Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY Edited by
A...
60 downloads
1363 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY Edited by
A. H. ROSE School of Biological Sciences Buth University. U K
and
D. W. TEMPEST Departmmt sf Microhiologj? Uniiwsitj?of Sliefieli, U K
Volume 30
ACADEMIC PRESS Hareourr Bruce Jovanovieh, Publishers London San Diego New York Berkeley Boston Sydney Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper @
ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24-28 Oval Road London NW 1 7DX US.Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. San Diego CA 92101
Copyright K> 1989 by ACADEMlC PRESS LlMlTED
All Righis Resivvcd
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any other mcans, without written permission from the publishers British Library Cataloguing in Publicution Data
Advances in microbial physiology. Vol. 30 1. Micro-organisms-Physiology 1. Rose, A. H. 11. Tempest, D. W. 576.11 QR84 lSBN 0-12-027730-1 ISSN 0065-291 1
Typeset and printed in Great Britain by Galliard (Printers) Ltd, Great Yarmouth
Contributors C. A. Bilinski Research Department, Labatt Brewing Company Limited, London N6A 4M3, Ontario, Canada A. Datta Molecular Biology Laboratory, School of Life Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi - 1 0 067, India K. Ganesan Molecular Biology Laboratory School of Life Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi - 1 0 067, India N. A. R. Cow Department of Genetics an I Microbiology, Marischal College, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen AB9 lAS, UK N. Marmiroli Instituto di Genetica, Universita di Parma, 43100 Parma, Italy J. J: Miller Department of Biology, McMaster University, Hamilton LIB 4K1, Ontario, Canada. K. Natarajan Molecular Biology Laboratory, School of Life Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi - 110 067, India J. Postgate Houndean Lodge, 1 Houndean Rise, Lewes, East Sussex, BN7 IEG, UK J. Preiss Department of Biochemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA J. 1. Prosser Department of Genetics and Microbiology, Marischal College, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, AB9 1AS, Scotland T. Romeo Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Texas College of Osteopathic Medicine, Camp Bowie a t Montgomery, Fort Worth, TX 76107, USA
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents Contributors
V
Trends and Perspectives in Nitrogen Fixation Research JOHN POSTGATE
I. Background 11. Chemistry 111. Biochemistry IV. Genetics V. Physiology VI. Ecology VII. Envoi References
1
5 7 9 13 17 19 19
Apodxis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Other Eukaryotic Microorganisms C. A. BILINSKI, N. MARMIROLI and J. J. MILLER
I. Introduction: occurrence of apomixis in yeast 11. The meaning of apomixis in plants, animals and fungi 111. Apomixis in some eukaryotic micro-organisms IV. Inheritance of apomixis in yeasts
V. VI. VII. VIII.
Environmental modification of the apomictic phenotype Timing of events controlling the manner of nuclear division Nucleomitochondrial interactions in facultative apomixis Ecology of apomixis in yeasts IX. Concluding remarks References
23 26 29 33 36 39 41 42 46 48
Current Trends in Candida albicans Research A. DATTA, K. GANESAN and K. NATARAJAN 1. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction Genetics Morphogenesis Pathogenesis Problems in research on Candida albicans
53 54 58 67 79
viii
CONTENTS
82 84 84
VI. Summary VII. Acknowledgements References
Circulating Ionic Current in licro-organisms I
N. A. R. GOW
I. 11. Ill. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX.
In trod ucti on Measurement of ionic currents Studies on bacteria Currents in fungi Currents in protozoa Currents in algae Effects of applied voltage and ion gradients Ionic currents and cellular physiology Conclusions References
89 90 92 93 102 105 113 114 119 120
Autotrophic Nitrification in Bacteria J. I. PROSSER
I. Introduction 11. Ecological and economic importance of nitrification 111. Taxonomy and species diversity
IV. V. Vi. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI.
Biochemistry of nitrifying bacteria Growth of nitrifying bacteria in liquid culture Surface growth The effect of oxygen and light on nitrification The effect of pH value on nitrification lnhibition of nitrification Concluding remarks Acknowledgements References
125 126 128 129 136 146 148 157 169 175 177 177
Physiology, Biochemistry and Genetics of Bacterial Glycogen Synthesis J. PREISS and A. ROMEO
Introduction Occurrence of glycogen in bacteria Enzymes involved in synthesis of glycogen Characterization of the bacterial glycogen biosynthesic enzymes Genetic regulation of glycogen biosynthesis in Escherichiu coli V1. Acknowledgements References
I. 11. 111. IV, V.
183 184 189 193 218 233 233
Trends and Perspectives in Nitrogen Fixation Research JOHN POSTGATE Houndean Lodge, 1 Houndean Rise. Lewes, East Sussex BN7 IEG, U.K.
1. Background. . . . . . . . . A. The nitrogen cycle. . . . . . B. Research trends . . . . . . 11. Chemistry . . . . . . . . . A. Models for nitrogenase function . . B. Exploitable systems . . . . . 111. Biochemistry . . . . . . . . A. The dinitrogen-binding site . . . B. Enzymology of nitrogenases , . . 1V. Genetics . . . . . . . . . A. The Klebsieh and Azorobucrer models B. Evolution and genetic manipulation . V. Physiology . . . . . . . . . A. Definition. . . . . . . . B. Functional responses . . . . . C. Symbioses. . . . . . . . VI. Ecology . . . . . . . . . A. New diazotrophic systems. . . . B. Exotic diazotrophic systems . . . V11. Envoi . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . .
. .
.
. .
. .
. .
.
. . . . . . . .
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . . .
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . .
.
. . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
1 1
3
S S
6 I I I 9 9 12 13 13
13
1s 17 11 18 19 19
I. Background A. THE NITROGEN CYCLE
The biological cycles of carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, sulphur and other elements involved in growth and metabolism are fundamental to the persistence of life on this planet, and the rbles of microbes in these cycles are crucial. Despite the rapidity of much microbial metabolism, the global turnover times of these cycles may be extremely long because they are the resultants of a multitude of ADVANCES IN MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY, VOL. 30 ISBN 0-12-027730-1
Copyright @> 1969. by Academlc Press Limited All nghts of reproduction in any form reserved
2
JOHN POSTGATE
local subcycles with turnovers ranging from fast to very slow indeed (see Sprent, 1987). For example, in the global nitrogen cycle, illustrated in Fig. 1, every nitrogen atom in the atmosphere cycles once in about lo6 years, but in a tropical rice paddy, where nitrogen fixation takes place in the water and denitrification in the mud, the turnover time must be a matter of a few years only. Similar principles apply to all the biological cycles, and the influence of mankind has been to perturb them, always in the direction of a net acceleration. Thus, by consuming native sulphur, the product of PermioJurassic sulphate reduction, and by burning coal, i.e. carbon fixed in the carboniferous era, we accelerate in obvious manners the sulphur and carbon cycles. The effects of mankind’s intervention in the nitrogen cycle, though less obvious to laymen, is equally impressive and is of special interest because of its impact on world agriculture.
Denitrification 2x108
Ammonif ication
* -- - - - -- - --- 3
-
NH3 -Plant
lolo--
and microbial protein
- -- - - - --
-
Animal protein
------------ ------- Assimilation- __ - --_- - - - - - - - ___ - - - _ _ _ _
+
3 x 10’0 FIG. 1. The nitrogen cycle. A simple form of the cycle is illustrated. The numbers beneath the various steps are orders of magnitude of turnover in tonnes per year. For more precise data, see Delwiche (1977) and Clark and Rosswall (1981).
In the early stages of this planet’s biological history, the reserves of chemically fixed nitrogen in the “primitive soup” must have been adequate for the emergence of life, and for many millennia of its evolution the input of new nitrogen into the primitive biosphere was probably wholly chemical: comprising molecules such as cyanide, hydroxylamine and Urey/Miller organic nitrogen, generated locally from pristine NH, and HCN by lightning, irradiation and volcanic activity. The biological nitrogen “cycle” would then have been a matter of linear exchange of nitrogen between organic and inorganic combination. As the primitive atmosphere became less reducingby photolysis of H,O leading to escape of H, and transient formation of 0,-more oxidized forms of fixed nitrogen (dinitrogen, hydroxylamine, nitrite and,
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
3
later, nitrate) would tend to replace NH,. By the time oxygen had become a permanent component of the atmosphere (there is still no agreement when; about lo9 years ago was widely accepted in the early 1970s, but earlier dates are now favoured (Towe, 1983)), nitrite and nitrate would have become the biosphere's major inorganic nitrogen reserves, and these sources must have tended to limit the biomass of the biosphere. Thus selection pressure favouring of the emergence of biological nitrogen fixation arose. Postgate (1 982) argued that ability to fix nitrogen might therefore be a relatively recent acquisition of living things, but this is a matter of informed speculation (see reviews by Sprent and Raven (1987) and Postgate and Eady ( 1 988)), not scientific fact, because the crucial geochemical basis still is lacking. Whatever may be the historical truth, biological nitrogen fixation now exists, and in consequence nitrogen is no longer a limiting nutrient for most equilibrium or climax ecosystems. In virgin forests, natural savannah and other fertile regions which are in ecological balance, biological fixation provides an adequate input of nitrogen, and factors such as temperature, hydration, salinity or availability of other nutrients (such as phosphorous, sulphur and potassium) determine biomass production. However, perturbation of a balanced ecosystem by stresses such as fire, inundation, vulcanism or drought, renews or recycles all the biological elements so, during recovery, supplies of fixed nitrogen generally become limiting. During the present millennium the most persistent perturbations of the natural environment have been brought about by agriculture and forestry, so today, on a global scale, world productivities of these industries is determined by the input of fixed nitrogen into agricultural soils and managed forests. B. RESEARCH TRENDS
In the late 1980s the world's human population passed 5 x lo9. Every concerned scientist recognizes that, assuming no global catastrophe intervenes, it will reach 10'' during the next century. Whether it takes two, three or four decades to reach this number, and whether it then stabilizes, depends on sociopolitical matters such as the efficacy and acceptability of measures of population control. But the inescapable truth is that there are already sufficient children on this earth, who will reproduce before their antecedents die, to ensure a doubling of the world's population even if all programmes of population control were immediately successful. This explosive growth of the world's population in the twentieth century has been supported by the Haber process for fixing molecular dinitrogen from the atmosphere. The net input of industrial nitrogen fertilizer today is said to support a third of the world's present population; to feed double that
4
JOHN POS’fGATE
population will require at least a doubling of the net input of fixed nitrogen into the world’s agricultural soils. Consideration of ways of achieving this augmented input raises very important questions. When is chemically fixed and when is biologically fixed nitrogen the most appropriate fertilizer? How far, under ever increasing pressure for living space, can and should new land be brought into use? Does the obvious overuse of industrial nitrogen fertilizer in some countries justify regulation, by the U.N. or more parochial agencies, of fertilizer use‘?Are the environmental consequences of such a massively increased nitrogen input (in terms of eutrophication, effects of atmospheric nitrogen oxides, contamination of drinking water) as serious as some environmentalists fear? Will the mounting costs of energy (for transport and packaging as much as for production) price Haber nitrogen out of reach of less wealthy countries? Can agricultural procedures be reformed, perhaps redirected to exploitation of biological fixation, without drastic political and economic strain? These are truly vital questions, but they can only be touched upon in a scientific survey. Whatever view one takes of these demographic, sociopolitical and economic problems, it remains clear that mankind must exploit both industrial and biological nitrogen fixation more effectively and extensively than in the past. Such considerations emphasize the practical importance of the research efforts now being put into the study of nitrogen fixation. They impose perfectly proper constraints on the directions of that research and on the perspectives revealed thereby. However, it is a truism which cannot be emphasized too often that progress in practical directions, in any technology, depends utterly on new understanding of the science which underlies that technology. This is especially true of the present subject because the processes underlying nitrogen fixation are not only far from being understood at a fundamental level but also raise fascinating basic questions in chemistry, biochemistry, physiology, genetics and general biology. Even at an elementary level one can point to simple yet vexing questions. Thus, the Haber process requires high pressures, elevated temperatures, special catalysts and anoxic, anhydrous conditions to split and reduce the very stable N=N molecule; how then d o microbes conduct this chemical miracle in wet, aerated soil at ambient pressures and temperatures? And again, if available nitrogen in the environment has determined the productivity of the biosphere for millions upon millions of years, how can it be that the biological process for obtaining this nutrient from the atmosphere, physically the biosphere’s most accessible resource, has remained restricted to some 50 genera of prokaryotes, the most effective of which perform in symbiosis with plants? These are actually very broad questions, but shadowy answers are beginning to form. Attack upon such questions has determined the directions of most basic research over the last three decades, whether the overt objective
5
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
has been the advance of knowledge or the amelioration of the human condition. In this review an attempt has been made to provide an overview of the state of published research bearing on the more fundamental aspects of diazotrophy, as it stood towards the beginning of 1989, and to indicate likely directions of further research. As far as has been practicable, reference has been made to review articles rather than primary publications for amplification of the topics discussed. 11. Chemistry A. MODELS FOR NITROGENASE FUNCTION
The study of the properties of the dinitrogen complexes of the transition metals, examples of which are listed in Fig. 2, has provided purely chemical precedents for a number of the reactions of nitrogenases. Examples of such complexes are known which can be formed directly from gaseous dinitrogen in mild, protic conditions, sometimes by displacement of two hydride groups; which can be protonated in an essentially stepwise sequence to hydrazine, ammonia or a mixture of both. Collectively such reactions provide a synthetic model for the binding of N, by nitrogenase, the obligatory release of H, by the functioning enzyme and the formation of stoichiometric amounts of hydrazine when the enzyme is quenched with acid or alkali during N, reduction (see discussions by Henderson et al. (1983), Leigh and Postgate (1985), Newton (1988) and Postgate (1982)). The precise conditions for chemical stability, and for formation of hydrazine as against NH, as end product of protonation, remain uncertain, being conditioned by the ligand Metal
Formula
Ruthenium Cobalt Molybdenum Iron Rhenium Tantalum
[RU(Nz) (NH3)51 ’ xz CoH(N2)(R3P)3 M0 ( N,) 2 (d PPe)2 [FeH(N,)(dppe),I x ReCI(N,) (RR‘,P), Ta CI ( P) ,-N ,-Ta C l3(
R = C6HsR‘ = CH3-
R ” = C 2 H5dppe = R,P . CH,CH,. PR,
’
P) ,
FIG. 2. Examples of dinitrogen complexes. These are organometallic compounds formed by metals of the “transition” group of the Periodic Table. Their complete formulae are complicated, so for simplicity X replaces anions such as CI- where appropriate, and the code above is used for the organophosphine components of the molecules. For more details see Henderson et al. (1983) and Newton (1987).
6
JOHN POSTGATE
environment of the metal and the nature of both the protonating agent and the solvent environment. Moreover, although chemical kinetics have revealed the early steps of protonation satisfactorily, the later stages of NH, formation are less clear. The discovery of nitrogenases based on vanadium and iron atoms (below) has rekindled interest in the dinitrogen complexes of those metals, and also in the long-established but mechanistically elusive protonations of vanadium(r1) compounds studied by Professor Shilov and his colleagues (see Nikinova et ul., 1980). However, in the biological systems the ligands are not organophosphines or other laboratory chemicals; they are biological molecules: protein (or amino-acid residues therefrom), probably molecules such as homocitrate (Hoover et af.,1988),and very likely iron and sulphur atoms. So the study, of more “biological” ligands such as amino and carboxy acids in regular dinitrogen complex chemistry is gaining momentum, coupled with increased urgency over the elucidation of the structures and atomic locations of those conspicuous but intractable features of prosthetic sites of dinitrogenases: the co-factors FeMoco and FeVaco. B. EXPLOITABLE SYSTEMS
Studies on the mechanism of protonation of the dinitrogen group coordinated to a transition metal will necessarily continue until protonation of complexes of the type of the classical tungsten molecule cis-W(N,),(PMe,Ph), (Chatt et al., 1987) is fully understood. Already the possibility of cyclic, and thus potentially catalytic, processes based on such reactions is under investigation, a recent and exciting version being the cyclic electrochemical reduction of a regenerable tungsten dinitrogen complex which was reviewed by Pickett el ul. (1988), a reaction which has potential application as a lowtechnology substitute for the Haber process. At the time of writing, an important problem is the provision of a regenerable protonating component. Recent successes have naturally led to broader perceptions of man-made dinitrogen-fixing systems (reviewed by Newton, 1987) including the historic process for oxidative attack on N, by O2 plus an electric arc (the Berkland-Eyde process) and potential applications of the photoreduction of N, catalysed by titanium dioxide. The reductive nature of the biological process has, however, exerted a strong influence on the development of the complex chemistry of dinitrogen and it is to be hoped that a systematic approach to the oxidative attack of metal-bound N,, complementary to the excellent studies of its reductive attack, will not be long delayed. Perhaps, however, one should discourage a very long-term prospect which arises therefrom: the artefactual creation of a dinitrogen oxygenase in bacteria or plants, would present grotesque environmental problems (see Clement, 1980).
1RENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES I N NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
7
111. Biochemistry A. THE DINITROGEN-BINDING SITE
Although involvement of molybdenum had been suspected since Bortels (1930) first demonstrated that this element is a prerequisite of diazotrophic growth, chemistry has only recently provided good reasons for believing that the N,-binding site of dinitrogenase is a transition metal. Scientists are prejudiced by largely circumstantial evidence towards the view that one, or conceivably two, molybdenum atoms constitute the binding site in conventional dinitrogenase, with vanadium or iron atoms performing comparable functions in the two “alternative” dinitrogenases (Bishop et al., 1988; Eady et al., 1988) recognized so far. Plausible though this view is, it cannot be taken as proved until the modes of action of FeMoco, FeVaco, and “FeFeco” if such a moiety exists, are established. Replacement experiments in vitro using apo-Mo-dinitrogenase from Klebsiella pneumoniae and extracts containing nifV FeMoco (Hawkes et al., 1984) or Azotohacter chroococcum FeVaco (Eady et al., 1988) now provide unequivocal evidence that FeMoco and FeVaco are, contain, or are part of, the N,-binding sites of Mo- and Vdinitrogenase, respectively. However, this information still leaves iron atoms, sulphur atoms or even ligands adjacent to the co-factor clusters, as possible binding sites. The adjacent ligands have rarely been considered overtly as binding sites, but the exciting evidence summarized by Shah et al. (1988) that nfV- mutants lack homocitrate and that homocitrate corrects the nifVphenotype suggests not only that the nifV product is involved in homocitrate synthesis but also that fully functional FeMoco is ligated to homocitrate or a derivative thereof. Elucidation of the structures and rdles of these co-factors is urgent for biochemical as well as chemical reasons and the approach of Imperial et al. ( I 988), investigating co-factor biosynthesis via the products of genes known to be involved (nifN, E, V, B, Q-see Fig. 3), is one of many examples of the interaction of biochemistry and genetics, an interaction which will continue to have a major influence on the directions of biochemical research. B. ENZYMOLOGY OF NITROGENASES
Specialists in the enzymology of nitrogenases are well aware of the perennial difficulties research workers have with the specific activities and analytical compositions of preparations of nitrogenase proteins: problems of obtaining consistent data as between laboratories, even as between preparations made with different batches of cells, have not been solved and published values for these two quantities differ to a vexing extent. The consensus is that iron and
8
JOHN POSTGATF
sulphur analyses generally underestimate the molar content of these atoms in the molybdoprotein and it is still uncertain whether equal numbers of these two elements are present or whether iron atoms marginally outnumber sulphur. As far as the iron protein is concerned, most authorities are satisfied that it carries one 4 F e 4 S cluster per molecule, but at least one claim has been made that two such clusters are present in the undamaged protein (see Eady, 1986).Published specific activities for the two proteins cover an approximately three-fold range. These problems are partly rooted in the methodology of handling and analysing the extremely sensitive nitrogenase proteins, but they may also indicate that precursor or degraded forms are actually part of the ordinary cell’s complement of nitrogenase. Despite these sources of uncertainty, which are sometimes dismissed too easily, studies of the mode of action of Mo-nitrogenase, using artificial electron donors, progressed dramatically in the late 1970s and early 1980s with the exploitation of rapid reaction kinetics together with absorption (visible, UV and pray) and electron spin resonance spectroscopic techniques. A grand scheme for the functioning of K.pneumoniae nitrogenase was put forward by Thorneley and Lowe ( 1 985) which matched observed data well and is now in the process of refinement to accommodate such details as the N,-specific D, exchange reaction, or interaction with the natural electron donor. Yet certainty about the nature of the latter substance had to await input from molecular genetics: although biochemical evidence has long suggested that flavodoxins or ferredoxins are the primary electron donors to nitrogenases (Walker and Mortenson, 1974; Yates, 1972), doubt remained that the observed phenomena might be artefactual-analogous to the action of a viologen dye-and it required the recognition of the NifF- phenotype, followed by identification of the nifF and nif‘J gene products, to make the first unequivocal identification of a primary electron donor to nitrogenase: the nfF-encoded flavodoxin which donates electrons to the Fe-protein of K. pneumoniae nitrogenase (NievaGomez et al., 1980).Nif F cloned in Escherichia coli was used by Deistung and Thorneley (1986) to obtain supplies of the flavodoxin for research on nitrogenase kinetics: Cloned genes are being exploited for studying the biochemistry of most of the nifgene products. A combination of separately cloned genes in an alien genetic background was the experimental basis of evidence that only two ~ ( f gene products, NIFM and NIFH, are necessary for the biosynthesis of active dinitrogenase reductase (Howard et al., 1986; Paul and Merrick, 1987, 1988). The availability of amino-acid sequences for nif gene products deduced from DNA sequences has enabled the application of site-specific mutagenesis to mechanistic problems, and dinitrogenases with known amino-acid substitutions have already been reported (Dean et al., 1988).Such studies cannot fail to extend understanding of the biochemistry of nitrogenase; the problem now,
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
9
of course, is to decide which gene products-which proteins-to study and which amino acids to alter. Molecular biology has not yet eliminated the need for intuition. Detailed DNA sequence data were essential to the demonstration of the existence of the “alternative” nitrogenases. Bishop et al. (1988) gave a brief account of the chequered history of these nitrogenases, whose reality was widely doubted until a strain of Azotohacter uinelandii became available with its regular structural nif genes unequivocally deleted. The tenacity of Dr Bishop was then rewarded: the subject has taken wing with the discovery of the V- and Fe-nitrogenases. The observation that ethane is formed from acetylene by non-Mo-nitrogenases, in addition to ethylene, whereas ethylene is the exclusive product formed by Mo-nitrogenase (Dilworth et al., 1987),has indicated a presumptive test for the new nitrogenases which has already provided evidence for such nitrogenases in organisms other than azotobacters (Chan ef al., 1988; Kentemich et al., 1988).Are nitrogenases based on tungsten, ruthenium or other transition metals waiting to be discovered? Evidence (Hales and Case, 1987) that tungstate-resistant A . uinelandii can, in special conditions, make an active dinitrogenase containing both molybdenum and tungsten in 1 :1 ratio, is suggestive. The biochemistry of these new nitrogenases will be fascinating; its elucidation will obviously accelerate understanding of the modes of action of all nitrogenases. But enthusiasm should not lead to neglect of microbiologically exotic Mo-nitrogenases such as those of halotolerant and psychrophilic diazotrophs, as well as diazotrophic archaebacteria, both mesophilic (Murray and Zinder, 1984) and thermophilic (Belay et al., 1984). A final outstanding biochemical question remains: what is the chemical basis of the oxygen sensitivity of all known nitrogen proteins? It is a question few have chosen to address, if only because it involves the deliberate destruction of precious proteins, but we need to know the answer because only then can we decide whether an oxygen-tolerant nitrogenase could in principle exist (or be constructed by protein engineering).
IV. Genetics A. THE
Klehsiella
AND
Azotohacter
MODELS
A complete sequence of 24,206 base pairs of DNA covering the whole of the K. pneumoniae n$regulon is now available (Arnold et al., 1988).The regulon was for several years believed to consist of only 17 genes, though the possibility of additional small genes was not excluded. Sequence data have now revealed that it includes 20 open reading frames (Fig. 3), representing genes which are transcribed when nif is derepressed. They are clustered into seven contiguous
10
JOHN POSTGATE
(bisD, GI
Q
Mo uptake or processing
B
FeMoco synthesis or processing
A
Positive regulator
L
Negative regulator
F
Flavodoxin synthesis
M
Processing Fe-protein
2
?
W
?
V
Processing FeMoco
S
?
U
?
X
?
N
Processing FeMoco
E
Processing FeMoco
Y
?
T
?
K
Synthesis of p-subunit of MoFe-protein
D
Synthesis of a subunit of MoFe-protein
H
Synthesis of Fe -protein
-
(C) ? J
Synthesis of pyruvate-flavodaxin oxidoreductose
(shiA1
FIG. 3. The nif regulon of Klehsiellupneumoniue. The gene cluster is preceded by the his operon and followed by shiA on the K. pneumoniue chromosomc. The arrows signify directions of transcription of the component operons; the biological functions of the encoded peptides are as known in late 1988. A twenty-first gene ( C )has been proposed but is probably part of J.
operons which are not all transcribed in the same direction and one of which includes a secondary promoter (Fig. 3). The amino-acid sequences and various other physicochemical data can be deduced for all 20 gene products but the physiological functions of only about half of them are known (Fig. 3). In particular, the n(fDK genes code for the structural peptides of dinitrogenase and niJ'H for the polypeptide of dinitrogenase reductase; the n$LA operon specifies proteins which regulate the expression of all other ntf operons. Expression of K . pneumoniue n$has features in common with the regulation
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
11
of the assimilation of other nitrogen sources (such as nitrate, urea, amino acids) in coliform bacteria: it is regulated in a distinctive way involving action of the products of the ntr genes, which are unlinked to nif: One of these, ntrA (also known as rpoN), codes for a special a-factor, a54.The two others, ntrBC are un-linked to ntrA/rpoN and specify repressor and activator substances. When ammonium ions or some other assimilable nitrogen sources in the external environment are sensed, by a cascade mechanism which is only partly understood, the nrrBC products act in repressive mode. The review by Merrick (1988a) gave fuller details of this developing subject. The ntr gene products have their effect on ntfexpression at the nifLA operon, regulating synthesis of NlFA which, modulated by NIFL, acts at the promoters of the other seven operons within the nifregulon. Genes regulated by ntr or nifLA products have promoter sequences different from the normal E. coli promoter consensus sequence. Though the outlines of nif regulation by fixed nitrogen in K. pneumoniue are known, and the functional domains of the regulatory proteins are being identified, the precise ways in which regulator proteins recognize and act at the appropriate promoter, as well as the details of how fixed nitrogen is sensed and induces repression, remain elusive; folding of the DNA is among the factors involved (see reviews by Dixon, 1988; Merrick, 1988a,b). The pathway of genetic regulation of nifby 0, is being revealed as different in a number of important respects. The relative 0, tolerance of certain nifL mutants earlier suggested that NIFL was intimately concerned with 0,induced control at the transcriptional level; this belief has been confirmed by studies of nif-lac fusions in appropriate mutant backgrounds. There is also evidence for post-transcriptional regulation through 0,-mediated destabilization of the otherwise uncommonly stable nifmRNA. However, whereas nif regulation by fixed nitrogen has many features in common with the general regulation of nitrogen assimilation in coliform bacteria, no comparable sharing of features has been demonstrated between O2 regulation of nifand the 0, regulation of aerobic versus anaerobic metabolism in coliforms; claims to the contrary have not been substantiated. These matters were discussed in Hill’s ( 1 988) succinct review. Rapid progress is being made in the research area of genetic regulation of nif at the time of writing and it has become very clear how very fortunate we were that K . pneumoniue was the first major subject for the study of nifgenetics, because it is uncomplicated by “alternative” nifsystems and its nifgenes are clustered into the familiar regulon. Thus it is an excellent model system for research, especially now that we have learned that, in most other diazotrophs, the nifgenes are not clustered, nor is regulation by ntr necessarily the rule. As far as gene organization is concerned, for example, in those azotobacters and rhizobia that have been studied, the genes for Mo-nitrogenases are only partly contiguous, being dispersed as three or four clusters, and they include some
12
JOHN POSTGATE
(e.g. JixABC) not recognized in K . pneumoniue. A particularly fascinating problem is presented by A . chroococcum and A. vinelundii, which have genetic systems coding for the new nitrogenases as well as for Mo-nitrogenase: Vnitrogenase in A . chroococcum, both V- and Fe-nitrogenases in A. vinelundii. The structural genes for these nitrogenases are quite distinct, in sequences and locations, but some, though not all, genes involved in processing the nitrogenase proteins may be shared. In A . uinelundii,nifN is specific to the Monitrogenase, but n i f M and njf B are concerned with all three nitrogenases. In the matter of nifregulation, ntr genes are indeed present in A. uinelundii, but the ntrBC products seem only to regulate synthesis of V-nitrogenase (see Kennedy and Toukdarien, 1987; Merrick, 1988b) and a new regulatory gene, nfrX is involved with the other two nitrogenases (Bali et ul., 1988). Among non-symbiotic diazotrophs, increased structural and regulatory complexity seems to parallel increased aerotolerance, reaching a peak in heterocystous cyanobacteria, where nif is dispersed and a seemingly unique process of DNA re-arrangement involving excision of two fragments (data summarized by Haselkorn et ul. (1987)) accompanies derepression of ntfwhy? B. EVOLUTION AND GENETIC MANIPULATION
The divergencies in nif arrangement and regulation among various prokaryotes, and even between Mo- and non-Mo-nifin the same prokaryote, show no logical pattern at present; there is a need to know and understand them and this need will condition the main stream of nifgenetics for some years to come. Although their relevance to agriculture has led many laboratories to concentrate on njfin rhizobia, azospirilla or cyanobacteria, the divergencies of the diazotrophic methanogens from the K. pneumuniue model will be of special fundamental interest because the archaebacteria have many distinctive genetical and biochemical features. Already comparison of the deduced amino-acid sequences of the dinitrogenase reductases (nzfH products) from various methanogens (Sibold and Souillard, 1988) indicates that considerably more evolutionary divergence of nifhas taken place within this subgroup of the archaebacteria than has been observed among eubacteria, yet that one of two such proteins from a thermophile shows greater similarity to a dinitrogenase reductase from the eubacterium Closlridium pusteuriunum than to its own companion or to analogous proteins from other methanogens. The possibility therefore resurfaces that lateral nif gene transfer, already proposed within the eubacteria (Postgate, 1982) and doubted as a result of earlier sequence comparisons (Hennecke et ul., 1985),may not only be a reality but may have occurred between the two prokaryotic kingdoms, with the archaebacteria as the “donor” kingdom in which the process originated.
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
13
However, Postgate and Eady (1988) have warned against the too-ready acceptance of protein sequence data as indicators of evolutionary pathways. The creation of an entirely new diazotroph, E. coli, by nifgene transfer from K. pneumoniae was crucial to the early exploration of nifgenetics and the extension of such studies to other bacteria yielded valuable information regarding nif expression in alien prokaryotic backgrounds which was reviewed by Postgate et al. (1987). Attention is now turning to expression of individual nif genes such as nifH or nifD in eukaryotes and limited success has been achieved (e.g. by Zilberstein et al., 1988), but, although rational approaches to the goal can be prescribed (e.g. by Postgate, 1987), expression of a full complement of nifgenes in a eukary0te-i.e. eukaryotic diazotrophy-is still a long way off. The dramatic advances of nifmolecular genetics have prejudiced most scientists in favour of a constructional approach, that of engineering nif genes into, say, a plant chloroplast. However, if a sound strategy was available for generating a diazotrophic organelle in plant tissue from a diazotrophic endosymbiont, exploiting perhaps the uptake and conservation of L-forms claimed by Aloysius and Paton (1984), that avenue might enable some of the physiological problems of nif expression which a diazotrophic plant would face to be solved more easily. V. Physiology A. DEFINITION
The physiology of a microbe is the resultant of the interaction of its genetics and its biochemistry. It is therefore entirely appropriate that modern microbial physiology should incorporate substantial genetical and biochemical components, even if classical physiologists find the jargon and concepts troublesome. At the Corvallis international symposium on nitrogen fixation (Evans et al., 1985) about half of the papers categorized as “genetics” in this research area actually described the exploitation of genetics to answer physiological questions. In the matter of the regulation of nitrogenase synthesis in response to oxygenation or starvation of fixed nitrogen, this truism is obvious, and the discovery of a molybdoprotein as an apparent autoregulator of nif required the use of lac-nif fusions. Molecular genetical approaches are now becoming available in most contexts within the classical physiology of diazotrophy. B. FUNCTIONAL RESPONSES
Many of the physiological stratagems available to diazotrophs for the protection of nitrogenase from oxygen damage are reasonably well
14
JOHN POSTCAIE
understood (see Postgate, 1982; Hill, 1988), though refinement of detail, and alteration of emphasis in some instances, will be needed. Two examples are: (1) the “classical” account of oxygen tolerance in azotobacters in terms of respiratory and conformational protection does not cover all levels of 0, stress (Post et al., 1983; Yates, 1988); (2) the rBle of heterocysts in cyanobacterial oxygen exclusion is clear, yet the unicellular Gloeothece is remarkably tolerant of 0, (Maryan et al., 1986) without benefit of heterocyst formation. Such deviations are very important and far from satisfactorily explained at present. Delay in the use of genetics in this research area has arisen largely because the appropriate classes of mutant (e.g. the oxygensensitive Fos- mutants of azobacters (Ramos and Robson, 1985a,b)) are not easy to isolate. Diazotrophs generally show one or both of two “switch-on/off” reactions to their environment, neither of which involves regulation of enzyme synthesis. The first of these is the response to O,, typified by azotobacter’s reversible cessation of nitrogenase activity under excessive 0, stress (the “conformational protection” syndrome). Although it was discovered in the strictly aerobic and very 0,-tolerant A. chroococcurn, comparable phenomena have been detected in all diazotrophs in which 0,-induced switch-on/off has been sought (see Yates, 1988). It occurs even in the highly exacting obligate anaerobe Desulfouihrio gigas, though with this organism recovery from exposure to oxygen is slow compared with azotobacter (see Postgate et al., 1988). If the process is universally associated with diazotrophy, as seems to be the case, the relevant genes ought to be common to all diazotrophs and perhaps linked to nu‘ in some bacteria. A physiological consequence of the reversible inhibition of nitrogenase activity by oxygen which is not always appreciated is that 0,-induced switch-off is also a fortuitous posttranscriptional regulator of nitrogenase synthesis, because switched-off cells rapidly become starved of assimilable nitrogen and further enzyme synthesis will diminish since it can only take place at the expense of endogenous breakdown of cell material. Such cells thus formally resemble dinitrogenlimited populations and may be physiologically poised for the “hyperinduction” of nitrogenase discussed below. The second switch-on/off reaction is a comparable reversible response to low levels of NH, exemplified in Rhodopseudomonas paiustris (see Alef rt al., 1981), and in A . uinelundii of certain physiological status (Klugkist and Haaker, 1984), which can be interpreted teleologically as a measure of ATP economy: it is logical to consume available fixed nitrogen before using N,, The enzymological bases of both of these responses are beginning to be understood but the preliminary sensing mechanisms remain enigmatic. In addition to familiar on-off regulation both of synthesis and activity, nif’
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
15
expression can also display hyperactivity. In this respect it recalls the widely forgotten physiological phenomenon of hyperinduction, long ago demonstrated with primary catabolic enzymes such as 8-galactosidase (Novick and Horiuchi, 1962) as a response to growth limitation by the subtrate of that enzyme, lactose. In that case, actual hypersynthesis of enzyme was demonstrated, though its interpretation in terms of gene multiplication can be questioned (Smith and Dean, 1971). Nitrogenase activity can show comparable hyperinduction under limitation by availability of dinitrogen (Arp and Zumft (1983) summarized earlier reports) and also in circumstances in which the stimulus is less clear (intense illumination of a photosynthetic diazotroph in glutamate-limited conditions (Jouanneau et al., 1985)). Its physiological and genetic basis deserves further study, particularly since it may provide insight into the persistence of nitrogenase as against other enzyme activities in rhizobia, as the transition to the symbiotic dormancy of bacteroids proceeds.
C. SYMBIOSES
The physiologies of the various diazotrophic symbioses are, of course, among the most fascinating subjects of study at the interface of microbiology and plant science. Understanding of rhizobium-legume systems, particularly, has benefitted immensely from genetical input, as witness the sym plasmids and the plethora of nifl nod, hsp,.fix and related genes which molecular genetics is currently revealing (see many contributions in the 1988 Koln symposium on nitrogen fixation (Bothe et al., 1988)).The sequential regulation of such genes as nodulation proceeds is beginning to be revealed, particularly the influence of products determined by the host plant’s genes both in host-symbiont recognition (e.g. plant flavonoids; see Johnston et al. (1988)) and in nodule maturation. The mechanism whereby oxygen supply to the bacteroids is regulated, involving a semi-permeable physical barrier to 0, and a haemoglobin as an O2carrier, is becoming clear (see Evans et al., 1987) and so are both the nature of the carbon contributed by the plant and the forms of nitrogen exported by its symbiont. It is the more remarkable, then, that the physiological status of bacteroids themselves, in terms of nitrogen, carbon or oxygen limitation, remains obscure. Another persistent question concerns the physiological function of uptake hydrogenases in nodule systems (see discussion by Evans et al., 1987). In theory this hydrogenase ought to benefit diazotrophs by enabling them to recover some of the ATP lost in the hydrogen-evolving feature of nitrogenase
16
JOHN POSTGATE
function, an economy which ought to be reflected in modest but real yield increases. Yet the phenomenon has proved difficult to reproduce in the hands of different research workers, partly because, until isogenic Hup' and Hup mutants of a single rhizobial genotype became available recently, earlier tests necessarily made use of natural hydrogenase-positive and hydrogenasenegative rhizobia, among which non-specific interstrain differences might mask differences due to possession or not of hydrogenase. Tests with true isogenic mutants of Bradyrhizobium japonicum appear to substantiate the claim that the Hup' phenotype is advantageous but a paradox remains: with natural strains which show positive effects, the benefit of hydrogenase is often disproportionately large. Where one might expect hydrogen recycling to incur saving in the region of 10% to the energy economy of the symbiosis, improvements of 25% or more have been recorded. A threshold effect is thus indicated, one which bears upon the later history of the symbiosis. In this context the evidence of Aguilar e f al. (1985)is suggestive: making use of Hupmutants of A . chroococcum (Yates and Robson, 1985) they showed in chemostat studies that the most pronounced benefit of uptake hydrogenase for this organism is in the initiation ofdiazotrophy; in the steady state its effect is small, at just about at the theoretical level. A comparable benefit in the legume symbiosis might be difficult to detect because in many experimental or environmental condition it could be over-ridden by the physiological response of the plant host to those conditions. The soyabean, lucerne (alfalfa), clover and pea symbioses have been the main examples of the legume symbiosis used in research but others are now becoming popular. Much interest has been excited by the stem-nodulating system of Sesbania rostrata and its attendant Azorhizobium caulinodans (see Alazard et al., 1988)because it has novel features: nodules closer to the sites of photosynthesis than is usual, and a relatively aerotolerant symbiont. Dilworth (1987) surveyed other prospects and questions in the research area of rhizobium biology which stem from recent advances in knowledge of biological nitrogen fixation, including mineral nutrition and the possible involvement of non-Mo-nitrogenases. Among the actinorhizal and cyanobacterial symbioses, too, there are several examples of paradoxical physiologies whose resolution will advance knowledge. Three examples are: lack of vesicles without concomitant oxygen sensitivity in the nodules of Casuarina; seemingly futile persistence of the photosynthesis pigments in the cyanobacterial symbiont of the coralloid roots of Macrozamiu; and extraordinary tolerance of dehydration in diazotrophic lichens. No doubt research on the lesser-known symbioses and associations will produce many other conflicts with the dogma deriving from Klebsiella, Azotobacter and soyabeans, thus forcing constructive revision of our present global view of the physiology of diazotrophy.
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
17
VI. Ecology A. NEW DIAZOTROPHIC SYSTEMS
The collection and classification of the agents of diazotrophy proceeds apace; new microbes and new symbioses, including associations with animals, will continue to be added to the lists. “Ghosts” (Postgate, 1988) will probably continue to be reported annually as well, if only because there seem always to be a few research workers who remain unaware that, to be convincing, a report of a new nitrogen-fixing system must fulfill two elementary criteria. Firstly, the systems or cultures must be unequivocally free of known diazotrophs; secondly, they must demonstrate significant uptake of 5N,. An exciting development during the last two decades was the discovery of the rhizocoenoses: the mutualism between Azotobacter paspali and cultivars of Paspalum notatum and, soon after, the rediscovery of what is now known as Azospirillum with its catholic association with the roots of various Gramineae. Numerous associations between diazotrophic bacteria and the roots on monocotyledenous and dicotyledenous plant roots, without gross morphological alteration of root structure comparable to nodule formation, are now known and, though an element of specificity and mutualism is usually present, the contribution of fixed nitrogen by the diazotroph to the partnership is generally marginal (see review by Dobereiner and De Polli, 1980). In particular, the benefit of Azospirillum to the plant seems to be mainly to increase root density (Okon et al., 1988). Although this information has disappointed those who envisaged the immediate application of an equivalent of the legume symbiosis among cereals, search for natural systems capable of higher nitrogen inputs, or the genetic engineering of such systems, is still a promising area of inquiry. As far as new types of diazotroph are concerned, in two instances, Erwinia and Pseudomonas, establishment of diazotrophy in a new genus was simultaneous with the creation of diazotrophic strains of that genus by genetic manipulation (see Postgate et al., 1987). The majority of new strains had earlier been missed for two general reasons: firstly, the extreme oxygen sensitivity of some microaerobic diazotrophs was not always adequately anticipated; secondly, the rhizosphere, the “home” of many of the newer organisms, has only gradually been recognized as an exceptionally good habitat for diazotrophs, whether or not their activities benefit the plant. Most of the newer diazotrophs are conventional eubacteria; the discovery of diazotrophy among the archaebacteria, so far only among the methanogens, is an important development, particularly since it includes a clear example of thermophilic diazotrophy (see below). Inter- and intra-generic transfer of nifin eubacteria, especially on plasmids,
18
JOHN POSTCATE
is a routine operation in the laboratory and the discovery of naturally plasmid-borne nif(e.g. in rhizobia, Banfalvi et al. (1981); Lignobacter, Derylo et al. (1981);desulfovibrios, Postgate et al. (1986))renders it likely that nifgene transfer occurs in the natural environment. Location on a plasmid is not a prerequisite of such transfer: K. pneumoniae can be an effective donor of functional nif-as it was in R. A. Dixon's original gene transfer experiment (Dixon and Postgate, 1972kdespite its genes being chromosomal, because the regulon has some of the properties of a transposon (Piihler et al., 1979)and is thus mobilizable as a linkage group. Azotobacters, with their dispersed niJ; are unlikely to donate a potentially functional package, but the large nif-sym plasmids of rhizobia could well do so. From the viewpoint of ecology, and microbial systematics, this genetic fluidity implies that new diazotrophic species might arise by lateral gene transfer wherever selection pressure favours them. The present Rhizobium-Agrobacterium taxonomy may have arisen from plasmid exchange. Laboratory constructs indicate that, given appropriate selection pressure, naturally occurring diazotrophic strains of Serratia marcescens could be expected (Krishnapillai and Postgate, 1980). Although laboratory-generated diazotrophic strains exist, the normal habitats of E. coli and Proteus mirabilis are probably too nitrogen rich for natural selection of diazotrophic strains to be likely. B. EXOTIC DIAZOTROPHIC SYSTEMS
The single report of diazotrophy in truly thermophilic eubacteria (Closrridium thermosaccharolyticum and C. thermoautotrophicum; Bogdahn and Kleiner (1986)),growing optimally at 65°C urgently requires confirmation because the only earlier example of heat-tolerant eubacterial diazotrophy referred to a borderline case: the cyanobacterium Mastigocladus which grows best at 48"C, though its nitrogenase shows activity at higher temperatures (Stevens et al., 1985). Conversely, the nature, distribution and quantitative activity of psychrophilic diazotrophs, e.g. in the tundra and the oceans, raises problems on the borderline of ecology and biochemistry: Mo-nitrogenase apparently has temperature/activity relationships which cause it to allocate almost all of its electron supply to evolution of H,, not fixation of N,, at temperatures below 10-15°C (Thorneley and Eady, 1977), a property which would be expected to render it useless over the greater part of this planet's surface. Are natural nitrogenases psychrophilic and research materials atypical? Or do they use an alternative, less cold-sensitive enzyme, such as V-nitrogenase (Miller and Eady, 1989),in the real world? Is this why alternative nitrogenases exist? Since tungstate is an inhibitor of molybdenum uptake, are tungstaterich areas colonized by vanadium- or iron-based diazotrophs? The discovery of the new nitrogenases, with at least one instance in a symbiont, Azorhizobium
TRENDS AND PERSPECTIVES I N NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
19
(Chan et al., 1988), raises new questions concerning the ecology of diazotrophy, not least of which arises from the fact that that the acetylene test may underestimate V-nitrogenase activity by up to 10-fold (Eady, 1988). VII. Envoi
In the 1960s the interaction of chemistry and enzymology led to some of the most dramatic advances in our understanding of the basics of biological nitrogen fixation; with the emergence of nifand later syrn genetics in the 1970s, new and equally impressive developments took place and allowed the even more recent use of molecular approaches. Understanding of the physiology of diazotrophy has gained enormously from all these advances, and the day of a “molecular ecology” of diazotrophy is dawning. In all, the recent history of research on nitrogen fixation as a fundamental scientific problem has been an example par excellence of the value of an interdisciplinary approach. The study of diazotrophy in its more biological aspects-which include ecology, symbioses per se and applied research directed towards agriculture, forestry, etc.-is the major pre-occupation of the over 150 laboratories engaged in nitrogen fixation research throughout the world. At the penultimate meeting of the International Biological Programme, fewer than 10% of some 112 contributing laboratories were in any sense working on the fundamental aspects which have provided the main theme of this article. Given the economic importance of nitrogen fixation for the future of mankind, that is probably a reasonable distribution of research effort. But the ecologist and applied scientist must be constantly alert to the developments taking place at more fundamental levels, because they bear upon their methods and outlooks, which themselves require continuous revision and renewal. There is an information cycle, in which observations arising from research in the field raise questions at a fundamental level and investigation of these, while rarely providing simple answers, compels revision of more practical approaches. Today the science is in a period in which spectacular developments are taking place at fundamental levels and the input from those developments, into both basic science and research into the real world, will be spectacular in their turn. REFERENCES
Aguilar. 0.M., Yates, M. G . and Postgate, J. R. (1985).JournalqfGeneral Microbiology 131,3141. Alazard, D. I., Ndoya, 1. and Dreyfus, B. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 765-769. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Alef, K., Arp, D. J. and Zumft, W. G. (1981). Archives of Microbiology 130, 138. Aloysius, S. K. D. and Paton, A. M. (1984). Journal of Applied Bacteriology 56, 465.
20
JOHN POSTGATE
Arnold, W., Rump, A,, Klipp, W., Priefer, U. B. and Piihler, A. (1988). I n “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After”(Pr0ceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds). p. 303. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Arp, D. J. and Zumft, W. G . (1983). Journul qfBacferiolog.y 153, 1332. Bali, A., Hill, S., Santero, E., Toukdarien, A., Walmsley, J. and Kennedy, C. (1988). I n “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After”(Pr0ceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation)(H.Bothe. F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), p. 316. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Banfalvi. Z., Randhawa. G . S., Kondorosi, E., Kiss, A. and Kondorosi, A. (1981). Molecular and General Genetics 184, 3 18. Belay, N., Sparling, R. and Daniels, L. (1984). Narure, London 312, 286. Bishop, P. E.. Premuker, R., Joeger, R. D., Jacobsen, M. R.. Dalton, J. A,, Chisnall, J. R. and Wolfinger, E. D. (1988). I n “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings ofthe 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 71-79. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Bogdahn, M. and Kleiner. D. (1986). Archives qf Microbiology 144, 102. Bortels, H. (1930). Archivfur Mikrobiologie 1, 333. Bothe, H., delruijn, F. J. and Newton, W. E. (eds) (1988). “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings o f the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation). Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Chan, Y.-K., Pau. R., Robson, R. L. and Miller, R. W. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), p. 88. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Chatt, J., Pearman, A. J. and Richards, R. L. (1987). Journul qfrlie Cheniicul Society (Dalton) 1852. Clark, F. E. and Rosswell. T. (eds) (1981).“Terrestrial Nitrogen Cycles”, Ecological Bulletin No. 33. Swedish Natural Research Council, Stockholm. Clement, H. (1980). “The Nitrogen Fix.” Ace Books, New York. Dean, D. R., Brigle, K. E., May, H. D. and Newton, W. E. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 107-1 14. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Deistung. J. and Thorneley, R. N. F. (1986). Biochemicul Journul 239, 69. Delwiche, C. C. (1977). Scienrific American 223(3), 137. Derylo, M., Glowacka, M., Skorupska, A. and Lorkiewicz, 2. (I98I). Archives u / Microhio/ogy 130, 322. Dilworth. M.J. (1987). Philusnphicuf Transactions of the Rqvul Society of London, S e r k B 317, 279. Dilworth, M. J.. Eady, R. R., Robson, R. L. and Miller, R. W. (1987). Nurure, London 273, 197. Dixon, R. A. (1988). In “The Nitrogen and Sulphur Cycles” (42nd Symposium of the Society for General Microbiology) (J. A. Cole and S. J. Ferguson, eds), pp. 417438. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge. Dixon, R. A. and Postgate, J. R. (1972). Nature, London 237, 1102. Dobereiner, J. and De-Polk H. (1980). In “Nitrogen Fixation” (Proceedings of the Phytochemical Society of Europe’s Symposium Number 18) (W. D. P. Stewart and J. R. Gallon, eds), pp, 301-333. Academic Press, London. Eddy, R. R. (1986).Molecular biology. In “Nitrogen Fixation”. vol. 4, pp, 149.Clarendon Press, Oxford. Eady, R. R. (1988). EioFuctor.7 I, 111. Eady, R. R.. Robson, R. L., Pau, R. N., Woodley, P., Lowe, D. J., Miller. R. W.,Thorneley, R. N. F., Smith, B. E., Gormal. C., Eldridge, M. and Bergstrom, J. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After”(Pr0ceedings of the 7th.lnternational Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe. F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 81-86. GUStdV Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Evans, H. J., Bottomley, P. J. and Newton, W. E. (eds) (1985). “Nitrogen Fixation Research
TRENDS A N D PERSPECTIVES IN NITROGEN FIXATION RESEARCH
21
Progress” (Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Nitrogen Fixation). Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht. Evans, H. J., Zuber, M. and Dalton, D. A. (1987). Philosophical Transactions qfthe Royal Society of London, Series B 317, 209. Hales, B. J. and Case, E. E. (1987). Journal of Biological Chemistry 262, 16205. Haselkorn, R., Golden, J. W., Lammers, P. J. and Mulligan, M. E. (1987). Philosophical Transacrions of the Royal Sociery of London, Series B 317, 173. Hawkes, T. R., McLean, P. A. and Smith, B. E. (1984): Biochemical Journal 217, 317. Henderson, R.A., Leigh, G. F. and Pickett, C. J. (1 983). Advances in Inorganic and Radiochemistry 27, 192. Hennecke, H., Kaluza, K., Thony, B., Fuhrmann, M., Ludwig, W. and Stackebrandt, E. (1985). Archives of Microbiology 142, 342. Hill, S. (1988). FEMS Microbiology Reuiew 54, 111. Hoover, T., Imperial, J., Ludden, P.and Shah, V. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), p. 127. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Howard, K. S., McLean, P. A., Hanson, F. B., Lemlay, P. D., Koblan, K. S. and Orme-Johnson, W. H. (1986). Journal of Biological Chemistry 262, 772. Imperial, J., Shah, V. K., Hoover, T. R. and Ludden, P. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), p. 128. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New Ycrk. Johnston, A. W. B., Firmin, J. L. and Rossen, L. (1988). In “The Nitrogen and Sulphur Cycles” (42nd Symposium of the Society for General Microbiology) (J. A. Cole and S. J. Ferguson, eds), pp. 439455. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Jouanneau, Y., Wong. B. and Vignais, P. M. (1985). Biochimica el Biophysica Aria 808, 149. Kennedy, C. and Toukdarien, A. (1987). Annual Reviews of Microbiology 41, 227. Kentemich, T., Danneberg, C. and Bothe, H. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), p. 89. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Klugkist, J. and Haaker, H. (1984). Journal qf Bacteriology 157, 148. Krishnapillai, V. and Postgate, J. R. (1980). Archiues of Microbiology 127, 115. Leigh, G. J. and Postgate, J. R. (1985). In “Gas Enzymology” (H. Degn, R. P. Cox and H. Toftland, eds), pp. 229-246, D. Reidel, Odense. Maryan, P.,Eady, R. R.. Chaplin, A. E. and Gallon, J. R. (1986). FEMS Microbiology Letters 34, 251. Merrick, M. J. (1988a).In “The Nitrogen and Sulphur Cycles”(42nd Symposium of the Society for General Microbiology) (J. A. Cole and S. J. Ferguson, eds), pp. 331-361. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Merrick, M. J. (1988b). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 293-302. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Miller. R. W. and Eady, R. R. (1989). Biochemical Journal 256,429. Murray, P. L. and Zinder, S. H. (1984). Nature, London 312, 284. Newton, W. E. (1987). Philosophical Transactions of /he Royal Sociery of London, Series B 317, 259. Newton, W. E. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After’’ (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 43-50. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Nieva-Gomez, D., Roberts, G. P., Klevickis, S. and Brill, W. S. (1980). Proceedings ef the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 77, 2555. Nikinova, L. A,, Rummel, S., Shilov, A. E. and Wahren, M. (1980). Nouveau Journal de Chimie 4, 427430. Novick. A. and Horiuchi, T. (1962). Cold Spring Harbour Syniposia on Quanrirative Biology 26, 239. Okon, Y., Fallick, E., Arig, S., Yahalom, E. and Tal, S. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H.
22
JOHN POSTGATE
Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 741-746. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Paul, W. and Merrick. M. J. (1987). European Journal of Biochemistry 170, 259. Paul, W. and Merrick, M. J. (1988). 1n“Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After”(Pr0ceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe. F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton. eds), p. 316. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Pickett, C. J., Cate, K., Macdonald, C . J., Mohammed, M. Y.,Ryder, K. S. and Talarmin, J. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation)(H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 51-56. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Post. E., Kleiner, D. and Oelze, J. (1983). Archives qf Microhiologj) 134, 68. Postgate, J. R. (1982). “The Fundamentals of Nitrogen Fixation”. Cambridge University Press, Cam bridge. Postgate, J. R. (1987). Journal of Applied Bacterio/og.v 63, 85s. Postgate, J. R. (1988). New Scientist (1598) 49. Postgate, J. R. and Eady, R. R. (1988). 1n“Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After”(Pr0ceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 31-42. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Postgate, J. R.. Dixon, R., Hill, S. and Kent, H. (1987). Philosophical Transactions q f t h e Royal Society of London. Series B 317, 227. Postgate. J. R., Kent, H. M. and Robson. R. L. (1986). FEMS Microbiology Letters 33, 159. Postgate, J. R., Kent, H. M. and Robson, R. L. (1988). 1n“The Nitrogen and Sulphur Cycles”(42nd Symposium of the Society for General Microbiology) (J. A. Cole and S. J. Ferguson, eds), pp. 457471. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Piihler, A., Burkhardt. H. J. and Klipp, W. (1979). In “Plasmids of Medical, Environmental and Commercial Importance” (K. N. Timmis and A. Piihler, eds), pp. 435-447. Elsevier-North Holland, Amsterdam. Ramos, J. R. and Robson, R. L. (1985a). Journal qf General Microbio1og.y 131, 1449. Ramos. J. R. and Robson, R. L. (1985b). Journal OJ Bacteriology 162, 746. Shah, V. K., Hoover,T. R., Imperial, J., Paustian,T. D., Roberts, G. P. and Ludden, P. W. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After’’ (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 115-120. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Sibold. L. and Souillard, N. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After” (Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation) (H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), pp. 705-710. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York. Smith, R. W. and Dean, A. C. R. (1971). Journul of Generul Microbiology 72, 37. Sprent. J. I. (1987). “The Ecology of the Nitrogen Cycle”. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Sprent, J. I. and Raven, J. A. (1987). Proceedings ofthe Rovul Sociery of Edinburgh, Series B 85, 215. Stevens, S. E.. Mehta, V B. and Lane, L. S. (1985). In “Nitrogen fixation and C 0 2 metabolism”. (P. W. Ludden and J. E. Burris, eds), pp. 236243. Elsevier, New York. Thorneley, R. N. F. and Eddy. R. R. (1977). Biochemical Journal 167, 457. Thorneley. R. N. F. and Lowe, D. J. (1985). In “Molybdenum Enzymes” (T. Spiro, ed.), pp. 221-284. Wiley, London. Towe, K. M. (1983). Precambrian Research 20, 161. Walker, G. A. and Mortenson, L. E. (1974). Journal ofBiologica1 Chemistry 249,6356. Yates, M. G. (1972). FEBS Letters 27, 63. Yates, M. G. (1988). In “The Nitrogen and Sulphur Cycles” (42nd Symposium of the Society for General Microbiology) (J. A. Cole and S. J. Ferguson, eds). pp. 383-416. Cambridge University Press. Yates, M. G. and Robson, R. L. (1985). Journal of General Microbiology 131, 1459. Zilberstein. A., Koncz, C., Kaufman, R.. Geva, N.. Zamir, A. and Schell, J. (1988). In “Nitrogen Fixation: Hundred Years After”(Pr0ceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Nitrogen Fixation)(H. Bothe, F. J. deBruijn and W. E. Newton, eds), p. 648. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart and New York.
Apomixis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Other Eukaryotic Micro-organisms CARL A. BILINSKI," NELSON MARMIROLIb and JOHN J. MILLER' Research Department, Labatt Brewing Company Limited, London N6A 4M3, Ontario. Canada, 'Instituto di Cenetica, Universita di Parma, 43100 Parma, Italy, and 'Department of Biology. McMaster University, Hamilton U S 4K1,Ontario, Canada
a
I. Introduction: occurrence of apomixis in yeast .
.
11. The meaning of apomixis in plants, animals and fungi
.
.
. .
111. Apomixis in some eukaryotic micro-organisms . . . . IV. Inheritance of apomixis in yeasts . . . . . . . V. Environmental modification of the apomictic phenotype . VI. Timing of events controlling the manner of nuclear division VII. Nucleomitochondrial interactions in facultative apomixis . VIII. Ecology of apomixis in yeasts . . . . . . . . IX. Concluding remarks . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
23 26 29 33 36 39
.
41
.
42 46 48
.
I. Introduction: Occurrence of Apomixis in Yeast Sporulation in a cell of Saccharomyces cerevisiae is normally preceded by meiotic division of the diploid vegetative nucleus, and each of the resulting four haploid nuclei becomes enclosed within a developing spore. The four spores (ascospores) in the differentiated cell (now termed the ascus) can mate in pairs immediately upon germination to initiate clones of diploid vegetative cells, or mating may be delayed for an indefinite number of haploid vegetative generations. The process of cell fusion involved in mating is under control of the mating-type loci, designated M A T a and MATu. A M A T a cell will mate only with a MATu cell, and vice versa. The number of spores in each ascus is typically four, but this is not invariable. In virtually any sporulated culture, asci containing one, two or three spores are also found. The average number of spores per ascus is known ADVANCES I N MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY, VOL. 30 ISBN 0-12-027730-1
Copynght 0 1989, by Academic Press Ltmited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
24
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
to be influenced by a number of factors. These are as follows: (1) Although the sole nutrient required in a sporulation medium for optimum sporulation of most strains is a carbon source, e.g. potassium acetate, some asci develop in water or buffer and these are mainly two-spored. Effects of kind or concentration ofcarbon source, presence of other nutrients, and some other conditions of culture on number of spores per ascus were summarized by Miller (1981).Two-spored ascus production seems nutritionally less exacting than production of spore tetrads. A number of compounds, when added to sporulation medium, lower the frequency of spore tetrads, e.g. urethane, glutamic acid (Miller, 1963),cycloheximide (J. J. Miller, unpublished observations). (2) Conditions in presporulation growth medium are also important, e.g. omission of inositol (Tremaine and Miller, 1954) or presence of ethidium bromide for one generation of growth (Kuenzi et al., 1974) increase twospored ascus production. Bilinski et al. (1986, 1987a,b) found evidence that tetrad formation in polyploid brewing yeasts required presporulation growth under conditions in which respiratory and carbon catabolite-repressible gene functions were completely derepressed. Tetrad percentages can also be affected by temperature (reviewed by Bilinski and Casey, 1989; Miller, 1989). (3) Haber and Halvorson (1972) found that newly formed cells produced fewer spores and sporulated more slowly than larger, older, budded cells. This was confirmed by the observation of Sando et al. (1973) that the number of spores formed in a cell was affected by its stage in the vegetative cell cycle. (4) The importance of genetic background is indicated by many examples, e.g. Adams (1 950), Fowell(1951, 1967),Fowell and Moorse (1960).Grewal and Miller (1972)also found wide variation in average numbers ofspores per ascus among yeast strains. Klapholz and Esposito (1980a) detected modifiers that decrease the number of spores formed per ascus as well as total ~ S C U S production. By mutagenesis with ethyl methanesulphonate, Okamoto and Iino (1981) obtained a recessive mutation that caused production of predominantly two-spored asci. Panek et al. (1985) found no spore tetrads in asci of diploids low in trehalose synthase activity.
Cytological, genetical and biochemical studies (reviewed by Miller, 1981) have shown that the nuclei enclosed in the spores of such two-spored asci are haploid and, in fact, two unenclosed (epiplasmic) nuclei are visible in each ascus. Nuclei in these spore pairs are frequently non-sister since they are derived from separate meiosis 11 divisions and, hence, their enclosure is indicated to be not random. This characteristic of two-spored asci was used by Srivastava et al. (1983)to develop a novel, rapid technique for gene mapping in yeast. In a few instances asci containing two uninucleate spores lacking discarded
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
25
epiplasmic nuclei have been produced experimentally. Schild and Byers (1980) obtained two cell division-cycle mutants in which ascus walls formed around the products of meiosis I, producing two viable diploid spores per ascus. Haploid strains disomic for chromosome 111 formed two-spored asci (Roth and Fogel, 1971; Wagstaff et al., 1982). Chromosome 111 carries the matingtype gene which must normally be heterozygous (MA Ta/MATa) for sporulation to occur (Roman and Sands, 1953). Three strains of Sacch. cereuisiae are known that normally produce two spores per ascus and lack epiplasmic nuclei. These resulted from a search for highly sporogenic strains by J. J. Miller during 1964-1969 for use in a study of changes in chemical composition during sporulation. Of 25 1 strains obtained from culture collections and individuals, 140 were sporogenic (arbitrarily defined as producing at least 1% asci under the conditions employed). In 15 of these the asci were predominantly two-spored. The latter strains were studied cytologically by N. S. Grewal as part of a research project for a graduate degree at McMaster University, and in three, which produced exclusively twospored asci, the nucleus in the ascus divided only once. It was concluded that the spores were diploid because conjugations never occurred when they germinated, their DNA content was equal to that of the vegetative cells and clones derived from single spores were competent to sporulate (Grewal and Miller, 1972). The three strains comprised a highly sporogenic strain, designated 19e1, obtained from Station Agronomique et Oenologique de Bordeaux, France, where it was isolated from a natural fermentation, and strains 4098 and 41 17 from the American Type Culture Collection, which lists them as German white wine and Menes wine yeasts, respectively. The 19el strain was also obtained from the Czechoslovak Collection of Microorganisms, Brno, designated as Sacch. cereuisiae strain 292. Sporulation in which a single nuclear division occurred in the ascus was described by Guilliermond (1903) in Sacch. pastorianus. The asci were twospored and conjugation between germinating spores was not observed. Renaud (1937) isolated from wine fermentations three Saccharomyces strains that produced predominantly two-spored asci. Conjugations were rarely observed among germinating spores and, when asci were placed in a growth medium long enough for the spores to swell and commence budding, and then transferred to a sporulation medium, pairs of new spores developed directly within both of the spores in a given ascus or in the buds developing from them. Unfortunately, Renaud did not attempt to determine the manner of nuclear division in the asci of these yeasts. Apparently, other genera of yeasts may also sporulate without meiotic nuclear division. Manuel (1937) found with certain species of Hansenula and Pichia that, although sporulation of single cells occurred, there was no evidence of conjugation at any stage of spore germination or vegetative
26
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
growth. Again, nuclear cytology in the ascus was not studied. Using genetical techniques, Henninger (1973) studied the developmental cycle of Endomycopsis fibuliger, which had been shown by Guilliermond (1909) to lack conjugation, and concluded that the asci (two- to four-spored) formed from haploid vegetative cells. Henninger and Emeis (1974) using similar methods with two strains of Lipomyces showed that neither vegetative cells nor spores were haploid. There was no evidence for either conjugation or meiosis in the developmental cycle. A mutant of Schizosaccharomyces pombe that produced two uninucleate, diploid spores per ascus has been found to lack conjugation (Nakaseko e f al., 1984).Evidently, only the first division of meiosis occurred in the developing asci. The term “apomixis” was applied by Henninger (1973) and by Henninger and Emeis (1974) to the two types of developmental cycle they described in Endomycopsis and Lipomyces species, following the usage of Gaumann ( 1 926), and the term has also been applied to the two-spored Sacch. cereuisiae of Grewal and Miller (Moens et al., 1977; Bilinski and Miller, 1980; and others). Succharomyces strains have obvious advantages as the experimental organism for investigating morphogenesis of eukaryotes, which are well summarized by Breitenbach and Lachkovics (1983). These include ease of culture of both haplophase and diplophase, short generation time, ability to induce and control meiosis and sexual conjugation, ability to isolate and grow all four products in each meiotic tetrad, and the availability of a detailed genetic map. As a result, since the discovery of apomictic strains of Saccharomyces in 1972, a considerable volume of research has appeared which has much advanced the knowledge of this infrequent mode of yeast reproduction. This should be of value in understanding induction of apomixis in organisms less convenient for experimental study. The purposes of this review are to survey the occurrence of apomixis in micro-organisms, outline the basic molecular information on apomixis derived from yeast, and assess its relevance to apomixis-related cellular phenomena. 11. The Meaning of Apomixis in Plants, Animals and Fungi
The term “apomixis” has long been used in reproductive biology. It derives from two Greek words-apo meaning away from and mixis meaning the act of mingling(Websterj-and was first applied by Winkler (1906, 1908) to the loss of sexual reproduction (amphimixis) and its replacement by an asexual multiplication process not involving cell and nuclear fusion. His 1908 review discussed the occurrence of apomixis in the plant kingdom and distinguished three types, namely vegetative propagation (reproduction by sprouts, etc.), apogamy (sporophyte originating from vegetative cells of gametophyte) and
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
27
parthenogenesis (sporophyte originating from diploid or haploid egg without fertilization). Concerning bacteria and blue-green algae, he stated that, although these organisms apparently only multiplied asexually, they should not be called apomictic since there was no evidence that they had ever had sexual reproduction and thus could not be said to have lost it. Stebbins (1950) noted that differences of opinion arose among botanists concerning correct terminology, since apomictic phenomena are complex and advances in plant morphology and genetics since the time of Winkler necessitated much re-interpretation. In the classification of apomictic phenomena in plants developed by Gustafsson (1946) and modified by Stebbix (1 950), apomixis includes all forms of vegetative reproduction (e.g. by bulbs, runners and rhizomes) as well as agamospermy, reproduction by means of embryos and seeds produced without fertilization. There are two types of agamospermy: (1) adventitious embryony, in which embryos develop from the diploid tissue of the nucellus (the central tissue of the ovule) or of the ovule integument and (2)gametophytic apomixis, in which a diploid gametophyte (morphologically resembling the usual haploid gametophyte) arises as a result of some method of circumventing meiosis. This can happen either by developing the diploid gametophyte directly from a cell of the nucellus or of the integument (=apospory), or by the development from a cell of the archesporium in which the usual meiotic nuclear divisions do not occur and there is no chromosome reduction (= diplospory). The 2N gametophyte that results from either apospory or diplospory gives rise to an embryo through multiplication of the egg cell (=parthenogenesis)or of one of the other cells of the gametophyte ( = apogamety). Nogler (1984) has recently reviewed gametophytic apomixis in plants. In zoology, a somewhat different terminology has been used. All types of reproduction involving development of the egg cell into a new individual without fertilization are called parthenogenesis by Suomalainen (1 950) and Suomalainen et al. (1976, 1987). In a systematization based on cytological events, three types of parthenogenesis were distinguished: (1) In haploid parthenogenesis eggs in which chromosome reduction has occurred develop into haploid individuals. In some groups of animals it is very important, e.g. male bees develop in this manner. ( 2 ) Automictic parthenogenesis in which chromosome reduction occurs in the narmal manner and the diploid chromosome number is restored by fusion of two of the haploid nuclei. (3) Apornicticparthenogenesis in which there is no chromosome reduction or nuclear fusion. Only one maturation division occurs in the eggs and this division is equational.
The latter two types of parthenogenesis were grouped under the inclusive term
28
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMIROLI A N D JOHN J MILLER
diploidparthenogenesis by Beatty (1957), who defined apomixis in animals in a broader sense, i.e. “development without fusion of reproductive cells of opposite sex.. . the embryo is derived from the female parent only”. Beatty’s usage has not been generally adopted. Thus, in the treatise by White (1973) apomixis in animals was defined, similarly to Suomalainen’s apomictic parthenogenesis, as the production of individuals by a process that does not involve fertilization and in which meiosis is entirely suppressed. In the publications of Strunnikov (1978) and his coworkers ameiotic parthenogenesis is equivalent to Suomalainen’s apomictic parthenogenesis. In mycology the terminology derives mainly from Gaumann (1 928), who listed three forms of fertilization that occur in fungi: (1) Amphimixis, the conjugation of sexual cells that are not closely related. (2) Automixis, the conjugation of closely related sexual cells. (3) Pseudomixis, the conjugation of vegetative cells.
Reproduction that occurred by the vegetative development of sexual cells in the absence of fertilization was termed apomixis. He recognized two kinds of apomixis, parthenogenesis, the apomictic development of haploid cells and apogamy, the apomictic development of diploid cells. Burnett’s (1976) treatise designates as apomictic (or amictic) “fungi which appear to possess all the attributes of normal sexual reproduction but on investigation are found to lack both meiosis and fertilization”, and states that, although it has not often been detected, there is good evidence for its occurrence in all three major groups of fungi. In order to relate research on yeast apomixis to that with other organisms, it is useful to consider the classification that would be given to the types of reproduction found in the two-spored Such. cereuisiue strains of Grewal and Miller (1972), and also in typical meiotic strains, using terminology currently employed with the three foregoing biotic groups. Under the GustafssonStebbins system for plants, both the two-spored and the meiotic strains are apomictic because of their asexual reproduction by budding. The meiotic strains also, of course, reproduce by the normal sexual process, and the twospored strains show gametophytic apomixis involving diplospory (single nuclear division in the ascus) and parthenogenesis (development from the diploid spore without fertilization). Under Suomalainen’s system for animals based on cytology, two-spored yeast strains are examples of apomictic parthenogenesis. Typical meiotic strains can be regarded as examples of automictic parthenogenesis in those frequent instances where conjugation occurs in the asci between germinating spores of the same tetrad, or as examples of sexual reproduction ( = gamogony or zygogenesis) where conjugation occurs between spores from different asci or between haploid cells derived from them. Meiotic strains also exemplify haploid parthenogenesis,
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
29
since their haploid spores can, on germination, yield haploid cells that can multiply without fertilization. Asexual reproduction in the diploid phase ( = agamogony), e.g. cell division of protozoa, is not included under parthenogenesis, but we may note that budding of diploid cells is the commonest form of reproduction in strains of Saccharomyces. Applying Gaumann’s mycological scheme, the two-spored strains are obviously apomictic (and apogamic). The haploid spores of meiotic yeast strains, however, are also capable of apomictic development (parthogenesis sensu Gaumann), since they can develop in the absence of fertilization. Since conjugation in the meiotic yeasts can occur between spores from the same or from different asci and between vegetative cells derived from spores, most strains are also capable of Gaumann’s three types of fertilization (see above). Asexual reproduction, e.g. by conidia, hyphal fragmentation or budding, was not included in fungal apomixis by Gaumann. We refer to the process of sporulati.on in our two-spored Saccharomyces strains as apomixis, since this is in accord with accepted usage in mycology (Gaumann, 1926; Burnett, 1976). It has been used previously in this sense in strains of Saccharomyces (Moens et al., 1977; Bilinski and Miller, 1980; Marmiroli et al., 1981a) and in other yeasts (Henninger, 1973; Henninger and Emeis, 1974). The expression “single division meiosis” (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a)seems inappropriate, since the word meiosis (Gr. meioun = to make smaller) implies reduction, yet a striking feature of sporulation in these yeasts is the absence of reductional division. “Meiotosis” (Esposito and Esposito, 1979) has the same disadvantage. White (1973) referred to certain instances of parthenogenesis in animals asfacultative since it could be induced artificially. Although diploid spore production in our predominantly twospored yeasts is a genetically-determined trait (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a), evidence (Bilinski and Miller, 1980, 1984; Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985) that the correct meiotic phenotype with haploid spore production can be rescued by environmental manipulation would justify designation of their sporulation as ,facultative apomixis. 111. Apomixis in some Eukaryotic Micro-organisms
In one sense of the meaning of apomixis in zoology (see p. 27), haploid apornixis is a normal mode of reproduction in most fungi. That is, haploid cells resulting from meiotic divisions may develop into haploid thalli, which are normally of brief duration as in basidiomycetes or of long duration as in ascomycetes, before fertilization and zygote formation occur. In many fungi, haploid thalli reproduce themselves by producing haploid spores asexually and, in one subdivision of the fungi (Deuteromycotina), no true sexual
30
CARL A. BILINSKI, NELSON MARMIROLI A N D JOHN J. MILLER
reproduction occurs. Here we restrict the meaning of apomixis (after Burnett, 1976)to reproduction of fungi which produce sexual structures but which lack both meiosis and fertilization. We will treat as haploid apomixis formation of haploid spores or cells by such sexual structures, and as diploid apomixis instances in which they form diploid spores or cells. Automixis, the reproductive process in which a new diploid individual arises from fusion of haploid nuclei produced from a single meiotically dividing nucleus (Gaumann, 1926; Mogie, 1986), will not be considered here. Emerson (1950) cited examples of apomixis in species of Allomyces (Chytridiomycetes) in which haploid and diploid thalli alternate in the life cycle. Nuclei in resistant sporangia borne on the diploid normally undergo meiosis in formation of uninucleate zoospores each of which can give rise to a haploid thallus. In certain isolates these zoospores developed without fertilization and with high frequency into diploid thalli, a process that was favoured by good nutrition. This may be an example of diploid apomixis. Deacon (1980)noted that many Oomycete fungi, which normally require two mating types to develop sexual spores, may develop them directly from the female sex organ and thus obtain the survival advantage of these resistant spores when one of the mating types is lost. The Zygomycete Syzygites megalocarpus (Cutter, 1942) shows no nuclear fusion or meiosis at any stage in its life cycle, yet it develops sexual structures characteristic of other Mucorales (multinucleate gametangia and zygospores). In ascomycetes the instances of diploid apomixis in Saccharomyces species already cited have been the object of more cell biological research than apomixis in any other micro-organism, and this will be discussed in detail later. Examples of diploid apomixis in other yeasts are strains of Lipomyces starkeyi and L. kononenkoae, studied by Henninger and Emeis (1 974), which lacked meiosis and in which neither vegetative cells nor spores were haploid, and a mutant of Schiz. pombe lacking conjugation in which two uninucleate, diploid spores developed in each ascus (Nakaseko et al., 1984). Endomycopsis fihuliger, which lacks conjugation and in which asci develop from haploid vegetative cells (Henninger, 1973), evidently undergoes haploid apomixis. Since nuclei of mycelial ascomycetes are typically haploid (although some instances of diploidy in this group of fungi are listed in the review of Caten and Day, 1977), apomixis here, when it occurs, must be usually of the haploid type, Gaumann (1940) cited instances of ascomycetes whose antheridia are functionless or absent, and in which ascospore development is not preceded by nuclear fusion or meiotic division. In an important group of plant parasites, the Erysiphales (powdery mildews), he considered most strains to be apomictic. Nuclear behaviour preceding ascospore formation may vary. In Ascobolus equinus (Bjorling, 1944) the single haploid nucleus in the young ascus undergoes three mitoses to form the nuclei of the eight ascospores, and
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
31
in Podospora arizonensis (Mainwaring and Wilson, 1968) the young ascus is initially binucleate but no fusion occurs, both nuclei divide twice mitotically, and eight ascospores result. Bjorling (1944) drew attention to the fact that, although apomixis is of common occurrence in plants, it is comparatively rare in ascomycete fungi. The vegetative mycelium of most basidiomycetes is dikaryotic and nuclear fusion followed by meiosis precedes formation of basidiospores, which are thus haploid, and on germination they initiate haploid mycelia. In the corn smut fungus (Ustilago maydis; Ustilaginales), haploid mycelia are not pathogenic and fusion between mycelia of compatible mating types to restore the dikaryotic phase must precede development of the smut disease. Holliday (1961) studied strains of this fungus in which about 10% of the basidiospores were “solopathogenic”, i.e. capable of initiating disease development independently, and he attributed this to failure of reduction at meiosis so that the basidiospores were diploid. Similarly, some isolates of two species of basidiomycetous yeasts, Rhodosporidium toruloides (Banno, 1967) and Rhodosp. sphaerocarpum (Newell and Fell, 1970) were shown capable of producing teliospores, which normally precede basidiospore formation, without conjugation, and germination of the diploid uninucleate teliospores did not involve meiosis. This process, termed “self-sporulation” by Newell and Fell (1970), is probably diploid apomixis. Haploid apomixis has often been described in basidiomycetes and the literature on this subject was surveyed by Prillinger (1 982),who cited many examples. Features of life cycles indicative of this phenomenon are: basidia bearing two instead of four haploid uninucleate basidiospores, uninucleate instead of binucleate young basidia, absence of nuclear fusion and meiosis, and uninucleate mycelia lacking clamp connections. Fruiting bodies of Schizophyllum commune, which formed in monokaryotic cultures originating from single basidiospores, bore twospored basidia (Esser et al., 1979),and their morphogenesis was controlled by three pleiotrophic genes acting in sequence, as in dikaryotic fruiting. Diploid apomixis is also found in the true slime moulds (Myxomycetes). In this class of organisms, multinucleate plasmodia containing diploid nuclei grow in size by fusing with other plasmodia and by nuclear divisions; at maturity they develop sporangia in which the protoplasm cleaves into uninucleate spores (see Alexopoulos and Mims, 1979). Meiosis evidently occurs in young spores which become uninucleate and haploid through disintegration of all but one nucleus. The diploid plasmodia1 stage is restored through fusion of myxamoebae or flagellated swarm cells that emerge from germinating spores. In his review of myxomycete genetics, Collins (1981)concluded that a common life-cycle mode in these organisms is apomixis and that in nature this mode may alternate with the sexual modes so that either one can predominate at a particular time or location. Of 44 isolates of Didymium
32
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J MILLER
iridis studied by Betterley and Collins (1983), 12 were sexual (i.e. requiring fusion of haploid cells of opposite mating types for plasmodia1 development). Lack of evidence for meiosis and nuclear fusion in the others indicated a 2N-2N apomictic life cycle. Co-existence of sexual and apomictic strains may be widespread among myxomycete species (Collins, 198 1, 1986). Instances of diploid apomixis in protozoa are described in the review of Raikov (1972). For example, sexual reproduction in the diploid ciliate Paramecium pufrinum normally involves conjugation of two cells of compatible mating type followed by meiosis and exchange of haploid nuclei. In certain strains, however, conjugation occurred but meiosis, chromosome reduction and exchange of nuclei were not observed; the haploid phase had evidently been lost. Occasionally, a mutation appeared in such strains that restored the typical sexual mode of reproduction. Apomixis is common in the rotifers (Rotatoria), Of the two classes into which this invertebrate phylum is commonly divided (see Pennak, 1978), virtually all species in the class Digononta appear to lack males and reproduce parthenogenetically. In the Monogononta, which comprise about 90% of the known rotifer species, males occur only one to several weeks each year. At other times, the females, whose body cells are diploid, reproduce apomictically by producing eggs that undergo only one, non-reductional, division in the ovary during maturation and are thus diploid and hatch into females. Another type of female (mictic) eventually appears. It produces haploid eggs which become “resting” or “winter” eggs if fertilized, or which develop into haploid males if not. The resting eggs hatch into females which reproduce apomictically . In different classes of algae, development of single gametes into new haploid individuals without fusion has often been reported (Ettl et al., 1967; Bold and Wynne, 1978). Reproductive behaviour that may be equivalent to Saccharomyces-type diploid apomixis seems less frequent but does occur, as the following examples show. In a unicellular group, the pennate diatoms (class Bacillariophyceae, order Bacillariales), vegetative cells are diploid and, in sexual reproduction, produce non-motile gametes, usually one or two per cell. The cells (now gametangia) conjugate and the gametes fuse to form zygotes which then deveiop into auxospores. In some races of Cocconeis pfucentufuthere is no conjugation. A single nuclear division replaces the two steps of meiosis, and development of diploid auxospores follows (Drebes, 1977). In the red algae (Rhodophyceae), meiosis typically occurs in terminal cells (sporangia) on filaments of the diploid tetrasporophyte plants, and each meiosis results in the formation of a row or tetrad of four spores, each of which can germinate to form a gametophyte plant. In some species, binucleate sporangia occur which produce two spores (Bold and Wynne, 1978). Similarly, in brown algae (Phaeophyceae) meiosis occurs in sporangia borne on diploid
AF'OMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
33
plants, and the resulting spores give rise to haploids. In Huplospora globosa (Kuhlenkamp and Muller, 1986), the meiotic process in the developing sporangia is incomplete, and there is no reduction of chromosome numbers. Although the resulting spores develop into gametophyte plants, fertilization does not occur and the eggs develop directly into sporophytes. In some isolates, gametophytes rarely occur and the spores produced by the sporophyte plants develop directly into sporophytes. In Ufuu mutahilis, a green alga (Chlorophyceae), Foyn (1962) observed production of diploid in place of haploid gametes, possibly caused by failure of chromatid separation. These developed without fusion into diploid plants. The foregoing examples demonstrate that apomixis (in the mycological sense) is of widespread occurrence among lower eukaryotes, and such organisms are thus not distinct in this respect from more advanced organisms. A thorough survey of the distribution of parthenogenetic reproduction among animal groups is given by Suomalainen e f uf.(1987). For treatments of its occurrence in plants see Stebbins (1950,1971,1980), Asker (1979,1980) and Nogler (1984). The early literature on aberrant types of reproduction in fungi, algae, mosses, ferns, gymnosperms and angiosperms was surveyed by Winkler (1 942). IV. Inheritance of Apomixis in Yeasts In the typical life cycle of Succh. cereuisiue, sporulation encompasses meiosis and ascospore formation (Baker e f ul., 1976; Esposito and Klapholz, 1981). Diploid cells heterozygous (MA Tu/MATa) for the mating-type locus can be induced by nutrient deprivation (see Miller, 1989) to differentiate into asci (sexual structures) within which occurs meiosis followed by ascospore formation. Thus, a maximum of four uninucleate haploid ascospores can be expected to occur in each ascus, two of which are MATu and the remaining two MA Ta.Diploidization occurs through fusions between haploid spores and/or cells of opposite mating type. Thus, haploid and diploid generations can alternate in the life cycle; this is, however, not invariable since the three apomictic strains (ATCC4117, ATCC4098 and 19el)described by Grewal and Miller (1 972) are capable of sporulation yet remain diploid throughout their life cycles. In a genetical analysis of strain ATCC4117, Klapholz and Esposito (1980a) identified two recessive mutations, designated spol2-1 and spol3-I, either of which alone can cause production of diploid spores that give rise to vegetative progeny capable of sporulation without prior matings. By complementation analysis, strain 19el was found to harbour the spol2-1 mutation only. Strain ATCC4098, like ATCC4117, harboured both
34
CARL A BILINSKI. N t L S O N MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J MILLER
mutations (S. Klapholz, personal communication). Analysis (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980b) of recombination and chromosome segregation during sporulation of spol2-1 and spol3-1 diploid strains indicated retention of a normal meiotic prophase, since recombination frequencies approximated standard meiotic levels. However, maintenance of heterozygosity for centromere-linked markers indicated that meiosis I1 occurred in the developing asci without prior completion of a meiosis I division. Further genetic work has shown SP013 to be epistatic to SP012 and, hence, to act prior to SP012 on a common pathway responsible for segregation of homologous centromeres in meiosis I (Esposito and Klapholz, 1981; Wagstaff ef al., 1982). That meiosis I chromosome segregation is bypassed, despite retention of an apparently normal meiotic prophase, is substantiated by ultrastructural observations. Moens (1974) observed that the single nuclear division which preceded diploid-spore formation in strains ATCC4117 and 19el resembled the nuclear behaviour of typical diploid strains that undergo the two meiotic nuclear divisions to yield four haploid spores in each ascus. As in strains that form four-spored asci, a round, granular body was observed in association with nucleoli of sporulating cells. This structure is known to contain synaptonemal complex-like elements (Moens and Rapport, 1971). He also noted that nuclear division in strains 19el and ATCC4117 commenced with a spindle which could have been either a mitotic or a first meiotic spindle. But suddenly the spindle pole bodies, spindle and nucleus adopted characteristics of meiosis I1 of strains that produce four-spored asci; in addition, on completion of nuclear division and ascospore formation, the parental nucleolus was found discarded in the epiplasm surrounding the two diploid spores, as in meiosis I1 of strains that produce four-spored asci (Moens, 1971). Subsequent studies with diploid spore-forming strains derived from ATCC4117 (Moens e f al., 1977; Marmiroli et a]., 1981a) substantiated that a single meiosis 11-likedivision occurred in the developing asci despite retention of a normal meiotic prophase, as indicated by the presence of synaptonemal complexes. In the myxomycete Stemonitis juuogenita, synaptonemal complexes have also been observed in an apomictic line (Gaither and Collins, I984), indicating that chromosome pairing occurs but meiosis is arrested prior to reduction division. A comparison of meiotic and apomictic nuclear divisions in Sacch. cereuisiae is given in Fig. 1. For a recent treatment of the cytology, mechanics and biochemistry of meiosis, see Moens ( 1987). In a small proportion ofdyads produced by the spol2-1 and spol3-1 diploid strains, homozygosity for centromere-linked markers has been detected, indicating that meiosis I chromosome segregation preceded spore formation (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980b).Nakaseko et al. (1984)isolated diploid sporeforming mutants from Schiz. pombe in which ascospore formation was
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
35
meiotic pmphase
FIG. 1. Diagrammatic representation of ultrastructural events leading to apomictic dyad and meiotic tetrad formation in Saccharomyces cereuisiae. In both developmental routes structures expected of meiotic prophase are evident; these include spindle pole bodies (spb),axial cores (ac),synaptonemal complexes (sc),nucleolar organizer (no)and a nuclear dense body (ndb).In spol2-1 and spol3-1 mutants, meiosis I fails to proceed to completion. The reductional chromosome segregation of meiosis is bypassed (- - -) and instead, a single meiosis 11-like division ensues. In apomixis, the nucleolus, represented by the stippled region and shown to be confined to one lobe of the nucleus, is discarded in the epiplasm as in meiosis I1 of strains forming four-spored asci. Two diploid (2n) spores are produced instead of the usual four haploid (n) spores per ascus. Adapted from Moens (1982).
evidently preceded by meiosis I without meiosis 11, thus also rendering segregants diploid and homozygous for centromere-linked markers. Two cell division-cycle (cdc) mutants of Succh. cereoisiae, designated cdc5 and cdc 14, also produce asci containing two diploid spores that evidently result from a single reduction division at the semipermissive temperature (Schild and Byers, 1980). In plants, meiotic mutants that yield diploid progeny by reductional chromosome segregation have been detected in citrus fruit crosses by Esen et al. (1979), in irradiated Jimson weed (Duturu stramonium) by Satina and Blakeslee (1939, and in maize by Nel(l975). Parthenogenesis in angiosperm plants appears, however, to be usually a quantitative trait under polygenic control (see the review by Nogler, 1984). Mutations responsible for apomictic sporulation in Succh. cereoisiue may have their counterparts in other lower eukaryotes. In slime moulds (Myxomycetes), apomixis, presumably controlled by mutations that block reduction division during meiosis, is a prominent mode of reproduction. Apomictic-heterothallic interconversion occurs, and may cause these two reproductive states to alternate in nature, which could be important in the
36
C A R L A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
process of speciation (Collins, 1981, 1986). In certain species of Duphniu (Cladocera) loss of sexual reproduction is evidently due to the occurrence of a single meiosis suppressor (Hebert, 1987). Since the mutation is sex-limited in expression, causing loss of meiosis in the female line, male carriers can spread the gene for asexuality. According to Cuellar (1987), “we seem to know less about the origins of parthenogenesis than we did more than half a century ago”. With identification of apomixis in Succh. cereuisiue, a unicellular eukaryote that is amenable to genetic analysis, some insight can be gained regarding at least one possible origin of apomixis in diploid species. Succhuromyces cereuisiue strains 19el and ATCC4117 are diploids that harbour dominant genes for homothallism (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a; Bilinski, 1983) and genetic analysis has shown that there are two recessive mutations, designated spol2-1 and spol3-1, either of which alone can cause apomictic sporulation (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a).In homothallic strains of Succh. cereuisiue diploidization occurs through fusions between MATu and MATcr haploid cells that are both descendants of the same haploid ascospore. Consequently, diploid cells are produced that are isogenic for all loci except mating type (Herskowitz and Oshima, 1981). These diploid cells are heterozygous ( M ATuIMATcr) for the mating-type locus, and this condition renders them sporogenic. Occurrence of a mutation in S P 0 1 2 or S P 0 1 3 in a homothallic diploid ancestor would offer a simple explanation for the origin of diploid apomixis in Succh. cereuisiue. Self-diploidization following germination of haploid spores whose chromosomes bear homothallism genes, and either of the mutations known to cause apomictic sporulation, would result in diploid progeny that are heterozygous (MATaIMATcr) for the mating-type locus and, thus, sporogenic but (initially) isogenic for all other loci including the mutation causing apomixis.
V. Environmental Modification of the Apomictic Phenotype A few tetrads have been found to be produced consistently by spol2-1, spol3-1 and spol2-1 spol3-1 diploids under commonly employed sporulation conditions (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a; Bilinski and Miller, 1980; Bilinski, 1983). This observation suggested that the strains might be facultatively apomictic, a situation quite common in organisms in which apomixis occurs, as pointed out by Winkler (1942). He noted that such organisms can usually also reproduce sexually; for example, in flower heads of many species of Hierucium, both sexual and apomictic flowers may occur side by side. Studies of effects of nutrition on apomictic Succh. cereuisiue have shown that meiosis, and hence production of asci containing four haploid ascospores, can be
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
37
restored (Bilinski and Miller, 1980; Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985). In strain 19e1, a spol2-1 SP013 diploid (Esposito and Klapholz, 1981),increasing the glucose concentration supplied in the presporulation medium, or the potassium acetate concentration in sporulation medium, induced tetrad formation, and the effects on tetrad yields of simultaneously increasing both of these concentrations were additive (Bilinski and Miller, 1980). The further addition of zinc sulphate to both presporulation and sporulation media gave still higher yields and, under this condition, apomictic dyads and meiotic tetrads were formed in nearly equal percentages. In strain ATCC4117, a spol2-1 spol3-1 diploid (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a),increases in carbonsource concentrations alone were not found to enhance tetrad formation and their induction frequency increased only on further addition ofzinc ions to the culture media (Bilinski, 1983). Restoration of meiosis in apomictic strains was also accomplished by some treatments other than the foregoing modifications in culture medium composition. The incubation temperature most commonly used for presporulation growth and induction of sporulation of Succh. cereuisiue is 2 7 T , which approximates the optimum with most strains (Miller, 1988). In strain 19e1, it was found possible to induce tetrads by mild temperature shock at 18 or 36°C for the first few hours of sporulation (Bilinski and Miller, 1984), and also by inhibition of protein synthesis with cycloheximide administered during the first few hours of incubation under sporulation-inducing conditions (Bilinski et ul., 1983).In strain ATCC4117, heat shock at 38 or40"C also induced tetrad formation when applied during the same time period of sporulation as with 19el (N. Marmiroli and C. A. Bilinski, 1988, unpublished observations). Success in tetrad induction was also achieved with strain ATCC4117 by manipulation of the carbon source to nitrogen source ratio present during presporulation growth (Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985). Maximum tetrad yields occurred in sporulation medium when cells were grown in a defined medium containing 6% (w/v) glucose and 0.1 YO(w/v) ammonium sulphate. When the glucose concentration was lowered or when the ammonium sulphate concentration was increased, tetrad yields declined. Glucose added to sporulation medium is known to arrest yeast cells in meiosis I (Miller, 1964), but inclusion of this catabolite repressor in sporulation media at levels that prevent sporulation of meiotic strains has no apparent effect on apomictic sporulation in strains 19e1, ATCC4117 and ATCC4098 (Grewal and Miller, 1972; Bilinski and Miller, 1980; Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985). The mutations responsible for apomictic sporulation in these strains (see Section IV, p. 33) have evidently released sporulation from glucose catabolite repression and this may be of industrial relevance (see Section IX, p. 42). Alternatively, the mutations may be epistatic to gene functions regulated by glucose in meiosis I and, hence, may act prior to the
38
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN 1. MILLER
glucose-sensitive step, thereby permitting apomictic sporulation in the presence of glucose. The effect can be dramatic since, under nutritional conditions that restored the two meiotic nuclear divisions in strains 19el and ATCC4117 (Bilinski and Miller, 1980; Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985), inclusion of glucose, even at a concentration as low as 0.1% (w/v) in the sporulation medium, strongly inhibited meiotic tetrad production with no significant decrease in formation of apomictic dyads in the same sporulation culture. Since glucose repression of mitochondria1 functions is a wellestablished phenomenon in Sacch. cerevisiae (Polakis and Bartley, 1965; Tzagoloff, 1969; Perlman and Mahler, 1974), the apomictic strains thus present themsevles as model systems for investigation of nucleomitochondrial interactions during sporulation (see Section VII, p. 41). The ability to condition environmentally apomictic Sacch. cerevisiae for a complete meiotic programme that culminates in haploid spore production is cause to give some consideration to the possibility of reversing the process, i.e. inducing apomictic sporulation in strains that normally produce haploid spores. In fact, progress in this direction has been made by blocking meiosis I1 with the drugs bleomycin, mitomycin C (Sora et al., 1983)and caffeine (Sora et al., 1984),thereby facilitating recovery of diploid products of the sporulation process. Investigation of the effects of nutrition on ascosporogenesis in apomictic yeast indicated a r81e for zinc in yeast meiosis (Bilinski and Miller, 1980).The precise manner of action of the micronutrilite in restoration of meiosis is unknown. Zinc is known to interact with membranes and participate as a cofactor in macromolecular synthesis (Chvapil, 1973), affect chromatin configuration (Kvist, 1980), promote tubulin polymerization (Crepeau and Fram, 1981), affect ribosome structure (Subcommittee on Zinc, 1979) and accumulate in nucleoli (Fujii, 1954, 1955).Translocation of zinc from vacuolar to nuclear compartments has, in fact, been observed microcytochemically during the first few hours of sporulation under the nutritional conditions that restored meiosis in strain 19el (Bilinski and Miller, 1983).Zinc accumulated in nuclear membranes and nucleoli during this period, and co-incident with this cytological event was an apparent inhibition of protein synthesis that was correlated with the restoration of meiosis (Bilinski el al., 1983). These observations are of interest, since in normal meiosis SPOZZ and SPOZ3 gene products might prevent occurrence of meiosis I1 until meiosis I has been completed (Esposito and Klapholz, 1981; Klapholz and Esposito, 1980b; Wagstaff et af., 1982). Protein breakdown is apparently unaffected on inhibition of protein synthesis in sporulating yeast cultures (Magee and Hopper, 1974). Thus, it is conceivable that the protein synthesis inhibition evident on inclusion of zinc in sporulation medium (Bilinski el a/., 1983) restored meiosis by interrupting the normal sequence of gene expression while
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
39
permitting breakdown of the proteins encoded by genes that would otherwise allow cells to undergo meiosis I1 without prior completion of a meiosis I division. Some of these may, in fact, be mitotic cell-division-cycle (CDC) genes normally not expressed during yeast sporulation as a consequence of SP012 and SP013 regulation (see Section VI, p. 40).
VI. Timing of Events Controlling the Manner of Nuclear Division Since spol2-1 and spol3-1 mutants are rendered capable of meiosis I1 without prior completion of meiosis I (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980a,b), it has been suggested that, in wild-type (SP012 x SP013) diploid cells, which have normal meiosis, occurrence of meiosis I1 is prevented until meiosis I is completed (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980b;Esposito and Klapholz, 1981).The underlying mechanism whereby SP012 and SP013 cells exert such control is as yet unclear, but some insight has been gained by monitoring the sequence of biochemical and nuclear events during sporulation employing the culture conditions that permit manipulation of the apomictic phenotype in strain 19el (Bilinski et al., 1983). These are as follows: (a) cultivation under commonly used culture conditions (1% (w/v) glucose in presporulation medium; 2% (w/v) potassium acetate in sporulation medium), which yield almost exclusively apomictic dyads and are termed non-permissive conditions for meiosis; (b) cultivation with high concentrations of carbon source (6% (w/v) glucose in presporulation medium; 3.5% (w/v) acetate in sporulation medium with addition of 25 pg ml- zinc sulphate to both media. The latter combination yields meiotic tetrads and apomictic dyads in nearly equal frequency, and we have termed it semipermissive for meiosis. Yeast cells normally complete mitosis during the first few hours of incubation under sporulation-inducing conditions and then arrest in the G 1 interval of the cell cycle prior to embarking upon a meiotic programme (Hirschberg and Simchen, 1971).Under non-permissive conditions for meiosis in strain 19e1, the single nuclear division which preceded apomictic dyad formation, however, commenced within the first hour of sporulation (Bilinski et al., 1983). Limitation of protein synthesis, a condition known to signal G1 arrest (Unger and Hartwell, 1976), has been correlated with restoration of meiosis in strain 19e1, and a delay in the onset of nuclear division was observed to co-incide with limitation of protein synthesis during the first few hours of incubation in sporulation medium (Bilinski et al., 1983). During this period, zinc ions were shown to translocate from vacuolar to nuclear compartments and accumulate in the nucleolus and nuclear membrane (Bilinski and Miller, 1983). Meiotic tetrads have been shown to be induced when strains 19el and ATCC4117 are heat shocked during the same early time
40
C A R L A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
period (Bilinksi and Miller, 1984; N. Marmiroli and C. A. Bilinski, 1988, unpublished observation) and it is known that heat shock causes transient G1 arrest (Johnston and Singer, 1980). Thus, it is conceivable that spol2-1 and spol3-1 mutants are defective in regulation ofcertain cell division-cycle (CDC) genes such as those indicated to control events leading to arrest of yeast cells in GI, for instance CDC25 and CDC35, which also evidently regulate the choice between mitosis and meiosis in response to nutritional stimuli (Shilo et al., 1978).Although the basis for restoration of normal meiosis remains at present unclear, it is evident that events occur early in the sporulation culture which determine whether a given nucleus will undergo meiotic instead of apomictic division. In fact, the gene S P O l 3 has been cloned recently and its expression was found to commence within the first hour of sporulation (Wang et ul., 1987). This co-incides with the time period found to play a key r81e in determining whether apomixis or meiosis ensues. Investigations into the regulation of nuclear division in strain 19el (Bilinski et al., 1983, 1987c)have led to identification of at least three prerequisites for the morphogenetic switch from diploid to haploid spore production during sporulation. These are: (a) limitation of protein synthesis during the early hours of sporulation; (b) a delay in the onset of nuclear division following inoculation of sporulation cultures; (c) occurrence of at least one complete mitotic cell-division cycle. The last prerequisite is of particular interest since a rble for the cell-division cycle in determination of the manner of nuclear division during sporulation has already been suggested above. The number of buds which a yeast cell has produced, and hence its “age”, can be determined by fluorescence staining with calcofluor which reveals the bud scars, and the number of these occurring on the surface of a cell serves as a direct measure of the number of complete mitotic cell-division cycles that it has experienced. These studies (Sando and Saito, 1970; Yanagita et al., 1970)have shown that older cells which have completed several mitotic cell-division cycles produce three- and four-spored asci, whereas freshly formed cells, which lack calcofluor-stainable bud scars and have not yet produced daughter cells, seldom sporulate. Haber and Halvorson (1972) also noted that small cells or buds, in general, have a lower capacity to sporulate than larger mother cells; however, even buds similar in volume to their mother cells sporulated much less frequently. Bilinski et al. (1987~)found that apomictic dyad but not meiotic tetrad formation can occur in newly formed vegetative cells that have not produced a bud and thus have not experienced a mitotic cell-division cycle. The existence of a cell-division age dependency prerequisite for rescue of normal meiosis offers a reasonable explanation for the inability to condition all sporulating cells of a given apomictic mutant for the two meiotic nuclear divisions (Bilinski and Miller, 1980; Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985). That apomictic dyad formation occurred in newly formed daughter cells is of
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
41
particular interest given the genetic basis for apomixis in Sacch. cerevisiae described in Section IV (p. 33) since the mutations prevent meiosis but permit newly formed cells to sporulate. This observation can account for the fact that sporulation in apomictic Sacch. cerevisiae occurs at very high percentage rates under standard sporulation conditions (Grewal and Miller, 1972; Moens, 1974; Bilinski and Miller, 1980). VII. Nucleomitochondrial Interactions in Facultative Apomixis
Studies (Ephrussi and Hottinguer, 1951;Miller and Halpern, 1956; Puglisi and Zennaro, 1971; Gorts, 1975; Marmiroli et al., 1981b) have shown that respiration and mitochondrial protein synthesis play an important rdle in conditioning yeast cells for sporulation. Not all respiration-related functions are, however, needed for sporulation since several respiratory deficient mutants have been found that retain sporogenic ability (Pratje et al., 1979; Hartig and Breitenbach, 1980). Other mutants have been identified that are able to sporulate under conditions of catabolite repression (Dawes, 1975; Vezinhet et al., 1979; Dawes and Calvert, 1984),and the spof2-f and spof3-f mutations that cause apomictic sporulation can be considered to be in this category since apomictic dyad though not meiotic tetrad formation can occur under conditions of glucose catabolite repression (see Section V, p. 36). Consistent with this observation is the fact that meiotic but not apomictic sporulation is strongly inhibited following inclusion in sporulation medium of erythromycin, a specific inhibitor of mitochondrial protein synthesis (ClarkWalker and Linnane, 1966). Erythromycin has been shown to prevent yeast meiosis by arresting development in prophase of meiosis I at some point between intragenic and intergenic recombination (Marmiroli et al., 1983, 1985). Thus, it is possible that spof2-f and spof3-f mutations render cells capable of sporulation in the presence of erythromycin by acting prior to the erythromycin-sensitive step(s) in the meiotic prophase. This is likely since apomictic dyads are still produced in the presence of mutations (spoff - I , rad52-I) that abolish meiotic recombination (Esposito and Klapholz, 1981; Malone and Esposito, 1981). The fact that restoration of meiosis in apomictic genetic backgrounds is impeded on inhibition of mitochondrial protein synthesis (Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1985)confirms that meiosis is indeed dependent upon mitochondrial translation products (Marmiroli et al., 1981b, 1983,1985; Marmiroli and Lodi, 1984a; Puglisi and Zennaro, 1971). Previous investigations (Petersen et al., 1979; Trew et al., 1979; Wright and Dawes, 1979; Wright et al., 1981; WeirThompson and Dawes, 1984)demonstrated synthesis of sporulation-specific proteins in Sacch. cerevisiae, and these are not synthesized when mitochondrial protein synthesis is prevented (Marmiroli and Lodi, 1984b).In fact,
42
CARL A. RILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
certain sporulation-specific proteins correspond to known heat-shock proteins (Marmiroli and Lodi, 1984a,b) and this has been confirmed by hybridization of sporulation-specific transcripts with cloned heat-shock genes (Kurtz and Lindquist, 1984, 1986; Kurtz et al., 1986). Some of these sporulation-specific heat-shock proteins are not synthesized when translation of mitochondrial transcripts is blocked by inclusion of erythromycin in sporulation medium (Marmiroli and Lodi, 1984a,b). This observation is important since meiotic-tetrad production is enhanced in strain ATCC4117 and induced in strain 19el when cells of these apomictic strains are heat shocked on transfer from presporulation growth to sporulation-inducing conditions (Bilinski and Miller, 1984; Marmiroli and Bilinski, 1989). In strain ATCC4117, tetrad induction by heat shock has been correlated with induction of certain heat-shock proteins that correspond to sporulation-specific proteins whose synthesis is prevented by inclusion of erythromycin in sporulation medium (N. Marmiroli, unpublished results). The precise rale of these proteins in restoration of meiosis is at present unclear. Given the foregoing effects of erythromycin and heat shock on sporulation in strain ATCC4117, it is conceivable that the mutations responsible for apomixis in Suc.c/z. cerevisiue (see Section IV, p. 33) alter mitochondrial control over the meiotic process. In this regard it is well known that mitochondrial gene expression can be regulated by nuclear genes (for a review see Evans, 1983). Thus, apomictic mutants of Succh. cereuisiae are indicated by these data to have potential for analysis of nucleomitochondrial interactions in determination of the manner ofdevelopment a given cell will follow under sporulationinducing conditions. No such analysis has evidently been undertaken in facultatively apomictic forms of higher eukaryotes, perhaps because none is so amenable to genetic manipulation as Sacch. cerevisiae.
VIII. Ecology of Apomixis in Yeasts No study has been made of the distribution and significance of apomictic strains of Succk. cerevisiae in nature. That they do exist is indicated by their occurrence among strains derived from natural wine fermentations (see p. 25). This characteristic, controlled by a single gene difference affecting only sexual reproduction (see p. 33) offers some useful features as a model system for a study of population dynamics and ecology of wild yeasts. Information on the comparative sensitivity of yeast spores and vegetative cells to stresses has been summarized by Miller (1989). Unlike the bacterial endospore, the yeast ascospore (also an endospore) has heat sensitivity that is only slightly less than that of the vegetative cell, but, in many other respects, its resistance to environmental stress is comparable to that of the bacterial spore. It resists killing by ethanol, diethyl ether, heat, cold, alternate freezing and
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
43
thawing, desiccation, mechanical damage, starvation, radiation and wall digestion by animal and microbial glucanases. A state of dormancy is indicated by low respiratory activity (Pontefract and Miller, 1962)and by the apparent absence of ATP (Barton et al., 1980)and of mRNA turnover (Kurtz and Lindquist, 1984).The well-known difficulty in staining yeast spores with some dyes and in destaining them with acid in common spore-staining procedures indicates low wall permeability (Kelly and Gay, 1969), and this feature may have survival value in the presence of environmental toxins such as the killer factors produced by many naturally occurring yeasts (Starmer et al., 1987; Young, 1987). The hydrophobic surface of the spore wall may aid dissemination by adhering to the exoskeleton of insects or to cuticular plant surfaces, and may even enable movement on water films by surface tension like the hydrophobic spores of the fungus Pithomyces chartarum (Crawley et al., 1962). The products of meiotic nuclear division are thus enclosed in cells that are dormant and more rugged than vegetative cells, and are able to resume vegetative activity when nutritional and other conditions favour renewed growth (Miller, 1989).According to Phaff (1986), the natural habitats of Sacch. cerevisiae strains are not well defined; possible free-living progenitors of industrial strains have been isolated from exudates of pine and oak, oak bark, soil beneath oaks and intestinal tracts of species of Drosophila. Vegetative (mitotic) nuclear division and multiplication of yeast may proceed under environmental conditions well known to be inhibiting to meiosis (Miller, 1989),e.g. low pH value, low water activity, low temperature, anaerobiosis, moderate concentrations of glucose, and presence of ethanol or carbon dioxide, and it seems reasonable to assume that these factors, so commonly encountered in the normal environment of yeast, would restrict spore production in nature. Less is known of the response of apomictic sporulation to environmental stresses, but there is some evidence that it may be less sensitive than meiotic sporulation. Experiments (J. J. Miller, unpublished results) to compare sporulation of the three known apomictic yeast strains with that of two meiotic strains at several temperatures showed that all sporulated well at 27°C; all grew well at 10°C but only the apomictic strains sporulated at 10°C within 10 days. Grewal and Miller (1972), Bilinski and Miller (1980) and Marmiroli and Bilinski (1985) found sporulation of apomictic strains less sensitive to glucose inhibition than that of meiotic strains. Using nutritional conditions that restored meiosis in almost half of the showed that newly developing asci of an apomictic strain, Bilinski et al. (1987~) formed daughter cells could sporulate apomictically but not meioticaily, which suggests that apomixis is the less demanding type of sporulation. Previous production of at least one bud by the cell that becomes the ascus appeared to be a requirement for meiotic, although not for apomictic, sporulation.
44
CARL A BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl AND JOHN J MILLER
The frequency, value and significance of parthenogenesis and apomixis are important problems in population genetics, and have been discussed extensively by many authors (Crow and Kimura, 1971; Williams, 1975; Maynard Smith, 1978; Vespdainen and Jarvinen, 1979; Asker, 1980; Gerritsen, 1980; Lloyd, 1980; Stebbins, 1980; Manning, 1981; Marshall and Brown, 1981; Nogler, 1984; Uyenoyama, 1987). Several advantages can be attributed to non-sexual forms of reproduction. When such a population occurs at a low density, as in colonization of a new habitat, the problem of mating encounters would not arise. Fortuitous genotypes that happen to be particularly well adapted to an environment could be perpetuated without being broken up by recombination. Polyploids or hybrids expressing heterosis of competitive value but prone to meiotic disturbances could be stabilized and propagated rapidly. Since energy and resources need not be used to produce males, an asexual clone can produce more reproductive individuals in a given environment compared with a sexual competitor. These advantages of asexual reproduction are countered by a very important disadvantage, i.e. less genetic diversity can be generated, since, to incorporate two beneficial mutations in the same clone, the second must occur in a descendant of the individual in which the first occurred. Although the number of individuals may be increased, they tend to be copies of one another, so that an asexual population may become an evolutionary “dead end”, and prone to extinction if in competition with related sexual forms. Apomictic forms may, however, be favoured by early colonization of habitats and by low-competition environments, often showing vigorous, “weedy” proliferation and (in animals) tend to occur in cooler or drier conditions than related sexual forms. Detailed, critical discussion of this area of population genetics is given in the references already cited. In the absence of information concerning the frequency and distribution of apomictic yeasts in natural environments, an assessment of their significance must be speculative and based on behaviour in artificial culture. I t is probable that they are not abundant, since examination of sporulation of 140 sporogenic yeast strains obtained randomly from culture collections yielded only three that were apomictic (Grewal and Miller, 1972).Such yeasts possess two types of parthenogenetic development: budding, in which mitotic division of the mother-cell nucleus supplies a diploid nucleus to the growing bud, and apomictic nuclear division in sporulation. Although meiotic levels of recombination occur during the latter (Klapholz and Esposito, 1980b), it can concern only the genetic material initially present in the diploid cell and will represent an evolutionary “dead end”. However, Stebbins (1971) noted that apomictic complexes may contain some populations that are sexual or facultatively apomictic, and can enrich the gene pool of an obligate apomict from time to time. From a study of the slime mould Didymium iridis, Collins
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
45
and Gong (1985) obtained evidence that its apomictic and sexual reproductive modes of development may alternate in nature. Bilinski and Miller (1980, 1984) showed that environmental modification during sporulation and presporulation growth can induce meiotic division in apomictic yeasts. The apomictic yeast strains are diploid (Grewal and Miller, 1972; Esposito ez al., 1974),and thus the frequent correlation between polyploidy and apomixis well known in animalsand plants (Lokki and Saura, 1980; Stebbins, 1980; Nogler, 1984) seems absent here, although polyploidy can occur in yeasts (Leupold, 1956) and especially in brewing yeasts (Stewart, 1981). There is evidence for polyploidy in the major groups of true fungi and in slime moulds, but most of the numerous reports are cytological and speculative (Rogers, 1973; Maniotis, 1980). The best established instances involve fungi with prominent diplophases in their life cycles. Burnett (1975) noted no correlation between apomixis and polyploidy in fungi. From the foregoing comparisons, there seems no obvious selective advantage for apomictic sporulation in Saccharomyces species over vegetative budding in respect to values generally attributed to asexual reproduction, and it is legitimate to wonder why both of these reproductive modes should exist together. A possible ecological role for apomixis in wild yeasts is that, since each apomictically produced spore on germination yields diploid cells, the problem of re-establishing the diploid phase presented by overly thin disperson of haploid spores which have survived a time of stress is overcome. Further, considering the sensitivity of meiotic nuclear division to stresses, it can also be argued that apomixis in yeast may provide a means to invoke the aid of the spore in surviving adversity without the need to undergo stresssensitive meiotic divisions. Stebbins (1950) suggested that the normal course of meiosis in plants can be upset more easily by various environmental disturbances than that of mitosis, and Suomalainen’s (1950) review on animal parthenogenesis gives instances of greater hardiness in parthenogenetic than in bisexual forms. As polyploidy seems not to be a factor in fungal apomixis (see p.45), organisms such as yeast are promising material for experimental investigation of the relevance of mechanics of mitosis and meiosis to the origin and dispersion of apomictic forms. Techniques for probable use in such studies are the rapid Giemsa yeast nuclear staining procedure of Miller (1989) and the possibility of selecting apomictic strains from mixed growing populations by sporulation under conditions (e.g. glucose concentration, temperature) that favour apomictic over meiotic sporulation. Spores that develop in the selective environment could then be recovered in a viable condition by killing the vegetative cells, using diethyl ether (Dawes and Hardie, 1974). The use of selective media for isolation of yeasts from their natural habitats is discussed by Phaff (1986) and by Phaff and Starmer (1987).
46
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
IX. Concluding Remarks
Some of the current interest in apomixis stems from its possible application in agriculture as an aid in crop rearing and in development of improved varieties. As discussed by Doll (l973), advantages of apomixis, a phenomenon widespread among agricultural plants, include the following. Formation of seeds is independent of pollination and fertilization and often, therefore, better and more reliable than in the case of related sexual varieties. Heterosis can be maintained through apomixis. Apomixis provides an escape from sterility which may be important with polyploid varieties. Many apomictic agricultural plants show, in comparison with related sexual varieties, a greater degree of vitality and competitiveness which cannot be explained as a heterosis effect; in the important crop genus Poa, which includes many facultative apomicts, the apomictic mode of reproduction is more prominent in cold years and in colder climates. Thus there is much interest (see Nogler, 1984) in introducing apomixis into cultivated sexual plants, especially those unsuitable for large-scale vegetative propagation, such as cereals, and advances will require knowledge of the functioning of the genes for apomixis and thorough understanding of the physiological background of the components of the system. Hanna (1980) suggested a study of transfer of chromosome segments carrying apomictic genes and of methods for turning these genes off and on with chemicals. The existence of yeast strains that sporulate apomictically, and the identification of recessive genes for apomixis in these strains, give an opportunity to obtain information on apomixisrelated cellular phenomena relevant to this important area by exploiting the advantages of working with a unicellular organism. Research on control of sexual and apomictic reproduction of silkworms in the U.S.S.R. led to methods for increasing yields through production of populations with high proportions of either female or male larvae (Strunnikov, 1978). Higher silk yields are obtained from the latter. Apomixis in mammals would have, obviously, great agricultural (and ethical!) significance but, although the parthenogenetic mode of reproduction is fairly common in lower animals and even in some fairly advanced in the evolutionary scale such as amphibians, reptiles and, rarely, birds, it has not been shown conclusively to occur in mammals (see the review by Mittwoch, 1978). This has been accounted for on the basis of a need for both maternal and paternal genomes, not merely for heterozygosity during embryo development (reviewed by Miller, 1987). That is, maternal and paternal genomes acquire critical differences, and a mechanism that was suggested for this is imprinting of chromosomal DNA during gamete production by insertion of chemical groups, e.g. methylation. A medical problem linked to parthenogenetic development is the type of human ovarian tumour referred to as cystic
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
47
teratomas or dermoid cysts, which are benign growths containing tissue elements that arise from all three germ layers. Information concerning the chromosome morphology of cells from these structures obtained by means of electrophoretic enzyme analysis and chromosome-banding techniques indicated that the specimens examined (Linder et al., 1975) had developed without fertilization from single germ cells resulting from the first meiotic division with suppression of meiosis 11. Chromosome polymorphisms situated at or near the centromeres were found to be homozygous in the tumour cells. In a similar study, Parrington et al. (1984)concluded that, although most of the 21 tumours they examined evidently could have arisen from single germ cells resulting from the first meiotic division, others could have originated from failure of meiosis I with successful meiosis 11, thereby resulting in retention of heterozygosity for centromere-linked markers. The latter type of germ-cell development resembles the sequence of cytological events described in Section IV (p. 33) with apomictic yeast. The other type, involving suppression of meiosis 11, has also been demonstrated in Sacch. cereuisiae in two cell-division cycle mutants (Schild and Byers, 1980). Sora and Bianchi (1982) evidently induced apomictic nuclear division in place of meiosis in some cells of a strain of Sacch. cereuisiae by addition of caffeine, and this suggests that study of induction of apomictic nuclear division in this yeast species may supply information relevant to the genesis of teratomas. Fekete (1987) recently proposed that some malignant cells may have a parthenogenetic origin. Some useful features of Sacch. cereuisiae as an experimental organism for research on apomixis are summarized at the end of Section I (p. 26). The fact that the mutations ( 3 ~ 0 1 2 - 1 ,3 ~ 0 1 3 - 1 )have been indicated to release sporulation from glucose catabolite repression (see Section VII, p. 41) may be of relevance in brewery fermentations, since glucose repression is the major factor regulating metabolism of carbohydrates such as maltose (van Wijk et al., 1969),sucrose (Gascon et a/., 1968)and galactose (Spiegelman and Reiner, 1947).Thus, it is conceivable that mutations responsible for apomixis in Sacch. cereuisiae are pleiotropic by also derepressing enzyme synthesis for carbohydrate catabolism under conditions of glucose catabolite repression, thereby improving fermentation performance through enhancement of rates of carbohydrate assimilation and hence of ethanol production. Should this turn out to be so, the fact that gene S P 0 1 3 has been cloned (Wang et al., 1987) will facilitate possible introduction of the characteristic into other yeasts uia gene disruption (Rothstein, 1983).Looking to the future, we may suggest that its possible introduction into higher organisms of economic importance may aid development of techniques to improve control of their reproduction. We see, in conclusion, that the tendency towards apomictic in place of sexual reproduction occurs almost universally throughout the biotic world, and that the lower eukaryotic micro-organisms are no exception in this regard.
48
CARL A BILINSKI. NELSON MARMlROLl A N D JOHN J. MILLER
Inconsistencies occur in the terminology concerning parthenogenetic reproduction of plants, animals and fungi which must be considered when comparisons are made. Apomixis has been shown to occur in three readily available strains of Succh. cereuisiue. As in other organisms, its frequency is environmentally influenced. It may play a r61e in aiding yeast survival by allowing formation of resistant spores without having to undergo meiosis and by permitting sporulation under conditions that would otherwise prevent sporulation in standard meiotic strains. Mitochondria1 functioning plays a less essential r61e in yeast apomixis than in meiosis. Differences in composition and/or microstructure between old and young cells enable the former to effect both meiosis and apomixis, and the latter only apomixis. A single gene can control the apomictic phenotype but more than one locus is involved. Research on the occurrence and distribution of such genes in Succh. cereuisiue and related yeasts in Nature could contribute to microbial ecology and population genetics as well as to an understanding of morphogenetic controls of meiosis. In its historical r61e as an experimental subject for fundamental research, Sacch. cereuisiue provides opportunities for obtaining information in the field of reproduction that may have have wider relevance. Study of yeast apomixis is challenging and offers important scientific as well as applied rewards. REFERENCES
Adams, A. M. (1950). Canadian Journal efRe.vearch F 28, 413. Alexopoulos, C. J. and Mims, C. W. (1979). “Introductory Mycology”, 3rd edn. John Wiley, Chichester. Toronto. Asker, S . (1979). Hereditas 91, 231. Asker, S . (1980). Heredirus 91, 277. Baker, B. S., Carpenter, A. T. C., Esposito, M. S., Esposito, R. E. and Sandler, L. (1976). Annuul Review, of Generics 10, 53. Banno, I. (1967). Journal of Generul and Applied Microbiology 13, 167. Barton, J. K., den Hollander, J. A., Lee, T. M., MacLaughlin, A. and Shulman, R. G. (1980). Proceedings of rhe Narional Academy I$Sciences nfthe United Stares uf Americu 77, 2470. Beatty, R.A. (1957). “Parthenogenesis and Polyploidy in Mammalian Development”. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Betterley, D. A. and Collins, 0. R.(1983). Mycologia 75. 1044. Bilinski. C. A. ( 1 983). Ph.D. Thesis: McMaster University, Hamilton. Ontario, Canada. Bilinski. C. A. and Casey, G. P. (1989). Yeast 5 (in press). Bilinski, C. A. and Miller, J. J. (1980). Journal uf Bacteriology 143, 343. Bilinski, C. A. and Miller, J. J. (1983). Canadian Journal qf Generics and Cytology 25, 415. Bilinski, C. A. and Miller, J. J. (1984). Cunadiun Journal uf Micrubiology 30, 793. Bilinski, C. A., Miller, J. J. and Girvitz, S . C. (1983). Journal of Bacreriology 155, 1178. Bilinski, C. A., Russell, I. and Stewart, G . G. (1986). Journal q f t h e Insrirure qf Brewing 92, 594. Bilinski, C. A., Russell, 1. and Stewart, G . G . (1987a). Journal qfthe Insriru/e qf Brewing 93,216. Bilinski, C. A., Hatfield. D. E., Sobczak. J. A., Russell, 1. and Stewart, G. G . (1987b). In “Biological Research on Industrial Yeasts” (G. G. Stewart, 1. Russell, R.D. Klein and R. R.Hiebsch, eds), vol. 2, pp. 37-47. CRC Uniscience Series. C R C Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Bilinski, C. A., Marmiroli, N. and Miller, J. J. (1987~).Yeas/ 3, 1.
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
49
Bjorling, K. (1944). Kungl. FysiograJiska Sallskapets i Lund 14, 147. Bold, H. C. and Wynne, M. J. (1978). “Introduction to the Algae”. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.. Breitenbach, M. and Lachkovics, E. (1983). In “Secondary Metabolism in Fungi” (J. W. Bennett and A. Ciegler, eds). pp. 307-374. Marcel Dekker, New York and Basel. Burnett, J. H. (1975). “Mycogenetics”. John Wiley, London. Burnett, J. H. (1976). “Fundamentals of Mycology”, 2nd edn. Edward Arnold, London. Caten, C. E. and Day, A. W. (1977). Annual Review of Phytopathology 15, 295. Chvapil, M. (1973). Life Sciences 13, 1041. Clark-Walker, G . D. and Linnane, A. W. (1966). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 25, 8. Collins, 0. R. (1981). Journal qfrhe Elisha Mitchell Scientific Socicvy 97, 101. Collins, 0. R. (1986). Bulletin ofthe British Mycological Society 20 (Suppl. I), 6. Collins, 0. R. and Gong, T. (1985). Mycologia 77, 300. Crawley, W. E., Campbell, A. G. and Smith, J. D. (1962). Nature 193, 295. Crepeau, R. H. and Frdm, E. K. (1981). Ultramicroscopy 6, 7. Crow, J. F. and Kimura, M. (1971). In “Readings in Population Biology”(P. S. Dawson and C. E. King, eds), pp. 439450. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Cuellar, 0.(1987).In “Meiosis”(P. B. Moens, ed.), pp. 43-104, Academic Press, Orlando, Florida. Cutter, V. M. (1942). Bulletin of the Torrey Botanical Club 69, 592. Dawes, 1. W. (1975). Nature 255, 707. Dawes, 1. W. and Calvert, G. R. (1984). Journal of General Microbiology 130, 605. Dawes, I . W. and Hardie, I. D. (1974). Molecular and General Genetics 131, 281. Deacon, J. W. ( 1 980). “Introduction to Modern Mycology”. Blackwell Scientific, Oxford. Doll, R. (1973). Biologische Rundschau 11, 362. Drebes, G. (1977).In“The Biology of Diatoms”(D. Werner, ed.), pp. 25Ck283. Blackwell, London. Emerson, R. (1950). Annual Review of Microbiology 4, 169. Ephrussi. B. and Hottinguer, H. (1951).Coldspring Harbor Symposium in Quantitarive Biology 16, 75. Esen, A,. Soost, R. K. and Geraci, G. (1979). Journal of Heredity 70, 5. Esposito. M . S. and Esposito, R. E. (1979). Biologie Cellulaire 33, 93. Esposito, M. S., Esposito, R. E. and Moens, P. B. (1974). Molecular and General Genetics 135,91. Esposito, R. E. and Klapholz, S. (1981). In“Molecular Biology of the Yeast Saccharomyces, Life Cycle and Inheritance” (J. N. Strdthern, E. W. Jones and J. R. Broach, eds), pp. 21 1-287. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York. Esser, K., Saleh, F. and Meinhardt, F. (1979). Currenr Generics I, 85. Ettl, H., Muller, D. G.. Neumann, K., Stosch, H. A. V. and Weber, W. (1967). Handbuch der Pjlanzenphysiologie 18, 597. Evans, 1. H. (1983). In “Yeast Genetics, Fundamental and Applied Aspects” (J. F. T. Spencer, D. M. Spencer and A. R. W. Smith, eds), pp. 269-370. Springer-Verlag, New York. Fekete, B. (1987). Medical Hypotheses 23, 109. Foyn, B. (1962). Nature 193, 300. Fowell, R. R. (1951). Journal ofthe Institute of Brewing 57, 180. Fowell, R. R. (1967). Journal of Applied Bacteriology 30, 450. Fowell, R. R. and Moorse, M. E. (1960). Journal of Applied Bacteriology 23, 53. Fuji, T. (1954). Nature 174, 1108. Fujii. T. (1955). Journal qfrhe Faculty ofScience, University of Tokyo, Secrion IV 7, 313. Gaither, T. and Collins, 0. R. (1984). Mycologia 76, 1123. Gascon, S., Neumann, N. P. and Lampen, J. 0.(1968).Journal of Biological Chemistry 243, 1573. Gaumann, E. A. (1 926). “Vergleichende Morphologie der Pike”. Verlag Fischer, Jena. Gaumann, E. A. (1928). “Comparative Morphology of Fungi”. McGraw Hill, New York. Gaumann, E. A. (1940). Zeir.schrif.fir Botanik 35, 433. Gerritsen, J. (1980). American Naturalist 115, 71 8. Gorts, C. P. M. (1975). Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 41,265. Grewal, N. S. and Miller, J. J. (1972). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 18, 1897. Guilliermond, M. A. (1903). Revue Gindrale de Botanique IS, 49.
50
CARL A. BILINSKI. NELSON MAKMlKOLl A N D JOHN 1. MILLER
Guilliermond, M. A. (1909). Revue Gberale de Eotanique 21, 353. Gustafsson, A. (1946). Lunds Universilets Arskrrkrift 42, 2. Haber, J. E. and Halvorson. H. 0. (1972). Journal of Bacteriology 109, 1027. Hanna, W. H. (1980). “Proceedings of 37th Southern Pasture and Forage Crop Improvement Conference, New Orleans”, pp. 75-80. Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture. Hartig, A., and Breitenbach, M. (1980). Current Genetics 1, 97. Hebert, P. D. N. (1987). Hydrohiologia 145, 183. Henninger, W. (1973). “3 Symposium Technische Mikrobiologie, Berlin” (H. Dellweg, ed.), pp. 469474. Verlag Institut fur Garungsgewerbe und Biotechnologie, Berlin. F.R.G. Henninger, W. and Emeis, C. C. (1974). Archives of Microbiology 101, 365. Herskowitz, 1. and Oshima, Y. (1981). I n “Molecular Biology of the Yeast Snccharomyces, Life Cycle and Inheritance” (J. N. Strathern, E. W. Jones and J. R. Broach, eds), pp. 181-209. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York. Hirschberg, J. and Simchen, G. (1977). Experimental Cell Research 105, 245. Holliday, R. (1961). Genetical Research 2, 231. Johnston, G. C. and Singer, R. A. (1980). In “Current Developments in Yeast Research” (G. G . Stewart and 1. Russell, eds), pp. 555-560, Pergamon Press, Toronto. Kelly, M. S. and Gay. J. L. (1969). Archiv,fur Mikrobiulogie 66, 1. Klapholz, S. and Esposito, R. E. (1980a). Genetics 96, 567. Klapholz, S. and Esposito, R. E. (1980b). Genetics 96, 589. Kuenzi, M. T., Tingle, M. A. and Halvorson, H. 0. (1974). Journal of Bacteriology 117, 80. Kuhlenkamp, R. and Miiller, D. G . (1986). British Phycological Journal 20, 301. Kurtz, S. and Lindquist, S. (1984). Proceedings ofthe National Academy ofsciences of the United States of America 81, 7323.
Kurtz, S. and Lindquist, S. (1986). Cell 45, 771. Kurtz. S.. Rossi, J. H., Petko, L. and Lindquist, S. (1986). Science 231, 1154. Kvist, U. (1980). Actu Physiologica Scandinavica 109, 79. Leupold, U. (1956). Journal qf Genetics 54, 41 1. Linder, D., Kaiser-McCaw, B. and Hecht, F. (1975). New England Journnl q / Medicine 292, 63.
Lloyd, D. G. (1980). Eoolutionary Eiology 13, 69. Lokki. J. and Saura, A. (1980). In “Polyploidy: Biological Relevance” (W. H. Lewis, ed.), pp. 277-312. Basic Life Sciences. Vol. 13. Plenum Press, New York and London. Magee, P. T. and Hopper, A. K. (1974). Journal sf Bacteriology 119, 952. Mainwaring, H. R. and Wilson, 1. M. (1968). Transactions of the Brifish Mycological Society 51, 663.
Malone, R. E. and Esposito, R. E. (1981). Molecular and Cellular Biology 1, 891. Maniotis, J. (1980). In “Polyploidy: Biological Relevance” (W. H. Lewis, ed.), pp. 163-192. Basic Life Sciences, vol. 13. Plenum Press, New York and London. Manning, J. T. (1981). Journal of Theoretical Biology 93, 491. Manuel, J. (1973). Comptes Rendus de I’Academie des Sciences 204. 1955. Marmiroli, N. and Bilinski, C. A. (1985). Yeast 1, 39. Marmiroli, N. and Lodi, T. (1984a). Current Genetics 8, 429. Marmiroli, N. and Lodi, T. (1984b). Molecular and General Genetics 188, 69. Marmiroli, N., Ferrari, C., Tedeschi, F., Puglisi, P. P. and Bruschi, C. (1981a). Biologie Cellulaire 41, 79.
Marmiroli, N., Ferri, M. and Puglisi, P. P. (1983). Journal of Bacteriology 154, 118. Marmiroli, N., Tassi. F., Bianchi, L., Algeri, A. A., Puglisi, P. P. and Esposito, M. S. (1981b). Current Genetics 4, 5 1.
Marmiroli, N., Tedeschi, F., Ferrari, C. and Puglisi, P. P. (1985) Microbiologica 8, 233. Marshall, D. R. and Brown, A. H. D. (1981). Heredity 47, 1. Maynard Smith, J. (1978). “Evolution of Sex”. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Miller, J. A. (1987). Bioscience 37, 389. Miller, J. J. (1963). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 9, 259. Miller, J. J. (1964). Experimental Cell Research 33, 46.
APOMlXlS IN EUKARYOTIC MICRO-ORGANISMS
51
Miller, J. J. (1981). In “Current Developments in Yeast Research: Proceedings Fifth International Yeast Symposium” (G. G. Stewart and I. Russell, eds), pp. 239-244. Pergamon Press, Toronto. Miller, J. J. (1989). In “The Yeasts” (A. H. Rose and J. S. Harrison, eds), 2nd edn, vol. 3, pp. 489-550. Academic Press, London. Miller, J. J. and Halpern, C. (1956). Canadian Journal qf Microbiology 2, 519. Mittwoch, U.(1978). Journal qf Medical Genetics 15, 165. Moens, P. B. (1971). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 17, 507. Moens, P. B. (1974). Journal of Cell Science 16, 519. Moens, P. B. (1982). Canadian Journal of Genetics and Cytology 24, 243. Moens. P. B. (1987). “Meiosis”. Academic Press, Orlando, Florida. Moens, P. B., Mowat, M., Esposito, M. S . and Esposito, R. E. (1977). Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 277, 351. Moens, P. B. and Rapport, E. (1971). Journal of Cell Biology 50, 344. Mogie, M. (1986). Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 28, 321. Nakaseko, Y., Niwa, 0. and Yanagida, M. (1984). Journal of Bacteriology 157, 334. Nel, P. M. (1975). Genetics 79, 435. Newell, S. Y. and Fell, J. w. (1970). Mycologia 62, 272. Nogler, G. A. (1984). In “Embryology of Angiosperms’’ (B. M. Johri, ed.), pp. 475-518. SpringerVerlag, Berlin and New York. Okamoto, S . and Iino, T. (1981). Genetics 99, 197. Palmer, R. G. (1971). Chromosoma (Berlin) 35, 233. Panek, A. C., Bernardes, E. and Panek, A. D. (1985). Yeast Newsletter 34, 57. Parrington, J. M., West, L. F. and Povey, S . (1984). Journal of Medical Genetics 21, 4. Pennak. R. W. (1978). “Fresh-water Invertebrates of the United States”. John Wiley, New York. Perlman, P. S. and Mahler, H. R. (1974). Archives of Biochemisrry and Biophysics 162, 249. Petersen, J. G. L., Kielland-Brandt, M. C. and Nilsson-Tillgren, T. (1979). Carlsberg Research Communications 44, 149. Phaff, H. J. (1986). Microbial Ecology 12, 31. Phaff, H. J. and Starmer. W. T. (1987). In “The Yeasts” (A. H. Rose and J. S . Harrison, eds), 2nd edn, vol. 1, pp. 123-180. Academic Press, London. Polakis, E. S. and Bartley, W. (1965). Biochemical Journal 97, 284. Pontefract, R. D. and Miller, J. J. (1962). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 8, 573. Pratje. E., Schultz, R., Schnierer, S . and Michaelis, G. (1979). Molecular and General Genetics 176, 41 1.
Prillinger, H. (1982). Zeitschrifi fur Mykologie 48, 275. Puglisi, P. P. and Zennaro, E. (1971). E-vperienlia 27, 963. Raikov, 1. B. (1972). In “Research in Protozoology” (T. C. Chen, ed.), vol. 4, pp. 148-289. Pergamon Press, Oxford. Renaud, J. (1937). Comptes Rendus de la SocietP de Biologie 125, 622. Rogers, J. D. (1973). Eiiolution 27, 153. Roman, H. and Sands, S . M. (1953). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences ofthe United States of America 39, 17 1. Roth, R. and Fogel, S . (1971). Molecular and General Genetics 112, 295. Rothstein, R. J. (1983). In “Methods in Enzymology”(R. Wu, L. Grossman and K. Moldave, eds), vol. 101, part C. Academic Press, New York. Sando, N. and Saito, T. (1970). Journal of General and Applied Microbiology 16, 347. Sando, N., Maeda, M., Endo, T.,Oka, R. and Hayashibe, M. (1973). Journalof Generaland Applied Microbiology 19. 359. Satina, S. and Blakeslee, A. F. (1935). Botanical Gazette 96, 521. Schild, D. and Byers, B. (1980). Generics 96, 859. Shilo, V., Simchen, G. and Shilo, B. (1978). Experimental Cell Research 112, 241. Sora, S . and Bianchi, M. (1982). Molecular and Cellular Biology 2, 1299. Sora, S., Crippa, M. and Lucchini, G. (1983). Mutation Research 107, 249. Sora. S., Rossi, C. and Cdrbone, M. L. A. (1984). Mutation Research 141, 161. Spiegelman, S . and Reiner, J. M. (1947). Journal of General Physiology 31, 175. Srivastava, P. K., Harashima, S. and Oshima, Y. (1983). Molecular and General Genetics 191,165.
52
CARL A. RILINSKI, NELSON MARMlROLl A N D IOHN J. MILLER
Starmer, W. T., Ganter, P. F.. Aberdeen, V., Lachance, M.-A. and Phaff, H. J. (1987). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 33, 783. Stebbins, G . L. (1950). “Variation and Evolution in Plants”. Columbia University Press, New York and London. Stebbins, G. L. (1971). “Chromosomal Evolution in Higher Plants”. Edward Arnold, London. Stebbins, G. L. (1980). I n “Polyploidy: Biological Relevance” (W. H. Lewis, ed.), pp.495-520. Basic Life Sciences, vol. 13. Plenum Press, New York and London. Stewart, G. G. (1981). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 27, 973. Strunnikov, V. A. (1978). Soviet Journal of Developmental Biology (English translation) 9, I. Subcommittee on Zinc (1979). Zinc in metalloproteins. I n “Zinc”, chapt. 8, pp. 211-223. Committee on Medical and Biologic Effects of Environmental Pollutants, Division of Medical Sciences, National Research Council. University Park Press, Baltimore. Suomalainen, E. (1950). Advances in Genelics 3, 193. Suomalainen, E., Saura, A. and Lokki, J. (1976). Evolutionary Biology 9, 209. Suomalainen, E., Saura, A. and Lokki, J. (1987). “Cytology and Evolution in Parthenogenesis”, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Tremaine, J. H. and Miller, J. J. (1954). Botanical Gazette 115, 31 I . Trew, B. J., Friesen, J. 0. and Moens, P. B. (1979). Journal of Bacteriology 138, 60. TzagololT, A. (1969). Journal of Biological Chemistry 244, 5027. Unger, M. W. and Hartwell, L. H. (1976). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the Uniled States of America 73, 1664. Uyenoyama, M. K. (1987). I n “Meiosis” (P. B. Moens, ed.). pp. 21-41. Academic Press, Orlando. Van Wijk, R., Oewehand, J., van den Bus, T. and Koningsberger, V. V. (1969). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 186. 178. Vespdainen, K. and Jarvinen, 0. (1979). American Zoologist 19, 739. Vezinhet. F., Kinnaird, J. H. and Dawes, 1. W. (1979). Journal of General Microbiology 1 IS, 391. Wagstaff, J. E., Klapholz, S. and Esposito, R. E. (1982). Proceedings qf the National Academy qf Sciences of the United States of America 79, 2986. Wang, H. T., Frackman, S., Kowalisyn, J., Esposito, R. E. and Elder, R. (1987). Molecular and Cellular Biology 1, 1425. Weir-Thompson, E. M. and Dawes, I. W. (1984). Molecular and Cellular Biology 4, 695. White, M. J. D. (1973).“Animal Cytology and Evolution”, 3rd edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Williams, G. C. ( I 975). “Sex and Evolution”. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Winkler, H. (1906). Annales du Jardin Botanique de Buitenzorg 2 serie 5, 208. Winkler, H. (1908). Progressus Rei Botanicae 2, 293. Winkler, H. (1942). Planta (Berlin) 33, 1. Wright, J. F. and Dawes, I. W. (1979). FEBS Letters 104, 183. Wright, J. F., Ajam, N. and Dawes, I. W. (1981). Molecular and Cellular Biology 1, 910. Yanagita, T., Yagishawa, M., Oishi, S., Sando, N. and Suto, T. (1970). Journal of General and Applied Microbiology 16, 347. Young, T. W. (1987). In “The Yeasts” (A. H. Rose and J. S. Harrison, eds.), 2nd edn, vol. 2, pp. 131-164. Academic Press, London.
Current Trends in Candida albicans Research ASIS DATTA, K. GANESAN and K. NATARAJAN Molecular Biology Laboratory, School of Life Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi I10 067, India
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . 11. Genetics . . . . . . . . . A. Ploidy. . . . . . . . . B. Parasexual analysis . . . . . C. Molecular genetics . . . . . 111. Morphogenesis . . . . . . . , A. Yeast-to-hypha conversion . . . B. Switching of colony morphology . . IV. Pathogenesis . . . . . . . , A. What makes Candida albicans infectious? B. Cure for candidiasis . . . . . V. Problems in research on Candida albicans . VI. Summary . , . . . . . . . VII. Acknowledgements . . . , . . . References . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . ,
. .
. . . ,
. . . .
. .
. . .
.
. .
. . . . ,
.
. . . . .
.
. . . . . . ,
. .
. . . .
. . . . .
.
.
. . . . . .
. . . . . ,
. . . . . . . . .
. .
. .
,
,
.
.
.
.
.
. . . ,
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
53 54 54 56 57 58 59 65 67 68 77 79 82 84 84
I. Introduction
Candida albicans has aroused considerable interest because it is a human pathogen and it can also exist in different cellular morphologies. The objectives envisaged in C. albicans research are: (1) to understand the basis of pathogenicity and work out a specific therapy and (2) to study cellular differentiation. These aspects constitute the main subject of this review. Publications on C. albicans have proliferated rapidly in the last few years. There are review articles covering C. albicans morphogenesis (Odds, 1985; Shepherd et al., 1985; Soll, 1986), genetics (Shepherd et al., 1985), antigenic variation (Poulain et al., 1985), pathogenicity (Bodey and Fainstein, 1985; Shepherd et al., 1985; Dei-Cas and Vernes, 1986) and also host-defense mechanism (Waldorf, 1986). There are some exciting developments in C. albicans research. Some of them concern high-frequency switching of colony ADVANCES IN MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY, VOL 30 ISBN 0-12-027730-1
Copyright &' 1989. by Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction in dny form reserved
54
ASlS DATTA,
K.G A M S A N AND K.NATARAJAN
morphology, surface antigens and genetic transformation systems. However, there are obvious difficulties in studying C. afbicans. As it is naturally diploid and a sexual cycle is absent, genetic analysis by conventional techniques cannot be applied. The other problem, which has not been seriously considered so far, is the inherent strain differences. We have highlighted this as one of the problems facing C. albicans research. 11. Genetics
Genetic analysis of C. afbicans has been hampered due to its diploid nature and the lack of a sexual cycle. However, some progress has been made in isolation of mutants, in hybridization and in recombination analysis. These studies were recently reviewed by Shepherd et af. (1985). Our emphasis i s on advances made in the last two years with particular reference to the molecular genetics of this organism. A. PLOIDY
Most clinical isolates of C. afbicans are diploid; few isolates appear to be haploid or tetraploid. The content of DNA and genomic complexity of many isolates indicate that they are diploid. While chemical estimations of DNA content gave a value of 37 fg per cell, kinetic complexity measurements gave half this value per haploid genome (Riggsby et al., 1982). Besides, survival rates of many strains exposed to mutagens were similar to those of Saccharonayces cereuisiae diploids rather than haploids (Olaiya et af.,1980;Suzuki et a/., 1982). Another evidence comes from the biased set of auxotrophs yielded by C. albicans strains. These strains on mild mutagenesis yielded either no auxotrophs or a limited set of auxotrophs at high frequencies (Whelan et al., 1980; Whelan and Magee, 1981; Poulter et al., 1982). The auxotrophs were often found as part of sectored colonies, the prototrophic sector being refractory to further mutagenesis. These results were explained as follows. The strains are diploid and are heterozygous for a limited number of recessive auxotrophic alleles; on mutagenesis, wild-type and mutant alleles segregate by mitotic recombination, giving rise to auxotrophs and stable prototrophs (Fig. 1). Additional evidence for diploidy comes from revertants of these auxotrophs, whose mutation spectra were similar to those of their respective prototrophic parent strains. Furthermore, protoplast fusion (see Section 1I.B) and gene-disruption experiments (see Section 1I.C)confirm the diploid nature of C. albicans. However, not all strains of C. albicans are diploid. Suzuki et al. (1982) found a few haploid and tetraploid strains in their extensive search among clinical isolates. They analysed the isolates for nuclear DNA content, and for
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
55
d Homozygous 3
MET
prototrophic segregan t Mitotic recombination in h e teroz yg ous prototrophic p a r e n t
- - : - <
-
met
Horno zy g o us auxo t rop h ic segregant
FIG. 1. Mitotic recombinationcan explain the biased auxotrophic spectra of Candida albicans. The example shown is of strain FC18 (Whelan ef al., 1980), which segregates methionine auxotrophs at high frequency.
sensitivity to ultraviolet irradiation. Ploidy was decided by using Sacch. cereuisiae strains of different ploidy as standards. Fifteen of the isolates were diploid, three were haploid and one was tetraploid. The haploids were atypical since they did not form germ tubes. Olaiya et af.(1980) also reported variant haploid strains which were germ-tube negative. However, to confirm that these strains are true haploids, it has to be shown that their auxotrophic spectra are unbiased, and revertants of auxotrophs obtained from them do not behave as heterozygotes. Ploidy shift, from diploid to tetraploid and from tetraploid to diploid, was reported in a particular strain of C. albicans (Suzuki et al., 1986a). A shiftdown in ploidy was seen in tetraploid cells when nuclear division and cell division proceeded without a significant increase in the content of DNA per cell. This phenomenon is apparently similar to meiosis I1 in Sacch. cereuisiae, but differs in that it produces diploid daughter nuclei. A ploidy shift from diploid to tetraploid was found when the cells underwent rapid nuclear DNA synthesis without much increase in cell number. Increase in ploidy was probably due to chromosome duplication in the absence of nuclear division (Suzuki et al., 1986a). In conclusion, it can be stated that most of the natural isolates of C. albicans are diploid; however, some strains are haploid though atypical. An extensive search among clinical isolates may yield a haploid strain which would resemble a typical C. albicans strain in its physiology, morphogenesis and pathogenesis. From such a strain, it should be possible to isolate any desired mutant defective in morphogenesis or pathogenesis without depending on the chance occurrence of natural heterozygotes.
56
ASlS DATTA. K. GANBSAN AND K. NATARAJAN
B. PARASEXUAL ANALYSIS
No natural sexual cycle has been reported in C. albicans so far. However, Suzuki ef al. (1986b) have shown hybridization, at low frequency, between C. ufbicansstrains and between C. albicuns and C. guilfiermondii;mild ultraviolet irradiation of C. alhicuns was needed to induce hybridization. The DNA content of the hybrids varied from near diploid to triploid levels. The hybrids have apparently resulted from partial transfer of genetic material between the nuclei of heterokaryons rather than from true karyogamy. Extensive work has been done on hybrids that were obtained by fusion of protoplasts. Sarachek ef al. (1 981) and Sarachek and Weber (1984) studied the nature of these hybrids in detail. The products of protoplast fusion are heterokaryons which assort their nuclei into monokaryotic blastospores. Most of these monokaryons have parental-type nuclei, but some have hybrid nuclei with their DNA content between one and two times that of parental strains. Hybrid nuclei arise by transfer of a portion of the genetic material between nuclei of the heterokaryon. The amount of genetic material transferred increases with increasing growth temperatures in the range 2 5 4 I "C.It is not clear whether whole chromosomes are transferred between nuclei. Sarachek and Weber (1986) have shown that the nuclei of heterokaryons often undergo heritable recessive lethal or growth-debilitating genetic damage. These were ascribed to nullisomics, functionally severe aneuploids or deletions of parts of chromosomes, perhaps sustained during internuclear genetic exchanges. Hybrids of C. albicans are unstable. Even tetraploids, apparently obtained through true karyogamy, lose their chromosomes. Cells which are heterozygous for 5-fluorocytosine resistance are only partially resistant to the drug, compared to homozygous resistant cells which are highly resistant. Selection for increased resistance in heterozygous tetraploid hybrids resulted in highly resistant variants which were of lower ploidy. In terms of DNA content, they were aneuploid, triploid or diploid (Whelan et al., 1985). Chromosome loss also can be induced in C. albicans(Hi1ton et a/., 1985). Heat shock leads to a decrease in DNA content of tetraploids and aneuploids to near diploid levels. Such a shock induces mitotic instability in diploid strains as well. However, no change in DNA content is observed; the mechanism for this is not clear. Frequencies of mitotic recombinants, induced in partial hybrids by ultraviolet irradiation, also indicate that most strains of C. albicans are diploid (Sarachek and Weber, 1984). If parent strains are haploid, all partial hybrids prototrophic for a particular requirement must be uniformly heterozygous ( + -) for the wild type (+) and mutant ( - ) alleles. These hybrids should segregate auxotrophic recombinants at similar frequencies. However, if the
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
57
parent strains are diploid, partial genetic exchanges in heterokaryons, between a nucleus with auxotrophic alleles ( - -) and one carrying the corresponding wild-type alleles ( + +), would give three kinds of heterozygotes, namely - - +, - + + and - - + +. Ultraviolet irradiation should induce auxotrophic recombinations readily in - - strains, but not at all in ones and at a very low frequency in - strains. Segregation data for partial hybrids clearly show that parent strains are diploid (Sarachek and Weber, 1984). In spite of these limitations, protoplast fusion was successfully used for complementation and recombination analysis. Linkage relationships were deduced mainly from mitotic instability of diploid, aneuploid or tetraploid heterozygotes. Ultraviolet radiation-induced mitotic crossing over was used to map the genes with respect to centromeres. Chromosome loss, spontaneous or induced, has provided information about whole linkage groups. Five linkage groups have been demonstrated so far (Sarachek et al., 1981 ;Poulter et al., 1982; Whelan and Soll, 1982; Kakar et al., 1983; Poulter and Hanrahan, 1983; Poulter and Rikkerink, 1983; Hilton et al., 1985; Shepherd et al., 1985). Electrophoretic karyotype analyses of many C. alhicans strains have been performed. The number of chromosomes reported range from five to 10, depending on the technique employed (Snell and Wilkins, 1986; Lott et af., 1987; Magee and Magee, 1987; Snell et al., 1987). The differences could be due to electrophoretic artefacts; high electric-field strengths and non-uniform electric fields used in typical pulsed-field gradient gel-electrophoretic techniques often lead to DNA disappearance, especially when molecules approach or exceed the sizes of the largest chromosomes of Sacch. cerevisiae (Smith et al., 1987). Such artefacts might also occur with field inversion gelelectrophoresis. Another problem special to C. albicans stems from its ploidy; homologous chromosomes (if they are different in size) might be resolved during electrophoresis and thus can be mistaken for heterologous chromosomes. Southern blotting with cloned gene probes, in conjunction with pulsed field gel-electrophoretic techniques which can resolve DNA molecules with millions of base pairs (Smith et al., 1987), would give a firm answer about chromosome number in C. alhicans.
+ ++
++
C. MOLECULAR GENETICS
Since classical genetics of C. alhicans is tedious and depends on the chance occurrence of heterozygotes to isolate any desired mutant, reverse genetic techniques are all the more imperative. The general approach used so far to clone C. albicans genes is through complementation of Sacch. cerevisiae mutants with plasrnids from C. albicans genomic libraries; URA3 (Gillum ef
58
ASlS DATTA, K GANESAN A N D K. NATARAJAN
al., 1984), HIS3, T R P l (Rosenbluh et al., 1985)and ADEZ (Kurtz et al., 1986) genes were cloned in this manner. Using the ADE2 gene, Kurtz et al. (1986) transformed C. albicans, albeit at low frequency. Their analysis of a limited number of transformants showed that transformation had occurred through homologous recombination at the ADE2 region, of either of the two chromosomal homologues. Through integrative transformation, Kelly et al. (1987) disrupted the URA3 gene of C. albicuns. The ADEZ gene was used as a selectable marker for transformation. The cloned C . albicans URA3 gene was disrupted with the ADEZ gene and the linearized DNA was used for transformation. Both insertional inactivation and a deletion which removes part of the URA3 gene could be engineered into the C. albicans genome. EcoRI restriction sites were different at the (IRA3 regions of the two chromosomal homologues, with which it was shown that either of the homologues could be disrupted. Transformants of one strain (A81-Pu)which were heterozygous for the ura3 mutation were rendered homozygous by ultraviolet irradiation. However, this could not be done with transformants of another strain (SGY 129),which apparently has more than two copies of the URA3 gene. Thus, directed mutagenesis appears possible as long as the gene to be disrupted is not present at more than one locus. Kurtz et ul. (1987) isolated an autonomously replicating sequence (ARS) from C. albiruns, which allows plasmids to be maintained extrachromosomally in this yeast. Such plasmids transform at high frequency and facilitate cloning of nuclear genes through mutant complementation. These plasmids are generally present in high copy number, and thus can be used to study the effect of gene dosage on gene expression. Plasmids with C. albicuns ARS form head-to-tail tandem repeats, which are either present as unstable free plasmids or are integrated stably into the chromosome (Kurtz et ul., 1987). The sequence responsible for ARS phenotype is 350 base pairs in size, and is present as a single copy in each haploid genome. Perhaps this small fragment does not have sufficient sequence information to function like ARSs of Succh. cereuisiue. Additional sequences, or a much larger fragment from the C. alhicans genome, might make these autonomously replicating plasmids more useful. 111. Morphogenesis
Cundidu alhicuns is a polymorphic fungus. It displays four different cellular and a variety of colony morphologies. It grows as blastospores, pseudohyphae or hyphae; it can also form chlamydospores. Blastospores are round or oval cells, 2-5 pm in diameter, with multipolar budding. Pseudohyphae consist of elongated yeast cells attached to each other; junctions between pseudohyphal cells are constricted. True hyphal cells are longer than blastoconidia and have
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS
RESEARCH
59
perforated septa; cell junctions are not constricted. Chlamydospores are thickwalled asexual spores formed by the rounding up of pre-existing cells (Torosantucci and Cassone, 1983; Odds, 1985). All of these forms can be induced in vitro, under defined growth conditions. A. YEAST-TO-HYPHA CONVERSION
Yeast-to-hypha conversion occurs through an intermediate germ-tube stage. An enormous amount of work has been carried out over the years on this aspect. For recent reviews see Odds (1985), Shepherd et af. (1985) and Sol1 (1 986).
I . Inducers Yeast-to-hypha transition in C. alhicans is controlled by environmental conditions. By varying different parameters such as the carbon source, pH value, ions and temperature, hyphae formation can be induced. It appears that the metabolic state of the cell is an important factor in the ability of C. alhicans to respond to conditions that favour germ-tube formation. It has been demonstrated that actively growing cultures need to be starved before they can produce germ tubes (Shepherd e / al., 1980a). Such starved cells can produce germ tubes regardless of their position in the cell cycle. A number of factors are known to regulate the dimorphic transition of C. alhicans, the most important being growth medium and temperature. Germ tubes are induced when blastospores are incubated at a temperature between 33 and 42'C in a medium containing amino acids such as proline, glutamine and arginine (Odds, 1979), aminosugars such as N-acetylglucosamine and N acetylmannosamine (Simonetti et af., 1974; Sullivan and Shepherd, 1982; Natarajan e / af., 1984) or ethanol (Pollack and Hashimoto, 1985). Furthermore, N-acetylhexose derivatives, such as chitin, mucin, hyaluronic acid and immobilized N-acetylglucosamine (Shepherd and Sullivan, 1983),are all capable of inducing germ tubes. Since these derivatives are not metabolized or transported into cells, it is believed that the inducer binds to a cell-surface receptor and produces an intracellular signal, which primes the cells for germtube formation. Germ-tube formation is induced at 37°C. Above 33°C mycelia are formed while below that temperature pseudomycelia are produced (Cassone et al., 1985). Divalent cations are necessary for germ-tube formation. It has been shown that magnesium ions are required for germination (Walker et af., 1984). The involvement of calcium ions in this process has also been reported (see Section ITI.A.3.a). A pH value in the range 6-8 iscritical for germ-tube formation (Odds, 1979). Under certain conditions, pH value can serve as a sole determinant of cell
60
ASlS DATTA, K. GANESAN AND K. NATARAJAN
morphology. When yeast cells, which have entered the stationary phase of growth due to zinc depletion, are released into fresh medium at 37°C they synchronously form buds at pH 4.5, and form germ tubes at pH 6.7 (Buff0 el al., 1984).The advantage with this method is that the conditions for inducing the alternate phenotypes are very similar, facilitating meaningful analysis of temporal and spatial differences between the phenotypes (Soll, 1986). However, Pollack and Hashimoto (1987) reported that germ tubes are produced at a pH value as low as 3.0, in a medium lacking glucose, suggesting that glucose, at low pH values, suppresses germ-tube formation. However, the mechanism of inhibition is not clear. 2. Morphogenesis-Associated Changes Extensive work has been done on changes associated with yeast-to-hypha conversion in C. alhicans. For comprehensive reviews see Odds (1989, Shepherd er al. (1985) and Soll (1986). Here we concentrate on those aspects which are promising in elucidating the mechanism of morphogenesis. Under pH-regulated dimorphism, the budding and hyphae-forming populations differ in the time of commitment to respective morphologies, in the onset of septation, in the location of septum between the mother and daughter cells and in the shape and dynamics of growth of the daughter cell. Commitment to budding occurs at about the time of evagination, while commitment to hypha formation occurs 20-30 min after evagination (Mitchell and Soll, 1979a). Onset of septum formation is also delayed in hyphae compared with that of buds, and correlates closely with the time of commitment. The septum is positioned a t the junction of the mother cell and bud, but within the hypha about 2pm from the junction (Mitchell and Soll, 1979b). The most obvious difference between budding and hypha-forming cells is the shape of the daughter cell. Staebell and Sol1 (1985)explained this in terms of temporal and spatial differences in cell-wall expansion during bud and hypha formation. During bud growth, a very small, highly active apical zone accounts for about 70% of surface expansion. When the bud reaches about two-thirds of its final surface area, the apical zone shuts down, and subsequent growth is completed by a general expansion. During growth of hypha, at least 90% of expansion is due to a small, highly active, apical growth zone, and less than 10% is due to the general mechanism. The apical growth zone of hyphae never shuts down as long as growth continues in hyphal form. Anderson and Sol1 (1986) reported that actin localization is correlated with the growth zones of buds and hyphae of C. alhicans. In both budding and hypha-forming cells, just before evagination, actin granules are localized at the site of evagination. When the incipient bud or hypha appears, actin granules are seen within them. With continued bud growth, the actin granules are then
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDlDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
61
redistributed throughout the cytoplasmic cortex. In marked contrast, the majority of actin granules are seen clustered at the hyphal apex. Thus, actin localization seems to determine cell-wall expansion zones. However, it is not clear what in turn determines actin localization. An answer to this problem would perhaps advance our understanding of morphogenesis in C. albicans. During commitment to either the bud or hyphal form, no significant biochemical difference has been observed between budding and hyphaforming cells. Chitin content and chitin synthase activity were shown to be higher in hyphae compared with buds (Braun and Calderone, 1978; Chiew et al., 1980).However, with pH-regulated dimorphism, no difference was seen in the initial rate of chitin synthesis (Soll, 1986). Thus, it is unlikely that chitin synthase is involved in regulation of morphogenesis. Cyclic AMP (CAMP)is involved in signal transduction in many organisms. Cyclic AMP (Niimi et al., 1980; Singh et al., 1980b), CAMP-dependent protein kinases (B. Gupta Roy and A. Datta, unpublished observation) and CAMP-independent protein kinases (Gupta Roy and Datta, 1986)have been detected in C. albicans. With certain induction conditions, germ-tube formation was accompanied by a rise in intracellular concentration of CAMP (Niimi et al., 1980; Chattaway et al., 1981). But, with pH-regulated dimorphism, cAMP contents in budding and hypha-forming populations were not different (Soll, 1986).Thus, it is unlikely that cAMP is involved in signal transduction. Patterns of DNA methylation were studied in yeast and mycelial forms (Russell et al., 1987). The 5methylcytosine content was lower in the mycelial form compared with the yeast form. However, the significance of this observation is not clear. 3. Regulation
Morphogenesis in C. albicans is a phenomenon triggered by environmental conditions. Presumably, transduction of these external signals into the cell results in a differential gene expression, that would in turn result in differentiated phenotypes. Both Ca(rr)and calmodulin are likely to be involved in signal transduction. a. Ca(rItCalmodu1in and Protein Phosphorylation Calmodulin is a ubiquitous protein that plays a central role in many aspects of cellular regulation (Cheung, 1980). Calmodulin is present in C. albicans (Hubbard et al., 1982)and other fungi (Muthukumar et al., 1985,1987). In the dimorphic ascomycete Ceratocystis ulmi, the Ca(rrbalmodu1in interaction is important for commitment to morphological forms (Muthukumar and Nickerson, 1985) and also for mycelium production (Muthukumar and Nickerson, 1984). Chlorpromazine, a known calmodulin antagonist, blocks germ-tube formation by C. albicans (Wood and Nugent, 1985). The
62
ASlS DAT’IA. K. G A N E S A N A N D K. N A T A R A J A N
involvement of Ca(ir)-calmodulin and protein phosphorylation in C. alhirans germ-tube formation is being investigated in our laboratory. Germ-tube formation by this yeast is arrested by trifluoperazine (TFP), a calmodulin inhibitor (Gupta Roy and Datta, 1987). Experiments with the ionophore A23187 have indicated that intracellular Ca(rr) is also required for germ-tube formation. Incorporation of 32Pis higher in germ tube-forming cells; but TFP decreases 32P incorporation (Gupta Roy and Datta, 1987). SDS-PAGE analysis revealed germ tube- and bud-specific protein phosphorylation (V. D. Paranjape, B. Gupta Roy and A. Datta, unpublished observation). Characterization of these morphology-specific phosphoproteins and identification of the putative protein kinases might unravel the signal-transduction pathway involved in morphogenesis. b. Identification of Morphology-Related Gene Products In systems where differentiation is well studied, such as the decision of phage lambda to enter either the lytic or lysogenic mode of growth, and sporulation in Bacillus spp., master control genes regulate differentiation. These genes cause differential expression of other genes, resulting in differentiation. Differential gene expression involves synthesis, disappearance or changes in the contents of certain polypeptides. There are two inherent problems in identifying polypeptides which are differentially expressed in buds or hyphae. The first problem is caused by limitations in the techniques employed. Regulatory polypeptides would be present only in minute amounts and thus might go undetected. The second problem arises from the different culture conditions used to form buds and hyphae. These conditions alone might cause differential expression of certain polypeptides unrelated to morphogenesis. Manning and Mitchell ( 1980b)and Finney et al. (1985) circumvented this problem with strains which were defective in hypha formation. Finney ct al. (1985)identified two polypeptides, one exclusively expressed in buds and the other in hyphae. If they are truly morphology specific, they should be consistently seen under any condition used to grow buds or hyphae. However, Manning and Mitchell (1980b)could not identify any polypeptide specific for either of the morphologies, under their induction conditions. Some proteins are specificallyexpressed on the cell surface of hyphae (Table 1; Anderson and Soll, 1987; Ponton and Jones, 1986; Smail and Jones, 1984; Sundstrom and Kenny, t984). Antibodies against these proteins were used in immunofluorescence experiments. These antibodies did not stain the mother cells, but intensely stained germ tubes and hyphae. Blastospores budding from these hyphae were not stained, confirming the hypha-specific expression of these proteins. If genes coding for these proteins are cloned, their control of expression can be studied. From such studies, it would be possible to know
63
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
TABLE 1. Cell surface antigens of Cundidu ulbicans
Molecular weight Location
(M, x
Chemical nature
Serum levels during disease
Hyphaspecific
Glycoprotein (mannoproteins) Glycoprotein
N.D."
Yes
N.D.
Yes
Cell surface 200-235
GIycoprotein
N.D.
Yes
Cell surface N.D.
Carbohydrate
N.D.
Yes
Cytoplasm
48
Protein
Present
N.D.
Secreted
N.D.
Present
N.D.
Secreted
47
Carbohydrate (probably mannans) Carbohydrate
Present
N.D.
N.D. N.D.
Present
N.D. Nob
Cell surface 200 Cytoplasm
19
Secreted 47 Cell surface 13.5
N.D.
Reference Sundstrom and Kenny (1984, 1985) Ponton and Jones (1986) Ponton and Jones ( 1986) Brawner and Cutler ( 1 986a. b) Strockbine el a/. ( 1984a,b) Hopwood et a/. (1986)
Matthews et a/. (1987) Neale el al. (1987) Anderson and Sol1 ( 1987)
N.D., not determined. The 13,500 D a cell-surface antigen is unique to budding, non-germinating opaque cells.
more about, and finally to identify, the master control gene which determines differentiation. 4. Morphological Variants
Another approach in investigating morphogenesis is to study mutants defective in hypha formation. By pin-pointing defects at the biochemical and genetic levels, we might learn more about regulation of morphogenesis. There are several reports of strains that exhibit a variant morphology. They have been isolated from natural populations (Table 2) (Shimokawa and Nakayama, 1984, 1986; Cannon, 1986; Howard et al., 1986), by nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis (Hubbard er af.,1986) or by mild ultraviolet irradiation (Pomes er al., 1985). Use of an induced mutant is suspect, because there is likelihood of simultaneous mutations at unlinked loci. Shimokawa and Nakayama (1986) isolated a variant, obtained by plating normal wild-type cells; this natural variant (a spontaneous mutant) exhibited a rough-colony phenotype but the cellular morphology was yeast-form.
64
A S S DATTA.
K.GANESAN A N D K. NATARAJAN
TABLE 2. Morphological variants of Candida a/bicuns“ Cellular morphology Strain
25°C
37°C
Pathogenicity
2252’ B311V6
Y
H
Y
N.D.d Non-pathogenic
hOG301
H
H
Y Y
(a) Pathogenic (b) Non-pathogenic N.D. N.D.
Y
(a) Non-pathogenic
Y
(b) Pathogenic Pathogenic
Y‘
N.D. MM2002 Y 300-SG (3153A-SG) Y CA2 A12
Y
Reference Manning and Mitchell f1980a) Buckley el a/. (1982); Sobel et a/.(1 984) Shepherd (1 985) Hubbard et a/. (1986) Cannon (1986) Howard e/ a/. (1986) Mattia et a/. (1982); Bistoni et u/. (1986) Shepherd (1985) Torosantucci and Cassone (1983)
Strain hOG301 is an induced mutant, while the other strains are spontaneous mutants. All strains except hOG301 have been typed as authentic C. dbicans. Candidu u/hican.r 2252 produced germ tubes at 37°C in human serum. ‘ Y indicates the yeast form and H the hyphal form. N.D., not determined.
Interestingly, the rough-colony phenotype was conditional; it appeared rough only when grown on Sabouraud glucose agar. This variant was typed as C. afbicans,and displayed cell aggregation and adhesion to glass surfaces. It had about one-fourth of the amount of mannan compared with its parent. Furthermore, its surface hydrophobicity was also high. Cannon (1986) has reported a mutant that is impaired in mycelium production. By several criteria, this mutant was shown to be derived from the parental strain of C. alhicans. N o studies have been undertaken using this mutant to understand morphogenesis. Howard et al. (1986) reported a variant C. alhicans that occurred at a frequency of 0.1 % among natural populations; the reversion frequency was This variant grows as pseudohyphae and does not produce germ tubes. This isolate was verified to be C. albicans. Further investigations are required to pin-point the cause of the defect in germ-tube formation. Hubbard et al. (1986) isolated a “mycelial” mutant after nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis. This had a rough-colony morphology and exhibited a stable, filamentous cellular morphology. A “rough”-colony morphology mutant was reported by Pomes et al. (1985). The wild-type (smooth-colony) strain, upon mild ultraviolet irradiation, gave rise to many “rough” segregants. Rough colonies, on further ultraviolet irradiation, gave sectored rough/smooth segregants. The smooth segregant spontaneously
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
65
segregated to produce some rough colonies. Possible involvement of a dominant gene that could control dimorphism (the gene might be involved in repression of mycelium during growth as yeast) has been postulated. B. SWITCHING OF COLONY MORPHOLOGY
Candida afbicans not only can change its cellular morphology in response to growth conditions, but also can heritably switch its cellular phenotype. This was recently discovered in the form of colony morphology switching. The yeast normally forms smooth, white colonies. However, it can switch its colony morphology, heritably and reversibly. At least three different switching systems are known. The first to be reported was in strain 3153A, which switches between at least seven phenotypes, namely smooth, star, ring, irregular wrinkle, hat, stipple and fuzzy (Fig. 2A-G; Slutsky et af., 1985). Spontaneous conversion from the original smooth phenotype to variant phenotypes occurs at a frequency of 1.4 x but is increased 200-fold following a low dose of ultraviolet radiation. After this initial conversion, cells switch spontaneously to other phenotypes at a combined frequency of 2 x lo-* (Slutsky et al., 1985). A C.albicans isolate from a vaginitis patient also exhibited a similar switching system (Soll et al., 1987). A second high-frequency switching system, referred to as white-opaque transition, was first reported in strain WO-1, an isolate from a patient with systemic candidiasis (Slutsky et al., 1987). In this system, cells switch heritably, reversibly and at a high frequency (lo-’) between white hemispherical colonies and opaque colonies which were larger, flatter and grey (Fig. 2 H). A similar switching system was also reported with three isolates from vaginitis patients (Soll et al., 1987). A third switching system was seen in five isolates from vaginitis patients (Soll et al., 1987). Here, the strains switch between a smooth-colony morphology and a heavily myceliated colony morphology. These strains also switch to other colony forms; however, the switching repertoire is not the same for all strains. Colony morphology switching has also been shown in benomyl-induced rough-colony mutants of C. afbicans (Pomes et al., 1987). The parent strain has a white smooth-colony morphology which is stable. However, the rough-colony mutants spontaneously segregate smooth or sectored (rough/smooth) colonies at about 2% frequency. The smooth segregants switch to a rough phenotype at similar frequencies. Other switch morphologies-“wavy” and ‘fuzzy”-which are capable of switching to other forms were also obtained. The cellular basis for the differences in diverse colony morphologies has been worked out only for the white-to-opaque transition (Anderson and Soll, 1987; Slutsky et af., 1987). White and opaque cells differ in their shape, size and budding pattern. Opaque cells are bean shaped, at least twice as large as white
66
ASlS D A T T A . K. G A N E S A N A N D
K. N A T A R A J A N
FIG. 2. Colony morphology of switch phenotypes of Candida afbicansstrain 3153A (A-G) and strain WO-1 (H). Key: A, smooth; B, star; C, ring; D, irregular wrinkle; E, stippled; F, hat; G, fuzzy; H, a white (W) colony with an opaque (Op) sector of strain WO-1. From Slutsky er al. (1985, 1987).
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANBIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
67
cells, contain twice the mass of white cells and exhibit budding at opposite poles, a condition rarely seen in white cells. No significant difference is seen in ploidy or in nuclear number. When compared with white cells, opaque cells have a longer generation time, fail to form hyphae under standard induction conditions, and are both cold- and heat-sensitive (Slutsky et al., 1987). Opaque cells also show a few other unique features (Anderson and Soll, 1987). Their cell surface has a pimpled or punctate pattern. The dynamics of actin localization indicate that the growth of budding opaque cells is similar to that of budding white cells during the early stages, but similar to that of hyphaforming white cells in the later stages of growth. A hypha-specific antigen is also expressed on the surface of budding opaque cells. An opaque-specific surface antigen is also seen, but distributed in a punctate pattern. Thus, the opaque phenotype seems to result from temporally modulated expression of bud-, hypha- and opaque-specific genes (Anderson and Soll, 1987). Two aspects which are most striking in colony-morphology switching are that it occurs at high frequency and that it results in a large number of phenotypic changes. Thus, switching is probably due to a change in the expression of a master control gene. This gene, presumably, regulates expression of many other genes which would result in diverse phenotypes. A mechanism similar to transposition may affect expression of the regulatory gene and cause switching. A particular mid-repeat sequence is known to be highly mobile in the genome of strain WO- 1, which undergoes white-opaque transition (Soll et al., 1987). However, the genomic changes caused by this sequence were not correlated with the switch phenotypes, indicating that it is not involved in switching. The transposon responsible for switching, if such exists, remains to be discovered. Colony-morphology switching may modulate the capacity of C. alhicans to invade diverse body locations, to evade the host immune system, possibly by changes in cell-surface antigens, or to change antibiotic resistance. Soll et al. (1987) have shown that switching occurs, in some instances, at the site of infection. Many isolates from vaginitis patients were present in multipleswitch phenotypes or were in a high-frequency mode of switching (lo-' to 10- 3). Thus, it is likely that colony-morphology switching plays an important role in pathogenesis. 1V. Pathogenesis
The pathogenic potential of C. alhicans has made it a medically important organism. The yeast causes candidiasis in humans and other mammals. Other species responsible for candidiasis in humans are C. tropicalis, C . pseudotropicalis, C.guilliermondii, C. krusei, C.parapsilosis and C.stellatoidea.
68
ASlS DATTA. K. GANESAN A N D K. NATARAJAN
Candida albicans is the predominant species identified and so this organism is used in most of the studies. Pathologic studies have demonstrated three types of infections, namely superficial, locally invasive and systemic (Luna and Tortoledo, 1985). Superficial infections are the most common and are seen on the mucous membranes of the oral cavity and respiratory tract, and on the skin. Locally invasive candidiasis occurs in immunocompromised patients and is frequently encountered as ulcerations of intestinal, respiratory or genito-urinary tracts. Systemic candidiasis is the most serious variety and involves invasive infection of the parenchyma of visceral organs, such as the heart, kidneys, liver, spleen, lungs and brain. Candida albicans pathogenesis has been described in many reviews (Odds, 1979; Rogers and Balish, 1980; Bodey and Fainstein, 1985; Dei-Cas and Vernes, 1986; Waldorf, 1986). In this review, reports that have appeared in the last two years are covered. At the end of this section, the progress made towards a cure for candidiasis is discussed. A. WHAT MAKES
Candida albicans INFECTIOUS?
Candida albicans is a commensal of the respiratory and gastro-intestinal tracts, the vagina and, less frequently, the skin of healthy persons. The majority of the carriers suffer no ill effects as a result of colonization. However, an important feature of C.albicans pathogenesis is that this harmless commensal becomes infectious, leading to candidiasis, when the host defense breaks down. Hence candidiasis is a disease of the diseased and C. albicans is called an opportunistic pathogen. The host defenses include the skin-mucosal barriers, the immune system and hormone levels.
I . Predisposing Factors and Host Defense Mechanisms a. Skin and Mucosal Barriers The stratified squamous epithelium normally functions as a very effective barrier against microbial invasion (Smith, 1985). Mechanical breakdown of the normal skin defenses is the most important predisposing factor for skin infections. The breakdown might occur as in burn injury or due to increased moisture and maceration of the skin. Mucosal surfaces are the initial site of infection for C. albicans and the major encounter between microbial pathogenic factors and host defenses occurs at this surface. Mucosal surfaces of the mouth, the gut and the vagina may be colonized with C.albicans in up to 80% of normal individuals (Odds, 1979) and the colonization is generally increased in patient populations. The interaction between C.albicans and other commensals is perhaps the most important factor affecting the degree of colonization of mucosal surfaces. The bacterial flora prevents binding and invasion of C. albicans. Given the importance of the normal microbial flora in
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
69
suppressing C. albicans colonization, antibiotic therapy thus acts as one of the predisposing factors. b. Immune System The immune system is normally effective in combating C. albicans. Candida albicans infection is dependent on breakdown of the host immune system. The predisposing factors are seen in leukemia patients receiving immunosuppressive therapy (Jones, 1981; Cole et al., 1987; Reizenstein, 1987), in cancer patients (Cho and Choi, 1979), in patients after surgical intervention and in AIDS patients (Klein and Watanakunakorn, 1979; Mildvan et al., 1982; Klein et al., 1984; Centers for Disease Control, 1986; Pedersen et ul., 1987).An analysis of the underlying defects in these patients indicated that C. albicans infection is specifically associated with defective cell-mediated immunity. Delayed-type hypersensitivity (Valdimarsson et al., 1973),an abnormal in vitro proliferative response to C. albicans antigens and an enhanced level of antiCandida antibodies (Takeya et al., 1976) clearly show that defective cellmediated immunity predisposes a host to C. ulbicans infection. c. Inherent Immunity Inflammation is the body’s first reaction to C. albicans invasion. The inflammatory response includes an increased blood supply to the infected area and an increased capillary permeability. These responses help the soluble mediators of immunity to reach the site of infection, while the neutrophil polymorphs, and to a lesser extent the macrophages, migrate out of the capillaries into the surrounding tissues. Once they reach inside the tissue, they migrate towards the site of infection by chemotaxis. The complement factors are believed to function in the chemotactic process. Polymorphonuclear neutrophils contain lysosomal granules, which possess a variety of hydrolytic enzymes. These neutrophils engulf the yeast form of C. albicans. The lysosomal granules fuse with the vacuole containing C. albicans to form a phagolysosome which brings about an efficient killing of the yeast. Candidu albicans hyphae are also frequently encountered in tissues. However, they are too large to be phagocytozed and are probably killed by certain extracellular processes (Waldorf, 1986). In experimental lung infection of mice, the host immune response is dependent on the size of the C. albicans inoculum. A large inoculum elicits neutrophil influx (Nugent and Onofrio, 1983);a smaller inoculum elicits a soluble factor, a protein of M , 29,000, that has a direct candidacidal activity (Nugent and Fick Jr., 1987). Macrophages play a central rble in cell-mediated immunity, because they are involved both in initiation of responses as antigen-presenting cells and in the effector phase as microbicidal cells. Many macrophage functions are
70
ASlS DATTA.
K
GANESAN A N D
K. NATARAJAN
enhanced by a process known as activation, brought about by lymphokines. There are many such lymphokines produced by T-cells (Roitt e? al., 1985). I n a particular experiment, the macrophage colony-stimulating factor, which is a lymphokine, enhanced the ability of macrophages to kill C. alhicans (Karbassi et al., 1987). In this experiment, the colony-stimulating factor is believed to have increased the density of mannose-binding receptors on the macrophage surface, thereby resulting in enhanced binding and ingestion of C. alhicans. The factors that predispose C. ulhicans infections are low neutrophil levels and defective cell-mediated immunity. In a particular instance, T-lymphocytes from chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis patients could not proliferate in oitro, and also could not exert helper activity for B-cell antibody production (Durandy et al., 1987). Thus, the normal anti-Candida defense system would not be active to thwart C. alhicans infection, leading to an efficient invasion and progression of the disease. d. Candidu-Induced Immunity Candida alhicuns also exerts a definite influence on the host immune response resulting in a debilitated candidacidal action. Diamond et al. (1980) showed that hyphae of C. alhicans secrete a peptide that inhibits neutrophil binding to the hyphae. Mannan, a major constituent of the cell wall in C. alhicans, was detected in the serum of some patients with mucocutaneous candidiasis (Fischer er ul., 1978). Mannan inhibited a Candidu antigen-induced in oitro proliferation of normal lymphocytes and also blocked the antigen-presenting ability of macrophages (Fischer et al., 1982). These mannan effects would result in an impaired cellular immune response. In another study, polysaccharide fractions (containing mostly mannose and glucose residues) from C. alhicans stimulated the T-cells to produce a suppressor factor, which in turn inhibited interleukin 1 and interleukin 2 production (Lombardi et ul., 1985). Since interleukins play an important r81e in T-lymphocyte proliferation, action of the suppressor factor would result in a poor immune response. e. Hormone Levels Hormonal changes during pregnancy predispose women to vaginal candidiasis, particularly vaginal thrush (Odds, 1979; Hurley, 1975). The presence of cornified epithelium and absence of leukocytes, which are normally observed during oestrous phase or are due to artificial administration of oestrogen, predispose rats to vaginitis. Oestrogen administration promotes colonization by C. alhicans, but progesterone administration does not (Kinsman and Collard, 1986). Corticosterone-, progesterone- and
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
71
oestrogen-binding proteins have been identified in C. albicans (Loose er al., 1981; Powell and Drutz, 1983; Powell et al., 1983; Das and Datta, 1985).These proteins might help C. albicans to sense the hormonal status of the host and respond appropriately. However, so far there is no evidence for this. 2. Virulence Factors a. Morphology Both yeast and hyphal forms of C. alhicans are seen at infected sites. It is believed that, for C.albicans to become invasive, a change in morphology from yeast to hypha is important. However, there is no conclusive evidence to show that virulence is solely dependent on either of the morphological forms. The relevance of morphology to virulence can be understood by studying the capacity of morphology mutants to induce experimental infections (Table 2). A spontaneous mutant, which did not form germ tubes, was reported to be less pathogenic compared with its parent strain (Sobel er al., 1984). A nitrosoguanidine-induced morphology mutant of C. albicans (hOG301) has a stable mycelial morphology (Hubbard et al., 1986). There are conflicting reports about the pathogenicity of this strain; it was found to be nonpathogenic by one group (Hubbard et al., 1986) but pathogenic by another (Shepherd, 1985). The reason for these disparate claims about the pathogenicity of strain hOG301 is not clear. Besides, the pathogenicity of CA2, a non-germ-tube-producing natural variant, is also controversial (Shepherd, 1985; Bistoni et al., 1986). Shepherd (1985) has shown that both budding and hyphal forms of C. albicans are pathogenic. Tissue sections from dead mice revealed that both morphological forms are seen after inoculation with the normal parent strain; but the original morphology (as seen in culture) of mutant strains (hOG301 and CA2) is preserved under in uiuo conditions (Shepherd, 1985).Since the pathogenicity of mutant strains is controversial, it is difficult to draw any conclusion from these publications. However, in the absence of any definite evidence for pathogenicity of the two morphologies, it is generally thought that hyphae are important for tissue invasion. b. Adherence Adherence is the capacity of C. albicans to bind to host cells, which enables the fungus to colonize. Adherence of C. albicans has been shown to play a necessary r6le for virulence of the organism (Macura er al., 1983; Ray et al., 1984; Segal er al., 1984; Ghannoum and Elteen, 1986; Lehrer et al., 1986). Pathogenic strains have adherence values significantly higher than those of non-pathogenic strains (Macura et al., 1983). Besides, in rodents, in uitro
72
ASlS DATTA.
K
GANESAN A N D
K.NATARAJAN
adherence capacity has been observed to correlate with pathogenicity (Ray et al., 1984). Moreover, vaginal epthelial cells from pregnant or diabetic women have a greater capacity to bind C. albicans in uitro. Isolates from patients with vaginitis have a higher adherence capacity than those from asymptomatic carriers (Segal et al., 1984). Adherence-negative mutants have been isolated (Cihlar et al., 1984; Calderone et al., 1985). Cerulenin, an antibiotic which affects fatty-acid synthesis by blocking fatty-acyl synthase, inhibits germ-tube formation (Hoberg et al., 1983) and has been demonstrated to be useful in the study of the surface of C. albicans. A cerulenin-resistant mutant had a modified cell wall which was impermeable to the antibiotic(Hoberg et al., 1986).The mutant also had a lower adherence capacity. It was found to be less virulent than the parent strain in experimental endocarditis in rabbits, and in experimental vaginal infection in mice (Lehrer et al., 1986). However, the parent and the mutant strains caused renal candidiasis to the same extent (Calderone et al., 1985). Mannose (Maisch and Calderone, 1981; Sandin et al., 1982) and Nacetylglucosamine (Segal et al., 1982) have been implicated in adherence. Reorganization of cell-wall glycoproteins is also of probable importance in adherence. Extracellular material, probably rich in aminosugars, is released from the yeast surface. Residues of N-acetylglucosamine which are present under the external cell wall are probably exposed by loss of wall material (Tronchin et a/., 1984). Lipids are also involved in adherence; phospholipids, sterols and sterol esters are the major classes of lipid that blocked adherence on pretreatment of either yeast cells or target cells (Ghannoum et al., 1986). Cell-surface hydrophobicity seems to be important in adherence, A rough colony-morphology variant with greater cell-surface hydrophobicity had greater adherence capacity (Shimokawa and Nakayama, 1986). c. Secretory Proteinases
In the search for virulence factors, secretory acid proteinases have gained importance. Induction by proteins leads to secretion of proteinase by C. albicans in culture. This proteinase is active only at low pH values (3.0-5.5; Ruchel, 198 I). Strain-specific proteinases have also been detected (Ruchel et ul., 1982). Interestingly, a high titre of antibody against a proteinase produced by C. albicans was detected in patients suffering from systemic candidiasis (MacDonald and Odds, 1980). A secretory proteinase-defective mutant was shown to be less virulent in mice (MacDonald and Odds, 1983).Kwon-Chung et ul. (1985) have shown that for C.albicans virulence, secretory proteinase activity is important. In a mouse model system, pathogenicity of a secretory proteinase-defective mutant, its parent and its revertant from tissue sections,
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
73
was studied. The parent had a high level of secretory proteinase and was very virulent. The mutant, with no detectable proteinase in uitro, was relatively avirulent. However, a few mice injected with the mutant died after a long incubation period. Isolates obtained from dead mice were found to be revertants, which secreted the proteinase at about half the level of the parent strain. Ghannoum and Elteen (1986) compared 53 isolates of C. albicans and demonstrated that isolates with a greater capacity to secrete proteinase had a higher adherence capacity while the extent of tissue colonization was also high. A strong correlation between proteinase secretion and adherence was observed. Candida albicans invasion into chorioallantoic membrane (Shimuzu et al., 1987)and its virulence for mice (Kondoh ef al., 1987)were used as models to study the relationship between proteinase secretion and pathogenicity. The results indicate that, besides proteinase, other factors are also involved in pathogenesis. Studies on an acid proteinase secreted by C. albicans have shown that the enzyme is necessary but not the sole determinant of pathogenicity. Since the proteinase requires a low pH value (between 3 and 5.5) for activity, it is difficult to explain how this enzyme can be active at the site of C. albicans colonization; the enzyme is actually denatured at neutral pH values (Ruche1et al., 1982). Besides, human saliva inhibited proteinase activity (Germaine and Tellefson, 1981). However, vaginal fluid has a pH value that is close to the optimal pH value required for proteinase activity. It also contains proteinaceous secretions that are potential proteinase inducers. Isolates of the yeast from vaginitis patients secreted more proteinase than isolates from carriers (Cassone et a/., 1987).Thus, at least in vaginitis, acid proteinase seems to play an important rB1e. Its rBle in other forms of candidiasis (though the proteinase appears to be secreted) is doubtful. d. Other Secretory Hydrolytic Enzymes Phospholipases secreted from C. albicans are likely to be involved in pathogenicity (Samaranayake ei al., 1984; Banno et al., 1985;Barrett-Bee et al., 1985).Capacity to adhere to buccal epithelial cells and pathogenicity for mice of four C. albicans isolates correlated with a high phospholipase activity (Barrett-Bee et al., 1985). Non-pathogenic yeasts and avirulent C. albicans strains had lower phospholipase activities (Barrett-Bee et al., 1985). N-Acetylglucosaminidase (chitobiase) is secreted during germ-tube formation by C. albicans (Sullivan et al., 1984). A mutant defective in production of chitobiase was less virulent compared with its parent strain (Jenkinson and Shepherd, 1987).Since this mutant was obtained after rigorous mutagenesis, and because its reversion frequency was high, the above result is not conclusive.
74
ASlS DATTA. K.GANESAN A N D K. NATARAJAN
3. Cell-Surface Antigens
Identification of surface antigens of C . albicans is important for the following reasons: (a)The yeast-to-hypha transition may be brought about by the appearance of new or modified surface antigens. Alternatively, as a consequence of hypha formation, cell-surface determinants can change. (b) Adherence is apparently linked to pathogenicity, and the cell surface of C.albicans is involved in adherence. Cell-surface glycoproteins have been implicated in adherence to the host cell surface (Lehrer et al., 1986; Maisch and Calderone, I98 1;Tronchin et al., 1984), and most of the C. albicans antigens are glycoproteins (Poulain et al., 1985). (c) Candida albicans might change its cell-surface antigens to evade the host immune system. The current trend in work on surface antigens of C. albicans has been on identification of morphology-specific (mainly hyphae-specific) surface antigens and of cell-surface antigens expressed during pathogenesis. Germ tube-specificsurface antigens have been identified using polyclonal antisera by two groups (Table 1; Sunstrom and Kenny, 1984,1985; Sundstrom et al., 1987; Smail and Jones, 1984; Ponton and Jones, 1986). Strains of C. albicans exhibit colony-morphology switching (see Section 1II.B). In the white-opaque switching system, opaque cells are defective in hypha formation. However, they express a cell surface antigen which is specific for hypha-forming white cells. Opaque cells also express a unique antigen of M , 13,500 (Anderson and Soll, 1987). Monoclonal antibodies against blastospores recognized two different cell-surface antigens, namely AgC6 and AgH9 (Brawner and Cutler, 1984, 1986a). Antigens AgC6 and AgH9 were present on old buds and were absent from the surface of new buds, which indicates that there is a temporal difference in expression of these antigens (Brawner and Cutler, 1986a). Expression of these antigens has also been studied during morphogenesis (Brawner and Cutler, 1986b). Antigen AgH9 initially disappeared from the mother cell and preferentially appeared on hyphae during the first four hours of germination, but reappeared on the mother cell by 20 hours. However, antigen AgC6 was constantly expressed on the cell surface of both mother cells and hyphae during germination. Interestingly, expression of these antigens was similar on both hyphae and pseudohyphae (Brawner and Cutler, 1986b). It is important to know whether antigens detected in uitro are also expressed in uiuo, so that the results can be extrapolated to the diseased conditions. Patients with disseminated candidiasis had higher levels of IgG directed against a protein of 48,000Da (Strockbine et al., 1984b). The size of this
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
75
protein is similar to actin. Anti-actin antibodies are produced in patients suffering from myasthenia gravis (Williams and Lennon, 1986). Since the 48,000 Da antigen can be used in diagnostics, it was important to know if this was actin. Using an anti-48,000 Da monoclonal antibody, it was shown that actin from C. albicans and the 48,000 Da antigen are immunologically unrelated (Fiss and Buckley, 1987). Thus, the anti-48,000 Da monoclonal antibody can be used in serodiagnostic tests for disseminated candidiasis. A heat-stable 47,000 Da antigen has been detected in sera of most patients with systemic infections (Matthews e f al., 1987).However, the chemical nature of this antigen has not been elucidated. It is also not clear if this antigen is the same as those detected by Strockbine er af. (1984a,b). Recently, Neale er af. (1987) have identified a major antigen of 47,00ODa, as part of circulating immune complexes in patients with C. albicans osteomyelitis. 4. Arninosugar Metabolism
Aminosugars are present in mucous membranes, which are the sites of colonization by C. albicans. Although aminosugars are not in the free form, they are present as part of proteins (glycoproteins). Since C. albicans has to survive on the mucous membrane by utilizing a sugar (possibly aminosugars) as a source of energy, we initiated studies on aminosugar metabolism in C. albicans to gain a better understanding of the biochemical basis of candidiasis. A comparative study of utilization of N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc) by pathogenic and non-pathogenic strains was carried out in our laboratory (Singh and Datta, 1979a). Non-pathogenic yeasts cannot utilize GlcNAc, which suggests that the aminosugar metabolic pathway is important in pathogenesis. The aminosugar metabolic pathway in C. albicans was first elucidated in our laboratory. N-Acetylglucosamine is transported by a membrane-associated permease (Singh and Datta, 1979a; Singh e f al., I980a; Mattia et af..1982).The transported sugar is metabolized by the sequential action of GlcNAc kinase (Bhattacharya er al., 1974a,b; Singh and Datta, 1979b; Rai et al., 1980; Shepherd ei al., 1980b),GlcNAc 6-phosphate deacetylase (Gopal et al., 1982; Rai and Datta, 1982) and glucosamine 6-phosphate deaminase (Singh and Datta, 1979b,c; Das and Datta, 1982; Gopal et al., 1982).All of these enzymes are induced on addition of GlcNAc to cultures of C. albicans. A typical feature of this system is the absence of glucose repression (Singh and Datta, 1978; Singh er al., 1980b).Western blot analysis revealed that the deaminase level was stimulated 20-fold when GlcNAc was added to a growing glucosecontaining culture of C. afbicans (K. Natarajan, unpublished result). N-Acetylmannosamine (ManNAc) induces ManNAc 2-epimerase activity in C. albicans (Biswas er al., 1979). Moreover, ManNAc induces all of the
N-Acetvlglucosamine
I N-Acetvlmannosam i n
Clucosanine
WGlucosamine-mClucosanine
6-Phosphate
C l vc cr 1YS is
FIG. 3. Aminosugar metabolism in Cundidu ufbicans: A, N-acetylglucosamine permease, B, N-acetylglucosamine kinase; C, N-acetylglucosamine 6-phosphate deacetylase; D, glucosamine 6-phosphate deaminase; E, N-acetylmannosamine 2-epimerase; F, general sugar permease. Cundida ulbicuns strains seem to vary in their capacity for N-acetylmannosamine transport.
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDlDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
77
enzymes of GlcNAc metabolism (Biswas et al., 1979; Sullivan and Shepherd, 1982). N-Acetylmannosamine can also be utilized by at least two C. albicans strains as a sole carbon source for growth (Biswas et al., 1979; Torosantucci and Cassone, 1983). But it has also been reported that a different C. albicans strain cannot transport ManNAc from the medium (Sullivan and Shepherd, 1982). This discrepancy is probably due to strain differences. Glucosamine (GlcN) also supports growth of C. albicans(Torosantucci and Cassone, 1983). This sugar is transported probably by a general sugar permease, and a GlcN kinase has also been detected (Corner et al., 1986). NAcetylglucosamine kinase is not induced by GlcN (Natarajan et al., 1984; Corner et al., 1986).The aminosugar metabolic pathway is summarized in Fig. 3. Presently, it is speculative whether the capability to metabolize GlcNAc is important for pathogenesis because the sugar in the free form is not available at the site of colonization. However, N-acetylglucosaminidase (chitobiase), which is also induced by GlcNAc (Sullivan et al., 1984),might release GlcNAc residues from glycoproteins. These residues can be utilized by C.albicans for its growth. The inducible GlcNAc-metabolizing system is a good model to study the regulatory circuits of gene expression. Studies with inhibitors indicate that the genes of the GlcNAc metabolic pathway are regulated at the stage of transcription (Singh and Datta, 1979b; Biswas et al., 1982; Gopal et al., 1982). To understand molecular details of the process and to study the relevance of GlcNAc metabolism in pathogenesis and morphogenesis, we are currently involved in molecular cloning of the genes for GlcNAc metabolic enzymes. B. CURE FOR CANDIDIASIS
Candidiasis is still an intractable malady. However, in this section, we describe progress made towards finding a cure for candidiasis. Rapid and reliable identification of the causative organism is necessary to devise a suitable therapy. Experiments related to diagnostics are being done to identify antigens of C. albicans and metabolites in the sera of patients. A heat-stable antigen (mannan) and a heat-labile antigen (a protein) have been detected in serum (Bennett, 1987). Other reports on circulating antigens have been discussed. The 47,000 and 48,000 Da antigens are consistently detected in the sera of patients with systemic candidiasis (see Section IV.A.3). These are absent from healthy individuals and those who are in the recovery phase of the disease. Monoclonal antibodies against the 48,000 Da antigen are available (Strockbine et al., 1984a)which can be used in diagnosis. Another approach to identifying the pathogen is by species typing. Identification by classical methods involves, among others, cumbersome sugar assimilation and fermentation tests and ability to form germ tubes. In a rapidly advancing area,
78
ASlS DA’ITA.
K GANESAN AND K. NATARAJAN
species typing is being attempted by analysis of mitochondria1 DNA (Olivo et al., 1987), rRNA-encoding DNA (Scherer and Stevens, 1987) and actinencoding DNA (Mason et al., 1987). Refinement of DNA analysis strategies and serodiagnosis holds the key for an efficient and reliable diagnostic tool for C. albicans. The prevalent view concerning the source of the pathogen is that it is from the patient’s gastro-intestinal tract. However, Burnie et al. (1985) reported that an outbreak of systemic candidiasis in a hospital intensive-care unit was caused by a single strain of C. alhicans. Hospital-acquired C. albicans infections have recently become more prevalent. If such infections are due to a single strain, then management of the disease would be easier. General antifungal agents are prescribed for candidiasis. Polyenes, such as nystatin and amphotericin B, has been used for a long time. The efficacy of these antibiotics has been evaluated with divergent results. High doses of amphotericin B lead to impaired renal function. But, Medoff et al. (1972) reported a low-dose therapy that was effective in clearing systemic infections. Amphotericin B at low doses stimulates the host immune system, in addition to its antifungal action. However, the low-dose regimen is not effective against candidemia and some other forms of candidiasis. Although there are reports of polyene-resistant strains of C. alhicuns isolated from patients with defective neutrophil function, amphotericin-B-resistant strains are considered rare (Drutz, 1987). Other therapeutic agents include 5-fluorocytosine (5FC), and azoles (imidazole derivatives such as ketoconazole, miconozole and clotrimazole. 5Fluorocytosine is converted by cytosine deaminase into 5-fluorouracil which is incorporated into DNA and RNA. In addition, 5FC inhibits DNA synthesis. It is specific for C. alhicans, since cytosine deaminase is absent from, or is present at a very low level in, host mammalian cells. Unlike amphotericin B, 5FC is almost completely absorbed from the gastro-intestinal tract and thus enters into circulation. It is excreted unchanged in high concentrations through urine (Bennett, 1977). Strains of C. alhicans resistant to 5FC have been documented. The gene conferring resistance was heterozygous in the clinical isolates (Defever et al., 1982); the heterozygous strains segregated and gave rise to highly resistant strains. Conflicting results have been reported on the potential value of imidazoles in prophylaxis. A rBle for miconazole in management of immunocompromised patients seems very limited (Meunier, 1987). Ketoconazole is highly effective in patients with chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis (Horsburg and Kirkpatrick, 1983) as well as in AIDS patients with oropharyngeal candidiasis(Go1d and Armstrong, 1984). However, the definitive rBle as well as specific indications for ketoconazole in other immunocompromised patients have not yet been clearly established.
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDIDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
79
There are several other antibiotics that can interfere with RNA or protein synthesis in cell extracts of C. albicans, but do not affect the organism as such, probably because intact C. ulbicans does not take them up. Amphotericin B, at low concentrations, is non-toxic and non-lethal, but perturbs the cell membrane which results in an increased permeability to other drugs. Medoff (1987) reported that a low concentration of amphotericin B increased uptake of 5FC by C. albicans; as a result, the minimum inhibitory concentration required for 5FC was decreased. Controlled studies have yet to be done before prescribing this combination therapy. Another approach for treatment of candidiasis has been to develop a drugcarrier system; liposomes are being used to deliver amphotericin B (LopezBerestein, 1987).The high hydrophobicity of amphotericin B makes it a good candidate for liposomal incorporation. Liposome-encapsulated amphotericin B is superior to amphotericin B alone in treatment of experimental candidiasis in neutropenic mice (Lopez-Berestein et af., 1984). Liposome-mediated drug delivery holds promise as high concentrations can be given without the usual side effects. In conclusion, there is still no consensus on the best prophylactic approach in candidiasis (Meunier, 1987). Elimination of predisposing factors is still a judicious approach in effective management of candidiasis. V. Problems in Research on Candida albicans
The main difficulty in research on C. albicans has been due to the organism itself. Natural isolates are predominantly diploid; also, a sexual cycle is absent. Advancement of knowledge in fungi, especially yeasts like Saccharomyces cereuisiue, has been through elaborate genetic analyses using conventional techniques. Genetic analyses in C. albicans has been attempted through parasexual techniques but with limited success. The second difficulty with C. albicans are the variations between strains. This has created confusion in interpreting results of many studies. In this section, aspects of strain variations are discussed. Strains of C. alhicans display a great deal of heterogeneity in germ-tube formation. All strains do not possess the capability to form germ tubes; even if a strain has the capability, it does not form germ tubes under all conditions that favour this morphological change. To illustrate this point, C. albicans 2252, although it formed germ tubes in serum, did not do so in all other media examined (Manning and Mitchell, 1980a). Strains of C. alhicans have been classified as high responders, low responders and non-responders based on the ease with which they can be induced to form germ tubes. High responders can be induced by GlcNAc alone, whereas low responders can be induced by
80
ASlS D A T T A .
K.G A N E S A N A N D K.N A T A R A J A N
serum or GlcNAc together with serum; non-responders do not form germ tubes (Mattia et al., 1982). Strains of C. alhicans vary in expression of cell-surface antigens (Brawner and Cutler, 1984; Sundstrom and Kenny, 1985; Hopwood et al., 1986). This reflects inherent differences 'among strains. Even clonal populations of a particular strain exhibited heterogeneous reactivity to patient serum (Fig. 4; Poulain et al., 1985). Manning and Mitchell (1980b) showed differences in polypeptides between two C. alhicans strains, a germ tube-producing strain (4918)and another that does not form germ tubes(2252). Over 80 polypeptides were different in cells of strains 2252 and 4918, when compared under identical experimental conditions. This observation implies that the comparison between any two strains is difficult. Candidu alhicans exhibits strain-specific variations with respect to natural heterozygosity. On mild mutagenesis, they yield a limited set of auxotrophs at high frequency and each strain gives rise to a particular type of auxotroph. For example, C. albicans ATCC 10261 is heterozygous for a gene involved in lysine biosynthesis (Hilton et a[., 1985); strain NIH Ca529 gave suf- segregants (defective in reduction of inorganic sulphate) (Whelan and Soll, 1982) and strain 6631 gave rise to canavanine-sensitive segregants at a high frequency (Crandall, 1983). Singh and Datta (1978) reported that glucose does not repress induction of the GIcNAc metabolic pathway in C. alhicans 3100. Also, in another strain (SC5314), there is no glucose repression of GlcNAc kinase and GlcNAc 6phosphate deaminase activities (A. Banerjee and K. Natarajan, unpublished observations). However, Niimi et al. (1987)have reported glucose repression in two other strains of C. albicans. Careful examination of the results (Niimi et al., 1987) revealed that, under identical conditions, the two strains exhibited quantitative differences in glucose repression of the GlcNAc uptake system. This is also true for GlcNAc kinase activity (Niimi et al., 1987).These results can only be explained in terms of strain differences. Ability to form germ tubes is one of the main criteria by which C. albicuns is identified (Meyer et al., 1984). Variability in germ-tube formation among C. albicans strains has lead to problems in species identification. Presently, the focus is on the DNA fragment pattern generated by restriction endonucleases (Magee et al., 1987; Olivo et al., 1987; Scherer and Stevens, 1987). Each Candida species has a characteristic DNA restriction-fragment pattern (Magee et a[., 1987). However, various strains of C. albicans displayed variations in the lengths of restriction fragments (Magee et al., 1987). Physiological characteristics of C. albicans are modulated by growth temperature (Hazen and Hazen, 1987).When cells grown a t 28 and 37°C were compared, virulence, cell-surface hydrophobicity, and germ-tube formation were found to differ. Hazen and Hazen (1987) concluded that cells grown at
Titre J
I
l o 2 0
50
( 0 0 2 0 0 4 0 0 & m 1 6 0 0 3 2 0 0 6 4 m
+
CMRT 91
FIG. 4. Clonal populations of Candida albicans strain VW show variation in the level of cell-surface antigents, as determined by their reactivity to patient sera A and B. Titres of sera A and B against the original uncloned strain were 100 and 400, respectively. The most representative groups of the clonal populations reacted at titres similar to those of the original strain. GMRT 91 and 716 indicate the geometrical mean range titres for respective sera. From Poulain ef at. (1980).
82
ASlS D A T T A . K G A N E S A N A N D K N A T A R A J A N
37°C are affected more by environmental perturbations and germinate less. Cells grown at 28°C are more virulent than those grown at 37°C. These observations indicate that apparent subtle differences can lead to serious problems. Differences in growth temperature, media composition, stage of cell growth, etc., have to be seriously considered by researchers. We have shown, through a few examples, the magnitude of strain differences and how inherent differencescan lead to inconclusive results. Thus, findings in one strain cannot be generalized to the species C. alhicans as a whole. It is difficult to ascribe reasons for the enormous variation among C. ulhicuns strains. Lack of a sexual cycle appears to be the reason for strain variations. With no opportunity for mixing of genetic traits, strains seem to accumulate variations and evolve independently. Even clonal populations of a particular strain exhibited heterogenous reactivity to patient serum (Fig. 4;Poulain et a/., 1980, 1985). Such variations might be due to mechanisms similar to colonymorphology switching, but more subtle. Colony-morphology switching is associated with a large number of differences at the cellular and molecular level (see Section II1.B). Thus, switching alone can cause strain variations. Presently, different strains of C. alhicans are being used to study morphogenesis. A couple of selected, standard C. albicans strains are recommended to carry out research related to genetics and morphogenesis. However, pathogenesis experiments cannot be undertaken with a few strains. Since C. ulhicuns strains vary in their cell-surface antigens and in their relative virulence, a specific immunization therapy for candidiasis would be acceptable only after considerable experimentation with regard to its ability to protect the host against most, if not all, strains. V1. Summary
Canclidu alhicuns is an opportunistic pathogen of human beings and other mammals. Two other features, besides its pathogenicity, have made it a popular organism of study. It exists in different cellular forms and can change from one form to another, depending on growth conditions. Thus, it is being used as a model system to study cellular differentiation. It can also heritably and reversibly switch its cellular and colony morphologies. The yeast is diploid and lacks a sexual cycle. Thus, it has not been possible to apply the powerful methods of genetic analysis to understand morphogenesis or pathogenesis. Few clinical isolates are haploid, but they do not form hyphae and are not yet well characterized. Recombinant DNA techniques are increasingly being applied to C. albicans to solve many of the unanswered questions of morphogenesis and pathogenesis. Genetic transformation and gene-disruption techniques were recently developed for the yeast. Thus it is
CURRENT TRENDS IN CANDlDA ALBICANS RESEARCH
83
possible to study the rdle of any cloned gene through directed mutagenesis. However, the difficulty is to clone the putative genes involved in morphogenesis or pathogenesis. Cundidu ulbicuns exists in four different cellular forms, namely blastospores, pseudohyphae, hyphae and chlamydospores. Blastospore-to-hypha conversion is well studied. A variety of conditions can induce this transition. It is not clear how cells sense such varied conditions and respond appropriately. In other systems where differentiation is well understood, regulatory genes which control differentiation have been uncovered. These genes cause differential expression of other genes, and ultimately differentiated phenotypes. Thus, it is likely that differential gene expression is involved in the bud-to-hypha transition in C. ulhicuns. Certain proteins are expressed exclusively on the cell surface of hyphae. It should be possible to clone genes coding for these proteins. A study of the expression of these genes might allow us to identify the regulatory gene which determines differentiation. Another approach to understanding morphogenesis is to study how the difference in the shape of buds and hyphae is generated. This difference appears to be due to the differential activity of apical and general growth zones, which determine growth of the cell wall. Activity of these growth zones is apparently determined by actin localization. It remains a possibility that conditions which induce hyphae formation may directly affect actin localization or cell-wall growth zones and cause differences in cell shape. Cundidu ulbicuns can also heritably switch its cellular phenotype. This has come to light from a study of colony-morphology switching. Some strains can switch their colony morphology, both heritably and reversibly. At least three switching systems are known. The white-to-opaque transition is well studied at the cellular level. White and opaque cells differ in a large number of features. Since switching occurs at a high frequency, the differences in phenotypes are probably due to a change in expression of a key regulatory gene. A mechanism analogous to transposition may affect expression of the regulatory gene and cause switching. Opaque cells are not capable of forming hyphae under standard induction conditions. However, they express hypha-specific proteins on their cell surface during the later stages of bud growth. Thus, identification of the regulatory gene, and genes controlled by it, would not only explain switching, but may also explain differentiation of buds into hyphae in normal cells. Cundidu ulhicuns is present as a commensal in healthy hosts, but becomes pathogenic in individuals with immune dysfunction or hormonal imbalance. It causes superficial, locally invasive and systemic infections. Among the factors which make it virulent are its ability to adhere to host cells, and to secrete proteinases and other hydrolytic enzymes. Its cell-surface proteins and its capacity to utilize aminosugars are also likely to be important in
84
ASlS DATTA. K GANESAN AND K. NATARAJAN
pathogenesis. Its ability to change its cell morphology heritably, or in response to growth conditions, is also likely to play an important r6le in pathogenesis. The most active component of the host defence against C. afbicans is phagocytosis. Macrophage colony-stimulating factor-1 and a 29,000 Da protein are also known to be active in host defense. Cundidu ulbicans evades the host immune response by suppressing phagocytic functions. Its cell-wall components, particularly mannan, are mainly responsible for this suppression. Furthermore, a peptide secreted by the yeast is also involved.
VII. Acknowledgements We are indebted to all of the former and current researchers in this laboratory. Our special thanks go to Bipasha Gupta Roy, Anasua Banerjee and Vijay Paranjape for their helpful discussions. We are thankful to Samar Chatterjee for his critical comments on the manuscript, and Sarjeet Singh and Gajanan Hegde for their efficient typing. REFERENCES
Anderson, J. M. and Soll, D. R. (1986). Journal qf General Microbiology 132, 2035. Anderson. J. M. and Soll, D. R. (1987). Journal of Bacteriology 169, 5579. Banno, Y., Yamada, T. and Nozawd, Y. (1985). Sabouraudia 23.47. Barrett-Bee, K., Hayes, Y., Wilson, R. G.and Ryley, J. F. (1985).Journal ofGeneru1 Microbiology 131, 1217. Bennett, J. E. (1977). Annals qf Internal Medicine 86, 319. Bennett, J. E. (1987). Reoiew of Infecrious Diseases 9, 398. Bhattacharya, A., Banerjee, S. and Datta, A. (1974a). Biochimica et Biophysica Aria 374, 384. Bhattacharya, A., Puri, M. and Datta, A. (1974b). Biochemical Journal 141, 593. Bistoni. F., Vecchiarelli. A., Ceuci, E., Puccetti, P., Marconi, P. and Cassone, A. (1986).Infivtion and Immunity 51, 668. Biswas, M., Singh, B. and Ddtta, A. (1979). Biochimica el Biophysica Acta 585. 535. Biswas, M., Singh, B., Rai, Y. P. and Datta, A. (1982).fndian Journal oJE.uperimenta1 Biology 20, 829. Bodey, G. P. and Fainstein, V. (1985). “Candidiasis”. Raven Press, New York. Braun, P. C. and Calderone, R. A. (1978). Journal qf Bacteriology 133, 1472. Brawner, D. L. and Cutler, J. E. (1984). Infection and Immunity 43, 966. Brawner, D. L. and Cutler. J. E. (1986a). Infection and Immunity 51, 327. Brawner. D. L. and Cutler, J. E. (1986b). Infection and Immunity 51, 337. Buckley, H. R., Price, M. R. and Daneo-Moore. L. (1982). Infection and Immunity 37, 1209. Buffo, J., Herman, M. A. and SOH, D. R. (1984). Mycopathologia 85, 21. Burnie, J. P., Odds, F. C., Lee, W., Webster, C. and Williams, J. D. (1985).British Medical Journal 290, 746. Calderone, R.A., Cihlar, R. L., Lee, D. D.-S., Hoberg, K. and Scheld, W. M. (1985). Journal of Infectious Dbeases 152, I1 0.
Cannon, R. D. (1986). Journal of General Microbiology 132, 2405. Cassone, A., Bernardis, F. D., Mondello, F., Ceddia, T. and Agatensi, L. (1987). Journal of Infectious Diseases 156, 777. Cassone, A., Sullivan, P. A. and Shepherd, M. G. (1985). Microbiolugica 8, 85.
CURRENT TRENDS IN C A N D I D A ALEICANS RESEARCH
85
Centers for Disease Control (1986) Update. Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, United States. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Reports 35, 17. Chattaway, F. W., Wheeler, P. R. and OReilly, J. (1981). Journalof GeneralMicrobiology 123,233. Cheung, W. Y . (1980). Science 207, 19. Chiew, Y.Y.,Shepherd, M. G. and Sullivan, P. A. (1980). Archives of Microbiology 125, 97. Cho. Y.S. and Choi, H. Y . (1979). American Journal of Clinical Pathology 72, 617. Cihlar, R., Hoberg, K. and Calderone, R. A. (1984). In “Microbiology” (L. Levine and D. Schlessinger, eds), pp. 148. American Society for Microbiology, Washington D.C. Cole, S., Zawin, M.. Lundberg, B., Hoffman, J., Bailey, L. and Ernstoff, M. A. (1987). American Journal of Medicine 82, 662. Corner, B. E., Poulter. R. T. M., Shepherd, M. G. and Sullivan, P. A. (1986). Journal of General Microbiology 132, 15. Crandall, M. (1983). Current Genetics 7, 167. DdS, M. and Datta, A. (1982). Biochemistry International5, 735. Das, M. and Datta, A. (1985). Biochemistry International 11, 171. Defever, K. S., Whelan, W. L., Rogers, A. L., Beneke, E. S., Veslenak, J. M. and Soll, D. R. (1982). Antimicrobial Agents and Chemorherapy 22, 8 10. Dei-Cas, E. and Vernes, A. (1986). In “Critical Reviews in Microbiology”(W. M. OLeary, ed.), vol. 13, pp. 173. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Diamond, R. D., Oppenheim, F., Nakagdwa, Y.,Krzesicki, R. and Haudenschild, C. C. (1980). Journal of Immunology 125, 2797. Drutz, D. J. (1987). Reuiew oflnfectious Diseases 9, 417. Durandy. A., Fischer, A., Le Deist, F., Drouhet, E. and Griscelli, C. (1987). Journal of Clinical Immunology 7, 400. Finney, R., Langtimm, C. J. and Soll, D. R. (1985). Mycoparhologia 91, 3. Fischer, A., Ballett, J. J. and Griscelli, C. (1978). Journal of Clinical Investigation 62, 1005. Fischer. A., Pichat. L..Audinot. M. and Griscelli, C. (1982). ClinicalandE.rperimentulImmunol~~g~~ 47, 653.
Fiss. E. and Buckley, H. R. (1987). Infection and Immunity 55, 2324. Germaine, G . R. and Tellefson, L. M. (1981). Injection and fmmunity 31, 323. Ghannoum. M. and Elteen, K. A. (1986). Journal of Medical and Velerinary Mycology 24, 407. GhdnnOUm, M. A., Burns, G. R., Elteen, K. A. and Radwan, S. S. (1986). Infection and Immunity 54, 189. Gillum, A. M., Tsay, E. Y. H. and Kirsch, D. R. (1984). Molecular and General Generics 198, 179. Gold, J. W. M. and Armstrong, D. (1984). Annals ofihe New York Academy of Sciences 437,383. Gopal, P., Sullivan, P. A. and Shepherd, M. G. (1982). Journal of General Microbiology 128,2319. Gupta Roy, B. and Datta, A. (1986) Biochemical Journal 234, 543. Gupta Roy, B. and Datta, A. (1987). FEMS Microbiology Letters 41, 327. Hazen, K. C. and Hazen, B. W. (1987). Microbiology and Immunology 31,497 Hilton, C., Markie, D., Corner, B., Rikkerink, E. and Poulter, R. (1985). Molecular and General Genetics 200, 162. Hoberg, K. A., Cihlar, R. L. and Calderone, R. A. ( I 983). An/imicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 24, 401.
Hoberg, K. A., Cihlar, R. L. and Calderone, R. A. (1986). Infection and lmmuniry 51, 102. Hopwood. V., Poulain, D., Fortier, B., Evans, G. and Vernes, A. (1986). Infecrion and Immunity 54, 222.
Horsburgh Jr. C. R. and Kirkpatrick, C. H. (1983). American Journal of Medicine 74, 23. Howard, D. H., Zeuthen. M. L. and Dabrowa, N. (1986). Journal of General Microbiology 132, 2359.
Hubbard. M., Bradley, M., Sullivan, P., Shepherd, M. and Forrester, I. (1982). FEBS Lerters 137, 85.
Hubbard, M. J., Markie. D. and Poulter, R. T. M. (1986). Journal ofBarleriology 165, 61. Hurley, R. (1975). The Practitioner 215, 753. Jenkinson, H. F. and Shepherd, M. G. (1987). Journal of General Microbiolog-v 133, 2097. Jones, J. M. (1981). Annuls of Internal Medicine 94, 475. Kakar, S. N., Partridge, R. M. and Magee, P. T. (1983). Genetics 104, 241.
86
ASlS DATTA.
K.G A N E S A N A N D K. NA’IAKAJAN
Karbassi. A., Becker, J. M., Foster, J. S. and Moore, R. N. (1987). Journalof Immunology 139,417. Kelly, R., Miller, S. M., Kurtz, M. B. and Kirsch, D. R. (1987). Molecular and Cellular Biology 7 , 199. Kinsman, 0. S. and Collard, A. E. (1986). Injection and Immunity 53, 498. Klein, J. J. and Watanakunakorn, C. (1979). American Journal of Medicine 67, 51. Klein, R. S.. Harris, C. A.. Small, C. B., Moll, B., Lesser, M. and Friedland, G. H. (1984). New Englund Journal of Medicine 311, 354. Kondoh. Y., Shimuzu, K. and Tanaka, K. (1987). Microbiology and Immunology 31, 1061. Kurtz, M. B., Cortelyou, M. W. and Kirsch, D. R. (1986). Molecular and Cellular Biology 6 , 142. Kurtz, M. B., Cortelyou, M. W., Miller, S. M., Lai, M. and Kirsch, D. R. (1987). Molecular and Cellular Biology 7 . 209. Kwon-Chung, K. J., Lehman, D., Good, C. and Magee, P. T. (1985). Infection and Imnruni/y 49, 571. Lehrer, N.. Segal, E., Cihlar, R. L. and Calderone, R. A. (1986).Journal of Medicaland Veterinury M-vcohgy 24, 127. Lombardi, G., Vismara, D., Piccolella, E., Colizzi, V. and Asherson, G. L. (1985). Clinical and Esperimental 1niniunolog.v 60,303. Loose, D. S., Schurman. D. J. and Feldman, D. (1981). Nature 293, 477. Lott, T. J.. Boiron, P. and Reiss, E. (1987). Molecular and General Genetics 209, 170. Lopez-Berestein, G . (1987). Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 31, 675. Lopez-Berestein, G.,Hopfer, R. L., Mehta, K.. Hersch, E. M. and Juliano, R. L. (1984).Journalof In/iJctious Diseases 150, 278. Luna, M. A. and Tortoledo, M. E. (1985). In “Candidiasis” (G. P. Bodey and V. Fainstein. eds.), pp. 13-27, Raven Press, New York. MacDonald, F. and Odds, F. C. (1980).Journal (?/Medical Microbiology 13, 423. MacDonald, F. and Odds, F. C. ( I 983). Journal of Generul Microbi01og.v 129, 43 I . Macura, A., Powlik, B. and Wita, B. (1983).Zenrralbla/r,fir Bakreriologie und Ahteilung Originale (A) 254, 561. Maisch, P. A. and Calderone. R. A. (1981). Ic/ection and Immunity 32, 92. Magee, B. B. and Magee, P. T. (1987). Journal of General Microbiology 133, 425. Magee, B. B., DSouza, T. M. and Magee, P. T. (1987). Journal of Bacteriology 169, 1639. Manning, M. and Mitchell, T. G. (1980a). Journul q / Bacteriology 142, 714. Manning, M. and Mitchell, T. G. (1980b). Journal flfBUCtf‘rio/Ogy 144, 258. Mason, M. M., Lasker, 8. A. and Riggsby, W. S. (19871. Journul ofClinicul Microbio/ogjS25,563. Matthews, R. C.. Burnie. J. P.and Tabaqchali, S. (1987).Journd ofClinica1 Microbiologji 25,230. Mattia, E., Carruba, G., Angiolella. L. and Cassone, A. (1982).Journal of Bacteriolog)~152, 555. Medoff, G. (1987). Reiliew of Infectious Diseases 9, 403. Medoff, G.,Dismukes, W. E., Meade, R. H. and Moses, J. M. (1972). Archives of Internal Medicine 130, 24 I. Meunier, F. (1987). Review of Infivtious Diseases 9, 408. Meyer, S. A., Ahearn. D. G. and Yarrow, D. (1984)1n“The Yeasts, A Taxonomic Study”(N. J. W. Kreger-Van Rij, ed.), 3rd edn, pp. 585-844. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Mildvan. D., Mathur, V., Enlow, R. W., Romain, P. L., Winchester, R. J., Colp, C., Singhman, H., Adelsberg, B. R. and Spigland, 1. (1982). Annals qf Inrernal Medicine 96, 700. Mitchell. L. and SOH,D. R. (1979a). Experimental Cell Research 120, 167. Mitchell, L. and Soll, D. R. (1979b). Experimental Mycology 3, 298. Muthukumar, G. and Nickerson, K. W. (1984). Journal of Bacteriolcigy 159, 390. Muthukumar, G. and Nickerson, K. W. (1985). FEMS Microbiology Le/ter.s 25, 199. Muthukumar, G., Kulkarni, R. K. and Nickerson, K. W. (1985).Journalc~fBucteriolugy162,47. Muthukumar, G., Nickerson, A. W. and Nickerson, K. W. (1987).FEMS Microbiology Letters 41, 253. Natarajan, K., Rai, Y. P. and Datta, A. (1984). Biochemistry In/ernational9, 735. Neale, T. J., Muir, J. C. and Drake, B. (1987). Australia andNen*Zeuland JournalofMedicine 17, 201. Niimi, M., Kamiyama, A., Tokunaga, M. and Nakayama, H. (1987). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 33, 345.
C U R R E N T T R E N D S IN CANDlDA ALBlCANS RESEARCH
87
Niimi, M., Niimi, K., Tokunaga, J. and Nakayama, H. (1980). Journalof Bacteriology 142, 1010. Nugent, K. M. and Fick Jr, R. B. (1987). Infection and Immunitj~55, 541. Nugent, K. M. and Onofrio, J. M. (1983). American Review c~f Respiratory Diseuses 128, 909. Odds, F. C. (1979). In ”Candida and Candidosis”. University Park Press, Baltimore. Odds, F. C. (1985).In “Critical Reviews in Microbiology” (W. M. OLeary, ed.), vol. 12, pp. 4S93. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Olaiya, A. F., Steed, J. R. and Sogin, S. J. (1980). Journal qfBacteriology 141, 1284. Olivo, P. D., McManus, E. J., Riggsby, W. S. and Jones, J. M. (1987). Journalof Infectious Diseases 156, 214. Pedersen, C., Gerstoft, J.. Lindhardt, B. 0. and Sindrup, J. (1987).Journal of Infectious Diseases 156, 529. Pollack, J. H. and Hashimoto, T. (1985). Journal of General Microbiology 131, 3303. Pollack, J. H. and Hashimoto, T. (1987). Journal of General Microbiology 133, 415. Pomes. R., Gil, C. and Nombela, C. (1985). Journal of General Microbiology 131, 2107. Pomes. R.. Gil, C., Cabetas, M. D. and Nombela, C. (1987).FEMS Microbiology Letrers 48, 255. Ponton, J. and Jones, J. M. (1986). Infection and Immunity 54, 864. Poulain, D., Vernes, A. and Fruit, J. (1980). Sabouraudia 18, 61. Poulain. D., Hopwood, V. and Vernes, A. (1985). In “Critical Reviews in Microbiology” (W. M. O’Leary. ed.), vol. 12, pp. 223-270. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Poulter, R. and Hanrahan, V. (1983). Journal sf Bacteriology 156, 498. Poulter, R., Hanrahan, V., JelTery, K., Markie, D., Shepherd, M. G. and Sullivan, P. A. (1982). Journal of Bacteriology 152, 969. Poulter, R. T. and Rikkerink, E. H. (1983).Journal of Bacreriology 156, 1066. Powell, B. L. and Drutz, D. J. (1983). Journal of In/l.crious Diseases 147, 359. Powell, B. L., Frey, C. L. and Drutz, D. J. (1983). 23rd Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, Abstract No. 751. Rai, Y. P. and Datta, A. (1982). Indian Journul of Biochemistry and Biophysics 19, 285. Rai, Y. P., Singh, B., Elango, N. and Datta, A. (1980). Biochimica el Biophysica Acra 614, 350. Ray, T. L., Digre, K. B. and Payne, C. D. (1984).Journal of Inoesligaiive Dermatology 83, 37. Reizenstein, P. (1987). Lancet i. 275. Riggsby, W. S., Torres-Bauza. L. J., Wills, J. W. and Townes, T. M. (1982). Molecular and Cellular Bio1og.v 2, 853. Rogers, T. J. and Balish, E. (1980). Microbiological Reuiews 44, 660. Roitt, 1. M.. Brostoff, J. and Male, D. K. (1985).“Immunology”, p. 11.9, Gower Medical, London. Rosenbluh. A., Mevarech, M., Koltin, Y. and Gorman, J. A. (1985). Molecular and General Genetics 200, 500. Ruchel. R. (1981). Biochimica et Biophjisica Aria 659, 99. Ruchel, R., Tegeler, R. and Trost. M. (1982). Sahouraudia 20, 233. Russell, P. J., Welsch, J. A., Rachlin, E. M. and McCloskey, J. A. (1987).Journul of Barreriology 169, 4393. Samaranayake, L. P., Raeside, J. M. and MacFarlane, T. W. (1984). Sabouraudia 22, 201. Sandin, R. L., Rogers, A. L., Patterson, R. J. and Beneke, E.S. (1982).InfecrionandImmunit.v 35.79. Sarachek, A. and Weber, D. A. (1984). Current Genetic.s 8, 181. Sarachek, A. and Weber, D. A. (1986). Current Genetics 10, 685. Sarachek, A,, Rhoads, D. D. and Schwarzhofl, R. H. (1981). Archives qf Microbiology 129, 1. Scherer, S. and Stevens, D. A. (1987). Journal of Clinical Microbiology 25, 675. Segal, E., Lehrer, N. and Ofek. I. (1982). Experimental Cell Biology 50, 13. Segal. E.. Soroka, A. and Schechter, A. (1984). Sabouraudia 22, 191. Shepherd, M. G. (1985). It~fectionand Immuniry 50, 541. Shepherd, M. G. and Sullivan, P. A. (1983). FEMS Microbiology Letters 17, 167. Shepherd, M. G., Chiew, Y. Y.. Ram, S. P. and Sullivan, P. A. (1980a). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 26, 2 1. Shepherd. M. G., Ghazali, H. M. and Sullivan, P. A. (1980b). E.xperimentu1 Mycology 4, 147. Shepherd, M. G., Poulter, R. T. M. and Sullivan, P. A. (1985).Annual Review of Microbiology 39, 579. Shimokawa, 0. and Nakayama, H. (1984). Sabouraudia 22, 315.
88
ASlS DATTA, K . GANESAN A N D K. NATARAJAN
Shimokawa, 0. and Nakayama, H. (1986). Journal of Medical and Veterinary Mycology 24, 165. Shimuzu, K., Kondoh. Y. and Tanaka, K. (1987). Microbiology and Immunology 31, 1045. Simonetti, N., Strippoli, V. and Cassone, A. (1974). Nature 250, 344. Singh, B. R. and Datta, A. (1978). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 84.58. Singh, B. and Datta, A. (1979a). Biochimica el Biophysica Acfa 557. 248. Singh. B. and Datta. A. (l979b). Biochemical Journal 178, 427. Singh, B. and Datta, A. (1979~).Biochimica et Biophysica Acra 583, 28. Singh, B. R., Biswas, M. and Datta, A. (1980a). Journal qf Bacteriology 144, 1. Singh. B., Gupta Roy, B., Hasan, G. and Datta, A. (1980b). Biochimica el Biophysica Acla 632,345. Slutsky. B., Buffo, J. and Soll, D. R. (1985). Science 230, 666. Slutsky. B., Staebell, M., Anderson. J., Risen, L.. Pfaller, M. and Soil, D. R. (1987). Journul of Bucreriology 169, 189. Smail, E. H. and Jones, J. M. (1984). Infection and Immuniry 45, 74. Smith. C. B. (1985). In “Candidiasis”(G. P. Bodey and V. Fainstein, eds.), pp. 53-70. Raven Press, New York. Klco, S., Fan, J.-B., Yanagida, M. and Cantor,C. R. (1987). Smith, C. L.. Matsumoto, T., Niwa, 0.. Nucleic Acids Research IS. 448 I . Snell, R. G. and Wilkins, R.J. (1986). Nucleic Acids Research 14, 4401. Snell, R. G., Hermans, I. F., Wilkins, R. J. and Corner. B. E. (1987). Nucleic Acids Research IS, 3625.
Sobel. J. D., Muller, G. and Buckley, H. R. (1984). Infection and Immunity 44, 576. Soll, D. R. ( I 986). BioE.s.say,s5, 5. Soll, D. R., Langtimm, C. J., McDowell, J., Hicks, J. and Galask, R. (1987). Journal uf Clinical Micr<~bio/ogy 25, 161 I. Staebell, M. and Soll. D. R. (1985). Journal qf General Microbiology 131, 1467. Strockbine, N. A., Largen, M. T. and Buckley, H. R. (1984a). Infection and Immunity 43, 1012. Strockbine, N. A.. Largen, M. T.. Zweibel, S. M. and Buckley, H. R. (l984b). Infection and Immunity 43, 715. Sullivan, P. A. and Shepherd, M. G. (1982). Journal o j Bacteriology 151, 1118. Sullivan, P. A., Mchugh. N. J., Romana, L. K. and Shepherd, M. G . (1984). Journal of General Microbiology 130, 2213. Sundstrom, P. M. and Kenny, G. E. (1984). Infection and Immunity 43, 850. Sundstrom, P. M. and Kenny, G. E. (1985). Infixtion and Immuniry 49, 609. Sundstrom, P. M.. Nichols, E. J. and Kenny, G. E. (1987). Infection and Immunity 55, 616. Suzuki, T., Nishibayashi, S., Kuroiwa, T.. Kanbe, T. and Tanaka, K. (1982). Journiil of Bacteriology 152, 893. Suzuki, T., Kanbe. T.. Kuroiwa. T. and Tanaka, K. (1986a). Journal ~fGeneru1MicTfJbifJ/~J~J 132, 443.
Suzuki. T., Rogers, A. L. and Magee, P. T. (1986b) Yeu.st 2, 53. Takeya, K., Nomoto, K., Matsumoto. T., Miyake, T. and Himeno. K. (1976). Clinicul and E.xperinienra1 Imntunolog~~ 25, 497. Torosantucci, A. and Cassone, A. (1983). Sabouraudiu 21, 49. Tronchin, G., Poulain, D. and Vernes, A. (1984). Archives uf Microbiology 139, 221. Valdimarsson, H. J., Higgs, J. M., Wells, R. S., Yamamura. M., Hobbs, J. R. and Holt, J. L. (1973). Cellular Immunology 6, 348. Waldorf, A. R. (1986). In “Critical Reviews in Microbiology” (W. M. O’Leary, ed.), vol. 13, pp. 133-172. C R C Press, Boca Raton, Florida. Walker, G. M.. Sullivan, P. A. and Shepherd, M. G. (1984). JiJUrnd ofGenera1 Microbiology 130, 1941.
Whelan, W. L. and Magee, P. T. (1981). Journul of Bucreriology 145, 896. Whelan, W. L. and Soll, D. R. (1982). Molecular and General Generics 187, 477. Whelan, W. L., Markie, D. M., Simpkin, K. G. and Poulter. R. M. (1985). Journal of Eacreriology 161, 1131.
Whelan. W. L., Partridge, R. M. and Magee, P. T. (1980). Molecular und Generul Generics 180, 107. Williams, C. L. and Lennon, V. A. (1986). Journal qf Experimental Medicine 164, 1043. Wood, N. C. and Nugent, K. M. (1985). Anfinticrobid Agenfs and Chemotherapy 27,692.
Circulating Ionic Currents in Micro-organisms N . A . R . GOW Department of Genetics and Microbiology. Marischal College. University of Aberdeen. Aberdeen AB9 I A S . U.K.
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . Measurement of ionic currents . . . . . . . 111. Studies on bacteria . . . . . . . . . . IV . Currents in fungi . . . . . . . . . . A. Blasrocladiella species . . . . . . . . . B. Achlya species-urrents and growth . . . . C . Achlya species-urrents and differentiation . . D. Allomyces species . . . . . . . . . E. Neurospora crassa and other filamentous fungi . V. Currents in protozoa . . . . . . . . . A . Amoebae-Amoeba and Chaos species . . . B. Ciliates-Paramecium species . . . . . . C . Slime moulds-Physurum and Dictyostelium species V1. Currents in algae . . . . . . . . . . A . Fucoid eggs-Fucus and Peluetia species . . . B. Chara and Nirellu species . . . . . . . C. Acetabularia species . . . . . . . . D. Tip-growing algae-Griflthsia and Vaucheria species E. Micrasrerias and Closterium species . . . . F. Noctiluca species . . . . . . . . . VII . Effects of applied voltage and ion gradients . . . . VIII . Ionic currents and cellular physiology . . . . . IX . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
89 90 92 93 93 96 99 100 101 102 102 103 104 105 105
107 110 111 112 112 113 114 119 120
.
I Introduction A fundamental aspect of the physiology of growth lies in the ability of a cell or group of cells to undergo spatial differentiation . Biological cells often have a sidedness or polarity so that the cell is structurally and physiologically differentiated along its length and around its perimeter. Growth itself is also commonly asymmetrical and is directed to one or a limited number of sites of the cell. This directed growth is essential to proper development and
.
ADVANCES I N MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY VOL . 30 ISBN 0-12-027730-1
.
Copyright (; 1989 by Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
90
N A. R. COW
differentiation. The ways in which cells make one end of themselves different from the other are at present rather mysterious, although a number of physiological phenomena have been found which accompany spatial differentiation of cells and have been put forward as candidates for determinants of cell polarity and positional information. In eukaryotic microorganisms, and eukaryotic cells in general, one such candidate is the circulating currents of inorganic ions or so-called “ionic currents” which many cells drive through themselves. These currents enter in one region, flow through the cytoplasm along the length of the cell and then exit at a separate location on the cell surface. The current-loop is closed in the extracellular space (periplasm, cell wall and external medium) so that the ionic current circulates through a spatially defined loop or circuit. These ionic currents reflect natural asymmetries in the arrangement of ion-transport systems in the plasma membrane. What is intriguing is that the profile of many of these ionic currents often reflects the morphological polarity of cells or the spatial differentiation of the cell or tissue (Jaffe, 1981, 1985; Nuccitelli, 1983, 1984). Ionic currents have been described in plant, animal and microbial systems, in individual cells of unicellular and multicellular organisms, in tissues and organs, and in both embryonic and mature cells. They are found during the normal course of growth and development and are associated with initiation and maintenance of growth and with regrowth and damage repair (Jaffe, 1985). Ionic currents are therefore very common in nature. Indeed, to my knowledge, there has only been one notable failure to find a current in a developmental system. What is much less clear is the rBle that these circulating ionic currents play in the physiology of the cell. Some of the clearest insights into the answer to this have come from studies on eukaryotic microbial systems, and it is these systems on which this review is primarily focused. 11. Measurement of Ionic Currents
Since ionic currents are carried by charged particles, their flow creates an electrical current and a voltage gradient around the cell. They are often studied by measuring the extracellular component of the current using an ultrasensitive vibrating micro-electrode called a vibrating probe. This instrument consists of a glass micropipette or platinum/iridium wire on the end ofwhich iselectroplated a platinum ball. The electrode iscaused to vibrate at a frequency of between 200 and 800 Hz over a distance of between 10 and 50 pm and a voltage is measured between the extremities of the vibration. The resistivity of the growth medium can be easily determined from the reciprocal of its electrical conductivity, and the inward or outward flow of current can then be calculated using a modified form of Ohm’s law (Jaffe and Nuccitelli,
CIRCULATING IONIC CURRENTS IN MICRO-ORGANISMS
91
1974). Electrophysiologists, like electricians, define the direction of current with respect to the net movement of positive electrical charge and, therefore, an inward electrical current at onz position of a cell represents a net influx of cations or a net efflux of anions. It must be emphasized, however, that the vibrating probe only measures net electrical current; it cannot discriminate between the currents and countercurrents of individual ionic species. The voltage gradients that are detected around living cells are then processed by a lock-in amplifier which detects signals only at the frequency at which the electrode is being vibrated. Consequently, the vibrating probe is able to select a very small signal from a noisy background and this improved signal-to-noise ratio gives the instrument about three orders of magnitude more sensitivity than static voltage-sensitive micro-electrodes. This greatly increased sensitivity allows detection of the electrical currents of single-celled microbes where the extracellular electric currents and electrical fields can be as small as OSpAcm-’ and 1 nVpm-’, respectively-too small to be measured with conventional electrodes. The vibrating probe is held in position with a micromanipulator and can be moved around the cell to build up a map or profile of the flow of electrical current. These extracellular measurements are therefore completely noninvasive and require only that the cell be oriented in such a way as to allow the probe to be brought into position adjacent to the cell, and that the cell be immersed in a suitable liquid medium, preferably of a high resistivity. The specimen is normally examined using an inverted microscope which may be coupled to a video camera. The vibrating probe was originally developed by Lionel Jaffe and Richard Nuccitelli (1974) and was based on glass electrodes which vibrated in one plane and a simple one-dimensional current vector. Additional information and descriptions of elaborations and modifications of this design are given by Dorn and Weisenseel (1982), Nawata (1984) and Scheffey (1988). Subsequent technical modifications and refinements have produced instruments with more robust wire electrodes which can be made to vibrate in two dimensions so that the currents in two axial planes are made simultaneously. The resultant vector is calculated by a computer, and the direction and magnitude of the current vector are displayed on a television screen while the image is stored on videotape (Freeman et al., 1985; Nuccitelli, 1986; Scheffey, 1988). This two-dimensional probe system greatly facilitates examination of specimens with a complex architecture. In most cases, it is desirable to know something of the ionic composition of the current. This is usually done by performing a series of experiments where bathing media are exchanged for ones in which individual ions are first omitted and then restored. If removal of an ion from the external medium causes a decrease in the measured current density it may be inferred that the ion was carrying a proportion of the original current. Ion-substitution
92
N.A. R. COW
experiments only provide an indirect indication of the chemical nature of the electrical current and are least satisfactory when proton currents are considered. Modulation of the external proton concentration can only be achieved by changing the pH value of the medium, and this may have biological as well as electrophysiological consequences. It is possible to study ion currents by measuring the external ionic gradients that result from the flow of an ionic current using extracellular ion-selective micro-electrodes. For example, in the water mould Achlya bisexualis, a proton current enters the hyphal tip. The external medium in the region where protons enter the hypha is made alkaline; where protons are expelled the medium is acidic (Gow et al., 1984).The external pH gradient would therefore seem to be a manifestation of the protonic electrical current. Recently, W. Kuhlreiber and L. F. Jaffe (unpublished observation) developed a vibrating calcium electrode which can detect extracellular calcium-ion gradients generated by calcium-ion currents. Finally, the directional flow of electrical current can also be determined from membrane-potential measurements using intracellular micro-electrodes. The ionic composition can be inferred from the sensitivity of the membrane potential to changes in the external concentration of individual ions. See, for example, the studies of Van Brunt et al. (1982) and Kropf (1986) which are described later in this chapter. 111. Studies on Bacteria
Prokaryotes may not have transcellular ion currents. The only recorded failures to detect currents have been in a study of cyanobacterial filaments of Oscillatoria princeps, Anabaenaflos-aquae and Anabaena cylindricu (Jaffe and Walsby, 1985).No current was found around developing heterocysts of A.,fiosaquae or around gliding filaments of 0. princeps and A. cylindricu. Hader (1978) reported large voltages of around 20 mV along filaments of the gliding cyanobacterium Phorrnidium uncinatum which were detected by measuring the voltage across a narrow constriction as the filament passed through. This large voltage would be expected to support a current in the order of lOpAcrn-’ along the filament. Jaffe and Walsby (1985) failed to find such a current in gliding cyanobacteria. The voltages measured by Hader (1978) may have been diffusion potentials generated by formation of a transient gradient of pH value or some other charged secretion in the slime rather than flow of electrical current through and around the cyanobacterial filaments. Bacteria other than cyanobacteria are too small to be examined with vibrating probes since cells of diameters much less than lOpm are unlikely to be able to generate currents of a detectable density. Harold and Van Brunt (1977) showed that Srreptococcusfaecalis was capable of growth without a membrane potential
CIRCULATING IONIC CURRENTS IN MICRO-ORGANISMS
93
when exposed to the potassium/proton ionophore valinomycin. The growth medium had to be of a pH value which matched the normal cytoplasmic pH value, and of a composition that allowed the cell to maintain high concentrations of internal potassium ions and to obtain nutrients in the absence of ion-driven transport. However, the cells clearly did not require a membrane potential for growth or division. Since currents require a driving voltage across the cell membrane, we must conclude that these bacteria d o not need a current for the processes of growth and division. IV. Currents in Fungi A.
Blastocladiella
SPECIES
This fungus is a water mould of the phylum Chytridiomycota and consists of a spheroid thallus which is anchored to the substrate of its aquatic environment by a series of slender branching rhizoids (Fig. 1). The thallus differentiates into a sporangium which releases swimming zoospores through a discharge papilla at its apex. The zoospores are chemotactic and eventually settle and germinate
BlastccladMa
Pelvetia
Ach&a/tU?urospara
Acetabularia
Allomyces
Cbura/Nite//o
A Vaucberia
Amoeba
Noctifuca
FIG. 1. Circulating ionic currents from representative eukaryotic micro-organisms as described in the text. The arrows indicate the movement of positive electrical current. The direction of growth or movement of the hyphae of species of Achlya, Neurospora and Allomyccs of cells of Amoeba, Pelvetia, Acetabularia, Vaucheria and Micrasterias and plasmodium of fhysarum are, in each organism, towards the upper end of the figure.
94
N A R GOW
on a suitable substrate thereby perpetuating the life cycle. Stump et al. (1980) showed that positive electrical current entered the rhizoid region and exited from the thallus and sporangium. When sporulation was initiated by replacing the growth medium with non-nutrient buffer, the current pattern reversed so that current now entered the sporangium. This reversed pattern was maintained until the last 45 min prior to zoospore discharge when outward current was again found at the sporangium. As zoospores were released, the current declined to zero by the time zoospores had all been discharged. Ion-substitution experiments showed the current accompanying vegetative growth of the thallus was insensitive to removal of all of the major inorganic ions other than calcium ions and protons. Removal of calcium ions induced rapid vacuolation and aberrant growth as well as fluctuations in the direction and magnitude of the current. By a process of elimination, protons were left as the most likely current-carrying ion. The hypothesis that a proton current might influence the site of rhizoid formation and subsequent rhizoid growth had also been suggested in previous experiments where glass fibres coated with the proton ionophores tetrachlorosalicylanilide and compound 1799 were found to cause orientation of the rhizoids towards the source of ionophore (Harold and Harold, 1980). Gradients of the calcium ionophores A23187 and ionomycin, and various other types of inhibitors, did not affect the direction of rhizoid growth. But rhizoids were also oriented strongly by gradients of phosphate and amino acids, but not glucose, potassium ions or calcium ions (Harold and Harold, 1980). Proton currents therefore entered the rhizoid during growth. Proton leakage, induced using ionophores, caused orientation of the rhizoids towards the site of maximum proton entry. In ensuing work, Van Brunt et al. (1982) investigated the genesis of the circulating current using intracellular micro-electrodes inserted into the thallus. In contrast to the findings of Slayman and his collaborators (Slayman, 1965a,b; Slayman et al., 1973) who found the membrane potential of the ascomycete Neurosporci crassa was due mainly to an electrogenic proton pump, the membrane potential in Blastocladiella emersonii was shown to be set by outward diffusion of potassium ions (Van Brunt er al., 1982). This was suggested from experiments in which the membrane potential was measured in media containing different concentrations of potassium ions. When the external potassium ion concentration was high, few of the high internal potassium ions diffused out of the cell, and the membrane potential was correspondingly low. When the potassium-ion gradient across the membrane was increased by lowering the external potassium-ion concentration, the membrane potential increased correspondingly. Potassium-ion efflux from the thallus(Fig. 2) was calculated to be large enough to account for the size of the outward currents measured with the vibrating probe. On the basis of these observations, it was suggested that potassium ions were accumulated by an
CIRCULATING IONIC CURRENTS IN MICRO-ORGANISMS
95
H+aa
Elostocladiella emersanii
Achka bisexwk
H CO;
ATP K+ Ca2+
Pebtia hstyiata
Chara cwralha
FIG. 2. Proposed mechanisms for generation of four circulating currents in four aquatic eukaryotic micro-organisms as described in the text. Mechanisms are shown for sporangia of Blastocladiella emersonii, hyphae of Achlya bisexualis, zygotes of Pelvetia fastigiata and internodal cells of Chara corralina.
electroneutral pump in the thallus which exchanged potassium ions for protons, while the inward current at the rhizoids maintained the overall charge balance was due to localized proton leakage (Fig. 2). The rhizoid of B. emersonii is therefore a site at which protons leak into the cell. Presumably, proton carriers, such as proton symporters, are localized at this site. Kropf and Harold (1982) showed that the rhizoids of this organism were also sites at which nutrients were taken up. These results again re-inforce the observation that the rhizoids of B. emersonii are chemotropic for
96
N A. R. COW
phosphate and amino acids (Harold and Harold, 1980). The