CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page i — #1
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 ...
270 downloads
2561 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page i — #1
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page ii — #2
CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING EDITED BY
DAVID G. PENNEY
Boca Raton London New York
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page iii — #3
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page iv — #4
Dedication ——————— I wish to dedicate this book first to my mother, Gertrude Ellen (Goodhew) Penney, always a source of support and encouragement, to my grandchildren, and to all of those victims of carbon monoxide poisoning who sought but did not find professional help for their suffering.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page v — #5
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page vi — #6
Preface Carbon Monoxide Poisoning is a new title covering further areas of the expansive field of carbon monoxide (CO) toxicology that were not covered in the first two books, Carbon Monoxide and Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, both edited by David G. Penney, PhD. Both were published by CRC Press, the first in 1996 and the second in 2000. This book is designed to be complementary to both earlier books, forging into new areas and following new themes. The scope of this book is even broader than the earlier two. The first book took a very scholarly approach, presenting the latest basic and medical science of CO toxicology in 13 chapters. The contents of that book remain current. The second book was broader in its approach, and while extending presentations of basic and medical science, added discussions of human CO exposure under specialized conditions and in geographic locations other than the United States, in 23 chapters. It also presents a large body of new data on both acute and chronic CO poisoning. This present, third book, Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, further extends these presentations both to new areas such as the law, rehabilitation, personal experience with CO poisoning, education of the public about CO using the World Wide Web, and so forth, and adds further new data on chronic CO poisoning. This book contains some unique features: 1. A critical look at the efficacy of hyperbaric oxygen therapy in decreasing the damage caused by CO poisoning 2. The use of exciting new scanning techniques in revealing damage from CO poisoning 3. The introduction of a handheld pulse-oximeter that reads COHb directly and noninvasively 4. New data showing the persistent health damage that can be caused by chronic CO poisoning 5. The dangers of CO poisoning possible in motor homes, recreational boats, and so on 6. The levels of ignorance regarding CO on the part of the general public Interest in the effects of carbon monoxide on human health has grown rapidly during the past 20+ years. Governmental agencies, private groups, and the public are concerned. While an old and familiar poison, CO remains the number one “poison” in our environment in terms of its “brain-killing” potential, and its potential for overall immediate and long-term health harm. The public and the medical community need to obtain quality information about the risks from CO and need the means to identify and manage victims of CO poisoning successfully. It is hoped that this book, and its two previous companions, will in some way be of value in meeting these challenges.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page vii — #7
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page viii — #8
Author David G. Penney, PhD, is a retired professor of physiology, who taught and conducted research on carbon monoxide at the School of Medicine, at Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan. He was at one time adjunct professor of occupational and environmental health in the School of Allied Health Professions at Wayne State University. He is also a retired director of general surgical research at Providence Hospital in Southfield, Michigan, where for 12 years he directed the scholarly activities of surgical residents and attending surgeons. Dr. Penney obtained his BSc degree from Wayne State University in 1963, and his MSc and PhD degrees from the University of California, Los Angeles, in 1966 and 1969, respectively. Before coming to Wayne State University in 1977, he was a faculty member at the University of Illinois, Chicago. With his wife, Linda Mae Penney, the couple have six children. Dr. Penney’s professional interests have been focused on carbon monoxide for over 37 years, in both animal models and in humans. His special interests center around chronic CO poisoning, education of the public about the dangers of CO poisoning, the diagnosis and management of CO poisoning victims, and the medicolegal aspects of CO toxicology. Dr. Penney has assisted many national and international government and nongovernment agencies in matters involving carbon monoxide. He was among the earliest consultants to the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in setting CO standards for outside air. He assisted the World Health Organization (WHO) in the late 1990s in setting similar standards for the world. He has worked with the Australian Medical Association (AMA) and with other concerned groups in Australia to attempt to stem the tide of suicides involving CO. Currently, Dr. Penney assists Underwriters Laboratory (UL) as a medical expert on CO in establishing standards for CO alarms and other gas-monitoring equipment, and major gas distributing companies in educating the public about the dangers of CO poisoning. Dr. Penney’s published works on CO include over 65 peer-reviewed research articles, several dozen other articles and abstracts, a number of review articles, book chapters, and three other books in print. At last count, Dr. Penney had more research articles and books published on the topic of CO toxicology than anyone else in the world. He has also published several other books on medical education and on Royal Oak history, and for some years wrote a column on local history for a hometown newspaper.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page ix — #9
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page x — #10
Acknowledgments I wish to thank all the authors, former patients, and all who have contributed to this book. It has been a long road and at times it seemed impossible. Now it is done. Thanks to everyone. I also wish to thank Wayne State University School of Medicine and my Department of Physiology chairman, Dr. Joseph Dunbar, for granting me the time off in 2005 to get the book off the ground. I of course thank CRC – Taylor and Francis Publishers and all their employees who have been wonderful to work with these past 12 years, in developing my three books on carbon monoxide. Finally, I wish to thank my wife Linda for her constant support in developing these books, hearing my complaints, providing inspiration and also some perspiration in getting the work done. I of course thank my mother, Gertrude, for her support, encouragement and even late night help with data entry.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xi — #11
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xii — #12
Contributors Rob Aiers
Kosmas Galatsis, Ph.D.
Envirotec (UK) Ltd. Hampshire, U.K.
Microelectronics Advanced Research Corporation Center on Functional Engineered Nano Architectonics University of California Los Angeles, California
Carol L. Armstrong, Ph.D., A.B.P.N. Division of Oncology The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Department of Neurology University of Pennsylvania Medical School Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Steve N.M. Collard, B.A., M.E.D. Adjunct Professor of Law Nova Southeastern University Valrico, Florida
David C. Cone, M.D. Division of Emergency Medicine Yale New Haven Hospital Yale University School of Medicine New Haven, Connecticut
Joseph A. Cramer Wyoming, Michigan
James F. Georgis, O.D. Optometry Clinic Pueblo, Colorado
James M. Gracey, Ed.D. Colorado Institute for Injury Rehabilitation, Inc. Denver, Colorado
Neil B. Hampson, M.D. Center for Hyperbaric Medicine Section of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Virginia Mason Medical Center Seattle, Washington
Jacqueline L. Cunningham, Ph.D. Department of Psychology The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Michael F. Hanzlick
Thomas M. Dydek, Ph.D., D.A.B.T., P.E.
Alastair W.M. Hay, Ph.D.
Dydek Toxicology Consulting Austin, Texas
Gas Dynamics Corporation St. Paul, Minnesota
Molecular Epidemiology Unit LIGHT Laboratories School of Medicine University of Leeds Leeds, U.K.
Peter G. Flachsbart, Ph.D., A.I.C.P.
Dennis A. Helffenstein, Ph.D.
Department of Urban and Regional Planning University of Hawaii at Manoa Honolulu, Hawaii
Colorado Neuropsychological Associates Colorado Springs, Colorado
Robert E. Engberg, B.S., P.E.
Hanzlick & Associates Highland Ranch, Colorado
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xiii — #13
Contributors
xiv
Gunnar Heuser, M.D., Ph.D.
Joshua A. Mott, Ph.D.
Neuromed and Neurotox Associates Santa Barbara, California Clinical Assistant Professor University of California, Los Angeles Los Angeles, California
CDC/CCID/NCIRD Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch National Center for Environmental Health Atlanta, Georgia
S. Gregory Hipskind, M.D., Ph.D. Department of Anthropology Western Washington University Bellingham, Washington
Ramona O. Hopkins, Ph.D. Psychology Department and Neuroscience Center Brigham Young University Provo, Utah
Gary Hutter, Ph.D. Meridian Engineering & Technology, Inc. Glenview, Illinois
David G. Penney, Ph.D. Wayne State University School of Medicine, and Providence Hospital and Medical Centers (retired) St. Augustine, Florida & Beulah, MI
Linda M. Penney St. Augustine, FL & Beulah, MI
Kevin J. Reilly, Jr.
Richard Karg, B.S., M.S.
Training Operations & Firefighter Diversified Security Solutions, Inc. Saddle Brook, New Jersey
R.J. Karg Associates Topsham, Maine
James W. Rhee, M.D.
Michael E. King, Ph.D. CDC/CCEHIP/NCEH Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch National Center for Environmental Health Atlanta, Georgia
Jerrold B. Leikin, M.D. Rush Medical College Chicago, Illinois and Evanston Northwestern Health Care Glenview, Illinois
Section of Emergency Medicine & Medical Toxicology The University of Chicago Chicago, Illinois
Frank Ricci New Haven City Fire Department New Haven, Connecticut
Carlos D. Scheinkestel, M.D. Monash University Melbourne, Australia
Jane Brown McCammon, B.S., M.S.
Robert E. Schreter, B.S., P.E.
Double Angel Foundation Broken Circle M Consulting, LLC Littleton, Colorado
R. Schreter and Associates, Inc. Roswell, Georgia
Peter Tikuisis, Ph.D. Ian L. Millar Monash University Melbourne, Australia
Human Modeling Group Defence Research & Development Canada Toronto, Ontario, Canada
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xiv — #14
Contributors
Christian Tomaszewski, M.S., M.D., F.A.C.E.P., F.A.C.M.T. Department of Emergency Medicine University of Pittsburgh Medical Center Hannad Medical Corporation Doha, Qatar
Suzanne R. White, M.D., F.A.C.M.T., F.A.C.E.P. Children’s Hospital of Michigan Regional Poison Control Center Department of Emergency Medicine Wayne State University School of Medicine Detroit, Michigan
xv
Stephen P. Willison, B.S., J.D. Willison & Hellman, P.C. Grand Rapids, Michigan
Wojtek B. Wlodarski, D.Sc., Ph.D., M.Sc. E.E. School of Electrical and Computer Systems Engineering Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xv — #15
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xvi — #16
Table of Contents Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xxi
Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide, 1996 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xxv
Chapter 1 Introduction to and Overview of the Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney
1
Chapter 2 Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peter G. Flachsbart Chapter 3 Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures. . . . . . . . . Robert E. Engberg Chapter 4 Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide into Mobile Homes, Recreational Vehicles, and Other Enclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Robert E. Schreter Chapter 5 Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field Protocol for Measuring CO Emissions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Richard Karg Chapter 6 Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents Involving Gas-Burning Appliances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Michael Hanzlick Chapter 7 Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jane McCammon
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xvii — #17
5
43
57
99
129
157
xviii
Contents
Chapter 8 Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection . . . . . . . . . Gary Hutter Chapter 9 Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States: A Review of National Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Michael E. King and Joshua A. Mott Chapter 10 Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kosmas Galatsis and Wojtek Wlodarski Chapter 11 Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond: Use of the World Wide Web in Saving Lives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rob Aiers
197
233
251
271
Chapter 12 Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Thomas M. Dydek
287
Chapter 13 Carbon Monoxide Detectors as Preventive Medicine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James W. Rhee and Jerrold B. Leikin
305
Chapter 14 Misconceptions About Carbon Monoxide. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney
313
Chapter 15 A Survey Study of Public Perceptions About Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney and Linda M. Penney
325
Chapter 16 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Suzanne R. White
341
Chapter 17 The Case for the Use of Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy in Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Christian Tomaszewski
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xviii — #18
375
Contents
xix
Chapter 18 Hyperbaric Oxygen for Acute Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Useful Therapy or Unfulfilled Promise? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carlos D. Scheinkestel and Ian L. Millar Chapter 19 A Challenge to the Healthcare Community: The Diagnosis of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney Chapter 20 Neuroimaging after Carbon Monoxide Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gunnar Heuser
391
437
449
Chapter 21 Recent Advances in Brain SPECT Imaging after Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 457 S. Gregory Hipskind Chapter 22 Neurocognitive and Affective Sequelae of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . Ramona O. Hopkins Chapter 23 Neurocognitive and Neurobehavioral Sequelae of Chronic Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: A Retrospective Study and Case Presentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dennis A. Helffenstein Chapter 24 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: A Case Series . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney Chapter 25 Functional and Developmental Effects of Carbon Monoxide Toxicity in Children . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carol L. Armstrong and Jacqueline Cunningham Chapter 26 Issues in Rehabilitation and Life Care Planning for Patients with Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James M. Gracey Chapter 27 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning with Yoked Prism Lenses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James F. Georgis
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xix — #19
477
495
551
569
591
619
xx
Contents
Chapter 28 Firefighters and Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kevin J. Reilly, Jr., Frank Ricci, and David Cone Chapter 29 The Purpose and the Process of Litigation in a Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stephen P. Willison
643
655
Chapter 30 Offering Expert Opinions in a Carbon Monoxide Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stephen P. Willison
671
Chapter 31 Injury Caused by Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Defining Monetary Damages Steve Collard
683
Chapter 32 My Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: A Victim’s Story . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Joseph A. Cramer
725
Chapter 33 Noninvasive Measurement of Blood Carboxyhemoglobin with Pulse CO-Oximetry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neil B. Hampson Chapter 34 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Exposure: How Much Do We Know About it?—an Update . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alastair W.M. Hay
739
745
Chapter 35 Essential Reference Tables, Graphs, and Other Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney
753
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
765
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xx — #20
Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide Toxicity 2000
Chapter 1 History of Carbon Monoxide Toxicology Dieter Pankow Chapter 2 Carbon Monoxide in Breath, Blood, and Other Tissues Hendrik J. Vreman, Ronald J. Wong, and David K Stevenson Chapter 3 Carbon Monoxide Detectors Richard Kwor Chapter 4 The Setting of Health-Based Standards for Ambient Carbon Monoxide and Their Impact on Atmospheric Levels James A. Raub Chapter 5 Effect of Carbon Monoxide on Work and Exercise Capacity in Humans Milan J. Hazucha Chapter 6 The Interacting Effects of Altitude and Carbon Monoxide James J. McGrath Chapter 7 Interactions Among Carbon Monoxide, Hydrogen Cyanide, Low Oxygen Hypoxia, Carbon Dioxide, and Inhaled Irritant Gases David A. Purser Chapter 8 Carbon Monoxide Poisoning and Its Management in the United States Neil B. Hampson
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxi — #21
Contents
xxii
Chapter 9 Death by Suicide Involving Carbon Monoxide around the World Pierre Baume and Michaela Skopek Chapter 10 Carbon Monoxide as an Unrecognized Cause of Neurasthenia: A History Albert Donnay Chapter 11 Update on the Clinical Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Suzanne R. White Chapter 12 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning in France Monique Mathieu-Nolf and Daniel Mathieu Chapter 13 Acute Carbon Monoxide Poisonings in Poland - Research and Clinical Experience Jerzy A. Sokal and Janusz Pach Chapter 14 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning in the United Kingdom Martin R. Hamilton-Farrell and John Henry Chapter 15 Carbon Monoxide Air Pollution and Its Health Impact on the Major Cities of China Qing Chen and Lihua Wang Chapter 16 Use of Scanning Techniques in the Diagnosis of Damage from Carbon Monoxide I.S. Saing Choi Chapter 17 Low-Level Carbon Monoxide and Human Health Robert D. Morris Chapter 18 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Poisoning David G. Penney Chapter 19 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Exposure: The CO Support Study Alistair WM. Hay, Susan Jaffer, and Debbie Davis
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxii — #22
Contents
Chapter 20 Neuropsychological Evaluation of the Carbon Monoxide-Poisoned Patient Dennis A. Helffenstein Chapter 21 Pediatric Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Suzanne R. White Chapter 22 Carbon Monoxide Production, Transport, and Hazard in Building Fires Frederick W. Mowrer and Vincent Brannigan Chapter 23 Approaches to Dealing with Carbon Monoxide in the Living Environment Thomas H. Greiner and Charles V. Schwab
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxiii — #23
xxiii
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxiv — #24
Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide 1996
Chapter 1 Carbon Monoxide Analysis Roger L. Wabeke Chapter 2 Carbon Monoxide Formation Due to Metabolism of Xenobiotics Dieter Pankow Chapter 3 Modeling the Uptake and Elimination of Carbon Monoxide Peter Tikuisis Chapter 4 Cerebrovascular Effects of Carbon Monoxide Mark A. Helfaer and Richard J. Traystman Chapter 5 Pulmonary Changes Induced by the Administration of Carbon Monoxide and Other Compounds in Smoke Daniel L. Traber and Darien W Bradford Chapter 6 Effects of Carbon Monoxide Exposure on Developing Animals and Humans David G. Penney Chapter 7 Carbon Monoxide - From Tool to Neurotransmitter Nanduri R. Prabhakar and Robert S. Fitzgerald Chapter 8 Toxicity of Carbon Monoxide: Hemoglobin vs. Histotoxic Mechanisms Claude A. Piantadosi
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxv — #25
Contents
xxvi
Chapter 9 Carbon Monoxide-Induced Impairment of Learning, Memory, and Neuronal Dysfunction Masayuki Hiramatsu, Tsutomu Kameyama, and Toshitaka Nabeshima Chapter 10 Behavioral Effects of Carbon Monoxide Exposure: Results and Mechanisms Vernon A. Benignus Chapter 11 Delayed Sequelae in Carbon Monoxide Poisoning and the Possible Mechanisms Eric Kindwall Chapter 12 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Suzanne R. White Chapter 13 Options for Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, Including Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy Stephen R. Thom
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxvi — #26
1
Introduction to and Overview of the Field David G. Penney
CONTENTS References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4
I have designed this book to complete the series on carbon monoxide (CO) begun with Carbon Monoxide, 19961 and continued with Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, 2000.2 This and the second book are NOT new editions of the first book, as has often been assumed. While CO may seem a very narrow subject area, it finds its way into many diverse disciplines and its literature is vast. This third book, Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, completes the trilogy and should become a standard reference source on CO for years to come. The new book covers areas not previously presented, including rehabilitation, education of the public using the WWW, litigation involving CO poisoning, economic loss assessment, and firefighting. There are areas of update, such as the chapter by Dr. Suzanne White, on diagnosis and management. There are two chapters in which the authors take opposing views, one stating the case for use of hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) by Dr. Christian Tomaszewski and against the use of HBOT by Dr. Carlos Scheinkestel. One chapter deals with toxicology investigation (i.e., forensic) procedures. A series of chapters detail the risk of CO poisoning from kitchen ranges, recreational trailers and motor homes, and recreational powerboats. Three chapters cover the very important area of neuropsychological evaluation of adults and children following CO poisoning. The chapter by Dr. Dennis Helffenstein presents new data on a case series of patients that had sustained chronic CO poisoning. I have written a companion chapter to his in which a retrospective review of 61 chronically CO-poisoned patients were symptomatically evaluated (Chapter 24). Better Education of Physicians: This is essential if CO-poisoned patients are to be properly diagnosed and treated in the future. Several years ago I overheard a prominent emergency room physician say, “the standard of care for CO poisoning in the U.S. is less than the standard of care.” I estimate that in 80% of CO cases reviewed, one, two, or more mistakes were made in diagnosing and/or treating CO-poisoned patients. This may involve misdiagnosis, dependence on faulty pulse-oximetry data, administering NBO with the wrong 1
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 1 — #1
2
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
equipment (e.g., nasal prongs), failure to order HBOT when it was needed and possible, discharge of patients while still symptomatic, and so forth. Physicians should also be informed of the possible serious permanent health harm that chronic or lower-level acute CO poisoning can cause if not diagnosed immediately and treated fully. From my perspective, the CO cases that result from acute poisoning and those most likely to reach the media are actually the smaller fraction of all CO poisonings, while the chronic (i.e., occult) CO poisonings make up by far the largest fraction, and probably result in the most injuries, but they are the very group that physicians are least trained to properly deal with. Better Education of the Public: The public too needs education about the dangers presented by CO exposure. My chapter presenting the results of surveys of public perceptions of CO in Michigan and Florida shows this. While almost everyone knows that CO is a deadly poison, substantial fractions (sometimes most) of the adult and juvenile population cannot intelligently evaluate the risk of CO from automobiles, propane radiant heaters, generators, and recreational powerboats. In some situations people are overly cautious in a given situation, but in other situations people vastly underestimate the risk of injury and death. Youth, as opposed to adults, are particularly uninformed. New Approaches to Treating Acute, Severe CO Poisoning: There appears to be very little new in treating acute severe CO poisoning. We cannot decide for sure whether HBOT is more effective in reducing neurologic sequelae, even though it has been used for approximately 50 years. The pros and cons chapters on HBOT provide detailed discussions of many aspects of the situation, and a few ideas about possible new approaches. The bright light in this area is almost certainly the new generation of pulse-ox devices that read COHb directly and noninvasively. See Dr. Neil Hampson’s chapter about the testing of this device. Requiring Proper Warnings on Combustion Equipment: The lack of proper and adequate warnings on equipment that do, or under foreseeable conditions might, emit harmful or lethal amounts of CO remains a real problem. People continue to die because warnings on combustion devices are not obvious, explicit and direct, and not on the device itself. Warnings in operating manuals should be continued and improved, but they alone are insufficient because manuals are usually separated from the device. Warnings on the device must tell the user what might occur in using the device a certain way. Statements such as “provide adequate ventilation” are useless. The warning must specify where and when not to use the device, and for how long. Warnings in the United States should be written in both English and Spanish, along with standard prohibition symbols. Some of the devices this applies to include portable generators, cement saws, lawn mowers, pressure washers, scissor-lifts, kerosene heaters, propane-radiant heaters, lamps and cook stoves, powerboats, charcoal grills and hibachis, and so forth. See Dr. Hutter’s excellent chapter on warnings.
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 2 — #2
Introduction to and Overview of the Field
Rethinking Work Guidelines for Carbon Monoxide that Reflect the Science: Another area that needs immediate attention is threshold limit standards for inhalation of CO. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and World Health Organization (WHO) after extensive study and deliberation some years ago set the 8-h standard at 9 ppm, or 10 mg/m3 for outside air. On the other hand, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) have set different standards for the work environment. We know that people with coronary artery disease, congestive heart failure, asthma, and a state of fetal development are often members of the workforce, and represent a more sensitive, higher risk subgroup of the general population. It is also well known that people, even those with no obvious risk factors, vary widely in their tolerance of CO. Why then should the standards be so different—9 ppm (EPA, WHO) versus 50 ppm (OSHA) for the same species? This is a 5-1/2 fold difference! I believe it is time we in the toxicology community re-examine ambient air CO concentration work standards, and make decisions for new standards based only on the best science. Realization that Brain Damage Resulting from CO Poisoning Is not Dependent on COHb and/or Severity of Poisoning: New studies make it clear what many of us have believed for some time based on experience, that brain damage from CO poisoning is only very poorly correlated with the severity of the poisoning by whatever criteria, even the COHb saturation. Some people with very severe poisoning and/or high initial COHb values make remarkable recoveries, while some with what appears to be minimal poisoning, and even on occasion, near normal COHb when measured, incur substantial damage. Clearly, loss of consciousness is not required for the development of neurologic sequelae, although I sometimes hear the less well-informed say that it is. I believe everyone agrees that a longer (i.e., soaking) exposure is more detrimental than a short one, but strangely some still insist that chronic, lower-level CO exposure can cause no permanent harm. Other markers for brain damage have been proposed such as acidosis, gait/balance/clumsiness on presentation, and release of cellular enzymes, but it remains unclear how useful they are. Carbon Monoxide Disaster Management: Release of CO during certain kinds of disasters could pose significant problems. Fire almost invariably gives off CO as an incomplete combustion product, and fire is a larger or a smaller component in most disasters, especially those that might be instigated by terrorists. It is unclear to me whether any overall planning has been done by agencies of the government with respect to CO. Firefighters regularly encounter CO in the work they do, and have equipment such as self-contained breathing apparatus to deal with it. See the chapter on firefighting by Mr. Reilly, Mr. Ricci, and Dr. Cone. Other concerns for human health that may not yet be fully addressed include indoor car, monster truck, and motocross events, work in coal mines, warehouses, enclosed construction sites, and so forth where significant CO is generated by combustion devices. Since it is dangerous and
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 3 — #3
3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
4
foolhardy to run a portable generator inside a garage or house, why is it not dangerous to human health to run several monster trucks with huge gasolinefueled engines lacking catalytic converters inside a covered sports stadium? The recent Sago Mine disaster where a dozen men died slowly, mainly from CO poisoning, points out the need for adequate emergency equipment that would allow men to live for extended periods of time in the presence of lethal CO air concentrations. Autostarters—are they safe? How often will car engines be started inadvertently (by children, otherwise by mistake) in a closed garage, leading to injury or death from CO poisoning? The wonder is that CO has been with man since prehistory, probably since we first began using fire. Other scourges such as plague, cholera, typhus, smallpox, and so forth are gone, at least from the developed world, whereas this simple, small molecule, CO, continues to afflict us, and probably will, at least as long as we are wedded to the “carbon energy cycle.” I hope you enjoy this book and will use it with its earlier brothers, Carbon Monoxide (1996)1 and Carbon Monoxide Toxicity (2000).2
References 1. Penney, D.G., ed. Carbon Monoxide, CRC Press, NY, 1996, 296 pp. 2. Penney, D.G., ed. Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, CRC Press, NY, 2000, 560 pp.
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 4 — #4
2
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide Peter G. Flachsbart
CONTENTS 2.1 2.2
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Standards and Guidelines for Exposure to Ambient Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Trends in Carbon Monoxide Emissions and Ambient Air Quality . . . . . . . 2.4 Human Exposure to Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Microenvironmental Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1 Residential Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1.1 Nonfatal Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1.2 Fatal Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.2 Occupational Exposures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.3 Shopping Center Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4 Recreational Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4.1 Exposures on Recreational Vehicles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4.2 Exposures at Indoor Sporting Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5 Commuter Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.1 Defective Exhaust Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.2 Parking Garages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.3 Service Stations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.4 Drive-Up Facilities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.5 Airbag Deployment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.6 Motor Vehicle Emission Standards. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 Exposure to Methylene Chloride . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6.1 Nonoccupational Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6.2 Occupational Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8 Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6 7 8 10 17 17 18 19 20 22 23 23 24 25 26 29 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 32 34 34 5
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 5 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
6
2.1 INTRODUCTION Carbon monoxide (CO) is a gas commonly produced by incomplete combustion of fuels containing carbon atoms. Many people use these fuels (i.e., coal, gasoline, kerosene, natural gas, oil, propane, and wood) around the globe. As a result, CO is ubiquitous in the atmosphere. However, without sophisticated instruments, a person is unable to detect CO, because the gas is not irritating and has no color, odor, or taste. Moreover, the gas is a potential health hazard, because exposure to CO can starve critical body organs, especially the brain and heart, of oxygen. Once inside the lungs, CO molecules pass easily into the bloodstream and compete with oxygen for hemoglobin (Hb) in the red blood cells. About 95% of the absorbed CO readily binds with Hb to form carboxyhemoglobin (COHb), because the affinity of Hb for CO is over 200 times stronger than it is for oxygen. Thus, the percentage of total Hb in the blood that is in the form of COHb is a biomarker of CO exposure.1 The health effects of CO, which are a function of its concentration and the duration of exposure, range from subtle to severe. They include neurobehavioral, cardiovascular, and developmental effects, observed at low levels of CO exposure, to unconsciousness and death, which occur after acute exposure to high CO concentrations. Lethal CO exposures are usually linked to CO concentrations greater than 1000 parts per million (ppm) by volume. Coma, convulsions, cardiopulmonary arrest, and death have been observed when COHb levels reach 50%, although death from CO poisoning is frequently reported at far lower COHb saturations. The exact COHb concentrations that trigger acute and chronic health effects in different people differ widely. Sublethal levels of CO may cause neurological-type symptoms, including fatigue, headache, nausea, vomiting, deficit in short-term memory, to name a few. Exposures to these CO concentrations are often misdiagnosed as viral illness, clinical depression, and so forth. Still lower CO exposures (i.e., those producing less than 10% COHb) may not be associated under certain circumstances with overt symptoms.2,3 This broad range of effects makes CO relevant to people concerned with ambient air quality management as well as officials responsible for protecting public health and safety. Ambient air quality standards are the foundation of air quality management programs in many countries worldwide. Such standards typically specify maximum permissible concentrations in ambient air for certain pollutants. To achieve ambient standards in the United States, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) implemented progressively tighter tailpipe emission standards for motor vehicles. As a result, these standards have substantially reduced ambient CO concentrations in most metropolitan areas of the U.S. and have had other collateral benefits. For example, the nation had 11,667 fewer deaths from accidental CO poisoning between 1968 and 1998, according to a study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDCP).4 Still, an average of 480 U.S. residents died each year during 2001–2002 from nonfire-related unintentional CO poisoning. In addition, an estimated 15,200 persons, that is, people with confirmed or possible nonfire-related CO exposure or poisoning, were treated annually in U.S. hospital emergency rooms.5 In fact, more than 50% of all fatal poisonings reported in many countries may be attributable to CO, because these cases are under-reported or misdiagnosed by medical professionals.2
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 6 — #2
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
7
This chapter explores reasons behind the paradox of declining ambient CO concentrations in urban areas of the United States coupled with persistent injuries and fatalities from CO poisoning. The chapter is organized around the superposition principle of CO exposure, which may help to explain this paradox. This principle holds that CO concentrations at any given point in time and space consist of both ambient and microenvironmental components. The next section takes a closer look at ambient CO concentrations in urban areas. The chapter then describes how the development of portable monitors enabled measurements of personal exposure to CO concentrations in places where people perform routine daily activities. Since these activities often occur in specific microenvironments, the chapter then describes typical CO exposures where people live, work, shop, play and commute, and factors that affect these exposures. The last section offers some concluding thoughts.
2.2 STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES FOR EXPOSURE TO AMBIENT CONCENTRATIONS OF CARBON MONOXIDE The Clean Air Act (CAA) of 1963 was amended by the U.S. Congress in 1970, 1977, and 1990. The 1977 and 1990 versions largely reaffirmed the course set by the 1970 amendments.6 Under the 1970 CAA amendments, the U.S. EPA established the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) and set deadlines for their attainment. The current NAAQS reflect EPA’s scientific judgments about maximum allowable ambient concentrations and averaging times for certain “criteria” air pollutants including CO. Criteria air pollutants are those that could reasonably endanger public health or welfare. The 1970 and 1990 CAA amendments also mandated stringent motor vehicle emission standards as a means to achieve the NAAQS for CO and other air pollutants that have been linked to mobile sources. Air pollutant concentrations can be expressed either as ppm or as milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3 ) of air. Many of the studies reviewed in this chapter refer to the NAAQS for guidance on allowable limits of CO exposure. The EPA promulgated identical primary and secondary NAAQS for CO on April 30, 1971. The primary standards specify a level of air quality sufficient to protect public health and the secondary standards are intended to protect public welfare. The standards include “an adequate margin of safety” to reflect scientific uncertainties related to measurement of the effects of air pollutant exposure in the population. In 1985, EPA rescinded the secondary standard for CO, but retained two primary standards: 9 ppm (10 mg/m3 ) as an 8-h average and 35 ppm (40 mg/m3 ) as a 1-h average. Each standard may be exceeded once per year in an air quality control region (AQCR) without violating the standard.7 The NAAQS for CO are designed to keep COHb levels below 2% in the blood of 99.9% of nonsmoking healthy adults and people who belong to probable high-risk groups. Smokers are excluded because they may exhale more CO into the air than they are inhaling from the ambient environment. The high-risk groups include the elderly; pregnant women; fetuses; young infants; and those suffering from anemia or certain other blood, cardiovascular, or respiratory diseases. People at greatest risk
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 7 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
8
from exposures to ambient CO levels are those with coronary artery disease. Some of these people suffer myocardial ischemia as identified by ST-segment depression, during exercise when their COHb levels ≥ 2.4%.7 The symptoms of this disease are spasmodic attacks of chest pain (angina pectoris) caused by insufficient oxygen in the heart muscles. Controlled laboratory studies are needed to observe these health effects, because the COHb levels are at or near the lower margin of detection of current instruments.8 Although annual death rates from heart disease have been declining since 1980, heart disease is still America’s leading cause of death.9 Coronary artery disease reduces a person’s circulatory capacity, which is particularly critical during exercise when muscles need more oxygen. Given the widespread prevalence and lack of awareness of coronary heart disease, Godish3 argues that a significant number of people still may be at risk from CO exposure, even if ambient CO concentrations do not exceed the 8-h NAAQS for CO. The World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines for CO (see below) are also relevant to this discussion. Relative to the NAAQS for CO in the U.S., these guidelines have an identical 8-h concentration but a lower 1-h concentration. Unlike the NAAQS, the guidelines specify maximum concentrations for two shorter time spans (30 min and 15 min).10,11 Maximum Concentrations
Averaging Times
9 ppm (10 mg/m3 ) 25 ppm (30 mg/m3 ) 50 ppm (60 mg/m3 ) 90 ppm (100 mg/m3 )
8h 1h 30 min 15 min
WHO’s guidelines are intended to prevent blood levels of COHb from exceeding 2.5–3% in nonsmoking populations even when a person engages in relatively heavy work. Romieu12 reported that average COHb levels are about 1.2–1.5% in the general population and from 3% to 4% in the blood of cigarette smokers.
2.3 TRENDS IN CARBON MONOXIDE EMISSIONS AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY The CAA amendments have substantially reduced nationwide CO emissions, even as other socio-economic indicators of growth have increased. For example, between 1970 and 2002, nationwide emissions of CO fell 48%, despite national increases of 38% in population, 155% in vehicle miles of travel (VMT), and 164% in gross domestic product.13 The rapid growth of VMT has been attributed to the decentralization of jobs and housing within urban regions during the post World War II era.14 The CAA amendments have also reduced ambient CO concentrations in urban areas of the United States. The U.S. EPA determines compliance with the NAAQS based on measurements of ambient air quality made by a nationwide network of fixed-site monitoring (FSM) stations. Ambient concentrations of air pollutants are
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 8 — #4
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
9
typically measured in air “external to buildings, to which the general public has access.”15 In urban areas, most ambient stations that measure CO concentrations are located near roadways.16 These stations use nondispersive infrared reference (NDIR) spectrometry to measure ambient CO concentrations. Monitoring instruments based on the NDIR method are large, complex and expensive, and require a vibration-free, air-conditioned facility for the production of accurate and reliable data. The nationwide network consists of state and local air monitoring stations (SLAMS), which send data to EPA’s Aerometric Information Retrieval System (now Air Quality System) within six months of acquisition.17 Several stations within the SLAMS network belong to a network of national air monitoring stations (NAMS) to enable national assessments of air quality. FSM stations typically reveal two peaks in ambient CO concentrations. These peaks usually coincide with periods of congested rush-hour traffic.7 For that reason, some exposure analysts consider CO to be a signature air pollutant for mobile sources. On a nationwide basis, the EPA’s annual emissions inventory revealed that highway vehicles accounted for 62.8% of the 93.7 million tons of CO emitted from all sources except fires in 2003.13 Regional inventories show that motor vehicles account for even higher percentages of all CO emissions released into the ambient air. For example, CO emissions from motor vehicles ranged from 78% of all CO emissions in Fairbanks, Alaska, to 96% of all CO emissions in Phoenix, Arizona. EPA classified both cities as having “serious” levels of ambient CO concentrations in 1999.18 An ambient station is considered to be in violation (i.e., nonattainment) of the NAAQS for CO, if it records a nonoverlapping average concentration that exceeds either the 1-h or 8-h standard more than once per calendar year. The historical record shows that cities have had more difficulty satisfying the 8-h standard than the 1-h standard. For the 8-h standard, the nonoverlapping average omits other high values that occur within 8 h of the first value. Also, values of 9.5 ppm, or greater, are counted as exceeding the 8-h standard due to the standard’s rounding convention. Maximum 8-h average CO concentrations typically exceeded 30 ppm when continuous monitors were first installed in some U.S. cities in the early 1960s. When EPA promulgated the NAAQS for CO in 1971, 91.4% of 58 ambient monitors recorded violations of the 8-h standard and 12.1% of 58 stations recorded violations of the 1-h standard.16 In 1996, EPA’s Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS) reported that CO levels exceeded the NAAQS in seven counties, which had a combined population of more than 12.7 million people.19 The CAA amendments require states to develop plans to achieve and maintain ambient air quality that satisfies the NAAQS. To prepare these plans, states inventory emissions in each AQCR for a baseline year and determine the necessary emission reductions to achieve the NAAQS. Pursuant to the 1977 CAA amendments, many states established inspection and maintenance (I/M) programs as required by their plans for those regions that were in nonattainment of the NAAQS. An AQCR must satisfy the CO NAAQS for two consecutive years to be considered in attainment by EPA. States must submit plans to EPA showing how the region will maintain that attainment for at least 10 years. As of March, 2006, OAQPS reported that there were 38 CO “maintenance areas” in the United States encompassing 89 counties with a combined population of 46.8 million people.20
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 9 — #5
10
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
Since 1995, 11 cities have reported violations of the 8-h standard and no monitor has reported a violation of the 1-h standard.16 Violations appear to persist in areas with meteorological and/or topographical handicaps. Meteorological handicaps make it particularly difficult for cities to satisfy the standard, because of the stochastic nature of ambient air pollutant concentrations. For example, violations of the NAAQS for CO in Fairbanks, Alaska, have been attributed to stagnant air masses during winter months. The atmosphere is more stable in Fairbanks during winter, because less sunlight causes ground-level temperature inversions to occur more frequently. Also, less air pollutant dispersion occurs in winter, because winds are milder and mountains surrounding the city hinder horizontal dispersion.16 As of March 2006, the EPA had classified five American cities (El Paso, Texas; Las Vegas and Reno, Nevada; the Los Angeles South Coast Air Basin, California; and Missoula, Montana) as urban areas that were in nonattainment of the NAAQS for CO. They represented eight counties with a total population of about 15.4 million people.21 Compared to 1996, there was one more county in nonattainment of the NAAQS for CO by 2006, and the total population living in such areas had increased by 21.3%.
2.4 HUMAN EXPOSURE TO CARBON MONOXIDE The study of population exposure is multidisciplinary and the definition of personal exposure has evolved over time. A recent definition states that exposure is the contact between an agent and a target at a specified contact boundary, defined as a surface in space containing at least one exposure point, that is, a point at which contact occurs. According to this definition, an inhaled CO molecule (the agent) reaches a human (the target) at the lining of the lung (the contact boundary), where CO exchange takes place between air and blood.22 Actual studies of CO exposure use small-scale portable monitors to measure CO concentrations within a few feet of a person’s nasal and oral cavities. These studies assume that the air surrounding the person is well mixed and that measured CO concentrations in that air represent the person’s actual exposure from CO inhalation. Besides inhalation exposure to CO, metabolic degradation of many drugs, solvents (e.g., methylene chloride), and other compounds of CO can elevate levels of COHb in a person’s blood. Because the endogenous production of CO from drugs and solvents may continue for several hours, it can prolong any cardiovascular stress from COHb. Moreover, the maximum COHb level from endogenous CO production can last up to twice as long as COHb levels caused by comparable exposures to exogenous CO.23,24 Hence, this chapter also discusses the literature on exposure to methylene chloride. Figure 2.1 illustrates an individual’s air pollutant exposure over time. In this figure, the function Ci (t) describes the CO concentration to which an individual i is exposed at any point in time t. Ott defined this event as the instantaneous exposure of an individual.25 The shaded area under the curve represents the accumulation of instantaneous exposures over some period of time (t1 − t0 ). This area also is equal to the integral of the air pollutant concentration function, Ci (t), between t0 and t1 . Ott defined the quantity represented by this area as the integrated exposure. An exposure analyst can derive the average concentration to which a person is exposed
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 10 — #6
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
11
Concentration
Ci (t )
t0
t1 Time
FIGURE 2.1 Exposure of person i to air pollutant concentration (C) as a function of time t.
by dividing the person’s integrated exposure by the period of integration (t1 − t0 ). This average concentration is sometimes referred to as the average exposure. To compare the average concentration with an established air quality standard, the period of integration should equal the averaging period of the standard. This concept of exposure thus combines two parameters, the air pollutant concentration and the time duration of exposure to the air pollutant. An exposure analyst assumes that these two parameters are directly proportional to the dosage of CO in the body, as represented by the level of COHb in the blood stream, and ultimately to health outcomes. Prior to the use of portable monitoring devices, exposure analysts relied on ambient data from FSM stations in urban areas to estimate population exposure. Such data were used to provide crude estimates of population exposure to CO concentrations that violated the NAAQS. For example, the President’s Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) did a crude estimate of population exposure to CO in the late 1970s.26 This method is based on data collected for each county in the United States. The estimate is derived as follows: TPE =
n
(pi )(di )
(2.1)
i=1
where TPE = the total population exposure in the United States (person-days) = the resident population of county i (persons) pi di = the number of days in a calendar year that violations of the NAAQS for CO are observed in county i (days) n = the total number of counties in the United States in a given year
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 11 — #7
12
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
For 1978, the CEQ estimated that the nation’s total population exposure above the 1-h NAAQS for CO of 35 ppm was 2.80 billion person-days. This represented about 3.7% of the total possible exposures of 75.555 billion person-days, which was derived by multiplying an estimated 207 million U.S. residents in 1978 times 365 days in a year.26 CEQ’s method was a crude estimate of total population exposure, because the estimate rested on three major assumptions: 1. The CO concentrations measured by the county’s fixed-site monitors were representative of concentrations to which residents were actually exposed. If a county had more than one fixed-site monitor, then the monitor with the worst CO concentration represented the exposure of all residents in the county. 2. Residents did not leave the county on days that violations of the NAAQS for CO occurred for that county. 3. There were no violations of the NAAQS for CO in counties that were not monitored (e.g., rural counties). Several scientific studies have questioned the validity of the first two assumptions as discussed below. The first assumption implies that ambient CO concentrations are spatially homogeneous throughout a county. A study in the early 1970s questioned the ability of FSM stations to accurately represent human exposure to ambient CO concentrations. Using large Tedlar™ bags filled by a constant flow pump over 5-min periods, Ott collected 1128 CO concentrations at “breathing height” at outdoor locations in San Jose, California, on weekdays between October 1970 and March 1971.27 Of 438 samples collected on 21 dates while walking along sidewalks of congested downtown streets, 60% were above values measured concurrently at the nearest FSM station. The correlation between the “walking samples” and FSM values was positive, but low (r = 0.20). On 2 of 7 days, the sidewalk concentrations (13 and 14.2 ppm) averaged over an 8-h period were well above the corresponding concentrations (4.4 and 6.2 ppm, respectively) reported for the FSM station. Overall, the 8-h average CO concentrations for the 7 days ranged between 1.4 and 3 times the values observed simultaneously at the FSM station. The highest values were in late December when streets were heavily congested with traffic due to Christmas shopping.28 The San Jose study confirmed the hypothesis that FSM stations did not represent the CO exposures of a person walking in outdoor settings of a major city. Since the San Jose study measured the CO exposure of only one person, other studies tested the hypothesis for larger groups of people. Some of these studies focused on commuters, because CO is a signature air pollutant of motor vehicle tailpipe emissions. For example, Cortese and Spengler29 recruited 66 nonsmoking volunteers who lived in different parts of the metropolitan area of Boston, Massachusetts. Each volunteer carried an Ecolyzer monitor attached to a Simpson recorder for 3–5 days between October 1974 and February 1975. The study reported that the mean of all commuter exposures (11.9 ppm) was about twice the concurrent concentration measured at six FSM stations (6 ppm). Automobile commuters had exposures nearly twice that of
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 12 — #8
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
13
transit users, and about 1.6 times that of people who did “split-mode” commuting, which involved both auto and transit. The first assumption of the CEQ method of exposure estimation also raises the following question: To what extent do ambient CO levels reflect the CO concentrations to which people are exposed indoors? Early studies of human activity patterns in America30 and other industrialized countries31 have consistently shown that people spend most of their time indoors. Several studies published in the early 1970s addressed this question.32−34 Each study examined the relationship between indoor and outdoor CO concentrations. In the absence of indoor sources, these studies found that indoor CO concentrations of office buildings tended to follow outdoor CO levels with some degree of time lag and with a tendency not to reach either the extreme high or low values that were found outdoors. The General Electric study also reported that CO concentrations were larger indoors than outdoors at heights greater than 100 ft above the roadway, due to entrapment of CO within the building.33 To simplify the exposure calculation, the CEQ assumed that each person spent 24 h at home, because the method relied on household data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. The CEQ method also assumed that people did not travel outside the area represented by the FSM station. People who live in cities spend a significant amount of personal time in pursuits away from the home. In a study of metropolitan Washington, DC, residents in 1968, Chapin found that the hours spent away from home, on the average, ranged from 6.33 h on Sunday to 10.64 h on Friday.30 In other words, people spent between 26.4% and 44.3% of their day away from home. Chapin also reported that people travel an average of 14.2 miles per day, which suggested that people moved between areas represented by different FSM stations over the course of the day. By the early 1980s, additional studies raised further questions as to the ability of FSM stations to represent the CO exposures of the public.35,36 As stated previously, FSM stations use the NDIR method to measure ambient CO concentrations. Because NDIR monitors are not portable, they cannot be used to measure CO exposure as a person performs routine daily activities. The advent of microelectronics during the 1970s enabled considerable progress to be made in the development of reliable, compact, mobile air quality monitoring instruments. The most dramatic of these were the new miniaturized personal exposure monitors (PEMs) as described by Wallace and Ott.37 These instruments could go nearly anywhere, as they were equipped with batteries and shoulder straps. The utility of PEMs for measuring personal CO exposure was demonstrated in several early studies. These included a study of automobile commuters in Los Angeles during the summer of 1973,38 and field surveys of personal exposure in many commercial settings of several California cities between November 1979 and July 1980.39 Continued technical improvements of PEMs stimulated scholarly interest in how to use them in studies of personal and population exposure. Both direct and indirect methods in the use of PEMs have evolved. The direct method distributes PEMs to ordinary people who record their CO exposures and activities directly using either a paper diary or an electronic data logger. For example, Cortese and Spengler used this method in their survey of Boston commuters.29 A second method relies on indirect estimates of population exposure, based on the
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 13 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
14
following model advocated by Fugas40 and Duan.41 Ei =
n
ck (tik )
(2.2)
k=1
where Ei = the total integrated exposure of person i over some time period of interest (e.g., 24 h) ck = the air pollutant concentration in microenvironment type k tik = the amount of time spent by person i in microenvironment type k n = the number of microenvironment types encountered by person i over the period of interest. The total exposure of a population can be determined by summation of the integrated exposures of individuals who are members of that population. The indirect method assumes that an individual’s total exposure to air pollution is a function of location and time. It follows that variation in the total exposure of an individual occurs because air pollution concentrations vary from one location to another and because time spent in different locations varies substantially from person to person. The indirect method postulates the existence of “microenvironments” in which a person is exposed to an air pollutant at a given concentration over a fixed period of time. Duan described a microenvironment as a “chunk of air space with homogeneous pollutant concentration.”41 Because of the potentially large number of microenvironments, Duan suggested that similar ones should be grouped, either by location (e.g., indoor or outdoor) or activity performed at a location (e.g., residential or commercial) into “microenvironment types.” Under the CAA, the U.S. EPA has authority to perform periodic reviews of the criteria that support the NAAQS. In the early 1980s, EPA scientists developed a riskanalysis framework to support its reviews of the NAAQS for CO.42,43 This framework required estimates of the percentage of an urban population that was exposed to CO concentrations that exceeded the NAAQS. The need for these estimates was partly related to EPA’s proposal to change the form of the primary standard from deterministic to statistical.44 In response to this need, the EPA supported development of several large-scale population models of CO exposure in the early 1980s. These models included the Simulation of Human Activity and Pollutant Exposure (SHAPE) model and the NAAQS Exposure Model (NEM). Subsequently, the EPA supported development of the probabilistic NEM for CO (pNEM/CO) and the Air Pollutants Exposure Model (APEX). To provide data for these models, the EPA funded both direct and indirect studies of urban population exposure. The indirect studies included measurements of CO in various microenvironments and a nationwide survey of human activity patterns as described later. EPA’s direct studies took measurements of the daily CO exposures of the noninstitutionalized, nonsmoking adult populations (ages 18–70 years) living in two metropolitan areas of the United States. The surveys were performed using portable CO exposure monitors equipped with data loggers to reduce the data-collection
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 14 — #10
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
15
burden on the population. Field surveys of 454 residents of Denver, Colorado, and 714 residents of Washington, DC, occurred during the fall of 1982 and winter of 1983. Study participants carried PEMs equipped with data loggers. They also kept diaries for 48 h in Denver and for 24 h in Washington. The studies revealed that ambient CO levels at the composite network of fixed-site monitors were able to track variation in personal exposures. However, the network overestimated the 8-h exposures of people with low-level personal exposures and underestimated the 8-h exposures of people with high-level personal exposures. With respect to the underestimates, over 10% of the daily maximum 8-h exposures in Denver exceeded the NAAQS of 9 ppm, and about 4% did so in Washington. The end-expired breath CO levels were in excess of 10 ppm, which was roughly equivalent to about 2% COHb in about 12.5% of the Denver participants and about 10% of the Washington participants. Recall, that the NAAQS for CO are designed to keep COHb levels below 2% in the blood of the general public including probable high-risk groups. During the survey period, the composite CO concentrations at fixed-site monitors exceeded the 8-h NAAQS for CO (9 ppm) only 3% of the time in Denver, and never in Washington, DC. Hence, the results of these two surveys raised further doubts as to the ability of fixed-site monitors to represent the total CO exposure of urban populations.45 The results of the population exposure studies in Denver and Washington did not persuade the U.S. EPA to change the form of the NAAQS for CO from deterministic to statistical. In September, 1985, the EPA announced that it would retain the existing primary NAAQS for CO, but that it would rescind the secondary standard to protect public welfare, because there was no evidence to support it.7 However, one could argue that the results of these two studies provided some justification for the tighter CO emission standards that had taken effect for new cars sold outside of California during the 1980 model year. (Under the CAA, the state of California has authority to set its own tailpipe emission standards.) For example, Table 2.1 shows results for selected microenvironments of the Denver study. The table shows that higher CO concentrations were associated with commuting by motor vehicles (i.e., motorcycle, bus, car, and truck). It also shows that indoor CO concentrations in excess of the NAAQS were observed in public garages and in service stations or vehicle repair facilities. In the Washington study, participants who commuted 6 h or more per week had higher CO exposures than those who commuted fewer hours per week. Likewise, participants who had occupations that involved motor vehicles (e.g., professional drivers of trucks, buses, and taxis; automobile mechanics; garage workers; and policemen) had a mean CO exposure (22.1 ppm) that was over three times higher than the average exposure of those who did not work with motor vehicles (6.3 ppm). The Denver population exposure study provided raw data to test the SHAPE model and the probabilistic version of the NAAQS Exposure Model (pNEM/CO). The evaluation of SHAPE showed close agreement between the observed and predicted arithmetic means of the 1-h and 8-h maximum average CO exposures. However, SHAPE over-predicted low-level exposures and under-predicted high-level exposures.48 Likewise, an evaluation of pNEM/CO showed relatively close agreement between simulated and observed exposures for CO concentrations near the
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 15 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
16
TABLE 2.1 Carbon Monoxide Concentrations of Selected Microenvironments in Denver, Colorado, 1982–1983 (Listed in Descending Order of Mean CO Concentration) n
Meana (ppm)
Standard Error (ppm)
22 76 3, 632 405 619 9
9.79 8.52 8.10 7.03 3.88 1.34
1.74 0.81 0.16 0.49 0.27 1.20
29 22 12 61 126 16 74 29 21
8.20 7.53 3.68 3.45 3.17 1.99 1.36 0.97 0.69
0.99 1.90 1.10 0.54 0.49 0.85 0.26 0.52 0.24
Indoor Public garages 116 Service stations or vehicle repair facilities 125 Other locations 427 Other repair shops 55 Shopping malls 58 Residential garages 66 Restaurants 524 Offices 2, 287 Auditoriums, sports arenas, concert halls 100 Stores 734 Health care facilities 351 Other public buildings 115 Manufacturing facilities 42 Homes 21, 543 Schools 426 Churches 179
13.46 9.17 7.40 5.64 4.90 4.35 3.71 3.59 3.37 3.23 2.22 2.15 2.04 2.04 1.64 1.56
1.68 0.83 0.87 1.03 0.85 0.87 0.19 0.002 0.48 0.21 0.23 0.30 0.39 0.02 0.13 0.25
Microenvironment In-Transit Motorcycle Bus Car Truck Walking Bicycling Outdoor Public garages Residential garages or carports Service stations or vehicle repair facilities Parking lots Other locations School grounds Residential grounds Sports arenas, amphitheaters Parks, golf courses
a An observation was recorded whenever a person changed a microenvironment, and on every
clock hour; thus each observation had an averaging time of 60 min or less. Source: Johnson, T. A Study of Personal Exposure to Carbon Monoxide in Denver, Colorado, Report No. EPA-600/4/84-014, Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1984 as reported in U.S. EPA. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, Report No. EPA 600/8-90/045F, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1991.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 16 — #12
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
17
average exposure (i.e., within the range of 6–13 ppm for the 1-h standard and within 5.5–7 ppm for the 8-h standard). Like SHAPE, pNEM/CO also over-predicted lower exposures and under-predicted higher exposures for both standards.49
2.5 MICROENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURES This section describes studies of CO exposures in microenvironments that people use to live, work, shop, play, and commute. In particular, it identifies factors that may contribute to high-level exposures in these microenvironments. High-level exposures deserve more attention, because population exposure models (i.e., SHAPE and pNEM/CO) appear to underestimate high-level exposures in these microenvironments, as stated earlier. These microenvironments were also chosen, because they were identified by the U.S. EPA’s National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS) as locations relevant to air pollution exposure. That survey collected 24-h retrospective diary data on activities and their locations from 9196 respondents interviewed in the 48 contiguous states from late September 1992 through September 1994. Table 2.2 summarizes the minutes spent on the diary days in six locations for respondents to the survey.50
2.5.1 RESIDENTIAL EXPOSURES Exposure to CO in the home is an important component of a person’s total daily exposure, because an estimated 68.7% of one’s time on average is spent inside a residence.50 Major sources of CO concentrations inside the home include unvented or poorly vented furnaces, gas appliances, fireplaces, wood stoves, kerosene space heaters, and charcoal grills and hibachis. Other CO sources include motor vehicles inside an attached garage. Studies of exposures to nonfatal concentrations are discussed first, followed by studies of unintentional deaths caused by high indoor CO concentrations.
TABLE 2.2 Time Spent in Different Locations by 9196 Participants of The National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS), October 1992–September 1994 Location In a residence Office-factory Bar-restaurant Other indoor In an enclosed vehicle Outdoors
Overall Mean (min)
Doer %
Doer n
Doer Mean (min)
990 78 27 158 79 109
99.4 20.0 23.7 59.1 83.2 59.3
9153 1925 2263 5372 7596 5339
996 388 112 267 95 184
Source: Modified from Klepeis et al., J. Expo. Anal. Env. Epid., 11, 231, 2001.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 17 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
18
2.5.1.1 Nonfatal Exposures Many Americans have appliances that emit CO in the home. These homes often use gas (natural gas and liquid propane) for cooking, heating water, and drying clothes. Of all participants of the NHAPS study, 38.3% had a gas range or oven at home, and 23.7% said that it had a burning pilot light. The same study showed that some people still use small appliances to heat a room: fireplace (10%); wood stove (6%); and kerosene space heater (2%). In the presence of indoor sources such as gas appliances, indoor CO concentrations often exceed outdoor levels.47 In a 1985 Texas study, CO concentrations were greater than or equal to the NAAQS for CO of 9 ppm in 12% of surveyed homes. Residential CO concentrations were high in cases where unvented gas space heaters were used as the primary heat source.51 According to the Barbecue Industry Association, 44 million American households owned a charcoal grill in 1989, and an estimated 600 million charcoal-barbecuing events took place annually.52 An earlier study showed that the air stream from charcoal grills contained 20–2000 ppm of CO, with 75% of grills emitting 200 ppm and above.53 Another study reported COHb levels ranging from 6.9% to 17.4% in a family of four people in northern California who had been exposed to smoke from cooking indoors on a barbecue grill, which was found by firefighters in the middle of the living room.54 Based on data for ten counties, a study in Washington state reported features of unintentional CO poisoning cases that occurred between 1982 and 1993.52 Most cases occurred when electrical power was interrupted during fall and winter months, because of either regional storms or unpaid utility bills. Of 509 patients treated with hyperbaric oxygen, 79 (16%) were exposed to CO emissions when charcoal briquets were burned for heating or cooking in 32 separate incidents. Non-English speaking Hispanic whites and Asians were disproportionately represented among the cases. The COHb levels of these 79 people averaged 21.6% and ranged from 3.0% to 45.8%. Two studies assessed CO exposure to emissions from unvented portable kerosene heaters in eight small mobile homes with no gas appliances and low air exchange rates.55,56 Each home was monitored for an average of 6.5 h per day for 3 days per week for 4 weeks. For 2 weeks the heater was on, and, for 2 weeks, it was off. When the heater was turned on, it was in use for an average of 4.5 h. When the heater was in use, study participants (all nonsmokers) spent most of their time in the family room or kitchen. Sampling took place in the living area about 1.5–3 m from the heater. The mean 8-h CO concentrations were 7.4 ppm (1-h peak = 11.5 ppm) when the heater was on and 1.4 ppm (1-h peak = 1.5 ppm) when it was off. Peaks usually were observed at the end of the combustion period. The ambient CO level measured 0.5 h prior to heater use ranged from 0 to 8 ppm. When the heater was on, three of the eight homes had 8-h average CO levels that exceeded the NAAQS, and one home routinely had levels of 30–50 ppm. A California study reported CO exposures for a random sample of homes that used gas appliances during a 48-h period from December 1991 to April 1992.57−59 For periods of 48 h, the median CO concentration was 1.2 ppm (indoors) and 0.8 ppm (outdoors), and the median of the maximum 8-h average CO concentration was 2.0 ppm (indoors) and 1.4 ppm (outdoors). Of surveyed homes, 13 of 286 homes (4.5%)
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 18 — #14
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
19
had indoor CO concentrations above the NAAQS of 9 ppm for 8 h, and 8 of 282 homes (2.8%) had outdoor CO concentrations above this standard. Although most of the exceedances occurred in the Los Angeles basin, these percentages could be low because the basin was under-represented in the statewide sample. The study did not translate these percentages into statewide estimates. The study suggested that a small percentage of California homes would still have indoor CO problems even if outdoor CO levels at these homes complied with federal ambient standards. For a common sample of 277 homes, 17 homes (6.1%) had 1-h maximum concentrations indoors that were at least 5 ppm higher than outdoor levels, and 10 homes (3.6%) had 8-h maximum CO concentrations indoors that were at least 5 ppm higher than outdoor levels. Using univariate regression analysis, outdoor CO concentrations explained approximately 55% of the indoor CO variation. Higher net indoor CO levels (indoor minus outdoor CO concentrations) were traced definitively to space heating with gas ranges and gas-fired wall furnaces, use of gas ranges with continuous gas pilot lights, small home volumes, and cigarette smoke. However, several other factors also may have contributed to the higher CO levels: malfunctioning gas furnaces, automobile exhausts leaking into homes from attached garages and carports, improper use of gas appliances (e.g., gas fireplaces), and improper installation of gas appliances (e.g., forced air unit ducts).59 2.5.1.2 Fatal Exposures Factors contributing to unintentional deaths from CO poisonings were identified by studies in California and New Mexico. In California, two studies collected data for the 1979–1988 period. In the first study, 59 of 444 deaths (13.3%) were caused by improper use of charcoal grills and hibachis.60 Of the 59 deaths, 54% occurred inside motor vehicles (e.g., vans, campers) and 46% in residential structures (e.g., homes, apartments, shacks, tents). Relative to their share of the state’s population, higher death rates occurred amongAsians, blacks, males, and people aged 20–39. The second study identified specific factors that contributed to unintentional deaths caused by CO from several combustion sources (e.g., charcoal grills and hibachis, other heating and cooking appliances, motor vehicles, small engines, camping equipment).61 In this study, there was a strong association between alcohol use and CO poisoning from motor vehicles. Typically, motorists under the influence of alcohol would pull into their garages, leave the engine running while listening to cassette tapes, and then fall asleep. Faulty heating equipment used during winter months was implicated in about 50% of all unintentional deaths in both the California study61 and the New Mexico study.62 The National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) and the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) estimated that 212 deaths in 1992 could be attributed to fuel-burning appliances used in the home. Of these deaths, 13 involved use of gasoline-powered appliances.63 An estimated 3900 CO injury accidents occurred in 1994, of which about 400 were associated with the use of gasoline-powered engines or tools. In response to the problem, several federal government agencies issued a joint alert concerning exposure to CO emitted by these sources.64 These sources involved use of pressure washers, air compressors, concrete-cutting saws, electric generators,
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 19 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
20
floor buffers, power trowels, water pumps, and welding equipment. Unintentional CO poisonings frequently happened indoors even when people took precautions to ventilate buildings. Power outages following hurricanes and tropical storms often create demand for alternate sources of electricity (e.g., portable gasoline generators) to run air conditioners and refrigerators. But these generators can be a significant source of CO exposures if they are placed in garages or outdoors near windows. The majority of exposures occur overnight when generators are used to run air conditioners and other appliances. Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, which struck the U.S. Gulf Coast in the late summer of 2005, caused 10 deaths from CO poisoning in 18 storm-affected counties of Alabama and Texas.65 All of the fatalities were caused by gasoline-powered generators placed either inside the home or in a fully enclosed space outside the home. Very few homes had functioning CO detectors. In four hurricanes that hit Florida in 2004, some victims of CO poisoning placed generators inside their homes or garages to protect the devices from weather damage or to prevent theft.66
2.5.2 OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURES The NHAPS study reported that 20% of Americans spent nearly 6.5 h per day on average working inside an office or factory.50 The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) estimated that 3.5 million workers who work in the private sector potentially are exposed to CO primarily from motor exhaust. The number of persons potentially exposed to CO in the work environment is greater than that for any other physical or chemical agent.67 In 1992, there were 900 work-related CO poisonings resulting in death or illness in private industry according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics as cited in a NIOSH report.64 Three risk factors affect industrial occupational exposure: (1) the work environment is located in a densely populated area that has high background (i.e., ambient) CO concentrations; (2) the work environment produces CO as a product or by-product of an industrial process, or the work environment tends to accumulate CO concentrations that may result in occupational exposures; and (3) the work environment involves exposure to methylene chloride (i.e., dichloromethane), which is metabolized to CO in the body. Proximity to fuel combustion of all types elevates CO exposure for certain occupations: airport employees; auto mechanics; small gasoline-powered tool operators (e.g., users of chainsaws); charcoal meat grillers; construction workers; crane deck operators; firefighters; forklift operators; parking garage or gasoline station attendants; policemen; taxi, bus and truck drivers; toll booth and roadside workers; and warehouse workers.47 Table 2.3 shows results for several occupational studies (typical CO values and/or ranges), averaging periods, and the measured or estimated percent COHb levels for nonsmokers, if reported. The CO exposure of office building workers has received less attention. Flachsbart and Ott83 developed a “rapid method” for surveying CO concentrations inside several high-rise buildings. In one case, they observed CO concentrations in excess of 9 ppm, which is the 8-h NAAQS for CO, on four visits to a 15-story office building in Palo Alto, California. A survey in April 1980, showed that CO concentrations in the building’s underground garage averaged 40.6 ppm. The CO levels ranged from
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 20 — #16
5.0–13.6 (0.25 h) 5–300 (0.1–1.7 h) (INT) 5.8–12.5 TWA (0.5–1 h) NA >200 (<2 min) 16.2–24.3 TWA (8 h) 250–300 (5 h) NA (4.4 h) 370–386 (NA) 25–47 TWA (8–12 h) 3–34 (8 h) 42.6% > 35 (1 h) 2.7 (8 h) 1–4.3 (8 h) 5–42 (ENV)
Airport workers NA NA NA 9.2–75.6 in 5 farmers NA > 4 in 10 NS 5–22 for 4 NS 4.2–28.7 for 7 NS 21.1 ± 0.7 6.3–13.3 for 4 NS > 3.25 in 5% of NS > 5 in 45% of NS NA NA <5
Measured or Estimated Percent COHb Massachusetts, U.S. U.S. France U.S. U.S. Germany North Carolina, U.S. North Carolina, U.S. North Carolina, U.S. Colorado, U.S. California, U.S. Ontario, Canada 4 states, U.S. Denmark Massachusetts, U.S.
State/Country
68 69 70 71 64 72 73 74 75 76 77, 78 79 80 81 82
References
Note: ENV = short-term environmental measurements; INT = interior of vehicle; NA = not available; NS = non-smokers; and TWA = time-weighted average Source: Modified from Apte, M. A population-based exposure assessment methodology for carbon monoxide: development of a carbon monoxide passive sampler and occupational dosimeter, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 1997 and updated.
Garage mechanics Traffic/roadway workers
Forklift operators and workers in facilities with forklifts
Bus drivers Chainsaw/gas tool operators
CO Concentration (ppm) and Averaging Period
Occupational Category
TABLE 2.3 Studies of Occupational Exposures and Dosages
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations 21
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 21 — #17
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
22
10.2 to 18.5 ppm on the first eleven floors of the building, but were only 2–4 ppm on the top four floors. They attributed these findings to three factors: (1) fans ventilating the garage had been switched off to reduce electricity costs, because utility rates had increased sharply due to an international energy crisis; (2) the door connecting the garage with the main stairwell of the building was kept open; and (3) the first eleven and top four floors of the building were served by separate ventilation systems. Once the first two factors were corrected (i.e., the garage fans were switched on and the connecting door to the garage was closed), Flachsbart and Ott83 reported that average CO levels in the garage dropped from 40.6 ppm (before) to 7.9 ppm (after), while typical CO levels in the building fell from 11 ppm to 12 ppm (before) to 1 ppm to 2 ppm (after).
2.5.3 SHOPPING CENTER EXPOSURES The NHAPS study estimated that 59.1% of Americans spent nearly 4.5 h per day on average at other indoor locations, such as shopping malls, stores, schools, churches, health clubs, laundromats, salons, and parking garages.50 Of these locations, major shopping centers, in particular, attract and generate relatively large volumes of motor vehicle traffic that typically circulates at low speeds with frequent stops and starts. This traffic pattern produces relatively high CO emissions, which can accumulate to unhealthy levels if emissions occur in enclosed or semienclosed spaces. Since shopping centers also attract large numbers of people, the potential for human exposure to high CO levels is great. In the 1980s, the Ala Moana Shopping Center in Honolulu, Hawaii, was an example of this type of indoor CO exposure problem. First, the center had 155 business outlets that attracted 40 million people including many tourists each year. Second, the center had an attached structure with 7800 parking spaces on several decks. CO emission rates were high, because the posted speed limit for motor vehicles in the structure was 15 mph for the safety of pedestrians. CO emission rates increase when vehicle speeds fall below 15 mph. Third, one deck of the parking structure functioned as a lid on the exhaust emissions of cars at the street level of the structure. Fourth, many of the 94 outlets at street level kept their doors open during business hours to attract customers. This allowed CO concentrations from the parking area and internal driveways to diffuse into many retail outlets.84 Flachsbart and Brown visited 25 of the 94 street-level outlets at the shopping center every 5 days between November 1981 and March 1982.85 During one visit 4 days before Christmas Day, they estimated that average 1-h concentrations of CO inside ten stores exceeded the federal ambient standard of 35 ppm, but not the occupational standards which were 200 ppm for a 1-h period and 50 ppm for an 8-h period. The average CO levels during 3-min visits to these ten stores on that date ranged from a low of 36.3 ppm to a high of 86.7 ppm. An earlier study of the shopping center’s ground-level parking area found average CO levels ranging from 12 to 37 ppm.86 Although the two studies surveyed different locations of the shopping center, the lower CO levels observed by the 1981–1982 study of the center could be attributed to implementation of the federal motor vehicle emission control program during the 1970s.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 22 — #18
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
23
2.5.4 RECREATIONAL EXPOSURES Recreational exposures occur when people use recreational vehicles and when they watch or participate in certain indoor sporting events that involve motor vehicles.
2.5.4.1 Exposures on Recreational Vehicles Two studies examined personal exposure to CO in the exhaust of recreational vehicles. In the first study, Simeone sampled CO concentrations in the passenger areas of large power boats with side-mounted exhausts during routine cruises offshore of Annapolis, Maryland, and Boston, Massachusetts.87 In Boston harbor, CO concentrations averaged 56 ppm during a 60-min cruise and 28 ppm after a 30-min cruise. For the Chesapeake Bay cruises near Annapolis, average stabilized CO concentrations at the helm ranged from 93 to 170 ppm over 20- to 30-min periods and 272 ppm over 30 min on the rear deck near the transom of the boat. In both studies, exhaust gas was affected significantly by airflow about the boat under certain head winds. At head wind speeds of 10–30 knots, turbulent mixing occurred in closer proximity to the rear of the boats, enabling exhaust gases to migrate freely into each boat. In the second study, Snook studied the CO exposure of a second snowmobiler who tailed a lead snowmobiler on a 2- to 3-miles straight trail over level terrain in Grand Teton National Park, Wyoming.88 The CO exposure of the second snowmobiler was measured under stable atmospheric conditions in Tedlar™ bags. The distance between the two snowmobiles ranged from 25 to 125 ft., and speeds ranged from 10 to 40 mph. The second snowmobiler’s maximum average centerline exposure was 23.1 ppm, which occurred at 10 mph and 25 ft. behind the lead snowmobile. Although Snook reported no averaging times for exposures, one can estimate that these times ranged from 3 to 18 min from the data given on the snowmobiler’s travel distance and vehicle speed. In general, the centerline CO concentrations decreased with increasing distance between snowmobiles and increased with greater speeds, but only for distances greater than 25 ft. between snowmobiles. At 15 ft. off centerline, average concentrations fell sharply to levels of 0–7.5 ppm. When the snowmobiler drove alone (self-exposure), the average concentration minus the background concentration was 1.3–3.0 ppm. Background concentrations ranged from 0.2 to 0.5 ppm. At the time of Snook’s study, snowmobile tourism was a booming business across the nation and in several national parks. During the winter of 1993 and 1994, over 87,000 tourists traveled by snowmobile in Yellowstone National Park.89 Under steady-state conditions, a snowmobile may emit from 10 to 20 g of CO per mi, while a modern U.S. automobile equipped with a catalytic converter emits far less (0.01– 0.04 g of CO per mi) at speeds of 10 to 40 mph. Snook and Davis reported that there were no federal laws regulating the exhaust from snowmobile engines, and states were pre-empted from implementing snowmobile emission standards.90 The typical snowmobile utilized a two-stroke engine, because it is less expensive than a four-stroke engine and provides a high power-to-weight ratio. However, a two-stroke engine produces relatively high emissions of CO.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 23 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
24
2.5.4.2 Exposures at Indoor Sporting Events Significant quantities of CO are emitted by certain types of machines during sporting events that occur in poorly ventilated indoor arenas. The CO is emitted by several sources, including ice-resurfacing machines and ice edgers during skating events; gaspowered radiant heaters used to heat viewing stands; and motor vehicles at motocross, monster-truck, and tractor-pull competitions. These competitions usually involve many motor vehicles with no emission controls. Several studies of CO exposure at indoor sporting events are noteworthy. First, Kwok reported episodes of CO poisoning among skaters inside four arenas in Ontario, Canada.91 Mean CO levels ranged from 4 to 81 ppm for periods of about 80 min. The CO levels in the spectator areas ranged from 90% to 100% of levels on the ice rinks. The ice resurfacing machines lacked catalytic emission controls. Second, both Sorensen92 and Miller et al.93 reported CO concentrations greater than 100 ppm in rinks from the use of gasoline-powered resurfacing machines. High concentrations were attributed to poorly maintained machines and insufficient ventilation in one rink. Third, based on data collected in the Québec city area, Lévesque et al.94 developed a linear relationship between CO exposure and the CO concentration in exhaled breath, but could not eliminate other factors affecting the relationship. In a later study, Lévesque et al.95 measured the alveolar CO of 14 male adult nonsmokers who played ice hockey, but who were not exposed in occupational settings. Rink CO concentrations ranged from 0 to 76.2 ppm. The study again found a linear relationship between exposure and absorbed CO, such that for each 10 ppm of CO in the indoor air, the players absorbed enough CO to raise alveolar CO by 4.1 ppm or about 0.76% COHb. In the United States, surveys of CO exposure were done at ice arenas in Vermont, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, and Washington. For a rink in Massachusetts, Lee et al.96 showed that excessive CO concentrations can occur, even with well-maintained equipment and fewer resurfacing operations, if ventilation is inadequate. Average CO levels were less than 20 ppm over 14 h, with no significant source of outdoor CO. Ventilation systems could not disperse pollutants emitted and trapped by temperature inversions and low air circulation at ice level. In another study, Lee et al.97 reported that CO concentrations measured inside six enclosed rinks of the Boston area during a 2-h hockey game ranged from 4 to 117 ppm, whereas outdoor levels were about 2–3 ppm. The alveolar CO of hockey players increased by an average 0.53 ppm per 1 ppm CO exposure over 2 h. Fifteen years earlier, Spengler et al.98 found similar CO concentrations in the Boston area, with levels ranging from 23 to 100 ppm for eight enclosed rinks. In 1991, Paulozzi et al.99 reported that 25 people exposed to CO during a Vermont high-school ice hockey game had mean COHb levels of 8.9%, but did not report whether any of them were smokers. Although Paulozzi et al. were unable to measure CO concentrations at the game, Smith et al.100 reported CO levels of 150 ppm (no averaging time was given) at an indoor ice-hockey rink in Wisconsin. To document the extent of the problem in Vermont, Paulozzi et al. measured CO concentrations during eight high-school games in the state, and reported that average CO levels for the entire game ranged from <5 ppm to 101 ppm with a mean of 35 ppm.101
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 24 — #20
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
25
Hampson reported a maximum CO level of 354 ppm inside an ice arena in Seattle, Washington, in March 1996.102 Based on data for 17 persons, whose tobacco use was not reported, the average COHb level was 8.6% (range of 3.3–13.9%). The source of the CO was a malfunction in a 20-year-old ice resurfacing machine. The study also reported that CO may have diffused into an adjacent bingo hall through an open door. In view of these studies, the State of Minnesota declared in Regulation No. 4635 that CO measurements taken 20 min after ice resurfacing must be less than 30 ppm.102 Studies also have been done in sports arenas that allow motor vehicles. Boudreau et al.103 reported CO levels for three indoor sporting events (i.e., monster-truck competitions, tractor pulls) in Cincinnati, Ohio. The CO measurements were taken before and during each event at different elevations in the public seating area of each arena with most readings obtained at the midpoint elevation where most people were seated. Average CO concentrations over 1–2 h ranged from 13 to 23 ppm (before the event) to 79 to 140 ppm (during the event). Measured CO levels were lower at higher seating levels. The ventilation system was operated maximally, and ground-level entrances were completely open. High CO concentrations also have been found at motor vehicle competitions in Canada. Luckurst and Solkoski104 recorded CO concentrations at two tractorpull events in Winnipeg, Manitoba. The mean of instantaneous concentrations at 25 locations in the arena ranged from 68 ppm at the start of the first event to 262 ppm by the end. At the second event, the range was 78–436 ppm. Lévesque et al.105 reported CO levels at an indoor motocross competition held in a skating rink in the Québec City region. The May, 1994 event lasted from roughly 8:00 p.m. to midnight. Average CO concentrations determined at five stations located at different points in the arena ranged from 19.1 to 38.0 ppm, with the higher levels measured during the second half of the show. High CO concentrations forced a health official to interrupt the event seven times to help clear the air. Covariance analysis showed that CO levels were related to the initial CO concentration, the event duration, engine size, and especially the number of motorcycles on the track.
2.5.5 COMMUTER EXPOSURES The NHAPS study estimated that 83.2% of Americans spent 95 min per day on average inside a motor vehicle.50 Time spent inside a vehicle, as a percentage of a 24-h day (6.6%), is relatively small compared to the percentage of time spent at home (69.2%) or at work (26.9%). Still, one might expect commuter CO exposure to be high. Highway vehicles accounted for 62.8% of the total CO emitted from all sources except fires in the U.S. in 2003.13 In urban areas, highway vehicles typically account for even higher percentages of total CO emissions.3 Moreover, highway vehicles potentially are a major contributor to a person’s total CO exposure, especially if a person is routinely near motor vehicle emissions.106 Some evidence of this comes from the Denver population exposure study, which indicated that CO exposure while driving was a major component of a person’s daily CO exposure.45,48
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 25 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
26
In some ways, driving on congested roadways is analogous to swimming in a polluted river. However, the analogy isn’t perfect, because most commuters have enclosed vehicles, which may not fully protect their occupants from ambient CO concentrations. In a Los Angeles study, Petersen and Allen107 reported that interior CO concentrations averaged 92% of exterior levels. An earlier study by Petersen and Sabersky found that CO concentrations measured outside vehicles exhibit rapid variations and high peaks, while simultaneously measured concentrations inside a vehicle show more gradual variations.38 Several factors affect variation in the CO exposures of commuters as shown in Table 2.4, which lists several American studies in chronological order that have been performed on this subject over a 28-year period since 1974. Table 2.4 includes three studies of actual commuters29,45,108 and five studies of commuter microenvironments.109−113 A Boston study in 1974 revealed variation in the CO exposure of a bicyclist by street type, as defined by traffic volume and number of lanes.109 A few years later, Holland found that automobile commuter exposures varied among four cities surveyed during the winter of 1981.110 A later study attributed Denver’s higher exposures to its colder winter climate and higher altitude.114 Table 2.4 shows that exposures vary by commuting period (morning versus afternoon);29 trip type (residential versus commuting to an urban area);110 mode of travel (automobile, bus, and rail);111 season of the year (summer versus winter);108 trip location (rural, interstate beltway, and urban);112 and year of study.113 Akland et al.45 reported that actual commuters who spent six or more hours per week in travel had greater exposures than those who spent less than 6 h. Finally, Table 2.4 shows that seven of these studies found that commuter exposures typically exceeded concurrently measured ambient concentrations.29,45,108,110−113 2.5.5.1 Defective Exhaust Systems The need to control CO emissions from motor vehicles can be traced in part to studies that tied high CO exposures during commuting to defective exhaust systems and cars without effective emission controls. For example, Amiro115 found that engine and/or tailpipe emissions of CO leaked into passenger cabins of 9 of 19 vehicles studied. CO concentrations inside contaminated vehicles ranged up to 400 ppm. Clements reported that of 645 school buses tested, 7.2% had average CO readings in excess of 20 ppm, and 5.4% had maximum readings above 50 ppm.116 He estimated that CO concentrations in excess of 20 ppm existed in school buses ridden by up to 2.1 million U.S. school children on a daily basis in the 1970s. In a two-step study, Ziskind et al.117 first identified which sustained-use vehicles (buses, taxicabs, and police cars) had faulty exhaust systems, that is, they leaked CO into passenger cabins. Of 120 rides taken in faulty vehicles during the second step, the researchers found that 58% had CO concentrations that exceeded the U.S. NAAQS of 9 ppm for 8 h. In a later study, Hampson and Norkool reported that 20 of 68 children were treated for accidental CO poisoning after riding in the back of eight pickup trucks in Seattle, Washington, between 1986 and 1991.118 Average COHb levels measured in an emergency room were 18.2% ± 2.4% (mean ± standard error of the mean), and ranged from 1.6% to 37.0%. Seventeen of the twenty children rode under a rigid closed canopy attached to
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 26 — #22
Auto Auto
October ’74–February ’75
January–March ’81
January–March ’81
January–March ’83
Commuting period Morning Afternoon
City
Trip type Residential driving Urban commute
Mode of travel Washington, DC
Four citiesc
Stamford, CT Los Angeles, CA Phoenix, AZ Denver, CO
Boston, MA
Auto Bus Rail
Auto Auto
Auto Auto Auto Auto
Bicycle Bicycle Bicycle
Boston, MA
Summer ’74
Type of street Narrow-busy 2-lanes Wide-busy 4-lanes Narrow-light 2-lanes
Travel Mode
Study Period
Factor Urban Area
TABLE 2.4 Factors Affecting Commuter Carbon Monoxide Exposure.
9.1–22.3 3.7–10.2 2.2–5.2
2.9–7.6 6.2–16.1
5.2 8.5 6.7 10.3
12.8 13.9
16.4 (17.3)a 14.4 (10.9)a 10.1 (8.8)a
Mean or Median CO Concentration (ppm)
±2 to ±9 ±1 to ±7 0.5 to ±5
±3.6 to ±5.0 ±4.7 to ±7.7
±4.7 ±5.8 ±4.9 ±7.7
±5 ±6
3.3 (4.6)a 3.5 (1.9)a 0.88 (1.5)a
Range or SD of CO Concentration (ppm)
2.3
±2.4 to ±3.9 ±3.9 to ±5.8
4.2–5.5b 3.9–5.8 2.4–3.9 3.1–5.8
6.0
NA NA NA
Typical Ambient CO Concentration (ppm)
(Continued)
111
110
110
29
109
References
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations 27
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 27 — #23
9.7e 4.8e 1.5e
4 11 13
6.5 10.1
5.04 7.90
Mean or Median CO Concentration (ppm)
±3.1 ±1.7 ±0.8
NA NA NA
±2.2 ±5.8
NA NA
Range or SD of CO Concentration (ppm)
1.3 1.31 0.61
NA NA 2.8
2.8 4.3
3.2
Typical Ambient CO Concentration (ppm)
Note: a Rush hours: 7–9:30 a.m. and 3–5:30 p.m.; (non-rush hour concentrations) b Ambient concentration was measured outside the automobile. c Four cities were Stamford, CT; Los Angeles, CA; Phoenix, AZ; and Denver, CO. d Surveys occurred in the suburbs of Menlo Park, Palo Alto, and Los Altos. e Median of net CO concentrations for 50 trips, where the net value of each trip = average trip CO concentration − background CO concentration. NA = not available
San Francisco, CAd
Raleigh, NC
Los Angeles, CA
Auto Auto Auto
Auto Auto Auto
August–September ’88
Trip location Rural Interstate beltway Urban
February ’80–February ’81 February ’91–February ’92 February ’01–March ’02
Auto Auto
May ’87–March ’88
Season Summer Winter
Year of study
All All
Washington, DC
November ’82–February ’83
Travel Mode
Weekly travel < 6 h/wk ≥ 6 h/wk
Urban Area
Study Period
Factor
TABLE 2.4 Continued
113
112
108
45
References
28 Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 28 — #24
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
29
the bed of the truck, and the other three children rode beneath a tarpulin. Six pickups had a known leak in their exhaust system: three had a rear-end tailpipe and three had a side-mounted tailpipe. 2.5.5.2 Parking Garages Initial studies of CO concentrations in parking garages focused primarily on the garage itself. Trompeo et al.,119 who surveyed 12 underground garages in Turin, Italy, reported that CO levels averaged 98 ppm and ranged from 10 to 300 ppm for 132 observations. Chovin120 measured CO levels of 80–100 ppm on average in poorly ventilated garages in Paris, France. CO concentrations in parking garages can reach a peak in the late afternoon when many drivers leave work and start their cars at the same time. Goldsmith121 and Flachsbart et al.111 found that mass exits from garages can elevate pollutant levels to very high concentrations. The latter study observed spikes in CO concentrations (mean = 94.0 ppm based on 3-min averages, n = 14 cases) inside a test vehicle as it exited the underground garage of a government office building in Washington, DC, during a winter survey in 1983. The study also attributed these spikes in CO concentrations to the fact that many cars were operating under “cold-start” conditions. Once the test vehicle exited the garage, high CO concentrations inside the vehicle gradually dissipated, but the dissipation rate was slow because the vehicle’s windows were kept closed due to cold weather. 2.5.5.3 Service Stations Many motorists typically pump their own fuel at service stations. For safety reasons, most people shut off the engine of their vehicle after they arrive at the station. However, some people may be exposed to CO emitted by vehicles entering or exiting the station. Amendola and Hanes measured CO concentrations in thirteen service stations and two automobile dealerships in the New England area.122 Results varied by season, with CO concentrations ranging from 2.2 to 21.6 ppm in warm weather and 16.2 to 110.8 ppm during cold weather. They cited reduced ventilation as another cause of higher concentrations during winter. Based on a random sample of 100 self-service stations in four counties of southern California, Wilson et al.123 reported a median CO concentration (4.3 ppm), which was about twice that of the ambient level (2.0 ppm) for 5-min averaging times. 2.5.5.4 Drive-Up Facilities Passengers have been exposed to extremely high CO levels when motor vehicles are idling in a queue. During February and March of 1976, Myronuk124 measured CO concentrations inside an automobile at space-confined, drive-up facilities in Santa Clara Valley, California. The in-vehicle CO concentrations ranged from 15 to 95 ppm for 15-min averages, with short-term peaks of 100–400 ppm. High CO averages could be attributed to older vehicles that lacked catalysts, even though these vehicles probably had other forms of emission controls and appeared to be well maintained
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 29 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
30
and tuned. Background CO levels were only 2–5 ppm and monitoring occurred when wind speeds were low. Concentrations varied widely if ventilating fans for heater or air conditioning units were in operation. 2.5.5.5 Airbag Deployment Airbags are currently a required safety feature on new cars sold in the United States. On the basis of deployment of four airbags, Wheatley et al.125 reported that time-weighted-average (TWA) CO concentrations ranged from 174 to 370 ppm. Peak CO concentrations occurred 2 min after deployment. 2.5.5.6 Motor Vehicle Emission Standards One of the most significant factors affecting commuter exposure in the United States has been the federal motor vehicle emission control program.126 The CAA amendments of 1970, 1977, and 1990 established a series of progressively tighter motor vehicle emission standards and other controls on new cars sold in the United States. Tighter controls on the tailpipe emissions of new cars had the effect of offsetting the expansion of motor vehicle travel caused by population growth and urban sprawl since 1970.127 Prior to the 1968 model year, the CO tailpipe emissions of passenger cars in the U.S. were 84.0 g per mi. A series of progressively tighter CO emission standards took effect beginning with the 1968 model year, when a standard of 51.0 g per mi took effect. By the 1975 model year, CO tailpipe emissions fell to 15.0 g per mi as a result of the catalytic converter, which became standard equipment on new cars sold in the U.S. The CO emission standard was then lowered to 3.4 g per mi for the 1981 model year and then to 1.7 g per mi by the 2003 model year.3 This amounted to a reduction of nearly 98% in the CO emission rate of new cars between the 1967 and 2003 model years. Several studies show the effects on CO exposure of this trend. First, Flachsbart did a meta-analysis of 16 commuter exposure studies that occurred in the U.S. between 1965 and 1992.128 These studies reported typical (mean or median) CO concentrations for trips, most of which lasted an hour or less. CO concentrations fell from 37 ppm in 1965, as reported by Haagen-Smit129 for a study in Los Angeles, California, to 3 ppm in 1992 for a study by Lawryk et al.130 in the New Jersey suburbs of New York City. A more recent study of an arterial highway on the San Francisco Peninsula indicated that the median CO exposure of 50 trips taken over a 15-month period between 2001 and 2002 was 1.5 ppm.113 If one assumes that the results of these 17 separate studies between 1965 and 2002 are representative of commuter CO exposures in cities nationwide, then exposures fell 96% over the 37-year period. Notice that this percentage reduction in commuter exposure (96%) is nearly identical to the percentage reduction in the CO emission rate for new cars (98%). Also, the time period represented by the CO exposure reduction (1965–2002) is nearly identical to the period used to estimate the emission rate reduction (1967–2003). Finally, Mott et al.4 found that unintentional motorvehicle-related CO death rates in the United States fell from 4.0 to 0.9 deaths per one million person-years between 1975, when the catalytic converter was introduced, and
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 30 — #26
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
31
1998. They estimated that if rates of unintentional CO-related deaths had remained at pre-1975 levels, then 11,667 more vehicle-related CO deaths might have occurred by 1998. It’s quite possible that modern motor vehicle emission control programs have substantially reduced the sharp peaks in CO exposures observed in older studies of commuting microenvironments. A longitudinal study of commuting in California noticed a lack of sharp peaks in CO measurements during surveys of an arterial highway in 2001–2002 relative to observations of the same highway during previous surveys in 1980–1981 and 1991–1992. The study attributed this finding to California’s implementation of (1) an I/M program (i.e., Smog Check) in 1984; and (2) tougher “durability standards” on emission controls which were adopted in September 1990 and phased-in on new cars sold in California in 1993 and 1994.113
2.6 EXPOSURE TO METHYLENE CHLORIDE Exposure to halogenated hydrocarbons such as methylene chloride, which can be metabolized to CO in the body, occurs when the chemicals are found in contaminated ambient air and groundwater, and in consumer products that contain the chemical as a solvent, flame-retardant additive, or propellant.
2.6.1 NONOCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE Exposure to methylene chloride in the home, for example, primarily occurs through use of paint and varnish removers. Exposure may also occur through use of aerosol propellants such as those found in hair sprays, antiperspirants, air fresheners, and spray paints. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry reported that some aerosol products may contain up to 50% methylene chloride.24 Ambient exposure may occur near production and use facilities or near hazardous waste sites that store methylene chloride. In a study reported in 1983, ambient concentrations of methylene chloride near organic solvent cleaning and paint and varnish removal operations ranged from 7.1 to 14.3 parts per billion (ppb) averaged over one year.131 Although methylene chloride readily disperses when released into the air, it may remain in groundwater for years, and be ingested in drinking water or inhaled when it volatilizes during showering and laundering.24 Exposure to about 500 ppm methylene chloride for several hours can elevate COHb levels to 15%. Increases in COHb levels can be detected in the blood of nonsmokers about 30 min after exposure to methylene chloride. Stewart et al.132 showed that elevated COHb levels were proportional to a series of controlled exposures to methylene chloride. In another controlled experiment, Stewart and Hake133 observed postexposure levels of COHb ranging from 5% to 10% after 3 h use of a liquid-gel paint remover containing 80% methylene chloride and 20% methanol by weight. Concurrent exposure to methylene chloride and methanol prolongs the period of elevated COHb in the body.23,133,134 Peterson reported COHb levels of up to about 10% saturation after inhalation of methylene chloride concentrations ranging from 50 to 500 ppm over 5 days, for 7.5 h per day.135
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 31 — #27
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
32
2.6.2 OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE Certain occupations expose workers to organic solvents such as methylene chloride. The solvent is widely used as a degreaser, paint remover, aerosol propellant, and blowing agent for polyurethane foams. It is used as an extractant for foods and spices, a grain fumigant, and a low-pressure refrigerant. It also is used in the manufacturing of synthetic fibers, photographic film, polycarbonate plastics, pharmaceuticals, printed circuit boards, and inks. More than one million workers have significant potential for exposure to methylene chloride.24 Moreover, the highest levels of exposure to methylene chloride often occur in the workplace. To protect worker health, the 8-h TWA threshold limit value for methylene chloride was set at 50 ppm by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH).136 Exposure at this concentration leads to COHb levels of about 1.9% in experimental subjects. Exposure to 500 ppm for several hours may elevate COHb levels as high as 15%. An 8-h exposure to about 500 mg/m3 (3.5 mg/m3 = 1 ppm) of methylene chloride vapor is equivalent to an 8-h exposure to 35 ppm of CO.137 Methylene chloride stored in tissue may continue to be metabolized to CO after several hours of acute exposure. In such cases, COHb levels will continue to rise and peak as high as 25% about 5–6 h after exposure.24 Shusterman et al.138 reported an apparent linear elevation of COHb as a function of hours worked by a furniture refinisher who used paint stripper containing methylene chloride. Ghittori et al.139 reported a significant linear correlation (r = 0.87) between methylene chloride concentration in air and CO in alveolar air of nonsmoking and sedentary factory workers in Italy. Exposure to 600 mg/m3 of methylene chloride for 7.5 h was associated with a COHb level of 6.8% in eight volunteers. Exposure to methylene chloride also can be fatal. Leikin et al.140 reported fatalities of two people who were exposed to unknown concentrations of methylene chloride while they removed paint in an enclosed space. Death was caused not by CO poisoning, but by solvent-induced narcosis. Before they died, their COHb levels continued to rise following cessation of exposure despite treatment with high levels of oxygen.
2.7 CONCLUSIONS This chapter reviewed several types of CO exposure studies. Some studies measured CO concentrations in places where people live, work, shop, play, and commute. Other studies determined the amount of time people spent doing these activities. Still other studies identified factors that contribute to exposures in excess of federal ambient or occupational standards. A few conclusions from these studies follows. The NHAPS found that Americans continue to spend most of their time indoors. On average over a 24-h period, they spent 86.9% of their time indoors either at home, work, bar–restaurant, or elsewhere. They spent 5.5% of their time inside a motor vehicle and only 7.6% of their time outdoors.50 These percentages applied to the entire national sample of 9196 respondents interviewed in the 1990s, not just to the “doers” of various activities. If most Americans spend only a few hours outdoors each day, then indoor and in-vehicle CO exposures are important components of total human exposure.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 32 — #28
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
33
The findings of the NHAPS study underscore the importance of studies that compared indoor and outdoor CO exposures. Some of these studies indicated that indoor and outdoor CO exposures differed from those predicted from observations at fixedsite monitors, which are used by the U.S. EPA to determine compliance with the NAAQS. When ambient CO levels are either high or low on a given day, fixed-site monitors still reflect the corresponding high or low aggregates of personal exposures on those days. Otherwise, the stations do not adequately represent the CO exposures of community residents while they are exposed to motor vehicle exhaust during commuting, and to occupational and residential sources of unvented or poorly vented fuel combustion. The mean COHb level of people exposed to CO from these sources is greater than their mean COHb level predicted solely from exposure to CO of ambient origin. Longitudinal studies show that federal and state motor vehicle emission control programs have substantially reduced the CO exposures of urban commuters in the United States. These studies have two implications. First, similar reductions in exposure may exist for other microenvironments, especially those that may be affected substantially by tailpipe emissions from motor vehicles (e.g., office buildings and shopping centers attached to parking garages, as well as service stations, waiting lines at drive-up facilities, and sidewalks along busy streets). Unfortunately, there appear to be no published trend studies of CO exposure for these other microenvironments. Second, one would expect that results of certain population studies (e.g., the Denver–Washington study of 1982–1983) may no longer represent the CO exposures of current urban populations in the United States. More recent studies have shown that people are still exposed to elevated CO levels in certain indoor microenvironments (e.g., unventilated parking garages, motor vehicles with leaky exhaust systems, small homes with unvented or poorly vented gas stoves and space heaters). Moreover, studies report that high-level CO exposures can occur when people use unregulated gasoline-powered appliances, engines, and tools (e.g., chainsaws), even under ventilated conditions. These locations and activities are not part of the regulated ambient environment. However, these microenvironments typically represent settings of fatal and nonfatal CO poisonings. Studies of California homes indicated that elevated CO concentrations (>9 ppm) were caused by several factors, such as attached garages and carports; ranges with continuous gas pilot lights; and improper use and installation of gas appliances, especially in small homes. Other studies have found elevated CO concentrations (>9 ppm) when people ride certain types of recreational vehicles (e.g., snowmobiles, power boats), gather indoors to barbecue food (sometimes to cope with electrical power outages after severe storms), and watch sporting events held at indoor arenas. High-level exposures (>25 ppm) may occur inside arenas when they are used for ice skating or motocross, monster-truck, and tractor pull competitions. Vehicles in these competitions often lack any type of emission controls. At some events, ventilation did not sufficiently lower CO concentrations to safe levels (<9 ppm) for the general public. Finally, CO exposures are high in certain occupations, such as garage mechanics and chainsaw/gas tool operators, and for people who operate or work around forklifts. More than one million people have high exposure to methylene chloride in the
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 33 — #29
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
34
workplace, which is a concern because it can metabolize to CO in the body after several hours of exposure.
2.8 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Portions of this chapter are reprinted with permission from: Chemosphere—Global Change Science, vol. 1, M.A.K. Khalil, J.P. Pinto, and M.J. Shearer, Eds., P.G. Flachsbart, “Human Exposure to Carbon Monoxide from Mobile Sources,” pages 301–329, copyright (1999), published by Elsevier; Urban Traffic Pollution, D. Schwela and O. Zali, Eds., P.G. Flachsbart, “Chapter 4: Exposure to Exhaust and Evaporative Emissions from Motor Vehicles,” pages 89–132, copyright (1999), published by the WHO; Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology, 11(3), Neil E. Klepeis et al., “The National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS): a resource for assessing exposure to environmental pollutants,” pages 231–252, copyright (2001), published by Nature Publishing Group; A Population-Based Exposure Assessment Methodology for Carbon Monoxide: Development of a Carbon Monoxide Passive Sampler and Occupational Dosimeter, copyright (1997) by Michael G. Apte, Ph.D. Thesis, University of California, Berkeley; and Human Exposure Analysis, W. Ott, A. Steinemann, and L. Wallace, Eds., Peter G. Flachsbart, “Exposure to Carbon Monoxide,” pages 113–146, copyright (2007), published by CRC Taylor & Francis.
References 1. Burr, M.L. Combustion products, In Indoor Air Quality Handbook, Spengler, J.D., Samet, J.M., and McCarthy, J.F., eds., McGraw-Hill, New York, 2000, chap. 29. 2. Raub, J.A., Mathieu-Nolf, M., Hampson, N.B., and Thom, S.R. Carbon monoxide poisoning—a public health perspective, Toxicology, 145, 1, 2000. 3. Godish, T. Air Quality, 4th ed., Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL, 2004, 156–159. 4. Mott, J.A., Mitchell, I.W., Alverson, C.J., Macdonald, S.C., Bailey, C.R., Ball, L.B., Moorman, J.E., Somers, J.H., Mannino, D.M., and Redd, S.C. National vehicle emissions policies and practices and declining US carbon monoxide-related mortality, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 288, 988, 2002. 5. Vajani, M. Unintentional non-fire-related carbon monoxide exposures - United States, 2001–2003, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 54, 36, January 21, 2005. 6. Fiorino, D. Making Environmental Policy, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1995, 25–28. 7. U.S. EPA. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, Report No. EPA 600/P-99/001F, Office of Research and Development, National Center for Environmental Assessment, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 2000. 8. Raub, J. Environmental Health Criteria 213: Carbon Monoxide, 2nd ed., World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1999. 9. Arias, E., Anderson, R.N., Kung, H.-C., Murphy, S.L., and Kochanek, K.D. Deaths: final data for 2001, National Vital Statistics Reports, 52(3), Center for Health Statistics, Hyattsville, MD, 2003. 10. WHO. Carbon monoxide, In Air Quality Guidelines for Europe, WHO Regional Publications, European Series No. 23, World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, 1987, 210–220.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 34 — #30
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
35
11. WHO. Updating and revision of the air quality guidelines for Europe, Meeting of the WHO Working Group “Classical” Air Pollutants, Report No. EUR/ICP/EHAZ 94 05/PB01, World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, 1995. 12. Romieu, I. Epidemiological studies of health effects arising from motor vehicle air pollution, In Urban Traffic Pollution, Schwela, D. and Zali, O., eds., E & FN Spon, London, 1999, chap. 2. 13. U.S. EPA. National Air Quality and Emissions Trends Report, 2003 Special Studies Edition, Report No. EPA 454/R-03-005, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 2003. 14. Muller, P.O. Transportation and urban form: stages in the spatial evolution of the American metropolis, In The Geography of Urban Transportation, 3rd ed., Hanson, S. and Giuliano, G., eds., Guilford Press, New York, 2004, chap. 3. 15. U.S. Code of Federal Regulations, 40 CFR 50.1(e). 16. National Research Council. Managing Carbon Monoxide Pollution in Meteorological and Topographical Problem Areas, National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 2003. 17. Blumenthal, D. The use of real-time air quality data in daily forecasting and decisionmaking, EM: The Magazine for Environmental Managers, September, 2005, 18. 18. U.S. EPA. National Air Quality and Emissions Trends Report, 1999, Report No. EPA/454/R-01-004, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 2001. 19. U.S. EPA. National Air Quality and Emissions Trends Report, 1996, Report No. EPA/454/R-97-013, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1998. 20. See: http://www.epa.gov/oar/oaqps/greenbk/cmsum. 21. See: http://www.epa.gov/oar/oaqps/greenbk/cntc. 22. Zartarian, V.G., Ott, W.R., and Duan, N. A quantitative definition of exposure and related concepts, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 7, 411, 1997. 23. Wilcosky, T. and Simonsen, N.R. Solvent exposure and cardiovascular disease, Am. J. Ind. Med., 19, 569, 1991. 24. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. Methylene chloride toxicity, Am. Fam. Phy., 47, 1159, 1993. 25. Ott, W. Concepts of human exposure to air pollution, Environ. Int., 7, 179, 1982. 26. Council on Environmental Quality. Environmental Quality - 1980: The Eleventh Annual Report of the Council on Environmental Quality, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1980, 27–40. 27. Ott, W. An urban survey technique for measuring the spatial variation of carbon monoxide concentrations in cities, Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, 1971. 28. Ott, W. and Eliassen, R. A survey technique for determining the representativeness of urban air monitoring stations with respect to carbon monoxide, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 23, 685, 1973. 29. Cortese, A.D. and Spengler, J.D. Ability of fixed monitoring stations to represent personal carbon monoxide exposure, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 26, 1144, 1976. 30. Chapin, F.S., Jr. Human Activity Patterns in the City, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1974. 31. Szalai, A., ed. The Use of Time: Daily Activities of Urban and Suburban Populations in Twelve Countries, Mouton and Co., The Hague, The Netherlands, 1972.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 35 — #31
36
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 32. Yocom, J.E., Clink, W.L., and Cote, W.A. Indoor/outdoor air quality relationships, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 21, 251, 1971. 33. General Electric Company. Indoor–Outdoor Carbon Monoxide Pollution Study, Report No. NTIS-PB220428, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1972. 34. Godin, G., Wright, G., and Shephard, R. Urban exposure to carbon monoxide, Arch. Environ. Health, 25, 305, 1972. 35. Meyer, B. Indoor Air Quality, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1983, 159–160. 36. Spengler, J. and Soczeck, M. Evidence for improved ambient air quality and the need for personal exposure research, Environ. Sci. Technol., 18, 272A, 1984. 37. Wallace, L.A. and Ott, W.R. Personal monitors: a state-of-the-art survey, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 32, 601, 1982. 38. Petersen, G.A. and Sabersky, R.H. Measurement of pollutants inside an automobile, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 25, 1028, 1975. 39. Ott, W.R. and Flachsbart, P.G. Measurement of carbon monoxide concentrations in indoor and outdoor locations using personal exposure monitors, Environ. Int., 8, 295, 1982. 40. Fugas, M. Assessment of total exposure to an air pollutant, Paper No. 38-5 in Proc. Int. Conf. Environ. Sensing and Assess., Vol. 2, Las Vegas, NV, 1975, 1. 41. Duan, N. Models for human exposure to air pollution, Environ. Int., 8, 305, 1982. 42. Padgett, J. and Richmond, H. The process of establishing and revising national ambient air quality standards, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 33, 13, 1983. 43. Jordan, B.C., Richmond, H.M., and McCurdy, T. The use of scientific information in setting ambient air standards, Environ. Health Perspectives, 52, 233, 1983. 44. Federal Register. Carbon monoxide; proposed revisions to the national ambient air quality standards: proposed rule, 45, 55066, August 18, 1980. 45. Akland, G.G., Hartwell, T.D., Johnson, T.R., and Whitmore, R.W. Monitoring human exposure to carbon monoxide in Washington, D.C., and Denver, Colorado, during the winter of 1982–1983, Environ. Sci. Technol., 19, 911, 1985. 46. Johnson, T. A Study of Personal Exposure to Carbon Monoxide in Denver, Colorado, Report No. EPA-600/4/84-014, Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1984. 47. U.S. EPA. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, Report No. EPA 600/8-90/045F, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1991. 48. Ott, W.R., Thomas, J., Mage, D.T., and Wallace, L. Validation of the simulation of human activity and pollutant exposure (SHAPE) model using paired days from the Denver, CO, carbon monoxide field study, Atmos. Environ., 22, 2101, 1988. 49. Law, P.L., Lioy, P.J., Zelenka, M.P., Huber, A.H., and McCurdy, T.R. Evaluation of a probabilistic exposure model applied to carbon monoxide (pNEM/CO) using Denver personal exposure monitoring data, J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc., 47, 491, 1997. 50. Klepeis, N.E., Nelson, W.C., Ott, W.R., Robinson, J.P., Tsang, A.M., Switzer, P., Behar, J.V., Hern, S.C., and Engelmann, W.H. The national human activity pattern survey (NHAPS): a resource for assessing exposure to environmental pollutants, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 11, 231, 2001. 51. Koontz, M.D. and Nagda, N.L. A Topical Report on a Field Monitoring Study of Homes with Unvented Gas Space Heaters: Volume III, Methodology and Results, Contract No. 5083-251-0941, Gas Research Institute, Chicago, 1988.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 36 — #32
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
37
52. Hampson, N.B., Kramer, C.C., Dunford, R.G., and Norkool, D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning from indoor burning of charcoal briquets, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 271, 52, 1994. 53. Yates, M.W. A preliminary study of carbon monoxide gas in the home, J. Environ. Health, 29, 413, 1967. 54. Gasman, J.D., Varon, J., and Gardner, J.P. Revenge of the barbecue grill: carbon monoxide poisoning, West. J. Med., 153, 656, 1990. 55. Mumford, J.L., Williams, R.W., Walsh, D.B., Burton, R.M., Svendsgaard, D.J., Chuang, J.C., Houk, V.S., and Lewtas, J. Indoor air pollutants from unvented kerosene heater emissions in mobile homes: studies on particles, semivolatile organics, carbon monoxide, and mutagenicity, Environ. Sci. Technol., 25, 1732, 1991. 56. Williams, R., Walsh, D., White, J., Jackson, M., and Mumford, J. Effect on carbon monoxide levels in mobile homes using unvented kerosene heaters for residential heating, Indoor Environ., 1, 272, 1992. 57. Wilson, A.L., Colome, S.D., and Tian, Y. California Residential Indoor Air Quality Study, Volume 1 - Methodology and Descriptive Statistics, Integrated Environmental Services, Irvine, CA, 1993. 58. Wilson, A.L., Colome, S.D., and Tian, Y. California Residential Indoor Air Quality Study, Volume 1 - Methodology and Descriptive Statistics, Appendix, Integrated Environmental Services, Irvine, CA, 1993. 59. Colome, S.D., Wilson, A.L., and Tian, Y. California Residential Indoor Air Quality Study, Volume II - Carbon Monoxide and Air Exchange Rate: A Univariate & Multivariate Analysis, Integrated Environmental Services, Irvine, CA, 1994. 60. Liu, K., Girman, J.R., Hayward, S.B., Shusterman, D., and Chang, Y. Unintentional carbon monoxide deaths in California from charcoal grills and hibachis, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 3, 143, 1993. 61. Girman, J.R., Chang, Y.-L., Hayward, S.B., and Liu, K.-S. Causes of unintentional deaths from carbon monoxide poisonings in California, West. J. Med., 168, 158, 1998. 62. Yoon, S.S., Macdonald, S.C., and Parrish, R.G. Deaths from unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning and potential for prevention with carbon monoxide detectors, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 279, 685, 1998. 63. National Center for Health Statistics and U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Death certificate file, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, 1992. 64. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Preventing Carbon Monoxide Poisoning from Small Gasoline-Powered Engines and Tools [NIOSH alert], Report No. DHHS (NIOSH) 96–118, Public Health Service, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Cincinnati, OH, 1996. 65. Tucker, M., Eichold, B., Lofgren, J.P., Holmes, I., Irvin, D., Villanacci, J., Ryan, J., et al. Carbon monoxide poisonings after two major hurricanes—Alabama and Texas, August – October 2005, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 55, 236, 2006. 66. Sniffen, J.C., Cooper, T.W., Johnson, D., Blackmore, C., Patel, P., Harduar-Morano, L., Sanderson, R., et al. Carbon monoxide poisoning from hurricane-associated use of portable generators - FL, 2004, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 54, 697, 2005. 67. Pedersen, D.H., and Sieber, W.K. National Occupational Exposure Survey, Volume III: Analysis of Management Interview Responses, Report No. PB90-193640, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1988. 68. Bellin, P. and Spengler, J.D. Indoor and outdoor carbon monoxide measurements at an airport, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 30, 392, 1980.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 37 — #33
38
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 69. McCammon, C.S., Halperin, W.F., and Lemin, R.A. Carbon monoxide exposure from aircraft fueling vehicles, Arch. Environ. Health, 36, 136, 1981. 70. Limasset, J., Diebold, F., and Hubert, G. Assessment of bus drivers’ exposure to the pollutants of urban traffic, Sci. Total Environ., 134, 39, 1993. 71. Kahler, M., Kuhse, W., and Wintermeyer, L.A. Unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning from indoor use of pressure washers - Iowa, January 1992–January 1993, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 42, 777, 1993. 72. Bünger, J., Bombosch, F., Mesecke, U., and Hallier, E. Monitoring and analysis of occupational exposure to chain saw exhausts, Am. Ind. Hygiene Assoc. J., 58, 747, 1997. 73. Baucom, C.D., Freeman, J.I., and MacCormack, J.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning in a garment-manufacturing plant - North Carolina, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 36, 543, 1987. 74. Fawcett, T.A., Moon, R.E., Francia, P.J., Mebane, G.Y., Theil, D.R., and Piantadosi, C.A. Warehouse workers headache: carbon monoxide poisoning from propane-fueled forklifts, J. Occup. Med., 34, 12, 1992. 75. Ely, E.W., Moorehead, B., and Haponik, E.F. Warehouse workers’ headache: emergency evaluation and management of 30 patients with carbon monoxide poisoning, Am. J. Med., 98, 145, 1995. 76. McCammon, J.B., McKenzie, L.E., Heinzman, M. Carbon monoxide poisoning related to the indoor use of propane-fueled forklifts in Colorado workplaces, Appl. Occup. Environ. Hyg., 11, 192, 1996. 77. Apte, M. A population-based exposure assessment methodology for carbon monoxide: development of a carbon monoxide passive sampler and occupational dosimeter, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 1997. 78. Apte, M.G., Cox, D.D., Hammond, S.K., and Gundel, L.A. A new carbon monoxide occupational dosimeter: results from a worker exposure assessment survey, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 9, 546, 1999. 79. Gourdeau, P., Parent, M., and Soulard, A. Exposition à l’oxyde de carbone dans les garages d’automobiles: évaluation chez les mécaniciens, Canada J. of Public Health, 86, 414, 1995. 80. Boeniger, M.F. Description of Facilities and Employee Exposure to Carbon Monoxide at Four Different Bridge and Tunnel Toll Authorities in the United States, Report No. IWS-45-02, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Division of Surveillance, Field Studies, Hazard Evaluations, Cincinnati, OH, 1995. 81. Raaschou-Nielsen, O., Nielsen, M.L., and Gehl, J. Traffic-related air pollution: exposure and health effects in Copenhagen street cleaners and cemetery workers, Arch. Environ. Health, 50, 207, 1995. 82. Kamei, M. and Yanagisawa, Y. Estimation of CO exposure of road construction workers in tunnel, Ind. Health, 35, 119, 1997. 83. Flachsbart, P.G. and Ott, W.R. A rapid method for surveying CO concentrations in high-rise buildings, Environ. Int., 12, 255, 1986. 84. Flachsbart, P.G. and Brown, D.E. Surveys of Personal Exposure to Vehicle Exhaust in Honolulu Microenvironments., Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, HI, 1985. 85. Flachsbart, P.G. and Brown, D.E. Employee exposure to motor vehicle exhaust at a Honolulu shopping center, J. Archit. Plan. Res., 6, 19, 1989. 86. Bach, W. and Lennon, K. Air pollution and health at Ala Moana Shopping Center in Honolulu, Hawaii Med. J., 31, 104, 1972.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 38 — #34
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
39
87. Simeone, L.F. The Intrusion of Engine Exhaust into the Passenger Areas of Recreational Power Boats, Report No. DOT-VNTSC-CG-91-1, John A. Volpe National Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge, MA, 1991. 88. Snook, L.M. An investigation of driver exposure to carbon monoxide while traveling in the wake of a snowmobile, Ph.D. thesis, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, 1996. 89. Wilkinson, T. Snowed under, National Parks, 69, 32, 1995. 90. Snook, L.M. and Davis, W.T. An investigation of driver exposure to carbon monoxide while traveling in the wake of a snowmobile, Paper No. 97-RP143.02 presented at the 90th Annual Meeting of the Air & Waste Management Association, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, 1997. 91. Kwok, P.W. Reduction of carbon monoxide in indoor skating arenas, Environ. Health Rev., 25, 60, 1981. 92. Sorensen, A.J. The importance of monitoring carbon monoxide levels in indoor ice skating rinks, J. Am. Coll. Health, 34, 185, 1986. 93. Miller, R.K., Ryan, M.C., and Bilowus, P. Carbon monoxide poisoning in indoor ice skating arenas, Va. Med., 116, 74, 1989. 94. Lévesque, B., Dewailly, E., Lavoie, R., Prud’Homme, D., and Allaire, S. Carbon monoxide in indoor ice skating rinks: evaluation of absorption by adult hockey players, Am. J. Public Health, 80, 594, 1990. 95. Lévesque, B., Lavoie, R., Dewailly, E., Prud’Homme, D., and Allaire, S. An experiment to evaluate carbon monoxide absorption by hockey players in ice skating rinks, Vet. Hum. Toxicol., 33, 5, 1991. 96. Lee, K., Yanagisawa, Y., and Spengler, J.D. Carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide levels in an indoor ice skating rink with mitigation methods, Air Waste, 43, 769, 1993. 97. Lee, K., Yanagisawa, Y., Spengler, J.D., and Nakai, S. Carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide exposures in indoor ice skating rinks, J. Sports Sci., 12, 279, 1994. 98. Spengler, J.D., Stone, K.R., and Lilley, F.W. High carbon monoxide levels measured in enclosed skating rinks, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 28, 776, 1978. 99. Paulozzi, L.J., Satink, F., and Spengler, R.F. A carbon monoxide mass poisoning at an ice arena in Vermont, Am. J. Public Health, 81, 222, 1991. 100. Smith, W., Anderson, T., Anderson, H.A., and Remington, P.L. Nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide intoxication in an indoor ice arena - Wisconsin, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 41, 383, 1992. 101. Paulozzi, L.J., Spengler, R.F., Vogt, R.L., and Carney, J.K. A survey of carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide in indoor ice areas in Vermont, J. Environ. Health, 56, 23, 1993. 102. Hampson, N.B. Carbon monoxide poisoning at an indoor ice arena and bingo hall Seattle, 1996 [reprint of MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 45, 265, 1996] JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 275, 1468, 1996. 103. Boudreau, D.R., Spadafora, M.P., Wolf, L.R., and Siegel, E. Carbon monoxide levels during indoor sporting events - Cincinnati, 1992–1993 [reprint of MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 43, 21] J. Am. Med. Assoc., 271, 419, 1994. 104. Luckurst, D.G. and Solkoski, G. Carbon monoxide levels in indoor “tractor-pull events”—Manitoba, Can. Dis. Wkly. Rep., 16, 79, 1990. 105. Lévesque, B., Allaire, S., Prud’Homme, D., Rhainds, M., Lebel, G., Bellemarre, D., and Dupuis, K. Indoor motocross competitions: air quality evaluation, Am. Ind. Hygiene Assoc. J., 58, 286, 1997. 106. Colvile, R.N., Hutchinson, E.J., Mindell, J.S., and Warren, R.F. The transport sector as a source of air pollution, Atmos. Environ., 35, 1537, 2001.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 39 — #35
40
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 107. Petersen, W. and Allen, R. Carbon monoxide exposures to Los Angeles area commuters, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 32, 826, 1982. 108. Shikiya, D., Liu, C., Kahn, M., Juarros, J., and Barcikowski, W. In-vehicle Air Toxics Characterization Study in the South Coast Air Basin, South Coast Air Quality Management District, El Monte, CA, 1989. 109. Kleiner, B.C. and Spengler, J.D. Carbon monoxide exposures of Boston bicyclists, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 26, 147, 1976. 110. Holland, D.M. Carbon monoxide levels in microenvironment types of four U.S. cities, Environ. Int., 9, 369, 1983. 111. Flachsbart, P.G., Mack, G.A., Howes, J.E., and Rodes, C.E. Carbon monoxide exposures of Washington commuters, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 37, 135, 1987. 112. Chan, C.-C., Ozkaynak, H., Spengler, J.D., and Sheldon, L. Driver exposure to volatile organic compounds, CO, ozone, and NO2 under different driving conditions, Environ. Sci. Technol., 25, 964, 1991. 113. Flachsbart, P., Ott, W., and Switzer, P. Long-term trends in exposure to carbon monoxide on a California arterial highway, Paper No. 69237 presented at the 96th Annual Meeting of the Air & Waste Management Association, San Diego, CA, 2003. 114. Ott, WR., Mage, D.T., and Thomas, J. Comparison of microenvironmental CO concentrations in two cities for human exposure modeling, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 2, 249, 1992. 115. Amiro, A. CO presents public health problems, J. Environ. Health, 32, 83, 1969. 116. Clements, J. School Bus Carbon Monoxide Intrusion, Report No. DOT-HS-803-705, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation, Washington, D.C., 1978. 117. Ziskind, R., Rogozen, M., Carlin, T., and Drago, R. Carbon monoxide intrusion into sustained-use vehicles, Environ. Int., 5, 109, 1981. 118. Hampson, N.B. and Norkool, D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning in children riding in the back of pickup trucks, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 267, 538, 1992. 119. Trompeo, G., Turletti, G., and Giarusso, O. Concentrations of carbon monoxide in underground garages, Rassegna di Medicina Industriale, 33, 392, 1964. 120. Chovin, P. CO, analysis of exhaust gas investigations in Paris, Environ. Res., 1, 198, 1967. 121. Goldsmith, J. Contribution of motor vehicle exhaust, industry, and cigarette smoking to community CO exposures, Ann. NY Acad. Sci., 15, 122, 1970. 122. Amendola, A. and Hanes, N. Characterization of indoor carbon monoxide levels produced by the automobile, In Indoor Air Volume 4, Chemical Characterization and Personal Exposure, NTIS Report No. PB85-104214, Berglund, B. et al., eds., Swedish Council for Building Research, Stockholm, 1984, 97–102. 123. Wilson, A.L., Colome, S.D., and Tian, Y. Air Toxics Microenvironment Exposure and Monitoring Study, South Coast Air Quality Management District, El Monte, CA, 1991. 124. Myronuk, D. Augmented ingestion of carbon monoxide and sulfur oxides by occupants of vehicles while idling in drive-up facility lines, Water Air Soil Pollut., 7, 203, 1977. 125. Wheatley, A.D., Sadhra, S., and Beach, J.R. Exposure to toxic gas and particle phase pollutants evolved during deployment of airbags in vehicles, Indoor Environ., 6, 134, 1997. 126. Flachsbart, P.G. Human exposure to carbon monoxide from mobile sources, In Carbon Monoxide, Khalil, M.A.K., Pinto, J.P., and Shearer, M.J., eds. [special issue of papers
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 40 — #36
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
127. 128.
129. 130.
131.
132.
133. 134. 135. 136.
137.
138.
139. 140.
41
from an international conference, December, 1997, Portland, OR] Chemosphere: Global Change Science, 1, 301, 1999. Transportation Research Board. Expanding Metropolitan Highways: Implications for Air Quality and Energy Use, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 1995. Flachsbart, P.G. Long-term trends in United States highway emissions, ambient concentrations, and in-vehicle exposure to carbon monoxide in traffic, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 5, 473, 1995. Haagen-Smit, A.J. Carbon monoxide levels in city driving, Arch. Environ. Health, 12, 548, 1966. Lawryk, N.J., Lioy, P.J., and Weisel, C.P. Exposure to volatile organic compounds in the passenger compartment of automobiles during periods of normal and malfunctioning operation, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 5, 511, 1995. Systems Applications, Inc. Human Exposure to Atmospheric Concentrations of Selected Chemicals, Vol. II, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1983. Stewart, R.D., Fisher, T.N., Hosko, M.J., Peterson, J.E., Baretta, E.D., and Dodd, H. C. Experimental human exposure to methylene chloride, Arch. Environ. Health, 25, 342, 1972. Stewart, R.D. and Hake, C.L. Paint-remover hazard, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 235, 398, 1976. Buie, S.E., Pratt, D.S., and May, J.J. Diffuse pulmonary injury following paint remover exposure, Am. J. Med., 81, 702, 1986. Peterson, J.E. Modeling the uptake, metabolism and excretion of dichloromethane by man, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 39, 41, 1978. ACGIH. Threshold Limit Values for Chemical Substances and PhysicalAgents: Biological Exposure Indices, American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, Cincinnati, OH, 1996. U.S. EPA. Health Assessment Document for Dichloromethane Methylene Chloride, Report No. EPA/600/8-82/004F, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1985. Shusterman, D., Quinlan, P., Lowengart, R., and Cone, J. Methylene chloride intoxication in a furniture refinisher: a comparison of exposure estimates utilizing workplace air sampling and blood carboxyhemoglobin measurements, J. Occup. Med., 32, 451, 1990. Ghittori, S., Marraccini, P., Franco, G., and Imbriani, M. Methylene chloride exposure in industrial workers, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 54, 27, 1993. Leikin, J.B., Kaufman, D., Lipscomb, J.W., Burda, A.M., and Hryhorczuk, D.O. Methylene chloride: report of five exposures and two deaths, Am. J. Emerg. Med., 8, 534, 1990.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 41 — #37
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 42 — #38
3
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures Robert E. Engberg
CONTENTS 3.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Carbon Monoxide Safety and Monitoring Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Metabolic Uptake of Oxygen and Room Air Ventilation for Humans . . . 3.4 The Tracer Gas Model for Predicting CO Accumulation in Structures . . 3.5 Ventilation Requirements for Humans in Small Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 Oxygen Depletion Sensor Applications to Small Burners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7 Combustion Equations for Gas Burners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.8 Carbon Monoxide Accumulation Due to Small Engine Exhaust Gases . . 3.9 OSHA and Industry Standards for CO Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.10 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43 44 45 47 48 48 50 53 54 54 55
3.1 INTRODUCTION The problem of carbon monoxide (CO) production within habitable enclosures (i.e., breathing spaces) has been a chronic problem since the use of hydrocarbon fuels became widespread. We know that CO generation from these fuel sources is commonly caused by the lack of, or starvation of, adequate oxygen during the combustion process whether in a heating appliance, engine, or lighting fixture. The creation of CO becomes a problem when it enters an occupied space used by living creatures, either by accident or by design. Humans cannot sense such occult emissions until the blood saturation with CO begins to affect coordination and mental state. CO is transparent and colorless to the occupant of the space, as well as being odorless and nonirritative. When CO is discovered in significant concentration in a breathing space, the occupants may suffer sickness and even death. The presence of CO is not usually suspected in an enclosed space until dangerous levels are reached. CO generation from burning hydrocarbon fuels in combustion devices is due most often to improper fuel–air combustion ratios. This can be caused by oxygen starvation 43
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 43 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
44
at the burner and by improper setting of the fuel–air ratio at the appliance. Testing of combustion devices installed in small enclosures reveals that 4–5 air changes per hour (ACH) is necessary to allow the device to operate safely and not generate a CO concentration of greater than 100 parts per million (ppm). Experience shows that the fuel–air ratio of the burner can be easily upset by lack of inspection and maintenance of the combustion device. Primary air adjustment shutters are commonly obstructed by the collection of dust and lint, while combustion air passages can become restricted or exhaust ventilation ducts plugged. This causes the production of CO in closed spaces. It was not until the 1980s that the use of burner safety devices were legislated and used within the United States to attack the problem of CO deaths and injuries in closed breathing spaces. During the past 10 years, manufacturers of small portable heating appliances have designed and installed burner safety devices to affect shutdown under ambient conditions that might produce dangerous levels of CO. The most common and simple safety device built into fuel consuming appliances has been the oxygen depletion sensor (ODS). It is incorporated into the flame safety system of most burners. A typical ODS consists of a thermocouple that senses flame outage and acts to shut down the fuel valve and the pilot flame. This combination makes up the typical flame safety and ODS assembly on a fuel-burning device. A second option has been to incorporate a CO sensor into devices such as gas engines. The past decades have brought national and state codes and standards to bear in an effort to eliminate CO hazards in fuel burning devices, and in building construction standards and techniques. The American National Standards Institute (ANSI), the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), Underwriters Laboratory (UL), Canadian Gas Association (CGA) and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) are at the forefront as agencies that write and enforce CO safety device requirements in commercial products and building construction. One example of a standard is the requirement for minimum exhaust concentration limits generated within a test enclosure that is heated with a liquefied petroleum (LP) gas fueled, infrared (IR) camp type heaters (ANSI and CGA). Technology has greatly advanced in CO monitoring techniques and the measurement of environmental conditions. We can now estimate the oxygen uptake of a human at a given activity level in a closed space, in the presence of CO being produced by a malfunctioning heater operating under specified air exchange and combustion rates. We will discuss each of these techniques in the following sections.
3.2 CARBON MONOXIDE SAFETY AND MONITORING DEVICES It has become commonplace to install CO sensors in breathing spaces that have the potential of accumulating CO due to fuel combustion by heating appliances and engines. CO alarms are available at most hardware and home supply stores. The law requires CO monitors in most new house and apartment construction. For the UL
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 44 — #2
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
45
standards governing the set points of common CO alarms see Chapter 28 in this book. The way UL has set up the standards, lower CO concentrations take longer to produce audible alarm while higher CO concentrations trip the alarm in less time. The intent is to roughly model the rate of CO uptake by humans. Other types of CO monitors are designed for marine engine rooms, industrial environments, and so forth. Monitoring and data logging CO sensors are available for personal use, where walk around monitoring of an indoor environment may be needed. These units are available in pocket-sized and handheld models that record data from the environment at preset time intervals and store the data for downloading to computer for later display and interpretation. As stated above, the ODS has become popular for the safe shutdown of burner systems. The device has a calibrated shutdown feature that gauges ambient oxygen concentration by changing flame shape. The predetermined pilot flame will degrade in shape with the reduction of ambient oxygen. When this happens, the flame moves off the thermocouple, causing thermocouple output current to decline, which trips a gas valve, shutting down the burner. This principle was developed in Europe. The ODS has been a common safety device required on gas heating appliances since the 1970s. The pilot flame is a common safety device used with gas fueled appliances. It has been used successfully for many decades in the United States and Europe. It assures the ignition of any gas fumes or vapors around the burner and serves to ignite the burner. Its continued operation is also monitored through the use of a thermocouple that senses pilot flame heat. Pilot flames may be ignited either by a match or the everpopular piezoelectric spark igniter. The latter has become an added safety feature on gas burning appliances, since no open continuously burning flame is present, which might present a fire hazard and also consumes fuel over time. Exhaust stack gas analyzers are another type of CO sensor used to monitor boiler burner combustion efficiency. These handheld analyzers and monitors can be used to data-log exhaust stack conditions in terms of CO, oxygen, and carbon dioxide. They may also monitor other burner characteristics such as temperature, draft, excess air, and unburned hydrocarbons. These units also allow burner overall efficiency to be computed in a continuous fashion. Placing a thermocouple near the burner screen on an LP-fueled camp heaters is another safety device. One characteristic of some infrared heaters is the variation of burner screen temperature with respect to declining oxygen levels in a heated breathing space. The manufacturer may chose to design the screen-thermocouple such that it will shut down the burner with decreasing oxygen levels. This will occur before burner CO production is excessive. The details of this option are discussed later in this chapter.
3.3 METABOLIC UPTAKE OF OXYGEN AND ROOM AIR VENTILATION FOR HUMANS A major concern for humans occupying a small breathing space is the provision for adequate ventilation of that space for creature comfort, health, and safety. One design
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 45 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
46
question is just how much oxygen is consumed by the human body and how much ventilation is needed. To do that we must estimate the oxygen uptake of the human body. Coupled with this concern will be determining the oxygen depletion within the space that can be expected or allowed. For a description of the metabolic variables necessary for this calculation see Reference 1. All of these variables and concerns are best addressed by an example of a typical breathing space and occupant model. Such an example might be two hunters sleeping in a camp tent. The parameters that will be assumed for this calculation are as follows: 1. A tent will be of a cabin-type design, with nominal floor dimensions of 7.5 × 9.5 × 6.0 ft. (w × l × h), respectively, or 235 cu. ft., approximately. The tent will have been treated with a water repellent coating. 2. Two men sleeping and each weighing 200 pounds, no outdoor wind, and all tent windows and opening flaps closed. 3. A propane fueled, infrared heater set at a low heat setting of 8000 BTU/h, using commercial propane with a higher heating value (HHV) of 2550 BTU/cu. ft.2 4. Ambient air having 20.9% oxygen, and a design lower limit of 18.5% oxygen, where CO begins to be generated when using a typical camp heater. The mathematical variables used in the following equations and calculations are defined as follows with their associated units denoted in [… ..]: ACH = Vm /Ve , where Vm = minimum rate of fresh airflow per person, [cu. ft./h] and Ve = volume of the enclosure [cu. ft.]. M = metabolic rate (met) for a human is given as, 1 met = 18.4 [BTU/h * sq. ft.]. And M = 567(0.23∗ RQ+0.77)∗ QO2 /Ad, where RQ = 0.83 for light and sedentary activity; QO2 = volumetric rate of oxygen consumption at conditions (STPD) of 32◦ F, 14.7 psi (std. atm.) [cu. ft./h], and for a sleeping man the value to be used is M = 13 BTU/h*sq. ft. Now, solving for the oxygen uptake: QO2 = 13∗ 19.6/567∗ (0.23∗ 0.83 + 0.77) = 0.47 cu. ft./h. So, for two men, the oxygen uptake in the tent will be 0.94 cu. ft./h. Now, from our defined limits of minimum oxygen reduction in this space, we have: QO2 avail = (0.209 − 0.185)∗ V = 0.024∗ 235 = 5.64 cu. ft. of oxygen available. We next consider the oxygen uptake by the LP, infrared camp heater set at the “low” heat position, with a fuel flow as defined above. Using the HHV for propane vapor as 2550 BTU/cu. ft. (Reference 2, p. 24) and the stoichiometric combustion of propane, (volume of oxygen reacting for each volume of LP vapor is 5), we have: VO2 /VLP = 5 Therefore, when operating at the ‘low’ heat setting of 8000 BTU/h, we get: VLP = 8000/2550 = 3.137 cu. ft./h of propane used.
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 46 — #4
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
47
Next, the volume of oxygen utilized by the heater becomes VO2 = 5∗ 3.137 = 15.69 cu. ft./h. The time (t) needed to bring the oxygen level down to the critical minimum level at the onset of CO production will be: t = QO2 avail /(VO2 +2∗QO2 ) = 5.64/(15.69 + 0.94) = 5.64/16.62 = 0.339 h or 20.4 min. We can expect that after this amount of time spent in the tent, CO will begin to be generated by the heater assuming that no air exchange, or infiltration, has occurred during this period of time. The next job is to estimate the amount of infiltration air (ACH) that will be needed to maintain the oxygen level within the tent above 18.5%, remembering that the heater and the two men are competing for the available oxygen. We first write the equation that: QO2 (consumed) = QO2 (infiltrated) = 15.69 + 0.94) = 16.63 cu. ft./h = (0.209 − 0.185)∗ Vair , so, Vair = 16.63/0.024 = 692.7 cu. ft. of air exchange. Thus, ACH = Vm /Ve = 692.7/235 = 2.95 air changes per hour are needed to maintain an 18.5% level of oxygen in the tent. This value for ACH is in good agreement with experimental values for ACH required for LP heaters to not accumulate CO in closed breathing spaces.3
3.4 THE TRACER GAS MODEL FOR PREDICTING CO ACCUMULATION IN STRUCTURES This approach allows one to predict ACH for any enclosure. It is assumed that the tracer gas is distributed uniformly in the initial charge of fugitive gas used for this measurement. It is also assumed that air infiltration into the structure is uniformly distributed throughout the space. The typical tracer gas used for this measurement is sulfur hexafluoride (SF6 ). Its concentration (C) is described by the equation Ct = Co e−kt and solving for kt, ln (Ct /Co ) = −kt The latter equation indicates that a semilog plot of the quantity ln (Ct /Co ) versus time will be linear with time and that the ACH, (k) will be equal to the slope of this line. Since this line is expected to be linear, linear regression can be used to fit a line to the data and the expression describing how well the line fits the data is R2 , where R is the correlation coefficient. Assume that if testing yields an R2 greater than 0.9, then the test is acceptable. Now, if the ACH (k) is known, then the source strength (S) for CO generation of the heater can be computed from a simple mass balance of CO in the chamber. The equation predicting the CO generation rate is St(i+1) =
V ∗ k[Ct(i+1) − Ct(i) ∗ e−k{ti+1 −ti } ] , [1 − e−k{ti+1 −ti } ]
where V = the tent volume; St(i+1) is the generation rate of CO at time ti+1 , k = ACH, Ct(i+1) is the concentration of CO at time ti+1 and Ct(i) is the concentration of CO at time ti . The above equation was derived based on the assumption that the air in the
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 47 — #5
48
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
chamber is well mixed and that CO is not absorbed or adsorbed into the tent material or its contents.
3.5 VENTILATION REQUIREMENTS FOR HUMANS IN SMALL STRUCTURES The ventilation rate for a small enclosure is much the same as for larger spaces that are designed for occupation by humans. The American Society of Heating, Refrigeration, and Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) standard 62 specifies guidelines for the minimum ventilation airflow rate for various habitable structures. A flow rate of 15 scfm per person is a common requirement for residential structures. This flow rate will provide enough air to maintain the normal oxygen level for an average adult and will remove most pollutants as they accumulate in typical spaces. To reiterate, the oxygen depletion due to its uptake by two adults using a small camp heater within a tent space requires a minimum of about 3–6 ACH to supply enough oxygen to allow proper metabolism and to prevent the dangerous accumulation of CO. One must look at the geometry of the tent to predict whether the ACH will be effective for the occupants. Please make reference to the ASHRAE Fundamentals Handbook 1 that describes the dynamics of ventilation in a breathing space. It asks designers to incorporate cross ventilation such that lower air levels are systematically exchanged at the prescribed rate. This prevents vent gases or other pollutants from settling down and accumulating in sleeping areas. The method of cross ventilation that incorporates a low level air entry opening with an upper level exhaust or discharge opening of equal area is the optimum design, as it promotes thermal differences and relative ambient winds to power air exchange within the space. The designer should use, as a rule of thumb, about 1 sq. in. per 1000 BTU/h of burner capacity. The definition of a confined space is considered to be 50 cu. ft. for each 1000 BTU/h of input burner rating. No single vent opening dimension should be less than 3 in. This ventilation flow rate will translate to an ACH in the tent computation to be: ACH = 15 cu. ft./min*60 min/h/235 cu. ft. = 3.83. We may compare this value with the calculated ventilation needed to maintain the minimum oxygen level for combustion in the above example of 2.95 ACH. Clearly, a ventilation rate to avoid CO buildup was about 6.0 ACH as shown in Reference 3. This resulted in less than 100 ppm CO.
3.6 OXYGEN DEPLETION SENSOR APPLICATIONS TO SMALL BURNERS An ODS system is simply a pilot burner whose flame impinges on a thermocouple that in turn powers a gas safety valve electromagnet. What is unique about an ODS is the tripping of the gas safety valve at a specified level of oxygen depletion. The tent enclosure computation above specified the oxygen safety valve trip level was 18.5%, as compared to a normal ambient oxygen concentration of 20.9%. Codes and
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 48 — #6
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
49
standards recognize that it is not healthy or safe for humans to function in oxygen reduced atmospheres (<18%) for more than 8 h. The theory of ODS operation is based on flame geometry changing during a reduction in ambient oxygen (Figure 3.1). Change in position of the pilot flame with respect to the thermocouple allows the thermocouple tip to cool to a point that will cause the electromagnet to trip the safety valve, shutting off the heater’s burner. Safety shutdown is typically designed to occur at 18.5% ambient oxygen. This oxygen level is above the threshold that will cause excessive CO to be produced within the burner. Typical ODS flame geometry changes are shown in Figure 3.1. The ODS was developed and used extensively in Europe for 30 years prior to it being adopted in the United States in 1980. It was first mandated here on ventless,
Pilot burner Thermo couple
Ignition plug
Gas
Pilot burner Thermo couple
Ignition plug
Pilot burner Thermo couple
Ignition plug
Gas
FIGURE 3.1 Operation of an oxygen depletion sensor. Upper panel: Normal operation— 20.9% oxygen. Pilot flame touches tip of thermocouple, generating the thermoelectricity needed to hold the safety valve open. Middle panel: Oxygen level dropping—19% oxygen. The flame begins to lift off the precision pilot burner. The thermocouple begins to cool. Lower panel: Safety shutdown—18% oxygen. The unstable pilot flame moves away from the thermocouple to stop generating the electricity needed to hold the spring-loaded safety valve open. The heater shuts down. (Source: Adapted from a sales brochure, no copyright, ca. 1996.)
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 49 — #7
50
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
gas space heaters. In the late 1990s, this safety device was beginning to be applied to gas heaters used by the hunters, campers, and the recreational industry generally for satisfying the demand for safe, small, infrared, and catalytic heaters. Many infrared camp heater designs use LP gas to fuel the main burner at relatively high vapor pressures, that is, typically 7–15 psig. Pressure at the burner orifice or gas tip is controlled by a gas regulator on the heater control panel, that is, the heat setting control knob. This knob usually adjusts the regulator to about 7 psig in the low heat range and to about 15 psig in the heater’s high heat range. These regulator pressures are problematic for the ODS pilot burner, because it usually operates at about 3–5 inches water column (in. w.c.), or approximately 0.11–0.18 psig. One solution for this problem is to add a second stage regulator that reduces the high pressure going to the main burner regulator to a lower pressure. Normally, some pilot flame shielding is required to deflect radiated heat from the main burner and also to shield the small ODS flame from wind and drafts, thus stabilizing the ODS flame’s play on the thermocouple. The approximate heat output of a typical ODS flame at 3.5 in. w.c. pressure, using a 0.00665 in. diameter, 60◦ orifice angle, will be 175 BTU/h. This is the maximum amount of gas that may pass through the pilot burner without having a code required safety valve to shut off the pilot gas flow when flame outage occurs. It may be desirable to relax this orifice diameter in order to fit a commercially available drill bit size, for example, 0.006 in. Using this bit and the 175 BTU/h code limitation, we can use a 5.3 in. w.c. orifice pressure. This will produce a desired maximum gas flow and satisfy the safety code. The burner system designer may now determine the most economical arrangement of gas safety shutdown piping and equipment for his product. Also, the heater designer has the choice of commercially available vertical, angled, and horizontally mounted ODS designs in order to best accommodate his design preferences. Some other ODS variants have been used by Copreci, an Italian manufacturer.
3.7 COMBUSTION EQUATIONS FOR GAS BURNERS The reader is advised to refer to Reference 4 for a complete summary of formulae to determine the products of combustion for gaseous fuels such as propane and butane that are typically used to fuel space and construction heaters for small volume enclosures. This reference also details the combustion analysis that relates the amount of combustion air needed for the stoichiometric combustion of various gaseous fuels. Such an equation for the stoichiometric or theoretical oxidation of propane will be Balanced equation: C3 H8 + 5O2 = 3CO2 + 4H2 O Molecular weights: 44.094 + 5∗ 32 = 3∗ 44.01 + 4∗ 18.016 Relative combining weights: 1 lb + 3.629 lb = 2.995 lb + 1.634 lb Combustion data for typical hydrocarbon fuels are given in Table 3.1.2 Additional combustion data and LP-gas properties are found in reference 4. It should be remembered that commercial propane (i.e., LP-gas) contains a number of other hydrocarbons that are limited by the HD5 or HD-5, P grade specification. That is,
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 50 — #8
CH4 C2 H4 C2 H3 C4 H10 C5 H12 C2 H4 C3 H6 C4 H8 9.55 16.70 23.86 31.02 38.19 14.32 21.48 28.58
Air 2.0 3.5 5.0 6.5 8.0 3.0 4.5 6.0
Oxygen 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 2.0 3.0 4.0
Carbon Dioxide 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 2.0 3.0 4.0
Water Vapor 7.55 13.20 18.86 24.52 30.19 11.31 16.98 22.58
Nitrogen
Products of Combustion ln Cu. FL. formed by Burning 1 cu. ft.
17.24 16.13 15.71 15.49 15.35 14.80 14.80 14.80
Air 3.98 3.73 3.63 3.58 3.54 3.42 3.42 3.42
Oxygen
Pounds Required for Combustion 1 lb. of Gas or Vapor
Source: Handbook Propane–Butane Gases, 4th ed., Chilton Company, Los Angeles, CA, PP. 22,23 1962.
Methane Ethane Propane Butane Pentane Ethylene Propylene Butylene
Chemical Formula
Cubic Feel Required per Cu. Ft. of Gas or Vapor for Combustion
TABLE 3.1 Combustion Data for Hydrocarbons
2.74 2.92 2.99 3.03 3.05 3.13 3.13 3.13
Carbon Dioxide
2.24 1.79 1.63 1.55 1.50 1.28 1.28 1.28
Water Vapor
13.26 12.40 12.08 11.91 11.80 11.38 11.38 11.38
Nitrogen
Products of Combustion in Pounds from Burning One Pound Gas or Vapor
11.7 13.1 13.7 14.0 14.2 15.0 15.0 15.0
Ultimate Carbon Dioxide ln Flue Products Percent
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 51 — #9
51
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
52
TABLE 3.2 Physical and Chemical Properties of LP-Gasa Propane Formula Boiling point (◦ F) Specific gravity of gas (air = 1.00) Specific gravity of liquid (water = 1.00) lb per gallon of liquid at 60◦ F BTU per gallon of gas at 60◦ F BTU per lb. of gas BTU per cu. ft. of gas at 60◦ F cu. ft. of vapor (at 60◦ F) gallon cu. ft. of vapor (at 60◦ F) lb Latent heat of vaporization at boiling point BTU per gallon Combustion data cu. ft. air required to burn 1 cu. ft. gas Flash point (◦ F) Ignition temperature in air (◦ F) Maximum flame temperature in air (◦ F) Limits of flammability percentage of gas in air mixture At lower limit (%) At upper limit (%) Octane number (ISO-Octane = 100)
Butane
C3 H8 −44 1.50 0.504 4.20 91,502 21,548 2488 36.38 8.66 773
C4 H10 15 2.01 0.582 4.81 102,032 21,221 3280 31.26 6.51 808
23.86 −156 920–1120
31.02 N.A. 900–1000
3,595
3,615
2.15 9.6
1.55 8.6
Over 100
92
a Commercial quality. Figures shown in this chart represent average values.
Source: LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual Engineered Controls International, Inc. (Reg O), Elon College, NC, pp. 2,3, 1962, Revised March, 2000.
propane must constitute a minimum of 90.0% of the gas, propylene can be at most 5.0%, and the butanes and heavier aliphatics must not exceed 2.5%. For a summary of the properties of commercial propane and butane, the reader is referred to Table 3.2.5 The LP-gas is to have a vapor pressure at 100◦ F of greater than 175, but not exceeding 208 psig (Table 3.3). Other reference sources are 4 and 6. It is sometimes necessary to compute CO in combustion products in a specific manner to comply with industry standards as defined on an free-air basis. Instruments can determine the amount of CO on an air-free basis by first measuring the amount of oxygen and CO present in the sample, then using the following equation to calculate CO on a free-air basis: CO air-free = 20.9∗ CO/(20.9 − O2 %)
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 52 — #10
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
53
TABLE 3.3 Vapor Pressures of LP-Gasesa Temperature (◦ F) (◦ C) −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110
−40 −34 −29 −23 −18 −12 −7 −1 4 10 16 21 27 32 38 43
Approximate Pressure (PSIG) Propane Butane 3.6 8 13.5 23.3 28 37 47 58 72 86 102 127 140 165 196 220
3.0 6.9 12 17 23 29 36 45
a Conversion formula: Degrees C = (◦ F − 32) × 5/9
Degrees F = (9/5 ×◦ C) + 32 Source: LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual, Engineered Controls International, Inc. (Reg O), Elon College, NC, pp. 2,3, 1962, Revised March, 2000.
This computation compensates for the amount of excess air provided by the burner. Excess air from a burner dilutes the products of combustion and causes a test for CO to be understated. A CO air-free measurement eliminates the excess air dilution.
3.8 CARBON MONOXIDE ACCUMULATION DUE TO SMALL ENGINE EXHAUST GASES Some serious injuries and deaths have occurred because the general public is not fully aware of the latent danger in operating internal combustion engines in confined breathing spaces or in poorly ventilated structures. An analysis of the combustion products or exhaust gases from engines fueled by hydrocarbons shows they generally produce CO in great abundance as compared to burners in various heaters and lighting appliances. As a comparison, a gas burning appliance will be “red tagged” in many municipalities if its flue products contain an excess of 400 ppm of CO. Some states have limited the legal level of CO in the automobile engine exhaust at 1.2%. Precatalytic CO production in typical gasoline engines is 12,000 ppm CO or more. A poorly tuned gasoline engine may produce 30 times the CO that a misadjusted gas
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 53 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
54
burning appliance will typically generate. In most cases where gasoline engines are operated, engine exhaust is vented directly into the habitable space as opposed to an exhaust stack as with gas burning appliances. Use of a breathing space shared by a running gasoline engine subjects the people to lethal concentrations of CO very quickly and unexpectedly. The consequences of operating a small gasoline engine in a closed space are seen in Reference 7. For example, a 5 hp, four-cycle, gasoline-fueled engine will generate CO at a rate of 1.72 cfm. A simple calculation reveals that for most small structures, a significantly elevated CO concentration will exist there after just a few moments of engine operation. Thus, gasoline-powered engine operation in small rooms becomes hazardous to the occupants very quickly and requires excessive ventilation, that is, many ACH. In fact, the number of ACH necessary to limit CO buildup in such a space may be in excess of 20 just to limit the CO concentration to 400 ppm. The rule of thumb is that small gasoline-fueled engines should NEVER be operated in closed breathing spaces.
3.9 OSHA AND INDUSTRY STANDARDS FOR CO EXPOSURE In times past, a 100 ppm CO exposure level was acceptable for humans over extended periods of time, that is, the 8-h workday. The history of acceptable CO standards for human exposure has been one of a gradual decline in that number over the past 100 years. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and OSHA now use a level of 35 ppm, time-weighted-average (TWA), over 8 h. The concern has been to keep blood carboxyhemoglobin saturation to less than 5% for both chronic exposure in the workplace and for workers with cardiovascular or pulmonary disease. Other approval and standards organizations such as ASHRAE defer in their Standard 62-89 to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standard for outdoor air quality. EPA sets the ambient limit at 9 ppm, averaged over 8 h. EPA also allows exposure to 35 ppm CO or lower, averaged over 1 h. Finally, the ANSI guide number Z21.1, allows the ambient atmosphere surrounding an unvented space heater to achieve a maximum of 200 ppm CO when measured on an air-free basis. On the same basis, a maximum flue gas concentration of 400 ppm is allowed and an unvented gas oven may produce a maximum of 800 ppm. See Section 3.7 for the equation used to calculate CO on a free-air basis. Many state statutes limit flue gas products of combustion for a heating appliance to no more than 400 ppm at anytime in the equipment setup or operating range. Many state and municipal inspectors will “red tag” any fuel burning appliance that is found to exceed that CO limit.
3.10 CONCLUSION The aspects of CO accumulation in small structures introduced by using consumer products such as LP-gas heaters, lanterns, and small gasoline engines motivates a special series of cautions, warnings, designs, and code compliance considerations.
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 54 — #12
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
55
These concerns must be addressed by the consumers, designers, and certainly by the engineers creating products and structures for the stream of commerce. The number of mishaps and associated litigation speaks for the issue of properly operating fuelburning products in small structures such as tents, fishing shanties, campers, garages, and so forth to name just a few. The first aspect of operating these appliances in small breathing spaces must be that of safety for the consumer, that is, public. The chemical and physiological effects of CO have made it a serious design factor for engineers, manufacturers, and consumers alike.
References 1. Berglund, L.G. ASHRAE Handbook-Fundamentals, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air Conditioning Engineers, Inc., Atlanta, GA, pp. 8.6, 8.7, Chapter 8, 2001. 2. Denny, L.C., Luxon L.L. and Hall, B.E. Handbook Propane–Butane Gases, 4th ed., Chilton Company, Los Angeles, CA, pp. 22, 23, 1962. 3. Tucholski, D.R. Technical Feasibility of a CO Shutdown System for Tank-Top Heaters, U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC), Washington, D.C., p. 53, 2005. 4. Reed, R.J. North American Combustion Handbook, 3rd ed., Vol. 1, North American Manufacturing Company, Cleveland, OH, p. 49, 1986. 5. LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual, Engineered Controls International, Inc. (RegO), Elon College, NC, 1962, Revised March, 2000. 6. Segeler, C.G. Editor-in-Chief; Ringler, M.D., Assistant Editor; Kafka, E.M., Technical Assistant, Gas Engineers Handbook, The Industrial Press, New York, NY, pp. 6–33, 1966. 7. Earnest, G.S., Mickelsen, R.L., McCammon, J.B. and O’Brien, D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning from small, gasoline-powered, internal combustion engines: just what is a well-ventilated area? Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 58, 787–791, 1997.
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 55 — #13
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 56 — #14
4
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide into Mobile Homes, Recreational Vehicles, and Other Enclosures Robert E. Schreter
CONTENTS 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4
4.5
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Accident Statistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Codes and Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Potential Sources of Carbon Monoxide within Motor Homes and Other Enclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1 Internal Combustion Engines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1.1 Large Vehicle Propulsion Engines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1.2 Auxiliary Power Generators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2 Interior Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.1 Ranges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.2 Ovens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.3 Gas Refrigerators (LP Gas) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.4 Domestic Water Heaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.5 Gas or Oil-Fired Space Heaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.6 Clothes Dryers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.7 Fireplaces (LP Gas) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.8 Other Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Primer on the Mechanism of Formation of Carbon Monoxide from Fuel-Fired Appliances found in Mobile Homes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.1 The Physical and Chemical Properties of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . 4.5.2 The Combustion Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58 59 59 60 61 62 62 64 64 64 65 65 65 65 66 66 67 67 68
57
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 57 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
58
4.5.2.1
Basic Requirements to Initiate and Perpetuate the Combustion Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.3 Thermochemical Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.4 Excess Air Combustion. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.5 Excess Fuel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 Application of Combustion Theory to Actual Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Situations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.1 Introduction to the Flow of Exhaust Gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.2 Total Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.3 Stagnation Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.4 Thermal Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.5 Air Flow Around and Through Enclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.6 Wind Rose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.7 Scoops, Deflectors, and Openings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.8 Resonance, Cyclical Flow into and out of an Enclosure. . . . . . . . . . 4.6.9 Flow into and out of Living Quarters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.10 Flue and Chimney Dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.11 Back-drafting of Flue Gases into the Enclosure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.12 Dynamics of Generator Tailpipe Exhaust . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.13 Exhaust Flow Through Bent or Displaced Exhaust Pipes . . . . . . . . 4.6.14 Missing Exhaust Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7 Accumulation of Carbon Monoxide within an Enclosure. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.1 Rate of Dissipation of Carbon Monoxide from an Enclosure . . . . 4.8 Test Methods for Determining the Location of Leakage into an Enclosure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.1 Smoke Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.2 Basic Considerations during Smoke Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.3 Positive Pressure Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.4 Negative Pressure Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.5 Typical Smoke Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.9 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
68 69 71 72 72 72 73 75 76 77 78 78 81 82 82 83 83 85 86 87 89 90 91 91 92 92 93 96 96
4.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter deals with nonfire related carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning accidents that occur in mobile homes, live-in trailers, portable offices and other mobile living or work enclosures containing devices that can produce CO or other toxic gases. The flow mechanisms and equations presented apply equally to all stationary buildings subject to wind and thermal activity. I will briefly discuss American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) codes that apply to recreational vehicles, motor homes and the like and stress the code requirements involved in sealing the living compartment against toxic gases and vapors produced externally. This chapter addresses the individual sources that generate CO within the living compartment and sources that are part of the mobile home but external to the living compartment, as well as those produced in the vicinity. It discusses each
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 58 — #2
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
59
of the appliances, the mechanisms by which they produce CO and the expected concentration of CO associated with them. It compares the probability of their entering into life threatening asphyxiations. It also discusses other sources of CO emanating from other vehicles or generators in the vicinity. I will discuss the physical properties and behavior of CO and the mechanism of its formation in various types of appliances and internal combustion engines. It discusses the combustion process, thermochemical equations, and how excess air, excess fuel, mixing of air and fuel and available time for the completion of combustion affect its production. I will introduce the concept of total pressure, including wind and thermal pressure and how these pressures are the driving forces that result in CO penetrating leaks into the living compartment. The chapter covers the application of combustion theory and aerodynamics and how they apply to CO accidents. It discusses how wind and the aerodynamic shapes and openings encountered in mobile homes and other enclosures affect air and gas flow movement into, through, and out of enclosures. There is a general discussion of exhaust systems for internal combustion engines and how they play a role in life threatening CO asphyxiations. It discusses how missing or damaged engine generator tailpipes are major contributors to fatal accidents. This chapter presents methods used to evaluate the rate of accumulation of CO within enclosures. Computational methods used to determine CO concentration at any point in time during the inflow are presented. It also presents computational methods to determine the dissipation of CO during periods where the generating source is shut down or its flow rate curtailed. The methods presented predict the partial pressure within an enclosure and how it may be used in conjunction with the Coburn–Forster– Kane equation to predict carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) in a victim’s blood (see other books in this series). Finally, the chapter discusses methods that may be used to determine the locations of leaks into the living compartment and the magnitude of inflow into the enclosure.
4.2 ACCIDENT STATISTICS Between 1995 and 1999, an estimated 10,200 people reported to hospital emergency rooms each year for nonfire-related CO poisoning injuries associated with consumer products.1 There were more than 500 unintentional nonfire related deaths and injuries resulting from CO-poisoning accidents associated with the use of consumer products. An average of 22 deaths per year was associated with engine-driven generators and engine-driven products, which includes deaths associated with mobile homes. Between 1993 and 1997 deaths from motor vehicle exhausts, averaged 534 annually. Many CO accidents are not recognized, and because of data collection problems, many cases go unreported. Nonfatal injuries mostly go unreported, therefore, there are few accurate statistics.
4.3 CODES AND STANDARDS TheANSI 119.2,2 and NFPA501c3 have written and promulgated standards applicable to CO in mobile homes and recreational vehicles. The standards cover fire and life
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 59 — #3
60
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
safety criteria for recreational vehicles to provide reasonable protection from loss of life from fire and explosion. In particular, the standard sets down requirements for fuel burning devices used in connection with recreational vehicles. They pay special attention to the location of internal combustion engines and their exhaust ports relative to leakage into the living compartment of the vehicle. In essence, the codes state that exhaust gases shall be directed away from the vehicle and that the exhaust system shall be installed in a manner by which the exhaust pipes are not unduly subject to road damage. They also state that all fuel-burning devices, except ranges and ovens, shall be designed and installed to provide for the complete separation of the combustion system from the interior atmosphere of the recreational vehicle. Throughout this chapter, the interior of the recreational vehicle would be referred to interchangeably as the living compartment or living enclosure. Essentially, this means that the combustion air intake, the burner, the combustion chamber, heat transfer elements, and exhaust piping shall be outside the living compartment. It further states that exhaust or flue outlets shall not terminate under the recreational vehicle. The codes further state that internal combustion engines (motor generators), engine driven pumps or the like shall be mounted in compartments that are vapor tight to the interior of the vehicle (living compartment). The wording is somewhat confusing in that of necessity the engine compartment cannot be sealed because the engine requires combustion and cooling air, therefore, cannot be sealed. However, the meaning of the code is quite clear that the living compartment must be sealed to prevent exhaust gas penetrating the enclosure. In addition, the code states that all penetrations into the living compartment shall be sealed. Furthermore, fuel lines and exhaust systems shall not penetrate the living compartment. All recreational vehicles that are equipped with or are equipped to accommodate a future installation of an internal combustion engine shall be equipped with a listed CO detector or alarm. Readers interested in detail information regarding codes or standards are referred to ANSI 119.2 and NFPA 501 c.2,3
4.4 POTENTIAL SOURCES OF CARBON MONOXIDE WITHIN MOTOR HOMES AND OTHER ENCLOSURES Motor homes contain a variety of appliances utilizing combustion that can generate CO as well as other toxic gases. The probability of creating serious injury or death is a function of the amount of CO produced by the appliance and the concentration ultimately trapped in the enclosure. The likely devices and appliances fall into one of two classes depending on level of CO that can be expected 1. Internal combustion engines produce levels of CO ranging from 10,000 to 70,000 ppm or more; CO concentration drops by 95% or more when the
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 60 — #4
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
61
exhaust system is equipped with a catalytic converter. Without a catalytic converter, the probability of life threatening accidents occurring is very high if exhaust gases leak into occupied enclosures. 2. Ranges, stoves, ovens, water heaters, and so forth produce much lower levels of CO, generally in the range of a few ppm up to a few hundred ppm. The probability of these devices causing life-threatening accidents is considerably lower than with internal combustion engines. However, these concentrations are capable of causing brain damage and other healthrelated injuries and cannot be dismissed out of hand. In any CO asphyxiation incident, regardless of the CO level, it is a good practice to inspect all devices that could potentially generate CO. Measure their output, and catalog emissions even though they may appear to be unrelated to the accident and the environment in which the accident occurred.
4.4.1 INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES Internal Combustion Engines present the greatest hazard from the standpoint of CO poisonings. As stated above, CO concentrations of 10,000–70,000 ppm are not uncommon. CO at these magnitudes, even when diluted 30 or 40 to 1 can be lethal, can quickly result in death. Internal combustion engines produce high levels of CO because of the brief period available to complete combustion. As an example, a single cylinder engine running at 2400 rpm must fire 20 times per second. It must draw in a charge of air, meter and inject an appropriate quantity of fuel through a crude carburetor, and mix the air and fuel in 0.0236 s. The mixture must then be ignited, the flame propagate throughout the cylinder, and finally complete the power stroke in 0.014 s. In this brief period of time, it is virtually impossible to perfectly mix each fuel molecule with the appropriate amount of air and burn it to completion in about 0.04 s. Consequently, incomplete combustion is the inevitable result. In addition, the boundary of the metal cylinder, the cylinder head, and piston are all relatively cold surfaces, therefore cause quenching and additional incomplete products of combustion. As a result, the small internal combustion engine is naturally inefficient and produces high levels of CO and other products of incomplete combustion. Modern automobile and truck engines, although greatly improved, still produce high levels of CO, but because of catalytic exhaust systems now deliver much lower levels of CO to the atmosphere. Of the fatal CO motor home accidents that I have investigated, the majority can be traced to the motor generator and its exhaust system. The majority occurred after the exhaust system was damaged, displaced, or missing. The damage to or the absence of the tailpipe allowed high levels of CO and other toxic exhaust gases to be directed under the motor home where they accumulated and found their way into the living compartment. It should be noted that despite numerous accidents many generator exhaust systems are still located in unprotected areas where they are subject to damage from direct impact from road hazards.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 61 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
62
H
E F
B
G
D I A
J
K
C
FIGURE 4.1 Air flow over and through an enclosure.
4.4.1.1 Large Vehicle Propulsion Engines Older motor home engines, built before mandated emission standards, commonly produced in excess of 4% (40,000 ppm) CO. Modern engines still produce high levels of CO; however, modern catalytic exhaust systems have reduced CO discharge drastically in order to meet the current CO emission standard. Other than intentional suicide, and operating the motor home engine for heating purposes in quiescent zones, the main propulsion engine is rarely the cause of fatal asphyxiations. The propulsion engine is rarely running long enough, when the vehicle is not in motion, to accumulate a high enough concentration of CO. When in motion, the position of the exhaust pipe encourages rapid dilution and dissipation of CO, discharging it away from the vehicle. There is one exception, and that is in the area directly behind the vehicle. Large moving objects create a suction wake directly behind the vehicle, which encourages exhaust gases to accumulate, much like the vortex G, shown in Figure 4.1. Codes recognize this problem and require special sealing to avoid leaks into the living compartment in those areas. In addition, codes require that openings like windows must be permanently sealed to avoid opening. Main propulsion engine exhaust pipes are generally large and structurally strong, with substantial means of attachment to the vehicle. Although they are frequently in unprotected areas, the pipes and supports are strong and can sustain impacts that would damage smaller lighter generator exhaust pipes. Although this does not preclude an accident, it greatly reduces the probability. A motor home if left with the engine idling, for a prolonged period of time, especially, if parked in a protected zone or in a depression, may permit exhaust gases to accumulate underneath. The accumulation of exhaust gases in the vicinity of the discharge end of the tailpipe thwarts the natural dilution of exhaust gases, thereby exposing leakage areas to highly concentrated exhaust gases. The temperature of undiluted exhaust gas is high thereby creating a thermal head that facilitates infiltration into the living compartment through breaches in the vehicle floor. 4.4.1.2 Auxiliary Power Generators The majority of standby power generators, used in motor homes, are driven by single cylinder, four-stroke engines. Some of the larger generators use larger two-cylinder,
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 62 — #6
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
63
four-stroke cycle engines. The range of sizes run from 2.5 kW (7 bhp) to 7 kW (14 bhp). They are available for gasoline, liquefied petroleum (LP), liquid or vapor state fuels, and occasionally diesel fuel. Codes require that all motor-driven generators be mounted in compartments that are outside of the living compartment. The generators are generally located in a ventilated compartment along the periphery of the motorhome. The generator compartment cannot be sealed and must be open to the outside air to maintain a constant flow of cooling and combustion air to the engine. The code requires that all generators be mounted in compartments that must be outside of the living enclosure. Typically, the generators are equipped with exhaust systems that consist of a muffler, tailpipe, and tailpipe support brackets. The exhaust pipe, approximately 1 in. in diameter, usually made of 16 gauge stainless steel, is routed under the motorhome and generally protrudes out the side or back of, and beneath the lower skirt of the motorhome. Engines are provided with mufflers to reduce exhaust noise levels, which are typically 67–70 dBA (sound pressure level at 10 ft.). On some “Quiet” models sound levels as low as 60 dBA are available. It should be noted that even at 60 dBA the noise signature is loud enough that a defect in the exhaust system can readily be detected by a person, used to the sound, standing in the vicinity of the generator. This provides a safety feature to persons that check the generator in use. In general, low horsepower engines are inefficient and produce very high levels of CO. Exhaust gas composition may range from 4.0% to 7.0%, (40,000–70,000 ppm) of CO with associated carbon dioxide levels ranging from 6% to 10% (60,000–100,000 ppm). Exhaust gases are discharged at a temperature of 400–800◦ F depending on the generator load. Of all appliances, motor generators present the greatest danger to human life and health. The high CO concentration (40,000–70,000 ppm) in the exhaust gas, even when the engine is in good working order, creates a serious poisoning hazard. By comparison, with a few exceptions, other CO-producing devices commonly found in motor homes, produce CO levels up to 400–500 ppm and only then when they are not working properly. These lower CO levels may still present a health hazard, but of a far lower magnitude than a generator. Because generators present such a high exhaust gas hazard, it is required that a special standard of care be exercised to ensure that the generator engine and all its associated components be maintained in first class condition, and be protected against accidental damage. Generator engines are quite reliable when properly maintained. However, the exhaust gas is highly toxic regardless of the operating condition of the engine. Essentially, nothing can be done to relieve the fundamental CO hazard. With regard to life safety, the exhaust system is the most critical component of the motor generator and should be protected at all cost. In general, the exhaust pipe and muffler are located under the engine with the tailpipe projecting below the skirt of the motor home. In the majority of cases, the discharge of the tailpipe is located perpendicular to the side of the motor home and projects out a minimum distance of 1 in. beyond the side of the motor home. For additional protection, codes require that the exhaust pipe may not be located closer
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 63 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
64
than 6 in. from any air intake. This assumes that the pipe discharges into clean air to dilute the exhaust products. The tailpipe, by virtue of its location below the vehicle, is in an unprotected position and is subject to impact from curbs, road hazards, uneven terrain, and flying debris. Most frequently, tailpipe support brackets are weak and will not withstand substantial impact. The pipe is normally a thin wall stainless steel tube that is readily subject to impact damage. My experience shows that the majority of fatal accidents are caused by damaged, out of position, or missing tailpipes.
4.4.2 INTERIOR DEVICES 4.4.2.1 Ranges The majority of cooking stoves used in motor homes or trailers burn LP as a fuel. Propane, butane, or a combination thereof are commonplace. Exhaust gases from the burners are vented directly into the living compartment of the motor home. Gravity vents may be provided or a fume hood may be located above the range. A fume hood collects range exhaust products of combustion along with cooking vapors and discharges the gases through a register located on the outside wall or roof of the motor home. The registers are normally equipped with flap type check valves to prevent back flow into the motor home from wind movement. Some fume hoods used over stoves filter out grease and smoke, but return combustion products to the living compartment. These systems do not remove CO, carbon dioxide, or other toxic gases, but simply circulate them within the enclosure. Exhaust fan capacities are typically in the range of 50–125 acfm. All exhaust systems require similar quantities of make-up air to prevent back drafting. Tests conducted by the author show that CO levels, taken just above the visible flame, range from 15 to 70 ppm; properly adjusted burners have blue flames. Badly adjusted or damaged burners, frequently typified by yellow tipped flames, have CO levels of 100–770 ppm (this figure may vary by location). Burner pilot lights can contribute an additional 28–56 ppm. Ranges used for cooking rarely are hazardous because they are used for a limited time. When used for prolonged cooking they are generally used in conjunction with an exhaust hood. Ranges can pose a hazard if used in a small, tight compartment without sufficient air infiltration or when operated for prolonged periods of time. Ranges should never be used for space heating. 4.4.2.2 Ovens Ovens also discharge products of combustion and cooking vapors directly into the living compartment. Ovens having blue flames can produce 35–768 ppm of CO and their pilots can add up to an additional 960 ppm.4 Some ovens use a gravity flue to discharge oven gases outside the living compartment. When used they should be equipped with backflow protection. Because of the relatively low temperature of exhaust gases and the short stack length, the flue draft developed is limited. Back drafting may present a problem when dryers or
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 64 — #8
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
65
exhaust fans are used simultaneously within the same enclosure. Under back-drafting conditions, CO can increase to dangerous levels. During back drafting, CO levels far exceed the norm expected of the appliance. Like cooking ranges, ovens are used for relatively short periods of time and are generally vented. However, when used in tightly sealed enclosures without sufficient infiltration air, they can present a hazard. Ovens should never be used for space or supplemental heating. 4.4.2.3 Gas Refrigerators (LP Gas) The majority of motor homes and trailers use gas or combination gas-electric refrigerators. The combustion unit for a gas refrigerator is contained in a separate metal enclosure that is located outside the living quarters. Combustion air is drawn into the combustion tube, mixed with vaporized propane, ignited and burned and flue products passed through a heat exchanger and discharged to the outside atmosphere. Thus, combustion gases are isolated from the living compartment. Of all appliances, gas refrigerators show a low frequency of CO poisonings. Negative living compartment pressure does not pose a problem. 4.4.2.4 Domestic Water Heaters The combustion unit for a gas fired water heater is contained in a separate metal enclosure that is located outside the living quarters. Combustion air is drawn into the combustion tube, mixed with vaporized propane, ignited, burned, and flue products passed through a heat exchanger. They are discharged to atmosphere outside the living compartment. Make-up and hot water connections that penetrate the living compartment must be sealed to prevent external gases from penetrating the living compartment. Negative living compartment pressure does not pose a problem except through leaking seals around pipes or electrical connections entering/leaving the living compartment. The risk of dangerous amounts of CO entering the living compartment, except at seals, is small. 4.4.2.5 Gas or Oil-Fired Space Heaters The combustion unit of the space heater must have an air intake and discharge that are external to the living compartment. Hot combustion gases are contained inside a stainless steel heat exchanger that separates them from the living compartment. Pressurized air flow across the outside of the heat exchanger picks up and carries hot air into the living compartment. The risk of dangerous levels of CO penetrating the living compartment is small. 4.4.2.6 Clothes Dryers Clothes dryers when fuel-fired have the combustion unit outside the living compartment. The combustion unit is much like those used in approved space heaters,
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 65 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
66
water heaters, and refrigerators. Clothes dryers present an additional but indirect hazard, because the dryer exhaust can lower living compartment pressure to the point where back drafting by other appliances occurs. Lower living compartment pressure also increases the probability of drawing external exhaust gases into the living compartment. If a clothes dryer is used it is imperative that a sufficient make up air supply be provided to prevent back drafting into the living compartment.
4.4.2.7 Fireplaces (LP Gas) Fireplaces and even wood burning stoves have become available for use in mobile homes. Because their flames are exposed inside the living compartment, anything that could result in back drafting will cause exhaust gases to be discharged directly into the living compartment. Gas fireplaces, even in conventional homes, are notorious for discharging CO into living areas. Fireplaces are subject to back drafting any time that living compartment pressure is reduced below atmospheric pressure (see Figure 4.2).
4.4.2.8 Other Sources The use of portable kerosene, gasoline, and propane or natural gas heaters is not recommended. Regardless of the type, they discharge their products of combustion into the living compartment. Even when operating properly they require an adequate supply of combustion air, which may not be present in a tight enclosure. Heaters of this type are portable and can be easily upset, presenting an additional fire and toxic gas hazard. Many of these devices are position sensitive and cannot function in other than a vertical attitude. Their use is prohibited by ANSI 119.2 in that the products of combustion are discharged into the living compartment. There is a history of numerous asphyxiation accidents related to this type heater.
Fresh air
Leakage air Dryer exhaust Dryer exhaust
Exhaust gas back flow
Clothes dryer
FIGURE 4.2 Back-drafting in a fireplace flue.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 66 — #10
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
67
4.5 PRIMER ON THE MECHANISM OF FORMATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE FROM FUEL-FIRED APPLIANCES FOUND IN MOBILE HOMES 4.5.1 THE PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF CARBON MONOXIDE To understand how CO is generated and transported into a motor home, it is necessary to understand its physical properties, where and how it is formed, and how dangerous concentrations are transported into living compartments. CO is a clear gas that is odorless, tasteless and has a density slightly less than air. It is generally a product of incomplete combustion of carbon or hydrocarbon fuels. Its physical properties are seen in Table 4.1.5 The common understanding is that CO is lighter than air, as it is in the pure state. At standard temperature and pressure, it has a density of 0.0779 lb/cu. ft.; air is 0.0807. The difference in density creates a natural buoyancy. However, under most circumstances where we find it, CO is a product of incomplete combustion. Therefore, it is not a pure gas, but contained in a mixture of exhaust gases containing nitrogen, carbon dioxide, and water vapor in proportions dictated by Equation 4.1. Because of the density of these gases, the combined mixture has an essentially neutral buoyancy. For illustrative purposes, assume that a motor generator is fueled by octane, C8 H18 . Its exhaust products are 6% CO and 8% CO2 . Under these conditions the exhaust gas density is 0.0805 lb/cu. ft. at STP (standard temperature and pressure 60◦ F and 29.92 mm Hg), which has essentially neutral buoyancy when compared to air
TABLE 4.1 Physical Constants for Carbon Monoxide∗ Name
Symbol
Chemical symbol Density, STP Molecular weight Specific gravity (air) Specific gas constant Specific heat p = c Specific heat v = c Specific heat ratio Specific volume Speed of sound Heat of combustion Heat of combustion Flammability in air lower Flammability in air upper Flame temperature in air Auto ignition temperature
CO rho MW SG R Cp Cv k nu C
LFL UFL
Value
Units
0.0779 28.011 0.967 55.19 0.248 0.177 1.4 13.557 1154.8 310 4340 12.5 74 3542 1228
lb/cu.ft.
ft. lbf /lbm R◦ Btu/lb◦ F Btu/lb◦ F — cu. ft./lb ft./s Btu/cu. ft. Btu/lb Vol% of total volume Vol% of total volume ◦F ◦F
∗Also see Chapter 35.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 67 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
68
0.0807,lb/cu. ft. at STP. Therefore, an exhaust gas mixture, with neutral temperature differential, will not have natural buoyancy at STP. Any buoyancy characteristics associated with combustion products will be due solely to a temperature differential between the exhaust gas stream and the surrounding air. For example, a hot jet stream of exhaust at 800◦ F in air will be buoyant and have a resultant direction and magnitude that will be the vector sum of the vertical thermal component and jet vector of the initial gas stream. Ahot gas stream jetted into ambient air naturally entrains large volumes of ambient air, thereby lowering its temperature, thus its buoyancy. As the stream gains volume it slows down. Any computations should take into account the momentum exchange, the increasing volume of the stream and diminishing temperature.
4.5.2 THE COMBUSTION PROCESS Under most circumstances, CO is an undesirable product of combustion. It is formed as a result of incomplete or inefficient burning of carbonaceous substances. By definition, combustion is the rapid oxidation of fuel accompanied by the liberation of heat and light. The combustion process, even in its simplest form, say burning methane in air, is not fully understood. Equation 4.2 shows a methane and excess air mixture burning to completion, forming products of combustion containing water, carbon dioxide, and excess air. Unlike the simplified end-points equation shown, there can be up to 31 intermediate steps in the oxidation of methane. If at any time during the combustion process the reaction is chilled or in any way interrupted, the intermediate reactions will freeze leaving one or more intermediate partial products of combustion. One of the more common partial products is CO. If temperatures remain high and oxygen is present some or all the intermediate products may be oxidized to completion. If the temperature drops below the critical reaction temperature or if oxygen is not present, the intermediate products will become stable and be represented in the exhaust gases. The most common causes for incomplete combustion are quenching, incorrect fuel air ratios and inadequate mixing resulting in stratification, and burning in the fuel rich or reducing fuel air region. The combustion process involves mixing of multiple gas products, mass transport, chemistry, and heat transfer. For the purpose of this discussion, many of the more complex processes will be simplified and we will deal, as much as possible, with the reactants and end products of combustion as defined by the thermo-chemical equations. It should be understood that the equations shown are representative of those containing intermediate reaction, but only at the beginning and the end. 4.5.2.1 Basic Requirements to Initiate and Perpetuate the Combustion Process Fuel must be present in a state that is burnable. Liquid and solid fuels will not burn. Fuel must be in a gaseous state for it to combine with oxygen and burn. Liquid fuels have to be atomized to small particles so that on exposure to high temperatures, the pilot flame, they quickly gasify so they can burn. Similarly, solid
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 68 — #12
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
69
fuels must be pulverized so that on exposure to high temperature, the pilot flame, they quickly gasify and burn. The fuel must also be present in sufficient quantity to be within the flammable limits (Table 4.1), and the initial flame size must exceed the minimum kernel diameter in order to propagate. An oxidizer, air or oxygen, must be present and intimately mixed with the fuel. The mixture must be within flammable limits, at least in a localized area, where ignition is to occur. There must be a source of ignition, of sufficient energy to raise the temperature of a critical mass of the fuel mixture above the ignition temperature to initiate the reaction. If the reaction is to perpetuate itself, the heat generated must be at least equal to the net heat loss from the flame and the heat required to heat the incoming mixture to ignition temperature. If the heat generated is equal to or greater than those requirements, the reaction will propagate.
4.5.3 THERMOCHEMICAL EQUATIONS Combustion like any other chemical reaction may be represented by thermochemical reaction equations. The equations show the fuel and air input and the products of combustion and heat liberated. The typical equation shows the initial ingredients and the final products of combustion, but does not show the intermediate reactions. For those interested in the detailed combustion process, see various sources.6–8 In general, this presentation will concern itself with the end-products of rich combustion, primarily CO and carbon dioxide. There are times when quenching, chilled flames, and blow off create intermediate toxic products of combustion. Essentially, we will concern ourselves with three thermochemical equations, Equation 4.1 for rich or excess fuel (i.e., deficiency of air), Equation 4.2 is for an excess of air, and Equation 4.3 is for secondary oxidation of CO formed in Equation 4.1. The term “E” represents the equivalence ratio or the ratio of actual to stoichiometric air. Stoichiometric air being that amount of oxygen required for perfect combustion. Thermochemical Equation for Methane Excess Fuel CH4 + 2 E O2 + 7.52 E N2 = (4 E − 3) CO2 + (4 − 4 E) CO + 2H2 O + 7.52 E N2 + Heat (1040 BTU/ft 3 )
(4.1)
Thermochemical Equation for Methane and Excess Air. CH4 + 2 E O2 + 7.52 E N2 = CO2 + 2H2 O + 2(E − 1)O2 + 7.52 E N2 + Heat (E∗ 1040 BTU/ft 3 )
(4.2)
Thermochemical Equation for Carbon Monoxide. CO + O = CO2 + Heat (323.5 BTU/ft 3 )
(4.3)
Equation 4.2 is presented in graphic form (see Figure 4.3). This chart gives a quick visualization of how combustion proceeds to either excess fuel or excess air. An equivalence ratio of 1, the abscissa, occurs at stoichiometric or perfect combustion.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 69 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
70
DEN*100 CO2 CO O2
Exhaust gas percent wet methane CH4
18 16
Percent (Wet)
14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
1
2
3 4 Equivalence ratio
5
6
FIGURE 4.3 Exhaust gases from the combustion of methane.
Some notable observations about Figure 4.3. 1. The CO2 curve peaks at an equivalence ratio of 1, and falls off on the reducing and oxidizing side of stoichiometric. 2. Maximum combustion efficiency is achieved when carbon dioxide is maximized. 3. Therefore, the CO2 curve is a good indicator of the quality of combustion. 4. Since CO2 is readily measured, it can be used, in conjunction with a determination of the presence of oxygen to assess the equivalence ratio. 5. Flame temperature also follows the CO2 curve (flame temperature actually peaks slightly on the reducing side of E = 1 but for general purposes the difference can be disregarded). 6. These observations are helpful in determining if a flame is reducing and generating CO. The chart shown is for methane. There are two charts for each fuel: (1) wet gas analysis, where the water of combustion remains in the exhaust gas, and (2) dry gas analysis, assuming that the water of combustion has condensed. Figure 4.3 represents a wet gas analysis. The use of wet gas analysis is appropriate for combustion systems where the exhaust gas temperature is above the dew point. The majority of charts found in the literature are set-up on a dry basis. This was done when the most common combustion analyzer was the Orsat. It being a wet absorption analyzer caused the gas temperature to drop below the dew point, removing all the water, and thereby yielding the products of combustion on a dry basis. Care must be taken when using a chart to determine if analysis is on a wet or dry basis. Section 4.10 shows a similar graph drawn on a dry basis. This approach may be more recognizable and is used more frequently by those involved in general combustion work.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 70 — #14
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
71
The maximum CO2 for each fuel will be different and may be calculated from Equation 4.1. Burners are normally adjusted for near peak CO2 on the slightly oxidizing side to insure complete combustion. The majority of good combustion equipment operates with an equivalence ratio in the range of 1.0–1.4. Electronic instruments can be calibrated to read either wet or dry percent. Therefore, it is important to know how the instrument is calibrated.
4.5.4 EXCESS AIR COMBUSTION Excess air combustion occurs at any time that the quantity of combustion air exceeds the stoichiometric requirements. This can occur on an overall basis, where fuel and air are uniformly mixed throughout the combustion chamber, or on a local basis within the combustion envelope, usually classified as stratified mixing. Stratified mixing can result in rich and lean zones occurring within the same flame envelope. One of the fundamental problems that occurs in most combustion systems is that it is difficult to mate every fuel molecule with the correct number of oxygen molecules. Failure to do so can result in rich excess fuel zones and lean excess air zones within the same combustion envelope. When there is too much air for a given amount of fuel, the flame temperature drops because of heating the additional excess air. If the quantity of excess air is sufficient then the flame temperature can drop below the critical reaction temperature and flameout can occur. However, prior to flameout, flame quenching starts and partial products of combustion such as CO and various aldehydes appear and become stable in the exhaust gases. If the quenching is local, and the partial products are subsequently reheated to a temperature in excess of the critical reaction temperature then the partial products may go to completion in the subsequent burn. Figure 4.4 shows a curve of flame temperature (◦ F) versus excess air (%). As excess air, increases flame Temperature versus excess air 4000 Temperature Temperature (F°)
3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Excess air (% )
FIGURE 4.4 Flame temperature versus excess air (%), natural gas. (R. Schreter and Associates, 1997).
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 71 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
72
temperature decreases. As the temperature approaches 1200◦ F, the critical reaction temperature, partial products of combustion and unburned fuel emerge. At very high levels of excess air, CO and formaldehyde can be generated.
4.5.5 EXCESS FUEL Excess fuel combustion occurs at any time that the quantity of fuel exceeds the stoichiometric requirements. As with excess air, this can occur on an overall basis or on a local basis within the combustion envelope. As depicted in Figure 4.3, CO appears at any value of E < 1. Small amounts of CO may occur even at E = 1.05, slightly excess air, because of difficulty mixing all the fuel with all the air. The rise of CO is very rapid on the excess fuel side as can be seen in Figure 4.3. Rich reactions contribute to the formation of CO in appliances when they are deficient in combustion air. The same type of reaction occurs when back drafting occurs. During back drafting, the reversal of flow upsets the mixing process and flame stability, resulting in rich combustion, blow off, quenching and formation of partial products of combustion.
4.6 APPLICATION OF COMBUSTION THEORY TO ACTUAL CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING SITUATIONS Aerodynamics and gas dynamics are the primary factors driving exhaust gas leakage into or out of the living compartment of a motor home, or for that matter any enclosure. The following theory is intended for use with motor homes; however, the same approach may be used in any low-pressure flow situation that might occur in a residential or commercial building.
4.6.1 INTRODUCTION TO THE FLOW OF EXHAUST GASES The flow rate of air, CO or a mixture of exhaust gases through leaks in the enclosure boundary is of critical importance to the concentration of toxic gases within the enclosure. The physical conditions governing low pressure gas flow usually encountered in motor homes greatly simplifies calculations, because the compressibility of the gases may be disregarded. The range of total pressure and differential pressure is low, further simplifying the flow equation. Flow is mainly through orifice type openings and friction can generally be disregarded. A discharge coefficient appropriate for the type of opening is required. Discharge coefficients may be found in most sources on fluid flow. Because differential pressures across orifices or leakage holes are low, a simplified velocity equation may be used as expressed in Equation 4.4. Gas Velocity at Low Pressures. U=
2∗gc ∗R∗
T0 ∗ (P0 − P1 ) P0
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 72 — #16
(4.4)
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
73
The continuity equation may then be used to determine the flow rate (Equation 4.5). Gas Flow Q = Cd∗A∗U
(4.5)
For very low pressures where (P0 − P1 /P1 ) ≤ 0.01, a much simplified flow equation may be used. Low Pressure Gas Flow. Q1−2 = 1658.5∗Cd∗a∗ (h0 − h1 ) ∗
δg δa
(4.6)
where a is area (sq. inches) A is area (sq. ft.) δa is density of air at STP δg is density of gas at flowing conditions F is frictional loss in units consistent with pressure gc is the constant 32.2 h0 is upstream pressure (inches of water) h1 is downstream pressure (inches of water) Cd is discharge coefficient P0 is upstream pressure (lb/sq. ft. abs) P1 is downstream pressure (lb/sq. ft. abs) Q1−2 is flow rate (cu. ft./h) R is universal gas constant (ft lb/lb R0 ) T0 is upstream absolute temperature (R0 ) U is velocity (ft./s)
4.6.2 TOTAL PRESSURE The pressures, ht and Pt , represent total pressures that are used in connection with moving air streams. Total pressure includes static pressure and a velocity component. Moving gas streams have both potential and kinetic energy components. In lowpressure gas flow, they are generally thought of as total, static, and velocity pressures (Equation 4.7). Total pressure is the sum of the static and velocity pressures and may be represented by any consistent set of units. Total Pressure. ht = hs + hv + f
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 73 — #17
(4.7)
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
74
where f is frictional loss [in. water column (w.c.)] hs is static pressure (in. w.c.) ht is total pressure (in. w.c.) hv is velocity pressure (in. w.c.) An example will be helpful to illustrate the concept of total pressure and the interchange of static and velocity pressures. Assume a large tank has been pressurized to a static pressure of hs . Because the tank is large and the outflow is small, there is negligible velocity within the tank. Therefore within the tank hv = 0. From Equation 4.7, ht = hs . As the fluid approaches and enters the pipe, it must accelerate and gain velocity. The static pressure diminishes and the velocity pressure increases (see plane a). Concurrently, because of turbulence there is a permanent frictional head loss that causes the total pressure, ht to decline slightly (see point e). In the straight section of pipe, plane (a to b), fluid reaches maximum velocity, requiring a corresponding loss in static pressure (see plane a). The fluid then enters a divergent nozzle (b to c), where the velocity diminishes, restoring static pressure. Throughout the pressure interchange (a to c), there is a gradual loss of total pressure due to friction and turbulence (e to f). As the fluid emerges from the nozzle, it continues to expand and then it impacts the wall. The remaining velocity is converted back into static pressure with an accompanying friction loss (f to g). The static pressure is now equal to the total pressure since velocity is now zero. The regaining of velocity pressure into static pressure, hs , is referred to as stagnation pressure (see Figure 4.5).
Wall h
Flow
Tank
g f
Total pressure
e
Friction Static pressure
Velocity pressure
D
a
b
c
d
FIGURE 4.5 Total velocity and static pressure versus position.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 74 — #18
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
75
After striking the wall at point h, the static pressure being higher than the ambient pressure causes the gas to accelerate in a direction perpendicular to the original jet, again causing another interchange between total, velocity, and static pressure. This concept is extremely important and will be used throughout discussions of moving gas streams.
4.6.3 STAGNATION PRESSURE When a moving gas stream impacts a stationary barrier or wall the stream velocity diminishes or approaches zero. The kinetic energy of the moving stream is transformed into potential energy in the form of pressure. The change into potential energy raises the local static pressure, which is termed stagnation pressure. Stagnation pressure plays an important role in the inflow and outflow of gases in a motor home or like enclosure. The stagnation pressure can be due to a moving body, such as a motor home impacting stationary air, or to a moving air stream or wind impacting a stationary body. The magnitude of the stagnation pressure may be calculated from the velocity component and the angle of incidents to the plane of the impact surface. In low-pressure air flow calculations it is traditional to refer to velocity in ft./min and stagnation pressure in terms of inches of water column (see Equation 4.8). Stagnation Pressure. h =
Um 1096.5
2 ∗ δ ∗ sin φ
(4.8)
Where δ is density of fluid at flowing temperature and pressure (lb/ft3 ) h is stagnation pressure (in. w.c.) φ is angle of incidence of Vm to plane of stagnation degrees Um is velocity of stream (ft./min) A useful chart, Figure 4.6, shows the magnitude of stagnation pressure for air at various wind speeds impacting a stationary surface. To put this in perspective consider the following example: a 20 mph wind impacts a stationary wall at an angle of 90◦ . From Figure 4.6, the stagnation pressure will be 0.20 in. w.c. Assume that there is a single 2 ft. × 4 ft. closed double hung window in the wall. Assume that the window has a 1/64 inch crack along all moving surfaces. The total leakage area will be A=
1 × 12 × (2 + 2 + 2 + 4 + 4) = 2.625 sq.in 64
Using Equation 4.6 we can calculate that the air flow through the window crack will be 1572 acfh, which is a substantial leakage.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 75 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
76
Stagnation pressure in. water column
Stagnation pressure (in. water column) 1.40 1.20 1.00 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20 0.00 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Wind speed MPH
FIGURE 4.6 Stagnation pressure.
4.6.4 THERMAL PRESSURE Any time there is a temperature gradient within or between the inside and outside of an enclosure, thermal pressure will develop at the top of the enclosure. Thermal pressure is a function of temperature difference, density of the fluid or fluids, and vertical height from the inlet to outlet in feet. The usual units for thermal pressure are inches of w.c. Equation 4.9 represents the equation for thermal pressure: Thermal pressure. p∗MW ∗H 1 1 ht = ∗ − 55.77 T2 T1
(4.9)
Where ht is thermal pressure head (in. w.c.) H is height of the enclosure (ft.) MW is molecular weight of gas p is atmospheric pressure (psia) T2 is absolute atmospheric temperature (Rankine degrees) T1 is absolute enclosure temperature (Rankine degrees) Thermal pressure can be treated as any other pressure to determine flow across an opening (see Equation 4.6). Thermal pressure is important in the flow of exhaust because of the temperature gradient between the hot exhaust gas and that of the surrounding atmosphere. To put it into perspective, a temperature gradient of 100◦ F in a 6-ft. high enclosure will create a thermal pressure of 0.0237 in. w.c. That thermal pressure would create a flow of 204 scfh per square inch of leakage area.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 76 — #20
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
77
4.6.5 AIR FLOW AROUND AND THROUGH ENCLOSURES Aside from fans, blowers, exhausters, or similar power gas moving devices, thermal head, and wind are the principal cause of flow of gases into or out of enclosures such as motor homes or buildings. Any time that wind moves across or around any object, pressure gradients form around it. It is these pressure gradients acting on openings in the enclosure that create flow into and out of the enclosure. Figure 4.1 shows an elevation view of a simplified enclosure (B) exposed to wind flow. The wind blowing from left to right. The horizontal lines (A) represent stream tubes of air. As the lower stream tubes approach the vertical wall, their horizontal velocity approaches zero, converting kinetic energy to static pressure (stagnation pressure). This builds a positive pressure region along the upwind face. The static pressure gradient on the upwind face is greatest at the bottom where virtually all kinetic energy or velocity pressure is converted to static pressure (C). At higher levels there is flow moving up the wall, therefore static pressure will be somewhat lower due to transition into velocity. Total pressure remains essentially constant across the face with the exception that there is a frictional loss due to turbulence. Air within the positive pressure region (M) flows into the lower pressure region (D) and accelerates to join the higher velocity stream tubes flowing across the top of the object at (B). As the velocity increases, static pressure diminishes forming a low pressure region (F) along the top of the object. This effect may be likened to the low pressure created as air flows across the top of an airfoil. As the stream tubes flow past, the downstream edge of the object they deflect down due to the low-pressure vortex (G) on the downstream side of the body. Surface drag from the stream tubes acting on the low pressure region (G) cause a clockwise rotation to the low-pressure wake (G). At very low Reynolds numbers vortex (G) will remain stable in the cavity formed by the ground and the downstream wall of the object. At Reynolds numbers above 50, which is most common in air flow, vortex (G) becomes unstable and periodically moves downstream, as represented by vortex (H). Then a new vortex is established and grows in size at (G) until it separates. This process is referred to as vortex shedding. While vortex shedding introduces instability downstream for the object, the pressure in the immediate downstream area while variable in magnitude remains essentially negative. When openings exist in the enclosure, as shown in Figure 4.1, positive pressure on the windward side causes flow into the enclosure through openings (I). As a result of the inflow, internal pressure increases. The internal pressure being higher than that on the downwind side causes a pressure differential that results in flow through any openings (K). The negative pressure (G) further increases the pressure differential resulting in a further increase of flow. If the enclosure is divided into rooms or other subdivisions, flow will work its way through openings in the partitions, traveling from high to low pressure. Flow rate will be governed by pressure differential and area of leakage paths, in accordance with Equation 4.6. If multiple leaks are involved, a series of simultaneous equations may be written to determine the net flow through the enclosure. It is apparent that if CO was discharged on the upstream side, then it would be induced into the interior of the enclosure.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 77 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
78
4.6.6 WIND ROSE When a CO-poisoning incident occurs and external wind conditions appear to be a factor, it is desirable to be able to determine the wind effect over the time span of the accident. The wind may be at a constant velocity and direction during the entire incident or it may vary widely in direction and velocity. The wind intensity and direction are a vector quantity that may constantly change with time. Because of the highly variable nature of the wind, it is helpful to develop a graphic image, as well as a mathematical model of the wind effect relative to time. There are three factors that are pertinent: velocity, direction, and duration which add to the difficulty in graphing the event. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)9 hourly weather reports provide all the data necessary to evaluate the role of weather on an incident. The reports give wind direction, speed, temperature, and a number of other factors, for each hourly segment. The NOAA weather service developed a chart called a wind rose used to assess average wind direction and speed for given airport locations for the purposes of runway direction. Using this basic concept as a starting point, I developed a chart that is useful for forensic investigation of wind-related incidents. Initially, the wind direction, wind speed and the time for each hourly segment is logged into a chart (Table 4.2). The data are then plotted on a 360◦ polar graph in which wind direction, degrees, and intensity (knots) is entered on the polar graph. Entries are shown as 1-h segments for any given direction. The length of each vector represents the wind speed for that particular vector. Where there are multiple vectors or any given heading, each alternating sector is colored for easy differentiation. I normally place time in, {0800}, showing the actual time for each sector so that I do not have to refer to the database for that information. Plotting wind impact surfaces on the chart also aids in visualization. The rose (Figure 4.7) shows that during a 24-h period there were two prominent groupings of wind. The one of interest spans from about 2200 on 2/13 to 0800 on 2/14, having a wind direction of from 70◦ to 180◦ , which is predominantly out of the east. In this case, the front of the building is represented by the line from 30◦ to about 210◦ . The concern was for stagnation pressure on the “East East South” face of the building within the time frame of the accident. Study of the data (Table 4.2) showed that during the critical hours winds out of the east created substantial stagnation pressure, thereby, pressurizing not only the face of the building but all the rooms having openings on that side of the building. In the case represented by this wind rose there were a number of large louvers opening into a boiler room that contained the boiler that generated CO. As a result of the wind, the room was pressurized driving CO into other sections of the building, which contained the living quarters. The wind rose also shows that more intense winds out of the southwest occurred later in the day; however, they occurred outside of the critical time and were of no consequence.
4.6.7 SCOOPS, DEFLECTORS, AND OPENINGS It is commonplace to have ventilators and exhaust fans on or in the roof of motor homes and most portable trailers and offices. These ventilators frequently project into
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 78 — #22
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
79
TABLE 4.2 Weather Data Giving Wind Direction, Wind Speed, and Temperature Date
Time
Wind Direction (degree)
Wind Speed (knots)
Temperature (◦ F)
2/13/2004 2/13/2004 2/13/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004
2200 2300 2400 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800
90 90 180 126 290 150 0 180 0 0 140 0 0 0 240 260 240 220 220 230 230
4 8 3 1 3 4 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 0 9 11 9 7 6 14 10
33.8 35.6 32.0 30.2 30.2 30.2 37.4 33.8 33.8 30.2 33.8 37.4 44.6 48.2 53.6 55.4 55.4 57.2 55.4 55.4 53.6
North 360°
Front face of building
Wind speed 3 (knots)/ring
270°
90° (2300) (2200) (0100) (0800) (0300) (0500) (2400) 180°
FIGURE 4.7 Wind rose for 02/13/04 (2200 hrs) to 02/14/04 (1800 hrs).
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 79 — #23
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
80 A
B
D
C
E
FIGURE 4.8 Ventilator acting as a deflector.
A
B
G −
H −
+ +
C +
+
−
−
−
+
F D E
FIGURE 4.9 Ventilator acting as a scoop.
the wind stream and induce flow during motion of the vehicle, or in windy conditions with the vehicle being stationary. Figure 4.8 and 4.9 show pressure gradients and direction of flow into or out of an enclosure, depending on the direction of wind flow across the ventilator. Figure 4.8 shows wind flow (A) from left to right, that is deflected upward as it encounters the cover sloping up to the right. The increased velocity at B lowers the static pressure resulting in a low-pressure region at D, downstream of the cover. Assuming neutral pressure within the enclosure (C), flow from inside the enclosure (E) will move from the neutral pressure zone (C) to the negative pressure zone (D), downstream of the deflecting cover. Knowing the relative wind velocity, its angle of incidence the shape and configuration of the ventilator, and the area of the opening the flow rate through the enclosure can be calculated using Equation 4.6. Figure 4.9 shows airflow (A) from left to right that impacts the underside of the cover (B), causing partial stagnation of stream (C), resulting in a positive pressure region (D) on the underside of the cover and at the mouth of the ventilator opening. This assumes that the interior of the enclosure is at neutral pressure (E). The pressure differential plus the remaining velocity pressure will result in air flowing into the enclosure. The flow rate entering the enclosure can be calculated using Equation 4.6. If the pressure within the enclosure is other than neutral, then the differential pressure (h0 −h1 ) must be adjusted accordingly.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 80 — #24
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
81
4.6.8 RESONANCE, CYCLICAL FLOW INTO AND OUT OF AN ENCLOSURE Airflow across any opening leading into a closed chamber can result in cyclical pressure pulsations within the enclosure. The cyclical pressure pulsations result in a cyclical inflow and outflow of gas from the enclosure. The pulsations, depending on the shape of the opening can result in a net inflow or outflow from the enclosure. This phenomenon is well known to passengers riding inside an automobile when the rear windows are partially open. The cyclical low frequency pressure surges are commonly referred to as buffeting. The pressure surges can go unnoticed or be significant to the extent of being painful to the ears. A similar effect can be experienced inside a motor home or other enclosure when airflow across an open window or ventilator results in buffeting. The frequency of the oscillation is a function of the volume of the enclosure and the physical characteristics of the opening. The technical term for this type of oscillation is helmholtz resonance. The equation that governs this phenomenon is Helmholtz resonance. 1 fo = ∗ ∗ 2 π
c2∗ S lc∗ V
(4.10)
Where c is speed of sound, at flowing temperature and pressure of the gas (ft./s) fo is resonant Frequency (Hz) lc is effective length of the throat opening S is cross-sectional area of the throat opening (sq. ft.) V is volume of the enclosure (cu. ft.) An example will illustrate the significance of Helmholtz resonance. Assume a trailer 8 × 30 × 7 has a volume of a 1680 cu. ft. Assume it has a single partially open window having an open area of 0.44 sq. ft. and a 0.5
throat, thickness of the pane, at the opening. Also assume that the fluid medium is air at 60◦ F. The frequency of the oscillation will be 7.1 Hz (cps). This frequency is well below the range of human hearing; therefore, the oscillation will go undetected. However, it will still induce large volumes of outside fluid during the negative cycle. It should be noted that low frequency pulsations, if of sufficient amplitude, could be detected by feeling. The inducted fluid will then mix with the contents of the enclosure. On the positive cycle, a similar volume of mixture will be expelled. This of course assumes that the opening is bidirectional in configuration. If the atmosphere outside the window contains a significant percentage of CO, then each half cycle will induce CO into the interior. Over a period of time, the interior concentration of CO will increase and could become significant. See Section 4.7 for a discussion of the rate of accumulation.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 81 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
82
4.6.9 FLOW INTO AND OUT OF LIVING QUARTERS After the foregoing discussion it is apparent that flow into or out of an enclosure occurs only if there is a pressure imbalance and an opening that will allow flow. The pressure imbalance can be due to a mechanical device like a pump or fan; thermal activity creating pressure imbalance due to density variations; or wind pressure acting on the enclosure. The leakage areas may be the obvious ones such as windows, doors, ventilators, or unsealed openings around pipes or electrical penetrations into the living compartment. Leaks can also occur at joints in the walls and floors, through cracks or labyrinth openings that are not apparent to an observer. In CO poisonings, the percent CO concentration in the enclosure is of prime importance. CO may be generated within the enclosure or outside and leak into the enclosure, or a combination of the two. Flow into or out of the enclosure is critical because it can increase the concentration within or it can dilute the concentration by bringing in fresh air and washing out CO during the air exchange process.
4.6.10 FLUE AND CHIMNEY DYNAMICS A flue or chimney is used to remove the products of combustion from inside a building or enclosure. It operates on the same principle as thermal pressure except that the pressure is negative when measured at the base of the flue. In addition, because flow is confined within a solid boundary, the chimney or flue, friction within the duct must be considered. Equation 4.11 may be used to calculate the suction created by a flue or chimney. Careful inspection of the equation shows a similarity with that of Equation 4.9, except that there is an additional back end representing the fluid friction inside the chimney. Flue draft h=
p∗MW∗H 1 1 .09∗H∗U 2 p∗MW ∗ − − 1+ ∗ 55.77 Tf Ta D∗2∗g 10.729∗Ta
Where D is flue diameter (ft.) g is a constant = 32.2 h is flue suction (in. w.c.) H is height of the flue or chimney (ft.) MW Molecular Weight of the flowing gas p is absolute pressure (psia) Ta is absolute temperature of ambient air (R◦ ) Tf is absolute temperature of flowing gas (R◦ ) U is the velocity of the flue gas (ft/sec)
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 82 — #26
(4.11)
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
83
To solve Equation 4.11 it is necessary to assume a flue gas velocity. An acceptable range to start with is 14.0–16.5 ft./s
4.6.11 BACK-dRAFTING OF FLUE GASES INTO THE ENCLOSURE Back drafting is one of the common root causes for CO poisoning. Back drafting is a process whereby the normal direction of exhaust flow is reversed because the suction inside the enclosure is greater than the thermal suction created as a result of the temperature difference across the flue. Back drafting can occur in any closed or semiclosed enclosure. The most common cause is a result of an exhaust fan, or similar air removal device, overpowering the flue suction. The exhaust device may be an exhaust fan, a bathroom or kitchen exhauster, clothes dryer or even another chimney of greater height and temperature difference. Figure 4.2 shows an example of back drafting through a chimney as a result of a clothes dryer operating. The room is relatively tight which limits leakage air into the room. The exhaust fan in the clothes dryer has a capacity, which exceeds the leakage rate of air into the room, thereby lowering the pressure within the room. If the suction pressure within the room is equal to or greater than the flue suction, the flow up the chimney stalls, resulting in a reversal of flow in the chimney. Ambient air is drawn down the chimney, providing combustion air to the flame from above. This changes the normal direction of airflow across the flame holder, disturbing mixing and flame stability. The flame instead of being sucked up the stack, is blown toward the inside of the enclosure. The exhaust gases then change direction and are discharged into the enclosure. Additionally, the flow reversal disturbs the normal combustion process and its flame stability, causing the flame to blow off, increasing the production of partial products of combustion. Figure 4.2 shows a back drafting chimney as a result of a suction created by a clothes dryer. Back drafting has become much more common as homes and buildings becoming tighter (less air leaks) and the prevalence of air exhausting appliances like clothes dryers and exhaust fans, roof exhausters and multiple chimneys becomes more common. The way to avoid the problem is to install appliances that have their own outside air intake, which are frequently power driven. Another method would be to install a general outside air intake. Motor homes, trailers and portable buildings, because of their requirement to seal the living compartment tend to have fewer air leaks, thereby, become prone to back drafting when exhaust devices are used.
4.6.12 DYNAMICS OF GENERATOR TAILPIPE EXHAUST Generator tailpipe exhaust, by code, must always be external to the living compartment. As described earlier, the tailpipe is generally perpendicular to the outside wall of a motor home, is below, and protrudes beyond its periphery. For the purpose of perspective, consider that a 4 kW single cylinder, four-cycle gasoline-fueled engine (Octane, C8 H18 , will be used as the formula for gasoline) generator will be used. At a 3 kW load the exhaust volume will be about 2030 acfh at 800◦ F. At the 1.1 in.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 83 — #27
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
84
diameter exhaust pipe, typical for that size generator, exit velocity will be 85 ft./s. When the exhaust jet enters stationary ambient air, the surface drag of the jet stream moves ambient air along with it. Ambient air is entrained into the outer portion of the jet stream causing the outer layer to lose velocity and through drag eventually to slow the core stream. The velocity profile across the jet will be Gaussian as shown in Figure 4.10. As cold air is entrained into the hot jet the average temperature of the jet diminishes. Normally it would be expected that the hot jet would have a tendency to rise, due to its buoyancy. However, in the early stages of the jet, the first 20–30 diameters, the horizontal velocity is high compared to the vertical velocity resulting from thermal buoyancy. Therefore, the vertical movement of the jet will be small. In the example shown in Figure 4.10 the vertical rise at 36 diameters is approximately 1.5 diameters, which is not significant. When the horizontal jet velocity slows, the thermal rise becomes more significant. From Figure 4.11, the entrainment at 36 diameters (3 ft.) will be in the order 17:1 and could be as high as 30:1. The example used a 17:1 entrainment ratio.
Gaussian velocity distribution
Entrainment of ambient gas
Thermal rise l.45 D
0D
4D
8D
Exhaust pipe
12 D 16 D
20 D
24 D
36 D
Jet profile
FIGURE 4.10 Expanding jet.
Velocity fps; entrainment ratio
Entrainment ratio versus distance 100 80 60 40
Velocity
20
Entrainment ratio
0 −20
0
5
10
15
20
Distance in nozzle diameters
FIGURE 4.11 Jet velocity and entrainment versus jet distance in diameters.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 84 — #28
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
85 Wall
Trapped exhaust gas Direction of flow of exhaust gas Motor home Entrained exhaust Tailpipe
Exhaust discharge
FIGURE 4.12 Entrainment in a confined area.
The initial CO concentration would be diluted by a factor of 17:1. The CO concentration in the vicinity of the jet at 3 ft., for an initial CO concentration of 40,000 ppm, would be approximately 2350 ppm. Further dilution would occur at greater distances downstream. If the exhaust jet is discharged into a region that has limited air circulation or that traps or confines the exhaust, then the jet will be immersed in a cloud of exhaust gases (see Figure 4.12). Initially, the exhaust jet entrains ambient air diluting the exhaust concentration. As the jet strikes the wall, its velocity drops to zero and the exhaust gases stagnate. Because of the confinement, the exhaust gases accumulate between the road, the wall, and the motor home. The entraining action of the jet instead of drawing in fresh air and diluting the CO level in the jet, it entrains and re-circulates exhaust gas, gradually concentrating it, up to the maximum concentration in the exhaust jet. On the basis of this behavior, it is important to insure that the exhaust system is in good condition and discharges outside the motor home and into an area, that is unrestricted where exhaust gases can readily dissipate.
4.6.13 EXHAUST FLOW THROUGH BENT OR DISPLACED EXHAUST PIPES Because exhaust systems are usually located in exposed locations they are prone to impact and may become damaged, bent or rotated out of position. When this happens, they may discharge exhaust gases under the motor home or possibly discharge it against the inside of the skirt or other interior surfaces. If the jet discharges under the vehicle, there is a tendency for the exhaust to become stagnant there. As a result, the exhaust jet entrains the locally stagnant exhaust and the CO does not dissipate. If the jet strikes another object, the jet loses its velocity, therefore its entraining ability. The exhaust becomes stagnant and does not dilute or dissipate. The slow moving or stagnant cloud of highly concentrated CO remains under the motor home and inside the generator compartment.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 85 — #29
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
86
Without entrainment the highly concentrated CO cloud remains at high temperature, therefore is highly buoyant, creating thermal pressure on any leaks that may exist into the living compartment. In addition, any suction pressure within the enclosure, resulting from wind or other effects, will add to the entrainment of the offending gases. The concentrated pocket of exhaust under the floor of the motor home is in a location where leaks into the living quarters are more likely. If the exhaust jet impinges on the skirt or other surface at an angle, the jet stream will attach to and flow along the wall, (Coanda effect or wall jet attraction, Henry Coanda, French aviator, ca. 1918). The flattened jet is under negative pressure, causing it to entrain local ambient gases. Since this occurs in a confined area under the motor home, the gas being entrained is primarily exhaust gases, resulting in a high concentration of CO. The concentrated gases are in a location that is prone to have leaks into the living compartment.
4.6.14 MISSING EXHAUST SYSTEMS If the exhaust system, either the tailpipe or the muffler has been broken off, the remaining vertical spud directs the exhaust jet toward the ground. The jet characteristics are similar to those previously described. The hot exhaust gas jet entrains ambient gas and the mixed jet then impacts the ground. The hot jet after striking the ground flows outward from the point of impact and because of its buoyancy then flows upward. Thereafter, a recirculation pattern develops (Figure 4.13). The exhaust cloud remains in position, continually being regenerated. The suction in the exhaust jet entrains local gases, which are primarily exhaust gas and fresh air dilution is minimal. The re-entrained exhaust jet builds up a stationary, highly concentrated CO cloud under the generator and motor home. Winds acting perpendicular to the exhaust stream could move the cloud to a safer location depending on the direction and magnitude of the wind stream and terrain or boundaries in the vicinity of the generator. The stationary cloud has a relatively high temperature and therefore creates thermal pressure on the underside of the motor home and generator compartment where the probability of leaks into the living compartment is most likely. Generator compartment
Muffler spud Generator platform
Hot exhaust gas
Pavement
Recirculation vortex
FIGURE 4.13
Jet entrainment and recirculation under a motor generator without a tail pipe.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 86 — #30
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
87
4.7 ACCUMULATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE WITHIN AN ENCLOSURE The extent of disability or death of individuals exposed to CO and other toxic exhaust gas products of combustion is directly related to the partial pressure of the toxic gases within the enclosure, the duration of exposure, as well as the physical condition and rate of exertion of the individual and presence of other gases such as carbon dioxide. This discussion does not consider the medical aspects of such poisoning and refers the reader to other authoritative texts on the subject (other chapters in this book, and10,11 ). Earlier I described the sources of exhaust gases that are produced either within the enclosure or the volume flow rate of exhaust gases leaking into the enclosure from exterior sources. This section describes the procedures for determining the exhaust gas concentration at any specific time in the CO accumulation cycle. This information in conjunction with the Coburn–Forster–Kane equation may be used to evaluate the individual exposure to CO and their resultant COHb. Equation 4.14 evaluates the exponential increase of CO concentration within an enclosure that is initially filled with clean uncontaminated air. The program assumes that perfect mixing will occur within the enclosure. This is a reasonable assumption because the contaminating fluid is either jetted into the enclosure or is drawn in as a result of pressure differential, or is due to a thermal plume or jet with a sizable thermal head, all of which create mixing. In addition, the enclosures are generally small and are not subdivided into tight rooms or enclosures, that might create isolation or stratification of the leakage gases. Equation 4.14 allows for simultaneous introduction of exhaust gas, CO and also leakage of uncontaminated outside air. This same equation may be used to evaluate the concentration of other component gases contained in the exhaust gas by substituting the gas concentration in ppm, that is, QCO2 for QCO in ppm. Volume flow of carbon monoxide in incoming exhaust (CFM). QCO = QX ∗ CO/1000000
(4.12)
Total volume of exhaust plus leakage air into the enclosure (CFM). QMm = QLm + QX Concentration of carbon monoxide at time t. (QMm )∗ tn 100∗ QCO ∗ V Cn,m = 1−e QMm where CO is CO concentration, ppm, in incoming exhaust Cn,m is CO concentration within the enclosure at time tn and QMm , ppm e is a constant = 2.7183
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 87 — #31
(4.13)
(4.14)
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
88
m is step iterator (cfm) n is iterator of time (min.) Qco is volume flow of CO in the incoming exhaust gas (cfm) QL m is leakage of air entering the enclosure. Iterated by m (cfm) QMm is total volume of exhaust plus leakage air entering the enclosure (cfm) QX is volume of exhaust entering the enclosure (cfm) tn is the iterated value of time in min V is net volume of the enclosure (cu. ft.) Example: Assume a motor home having a 1680 cu. ft. volume, initially containing clean air, and with two openings, one at the top and one near the floor. Assume there is a 150 cfm roof exhauster located in the ceiling. Assume another motor home is parked parallel to this one whose motor generator is discharging exhaust gases containing 50,000 ppm CO in the direction of the first motor home, near the lower opening. Because of dilution and the size opening, assume that 100 cfm of diluted exhaust containing 2000 ppm of CO is drawn into the lower opening of the first motor home. Simultaneously, 50 cfm of clean air, (150 fan-100 exhaust), is drawn in through the upper opening. Determine the CO concentration with respect to time. Plot CO concentration when the total volume of exhaust plus leakage, QM m = 100, 125, 150, and 175, 200 cfm. Figure 4.14 shows the CO concentration in ppm within the enclosure with respect to time. Iterative computations were done for Qmx = 100 to 200 cfm. The middle dash line (m = 2) represents a flow of 150 cfm, when m = 150, which is equal to the exhaust fan volume of 150 cfm. The series of curves shows how CO concentration changes with higher and lower leakage flow rates, QL, into the enclosure.
CO concentration (ppm) at time tn 2000
C ppm0,n
CO concentration (ppm)
C ppm1,n 1500
C ppm2,n C ppm3,n
1000
C ppm4,n
500
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
tn Time (min)
FIGURE 4.14 Accumulation of carbon monoxide within an enclosure.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 88 — #32
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
89
Based on this information it is possible to predict the CO concentration at any period of time or to integrate the area under the curve, and to divide by time to determine the average concentration for any time span. Some important points may be made regarding this set of curves: 1. The solid curve, representing zero air leakage, shows that the CO concentration in the enclosure reaches a maximum concentration in the incoming exhaust gas after about 80 min. 2. Each successive curve maxes out at a lower concentration, all at about 80 min or less. 3. The CO concentration rises to a level dangerous to humans within 6 or 7 min. The CO concentration, for the example given, rises very rapidly for the first 20 min, reaching about 1100 ppm. Thereafter, the rate of rise diminishes and levels off at a maximum CO concentration of 1300 ppm at about 50 min. Thereafter the concentration stabilizes and remains constant. This information derived from this calculation can then be used in conjunction with the Coburn, Forster, Kane (CFK) equation, to determine blood COHb rise for any given period of time.
4.7.1 RATE OF DISSIPATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE FROM AN ENCLOSURE Earlier I discussed the rate of accumulation of CO within an enclosure. This section directs its attention to the dissipation of the accumulated CO when the rate of influx of CO, QCO , decreases or is zero, while a fan or exhauster continues bringing in fresh air. Dissipation of carbon monoxide within an enclosure. βn,m = ppmx ∗ e−((QCO + Qx) ∗ tn /V ) (4.15) where βn,m is CO concentration in the enclosure at the end of time tn (ppm). n is time iterator (min) ppmx is CO concentration at the start of the reduction QCO is volume flow rate of CO entering the enclosure, if any (cu. ft./min) Qx is volume flow rate of clean air entering the enclosure (cu. ft./min) t is time (min) V is volume of enclosure (cu. ft.) Reconsider the previous example with the following modifications: Assume that after 20 min of operation the motor generator is turned off, but all other conditions remain the same. Determine the rate of dissipation of CO within the enclosure with
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 89 — #33
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
90
Dissipation of CO versus time
Co concentration (ppm)
1500
1200
β 2, n
900
600
300
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
tn Time (min)
FIGURE 4.15 Dissipation of carbon monoxide from an enclosure.
respect to time. The exhaust fan, still running, takes up 150 cu. ft./min of fresh air which dilutes the 1100 ppm CO concentration within the enclosure. Equation 4.15 may be used to calculate the CO concentration after any time period. Figure 4.15 shows the dissipation curve starting at 1100 ppm at time t = 0 which correlates with Figure 4.14 at 20 min. Calculation of the type shown in section 4.7 and 4.7.1 can be used to calculate CO concentration where the source of CO cycles on and off, as would occur with a thermostatically controlled furnace. Depending on the on-off cycle time, the resultant graph would appear as a saw tooth curve. Integration of the area under that curve divided by time would yield the average concentration over any selected time span. If this information is to be used in the determination of blood COHb, a similar saw tooth curve would have to be produced accounting for the rise in COHb during periods where the CO partial pressure of the atmosphere exceeds the partial pressure of CO in the lungs. Also half-life calculations would have to be done to account for decreasing COHb where the partial pressure of CO in the enclosure is below that of the lungs during off time.
4.8 TEST METHODS FOR DETERMINING THE LOCATION OF LEAKAGE INTO AN ENCLOSURE In cases where CO intrusion into the living compartment occurs, it becomes important to determine the location and relative size of the opening or breach in the living compartment. NFPA3 and ANSI2 safety codes require that the living compartment of a mobile home or trailer equipped with a motor generator must be sealed against
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 90 — #34
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
91
intrusion of exhaust gases. Therefore, any opening or potential leakage path into the living compartment that is not sealed is of significance. Since exhaust gases, CO, carbon dioxide and nitrogen, are all colorless, odorless, and tasteless, it is not possible to detect their leakage using normal sensory perceptions. Scientific instruments, that detect the presence of the offending gas, may be used as long as it is possible to replicate original conditions regarding flow and generation of CO. Replication, particularly when wind or atmospheric conditions play an active role is usually very difficult. Additives to the gas stream may be used to enhance sensory perception as long as they do not affect the results. Smoke testing has proven to be simple, inexpensive and accurately shows the magnitude and position of leaks.
4.8.1 SMOKE TESTING Injecting smoke into an area where exhaust gases were known to accumulate is a practical way to make leakage into the living compartment visible, without appreciably changing the physical characteristics of the leakage stream. Visual contrast of smoke is good, as are photographic characteristics. Smoke makes it easy to detect the location of small and large leaks as well as to assess their magnitude. It should be pointed out that this is not an attempt to replicate the original exhaust gas stream. It is intended to show leakage paths and give an order of magnitude to the leakage stream. Commercial smoke-producing devices are readily available, which are inexpensive and safe to operate. These include candles of various sizes as well as other smoke generators. Candles will generate smoke over periods from 30 s to 3 min, in volumes from 4,000 to 40,000 cu. ft. Smoke generators can provide a continuous stream of high quality smoke where required. Colored smoke is available in candle form. Colored smoke gives excellent contrast especially in bland backgrounds, however, colored smoke is apt to cause permanent stains. Most manufacturers state that their smoke is not toxic. My experience has been that breathing smoke, even for a short duration, leaves an aftertaste, and lung congestion that is objectionable, and that persists for many hours. The use of a good high quality respirator seems to alleviate that problem. Smoke particle size in ranges from 2 µm (0.00004 in.) to 60 µm (0.0024 in.) therefore, has little effect on changing the flow characteristics of a gas stream. The smoke is stable and persistent, having a settling time of about 1.5 h, which is more than enough for most tests. The smoke, because of its small size will penetrate very small openings. Smoke can be released in open air or injected into the intake of a portable blower, when a pressurized stream is required. The internet is a good source for smoke candles or generators. Smoke candles, or the fluid used for a smoke generators are not permitted as carry on or shipped baggage on commercial aircraft.
4.8.2 BASIC CONSIDERATIONS DURING SMOKE TESTING In order to have either an inflow or an outflow of gases there must be a pressure differential between the inside and outside of the enclosure. The simplest way to
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 91 — #35
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
92
accomplish the pressure differential is to increase or decrease the enclosure internal pressure while allowing the ambient or outside pressure to remain at atmospheric conditions. Negative internal pressure replicates the conditions that would normally draw CO into the living compartment, therefore tends to replicates the actual accident conditions, assuming that the leakage areas have not been changed. Under some atmospheric conditions, generally high ambient temperatures, a thermal head may develop as a result of temperature differentials occurring during testing and must be overcome by additional pressure differential. Tests can be done by pressurizing or by creating a negative pressure within the enclosure. The specific type of test will be dictated by the circumstances.
4.8.3 POSITIVE PRESSURE TESTING Positive pressure testing requires a means for increasing internal pressure within the motor home or enclosure. This requires the installation of a turbo blower or other device that is not normally found in this type of enclosure. Additionally it requires that exhaust fans, ventilators, dryers, and similar openings be sealed during the test. Observation of small quantities of leaking smoke may be difficult to see in ambient or bright light conditions. Windy conditions will tend to dilute all but very large leakage streams. The diluted streams are much more difficult to photograph in bright sunlight where it may be impossible to control front lighting. Many of these problems can be eliminated if the testing can be done inside a building where wind and lighting can be controlled.
4.8.4 NEGATIVE PRESSURE TESTING Negative pressure testing is done by lowering the pressure inside the enclosure while providing a reservoir of dense smoke on the outside of the enclosure. It is desirable to locate the source of the smoke in the area where leaks are suspected. The advantage of this type of testing is that most motor homes, trailers or portable buildings already have exhaust ventilators, bathroom exhausters, fume hoods and dryers, that can be used to lower the enclosure pressure. Additionally, it is easier to see the smoke in interior controlled lighting conditions, where front and side lighting is easily achieved. Most tests can be performed without modification to the living enclosure. This is a distinct advantage in production testing but it is especially valuable in forensic cases where approval for modifications would have to be obtained, in advance of testing, from opposing counsel. Most CO intrusion incidents are from auxiliary generator engine exhaust that is normally discharged outside the living enclosure. As a generalization, motor homes develop exterior leaks in the floors and transition area of walls to floors, around wheel wells, and around conduits or pipes that penetrate the living enclosure. Frequently the leakage path is convoluted and difficult to detect using a light source or by trying to push a flexible object through the opening. Smoke testing is an easy and efficient way to detect these types of openings.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 92 — #36
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
93
4.8.5 TYPICAL SMOKE TESTING Smoke testing will give a good visual picture of the location and magnitude of leaks into a living compartment. Still and video photographs provide a means of recording real time results of the test. If photographs are judiciously taken they can be used to determine relative location and relative magnitude of leaks. Photos and videos are invaluable in forensic cases since they provide visual proof that leakage paths are present in the living compartment, which is in direct violation of NFPA and ANSI safety codes. Pictures are worth a thousand words, but only if it they are clear and depict the objects of interest accurately without distortion. As an example, the photographs in Figures 4.16 through Figure 4.22 tell a story of how and where CO leaked into the motor home. They show a replication, using smoke as a visible medium, of exhaust gas entering a motor home. The desired effect in this case was to show how large volumes of CO entered the motor home in a very short period of time. The photographs clearly show how the accumulation of smoke (the smoke representing CO) occurred. At the start of the test in the example shown, the interior of the motor home was clear without any obstruction. Figure 4.16 shows a view looking toward the back of the motor home. This shows that the internal atmosphere is clear. An additional photograph taken looking forward through the motor home and out the windshield shows that that section of the motor home is also free of haze (Figure 4.17). Figure 4.18 shows the first wisps of smoke appearing through the upper drawer of the end table. This photograph was taken after 1 min of elapsed time (ET) following initiation of smoke. This leak occurred at the left rear corner of the motor home. This was particularly important because that is where the generator was located. The smoke candle was located directly under the generator. The smoke traveled through a convoluted passage that could not be detected during inspection.
FIGURE 4.16 Looking aft before testing.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 93 — #37
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
94
FIGURE 4.17 Looking forward before testing.
FIGURE 4.18 Left rear corner, first smoke 1 min elapsed time.
From preliminary testing it was suspected that a large leak existed in the middlearea of the motor home. Thus attention was focused on that area. Figure 4.19 shows a view looking aft from the middle-point of the motor home. A large discharge of smoke was detected coming from the lower part of a storage cabinet. The interior atmosphere has become partially obscured at 2 min ET. Figure 4.20, 25 s later, shows obscuration has all but eliminated all detail in the previous photograph. Figure 4.21 shows total obscuration of the cabinet shown on the right of the previous photograph. This series of six photographs shows the location of the two leaks, and it shows that the mid point leak is the larger of the two. It shows that the rate of leakage is very
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 94 — #38
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
95
FIGURE 4.19 Looking aft second leak area, 2 min elapsed time.
FIGURE 4.20 Looking aft second leak 2 min 25 s elapsed time.
high in the interior part of the vehicle. The photographs show that the leaks were very large and smoke permeated the interior of the vehicle in a very short time. Total obscuration took place in three minutes. Timing with a stop watch, backed up by the time record from the digital and video cameras, used in conjunction with the known volume of the vehicle, made it possible to approximate the leakage rate of smoke into the interior of the vehicle. I have found that smoke testing is an efficient means of determining the location of leaks and also their relative magnitude. It has proven to be an invaluable asset in forensic cases.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 95 — #39
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
96
FIGURE 4.21 Second leak, totally obscured cabinet, 3 min elapsed time. Exhaust gas percent dry methane CH4 20 18
Percent (dry)
16 14 DEN*100 CO2 CO O2
12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
1
2
3 4 Equivalence ratio
5
6
FIGURE 4.22 Exhaust gas percent dry methane.
4.9 CONCLUSION Using the techniques presented in this paper, the source and magnitude of CO leaks into mobile homes and other enclosures may be determined. Photographs of the smoke intrusion provide a visual demonstration of the presence of leaks.
References 1. Mah, J.C. Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths and injuries Associated with the Use of Consumer Products U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission, October, 2000. 2. American National Standards Institute, Washington, DC.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 96 — #40
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
97
3. National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, MA. 4. Environmental Protection Agency. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, EPA 600/P-00/001B, Tables 3–7, 1999, Cincinnati, OH. 5. Boltz R. E. and Tuve G. L. Handbook of Tables for Applied Engineering Science, 2nd edition, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1987. 6. Williams, G. C. et al., The Combustion of Methane in a Jet Mixed Reactor, Twelfth Symposium on Combustion, Pittsburg, PA. 1968. 7. Jones, J.C. Combustion Sciences: Principles and Practices, Millennium Books, Newton, Australia, 1933. 8. Linan, L. and Williams, F. Fundamental Aspects of Combustion, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1993. 9. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration, Washington, DC 10. Penney, D.G. Carbon Monoxide, p. 296, CRC Press, NY, 1996. 11. Penney, D.G. Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, p. 560, CRC Press, NY, 2000.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 97 — #41
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 98 — #