Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY VOLUME 41
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY Edited by
R. K. POOLE Department of Molecular Biology and Biotechnology The Krebs Institute f o r Biomolecular Research The University of Shefield Firth Court, Western Bank Shefield SIO 2TN, UK
Volume 41
ACADEMIC PRESS A Harcaurt Science and Technology Company
San Diego San Francisco New York Boston London Sydney Tokyo
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright 0 1999 by ACADEMIC PRESS All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Academic Press 24-28 Oval Road, London NW I 7DX. UK http:Nwww.hbuk.co.uWap/ Academic Press A Harcourt Science and Technology Company
525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495. USA http://www.apnet.com ISBN 0-12-027741-7 A catalogue for this book is available from the British Library
Typeset by M Rules, London, UK Printed in Great Britain by MPG Books Ltd, Bodmin, Cornwall 990001020304MP98765432 1
Contents
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 41 .................................
ix
Factors Affecting the Production of L-Phenylacetylcarbinol by Yeast: A Case Study Alison L. Oliver. Bruce N . Anderson and Felicity A. Roddick Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 2 . Biochemical production of L-phenylacetylcarbinol . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 3. Development and optimization of the fermentation process . . . . . . 11 4 . An industrial process for the production of L-phenylacetylcarbinol . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 5. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
Fungal Production of Citric and Oxalic Acid: Importance in Metal Speciation. Physiology and Biogeochemical Processes Geoffrey M . Gadd 1. 2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7. 8.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 Metal chemistry of oxalic and citric acids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 Fungal biosynthesis of oxalic acid and calcium oxalate formation . 53 Role of metals and oxalate in lignocellulose degradation and plant pathogenesis ...................................... 61 Catabolism of oxalic acid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Fungal biosynthesis of citric acid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Fungal organic acid production and metal biogeochemistry . . . . . . 68 Fungal organic acid production and metal biotechnology . . . . . . . . 76
vi
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
78 79
Bacterial Viability and Culturability Michael R. Barer and Colin R. Harwood 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 The ‘viable but non-culturable’ (VBNC) hypothesis . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 ‘As yet uncultured’ (AYU) bacteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 ‘New’methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Factors influencing the outcome of culturability tests . . . . . . . . . . 1 1 1 Should bacterial viability be assessed at the individual or community level? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 124 8. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126 126 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Histidine Protein Kinase Superfamily Thorsten W. Grebe and Jeffry B . Stock 1. 2. 3. 4.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Histidine protein kinase subfamilies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cognate receiver domains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Domain shuffling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
139 197 206 211 214 214
Bacterial Tactic Responses Judith P. Armitage Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 231 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 231 232 2 . What is meant by ‘bacterial taxis’? ........................ 3 . History . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 233 4 . How Bacteria swim and glide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 5. The chemosensory pathway of E . coli ...................... 238 6. Responses to electron acceptors and light . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .263 7 . What is the role of tactic responses in natural environments? . . . .269 8 . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 277 Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 277 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 278
vi i
CONTENTS
The Bacterial Flagellar Motor
Richard M . Berry and Judith P. Armitage Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. The flagellar structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Flagellar motor function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Models of the flagellar motor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
292 292 296 310 322 328 329 329
Authorindex . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Subject index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
339 363
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contributors to Volume 41
Bruce N. ANDERSON, Department of Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University, GPO Box 2476V, Melbourne, Victoria 3001, Australia (
[email protected]) Judith P. ARMITAGE, Microbiology Unit, Department of Biochemistry, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3QU, UK (
[email protected]) Michael R. BARER, Department of Microbiology and Immunology, The Medical School, University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Framlington Place, Newcastle-upon-Tyne NE2 4HH, UK (
[email protected]) Richard M. BERRY, The Randall Institute, King’s College London, 26-29 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5RL, UK Geoffrey M. GADD,Department of Biological Sciences, University of Dundee, Dundee DD 1 4HN, UK (
[email protected]) Thorsten W. GREBE, Department of Molecular Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA (
[email protected]) Colin HARWOOD, Department of Microbiology and Immunology, The Medical School, University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Framlington Place, Newcastle-upon-Tyne NE2 4HH, UK CSL Limited, 45 Popular Road, Parkville 3052, Alison L. OLIVER, Australia
X
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 41
Felicity A. RODDICK, Department of Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University, GPO Box 2476V, Melbourne, Victoria 300 1, Australia (
[email protected]) Jeffry B. STOCK, Department of Molecular Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544,USA (
[email protected])
Factors Affecting the Production of L-Phenylacetylcarbinol by Yeast: A Case Study Alison L. Oliver, Bruce N. Anderson and Felicity A. Roddick Department of Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering, RMIT University. GPO Box 2476V Melbourne, victoria 3000, Australia
ABSTRACT
L-Phenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC)is the precursor for L-ephedrine and Dpseudoephedrine, alkaloids possessing a-and 0-adrenergic activity. The most commonly used method for production of L-PAC is a biological method whereby the enzyme pyruvate decarboxylase (PDC) decarboxylates pyruvate and then condenses the product with added benzaldehyde. The process may be undertaken by either whole cells or purified PDC. If whole cells are used, the biomass may be grown and allowed to synthesize endogenous pyruvate, or the cells may be used as a catalyst only, with both pyruvate and benzaldehyde being added. Several yeast species have been investigated with regard to L-PACproducing potential; the most commonly used organisms are strains of Sacchuromyces cerevisiue and Cundidu utilis. It was found that initial high production rates did not necessarily result in the highest final yields. Researchers then examined ways of improving the productivity of the process. The substrate, benzaldehyde, and the product, L-PAC,as well as the by-products, were found to be toxic to the biomass. Methods examined to reduce toxicity include modification of benzaldehyde dosing regimes, immobilization of biomass or purified enzymes, modification of benzaldehyde solubility and the use of twophase reaction systems. Various means of modifying metabolism to enhance enzyme activity, relevant metabolic pathways and yield have been examined. Methods investigated include the use of respiratory quotient to influence pyruvate production and induce fermentative activity, reduced aeration to increase PDC activity, and carbohydrate feeding to modify glycolytic enzyme activity. The effect of temperature on L-PACyield has been examined to identify conditions ADVANCES IN MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY VOL 41
ISBN 0-12-027741-7
Copyright 0 1999 Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
2
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
which provide the optimal balance between L-PAC and benzyl alcohol production, and L-PAC inactivation. However, relatively little work has been undertaken on the effect of medium composition on L-PACyield. Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Biochemical production of L-phenylacetyl carbinol ....................... 2.1. Mechanism of L-PACproduction ...................... 2.2. Pyruvate decarboxylase and provision of substrates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. Alcohol dehydrogenase and reaction by-products .................... 3. Development and optimization of the fermentation process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Selection of a high-yielding producer organism ...................... 3.2. Physicochemical conditions and their effect on L-PACproduction . . . . . . . 3.3. Physiological condition of cells for optimum L-PAC production . . . . . . . . . 3.4. Nutrient effects in L-PAC production ............................... 3.5. Production of L-PACby batch, fed-batch or continuous fermentation . . . . 3.6. The use of additives to modify metabolic activity .................... 3.7. Reduction of the toxic effects of substrate, product and by-product . . . . . 3.8. Other methods for influencing L-PACproduction ..................... 4. An industrial process for the production of L-phenylacetylcarbinol . . . . . . . . . . 5. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 3 4 4 6 9 11 12 13 16 18 20 21 23 33 34 39 40
ABBREVIATIONS
ADH BCD CSL 2,4-D DMF Ki kl'a
Km L-PAC NAA PCO, PDC PEG PO, RQ TPP YADH
Alcohol dehydrogenase P-Cy clodextrin Corn steep liquor 2,4-Dichlorophenoxy acetic acid N,N-Dimethylformamide Inhibition constant - the concentration of a compound at which a reaction is inhibited by 50% Volumetric liquid mass transfer coefficient for oxygen Michaelis constant - the substrate concentration at which the reaction velocity is 50% of its maximum L-Phenylacetylcarbinol a-Naphthoxy acetic acid Partial pressure of carbon dioxide (millibar) Pyruvate decarboxylase Polyethylene glycol Partial pressure of oxygen (% saturation) Respiratory quotient Thiamine pyrophosphate Yeast alcohol dehydrogenase
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
3
1. INTRODUCTION
L-Phenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC)is used as a substrate in the manufacture of Lephedrine and D-pseudoephedrine, alkaloids possessing a-and P-adrenergic activity (Long and Ward, 1989b). Ephedrine is used in the treatment of conditions including hypotension and asthma, while pseudoephedrine, an optical isomer of ephedrine, is used mainly as a nasal decongestant in cold and influenza medications. These alkaloids can be produced by one of two methods: direct extraction from plant material (Ephedra spp.) or synthesis using L-PAC as a precursor. Until early this century, plant material was the sole source of both ephedrine and pseudoephedrine; however, the total alkaloid content in Ephedra spp. is generally low, the highest concentration being approximately 2.5% by weight, and occurs as a mixture of ephedrine and pseudoephedrine. The alkaloid content is also subject to seasonal variation, requiring the collection of large amounts of plant material followed by time- and labour-intensive processing (Morton, 1977). In contrast, the synthesis of ephedrine or pseudoephedrine via L-PACis less labour intensive and independent of climatic conditions, enabling a continuous supply of product of guaranteed quality. While there are several chemical methods for L-PAC synthesis (Culik et al., 1984; Nikolova et al., 1991), the usual method of production is via yeast fermentation. Production via fermentation is preferable to chemical synthesis because of the mild conditions used, and because the pharmacologically active laevorotatory form (L-PAC) is produced whereas chemically synthesized PAC is a racemic mixture (D-PACand L-PAC).D-PACcannot be used to prepare L-ephedrine or D-pseudoephedrine. In addition, the waste products of other processes, e.g. molasses, can be used as raw materials in the L-PAC fermentation medium, after which the spent broth is amenable to biological waste treatment. The final ephedrine and pseudoephedrine concentrations produced by synthetic routes are similar to those present in plant extracts. This review is divided into three sections: first in the specific processes involved in the conversion of benzaldehyde to L-PAC are examined and the background on the enzymes involved in the process is provided; in the second the effects of manipulating fermentation parameters on yeast behaviour are examined; and in the third an industrial process used for the production of LPAC is outlined (Oliver et al., 1997).
4
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
2. BIOCHEMICAL PRODUCTION OF LPHENYLACETYLCARBINOL 2.1. Mechanism of L-PACProduction
The biochemical production of L-PAC was first demonstrated in the early 1920s by Neuberg and co-workers who described its formation after the addition of benzaldehyde to a culture of actively fermenting top yeast (McKenzie, 1936). They proposed two possible mechanisms: the first, thought to be the most likely of the two scenarios, was the conversion of pyruvate by carboxylase to an activated acetaldehyde followed by the enzymic combination of benzaldehyde and the activated acetaldehyde by carboligase; the second proposal was the joining of benzaldehyde and pyruvate via a carboligase, followed by decarboxylation of the complex using carboxylase (McKenzie, 1936). Pyruvate decarboxylase (PDC) is now known to be responsible for both nonoxidative decarboxylation and a carboligase reaction, which results in the production of a-hydroxy ketones (Pohl, 1997). The production of L-PACby yeast was considered to be analogous to the production of acetoin (methylacetylcarbinol)which was demonstrated by Green el al. in 1942 using a crude yeast enzyme extract. Weight was added to the hypothesis that acetaldehyde was an intermediate in the production of acetoin when Gross and Werkman ( 1947) demonstrated the incorporation of isotopically labelled acetaldehydeinto acetoin by a dried yeast ‘juice’.Acetoin was not considered to be a normal fermentation product by Happold and Spencer (1952), although it is a known product of wine yeast fermentation (Romano and Suzzi, 1996).Happold and Spencer’s proposal is supported by Hohmann (1997), who suggested that the production of acetoin is ‘probably not important under physiological conditions,’owing to the low concentrations of acetaldehyde present in yeast cytosol. Happold and Spencer found that the presence of additional acetaldehyde resulted in the formation of acetoin. Green et al. (1942) found that the production of significant quantities of acetoin required the presence of both acetaldehyde and pyruvate rather than either in isolation. The role of a single enzyme for the production of acetoin was advanced by Juni (1952) who was unable to separate his brewer’s yeast extract into separate fractions for pyruvate decarboxylation and for acetoin formation. He later introduced the concept of a two-site mechanism for the formation of acetoin (Juni, 1961). Although it was previously assumed that PDC catalysed the condensation of benzaldehyde and pyruvate to L-PAC,confirmation did not occur until BringerMeyer and Sahm (1988) demonstrated the production of L-PACby purified PDC from both Zymomonas mobilis and Saccharomyces carlsbergensis. Their results were confirmed by Cardillo et al. (199 I ) who showed that benzaldehyde was condensed more readily than other substituted aldehydes by
5
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
Saccharomyces spp. Although Fuganti et al. (1988) questioned whether the enzyme responsible for L-PAC production was known, they reconfirmed the ability of baker's yeast to produce L-PAC and considered the mechanism of LPAC production to be analogous to the production of acetoin, thereby implying that PDC was essentially responsible for L-PACproduction. Crout et al. (199 1) provided definitive proof of the ability of purified yeast PDC to convert a range of aldehydes to ketols, including L-PAC, by following the reactions using 'H-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Kren et al. (1993) also demonstrated the production of various ketols by purified yeast PDC. PDC, located in the cytosol, catalyses the irreversible conversion of pyruvate to acetaldehyde with the resultant loss of a molecule of CO,. The reaction requires the cofactors thiamine pyrophosphate (TPP) and a magnesium ion, which is thought to act as a link between the apoenzyme and the thiamine pyrophosphate (Pohl, 1997).
CH,CHO + CO, Acetaldehyde
CH,COCOOH PYruvate decarboxY1ase, Pyruvate TTP, Mg2+
(1)
PDC then catalyses the condensation of acetaldehyde and pyruvate, forming acetoin:
,
CH,COCOOH + CH,CHO PDC CH,CHOHCOCH, Pyruvate Acetaldehyde p p , Mg2+ Acetoin
+ CO,
(2)
After the formation of acetaldehyde according to Equation 1, L-PAC is formed (analogous with Equation 2) by the condensation of acetaldehyde with added benzaldehyde:
,
PDC C6H,CHOHCOCH, CH,COCOOH + C,H,CHO PAC Pyruvate Benzaldehyde p p , Mg2+
+ C02
(3)
L-PACis considered to be a product of the stationary phase of growth (Liew et al.,1995). In the process employed by Oliver et al. (1997), the pyruvate consumed in the reaction is generated by the yeast via glycolysis and is allowed to accumulate exogenously during the exponential phase of growth. Commercial processes are generally divided into two stages: a first stage where the yeast is grown and pyruvate is accumulated, followed by a bioconversion stage where benzaldehyde is added and L-PAC produced. For fermentations where pregrown yeast is used as a catalyst only, direct pyruvate supplementation is required in the bioconversion phase.
6
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
2.2. Pyruvate Decarboxylase and Provision of Substrates
As described above, PDC is the enzyme responsible for the production of LPAC. PDC is usually found to exist as either dimers or tetramers whereby the active PDC holoenzyme generally exists as a tetramer, while the apoenzyme exists as a dimer (Pohl, 1997). The existence of the dimer and tetramer forms is pH dependent. In yeast, PDC has been reported to exist only as a tetramer in the pH range 5.5-6.5, as both tetramers and dimers at pH values up to 9.5, and dimers only at pH > 9.5 (Pohl, 1997). However, Hohmann (1997) has reported the existence of PDC only in the form of dimers at a pH of 8.4. PDC from 2. mobifis has been found to exist only in the form of tetramers (Pohl, 1997). While PDC subunits were thought previously to have different compositions, they are now known to be identical (Hohmann, 1997). A total of six PDC genes has been identified in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, of which three are structural genes (PDC 1, PDC5 and PDC6) and the remaining three are considered to be genes related to expression of PDC (PDC2, PDC3, PDC4) (Flikweert etal., 1996; Hohmann, 1997; Pohl, 1997; ter Schure et al., 1998).A single structural gene coding for PDC has been identified in 2. mobilis (Pohl, 1997). While the majority of work in this area appears to have been performed on S. cerevisiae, genes for PDC have been identified in a number of yeast species, not including Candida utilis. Flikweert and co-workers undertook studies to assess the role of each of the isoenzymes in overall PDC activity, and found that the expression of each of the isoenzymes in S. cerevisiae differed. Using batch culture with either ethanol or glucose as carbon substrate, PDC 1 was expressed constitutively while PDC5 was induced in the presence of glucose. PDC6 was present at insignificant levels. These findings were echoed in a review on pyruvate decarboxylases by Hohmann ( 1 997), who indicated that only PDC 1 and PDC5 played an apparent role in sugar catabolism, with 80-90% and 10-20% of total PDC activity being attributed to these two genes, respectively, for glucose-grown biomass. In addition to the production of acetoin, S. cerevisiae PDC has been found to be involved in the production of fuse1 oils, which are flavour compounds present in alcoholic beverages and bread. Fuse1 oils are produced by the decarboxylation of branched chain 2-0x0 acids, derived from aromatic amino acids. The products are then dehydrogenated by alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH). The activity of PDC with the 2-0x0 acids is significantly lower than for pyruvate (ter Schure et al., 1998). Production of novel aldehyde analogues is discussed later in this chapter. PDC activity can be induced and manipulated both by the degree of aeration supplied to the culture and by the choice of carbohydrate substrate in the medium. PDC activity is required to enable glycolytic flux only under anaerobic conditions; therefore, a reduction in aeration should result in the induction of PDC. Both Sims and co-workers (1991) and Rogers et al. (1997) have
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
7
demonstrated that an increase in C. utilis PDC activity occurs when oxygen concentration is reduced. Such a response is highly beneficial for the production of L-PAC.However, both groups of researchers found that the activity of ADH, responsible for generation of unwanted by-products, exceeds that of PDC under anaerobic or partially anaerobic conditions. The effect of aeration conditions on yeast physiology is discussed later in this chapter. Induction of PDC activity by carbohydrate source is dependent on the yeast species involved and the carbohydrate source supplied. Glucose is one substrate capable of inducing glycolytic enzymes, especially PDC. A number of workers have demonstrated that the addition of glucose to cultures results in an increase in the level of PDC activity. Maitra and Lob0 (1971) found that the addition of glucose as a pulse to Saccharomyces spp. cultures resulted in an increase in the production of glycolytic enzymes, including PDC, following a short lag period. The medium used for growth was carbohydrate-free and acetate was used as the carbon source. Similarly, Schmitt and Zimmerman (1982) demonstrated an 18-fold increase in the PDC activity of S. cerevisiae after glucose was added to a shake flask culture grown on ethanol as the sole carbohydrate source. These results are in agreement with those of Harrison (1972) and Sims et al. (1991). Sims and co-workers also demonstrated the reversible nature of PDC activation. They showed that, under anaerobic conditions, when deprived of glucose (by centrifuging and resuspending biomass in glucose-free medium) the PDC activity of C. utilis was reduced by 50%. PDC activity was restored by the addition of glucose to the medium under anaerobic conditions; however, if the culture was aerated in addition to glucose supplementation, there was no change in PDC activity. Such enzyme activation does not occur for all carbohydrate types. When yeast species are grown anaerobically on glycosides which give the Kluyver effect, PDC activity is reduced compared with glycosides, such as glucose, which can be metabolized anaerobically (Sims and Barnett, 1991). As a result of their research, they found that PDC activity may be rate limiting in anaerobic conditions. This finding is in agreement with that of van Urk et al. (1989). PDC is a substrate-pyruvate-activated enzyme (Hubner et al., 1978; Hohmann, 1997), which is also allosterically inhibited by inorganic phosphate (Boiteux and Hess, 1970). Boiteux and Hess reported an increase in the Michaelis constant (K,) of purified PDC from S. carlsbergensis from 1.3 mM in the absence of inorganic phosphate to approximately 11 m~ in the presence of 100 nm phosphate. The inhibitory effect was determined to be competitive in nature, the variation in K , having no effect on the maximum activity of the enzyme. The sensitivity of PDC to inhibition by phosphate was determined to be of the same order of magnitude as its sensitivity to activation by pyruvate. Saccharomyces spp. and C. utilis are commonly used for the production of L-PAC;however, in early work, little was done to compare enzyme activities directly. The PDCs of S. cerevisiae and C. utilis were compared by van Dijken
8
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
and Scheffers (1986), and van Urk et al. (1989). They determined that the activity of PDC from S. cerevisiae was approximately eight times that of PDC from C. urilis, although the PDC from the former was determined to be more sensitive to inhibition by phosphate. With respect to phosphate, the PDC from C. utilis displayed similar K , values to that from S. carlsbergensis, namely 3.6 mM in the absence of phosphate, and 11 mM in the presence of 100 mM phosphate. In contrast, PDC from S. cerevisiae exhibited K , values of 3.0 mM in the absence of phosphate and 48 mM in the presence of 100 mM phosphate. Consequently, the availability of phosphate plays an important role in the activity of PDC and thus PDC productivity. A combination of reduction in the cytosolic concentration of phosphate and increased pyruvate concentrations was proposed by van Urk et al. (1989) as contributing factors to increased PDC activity after pulsing the culture with glucose. The process used by Oliver et al. (1 997) involved pulsing with molasses midway through the fermentation, hence a similar increase in PDC activity would most probably have resulted. Significant work has been undertaken by Rogers and co-workers (Chow et al., 1995; Shin and Rogers, 1996a; Rogers et al., 1997) to evaluate the kinetics of PDC from C. utilis in both purified form and in whole cells. They recorded PDC activities of 0.85-0.9 U/mg protein for whole, stationary-phase biomass after growth in batch culture. After partial purification, Chow et al. (1995) recorded an increase in PDC activity to 4.8 U/mg protein, which was comparable with commercially obtained PDC. Pohl (1997) suggests that a specific activity in the range of 45-60 U/mg can be achieved for PDC purified from yeast and plants. Rogers et al. (1997) reported a number of kinetic parameters for purified PDC from C. utilis. The K , values for benzaldehyde and pyruvate were 42 m M (4°C pH 7.0) and 2.2 mM (25°C pH 6.0) respectively, with concentrations in excess of 10 m~ pyruvate required to give saturating conditions. The inhibition for acetaldehyde was approximately 20 m ~while , substrate inhiconstant (Ki) bition was evident at benzaldehyde concentrations in excess of 180 mM ( 19.1 gm Chow et al. (1995) undertook studies to determine the kinetics of deactivation of PDC by benzaldehyde. They determined that the deactivation followed first-order kinetics for benzaldehyde; however, the response was not linearly related to time for benzaldehyde concentrations between 100 and 300 mM. In much of the work undertaken on production of L-PAC, PDC has been found not to be the factor limiting L-PAC production (Vojtisek and Netrval, 1982; Shin and Rogers, 1996a; Tripathi et al., 1997) since some PDC activity remained at the end of the fermentations. Rather, both Tripathi and co-workers ( I 997) and Vojtisek and Netrval(1982) found that low pyruvate concentration in the medium limited yields. Glycolytic enzymes were implicated as potentially rate limiting by both Tripathi and co-workers, and Nikolova and Ward (1991).
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
9
Based on the information above, the conditions used by Oliver et al. (1997) (see Section 4) appear to be highly conducive to the production of L-PAC. Pyruvate is present in significant quantities and, according to Hohmann ( 1 997), the capacity of pyruvate dehydrogenase is limited compared with that of PDC, thereby restricting metabolism of pyruvate via the only alternative route. Further, the biomass is supplemented with carbohydrate in combination with reduced aeration. The work of Sims and Barnett (199 1) and Sims et al. (199 1) indicates that the combination of these two conditions is conducive to the induction of PDC.
2.3. Alcohol Dehydrogenase and Reaction By-products
The complete conversion of added benzaldehyde to L-PACis not achieved in whole cell systems because of the formation of by-products, namely benzyl alcohol and benzoic acid (Smith and Hendlin, 1953; Ose and Hironaka, 1957; Agarwal et al., 1987; Long and Ward, 1989b; Mahmoud et al., 1990a,b,c; Tripathi et al., 1991). Minor by-products include acetoin, butane-2,3-dione, 1phenylpropan-2,3-dione, 1-phenyl-1,2-propandioland 2-hydroxypropiophenone (Pohl, 1997). Benzaldehyde volatilizes readily, which may lead to some losses, even in fermenters equipped with exhaust air condensers. The main by-product of the L-PACprocess, however, is benzyl alcohol with reports of up to 50% of added benzaldehyde being converted to benzyl alcohol (Ose and Hironaka, 1957). For each gram of added benzaldehyde converted to benzyl alcohol rather than to L-PAC,the potential L-PACyield is reduced by approximately 1.4 g. The benzyl alcohol yields obtained in the study by Oliver et al. (Oliver, 1996; Oliver et al., 1997) were up to 4 g/l, equivalent to lost L-PACproduction of nearly 6 g/l. It is clear that minimizing the formation of benzyl alcohol production during L-PAC fermentations has the potential to increase the final L-PACyield significantly.This is further demonstrated by the work of Shin and Rogers (1996a,b) and Rogers et al. (1997), who performed a mass balance on the process for production of L-PAC using purified PDC. They were able to account for 98% of benzaldehyde consumption, the remaining 2%being attributed to evaporative losses and experimental error. All of the pyruvate added was accounted for as PAC, acetoin, free acetaldehyde or residual pyruvate. It appeared that further yields of L-PAC may have been achieved had additional benzaldehyde been added, as there was residual PDC activity after 6 h. Benzyl alcohol production from benzaldehyde is facilitated by the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase, as shown in Equation 4. C,H,CHO NADH+H+ Benzaldehyde
ADH
C,H5CH,0H +NAD+ (4) Benzyl alcohol
10
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
The production of benzyl alcohol, in addition to a range of other aromatic alcohols, by pure ADH has been demonstrated by Long et al. (1989), although Bowen et al. (1 986) had previously investigated the inhibition of yeast ADH by aldehydes and found that their enzyme preparation displayed no reactivity with benzaldehyde. The reaction is reversible, although equilibrium constants ( K , ) of lo4 at pH 7.0 (Conn et al., 1987) and 7 x 10-9-1.8 x lo-'' (Jones, 198d) have been reported. In view of the reported equilibrium constants, the formation of ethanol, or benzyl alcohol, would be highly favoured under the fermentation conditions used for L-PACproduction if the equilibrium constants were similar for all ADH isoenzymes. The inhibition of both fermentation and growth by ethanol have been demonstrated to be completely independent and non-competitive (Aiba et al., 1968; Brown et al., 1981; Pascual et al., 1988). There are differences in ADH activities between Crabtree-positive and Crabtree-negative yeasts, with the ADH activity of Crabtree-negative yeasts, e.g. C. utilis, being significantly lower than that of Crabtree-positive yeasts, e.g. S. cerevisiae. van Urk et al. (1990) measured activities of 1.61-2.91 U/mg protein for C. utilis and 5.7-7.0 U/mg protein for S. cerevisiae. Accordingly, with respect to reported ADH activities, it would appear that Crabtree-negative yeasts such as C. utilis would be better suited to L-PAC production than Crabtree-positive yeasts. However, the activity of PDC from C. utilis ( 0 . 0 8 4 1 1 Wing protein) was much lower than that of S. cerevisiue (0.58-1.12 U/mg protein). Further, in contrast to S. cerevisiae, the PDC activity of C. urilis did not increase when the culture was pulsed with glucose. The latter finding is in contrast to that of Sims et al. (1991) who found that PDC was synthesized de novo in response to glucose pulsing. Verduyn et al. (1988) compared the substrate specificities of ADH purified from freshly grown Hansenula polymorpha and C. utilis with commercially obtained ADH purified from S. cerevisiae. They found that the ADHs from both H. polymorpha and C. utilis were capable of reducing methylglyoxal and displayed greater activity than the ADH from S. cerevisiae when butanol was the substrate. The activity of the enzyme from C. utilis was actually higher for butanol than for ethanol under optimal pH conditions, unlike the enzyme from Succharornyces. A further dissimilarity to the S. cerevisiae enzyme was the maintenance of the degree of activity with increasing chain length of substrate: ADH from C. utilis was found to be reactive with 2-propanol and 2-butanol. While the ADH from C. utilis appears to have several distinct advantages over the enzyme from S. cerevisiae, the affinity of the former for ethanol is considerably lower than that of the latter, although this is counterbalanced by its greater stability. Verduyn and co-workers noted that three isoenzymes existed in S. cerevisiae, two being cytoplasmic and one mitochondrial. However, work undertaken by Nikolova and Ward (1991) using mutants lacking all three of these isoenzymes showed that some ADH activity remained. ADH-IV activity
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
11
has since been demonstrated in S. cerevisiue and is thought to have potential for the production of benzyl alcohol (Rogers et ul., 1997). Other aldehydes for which whole baker’s yeast has been found to be reactive include a,a,a-trifluorotolualdehyde, nitrobenzaldehyde, anisaldehyde, fluorobenzaldehyde, tolualdehyde and chlorobenzaldehyde. All of these aldehydes were used as substrates and converted to the corresponding alcohols when substituted in either the ortho-, metu- or puru-positions (Nikolova and Ward, 1994b), although increasing substrate hydrophobicity reduced yeast catalytic activity. These substrates were tested in a two-phase medium of hexane containing 2% (v/v) water. While activity was demonstrated for all of these substrates, the conversion of benzaldehyde to benzyl alcohol proceeded at almost the highest rate. Only the rate of conversion of p-nitrobenzaldehyde was higher, while the lowest rate was for a,a,a-trifluoro-o-tolualdehyde. Other studies by Leskovac et ul. (1997) found that aliphatic aldehydes were the most efficiently reduced by yeast ADH (YADH), followed by branchedchain aldehydes and lastly by aromatic aldehydes. Leskovac and co-workers used 4-dimethylamino-truns-cinnamaldehydeand chloroacetaldehyde as substrates; the YADH was of unspecified origin. The conversion of chloroacetaldehyde was essentially irreversible, the first known instance of a near-irreversible reaction involving YADH. The reduction of acetaldehyde to ethanol by ADH is an important metabolic mechanism in yeasts because of its role in the regeneration of NAD+, an electron acceptor in the phosphorylation of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate, an intermediate in the glycolytic pathway. The regeneration of NAD+ assumes particular importance when in situ accumulation of pyruvate is desired. To date, there has been no success in completely preventing the production of benzyl alcohol in whole cell cultures, despite many reported attempts. There has, however, been some success in reducing the amount of benzaldehyde converted to benzyl alcohol. Methods which have been used include the random induction of mutant strains, the use of isoenzyme mutants, benzaldehyde dosing protocols and the use of additives to variously enhance PDC activity and reduce ADH activity. As briefly mentioned above, work is also taking place on developing purified enzyme systems. Studies which were undertaken specifically with the aim of reducing the benzyl alcohol yield, rather than increasing PDC activity, are discussed in greater detail later in this review.
3. DEVELOPMENT AND OPTIMIZATION OF THE FERMENTATION PROCESS
The development and optimization of a fermentation process is dependent on an array of factors, including the type of organism used, its physiological
12
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
condition, the physical conditions for growth/production and the medium composition, all of which when correctly combined create conditions conducive to high product yields. Studies into the optimization of L-PAC production by these various processes are reviewed below. 3.1. Selection of a High-yielding Producer Organism
L-PAC yields can be significantly affected by the choice of the production strain. Desirable qualities include the presence of a high level of PDC activity, low ADH activity, and high tolerance levels for benzaldehyde, benzyl alcohol and PAC. High affinity for benzaldehyde by PDC is beneficial but rarely measured. The importance of some of these criteria was demonstrated by Bringer-Meyer and Sahm (1988) when they compared purified enzymes from whole cell cultures of S. carlsbergensis and 2. mobilis. Although the PDC activity of 2. mobilis was five times that of the enzyme from S. carlsbergensis, a lower affinity for benzaldehyde resulted in a L-PACyield in 2. rnobilis, which was four to five times lower. Most early studies compared strains on an holistic basis, measuring their ability to produce PAC, and productivity over a set period, rather than identifying the biochemical basis for their performance. No single species of organism has been accepted universally as the strain most suited to L-PAC production, although Saccharomyces spp. have been identified as the best L-PACproducers in comparative studies by a number of groups (Becvarova and Hanc, 1963; Gupta et al., 1979; Netrval and Vojtisek, 1982; Mahmoud et al., 1990a), and are known to be producers of acetoin (Romano and Suzzi, 1996). Importantly, Netrval and Vojtisek demonstrated that the yeast with the highest initial productivity was not necessarily the most productive over an extended period (24 h), in contrast to Becvarova and Hanc’s suggestion (based on 6-h transformations) that the highest yields were produced by the yeast with the highest decarboxylase activity. Netrval and Vojtisek’s findings have been supported by those of Shin and Rogers (1996a,b) and Rogers et al. (1997) who found that, while initial rates of L-PAC production were higher at higher PDC activities, this did not necessarily result in higher final yields. These findings have also been supported by the work of Tripathi et al. (1997) and Bringer-Meyer and Sahm (1988). Prior to Becvarova and Hanc’s (1963) comparison of six brewing and food yeasts, screening of organisms was limited. Both brewer’s (Smith and Hendlin, 1953, 1954; Netrval and Vojtisek, 1982) and baker’s (Becvarova et al., 1963; Voets et al., 1973; Long et al., 1989; Long and Ward, 1989a; Nikolova and Ward, 1992a) yeasts were, and have continued to be, common choices owing to their ready availability and low cost. Both possess good PDC activity, although brewer’s yeast also has high ADH activity. Although some ADH activity is desirable for the regeneration of NAD+, particularly if pyruvate is
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
13
being generated in situ, high ADH activity can result in high levels of benzyl alcohol, which potentially reduces the L-PACyield by reducing the amount of available benzaldehyde for conversion to L-PAC. Baker’s yeast may be preferable because of its generally lower ADH activity. Other strains used include locally isolated strains of S. cerevisiae (Agarwal et al., 1987;Tripathi et al., 1988; Agarwal and Basu, 1989) and various yeast strains from culture collections (Becvarova and Hanc, 1963). The L-PAC yields from local isolates were comparable to yields from yeasts obtained from culture collections. One way of seeking further increases in L-PACyield is via the use of genotypically and/or phenotypically modified biomass, although success is not guaranteed. For example, Nikolova and Ward ( 1 99 1) tested eight S. cerevisiae ADH I, II and I11 isoenzyme mutants, and achieved similar benzyl alcohol concentrations for all the strains tested regardless of their isoenzyme configurations. Also, a benzaldehyde-tolerant strain of C. utilis with increased productivity and benzaldehyde consumption rate isolated by Dissara and Rogers (1995) had a lower final L-PACyield than the parent strain because of a lower specific growth rate. The use of chemical (ethylmethane sulphonate, N-methyl-N’-nitro-Nnitrosoguanidine, nitrous acid) and physical (ultraviolet and gamma rays) agents to generate mutant strains has met with some success, with increases in L-PACyield ranging from 10% using S. cerevisiae (Sambamurthy et al., 1984; Ellaiah and Krishna, 1987) to 100%using S. cerevisiae and C.Jlareri (Seely et al., 1989b). The types of changes induced have included acetaldehyde and ephedrine resistance (Seely et al., 1989b), increased productivity, benzaldehyde tolerance and benzaldehyde consumption rate (Sambamurthyeta!., 1984; Ellaiah and Krishna, 1987; Dissara and Rogers, 1995). Benzaldehyde, L-PAC and sodium cyanide resistance has been induced by exposure of Saccharomyces spp. cultures to each of the three chemical agents (Gupta et al., 1979; Ellaiah and Krishna, 1987), although only benzaldehyde-tolerant strains had improved rates of conversion of benzaldehyde to L-PAC. Another approach has been the use of site-directed mutagenesis to increase the carboligase activity of PDC. When applied to PDC extracted from Z. mobilis, the resultant mutant enzyme gave a three-to four-fold increase in LPAC production when coupled with an enzymatic system to remove acetaldehyde [Bruhn et al. 1995, 1996 (as cited by Pohl, 1997)l. 3.2. Physicochemical Conditions and their Effect on L-PAC Production
The physical environment of a fermentation affects cell metabolism and structure, and product stability. Product stability is increasingly likely to be directly
14
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
affected if the product is excreted into the fermentation medium, as is L-PAC. The three variables over which process control is most precise are dissolved oxygen, pH and temperature. 3.2.1. Effect of Dissolved Oxygen Concentration on Metabolism Both Voets et al. (1973) and Ellaiah and Krishna (1988) demonstrated the benefit of limited aeration on L-PAC production by S. cerevisiae. Aeration of medium at a rate of 0.3 Vl.min enhanced L-PAC production compared with non-aerated cultures, although at 0.5 Vl.min, L-PAC production was reduced (Voets et al., 1973). Ellaiah and Krishna (1988) demonstrated that L-PACyield varied with the mass transfer coefficient (kLa), the maximum L-PAC yield being obtained when the kLa was 2.35 mm/l.h. Culik et al. (1984) deliberately reduce3 aeration to induce fermentative activity in S. coreanus and hence to stimulate L-PACproduction. They found that increasing the rate of aeration when L-PAC production began to slow increased the final L-PACyield, although the specific reasons for enhanced LPAC production were not detailed. Rogers and co-workers (1997) also employed a strategy of reduced aeration to stimulate the activity of PDC in their fed-batch and three-stage continuous culture systems with resulting LPAC yields of 22 g/l (in defined medium) and 10.6 g/l, respectively. Mahmoud et al. (1990a,b,c)induced anaerobiosis in S. cerevisiae by sparging the culture with nitrogen gas, which may have improved the L-PAC yield by ensuring the regeneration of NAD+, essential for the production of pyruvate from sucrose. However, the benzyl alcohol yields may have also been increased in the nitrogen-sparged cultures, compared with the aerated cultures, owing to the absence of molecular oxygen, which is known to exert a repressive effect on ADH activity (Nagodawithana et al., 1974; Jones et al., 1981; Ward and Young, 1990). In their study of the role of PDC on the Kluyver effect on C. utilis, Sims et al. (1991) found that PDC was synthesized de novo under anaerobic conditions in the presence of D-glucose. Under aerobic conditions the PDC was partially deactivated. Anaerobic conditions in these experiments were achieved by sparging with nitrogen gas; however, Sims and co-workers also demonstrated that depletion of oxygen by actively growing biomass was also sufficient to enable synthesis of PDC. Concomitant with the increase in PDC activity under anaerobic conditions was an increase in ADH activity, which in the case of the process used for L-PAC production could lead to higher concentrations of benzyl alcohol, i.e. reduced L-PAC yields. It is likely that reduction in aeration (Culik et al., 1984). and even sparging of cultures with nitrogen as practised by Mahmoud et al. (1990a,b,c), was intended to increase PDC activity. It is also possible that the reductions in L-PAC yields observed by Voets et al. (1973) and
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
15
Ellaiah and Krishna (1988) under conditions of increased aeration were due to deactivation of PDC as a result of the cultures becoming aerobic. The findings of van Dijken and Scheffers (1986) suggest that increased glycolytic flux results from glucose pulsing under anaerobic conditions for C. utilis, thus increasing the levels of pyruvate. This is important in that the L-PAC yield is potentially enhanced owing to increased pyruvate availability. In contrast to the findings of Rogers and co-workers, Tripathi et al. (1997) found that L-PACyields were higher if the biomass was grown anaerobically, with the biotransformation taking place under aerobic conditions. The greater yields were attributed to the induction of PDC under the anaerobic growth conditions accompanied by increased pyruvate concentrations. However, with aerobic growth, it is likely that pyruvate would be diverted from the production of L-PAC by consumption through aerobic metabolic pathways. Variation in the levels of enzymes owing to differences in aeration is not peculiar to PDC. In a paper published in 1972, Harrison noted that growth of microorganisms or cultured cells under either aerobic or anaerobic conditions affected the levels of enzymes present. Anaerobic conditions were likely to enhance the levels of enzymes related to fermentation pathways, and low dissolved oxygen concentrations resulted in increases in glycolytic enzyme concentrations. Aerobic conditions enhanced the levels of Krebs cycle enzymes. Oliver et al. (1997) (see Section 4)used a system where, after the growth of biomass, the level of aeration was reduced in conjunction with pulsing of molasses. Based on the discussion in preceding paragraphs, an increase in PDC activity would have occurred. Pyruvate production continued for some time into the bioconversion phase of the fermentation process of Oliver and coworkers even under conditions of increasing benzaldehyde concentration. 3.2.2. Eflect of pH on Cellular Metabolism
When using S. cerevisiae for L-PAC fermentations, a pH range of 4-6 has generally been employed (Smith and Hendlin, 1953; Voets et al., 1973; Gupta et al., 1979; Long and Ward, 1989a,b), while Rogers and co-workers (1997) employed a pH of 6.2 for the bioconversion stage of their three-stage process using C. utilis. Rogers et al. (1997) also found that L-PACproduction was more sensitive to pH than was benzyl alcohol production. 3.2.3. Effect of Temperature on Metabolism
According to Rogers (1990), the rate of L-PAC production by C. utilis was approximately 1.5 times higher at 30 "C than at 20 "C; however, benzyl alcohol
16
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
yield was also increased at the higher temperature. The use of a lower temperature improved L-PAC yield with respect to benzyl alcohol yield and increased L-PAC stability, although the growth rate declined at temperatures below 25 "C. The use of a lower temperature may have also helped to reduce alcohol toxicity. Temperatures as high as 35 "C were found to have little effect on L-PACproduction by S. cerevisiae (Ellaiah and Krishna, 1988), although temperatures ranging from 25 "C (Vojtisek and Netrval, 1982; Nikolova and Ward, 1991) to 28-30 "C are used more routinely (Smith and Hendlin, 1953, 1954; Voets et al., 1973; Netrval and Vojtisek, 1982; Nikolova and Ward, 1991, 1994a). The manipulation of fermentation temperatures to improve yields has generally not been a key component of laboratory studies. 3.3. Physiological Condition of Cells for Optimum L-PAC Production
The biotransformation of a chemical is largely dependent on the physiological condition of the biomass, which, in turn, is influenced by the medium composition and physicochemical conditions used throughout the process. This applies to both the growth phase and the bioconversion phase of the L-PACfermentation. While a popular choice for laboratory studies, the use of purchased commercial baker's (Long and Ward, 1989a,b;Voets e f al., 1973; Nikolova and Ward, 1992a,c, 1994a) and brewer's yeast (Smith and Hendlin, 1953;Vojtisek and Netrval, 1982) as added biocatalyst reduces the ability for control and/or optimization of biomass preparation. The absence of control over biomass preparation may be of particular concern where purchased biocatalysts are used after very short acclimatization periods. Although baker's yeast is considered to have good PDC activity, as described above, the reduction in aeration results in enhanced production of PDC, provided that the acclimatization period is sufficient to allow for further induction of PDC production. Insufficient time for induction of PDC may result in reduced L-PACyields. No studies were undertaken to determine enzyme activities or the effect of the acclimatization period on those activities. The effect of cell age has been considered for S. cerevisiae (Agarwal et al., 1987), with the greatest L-PAC production observed with biomass that was 15-24 h old. The L-PACyield was considered to be dependent on a combination of enzyme activity and benzaldehyde tolerance, with reduced yields from older or younger biomass owing to lower activity or tolerance. Freshly cultivated inoculum ranged from 16 h (Ellaiah and Krishna, 1987) to 24 h (Netrval and Vojtisek, 1982; Mahmoud et al., 1990a,b,c; Nikolova and Ward, 1991, 1992b) and even to 28 h old (Becvarova and Hanc, 1963). The age of commercially obtained brewer's and baker's yeast was never stated, and as little as
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
17
1 h was allowed for adaptation to transformation conditions prior to commencement of the benzaldehyde feed (Smith and Hendlin, 1954; Voets et al., 1973; Long and Ward, 1989b).Yeast freshness was considered to be important by Becvarova et al. (1963) and Voets et al. (1973). The cessation of L-PAC production has been directly linked with reduced viability by Long and Ward (1989b); however, the loss of viability coincided with exposure to high benzaldehyde concentrations.Although PDC activity is resistant to benzaldehyde concentrations as high as 7 g/l, sucrose metabolism, cell growth and viability, which may in turn reduce the L-PAC production capacity, are affected by concentrations as low as 2-3 g/l. Indeed, recent reports (Rogers et al., 1997) placed the minimum concentration required for inhibition of growth of C. utilis at 1 gA, with a growth inhibition constant of just 0.30 g/l. They found that the specific rate of L-PAC production was strongly affected at benzaldehyde concentrations of 3 g/l. Biomass rendered non-viable by other means can still catalyse the transformation of benzaldehyde to L-PAC provided that pyruvate is supplied, as demonstrated with non-viable immobilized S. cerevisiae biomass (Seely et al., 1989a). Other authors have noted differences in metabolic activity whilst using acetone powders of yeast. Increased residual benzaldehyde and acetyl benzoyl concentrations were detected, but benzyl alcohol was not detected when acetone-dried powders were used by Voets et al. (1973). transcinnamaldehyde, a compound not normally detected in fermentations using freshly grown biomass, was detected in S. cerevisiae acetone powder fermentations (Voets et al., 1973). In contrast, Ose and Hironaka (1957) found that benzyl alcohol was produced by acetone dried yeast powders. When both benzaldehyde and pyruvate are present in sufficient concentration, PDC activity is reportedly the rate-limiting factor in L-PAC production by S. carlsbergensis (Vojtisek and Netrval, 1982), and low PDC concentrations were identified as a cause of low L-PACproduction capacity by S. cerevisiae (Mahmoud et af.,1990a). Continuous culture, particularly at high dilution rates, has been shown to be an effective method for increasing S. cerevisiae PDC activity, with four- and seven-fold increases in specific productivity for 23- and five-fold increases in flow rate during the growth and transformation phases of the fermentation, respectively (Tripathi et al., 1988, 1991). Culik et aE. (1984) adapted biomass for L-PAC production by preventing diauxic growth during the growth phase. This was achieved by ensuring sufficient oxygen supply. Fermentative metabolism was then induced in the Saccharomyces sp. by reducing aeration and regulating the feeding of sucrose. Using such methods, L-PAC yields of 10 g/l or more could be achieved. Alternatively, Seely et al. (1989b) allowed the cultures of S. cerevisiae to become oxygen-limited or anaerobic for up to 16 h prior to commencement of biotransformation. By following these guidelines, cells from any stage of
18
ALISON
L. OLjVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
growth up to late log phase could be successfully used for L-PACproduction with little variation in yield. 3.4. Nutrient Effects in L-PACProduction
The role of nutrition in the production of L-PAChas received limited attention to date. Manipulation of fermentation media, in particular, complex industrial media, to enhance the production of L-PAC requires an understanding of the metabolic roles of macronutrients and micronutrients.The work undertaken on yeast nutrient requirements in general and their effects on metabolism is extensive, and it is neither practical nor possible to review all aspects of the work here. Some aspects of yeast nutrition relevant to L-PAC production will therefore be discussed briefly. Vojtisek and Netrval(l982) investigated the use of corn steep liquor (CSL) and yeast hydrolysate, and found them both to be beneficial for the production of L-PAC by S. carlsbergensis when added to an otherwise simple medium. Noronha and Moreira (1993) developed a L-PAC production medium (details not published) with a glucose concentration of approximately 100 g/l (S. Noronha, 1996, personal communication) to stimulate the fermentative activity of S. cerevisiae. Others, all employing S. cerevisiae, have used media ranging from fully defined media (Agarwal ef al., 1987; Tripathi et al., 1991) to very simple media containing nothing more than molasses and urea and/or phosphate (Ellaiah and Krishna, 1987, 1988). Glucose, sucrose and pyruvate are frequently used substrates for the L-PAC production process with the sucrose supplied either as pure sucrose or as molasses. Glucose or sucrose is generally used when biomass is grown in situ prior to the initiation of the bioconversion phase (Netrval and Vojtisek, 1982; Ellaiah and Krishna, 1988; Nikolova and Ward, 1991). Sucrose has also been used as a substrate for the generation of pyruvate during a short acclimatization period prior to benzaldehyde dosing when commercially obtained biomass was used (Long and Ward, 1989a,b;Nikolova and Ward, 1991).When the biomass is used essentially as a catalyst, pyruvate is generally used and has been found to produce higher and more reproducible L-PAC yields because the regeneration of NADH is limited, and hence the production of benzyl alcohol is also limited (Nikolova and Ward, 1991). It is not uncommon for industrial fermentation media to contain one or more complex materials. Generally inexpensive and readily available complex carbon and nitrogen sources may also be used as a source of vitamins, trace elements and growth factors (Zabriskie et al., 1980), in some cases fulfilling all of the vitamin requirements of the organism (Stanbury and Whitaker, 1984). However, various compounds may be present in inhibitory concentrations (Oura, 1983; Jones and Greenfield, 1984; Cejka, 1985), may be
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
19
non-metabolizable (Reed and Peppler, 1973; Meyrath and Bayer, 1979), or may be complex ionic nutrients (Jones and Greenfield, 1984; Berry and Brown, 1987), functions which may be considered as either beneficial or detrimental. Optimization of individual nutrients is difficult because a change in the concentration of the complex material alters the concentrations of all individual components. Increased yields may be obtained by using defined medium, although the use of a defined medium on an industrial scale may limit the commercial viability of the process (Zabriskie et ul., 1980, Stanbury and Whitaker, 1984). Among the benefits of using defined medium are constant composition, and the exclusion of toxic or inhibitory compounds; however, the cost of the medium may be disproportionate to the value of the product and the overall yields may be no better. Defined media are frequently used on a laboratory scale to determine nutrient requirements. Dissara and Rogers (1995) achieved L-PACyields of up to 22 g/l using a defined medium, on a 5-1 scale, compared with 13 g/l in undefined medium. On the other hand, Vojtisek and Netrval (1982) achieved higher L-PAC yields (4.7-5.6 g/l) when yeast hydrolysate and/or CSL was included in the medium compared with yeast hydrolysate alone (2.5 gA). However, the basal medium used by Vojtisek and Netrval was much simpler than the defined medium used by Dissara and Rogers. The work undertaken on production of L-PACto date has been quite limited in the extent to which the effects of nutrients on metabolism have been closely examined. An investigation undertaken by Derrick and Large (1993) on the growth of C. utilis in continuous culture using valine and ammonium as nitrogen sources found that, under nitrogen limitation, increases in pyruvate yield of up to 100-foldwere achieved. Thus growth under nitrogen limitation may in turn lead to enhanced L-PACyields. One of the drawbacks from the use of complex industrial fermentation media is the presence of an array of different forms of the same macronutrients leading to diauxic growth patterns. Diauxic growth is more frequently seen in batch cultures; in continuous culture the biomass can adapt and eventually use all of the nutrients simultaneously. Culik et al. (1984) experienced scale-up problems owing to diauxic growth; ammonium and sucrose were used preferentially, followed by the utilization of carbon and organic nitrogen from corn extract, and finally ethanol produced initially from sucrose was used. Diauxic growth is not exhibited by all organisms; C. utilis, for example, is capable of the simultaneous use of metabolically produced ethanol in conjunction with added glucose (Ghoul et al., 1991), whereas the addition of glucose to S. cerevisiue cells will cause an immediate return to net ethanol generation rather than consumption (van Urk et al., 1988, 1990). Oliver (1996) et al. and Oliver (1 997) undertook a study aimed at simplifying a complex medium used industrially for the production of L-PAC by C. utilis. Medium components included molasses, CSL and whey in addition to
20
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
pure sources of glucose, phosphate, nitrogen, magnesium and thiamine. Although C. utilis is known to be prototrophic for vitamins, the thiamine was provided to ensure that the cofactor demand exerted by PDC was met. They found that up to 60% of the original molasses content of the medium could be substituted by the equivalent amount of sucrose in the form of raw sugar, with no loss in either pyruvate or L-PACyield. Furthermore, both CSL and whey could be omitted from the medium leading to slight increases in pyruvate yield but no change in L-PACyield. These results are consistent with the findings of Derrick and Large (1993) discussed above. Other benefits arising from these modifications to the medium included reduced inorganic content and chemical oxygen demand of the spent medium, the latter largely due to lower residual reducing sugar levels. The protocol used by Oliver (1996) and Oliver et al. ( 1997) included pulse feeding of carbohydrates (either molasses or sucrose). Rogers et al. (1997) also employed pulsed carbohydrate feeding in some of their studies. The benefits of using pulse feeding of carbohydrate in relation to the induction of PDC activity are outlined in Section 2.2. 3.5. Production of L-PAC by Batch, Fed-batch or Continuous Fermentation
The majority of studies on the production of L-PAChave been undertaken on a batch basis for comparison of yeast strains and to optimize production; the development of fed-batch or continuous production of L-PAC is relatively recent. The advantages of fed-batch or continuous production lie in the use of the same culture of organisms for production over an extended period, so reducing downtime, reducing of substrate and product toxicity by continuous dilution of medium, leading to higher final yields. Agarwal and Basu (1989) compared batch and fed-batch fermentationsusing free cells of S. cerevisiue and found that fed-batch fermentationscould be run for up to 14 times longer than batch fermentations. ‘Semi-continuous’may be a more appropriate term than ‘fed-batch’because aliquots of medium were periodically replaced rather than additional medium being added to the total volume. The fed-batch protocol was most beneficial up to the third cycle when the total LPAC yield was up to 120% higher than the total yield for an equivalent number of batch fermentations,i.e. based on an equivalent medium volume. Thereafter,the productivity decreased but was relatively constant, with approximately 50% more L-PACat any given time than for an equivalent number of batch fermentations. Mahmoud et al. (1990b) compared batch and ‘semi-continuous’fermentation protocols using S. cerevisiue immobilized in alginate. Unlike Agarwal and Basu (1989) who also used a strain of S. cerevisiue, Mahmoud et ul. (1990b) replaced the entire volume of medium at the end of each 24-h cycle rather than
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
21
a proportion thereof but similarly recorded a decrease (approximately 50%)in L-PACproduction after the first two cycles, which could not be restored by the regeneration or re-immobilization of the biomass. L-PACproduction remained relatively constant for the remaining cycles. Over seven cycles a fivefold increase in total L-PACyield was measured relative to a single batch fermentation, although it was unclear whether this referred to batch fermentations conducted in shake flasks (Mahmoud et al., 1990a) or a single cycle in a column reactor (Mahmoud et ul., 1990b). When transformations were run continuously, flow rate was determined to influence productivity (Tripathi et al., 1991) with a sevenfold increase in productivity, through a fivefold increase in flow rate for S. cerevisiue. The continuous system developed by Rogers and co-workers is fundamentally different from the systems developed by Agarwal and Basu (1989) and Mahmoud et al. (1990b).While the systems established by the last two groups embodied the concept of periodical replacement of part or all of the medium, the fermentation conditions were kept constant. In the case of Rogers et al. (1997), conditions were modified to exploit particular aspects of yeast physiology and metabolism. They found that a single-stage continuous system was unsuitable for use because of the toxicity of the benzaldehyde. Continuous culture may also affect enzyme activities, since the PDC and ADH activities of C. utilis were lower than those of S. cerevisiue when grown under the same continuous culture conditions (Derrick and Large, 1993). A well-controlled fed-batch system was considered by Rogers et al. (1997) to be preferable to a continuous system. Two- and three-stage systems were developed of which the three-stage system was the best. The separate stages were designed to: (1) optimize biomass yield; (2) induce semi-fermentativeactivity and enhance PDC activity; and (3) provide a biotransformation phase where benzaldehyde was added and converted to L-PAC.Respiratory quotient (RQ) was the major control variable for each stage. Using a continuous process, LPAC yields of up to 10.6 g/l were achieved, while yields of up to 22 g/l have been achieved for a three-stage fed-batch system. Significant reductions in PDC activity occurred. Similar to Sims et al. (1991), Rogers and co-workers reported an approximate fivefold increase in PDC activity, induced by controlling the RQ at 4-5 to induce partially fermentative conditions. Shin and Rogers (1995b) found that an RQ of 5-7 was most favourable for L-PACproduction with minimum benzyl alcohol formation. While pyruvate yields were enhanced at higher RQ levels, higher benzyl alcohol yields resulted.
3.6. The Use of Additives to Modify Metabolic Activity As previously mentioned, the complete conversion of benzaldehyde to L-PAC has not been achieved with any yeast strains as some benzyl alcohol has always
22
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
been produced. Even the use of ADH isoenzyme mutants (Nikolova and Ward, 1991) failed to prevent benzyl alcohol production. In the absence of an ADHfree yeast, reduced benzyl alcohol production and increased L-PAC yields have been sought by the use of additives, e.g. inhibitors or alternative hydrogen acceptors, which are not required for normal metabolic activity. The use of additives to reduce benzyl alcohol yield by dried brewer’s yeast was originally investigated by Smith and Hendlin (1954) who proposed three different methods: the use of alternative H+ acceptors, the addition of sulphydryl inhibitors (to inhibit ADH), and the use of nicotinic acid analogues to compete with NADH for enzyme active sites. Colloidal sulphur was the only H+ acceptor which successfully reduced the benzyl alcohol yield; however, owing to its toxicity, the L-PAC yield was also reduced. The use of sulphydryl inhibitors was similarly unsuccessful owing to the inhibition of other sulphide-containing glycolytic enzymes. Of the nicotinic acid analogues, only the amides were successful in reducing benzyl alcohol yields. Using concentrations of analogues up to 50 mM, reductions in benzyl alcohol of up to 20% were achieved with an equivalent concomitant increase in the yield of L-PAC. Ose and Hironaka (1957), also using dried brewer’s yeast, confirmed the findings of Smith and Hendlin and tested an additional hydrogen acceptor, acetaldehyde. They found that 70% conversion of benzaldehyde to L-PAC was achieved when a mixture of acetaldehyde and benzaldehyde was added to the medium compared with 40% conversion without added acetaldehyde. The increase in L-PAC yield matched the decrease in benzyl alcohol. By using radiolabelled acetaldehyde, Ose and Hironaka were able to exclude the use of acetaldehyde as a substrate in the production of L-PAC and it was believed to be an alternative hydrogen acceptor to benzaldehyde, thus preventing the production of benzyl alcohol. Acetaldehyde dosing has since been used successfully by Becvarova et al. (1963) and Becvarova and Hanc (1963), who used a mixture of equal parts of benzaldehyde and a 50% aqueous solution of acetaldehyde, or equal parts of benzaldehyde and acetaldehyde, respectively, to achieve increased L-PACyields compared with controls where no acetaldehyde was added. Netrval and Vojtisek (1982), and Vojtisek and Netrval(1982), routinely added a mixture of acetaldehyde and benzaldehyde to fermentations, although no comparison was given for a fermentation without added acetaldehyde. Increases of up to 30% in L-PACproduction by C. utilis were obtained by Oliver (1996) when acetaldehyde was supplied at two different concentrations and under varying dosing regimes. Acetaldehyde was supplied at levels equimolar and twice equimolar to the anticipated maximum benzyl alcohol yield, and, in contrast to the findings of Ose and Hironaka (1 957), led to a marginal (less than 10%) increase in benzyl alcohol production,. While the use of acetaldehyde may result in reduced benzyl alcohol yields, it is important to balance the benefits with the known disadvantages.
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
23
Acetaldehyde is known to be more toxic than ethanol on a weight basis (Stanley, 1993). Inhibition of growth by concentrations as low as 0.3 g/l have been observed (Stanley et al., 1993), although the acetaldehyde concentration calculated by Stanley to inhibit growth of S. cerevisiae by 50% was 0.5 g/l. This concentration is similar to that reported by Carlsen et al. (1991) as inhibitory to the respiration of S. cerevisiae (0.55 gA) grown on glucose. Some individual enzymes are even more sensitive to the effects of acetaldehyde: PDC has a Ki of 4-7 m~ (0.2 - 0.3 g/l) while ADH has a Ki of 120-160 p~ (5-7 mg/l) (Jones, 1989). Rogers et al. (1997) determined an inhibition constant for acetaldehyde for C. utilis-derived PDC of 20 m~ (equivalent to 0.882 gA). These quantities are much lower than the amounts added to the fermentation medium by Oliver (1996) (up to 1.5 gA), suggesting that some inhibition of PDC and hence reduced L-PAC yields may have occurred. The physiological role of acetaldehyde is believed to be as a competitor with benzaldehyde for active sites on ADH. The miscibility of acetaldehyde with aqueous solutions is greater than for benzaldehyde and so it should be more readily available to ADH than benzaldehyde. Dosing with acetaldehyde allows the reaction to proceed in the direction favoured under fermentation conditions, in addition to enabling the regeneration of NAD+ for use in glycolysis. The addition of acetaldehyde to medium has been reported by Stanley (1993) to stimulate glycolytic flux in anaerobic fermentations through increased generation of NAD+. Ellaiah and Krishna (1987) tested the additives a-naphthoxy acetic acid (NAA), 2,4-dichlorophenoxy acetic acid (2,4-D), ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) and niacinamide on a strain of S. cerevisiae. None were successful in enhancing L-PAC yield; reductions of up' to 25% were observed. On addition of 20 p g / d niacinamide, there was a negligible decrease in L-PAC yield ( 6 5 % ) in contrast to the findings of Smith and Hendlin (1954). Other respiratory inhibitors which have been tested for their ability to improve L-PAC yield by C. utilis include sodium azide, sodium cyanide and salicyl hydroxamic acid (Rogers, 1990). Of these, only the addition of sodium azide resulted in an increase (10%)in L-PAC yield and was accompanied by a similar decrease in benzyl alcohol yield. 3.7. Reduction of the Toxic Effects of Substrate, Product and By-product
Production of L-PAC is self-limitingowing to the toxic nature of benzaldehyde, benzyl alcohol and L-PAC. The potential effects of benzaldehyde on biomass and fermentation outcome include retardation or inhibition of growth, reduction of viability and alteration of cell permeability to substrate and product (Long and Ward, 1989b). Liew et al. (1995), who studied the use of a
24
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
continuous membrane bioreactor, attributed reduced flux across the membrane to lysis of biomass on addition of benzaldehyde. Benzyl alcohol is substantially more toxic than ethanol, with benzyl alcohol concentrations as low as 5 g/l causing up to 80% inhibition of both L-PAC and benzyl alcohol production rates for C. utilis (Rogers et al., 1997) in addition to inhibition of growth. Ethanol concentrations of up to 21 g/l caused only minor inhibition of initial benzyl alcohol production, and the Kifor growth of C. utilis was 39 g/l ethanol (Rogers et al., 1997). The same group has reported a Ki for growth of 4.1 gA L-PAC,which is therefore also much more toxic than ethanol. In terms of the sensitivity of individual enzymes, purified yeast ADH is more sensitive to benzaldehyde (with inactivation at concentrations as low as 0.2 g/l) and PAC than purified yeast PDC which is most sensitive to benzyl alcohol (Long and Ward, 1989b). Owing to the highly toxic nature of benzaldehyde, the ability of yeast to adapt is limited. Pelleting of free cells in fermentations when exposed to benzaldehyde was noted by Mahmoud et d.(1990a) and was thought to be a mechanism for reduction of the toxic effect of benzaldehyde. Because of the limited tolerance of yeast to benzaldehyde, benzyl alcohol and L-PAC,various physical methods have been developed to reduce the exposure of the yeast. The techniques used include benzaldehyde dosing regimes, immobilizationof biomass, biphasic fermentations and the use of additives. The role of nutrientshffering agents in reducing the toxic effects of benzaldehyde also merits consideration, although the number of studies in the area is extremely limited. The addition of 20% yeast extract to enzyme suspensions was found by Long and Ward (1989b) to be helpful in slowing the inactivation of ADH with 61% residual activity after 6 h in the presence of 7 g/l benzaldehyde. 3.7.1. Substrate Dosing
One of the simplest and least costly methods of reducing the biomass exposure to inhibitory concentrations of benzaldehyde is to alter the benzaldehyde dosing regime and thus limit the maximum benzaldehyde concentration in the medium at any time. Much of the early experimental work undertaken on the production of L-PACwas conducted on a small scale in shake flasks, leaving little scope for variation in the benzaldehyde dosing regime. Long and Ward (1989b) compared the L-PAC yields obtained from S. cerevisiae using shake flasks, where a total of 12 gA of benzaldehyde was added to each flask, being added as either two aliquots each of 6 g/l.h or six aliquots each of 2 g/l.h. Markedly different behaviour was demonstrated by the yeast for the two conditions. When six small aliquots of benzaldehyde were added to the broth, the yeast viability was maintained at close to the initial level for the
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
25
first 4 h of the biotransformation,while the cell viability in the culture dosed with 6 g/l.h benzaldehyde dropped to approximately 30% of the initial value within the same period. Sucrose consumption continued in the medium with the small benzaldehyde doses and the residual benzaldehyde concentration was lower than in the medium receiving the two large doses. Higher L-PACtitres were also recorded in the medium with the six benzaldehyde doses - approximately 4 4 . 5 g/l compared with 3.3 g/1 for the medium with two doses although the maximum L-PACconcentration occurred earlier in the fermentation for the condition with two doses. The benefits of protecting biomass from large initial concentrations of benzaldehyde were clearly demonstrated. During their development of a semi-continuous process for L-PACproduction using S. cerevisiae, Mahmoud et al. (1990b) compared intermittent and continuous benzaldehyde dosing protocols. They found that, by adding benzaldehyde continuously over 6 h, up to double the amount (12 g/l) could be added compared with the amount previously added intermittently (6 g/l) without inhibition of L-PACproduction, resulting in 2.5 times the L-PAC yield (10 g/l rather than 4 g/l). The advantages offered by continuous benzaldehyde dosing over intermittent feeding were also demonstrated when a wild-type strain and a strain of S. cerevisiae adapted to benzaldehyde were exposed to intermittent and continuous dosing of benzaldehyde to the same final benzaldehyde concentration (8 g/l). For the adapted cells, 70% of the added benzaldehyde was converted to L-PAC under continuous dosing, while only 26% was converted in the intermittently dosed medium. For the wild-type cells, the conversion efficiencies were 57% and 41%, respectively. The use of a continuous feeding protocol appeared to reduce the inhibitory effect of benzaldehyde and led to more efficient conversion of benzaldehyde to L-PAC. Studies by Agarwal et al. (1987) found that, by maintaining medium benzaldehyde concentrations greater than 4 m, PDC activity remained higher than ADH activity in S. cerevisiae. The reduced rate of benzyl alcohol production at higher concentrations was likely to be the result of inactivation of ADH by benzaldehyde. Long and Ward (1989b) found that residual activity of purified ADH exposed to 0.2 g/l benzaldehyde had dropped to 82% after 6 h compared with a residual activity of 90.6%for ADH incubated in the absence of benzaldehyde, and had dropped to 33% for ADH incubated in the presence of 3 g/l benzaldehyde. In contrast, the PDC activity remained constant at 89% and 87% in the presence of 0.2 g/l and 7 g/l benzaldehyde, respectively. Thus, benzaldehyde concentration and dosing regime may be used to help control the formation of by-products. While the potential use of high benzaldehyde concentrations to lower benzyl alcohol yields was recognized by Long and Ward (1989b), they also noted that the inhibition or inactivation of ADH by benzaldehyde could restrict the regeneration of NAD+.This may be beneficial in whole cell systems where the biomass is used as a catalyst and exogenous pyruvate is added to the
26
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
medium. However, when endogenous production of pyruvate is required, as in the system used by Oliver et al. (1997), the addition of benzaldehyde resulting in inhibition of ADH may also result in reduced glycolytic flux and hence reduced L-PACyields. Work undertaken by Rogers et al. (1997) expanded on that of Agarwal et al. (1987) by demonstrating that higher yields of by-products were formed at benzaldehyde concentrations of less than 150 m and greater than 200 m, and when the molar ratio of benzaldehyde to pyruvate was between 0.5 and 1.O. Shin and Rogers (1995b) found that benzyl alcohol was preferentially produced by both free and immobilized biomass at concentrations of less than 30 m benzaldehyde, while L-PAC was the main product when benzaldehyde concentrations were in excess of 40 m. A two-phase protocol was utilized by Oliver et al. (1997) comprising batch generation of the C. utilis biomass followed by fed-batch L-PACproduction. In the production phase, conversion of the accumulated pyruvate to L-PAC was maximized by the addition of a large initial aliquot of benzaldehyde, this was accompanied by the addition of nutrients and carbohydrate to promote further pyruvate production prior to the commencement of continuous benzaldehyde dosing and a second addition of carbohydrate. 3.7.2. Immobilization of Enzymes or Biomass
Benzaldehyde concentrations as low as 1-2 g/l are capable of inhibiting the growth of C. utilis (Dissara and Rogers, 1995) and S. cerevisiue (Long and Ward, 1989b) and, although higher initial concentrations of benzaldehyde (6 g/l) can result in higher L-PACproduction, there is an almost immediate effect on cell viability (Long and Ward, 1989b). Some protection from the toxic effects of substrates and/or products can be conferred by immobilizing the biomass, a process also used successfully for enzymes. The potential benefits of immobilization include modification of metabolism, stabilizing and extending the life of the catalyst, broadening the range of reaction conditions, simplifying product recovery and the separation of biomass from spent broth, and simplifying biomass recycling (Navarro and Durand, 1977; Ward and Young, 1990; Shacar-Nishri and Freeman, 1993). One of the negative aspects of immobilization of biomass, as observed by Rogers et al. (1997), is the more limited control over metabolism manifested as reduced L-PAC yields, although enhanced resistance to benzaldehyde was noted. The reduced L-PAC yields were attributed to lower levels of accumulated pyruvate (by a factor of 2-3 times). A further effect of immobilization is limitation of mass transfer owing to reduced diffusion. Both Shin and Rogers (1996b) and Rogers et al. (1997) reported an increased K,,, for pyruvate with immobilized purified PDC.
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
27
Immobilization may be by entrapment within a matrix, adsorption to a support or cross-linking to either a support or to adjacent cells. In studies on L-PACproduction, entrapment in alginate has been the most common method of immobilization, although Seely et al. (1989a) investigated the use of polyazetidine for the immobilization of whole cells, Nikolova and Ward (1994a) tested a variety of polymers using lyophilized yeast, and Shin and Rogers (1995a,b) used polyacrylamide and calcium alginate for the immobilization of PDC. Rogers et al. (1995, 1997) compared the performance of free and immobilized biomass and PDC from various biotransformation processes on the basis of productivity and molar conversion yield (Table 1). Both are important criteria for comparing industrial-scaleprocesses, although the use of productivity, rather than specific productivity as a performance indicator limits the ability to compare different strains or conditions directly. The L-PACyields of the immobilized and free cell processes were similar; however, owing to the reduced productivity of the immobilized biomass additional reaction time was required. Increased L-PACyields and productivities were recorded for the purified and immobilized PDC transformations compared with the whole cell methods. Modified enzyme activity was observed by Shin and Rogers (1995a) when they compared the performance of PDC from C. utilis, both free and immobilized in polyacrylamide beads. The immobilized PDC was reported to have displayed higher activity ( K , = 72 m)and greater tolerance to benzaldehyde (Ki = 161 m) than free PDC, although figures were not given for the free PDC. A Ki for L-PACof 240 r m was reported for immobilized PDC. The modifications in activity and tolerance were attributed to the presence of a benzaldehyde concentration gradient in the beads. The optimum pH differed for free and immobilized PDC, while the reaction with immobilized PDC was more sensitive to temperature. Among the disadvantages of immobilization noted were the lower conversion efficiency and longer time required for biotransformation. Immobilized PDC used on a continuous basis generated an average L-PACconcentration of 4.5 g/l and exhibited a half-life of 29 days, its stability apparently affected by both denaturation of the enzyme and its leakage from the matrix. The average L-PAC concentration contrasted with the maximum of 17.1 g/l achieved using immobilized PDC in a 16-h batch biotransformation. Tripathi et al. (1997) reported free cells to be more efticient at biotransforming benzaldehyde than immobilized cells; they noted that this contradicted the findings of other groups. However, it appears that the benzaldehyde concentration used in their work was within the range where ADH activity exceeded PDC activity. Nikolova and Ward (1994a) investigated the effect of the physicochemical properties of a selection of polymers on the production of L-PACand benzyl alcohol by baker’s yeast. Freshly lyophilized biomass was used as a catalyst for
Table I Comparison of kinetic evaluations for various methods of L-phenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC)production. Reproduced with permission from Rogers er al. (1997) Process
L-PAC(gll)
Batch and fed-batch proeesse~ Free cells 12.4 22.4 Free cells (cyclodextrins) 12 Immobilized cells 9.9 10 15 Free PDC 28.6 27.1 Immobilized P d c
continoous pl-omses Immobilized cells Immobilized cells (semicontinuous) Three-stage system (free cells) PDC = pyruvate karboxylase.
Reaction time (h) productivity (g/l.h)
Molar conversion yield (96)
Reference
17 14
57 65
Culik et al. (1984) Wang et al. (1994)
0.73 1.6
3 24 22 8 12
3.3 0.42 0.7 3.6 2.3
59 58 95 93
Mahmoud er ul. (1990~) Seely er al. (1989a) Mahmoud et ul. (199Ob) Shin and Rogers (199%) Shin and Rogers (196a) Shin and Rogers (1996b)
4
-
0.6
45
Shin and Rogers (1995b)
4.5
-
0.4-0.8
57
Mahmoud et al. (199Ob)
10.6
-
0.44
56
Wang (1993)
60
rn W
c
8 z
?
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
29
the transformation of benzaldehyde to L-PAC. The highest L-PAC yield (0.98 g/l) was produced by the free cell suspension followed by the hydrophilic, polyethylene glycol-containing polymers (ENT-4000 and PU-6), the polypropylene glycol-containing gels (PU-3 and ENTP-2000), and lastly the alginate and silicone gels. The hydrophobic gels, PU-3 and ENTP-2000, produced the highest and lowest L-PAC:benzyl alcohol ratios, respectively (1:0.08 and 1:1.80); the free cell suspension was second only to the PU-3 gel in the ratio of product to by-product obtained. The results of the biotransformation were attributed to the physicochemical properties of the gels including hydrophilicity,hydrophobicity and porosity, although little detail as to the relative properties of the polymers was given. The high porosity of alginate beads enables easy and relatively unrestricted diffusion of substrates and products, an important factor in preventing toxicity (Smidsrod and Skjak-Braek, 1990).Mahmoud et al. (1990a,b) investigated the use of S. cerevisiae ATCC 834 immobilized in calcium alginate for both batch and semi-continuous fermentations. The immobilized cells could withstand benzaldehyde concentrations up to 0.6% w/v, while the growth of free cells was inhibited in 0.4% benzaldehyde - 2 . 5 4 times higher than reported by Gupta et al. (1979), who found that 0.15% benzaldehyde was sufficient to inhibit the growth of S. cerevisiae CBS 1171. Increased benzaldehyde tolerance, attributed to the presence of a benzaldehyde concentration gradient, as for Shin and Rogers (1995b), enabled the production of up to 7.5 times more L-PACthan for free cells. The benzaldehyde uptake rate by immobilized cells remained constant at varying initial benzaldehyde concentrations up to 0.6% w/v benzaldehyde. At higher initial benzaldehyde concentrations, the benzaldehyde uptake rate decreased. In contrast, the benzaldehyde uptake rate decreased beyond an initial benzaldehyde concentrationof only 0.4% with free cells. Variation in the L-PAC yield with variation in the bead cell mass was attributed to the development of concentration gradients within the beads and therefore a lower concentration of benzaldehyde being available to the internal biomass. In semi-continuous fermentations undertaken by Mahmoud et al. (1990b), the same batch of biomass beads was used for up to seven cycles with some bead damage and biomass loss observed after three cycles. The observed bead damage coincided with an approximate 50% drop in L-PACproduction, which was possibly due to the increased exposure of the yeast to the benzaldehyde and transformation products, and hence increased toxic effects. Reactivation of the beads after the third cycle made no difference to the L-PACyield per cycle, with similar yields per cycle (2.5-3 g/l) for the third through to the seventh biotransformationcycle. The total amount of L-PACproduced in seven cycles was five times the amount produced in just one cycle. Bead cell mass is an important parameter, with 5 g of beads per 50 ml of medium determined to be the optimal concentration by Tripathi et al. (1991)
30
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
for their strain of S. cerevisiae. Higher concentrations of beads resulted in a rapid decline in productivity which was attributed to oxygen limitation. The beads were resuspended in fresh medium that did not contain any pyruvate prior to the biotransformation. Supplementationof the medium with pyruvate may have enabled the use of higher bead concentrations without a loss of productivity. The creation of cross-links between cells using polyazetidine was patented by Seely et al. (1989a) as an alternative method of immobilization. Although the cross-linking of cells to solid substrates including glass beads, sand and ion- exchange resins was described, the cross-linking of cells directly to other cells was preferred, owing to the cost advantages compared with the additional cost of using a physical support. Freshly grown biomass was rendered nonviable, and the cell-wall structure modified to enhance permeability to substrates and products during the preparation process. An added advantage of this method is the ability to store the immobilized biomass for extended periods after preparation. The advantages of immobilizing yeast using polyazetidine on the basis of L-PAC yield could not be determined because the immobilized system was not compared with a free cell system; yields of up to 12 g/l were achieved. While the immobilization matrix appears to have a definite effect, the preparation of the biomass prior to immobilization also has a significant effect on L-PACproduction. Shin and Rogers (1995b) enhanced PDC activity prior to harvesting and immobilization of the biomass by reducing the aeration and stirring rate. They noted that enzyme activity decreased initially after immobilization but was restored to near pre-immobilizationlevels once a glucose feed had been introduced. Liew et al. (1995) used a method dissimilar to the other continuous methods described above, namely a continuous membrane bioreactor where biomass was recovered by membrane filtration. There appeared to be a number of distinct disadvantages with this method; the flux was affected by high biomass concentrations and, as mentioned previously, by lysis of biomass after the addition of benzaldehyde. 3.7.3. Modi$cation of Benzaldehyde Solubility
The effect of benzaldehyde solubility on L-PAC yields has been tested by incorporating co-solvents to increase the concentration of dissolved benzaldehyde in the medium beyond the solubility limit of benzaldehyde in water (0.03 g/lOO ml). Ideally, neither L-PACyield nor L-PACformation should be directly nor adversely affected by the co-solvent used. The effect of increasing benzaldehyde solubility on L-PAC production by S. cerevisiae was tested by Mahmoud et al. (1990a), who dissolved 0.6 ml of benzaldehyde in 6 ml of
THE PROOUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
31
N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) prior to adding the benzaldehyde to the medium. They found that increasing the solubility of the benzaldehyde in this manner had no significant effect on L-PAC yield, and therefore the benzaldehyde was neither more toxic nor more readily converted to L-PACwhen it was more soluble. The results presented by Mahmoud et al. (1990a), however, did not preclude the possibility of DMF toxicity as a counterbalance to potentially higher L-PACyields in the presence of higher benzaldehyde concentrations. The lack of improvement in yield using DMF as a co-solvent contrasts with the results of Seely et al. (1989a) who, using a strain of S. cerevisiae, described increased conversion rates and final yields when co-solvents were incorporated in the medium to increase the concentration of dissolved benzaldehyde. The co-solvents used included methanol, ethanol, propanol and butanol as well as ethylene glycol, glycerol and polyethylene glycol (PEG) of varying molecular weights. The inclusion of 20% by weight of ethanol as a cosolvent for benzaldehyde in the reaction medium was reported to have increased both the rate of reaction and the final yield of L-PAC (from 0.6 g/l in the absence of ethanol with 25 m~ benzaldehyde, to up to five times in the presence of 25 m~ benzaldehyde and to up to 10 times (5.5 g/l) in the presence of 100 m~ benzaldehyde). L-PAC yields of 10.5 g/l were reported in the presence of glycerol compared with 6 g/l in the absence of the co-solvent. The use of PEG as a co-solvent was considered particularly advantageous because,unlike short-chain alcohols it has no adverse effect on the PDC, . Growth has been found to be more sensitive than fermentation to ethanol inhibition, with concentrations as low as 4 8 % (w/v) being sufficient to reduce the growth rate of a laboratory strain of S. cerevisiae (Brown et al., 1981).An ethanol concentration of 12% (w/v) was required to inhibit growth completely, similar to the ethanol concentration found to inhibit the growth of a commercial S. cerevisiue strain (Brown et al., 1981); 9-10% (w/v) ethanol is commonly reported as being required for complete inhibition of growth (Casey and Ingledew, 1986). The growth rate inhibition constant (Ki) reported for the S. cerevisiae strain used by Brown and co-workers was 2.01% (w/v); the Ki for fermentation was 4.46% (w/v) with a slightly higher fermentation Ki (6.1% (w/v) for the commercial yeast strain. A fermentation Ki of 3.7% was reported by Pascual et al. (1988) for S. cerevisiae. These ethanol concentrations are all significantly lower than the 20% (w/v) ethanol added to the reaction medium by Seely et al. (1989a). However, fermentativeactivity has been reported in the presence of ethanol concentrations as high as 20% (Aiba et al., 1968) and 30% (Casey and Ingledew, 1986), and a lesser degree of toxicity has been reported for ethanol that has been added to yeast cultures compared with endogenously produced ethanol (Nagodawithana and Steinkraus, 1976; Novak et al., 1981; Casey and Ingledew, 1986). However, Pamment and coworkers (Dasari et al., 1990) indicated that the apparent inhibition due to endogenously produced ethanol also included that due to the by-products of the fermentation. On the
32
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
other hand, studies by Rogers et al. (1997) indicated a potential positive contribution from added ethanol in that up to 2-3 M ethanol produced an initial rate increase of 3040% in PDC activity. When benzaldehyde was supplied to C. utilis either neat or diluted with ethanol (1:2, v/v) at two dosage rates by Oliver et al. (1997), there was little effect on L-PACproduction, with only slight increases recorded at the higher benzaldehyde dose rate in the presence of ethanol. Carbohydrate metabolism was enhanced and benzaldehyde conversion was reduced with the addition of ethanol and with increased benzaldehyde flow rate, although the benzyl alcohol concentration was 50% less under the latter condition. The reduction in benzyl alcohol yield was probably due to more rapid inactivation of the ADH, as suggested by Agarwal et al. (1987) following their studies with S. cerevisiae. The creation of benzaldehyde inclusion compounds using P-cyclodextrin (BCD) was used effectively by Mahmoud et al. (1990~) to both increase the availability of benzaldehyde and to reduce the exposure of biomass to the benzaldehyde. In the presence of BCD, a total cumulative amount of 12-14 g/l benzaldehyde could be added to the medium, a significantly higher amount than previously reported (5-6 g/l), without causing serious damage to cells. Using such high concentrations of benzaldehyde, L-PAC yields of up to 12 g/l were achieved in the presence of 1.5% BCD compared to a yield of approximately 5.5 g/l L-PAC for the control experiment. Mahmoud and co-workers proposed that improved L-PACyields in the presence of BCD were the result of lower concentrations of free benzaldehyde, owing to its incorporation into BCD inclusion complexes, which in turn reduced the toxic effects of benzaldehyde but possibly also reduced its rate of conversion. A reduction in the rate of benzaldehyde conversion in the presence of BCD was discounted by the observation that maximum L-PACtitres occurred earlier in the presence of the BCD than in the control fermentations and benzaldehyde consumption was more rapid in the former. The role of cyclodextrins as a metabolic stimulant was confirmed by increased rates of glucose consumption with increasing BCD concentration and a trend, although inconclusive, towards increased cell growth rates. 3.7.4. livo-phase Fermentation Medium
Biphasic systems are particularly useful when either the substrate or product is poorly water soluble, as is the case with the L-PAC production process. The biomass or enzymes are suspended in a partially hydrated, water-immiscible solvent and the substrate or products partition into the solvent, As for immobilized cell systems, the advantages of biphasic systems include easy separation of substrate and product from the catalyst and, in some instances
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
33
greater stability of either the enzymes or whole cells (Antonini et al., 1981), although substrate and product inhibition may still occur. Nikolova and Ward have investigated the use of whole cells, cell-free extracts and pure enzymes in biphasic systems for the production of L-PACand benzyl alcohol (Nikolova and Ward, 1992a,b,c). Furthermore, the effect of these solvents on the activity of whole biomass immobilized in silicon-alginate was investigated (Nikolova and Ward, 1993). Hexane, hexadecane, toluene, decane, ethylacetate, butylacetate, toluene and chloroform were evaluated for their ability to support and/or improve the bioconversion potential of yeast in the systems mentioned above. The best yields of both L-PACand benzyl alcohol, with the least cell damage, were achieved with the non-polar solvents hexane and hexadecane using moisture levels of 2% for enzyme systems and 10% for whole cell systems (Nikolova and Ward, 1992a,b,c). When immobilized biomass was used in a non-aqueous system (2% moisture), the solvents for which the highest yields for benzyl alcohol were produced were hexane and decane (Nikolova and Ward, 1993). Below 2% moisture, PDC and ADH activity decreased. The use of whole cell systems obviated the need for cofactors and catalyst extraction, offering instead ease of biomass recycling and improved enzyme stability (Nikolova and Ward, 1992b,c). The activity of yeast ADH and ADH isoenzyme mutants of S.cerevisiae in hexane with 2% moisture was one-half to one-third the activity of the same systems in aqueous medium for benzyl alcohol production; PDC activity was not directly compared (Nikolova and Ward, 1992a,b,c). Yields were generally lower in the biphasic medium, with the exception of the ADH isoenzyme mutant containing ADH I, II and LII which had a similar reaction rate in both media (Nikolova and Ward, 1992a,b,c). Non-polar solvents are perceived to be effective in twophase systems because they are believed to prevent the complete removal of water which is present in the enzyme microenvironment. This rationale is likely to apply also in whole cell systems. 3.8. Other Methods for Influencing L-PACProduction
Other methods used to influence the L-PACfermentation process include the application of low-voltage alternating current to the medium during growth and biotransformation (Ellaiah and Krishna, 1988) and the control of the respiratory quotient (Rogers et al., 1997). The application of an alternating current had no effect on the final L-PACyield and, apart from stating that growth was stimulated, no rationale was put forward for its use by Ellaiah and Krishna. The use of respiratory quotient (the ratio of the rate of CO, production to 0, consumption) to control fermentations is based on the manipulation of fermentative activity. Fully respiratory growth (RQ = 1) resulted in increased benzyl alcohol production and correspondingly poor L-PAC yields. The
34
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
optimal RQ for the production of L-PACby C. utilis was determined to be approximately 4-5 (Rogers ef al., 1997). Neither of these methods are currently used for the production of L-PAC.
4. AN INDUSTRIAL PROCESS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF
L-PHENYLACENLCARBINOL
Work conducted by the authors on the effect of nutrients on L-PACproduction was based on a process used on a commercial scale. As described previously, a two-phase fed-batch fermentation procedure was used. The first phase comprised the growth phase where the conditions were conducive to the growth of biomass and accumulation of an exogenous store of pyruvate, while in the second, the bioconversion phase, PDC catalysed the conversion of the accumulated pyruvate and added benzaldehyde to form L-PAC.The growth-phase medium used originally comprised (in g/l): molasses 104, CSL 5.32, glucose syrup 10.6, urea 3.76 and KH,PO, 0.52. A typical 'standard' fermentation is described below; a time line illustrates the variations (Fig. 1). The physical variables of the fermentation were set at pH 5.2, 24.8 "C and 1.2 volumes per volume per minute (vvm) air. The medium was saturated with oxygen prior to inoculation. For an initial period of 2.5-3 h post-inoculation the PO, was stable after which oxygen consumption increased rapidly. Consumption of oxygen exceeded the rate of replenishment and resulted in a PO, of zero within 10 h of inoculation (Fig. 2). Measurement of the partial pressure of dissolved CO, showed that pC0, increased concomitantly with the decrease in PO,, a further indication of increased metabolic activity. During the growth phase, biomass grew actively and the available carbohydrate supply was metabolized until it was exhausted (approximately 16 h after inoculation). A minimum viable cell count of lo9 cells/ml (dry weight of approximately 19 gA) was achieved at the end of the growth phase. Acidification of the medium, as a result of pyruvate production, occurred continuously during the growth phase, requiring the addition of alkali to maintain the pH at the set point of 5.2. Typical exogenous pyruvate concentrations of 4-5 g/l were achieved by the end of the growth phase using the original medium formulation. The bioconversion phase was initiated by the alteration of the independent variables (pH 6.2, 18.8 "C, 0.6 vvm air), the addition of extra medium components [molasses 54 g/l and 16 mV1 nutrient solution containing (in gA): urea 0.89, whey 0.98, KH,PO, 0.59, MgSO, 0.28, and thiamine HC10.0012] plus a dose of benzaldehyde (0.8 mv1). These changes resulted in a sudden increase in p C 0 , followed by a decrease, suggesting that the cells became stressed. Tivo
35
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
Start fermentation 10 L Growth Medium
0.4% (v/v) aliquot
(GP)
16 h. 24.8"C, 1.2 vvm. p H 5.2
Addition of carbohydrate (54 g/L GP medium) Bioconversion mixture (16 mUL GP medium) Benzaldehyde aliquot (0.8 mUL GP medium)
Initiate Bioconversion Phase (BPI
2 h, 18.8" C,0.6 vvm. pH 6.2
Addition of carbohydrate (74 GP medium) Continuous benzaldehyde flow commenced ( I .5 mUL GP medium.h)
I
.
I
Initiate Pump Start (PSI I
22 h, 18.8" C, 0.6 wm,p H 6.2
Acidification of medium ceases, continuous addition of acid commences (AR) (approx. 5 h after BP initiated)
A
PdinpCQ (approx. 12 h after BP initiated)
1 0 1 1 Fermentation terminated after
Figure I Schematic diagram of the procedure followed for a standard fermentation by Oliver et nl. (1997).
36
s"
I
8 7
I
7
I
l-
3
I
s
I
8
I
I 9
0
I I
I 0 rn
I
I
I
I
8I
8
I
2I
I
:
I
2I
2 7
8
2
z I z
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
z :
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
37
hours later, further molasses was added (74 gA) and a pump started to add benzaldehyde continuously (total 15 m u ) at 1.5 ml/l.h. Acidification of the medium due to the production of pyruvate continued for approximately 5 h after the initiation of the bioconversion phase, albeit at a reduced rate. After this time, the rate of alkali dosing slowed and the pH gradually rose above the bioconversion phase set point of 6.2 (Fig. 2) and acid addition commenced. The increase in pH and the resulting acid dosing to maintain the pH suggested that pyruvate was being metabolized (resulting in L-PACor other less acidic metabolites). The period between the cessation of alkali dosing and the commencement of acid dosing was designated as the acid rollover. The acid rollover coincided with the commencement of an increase in the PO, and a decrease in the p C 0 , The biomass concentration contmued to increase for a few hours after the initiation of the bioconversion phase and then began to decline. Cell viability remained higher than 90%, after which a decline in both biomass concentration and viability commenced. Viability was less than 5% at the end of the fermentation. Approximately 12 h after the initiation of the bioconversion phase, there was a surge in the pCO,, which then subsided over a period of approximately 4 h. The peak was indicative of an increase in PDC activity, CO, being a product of the PDC-catalysed reaction. A small dip in the PO, occurred concomitantly with the increase in CO, concentration. The fermentation was continued for a total of 40 h before it was terminated, based on the protocol for full-scale commercial L-PAC production. The protocol followed was intended to maximize the L-PAC yields achieved, based on the physiological behaviour of yeast as described earlier in this review. Biomass was allowed to grow under good aeration conditions, producing an endogenous supply of pyruvate, until, by the end of the growth phase, the conditions had become fermentative because of the high rate of oxygen consumption. The reduction of aeration at the start of the bioconversion phase helped to ensure that the conditions remained partially fermentative, and the medium was pulsed with carbohydrate to induce PDC activity. A pulse of benzaldehyde was also added to stimulate the PDC activity without causing excessive benzyl alcohol production. The slow benzaldehyde feed started later was intended to maintain PDC activity at higher rates than ADH activity. The main aim of the authors’ study was the simplification of the fermentation medium without detriment to the L-PAC yield. The potential benefits included reduced production costs, and reduced nutrient load and chemical oxygen demand (COD) in the spent broth. They successfully demonstrated that up to 60% of the molasses added to the medium could be replaced by sucrose (as raw sugar), to give an increase in L-PAC (to 14 g/l) and pyruvate (6 g/l) yields. No effect was observed on the benzyl alcohol yield (1.1 g/l). The effect
38
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
of such a change is an anticipated savings in storage costs owing to the proportionately higher sucrose concentration in raw sugar compared with molasses. Later studies by the authors also demonstrated that the total concentration of carbohydrate in the growth-phase medium could be reduced by up to 20% without significant losses in L-PACyield. A guaranteed minimum of 10 g/l of L-PACcould not be achieved if the bioconversion phase carbohydrate content was reduced by more than 25%. Both CSL and whey powder were added in relatively small quantities and the exact role of either component was unknown. CSL is high in nitrogenous compounds and this, combined with the fact that a considerable quantity was added to the fermentation medium with respect to the amount of urea added, was thought to be the reason for its inclusion in the medium. Results show, however, that omission of CSL from the medium had no detrimental effects on the overall outcome of the fermentation. Marginally increased pyruvate yields, attributed to increased glycolytic flux, were recorded (6.7 g/l), as was a reduction in ADH activity (benzyl alcohol yields of 0.5 g/l). These changes did not, however, translate to increased L-PAC yields, which remained essentially unchanged (12.8 g/l). The addition of whey to the medium was originally undertaken to provide a source of lactose. However, because C. utilis is unable to utilize this carbohydrate (the medium was not originally developed for the growth of C. utilis), the inclusion of whey in the medium was considered superfluous. Whey also contributes lactic acid (which C. utilis can utilize) and thiamine, but at the concentrations present combined with the amount of whey added to the medium, the contribution of both was considered to be insignificant. The omission of whey from the medium proved to be apparently beneficial, resulting in a 15% increase in the acid rollover pyruvate concentration. However, there was no effect observed on L-PAC yield, or on any of the other measured variables, including benzyl alcohol concentration. Preliminary experiments were undertaken by Oliver et al. ( 1997) to determine the effect of lowering urea and potassium dihydrogen phosphate concentrations. The results indicated that both of these materials could be reduced by up to 15% without any detrimental effect on either the L-PAC or the benzyl alcohol yields. As an extension to the work on the fermentation medium composition, the effect of benzaldehyde feed rate and acetaldehyde or ethanol addition were examined. While work by both Long and Ward (1989b) and Mahmoud et al. (1990b) demonstrated the benefits of benzaldehyde dosing over extended periods, Agarwal and co-workers (1987) showed that ADH activity remained higher than that of PDC when benzaldehyde concentrations were less than 4 m~ (Section 3.7.1). The rationale behind increasing the benzaldehyde flow rate was thus to raise the benzaldehyde concentration to a level such that ADH activity, and subsequently benzyl alcohol yield, would be significantly reduced.
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
39
Increasing the benzaldehyde flow rate from 1.2 ml/l.h to 2.5 mVl.h successfully brought about a reduction in benzyl alcohol concentration of 50%, although the resulting increase in L-PACyield was less than 10% (to approximately 13 gA). Increasing benzaldehyde flow rates also resulted in marginally reduced (slightly more than 10%)pyruvate concentrations. The lower benzyl alcohol concentrations were thought to be due to premature inactivation of ADH, as proposed by Agarwal et al. (1987). As noted in Section 3.6, it has been proposed that acetaldehyde can compete with benzaldehyde for sites on ADH. In studies by Oliver (1996), significant gains were made in the yield and efficiency of L-PACproduction in the presence of added acetaldehyde, although reductions in the benzyl alcohol yield were minimal. The addition of ethanol (up to a total of 9.8 g/l) was also tested as a method for increasing benzaldehyde solubility. The result was a very slight reduction in benzyl alcohol production at low benzaldehyde flow rates but minimal effect at the maximum benzaldehyde flow rate (2.5 ml/l.h) tested. The effect of added ethanol on L-PAC yield was negligible. The limited effects of ethanol dosing observed were considered to result from the addition of ethanol at inappropriately low levels in the study since the amount of ethanol added (0.22 M) was substantially less than the 2-3 M concentration shown by Rogers et al. (1997) to be required before an effect is observed on PDC activity in C. utilis. Acetaldehyde dosing was also undertaken. However, there was no effect on L-PACor benzyl alcohol yields when concentrations of 2 g/l or less were added.
5. CONCLUSION
In theory, the L-PACproduction process appears to be a straightforward condensation of added benzaldehyde with acetaldehyde generated metabolically through the decarboxylation of pyruvate. In practice, the process is far from simple because of toxicity effects from the substrate (benzaldehyde),the principal by-product (benzyl alcohol) and the product itself (L-PAC).A number of strategies have been employed to ameliorate the toxic effects, and to maximize the L-PACyield, whilst minimizing the generation of by-products. Such strategies rely heavily on increased understanding of the predominant enzyme systems involved (PDC and ADH), together with a more detailed understanding of the biochemical and physiological basis for variations in L-PAC yield between the yeast species examined and the different fermentation systems employed. The effects of nutrients on L-PAC production are less well understood and appear to be worthy of further investigation. An overall increase in the understanding of the biochemistry and physiology of yeast systems capable
40
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
of L-PACsynthesis will aid in the optimization of full-scale L-PACproduction through productivity increases and reduced medium-related expenses.
Agarwal, S.C. and Basu, S.K. (1989) Biotransformation of benzaldehyde to L-acetyl phenyl carbinol by fed batch culture system. J. Microb. Eiorechnol. 4, 84-86. Agarwal, S.C., Basu, S.K., Vora, V.C., Mason, J.R. and Pirt, S.J. (1 987) Studies on the production of L-acetyl phenyl carbinol by yeast employing benzaldehyde as precursor. Biotech. Eioeng. 29,783-785. Aiba, S., Shoda, M. and Nagatani, M. (1968) Kinetics of product inhibition in alcohol fermentation. Biotech. Eioeng. 10, 845-864. Antonini, E., Carrea, G. and Cremonesi, P. (1981) Enzyme catalysed reactions in water organic solvent two-phase systems. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 3,291-296. Becvarova, H. and Hanc, 0. (1963) Production of phenylacetylcarbinol by various yeast species. Folia Microbiol. 8, 4 2 4 7 . Becvarova, H., Hanc, 0. and Macek, K. (1963) Course of transformation of benzaldehyde by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Folia Microbiol. 8, 165-169. Berry, D.R. and Brown, C. (1987) Physiology of yeast growth. In: Yeast Eiotechnology (D. R. Berry, I. Russell, and G. G Stewart, eds), pp. 159-199. Allen and Unwin, London. Boiteux, A. and Hess, B. (1970) Allosteric properties of yeast pyruvate decarboxylase. FEES Lett. 9,293-296. Bowen, W.R., Pugh, S.Y.R. and Schomburgk, N.J.D. (1986) Inhibition of horse liver and yeast alcohol dehydrogenase by aromatic and aliphatic aldehydes. J. Chem. Technol. Eiotechnol. 36, 191-196. Bringer-Meyer, S. and Sahm, H. (1988) Acetoin and phenylacetylcarbinol formation by the pyruvate decarboxylases of Zymomonas mobilis and Saccharomyces carlsbergensis. Eiocatalysis 1,321-33 1. Brown, S.W., Oliver, S.G., Harrison, D.E.F. and Righelato, R.C. (1981) Ethanol inhibition of yeast growth and fermentation: differences in the magnitude and complexity of the effect. Eul: J. Appl. Microbiol. Eiotechnol. 11, 151-155. Cardillo, R., Servi, S. and Tinti, C. (1991) Biotransformation of unsaturated aldehydes by microorganisms with pyruvate decarboxylase activity. Appl. Microbiol. Eiotechnol. 36, 300-303. Carlsen, H.N.. Degn, H and Lloyd, D. (1991) Effects of alcohols on the respiration and fermentation of aerated suspensions of baker’s yeast. J. Gen. Micmbiol. 137,2879-2883. Casey, G . P. and Ingledew, W.M. (1986) Ethanol tolerance in yeasts. CRC Crit. Rev. Microbiol. 13, 219-280. Cejka, A. (1985) Preparation of media. In: Eiotechnology: A Comprehensive Treatise, Vol. 2 (H.-J. Rehm and G. Reed, eds), pp. 630-698. Verlag-Chemie, Weinheim. Chow, Y.S., Shin, H.S., Adesina, A.A. and Rogers, P.L. (1995) A kinetic model for the deactivation of pyruvate decarboxylase (PDC) by benzaldehyde. EiotechnoL Letr. 17, 1201-1 206. Conn, E.E., Stumpf, P.K., Bruening, G. and Doi, R.H. (1987) Outlines ofEiochemistry, 5th edn. John Wiley and Sons, Singapore. Crout, D.H.G.. Dalton, H., Hutchinson, D.W. and Miyagoshi, M. (1991) Studies on pyruvate decarboxylase: acyloin formation from aliphatic, aromatic and heterocyclic aldehydes. J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 1329-1334.
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
41
Culik, K., Netrval, J., Souhrada, J., Ulbrecht, S., Vojtisek, V. and Vodnansky, M. (1984) Czech patent no. 222941. Dasari, G., Worth, M.A., Connor, M.A. and Pamment, N.B. (1990) Reasons for the apparent differences in the effects of produced and added ethanol on culture viability during rapid fermentations by Saccharornyces cerevisiae. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 35, 109- 122. Demck, S. and Large, P. J. (1993) Activities of the enzymes of the Ehrlich pathway and formation of branched-chain alcohols in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Candida utilis grown in continuous culture on valine or ammonium as sole nitrogen source. J. Gen. Microbiol. 139, 2783-2792. Dijken, J.P. van and Scheffers, W.A. (1986) Redox balances in the metabolism of sugars by yeasts. FEMS Micmbiol. Rev. 32, 199-224. Dissara, Y.and Rogers, P.L. (1995) Evaluation of mutants of Candida utilis for L-PAC production from benzaldehyde. Proceedings of the 4th Pacific Rim Biotechnology Conference, pp. 248-249. Ellaiah, P. and Krishna, K.T. (1987) Studies on the production of phenyl acetyl carbinol from benzaldehyde by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Indian Drugs 24, 192-1 95. Ellaiah, P. and Krishna, K.T. (1988) Effect of aeration and alternating current on the production of phenyl acetyl carbinol by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Indian J. Technol. 26, 509-5 10. Flikweert, M.T., Zanden, L. van der, Janssen, W.M. T.M., Steensma, H.Y., Dijken, J.P. van and Pronk, J. T. ( I 996) Pyruvate decarboxylase: an indispensable enzyme for growth of Saccharomyces cerevisiae on glucose. Yeast 12, 247-257. Fuganti, C., Grasselli, P., Poli, G., Servi, S. and Zorzella, A. (1988) Decarboxylative incorporation of a-oxobutyrate and a-oxovalerate into (R)-a-hydroxyethyl- and n-propyl ketones on reaction with aromatic and a$-unsaturated aldehydes in baker’s yeast. J. Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun. 16 19- 1621. Ghoul, M., Boudrant, J. and Engasser, J.M. (1991)A comparison of different techniques for the control of the growth of Candida utilis CBS 621. Process Biochem. 26, 135-142. Green, D.E., Westerfeld, W.V., Vennesland, B. and Knox, W.E. (1942) Carboxylases of animal tissues. J. Biol. Chem. 145, 69-84. Gross, N.H. and Werkman, C. H. (1947) Isotopic composition of acetyl methyl carbinol formed by yeast juice. Arch. Biochern. 15, 125-131. Gupta, K.G., Singh, J., Sahni, G. and Dhawan, S. (1979) Production of phenyl acetyl carbinol by yeasts. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 21, 1085-1089. Happold, F.C. and Spencer, C. P. (1952) The enzymic formation of acetylmethylcarbinol and related compounds. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 8,543-556. Harrison, D.E.F. (1972) Physiological effects of dissolved oxygen tension and redox potential on growing populations of micro-organisms. J. Appl. Chem. Biotechnol. 22, 417-440. Hohmann, S. (1997) Pyruvate decarboxylases. In: Yeast Sugar Metabolism (F.K. Zimmerman and K.-D. Entian, eds), pp. 187-21 1. Technomic, Lancaster, PA. Hubner, G., Weidhase, R. and Schellenberger, A. (1978) The mechanism of substrate activation of pyruvate decarboxylase: a first approach. Eul: J. Biochem. 92,175-1 81. Jones, R. P. (1989) Biological principles for the effects of ethanol. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 11,130-153. Jones, R.P. and Greenfield, P.F. (1984) A review of yeast ionic nutrition. Part I: growth and fermentation requirements. Process Biochem. 19,4840. Jones, R.P., Pamment, N. and Greenfield, P. F. (1981) Alcohol fermentation by yeasts -the effect of environmental and other variables. Process Biochem. 16,4249. Juni, E. (1952) Mechanisms of the formation of acetoin by yeast and mammalian tissue. J. Biol. Chem. 195,727-734.
42
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
Juni, E. (1961) Evidence for a two-site mechanism for decarboxylation of a-keto acids by a-carboxylase. J. Biol. Chem. 236,2302-2308. k e n , V., Crout, D.H.G., Dalton, H., Hutchinson, D.W., Konig, W., Turner, M.M., Dean, G. and Thomson, N. (1993) Pyruvate decarboxylase: a new enzyme for the production of acyloins by biotransformation. J. Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun. 341-343. Leskovac, V., Trivic, S., Zeremski, J., Stancic, B. and Anderson, B.M. (1997) Novel substrates of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase - 3,4-dimethylamino-cinnamaldehyde and chloroacetaldehyde. Biochem. Mol. Biol. Int. 43, 365-373. Liew, M.K.H., Fane, A.G. and Rogers, P.L. (1995) Applicability of continuous membrane bioreactor in production of phenylacetylcarbinol. J. Chem. Tech. Biotechnol. 64, 200-206. Long, A. and Ward, O.P. (1989a) Biotransformation of aromatic aldehydes by Sacchatumyces cerevisiae: investigation of reaction rates. . I . Industrial Microbiol. 4, 49-53. Long, A. and Ward, O.P. (1989b). Biotransformation of benzaldehyde by Saccharrmyces cerevisiae: characterization of the fermentation and toxicity effects of substrates and products. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 34,933-94 I . Long, A., James, P. and Ward, O.P. (1989) Aromatic aldehydes as substrates for yeast and yeast alcohol dehydrogenase. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 33,657-660. Mahmoud, W.M., El-Sayed, A.H. and Coughlin, R.W. (1990a) Production of L-phenylacetyl carbinol by immobilised yeast cells: I. Batch fermentation. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 36,47-54. Mahmoud, W.M., El-Sayed, A.H. and Coughlin, R.W. (1990b) Production of‘ L-phenylacetyl carbinol by immobilised yeast cells: 11. Semicontinuous fermentation. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 36, 55-63. Mahmoud, W. M., El-Sayed, A.H. and Coughlin, R.W. (1990~)Effect of P-cyclodextrin on production of L-phenylacetyl carbinol by immobilised cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 36, 256-262. Maitra, P.K. and Lobo, Z. (1971) A kinetic study of glycolytic enzyme synthesis in yeast. J. Biol. Chem. 246,475488, McKenzie, A. (1936) Asymmetric synthesis. Ergebnisse Enzymforsch. 5,49-78. Meyrath, J. and Bayer, K. (1979) Biomass from whey. In: Economic Microbiology, Vol. 4 (A. H. Rose, ed.), pp. 207-269. Academic Press, London. Morton, J.F. (1977) Major Medicinal Plants: Botany, Culture and Uses, pp. 33-36. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield. Nagodawithana, T.W. and Steinkraus, K.H. (1976) Influence of the rate of ethanol production and accumulation on the viability of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in ‘rapid fermentation’. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 31, 158-162. Nagodawithana, T.W., Castellano, C. and Steinkraus, K.H. (1974) Effect of dissolved oxygen, temperature, initial cell count and sugar concentration on the viability of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in rapid fermentations. Appl. Microhiol. 28, 383-39 I . Navarro, J.M. and Durand, G. (1977) Modification of yeast metabolism by immobilization onto porous glass. Eur: J. Appl. Microbiol. 4,243-254. Netrval, J . and Vojtisek, V. (1982) Production of phenylacetylcarbinol in various yeast species. Eur: J. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 16, 35-38. Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. (1 99 1) Production of L-phenylacetyl carbinol by biotransformation: product and by-product formation and activities of the key enzymes in wild-type and ADH isoenzyme mutants of Sacchatumyces cerevisiae. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 20,493498. Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. (1992a) Production of phenylacetyl carbinol by biotransformation using baker’s yeast in two-phase systems. In: Biocatalysis in Non-conventional Media (J. Tramper et al., eds), pp. 675-680. Elsevier Science Publishers, Amsterdam.
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOLBY YEAST
43
Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. (1992b) Reductive biotransformation by wild type and mutant strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in aqueous-organic solvent biphasic systems. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 39, 870-876. Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. ( 1 992c) Whole cell yeast biotransformations in two-phase systems: effect of solvent on product formation and cell structure. J. Industrial Micmbiol. 10, 169-177. Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. (1993) Effect of organic solvent on biotransformation of benzaldehyde to benzyl alcohol by free and silicone-alginate entrapped cells. Biotechnol. Technol. 7 , 897-902. Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. (1994a) Effect of support matrix on ratio of product to by-product formation in L-phenylacetyl carbinol synthesis. Biotechnol. Lett. 16,7-10. Nikolova, P. and Ward, O.P. (1994b) Reductive biotransformation of benzaldehyde derivatives by baker’s yeast in non-conventional media: effect of substrate hydrophobicity on the biocatalytic reaction. Biocutulysis 9,329-341. Nikolova, P., Long, A. and Ward, O.P. (1991) Colorimetric determination of L-phenylacetyl carbinol produced by biotransformation of benzaldehyde and pyruvate using Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Biotechnol. Technol. 5 , 3 1-34. Noronha, S . and Moreira, A.R., (1993). Bioconversion of benzaldehyde by yeast. Ahstr: Pup. Am. Chem. SOC.205, Biot, 173. Novak, M., Strehaiano, P., Moreno, M. and Goma, G. (1981) Alcoholic fermentation: on the inhibitory effect of ethanol. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 23, 201-21 1. Oliver, A. L. (1996) Influence of medium components on the production of phenylacetylcarbinol (PAC) by yeast. M. App. Sci. Thesis. Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, Melbourne, Australia. Oliver, A.L., Roddick, F.A. and Anderson, B.N. (1997). Cleaner production of phenylacetylcarbinol through productivity improvements and waste minimization. Pure Appl. Chem. 69,2371-2385. Ose, S . and Hironaka, J. (1957) Studies on production of phenyl acetyl carbinol by fermentation. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Enzyme Chemistry 2, 457460. Oura, E. (1983) Biomass. In: Biotechnology: A Comprehensive Treatise, Vol. 3 (H.-J. Rehm and G. Reed, eds), pp. 18-19. Verlag-Chemie, Weinheim. Pascual, C., Alonso, A., Garcia, I., Romay, C. and Kotyk, A. (1988) Effect of ethanol on glucose transport, key glycolytic enzymes, and proton extrusion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 32, 374-378. Pohl, M. (1997) Protein design on pyruvate decarboxylase (PDC) by site-directed mutagenesis Adv. Biochem. Eng. Biotechnol. 58, 15-43. Reed, G. and Peppler, H.J. (1973) Yeast Technology. AVI, Connecticut. Rogers, P.L. (1990) ICI Internal Report. Orica Ltd, Ascot Vale, Victoria, Australia. Rogers, P.L., Shin, H.S. and Wang, B. (1995) Review of biotransformation of benzaldehyde to L-phenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC), an intermediate in L-ephedrine production. Proceedings of the 4th Pac$c Rim Biotechnology Conference, pp. 2 10-2 11. Rogers, P.L. Shin, H.S. and Wang, B (1997) Biotransformation for ephedrine production. Adv. Biochem. Eng. Biotechnol. 56,33-59. Romano, P. and Suzzi, G. (1996) Origin and production of acetoin during wine yeast fermentation. Appl. Environ. Microhiol. 62, 309-3 15. Sambamurthy, K., Ellaiah, P. and Krishna, K.T. (1984) Studies on the production of phenyl acetyl carbinol from benzaldehyde by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Indian J. Pharm. Sci. Jan-Feb, 62. Schmitt, H.D. and Zimmermann, F.K. (1982) Genetic analysis of the pyruvate decarboxylase reaction in yeast glycolysis. J. Bacteriol. 151, 1146-1 152.
44
ALISON L. OLIVER, BRUCE N. ANDERSON AND FELICITY A. RODDICK
Schure, E.G. ter, Flikweert, M.T., Dijken, J.P. van, Pronk, J.T. and Venips, C.T. (1998) Pyruvate decarboxylase catalyses decarboxylation of branched-chain 2-oxoacids but is not essential for fuse1 alcohol production by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64, 1303-1 307. Seely, R.J., Heefner, D.L., Hageman, R.V., Yarus, M.J. and Sullivan, S.A. (1989a) US patent 89/04421. Seely, R.J., Hageman, R.V., Yarus, M.J. and Sullivan, S.A. (1989b) US patent 89/04423. Shacar-Nishri, Y. and Freeman, A. (1993) Continuous production of acetaldehyde by immobilked yeast with in situ product trapping. Appl. Biochem. Biotechnol. 39140,387-399. Shin, H.S. and Rogers, P.L. (1995a) Kinetics of biotransformation of benzaldebyde to Lphenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC) by immobilised pyruvate decarboxylase from Candidu utilis. Proceedings ofthe 4th Pacgc Rim Biotechnology Conference, pp. 328-329. Shin, H.S. and Rogers, P.L. ( I 995b) Biotransformation of benzaldehyde to L-phenylacetylcarbinol, in intermediate in L-ephedrine production, by immobilised Candidu utilis. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 4 7 - 1 4 . Shin, H.S. and Rogers, P.L. (1996a) Production of L-phenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC) from benzaldehyde using partially purified pyruvate decarboxylase (PDC). BiotechnoL Bioeng. 49, 52-62. Shin, H.S. and Rogers, P.L. (1996b) Kinetic evaluation of biotransformation of benzaldehyde to L-phenylacetylcarbinol by immobilised pyruvate decarboxylase from Candidu utilis. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 49,429-436. Sims, A.P. and Barnett. J.A. (1991) Levels of activity of enzymes involved in anaerobic utilization of sugars by six yeast species: observations towards understanding the Kluyver effect. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 77, 295-298. Sims, A.P., Stalbrand, H. and Bamett. J.A. (1991) The role of pyruvate decarboxylase in the Kluyver effect in the food yeast, Candidu utilis. Yeast 7,479-487. Smidsrod, 0 . and Skjak-Braek, G. (1990) Alginate as immobilization matrix for cells. Trends Biotechnol. 8, 71-78. Smith, P.F. and Hendlin, D. (1953) Mechanism of phenylacetylcarbinol synthesis by yeast. J. Bacteriol. 65,440-445. Smith, P.F. and Hendlin, D. (1954) Further studies on phenylacetylcarbinol synthesis by yeast. Appl. Microbiof. 2, 294. Stanbury, P.F. and Whitaker, A. ( 1 984) Principles of Fermentation Technology, pp. 74-90. Pergamon Press, Oxford. Stanley, G.A. (1993) Acetaldehyde effects in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Ph.D. thesis, University of Melbourne, Australia. Stanley, G.A., Douglas, N.G., Every, E. J., Tzanatos, T. and Pamment, N. B. (1993) Inhibition and stimulation of yeast growth by acetaldehyde. Biotechnol. Lett. 15, 1199-1204. Tripathi, C.K.M., Basu, S.K., Vora, V.C., Mason, J.R. and Pirt, S.J. (1988) Continuous cultivation of a yeast strain from biotransformation of L-acetyl phenyl carbinol (L-PAC) from benzaldehyde. Biotechnol. Lett. 10,635-636. Tripathi, C.K.M., Basu, S.K., Vora, V.C., Mason, J.R. and Pirt, S.J. (1991) Biotransformation of benzaldehyde to L-acetyl phenyl carbinol (L-PAC)by immobilised yeast cells. Res. Industry 36, 159-160. Tripathi, C.K.M., Agarwal, S.C., Bihari, V., Joshi, A.H. and Basu, S.K. (1997) Production of L-phenylacetylcarbinol by free and immobilised yeast cells. Indian J. Exp. Biol. 35, 886-889. Urk, H. van, Mak, P.R., Scheffers, W.A. and Dijken, J.P. van ( I 988) Metabolic responses of Saccharomyces cerevisiae CBS 8066 and Candida utilis CBS 621 upon transition from glucose limitation to glucose excess. Yeast 4, 283-291.
THE PRODUCTION OF L-PHENYLACETYLCARBINOL BY YEAST
45
Urk, H. van, Schipper, D., Breedveld, G.J., Mak, P.R., Scheffers, W.A. and Dijken, J.P. van ( 1989) Localization and kinetics of pyruvate-metabolising enzymes in relation to aerobic alcoholic fermentation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae CBS 8066 and Candida utilis CBS 621. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 992.78-86. Urk, H. van, Voll, W.S.L., Scheffers, W.A. and Dijken, J.P. van (1990) Transient-state analysis of metabolic fluxes in Crabtree-positive and Crabtree-negative yeasts. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 56, 281-287. Verduyn, C., Breedveld, G.J., Scheffers, W.A. and Dijken, J.P. van (1988) Substrate specificity of alcohol dehydrogenase from the yeasts Hansenula polymorpha CBS 4732 and Candida utilis CBS 621. Yeast 4, 143-148. Voets, J.P., Vandamme, E.J. and Vlerick, C. (1973) Some aspects of the phenylacetyl carbinol biosynthesis by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Z. Allg. Mikrobiol. 13,355. Vojtisek, V. and Netrval, J. (1982) Effect of pyruvate decarboxylase activity and of pyruvate concentration on the production of 1 -hydroxy- 1-phenylpropanone in Saccharornyces carlshergensis. Folia Microbiol. 27, 173-177. Wang, B. (1993) Kinetic study of fed-batch and continuous bioconversion processes for Lphenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC) production by the yeast Candida utilis. Ph.D. thesis, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia. Wang, B., Shin, H.S. and Rogers, P.L. (1994) Microbial and enzymatic biotransformation of benzaldehyde to L-phenylacetylcarbinol (L-PAC),an intermediate in L-ephedrine production. In: Better Living Through Innovative Biochemical Engineering (W.K. Teo, M. G.S. Yap and S.W.K. Oh, eds), p. 249. Continental Press, Singapore. Ward, O.P. and Young, C. S. (1990) Reductive biotransforrnations of organic compounds by cells or enzymes of yeast. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 12,482-493. Zabriskie, D.W., Arrniger, W.B., Phillips, D.G. and Albano, P.A. (1980) Traders’ Guide to Fermentation Media Formulation.Traders’ Protein Division, Traders’ Oil Mill Company, Memphis, TN.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Fungal Production of Citric and Oxalic Acid: Importance in Metal Speciation, Physiology and Biogeochemical Processes Geoffrey M. Gadd Department of Biological Sciences, University of Dundee, Dundee, DDI 4HN9 UK
ABSTRACT
The production of organic acids by fungi has profound implications for metal speciation, physiology and biogeochemical cycles. Biosynthesis of oxalic acid from glucose occurs by hydrolysis of oxaloacetate to oxalate and acetate catalysed by cytosolic oxaloacetase, whereas on citric acid, oxalate production occurs by means of glyoxylate oxidation. Citric acid is an intermediate in the tricarboxylic acid cycle, with metals greatly influencing biosynthesis: growth limiting concentrations of Mn, Fe and Zn are important for high yields. The metal-complexing properties of these organic acids assist both essential metal and anionic (e.g. phosphate) nutrition of fungi, other microbes and plants, and determine metal speciation and mobility in the environment, including transfer between terrestrial and aquatic habitats, biocorrosion and weathering. Metal solubilization processes are also of potential for metal recovery and reclamation from contaminated solid wastes, soils and low-grade ores. Such ‘heterotrophicleaching’can occur by several mechanisms but organic acids occupy a central position in the overall process, supplying both protons and a metal-complexing organic acid anion. Most simple metal oxalates [except those of alkali metals, Fe(II1) and All are sparingly soluble and precipitate as crystalline or amorphous solids. Calcium oxalate is the most important manifestation of this in the environment and, in a variety of crystalline structures, is ubiquitously associated with free-living, plant symbiotic and pathogenic fungi. The main forms are the monohydrate (whewellite) and the dihydrate (weddelite) and their formation is of significance in biomineralization, since they affect nutritional heterogeneity in soil, especially Ca, P, K and A1 cycling. The formation of insoluble toxic metal oxalates, e.g. of Cu, may confer ADVANCES IN MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY VOL 41 ISBN 0-12-027741-7
Copyright 0 1999 Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
4a
GEOFFREY M. GADD
tolerance and ensure survival in contaminated environments. In semiarid environments, calcium oxalate formation is important in the formation and alteration of terrestrial subsurface limestones. Oxalate also plays an important role in lignocellulose degradation and plant pathogenesis, affecting activities of key enzymes and metal oxidoreduction reactions, therefore underpinning one of the most fundamental roles of fungi in carbon cycling in the natural environment. This review discusses the physiology and chemistry of citric and oxalic acid production in fungi, the intimate association of these acids and processes with metal speciation, physiology and mobility, and their importance and involvement in key fungal-mediated processes, including lignocellulose degradation, plant pathogenesis and metal biogeochemistry. 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Metal chemistry of oxalic and citric acids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Fungal biosynthesis of oxalic acid and calcium oxalate formation . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Oxalic acid biosynthesis ......................................... 3.2. Calcium oxalate ................................................ 4. Role of metals and oxalate in lignocellulose degradation and plant pathogenesis ...................................................... 4.1. Lignocellulose degradation ...................................... 4.2. Plant pathogenesis ............................................. 5. Catabolism of oxalic acid ............................................ 6. Fungal biosynthesis of citric acid ...................................... 6.1. Role of metals in citric acid production ............................. 7. Fungal organic acid production and metal biogeochemistry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1. Metal solubilization and anion mobility ............................. 7.2. Role of organic acids in corrosion of stone and building materials . . . . . . 7.3. Role of fungal oxalate in limestone biomineralization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. Fungal organic acid production and metal biotechnology ................. 8.1. Metal solubilization for recovery and bioremediation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements ................................................. References ........................................................
48 50 53 53 55 61 61 64 65 65 67 68 68 72 74 76 76 78 79
1. INTRODUCTION
In the terrestrial environment,fungi are of fundamental importance as decomposers, plant pathogens and symbionts (mycorrhizas),playing important roles in carbon, nitrogen and other biogeochemical cycles (Wainwright, 1988).They are often dominant in acidic conditions and, in soil, can comprise the largest pool of biomass (including other microorganisms and invertebrates)(Metting, 1992). This, combined with their branching filamentous explorative growth habit and high surface area to mass ratio ensures that fungal-metal interactions
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
49
are an integral component of major environmental cycling processes. Metals, both essential and inessential, and their derivatives can interact with fungi in various ways depending on the metal species, organism and environment, while fungal metabolic activities can also influence speciation and mobility (Gadd, 1993;Wainwright and Gadd, 1997). Certain mechanisms may mobilize metals into forms available for cellular uptake and leaching from the system, e.g. complexation with organic acids, other metabolites and siderophores (Francis, 1994), while immobilization may result from sorption on to cell components and exopolymers, transport and intracellular and extracellular sequestration or precipitation (Morley and Gadd, 1995; Gadd, 1996; Sayer and Gadd, 1997; White et al., 1997). Such apparently opposing processes of solubilization and immobilization are important for biogeochemical cycles for indigenous or introduced metals, and fundamental determinants of fungal growth, morphogenesis and physiology (Morley et al., 1996; Ramsay et al., 1999). Furthermore, several processes are relevant to environmental bioremediation (White et al., 1997; Sayer et al., 1998). Organic acids have important roles in fungal nutrition and physiology, apart from their possible utilization as carbon and energy sources, which include contributions to intracellular osmotic potential, charge balance and pH homeostasis (see Jennings, 1995). In addition, the production of metal-complexing organic acids assists both essential metal and anionic nutrition of fungi and plants via the solubilization of phosphate and sulphate, from insoluble metalcontaining substances, including salts and minerals. Production of such acids is also important in biodeterioration and weathering. Although much information on fungal organic acid production has been obtained as a result of the commercial importance of citric acid (Mattey, 1992; Kubicek, 1998),the wider significanceof citric and oxalic acids in affecting metal speciation and mobility should not be overlooked. As well as the relevance to metal nutrition and toxicity, metal solubilization by the formation of organic acid complexes is important in environmental metal mobility and transfer between terrestrial and aquatic habitats, in plant nutrition and productivity, metal recovery from wastes and low-grade ores (‘heterotrophic leaching’) (Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993), and bioremediation (Francis et al., 1992; Dodge and Francis, 1994; Francis and Dodge, 1994). Metal immobilization by insoluble metal oxalate formation is again a process of marked environmental significance regarding fungal survival, biodeterioration, pathogenesis, soil weathering, mineral formation and metal detoxification. Oxalate-containing or oxalate-derived minerals, including humboldtine (ferrous oxalate dihydrate), whewellite (calcium oxalate monohydrate) and weddelite (calcium oxalate dihydrate), occur in the geosphere, with significant microbiological involvement in their production. Many plants contain calcium oxalate, which can render them poisonous to herbivores and humans, and this can also constitute a significant fraction of the dry weight of lichen thalli (Purvis and Halls, 1996). In a fungal
50
GEOFFREY M. GADD
context, oxalic acidkalcium oxalate has long been known to be of ubiquitous occurrence and associated with fungi from different groups (Hamlet and Plowright, 1877; De Bary, 1887). The scope of this review is the physiology and chemistry of citric and oxalic acid production in fungi, the intimate association of these acids and processes with metal physiology and mobility, and their importance and involvement in key fungal-mediated processes, including lignocellulose degradation and plant pathogenesis, and metal biogeochemistry.
2. METAL CHEMISTRY OF OXALIC AND CITRIC ACIDS
Organic acids can form coordination compounds or complexes with metals. These may be non-ionic, anionic or cationic depending on the sum of the charges of the central metal atom or ion and surrounding ions and molecules (Basolo and Johnson, 1964; Munier-Lamy and Berthelin, 1983). If the organic acid, e.g. citric or oxalic acid, contains two or more electron donor groups so that one or more rings are formed, then the organic acid can be termed a chelating agent and the resulting complexes termed metal chelates (Martell and Calvin, 1952). Such complexation is dependent on the relative concentrations of the anions and metals in solution, the pH and the stability constants of the various complexes (DenCvre et al., 1996). Oxalic acid is a relatively strong acid and crystallizes from water as monoclinic prisms of oxalic acid dihydrate. In the biosphere, oxalic acid occurs in rocks, microorganisms, including fungi, plants and animals as the free acid but more commonly as the K or Ca salt (Hodgkinson, 1977). Indeed, in a microbiological context, raphides of calcium oxalate were, with microbes, among the first objects to be observed under the optical microscope (Leeuwenhoek, 1675). Like monocarboxylic acids, oxalic acid can be converted into salts and, as with other dicarboxylic acids, it is possible to obtain compounds where only one of the carboxyl groups has been derivatized, or where both carboxyl groups have been converted into the same or different derivatives (Hodgkinson, 1977). The oxalate ion, C 0 2-, is a bidentate 2. 4 ligand, forming a five-membered chelate ring when it binds to a metal (Fig. 1). A metal (M) which normally forms octahedral six-coordinate complexes (e.g. A13+,Cr3+,Fe3+)can bind three oxalates to form an anionic complex (Fig. 1):
This can be crystallized as a potassium salt K3[M(C204),].3H20.Metals which form square planar four-coordinate complexes (e.g. Cu2+,Zn2+) can complex two oxalates (Fig. l),
51
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
L
1
B
A
C
3-
D
E
Figure I Metal complex formation by oxalic acid. (A) oxalic acid; (B) oxalate; (C) bidentate metal (M) complex formation; (D) complex anion formation with metals which form square planar four-coordinatecomplexes, e.g. Cu2+,(Cu oxal)2-; (E) complex anion formation with metals which form octahedral six-coordinate complexes, e.g. A13+, Fe3+, C?+, (A1 ~ x a l ) ~(Fe - , oxal)j-, (Cr ~ x a l ) ~ - .
M2++ 2C20,2- + M(C20,)22-
(2)
with the crystallized potassium salt being K2[M(C20,),].2H20. Some metals, e.g. Al, Cr, Zn and Fe, form acid complexes, e.g. H,[Cr(C,O,)]. Most simple oxalates are sparingly soluble in water except those of the alkali metals (Li, Na, K), ammonium and Fe(III), the last probably because of the formation of the Fe[Fe(C,O,),] complex. Divalent metal oxalates are of similar solubilities with the most soluble being magnesium oxalate and the least soluble being calcium and lead oxalates (Table l). Precipitation occurs according to the following equation: M,qn+
+ n/2C20,2- + M(C2O,),,.xH20
(3)
Because of the coordinating properties of the bidentate oxalate ion, most metals of particular interest to biologists form both simple and complex oxalates; these metals include Mg, Ca, Sr, Ba, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Ga, Ag, Cd, Sn, Hg, Pb, and a range of actinides and lanthanides. Many simple oxalates are crystalline or amorphous solids with solubility constants ranging from lo4 to The values for divalent metal oxalates generally lie between
52
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Table I
Solubility products of some metal oxalates (Adapted from Chang, 1993)
Metal oxalate
Temperature (“C)
Solubility product
Barium (dihydrate) Cadmium (trihydrate)
18 18 25 18 25
I .20 x 1.53 x 1.42 x 1.78x 2.57 X 2.87 x 2.10 x 2.74 x 8.51 x 8.57 x 4.83 X 1.70 x I .75 x 5.40 x 5.61 x 1.35x 1.37 x
Calcium (monohydrate)
25 25
Copper (11) Ferrous Lead
18
Magnesium (dihydrate) Manganese (11) (dihydrate) Mercury (I) Silver (I) Strontium (monohydrate) Zinc (dihydrate)
25 25 25 25 25 25 18 18
25
10-7 10-9
lW9 10-7
lo-” 1O-Io 10-5 10“ 10-7
I 0-13 lo-’, 10-9 10-9
CH2COOH
I
HO-C-COOH
I
CH2COOH A
B
Figure 2 Metal complex formation by citric acid. (A) citric acid; (B) bidentate complex, e.g. (Ca cit)-, (Ni cit)-, (Fe(OH), cit)2-; (C) tridentate complex, e.g. (Cd tit)-, (Fe tit)-, (FeOH tit)*-, (Pb cit)-, (Cu tit)% (D) binuclear complex - (UO,), tit:-. Adapted from Francis et al. (1992).
53
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
(Table 1). It is generally believed that only simple oxalates can and occur in biological systems because the excess oxalate ion required for complex stability would be toxic. Citric acid can form mononuclear, binuclear or polynuclear complexes depending on the metal (Fig. 2). Ca2+,Fe3+and Ni2+form bidentate, mononuclear complexes with two carboxylic acid groups while Cu2+,Fe2+,Cd2+and Pb2+form tridentate mononuclear complexes with two carboxylic acid groups and the hydroxyl group. Uranium forms a binuclear complex involving four carboxylic acid groups and two hydroxyl groups from two citric acid molecules (Francis et al., 1992) (Fig. 2). Such complex formation affects metal mobility, toxicity and biodegradation: the recalcitrance of metal citrate complexes may play a role in the migration of hazardous metals from metal and nuclear disposal sites (Francis et al., 1992).
3. FUNGAL BIOSYNTHESIS OF OXALlC ACID AND CALCIUM OXALATE FORMATION 3.1. Oxalic Acid Biosynthesis
Oxalic acid may be considered as a toxic by-product of citric acid production, and its synthesis appears to depend on whether glucose or citric acid is used as the carbon source (Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999). Biosynthesis on glucose occurs by hydrolysis of oxaloacetate to oxalate and acetate catalysed by cytosolic oxaloacetase [oxaloacetate (acety1)hydrolasel (Fig. 3); this can be considered to be a valve whereby carbon overflow is channelled into an energetically neutral pathway and so competes with citrate production (Kubicek, 1988;Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999).Where citric acid is used, oxalic acid production occurs by means of the glyoxylate cycle (Fig. 4)(Hodgkinson, 1977; Dutton and Evans, 1996; Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999).
2 ADP
Glucoseu
2 ATP
2 ADP
2 b m v a t e y 2 woacetate
co2
<
OXALATE Acetate
-
?
Figure 3 Oxalate biosynthesis by Aspergillus niger. Further steps in acetate metabolism are uncertain (Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999).
54
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Succinate C I ~ T -------E Isocitrate
Glyoxylate
-
OXALATE
Figure 4 Oxalate biosynthesis by glyoxylate oxidation (see Dutton and Evans, 1993; Shimada et al., 1997).
Cytoplasmic oxaloacetase is inducible in A. niger and dependent on neutralization of acidic growth medium, the presence of carbonate and Mn2+as a cofactor (Havir and Anagnostakis, 1985; Dutton and Evans, 1996). The enzyme has also been identified in several species of brown- and white-rot fungi, including Tyromyces palustris, Coriolus versicolor and Phanerochaete chrysosporium (Akamatsu et al., 1991, 1992, 1993a,b,c).In addition to mitochondrial production of oxaloacetate in the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, Aspergillus niger also possesses a cytosolic pyruvate carboxylase which produces oxaloacetate, a reaction important in citric acid production by this species (Kubicek, 1998; Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999). In Sclerotium rolfsii, glyoxylate is oxidized to oxalate by glyoxylate dehydrogenase (glyoxylate NADP- oxidoreductase)(Maxwell and Bateman, 1968a),the glyoxylate arising from the action of isocitrate lyase on isocitrate, which is cleaved to succinate and glyoxylate (see Gadd, 1988). Production of glyoxylate dehydrogenase is induced by pH values >3.5, with optimal activity at pH 9 (Balmforth and Thomson, 1984). Glyoxylate oxidation to oxalate by glyoxylate dehydrogenase has also been observed in other fungi including Fomes annosus and Tyromycespalustris (Hutterman et al., 1980;Akamatsu, 1993).In S. rolfsii, glyoxylate dehydrogenase and isocitrate lyase appeared to be located in microbodies (Maxwell et al., 1972; Armentrout et al., 1978), which could be analogous to plant glyoxysomes (Dutton and Evans, 1996). The ectomycorrhiza Puxillus involutus was able to use bicarbonate for oxalate biosynthesis in a nitrate-nitrogen medium, the oxalate being synthesized either directly from oxaloacetate, or via citrate, isocitrate and glyoxylate (Lapeyrie, 1988).As well as these mechanisms of oxalate production, ascorbic acid analogues may also act as precursors of oxalic acid synthesis in certain fungi, e.g. Sclerotinia sclerotiorum, although further work is needed to confirm the steps involved (Franceschi and Loewus 1995; Loewus et al., 1995). Oxalic acidoxalate production is widespread in fungi with factors affecting biosynthesis including carbon and nitrogen source, and medium or environment pH (Punja and Jenkins, 1984a; Lapeyrie etal., 1987; Bennett and Hindal, 1989; Pierson and Rhodes, 1992; Akamatsu et al., 1993c, 1994; Dutton et al., 1993; Micales, 1994, 1995a; Wang and McNeil, 1995; Dutton and Evans, 1996; Shimada et al., 1997; Gharieb and Gadd, 1999). For example, nitrate as a nitrogen source and maintenance of the culture pH above 3.0 enhanced
55
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
oxalate production by S. rolfsii (Maxwell and Bateman, 1968a,b). Effects of C, N and the pH have also been noted on a wide variety of wood-rotting basidiomycetes, including both white-rot and brown-rot species, especially when carbon sources are depleted in medium (Dutton et al., 1993; Gharieb and Gadd, 1999). While it is dificult to generalize, it appears that brown-rot fungi tend to produce most oxalate in low-nitrogen culture media, whereas white rots prefer high-nitrogen media (Akamatsu et al., 1994; Henriksson et al., 1995; Shimada et al., 1997). However, differences in yield may reflect differences in production through the growth phase. For example, the white-rot basidiomycetes, Coriolus versicolor, Heterobasidium annosum, Pleurotus jlorida and Phanerochaete chrysosporium, produced millimolar concentrations of oxalate in the stationary phase, but little was produced during earlier active growth and no lowering of medium pH was observed. In contrast, some brown-rot fungi, Amyloporia xantha, Coniophora marmorata, Coniophora puteana and Poria vaporaria produced oxalate throughout growth and concentrations up to 20 mM reduced the medium pH (Dutton et al., 1993). Differences in oxalate yield may also reflect differential expression of the oxalate-degrading enzyme, oxalate decarboxylase, in the different species (Micales, 1995b, 1997). Under nutrient-rich conditions, oxalate was not produced by l? chrysosporium (Kuan and Tien, 1993), while Poria placenta increased oxalate production under nitrogen limitation (Micales, 1994) or during growth on amorphous cellulose (Ritschkoff et al., 1995). Carbon and nitrogen sources influence oxalate production by plant pathogenic and mycorrhizal fungi (see Dutton and Evans, 1996), with nitrate being the preferred nitrogen source for Paxillus involutus (Lapeyrie et al., 1987). Oxalate production by P. involutus was enhanced by the presence of carbonatehicarbonate (Lapeyrie et al., 1987; Lapeyrie, 1988).
3.2.Calcium Oxalate In the environment, the main forms of calcium oxalate are the monohydrate (whewellite) and the dihydrate (weddelite), which extensively occur in fossil rocks, microorganisms, plants and human urinary calculi. The monohydrate is monoclinic while the dihydrate is tetragonal in crystallization, although both can crystallize in a variety of forms. The solubility and instability of hydrated calcium oxalate increases with increasing water of crystallization, and this is reflected in the pattern of crystallization of calcium oxalate from aqueous solution. The initial precipitation phase is the trihydrate which loses water of crystallization to form either the monohydrate or the dihydrate, depending on conditions: CaC20,.3H20,
+ CaC,0,.2H20, + H,O
(4)
56
GEOFFREY M. GADD
CaC20,.2H,O,
+ CaC,O,H,O, + H,O
(5)
CaC20,.3H,0,
+ CaC,O,.H,O, + 2H,O
(6)
or
The solubility of calcium oxalate increases with decreasing pH because of the formation of dioxalate ions and oxalic acid: Ca2++ C,O,2-
CaC,O, C,OZ-
t)
(7)
+ H+ t)H.C,O,
H.C,04-
+ H+t)H,C,O,
(9)
Solubility increases markedly below pH 5 and may also be increased by the presence of substances which will form soluble complexes with either calcium or oxalate ions, such as citric acid and magnesium. Conversely, solubility may be decreased by the presence of a common ion, e.g. by the addition of calcium chloride or ammonium oxalate. The ubiquitous association of oxalic acidcalcium oxalate with many and diverse kinds of fungi from all major classes has long been evident in natural, laboratory and industrial environments (De Bary, 1887; Foster, 1949; Arnott, 1982a,b, 1995; Malajczuk and Cromack, 1982; Dutton et al., 1993; Dutton and Evans, 1996).In fact, the absence of calcium oxalate may be a more significant systematic character in some species (Krisai and Mrazek, 1986).Calcium oxalate crystals can be associated with the hyphae of oxalic acid-producing strains, as well as fruiting bodies, with the main forms being the monohydrate (whewellite) and the dihydrate (weddelite), the latter being the most ubiquitous (Fig. 5 ) . Sometimesthe two hydration states can be distinguished by their morphology as the monohydrate belongs to the monoclinic system, while the dihydrate belongs to the hexagonal system (Arnott, 1995). It is thought that monohydrate crystals may arise from previously produced dihydrate in a recrystallization process , the monohydrate being the more stable form. However, (Verrecchia et ~ l . 1993), Horner et al. (1995) found that the youngest portions of fungal rhizomorphs (from an oak wood) possessed monohydrate crystals, whereas older parts of the hyphae were associated with the dihydrate, while only monohydrate was found in mantle hyphae of larch ectomycorrhiza (Jones et al., 1992).This could reflect changes that occur over development and maturation of the calcium oxalate, although contrasts with the proposed sequence of events for biomineralizationin Quaternary calcretes (Verrecchiaet al., 1993).The relative contribution of fungal metabolism or diagenesis in effecting changes in crystal morphology and hydration state is therefore unclear at present.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
57
Figure 5 Scanning electron micrographs of calcium oxalate crystals produced in solid malt extract agar medium supplemented with 0.5% (w/v) gypsum by (a) Serpulu himantioides, (b) Aspergillus niger and (c,d) in leaf litter microcosms. In (c), note the small needle-like crystals characteristic of calcium oxalate monohydrate, as well as prismatic crystals of calcium oxalate dihydrate, and, in (d), the prism-like crystal of calcium oxalate dihydrate within the hyphal network. Scale bar markers: 10 pm (Gharieb, Sayer, Tait and Gadd, unpublished; see Gharieb et al., 1998).
In the environment, calcium oxalate formation by free-living and symbiotic mycorrhizal fungi is frequently observed both in soil, decomposing wood and in leaf litter (Graustein et al., 1977; Cromack e f al., 1979; Lapeyrie et al., 1984; Snetselaar and Whitney, 1990; Cairney and Clipson, 1991; Homer et al., 1995; Shinners and Tewari, 1997; Tewari et al., 1997), and also associated with certain plant pathogenic fungi (Punja and Jenkins, 1984b; Punja et al., 1985; Yang et al., 1993; Arnott, 1995). A variety of calcium oxalate crystal formations have been described with many fitting into the four groups: tetragonal bipyramids, prisms, tablets and needles (Keller, 1985; Amott, 1995; Whitney
58
GEOFFREY M. GADD
and Amott, 1986a,b, 1988; Shinners and Tewari, 1997). However, morphology is extremely variable and crystals can be separate or arranged in arrays, and may also arise from twinning (Arnott, 1995). The most common types in plants are large single needles (styloids),bundles of needles (raphides), stellate conglomerates (druses), rhombohedra1 (prismatic) and packets of angular microcrystals (crystal sand); analogous morphologies also arise in fungi (Franceschi and Loewus, 1995). Some crystal shapes appear to be transient, although in some cases their shape and location appears to be species specific (Horner et al., 1995). While most reports demonstrate calcium oxalate forrnation external to the biomass, an obvious consequence of oxalic acid excretion (Sayer and Gadd, 1997; Gharieb et al., 1998), other reports have described intracellular formation of calcium oxalate, with some crystals apparently covered by a wall or membrane (De Bary, 1887; Arnott, 1982a,b, 1995; Powell and Arnott, 1985; Whitney and Arnott, 1987) or deduced to arise in specific wall chambers (Amott, 1995), or in vacuolar vesicles (Lapeyrie et al., 1990). For fungi growing in the soil, the regularity of calcium oxalate deposits over the surface of hyphae has suggested a more complex mode of formation than precipitation of oxalate with exogenous calcium, hence the proposal that deposition of calcium oxalate arises within the hyphae and is not a simple surface precipitation (Arnott, 1982a,b, 1995;Arnott and Webb, 1983;Arnott and Fryar, 1984). However, it seems doubtful whether truly intracellular calcium oxalate deposition occurs in fungi (Franceschi and Loewus, 1995). In several fungi, semi-mature crystals are encased in an organic sheath covering the hyphae. Such sheaths are carbohydrate/proteinbased (Nicole et al., 1993) but are subject to distortions and shrinkage when treated with conventional electron microscopy reagents (Daniel, 1994; Connolly et al., 1995). It is likely that shrinkage during dehydration could make the extracellular matrix of fungi appear like the cell wall and lead to possible misinterpretation of electron micrographs (Connolly and Jellison, 1995; Connolly et al., 1995). In the white rot Resinium bicolor, the hydrated hyphal sheath is considerably thicker than the dehydrated sheath and contains numerous calcium oxalate crystals. Calcium oxalate druses nucleated and grew only in the more mature hyphal sections, suggesting that only the hyphal sheath possessed the extensibility necessary to accommodate them (Connolly and Jellison, 1995). The pattern of crystal formation along hyphae may reflect the nature and location of oxalate andor Ca2+secretion, although exogenous calcium is generally abundant (Connolly and Jellison, 1995). It is pertinent that, in plants, oxalates may accumulate in vacuoles, but there is no significant information relating to the role of the fungal vacuole in oxalate storage or deposition (Franceschi and Loewus, 1995). In basidiomycete rhizomorphs, some of the interwoven hyphae are encrusted with crystals and ‘vessel hyphae’ within may also possess crystalline deposits (Cairney et al., 1989; Cairney, 1990; Cairney and Clipson, 1991). Because of this, it is thought that the ability of litter degraders to
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
59
translocate and precipitate calcium as calcium oxalate could contribute to nutritional heterogeneity in soil, with concomitant influences on P, A1 and K (see later) (Connolly and Jellison, 1995, 1997).While the abundance of oxalate and importance in P and Ca cycling is clear for forest ecosystems, in arid ecosystems, oxalate production by mycorrhizal fungi appears limited to matforming fungi, such as Hysterangium separabile, and arbuscular hyphae do not have associated crystal structures (Allen et al., 1996). In addition to calcium oxalate, fungi are also able to precipitate other metal oxalates (Figs 6 and 7). The production of oxalic acid by fungi provides a means of immobilizing soluble metal ions, or complexes, as insoluble oxalates, decreasing bioavailability and conferring tolerance (Sayer and Gadd, 1997).As mentioned earlier, most metal oxalates are insoluble, some exceptions being Na, K, Li and Fe (Strasser et al., 1994). Copper oxalate (moolooite) has been observed around hyphae growing on wood treated with copper as a preservative (Murphy and Levy, 1983; Sutter et al., 1983, 1984).The copper appeared on the surface of the wood and around hyphae as copper oxalate, which was reported to be non-toxic because of its insolubility. A. niger can form metal oxalate crystals after 1-2 days when grown on medium amended with a wide range of metal compounds, including insoluble metal phosphates (Fig. 6)
Figure 6 Solubilization of insoluble Co,(PO,), by organic acid production and subsequent reprecipitationas insoluble cobalt oxalate. Aspergillus niger was grown at 25 "C for 6 days on malt extract agar containing 0.5% (wlv) Co,(PO,),. The photograph shows the clear zone of solubilization around the colony and the precipitation of cobalt oxalate crystals within this zone (see Gadd, 1996; Sayer and Gadd, 1997).
60
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Figure 7 Scanning electron micrographs of purified insoluble metal oxalate crystals produced by Aspergillus niger. (a) Cobalt oxalate, (b) copper oxalate, (c) zinc oxalate, (d) manganese oxalate, (e) strontium oxalate dihydrate and (f) strontium oxalate dihydrate with needle-like crystals of strontium oxalate monohydrate; (a-d) were obtained after growth on solid malt extract agar (MJZA) supplemented with 0.5% (w/v) of the corresponding metal phosphates; (e) and (9 were obtained after growth on MEA containing 15 m~ %(NO,),. Scale bar markers: (a,d) 100 pm; (b,c,e,f) 10 pm (Sayer, Whatley and Gadd, unpublished; see Sayer and Gadd. 1997).
61
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
(Sayer and Gadd, 1997) and powdered metal-bearing minerals (Fig. 5) (Sayer et al., 1997; Gharieb et al., 1998). A. niger has been shown to produce metal oxalates with many different metals, e.g. Ca, Cd, Co, Cu, Mn, Sr and Zn (Fig. 7) (Sayer and Gadd, 1997). Morphological examination of fungal-produced metal oxalate crystals and comparison, where possible, with chemically synthesized oxalates, has often shown some clear differences in crystallographic form (Vivier et al., 1994; Sayer and Gadd, 1997). Thus, the formation of oxalates containing potentially toxic metals may provide a mechanism whereby oxalate-producing fungi can tolerate environments containing high concentrations of toxic metals. Copper oxalate has also been observed in lichens growing on copper-rich rocks where it is also thought that the precipitation of copper oxalate could be a detoxification mechanism (see later) (Purvis, 1984, Purvis and Halls, 1996).
4. ROLE OF METALS AND OXALATE IN LIGNOCELLULOSE DEGRADATION AND PLANT PATHOGENESIS 4.1. Lignocellulose Degradation
Brown-rot and white-rot fungi are the main wood-rotting basidiomycetes, with brown rots, e.g. Coniophoraputeana and Serpula lacrymans, unable to metabolize lignin (leaving an amorphous brown residue) and white rots, e.g. Phanerochaete chrysosporium and Coriolus versicolor, able to degrade all plant cell wall components (Dutton and Evans, 1996). Oxalate plays an important role in affecting the activity of key enzymes and processes in both these groups of fungi (Goodwin et al., 1994; Khindaria et al., 1994; Shimada et al., 1994; Tanaka et al., 1994). In brown rots, oxalic acid production lowers the external pH, which aids cellulose degradation but also gives rise to oxygen radicals. The pH of wood can fall to around 2.5 after the growth of brown rots (Green et al., 1991; Espejo and Agosin, 1991; Dutton et al., 1993; Micales, 1994); such low pH values arise because of the strength of oxalic acid as an organic acid (pK, = 1.1) (Hyde and Wood, 1997). The oxalic acid is believed to act as an electron donor in the reduction of Fe(II1) to Fe(II), with the resultant Fe(I1) being oxidized in the Fenton reaction, yielding hydroxyl radicals for the oxidative degradation of cellulose and hemicellulose (Hirano et al., 1995; Dutton and Evans, 1996; Hyde and Wood, 1997): Fe2++ H,02
+ Fe3++ HO'+ HO-
(10)
However, direct reduction of Fe(II1) by oxalate has been dismissed because of the slow speed of reaction and requirement for light (Horne, 1960; Wood,
62
GEOFFREY M. GADD
2.5 3.5 4.5 pH 3.0 4.0
Figure 8 Model for hydroxyl radical production by brown-rot fungi without damage to the hyphae (adapted from Hyde and Wood, 1997). Secretion of cellobiose dehydrogenase (CDH) provides a mechanism for Fe(II1) reduction in the presence of oxalate: diffusion of Fe(I1) away from the hyphae promotes autooxidation. Generation of Fe(II)/H,O, away from the hyphae means resultant hydroxyl radicals will not be deleterious to the fungus.
1994; Zuo and Hoigne, 1994; Hyde and Wood, 1997). Another hypothesis has been proposed where Fe(II1) is reduced to Fe(I1) by extracellular cellobiose dehydrogenase, meaning that cellobiose or cellulose act as an electron source for both reduction of Fe(II1) and 0, to generate H,O, for the Fenton reaction (Fig. 8) (Hyde and Wood, 1997). It should be noted that oxalate may promote the Fenton reaction in a bifunctional manner, since increasing concentrationsof oxalate (< 5 mM or an oxalate : Fe ratio of 50) can inhibit oxidative breakdown of cellulose catalysed by Fenton oxidation, and also H,O, and Fe(1II) (Shimada et al., 1997).Thus, while both Fe(II1) and H,O, are important for Fenton-type oxidation, if oxalate exceeds 5 mM in wood, then non-enzymatic cellulose hydrolysis may be more important in brown-rot wood decay (Akamatsu et al., 1991; Shimada et al., 1997). It is possible that lignin scavenges the hydroxyl radicals first, and then phenoxy and other indirectly formed lignin-derived radicals may attack cellulose and hemicellulose because there is no selectivity for hydroxyl radicals to oxidize cellulose (Magara et al., 1994; Shimada et al., 1997). In brown-rot fungi, polygalacturonase and oxalic acid formation are also induced by pectin. The enzyme and oxalic acid may act synergistically to hydrolyse pectin in pit membranes and middle lamellae (Green et al., 1995). Here, a possible involvement of calcium oxalate should be alluded to since calcium is mainly located as calcium pectate in middle lamellae. Thus, in pectin degradation, the calcium is removed by calcium oxalate formation, which may perturb cell wall structure, perhaps favouring entry of lignocellulosic enzymes
63
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
(Dutton ef al., 1993).However, there are relatively few reports on pectinase production by wood-rotting fungi (Dutton and Evans, 1996). In white-rot fungi, the low production of oxalic acid observed has been explained as a result of the presence of oxalate decarboxylase, which degrades oxalate to formate and CO, (Micales, 1995b; Green and Highley, 1997). However, decomposition of oxalate is also a result of interactions with whiterot lignin and manganese peroxidases. In the absence of oxalate, veratryl alcohol and Mn(I1) are oxidized by lignin peroxidase (Lip) and manganese peroxidase (MnP), respectively, producing veratrylaldehyde (VA) and Mn(II1). Such a system is metal regulated because high [Mn] induces the MnP system, while repressing the Lip system. At low [Mn], MnP is repressed and Lip is induced (Perez and Jeffries, 1993). However, if oxalate is present, VA cation radicals and Mn(II1) are reduced back to the substrate level by oxalate which, at the same time, yields CO, and formate radicals; these are further oxidized to superoxide anion radicals under aerobic conditions (Fig. 9) (Shimada et al., CH20H
LiP or MnP
[Mn3+] or
c02 O * - x +
02
co2:
700-
coo-
[VAtl
6
or
[Mn3+]
OCH3 OCH3
Figure 9 Reaction mechanisms for oxidative decomposition of oxalate by lignindegrading systems with lignin peroxidase (Lip) and manganese-dependent peroxidase (MnP) (adapted from Shimada ef a[., 1997). In the absence of oxalate, veratryl alcohol (VA) and Mn(I1) are oxidized by LIP or MnP, respectively, to veratraldehyde via VA cation radicals and Mn(II1). In the presence of oxalate, VA cation radicals and Mn(II1) are reduced back to the substrate level with production of CO, and formate radical, which further results in superoxide anion radicals. Thus, lignin degradation can be inhibited by the presence of oxalate.
64
GEOFFREY M. GADD
1997).The oxalate is important in Lip repression at high [Mn] because, as long as Mn(I1) and Mn(II1) are kept in solution by chelation, repression continues. However, Mn(IV)02 is eventually precipitated, which relieves repression and allows lignin degradation to proceed (Perez and Jeffries, 1993). Thus, in the presence of oxalate, lignin degradation is inhibited and this has been shown to be non-competitive in nature, both for VA and Mn(I1) oxidation (Akamatsu et al., 1990; Popp et al., 1990; Ma et al., 1992; Shah et al., 1992; Shimada et al., 1997). Despite this, the formation of superoxide anion radicals will lead to H202production (see above). Oxidation of phenolic moieties of lignin is not inhibited by oxalate and if these accumulate, lignin degradation may be inhibited (Akamatsu et al., 1990). The presence of oxalate decarboxylase and phenol oxidase (laccase) in white-rot fungi may provide a mechanism for removal of oxalate and phenolics, so that the Lip system may function adequately (Shimada et al., 1997).Apart from the roles described, oxalate also acts as a Mn chelator and stabilizes Mn(II1) in the MnP system (Perez and Jeffries, 1993; Kishi et al., 1994). This interaction facilitates Mn(II1) dissolution from the Mn(III)-enzyme complex to be followed by Mn(I1I) catalysed oxidation of phenolic components (Popp et al., 1990; Dutton and Evans, 1996; Shimada et al., 1997). 4.2. Plant Pathogenesis
Oxalic acid has been implicated in the phytopathogenesis of several fungi with its effects being due to several mechanisms which may act singly or in concert (Rowe, 1993). The decrease in pH of infected tissues on oxalic acid production may enhance the activity of extracellular lytic enzymes, many of which have pH optima below 5 , as well as being of general detriment to plant tissues (Dutton and Evans, 1996). As mentioned above, some fungi secrete oxalic acid with cell wall degrading enzymes, and this may assist the solubilization of pectin in membranes in the middle lamellae (Green et al., 1995). The occurrence of calcium oxalate in necrotic plant tissue infected by numerous fungal plant pathogens (Punja and Jenkins, 1984a) provides further evidence for the important role of oxalic acid in calcium removal, which in turn allows polygalacturonase to hydrolyse pectates more easily (Green et al., 1995; Dutton and Evans, 1996). Interestingly, mutants of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum that are unable to synthesize oxalic acid were, in contrast to wild-type strains, non-pathogenic in bioassays (Godoy et al., 1990),while plant cultivars resistant to S. sclerotiorum were more oxalic acid-tolerant than sensitive cultivars (Noyes and Hancock, 198l). Several other similar examples occur in the literature (Kritzman et al., 1977; Havir and Anagnostakis, 1983; Marciano et al., 1983; Wang and Tewari, 1990; Callahan and Rowe, 1991). Numerous other debilitating or toxic effects of oxalic acid have also been
65
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
documented. These include calcium removal from plasma membranes, copper removal causing inhibition of enzymes, such as polyphenol oxidase, and magnesium oxalate formation arising from Mg removal from ribosomal subunits, enzymes, ATP and chlorophyll (Rao and Tewari, 1989; Ferrar and Walker, 1993).
5. CATABOLISM OF OXALlC ACID
Oxalic acid is decarboxylated by oxalate decarboxylase to CO, and formate: (COOH),
+ CO, + HCOOH
(1 1)
The formate may subsequently be dehydrogenated by formate dehydrogenase, yielding NADH and CO, (Shimada et al., 1997). Oxygen-requiring oxalate decarboxylase is found in a variety of fungi. In some wood-rotting basidiomycetes, oxalate decarboxylase is induced by the presence of oxalic acid (Magro et al., 1988; Mehta and Datta, 1991; Dutton et al., 1994; Micales, 1997), although in Aspergillus niger, the enzyme was non-inducible and only synthesized when the culture pH fell below 2.5 (Emiliani and Bekes, 1964). The optimum pH for oxalate decarboxylase is in the range pH 1.75-2.20 (Micales, 1995b). In Coriolus versicolor, oxalate decarboxylase was found intracellularly and extracellularly: secretion occurred at the end of exponential growth, which accounts for the lack of detectable oxalate in the medium at this growth stage. However, oxalate levels rose after this because the pH of the medium became too high for oxalate decarboxylase activity (Dutton et al., 1994). Addition of calcium carbonate to medium, which raises the pH, also inhibits oxalate decarboxylase activity (Takao, 1965). In Postia placenta, oxalate decarboxylase was induced by growth inhibitory concentrations of oxalic acid in low- and highdecay isolates, and was associated with the hyphal surface and hyphal sheath (Micales, 1997). The oxalate decarboxylase-mediated prevention of oxalate overproduction may maintain a non-toxic, low pH microenvironment which facilitates decay (Micales, 1997). Such a process may be enhanced by the formate produced during oxalic acid breakdown combining with the remaining oxalic acid to form a low pH buffer (Agosin et al., 1989).
0. FUNGAL BIOSYNTHESIS OF CITRIC ACID
Citric acid is an intermediate in the TCA cycle and therefore is ubiquitous in living organisms. It is extensively used in the food and beverage industry and
66
GEOFFREY M.GADD Acetyl-CoA ,
Figure 10 Citrate formation from gluocose via anaplerotic CO, fixation (see Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999).
is produced predominantly by A. niger. World annual production is estimated around 40 000 tons (Roehr et al., 1992). It forms complexes with metals (Fe, Cu) and is therefore used for stabilization of oils and fats, and to prevent metal-ion catalysed oxidation of ascorbic acid (Kubicek, 1998).A. niger forms citric acid by the conversion of pyruvate, which arises from glycolytic catabolism of glucose to the precursor of citrate, oxaloacetate (Roehr et al., 1996; Kubicek, 1998).A key step in this process is the use of 1 mol pyruvate (of the 2 mol arising from glycolytic conversion of 1 mol glucose) and the CO, released during acetyl CoA formation to form oxaloacetate (Fig. 10). If oxaloacetate was only formed by one turn of the TCA cycle, 2 mol CO, would be lost and only two-thirds of the glucose carbon would give rise to citric acid. Such anaplerotic CO, fixation is catalysed by pyruvate carboxylase, itself induced by high carbohydrate concentrations, and this explains high commercial yields of citric acid (Kubicek, 1998). In A. niger, pyruvate carboxylase is cytosolic in location (Bercovitz et al., 1990) and pyruvate is directly converted to oxaloacetate and then to malate by malate dehydrogenase (Ma et al., 1981). It is thought that cytosolic malate is the co-substrate of the mitochondrial tricarboxylic acid carrier and enhanced intracellular malate may therefore stimulate citrate export from mitochondria (Kubicek, 1988, 1998). A. niger possesses a further glucose catabolism pathway catalysed by glucose oxidase, which converts glucose to gluconic acid, and this enzyme is induced by high glucose concentrations and aeration (Dronawat et al., 1995; Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999). Therefore, gluconic acid may also be present at least at the initial phase of a citric acid fermentation, although glucose oxidase (extracellular) is eventually inactivated once the pH falls below 3.5 (Mischak er al., 1985).A. niger may also produce oxalic acid as a by-product of citric acid fermentation, depending on whether glucose or citric acid is used as the carbon source (see elsewhere) (Kubicek, 1988; Kubicek et al., 1988; Wolschek and Kubicek, 1999). The concentration and kind of carbon source are important parameters for citric acid production, and only easily assimilated sugars allow both high yields and rates of citric acid production (Kubicek and Roehr, 1986). Other important factors include dissolved oxygen tension and aeration (Kubicek et
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
67
al., 1998), pH (Kubicek and Roehr, 1986), nitrogen source (Dawson et al., 1989; Choe and Yoo, 1991; Yigitoglu and McNeil, 1992), phosphate and the presence of certain metals (see below) (Kubicek, 1998). Citric acid is reported to appear in large amounts when the pH falls below 2.5. Such a low pH may influence the growth phase and pH <3.5 may inactivate glucose oxidase, which would otherwise convert some of the glucose into gluconic acid (Mischak et al., 1985; Roukas and Harvey, 1988). Other pH effects may include effects on citrate transport and activity of the plasma membrane H+-ATPase (Mattey et al., 1988; Mattey, 1992). 6.1. Role of Metals in Citric Acid Production
The influence of metals can be so important that this can be regarded as the key to a successful submerged fermentation in an industrial context (Kubicek, 1998). Growth-limiting concentrations of Mn, Fe and Zn are essential to achieve high yields of citric acid; for example, Mn concentrations as low as 2 pg 1-’ can reduce acid production by 20% (Clark et al., 1966). Because of such effects, industrial carbon sources may need to be rendered ‘metal-free’ before use or apparently antagonistic substances, such as copper, lower alcohols or lipids, are added (Kubicek, 1998). Since the available Mn2+is too low to activate divalent cation dependent enzymes, such as isocitrate dehydrogenase, it seems that a metabolic step is affected that requires bound rather than free Mn2+(the converse appears to be the case for Zn2+and Fe2+)(Kubicek, 1998). Although it has been suggested that Mn deficiency impairs DNA and protein synthesis (Ma et al., 1985; Hockertz et al., 1987), this is not the only metabolic effect: inhibition of triglyceride and phospholipid synthesis has also been observed (Orthofer et al., 1979; Kubicek and Roehr, 1986; Jernecjc et al., 1989; Meixner et al., 1985). The latter may have consequences for membrane permeability and relevant transport processes: increased citrate efflux has been observed under Mn2+limitation, while citrate uptake from the medium was detected only in A. niger precultivated in Mn-replete medium (Netik et al., 1997). In addition, measurement of citrate uptake required the presence of Mn2+in the assay and was also inhibited by ethylenediamine tetra-acetic acid (EDTA). The Mn2+requirement could partially be replaced by Mg2+,Fe2+or Zn2+, although it was inhibited by Cu2+ (Netik et al., 1997). The effect of Cu2+may be due to inhibition of Mn2+uptake, which can occur via a specific system in A . niger (Hockertz et al., 1988; Seehaus et al., 1990). It is hypothesized that the citrate uptake system depends on Mn2+symport or, more likely, requires metal ion-complexed citrate. For export, since Mn2+deficiency can lead to changes in membrane lipid composition (Meixner et al., 1985), it has been speculated that this leads to ‘carrier inversion’, where an uptake system pumps citrate out of the cells (Netik et al., 1997). This carrier-inversion
68
GEOFFREY M. GADD
hypothesis may also explain the antagonistic effect of lower alcohols and fatty acids on the presence of Mn2+in fermentation substrates (Kubicek and Roehr, 1986). Such a reciprocal regulation of citrate uptake or export by Mn2+has obvious nutritional consequences for the organism (Netik et al., 1997). Mn deficiency also causes gross morphological alterations in A. niger with the production of bulbous, highly branched, vacuolate mycelia with thickened cell walls (Kisser et al., 1980). Such a morphology fortuitously provides better rheology and enables higher oxygen transfer in citric acid fermentations (Olsvik et al., 1993; Fujita et al., 1994; Iwahori et al., 1995). Interestingly, the addition of calcium (0.5 gl-I CaC1,) to the medium of citric acid-producing A. niger reduced biomass yield but increased citric acid production, with the induction of a pelleted growth form, and increased branching and bulbous cells. It was thought that a cytotoxic effect of citric acid may be involved in these morphological changes (Pera and Callieri, 1997). The effect of Fe is less clear and it is possible that any observed effects are due to contaminating Mn (Kubicek and Roehr, 1986). The mechanism of the Zn2+effect on citric acid production, which is not as pronounced as that of Mn, is similarly uncertain.
7. FUNGAL ORGANIC ACID PRODUCTION AND METAL BIOGEOCHEMISTRY 7.1. Metal Solubilization and Anion Mobility
Solubilization of insoluble metal compounds is an important but unappreciated, aspect of fungal physiology for the release of anions, such as phosphate, and essential metal cations into forms available for intracellular uptake and also into biogeochemical cycles. Fungal solubilization of insoluble metal compounds, including certain oxides, phosphates, sulphides and mineral ores, and leaching of metals from soil and other solids, can occur by several mechanisms, with organic acids occupying a central position in the overall process. Solubilization can occur by protonation of the anion of the metal compound, decreasing its availability to the cation, with nutrient-proton antiport the plasma membrane proton-translocatingATPase and the production of organic acids acting as sources of protons for ‘acidolysis’(Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993; Gadd, 1993; Sayer et al., 1995; Karamushka et al., 1996; Morley et al., 1996; Dixon-Hardy et al., 1998). In addition, organic acid anions are frequently capable of soluble complex formation (‘complexolysis’) with metal cations thereby increasing mobility (Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993; White et al., 1997). Such complexation is dependent on the relative concentrations of the anions and metals in solution, pH and the stability constants of the various complexes (Densvre et al., 1996). Another example of organic acid-mediated
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
69
solubilization is ‘redoxolysis’, where oxalic acid can effect the reduction of Fe(II1) to Fe(I1) thus increasing iron solubility (Ghiorse, 1988). A further mechanism of metal solubilization is the production of low molecular weight iron-chelating siderophores that specifically solubilize Fe(II1). Siderophores are the most common means of acquisition of iron by fungi, the most common fungal siderophore being femchrome (Crichton, 1991).Using a simple screening method based on observing clear zones of solubilization around colonies growing on solid medium amended with the desired insoluble metal compound (Jones et al., 1991; Lapeyrie et al., 1991; Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993; Sayer et al., 1995), the incidence of metal-solubilizing ability among natural soil fungal communities appears to be high; in one study approximately one-third of the isolates tested were able to solubilize at least one of Co3(P04),, ZnO or Zn,(PO,), and approximately one-tenth were able to solubilize all three compounds (Sayer et al., 1995). Using this method, A. niger was found to be capable of solubilizing a wide range of insoluble metal compounds, including CdS, Cu,(PO,),, nickel phosphate, manganese sulphide and metal-bearing mineral ores, including cuprite (CuS), rhodochrosite [Mn(CO,),] (Sayer et al., 1997) and gypsum (CaS0,.2H20) (Gharieb et al., 1998). A range of low molecular weight organic acids, including oxalic, formic, citric, malic and acetic acids, are found in soil and derive from a number of sources which include organic matter decomposition, plant root exudates, and fungal and bacterial metabolite production (Song and Huang, 1988; Berthelin etal., 1991; Drever, 1994).As described earlier, such acids can have profound effects on the speciation and mobility of metals, with resultant consequences for biogeochemical cycles, microbial and plant nutrition, and nutrient cycling. As well as influences on metal solubility, organic acids can also increase the availability of phosphate and sulphate (Evans and Anderson, 1990; Drever and Vance, 1994; Cajuste et al., 1996; Gharieb et al., 1998). Most phosphate fertilizers are applied in a solid form (e.g. calcium phosphate) and need to be solubilized before becoming available to plants and other organisms (Asea et al., 1988; Kucey, 1988; Leyval et al., 1993; Bojinova et al., 1997). Increased phosphate uptake by mycorrhizal plants is believed to be due to the high phosphate-solubilizing ability of the mycorrhizal symbionts (Lapeyrie et al., 1991) and, in Canada, a formulation containing spores of Penicillium bilaii has been registered for application to crops because it is believed that the phosphate-solubilizing ability of the fungus (Asea et al., 1988) will improve crop productivity (Cunningham and Kuiack, 1992). This organism produces both citric and oxalic acid, with citric acid being produced under nitrogen limitation and oxalic acid under carbon limitation (Cunningham and Kuiack, 1992). As mentioned earlier, protons which arise from other mechanisms also contribute to metal (and phosphate) solubilization in addition to the action of the organic acids: in the absence of organic acid production, proton excretion which
70
GEOFFREY M. GADD
accompanied NH,+assimilation was important in AlPO, and calcium phosphate solubilization (Lapeyrie et al., 1991; Illmer and Schinner, 1992, 1995; Illmer et al., 1995). Soil fungi, including mycorrhizas, may increase inorganic nutrient availability to plants and other microorganisms by increasing the mobility of essential metal cations and other anions, e.g. sulphate (Gharieb et al., 1998). It is significant that root infection is favoured in nutrient-deficient soils, and this promotes increased growth of the host plant. It is believed that mycorrhizas provide host plants with growth-limiting resources at the stages in their growth when they are most required (Read, 1991). Solubilization may therefore be important for the release of essential metal ions to plants. Oxalate is a common low molecular weight organic anion in many soils; it is sometimes dominant (Graustein et al., 1977), and this increases the solubility of both P and Al, thus influencing nutrient availability and soil weathering (Fox and Comerford, 1990, 1992). Oxalate concentrations in the soil solution can range from 25 to 1000 p~ in forest soils, and oxalate may be the only low molecular weight organic acid found in non-rhizosphere soil (Fox and Comerford, 1990). Ligand-exchange reactions at oxide surfaces directly release P, while surface complexation also enhances dissolution of Al-oxide surfaces, increasing both A1 and P solubility. Such solubilization increases as the organic acid anion concentration increases (Fox et al., 1990a,b). Oxalic acid may also solubilize P bound by Ca2+and Fe3+(Cannon et al., 1995; Cajuste et al., 1996) with the process approximating to the model of Jurinak et al. (1986) for oxalate-mediated increase in P solubility from apatite: Ca,(PO,),OH
+ 5H,C,O, + 5CaC,O, + 3H3P0, + H,O
(12)
Similar reactions occur with A1 and Fe phosphate minerals. The occurrence and position of carboxylic and phenolic functional groups on organic acids determines complexing ability, which is thus related to the stability constant of the ligand. P release is generally greater with acids that form stable metal complexes (Fox et al., 1990a,b; Bolan et al., 1994). For Al, log K,, was a good indicator of this and, of several organic acids examined, A1 and P release increased exponentially with increasing values of stability constants (Fox et al., 1990b). Oxalate concentrations are generally higher in the rhizosphere (Fox and Comerford, 1990),which has obvious implications for P availability to the plant (Fox and Comerford, 1992).It has been found that the amounts of A1 and P released are controlled by the cumulative oxalate loading rate, suggesting that continuous release of even small amounts of organic anions could solubilize large amounts of P and A1 on an annual basis (Fox and Comerford, 1992). Oxalic acid is produced by ectomycorrhizalfungi (Graustein et al., 1977) and this may be significant in increasing P availability to host plants (Cannon et al., 1995). Oxalate is a major organic acid produced by Paillus involutus and Pisolinthus tinctorius, with both fungi able to weather a phlogopite mica,
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
71
displacing interlayer K+,Al'+ and/or Mg2+from within the mineral (Paris et al., 1995a). The role of H+ in K+ replacement was invoked with the formation of metal oxalates acting on the multivalent cations (Paris et al., 1996). It was found that I? involutus was a very active oxalate producer under K+ and Mg2+ deficiency, which could explain mineralogical changes that are effected by the fungi and further underline the key role of oxalic acid in weathering in response to nutrient limitation (Comerford et al., 1990; Paris et al., 1996). Oxalic acid from I? involutus is also involved in vermiculite weathering (Paris et al., 1995b).Within mats of Hysterangium crassum, soil oxalate concentrations were higher than in surrounding soil, while the pH was considerably lower (Cromack et al., 1979). Bulk weathering of the clay minerals was more pronounced in these mats than in uncolonized soil, a result again of Fe and A1 solubilization. Similar observations have been made for Hysterangium setchellii and Gauteria monticola in relation to P solubility (Griffiths et al., 1994). Citric acid is also able to increase soluble P - as are other organic acids not discussed in this article, e.g. acetic, formic, lactic, malic and tartaric acids (Bolan et al., 1994; Kpomblekou-A and Tabatabai, 1994); tricarboxylic acids (e.g. citric acid) were more effective than dicarboxylic acids (e.g. oxalic acid) (Bolan et al., 1994). In one study, 1 m~ citric and oxalic acids were more effective than 1 m~ H2S0, in phosphate release from phosphate-containingrocks (Kpomblekou-A and Tabatabai, 1994). The complexing ability of oxalate and its effect on A1 mobility is also a factor in secondary-porositydevelopment in sandstones during diagenesis by increasing feldspar solubility and dissolution rate (Huang and Longo, 1992; Franklin et al., 1994). Similar observations on increases in mineral solubility and dissolution kinetics have also been made at lower 'room' temperatures for feldspar (Manley and Evans, 1986; Mast and Drever, 1987; Amrhein and Suarez, 1988; Drever and Stillings, 1997). In some of these studies, the higher dissolution rates in the presence of organic acids were concluded to be a result of H+ activity rather than complexation (Manley and Evans, 1986), while dissolution rates were proportional to the A1 content (Amrhein and Suarez, 1988; Stillings et al., 1996). Dissolution kinetics of kaolinite were also increased by oxalate (Chin and Mills, 1991). Although organic acids may accelerate dissolution by lowering pH, this may be significant only below approximately pH 5 (Drever and Stillings, 1997). Quartz dissolution and iron crystallite formation are also associated with fungal-derived oxalic acid (Feldmann, 1997; Feldmann et al., 1997).Although gross concentrations of organic anions in the soil solution may appear insufficient to cause significant increases in dissolution rates of silicate minerals, higher concentrations are likely to be present in microenvironments surrounding fungal hyphae (Drever and Stillings, 1997); it should also be noted that individual organic acids in the soil solution can exceed millimolar concentrations (Stevenson, 1967), with extremely high concentrations in the vicinity of certain plants and fungal hyphae (Cromack et al.,
72
GEOFFREY M. GADD
1979; Gardner et al., 1983). It is now known that weatherable minerals under many European coniferous forests contain a network of pores, believed to be formed by fungal excretion of organic acids. Symbiotic mycorrhizal hyphae could translocate dissolved minerals from these pores directly to the plants, and thus avoid nutrient competition with other microbes (Jongmans et al., 1997). The pores are about 3-10 pm, sometimes containing hyphae, and widespread in feldspars and horneblendes from a variety of locations. Organic acid concentrations in the soil ranged from micromolar to millimolar and included citrate and oxalate: it was calculated that calcium-rich feldspars could be dissolved to form pores at the rate of 0.3-30 pm year' (Jongmans et al., 1997). Solubilization of insoluble toxic metal compounds in the environment can have adverse effects if potentially toxic metal ions are released into the soil and/or water systems from metal-contaminatedlocations (Francis et al., 1992). It has been suggested that certain microbiological solubilization processes, including proton efflux, are included in the safety assessment of waste repositories (Arter et al., 1991). Metal-citrate complexes are highly mobile and are not readily degraded (Francis et al., 1992). Brynhildsen and Rosswall(l996) have found that citrate degradation by mixed microbial cultures from soil extracts was completely inhibited when the acid was bound to Zn, Cu or Co, and partly inhibited when bound to Al, although degradation of Cu and Zn citrate complexes was unaffected in soil. Some rock phosphate fertilizers contain Cd, and solubilization of these to release the phosphate could also release Cd, increasing its availability to the soil biota (Leyval et al., 1993). Metal-contaminated mining areas are often revegetated to help stabilize soils and reduce runoff and wind erosion. The production of organic acids and other metabolites by rhizosphere microorganisms in such locations can also influence metal mobility, especially when the soil microflora have not been completely restored (Banks et al., 1994a,b). 7.2. Role of Organic Acids in Corrosion of Stone and Building Materials
Microbial organic acid production can lead to corrosion of building materials (Little etal., 1994; Douglas and Singh, 1995) and stone monuments (Hirsch et al., 1995; Garcia-Valles et al., 1996). A wide range of organisms can cause changes in the surface layers of rocks, with organic acid production an important component of the overall process (Berthelin, 1983).Acidogenic fungi can cause extensive deterioration of clays, micas and feldspars due to production of oxalic, citric and gluconic acids (De la Torre et al., 1993). Different groups of organisms appear to act synergistically in stone deterioration with algal/cyanobacterial lysis providing nutrients for heterotrophs, and
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
73
development of more complex microbial communities.Fungal strains isolated from weathered sandstone included oxalic, fumaric and succinic acidproducing strains of Penicillium and Fusarium, with Penicillium corylophilum producing oxalic acid only when cultured in the presence of the alga Monoraphidium braunii (Gomez-Alarconet al., 1994). In other studies, fungi isolated from sandstone produced citric, glutamic, pyruvic, malic, succinic, lactic, formic, fumaric and oxalic acids in laboratory culture; many of these acids could also be extracted from rock samples (Hirsch et al., 1995). Fungalproduced organic acids are also capable of cement degradation, a phenomenon of relevance to deterioration of building materials and also nuclear waste repositories. Minerals in cement, e.g. hydrated calcium silicate and Ca(OH),, were readily degraded by alkalophilic strains of A. niger and Mycelia sterilia producing oxalic, gluconic and malic acids (Perfettini et al., 1991). Oxalic acid production is also involved in the corrosion of stonework by lichens. Physical and chemical changes to stonework of ancient monuments, such as fracturing and encrustation can lead to biodeterioration, with calcium oxalate (whewellite and weddelite) being a significant chemical component in surface patinas, particularly on limestone (Edwards et al., 1992, 1994; Russ et al., 1996).Weddelite has been proposed to serve as a water-absorbing substrate which transforms to whewellite when the humidity falls (Lamprecht et al., 1997).At the thallus-substrate interface, oxalic and polyphenolic lichen acids are produced by the fungal symbiont, which act to remove metals from the mineral substrate while carbonic acid arises from CO, produced in respiration. Calcium oxalate can be a major constituent of lichen thallus encrustation, as well as calcium carbonate in some cases (Edwards et al., 1992, 1994, 1995, 1997; Prieto et al., 1997). The nature of the metal oxalate may depend on the chemical composition of the rock (Edwards and Lewis, 1994). For example, Pertusaria corallina produces calcium oxalate on a basalt substrate but magnesium oxalate forms during growth of Lecanora a m on serpentine (Edwards and Lewis, 1994). Hydrated copper oxalate, moolooite CuC,O,.nH,O (n-0.4-0.7), is found as vivid blue inclusions in whewellite or weddelite occurring within the medulla of four lichen species growing on copper-bearing rocks (Chisholm et al., 1987). In some copper-tolerant lichen species, the copper oxalate content can reach 5% of the thallus dry weight (Purvis, 1984). Calcium oxalate is also located on the surface of many lichens, as well as within the thallus and at the thallus-rock interface, and these may persist even after death. Within such lichen encrustations, which can be up to 2 mm thick, further deterioration can result in changes in the hydration state of the calcium oxalate (Edwards and Lewis, 1994). On granite, a monolayered or multilayered patina can arise from surface biofilm activity, mineral deposition and dust trapping, which can be regarded as a microstromatolitic structure, containing calcite, calcium oxalate, gypsum and calcium phosphate as main minerals, and deduced to be produced by the stromatolite-forming microorganisms
74
GEOFFREY M. GADD
(Blazquez et al., 1997). Oxalate has been shown to be the only organic acid detectable in cryptoendolithic (‘hidden-in-rock’), lichen-dominated, microbial communities in Antarctica with a proposed significant role in affecting dissolution of Si, Fe, Al, P and K (Johnston and Vestal, 1993). 7.3. Role of Fungal Oxalato in Limestone Biomineralization
Fungi can play a significant role in limestone diagenesis in semi-arid regions where large areas of limestones and carbonate soils are cemented by calcite (Verrecchia et al., 1990). Weathered profiles that develop on chalky parent rocks in arid regions usually include a layer called a ‘platy calichekalcrete’ or ‘platy zone’ (Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996). While physical and chemical phenomena contribute to this process, the most abundant organic feature is mineralized fungal hyphae and it is now realized that fungal activity is of fundamental importance to the mineral dynamics of the porekarbonate system. Fungal hyphae are present in the pores, which range in diameter from several micrometres to several hundred micrometres (Verrecchia et al., 1990,1993). The hyphae that develop in the pores of the limestone are encrusted with sharp crystalline spikes exterior to the hyphae. Up to around 80% of the limestone micropores are inhabited by fungi and, in some places, pores are partly infilled with needle-fibre calcite (Verrecchia et al., 1990) with the matrix around the pore being enriched in CaCO,; this is sometimes recrystallized and separated from the pore by a mat of calcite crystals (Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996). The crystals, often needle-like but showing a variety of morphologies, are calcium oxalate monohydrate (whewellite) and arise from oxalic acid production by the fungi, itself promoted by alkaline conditions, and subsequent precipitation of calcium oxalate:
In the absence of fungal hyphae, the calcite needles have different forms, and the fungi are clearly altering the mineral dynamics of the porekarbonate microsystem (Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996). It is likely that polyhydrate oxalates form first and, after dehydration, evolve into the monohydrate (Verrecchia et al., 1993). A biogeochemical model of this system proposes that organic acid excretion, and calcium oxalate formation, leads to dissolution of the internal pore walls so that the solution becomes enriched in dissolved carbonates. During passage of this solution through the pore walls, CaCO, recrystallizes owing to a decrease in pCO,, which contributes to hardening of the material. Subsequent biodegradation of the oxalate as a result of microbial activity leads to
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
75
Figure I I Mechanisms involved in the pore-fungus-carbonate-oxalate system (adapted from Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996). H = fungal hypha and associated crystals of calcium oxalate; MH = mineralized fungal hypha containing crystals of needle-fibre calcite (NFC). After decomposition, NFC is freed within the pore system. CaCO, (sec.) (shaded area) = a secondary CaCO, cement arising from either precipitation in the soil solution or transformation of oxalate. The stippled area denotes clay and quasi-coatings. The processes shown lead to the eventual closing of the system, and cementation of chalky material and calcretes in surficial and semi-arid environments.
76
GEOFFREY M. GADD
transformation into carbonate, which results in precipitation of calcite in the pore interior or periphery, the latter ultimately leading to closure of the pore system and hardening of the chalky parent material (Fig. 1 1) (Verrecchia et al., 1990;Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996). The final stage is conversion of calcium oxalate into calcium carbonate by diagenesis:
Many soil microorganisms can convert calcium oxalate to calcium carbonate (Graustein et al., 1977) and this process increases secondary calcium carbonate cementation. Ultimately, the pores become completely filled and a hard limestone (‘desert crust’) results (Verrecchia, 1990; Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996). During decomposition of hyphae, associated calcite crystals are released and these can act as sites of further secondary calcite precipitation (Verrecchia et al., 1993;Verrecchia and Verrecchia, 1994). Thus, fungal activity, in influencing cation mobility and acidification, is an important factor in early lithification, alteration and diagenesis of terrestrial subsurface limestones (Verrecchia and Dumont, 1996).
8. FUNGAL ORGANIC ACID PRODUCTION AND METAL
BIOTECHNOLOGY 8.1. Metal Solubilization for Recovery and Bioremediation
The fungal removal or leaching of metals (‘heterotrophic leaching’) from industrial wastes and by-products, low-grade ores (Dave and Natarajan, 1981 ; Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993) and metal-bearing minerals (Tzeferis et al., 1994; Drever and Stillings, 1997), is a process relevant to metal recovery and recycling and/or bioremediation of contaminated solid wastes (Groudev, 1987; Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993; Hahn et al., 1993; Krebs et al., 1997; White et al., 1997). It should also be noted that heterotrophic leaching may also have application to biotechnological recovery of phosphate (or indeed other solubilized anions) from rock phosphate or other sources (Parks er al., 1990; Vassilev et al., 1995, 1997; Bojinova et al., 1997). Most biological leaching processes utilize chemoautotrophic bacteria, particularly Thiobacillus spp. (Ewart and Hughes, 1991). However, the pH of culture media may be increased by many industrial metal-containing wastes, such as filter dusdoxides from metal processing, and most thiobacilli cannot solubilize metals effectively above pH 5.5, the optimum being pH 2.4 (Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993). Although fungi need aeration and a carbon source, they can function at higher pH values and so could have potential where leaching with bacteria is not possible. However,
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
77
fungi may not readily be used in situ, and their use in specific bioreactors is generally envisaged. Leaching of metals with fungi can be very effective, although a high level of organic acid production may need to be maintained. For example, laboratory-scale leaching of Ni, Co and Mn from low-grade laterite ores has been carried out using strains of Aspergillus and Penicillium (Tzeferis et al., 1994; Sukla e f al., 1995). Leaching of 55-6096 Ni was achieved when the fungi were grown in the presence of the ore, and 70% was leached at high temperature (95 "C)by the application of metabolites produced on cultivation of the fungi at 3OoC in a glucose and sucrose medium (Tzeferis, 1994). Heterotrophic leaching by fungi can occur as a result of several processes, including the production of protons, and siderophores (in the case of iron). In most fungal strains, however, leaching occurs mainly by the production of organic acids which provide a source of protons and complexing organic acid anions (Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993; Muller et al., 1995; Sayer and Gadd, 1997). The pH of non-regulated A. niger cultures can fall to values between 1.5 and 2.0 owing to high citric acid production, the optimal pH for citric acid production being below 3.5 (Schrickx et d., 1995). As discussed previously, organic acid production can be manipulated by changes in culture conditions (Xu et al., 1989; Schrickx et al., 1995; Dixon-Hardy et al., 1998). For example, manganese deficiency M) leads to the production of large amounts of citric acid by A. niger (Meixner et al., 1985), and industrial concentrations of citric acid produced by A. niger can reach 600 m~ (Mattey, 1992). Oxalic acid production can also be manipulated for solubilization of metals such as A1 and Fe: up to -430 m~ oxalic acid was excreted in a stirred-tank reactor controlled at pH 6. While both gluconic and oxalic acid were produced on sucrose, only oxalic acid was produced on lactose permeate, a low-cost carbon substrate (Strasser et al., 1994). Fly ash from municipal waste incineration contains a variety of metals (Cd, Zn, Ni, Pb and Cu), with A1 and Zn in particular being present in amounts considered economical for recovery (Singer et al., 1982;Torma and Singh, 1993; Bosshard et at., 1996).A. niger produced gluconate in the presence of fly ash but citric acid in its absence; variation in fly ash concentration resulted in varying amounts of solubilized metals. A two-step process, where citric acid produced by controlled growth of A. niger was used as the leaching agent, provided a leaching system only marginally less efficient than leaching with commercial citric acid of equal molarity (Bosshard et al., 1996). A strain of Penicillium simplicissimum isolated from a metal-contaminated site devel) the presence of metal oped the ability to produce citric acid (> 1 0 0 m ~in contaminants, and has been used successfully to leach Zn from insoluble ZnO contained in industrial filter dust (Schinner and Burgstaller, 1989; Franz et al., 1993; Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993). Acidolysis was found to be the main ZnO solubilization mechanism.
78
GEOFFREY M.GADD
ZnO + 2H+ + Zn2++ H,O
(15)
with the protons from the citric acid produced being responsible for nearly all the solubilization,prior to possible formation of a zinc citrate complex, which may prevent Zn2+toxicity (Burgstaller et al., 1992). Citric acid efflux is enhanced in t? simplicissirnum by the presence of filter dust andor zinc oxide, an effect of the high buffering capacity of zinc oxide (Franz et al., 1991; Burgstaller et al., 1994). Biological leaching of red mud, a chemical waste produced by alkaline extraction of alumina from bauxite, has been examined with t? simplicissimum, the most efficient fungus for solubilization of A1 (1880 mg I-’ at 3% (v/v) red mud) (Vachon et al., 1994). However, 75% of A1 present (10585 mg I-’) was leached from 10%(v/v) red mud, an amount greater than that achieved using pure commercial citric acid. The authors concluded that biologically produced organic acids did provide a feasible possibility for industrial-scale extraction (Vachon et al., 1994). Culture filtrates from A. niger have also been used to leach Cu, Ni and Co from copper converter slag (Sukla et al., 1992). If necessary, metal-citrate complexes could eventually be degraded for ultimate metal recovery (Francis, 1994). Another possible application or effect of fungal metal solubilization could be the removal of unwanted contaminants, such as phosphates (Burgstaller and Schinner, 1993), while interaction of leaching technologies with biosorption is also a possibility (Gadd, 1993; Tobin et al., 1994). Another related bioremediation scheme uses commercial citric acid to remove metals and radionuclides from contaminated wastes by forming watersoluble metal citrate complexes. The resulting metal citrate complexes are then microbially and photochemically degraded and the metals recovered in concentrated form with the degrading bacterial biomass (Francis et al., 1992; Francis and Dodge, 1994; Dodge and Francis, 1994).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author gratefully acknowledges research support from the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (SPC 028 12), the Royal Society (London), the Royal Society of Edinburgh, NATO (Envir. LG 950387) and the Nuffield Foundation. Thanks are also due to Dr Jacqueline Sayer, Dr Mohammed Gharieb, Dr Victor Karamushka, and Amanda Whatley and Karen Tait for their sterling contributions on various aspects of metal-fungal-organic acid interactions. Martins Kierans and Margaret Gruber are also acknowledged for assistance with scanning electron microscopy and photography.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
79
Agosin, E., Jarpa, S., Rojas, E. and Espejo, E. (1989) Solid-state fermentation of pine sawdust by selected brown-rot fungi. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 11, 51 1-517. Akamatsu, Y.(1993) Enzymatic formation of oxalic acid from glyoxylic acid with cell-free extracts of Tyromyces palustris. J. Jpn. Wood Res. SOC. 39, 860-862. Akamatsu, Y., Ma, D.B., Higuchi, T. and Shimada, M. (1990) A novel enzymatic decarboxylation of oxalic acid by the lignin peroxidase system of white-rot fungus Phanerochaete chrysosporium. FEBS Lett. 269,26 1-263. Akamatsu, Y., Ohta, A., Takahashi, M. and Shimada, M. (1991) Enzymatic formation of oxalate from oxaloacetase with cell-free extracts of brown-rot fungus Tyromyces palustris in relation to biodegradation of cellulose. J. Jpn. Wood Res. SOC.37,575-577. Akamatsu, Y.,Takahashi, M. and Shimada, M. (1992) Cell-free extraction and assay of oxaloacetase from the brown-rot fungus Tyromyces palustris. J. Jpn. Wood Res. SOC. 38, 495-500. Akamatsu, Y., Takahashi, M. and Shimada, M. (1993a) Influence of various factors on oxaloacetase activity of the brown-rot fungus Tyromyces palustris. J. Jpn. Wood Res. SOC. 39,352-356. Akamatsu, Y., Takahashi, M. and Shimada, M. (1993b) Cell-free extraction of oxaloacetase from white-rot fungi including Coriolus versicolor. Wood.Res. 79, 1-6. Akamatsu, Y.,Takahashi, M. and Shimada, M. (1993~)Influences of various factors on oxaloacetase activity of the brown-rot fungus Tyromyces palustris. J. Jpn. Wood Res. SOC. 39,352-356. Akamatsu, Y.,Takahashi, M. and Shimada, M. (1994) Production of oxalic acid by woodrotting basidiomycetes grown on low and high nitrogen culture media. Muter. Org. 28, 251-264. Allen, M.F., Figueroa, C., Weinbaum, B.S., Barlow, S.B. and Allen, E.B. (1996) Differential production of oxalate by mycorrhizal fungi in arid ecosystems. Biol. Fertil. Soils 22, 287-292. Amrhein, C. and Suarez, D.L. (1988) The use of a surface complexation model to describe the kinetics of ligand-promoted dissolution of anorthite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 52, 2785-2793. Armentrout, V.N., Graves L.B. Jr. and Maxwell, D.P. (1978) Localization of enzymes of oxalate biosynthesis in microbodies of Sclerotium rolfsii. Phytopathology 68, 1597- 1599. Arnott, H.J. (1982) Calcium oxalate (weddelite) crystals in forest litter. Scann. Electron Microsc. P3, 1141-1 149 Amott, H.J. (1995) Calcium oxalate in fungi. In: Calcium Oxalate in Biological Systems (S.R. Khan, ed.), pp. 73-1 11. CRC Press, Boca Raton. Arnott, H.J. and Fryar, A. (1984) Raphide-like crystals from Arlington, Texas compost. Scann. Electron Microsc. IV, 1745-1750. Amott, H.J. and Webb, M.A. (1983) The structure and formation of calcium oxalate crystal deposits on the hyphae of a wood rot fungus. Scann. Electron Microsc. IV, 1747-1758. Arter, H.E., Hanselmann, K.W. and Bachofen, R. (1991) Modelling of microbialdegradation processes - the behaviour of microorganisms in a waste repository. Experientia 47, 542-548. Asea, P.E.A., Kucey, R.M.N. and Stewart, J.W.B. (1988) Inorganic phosphate solubilization by two Penicillium species in solution culture and soil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 20,459464. Balmforth, A.J. and Thomson, A., (1984) Isolation and characterization of glyoxalate dehydrogenase from the fungus Sclerotium rolfsii. Biochem. J. 218, 113-1 18.
80
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Banks, M.K., Waters, C.Y. and Schwabb, A.P. (1994a) Influence of organic acids on leaching of heavy metals from contaminated mine tailings. J. Environ. Sci. Health A29, 1045-1 056. Banks, M.K., Schwabb, A.P., Fleming, G.R. and Herrick, B.A. (1994b)Effects of plants and soil microflora on leaching of zinc from mine tailings. Chemosphere 29, 1691-1699. Basolo, F. and Johnson, R.C. (1964) Coordination Chemistry. The Chemistry ofthe Metal Complexes. W.A. Benjamin Inc., New York. Bennett, A.R. and Hindal, D.F. (1989) Mycelial growth and oxalate production by five strains of Cryphonectria parasitica in selected liquid culture media. Mycologia 81, 554-560. Bercovitz, A., Peleg, Y., Battat, E., Rokem, J.S. and Goldberg. I. (1990) Localisation of pyruvate carboxylase in organic acid producing Aspergillus strains. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 56, 1594-1 597. Berthelin, J. ( 1983) Microbial weathering processes. In: Microbial Geochemistry (W.E. Krumbein, ed.), pp. 223-263. Blackwell, Oxford. Berthelin, J., Leyval, C., Laheurte, F. and De Giudici, P. (1991) Involvements of roots and rhizosphere microflora in the chemical weathering of soil minerals. In: Plant Root Growth: An Ecological Perspective (D. Atkinson, ed.),pp. 187-200. Special Publication Series of the British Ecological Society, No. 10, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. Blazquez, E, Garcia-Valles, M., Krumbein, W.E., Sterflinger, K. and Vendrell-Saz, M. (1997) Microstromatolitic deposits on granitic monuments: development and decay. Eur: J. Mineral. 9, 889-901. Bojinova, D., Velkova, R., Grancharov. I. and Zhelev, S. (1997) The bioconversion of Tunisian phosphorite using Aspergillus niger. Nutrient Cycl. Agroecos. 47,227-232. Bolan, N.S., Naidu, R., Mahimairaja, S . and Baskaran, S. (1994) Influence of low-molecular-weight organic acids on the solubilization of phosphates. BioL. Fertil. Soil. 18, 31 1-319. Bosshard, P.P., Bachofen, R. and Brandl, H. (1996) Metal leaching of fly ash from municipal water incineration by Aspergillus niger. Environ. Sci. Technol. 30,3066-3070. Brynhildsen, L. and Rosswall, T. (1996) Effects of metals on the microbial mineralization of organic acids. Water Air Soil Pollut. 94,45-57. Burgstaller, W. and Schinner, F. (1993) Leaching of metals with fungi. J. Biotechnol. 27, 91-1 16. Burgstaller, W., Strasser, H., Wobking, H. and Schinner, F. (1992) Solubilization of zinc oxide from filter dust with Penicllium simplicissimum: bioreactor leaching and stoichiometry. Environ. Sci. Technol. 26,340-346. Burgstaller, W., Zanella, A. and Schinner, F. (1994) Buffer-stimulated citrate efflux in Penicillium simplicissimum. Arch. Microbiol. 161, 75-8 1. Cairney, J.W.G. (1990) Internal structure of mycelial cords of Agaricus carminescens from Heron Island, Great Barrier Reef. Mycol. Res. 94, 117-1 19. Cairney, J.W.G. and Clipson, N.J.W. (1991) Internal structure of rhizomorphs of Techisporu vaga. Mycol. Res. 95,764-767. Cairney, J.W.G., Jennings, D.H. and Veldtkamp, C.J. (1989) A scanning electron microscope study of the internal structure of mature linear mycelial organs of four basidiomycete species. Can. J. Bot. 67,2266-227 1. Cajuste, L.J., Laird, R.J., Cajuste, B. and Cuevas, B.G. (1996) Citrate and oxalate influence on phosphate, aluminium and iron in tropical soils. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 27, 1377-1386. Callahan, F.E. and Rowe, D.E. (1991) Use of a host-pathogen interaction system to test whether oxalic acid is the sole pathogenic determinant in the exudate of Sclerotinu trifoliorum. Phytopathology 81. 1546-1 550.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
81
Cannon, J.P., Allen, E.B., Allen, M E , Dudley, L.M. and Jurinak, J.J. (1995) The effects of oxalates produced by Salsola tragus on the phosphorus nutrition of Stipa pulchra. Oecologia 102, 265-272. Chang, J.C. (1993) Solubility product constants. In: CRC Handbook of Chemisrry and Physics (D.R. Lide, ed.), p. 39. CRC Press, Boca Raton. Chin, P.K.F. and Mills, G.L. (1991) Kinetics and mechanisms of kaolinite dissolution effects of organic ligands. Chem. Geol. 90, 307-3 17. Chisholm, J.E., Jones, G.C. and Purvis, O.W. (1987) Hydrated copper oxalate, moolooite, in lichens. Mineral. Mag. 51,7 15-7 18. Choe, J. andYoo, Y.J. (199 I ) Effect of ammonium ion concentration and application to fedbatch culture for overproduction of citric acid. J. Ferment. Bioeng. 72, 106-109. Clark, D.S., Ito, K. and Horitsu, H. (1966) Effect of manganese and other heavy metals on submerged citric acid fermentation of molasses. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 8,465-47 I . Comerford, N.B., Harris, W.G. and Lucas, D. (1990). Release of nonexchangeable potassium from a highly weathered forested Quartzipsarnment. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 54, 142 1-1426. Connolly, J.H. and Jellison, J. ( 1 995) Calcium translocation, calcium oxalate accumulation and hyphal sheath morphology in the white-rot fungus Resinicium bicolor. Can. J. Bot. 73,927-936. Connolly, J.H. and Jellison, J. (1997) Two-way translocation of cations by the brown rot fungus Gloeophyllum trabeum. Int. Biodet. Biodeg. 39, 181-188. Connolly, J.H., Chen, Y. and Jellison, J. (1995) Environmental scanning electron microscopic observation of the hyphal sheath and mycofibrils in Postia placenta. Can. J. Microbiol. 41,433437. Crichton, R.R. (199 1 ) Inorganic Biochemistry of Iron Metabolism. Ellis Horwood, Chichester. Cromack, K. Jr, Sollins, P., Graustein, W.C., Speidel, K., Todd, A.W., Spycher, G., Li, C.Y. and Todd, R.L. (1979) Calcium oxalate accumulation and soil weathering in mats of the hypogeous fungus Hysterangium crassurn. Soil Biol. Biochem. 11,463468. Cunningham, J.E. and Kuiack, C. (1992) Production of citric and oxalic acids and solubilization of calcium phosphate by Penicillium bilaii. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 58, 145 1- 1458. Daniel, G. (1994) Use of electron microscopy for aiding our understanding of wood biodegradation. FEMS Microhiol. Rev. 13,219-233. Dave, S.R. and Natarajan, K.A. (1981) Leaching of copper and zinc from oxidised ores by fungi. Hydrometallurgy 7,235-242. Dawson, M.W., Maddox, I.S. and Brooks, J.D. (1989) Evidence for nitrogen catabolite repression during citric acid production by Aspergillus niger under phosphate limited growth conditions. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 33, 1500-1504. De Bary, A. (1 887) Comparative Morphology and Biology of the Fungi, Mycetozoa and Bacteria. Clarendon Press, Oxford. De la Torre, M.A., Gomez-Alarcon, G., Vizcaino, C. and Garcia, M.T. (1993) Biochemical mechanisms of stone alteration carried out by filamentous fungi. Biogeochemistry 19, 129-147. Denevre, 0.. Garbaye, J., and Botton, B. (1996) Release of complexing organic acids by rhizosphere fungi as a factor in Norway Spruce yellowing in acidic soils. Mycol. Res. 100, 1367-1374. Dixon-Hardy, J.E., Karamushka, V.I., Gruzina, T.G., Nikovska, G.N., Sayer, J.A. and Gadd, G.M. (1998) Influence of the carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus source on the solubilization of insoluble metal compounds by Aspergillus niger. Mycol. Res. 102, 1050-1054. Dodge, C.J. and Francis, A.J. (1994) Photodegradation of uranium citrate complex with uranium recovery. Environ. Sci Technol. 28, 1300-1306.
82
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Douglas, J. and Singh, J. (1995) Investigating dry rot in buildings. Building Res. lnjo. 23, 345-352. Drever, 3.1. (1994) The effect of land plants on weathering rates of silicate minerals. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 58,2325-2332. Drever, J.I. and Stillings, L.L. (1997) The role of organic acids in mineral weathering. (2011. SU$ 120, 167-181. Drever, J.I. and Vance, G.F. (1994) Role of soil organic acids in mineral weathering processes. In: Organic Acids in Geological Processes (E.D. Pittman and M.D. Lewan, eds), pp. 138-161. Springer, New York. Dronawat, S.N., Svihla, C.K. and Hanley, T.R. (1995) The effects of agitation and aeration on the production of gluconic acid by Aspergillus niger: Appl. Biochem. Biotechnol. 51/52, 347-354. Dutton, M.V. and Evans, C.S. (1996) Oxalate production by fungi: its role in pathogenicity and ecology in the soil environment. Can. J. Micmbiol. 42, 881-895. Dutton, M.V., Evans, C.S., Atkey, P.T. and Wood, D.A. (1993) Oxalate production by basidiomycetes, including the white-rot species Coriolus versicolor and Phanerochaete chrysosporium. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 39, 5- 10. Dutton, M.V., Kathiara, N., Gallacher, I.M. and Evans, C.S. (1994) Purification and characterisation of oxalate decarboxylase from Coriolus versicolor. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 116,321-326. Edwards, H.G.M. and Lewis, I.R. (1994)FT-Raman spectroscopic studies of metal oxalates and their mixtures. Spectrochim. Acta 50, 189 1-1 898. Edwards, H.G.M., Farwell, D.W., Jenkins, R. and Seaward, M.R.D. (1992) Vibrational Raman spectroscopic studies of calcium oxalate monohydrate and dihydrate in lichen encrustations on Renaissance frescoes. J. Raman Spectrosc. 23, 185-1 89. Edwards, H.G.M., Edwards, K.A.E., Farwell, D.W., Lewis, I.R. and Seaward, M.R.D. ( 1 994) An approach to stone and fresco lichen biodeterioration through Fourier-transform Raman microscopic investigation of thallus substratum encrustations. J. Ruman Spectrosc. 25,99-103. Edwards, H.G.M., Russell, N.C., Seaward, M.R.D. and Slarke, D. (1995) Lichen biodeterioration under different microclimates - an FT Raman-spectroscopic study. Spectrochim. Actu 51,2091-2100. Edwards, H.G.M., Russell, N.C. and Seaward, M.R.D. (1997) Calcium oxalate i n lichen biodeterioration studied using FT-Raman spectroscopy. Spectrochim. Actu 53,99-105. Emiliani, E. and Bekes, P. (1964) Enzymatic oxalate decarboxylation in Aspergillus niger. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 105,488-493. Espejo, E. and Agosin, E. (1991) Production and degradation of oxalic acid by brown-rot fungi. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 57, 1980-1986. Evans, A. and Anderson, T.J. (1990) Aliphatic acids: influence on sulphate mobility in a forested Cecil soil. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 54, 1 136-1 139. Ewart, D.K. and Hughes, M.N. (1991) The extraction of metals from ores using bacteria. Adv. Inorg. Chem. 36, 103-135. Feldmann, M. (1997) Geomicrobial processes in the subsurface: a tribute to Johannes Neher’s work. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 20, 18 1-1 89. Feldmann, M., Neher, J., Jung, W. and Graf, F. (1997) Fungal quartz weathering and iron crystallite formation in an Alpine environment, Piz Alv, Switzerland. Eclogue Geol. Helv. 90, 541-556. Ferrar, P.H. and Walker, J.R.L. (1993) o-Diphenol oxidase inhibition - an additional role for oxalic acid in the phytopathogenic arsenal of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum and Sclerotium mlfsii. Physiol. Mol. Plant Puthol. 43,415-422. Foster, J.W. (1949) Chemical Activities ofFungi. Academic Press, New York.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
83
Fox, T.R. and Comerford, N.B. (1990) Low-molecular-weight organic acids in selected forest soils of the southeastern USA. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. J. 54, 1139-1 144. Fox, T.R. and Comerford, N.B. (1992) Influence of oxalate loading on phosphorus and aluminium solubility in spodosols. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. J. 56, 290-294. Fox, T.R. Comerford, N.B. and McFee, W.W. (1990a) Kinetics of phosphorus release from spodosols: effects of oxalate and formate. Soil Sci. Am. J. 54, 1441-1447. Fox, T.R. Comerford, N.B. and McFee, W.W. (1990b) Phosphorus and aluminium release from a spodic horizon mediated by organic acids. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. J. 54, 1763- 1767. Franceschi, V.R. and Loewus, F.A. (1995) Oxalate biosynthesis and function in plants and fungi. In: Calcium Oxulate in Biological Systems (S.R. Khan, ed.), pp. 113-130. CRC Press, Boca Raton. Francis, A.J. ( 1994) Microbial transformations of radioactive wastes and environmental restoration through bioremediation. J. Alloys Comp. 213/214,226-23 I . Francis, A.J. and Dodge, C.J. (1994) Influence of complex structure on the biodegradation of iron-citrate complexes. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 59, 109-1 13. Francis, A.J., Dodge, C.J. and Gillow, J.B. (1992) Biodegradation of metal citrate complexes and implications for toxic metal mobility. Nature 356, 140-142. Franklin, S.P., Hajash, A., Dewers, T.A. and Tieh, T.T. (1994) The role of carboxylic acids in albite and quartz dissolution: an experimental study under diagenetic conditions. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 58,4259-4279. Franz, A., Burgstaller, W. and Schinner, F. (1991) Leaching with Penicillium simplicissimum: influence of metals and buffers on proton extrusion and citric acid production. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 57, 769-774. Franz, A., Burgstaller, W. Miiller, B. and Schinner, F. (1993) Influence of medium components and metabolic inhibitors on citric acid production by Penicillium simplicissimum. J. Gen. Microbiol. 139, 2101-2107. Fujita, M., Iwahori, K., Tatsuta, S. and Yamakawa, K. (1994) Analysis of pellet formation of Aspergillus niger based on shear stress. J. Ferment. Bioeng. 78, 368-373. Gadd, G.M. (1988) Carbon nutrition and metabolism. In: Physiology of Industrial Fungi (D.R. Berry, ed.), pp. 21-57. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. Gadd. G. M. (1993) Interactions of fungi with toxic metals. New Phytol. 124, 25-60. Gadd, G.M. (1996) Roles of microorganisms in the environmental fate of radionuclides. Endeavour 20, 150-156. Garcia-Valles, M., Blazquez, F., Molera, J. and Vendrell-Saz, M. (1996) Studies of patinas and decay mechanisms leading to the restoration of Sta. Maria de Montblanc (Catalonia, Spain). Stud. Consem. 41, 1-8. Gardner, W.K., Barber, D.A. and Parbery, D.G. (1983) The acquisition of phosphorus by Lupinus albus L.: 111. The probable mechanism by which phosphorus movement in the soil/root interface is enhanced. Plant Soil 70, 107-204. Gharieb, M.M. and Gadd, G.M. (1999) Influence of nitrogen source on the solubilization of natural gypsum (CaS0,.2H20), and the formation of calcium oxalate by different oxalic and citric acid-producing fungi. Mycol. Res. 103, 473481. Gharieb, M.M., Sayer, J.A. and Gadd, G.M. (1998) Solubilization of natural gypsum (CaS0,.2H20) and the formation of calcium oxalate by Aspergillus niger and Serpula himantiodes. Mycol. Res. 102, 825-830. Ghiorse, W.C. (1988) Microbial reduction of manganese and iron. In: Biology ofAnaerobic Microorganisms (A.J.B. Zehnder ed.), pp. 178-210. Wiley, New York. Godoy, G., Steadman, J.R., Dickman, M.B. and Dam, R. (1990) Use of mutants to demonstrate the role of oxalic acid in pathogenicity of Sclemtinia sclerotiorum on Phaseolus vulgaris. Physiol. Mol. Plant Pathol. 37, 179-191.
84
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Gomez-Alarcon, G., Munoz, M.L. and Flores, M. (1994) Excretion of organic acids by fungal strains isolated from decayed sandstone. Int. Biodet. Biodeg. 34, 169-180. Goodwin, D.C., Barr. D.P., Aust, S.D. and Grover, T.A. (1994) The role of oxalate in lignin peroxidase-catalyzed reduction: protection from compound 111 accumulation. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 315,267-272. Graustein, W.C., Cromack, K. Jr and Sollins, P. (1977) Calcium oxalate: occurrence in soils and effects on nutrient and geochemical cycles. Science 198, 1252-1254. Green, F. and Highley, T.L. (1997) Mechanism of brown-rot decay: paradigm or paradox. Int. Biodet. Biodeg. 39, 1 13-1 24. Green, F., Larsen, M.J., Winandy, J.E. and Highley, L. (1991) Role of oxalic acid in incipient brown-rot decay. Mate,: Org. 26, 191-213. Green, F., Clausen, C.A., Kuster, T.A. and Highley, T.L. (1995) Induction of polygalacturonase and the formation of oxalic acid by pectin in brown-rot fungi. World J. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 11,5 19-524. Griftiths, R.P., Baham, J.E. and Caldwell, B.A. (1994) Soil solution chemistry of ectomycorrhizal mats in forest soil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 26, 33 1-337. Groudev, S.N. (1987) Use of heterotrophic microorganisms in mineral biotechnology. Acta Biotechnol. 7 , 299-306. Hahn, M., Willscher, S. and Straube, G. (1993) Copper leaching from industrial wastes by heterotrophic microorganisms. In: Biohydrometaflurgical Technologies, Vol. 1 (A.E. Torma, M.L. Ape1 and C.L. Brierley, eds), pp. 99-108. The Minerals, Metals and Materials Society, Warrendale. Hamlet, W.M. and Plowright, C.B. ( 1 877) On the occurrence of oxalic acid in fungi. C h m . News 36,93-94. Havir, E.A. and Anagnostakis, S.L. (1983) Oxalate production by virulent but not by hypovirulent strains of Endothia parasifica. Physiof. Plant Pafhol. 23,369-376. Havir, E.A. and Anagnostakis, S.L. (1985) Oxaloacetate acetylhydrolase activity in virulent and hypovirulent strains of Endothia (Cryphonectia)parassica. Physiol. Plant Pathol. 26. 1-9. Henriksson, G. Ander, P. and Pettersson, P. (1995) Cellobiose dehydrogenase (cellobiose oxidase) from Phanerochaefe chrysosporium as a wood degrading enzyme. Studies on cellulose, xylan and synthetic lignin. Appf. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 42, 790-796. Hirano, T., Tanaka, H. and Enoki, A. (1995) Extracellular substance from the brown-rot basidiomycete Tyromyces palustris that reduces molecular oxygen to hydroxyl radicals and reduces ferric iron to ferrous iron. J. Jpn. Wood Res. Soc. 41,334-34 I . Hirsch, P., Ekkhardt, F.E.W. and Palmer, R.J. (1995) Fungi active in weathering of rock and stone monuments. Can. J. Bot. 73, S 1 3 8 4 s 1390. Hockertz, S., Plonzig, J. and Auling, G. (1987) Impairment of DNA formation is an early event in Aspergillus niger under manganese starvation. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 25, 590-593. Hockertz. S., Schmid, J. and Auling, G. (1988) A specific transport system for manganese in the filamentous fungus Aspergillus niger. J. Gen. Microbiol. 133, 35 13-35 19. Hodgkinson, A. ( I 977) Oxalic Acid in Biology and Medicine. Academic Press, New York. Home, R.A. (1960) The kinetics of the oxalate catalysis of the iron(I1)-iron (111) electronexchange reaction in aqueous solution. J. Phys. Chem. 64, 1512-1517. Homer, H.T., Tiffany, L.H. and Knaphus, G. (1995) Oak leaf litter rhizomorphs from Iowa and Texas: calcium oxalate producers. Mycologia 87, 34-40. Huang, W.L. and Longo, J.M. (1992) The effects of organics on feldspar dissolution and the development of secondary porosity. Chem. Geol. 98.271-292. Hutterman, A., Kuhl, W.E. and Chet, I. (1980) The effect of L-threonine on oxalic acid synthesis by Fomes annosus. Eur. J. For. Pathol. 10,339-344.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
85
Hyde, S.M. and Wood, P.M. (1997) A mechanism for production of hydroxyl radicals by the brown-rot fungus Coniophora puteunu: Fe(II1) reduction by cellobiose dehydrogenase and Fe(I1) oxidation at a distance from the hyphae. Microbiology 143,259-266. Illmer, P. and Schinner, E (1992) Solubilization of inorganic phosphates by microorganisms isolated from forest soils. Soil Biol. Biochem. 24,389-395. Illmer, P. and Schinner, F. (1995) Solubilization of inorganic calcium phosphates - solubilization mechanisms. Soil Biol. Biochem. 27, 257-263. Illmer, P., Barbato, A. and Schinner, F. (1995) Solubilization of hardly-soluble AIPO, with P-solubilizing microorganisms. Soil Biol. Biochem. 27, 265-270. Iwahori, K., Tatsuta, S., Fujita, M. and Yarnakawa, K. (1995) Substrate permeability in pellets formed by Aspergillus niger. J. Ferment. Bioeng. 79, 387-390. Jennings, D.H. (1995) The Physiology of Fungal Nutrition. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Jernecjc, K., Vendramin, M. and Cimerman, A. (1989) Lipid composition of Aspergillus niger in citric acid accumulating and non-accumulating conditions. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 11,452456, Johnston, C.G. and Vestal, J.R. (1993) Biogeochemistry of oxalate in the Antarctic cryptoendolithic lichen-dominated community. Microb. Ecol. 25,305-3 19. Jones, D., Smith, B.F.L., Wilson, M.J. and Goodman, B.A. (1991) Phosphate solubilizing fungi in a Scottish upland soil. Mycol. Res. 95, 1090-1093. Jones, D., McHardy, W.J., Wilson, M.J. and Vaughan, D. (1992) Scanning electron microscopy of calcium oxalate on mantle hyphae of hybrid larch roots from a farm forestry experimental site. Micron Microsc. Actu 23, 315-3 17. Jongmans, A.G., Van Breeman, N., Lundstrom, U., Van Hees, R.A.W., Finlay, R.D., Srinivasan, M., Unestam, T., Giesler, R., Melkerud, P.-A. and Olsson, M. (1997) Rockeating fungi. Nature 389,682-683. Jurinak, J.J., Dudley, L.M., Allen, M.F. and Knight, W.G. (1986) The role of calcium oxalate in the availability of phosphorus in soils of semi-arid regions: a thermodynamic study. Soil Sci. 142,255-261. Karamushka, V.I., Sayer, J.A. and Gadd, G.M. (1996) Inhibition of H+ efflux from Succharomyces cerevisiae by insoluble metal phosphates and protection by calcium and magnesium: inhibitory effects a result of soluble metal cations? Mycol. Res. 100, 707-7 13. Keller, J. (1 985) Les cystides crystalliferes des Aphyllophorales. Mycol. Helvet. 1,277-305. Khindaria, A., Grover, T.A. and Aust, S.D. (1994) Oxalate-dependent reductive activity of manganese peroxidase from Phunerochuete chrysosporium. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 314,301-306.
Kishi, K., Wariishi, H., Marguez, L., Dunford, H.B. and Gold, M.M. (1994) Mechanisms of manganese peroxidase compound I1 reduction. Effect of organic acid chelators and pH. Biochemistry. 33,8694-8701. Kisser, M., Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1980) Influence of manganese on morphology and cell-wall composition of Aspergillus niger during citric acid fermentation. Arch. Microbiol. 128,2633. Kpomblekou-A, K. and Tabatabai, M.A. (1994) Effect of organic acids on release of phosphorus from phosphate rocks. Soil Sci. 158,442453. Krebs, W., Brombacher, C., Bosshard, P.P., Bachofen, R. and Brandl, H. (1997) Microbial recovery of metals from solids. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 20, 605-617. Krisai, I. and Mrazek, E. (1986) Calcium oxalate crystals in Geastrum. Plant. Syst. Evol. 154,325-341.
Kritzman, G., Chet, I. and Henis, Y.(1977) The role of oxalic acid in the pathogenic behaviour of Sclerotium rolfsii Sacc. Exp. Mycol. 1,280-285.
86
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Kuan, I.C. and Tien, M. (1993) Stimulation of Mn peroxidase activity: a possible role for oxalate in lignin biodegradation. Pmc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 90, 1242-1246. Kubicek, C.P. (1988) The role of the citric acid cycle in fungal organic acid fermentations. Biochem. Soc. Symp. 54, 1 13-126. Kubicek, C.P. (1 998) Citric acid production. In: Commercial Fermentations and Nutritional Needs of their Microorganisms (T. Nagodawithana and G. Reed, eds), pp. 236-257. Esteekay Associates Inc., Milwaukee, WI. Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1 986) Citric acid fermentation. CRC Crit. Rev. Biotechnol. 3, 331-373. Kubicek, C.P., Schreferl-Kunar, G., Wohrer, W. and Roehr, M. (1988) Evidence for a cytoplasmic pathway of oxalate biosynthesis in Aspergillus niger. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54,633-637. Kubicek, C.P., Zehentgruber, O., El-Kalak, H. and Roehr, M. (1998) Regulation of citric acid production by oxygen; effects of dissolved oxygen tension on adenylate levels and respiration in Aspergillus niger. Eur: J. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 9, 101-1 16. Kucey, R.M.N. (1988) Effect of Penicillium bilaii on the solubility and uptake of P and micronutrients from soil by wheat. Can. J. Soil Sci. 68, 261-270. Lamprecht, I., Reller, A., Riesen, R. and Wiedemann, H.G. (1997) Ca-oxalate films and microbiological investigations of the influence of ancient pigments on the growth of lichens - thermogravimetric/thermomicroscopicanalyses. J. Thermal Anal. 49, 1601-1607. Lapeyrie, F. ( 1988) Oxalate synthesis from soil bicarbonate by the mycorrhizal fungus Paxillus involutus. Plant Soil 110, 3-8. Lapeyrie, F., Perrin, M., Pepin, R. and Bruchet, G . (1984). Extracellular formation of weddelite cultured in vitro by Punillus involutus: significance of this production for ectomycorrhizal symbiosis. Can. J. Bot. 62, 11 16-1 121. Lapeyrie, F., Chilvers, G.A. and Bhem, C.A. (1987) Oxalic acid synthesis by the mycorrhizal fungus Paxillus involutus (Batsch, ex Fr.) FK New Phytol. 106, 139-146. Lapeyrie, F., Picatto, C., Gerard, J. and Dexheimer, J. (1990) T.E.M. study of intracellular and extracellular calcium oxalate accumulation by ectomycorrhizal fungi in pure culture or in association with Eucalyptus seedlings. Symbiosis 9, 163-166. Lapeyrie, F., Ranger, J. and Vairelles, D. (199 I ) Phosphate solubilizing activity of'ectomycorrhizal fungi in vitro. Can. J. Bot. 69, 342-346. Leeuwenhoek, A. van (1675) Microscopical observations. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 10, 380-3 85. Leyval, C., Surtiningsih, T. and Berthelin, J. (1993) Mobilization of P and Cd from rock phosphates by rhizosphere microorganisms (phosphate dissolving bacteria and ectomycorrhizal fungi). Phosphorus Sulfur Silicon 77, 133-1 36. Little, B., Ray, R., Hart, K. and Wagner, P. (1994) Fungal-induced corrosion of wire rope exposed in humid atmospheric conditions. CorK Prev. Control 41,89-93. Loewus, FA., Saito, K., Suto, R.K. and Maring, E. (1995) Conversion of D-arabinose to Derythroascorbic acid and oxalic acid in Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Biochem. Biophys. R ~ JComm. . 212, 196-203. Ma, H., Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1981) Malate dehydrogenase enzymes in Aspergillus niger. FEMS Micmbiol. Lett. 12, 147-1 5 1. Ma, H., Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1985) Metabolic effects of manganese deficiency in Aspergillus niger: evidence for increased protein degradation. Arch. Microbiol. 141, 266-268. Ma, D.B., Hattori, T., Akamatsu, Y., Adachi, M. and Shimada, M. (1992) Kinetic analysis of the noncompetitive inhibition of the lignin peroxidase catalyzed reaction by oxalic acid. Biosci. Biochem. Biotechnol. 56, 1378-1 38 I ,
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALIC ACID
87
Magara, K., Ikeda, T., Tomiura, Y. and Hosoya, S. (1994) Accelerated degradation of cellulose by lignin during ozonolysis. J. Jpn. Wood Res. SOC.40, 1152-1 154. Magro, P., Marciono, P. and Di Lenna, P. (1988) Enzymatic oxalate decarboxylation in isolates of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 49, 49-52. Malajczuk, B.N. and Cromack, K. (1982) Accumulation of calcium oxalate in the mantle of ectomycorrhizal roots of Pinus radiata and Eucalyptus marginata. New Phytol. 92, 527-531. Manley, E.P. and Evans, L.J. (1986) Dissolution of feldspars by low-molecular-weight aliphatic and aromatic acids. Soil Sci. 141, 106-1 12. Marciano, P., Lenna, P. Di and Magro, P. (1983) Oxalic acid, cell wall-degrading enzymes and pH in pathogenesis and their significance in the virulence of two Sclerotinia sclerotiorum isolates on Sunflower. Physiol. Plant Pathol. 22, 339-345. Martell, A.E. and Calvin, M. (1952) Chemistry of the Metal Chelate Compounds. PrenticeHall Inc., New York. Mast, M.A. and Drever, J.L. (1987) The effect of oxalate on the dissolution rates of oligoclase and tremolite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 51,2559-2568. Mattey, M. (1992) The production of organic acids. CRC Crit. Rev. Biotechnol. 12,87-132. Mattey, M., Legisa, M. and Lowe, S. (1988) Effect of lectins and inhibitors on membrane transport in Aspergillus niger. Biochem. SOC. Trans. 16,969-970. Maxwell, D.P. and Bateman, D.F. (l968a) Oxalic acid biosynthesis by Sclerotium rolfsii. Phytopathology 58, 1635-1642. Maxwell, D.P. and Bateman, D.F. (1968b) Influence of carbon source and pH on oxalate accumulation in culture filtrates of Sclerotium rolfsii. Phytopathology 58, 135 1-1 355. Maxwell, D.P., Williams, P.H. and Maxwell, M.D. (1972) Studies on the possible relationships of microbodies and multivesicular bodies to oxalate, endopolygalacturonase and cellulase (Cx) production by Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Can. J. Bot. 50, 1743-1748. Mehta, A. and Datta, A. (1991) Oxalate decarboxylase from Collybia velutipes. Purification, characterisation and cDNA cloning. J. Biol. Chem. 266,23548-23553. Meixner, O., Mischak, H., Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1985) Effect of manganese deficiency on plasma membrane lipid composition and glucose uptake in Aspergillus niger. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 26,271-274. Metting, F.B. (1992) Structure and physiological ecology of soil microbial communities. In: Soil Microbial Ecology, Applications and Environmental Management (F.B. Metting, ed.), pp. 3-25. Marcel Dekker, New York. Micales, J.A. (1994) Induction of oxalic acid by carbohydrate and nitrogen sources in the brown-rot fungus Postia placenta. Mate,: Org. 28, 197-207. Micales, J.A. (l995a) In v i m oxalic acid production by the brown-rot fungus Postia placenta. Mate,: Org. 29, 159-176. Micales, J.A. (19956) Oxalate decarboxylase in the brown-rot wood decay fungus Postia placenta. Matel: Org. 29, 177-186. Micales, J. A. (1997) Localization and induction of oxalate decarboxylase in the brown-rot wood decay fungus Postia placenta. Int. Biodet. Biodeg. 39, 125-132. Mischak, H., Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1985) Formation and location of glucose oxidase in citric acid producing mycelia of Aspergillus niger. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 21, 27-3 I . Morley, G.F. and Gadd, G.M. (1995) Sorption of toxic metals by fungi and clay minerals. Mycol. Res. 99, 1429-1438. Morley, G.F., Sayer, J.A., Wilkinson, S.J., Gharieb, M.M. and Gadd, G.M. (1996) Fungal sequestration, solubilization and transformation of toxic metals. In: Fungi and Envimnmental Change (J.C. Frankland, N. Magan and G.M. Gadd, eds.), pp. 235-256. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
88
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Miiller, B., Burgstaller, W., Strasser, H., Zanella, A. and Schinner, F. (1995) Leaching of zinc from industrial filter dust with Penicillium, Pseudornonas and Corynebacterium citric acid is the leaching agent rather than amino acids. J. Indust. Microbiol. 14, 208-2 12. Munier-Lamy, C. and Berthelin, J. (1983) Formation of polyelectrolyte complexes with the major elements Fe and Al and the trace elements U and Cu during heterotrophic microbial leaching of rocks. Geomicrobiol. J. 5 , 119-147. Murphy, R.J. and Levy, J.F. (1983) Production of copper oxalate by some copper tolerant fungi. Trans. Br. Mycol. SOC.81, 165-168. Netik, A., Torres, N.V., Riol, J.-M. and Kubicek, C.P. (1997) Uptake and transport of citric acid by Aspergillus niger is reciprocally regulated by manganese ions. Eiochim. Eiophys, Acts 1326,287-294. Nicole, M., Chamberland, H., Rioux, D., Lecours, N., Rio, B., Geiger, J.P. and Ouellette, G.B. (1993) A cytochemical study of extracellular sheaths associated with Rigidoporous lignosus during wood decay. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 59,2578-2588. Noyes, R.D. and Hancock, J.G. (1981) Role of oxalic acid in the Sclerotinia wilt of sunflower. Physiol. Plant Pathol. 18. 123-1 32. Olsvik, E., Tucker, K.G., Thomas, C.R. and Kristiansen, B. (1993) Correlation of Aspergillus niger broth rheological properties with biomass concentration and the shape of mycelial aggregates. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 42, 1046-1052. Orthofer, R., Kubicek, C.P. and Roehr, M. (1979) Lipid levels and manganese deficiency in citric acid producing strains of Aspergillus niger. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 5,403406. Paris, F., Bonnaud, P., Ranger, 3. and Lapeyrie, F. (1995a) In vitro weathering of phlogopite by ectomycorrhizal fungi. 1. Effect of K and Mg deficiency on phyllosilicate evolution. Plant Soil 177, 19 1-20 1. Paris, F., Bonnaud, P., Ranger, J., Robert, M. and Lapeyrie, F. (1995b) Weathering of ammonium or calcium saturated 2: 1 phyllosilicates by ectomycorrhizal fungi in vitro. Soil Biol. Eiochem. 27, 1237-1 244. Paris, F., Botton, B. and Lapeyrie, F. (1996) In vitro weathering of phlogopite by ectomycorrhizal fungi. 11. Effect of KC and Mg2+deficiency and N sources on accumulation of oxalate and H+. Plant Soil 179, 141-150. Parks, E.J., Olson, G.J., Brinckman, F.E. and Baldi, F. (1990) Characterization by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) of the solubilization of phosphorus in iron ore by a fungus. J. Indust. Microbiol. 5, 183-190. Pera, L.M. and Callieri. D.A. (1997) Influence of calcium on fungal growth, hyphal morphology and citric acid production in Aspergillus niger. Folia Microbiol. 42,551-556. Perez, J. and Jeffries, T.W. (1993) Role of organic acid chelators in manganese regulation of lignin degradation by Phanerochaete chrysosporium. Appl. Eiochem. Biotechnol. 39/40, 227-238. Perfettini, J.V., Revertegat, E. and Langomazino, N. (1991) Evaluation of cement degradation by the metabolic products of two fungal strains. Experientia 47, 527-533. Pierson, P.E. and Rhodes, L.H. (1 992) Effect of culture medium on the production of oxalic acid by Sclerotinia trifoliorum. Mycologia 84,467-469. Popp, J.L.. Kalyanaraman, B. and Kirk, T.K. (1990) Lignin peroxidase oxidation of Mn2+ in the presence of veratryl alcohol, malonic or oxalic acid and oxygen. Biochemistry 29, 10475-1 0480. Powell, M.D. and Amott, H.J. (1985) Calcium oxalate crystal production in two members of the Mucorales. Scann. Electron Microsc. 1985, 183-1 89. Prieto, B., Silva, B., Rivas, T., Wierzchos, J. and Asdaso, C. (1997) Mineralogical transformation and neoformation in granite caused by the lichens Tephromela atra and Ochrolechia parella. Int. Biodet. Biodeg. 40,191-199.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
89
Punja, Z.K. and Jenkins, S.F. (1984a) Influence of medium composition on mycelial growth and oxalic acid production in Sclerotium mlfsii. Mycologia 76,947-950. Punja, Z.K. and Jenkins, S.F. (1984b) Light and scanning electron microscopic observations of calcium oxalate crystals produced during growth of Sclerotium rolfsii in culture and in infected tissue. Can. J. Bot. 62, 2028-2032. Punja, Z.K., Huang, J.-S. and Jenkins, S.F. (1985) Relationship of mycelial growth and production of oxalic acid and cell wall degrading enzymes to virulence in Sclerotium mlfsii. Can. J. Plant Pathol. 7, 109-1 17. Purvis, O.W. (1984) The occurrence of copper oxalate in lichens growing on copper sulphide-bearing rocks in Scandinavia. Lichenology 16, 197-204. Purvis, O.W. and Halls, C. (1996) A review of lichens in metal-enriched environments. Lichenology 28,57 1 4 0 1 . Ramsay, L.M., Sayer, J.A. and Gadd, G.M. (1999) Stress responses of fungal colonies towards toxic metals. In: The Fungal Colony (N.A.R. Cow, G.Robson and G.M. Gadd, eds.), pp. 178-200. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Rao, D.V. and Tewari, J.P. (1989) Occurrence of magnesium oxalate crystals on lesions incited by Mycena citricolor on coffee. Phytopathology 79,783-787. Read, D.J. (1991) Mycorrhizas in ecosystems. Experientia 47,376-391. Ritschkoff, A.C., Ratto, M., Buchert, J. and Viikari, L. (1995) Effect of carbon source on the production of oxalic acid and hydrogen peroxide by brown-rot fungus Poria placenta. J. Biotechnol. 40, 179-186. Roehr, M., Kominek, J. and Kubicek, C.P. (1992) Industrial acids and other small molecules. In: Aspergillus - Biology and Industrial Applications (J.W. Bennett and M.A. Klich, eds), pp. 91-13 I . Butterworth-Heinemann, Woburn, MA, USA. Roehr, M., Kubicek, C.P. and Kominek, J. (1996) Citric acid. In: Biotechnology, 2nd edn (H.J. Rehm, G. Reed, A. Piihler and P. Stadler, eds), pp. 307-345. Verlag Chemie, Weinheim. Roukas. T. and Harvey, L. (1988) The effect of pH on production of citric and gluconic acid from beet molasses using continuous culture. Biotech. Lett. 10,289-294. Rowe, D.E. (1993) Oxalic acid effects in exudates of Sclerotinia trifoliorum and S. sclerotiorum and potential use in selection. Crop Sci. 33, 1146-1 149. Russ, J., Palma, R.L., Lloyd, D.H., Boutton, T.W. and Coy, M.A. (1996) Origin of the whewellite-rich rock crust in the Lower Pecos region of Southwest Texas and its significance to paleoclimate reconstructions. Quaternary Res. 46,27-36. Sayer, J.A. and Gadd, G.M. (1997) Solubilization and transformation of insoluble inorganic metal compounds to insoluble metal oxalates by Aspergillus niger. Mycol. Res. 101, 653461. Sayer, J.A., Raggett, S.L. and Gadd, G.M. (1995) Solubilization of insoluble metal compounds by soil fungi: development of a screening method for solubilizing ability and metal tolerance. Mycol. Res. 99,987-993. Sayer, J.A., Kierans, M. and Gadd, G.M. (1997) Solubilization of some naturally-occurring metal-bearing minerals, limescale and lead phosphate by Aspergillus niger. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 154, 29-35. Sayer, J.A., White, C., Bridge, T.A.M. and Gadd, G.M. (2000) Removal of inorganic species including metals. In: Bioremediation: Sustainable Technologyfor the 21st Century (H. Eccles, ed.), Taylor and Francis, London (in press). Schinner, F. and Burgstaller, W. (1989) Extraction of zinc from industrial waste by a Penicillium sp.. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 55, 1153-1 156. Schrickx, J.M., Raedts, M.J.H., Stouthamer, A.H. and van Verseveld, H.W. ( 1995) Organic acid production by Aspergillus niger in recycling culture analysed by capillary electrophoresis. Anal. Biochem. 231, 175-181.
90
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Seehaus, C, Pilz, E and Auling, G. (1990)High-affinity manganese transport systems by filamentous fungi. Zentralbl. Bakteriol. 272, 357-358. Shah, M.M., Grover, T.A., Ban; D.B. and Aust, S.D. (1992) On the mechanism of inhibition of the veratryl alcohol oxidase activity of lignin peroxidase H2 by EDTA. J. Biol. Chem. 267,564-569. Shimada, M., Ma, D.B., Akamatsu, Y.and Hattori, T. (1994)A proposed role of oxalic acid in wood decay systems of wood-rotting basidiomycetes. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 13,285-296. Shimada, M., Akamatsu, Y., Tokimatsu, T., Mii, K. and Hattori, T. (1997) Possible biochemical roles of oxalic acid as a low molecular weight compound involved in brown-rot and white-rot wood decays. J. Biotechnol. 53, 103-1 13. Shinners, T.C. and Tewari, J.P. (1997) Diversity in crystal production by some bird’s nest fungi (Nidulariaceae) in culture. Can. J. Chem. 75, 850-856. Singer, A., Navrot, J. and Shapka, R. (1982) Extraction of aluminium fly ash by commercial and microbiologically produced citric acid. Eur. J. Appl. Environ. Microb. Biotechnol. 60,3079-3088. Snetselaar, K.M. and Whitney, K.D. (1990) Fungal calcium oxalate in mycorrhizae of Monotropa unijlora. Can. J. Bot. 68,533-543. Song, S.K. and Huang, P.M., (1988) Dynamics of potassium release from potassium-bearing minerals as influenced by oxalic and citric acids. Soil Sci. SOC.Am. J. 52, 383-390. Stevenson, F.J. (1967) Organic acids in soil. In: Soil Biochemistry, Vol. 1 (A.D. McLaren and G.H. Peterson, eds), pp. 119-146. Marcel Dekker, New York. Stillings, L.L., Drever, J.I., Brantley, S.L., Sun, Y.T. and Oxburgh, R. (1996) Rates of feldspar dissolution at pH 3-7 with 0-8 mM oxalic acid. Chem. Geol. 132,79-89. Strasser, H., Burgstaller, W. and Schinner, F. (1994) High-yield production of oxalic acid for metal leaching processes by Aspergillus niger. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 119, 365-370. Sukla, L.B., Kar, R.N. and Panchanadikar, V. (1992) Leaching of copper converter slag with Aspergillus niger culture filtrate. Biometals 5, 169-172. Sukla, L.B., Kar, R.N., Panchanadikar, V.V., Choudhury, S. and Mishra, R.K. (1995) Bioleaching of lateritic nickel ore using Penicillium sp.. Trans. Ind. Inst. Metols 48, 103- 106. Sutter, H.-P., Jones, G.E.B. and Walchi, 0. (1983) The mechanism of copper tolerance in Poriaplacenta (Fr) Cke. and Poria vaillantii (Pers.) Fr. Matel: Org. 18, 241-262. Sutter, H-P., Jones, G.E.B. and Wllchi, 0. (1984) Occurrence of crystalline hyphal sheaths in Poriaplacenta (Fr) Cke. J. Inst. Wood Sci. 10, 19-23. Takao, S. (1 965) Organic acid production by basidiomycetes I. Screening of acid-producing strains. Appl. Microbiol. 13, 732-737. Tanaka, N., Akamatsu, Y., Hattori, T. and Shimada, M. (1994) Effect of oxalic acid on the oxidative breakdown of cellulose by the Fenton reaction. Wood Res. 81.8-10. Tewari, J.P., Shinners, T.C. and Briggs, K.G. (1997) Production of calcium oxalate crystals by two species of Cyathus in culture and infested plant debris. Z. Naturfor.sch. 52c. 42 1-425. Tobin, J.M., White, C. and Gadd, G.M. (1994) Metal accumulation by fungi: applications in environmental technology. J. Indust. Microbiol. 13, 126-1 30. Torma, A.E. and Singh, A.K. (1 993) Acidolysis of coal fly ash by Aspergillus niger. Fuel 12, 1625-1630. Tzeferis, P.G. (1994) Leaching of a low-grade hematitic laterite ore using fungi and biologically produced acid metabolites. Int. J. Mineral Proc. 42, 267-283. Tzeferis, P.G., Agatzini, S. and Nerantzis, E.T. (1994) Mineral leaching of non-sulphide nickel ores using heterotrophic micro-organisms. Lett. Appl. Microbiol. 18,209-2 13. Vachon, P. Tyagi, R.D., Auclair, J.C. and Wilkinson, K.J. (1994) Chemical and biological leaching of aluminium from red mud. Environ. Sci. Technol. 28, 2630.
FUNGAL PRODUCTION OF CITRIC AND OXALlC ACID
91
Vassilev, N., Baca, M.T., Vassileva, M., Franco, I. and Azcon, R. (1995)Rock phosphate solubilization by Aspergillus niger grown on sugar-beet waste medium. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 44,546-549. Vassilev, N., Vassileva, M. and Azcon, R. ( 1 997) Solubilization of rock phosphate by immobilized Aspergillus niger. Biores. Technol. 59, 1 4 . Verrecchia, E.P. ( 1990) Lithodiagenetic implications of the calcium oxalatexarbonate biogeochemical cycle in semi-arid calcretes, Nazareth, Israel. Geomicrobiol. J. 8, 89-101. Verrecchia, E.P. and Dumont, J.-L. (1996) A biogeochemical model for chalk alteration by fungi in semiarid environments. Biogeochemistry 35,447470. Verrecchia, E.P. and Verrecchia, K.E. (1994) Needle-fiber calcite: a critical review and a proposed classification. J. Sedim. Res. A64 650-664. Verrecchia, E.P., Dumont, J.L. and Rolko, K.E. (1990) Do fungi building limestones exist in semi-arid regions? Naturwissenschaften 77, 584-586. Verrecchia, E.P., Dumont, J.L. and Verrecchia, K.E. (1993) Role of calcium oxalate biomineralization by fungi in the formation of calcretes: a case study from Nazareth, Israel. J. Sedim. Petrol. 63, 1000-1006. Vivier, H., Marcant, B. and Pons, M.-N. (1994) Morphological shape characterization: application to oxalate crystals. Particle Particle Sys. Cha,: 11, 150-155. Wainwright, M. (1988) Metabolic diversity of fungi in relation to growth and mineral cycling in soil - a review. Trans. B,: Mycol. SOC.90, 159-170. Wainwright, M. and Gadd, G.M. (1997) Fungi and industrial pollutants. In: The Mycota IV Environmental and Microbial Relationships (D. T. Wicklow and B. E. Soderstrom, eds), pp. 85-97. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Wang, A. and Tewari, J.P. (1990) Role of oxalic acid in pathogenesis by Mycena citricolor (Agan'cales, Hymenomycetes), causal agent of the American leaf spot of coffee. Crypt. Bot. 1,396-398. Wang, Y.C. and McNeil, B. (1995) pH effects on exopolysaccharide and oxalic acid production in cultures of Sclerotium glucanicum. Enzyme Microbiol. Technol. 17, 124-1 30. White, C., Sayer, J.A. and Gadd, G.M.(1997) Microbial solubilization and immobilization of toxic metals: key biogeochemical processes for treatment of contamination. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 20,503-5 16. Whitney, K.D. and Amott, H.J. (1986a) Morphology and development of calcium oxalate deposits in Gilbertella persicaria (Mucorales) Mycologia 78,42-5 1. Whitney, K.D. and Amott, H.J. (1986b) Calcium oxalate crystals and basidiocarp dehiscence in Geastrum saccutum (Gasteromycetes) Mycologia 78,649-656. Whitney, K.D. and Amott, H.J. (1987) Calcium oxalate crystal morphology and development in Agaricus bisporus. Mycologia 79, 180-1 87. Whitney, K.D. and Amott, H.J. (1988) The effect of calcium on mycelial growth and calcium oxalate crystal formation in Gilbertella persicaria (Mucorales) Mycologia 80, 707-7 15 . Wolschek, M.F. and Kubicek, C.P. (1999) Biochemistry of citric acid accumulation by Aspergillus niger. In: Citric Acid Biotechnology (B. Kristiansen, M. Mattey and J. Linden, eds), pp. 1 1-3 1. Taylor and Francis, London. Wood, P.M. (1994) Pathways for production of Fenton's reagent by wood-rotting fungi. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 13, 313-320. Xu, D.-B., Madrid, C.P., Roehr, M. and Kubicek, C.P. (1989)The influence of type and concentration of the carbon source on the production of citric acid by Aspergillus niger. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 30, 553-559. Yang, J., Tewari, T.P. and Verma, P.R. (1993) Calcium oxalate crystal formation in Rhizoctonia solani AG 2-1 culture and infected crucifer tissue: relationship between host calcium and resistance. Mycol. Res. 97, 1516-1522.
92
GEOFFREY M. GADD
Yigitoglu, M. and McNeil, B. (1992) Ammonium and citric acid supplementation in batch cultures of Aspergillus niger. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 8 , 7 1-74. Zuo, Y. and Hoigne, J. (1994) Photochemical decomposition of oxalic, glyoxalic and pyruvic acids catalyzed by iron in atmospheric waters. Atmos. Environ. 28, 123 1-1239.
Bacterial Viability and Culturability Michael R. Barer and Colin R. Harwood Depanment of Microbiology and Immunology, The Medical School, Framlington Place, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE2 4HH
ABSTRACT
Renewed interest in the relationships between viability and culturability in bacteria stems from three sources: (1) the recognition that there are many bacteria in the biosphere that have never been propagated or characterized in laboratory culture; (2) the proposal that some readily culturable bacteria may respond to certain stimuli by entering a temporarily non-culturable state termed 'viable but non-culturable' (VBNC) by some authors; and (3) the development of new techniques that facilitate demonstration of activity, integrity and composition of non-culturable bacterial cells. We review the background to these areas of interest emphasizing the view that, in an operational context, the term VBNC is self-contradictory (Kell et al., 1998) and the likely distinctions between temporarily non-culturable bacteria and those that have never been cultured. We consider developments in our knowledge of physiological processes in bacteria that may influence the outcome of a culturability test (injury and recovery, ageing, adaptation and differentiation, substrateaccelerated death and other forms of metabolic self-destruction, prophages, toxin-antitoxin systems and cell-to-cell communication). Finally, we discuss whether it is appropriate to consider the viability of individual bacteria or whether, in some circumstances, it may be more appropriate to consider viability as a property of a community of bacteria. 1. Introduction ....................................................... 2. Definitions ........................................................ 3. The 'viable but non-culturable' (VBNC) hypothesis ....................... 4. 'As yet uncultured' (AYU) bacteria ..................................... 5. 'New'methods ..................................................... 5.1. Fluorescence methods ..........................................
ADVANCES IN MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY VOL 41 ISBN 0-12-027741-7
94 95 96 99 102 102
Copyright 0 1999 Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
94
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
5.2. The Kogure ‘tentative direct microscopic method of counting live 103 bacteria’ ...................................................... 5.3. Molecular approaches ........................................... 106 5.4. Developments in instrumentation ................................. 108 110 5.5. What do the ‘new’ methods tell us? ................................ 111 6. Factors influencing the outcome of culturability tests ..................... 6.1. Injury and recovery ............................................. 112 113 6.2. Ageing ....................................................... 6.3. Adaptation and differentiation .................................... 115 6.4. Substrate-accelerated death and other forms of metabolic self-destruction ................................................ 117 6.5. Lysogenic bacteriophages and toxin-antitoxin systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 120 6.6. Cell-to-cell communication (quorum sensing) ....................... 7. Should bacterial viability be assessed at the individual or community level? , . 122 8. Conclusions ....................................................... 124 Acknowledgements ................................................. 126 References ........................................................ 126
1. INTRODUCTION
The terms ‘viable’ and ‘viability’ are used extensively both in microbiology and in common parlance. Here we argue that the microbiological usage is in danger of losing its meaning unless a new consensus can be developed. We revisit the arguments set out by Postgate (1967) in the first paper of the first volume of this series, review technical and conceptual developments since that time and draw conclusions in the light of those developments. While discussions concerning the appropriate use of terms may appear to be academic, it should not be forgotten that many practical decisions in the real world are based on detecting specific bacteria by culture and on enumerating them by ‘viable counts’. Judgements on the classification of food or drink as microbiologically safe for human consumption, of beaches being sufficiently clean for recreational bathing, of antibiotics having bactericidal activity, and of pharmaceutical preparations being sterile and suitable for parenteral administration are all currently based on culture tests where viability is equated with culturability. The introduction of new molecular and cytological techniques that facilitate detection of bacteria independently of culture has raised the prospect of developing new criteria that attach the decision-making process to these determinations rather than culture and subsequent incorporation of these into legislation. In consequence, the need for precision and consensus in our use of the term viability as applied to bacteria and its practical implications is, if anything, increasing. It is our belief that progress towards a new consensus can be achieved by making a clear distinction between use of these terms in operational (practical)
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
95
and conceptual (theoretical) domains (Kell et al., 1998). Precedent leads us to recognize that measurement of the number of bacteria in a sample that can be propagated in laboratory cultures (culturability*) provides the most widely accepted practical measure of viability (Postgate, 1976; Madigan et al., 1997). However, two prominent strands of research have undermined the sanctity of the operational canon which equates viability and culturability.The first strand concerns the proposal that certain bacteria may become temporarily nonculturable - termed by some ‘viable but non-culturable’ (VNC or VBNC) - in response to specific stimuli, while the second stems from the recognition by molecular and cytological means that there are many bacteria in the biosphere that have never been cultured. The difficulties raised by investigations in these areas are, to some extent, compounded by the new methods alluded to above. Thus, where such methods have been applied together with culture, substantial discrepancies have been recognized in both the distribution and activity of specific organisms determined by the two approaches. One obvious potential solution to these problems is to adopt an operational definition of viability other than culturability. Clearly, such a general change would require extensive validation of the methodology employed and the question of whether this can be justified by currently available evidence is considered below. A more difficult aspect of the current debate is the lack of consensus in what microbiologists mean by ‘viability’. We do not propose to amplify on these semantic arguments here as we have considered them at length elsewhere (Barer, 1997; Kell et al., 1998). However, while the debate persists, we consider it essential that workers define their own usage of these terms.
2. DEFINITIONS
In general, bacterial species can be divided into those that have and those that have not been propagated by laboratory culture. It follows, therefore, that culturability can only be used as an operational definition of viability in the former group. A universal definition of bacterial viability therefore requires discussion of some conceptual issues. In common parlance, use of the terms ‘viable’ and ‘viability’ reflects our expectation that entities, which may be animate, inanimate or abstract, will survive over a generally accepted (but rarely stated) period of time. In macrobiology, the time frame for the viability of an individual is the normal life span for that species in a particular environment. In microbiology, the life *While accepting that the terms ‘cultivable’and ‘capacity for cultivation’are linguistically accurate, established usage and the need to cross-refer to other texts leads us to use ‘culturable’and ‘culturability’ in the present context.
96
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
span of individual cells is rarely considered and the time frame under consideration often extends for several generations. It follows that reproductive capacity becomes as inherent to our view of the viability of bacteria as it would be to our understanding of the long-term survival of any species. Since life span itself is an important and necessary variable in microbial physiology, it is hardly surprising that application of terms commonly applied to entities that have relatively constant life expectancies (unless they are prematurely terminated) gives rise to confusion. As a point of reference for subsequent discussions we have provided brief conceptual and operational definitions of commonly used (and misused) terms relating to bacterial culturability and viability (Table 1). A number of general points emerge. Firstly, the operational definitions are, by their very nature, retrospective, i.e. they can only be applied after completion of a defined and sometimes lengthy test. Even though the results of some rapid tests correlate well with culturability in some defined settings, we are not aware of any generally applicable test that allows the viability of bacteria to be determined in real time (see below). Secondly, the definitions have been coined such that they may be applied at the single-cell or population level, another point to which we shall return. Finally, we emphasize that these definitions are primarily intended to serve the objectives of this review; we are not advocating a microbiological form of ‘politicalcorrectness’.We recognize modifications that we have made from an earlier review and accept that others may wish to use alternative definitions. Nonetheless, we appeal to authors to either state or refer to the definitions to which they adhere. It will be noted that we have avoided defining the terms ‘live’, ‘alive’, ‘vital’, ‘senescent’, ‘moribund’and ‘dead’. In general, we prefer to limit the use of these terms since they are powerfully evocative in an anthropomorphic context. However, they may be useful and can be defined by reference to terms in Table 1. Of course, it is also recognized that there are difficulties in applying these terms in a human context, particularly in a medico-legal sense.
3. THE ’VIABLE BUT NON-CULTURABLE’ (VBNC) HYPOTHESIS
The issues relating to putative VBNC states have been recently reviewed (Kell et al., 1998) and consequently will only be covered briefly in this review. Our initial comments refer only to those bacteria that can readily be cultured in the laboratory. A combination of laboratory experiments and epidemiological issues led Colwell and her associates to develop the VBNC hypothesis (Xu et al., 1982; Brayton et al., 1987; Hussong et al., 1987a,b; Roszak and Colwell, 1987a,b;
Table I
Definitions
Term
:
Conceptual definition
Operational definition
0
1. Viable
Retaining the capacity for replication over a stated or generally accepted time frame
Explicit demonstration of replication in a validated laboratory system
Ft
2. Replication
Genomic replication and segregation into a new selfpropagating unit (propagule)
Observed cell fission or increase in number of propagules
3. Culturabie
Capable of detectable replication in a realizable laboratory system
Detected replication in a validated laboratory system
4. Growth
Accumulation of biomass
Demonstrated accumulation of biomass
5. Dormancy
A reversible state of low metabolic activity in a unit that maintains viability
A demonstratedreversible low state of metabolic activity demonstrated by a specific technique or set of techniques in an
? C
operationally viable unit A demonstrated transition from a temporary state of nonculturability in a defined system to culturability in that system. The procedure must exclude regrowth as a possible explanation
5
;;I I
G
2
%0 0
C
6. Resuscitation Transition from a state in which the specified unit had temporarily lost the capacity for self-replication to regaining that capacity 7. Regrowth Growth and/or replication of a very small subpopulation of the study population that causes changes in cell numbers that are below the limit of detection for the study methods applied 8. Cryptic Growth andor replication of a subpopulation within the study growth population that cannot be detected by the methods applied 9. Suicide An irreversible process by which a viable unit determines the loss of its own viability by a specific mechanism
a
5
Growth andor replication demonstrated by one method that led to detection of the organism by another, less sensitive, method. If the latter were applied alone, resuscitation would appear to have occurred Growth andor replication demonstrated by one method that was not detected by another, less sensitive method A non-reversible response in which a population of propagules can be shown to have lost demonstrableviability as a result of a process intrinsic to that response
10. Activity
A metabolic or behavioural process occurring within the unit under consideration.The unit may be viable or non-viable
A demonstrated behavioural, biochemical or physiological process occurring within the unit under consideration
1 1. Survival
Maintenance of viability
Maintenance of operational viability
(D
4
98
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Pearson et al., 1993). Coherent arguments have been advanced to support the view that a number of pathogenic bacteria, notably Vibrio cholerae (Huq and Colwell, 1996) and Campylobacterjejuni (Rollins and Colwell, 1986; Pearson et al., 1993) adopt specific physiological states during residence outside human or animal hosts, and that these states are critical to the maintenance of environmental sources and reservoirs of infection. In the proposed VBNC state, it is contended that cells may become temporarily non-culturable until they are exposed to an environment that stimulates their resuscitation and that the cells that retain capacity for resuscitation can be identified by application of a cytological test of activity (Oliver, 1993). These proposals have led to a flurry of purported demonstrations of bacteria that have the capacity for transition to and from the proposed VBNC state (Oliver, 1993; Kell et al., 1998). However, there are two critical practical issues in assessing the evidence relating to the VBNC hypothesis. The first, to which we return below, is the degree to which activity assays can be accepted as measures of viability. The second concerns whether the cell populations that were studied truly resuscitated or whether the observed phenomena can be attributed to ‘regrowth’.We emphasize the need for careful statistical analysis in such experiments, particularly where infectivity is studied in animals (Jones et al., 1991; Oliver and Bockian, 1995) or humans (Colwell et al., 1996), so that effects can be unambiguously attributed to temporarily non-culturable cells as distinct from a small fraction of culturable cells (Barer et al., 1998; Kell et al., 1998). Failure to make this distinction in published infection studies does not detract from the interest of the work; however, it does undermine the degree to which the observed effects can be attributed to temporarily nonculturable cells. Despite a number of studies where transition to and from a temporarily nonculturable state offers the simplest explanation for the observed phenomena ( e g Votyakova et al., 1994; Wai et al., 1996; Steinert et al., 1997; Whitesides and Oliver, 1997),we do not consider that these enable us to define a VBNC state or states in physiological terms. Reports of resuscitation are still relatively rare. Given other potential explanations, we believe it is necessary for the reported resuscitation phenomena to be repeated in several laboratories. Moreover, as there is much concern over the potential hazards posed by temporarily non-culturable bacteria (Byrd et al., 1991;Barer et al., 1993), a high priority should be given to the development of methods capable of distinguishing between such bacteria and those that are permanently non-culturable (non-viable).Such methods could then be applied to determine how extensive infective and other hazards posed by temporarily non-culturable bacteria might be. It should be apparent from Table 1 that we consider culturability to be the only validated operational definition of viability. In consequence, we consider the term ‘VBNC’ to be an oxymoron (Barer, 1997) and prefer the terms ‘temporarily non-culturable’ (Ekweozor et al., 1998) or ‘not immediately
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
99
culturable’ (NIC) (Kell et al., 1998) to describe non-culturable cells that are capable of being resuscitated. Whether temporal non-culturability can result from a specific programmed differentiation or adaptive processes remains an open question. As far as we are aware, no clear evidence for either type of process has been presented. We also consider the view that all categories of currently identified temporarily non-culturable cells are most appropriately referred to as ‘injured’ (see below) is both pertinent and in need of further attention. Finally, some authors have used the term ‘VBNC’to encompass all bacterial cells that can be detected (e.g. by microscopy) but which defy our attempts to culture them (Bloomfield et al., 1998). Clearly, this usage potentially includes temporarily non-culturable cells and cells of bacteria that have never been cultured in the laboratory. Indeed, some authors have even suggested that our failure to culture cells in both categories may be attributable to a single biochemical phenomenon (Dodd et al., 1997; Bloomfield et al., 1998).We cannot accept this latter view since many different processes have been demonstrated to underlie both temporary non-culturable states and our failure to isolate specific organisms in culture (Barer et d., 1998). Moreover, we consider that application of VBNC to ‘as yet uncultured’ bacteria adds further to the terminological confusion.
4. ‘AS YET UNCULTURED’ (AYU) BACTERIA
The sequence of discoveries and developments that led to a recognition of the extent to which we have so far failed to recover many bacterial species in culture is one of the most exciting developments in modern bacteriology (Pace, 1997). For many years the discrepancy between number of bacterial cells that could be detected by microscopy and the number of colony-forming units recoverable in samples from a given environment has been recognized by the phrase ‘the great plate count anomaly’ (Staley and Konopka, 1985).The emergence and acceptance of Woese’s 16s ribosomal RNA sequence data as the basis for the universal phylogenetic tree (‘tree of life’) (Woese, 1987)paved the way for an unusual development; a field of biological science that could measure the scale of its own ignorance. Over a period of 5 years or so, the practical foundations for the investigation of AYU bacteria were established. Two key developments, the design and use of universal primers for bacterial 16s rRNA genes that facilitated the recovery and sequencing of these genes from environmental samples (Giovannoni et al., 1990) and the synthesis of labelled rRNA-directed oligonucleotide probes whose specific binding in situ can be determined by microscopy or cytometry, underpinned this achievement (Giovannoni et ai.,1988; Delong et al., 1989).
100
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
These methods have enabled explicit identification of AYU bacteria at both molecular and cellular levels (Amann et al., 1995). Although in practice it is difficult to differentiate between the relative contributionsof biomass and biodiversity (many AYU organisms with restricted diversity versus few organisms comprising many diverse AYU taxa), there now seems little doubt that the AYU fraction of bacterial biodiversity exceeds the cultured fraction by between one and two orders of magnitude (Wayne, et al. 1987; Pace, 1997). More recently, the capacity to determine metabolic activity and gene expression by cytological assay in cells identified by rRNA oligonucleotide probes has further extended our potential to investigate AYU bacteria (Whiteley et al., 1996; Poulsen et al., 1997; Moller et al., 1998). In the present context, consideration must be given to how the viability of AYU bacteria may be assessed and the factors that may underlie our failure to recover these organisms in culture. The general issue of viability is relatively straightforward since cells attributable to AYU bacteria must have been the progeny of cells that were viable. However, unless their potential to replicate can be explicitly demonstrated, no specific individual cell can be identified as being viable. Cytological assessments of metabolic activity, DNA content and rRNA content show that a cell may retain certain resources that are compatible with viability but, as discussed below, their correlation with replicative potential is uncertain. It should be appreciated that many of the organisms assigned AYU status may, in fact, be culturable, hence our use of the term ‘uncultured’rather than ‘unculturable’(Wayne ef al., 1987). It is well recognized that almost every attempt to recover bacteria from environmental samples leads to the isolation of novel species. It is also widely appreciated that, where isolation of bacteria that comprise a small minority of those in a particular sample is desired, powerful selective culture methods may be required. Hence isolation of some potentially readily culturable bacteria may be delayed until suitable selective methods have been developed. Finally, there are many cultured organisms in collections such as those of pharmaceutical companies that have yet to be identified. Until all the organisms in culture have had their 16s rRNA genes sequenced, we cannot be certain that organisms identified by molecular methods are even difficult to culture. Despite these cautionary points, the evidence for the existence of AYU bacteria is substantial and we must therefore consider why their isolation and culture may be difficult or even ultimately unachievable. rlllJo broad categories are considered, firstly slow or cell density-limited growth and, secondly, highly specific nutritional and/or environmental requirements. Button and his colleagues achieved a most revealing demonstration of the former category (Button et al., 1993; Schut et al., 1993). Working on marine samples from Alaska these workers used dilution cultures to obtain growth vessels that contained only one replicating bacterial unit. They hypothesized that
BACTERIAL Vl ABl LlTY AND CU LTURABILlTY
101
marine oligotrophs might be adapted to grow at low cell densities and that their replication might not be detected by visible turbidity. They therefore elected to monitor growth by flow cytometry. Not only did they recover several isolates with mean generation times in the range 12-72 h by this approach but they also observed that the proportion of bacteria that could be considered unculturable by this method was only 40% of the total population detected. This contrasts with the 0.01-1 % range of unculturable (strictly ‘unplatable’) cells often quoted in relation to marine samples (Amann et al., 1995). It is clear that it would be very difficult to isolate cells replicating at these rates from non-oligotrophicenvironments unless suitable selective reagents can be identified. Moreover, the monitoring of growth by flow cytometry is only likely to be applied in a limited number of research laboratories. Interestingly, repeated passage of one of the isolates in this study led to its developing the capacity to form colonies on agar media. Whether this capacity was a pre-existing property of the organism, or the result of a mutation or mutations selected for in vitro remains to be established (Schut et al., 1997). The spectacular successes achieved in isolating what appear to be most of the major pathogenic bacteria affecting humans in the period from 1880 to 1920 arguably produced a sense of complacency about what could be achieved by conventional agar culture. The inclusion of blood and animal tissue extracts in media clearly provides a complex nutritional environment appropriate to many if not most medically significant bacteria. Nonetheless, there were warnings amongst the observations made during the ‘golden era of bacteriology’ that crude replication of the nutritional components present in the environment inhabited by the bacteria in question would not necessarily lead to their isolation and culture. Foremost amongst these observations is the recognition of Hansen’s bacillus, Mycobacterium leprae, which, since it was reported (Hansen, 1880), has defied all attempts at propagation in axenic culture. Interestingly, other species of the genus Mycobacteriurn provide examples of organisms whose nutritional requirements are highly exacting. These include M. paratuberculosis, which requires the mycobacterial iron-chelating agent mycobactin (Barclay and Ratledge, 1983), M. haemophilum, which requires blood, an unusual requirement for mycobacteria (Wayne and Sramek, 1992), and M. genovense (Bottger et al., 1992). The last of these examples falls into the novel category of organisms that were identified first by molecular methods and subsequently recovered in culture (Bottger et al., 1992; Coyle et al., 1992). Perhaps the most exciting case of an organism in this category is Tropheryma whippelii, the agent of the chronic human intestinal condition Whipple’s disease. Relman and associates ( 1992) identified this organism by molecular methods and, subsequently, Schoedon et al. (1997) recovered it by intracellulargrowth in macrophage cultures by addition of the cytokine interleukin 4.The organism’s requirements are evidently so specific that macrophages require a specific pattern of
102
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
stimulation before they provide an environment capable of supporting replication of i? whippelii. These observations have stimulated renewed interest in attempts to culture M . leprae by selective macrophage stimulation (Fredricks and Relman, 1997). However, there are alternative possibilities suggested by recent work that may offer an answer to the riddle posed by this defiant bacterium (Mukamolova et al., 1998) (see below). These examples serve to illustrate growth patterns and environmental issues that may be responsible for the extent of AYU bacteria. We consider the evidence that these phenomena account for the majority of failed attempts at isolatiodculture to be substantial. Nonetheless, although we reject use of the term VBNC in this context (Barer et al., 1998; Bloomfield et al., 1998), we recognize the possibility that exposure to certain media may cause some bacterial cells to injure themselves as a result of their own metabolic processes and look forward to publication of evidence relating to this possibility in specific instances.
5. ‘NEW‘ METHODS
Postgate (Postgate, 1967, 1969, 1976) divided procedures for estimating viability into direct (culture-based) and indirect (non-culture-based) methods. While we agree with this classification, our discussion will predominantly concern indirect methods, since most recent activity has been in this field. We review four major areas of development and discuss their impact on the issues of viability and culturability. 5.1. Fluorescence Methods
While some fluorescence methods were available at the time of Postgate’s review, many new procedures have since been developed. One important factor is the development of improved instrumentation, facilitating detection and measurement of fluorescence (see below), and another is the remarkable success of the company ‘MolecularProbes’, which has popularized the use of fluorescent reagents first in eukaryotic cell biology and latterly in bacteriology. Whatever the detection system, fluorescence-based assays provide signals that can be related to known properties of the organisms tested. Just as importantly, the results can be monitored at the cellular rather than the population level. Apart from the mild cachet associated with fluorescence detection technology, the central attraction of fluorescence methods stems from their sensitivity (low, i.e. micromolar, reagent concentrations can often be used) and the fact
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
103
that they are applicable to samples even when they or the background on which they are mounted is opaque. What do fluorescence methods measure? Essentially they should be considered as equivalent to other cytochemical or histochemical methods. All the same considerations regarding reagent access, mechanism of labelling and localization apply. Histochemical control reactions are often highly demanding but they are rarely performed in microbiological investigations. It is also important to recognize that a labelling property that is associated with replicating cells but that is absent from formaldehyde or heat-fixed cells does not enable us to conclude that the method is capable of detecting viability. We agree with McFeters et al. (1995) that the methods should be viewed as indicators of the specific aspects of cellular physiology and/or metabolism upon which the outcome of labelling is dependent. We do not propose to review systematically the fluorescence methods that have been reported to provide indirect measures of viability. We recognize that some methods have been validated as indirect measures of viability in some circumstances, for example, where cells have been exposed to defined stresses leading to loss of culturability by a limited range of mechanisms. Nonetheless, we retain the view of Postgate that indirect (including fluorescence) methods do not provide 'short cuts' (Postgate, 1976) by which viability may be determined. This does not mean that we consider fluorescence methods to be without value or that there are no situations in which they may be used as an indirect measure of viability or of likely viability. The recognition of particular activities within cells may be of significance whether or not those cells retain the capacity for further self-replication. Furthermore, where the relationship between labelling property and growth potential has been extensively validated against specific processes causing cells to lose viability (e.g. loss of membrane integrity), indirect methods may be useful. A non-exhaustive list of fluorescence methods is outlined in Table 2. 5.2. The Kogure 'Tentative Direct Microscopic Method of Counting Live Bacteria'
Somewhere en route, this admirable method (Kogure et al., 1979), which was developed to assess possible viability of uncultured bacteria in marine samples, has been redirected to the assessment of cultures rendered non-culturable in vitro (Xu et al., 1982; Roszak etal., 1984; Roszak and Colwell, 1987b; Linder and Oliver, 1989).The procedure involves amendment of samples from aquatic environments containing bacteria with low amounts of nutrient (classically, yeast extract) and the DNA gyrase inhibitor, nalidixic acid. Incubation, usually at 20 "C, leads to cell elongation without fission in a variable proportion of the
104
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Table 2 An overview of fluorescence and luminescence methods that have been used to assay activity or cellular integrity in bacteria Method
Example
Comment
Enzyme substrates
Fluorescein diacetate,' fluorescein digalactoside.2 ChemChrome B3
Enzyme not necessarily expressed under all physiological conditions
Redox indicators
CTC? Alamar Blue5
Results depend on endogenous and exogenous substrate and may be independent of the electron transport system
Membrane energizatiodpotential probes
Rhodamine 123: Oxano17
Controls necessary to confirm labelling or exclusion due to physiological property
Permeability probes
Propidium iodide! ethidium homodimerg
No clear cut-off, some live cells are permeant
Nucleic acid stains
Hoechst 33258/33342,1° DAP1,I'SYTO series,'*
Quantification of the target nucleic acid is dependent on its physical state
~ 0 ~ 0 1 3
FISH probes
16s rRNA-directed probes,I4 Elegant means of identifying target cells and assessing chromosomal painting15 ribosomal content
Specific ion probes
Quin 2, Fura 2, Indo I , SBFI, SPQ16
Calcium, sodium and chloride probes. Little used in bacterial studies
pH probes
BCECF,17 Calcein,l* SNARF- 1
Mainly used in physiological studies and on large cell populations
Proprietary viability
SYTOX green,19BacLight LIVEDEAD kit2'
Essentially nucleic acid stains with differential permeability for intact cells
Sources: 1 = Mor er ol. (1988), Diaper and Edwards (1994); 2 = Ikenaka ef al. (1990). Plovins er al(1994). Nwoguh er al. (1995); 3 = Diaper and Edwards (19941, Clarke and Pinder (1998); 4 = Rodriguez eta/. (1992), Bovill er al. (1994); 5 = Collins and Franzblau (1997); 6 = Bercovier er al. (1987). Kaprelyants and Kell(1992): 7 = Jepras er al. (1995). Lopezamoros et al. (1995); 8 = Gant eral. (1993); 9 = Kaneshiro era/. (1993); 10 = Davey and Kell(1996); 1 I = Hoff (1988). Kepner and Pratt (1994); 12 = Ibrahim el nl. (1997); Lebaron el al (1998); 13 = Mane eral. (1996); 14 =Amann eral. (1995). Poulsen er a / . (1995); 15 = Lanoil and Giovannoni (1997); 16 = Davey and Kell(1996), Slavik (1998); 17 = Molenaaref al. (1991); 18 =Diaper and Edwards (1994); 18 =Diaper and Edwards (1994); 19 = Roth eral. (1997): 20 = Braux er al. (1997). Decamp er nl. (1997). Jacobsen er nl. (1997), Joux er al. (1997). Rigsbee er nl. (1997). Duffy and Sheridan (1998). Vim et al. (1998).
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
105
cells. The initial explanation for the cell elongation was that nalidixic acid prevented cell division but not cell growth. The method is particularly attractive because, apart from the added nutrient, it appears to demonstrate growth potential in a medium that retains characteristics of the natural environment of the bacteria present. Also, by inhibiting cell division, it seems to place both culturable and non-culturable bacteria on an even playing field because the former are prevented from overwhelming the latter, as would be the case with a culture-based test. Application in the types of study for which the method was originally designed and with the cautious interpretation implied by Kogure and colleagues, original title and subsequent modifications seems justified (Brayton et al., 1987; Barcina et al., 1995). However, extension of the method to characterize non-culturable cells of culturable bacteria raises some important questions. Inclusion of nalidixic acid in the incubation mixture was originally intended to prevent cells from dividing. This poses a paradox that is particularly apparent where the non-culturable cells have been produced from culturable cells in laboratory microcosms. Such cells (whether temporarily or permanently non-culturable) are supposedly not capable of division, so why is the nalidixic acid required? We suggest that, rather than simply preventing division of cells stimulated to grow by nutrient amendment, the nalidixic acid itself provides a stimulus to which some cells respond. This response is likely to be an SOS response, a well recognized effect of quinolone antimicrobial agents (Drlica and Zhao, 1997). The SOS response includes expression of SulA, a protein that interacts with the tubulin-like protein FtsZ preventing septation and resulting in filamentous growth of cells (Bi and Lutkenhaus, 1993; Walker, 1996). These observations do not resolve the paradox posed by the responses observed when the Kogure method is applied to laboratory microcosms. Central to the paradox is the question of whether the growth implied by the elongation process is a response to the quinolone, the nutrient amendment or both. In our experience, both appear essential (A. T. Newton, R. Smith and M. R. Barer, unpublished observations), although we have not been able to exclude the possibility that limited replication occurs in the absence of the quinolone. Further, if nutrient amendment is capable of producing growth in a fraction of the population, why is this not reflected by the culturability test applied at the same time? Two recognized phenomena might be invoked as alternative answers to this latter question. The first is the phenomenon of limited replication (Binnerup et al., 1993); perhaps the elongating cells are not capable of completing more than a limited number of generations, specifically, below the number that could be recognized by the simultaneously applied test of culturability or by changes in the total cell count. The limitation might be imposed by available resources, injury to cell components, such as DNA, or processes akin to those controlling maximum cell density during primary
106
MICHAEL R. BARER A N D COLIN R. HARWOOD
isolation of the marine oligotroph Sphingomonas sp. strain RB2256 (Schut et al., 1997). Alternatively, it is well recognized that most probable number (MPN; or limiting dilution broth) counts and agar plate counts may give divergent results (Kaprelyants and Kell, 1993; Kaprelyants et al., 1994; Votyakova et al., 1994).The effort required to conduct MPN counts has limited their use and we simply do not know whether such counts, performed in the same medium as the Kogure test (without the quinolone), would give figures comparable to the Kogure result. All of these possibilities are amenable to experimental assessment, as are our speculations concerning the SOS response. In recommending that these issues be addressed, we also urge attention to statistical issues. Few publications clearly state their criteria for assigning cells observed in the Kogure test to positive or negative categories. It is not adequate to make such assignments on subjective criteria unless control and stimulated preparations are counted in a blinded fashion. Moreover, if a criterion such as doubling in cell length is used, this is only meaningful by reference to a control population. For example if, in a population where the distribution of cell lengths is normal, the standard deviation of the cell length in the control population is half the mean cell length, at least 1.25% of the control population will meet the doubling criterion. This issue becomes particularly important when the elongating population comprises a small proportion of the total cell count. Kogure-positive cells are often reported at less than 1% of the total cell count. To achieve counts with statistical validity, the positive cells would have to be longer than the control population mean by at least three control population standard deviations (and more as the fraction of responding cells becomes smaller). Finally, these considerations raise the question of what the appropriate control should be for the Kogure test when it is applied to laboratory microcosms. Should we use unamended samples or samples treated with either nutrient or nalidixic acid alone? 5.3. Molecular Approaches
The development of our understanding of bacteria at the molecular level and of techniques for genetic manipulation has provided some remarkable and powerful techniques for the interrogation of cell functions. In studies that essentially extend those which underpinned recognition of AYU bacteria, many workers have addressed the two questions, can we detect molecular processes in non-culturablebacteria and are they related to viability? Two types of assay have been used: detection of specific messenger RNA (mRNA) by combined reverse transcription and the polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) (Engstrand et al., 1992; Khan et al., 1996; Yamazaki et al., 1996; Felske et al., 1997; Rayner et al., 1998; Sheridan et al., 1998), and detection of cellular rRNA by in situ hybridization (ISH) (Delong et al., 1989; Lee et al.,
BACTERIAL VlABl LIP/ AND CULTURABlLlTY
107
1993; Amann et al., 1995). The generally short half-life of mRNA in bacteria makes this a desirable target and the argument that cells containing such short-lived molecules must be actively making them seems coherent. However, it is well known that the half-lives of certain mRNA species are substantially extended in certain physiological states, notably during starvation (Albertson and Nystrom, 1994; Marouga and Kjelleberg, 1996). Furthermore, most studies that have used RT-PCR to assess ‘viability’have applied the reaction at the population level, and this means that stringent precautions must be taken to exclude possible contributions from a sub-population of culturable cells that were present at or below the detection limit of the culture method applied. The demanding nature of the RT-PCR reaction and the culturability assays means that these two procedures are rarely combined in a statistically adequate fashion. The continuing improvement of in situ RT-PCR reactions applied to bacterial systems is a promising development that should allow the presence of specific transcripts to be assigned at the cellular level, thereby facilitating specific recognition of transcripts in non-culturable cells (Tolker-Nielsen et ul., 1998). As noted above, oligonucleotide ISH reactions directed at 16s or 23s rRNA molecules can be used to study non-culturable cells of both culturable and AYU bacteria. Although rRNA content is related to growth rate (Delong et ul., 1989; Lee et al., 1993; Poulsen et al., 1995) and has been observed to decline in non-growing cells and indeed in non-culturable cells, the minimum concentration of rRNA compatible with viability is not known. Clearly, the detection of rRNA indicates some potential for protein synthesis; however, rRNA is relatively stable and the relationship to recent translation is even less clear than in the case of mRNA. The recent demonstration that the pre-rRNA molecules (partially processed transcripts of the rDNA operon) can be detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) (Licht et al., 1998) provides another exciting avenue through which dynamic molecular processes can be interrogated at the cellular level in bacteria. An alternative approach for detecting transcriptional and translational activity in non-culturable cells is to use reporter genes. Here, a gene whose expression can readily be detected is introduced into, and maintained in, a culturable cell population. The reporter gene is either used to monitor expression of a particular gene or operon as a transcriptional or a translational fusion. The cells from the cultured population are then rendered non-culturable and expression of the reporter molecule monitored biochemically or at the cytological level. Where the objective is to monitor expression of a specific gene in nonculturable cells, careful controls are necessary to distinguish expression before and after transition to non-culturability. Induced expression relating to a specific promoter offers clear advantages in this respect because application of the inducing signal can be delayed until the target cells are non-culturable. Selected examples of reporter gene-based studies relevant to these issues are given in Table 3.
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
108
Table 3 Examples of the use of reporter gene systems to assess bacterial activity and integrity Reporter
Use
lac2
Activity in non-culturablecells Nwoguh et al. (1995)
Green fluorescent protein (Gfp)
Marking of cells and evidence of protein synthesis
Dhandayuthapani et al. ( 1 995), Kremer et al. ( 1 995)
Red-shifted variants of Gfp
High throughout screening assays in M.tuberculosis
Collins et al. ( 1 998)
Unstable variants of Gfp
To differentiate recent translation from persisting protein
Andersen et al. (1998)
Vibrio harveyi
Marking of cells Activity assays
Aminhanjani et al. (l993), Ferguson et al. (1995). Loessner et al. (1996). Aldsworth et al. (1998)
Reporter bacteriphages for detection and activity assay
Jacobs et al. (1993), Sarkis et al. ( 1995)
L d B Firefly luciferase
References
TWO further approaches that may be considered within the molecular genetic category should be mentioned here. These are detection of gene transfer involving non-culturable cells and the use of bacteriophages. One interesting report indicates that plasmids may be transferable from culturable to non-culturable cells (Arana et al., 1997) and the development of plaqueforming bacteriophages as a rapid means of detecting specific bacteria (Wilson et al., 1997; Stewart et a/.,1998) raises the possibility that these viruses might be able to multiply in non-culturable cells of the target organism. Further investigation of these approaches is necessary before their value can be assessed. 5.4. Developments in Instrumentation
In the present context, developments in instrumentation have either extended the range of direct and/or indirect methods used to assess activity at cellular or population levels. In this section, we assess the impact that the availability of these instruments has had on studies concerned with bacterial viability and culturability. Flow cytometry (FCM), which was developed in the 1970s, has been used in both direct and indirect assays (Davey and Kell, 1996).The method depends
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
109
on passing a stream of single cells past a light source (often a laser) and detecting both light-scattering and fluorescence with strategically placed photomultiplier tubes. It allows for the rapid assessment of the light scattering properties and fluorescence (up to three excitation and emission wavelengths simultaneously) of cell suspensions at flow rates around 103 cells per second. This clearly facilitates the analysis of very large cell populations and the simultaneous recording of up to four distinct cellular properties. The use of FCM to detect growth at times well before change in biomass would have been detected by macrocolony formation or increase in broth turbidity has been used to considerable effect (Button et af.,1993). Moreover, the availability of these instruments has undoubtedly assisted development of new fluorescent or fluorogenic reagents by increasing the market for such products. FCM functions optimally with relatively high cell density suspensions that are free from particles that may either block the flow or generate confusing signals. A particularly valuable addition to flow cytometry is fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS), which can be used to separate populations of cells with specific signal patterns (Davey and Kell, 1996). An interesting recent development, related to FCM, is solid-phase cytometry (Mignon-Godefroy et al., 1997). Here the test material is accumulated on a sample filter, fluorescently labelled then scanned with a narrow laser beam; emissions are again detected by a photomultiplier.The potential advantages of this approach include easier processing of larger sample volumes than FCM, the ability to tolerate more particulate material, the capacity to cross-check specific signals by microscopy and, in some cases, the capacity to place the sample filters on agar plates and obtain colonial growth that can be specifically related to individual signals. The technology is particularly valuable for the detection and confirmation of rare events. It clearly has much to offer in the present context and we await its further evaluation with interest. Three lines of development in fluorescence microscopy have augmented the range of available instrumentation: charged coupled device (CCD) cameras (particularly where the detector is cooled) have enhanced the sensitivity of cytological assays (Shotton, 1993); digital image analysis systems have enabled objective and quantitative assessments of the results (Whiteley et af., 1998); and the development of convolutional deblurring systems (Shaw, 1994) and confocal microscopes (Pawley, 1995) have allowed analysis of thick samples (10-300 pm) in three dimensions. The last of these developments is particularly important because it enables bacteria to be analysed under circumstances where their spatial interrelationships with other features in their natural environments, including other microorganisms, have not been unduly disrupted (James et al., 1995;Manz et al., 1995; Neef et al., 1996; Christensen et af., 1998). These situations include biofilms and flocks or other consortia of organisms (Amann et al., 1996; Neef et al., 1996). Microscopy has predominantly been used in indirect assessments of
110
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
viability and the microcolony assays used by Postgate and Quesnel and their colleagues (Postgate, 1967;Al-Qudah et al., 1983) have not, with some notable exceptions (Rodrigues and Kroll, 1988; Hojberg et al., 1997), been used extensively in recent years. Many instruments have been developed with the objective of detecting growth earlier than is possible by conventional colony or turbidity methods and the reader is referred to recent reviews for a discussion of their relative merits (Swaminathan and Feng, 1994; Hobson et al., 1996). The discussion above concerning limited cell replication raises an interesting point in this context (and in relation to microcolony assays). What is the minimum number of generations that can be considered indicative of viability? 5.5. What Do the 'New' Methods Tell Us?
A theme we have pursued throughout this section has been our ability to classify all new methods into direct and indirect assessments of viability. We see no reason to deviate from the framework established by Postgate and hold that, irrespective of their sophistication, the newly developed indirect methods are not reliable means of determining viability in all circumstances.We recognize that to some this view may seem harsh and offer further discussion in two areas to support our view. The first area concerns the significance of negative reactions obtained in indirect assays. Where these assays depend on reagent delivery into or extraction of indicator molecules from non-culturable cells, there are no reliable means by which we can be sure that these key aspects of the assay have performed successfully. Such permeability issues can be addressed in growing cells. However, it is self-evident that the structure of the cell envelope changes during sporulation, and several workers have noted changes in cell structure and lipid composition during studies in non-culturable forms of culturable bacteria (Rollins and Colwell, 1986; Linder and Oliver, 1989; Colwell and Huq, 1994; Hazeleger et al., 1995). These observations make it difficult to be sure that reagent access is adequate or that extraction of the molecule to be analysed has been effective. Moreover, why should temporarily non-culturable cells be active rather than dormant (cf. Table 1 and Kell et al., 1998)? Dormant cells of M. luteus and bacterial spores, respectively, show reduced activity (Kaprelyants and Kell, 1993) or no activity (Coney, R. P. and Barer, M. R., unpublished observations) in rhodamine-123 accumulation assays. Why should demonstrable aspects of cellular activity continue in temporarily nonculturable bacteria? In sporulating bacteria, performing the assay after a germinant has been added to the sample can, to some extent, circumvent this problem. However, in the case of non-culturable bacteria that are putatively temporarily so, we have no idea what the appropriate germinant might be.
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
111
These issues undermine our confidence in activity assays and assays aimed at determining the content (e.g. DNA and RNA) of non-culturable cells. We also wish to expand briefly on the potential significance of assays which demonstrate that recent transcription and/or translation must have taken place in non-culturable cells (see Section 5.3). Although such demonstrations may seem a plausible basis on which to consider a cell viable and the processes involved are undoubtedly a necessary aspect of viability, they are not in themselves sufficient for cell replication. The same argument may be applied to a positive result in the Kogure test, although the processes involved there are not clearly established. This distinction between aspects of cellular composition and activity that are necessary for and those that are sufficient for viability provide a clear view of the problems faced by indirect assays. If a cell can be shown to contain the same amount of DNA as a cell of the same strain that was subsequently cultured, we still do not know whether it has the DNA it needs for replication. It has what appears to be sufficient DNA but it may not have the necessary DNA. Even the quantitative issues cannot readily be resolved. We simply do not know what the minimum set of intact processes required for viability may be, let alone have the capacity to demonstrate them all in one assay. Moreover, it seems likely that lesions or deficiencies affecting any one of these processes might lead to non-culturability and potential reasons for nonculturability are, therefore, legion. We may learn more about these issues from minimum genome programmes (Itaya, 1995). These arguments may also be inverted to pose the question, ‘what features may we expect in a cell that has lost viability as a result of one particular lesion or deficiency?’. There seems no obvious reason why such a cell should go to the trouble of dismantling its physiological functions simply to assist microbiologists in differentiating between viable and non-viable cells. Of course, cellular autolysis may provide essential nutrients to other bacteria in the same community. Conversely, maintenance of cell integrity in non-viable cells may also provide certain advantages to a bacterial community because such cells may continue to participate in nutrient cycling reactions or production of secondary metabolites that inhibit other organisms. Loss of the capacity to replicate does not mean that an organism ceases to have a useful function in its community (consider the historical role of eunuchs).
6. FACTORS INFLUENCING THE OUTCOME OF CULTURABILITY TESTS
Culturability tests are integral to virtually all aspects of bacteriology. From the determination of inhibitory action in identification and susceptibility tests to monitoring the microbial content of industrial systems, environmental samples
112
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
and medical specimens, what can be grown and the number of independent colony- or turbidity-forming units present constitute the benchmarks against which practical decisions are taken. The value of culture as a basis for such decisions has been undermined by the developmentsoutlined above. Moreover, the desirability of replacing culture by molecular methods for diagnostic work presents additional challenges. Just as we have learned to temper our reactions to the detection of microbes by microscopy by comparing such results with those obtained by culture, it seems likely that we shall need more sophisticated molecular detection systems (e.g. detection of specific mRNA molecules) that are more explicitly and practically instructive than detection of genomic DNA. Where the influence of an organism on its environment is dependent on its potential for replication (viability) any new indicator will have to be calibrated against culturability. Thus, for the foreseeable future, it will be necessary to understand the factors that can cause a viable cell to be temporarily nonculturable. 6.1. Injury and Recovery
Injury can be caused by chemical or physical agents and may be lethal (render cells non-viable) or sublethal; the latter may affect subsequent growth characteristics. Where the processes have been studied, some information concerning the molecular species that have been damaged is available. Thus, for example, injury to the cell envelope (Ray et al., 1976), proteins (Elkest and Marth, 1992; Nystrom, 1998) and DNA (Walker, 1996) are all recognized, and recovery is seen as the processes by which those damaged molecules are repaired or replaced. The SOS response discussed above, was first recognized as a response to DNA damage (Defais et al., 1971) and arrests cell division (hence culturability) until SulA-mediated inhibition of FtsZ (septation) ceases. A large section of the information on injury and repair processes in bacteria relates to DNA damage and is concerned with the potential of the repair processes to introduce genetic change (Quillardet and Hofnung, 1993). Relatively few investigations have studied the interactions between sublethal DNA damage and culturability. Perhaps the most relevant recent work here is that of Mackey and Seymour (1987) who investigated the recovery of DNA repair mutants of Escherichiu coli after heat-induced damage. They found sensitivity to heating at 52 "C was increased in recA, recB and pol A mutants, but not in uvrA, uvrB or recF mutants. Interestingly, they observed specific immediate post-exposure conditions that could either increase or decrease the colony counts obtained in their polA mutant. The authors suggested that their treatment rendered the target cells sensitive to hydrogen peroxide in the culture medium by inactivating inducible catalase/peroxidase. Classically,injury has been recognized by failure of an organism to grow on
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
113
a selective medium that normally supports its growth whilst maintaining its ability to grow on a non-selective medium (Allen et al., 1952; Mossel and Ratto, 1970; Ray et al., 1972; Speck et al., 1975; Hackney et al., 1979). However, damage can also produce cells that cannot grow at all until the recovery (repair) process has taken place (Walker, 1996; Dukan et al., 1997). Thus, while the selectivehon-selective medium test provides a useful generic approach to detect injured cells for experimental studies (LeChevallier et al., 1985; Singh et al., 1986), it cannot be considered universal. Another approach to identifying injured cells has been to compare colony counts on media with and without additions that reduce oxidative stress. In the 1970s, it was recognized that, in some cases, addition of reagents such as pyruvate or catalase to the recovery medium could give higher colony counts relating to certain stressed bacterial populations than unsupplemented media (Martin et al., 1976; Brewer et al., 1977; Flowers et al., 1977; Mossel et al., 1980a). Like the selectivehon-selective medium approach, this method can be used to categorize cells as injured (Arana et al., 1992) but does not provide a means of detecting all injured cells (Mossel et al., 1980a). In some cases, peroxide in the enumeration medium may be acting as a selective reagent (Mackey and Seymour, 1987) whereas in others peroxide toxicity may occur prior to plating (Arana et al., 1992). Injury can also be recognized by demonstrating the necessity for a recovery phase before cells will grow on under conditions used for selective isolation. This type of phenomenon has been demonstrated with respect to the ability of organisms to grow at relatively high temperatures (Mossel et al., 1980b; Humphrey, 1986) and on selective media (Speck et al., 1975). The noxious agent in injury is normally thought to be exogenous. However, the possibility has been recognized that damaging molecular species such as oxygen radicals may be produced endogenously by bacteria that have not adapted to a specific medium or that are not capable of doing so (see Section 6.4). 6.2. Ageing
Ageing in bacteria may be defined as the process that occurs when growth ceases. At some point, this presumably leads to loss of replication potential. The effects of this process may be mitigated by turnover, but it seems reasonable to assume that accumulation of damage and decline in the resources available to repair that damage are constant pressures on the viability of nongrowing bacteria. Nystriim (1998) has recently proposed a scheme that identifies several molecular processes at the centre of the ageing process in bacteria. The scheme concentrates on proteins as the key molecules that determine whether a cell
114
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
retains the capacity for replication and identifies oxidative stress as the principal detrimental influence. Hence those activities that can reverse or oppose the effects of oxidation, particularly on sulfur groups, appear to maintain culturability, essentially by retarding the ageing process. The molecules responsible for reversal of damage include heat-shock proteins, L-isoaspartyl protein methyl transferase, peptide methionine sulphoxide reductase and glutathione reductase, while catalase and superoxide dismutase actively oppose damage. The ArcNArcB response regulator/sensorpair appears to control many of the elements of this system. ArcA represses genes encoding dehydrogenases of the flavoprotein class, several enzymes of the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle and the cytochrome o-type oxidase complex while other regulators, including OxyR, SoxRS, RpoS and RpoH, up-regulate the expression of elements that reverse or oppose the effects of oxidant stress. The net effect is to reduce the production of oxygen radicals and to protect cells from their deleterious effects. The scheme proposed by Nystrom (1998) provides an excellent platform from which many hypotheses concerning the survival of growth-arrestedcells may be tested. For example, the bulk rate of protein synthesis and turnover in growth-arrested cells should have discernible effects on survival. However, in the present context, we are concerned with damage to polypeptides that are required for the cell or population of cells to return to a growingheplicating state, and we are faced with the question of how many distinct targets in the proteome can be involved. A priori it seems likely that there could be many critical targets (e.g. RNA polymerase, adenylate kinase, FtsZ) or combinations thereof, whose damage might limit (see Section 6.1) or abolish a cell’s replication potential. Ultimately, it would be desirable to identify all of these putative targets, although the technical difficultiesinvolved would be substantial. A starting point might be to ask whether the evidence points to a restricted range of dominant targets or to a more diverse set. It seems unlikely that polypeptides are the only molecular targets underpinning the ageing process. In a given environment, cellular nucleic acids, lipids and carbohydrates all, presumably, accumulate damage that has the potential to affect culturability. Clearly, the impact of these lesions depends on whether the cell concerned has retained repair andor turnover functions, which would, of course, be determined by its functional protein complement. Moreover, these non-protein organic molecules appear to be less sensitive to oxidative modification and their damage has been studied extensively in relation to specific noxious influences (e.g. antibiotics, disinfectants, radiation, heat). Another way to look at ageing in bacteria is to consider the age of individual cellular components. Even in replicating cells, all components are not of equal age. For example, semi-conservative replication of DNA means that one strand of the genomic DNA was acquired from the parental cell and there is a
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
115
one in four chance that the strand concerned came from the grandparent. Cell wall material also passes on from generation to generation. While the septa1 material is newly synthesized, the poles contain material that was synthesized in previous generations (Clarke-Sturman et al., 1989). It is therefore possible that a given cell may have certain components, such as single nucleic acid strands, ribosomes and peptidogylcan, that are several generations old. The critical and largely unanswerable question here is the degree to which partition of such aged components into a particular cell may compromize its culturability. However, although these processes have the potential to produce some degree of replicative senescence, the effect is not uniform on the population of a replicating culture. At one extreme it may be imagined that a given strand of genomic DNA has a finite ‘life span’ of say 12 h when its environment is that of a steadily replicating cell. If the host organism replicates 20 times in this period, then one cell in lo6 will contain this aged molecule after 12 h. The frequency at which cells are affected by receipt of old components can therefore be seen as a function of the life span of the component, its rate of turnover and the rate of cell replication. In this context, replication itself can be seen as a way of avoiding the ageing process and confining its effects to a minority of cells. 6.3. Adaptation and Differentiation
It is clear that a simple growinghon-growing two-state description of bacteria, which dominated many aspects of practical bacteriology in the past, is not adequate to describe the different ways in which these organisms behave. All the environmental signals that a bacterial culture is capable of sensing alter the profile of genes transcribed and messages translated by that culture (VanBogelen et al., 1997). In some cases, particular signals elicit a programme of successive changes in gene expression (Kjelleberg et al., 1993). By convention, when such a programme leads to morphological changes that can be recognized by light microscopy, the process is called differentiation.* It is quite clear that differentiation into forms such as spores can alter culturability. This can be quantitative by changing the lag phase (effectively by adding the time taken for germination and outgrowth) or qualitative by restricting the range of media that support growth of the organism to those that contain the required germinants. The critical question for this discussion is whether some non-differentiating organisms are capable of adaptive responses that affect either or both aspects of culturability. These issues have been highlighted in a recent review in which the authors consider whether the
* The distinction is somewhat arbitrary and we would prefer to use the terms morphological and physiologicallmetabolic differentiation. Nonetheless, we retain the conventional usage here.
116
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
responses of bacterial cells, which were demonstrated to be temporarily nonculturable (or NIC), are best classified as adaptation or injury (Kell et af., 1998). Two well-studied systems provide a focus for these considerations: the effect of cold storage on Vibrio vulnificus and dormancy in extended stationary phase in Micrococcus futeus. The I! vulni$cus studies published predominantly by Oliver and his associates seem to provide a particularly promising avenue through which a genetic basis for temporal non-culturability might be determined. Exposure of this organism to temperatures around 4 "C is associated with a decline in culturability without cell lysis. Hence, large numbers of non-culturable cells are produced over periods ranging from days to several weeks depending on the state of the inoculum at the time of temperature downshift and the maintenance environment (Oliver, 1995). On several occasions, resuscitation of these non-culturable cells has been reported following temperature upshift (Nilsson et al., 1991; Oliver and Bockian, 1995; Oliver et af., 1995; Whitesides and Oliver, 1997; Warner and Oliver, 1998). The association of these temperature shifts with changes in culturabilty indicates that environmental signals known to elicit adaptive responses, the coldand heat-shock responses, may, respectively, cause cells to become NIC and subsequently to resuscitate. Although it is attractive to speculate that cells may 'elect' to become NIC as part of the cold-shock response (McGovern and Oliver, 1995; Panoff et a f . , 1998), we are not aware of any evidence that expression of genes within the cold-shock regulon of I! vulnificus cause cells to become either temporarily or permanently non-culturable. The I! vulnificus story is complicated by data indicating that cold-induced injury plays a significant role in loss of culturability and that a fraction of the injured population may retain the potential to resuscitate presumably through their capacity for repair (Weichart and Kjelleberg, 1996;Weichart et al., 1997). Moreover, some concerns have been expressed about the capacity of the culture methods applied in the earlier studies to distinguish between resuscitation and regrowth (Weichart et af., 1992) and a few of these concerns remain (Kell et af., 1998). Nonetheless, work on I! vulnificus holds out the clearest possibilities for linking the established field of adaptive responses in bacteria with the VBNC hypothesis. The extended stationary phase phenomena studied in M. futeus by Kaprelyants, Kell and their colleagues provides an example of a well-studied system in which temporary non-culturability is associated with dormancy as defined operationally in Table 1. Maintenance of stationary-phase M. futeus cultures at room temperature for several months leads to production of large numbers of non-culturable cells. These showed substantially reduced capacity to take up the membrane energization-sensitivedye rhodamine-123 (the test of dormancy in these experiments) compared with early stationary- or exponential-phase cells (Kaprelyants and Kell, 1993). Further studies demonstrated that
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
117
temporarily non-culturable cells could be resuscitated in the presence of supernatants from growing M. luteus cultures (Kaprelyants et al., 1994, 1996). Critically, the use of most probable number cultures and penicillin lysis in these experiments excluded regrowth as a likely explanation for the claimed resuscitation events. The influence of culturable cells on NIC cells was further elucidated (Votyakova et al., 1994) and the approach has recently led to the identification of a 17 kDa protein exported by M. luteus that is responsible for resuscitation (Mukamolova et al., 1998). As the production of non-culturable cells in the M.luteus studies is a slow process compared with the phenomena observed in K vuln@cus, it seems less likely that an adaptive response is involved in the sense of a programme of gene expression which leads to the development of NIC cells. However, the changes in gene expression that occur in stationary phase have been studied extensively (Kolter et al., 1993; Hengge-Aronis, 1996; Nystrom, 1998) and it remains possible that the development of M. luteus cells that are both NIC and dormant could represent one aspect of this adaptive response. Interestingly, there is also evidence that NIC M. luteus cells are injured and that a repair process takes place. Prior to resuscitation, many dormant cells are permeant to the fluorescent DNA stain PO-PRO-3 and resuscitation is associated with restoration of the membrane barrier to this reagent (Votyakova et al., 1994; Kaprelyants et al., 1996). Since these observations favour damage rather than a specific adaptive response as the cause for declining culturability in the M . luteus studies, there seems little incentive to search for genes that might actively promote transition to the NIC state. In contrast, the recent description of the 17 kDa resuscitation promoting factor (Rpf) holds out strong prospects for identifying genes whose expression is regulated by this ‘bacterial cytokine’ (Mukamolovaet al., 1998). 6.4. Substrate-accelerated Death and Other Forms of Metabolic Self-destruction
In this and the next section we consider processes intrinsic to the cell population under investigation that may, when stimulated, lead to a reduction in culturable cell numbers. These processes are very difficult to take into account when performing culturability tests because their importance has only been demonstrated in a limited range of systems. Postgate and colleagues described the phenomenon of substrate-accelerated death (Dawes, 1976). They observed that, when cultures of Klebsiella aerogenes were grown to stationary phase by specific substrate limitation then maintained in non-nutrient media containing that substrate, widely divergent values were obtained for culturability on recovery media supplemented with or without the ‘traumatic’ (sic) substrate (Postgate and Hunter, 1963, 1964;
118
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Calcott and Postgate, 1972). Their culturability (viability) test was a slideculture-based microcolony assay and they found that the specific substrate exhausted cultures yielded a significantly higher percentage of colony-forming cells on medium without the traumatic substrate compared with medium with this substrate. Thus, in the case of lactose exhaustion, counts on lactose-containing medium could be brought up to the same levels obtained on lactose-free medium by inclusion of cyclic AMP (CAMP)in the lactose-containing recovery medium (Calcott and Postgate, 1972). Moreover, cells treated with the traumatic substrate had low levels of cAMP (Calcott et al., 1972) and these may have been attributable to phosphodiesterase activity (Calcott and Calvert, 1981). Although it was clear that CAMP-dependent processes such as genes regulated by the cognate CRP (CAMPreceptor protein) protein and catabolite repression were involved, neither the mechanism of ‘death’nor the protective effect of CAMPhave been explained. Although phenomena associated with substrate-accelerated death have been demonstrated in Klebsiella, Escherichia, Streptococcus, Azotobacter, Arthrobacter and Mycobacteriu (Calcott and Calvert, 198 l), the overall importance of these phenomena has not been established. Substrate-accelerated death could account for underestimates of viability in any system in which cells are exposed to the original limiting nutrient in the recovery medium. This issue can be readily addressed in laboratory experiments but clearly presents a problem for environmental studies where the limiting nutrient is unlikely to be known. As pointed out by Dawes (1976), there are adjustments that could be made to recovery media that might reduce this problem but, as far as we are aware, neither these nor the overall impact of substrate-accelerated death on recovery of bacteria from environmental samples have been investigated systematically. The advances in our understanding of cAMP in prokaryotes (Botsford and Harman, 1992) and in metabolic control at the molecular level combined with the resurgence of interest in bacterial viability indicate that the time is ripe for a re-investigation of substrate-accelerated death. Recently, it has been suggested that VBNC phenomena might be explained on the basis of a metabolic imbalance that leads to overproduction of oxygen radicals in relation to the source cell’s capacity to deal with these potentially lethal molecular species (Dodd et al., 1997; Bloomfield et al., 1998). Although there are many attractive aspects to this proposal as an explanation for discrepancies between active cell numbers and those that can produce colonies, we and others have been critical of the formulation of the hypothesis (Barer et al., 1998). The principal reasons for this are the authors’ implication that VBNC phenomena can be considered unitary in their origin and their use of the term ‘suicide’.As we note above, and quite apart from the contradictions of the term VBNC, so many different processes that lead to the production of nonculturable cells have been brought under its umbrella that we do not believe the
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
119
term can have any useful meaning in relation to the specific processes discussed by these authors. Moreover, we do not favour the use of the term ‘suicide’ in this context because there are mechanisms that have been defined at the molecular level that can be legitimately described by this term (see Section 6.5). These points aside, there is circumstantial evidence for the self-destructive mechanism proposed (Aldsworth et al., 1998), although the degree to which it can be distinguished from the catalase protection phenomena described in Section 6.1 and specifically assigned to oxidative damage remains to be established. 6.5. Lysogenic Bacteriophages and Toxin-Antitoxin Systems
These two elements -the hoWsoc programmed cell death system is an example of the latter (Gerdes et al., 1997) - both have the potential to influence the outcome of a culturability test. They are considered together here because they represent fairly well characterized molecular processes that can lead to a sudden fall in culturability in response to specific stimuli. Moreover, the balance of selective pressures that leads to their maintenance within a bacterial population indicates that they may confer some survival advantage on the host cell. In the case of bacteriophages, this may be in the form of genes such as ‘virulence’ determinants whose expression may be advantageous in the life cycle of the host bacterium. Although it seems self-evident that populations of bacteria carrying lysogenic bacteriophages have the potential for rapid loss of culturability when phage production is induced, there is little information on the influence this potential has in practice. Given the potential for oxidative stress at the time of plating bacteria onto agar and the capacity for such stress to induce DNA damage, we speculate that, in some cases, low colony counts might result from SOS response-related induction of bacteriophage. The frequent recognition of prophages by the genome-sequencing projects (Blamer et al., 1997; Kunst et al., 1997; Cole et al., 1998) makes the potential for phagemediated lysis at the time of plating extensive. In contrast, the toxin-antitoxin systems have generally been identified as plasmid maintenance determinants and have been employed to this end in biotechnological applications (Pecota et al., 1997). While it is straightforward to understand why a host bacterium maintains a plasmid-encoded toxin-antitoxin system, the presence of chromosomal homologues of these systems indicates that there may be other selective pressures involved in their maintenance. For example, the capacity for cells to self-destruct may confer a survival advantage on the organism at the population level, particularly when the population is large and confronted with starvation (Aizenman et al., 1996;
120
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Nystrom, 1998). In this context it does seem legitimate to use the term ‘suicide’ because the process is encoded by host genes and seems to represent an evolved response to environmental circumstances. We contend that this contrasts with the metabolic self-destruction processes (i.e. substrate-accelerated death, see Section 6.4) that result from failure to adapt to a new environment. Bacterial toxin-antitoxin systems are characterized by the production of a stable toxin and an unstable antitoxin. They fall into two groups, the proteic systems (Jensen and Gerdes, 1995), in which toxin-antitoxin interactions occur at the protein level, and those in which translation of the toxin mRNA is regulated by antisense RNA (Gerdes et al., 1997). In the latter case the relative instability of the antisense (antitoxin) messenger provides the incentive for its continued transcription rather than direct neutralization of the active toxin by an unstable polypeptide. From the perspective of this discussion, three very interesting proteic ‘suicide’ systems have been identified in E. coli. Firstly, the chromosomal chpA locus (also designated rnazEF) is located just downstream of the relA gene. Its transcription is repressed by ppGpp and amino-acid starvation (Aizenman et al., 1996) and can therefore be expected to result in an excess of toxin (Nystrom, 1998). Secondly, the delayed relaxed phenotype, which includes poor recovery after starvation, associated with relB mutants has recently been shown to involve a newly identified toxin-antitoxin system encoded by the chromosomal relBEF operon. Thirdly, the ccd system of the F plasmid encodes the CcdB toxin which binds to the GyrA subunit of DNA gyrase by a mechanism that is similar to quinolones. The CcdB toxin is also a powerful inducer of the SOS response (Couturier et al., 1998)’and its expression and neutralization presumably influence the processes affecting activity and culturability assays discussed above (see Sections 5.2 and 6.1). The molecular target of toxin action has only been identified in the case of CcdB and two other systems, and the phenotype of the cells at the time when culturability is lost is essentially unknown. Moreover, the recognition that toxin action may sometimes be reversible (Jensen and Gerdes, 1995)raises the possibility that cells may be rendered temporarily non-culturable by the action of some toxins belonging to these toxin-antitoxin gene families. The systems discussed in this section are primarily of concern in the present context inasmuch as they may affect culturability and activity assays at the time of sampling. It is clear that they can have a substantialeffect on cell integrity and replication, although very little is known about their influence in practice. 6.6. Cell-to-cell Communication (Quorum Sensing)
This topical subject has been addressed in several recent reviews (Fuqua et al., 1996; Swift etal., 1996a,b; Gray, 1997; Kleerebezem et al., 1997) and will not
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
121
be covered in detail here. However, the proposal that bacteria may need to communicate with each other for growth (Kaprelyants and Kell, 1996) is clearly relevant to this review. It is now clear that many aspects of bacterial physiology are profoundly influenced by potent autocrine molecular signals. In Gram-positive bacteria, post-translationally processed peptides have been the dominant molecular family identified (Kleerebezem et al., 1997), while the N-acyl homoserine lactones appear to be the key extracellularcompounds in many Gram-negative bacteria (Swift et al., 1996a,b). Signalling has been shown to be involved in processes as diverse as competence induction (Kleerebezem et al., 1997), luminescence (Williams et al., 1992) and virulence (Pearson et al., 1997). Here we are concerned with the effect that the concentration of a particular signal (or signal antagonist) may have on culturability assays. The central dogma of those that perform colony and MPN counts has been that a viable individual cell has the independent capacity to replicate to discernible levels when placed in an appropriate nutritious medium. Kaprelyants and Kell challenge this view by presenting evidence that counts of culturable bacteria maintained in extended stationary-phasecultures can be enhanced by several orders of magnitude in the presence of conditioned media containing putative communication molecules (pheromones). Subsequently, this group has characterized one of the molecules in the conditioned medium as a bacterial cytokine, Rpf (see Section 6.3), and it should now be possible to determine the basis for its biological activity. A search for rpfhomologues in other bacteria revealed that related genes appear to be present in mycobacteria (notably the pathogenic species M . tuberculosis and M. leprae) and in several other high G+C ratio Gram-positive bacteria but not in other bacteria for which the cornplete genome sequence was available (Mukamolova et al., 1998). While these findings have exciting implications for the cultivation of mycobacteria and for the extended latent phase of clinical tuberculosis, the general question of whether rpfis just one example of an essential gene contributing to the growth and replication of all bacteria must be addressed. At present there is little evidence to support the view that Gram-negative and low G+C Gram-positive bacteria have Rpf-like systems. However, there are several experimental systems in which communication clearly influences the length of the lag phase or the rate of growth (Kaprelyants and Kell, 1996). Conversely, the presence of autocrine inhibitory or killer molecules has also been inferred in a number of studies (Weichart et al., 1992; Zambrano and Kolter, 1993; Barrow et al., 1996; Zhang-Barber et al., 1997). These factors make it difficult to decide on conditions under which to perform culture tests. Signalling molecules may be present at the time of sampling and subsequently they may be disrupted by or diluted out by the test procedure. Moreover, conditions of the test procedure may influence production of signalling molecules. However limited or influential cell signalling phenomena are on the
122
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
outcome of culturability assays, this particular Pandora’s box is now open and signalling as a potential source of bias must now be taken into account. Clearly ,all standard dilution assays such as colony and MPN counts do not provide cells with the same concentration of signalling molecules at each dilution level. The challenge is to devise culturability tests that control the constellation of signalling molecules available to the test population and to do so in a manner that enables consistent determinations. In one interesting study, Bogosian and colleagues (1998) attempted to account for these difficulties by providing equal access to the putative growth-supporting pheromones of immediately culturable cells in a mixed-culture assay system. In fact, they were unable to detect any influence attributable to signalling molecules and, in particular, found no evidence for transition from NIC to culturable states in the Enterobacteriaceaetested. It is worth noting that most signalling phenomena have been recognized between cells belonging to a single species or strain. There is no theoretical bar to cross-talk between species in microbial consortia. Indeed it would be surprising, given the relatively restricted range of molecules so far identified in this role, if more examples of cross-talk did not emerge in the future (Bassler et al., 1997; Dunphy et al., 1997). Finally, direct interference with signalling processes has recently been shown to affect the survival capacity of carbon-starved bacteria (Srinivasan et al., 1998). The antagonistic molecules were isolated from marine plants and appear to prevent establishment of biofilm growth on leaf surfaces. Clearly, we have some way to go before we have identified, let alone controlled, the influence of signalling molecules on culturability tests.
7. SHOULD BACTERIAL VIABILITY BE ASSESSED AT THE INDIVIDUAL OR COMMUNITY LEVEL?
In this review we have predominantly considered viability as a testable property of individual cells. However, in the preceding section we recognized that contributions from other cells in a community of bacteria may influence the capacity of a particular cell to yield a positive result in a culturability test. Furthermore, we have also noted the possibility that some cells in a community may deliberately sacrifice themselves in order to provide resources, enabling the remaining cells to maintain themselves against adverse conditions. To these instances we should add the recognition that community size clearly influences many bacteriological phenomena. The duration of the lag phase has been shown to be inversely related to the number of cells present at the time of inoculation in several instances (note this is distinct from the effects on time before growth can be detected; see Kaprelyants and Kell, 1996);
BACTERIAL VlAB ILlTY AND CULTURABILlTY
123
establishment of infections requires that the infectious dose is exceeded and both the outcome and reproducibility of antibiotic susceptibility tests depend on careful inoculum control. It also seems clear that, apart from the extracellular products that have been characterized as pheromones, the activity of certain enzymes at the community level as opposed to the individual level in ‘detoxifying the environment’, e.g. by antibiotic (Brook and Gober, 1995) or hydrogen peroxide degradation (Ma and Eaton, 1992),can protect cells that do not produce the required activity within that community. These considerations provoke us to ask whether it is appropriate to assess the viability of individual bacteria. On the one hand, the capacity of an individual cell to replicate to discernible levels seems closely linked to a panoply of signals received from its colleagues and the environment. On the other, survival during replication appears to depend on a variety of protective activities, many of which are provided by the community rather than the individual. An alternative view is that viability is a property of a community of bacteria. In different settings, the community may comprise a single strain or diverse species. From this perspective, viability might be recognized as the capacity of the test community to increase its biomass andor numbers in a specific environment. One consequence of this approach is that the absolute number of propagules in a community is just one component of that community’s fitness for a particular environment. Thus, while it may be possible to revive injured cells within in a community, as observed by McFeters’ group (LeChevallier et al., 1985; Singh et ul., 1986), their capacity to contribute to a stressful colonization event such as an infection may be limited. Conversely, there might be community-levelresponses that confer greater fitness for certain environments such that a smaller number of individuals drawn from that population could successfully colonize. Outside the laboratory, bacterial communities are nearly always consortia composed of different species. There are many instances where interactions between heterologous species may alter the outcome in culturability or activity assays. These may involve well-recognized molecules presumably involved in natural competition, such as antibiotics and colicins. Alternatively, metabolic cross-protection (Aldsworth et al., 1998) or cross-talk between signalling molecules (Kaprelyants and Kell, 1996) could be involved.Again, it is appropriate to consider the relevance of these factors to the outcome of a culturability test. Coordinated behaviour of bacteria in natural communities is most strikingly observed in biofilms. The importance of signalling in the establishment, development and structure of these complex consortia is now clear, and evaluation of the health and survival potential of a particular biofilm by assessing the number of culturable cells within it seems wholly inappropriate (Davies et al., 1998; Kolter and Losick, 1998). Conversely, there clearly are some settings in which the survival of a single propagule is of biological and practical significance. The general need for
124
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
sterility (absence of any viable cells) in the provision of surgical instruments, parenteral pharmaceutical preparations and many industrial processes seems beyond doubt. There is also considerable evidence to suggest that some undesirable processes such as hazardous levels of contamination, spoilage during food production or other manufacturing processes and infective diseases can be initiated by a single organism. In view of these considerations, we suggest that viability tests might be adjusted to determine the potential of bacteria within the sample material to initiate a specific process. Clearly, this is already the case in many instances where experience and legislation have established upper limits to acceptable levels of culturability of specific bacteria in foods, potable water and bathing areas. However, there is considerable unease relating both to the utility and the validity of these (semi-)quantitative tests. One purpose of this section has been to raise the issue of whether quantitative tests of culturability actually provide the best test of an organism’s ability to colonize or influence a new environment.
8. CONCLUSIONS (Figs 1 and 2)
1. Culturability remains the only secure operational definition of viability. 2. We prefer the terms temporarily non-culturable and not immediately culturable (NIC) to ‘viable but non-culturable’ (VNCNBNC). 3. As yet uncultured (AYU) bacteria should be considered separately from non-culturable forms of culturable bacteria. 4. New indirect methods, such as fluorescence and reporter gene-based assays provide information about the physiological properties of cells but can only be considered reliable indicators of culturability under highly defined conditions. 5. The outcome of a culturability test can be influenced by multiple factors. Some of these have been summarized in Fig. 1. These make it very difficult to design, sample and test regimens that reveal all potentially culturable cells of a particular bacterial strain within environments that present different stimuli to the test organism. Our experience indicates that these factors become more significant in bacterial populations that are not replicating or have been stressed or both. 6. There are some situations where it is more appropriate to consider the viability of a bacterial population or community rather than its component individuals.
Input
Environm mts relevant to the test Natural or Test sample and II Culture conditions Experimental
Properties of the organism(s) to be tested (Genetically determined):
state@) (PS) of
Range of stimulons and the responses they may initiate
sample processing
New Physiological state@) (PS):
the test organisms: Replicating/ Non-replicating’
Nutritional requirements Physical requirements
l
General responses to environmental
R/NR GRTES ?+ Activation of: Suicide systems Prophages Metabolic selfdestr~ction~
I Replication I GRTES ?+ Activation of Suicide systems Prophages Metabolic self-destruction
t
Properties of the
PO + PS Environmental Stimuli: Chemical Physical
OutDut
4
f
Environmental Stimuli: Chemical Physical Biological
Environmental Stimuli: Chemical Physical Biological
Number of cells5 at end of test in a) colonies or b) broth a) Colony or microcolony size b) Cell number
in broth. May be detected by: turbidity, absorbance, conductivity. flow cytometry Coulter counter, indicator change and many other means
Figure 1 Scheme indicating some of the potential influences on the outcome of a culturability test. Notes: 1 = Non-replicating may include dormant forms such as spores; 2 = the patterns of response indicated by this phase are outlined in Fig. 2; 3 = these include, in particular, signalling molecules (pheromones, cytokines, etc.); 4 = although these processes may occur in the environment from which the sample was drawn, they are only relevant after sampling inasmuch as their stimulation by the test may lead to an unrepresentative result; 5 = number of cells is used for simplicity here. Increase in biomass sufficient for detection would also be acceptable.
A
lu
m
126
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Exposure to rpeclfic rtimuli
A Severe
Death Recovery
Mild
7 Differentiation
Figure 2 Scheme outlining the main patterns of response to environmental stimuli. Responses are determined by the strength of the stimulus and the genes comprising the stimulons activated by specific stimuli in the particular organisms tested.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The financial support of the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council, the Natural Environmental Research Council and the Wellcome Trust for work on non-culturable cells in the authors' laboratories is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES Aizenman, E., Engelberg-Kulka, H. and Glaser, G. (1996)An Escherichia coli chromosnma1 addiction module regulated by guanosine [corrected] 3',5'-bispyrophosphate: a model for programmed bacterial cell death [published erratum appears in Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 1996,93,9991]. Pmc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 93,6059-6063. Albertson, N.H. and Nystrom, T. (1994)Effects of starvation for exogenous carbon on functional messenger RNA stability and rate of peptide chain elongation in Escherichia coli. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 117,181-188. Aldsworth, T.G., Sharman, R.L., Dodd, C.E.R. and Stewart, G.(1998)A competitive microflora increases the resistance of Salrnonellu typhimuriurn to inimical processes: evidence for a suicide response. Appl. Environ. Micmbiol. 64,1323-1327. Allen, L.A., Pasley, S.M. and Pierce, M.S.F. (1952)Conditions affecting the growth of Bacterium coli on bile salts media. Enumeration of this organism in polluted waters. J. Gen. Micmbiol. 7,257-267. Al-Qudah, A.A., Mostratos, A. and Quesnel, L.B. (1983)A proposed life cycle for the Reiter treponeme. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 55, 417-428. Amann, R.I., Ludwig, W. and Schleifer, K.H. (1995)Phylogenetic identification and in situ detection of individual microbial cells without cultivation. Microbiol. Rev. 59,143-169. Amann, R., Snaidr, J., Wagner, M., Ludwig, W. and Schleifer, K.H. (1996)In situ visualization of high genetic diversity in a natural microbial community. J. Bacteriol. 178,
3496-3500. Aminhanjani, S., Meikle, A., Glover, L.A., Prosser, J.I. and Killham, K. (1993)Plasmid and chromosomally encoded luminescence marker systems for detection of Pseudornonasjluorescens in soil. Mol. Ecol. 2.47-54.
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
127
Andersen, J.B., Sternberg, C., Poulsen, L.K., Bjorn, S.P., Givskov, M. and Molin, S. (1998) New unstable variants of green fluorescent protein for studies of transient gene expression in bacteria. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 64,2240-2246. Arana, I., Muela, A., Iriberri, J., Egea, L. and Barcina, I. (1992) Role of hydrogen-peroxide in loss of culturability mediated by visible-light in Escherichia coli in a fresh-water ecosystem. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 58, 3903-3907. Arana, I., Pocino, M., Muela, A., Fernandez-Astorga, A. and Barcina, I. (1997) Detection and enumeration of viable but non-culturable transconjugants of Escherichia coli during the survival of recipient cells in river water. J. Appl. Microbiol. 83, 340-346. Barcina, I., Arana, I., Santorum, P., Iribem, J. and Egea, L. (1995) Direct viable count of Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria using ciprofloxacin as inhibitor of cellular division. J. Microbiol. Meth.22, 139-150. Barclay, R. and Ratledge, C. (1983) Iron-binding compounds of Mycobacterium avium, M. intracellulare, M . scrofulaceum, and mycobactin-dependent M . paratuberculosis and M. avium. J. Bacteriol. 153, 1138-1 146. Barer, M.R. (1997) Viable but non-culturable and dormant bacteria: time to resolve an oxymoron and a misnomer? [editorial]. J. Med. Micmbiol. 46,629-63 1. Barer, M.R., Gribbon, L.T., Harwood, C.R. and Nwoguh, C.E. (1993) The viable but nonculturable hypothesis and medical microbiology. Rev. Med. Micmbiol. 4, 183-191. Barer, M.R., Kaprelyants, AS., Weichart, D.H., Harwood, C.R. and Kell, D.B. (1998) Microbial stress and culturability: conceptual and operational domains. Microbiology. (UK) 144,2009-2010. Barrow, P.A., Lovell, M.A. and Barber, L.Z. (1996) Growth suppression in early stationary phase nutrient broth cultures of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli is genus specific and not regulated by sigma S. J. Bacteriol. 178,3072-3076. Bassler, B.L., Greenberg, E.P. and Stevens, A. M. (1997) Cross-species induction of luminescence in the quorum-sensing bacterium vibrio harveyi. J. Bacteriol. 179.40434045. Bercovier, H., Resnick, M., Kornitzer, D. and Levy, L. (1987) Rapid method for testing drug-susceptibility of Mycobacteria spp and Gram-positive bacteria using rhodamine123 and fluorescein diacetate. J. Microbiol. Meth. 7, 139-142. Bi, E. and Lutkenhaus, J. (1993) Cell division inhibitors SulA and MinCD prevent formation of the FtsZ ring. J. Bacteriol. 175, l 118-1 125. Binnerup, S.J.,Jensen, D.F., Thordal-Christensen, H. and Sorgensen, J. (1993) Detection of viable, but non-culturable Pseudomonas fluorescens DF57 in soil using a microcolony epifluorescence technique. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 12,97-105. Blattner, ER.,Plunkett, G.R., Bloch, C.A. et al. (1997) The complete genome sequence of Escherichia coli K-12. Science 277, 1453-1474. Bloomfield, S.F., Stewart, G.S., Dodd, C.E., Booth, I.R. and Power, E.G. (1998) The viable but non-culturable phenomenon explained? Microbiology 144, 1-3. Bogosian, G., Moms, P.J.L. and 0' Neil, J. P. (1998) A mixed culture recovery method indicates that enteric bacteria do not enter the viable but non-culturable state. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64, 17361742. Botsford, J.L. and Harman, J.G. (1992) Cyclic AMP in prokaryotes. Microbiol. Rev. 56, 100-122. Bottger, E.C., Teske, A., Kirschner, P., Bost, S., Chang, H.R., Beer, V. and Hirschel, B. (1992) Disseminated Mycobacterium genavense infection in patients with AIDS. Lancet 340,7680. Bovill, R.A., Shallcross, J. A. and Mackey, B. M. (1994) Comparison of the fluorescent redox dye 5 cyano 2.3 ditolyltetrazolium chloride with p iodonitrotetrazolium violet to detect metabolic activity in heat stressed Listeria monocytogenes cells. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 77. 353-358.
128
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Braux, AS., Minet, J., TamanaiShacoori, Z., Riou, G. and Cormier, M. (1997) Direct enumeration of injured Escherichia coli cells harvested onto membrane filters. J. Micmbiol. Meth. 31, 1-8. Brayton, P.R., Tamplin, M.L., Huq, A. and Colwell, R.R. (1987) Enumeration of Vibrio cholerae 0 1 in Bangladesh waters by fluorescent antibody direct viable count. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 53,2862-2865. Brewer, D.G., Martin, S.E. and Ordal, Z. J. (1977) Beneficial effects of catalase or pyruvate in a most-probable-number technique for the detection of Staphylococcusaureus. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 34,797-800. Brook, I. and Gober, A.E. (1995) Role of bacterial interference and beta-lactamase-producing bacteria in the failure of penicillin to eradicate group A streptococcal pharyngotonsillitis. Arch. Otolatyngol. Head Neck Surg. 121, 1405-1409. Button, D.K., Schut, F., Quang, P., Martin, R. andRobertson, B.R. (1993)Viability and isolation of marine bacteria by dilution culture: theory, procedures, and initial results. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 59, 881-891. Byrd, J. J., Xu,H.S. and Colwell, R.R. (1991)Viable but nonculturable bacteria in drinking water. Appl. Environ. Micmbiol. 57, 875-878. Calcott, P.H. and Calvert, T.J. (1981) Characterization of 3'5' cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase in Klebsiella aerogenes and its role in substrate accelerated death. J. Gen. Micmbiol. 122, 3 13-32 1. Calcott, P.H. and Postgate, J. R. (1972) On substrate-accelerated death in Klebsiella aerogenes. J. Gen. Micmbiol. 70, 115-122. Calcott, P.H., Montague, W. and Postgate, J. R. (1972) The levels of cyclic AMP during substrate accelerated death. J. Gen. Micmbiol. 73, 197-200. Christensen, B.B., Sternberg, C., Andersen, J. B., Eberl, L., Moller, S., Givskov, M. and Molin, S. (1998) Establishment of new genetic traits in a microbial biofilm community. Appl. Envimn. Micmbiol. 64,2247-2255. Clarke, R.G. and Pinder, A.C. (1998) Improved detection of bacteria by flow cytometry using a combination of antibody and viability markers. J. Appl. Microbiol. 84, 577-584. Clarke-Sturman A.J., Archibald A.R., Hancock I.C., Harwood C.R., Merad T., Hobot J.A. (1989) Cell wall assembly in Bacillus subtilis: partial conservation of polar wall material and the effect of growth conditions on the pattern of incorporation of new material at the polar caps J. Gen. Micmbiol. 135,657-665. Cole, S.T., Brosch, R., Parkhill, et al. (1998) Deciphering the biology of Mycobacterium tuberculosis from the complete genome sequence. Nature 393,537-544. Collins, L.A. and Franzblau, S.G. (1997) Microplate Alamar blue assay versus BACTEC 460 system for high-throughput screening of compounds against Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Mycobacteriumavium.Antimicmb.Agent. Chemother: 41, 1004-1 009. Collins, L.A., Torrero, M.N.and Franzblau, S.G. (1998) Green fluorescent protein reporter microplate assay for high-throughput screening of compounds against Mycobacterium tuberculosis.Antimicmb.Agent. Chemother.42,344-347. Colwell, R.R. and Huq, A. (1994) Vibrios in the environment: viable but non-culturable Vibrio cholerae. In: Vibrio cholerae and Cholera. (I.K. Wachsmuth, P.A. Blake and 0. Olsvik, eds), pp. 95-102. ASM Press, Washington, D.C. Colwell, R.R., Brayton, P., Hemngton, D., Tall, B., Huq, A. and Levine, M.M. (1996) Viable but non culturable Vibrio cholerae-01 revert to a cultivable state in the human intestine. World J. Micmbiol. Biotechnol. 12,28-3 1. Couturier, M., Bahassi, E.M. and Van Melderen. L. (1998) Bacterial death by DNA gyrase poisoning. Trends Micmbiol. 6,269-275. Coyle, M.B., Carlson, L.C., Wallis, C.K., Leonard, R.B., Raisys, V.A.. Kilburn, J.O.,
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
129
Samadpour, M. and Bottger, E.C. (1992) Laboratory aspects of Mycobacterium genavense, a proposed species isolated from AIDS patients. J. Clin. Microbiol. 30, 3206-3012. Davey, H.M. and Kell, D.B. (1996) Flow-cytometry and cell sorting of heterogeneous microbial populations - the importance of single-cell analyses. Microbiol. Rev. 60,641. Davies, D.G., Parsek, M.R., Pearson, J.P., Iglewski, B.H., Costerton, J.W. and Greenberg, E.P. (1998) The involvement of cell-to-cell signals in the development of a bacterial biofilm. Science 280,295-298. Dawes, E.A. (1976) Endogenous metabolism and the survival of starved prokaryotes. In: The Survival of Vegetative Microhes (T.R.G. Gray and J.R. Postgate, eds) pp. 19-54. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Decamp, O., Rajendran, N., Nakano, H. and Nair, G.B. (1997) Estimation of the viability of Vibrio cholerae 01 39 by assessing cell membrane integrity. Microbios 92, 83-89. Defais, M., Fauquet, P., Radman, M. and Errera, M. (1971) Ultraviolet reactivation and ultraviolet mutagenesis of lambda in different genetic systems. Virology 43,495-503. Delong, E.F., Wickham, G.S. and Pace, N.R. (1989) Phylogenetic stains - ribosomal RNAbased probes for the identification of single cells. Science 243, 1360-1363. Dhandayuthapani, S., Via, L.E., Thomas, C.A., Horowitz, P.M., Deretic, D. and Deretic, V. (1995) Green fluorescent protein as a marker for gene expression and cell biology of mycobacterial interactions with macrophages. Mol. Microbiol. 17,901-912. Diaper, J. P. and Edwards, C. (1994) The use of fluorogenic esters to detect viable bacteria by flowcytometry. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 77, 221-228. Dodd, C.E.R., Shaman, R.L., Bloomfield, S.F., Booth, I.R. and Stewart, G. (1997) Inimical processes: bacterial self-destruction and sub-lethal injury. Trends Food Sci. Technol. 8, 238-24 1. Drlica, K. and Zhao, X. L. (1997) DNA gyrase, topoisomerase IV, and the 4-quinolones. Microbiol. Mol. Biol. Rev. 61,377-384. Duffy, G. and Sheridan, J. J. (1998) Viability staining in a direct count rapid method for the determination of total viable counts on processed meats. J. Micmbiol. Meth. 31, 167-174. Dukan, S., Levi, Y. and Touati, D. (1997) Recovery of culturability of an HOCI-stressed population of Escherichia coli after incubation in phosphate buffer: resuscitation or regrowth? Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63,4204-4209. Dunphy, G., Miyamoto, C. and Meighen, E. (1997)A homoserine lactone autoinducer regulates virulence of an insect-pathogenic bacterium, Xenorhabdus nematophilus (Enterobacteriaceae). J. Bacteriol. 179, 5288-5291. Ekweozor, C.C., Nwoguh, C.E. and Barer, M.R. (1998)Transient increases in colony counts observed in declining populations of Campylobacter jejuni held at low temperature. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 158, 267-272. Elkest, S.E. and Marth, E.H. ( I 992) Freezing of Listeria monocytogenes and other microorganisms - a review. J. Food Protect. 55,639-648. Engstrand, L., Nguyen, A.M., Graham, D.Y. and el-Zaatari, F.A. (1992) Reverse transcription and polymerase chain reaction amplification of rRNA for detection of Helicobacter species. J. Clin. Microbiol. 30,2295-230 1. Felske, A., Rheims, H., Wolterink, A., Stackebrandt, E. and Akkermans, A.D. (1997) Ribosome analysis reveals prominent activity of an uncultured member of the class Actinobacteria in grassland soils. Microbiology (UK) 143, 2983-2989. Ferguson, Y., Glover, L.A., McGillivray, D.M. and Prosser, J.I. (1995) Survival and activity of lux-marked Aeromonas salmonicida in seawater. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61, 3494-3498. Flowers, R.S., Martin, S.E., Brewer, D.G. and Ordal, Z.J. (1977) Catalase and enumeration of stressed Staphylococcus aureus cells. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 33, 1 1 12-1 117.
130
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
Fredricks, D.N. and Relman, D.A. (1997) Cultivation of Whipple bacillus: the irony and the ecstasy. Lancet 350, 1262-1 263. Fuqua, C., Winans, S.C. and Greenberg, E.P. (1996) Census and consensus in bacterial ecosystems: the LuxR-Lux1 family of quorum-sensing transcriptional regulators. Annu Rev. Microbiol. 50,727-5 1 . Cant, V.A., Warnes, G., Phillips, I. and Savidge, G.F. (1993) The application of flow cytometry to the study of bacterial responses to antibiotics. J. Med. Microbiol. 39, 147-154. Gerdes, K., Gultyaev, A.P., Franch, T., Pedersen, K. and Mikkelsen, N.D. (1997) Antisense RNA-regulated programmed cell death. Annu. Rev. Genet. 31, 1-31. Giovannoni, S.J., Delong, E.F., Olsen, G.J. and Pace, N.R. (1988) Phylogenetic group-specific oligodeoxynucleotide probes for identification of single microbial-cells. J. Bacteriol. 170,720-726. Giovannoni, S.J., Britschgi, T.B., Moyer, C.L. and Field, K.G. (1990) Genetic diversity in Sargasso Sea bacterioplankton. Nature 34560-63. Gray, K.M. ( 1 997) Intercellular communication and group behavior in bacteria. Trends. Microbiol. 5, 184-188. Hackney, C.R., Ray, B. and Speck, M.L. (1979) Repair detection procedure for enumeration of fecal coliforms and enterococci from seafoods and marine environments. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 37,947-953. Hansen, G.A. ( 1 880) Bacillus leprae. VirchowsArchiv 79, 3 2 4 2 . Hazeleger, W.C., Janse, J.D., Koenraad, P., Beumer, R.R., Rombouts, EM. and Abee, T. ( I 995) Temperature-dependent membrane fatty-acid and cell physiology changes in coccoid forms of Campylobacterjejuni. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61.27 13-27 19. Hengge-Aronis, R. (1996) Back to log phase sigma(s) as a global regulator in the osmotic control of gene expression in Escherichia coli. Mol. Microbiol. 21, 887-893. Hobson, N.S., Tothill, I. and Turner, A.P.F. (1996) Microbial detection. Biosensors Bioelectron. 11,455-477. Hoff, K.A. (1988) Rapid and simple method for double staining of bacteria with 4’,6 diamidino 2 phenylindole and fluorescein isothiocyanate labeled antibodies. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54,2949-2952. Hojberg, O., Binnerup, S.J. and Sorensen, J. (1997) Growth of silicone-immobilized bacteria on polycarbonate membrane filters, a technique to study microcolony formation under anaerobic conditions. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63, 2920-2924. Humphrey, T.J. (1986) Techniques for the optimum recovery of cold injured Carnpylohacter jejuni from milk or water. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 61, 125-132. Huq, A. and Colwell, R.R. (1996) A microbiological paradox viable but nonculturable bacteria with special reference to Vibrio cholerue. J. Food Protect. 59, 96-101. Hussong, D., Colwell, R.R., Obrien, M., Weiss, E., Pearson, A.D., Weiner, R.M. and Burge, W. D. (1987) Viable Legionella pneumophila not detectable by culture on agar media. Bio-Technology. 5,947-950. Ibrahim, P., Whiteley, A S . and Barer, M.R. (1997) SYTO16 labelling and flow cytometry of Mycobacterium aviurn. Left. Appl. Microbiol. 2 5 , 4 3 7 4 1 . Ikenaka, K., Fujino, I., Morita, N., Iwasaki, Y., Miura, M., Kagawa, T., Nakahira, K. and Mikoshiba, K. (1 990) Reliable transient promoter assay using fluorescein-di-beta+ galactopyranoside substrate. DNA Cell Biol. 9,279-286. Itaya, M. (1995) An estimation of minimal genome size required for life. FEBS Lett. 362, 257-60. Jacobs, W.R., Barletta, R.G., Udani, R.. Chan, J., Kalkut, G., Sosne, G., Kieser, T., Sarkis, G.J., Hatfull, G.F. and Bloom, B.R. (1993) Rapid assessment of drug susceptibilities of Mycobucteriurn tuberculosis by means of luciferase reporter phages. Science 260, 819-822.
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
131
Jacobsen, C.N., Rasmussen, J. and Jakobsen, M. (1997) Viability staining and flow cytometric detection of Listeria monocytogenes. J. Microbiol. Meth. 28, 35-43. James, G.A., Korber, D.R., Caldwell, D.E. and Costerton, J. W. (1995) Digital imageanalysis of growth and starvation responses of a surface-colonizing Acinefobacter sp. J. Bacteriol. 177, 907-915. Jensen, R.B. and Gerdes, K. (1995) Programmed cell-death in bacteria - proteic plasmid stabilization systems. Mol. Microbiol. 17, 205-210. Jepras, R.I., Carter, J., Pearson, S.C., Paul, F.E. and Wilkinson, M.J. (1995) Development of a robust flow cytometric assay for determining numbers of viable bacteria. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61, 2696-2701. Jones, D.M., Sutcliffe, E.M. and Curry, A. (1991) Recovery of viable but non-culturable Campylobacter jejuni. J. Gen. Microbiol. 137, 2477-2482. Joux, F., Lebaron, P. and Troussellier, M. (1997) Succession of cellular states in a Salmonella typhimurium population during starvation in artificial seawater microcosms. FEMS Micmbiol. Ecol. 22,65-76. Kaneshiro, E.S., Wyder, M.A., Wu, Y. P. and Cushion, M.T. ( 1 993) Reliability of calcein acetoxy methyl-ester and ethidium homodimer or propidium iodide for viability assessment of microbes. J. Microbiol. Meth. 17, 1-16. Kaprelyants, A S . and Kell, D.B. (1992) Rapid assessment of bacterial viability and vitality by rhodamine 123 and flow cytometry. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 72,410--122. Kaprelyants, A S . and Kell, D.B. (1993) Dormancy in stationary-phase cultures of Micrococcus luteus - flow cytometric analysis of starvation and resuscitation. Appl. Environ. Microhid. 59, 3 187-3 196. Kaprelyants, A.S. and Kell, D.B. (1996) Do bacteria need to communicate with each other for growth. Trends. Microbiol. 4, 237-242. Kaprelyants, A.S., Mukamolova, G.V. and Kell, D.B. (1994) Estimation of dormant Micrococcus luteus cells by penicillin lysis and by resuscitation in cell free spent culture medium at high dilution. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 115, 347-352. Kaprelyants, A.S., Mukamolova, G.V., Davey, H.M. and Kell, D.B. (1996) Quantitative analysis of the physiological heterogeneity within starved cultures of Micrococcus luteus by flow cytometry and cell sorting. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 62, 13 I 1-1 3 16. Kell, D.B., Kaprelyants, A.S., Weichart, D., Harwood, C.R. and Barer, M.R. (1998) Viability and activity in readily culturable bacteria: a review and discussion of the practical issues. Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek. 73, 169-187. Kepner, R.L. and Pratt, J. R. (1994) Use of fluorochromes for direct enumeration of total bacteria in environmental samples. Past and present. Microbiol. Rev. 58, 603415. Khan, M.A., Potter, C.W. and Shanard, R.M. (1996) A reverse transcriptase-PCR based assay for in-vitro antibiotic susceptibility testing of Chlamydia pneumoniae. J. Antimicrob. Chernother. 37,677-685. Kjelleberg, S . , Albertson, N., Flardh, K., et al. (1993) How do non differentiating bacteria adapt to starvation? Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 63, 333-34 1. Kleerebezem, M., Quadri, L.E., Kuipers, 0. P. and de Vos, W. M. (1997) Quorum sensing by peptide pheromones and two-component signal-transduction systems in Gram-positive bacteria. Mol. Microbiol. 24, 895-904. Kogure, K., Simidu, U. and Taga, N. (1979) A tentative direct microscopic method for counting living marine bacteria. Can. J. Microbiol. 25,415420. Kolter, R. and Losick, R. (1998) One for all and all for one [comment]. Science 280, 226-227. Kolter, R., Siegele, D.A. and Tormo, A. (1993) The stationary phase of the bacterial life cycle. Annu. Rev. Microhiol. 47, 855-74. Kremer, L., Baulard, A., Estaquier, J., Poulaingodefroy, 0. and Locht, C. (1995) Green
132
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
fluorescent protein as a new expression marker in mycobacteria. Mol. Microbiol. 17, 9 13-922. Kunst, F., Ogasawara, N., Moszer, I., et al. (1997) The complete genome sequence of the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis. Nature 390, 249-256. Lanoil, B.D. and Giovannoni, S.J. (1997) Identification of bacterial cells by chromosomal painting. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63, 1 1 18-1 123. Lebaron, P., Parthuisot, N. and Catala, P. (1998) Comparison of blue nucleic acid dyes for flow cytometric enumeration of bacteria in aquatic systems. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64, 1725-1730. LeChevallier,M.W., Singh, A., Schiemann, D.A. and McFeters, G.A. (1985) Changes in virulence of waterborne enteropathogens with chlorine injury. Appl. Environ. Mirmbiol. 50, 412-419. Lee, S.H., Malone, C. and Kemp, P.F. (1993) Use of multiple 16s ribosomal-RNA-targeted fluorescent-probes to increase signal strength and measure cellular RNA from natural planktonic bacteria. Ma,: Ecol. Pros,: Se,: 101, 193-201. Licht, T.R., Tolker-Nielsen,T., Holmstrom, K., Krogfeldt, K. A. and Molin, S. (1998) Inhibition of Escherichia coli precursor-16s rRNA procession by mouse intestinal contents. Eighth International Symposium on Microbial Ecology (ISME-8),Halifax, Canada (in press). Linder, K. and Oliver, J.D. (1989) Membrane fatty acid and virulence changes in the viable but non-culturable state of Vibrio vulnificus. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55, 2837-2842. Loessner, M.J., Rees, C.E.D., Stewart, G.and Scherer, S. (1996) Construction of luciferase reporter bacteriophage-A5 1 1-luxab for rapid and sensitive detection of viable listeria cells. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 62, 1133-1 140. Lopezamoros, R., Mason, D.J. and Lloyd, D. (1995) Use of 2 oxonols and a fluorescent tetrazolium dye to monitor starvation of Escherichia coli in seawater by flow-cytometry. J. Mirrobiol. Meth. 22, 165-176. Ma, M. and Eaton, J.W. (1992) Multicellular oxidant defense in unicellular organisms. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 89, 7924-7928. Mackey, B.M. and Seymour, D.A. (1987)The effect of catalase on recovery of heat-injured DNA-repair mutants of Escherichia coli. J. Gen. Microbiol. 133, 1601-1 610. Madigan, M.T., Martinko, J.M. and Parker, J. (1997) Brock Biology of Microorganisms. Prentice-Hall. Upper Saddle River N. Manz, W., Amann, R., Szewzyk, R., Szewzyk, U., Stenstrom, T.A., Hutzler, P. and Schleifer, K.H. (1995) In situ identification of Legionellaceae using 16s ribosomal RNA targeted oligonucleotide probes and confocal laser scanning microscopy. Microbio1.-UK 141, 29-39. Marie, D., Vaulot, D. and Partensky, F. (1996) Application of the novel nucleic acid dyes YOYO I , YO PRO 1, and PicoGreen for flow cytometric analysis of marine prokaryotes. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 62, 1649-1655. Marouga, R. and Kjelleberg, S. (1996) Synthesis of immediate upshift (Iup) proteins during recovery of marine Vibrio sp. strain S14 subjected to long term carbon starvation. J. Bacteriol. 178, 8 17-822. Martin, S.E., Flowers, R.S. and Ordal, Z.J. (1976) Catalase: its effect on microbial enumeration. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 32,73 1-734. McFeters, G.A., Yu,F.P.P., Pyle, B.H. and Stewart, P.S. (1995) Physiological assessment of bacteria using fluorochromes. J. Microbiol. Meth. 21, 1-1 3. McGovern, V.P. and Oliver, J. D. (1995) Induction of cold responsive proteins in Vibrio vulnificus. J. Bacteriol. 177,4131-4133. Mignon-Godefroy, K., Guillet, J. G. and Butor, C. (1997) Solid phase cytometry for detection of rare events. Cytometry 27, 336-344. Molenaar, D., Abee, T. and Konings, W.N. (1991) Continuous measurement of the
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
133
cytoplasmic pH in Lactococcus lactis with a fluorescent pH indicator. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 1115,75-83. Moller, S., Stemberg, C., Andersen, J.B., Christensen, B.B., Ramos, J. L., Givskov, M. and Molin, S. (1998)In situ gene expression in mixed-culture biofilms: evidence of metabolic interactions between community members. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64,
721-732. Mor, N., Resnick, M., Silbaq, F., Bercovier, H. and Levy, L. (1988)Reduction of tellurite and deesterification of fluorescein diacetate are not well correlated with the viability of mycobacteria. Ann. Inst. Pasteur Microbiol. 139,279-288. Mossel, D.A. and Ratto, M.A. (1970)Rapid detection of sublethally impaired cells of Enterobacteriaceae in dried foods. Appl. Microbiol. 20,273-275. Mossel, D.A.A., Veldman, A. and Eelderink, I. (1980a)Comparison of the effects of liquidmedium repair and the incorporation of catalase in Macconkey type media on the recovery of Enterobacteriaceae sublethally stressed by freezing. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 49,
405419. Mossel, D.A.A., Wijers, B. and Bouwerhertzberger, S. (1980b)The enumeration and identification of stressed Escherichia coli in foods using solid medium repair and Eijkman thermotrophic criteria. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 49,R17-RI 8. Mukamolova, G.V., Kaprelyants, A.S.,Young, D.I.,Young, M. and Kell, D.B. (1998)A bacterial cytokine. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 95,8916-892 1. Neef, A,, Zaglauer, A., Meier, H., Amann, R., Lemmer, H. and Schleifer, K.H. (1996) Population analysis in a denitrifying sand filter: conventional and in situ identification of Paracoccus spp. in methanol-fed biofilms. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 62,43294339. Nilsson, L., Oliver, J. D. and Kjelleberg, S. (1991)Resuscitation of Vibrio vulnificus from the viable but nonculturable state. J. Bacteriol. 173,5054-5059. Nwoguh, C.E., Harwood, C.R. and Barer, M.R. (1995)Detection of induced beta-galactosidase activity in individual non-culturable cells of pathogenic bacteria by quantitative cytological assay. Mol. Microbiol. 17,545-554. Nystrom, T. (1998)To be or not to be: the ultimate decision of the growth-arrested bacterial cell. FEMS Microbiol. Rev.21,283-290. Oliver, J. D. (1993)Formation of viable but non-culturable cells. In: Starvation in Bacteria (S. Kjelleberg, ed.), pp. 239-272. Plenum, New York. Oliver, I. D. (1995)The viable but non-culturable state in the human pathogen Vibrio vulnijicus. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 133,203-208. Oliver, J.D. and Bockian, R. (1995)In vivo resuscitation, and virulence towards mice, of viable but non-culturable cells of Vibrio vulnijicus. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61,
2620-2623. Oliver, J.D., Hite, F., McDougald, D., Andon, N.L. and Simpson, L.M. (1995)Entry into, and resuscitation from, the viable but nonculturable state by Vibrio vuln$cus in an estuarine environment. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61,2624-2630. Pace, N.R. (1997)A molecular view of microbial diversity and the biosphere. Science 276,
734-740. Panoff, J.M., Thammavongs, B., Gueguen, M. and Boutibonnes, P. (1998)Cold stress responses in mesophilic bacteria. Cryobiology 36.75-83. Pawley, J.B. (1995)Handbook of Biological Confocal Microscopy. Plenum Press, New York. Pearson, A.D., Greenwood, M., Healing, T.D., Rollins, D., Shahamat, M., Donaldson, J. and Colwell, R.R. (1993)Colonization of broiler chickens by waterborne Campylobacter jejuni. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 59,987-996. Pearson, J.P., Pesci, E.C. and Iglewski, B.H. (1997)Roles of Pseudomonas aeruginosa las and rhl quorum-sensing systems in control of elastase and rhamnolipid biosynthesis genes. J. Bacteriol. 179,57565767.
134
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R . HARWOOD
Pecota, D.C., Kim, C.S., Wu, K., Gerdes, K. and Wood, T.K. (1997)Combining the hok/sok, parDE, and pnd postsegregational killer loci to enhance plasmid stability. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63, 1917-1924. Plovins, A., Alvarez, A.M., Ibanez, M., Molina, M. and Nombela, C. (1994) Use of fluorescein di beta D galactopyranoside (Fdg) and C 12 Fdg as substrates for beta galactosidase detection by flow cytometry in animal, bacterial, and yeast cells. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 60,4638-4641. Postgate, J. (1967) Viability measurements and the survival of microbes under minimum stress. In: Advances in Microbial Physiology, Vol. 1 (A.H. Rose and J. Wilkinson, eds), pp. 1-21 Academic Press, London. Postgate, J. R. (1969) Viable counts and viability. Meth. Microbiol. 1, 61 1-628. Postgate. J. R. (1976) Death in microbes and macrobes. In: In The Survival of Vegetutive Microbes (T.R.G. Gray and J.R. Postgate, eds), pp. 1-19. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Postgate, J. R. and Hunter, J. R. (1963) Acceleration of bacterial death by growth substrates. Nature 198,273-280. Postgate, J. R. and Hunter, J. R. (1964) Accelerated death of Aerohacter aerogenes starved in the presence of growth-limiting substrates. J. Cen. Microbiol. 34,459-473. Poulsen, L.K., Licht, T.R., Rang, C., Krogfelt, K.A. and Molin, S. (1995) Physiologicalstate of Escherichia coli Bj4 growing in the large-intestines of streptomycin-treated mice. J. Bacteriol. 177, 5840-5845. Poulsen, L.K., Dalton, H.M., Angles, M.L., Marshall, K.C., Molin, S. and Goodman, A.E. ( 1 997) Simultaneous determination of gene expression and bacterial identity in single cells in defined mixtures of pure cultures. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63, 3698-3702. Quillardet, P. and Hofnung, M. (1993) The SOS chromotest - a review. Mutat. Res. 297, 235-279. Ray, B., Janssen, D.W. and Busta, F.F. (1972) Characterization of the repair of injury induced by freezing Salmonella anaturn. Appl. Microbiol. 23, 803-809. Ray, B., Speck, M.L. and Dobrogosz, W.J. (1976) Cell wall lipopolysaccharide damage in Escherichia coli due to freezing. Cryobiology 13, 15340. Rayner, M.G., Zhang, Y., Gorry, M.C., Chen, Y., Post, J.C. and Ehrlich, G.D. (1998) Evidence of bacterial metabolic activity in culture-negative otitis media with effusion. J. Am. Med. Ass. 279,296-299. Relman, D.A., Schmidt, T.M., MacDermott, R.P. and Falkow, S. (1992) Identification of the uncultured bacillus of Whipple’s disease. N. Engl. J. Med. 327,293-301. Rigsbee, W., Sirnpson, L.M. and Oliver, J.D. (1997) Detection of the viable but non-culturable state in Escherichia coli 0157;H7. J. Food Safety 16,255-262. Rodrigues, U.M. and Kroll, R.G. (1988) Rapid selective enumeration of bacteria in foods using a microcolony epifluorescence microscopy technique. J. Appl. Bacteriol. 64, 65-78. Rodriguez, G.G., Phipps, D., Ishiguro, K. and Ridgway, H.F. (1992) Use of a fluorescent redox probe for direct visualization of actively respiring bacteria. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 58, 1801-1808. Rollins, D.M. and Colwell, R.R. (1986) Viable but non-culturable stage of Campylobacter jejuni and its role in survival in the natural aquatic environment. Appl. Environ. Micmbiol. 52, 531-538. Roszak, D.B. and Colwell, R.R. (1987a) Metabolic activity of bacterial cells enumerated by direct viable count. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 53, 2889-2893. Roszak, D.B. and Colwell, R.R. (1987b) Survival strategies of bacteria in the natural environment. Microbiol. Rev. 51,365-379.
BACTERIAL VIABILITY AND CULTURABILITY
135
Roszak, D.B., Grimes, D.J. and Colwell, R.R. (1984) Viable but nonrecoverable stage of Salmonella enteritidis in aquatic systems. Can. J. Microbiol. 30, 334-338. Roth, B.L., Poot, M., Yue, S.T. and Millard, P.J. (1997) Bacterial viability and antibiotic susceptibility testing with SYTOX Green nucleic acid stain. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63, 242 1-243 1. Sarkis, G.J., Jacobs, W.R. and Hatfull, G.F. (1995) L5 luciferase reporter mycobacteriophages a sensitive tool for the detection and assay of live mycobacteria. Mol. Microbiol. 15,1055-1067. Schoedon, G., Goldenberger, D., Forrer, R., Gunz, A., Dutly, F., Hochli, M., Altwegg, M. and Schaffner, A. (1997) Deactivation of macrophages with interleukin-4 is the key to the isolation of Tmpheryma whippelii. J. Infect. Dis. 176,672-7. Schut, F., Devries, E.J., Gottschal, J.C., Robertson, B.R., Harder, W., Prins, R.A. and Button, D.K. (1993) Isolation of typical marine bacteria by dilution culture growth, maintenance, and characteristics of isolates under laboratory conditions. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 59,2 150-2 160. Schut, F., Gottschal, J.C. and Prins, R.A. (1997) Isolation and characterisation of the marine ultramicrobacterium Sphingomonas sp. strain RB2256. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 20, 363-369. Shaw, P. (1994) Deconvolution in 3-D optical microscopy. Histochem. J. 26,687-694. Sheridan, G.E., Masters, C.I., Shallcross, J.A. and MacKey, B.M. (1998) Detection of mRNA by reverse transcription-PCR as an indicator of viability in Escherichia coli cells. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64, 1313-1318. Shotton, D. (1993) An introduction to the electronic acquisition of light microscope images. In: Electronic Light Microscopy (D. Shotton, ed.), pp. 1-38. Wiley-Liss, New York. Singh, A., Yeager, R. and McFeters, G.A. (1986) Assessment of in vivo revival, growth, and pathogenicity of Escherichia coli strains after copper- and chlorine-induced injury. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 52, 832-837. Slavik, J. ( 1998) Microspectrofluorimetry: measuring ion concentrations in living microbes. In: Digital Image Analysis of Microbes (M.H.F. Wilkinson and F. Schut, eds), pp. 309-3242. John Wiley, New York. Speck, M.L., Ray, B. and Read, R.B. Jr. (1975) Repair and enumeration of injured coliforrns by a plating procedure. Appl. Microbiol. 29, 549-550. Srinivasan, S., Ostling, J., Charlton, T., de Nys, R., Takayama, K. and Kjelleberg, S. (1998) Extracellular signal molecule(s) involved in the carbon starvation response of marine Vibrio sp. strain S14. J. Bacteriol. 180,201-209. Staley, J. T. and Konopka, A. (1985) Measurement of in situ activities of nonphotosynthetic microorganisms in aquatic and terrestrial habitats. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 39, 321-46. Steinert, M., Emody, L., Amann, R. and Hacker, J. (1997) Resuscitation of viable but nonculturable Legionella pneumophila Philadelphia JR32 by Acanthamoeba castellanii. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63,2047-2053. Stewart, G., Jassim, S.A.A., Denyer, S.P., Newby, P., Linley, K. and Dhir, V.K. (1998) The specific and sensitive detection of bacterial pathogens within 4 h using bacteriophage amplification. J. Appl. Micmbiol. 84,777-783. Swaminathan, B. and Feng, P. (1994) Rapid detection of food-borne pathogenic bacteria. Annu. Rev. Micmbiol. 48,401-426. Swift, S., Stewart, G. and Williams, P. (1996a) The inner workings of a quorum sensing signal generator. Trends. Microbiol. 4,463465. Swift, S., Throup, J. P., Williams, P., Salmond, G.P.C. and Stewart, G. (1996b) Quorum sensing - a population-density component in the determination of bacterial phenotype. Trends. Biochem. Sci. 21,214-219. Tolker-Nielsen, T., Holmstrom, K., Boe, L. and Molin, S. (1998) Non-genetic population
136
MICHAEL R. BARER AND COLIN R. HARWOOD
heterogeneity studied by in situ polymerase chain reaction. Mol. Microbiol. 27, 1099-1 105. VanBogelen, R.A., Abshire, K.Z., Moldover, B., Olson, E.R. and Neidhardt, F.C. (1997) Escherichia coli proteome analysis using the gene-protein database. Electrophoresis 18, 1243-5 1. Virta, M., Lineri, S., Kankaanpaa, P., Karp. M., Peltonen. K., Nuutila, J. and Lilius, E.M. (1998) Determination of complement-mediated killing of bacteria by viability staining and bioluminescence. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64.5 15-5 19. Votyakova, T.V., Kaprelyants, A.S. and Kell, D.B. (1994) Influence of viable cells on the resuscitation of dormant cells in Micrococcus luteus cultures held in an extended stationary phase - the population effect. Appl. Envimn. Microbiol. 60.32843291. Wai, S.N., Moriya, T., Kondo, K., Misumi, H. and Amako, K. (1996) Resuscitation of Vibrio cholerae 0 1 strain tsi4 from a viable but non-culturable state by heat shock. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 136, 187-191. Walker, G.C. (1996) The SOS response of Escherichia coli. In: Escherichia coli and Salmonella, Vol. 1. (F.C. Neidhardt, ed.), pp. 1400-1416. ASM Press, Washington, D.C. Warner, J.M. and Oliver, J.D. (1998) Randomly amplified polymorphic DNA analysis of starved and viable but non-culturable Vibrio vulnificus cells. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64,3025-3028. Wayne, L.G. and Sramek, H.A. (1992)Agents of newly recognized or infrequently encountered mycobacterial diseases. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 5, 1-25. Wayne, L.G., Brenner, D.J., Colwell, R.R., et al. (1987) Report of the Ad HOCCommittee on Reconciliation of Approaches to Bacterial Systematics. Int. J. System. Bacteriol. 37, 463-464. Weichart, D. and Kjelleberg, S. (1996) Stress resistance and recovery potential of culturable and viable but non-culturable cells of Vibrio vuln@cus. Microbiology 142 (UK), 845-53. Weichart, D., Oliver, J.D. an{ Kjelleberg, S. (1992) Low temperature induced non culturability and killing of Vibrio vuln$cus. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 79,205-210. Weichart, D., McDougald, D., Jacobs, D. and Kjelleberg, S. (1997). In situ analysis of nucleic acids in cold-induced non-culturable Vibrio vuln@cus. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63.27542758. Whiteley, AS., O’Donnell, A.G., Macnaughton, S.J. and Barer, M.R. (1996) Cytochemical colocalization and quantitation of phenotypic and genotypic characteristics in individual bacterial cells. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 62, 1873-1879. Whiteley, AS., Grewal, Hunt, A. and Barer, M.R. (1998) Determining biochemical and physiological phenotypes of bacteria by cytological assay. In: Digital Image Analysis of Microbes (M.H.F. Wilkinson and F. Schut, eds), pp. 281-308. John Wiley, New York. Whitesides, M.D. and Oliver, J. D. (1997) Resuscitation of Vibrio vulntjicus from the viable but non-culturable state. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63, 1002-1005. Williams, P., Bainton, N.J., Swift, S., Chhabra, S.R., Winson, M.K., Stewart, G., Salmond, G.P.C. and Bycroft, B.W. (1992).Small molecule-mediated density-dependent control of gene-expression in prokaryotes - bioluminescence and the biosynthesis of carbapenem antibiotics. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 100, 161-167. Wilson, S.M., al-Suwaidi, Z., McNerney, R., Porter, J. and Drobniewski, F. (1997) Evaluation of a new rapid bacteriophage-based method for the drug susceptibility testing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Nat. Med. 3,465-468. Woese, C.R. (1987) Bacterial evolution. Microb. Rev. 51,221-271. Xu,H.S., Roberts, N., Singleton, EL., Attwell, R.W., Grimes, D.J. and Colwell, R.R. (1982) Survival and viability of nonculturable Escherichia coli and Vibrio cholerue in the estuarine and marine environment. Microbial Ecol. 8.313-323.
THE BACTERIAL FLAGELLAR MOTOR
137
Yamazaki, K., Teduka, H., Inoue, N. and Shinano, H. (1996) Specific primers for detection of Alicyclobacillus acidoterrestris by RT-PCR. Lett. Appl. Microbiol. 23, 350-354. Zambrano, M.M. and Kolter, R. (1993) Escherichia coli mutants lacking NADH dehydrogenase I have a competitive disadvantage in stationary phase. J. Bacteriol. 175, 5642-5641.
Zhang-Barber, L., Turner, A.K., Martin, G., Frankel, G., Dougan, G. and Barrow, P.A. (1997) Influence of genes encoding proton-translocatingenzymes on suppression of Salmonella typhimurium growth and colonization. J. Bacteriol. 179.7 186-7 190.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Histidine Protein Kinase Superfamily Thorsten W. Grebe and Jeffry B. Stock Department of Molecular Biology, Princeton University, NJ 08544, USA
ABSTRACT
Signal transduction in microorganisms and plants is often mediated by His-Asp phosphorelay systems. Two conserved families of proteins are centrally involved: histidine protein kinases and phospho-aspartyl response regulators. The kinases generally function in association with sensory elements that regulate their activities in response to environmental signals. A sequence analysis with 348 histidine kinase domains reveals that this family consists of distinct subgroups. A comparative sequence analysis with 298 available receiver domain sequences of cognate response regulators demonstrates a significant correlation between kinase and regulator subfamilies. These findings suggest that different subclasses of His-Asp phosphorelay systems have evolved independently of one another. 1. Introduction ....................................................... 1.1. Protein phosphorylation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Histidine protein kinases ......................................... 1.3. Systemdesign . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. Homologyboxes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Histidine protein kinase subfamilies ................................... 2.1. Subfamilies of histidine kinases ................................... 3. Cognate receiver domains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Domain shuffling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
139 139 140 182 195 197 199 206 211 214 214
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1. Protein Phosphorylation in Bacteria
The discovery of protein phosphorylation dates back to the middle of the last century, when milk and egg proteins were found to contain covalently linked ADVANCES IN MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY VOL 41
ISBN 0-12-027741-7
Copyright 0 1999 Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
140
THORSTEN W. GREBE AND JEFFRY 6.STOCK
inorganic phosphate. Phosphoserine was detected in egg yolk protein in 1932 (Lipmann and Levene, 1932) and phosphothreonine was identified in casein over two decades later, while phosphotyrosine as a mode of protein modification was unknown until 1979 (Eckhart er al., 1979). The first phosphorylation on histidine was reported by Boyer et al. (1962) who discovered this type of modification in mitochondria1 succinyl-CoA synthase (succinyl-thiokinase). Krebs and Fischer were the first to recognize the importance of protein phosphorylation in the regulation of enzymatic activities (Krebs and Fischer, 1956). Many additional examples of regulation through phosphorylation were subsequently discovered in eukaryotes, but a striking lack of protein phosphorylation in prokaryotes led to the view that this type of modification was exclusively eukaryotic. A first indication to the contrary was reported by Kuo and Greengard (1969) who claimed to have isolated a cyclic AMP-dependent kinase from Escherichiu coli that could transfer phosphate from ATP to histones. However, this observation has never been reproduced. The issue of whether there are ATP-dependent kinases in bacteria was settled only when Wang and Koshland reported the isolation of the first regulatory serine- and threonine-phosphoryl groups from an acidic hydrolysate of bacterial proteins in 1978. At this time, most routine purification procedures for proteins called for acidic conditions at one point or another, e.g. acidic media or trichloroacetic acid TCA precipitations. Serine-, threonine- and tyrosine phosphates survive this kind of treatment. The phosphoramidate bond of phosphohistidines, however, is very prone to acid hydrolysis. Phosphohistidinesare stable to alkali and survive 13h at 100°C in 1 . 5 potassium ~ hydroxide (Buss & Stull, 1983), but a standard TCA precipitation can cause significant hydrolysis. In addition, phosphohistidines have a higher free energy than ATP and tend to function substoichiometricallyas phosphotransfer intermediates rather than as regulatory modifications per se. For these reasons, the discovery of histidine protein kinases in bacteria was delayed until these important regulatory components were purified and studied in vitro (Hess et al., 1988; Ninfa et al., 1988a,b). Even the very rare event of bacterial kinase phosphorylation on tyrosines was discovered before the far more common modification on histidines (Vallejos et al., 1985). 1.2. Histidine Protein Kinases
The first histidine protein kinases to be sequenced were EnvZ (Mizuno et ul., 1982), PhoR (Tommassen et al., 1982), CpxA (Albin et al., 1986), NtrB (Nixon et al., 1986), DctB (Ronson et al., 1987a), VirA (Leroux et al., 1987) and CheA (Stock et al., 1988). The role of these proteins in signal transduction
THE HISTIDINE PROTEIN KINASE SUPERFAMILY
141
was deduced from an analysis of the evolutionary relationship between the genes involved in chemotaxis and osmosensing in E. coli and Salmonella (Stock et al., 1985). The first indication that a protein kinase activity was involved came from studies of nitrogen regulation in E. coli (Ninfa and Magasanik, 1986). Ninfa et al. proposed the first model for two-component signal transduction: NtrB functions as a kinase/phosphatase to control the amount of cellular NtrC-phosphate in response to cytoplasmic signals of nitrogen availability. NtrC acts in turn to regulate transcription at nitrogen-regulated promoters. The chemotaxis system of E. coli was second to provide support for the kinase signal transduction mechanism. In this system it was demonstrated that the kinase CheA autophosphorylates and then passes its phosphoryl group to a cognate response regulator protein, CheY (Hess et al., 1988a,b;Wylie et al., 1988). Several-hundred homologous systems have been found since and many have been shown to employ essentially the same biochemical mechanism as that originally elucidated in the Ntr and Che systems. The initial conviction that histidine protein kinases are restricted to prokaryotic organisms has had to be revised (Chang et al., 1993; Ota and Varshavsky, 1993; Chang and Meyerowitz, 1994; Swanson and Simon, 1994). To date, 5% of all histidine protein kinase sequences are found in fungi, amoebae and plants. In addition, mitochondria1 branched-chain alpha-ketoacid dehydrogenase kinases which phosphorylate at serine residues show an intriguing sequence homology with histidine kinases. The H-, N-, D- and G-boxes are conserved, but the phosphorylated target protein does not appear to contain a receiver domain (Popov et al., 1992, 1997; Chang and Meyerowitz, 1994; Harris et al., 1995, 1997). Mitochondria1pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase also shares homologous N-, Dand G-boxes with canonical histidine protein kinases, but the target phosphorylation site is a serine (Popov et al., 1993; Thelen et al., 1998).The existence of both these proteins, which are encoded as nuclear genes, raises the possibility that histidine protein kinases were passed from bacteria through mitochondria to vertebrate species. A similar situation may pertain to chloroplasts and plant evolution. A particular case are the phytochromes. Phytochromes are photosensory molecules that show significant homology to histidine protein kinases (Schneider-Poetsch et al., 1991). Only a few members of the phytochrome superfamily have canonical H-boxes, e.g. PhyA-osa (Kay et al., 1989) and PhyC-ath (Cowl et al., 1994). (For a list of three-letter species identifiers, see Table 1.) Phytochromes channel photosensory information into signallingpathways that use G-proteins rather than response regulators (Neuhaus et al., 1993). The cyanobacterial phytochrome Cphl-ssp is an exception, however. It donates phosphoryl groups to a response regulator, Rphl (Yeh et al., 1997), and may therefore be considered a missing link in the evolution of histidine protein kinases to phytochromes (Quail, 1997). There are five phytochromes in
Toble 1
A
Alphabetical list of three-letter species identifiers used in this chapter
P h)
aae Aquija aeolicus abr Azospirillum brasilense aca Azorhizobium caulinodans aeu Alcaligenes eutrophus a h Archaeoglobusfulgidus arh Agrobacterium rhizogenes aSp Anabaenasp. ath Arabidopsis thaliann atu Agrobacteriumtumefaciens avi Azotobacter vinelandii bav Bordetella avium bbr Bacillus brevis bbu Borrelia burgdorferi bfr Bactemidesfragilis bja Bradyrhizobiumjaponicum bme Bacillus megaterium bpa Bradyrhizobiwnparasponia bpe Bordetella pertussis bps Burkholderiapseudomallei bpt Bordetellaparapertussis bsu Bacillus subtilis bte Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron bth Bacillus thuringiensis cac Closhidium acetobutylicum cal Candida albicans cbu Coxiella bumetii ccr Caulobactercrescentus cpe Clostridiumperfringens cpi Carnobacteriumpiscicola ctr Chlamydia trachomatis cvi Calothrix viguien
ddi eae eae eag eca ed eM)
efa efe fdi fsP ge hha hi0 hPY bsa hse hsp kox kPn Ila ImO
IPl Isa mb mex mle mor mth mtu mxa
Diciyostelium discoidewn Eubacteriwn acidaminophilum Enterobacteroemgenes Enterobacteragglomerm Erwinia carotovora Enterobacter cloacae Escherichia coli Enterococcusfaecalis Enterococcusfoecium Fremyella diplosiphon Fischerella sp. Glomerella cingulata Halobacterium halobium Haemophilus injluenzae Helicobacterpylon Halobacterium salinarum Herbaspirillumseropedicae Halobacterium sp. Klebsiella oxytoca Klebsiellapneumoniae Loctococcus h t i s Listeria monocyiogenes Lactobacillusplantarum Lactobacillus sake Mycobacterium bovis Methylobacteriumatorquens Mycobacterium kprae Methylobacteriumorganophilum Methanobacterium t h e m . Mycobacterium tuberculosis Myxococcusxanthus
ucr Neurospora crassa osa Oyza sariva (Rice) pae Pseudomoms aeruginosa pde Paracoccus denitrificans pho Pyrococcus horikoshii pmi Proteus mirabilis por Chloroplast of Porphyra purpurea . . . . ipu Pseuimoms put& pso Pseudomonas solanacearum psp Pseudomoms sp. pst Provia'encia stuartii psy Pseudomoms syringae pto Pseudomoms tolaasii pvi Pseudomonas viridijlava pvu Proteus vulgaris rca Rhodobacter capsulatus rce Rhodospirillum centenum reu Ralstonia eutrvpha rte Rhizobium Ieguminosarum m e Rhizobiwn meliloti rpa Riftia pachyptila enhsymbiont rph Rhizobiumphaseoli rra Rathayibacter rathayi rru Rhodospirillum rubrum rsh Rhodobactersphaeroides m Ralstonia solanacearum rsp Rhodococcus sp. san Streptococcusanginosus sau Staphylococcusaweus sce Saccharomyces cerevisiae sco Streptomycescoelicolor
set sdu sdy sep sgo shy sin sli slu sly smi sml SQU
spo
ssp sti sty
syn
tde lfe bna tpa
ttl val
vco vha xca m e xor yen
Streptococcusconstellatus Salmonella dublin Shigella dysenteriae Staphylococcus epidennidis Streptococcusgordonii Streptomyceshygroscopicus Streptococcusintermedius Streptomyceslividans Staphylococcus lugdunensis Solanum lycopersicum Streptococcusmitis Streptococcusmilkri Streptococcuspneumoniae Schizosaccharomycespombe synechococcus sp. Salmonellatyphi Salmonella typhimrium Synechocystis sp. Treponema denticola Thiobacillusferrooxidans Themtogamantima Treponemapallidum Thauera TI Wbrioalginolyticus Wbtio cholerae Wbrioharveyi Xanthomoms campestris Xenorhabdus nematophilus Xanthomonas oryzae Yersinia enterocolitica
THE HISTIDINE PROTEIN KINASE SUPERFAMILY
143
Arabidopsis (Clack et al., 1994), only one of which has a histidine at the position that a sequence comparison predicts would be the phosphorylation site. In this context, it should be noted that there are several histidine kinase homologues in bacteria that either are not kinases or that phosphorylate at residues other than histidine. These include E l 169520_bme, ERS2_ath, G2648505_afu, G264893 1-afu, G2649096_afu, G2649555_afu, G2650176_afu,G2650366_afu, G2650669_afu, J04195_syn, MTH786_mth, NifL-eag, NifL-kox, NifL-kpn, S111687_syn, TP0980_tpa, TP098 I -tpa, YegE-eco, YhcK-eco and YtrP-bsu (for species identifiers, see Table 1). There are numerous proteins in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes that are unrelated to the histidine protein kinase superfamily but are nevertheless phosphorylated on histidines. Examples are succinyl-CoA synthetase (Boyer et al., 1962; Mitchell et al., 1964), enzymes I, IIA, and IIB and HPr of the phosphoeno1pyruvate:sugarphosphotransferase system (PTS) (Kundig et al., 1964; Weigel et al., 1982; Reizer et al., 1993), nucleoside diphosphate kinase (NDPK) (Zetterqvist, 1967;Walinder, 1968; Walinder et al., 1968), isocitrate lyase (Robertson et al., 1988), phosphoglycerate mutase (Rose, 1970; Rose et al., 1973, adrenocortical cyclic nucleotide-independent protein kinase (Kuroda and Sharma, 1982, 1983), histones HI and H2a from Physarumpolycephalum (Pesis et al., 1988), as well as rat and bovine histones H4 (Fujitaki et al., 1981; Huebner and Matthews, 1985), and human P-selectin (Crovello et al., 1995). Physiological processes that involve sensing through histidine kinases include cell differentiation and cell-cycle regulation, chemotaxis and gliding motility, nitrogen and phosphate homeostasis, production of and resistance to antibiotics, quorum sensing and genetic competence, setting of circadian rhythms and fruit ripening, regulation of turgor and sugar transport, virulence and pathogenicity (Table 2) (for reviews, see Stock et al., 1989; Parkinson and Kofoid, 1992;Alex and Simon, 1994; Hoch and Silhavy, 1995;Appleby et al., 1996; Stock and Surette, 1996; Ohta and Newton, 1996; Wurgler-Murphy and Saito, 1997. Table 3 shows a list of the histidine kinases that have been included in the present sequence analysis, together with accession numbers and potential cognate response regulators. Histidine protein kinases can be found in all major branches of the bacteria and archaea as well as in eukaryotes. The only major group lacking these systems is the animal kingdom. Aside from mitochondria1 homologues, no histidine kinases have been identified in these organisms and their is apparently no histidine protein kinase homologue in the Caenorhabditis elegans genome. In prokaryotes, there seem to be no general rules governing which divisions use histidine kinases and which do not (Fig. 1). It rather seems that the distribution of reported kinases mirrors society’s major research foci, namely
Table 2 Twocomponent phosphorelay systems and their functions. The extension ‘-RR’indicates the receiver domain of a hybrid kinase.
Process
Kinase
Regulator
Organism (reference for kinase)
Antibiotic resistance/synthesis Antibiotic synthesis Antifungal antibiotics Vancomycin resistance
AbsA 1 APdA vans
AbsA2 A@-RR VanR
Streptomyces (Brian et al., 1996) Pseudomom (Corbell and Loper, 1995) Enternbacteria (Arthur et al., 1992)
Catabolism
DegS
DegU
Bacillus (Louw et al.. 1994)
Chemotaxis
CheA
CheY, CheB
Archoeoglobus (Klenk et al., 1997), Bacillus (Fuhrer and Ordal, 1991), Borrelia (Fraser et al., 1997; Trueba et al., 1997), Enterobacter (Dahl et al., 1989), Escherichia (Kofoid and Parkinson, 1991), Halobacterium (Rudolph and Oesterhelt, 1995), Helicobacter (Tomb et al., 1997), Listeria (Dons et al., 1994), Pseudomom (Ditty et al., 1998), Pyrncoccus (Kawarabayasiet al., 1998), Rhizobium (Greck et al., 1995), Rhodobacter (Ward et al., 1995; HambLin et al., 1997), Rhodospirillum (Jiang and Bauer, 1997), Salmonella (Stock et al., 1988). Synecbcystis (Kaneko et al., 1996), Thenotoga Swanson et al., 1996) and Treponema (Fraser et al., 1998)
Autoinduction Competence Competence Quorum Sensing
COmD Cod LuxN, LuxQ
COmE
Streptococcus (Cheng et al., 1997; Pestova et al., 1996) Bacillus (Weinrauch et al., 1990) Vibrio (Bassler etal., 1993, 1994)
COmA Lux0
-.. P
P
L
rn n n
9
m
Differentiation/ development Cell cycle control Motility Nodulation Capsule synthesis Ethylene response Light response, bacteria Light response, plants Cytokinin binding Osmosensing/development Osmosensing Germination Hyphal growth Sporulation
-I
Difl FrzE NodV RcsC ETR (ERS) Cph 1 PhyC CKIl DokA Slnl DhkB Nikl KinA,B,C
DifK FrzE-RR NodW RcsB ETR-RR Rcp 1 ?
cKI1-RR DokA-RR Sln 1-RR DhkB-RR Nikl-RR SPOOF
Caulobacter (Ohta et al., 1992) Myxococcus (McCleary and Zusman, 1990) Brudyrhizobium (Gottfert et al., 1990) Enterobacteria (Stout and Gottesman, 1990) Arabidopsis (Hua et al., 1995), Lycopersicon (Payton et al., unpublished) Synechocystis (Yeh et al., 1997) Arabidopsis (Cowl et al., 1994) Arabidopsis (Kakimoto, 1996) Dictyostelium (Schuster et al., 1996) Saccharomyces (Ota and Varshavsky, 1993) Dictyostelium (Zinda and Singleton, 1998) Neurospora (Alex et al., 1996) Bacillus (Perego et al., 1989; Trach and Hoch, 1993; LeDeaux and Grossman, 1995)
I rn
z
0)
-4 -
P
rn z D W
0
;;I -
z E z
% rn v)
C
-u
rn W
Nitrogen metabolism N,-fixation Nitrate reduction Nitrogen assimilation
Phosphate metabolism
P FixL
FixJ
NarX NtrB
NarL NtrC
CreC
CreB
PhoR
PhoB
Azorhizobium (Kaminski and Elmerich, 1991), Bradyrhizobium (Anthamatten and Hennecke, 1991), Rhizobium (Patschkowski et al., 1996; D'hooghe et al., 1998) Enterobacteria (Stewart et al., 1989) Azospirillum (Machado et al., 1995), Brudyrhizobium (Nixon et al., 1986), Escherichia coli (Miranda-Rios et al., 1987), Herbaspirillum (Steffens et al., unpublished), Klebsiellu (MacFarlane and Merrick, 1985), Proteus (Steglitz-Morsdorfet al., 1993), Rhizobium (Patriarca et al., 1993), Rhodobacter (Foster-Hartnettet al., 1993), Rhodospirillum (Zhang et al., 1995), Salmonella (McFarland et al., 1981), 7'hiobacillus (Kilkenny et al., 1994), Vibrio (Maharaj et al., 1989) Enterobacteria (Wanner and Latterell, 1980 Amemura et al., 1986; Wanner, 1995) Enterobacteria (Makino et al., 1986; Lee et al., 1989)
CitA, DpiA
CitB, DpiB
Enterobacteria (Bott, 1997; Ingmer et al., 1998)
s
7
a
Citrate fermentation
P VI
-.
Table 2 cont.
m P
--
Process
Kinase
Regulator
Organism (reference for kinase)
Adaptation Anaerobic repression Chromatic adaptation Osmosensing
ArcB RcaE EnvZ
ArcB-RR
KdpE
E. coli (Iuchi et al., 1990) Fremyella (Kehoe and Grossman, 1996) E. coli (Mizuno et al., 1982),Salmonella (Liljestrom et al., 1988), Xenorhabdus (Tabatabai and Forst, 1995) E. coli (Wdderhaug et al., 1992)
CiaR PmrA
Streptococcus (Guenzi et al., 1994) Streptococcus (Soncini and Groisman, 1996)
Turgor sensing (K+-transport) KdpD Cell wall integrity
CiaH
PmrB Transport Dicarboxylic acid Hexose-phosphate Phosphoglycerate Vilence/pathogenicity Alginate Alginate Pectate lyase Phytotoxin Vilence Vilence Extracellular &toxin Extracellular toxins Plant cell transformation Root colonization
?
OmpR
DctB UhPB PgtB
Algz Kid PelY CorS BvgS PhOQ AgrC
Rhizobium (Ronson et al., 1987a) E. coli (Island et al., 1992) Salmonella (Yang et al., 1988)
vis
NgR AlgB PelY-RR CorR BvgA PhoP AgrA ViR
VuA COlS
ColR
v i
Pseudomonas (Yu et al., 1997) Pseudomonas (Ma et al., 1997) Pseudomoms (Liao et al., 1994) Pseudomonas (Ullrich et al., 1995) Bordetella (Arico et al., 1989) Salmonella (Miller et al., 1989) Staphylococcus (Novick et al., 1995) Clostridium (Lyristis et al., 1994) Agmbacterium (Leroux et al., 1987; Morel et al., 1989) Pseudomonas (Dekkers et al., 1998)
rc, R rn
#
c rn n n R
<
m cn
4
8 7i
Table 3 List of histidine protein kinases. Species names are in alphabetical order. The group affiliation of histidine kinase domains and receiver domains is given in italics below the name of the protein. The classification of response regulators is based on the receiver domains. The numbers rn indicate the amino acid range of kinase and receiver domains, respectively, that have been used in the sequence analysis. ‘RR’ indicates the receiver Z rn domain of a hybrid kinase 2
2 G
5
Kinase
Regulator(s)
Species (Accessic a)
(Subfamilv)
(Subfamily)
(aa range of kinase domain)
(aa range of receiver domain)
Agrobacterium tumefaciens
ChvG atu
ChvI atu
LI 8860
HPK 3 b 333-570 of total 690
RAl
Agrobacterium tumefaciens
V i A atu
VuA RR atu
VirG atu
XI6905
HPK 4. hybrid 459-695 of total 833
Llnclassi$ed (VirA) 691-832
R A2 2 6 1 45
Agrobacterium tumefaciens
VirAL atu
VirAL RR atu
X05241
HPK 4, hvbrid m 9 5 of total 835
Unclassified (WrA) 691-834
Alcaligenes hydrogenophilus
H o d ahy
HoxA ahy
U82565
HPK 3g 200453 of total 456
RF 9-127
-Q
33
0
iz E
1-1 I8
Anabaena sp. PCC 7120
CvaC asD
CvaC RRI asp
CyaC RR2 asp
D89625
HPK l a 505-734 of total 1155
R A2 9-123
RF 796916
Anabaena sp. PCC 7120
HeDK asD
U68034
HPK l b 329-570 of total 575
Aquifex aeolicus
HksPl aae
NtrCl aae
a 0 0 0 7 2 4 AE000657
HPK 4 423-636 of total 646
R A4 1-124
Aquifex aeolicus
HksP2 aae
PhoB aae
AEWJ683 AEooo657
HPK 4 87-310oftotal310
RAI 5-125
Species
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(Subfmily)
(Accession)
(aa range of b a s e domain)
(Subfami@) (aa range of receiver domain)
Aquifex aeolicus
HksP4 aae
NhC3 aae
Auxx)679 AEOoO657
HPK 4
R A4
122-339 of total 339
1-123
Arabidopsis thaliana
ERS ath
U21952
HPK I b 333-585 of total 613
Arabidopsis thaliana
ETRl atb
ETRl RR ath
L24119
HPK Ib, hybrid 334572 of t d 738
RBI 609-73 1
62708752 atb HPK Ic, hybrid
R 82
472-747oftotal1190
1026-1 180
Arabidopsis thalianu Am3952
G2708752 RR ath
Arabidopsis thaliana Columbia
62435516 atb
G24355 16 RR ath
2435516 AFO24504
HPK Ic, hybrid (noH-Box)
R B2 461439
1-251 oftotal648
Arabidopsis thaliana Wassilewskzjia
CKIl atb
CKIl RR ath
D87545
HPK Ic, hybrid
R 82
391469 of total 1122
985-1 122
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
CheY afu
CheB afu
AFXIO1031Awwx)782
R C2
R C5
1-121
1-123
A rchaeoglobusfulgidus AE000958 AM00782 398-600 of total 608
Archaeoglobusfulgidus
62648833 afu
AE000984 AM00782
HPK 6 325-528 of total 528
m
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
62648910&
AM00989 AM00782
HPK 6 1 15-3 17 of total 323
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
62649045 afu
AEooo997 AEooo782
HPK 6 121-323 of total 338
Archaeoglobus fulgidus AEOOlOOO AEOOO782
62649082afu
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
62649099 afu
AEOOloOl AUWX)782
HPK 6 m 2 1 6 of total 222
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
62649399 afu
AEOO1022AEooo782
HPK 6 256-450 of total 456
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
62649708 afu
AEOO1042AE000782
HPK 6 127-330oftotal334
Archaeoglobus fulgidus AM01051 AEooo782
Archaeoglobus fulgidus AM01073 AEooo782
Archaeoglobus fulgidus
z
z
62249834 afu HPK 6 325-531 of total 531
62650174afu
G2650175 afu
HPK 6 113-324 of total 329
R C2 10-125
62650436 afu
AEOO1092AMoo782
HPK 6 261472 of total 481
Azorhizobium caulinodans
Icizhca
X56658
-0
0
HPK 3h 679-908 of total 908
HPK 4 266494 of total 504
FixJ aca RA4
5-122
Species (Accession)
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(Subfmily) (aa ranee of kinase domain)
(Subfamily)
(aa range of receiver domain)
Azorhizobium caulinodans
NtrY aca
X63841 S71362
NtrX aca
HPK 4
R A4
495-725 of total 771
2-122
Azospirillum brasilense
NtrB abr
NtrC abr
237984
HPK 4
R A4
147-378 of total 400
3-121
Bacillus brevis
DegS bbr
DegU bbr
L15444
HPK 7
R Cl
175-381 of total 386
9-129
Bacillus sp. B21-2 Dl0690
Ibc&L!m HPK 4
155-367 of total 373
Bacillus subtilis
CheA bsu
CheY bsu
CheB bsu
M57894M51894299112ALi339126
HPK 9
R CS
347-537 of total 671
R C2 2- 120
Bacillus subtilis
C o d bsu
C o d bsu
X54010 293932
HPK 7
RE
557-769 of total 769
1-127
Bacillus subtilis
DePS bsu
DegU bsu
U56901
HPK 7
R CI 3-123
17&385 of total 385
1-122
Bacillus subtilis
KinA bsu
SpoOF bsu
M31067
SpoOA bsu
HPK 4
R C2 2-120
R CI
386604 of total 606
3-125
Bacillus subtilis
KinB bsu
SpoOF bsu
SDoOA bsu
U63302 U33938 S61781 299120
HPK 4
R C2
202-423 of total 428
2-120
R CI 3-125
r
m
KinC bsu
S - d F bsu
SpOA bsu
L34803 U51911 AFO12285AFO12284
HPK 4 205-423 of total 428
R C2
R CI
Bacillus subtilis
bs!m HPK 8
l=Ycma!
Bacillus subtilis
371-583oftoId 593
R C3 1-128
Bacillus subtilis
PhoR bsu
PhoP bsu
ha3549
HPK l a 341-572 of total 579
RAl 2-120
Bacillus subtilis
ResE bsu
ResD bsu
LO9228 Z991 I6 A m 1 2 6
HPK la
RA1 6123
Z99 1 I8 AUX)9126
355-589 of total 589
Bacillus subtilis
SDaK bsu
SpaR bsu
U09819 LO7785
HPK 3c 228456 of total 459
RAI
Bacillus subtilis
1-1 17
YcbA bsu
Y cbB bsu
299105AL009126
HPK 3 (only I12 aa) 277-380 of total 387
1-121
Bacillus subtilis
YclK bsu
YclJ bsu
D50453
HPK l a 238468 of total 473
RAl 1-122
Bacillus subtilis BOO1488
YdbF bsu HPK 5 3 12-525 of total 535
R Cl
YdbG bsu R C4 5-127
YdfH bsu
Ydfl bsu
A8001488
HPK 7 191-399 of total 407
R CI 1-126
Bacillus subtilis
YesM bsu
YesN bsu
HPK 8 373-577 of total 577
R CI
Bacillus subtilis
299107AL009126
1-126
Species (Accession)
Bacillus subtilis D78508
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(SUbfnmilY) (aarange of kinase domain)
(Subfmily) (aamge of reCejver domain)
Y6.l bsu
YfiK bsu
HPK 7
R CI
182-384 of total 400
1-121
Bacillus subtilis 2443240 32CL52.5of total 542
Bacillus subtilis
YkoH bsu
YkoG bsu
Z99110Aux)9126
HPK la
R A1
222-449 of total 454
3-121
Bacillus subtilis Z99111AuK)9126
3BrQI.w HPK 4
507-726 of total 738
Bacillus subtilis
YkvDbSU
Z99111ALo09126
HPK 4 282-502
Bacillus subtilis 2619013
No R. MaR 0;total 506
YAEmm HPK 7
169-370 of total 370
HPK 3i
R A1
105-323 of total 334
1-126
3 19-524 of total 533
R C4 1-122
Bacillus subtilis Z99119 Aux)9126
YocG bsu R C1 1-125
YtsA bsu
Bacillus subtilis 293931 299120
Bacillus subtilis
Yvco bsu
YvcP bsu
294043
HPK 3i
RAI
117-346 of total 356
1-125
R
Bacillus subtilis
Yvfr bsu
YvfU bsu
-I
299121 A m 1 2 6
HPK 7
R Cl
12C323 of total 328
1-127
rn
Bacillus subtilis
YvaE bsu
Y vaC bsu
299120 Aux)9126
HPK 7
R CI
140-343 of total 360
1-123
Bacillus subtilis
YaGbSU
Y vrH bsu
299120299121 Au)o9126
HPK la
RAI
340-573 of total 573
136-256
Bacillus subtilis
YwpD bsu
299122 Aux)9126
HPK 8 -267
I
E z D cn rn cn
of total 278
Bacillus subtilis
YxdK bsu
YxdJ bsu
D14399
HPK 3i
RAI
102-323 of total 325
1-118
Bacillus subtilis
YxiM bsu
YxiL bsu
D83026 D45911
HPK 7
R C1
192-393 of total 406
5-131
Bacillus subtilis
YvcG bsu
YvcF bsu
D78193
HPK la
RAI
367-601 of total 61 I
2-1 18
Bacillus thuringiensis
HkoAbth
U03552
HPK 4
s rn
3xI n
D
s
I-
<
153-372 of total 312
Bacteroides fragilis
RDrX bfr
RprY bfr
s59000
HPK lo
RAI
280-514oftotal519
7-125
Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron
RteA bte
RteA RR bte
RteB bte
M81439 M81881
HPK 3 d hybrid, H2-dOmain 28S515 of total 772
Unclassified
Unclass$ed (R A, C ) 3-122
539-658
A
ul w
Table 3 (continued)
Species (Accession)
Kinase
Regulator@)
(Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
(Subfamily) (aa range of receiver domain)
Bordetella avium
Riss bav
RisA bav
AJ224802
HPK 2b 239-460of total 474
RA1
9-129
Bordetella pertussis
BvgS bDe
BveS RR bpe
BveA bDe
M24101
HPK lb. hybrid, H2-domain 71CL945of total 1238
RBI 972-1097
R Cl
Borrelia burgdorferi
CbeAl bbu
CheY2 bbu
CheB2 bbu
L39965 U61498 X91907 AEmI 158 AwKx)783
HPK 9 385-576 of total 716
R C2
25-146
Unchsified 1-86
2-121
Borrelia burgdorferi
CheA2 bbu
CheY3 bbu
CheB 1 bbu
AM01 168 Awxx)783 U28%2
HPK 9 534-722 of total 864
R C2
Unclassified 1-98
25146
Borrelia burgdorferi
62688313 bbu
G2688313 RR bbu
G2688314 bbu
AM01 146 AwwK)783
HPK lb, hybrid 754-994 of total 1494
R B1
R A2
1155-1280
Borrelia burgdorferi
GMss706 bbu
(32688707 bbu
Awx)1176
HPK 4 143-358 of total 382
R A4
3-120
2!rn W
rn
D
Bradyrhizobiumjaponicum
BdfA bia
2801651 AH42096
HPK l a [Yf o r HI 631-865 of total 873
Bradyrhizobiumjaponicum
FixL bia
Fixl bja
X56808
HPK 4 272-500 of total 505
R A4
4122
Bradyrhizobiumjaponicum
NodV bia
NodW bja
M31765
HPK 4 653-882of total 889
R A4
z
0
c rn n
20-131
n
s
m cn
--I
0 0 21
Bradyrhizobiumjaponicum
NwsA bia
NwsB bia
222637
HPK 4 572-804 of total 81 1
R A4 14-132
Bradyrhizobiumjaponicum
Ra@ bia
RayA bja
Yo9666
HPK 2a 225-455 of total 474
RA1 1-120
Brudyrhizobiumjaponicum
Re@ bja
ReeR bja
A1006100
HPK 3e 200420 of total 440
R A4 12-135
Brudyrhizobiumparusponia
NtrB bpa
NtrC bpa
MI4227
HPK 4 130-363 of total 377
R A4 3-121
Burkholderia pseudomallei
I r s bDS
IrlR bps
MOO5358
HPK 2a 23-60 of total 464
RAI 1-1 19
Calothrix viguieri
E307792 evi
2765035 YO9899
HPK l a 505744 of total 744
Candida albicans
CaHKl cal
CaHKl RR cal
AFO13273
HPK Ib, hybrid 1988-2222oftotal2471
R Bl 233&2471
Candida albicans
CaSLNl cal
CaSLNl RR cal
-006362
HPK l b , hybrid (insert) 500-644 and 968-1044 of total 1377
R Bl 1247-1 373
Candida albicans
Chiklcal
Chikl RR cal
A8006363 U69886
HPK l b , hybrid 491-730 of total 1081
R Bl 873996
Camobacterium piscicola
CbnK cDi
CbnR cpi
LA7121
HPK 10 220-429 of total 442
RD 2-130
-I
5
Table 3 (continued)
Species
(Accession)
a
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(WfmW
(
(aa range of kinase domain)
(aa range of receiver domain)
Caulobacter crescentus
DivJ ccr
DivK ccr
HPK Ib
RBI 2-122
Caulobacter crescentus
DivL ccr
CtrA ccr
WuJetaL(1999)
HPK l o [Yfor HI
RAI 1-124
531-757 of total 769
Caulobacter crescentus
PleC ccr
DivK ccr
M91449
HPK Ib
RBI 2-122
592-827 of total 841
Chloroplast of Porphyra purpureu Avon
Ycfza mr
U38804
HPK l a
Q,
wfmw
M98873
318-549 of total 5%
ul
408456 of total 656
Clostridium acetobutylicurn
KdDD cac
KdpE cac
U3%73
HPK la
RAI 4-121
667-900 of total 900
Coxiella burnetii
OrsA cbu
U07186 2126373
HPK 2b
r
208421 of total 425
Dictyosteliurn discoideum
DhkA ddi
DhkA RR ddi
RegA ddi
U42597
HPK Ib, hybrid
R B1 2024-2148
RAI
1377-1621 of total 2150
Dictyosteliurn discoideurn
DhkB ddi
DhkB RRddi
AFD24654
HPK Ib. hybrid
RBI 1838-1969
951-1 185 of total 1%9
Dictyosteliurn discoideurn
DhkC ddi
DhkC RR ddi
-29726
HPK Ib, hybrid
R BI 1076-1 200
410-1550 of total 1225
?J
Y
Dictyostelium discoideum
DhkD ddi
DhkDRRddi
AF029704
HPK la, hybrid 202440 of total 709
R A2 568-69 1
Dictyostelium discoideum
DokA ddi
DokA RR ddi
X96869
HPK Ib, hybrid 1033-1265 of total 1670
R BI 1516-1635
Enterococcus faecium
VanS efe
VanR efe
M68910
HPK l a 145-372 of total 384
RAI 2-119
Erwinia carotovora
RDfA eca
RpfA RR eca
U62023
HPK Ib. hybrid, H2&main 182-5 18 of total 929
R BI 674-796
Escherichia coli
ARB eco
ArcB RR eco
ArcA eco
X53315 U18997 U00096
HPK Ib. hybrid, H2-domnin 273-508 of total 778
RBI 52345
RAI 1-120
Escherichia coli
A M eco
At& eco
L13078 D90851
HPK 4 379-599 of total 608
RA4 4-122
Escherichia coli
BaeS eco
BaeR eco
Dl4054 D90846 D90847
HPK la 231457 of total 466
RAI 9-127
Escherichia coli
BarA eco
BarA RR eco
Dl0888 DO1163 D90894 Auw)o362 UOOO96
HPK Ib, hybrid, H2-domain 283-517 of total 918
R BI 667-786
Escherichia coli
BasS eco
BasR eco
U14003 AEooo483 U00096
HPK 2a 133-353 of total 363
RA1 1-1 18
Escherichia coli
CheA eco
CheY eco
CheB eco
M34669
HPK 9 319-507
RA3 S126
R C5 3-124
Of total 654
Table 3 (continued)
Species
(Accession)
Escherichia coli D90835
A
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(SI&fm.ly) (aa range of kinase domain)
(SUbfami[y) (aa range of receiver domain)
!Ar!&BQ
HPK 2a 226452 of total 452
CopR e c ~ 37-161
CDXA eco
CDXR eco
X13307
HPK 26 230-453 of total 458
RAI 1-1 17
Escherichia coli
crec eco
CreB eco
U14003 Uooo96
HPK 3c 246470 of total 474
RAI
BxSsm
I2sa&zQ
U14003
HPK 5 330-535 of total 543
m
RAI
Escherichia coli
Escherichia coli
Ln
>121 4
R C4 1-123
Escherichia coli
DDiB eco
DpiA eco
U82598 W7510 U46667
HPK 5 328-538 of total 552
R C4 4-123
Escherichia coli
EnvZ eco
OmDR eco
J01656AMoo416 U00096
HPK 26 224-437 of total 450
RAI
EI&cQ
Eves RR e c ~
EvgA eco
R BI
R CI 1-124
Escherichia coli D14008 AEooo325 U00096
HPK Ib. hybrid, H2-domnin 702-935 of total 1197
Escherichia coli
61033145eco
AEooo342 uooo%
HPK 3c
u36841
25-91
rri 2
r
'G122
958-1076
D
z
0
c rn n n
a
< !JJ
of total 496
Escherichia coli
HvdH eco
HydG eco
M28369
HPK 4 235-455 of total 465
R A4
5-123
v)
I
x
Escherichia coli
KduD eco
KdDE eco
M36066
HPK l a 654-882 of total 894
RAl 1-1 18
kbEQXx3
NarP eco
NarL eco
351-556 of total 566
R Cl 6-126
R Cl 6-126
Escherichia coli
NarX eco
NarL eco
NarP eco
X69189 X13360 X15996 X65715 D90757
HPK 7 38CL585 of total 598
R Cl 6-126
R CI 6-126
Escherichia coli
NtrB eco
NtrC eco
X05173 L19201 AM00462 U00096
HPK 4 12CL346 of total349
RA4 3-121
Escherichia coli
Pcos eco
PcoR eco
X83541
HPK 2a 238-4155 of total 466
RAl 1-1 19
Escherichia coli
Phd)eco
PhoP eco
D90393 AJ300213 Uooo%
HPK 3a
RAI
258-479 of total 486
1-118
Escherichia coli X65714 D90875 M94724 AM00333 U00096
HPK 7
Escherichia coli
WoR eco
PhoB eco
U73857 X04704 AM00146 UOOO96
HPK l a
RAl 2-122
194422 of total 43 1
-I
I rn
W 5J
0
!i z xz
E;rn
Escherichia coli
RcsC eco
RcsC RR eco
RcsB eco
M28242 L11272
HPK lb.. hvbrid ,
444-673 of total 933
RBI 808-926
RE 3-126
Escherichia coli
RstB eco
RstA eco
U41101 AM00256 Uooo%D90804 D90803
HPK 26 202425 of total 433
RA2 4-121
Eschenchia coli
Tors eco
Tors RR eco
TorR eco
X94231 X78195AEOOO201 Uoo096
HPK l b , hybrid H2-domain 424-65 1 of total 904
R 83 67 1-790
RAl 2-119
Table 3 (continued)
Species (Accession)
Kinase
Regulator(s)
( S ~ f ~ ~ Y ) (aa range of kinase domain)
(SUbfamibJ (aa range of receiver domain)
Escherichia coli
UhDB eco
UhDA eco
M17102L10328AE000444U00096
HPK 7
R CI
2944% of total 500
1-124
Escherichia coli
YehU eco
YehT eco
uoooo7
HPK 8
R C3 6130
363-561 of total 561
Escherichia coli
YehUl eco
MrkE eco
1799791 D90868
HPK 8
R C3
346-550 of total 559
1-120
YgiY eco HPK 20
RAI
227449 of total 449
1-118
Escherichia coli U28377
Fischerella sp. PCC 7605
62160761fbu
U97518
HPK lai
Q)
0
G882555 eco
58-295 of total 308
r
Fremyella diplosiphon
RcaE fdi
RcaF fdi
RcaCn fdi
c)
U59741
HPK lai 41 1-646 of total 655
RA2
RAl 1-125
W
Glomerella cingulata
Chkl pci
Chkl RR gci
u77605 w7606
HPK Ib, hybrid
RBI 64%745
101-34Ooftotal745
3124
D
rn rn
D
z
0 L
rn
n
Haemophilus injluenzae
ArcBhin
U32707 LA2023
HPK Ib
n
? m
112-325 of total 325
Haernophilus infuenzae
NarOhin
NarP hin
U32713 LA2023
HPK 7
R CI 4-124
354-563 of total 567
cn -I
0
0
x
Haemophilus influenzae
PhoR hin
PhoB hin
U32818 LA2023
HPK IA I8W14 of total 425
RAI 2-121
Haemophilus influenzae
YpiX hin
U32843 LA2023 225-45 1 of total 45 1
RA1 1-118
-I
I rn
Halobactenurn salinarum
CheA hss
CheY hsa
CheB hsa
X82645
HPK 9 348-539 of total 668
R C2 2-120
R CS 1-121
Halobacterium sp. NRC-I
H0337 hSD
H0337 RR h w
2822308
HPK 6, RR-HK 707-913 oftotal 917
RF 92-2 14
Helicobacter pylon
CheA hDy
CheA RR hpv
CheY hpy
AE000555 AMOO5l 1
HPK 9, hybrid 324514 of total 803
RA2 676-803
R A3 1-124
Helicobacter pylon'
62314530 h y
G231453 1 hvv
A m 3 6 AEOOO511
HPK 3a 181-392 of total 397
R A4 3-123
Herbaspirillum seropedicae
NtrB hse
NhC hse
AFO82873
HPK 4 128-363 of total 363
R A4 1-128
Klebsiella pneumoniae
CitB kun
U31464 331-539 of total 547
R C4 3-123
Klebsiella pneumoniae
PhoR kvn
PhoB kpn
M31794
HPK l a 194-422 of total 431
RAI 2-122
Lactobacillus plantarurn CI I
PlnB ID1
PlnC lpl
PlnD lpl
X94434 X75323
HPK 10 235-442 of total 442
RD 1-129
RD 1-129
Species (Accession)
Lactobacillusplantanun LPCOlO Y15127
Kinase
Regulator@)
(Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
(Subfamily) (aa range of receiver domain)
PlsK ID1 HPK 10 2 1 9 2 6 of total 426
Lactobacillus sake Lb706
SakBISa
221855
HPK 10
PlsR ID1 RD 4-129
1 9 9 3 0 of total 430
Lactobacillus sake LTH 673
SDDKIsa
248542 AFOO2276
HPK 10 223-448 of total 448
SpDR Isa RD 1-121
Lactococcus lactis 6F3
NisK Ila
NisR lla
x76884
HPK 3c
RAI 1-126
219-447 of total 447
Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris
LIkiIlAUa
us1166
HPK la 257-490 of total 4W
Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris
LlkinB Ila
U81485 2182990
HPK la 294-517 of total 517
Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris
LlkinC Ila
US1486
HPK
In
21-58
of total 475
Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris
LlkiIlDIla
U81487
HPK 7 121-326 of total 332
Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris
Llkineorfl Ila
US1488
HPK la 220441 of total441
m
Listeria monocytogenes X76170
CheA lmo
CheY Imo
-I
HPK 9
RC 2 1-1 19
rn
~~~
~~
295486 of total 618
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH1124 mth
AE000882 AE000666
HPK I 1
I
171-348 of total 348
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH123 mth
AE000801 AE000666
HPK I 1
-0
n
0
dz
146356 of total 356
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH1260 mth
AE000892 AE000666
HPK 11, IR for HI 146354 iftotal 354
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH174 mth
AE000805 AE000666
HPK I 1 577-785 of total 785
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH292 mth
AE000814 AE000666
HPK I 1 357-564 of total 564
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH356 mth
AE000821 AE000666
HPK 11 362-567 of total 567
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH360 mth
AE00082 1 AE000666
HPK I 1 486700 of total 700
Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH444 mth
MTH445 mth
AE000828 AE000666
HPK 3h 142-369 of total 373
RH 4-134
Methanobacterium therrnoautotrophicum
MTH446 mth
MTH447 mth
AE000829 AE000666
HPK I 1
Unclassified (Mth447D01) 1-121
371-583 of total 583
Species (Accession)
Kinase
Regulator@)
(Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
fSUbfom2yJ
Methambacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH459 rnth
AEooo830 AM00666
HPK 11
(aarange of receiver domain)
288-495 of total 495
Methanobacterium themautotmphicum
MTH468 mth
AEooo831 AEooo666
HPK 11 350-554 of total 554
Methambacterium thermoautotrophicum
MTH619 rnth
AEooo843 AM00666
HPK I 1
539-749 of total 749
Methobacterium themautotmphicum
MTH823 rnth
AEooo859 AEooo666
HPK I1
494-677 of total 677
Methanobacterium themautotmphicum
MTH901 rnth
MTHW1 RR mth
AEooo865 AEooo666
HPK 11,RR-HK 139-352of total 352
3-124
Methanobacterium thermoautotmphicurn
MTHW2 rnth
MTH901 rnth
AEooo865 AEooo666
HPK 11 2.54-462 of total 462
5125
Methanobacterium themautotmphicum
MTH985 rnth
AEOOO872 AM00666
HPK I1
Unclassified (Mth4471901)
Unclassifid (Mth447hW)
150-365 of total 365
Methylobacterium organophilum
MxcO mor
U18290 1586734
HPK 7
26 1467 of total 495
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
3Oc mtu
31c mtu
273101 24401 13 299494
HPK 2a
RAI
221-146 of total 446
1&134
...
z
r
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
El264624 rntu
El264625 mtu
m22121
HPK la
RAI
237465 of total475
8-127
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
G2072665 mtu
2072665 295120AL123456
HPK I 1
2m z fn
=! 0 Z
283-501 of total 501
rn -0
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
MtrB rntu
MtrA mtu
U14909295121 a1234 5 6
HPK la
RAI
286-520 of total 567
5-127
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
PhoR mtu
PhoP mtu
280226 a123456
HPK la
RAl
2 M 9 of total 485
19-146
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
SenX3 rntu
ReeX3 mtu
Y13628 277162 a 1 2 3 4 5 6
HPK l u
RAl
148-376 of total 410
1-120
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
TrcS mtu
TrcR mtu
U88959 292539 P96368 a 1 2 3 4 5 6
HPK la
R A1
26a-499 of total 509
51-175
Myxococcus xanthus
FnE m a
FrzE RR m a
Frzzi m a
M35192
HPK 9. hybrid
R A3
316507 of total 777
658-777
Wnchsified 1-126
Myxococcus xanthus
Pils mxa
PilR m a
L39904
HPK 4
R A4
306-525 of total 525
4-122
Myxococcus xanthus DKlOl
Sass mxa
AF029787
HPK 4 2 6 H 8 2 of total 497
Myxococcus xanthus DK.5090 U20214
LkfzbEa HPK 3g,RI-HK 139-385 of total 385
AseA RR m a RF
7- 120
z
41 Ei Z
xZ
$ rn
Table 3 (continued)
Species (Accession)
a
Kinase (Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
(SGWlY)
(aa range of m i v e r domain)
Neurospora crassa
Nikl ncr
Nikl RR n a
u50264
HPK l b , hybrid 699-935 of total 1281
RBI 10851210
Paracoccus denitnjkans
E& !&
ms RRpde
HPK 3d 75303 of total 441
RG 324441
Paracoccus denitriJicans
MoxY pde
MoxX pde
M92421
HPK 7 225439 of total 446
RE
AJ223460 PDAJ3460
m m
Rermlatods) ._
IS134
Proteus rnirabilis
RcsC Dmi
RcsC RR pmi
RcsB pmi
AFO71215
HPK l b , hybrid 3 1-247 of total 507
RBI 396-507
RE %I24
Proteus vulgaris
NtrB DVU
NtrC pvu
X68129
HPK 4 120-348 of total 348
R A4 3-121
Providencia stwm'i
AarGpst
AarR Dst
AFO41833
HPK 3a 256-485 of total 485
R A1 1-82
Pseudomom aeruginosa
LUz€?@ HPK 8
1542971 U50713
156358 of total 358
AlgR pae R C3 1-123
Pseudomom aeruginosa
CheAY m e
ChpA RR
CheB pae
U79580
HPK 9 1151-1339 of total 1638
R A3 1515-1636
6-122
Pseudomonas aeruginosa
LemA -me
L e d RR pae
AFO303.52
HPK Ib, hybrid, H2-domain 274-510 of total 925
RBI 664-78 1
Unclarsified
m
PilR Dae
Pseudomonas aeruginosa 212154 L22436
Pseudomonas aeruginosa
300-526 of total 530
R A4 3-130
Pi15pae
PirR pae
AF05 1692
HPK 2 b 224442 of total 458
Pseudomom aeruginosa FRDI
KinB Dae
RAl 9-132
AleB pae
u97063
HPK l a 3 6 5 9 5 of total 595
R A4 8-136
Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAK
FleS w e
HeR Dae
LA1213
HPK 4 172-365 of total 402
R A4 2-120
Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA0
PfeS oae
PfeR pae
Lo7739
HPK 26 225-446 of total 446
R A1 77-201
Pseudomonas fluorescens
COlS Dfl HPK 20 202425 of total 425
ColR pfl
YO9798
Pseudomonas fluorescens
L2-2
L29642
Dfl HPK la, hybrid 191-575 of total 575
Pseudomonas fluorescens
StvS Dfl
R A1 1-124
L29642 RR Dfl R A3 449-568
StyR pfl
AF024619
HPK 4 280-51 1 of total 522
R A4
Pseudomonas fluorescens v-5
4-121
Alxkw!
ApdARRpfl
U30858
HPK lb. hybrid, H 2 - d o m i n 275-510 of total 917
RBI -790
Pseudomonas putida
CheA DPU HPK 9 415-605 of total 747
CheY ppu
CheB Dpu
RA3 1-124
R C5 2-125
AFo31898
Table 3 (continued)
Species
(Accession)
-. Kinase
Regulator(s)
(Subfmily)
(S~familyl (aa range of receiver domain)
(aa range of kioase domain)
Pseudomonas putida
Tods pDU
TodT DVU
U72354
HPK 4
R A4 25-146
741-971oftotal978
Pseudomonas solanacearum
VsrA DSO
VsrD DSO
u02041
HPK 7
R CI
264473 of total 502
1-127
Q,
a0
Pseudomom solanacearum
VsrB RR Dso
vsrc DSO
L21173
RF
Unclassified 5-130
253-483 of total638
Pseudomonas sp. VLBl20 AH31161
Pseudomonas sp. Y2 AJKKJ330
swkEsk!
510-631
StdR psp
HPK 4
R A4
from partid sequence
4-128
€tYum!
HPK la hybrid 175405 of total982
stys RR psg RA2 451-570
stx€LIm HPK 4
741-971 of total 982
Pseudomonas syringoe P". glycinea U33326
Cors Dsv
CorR Dsv
HPK 3d
RG 1-120
19-27
of total 434
Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae
HpkY -DSV
G2078566 Dsv
AFoo1355
4 ~~.
HPK
RF
103-342 of total 342
1-1 19
Pseudomorns syringae pv. syringae
LemA Dsv
L e d RR psy
M80477
HPK Ib.. hvbrii H2-domain ,
RBI 656784
~~
265-500 of total 907
D z
0
Pseudomoms syringae pv. tomato LO5176
coDsDsv HPK 20 226456 of total 487
CopR psy RAI 1-1 19
Pseudomnas tolaasii
WeN Dto
PheN RR pto
u95300
HPK Ib. hvbrid, H2-domain 7 1-305 of;otal706
RBI 46-585
Pseudomoms viridiflava
PelY ~ v i
PelY RR pvi
L30101
HPK Ib, hybrid, H2-domain 2.54489 of total 896
R Bl 644-772
Pyrococcus horikoshii
CheA pho
CheY pho
AP000002 MOO9481
HPK 9 438-628 of total 766
R C2 1-120
c z c s reu
CzcR reu
HPK 2a 22-52 of total 475
R A1 1-117
Ralstonia eutropha
H o d reu
HoxA reu
U82564
HPK 3g 201-457 of total 622
RF 5-126
Rhizobium leguminosarum
DctB rle
DctD rle
X06253
HPK 4 396-622 of total 622
RA4 5-126
Rhizobium leguminosarum
F d rle
FixL RR rle
270305
HPK 4 , hybrid 2614% of total641
RF 521-641
Rhizobium leguminosarum
Ralstonia eutropha X98451 M26073 S51060 X67305
PODOrle
PopP rle
X89983
HPK 3a 236-379 and 392467 of total 467
RAI 1-1 19
Rhizobium meliloti
ActS m e
L39938
HPK 3e 200-419 of total 433
L l G 3 u m R A4 21-138
-I
I rn
-0
W
0
i v,
Table 3 (continued) Species (Accession)
4
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
(Subfamily) (aa range of receiver domain)
4
0
Rhizobium meliloti
CheA rme
CheYI m e
U13166
HPK 9 416-4335 of total 758
RA3
RC
2-121
4-128
Rhizobium meliloti
JktB m e
!2ah?s
J03683
HPK 4 41 1 4 3 6 of total 636
R A4 4-125
Rhizobium meliloti
ExoS m e
ChvI m e
AF027298
HPK 36 331-568 of total 577
R A1 1-123
Rhizobiurn meliloti
ExsG m e
ExsF m e
2808506 AJ225561
HPK 11 700-912 of total 912
7-124
Rhizobium meliloti
FigL m
FixJ rmg
J03 174 221854
HPK 4 266-494 of total 505
e
Rhizobium phaseoli
NtrB roh
X7 1436
HPK 4 131-363 oftotal 383
Rhodobacter capsulatus
w2ba
X64733 446774
HPK 4 420-649 of total 657
CheB m e
UncrosSified
R A4
3-124
DctR rca R A4
2-125
c rn
n n
Rhodobacter capsulatus BIO
HuDT rca
Lo2348
HPK 3g 1 9 H 5 6 of total 456
Rhodobacter capsulatus SB1003
NtrB rca
NtrC rca
X72382 L11718 X12359
HPK 4 12 1-350 of total 356
R A4 2-123
ID
<
m
+
v)
8 iT
Rhodobacter capsulatus SB1003 L35179
IbmGa HPK 3e
Rhodobacter sphaeroides
RegA rca
-I
R A4 11-135
rn
I
CheY rsh
X80027 349-475 of total686
R A3 2-122
Rhodobacter sphaeroides
CheAII rsh
CheY rsh
CheB rsD
No00977
HPK 9 32C-509 of total 654
R A3 2-121
R C5 9- 134
Rhodobacter sphaeroides
DorS rsh
DorS RR rsh
DorR rsh
AFO16236
HPK I b , hybrid H2-domain 305-539 of total 815
R Bl 558-684
RAI 4-130
Rhodobacter sphaeroides
HuDT rsh
L37 195
HPK 3g 1 8 7 4 3 of total 443
Rhodobacter sphaeroides
PrrB rsh
PrrA rsh
U22347
HPK 3e 202430 of total 462
R A4 12-135
Rhodococcus sp. M5
BpdS rsp
BpdT rsp
U85412
HPK 7 137C-1576 of total 1576
R CI 1-122
Rhodospirillum centenurn SW
CheAY rce
CheA RR rce
U64519
CheY rce
HPK 9, hybrid 277468 of total 901
R A3 77&901
R A3 1-121
Rifia pachyptila endosymbiont
RssA ma
RssA RR rpa
U91704
RssB 'pa
HPK Ib, hybrid 377412 of total 773
R BI 64s773
R A2 6-127
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
SLnl sce
Slnl RR sce
U01835
Sskl sce
HPK Ib, hybrid (insen) 557-701 and 849-925 of total 1220
R BI 1087-1213
R B1 503449
-.
Table 3 (continued)
Kinase Species (Accession)
(Subfamily) (Aa range of kinase domain)
AF060858
2 2 1 4 9 of total 454 M21279
Salmonella typhimurium L13395 L13394
(Aa range of receiver domain)
&!m!x
HPK 4 438-660 of total 668
I?mEbQ
HPK 20 13S356 of total 356
RAI 22-139
&!a?! Unclassified F128
PmrA sty RAI 1-123
SViR sty
U51927
HPK Ib. hybrid 38641 1 of total 823
RBI
ll.!wb&
IBubz?!
Schizosaccharomycespombe
E339934 SDO
E339934 RR spo
298918
HPK lb, hybrid 1744-1983 of total 2310
R Bl 2178-2310
Solanum lycopersicum
ERS slv
U38666
HPK l b 33S584 of total 635
Solanum lycopersicum
ETRl slv
ETRl RR sly
U41103
HPK 16. hybrid 348402 of total 754
RB1 627-748
Staphylococcus aureus
Lyts sau
LytR sau
LA2945
HPK 8 ~.~ .~ .
R C3 1-124
M89480
ru
(Subfamil)
Salmonella typhimurium
Salmonella typhimurium
21
CoDR sdu
Salmonella dublin
Salmonella typhimurium
Regulator(s)
HPKT 2 9 4 4 % of total 500
370-584 of total 584
684-805
RCl 1-124
P0 c rn
-n n
2
m
Staphylococcus aureus KS154
A g C sau
AmA sau
U85096
HPK
RD
10
220-430 of total 430
1-1 14
Staphylococcus aureus RN4282
AgrCl sau
A g A 1 sau
X52543
HPK 10 221423 of total 423
RD 1-129
&dhl!
AerA sep
Staphylococcus epidemidis AFO12132
HPK 10
217.429 of total 429
Streptococcus constellam NCTC I1325
ComD sct
NO00867
HPK
RD 1-127
10
228440 of total 440
Streptococcus gordonii
c o d SQO
C O m E sgo
U80077
HPK 10
RD
239-453 of total 453
Streptococcus gordonii Challis NCTC 7
C o d 1 seo
COmEl seo
X98109
HPK 10
RD 1-123
240-453 of total 453
Streptococcus gordonii NCTC 3165
c o d 3 SPO
No00870
HPK 10 240453 of total 453
Streptococcus gordonii NCTC 7865 X98110
COmD2 SEO HPK 10 239-452 of total 452
Streptococcus intemedius NCDO 2227
ComD sin
NO00869
HPK I0
COmE2 seo RD 1-1 17
229441 of total 441
Streptococcus pneumoniae R6
c i a SDn
X77249
HPK la 207-436 of total 444
CiaR spn 1-120
Species (AcceSSiOn)
Streptococcuspneumoniae R6 U33315 U76218
Kinase (ShfAyJ
(aa range of kinase domain)
caam!l HPK 10 215437oftotal441
Regulator(s) (WfmW
(aa range of receiver domain)
ComE spn RD 1-126
Streptomyces coelicolor
AbsAl sco
AbsA2 sco
U51332
HPK 7
R CI
183-389 of total 571
1-127
Streptomyces coelicolor
Afsoz sco
AfSOl sco
DIM54
HPK la
RAl 1-1 19
225-507 of total 535
Streptomyces coelicolor
E1215U)l sco
El215200 sco
-20958
HPK 20
RAI
242467 of total 481
1-127
Streptomyces coelicolor
El286180 sco
El286181 sco
-22374
HPK 7
R CI
184-384 of total 384
9-134
Streptomyces coelicolor
El286185 sco
El286184 sco
-22374
HPK 5
R C4
334-541 of total 566
1-122
Streptomyces coelicolor
El310290 sco
El310290 RR sco
El310292 sco
AL031031
HPK I b, hybrid
RBI 1707-1829
4-128
1356-1610 of total 1829
Streptomyces coelicolor
El311959 sco
-31
R C1
107 183-395 of total 405
2-127
Streptomyces coelicolor
El313519 sco
El313520 sco
-31
HPK 7
R CI
208-421 of total 429
1-127
155
RA2
Streptomyces hygroscopicus NRRL 5491 X86780
am!E HPK 2a
175-399 of total 399
sMm!Y
Streptornyces lividans 66
cuts sli
CUtR sli
X58793
HPK 20
RAI 1-125
18s.414 of total 414
Synechococcus PCC7942
y70379 SSD
G1575690 SSE
U70379
HPK la
R A1 1-120
210-438 of total 438
Synechococcus sp. PCC7942 D14056
-I m
I
RAI 1-125
€ixsl&
xz
HPK lai
D
142-379 of total 387
Synechococcus sp. PCC7942
SDhS SSD
SphR ssp
D13172
HPK l a
RAl 22-152
160-396 of total 415
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
D ~ D svn A
X72856
HPK la
%
413-657 of total 663
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
CheAY 1 svn
CheAY 1 RR syn
CheY syn
D64006
HPK 9,hybrid
R A3 1274-1397
R A2 1-1 19
903-1093 of total 1402
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 D90904AB001339
C h e A Y 2 svn HPK 9, hybrid 454644 of total 924
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 D64001
C D h l ssp HPK 3h, phytochmme 5 19-745 of total 748
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Sll0337 svn
D63999
HPK la 188421of total 430
CheAY2 RR ssp RA3 199-924
Rcpl ssp RH 8-141
Species (Accession)
Kinase
Regulatorjs)
(Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
(SqmiW (aa range of receiver domain)
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
sn0474S
D&u)(L1AB001339
HPK l b 4-50
V ~
of total 806
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
€NO750svn
D64ooo
h!PK l a i 147-383 of total 383
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
wo7mSvn
S110789 svn
D64005
HPK l a 2-3 of total 458
RA1
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
SII0798 svn
Sll0797 svn
D64005
HPK la
RAI
2 1 U 5 of total 454
1-122
1-122
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slll003 spn
D90902
HPK l a 428661 of total 661
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 D90905 U67397
sn1124 m
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
sll1228m
S111228 RR svn
1653170D90911
HPK lb, hybrid 153-392 of total 663
RBI 417-540
HPK l a 1157-1367 oftotal 1371
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 m
7 590-829 of total 998
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Sll1475 svn
D90916
HPK l a 59-287 of total 297
m
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
SL11590 syn
S111592 svn
-I
m 1 0
HPK 3f 112-350 of total 350
R CI 7-127
rn
I
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
SU1672 syn
S111672 RR svn
S111673 svn
D909oO
HPK Ib. hybrid 365-602 of total 834
RBI 629-750
R A2 8-13]
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
SU1871 SM
Slr1982 syn
m 1 2
HPK l b 428-663 of total 671
4123
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
su1888 SYll
m 1 2
HPK Ib 185432 of total 432
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
su1905 m
Sll1905 RR2 svn
S111905 RRl svn
m 1 0
HPK l b , hybrid 311-542oftotal1014
RBI
R A2
739-855
17-139
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
slro210 SM
D64002
HPK l b 190-407of total 417
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
slro222 m
SM222 RRn syn
D64ooo
HPK la,hybrid 930-1162oftotal1178
Unclassified 5-126
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
SlrO311 sp
SM312 svn
D64005
HPK 7 550-759 of total 759
R C1 6-132
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slro322 syn
SM322 RR svn
D63999
HPK 9,hybrid 432-622 of total 1095
R A3 799-925
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
slro484 syn
D64001
HPK Iai 404-641 of total 675
A
Table 3 (continued)
Species (Accession)
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(Subfamily) (aa range of kinase domain)
(Subfrn.lYl (aa range of receiver domain)
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
slro533 svn
D64006
HPK l a 168-405 of total 405
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
sLr0640 S
D64CKJ2
HPK 3b 18-35 of total 441
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr1324 svn
LBO911
HPK l a 178407 of total 420
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr1393 svn
D90904
HPK Ib (insert) 717-751and768-962oftotal974
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr1414 svn
D909oO
HPK 3f [Rfor HI 195-422 of total 437
11 OD
M
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr1759 svn
Slr1759 RR2 syn
Slr1759RRI syn
D90903
HPK Ib, hybrid 768-1014 of total 1462
RBI 1139-1305
R 83 1033-1 I50
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr1805 svn
S111708 svn
D90908
HPK 3f 517-749 of total 749
R CI
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr1969 svn
Slr1969 RR svn
D90912
HPK l a hybrid 369-656 of total 750
631-750
13-142 Unclawified
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr2098 svn
Slr2098 RR svn
Slr2099 svn
LBO910
HPK Ib, hybrid 517-751oftotal1261
R 83 7704%
RA2 1&134
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr2099 spn
Slr2100 svn
m 1 0
HPK l a i 134-366 of total 366
R A2 10-127
Synechocystis sp. PCC6803
Slr2104 svn
Slr2104 RR svn
m 1 0
HPK Ib, hvbrid 448-682 of total 950
RA2 717-836
Thauera TI
n t c 1 ttl
TutC RR ttl
TUBttl
u57m
HPK l a . hybrid 171404 of total 979
R A2 449-567
RA4 7-127
Thauera TI
n t c 2 ttl
(seeTutcl-ttl)
HPK 4 738-967 of tOmI 979
Thermotoga maritima
CheA tma
CheY mta
U30501
HPK 9 348-539ofIotal671
RC 2 2-120
Thermotoga maritima
HD~A tma
DrrA tma
U67196
HPK l a 17W12 of total 412
RAl f129
Thiobacillusferrooxidans ATCC 33020
NtrB tfe
NtrC tfe
L18975
HPK 4 127-352 of total 361
R A4 1-123
Treponema denticola
CheA Me
CheY tde
.GO74950
HPK 9 500-4547 of total 801
R C2 24- 145
Treponemapallidurn
CheA tDa
CheY tpa
U61851 AEoo1215 AM00520
HPK 9 4 7 M 5 9 of total 812
R C2 24-144
vibrio alginolyticus NCIB 1I038
NtrB val
NtrC val
m8499
HPK 4 120-348 of total 348
R A4
Table 3 (continued)
Species (Accession)
2
Kinase
Regulator(s)
(Subfmily) (Aam g e of kinase domain)
(Subfamily) (Aarange of receiver domain)
Kbrio cholerae
FlrB vch
FlrC vch
AFO14113
HPK 4 116-337oftotal351
R A4 3-125
vibrio cholerae
WoR vco
PhoB vco
AFo43352
HPK l a 196-426 of total 433
RAI 2-1 25
OD
0
vibrio harveyi
Lux0 vha
L u x O RR vha
L u x O vha
urn069
HPK Ib. hybrid 473-710 of tntal859
R RI
R A4 1-124
Xanthomom campestris pv. campestris
RDfC xca
RpfC RR xca
SwissPmt: P49246
HPK Ib, hybrid, H2-domain 130-364 of total 677
R B1 412-536
Xanthomom oryzae pv. oryzae
RaK xor
RDfC RR xor
X97865
HPK l b , hybrid H2-domain 130-363 of total 676
410-536
20
RBI
Xenorhubdus nematophilus
EnvZ m e
om& me
urn746
HPK 26 116-342 of total 342
RAI 4128
GI rn
W
m rn
THE HISTIDINE PROTEIN KINASE SUPERFAMILY
181
Table 4 Major prokaryotic divisions. Names underlined indicate divisions with reported histidine kinases. The classification is based on the taxonomy homepage at the American National Center for Biotechnology Information
Archaea Crenarchaeota Pyrodictiales Sulfolobales Thermoproteales Unclassified Crenarchaeota Euryarchaeota Archaeoelobales Halobacter ides Methanococcales (Methanococcusjannaschii) Methanomicrobiales Methanopyrales Thermococcales Thennoplasmales Unclassified Euryarchaeota Korarchaeota Environmental samples Unclassified Archaea Halophilic archaea Environmental samples
Eubacteria Aauificales
ChlamydialesNermcomicrobia group Coprothermobacter group Cyanobacteria (blue-green alcael C y t o p h a J m w Fibrobacter/acidobacteriumgroup es (Gram-oositive bacterid Flexistipes group Fusobacteria Green non-sulfur bacteria Holophaga group Nitrospira group Planctomycetales Proteobacteria Synergistes group Thermodesulfobacterium group Thermotogales Thermus/deinococcus group Unclassified Eubacteria
182
THORSTEN W. GREBE AND JEFFRY B. STOCK
human and plant pathogens as well as biotechnologicallypromising organisms such as extremophiles.The number of histidine kinases within different organisms can vary substantially - from 0 in Mycoplasma genitalium (Fraser et al., 1995) and Methanococcus jannaschii (Bult et al., 1996) to more than 30 in Bacillus subtilis (Kunst et al., 1997) and Synechocystis (Kaneko et al., 1996; Mizuno et al., 1996). Organisms that can live in a wide range of different environmental conditions appear to be equipped with larger sets of histidine kinases, which often function as sensors for changing environmental parameters. Being able to survive in sewers, intestines, blood plasma and almost any type of nutrient broth, E. coli sports some 30 sensor protein kinases (Blattner et al., 1997; Mizuno, 1997). Haemophilus injluenzae, a human pathogen, which specializes on warm-blooded hosts, has a restricted set of four identified histidine kinases, while Mycoplasma genitalium, an obligate parasite that lives in a practically constant environment, has a genome that appears totally to lack histidine kinase homologues. 1.3. System Design
In recognition of the two conserved protein superfamilies of His-Asp phosphorelay systems, they have been termed two-component regulatory systems (Ronson et al., 1987b), despite the fact that other, relatively diverse elements of protein structure, are invariably involved. Nevertheless, in their simplest form, these systems comprise only two proteins, a histidine protein kinase and a response regulator. The histidine kinases typically contain two functionally and structurally distinct parts, a variable N-terminal sensor region and a conserved C-terminal kinase core domain that features the phosphoaccepting histidine as well as the so called homology boxes. The latter are highly conserved sequence fingerprints that serve to define the family (Stock et al. 1988; Parkinson and Kofoid, 1992). Some kinases lack the sensing domain, e.g. the chemotaxis kinase CheA where sensing has been outsourced to a distinct class of chemoreceptors, termed MCPs (Adler, 1969; Kondoh et al., 1979; Grebe and Stock, 1998); and NtrB, where an auxiliary protein, PI,, relays information on the status of cellular nitrogen metabolism (Brown et al., 1971;Adler et al., 1975; Ninfa et al., 1995; Jiang et al., 1998a,b).A few additional examples of kinases that appear not to have sensing domains have been found through sequencing projects over the last few years, including G2313251-hpy (Tomb et al., 1997), G2649099-afu (Klenk et al., 1997), and probably G953193-pae (Hachler et al., 1996). Despite the fact that the first two histidine kinases identified, NtrB and CheA, exhibited this characteristic, kinases without sensing domains are extremely rare. Because they lack transmembrane sensors, NtrB and CheA are soluble proteins and, therefore, they are relatively easy to purify and characterize.
THE HISTIDINE PROTEIN KINASE SUPERFAMILY
183
Response regulators generally contain at least two functional domains: a phospho-aspartyl receiver domain that interacts with the kinase domain of a cognate histidine protein kinase, and one or more output domains, . Response regulators most commonly transcription factors with output domains that bind DNA. About 25% of all response regulators have no output domain, however, and a few output domains have been identified with enzymatic activities, e.g. CheB of the chemotaxis system is a protein methylesterase (Stock and Koshland, 1978) and RegA from Dictyostelium is a CAMPphosphodiesterase (Shaulsky et al., 1998). The sensing domains of the histidine protein kinases regulate the rate of autophosphorylation. The phosphorylated kinase in turn interacts with the receiver domain of its cognate response regulator, donating its phosphorylgroup to an invariant aspartate in the receiver domain. A phosphorylationinduced conformational change in the receiver is thought to modify the activities of associated response regulator output domains. Phosphorylation of response regulators with no output domains are thought to cause changes in affinity for target effector proteins, e.g. phosphorylation of CheY causes this isolated receiver domain to bind to the flagellar motor switch to cause a change in swimming direction that leads to chemotaxis (Welch et al., 1993; Alon et al., 1998; Scharf et al., 1998). There are other examples, however, where isolated receiver domains appear to function solely to pass phosphoryl groups between histidines in more complicated phosphorelay systems. For example, SpoOF in the Bacillus subtilis sporulation system passes phosphoryl groups from a histidine in the kinase KinA to a histidine in SpoOB (Hoch, 1995; Tzeng and Hoch, 1997). Phosphatase activities also play critical roles in regulating response regulator phosphorylation. They can be either located within the receiver domain, e.g. CheY (Sourjik and Schmitt, 1998) CheB (Stock and Surette, 1996), in the kinase domain, e.g. EnvZ (Igo et al., 1989; Kanamaru et al., 1989; Yang and Inouye, 1993; Dutta and Inouye, 1996) or require additional proteins, e.g. CheZ in chemotaxis (Hess et al., 1988b), and RapA, B in sporulation (Hoch, 1995; Reizer et al., 1997). Apart from the conserved kinase domain, histidine kinases vary substantially in design. They can be membrane bound or soluble, e.g. EnvZ is an integral membrane protein with two transmembrane helices framing a periplasmic sensing domain (Forst et al., 1987 and KinC of B. subtilis (Kobayashi et al., 1995; LeDeaux and Grossman, 1995) has two transmembrane helices but lacks an extended periplasmic domain. Kinases with four predicted transmembrane helices include KdpD (Zimmann et al., 1995) and FixL (Lois et al., 1993). Based on its hydrophobicity profile, there are at least eight transmembrane helices in UhpB (Friedrich and Kadner, 1987; Kadner, 1995), whereas CheA (Ridgway et al., 1977), DegS (Henner et al., 1988; Kunst et al., 1988; Tanaka and Kawata, 1988; Msadek et al., 1990, 1995), KinA (Perego et
Figure I Sequence alignments for the individual histidine protein k i n a (HPK) subfamilies. Flanking sequences between H-, X-, N-, D-, F- and G-boxes have been removed. Light shading marks hydrophobic residues: A, C, F, I, L, M and V. Generally, dark shading indicates conserved residues. In the X-box,dark shading indicates conserved charged residues. Above the alignments of the individual groups: ‘.’ variable residue, ‘-’ represents D or E, ‘+’ K or R, and ‘h’ a conserved hydrophobic amino acid. ‘y’ indicates any of the structurally similar residues H, F or Y; ‘B’ is D or N. The X-box is only shown for those HPK subfamilies, HPK,,,for which it could ambiguously be defined through sequence comparisons. It is therefore not shown for H P q , , .
8
E
i
M
EJ!
iT
u 0
s
s'
8
i
Figure 1 cont.
192
THORSTEN W. GREBE AND JEFFRY B. STOCK
Table 5 Classification of kinases. Left = kinase group; right = name of protein; for three-letter sequence identifiers, see Table 1 HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK la HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK la HPK la HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK l a HPK la HPK l a HPK la HPK la HPK l a HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK l a HPK l a HPK la HPK la HPK la HPK la HPK la HPK la HPK la, [Y for HI HPK la, [Y for HI HPK I& hybrid HPK la, hybrid HPK la, hybrid HPK la, hybrid HPK la, hybrid HPK la. hybrid HPK lai HPK lai HPK Iai
AfsQZ-sco BaeS-eco Cia-spn CyaC-w DspA-syn E1264624-mtu E307792Lcvi HpkAtma KdpD-cac KdpD-eco KinB-pi% LlkinA-lla LlkinB-lla LlkinC-lla Llkineorfl-lla MtrB-mtu
PhoR-bsu PhoR-eco PhoR-hin PhoR-kpn PhoR-mtu PhoR-vco ResE-bsu RprXbfr SenX3-mtu s110337-syn S110790-syn S110798-syn SII 1003-syn Slll124-syn S111475-syn Slr0533-syn Slrl324Lsyn SphS-ssp TrcS-mtu u70379-ssp Vans-efe Ycf26-por YclK-bsu YkoH-bsu YvrG-bsu YycG-hsu BdfA-bja DivL-ccr DhkD-ddi L29642-pfl Slr0222-syn Slr 1969-syn StyS I -psp TU~C 1-ttl G216076l-fsp RcaE-fdi
sars-ssp
HPK lai s110750-syn HPK lai Slr0484-syn Slr2099-syn HPK lai ArcB-hin HPK Ib HPK Ib Divl-ccr HPK Ib ERS-ath HPK Ih ERS-sly HPK Ib HepK-asp HPK Ib PleC-ccr HPK Ib S110474-syn HPK Ib s111353-syn SII 187I-syn HPK Ib SIII888-syn HPK Ib HPK Ib Slr0210-syn Slr1393Xsyn HPK Ih (Insert) HPK Ib, hybrid CaHKl-cal Chikl-cal HPK I b. hybrid HPK Ib, hybrid Chkljci HPK Ib, hybrid DhkA-ddi DhkB-ddi HPK Ib, hybrid DhkC-ddi HPK Ib, hybrid DokA-ddi HPK Ib, hybrid El3 10290-sco HPK Ib. hybrid E339934-spa HPK Ib, hybrid HPK Ib, hybrid ETR I -ath ETRI -sly HPK Ib. hybrid 132688313-bhu HPK 1b, hybrid HPK Ib, hybrid LuxQ-vha HPK Ih, hybrid Nikl-ncr HPK Ih, hybrid RcsC-eco HPK Ib, hybrid RcsCgmi HPK Ib. hybrid RssA-rpa HPK Ib, hybrid S111228-syn HPK I b, hyhrid S111672-syn HPK Ib. hybrid S111905-syn HPK Ib, hybrid slr1759-syn HPK Ih, hybrid Slr2098-syn HPK 1b. hybrid Slr2 I04-syn HPK Ih, hyhrid SpiR-sty HPK Ib, hybrid (insert) CaSLNl-cal HPK Ib. hybrid (insed) Slnl-sce HPK Ib, hybrid, H2 A@-pfl HPK Ib, hybrid, H2 ArcB-eco HPK Ib, hybrid, H2 BarA-eco BvgS-bpe HPK 1 b, hybrid, H2 HPK Ih, hyhrid. H2 DorS-rsh HPK Ih, hybrid, H2 EvgS-eco HPK Ih. hybrid, H2 LemA-pae HPK Ib. hybrid, H2 Led-psy HPK Ib, hybrid, H2 PelY-pvi HPK Ib, hybrid, H2 PheN-pto HPK Ih. hybrid, H2 RpfA-eca HPK Ib. hybrid, H2 RpfC-xca
HPK Ib, hybrid, H2 HPK I b, hybrid, H2 HPK Ic. hybrid HPK Ic. hybrid HPK Ic. hvbrid . .(noH-box) HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 20 HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2a HPK 2b HPK 2b HPK 2h HPK 2b HPK 2b HPK 2h HPK 2h HPK 2b HPK 3a HPK 3a HPK 3a HPK 3a HPK 3b HPK 3b HPK 3h HPK 3c HPK 3c HPK 3c HPK 3c HPK 3c HPK 3d HPK 3d HPK 3d HPK 3d, hybrid, H2 HPK 3e HPK 3e HPK 3e HPK 3e HPK 3f HPK 31 HPK 3f, [R for HI HPK 3g
RpfC-xor Tors-eco CKI 1-ath G2708752-alh 2435516-ath 30c-mtu Bass-eco COB-pfl Cops-eco COPSJSY Cops-sdu Cuts-sli czcs-reu E1215201-sco IrlS-bps OrfS-shy PcoS-eco PmrB-sty KagB-hja YgiY-eco YgiY-hin CpxA-eco EnvZ-eco EnvZxne PfeS-pae PirS-pae QrsA-chu RisS-bav RstB-eco AarG-pst G2314.530-hpy PhoQ-eco PopQ-rIe ChvG-atu ExoS-mie Slm640-syn CreC-eco G1033145-eco NisK-lla SpaK-bsu YchA-bsu CorS-ps y FlhS-pde VsrB-pso RteA-hte Acts-rme PrrB-rsh Re@-rca Regs-hja SII ISYO-syn Slr1805-syn Slr1414-syn Hod-ahy
193
THE HISTIDINE PROTEIN KINASE SUPERFAMILY
Table 5 cont. HPK 3g HPK 3g HPK 3g HPK 3g. RKHK HPK 3h HPK 3h HPK 3h, phytwhrome HPK 3i HPK 3i HPK 3i HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4 HPK 4
Hod-reu HupT-rca HupT-rsh AsgA-mxa G2649082-ah MTH444-mth Cph I-ssp YtsB-bsu YvcQ-hsu YxdK-hsu AtoS-eco DctB-rle DctB-rme DctS-rca DegM-bsp FixL-aca FixL-bja FixL-me FleS-pae FlrB-vch G2688706-hbu HknA-bth HksPl-aae HksP2-aae HksP4-aae HpkY-psy HydH-eco HydH-sty KinA-bsu King-bsu KinC-hsu NodV-bja NuB-ahr NtrB-bpa NtrB-eco NtrB-hse NtrB-pvu NtrB-rca NuB-rph NUB-tfe NuB-Val NtrY-aca NwsA-bja PgtB-sty PilS-mxa PilS-pae Sass-mxa StdSc-psp StyS-pfl StyS2-psp TodS-ppu TU~C~-~I YkrQ-bsu YkvD-bsu
HPK 4, hyhrid HPK 4, hybrid HPK 4, hyhrid HPK 5 HPK 5 HPK 5 HPK 5 HPK 5 HPK 5 HPK 5 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6 HPK 6, RR-HK HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK I HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 7 HPK 8 HPK 8 HPK 8 HPK 8 HPK 8 HPK 8 HPK 8 HPK 9 HPK 9
FixL-rle VirA-atu VirAL-atu CitA-kpn DcuS-eco DpiB-eco E1286185-sco YdhF-bsu YflR-hsu YufL-bsu G2648416-afu G2648833-afu G26489 10-afu G2649045-afu G2649099-afu G2649399-afu G