredoxins was observed at BLMs formed on gold from neutral phosphatidylcholines (2.5 mg=mL) or phosphatidylcholine (50 mg=mL) including dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide (DODAB) [133]. Linear di¡usion control of the electrochemistry was found, and binding of the negative ferredoxins to the positive BLMs was largely electrostatic. Thus, while binding of the protein to the BLM is important in this method, electroactive proteins do not seem to have residence times of more than a few seconds on the charged membranes. Binding and good CV responses are favored by low concentrations of neutral lipid in the adsorbate solution, inclusion of a surfactant of complimentary charge of the protein, and low ionic strength in the protein solution. Both hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions between the BLM and the protein may be important for binding. On ITO electrodes, BLMs with low concentrations of neutral lipid (0.5 mg=mL) in the adsorbate solutions gave adsorption-controlled voltammetry of cyt c [134]. At higher lipid concentrations (5 mg=mL), with or without addition of anionic surfactant, di¡usion-controlled cyt c voltammetry was found. These results were similar to those for BLMs on gold electrodes. A later study on ITO reported conditions under which voltammetry suggested various degrees of insertion of cyt c into the BLM, involving the relative balance of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions [135]. BLMs were also used to compare reactions of cyt c bound to membranes and in solution with £avodoxin semiquinone and reduced spinach ferredoxin [136]. BLMs on ITO were used to obtain CV of integral membrane proteins cyt f and cyt c oxidase [137]. BLMs on gold were used to study redox chemistry of spinach thioredoxins f and m and ferredoxin:thioredoxin reductase [138]. An approach to making bilayers containing membrane proteins on electrodes involves chemisorption of a submonolayer of alkane thiol onto a
36
Rusling and Zhang
gold or silver electrode in the presence of a bilayer-forming surfactant. Alkanethiols and detergent-solubilized enzyme in bu¡er are put in contact with a gold electrode while being dialyzed against bu¡er without additives [139]. Dialysis dilutes the solubilizing agents in the enzyme solution, helping to co-deposit enzyme with the alkanethiol on the electrode. Escherichia coli fumarate reductase and fructose dehydrogenase [140] were immobilized for biosensor applications by this method. The large transmembrane protein cyt c oxidase was immobilized in this way [141144], and was shown to mediate electron transfer with its natural redox partner reduced cyt c.
7.2
Cast Surfactant Films Incorporating Proteins
Spreading organic solutions or aqueous vesicle dispersions of waterinsoluble surfactants onto solid surfaces is a simple way to make ordered, stable multilayer ¢lms [145]. In a procedure called casting, the solution or dispersion is spread evenly onto the surface, and the solvent is allowed to evaporate. The surfactants self-assemble into ordered stacks of bilayers (Fig. 15).When these ¢lms are annealed in aqueous bu¡ers, large amounts of water become associated with the head groups between bilayers. Di¡erential scanning calorimetry can be used to observe gel-to-liquid crystal phase transitions of these ¢lms. This features a transition from the solid-like gel phase in which hydrocarbon tails are extended in all-trans conformations to a more £uid liquid crystal state featuring dynamic gauche bonds in the tails [6].Gel-to-liquid crystal transitions are characteristic of surfactant and lipid bilayer structures, and transition temperatures in the ¢lms are similar to those of vesicle dispersions of the same surfactant. Double- and triple-chain surfactants, by virtue of the large volume of their tail regions, have surfactant packing parameters between 0.5 and 1 and can be used to form these multibilayer ¢lms. The casting technique provides a viable alternative to LB ¢lm transfer for easily preparing multiple bilayer ¢lms of surfactants on surfaces. Kunitake et al. ¢rst inserted a protein, myoglobin (Mb), in an oriented fashion between bilayers of dialkylphosphate surfactants [146]. This work pre¢gured the use of metalloproteinsurfactant ¢lms on electrodes for voltammetry. Polymer-stabilized surfactant ¢lms can be made by replacing the counterions of the surfactants with ionic polymers in the casting solutions [147149]. For example, bromide in DDAB (Fig. 14) can be replaced with polystyrene sulfonate, and the ¢lm can be cast from the resulting surfactantpolymer conjugate. Films are structured in multiple bilayers (cf. Fig. 15), with polyions associated with head groups.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
FIG. 15
37
Idealized model of a cast multibilayer surfactant film on a surface.
Proteins incorporated into stacked lipid bilayers can lead to larger concentrations of redox sites per unit electrode area, resulting in larger voltammetric peaks. Self-assembled ¢lms are made by casting from aqueous vesicle dispersions containing the protein. Vesicles are closed globular structures. They are essentially water pools surrounded by a bilayer of lipid. When these structures dry after being cast onto a solid surface, they £atten, resulting in stacks of bilayers. Metalloproteins in such ¢lms have given reversible cyclic voltammetry, as illustrated by a CV of the bacterial iron heme enzyme cyt P450cam in ¢lms (ca. 0.5 mm) of dimyrystoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) (Fig. 16) [60]. This CV clearly shows nearly symmetric peaks for FeIII reduction on the forward scan and FeII oxidation on the reverse scan. A Soret absorption band at 447 nm for the FeIIcarbon monoxide (CO) complex of cyt P450cam in these ¢lms showed that the enzyme was in its native state. CV midpoint potentials shifted by about þ60 mV when the cyt P450FeII-CO complex was formed during CV scans with CO in the solution. Bare PG electrodes in cyt P450cam solutions or DMPC ¢lms in bu¡er gave no CV peaks (Fig. 16, b and c). This ¢gure helps to illustrate general
38
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 16 Cyclic voltammograms on basal-plane PG electrodes at 0.1 V=s in pH 7 buffer: (a) cyt P450cam-DMPC film in oxygen-free buffer containing no enzyme; (b) bare electrode in oxygen-free buffer containing 40 mM cyt P450cam; (c) DMPC film in oxygen-free buffer containing no enzyme. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 60. Copyright 1997, Royal Society of Chemistry).
features of voltammetry of metalloproteins in lipid ¢lms and many of the other types of ¢lms discussed in this chapter, i.e., such ¢lms ‘‘turn on’’direct protein voltammetry. Many metalloproteins do not show direct electrochemical reductionoxidation peaks on bare solid electrodes. For example, quasireversible CVs of cyt P450cam in solution were found only with highly pure enzyme at temperatures near 0 C [150]. In contrast, cast surfactant ¢lms containing cyt P450cam give reversible CVs and were stable for over a month when stored in bu¡er at 5 C. Further, in solution at these temperatures the enzyme would have fully denatured in several days. Solution pH controls the E00 values of cyt P450cam in these ¢lms [60,64], which were considerably positive of solution values [151]. Soluble proteins can also be taken up from bu¡ers into cast liquid crystal ¢lms of surfactants on electrodes [152154]. For example, Mb in pH 5.5 bu¡er was taken up into DDAB ¢lms, giving chemically reversible voltammetry for the heme FeIII=FeII redox couple of Mb [152]. DDAB and Mb are both positive at pH 5.5, so hydrophobic interactions are probably important for ¢lm stability. However, ¢lms made by mixing the protein
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
39
solution with a vesicle dispersion and casting are preferable because it is easier and faster, provides a known amount of protein in the ¢lm, and gives ¢lms that are slightly better ordered [155]. Both techniques lead to comparable voltammetry. CVs of thin proteinsurfactant ¢lms (i.e. 1mm) at scan rates <0.5 V=s typically show nonideal thin layer behavior, with peak current proportional to scan rate. However, CV peaks for 20 mm Mb-DDAB ¢lms (Fig. 17) have a characteristic ‘‘di¡usional tail’’ consistent with the in£uence of di¡usion of charge within the ¢lm. Reductionoxidation peak separations were about 100 mV at 0.1 V=s, and peak current was proportional to the square root of scan rate consistent with di¡ustion-controlled ¢lm voltammetry. The slope of the linear Ip versus u1=2 plot gave a charge transport di¡usion coe⁄cient (Dct) of 4 107 cm2=s [152]. This may re£ect physical di¡usion of the protein in the ¢lm, or ‘‘electron hopping’’ by electron self-exchange reactions between Mb redox sites [50]. When 20-mm DDAB ¢lms containing no protein were placed into a Mb solution, periodic voltammetric scans showed that the protein arrived at the electrode in under 10 s. Using the Dct of
FIG. 17 Cyclic voltammograms at 100 mV=s and 25 C: (a)pH 5.5 buffer containing no protein on a bare PG electrode; (b) 25 mM Mb purified by ultrafiltration in buffer on bare PG; (c) 20 mm Mb-DDAB film on PG electrode in buffer, no Mb in solution. (Adapted from Ref. 153 with permission. Copyright 1995, American Chemical Society.)
40
Rusling and Zhang
4 107 cm2=s, the relation between molecular displacement D, D, and di¡usion time t in Eq. (5) predicts t ¼ 5 s, consistent with the arrival time of Mb at the electrode.This suggests that physical movement of Mb through the DDAB ¢lms transport the charge. Mass and charge transport within lipid ¢lms depends on their phase. For example, transport studies like those described above showed that, at 25 C, Mb di¡uses rapidly through lamellar liquid crystal ¢lms of DDAB and phosphatidylcholines, but not through ¢lms of solid-like gel-state DHP (cf. Fig. 14) [53]. DDAB ¢lms are in the lamellar liquid crystal phase at 25 C. The £uidity of this phase facilitates the movement of the protein during voltammetry. In thick ¢lms, normal pulse voltammetry (NPV) limiting currents are a direct measure of Dct1=2 [49]. NPV limiting currents for gel-state Mb-DDAB ¢lms at temperatures below the gel-to-liquid crystal phase transition temperature (Tc) were small. As the temperature was increased, the limiting current increased in a sigmoid shape (Fig. 18) consistent with a transition from the gel to liquid crystal phase.The in£ection point of this Ilim versus T curve occurs near the Tc of about 12 C measured by di¡erntial scanning calorimetry. Sigmoid-shaped Ilim versus T curves are not observed for very thin ¢lms under conditions where di¡usion does not in£uence the voltammogram. Atomic force microscopy images also suggested that Mb inserts into DDAB bilayers [94,95]. A potential-driven phase transition in DDAB ¢lms was uncovered by AFM which may cause movement of DDAB microstructures and possibly aid in-¢lm transport of Mb during CV scans. Unlike Mb-DDAB, ¢lms of phosphatidylcholines thin to 0.5 mm after soaking in bu¡er for about 1 h, but then remain stable for weeks. This may occur because phosphatidylcholines are slightly more water-soluble that the very insoluble DDAB. Midpoint potentials of the CVs of Mblipid and cyt P450camlipid ¢lms shifted negative with increasing solution pH. The properties of the proteins in these ¢lms are controlled by the pH and salt content of the external solution. Mb gave direct, reversible heme FeIII=FeII electron transfer in a variety of ¢lms of double-chain or triple-chain surfactants [64,156] on PG, Au, ITO, or Pt electrodes. None of these electrodes gave signi¢cant voltammetric peaks in nominally pure Mb solutions. However, quasi-reversible peaks developed after several hours of repetitive scanning of PG electrodes in Mb solutions [157]. Adsorption of proteins and macromolecular impurities on bare electrodes can inhibit electron exchange between the protein of interest and the electrode. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, surface infrared spectroscopy, and voltammetric studies detected the presence of such macromolecular
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
41
FIG. 18 Influence of temperature on limiting current from normal pulse voltammetry (pulse width 10 ms) for Mb-DDAB films on PG in pH 5.5 buffer. (Adapted from Ref. 153 with permission. Copyright 1994, American Chemical Society.)
adsorbates on electrodes in Mb solutions [154]. However, competitive adsorption on an electrode surface between surfactant, protein, and macromolecular impurities in the protein solution is always won by the surfactants when present in large enough amounts. This is true in cast ¢lms of insoluble surfactants or in a 0.1 M solution of a soluble ionic surfactant. The adsorbed layer of ordered surfactant or lipid inhibits macromolecule adsorption, and maintains a viable path for electron exchange between the electrode and the protein. The type of surfactant greatly in£uences E00 of the protein in these ¢lms. Values in DDAB ¢lms are the most positive and closest to reported solution E00 s for Mb [7], although still about 50 mV negative of solution values. The most negative E 00 s for Mb were found in ¢lms of the zwitterionic phosphatidylcholines (DMPC and DLPC).Values in DDAB ¢lms are about
42
Rusling and Zhang
100 mV positive of those in DMPC ¢lms. Similar trends were observed for hemoglobin (Hb). Thus, surfactant head group charge may be important in determining E00. Electrode material also had a strong in£uence on E00. For Mb in DDAB ¢lms, E00 values ranged from 50 to þ 120 mV versus NHE at pH 5.5 in the order ITO < Au < PG < Pt [7]. The apparent rate constant k s depended weakly on electrode material. The in£uence of surfactant type and electrode material on E00 s suggests a possible electrical double-layer e¡ect at the electrode¢lm interface on the potential actually felt by the protein. Surfactantprotein interactions may also be important. Re£ectance-absorbance FT-IR (RAIR) and visible spectroscopy showed that Mb in the DDAB and lipid ¢lms had a nearly native conformation in the medium pH range, and that partial unfolding occurred at pH 5. Low-angle X-ray di¡raction con¢rmed that the sufactant ¢lms are arranged in bilayers [7,64]. The Bragg di¡ractions for Mbsurfactant ¢lms were generally consistent with the width of a bilayer with tilted hydrocarbon tails. Gel-to-liquid crystal phase transition temperatures (Tc) within several degrees of values for bilayer vesicle dispersions of the same surfactant also suggest that surfactants in the ¢lms are arranged in bilayers. Electron spin resonance (ESR) anisotropy and linear dichroism of Mb-DDAB ¢lms showed that the iron heme group was oriented in surfactant ¢lms, but with relatively broad angular distributions [155]. Mb hemes were oriented at angles about 60 to ¢lm normal, regardless of head group charge or surfactant type, suggesting that orientation does not depend on coulombic interactions. The protein may be partly imbedded in the hydrocarbon tail regions of the bilayers and depend on hydrophobic interactions for orientation and retention. NMR showed that anions such as chloride and acetate bind strongly to Mb within the ¢lms [158], neutralizing some of the surface charge and possibly allowing the protein to reside in hydrophobic regions more easily. A simpli¢ed model of Mbsurfactant ¢lms based on characterization studies is shown in the ¢fth entry in Table 1. The cast surfactant ¢lm technique appears general, and a variety of other metalloproteins have given chemically reversible voltammetry in these ¢lms. They include hemoglobin [159161], cytochromes c, c3, and c553 [162164], ferredoxins (ironsulfur proteins) [165169], M. tuberculosis catalase-peroxidase, and other peroxidases [51]. The most complex protein studied in lipid ¢lms has probably been the very large reaction center protein (RC) from the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides, which contains multiple bound redox cofactors. Cyclic voltammetry of thin ¢lms made from RC and dimyristoylphosphatidyl
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
43
choline on PG electrodes in bromide-free bu¡ers at 4 C revealed a reproducible, chemically irreversible oxidation peak at 0.98 V and a reduction peak at 0.17 V versus NHE [170]. The reduction peak disappeared for RCs with the quinones removed, suggesting that this peak represents reduction of quinone cofactors. The oxidation peak showed a catalytic current increase in the presence of ferrous cytochrome c, and decreased by 85% when illuminated by visible light, suggesting assignment to the primary electron donor cofactor which should display these features. On gold electrodes, RClipid ¢lm voltammetry was complicated by halide ion adsorption [171]. Polyionsurfactant ¢lms have also been used to incorporate proteins on electrodes. The polyionsurfactant complexes are dispersed in water by sonication, and protein is added to this solution before casting. Myoglobin was incorporated into cast and LB ¢lms of several polyionsurfactant complexes on PG electrodes. Reversible voltammetry in the liquid crystal phase, and characteristic gel-to-liquid crystal phase transitions were observed in all cases [126]. Similar to the simple surfactant ¢lms, formal potentials depended on surfactant structure and charge. Mb was also studied in composite ¢lms of DDAþ and polyacrylate (PA ) [172]. Electrochemical results and a Tc of 18 C compared of 11C for DDABMb ¢lms suggest slightly less £uidity in DDAPAMb ¢lms compared to DDABMb. Electrochemical sensors based on antigenantibody interactions show great promise for biomedical and biohazard detection. In a study optimizing surfactantpolyion ¢lms for such uses, electrical impedance was used to show that molecular organization of ¢lms of dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide with poly(styrenesulfonate) (PSS) or Na¢on on pyrolytic graphite electrodes was improved by annealing in water [173]. Films made by dipping negatively charged Na¢on-coated electrodes into DODAB dispersions had similar phase-transition temperatures to water-annealed cast DODABNa¢on ¢lms. Impedance changes upon binding of bovine serum albumin (BSA) in solution to anti-BSA in DODABNa¢on ¢lms suggested that the method of preparation and optimization of the amount of cholesterol in the ¢lm were important for applications of impedance-based detection of antigenantibody binding [173]. Exfoliated clay platelets can serve as inorganic counter anions for cationic surfactants such as DDAþ . Films were made by casting aqueous dispersions of Hb and DDAB-clay composite onto PG electrodes [174]. Cyclic voltammetry gave chemically reversible peaks at a midpoint potential of 0.06 V versus NHE at pH 7. Only the inner layers of the ¢lm were electrochemically active, and Hb was not completely inserted between clay platelets. These ¢lms are stable upon storage for over 2 months.
44
8
Rusling and Zhang
FILMS CONSTRUCTED LAYER BY LAYER
Preparation of biomolecule ¢lms by constructing a single layer at a time provides excellent control over thickness, and enables the design of ¢lm architecture according to the preconceived plans of the builder. Films containing one or two layers of enzyme that are less than 10 nm thick are easily made. Thicker ¢lms can be made by adding more layers. Also, several different enzymes can be incorporated and spatially separated on the normal axis of the ¢lm in this way. One modern approach utilizes the highly selective binding of antigens with antibodies. Enzymes linked to antibodies can be bound to antigen layers adsorbed onto electrodes [175,176]. Additional layers of enzyme can be added with similar strategies. An advantage is high enzyme activity and orientation. A disadvantage is that the enzyme conjugates need to be synthesized and puri¢ed. Alternate adsorption of monolayers of biomolecules and polyions is a more general method that has been developed over the past decade by Lvov, Decher, and others [177179]. This technique has been used to make ultrathin ¢lms of a wide variety of proteins and oppositely charged polyions [178181]. The procedure is illustrated for a construction of a ¢lm on a negatively charged solid (Fig. 19). The initial negative charge might be obtained on a metal oxide by treatment with base, or on gold or silver by treatment with an alkanethiol terminating in a sulfonate or carboxylic acid group. This negatively charged solid is then immersed into a 13-mg=mL solution of positively charged polyions. The polycations adsorb at monolayer coverage in about 1520 min, e¡ectively reversing the charge on the solid surface. The solid is rinsed in water, then immersed in a 13-mg=mL solution of negatively charged proteins. The negative surface charge on the protein is stabilized by dissolving it in a bu¡er of pH larger than the protein’s isoelectric point. A monolayer of protein is adsorbed from this solution, and the surface develops a negative charge. Both adsorption steps can be repeated many times to obtain the desired number of reproducible alternating layers in a multilayer assembly. Film growth can be monitored during or after each adsorption step with quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) weighing, surface plasmon resonance, spectroscopy, or voltammetry. Figure 19 also shows a conceptual picture of layer-by-layer ¢lms. Nearest-neighbor protein and polyion layers are somewhat intimately mixed, as documented for ¢lms of linear polycations and polyanions [177], but ¢rst and third (or fourth) layers are spatially separated. Most enzymes retain good activity in these ¢lms [178]. Some polyions that have been used to make such ¢lms are shown above. They include metal oxide nanoparticles and DNA.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
45
Alternate layer-by-layer adsorption has been used to provide ultrathin ¢lms of redox proteins myoglobin and cyt P450cam featuring direct electron exchange with electrodes [68]. Films made on gold electrodes required an undercoating of mercaptopropanesulfonate (MPS) to facilitate direct voltammetry of the proteins. MPS chemisorbs via AuS bonds, placing a layer of negative sulfonate groups at the electrodesolution interface to adsorb the ¢rst layer of polycation or cationic protein. Chemically reversible cyclic voltammograms were found for the FeIII =FeII redox couple of the proteins in ¢lms on smooth gold, as illustrated for a ¢lm containing a monolayer of cyt P450cam (Fig. 20). Films containing Mb or cyt P450 on smooth vapor-deposited gold electrodes had only about 1.31.5 electroactive layers. The number of electroactive layers was greatly increased by growing ¢lms on mechanically roughened PG electrodes, which may provide a disorder-inducing template
46
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 19 Illustration of the method of alternate layer-by-layer adsorption for constructing polyionprotein films.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
47
for the ¢lm that could decrease average interprotein distance and enhance electron transport by ‘‘electon hopping’’ between redox sites in the ¢lms. Also, when polyions were deposited from solutions with relatively high salt concentrations, where they are coiled rather than linear, much more protein was adsorbed in the subsequent deposition step. Thus, ¢lms constructed on rough PG electrodes by adsorbing PSS from 0.5 M NaCl and Mb from dilute pH 5.5 bu¡er gave up to 7 electroactive Mb layers, as illustrated by CV (Fig. 21) [182]. Similar ¢lms on smoothly polished PG electrodes showed a saturation in electroactivity after three or four layers of Mb. Electrode roughness seems to be important in obtaining optimal electroactivity. Films were stable for several months upon storage dry or in bu¡er solutions. Peak currents of Mb and cyt P450cam in these ¢lms were proportional to scan rate at n <1V=s, but peak widths were much larger than 90 mV, suggesting nonideal thin-layer electrochemical behavior. Reversible voltammetry was also found for ¢lms of polycations and putidaredoxin, the natural bacterial ferredoxin redox partner of cyt P450cam [169]. SWVdata on {PSS (0.5 M NaCl)=Mb}6 ¢lms constructed on rough PG analyzed with the E0dispersion model gave an average ks of 53 s1, in the same range as Mbsurfactant and cast Mbpolyion ¢lms [182]. An average
FIG. 20 Cyclic voltammogram at scan rate 0.5 V=s of PEI=PSS=Cyt P450cam film on a AuMPS-coated QCM resonator in pH 7 buffer. (Adapted from Ref. 68 with permission. Copyright 1998, American Chemical Society.)
48
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 21 Background-subtracted cyclic voltammograms in pH 5.5 buffer at 0.3 V=s of rough PG electrode coated with {PSS(0.5 M Nacl)=Mb}n films with n ¼ 1,4,6, and 7. (Adapted from Ref. 182 with permission. Copyright 2000, American Chemical Society.)
E 00 of 0.085 V versus NHE was similar to values for Mb in cast phospholipid and Eastman AQ ionomer ¢lms. The mechanical stability of ¢lms constructed layer by layer in £owing or stirred solutions is much better than that of cast surfactant ¢lms, and so these layered ¢lms will probably be more useful for device applications. Layered polyionprotein ¢lms have storage stability of several months as long as the protein is table. A quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) can be used to monitor ¢lm formation [178,179]. The frequency of a QCM resonator decreases in direct proportion to the mass on its metal coating, provided the visoelasticity of the interface does not change [183]. QCM is typically sensitive to 1 ng. In-situ QCM measurements on MPS-coated gold=quartz resonators showed that adsorbed saturation for protein and polyion layers is reached in 1520 min. Estimates of the weight of each layer, and of the repeatability of the multiple adsorption steps, can be obtained from QCM of dry ¢lms. Drying minimizes bias from interfacial viscoelasticity changes. For 9-MHz quartz resonators, mass per unit M =Aðg=cm2 Þ of the ¢lm layer is related to the QCM frequency shift DF (Hz) by [180] M =A ¼ DF =ð1:83 108 Þ
ð21Þ
where the area is that of the metal disk on the quartz resonator in square centimeters. Direct scaling between DF and nominal ¢lm thickness ðdÞ is given by
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
49
dðnmÞ ð0:016 0:002ÞDF ðHzÞ
ð22Þ
This expression was con¢rmed by comparison with high-resolution crosssectional images from scanning electron microscopy of ¢lms made from a variety of proteins and polyions [180]. Measurements of QCM frequency changes after each layer of the ¢lm is adsorbed are illustrated for a multilayer assembly of Mb and DNA on a MPSAu surface (Fig. 22). The ¢lm was dried in a stream of nitrogen before each measurement. Frequency decreasing linearly and at regular intervals throughout the multiple adsorption steps demonstrates repeatable adsorption. From Eq. (22), the thickness of this ¢lm of 18 layers is 95 nm. The fraction of electroactive protein can be obtained by dividing the electroactive mass of protein obtained from integrating slow-scan CVs on the gold resonator by the total mass measured by QCM. Negatively charged metal oxide nanoparticles can also be used with positively charge proteins for layer-by-layer construction of ¢lms. For example, Mb was adsorbed from pH 5.2 bu¡er,where it is positively charged, and SiO2 nanoparticles of 45 nm diameter were adsorbed from weakly basic solutions onto a bed of PSS=PDDA adsorbed separately from 0.5 M NaCl
FIG. 22 QCM frequency changes for dry films at each step of assembly of a Mb=DNA film on a smooth AuMPS underlayer. DNA was double-stranded calf thymus (ds-CT). Measurements after adsorption cycles 911 were omitted. (Adapted from Ref. 68 with permission. Copyright 1998, American Chemical Society.)
50
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 23 Cyclic voltammograms at 0.3 V=s in pH 5.5 buffer of PG=PSS= PDDA=SiO2(Mb=SiO2)n for films with n ¼ 2,5, and 9. (Adapted from Ref. 184 with permission. Copyright 2000, American Chemical Society.)
onto rough PG. CV peak currents increased with layer number for up to nine bilayers of protein and SiO2 nanoparticles (Fig. 23) [184]. Masses measured by QCM during formation of the SiO2Mb ¢lms showed that there was enough protein in the ¢lm to completely coat each nanoparticle. Similar ¢lms were made from Mb and 2050-nm MnO2 nanoparticles. Full protein coating of each particle may provide connecting pathways of closely packed Mb molecules which could facilitate propagation of charge within the ¢lm by a electron hopping mechanism. As shown in Fig. 22, DNA can be used as a polyanion in the layer-bylayer method. Films of DNA and Mb or cyt P450cam also gave chemically reversible voltammetry. CVs were similar to those in Figs. 20, 21, and 23 [121]. The amount of electroactive protein in layered ¢lms depends on the materials used. Figure 24 compares the number of moles of electroactive Mb per unit area on rough PG electrodes determined by integrating CVs for ¢lms made using nanoparticles, PSS adsorbed from 0.5 M NaCl, and ds-DNA. PSS and DNA gave larger amounts of Mb per unit area, but no further
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
51
FIG. 24 Influence of number of bilayers deposited on the amount of electroactive myoglobin in film constructed on rough PG with various polyanions. PSS and dsCT DNA were adsorbed from 0.5 M NaCl solutions.
increase in electroactivity were found for more bilayers than 7. Increase in protein electroactivity extended to 10 bilayers with the MnO2 and SiO2 nanoparticles, but smaller total amounts of Mb were obtained in these ¢lms. These latter ¢lms have thicknesses of 350 nm for SiO2=Mb ¢lms and 30 nm for MnO2 =Mb ¢lms, and charge transfer through these ¢lms probably follows an ‘‘electron hopping’’ pathway. The MnO2=Mb ¢lms are thinner for nominally similar numbers of bilayers because of competitive adsorption during layer growth [184]. QCM and AFM were used to characterize layers of polyions and cyt P450s and their binding to protein redox partners during layer-by-layer ¢lm growth [185]. When applied as the ¢rst adsorbed layer on a silver-coated QCM resonator, both cationic PEI and anionic PSS formed polymer islands featuring globular structures of about 7 and 11 nm in diameter, respectively, as visualized by AFM. By the time the fourth alternate layer of PEI or PSS had been adsorbed, the polymer islands merged and protein adsorption as a ¢fth layer was visualized on a nearly continuous, relatively smooth ¢lm. Cyt P450cam and cyt P450 2B4 appeared as globules on the polymer underlayers
52
Rusling and Zhang
with diameters of about 10 nm. In general, cyt P450s have nonuniform charge distributions featuring negative and positive ends of the macromolecule, and could be oriented with either charged end up (i.e., positive or negative) by controlling the charge sign of the underlying polyion layer [185]. 9
DNA DAMAGE DETECTION WITH FILMS
Electrochemical sensors coated with stable DNA ¢lms could facilitate rapid in-vitro electrochemical detection of DNA damage by toxic metabolities.On solid electrodes, oxidation of guanine bases is a viable target as guanine is the most easily oxidized base. As mentioned above, cast ¢lms of ds-DNA and ionomers Eastman AQ and Na¢on on graphite electrodes were used to detect DNA damage by direct oxidation using derivative square-wave voltammetry [13,121]. Oxidation peaks developed as the ¢lm was incubated with styrene oxide,which forms known covalent adducts with guanine and adenine bases in DNA. The incubation method was shown by capillary electrophoresis to generate damaged DNA bases under the conditions used. In related work, damage from ionizing radiation to DNA adsorbed onto carbon electrodes was detected by chronopotentiometry [186]. Disadvantages of direct electrochemical oxidations include poor signal-to-noise ratios and data analysis which requires derivative or other background corrections. Catalytic methods of DNA oxidation mentioned in Sec. 4.5 have been applied to improve signal to noise in SWV detection of calf thymus (CT) dsDNA damage in ¢lms [187]. Layer-by-layer growth was used to make ¢lms of DNA and the polycation PDDA. The best sensitivity was found with dsDNA as the outer layer of the ¢lm and at low salt concentration.QCM on gold resonators showed a linear change in average frequency with addition of multiple layers of PDDA and CT ds-DNA (Fig. 25). Error bars illustrate the typical reproducibility obtainable in forming the layers. Films on oxidized PG electrodes of structure (PDDA=ds-DNA)2 were used of analytical purposes. From the QCM results and Eqs. (21) and (22), the average thickness was 6 nm with 0.23-mg ds-DNA per ¢lm. When (PDDA=ds-DNA)2 ¢lms were reacted with styrene oxide, the SWV oxidation peaks increased with the incubation time (Fig. 26). Average peak current for catalytic SWV oxidation of the ds-DNA ¢lms using 50-mM 0 Ru(bpy)2þ 3 (bpy=2,2 -bipyridine) as the catalyst in solution increased with incubation time for the ¢rst half-hour, then decreased slightly (Fig. 27). Error bars re£ect electrode-to-electorde variability. Incubation of ¢lms with toluene, for which no chemical reactions with DNA have been reported, gave catalytic oxidation peaks that remained within electrode-to-electrode variations of controls (Figs. 26 and 27). Catalytic SWV oxidation with Ru(bpy)2þ 3 provided more sensitive detection of DNA damage than direct
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
53
FIG. 25 QCM frequency shifts for cycles of alternate PDDA=DNA adsorption on gold resonators coated with mixed monolayers of mercaptopropionic acid and mercaptopropanol. (Average values for eight resonators). (Adapted from Ref. 187 with permission. Copyright 2001, American Chemical Society.)
SWV oxidation. Studies of DNA and polynucleotides in solutions and ¢lms suggested that oxidation of guanine and chemically damaged adenine in partly unraveled, damaged DNA were the most likely contributors to the catalytic peaks [187]. An alternative method to monitor DNA damage in layered ¢lms involves using an electroactive cation probe that binds better to ds-DNA than to damaged DNA.This approach was used with Co(bpy)3þ 3 as the probe for ¢lms of (PDDA=ds-DNA)2 grown layer by layer on PG electrodes ¢rst coated with a layer of PSS [188]. After incubation of ¢lms of (PDDA=dsDNA)2 with saturated styrene oxide at 37 C in a separate reactor for various times, electrodes were rinsed, placed into 20 mM Co(bpy)3þ 3 , and analyzed by SWV. The peak for a ¢lm before incubation is shown in Fig 28a, labeled ‘‘0 min.’’ When the ¢lm was incubated with styrene oxide, peak current
54
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 26 SWV of (PDDA=ds-DNA)2 films on oxidized PG in pH 5.5 acetate buffer containing 50 mM NaCl, with 50 mM RuðbpyÞ2þ 3 in buffer, and after incubations at 37 C with styrene oxide (SO) or toluene. Controls were incubated in buffer only. (Adapted from Ref. 187 with permission. Copyright 2001, American Chemical Society.)
decreased with increasing time because of the decreasing ability of the damaged outer layer of DNA to bind Co(bpy)3þ 3 . Control incubations with toluene or in bu¡er alone showed no trends in peak current with incubation time (Fig. 28b). An advantage of this method is that one electrode can be used to measure a single incubation time course. Denoting the initial SWV peak current as Ip;initial , and the peak current after incubation as Ip;final , plots of the peak current ratio, Ip;initial =Ip;final versus incubation time (Fig. 29) can be used to monitor rates of DNA damage. Use of this ratio helps correct for electrodeto-electrode variations in Ip;initial . Increase in Ip;initial =Ip;final were found for ds-DNA electrodes with increasing incubation time in styrene oxide solu-
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
55
FIG. 27 The influence of incubation time with styrene oxide and toluene on the average catalytic peak current (corrected for controls) for 515 trials per data point for (PDDA=ds-DNA)2 films. Error bars represent standard deviations. (Adapted from Ref. 187 with permission. Copyright 2001, American Chemical Society.)
tions. No signi¢cant variations were found for controls with or without toluene. 10
PROSPECTS FOR THE FUTURE
One of the main themes of this chapter is the excellent recent progress that has been made in preparing stable electroactive ¢lms containing biomolecules. Several types of ¢lms can now facilitate direct electron exchange between native enzymes and electrodes, an achievement which in most cases was only a dream as little as 20 years ago. Films can also be designed to catalyze enzyme reactions with an electrochemical driving force, either for speci¢c reactions by covalent bonding strategies, or with more general approaches based on monolayer or multilayer co-adsorption with polyions or surfactants. Films of DNA can be designed for applications such as damage analysis or hybridization. Taken together, the ¢lms described here
56
Rusling and Zhang
FIG. 28 SWV difference currents in 20 mM CoðbpyÞ3þ 3 at pH 5.5 of (PDDA=dsDNA)2 films after: (a) incubations with syrene oxide; (b) control incubations with toluene. (Adapted from Ref. 188 with permission. Copyright 2002, Wiley-VCH.)
provide complementary alternatives for fundamental studies of biomolecules, and for device development. What might we expect in the future from this research area? We predict signi¢cant progress in applications of enzyme and DNA ¢lms to biosensors, bioreactors, biomedical devices, and fundamental biochemical
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
57
FIG. 29 Influence of incubation time on average SWV peak current ratios for (PDDA=ds-DNA)2 films in 20 mM CoðbpyÞ3þ at pH 5.5 after incubations with 3 styrene oxide, toluene, or pure buffer. Ifinal corresponds to the peak current after each incubation; Iinitial corresponds to peak current before incubation. (Adapted from Ref. 188 with permission. Copyright 2002 Wiley-VCH.)
research. We could envision future biosensors that can detect physiological abnormalities from analysis of blood, urine, sweat, or even from noninvasive analyses that make measurement through the skin or in the saliva. Electrode arrays may be developed to provide many biomedical tests simultaneously. It is very likely that biosensors will be included in feedback loops to control implanted biomedical devices. Testing patients for genetic diseases via mutated DNA hybridization assays may be possible by using enzyme tags that develop signals via direct electron transfer and electrochemical catalysis. Future sensors may be constructed to detect toxicity of metabolites of organic pollutants and drugs. Simple biosensors could be developed to detect hazardous biological materials such as pathogenic bacteria.
58
Rusling and Zhang
In closing, the area of electroactive biomolecular ¢lms is a good example of how fundamental research leads to technological advances that bene¢t our society.What began purely as fundamental laboratory endeavors only 20 or so years ago has opened the door to a wide variety of useful devices that promise to come to fruition in the next few decades.The ¢rst success story in this ¢eld has been the advent of electrochemical enzyme-based glucose sensors for home use by diabetic patients [8].We expect and hope that this is just the tip of the iceberg. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author’s research described herein was supported by Grant ES03154 from National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS), National Institutes of Health (NIH), and the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) through Grant 99-35306-7609. Contents are solely the responsibility of the author and do not necessarily represents o⁄cial views of NIEHS, NIH, or USDA.The author is also grateful to students and colleagues named in joint publications whose valuable contributions made the work possible. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
J Deisenhofer, H Michel. Science 245:14631473, 1989. G Feher, JP Allen, MY Okamura, DC Rees. Nature 339:111116, 1989. RE Blankenship, MT Madigan, CE Bauer, eds. Anoxyygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria. Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1995. JB Schenkman, H Greim, eds. Cytochrome P450. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1993. PR Ortiz de Montellano, ed. Cytochrome P450. 2nd ed. New York: Plenum, 1995. A Kotyk, K Janacek, J Koryta. Biophysical Chemistry of Membrane Function. Chichester, UK: Wiley, 1988. JF Rusling, Z Zhang. In: HS Nalwa, ed. Handbook of Surfaces and Interfaces of Materials.Vol. 5. Biomolecules, Biointerfaces, and Applications. San Diego, CA, Academic: 2001, pp 3371. G Ramsay, ed. Commercial Biosensors. New York: Wiley, 1998. SR Mikklesen. Electroanalysis 8:1519, 1996. HH Thorp. Trends Biotechnol 16:117121, 1998. J Wang. Chem Eur J 5:16811685, 1999. E Palacek, M Fojta. Anal Chem 73:74A183A, 2001. J Mbindyo, L Zhou, Z Zhang, JD Stuart, JF Rusling. Anal Chem 72:20592065, 2000. EF Bowden, FM Hawkridge, HN Blount. In: S Srinivasan, YA Chizmadzhev, JO’M Bockris, BE Conway, E Yeager, eds. ComprehensiveTreatise of Electrochemistry.Vol. 10. NewYork: plenum, 1985, pp 297346.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46.
59
FA Armstrong. In: Bioinorganic Chemistry. Structure and Bonding 72. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1990, pp 137221. P Yeh,T Kuwana. Chem Lett 11451148, 1977. MJ Eddowes, HAO Hill. Chem Commun 31543155, 1977. DE Reed, FM Hawkridge. Anal Chem 59:23342339, 1987. EF Bowden, FM Hawkridge, JC Chlebowski, EE Bancroft, C Thorpe, HN Blount. J Am Chem Soc 104:76417644, 1982. FA Armstrong, HAO Hill, BN Oliver. Chem Commun 976977, 1982. GG Guilbault, M Mascini. Analytical Uses of Immobilized Biological Compounds for Detection, Medical, and Industrial Uses. Holland: Reidel, 1988. JM Kau¡mann, GG Guilbault. In: Bioanalytical Applications of Enzymes. Methods Biochemical AnalysisVol. 36. New York: Wiley, 1992, pp 63113. GG Guilbault. Analytical Uses of Immobilized Enzymes. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1984. JD Czaban. Anal Chem. 57:345A356A, 1985. T Yokota, K Itoh, A Fujishima. J Electroanal Chem. 216:289292, 1987. Z Salamon, G Tollin. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 25:447454, 1991. Z Salamon, G Tollin. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 26:321334, 1991. FA Armstrong, HA Heering. J Hirst. Chem Soc Rev 26:169179, 1997. MJ Tarlov, EF Bowden. J Am Chem Soc 113:18471849, 1991. EM Boon, DM Ceres,TG Drummond, MG Hill, JK Barton. Nature Biotechol 18:10961100, 2000. F Azek, C Grossiord, M Joannes, B Limoges, P Brossier. Anal Biochem 282:107113, 2000. DJ Caruana, A Heller. J Am Chem Soc 121:769774, 1999. F Patolsky, E Katz, A Bardea, I Willner. Langmuir 15:37033706, 1999. B Singer, D Grunberger. Molecular Biology of Mutagens and Carcinogens. New York: Plenum, 1983. W. Pauwels, P Vodiceka, M. Servi, K. Plna, H Veulemans, K Hemminki. Carcinogenisis 17:26732680, 1996. EE McConnell, JA Swenberg. CRC Crit RevToxicol 24:S49S55, 1994. ER Nestmann, DW Bryant, CJ Carr, TT Fennell, NJ Gorelick, JE Gallagher, JA Swenberg, GM Williams. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 24:918, 1996. E Palecek. Electroanalysis 8:714, 1996. E Palecek, P Boublikova, F Jelen. Anal Chim Acta 187:99107, 1986. F Jelen, M Fojta, E Palecek. Electroanal Chem 427:4956, 1997. F Jelen, M Tomschik, E Palecek. J Electroanal Chem 423:141148, 1997. M Fojta, E Palecek. Anal Chim Acta 342:112, 1997. M Fojta, V Stankova, E Palecek, P Koscielniak, J Mitas. Talanta 46:155161, 1998. J-M Sequaris, P Valenta, HW Nurnberg. Int J Radiat Res 42:407415, 1982. J-M Sequaris, P Valenta, J Electroanal Chem 227:1120, 1987. J Wang, X Cai, J Wang, C Johnsson, E Palecek. Anal Chem 67:40654075, 1995.
60 47. 48.
49. 50.
51. 52. 53. 54. 55.
56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71.
Rusling and Zhang RW Murray. In: AJ Bard,ed. Electroanalytical Chemistry. Vol. 13. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1984, pp 191368. RW Murray. In: RW Murray, ed. Molecular Design of Electrode Surfaces. Techniques of Chemistry Series.Vol. 22. New York: Wiley-Interscience, 1992, pp 148. AJ Bard, LR Faulkner. Electrochemical Methods. 2nd ed. Newyork: Wiley, 2001. M Madja. In: Murray, RW ed. Molecular Design of Electrode Surfaces. Techniques of Chemistry Series. Vol. 22. New York: Wiley-Interscience, 1992, pp 159206. Z Zhang, S Chouchane, RS Magliozzo, JF Rusling. Chem Commun 177178, 2001. TM Nahir, RA Clark, EF Bowden. Anal Chem 66:25952598, 1994. Z Zhang, JF Rusling. Biophys Chem 63:133146, 1997. A-EF Nassar, Z Zhang, N Hu, JF Rusling, TF Kumosinski. J Phys Chem B 101:22242231, 1997. N Oyama, T Ohsaka. In: RW Murray ed. Molecular Design of Electrode Surfaces. Techniques of Chemistry Series.Vol. 22. New York: Wiley-Interscience, 1992, pp 333402. A-EF Nassar, JF Rusling, N Nakashima. J Am Chem Soc 118:30433044, 1996. J Osteryoung, JJ O’Dea. In: AJ Bard, ed. Electroanalytical Chemistry.Vol. 14. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1986, pp 209308. A Mugweru, JF Rusling. Electrochem Commun 3:406409, 2001. JJ O’Dea, J Osteryoung. Anal Chem 65:30903097, 1993. Z Zhang, A-EF Nassar, Z Lu, JB Schenkman, JF Rusling. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 93:1769-1774, 1997. RA Marcus, N Sutin. Biochem Biophys Acta 811:265322, 1985. TM Nahir, EF Bowden. J Electroanal Chem 410:913, 1996. TM Saccucci, JF Rusling. J Phys Chem B 105:61426147, 2001. JF Rusling. Acc Chem Res 31:363369, 1998. A-E Nassar, JM Bobbitt, JD Stuart, JF Rusling. J Am Chem Soc 117:1098610993, 1995. FA Armstrong. In: G Lenz, G Milazzo. eds. Bioelectrochemistry of Biomacromolecules. Basel, Switzerland: Birkhauser Verlag, 1997, pp 205255. JF Rusling, TF Kumosinski. Nonlinear Computer Modeling of Chemical and Biochemical Data. New York: Academic, 1996, pp 100102. YM Lvov, Z Lu, JB Schenkman, X Zu, JF Rusling. J Am Chem Soc 120:40734080, 1998. X Zu, Z Lu, Z Zhang, JB Schenkman, JF Rusling. Langmuir 15:73727377, 1999. J Kong, JN Mbindyo, X Wu, JX Zhou, JF Rusling. Biophys Chem 79:219229, 1999. Z Zhang, S Chouchane, RS Magliozzo, JF Rusling. Anal Chem 74:114119, 2002.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films
61
72. S Steenken, SV Jovanovic. J Am Chem Soc 119:617617, 1997. 73. (a) DH Johnston, KC Glasgow, HH Thorp. J Am Chem Soc 117:89338938, 1995. (b) ME Napier, HH Thorp. Langmuir 13:63426344, 1997. (c) BT Farrer, HH Thorp. Inorg Chem 39:4449, 2000. (d) IV Yang, HH Thorp. Inorg Chem 39:49694976, 2000. (e) PM Armistead, HH Thorp. Anal Chem 72:37643770, 2000. (f ) MF Sistare, SJ Codden, G Heimlich, HH Thorp. J Am Chem Soc 122:47424749, 2000. (g) VA Szalai, HH Thorp. J Phys Chem B 104:68516859, 2000. 74. AC Onkto, PM Armistead, SR Kircus, HH Thorp. Inorg Chem 38:18421846, 1999. 75. PM Armistead, HH Thorp. HH Anal Chem 73:558564, 2001. 76. J Hirst, FA Armstrong. Anal Chem 70:50625071, 1998. 77. HA Heering, J Hirst, FA Armstrong. J Phy Chem B 102:68896902, 1998. 78. FA Armstrong, GS Wilson. Electrochim Acta 45:26232645, 2000. 79. JN Butt, A Sucheta, FA Armstrong, J Breton, SJ George, AJ Thompson, EC Hatchikian. J Am Chem Soc 113:89488950, 1991. 80. JN Butt, FA Armstrong, J Breton, SJ George, AJ Thompson, EC Hatchikian. J Am Chem Soc 113:66636670, 1991. 81. J Hirst, JLC Du¡, GNL Jameson, MA Kemper, BK Burgess, FA Armstrong. J Am Chem Soc 120:70857094, 1998. 82. J Hirst, GNL Jameson, JWA Allen, FA Armstrong. J Am Chem Soc 120:1199411999, 1998. 83. JL Breton, JLC Du¡, JN Butt, FA Armstrong, SJ George,Y Petillot, E Forest, G Schafer, AJ Thompson. Eur J Biochem 233:937946, 1995. 84. A Sucheta, BAC Ackrell, B Cochrane, FA Armstrong. Nature 356:361362, 1992. 85. J Hirst, BAC Ackrell, FA Armstrong. J Am Chem Soc 119:74347439, 1997. 86. HA Heering, JH Weiner, FA Armstrong. J Am Chem Soc 119:1162811638, 1997. 87. MS Mondal, DG Goodin, FA Armstrong. J Am Chem Soc 120:62706276, 1998. 88. JP McEvoy, FA Armstrong. Chem Commun 16351636, 1999. 89. K Chen, J Hirst, R Camba, CA Bonagura, CD Stout, BK Burgess. FA Armstrong. Nature 405:814817, 2000. 90. T Ikeda, S Miyaoka, K Miki. J Electroanal Chem 352:267278, 1993. 91. KL Egodage, BS de Silva, GS Wilson. J Am Chem Soc, 119:52955301, 1997. 92. K Draoui, P Bianco, J Haladjian. F Guerlesquin. M Bruschi. J Electroanal Chem 313:201214, 1991. 93. JN Butt, M Filipiak,WR Hagen. Eur J Biochem 254:116122, 1997. 94. S Boussaad, NJ Tao, R Arechabaleta. Chem Phys Lett 280:397403, 1997. 95. S Boussaad, NJ Tao. J Am Chem Soc 121:45104515, 1999. 96. EP Friis, JET Andersen, LM Madsen, N Bonander, P Moller, J Ulstrup. Electrochim Acta 42:28892897, 1997. 97. EF Bowden, Interface 6:4044, 1997.
62
Rusling and Zhang
98. JJ Davis, CM Halliwell, HAO Hill, GW Canters, MC van Amsterdam,Verbeet, M.Ph. New J Chem 11191123, 1998. 99. AN shipway, I Willner. Accts Chem Res 34:421432, 2001. 100. V Heleg-Shabtai, E Katx I Willner. J Am Chem Soc 119:81218122, 1997. 101. A Bardea, E Katz, AF Bˇckmann, I Willner. J Am Chem Soc 119:91149199, 1997. 102. I Willner, V Hegel-Shabtai, E Katz, HK Rau, W Haehnel. J Am Chem Soc, 121:64556468, 1999. 103. F Patolsky, M Zayats, E Katz, I Willner. Anal Chem 71:31713180, 1999. 104. L Alfonta, E Katz, I Willner. Anal Chem 72:927935, 2000. 105. DE Benson, DW Conrad, RM de Lorimier, SA Trammell, HW Hellinga. Science 293:16411644, 2001. 106. BN Oliver, JO Egekeze, RW Murray. J Am Chem Soc 110:23212322, 1988. 107. CR Martin, H Freiser. Anal Chem 53:902904, 1981. 108. MN Szentirmay, CR Martin. Anal Chem 56:18981902, 1984. 109. CAC Sequeira. In: RG Linford, ed. Electrochemical Science and Technology of Polymers 2. London: Elsevier Applied Science, 1990, pp 319374. 110. CEW Hahn, HAO Hill, MD Ritchie, JW Sear. Chem Commun 125126, 1990. 111. P Bianco, J Haladjian. Electroanalysis 6:415422, 1994. 112. P Bianco, J Haladjian. J Electrochem Soc 139:24282432, 1992. 113. P Bianco, J Haladjian S Giannandrea-Derocles. Electroanalysis 6:6774, 1994. 114. JDH Glenn, EF Bowden, Chem Lett 399400, 1996. 115. M Wirz, J Klucik M Rivera. J Am Chem Soc 122:10471056, 2000. 116. P Bianco, A Taye, J Haladjian J Electroanal Chem 337:299303, 1994. 117. N Hu, JF Rusling. Langmuir 13:41194125, 1997. 118. J Yang, N Hu, JF Rusling. Electroanal Chem 463:5362, 1999. 119. E Lojou, P Bianco, M Bruschi. Electrochim Acta 43:20052013, 1998. 120. M Wright, MJ Honeychurch, HAO Hill. Electrochem Commun 1:609610, 1999. 121. JF Rusling, L Zhou, B Munge, J Yang, C Estavillo, JB Schenkman. Faraday Disc 116:7787, 2000. 122. A Kotyk, K Janacek, J Koryta. Biophysical Chemistry of Membrane Function Chichester, UK: Wiley, 1988. 123. J Issraelachvili. Intermolecular and Surface Forces. 2nd ed. San Diego, CA Academic, 1992. 124. DF Evans, DJ Mitchell, BW Ninham. J Phys Chem 90:28172825, 1986. 125. T Yokota, K Itoh, A Fujishima. J Electroanal Chem 216:289292, 1987. 126. A-EF Nassar, Y Narikiyo, T Sagara, N Nakashima, JF Rusling. J Chem Soc FaradayTrans 91:17751782, 1995. 127. HT Tien, Z Salamon. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 22:211218, 1989. 128. T Martynski, HT Tien. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 25:317342, 1991. 129. A Guerrieri,TR Cataldi, HAO Hill. J Electroanal Chem 297:541547, 1991. 130. Z Salamon, G Tollin. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 25:447454, 1991. 131. Z Salamon, G Tollin. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 26:321334, 1991.
Designing Functional Biomolecular Films 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150. 151. 152. 153. 154. 155. 156. 157. 158. 159. 160. 161. 162. 163. 164. 165. 166.
63
Z Salamon, FK Gleason, G Tollin. Arch Biochem Biophys 299:193198, 1992. Z Salamon, G Tollin. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 27:381391, 1992. Z Salamon, G Tollin. Photochem Photobiol 58:730736, 1993. Z Salamon, G Tollin. J Bioenerg Biomembranes 29:211221, 1997. G Cheddar, G Tollin. Arch Biochem Biophys 310:392396, 1994. Z Salamon, JT Hazzard, G Tollin. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:64206423, 1993. Z Salamon, G Tollin, M Hirisawa, L Gardet-Salvi, A-L Stritt-Etter, DB Kna¡, P Schˇrmann. Biochim Biophys Acta 1230:114118, 1230. KT Kinnear, HG Monbouquette. Langmuir 9:22552257, 1993. KT Kinnear, HG Monbouquette. Anal Chem 69:17711775, 1997. JK Cullison, FM Hawkridge, N Nakashima, S Yoshikawa. Langmuir 10:877882, 1994. JD Burgess, FM Hawkridge. Langmuir 13:38713786, 1997. JD Burgess, MC Rhoten, FM Hawkridge. Langmuir 14:24672475, 1998. JD Burgess, MC Rhoten, FM Hawkridge. J Am Chem Soc 120:44884491, 1998. N Nakashima, R Ando,T Kunitake. Chem Lett 15771580, 1983. I Hamachi, S Noda,T Kunitake. J Am Chem Soc 113:96259630, 1991. T Kunitake, M Shimomura, T Kajiyama, A Harada, K Okuyama, M Takayanagi. Thin Solid Fims 121:L89L91, 1984. T Kunitake, A Tsuge, N Nakashima. Chem Lett 17831786, 1984. M Shimomura,T Kunitake. Polymer J 16:187190, 1984. J Kazlauskaite, ACG Westlake, L-L Wong, HAO Hill. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 21892190, 1996. SG Sligar, DL Cinti, GG Gibson, JB Schenkman. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 90:925932, 1979. JF Rusling, A-EF Nassar. J Am Chem Soc 115:1189111897, 1993. JF Rusling, A-EF Nassar. Langmuir 10:28002806, 1994. A-EF Nassar,WS Willis, JF Rusling. Anal Chem 67:23862392, 1995. A-EF Nassar, Z Zhang, JF Rusling, V Chynwat, HA Frank, K Suga. J Phys Chem B 99:1101311017, 1995. A-EF Nassar, Y Narikiyo, T Sagara, N Nakashima, JF Rusling. J Chem Soc FaradayTrans 91:17751782, 1995. A Onuoha, JF Rusling. Unpublished results. JF Rusling, A-EF Nassar,TF Kumosinski. Biophys Chem 67:107116, 1997. J Yang, N Hu. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 48:117127, 1999. Z Lu, Q Huang, JF Rusling. J Electroanal Chem 423:5966, 1997. M Ciureanu, S Goldstein, MA Mateescu. J Electrochem Soc 145:533541, 1998. P Bianco, J Haladjian. J Electroanal Chem 367:7984, 1994. P Bianco, J Haladjian. Electochim Acta 39:911916, 1994. J Hanzlik, P Bianco, J Haladjian. J Electroanal Chem 380:287290, 1995. P Bianco, J Haladjian. Electroanalysis 7:442446, 1995. P Bianco, J Haladjian. Electrochim Acta 42:587594, 1997.
64 167.
Rusling and Zhang
M Tominaga, J Yanagimoto, JF Rusling, AEF Nassar, N Nakashima. Chem Lett 523524, 1996. 168. AEF Nassar, JF Rusling M Tominaga, J Yanagimoto N Nakashima. J Electronal Chem 416:183185, 1996. 169. Z Lu,YM Lvov, I Jansson, JB Schenkman, JF Rusling. J Colloid Interface Sci 224:162168, 2000. 170. B Munge, Z Pendon, HA Frank, JF Rusling. Bioelectrochemistry 54:145150, 2001. 171. Z Gao, HA Frank, YM Lvov, JF Rusling. Bioelectrochemistry 54:97100, 2001. 172. Y Hu, N HuY Zeng. Talanta 50:11831195, 2000. 173. K Abe, RE Schmukler, JF Rusling. Electroanalysis 10:948954, 1998. 174. X Chen, N Hu,Y Zheng, JF Rusling J Yang. Langmuir 15:70227030, 1999. 175. C Bourdillon, C Demaille, J Moiroux, JM Saveant. Accts Chem Res 29:529535, 1996. 176. C Demaille, J Moiroux, JM Saveant, C Bourdillon. In: Y Lvov H M˛hwald, H eds. Protein Architecture: Interfacing Molecular Assemblies and Immobilization Biotechnology. New York: Marcel Dekker, 2000, pp 311335. 177. G Decher. Science 277:12311237, 1997. 178. Y Lvov. In: Y Lvov, H M˛hwald, eds. Protein Architecture: Interfacing Molecular Assemblies and Immobilization Biotechnology. New York: Marcel Dekker, 2000, pp 125167. 179. Y Lvov. In: RW Nalwa ed. Handbook of Surfaces and Interfaces of Materials Vol. 3. Nanostructured Materials, Micelles and Colloids.Academic, CA: San Diego, 2001, pp 170189. 180. Y Lvov, K Ariga, I Ichinose,T Kunitake. J Am Chem Soc 17:61176123, 1995. 181. M Onda,Y Lvov, K Ariga,T Kunitake. J Ferment Bioeng 82:502506, 1996. 182. H Ma, N Hu, JF Rusling. Langmuir 16:49694975, 2000. 183. DA Buttry, MD Ward. Chem Rev 92:13551379, 1992. 184. Y Lvov, B Munge, O Giraldo, I Ichinose, SL Suib, JF Rusling. Langmuir 16:88508857, 2000. 185. JB Schenkman, I Jansson, Y Lvov, JF Rusling, S Boussaad, NJ Tao. Arch Bichem Biophs 385:7887, 2001. 186. J Wang, G Rivas, M Ozsoz, DH Grant, X cai. C Parrado. Anal Chem 69:14571460, 1997. 187. L Zhou, JF Rusling. Anal Chem 73:47804786, 2001. 188. J Yang, Z Zhang, JF Rusling. Electroanalysis, 2002, in press.
2 Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films Immobilized on Self-Assembled Monolayers of Organothiols Katsumi Niki* and Brian W. Gregoryy Illinois State University, Normal, Illinois, U.S.A.
1
INTRODUCTION
Electrode reactions of proteins and enzymes on bare electrodes usually do not take place at their formal potentials (reactions are irreversible). A new era of modern bioelectrochemistry began in 1977 with voltammetric studies of small protein molecules, and was pioneered by groups led by Kuwana [1], Hill [2], and Niki [3]. From these studies, it was found that modi¢cations of electrode surfaces are imperative to facilitate the direct electrochemistry of biological molecules. The direct electrochemistry of biological molecules not only provides important thermodynamic and mechanistic information from biological reactions, but also allows one to develop ‘‘molecular wiring’’ (electrical communication) between electrochemically inactive biological molecules and electrodes for various advanced applications. The use of surface-modi¢ed electrodes has since become well established in electrochemical studies of small protein molecules such as cytochromes, ferredoxins, and blue copper proteins. Taniguchi’s group ¢rst
*Present a⁄liation: The Beckman Institute, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California, U.S.A. y Present a⁄liation: Samford University, Birmingham, Alabama, U.S.A.
65
66
Niki and Gregory
proposed direct electrochemistry of cytochrome c (cyt c) on the pyridinethiol-modi¢ed electrodes,which was found later to form self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on gold electrodes [4,5]. Since that time, numerous surface modi¢ers have been reported [6,7]. However, the application of chemically modi¢ed electrodes to direct electrochemical studies of biological molecules has still been limited. Among the various surface modi¢ers that have been employed, o-functional alkanethiol SAMs are considered the most attractive for mimicking physiological electron transfer (ET) partners with positively charged protein-binding sites [8]. Electrochemical approaches which utilize such SAMs for investigating ET mechanisms are advantageous in that the driving force of the ET reaction can be regulated through control of the electrode potential, and the ET path length can be varied by using alkanethiols of varying chain lengths. In this regard, the electrode reaction of cyt c through carboxylate-terminated alkanethiol SAMs is considered to be a simpli¢ed model system for biological ET processes. Electrostatic interactions between the positively charged lysine amino groups immediately surrounding the heme crevice of cyt c and the negatively charged carboxylate termini of the SAMs stabilize the binding of cyt c, analogous to its complex with negatively charged physiological redox partners such as the cyt c=cyt b5 complex. Although there are numerous surface modi¢ers (from well-de¢ned SAMs to polymer composites) which facilitate rapid ET reactions of biological molecules (from simple proteins to enzymes containing multiple redox active sites) without electron transfer mediators, this chapter focuses on the fundamental electrochemistry of SAMs and SAM=protein ¢lms. In particular, an emphasis is placed on those SAMs that can be formed on conductive substrates and that have been utilized as templates for protein adsorption. Due to the fact that the vast majority of work in this area has centered primarily on organothiol-based SAMs on metals, this chapter will focus on the use of these particular SAMs in studies of protein binding and adsorption. Therefore, the utilization of organosilane monolayers on conductive oxide substrates (e.g., In2O3) as templates for protein adsorption will only be mentioned here [9]. The ¢rst section of this review will summarize the physicochemical properties and structures of SAMs that have been utilized as surface modi¢ers for binding proteins to electrode surfaces, and will focus on alkanethiol monolayers. The second section will discuss results from some of the redox proteins that have been studied at these modi¢ed surfaces, although the electrochemistry of cyt c will be emphasized. Due to the meteoric rise in popularity of self-assembly over the last 10^20 years and the vast quantity of literature that has followed, this review is not intended to be comprehensive, but rather illustrative of the general, present understanding of both SAMs and the behavior of redox proteins at SAMs. For
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
67
more speci¢c information, the reader is encouraged to seek other excellent and more exhaustive reviews=monographs of SAM methodology and structure [10^15] and faradaic bioelectrochemistry [7]. 2
SELF-ASSEMBLED MONOLAYERS OF ORGANOTHIOLS
Molecular self-assembly has been described as ‘‘the spontaneous association of molecules under equilibrium conditions into stable, structurally wellde¢ned aggregates joined by noncovalent bonds’’ [16,17]. Such noncovalent synthetic routes are directed toward ‘‘designing’’ molecules that spontaneously self-organize into predetermined structures, and are inspired by the multitude of highly functional, complex biological structures found in nature (cell membranes, secondary protein structure, the a-helical structure of DNA, etc.). The rational design of molecular functionality by controlling both the self-organization process and resulting aggregate structure is therefore the ultimate goal of many self-assembly strategies. Due to the wide variety of noncovalent intermolecular interactions that may be utilized (dispersion, hydrogen bonding, dipole ^ dipole, ionic, etc.), self-assembly methods o¡er great potential as versatile alternatives to lithographic techniques. Furthermore, self-assembly methods are expected to be inherently less wasteful, since they allow the construction of organized assemblies from the ‘‘bottom up’’ rather than through the ‘‘top-down’’ approach of lithographic techniques. Self-assembled monolayers have been touted over the past two decades as useful model systems for investigations of the self-assembly process. SAMs usually consist of densely packed molecular units that are bound to the surface through a head group which has a speci¢c interaction with the substrate. The molecular precursors that constitute the ¢lm are typically surfactant-based in structure, and spontaneously assemble and selforganize on the substrate surface during deposition. Deposition is achieved either via vapor-phase dosing of the substrate or by exposure of the substrate to a solution containing the precursor molecule. The most widely investigated types of monolayer assemblies formed via this methodology have been alkane- and arylthiols (and their disul¢de derivatives) chemisorbed on noble metal surfaces [10^15], and organosilicon derivatives on hydroxylated surfaces (e.g., SiO2, Al2O3, SnO2, TiO2) [10]. The usefulness of SAMs in the investigation of a wide variety of important interfacial phenomena (e.g., electron transfer [18,19] and corrosion inhibition [20]) has also been widely exploited [10,11]. Clearly, the ability to modify the chemical and=or physical properties of a surface with molecular-level control has been a major driving force toward understanding both the spatial and electronic structure of these ¢lms. In this section of the chapter, we will brie£y review both the current
68
Niki and Gregory
understanding of the structure and physicochemical properties of these SAMs, including those that are critical in in£uencing protein adsorption. 2.1
Formation of SAMs
The speci¢c a⁄nity of the thiol head group for a wide variety of metal (and some nonmetal) surfaces makes these types of monolayer ¢lms appealing since they can be formed on a fairly wide range of materials. From a synthetic standpoint, this is attractive since a vast array of precursor molecules can be fashioned for potential use in SAM formation simply through chemical attachment of the ^ SH moeity. Since the formation of SAMs is dictated by both intermolecular interactions and those with the substrate, not all thiolderivatized molecules necessarily yield self-assembled ¢lms. In fact, the terms ‘‘self-assembled monolayer’’and ‘‘self-assembled ¢lm’’ have been used excessively for any number of adsorbed ¢lms, regardless of their structural organization. The vast majority of organothiols (and organodisul¢des) that have been studied and utilized for self-assembly work have been those based on alkyl-chain derivatives [e.g., R(CH2)nSH,where n 1 and R ¼ CH3, OH, COOH, NH2, or some other functional group, hereafter referred to as RCnSH] or simple aromatic functionalities (RSH, where R ¼ C6H5, C5H4N, etc.). The various types of o-functionalized alkanethiol precursors used for self-assembly are particularly vast; a more complete listing of these endgroup-modi¢ed alkanethiol precursors (and other thiol-derivatized molecules) can be found elsewhere [11,21]. Gold, in both polycrystalline and single-crystal form, has been the most extensively employed substrate material for SAM formation. This is due not only to its availability in high purity, but also to the observations that its surface supports little or no native surface oxide and is easily cleaned. Procedures for cleaning Au substrates are well established, and depend in large part on the form of the substrate: oriented and polished bulk Au single crystals versus single-crystalline evaporated Au ¢lms (on solid support) versus polycrystalline bulk Au [13]. Since the organization and structure of the ¢lm (both local and long-range) is often strongly in£uenced by substrate surface order, smooth well-de¢ned surfaces [such as evaporated Au(111) ¢lms on mica] are generally employed for investigating molecular-level structural details in these ¢lms. Despite the high degree of ¢lm crystallinity, alkanethiol SAMs on these surfaces have been shown electrochemically to be more permeable to solution species than those formed on polycrystalline, macroscopically rough Au substrates [22,23]. Such access to the substrate is primarily limited to defect sites and grain boundaries within the ¢lm, step edges, etc. The ability of the SAM to ‘‘block’’ the electrode is essential if one wishes to investigate ET kinetics at large overpotentials, where solvent
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
69
decomposition or electrolyte redox processes might otherwise preclude their observation. The formation of thiol-based SAMs is typically achieved either through exposure of the gold to a solution containing the thiol or via vaporphase dosing of Au with the gas-phase adsorbate precursor. Awide variety of protocols for self-assembly from solution are available from the literature, and di¡er primarily in choice of solvent, thiol solution concentration, deposition time, and temperature [13]. Ethanolic deposition solutions generally tend to be preferred due to their availability in high purity, their low solvent toxicities, and the fact that long-chain alkanethiols exhibit reasonable solubilities in them ( 103 M range). Although other, less commonly used solvents (e.g., hexane, hexadecane) o¡er larger alkanethiol solubilities, their intercalation within the SAM has been suspected of increasing ¢lm disorder [24]. Furthermore, the composition of mixed SAMs may be highly dependent on the particular solvent chosen for the deposition (due to di¡ering solution solubilities). At the millimolar concentrations often employed for deposition, alkanethiol monolayer formation occurs on a very quick time scale (seconds), although the two-dimensional organizational process continues for a number of hours [11^15]. Consequently, SAM formation from millimolar ethanolic solutions is often allowed to proceed from times ranging from overnight up to a week past immersion. The ¢rst kinetic studies of alkanethiol adsorption from solution were initiated by Bain et al. [24]. For moderately concentrated solutions (1 mM), it was found that the self-assembly process on polycrystalline gold surfaces consisted of two distinct steps: an initial fast step which lasts at most a few minutes, during which time the contact angles and thicknesses of the ¢lms have reached 80^90% of their limiting values; and a second, slower step lasting several hours, during which the thickness (by ellipsometry) and contact angles slowly approach their ¢nal values. Consequently, the overall mechanism has been explained by the initial formation of a relatively amorphous monolayer (¢rst step), followed both by the slow expulsion of solvent and contaminants from the ¢lm and by the slow consolidation and ordering of the ¢lm through additional alkanethiol adsorption and its lateral di¡usion on the surface (second step). Thus, the second, slower step has been characterized as a two-dimensional (2-D) crystallization process within the ¢lm. A number of subsequent time-domain studies have demonstrated that alkanethiol monolayer formation on Au exhibits Langmuir adsorption kinetic behavior. This process has been investigated in some detail by secondharmonic generation (SHG) [25^27]. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) [25,27], near-edge X-ray absorption ¢ne structure (NEXAFS) [28], surface acoustic wave (SAW) experiments (via vapor-phase adsorption) [29], quartz crystal microbalances (QCM) [30,31], and infrared re£ection-absorption
70
Niki and Gregory
spectroscopy (IR-RAS) [32]. For deposition from dilute solution (108^107 M), it has been shown that adsorbed alkanethiols adopt a conformation and orientation at submonolayer coverages that allows them to maximize their interactions with the substrate (i.e., lie in contact with the substrate surface). As the coverage increases, nucleation and a gradual change in the average molecular tilt angle (toward the surface normal) occurs. The formation of such a ‘‘lying-down’’ phase for presaturation coverages of alkanethiols on Au(111) during the self-assembly process (both from solution and via gas-phase dosing) has recently been veri¢ed by IRRAS [32], ultrahigh-vacuum scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) [14,33^ 36], and by low-energy He atom di¡raction [37,38].Thus, many of the atomic and molecular resolution details inherent to the evolution of the ¢lm structure during ¢lm formation are now being explicitly delineated. Exchange kinetics between adsorbed and solution species for alkanethiol ¢lms on gold have been investigated using electroactive alkanethiols [39] and 35S-radiolabeled alkanethiols [40]. In both studies, signi¢cant exchange (>50%) was observed for concentrations typical of most solution deposition work (0.1^1 mM), while full exchange was observed only in neat alkanethiol solution [40]. Similar exchange reactions have also been observed recently for alkanethiol SAMs exposed to H2S vapor [41]. These studies, furthermore, have shown that the exhange kinetics have a pronounced dependence on alkanethiol chain length, with the shorter-chain homologues exhibiting faster displacement rates [39]. Such results have suggested that exchange occurs near defect sites and domain boundaries, where the alkanethiol surface mobility (which is dependent on alkyl chain length) is greatest.These observations have been corroborated by others who have monitored solution exchange reactions by IR-RAS [12] and by changes in contact angle [42,43]. Early X-ray photoelectron spectroscopic (XPS) studies concluded that the products of alkanethiol or dialkyl disul¢de chemisorption on such surfaces were indistinguishable and were consistent with the formation of a metal thiolate (e.g., Au(I) thiolate (RSAu þ Aun0): Sð2p3=2 Þ 162 eV; polymeric Au(I) hexadecylthiolate: Sð2p3=2 Þ162.5 eV [44]) [45^48]. DGads for alkanethiol adsorption on gold surfaces has been estimated by QCM [30,31] and from electrochemical data to be (17^21) kJ=mol, with a slight dependence on the chain length. The similarity in these values with estimates for aliphatic chain interaction energies has again suggested that the exchange dynamics between adsorbed and solution species are dictated by interchain dispersion interactions and therefore most likely occur near defects, step edges, and domain boundaries [30]. Furthermore, these results have argued in favor of the formation of dihydrogen gas [rather than H þ (aq)] as the primary mechanism for loss of hydrogen during the deposition process [30,40].
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
71
Schleno¡ et al. [40] have estimated (from prior electrodeposition data [49]) the homolytic RS ^ Au bond strength to be approximately 167 kJ=mol, which agreed well with bond energetics considerations ( 184 kJ=mol) [12]. 2.2
SAM Film Structure
The orientation, conformation, and two-dimensional structure of the polymethylene portion of alkanethiols SAMs at saturation coverage on Au(111) have been extensively investigated both qualitatively and quantitatively by a number of methods, including IR-RAS [50,51], Raman spectroscopy [52,53], grazing incidence X-ray di¡raction (GIXD) and He atom di¡raction [54,55], sum frequency generation [56,57], NEXAFS [58], and ultraviolet photoemission spectrscopy [59]. It is now well established that for long-chain alkanethiols (n 8) on these surfaces, the alkyl chains are fully extended in a nearly all-trans con¢guration, tilted 30 (from the surface normal) with a twist angle b about the molecular axis of 52 [50], and closely packed to yield a highly dense, crystalline two-dimensional arrangement at the surface. The all-trans conformation has been con¢rmed by the observation of CH2 twisting and wagging bands in the low-frequency infrared spectra of these ¢lms, implying that the local environment of the chains is similar to that of bulk crystalline n-alkanes [50]. In addition, the SAM ¢lm thickness has been shown to vary linearly with chain length for polymethylene chains composed of 9 to 21 carbons [24,51,60,61]. The molecular surface density on Au(111) ( 21.6 —2=molecule [12,14,33]) is slightly larger than that for bulk
FIG. 1 Schematic depicting the general organizational features of a CH3(CH2)9SH SAM at saturation coverage on an Au electrode surface.
72
Niki and Gregory
crystalline n-alkanes ( 18.4 —2=chain [62]), and is a consequence of chain tilting which facilitates interchain dispersion interactions. The atomic and molecular resolution details of the two-dimensional organization of alkanethiol SAMs on Au(111) at saturation coverages have been examined extensively by STM [14,63^70] and by GIXD and He atom di¡raction [54,55,71]. It is now generally agreed that at saturation pffiffiffi coverage, long-chain alkanethiols ðn 8Þ close-pack to form a ð3 2 3Þ unit cell on Au(111), are tilted toward next-nearest neighbors (NNN), and that four thiols are contained per unit cell in a pair-wise arrangement (which suggests that there are two crystallographically distinct thiols per unit cell) [14,72]. Although this notation signi¢es that two-dimensional structure is a pffiffiffithe p ffiffiffi superlattice based on an underlying ð 3 3ÞR30 periodicity, it denotes a rectangular unit cell on a hexagonal substrate mesh [54]. Thus, it is often supplanted by a more common structural designation which is based on the hexagonal mesh of the thiols: a c(2 4) superlattice. It has been suggested that the crystallographic di¡erence between the thiols that comprise the c(2 4) unit cell, and thus the origin of the superlattice structure, arises from twisting about the hydrocarbon chain axis in either a clockwise or counterclockwise fashion [72]; this would be consistent with previous IR-RAS results [73]. However, this likely cannot explain the di¡erences in tunneling current observed between the crystallographically distinct species within the unit cell. Based on analyses by both X-ray di¡raction [74] and X-ray standing waves [75], a more controversial explanation as to the origin of the observed superlattice has been put forth involving ‘‘dimerization’’of the sulfur head groups. Although this description has been met with some criticism [11,55,76], other studies have appeared which support its general conclusions [57,77,78]. STM studies of short-chain alkanethiols (n ¼ 4 or 6) at saturation coverage on Au(111) have evidenced the presence of a two-dimensional liquid phasepatffiffiffi room temperature.The slow formation of ordered domains having a ( p 3) ( p ¼ 8, 9, or 10) structure within this surface liquid phase was attributed either to the slow desorption of thiol or of entrained solvent within the ultrahigh vacuum chamber [64]. Subsequent studies of C4SH on Au(111) have demonstrated similar surface structures [70]. Alkanethiol SAMs at saturation coverage on Au(100) have also been investigated by electron di¡raction [79,80], He atom di¡raction [81,82], and by GIXD and X-ray re£ectivity (XR) [82]. Li et al. employed both He atom di¡raction and GIXD=XR to study the annealed, equilibrium structure of C18SH=Au(100) [82]. The proposed structure consistent with all diffraction=re£ectivity data consisted of: (1) rows of Au adatoms, forming a p(1 4) array on the unreconstructed Au(100) surface; and (2) alkanethiol molecules adsorbed onto both the adatom rows and terrace atoms in
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
73
between. The large c(2 8) unit cell observed by He atom di¡raction was attributed to the height modulation imposed on the adsorbed alkanethiol ¢lm by the adatom rows. The extracted alkanethiol orientation and surface density (i.e., yt ¼ 33.5 and 22.19 —2=molecule, respectively) were found to be similar to that on Au(111) (i.e., yt ¼ 30.3 and 21.62 —2=molecule) [82]. Recent STM studies of C4SH SAMs on Au(100) have evidenced surface structures which support this model,with the exception of the observed periodic height modulation being due rather to missing rows of Au atoms [83]. The self-assembly of alkanethiol monolayers on other metal (and some semiconductor) surfaces has also been fairly extensively investigated, although to a lesser degree than those on Au. These studies have included alkanethiol SAMS on polycrystalline Ag [52,53,84^91], Ag(111) [92^95], Cu [84,85,96,97], and GaAs [98]. It has been established that the SAM structures on the other coinage metals (Ag and Cu) are in some respects similar to those on Au; in all three cases, ¢lms created from the long-chain homologues (n10) are densely packed with fully extended, all-trans hydrocarbon chains. In other respects, however, they exhibit distinct di¡erences relative to the former. In particular, IR-RAS data has indicated that the alkanethiol molecular orientation is closer to the surface normal, ranging from 11 to 15 on both Ag and Cu (compared to 30 on Au), and that the twist angle is signi¢cantly less (b ¼ 41^48 on both Ag and Cu, compared to 52^53 on Au). 2.3
Electrochemistry of SAMs
The formation of an organized SAM on an electrode surface modi¢es the electrochemical properties of the electrode in various ways. The restricted approach of solution species to the electrode surface acts to decrease the electrical double-layer capacitance at the electrode=solution interface, and thus the observed charging current; this of course can be mediated somewhat by the presence of holes or permeable defect sites,which would consequently permit access of such species. For well-ordered and organized SAM systems (such as alkanethiols on Au), the kinetics of interfacial electron transfer can be easily regulated since the ET distance to suitable redox species (either in solution or tethered to the alkyl chain) can be accurately controlled via the length of the chain. Furthermore, the ability to utilize a wide variety of endgroup-functionalized SAMs, coupled with the ease with which multicomponent mixed ¢lms can be constructed, allows one to tailor the electrode surface in a purposeful fashion to develop electrochemical sensors. The electrochemical behavior of thiol-based SAMs has been extensively investigated, and an excellent, thorough monograph on this subject of recent vintage is available [13]. Therefore, only some of the results more relevant to the formation of stable SAM=protein ¢lms are brie£y mentioned here.
74
Niki and Gregory
An understanding of the intrinsic electrochemical characteristics of SAM-modi¢ed electrodes is essential if one intends to investigate the redox behavior of proteins adsorbed onto them. As a starting point, the electrochemical stability limits of the SAM must certainly be established, as these would result in physical removal of the SAM from the electrode surface. For n-alkanethiol monolayers on Au in basic solution (0.5 M KOH), the potential window over which no SAM-speci¢c faradaic processes occur is quite large (>1.5-V range), and extends from potentials corresponding to cathodic stripping of the ¢lm [99^105] to those for its oxidative stripping [99].While the former results in formation of a thiolate product (which often accumulates in a layer adjacent to the electrode surface due to chain-length-dependent solubility e¡ects), the latter transpires at potentials at which oxidation of adsorbed thiol occurs concomitantly with partial oxidation of the Au substrate. Highly basic solutions are required to observe voltammetric peaks corresponding to cathodic stripping of the SAM, since they are obscured by hydrogen evolution even in neutral pH solutions. Widrig et al. have demonstrated that in su⁄ciently basic solution (pH > 11), cathodic stripping of CnSH SAMs (n ¼ 3^18) from evaporated Au(111) ¢lms on mica occurs in the range 0.7 to 1.4 V range (versus Ag=AgCl), and that the peak potential shifts in a linear fashion to more negative values with increasing chain length [99]. The integrated charge (90 7 mC=cm2), however, was found to be independent of chain length. 10 2 Assuming an alkanethiol pffiffiffi pffiffiffi surface coverage of 7.6 10 mol=cm [calculated based on a ( 3 3) alkanethiol surface periodicity on Au(111)] and a surface roughness factor of 1.2, the authors concluded that the cathodic desorption process is consistent with a one-electron reduction of the adsorbed thiol to form a thiolate: Au SCn þ e ! Auð0Þ þ Cn S
ð1Þ
Although changes in magnitude of the interfacial charging current during the stripping process have led to some controversy over the assignment of a unit faradaic charge for this process [106,107], many subsequent electrochemical investigations of alkanethiol SAMs have utilized the reductive desorption process as a means of measuring adsorbate surface coverage [100^105]. Weisshaar et al. have also demonstrated that alkanethiol surface coverages can be electrochemically controlled via oxidative deposition from alkanethiolate-containing basic solutions, or through oxidative redeposition of the reductively stripped monolayer [101]. Thus, electrochemical methods for estimating surface coverage are becoming increasingly important in mixed SAM systems formed via co-deposition procedures (see Sec. 2.5), since the ¢lm composition may di¡er signi¢cantly from that in solution. Finally, by comparing the cathodic stripping curves for C10SH and
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
75
HOOC ^(CH2)10SH SAMs on Au, Imabayashi et al. have shown that the nature of the end group can have a signi¢cant e¡ect on the reductive desorption peak potentials [104]. Oxidative stripping of short-chain alkanethiol SAMs (e.g, C 3SH, C4SH) has been observed to coincide with oxidation of the Au surface; oxidation of CnSH (n > 4) was not observed due to solvent oxidation. After correcting for the charge associated with Au oxidation, the remaining integrated charge (280 35 mC=cm2) led the authors to propose the formation of a sul¢nate upon alkanethiol oxidation in basic solution: Au SCn þ 4OH ! Auð0Þ þ Cn SO 2 þ 2H2 O þ 3e 0
ð2Þ 0
Although early studies using 4,4 -dipyridyl disul¢de (4,4 -PySSPy) as an electrode surface modi¢er found that it facilitated heterogeneous ET reactions of cyt c [4,5], only upon its more recent classi¢cation as a SAMforming material has its electrochemical behavior [and that of the corresponding thiol, 4-mercaptopyridine (4-PySH)] come under serious investigation [108^111]. Recently, Lamp et al. presented electrochemical and spectroscopic evidence indicating that SAMs formed from either 4-PySH or 4,40 -PySSPy decompose spontaneously into atomic and oligomeric sulfur upon prolonged exposure times to even dilute deposition solutions [108]. Samples prepared from 2-PySH, however, exhibited no evidence of such sulfurization, and consequently the authors were unable to explain the mechanism of decomposition. Using voltammetry and in-situ STM, Sawaguchi et al. investigated SAMs of 4-PySH, 2-PySH, and thiophenol (PhSH) on Au(111). Although surface coverages (via reductive desorption) for the three were similar (4-PySH: 4.6 1010 mol=cm2; 2-PySH: 4.7 1010 mol=cm2; PhSH: 4.4 1010 mol=cm2), only 4-PySH demonstrated an ability to facilitate facile electron transfer with cyt c, in agreement with previous reports [112^114]. In addition, STM images of the 2-PySH SAM indicated that the adsorbate coordinated to the surface through both the sulfur and the pyridine nitrogen, explaining its inability to facilitate the ET process [110]. The electrochemical behavior and structure of 4-PySH SAMs on unreconstructed Au(100) surfaces have also been investigated by voltammetry and STM [111]. It has been demonstrated that for relatively high electrolyte concentrations (>0.1 M), the total interfacial capacitance in these SAM systems is governed by that for the monolayer itself (CML). Using the simple Helmholtz model,CML can be related to ¢lm thickness: 1 d ¼ CML e0 eML
ð3Þ
76
Niki and Gregory
where e0 and eML are the permittivity of free space and the static dielectric constant of the ¢lm, respectively, and d is the ¢lm thickness [60,99]. In early SAM studies, Porter et al. showed that plots of CML1 versus the number of methylene units n for CnSH SAMs deposited on polycrystalline Au substrates exhibited linear behavior for n 10 [60]. However, signi¢cant nonlinear behavior was observed for n 8, the degree of which strongly depended on the nature of the electrolyte solution. The appearance of these two chain-length regimes suggested early on that long-chain CnSH monolayers on Au were highly impermeable to aqueous solution species. Subsequent interfacial capacitance investigations of CnSH SAMs on atomically £at Au(111)=mica substrates in 0.5 M KOH demonstrated a high degree of linearity extending over the whole chain-length regime n ¼ 3 to 18 [99]. However, a rather large value for eML was extracted from the slope of the plot (eML ’ 7, in comparison to the expected value eML 2:5); this was interpreted as arising from a higher defect density within the SAM [99]. 2.4
Endgroup-Modified SAMs
Fundamental interest in the acid ^ base properties of o-functionalized alkanethiol SAMs possessing carboxylate ^ or amino-terminal groups has largely been driven by their ability to interact=react with other functional compounds. Depending on solution pH, such terminal groups can electrostatically bind charged solution species (including charged proteins such as cyt c) at the SAM=solution interface. Furthermore, covalent attachment of appropriate precursors to these functionalities can also provide a convenient ¢rst step toward fabricating novel supramolecular architectures. Due to their well-ordered nature, alkanethiol SAMs have become useful model systems for both experimental and theoretical investigations of terminalgroup acid ^ base behavior in relatively well-de¢ned environments. In this regard, the surface pKa values of carboxylic acid-derivatized alkanethiol SAMs have been extensively investigated by contact angle titrations [115^118], voltammetry [119], interfacial capacitance measurements [120], QCM [121^123], atomic force microscopy (AFM) [124,125], and an indirect laser-induced temperature method [126]. The transition from fully protonated to a fully deprotonated state in these SAMshasbeen reported tobe considerably broader than that observed for aqueous soluble alkanoic acids [116].WhilesuchaqueoussystemsexhibitpKa’sof4^5,ithasbeenexpectedthat the corresponding surface acid dissociation constants might di¡er from these due to (1) the proximity of a low dielectric material (i.e., alkane layer) near the end-group region; (2) di¡erences in hydrogen-bonding characteristics relativetothatfor thefreespeciesinsolution(which likelychangewiththeextentof deprotonation); (3) changes in the dielectric constant in the solution region
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
77
adjacenttotheendgroupsastheybecomeprogessivelydeprotonated;(4)other interfacialelectric ¢eld e¡ects that arise fromthe increasing negativecharge at the SAM=solution interface. In some cases, the surface pKa’ s for these carboxylic acid-derivatized SAMs have been reported to be 3^5 pH units more alkaline than corresponding aqueous soluble systems (e.g., butyric acid). For example, a reversible voltammetric wave was observed at 0.6 V (versus Hg=Hg2SO4) byWhite et al. for a mixed SAMcontaining HOOC ^(CH2)10SH and C10SH, which they attributed to an electric ¢eld-driven protonation=deprotonation process of the carboxylic acid moeities at the interface [119]. These waves exhibited maximum peak currents for solution pH’ s near 8.5. Kakiuchi et al. have measured changes in the double-layer capacitance of HOOC ^(CH2)nSH SAMs as a means of estimating apparent surface pKa’ s [120]. In these systems, apparent surface pKa’ s of 7.7, 8.7, 9.2, and 10.3 were found for n ¼ 2, 4,6, and10, respectively, suggesting a signi¢cant chain-length dependence.Other studies, however, have indicated that the surface pKa’s for carboxylic acid-derivatized SAMs are only slightly higher than the analogous aqueous systems [122,123,127].Using QCM, Sugihara et al.estimated surface pKa0 s of 5.8, 6.0, 6.2, and 6.5 for chain lengths n ¼ 2, 5, 10, and 15, respectively [122]. Other values in this range have been reported by Simmons et al., who estimated surface pKa0 s of 6.31, 6.80, 6.67, and 7.16 for n ¼ 1, 2, 10, and 15, respectively.Other factorshavealsoappeared tohaveane¡ectontheobserved surface pKa0 s, including alkanethiol surface coverage [123] and the mole fraction of carboxylic acid-derivatized alkanethiols in mixed SAM systems [117,118,123]. 2.5
Mixed Monolayers
The study of mixed alkanethiol SAMs has been driven in large part by the possibility of advanced technological applications that may require systematic control over interfacial ¢lm properties. Early investigations of the simplest mixed SAM systems involved the co-adsorption of binary mixtures of alkanethiols (or dialkyldisul¢des) on Au, and centered on mixtures containing either di¡ering terminal groups (CH3 versus OH) [42,44], di¡ering chain-length components [43,128], or both [129,130]. In many of these early studies, changes in ¢lm properties were monitored by examining variations in ellipsometric ¢lm thickness, contact angle, or vibrational peak positions=intensities as a function of alkanethiol solution mole ratio. For SAMs composed of di¡ering-chain-length alkanethiols only, Bain et al. concluded that the ¢lms consisted of a densely packed molecular region near the Au surface and a disordered outer region in contact with the deposition solution [43,128]. Thus, by varying the solution ratio of the two components, the degree of disorder at the ¢lm=solution interface could be reproducibly controlled. Preferential adsorption of the longer-chain component was
78
Niki and Gregory
observed from ethanolic solutions (due to a somewhat low solution solubility), and substantial variations in ¢lm composition with solvent were noted, both arguing in favor of thermodynamic control of the composition of the SAM [43]. Although large-scale phase segregation into single-component domains was not observed in these studies, the authors speculated as to the improbability of a completely random distribution of both components in the ¢lm. Similar conclusions regarding component distributions within these ¢lms have been made in studies of mixed-composition SAMs fabricated either from mixtures of alkanethiols di¡ering in their terminal functionalities [42,131], or from asymmetric disul¢des having di¡erent end groups [131]. Additionally, a systematic investigation of equimolar, binary mixtures of HOCH2^(CH2)15SH and CH3^(CH2)(15 þ m)SH (where 6 < m < 6) self-assembled onto Au from ethanolic solutions have led to a general structural model in which the ¢lm organization evolves from one exhibiting random mixing (at low m) to one evidencing phase segregation (at high m) [130]. Electrochemical methods have been recently employed to address issues of phase segregation in mixed SAMs, and have taken advantage of the fact that reduction potentials (which result in desorption) of the alkanethiols in strongly basic solution are dependent on both alkyl chain length [99^105] and terminal functionality [104,105]. The obvious utility underlying an electrochemical approach to such a problem lies both in its ability to distinguish between and to quantify such components at the surface. Nishizawa et al. have examined the electrochemical desorption of a SAM formed from a binary mixture of 3-mercaptopropionic acid (3MPA) and C16SH, which differ signi¢cantly both in alkyl chain length and in the nature of the end group [132]. In these studies, two separate cathodic stripping peaks were observed, and were attributed to reductive desorption of each component separately, implying phase segregation of the components within the ¢lm [132]. Longer exposure times to the deposition solution were shown to yield mixed ¢lms exhibiting larger fractions of C16SH. Furthermore, porous SAMs could be generated through selective desorption of the more positive desorption feature (belonging to the shorter-chain component, 3MPA)[132]. In contrast, based on measured oxidation peak currents for cyt c and FeðCNÞ4 6 as a function of C18SH mole fraction in binary SAMs of 3MPA and C18SH on Au, Sato et al. concluded that rather uniform mixing of the co-adsorbed thiols was occurring [133]. This was corroborated with the observation that although two separate reductive desorption peaks were seen in the mixed monolayer, the one attributed to 3MPA shifted to more negative potentials as the fraction of C18SH increased [133]. Arnold et al. have demonstrated (also via electrochemical desorption) the presence of homogeneous mixing in binary alkanethiol SAMs whose components exhibit similar chain lengths
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
79
but highly dissimilar end groups (CH3 versus COOH) [134]. Subsequent approaches to electrochemically mediated, selective removal of constituents from phase-segregated SAMs have led to methods for their selective replacement [135^137]. Questions of miscibility and lateral distribution within various mixed SAMs have also been addressed recently by high-spatial-resolution techniques such as STM, which yield real-space structural information at the molecular level. This is particularly important since many of the aforementioned methods for analyzing ¢lm composition and distribution yield information about the macroscopic properties of the ¢lm. Stranick et al. observed phase separation by STM in binary mixed monolayers of C16SH and CH3O2C ^ C15SH on Au, resulting in the formation of nanometer-scale domains [138]. These components, di¡ering only in the nature of their end groups, were chosen based not only on their inability to hydrogen-bond but also on their identical hydrocarbon chain lengths. The authors concluded that the phase-separation process must be driven entirely by terminalgroup interactions, despite the fact that di¡erences in their relative interaction strengths must be small. Further studies by Stranick et al. with mixed monolayers having di¡ering end groups (including OH and CN) have also demonstrated some phase separation [139]. Internal functionalization has also been shown to drive the phase-separation process in binary mixed SAMs of internally functionalized alkanethiols (e.g., amide-containing alkanethiols) and nonfunctionalized alkanethiols (e.g., C10SH) [140]. 3 3.1
SAM/PROTEIN FILMS Voltammetric Studies
3.1.1 Cytochrome c at Bare Electrodes Cytochrome c in solution often exhibits an irreversible voltammetric response at gold electrodes, and an adsorbed layer of cyt c on an electrode surface blocks the ET reaction of cyt c in solution. The only exception to this involves cytochromes c3 extracted from the sulfate-reducing bacteria Desulfo vibrio [3]. This unique class of heme proteins contains four hemes in the molecule and exhibits a reversible voltammetric response at various electrode materials without surface modi¢ers [3]. Hinnen and Niki examined the formal potential of horse heart cyt c adsorbed on polycrystalline gold, ruthenium, and glassy carbon electrodes by electrore£ectance (ER) voltammograms. The formal potential was measured to be around 0.18 V (versus NHE) in 30 mM phosphate bu¡er at pH 7.0, which is 0.44 V more negative than that of the native one; however, the adsorbed cyt c undergoes a
80
Niki and Gregory
rapid (reversible) ET reaction at this potential [141,142]. On the other hand, the formal potential of cyt c3 adsorbed on metal electrodes is nearly the same as that of the native protein in solution [143]. 3.1.2 Proteins Immobilized Electrostatically on Self-Assembled Monolayers Cytochrome c at 4,40 -Bypyridine and 4-Pyridinethiol SAMs. Hinnen and Niki [142] and Sagara et al. [144] studied the interfacial properties of cyt c at a gold electrode in the presence of various surface modi¢ers by the ER technique and found that there are two types of surface modi¢ers. Cytochrome c immobilized on bis(4-pyridyl) disul¢de (4-PySSPy) or 4-mercaptopyridine (PySH)-modi¢ed gold electrodes undergoes electrode reactions through the layer of the surface modi¢er (SAM ¢lm).The formal potential of cyt c immobilized on the 4-pyridinethiolate SAM is slightly more negative than that of the native one.On the other hand, the formal potential of cyt c coadsorbed with 4-40 -bipyridine (in 10 mM 4,40 -bipy solution) is 0.03 V (versus NHE), which is about 0.23 V more negative than that of the native one and 0.21 V more positive than that adsorbed on the bare gold electrode. It is also interesting to note that the electrode reaction of cyt c co-adsorbed with 4,40 bipy undergoes a rapid (reversible) electrode reaction at the formal potential in its adsorbed state.The formal potential of cyt c co-adsorbed with 4,40 -bipy on the gold electrode is strongly dependent on the concentration of 4,40 -bipy in solution, and varies from 0.18 V (versus NHE, without 4,40 -bipy) to 0.03 V (saturated 4,40 -bipy solution) [145]. Cytochrome c at Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. Tarlov and Bowden ¢rst demonstrated the feasibility of using carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol SAMs to study the ET reaction of cyt c [146]. Cytochrome c electrostatically immobilized on carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol SAMs exhibits a reversible voltammetric response at its formal potential, but the ET rate constant varies with the chain length of alkanethiols. The formal potential of cyt c depends on the degree of electrostatic interaction between it and the carboxylic acid terminus and on the amount of adsorbed cyt c [7,147^152]; the measured formal potential is shifted negatively by approximately 10^50 mV. The full-width-at-half-maximum peak width of the cyclic voltammogram is somewhat larger than that of the theoretical value, and the deviation from the ideal value has been explained in terms of the distribution of the ET rate constants of cyt c at the SAM surface [148,149,153]. Noting that peak potential separations are always greater than 57 mV and the di¡usion coe⁄cients are smaller than those obtained from studies at simple electrodes, Honeychurch and Rechnitz have analyzed the
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
81
cyclic voltammograms of cyt c in solution at 4-pyridinethiol-modi¢ed gold electrodes by taking into account the potential distribution at the electrode=solution interface [154]. Cytochrome c at Mixed SAMs. Electrode reactions of horse heart cyt c in solution at mixed SAMs of 4-pyridinethiol and methyl-terminated alkanethiols on gold electrodes have been investigated. It was found that the voltammogram becomes sigmoidal with an increase in the fraction of methyl-terminated alkanethiols in the SAMs, and the peak current decreases, accordingly. Alkanethiols with shorter chains were observed to be much more e¡ective at suppressing the peak current than those with longer chains. This is likely due to island formation in the mixed SAMs, which results from weak interaction between 4-pyridinethiol and the long-chain alkanethiols (or due to the strong lateral interactions between long-chain alkanethiols) [155]. On the other hand, the e¡ect was pronounced as n increased from 3 to 18 in the mixed SAMs of HOOC(CH2)2SH and HOOC(CH2)nSH [156]. These results can be explained in terms of the stability of n-alkanethiol SAMs: shorter-chain alkanethiols produce a less stable SAM layer because the hydrophobic e¡ect is smaller [157]. Cytochrome b5 and Enzymes at Poly-L-Lysine=Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMS. A monolayer of cyt b5 exhibits a well-de¢ned voltammetric response at multilayers of cationic poly-L -lysine=carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol-modi¢ed gold electrodes in 8.8 mM phosphate bu¡er solution at pH 7.0 [158]. Its formal potential was 0.040 V (versus NHE), which is about 30 mV more positive than the native one in the same solution. The measured ET rate of cyt b5 through the multilayer was 1.2 0.3 s1. Both glucose oxidase (GOD) [159] and lactate oxidase [160] immobilized on poly-L -lysine-covered carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol SAMs show voltammetric responses and exhibit linear relationships with their substrates up to 2 and 0.2 mM respectively. Glucose Oxidase Immobilized on DTSSP and DSP SAMs. Glucose oxidase immobilized at SAMs of either 3,30 -dithiobis-sulfocinnimidylpropionate (DTSSP) or dithiobis(cinnimidylpropionate) (DSP) undergoes a reversible charge transfer reaction at E1=2 0:282 V (versus Ag=AgCl), and its ET rate constant has been estimated to be 0.026 s1 [161]. Enhancement of the oxidation current of the GOD=DTSSP=Au assembly (on addition of glucose) was observed under anaerobic conditions. Immobilization of
82
Niki and Gregory
FAD on the DTSSP-modi¢ed gold surface gives rise to well-de¢ned, reversible electrochemistry at E1=2 ¼ 0.395 V (versus Ag=AgCl) [161]. 3.1.3 Immobilized Proteins Covalently Attached to Self-Assembled Monolayers Cytochrome c. Collinson and Bowden studied cyt c covalently attached to HOOC(CH2)15SH=Au electrodes via an electrostatically guided carbodiimide coupling. The cyclic volammetric results revealed that the coverage of electrochemically active cyt c was about one-third monolayer and the formal potential was slightly more negative than that in the solution. The ET rate constants of cyt c immobilized electrostatically and bonded covalently to HOOC(CH2)15S=Au electrode were almost the same [147]. Cytochrome c Oxidase. Dong and co-workers have reported that cyt c oxidase covalently bonded to a HOOC(CH2)2S=Au electrode by a carbodiimide coupling exhibits a reversible voltammetric response due to the redox reaction of cyt a3 in the molecule and can mediate the redox reaction of cyt c in the solution [162]. The ET rate constant depends strongly on the ionic strength and composition of the supporting electrolyte. Spatially Ordered Catalytic Enzyme Assemblies on Electrodes. Redox enzymes organized onto electrodes as monolayer assemblies with covalently attached redox relay groups yield electrochemically active enzyme electrodes exhibiting bioelectrocatalytic features [163]. Enzymes or proteins have been covalently bonded to SAMs on electrodes via (1) coupling of the carboxylic acid termini of SAMs on electrodes (or their active esters) to lysine residues of the proteins, (2) direct coupling of the amine termini of SAMs to glutamic=aspartic residues of proteins, (3) or stepwise coupling of the lysine residues of an enzyme to the SAMs by bifunctional reagents. For example, enzyme electrodes consisting of glutathione reductase coupled to a carboxylic acid-functionalized monolayer via lysine residues (surface coverage is 2 1011 mol cm2) have been electrically contacted with the electrode via covalently attached N-methyl-N0 -carboxyalkyl-4,40 -bipyridium electron relay units. Several methods have been developed to increase biocatalytic activities of enzyme electrodes.One approach includes the assembly of an enzyme multilayer network on the electrode surface. Other methods to assemble multilayer enzyme electrodes include the interlayer linkage of the enzyme layers by biotin ^ avidin, antibody ^ antigen, or lectin ^ sugar interactions [164].
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
3.2
83
Structural Studies
3.2.1 Orientation of the Prosthetic Group Cytochrome c. Yeast cyt c has been covalently bound to the surface of multilayer ¢lms consisting of even numbers of arachidic acid monolayers (COOH groups are exposed at the surface) plus a surface monolayer of thioethyl stearate. Optical linear dichromism was used to determine the average orientation of the heme group within cyt c relative to the multilayer surface plane. Orientations of the heme were observed to be similar for both electrostatically immobilized (on the acid terminus of the multilayer) and covalently bound yeast cyt c; in both cases, the heme was observed to be nearly co-planar with the surface plane [165,166]. Glass slides or Ge=Si multilayer substrates coated with a covalently bound SAM (11-siloxyundecanethiol, which exposes a free thiol end group) covalently binds yeast cyt c molecules through the cysteine-102 residue, forming a disul¢de linkage. The cyt c monolayer binds to the surface at approximately closed-packed inplane densities, and also binds photosynthetic reaction centers electrostatically [167]. The orientation distribution of the heme group in adsorbed cyt c was determined by a combination of absorption linear dichromism and emission anisotropy. A Langmuir-Blodgett ¢lm consisting of three layers of cadmium arachidate, followed by a single arachidic acid layer, were ¢rst deposited on silicon oxynitride or sol-gel glass planar waveguides [168,169]. Electrostatic adsorption of the positively charged protein (cyt c) to the negatively charged head group of the exterior arachidic acid monolayer resulted in a narrow orientation distribution of the heme (tilt angle ¼ 46 6 ). Cytochrome b5. Sligar and co-workers have successfully utilized denovo gene synthesis to selectively modify the properties of cyt b5 building blocks, to allow fundamental measurements of ET and construction of mesoscale biological assemblies with de¢ned two-dimensional orientation and structure [170^174]. A unique surface cysteine residue was introduced into the cyt b5 surface by genetic engineering techniques, and this cysteine was used to covalently attach the protein to a silica surface derivatized with a thiol-reactive alkylsilane, or to atomically £at gold on mica. Linkers have included alkyl chains with a terminal halide to provide the electrophilic center for protein derivatization. Surface coverages are typically greater than 90%. TheT65C mutant of cyt b5 (threonine-65 is replaced by cysteine) has been covalently attached through Cys-65 to bromine-terminated alkanethiol SAMs on gold electrodes; however, no voltammetric response was obtained [173]. The heme orientation of these mutants was determined by linear dichromism. TheT8C (threonine-8 is replaced by cysteine) and T65C
84
Niki and Gregory
cyt b5 mutants exhibit very distinct linear dichromism e¡ects, with opposite relative signs for the optical signal representing parallel minus perpendicular light component absorption. The average tilt angles forT8C and T65C lie on either side of 54.7 [172]. Myoglobin. Myoglobin (Mb), modi¢ed by site-directed mutagenesis to include a unique cysteine residue, covalently binds selectively to selfassembled haloalkylsilylated silica surfaces. The Mb A126C (alanine-126 in myoglobin is replaced by cysteine) orients the heme plane nearly parallel to the point of attachment, thereby producing alignment of the heme prosthetic group essentially consistent with the surface normal. The results indicate that on average, the heme normal of Mb A126C is oriented 44 2 relative to the surface normal [174]. 3.2.2 The Spin State of the Heme Chromophore: SERRS (SERS) Studies Cytochrome c at Silver Electrodes. Hildebrandt and Stockburger have extensively studied the conformation and redox properties of horse heart cyt c adsorbed on silver electrodes by surface-enhanced resonance Raman scattering (SERRS), and have found that cyt c exhibits various conformational states upon adsorption on the bare silver electrode [175^180]. An adsorption-induced transformation from the six-coordinate low-spin state (6cLS) to the ¢ve-coordinate high-spin state (5cHS) was observed.The formal potential of the 5cHS state was estimated to be 0.17 V, in agreement with results obtained by Hinnen and Niki [141,142]. The SERRS spectrum of cyt c immobilized on a carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol modi¢ed gold or silver electrode reveals that both oxidized and reduced forms of cyt c are in the 6cLS state [181,182], and that its formal potential is 0.26 V (versus NHE) in 10 mM phosphate bu¡er solution at pH 7.0 [147,149]. These results strongly support the retention of the native state of cyt c on the carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol modi¢ed electrodes. Song et al. reported the formal potential of cyt c of the cyt c=HOOC(CH2)nSH=Au (n ¼ 5, 10, and 15) system to be 0.215 V in 4.4 mM phosphate bu¡er solution at pH 7.0 [148]. Cytochrome c in the Presence of 4,40 -Bipyridine. Fan et al. studied the conformation of pyridine derivatives by SERS at a silver electrode in the presence of cyt c [181].When 4,40 -bipy-modi¢ed silver electrodes are transferred to a cyt c solution, 4,40 -bipy is partially displaced by cyt c from the electrode and a mixed adsorbed layer of 4,40 -bipy and cyt c is formed. The spin state of the co-adsorbed cyt c with 4,40 -bipy is a mixture of the 5cHS and 6cLS states, and the formal potential of the co-adsorbed cyt c is 0 V (versus NHE).
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
85
Cytochrome c at Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. The SERRS spectrum of cyt c immobilized on carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol-modi¢ed gold or silver electrodes reveals that both oxidized and reduced forms of cyt c are in the 6cLS state [182,183], and that its formal potential is 0.26 V (verus NHE) in 10 mM phosphate bu¡er solution at pH 7.0 [150,184]. These results strongly support the retention of the native state of cyt c on the carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol-modi¢ed electrodes. The electrostatic binding of cyt c to the SAM-modi¢ed electrode yields a highly oriented con¢gurational state with the heme edge directed toward the electrode surface [152]. On the other hand, covalent binding of cyt c to the carboxylic acid-terminated SAM-modi¢ed electrode yields a randomly oriented con¢gurational state with no preferred direction between the heme edge and the electrode surface [152]. Cytochrome c3 at 4,40 -Bipyridyl and Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. The SERS bands attributable to both cyt c3 (a tetraheme protein,with the hemes well exposed to the solvent) from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans (Norway strain) and 4,40 -bipy suggest that 4,40 -bipy is coadsorbed with cyt c3 on the silver electrode surface [185]. Ferri-cyt c3 exists in the mixed 6cLS and 5cHS spin state, which is similar to that observed in the absence of 4,40 -bipy. The transformation from the oxidized form (the mixed-spin state) to the reduced form (6cLS state) is completed at 0.0 V (versus NHE), which is 0.2 V more positive than the formal potential of the most positive redox site of the native cyt c3. The intensity of the SERRS spectrum of the cyt c3 co-adsorbed with 4,40 -bipy in the low-frequency region (370^430 nm) is considerably weak compared to that for RRS in solution. These results suggest that 4,40 -bipy has a signi¢cant e¡ect on the heme environment of the adsorbed cyt c3. The formal potential of cyt c3 coadsorbed with 4,40 -bipy is monitored by the shift of the oxidation-state marker band, which becomes more positive with increasing concentrations of 4,40 -bipy. The shift of the formal potential may be explained in terms of a decrease in the solvent exposure of the heme due to increased shielding of the exposed heme edge by 4,40 -bipy molecules. Both SERRS and ER voltammetric techniques have been used to investigate the e¡ect of surface modi¢ers [11-mercaptoundecanoic acid (11MUDA) and 4,40 -bipy] on the structure and redox properties of cyt c3 at a silver electrode [185]. The ER voltammograms of cyt c3 immobilized on 11MUDA exhibit a small hysteresis between the forward and backward potential scans, suggesting that the redox process is reversible and cyt c3 retains its native structure. The SERRS spectra of cyt c3 (both oxidized and reduced forms) immobilized on 11-MUDA clearly indicate that the hemes are in the 6cLS state. The formal potential of cyt c3 immobilized on the
86
Niki and Gregory
11-MUDA-modi¢ed silver electrode was monitored by the shift of the oxidation-state marker band and is 0.20 V (versus NHE) , which is about 0.10 V more negative than that observed on a bare silver electrode [144]. 3.3
Electron Transfer Kinetics of Proteins at Modified Electrodes
Intermolecular ET processes between the positively charged and negatively charged sites of electron-transfer protein molecules such as cyt c=cyt b2 [186] cyt c=cyt c peroxidase [187], cyt c plastcyanine [188^190], and cyt c=cyt b5 [191^194] couples have been investigated in solutions having di¡erent ionic strength, pH, and viscosity. E¡ects of solution viscosity on the con¢gurational rearrangement reaction rate between ETprotein complexes have been studied theoretically [195,196] and experimentally [188^192,194,197^200]. The nonuniform charge distributions on the surface of protein molecules often lead to multiple con¢gurational states in the protein coupling. The initial step in the formation of the protein complex is a nonspeci¢c electrostatic association between the two proteins, followed by rotational di¡usion on the molecular surface to reach the proper con¢guration for the ET event. When the protein couple forms multiple con¢gurations, the intermolecular ET rate is limited by the rotational di¡usion of the molecules. This process can be viewed as directional ET regulated by a ‘‘gating mechanism’’ [186^ 189,191^194,201^213]. Intermolecular ET rates depend strongly on the ionic strength, pH, and temperature of the solution and are reported to be in the range of 103^105 s1. Details of the molecular structure of such complexes and intermolecular ET reactions have not been fully understood by using physiological redox complexes because of the complexity of biological systems. In electrochemical systems, on the other hand, the electrodes act as both electron acceptor and electron donor, and are considered to be a simple model system to mimic a charged interface of the physiological binding domain. The electrode reaction of cyt c immobilized electrostatically to carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol SAMs is considered to be the simplest model for biological ET processes. The advantages of an electrochemical approach to investigate the ETmechanism are that one can regulate the ETpath length by using alkanethiol SAMs of varying chain lengths and deconvolute the intermolecular ET event at the interface from the intramolecular ET event, provided that one can measure ET rate constants up to 105 s1. The charging current of the electrical double layer at the electrode interface limits the measurable ET rate when traditional electrochemical techniques (cyclic voltammetry and AC impedance) are used. At well-de¢ned surfaces having geometric areas of approximately1 cm2, the fastest reliable ETrates that have
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
87
been reported are around 100 s1, which are much slower than intermolecular ET rates for protein complexes [188,189,194,201,202]. Thus, it is di⁄cult to measure intermolecular ETevents by traditional electrochemical techniques. The UV-visible potential-modulated re£ectance (ER) spectroscopic technique, on the other hand, involves the measurement of a faradaic current as an optical response generated by an AC modulation of the electrode potential, and the e¡ect of double-layer charging on the optical response can be minimized [214].This technique enables one to measure ET rates up to approximately 10 4 s1. 3.3.1 Electron Transfer Reaction Rates Through Alkanethiol SAMs Horse Heart Cytochrome c at Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. It has been shown that the long-range ET rate between metal electrodes and electroactive species through alkanethiol SAMs decreases with the chain length of the SAM [13,150,215^219]. For these systems, the ET reaction rate constant at the binding site between cyt c and the carboxylate terminus depends on the number of methylene groups n in the alkyl chain: ks ¼ kðn¼0Þ expðbnÞ
ð4Þ
where k(n ¼ 0) is the apparent ET rate constant extrapolated to n ¼ 0 [220]. The exponential decay factor b has been found to be 1.09 0.02 per methylene group regardless of the type of redox species at the terminus of alkanethiol SAMs when n 10 [13,150,215^219]. The ET reaction rates between cyt c (horse heart) and a Au(111) electrode through carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol [HOOC(CH2)nSH] self-assembled monolayers have been measured by the ER technique as a function of the chain length of alkanethiols (n ¼ 2 ^ 11) [214,221]. The ET reaction rate constant decreases exponentially with the chain length as shown in Fig. 2, and the exponential decay factor given by the Marcus theory is b ¼ 1.09 0.02 per methylene group (0.71 0.01 —1). The ET rates through the long-chain alkanethiol SAMs are controlled by the ET rates through the alkyl chain. The ET reaction rates through the short-chain alkanethiol monolayers, on the other hand, are nearly independent of the chain length. It has been assumed that there is a con¢gurational rearrangement of cyt c on the SAM prior to the ET reaction. Given by reaction (5), a thermodynamically stable adsorbed structure of cyt c(ox)(I), which is formed upon the adsorption of cyt c from the solution to the carboxylate termini, undergoes a con¢gurational rearrangement to cyt c(ox)(II), at which the most e⁄cient ET reaction takes place [given by reaction (6)]. The ET reaction is followed by a second con¢gurational rearrangement given by reaction (7) to form a thermodynamically stable binding state, cyt c(red)(I). The rate-controlling step of the ET reaction through
88
Niki and Gregory
FIG. 2 Logarithmic plot of the ET rate constant (ket) of horse heart cyt c through carboxylate-terminated alkanethiol SAMs on a Au electrode with respect to alkanethiol chain length n: ( ) data from Ref. 3 in 10 mM phosphate buffer solution at pH 7.0; (~) data from Ref. 19 in 4.4 mM phosphate buffer solution at pH 5.
short alkanethiol chains is very likely to be the conformational rearrangement of cyt c on the SAM surface given by reaction (5), and the transformation rate constant k1 of the forward reaction is estimated to be 2.6 103 s1. k1
* cyt cðoxÞðIIÞ cyt cðoxÞðIÞ ) k2
kf
* cyt cðredÞðIIÞ cyt cðoxÞðIIÞ þ e ) k3
kb
* cyt cðredÞðIÞ cyt cðredÞðIIÞ )
ð5Þ ð6Þ ð7Þ
k4
The transformation rate constant k1 is markedly suppressed with increasing solution viscosity, and accords with the intermolecular ETrate of the protein couple limited by the rotational di¡usion of the molecules [221]. The ET rate through longer-chain alkanethiols decreases with increasing ionic strength
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
89
or decreasing pH of the solution. The rate-limiting ET step through short alkyl chains results from a con¢gurational rearrangement process of cyt c from a stable binding form on the carboxylic acid terminus to a con¢guration which facilitates the most e⁄cient ET pathway, and is represented by reaction (5) [221]. It is possible to elucidate the binding site of cyt c(ox)(II) that facilitates the most e⁄cient ET pathway from the extrapolated value of ks to n ¼ 0 at low ionic strength, the value of which is about 5 10 6 s1.The ETrates from the heme edge to various lysine residues on the surface of cyt c can be estimated from the results of Gray and Winkler [222], and the intramolecular ET rate from the heme edge to lysine-13 is estimated to be 2 105 s1. It is very probable that Lys-13 hydrogen bonds to the carboxylate terminus of the alkanethiol SAMs. The ET rate constant of RC9-K13A (lysine-13 of rat cyt c, RC9, is replaced by alanine) of rat cyt c expressed in yeast [223] immobilized on 3mercaptopropionic acid SAMs on gold electrodes was measured to be 0.2 0.05 s1 [224]. In contrast, the ET rate of native horse heart cyt c at 3-mercaptopropionic acid SAMs on gold electrodes has been estimated to be 8.4 105 s1 from Fig. 2. This result suggests that Lys-86 is a potential candidate to facilitate the ETpathway of RC9-K13A cyt c. Iso-1 Cytochrome c at Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. Cytochrome c extracted from yeast (iso-1 cyt c) exhibits a di¡erent kinetic nature from that of horse heart cyt c at carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol-modi¢ed gold electrodes. While the three-dimensional structures of iso-1 cyt c and horse heart cyt c are very similar, the ET rate of iso-1 cyt c is approximately three times slower than that of horse heart cyt c [225]. The exponential decay factor of the ET rates through longer alkyl chains (n ¼ 7 and 10) is similar to that of horse heart cyt c. The slow ET rate may be explained by assuming the ET pathway that lies from the heme edge to the carboxylic acid terminus of the SAM occurs via Lys-11of iso-1cyt c [224]. This is likely due to the inability of Arg-13 to form stable hydrogen bonds to the carboxylic acid terminus of the alkanethiol because of its resonance structure. Cytochrome c at Mixed Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs: The ET rate constants of cyt c (horse heart) immobilized on mixed SAMs of carboxylic acid- and methyl-terminated alkanethiols [HOOC(CH2)10SH= CH3(CH2)9SH] with varying mole fractions were determined by the ER spectroscopic technique [134].The mixed monolayers were co-deposited from ethanolic solutions containing both components at speci¢c mole fractions. The mixed monolayers were found to be homogeneous, with compositions that were very similar to those in the solution
90
Niki and Gregory
phase. The ET rate constant showed a maximum when the mole fraction of the carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiol was 0.8, and was approximately six times faster than one comprised only of HS(CH2)10 COOH. Bowden and co-workers have reported an interesting result obtained for the voltammetry of horse heart and yeast cyt c immobilized at mixed SAMs [225].With horse heart cyt c, the ET rate constant through the mixed SAM deposited from a solution containing an equimolar mixture of HS(CH2)10COOH and HS(CH2)8OH (the composition of the SAM on the electrode is considered to be an equimolar mixture) is approximately ¢ve times faster than one comprised only of HS(CH2)10COOH. In contrast, with yeast cyt c, there is a 2500-fold rate enhancement when switching to the mixed HS(CH2)10COOH= HS(CH2)7OH monolayer (again considered to be a 1:1 mixture). The two proteins have similar ET reorganization energies and surface charge distributions, but there are large di¡erences in amino acid composition that may a¡ect the ETcoupling to the electrode. Cytochrome c Covalently Attached to Carboxylic Acid-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. Collinson et al. measured the ETrate of cyt c covalently attached to 16-mercaptohexadecanoic acid SAMs on gold by cyclic voltammetry and found that the ET rate is similar to that for cyt c immobilized electrostatically on the same electrode [147]. Cytochrome c at N-Acetylcysteine-Modified Electrodes. Ruzgas et al. proposed a modi¢ed approach to evaluate the ET rate constant of cyt c at modi¢ed electrodes from the ER response [151]. The ET rate constant evaluated by using the modi¢ed equivalent circuit, however, was unreasonably small. In contrast, the ET rate constant evaluated by using the equation of Feng et al. [214] was reasonable. Cytochrome c at Hydroxy-Terminated Alkanethiol SAMs. Miller and co-workers studied the electrode reactions of horse heart, tuna, and yeast cyt c in solution at hydroxy-terminated alkanethiol-modi¢ed gold electrodes to determine thermodynamic and kinetic parameters [226]. Well-de¢ned voltammograms were obtained at HO(CH2)3SH SAMs, whereas those at HO(CH2)11SH SAMs were drawn out and ill-de¢ned. After corrections for di¡usion limitation and double-layer charging, the kinetic parameters were calculated and it was concluded that the reorganization energies and the maximum ET rates among these cyts c were indistinguishable. However, both the calculated reorganization energies and di¡usion coe⁄cients of the cyts c in this study di¡er signi¢cantly from the results of others [220,227].
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films
91
3.3.2 Azurin Immobilized (by Hydrophobic Interaction) on Hexanethiol SAMs The ER spectroscopic technique has been applied to the study of the redox reaction kinetics of the blue copper protein azurin. Azurin was irreversibly adsorbed on the hexanethiol SAM by hydrophobic interactions; the SAM itself was deposited on a polycrystalline gold electrode from 1^5 mM ethanolic solutions of hexanethiol. Azurin adsorbed on the SAM was shown to be intact and electrochemically reversible [228]. The formal potential of the adsorbed azurin was 95 8 mV (versus Ag=AgCl), which is nearly identical to that of the native azurin in solution. The ETrate was determined by cyclic voltammetry, AC impedance techniques, and ER spectroscopy. The ET rate constants determined byAC impedance and ER techniques were 300 s1 and 150^200 s1, respectively, which were considerably higher than the values determined voltammetrically (4^12 s1). The disparity between the ET rates measured voltammetrically and by ER suggests that the redox reaction may not be a single-step process.The reorganization energy determined from the temperature dependence was found to be l ¼ 1 0.2 eV with a frequency factor 2.2 10 6 s1. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4.
P Yeh,T Kuwana. Chem Lett 1145, 1977. MA Eddows, HAO Hill. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 722:772^773, 1977. K Niki,T Yagi, H Inokuchi, K Kimura. J Electrochem Soc 124:1889, 1977. I Taniguchi, K Toyosawa, H Yamaguchi, K Yasukouchi. J Chem Soc Chem Commun. 1032, 1982. 5. I Taniguchi, K Toyosawa, H Yamaguchi, K Yasukouchi. J Electroanal Chem 140:187, 1982. 6. FA Armstrong. Struct Bond 72:137, 1990, and references therein. 7. FA Armstrong, GS Wilson. Electrochim Acta 45:2623, 2000, and references therein. 8. MJ Tarlov, EF Bowden. J Am Chem Soc 113:1847, 1991. 9. FM Hawkridge, I Taniguchi. Comments Inorg Chem 17:163, 1995. 10. A Ulman. An Introduction to Ultrathin Organic Films. San Diego, CA: Academic, 1991, and references therein. 11. A Ulman. Chem Rev 96:1533, 1996. 12. LH Dubois, RG Nuzzo. Annu Rev Phys Chem 43:437, 1992. 13. HO Finklea. In AJ Bard, I Rubinstein, eds. Electroanalytical Chemistry. Vol. 19. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1996, pp 109^335, and references therein. 14. GE Poirier. Chem Rev 97:1117, 1997. 15. A Ulman, ed. Self-Assembled Monolayers of Thiols. Thin Films. Vol. 24. San Diego, CA: Academic, 1998. 16. GM Whitesides, JP Mathias, CT Seto. Science 254:1312, 1991.
92 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31.
32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50.
Niki and Gregory GM Whitesides, EE Simanek, JP Mathias, CT Seto, DN Chin, M Mammen, DM Gordon. Accts Chem Res 28:37, 1995. J Cheng, G Sa'ghi-Szabo¤, JA Tossell, CJ Miller. J Am Chem Soc 118:680, 1996. JN Richardson, SR Peck, LS Curtin, LM Tender, RH Terrill, MT Carter, RW Murray, GK Rowe, SE Creager. J Phys Chem 99:766, 1995. PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides. J Am Chem Soc 114:9022, 1992. PE Laibinis, BJ Palmer, S-W Lee, GK Jennings. In: A Ulman, ed. Self-Assembled Monolayers of Thiols. Thin Films. Vol. 24. San Diego, CA: Academic, 1998, and references therein. SE Creager, LA Hockett, GK Rowe. Langmuir 8:854, 1992. L-H Guo, JS Facci, G McLendon, R Mosher. Langmuir 10:4588, 1994. CD Bain, EB Troughton, Y-T Tao, J Evall, GM Whitesides, RG Nuzzo. J Am Chem Soc 111:321, 1989. M Buck, F Eisert, J Fischer, M Grunze, F Tra«ger. Appl Phys A 53:552, 1991. M Buck. Appl Phys A 55:395, 1992. M Buck, F Eisert, J Fischer, M Grunze, F Tra«ger. J Vacuum Sci Technol A 10:926, 1992. G Ha«hner, Ch Wo«ll, M Buck, M Grunze. Langmuir 9:1955, 1993. RC Thomas, L Sun, RM Crooks, AJ Ricco. Langmuir 7:620, 1991. DS Karpovich, GJ Blanchard. Langmuir 10:3315, 1994. DS Karpovich, HM Schessler, GJ Blanchard. In: A Ulman, ed. Self-Assembled Monolayers of Thiols. Thin Films.Vol. 24. San Diego, CA: Academic, 1998, p 43. KD Truong, PA Rowntree. J Phys Chem 100:19917, 1996. GE Poirier, ED Plyant. Science 272:1145, 1996. GE Poirier. Langmuir 15:1167, 1999. R Yamada, K Uosaki. Langmuir 14:855, 1998. J Noh,T Murase, K Nakajima, H Lee, M Hara. J Phys Chem B 104:7411, 2000. N Camillone III,TYB Leung, P Schwartz, P Eisenberger, G Scoles. Langmuir 12:2737, 1996. P Schwartz, F Schreiber, P Eisenberger, G Scoles. Surface Sci 423:208, 1999. DM Collard, MA Fox. Langmuir 7:1193, 1991. JB Schleno¡, M Li, H Ly. J Am Chem Soc 117:12528, 1995. Y-T Tao, K Pandian,W-C Lee. J Am Chem Soc 122:7072, 2000. CD Bain, J Evall, GM Whitesides. J Am Chem Soc 111:7155, 1989. CD Bain, GM Whitesides. J Am Chem Soc 111:7164, 1989. CD Bain, HA Beibuyck, GM Whitesides. Langmuir 5:723, 1989. RG Nuzzo, BR Zegarski, LH Dubois. J Am Chem Soc 109:733, 1987. RG Nuzzo, FA Fusco, DL Allara. J Am Chem Soc 109:2358, 1987. PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides, DL Allara, Y-T Tao, AM Parikh, RG Nuzzo. J Am Chem Soc 113:7152, 1991. MM Walczak, CA Alves, BD Lamp, MD Porter. J Electroanal Chem 396:103, 1995. DE Weisshaar, BD Lamp, MD Porter. J Am Chem Soc 114:5860, 1992. RG Nuzzo, LH Dubois, DL Allara. J Am Chem Soc 112:558, 1990.
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films 51. 52. 53. 54. 55.
56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79.
93
PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides, DL Allara, Y-T Tao, AN Parikh, RG Nuzzo. J Am Chem Soc 113:7152, 1991. MA Bryant, JE Pemberton. J Am Chem Soc 113:3629, 1991. MA Bryant, JE Pemberton. J Am Chem Soc 113:8284, 1991. P Fenter. In: A Ulman, ed. Self-Assembled Monolayers of Thiols. Thin Films. Vol. 24. San Diego, CA: Academic, 1998, and references therein. TM Schultz. 2 and 3 dimensional systems studied using X-ray crystallographic techniques. PhD thesis, Riso National Laboratory and Aarhus University, 1998. AL Harris, CED Chidsey, NJ Levinos, DN Loiacono. Chem Phys Lett 141:350, 1987. MS Yeganeh, SM Dougal, RS Polizzotti, P Rabinowitz. Phys Rev Lett 74:1811, 1995. G Ha«hner, M Kinzler, C Thu«mmler, ChWo«ll, M Grunze. J Vacuum Sci Technol A 10:2758, 1992. A-S Duwez, S Di Paolo, J Ghijsen, J Riga, M Deleuze, J Delhalle. J Phys Chem B 101:884, 1997. MD Porter, TB Bright, DL Allara, CED Chidsey. J Am Chem Soc 109:3559, 1987. SD Evans, A Ulman. Chem Phys Lett 170:462, 1990. S Abrahamsson, B Dahle¤n, H Lo«fgren, I Pascher. Prog Chem Fats Other Lipids 16:125, 1978. GE Poirier, MJ Tarlov. Langmuir 10:2853, 1994. GE Poirier, MJ Tarlov. Langmuir 10:3383, 1994. GE Poirier, MJ Tarlov, HE Rushmeier. Langmuir 10:3383, 1994. N Camillone III, P Eisenberger,TYB Leung, P Schwartz, G Scoles, GE Poirier, MJ Tarlov. J Chem Phys 101:11031, 1994. E Delamarche, B Michel, Ch Gerber, D Anselmetti, H-J Gu«ntherodt, H Wolf, H Ringsdorf. Langmuir 10:2869, 1994. D Anselmetti, A Barato¡, H-J Gu«ntherodt, E Delamarche, B Michel, Ch Gerber, H Kang, H Wolf, H Ringsdorf. Europhys Lett 27:365, 1994. F Tera¤n Arce, ME Vela, RC Salvarezza, AJ Arvia. J Chem Phys 109:5703, 1998. J Kang, PA Rowntree. Langmuir 12:2813, 1996. P Fenter, P Eisenberger, KS Liang. Phys Rev Lett 70:2447, 1993. N Camillone III, CED Chidsey, G-Y Liu, G Scoles. J Chem Phys 98:3503, 1993. LH Dubois, BR Zegarski, RG Nuzzo. J Electron Spectrosc Rel Phenom 54=55:1143, 1990. P Fenter, A Eberhardt, P Eisenberger. Science 266:1216, 1994. P Fenter, F Schreiber, L Berman, G Scoles, P Eisenberger, MJ Bedzyk. Surface Sci 412=413:213, 1998. T Ishida, S Yamamoto, W Mizutani, M Motomatsu, H Tokumoto, H Hokari, H Azehara, M Fujihira. Langmuir 13:3261, 1997. JJ Gerdy,WA Goddard III. J Am Chem Soc 118:3233, 1996. L-J Wan,Y Hara, H Noda, M Osawa. J Phys Chem B 102:5943, 1998. LH Dubois, BR Zegarski, RG Nuzzo. J Chem Phys 98:678, 1993.
94
Niki and Gregory
80. L Strong, GM Whitesides. Langmuir 4:546, 1988. 81. N Camillone III, CED Chidsey, G-Y Liu, G Scoles. J Chem Phys 98:4234, 1993. 82. J Li, KS Liang, N Camillone III,TYB Leung, G Scoles. J Chem Phys 102:5012, 1995. 83. GE Poirier. J Vac Sci Technol B 14:1453, 1996. 84. PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides, DL Allara, Y-T Tao, AN Parikh, RG Nuzzo. J Am Chem Soc 113:7152, 1991. 85. PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides. J Am Chem Soc 114:1990, 1992. 86. GK Jennings, PE Laibinis. J Am Chem Soc 119:5208, 1997. 87. MM Walczak, C Chung, SM Stole, CA Widrig, MD Porter. J Am Chem Soc 113:2370, 1991. 88. R Sobocinski, MA Bryant, JE Pemberton. J Am Chem Soc 112:6177, 1990. 89. M Schoen¢sch, JE Pemberton. Langmuir 15:509, 1999. 90. CJ Sandro¡, S Garo¡, KP Leung. Chem Phys Lett 96:547, 1983. 91. TO Deschaines, KT Carron. Appl Spectrosc 51:1355, 1997. 92. JYGui, DA Stern, DG Frank, F Lu, DC Zapien, AT Hubbard. Langmuir 7:955, 1991. 93. R Heinz, JP Rabe. Langmuir 11:506, 1995. 94. A Dhirani, MA Hines, AJ Fisher, O Ismail, P Guyot-Sionnest. Langmuir 11:2609, 1995. 95. P Fenter, P Eisenberger, J Li, N Camillone III, S Bernasek, G Scoles, TA Ramanarayanan, KS Liang. Langmuir 7:2013, 1991. 96. PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides. J Am Chem Soc 114:9022, 1992. 97. Y Yamamoto, H Nishihara, K Aramaki. J Electrochem Soc 140:436, 1993. 98. CW Sheen, J-X Shi, J Martensson, AN Parikh, DL Allara. J Am Chem Soc 114:1514, 1992. 99. CA Widrig, C Chung, MD Porter. J Electroanal Chem 310:335, 1991. 100. MM Walczak, DD Popenoe, RS Deinhammer, BD Lamp, C Chung, MD Porter. Langmuir 7:2687, 1991. 101. DE Weisshaar, BD Lamp, MD Porter. J Am Chem Soc 114:5860, 1992. 102. C-J Zhong, J Zak, MD Porter. J Electroanal Chem 421:9, 1997. 103. C-J Zhong, MD Porter. J Electroanal Chem 425:147, 1997. 104. S Imabayashi, M Iida, D Hobara, ZQ Feng, K Niki,T Kakiuchi. J Electroanal Chem 428:33, 1997. 105. D Hobara, K Miyake, S Imabayashi, K Niki, T Kakiuchi. Langmuir 14:3590, 1998. 106. TW Schneider, DA Buttry. J Am Chem Soc 115:12391, 1993. 107. P Krysinski, RV Chamberlain II, M Majda. Langmuir 10:4286, 1994. 108. BD Lamp, D Hobara, MD Porter, K Niki,TM Cotton. Langmuir 13:736, 1997. 109. I Taniguchi, S Yoshimoto, M Yoshida, S Kobayashi, T Miyawaki, W Aono, Y Sunatsuki, H Taira. Electrochim Acta 45:2843, 2000. 110. T Sawaguchi, F Mizutani, S Yoshimoto, I Taniguchi. Electochim Acta 45:2861, 2000. 111. S Yoshimoto,T Sawaguchi, F Mizutani, I Taniguchi. Electochem Comm 2:39, 2000.
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126. 127.
128. 129. 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144.
95
I Taniguchi. Denki Kagaku 56:158, 1988. C Zhou, S Ye,TM Cotton, X Yu,T Lu, S Dong. J Electroanal Chem 319:71,1991. I Taniguchi, S Yoshimoto, K Nishiyama. Chem Lett 353, 1997. CD Bain, GM Whitesides. Langmuir 5:1370, 1989. EB Troughton, CD Bain, GM Whitesides, RG Nuzzo, DL Allara, MD Porter. Langmuir 4:365, 1988. TR Lee, RI Carey, HA Biebuyck, GM Whitesides. Langmuir 10:741, 1994. SE Creager, J Clarke. Langmuir 10:3675, 1994. HS White, JD Peterson, Q Cui, KJ Stevenson. J Phys Chem B 102:2930, 1998. T Kakiuchi, M Iida, S Imabayashi, K Niki. Langmuir 16:5397, 2000. J Wang, LM Frostman, MD Ward. J Phys Chem 96:5224, 1992. K Shimazu,T Teranishi, K Sugihara, K Uosaki. Chem Lett 669, 1998. K Sugihara and K Shimazu, Annual Meeting of the Electrochemical Society of Japan, Nagaoka, Japan, private communication October 1998. K Hu, AJ Bard. Langmuir 13:5114, 1997. DV Vezenov, A Noy, L Rozsnyai, CM Lieber. J Am Chem Soc 119:2006, 1997. JF Smalley, K Chalfant, SW Feldberg,TM Nahir, EF Bowden. J Phys Chem B 103:1676, 1999. N Simmons, J Zak, CC Wu, MM Walczak, MD Porter. Symposium on Langmuir-Blodgett and Self-assembled Films, abstr 12, 205th ACS National Meeting, Denver, CO, March 1993. PE Laibinis, RG Nuzzo, GM Whitesides. J Phys Chem 96:5097, 1992. JP Folkers, PE Laibinis, GM Whitesides. Langmuir 8:1330, 1992. SVAtre, B Liedberg, DL Allara. Langmuir 11:3882, 1995. T Takami, E Delamarche, B Michel, Ch Gerber, H Wolf, H Ringsdorf. Langmuir 11:3876, 1995. M Nishizawa,T Sunagawa, H Yoneyama. J Electroanal Chem 436:213, 1997. Y Sato, F Mizutani. J Electroanal Chem 438:99, 1997. S Arnold, ZQ Feng,T Kakiuchi,W Knoll, K Niki. J Electroanal Chem 438:91, 1997. S Imabayashi, N Gon, T Sasaki, D Hobara, T Kakiuchi. Langmuir 14:2348, 1998. D Hobara,T Sasaki, S Imabayashi,T Kakiuchi. Langmuir 15:5073, 1999. T Kakiuchi, K Sato, M Iida, D Hobara, S Imabayashi, K Niki. Langmuir 16:7238, 2000. SJ Stranick, AN Parikh,Y-T Tao, DL Allara, PS Weiss. J Phys Chem 98:7636, 1994. SJ Stranick, SV Atre, AN Parikh, MC Wood, DL Allara, N Winograd, PS Weiss. Nanotechnology 7:438, 1996. RK Smith, S Reed, J Monnell, PA Lewis, RS Clegg, KF Kelly, LA Bumm, JE Hutchison, PS Weiss. J Phys Chem B, in press. C Hinnen, R Parsons, K Niki. J Electroanal Chem 147:329, 1983. C Hinnen, K Niki. J Electroanal Chem 264:157, 1989. K Niki,Y Kawasaki,Y Kimura,Y Higuchi, N Yasuoka. Langmuir 3:982, 1987. T Sagara, K Niwa, A Sone, C Hinnen, K Niki. Langmuir 6:254, 1990.
96 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150.
Niki and Gregory
T Sagara, H Murakami, S Igarashi, H Sato, K Niki. Langmuir 7:3190, 1991. MJ Tarlov, EF Bowden. J Am Chem Soc 113:1847, 1991. M Collinson, EF Bowden, MJ Tarlov. Langmuir 8:1247, 1992. S Song, RA Clark, EF Bowden, MJ Tarlov. J Phys Chem 97:6564, 1993. RA Clark, EF Bowden. Langmuir 13:559, 1997. Z-Q Feng, S Imabayashi, T Kakiuchi, K Niki. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 93:1367, 1997. 151. T Ruzgas, LWong, AK Gaigalas,VLVilker. Langmuir 14:7298, 1998. 152. LA Dick, AJ Haes, RP Van Duyne. J Phys Chem B 104:11752, 2000. 153. TM Nahir, EF Bowden. J Electroanal Chem 410:9, 1996. 154. MJ Honeychurch, GA Rechnitz. J Phys Chem B 101:7472, 1997. 155. Y Sato, F Mizutani. Denki Kagaku 63:1173, 1995. 156. Y Sato, F Mizutani. J Electroanal Chem 438:99, 1997. 157. KJ Stevenson, M Mitchell, HS White. J Phys Chem B 102:1235, 1998. 158. JDH Glenn, EF Bowden. Chem Lett 399, 1996. 159. F Mizutani,Y Sato, S Yabuki,Y Hirata. Chem Lett 251, 1996. 160. F Mizutani,Y Sato,Y Hirata, S Yabuki. Denki Kagaku 64:1266, 1996. 161. L Jaing, CJ McNeil, JM Cooper. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 1293, 1995. 162. J Li, G Cheng, S Dong. J Electroanal Chem 416:97, 1996. 163. I Willner, E Katz, B Willner. Electroanalysis 9:965, 1997, and references therein. 164. C Bourdillon, C Demaille, J Moiroux, J-M Save¤ant. Accts Chem Res 29:529, 1996, and references therein. 165. JM Pachence, RF Fischetti, JK Blasie. Biophys J 56:327, 1989. 166. JM Pachence, SM Amador, G Maniara, J Vanderkooi, JM Dutton, JK Blasie. Biophys J 58:379, 1990. 167. SM Amador, JM Pachence, RF Fischetti, JP McGauley Jr, AB Smith III, JK Blasie. Langmuir 9:812, 1993. 168. PL Edmiston, JE Lee, S-S Cheng, SS Saavedra. J Am Chem Soc 119:560, 1997. 169. JE Lee, SS Saavedra. In: TA Horbett, JL Brash, eds. Proteins at Interfaces II. ACS Symposium Series 602. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society, 1995, p 269. 170. K Rogers, SG Sligar. J Am Chem Soc 113:9419, 1991. 171. PS Stayton, JM Olinger, M Jiang, PW Bohn, SG Sligar. J Am Chem Soc 114:9298, 1992. 172. H-G Hong, SG Sligar, PW Bohn. Anal Chem 65:1635, 1993. 173. H-G Hong, M Jiang, SG Sligar, PW Bohn. Langmuir 10:153, 1994. 174. MA Firestone, M Shank, SG Sligar, PW Bohn. J Am Chem Soc 118:9033, 1996. 175. P Hildebrandt, M Stockburger. Biochemistry 28:6722, 1989. 176. P Hildebrandt, M Stockburger. J Phys Chem 90:6017, 1986. 177. P Hildebrandt, M Stockburger. In: AJ Alix, PL Bernard, M Manfait, eds. Spectroscopy of Biological Molecules: Proceedings of the First European Conference on Spectroscopy and Biological Molecules. Chichester, UK: Wiley, 1985, p 25.
Electrochemistry of Redox-Active Protein Films 178.
179. 180. 181.
182. 183. 184. 185. 186. 187. 188. 189. 190. 191. 192. 193. 194. 195. 196. 197. 198. 199. 200. 201. 202. 203. 204. 205. 206. 207. 208. 209.
97
P Hildebrandt, M Stockburger. In: HD Bist, JR Durig, JF Sullivan, eds. Raman Spectroscopy: Sixty Years on Vibrational Spectra and Structure. Vol 17A. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1989, p 443. P Hildebrandt, M Stockburger. Biochemistry 28:6710, 1989. P Hildebrandt. J Mol Struct 242:379, 1991. K-J Fan, I Satake, K Ueda, H Akutsu, K Niki. In: G Dryhurst and K Niki, eds. Redox Chemistry and Interfacial Behavior of Biological Molecules. NewYork: Plenum, 1988, p 125. D Hobara, K Niki,TM Cotton. Denki Kagaku 61:776, 1993. D Hobara, K Niki, C-L Zhou, G Chumanov,TM Cotton. Colloids Surfaces A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects 93:241, 1994. Z-Q Feng, S Imabayashi, T Kakiuchi, K Niki. J Electroanal Chem 394:149, 1995. D Hobara, K Niki,TM Cotton. Biospectroscopy 4:161, 1998. G McLendon, K Parude, P Bak. J Am Chem Soc 109:7540, 1987. JT Hazzard, G McLendon, M Cusanovich, G Tollin. Biochim Biophys Res Commun 151:429, 1988. JS Zhou, NM Kostic¤. J Am Chem Soc 114:3562, 1992. JS Zhou, NM Kostic¤. J Am Chem Soc 115:10796, 1993. JS Zhou, NM Kostic¤. Biochemistry 32:4539, 1993. A Willie, P Stayton, SG Sligar, B Durham, F. Millett. Biochemistry 31:7237, 1992. A Willie, M McLean, R-Q Liu, S Hilgen-Willis, AJ Saunders, GJ Pielak, SG Sligar, B Durham, F Millett. Biochemistry 32;7519, 1993. SH Northrup, KA Thomasson, CM Miller. Biochemistry 32:6613, 1993. Q Ling, NM Kostic¤. Biochemistry 33:12592, 1994. HA Kramers. Physica (Utrecht) 7:284, 1940. A Ansari, CM Jones, ER Henry, J Hofrichter, WA Eaton. Science 256:1796, 1992. MM Cornogorac, C-Y Shen, S Young, O Hansson, NM Kostic¤. Biochemistry 35:16465, 1996. JS Zhou, NM Kostic¤. Biochemistry 31:7543, 1992. L Qui, NM Kostic¤. Biochemistry 33:7543, 1994. MM Ivkovic¤ -Jensen, NM Kostic¤. Biochemistry 36:8135, 1997. BM Ho¡man, MA Ratner. J Am Chem Soc 109:6237, 1987. BM Ho¡man, MA Ratner. J Am Chem Soc 110:8267, 1988. JT Hazzard,TL Poulos, G Tollin. Biochemistry 26:2836, 1987. CC Moser, PL Dutton. Biochemistry 27:2450, 1988. G McLendon. Accts Chem Res 21:160, 1988. BS Brunschwig, N Sutin. J Am Chem Soc 111:7454, 1989. LD Eltis, RG Herberty, PG Barker, AG Mauk, SH Northrup. Biochemistry 30:3663, 1991. J Fietelson, G McLendon. Biochemistry 30:5051, 1991. JM Nocek, ED Stemp, MG Finnegan,TI Koshy, MK Johnson, E Margoliash, AG Mauk, H Smith, BM Ho¡man. J Am Chem Soc 113:6822, 1991.
98 210. 211. 212. 213. 214. 215. 216. 217. 218. 219. 220. 221. 222. 223. 224. 225. 226. 227. 228.
Niki and Gregory MC Waker, G Tollin. Biochemistry 30:5546, 1991. EP Sullivan Jr, JT Hazzard, G Tollin, JH Enemark. J Am Chem Soc 114:9662, 1992. MC Waker, G Tollin. Biochemistry 31:2798, 1992. SM Andrew, KA Thomasson, SH Northrup. J Am Chem Soc 115:5516, 1993. Z-Q Feng,T Sagara, K Niki. Anal Chem 67:3564, 1995. AM Becka, CJ Miller. J Phys Chem 96:2657, 1992. HO Finklea, DD Hanshew. J Am Chem Soc 114:3173, 1992. J Xu, H-L Li,Y Zhang. J Phys Chem 97:11497, 1993. JF Smallet, SW Feldberg, CE Chidsey, MR Linford, MD Newton, YP Liu. J Phys Chem 99:13141, 1995. HO Finklea, L Liu, MS Ravenscroft, S Puntri. J Phys Chem 100:18852, 1996. RA Marcus, N Sutin. Biochim Biophys Acta 811:265, 1985, and references therein. A Avila, BW Gregory, K Niki,TM Cotton. J Phys Chem B 104:2759, 2000. HB Gray, JRWinkler. Annu Rev Biochem 65:537,1996, and references therein. Y Wang, E Margoliash. Biochemistry 34:1948, 1995. K Niki, KP Pressler, JR Sprinkle, H-Y Li, E Margoliash. Elektrokhimiya, in press. AE Kasmi, JM Wallace, EF Bowden, SM Binet, RJ Linderman. J Am Chem Soc 120:225, 1998. S Terrettaz, J Cheng, CJ Miller, RD Guiles. J Am Chem Soc 118:7857, 1996. A Ehrenberg, S Paleus. Acta Chem Scand 9:1955, 1955. AK Gaigalas, G Naiura. J Colloid Interface Sci 193:60, 1997.
3 Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports John T. Elliott, Curtis W. Meuse, Vitalii Silin, Susan Krueger, John T. Woodward, Teresa Petralli-Mallow, and Anne L. Plant National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland, U.S.A.
1 1.1
INTRODUCTION The Biological Membrane
Biological membranes are complex and dynamic structures. The biological functions associated with membranes involve a number of di¡erent molecular species, and theories of how the molecular species are organized are still evolving.The ‘‘£uid mosaic’’ model of freely di¡using proteins and lipids in a two-dimensional £uid [1] has been re¢ned to account for the presence of functional domains [2^4]. The composition, dynamics, source, and even existence of discrete segregated features, such as membrane ‘‘rafts,’’are currently sources of signi¢cant controversy [5,6]. As a result of ambiguities in the complex nature of biomembranes, better physical and theoretical models are constantly under development. Both lipid and protein components of membranes are responsible for membrane function as well as structure. In addition, membrane protein function can be in£uenced by the lipid matrix that surrounds it. Attempts to 99
100
Elliott et al.
understand integral membrane protein structure at the atomic level by crystallization and di¡raction remains a critical challenge.Only a few membrane protein structures have been determined by X-ray di¡raction [7^9]. It is assumed that the protein’s crystal structure is likely to be the same as that of the active protein in its native membrane environment; in fact, the function of bacteriorhodopsin in crystals has been demonstrated directly [10]. Nevertheless, part of the challenge associated with membrane protein structures is that their native structure and function can be highly dependent on an appropriate lipid environment. Two-dimensional protein crystallization provides some promise of a general way of crystallizing membrane proteins in the presence of lipid or detergent [11]. In general, the lipid environment is highly dynamic, and moving molecules are not good subjects for X-ray di¡raction. Understanding how membrane protein structural changes are responsible for functions such as transport and signal transduction is a critical issue. Active biological membranes are dynamic on a time scale of minutes and hours at the cellular level (e.g., membrane tra⁄cking), and on a scale of milliseconds and nanoseconds on the intermolecular and intramolecular levels. The function of membrane proteins during transport of molecules across the lipid barrier, or during intracellular kinase activation resulting from an extracellular ligand binding to a receptor, likely occurs via protein conformational changes. In addition to such intramolecular dynamics, protein and lipid components di¡use laterally in the plane of the membrane, and di¡erent approaches to study di¡usion can provide information on appropriately di¡erent time scales [12,13]. Furthermore, lipid components can di¡use between the membrane and the surrounding aqueous milieu, by a process that is well explained by thermodynamic considerations [14]. 1.2
Traditional Model Membranes for Studying Biology and Biophysics
Model membrane systems have historically been essential to the development of our understanding of biological membranes. Their use allows us to study isolated features of these otherwise highly complicated structures. Knowledge of physical constants and principles provide the backdrop for careful measurements in limited-component systems, which in turn provide the basis of hypotheses that can be tested in more complex systems. Lipid vesicles or liposomes [15], black (or more recently, bilayer) lipid membranes [16], multilayers of lipid for di¡raction studies [17], planar lipid bilayers on solid supports [18^19], and more recently, bicelles [20] are all forms of model systems that have distinct advantages and disadvantages as models of biological membranes. The patch clamp technique [21] is probably the approach
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
101
that allows the study of membranes in their most native form, but its use is limited mainly to electrical measurements and it is technically challenging. The liposome is probably the most popular model membrane, and has contributed greatly to our understanding of biological membranes. Liposomes are usually made from puri¢ed lipids or their mixtures, and can be fabricated to incorporate membrane proteins (proteoliposomes). The structure of the spherical bilayer surrounded by and encapsulating an aqueous solution is thermodynamically stable and assembles spontaneously when phospholipids are mixed with water. As a result of its stability and ease of formation, it is a model membrane system that has found application in arenas outside basic research, namely, in drug delivery [22] and, to a lesser extent, in diagnostics. Supported lipid bilayers on glass are a model membrane system on a planar support. The planar geometry provides the opportunity to examine membranes with techniques that are not amenable to vesicles. They have been employed in many important biophysical studies (for examples, see Ref. 23 and the many other contributions that followed this seminal work [24^26]), and they are most often probed with £uorescence microscopy [23] and infrared spectroscopy [27]. These membranes are composed of two lea£ets of natural lipid, and are associated with the surface through electrostatic interactions. Although this bilayer is probably £oating above the surface on a water layer of several tens of angstroms, it does not provide an optimal biomimetic matrix for all transmembrane proteins. Data indicate that some transmembrane proteins associated with planar-supported bilayers on glass do not di¡use readily [28,29], while others appear to di¡use freely [30]. In addition, the association of these layers with the surface is sensitive to the solution ion strength, and so forming the bilayer to take background data before adding protein is often not successful. Neutron re£ectivity measurements indicate that incomplete surface coverage can be a problem with these bilayers [31]. However, supported lipid bilayers on glass and on electrode surfaces supply many opportunities in experimental biophysics, biology and materials science. 1.3
The Hybrid Bilayer Membrane
If one could design the ideal model membrane, it would form by selfassembly, be robust enough to be probed for long periods of time, be appropriately £exible and dynamic on a molecular scale to allow lateral di¡usion and insertion of molecules, and be addressable analytically by a number of techniques. This latter point is extremely important, because the use of multiple techniques can reduce ambiguity and prevent erroneous conclusions.
102
Elliott et al.
FIG. 1 The simplest form of an alkanethiol/phospholipid hybrid bilayer membrane on a gold-coated support. Thiols with many different length alkane chains have been used to form the proximal leaflet closest to the gold layer. Many different compositions of lipid and lipid plus protein have been used to form the distal leaflet. (From Ref. 33.)
The focus of this chapter will be bilayers that are formed at metal surfaces. Metal-tethered membranes are similar to glass-supported bilayers, but they are composed of two di¡erent lipid lea£ets.What we have called the hybrid bilayer membrane (HBM) [32] is composed of a monolayer of alkanethiol, which is tightly bound to the surface through a strong association between sulfur and gold, and a second monolayer of phospholipid. This simple construct is depicted in Fig. 1. There are many variations on this theme, which di¡er from this most simple formulation. These HBMs use other sulfur-containing molecules for the tethering layer, and contain di¡erent lipids, proteins, and other molecules in the bilayer. In this chapter, we will refer to all forms of bilayers that involved thiol-gold tethers as hybrid bilayers or HBMs. A short review of this topic has been presented previously [33]. 1.3.1 Advantages and Potential Disadvantages of Hybrid Bilayers on Metal Supports Hybrid bilayers on metal supports are easy to prepare and are very stable. These attributes make this model membrane adaptable to application in sensors, diagnostics, and assays. Optimization of thiol-tethered membranes to make them more biomimetic is an area of active research. Focus has been placed on introducing an aqueous compartment between the metal support and the alkane chains of the bilayer, and increasing the £uidity of the lipidic moieties in the tethering layer. The use of the exquisite properties associated
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
103
with biological membranes, such as molecular recognition, dynamic reorganization, and formation of channels and transport systems within an otherwise insulating layer, can now be employed in sensor applications.This has been accomplished quite elegantly by the Cornell group, which has produced robust, sensitive, and commercially viable devices based on metalsupported hybrid bilayers [34]. Hybrid bilayers on metal are more robust than glass-supported bilayers. The high degree of stability is provided by covalently tethering a hydrophobic layer to the solid support through a sulfur and gold interaction. (Whether or not a covalent bond is formed between sulfur and gold is debatable; however, the free energy of this interaction is some 40^50 kcal/mol [35]). Covalent tethering can also be achieved through silane bond formation to glass and other materials, but tethering molecules using thiol groups is often easier and more reproducible than silane chemistry. Hybrid bilayers on metal supports are analytically addressable by a wide range of surface analytical techniques. Because the alkanethiol/lipid bilayers are on metal, highly informative techniques such as surface plasmon resonance (SPR) impedance analysis, and electrochemistry can be used to probe kinetics and to provide structural information. These techniques are particularly powerful when used simultaneously. Simultaneous use of SPR and impedance analysis to measure the kinetics of bilayer formation showed di¡erences in the density of lipid layers that added to di¡erent thiol-tethered monolayers [36], demonstrated the hydration of a cholera toxin layer bound to an HBM containing GM1 ganglioside [37], and permitted discrimination between speci¢c and nonspeci¢c binding of ligands to the supported membrane surface [38]. These analytical techniques are highly amenable for use in routine screening and sensing applications. HBMs can be characterized by infrared spectroscopy, atomic force microscopy, ellipsometry, and with techniques that have not been typically used in the study of biology. For example, the high-vacuum technique, ESCA (electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis), can be used to de¢ne the surface properties of an HBM at the atomic level [39]. The use of nontraditional methods for querying model membranes provides the opportunity to ask (and answer) questions about membranes that have been di⁄cult or impossible to address previously. A distinct disadvantage associated with the use of the metal support is the limitations to £uorescence microscopy measurements, which are imposed by the electromagnetic characteristics of the metal. However, recent advances in surface plasmon enhanced £uorescence [40,41] may lead to the wider use of £uorophores with metal-supported bilayers. To the extent that hybrid bilayers are biomimetic, their use can enhance the understanding of membranes by simplifying experiments,
104
Elliott et al.
reducing ambiguity in data interpretation, and allowing for greater experimental control. By combining experimental techniques, this approach may eventually allow simultaneous monitoring of membrane lipid and protein structural changes, and membrane function, so that the relationship between structure and function can be better understood. Because of the stability and ease of formation, hybrid bilayers are also excellent model systems for studying and developing new measurement techniques. The robustness of this well-behaved model system simpli¢es experimental complexities. Two examples we will discuss are neutron re£ectivity of single bilayer membranes, and nonlinear optical spectroscopy. In this chapter,we will focus primarily on fabrication, characterization tools, and applications for supported model membranes on metal surfaces. This relatively narrow topic has been strongly contributed to during this past decade. However, it should be appreciated that the literature describing planar nontethered bilayers and bilayers tethered on glass supports is vast, and that these are important alternative approaches to the study of biological membranes. 2
FABRICATION, STABILITY, AND CHARACTERIZATION OF HYBRID BILAYERS
The structure of the alkanethiol/phospholipid hybrid bilayer as shown in Fig. 1 has been examined using the techniques described below. We have prepared HBMs with a variety of alkanethiols and phospholipids, such as 1,2-dimystroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC), 1,2-dipalmitoylsn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC), 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC), 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC), and 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoserine (DOPS). Construction of a simple hybrid bilayer membrane is a two-step process. First, an alkanethiol self-assembled monolayer [42] is formed on a bare gold surface. Next, a phospholipid monolayer is transferred onto the hydrophobic alkanethiol monolayer. Addition of the phospholipid monolayer can be achieved by Langmuir-Blodgett trough transfer, solvent painting, detergent dilution, or by exposing the alkanethiol monolayer to phospholipid vesicles [33]. The ability to use phospholipid vesicles to form an HBM is convenient, since vesicles are easy to prepare and use in many experimental procedures. When phospholipid vesicles are added to an aqueous solution above an alkanethiol-covered surface, a phospholipid monolayer spontaneously assembles onto the alkanethiol lea£et.The hydrophobicity of the alkanethiol layer provides the thermodynamic driving force for bilayer formation. The exact molecular details of the process have not been elucidated, although the kinetics of the process are consistent with a vesicle-dependent rather than a
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
105
monomer-dependent process [43]. A popular schematic depicting the monolayer formation process as an unfolding of vesicles at a hydrophobic surface has been presented [44]. Several di¡erent methods have been used to follow bilayer formation in real time. Studies using surface plasmon resonance, impedance spectroscopy, and the quartz crystal microbalance o¡er mechanistic detail about the rate-determining step and/or information about the resulting structure.
2.1
Surface Plasmon Resonance
2.1.1 Introduction to Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) Surface plasmons are electron density oscillations at an interface between a metal and a dielectric. For surface plasmons to exist, the two materials must have dielectric permeabilities, e, of opposite sign [45]. Plasmons propagate in the plane of the interface, and the electromagnetic ¢eld decays exponentially with distance, z, from the interface. The real part of the dielectric constant for most metals is negative and opposite in sign to air or water in the spectral range from infrared to visible. For biotechnology applications, gold is probably the most suitable metal because of its optical and chemical properties. Light impinging on a metal surface can couple into surface plasmons only if its electromagnetic wave momentum is equivalent to that of the surface plasmon. The surface plasmon momentum, ksp, is dependent on em and ed (for the metal and dielectric media, respectively), and is proportional to the angular frequency of the light, o. The surface plasmon momentum is larger than the momentum of the incident light, kb, as follows: ksp ¼ o=c ½em ed =ðem þ ed Þ1=2 1=2 kb ¼ o=c ed
ð1Þ ð2Þ 1=2
1=2
Using a prism coupler with refractive index, np ¼ ep > ed , as shown in Fig. 2, is one way of achieving the resonance condition. To achieve resonance, the angle, j, of the incident light must be adjusted such that ksp ¼ kb np sin j
ð3Þ
A sharp minimum in re£ection coe⁄cient occurs at angles at which the incident light is coupled into surface plasmon excitation, as shown in Fig. 2. The angle at which this minimum occurs is strongly dependent on the complex refractive indices of all the media, and the thickness of the layers that are deposited at the gold surface. As layer thickness grows, the SPR minimum shifts correspondingly to larger angles, as shown in Fig. 2. This shift can be
106
Elliott et al.
FIG. 2 (a) Diagram of surface plasmon excitation. The bulk propagation vector, kb, increases np times inside a prism with refractive index np. By changing the angle of incidence, j, the component of the propagation vector parallel to surface ðnp kb sin jÞ can be matched to the surface plasmon wave vector, kSP, on a metal surface with a refractive index, nm, and thickness, d. I0 and I are intensities of the incident and reflected laser beam, and R ¼ I=I0 is the reflection coefficient. (b) Dependence of the reflection coefficient on the angle of incidence. The solid line is before, and the dotted line is after addition of material to the surface. The sharp minimum appears due to surface plasmon excitation. The SPR line width is denoted w. (From Ref. 47.)
followed over time as biological molecules interact with the surface. The technique can be sensitive to less than a 0.5 — change in layer thickness. The sharpness of the angular dependence of the re£ectivity is dependent on how well the resonance condition is achieved, and on the smoothness of the surface. Roughness of the metal, or inhomogeneity in the lateral distribution of material binding to the surface, can result in broadening of the angular dependence of the re£ectivity. This can reduce sensitivity, particularly if the roughness is associated with the metal layer, because it can make the measurement of the angle of minimum re£ectivity ambiguous. On the other hand, the broadening can in some cases provide information about
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
107
how homogeneously species from solution bind to the reactive surface [46,47]. The power of the SPR technique is that it provides high sensitivity and label-free detection of analyte interaction with the surface. As a result, it allows real-time measurements of the kinetics of the interaction. Furthermore, it can be combined with other methods such as electrochemistry for simultaneous measurements [36]. SPR is suitable for studying hybrid bilayer formation and protein ^ membrane interactions. 2.1.2 Kinetics of Formation of HBMs The kinetics of HBM formation can be easily followed in real time using SPR. Phospholipid vesicles are allowed to £ow across a hydrophobic alkanethiol monolayer, and as lipid adds to the surface, the angle of minimum re£ectivity from the surface shifts correspondingly to higher angles.The ¢rst example of using SPR to observe the kinetics of formation of a surfacesupported bilayer was published by Spinke et al. [48]. We have used SPR in an attempt to elucidate the physicochemical mechanisms by which these bilayers form. The process of HBM formation is an example of the e¡ect of interfacial free energy on molecular reorganization at a surface.We can envision at least two mechanisms of bilayer formation, as shown in Fig. 3. The bilayer could form by reorganization of intact phospholipid vesicles, as was originally proposed by Kalb et al. [44]. However, since phospholipid molecules have a small but ¢nite solubility in water, it is possible that the formation of the bilayer occurs by addition of individual phospholipid molecules to the surface. If this is the case, then the composition of the resulting bilayer may be signi¢cantly di¡erent than one that would be obtained if a cooperative deposition of molecules comprising the vesicle lamellae is responsible for bilayer formation. We distinguished these two mechanisms by examining the kinetics of bilayer formation at di¡erent concentrations of vesicles [43]. The experimental results for addition of DMPC to a hydrophobic alkanethiol surface are presented in Fig. 4. The data show that the time dependence for the increase in surface-layer thickness is strongly dependent on the concentration of phospholipid vesicles in the solution. For this study, experiments were conducted under static, non£owing, conditions. The kinetics of phospholipid addition to the alkanethiol layer are generally more rapid under conditions of continuous £ow, where the rate of mass transport of vesicles to the surface is enhanced, but these data are more di⁄cult to model than data obtained under the conditions used in this study. The model presented is intended to rationalize the kinetics of the bilayer-forming process. We consider the following probable sequence of events: di¡usion of vesicles and/or lipid monomer molecules to the surface
108
Elliott et al.
FIG. 3 Two mechanisms for the formation of HBMs from vesicles were considered: (1) that intact vesicles add to the hydrophobic surface, or (2) monomer phospholipid transfers from vesicles, through the aqueous phase to the hydrophobic surface. (From Ref. 33.)
FIG. 4 Concentration-dependent kinetics of HBM formation. Concentrations listed to the right of each curve are in mg lipid/mL. Addition of lipid to the surface was allowed to occur under unstirred conditions. Dotted lines are the results of fitting Eq. (4). (From Ref. 43.)
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
109
where they are either repelled or retained, followed by adsorption and/or reorganization at the surface, and with time, saturation of the surface with a monolayer of lipid. The mathematical form of the model that was used to describe the data expresses the time-dependent surface concentration in terms of the maximum surface coverage of phospholipid, G, the bulk concentration of an adsorbing species, C0, the bulk di¡usion of an adsorbing species, D, and a surface reorganization rate constant, K: " ( " ) 2 1=2 # KC0 D K t K 2t GðtÞ ¼ Gm 1 exp 1 exp erfc K2 D D Gm !# 2 Dt 1=2 þ ð4Þ K p where erfc indicates the complementary error function [49]. The rate constant K characterizes the in£uence of surface reorganization kinetics on the surface concentration of lipid. We emphasize that K refers not only to the surface adsorption of intact vesicles, but also incorporates the vesicle disruption process and the surface migration dynamics of lipid monomer. K therefore designates an entire set of quite complex surface kinetic processes. Large values of KðK 2 =D 1Þ correspond to instantaneous surface kinetics (compared to di¡usion) and therefore perfect adsorption at available surface sites. Small values of K imply that bulk material is partially re£ected or repelled by the active surface, and that surface kinetic processes are slow relative to di¡usion. The results of ¢tting the kinetic data to Eq. (4) are shown in Fig. 4. As can be seen, the model ¢ts all the data sets well. Further examination of the data by comparing them to expressions for the limiting cases of the expression described in Eq. (4) indicated that there are two apparent concentration regimes in which the rate of bilayer formation is limited by di¡erent processes. At high vesicle concentrations, the rate of bilayer formation is dependent on the di¡usion constant of the vesicles. This indicates the development of a time-dependent concentration gradient pro¢le at the surface, which develops because the reorganization process at the surface is occurring quickly relative to the rate of di¡usion. However, at lower vesicle concentrations, the rate of vesicle di¡usion to the surface is not kinetically limiting. Surface reorganization is apparently slow relative to the rate of vesicle di¡usion, suggesting that perhaps under these conditions, we observe nonproductive association of lipid vesicles with the surface, i.e., approach of vesicles that fail to reorganize at the surface. Interestingly, ¢tting the data to this model that explicitly took into account contribution from monomer phospholipid revealed that lipid
110
Elliott et al.
monomer does not appear to play a signi¢cant role in bilayer formation. The ¢tted parameters resembled those found for the model that considered the contribution from vesicles only.The apparent unimportance of phospholipid monomer in the addition of lipid to the surface may re£ect that vesicles contribute much more to covering surface area per ‘‘event’’ than do individual lipid molecules. The fact that formation of the bilayer does appear to be a vesicle-dependent process makes it reasonable to estimate the HBM composition based on the composition of the vesicle precursors. This is important for applications that use ligand- or receptor-containing vesicles for the construction of an HBM surface. 2.1.3 Using SPR to Measure Specific Interactions at the Membrane Surface Given this information about the mechanism of HBM formation from lipid vesicles, it is easy to prepare membrane mimics that contain biological recognition moieties. There are many examples of biomembrane-surface speci¢c processes being investigated with the use of HBMs and SPR. Several of these studies are described in the applications section of this chapter. Figure 5 shows SPR monitoring of cytochrome c adsorption to HBMs formed from vesicles containing phosphatidylcholine, a net neutral
FIG. 5 The formation of an HBM by the addition of phospholipid vesicles to an alkanethiol monolayer and the adsorption of protein to the HBM can be monitored by SPR. Cytochrome c adsorbs to the surface of HBMs prepared from vesicles containing negatively charged phospholipid. The w indicates the flow of buffer to wash the surface. (From Ref. 50.)
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
111
phospholipid, and phosphatidic acid, a negatively charged phospholipid [50].Cytochrome c did not bind to HBMs that were formed from vesicles that contained only the neutral phospholipid. Although many of the published SPR studies have been performed on custom-built instrumentation, it was demonstrated that HBMs could be formed and studied in a commercial SPR device [51]. Since then, ‘‘sensor chips’’ designed for HBM-based studies have been made commercially available, facilitating studies such as antibody ^ antigen recognition on immobilized receptors [52] and protein ^ membrane interactions [53] in commercial SPR devices. 2.2
Electrochemistry and Impedance Analysis
Electrochemistry and impedance analysis techniques are highly applicable to the study of membranes tethered to a metal surface. HBMs are completely supported on an electrode that is parallel to the membrane surface. The unique electrical and structural properties of phospholipid membranes and the thiol tethering layer provide the opportunity to use electrical techniques to characterize fabrication approaches, self-assembly processes, and structural details of the model membranes. In some cases, these techniques can also be used to monitor the activity of peptides, proteins, and other biomolecules introduced into the membrane. 2.2.1 Impedance Analysis Impedance spectroscopy is an AC method involving the application of small AC potentials to charge and discharge the surface with solution electrolyte ions.The amplitude and delay in surface charging with respect to the applied potential are examined by applying small positive and negative potentials at various frequencies. The physical structure of the material on the electrode surface can be approximated as a combination of electrical circuit components in an equivalent circuit model.The frequency dependence of the impedance response can be simulated for a chosen equivalent circuit model, and compared with the impedance response observed for the actual sample. In an iterative process, values for equivalent circuit components can be adjusted until good correspondence between the data and the model are achieved. Impedance studies have been used to characterize alkanethiol monolayers [54^57], and both simple and complex HBMs [34,58]. It is also important to note that there is a large body of data that describes the electrical properties of actual biological membranes [59,60], and these data aid in predicting the electrical response of the metal-tethered model membranes. When a metal surface coated with a thin organic ¢lm, such as an alkanethiol monolayer or an HBM, is introduced into an electrochemical cell
112
Elliott et al.
containing an electrolyte solution, its cross section is similar to that of a plane plate capacitor. The organic coating acts as an insulating dielectric ¢lm parallel the metal electrode. The complex impedance response of this electrode is de¢ned by i ð5Þ oC where Rs is the solution resistance and i=oC is the frequency-dependent impedance due to capacitance. Capacitance is dependent on the physical properties of the insulating layer in the following way: Z ¼ Rs
A ð6Þ d where e0 is the permittivity of free space (8.85 1014F/cm), e is the dielectric constant of the organic ¢lm, d is the dielectric layer thickness, and A is the area of the electrode. Thus the value of e=d for the dielectric ¢lm can be determined. If the dielectric constant of the ¢lm is known, the impedance analysis provides information about the structure (i.e., the thickness) of the dielectric layer. Therefore, if the impedance response can be ¢tted to simple equivalent circuit modes, these data can be used to obtain gross structural information about the molecular ¢lms that are used to fabricate HBMs. The capacitance values for the HBM and alkanethiol layer can be used to calculated the capacitance of the lipid layer by C ¼ e0 e
1 1 1 ¼ þ CT Cal Cpl
ð7Þ
where CT is the total capacitance, Cal corresponds to the capacitance of the alkanethiol monolayer,which can be determined before adding phospholipid to the layer, and Cpl is the capacitance of the phospholipid layer. Infrared and Raman spectroscopy have shown that structural changes in the alkanethiol layer upon addition of the phospholipid layer are negligible [61], thus supporting the validity of using this additive model. Determination of Cpl allows assessment of the phospholipid monolayer thickness and dielectric constant. Examples of impedance data and a simple equivalent circuit model for alkanethiol monolayers and HBMs are shown in Fig. 6. The Bode plot (Fig. 6c) shows absolute impedance (jZj) versus frequency, where rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi 1 ð8Þ jZj ¼ Rs2 þ 2 2 o C When the frequency of the applied potential is large, the capacitance element is negligible, and the jZj is equal to the solution resistance. At lower
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
113
FIG. 6 Impedance response from a simple alkanethiol-based HBM. The impedance response of the HBM can be modeled with the circuit shown (A). The capacitance elements correspond to the alkane chain regions of the thiol and phospholipid, respectively. The impedance responses before and after fusion of DMPC vesicles to an octadecanethiol monolayer represented in complex capacitance (B), Bode (C), and phase (D) plots. The capacitance of the octadecanethiol monolayer is 0.89 mF/cm2. The total capacitance drops to a value of 0.58 mF/cm2 after the addition of DMPC phospholipid vesicles.
frequencies, the capacitive impedance becomes much greater the solution resistance and 1 or logðjZjÞ logðoÞ logðCÞ ð9Þ Z oC A plot of logðjZjÞ versus log(o) at frequencies where the capacitive element dominates the impedance response is then a line with slope 1 and intercept at logðCÞ. A plot of phase versus frequency is presented in Fig. 6d. The phase difference between the applied potential and potential across the capacitor is described by ImðZÞ 1 y ¼ tan1 or y ¼ tan1 ð10Þ ReðZÞ oðRs CÞ
114
Elliott et al.
where Im(Z) and Re(Z) are the imaginary and real parts of the complex impedance, respectively. In the limiting case where o ! 1, the phase angle is 0 ; and in the case where o ! 0, the phase angle is 90. In a plot of phase versus log(o), the phase angle should approach 90 as the applied potential frequency approaches 0. The complex capacitance plot shown in Fig. 6b is another useful way to represent impedance data, since the capacitance value can be read directly from the plot. The axes of this plot are Im(Y)/o and Re(Y)/o, where Y is the admittance (Z1) and, Im(Y) and Re(Y) are the imaginary and real parts of the admittance: ReðY Þ oRs C 2 ¼ 2 2 2 o o Rs C þ 1
and
ImðY Þ C ¼ 2 2 2 o o Rs C þ 1
ð11Þ
In the limiting case where o ! 0, Im(Y)/o approaches C. The impedance response of the circuit on the complex capacitance plane is a semicircle with a radius of C/2 o¡set from the origin on the imaginary axis by C/2 (Reference 62 shows how these variables ¢t into an equation of a circle). The impedance data shown in Fig. 6 were collected before and after DMPC vesicles were fused to a C18SH alkanethiol layer. The Bode plot exhibits a slope of 1, the complex capacitance plot is a semicircle, and the phase is at 90 at low frequencies. By examining the data using di¡erent plotting methods, it is possible to conclude that the spectra can be ¢tted with a simple capacitor in series with a solution resistor model. In practice, simple equivalent circuit models such as that shown in Fig. 6 do not always describe the data adequately. Even alkanethiol monolayers are known to deviate from ideal capacitor behavior at low frequencies, and it has been shown that they are better represented by complex phase elements (CPEs) instead of capacitors [63]. Unfortunately, values obtained with the use of CPE elements in the equivalent circuit cannot be easily interpreted as well-de¢ned structure-based electrical elements. Clearly, equivalent circuit models must be chosen with discretion. Simply adding more electrical elements to a model can often improve the ¢t to the data but without necessarily improving physical insight. Another caveat to impedance analysis is that only e=d can be obtained directly from capacitance measurements, and the calculation of either value will depend on information about one of the values. The exact dielectric constant of the phospholipid monolayer is unclear, as it appears to depend on the phospholipid acyl chain and the method of lipid deposition. A dielectric constant of 2.1 is obtained with unsupported black lipid membranes (BLMs), and this value is often used to describe a phospholipid monolayer [64,65]. Plant et al. have shown that the dielectric constant for a series of monounsaturated lipid monolayers prepared by fusing vesicles to an alkanethiol
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
115
surface is 2.7 [58]. Lingler et al. used simultaneous SPR and impedance measurements to show that a DMPC monolayer formed by vesicle fusion onto a thiol phospholipid monolayer also has a dielectric constant of 2.7 [36]. Discrepancies may arise from the use of organic solvent (e.g., decane) in the BLM membrane preparation [58]. The solvent remains dissolved in the bilayer and reduces the dielectric constant towards that of a pure alphatic oil (e 2:0). Plant et al. showed that HBMs formed with vesicles prepared with 5:1 phospholipid:decane exhibited lower capacitance than those prepared with lipid vesicles [32]. Furthermore, when this HBM was kept under the electrolyte solution for 16 h, its capacitance increased to near expected values as decane partitioned out of the membrane.Using Eqs. (6) and (7), and the data shown in Fig. 6, the capacitance of the DMPC layer is 1.6 mF/cm2 and the thickness of the hydrocarbon region of the DMPC layer is 14 —, using a dielectric constant of 2.7. Upon addition of phospholipid vesicles to a solution above an alkanethiol monolayer, one can monitor changes in the impedance of the surface ¢lm as the HBM is formed. The kinetics of this monotonic response are highly analogous to the shape of the respective SPR response, suggesting that both techniques are reporting on the average change in surface area covered by the additional dielectric phospholipid layer [36,51]. Impedance analysis has been used extensively to evaluate the formation and physical properties of simple HBMs formed on well-packed and well-de¢ned alkanethiol surfaces. For example, Steinem et al. evaluated HBMs prepared by vesicle fusion, Langmuir-Blodgett trough transfer, and detergent dialysis techniques and found that there is little variation in the capacitance of the resulting phospholipid monolayer [66]. Ding et al. reported the use of a paint-freeze technique to remove organic solvent from painted monolayers [67]. An interesting study using a combination of SPR and impedance measurements on a single sample demonstrated that the organization of the phospholipid monolayer is dependent on the chain length of the underlying alkanethiol monolayer [36]. Phospholipid layers on C2^ C7 alkanethiol monolayers exhibited high capacitance and low thickness values, suggesting some level of disorder. The disorder appears to decrease as the thickness of the alkanethiol monolayer increases. Other studies have shown that HBM capacitance has a temperature dependence that nearly re£ects the transition temperature of the phospholipid monolayer [36,68]. The resistivities of an HBM have been measured and are as high as 5 107 O-cm2 [58]. This is within an order of magnitude of the resistivity observed across unsupported model membranes [69]. Nevertheless, although the upper phospholipid lea£et has characteristics similar to those in biological membranes, the lower alkanethiol lea£et of the simple HBM is signi¢cantly di¡erent from that expected in a biological membrane. More
116
Elliott et al.
advanced HBMs that contain hydrated reservoirs between the phospholipid membrane and the gold electrode have been fabricated to more closely mimic true biological membranes [34]. The alkylthiolates used to prepare these HBMs include a hydrophilic ethylene oxide [70^75] or peptide [76] linker between the thiol and the hydrophobic alkyl chains. Once membranes are formed on the alkylthiolate layer, the hydrophilic region de¢nes the reservoir characteristics. The predicted electrical model for tethered membranes with a proximal aqueous reservoir is shown in Fig.7. A solution resistor is in series with a parallel resistor/capacitor to represent the insulating alkane regions of the
FIG. 7 Impedance response from an alkylthiolate-based HBM with a thin hydrated reservoir proximal to the electrode. HBMs with hydrated reservoirs between the membrane and the solid support are intended to accommodate the extramembraneous regions of transmembrane proteins (A). The circuit model used to fit these data is also shown (A). Complex capacitance (B), Bode (C), and phase (D) plots of a mixed b-mercaptoethanol/1-thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-octadecane tethering monolayer before and after phospholipid addition by ethanol painting are shown. The capacitance transition in the Bode plot, the dip in the phase plot, and the dual semicircle-like features in the complex capacitance plots are typical features in the impedance response of this type of HBM. The values for the equivalent circuit determined from fitting routines are CM ¼ 1.0 mF/cm2, RM ¼ 5000 O-cm2, CHYD ¼ 9 mF/cm2.
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
117
membrane. A second capacitor in series with the parallel RC components represents the Helmholtz capacitance in the hydrated reservoirs.There are a number of descriptions of the construction and characterization of HBMs containing aqueous reservoirs [34,77,78]. Figure 7 shows the impedance analysis of an HBM with an aqueous reservoir that was prepared in our laboratory. The structure is created by applying POPC in ethanol over a mixed monolayer of b-mercaptoethanol and thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-octadecane [70] and e¡ecting membrane formation by the addition of bu¡er [34]. The b-mercaptoethanol is intended to prevent tight alkane packing in the thiol-containing monolayer, and to allow the thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-octadecane to assume a more disordered conformation than it does as a single-component monolayer [70]. The impedance response from these structures shows distinct spectral features in both the Bode, phase, and complex capacitance plots that are clearly di¡erent than those for the simple HBM shown in Fig. 6. In Fig. 7, the impedance response shows a transition at approximately 100 Hz that is a characteristic of the tethered membranes containing an aqueous reservoir. The Bode plot shows that between 60,000 and 100 Hz, the HBM impedance is dominated by the membrane capacitance. Below 10 Hz, the impedance is dominated by the Helmholtz capacitance of the reservoir region. This is represented as two adjacent semicircular-like features in the complex capacitance plot. Fitting the data to the equivalent circuit model results in a membrane capacitance that corresponds to 1.0 mF/cm2, a membrane resistance of 5500 O-cm2 and a Helmholtz capacitance of 9 mF/cm2. The capacitance and speci¢c conductance of the membrane is signi¢cantly higher than that observed with both black lipid membranes and alkanethiol-based HBMs. This is likely a result of defects in the membrane. The Helmholtz capacitance is lower than the 20^35 mF/cm2 typically observed at a gold electrode. This di¡erence is likely due to the reduction of gold surface area by the alkylthiolates and possibly due to partial ordering of the water molecules so that the e¡ective dielectric constant is signi¢cantly less than that in bulk solution [72]. Steinem et al. formed similar reservoir-containing tethered membranes by POPC vesicle fusion to thia-tri(ethylene oxide)-phospholipid monolayers and obtained membranes with resistance values of 11,000 O-cm2 [73]. This low value suggests defects are present in the phospholipid surface. Stora et al. formed tethered bilayers via detergent dialysis techniques and found a speci¢c membrane resistance of 5000 O-cm2 [78]. This is similar to the values we obtain with ethanol-painted POPC membranes as shown in Fig. 7. Raguse et al. used impedance analysis to examine thiol-tethered membranes with di¡erent reservoir volumes [72]. The phytanoyl-based
118
Elliott et al.
phosphatidylcholine/diacylglycerol ether lipid mixture and the ethanol painting method used in their studies result in highly resistive phospholipid membranes (>5 10 6 O-cm2) that are comparable to alkanethiol-supported phospholipid layers. Their results clearly show that the hydrated region proximal to the gold electrode responds to both the length of the hydrophilic tether and the spacer concentration. They note that the use of other lipids, such as 20:1 diacyl phosphatidylcholine, results in a membranes with resistance values of 200,000 O-cm2, suggesting that the unsaturated lipids form less insulating layers. Overall, this illustrates that the type of phospholipid, the underlying tethering architecture, and the method by which phospholipids are adsorbed to alkylthiolate layers in£uences the electrical properties of these HBM. It also suggests that more structurally complex tethered bilayers may be prone to defects. A variation of the reservoir-containing tethered membrane that contains micropatterned regions of b-mercaptoethanol surrounded by thiapoly(ethylene oxide)-cholesterol has been used to form micropatterned suspended bilayers membranes [79]. The capacitance drops by a factor 10 to a value of 0.9 mF/cm2 after vesicle addition, suggesting that phospholipid monolayers are adsorbed on the cholesterol-based anchors and suspended bilayers are formed over the b-mercaptoethanol regions. A multielement electrical model was applied to the micropatterned HBM, and results indicated that the membrane resistance was high enough to detect conductance changes induced by valinomycin and gramicidin. 2.2.2 Electrochemical Analysis The integral gold electrode also allows examination of HBMs with surfacesensitive electron transfer techniques. While optical techniques such as SPR, ellipsometry, impedance analysis, and infrared provide information about the surface average, electrochemistry provides information about microscopic coverage details present in the monolayer components of the HBM [57]. Electron transfer between the gold electrode and a solution redox species is dependent on the di¡usion of a redox species near the gold electrode (i.e., mass transfer), and the electron-transfer rate constant. The faradaic currents that arise from electron transfer between a redox species and the electrode is maximal at a bare clean electrode. When a gold electrode is covered with a highly insulating organic layer, such as a well-packed alkanethiol or alkanethiol/phospholipid bilayer, then the faradaic currents are typically suppressed [58]. Residual currents result from electron transfer through pinholes or defects in the insulating surface [57]. Pinholes are regions in the ¢lm at which the bare gold electrode is exposed, and electron transfer in these regions is controlled by mass transfer. Defects are considered regions where ¢lm coverage is such that redox species can transfer
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
119
electrons to the gold electrode, but at a diminished rate [57]. In alkanethiols SAMs, defect sites are thinner (e.g., collapsed alkane chains) than the wellpacked regions [62]. Electrochemical analysis methods such as cyclic vol tammetry and AC impedance spectroscopy can provide structural information about the molecular layers that compose HBMs. An excellent review of electrochemistry on organized monolayers on gold electrodes can be found in Ref. 57. Cyclic voltammetry monitors the faradic currents as the potential of the gold electrode is swept from one potential to another and back to the original potential at a linear rate [80]. Figure 8 shows a cyclic voltammogram of a bare gold electrode in the presence of 1 mM K3Fe(CN)6. The large negative and positive peaks in the voltammogram re£ect the large oxida tion and reduction currents at potentials near the formal potential of Fe(CN)63/4. The peak-to-peak separation is 59 mV, indicating a reversible reaction at the gold electrode [80]. A cyclic voltammogram of a gold electrode with a alkanethiol monolayer in the presence of 1 mM K3Fe(CN)6 [58] is also shown in Fig. 8. The absence of a peak near the formal potential suggests that the monolayer is free of pinholes. Larger potentials are required to produce currents, indicating that the redox species is unable to make close contact with the electrode surface. Fe(CN)63/4 may not be the
FIG. 8 Cyclic voltammetry of an HBM, an alkanethiol monolayer, and bare gold. Voltammograms were collected at 50 mV/s in the presence of K3Fe(CN)6 in 1 M KCl. (From Ref. 58.)
120
Elliott et al.
best probe of pinholes due to its relatively slow electron transfer kinetics at the gold electrode [81,82]. In a study evaluating pinholes in monolayers and HBMs with Fe(CN)63/4, Ru(NH3)63 þ /2 þ and hydroxymethylferrocene (FcCH2OH) redox couples, Brevnov and Finklea showed that pinholes are more readily observed with the kinetically fast Ru(NH3)63 þ /2 þ and FeCH2OH probes [81]. Figure 8 also shows a voltammogram obtained after the addition of a phospholipid layer to the alkanethiol monolayer [58]. When phospholipids are added to an alkanethiol monolayer, the observed faradaic currents are further suppressed. Studies with kinetically fast redox probes show that the phospholipid layer suppresses currents that arise from electron transfer at both defects and pinholes in longer-chain alkanethiol monolayers [81]. This indicates that the phospholipid layer is able to span the defects in the alkanethiol monolayer and act as an e¡ective barrier to both electron transfer and ion penetration [36,83]. Interestingly, in alkanethiol monolayers with alkane chain lengths of seven carbons or less, the phospholipid monolayers do not completely suppress faradaic currents in the presence of ferrocenecarboxylic acid [36].These data support the results of impedance and optical measurements that suggest that phospholipid monolayers on short-chain thiols are not fully ordered and have a greater number of defects [36]. AC impedance spectroscopy in the presence of a redox species is an additional technique that allows one to address the nature of the structural defects in the HBM ¢lm. AC impedance spectroscopy can be performed at low overpotentials, allowing one to observe electron transfer at pinholes [57].The application of low overpotentials may also minimize damage to the alkylthiolate layers [84]. In the simplest case, a Nyquist plot [Re(Z) versus Im(Z)] of the impedance response will contain a semicircle with a diameter that is the apparent charge transfer resistance, RCT, at the electrode [85]. If the pinholes are modeled as a microelectrode array, the fraction of pinhole coverage can be calculated by y¼1
0 RCT RCT
ð12Þ
where y is the fraction of pinhole coverage, RCT0 is the measured charge transfer resistance on bare gold and RCT is the charge transfer resistance obtained in the presence of the insulating layer [84]. Further analysis of the impedance response allows characterization of the size and distribution of pinholes [85]. For a pinhole-free covered electrode, AC impedance spectroscopy can be used to characterize the collapsed sites that are present in the ¢lm [62,86]. Several studies have used AC impedance to characterize pinholes and defects in alkylthiolate monolayers [84^88]. Excellent examples of the
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
121
experimental methods and observations can be found in these references. Only a few studies have used AC impedance to characterize the defects in HBM ¢lms. Plant et al. evaluated an HBM with AC impedance in the presence of the Fe(CN)63/4 redox species [58]. The resulting spectrum was semicircular, with no evidence of mass transfer-limited faradaic processes. This is characteristic of a pinhole-free membrane in which electron tunneling (presumably at collapsed sites) is the predominant faradaic process. Diao et al. utilized AC impedance to determine the mechanism by which electron tunneling occurs through an HBM on a pinhole-free alkanethiol layer [62]. Based on measured rate constants and the AC impedance spectra, they concluded that Fe(CN)63/4 di¡uses through pinholes in the phospholipid layer over the collapsed sites and transfers electrons through the collapsed alkanethiol layer. 2.3
Infrared Spectroscopy
Infrared (IR) spectroscopy has long been used to characterize the molecular structure, conformation, and orientation of planar lipid monolayers, bilayers and their composite proteins and carbohydrates [27,89,90]. IR spectral signatures describe the normal modes of vibrations caused by displacements in the permanent bond dipole moments of the chemical bonds in the sample molecules. These displacements are sensitive to di¡erences in the con¢guration and conformations of the chemical bonds, and as a result, infrared spectroscopy can be used to characterize the number, composition, structure, and conformation of the molecules that comprise an HBM. For example, in a supported bilayer system, the inner lea£et, the outer lea£et, and the resident protein can all be observed simultaneously, allowing complex interactions between these components to be characterized. IR spectroscopy can be used as a noninvasive method to study the formation and structure of an HBM. The use of this technique can facilitate the application of new and advanced analytical tools to HBMs by removing ambiguities and supplying corroborative evidence to assist data interpretation. IR spectroscopy operates on a short time scale ( 1012 s, to prevent the time averaging of molecular motions) and does not require invasive and possibly perturbing molecular tags. 2.3.1 The Molecular Structure of HBMs in Air The simplest sample con¢guration for studying HBMs is external re£ection in air [61,91], referred to as re£ection absorption infrared spectroscopy (RAIRS). In our studies, we have employed a high angle of incidence and re£ection from an HBM on a 150-nm-thick gold ¢lm to maximize the surface ¢eld strength and the area sampled. In this con¢guration, the re£ected
122
Elliott et al.
light that is polarized parallel to the substrate undergoes a nearly 180 phase change. With this phase change, the parallel polarized components of the incident and re£ected light destructively interfere with each other and the net result is that the observed spectrum of the HBM is almost entirely due to vibrations that occur perpendicular to the surface. In our laboratory, a variety of HBMs with di¡erent alkanethiols (hexanethiol, decanethiol, and octadecanethiol) and phospholipid with di¡erent chain lengths (DMPC, POPC, DOPC, DPPC, and DSPC) have been characterized. RAIRS data clearly show bands from the alkane chains and the choline head groups of the phospholipids in HBMs and con¢rm the presence of the phospholipid layer [61,91]. We have also characterized the e¡ect the addition of phospholipid has on the structure of the underlying alkanethiol monolayer using surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy and RAIRS spectra of alkanethiols in the presence and absence of an added layer of deu terated phospholipid [61]. The results indicated that the addition of a phospholipid monolayer caused only very small structural changes that are consistent with increased order in the underlying alkanethiol monolayer. Importantly, these data also suggest that the structure-dependent electrical properties of the alkanethiol layer are not signi¢cantly a¡ected during the formation of the bilayer.The information obtained in this study validates the use of the equivalent circuit models for impedance analysis of simple HBMs [see Eqs. (6) and (7)]. RAIRS structural studies of HBMs constructed with hydrogenated phospholipids [91] reveal a series of CH2 wagging progression bands in the 1000^1500 cm1 region. Since wagging progressions are too weak to be observed in alkanethiols [92], these progression bands are probably from the lipid layer. If the progression bands are from the lipid layer, they suggest that the phospholipid portion of the HBMs has a high degree of intramolecular order [93]. To evaluate more clearly the separation of the wagging progressions, a spectrum of d62DPPC in an HBM was subtracted from a spectrum of DPPC in an HBM. After subtraction, only the features due to the hydrogenated alkane chains remained, supporting the idea that the wagging progressions are from the lipid layer. The separation between these wagging progression bands, Dn, can be related to the number of trans bonds [92] contributing to the wag-twist modes, m, by Dn ¼ 326=m þ 1
ð13Þ
The values derived indicated that for HBMs in air, phospholipids of several di¡erent chain lengths average one gauche bond per chain. Thus, HBMs in air appear to contain a well-ordered lipid layer similar to that in a gel-phase lipid bilayer.This would be expected for DPPC and DSPC,with gel-to-liquid
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
123
crystalline transition temperatures of 41 and 55 C, respectively. However, the gel-to-liquid crystalline transition temperature of DMPC is 23 C, and at room temperature a disordered DMPC layer might be expected. One explanation for the highly ordered structure of DMPC in an HBM is that the stability of the octadecane thiol lea£et stabilizes the DMPC lea£et, leading to a higher transition temperature. Another possibility is that a lower degree of lipid hydration that results from the samples being in air could raise the e¡ective transition temperature. The highly ordered nature of the phospholipids in the HBMs allows their acyl chains to be described as if they were rigid. This approximation allows the optical constants of the phospholipids to be obtained from IR measurements of bulk polycrystalline lipid samples, which would be expected to have similar numbers of gauche defects.These optical constants allow electromagnetic wave theory to be used to simulate the CH stretching region of the RAIRS spectra of DPPC layers. The angles for the tilt, twist, and azimuth of the phospholipid acyl chains were found to be 34, 38, and 50, respectively [91]. These models also reveal that the lipid layers can be described as uniaxial, with the azimuthal angle having little e¡ect on the simulated spectra. 2.3.2 HBMs Characterized by IR Spectroscopy in situ An advanced type of external-re£ection infrared spectroscopy, polarizationmodulation infrared re£ection adsorption spectroscopy, has been utilized to characterize HBMs under aqueous solutions [94]. This study examined HBMs consisting of DMPC and hexadecanethiol with and without gramicidin D. The resulting spectra show clearly the di¡erence between the hexadecanethiol monolayer, the hexadecanethiol/DMPC HBM, and the HBM containing gramacidin.Changes in the absorption intensities corresponding to the CH stretching region (2800^3000 cm1) in the alkanethiol monolayer and the HBM spectra are consistent with the formation of a complete bilayer. For the HBM, the frequency of the CH2 asymmetric stretching band, 2917 cm1, indicates that the lipid layer acyl chains are quite ordered, as disordered chains are expected at a frequency of around 2924 cm1. In the HBMs containing gramicidin D, characteristic amide A, amide I, and amide II protein bands are shifted to frequencies lower than those observed for gramicidin in water. These frequency shifts likely indicate that the environment or conformation of gramicidin in water is altered upon incorporation into the HBM. HBMs can also be studied under aqueous solution using total internal re£ection approaches. The major advantage to using internal re£ection is that the HBM can be monitored in situ under £ow conditions. IR spectra of
124
Elliott et al.
the HBM can be collected during the fabrication stage (e.g.,vesicle addition) and during the addition of membrane-active biomolecules. A second advantage is that both the parallel and the perpendicular components of the absorption spectrum are available. This information is valuable when it is used to describe structural details of the molecular constituents (i.e., lipids and proteins) that comprise an HBM. In total internal re£ection studies, the gold ¢lm that supports the HBM is deposited on an internal re£ection crystal. Two signi¢cant problems arise from using gold ¢lms on the re£ection surface. First, the metal ¢lm greatly attenuates the re£ected light. This results in the need to use ultrathin gold ¢lms (<20 nm) on the internal re£ection element.The second problem is that can be di⁄cult to coat a surface reproducibly with a continuous ultrathin metal ¢lm. The presence of a discontinuous gold layer can be problematic when determining the structure of an HBM. Since the thiols adsorb only to the gold-coated portion of the surface, it is unclear whether the HBM consists of a proximal alkanethiol and a distal phospholipid or if the proximal layer is a mixture of alkanethiol and phospholipid. Furthermore, optical properties of the re£ection surface are not uniform. The nonuniformity of the electromagnetic ¢eld at the surface makes quantitative and even qualitative interpretations of the absorption band intensities di⁄cult, compromising the information that can be obtained about the molecular properties of the HBM components. Sevin-Landais et al. used internal re£ection studies to evaluate the structure of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor immobilized in a HBM [96]. The methodology used to prepare the ultrathin gold layer on the internal re£ection crystal [98] may result in a discontinuous gold ¢lm that covers only 80^85% of the crystal surface. As described above, the presence of an incomplete gold ¢lm may in£uence the structure information in the observed IR spectrum. Cheng et al. [97] used a 14-re£ection crystal coated with 20 nm of gold to examine thia-poly(ethylene oxide)-cholesterol-based HBMs.The multiple re£ections result in a total path length of at least 140 nm through the gold layer. The decay length for the intensity of the light through the gold is given by 4*p*k/l, where k is the extinction coe⁄cient for gold at wavelength l. In the C-H stretching spectral region (2800^3000 cm1), the decay length of gold is 13 nm. If the light had to travel through a path length of 140 nm, essentially no light would be left to detect. However, if the gold layer is discontinuous, the path length through the gold could be substantially less and the signal proportionally greater. This is similar to the phenomenon exploited in surface-enhanced infrared spectroscopy, an internal re£ection technique that takes advantage of the higher plasmon density at the surface of discontinuous gold layers (see Ref. 95 as an example).
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
125
Using a multiple internal re£ection element, Cheng et al. [97] found that the orientation of the phospholipid lipid acyl chains on the cholesterolbased HBM was 12 relative to normal. This value is di¡erent than the 26 orientation angle determined in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies of cholesterol/phospholipid mixtures that are representative of the lipids on the HBM surface [97]. Although there are several possible reasons for the di¡erences in orientation angles, this ambiguity illustrates the di⁄culty of quantifying the IR spectra in the presence of an inhomogeously coated surface. Recently, our group has minimized the problem of signal attenuation by the thin gold layer in the multiple internal re£ection geometry by using a single internal re£ection. A silicon crystal was used as the support for the gold ¢lm, and this improved the integrity of the layer. Figure 9 is an AFM image of a 10-nm gold layer on a silicon wafer with a 0.5-nm chromium adhesion layer. This layer has a root-mean-square roughness of <0.3 nm for a 1-mm2 area. The electric ¢eld strengths at the gold surface for di¡erent gold ¢lm thicknesses can be calculated, as shown in Fig. 10, by adapting the three-layer method of Hansen [99] as implemented by Axelsen [100] to accommodate a gold layer. Using the data in Figure 10 and this new
FIG. 9 (a) Atomic force microscopy shows the continuity of a 10-nm gold film on a 0.5-nm chromium support layer on a silicon wafer. (b) Histogram shows the distribution of the surface roughness of the film equivalent to 0.3-nm RMS roughness for a 1-mm2 area.
126
Elliott et al.
FIG. 10 The field strengths Ex2 , Ey2 , and Ez2 at the air/gold interface for a single reflection at a three-layered silicon/gold/air sample as a function of the gold thickness.
three-layer model, the orientation of lipid acyl chains during addition of the phospholipid layer to an alkanethiol layer can be determined from the parallel and perpendicularly polarized spectra shown in Fig. 11. Using the single internal re£ection technique, the average orientation of DMPC acyl chains in an HBM was calculated to be 25 relative to
FIG. 11 Single internal reflection spectra of the CD stretching region polarized parallel (s) and perpendicular (p) to the crystal surface for a deuterated d54DMPC layer under aqueous solution.
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
127
normal. This value compares nicely with the NMR value reported by Cheng et al. [97] and with the 26 tilt for DMPC in the gel phase on an ATR crystal reported by Hubner and Mantsch [101]. The current challenge for the infrared characterization of HBMs is in developing the methods and models required to derive the quantitative structural information that is available in the infrared spectra. While some methods have been developed for the characterization of lipid/protein layers at the surfaces of internal re£ection crystals [89,100,102], the presence of the gold ¢lm adds an additional level of complexity. However, we have shown that the use of single-bounce techniques and homogenous thin gold ¢lms can allow for successful quantitative measurements. 2.4
In Situ Ellipsometry and Quartz Crystal Microbalance
Other techniques that allow the observation of kinetic changes in HBMs include in-situ ellipsometry and the quartz crystal microbalance. 2.4.1 In Situ Ellipsometry When linearly polarized light is re£ected from a surface, its polarization is altered by virtue of its interaction with the surface. In ellipsometry, two parameters, phase (D) and relative amplitude (c), are measured to de¢ne the polarization change in the re£ected polarized light. For a three-phase samplei.e., a supporting base layer, a ¢lm layer of unknown properties, and an ambient layer (of air or water, for example)the ellipsometric values for the ¢lm layer can be calculated by measuring the ellipsometric values of the surface before and after ¢lm deposition [103]. The ratio of the complex re£ection coe⁄cients for the parallel and perpendicular polarized components of the re£ected light can be calculated from these ellipsometric values and used with the Fresnel equations to solve for the optical properties of the ¢lm (index of refraction n, extinction coe⁄cient k, and thickness d), provided the optical constants of the support (n and k), the index of refraction of the ambient layer, and the incident angle of the probe beam are known [103]. The solution is found numerically by adjusting the optical properties of the ¢lm with computer software until a best-¢t answer is obtained. In the case of ultrathin ¢lms, the index of refraction (n) and the extinction coe⁄cient (k) of the organic ¢lm are required to determine its thickness (d). For the organic monolayers used for HBM construction, n 1:45 and k 0 are generally acceptable optical constants [55,91]. Alternatively, if the thickness of the organic material is known, then the optical properties of the organic ¢lm can be determined. Ellipsometric values can be collected at a single wavelength or at multiple wavelengths. The latter technique, called spectroscopic ellipsometry, increases the number of known quantities about the ¢lm. If n and k
128
Elliott et al.
are assumed to be constant for a particular wavelength range, then d for the ¢lm can be obtained. If the ¢lm thickness is considered constant for each measurement, then n and k of the ¢lm in a di¡erent wavelength range can be determined [104]. Spectroscopic ellipsometry provides the opportunity to characterize absorbing species (i.e., proteins or photophores) that can be used in HBM construction. Ex situ ellipsometry is used routinely to measure the thickness of ultrathin dielectric ¢lms such as alkanethiol monolayers on gold, and these results compare favorably with those obtained with impedance studies [55,57]. In-situ ellipsometry provides the opportunity to monitor the growth of a dielectric ¢lm under aqueous conditions [105]. Unlike SPR, it can be performed on thick gold ¢lms supported on opaque substrates. In situ ellipsometry has been used to examine the formation of DOPG layers on decanethiol monolayers [106]. In these studies, ellipsometric measurement from a single-wavelength ellipsometer (632.8 nm) suggested that between 2.1and 2.5 nm of lipid were deposited on the alkanethiol ¢lm.This is in agreement with the values measured with other techniques. Our laboratory has been examining HBM formation with in situ spectroscopic ellipsometry. Our results are in agreement with other measurements that indicate the equivalent of 2.0 nm of phospholipid absorbs onto alkanethiol monolayer. 2.4.2 Quartz Crystal Microbalance A quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) is a piezoelectric acoustic wave device that can be used to monitor mass changes at a surface. If the QCM crystal is coated with a gold ¢lm and modi¢ed with thiols, the technique provides an alternative for monitoring the formation of HBMs. When the QCM is operating in shear mode, the resonance frequency and dissipation of the shear wave are dependent on the total mass and the viscoelastic properties of the mass coupled to the surface [107]. For HBM assembly,the ability to measure each of these properties provides the ability to distinguish between lipid adsorption in the form of a monolayer or in the form of vesicles. In general, the resonance frequency is proportional to the mass that becomes mechanically coupled to the surface. Depending on the morphology of the lipid adsorbed to the surface (i.e., monolayer or vesicles), the coupled mass will include lipid, and may include water trapped inside and between vesicles [108]. The dissipation energy, re£ected in the resonance amplitude decay, is dependent on the viscoelastic properties of the coupled mass. Keller and Kasemo used QCM to monitor the fusion of small unilameliar vesicles to SiO2, oxidized Au, and alkanethiol surfaces [109]. Their results show that they can easily distinguish between absorbed intact vesicles on the oxidized Au surface and the phospholipid monolayer on the
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
129
alkanethiol SAM by monitoring the resonance frequency and dissipation of the shear wave. Interestingly, the results show a two-step process for vesicle fusion on the SiO2 surface: vesicles adsorb to the surface, and when they reach a critical concentration, they fuse to form a bilayer [108]. Two-step behavior was not observed during vesicle fusion onto alkanethiol SAMs, indicating that preadsorption of intact vesicles does not occur at a hydrophobic surface. In addition to monitoring phospholipid adsorption, QCM can be used to study the preparation of the supporting alkanethiol monolayers and in biosensor applications [110]. Burgess et al. utilized QCM measurements to prepare an octadecanethiol submonolayer for HBMs that could accommodate transmembrane proteins [111,112]. Steinem et al. have used QCM to monitor the binding of protein toxins, lectins, and antibodies to ligands integrated into an HBM surface [113,114]. 2.5
Atomic Force Microscopy
Unlike the techniques discussed above, which provide information over a scale of micrometers to millimeters, atomic force microscopy (AFM) allows a surface to be imaged at the nanometer scale. AFM is a local probe that provides detailed information about a small area of the sample. By combining the information from the AFM with that from the nonlocal probes discussed in this chapter, it is possible to gain a far more complete understanding of the structure of the supported membrane systems. AFM is a critical technique for characterizing HBMs and for helping to verify the interpretation of data from other measurements. The atomic force microscope belongs to the class of scanning probe microscopes that originated with the Nobel Prize-winning invention of the scanning tunneling microscope in 1982 [115]. The introduction of the AFM in 1986 [116] eliminated the need for an electrically conductive sample and opened the ¢eld to biologically relevant samples. Continued improvements since that time, including intermittent contact imaging and scanning probe microscopes designed speci¢cally for imaging in liquid environments, have allowed for the routine use of AFM with biological samples [117]. The AFM functions by scanning a microfabricated probe over the sample surface (see Fig. 12). The scanning is performed with a piezoelectric tube scanner that moves in the x, y, and z directions. The probe consists of a sharp tip at the end of a thin cantilever that is typically several hundred micrometers in length and has a spring constant in the range 0.01^1 nN/m. The de£ection of the cantilever is measured using an optical lever in which a laser beam is focused on the end of the cantilever and re£ected into a split photodiode.When the tip contacts the sample, the cantilever de£ects and the
130
Elliott et al.
FIG. 12 Schematic of an atomic force microscope. Refer to text for a full description.
beam moves across the split photodiode.The voltage di¡erence from the two halves of the photodiode is then used as a feedback signal to move the tip (or sample) up and down to maintain a constant cantilever de£ection. As the surface is scanned, the distance the sample must be raised or lowered is recorded and used to make an image. The resulting image is of a surface that applies a constant force to the tip and is usually interpreted as a topographic image of the sample, although some caveats to this interpretation will be discussed. The lateral resolution of the AFM is determined largely by the shape of the tip.Tips with a nominal radius of curvature of less than 10 nm are commercially available; however, radius of curvature is not always the relevant measure. For atomically smooth samples, it is only a few atoms at the end of the tip that interact appreciably with the sample, while for a steeply sloped sample, the aspect ratio of the tip may be more important. The majority of AFM studies on supported lipid layers have been performed on glass, silicon, or mica substrates.While a general discussion of this work is outside the purview of this chapter, many of the caveats of applying AFM to supported membrane systems are the same regardless of the underlying support. From the earliest attempts to image a supported membrane it was recognized that even forces less than a nanonewton exerted by the tip on the sample were likely to deform and disrupt the membrane [118]. While catastrophic damage is easy to detect by repeated scanning of the same area, noncatastrophic compression of the sample can give misleading height measurements while leaving the sample intact. Additionally, if one or more components of the supported membrane is charged, there can be electrostatic forces between the AFM tip and the sample. Again, this leads to a
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
131
surface of constant force that is di¡erent from the topography of the sample as the tip is repelled by long-range electrostatic forces instead of short-range van der Waals forces. Both the experimental and theoretical aspects of these issues are well treated in a pair of recent articles [119,120]. The advantage of using mica, silicon, or glass as a substrate is that they are extremely £at over large areas. By using a £at substrate, any features observed by the AFM can be attributed to the sample.While metal ¢lms can be annealed to give atomically £at planes, these are relatively small laterally and typically have large valleys between £at areas. One imaginative way around this problem has been to use the AFM in nontopographic modes. Both phase-contrast and frictional force modes are sensitive to sample compliance, and to tip and sample surface chemistry, while they are relatively insensitive to topography. Burgess et al. have used phase contrast to locate cytochrome c oxidase in a supported membrane [121]. By comparing the phase images from samples with and without the oxidase, the phase signal characteristic of the oxidase was established. The corresponding locations in the topographic image could then be identi¢ed as the oxidase despite its similarity to the roughness of the substrate. Jenkins et al. used frictional force measurements on a substrate patterned with b-mercaptoethanol and a thiol-linked cholesterol [79]. Di¡erences in the friction between the two regions, and changes in this friction when lipid was added,were used to infer the formation of a suspended bilayer over the b-mercaptoethanol. We have taken another approach originally inspired by our desire to perform neutron scattering experiments on supported bilayers. As discussed below, the root-mean-square (RMS) roughness of each interface is a critical parameter in extracting information from a neutron scattering curve. To make smooth substrates,we deposit gold ¢lms on the order of 10 nm thick on silicon wafers with a 1.5-nm chromium adhesion layer. We have prepared such ¢lms using two di¡erent techniques [122,123], both with an RMS roughness <0.3 nm over a 1-mm2 area (see Fig. 9). While somewhat rougher than the nonmetallic substrates, they are smoother than thermally evaporated or annealed gold samples. Using these substrates, we can easily distinguish holes in monolayers or additional overlayers from the substrate roughness when samples are imaged in topographic mode. The smooth gold substrates allow the AFM to assess the quality of each layer of the HBM at the nanoscale.This has proved to be extremely valuable when combined with other techniques. We o¡er below several examples from our own work in which the combination of the AFM and a nonlocal probe can give information that neither can provide alone. In our early experiments, we frequently needed to reuse gold substrates, due to the expense of the smooth gold ¢lms. The samples were cleaned in a UV/ozone cleaner, rinsed, and placed in an alkanethiol solution
132
Elliott et al.
FIG. 13 AFM images of hexadecanethiol self-assembled monolayers on UV/ ozone cleaned gold. (a) The gold was soaked in ethanol after cleaning and before incubation in the hexadecanethiol solution, giving a uniform monolayer. (b) The gold was placed in hexadecanethiol solution immediately after UV/ozone cleaning, leading to the formation of islands on top of the monolayer. The z scale is 8 nm black to white in both images.
overnight to form a new monolayer. A contact angle with water of 110 was taken to indicate that a good monolayer had formed.When a new researcher changed the rinsing protocol, there was no observable di¡erence in the contact angle. However, the AFM showed the presence of small islands with uniform height on the surface, as seen in Fig. 13b [124]. Note that the AFM image of the properly prepared monolayer in Fig. 13a, as well as the area between the islands in Fig.13b, is indistinguishable from that of the bare gold substrate. Thus, while the AFM was required to see the islands, the contactangle measurement was required to know that the alkanethiol monolayer had formed on the surface. In a similar vein, we can use the AFM to image the completed HBM in situ. However, we are again faced with the problem that a well-formed HBM is expected to have a featureless surface that di¡ers little from that of the supporting layer. How can we be certain that the lipid monolayer has formed on top of the alkanethiol monolayer? One answer is to use the tip to scrape a hole in the lipid.We have done this successfully. However, we frequently ¢nd that the subsequent images are of poor quality, due to either damage or contamination of the tip, preventing further measurements. Since the sample is already in a £uid cell and has a gold substrate, we can add a platinum counterelectrode to the cell and use impedance analysis. As discussed
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
133
FIG. 14 (a) AFM image of an octadecanethiol monolayer exposed to a DMPC vesicle solution for several hours. The uniform monolayer of DMPC leaves the topography of the surface essentially unchanged from that of the monolayer. (b) A complex capacitance plot shows that after exposure to the DMPC vesicles the capacitance of the surface has decreased, indicating that a layer of DMPC has adsorbed on the alkanethiol monolayer.
above, as a layer of phospholipid adsorbs to the alkanethiol surface, it increases the thickness of the insulating layer between the gold and the buffer solution. This causes a reduction in the capacitance of the layer that can be monitored on-line. Figure 14 shows an in situ image of an octadecanethiol monolayer after incubation under DMPC vesicles. The image is similar to that of a bare monolayer. However, by applying the two techniques simultaneously, we can con¢rm that this topographically £at surface is indeed an intact HBM: the impedance plots show that the capacitance of the layer has changed from 0.97 to 0.70 mF, indicating the presence of an adsorbed layer of phospholipid. 3
NEW TECHNIQUES APPLIED TO HBMS
The development of measurement tools for probing the structure and function of engineered membrane mimics on metal supports and the cell membrane components incorporated into them is essential for optimizing their biomimetic character and for using them to learn more about biological membranes. The stability of HBMs and their ease of formation make them ideal model systems for study with emerging measurement techniques.
134
3.1
Elliott et al.
Neutron Reflectivity
Neutron re£ectivity has been thoroughly described in the context of the characterization of condensed-matter thin-¢lm systems at interfaces [125^ 128]. The specular re£ection of neutrons, R(Q), in which the angle of re£ection is equal to the angle of incidence, is de¢ned as the intensity of the specularly re£ected beam divided by the intensity of the incident beam. Here, Q ¼ ð4p=lÞ sin y, where l is the incident neutron wavelength and y is the angle of incidence relative to the plane of the ¢lm. The measured re£ectivity, R(Q), is given by jrðQÞj2, where r(Q) is the complex re£ection amplitude. Thus, the phase information is lost in a typical measurement of R(Q). The neutron scattering length density (SLD) pro¢le of a ¢lm, often represented by r(z), is a function of ¢lm depth, z. For a given layer de¢ned over a range of z values, the SLD is de¢ned as the sum of the coherent neutron scattering lengths of all of the atoms in that layer, divided by the volume of the layer. Thus, the SLD pro¢le is a continuous function of z that relates directly to the chemical composition of the ¢lm. For this reason, it is sometimes termed a compositional depth pro¢le. While r(Q), and thus R(Q), can be calculated exactly from the SLD pro¢le of a ¢lm, the SLD pro¢le cannot be obtained directly from the measured R(Q). Thus, data-¢tting methods are usually used to obtain SLD pro¢les that are consistent with the re£ectivity data. Both standard model-dependent ¢tting methods using stepped functions based on the theoretical lipid composition, and model-independent ¢tting methods using randomly generated smooth functions represented, for example, by parametric B-splines [129], are used for this purpose. An advantage of using neutron re£ectivity for the study of biological systems is that neutrons are sensitive to the light elements, such as carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, and oxygen, which are so important in biological materials. Furthermore, neutrons are sensitive to isotopic di¡erences in these elements. Thus, a simple substitution of deuterium for hydrogen can substantially alter the SLD pro¢les of biological ¢lms while having a minimal e¡ect on their biochemistry. By making several re£ectivity measurements on the same system, but with di¡erent components deuterated, a more accurate model structure can be determined, since it must be consistent with all of the re£ectivity data sets simultaneously. This ‘‘contrast variation’’ method is used widely in the characterization of biomimetic ¢lms, and its importance would be di⁄cult to overstate. Finally, because neutrons interact weakly with materials, a solid support can be used as the incident medium in neutron re£ectivity experiments.This allows a supported bilayer to be measured in situ, in full contact with water. Over the past decade, the neutron re£ectivity technique has been used increasingly to assist in the structural characterization of biomimetic
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
135
membranes that are in contact with water. Achieving the sensitivity that allowed single bilayer membranes to be studied has been on ongoing challenge. It was demonstrated that decreasing the volume of aqueous solution in contact a biological membrane greatly decreased the background from incoherent scattering from hydrogen and deuterium, and allowed measurements to be made out to Q ¼ 0:25 —1 [130]. This was more than twice the Q value that was achieved in earlier experiments on supported single bilayers [131]. This new experimental setup was subsequently used to study DPPC phospholipid bilayers adsorbed onto planar silicon substrates from vesicles in solution [31]. Neutron re£ectivity was used to study the structural details of supported hybrid bilayer membranes (HBMs) in D2O solution [91]. The structural parameters of the DPPC monolayer in contact with water were found to agree with those from partially hydrated multibilayer systems. However, the thickness and hydration of the lipid head-group region was found to be in better agreement with the results of the previous supported single-bilayer experiment [31]. The interpretation of the resultant SLD pro¢les was simpli¢ed, since the HBM is formed on the gold-coated silicon substrate with complete surface coverage and since complementary re£ection-absorption infrared spectroscopy measurements allowed an independent determination of the tilt angle of the alkane chains. In more recent HBM experiments [132], a monolayer of chain-deuterated DMPC (d54DMPC) was deposited onto monolayers of two di¡erent types of alkanethiol. The ¢rst HBM studied was formed from octadecanethiol and d54DMPC monolayers and was studied in the presence of melittin, a peptide toxin. The second HBM used a novel thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-alkane (THEO-C18) molecule [70] in which a hydrophilic hexa (ethylene oxide) moiety is incorporated between the sulfur moiety at the gold surface and the alkane chain. Since neutron re£ectivity is extremely sensitive to the presence of D2O in the THEO-alkane monolayer, one of the purposes of the experiments was to ascertain the degree of hydration of the ethylene oxide region. In order to obtain angstrom-level information about the structure of these HBMs, improvements in instrumentation and the sample environment were made to allow re£ectivity data to be obtained down to 108 in re£ected intensity and out to Q values as high as 0.7 —1. Under these conditions, the resolution of the neutron re£ectivity experiment is now limited only by the roughness of the supporting substrate.Thus, like in the studies of HBMs with AFM, smooth gold-coated substrates were essential for successful highresolution neutron re£ectivity experiments. The structures of both HBMs were quanti¢ed by comparing the resultant SLD pro¢les to pro¢les generated by molecular dynamics simulations of octadecanethiol/DPPC HBMs.
136
Elliott et al.
It was found that the octadecanethiol and THEO-C18 lea£ets of the HBMs exhibit roughness similar to that of the gold surface. However,this roughness does not propagate throughout the d54DMPC phospholipid lea£et in either HBM. Since the phospholipid is in the £uid state, the d54DMPC lea£et is much more disordered than either the octadecanethiol or THEO-C18 leaflets. Therefore, the d54DMPC essentially anneals, smoothing out the roughness present in the distal lea£et of the bilayers. The measured neutron re£ectivities from the THEO-C18/d54DMPC HBMs in the absence and presence of melittin are shown in Fig.15. Extensive model ¢tting [129] allowed the SLD pro¢les for the HBMs to be obtained with unprecedented accuracy and detail. Since care was taken to obtain a ‘‘family’’of ¢tted SLD pro¢les in each case, the variations in the sensitivity of the neutron re£ectivity technique from region to region could easily be tracked. The SLD pro¢les obtained for the HBM in both the absence and presence of melittin are shown in Fig. 16. The results show unequivocally that the ethylene oxide region of the THEO-C18 layer is not hydrated with bulk D2O from the solution. Furthermore, it is evident that melittin does not alter the HBM in a way that allows bulk water to penetrate into this region. The location of melittin appears to be primarily in the DMPC head groups.
FIG. 15 Reflectivity from thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-C18/DMPC HBMs. Measured neutron reflectivity versus Q from thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-alkane/C18 HBMs in the presence ( ) and absence ( ) of the membrane-active peptide, melittin, in contact with D2O solution. Chain-deuterated DMPC molecules (d54DMPC) were used to increase the contrast between the alkanethiol and phospholipid layers. (From Ref. 132.)
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
137
FIG. 16 Boundaries of the families of PBS-fitted scattering-length density profiles obtained from the neutron reflectivity data for thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-C18/ d54DMPC HBMs in D2O solution with (light shaded area) and without (darker shaded area) melittin. The chromium and gold regions are not shown in the scattering length density profiles for clarity. (From Ref. 132.)
The large change in SLD suggests that there is signi¢cantly less water in this region when melittin is present. However, melittin does have a signi¢cant e¡ect on the alkanethiol layer, since it is found to be approximately 3 — thicker in the presence of melittin. This can occur if the thickness of the alkane chains has increased, presumably through a decrease in tilt angle. In spite of the fact that SLD pro¢les have been determined with unprecedented con¢dence and detail, the simultaneous presence of water and melittin in the DMPC acyl chain region could not be ruled out in this work. Thus, contrastvariation experiments are still needed to determine the amount of melittin and water in all of the layers. Recently, a new phase-sensitive neutron re£ectivity method that allows the determination of the compositional depth pro¢les of biomimetic membranes from ¢rst principles, without the need for ¢tting, has been reported [133]. In this technique, two measurements are made on identical samples deposited on two di¡erent gold-coated substrates, such as silicon and sapphire. The neutrons are incident through the highly transparent sin gle-crystal silicon or sapphire substrate, which becomes the ‘‘fronting’’ medium in these experiments. By so varying the composition, and thus the SLD, of the fronting medium, it is possible to obtain the complex re£ection amplitude, rðQÞ, which includes the phase information, for the HBM.
138
Elliott et al.
Determination of the complex re£ection amplitude using this surround variation method [133] allows the related SLD pro¢les to be obtained by ¢rstprinciples inversion without the need for ¢tting or adjustable parameters. The SLD pro¢le obtained in this way is ensured to be unique, and it compared favorably with that calculated from the chemical compositional pro¢le predicted by a molecular dynamics simulation of an HBM of similar structure [134], as shown in Fig. 17. Again, it should be emphasized that this new experimental method, which yields exact SLD pro¢les, must still be combined with the contrastvariation technique to obtain information on the location of protein and water in all of the regions of the HBM. It should also be pointed out that a direct inversion method such as this, which allows for a unique determination of a unique SLD pro¢le, is absolutely essential in order to model the structure of more complicated biomimetic systems, especially those containing integral membrane proteins.
FIG. 17 Scattering-length density profile (gray line) resulting from a direct inversion of real r(Q) for a thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-C18/d54DMPC HBM in 38% D2O solution, compared with that predicted by a molecular dynamics simulation (black line) of an octadecanethiol/DPPC HBM. The ethylene oxide region was modeled as part of the substrate. Data truncation effects are responsible for the oscillation in the inversion profile in the gold regions. (From Ref. 133.)
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
3.2
139
Nonlinear Optical Spectroscopy
Vibrational sum frequency generation (SFG), a nonlinear optical vibrational spectroscopic technique, is among several methods we are developing as new in situ probes of HBMs. SFG o¡ers several advantages due to its high surface selectivity, submonolayer sensitivity, and excellent spatial, spectral, and temporal resolution [135,136]. SFG is capable of in situ measurements at biological interfaces and is potentially able to give direct information about the structure, orientation, aggregation, and organization of surfaceassociated biomolecules. Historically used by physicists and chemists for studies of small molecules at interfaces [137], vibrational SFG and second harmonic generation (SHG), an electronic spectroscopy version of SFG, have only recently been applied to surface studies of molecules of biological interest. Some aspects of interest to the biological spectroscopists have been reviewed [138].We have applied SHG-circular dichroism to probe the interaction of cytochrome c with HBMs [50]. In SFG, two laser beams are simultaneously re£ected from an interface, as depicted in Fig.18. Due to the nonlinear properties of the surface, the two photons, at frequencies o1 and o2, can interact to create a third photon with a frequency that is at the sum of the two photon frequencies, o3 ¼ o1 þ o2.This occurs through a nonlinear polarization P(2)of the surface caused by the electric ¢elds (E) of the incident light and the second-order nonlinear susceptibility x(2)of the surface: Pð2Þ ðo3 Þ ¼ xð2Þ : Eðo2 Þ : Eðo1 Þ
ð14Þ
For example, broad-band infrared photons (2700^3100 cm1) can be summed with 800-nm photons to produce SFG photons at 650 nm [139]. Due to the vibrational resonance of the infrared photons, the 650-nm photons
FIG. 18 Schematic showing the process of sum frequency generation using incident light of frequencies o1 (IR) and o2 (visible) and producing SFG light at a frequency o3 (sum).
140
Elliott et al.
convey the vibrational response, and thereby, information regarding molecular structure within the surface. The symmetry properties of x(2) are the origin of the exceptional surface speci¢city of SFG [137].Within the electric dipole approximation, x(2) is zero for centrosymmetric media,which include achiral solutions such as air, water, etc. An interface between two media, such as gas/solid or liquid/solid, naturally breaks centrosymmetry, which allows x(2) to be nonzero, and SFG may occur. Therefore, SFG signals are only generated by molecules at the interface, and there is zero background from molecules in solution. Taking the symmetry requirements to the level of individual molecules, SFG activity also requires noncentrosymmetric vibrations, or noncentrosymmetric arrangements of vibrations,which leads to the requirement of an simultaneous nonzero IR dipole and a nonzero Raman transition dipole for SFG activity [137].The resultant SFG spectra can therefore be less complex than IR or Raman spectra and, in principle, yield more information about molecular orientation. Furthermore, since the relationship between SFG activity and symmetry is closely tied to molecular structure, both the presence and absence of vibrational bands in SFG spectra can be helpful in interpreting complex surface IR and Raman spectra. Due to the symmetry properties of x(2), SFG is sensitive to the orientation (up/down, tilt angle) of interfacial molecules [137]. Due to the asymmetric nature of an interface, amphiphilic molecules often adsorb with a net orientation in the direction normal to the interface. As x(2) is a third-rank tensor, the sign of x(2) inverts with a 180 rotation of molecular orientation, and thus the sign of a SFG band changes.Consequently, the net orientation of an adsorbate can often be inferred from the observed sign of the SFG bands. Additionally, a layer of adsorbates with random orientations (in the direction normal to the surface) will mutually cancel and yield no net SFG bands. For surface coverages up to a monolayer, x(2) can be modeled [137] as xð2Þ ¼ Ns hbi
ð15Þ
where Ns is the number density of molecules on the surface and b is the second-order optical polarizability of an individual molecule. The brackets indicate an average over all orientations of the molecules.The intensity of the SFG bands is proportional to the square of x(2). Therefore, SFG band intensities can be used to follow the adsorption of molecules at a surface, e.g., the adsorption of phospholipids during the formation of an HBM. 3.2.1 The HBM as a Model System for SFG Technique Development As an experimental system for the development of new techniques, HBMs have the obvious advantages of robustness and ease of preparation. In
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
141
addition, the underlying gold support of the HBM gives large SFG signals that are not vibrationally resonant and are convenient for heterodyning with a vibrationally resonant SFG signals [135]. The HBM’s alkanethiol monolayer is particularly amenable to SFG studies, and it has already been extensively characterized in linear vibrational [140] and SFG studies. Furthermore, the alkanethiol monolayer can be deuterated,which allows it to be probed independently of other molecules as needed. 3.2.2 In Situ SFG During HBM Formation We have used the formation of HBMs by vesicle fusion to demonstrate the ability of SFG to gain in situ spectroscopic information [141].The kinetics of vesicle fusion to an alkanethiol monolayer during HBM formation have been studied by surface plasmon resonance [43], but understanding the molecular level details of the process has been an ongoing challenge. Using a broadband SFG approach [139], it is possible to follow, spectroscopically, the evolution of the phospholipid monolayer in real time. Figure 19 shows SFG spectra before and throughout the interaction of deuterated phospholipid vesicles at the D2O bu¡er/deuterated alkanethiol monolayer interface. This isotope-labeled version of phospholipid (d13DMPC) has a fully deuterated head group and has hydrogenated acyl chains. The strong features in the spectra in Fig. 19 are assigned to vibrational modes of the acyl-chain methyl groups. The spectra show only weak methylene resonances (at 2850 cm1 and broad features in the region of 2890^2910 cm1). The presence of strong methyl modes and weak methylene modes indicates that the phospholipid alkyl chains are highly symmetric, and thus highly ordered. A symmetric bilayer would be expected show no vibrational bands in SFG spectra due to destructive interference between the two layers. An ordered monolayer of phospholipid on an alkanethiol monolayer would be expected to have its methyl groups pointing toward the gold surface, and would show an SFG spectrum with bands pointing up.We observed positive bands in our SFG spectra of adsorbed d13DMPC, indicating that the terminal methyl groups have a net orientation toward the alkanethiol monolayer. This is consistent with the expected orientation of the phospholipid acyl chains due to van der Waals’ interactions with the thiol alkane chains. The observation of only weak methylene resonances indicates that the acyl chains of DMPC are highly ordered, and are predominantly in a trans con¢guration, as CH 2 modes of trans acyl chains are symmetry-forbidden in SFG. The time frame of HBM formation observed by our SFG studies, roughly 45 min, is within the time frame of HBM formation observed by surface plasmon resonance. SPR has demonstrated the phospholipid monolayers in HBMs are stable under continuous £ow, but that unfused
142
Elliott et al.
FIG. 19 SFG spectra before and throughout d13DMPC vesicle fusion at the D2O buffer/d37octadecanethiol monolayer interface. The spectra shown are at 10-min intervals over 90 min after the addition of vesicles to the sample reservoir. Each spectrum was ratioed to the SFG spectrum of the buffer/d37octadecanethiol interface to remove the nonresonant background of the underlying gold film. Each spectrum was collected over 60 s at a resolution of 4^5 cm1. The input beams were plane-polarized.
vesicles and/or multilayers are washed away after a bu¡er rinse.We observe an increase in the SFG band intensities after rinsing with bu¡er. This likely indicates that a signi¢cant amount of adsorbed phospholipid was not perturbed by the bu¡er washes, but perhaps unfused vesicles or multilayers (which could destructively interfere with the SFG signal) were removed.The observation that our SFG spectral features nearly disappear after an air and ethanol rinse indicates signi¢cant disruption and removal of the adsorbed phospholipid, in agreement with SPR results. 4
APPLICATIONS OF HBMS
The variety of analytical methods that can be used to address the physical properties of HBMs makes them ideal as biomimetic platforms for studying membrane biology and biosensor development. The ability to control the fabrication details of the individual phospholipid and alkylthiolate lea£ets allows construction of an HBM tailored to optimize a particular analytical
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
143
signal that corresponds to the molecular interaction being studied. This section focuses on studies that have utilized HBMs as active biomimetic membranes.We have attempted to include unique issues addressed in fabrication and experimental design to provide a general view of the role that HBMs can play in biological studies. The section is divided into two parts. The ¢rst part deals with sensing and screening applications, in which HBMs are used as sensor platforms to report the function of a biomolecule (proteins, peptides, or small molecules). These studies illustrate the possibilities of using HBMs to construct biosensors for clinical, industrial, and pharmaceutical applications. The second part of this section describes studies in which new information about biomolecules are obtained with the use of HBMs as biomimetic surfaces. In these applications, HBMs o¡er the ability to study structure and/or function of biomolecules with methods that are not readily available with other model membrane systems. 4.1
HBMs in Screening and Sensing Applications
One of the most common uses for HBMs is to monitor the interaction between protein receptors and biological ligands at a surface. The HBM o¡ers several features that are useful in these studies. 1. The HBM is a highly reproducible, rugged, well-de¢ned planar surface. The supported planar con¢guration provides analytical accessibility not available for some other model systems (i.e., vesicles). Assumptions about the chemistry and physical structure of the experimental test surface can be con¢rmed through analytical studies. 2. The lipid layer can be deposited onto the alkanethiol layer by vesicle fusion. Fusion of lipid vesicles containing various components (lipids, ligands, or proteins) provides a convenient method to transfer the components to the test surface. 3. The phospholipid layer resists nonspeci¢c protein adsorption, and the alkanethiol/phospholipid bilayer covers the entire analytical surface [37,51]. This combination signi¢cantly reduces the level of nonspeci¢c protein absorption during binding assays. 4. Alkanethiol monolayer chips are commercially available for surface plasmon resonance instrumentation that is routinely used in many laboratories. Among the ¢rst uses of HBMs was to examined the binding of cholera toxin to GM1 ganglioside ligands immobilized in the phospholipid matrix [37,142]. In these experiments, the HBM was formed by fusing vesicles containing the ganglioside ligands to an alkanethiol monolayer, and SPR was
144
Elliott et al.
used to measure mass changes at the HBM surface. The surface concentration of ligand could be controlled by varying the ligand concentration in the vesicles [37]. In addition to SPR, QCM has been used to monitor the binding of cholera, tetanus, and pertussis toxins, and peanut lectins to HBMs containing various gangliosides [113,143]. HBMs should be useful for screening binding interactions with the variety of lipid ligands that exist in native cellular membranes, such as phosphatidylinositols, gangliosides, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylcholine, etc. Plant et al. used SPR to monitor the binding of streptavidin to biotinDPPE ligands immobilized in an HBM surface [51]. The ability to bind streptavidin to the HBM expands its use for a number of applications. The streptavidin tetramer is thought to bind with two sides directed toward the surface and two sides toward the bathing solution [51]. Biotinylated ligands or receptors can then be immobilized on the sensor surface and used in other mass-sensitive screening assays. Experiments with lipopeptides [144] suggest that a variety of peptides and other biomolecules can be immobilized in HBMs through covalent attachment to lipid moieties. For example, lipid-linked antibodies and proteins have been immobilized in HBMs [145,146]. Double-stranded DNA fragments have been immobilized into HBM surfaces via cholesterol-based membrane anchors and the resulting membranes were used to study DNA/ protein-binding interactions [147]. Glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)linked proteins, aminopeptidase N [144], and promastigote surface protease [148] have also been functionally anchored into HBMs. It is important that GPI-linked proteins can be immobilized in HBMs, since almost any soluble protein can be made to exhibit a GPI link with the use of molecular biology methods [149]. A number of potential screening applications with lipidderivitized molecules can be envisioned. A study that examined the binding kinetics of the therapeutic coagulant factor VIII from di¡erent sources to HBMs containing negatively charged lipids [53] found that the membrane-binding a⁄nity was dependent on the puri¢cation level and whether the protein was derived from natural or recombinant sources. The study suggests that the HBM may be useful for quality control screening purposes. The gold surface associated with HBMs provides the opportunity to electrically monitor changes that occur at the membrane surface. Electrical readout of protein function or membrane structure is convenient for biosensor applications and for studying fundamental structure/function relationships. Variations in HBM design allow for di¡erent insulating and conductivity characteristics as appropriate for the components and responses being studied. It is important to note that an HBM can be integrated into instruments that simultaneously monitor optical and electrical
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
145
properties. This feature provides the opportunity to make independent measurements of the di¡erent kinds of changes that occur in the membrane [38]. The excellent insulating properties and high speci¢c capacity of an alkanethiol-supported membrane allows the HBM to be used as a sensitive capacitive electrode. The function of ion-translocating membrane proteins including bacteriorhodopsin, Naþ ,Kþ -ATPase, Hþ ,Kþ -ATPase, and Ca2 þ -ATP can be detected when membrane fragments containing these proteins are adsorbed onto an HBM [150].When a short light pulse is used to stimulated pump activity (i.e., release caged-ATP), ion transport into the interstitial space between the added membrane fragment and the HBM results in a measurable change in charge at the gold electrode. Fast £ow methods were used to study Naþ ,Kþ -ATPase in response to rapid concentration changes of ATP and ions in the bathing solution [151].These types of experiments are only possible with rugged solid-supported membranes. The use of HBMs to monitor the function of ion pumps could have a number of pharmaceutical or clinical screening applications. Alkanethiol-supported HBMs are excellent barriers that prevent redox species from encountering the gold electrode. In many cases, this feature limits the use of these HBM to electrical measurements that monitor impedance changes that occur in the membrane. Although impedance measurement can be used to monitor biological activity at a membrane surface (e.g., PLA2 activity [38] and ion-channel formation [34]), it is often desirable to reduce the barrier properties of the supporting thiol layer so that redox species can e⁄ciently transfer electrons to the gold electrode. Electroactive HBMs are prepared by introducing molecular defects in the alkanethiol layer that allow the redox species to participate in electron transfer processes with the gold electrode [57,152]. Ideally, the defects are large enough to provide electrode access, but small enough to allow a continuous monolayer of phospholipid to cover the holes. Phospholipids adsorbed onto disordered short-chain alkanethiol monolayers or longer-chain alkylthiol monolayers containing defects allow the use of lipophilic redox species to mediate electron transfer between redox-active peripheral membrane proteins and the gold electrode. The activities of urate oxidase [153], fructose dehydrogenase [154], and Escherichia coli pyruvate oxidase [155] have been monitored with electroactive HBMs. In addition to functioning as a membrane surface for protein immobilization, the bilayer structure acts as an e¡ective barrier preventing extraneous charged hydrophilic redox species, such as ascorbic acid, from interacting with the gold electrode. This is important for the development of biosensors that will assay complex solutions (i.e., blood, urine, or fruit extracts) containing additional redox-active compounds.
146
Elliott et al.
Our laboratory has developed an electroactive HBM that allows us to monitor the activity of biomolecules that induce structure defects in the supported phospholipid membrane. The alkylthiolate monolayer layer is formed from 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-[3-[2pyridyldithio]propionate] as shown in Fig. 20a.The resulting monolayer has extensive pinholes as determined from the redox currents observed in the presence of Fe(CN)63/4 (Fig. 20b). When POPC vesicles are added, the redox currents drop >40-fold, indicating the adsorbed phospholipid layer prevents permeation of the charged redox species (Fig. 20b). Impedance analysis and in situ ellipsometry agree with the CV results and indicate the formation of a phospholipid monolayer with the correct structure. This HBM is sensitive to structure defects in the phospholipid layer since the supporting alkylthiolate layer has a large number of pinholes. We used this surface to detect the function of peptides and proteins that may induce structural perturbations in the phospholipid layer. Figure 20c shows a plot of the peak faradaic current near the formal potential of Fe(CN)63/4 after two di¡erent concentrations of bacterial phospholipase C have been added. As observed, phospholipase C appears to induce structure defects in the HBM (Fig. 20d) that allow the charged redox species access to the gold electrode.We were also able to use this membrane system to detect low concentrations (30 nM) of the peptide toxin, melittin. Our results support the prevailing idea that melittin increases membrane permeability. We are presently attempting to determine the types of structure defects that are formed in the phospholipid surface using a combination of electrochemistry, infrared spectroscopy, and neutron re£ectivity. This study illustrates how the fabrication versatility of the HBMs can be used to tailor the surface for coupling enzymatic function to electrical readouts. A number of di¡erent chemistries have been employed in HBMs to provide a hydrated region between the alkane chains of the membrane and the solid surface. These include ethylene oxide units [34,70^75], hydrophilic peptides and similar linker chemistries [76,156], and polymeric materials [39,45,157,158]. The thin aqueous reservoir may better accommodate the extramembraneous regions of transmembrane proteins, and these regions may act as an ion reservoir proximal to the metal electrode. Cornell et al. developed an impedance biosensor based on analytedirected association or disassociation of gramicidin subunits in each lea£et of a tethered HBM [34]. This sensor was the ¢rst example of a hybrid bilayer membrane constructed with ethylene oxide-containing alkylthiolates to form a thin aqueous reservoir between the phospholipid membrane and the solid surface. The detection limit for various drugs, proteins, hormones, antibodies, and DNA [159] has been reported to be in the 107^1013 M range [160]. A schematic of this construct, shown in Fig. 21a, illustrates the
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
147
FIG. 20 Detection of phospholipase C activity with an electroactive HBM. A monolayer of 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-[3-[2-pyridyldithio]propionate] (A) containing a large number of defects as observed by cyclic voltammetry in the presence of Fe(CN)63/4. When POPC phospholipid vesicles are added to the monolayer, the redox current is reduced greater than 40fold after 7 h (B). SPR and impedance analysis confirmed the formation of a phospholipid monolayer on the alkylthiolate surface. When phospholipase C is added to the HBM, faradaic current near the formal potential is observed (C), suggesting that PLC introduces defects in the membrane surface (D).
high level of engineering that is possible with self-assembly techniques. The long-term stability, ease of construction, and high sensitivity suggest that the device may be suitable for commercial pharmaceutical and clinical applications. The bacterial ion channel OmpF was reconstituted into HBMs formed with thia-poly(ethylene oxide)-phospholipids [78]. Simultaneous impedance spectroscopy and SPR measurements were used to monitor channel gating when a fragment of colicin N, a ligand for the OmpF porin, bound to the receptor. Glazier et al. examined the insertion of a-hemolysin into HBMs prepared from thia-hexa(ethylene oxide)-octadecane [161].The data suggest that the channel-forming protein at least partially reconstitutes in the
148
Elliott et al.
FIG. 21 Complex HBMs. (A) Multiple of poly(ethylene oxide)-based alkylthiols and spacer thiols were used to construct the lower leaflet of an analyte sensor HBM. A gramicidin hemichannel in the lower leaflet was immobilized through a thia(ethylene oxide) linker. The upper monolayer contains lipid and a second gramicidin hemi channel. Dimerization of gramicidin was prevented by an immobilized ligand^receptor interaction. The addition of excess ligand competitively displaces the upper gramicidin channel from the anchor, allowing the formation of a conducting gramicidin dimer. (Adapted from Ref. 34.) (B) UV lithography was used to prepare patterned thiol monolayers containing thia-poly(ethylene oxide)phospholipid and 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid. The spanning bilayers containing rhodopsin and its associated G proteins were then formed by detergent dilution techniques. (Adapted from Ref. 170.)
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
149
supported membrane. HBMs have also been used in simple ion sensor applications. For example, potassium sensors that utilize the ionophore valinomycin have been demonstrated [72,73,162,163]. Several studies have demonstrated functional reconstitution of complex transmembrane proteins in HBMs. Mammalian cytochrome c oxidase (COX) is a large 28-transmembrane helix protein with 13 subunits. It is involved in the oxidative phosphorylation pathway and catalyzes the reduction of oxygen by cytochrome c. Burgess et al. used detergent dilution methods to reconstituted COX into a submonolayer of octadecanethiol on silver/ gold-coated quartz crystals for QCM and electrochemistry studies [112].The protein exhibited electron transfer to the gold electrode, indicating that it was reconstituted in a functional form. The COX-modi¢ed electrode could also be used to monitor the oxidation of reduced cytochrome c. AFM examination of the HBM surface suggested the presence of monomers and small aggregates of COX [121]. Importantly, the electrodes were stable and could withstand temperatures in excess of 80 C, suggesting that surface immobilization stabilizes the COX protein structure [164]. COX was also reconstituted into peptide-supported HBMs [165]. Immobilization, structure, and function of the COX protein were examined simultaneously with SPR, surface plasmon £uorescence, and electrochemistry in the same sample cell. Evidence for COX insertion was provided by SPR and surface plasmon £uorescence using £uorescently labeled antibodies. Impedance analysis indicated that only 70% of the surface was covered with a lipid bilayer, but electron transfer and proton pumping in the presence of reduced cytochrome c, and its dependence on cyanide concentration, were demonstrated. Electron transfer during oxidation of cytochrome c was monitored at þ 300 mV and transmembrane proton accumulation was measured at 700 mV, where Hþ is reduced to H2. Several other transmembrane proteins have been reconstituted into peptide and ethylene oxide-linked membranes. Naumann et al. immobilized Hþ -ATPases into peptide-supported bilayers and were able to monitor ATPdependent proton pumping with square-wave voltammetry and doublepulse chronoamperometry techniques [166,167]. Functional reconstitution of bacteriorhodopsin on thiophospholipid HBMs has been attained [168]. In this study, pump currents were measured by impedance analysis. The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (NAR) has been reconstituted into HBMs and was shown to retain the binding properties of structuresensitive antibodies, a-bungarotoxin, and a small molecule agonist, carbamoylcholine [96,169]. Internal re£ection IR studies suggest the structural properties of the protein in the supported membranes are similar to those in native membranes. Yu et al. immobilized NAR into alkanethiol HBMs to monitor real-time kinetics of an immunogen complex reaction [52].
150
Elliott et al.
Although NAR ion-channel activity was not demonstrated in either of these studies, the results suggest that the structural features of the channel are conserved on the supported membrane systems. G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCR) are an important class of drug targets for the pharmaceutical industry. Rhodopsin, a light-activated GPCR, and its associated G proteins have been reconstituted into a patterned HBM [170]. The use of detergent dialysis techniques resulted in the formation of suspended bilayers containing rhodopsin over micropatterned regions of 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid as depicted in Fig. 21b. Using imaging SPR, light- and GTP-dependent G-protein release from the receptor was demonstrated.The patterned HBM used in this study was prepared with UV lithography techniques. This demonstrates the fabrication versatility that is available with HBM systems. HBMs can also be prepared with cell membrane proteins that are not easy to purify. An e⁄cient way of producing a supported membrane containing transmembrane proteins is to fuse whole cell membranes, isolated by osmotic cell lysis, to alkanethiol monolayers. Cell membrane hybrids from erythrocyte [171] and mammalian COS cell membranes have been prepared in our laboratory. Approximately 35 — is added to the thickness of the surface layer, suggesting the addition of the equivalent of a single lea£et of the cell membrane. The kinetics of addition of the membrane layer are determined by the di¡usion constant of the cell membrane vesicles, suggesting that the mechanism for cell membrane hybrid formation is the same as that for HBM formation [43]. Cell membrane hybrids may be useful for screening biological ligands. Figure 22 shows that cell membrane hybrids prepared from the membranes of COS cells transfected with CCR5, a chemokine receptor, bind antibodies to both the N terminus and the C terminus of CCR5. This result indicates the receptor has a bidirectional orientation at the surface.These antibodies do not bind to cell membrane hybrids prepared from untransfected COS cell membranes, as shown in the inset of Fig. 22. More recent data indicate that these cell membrane hybrids speci¢cally recognize their chemokine ligand, RANTES. 4.2
Supported Membranes for Understanding Biological Molecule Function
Hybrid bilayer membranes provide the opportunity to examine membranebound proteins with methods that are not readily accessible to other model membrane systems. For example, the electrode allows the ability to apply a potential across the membrane surface while surface features are being examined with other physical techniques. Real-time binding kinetics can be obtained with SPR and QCM techniques. Changes in membrane structure in
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
151
FIG. 22 Cell membrane hybrids for chemokine screening. Mammalian COS cells transfected with CCR5 chemokine receptor were the source of membrane for forming the cell membrane hybrid. The kinetics of the formation of the hybrid are analogous to that for HBMs from vesicles. Antibodies to the N terminus of the genetically engineered chemokine, and to the C terminus, bind to the cell membrane hybrid, but not to hybrids prepared from membranes of cells that were mock-transfected (inset).
response to a protein can be measured by AFM, IR spectroscopy, impedance, and electrochemical techniques. These data can provide new information about the structure and function of biomolecules at membrane interfaces. A variety of interesting observations were made in the studies described in the previous section. For example, Cooper et al. [144,172] reported that the binding a⁄nity for glycopeptide antibiotics to the HBM-anchored C22 -Lys(Ac)-D -Ala-D -Ala mucopeptide correlated with their relative antimicrobial activity. This is in contrast to the binding a⁄nities obtained from the antibiotics and a soluble form of the mucopeptide. This result suggests that, in at least some cases, membrane-immobilized ligands are a more representative model of the native proteins present in the bacterial cell wall. Similar results were observed for the binding a⁄nity and kinetics between the Cry1Ac toxin and HBM-immobilized GPI-linked aminopeptidase M [144]. The binding a⁄nity was measured to be 3.0 nM and is in agreement with vesicle studies, but this value is 30-fold lower than that reported with the respective soluble versions. The dissociation constant between solubilized bacterial porin OmpF and the R domain of its ligand, colicin N, is 100 mM,
152
Elliott et al.
but when OmpF was immobilized in an HBM, the dissociation constant was measured to be 0.6 mM [78], similar to the value measured in vivo. In addition, it was found that the Rdomain of colicin N caused closure of the OmpF porin channel. These data are examples of the importance of immobilizing proteins and ligands into membrane mimic environments. Details about the speci¢c binding and electrogenic transport properties of Kþ (and Naþ in Naþ ,Kþ -ATPase were identi¢ed with a rapid solution-exchange technique that is possible for protein only on a solidsupported membrane [173]. The intrinsic disassociation rate constant for the transducin/rhodopsin complex ( 2.5 mM1-s1) was measured directly by SPR on the patterned GPCR-containing HBMs [170].The availability of a well-de¢ned membrane surface allowed a direct measure of the approximate number of phospholipids ( 208lipids/protein) associated with a membrane-bound phospholipase A2 protein [174]. Burgess et al. were able to use cytochrome c oxidase immobilized into HBMs to study the kinetics and conditions that are required to convert the enzyme between a resting and pulse state [175]. They found that resting-state activities are observed when the electron transfer rate is 0.4^0.7 s1, values 10-fold lower than those previously reported. A signi¢cant number of studies on the structure and function of the peptide toxin melittin have been performed with HBMs. Melittin is a poreforming peptide that is responsible for lysing cellular membranes. Although it is known to form pores large enough to cause the release of hemoglobin in erythrocytes, the exact action of the molecule is unknown. Some studies suggest that melittin resides perpendicular to the phospholipid membrane, and others suggest that it lies parallel to the membrane. Plant et al. used capacitance and electrochemical measurements to examine the e¡ect of melittin on HBMs [32,58]. Melittin did not signi¢cantly change the capacitance of the membrane, suggesting that it did not cause signi¢cant membrane disruption, but increases in electron transfer with Fe(CN)63/4 were observed, suggesting that melittin does form lesions in the phospholipid surface. Recent electrochemical work demonstrated that some of the e¡ect of melittin on increasing electron transfer for negatively charged redox species could be explained by electrostatic e¡ects [81]. In these studies, it was found that melittin addition to an HBM completely suppressed pinhole redox currents from Ru(NH3)63 þ /2 þ , did not change the residual redox currents from hydroxymethylferrocine (FcCH2OH), and increased the redox currents associated with Fe(CN)63/4. These data suggest that the basic residues in melittin at least in part alter the redox processes by electrostatic screening interactions. In this study, the capacitance of the HBM increased upon the addition of melittin, suggesting that the toxin perturbs the membrane structure. Steinem et al. found that the addition of up to 6 mM
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
153
melittin does not signi¢cantly alter the capacitance nor the resistance across an ethylene oxide-supported HBM [77]. Interestingly, they showed that phospholipase A2 and melittin act synergistically to greatly reduce membrane capacitance and increase conductance. A QCM study by the same group suggests that melittin forms multilayers on the HBM surface [176]. From the results in these studies and those from many di¡erent bilayer systems, it is still unclear how melittin functions at the membrane surface. We are attempting to put to rest many controversies surround melittin action with the use of neutron re£ectivity [91,132,133], SPR, and other electrochemical measurements. We anticipate that the use of a rugged supported membrane will continue to allow such detailed questions to be addressed and eventually lead to an unraveling of the parameters associated with melittin behavior, including concentration dependence, and the e¡ects of charge and applied potential.
5
CHALLENGES
For many applications, including the molecular recognition of membrane surface ligands, and studies of peripheral membrane enzyme activity, the structure of the simple HBM is probably su⁄cient. However, for applications involving transmembrane proteins, and particularly for studies involving membrane protein structure and function, it may be necessary to prepare a membrane that has a more biomimetic character. The fabrication chemistry and methodology may need to be tailored not only to optimize bioactivity, but also to achieve a speci¢c assay readout. For example, to read out protein function electrically, the insulating properties of the membrane may be very important. If optical readouts are used to monitor protein function, then the insulating properties of the membrane may be irrelevant. For transmembrane proteins, a hydrated compartment proximal to the gold surface is expected to be required for correct reconstitution. Examples of sophisticated chemistries and fabrication approaches have been discussed in the previous section. However, new approaches to solving this issue are still under development, and include chelator-based linkers for supporting planar bilayers [156,177], covalent linker chemistries [178,179], streptavidinsupported membranes [180], and polymer-based supports [19]. Another approach that is being examined is the fabrication of surfaces that are patterned with areas of thiol-linked alkanes and areas of short polar moieties [79,170,181]. This approach is an e¡ort to produce areas of tethered alkanethiol-phospholipid bilayers and areas of suspended phospholipidphospholipid bilayers that are not tethered to the surface. Methods to form
154
Elliott et al.
membrane micropatterned surfaces are signi¢cant because they have applications in microarray technologies for multiplexing, and high- and medium-throughput analyte analyses.Unambiguous characterization of the results of such fabrication approaches is not trivial. One study examined vesicle association and fusion to a patterned octadecanethiol and b-mer captoethanol surface by SPR microscopy [182]. The phospholipid adsorption kinetics on the two di¡erent areas are very di¡erent, but the total amount of lipid added to the surface appears to be consistent with the addition of phospholipid monolayer on the octadecanethiol regions and bilayer over the b-mercaptoethanol region. Impedance analysis of patterned surface requires the use of complicated equivalent circuit models to describe various types of defects that are possibly present at the surface [163]. In our laboratory we have observed that measurements from a single technique are not always su⁄cient to provide a correct interpretation of the data. For example, experiments were performed to examine the e¡ect of surface free energy on the kinetics of formation of HBMs from vesicles. Mixtures of ^ CH3 - and ^ OH-terminated thiols were used to vary the surface energy, and vesicle adsorption to the surface was monitored by SPR as shown on the left in Fig. 23. When vesicles were added to surfaces containing a fraction of 30% or less ^ OH alkylthiol, SPR indicated a change in thickness that was consistent with the addition of a single layer of phospholipid.The graph in Fig. 23 shows that the apparent change in thickness that occurred when vesicles were added to a surface that was 30% ^ OH alkylthiol was approximately 23 —. From these data alone, one would conclude that a monolayer of phospholipid added to the surface. However, impedance analysis indicated a capacitance for the putative ‘‘monolayer’’ of phospholipid of greater than 16 mF/cm2, which is approximately 10-fold higher than expected for an insulating lipid layer. Panel a on the right of Fig. 23 shows the result of addition of vesicles to the 100% ^ CH3 -terminated surface. The AFM image shows the surface is topographically smooth, consistent with the formation of a phospholipid monolayer. The addition of vesicles to the surface composed of 50% ^ OH alkylthiol (panel b) produced a rough surface, suggesting the presence of unfused or partially fused vesicles. Interestingly, at the 100% ^ OH-terminated surface, SPR data suggest addition of a complete bilayer of phospholipid. However, impedance analysis shows that there was e¡ectively no change in the capacitance of the surface after addition of phospholipid vesicles. The initial AFM scans of this surface were poorly resolved, although subsequent scanning produced a smooth topology as shown in panel c.Thus, in some circumstances, it will be critical to examine the results from several techniques in order to characterize the structural features of the surfaces correctly. This will be particularly important as fabrication approaches
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports
155
FIG. 23 Fusion of POPC vesicles to mixed monolayers containing HSC11OH and HSC11CH3. SPR data are shown on left. The fraction of methyl terminated thiol in the monolayer is indicated by x. Vesicles are added at time 0. The break in the curves indicates the flow of buffer without vesicles into the cell. On the right are shown AFM images of surfaces after exposure to vesicles. (a) x ¼ 1:0. (b) x ¼ 0:5. (c) The initial AFM scans on the 100% hydroxyl terminated surface ðx ¼ 0Þ are not well resolved (not shown), but after repeated scans, the lipid appears to organize into layer with a smooth topology. Scale at bottom is represents the z dimension.
become increasingly complex in our attempts to reconstitute active transmembrane proteins.
6
CONCLUSIONS
The hybrid bilayer membrane is composed of both synthetic and natural components that assemble at a solid support. While the composition and arrangement of the molecules of HBMs precludes a truly ‘‘native’’ structure, this approach does provide advantages such as ease of fabrication and stability of the structure. For these reasons, the HBM provides the opportunity to take advantage of the functions of biological membranes for applications such as sensing, screening, and diagnostics. The ruggedness of the HBM lends itself to a variety of analytical techniques, the combination of which makes it possible to know unequivocally
156
Elliott et al.
many details of the physical nature of the structure. Together with the fact that the preparation of the hybrid membrane is spontaneous and reproducible, HBMs can be easier to use as research tools and as commercial analytical devices than other model membranes. Many of the tools and approaches that have been used in the development, characterization, and application of HBMs involve materials science and engineering. For scientists interested in the materials properties of biologically derived structures, the hybrid membrane presents a healthy challenge as an ultrathin material, with features of interest that are on the nanometer scale. Importantly, the use of hybrid bilayer membranes is providing opportunities to examine biological membranes in new ways, and is beginning to provide new insight into biological molecules and biologically relevant phenomenan. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We would liketoacknowledge the manycontributions to the HBMproject that have been made by colleagues at NISTand other who have visited NISTduring experimental studies. We would like to thank Dr. Joseph Hubbard, Dr. N. Madhusudhana Rao and Dr. Herbert Wieder for their contributions to the work on the mechanism of hybrid bilayer formation, cell membrane hybrids, and vesicle fusion to mixed monolayer surfaces, respectively. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
10. 11. 12.
SJ Singer, GL Nicolson. Science 175:720, 1972. GL Nicolson. In: (CR Richmond et al., eds. Mammalian Cells: Probes and Problems. Oak Ridge,TN: Technical Information Center, pp 246^253, 1975. Y Schi¡mann. Mol Cell Biochem 42:117, 1982. K Jacobson, ED Sheets, R Simson. Science 268:1441, 1995. K Jacobson, C Dietrich. Trends Cell Biol 9:87, 1999. AK Kenworthy, N Petranova, M Edidin. Mol Biol Cell 11:1645, 2000. C Ostermeier, H Michel. Curr Opin Struct Biol 7:697, 1997. A Pautsch, GE Schulz. J Mol Biol 298:273, 2000. K Palczewski,T Kumasaka,T Hori, CA Behnke, H Motoshima, BA Fox,T Le, I, DC Teller, T Okada, RE Stenkamp, M Yamamoto, M Miyano. Science 289:739, 2000. J Heberle, G Buldt, E Koglin, JP Rosenbusch, EM Landau, J Mol Biol 281:587, 1998. J Rigaud, M Chami, O Lambert, D Levy, J Ranck. Biochim Biophys Acta 1508:112, 2000. M Edidin. J Cell Sci Suppl 17:165, 1993.
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49.
157
M Bloom, JLThewalt. Mol Membr Biol 12:9, 1995. JB Massey, DH Bick, HJ Pownall. Biophys J 72:1732, 1997. AD Bangham. Chem Phys Lipids 64:275, 1993. M Montal. J Membr Biol 98:101, 1987. YK Levine. Progr Surface Sci 3:279, 1973. E Sackmann. Science 271:43, 1996. E Sackmann, M Tanaka. Trends Biotechnol 18:58, 2000. CR Sanders, RS Prosser. Struct Fold Des 6:1227, 1998. BE Ehrlich. Meth Enzymol 207:463, 1992. A Chonn, PR Cullis. Curr Opin Biotechnol 6:698, 1995. LK Tamm, HM McConnell. Biophys J 47:105, 1985. JT Groves, C Wul¢ng, SG Boxer. Biophys J 71:2716, 1996. HM McConnell, TH Watts, RM Weis, AA Brian. Biochim Biophys Acta 864:95, 1986. M Seul, S Subramaniam, HM McConnell. J Phys Chem 89:3592, 1985. E Goormaghtigh, V Raussens, JM Ruysschaert. BBA- Rev Biomembr 1422:105, 1999. MLWagner, LK Tamm. Biophys J 79:1400, 2000. J Salafsky, JT Groves, SG Boxer. Biochemistry 35:14773, 1996. EM Erb, K Tangemann, B Bohrmann, B Muller, J Engel. Biochemistry 36:7395, 1997. BW Koenig, S Kruger, WJ Orts, CF Majkrzak, NF Berk, JV Silverton, K Gawrisch. Langmuir 12:1343, 1996. AL Plant. Langmuir 9:2764, 1993. AL Plant. Langmuir 15:5128, 1999. BA Cornell, VL Braach-Maksvytis, LG King, PD Osman, B Raguse, LWieczorek, RJ Pace. Nature 387:580, 1997. RG Nuzzo, BR Zegarski, LH Dubois. J Am Chem Soc 109:733, 1987. S Lingler, I Rubinstein,W Knoll, A O¡enhausser. Langmuir 13:7085, 1997. S Terrettaz,T Stora, C Duschl, H Vogel. Langmuir 9:1361, 1993. M Stelzle, G Weissmuller, E Sackmann. J Phys Chem 97:2974, 1993. KG Marra, DDA Kidani, EL Chaikof. Langmuir 13:5697, 1997. T Liebermann,W Knoll. Colloid Surface A 171:115, 2000. J Enderlein. Biophys J 78:2151, 2000. RG Nuzzo, DL Allara. J Am Chem Soc 105:4481, 1983. JB Hubbard,V Silin, AL Plant. Biophys Chem 75:163, 1998. E Kalb, S Frey, LK Tamm. Biochim Biophys Acta 1103:307, 1992. I Pockrand. Surface Sci 72:577, 1978. V Silin, H Weetall, DJ Vanderah. J Colloid Interface Sci 185:94, 1997. V Silin, A Plant. Trends Biotechnol 15:353, 1997. J Spinke, J Yang, H Wolf, M Liley, H Ringsdorf, W Knoll. Biophys J 63:1667, 1992. M Abramowitz, IA Stegun. Handbook of Mathematical Functions, National Bureau of Standards Applied Mathematics. Series 55, Chapter 7. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing O⁄ce, 1966.
158
Elliott et al.
50. TP Petralli-Mallow, AL Plant, ML Lewis, JM Hicks. Langmuir 16:5960, 2000. 51. AL Plant, M Brigham-Burke, EC Petrella, DJ O’Shannessy. Anal Biochem 226:342, 1995. 52. YY Yu, BJ VanWie, AR Koch, DF Mo¡ett,WC Davis. Anal Biochem 263:158, 1998. 53. S Raut, LWeller,TW Barrowcli¡e, Br J Haematol 107:323, 1999. 54. C Miller, P Cuendet, M Gratzel. J Phys Chem 95:877, 1991. 55. MD Porter, TB Bright, DL Allara, CED Chidsey. J Am Chem Soc 109:3559, 1987. 56. JR Macdonald. Impedance Spectroscopy: Emphasizing Solid Materials and Systems. New York: Wiley, 1987. 57. HO Finklea. In: (AJ Bard, I Rubinstein, eds. Electroanalytical Chemistry. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 109^335, 1996. 58. AL Plant, M Gueguetchkeri,W Yap. Biophys J 67:1126, 1994. 59. B Hille. Ionic Channels of Excitable Membranes. Sunderland: Sinauer Associates, 1997. 60. RB Gennis. Biomembranes. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1992. 61. CW Meuse, G Niaura, ML Lewis, AL Plant. Langmuir 14:1604, 1998. 62. P Diao, DL Jiang, XL Cui, DP Gu, RT Tong, B Zhong. Bioelectrochem Bioenerget 48:469, 1999. 63. E Boubour, RB Lennox. Langmuir 16:4222, 2000. 64. JP Dilger, SG McLaughlin,TJ McIntosh, SA Simon. Science 206:1196, 1979. 65. R Benz, O Frohlich, P Lauger, M Montal. Biochim Biophys Acta 394:323, 1975. 66. C Steinem, A Jansho¡,WP Ulrich, M Sieber, HJ Galla. Biochim Biophys Acta 1279:169, 1996. 67. L Ding, JH Li, SJ Dong, EK Wang. J Electroanal Chem 416:105, 1996. 68. EL Florin, HE Gaub. Biophys J 64:375, 1993. 69. HT Tien, J Kutnik, P Krysinski, ZK Lojewska. In: M Blank, ed. Electrical Double Layers in Biology. New York: Plenum, pp 149^166, 1985. 70. DJ Vanderah, CW Meuse,V Silin, AL Plant. Langmuir 14:6916, 1998. 71. DJ Vanderah, CP Pham, SK Springer, V Silin, CW Meuse. Langmuir 16:6527, 2000. 72. B Raguse, V Braach-Maksvytis, BA Cornell, LG King, PDJ Osman, RJ Pace, LWieczorek. Langmuir 14:648, 1998. 73. C Steinem, A Jansho¡, K dem Bruch, K Reihs, J Goossens, HJ Galla. Bioelectrochem Bioenerget 45:17, 1998. 74. LM Williams, SD Evans, TM Flynn, A Marsh, PF Knowles, RJ Bushby, N Boden. Langmuir 13:751, 1997. 75. H Lang, C Duschl, H Vogel. Langmuir 10:197, 1994. 76. N Bunjes, EK Schmidt, A Jonczyk, F Rippmann, D Beyer, H Ringsdorf, P Graber,W Knoll, R Naumann. Langmuir 13:6188, 1997. 77. C Steinem, HJ Galla, A Jansho¡. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2:4580, 2000. 78. T Stora, JH Lakey, H Vogel. Angew Chem Int Ed 38:389, 1999. 79. ATA Jenkins, N Boden, SD Bushby, PF Evans, PF Knowles, RE Miles, SD Ogier, H Schonherr, GJ Vansco. J Am Chem Soc 121:5274, 1999.
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114.
159
J Wang. Analytical Electrochemistry. New York: Wiley, 2000. DA Brevnov, HO Finklea. Langmuir 16:5973, 2000. O Chailapakul, RM Crooks. Langmuir 9:884, 1993. P Krysinski, MR Moncelli, F Tadini-Buoninsegni. Electrochim Acta 45:1885, 2000. E Sabatani, J Cohenboulakia, M Bruening, I Rubinstein. Langmuir 9:2974, 1993. HO Finklea, DA Snider, J Fedyk, E Sabatani,Y Gafni, I Rubinstein. Langmuir 9:3660, 1993. TM Nahir, EF Bowden. Electrochim Acta 39:2347, 1994. E Sabatani, I Rubinstein, R Maoz, J Sagiv. Electroanal Chem 219:365, 1987. E Sabatani, I Rubinstein. J Phys Chem 91:6663, 1987. LK Tamm, SA Tatulian. Q Rev Biophys 30:365, 1997. RA Dluhy. Appl Spectrosc Rev 35:315, 2000. CW Meuse, S Krueger, CF Majkrzak, JA Dura, J Fu, JT Connor, AL Plant. Biophys J 74:1388, 1998. AN Parikh, B Liedberg, SVAtre, M Ho, DL Allara. J Phys Chem 99:9996,1995. RG Snyder, JH Schachtschneider. Spectrochim Acta A 19:85, 1963. J Ha, CS Henry, I Fritsch. Langmuir 14:5850, 1998. R Kellner, B Mizaiko¡, M Jakusch, HD Wanzenbock, N Weissenbacher. Appl Spectrosc 51:495, 1997. A Sevin-Landais, P Rigler, S Tzartos, F Hucho, R Hovius, H Vogel. Biophys Chem 85:141, 2000. YL Cheng, N Boden, RJ Bushby, S Clarkson, SD Evans, PF Knowles, A Marsh, RE Miles. Langmuir 14:839, 1998. M Liley,TA Keller, C Duschl, H Vogel. Langmuir 13:4190, 1997. WN Hansen. J Opt Soc Am 58:380, 1968. MJ Citra, PH Axelsen. Biophys J 71:1796, 1996. W Hubner, HH Mantsch. Biophys J 59:1261, 1991. P Wenzl, M Fringeli, J Goette, UP Fringeli. Langmuir 10:4253, 1994. S Gottesfeld. Electroanal Chem 15:143, 1989. V Reipa, AK Gaigalas,VLVilker. Langmuir 13:3508, 1997. C Striebel, A Brecht, G Gauglitz. Biosens Bioelectron 9:139, 1994. PN Bartlett, K Brace, EJ Calvo, R Etchenique. J Mater Chem 10:149, 2000. M Rodahl, B Kasemo. Rev Sci Instrum 67:3238, 1996. CA Keller, K Glasmastar, VP Zhdanov, B Kasemo. Phys Rev Lett 84:5443, 2000. CA Keller, B Kasemo. Biophys J 75:1397, 1998. A Jansho¡, HJ Galla, C Steinem. Angew Chem Int Ed 39:4004, 2000. JD Burgess, FH Hawkridge. Langmuir 13:3781, 1997. JD Burgess, MC Rhoten, FM Hawkridge. Langmuir 14:2467, 1998. A Jansho¡, C Steinem, M Sieber, HJ Galla. Eur Biophys J Biophys 25:105, 1996. C Steinem, A Jansho¡, J Wegener, WP Ulrich, W Willenbrink, M Sieber, HJ Galla. Biosens Bioelectron 12:787, 1997.
160
Elliott et al.
115. 116. 117.
G Binnig, H Rohrer, Ch Gerber, E Weibel. Phys Rev Lett 49:57, 1982. G Binnig, CF Quate, Ch Gerber. Phys Rev Lett 56:930, 1986. VJ Morris, AR Kirby, AP Gunning. Atomic Force Microscopy for Biologists. London, UK: Imperial College Press, 1999. JA Zasadzinski, CA Helm, ML Longo, AL Weisenhorn, SA Gould, PK Hansma. Biophys J 59:755, 1991. YF Dufrene, T Boland, JW Schneider, WR Barger, GU Lee. Faraday Discuss 111:79, 1998. J Schneider,YF Dufrene,WR Barger, GU Lee. Biophys J 79:1107, 2000. JD Burgess, VW Jones, MD Porter, MC Rhoten, FM Hawkridge. Langmuir 14:6628, 1998. J Pedulla, RD Deslattes. In: RB Hoover, AB Walker, eds. Multilayer and Grazing Incidence X-Ray/EUV Optics II. Proc SPIE 2011:299, 1994. JT Woodward,V Silin, AL Plant, S Krueger. In preparation, 2001. JT Woodward, ML Walker, CW Meuse, DJ Vanderah, GE Poirier, AL Plant. Langmuir 16:5347, 2000. CF Majkrzak, GP Felcher. Mater Res Bull 15:65, 1990. J Penfold, RK Thomas. J PhysCondens Matter 2:1369, 1990. CF Majkrzak. Mater Res Soc Symp Proc 376:143, 1995. J Penfold, RM Richardson, A Zarbakhsh, JRP Webster, DG Bucknall, AR Rennie, RAL Jones, T Cosgrove, RK Thomas, JS Higgins, PDI Fletcher, E Dickinson, SJ Roser, IA McLure, AR Hillman, RW Richards, EJ Staples, AN Burgess, EA Simister, JW White. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 93:3899, 1997. NF Berk, CF Majkrzak. Phys Rev B 51:11296, 1995. S Krueger, JF Ankner, SK Satija, CF Majkrzak, D Gurley, M Colombini. Langmuir 11:3218, 1995. SJ Johnson,TM Bayerl, DC McDermott, GWAdam, AR Rennie, RK Thomas, E Sackmann. Biophys J 59:289, 1991. S Krueger, CW Meuse, CF Majkrzak, JA Dura, NF Berk, M Tarek, AL Plant. Langmuir 17:511, 2001. CF Majkrzak, NF Berk, S Krueger, JA Dura, M Tarek, D Tobias, V Silin, CW Meuse, J Woodward, AL Plant. Biophys J 79:3330, 2000. M Tarek, K Tu, ML Klein, DJ Tobias. Biophys J 77:964, 1999. CD Bain. J Chem Soc FaradayTrans 91:1281, 1995. GL Richmond. Anal Chem 69:A536^ A543, 1997. YR Shen. Nature 337:519, 1989. V Vogel. Curr Opin Colloid Interface 1:257, 1996. LT Richter,TP Petralli-Mallow, JC Stephenson. Opt Lett 23:1594, 1998. CD Bain, EB Troughton, YT Tao, J Evall, GM Whitesides, RG Nuzzo. J Am Chem Soc 111:321, 1989. T Petralli-Mallow, KA Briggman, LJ Richter, JC Stephenson, AL Plant. In: M Fallahi, B Swanson, eds. Advanced Materials and Optical Systems for Chemical and Biological Detection. Proc SPIE 3858:25, 1999. GM Kuziemko, M Stroh, RC Stevens. Biochemistry 35:6375, 1996.
118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126. 127. 128.
129. 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141.
142.
Biomimetic Membranes on Metal Supports 143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150. 151. 152. 153. 154. 155. 156. 157. 158. 159. 160. 161. 162. 163. 164. 165. 166. 167. 168. 169.
170. 171. 172. 173.
161
A Jansho¡, C Steinem, M Sieber, A elBaya, MA Schmidt, HJ Galla. Eur Biophys J Biophys 26:261, 1997. MA Cooper, AC Try, J Carroll, DJ Ellar, DH Williams. BBA-Biomembranes 1373:101, 1998. MA Cooper, DH Williams. Anal Biochem 276:36, 1999. I Vikholm, K Gyo«rvary, J Peltonen. Langmuir 12:3276, 1996. CI Webster, MA Cooper, LC Packman. DH Williams, JC Gray. Nucleic Acids Res 28:1618, 2000. M Liley, J Bouvier, H Vogel. J Colloid Interface Sci 194:53, 1997. ME Medof, S Nagarajan, MLTykocinski. FASEB J 10:574, 1996. K Seifert, K Fendler, E Bamberg. Biophys J 64:384, 1993. J Pintschovius, K Fendler. Biophys J 76:814, 1999. P Krysinki, HT Tien, A Ottova. Biotechnol Progr 15:974, 1999. T Nakaminami, S Ito, S Kuwabata, H Yoneyama. Anal Chem 71:4278, 1999. KT Kinnear, HG Monbouquette. Anal Chem 69:1771, 1997. O Pierrat, N Lechat, C Bourdillon, JM Laval. Langmuir 13:4112, 1997. U Radler, J Mack, N Persike, G Jung, R Tampe. Biophys J 79:3144, 2000. W Knoll, CW Frank, C Heibel, R Naumann, A O¡enhausser, J Ruhe, EK Schmidt,WW Shen, A Sinner. J Biotechnol 74:137, 2000. J Radler, E Sackmann. Curr Opin Solid State Matter 2:330, 1997. SW Lucas, MM Harding. Anal Biochem 282:70, 2000. BA Cornell, VL Braach-Maksvytis, LG King, PD Osman, B Raguse, LWieczorek, RJ Pace. Novartis Found Symp 225:231, 1999. SA Glazier, DJ Vanderah, AL Plant, H Bayley, G Valincius, JJ Kasianowicz. Langmuir 16:10428, 2000. L Ding, JH Li, EK Wang, SJ Dong. Thin Solid Films 293:153, 1997. ATA Jenkins, RJ Bushby, N Boden, SD Evans, PF Knowles, QY Liu, RE Miles, SD Ogier. Langmuir 14:4675, 1998. MC Rhoten, JD Burgess, FM Hawkridge. Electrochim Acta 45:2855, 2000. R Naumann, EK Schmidt, A Jonczyk, K Fendler, B Kadenbach, T Liebermann, A O¡enhausser,W Knoll. Biosens Bioelectron 14:651, 1999. R Naumann, A Jonczyk, C Hampel, H Ringsdorf,W Knoll, N Bunjes, P Graber. Bioelectrochem Bioenerget 42:241, 1997. R Naumann, A Jonczyk, R Kopp, J Esch, H Ringsdorf, W Knoll, P Gra«ber. Angew Chem Int Ed 34:2056, 2001. C Steinem, A Jansho¡, F Hohn, M Sieber, HJ Galla. Chem Phys Lipids 89:141, 1997. EK Schmidt, T Liebermann, M Kreiter, A Jonczyk, R Naumann, A O¡enhausser, E Neumann, A Kukol, A Maelicke, W Knoll. Biosens Bioelectron 13:585, 1998. S Heyse, OP Ernst, Z Dienes, KP Hofmann, H Vogel. Biochemistry 37:507, 1998. NM Rao, AL Plant,V Silin, S Wight, SW Hui. Biophys J 73:3066, 1997. MA Cooper, DH Williams. Chem Biol 6:891, 1999. J Pintschovius, K Fendler, E Bamberg. Biophys J 76:827, 1999.
162
Elliott et al.
174.
LS Jung, JS Shumaker-Parry, CT Campbell, SS Yee, MH Gelb. J Am Chem Soc 122:4177, 2000. JD Burgess, MC Rhoten, FH Hawkridge. J Am Chem Soc 120:4488, 1998. C Steinem, A Jansho¡, HJ Galla. Chem Phys Lipids 95:95, 1998. T Stora, Z Dienes, H Vogel, C Duschl. Langmuir 16:5471, 2000. G Brink, L Schmitt, R Tampe, E Sackmann. BBA-Biomembranes 1196:227, 1994. ATA Jenkins, J Hu, YZ Wang, S Schiller, R Foerch, W Knoll. Langmuir 16:6381, 2000. C Bieri, OP Ernst, S Heyse, KP Hofmann, H Vogel. Nat Biotechnol 17:1105, 1999. J Lahiri, P Kalal, AG Frutos, ST Jonas, R Schae¥er. Langmuir 16:7805, 2000. ATA Jenkins,T Neumann, A O¡enha«usser. Langmuir 17:265, 2001.
175. 176. 177. 178. 179. 180. 181. 182.
4 Peptide- and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies: Physical and Chemical Characterization for Optimal Function Paul W. Bohn University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, Illinois, U.S.A.
1 1.1
INTRODUCTION Why Biomolecular Films?
Recently, a great deal of attention has been focused on the development of biomaterials derived from peptides, oligopeptides, and proteinacious materials for a variety of technological applications, including chromatographic supportsespecially in a⁄nity chromatographybioreactors, biosensors, and as functionalized building blocks for intelligent materials. There are numerous driving motivations supporting the development of peptide and protein-bearing interfacial structures. Proteins are Mother Nature’s worker bees. A very large number of naturally occurring proteins and protein subunits have been separated, identi¢ed, and characterized structurally and functionally. Thus, they constitute an advantageous starting point for fabrication of interfacial structures which can e¡ect molecular recognition and couple that molecular recognition to a physical or chemical signal. Also, since the study of proteins has a long history and is well developed, many of the tools which have been developed to understand structure and function of proteins in homogeneous solution and in vivo are directly transferable to arti¢cial assemblies, where planar or more complex 163
164
Bohn
interfacial structures are decorated with protein assemblies. Finally, the set of experimental tools known collectively as genetic engineering has been exploited to extend the distribution of naturally occurring proteins, to elaborate their structural and functional capabilities and to provide a rich array of engineered molecular architectures for construction of biomolecular assemblies. One signi¢cant challenge to realizing the full promise of protein-based biomaterials is the development of strategies to assemble complex molecular species into structures with order on the supermolecular length scale, i.e., the mesoscale. On the mesoscale, not only is the inherent structure of each individual molecule important, but a host of other structural details must be considered. How are neighboring molecules oriented, one relative to the next? Do they present the same three-dimensional motifs to the solvent accessible portion of the structure? Is there two-dimensional or even threedimensional crystalline order in the assembly? Are the molecules su⁄ciently close and oriented properly such that intermolecular communication can be accomplished electrically, optically, or mechanically? Finally, there is the overriding concern that the native functionality of the immobilized protein or peptide is retained after being incorporated in the assembly. 1.2
Importance of Proper Characterization
Given the complexity of the structures which are contemplated, and the degree of detail about structure and function which is required, it is critical that a suite of powerful characterization methodologies be developed in concert with the synthetic and assembly strategies used to fabricate biomolecular ¢lms.These characterization strategies are required to yield di¡erent information in some circumstances than in others, but in all cases must draw a tight connection between the structure of the biomolecular assemblies and their designed function. There are a number of hurdles to overcome to properly characterize biomolecular assemblies. The ¢rst of these clearly is measurement sensitivity. Interfacial structures inherently are composed of a very small number of molecules. In the case of a close-packed monolayer of a protein with a characteristic 1000 —2 molecular footprint and areal density of 1013cm2, a characterization experiment which accesses a 100 mm 100 mm area of the interface, to the exclusion of all the background material surrounding it, is still only interrogating ca. 1 femtomole ( ¼1015 mol) of material. Of course, as the area probed becomes smaller, the number of molecules addressed decreases proportionately. Fortunately, experimental tools have been developed to address interfaces which generate signals large enough to distinguish small numbers of analyte species, even individual molecules in
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
165
favorable cases, so the small number of molecules available to be probed is not an insurmountable hurdle per se. It does, however, place signi¢cant constraints on the background generated by the surrounding materials, both solid and liquid, which may be used while still permitting useful characterization. Fluorescence spectroscopy, for example, is easily capable of generating signals which allow an individual molecule to be detected and distinguished from its neighbors. However, the background must either be completely devoid of emissive or scattering centers, or the experiment must reject signals generated from volumes of space other than the region being probed. Another key consideration is the length scale of the experiments which are used to characterize the biomolecular assemblies. It is important to distinguish between experiments that are characteristically molecular but provide information averaged over a macroscopic area and those which intrinsically sample the system on the nanometer length scale. In the depth dimension this issue is straightforward, because there are a number of localization phenomena, primarily optical, which can be used to provide a small and readily locatable sampling volume. Many of these optical localization phenomena scale with excitation wavelength, so it is possible to tune the volume probed simply by tuning the excitation wavelength. Achieving high spatial resolution with molecular speci¢city in the transverse, or in-plane direction, is much more di⁄cult, however. Optical experiments are limited by the di¡raction associated with the far-¢eld projection of sub wavelength image details. Tremendous advances have occurred in the past 15 years, primarily in the introduction of scanned probe microscopies which can elucidate molecular detail on the nanometer length scale and below. Scanned probe microscopies have rapidly come to the fore to play a major role in the characterization of interfacial structures generally, and biomolecular assemblies in particular. Finally, the very nature of peptide- and protein-containing biomolecules leads to another measurement challenge. In nature, most proteins derive their characteristic function from only a small portion of the molecule. In order to characterize biomolecular ¢lms composed of peptides and proteins properly, it is important to understand how the molecular sca¡olding interacts with the functional portion of the molecule to moderate its functionality in a biomolecular assembly. As but one example, surface-immobilized metalloproteins can undergo partial denaturation which disrupts the molecular sca¡olding directing the precise three-dimensional placement of the heme moiety, consequently disturbing, or in severe cases completely eliminating, the characteristic binding and spectroscopic properties associated with the heme prosthetic group.
166
1.3
Bohn
Scope of the Review
This chapter will focus on the physical and chemical characterization tools which have been successfully applied to characterization of bio¢lms composed of peptide and protein-based molecules. There are a variety of interesting biomolecular structures composed of sugar-based and oligonucleotide-based materials that have achieved both scienti¢c and technological interest. Although inclusion of these materials is beyond the scope of this chapter, in many cases the techniques and approaches applied to protein-containing ¢lms are also germane to characterizing biomolecular assemblies of these materials. The chapter will focus primarily on characterization, although some attention will be given to the methods of assembly which have been used to prepare complex monolayer and multilayer biomolecular assemblies. Although fabrication is not the major focus of this chapter, in some cases the method of assembly places constraints on the characterization tools which have to be considered in order to construct a detailed picture of how biomolecular structure a¡ects function. The characterization tools themselves are divided into those tools which are primarily physical and those which yield chemical information, although clearly some experiments have both characteristics. For example, the use of chemically derivatized tips in scanned force microscopies (SFMs) imparts molecular selectivity to the signal, yet the signal-generation process is primarily a physical event. Finally, the examples chosen to highlight the points made in the review are meant to be illustrativethis is not an exhaustive review of the current literature. If it were, the subject chosen for the current chapter could easily justify its own monograph. 2 2.1
METHODS OF ASSEMBLY Nonspecific Adsorption
From the contemporary perspective, nonspeci¢c adsorption is seen as an unwanted side product of a molecular assembly process which was designed to yield a speci¢c architecture in three dimensions. Nonspeci¢c adsorption thus gives rise to a dispersion in the structural presentation of protein and peptide motifs which is typically unwanted. The earlier literature, however, treats the native adsorption of proteins at surfaces as an interesting phenomenon to be studied in and of itself. Much of the pre-1985 interest in nonspeci¢c adsorption of proteins was driven by the need to understand plasma protein interactions with biomaterials which came into contact with blood. It was recognized early that protein transport to and from, and adsorption on, a foreign surface was much more rapid than the subsequent colonization by cells, e.g., platelets, leukocytes, erythrocytes, etc. These early studies had
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
167
a clear biomedical motivation to develop nonthrombogenic materials to be used in implanted devices, and they motivated a large number of studies of the fundamental mechanisms driving adsorption of plasma-borne proteins onto progressively more carefully prepared surfaces. Fluorescence spectroscopy and microscopy were key characterization tools used to study both kinetic and equilibrium properties of native protein adsorption in these systems [1^3]. A particularly important aspect of these early studies was the parallel development of total internal re£ection £uorescence (TIRF) spectroscopy as a tool for the direct interrogation of protein surface interactions [4,5].The development of TIRF methods was especially important because it allowed the interface between two disparate materials, e.g., the solid ^ liquid interface, to be investigated while rejecting the background arising from either of the two surrounding bulk phases. Furthermore, it is useful in the study of adsorbed proteins at biointerfaces, because a signal can be obtained which is quantitatively related to the number density of probed protein species at the interface. This quantitative capability can be used to monitor the amount and kinetics of adsorbed proteins, their conformational and orientation states, and how the interaction of an adsorbed protein with a solution-borne ligand a¡ects the £uorescence intensity. The advances in characterization capability represented by the TIRF technique was one development which spurred additional advances in the sophistication of biomolecular assembly methods, for example, the development of wettability gradient surfaces as a mechanism to display di¡erential protein surface interactions spatially [6,7]. 2.2
Langmuir-Blodgett Deposition
Given the interest in preparing well-characterized interfaces for studies of protein and peptide adsorption, it is natural that the Langmuir-Blodgett (LB) techniques were the ¢rst of the directed assembly techniques to be exploited.The LB process inherently a¡ords two-dimensional organization, i.e., polar order, at the air ^ water interface,which can be readily exploited for the preparation of organized biomolecular assemblies. LB techniques can be powerfully ampli¢ed by using them to position and orient molecular recognition moieties, and a great deal of early work focused on the avidin ^ biotin and streptavidin ^ biotin systems. Both avidin and streptavidin are strong biotin-speci¢c binding proteins. Streptavidin is composed of four subunits arranged such that two binding pockets each are arrayed on opposite sides of the protein, each subunit capable of binding one biotin moiety with remarkable speci¢city [8]. Furthermore, it was discovered that interaction with biotin-containing monolayers can facilitate two-dimensional
168
Bohn
crystallization of streptavidin at the air ^ water interface. The attainment of two-dimensional crystalline order at an interface was a key step, because for the ¢rst time it allowed translational symmetry to be attained in biomolecular assemblies,thereby opening these materials to the powerful techniques capable of characterizing crystalline order (Scheme 1) [9^11]. LB techniques are also advantageous, because the surface pressure at which biomolecular recognition events are studied at the air ^ water interface, or at which biomolecular ¢lms are transferred to a solid substrate, go a long way toward determining the density and molecular organization with which the active biomolecules are presented. Thus, the physical state of the lipid matrix elements are coupled to the binding characteristic of the receptors which are incorporated in the bio¢lms. LB techniques also allow for two-dimensional ordering and presentation of intermediate reactive species. An early and elegant demonstration of this principal was obtained by Samuelson and coworkers in the their development of a two-dimensionally ordered photodynamic protein system based on speci¢c molecular recognition utilizing either biotin ^ avidin or biotin ^ streptavidin [10].
SCHEME 1 Schematic representation of a biotin^streptavidin two-dimensional crystal at the air^water interface. The tetrameric streptavidin protein layer is indicated as partially filled with biotin molecules, which are terminated either with reactive moieties, X, or lipid tails. (Reprinted and adapted with permission from Ref. 9. Copyright 1993 American Association for the Advancement of Science.)
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
169
The immunoglobulins constitute another attractive system for exploiting LB technology. Dubrovsky and coworkers exploited the immunological reaction mediated by immunoglobulin G (IgG) organized at the air ^ water interface by binding it to the protein A [12]. They found that protein A organized the molecular assembly by binding only to the Fc arm of IgG molecules, increasing the number of active antibody elements which had their active components in sterically unhindered positions for solution binding, and thereby enhancing the density of ligand binding after transfer of the LB layer to a solid surface. Increases in binding between 10- and 100-fold of rabbit-derived anti-mouse IgG toward mouse IgG were found relative to the nonspeci¢c case. 2.3
Self-Assembly
The development of self-assembly was a truly revolutionary development in the capabilities of researchers to prepare interfacial assemblies with desired properties. Initial e¡orts focused largely on preparation of derivatized silicon oxide surfaces using silane-based nucleophilic substitution chemistry [13^17]. While a number of innovative self-assembly schemes were implemented based on this chemistry, the introduction of self-assembly based on Au ^ thiol chemistry by Whitesides, Nuzzo, and coworkers [18^21] had a much broader impact on the assembly of biomolecular architectures generally and protein-based architectures in particular. There are a number of reasons for the wide implementation of the Au ^ thiol chemistry. Au ¢lms can be prepared readily with a predominant (111) surface orientation by simple thermal evaporation, and the crystallography can be further re¢ned by postdeposition annealing, meaning that large terraces with well-de¢ned crystallographic properties are accessible with modest equipment investment. Au, as a coinage metal, is particularly resistant to chemical degradation of the surface, meaning that oxidation, which is a problem for transition metals generally, and more of a problem for Ag and Cu, is less an issue in Au chemistry.The ability to elaborate the o end of mercaptans synthetically gives rise to a very large number of potential reactive moieties which can be investigated and greatly enhances the power of the Au-thiol self-assembly process for producing biomolecular assemblies. Furthermore, Au can also be electrolessly deposited, so that it is possible to prepare Au coatings on nonplanar surfaces and even surfaces to which a line-of-sight path is not available. One ¢nal advantage of the Au ^ thiol system derives from the ready application of a number of widely used characterization tools, e.g., electrochemistry, surface plasmon resonances (SPRs), and external re£ection infrared absorption measurements, to characterize the assemblies on Au surfaces and thin Au ¢lms [22^26].
170
2.4
Bohn
Multilayer Assemblies
The real power of both LB and self-assembly techniques lies in the ability to place reactive moieties in solvent-accessible regions of molecules where they are available for subsequent reaction with species in the adjacent phase. By placing the reactive moiety at a particular location in the molecule and presenting the molecule to the interface in a well-de¢ned geometry, it is possible to direct reactions spatially to occur at a well-de¢ned location. The reactions themselves may be either thermal or, in a particularly powerful approach, photochemical. An exemplar of the photochemical approach is contained in work by Michel and coworkers [27]. They adsorbed an ofunctionalized dialkyl disul¢de on Au and in two steps converted this to a photoactive benzophenone derivative with good overall yield. Subsequently, antibodies were photoimmobilized on the surface in regions which were irradiated, resulting in a covalently linked antibody as determined by a number of di¡erent assays (cf. Scheme 2) The obvious advantage of introducing photoreactive moieties is the ability to exploit optical lithography to produce laterally patterned structures with micrometer and submicrometer spatial extent. Two other methods of multilayer assembly, which are related to but su⁄ciently distinct from self-assembly to merit mention on their own, are molecular grafting and electrostatic self-assembly. Molecular grafting starts with an appropriate surface-bound monomer, and by controlling chemistry repeat units may be added one at a time, thereby successively growing a polymer from the surface up. Directionally aligned helical peptides on Au have been obtained in this manner by directly grafting and growing an oligopeptide up from the surface [28]. Starting with a trithiolamine, N-carboxyanhydride coupling was used to add sequential layers of alanine to build up a poly(alanine) helical peptide. The great power of this technique is that molecular control is exerted on a peptide-by-peptide basis on the structure of the polymer, thereby acquiring control over primary structure and in many cases over secondary structure as well. Electrostatic selfassembly is a relatively new development in which polyelectrolytes of a de¢ned charge are added, layer by layer, in an alternating charge fashion, in order to create multilayer structures with de¢ned geometric characteristics. A particularly elegant use of this strategy has been demonstrated by Corn and coworkers using positively charged poly(lysine) in order to direct the assembly of subsequent negatively charged DNA oligomers [29,30]. The advantage accruing to the electrostatic self-assembly process is that it can be applied to almost any surface. It does not require a given starting surface, such as Au or SiO2, in order to build up sophisticated multilayer assemblies.
SCHEME 2 Schematic representation of the preparation of a photoreactive monolayer for IgG immobilization. (I) Assembly of the activated ester. (II) Reaction with the diamine. (III) Reaction with the isothiocyanate derivative of benzophenone. (IV) UV immobilization of the IgG. (Adapted from and reprinted with permission from Ref. 27. Copyright 1996 American Chemical Society.)
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies 171
172
3 3.1
Bohn
PHYSICAL CHARACTERIZATION Microscopy
Optical microscopy is the oldest of the techniques used to bring structural detail out of biomolecular assemblies. Yet it has proven to be an evergreen, especiallyasitis applied tostructuresinwhich lateralchangesinchemistryare used to e¡ect di¡erential organization of biomolecular assemblies [31^33],or situations in which the behavior of an external agent such as biological cell is of interest [34^38]. Especially important in this regard is the coupling of the basic microscopy experiment with a large number of image-enhancement methodologies and data treatments, for example, £uorescence microscopy, confocal microscopy, di¡erential interference contrast work, and the powerful array of image processing tools which have become available with ready access to imaging detectors. The power of simple optical microscopy to provide information on surface chemistry, as it can be used to direct biomolecular assembly, is illustrated by work performed by Friedman and collaborators [33]. These investigators were interested in identifying solution conditions which would lead to the growth of large optically accessible crystals of proteins such as lysozyme, a-lactalbumin, ribonuclease, hemoglobin, thaumatin, and catalase. Optical microscopy easily allowed areal density of crystal growth and crystal morphology to be characterized, so the development of certain crystalline motifs could be correlated with the solution conditions used in their preparation. In another illustrative example, Keana and coworkers investigated the photochemical derivatization of polymers to produce micrometer-scale structures decorated with biomolecules using deep UV-lithography of substituted per£uorophenyl azides.They used £uorescence microscopy of labeled horseradish peroxidase, bound selectively in areas of a micrometer-scale test pattern, to characterize the contrast obtained by their derivatization procedures and were able to correlate the £uorescence obtained from their images with spectrophotometric measures of enzyme activity for the bound species [31]. While optical microscopy has proven to be a valuable adjunct to other chemical and physical tools for characterizing simple surface chemistries, it is absolutely indispensable for studies of large supermolecular structures, such as biological cells, on surfaces. There has been a great deal of activity aimed at understanding the adhesion and spreading properties of various types of cells on model surfaces as a means to advance the design of biomaterials for implantable prostheses. Whitesides and co-workers studied the wetting and protein adsorptive behavior of alkanethiolate self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on Au ¢lms thin enough that optical microscopy could be done in transmission [32]. They successfully obtained phase-contrast micrographs of MG63 osteosarcoma cells on a patterned SAM and were able
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
173
to demonstrate dramatic di¡erences in attachment between hydroxylterminated SAMs and adjacent methyl-terminated SAMs. Ratner, Allara, and their co-workers studied the relationship between protein adsorption and endothelial cell growth on o-functionalized alkanethiolate SAMs on Au [35].Using optical microscopy as the primary tool for evaluating cell density and cell growth as a function of time and conditions, they were able to show that cells seated on a substrate in serum-containing medium interact with an adsorbed protein layer rather than with the substrate on which the protein rests, and they were able to make general conclusions about the rates of cell growth and their dependence on the terminal functionality of the alkanethiolate SAM. These simple experiments demonstrated conclusively that cell growth on tissue culture polystyrene outstripped growth rates on all of the monofunctional alkanethiolate SAMs studied, thereby implicating multiple chemical functionalities in the promotion of cell growth and spreading. Beyer and co-workers studied the derivatization of poly[(1-methylvinylisocyanate)-alt-(maleic anhydride)] with a variety of bioactive side chains, including a 22-amino acid peptide derived from the a chain of mouse laminin and an aminopropyl poly(ethylene glycol) monomethyl ether, as supports for hippocampal cell cultures [37]. Using both phase-contrast and £uorescence microscopy, they characterized the development of neural processes and showed that neural cell adhesion requires the presence of the polypeptide derived from laminin. Cell ^ semiconductor hybrids constitute an exciting new area of investigation in which one seeks to establish electrical communication between a biological cell, typically a neuron, and a prefabricated semiconductor device on which the cell is placed and grows.Gaub and coworkers examined hybrids of normal rat kidney ¢broblasts on semiconductors as a model system to replace heart muscle cells or nerve cells [36]. Fibroblasts have the advantage that they may be easily maintained in cell culture, eliminating the need to work from primary culture. These investigators used re£ection interference contrast microscopy and comparisons to atomic force microscopy (AFM) to characterize the behavior of heart muscle cells and normal rat kidney ¢broblasts side by side. Re£ection interference contrast microscopy is particularly powerful in these applications because the micrographs show regions of close contact, allowing investigators to identify focal contact regions and compare them with the global cell morphology. Optical microscopy of biomolecular assemblies and biological cells is particularly powerful when coupled with £uorescence derived from labeled antibodies to structural proteins characteristic of speci¢c elements of cytoskeletal organization. Tresco and coworkers studied the relationship among cell attachment, spreading, cytoskeletal organization, and migration rate for MC3T3-EL oesteoblasts on a variety of glass surfaces di¡ering in the
174
Bohn
nature of the terminal functional moieties of the organosilane SAMs [38]. It was especially important to be able to observe di¡erences in actin and vinculin organization of these 3T3 oesteoblasts in delineating di¡erences between cell attachment and spreading behavior on thiol and oxidized-thiol surfaces versus those surfaces terminated with quaternary amines and methyl groups. The results clearly illustrated the importance of the speci¢c chemistry of the surface rather than generic parameters, such as wettability, in determining cellular behavior. 3.2
Optical Properties
3.2.1 Ellipsometry Re£ection of electromagnetic radiation from smooth interfaces invariably alters the polarization properties of the radiation and provides a powerful mechanism to characterize the optical frequency dielectric response of the interface and the surrounding media. The amplitude re£ectivity, r, can be written as jrp j iðyp ys Þ e ¼ tan ceiD ð1Þ r¼ jrs j where p and s refer to the polarization state of the radiation, y is the phase shift upon re£ection, and r is the amplitude re£ectivity. The right-hand side of the above equation is the formal de¢nition of amplitude re£ectivity in terms of the ellipsometric parameters D and c. Single-wavelength null ellipsometry is the most common variant of the ellipsometric experiment and is performed by varying the general state of elliptically polarized light in the incident beam, until the re£ection from the surface produces a linearly polarized output which is then characterized. Once the ellipsometric parameters of the system have been determined, a generalized version of the ellipsometry equation is combined with the Fresnel relations for multilayer interface systems, and the entire system of equations is inverted to obtain the dielectric response and thicknesses of the relevant layers of the biomolecular assembly. Clearly, the complexity of this inversion process depends directly on the number of layers in the sample and the number of layers in the system for which the optical properties are known prior to the experiment. For reasons that will be apparent below, the applications of ellipsometry have been far outstripped by measurements of surface plasmon resonances. Nevertheless, ellipsometry has been used in a number of systems to characterize biomolecular assemblies. Lu and coworkers examined the oriented immobilization of IgG Fab0 fragments on SiO2 surfaces using ellipsometry to determine the surface concentration of the immobilized fragments [39]. Both oriented and randomly coupled IgG fragments were
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
175
covalently bound to derivatized silica surfaces containing pyridyl disul¢de groups. By comparing the total amount of immobilized immunoglobulin fragment to the active component determined from immunoassays, the authors were able to demonstrate large di¡erences in antigen-binding activity for fragments which are oriented with their active surfaces available to solution, thereby emphasizing the power of oriented molecular assemblies. Suci and coworkers demonstrated the utility of ellipsometry for characterizing sophisticated multilayer structures in their examination of biotinylated lipid ^ streptavidin Fab multilayer construction [40]. Ellipsometry was used to characterize the uptake of a biotinylated Fab fragment onto the preorganized streptavidin template by monitoring changes in the ellipsometric parameters ddD and ddc as a function of the active component in the solution phase. Comparison of the optical parameters derived from ellipsometric measurements indicated a dense attachment of the biotinylated Fab fragment to the surface. One important advantage retained by ellipsometry over SPR measurements is that it may be applied to a large number of substrate materials, whereas SPR measurements are largely con¢ned to systems fabricated on the coinage metals Au, Ag, and Cu. However, high accuracy is achieved only when working near the Brewster angle. Given the fact that optimal performance is obtained near a speci¢c angle, ellipsometric imaging can only be achieved through the aegis of imagining detectors. Recently, Sackmann and coworkers developed a high-resolution imaging microellipsometer which promises to advance the state of characterization of biofunctionalized surfaces, cf. Fig. 1 [41]. In their apparatus, the re£ected light from a collimated source is collected with a long-distance working objective and passed through a rotating analyzer before being projected onto the active area of a CCD camera by a tube lens. They were able to achieve lateral resolution of 3 mm and a height resolution of 5 — working at angles far from the Brewster angle and imaging areas of the order of a few tens to hundreds of square micrometers. The performance achieved in these studies promises to be a helpful adjunct to studies in which the biomolecular assembly of interest cannot be formed on a substrate suitable for SPR imaging. 3.2.2 Surface Plasmon Resonances (SPRs) The collective electron resonances which are pinned at the interface between metals and dielectrics can be e⁄ciently excited for a select group of metals, namely, Ag, Cu, and Au. These resonances, termed surface plasmon resonances, derive from the resonance conditions in the bulk dielectric functions of the two materials, and are contained implicitly in the Fresnel relations describing the optical response of a multilayer stack containing the
176
Bohn
FIG. 1 (a) Schematic diagram of the microimaging ellipsometer. (b) Ellipsometric images of n-C16H34 dewetting transition on thermally oxidized Si at 5 min (left) and 8 min (right) after deposition. (Adapted from Ref. 41. Copyright 1998 American Institute of Physics.)
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
177
metal and dielectric of interest. Surface plasmons are useful for the characterization of interfaces, because (1) they provide an enhanced electromagnetic ¢eld amplitude at the interface, (2) surface plasmons decay over a relatively short distance, with electric ¢elds having 1=e distances of a few hundred angstroms in the adjacent dielectric, and (3) they are completely p-polarized, leading to the acquisition of spatial orientation information about the dipoles with which they interact. In the characterization of biomolecular assemblies, surface plasmons (SPs) are typically excited in the Kretschmann geometry shown in Fig. 2.The molecular assembly of interest is usually applied as an adlayer on the SP supporting metal. Since, at a given frequency, the wave vector of a photon instant from vacuum is smaller than that of the surface plasmon with the same frequency, it is necessary to increase the momentum so that both energy and momentum conservation can be satis¢ed simultaneously. Kretschmann developed a simple and elegant solution to this conservation condition based on placing the SP supporting metal ¢lm on the base of a
FIG. 2 Schematic diagram of the sample configuration in a typical SPR experiment used to monitor protein binding events at a solid^liquid interface. The specific system depicted is meant to convey streptavidin (tetrameric solution phase component) binding to a biotinylated lipid present in the outer portion of a phospholipid double layer assembled on SiOx. (Adapted from Ref. 47. Copyright 1992 Biophysical Society.)
178
Bohn
high-index prism or hemicylinder,the refractive index of the prism serving to increase the wave vector of the incident bulk electromagnetic mode so that its p-component may be matched to the real part of the SP resonance of the same frequency. When the resonance is satis¢ed, excitation is coupled into the collective oscillation of electrons at the interface, thereby frustrating the near-total re£ection which would otherwise apply for the metal ^ dielectric interface. The coupling of energy into the surface plasmon is accompanied by a decrease in the bulk re£ectivity and an increase in Rayleigh scatter. The position of the SP resonance may be calculated from " # osp em es 1=2 ¼ k0 np sin yp ð2Þ Refksp g ¼ Re c em þ es where subscripts m, s, and p stand for metals, superstrate, and prism, respectively, and k0 is the vacuum wave vector of the instant radiation. An excellent summary of the underlying physics supporting the use of surface plasmons for characterizing biomolecular assemblies is contained in a recent review [22]. The most prevalent use of surface plasmons has involved characterizing interfacial binding events between immobilized receptors and solutionborne ligands [30,42^49]. Ligand binding and=or formation of a macromolecular complex with a solution-borne component naturally changes the optical dielectric function of the interfacial layer, which is most commonly characterized by a shift in the position of the SP resonance in momentum space, cf. Fig. 3. Qualitatively, the shift in surface plasmon resonance may be used to monitor the extent of modi¢cation of the interfacial layer. Quantitative measurements, however, are less straightforward. While the position and shape of the SPR resonance depend directly on the optical properties of the interface, inverting the equations in order to obtain the optical dielectric response function, including both refractive index and thickness information, requires rather more e¡ort than is typically devoted to the experiment in studies of biomolecular binding. In experiments where optical property data are obtained, it is common to ¢x either the refractive index or the thickness and to calculate changes in the other parameter to ¢t the shifts in the SPR resonance code. To determine both parameters simultaneously for a single ¢lm requires either measurements at two wavelengths or measurements under di¡erent superstrate refractive index conditions [50,51]. Whitesides and coworkers demonstrated that SPR measurements could be used to monitor nonspeci¢c adsorption of proteins in situ and in real time, by monitoring the deposition of RNase A, lysozyme, ¢brinogen, and pyruvate kinase on a set of mixed SAMs comprised of ethylene
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
179
FIG. 3 SPR reflectivity curves for a bare Au surface (*) and after deposition of sequential adlayers of HS(CH2)10CO2H (~), poly(lysine) ( ), and avidin ( ffl ). (Adapted and reprinted with permission from Ref. 30. Copyright 1995 American Chemical Society.)
oxide- and methyl-terminated alkanethiolates [45]. Their experimental methodology, which is now common, used an array detector to monitor a range of angles around the central portion of the plasmon resonance curve containing the minimum. Then the position of the minimum was ¢tted onthe-£y to determine the shift in optical properties, and this was then plotted in real time to follow the biomolecular events of interest. They and others have used this approach, or closely related variants, to follow a large number of biochemically interesting surface interaction systems, including the binding of carbonic anhydrase to self-assembled monolayers of alkanethiolates terminated with benzenesulfonamide groups on Au, and a number of studies in which surfaces designed to resist protein adsorption are characterized by SPR [42,44]. Corn and coworkers demonstrated how powerful it is to use SPR in conjunction with in situ Fourier transform-infrared spectroscopy for the characterization of multilayer assemblies. They exploited the electrostatic multilayer assembly technique to develop structures which present DNA oligomers for biosensing and DNA computing applications [30,52]. In these studies, an ionized carboxylic acid-terminated alkanethiolate was used as a template on which poly(lysine), a polycationic electrolyte, was adsorbed simultaneously with a positively charged avidin layer. The
180
Bohn
avidin then provided a template for the adsorption of biotinylated oligonucleotides. One of the most powerful factors in explaining the popularity of SPR measurements is the fact that thin Au ¢lms can also serve as substrates for in-situ electrochemistry and for external re£ection IR measurements, as recently demonstrated by work from Mrksich’s laboratory [49]. They assembled mixed alkanethiolate SAMs in which a fraction of the terminal functional groups were composed of hydroquinone moieties which could undergo reversible electron transfer to shuttle them between dihydroxy and quinoid-like forms, the quinoid-like form subsequently being reactive in a Diels-Alder addition with a biotinylated cyclopentadiene. The ability to follow the appearance of the quinoid-like form electrochemically, and to monitor the subsequent immobilization of streptavidin, through interaction with the biotinylated reaction product was a powerful adjunct in being able to work out the biomolecular assembly in this instance. It must also be said that much of the popularity of SPR measurement to monitor biomolecular binding is due to the advent of commercial instrumentation. The most prevalent commercial instrument is based on work done at Pharmacia in which hydrogel matrices are formed from carboxymethylated dextran to provide a matrix on the Au surface which can mediate reversible biochemical binding. Although the measurement principles are just as described above, the presence of the hydrogel matrix transforms the measurement. It impedes the direct adsorption of proteins at the interface, thereby avoiding problems with protein denaturation, and it greatly increases the mass sensitivity by increasing the volume sensed from a little more than a molecular monolayer to a volume extending an appreciable portion of the 1=e decay length of the surface plasmon ¢eld [53]. Relatively early in the use of surface plasmons as a tool for investigating biomolecular interfaces, it became clear that a simple change in the optics could transform the SPR measurement from a spatially integrating measurement, to one in which microscopic image information could be obtained, cf. Fig. 4. Gaub and coworkers exploited this capability and used SPR imaging to monitor the assembly of Fab0 fragments of a monoclonal antibody raised against a dinitrophenol hapten covalently bound to a phospholipid [54]. Dinitrophenol-labeled bovine serum albumin (BSA) was used as an antigen and monitored as it bound to the Fab0 fragment of the derivatized phospholipid. Step heights between protein-rich and surrounding phospholipid matrix domains were measured, and the data were found to agree well with the dimensions of crystallized Fab0 fragments. The spatial resolution in SP microscopy is limited not by the optical di¡raction limit, but by the spatial decay length of the SP resonances themselves. The
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
181
FIG. 4 Schematic diagram of the surface plasmon resonance microscope. Note the incident radiation is well collimated, and the image is processed by the collection lens (a microscope objective) onto an imaging detector of high spatial fidelity. (Adapted and reprinted with permission from Ref. 54. Copyright 1993 American Chemical Society.)
SP resonance is a propagating resonance with a characteristic in-plane decay length typically from a few micrometers up to many tens of micrometers depending on the optical parameters of the interface. Because the spatial resolution in an experiment in which the SP resonance is monitored cannot be any better than its propagation length, the spatial resolution in SP microscopy is typically degraded relative to that of phase-contrast optical microscopy. Nevertheless, the unique nature of the information which is obtained from the SP experiment, as well as its ability to monitor interfacial biochemical events, maintains high interest in this and continued e¡orts to develop microscopy exploiting the surface plasmon phenomenon [55,56]. A somewhat more challenging application of SPR involves using the shifts produced in the SP resonance to follow conformational or orientational changes in biomolecular components, because the resulting changes in optical properties are typically much smaller than for corresponding addition of a separate ligand or binding partner. Nevertheless, a number of groups have successfully exploited SPR to do just this. The simplest approach to using surface plasmons to monitor molecular orientation uses a subsequent recognition event to detect that orientation. In work from Gerisch’s laboratory a biosensor was modi¢ed to monitor the contact site A
182
Bohn
glycoprotein from the aggregating cells of Dictyostelium discoideum [57]. The protein was ¢xed in a known orientation by cross-linking with per£uorophenylazide, and the surfaces thus obtained were challenged with antibodies raised against either the native or denatured glycoprotein. Here the orientation was detected by the presence or absence of the immunocomplex. Direct determination of protein conformation was obtained by Sota and co-workers, who monitored changes in immobilized dihydrofolate reductase derived from Escherichia coli and attached to a carboxymethyl dextran matrix [58]. Exposure of the immobilized protein to an acidic environment resulted in changes in the SPR resonance position which corresponded to similar pH-induced changes in the molar ellipticity of the protein in homogeneous solution. Dufour and coworkers studied the use of SPR measurements and epitope mapping to monitor protein conformation as displayed through binding of ¢ve di¡erent anti-b-lactoglobulin monoclonal antibodies. Binding of the monoclonal antibodies was used as evidence of the presence of the native epitopes accruing from the original b-lactoglobulin [59]. Given the great success of SPR measurements in addressing a wide range of biomolecular assemblies, it is not surprising that SPR resonance measurements have made their way into a number of speci¢cally targeted biosensing platforms [43,60^62]. Bergener and coworkers developed an SPR-based biosensor to study the hybridization characteristics of peptide nucleic acid ligands, immobilized on sensor surfaces [60]. They found that covalently immobilized sensing molecules exhibited superior performance to those simply physically adsorbed, and they demonstrated that a perfectly matched peptide nucleic acid allowed the detection of singlestrand DNA at a sensitivity better than 1% of the background in a singlestranded DNA having a single C-to-T point mutation in the complement to the peptide nucleic acid. Kooyman and coworkers demonstrated another advantageous feature of SP resonances in their application to biosensing by showing how a parallel array of sensing modalities could be constructed in a single monolithic device [61]. Finally, a very interesting development in the use of SPR for biosensing by Natan and coworkers involved enhancement of SPR sensitivity by coupling the ligand to colloidal Au particles to create an antigen ^ Au colloid conjugate which, when arrayed near the original Au ^ dielectric interface, caused a larger shift in SP resonance than would have been observed by simple molecular binding alone. This enhancement in the shift and the change in the shape of the SP resonance is general and potentially quite powerful, since a great deal of chemistry exists, primarily derived from the electron microscopy literature, for speci¢cally coupling a wide variety of biomolecules to Au colloids [62].
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
3.3
183
Mechanical Properties
3.3.1 Quartz Crystal Microbalance (QCM) Measurements Another exceptionally sensitive and simple approach to monitoring changes in the composition of interfacial biomolecular layers is obtained through the piezoelectric e¡ect, in which an electric ¢eld applied across a piezoelectric material induces a stress in that material. When driven at the vibrational resonance frequency, the piezoelectric material oscillates, and any change in the mass of the surface of the oscillator results in a change in the vibrational frequency, as has been known since the pioneering work of Sauerbrey in the 1950s [63]. A popular piezoelectric material is ATcut quartz, and the ability to deposit thin gold layers on the surface of the quartz without signi¢cantly disrupting its piezoelectric properties means that all of the chemical and biochemical advantages which accrue to the use of AU ¢lms in SPR measurements also apply to QCM measurements [64]. The key ¢gures of merit in judging the QCM measurement are sensitivity to mass adsorption and ability to distinguish authentic mass-induced frequency shifts from non-signal-related sources of frequency shift. Mass sensitivity is easily capable of achieving submonolayer detection limits for typical biomolecular binding events. In cases where direct binding is not adequate to achieve frequency shift of the magnitude needed, sandwich assays can be implemented in which a secondary species is generated and used to accentuate the frequency shift, cf. Fig. 5.The inability to discriminate unambiguously between mass-induced changes in resonance frequency and frequency shifts due to environmentally induced changes in viscoelastic properties of materials adsorbed to the surface is a distinct disadvantage to the QCM measurement. However, frequently in studies of biomolecular assemblies, the changes in the mechanical response of the adsorbed layers is minor compared to changes in mass, so this disadvantage is not as troublesome as it might be. Many of the same biomolecular motifs used in studies performed with SPR are used in QCM measurements, i.e., immunochemically linked molecules and molecules linked to surfaces via biotin ^ avidin or biotin ^streptavidin chemistry. For example, Hu and coworkers demonstrated a highly sensitive immunosensor for detection of human complement C4, based on immobilization of an anti-C4 antibody on the surface of a QCM [65]. Protein A was bound to the surface to immobilize the antibody in an oriented fashion, giving results superior to the nonspeci¢c binding of IgG obtained via gluteraldehyde coupling or by physical adsorption. Nicolini et al. also noted the importance of orientation in studying the immunological activity of immunoglobulin Langmuir ¢lms oriented by a protein A sublayer [12]. Kunitake and coworkers used QCM measurements to follow the
184
Bohn
FIG. 5 Ability of the sandwich-type assay to enhance the frequency shift associated with the biomolecular binding event of interest. In this assay monitoring the binding of adenosine phosphosulfate reductase (APS reductase) to its rabbitderived antibody, the sandwich is formed with an enzyme^antibody conjugate which catalyzes the dimerization of 5-bromo-4-chloroindolylphosphate (BICP). (Adapted and reprinted from Ref. 64. Copyright 1990 American Association for the Advancement of Science.)
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
185
layer-by-layer assembly of alternating polycationic and polyanionic electrolytes in the electrostatic assembly process employing poly(ethyleneimine) and poly(styrene sulfonate) [66]. They used electrostatically assembled SAMs to support the adsorption of charged proteins, including cytochrome c, myoglobin, lysozyme, histone F3, glucoamylase, and glucose oxidase. More sophisticated biomolecular motifs have been implemented and monitored by QCM measurements byAizawa and coworkers. They have, for example, made extensive use of genetic engineering to produce fusion proteins in which one component is designed for binding to a surface and the other component for biomolecular binding to a target substrate. In one set of experiments, the B domain of staphylococcal protein A was repeated ¢ve times and terminated with a cysteine residue to facilitate self-assembly on Au. The B domain is a speci¢c IgG-binding domain and was used to immobilize antibody molecules in a highly oriented fashion [67,68].These workers also enhanced the sensitivity of QCM mass changes by binding the receptor, not to a single antibody molecule, but to a lipid-derived antibody which had been inserted into the outer lea£et of a large vesicle, cf. Fig. 6, thereby greatly amplifying the mass change. In structures in which the bacterially produced, lipid-tagged single-chain antibody against 2-phenyloxazolone was incorporated in phosphotidylcholine liposomes, the presence of soluble hapten could inhibit immunoliposome binding in a concentration-dependent manner and resulted in a competitive assay in which antigen was measured in the concentration range down to 108M [69]. Similar strategies were employed in studies of a polyfunctional arti¢cial proteins derived from calmodulin and glutathione-s-transferase. Glutathione was ¢rst self-assembled on Au and used to template the binding of calmodulin through ligand interaction with its partner glutathione-s-transferase. The fusion protein was reversibly adsorbed and desorbed by the binding of solution-borne glutathione in a competitive binding assay [70]. In a separate study, a related fusion protein of calmodulin was used directly by introducing a cysteine residue at the terminus, which could then mediate self-assembly at a Au surface. The authors demonstrated that the engineered calmodulin bound to the surface retained its Ca2þ -responsive modulation of enzyme function [71]. The fact that SPR measurements and QCM measurements both provide physical insight into the addition of molecules to Au ^ dielectric interfaces begs the question of how they compare with respect to critical measurement ¢gures of merit. The question has been addressed from a practical perspective by Sackmann and co-workers, who compared QCM and SPR £ow injection analysis systems for observing nonspeci¢c binding of BSA at Au surfaces and speci¢c binding of BSA to monoclonal antibodies immobilized on Au [72]. They concluded that neither measurement o¡ers a distinct advantage over the other in terms of sensitivity or background
186
Bohn
FIG. 6 Lipid-tagged antibody strategy for enhancing the response of a QCM to a selected binding event. (a, top) Genetic construction of the lipid-tagged antibody. (a, middle) Schematic diagram of the lipid-tagged antibody. (a, bottom) Schematic representation of the competitive binding of free hapten (Ox-CA) and lipid-tagged antibody bearing liposome. (b) Typical QCM response upon being challenged with various solutions. Note the disparity between signal magnitudes of the liposome exposure and exposure to molecular constituents. (Adapted and reprinted with permission from Ref. 69. Copyright 1998 American Chemical Society.)
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
187
FIG. 6 Continued.
rejection. Johannsmann and co-workers addressed the question from a more theoretical perspective and made several interesting observations [73]. First, they noted that the contrast in acoustics is usually far larger than it is in optics, owing to the large di¡erences in shear moduli among di¡erent materials, while refractive indices generally change by only a few percent. This naturally mitigates in the favor of QCM measurements. However, the acoustic thickness approaches the geometric thickness at rather low surface coverages and tends not to increase, as the ¢lm is densi¢ed by prolonged exposure to solution. These authors compared the two measurement principles in the adsorption of streptavidin on self-assembled monolayers of a biotinylated alkanethiol. Although the sensitivities to adsorption are similar, the authors noted an interesting di¡erence in the kinetics of assembly, presumably owing to the geometric thickness saturation e¡ect in QCM measurements, cf. Fig. 7. 3.3.2 Scanned Probe Microscopies Unquestionably, the invention of scanned probe microscopies (SPMs) primarily scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and atomic force
188
Bohn
FIG. 7 Comparison of SPR (a) and QCM (b) measurements of the assembly of streptavidin onto a biotinylated SAM. Panel compares the assembly kinetics as measured through the optical and acoustic thicknesses. (Adapted from Ref. 73. Copyright 2000 American Institute of Physics.)
microscopy (AFM) and then later a whole set of derivative techniques based on these two basic principleshas revolutionized the manner in which interfacial chemistry, physics, and biology is explored. Proteins and peptides immobilized at interfaces tend to develop structure on mesoscopic length scales which cannot be probed by optical microscopy, because the structural details are below the di¡raction limit and are therefore not amenable to direct optical imaging whether through phase-contrast optical microscopy, surface plasmon microscopy, or ellipsometric microscopy. To characterize structure on the sub-micrometer length scale, a wholly new approach is
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
189
required, an approach which is well ¢lled by the scanned probe microscopies. The general principles of scanned probe microscopies are well known, and an excellent recent review exists [74]. The vast majority of SPM studies to characterize biomolecular assemblies make use of AFM or some variant of it. This is understandable, inasmuch as the tunneling requirement of STM limits the ¢lm thicknesses of structures to be studied to 3 nm at most, far smaller than the thickness of typical biological assemblies. Nevertheless, in some limited applications STM can be useful, as demonstrated by the study of the assembly of l-cysteine on Au (111) by Kolb and co-workers [75]. Among the force microscopy e¡orts, two general themes emerge. In one, scanned force microscopies, AFM, tapping mode AFM, etc., are used to make topographic, or force map, images of surfaces and how those surfaces evolve upon exposure to biological agents. In the other set of measurements, the forces which exist between derivatized tips and biologically decorated surfaces are measured as a function of the tip-to-surface separation. A number of instructive AFM-based studies of protein assemblies are available in the literature. Patel and coworkers studied the binding of catalase to Au surfaces modi¢ed by SAMs of acid-terminated alkanethiols of varying chain lengths, in pure ¢lms and in ¢lms with mixtures of chain lengths [76]. They determined that the surfaces with mixed composition facilitated adsorption of catalase relative to pure carboxylate-terminated layers of either chain length. Work in Knobler’s laboratory examined how phase-separated two-component self-assembled organosilane monolayers could direct the selective adsorption of BSA [77]. They prepared twocomponent Langmuir ¢lms composed of octadecyltrichlorosilane and 1H,1H,2H,2H-per£uorodecyltrichlorosilane and showed that the BSA was preferentially adsorbed as aggregates on the CH3 -terminated regions of the patterned monolayers, cf. Fig. 8. AFM also has the advantage that it is applicable to a wider range of underlying substrates, as demonstrated by the study performed in Cullen’s laboratory examining time-resolved adsorption of IgG and glucose oxidase to highly oriented pyrolytic graphite [78]. Aizawa and coworkers also used HOPG in a study of an antibody-binding protein, which they termed (E12B2)n , fabricated to contain a hydrophobic peptide, E12, at one terminus and an antibody-binding peptide, B2, at the other [79]. AFM imaging was used to demonstrate e⁄cient self-assembly on a hydrophobic solid surface, i.e., HOPG. An issue of some concern in the study of soft materials, such as the biologically active assemblies of interest here, is the destruction of the assemblies by the force-sensing cantilevers when they are applied at forces beyond the yield limit of the monolayers being studied. When this is a concern, derivatives of the standard AFM techniques, such as tapping-mode AFM, can be invaluable. They were used
FIG. 8 Topographic AFM images of BSA adsorbed on mixed LB layers of OTS and FTS. Films in (a) and (b) were transferred at 8 mN=m but were compressed at 2 mm=min and 5 mm=min, respectively. (c) Higher-resolution image shows the height of the adsorbed BSA is relatively monodisperse at 25 3 nm. (Adapted and reprinted with permission from Ref. 77. Copyright 1996 American Chemical Society.)
190 Bohn
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
191
byViitala and coworkers in the study of the attachment of Fab0 fragments of a polyclonal anti-human IgG molecule to a polymerizable lipid with the linker group in the terminal position [80]. The linker, attached to a lipid, was imbedded in a monolayer of dilinoleoylphosphatidylethanolamine. AFM conclusively demonstrated that when the monomeric monolayer was used, large apertures were opened in the as-deposited monolayer, thereby completely obviating its usefulness, cf. Fig. 9. In contrast, cross-linking the monomer to produce a two-dimensional sheetlike polymer resulted in planar ¢lms with good structural integrity. Even more information can be obtained by characterizing the distance dependence of the forces generated when a chemically derivatized tip comes near a surface presenting the biological molecule of interest. Mueller and coworkers used force measurements between myelin basic protein (MBP) adsorbed on mica and lipid bilayer surfaces to demonstrate that the presence of myelin basic protein always led to an attractive force between tip and sample [81]. When retracting the tip, MBP molecules were found to exhibit elastic stretching behavior consistent with a wormlike chain model, yielding speci¢c values for persistence lengths and average contour lengths. While attached to a lipid bilayer, MBP did not show elastic stretching behavior. These observations were taken to indicate that MBP adopts a di¡erent conformation when in contact with lipids and that the lipid bilayer structure is strong modi¢ed by MBP attachment. Grunze and coworkers used functionalized scanning force microscope tips to investigate the resistance to protein adsorption of oligo(ethylene oxide)-terminated SAMs [82]. They
FIG. 9 A comparison of tapping-mode AFM images of monomeric (left) and cross-linked (right) linker phospholipid assemblies. (Adapted in part and reprinted with permission from Ref. 80. Copyright 2000 American Chemical Society.)
192
Bohn
observed a long-range hydrophobic attractive interaction for a SAM with three repeat units of ethylene oxide, i.e., (CH2CH2O)3, on Ag, whereas a repulsive force was measured for the same molecule on Au. Furthermore, in the Au system the repulsive force displayed a strong dependence on the intervening solution ionic strength, indicating a signi¢cant electrostatic contribution. The observed di¡erences in behavior between Ag and Au were attributed to distinct molecular conformations of the ethylene oxide units on Au (helical) and Au (all trans). Finally, Stewart and Hlady integrated a standalone scanning force microscope with a re£ection interference contrast microscope to measure the separation between the SFM probe and the sample surface directly. These measurements were then used to interpret a number of seemingly anomalous distance separation results which had been obtained for binding of immunologically active antigen ^ antibody complexes [83]. 4
CHEMICAL CHARACTERIZATION
As powerful as the above tools are, for monitoring changes in the building up of biomolecular assemblies at interfaces, they all su¡er from one critical £awchemical or molecular information must be inferred; it is not developed directly from the signals obtained. Although a very great deal can be learned about biomolecular structures through these techniques, it is evident that experiments providing information about functional groups, prosthetic groups, and speci¢c chemical moieties within a biomolecular assembly will be invaluable as an adjunct to the physical characterization tools discussed above. 4.1
Electronic Structure
4.1.1 Absorption Measurements There are a number of requirements for chemical characterization methods to be used for biomolecular assemblies. First, given the fact that planar interfaces contain a very small number of molecules, high sensitivity is a prerequisite.The experiment must be su⁄ciently unobtrusive that it does not damage or induce change in the biomolecular structure during the course of the experiment. Spectral probes, sensitive to small elements of the biomolecule, are important, because information concerning the disposition of the active site or prosthetic group in peptide and protein assemblies is critical to understanding the mode of interaction with solution-borne species. Finally, since all biological assemblies considered in this chapter are intended for applications in speci¢c biochemical environments, in situ spectral probes are highly desirable.
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
193
For a long time, traditional UV-visible absorption spectroscopy saw only limited application in the study of monolayer assemblies in general, and biological assemblies in particular, due to the small optical absorption cross section associated with typical transitions in the accessible region and the small number of molecules probed in the transmission geometry. Recently, a number of localized excitation strategies have been developed which have greatly enhanced the sensitivity of biomolecular assemblies to optical absorption, thereby placing the direct measurement of optical absorption into the realm of routine characterization probes of these systems. Optical absorption in biomolecular assemblies is particularly powerful when coupled with polarized-light transmission measurements, because the orientation of the electronic transition moment of the probed species can be measured, and thereby provide order parameters for oriented peptide and protein sequences at interfaces. Much of the early work examining monomolecular layers of biologically active molecules relied on prosthetic groups with extremely high inherent molar absorptivity, such as the heme moiety present in the cytochrome metalloproteins [84,85]. Kunitake and coworkers took advantage of the strong absorption of the heme moiety in myoglobin to examine the functional conversion of myoglobin from an oxygen storage protein to a redox enzyme upon exposure to NADH and £avin mononucleotide [86].This work presaged later oriented metalloprotein assembly work in that these investigators cast multibilayer ¢lms which were used to organize the proteins of interest relative to a macroscopic surface which could be used as a geometric ¢ducial plane. Another way in which molecular absorption can be used is demonstrated by the elegant set of experiments conducted by Charych and coworkers, in which they used optical spectroscopic changes in poly (diacetylene) ¢lms as a sensing mechanism for binding of glycolytic-linked moieties such as proteoglycans and glycoproteins [87^89]. They took advantage of the fact that the multivalent character of viral binding at a synthetic membrane, in which the organized supermolecular sensor structure is contained, can give rise to large conformational changes in the polymer side chains, which then disrupt the conjugation in the poly(diacetylene) backbone, shifting the absorption spectrum and resulting in a color change. In recent work, the conformationally induced changes in poly(diacetylene) spectroscopic properties have been used to detect the binding of lectins such as wheat germ agglutinin, concanavalin A, in£uenza virus, and entire E. coli organisms [87]. Planar interfaces can also act as a reference plane for organized and oriented assemblies of metalloproteins. Bohn, Sligar, and their coworkers were the ¢rst to exploit genetic engineering principles to create unique
194
Bohn
reactive sites on the solvent-accessible surface of metalloproteins, in order to link the protein to a reactive site of a self-assembled organosilane monolayer on SiO2 [90^94]. Several di¡erent organosilane-based reactive terminal functional groups were exploited, for reactive coupling to unique cysteine residues, introduced by genetic engineering, into metalloproteins, such as cytochrome b5, cytochrome c, and myoglobin [91,92]. A complete evaluation of all of the factors giving rise to uncertainty in the orientation of myoglobin mutants was performed by characterizing the order of the alkyl linker moieties by Fourier transform-infrared spectroscopy for short, C2 and C3, intermediate, C8, and long, C15, linker chains. The orientation of the terminal carbon ^ carbon bond was monitored by linking the terminal moiety to a dimethylaminopyridine (DMAP) chromophore. This moiety exhibits a linear transition moment pointing along the long molecular axis, so that performing polarized absorption measurements yields the orientation of the transition moment.With these two pieces of information in hand, linear dichroism measurements on the xy-degenerate Soret transition of the heme prosthetic group in myoglobin yielded results which could be compared to model calculations (Fig. 10). These investigators found surface roughness to be a minor contributor in determining overall macromolecular ordering, but the nature of the underlying silane self-assembled coupling layer strongly in£uenced the spatial and functional properties of the chemisorbed protein. Silane layers with short aliphatic chains and long aliphatic chains were found to produce ordered structures, whereas those produced from intermediate-chain-length organosilanes were conformationally disordered. Furthermore, the orientation of myoglobin predicted from the measured orientations of the linkers with the DMAP linear transition moment chromophore agreed exceptionally well with the orientations of the resulting myoglobin SAM, obtained from the orientation of the heme prosthetic group [90]. One of the impediments to studying protein and peptide molecular monolayers and multilayers arises from the sensitivity constraints described above. One obvious solution to the low spectroscopic sensitivity of transmission-based measurements is simply to increase the e¡ective pathlength. Bohn and coworkers were the ¢rst to show how integrated optical waveguide sample geometries could be used to measure absorption properties of adsorbed layers and orientations of molecular transition moments via waveguide linear dichroism measurements [95^97]. This work was later extended in the laboratories of Reichert [98,99] and Saavadra [100,101]. The work of Saavadra and coworkers is particularly interesting in this regard, because they used emission anisotropy obtained from total internal re£ection £uorescence measurements to obtain the distribution of orientations of cytochrome c immobilized on self-assembled monolayers. Their results
FIG. 10 (a, top) Geometric model of a noninteracting chromophore with a transition moment along the long molecular axis. b is the spherical polar angle between the molecular transition moment axis z0 and the surface normal z. (a, bottom) Geometric model of an x^y degenerate oscillator, e.g., the heme prosthetic group. y is the spherical polar angle between the heme normal and the surface normal. (b) Dichroic ratio as a function of the angle of incidence for polarized absorption of the A126C mutant of myoglobin. Solid squares are experimental data, and the solid lines are model calculations for various orientations, y. (Adapted and reprinted with permission from Ref. 90. Copyright 1996 American Chemical Society.)
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies 195
196
Bohn
indicated that a macroscopically ordered ¢lm of cyt c could be produced when a single high-a⁄nity but noncovalent binding motif, for example, the electrostatic attraction between the positively charged surface of cyt c and the negatively charged head groups of a Langmuir-Blodgett ¢lm of arachidic acid, was present between the protein surface and the substrate. These techniques are especially powerful, because the same long path-length advantages which are enjoyed by linear dichroism measurements in the integrated optical waveguide geometry can also be exploited in emission anisotropy measurements. Circular dichroism (CD) is a powerful tool for the study of secondary structure of proteins in solution, but relatively little has been done to date to exploit CD measurements of immobilized peptides and proteins at planar interfaces. De Jong and coworkers studied the protein mellitin on phospholipid layers [102]. Using literature reference circular dichroism spectra for the various possible secondary structures they expected to see, they ¢tted the experimental interfacial spectra to determine the orientation of the helical part of mellitin in oriented ¢lms. They found good agreement with the orientations produced from their circular dichroism measurements and those obtained by Fourier transform-IR measurements. Dutton and co-workers used interfacial circular dichroism measurements to study arti¢cial 4-a-helix bundle proteins assembled to accommodate heme prosthetic groups [103]. They reasoned that the orientation of these molecular maquettes at the air ^ water interface could be controlled by choosing the distribution of the charged amino acids used to make up the four helixes. Surprisingly, the heme moiety was found to dictate the orientation of a-helical axes relative to the surface planewith the parallel orientation obtained in the absence of the heme converting to a perpendicular orientation when heme was present. CD measurements were used to demonstrate that the molecular orientations obtained at the air ^ water interface were faithfully reproduced on solid substrate surfaces. Since CD is so sensitive to the presence and nature of secondary structure in proteins and polypeptides, and since the extent of denaturation in adsorbed proteins is a key question, one can expect greater e¡orts in the future to sidestep the sensitivity issues associated with transmission-based absorption measurements of circular dichroism. 4.1.2 Fluorescence Fluorescence spectroscopy can circumvent some of the sensitivity issues associated with absorption, because the low background associated with the £uorescence measurement means that quite low detection limits can be reached. In characterizing biomolecular ¢lms, £uorescence is used in three principal ways: (1) as a mechanism to follow the adsorption of solution
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
197
components to an interface; (2) with imaging techniques as a mechanism to follow patterning of biomolecular components in two dimensions; and (3) using the £uorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) technique as a mechanism to follow the dynamics of motion of biomolecular constituents in the plane. One of the most powerful modalities for studying the £uorescence properties of interfacially bound biomolecules is the Total Internal Re£ection Fluorescence (TIRF) experiment. In TIRF the evanescent wave generated upon total re£ection at a dielectric ^ dielectric interface is available for excitation of molecular electronic transitions within a decay length of the interface, typically of the order of the wavelength of the excitation radiation, i.e., 200^500 nm. Because the number density of target molecules at the interface is usually much larger than the bulk concentration in solution, interfacial molecules give rise to the majority of the signal, meaning that the interface is interrogated preferentially to solution. In addition, because experiments may be performed as a function of the excitation and emission polarization, emission anisotropy measurements may readily be accomplished in the TIRF con¢guration. Thus, it is not surprising that TIRF or some variant of it is a commonly encountered experimental paradigm in £uorescence spectroscopy of biomolecular assemblies. For example, Hlady and coworkers exploited the native £uorescence from the single tryptophan of human growth hormone (HGH), in order to monitor its adsorption to a variety of self-assembled surfaces [7,103]. They noted that the adsorbed amount of HGH was large when the alkyl chains were in an ordered structure and considerably lower where adsorption to disordered alkyl chains of fatty acid or phospholipid layers occurred. They were also able to follow adsorption kinetics on the hydrophilic head groups of self-assembled monolayers and compare them to kinetics for adsorption to hydrophilic solid surfaces. An elegant multilayer molecular construction and scheme for utilizing ligand ^ receptor binding for biosensing was developed by Aizawa and coworkers [104,105]. As shown in Scheme 3, the F(ab)2 fragment of antihuman IgG was bound to the surface followed by human IgG, then a fusion protein of protein A and luciferase was bound to the Fc fragment of the human IgG, thereby presenting the luciferase portion of the fusion protein to the ambient solution. Binding of the ligand luciferin then resulted in excitation-free bioluminescence which was used to sense the presence of luciferin or of the cofactors required in the bioluminescence from luciferase. Karyakin and coworkers demonstrated another interesting use of chemiluminescence by e¡ecting the biocatalytic reduction of H2O2 in the presence of catechol [106]. Horseradish peroxidase (HRP) was bound to the sensing arm of an anti-HRP antibody, which was then bound either to an alkanethiolate monolayer, or after disruption of the disul¢de bonds holding
198
Bohn
SCHEME 3 Molecular construction of the multilayer fusion protein based biosensor for luciferin. (Adapted with permission from Ref. 105. Copyright 1998 Elsevier Science.)
the Fc fragment together, directly to the Au surface through Au ^ thiol chemistry. The resulting bioluminescence was adequate for observation of the binding, despite the fact that Au is potentially an e⁄cient quencher of luminescence via coupling of the molecular excited state to bulk plasmons in the Au substrate.The observation of e⁄cient bioluminescence indicated that the active site of the HRP was su⁄ciently distant from the Au surface to allow e⁄cient radiative decay to occur, thus con¢rming one of the potential binding motifs for the HRP=anti-HRP conjugate.The above applications all rely on observing an increase in £uorescence upon binding of the target molecule. It is also possible to design assays in which the native £uorescence is diminished by the binding of a ligand. This approach was taken by Lo¤pez et al. in their study of the binding of streptavidin to a biotinylated surface containing a native population of synthetically introduced bodipy £uorophores [107]. Addition of the protein was e¡ective in changing both the lifetime of £uorescence and the overall £uorescence intensity, thereby signaling the binding event of interest. Fluorescence microscopy is a powerful technique for examining the patterning of biologically active surfaces with spatially dispersed £uorophores. It was used by Biebuyck and coworkers in their experiments to use micro£uidic networks to pattern biomolecules on Au, glass, and polystyrene [27]. Fluorescently labeled immunoglobulins were used as marker molecules and delivered to the substrates by micro£uidic networks in ways that resulted in spatially variegated patterns. Prestwich and coworkers
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
199
developed an elegant multilayer construction for photopatterning of antibodies on solid surfaces [108]. Their photoimmobilization started with an ethylene glycol-linked heterobifunctional molecule with a benzophenone moiety at one end, and a maleimide moiety at the other. The benzophenone was photoprocessed to cross-link it to poly(styrene), leaving the maleimide residue available for binding the free thiol of a Fab0 fragment of an antiBSA immunoglobulin. Then, a £uorescently tagged BSA was used to bind to the Fab0 fragment, giving rise to £uorescence at the polystyrene surface. Boxer’s group has been active in nonphotochemical patterning of surfaces utilizing supported lipid bilayers with immobilized £uorophores as a mechanism of visualizing the patterns which are produced. In one example from their laboratory, corrals, formed in one of two ways, were used to direct molecular self-assembly spatially. In the ¢rst method, poly(dimethylsiloxane) stamps were used to deposit arbitrarily shaped patterns of immobilized protein onto glass, followed by vesicle fusion into the regions which are not protein-covered. In the second method, supported bilayer membranes were blotted to remove the patterned region of the membrane, and the blotted regions were ¢lled in with protein from solution. In both methods, epi-£uorescence microscopy, using a dilute £uorophore probe, provided a potent mechanism to visualize the progress of the fabrication strategy [109]. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) is a powerful tool for studying the motion of £uorescently tagged molecules at interfaces [1,2,110,111]. An example of the information which can be gleaned in FRAP experiments on biomolecular assemblies was demonstrated by Yu and coworkers in their study of the interactions of £uorescently tagged BSA with pegylated trimethylsiloxanes [111]. These materials were of interest because of their biocompatibility and their ability to mimic the behavior of ethylene oxide-containing SAMs. The basics of the FRAP technique are shown in Fig.11.Overlapped lasers are brought into focus at an interface, and the areas of constructive interference provide a high local electric ¢eld amplitude, which can then be used to photobleach the £uorophores in that region. After a period of photobleaching, the sample consists of lines of bleached and unbleached molecules. Because photochemically reacted and unreacted molecules are chemically di¡erent, interdi¡usion of the pattern occurs, with a characteristic time behavior which depends on the twodimensional di¡usion properties of the di¡using molecules. These workers discovered that both high- and low-molecular-weight poly(ethylene-glycol)derivatized silanes signi¢cantly reduced the interaction between protein and substrate. The mobility and aggregation behavior of the tagged BSAwas found to be very di¡erent in the two kinds of pegylated layers, however, leading the authors to conclude that the adsorption behavior of proteins
FIG. 11 (a) Schematic diagram showing the elements of the FRAP measurement. (b) Representative FRAP signal for the diffusion of FITC-labeled BSA on pegylated SAMs. (Adapted in part and reprinted with permission from Ref. 111. Copyright 1999 American Chemical Society.)
200 Bohn
Peptide and Protein-Based Biomolecular Assemblies
201
depends not only on interactions with the polymer-graft modi¢ed surface, but also on di¡usion and self-aggregation behavior. 4.2
X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy
One of the workhorse techniques in the characterization of biomolecular assemblies is X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Three types of information are readily available from straightforward XPS experiments. Information about the atomic composition and oxidation state of atoms in the near-surface region are derived from energy-resolved XPS spectra. In addition, by comparing the magnitudes of signals of various species at different electron takeo¡ angles, it is possible to gain an understanding of the relative placement of atomic constituents in the direction perpendicular to the surface plane. Thus, in cases where some components of the biomolecular assembly have unique identifying atoms, its possible to learn a great deal about the structure of the assembly by careful analysis of XPS data. XPS studies have proven to be especially powerful in the analysis of multistep syntheses of multilayer biomolecular assemblies, especially those containing speci¢c polypeptide residues [112^117]. Healy and coworkers made extensive use of XPS in their multistep scheme to build up polypeptide surfaces on titanium oxide [112]. Starting with an amine-terminated organosilane, they used a heterobifunctional linker to provide a thiol-reactive moiety at the distal end which was then coupled to a cysteine-terminated polypeptide. By following spectra of the N1s, C1s, Si2p, and Ti2p photoelectrons, they were able to assign de¢nitively the components of the multilayer structure to the desired molecular precursors. XPS data were combined with spectroscopic ellipsometry to assess the identity, thickness, and surface density of the grafted layers thus produced.The surfaces were then subjected to adhesion studies with rat calvaria osteoblast-like cells. Menzel and coworkers used XPS in a similar study in which polypeptides were grafted to the surface of amino-terminated SAMs by N-carboxyanhydride polymerization [113]. Holland and co-workers also made extensive use of XPS in characterizing a synthetic peptide, ^ GRGDSPK ^, which was covalently bound to a dialdehyde starch coating on a polymer surface [114]. The RGDcontaining peptides were then used to modulate the attachment of human umbilical vein endothelial cells (EC) and to show that EC adhesion, spreading, and growth was similar for cells prepared on these surfaces as for cells prepared on a ¢bronectin-coated surface. Matsuta and coworkers made extensive use of angle-resolved and highresolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy in characterizing their derivatized poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) ¢lms [118,119]. In their scheme, an isocyanate reaction was used to develop linkers of di¡erent lengths, for
202
Bohn
derivatization of a variety of RGD-containing oligopeptides. The presence of the isocyanate moiety in their reaction scheme was critical and its availability was followed by careful analysis of the line shape in the C1s spectral region, cf. Fig. 12, and by following the time dependence of the N1s=C1s signal ratio at grazing and near-normal electron takeo¡ angles. Using XPS data, these workers were able to show that the surface-modi¢ed PVA had a density of RGD functionalities that was controlled by the degree of isocyanation of the PVA, and that bovine endothelial cells adhered well and grew on these derivatized polymers independent of the presence of serum. 4.3
Vibrational Spectroscopy
4.3.1 Infrared Spectroscopy The workhorse of molecular characterization in homogeneous solution is magnetic resonance spectroscopy. A wealth of detailed structural information can be obtained from relatively simple and straightforward experiments. Unfortunately, the sensitivity of NMR measurements is too low to make it generally applicable to low-surface-area materials, such as planar interfaces.
FIG. 12 The C1s region of the XPS spectrum of an isocyanate-derivatized poly(vinyl alcohol) surface as a function of reaction time. Note the high binding energy peak assigned to C¼O and due to the iso