CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page i — #1
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page ii — #2
CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING EDITED BY
DAVID G. PENNEY
Boca Raton London New York
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page iii — #3
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page iv — #4
Dedication ——————— I wish to dedicate this book first to my mother, Gertrude Ellen (Goodhew) Penney, always a source of support and encouragement, to my grandchildren, and to all of those victims of carbon monoxide poisoning who sought but did not find professional help for their suffering.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page v — #5
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page vi — #6
Preface Carbon Monoxide Poisoning is a new title covering further areas of the expansive field of carbon monoxide (CO) toxicology that were not covered in the first two books, Carbon Monoxide and Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, both edited by David G. Penney, PhD. Both were published by CRC Press, the first in 1996 and the second in 2000. This book is designed to be complementary to both earlier books, forging into new areas and following new themes. The scope of this book is even broader than the earlier two. The first book took a very scholarly approach, presenting the latest basic and medical science of CO toxicology in 13 chapters. The contents of that book remain current. The second book was broader in its approach, and while extending presentations of basic and medical science, added discussions of human CO exposure under specialized conditions and in geographic locations other than the United States, in 23 chapters. It also presents a large body of new data on both acute and chronic CO poisoning. This present, third book, Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, further extends these presentations both to new areas such as the law, rehabilitation, personal experience with CO poisoning, education of the public about CO using the World Wide Web, and so forth, and adds further new data on chronic CO poisoning. This book contains some unique features: 1. A critical look at the efficacy of hyperbaric oxygen therapy in decreasing the damage caused by CO poisoning 2. The use of exciting new scanning techniques in revealing damage from CO poisoning 3. The introduction of a handheld pulse-oximeter that reads COHb directly and noninvasively 4. New data showing the persistent health damage that can be caused by chronic CO poisoning 5. The dangers of CO poisoning possible in motor homes, recreational boats, and so on 6. The levels of ignorance regarding CO on the part of the general public Interest in the effects of carbon monoxide on human health has grown rapidly during the past 20+ years. Governmental agencies, private groups, and the public are concerned. While an old and familiar poison, CO remains the number one “poison” in our environment in terms of its “brain-killing” potential, and its potential for overall immediate and long-term health harm. The public and the medical community need to obtain quality information about the risks from CO and need the means to identify and manage victims of CO poisoning successfully. It is hoped that this book, and its two previous companions, will in some way be of value in meeting these challenges.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page vii — #7
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page viii — #8
Author David G. Penney, PhD, is a retired professor of physiology, who taught and conducted research on carbon monoxide at the School of Medicine, at Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan. He was at one time adjunct professor of occupational and environmental health in the School of Allied Health Professions at Wayne State University. He is also a retired director of general surgical research at Providence Hospital in Southfield, Michigan, where for 12 years he directed the scholarly activities of surgical residents and attending surgeons. Dr. Penney obtained his BSc degree from Wayne State University in 1963, and his MSc and PhD degrees from the University of California, Los Angeles, in 1966 and 1969, respectively. Before coming to Wayne State University in 1977, he was a faculty member at the University of Illinois, Chicago. With his wife, Linda Mae Penney, the couple have six children. Dr. Penney’s professional interests have been focused on carbon monoxide for over 37 years, in both animal models and in humans. His special interests center around chronic CO poisoning, education of the public about the dangers of CO poisoning, the diagnosis and management of CO poisoning victims, and the medicolegal aspects of CO toxicology. Dr. Penney has assisted many national and international government and nongovernment agencies in matters involving carbon monoxide. He was among the earliest consultants to the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in setting CO standards for outside air. He assisted the World Health Organization (WHO) in the late 1990s in setting similar standards for the world. He has worked with the Australian Medical Association (AMA) and with other concerned groups in Australia to attempt to stem the tide of suicides involving CO. Currently, Dr. Penney assists Underwriters Laboratory (UL) as a medical expert on CO in establishing standards for CO alarms and other gas-monitoring equipment, and major gas distributing companies in educating the public about the dangers of CO poisoning. Dr. Penney’s published works on CO include over 65 peer-reviewed research articles, several dozen other articles and abstracts, a number of review articles, book chapters, and three other books in print. At last count, Dr. Penney had more research articles and books published on the topic of CO toxicology than anyone else in the world. He has also published several other books on medical education and on Royal Oak history, and for some years wrote a column on local history for a hometown newspaper.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page ix — #9
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page x — #10
Acknowledgments I wish to thank all the authors, former patients, and all who have contributed to this book. It has been a long road and at times it seemed impossible. Now it is done. Thanks to everyone. I also wish to thank Wayne State University School of Medicine and my Department of Physiology chairman, Dr. Joseph Dunbar, for granting me the time off in 2005 to get the book off the ground. I of course thank CRC – Taylor and Francis Publishers and all their employees who have been wonderful to work with these past 12 years, in developing my three books on carbon monoxide. Finally, I wish to thank my wife Linda for her constant support in developing these books, hearing my complaints, providing inspiration and also some perspiration in getting the work done. I of course thank my mother, Gertrude, for her support, encouragement and even late night help with data entry.
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xi — #11
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xii — #12
Contributors Rob Aiers
Kosmas Galatsis, Ph.D.
Envirotec (UK) Ltd. Hampshire, U.K.
Microelectronics Advanced Research Corporation Center on Functional Engineered Nano Architectonics University of California Los Angeles, California
Carol L. Armstrong, Ph.D., A.B.P.N. Division of Oncology The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Department of Neurology University of Pennsylvania Medical School Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Steve N.M. Collard, B.A., M.E.D. Adjunct Professor of Law Nova Southeastern University Valrico, Florida
David C. Cone, M.D. Division of Emergency Medicine Yale New Haven Hospital Yale University School of Medicine New Haven, Connecticut
Joseph A. Cramer Wyoming, Michigan
James F. Georgis, O.D. Optometry Clinic Pueblo, Colorado
James M. Gracey, Ed.D. Colorado Institute for Injury Rehabilitation, Inc. Denver, Colorado
Neil B. Hampson, M.D. Center for Hyperbaric Medicine Section of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Virginia Mason Medical Center Seattle, Washington
Jacqueline L. Cunningham, Ph.D. Department of Psychology The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Michael F. Hanzlick
Thomas M. Dydek, Ph.D., D.A.B.T., P.E.
Alastair W.M. Hay, Ph.D.
Dydek Toxicology Consulting Austin, Texas
Gas Dynamics Corporation St. Paul, Minnesota
Molecular Epidemiology Unit LIGHT Laboratories School of Medicine University of Leeds Leeds, U.K.
Peter G. Flachsbart, Ph.D., A.I.C.P.
Dennis A. Helffenstein, Ph.D.
Department of Urban and Regional Planning University of Hawaii at Manoa Honolulu, Hawaii
Colorado Neuropsychological Associates Colorado Springs, Colorado
Robert E. Engberg, B.S., P.E.
Hanzlick & Associates Highland Ranch, Colorado
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xiii — #13
Contributors
xiv
Gunnar Heuser, M.D., Ph.D.
Joshua A. Mott, Ph.D.
Neuromed and Neurotox Associates Santa Barbara, California Clinical Assistant Professor University of California, Los Angeles Los Angeles, California
CDC/CCID/NCIRD Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch National Center for Environmental Health Atlanta, Georgia
S. Gregory Hipskind, M.D., Ph.D. Department of Anthropology Western Washington University Bellingham, Washington
Ramona O. Hopkins, Ph.D. Psychology Department and Neuroscience Center Brigham Young University Provo, Utah
Gary Hutter, Ph.D. Meridian Engineering & Technology, Inc. Glenview, Illinois
David G. Penney, Ph.D. Wayne State University School of Medicine, and Providence Hospital and Medical Centers (retired) St. Augustine, Florida & Beulah, MI
Linda M. Penney St. Augustine, FL & Beulah, MI
Kevin J. Reilly, Jr.
Richard Karg, B.S., M.S.
Training Operations & Firefighter Diversified Security Solutions, Inc. Saddle Brook, New Jersey
R.J. Karg Associates Topsham, Maine
James W. Rhee, M.D.
Michael E. King, Ph.D. CDC/CCEHIP/NCEH Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch National Center for Environmental Health Atlanta, Georgia
Jerrold B. Leikin, M.D. Rush Medical College Chicago, Illinois and Evanston Northwestern Health Care Glenview, Illinois
Section of Emergency Medicine & Medical Toxicology The University of Chicago Chicago, Illinois
Frank Ricci New Haven City Fire Department New Haven, Connecticut
Carlos D. Scheinkestel, M.D. Monash University Melbourne, Australia
Jane Brown McCammon, B.S., M.S.
Robert E. Schreter, B.S., P.E.
Double Angel Foundation Broken Circle M Consulting, LLC Littleton, Colorado
R. Schreter and Associates, Inc. Roswell, Georgia
Peter Tikuisis, Ph.D. Ian L. Millar Monash University Melbourne, Australia
Human Modeling Group Defence Research & Development Canada Toronto, Ontario, Canada
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xiv — #14
Contributors
Christian Tomaszewski, M.S., M.D., F.A.C.E.P., F.A.C.M.T. Department of Emergency Medicine University of Pittsburgh Medical Center Hannad Medical Corporation Doha, Qatar
Suzanne R. White, M.D., F.A.C.M.T., F.A.C.E.P. Children’s Hospital of Michigan Regional Poison Control Center Department of Emergency Medicine Wayne State University School of Medicine Detroit, Michigan
xv
Stephen P. Willison, B.S., J.D. Willison & Hellman, P.C. Grand Rapids, Michigan
Wojtek B. Wlodarski, D.Sc., Ph.D., M.Sc. E.E. School of Electrical and Computer Systems Engineering Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xv — #15
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xvi — #16
Table of Contents Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xxi
Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide, 1996 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xxv
Chapter 1 Introduction to and Overview of the Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney
1
Chapter 2 Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peter G. Flachsbart Chapter 3 Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures. . . . . . . . . Robert E. Engberg Chapter 4 Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide into Mobile Homes, Recreational Vehicles, and Other Enclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Robert E. Schreter Chapter 5 Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field Protocol for Measuring CO Emissions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Richard Karg Chapter 6 Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents Involving Gas-Burning Appliances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Michael Hanzlick Chapter 7 Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jane McCammon
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xvii — #17
5
43
57
99
129
157
xviii
Contents
Chapter 8 Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection . . . . . . . . . Gary Hutter Chapter 9 Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States: A Review of National Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Michael E. King and Joshua A. Mott Chapter 10 Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kosmas Galatsis and Wojtek Wlodarski Chapter 11 Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond: Use of the World Wide Web in Saving Lives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rob Aiers
197
233
251
271
Chapter 12 Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Thomas M. Dydek
287
Chapter 13 Carbon Monoxide Detectors as Preventive Medicine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James W. Rhee and Jerrold B. Leikin
305
Chapter 14 Misconceptions About Carbon Monoxide. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney
313
Chapter 15 A Survey Study of Public Perceptions About Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney and Linda M. Penney
325
Chapter 16 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Suzanne R. White
341
Chapter 17 The Case for the Use of Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy in Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Christian Tomaszewski
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xviii — #18
375
Contents
xix
Chapter 18 Hyperbaric Oxygen for Acute Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Useful Therapy or Unfulfilled Promise? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carlos D. Scheinkestel and Ian L. Millar Chapter 19 A Challenge to the Healthcare Community: The Diagnosis of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney Chapter 20 Neuroimaging after Carbon Monoxide Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gunnar Heuser
391
437
449
Chapter 21 Recent Advances in Brain SPECT Imaging after Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 457 S. Gregory Hipskind Chapter 22 Neurocognitive and Affective Sequelae of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . Ramona O. Hopkins Chapter 23 Neurocognitive and Neurobehavioral Sequelae of Chronic Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: A Retrospective Study and Case Presentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dennis A. Helffenstein Chapter 24 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: A Case Series . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney Chapter 25 Functional and Developmental Effects of Carbon Monoxide Toxicity in Children . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carol L. Armstrong and Jacqueline Cunningham Chapter 26 Issues in Rehabilitation and Life Care Planning for Patients with Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James M. Gracey Chapter 27 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning with Yoked Prism Lenses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James F. Georgis
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xix — #19
477
495
551
569
591
619
xx
Contents
Chapter 28 Firefighters and Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kevin J. Reilly, Jr., Frank Ricci, and David Cone Chapter 29 The Purpose and the Process of Litigation in a Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stephen P. Willison
643
655
Chapter 30 Offering Expert Opinions in a Carbon Monoxide Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stephen P. Willison
671
Chapter 31 Injury Caused by Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Defining Monetary Damages Steve Collard
683
Chapter 32 My Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: A Victim’s Story . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Joseph A. Cramer
725
Chapter 33 Noninvasive Measurement of Blood Carboxyhemoglobin with Pulse CO-Oximetry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neil B. Hampson Chapter 34 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Exposure: How Much Do We Know About it?—an Update . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alastair W.M. Hay
739
745
Chapter 35 Essential Reference Tables, Graphs, and Other Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . David G. Penney
753
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
765
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xx — #20
Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide Toxicity 2000
Chapter 1 History of Carbon Monoxide Toxicology Dieter Pankow Chapter 2 Carbon Monoxide in Breath, Blood, and Other Tissues Hendrik J. Vreman, Ronald J. Wong, and David K Stevenson Chapter 3 Carbon Monoxide Detectors Richard Kwor Chapter 4 The Setting of Health-Based Standards for Ambient Carbon Monoxide and Their Impact on Atmospheric Levels James A. Raub Chapter 5 Effect of Carbon Monoxide on Work and Exercise Capacity in Humans Milan J. Hazucha Chapter 6 The Interacting Effects of Altitude and Carbon Monoxide James J. McGrath Chapter 7 Interactions Among Carbon Monoxide, Hydrogen Cyanide, Low Oxygen Hypoxia, Carbon Dioxide, and Inhaled Irritant Gases David A. Purser Chapter 8 Carbon Monoxide Poisoning and Its Management in the United States Neil B. Hampson
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxi — #21
Contents
xxii
Chapter 9 Death by Suicide Involving Carbon Monoxide around the World Pierre Baume and Michaela Skopek Chapter 10 Carbon Monoxide as an Unrecognized Cause of Neurasthenia: A History Albert Donnay Chapter 11 Update on the Clinical Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Suzanne R. White Chapter 12 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning in France Monique Mathieu-Nolf and Daniel Mathieu Chapter 13 Acute Carbon Monoxide Poisonings in Poland - Research and Clinical Experience Jerzy A. Sokal and Janusz Pach Chapter 14 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning in the United Kingdom Martin R. Hamilton-Farrell and John Henry Chapter 15 Carbon Monoxide Air Pollution and Its Health Impact on the Major Cities of China Qing Chen and Lihua Wang Chapter 16 Use of Scanning Techniques in the Diagnosis of Damage from Carbon Monoxide I.S. Saing Choi Chapter 17 Low-Level Carbon Monoxide and Human Health Robert D. Morris Chapter 18 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Poisoning David G. Penney Chapter 19 Chronic Carbon Monoxide Exposure: The CO Support Study Alistair WM. Hay, Susan Jaffer, and Debbie Davis
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxii — #22
Contents
Chapter 20 Neuropsychological Evaluation of the Carbon Monoxide-Poisoned Patient Dennis A. Helffenstein Chapter 21 Pediatric Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Suzanne R. White Chapter 22 Carbon Monoxide Production, Transport, and Hazard in Building Fires Frederick W. Mowrer and Vincent Brannigan Chapter 23 Approaches to Dealing with Carbon Monoxide in the Living Environment Thomas H. Greiner and Charles V. Schwab
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxiii — #23
xxiii
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxiv — #24
Table of Contents for Carbon Monoxide 1996
Chapter 1 Carbon Monoxide Analysis Roger L. Wabeke Chapter 2 Carbon Monoxide Formation Due to Metabolism of Xenobiotics Dieter Pankow Chapter 3 Modeling the Uptake and Elimination of Carbon Monoxide Peter Tikuisis Chapter 4 Cerebrovascular Effects of Carbon Monoxide Mark A. Helfaer and Richard J. Traystman Chapter 5 Pulmonary Changes Induced by the Administration of Carbon Monoxide and Other Compounds in Smoke Daniel L. Traber and Darien W Bradford Chapter 6 Effects of Carbon Monoxide Exposure on Developing Animals and Humans David G. Penney Chapter 7 Carbon Monoxide - From Tool to Neurotransmitter Nanduri R. Prabhakar and Robert S. Fitzgerald Chapter 8 Toxicity of Carbon Monoxide: Hemoglobin vs. Histotoxic Mechanisms Claude A. Piantadosi
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxv — #25
Contents
xxvi
Chapter 9 Carbon Monoxide-Induced Impairment of Learning, Memory, and Neuronal Dysfunction Masayuki Hiramatsu, Tsutomu Kameyama, and Toshitaka Nabeshima Chapter 10 Behavioral Effects of Carbon Monoxide Exposure: Results and Mechanisms Vernon A. Benignus Chapter 11 Delayed Sequelae in Carbon Monoxide Poisoning and the Possible Mechanisms Eric Kindwall Chapter 12 Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Suzanne R. White Chapter 13 Options for Treatment of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, Including Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy Stephen R. Thom
8417: “8417_c000” — 2007/9/25 — 20:28 — page xxvi — #26
1
Introduction to and Overview of the Field David G. Penney
CONTENTS References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4
I have designed this book to complete the series on carbon monoxide (CO) begun with Carbon Monoxide, 19961 and continued with Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, 2000.2 This and the second book are NOT new editions of the first book, as has often been assumed. While CO may seem a very narrow subject area, it finds its way into many diverse disciplines and its literature is vast. This third book, Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, completes the trilogy and should become a standard reference source on CO for years to come. The new book covers areas not previously presented, including rehabilitation, education of the public using the WWW, litigation involving CO poisoning, economic loss assessment, and firefighting. There are areas of update, such as the chapter by Dr. Suzanne White, on diagnosis and management. There are two chapters in which the authors take opposing views, one stating the case for use of hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) by Dr. Christian Tomaszewski and against the use of HBOT by Dr. Carlos Scheinkestel. One chapter deals with toxicology investigation (i.e., forensic) procedures. A series of chapters detail the risk of CO poisoning from kitchen ranges, recreational trailers and motor homes, and recreational powerboats. Three chapters cover the very important area of neuropsychological evaluation of adults and children following CO poisoning. The chapter by Dr. Dennis Helffenstein presents new data on a case series of patients that had sustained chronic CO poisoning. I have written a companion chapter to his in which a retrospective review of 61 chronically CO-poisoned patients were symptomatically evaluated (Chapter 24). Better Education of Physicians: This is essential if CO-poisoned patients are to be properly diagnosed and treated in the future. Several years ago I overheard a prominent emergency room physician say, “the standard of care for CO poisoning in the U.S. is less than the standard of care.” I estimate that in 80% of CO cases reviewed, one, two, or more mistakes were made in diagnosing and/or treating CO-poisoned patients. This may involve misdiagnosis, dependence on faulty pulse-oximetry data, administering NBO with the wrong 1
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 1 — #1
2
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
equipment (e.g., nasal prongs), failure to order HBOT when it was needed and possible, discharge of patients while still symptomatic, and so forth. Physicians should also be informed of the possible serious permanent health harm that chronic or lower-level acute CO poisoning can cause if not diagnosed immediately and treated fully. From my perspective, the CO cases that result from acute poisoning and those most likely to reach the media are actually the smaller fraction of all CO poisonings, while the chronic (i.e., occult) CO poisonings make up by far the largest fraction, and probably result in the most injuries, but they are the very group that physicians are least trained to properly deal with. Better Education of the Public: The public too needs education about the dangers presented by CO exposure. My chapter presenting the results of surveys of public perceptions of CO in Michigan and Florida shows this. While almost everyone knows that CO is a deadly poison, substantial fractions (sometimes most) of the adult and juvenile population cannot intelligently evaluate the risk of CO from automobiles, propane radiant heaters, generators, and recreational powerboats. In some situations people are overly cautious in a given situation, but in other situations people vastly underestimate the risk of injury and death. Youth, as opposed to adults, are particularly uninformed. New Approaches to Treating Acute, Severe CO Poisoning: There appears to be very little new in treating acute severe CO poisoning. We cannot decide for sure whether HBOT is more effective in reducing neurologic sequelae, even though it has been used for approximately 50 years. The pros and cons chapters on HBOT provide detailed discussions of many aspects of the situation, and a few ideas about possible new approaches. The bright light in this area is almost certainly the new generation of pulse-ox devices that read COHb directly and noninvasively. See Dr. Neil Hampson’s chapter about the testing of this device. Requiring Proper Warnings on Combustion Equipment: The lack of proper and adequate warnings on equipment that do, or under foreseeable conditions might, emit harmful or lethal amounts of CO remains a real problem. People continue to die because warnings on combustion devices are not obvious, explicit and direct, and not on the device itself. Warnings in operating manuals should be continued and improved, but they alone are insufficient because manuals are usually separated from the device. Warnings on the device must tell the user what might occur in using the device a certain way. Statements such as “provide adequate ventilation” are useless. The warning must specify where and when not to use the device, and for how long. Warnings in the United States should be written in both English and Spanish, along with standard prohibition symbols. Some of the devices this applies to include portable generators, cement saws, lawn mowers, pressure washers, scissor-lifts, kerosene heaters, propane-radiant heaters, lamps and cook stoves, powerboats, charcoal grills and hibachis, and so forth. See Dr. Hutter’s excellent chapter on warnings.
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 2 — #2
Introduction to and Overview of the Field
Rethinking Work Guidelines for Carbon Monoxide that Reflect the Science: Another area that needs immediate attention is threshold limit standards for inhalation of CO. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and World Health Organization (WHO) after extensive study and deliberation some years ago set the 8-h standard at 9 ppm, or 10 mg/m3 for outside air. On the other hand, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) have set different standards for the work environment. We know that people with coronary artery disease, congestive heart failure, asthma, and a state of fetal development are often members of the workforce, and represent a more sensitive, higher risk subgroup of the general population. It is also well known that people, even those with no obvious risk factors, vary widely in their tolerance of CO. Why then should the standards be so different—9 ppm (EPA, WHO) versus 50 ppm (OSHA) for the same species? This is a 5-1/2 fold difference! I believe it is time we in the toxicology community re-examine ambient air CO concentration work standards, and make decisions for new standards based only on the best science. Realization that Brain Damage Resulting from CO Poisoning Is not Dependent on COHb and/or Severity of Poisoning: New studies make it clear what many of us have believed for some time based on experience, that brain damage from CO poisoning is only very poorly correlated with the severity of the poisoning by whatever criteria, even the COHb saturation. Some people with very severe poisoning and/or high initial COHb values make remarkable recoveries, while some with what appears to be minimal poisoning, and even on occasion, near normal COHb when measured, incur substantial damage. Clearly, loss of consciousness is not required for the development of neurologic sequelae, although I sometimes hear the less well-informed say that it is. I believe everyone agrees that a longer (i.e., soaking) exposure is more detrimental than a short one, but strangely some still insist that chronic, lower-level CO exposure can cause no permanent harm. Other markers for brain damage have been proposed such as acidosis, gait/balance/clumsiness on presentation, and release of cellular enzymes, but it remains unclear how useful they are. Carbon Monoxide Disaster Management: Release of CO during certain kinds of disasters could pose significant problems. Fire almost invariably gives off CO as an incomplete combustion product, and fire is a larger or a smaller component in most disasters, especially those that might be instigated by terrorists. It is unclear to me whether any overall planning has been done by agencies of the government with respect to CO. Firefighters regularly encounter CO in the work they do, and have equipment such as self-contained breathing apparatus to deal with it. See the chapter on firefighting by Mr. Reilly, Mr. Ricci, and Dr. Cone. Other concerns for human health that may not yet be fully addressed include indoor car, monster truck, and motocross events, work in coal mines, warehouses, enclosed construction sites, and so forth where significant CO is generated by combustion devices. Since it is dangerous and
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 3 — #3
3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
4
foolhardy to run a portable generator inside a garage or house, why is it not dangerous to human health to run several monster trucks with huge gasolinefueled engines lacking catalytic converters inside a covered sports stadium? The recent Sago Mine disaster where a dozen men died slowly, mainly from CO poisoning, points out the need for adequate emergency equipment that would allow men to live for extended periods of time in the presence of lethal CO air concentrations. Autostarters—are they safe? How often will car engines be started inadvertently (by children, otherwise by mistake) in a closed garage, leading to injury or death from CO poisoning? The wonder is that CO has been with man since prehistory, probably since we first began using fire. Other scourges such as plague, cholera, typhus, smallpox, and so forth are gone, at least from the developed world, whereas this simple, small molecule, CO, continues to afflict us, and probably will, at least as long as we are wedded to the “carbon energy cycle.” I hope you enjoy this book and will use it with its earlier brothers, Carbon Monoxide (1996)1 and Carbon Monoxide Toxicity (2000).2
References 1. Penney, D.G., ed. Carbon Monoxide, CRC Press, NY, 1996, 296 pp. 2. Penney, D.G., ed. Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, CRC Press, NY, 2000, 560 pp.
8417: “8417_c001” — 2007/9/11 — 12:17 — page 4 — #4
2
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide Peter G. Flachsbart
CONTENTS 2.1 2.2
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Standards and Guidelines for Exposure to Ambient Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Trends in Carbon Monoxide Emissions and Ambient Air Quality . . . . . . . 2.4 Human Exposure to Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Microenvironmental Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1 Residential Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1.1 Nonfatal Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1.2 Fatal Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.2 Occupational Exposures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.3 Shopping Center Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4 Recreational Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4.1 Exposures on Recreational Vehicles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.4.2 Exposures at Indoor Sporting Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5 Commuter Exposures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.1 Defective Exhaust Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.2 Parking Garages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.3 Service Stations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.4 Drive-Up Facilities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.5 Airbag Deployment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.5.6 Motor Vehicle Emission Standards. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 Exposure to Methylene Chloride . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6.1 Nonoccupational Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6.2 Occupational Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8 Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6 7 8 10 17 17 18 19 20 22 23 23 24 25 26 29 29 29 30 30 31 31 32 32 34 34 5
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 5 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
6
2.1 INTRODUCTION Carbon monoxide (CO) is a gas commonly produced by incomplete combustion of fuels containing carbon atoms. Many people use these fuels (i.e., coal, gasoline, kerosene, natural gas, oil, propane, and wood) around the globe. As a result, CO is ubiquitous in the atmosphere. However, without sophisticated instruments, a person is unable to detect CO, because the gas is not irritating and has no color, odor, or taste. Moreover, the gas is a potential health hazard, because exposure to CO can starve critical body organs, especially the brain and heart, of oxygen. Once inside the lungs, CO molecules pass easily into the bloodstream and compete with oxygen for hemoglobin (Hb) in the red blood cells. About 95% of the absorbed CO readily binds with Hb to form carboxyhemoglobin (COHb), because the affinity of Hb for CO is over 200 times stronger than it is for oxygen. Thus, the percentage of total Hb in the blood that is in the form of COHb is a biomarker of CO exposure.1 The health effects of CO, which are a function of its concentration and the duration of exposure, range from subtle to severe. They include neurobehavioral, cardiovascular, and developmental effects, observed at low levels of CO exposure, to unconsciousness and death, which occur after acute exposure to high CO concentrations. Lethal CO exposures are usually linked to CO concentrations greater than 1000 parts per million (ppm) by volume. Coma, convulsions, cardiopulmonary arrest, and death have been observed when COHb levels reach 50%, although death from CO poisoning is frequently reported at far lower COHb saturations. The exact COHb concentrations that trigger acute and chronic health effects in different people differ widely. Sublethal levels of CO may cause neurological-type symptoms, including fatigue, headache, nausea, vomiting, deficit in short-term memory, to name a few. Exposures to these CO concentrations are often misdiagnosed as viral illness, clinical depression, and so forth. Still lower CO exposures (i.e., those producing less than 10% COHb) may not be associated under certain circumstances with overt symptoms.2,3 This broad range of effects makes CO relevant to people concerned with ambient air quality management as well as officials responsible for protecting public health and safety. Ambient air quality standards are the foundation of air quality management programs in many countries worldwide. Such standards typically specify maximum permissible concentrations in ambient air for certain pollutants. To achieve ambient standards in the United States, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) implemented progressively tighter tailpipe emission standards for motor vehicles. As a result, these standards have substantially reduced ambient CO concentrations in most metropolitan areas of the U.S. and have had other collateral benefits. For example, the nation had 11,667 fewer deaths from accidental CO poisoning between 1968 and 1998, according to a study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDCP).4 Still, an average of 480 U.S. residents died each year during 2001–2002 from nonfire-related unintentional CO poisoning. In addition, an estimated 15,200 persons, that is, people with confirmed or possible nonfire-related CO exposure or poisoning, were treated annually in U.S. hospital emergency rooms.5 In fact, more than 50% of all fatal poisonings reported in many countries may be attributable to CO, because these cases are under-reported or misdiagnosed by medical professionals.2
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 6 — #2
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
7
This chapter explores reasons behind the paradox of declining ambient CO concentrations in urban areas of the United States coupled with persistent injuries and fatalities from CO poisoning. The chapter is organized around the superposition principle of CO exposure, which may help to explain this paradox. This principle holds that CO concentrations at any given point in time and space consist of both ambient and microenvironmental components. The next section takes a closer look at ambient CO concentrations in urban areas. The chapter then describes how the development of portable monitors enabled measurements of personal exposure to CO concentrations in places where people perform routine daily activities. Since these activities often occur in specific microenvironments, the chapter then describes typical CO exposures where people live, work, shop, play and commute, and factors that affect these exposures. The last section offers some concluding thoughts.
2.2 STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES FOR EXPOSURE TO AMBIENT CONCENTRATIONS OF CARBON MONOXIDE The Clean Air Act (CAA) of 1963 was amended by the U.S. Congress in 1970, 1977, and 1990. The 1977 and 1990 versions largely reaffirmed the course set by the 1970 amendments.6 Under the 1970 CAA amendments, the U.S. EPA established the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) and set deadlines for their attainment. The current NAAQS reflect EPA’s scientific judgments about maximum allowable ambient concentrations and averaging times for certain “criteria” air pollutants including CO. Criteria air pollutants are those that could reasonably endanger public health or welfare. The 1970 and 1990 CAA amendments also mandated stringent motor vehicle emission standards as a means to achieve the NAAQS for CO and other air pollutants that have been linked to mobile sources. Air pollutant concentrations can be expressed either as ppm or as milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3 ) of air. Many of the studies reviewed in this chapter refer to the NAAQS for guidance on allowable limits of CO exposure. The EPA promulgated identical primary and secondary NAAQS for CO on April 30, 1971. The primary standards specify a level of air quality sufficient to protect public health and the secondary standards are intended to protect public welfare. The standards include “an adequate margin of safety” to reflect scientific uncertainties related to measurement of the effects of air pollutant exposure in the population. In 1985, EPA rescinded the secondary standard for CO, but retained two primary standards: 9 ppm (10 mg/m3 ) as an 8-h average and 35 ppm (40 mg/m3 ) as a 1-h average. Each standard may be exceeded once per year in an air quality control region (AQCR) without violating the standard.7 The NAAQS for CO are designed to keep COHb levels below 2% in the blood of 99.9% of nonsmoking healthy adults and people who belong to probable high-risk groups. Smokers are excluded because they may exhale more CO into the air than they are inhaling from the ambient environment. The high-risk groups include the elderly; pregnant women; fetuses; young infants; and those suffering from anemia or certain other blood, cardiovascular, or respiratory diseases. People at greatest risk
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 7 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
8
from exposures to ambient CO levels are those with coronary artery disease. Some of these people suffer myocardial ischemia as identified by ST-segment depression, during exercise when their COHb levels ≥ 2.4%.7 The symptoms of this disease are spasmodic attacks of chest pain (angina pectoris) caused by insufficient oxygen in the heart muscles. Controlled laboratory studies are needed to observe these health effects, because the COHb levels are at or near the lower margin of detection of current instruments.8 Although annual death rates from heart disease have been declining since 1980, heart disease is still America’s leading cause of death.9 Coronary artery disease reduces a person’s circulatory capacity, which is particularly critical during exercise when muscles need more oxygen. Given the widespread prevalence and lack of awareness of coronary heart disease, Godish3 argues that a significant number of people still may be at risk from CO exposure, even if ambient CO concentrations do not exceed the 8-h NAAQS for CO. The World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines for CO (see below) are also relevant to this discussion. Relative to the NAAQS for CO in the U.S., these guidelines have an identical 8-h concentration but a lower 1-h concentration. Unlike the NAAQS, the guidelines specify maximum concentrations for two shorter time spans (30 min and 15 min).10,11 Maximum Concentrations
Averaging Times
9 ppm (10 mg/m3 ) 25 ppm (30 mg/m3 ) 50 ppm (60 mg/m3 ) 90 ppm (100 mg/m3 )
8h 1h 30 min 15 min
WHO’s guidelines are intended to prevent blood levels of COHb from exceeding 2.5–3% in nonsmoking populations even when a person engages in relatively heavy work. Romieu12 reported that average COHb levels are about 1.2–1.5% in the general population and from 3% to 4% in the blood of cigarette smokers.
2.3 TRENDS IN CARBON MONOXIDE EMISSIONS AND AMBIENT AIR QUALITY The CAA amendments have substantially reduced nationwide CO emissions, even as other socio-economic indicators of growth have increased. For example, between 1970 and 2002, nationwide emissions of CO fell 48%, despite national increases of 38% in population, 155% in vehicle miles of travel (VMT), and 164% in gross domestic product.13 The rapid growth of VMT has been attributed to the decentralization of jobs and housing within urban regions during the post World War II era.14 The CAA amendments have also reduced ambient CO concentrations in urban areas of the United States. The U.S. EPA determines compliance with the NAAQS based on measurements of ambient air quality made by a nationwide network of fixed-site monitoring (FSM) stations. Ambient concentrations of air pollutants are
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 8 — #4
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
9
typically measured in air “external to buildings, to which the general public has access.”15 In urban areas, most ambient stations that measure CO concentrations are located near roadways.16 These stations use nondispersive infrared reference (NDIR) spectrometry to measure ambient CO concentrations. Monitoring instruments based on the NDIR method are large, complex and expensive, and require a vibration-free, air-conditioned facility for the production of accurate and reliable data. The nationwide network consists of state and local air monitoring stations (SLAMS), which send data to EPA’s Aerometric Information Retrieval System (now Air Quality System) within six months of acquisition.17 Several stations within the SLAMS network belong to a network of national air monitoring stations (NAMS) to enable national assessments of air quality. FSM stations typically reveal two peaks in ambient CO concentrations. These peaks usually coincide with periods of congested rush-hour traffic.7 For that reason, some exposure analysts consider CO to be a signature air pollutant for mobile sources. On a nationwide basis, the EPA’s annual emissions inventory revealed that highway vehicles accounted for 62.8% of the 93.7 million tons of CO emitted from all sources except fires in 2003.13 Regional inventories show that motor vehicles account for even higher percentages of all CO emissions released into the ambient air. For example, CO emissions from motor vehicles ranged from 78% of all CO emissions in Fairbanks, Alaska, to 96% of all CO emissions in Phoenix, Arizona. EPA classified both cities as having “serious” levels of ambient CO concentrations in 1999.18 An ambient station is considered to be in violation (i.e., nonattainment) of the NAAQS for CO, if it records a nonoverlapping average concentration that exceeds either the 1-h or 8-h standard more than once per calendar year. The historical record shows that cities have had more difficulty satisfying the 8-h standard than the 1-h standard. For the 8-h standard, the nonoverlapping average omits other high values that occur within 8 h of the first value. Also, values of 9.5 ppm, or greater, are counted as exceeding the 8-h standard due to the standard’s rounding convention. Maximum 8-h average CO concentrations typically exceeded 30 ppm when continuous monitors were first installed in some U.S. cities in the early 1960s. When EPA promulgated the NAAQS for CO in 1971, 91.4% of 58 ambient monitors recorded violations of the 8-h standard and 12.1% of 58 stations recorded violations of the 1-h standard.16 In 1996, EPA’s Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS) reported that CO levels exceeded the NAAQS in seven counties, which had a combined population of more than 12.7 million people.19 The CAA amendments require states to develop plans to achieve and maintain ambient air quality that satisfies the NAAQS. To prepare these plans, states inventory emissions in each AQCR for a baseline year and determine the necessary emission reductions to achieve the NAAQS. Pursuant to the 1977 CAA amendments, many states established inspection and maintenance (I/M) programs as required by their plans for those regions that were in nonattainment of the NAAQS. An AQCR must satisfy the CO NAAQS for two consecutive years to be considered in attainment by EPA. States must submit plans to EPA showing how the region will maintain that attainment for at least 10 years. As of March, 2006, OAQPS reported that there were 38 CO “maintenance areas” in the United States encompassing 89 counties with a combined population of 46.8 million people.20
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 9 — #5
10
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
Since 1995, 11 cities have reported violations of the 8-h standard and no monitor has reported a violation of the 1-h standard.16 Violations appear to persist in areas with meteorological and/or topographical handicaps. Meteorological handicaps make it particularly difficult for cities to satisfy the standard, because of the stochastic nature of ambient air pollutant concentrations. For example, violations of the NAAQS for CO in Fairbanks, Alaska, have been attributed to stagnant air masses during winter months. The atmosphere is more stable in Fairbanks during winter, because less sunlight causes ground-level temperature inversions to occur more frequently. Also, less air pollutant dispersion occurs in winter, because winds are milder and mountains surrounding the city hinder horizontal dispersion.16 As of March 2006, the EPA had classified five American cities (El Paso, Texas; Las Vegas and Reno, Nevada; the Los Angeles South Coast Air Basin, California; and Missoula, Montana) as urban areas that were in nonattainment of the NAAQS for CO. They represented eight counties with a total population of about 15.4 million people.21 Compared to 1996, there was one more county in nonattainment of the NAAQS for CO by 2006, and the total population living in such areas had increased by 21.3%.
2.4 HUMAN EXPOSURE TO CARBON MONOXIDE The study of population exposure is multidisciplinary and the definition of personal exposure has evolved over time. A recent definition states that exposure is the contact between an agent and a target at a specified contact boundary, defined as a surface in space containing at least one exposure point, that is, a point at which contact occurs. According to this definition, an inhaled CO molecule (the agent) reaches a human (the target) at the lining of the lung (the contact boundary), where CO exchange takes place between air and blood.22 Actual studies of CO exposure use small-scale portable monitors to measure CO concentrations within a few feet of a person’s nasal and oral cavities. These studies assume that the air surrounding the person is well mixed and that measured CO concentrations in that air represent the person’s actual exposure from CO inhalation. Besides inhalation exposure to CO, metabolic degradation of many drugs, solvents (e.g., methylene chloride), and other compounds of CO can elevate levels of COHb in a person’s blood. Because the endogenous production of CO from drugs and solvents may continue for several hours, it can prolong any cardiovascular stress from COHb. Moreover, the maximum COHb level from endogenous CO production can last up to twice as long as COHb levels caused by comparable exposures to exogenous CO.23,24 Hence, this chapter also discusses the literature on exposure to methylene chloride. Figure 2.1 illustrates an individual’s air pollutant exposure over time. In this figure, the function Ci (t) describes the CO concentration to which an individual i is exposed at any point in time t. Ott defined this event as the instantaneous exposure of an individual.25 The shaded area under the curve represents the accumulation of instantaneous exposures over some period of time (t1 − t0 ). This area also is equal to the integral of the air pollutant concentration function, Ci (t), between t0 and t1 . Ott defined the quantity represented by this area as the integrated exposure. An exposure analyst can derive the average concentration to which a person is exposed
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 10 — #6
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
11
Concentration
Ci (t )
t0
t1 Time
FIGURE 2.1 Exposure of person i to air pollutant concentration (C) as a function of time t.
by dividing the person’s integrated exposure by the period of integration (t1 − t0 ). This average concentration is sometimes referred to as the average exposure. To compare the average concentration with an established air quality standard, the period of integration should equal the averaging period of the standard. This concept of exposure thus combines two parameters, the air pollutant concentration and the time duration of exposure to the air pollutant. An exposure analyst assumes that these two parameters are directly proportional to the dosage of CO in the body, as represented by the level of COHb in the blood stream, and ultimately to health outcomes. Prior to the use of portable monitoring devices, exposure analysts relied on ambient data from FSM stations in urban areas to estimate population exposure. Such data were used to provide crude estimates of population exposure to CO concentrations that violated the NAAQS. For example, the President’s Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) did a crude estimate of population exposure to CO in the late 1970s.26 This method is based on data collected for each county in the United States. The estimate is derived as follows: TPE =
n
(pi )(di )
(2.1)
i=1
where TPE = the total population exposure in the United States (person-days) = the resident population of county i (persons) pi di = the number of days in a calendar year that violations of the NAAQS for CO are observed in county i (days) n = the total number of counties in the United States in a given year
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 11 — #7
12
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
For 1978, the CEQ estimated that the nation’s total population exposure above the 1-h NAAQS for CO of 35 ppm was 2.80 billion person-days. This represented about 3.7% of the total possible exposures of 75.555 billion person-days, which was derived by multiplying an estimated 207 million U.S. residents in 1978 times 365 days in a year.26 CEQ’s method was a crude estimate of total population exposure, because the estimate rested on three major assumptions: 1. The CO concentrations measured by the county’s fixed-site monitors were representative of concentrations to which residents were actually exposed. If a county had more than one fixed-site monitor, then the monitor with the worst CO concentration represented the exposure of all residents in the county. 2. Residents did not leave the county on days that violations of the NAAQS for CO occurred for that county. 3. There were no violations of the NAAQS for CO in counties that were not monitored (e.g., rural counties). Several scientific studies have questioned the validity of the first two assumptions as discussed below. The first assumption implies that ambient CO concentrations are spatially homogeneous throughout a county. A study in the early 1970s questioned the ability of FSM stations to accurately represent human exposure to ambient CO concentrations. Using large Tedlar™ bags filled by a constant flow pump over 5-min periods, Ott collected 1128 CO concentrations at “breathing height” at outdoor locations in San Jose, California, on weekdays between October 1970 and March 1971.27 Of 438 samples collected on 21 dates while walking along sidewalks of congested downtown streets, 60% were above values measured concurrently at the nearest FSM station. The correlation between the “walking samples” and FSM values was positive, but low (r = 0.20). On 2 of 7 days, the sidewalk concentrations (13 and 14.2 ppm) averaged over an 8-h period were well above the corresponding concentrations (4.4 and 6.2 ppm, respectively) reported for the FSM station. Overall, the 8-h average CO concentrations for the 7 days ranged between 1.4 and 3 times the values observed simultaneously at the FSM station. The highest values were in late December when streets were heavily congested with traffic due to Christmas shopping.28 The San Jose study confirmed the hypothesis that FSM stations did not represent the CO exposures of a person walking in outdoor settings of a major city. Since the San Jose study measured the CO exposure of only one person, other studies tested the hypothesis for larger groups of people. Some of these studies focused on commuters, because CO is a signature air pollutant of motor vehicle tailpipe emissions. For example, Cortese and Spengler29 recruited 66 nonsmoking volunteers who lived in different parts of the metropolitan area of Boston, Massachusetts. Each volunteer carried an Ecolyzer monitor attached to a Simpson recorder for 3–5 days between October 1974 and February 1975. The study reported that the mean of all commuter exposures (11.9 ppm) was about twice the concurrent concentration measured at six FSM stations (6 ppm). Automobile commuters had exposures nearly twice that of
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 12 — #8
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
13
transit users, and about 1.6 times that of people who did “split-mode” commuting, which involved both auto and transit. The first assumption of the CEQ method of exposure estimation also raises the following question: To what extent do ambient CO levels reflect the CO concentrations to which people are exposed indoors? Early studies of human activity patterns in America30 and other industrialized countries31 have consistently shown that people spend most of their time indoors. Several studies published in the early 1970s addressed this question.32−34 Each study examined the relationship between indoor and outdoor CO concentrations. In the absence of indoor sources, these studies found that indoor CO concentrations of office buildings tended to follow outdoor CO levels with some degree of time lag and with a tendency not to reach either the extreme high or low values that were found outdoors. The General Electric study also reported that CO concentrations were larger indoors than outdoors at heights greater than 100 ft above the roadway, due to entrapment of CO within the building.33 To simplify the exposure calculation, the CEQ assumed that each person spent 24 h at home, because the method relied on household data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. The CEQ method also assumed that people did not travel outside the area represented by the FSM station. People who live in cities spend a significant amount of personal time in pursuits away from the home. In a study of metropolitan Washington, DC, residents in 1968, Chapin found that the hours spent away from home, on the average, ranged from 6.33 h on Sunday to 10.64 h on Friday.30 In other words, people spent between 26.4% and 44.3% of their day away from home. Chapin also reported that people travel an average of 14.2 miles per day, which suggested that people moved between areas represented by different FSM stations over the course of the day. By the early 1980s, additional studies raised further questions as to the ability of FSM stations to represent the CO exposures of the public.35,36 As stated previously, FSM stations use the NDIR method to measure ambient CO concentrations. Because NDIR monitors are not portable, they cannot be used to measure CO exposure as a person performs routine daily activities. The advent of microelectronics during the 1970s enabled considerable progress to be made in the development of reliable, compact, mobile air quality monitoring instruments. The most dramatic of these were the new miniaturized personal exposure monitors (PEMs) as described by Wallace and Ott.37 These instruments could go nearly anywhere, as they were equipped with batteries and shoulder straps. The utility of PEMs for measuring personal CO exposure was demonstrated in several early studies. These included a study of automobile commuters in Los Angeles during the summer of 1973,38 and field surveys of personal exposure in many commercial settings of several California cities between November 1979 and July 1980.39 Continued technical improvements of PEMs stimulated scholarly interest in how to use them in studies of personal and population exposure. Both direct and indirect methods in the use of PEMs have evolved. The direct method distributes PEMs to ordinary people who record their CO exposures and activities directly using either a paper diary or an electronic data logger. For example, Cortese and Spengler used this method in their survey of Boston commuters.29 A second method relies on indirect estimates of population exposure, based on the
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 13 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
14
following model advocated by Fugas40 and Duan.41 Ei =
n
ck (tik )
(2.2)
k=1
where Ei = the total integrated exposure of person i over some time period of interest (e.g., 24 h) ck = the air pollutant concentration in microenvironment type k tik = the amount of time spent by person i in microenvironment type k n = the number of microenvironment types encountered by person i over the period of interest. The total exposure of a population can be determined by summation of the integrated exposures of individuals who are members of that population. The indirect method assumes that an individual’s total exposure to air pollution is a function of location and time. It follows that variation in the total exposure of an individual occurs because air pollution concentrations vary from one location to another and because time spent in different locations varies substantially from person to person. The indirect method postulates the existence of “microenvironments” in which a person is exposed to an air pollutant at a given concentration over a fixed period of time. Duan described a microenvironment as a “chunk of air space with homogeneous pollutant concentration.”41 Because of the potentially large number of microenvironments, Duan suggested that similar ones should be grouped, either by location (e.g., indoor or outdoor) or activity performed at a location (e.g., residential or commercial) into “microenvironment types.” Under the CAA, the U.S. EPA has authority to perform periodic reviews of the criteria that support the NAAQS. In the early 1980s, EPA scientists developed a riskanalysis framework to support its reviews of the NAAQS for CO.42,43 This framework required estimates of the percentage of an urban population that was exposed to CO concentrations that exceeded the NAAQS. The need for these estimates was partly related to EPA’s proposal to change the form of the primary standard from deterministic to statistical.44 In response to this need, the EPA supported development of several large-scale population models of CO exposure in the early 1980s. These models included the Simulation of Human Activity and Pollutant Exposure (SHAPE) model and the NAAQS Exposure Model (NEM). Subsequently, the EPA supported development of the probabilistic NEM for CO (pNEM/CO) and the Air Pollutants Exposure Model (APEX). To provide data for these models, the EPA funded both direct and indirect studies of urban population exposure. The indirect studies included measurements of CO in various microenvironments and a nationwide survey of human activity patterns as described later. EPA’s direct studies took measurements of the daily CO exposures of the noninstitutionalized, nonsmoking adult populations (ages 18–70 years) living in two metropolitan areas of the United States. The surveys were performed using portable CO exposure monitors equipped with data loggers to reduce the data-collection
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 14 — #10
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
15
burden on the population. Field surveys of 454 residents of Denver, Colorado, and 714 residents of Washington, DC, occurred during the fall of 1982 and winter of 1983. Study participants carried PEMs equipped with data loggers. They also kept diaries for 48 h in Denver and for 24 h in Washington. The studies revealed that ambient CO levels at the composite network of fixed-site monitors were able to track variation in personal exposures. However, the network overestimated the 8-h exposures of people with low-level personal exposures and underestimated the 8-h exposures of people with high-level personal exposures. With respect to the underestimates, over 10% of the daily maximum 8-h exposures in Denver exceeded the NAAQS of 9 ppm, and about 4% did so in Washington. The end-expired breath CO levels were in excess of 10 ppm, which was roughly equivalent to about 2% COHb in about 12.5% of the Denver participants and about 10% of the Washington participants. Recall, that the NAAQS for CO are designed to keep COHb levels below 2% in the blood of the general public including probable high-risk groups. During the survey period, the composite CO concentrations at fixed-site monitors exceeded the 8-h NAAQS for CO (9 ppm) only 3% of the time in Denver, and never in Washington, DC. Hence, the results of these two surveys raised further doubts as to the ability of fixed-site monitors to represent the total CO exposure of urban populations.45 The results of the population exposure studies in Denver and Washington did not persuade the U.S. EPA to change the form of the NAAQS for CO from deterministic to statistical. In September, 1985, the EPA announced that it would retain the existing primary NAAQS for CO, but that it would rescind the secondary standard to protect public welfare, because there was no evidence to support it.7 However, one could argue that the results of these two studies provided some justification for the tighter CO emission standards that had taken effect for new cars sold outside of California during the 1980 model year. (Under the CAA, the state of California has authority to set its own tailpipe emission standards.) For example, Table 2.1 shows results for selected microenvironments of the Denver study. The table shows that higher CO concentrations were associated with commuting by motor vehicles (i.e., motorcycle, bus, car, and truck). It also shows that indoor CO concentrations in excess of the NAAQS were observed in public garages and in service stations or vehicle repair facilities. In the Washington study, participants who commuted 6 h or more per week had higher CO exposures than those who commuted fewer hours per week. Likewise, participants who had occupations that involved motor vehicles (e.g., professional drivers of trucks, buses, and taxis; automobile mechanics; garage workers; and policemen) had a mean CO exposure (22.1 ppm) that was over three times higher than the average exposure of those who did not work with motor vehicles (6.3 ppm). The Denver population exposure study provided raw data to test the SHAPE model and the probabilistic version of the NAAQS Exposure Model (pNEM/CO). The evaluation of SHAPE showed close agreement between the observed and predicted arithmetic means of the 1-h and 8-h maximum average CO exposures. However, SHAPE over-predicted low-level exposures and under-predicted high-level exposures.48 Likewise, an evaluation of pNEM/CO showed relatively close agreement between simulated and observed exposures for CO concentrations near the
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 15 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
16
TABLE 2.1 Carbon Monoxide Concentrations of Selected Microenvironments in Denver, Colorado, 1982–1983 (Listed in Descending Order of Mean CO Concentration) n
Meana (ppm)
Standard Error (ppm)
22 76 3, 632 405 619 9
9.79 8.52 8.10 7.03 3.88 1.34
1.74 0.81 0.16 0.49 0.27 1.20
29 22 12 61 126 16 74 29 21
8.20 7.53 3.68 3.45 3.17 1.99 1.36 0.97 0.69
0.99 1.90 1.10 0.54 0.49 0.85 0.26 0.52 0.24
Indoor Public garages 116 Service stations or vehicle repair facilities 125 Other locations 427 Other repair shops 55 Shopping malls 58 Residential garages 66 Restaurants 524 Offices 2, 287 Auditoriums, sports arenas, concert halls 100 Stores 734 Health care facilities 351 Other public buildings 115 Manufacturing facilities 42 Homes 21, 543 Schools 426 Churches 179
13.46 9.17 7.40 5.64 4.90 4.35 3.71 3.59 3.37 3.23 2.22 2.15 2.04 2.04 1.64 1.56
1.68 0.83 0.87 1.03 0.85 0.87 0.19 0.002 0.48 0.21 0.23 0.30 0.39 0.02 0.13 0.25
Microenvironment In-Transit Motorcycle Bus Car Truck Walking Bicycling Outdoor Public garages Residential garages or carports Service stations or vehicle repair facilities Parking lots Other locations School grounds Residential grounds Sports arenas, amphitheaters Parks, golf courses
a An observation was recorded whenever a person changed a microenvironment, and on every
clock hour; thus each observation had an averaging time of 60 min or less. Source: Johnson, T. A Study of Personal Exposure to Carbon Monoxide in Denver, Colorado, Report No. EPA-600/4/84-014, Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1984 as reported in U.S. EPA. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, Report No. EPA 600/8-90/045F, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1991.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 16 — #12
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
17
average exposure (i.e., within the range of 6–13 ppm for the 1-h standard and within 5.5–7 ppm for the 8-h standard). Like SHAPE, pNEM/CO also over-predicted lower exposures and under-predicted higher exposures for both standards.49
2.5 MICROENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURES This section describes studies of CO exposures in microenvironments that people use to live, work, shop, play, and commute. In particular, it identifies factors that may contribute to high-level exposures in these microenvironments. High-level exposures deserve more attention, because population exposure models (i.e., SHAPE and pNEM/CO) appear to underestimate high-level exposures in these microenvironments, as stated earlier. These microenvironments were also chosen, because they were identified by the U.S. EPA’s National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS) as locations relevant to air pollution exposure. That survey collected 24-h retrospective diary data on activities and their locations from 9196 respondents interviewed in the 48 contiguous states from late September 1992 through September 1994. Table 2.2 summarizes the minutes spent on the diary days in six locations for respondents to the survey.50
2.5.1 RESIDENTIAL EXPOSURES Exposure to CO in the home is an important component of a person’s total daily exposure, because an estimated 68.7% of one’s time on average is spent inside a residence.50 Major sources of CO concentrations inside the home include unvented or poorly vented furnaces, gas appliances, fireplaces, wood stoves, kerosene space heaters, and charcoal grills and hibachis. Other CO sources include motor vehicles inside an attached garage. Studies of exposures to nonfatal concentrations are discussed first, followed by studies of unintentional deaths caused by high indoor CO concentrations.
TABLE 2.2 Time Spent in Different Locations by 9196 Participants of The National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS), October 1992–September 1994 Location In a residence Office-factory Bar-restaurant Other indoor In an enclosed vehicle Outdoors
Overall Mean (min)
Doer %
Doer n
Doer Mean (min)
990 78 27 158 79 109
99.4 20.0 23.7 59.1 83.2 59.3
9153 1925 2263 5372 7596 5339
996 388 112 267 95 184
Source: Modified from Klepeis et al., J. Expo. Anal. Env. Epid., 11, 231, 2001.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 17 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
18
2.5.1.1 Nonfatal Exposures Many Americans have appliances that emit CO in the home. These homes often use gas (natural gas and liquid propane) for cooking, heating water, and drying clothes. Of all participants of the NHAPS study, 38.3% had a gas range or oven at home, and 23.7% said that it had a burning pilot light. The same study showed that some people still use small appliances to heat a room: fireplace (10%); wood stove (6%); and kerosene space heater (2%). In the presence of indoor sources such as gas appliances, indoor CO concentrations often exceed outdoor levels.47 In a 1985 Texas study, CO concentrations were greater than or equal to the NAAQS for CO of 9 ppm in 12% of surveyed homes. Residential CO concentrations were high in cases where unvented gas space heaters were used as the primary heat source.51 According to the Barbecue Industry Association, 44 million American households owned a charcoal grill in 1989, and an estimated 600 million charcoal-barbecuing events took place annually.52 An earlier study showed that the air stream from charcoal grills contained 20–2000 ppm of CO, with 75% of grills emitting 200 ppm and above.53 Another study reported COHb levels ranging from 6.9% to 17.4% in a family of four people in northern California who had been exposed to smoke from cooking indoors on a barbecue grill, which was found by firefighters in the middle of the living room.54 Based on data for ten counties, a study in Washington state reported features of unintentional CO poisoning cases that occurred between 1982 and 1993.52 Most cases occurred when electrical power was interrupted during fall and winter months, because of either regional storms or unpaid utility bills. Of 509 patients treated with hyperbaric oxygen, 79 (16%) were exposed to CO emissions when charcoal briquets were burned for heating or cooking in 32 separate incidents. Non-English speaking Hispanic whites and Asians were disproportionately represented among the cases. The COHb levels of these 79 people averaged 21.6% and ranged from 3.0% to 45.8%. Two studies assessed CO exposure to emissions from unvented portable kerosene heaters in eight small mobile homes with no gas appliances and low air exchange rates.55,56 Each home was monitored for an average of 6.5 h per day for 3 days per week for 4 weeks. For 2 weeks the heater was on, and, for 2 weeks, it was off. When the heater was turned on, it was in use for an average of 4.5 h. When the heater was in use, study participants (all nonsmokers) spent most of their time in the family room or kitchen. Sampling took place in the living area about 1.5–3 m from the heater. The mean 8-h CO concentrations were 7.4 ppm (1-h peak = 11.5 ppm) when the heater was on and 1.4 ppm (1-h peak = 1.5 ppm) when it was off. Peaks usually were observed at the end of the combustion period. The ambient CO level measured 0.5 h prior to heater use ranged from 0 to 8 ppm. When the heater was on, three of the eight homes had 8-h average CO levels that exceeded the NAAQS, and one home routinely had levels of 30–50 ppm. A California study reported CO exposures for a random sample of homes that used gas appliances during a 48-h period from December 1991 to April 1992.57−59 For periods of 48 h, the median CO concentration was 1.2 ppm (indoors) and 0.8 ppm (outdoors), and the median of the maximum 8-h average CO concentration was 2.0 ppm (indoors) and 1.4 ppm (outdoors). Of surveyed homes, 13 of 286 homes (4.5%)
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 18 — #14
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
19
had indoor CO concentrations above the NAAQS of 9 ppm for 8 h, and 8 of 282 homes (2.8%) had outdoor CO concentrations above this standard. Although most of the exceedances occurred in the Los Angeles basin, these percentages could be low because the basin was under-represented in the statewide sample. The study did not translate these percentages into statewide estimates. The study suggested that a small percentage of California homes would still have indoor CO problems even if outdoor CO levels at these homes complied with federal ambient standards. For a common sample of 277 homes, 17 homes (6.1%) had 1-h maximum concentrations indoors that were at least 5 ppm higher than outdoor levels, and 10 homes (3.6%) had 8-h maximum CO concentrations indoors that were at least 5 ppm higher than outdoor levels. Using univariate regression analysis, outdoor CO concentrations explained approximately 55% of the indoor CO variation. Higher net indoor CO levels (indoor minus outdoor CO concentrations) were traced definitively to space heating with gas ranges and gas-fired wall furnaces, use of gas ranges with continuous gas pilot lights, small home volumes, and cigarette smoke. However, several other factors also may have contributed to the higher CO levels: malfunctioning gas furnaces, automobile exhausts leaking into homes from attached garages and carports, improper use of gas appliances (e.g., gas fireplaces), and improper installation of gas appliances (e.g., forced air unit ducts).59 2.5.1.2 Fatal Exposures Factors contributing to unintentional deaths from CO poisonings were identified by studies in California and New Mexico. In California, two studies collected data for the 1979–1988 period. In the first study, 59 of 444 deaths (13.3%) were caused by improper use of charcoal grills and hibachis.60 Of the 59 deaths, 54% occurred inside motor vehicles (e.g., vans, campers) and 46% in residential structures (e.g., homes, apartments, shacks, tents). Relative to their share of the state’s population, higher death rates occurred amongAsians, blacks, males, and people aged 20–39. The second study identified specific factors that contributed to unintentional deaths caused by CO from several combustion sources (e.g., charcoal grills and hibachis, other heating and cooking appliances, motor vehicles, small engines, camping equipment).61 In this study, there was a strong association between alcohol use and CO poisoning from motor vehicles. Typically, motorists under the influence of alcohol would pull into their garages, leave the engine running while listening to cassette tapes, and then fall asleep. Faulty heating equipment used during winter months was implicated in about 50% of all unintentional deaths in both the California study61 and the New Mexico study.62 The National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) and the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) estimated that 212 deaths in 1992 could be attributed to fuel-burning appliances used in the home. Of these deaths, 13 involved use of gasoline-powered appliances.63 An estimated 3900 CO injury accidents occurred in 1994, of which about 400 were associated with the use of gasoline-powered engines or tools. In response to the problem, several federal government agencies issued a joint alert concerning exposure to CO emitted by these sources.64 These sources involved use of pressure washers, air compressors, concrete-cutting saws, electric generators,
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 19 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
20
floor buffers, power trowels, water pumps, and welding equipment. Unintentional CO poisonings frequently happened indoors even when people took precautions to ventilate buildings. Power outages following hurricanes and tropical storms often create demand for alternate sources of electricity (e.g., portable gasoline generators) to run air conditioners and refrigerators. But these generators can be a significant source of CO exposures if they are placed in garages or outdoors near windows. The majority of exposures occur overnight when generators are used to run air conditioners and other appliances. Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, which struck the U.S. Gulf Coast in the late summer of 2005, caused 10 deaths from CO poisoning in 18 storm-affected counties of Alabama and Texas.65 All of the fatalities were caused by gasoline-powered generators placed either inside the home or in a fully enclosed space outside the home. Very few homes had functioning CO detectors. In four hurricanes that hit Florida in 2004, some victims of CO poisoning placed generators inside their homes or garages to protect the devices from weather damage or to prevent theft.66
2.5.2 OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURES The NHAPS study reported that 20% of Americans spent nearly 6.5 h per day on average working inside an office or factory.50 The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) estimated that 3.5 million workers who work in the private sector potentially are exposed to CO primarily from motor exhaust. The number of persons potentially exposed to CO in the work environment is greater than that for any other physical or chemical agent.67 In 1992, there were 900 work-related CO poisonings resulting in death or illness in private industry according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics as cited in a NIOSH report.64 Three risk factors affect industrial occupational exposure: (1) the work environment is located in a densely populated area that has high background (i.e., ambient) CO concentrations; (2) the work environment produces CO as a product or by-product of an industrial process, or the work environment tends to accumulate CO concentrations that may result in occupational exposures; and (3) the work environment involves exposure to methylene chloride (i.e., dichloromethane), which is metabolized to CO in the body. Proximity to fuel combustion of all types elevates CO exposure for certain occupations: airport employees; auto mechanics; small gasoline-powered tool operators (e.g., users of chainsaws); charcoal meat grillers; construction workers; crane deck operators; firefighters; forklift operators; parking garage or gasoline station attendants; policemen; taxi, bus and truck drivers; toll booth and roadside workers; and warehouse workers.47 Table 2.3 shows results for several occupational studies (typical CO values and/or ranges), averaging periods, and the measured or estimated percent COHb levels for nonsmokers, if reported. The CO exposure of office building workers has received less attention. Flachsbart and Ott83 developed a “rapid method” for surveying CO concentrations inside several high-rise buildings. In one case, they observed CO concentrations in excess of 9 ppm, which is the 8-h NAAQS for CO, on four visits to a 15-story office building in Palo Alto, California. A survey in April 1980, showed that CO concentrations in the building’s underground garage averaged 40.6 ppm. The CO levels ranged from
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 20 — #16
5.0–13.6 (0.25 h) 5–300 (0.1–1.7 h) (INT) 5.8–12.5 TWA (0.5–1 h) NA >200 (<2 min) 16.2–24.3 TWA (8 h) 250–300 (5 h) NA (4.4 h) 370–386 (NA) 25–47 TWA (8–12 h) 3–34 (8 h) 42.6% > 35 (1 h) 2.7 (8 h) 1–4.3 (8 h) 5–42 (ENV)
Airport workers NA NA NA 9.2–75.6 in 5 farmers NA > 4 in 10 NS 5–22 for 4 NS 4.2–28.7 for 7 NS 21.1 ± 0.7 6.3–13.3 for 4 NS > 3.25 in 5% of NS > 5 in 45% of NS NA NA <5
Measured or Estimated Percent COHb Massachusetts, U.S. U.S. France U.S. U.S. Germany North Carolina, U.S. North Carolina, U.S. North Carolina, U.S. Colorado, U.S. California, U.S. Ontario, Canada 4 states, U.S. Denmark Massachusetts, U.S.
State/Country
68 69 70 71 64 72 73 74 75 76 77, 78 79 80 81 82
References
Note: ENV = short-term environmental measurements; INT = interior of vehicle; NA = not available; NS = non-smokers; and TWA = time-weighted average Source: Modified from Apte, M. A population-based exposure assessment methodology for carbon monoxide: development of a carbon monoxide passive sampler and occupational dosimeter, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 1997 and updated.
Garage mechanics Traffic/roadway workers
Forklift operators and workers in facilities with forklifts
Bus drivers Chainsaw/gas tool operators
CO Concentration (ppm) and Averaging Period
Occupational Category
TABLE 2.3 Studies of Occupational Exposures and Dosages
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations 21
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 21 — #17
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
22
10.2 to 18.5 ppm on the first eleven floors of the building, but were only 2–4 ppm on the top four floors. They attributed these findings to three factors: (1) fans ventilating the garage had been switched off to reduce electricity costs, because utility rates had increased sharply due to an international energy crisis; (2) the door connecting the garage with the main stairwell of the building was kept open; and (3) the first eleven and top four floors of the building were served by separate ventilation systems. Once the first two factors were corrected (i.e., the garage fans were switched on and the connecting door to the garage was closed), Flachsbart and Ott83 reported that average CO levels in the garage dropped from 40.6 ppm (before) to 7.9 ppm (after), while typical CO levels in the building fell from 11 ppm to 12 ppm (before) to 1 ppm to 2 ppm (after).
2.5.3 SHOPPING CENTER EXPOSURES The NHAPS study estimated that 59.1% of Americans spent nearly 4.5 h per day on average at other indoor locations, such as shopping malls, stores, schools, churches, health clubs, laundromats, salons, and parking garages.50 Of these locations, major shopping centers, in particular, attract and generate relatively large volumes of motor vehicle traffic that typically circulates at low speeds with frequent stops and starts. This traffic pattern produces relatively high CO emissions, which can accumulate to unhealthy levels if emissions occur in enclosed or semienclosed spaces. Since shopping centers also attract large numbers of people, the potential for human exposure to high CO levels is great. In the 1980s, the Ala Moana Shopping Center in Honolulu, Hawaii, was an example of this type of indoor CO exposure problem. First, the center had 155 business outlets that attracted 40 million people including many tourists each year. Second, the center had an attached structure with 7800 parking spaces on several decks. CO emission rates were high, because the posted speed limit for motor vehicles in the structure was 15 mph for the safety of pedestrians. CO emission rates increase when vehicle speeds fall below 15 mph. Third, one deck of the parking structure functioned as a lid on the exhaust emissions of cars at the street level of the structure. Fourth, many of the 94 outlets at street level kept their doors open during business hours to attract customers. This allowed CO concentrations from the parking area and internal driveways to diffuse into many retail outlets.84 Flachsbart and Brown visited 25 of the 94 street-level outlets at the shopping center every 5 days between November 1981 and March 1982.85 During one visit 4 days before Christmas Day, they estimated that average 1-h concentrations of CO inside ten stores exceeded the federal ambient standard of 35 ppm, but not the occupational standards which were 200 ppm for a 1-h period and 50 ppm for an 8-h period. The average CO levels during 3-min visits to these ten stores on that date ranged from a low of 36.3 ppm to a high of 86.7 ppm. An earlier study of the shopping center’s ground-level parking area found average CO levels ranging from 12 to 37 ppm.86 Although the two studies surveyed different locations of the shopping center, the lower CO levels observed by the 1981–1982 study of the center could be attributed to implementation of the federal motor vehicle emission control program during the 1970s.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 22 — #18
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
23
2.5.4 RECREATIONAL EXPOSURES Recreational exposures occur when people use recreational vehicles and when they watch or participate in certain indoor sporting events that involve motor vehicles.
2.5.4.1 Exposures on Recreational Vehicles Two studies examined personal exposure to CO in the exhaust of recreational vehicles. In the first study, Simeone sampled CO concentrations in the passenger areas of large power boats with side-mounted exhausts during routine cruises offshore of Annapolis, Maryland, and Boston, Massachusetts.87 In Boston harbor, CO concentrations averaged 56 ppm during a 60-min cruise and 28 ppm after a 30-min cruise. For the Chesapeake Bay cruises near Annapolis, average stabilized CO concentrations at the helm ranged from 93 to 170 ppm over 20- to 30-min periods and 272 ppm over 30 min on the rear deck near the transom of the boat. In both studies, exhaust gas was affected significantly by airflow about the boat under certain head winds. At head wind speeds of 10–30 knots, turbulent mixing occurred in closer proximity to the rear of the boats, enabling exhaust gases to migrate freely into each boat. In the second study, Snook studied the CO exposure of a second snowmobiler who tailed a lead snowmobiler on a 2- to 3-miles straight trail over level terrain in Grand Teton National Park, Wyoming.88 The CO exposure of the second snowmobiler was measured under stable atmospheric conditions in Tedlar™ bags. The distance between the two snowmobiles ranged from 25 to 125 ft., and speeds ranged from 10 to 40 mph. The second snowmobiler’s maximum average centerline exposure was 23.1 ppm, which occurred at 10 mph and 25 ft. behind the lead snowmobile. Although Snook reported no averaging times for exposures, one can estimate that these times ranged from 3 to 18 min from the data given on the snowmobiler’s travel distance and vehicle speed. In general, the centerline CO concentrations decreased with increasing distance between snowmobiles and increased with greater speeds, but only for distances greater than 25 ft. between snowmobiles. At 15 ft. off centerline, average concentrations fell sharply to levels of 0–7.5 ppm. When the snowmobiler drove alone (self-exposure), the average concentration minus the background concentration was 1.3–3.0 ppm. Background concentrations ranged from 0.2 to 0.5 ppm. At the time of Snook’s study, snowmobile tourism was a booming business across the nation and in several national parks. During the winter of 1993 and 1994, over 87,000 tourists traveled by snowmobile in Yellowstone National Park.89 Under steady-state conditions, a snowmobile may emit from 10 to 20 g of CO per mi, while a modern U.S. automobile equipped with a catalytic converter emits far less (0.01– 0.04 g of CO per mi) at speeds of 10 to 40 mph. Snook and Davis reported that there were no federal laws regulating the exhaust from snowmobile engines, and states were pre-empted from implementing snowmobile emission standards.90 The typical snowmobile utilized a two-stroke engine, because it is less expensive than a four-stroke engine and provides a high power-to-weight ratio. However, a two-stroke engine produces relatively high emissions of CO.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 23 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
24
2.5.4.2 Exposures at Indoor Sporting Events Significant quantities of CO are emitted by certain types of machines during sporting events that occur in poorly ventilated indoor arenas. The CO is emitted by several sources, including ice-resurfacing machines and ice edgers during skating events; gaspowered radiant heaters used to heat viewing stands; and motor vehicles at motocross, monster-truck, and tractor-pull competitions. These competitions usually involve many motor vehicles with no emission controls. Several studies of CO exposure at indoor sporting events are noteworthy. First, Kwok reported episodes of CO poisoning among skaters inside four arenas in Ontario, Canada.91 Mean CO levels ranged from 4 to 81 ppm for periods of about 80 min. The CO levels in the spectator areas ranged from 90% to 100% of levels on the ice rinks. The ice resurfacing machines lacked catalytic emission controls. Second, both Sorensen92 and Miller et al.93 reported CO concentrations greater than 100 ppm in rinks from the use of gasoline-powered resurfacing machines. High concentrations were attributed to poorly maintained machines and insufficient ventilation in one rink. Third, based on data collected in the Québec city area, Lévesque et al.94 developed a linear relationship between CO exposure and the CO concentration in exhaled breath, but could not eliminate other factors affecting the relationship. In a later study, Lévesque et al.95 measured the alveolar CO of 14 male adult nonsmokers who played ice hockey, but who were not exposed in occupational settings. Rink CO concentrations ranged from 0 to 76.2 ppm. The study again found a linear relationship between exposure and absorbed CO, such that for each 10 ppm of CO in the indoor air, the players absorbed enough CO to raise alveolar CO by 4.1 ppm or about 0.76% COHb. In the United States, surveys of CO exposure were done at ice arenas in Vermont, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, and Washington. For a rink in Massachusetts, Lee et al.96 showed that excessive CO concentrations can occur, even with well-maintained equipment and fewer resurfacing operations, if ventilation is inadequate. Average CO levels were less than 20 ppm over 14 h, with no significant source of outdoor CO. Ventilation systems could not disperse pollutants emitted and trapped by temperature inversions and low air circulation at ice level. In another study, Lee et al.97 reported that CO concentrations measured inside six enclosed rinks of the Boston area during a 2-h hockey game ranged from 4 to 117 ppm, whereas outdoor levels were about 2–3 ppm. The alveolar CO of hockey players increased by an average 0.53 ppm per 1 ppm CO exposure over 2 h. Fifteen years earlier, Spengler et al.98 found similar CO concentrations in the Boston area, with levels ranging from 23 to 100 ppm for eight enclosed rinks. In 1991, Paulozzi et al.99 reported that 25 people exposed to CO during a Vermont high-school ice hockey game had mean COHb levels of 8.9%, but did not report whether any of them were smokers. Although Paulozzi et al. were unable to measure CO concentrations at the game, Smith et al.100 reported CO levels of 150 ppm (no averaging time was given) at an indoor ice-hockey rink in Wisconsin. To document the extent of the problem in Vermont, Paulozzi et al. measured CO concentrations during eight high-school games in the state, and reported that average CO levels for the entire game ranged from <5 ppm to 101 ppm with a mean of 35 ppm.101
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 24 — #20
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
25
Hampson reported a maximum CO level of 354 ppm inside an ice arena in Seattle, Washington, in March 1996.102 Based on data for 17 persons, whose tobacco use was not reported, the average COHb level was 8.6% (range of 3.3–13.9%). The source of the CO was a malfunction in a 20-year-old ice resurfacing machine. The study also reported that CO may have diffused into an adjacent bingo hall through an open door. In view of these studies, the State of Minnesota declared in Regulation No. 4635 that CO measurements taken 20 min after ice resurfacing must be less than 30 ppm.102 Studies also have been done in sports arenas that allow motor vehicles. Boudreau et al.103 reported CO levels for three indoor sporting events (i.e., monster-truck competitions, tractor pulls) in Cincinnati, Ohio. The CO measurements were taken before and during each event at different elevations in the public seating area of each arena with most readings obtained at the midpoint elevation where most people were seated. Average CO concentrations over 1–2 h ranged from 13 to 23 ppm (before the event) to 79 to 140 ppm (during the event). Measured CO levels were lower at higher seating levels. The ventilation system was operated maximally, and ground-level entrances were completely open. High CO concentrations also have been found at motor vehicle competitions in Canada. Luckurst and Solkoski104 recorded CO concentrations at two tractorpull events in Winnipeg, Manitoba. The mean of instantaneous concentrations at 25 locations in the arena ranged from 68 ppm at the start of the first event to 262 ppm by the end. At the second event, the range was 78–436 ppm. Lévesque et al.105 reported CO levels at an indoor motocross competition held in a skating rink in the Québec City region. The May, 1994 event lasted from roughly 8:00 p.m. to midnight. Average CO concentrations determined at five stations located at different points in the arena ranged from 19.1 to 38.0 ppm, with the higher levels measured during the second half of the show. High CO concentrations forced a health official to interrupt the event seven times to help clear the air. Covariance analysis showed that CO levels were related to the initial CO concentration, the event duration, engine size, and especially the number of motorcycles on the track.
2.5.5 COMMUTER EXPOSURES The NHAPS study estimated that 83.2% of Americans spent 95 min per day on average inside a motor vehicle.50 Time spent inside a vehicle, as a percentage of a 24-h day (6.6%), is relatively small compared to the percentage of time spent at home (69.2%) or at work (26.9%). Still, one might expect commuter CO exposure to be high. Highway vehicles accounted for 62.8% of the total CO emitted from all sources except fires in the U.S. in 2003.13 In urban areas, highway vehicles typically account for even higher percentages of total CO emissions.3 Moreover, highway vehicles potentially are a major contributor to a person’s total CO exposure, especially if a person is routinely near motor vehicle emissions.106 Some evidence of this comes from the Denver population exposure study, which indicated that CO exposure while driving was a major component of a person’s daily CO exposure.45,48
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 25 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
26
In some ways, driving on congested roadways is analogous to swimming in a polluted river. However, the analogy isn’t perfect, because most commuters have enclosed vehicles, which may not fully protect their occupants from ambient CO concentrations. In a Los Angeles study, Petersen and Allen107 reported that interior CO concentrations averaged 92% of exterior levels. An earlier study by Petersen and Sabersky found that CO concentrations measured outside vehicles exhibit rapid variations and high peaks, while simultaneously measured concentrations inside a vehicle show more gradual variations.38 Several factors affect variation in the CO exposures of commuters as shown in Table 2.4, which lists several American studies in chronological order that have been performed on this subject over a 28-year period since 1974. Table 2.4 includes three studies of actual commuters29,45,108 and five studies of commuter microenvironments.109−113 A Boston study in 1974 revealed variation in the CO exposure of a bicyclist by street type, as defined by traffic volume and number of lanes.109 A few years later, Holland found that automobile commuter exposures varied among four cities surveyed during the winter of 1981.110 A later study attributed Denver’s higher exposures to its colder winter climate and higher altitude.114 Table 2.4 shows that exposures vary by commuting period (morning versus afternoon);29 trip type (residential versus commuting to an urban area);110 mode of travel (automobile, bus, and rail);111 season of the year (summer versus winter);108 trip location (rural, interstate beltway, and urban);112 and year of study.113 Akland et al.45 reported that actual commuters who spent six or more hours per week in travel had greater exposures than those who spent less than 6 h. Finally, Table 2.4 shows that seven of these studies found that commuter exposures typically exceeded concurrently measured ambient concentrations.29,45,108,110−113 2.5.5.1 Defective Exhaust Systems The need to control CO emissions from motor vehicles can be traced in part to studies that tied high CO exposures during commuting to defective exhaust systems and cars without effective emission controls. For example, Amiro115 found that engine and/or tailpipe emissions of CO leaked into passenger cabins of 9 of 19 vehicles studied. CO concentrations inside contaminated vehicles ranged up to 400 ppm. Clements reported that of 645 school buses tested, 7.2% had average CO readings in excess of 20 ppm, and 5.4% had maximum readings above 50 ppm.116 He estimated that CO concentrations in excess of 20 ppm existed in school buses ridden by up to 2.1 million U.S. school children on a daily basis in the 1970s. In a two-step study, Ziskind et al.117 first identified which sustained-use vehicles (buses, taxicabs, and police cars) had faulty exhaust systems, that is, they leaked CO into passenger cabins. Of 120 rides taken in faulty vehicles during the second step, the researchers found that 58% had CO concentrations that exceeded the U.S. NAAQS of 9 ppm for 8 h. In a later study, Hampson and Norkool reported that 20 of 68 children were treated for accidental CO poisoning after riding in the back of eight pickup trucks in Seattle, Washington, between 1986 and 1991.118 Average COHb levels measured in an emergency room were 18.2% ± 2.4% (mean ± standard error of the mean), and ranged from 1.6% to 37.0%. Seventeen of the twenty children rode under a rigid closed canopy attached to
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 26 — #22
Auto Auto
October ’74–February ’75
January–March ’81
January–March ’81
January–March ’83
Commuting period Morning Afternoon
City
Trip type Residential driving Urban commute
Mode of travel Washington, DC
Four citiesc
Stamford, CT Los Angeles, CA Phoenix, AZ Denver, CO
Boston, MA
Auto Bus Rail
Auto Auto
Auto Auto Auto Auto
Bicycle Bicycle Bicycle
Boston, MA
Summer ’74
Type of street Narrow-busy 2-lanes Wide-busy 4-lanes Narrow-light 2-lanes
Travel Mode
Study Period
Factor Urban Area
TABLE 2.4 Factors Affecting Commuter Carbon Monoxide Exposure.
9.1–22.3 3.7–10.2 2.2–5.2
2.9–7.6 6.2–16.1
5.2 8.5 6.7 10.3
12.8 13.9
16.4 (17.3)a 14.4 (10.9)a 10.1 (8.8)a
Mean or Median CO Concentration (ppm)
±2 to ±9 ±1 to ±7 0.5 to ±5
±3.6 to ±5.0 ±4.7 to ±7.7
±4.7 ±5.8 ±4.9 ±7.7
±5 ±6
3.3 (4.6)a 3.5 (1.9)a 0.88 (1.5)a
Range or SD of CO Concentration (ppm)
2.3
±2.4 to ±3.9 ±3.9 to ±5.8
4.2–5.5b 3.9–5.8 2.4–3.9 3.1–5.8
6.0
NA NA NA
Typical Ambient CO Concentration (ppm)
(Continued)
111
110
110
29
109
References
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations 27
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 27 — #23
9.7e 4.8e 1.5e
4 11 13
6.5 10.1
5.04 7.90
Mean or Median CO Concentration (ppm)
±3.1 ±1.7 ±0.8
NA NA NA
±2.2 ±5.8
NA NA
Range or SD of CO Concentration (ppm)
1.3 1.31 0.61
NA NA 2.8
2.8 4.3
3.2
Typical Ambient CO Concentration (ppm)
Note: a Rush hours: 7–9:30 a.m. and 3–5:30 p.m.; (non-rush hour concentrations) b Ambient concentration was measured outside the automobile. c Four cities were Stamford, CT; Los Angeles, CA; Phoenix, AZ; and Denver, CO. d Surveys occurred in the suburbs of Menlo Park, Palo Alto, and Los Altos. e Median of net CO concentrations for 50 trips, where the net value of each trip = average trip CO concentration − background CO concentration. NA = not available
San Francisco, CAd
Raleigh, NC
Los Angeles, CA
Auto Auto Auto
Auto Auto Auto
August–September ’88
Trip location Rural Interstate beltway Urban
February ’80–February ’81 February ’91–February ’92 February ’01–March ’02
Auto Auto
May ’87–March ’88
Season Summer Winter
Year of study
All All
Washington, DC
November ’82–February ’83
Travel Mode
Weekly travel < 6 h/wk ≥ 6 h/wk
Urban Area
Study Period
Factor
TABLE 2.4 Continued
113
112
108
45
References
28 Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 28 — #24
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
29
the bed of the truck, and the other three children rode beneath a tarpulin. Six pickups had a known leak in their exhaust system: three had a rear-end tailpipe and three had a side-mounted tailpipe. 2.5.5.2 Parking Garages Initial studies of CO concentrations in parking garages focused primarily on the garage itself. Trompeo et al.,119 who surveyed 12 underground garages in Turin, Italy, reported that CO levels averaged 98 ppm and ranged from 10 to 300 ppm for 132 observations. Chovin120 measured CO levels of 80–100 ppm on average in poorly ventilated garages in Paris, France. CO concentrations in parking garages can reach a peak in the late afternoon when many drivers leave work and start their cars at the same time. Goldsmith121 and Flachsbart et al.111 found that mass exits from garages can elevate pollutant levels to very high concentrations. The latter study observed spikes in CO concentrations (mean = 94.0 ppm based on 3-min averages, n = 14 cases) inside a test vehicle as it exited the underground garage of a government office building in Washington, DC, during a winter survey in 1983. The study also attributed these spikes in CO concentrations to the fact that many cars were operating under “cold-start” conditions. Once the test vehicle exited the garage, high CO concentrations inside the vehicle gradually dissipated, but the dissipation rate was slow because the vehicle’s windows were kept closed due to cold weather. 2.5.5.3 Service Stations Many motorists typically pump their own fuel at service stations. For safety reasons, most people shut off the engine of their vehicle after they arrive at the station. However, some people may be exposed to CO emitted by vehicles entering or exiting the station. Amendola and Hanes measured CO concentrations in thirteen service stations and two automobile dealerships in the New England area.122 Results varied by season, with CO concentrations ranging from 2.2 to 21.6 ppm in warm weather and 16.2 to 110.8 ppm during cold weather. They cited reduced ventilation as another cause of higher concentrations during winter. Based on a random sample of 100 self-service stations in four counties of southern California, Wilson et al.123 reported a median CO concentration (4.3 ppm), which was about twice that of the ambient level (2.0 ppm) for 5-min averaging times. 2.5.5.4 Drive-Up Facilities Passengers have been exposed to extremely high CO levels when motor vehicles are idling in a queue. During February and March of 1976, Myronuk124 measured CO concentrations inside an automobile at space-confined, drive-up facilities in Santa Clara Valley, California. The in-vehicle CO concentrations ranged from 15 to 95 ppm for 15-min averages, with short-term peaks of 100–400 ppm. High CO averages could be attributed to older vehicles that lacked catalysts, even though these vehicles probably had other forms of emission controls and appeared to be well maintained
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 29 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
30
and tuned. Background CO levels were only 2–5 ppm and monitoring occurred when wind speeds were low. Concentrations varied widely if ventilating fans for heater or air conditioning units were in operation. 2.5.5.5 Airbag Deployment Airbags are currently a required safety feature on new cars sold in the United States. On the basis of deployment of four airbags, Wheatley et al.125 reported that time-weighted-average (TWA) CO concentrations ranged from 174 to 370 ppm. Peak CO concentrations occurred 2 min after deployment. 2.5.5.6 Motor Vehicle Emission Standards One of the most significant factors affecting commuter exposure in the United States has been the federal motor vehicle emission control program.126 The CAA amendments of 1970, 1977, and 1990 established a series of progressively tighter motor vehicle emission standards and other controls on new cars sold in the United States. Tighter controls on the tailpipe emissions of new cars had the effect of offsetting the expansion of motor vehicle travel caused by population growth and urban sprawl since 1970.127 Prior to the 1968 model year, the CO tailpipe emissions of passenger cars in the U.S. were 84.0 g per mi. A series of progressively tighter CO emission standards took effect beginning with the 1968 model year, when a standard of 51.0 g per mi took effect. By the 1975 model year, CO tailpipe emissions fell to 15.0 g per mi as a result of the catalytic converter, which became standard equipment on new cars sold in the U.S. The CO emission standard was then lowered to 3.4 g per mi for the 1981 model year and then to 1.7 g per mi by the 2003 model year.3 This amounted to a reduction of nearly 98% in the CO emission rate of new cars between the 1967 and 2003 model years. Several studies show the effects on CO exposure of this trend. First, Flachsbart did a meta-analysis of 16 commuter exposure studies that occurred in the U.S. between 1965 and 1992.128 These studies reported typical (mean or median) CO concentrations for trips, most of which lasted an hour or less. CO concentrations fell from 37 ppm in 1965, as reported by Haagen-Smit129 for a study in Los Angeles, California, to 3 ppm in 1992 for a study by Lawryk et al.130 in the New Jersey suburbs of New York City. A more recent study of an arterial highway on the San Francisco Peninsula indicated that the median CO exposure of 50 trips taken over a 15-month period between 2001 and 2002 was 1.5 ppm.113 If one assumes that the results of these 17 separate studies between 1965 and 2002 are representative of commuter CO exposures in cities nationwide, then exposures fell 96% over the 37-year period. Notice that this percentage reduction in commuter exposure (96%) is nearly identical to the percentage reduction in the CO emission rate for new cars (98%). Also, the time period represented by the CO exposure reduction (1965–2002) is nearly identical to the period used to estimate the emission rate reduction (1967–2003). Finally, Mott et al.4 found that unintentional motorvehicle-related CO death rates in the United States fell from 4.0 to 0.9 deaths per one million person-years between 1975, when the catalytic converter was introduced, and
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 30 — #26
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
31
1998. They estimated that if rates of unintentional CO-related deaths had remained at pre-1975 levels, then 11,667 more vehicle-related CO deaths might have occurred by 1998. It’s quite possible that modern motor vehicle emission control programs have substantially reduced the sharp peaks in CO exposures observed in older studies of commuting microenvironments. A longitudinal study of commuting in California noticed a lack of sharp peaks in CO measurements during surveys of an arterial highway in 2001–2002 relative to observations of the same highway during previous surveys in 1980–1981 and 1991–1992. The study attributed this finding to California’s implementation of (1) an I/M program (i.e., Smog Check) in 1984; and (2) tougher “durability standards” on emission controls which were adopted in September 1990 and phased-in on new cars sold in California in 1993 and 1994.113
2.6 EXPOSURE TO METHYLENE CHLORIDE Exposure to halogenated hydrocarbons such as methylene chloride, which can be metabolized to CO in the body, occurs when the chemicals are found in contaminated ambient air and groundwater, and in consumer products that contain the chemical as a solvent, flame-retardant additive, or propellant.
2.6.1 NONOCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE Exposure to methylene chloride in the home, for example, primarily occurs through use of paint and varnish removers. Exposure may also occur through use of aerosol propellants such as those found in hair sprays, antiperspirants, air fresheners, and spray paints. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry reported that some aerosol products may contain up to 50% methylene chloride.24 Ambient exposure may occur near production and use facilities or near hazardous waste sites that store methylene chloride. In a study reported in 1983, ambient concentrations of methylene chloride near organic solvent cleaning and paint and varnish removal operations ranged from 7.1 to 14.3 parts per billion (ppb) averaged over one year.131 Although methylene chloride readily disperses when released into the air, it may remain in groundwater for years, and be ingested in drinking water or inhaled when it volatilizes during showering and laundering.24 Exposure to about 500 ppm methylene chloride for several hours can elevate COHb levels to 15%. Increases in COHb levels can be detected in the blood of nonsmokers about 30 min after exposure to methylene chloride. Stewart et al.132 showed that elevated COHb levels were proportional to a series of controlled exposures to methylene chloride. In another controlled experiment, Stewart and Hake133 observed postexposure levels of COHb ranging from 5% to 10% after 3 h use of a liquid-gel paint remover containing 80% methylene chloride and 20% methanol by weight. Concurrent exposure to methylene chloride and methanol prolongs the period of elevated COHb in the body.23,133,134 Peterson reported COHb levels of up to about 10% saturation after inhalation of methylene chloride concentrations ranging from 50 to 500 ppm over 5 days, for 7.5 h per day.135
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 31 — #27
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
32
2.6.2 OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE Certain occupations expose workers to organic solvents such as methylene chloride. The solvent is widely used as a degreaser, paint remover, aerosol propellant, and blowing agent for polyurethane foams. It is used as an extractant for foods and spices, a grain fumigant, and a low-pressure refrigerant. It also is used in the manufacturing of synthetic fibers, photographic film, polycarbonate plastics, pharmaceuticals, printed circuit boards, and inks. More than one million workers have significant potential for exposure to methylene chloride.24 Moreover, the highest levels of exposure to methylene chloride often occur in the workplace. To protect worker health, the 8-h TWA threshold limit value for methylene chloride was set at 50 ppm by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH).136 Exposure at this concentration leads to COHb levels of about 1.9% in experimental subjects. Exposure to 500 ppm for several hours may elevate COHb levels as high as 15%. An 8-h exposure to about 500 mg/m3 (3.5 mg/m3 = 1 ppm) of methylene chloride vapor is equivalent to an 8-h exposure to 35 ppm of CO.137 Methylene chloride stored in tissue may continue to be metabolized to CO after several hours of acute exposure. In such cases, COHb levels will continue to rise and peak as high as 25% about 5–6 h after exposure.24 Shusterman et al.138 reported an apparent linear elevation of COHb as a function of hours worked by a furniture refinisher who used paint stripper containing methylene chloride. Ghittori et al.139 reported a significant linear correlation (r = 0.87) between methylene chloride concentration in air and CO in alveolar air of nonsmoking and sedentary factory workers in Italy. Exposure to 600 mg/m3 of methylene chloride for 7.5 h was associated with a COHb level of 6.8% in eight volunteers. Exposure to methylene chloride also can be fatal. Leikin et al.140 reported fatalities of two people who were exposed to unknown concentrations of methylene chloride while they removed paint in an enclosed space. Death was caused not by CO poisoning, but by solvent-induced narcosis. Before they died, their COHb levels continued to rise following cessation of exposure despite treatment with high levels of oxygen.
2.7 CONCLUSIONS This chapter reviewed several types of CO exposure studies. Some studies measured CO concentrations in places where people live, work, shop, play, and commute. Other studies determined the amount of time people spent doing these activities. Still other studies identified factors that contribute to exposures in excess of federal ambient or occupational standards. A few conclusions from these studies follows. The NHAPS found that Americans continue to spend most of their time indoors. On average over a 24-h period, they spent 86.9% of their time indoors either at home, work, bar–restaurant, or elsewhere. They spent 5.5% of their time inside a motor vehicle and only 7.6% of their time outdoors.50 These percentages applied to the entire national sample of 9196 respondents interviewed in the 1990s, not just to the “doers” of various activities. If most Americans spend only a few hours outdoors each day, then indoor and in-vehicle CO exposures are important components of total human exposure.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 32 — #28
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
33
The findings of the NHAPS study underscore the importance of studies that compared indoor and outdoor CO exposures. Some of these studies indicated that indoor and outdoor CO exposures differed from those predicted from observations at fixedsite monitors, which are used by the U.S. EPA to determine compliance with the NAAQS. When ambient CO levels are either high or low on a given day, fixed-site monitors still reflect the corresponding high or low aggregates of personal exposures on those days. Otherwise, the stations do not adequately represent the CO exposures of community residents while they are exposed to motor vehicle exhaust during commuting, and to occupational and residential sources of unvented or poorly vented fuel combustion. The mean COHb level of people exposed to CO from these sources is greater than their mean COHb level predicted solely from exposure to CO of ambient origin. Longitudinal studies show that federal and state motor vehicle emission control programs have substantially reduced the CO exposures of urban commuters in the United States. These studies have two implications. First, similar reductions in exposure may exist for other microenvironments, especially those that may be affected substantially by tailpipe emissions from motor vehicles (e.g., office buildings and shopping centers attached to parking garages, as well as service stations, waiting lines at drive-up facilities, and sidewalks along busy streets). Unfortunately, there appear to be no published trend studies of CO exposure for these other microenvironments. Second, one would expect that results of certain population studies (e.g., the Denver–Washington study of 1982–1983) may no longer represent the CO exposures of current urban populations in the United States. More recent studies have shown that people are still exposed to elevated CO levels in certain indoor microenvironments (e.g., unventilated parking garages, motor vehicles with leaky exhaust systems, small homes with unvented or poorly vented gas stoves and space heaters). Moreover, studies report that high-level CO exposures can occur when people use unregulated gasoline-powered appliances, engines, and tools (e.g., chainsaws), even under ventilated conditions. These locations and activities are not part of the regulated ambient environment. However, these microenvironments typically represent settings of fatal and nonfatal CO poisonings. Studies of California homes indicated that elevated CO concentrations (>9 ppm) were caused by several factors, such as attached garages and carports; ranges with continuous gas pilot lights; and improper use and installation of gas appliances, especially in small homes. Other studies have found elevated CO concentrations (>9 ppm) when people ride certain types of recreational vehicles (e.g., snowmobiles, power boats), gather indoors to barbecue food (sometimes to cope with electrical power outages after severe storms), and watch sporting events held at indoor arenas. High-level exposures (>25 ppm) may occur inside arenas when they are used for ice skating or motocross, monster-truck, and tractor pull competitions. Vehicles in these competitions often lack any type of emission controls. At some events, ventilation did not sufficiently lower CO concentrations to safe levels (<9 ppm) for the general public. Finally, CO exposures are high in certain occupations, such as garage mechanics and chainsaw/gas tool operators, and for people who operate or work around forklifts. More than one million people have high exposure to methylene chloride in the
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 33 — #29
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
34
workplace, which is a concern because it can metabolize to CO in the body after several hours of exposure.
2.8 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Portions of this chapter are reprinted with permission from: Chemosphere—Global Change Science, vol. 1, M.A.K. Khalil, J.P. Pinto, and M.J. Shearer, Eds., P.G. Flachsbart, “Human Exposure to Carbon Monoxide from Mobile Sources,” pages 301–329, copyright (1999), published by Elsevier; Urban Traffic Pollution, D. Schwela and O. Zali, Eds., P.G. Flachsbart, “Chapter 4: Exposure to Exhaust and Evaporative Emissions from Motor Vehicles,” pages 89–132, copyright (1999), published by the WHO; Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology, 11(3), Neil E. Klepeis et al., “The National Human Activity Pattern Survey (NHAPS): a resource for assessing exposure to environmental pollutants,” pages 231–252, copyright (2001), published by Nature Publishing Group; A Population-Based Exposure Assessment Methodology for Carbon Monoxide: Development of a Carbon Monoxide Passive Sampler and Occupational Dosimeter, copyright (1997) by Michael G. Apte, Ph.D. Thesis, University of California, Berkeley; and Human Exposure Analysis, W. Ott, A. Steinemann, and L. Wallace, Eds., Peter G. Flachsbart, “Exposure to Carbon Monoxide,” pages 113–146, copyright (2007), published by CRC Taylor & Francis.
References 1. Burr, M.L. Combustion products, In Indoor Air Quality Handbook, Spengler, J.D., Samet, J.M., and McCarthy, J.F., eds., McGraw-Hill, New York, 2000, chap. 29. 2. Raub, J.A., Mathieu-Nolf, M., Hampson, N.B., and Thom, S.R. Carbon monoxide poisoning—a public health perspective, Toxicology, 145, 1, 2000. 3. Godish, T. Air Quality, 4th ed., Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL, 2004, 156–159. 4. Mott, J.A., Mitchell, I.W., Alverson, C.J., Macdonald, S.C., Bailey, C.R., Ball, L.B., Moorman, J.E., Somers, J.H., Mannino, D.M., and Redd, S.C. National vehicle emissions policies and practices and declining US carbon monoxide-related mortality, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 288, 988, 2002. 5. Vajani, M. Unintentional non-fire-related carbon monoxide exposures - United States, 2001–2003, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 54, 36, January 21, 2005. 6. Fiorino, D. Making Environmental Policy, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1995, 25–28. 7. U.S. EPA. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, Report No. EPA 600/P-99/001F, Office of Research and Development, National Center for Environmental Assessment, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 2000. 8. Raub, J. Environmental Health Criteria 213: Carbon Monoxide, 2nd ed., World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1999. 9. Arias, E., Anderson, R.N., Kung, H.-C., Murphy, S.L., and Kochanek, K.D. Deaths: final data for 2001, National Vital Statistics Reports, 52(3), Center for Health Statistics, Hyattsville, MD, 2003. 10. WHO. Carbon monoxide, In Air Quality Guidelines for Europe, WHO Regional Publications, European Series No. 23, World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, 1987, 210–220.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 34 — #30
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
35
11. WHO. Updating and revision of the air quality guidelines for Europe, Meeting of the WHO Working Group “Classical” Air Pollutants, Report No. EUR/ICP/EHAZ 94 05/PB01, World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, 1995. 12. Romieu, I. Epidemiological studies of health effects arising from motor vehicle air pollution, In Urban Traffic Pollution, Schwela, D. and Zali, O., eds., E & FN Spon, London, 1999, chap. 2. 13. U.S. EPA. National Air Quality and Emissions Trends Report, 2003 Special Studies Edition, Report No. EPA 454/R-03-005, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 2003. 14. Muller, P.O. Transportation and urban form: stages in the spatial evolution of the American metropolis, In The Geography of Urban Transportation, 3rd ed., Hanson, S. and Giuliano, G., eds., Guilford Press, New York, 2004, chap. 3. 15. U.S. Code of Federal Regulations, 40 CFR 50.1(e). 16. National Research Council. Managing Carbon Monoxide Pollution in Meteorological and Topographical Problem Areas, National Academies Press, Washington, D.C., 2003. 17. Blumenthal, D. The use of real-time air quality data in daily forecasting and decisionmaking, EM: The Magazine for Environmental Managers, September, 2005, 18. 18. U.S. EPA. National Air Quality and Emissions Trends Report, 1999, Report No. EPA/454/R-01-004, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 2001. 19. U.S. EPA. National Air Quality and Emissions Trends Report, 1996, Report No. EPA/454/R-97-013, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1998. 20. See: http://www.epa.gov/oar/oaqps/greenbk/cmsum. 21. See: http://www.epa.gov/oar/oaqps/greenbk/cntc. 22. Zartarian, V.G., Ott, W.R., and Duan, N. A quantitative definition of exposure and related concepts, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 7, 411, 1997. 23. Wilcosky, T. and Simonsen, N.R. Solvent exposure and cardiovascular disease, Am. J. Ind. Med., 19, 569, 1991. 24. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. Methylene chloride toxicity, Am. Fam. Phy., 47, 1159, 1993. 25. Ott, W. Concepts of human exposure to air pollution, Environ. Int., 7, 179, 1982. 26. Council on Environmental Quality. Environmental Quality - 1980: The Eleventh Annual Report of the Council on Environmental Quality, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1980, 27–40. 27. Ott, W. An urban survey technique for measuring the spatial variation of carbon monoxide concentrations in cities, Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, 1971. 28. Ott, W. and Eliassen, R. A survey technique for determining the representativeness of urban air monitoring stations with respect to carbon monoxide, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 23, 685, 1973. 29. Cortese, A.D. and Spengler, J.D. Ability of fixed monitoring stations to represent personal carbon monoxide exposure, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 26, 1144, 1976. 30. Chapin, F.S., Jr. Human Activity Patterns in the City, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1974. 31. Szalai, A., ed. The Use of Time: Daily Activities of Urban and Suburban Populations in Twelve Countries, Mouton and Co., The Hague, The Netherlands, 1972.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 35 — #31
36
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 32. Yocom, J.E., Clink, W.L., and Cote, W.A. Indoor/outdoor air quality relationships, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 21, 251, 1971. 33. General Electric Company. Indoor–Outdoor Carbon Monoxide Pollution Study, Report No. NTIS-PB220428, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1972. 34. Godin, G., Wright, G., and Shephard, R. Urban exposure to carbon monoxide, Arch. Environ. Health, 25, 305, 1972. 35. Meyer, B. Indoor Air Quality, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1983, 159–160. 36. Spengler, J. and Soczeck, M. Evidence for improved ambient air quality and the need for personal exposure research, Environ. Sci. Technol., 18, 272A, 1984. 37. Wallace, L.A. and Ott, W.R. Personal monitors: a state-of-the-art survey, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 32, 601, 1982. 38. Petersen, G.A. and Sabersky, R.H. Measurement of pollutants inside an automobile, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 25, 1028, 1975. 39. Ott, W.R. and Flachsbart, P.G. Measurement of carbon monoxide concentrations in indoor and outdoor locations using personal exposure monitors, Environ. Int., 8, 295, 1982. 40. Fugas, M. Assessment of total exposure to an air pollutant, Paper No. 38-5 in Proc. Int. Conf. Environ. Sensing and Assess., Vol. 2, Las Vegas, NV, 1975, 1. 41. Duan, N. Models for human exposure to air pollution, Environ. Int., 8, 305, 1982. 42. Padgett, J. and Richmond, H. The process of establishing and revising national ambient air quality standards, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 33, 13, 1983. 43. Jordan, B.C., Richmond, H.M., and McCurdy, T. The use of scientific information in setting ambient air standards, Environ. Health Perspectives, 52, 233, 1983. 44. Federal Register. Carbon monoxide; proposed revisions to the national ambient air quality standards: proposed rule, 45, 55066, August 18, 1980. 45. Akland, G.G., Hartwell, T.D., Johnson, T.R., and Whitmore, R.W. Monitoring human exposure to carbon monoxide in Washington, D.C., and Denver, Colorado, during the winter of 1982–1983, Environ. Sci. Technol., 19, 911, 1985. 46. Johnson, T. A Study of Personal Exposure to Carbon Monoxide in Denver, Colorado, Report No. EPA-600/4/84-014, Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1984. 47. U.S. EPA. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, Report No. EPA 600/8-90/045F, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1991. 48. Ott, W.R., Thomas, J., Mage, D.T., and Wallace, L. Validation of the simulation of human activity and pollutant exposure (SHAPE) model using paired days from the Denver, CO, carbon monoxide field study, Atmos. Environ., 22, 2101, 1988. 49. Law, P.L., Lioy, P.J., Zelenka, M.P., Huber, A.H., and McCurdy, T.R. Evaluation of a probabilistic exposure model applied to carbon monoxide (pNEM/CO) using Denver personal exposure monitoring data, J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc., 47, 491, 1997. 50. Klepeis, N.E., Nelson, W.C., Ott, W.R., Robinson, J.P., Tsang, A.M., Switzer, P., Behar, J.V., Hern, S.C., and Engelmann, W.H. The national human activity pattern survey (NHAPS): a resource for assessing exposure to environmental pollutants, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 11, 231, 2001. 51. Koontz, M.D. and Nagda, N.L. A Topical Report on a Field Monitoring Study of Homes with Unvented Gas Space Heaters: Volume III, Methodology and Results, Contract No. 5083-251-0941, Gas Research Institute, Chicago, 1988.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 36 — #32
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
37
52. Hampson, N.B., Kramer, C.C., Dunford, R.G., and Norkool, D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning from indoor burning of charcoal briquets, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 271, 52, 1994. 53. Yates, M.W. A preliminary study of carbon monoxide gas in the home, J. Environ. Health, 29, 413, 1967. 54. Gasman, J.D., Varon, J., and Gardner, J.P. Revenge of the barbecue grill: carbon monoxide poisoning, West. J. Med., 153, 656, 1990. 55. Mumford, J.L., Williams, R.W., Walsh, D.B., Burton, R.M., Svendsgaard, D.J., Chuang, J.C., Houk, V.S., and Lewtas, J. Indoor air pollutants from unvented kerosene heater emissions in mobile homes: studies on particles, semivolatile organics, carbon monoxide, and mutagenicity, Environ. Sci. Technol., 25, 1732, 1991. 56. Williams, R., Walsh, D., White, J., Jackson, M., and Mumford, J. Effect on carbon monoxide levels in mobile homes using unvented kerosene heaters for residential heating, Indoor Environ., 1, 272, 1992. 57. Wilson, A.L., Colome, S.D., and Tian, Y. California Residential Indoor Air Quality Study, Volume 1 - Methodology and Descriptive Statistics, Integrated Environmental Services, Irvine, CA, 1993. 58. Wilson, A.L., Colome, S.D., and Tian, Y. California Residential Indoor Air Quality Study, Volume 1 - Methodology and Descriptive Statistics, Appendix, Integrated Environmental Services, Irvine, CA, 1993. 59. Colome, S.D., Wilson, A.L., and Tian, Y. California Residential Indoor Air Quality Study, Volume II - Carbon Monoxide and Air Exchange Rate: A Univariate & Multivariate Analysis, Integrated Environmental Services, Irvine, CA, 1994. 60. Liu, K., Girman, J.R., Hayward, S.B., Shusterman, D., and Chang, Y. Unintentional carbon monoxide deaths in California from charcoal grills and hibachis, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 3, 143, 1993. 61. Girman, J.R., Chang, Y.-L., Hayward, S.B., and Liu, K.-S. Causes of unintentional deaths from carbon monoxide poisonings in California, West. J. Med., 168, 158, 1998. 62. Yoon, S.S., Macdonald, S.C., and Parrish, R.G. Deaths from unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning and potential for prevention with carbon monoxide detectors, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 279, 685, 1998. 63. National Center for Health Statistics and U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Death certificate file, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, 1992. 64. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Preventing Carbon Monoxide Poisoning from Small Gasoline-Powered Engines and Tools [NIOSH alert], Report No. DHHS (NIOSH) 96–118, Public Health Service, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Cincinnati, OH, 1996. 65. Tucker, M., Eichold, B., Lofgren, J.P., Holmes, I., Irvin, D., Villanacci, J., Ryan, J., et al. Carbon monoxide poisonings after two major hurricanes—Alabama and Texas, August – October 2005, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 55, 236, 2006. 66. Sniffen, J.C., Cooper, T.W., Johnson, D., Blackmore, C., Patel, P., Harduar-Morano, L., Sanderson, R., et al. Carbon monoxide poisoning from hurricane-associated use of portable generators - FL, 2004, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 54, 697, 2005. 67. Pedersen, D.H., and Sieber, W.K. National Occupational Exposure Survey, Volume III: Analysis of Management Interview Responses, Report No. PB90-193640, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1988. 68. Bellin, P. and Spengler, J.D. Indoor and outdoor carbon monoxide measurements at an airport, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 30, 392, 1980.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 37 — #33
38
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 69. McCammon, C.S., Halperin, W.F., and Lemin, R.A. Carbon monoxide exposure from aircraft fueling vehicles, Arch. Environ. Health, 36, 136, 1981. 70. Limasset, J., Diebold, F., and Hubert, G. Assessment of bus drivers’ exposure to the pollutants of urban traffic, Sci. Total Environ., 134, 39, 1993. 71. Kahler, M., Kuhse, W., and Wintermeyer, L.A. Unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning from indoor use of pressure washers - Iowa, January 1992–January 1993, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 42, 777, 1993. 72. Bünger, J., Bombosch, F., Mesecke, U., and Hallier, E. Monitoring and analysis of occupational exposure to chain saw exhausts, Am. Ind. Hygiene Assoc. J., 58, 747, 1997. 73. Baucom, C.D., Freeman, J.I., and MacCormack, J.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning in a garment-manufacturing plant - North Carolina, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 36, 543, 1987. 74. Fawcett, T.A., Moon, R.E., Francia, P.J., Mebane, G.Y., Theil, D.R., and Piantadosi, C.A. Warehouse workers headache: carbon monoxide poisoning from propane-fueled forklifts, J. Occup. Med., 34, 12, 1992. 75. Ely, E.W., Moorehead, B., and Haponik, E.F. Warehouse workers’ headache: emergency evaluation and management of 30 patients with carbon monoxide poisoning, Am. J. Med., 98, 145, 1995. 76. McCammon, J.B., McKenzie, L.E., Heinzman, M. Carbon monoxide poisoning related to the indoor use of propane-fueled forklifts in Colorado workplaces, Appl. Occup. Environ. Hyg., 11, 192, 1996. 77. Apte, M. A population-based exposure assessment methodology for carbon monoxide: development of a carbon monoxide passive sampler and occupational dosimeter, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 1997. 78. Apte, M.G., Cox, D.D., Hammond, S.K., and Gundel, L.A. A new carbon monoxide occupational dosimeter: results from a worker exposure assessment survey, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 9, 546, 1999. 79. Gourdeau, P., Parent, M., and Soulard, A. Exposition à l’oxyde de carbone dans les garages d’automobiles: évaluation chez les mécaniciens, Canada J. of Public Health, 86, 414, 1995. 80. Boeniger, M.F. Description of Facilities and Employee Exposure to Carbon Monoxide at Four Different Bridge and Tunnel Toll Authorities in the United States, Report No. IWS-45-02, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Division of Surveillance, Field Studies, Hazard Evaluations, Cincinnati, OH, 1995. 81. Raaschou-Nielsen, O., Nielsen, M.L., and Gehl, J. Traffic-related air pollution: exposure and health effects in Copenhagen street cleaners and cemetery workers, Arch. Environ. Health, 50, 207, 1995. 82. Kamei, M. and Yanagisawa, Y. Estimation of CO exposure of road construction workers in tunnel, Ind. Health, 35, 119, 1997. 83. Flachsbart, P.G. and Ott, W.R. A rapid method for surveying CO concentrations in high-rise buildings, Environ. Int., 12, 255, 1986. 84. Flachsbart, P.G. and Brown, D.E. Surveys of Personal Exposure to Vehicle Exhaust in Honolulu Microenvironments., Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, HI, 1985. 85. Flachsbart, P.G. and Brown, D.E. Employee exposure to motor vehicle exhaust at a Honolulu shopping center, J. Archit. Plan. Res., 6, 19, 1989. 86. Bach, W. and Lennon, K. Air pollution and health at Ala Moana Shopping Center in Honolulu, Hawaii Med. J., 31, 104, 1972.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 38 — #34
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
39
87. Simeone, L.F. The Intrusion of Engine Exhaust into the Passenger Areas of Recreational Power Boats, Report No. DOT-VNTSC-CG-91-1, John A. Volpe National Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge, MA, 1991. 88. Snook, L.M. An investigation of driver exposure to carbon monoxide while traveling in the wake of a snowmobile, Ph.D. thesis, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, 1996. 89. Wilkinson, T. Snowed under, National Parks, 69, 32, 1995. 90. Snook, L.M. and Davis, W.T. An investigation of driver exposure to carbon monoxide while traveling in the wake of a snowmobile, Paper No. 97-RP143.02 presented at the 90th Annual Meeting of the Air & Waste Management Association, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, 1997. 91. Kwok, P.W. Reduction of carbon monoxide in indoor skating arenas, Environ. Health Rev., 25, 60, 1981. 92. Sorensen, A.J. The importance of monitoring carbon monoxide levels in indoor ice skating rinks, J. Am. Coll. Health, 34, 185, 1986. 93. Miller, R.K., Ryan, M.C., and Bilowus, P. Carbon monoxide poisoning in indoor ice skating arenas, Va. Med., 116, 74, 1989. 94. Lévesque, B., Dewailly, E., Lavoie, R., Prud’Homme, D., and Allaire, S. Carbon monoxide in indoor ice skating rinks: evaluation of absorption by adult hockey players, Am. J. Public Health, 80, 594, 1990. 95. Lévesque, B., Lavoie, R., Dewailly, E., Prud’Homme, D., and Allaire, S. An experiment to evaluate carbon monoxide absorption by hockey players in ice skating rinks, Vet. Hum. Toxicol., 33, 5, 1991. 96. Lee, K., Yanagisawa, Y., and Spengler, J.D. Carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide levels in an indoor ice skating rink with mitigation methods, Air Waste, 43, 769, 1993. 97. Lee, K., Yanagisawa, Y., Spengler, J.D., and Nakai, S. Carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide exposures in indoor ice skating rinks, J. Sports Sci., 12, 279, 1994. 98. Spengler, J.D., Stone, K.R., and Lilley, F.W. High carbon monoxide levels measured in enclosed skating rinks, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 28, 776, 1978. 99. Paulozzi, L.J., Satink, F., and Spengler, R.F. A carbon monoxide mass poisoning at an ice arena in Vermont, Am. J. Public Health, 81, 222, 1991. 100. Smith, W., Anderson, T., Anderson, H.A., and Remington, P.L. Nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide intoxication in an indoor ice arena - Wisconsin, MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 41, 383, 1992. 101. Paulozzi, L.J., Spengler, R.F., Vogt, R.L., and Carney, J.K. A survey of carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide in indoor ice areas in Vermont, J. Environ. Health, 56, 23, 1993. 102. Hampson, N.B. Carbon monoxide poisoning at an indoor ice arena and bingo hall Seattle, 1996 [reprint of MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 45, 265, 1996] JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 275, 1468, 1996. 103. Boudreau, D.R., Spadafora, M.P., Wolf, L.R., and Siegel, E. Carbon monoxide levels during indoor sporting events - Cincinnati, 1992–1993 [reprint of MMWR: Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rep., 43, 21] J. Am. Med. Assoc., 271, 419, 1994. 104. Luckurst, D.G. and Solkoski, G. Carbon monoxide levels in indoor “tractor-pull events”—Manitoba, Can. Dis. Wkly. Rep., 16, 79, 1990. 105. Lévesque, B., Allaire, S., Prud’Homme, D., Rhainds, M., Lebel, G., Bellemarre, D., and Dupuis, K. Indoor motocross competitions: air quality evaluation, Am. Ind. Hygiene Assoc. J., 58, 286, 1997. 106. Colvile, R.N., Hutchinson, E.J., Mindell, J.S., and Warren, R.F. The transport sector as a source of air pollution, Atmos. Environ., 35, 1537, 2001.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 39 — #35
40
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 107. Petersen, W. and Allen, R. Carbon monoxide exposures to Los Angeles area commuters, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 32, 826, 1982. 108. Shikiya, D., Liu, C., Kahn, M., Juarros, J., and Barcikowski, W. In-vehicle Air Toxics Characterization Study in the South Coast Air Basin, South Coast Air Quality Management District, El Monte, CA, 1989. 109. Kleiner, B.C. and Spengler, J.D. Carbon monoxide exposures of Boston bicyclists, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 26, 147, 1976. 110. Holland, D.M. Carbon monoxide levels in microenvironment types of four U.S. cities, Environ. Int., 9, 369, 1983. 111. Flachsbart, P.G., Mack, G.A., Howes, J.E., and Rodes, C.E. Carbon monoxide exposures of Washington commuters, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc., 37, 135, 1987. 112. Chan, C.-C., Ozkaynak, H., Spengler, J.D., and Sheldon, L. Driver exposure to volatile organic compounds, CO, ozone, and NO2 under different driving conditions, Environ. Sci. Technol., 25, 964, 1991. 113. Flachsbart, P., Ott, W., and Switzer, P. Long-term trends in exposure to carbon monoxide on a California arterial highway, Paper No. 69237 presented at the 96th Annual Meeting of the Air & Waste Management Association, San Diego, CA, 2003. 114. Ott, WR., Mage, D.T., and Thomas, J. Comparison of microenvironmental CO concentrations in two cities for human exposure modeling, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 2, 249, 1992. 115. Amiro, A. CO presents public health problems, J. Environ. Health, 32, 83, 1969. 116. Clements, J. School Bus Carbon Monoxide Intrusion, Report No. DOT-HS-803-705, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation, Washington, D.C., 1978. 117. Ziskind, R., Rogozen, M., Carlin, T., and Drago, R. Carbon monoxide intrusion into sustained-use vehicles, Environ. Int., 5, 109, 1981. 118. Hampson, N.B. and Norkool, D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning in children riding in the back of pickup trucks, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 267, 538, 1992. 119. Trompeo, G., Turletti, G., and Giarusso, O. Concentrations of carbon monoxide in underground garages, Rassegna di Medicina Industriale, 33, 392, 1964. 120. Chovin, P. CO, analysis of exhaust gas investigations in Paris, Environ. Res., 1, 198, 1967. 121. Goldsmith, J. Contribution of motor vehicle exhaust, industry, and cigarette smoking to community CO exposures, Ann. NY Acad. Sci., 15, 122, 1970. 122. Amendola, A. and Hanes, N. Characterization of indoor carbon monoxide levels produced by the automobile, In Indoor Air Volume 4, Chemical Characterization and Personal Exposure, NTIS Report No. PB85-104214, Berglund, B. et al., eds., Swedish Council for Building Research, Stockholm, 1984, 97–102. 123. Wilson, A.L., Colome, S.D., and Tian, Y. Air Toxics Microenvironment Exposure and Monitoring Study, South Coast Air Quality Management District, El Monte, CA, 1991. 124. Myronuk, D. Augmented ingestion of carbon monoxide and sulfur oxides by occupants of vehicles while idling in drive-up facility lines, Water Air Soil Pollut., 7, 203, 1977. 125. Wheatley, A.D., Sadhra, S., and Beach, J.R. Exposure to toxic gas and particle phase pollutants evolved during deployment of airbags in vehicles, Indoor Environ., 6, 134, 1997. 126. Flachsbart, P.G. Human exposure to carbon monoxide from mobile sources, In Carbon Monoxide, Khalil, M.A.K., Pinto, J.P., and Shearer, M.J., eds. [special issue of papers
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 40 — #36
Exposure to Ambient and Microenvironmental Concentrations
127. 128.
129. 130.
131.
132.
133. 134. 135. 136.
137.
138.
139. 140.
41
from an international conference, December, 1997, Portland, OR] Chemosphere: Global Change Science, 1, 301, 1999. Transportation Research Board. Expanding Metropolitan Highways: Implications for Air Quality and Energy Use, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 1995. Flachsbart, P.G. Long-term trends in United States highway emissions, ambient concentrations, and in-vehicle exposure to carbon monoxide in traffic, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 5, 473, 1995. Haagen-Smit, A.J. Carbon monoxide levels in city driving, Arch. Environ. Health, 12, 548, 1966. Lawryk, N.J., Lioy, P.J., and Weisel, C.P. Exposure to volatile organic compounds in the passenger compartment of automobiles during periods of normal and malfunctioning operation, J. Expo. Anal. Environ. Epid., 5, 511, 1995. Systems Applications, Inc. Human Exposure to Atmospheric Concentrations of Selected Chemicals, Vol. II, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1983. Stewart, R.D., Fisher, T.N., Hosko, M.J., Peterson, J.E., Baretta, E.D., and Dodd, H. C. Experimental human exposure to methylene chloride, Arch. Environ. Health, 25, 342, 1972. Stewart, R.D. and Hake, C.L. Paint-remover hazard, JAMA: J. Am. Med. Assoc., 235, 398, 1976. Buie, S.E., Pratt, D.S., and May, J.J. Diffuse pulmonary injury following paint remover exposure, Am. J. Med., 81, 702, 1986. Peterson, J.E. Modeling the uptake, metabolism and excretion of dichloromethane by man, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 39, 41, 1978. ACGIH. Threshold Limit Values for Chemical Substances and PhysicalAgents: Biological Exposure Indices, American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, Cincinnati, OH, 1996. U.S. EPA. Health Assessment Document for Dichloromethane Methylene Chloride, Report No. EPA/600/8-82/004F, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, 1985. Shusterman, D., Quinlan, P., Lowengart, R., and Cone, J. Methylene chloride intoxication in a furniture refinisher: a comparison of exposure estimates utilizing workplace air sampling and blood carboxyhemoglobin measurements, J. Occup. Med., 32, 451, 1990. Ghittori, S., Marraccini, P., Franco, G., and Imbriani, M. Methylene chloride exposure in industrial workers, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 54, 27, 1993. Leikin, J.B., Kaufman, D., Lipscomb, J.W., Burda, A.M., and Hryhorczuk, D.O. Methylene chloride: report of five exposures and two deaths, Am. J. Emerg. Med., 8, 534, 1990.
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 41 — #37
8417: “8417_c002” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 42 — #38
3
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures Robert E. Engberg
CONTENTS 3.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Carbon Monoxide Safety and Monitoring Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Metabolic Uptake of Oxygen and Room Air Ventilation for Humans . . . 3.4 The Tracer Gas Model for Predicting CO Accumulation in Structures . . 3.5 Ventilation Requirements for Humans in Small Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 Oxygen Depletion Sensor Applications to Small Burners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7 Combustion Equations for Gas Burners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.8 Carbon Monoxide Accumulation Due to Small Engine Exhaust Gases . . 3.9 OSHA and Industry Standards for CO Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.10 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43 44 45 47 48 48 50 53 54 54 55
3.1 INTRODUCTION The problem of carbon monoxide (CO) production within habitable enclosures (i.e., breathing spaces) has been a chronic problem since the use of hydrocarbon fuels became widespread. We know that CO generation from these fuel sources is commonly caused by the lack of, or starvation of, adequate oxygen during the combustion process whether in a heating appliance, engine, or lighting fixture. The creation of CO becomes a problem when it enters an occupied space used by living creatures, either by accident or by design. Humans cannot sense such occult emissions until the blood saturation with CO begins to affect coordination and mental state. CO is transparent and colorless to the occupant of the space, as well as being odorless and nonirritative. When CO is discovered in significant concentration in a breathing space, the occupants may suffer sickness and even death. The presence of CO is not usually suspected in an enclosed space until dangerous levels are reached. CO generation from burning hydrocarbon fuels in combustion devices is due most often to improper fuel–air combustion ratios. This can be caused by oxygen starvation 43
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 43 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
44
at the burner and by improper setting of the fuel–air ratio at the appliance. Testing of combustion devices installed in small enclosures reveals that 4–5 air changes per hour (ACH) is necessary to allow the device to operate safely and not generate a CO concentration of greater than 100 parts per million (ppm). Experience shows that the fuel–air ratio of the burner can be easily upset by lack of inspection and maintenance of the combustion device. Primary air adjustment shutters are commonly obstructed by the collection of dust and lint, while combustion air passages can become restricted or exhaust ventilation ducts plugged. This causes the production of CO in closed spaces. It was not until the 1980s that the use of burner safety devices were legislated and used within the United States to attack the problem of CO deaths and injuries in closed breathing spaces. During the past 10 years, manufacturers of small portable heating appliances have designed and installed burner safety devices to affect shutdown under ambient conditions that might produce dangerous levels of CO. The most common and simple safety device built into fuel consuming appliances has been the oxygen depletion sensor (ODS). It is incorporated into the flame safety system of most burners. A typical ODS consists of a thermocouple that senses flame outage and acts to shut down the fuel valve and the pilot flame. This combination makes up the typical flame safety and ODS assembly on a fuel-burning device. A second option has been to incorporate a CO sensor into devices such as gas engines. The past decades have brought national and state codes and standards to bear in an effort to eliminate CO hazards in fuel burning devices, and in building construction standards and techniques. The American National Standards Institute (ANSI), the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), Underwriters Laboratory (UL), Canadian Gas Association (CGA) and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) are at the forefront as agencies that write and enforce CO safety device requirements in commercial products and building construction. One example of a standard is the requirement for minimum exhaust concentration limits generated within a test enclosure that is heated with a liquefied petroleum (LP) gas fueled, infrared (IR) camp type heaters (ANSI and CGA). Technology has greatly advanced in CO monitoring techniques and the measurement of environmental conditions. We can now estimate the oxygen uptake of a human at a given activity level in a closed space, in the presence of CO being produced by a malfunctioning heater operating under specified air exchange and combustion rates. We will discuss each of these techniques in the following sections.
3.2 CARBON MONOXIDE SAFETY AND MONITORING DEVICES It has become commonplace to install CO sensors in breathing spaces that have the potential of accumulating CO due to fuel combustion by heating appliances and engines. CO alarms are available at most hardware and home supply stores. The law requires CO monitors in most new house and apartment construction. For the UL
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 44 — #2
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
45
standards governing the set points of common CO alarms see Chapter 28 in this book. The way UL has set up the standards, lower CO concentrations take longer to produce audible alarm while higher CO concentrations trip the alarm in less time. The intent is to roughly model the rate of CO uptake by humans. Other types of CO monitors are designed for marine engine rooms, industrial environments, and so forth. Monitoring and data logging CO sensors are available for personal use, where walk around monitoring of an indoor environment may be needed. These units are available in pocket-sized and handheld models that record data from the environment at preset time intervals and store the data for downloading to computer for later display and interpretation. As stated above, the ODS has become popular for the safe shutdown of burner systems. The device has a calibrated shutdown feature that gauges ambient oxygen concentration by changing flame shape. The predetermined pilot flame will degrade in shape with the reduction of ambient oxygen. When this happens, the flame moves off the thermocouple, causing thermocouple output current to decline, which trips a gas valve, shutting down the burner. This principle was developed in Europe. The ODS has been a common safety device required on gas heating appliances since the 1970s. The pilot flame is a common safety device used with gas fueled appliances. It has been used successfully for many decades in the United States and Europe. It assures the ignition of any gas fumes or vapors around the burner and serves to ignite the burner. Its continued operation is also monitored through the use of a thermocouple that senses pilot flame heat. Pilot flames may be ignited either by a match or the everpopular piezoelectric spark igniter. The latter has become an added safety feature on gas burning appliances, since no open continuously burning flame is present, which might present a fire hazard and also consumes fuel over time. Exhaust stack gas analyzers are another type of CO sensor used to monitor boiler burner combustion efficiency. These handheld analyzers and monitors can be used to data-log exhaust stack conditions in terms of CO, oxygen, and carbon dioxide. They may also monitor other burner characteristics such as temperature, draft, excess air, and unburned hydrocarbons. These units also allow burner overall efficiency to be computed in a continuous fashion. Placing a thermocouple near the burner screen on an LP-fueled camp heaters is another safety device. One characteristic of some infrared heaters is the variation of burner screen temperature with respect to declining oxygen levels in a heated breathing space. The manufacturer may chose to design the screen-thermocouple such that it will shut down the burner with decreasing oxygen levels. This will occur before burner CO production is excessive. The details of this option are discussed later in this chapter.
3.3 METABOLIC UPTAKE OF OXYGEN AND ROOM AIR VENTILATION FOR HUMANS A major concern for humans occupying a small breathing space is the provision for adequate ventilation of that space for creature comfort, health, and safety. One design
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 45 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
46
question is just how much oxygen is consumed by the human body and how much ventilation is needed. To do that we must estimate the oxygen uptake of the human body. Coupled with this concern will be determining the oxygen depletion within the space that can be expected or allowed. For a description of the metabolic variables necessary for this calculation see Reference 1. All of these variables and concerns are best addressed by an example of a typical breathing space and occupant model. Such an example might be two hunters sleeping in a camp tent. The parameters that will be assumed for this calculation are as follows: 1. A tent will be of a cabin-type design, with nominal floor dimensions of 7.5 × 9.5 × 6.0 ft. (w × l × h), respectively, or 235 cu. ft., approximately. The tent will have been treated with a water repellent coating. 2. Two men sleeping and each weighing 200 pounds, no outdoor wind, and all tent windows and opening flaps closed. 3. A propane fueled, infrared heater set at a low heat setting of 8000 BTU/h, using commercial propane with a higher heating value (HHV) of 2550 BTU/cu. ft.2 4. Ambient air having 20.9% oxygen, and a design lower limit of 18.5% oxygen, where CO begins to be generated when using a typical camp heater. The mathematical variables used in the following equations and calculations are defined as follows with their associated units denoted in [… ..]: ACH = Vm /Ve , where Vm = minimum rate of fresh airflow per person, [cu. ft./h] and Ve = volume of the enclosure [cu. ft.]. M = metabolic rate (met) for a human is given as, 1 met = 18.4 [BTU/h * sq. ft.]. And M = 567(0.23∗ RQ+0.77)∗ QO2 /Ad, where RQ = 0.83 for light and sedentary activity; QO2 = volumetric rate of oxygen consumption at conditions (STPD) of 32◦ F, 14.7 psi (std. atm.) [cu. ft./h], and for a sleeping man the value to be used is M = 13 BTU/h*sq. ft. Now, solving for the oxygen uptake: QO2 = 13∗ 19.6/567∗ (0.23∗ 0.83 + 0.77) = 0.47 cu. ft./h. So, for two men, the oxygen uptake in the tent will be 0.94 cu. ft./h. Now, from our defined limits of minimum oxygen reduction in this space, we have: QO2 avail = (0.209 − 0.185)∗ V = 0.024∗ 235 = 5.64 cu. ft. of oxygen available. We next consider the oxygen uptake by the LP, infrared camp heater set at the “low” heat position, with a fuel flow as defined above. Using the HHV for propane vapor as 2550 BTU/cu. ft. (Reference 2, p. 24) and the stoichiometric combustion of propane, (volume of oxygen reacting for each volume of LP vapor is 5), we have: VO2 /VLP = 5 Therefore, when operating at the ‘low’ heat setting of 8000 BTU/h, we get: VLP = 8000/2550 = 3.137 cu. ft./h of propane used.
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 46 — #4
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
47
Next, the volume of oxygen utilized by the heater becomes VO2 = 5∗ 3.137 = 15.69 cu. ft./h. The time (t) needed to bring the oxygen level down to the critical minimum level at the onset of CO production will be: t = QO2 avail /(VO2 +2∗QO2 ) = 5.64/(15.69 + 0.94) = 5.64/16.62 = 0.339 h or 20.4 min. We can expect that after this amount of time spent in the tent, CO will begin to be generated by the heater assuming that no air exchange, or infiltration, has occurred during this period of time. The next job is to estimate the amount of infiltration air (ACH) that will be needed to maintain the oxygen level within the tent above 18.5%, remembering that the heater and the two men are competing for the available oxygen. We first write the equation that: QO2 (consumed) = QO2 (infiltrated) = 15.69 + 0.94) = 16.63 cu. ft./h = (0.209 − 0.185)∗ Vair , so, Vair = 16.63/0.024 = 692.7 cu. ft. of air exchange. Thus, ACH = Vm /Ve = 692.7/235 = 2.95 air changes per hour are needed to maintain an 18.5% level of oxygen in the tent. This value for ACH is in good agreement with experimental values for ACH required for LP heaters to not accumulate CO in closed breathing spaces.3
3.4 THE TRACER GAS MODEL FOR PREDICTING CO ACCUMULATION IN STRUCTURES This approach allows one to predict ACH for any enclosure. It is assumed that the tracer gas is distributed uniformly in the initial charge of fugitive gas used for this measurement. It is also assumed that air infiltration into the structure is uniformly distributed throughout the space. The typical tracer gas used for this measurement is sulfur hexafluoride (SF6 ). Its concentration (C) is described by the equation Ct = Co e−kt and solving for kt, ln (Ct /Co ) = −kt The latter equation indicates that a semilog plot of the quantity ln (Ct /Co ) versus time will be linear with time and that the ACH, (k) will be equal to the slope of this line. Since this line is expected to be linear, linear regression can be used to fit a line to the data and the expression describing how well the line fits the data is R2 , where R is the correlation coefficient. Assume that if testing yields an R2 greater than 0.9, then the test is acceptable. Now, if the ACH (k) is known, then the source strength (S) for CO generation of the heater can be computed from a simple mass balance of CO in the chamber. The equation predicting the CO generation rate is St(i+1) =
V ∗ k[Ct(i+1) − Ct(i) ∗ e−k{ti+1 −ti } ] , [1 − e−k{ti+1 −ti } ]
where V = the tent volume; St(i+1) is the generation rate of CO at time ti+1 , k = ACH, Ct(i+1) is the concentration of CO at time ti+1 and Ct(i) is the concentration of CO at time ti . The above equation was derived based on the assumption that the air in the
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 47 — #5
48
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
chamber is well mixed and that CO is not absorbed or adsorbed into the tent material or its contents.
3.5 VENTILATION REQUIREMENTS FOR HUMANS IN SMALL STRUCTURES The ventilation rate for a small enclosure is much the same as for larger spaces that are designed for occupation by humans. The American Society of Heating, Refrigeration, and Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) standard 62 specifies guidelines for the minimum ventilation airflow rate for various habitable structures. A flow rate of 15 scfm per person is a common requirement for residential structures. This flow rate will provide enough air to maintain the normal oxygen level for an average adult and will remove most pollutants as they accumulate in typical spaces. To reiterate, the oxygen depletion due to its uptake by two adults using a small camp heater within a tent space requires a minimum of about 3–6 ACH to supply enough oxygen to allow proper metabolism and to prevent the dangerous accumulation of CO. One must look at the geometry of the tent to predict whether the ACH will be effective for the occupants. Please make reference to the ASHRAE Fundamentals Handbook 1 that describes the dynamics of ventilation in a breathing space. It asks designers to incorporate cross ventilation such that lower air levels are systematically exchanged at the prescribed rate. This prevents vent gases or other pollutants from settling down and accumulating in sleeping areas. The method of cross ventilation that incorporates a low level air entry opening with an upper level exhaust or discharge opening of equal area is the optimum design, as it promotes thermal differences and relative ambient winds to power air exchange within the space. The designer should use, as a rule of thumb, about 1 sq. in. per 1000 BTU/h of burner capacity. The definition of a confined space is considered to be 50 cu. ft. for each 1000 BTU/h of input burner rating. No single vent opening dimension should be less than 3 in. This ventilation flow rate will translate to an ACH in the tent computation to be: ACH = 15 cu. ft./min*60 min/h/235 cu. ft. = 3.83. We may compare this value with the calculated ventilation needed to maintain the minimum oxygen level for combustion in the above example of 2.95 ACH. Clearly, a ventilation rate to avoid CO buildup was about 6.0 ACH as shown in Reference 3. This resulted in less than 100 ppm CO.
3.6 OXYGEN DEPLETION SENSOR APPLICATIONS TO SMALL BURNERS An ODS system is simply a pilot burner whose flame impinges on a thermocouple that in turn powers a gas safety valve electromagnet. What is unique about an ODS is the tripping of the gas safety valve at a specified level of oxygen depletion. The tent enclosure computation above specified the oxygen safety valve trip level was 18.5%, as compared to a normal ambient oxygen concentration of 20.9%. Codes and
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 48 — #6
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
49
standards recognize that it is not healthy or safe for humans to function in oxygen reduced atmospheres (<18%) for more than 8 h. The theory of ODS operation is based on flame geometry changing during a reduction in ambient oxygen (Figure 3.1). Change in position of the pilot flame with respect to the thermocouple allows the thermocouple tip to cool to a point that will cause the electromagnet to trip the safety valve, shutting off the heater’s burner. Safety shutdown is typically designed to occur at 18.5% ambient oxygen. This oxygen level is above the threshold that will cause excessive CO to be produced within the burner. Typical ODS flame geometry changes are shown in Figure 3.1. The ODS was developed and used extensively in Europe for 30 years prior to it being adopted in the United States in 1980. It was first mandated here on ventless,
Pilot burner Thermo couple
Ignition plug
Gas
Pilot burner Thermo couple
Ignition plug
Pilot burner Thermo couple
Ignition plug
Gas
FIGURE 3.1 Operation of an oxygen depletion sensor. Upper panel: Normal operation— 20.9% oxygen. Pilot flame touches tip of thermocouple, generating the thermoelectricity needed to hold the safety valve open. Middle panel: Oxygen level dropping—19% oxygen. The flame begins to lift off the precision pilot burner. The thermocouple begins to cool. Lower panel: Safety shutdown—18% oxygen. The unstable pilot flame moves away from the thermocouple to stop generating the electricity needed to hold the spring-loaded safety valve open. The heater shuts down. (Source: Adapted from a sales brochure, no copyright, ca. 1996.)
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 49 — #7
50
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
gas space heaters. In the late 1990s, this safety device was beginning to be applied to gas heaters used by the hunters, campers, and the recreational industry generally for satisfying the demand for safe, small, infrared, and catalytic heaters. Many infrared camp heater designs use LP gas to fuel the main burner at relatively high vapor pressures, that is, typically 7–15 psig. Pressure at the burner orifice or gas tip is controlled by a gas regulator on the heater control panel, that is, the heat setting control knob. This knob usually adjusts the regulator to about 7 psig in the low heat range and to about 15 psig in the heater’s high heat range. These regulator pressures are problematic for the ODS pilot burner, because it usually operates at about 3–5 inches water column (in. w.c.), or approximately 0.11–0.18 psig. One solution for this problem is to add a second stage regulator that reduces the high pressure going to the main burner regulator to a lower pressure. Normally, some pilot flame shielding is required to deflect radiated heat from the main burner and also to shield the small ODS flame from wind and drafts, thus stabilizing the ODS flame’s play on the thermocouple. The approximate heat output of a typical ODS flame at 3.5 in. w.c. pressure, using a 0.00665 in. diameter, 60◦ orifice angle, will be 175 BTU/h. This is the maximum amount of gas that may pass through the pilot burner without having a code required safety valve to shut off the pilot gas flow when flame outage occurs. It may be desirable to relax this orifice diameter in order to fit a commercially available drill bit size, for example, 0.006 in. Using this bit and the 175 BTU/h code limitation, we can use a 5.3 in. w.c. orifice pressure. This will produce a desired maximum gas flow and satisfy the safety code. The burner system designer may now determine the most economical arrangement of gas safety shutdown piping and equipment for his product. Also, the heater designer has the choice of commercially available vertical, angled, and horizontally mounted ODS designs in order to best accommodate his design preferences. Some other ODS variants have been used by Copreci, an Italian manufacturer.
3.7 COMBUSTION EQUATIONS FOR GAS BURNERS The reader is advised to refer to Reference 4 for a complete summary of formulae to determine the products of combustion for gaseous fuels such as propane and butane that are typically used to fuel space and construction heaters for small volume enclosures. This reference also details the combustion analysis that relates the amount of combustion air needed for the stoichiometric combustion of various gaseous fuels. Such an equation for the stoichiometric or theoretical oxidation of propane will be Balanced equation: C3 H8 + 5O2 = 3CO2 + 4H2 O Molecular weights: 44.094 + 5∗ 32 = 3∗ 44.01 + 4∗ 18.016 Relative combining weights: 1 lb + 3.629 lb = 2.995 lb + 1.634 lb Combustion data for typical hydrocarbon fuels are given in Table 3.1.2 Additional combustion data and LP-gas properties are found in reference 4. It should be remembered that commercial propane (i.e., LP-gas) contains a number of other hydrocarbons that are limited by the HD5 or HD-5, P grade specification. That is,
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 50 — #8
CH4 C2 H4 C2 H3 C4 H10 C5 H12 C2 H4 C3 H6 C4 H8 9.55 16.70 23.86 31.02 38.19 14.32 21.48 28.58
Air 2.0 3.5 5.0 6.5 8.0 3.0 4.5 6.0
Oxygen 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 2.0 3.0 4.0
Carbon Dioxide 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 2.0 3.0 4.0
Water Vapor 7.55 13.20 18.86 24.52 30.19 11.31 16.98 22.58
Nitrogen
Products of Combustion ln Cu. FL. formed by Burning 1 cu. ft.
17.24 16.13 15.71 15.49 15.35 14.80 14.80 14.80
Air 3.98 3.73 3.63 3.58 3.54 3.42 3.42 3.42
Oxygen
Pounds Required for Combustion 1 lb. of Gas or Vapor
Source: Handbook Propane–Butane Gases, 4th ed., Chilton Company, Los Angeles, CA, PP. 22,23 1962.
Methane Ethane Propane Butane Pentane Ethylene Propylene Butylene
Chemical Formula
Cubic Feel Required per Cu. Ft. of Gas or Vapor for Combustion
TABLE 3.1 Combustion Data for Hydrocarbons
2.74 2.92 2.99 3.03 3.05 3.13 3.13 3.13
Carbon Dioxide
2.24 1.79 1.63 1.55 1.50 1.28 1.28 1.28
Water Vapor
13.26 12.40 12.08 11.91 11.80 11.38 11.38 11.38
Nitrogen
Products of Combustion in Pounds from Burning One Pound Gas or Vapor
11.7 13.1 13.7 14.0 14.2 15.0 15.0 15.0
Ultimate Carbon Dioxide ln Flue Products Percent
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 51 — #9
51
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
52
TABLE 3.2 Physical and Chemical Properties of LP-Gasa Propane Formula Boiling point (◦ F) Specific gravity of gas (air = 1.00) Specific gravity of liquid (water = 1.00) lb per gallon of liquid at 60◦ F BTU per gallon of gas at 60◦ F BTU per lb. of gas BTU per cu. ft. of gas at 60◦ F cu. ft. of vapor (at 60◦ F) gallon cu. ft. of vapor (at 60◦ F) lb Latent heat of vaporization at boiling point BTU per gallon Combustion data cu. ft. air required to burn 1 cu. ft. gas Flash point (◦ F) Ignition temperature in air (◦ F) Maximum flame temperature in air (◦ F) Limits of flammability percentage of gas in air mixture At lower limit (%) At upper limit (%) Octane number (ISO-Octane = 100)
Butane
C3 H8 −44 1.50 0.504 4.20 91,502 21,548 2488 36.38 8.66 773
C4 H10 15 2.01 0.582 4.81 102,032 21,221 3280 31.26 6.51 808
23.86 −156 920–1120
31.02 N.A. 900–1000
3,595
3,615
2.15 9.6
1.55 8.6
Over 100
92
a Commercial quality. Figures shown in this chart represent average values.
Source: LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual Engineered Controls International, Inc. (Reg O), Elon College, NC, pp. 2,3, 1962, Revised March, 2000.
propane must constitute a minimum of 90.0% of the gas, propylene can be at most 5.0%, and the butanes and heavier aliphatics must not exceed 2.5%. For a summary of the properties of commercial propane and butane, the reader is referred to Table 3.2.5 The LP-gas is to have a vapor pressure at 100◦ F of greater than 175, but not exceeding 208 psig (Table 3.3). Other reference sources are 4 and 6. It is sometimes necessary to compute CO in combustion products in a specific manner to comply with industry standards as defined on an free-air basis. Instruments can determine the amount of CO on an air-free basis by first measuring the amount of oxygen and CO present in the sample, then using the following equation to calculate CO on a free-air basis: CO air-free = 20.9∗ CO/(20.9 − O2 %)
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 52 — #10
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
53
TABLE 3.3 Vapor Pressures of LP-Gasesa Temperature (◦ F) (◦ C) −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110
−40 −34 −29 −23 −18 −12 −7 −1 4 10 16 21 27 32 38 43
Approximate Pressure (PSIG) Propane Butane 3.6 8 13.5 23.3 28 37 47 58 72 86 102 127 140 165 196 220
3.0 6.9 12 17 23 29 36 45
a Conversion formula: Degrees C = (◦ F − 32) × 5/9
Degrees F = (9/5 ×◦ C) + 32 Source: LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual, Engineered Controls International, Inc. (Reg O), Elon College, NC, pp. 2,3, 1962, Revised March, 2000.
This computation compensates for the amount of excess air provided by the burner. Excess air from a burner dilutes the products of combustion and causes a test for CO to be understated. A CO air-free measurement eliminates the excess air dilution.
3.8 CARBON MONOXIDE ACCUMULATION DUE TO SMALL ENGINE EXHAUST GASES Some serious injuries and deaths have occurred because the general public is not fully aware of the latent danger in operating internal combustion engines in confined breathing spaces or in poorly ventilated structures. An analysis of the combustion products or exhaust gases from engines fueled by hydrocarbons shows they generally produce CO in great abundance as compared to burners in various heaters and lighting appliances. As a comparison, a gas burning appliance will be “red tagged” in many municipalities if its flue products contain an excess of 400 ppm of CO. Some states have limited the legal level of CO in the automobile engine exhaust at 1.2%. Precatalytic CO production in typical gasoline engines is 12,000 ppm CO or more. A poorly tuned gasoline engine may produce 30 times the CO that a misadjusted gas
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 53 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
54
burning appliance will typically generate. In most cases where gasoline engines are operated, engine exhaust is vented directly into the habitable space as opposed to an exhaust stack as with gas burning appliances. Use of a breathing space shared by a running gasoline engine subjects the people to lethal concentrations of CO very quickly and unexpectedly. The consequences of operating a small gasoline engine in a closed space are seen in Reference 7. For example, a 5 hp, four-cycle, gasoline-fueled engine will generate CO at a rate of 1.72 cfm. A simple calculation reveals that for most small structures, a significantly elevated CO concentration will exist there after just a few moments of engine operation. Thus, gasoline-powered engine operation in small rooms becomes hazardous to the occupants very quickly and requires excessive ventilation, that is, many ACH. In fact, the number of ACH necessary to limit CO buildup in such a space may be in excess of 20 just to limit the CO concentration to 400 ppm. The rule of thumb is that small gasoline-fueled engines should NEVER be operated in closed breathing spaces.
3.9 OSHA AND INDUSTRY STANDARDS FOR CO EXPOSURE In times past, a 100 ppm CO exposure level was acceptable for humans over extended periods of time, that is, the 8-h workday. The history of acceptable CO standards for human exposure has been one of a gradual decline in that number over the past 100 years. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and OSHA now use a level of 35 ppm, time-weighted-average (TWA), over 8 h. The concern has been to keep blood carboxyhemoglobin saturation to less than 5% for both chronic exposure in the workplace and for workers with cardiovascular or pulmonary disease. Other approval and standards organizations such as ASHRAE defer in their Standard 62-89 to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standard for outdoor air quality. EPA sets the ambient limit at 9 ppm, averaged over 8 h. EPA also allows exposure to 35 ppm CO or lower, averaged over 1 h. Finally, the ANSI guide number Z21.1, allows the ambient atmosphere surrounding an unvented space heater to achieve a maximum of 200 ppm CO when measured on an air-free basis. On the same basis, a maximum flue gas concentration of 400 ppm is allowed and an unvented gas oven may produce a maximum of 800 ppm. See Section 3.7 for the equation used to calculate CO on a free-air basis. Many state statutes limit flue gas products of combustion for a heating appliance to no more than 400 ppm at anytime in the equipment setup or operating range. Many state and municipal inspectors will “red tag” any fuel burning appliance that is found to exceed that CO limit.
3.10 CONCLUSION The aspects of CO accumulation in small structures introduced by using consumer products such as LP-gas heaters, lanterns, and small gasoline engines motivates a special series of cautions, warnings, designs, and code compliance considerations.
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 54 — #12
Carbon Monoxide Build-Up in Houses and Small Volume Enclosures
55
These concerns must be addressed by the consumers, designers, and certainly by the engineers creating products and structures for the stream of commerce. The number of mishaps and associated litigation speaks for the issue of properly operating fuelburning products in small structures such as tents, fishing shanties, campers, garages, and so forth to name just a few. The first aspect of operating these appliances in small breathing spaces must be that of safety for the consumer, that is, public. The chemical and physiological effects of CO have made it a serious design factor for engineers, manufacturers, and consumers alike.
References 1. Berglund, L.G. ASHRAE Handbook-Fundamentals, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air Conditioning Engineers, Inc., Atlanta, GA, pp. 8.6, 8.7, Chapter 8, 2001. 2. Denny, L.C., Luxon L.L. and Hall, B.E. Handbook Propane–Butane Gases, 4th ed., Chilton Company, Los Angeles, CA, pp. 22, 23, 1962. 3. Tucholski, D.R. Technical Feasibility of a CO Shutdown System for Tank-Top Heaters, U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC), Washington, D.C., p. 53, 2005. 4. Reed, R.J. North American Combustion Handbook, 3rd ed., Vol. 1, North American Manufacturing Company, Cleveland, OH, p. 49, 1986. 5. LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual, Engineered Controls International, Inc. (RegO), Elon College, NC, 1962, Revised March, 2000. 6. Segeler, C.G. Editor-in-Chief; Ringler, M.D., Assistant Editor; Kafka, E.M., Technical Assistant, Gas Engineers Handbook, The Industrial Press, New York, NY, pp. 6–33, 1966. 7. Earnest, G.S., Mickelsen, R.L., McCammon, J.B. and O’Brien, D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning from small, gasoline-powered, internal combustion engines: just what is a well-ventilated area? Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 58, 787–791, 1997.
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 55 — #13
8417: “8417_c003” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 56 — #14
4
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide into Mobile Homes, Recreational Vehicles, and Other Enclosures Robert E. Schreter
CONTENTS 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4
4.5
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Accident Statistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Codes and Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Potential Sources of Carbon Monoxide within Motor Homes and Other Enclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1 Internal Combustion Engines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1.1 Large Vehicle Propulsion Engines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1.2 Auxiliary Power Generators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2 Interior Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.1 Ranges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.2 Ovens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.3 Gas Refrigerators (LP Gas) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.4 Domestic Water Heaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.5 Gas or Oil-Fired Space Heaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.6 Clothes Dryers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.7 Fireplaces (LP Gas) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2.8 Other Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Primer on the Mechanism of Formation of Carbon Monoxide from Fuel-Fired Appliances found in Mobile Homes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.1 The Physical and Chemical Properties of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . 4.5.2 The Combustion Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58 59 59 60 61 62 62 64 64 64 65 65 65 65 66 66 67 67 68
57
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 57 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
58
4.5.2.1
Basic Requirements to Initiate and Perpetuate the Combustion Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.3 Thermochemical Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.4 Excess Air Combustion. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5.5 Excess Fuel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 Application of Combustion Theory to Actual Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Situations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.1 Introduction to the Flow of Exhaust Gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.2 Total Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.3 Stagnation Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.4 Thermal Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.5 Air Flow Around and Through Enclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.6 Wind Rose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.7 Scoops, Deflectors, and Openings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.8 Resonance, Cyclical Flow into and out of an Enclosure. . . . . . . . . . 4.6.9 Flow into and out of Living Quarters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.10 Flue and Chimney Dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.11 Back-drafting of Flue Gases into the Enclosure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.12 Dynamics of Generator Tailpipe Exhaust . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6.13 Exhaust Flow Through Bent or Displaced Exhaust Pipes . . . . . . . . 4.6.14 Missing Exhaust Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7 Accumulation of Carbon Monoxide within an Enclosure. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7.1 Rate of Dissipation of Carbon Monoxide from an Enclosure . . . . 4.8 Test Methods for Determining the Location of Leakage into an Enclosure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.1 Smoke Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.2 Basic Considerations during Smoke Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.3 Positive Pressure Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.4 Negative Pressure Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8.5 Typical Smoke Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.9 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
68 69 71 72 72 72 73 75 76 77 78 78 81 82 82 83 83 85 86 87 89 90 91 91 92 92 93 96 96
4.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter deals with nonfire related carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning accidents that occur in mobile homes, live-in trailers, portable offices and other mobile living or work enclosures containing devices that can produce CO or other toxic gases. The flow mechanisms and equations presented apply equally to all stationary buildings subject to wind and thermal activity. I will briefly discuss American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) codes that apply to recreational vehicles, motor homes and the like and stress the code requirements involved in sealing the living compartment against toxic gases and vapors produced externally. This chapter addresses the individual sources that generate CO within the living compartment and sources that are part of the mobile home but external to the living compartment, as well as those produced in the vicinity. It discusses each
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 58 — #2
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
59
of the appliances, the mechanisms by which they produce CO and the expected concentration of CO associated with them. It compares the probability of their entering into life threatening asphyxiations. It also discusses other sources of CO emanating from other vehicles or generators in the vicinity. I will discuss the physical properties and behavior of CO and the mechanism of its formation in various types of appliances and internal combustion engines. It discusses the combustion process, thermochemical equations, and how excess air, excess fuel, mixing of air and fuel and available time for the completion of combustion affect its production. I will introduce the concept of total pressure, including wind and thermal pressure and how these pressures are the driving forces that result in CO penetrating leaks into the living compartment. The chapter covers the application of combustion theory and aerodynamics and how they apply to CO accidents. It discusses how wind and the aerodynamic shapes and openings encountered in mobile homes and other enclosures affect air and gas flow movement into, through, and out of enclosures. There is a general discussion of exhaust systems for internal combustion engines and how they play a role in life threatening CO asphyxiations. It discusses how missing or damaged engine generator tailpipes are major contributors to fatal accidents. This chapter presents methods used to evaluate the rate of accumulation of CO within enclosures. Computational methods used to determine CO concentration at any point in time during the inflow are presented. It also presents computational methods to determine the dissipation of CO during periods where the generating source is shut down or its flow rate curtailed. The methods presented predict the partial pressure within an enclosure and how it may be used in conjunction with the Coburn–Forster– Kane equation to predict carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) in a victim’s blood (see other books in this series). Finally, the chapter discusses methods that may be used to determine the locations of leaks into the living compartment and the magnitude of inflow into the enclosure.
4.2 ACCIDENT STATISTICS Between 1995 and 1999, an estimated 10,200 people reported to hospital emergency rooms each year for nonfire-related CO poisoning injuries associated with consumer products.1 There were more than 500 unintentional nonfire related deaths and injuries resulting from CO-poisoning accidents associated with the use of consumer products. An average of 22 deaths per year was associated with engine-driven generators and engine-driven products, which includes deaths associated with mobile homes. Between 1993 and 1997 deaths from motor vehicle exhausts, averaged 534 annually. Many CO accidents are not recognized, and because of data collection problems, many cases go unreported. Nonfatal injuries mostly go unreported, therefore, there are few accurate statistics.
4.3 CODES AND STANDARDS TheANSI 119.2,2 and NFPA501c3 have written and promulgated standards applicable to CO in mobile homes and recreational vehicles. The standards cover fire and life
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 59 — #3
60
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
safety criteria for recreational vehicles to provide reasonable protection from loss of life from fire and explosion. In particular, the standard sets down requirements for fuel burning devices used in connection with recreational vehicles. They pay special attention to the location of internal combustion engines and their exhaust ports relative to leakage into the living compartment of the vehicle. In essence, the codes state that exhaust gases shall be directed away from the vehicle and that the exhaust system shall be installed in a manner by which the exhaust pipes are not unduly subject to road damage. They also state that all fuel-burning devices, except ranges and ovens, shall be designed and installed to provide for the complete separation of the combustion system from the interior atmosphere of the recreational vehicle. Throughout this chapter, the interior of the recreational vehicle would be referred to interchangeably as the living compartment or living enclosure. Essentially, this means that the combustion air intake, the burner, the combustion chamber, heat transfer elements, and exhaust piping shall be outside the living compartment. It further states that exhaust or flue outlets shall not terminate under the recreational vehicle. The codes further state that internal combustion engines (motor generators), engine driven pumps or the like shall be mounted in compartments that are vapor tight to the interior of the vehicle (living compartment). The wording is somewhat confusing in that of necessity the engine compartment cannot be sealed because the engine requires combustion and cooling air, therefore, cannot be sealed. However, the meaning of the code is quite clear that the living compartment must be sealed to prevent exhaust gas penetrating the enclosure. In addition, the code states that all penetrations into the living compartment shall be sealed. Furthermore, fuel lines and exhaust systems shall not penetrate the living compartment. All recreational vehicles that are equipped with or are equipped to accommodate a future installation of an internal combustion engine shall be equipped with a listed CO detector or alarm. Readers interested in detail information regarding codes or standards are referred to ANSI 119.2 and NFPA 501 c.2,3
4.4 POTENTIAL SOURCES OF CARBON MONOXIDE WITHIN MOTOR HOMES AND OTHER ENCLOSURES Motor homes contain a variety of appliances utilizing combustion that can generate CO as well as other toxic gases. The probability of creating serious injury or death is a function of the amount of CO produced by the appliance and the concentration ultimately trapped in the enclosure. The likely devices and appliances fall into one of two classes depending on level of CO that can be expected 1. Internal combustion engines produce levels of CO ranging from 10,000 to 70,000 ppm or more; CO concentration drops by 95% or more when the
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 60 — #4
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
61
exhaust system is equipped with a catalytic converter. Without a catalytic converter, the probability of life threatening accidents occurring is very high if exhaust gases leak into occupied enclosures. 2. Ranges, stoves, ovens, water heaters, and so forth produce much lower levels of CO, generally in the range of a few ppm up to a few hundred ppm. The probability of these devices causing life-threatening accidents is considerably lower than with internal combustion engines. However, these concentrations are capable of causing brain damage and other healthrelated injuries and cannot be dismissed out of hand. In any CO asphyxiation incident, regardless of the CO level, it is a good practice to inspect all devices that could potentially generate CO. Measure their output, and catalog emissions even though they may appear to be unrelated to the accident and the environment in which the accident occurred.
4.4.1 INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES Internal Combustion Engines present the greatest hazard from the standpoint of CO poisonings. As stated above, CO concentrations of 10,000–70,000 ppm are not uncommon. CO at these magnitudes, even when diluted 30 or 40 to 1 can be lethal, can quickly result in death. Internal combustion engines produce high levels of CO because of the brief period available to complete combustion. As an example, a single cylinder engine running at 2400 rpm must fire 20 times per second. It must draw in a charge of air, meter and inject an appropriate quantity of fuel through a crude carburetor, and mix the air and fuel in 0.0236 s. The mixture must then be ignited, the flame propagate throughout the cylinder, and finally complete the power stroke in 0.014 s. In this brief period of time, it is virtually impossible to perfectly mix each fuel molecule with the appropriate amount of air and burn it to completion in about 0.04 s. Consequently, incomplete combustion is the inevitable result. In addition, the boundary of the metal cylinder, the cylinder head, and piston are all relatively cold surfaces, therefore cause quenching and additional incomplete products of combustion. As a result, the small internal combustion engine is naturally inefficient and produces high levels of CO and other products of incomplete combustion. Modern automobile and truck engines, although greatly improved, still produce high levels of CO, but because of catalytic exhaust systems now deliver much lower levels of CO to the atmosphere. Of the fatal CO motor home accidents that I have investigated, the majority can be traced to the motor generator and its exhaust system. The majority occurred after the exhaust system was damaged, displaced, or missing. The damage to or the absence of the tailpipe allowed high levels of CO and other toxic exhaust gases to be directed under the motor home where they accumulated and found their way into the living compartment. It should be noted that despite numerous accidents many generator exhaust systems are still located in unprotected areas where they are subject to damage from direct impact from road hazards.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 61 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
62
H
E F
B
G
D I A
J
K
C
FIGURE 4.1 Air flow over and through an enclosure.
4.4.1.1 Large Vehicle Propulsion Engines Older motor home engines, built before mandated emission standards, commonly produced in excess of 4% (40,000 ppm) CO. Modern engines still produce high levels of CO; however, modern catalytic exhaust systems have reduced CO discharge drastically in order to meet the current CO emission standard. Other than intentional suicide, and operating the motor home engine for heating purposes in quiescent zones, the main propulsion engine is rarely the cause of fatal asphyxiations. The propulsion engine is rarely running long enough, when the vehicle is not in motion, to accumulate a high enough concentration of CO. When in motion, the position of the exhaust pipe encourages rapid dilution and dissipation of CO, discharging it away from the vehicle. There is one exception, and that is in the area directly behind the vehicle. Large moving objects create a suction wake directly behind the vehicle, which encourages exhaust gases to accumulate, much like the vortex G, shown in Figure 4.1. Codes recognize this problem and require special sealing to avoid leaks into the living compartment in those areas. In addition, codes require that openings like windows must be permanently sealed to avoid opening. Main propulsion engine exhaust pipes are generally large and structurally strong, with substantial means of attachment to the vehicle. Although they are frequently in unprotected areas, the pipes and supports are strong and can sustain impacts that would damage smaller lighter generator exhaust pipes. Although this does not preclude an accident, it greatly reduces the probability. A motor home if left with the engine idling, for a prolonged period of time, especially, if parked in a protected zone or in a depression, may permit exhaust gases to accumulate underneath. The accumulation of exhaust gases in the vicinity of the discharge end of the tailpipe thwarts the natural dilution of exhaust gases, thereby exposing leakage areas to highly concentrated exhaust gases. The temperature of undiluted exhaust gas is high thereby creating a thermal head that facilitates infiltration into the living compartment through breaches in the vehicle floor. 4.4.1.2 Auxiliary Power Generators The majority of standby power generators, used in motor homes, are driven by single cylinder, four-stroke engines. Some of the larger generators use larger two-cylinder,
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 62 — #6
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
63
four-stroke cycle engines. The range of sizes run from 2.5 kW (7 bhp) to 7 kW (14 bhp). They are available for gasoline, liquefied petroleum (LP), liquid or vapor state fuels, and occasionally diesel fuel. Codes require that all motor-driven generators be mounted in compartments that are outside of the living compartment. The generators are generally located in a ventilated compartment along the periphery of the motorhome. The generator compartment cannot be sealed and must be open to the outside air to maintain a constant flow of cooling and combustion air to the engine. The code requires that all generators be mounted in compartments that must be outside of the living enclosure. Typically, the generators are equipped with exhaust systems that consist of a muffler, tailpipe, and tailpipe support brackets. The exhaust pipe, approximately 1 in. in diameter, usually made of 16 gauge stainless steel, is routed under the motorhome and generally protrudes out the side or back of, and beneath the lower skirt of the motorhome. Engines are provided with mufflers to reduce exhaust noise levels, which are typically 67–70 dBA (sound pressure level at 10 ft.). On some “Quiet” models sound levels as low as 60 dBA are available. It should be noted that even at 60 dBA the noise signature is loud enough that a defect in the exhaust system can readily be detected by a person, used to the sound, standing in the vicinity of the generator. This provides a safety feature to persons that check the generator in use. In general, low horsepower engines are inefficient and produce very high levels of CO. Exhaust gas composition may range from 4.0% to 7.0%, (40,000–70,000 ppm) of CO with associated carbon dioxide levels ranging from 6% to 10% (60,000–100,000 ppm). Exhaust gases are discharged at a temperature of 400–800◦ F depending on the generator load. Of all appliances, motor generators present the greatest danger to human life and health. The high CO concentration (40,000–70,000 ppm) in the exhaust gas, even when the engine is in good working order, creates a serious poisoning hazard. By comparison, with a few exceptions, other CO-producing devices commonly found in motor homes, produce CO levels up to 400–500 ppm and only then when they are not working properly. These lower CO levels may still present a health hazard, but of a far lower magnitude than a generator. Because generators present such a high exhaust gas hazard, it is required that a special standard of care be exercised to ensure that the generator engine and all its associated components be maintained in first class condition, and be protected against accidental damage. Generator engines are quite reliable when properly maintained. However, the exhaust gas is highly toxic regardless of the operating condition of the engine. Essentially, nothing can be done to relieve the fundamental CO hazard. With regard to life safety, the exhaust system is the most critical component of the motor generator and should be protected at all cost. In general, the exhaust pipe and muffler are located under the engine with the tailpipe projecting below the skirt of the motor home. In the majority of cases, the discharge of the tailpipe is located perpendicular to the side of the motor home and projects out a minimum distance of 1 in. beyond the side of the motor home. For additional protection, codes require that the exhaust pipe may not be located closer
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 63 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
64
than 6 in. from any air intake. This assumes that the pipe discharges into clean air to dilute the exhaust products. The tailpipe, by virtue of its location below the vehicle, is in an unprotected position and is subject to impact from curbs, road hazards, uneven terrain, and flying debris. Most frequently, tailpipe support brackets are weak and will not withstand substantial impact. The pipe is normally a thin wall stainless steel tube that is readily subject to impact damage. My experience shows that the majority of fatal accidents are caused by damaged, out of position, or missing tailpipes.
4.4.2 INTERIOR DEVICES 4.4.2.1 Ranges The majority of cooking stoves used in motor homes or trailers burn LP as a fuel. Propane, butane, or a combination thereof are commonplace. Exhaust gases from the burners are vented directly into the living compartment of the motor home. Gravity vents may be provided or a fume hood may be located above the range. A fume hood collects range exhaust products of combustion along with cooking vapors and discharges the gases through a register located on the outside wall or roof of the motor home. The registers are normally equipped with flap type check valves to prevent back flow into the motor home from wind movement. Some fume hoods used over stoves filter out grease and smoke, but return combustion products to the living compartment. These systems do not remove CO, carbon dioxide, or other toxic gases, but simply circulate them within the enclosure. Exhaust fan capacities are typically in the range of 50–125 acfm. All exhaust systems require similar quantities of make-up air to prevent back drafting. Tests conducted by the author show that CO levels, taken just above the visible flame, range from 15 to 70 ppm; properly adjusted burners have blue flames. Badly adjusted or damaged burners, frequently typified by yellow tipped flames, have CO levels of 100–770 ppm (this figure may vary by location). Burner pilot lights can contribute an additional 28–56 ppm. Ranges used for cooking rarely are hazardous because they are used for a limited time. When used for prolonged cooking they are generally used in conjunction with an exhaust hood. Ranges can pose a hazard if used in a small, tight compartment without sufficient air infiltration or when operated for prolonged periods of time. Ranges should never be used for space heating. 4.4.2.2 Ovens Ovens also discharge products of combustion and cooking vapors directly into the living compartment. Ovens having blue flames can produce 35–768 ppm of CO and their pilots can add up to an additional 960 ppm.4 Some ovens use a gravity flue to discharge oven gases outside the living compartment. When used they should be equipped with backflow protection. Because of the relatively low temperature of exhaust gases and the short stack length, the flue draft developed is limited. Back drafting may present a problem when dryers or
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 64 — #8
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
65
exhaust fans are used simultaneously within the same enclosure. Under back-drafting conditions, CO can increase to dangerous levels. During back drafting, CO levels far exceed the norm expected of the appliance. Like cooking ranges, ovens are used for relatively short periods of time and are generally vented. However, when used in tightly sealed enclosures without sufficient infiltration air, they can present a hazard. Ovens should never be used for space or supplemental heating. 4.4.2.3 Gas Refrigerators (LP Gas) The majority of motor homes and trailers use gas or combination gas-electric refrigerators. The combustion unit for a gas refrigerator is contained in a separate metal enclosure that is located outside the living quarters. Combustion air is drawn into the combustion tube, mixed with vaporized propane, ignited and burned and flue products passed through a heat exchanger and discharged to the outside atmosphere. Thus, combustion gases are isolated from the living compartment. Of all appliances, gas refrigerators show a low frequency of CO poisonings. Negative living compartment pressure does not pose a problem. 4.4.2.4 Domestic Water Heaters The combustion unit for a gas fired water heater is contained in a separate metal enclosure that is located outside the living quarters. Combustion air is drawn into the combustion tube, mixed with vaporized propane, ignited, burned, and flue products passed through a heat exchanger. They are discharged to atmosphere outside the living compartment. Make-up and hot water connections that penetrate the living compartment must be sealed to prevent external gases from penetrating the living compartment. Negative living compartment pressure does not pose a problem except through leaking seals around pipes or electrical connections entering/leaving the living compartment. The risk of dangerous amounts of CO entering the living compartment, except at seals, is small. 4.4.2.5 Gas or Oil-Fired Space Heaters The combustion unit of the space heater must have an air intake and discharge that are external to the living compartment. Hot combustion gases are contained inside a stainless steel heat exchanger that separates them from the living compartment. Pressurized air flow across the outside of the heat exchanger picks up and carries hot air into the living compartment. The risk of dangerous levels of CO penetrating the living compartment is small. 4.4.2.6 Clothes Dryers Clothes dryers when fuel-fired have the combustion unit outside the living compartment. The combustion unit is much like those used in approved space heaters,
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 65 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
66
water heaters, and refrigerators. Clothes dryers present an additional but indirect hazard, because the dryer exhaust can lower living compartment pressure to the point where back drafting by other appliances occurs. Lower living compartment pressure also increases the probability of drawing external exhaust gases into the living compartment. If a clothes dryer is used it is imperative that a sufficient make up air supply be provided to prevent back drafting into the living compartment.
4.4.2.7 Fireplaces (LP Gas) Fireplaces and even wood burning stoves have become available for use in mobile homes. Because their flames are exposed inside the living compartment, anything that could result in back drafting will cause exhaust gases to be discharged directly into the living compartment. Gas fireplaces, even in conventional homes, are notorious for discharging CO into living areas. Fireplaces are subject to back drafting any time that living compartment pressure is reduced below atmospheric pressure (see Figure 4.2).
4.4.2.8 Other Sources The use of portable kerosene, gasoline, and propane or natural gas heaters is not recommended. Regardless of the type, they discharge their products of combustion into the living compartment. Even when operating properly they require an adequate supply of combustion air, which may not be present in a tight enclosure. Heaters of this type are portable and can be easily upset, presenting an additional fire and toxic gas hazard. Many of these devices are position sensitive and cannot function in other than a vertical attitude. Their use is prohibited by ANSI 119.2 in that the products of combustion are discharged into the living compartment. There is a history of numerous asphyxiation accidents related to this type heater.
Fresh air
Leakage air Dryer exhaust Dryer exhaust
Exhaust gas back flow
Clothes dryer
FIGURE 4.2 Back-drafting in a fireplace flue.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 66 — #10
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
67
4.5 PRIMER ON THE MECHANISM OF FORMATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE FROM FUEL-FIRED APPLIANCES FOUND IN MOBILE HOMES 4.5.1 THE PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF CARBON MONOXIDE To understand how CO is generated and transported into a motor home, it is necessary to understand its physical properties, where and how it is formed, and how dangerous concentrations are transported into living compartments. CO is a clear gas that is odorless, tasteless and has a density slightly less than air. It is generally a product of incomplete combustion of carbon or hydrocarbon fuels. Its physical properties are seen in Table 4.1.5 The common understanding is that CO is lighter than air, as it is in the pure state. At standard temperature and pressure, it has a density of 0.0779 lb/cu. ft.; air is 0.0807. The difference in density creates a natural buoyancy. However, under most circumstances where we find it, CO is a product of incomplete combustion. Therefore, it is not a pure gas, but contained in a mixture of exhaust gases containing nitrogen, carbon dioxide, and water vapor in proportions dictated by Equation 4.1. Because of the density of these gases, the combined mixture has an essentially neutral buoyancy. For illustrative purposes, assume that a motor generator is fueled by octane, C8 H18 . Its exhaust products are 6% CO and 8% CO2 . Under these conditions the exhaust gas density is 0.0805 lb/cu. ft. at STP (standard temperature and pressure 60◦ F and 29.92 mm Hg), which has essentially neutral buoyancy when compared to air
TABLE 4.1 Physical Constants for Carbon Monoxide∗ Name
Symbol
Chemical symbol Density, STP Molecular weight Specific gravity (air) Specific gas constant Specific heat p = c Specific heat v = c Specific heat ratio Specific volume Speed of sound Heat of combustion Heat of combustion Flammability in air lower Flammability in air upper Flame temperature in air Auto ignition temperature
CO rho MW SG R Cp Cv k nu C
LFL UFL
Value
Units
0.0779 28.011 0.967 55.19 0.248 0.177 1.4 13.557 1154.8 310 4340 12.5 74 3542 1228
lb/cu.ft.
ft. lbf /lbm R◦ Btu/lb◦ F Btu/lb◦ F — cu. ft./lb ft./s Btu/cu. ft. Btu/lb Vol% of total volume Vol% of total volume ◦F ◦F
∗Also see Chapter 35.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 67 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
68
0.0807,lb/cu. ft. at STP. Therefore, an exhaust gas mixture, with neutral temperature differential, will not have natural buoyancy at STP. Any buoyancy characteristics associated with combustion products will be due solely to a temperature differential between the exhaust gas stream and the surrounding air. For example, a hot jet stream of exhaust at 800◦ F in air will be buoyant and have a resultant direction and magnitude that will be the vector sum of the vertical thermal component and jet vector of the initial gas stream. Ahot gas stream jetted into ambient air naturally entrains large volumes of ambient air, thereby lowering its temperature, thus its buoyancy. As the stream gains volume it slows down. Any computations should take into account the momentum exchange, the increasing volume of the stream and diminishing temperature.
4.5.2 THE COMBUSTION PROCESS Under most circumstances, CO is an undesirable product of combustion. It is formed as a result of incomplete or inefficient burning of carbonaceous substances. By definition, combustion is the rapid oxidation of fuel accompanied by the liberation of heat and light. The combustion process, even in its simplest form, say burning methane in air, is not fully understood. Equation 4.2 shows a methane and excess air mixture burning to completion, forming products of combustion containing water, carbon dioxide, and excess air. Unlike the simplified end-points equation shown, there can be up to 31 intermediate steps in the oxidation of methane. If at any time during the combustion process the reaction is chilled or in any way interrupted, the intermediate reactions will freeze leaving one or more intermediate partial products of combustion. One of the more common partial products is CO. If temperatures remain high and oxygen is present some or all the intermediate products may be oxidized to completion. If the temperature drops below the critical reaction temperature or if oxygen is not present, the intermediate products will become stable and be represented in the exhaust gases. The most common causes for incomplete combustion are quenching, incorrect fuel air ratios and inadequate mixing resulting in stratification, and burning in the fuel rich or reducing fuel air region. The combustion process involves mixing of multiple gas products, mass transport, chemistry, and heat transfer. For the purpose of this discussion, many of the more complex processes will be simplified and we will deal, as much as possible, with the reactants and end products of combustion as defined by the thermo-chemical equations. It should be understood that the equations shown are representative of those containing intermediate reaction, but only at the beginning and the end. 4.5.2.1 Basic Requirements to Initiate and Perpetuate the Combustion Process Fuel must be present in a state that is burnable. Liquid and solid fuels will not burn. Fuel must be in a gaseous state for it to combine with oxygen and burn. Liquid fuels have to be atomized to small particles so that on exposure to high temperatures, the pilot flame, they quickly gasify so they can burn. Similarly, solid
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 68 — #12
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
69
fuels must be pulverized so that on exposure to high temperature, the pilot flame, they quickly gasify and burn. The fuel must also be present in sufficient quantity to be within the flammable limits (Table 4.1), and the initial flame size must exceed the minimum kernel diameter in order to propagate. An oxidizer, air or oxygen, must be present and intimately mixed with the fuel. The mixture must be within flammable limits, at least in a localized area, where ignition is to occur. There must be a source of ignition, of sufficient energy to raise the temperature of a critical mass of the fuel mixture above the ignition temperature to initiate the reaction. If the reaction is to perpetuate itself, the heat generated must be at least equal to the net heat loss from the flame and the heat required to heat the incoming mixture to ignition temperature. If the heat generated is equal to or greater than those requirements, the reaction will propagate.
4.5.3 THERMOCHEMICAL EQUATIONS Combustion like any other chemical reaction may be represented by thermochemical reaction equations. The equations show the fuel and air input and the products of combustion and heat liberated. The typical equation shows the initial ingredients and the final products of combustion, but does not show the intermediate reactions. For those interested in the detailed combustion process, see various sources.6–8 In general, this presentation will concern itself with the end-products of rich combustion, primarily CO and carbon dioxide. There are times when quenching, chilled flames, and blow off create intermediate toxic products of combustion. Essentially, we will concern ourselves with three thermochemical equations, Equation 4.1 for rich or excess fuel (i.e., deficiency of air), Equation 4.2 is for an excess of air, and Equation 4.3 is for secondary oxidation of CO formed in Equation 4.1. The term “E” represents the equivalence ratio or the ratio of actual to stoichiometric air. Stoichiometric air being that amount of oxygen required for perfect combustion. Thermochemical Equation for Methane Excess Fuel CH4 + 2 E O2 + 7.52 E N2 = (4 E − 3) CO2 + (4 − 4 E) CO + 2H2 O + 7.52 E N2 + Heat (1040 BTU/ft 3 )
(4.1)
Thermochemical Equation for Methane and Excess Air. CH4 + 2 E O2 + 7.52 E N2 = CO2 + 2H2 O + 2(E − 1)O2 + 7.52 E N2 + Heat (E∗ 1040 BTU/ft 3 )
(4.2)
Thermochemical Equation for Carbon Monoxide. CO + O = CO2 + Heat (323.5 BTU/ft 3 )
(4.3)
Equation 4.2 is presented in graphic form (see Figure 4.3). This chart gives a quick visualization of how combustion proceeds to either excess fuel or excess air. An equivalence ratio of 1, the abscissa, occurs at stoichiometric or perfect combustion.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 69 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
70
DEN*100 CO2 CO O2
Exhaust gas percent wet methane CH4
18 16
Percent (Wet)
14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
1
2
3 4 Equivalence ratio
5
6
FIGURE 4.3 Exhaust gases from the combustion of methane.
Some notable observations about Figure 4.3. 1. The CO2 curve peaks at an equivalence ratio of 1, and falls off on the reducing and oxidizing side of stoichiometric. 2. Maximum combustion efficiency is achieved when carbon dioxide is maximized. 3. Therefore, the CO2 curve is a good indicator of the quality of combustion. 4. Since CO2 is readily measured, it can be used, in conjunction with a determination of the presence of oxygen to assess the equivalence ratio. 5. Flame temperature also follows the CO2 curve (flame temperature actually peaks slightly on the reducing side of E = 1 but for general purposes the difference can be disregarded). 6. These observations are helpful in determining if a flame is reducing and generating CO. The chart shown is for methane. There are two charts for each fuel: (1) wet gas analysis, where the water of combustion remains in the exhaust gas, and (2) dry gas analysis, assuming that the water of combustion has condensed. Figure 4.3 represents a wet gas analysis. The use of wet gas analysis is appropriate for combustion systems where the exhaust gas temperature is above the dew point. The majority of charts found in the literature are set-up on a dry basis. This was done when the most common combustion analyzer was the Orsat. It being a wet absorption analyzer caused the gas temperature to drop below the dew point, removing all the water, and thereby yielding the products of combustion on a dry basis. Care must be taken when using a chart to determine if analysis is on a wet or dry basis. Section 4.10 shows a similar graph drawn on a dry basis. This approach may be more recognizable and is used more frequently by those involved in general combustion work.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 70 — #14
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
71
The maximum CO2 for each fuel will be different and may be calculated from Equation 4.1. Burners are normally adjusted for near peak CO2 on the slightly oxidizing side to insure complete combustion. The majority of good combustion equipment operates with an equivalence ratio in the range of 1.0–1.4. Electronic instruments can be calibrated to read either wet or dry percent. Therefore, it is important to know how the instrument is calibrated.
4.5.4 EXCESS AIR COMBUSTION Excess air combustion occurs at any time that the quantity of combustion air exceeds the stoichiometric requirements. This can occur on an overall basis, where fuel and air are uniformly mixed throughout the combustion chamber, or on a local basis within the combustion envelope, usually classified as stratified mixing. Stratified mixing can result in rich and lean zones occurring within the same flame envelope. One of the fundamental problems that occurs in most combustion systems is that it is difficult to mate every fuel molecule with the correct number of oxygen molecules. Failure to do so can result in rich excess fuel zones and lean excess air zones within the same combustion envelope. When there is too much air for a given amount of fuel, the flame temperature drops because of heating the additional excess air. If the quantity of excess air is sufficient then the flame temperature can drop below the critical reaction temperature and flameout can occur. However, prior to flameout, flame quenching starts and partial products of combustion such as CO and various aldehydes appear and become stable in the exhaust gases. If the quenching is local, and the partial products are subsequently reheated to a temperature in excess of the critical reaction temperature then the partial products may go to completion in the subsequent burn. Figure 4.4 shows a curve of flame temperature (◦ F) versus excess air (%). As excess air, increases flame Temperature versus excess air 4000 Temperature Temperature (F°)
3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Excess air (% )
FIGURE 4.4 Flame temperature versus excess air (%), natural gas. (R. Schreter and Associates, 1997).
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 71 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
72
temperature decreases. As the temperature approaches 1200◦ F, the critical reaction temperature, partial products of combustion and unburned fuel emerge. At very high levels of excess air, CO and formaldehyde can be generated.
4.5.5 EXCESS FUEL Excess fuel combustion occurs at any time that the quantity of fuel exceeds the stoichiometric requirements. As with excess air, this can occur on an overall basis or on a local basis within the combustion envelope. As depicted in Figure 4.3, CO appears at any value of E < 1. Small amounts of CO may occur even at E = 1.05, slightly excess air, because of difficulty mixing all the fuel with all the air. The rise of CO is very rapid on the excess fuel side as can be seen in Figure 4.3. Rich reactions contribute to the formation of CO in appliances when they are deficient in combustion air. The same type of reaction occurs when back drafting occurs. During back drafting, the reversal of flow upsets the mixing process and flame stability, resulting in rich combustion, blow off, quenching and formation of partial products of combustion.
4.6 APPLICATION OF COMBUSTION THEORY TO ACTUAL CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING SITUATIONS Aerodynamics and gas dynamics are the primary factors driving exhaust gas leakage into or out of the living compartment of a motor home, or for that matter any enclosure. The following theory is intended for use with motor homes; however, the same approach may be used in any low-pressure flow situation that might occur in a residential or commercial building.
4.6.1 INTRODUCTION TO THE FLOW OF EXHAUST GASES The flow rate of air, CO or a mixture of exhaust gases through leaks in the enclosure boundary is of critical importance to the concentration of toxic gases within the enclosure. The physical conditions governing low pressure gas flow usually encountered in motor homes greatly simplifies calculations, because the compressibility of the gases may be disregarded. The range of total pressure and differential pressure is low, further simplifying the flow equation. Flow is mainly through orifice type openings and friction can generally be disregarded. A discharge coefficient appropriate for the type of opening is required. Discharge coefficients may be found in most sources on fluid flow. Because differential pressures across orifices or leakage holes are low, a simplified velocity equation may be used as expressed in Equation 4.4. Gas Velocity at Low Pressures. U=
2∗gc ∗R∗
T0 ∗ (P0 − P1 ) P0
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 72 — #16
(4.4)
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
73
The continuity equation may then be used to determine the flow rate (Equation 4.5). Gas Flow Q = Cd∗A∗U
(4.5)
For very low pressures where (P0 − P1 /P1 ) ≤ 0.01, a much simplified flow equation may be used. Low Pressure Gas Flow. Q1−2 = 1658.5∗Cd∗a∗ (h0 − h1 ) ∗
δg δa
(4.6)
where a is area (sq. inches) A is area (sq. ft.) δa is density of air at STP δg is density of gas at flowing conditions F is frictional loss in units consistent with pressure gc is the constant 32.2 h0 is upstream pressure (inches of water) h1 is downstream pressure (inches of water) Cd is discharge coefficient P0 is upstream pressure (lb/sq. ft. abs) P1 is downstream pressure (lb/sq. ft. abs) Q1−2 is flow rate (cu. ft./h) R is universal gas constant (ft lb/lb R0 ) T0 is upstream absolute temperature (R0 ) U is velocity (ft./s)
4.6.2 TOTAL PRESSURE The pressures, ht and Pt , represent total pressures that are used in connection with moving air streams. Total pressure includes static pressure and a velocity component. Moving gas streams have both potential and kinetic energy components. In lowpressure gas flow, they are generally thought of as total, static, and velocity pressures (Equation 4.7). Total pressure is the sum of the static and velocity pressures and may be represented by any consistent set of units. Total Pressure. ht = hs + hv + f
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 73 — #17
(4.7)
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
74
where f is frictional loss [in. water column (w.c.)] hs is static pressure (in. w.c.) ht is total pressure (in. w.c.) hv is velocity pressure (in. w.c.) An example will be helpful to illustrate the concept of total pressure and the interchange of static and velocity pressures. Assume a large tank has been pressurized to a static pressure of hs . Because the tank is large and the outflow is small, there is negligible velocity within the tank. Therefore within the tank hv = 0. From Equation 4.7, ht = hs . As the fluid approaches and enters the pipe, it must accelerate and gain velocity. The static pressure diminishes and the velocity pressure increases (see plane a). Concurrently, because of turbulence there is a permanent frictional head loss that causes the total pressure, ht to decline slightly (see point e). In the straight section of pipe, plane (a to b), fluid reaches maximum velocity, requiring a corresponding loss in static pressure (see plane a). The fluid then enters a divergent nozzle (b to c), where the velocity diminishes, restoring static pressure. Throughout the pressure interchange (a to c), there is a gradual loss of total pressure due to friction and turbulence (e to f). As the fluid emerges from the nozzle, it continues to expand and then it impacts the wall. The remaining velocity is converted back into static pressure with an accompanying friction loss (f to g). The static pressure is now equal to the total pressure since velocity is now zero. The regaining of velocity pressure into static pressure, hs , is referred to as stagnation pressure (see Figure 4.5).
Wall h
Flow
Tank
g f
Total pressure
e
Friction Static pressure
Velocity pressure
D
a
b
c
d
FIGURE 4.5 Total velocity and static pressure versus position.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 74 — #18
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
75
After striking the wall at point h, the static pressure being higher than the ambient pressure causes the gas to accelerate in a direction perpendicular to the original jet, again causing another interchange between total, velocity, and static pressure. This concept is extremely important and will be used throughout discussions of moving gas streams.
4.6.3 STAGNATION PRESSURE When a moving gas stream impacts a stationary barrier or wall the stream velocity diminishes or approaches zero. The kinetic energy of the moving stream is transformed into potential energy in the form of pressure. The change into potential energy raises the local static pressure, which is termed stagnation pressure. Stagnation pressure plays an important role in the inflow and outflow of gases in a motor home or like enclosure. The stagnation pressure can be due to a moving body, such as a motor home impacting stationary air, or to a moving air stream or wind impacting a stationary body. The magnitude of the stagnation pressure may be calculated from the velocity component and the angle of incidents to the plane of the impact surface. In low-pressure air flow calculations it is traditional to refer to velocity in ft./min and stagnation pressure in terms of inches of water column (see Equation 4.8). Stagnation Pressure. h =
Um 1096.5
2 ∗ δ ∗ sin φ
(4.8)
Where δ is density of fluid at flowing temperature and pressure (lb/ft3 ) h is stagnation pressure (in. w.c.) φ is angle of incidence of Vm to plane of stagnation degrees Um is velocity of stream (ft./min) A useful chart, Figure 4.6, shows the magnitude of stagnation pressure for air at various wind speeds impacting a stationary surface. To put this in perspective consider the following example: a 20 mph wind impacts a stationary wall at an angle of 90◦ . From Figure 4.6, the stagnation pressure will be 0.20 in. w.c. Assume that there is a single 2 ft. × 4 ft. closed double hung window in the wall. Assume that the window has a 1/64 inch crack along all moving surfaces. The total leakage area will be A=
1 × 12 × (2 + 2 + 2 + 4 + 4) = 2.625 sq.in 64
Using Equation 4.6 we can calculate that the air flow through the window crack will be 1572 acfh, which is a substantial leakage.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 75 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
76
Stagnation pressure in. water column
Stagnation pressure (in. water column) 1.40 1.20 1.00 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20 0.00 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Wind speed MPH
FIGURE 4.6 Stagnation pressure.
4.6.4 THERMAL PRESSURE Any time there is a temperature gradient within or between the inside and outside of an enclosure, thermal pressure will develop at the top of the enclosure. Thermal pressure is a function of temperature difference, density of the fluid or fluids, and vertical height from the inlet to outlet in feet. The usual units for thermal pressure are inches of w.c. Equation 4.9 represents the equation for thermal pressure: Thermal pressure. p∗MW ∗H 1 1 ht = ∗ − 55.77 T2 T1
(4.9)
Where ht is thermal pressure head (in. w.c.) H is height of the enclosure (ft.) MW is molecular weight of gas p is atmospheric pressure (psia) T2 is absolute atmospheric temperature (Rankine degrees) T1 is absolute enclosure temperature (Rankine degrees) Thermal pressure can be treated as any other pressure to determine flow across an opening (see Equation 4.6). Thermal pressure is important in the flow of exhaust because of the temperature gradient between the hot exhaust gas and that of the surrounding atmosphere. To put it into perspective, a temperature gradient of 100◦ F in a 6-ft. high enclosure will create a thermal pressure of 0.0237 in. w.c. That thermal pressure would create a flow of 204 scfh per square inch of leakage area.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 76 — #20
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
77
4.6.5 AIR FLOW AROUND AND THROUGH ENCLOSURES Aside from fans, blowers, exhausters, or similar power gas moving devices, thermal head, and wind are the principal cause of flow of gases into or out of enclosures such as motor homes or buildings. Any time that wind moves across or around any object, pressure gradients form around it. It is these pressure gradients acting on openings in the enclosure that create flow into and out of the enclosure. Figure 4.1 shows an elevation view of a simplified enclosure (B) exposed to wind flow. The wind blowing from left to right. The horizontal lines (A) represent stream tubes of air. As the lower stream tubes approach the vertical wall, their horizontal velocity approaches zero, converting kinetic energy to static pressure (stagnation pressure). This builds a positive pressure region along the upwind face. The static pressure gradient on the upwind face is greatest at the bottom where virtually all kinetic energy or velocity pressure is converted to static pressure (C). At higher levels there is flow moving up the wall, therefore static pressure will be somewhat lower due to transition into velocity. Total pressure remains essentially constant across the face with the exception that there is a frictional loss due to turbulence. Air within the positive pressure region (M) flows into the lower pressure region (D) and accelerates to join the higher velocity stream tubes flowing across the top of the object at (B). As the velocity increases, static pressure diminishes forming a low pressure region (F) along the top of the object. This effect may be likened to the low pressure created as air flows across the top of an airfoil. As the stream tubes flow past, the downstream edge of the object they deflect down due to the low-pressure vortex (G) on the downstream side of the body. Surface drag from the stream tubes acting on the low pressure region (G) cause a clockwise rotation to the low-pressure wake (G). At very low Reynolds numbers vortex (G) will remain stable in the cavity formed by the ground and the downstream wall of the object. At Reynolds numbers above 50, which is most common in air flow, vortex (G) becomes unstable and periodically moves downstream, as represented by vortex (H). Then a new vortex is established and grows in size at (G) until it separates. This process is referred to as vortex shedding. While vortex shedding introduces instability downstream for the object, the pressure in the immediate downstream area while variable in magnitude remains essentially negative. When openings exist in the enclosure, as shown in Figure 4.1, positive pressure on the windward side causes flow into the enclosure through openings (I). As a result of the inflow, internal pressure increases. The internal pressure being higher than that on the downwind side causes a pressure differential that results in flow through any openings (K). The negative pressure (G) further increases the pressure differential resulting in a further increase of flow. If the enclosure is divided into rooms or other subdivisions, flow will work its way through openings in the partitions, traveling from high to low pressure. Flow rate will be governed by pressure differential and area of leakage paths, in accordance with Equation 4.6. If multiple leaks are involved, a series of simultaneous equations may be written to determine the net flow through the enclosure. It is apparent that if CO was discharged on the upstream side, then it would be induced into the interior of the enclosure.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 77 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
78
4.6.6 WIND ROSE When a CO-poisoning incident occurs and external wind conditions appear to be a factor, it is desirable to be able to determine the wind effect over the time span of the accident. The wind may be at a constant velocity and direction during the entire incident or it may vary widely in direction and velocity. The wind intensity and direction are a vector quantity that may constantly change with time. Because of the highly variable nature of the wind, it is helpful to develop a graphic image, as well as a mathematical model of the wind effect relative to time. There are three factors that are pertinent: velocity, direction, and duration which add to the difficulty in graphing the event. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)9 hourly weather reports provide all the data necessary to evaluate the role of weather on an incident. The reports give wind direction, speed, temperature, and a number of other factors, for each hourly segment. The NOAA weather service developed a chart called a wind rose used to assess average wind direction and speed for given airport locations for the purposes of runway direction. Using this basic concept as a starting point, I developed a chart that is useful for forensic investigation of wind-related incidents. Initially, the wind direction, wind speed and the time for each hourly segment is logged into a chart (Table 4.2). The data are then plotted on a 360◦ polar graph in which wind direction, degrees, and intensity (knots) is entered on the polar graph. Entries are shown as 1-h segments for any given direction. The length of each vector represents the wind speed for that particular vector. Where there are multiple vectors or any given heading, each alternating sector is colored for easy differentiation. I normally place time in, {0800}, showing the actual time for each sector so that I do not have to refer to the database for that information. Plotting wind impact surfaces on the chart also aids in visualization. The rose (Figure 4.7) shows that during a 24-h period there were two prominent groupings of wind. The one of interest spans from about 2200 on 2/13 to 0800 on 2/14, having a wind direction of from 70◦ to 180◦ , which is predominantly out of the east. In this case, the front of the building is represented by the line from 30◦ to about 210◦ . The concern was for stagnation pressure on the “East East South” face of the building within the time frame of the accident. Study of the data (Table 4.2) showed that during the critical hours winds out of the east created substantial stagnation pressure, thereby, pressurizing not only the face of the building but all the rooms having openings on that side of the building. In the case represented by this wind rose there were a number of large louvers opening into a boiler room that contained the boiler that generated CO. As a result of the wind, the room was pressurized driving CO into other sections of the building, which contained the living quarters. The wind rose also shows that more intense winds out of the southwest occurred later in the day; however, they occurred outside of the critical time and were of no consequence.
4.6.7 SCOOPS, DEFLECTORS, AND OPENINGS It is commonplace to have ventilators and exhaust fans on or in the roof of motor homes and most portable trailers and offices. These ventilators frequently project into
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 78 — #22
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
79
TABLE 4.2 Weather Data Giving Wind Direction, Wind Speed, and Temperature Date
Time
Wind Direction (degree)
Wind Speed (knots)
Temperature (◦ F)
2/13/2004 2/13/2004 2/13/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004 2/14/2004
2200 2300 2400 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800
90 90 180 126 290 150 0 180 0 0 140 0 0 0 240 260 240 220 220 230 230
4 8 3 1 3 4 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 0 9 11 9 7 6 14 10
33.8 35.6 32.0 30.2 30.2 30.2 37.4 33.8 33.8 30.2 33.8 37.4 44.6 48.2 53.6 55.4 55.4 57.2 55.4 55.4 53.6
North 360°
Front face of building
Wind speed 3 (knots)/ring
270°
90° (2300) (2200) (0100) (0800) (0300) (0500) (2400) 180°
FIGURE 4.7 Wind rose for 02/13/04 (2200 hrs) to 02/14/04 (1800 hrs).
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 79 — #23
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
80 A
B
D
C
E
FIGURE 4.8 Ventilator acting as a deflector.
A
B
G −
H −
+ +
C +
+
−
−
−
+
F D E
FIGURE 4.9 Ventilator acting as a scoop.
the wind stream and induce flow during motion of the vehicle, or in windy conditions with the vehicle being stationary. Figure 4.8 and 4.9 show pressure gradients and direction of flow into or out of an enclosure, depending on the direction of wind flow across the ventilator. Figure 4.8 shows wind flow (A) from left to right, that is deflected upward as it encounters the cover sloping up to the right. The increased velocity at B lowers the static pressure resulting in a low-pressure region at D, downstream of the cover. Assuming neutral pressure within the enclosure (C), flow from inside the enclosure (E) will move from the neutral pressure zone (C) to the negative pressure zone (D), downstream of the deflecting cover. Knowing the relative wind velocity, its angle of incidence the shape and configuration of the ventilator, and the area of the opening the flow rate through the enclosure can be calculated using Equation 4.6. Figure 4.9 shows airflow (A) from left to right that impacts the underside of the cover (B), causing partial stagnation of stream (C), resulting in a positive pressure region (D) on the underside of the cover and at the mouth of the ventilator opening. This assumes that the interior of the enclosure is at neutral pressure (E). The pressure differential plus the remaining velocity pressure will result in air flowing into the enclosure. The flow rate entering the enclosure can be calculated using Equation 4.6. If the pressure within the enclosure is other than neutral, then the differential pressure (h0 −h1 ) must be adjusted accordingly.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 80 — #24
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
81
4.6.8 RESONANCE, CYCLICAL FLOW INTO AND OUT OF AN ENCLOSURE Airflow across any opening leading into a closed chamber can result in cyclical pressure pulsations within the enclosure. The cyclical pressure pulsations result in a cyclical inflow and outflow of gas from the enclosure. The pulsations, depending on the shape of the opening can result in a net inflow or outflow from the enclosure. This phenomenon is well known to passengers riding inside an automobile when the rear windows are partially open. The cyclical low frequency pressure surges are commonly referred to as buffeting. The pressure surges can go unnoticed or be significant to the extent of being painful to the ears. A similar effect can be experienced inside a motor home or other enclosure when airflow across an open window or ventilator results in buffeting. The frequency of the oscillation is a function of the volume of the enclosure and the physical characteristics of the opening. The technical term for this type of oscillation is helmholtz resonance. The equation that governs this phenomenon is Helmholtz resonance. 1 fo = ∗ ∗ 2 π
c2∗ S lc∗ V
(4.10)
Where c is speed of sound, at flowing temperature and pressure of the gas (ft./s) fo is resonant Frequency (Hz) lc is effective length of the throat opening S is cross-sectional area of the throat opening (sq. ft.) V is volume of the enclosure (cu. ft.) An example will illustrate the significance of Helmholtz resonance. Assume a trailer 8 × 30 × 7 has a volume of a 1680 cu. ft. Assume it has a single partially open window having an open area of 0.44 sq. ft. and a 0.5
throat, thickness of the pane, at the opening. Also assume that the fluid medium is air at 60◦ F. The frequency of the oscillation will be 7.1 Hz (cps). This frequency is well below the range of human hearing; therefore, the oscillation will go undetected. However, it will still induce large volumes of outside fluid during the negative cycle. It should be noted that low frequency pulsations, if of sufficient amplitude, could be detected by feeling. The inducted fluid will then mix with the contents of the enclosure. On the positive cycle, a similar volume of mixture will be expelled. This of course assumes that the opening is bidirectional in configuration. If the atmosphere outside the window contains a significant percentage of CO, then each half cycle will induce CO into the interior. Over a period of time, the interior concentration of CO will increase and could become significant. See Section 4.7 for a discussion of the rate of accumulation.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 81 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
82
4.6.9 FLOW INTO AND OUT OF LIVING QUARTERS After the foregoing discussion it is apparent that flow into or out of an enclosure occurs only if there is a pressure imbalance and an opening that will allow flow. The pressure imbalance can be due to a mechanical device like a pump or fan; thermal activity creating pressure imbalance due to density variations; or wind pressure acting on the enclosure. The leakage areas may be the obvious ones such as windows, doors, ventilators, or unsealed openings around pipes or electrical penetrations into the living compartment. Leaks can also occur at joints in the walls and floors, through cracks or labyrinth openings that are not apparent to an observer. In CO poisonings, the percent CO concentration in the enclosure is of prime importance. CO may be generated within the enclosure or outside and leak into the enclosure, or a combination of the two. Flow into or out of the enclosure is critical because it can increase the concentration within or it can dilute the concentration by bringing in fresh air and washing out CO during the air exchange process.
4.6.10 FLUE AND CHIMNEY DYNAMICS A flue or chimney is used to remove the products of combustion from inside a building or enclosure. It operates on the same principle as thermal pressure except that the pressure is negative when measured at the base of the flue. In addition, because flow is confined within a solid boundary, the chimney or flue, friction within the duct must be considered. Equation 4.11 may be used to calculate the suction created by a flue or chimney. Careful inspection of the equation shows a similarity with that of Equation 4.9, except that there is an additional back end representing the fluid friction inside the chimney. Flue draft h=
p∗MW∗H 1 1 .09∗H∗U 2 p∗MW ∗ − − 1+ ∗ 55.77 Tf Ta D∗2∗g 10.729∗Ta
Where D is flue diameter (ft.) g is a constant = 32.2 h is flue suction (in. w.c.) H is height of the flue or chimney (ft.) MW Molecular Weight of the flowing gas p is absolute pressure (psia) Ta is absolute temperature of ambient air (R◦ ) Tf is absolute temperature of flowing gas (R◦ ) U is the velocity of the flue gas (ft/sec)
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 82 — #26
(4.11)
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
83
To solve Equation 4.11 it is necessary to assume a flue gas velocity. An acceptable range to start with is 14.0–16.5 ft./s
4.6.11 BACK-dRAFTING OF FLUE GASES INTO THE ENCLOSURE Back drafting is one of the common root causes for CO poisoning. Back drafting is a process whereby the normal direction of exhaust flow is reversed because the suction inside the enclosure is greater than the thermal suction created as a result of the temperature difference across the flue. Back drafting can occur in any closed or semiclosed enclosure. The most common cause is a result of an exhaust fan, or similar air removal device, overpowering the flue suction. The exhaust device may be an exhaust fan, a bathroom or kitchen exhauster, clothes dryer or even another chimney of greater height and temperature difference. Figure 4.2 shows an example of back drafting through a chimney as a result of a clothes dryer operating. The room is relatively tight which limits leakage air into the room. The exhaust fan in the clothes dryer has a capacity, which exceeds the leakage rate of air into the room, thereby lowering the pressure within the room. If the suction pressure within the room is equal to or greater than the flue suction, the flow up the chimney stalls, resulting in a reversal of flow in the chimney. Ambient air is drawn down the chimney, providing combustion air to the flame from above. This changes the normal direction of airflow across the flame holder, disturbing mixing and flame stability. The flame instead of being sucked up the stack, is blown toward the inside of the enclosure. The exhaust gases then change direction and are discharged into the enclosure. Additionally, the flow reversal disturbs the normal combustion process and its flame stability, causing the flame to blow off, increasing the production of partial products of combustion. Figure 4.2 shows a back drafting chimney as a result of a suction created by a clothes dryer. Back drafting has become much more common as homes and buildings becoming tighter (less air leaks) and the prevalence of air exhausting appliances like clothes dryers and exhaust fans, roof exhausters and multiple chimneys becomes more common. The way to avoid the problem is to install appliances that have their own outside air intake, which are frequently power driven. Another method would be to install a general outside air intake. Motor homes, trailers and portable buildings, because of their requirement to seal the living compartment tend to have fewer air leaks, thereby, become prone to back drafting when exhaust devices are used.
4.6.12 DYNAMICS OF GENERATOR TAILPIPE EXHAUST Generator tailpipe exhaust, by code, must always be external to the living compartment. As described earlier, the tailpipe is generally perpendicular to the outside wall of a motor home, is below, and protrudes beyond its periphery. For the purpose of perspective, consider that a 4 kW single cylinder, four-cycle gasoline-fueled engine (Octane, C8 H18 , will be used as the formula for gasoline) generator will be used. At a 3 kW load the exhaust volume will be about 2030 acfh at 800◦ F. At the 1.1 in.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 83 — #27
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
84
diameter exhaust pipe, typical for that size generator, exit velocity will be 85 ft./s. When the exhaust jet enters stationary ambient air, the surface drag of the jet stream moves ambient air along with it. Ambient air is entrained into the outer portion of the jet stream causing the outer layer to lose velocity and through drag eventually to slow the core stream. The velocity profile across the jet will be Gaussian as shown in Figure 4.10. As cold air is entrained into the hot jet the average temperature of the jet diminishes. Normally it would be expected that the hot jet would have a tendency to rise, due to its buoyancy. However, in the early stages of the jet, the first 20–30 diameters, the horizontal velocity is high compared to the vertical velocity resulting from thermal buoyancy. Therefore, the vertical movement of the jet will be small. In the example shown in Figure 4.10 the vertical rise at 36 diameters is approximately 1.5 diameters, which is not significant. When the horizontal jet velocity slows, the thermal rise becomes more significant. From Figure 4.11, the entrainment at 36 diameters (3 ft.) will be in the order 17:1 and could be as high as 30:1. The example used a 17:1 entrainment ratio.
Gaussian velocity distribution
Entrainment of ambient gas
Thermal rise l.45 D
0D
4D
8D
Exhaust pipe
12 D 16 D
20 D
24 D
36 D
Jet profile
FIGURE 4.10 Expanding jet.
Velocity fps; entrainment ratio
Entrainment ratio versus distance 100 80 60 40
Velocity
20
Entrainment ratio
0 −20
0
5
10
15
20
Distance in nozzle diameters
FIGURE 4.11 Jet velocity and entrainment versus jet distance in diameters.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 84 — #28
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
85 Wall
Trapped exhaust gas Direction of flow of exhaust gas Motor home Entrained exhaust Tailpipe
Exhaust discharge
FIGURE 4.12 Entrainment in a confined area.
The initial CO concentration would be diluted by a factor of 17:1. The CO concentration in the vicinity of the jet at 3 ft., for an initial CO concentration of 40,000 ppm, would be approximately 2350 ppm. Further dilution would occur at greater distances downstream. If the exhaust jet is discharged into a region that has limited air circulation or that traps or confines the exhaust, then the jet will be immersed in a cloud of exhaust gases (see Figure 4.12). Initially, the exhaust jet entrains ambient air diluting the exhaust concentration. As the jet strikes the wall, its velocity drops to zero and the exhaust gases stagnate. Because of the confinement, the exhaust gases accumulate between the road, the wall, and the motor home. The entraining action of the jet instead of drawing in fresh air and diluting the CO level in the jet, it entrains and re-circulates exhaust gas, gradually concentrating it, up to the maximum concentration in the exhaust jet. On the basis of this behavior, it is important to insure that the exhaust system is in good condition and discharges outside the motor home and into an area, that is unrestricted where exhaust gases can readily dissipate.
4.6.13 EXHAUST FLOW THROUGH BENT OR DISPLACED EXHAUST PIPES Because exhaust systems are usually located in exposed locations they are prone to impact and may become damaged, bent or rotated out of position. When this happens, they may discharge exhaust gases under the motor home or possibly discharge it against the inside of the skirt or other interior surfaces. If the jet discharges under the vehicle, there is a tendency for the exhaust to become stagnant there. As a result, the exhaust jet entrains the locally stagnant exhaust and the CO does not dissipate. If the jet strikes another object, the jet loses its velocity, therefore its entraining ability. The exhaust becomes stagnant and does not dilute or dissipate. The slow moving or stagnant cloud of highly concentrated CO remains under the motor home and inside the generator compartment.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 85 — #29
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
86
Without entrainment the highly concentrated CO cloud remains at high temperature, therefore is highly buoyant, creating thermal pressure on any leaks that may exist into the living compartment. In addition, any suction pressure within the enclosure, resulting from wind or other effects, will add to the entrainment of the offending gases. The concentrated pocket of exhaust under the floor of the motor home is in a location where leaks into the living quarters are more likely. If the exhaust jet impinges on the skirt or other surface at an angle, the jet stream will attach to and flow along the wall, (Coanda effect or wall jet attraction, Henry Coanda, French aviator, ca. 1918). The flattened jet is under negative pressure, causing it to entrain local ambient gases. Since this occurs in a confined area under the motor home, the gas being entrained is primarily exhaust gases, resulting in a high concentration of CO. The concentrated gases are in a location that is prone to have leaks into the living compartment.
4.6.14 MISSING EXHAUST SYSTEMS If the exhaust system, either the tailpipe or the muffler has been broken off, the remaining vertical spud directs the exhaust jet toward the ground. The jet characteristics are similar to those previously described. The hot exhaust gas jet entrains ambient gas and the mixed jet then impacts the ground. The hot jet after striking the ground flows outward from the point of impact and because of its buoyancy then flows upward. Thereafter, a recirculation pattern develops (Figure 4.13). The exhaust cloud remains in position, continually being regenerated. The suction in the exhaust jet entrains local gases, which are primarily exhaust gas and fresh air dilution is minimal. The re-entrained exhaust jet builds up a stationary, highly concentrated CO cloud under the generator and motor home. Winds acting perpendicular to the exhaust stream could move the cloud to a safer location depending on the direction and magnitude of the wind stream and terrain or boundaries in the vicinity of the generator. The stationary cloud has a relatively high temperature and therefore creates thermal pressure on the underside of the motor home and generator compartment where the probability of leaks into the living compartment is most likely. Generator compartment
Muffler spud Generator platform
Hot exhaust gas
Pavement
Recirculation vortex
FIGURE 4.13
Jet entrainment and recirculation under a motor generator without a tail pipe.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 86 — #30
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
87
4.7 ACCUMULATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE WITHIN AN ENCLOSURE The extent of disability or death of individuals exposed to CO and other toxic exhaust gas products of combustion is directly related to the partial pressure of the toxic gases within the enclosure, the duration of exposure, as well as the physical condition and rate of exertion of the individual and presence of other gases such as carbon dioxide. This discussion does not consider the medical aspects of such poisoning and refers the reader to other authoritative texts on the subject (other chapters in this book, and10,11 ). Earlier I described the sources of exhaust gases that are produced either within the enclosure or the volume flow rate of exhaust gases leaking into the enclosure from exterior sources. This section describes the procedures for determining the exhaust gas concentration at any specific time in the CO accumulation cycle. This information in conjunction with the Coburn–Forster–Kane equation may be used to evaluate the individual exposure to CO and their resultant COHb. Equation 4.14 evaluates the exponential increase of CO concentration within an enclosure that is initially filled with clean uncontaminated air. The program assumes that perfect mixing will occur within the enclosure. This is a reasonable assumption because the contaminating fluid is either jetted into the enclosure or is drawn in as a result of pressure differential, or is due to a thermal plume or jet with a sizable thermal head, all of which create mixing. In addition, the enclosures are generally small and are not subdivided into tight rooms or enclosures, that might create isolation or stratification of the leakage gases. Equation 4.14 allows for simultaneous introduction of exhaust gas, CO and also leakage of uncontaminated outside air. This same equation may be used to evaluate the concentration of other component gases contained in the exhaust gas by substituting the gas concentration in ppm, that is, QCO2 for QCO in ppm. Volume flow of carbon monoxide in incoming exhaust (CFM). QCO = QX ∗ CO/1000000
(4.12)
Total volume of exhaust plus leakage air into the enclosure (CFM). QMm = QLm + QX Concentration of carbon monoxide at time t. (QMm )∗ tn 100∗ QCO ∗ V Cn,m = 1−e QMm where CO is CO concentration, ppm, in incoming exhaust Cn,m is CO concentration within the enclosure at time tn and QMm , ppm e is a constant = 2.7183
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 87 — #31
(4.13)
(4.14)
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
88
m is step iterator (cfm) n is iterator of time (min.) Qco is volume flow of CO in the incoming exhaust gas (cfm) QL m is leakage of air entering the enclosure. Iterated by m (cfm) QMm is total volume of exhaust plus leakage air entering the enclosure (cfm) QX is volume of exhaust entering the enclosure (cfm) tn is the iterated value of time in min V is net volume of the enclosure (cu. ft.) Example: Assume a motor home having a 1680 cu. ft. volume, initially containing clean air, and with two openings, one at the top and one near the floor. Assume there is a 150 cfm roof exhauster located in the ceiling. Assume another motor home is parked parallel to this one whose motor generator is discharging exhaust gases containing 50,000 ppm CO in the direction of the first motor home, near the lower opening. Because of dilution and the size opening, assume that 100 cfm of diluted exhaust containing 2000 ppm of CO is drawn into the lower opening of the first motor home. Simultaneously, 50 cfm of clean air, (150 fan-100 exhaust), is drawn in through the upper opening. Determine the CO concentration with respect to time. Plot CO concentration when the total volume of exhaust plus leakage, QM m = 100, 125, 150, and 175, 200 cfm. Figure 4.14 shows the CO concentration in ppm within the enclosure with respect to time. Iterative computations were done for Qmx = 100 to 200 cfm. The middle dash line (m = 2) represents a flow of 150 cfm, when m = 150, which is equal to the exhaust fan volume of 150 cfm. The series of curves shows how CO concentration changes with higher and lower leakage flow rates, QL, into the enclosure.
CO concentration (ppm) at time tn 2000
C ppm0,n
CO concentration (ppm)
C ppm1,n 1500
C ppm2,n C ppm3,n
1000
C ppm4,n
500
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
tn Time (min)
FIGURE 4.14 Accumulation of carbon monoxide within an enclosure.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 88 — #32
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
89
Based on this information it is possible to predict the CO concentration at any period of time or to integrate the area under the curve, and to divide by time to determine the average concentration for any time span. Some important points may be made regarding this set of curves: 1. The solid curve, representing zero air leakage, shows that the CO concentration in the enclosure reaches a maximum concentration in the incoming exhaust gas after about 80 min. 2. Each successive curve maxes out at a lower concentration, all at about 80 min or less. 3. The CO concentration rises to a level dangerous to humans within 6 or 7 min. The CO concentration, for the example given, rises very rapidly for the first 20 min, reaching about 1100 ppm. Thereafter, the rate of rise diminishes and levels off at a maximum CO concentration of 1300 ppm at about 50 min. Thereafter the concentration stabilizes and remains constant. This information derived from this calculation can then be used in conjunction with the Coburn, Forster, Kane (CFK) equation, to determine blood COHb rise for any given period of time.
4.7.1 RATE OF DISSIPATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE FROM AN ENCLOSURE Earlier I discussed the rate of accumulation of CO within an enclosure. This section directs its attention to the dissipation of the accumulated CO when the rate of influx of CO, QCO , decreases or is zero, while a fan or exhauster continues bringing in fresh air. Dissipation of carbon monoxide within an enclosure. βn,m = ppmx ∗ e−((QCO + Qx) ∗ tn /V ) (4.15) where βn,m is CO concentration in the enclosure at the end of time tn (ppm). n is time iterator (min) ppmx is CO concentration at the start of the reduction QCO is volume flow rate of CO entering the enclosure, if any (cu. ft./min) Qx is volume flow rate of clean air entering the enclosure (cu. ft./min) t is time (min) V is volume of enclosure (cu. ft.) Reconsider the previous example with the following modifications: Assume that after 20 min of operation the motor generator is turned off, but all other conditions remain the same. Determine the rate of dissipation of CO within the enclosure with
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 89 — #33
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
90
Dissipation of CO versus time
Co concentration (ppm)
1500
1200
β 2, n
900
600
300
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
tn Time (min)
FIGURE 4.15 Dissipation of carbon monoxide from an enclosure.
respect to time. The exhaust fan, still running, takes up 150 cu. ft./min of fresh air which dilutes the 1100 ppm CO concentration within the enclosure. Equation 4.15 may be used to calculate the CO concentration after any time period. Figure 4.15 shows the dissipation curve starting at 1100 ppm at time t = 0 which correlates with Figure 4.14 at 20 min. Calculation of the type shown in section 4.7 and 4.7.1 can be used to calculate CO concentration where the source of CO cycles on and off, as would occur with a thermostatically controlled furnace. Depending on the on-off cycle time, the resultant graph would appear as a saw tooth curve. Integration of the area under that curve divided by time would yield the average concentration over any selected time span. If this information is to be used in the determination of blood COHb, a similar saw tooth curve would have to be produced accounting for the rise in COHb during periods where the CO partial pressure of the atmosphere exceeds the partial pressure of CO in the lungs. Also half-life calculations would have to be done to account for decreasing COHb where the partial pressure of CO in the enclosure is below that of the lungs during off time.
4.8 TEST METHODS FOR DETERMINING THE LOCATION OF LEAKAGE INTO AN ENCLOSURE In cases where CO intrusion into the living compartment occurs, it becomes important to determine the location and relative size of the opening or breach in the living compartment. NFPA3 and ANSI2 safety codes require that the living compartment of a mobile home or trailer equipped with a motor generator must be sealed against
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 90 — #34
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
91
intrusion of exhaust gases. Therefore, any opening or potential leakage path into the living compartment that is not sealed is of significance. Since exhaust gases, CO, carbon dioxide and nitrogen, are all colorless, odorless, and tasteless, it is not possible to detect their leakage using normal sensory perceptions. Scientific instruments, that detect the presence of the offending gas, may be used as long as it is possible to replicate original conditions regarding flow and generation of CO. Replication, particularly when wind or atmospheric conditions play an active role is usually very difficult. Additives to the gas stream may be used to enhance sensory perception as long as they do not affect the results. Smoke testing has proven to be simple, inexpensive and accurately shows the magnitude and position of leaks.
4.8.1 SMOKE TESTING Injecting smoke into an area where exhaust gases were known to accumulate is a practical way to make leakage into the living compartment visible, without appreciably changing the physical characteristics of the leakage stream. Visual contrast of smoke is good, as are photographic characteristics. Smoke makes it easy to detect the location of small and large leaks as well as to assess their magnitude. It should be pointed out that this is not an attempt to replicate the original exhaust gas stream. It is intended to show leakage paths and give an order of magnitude to the leakage stream. Commercial smoke-producing devices are readily available, which are inexpensive and safe to operate. These include candles of various sizes as well as other smoke generators. Candles will generate smoke over periods from 30 s to 3 min, in volumes from 4,000 to 40,000 cu. ft. Smoke generators can provide a continuous stream of high quality smoke where required. Colored smoke is available in candle form. Colored smoke gives excellent contrast especially in bland backgrounds, however, colored smoke is apt to cause permanent stains. Most manufacturers state that their smoke is not toxic. My experience has been that breathing smoke, even for a short duration, leaves an aftertaste, and lung congestion that is objectionable, and that persists for many hours. The use of a good high quality respirator seems to alleviate that problem. Smoke particle size in ranges from 2 µm (0.00004 in.) to 60 µm (0.0024 in.) therefore, has little effect on changing the flow characteristics of a gas stream. The smoke is stable and persistent, having a settling time of about 1.5 h, which is more than enough for most tests. The smoke, because of its small size will penetrate very small openings. Smoke can be released in open air or injected into the intake of a portable blower, when a pressurized stream is required. The internet is a good source for smoke candles or generators. Smoke candles, or the fluid used for a smoke generators are not permitted as carry on or shipped baggage on commercial aircraft.
4.8.2 BASIC CONSIDERATIONS DURING SMOKE TESTING In order to have either an inflow or an outflow of gases there must be a pressure differential between the inside and outside of the enclosure. The simplest way to
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 91 — #35
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
92
accomplish the pressure differential is to increase or decrease the enclosure internal pressure while allowing the ambient or outside pressure to remain at atmospheric conditions. Negative internal pressure replicates the conditions that would normally draw CO into the living compartment, therefore tends to replicates the actual accident conditions, assuming that the leakage areas have not been changed. Under some atmospheric conditions, generally high ambient temperatures, a thermal head may develop as a result of temperature differentials occurring during testing and must be overcome by additional pressure differential. Tests can be done by pressurizing or by creating a negative pressure within the enclosure. The specific type of test will be dictated by the circumstances.
4.8.3 POSITIVE PRESSURE TESTING Positive pressure testing requires a means for increasing internal pressure within the motor home or enclosure. This requires the installation of a turbo blower or other device that is not normally found in this type of enclosure. Additionally it requires that exhaust fans, ventilators, dryers, and similar openings be sealed during the test. Observation of small quantities of leaking smoke may be difficult to see in ambient or bright light conditions. Windy conditions will tend to dilute all but very large leakage streams. The diluted streams are much more difficult to photograph in bright sunlight where it may be impossible to control front lighting. Many of these problems can be eliminated if the testing can be done inside a building where wind and lighting can be controlled.
4.8.4 NEGATIVE PRESSURE TESTING Negative pressure testing is done by lowering the pressure inside the enclosure while providing a reservoir of dense smoke on the outside of the enclosure. It is desirable to locate the source of the smoke in the area where leaks are suspected. The advantage of this type of testing is that most motor homes, trailers or portable buildings already have exhaust ventilators, bathroom exhausters, fume hoods and dryers, that can be used to lower the enclosure pressure. Additionally, it is easier to see the smoke in interior controlled lighting conditions, where front and side lighting is easily achieved. Most tests can be performed without modification to the living enclosure. This is a distinct advantage in production testing but it is especially valuable in forensic cases where approval for modifications would have to be obtained, in advance of testing, from opposing counsel. Most CO intrusion incidents are from auxiliary generator engine exhaust that is normally discharged outside the living enclosure. As a generalization, motor homes develop exterior leaks in the floors and transition area of walls to floors, around wheel wells, and around conduits or pipes that penetrate the living enclosure. Frequently the leakage path is convoluted and difficult to detect using a light source or by trying to push a flexible object through the opening. Smoke testing is an easy and efficient way to detect these types of openings.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 92 — #36
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
93
4.8.5 TYPICAL SMOKE TESTING Smoke testing will give a good visual picture of the location and magnitude of leaks into a living compartment. Still and video photographs provide a means of recording real time results of the test. If photographs are judiciously taken they can be used to determine relative location and relative magnitude of leaks. Photos and videos are invaluable in forensic cases since they provide visual proof that leakage paths are present in the living compartment, which is in direct violation of NFPA and ANSI safety codes. Pictures are worth a thousand words, but only if it they are clear and depict the objects of interest accurately without distortion. As an example, the photographs in Figures 4.16 through Figure 4.22 tell a story of how and where CO leaked into the motor home. They show a replication, using smoke as a visible medium, of exhaust gas entering a motor home. The desired effect in this case was to show how large volumes of CO entered the motor home in a very short period of time. The photographs clearly show how the accumulation of smoke (the smoke representing CO) occurred. At the start of the test in the example shown, the interior of the motor home was clear without any obstruction. Figure 4.16 shows a view looking toward the back of the motor home. This shows that the internal atmosphere is clear. An additional photograph taken looking forward through the motor home and out the windshield shows that that section of the motor home is also free of haze (Figure 4.17). Figure 4.18 shows the first wisps of smoke appearing through the upper drawer of the end table. This photograph was taken after 1 min of elapsed time (ET) following initiation of smoke. This leak occurred at the left rear corner of the motor home. This was particularly important because that is where the generator was located. The smoke candle was located directly under the generator. The smoke traveled through a convoluted passage that could not be detected during inspection.
FIGURE 4.16 Looking aft before testing.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 93 — #37
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
94
FIGURE 4.17 Looking forward before testing.
FIGURE 4.18 Left rear corner, first smoke 1 min elapsed time.
From preliminary testing it was suspected that a large leak existed in the middlearea of the motor home. Thus attention was focused on that area. Figure 4.19 shows a view looking aft from the middle-point of the motor home. A large discharge of smoke was detected coming from the lower part of a storage cabinet. The interior atmosphere has become partially obscured at 2 min ET. Figure 4.20, 25 s later, shows obscuration has all but eliminated all detail in the previous photograph. Figure 4.21 shows total obscuration of the cabinet shown on the right of the previous photograph. This series of six photographs shows the location of the two leaks, and it shows that the mid point leak is the larger of the two. It shows that the rate of leakage is very
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 94 — #38
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
95
FIGURE 4.19 Looking aft second leak area, 2 min elapsed time.
FIGURE 4.20 Looking aft second leak 2 min 25 s elapsed time.
high in the interior part of the vehicle. The photographs show that the leaks were very large and smoke permeated the interior of the vehicle in a very short time. Total obscuration took place in three minutes. Timing with a stop watch, backed up by the time record from the digital and video cameras, used in conjunction with the known volume of the vehicle, made it possible to approximate the leakage rate of smoke into the interior of the vehicle. I have found that smoke testing is an efficient means of determining the location of leaks and also their relative magnitude. It has proven to be an invaluable asset in forensic cases.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 95 — #39
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
96
FIGURE 4.21 Second leak, totally obscured cabinet, 3 min elapsed time. Exhaust gas percent dry methane CH4 20 18
Percent (dry)
16 14 DEN*100 CO2 CO O2
12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
1
2
3 4 Equivalence ratio
5
6
FIGURE 4.22 Exhaust gas percent dry methane.
4.9 CONCLUSION Using the techniques presented in this paper, the source and magnitude of CO leaks into mobile homes and other enclosures may be determined. Photographs of the smoke intrusion provide a visual demonstration of the presence of leaks.
References 1. Mah, J.C. Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths and injuries Associated with the Use of Consumer Products U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission, October, 2000. 2. American National Standards Institute, Washington, DC.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 96 — #40
Formation and Movement of Carbon Monoxide
97
3. National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, MA. 4. Environmental Protection Agency. Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, EPA 600/P-00/001B, Tables 3–7, 1999, Cincinnati, OH. 5. Boltz R. E. and Tuve G. L. Handbook of Tables for Applied Engineering Science, 2nd edition, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1987. 6. Williams, G. C. et al., The Combustion of Methane in a Jet Mixed Reactor, Twelfth Symposium on Combustion, Pittsburg, PA. 1968. 7. Jones, J.C. Combustion Sciences: Principles and Practices, Millennium Books, Newton, Australia, 1933. 8. Linan, L. and Williams, F. Fundamental Aspects of Combustion, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1993. 9. National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration, Washington, DC 10. Penney, D.G. Carbon Monoxide, p. 296, CRC Press, NY, 1996. 11. Penney, D.G. Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, p. 560, CRC Press, NY, 2000.
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 97 — #41
8417: “8417_c004” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 98 — #42
5
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field Protocol for Measuring CO Emissions Richard Karg
CONTENTS 5.1
5.2
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.1 Objectives of Karg Field Protocol Development. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.2 ANSI Standard Z21.1-1993, Household Cooking Gas Appliances 5.1.3 As-Measured and Air-Free Carbon Monoxide Measurement . . . . . 5.1.4 Single-Zone Mass Balance Model and Room CO Concentrations 5.1.5 Field Testing, Laboratory Research, and Karg Field Protocol Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.5.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.5.2 Range Top Burners, Field Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.5.3 Range Top Burners, Laboratory Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.5.4 Oven Bake Burners, Field Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Karg Field Protocol for Measuring Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2 Visual Inspection and Customer Education . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2.1 Range Top Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2.2 Oven Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.3 Measurement of Emissions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.3.1 Safety During Measurement of Emissions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.3.2 Preparation for Burner Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.3.3 Range Top Burner Testing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
100 102 102 103 106 108 108 109 112 115 122 122 122 122 123 124 124 124 125 99
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 99 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
100
5.2.3.4 Oven Bake Burner Testing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.3.5 Burner or Range Failure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Acknowledgment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
125 126 126 127 127
5.1 INTRODUCTION Indoor air quality studies and carbon monoxide (CO) emissions testing from combustion appliances have pointed to a number of factors affecting indoor CO levels: source and source-use characteristics, building features, ventilation rates, air mixing within and between rooms, the existence and effectiveness of contaminant removal systems, and outdoor concentrations.1 Gas ranges are used by a significant percentage of the population and, as an unvented combustion appliance, can contribute to hazardous concentrations of CO in indoor air when they malfunction or are misused. The U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) estimates that 130 people died in 2001 from nonfire, nonauto related CO poisonings; 75 of these deaths were attributed to heating systems and 10 to gas ranges/ovens.2 From 1990 to 2001 the CPSC estimated between 6 and 14 people died each year from CO emitted from gas ranges/ovens.2−5 Data for the years 1994–1998 show an additional 600–900 per year suffered nonfatal poisonings.3 It is obvious from these data that gas ranges/ovens can malfunction and emit hazardous levels of CO. To reduce injuries and deaths from CO poisonings, gas range top burners and ovens should be tested regularly and maintained properly. Testing combustion appliances for CO emissions during servicing or home weatherization is not currently a standardized practice in the United States, although the low-cost electronic combustion analyzers available today make it easier to test CO emissions in the field. The lack of standard field testing procedures for measuring CO emissions, the uncertainty of the accuracy of field measurements, and the dearth of technicians trained to consider the complex nature of CO diagnostics have led to widely variable emission measurement protocols or to a total lack of field testing.6−10 Heating systems are more likely than gas cooking appliances to receive regular servicing.5 Most natural gas utilities recommend servicing of gas heating systems every 1–3 years. Gas ranges/ovens are seldom, if ever, serviced by a trained technician. Tilkalky suggested: “. . . routine service adjustments on the 10 range set resulted in statistically significant decreases in CO and NO2 following servicing. This finding implies that some servicing of the gas range may be desirable and have an impact on indoor levels of NO2 and CO, and should be investigated further on a larger data set to determine if this initial indication holds true for a larger population.”6 Furthermore, if a homeowner desires servicing of a cooking appliance, anecdotal reports suggest that they might have difficulty finding a trained and willing technician.11,12 From 1995 to 1998 the administrative office for the Ohio low-income weatherization program, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), conducted a survey of the 50 state and District of Columbia low-income weatherization programs to determine the CO emission testing methods used by these programs on all combustion
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 100 — #2
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
101
appliance types. Many of the questions used on these Ohio surveys were related to gas range tops and ovens. Tables 5.1 and 5.2 include oven and range top data from the 1998 Ohio survey.13 The wide variation and arbitrary nature of these testing methods was alarming. This lack of consistency among testing methods within this DOE program demonstrated the need for a standardized CO emissions testing protocol for technicians in the field. In addition, there were other reasons to develop a field protocol,
TABLE 5.1 Gas Range Top Burner Testing Data from Ohio Survey of carbon monoxide Protocols, 51 State Low-Income Weatherization Programs, 199813 Do you have a CO emissions protocol? n = 51 Pan on burner for test? n = 31 Sampling probe height above burner (inches)? n = 28 Highest acceptable CO reading (ppm)? n = 26
Burner warm up time before test (minutes)? n = 25
Yes = 37
No = 14
Yes = 4 Range = 6–36, Mean = 13.8, SD = 8.2, Median = 12, Favored = 12
No = 27
As-measured, n = 25 Range = 9–300 Mean = 58 SD = 62 Median = 50 Favored = 100
Air-free, n = 1 Value = 100
Range = 0.25–20, Mean = 5.4, SD = 3.5, Median = 5, Favored = 5
TABLE 5.2 Gas Oven Testing Data from Ohio Survey of CO Protocols, 51 State LowIncome Weatherization Programs, 199813 Do you have a CO emissions protocol? n = 51 Oven door open or closed? n = 36 Oven control on broil or bake? n = 42 Highest acceptable CO reading (ppm)? n = 32
Burner warm up time before test? n = 34
Yes = 37 Open = 10 Broil = 19 As-measured, n = 28 Range = 9–400 Mean = 110 SD = 103 Median = 100 Favored = 50 and 100
No = 14 Closed = 26 Bake = 23 Air-free, n = 4 Range = 35–400 Mean = 158 SD = 164 Median = 100 Favored = 100 Range = “at startup” to “steady-state”, Favored = 5 or 10 min
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 101 — #3
102
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
including (1) the use of gas ovens/ranges was widespread, (2) these appliances were often used as space-heating devices dwellings were becoming tighter, and (3) gas ranges and ovens were not regularly cleaned and tuned.14 The author was asked by the U.S. DOE’s Low-Income Weatherization Programs of the Chicago Region to develop the Field Protocol for Gas Range Carbon Monoxide Emissions Testing in 2001, hereafter referred to as the Karg Field Protocol.15,16
5.1.1 OBJECTIVES OF KARG FIELD PROTOCOL DEVELOPMENT The primary objective of developing the Karg Field Protocol was to identify range top and oven burners that are high emitters of CO. As residences are made tighter to save energy, a given CO emission for a gas range can become more hazardous to the occupants. This is discussed in Section 5.1.4 with the use of the single-zone mass balance model. Of course, the possibility of an increased hazard to occupants is a concern to the management and technicians working with weatherization programs. Secondly, the Karg Field Protocol was developed to bring standardization to range testing among 51 DOE low-income weatherization programs. The Ohio survey of emissions testing methods clearly demonstrated this need and made it obvious that there was no existing consensus. The final objective was to minimize arbitrary or biased evaluation by field technicians.
5.1.2 ANSI STANDARD Z21.1-1993, HOUSEHOLD COOKING GAS APPLIANCES Two important questions had to be answered while developing the Karg Field Protocol: What basis should be used to develop the threshold level of CO emissions at burners to ensure an acceptable ambient level for the occupants of a residence? Second, at what time after burner start-up should readings be recorded and what method of measurement should be used to accurately reflect the long-term CO emissions and thus, the potential hazard of a burner’s emissions to occupants. This second question is discussed in Section 5.1.5.4. Manufacturers of gas ranges must comply with American National Standards Institute document Household Cooking Gas Appliances (ANSI Z21.1, 1993).17 This standard states “An appliance shall not produce a concentration of CO in excess of 0.08% (800 ppm) in an air-free sample of the flue gases when the appliance is tested in a room having approximately a normal oxygen supply.”17 The test procedure required by this standard is lengthy, but simply stated: containers filled with five pounds of water are placed on each of the four range top burners. All the range top burners and the oven burner are started simultaneously. After 5 min of operation, the CO air-free is measured in a collection hood above the range. This air-free concentration must be 800 ppm or less. In 1996, the Gas Research Institute published a topical report entitled Critique of ANSI.Z21.1 Standard for CO Emissions from Gas-Fired Ovens and Ranges.8 This Battelle Laboratory appraisal of the 800 ppm emission level, originally set in 1925, found “The underlying basis for and allowable limit set by the original
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 102 — #4
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
103
CO standard were valid and conservative in 1925, and remain so today. . .”8 The report continues with “Gas ovens/ranges do not pose a public safety or health threat with regard to CO emissions, a performance characteristic that can be reliably validated either in the lab, factory, or field by using the current Z21.1 measurement protocol, and its specified limit of 800 ppm CO, O2 -free.”8 Although not all researchers agree with this conclusion,10 the gas range Karg Field Protocol used this American National Standards Institute (ANSI) level of 800 ppm CO air-free as the basis for the development of CO emission thresholds. It would have been problematic to select a basis for the Karg Field Protocol other than ANSI Z21.1, since it is the current standard by which manufacturers design and build gas ranges and ovens. A field protocol based on values more or less stringent than ANSI Z21.1 would have limited credibility within the industry and would have compromised field technicians. Therefore the Karg Field Protocol was designed to determine if a gas range complies with ANSI Z21.1.
5.1.3 AS-MEASURED AND AIR-FREE CARBON MONOXIDE MEASUREMENT Gas ranges are probably the most common unvented gas appliances in use in North America. Because they are unvented, they have the potential of contributing to unacceptable ambient indoor levels of CO. Fortunately, in most residential situations, they are not operated long enough to adversely affect occupants. However, there are cases where gas oven/ranges can emit enough CO to cause health hazards or trigger CO alarms.18 Examples include: (1) user operation of a gas oven/range as a spaceheating appliance;14 (2) user alteration of the oven, such as lining the oven bottom with aluminum foil, inadvertently covering the secondary air ports;5,19 (3) malfunctioning equipment, including excessive gas pressure, closed air shutters, damaged orifices, and warped oven flame spreaders;16 and (4) baking a large roast or fowl. As the awareness of CO hazards increases, more technicians are using electronic instruments for measurement of CO emissions. These electronic devices are connected to a flexible plastic tube with a hollow metal probe at the other end. When measuring CO emissions from a vented appliance, the metal probe is inserted into a drilled hole in the metal flue pipe. A vacuum pump in the measurement device pulls a combustion gas sample through the metal probe and plastic tube, into the CO measurement cell, and finally expels the gases through an exhaust port. Measurement of CO emissions from a gas oven is performed with a similar technique, however, rather than inserting the probe into a drilled hole in a vent pipe, the metal probe is inserted into the oven-vent port that is typically located at the rear of the range top. There are two scales with which to measure CO: one is “as-measured” and the other is “air-free.” As-measured CO is determined from a sample of combustion gases with no regard for the amount of excess air (oxygen, O2 ) diluting the CO concentrations. Excess air is the amount of oxygen in the combustion gases in excess of the exact amount needed for perfect combustion. When combustion is perfect, just the right amounts of fuel and oxygen are supplied to the combustion process so that all the oxygen is utilized, a process called stochiometric combustion.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 103 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
104
The basic problem with the as-measured method is this: As the amount of excess air increases, the as-measured CO value falls for a given source strength of CO.20 In other words, the amount of excess air in an emissions sample can, by dilution, significantly decrease the as-measured value. This can cause a technician to mistakenly think that a hazardous burner is working properly. On the other hand, air-free measurement of CO takes account of the amount of excess air in an emissions sample, incorporating an adjustment to the as-measured CO ppm value, thus simulating air-free (oxygen-free) conditions in the sample. To do this, a reading of oxygen percentage is taken from the emissions sample along with the CO as-measured ppm. This can be done with an emissions meter having the capability of measuring CO and oxygen percentage. Most emissions meters that measure oxygen and CO as-measured have an integral electronic chip that calculates the air-free level from as-measured CO ppm and oxygen percentage. CO air-free and the firing rate of the burner can be used to determine the CO emission rate; CO as-measured cannot. The use of the CO air-free measurement is generally supported within the scientific community because it is a normalized value.21 Understanding as-measured and air-free CO measurements can be aided with an analogy. If four drops of blue food color are placed in a small glass of water and another four drops in a full pitcher of water, the water in the glass is darker shade of blue than the water in the pitcher. When a sample from each water vessel is analyzed, the concentration of food color in the pitcher is lower than in the glass; this is analogous to CO as-measured. On the other hand, CO air-free is analogous to calculating the number of drops of food color in each vessel by analyzing the concentration by measuring (similar to CO as-measured) and by performing calculations to determine the amount of food coloring in each vessel. Of course, the resulting calculation would reveal four drops of food color in each vessel, a determination that could not be made if only the concentration were measured. Finally, either of these vessels of water, when dumped into a 5 gallon container of water, will color the 5 gallons of water to nearly the same degree. Either of these equivalent equations can be used for determining air-free CO in an emissions sample with values for CO as-measured and oxygen percentage: 20.9 COAFppm = · COppm (5.1a) 20.9 − O2 or COAFppm =
COppm 1 − 4.78 (O2 )
(5.1b)
where COAFppm = Carbon monoxide, air-free ppm COppm = As-measured combustion gas carbon monoxide, ppm O2 = Oxygen in combustion gas, as a percentage From any combustion emission sample, the highest percentage of oxygen possible is 20.9%—that of the earth’s atmosphere—and the lowest is zero, resulting
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 104 — #6
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field (a)
105
(b)
CO as-measured = 43 ppm O2 = 20% CO air-free = 1000 ppm
Oven A
CO as-measured = 522 ppm O2 = 10% CO air-free = 1000 ppm
Oven B
FIGURE 5.1 (a) Oven A has more dilution air than (b) oven B, so the CO as-measured value is lower, but the CO air-free values are the same for each oven, so each oven will pollute the kitchen air to the same degree.
from stoichiometric or oxygen-starved combustion. Whereas the oxygen content of combustion gases from natural gas or propane furnaces or boilers is usually within a range of 4.0–10.0%, the percentage of oxygen for a natural gas or propane range top burner or oven is much higher, normally within a range of 13.6–20.1% and averaging about 19.8%.16 This higher range of oxygen in the combustion gases leads to more diluted and lower as-measured readings. The two ovens pictured in Figure 5.1 demonstrate the inherent problem with as-measured values. For Oven A, the CO as-measured level is 43 ppm; safe by some standards. For Oven B, the CO as-measured level is 522 ppm; considered unsafe by most standards. However, each oven is emitting the same level of CO air-free—1000 ppm, which is unsafe by all standards. (Refer to Equation 5.1a for these calculations.) In other words, the source strength of CO from each oven as indicated by the CO air-free measurement is the same; each oven will lead to the same ambient level of CO in the kitchen air. A technician might pass Oven A and fail Oven B, not understanding that each is contributing equally to hazardous levels of ambient indoor CO. Measuring CO air-free gives the technician a better idea of the impact the CO emissions has on indoor air concentrations. As indicated above, the higher the percentage of oxygen in the combustion gases, the lower the CO as-measured readings will be. If excess air is zero, as-measured and air-free measurements will be equal. As excess air increases, CO as-measured readings decrease, but CO air-free readings do not change. The high excess air percentages for gas ovens and range top burners increases the importance of taking air-free measurements, because the high excess air can significantly lower as-measured readings, thus masking the true CO source strength. It is common to find an oxygen content of 19.8% in range top burner combustion gases. If this value is plugged into Equation 5.1a, the resulting CO air-free level
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 105 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
106
is 20 times the as-measured value. This is a rough general guideline relating CO as-measured to CO air-free values for gas range top burners.
5.1.4 SINGLE-ZONE MASS BALANCE MODEL AND ROOM CO CONCENTRATIONS Vented appliances are only a hazard when they spill or backdraft. On the other hand, gas ranges vent into the living space, so it is important to understand the relationship between the source strength of CO emissions and the resulting concentrations of CO in the ambient indoor air. The single-zone mass balance model equation is helpful for demonstrating this relationship. COppm =
COAFppm · Vg · Gr · 1 − (1/2.713ACHt ) ACH · v
(5.2)
where COppm = As-measured indoor ambient carbon monoxide, ppm COAFppm = Air-free carbon monoxide, ppm Vg = ft 3 of flue gas per ft3 of fuel gas (8.5 ft3 for natural gas, 21.8 ft3 for propane) Gr = Gas flow rate, in ft3 /h = input rate (Btu/h) / heat value of fuel (Btu/ft3 ) —an average input rate for an oven is 18,000 Btu/h, for a range-top burner 9,000 Btu/h —an average heat value for natural gas is 1000 Btu/ft3 , for propane 2500 Btu/ft3 2.713 = Napierian logarithmic base ACH = Number of natural air changes per hour of room or house t = Time interval, hours v = Volume of room or house, ft3 For example, if a natural gas range with a total input rate of 54,000 Btu/h is emitting CO air-free at a constant rate of 800 ppm in a house of 8000 ft3 having an air exchange rate per hour (ACH) of 1.5, the ambient indoor CO concentration will be 29 ppm after 2 h (Refer to Equation 5.3). The rate of 54,000 Btu/h is the sum of the input of four range top burners and the oven operating at the same time, a possibility if a user were operating the gas range as a space heater. 800AFppm · 8.5 · 54 · 1 − (1/2.7130.5·2 ) = 1.5 · 8000
COppm
COppm =29
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 106 — #8
(5.3)
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
107
This assumes the ambient CO is evenly dispersed throughout the house. In reality, the concentrations are likely to be higher in the kitchen than in remote sections of the living space. If the structure is tightened, reducing the ACH from 1.5 to 0.5, the ambient indoor CO level will increase. As shown in the Equation 5.4, at the end of the 2-h period the average ambient CO concentration will be 58 ppm, rather than 29 ppm. At the end of 4 h, the room concentration will be 80 ppm. 800AFppm · 8.5 · 54 · 1 − (1/2.7130.5·2 ) = 0.5 · 8000
COppm
(5.4)
COppm =58 It is clear that tightening the house (lowering the ACH) without also lowering range CO emissions or operating a vented range hood during range operation can create a more hazardous indoor condition. This has important implications for the weatherization of residential buildings. Figure 5.2 shows the above examples along with two other house leakage rates— 0.35 to 2.0 ACH. Notice that as the leakage rate decreases the indoor levels of CO increase and the number of hours before reaching a stabilized level increases. For example, at 2.0 ACH the stabilized level of 23 ppm is reached after 2 h. In contrast, at 0.5 ACH the stabilized level of 91 ppm is reached after 10 h. This situation might occur if occupants were operating all the burners for space heating with the oven door
140.00 0.35 ACH Ambient CO level, ppm
120.00 100.00
0.5 ACH
0.35 ACH 0.5 ACH 1.0 ACH 2.0 ACH
80.00 60.00
1.0 ACH
40.00 2.0 ACH 20.00 0.00 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Hours of CO production, 800 ppm air-free
FIGURE 5.2 Room ambient CO concentrations at various house leakage rates over 10-h period. CO production is at a constant rate of 800 ppm air-free from a total burner input of 54,000 Btu/h in an open-plan house of 8,000 ft3 .
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 107 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
108
open, thus the duty cycle of the oven would be 100% because the oven thermostat would never be satisfied. Field measurements of 18 gas ovens under the author’s direction in 2001 resulted in 8 of these tested units emitting in excess of 800 ppm CO air-free after 15 min of operation. Although the average gas oven has a firing rate of approximately 18,000 Btu/h—only one-third the value of 54,000 Btu/h input rate used in the total range input rate above—these failed ovens emitting in excess of the 800 ppm air-free CO emissions could cause hazardous ambient CO levels if one of these ovens were used to bake a large turkey or as a space heater. One notable oven emitted CO at a rate of 2270 ppm air-free. In the same example house as above, with a 0.35 ACH and the oven operating at 18,000 Btu/h, this CO emission level would result in an ambient CO of 62 ppm after 2 h and 93 ppm after 4 h. Other field and laboratory studies have revealed that lining the bottom of an oven with aluminum foil to catch spills can lead to higher CO emissions if the foil obstructs the secondary air openings at the oven bottom, as noted in the U.S. CPSC testing.5 This practice interrupts the oven venting path and becomes even more hazardous if the oven is operated with its door open.5 “The worst case situation of a consumer using a gas oven as a space heater with an aluminum foil, protective liner, produced the highest CO emission rates. These high emission rates can push CO ambient air concentrations to dangerous levels.”5
5.1.5 FIELD TESTING, LABORATORY RESEARCH, AND KARG FIELD PROTOCOL DEVELOPMENT The Karg Field Protocol for Gas Range Carbon Monoxide Emissions Testing was completed by the author in 2001. Funding and support for this protocol research and development was provide primarily by the U.S. DOE and the Chicago Region low-income weatherization programs of Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Ohio, and Wisconsin. Funding and support for laboratory work was provided by the Gas Research Institute of Des Plaines, Illinois, through GARD Analytics of Park Ridge, Illinois and WEC Consulting of Potomac, Maryland. A group of technical advisors was assembled for the project that included college faculty, scientists from government organizations, indoor air quality experts, technical consultants, and private laboratories. Tim Lenahan of the Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency was the contract manager for the project. 5.1.5.1 Introduction At the foundation of the development of this Karg Field Protocol was research in the field and laboratory. Eighteen oven bake burners, and 81 range top burners were tested in the mid-coast Maine area, and 19 range top burner tests were done at the Gas Research Institute laboratory facility. Of the 21 oven bake burners tested, 4 were natural gas and 17 were propane (LPG). All 21 of the gas ranges tested in the field were in primary residences or summer homes. Laboratory range top burner testing was done over a 3-day period to determine the best method for measuring range top burner CO emissions. No oven testing was done at the laboratory.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 108 — #10
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
109
Field testing required approximately 3 h in each house. During emissions testing, the houses were closed up with all windows and exterior doors shut. Range hood fans and other exhaust fans in the houses were not operated during the testing, unless ambient CO levels reached 35 ppm. All test equipment was calibrated with CO span gas at the beginning and end of each house test regimen. After each burner test the instrument was rinsed for 1–2 min. All oven emissions testing was done with two test instruments inserted into the oven vent at the back of the range top. During each 30-min oven test, these instruments were checked for correspondence. The oldest range tested had been in service 53 years; the newest only 1 year. Ten of the ranges had standing pilots and eleven had spark ignitions. Gas pressure was measured in ten of the ranges. Natural gas measured in three ranges was between 4 and 5 in. of water column and propane gas pressure measured in eight ranges was between 7 and 12 in. of water column. The actual firing rate of each burner was not measured, but label firing rates were recorded for 16 ranges. The mean and median range top burner label firing rate were 8,563 and 9,000 Btu/h and the mean and median oven bake burner label firing rate were 17,677 and 18,000 Btu/h. Ambient CO levels were continuously monitored during the field testing for the safety of house occupants and the field analyst. After range top burner testing, the highest ambient CO level recorded was 7 ppm; all other readings were zero. After oven bake burner testing, the highest level was CO level recorded was 78 ppm and the lowest was zero. The mean, median, and standard deviation were 7.8 ppm, 1.5 ppm, and 19.21 ppm for 16 field tests for which this information was recorded. Although the tested ranges were not adjusted after the initial emissions test and then tested again, other research has found evidence that adjustment of a gas range by a knowledgeable technician can lower CO emissions.6 Ranges should be cleaned, tested for CO emissions, and adjusted, if necessary. Anecdotal evidence suggests that gas ranges are seldom adjusted and rarely tested for CO emissions. 5.1.5.2 Range Top Burners, Field Testing Range top burner emission rates are affected by disruption of the burner flame. Air currents and flame impingement greatly affect CO output. In addition, sampling location also affects measured CO and oxygen concentrations. To reduce variability and increase correspondence between measured CO output and actual CO output, a number of devices and methods have been devised. Range top burner testing in the field was done using five different devices and methods to determine which method was the most uniform, repeatable, and best simulated actual burner use in a home. These devices and methods include (1) the CO Hot Pot™ (Figure 5.3), (2) a device similar to the CO Hot Pot™, but with a stainless steel kettle within the cylinder, (3) a device similar to the CO Hot Pot™, but with no bowl or water kettle within the cylinder, (4) a free-standing aluminum kettle on the burner, and (5) testing the burner CO emissions over an open burner with no special device. The first of three devices were designed and fabricated by the author to introduce standardization and increase the accuracy of field testing. The last two methods were found to be in common use
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 109 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
110
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 5.3 CO Hot Pot™ for measuring CO emissions from range top burners. Notice the stainless steel bowl at the bottom of the 8-in. diameter by 12-in. high cylinder. (a) Front view and (b) Top view of the CO Hot Pot™.
for testing range top burners by technicians working in the U.S. DOE low-income weatherization program.13 The CO Hot Pot™ was used on each range top burner for a five-minute test. This simple device (Figure 5.3) is an 8-in. round by 12-in. high galvanized sheet metal cylinder with a 6-in. round stainless steel bowl fastened concentrically at the cylinder’s bottom.22 This bowl is intended to simulate a pot or pan on the range burner. The Y-shaped brace at the top of the cylinder strengthens the top of the cylinder and supports an eye-bolt that holds the tip of the electronic instrument probe in place after it is inserted through a hole drilled in the side of the cylinder. A metal handle fastened to the other side of the cylinder facilitates easy placement of the cylinder on the range top burner grate. The cylinder contains the emissions and protects the combustion from lateral drafts that can significantly increase CO emissions as a result of flame impingement. This device was also used during range top burner testing in the Gas Research Institute laboratory. A second device that was field and laboratory tested was a cylinder similar to the CO Hot Pot™, but with a stainless steel water kettle in the place of the bowl. The spout of this kettle passed through a snug opening in the cylinder so that evaporating water from the kettle could escape without affecting the emissions readings taken inside the cylinder just above the kettle. This device had the same Y-brace and eye-bolt to hold the instrument probe. The kettle was always filled with four pounds of 60◦ F water just before a test. The third device tested was an open cylinder that was also used for range top burner testing, a replica of the CO Hot Pot™, but without the stainless steel bowl at the bottom. In addition to these three devices, the fourth method tested in the field and laboratory was a free-standing aluminum water kettle, without a cylinder around it, that was used on each range top burner. The size of this water kettle was similar to the stainless steel one housed in a cylinder. This aluminum kettle was always filled with four pounds of 60◦ F water before a test. Finally, the fifth method tested was the CO instrument probe held at a precise position over the open flame of the range top burner; no cylindrical device or water kettle.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 110 — #12
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
Left front range top burner, unit10 600
30
500
25
400
20
300
15
200
10
100
5
0
CO as-measured (ppm)
CO air-free ppm CO as-measured ppm 35
700 CO air-free (ppm)
111
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
Time after startup (minutes)
FIGURE 5.4 A typical emission profile of a 5-min range top burner test with CO Hot Pot™ showing CO as-measured and air-free ppm.
When each of these devices and methods were used on a range top burner, the end of the instrument probe was always positioned exactly ten inches above the top of the burner grate. Each test was conducted for 5 min while emissions at the burner were monitored and recorded. All burner measurements for CO as-measured, CO air-free, oxygen (O2 ) percentage, and temperature were logged every 0.25 min and recorded to a computer spreadsheet for analysis. Range top burner testing was always performed before oven testing to prevent the oven from preheating the range top area. Figure 5.4 shows typical profiles of CO as-measured and air-free ppm using the CO Hot Pot™ for a 5-min test. It was common for the emissions to peak within the first 2 min and then begin to fall as the burner parts warm up and steady state is reached. Range top burner emissions are less problematic to measure than oven emissions because the burner does not turn on and off (duty cycle) in order to hold a constant temperature. Notice that the CO air-free and as-measured emissions track each other in parallel, although air-free is approximately 17–20 times greater than as-measured. This is typical. The parallel characteristic of these two measurements is a result of a fairly consistent percentage of oxygen in the emission gases. Of the 81 range top burners tested during the field research, only 1 failed the Karg Field Protocol threshold of 35 ppm CO as-measured, using the CO Hot Pot™ at 5 min. This failed burner had an emissions rate of 38 ppm CO as-measured and 882 ppm CO air-free (20% oxygen). Oxygen percentages were within a fairly narrow range when using the CO Hot Pot™—between 17.9 and 20.8, with a mean of 19.8. Oxygen percentages this high can significantly affect the relationship between CO as-measured and air-free values. For example, for the failed range top burner mentioned above, the multiplier to get from CO as-measured to CO air-free is 23.2 (see Equations 5.1a and 5.1b). The high oxygen levels typically found in emissions from gas range top and oven burners lead to reduced levels of certainty when taking measurements in the field. Although one study by the Gas Research Institute found “The data sets reveal mean CO emissions on the low setting to be much larger than the values obtained
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 111 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
112
when the burners were set on high or medium,”6 the author’s testing in the field and the laboratory was done with the range burner setting on high. The highest setting was selected for the Karg Field Protocol because this setting; (1) most closely matches the Btu/h rating on the range name plate; (2) is the easiest setting for the technician to find; and (3) is the only repeatable setting on most range top burners, allowing the technician to retest at the same setting—Btu/h firing rate—after a burner is adjusted. 5.1.5.3 Range Top Burners, Laboratory Testing Laboratory chamber testing was done over a 3-day period at the Gas Research Institute facility to determine the best method of measuring CO emissions from range top burners. The CO Hot Pot™ and four other methods—all described in the previous section—were tested to determine which of the five methods would best predict the ambient emission CO levels in the test chamber. The CO Hot Pot™ was tested seven different times; the four other methods were each tested three times. The CO Hot Pot™ was tested more often because by the third day of testing, it already showed evidence of being the most promising of the five methods. During the chamber testing of range top burners, readings of CO as-measured, CO air-free, and oxygen were recorded with hand-held equipment at the burner with each of the five methods (devices) while the chamber ambient CO concentrations were recorded with stationary laboratory equipment. Both burner and chamber emissions were recorded every 0.25 min during the test periods. The equipment was set up on a range burner in the chamber, the technician left the chamber, the burner and emissions recording equipment was then activated from outside of the chamber. During most of the tests, a small fan was operating on the floor of the chamber to help mix emissions with the chamber air; care was taken to ensure air did not flow across the range top. The burner was operated for 30 min and then turned off from outside the chamber. The decay of the emissions was measured for another 15 min so that the rate of air changes per hour within the chamber could be calculated after each 30-min emissions test. For most of the tests, the chamber was then purged with an exhaust fan operating for 15 min within the chamber before the next test began. All tests were performed with the burners at the highest setting. (See Figure 5.5) The burner input rate is usually printed on the range nameplate for both natural gas and propane fuels. ANSI Standard Z21.1-1993 for manufacturers states “When operated for 5 min, starting with all parts of the appliance at room temperature, the burner adjustment shall be within + 5% of the capacities specified (on the nameplate).”17 Metering gas consumption during laboratory testing for this study showed that the metered consumption in Btu/h of five range top burners on two ranges varied from rated consumption by +15% to –29%. The metered burner consumption closest to rated consumption was –12%. These variations were significantly greater than the 5% required by the ANSI Standard. More field research is needed to determine the typical variation between nominal nameplate ratings and actual burner Btu/h. Figure 5.6 shows the chamber concentrations of CO during three tests using the CO Hot Pot™ over the 30-min test, the 15-min decay, and the 15-min purge. At the end of the 30-min test, the chamber concentrations were within less than 1 ppm of CO for the three tests on the same burner.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 112 — #14
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
113
FIGURE 5.5 Chamber testing with CO Hot Pot™ and Testo instrument sending emissions data directly to a computer outside the chamber. Notice the 12-in. square opening in the wall at the upper right and the floor fan to spread combustion emissions within chamber. Photo was taken through a sealed glass observation port.
10
Test 3, Range C Test 10, Range C
9
Test 15, Range C
Burner turned off
Decay allowed to continue without purging chamber
CO as-measured (ppm)
8 7 6 5
Chamber purged 4 3 2 1
0
15
30 Time after startup (minutes)
45
FIGURE 5.6 Test chamber CO concentrations for three range top burner tests using CO Hot Pot™. See Figure 5.7 for corresponding burner CO emission rates.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 113 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
114
Test3, Range C, CO air-free Test10, Range C, CO air-free Test15, Range C, CO air-free
350
Test15, Range C, CO as-measured
50
CO air-free (ppm)
250 40 200 30 150
CO as-measured ppm (scale at rightaxis)
20 100
CO as-measured (ppm)
CO air-free ppm (scale at left axis)
300
60
Test3, Range C, CO as-measured Test10, Range C, CO as-measured
10
50 Initial burner warmup
0
0 2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
30
Time after startup (minutes)
FIGURE 5.7 Burner CO emission rates for three range top burner tests using CO Hot Pot™. See Figure 5.6 for corresponding test chamber concentration.
Figure 5.7 shows the corresponding CO emissions measured at the burner for these three 30-min tests. At the end of the three tests, the CO as-measured values were 21, 21, and 19 ppm and the CO air-free values were 231, 231, and 199 ppm. At 6 min after burner startup, the test time selected for the Karg Field Protocol, the CO as-measured values for the three tests were 15, 14, and 10 ppm and the CO air-free values were 261, 225, and 161 ppm. The higher chamber CO concentrations and emission rate at the burner for test 3 shown in Figures 5.6 and 5.7 might have resulted from the CO Hot Pot™ being positioned slightly off center over the burner (laboratory notes and a photograph support this misalignment), although further tests were not conducted to determine if an off-center position over the burner would affect emissions. After field and laboratory testing, the CO Hot Pot™ was selected over the other four test methods for a number of reasons. 1. The cylinder of this device protects the CO emissions testing from the unpredictable affect of lateral air movement, making testing in the field more consistent and repeatable. During a test in the laboratory chamber with the free-standing water kettle, the chamber air conditioner inadvertently turned on, blowing air across the range top and causing the ambient CO concentration in the chamber to rise to just under 15 ppm. Similar tests with this free-standing water kettle on the same burner without the affect of the air conditioner fan resulted in a chamber CO just above 3 ppm. This minor laboratory accident demonstrated the importance of preventing air flow across burners during emissions measurement and supports the use of the cylindrical protective housing of the CO
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 114 — #16
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
115
Hot Pot™. Of course, emissions testing with the instrument probe merely held above an oven flame is subject to the same, if not more, variability from lateral air movement than when using a free-standing water kettle. 2. Burner emissions measurements with the CO Hot Pot™ were found to level off to steady-state conditions 5–6 min after burner startup in almost all tests in the laboratory and field. The other four methods were less consistent in performance. 3. Some of the other measurement methods where either too complicated to be practical in the field, or they demonstrated design flaws. The methods not using a cylindrical housing made the emissions testing subject to more error resulting from lateral drafts, as described above. The cylinder with a water kettle inside and the free-standing water kettle required filling with water and yielded variable results because of the changing water temperature. Finally, the open cylinder with no bowl or water kettle concentrically fastened at the bottom of the cylinder created a strong enough draft during some tests to cause the flames to lift off the burner, resulting in artificially high emissions readings. 4. The oxygen percentages in the emission gases when using the CO Hot Pot™ were usually close to 19.85. The field testing mean was 19.84% and the laboratory testing mean was 19.3. This rather tight range for oxygen percentage allowed the adoption of a relatively simple method for the Karg Field Protocol range top burner testing, using the CO Hot Pot™ for CO asmeasured readings rather than the more complex CO air-free measurement. The Karg Field Protocol calls for CO as-measured emissions measured with the CO Hot Pot™ of 35 ppm or less. For an oxygen percentage of 19.85%, this equates to a CO air-free threshold of just less than 700 ppm, 100 ppm less than the ANSI Standard Z21.1 level of 800 CO air-free ppm to which manufacturers must adhere. The ANSI Standard requires measurement at 5 min, whereas the Karg Field Protocol calls for measurement at 6 min. The author’s field and laboratory testing indicated that range top burner CO emissions measured with the CO Hot Pot™ are more likely to have settled into steady-state conditions at 6 min than at 5 min. The later emission measurement of the Karg Field Protocol is likely to yield results closer to the longer-term emissions of a range top burner than ANSI Standard test a 5 min. 5.1.5.4 Oven Bake Burners, Field Testing Oven testing was performed on bake burners only, even if a separate broil burner was installed and working in a tested oven. Oven testing was done at a setting of 350◦ F with the oven door closed, utensils removed from within and under the oven, and foil lining removed from the oven floor (none of the ovens floors were lined with foil when the field analyst arrived to test). Ovens were not cleaned before testing. Testing was done for thirty minutes while emissions at the oven burner and ambient kitchen air were monitored and recorded. All field measurements for CO
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 115 — #17
116
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
FIGURE 5.8 Redundant testing of CO emissions during field test. Two instrument probes are inserted into oven vent in a manner ensuring that room air will not dilute the sample.
as-measured, CO air-free, oxygen percentage, and temperature were logged very 0.25 min and recorded to a computer spreadsheet for analysis. The oven burner emissions were measured at the oven vent, which in all cases was at the back of the range top surface. Care was taken to measure emissions without the diluting affect of room air. Oven temperature was measured at the end of the emissions probe and with a separate oven thermometer placed in the oven. All emissions measurements were measured with two electronic instruments that were checked during the 30-min test period for correspondence. (See Figure 5.8) All instruments were calibrated before and after each test series at each site with 250 ppm CO calibration gas. Tikalsky et al. used 400◦ F for their field testing while Tsongas suggested a 350◦ F setting for his oven field protocol.6,23,24 The oven temperature setting used for the project field testing was 350◦ F and burner setting selected for the Karg Field Protocol was also 350◦ F. This temperature was selected because it is a common baking temperature and the oven requires less time to reach steady-state conditions than for a higher setting. The actual measured oven temperature at the end of the 30-min field tests for the 18 ovens ranged from 290◦ F to 375◦ F, with a mean of 347◦ F, a median of 340◦ F and a standard deviation of 20.7 F◦ . Separate broil burners were not included in the final protocol because it was thought that the additional time that would be required would not be worth the reduced risk to the range user. It was assumed that broil burners are not used as often as bake burners and, when they are used, they are not operated as long.25 Of the eighteen valid oven field tests that were conducted in 2001, ten passed the Karg Field Protocol and eight failed. The highest CO air-free ppm measured at the 15-min Karg Field Protocol mark was 1907, the lowest 244, the mean 932, the
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 116 — #18
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
117
Oven setting at 350°F 600
700 CO air-free ppm CO as-measured ppm
CO air-free (ppm)
600
500
O2 percent times 20 Temperature °F
500
400
400 300 300 200
200
100
100
0
0 2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
30
CO as-measured, temperature, and O2
median 769, and the standard deviation 588. Oven oxygen percentage ranged from a high of 20.9 to a low of 10.4 with a mean of 18.3. Two profiles for oven test data are shown in Figure 5.9 (oven number 15, which passed) and Figure 5.10 (oven number 11, which failed). Each figure shows CO air-free ppm (left Y-axis), CO as-measured ppm (right Y-axis), oxygen percentage times 20 (right Y-axis), temperature in ◦ F (right Y-axis), and time in minutes (X-axis). Notice in both figures how CO emissions peak just after start-up, then fall, and eventually settle into a steady-state, saw-tooth pattern as a result of the burner duty cycle. For each of these profiled field tests, the steady-state condition was reached approximately 11 min after startup. The longest time required to reach steady-state for the 18 oven field tests was 19.5 min, the shortest was just over 3 min, and the mean and median were 10. As a result of these observations, the timing for the oven bake burner CO emissions test for the Karg Field Protocol was set at 15 min from
Time from startup (min)
Oven setting at 350°F 3500
600
CO air-free ppm CO as-measured ppm
CO air-free (ppm)
3000
500
O2 percent times 20 Temperature °F
2500
400
2000 300 1500 200
1000
100
500 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
0 30
CO as-measured, temperature, and O2
FIGURE 5.9 Oven number 15 passed the developed oven bake burner Karg Field Protocol.
Timeafter startup, (min)
FIGURE 5.10 Oven number 11 failed the developed oven bake burner Karg Field Protocol.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 117 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
118
start-up or later. Only one of the 18 field tested ovens required more than 15 min to reach steady-state. As mentioned in Section 5.1.2, two important questions had to be answered before developing the Karg Field Protocol: First, what basis should be used to develop the threshold level of CO emissions at the burners to ensure an acceptable ambient level for the occupants of a residence? This is discussed in Section 5.1.2. Second, at what time after burner startup should readings be recorded and what method of measurement should be used to accurately reflect the long-term CO emissions and thus, the potential hazard of a burner’s emissions to occupants? The Karg Field Protocol time and method of measurement for ovens CO emissions was designed not only to reflect the ANSI Standard, but also to accurately predict the emission rate after the oven bake burner settled into a steady-state pattern.15 To gauge the level of accuracy, the emissions data for the eighteen ovens were used to compare the Karg Field Protocol method of measuring CO air-free ppm emissions at 15 min with the CO air-free emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min. The field testing process collected data every 0.25 min during a 30-min test of each oven. This analysis found that the oven Karg Field Protocol value had a coefficient of linear correlation to the CO air-free emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min of R = 0.95 and R2 = 0.9. (See Figure 5.11). In addition to the Karg Field Protocol, correlation was also checked with protocols developed by ANSI, Tsongas, and Building Performance Institute (BPI). Of the four, the Karg Field Protocol gave the highest correlation. As a result of designing the Karg Field Protocol to give close correspondence from CO air-free values averaged over 15–30 min, the protocol values averaged 102.4% of the longer term CO air-free emissions, whereas the ANSI protocol was found to be 71.6%. The Tsongas and BPI protocols could not be checked for this correspondence because they use a CO as-measured test method. These data for these four protocol comparisons to the author’s CO air-free values averaged over 15–30 min for 18 oven field tests are shown in Figure 5.12. These oven field data were also analyzed to determine the correlation between the CO air-free ppm emissions at 5 min and the CO air-free emissions averaged
CO air-free averaged from 15–30 min, ppm
Karg field protocol, oven measurement 2000 1500 R = 0.95 R2 = 0.90
1000 500 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Karg protocol, CO air-free at 15 min, ppm
FIGURE 5.11 Relationship in 18 tested ovens between Karg Field Protocol oven CO air-free measurement and CO air-free emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 118 — #20
FIGURE 5.12 Data for comparison of CO air-free emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min from 18 oven field tests by the author to 4 oven test protocols. Columns c, f, i, and k are from the author’s oven field test data measured according to the corresponding protocol. A brief description of each protocol CO measurement method is included in the last row.
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 119 — #21
119
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
CO air-free averaged from 15–30 min (ppm)
120
ANSI Z21.1 Protocol 2000 1500 R = 0.51 R2 = 0.26
1000 500 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
ANSI protocol, CO air-free at 5 minutes (ppm)
FIGURE 5.13 Relationship in 18 tested ovens between ANSI Z21.1 standard measurement of CO emissions at 5 min and CO air-free emissions averaged over 15–30 min.
from 15 to 30 min. This was done because the ANSI Standard Z21.1 with which gas range manufacturers must comply, requires CO emissions be measured at 5 min after startup; these emissions must be 800 ppm air-free or less.17 This analysis found that the 18 tested ovens at the 5-min ANSI Standard measurement requirement had a coefficient of linear correlation to the CO air-free emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min of R = 0.51 and R2 = 0.26. (Refer to Figure 5.13) These field data demonstrate that measuring CO air-free from a bake burner at 5 min after start-up is not a good predictor of longer-term CO air-free emissions and that it may underestimate steady-state, long-term emissions. This significant finding indicates that more research is needed to determine the match between the ANSI Standard method and actual field CO emissions from oven bake burners in the field. The oven field test data were analyzed to determine the comparability with two other published oven CO emission field protocols. The first, published in 1995 by Tsongas calls for the first CO as-measured ppm peak to be recorded after startup.23 If this peak is 100 ppm or greater at an oven temperature setting of 350◦ F, the oven fails the protocol. Of the 18 ovens tested in the field on 2001, only 2 passed this protocol with 70 and 39 CO as-measured ppm, with the average time for the first peak in CO as-measured emissions of 2.25 min. The Tsongas protocol was tested with the field data from the 18 ovens to determine how well it predicted the longer term oven emissions. (Results are illustrated in Figure 5.14) The Tsongas protocol did not correlate well with longer term CO air-free emissions. The Tsongas protocol CO as-measured value of 100 ppm appears to be significantly more stringent than the ANSI Z21.1 Standard. (Referring back to the oven emission profiles in Figures 5.9 and 5.10 will help demonstrate this poor correlation.) Finally, the oven field test data were analyzed to determine how well the BPI oven protocol predicts the longer term oven emissions.26 (Results are illustrated in Figure 5.15) The BPI protocol (being used across the U.S. by BPI certified technicians) calls for oven bake burner CO as-measured ppm testing at 5 min at the maximum oven temperature setting, short of broil. If CO as-measured emissions from ovens are from 100 to 300 ppm, or less, a CO alarm must be installed and a recommendation for oven service must be made to the customer. If CO oven emissions are more than 300 ppm, the unit must be serviced before any weatherization work is performed.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 120 — #22
CO air-free averaged from 15–30 min (ppm)
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
121
Tsongas oven measurement protocol 2000 1500 1000
R = 0.53 R2 = 0.28
500 0
0
200
400
600
800
1000 1200
1400
1600
Tsongas protocol, CO as-measured at first peak (ppm)
FIGURE 5.14 Relationship in 18 tested ovens between CO as-measured ppm emissions at the first peak after start-up and CO air-free emissions averaged over 15–30 min.
CO air-free averaged from 15–30 min (ppm)
BPI oven measurement protocol 2000 1500
R = 0.56 R2 = 0.31
1000 500 0
0
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
BPI Protocol, CO as-measured at 5 min (ppm)
FIGURE 5.15 Relationship in 18 tested ovens between CO as-measured ppm emissions at 5 min after start-up and CO air-free emissions averaged over 15–30 min.
Of the 18 ovens tested in the field in 2001, 13 passed this BPI protocol (300 ppm). Eight of these BPI passes also passed the Karg Field Protocol and five failed. Of five ovens that failed the BPI protocol, three failed the Karg Field Protocol and two passed. Although the 18 oven field tests were done at an oven setting of 350◦ F and the BPI protocol calls for the highest setting, the field test data at 5 min is valid. This is because at 5 min the oven set at 350◦ F is still moving toward a steady-state condition, just as it would be at a higher temperature setting. Of the four oven protocols compared with the field data of eighteen oven tests, the Karg Field Protocol appears to most accurately predict the averaged emissions from 15 to 30 min. There is no evidence to suggest that the steady-state, saw-tooth pattern of oven CO emissions over 15–30 min will significantly change after the 30-min mark, but because the author’s testing stopped at 30 min, he cannot demonstrate this. Because CO emissions from a gas range burner are seldom, if ever, hazardous unless the burner operates for a long period, this relationship between protocol readings and longer term emissions is important. Any protocol that does not correlate closely with longer term, steady-state emissions will not adequately reflect a CO hazard to occupants.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 121 — #23
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
122
5.2 KARG FIELD PROTOCOL FOR MEASURING CARBON MONOXIDE EMISSIONS FROM GAS RANGES 5.2.1 INTRODUCTION The purpose of this protocol is to guide the field analyst through a systematic procedure of gas range testing to determine whether a gas range burner is emitting unacceptable levels of CO. The burner limits for this protocol are 35 ppm CO as-measured for range top burners and 800 ppm CO air-free for oven bake burners. Oven broil burners are not required to be tested. This method covers residential grade floor-mounted gas ranges, drop-in range top burners, and built-in ovens only. If drop-in range top burners or built-in ovens are encountered, follow the appropriate sections of this protocol for these appliances. This protocol is not intended for use with (1) outdoor gas grills, (2) ovens in catalytic cleaning mode, (3) ovens vented into flues or chimneys, or (4) range/ovens with a downward vented exhaust fan while the fan is operating. This protocol is not intended to determine whether gas ranges operate acceptably during misuse, such as when a range is used for space heating. Accurately measuring CO emissions in the field is difficult due to the complex nature of combustion and dilution airflow patterns. Use of this protocol can increase the accuracy of measurements to, perhaps, +30%.8,10 This means that the protocol will sometimes result in false failures and false passes. Because there is a broad variety of gas ranges in the field, there is the possibility that range characteristics not addressed in this protocol will be encountered. Funding and support for this protocol research and development was provided in 2001 primarily by the U.S. DOE and the Chicago Region low-income weatherization programs of Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Ohio, and Wisconsin. Funding and support for laboratory work was provided by the Gas Research Institute of Des Plaines, Illinois, through GARD Analytics of Park Ridge, Illinois and WEC Consulting of Potomac, Maryland. Tim Lenahan of the Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency was the contract manager. This section of this chapter includes an abridged version of the Field Protocol and is not subject to the copyright of the publisher of this book.
5.2.2 VISUAL INSPECTION AND CUSTOMER EDUCATION 5.2.2.1 Range Top Inspection Inspect the range top burner area for cleanliness. If the burners or burner area are dirty enough to adversely affect the combustion process, inform the customer that the range should be cleaned to reduce the possibility of unacceptable emissions. Do not test for CO emissions until the problem is corrected. Inspect the burners for proper alignment and seating.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 122 — #24
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
123
All cooking vessel support grates should (1) be in place, (2) fit properly in the burner well, and (3) be in the configuration the manufacturer intended, with no broken parts. If any of the grates are missing or in unsatisfactory condition, the customer should not use the affected range burner until the substandard or missing grate is replaced. If a grate cannot be repaired or replaced, the decision whether to replace the range should be made. If the range top burners are ignited with a standing pilot light, verify that the pilot flame is present, is about 5/16 in length, and is soft blue in color (not yellow). 5.2.2.2 Oven Inspection Inspect the oven for cleanliness. If the burners or oven area are dirty enough to adversely affect the combustion process, inform the customer that the range should be cleaned to reduce the possibility of unacceptable emissions. Do not test for CO emissions until the problem is corrected. Check the oven for obstruction of the oven-floor vents. These vent holes must not be blocked by anything in the oven, such as aluminum foil, or anything stored below the oven. These vent openings must never be obstructed because they are a vital part of the oven combustion and venting systems. Check for air blockage at the bottom of the range and drawer and/or broiler compartment under the oven. Dust, lint, pet hair, rugs, or any other obstruction blocking free airflow to the oven bake burner must be removed. Check the oven bake-burner spreader plate (burner baffle). Most bake burners (the one at the bottom of the oven compartment) have a flame spreader plate just under the oven floor bottom and above the bake burner flame. A warped or detached spreader plate can result in flame impingement and quenching (cooling) of the gas flame, causing increased production of carbon monoxide. Many spreader plates are intentionally bent into curved or angular shapes, or dimpled, to add strength. Inspect carefully with a flashlight and inspection mirror to determine if the spreader plate has distorted from its original shape or has detached from the oven bottom. Ignite the bake burner to inspect the flame. The flame should not extend beyond the edge of the spreader plate. Also, inspect for carbon buildup on the spreader plate and the oven bottom. Any carbon build-up can be an indication of incomplete combustion caused by flame quenching or a fuel-rich gas mixture. If the range also has a broil burner at the top of the oven compartment, check its flame for proper size and color. If the oven bake burner is ignited with a standing pilot light, verify that the pilot flame is present, that it is about 5/16 in length, and is soft blue in color (not yellow). Inspect gas range installation for code compliance by referring to the latest edition of the National Fuel Gas Code (NFPA 54). Verify that the range is set up for the appropriate supply gas, either natural gas or propane (LPG). Although a mismatch between supply gas type and range set up is not a common occurrence, each range should be checked. Natural gas (methane) contains 1000 Btu/ft3 , while propane contains 2500 Btu/ft3 . Gas ranges using natural gas usually operate at a gas pressure of 3.5–5 in. of water, while propane operates
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 123 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
124
at 10–11 in. of water. Because of these characteristics, natural gas requires a larger orifice size than propane at each burner, and a lower gas pressure. If a range is set up for natural gas but has propane piped to it, it will be over-firing, probably creating unacceptable levels of CO. A gas range in this condition must not be used until the problem is corrected. Symptoms of this problem include noisy, yellow, and large flames rising above the burner support grates on the range top burners; carbon (smoke) emissions; or unacceptable carbon monoxide emissions. If a range is set up for propane but has natural gas piped to it, it will be under-firing. In this case, the customer might complain of the long period required to boil water or the extended time required for baking. This condition is usually not hazardous, but it should be corrected. If the flexible gas line connector can be inspected without moving the range, make sure the flexible connector is (1) not brass, (2) is not a two-piece connector, and (3) has no pre-1973 rings (in some cases, the date can be found on the flare nuts rather than the date rings). Do not move the range for the sole purpose of inspecting the flexible connector; this movement might crack or otherwise damage it. Check for gas leaks at the range top burner area, oven area, and any accessible gas lines with an appropriate combustible gas detector. Check for propane leaks below connections (propane falls) and for natural gas leaks above connections (natural gas rises). If any gas leaks are found, specify repair. Shut off the gas to the appliance and do not proceed with testing until the leak is repaired. If the gas range fails any of these items above (1) specify repair of the gas range or (2) specify replacement of the gas range, depending on the character of the problem. If the range does not fail, proceed, with the measurement of emissions.
5.2.3 MEASUREMENT OF EMISSIONS 5.2.3.1 Safety During Measurement of Emissions While performing the emissions testing, monitor CO concentrations in the kitchen. If indoor air concentrations rise above 35 ppm, shut down the burner(s), discontinue testing, and open windows and/or doors. Be cautious not to burn hands or other body parts on hot test equipment or the range. Also, be mindful not to damage test equipment by open flames or hot surfaces. Do not damage customer’s counters, floors, carpeting, or furniture with hot equipment or open flames. This protocol calls for range top burners to warm up for at least 6 min before recording emissions. Make sure that the open flame is not left unattended during this warm-up period. If the analyst wishes to attend to other tasks during the burner warm-up period, ask the customer to watch the burners during warm up. 5.2.3.2 Preparation for Burner Testing Always calibrate the emissions measurement instrument according the manufacturer’s recommendations. Before using the instrument, make sure that the most recent calibration is valid (check for the calibration label on the instrument). If the calibration
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 124 — #26
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
125
period has expired, calibrate the instrument before use. Zero the instrument according to the manufacturer’s recommendations before testing. 5.2.3.3 Range Top Burner Testing Test range top burners before testing the oven. Remove all objects from the range top. The range top burners are to be tested in order of right rear (RR), left rear (LR), right front (RF), and left front (LF). Test each range top burner with the CO Hot Pot™. This protocol with its limit of as-measured CO per burner is based on the use of the CO Hot Pot™, exactly as designed.22 The use of any other device or a variation of the CO Hot Pot™ is likely to yield different results. If room air from a fan or open window or door is blowing across the range top burners, ask the customer to turn off or redirect the fan, or close the window or door. The natural flow of combustion gases upward from the burner must not be disrupted during the emissions testing process. Center the CO Hot Pot™ on the burner grate. Prepare the emission measurement instrument for the test. Ignite the burner and turn to the highest setting. Start timing device. Insert the probe of the emission measurement device into the hole on the side of the CO Hot Pot™ and through to the center of the cylinder. At 6 min after ignition, watch the instrument CO readings for 2 min. Record high and low readings for this period. Average the high and low readings to get the 2-min average CO as-measured. The CO measured at the burner averaged over the 2 min must be 35 ppm or less, as-measured, using the CO Hot Pot™. Determine whether the burner passes or fails the limit. Test each of the top burners in the order specified above. 5.2.3.4 Oven Bake Burner Testing Test the oven bake burner only. If the oven has a separate broil burner, do not test it. Clear the oven of all pots, pans, or other objects. Clear area below oven of all objects. Leave oven shelves in place. If the vent holes on the oven bottom are obstructed with foil, catch pans, or anything else, ask the customer to remove the obstructions. Ignite the burner, with the temperature setting at 350◦ F. The oven burner may not ignite immediately; this is normal for some electronic ignition systems. Bake burners with standing pilots usually ignite faster. Start timing device. Insert the probe of the emission measurement instrument into the oven vent sleeve at the back of the range top. Make sure the open end of the instrument probe is fully inserted into the oven vent opening at its center. Do not allow dilution air to mix with the sampled combustion by-products. Ensure that grease or other build-up does not inadvertently block the instrument probe tip. After beginning the oven test, do not open the oven door. If the oven door is opened after the testing period begins, wait at least 5 min or to the end of the 15-min warm up time, whichever is longer, before taking emissions readings.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 125 — #27
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
126
It is not necessary to turn on the emissions measurement instrument at the beginning of the warm-up, but it must be ready to take readings after 15 min of oven warm-up time. After 15 min of burner warm up, watch the emission measurement instrument for the minimum and then maximum CO as-measured values. The corresponding CO air-free must be calculated and averaged for these minimum and maximum CO as-measured readings. The step-by-step details of measurement: After 15 min of warm up, watch for the minimum CO as-measured value (not the minimum CO air-free value). Record this minimum CO as-measured value and the corresponding oxygen percentage (if your instrument automatically calculates CO air-free, record this value at the minimum CO as-measured value). Continue to watch the instrument until you detect the next maximum CO as-measured value. Record this maximum value and the corresponding oxygen percentage (if your instrument automatically calculates CO air-free, record this value at the maximum CO as-measured value). Calculate the CO air-free emission rates for the minimum and maximum CO as-measured readings from Equation 5.1a (for natural gas and propane). Average the CO air-free emission rates for the minimum and maximum CO as-measured readings. Some emissions measurement instruments calculate CO air-free automatically. If this is the case, this equation need not be used. Averaged CO air-free must be 800 ppm or less, averaged from the CO air-free values corresponding to the CO as-measured minimum and maximum occurring after fifteen minutes of warm-up, with oven set to 350◦ F. Determine whether the burner passes or fails the limit. 5.2.3.5 Burner or Range Failure If a failed burner can be adjusted in a way that reduces the CO emissions to below those set by the levels of this protocol, then the range passes the protocol after the field analyst retests the range to ensure that the burner(s) now passes limits of the protocol. If the failed burner(s) cannot be tuned or replaced to pass the protocol levels or the gas range construction does not allow for adjustment or parts replacement, the gas range should be replaced.
5.3 CONCLUSIONS The Ohio surveys of the national weatherization program technicians demonstrated a significant lack of uniformity among gas range field testing protocols.13 This diversity of methods demonstrated disagreement about testing protocol and a dearth of understanding regarding reliable field test data and methods. Using the Karg Field Protocol for Gas Range Carbon Monoxide Emissions Testing developed by the author would increase accuracy and standardization and repeatability to field CO testing.15,16 The Karg Field Protocol demonstrates a fairly close correlation between field measurements of oven CO emissions and longer-term emissions averaged from
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 126 — #28
Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Gas Ranges and the Development of a Field
127
15 to 30 min. The 1996 Battelle study to determine the validity of the assumptions of the ANSI Standard Z21.1-1993, Household Cooking Gas Appliances8 did not examine the correlation of CO burner emissions at the 5-min mark of the ANSI test with the longer term oven emissions. The evidence from the author’s field testing suggests poor correlation between the data for ovens at the ANSI Z21.1 prescribed 5-min mark and the longer term, steady-state emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min. The author’s data suggests the longer term, steady-state emissions averaged from 15 to 30 min gives more representative results. This significant finding indicates that more research is needed to determine a valid oven testing method. The field research for the development of the Karg Field Protocol reveals that oven burners were more hazardous than range top burners. While just over 1% of the range top burners tested in the field failed the Karg Field Protocol, 40% of the over burners failed.15 Furthermore, during normal household use, oven burners are usually operated longer than range top burners, increasing the potential hazard of a high-emission oven burner. This increased oven failure rate in the test sample and longer run time for ovens indicates it is more important to field test oven burners than range top burners.
5.4 ACKNOWLEDGMENT I would like to thank Tom Greiner, Ph.D. for reviewing and editing this chapter.
References 1. Persily, A.K., Carbon Monoxide Dispersion in Residential Buildings: Literature Review and Technical Analysis, NISTIR 5906, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, October 1996. 2. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths Associated with the Use of Consumer Products: 2001 Annual Estimates, CPSC, Bethesda, MD, May, 2004. 3. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths and Injuries Associated with the Use of Consumer Products: Annual Estimates, CPSC, Bethesda, MD, June, 1999. 4. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths and Injuries Associated with the Use of Consumer Products: Annual Estimates, CPSC, Bethesda, MD, October, 2000. 5. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Summary of Carbon Monoxide Emissions Test Results of Gas Ranges with Self-Cleaning Ovens, Memorandum to Ronald Jordan from Dwayne Davis and Christopher Brown, February 6, 2001. 6. Tikalky, S. et al., Gas Range/Oven Emissions Impact Analysis, Gas Research Institute, Chicago, IL, December, 1987. 7. Reuther, J.J., Billick, I.H., Wiersma, S., Misconception, reality, and uncertainty regarding co-emissions from unvented gas appliances, paper given to Karg in 2001 by Billick. 8. Reuther, J.J., Critique of ANSI Z21.1 Standard for CO Emissions from Gas-Fired Ovens/Ranges, GRI-96/0270, September, 1996 for Gas Research Institute by Battelle, Columbus, OH, 1996.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 127 — #29
128
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 9. Greiner, T.H., The case of the CO leak: solving the mysteries of carbon monoxide exposures, Home Energy, 21–28, November/December 1997. 10. Greiner, T.H., Comments concerning carbon monoxide emissions from gas-fired ovens and ranges: with special reference to Battelle’s 1996 Critique of ANSI Z21.1, prepared for Affordable Comfort Conference, Chicago, IL, available from Iowa State University Extension, Ames, IA, 1998. 11. Andrews, T., Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency, personal communication, June 6, 2006. 12. Lenahan, T., Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency, personal communication, June 6, 2006. 13. Andrews, T., Survey Results of State Weatherization Programs Concerning Carbon Monoxide Standards and Testing for Heating and Cooking Appliances, 1998, Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency, Columbus, OH, 1998. 14. Heckerling, P.S. et al., Predictors of occult carbon monoxide poisoning in patients with headache and dizziness, Annals of Internal Medicine, 107, 174–176, 1987. 15. Karg, R.J., Field Protocol for Gas Range Carbon Monoxide Emissions Testing, Chicago Regional Diagnostics Working Group and U.S. Department of Energy, Washington, D.C., 2001. Unpublished. Available at www.karg.com/papers.htm. 16. Karg. R.J., CO testing for the real world, Home Energy, 30–33, January/February 2002. 17. American National Standards Institute, Household Cooking Gas Appliances, Standard Z21.1, American Gas Association, Cleveland, OH, 1993. 18. Greiner, T.H. and Schwab, C.V., Approaches to dealing with carbon monoxide in the living environment, Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, Penney, D.G., (ed.), CRC Press, New York, 2000, chap. 23. 19. Hedrick, R. and Billick, I., Gas Range/Oven Testing at the GRI Research House, slide presentation to GRI Industry Environmental Council, Rosemont, IL, March 15, 2000. 20. Karg, R.J., Air-free measurement of carbon monoxide emissions from gas ranges: analysis and suggested field procedure in Affordable Comfort ’98 Selected Readings, Madison, WI, May, 1998. 21. Reuther, J.J., Interlaboratory Program to Validate a Protocol for the Measurement of NO2 Emissions from Rangetop Burners, GRI-94/0458, December 1994 for Gas Research Institute by Battelle, Columbus, OH, 1994. 22. Karg, R.J., CO Hot Pot™ Assembly Instructions, www.karg.com/COhotpot.htm. 23. Tsongas, G., Carbon monoxide from ovens: a serious IAQ problem, Home Energy, 18–21, September/October 1995. 24. Tsongas, G., Field monitoring of elevated CO production from residential gas ovens, in Proceedings: Indoor Air Quality ’94, St. Louis, MO, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air Conditioning Engineers, Inc., Atlanta, GA, 1994. 25. Hedrick, R., personal communication, June 20, 2001. 26. Building Performance Institute (BPI), Technical Standards for Certified Building Analyst1, BPI, Malta, NY, 2005.
8417: “8417_c005” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 128 — #30
6
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents Involving Gas-Burning Appliances Michael Hanzlick
CONTENTS 6.1 6.2 6.3
6.4 6.5
6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.10 6.11
6.12 6.13
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Gas Appliance Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Venting System and Air for Combustion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.1 The Draft Diverter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.1.1 Safety Problems Associated with the Draft Diverter . . . Gas Appliance Safety Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gas Appliance Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.1 Household Cooking Gas Appliances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.2 Clothes Dryers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3 Space Heating Appliances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.1 Central Furnaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.2 Room Heaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.3 Wall Furnaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.4 Low-Pressure Boilers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.5 Water Heaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.6 Special Design Appliances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gas Appliance Certification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gas Appliance Installation Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . National Fuel Gas Code . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Manufacturers Installation Instructions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.9.1 Proper Fuel Input Adjustments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fuel Gases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Principles of Combustion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.11.1 Products of Complete Combustion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.11.2 Products of Incomplete Combustion. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CPSC Estimates of Carbon Monoxide Deaths . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Heating/Gas Appliance System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
130 130 131 132 133 134 135 135 135 135 135 136 136 136 137 137 138 139 139 139 140 140 143 143 144 145 145 129
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 129 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
130
6.14 Failure Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.15 Investigation of Root Cause . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.15.1 Initial Discovery and Investigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.15.2 Follow-Up Inspections and Investigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.15.3 Determination of Root Cause . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.15.4 Estimation of Ambient Carbon Monoxide Levels in Occupied Areas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.16 Case Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.16.1 Investigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.16.2 Failure Mode. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.16.3 Case Study Conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
146 148 149 149 151 151 151 152 153 153 155
6.1 INTRODUCTION The gas appliance industry is one of the oldest and most stable industries in the United States, having its origin in the early 1800s.1 The industry has prided itself on its record related to the safe and efficient operation of gas appliances and has consistently worked to improve the safety of gas appliances by incorporating design changes when appropriate. Of major concern in the industry is the production of carbon monoxide (CO) during appliance operation. CO is a colorless, odorless, highly toxic gas. While there are many sources for CO, it can be produced in gas burning appliances by the incomplete combustion (burning) of a carbon-based fuel, such as natural gas or propane. In the gas appliance industry, CO has been called the “silent killer” because its victims are normally unaware of any operational problems with the gas appliance or that they have been poisoned. Modern gas appliances, those manufactured within the last 50 years, are designed and safety certified to perform their intended function without producing dangerous levels of CO when installed, operated, and maintained in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. However, there are many key factors that are not controlled by the appliance manufacturer that can cause an otherwise safe appliance to begin to produce CO.
6.2 BASIC GAS APPLIANCE DESIGN The efficient and safe operation of a gas-fired appliance is dependent on a number of factors some of which are controlled by the overall design and construction of the appliance. Some of the most basic of these factors are (see Figure 6.1) • The proper amount of fuel must be mixed with the proper amount of oxygen and its temperature raised to the ignition point so that combustion (burning of the fuel to produce heat) takes place. • The actual mixing of the fuel and air takes place within the gas burner assembly contained within the appliance.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 130 — #2
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
Warm air plenum
131
Products of combustion mixed with dilution air exits to outside atmosphere
Vent system Warm air to heated area Draft diverter
Dilution air Enters at draft diverter relief opening
Hot products of combustion (flue gases)
Gas burner assembly
Cool return air from heated area
Air blower
Combustion air Mixes with fuel and is combusted in the gas burner assembly Fuel Natural gas or propane lgas
Blower compartment
FIGURE 6.1 Typical gas-fixed appliance (furnace).
• The initial ignition of the fuel is often accomplished by the use of an electric ignition device or by a small constant burning flame referred to as a pilot light or pilot burner. • The actual burning of the fuel and production of heat takes place in a confined combustion chamber within the appliance. • As the fuel is combusted or burned, hot products of combustion (flue gases) are formed and travel through the appliance. • Heat energy is removed from the hot products of combustion in the heat exchanger and used to provide useful functions (heat air to heat a home, cook food, dry clothes, or even produce light.) • Finally, the flue gases exit the appliance and are dispersed into the atmosphere through a venting system.
6.3 THE VENTING SYSTEM AND AIR FOR COMBUSTION As the appliance operates, products of combustion (flue gases) must be removed from the appliance and new air for combustion supplied. New air for combustion is mixed with the fuel and combusted at the main burner. This process establishes a “natural”
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 131 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
132
draft through the appliance due to the buoyancy of the hot flue gases, and establishes the rate at which heat is extracted from the appliance through its heat exchanger. This effect also acts to establish the overall operating efficiency of the appliance. In order for an appliance to operate at an efficient and safe level on a consistent basis, this natural draft through an appliance must be maintained at as near a constant level as possible. Products of combustion for a properly adjusted gas appliance contain amounts of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, excess oxygen, and water vapor.2 If the appliance is in poor condition, poorly maintained or installed incorrectly, products of combustion can also contain dangerous levels of CO. The products of combustion and flue gases are removed from the appliance and vented to the outside atmosphere through a venting system. The venting system that an appliance is connected to can have a dramatic effect on the draft through an appliance. The draft rate through a vent system can increase or decrease depending on a number of variables some of which include • • • • • •
Height of the vent terminal above the appliance Size of the vent system The difference between inside and outside temperatures (stack effect) Adequate supply of new makeup air for combustion to the appliance Outside wind conditions Obstructions near the vent terminal
The venting system must not be allowed to restrict or block the natural draft of combustion products through an appliance. If the natural draft through an appliance is blocked, incomplete combustion resulting in the production of CO and possible fire hazards are created. A continuous source of new combustion air containing oxygen must be supplied to the appliance to maintain proper combustion and operation of the appliance. If the supply of new combustion air is restricted incomplete combustion resulting in the production of CO can result.
6.3.1 THE DRAFT DIVERTER The draft diverter, or draft hood, is one method utilized to “couple” the gas appliance to the venting system and neutralize the effects that a vent system may have on the operation of the appliance. The draft diverter is a device that is built into an appliance and is designed to • Provide a path for the escape of the flue gases from the appliance in the event of no draft, back draft, or stoppage beyond the draft hood in the vent system. • Prevent a back draft from entering an appliance. • Neutralize the effect of stack action of the gas vent upon the operation of the appliance.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 132 — #4
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
133
In its most basic form, a draft diverter is in the shape of a “box.” It has an inlet for the products of combustion to enter, an outlet at the top connecting to the vent system and a “relief” opening on one side that is open to the area around the appliance. A draft diverter may contain one or more baffles to control how the products of combustion flow through the draft diverter. In operation, products of combustion from the appliance enter the draft diverter through the inlet, collect in the diverter box, and exit the draft diverter through the outlet to the venting system. During normal operation “dilution” air, air from the area around the appliance, enters the draft diverter through the relief opening and mixes with the products of combustion. This process of adding dilution air through the relief opening acts to allow the flow rate through the vent system to increase or decrease, depending on vent system design and outside atmospheric conditions, while maintaining a constant natural draft through the appliance. The design of the draft diverter also allows products of combustion to exit the appliance through the relief opening in the event that the vent system should become blocked or if a down draft or reverse draft should develop in the venting system. 6.3.1.1 Safety Problems Associated with the Draft Diverter While a draft diverter provides an important safety function of protecting the appliance from the effects of the venting system, the basic design of the draft diverter presents a serious safety concern in itself. Specifically, a blocked vent or a down draft condition in the vent will cause products of combustion to “spill” out of the draft diverter relief opening into the area around the appliance. This is normally not a problem if the blockage or down draft condition is caused by a temporary condition and the spillage only occurs for short periods of time. However, if the spillage condition is allowed to continue for a prolonged period of time a serious safety condition will develop. Products of combustion will be drawn back into the appliance, replacing the normal supply of combustion air, causing the appliance to have “incomplete” combustion resulting in the production of CO. This cycle, if allowed to continue, can generate sufficient amounts of CO in the area around the appliance to cause a serious threat to human life. Spillage of products of combustion from the draft diverter can be caused by • Blockage or restriction in the vent system • A poorly designed, maintained or installed vent system • Back draft in the vent system An inadequate supply of combustion air can also cause spillage. As oxygen is depleted in the combustion process, in the area around the appliance, new air containing oxygen for combustion will be drawn to the appliance from the path of least resistance. If the appliance is installed in a confined area, the path of least resistance can be through the venting system, which creates a back draft. This back draft causes the products of combustion to exit the appliance through the relief opening of the draft diverter.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 133 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
134
6.4 GAS APPLIANCE SAFETY DEVICES All modern day appliances are equipped with basic, and sometimes very complicated, safety devices in an attempt to ensure the safe operation of the appliance. Some of these safety controls include • Thermocouple used on constant burning pilot systems—A device that utilizes the heat from the constant burning pilot flame to generate an electric current to hold open a gas valve piped in series with the main gas burner. If the constant burning pilot flame is extinguished the gas valve closes and shuts off all gas to the appliance. The appliance user must manually relight the constant burning pilot flame. This type of safety is the most basic and is commonly found on all appliance types. • Electronic ignition systems—Electronic ignitions systems are either spark ignition systems or some form of a hot wire or carbon bar system. These systems eliminate the constant burning pilot flame and either ignites a small pilot flame or the main burner flame directly. The presence of a flame must be “proven” electronically within a very short time frame. If the flame fails to ignite all gas to the appliance is shut off and the appliance will not operate. This type of system can be very complicated and most require a trained service representative to repair. • High limit control—An electrical switch that senses the operating temperature of the appliance. The control is electrically connected to the appliance so that if the switch senses an over temperature condition the switch will act to shut down the operation of the appliance. Normally, the switch will automatically reset itself after the appliance cools down and allows the appliance to operate without any intervention by the user. • Flame rollout switch—A flame rollout switch is an electric temperature sensitive switch that monitors the temperature in the area around the main burner area. If a malfunction occurs that would cause the main burner flame to burn outside of the burner compartment, the rollout switch will act to shut down the operation of the appliance. In some cases this switch must be manually reset after it senses a malfunction. Although the technology for flame rollout switches has existed since at least the early 1950s, appliance manufacturers did not begin to routinely install flame rollout switches on appliances until the mid 1980s. • Vent safety shutoff system—A vent safety shut off system normally consists of an electrical switch that senses the temperature of the air in the draft diverter relief opening area. During normal operation the temperature in this area is at, or near, room temperature. If the vent system malfunctions causing products of combustion to spill out of the relief opening, the temperature at this location will rapidly rise to an elevated temperature because hot flue gases are exiting the appliance through the relief opening. The switch is electrically connected to the appliance so that if the switch senses an over temperature condition the switch will act to shut down the operation of the appliance. Normally, the switch will automatically reset itself after the appliance cools down and allows the appliance to operate
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 134 — #6
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
135
without any intervention by the user. Although the technology for vent safety shut off systems has existed since at least the early 1950s, appliance manufacturers did not begin to routinely install this safety device on appliances until the mid 1980s.
6.5 GAS APPLIANCE TYPES Although all modern gas appliances share the same basic design concepts, not all appliances are designed to operate alike or provide the same function to the consumer. The most common types of gas appliances are:
6.5.1 HOUSEHOLD COOKING GAS APPLIANCES Commonly referred to as gas stoves or gas ranges. Most household cooking appliances contain small top burners for cooking food in pots or pans, an oven for baking food and a broiler for broiling or grilling food. Household cooking appliances may be free standing, built-in or a combination of the two. Household cooking appliances are normally not equipped with a draft diverter and are not connected to a venting system. Instead, household cooking appliances usually exhaust the products of combustion directly into the area just above the appliance. This is the same area that is normally occupied by the user of the cooking appliance. For this reason, household cooking appliances are of special concern when considering the overall safety of operation of the appliance.
6.5.2 CLOTHES DRYERS Primarily used in the family living environment to dry clothes after washing. The gas fired clothes dryer looks very much like its electric counter part. Clothes dryers are not equipped with a draft diverter. Clothes dryers depend on an internal blower to circulate the hot products of combustion directly around and through the wet clothes to achieve the drying action. This same blower then forces the very wet cooler products of combustion from the clothes dryer through the dryer vent to the outside atmosphere. Clothes dryers consume an enormous amount of air from the living environment during the drying operation. For this reason it is critical that clothes dryers (both electric and gas) not be installed in the same room as other gas fired appliances.
6.5.3 SPACE HEATING APPLIANCES There are four basic types of space eating appliances: 6.5.3.1 Central Furnaces The most typical gas appliance utilized to heat a home. A central furnace is a selfcontained gas-burning appliance for heating air by the transfer of heat through a heat exchanger. The warm air is then circulated to the home through a heat distribution system (heating ducts.) A central furnace is normally equipped with an air blower
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 135 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
136
that provides the primary means for circulating the air. There are three variations of the central furnace • Upflow—The blower is located at the bottom of the furnace and air flows up through the appliance. • Downflow—The blower is located on the top of the furnace and air flows down through the appliance. • Horizontal—The furnace appears to be laying on its side; the blower is located at one end of the furnace and air flows horizontally through the appliance. Central furnaces are often equipped with a cooling coil in the warm air outlet of the furnace. During the hot summer months the furnace blower is utilized to circulate cool air to the home. Central furnaces are normally equipped with a draft diverter and are connected to a venting system. 6.5.3.2 Room Heaters Aself-contained, freestanding gas appliance utilized to heat a small area. Like a central furnace, room heaters heat air by the transfer of heat through a heat exchanger. The warm air is then allowed to circulate into the area to be heated. They may be equipped with a small fan or blower to assist the circulation of the warm air through the area being heated. Unlike a central furnace, a room heater is not connected to a heat distribution system. Room heaters are normally equipped with a draft diverter and most room heaters (vented) are connected to venting system. However, some room heaters (unvented) are designed to exhaust their products of combustion directly into the room being heated and are not connected to a venting system. 6.5.3.3 Wall Furnaces A self-contained gas appliance utilized to heat a small area. Wall furnaces are either recessed into a wall of the room being heated or installed flush on the wall. Like a central furnace, wall furnaces heat air by the transfer of heat through a heat exchanger. The warm air is then allowed to circulate into the area to be heated. Wall furnaces may be equipped with a small fan or blower to assist the circulation of the warm air through the area being heated. Unlike a central furnace, a room heater is not connected to a heat distribution system. Some wall furnaces are designed to provide heat to two adjacent rooms. In this case the wall furnace is located on the common wall between the two rooms and a small opening from the back of the wall furnace allows heat to flow into the second area. Wall furnaces are normally equipped with a draft diverter and are connected to a venting system. 6.5.3.4 Low-Pressure Boilers A self-contained gas burning appliance for supplying hot water for space heating. The boiler heats water by the transfer of heat through a heat exchanger. The hot water is
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 136 — #8
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
137
then circulated to the home through a piping distribution system and utilizes radiators to heat specific areas inside the home. A hot water heating system is normally equipped with one or more circulator pumps that circulate the hot water from the boiler to the areas being heated (zones.) Each area, or zone, may operate independently of the other zones. Low-pressure boilers normally maintain the water contained in the boiler at a constant temperature, usually around 180˚ F. Low-pressure boilers are normally equipped with a draft diverter and are connected to a venting system. 6.5.3.5 Water Heaters A water heater is a closed vessel in which water is heated through a heat exchanger by the hot products of combustion. The most common type of water heater is the automatic storage type that heats and then stores water, within the appliance, for delivery to the user on demand. Typical automatic storage type water heaters have 30 gallon, 40 gallon, or 50 gallon water capacities and deliver water between 100˚ F and 120˚ F. They are normally equipped with a draft diverter and are connected to a venting system. Water heaters are normally installed in the same area of the home as the central heating appliance. When this is the case, the water heater and the central heating appliance will usually share the same venting system. Each appliance is connected to the “common” vent system through its own vent connector. The vent connector consists of a short section of vent pipe that connects the outlet of each appliance to the inlet of the common vent system. In this type of installation, any failure of the common portion of the venting system will affect both appliances connected to it. 6.5.3.6 Special Design Appliances While most gas-fired appliances are equipped with draft diverters and are connected to a venting system, there are two special designs that eliminate the draft diverter and in some cases eliminate the need for a typical venting system. Direct Vent—A system consisting of an appliance, combustion air, and flue gas connections between the appliance and the outside atmosphere. The appliance, flue gas connections, and vent termination cap are supplied by the appliance manufacturer and constructed so that all air for combustion is obtained from the outside atmosphere and all flue gases are discharged to the outside atmosphere. In this type of system there is no draft diverter. The appliance, normally a wall furnace, is installed on an outside wall of the structure, and the combustion and flue gas connections are directly to and from the appliance through the wall to the outside atmosphere. Induced Draft—A system that utilizes a small air blower to induce or force the products of combustion through the venting system to the outside atmosphere. The blower takes the place of the draft diverter and forces the products of combustion through the system. This type of system is more efficient than the type of system that utilizes a draft diverter and is normally utilized on mid and high efficiency central space heating
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 137 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
138
systems. Both of these types of special design appliances are safer designs because they eliminate most of the problems associated with the draft diverter and the vent system.
6.6 GAS APPLIANCE CERTIFICATION In the United States, most building codes in effect today require that the building code authority approve any gas appliance before it is installed. Normally any gas appliance that has been tested and certified (listed) by an approved testing agency will be considered “approved” by the building code authority. Most gas appliance manufacturers in the United States voluntarily have their products tested and certified through a certification program provided by the Canadian Standards Association (CSA)3 and the Z21/83 Committee. The CSA and the Z21/83 Committee are jointly accredited by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) to develop the Z21 series of standards for gas burning appliances and related accessories. These standards cover construction requirements, safe operation, performance aspects, and laboratory test methods. CSA provides the administrative services required to operate the program, and the Z21/83 Committee, along with its Technical Advisory Groups, develop the Z21 series of standards in accordance with ANSI approved procedures. CSA is accredited by ANSI as a Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory and is considered to be an approved testing agency as required under most building codes. For gas appliances manufactured in the United States, the CSA Star indicates that the appliance has been tested under the applicable Z21 ANSI Standard and is certified to meet the requirements of that standard. (see Figure 6.2) Before the CSA, the American Gas Association (AGA) was recognized as the approved testing agency and used the same star certification seal as an indication that the appliance was certified to meet the requirements of the applicable Z21 standard. This seal, in some form, has been found on certified appliances manufactured since 1925.
D
ESIG N
C
ER
TIFIE
D
®
FIGURE 6.2 CSA Star.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 138 — #10
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
139
6.7 GAS APPLIANCE INSTALLATION REQUIREMENTS The installation, adjustment, operation, and repair of gas burning appliances are governed by national building codes adopted by the building authority having jurisdiction in a local community such as a city or county. There are currently four major national building code groups in the United States. • Building Officials and Code Administrators International, Inc. (BOCA) Primarily used in the Northeastern region of the United States. BOCA publishes the National Mechanical Code and the National Plumbing Code. • International Conference of Building Officials (ICBO) Primarily used in the Western half of the United States. ICBO publishes the Uniform Mechanical Code. • Southern Building Code Congress International, Inc. (SBCCI) Primarily used in the Southeastern region of the United States. SBCCI publishes the Standard Mechanical Code and the Standard Plumbing Code. • International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials (IAPMO) Primarily used in the Western half of United States. IAPMO publishes the Uniform Mechanical Code (jointly with ICBO) and the Uniform Plumbing Code. In 1972 the Council of American Building Officials (CABO) was established by BOCA, ICBO, and SBCCI to compile and standardize the code requirements published by BOCA, ICBO, and SBCCI. The International Code Council, Inc. (ICC) was organized on December 9, 1994 as successor to CABO. The ICC publishes the International Fuel Gas Code, the International Mechanical Code, and the International Plumbing Code. While each national building code group has developed its own set of codes that apply to the installation of gas appliances, the codes are very similar to one another with only minor differences between them. In some cases, the local building authority may supplement sections of a national code with more stringent requirements.
6.8 NATIONAL FUEL GAS CODE The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) was organized in 1896 to improve the methods of fire protection and to obtain and circulate information on these subjects.4 The NFPA in its efforts has developed a set of National Standard Codes that includes the National Fuel Gas Code—NFPA 54. The National Fuel Gas Code— NFPA 54 was developed by gas industry experts, and is considered to be the industry standard for the installation of gas piping and gas appliances.
6.9 MANUFACTURERS INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS The appliance manufacturer supplies each gas-burning appliance with detailed installation instructions. All of the national building codes referenced above require
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 139 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
140
that the appliance be installed in accordance with the manufacturer’s installation instructions. Most manufacturer’s installation instructions require the installation to comply with the National Fuel Gas Code—NFPA 54 and provide instructions for • • • • •
Proper gas appliance location Adequate gas piping supply Adequate combustion and ventilation air supply Proper venting system Proper fuel input adjustment
All of these topics are covered in detail in the National Fuel Gas Code— NFPA 54.
6.9.1 PROPER FUEL INPUT ADJUSTMENTS Even though all of the items listed in the installation instructions are critical for a safe installation, the most common installation requirement that is often overlooked is the proper fuel input adjustment. The fuel input rating for a gas-burning appliance can be found on the appliance rating plate attached to the appliance. This rating is the amount of fuel, expressed in British Thermal Units (BTUs), which the appliance will consume or burn during each hour of operation at sea level (zero feet in elevation.) Gas-burning appliances are preadjusted to burn this amount of fuel by the manufacturer before shipment to the distributor. The appliance installer will often assume that the fuel input is correct because it was pre-adjusted by the manufacturer. While this practice may be valid at sea level, at higher elevations above sea level it is not valid. A cubic foot of fuel (natural gas or propane gas) requires a specific amount of oxygen (supplied in the air) for proper and safe combustion. As the elevation above sea level increases, the amount of oxygen in the air decreases. Because an appliance is physically designed to burn a specific amount of gas with a specific amount of oxygen supplied in the combustion air, the fuel input rate to the appliance must be adjusted down, or derated, to account for the lower levels of oxygen at increased elevations. As stated in most appliance installation instructions, at elevations above 2000 ft. the fuel input rate must be reduced by 4% for each 1000 ft. above sea level. For example, a central furnace rated at 100,000 BTU/h as listed on its rating plate, would only be rated at 80,000 BTU/h when installed at 5,000 ft. above sea level (Denver, Colorado.) If the installer of this furnace did not check and adjust the fuel input rate for the increased elevation, the appliance would be burning a too rich mixture of fuel and air with the increased probability of producing dangerous amounts of CO.
6.10 FUEL GASES There are four major groups of fuel gases; natural gases, liquefied petroleum (LP) gases including propane and butane, manufactured gases, and mixed gases. The most common type fuels for household use in the United States are natural gas followed by propane and then to a much lesser extent butane. Natural gas, propane gas, and
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 140 — #12
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
141
butane gas are all classified as hydrocarbon gases. A hydrocarbon gas is a gas that is made up of both hydrogen and carbon atoms, thus the term hydrocarbon. Natural gas is a naturally occurring mixture of hydrocarbon gases as well as small amounts of nonhydrocarbon gases found in porous formations beneath the earth’s surface. The principle component of most natural gases found in the United States is methane. Lesser amounts of ethane, propane, butane, and other gases are also found in natural gas. The major source of propane and butane in the United States is crude petroleum. Another important source of propane and butane is from natural gas through a process known as absorption. These fuels are absorbed from natural gas in oil and then refined into propane, butane, and natural gasoline. The boiling point of natural gas at atmospheric pressure is −260◦ F.5 In order to liquefy natural gas it is necessary to cool it to its boiling point. As the pressure of natural gas is increased the boiling point also increases. The critical temperature of natural gas is about −116◦ F at about 673 pounds per square inch (PSI) of pressure. Simply put, this indicates that natural gas will always be in a vapor state whenever the temperature of the gas is above −116◦ F regardless of the pressure. A natural gas utility company normally provides natural gas to the end user through a distribution system of underground pipes. The boiling point of propane is −44◦ F at atmospheric pressure.6 When propane is enclosed in a container at room temperature it will reach a state in which some of the propane will be in a vapor state and some of the propane will liquefy. The propane vapor causes the pressure inside the container to increase. The pressure inside the container will depend on the temperature (see Table 6.1). This characteristic of propane allows the fuel to be stored very easily in a storage tank as a liquid and then vaporized and used as a fuel in a gas-fired appliance. Propane gas is most often found on portable appliances (outdoor grills), on recreational vehicles, and in rural areas as a heating fuel. The boiling point of butane is 32◦ F at atmospheric pressure. Like propane, when butane is enclosed in a container at room temperature it will reach a state in which some
TABLE 6.1 Vapor Pressures of Propane and Butane Gases Temperature (◦ F) −40 −20 0 20 40 60 70 80 100
Propane Vapor Pressure (psi)
Butane Vapor Pressure (psi)
1.3 10.7 23.5 40.8 63.3 92.5 109.3 128.1 172.3
3.0 11.5 16.5 22 37
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 141 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
142
of the butane will be in a vapor state and some of the butane will liquefy. Because the boiling point of butane is 32◦ F it will always remain a liquid at temperatures below 32◦ F. This characteristic makes it very difficult to use butane as a heating fuel in locations where the storage temperature is below 32◦ F. Another important characteristic shared by natural gas, propane gas, and butane gas is how the number of atoms affects the gases. Referring to Figure 6.3, note that methane has fewer carbon and hydrogen atoms than ethane, propane has more atoms than ethane, and butane has more atoms than propane. As the number of atoms increase the actual weight or density of the gas increases. Also as the number of atoms increases the heating value of the gas increases. The weight of a gas is normally expressed as a ratio of the weight of the gas compared to the weight of the same volume of dry air. This ratio is referred to as the specific gravity of the gas. A specific gravity greater than 1 indicates the gas is heavier than air and if the gas is released into the air it will sink to the lowest level. A specific gravity less than 1 indicates the gas is lighter than air and when released into the air it will rise. Referring to Table 6.2, note that natural gas is lighter than air. H H
C
H
H
H Methane CH4
H
H
H
C
C
H
H
H
Ethane C2H6
H
H
H
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
Propane C3H8
H
H
H
H
H
C
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
Butane C4H10
FIGURE 6.3 Carbon atoms and hydrogen atoms linked together; the aliphatic series.
TABLE 6.2 Specific Gravity and Heating Values of Several Hydrocarbon Gases
Specific gravity (Air = 1.00) Heating value BTU/cu. ft.
Natural gas
Propane
Butane
0.58 − 0.79
1.53
2.00
900 − 1200
2516
3280
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 142 — #14
H
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
143
Also propane and butane are both heavier than air. This characteristic makes natural gas a safer fuel because if released into the air it will rapidly dissipate into the atmosphere while propane and butane will tend to collect and pool at floor level. The heating value of a gas is normally expressed in British Thermal Units per cubic foot (BTU/cu. ft.) One (1) BTU is the amount of heat required to raise one (1) pound of water one (1) degree Fahrenheit (◦ F.) Referring to Table 6.2, note that butane has a higher heating value than propane and propane has a higher heating value than natural gas. This characteristic makes it critical that the gas-fired appliance be properly adjusted to burn the type of fuel that is supplied. A gas-fired appliance that has been adjusted to burn propane fuel will not operate safely on natural gas just as a gas-fired appliance adjusted to burn natural gas will not operate safely on propane.
6.11 BASIC PRINCIPLES OF COMBUSTION Combustion, or burning, of a fuel is defined as the rapid oxidation of the fuel. It is the process of oxygen acting with the fuel to produce heat and light very rapidly. Some people have defined combustion as the controlled explosion of a mixture of fuel and oxygen to produce controlled amounts of heat or light. For combustion to take place the proper amount of fuel must be mixed with the proper amount of oxygen (air.) Heat must be added to raise the mixture to its ignition point. Once ignition takes place the combustion process will continue as long as the fuel and air supply is maintained. About 10 cu. ft. of air containing normal amounts of oxygen is required to burn 1000 BTU of either natural gas or propane gas at optimal conditions. However, the limits of flammability, or explosive limits, of natural gas is between about 4% and 14% gas in air and for propane between about 2.4% and 9.6% gas in air. If the fuel mixture is below the explosive limit the mixture is too lean to burn; and, if the mixture is above the explosive limit the mixture is too rich to burn. The ignition point of natural gas and propane gas is normally between about 900◦ F and about 1000◦ F.
6.11.1 PRODUCTS OF COMPLETE COMBUSTION When a hydrocarbon fuel gas, like natural gas, is burned in a mixture of air containing a sufficient amount of oxygen (O2 ) the normal products of combustion are carbon dioxide (CO2 ) and water vapor (H2 O.) Included with the combustion products is the nitrogen (N2 ) that was contained in the combustion air. Nitrogen, because it is an inert gas and does not burn, passes through as part of the flue gases. The total volume of the flue gases contains (see Figure 6.4) CO2 and H2 O (products of combustion), N2 (carry through from the combustion air), and excess air. Heat as shown refers to ignition of the gas mixture. Excess air is air that was drawn into the appliance with the combustion air but was not needed for combustion. When burning a fuel such as natural gas or propane in a gas-designed appliance, the volume of gas burned on a per hour basis remains constant. Therefore, the volume of the products of combustion, CO2 and H2 O, will remain constant. However, the total volume of the flue gases will vary depending on the amount of excess air that
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 143 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
144
100 cu.ft. carbon dioxide Products of combustion
1000 cu.ft. combustion air (Oxygen + Nitrogen)
200 cu.ft. water vapor
100 cu.ft. natural gas 250 cu.ft. excess air
800 cu.ft. nitrogen
HEAT
250 cu.ft. excess air
1350 cu.ft. (fuel + combustion air + excess air)
1350 cu.ft. flue gases
FIGURE 6.4 Products of complete combustion.
is drawn into the appliance. Appliance manufacturers utilize excess air as a built-in safety factor when designing the combustion system in an appliance to ensure that complete combustion results. CO is not a product of complete combustion.
6.11.2 PRODUCTS OF INCOMPLETE COMBUSTION Sometimes when a hydrocarbon fuel gas is burned incomplete combustion results. When this occurs, CO is one byproduct of the incomplete combustion in addition to the normal byproducts of complete combustion, carbon dioxide (CO2 ) and water vapor (H2 O). The most common cause of incomplete combustion in a gas-fired appliance is an inadequate supply of combustion air. Another less common cause of incomplete combustion is flame cooling, and to a lesser extent, insufficient mixing of the fuel and combustion air. Flame cooling results when the flame impinges on a cool surface, such as a heat exchanger wall. This causes the flame to cool to below the ignition point of the fuel. When this occurs the mixture is not fully combusted and CO, as well as other byproducts, is an unwanted by product. CO is actually a hydrocarbon fuel similar to propane or butane. The heating value of CO is about 322 BTU/cu. ft. and the specific gravity is 0.9672, making it slightly lighter than air. CO has no odor. Although CO has no detectable odor, there is another byproduct of incomplete combustion that does. Just as CO is the byproduct of the carbon component in the fuel, there are also byproducts of the hydrogen component, namely aldehydes, hydrogen, and other hydroxylated compounds. Aldehydes usually have a sharp penetrating odor that acts to sting the nose and eyes. Very small amounts of aldehydes in air are detectable by the normal human nose. The presence of aldehydes indicates the presence of CO. However, the lack of a detectable odor does not necessarily indicate that combustion is complete since CO and hydrogen are both odorless.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 144 — #16
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
145
TABLE 6.3 CPSC Estimated Annual Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Deaths 1994–2002 (Nonfire Related)
Unspecified gas heating LP gas heating Natural gas heating Gas water heaters Gas cooking ranges/ ovens All other causes Total
1994–1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Total
Percent of Total (%)
25 46 35 7
3 22 19 1
7 29 37 3
6 26 28 0
15 50 22 1
56 173 141 12
7.3 22.6 18.4 1.6
7 80 200
6 58 109
11 51 138
10 60 130
3 97 188
37 346 765
4.8 45.2 100.0
6.12 CPSC ESTIMATES OF CARBON MONOXIDE DEATHS The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has tracked deaths in the United States due to CO from the late 1970s. In a report7 titled “Non-Fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths Associated With The Use Of Consumer Products 2002 Annual Estimates”, published on July 12, 2005, the Commission has estimated the number of deaths that has occurred each year from 1994 due to gas-fired appliances (see Table 6.3). As demonstrated in Table 6.3, the majority of deaths were caused by natural gas and LP gas (propane and butane) heating systems followed by gas-fired cooking ranges/ovens and to a lesser degree gas-fired water heaters. As noted in the CPSC report, these are estimates of documented deaths and do not include reported and nonreported injuries and illness caused by CO or deaths that were misdiagnosed as non-CO deaths. Table 6.3 also indicates, regardless of any advances in appliance design, the number of deaths each year attributed to gas-fired heating systems has remained fairly constant over the past 10 years. This supports the concept that the manner in which the gas appliance is installed and how the appliance is serviced and maintained has a huge influence on the safe operation of the appliance. Or, simply stated, the operating condition of the heating system as a whole has just as much influence, if not more, on the safe operation of the gas-fired appliance.
6.13 THE HEATING/GAS APPLIANCE SYSTEM When evaluating the operation of a gas-fired appliance, it is critical to consider the operation of the appliance including all of the external factors that impact the safe operation of the appliance. The gas-fired appliance and all of the external components impacting the operation of the appliance make up the heating system or gas appliance
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 145 — #17
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
146
system. As a minimum, the following external components or factors, along with the gas-fired appliance make up the system • The fuel supply— As discussed earlier, it is critical to adjust the appliance for the type of fuel that is supplied. In addition to the fuel type, the fuel line pressure and quality of the fuel is also important. If the fuel line pressure is too low improper mixing of the fuel and combustion air could result causing incomplete combustion. Conversely, too high of a fuel line pressure could cause the appliance to malfunction resulting in a fire hazard. The quality of the fuel, moisture content, and other contaminants could also cause the appliance to malfunction. • The combustion and ventilation air supply—For an appliance to operate as designed, it is critical that a sufficient amount of air for combustion is supplied to the appliance. A deficient supply of combustion can cause the venting system to malfunction resulting in a down draft through the vent system rendering the vent system inoperative. This causes all of the products of combustion to vent out of the appliance through the draft diverter relief opening. As discussed under the section “Safety Problems Associated With The Draft Diverter,” this condition can, and often does, result in the production of CO. It is just as important to ensure that a sufficient amount of ventilation air is also supplied to the appliance. An adequate amount of ventilation air will ensure that the draft effect in the venting system, and the appliance itself, will be maintained. Ventilation air is used to help cool the area around the appliance and, more importantly, provide air for dilution at the draft diverter as needed. • The venting system—The proper design, installation, and operation of the venting system is the single most important factor in the safe operation of a gas-fired appliance. Normally, if the venting system is functioning as intended, any CO produced by the appliance will be vented to the outside atmosphere. If the vent system fails, it is probable that the appliance will produce CO at some point in its operation. • The service personnel—Even if the gas-fired appliance system is properly installed and adjusted, it is critical that the operation of the system be checked annually and repaired as necessary. Normally it requires a minimum of two failures for CO to find its way into the living occupied area of a home. There must be source of CO (failure 1) and there must be a pathway into the occupied area (failure 2). Proper servicing of the system will help to ensure there are no failures during the useful life of the appliance.
6.14 FAILURE MODES As noted above, it normally requires at least two failures of the system to result in CO reaching the occupied area. For example, the first failure would cause the appliance to produce CO and the second failure would cause the CO to travel to the occupied area rather than being vented to the outside atmosphere.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 146 — #18
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
147
The following failure modes can result in incomplete combustion causing the appliance to produce CO: • Appliance burning too much fuel resulting in a rich mixture • Incorrect combustion air adjustment on the burner causing the flame to lift and impinge on a cooler surface • Restricted internal flue passageway resulting in poor draft through the appliance • Insufficient combustion air supply Normally the appliance will appear to operate safely under the above listed failures provided that the venting system is operating to vent the products of combustion to the outside atmosphere. The following failure modes can cause the venting system to malfunction: • Improper design, improper size, or insufficient vent height above the roof line. • Missing or damaged vent terminal cap at the vent terminal. A damaged or missing vent cap will allow wind to enter the vent system causing a back draft or no draft. A damaged or missing vent cap will also allow birds and other animals to enter the vent in an attempt to nest. • Insufficient combustion air supply can cause the vent to downdraft, or reverse flow. The lack of combustion air causes the pressure inside the room containing the appliance to be reduced. A downdraft through the vent system occurs when the pressure inside the room containing the appliance is decreased to a point below the outside atmospheric pressure. Note that an insufficient supply of air can cause two failures in the system, incomplete combustion resulting in the production of CO and the failure of the vent system. Other failure modes that can cause two failures in the system include • Excessive leakage in the return air system of a forced air furnace. Excessive leakage causes air from around the furnace to be pulled into the return air system of the furnace. Depending on the severity of the leakage this effect can cause the vent system to fail. In severe cases it can cause the burner flame to be pulled out of the furnace causing not only a CO hazard but a fire hazard as well. Once the furnace starts producing CO a direct path into the heated area is provided by the furnace heat distribution system pumping the CO into all areas of the heated space. • Cracked heat exchanger. A cracked heat exchanger can interfere with the draft effect through the appliance causing the appliance to produce CO. Depending on the location and size of the crack, products of combustion containing CO can enter the heated air stream rather than exiting the appliance through the venting system. Some appliances, such as a gas-fired cooking appliance (range/oven) and unvented room heaters, are not connected to a vent system. These appliances vent the products of combustion directly into the area above the appliance. For example, when the top
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 147 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
148
burners of a gas range are operated the products of combustion are vented directly into the area occupied by the user of the appliance. When the oven is used the products of combustion from the oven are vented from the appliance at a location at the back of the cook top directly into the area occupied by the user. In these types of appliances it is critical that the appliance be installed, operated, and maintained so that CO is not produced. Any failure causing incomplete combustion can result in a hazardous condition.
6.15 INVESTIGATION OF ROOT CAUSE Gas appliances are designed and performance certified using ANSI standards developed by the Z21/83 Committee. For example, gas-fired central furnaces are certified under ANSI Z21.478 to produce CO levels less than 400 parts per million (ppm) in an air free (no excess air) sample of the flue gases when tested in an atmosphere having a normal oxygen supply. While ANSI standards allow some amounts of CO, most gas appliances when installed in accordance with national and local codes and properly maintained will produce only trace amounts of CO (normally less than 10 ppm.) When investigating an incident it may or may not be evident that CO poisoning was the cause of the illness or death. However, even in those cases where it is obvious from the beginning that CO poisoning was the cause, it may not be as obvious as to what the root cause or source of the CO poisoning was. Many times police and fire investigators, and sometimes well trained heating technicians, base a conclusion on an obvious observable factor while missing the root cause of the accident. Most of the time, in CO accidents involving gas appliances, there are a number of factors that contribute to the cause. Many of these factors may have been present for a number of years before an observable incident has occurred. A malfunction in any one of the components of the heating system could cause the appliance to produce CO. When this happens, the appliance may seem to operate in a safe manner because the CO is being vented to the outside atmosphere through the venting system. However, if the venting system should fail for some reason or if a second malfunction should occur (i.e., faulty heat exchanger), dangerous levels of CO could be circulated to the occupied areas of the structure. Besides the obvious causes of failure, other less obvious causes are faulty installations, poorly maintained heating system components, and sometimes poorly designed features within the appliance itself. Many times a deteriorating condition is noticeable before a serious failure occurs. Rusted and discolored vent pipes, odors, unexplained gas pilot outages, water vapors condensing on windows during cold periods, and complaints of poor heating are all indicators of a malfunctioning heating system which, if left uncorrected, could result in a CO poisoning. Many times the people who first respond to an accident disturb key evidence while evaluating the scene and attempting to make the location safe. Typical actions taken by response personnel include moving boxes or furniture that may be blocking combustion air openings and removing panels from gas fired appliances to shut off the gas. In order to minimize any destruction of key evidence it is imperative that a
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 148 — #20
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
149
qualified expert who specializes in forensic investigations be contacted and allowed to inspect the site as soon as possible. When investigating the CO accident the following factors must be evaluated before a probable root cause can be determined. Extensive photographs and videotaping of the scene should be completed to document the conditions as found. Every effort should be made to preserve key evidence for evaluation. The conditions as found (initial discovery) must not be changed or corrected until the investigation is completed. In most cases the gas appliance and venting system components should be removed after the follow-up inspection and investigation and preserved as evidence. While it is preferred that a forensic expert be involved from the initial discovery through the completion of the investigation, this is normally not the case. What usually occurs is the forensic expert is called in at some point after the initial discovery and investigation is completed. From a forensic viewpoint it is important to involve an expert, at least on a consulting basis, as soon as possible after the incident.
6.15.1 INITIAL DISCOVERY AND INVESTIGATION • First discovery—Who discovered the victim? How did they discover the victim? What happened to cause them to find the victim? • Ambient conditions in the space as found—What were the conditions when the victim was first discovered? Was the room cool, warm or hot? Was there water moisture on the windows? Was there an odor in the room and if so what did it smell like? • First response—Who responded? What did the police and fire departments find? Did the local building code department respond? Did the local gas supplier or gas utility respond? Did they take photographs? What conditions did they find? Did they turn off the appliance? If so, how? Were any tests conducted on the appliances? Did they prepare a report? What conclusions did they reach? • Make safe—Did the local authorities call in someone to inspect the gas appliances to make safe? Was the building evacuated? If so, why? What actions were taken to make the building safe? Was the suspect gas appliance repaired or altered after the incident? If so, how and by whom?
6.15.2 FOLLOW-UP INSPECTIONS AND INVESTIGATION • Weather data—What was the local weather conditions preceding the incident? Outside temperature patterns, wind speed and direction, snow cover, rain, sleet, and so forth all may have a bearing on the operation of the venting system and combustion air and ventilation system. Weather data should be collected from local sources such as the state university and local newspapers. • Building orientation and construction—What direction is the building facing? Make a sketch of the building and rooms showing location of the victims, heating appliances, other gas burning appliances, fireplaces,
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 149 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
150
•
•
•
•
•
•
and other air consuming devices such as exhaust fans and exhaust hoods. Record all dimensions, including ceiling height and window and door locations. Note the age of the construction and construction type (frame, brick, etc.) and the tightness of the building (weather stripped, caulked, etc.). Mark locations of gas vents and sources of combustion air including size and type of air grills and air louvers. Overall condition and appearance of the building and gas appliances— Does it appear that the building and appliances are in good condition? Is there an existing hazardous condition? Is there a hazard tag on the gas appliance? If so, when was it placed and by who? What action is recommended to correct the hazard? Maintenance history—Have there been any previous problems reported? What types of repairs have been completed in the past? When were the problems reported and when were the repairs completed? Who discovered the problems and who made the repairs? Evaluate appliance installation—Is the appliance installed in compliance with the manufacturer’s installation instructions? Does the installation comply with national standards (NFPA 54) and local building codes? Record locations of fuel lines, gas pressure regulators including gas pressure regulator vent lines and propane tanks if fired on propane. Sketch the existing appliance installation and venting system. Identify sources of combustion and ventilation air and any other information that may be pertinent to the operation of the appliance. Note the condition of the appliance and venting system. Collect appliance data—Record all nameplate data for all appliances. Include serial numbers and model numbers on all automatic gas control valves. Also note any special devices or controls that may be installed on the appliances. Examples of special devices may include automatic vent dampers, heat reclaimers, and other retrofitted energy conservation devices. Conduct combustion tests—Test the gas appliance(s) to determine what their normal operating characteristics are. Test all gas appliances in the structure. Repeat all tests under different conditions to duplicate conditions that existed at the time of the incident. At a minimum, test for CO at the flue outlet (inlet to draft diverter) and measure stack temperature. Also it is necessary to measure oxygen or carbon dioxide content to be able to calculate CO on an air free basis. Note burner ignition and operating characteristics (yellow tip, blue flame, primary air adjustments, etc.). Ambient CO levels in the appliance area, as well as in the area where the victim was found, should be recorded and monitored. Measure the fuel input rate—Is the appliance properly adjusted for the elevation? The nameplate rating for certified appliances must be derated at the rate of 4% for each 1000 ft. in elevation. The actual heat (fuel) input should be determined and recorded. For propane-fired appliances it is necessary to measure the burner orifice sizes and compute the actual input. For natural gas fired appliances it is necessary to measure the actual
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 150 — #22
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
151
input by “clocking” the gas meter. It is necessary to contact the local gas utility for actual heating (BTU) and specific gravity values. • Miscellaneous factors—Are there any other factors or conditions that might have a bearing on the cause of this incidence? Such factors may include faulty maintenance by a third party or failure of a third party to provide a warning when they had knowledge of a hazardous condition.
6.15.3 DETERMINATION OF ROOT CAUSE Although the cause of the incident may seem obvious at first, guard against premature conclusions. Only after all of the items and information discussed above have been collected and analyzed is it possible to determine the root cause or causes of the CO poisoning. As stated earlier, with modern gas- fired appliances there are usually two or more failures that finally result in a tragic accident. The key is to collect as much data as soon after the incident as possible and evaluate that data to reach a determination of probable cause.
6.15.4 ESTIMATION OF AMBIENT CARBON MONOXIDE LEVELS IN OCCUPIED AREAS As a last step in evaluating a CO incident in a structure, it may be feasible to estimate the ambient CO levels inside the structure caused by the failures identified in the investigation. The factors that must be identified before an estimate of the ambient CO level can be calculated are • Type of fuel, heating value, and total volume of combustion products produced in cubic feet per 1000 BTU, dry basis (water vapor removed.) • Actual fuel input rate, BTU/h. • Combustion data indicating amount of CO produced by the appliance on an air free basis (excess air removed.) • Type of construction and estimated air exchange rate in the structure, expressed as air changes per hour. • Estimate of the operating cycle based on appliance usage and weather data. • Failure mode indicating how much of the produced CO actually enters the structure. After all of the above listed factors have been identified, an estimation of the ambient CO level within the structure can be calculated. As an illustrated example consider the following case study.
6.16 CASE STUDY During the early morning hours on January 12, two adults, male and female, were transported from their home to a local hospital emergency room suffering from severe headaches, nausea, and confusion. Blood tests indicated carboxyhemoglobin
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 151 — #23
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
152
(COHb) levels in the adult male of 32% and in the female of 35%. Neither individual smoked. As a result of this incident the couple’s single level home was inspected and an investigation conducted in an effort to locate the cause of the CO exposure.
6.16.1 INVESTIGATION • Incident location 1. Northern New Mexico 2. 5000 ft. elevation • Home description 1. Determined from local records and inspection a. Frame construction completed in 1972 b. Single level built over a crawl space c. 1680 sq. ft. in area d. 9 ft. ceilings e. 15,120 cu. ft. internal volume • Type appliance 1. Determined by inspection a. Forced air furnace, upflow b. Rated fuel input rate i. 125,000 BTU/h nameplate ii. 100,000 BTU/h at local conditions c. Atmospheric venting system with draft diverter d. Furnace installed in confined space utility closet. e. No combustion air supplied to utility room (operation depends on normal infiltration of air from the outside for combustion air.) • Fuel type—Natural gas supplied from the Texas Panhandle area. 1. Published data a. Heating value i. 1013 BTU/cu. ft. at sea level ii. 858 BTU/cu.ft. at local conditions b. Total volume of combustion products—8.545 cu. ft. dry basis • Actual fuel input rate 1. Determined by measurement a. 122.55 cu. ft. per h natural gas b. 105,149 BTU/h (5.1% over fired) • Combustion data at steady state conditions 1. Determined by measurement a. % O2 = 12.6 b. CO, ppm with diluted with excess air = 1650 c. CO, ppm excess air free = 4125
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 152 — #24
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
153
• Air changes per hour and type construction 1. Determined by measurement and calculation utilizing published American Society of Heating, Refrigerating And Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) tables and formula.9 a. Estimated air exchange rate i. 0.75 air changes per hour at design conditions ii. 0.56 air changes at average temperature difference (January) b. Average to tight • Weather conditions for time period 1. Local data sources a. January time period i. Average outdoor temperature 29.9◦ F b. Indoor temperature 72◦ F c. Average temperature difference 42.1◦ F d. Design outdoor temperature −1◦ F • Furnace operating cycle 1. Calculation based on furnace size and average weather data for time period a. Duty cycle 57.7% b. Burner cycles per hour 4
6.16.2 FAILURE MODE • Determined by investigation 1. Production of CO by furnace (source) a. Over fired (contributing cause of CO) b. Insufficient combustion air supply c. 4125 ppm CO air free basis 2. Total vent system failure caused by insufficient combustion air resulting in vent draft reversal 3. 100% spillage of combustion products into area around furnace 4. Excessive leakage of air into return air system of furnace at furnace base and junction of furnace to return air plenum connection (pathway into heated area) 5. 100% of combustion products circulated into occupied area
6.16.3 CASE STUDY CONCLUSIONS Figures 6.5 and 6.6 were generated by applying the collected data to standard formulas to calculate estimated ambient indoor CO levels.10−13 These plots indicate that after about 7 h of total elapsed time from start, the ambient CO level inside the structure has increased from 0 to around 250 ppm. The plots also indicate that the ambient
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 153 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
154
Ambient Co level (ppm)
300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Time 0–7 h
FIGURE 6.5 Estimated ambient carbon monoxide levels from starts to 7 h of elapsed time.
265.0
Ambient CO level (ppm)
260.0 255.0 250.0 245.0 240.0 235.0 230.0 Time 7–14 h
FIGURE 6.6 Estimated ambient carbon monoxide levels from 7 to 14 h of elapsed time.
level of CO within the structure stabilized after about 10 h from start and then varied between 245 and 260 ppm as the furnace cycled on and off. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)14 has published maximum allowable exposure limits for CO of 9 ppm for an 8-h exposure or 35 ppm for a 1-h exposure. The EPA has established that this exposure limit not be exceeded more than once per year. Exposure above these levels is considered harmful to public health. The estimated ambient CO levels demonstrated in this case study exceed the EPA recommended maximum allowable CO exposure limits for humans and indicate that the occupants were exposed to an extremely hazardous risk of CO poisoning.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 154 — #26
Investigating Carbon Monoxide-Related Accidents
155
References 1. American Gas Association, Gaseous Fuels, Properties, Behavior, and Utilization, 1954. 2. American Gas Association, Fundamentals of Combustion Revised, Catalogue No. XH9601. 3. Canadian Standards Association, CSA in the USA, http://www.csa-international.org/ testing_certification_us/ 4. National Fire Protection Association, National Fuel Gas Code Handbook, 1999, Lemoff, T.C., ed., Inc., NFPA No.: F9-54HB99. 5. Gas Engineers Handbook, Fuel Gas Engineering Practices, 1977, Industrial Press, Inc., NY, Segeler, C.G., editor First ed.—5th Printing. 6. Engineered Controls International, Inc. LP-Gas Serviceman’s Manual, L-545, 1962. 7. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Non-fire carbon monoxide deaths associated with the use of consumer products 2002 annual estimates, July 12, 2005. 8. American National Standards Institute, Inc., ANSI Z21.47, American National Standard for Gas-Fired Central Furnaces. 23rd ed., 1987. 9. American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, 2005 ASHRAE Fundamentals Handbook. 10. Calspan, Investigation of Safety Standards for Flame-Fired Furnaces, Hot Water Heaters, Clothes Dryers and Ranges, Report No. YG-5569-D-3, July, 1975, Contract No. CPSC-C-74-131. 11. Calspan, Safety Devices For Gas-Fired Appliances, Report No. 6608-D-1, May, 1980, Contract No. CPSC-C-79-1007. 12. Gas Research Institute, Environmental and Safety Research, September 1996, Topical Report, Critique of ANSI Z21.1 Standard for CO emissions from gas-fired ovens and ranges, Prepared by J.J. Reuther, Battelle. 13. Thomas H. Greiner, Ph.D., P.E., Associate Professor, Iowa State University, Comments concerning carbon monoxide emissions from gas-fired ovens and ranges with special reference to Battelle’s 1996 Critique of ANSI Z21.1 (1) 14. Environmental Protection Agency, National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for pollutants considered harmful to public health and the environment, http://epa.gov/air/criteria.html.
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 155 — #27
8417: “8417_c006” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 156 — #28
7
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment Jane McCammon
CONTENTS 7.1 7.2
7.3
7.4
7.5
7.6
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Identifying Marine CO Poisonings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 Identification of Marine CO Poisonings at Lake Powell. . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 Identification of Marine CO Poisonings Nationwide . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3 Additional Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Case Identification . . . . . Descriptive Characteristics of Known Marine Carbon Monoxide Poisonings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.1 Demographics, Distribution, and Outcome of Poisonings . . . . . . . . 7.3.2 Location of the Victim and Source of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . Medical Characteristics of the Cases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.1 Carboxyhemoglobin Measurement Limitations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.2 Boat-Related Carbon Monoxide Poisonings Resulting in Death . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4.3 Carbon Monoxide Exposure as a Drowning Risk Factor . . . . . . . . . 7.4.4 Non-Fatal Boat-Related Carbon Monoxide Poisonings . . . . . . . . . . Boats and CO Sources Related to Marine Poisonings, with Case Study Presentations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5.1 Ski Boats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5.2 Cabin Cruisers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5.3 Houseboats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Airborne Carbon Monoxide Concentrations Measured on and Near Boats. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.1 Methods for Measuring, Analyzing, and Evaluating CO in Air . . 7.6.2 Carbon Monoxide Concentrations Associated with Boat-Related CO Poisonings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.2.1 Ski Boats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.2.2 Cabin Cruisers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.2.3 Houseboats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6.2.4 Carbon Monoxide Exposure in Areas of Congested Boat Traffic (Lake Havasu Study). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
158 159 160 160 161 161 161 162 164 164 164 165 166 166 166 170 171 175 175 177 177 177 178 179 157
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 157 — #1
158
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
7.7
180
Prevention Efforts. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.1 U.S. Coast Guard Regulation of Boat Manufacturing/Recall Authority . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.2 Environmental Protection Agency Regulation of Marine Engine Emissions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.3 State Legislative Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.4 Effectiveness of Marine Carbon Monoxide Detector/Alarms in Prevention . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.4.1 Case-Based Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.4.2 Marine Carbon Monoxide Detector Evaluation . . . . . . . . 7.7.5 Engineering Control Research and Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.6 Innovations in EMS Medical Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.8 Summary and Future Directions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.9 Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
180 181 182 183 183 183 184 187 188 190 191
7.1 INTRODUCTION Although carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning has been recognized since the earliest medical writings, CO exposure continues to be a major cause of death and illness. Many fatal and nonfatal exposures go undetected and unreported. The development of effective prevention programs is severely hampered by the absence of a centralized, coordinated surveillance system. CO poisonings in the marine environment began receiving attention as early as 1984, with poisonings occurring inside living quarters (also referred to as the boat cabin) being recognized early on.1 In 1990 and 1991, the United States Coast Guard (USCG), responsible for regulating recreational boat manufacture, investigated issues related to intrusion of engine exhaust into boat cabins.2,3 CO poisoning associated with occupancy of cabins of recreational boats was first described in the scientific literature in 1995.4 Subsequently, the American Boat and Yacht Council (ABYC—a nonprofit membership organization that develops safety standards for boat building and repair) developed standards for CO detection systems for boats manufactured after July 31, 1998.5 However, CO poisonings occurring outside the boat cabin were another matter. Reports of outdoor CO poisonings in any setting are scant.6−9 Published reports of boat-related CO poisoning outside of a boat cabin, in which the boat occupant was swimming behind a motorboat10 and behind a houseboat11 appeared in 1998. The absence of data on outdoor CO poisonings confused National Park Service (NPS) Emergency Medical Services (EMS) providers on Lake Powell (within the Glen Canyon National Recreation Area—GCNRA) who had noticed a number of poisoning incidents involving boat occupants losing consciousness outdoors, beginning in the early 1990s. Through the early years of these poisonings, park officials sought evidence of other outdoor CO poisonings, but failed to find documentation of this problem elsewhere in the United States. When the first verified fatal marine CO poisoning occurred at Lake Powell in 1994, NPS EMS personnel had treated a total of 29 nonfatal CO poisonings associated with boats.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 158 — #2
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
159
On an August evening in 1994, NPS officials at the GCNRA dispatch center received an emergency call from boaters requesting assistance regarding the possible drowning of a 12-year old boy. Three boys had been swimming near the rear of a houseboat while family members were inside the air-conditioned living quarters of the boat. One of the boys became ill, and parents took him inside the boat to rest, attributing his illness to the hot weather. The other two boys continued swimming. The victim (the second boy) was on the swim platform at the time and complained to his companion about his legs feeling funny. The third boy climbed onboard and went inside the boat, complaining to his mother that he, too, did not feel well. The victim remained on the swim platform at the rear of the boat while others attended to his companion. Nearly an hour later, the group discovered that the victim was missing and began to search for him, concurrently summoning NPS assistance. NPS divers recovered the boy’s body from 21 ft. of water more than 2 h later. During the course of their investigation of this drowning, NPS discovered that the onboard gasoline-powered generator had been operating when the boys were swimming, and communicated this information to the medical examiner. As a result, a carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) analysis was requested as part of the autopsy. The analysis, repeated due to the high initial concentration, revealed a COHb of 61% documenting that the boy’s drowning was secondary to CO poisoning, the source of which was the generator.12 Although NPS requested assistance from the USCG after this boy’s death, and again in 1998 when two CO-related drownings occurred within 12 days of each other behind houseboats of a similar design, active response was lacking. This changed in August 2000, when two brothers, Dillon and Logan Dixey (aged 8 and 11 years), swimming at the rear of their family houseboat on Lake Powell, died as a result of CO poisoning. Their deaths were quick, occurring within minutes of exposure to generator exhaust under the swim deck, and were strikingly similar to five previously recognized fatalities on this lake behind houseboats of the same design. The brothers’ deaths, combined with the growing body of evidence at Lake Powell, triggered an interagency, multidisciplinary investigation, the goal of which was to identify effective prevention strategies at this lake.13 The interagency investigation rapidly grew to cover similar poisonings nationwide, with a number of local, state, and federal governmental agencies, individual boat and equipment manufacturers, boat rental companies, trade organizations, nonprofit organizations representing consumers, and individual boaters joining the effort to identify poisonings and interventions.
7.2 IDENTIFYING MARINE CO POISONINGS Data discussed in this chapter were derived from a variety of sources, and vary in level of documentation and detail available from the source. The most important thing to remember is that these are not all the poisonings that have occurred, but rather are the poisonings we know about from the sources discussed below. Case data are influenced by reporting bias (such cases were not recognized early on, recognition of cases has improved only slightly, awareness of reporting requirements is scant, and many cases
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 159 — #3
160
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
were reported because of increased news coverage); and misdiagnosis of disease and death etiology (many deaths were and are classified as drownings that were actually CO poisonings first).
7.2.1 IDENTIFICATION OF MARINE CO POISONINGS AT LAKE POWELL Todate, nearly 1/3 of all recognized cases occurred at Lake Powell, and were identified through extensive case-finding research conducted jointly by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC), National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), the Medical Advisor for Prehospital Care at GCNRA, NPS GCNRA staff, and the US Department of the Interior. The isolation of the lake, and related centralization of NPS emergency response and patient transport, resulted in early identification and thorough documentation of fatal and nonfatal marine poisonings by Glen Canyon NPS medical and law enforcement personnel. Computerized and hard copy records were abstracted to identify and describe Lake Powell CO poisonings.14 These included: NPS GCNRA law enforcement dispatch logs; NPS EMS response sheets; Page Hospital Emergency Department treatment records; hospital discharge data; and medical examiner/coroner autopsy reports.
7.2.2 IDENTIFICATION OF MARINE CO POISONINGS NATIONWIDE In the United States, data related to boating accidents are collected through the USCG Boating Accident Report Database (BARD), which provides vital information for USCG regulation of the manufacture and recall of recreational boats and boatingrelated equipment. Data used to compile the BARD statistics come from two sources: (1) Boating Accident Report data forwarded electronically to the USCG by recognized reporting authorities, typically the state boating law administrator in each state; and (2) reports of USCG investigations of fatal boating accidents that occurred on waters under Federal jurisdiction.15 To obtain the most accurate data, BARD relies as much as possible on recreational boating accident investigations conducted by local law enforcement personnel and submitted to the USCG electronically by the recognized reporting authority. In the absence of investigational data, information is collected from accident reports filed by recreational boat operators, who are required to report boating accidents that involve the vessel or its equipment.16 Included in the USCG database are recreational boat-related or equipment-related accidents in which: 1. A person dies; or 2. A person is injured and requires medical treatment beyond first aid, that is, treatment at a medical facility or by a medical professional other than at the accident scene; or
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 160 — #4
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
161
3. Damage to vessels and other property totals $2000 or more or there is a complete loss of any vessel; or 4. Aperson disappears from the vessel under circumstances that indicate death or injury. CO poisonings were specifically added to the listed USCG reporting guidelines in 2001, in response to confusion expressed among the reporting authorities as to whether recreational marine CO poisonings met the reporting requirements. Thus, a fraction of marine CO poisonings were reported to the Coast Guard prior to 2001.
7.2.3 ADDITIONAL CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING CASE IDENTIFICATION Intense national news coverage of the poisonings at Lake Powell, as well as technical presentations and other information dissemination, resulted in the identification of additional cases by researchers closely identified with this issue. The pattern that emerged from collection of related records from these independently identified cases indicated a broader problem, and pointed to emerging problems nationwide related to the design of houseboats and swim platforms on other types of motorboats. These randomly identified cases were added to those identified in the Lake Powell investigation and those contained in BARD to comprise a document now known as the National Case Listing.17 Data discussed below are derived from the January 2006 listing and analysis of the supporting database.
7.3 DESCRIPTIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF KNOWN MARINE CARBON MONOXIDE POISONINGS 7.3.1 DEMOGRAPHICS, DISTRIBUTION, AND OUTCOME OF POISONINGS The National Case Listing contains detailed information about 607 US boat-related CO poisonings requiring medical treatment or emergency response occurring on water bodies in or adjacent to 32 states. Further information is described in publications by the CDC.13,18,19 One-hundred-twenty-two (20%) of the 607 people died as a result of the poisoning. Ninety-eight percent of the poisonings occurred between 1990 and 2005. Age was known for 432 (71%) of the cases: 42% of the 432 cases were children (aged 18 or younger). Gender was known for 393 (64%) of the cases, which was fairly evenly divided between males (204 or 52%) and females (189 or 48%). Figures 7.1 through 7.3 show the distribution of cases by year, month, and state. The decline in cases in 2005, shown in Figure 7.1, is primarily an effect of the time lapse between the occurrence of the incident and reporting or verification of the case. (As of this writing, we have preliminary information regarding 13 additional cases for 2005.) Monthly distribution of marine CO poisonings is opposite that of
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 161 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
162
Number of boat-related CO poisonings by year Total poisonings identified =607
Date of chart: 1/2006
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 unk
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
1990
1989
1988
1987
1986
1985
1984
0
Fatal
Non–fatal
FIGURE 7.1 Distribution of boat-related carbon monoxide poisonings by year. Distribution of boat-related CO poisonings by month
Number of people poisoned
120 100 80 60 40 20
K N U
EC D
O V N
T C O
P SE
G AU
L JU
N JU
AY M
R AP
AR M
B FE
JA N
0
FIGURE 7.2 Distribution of boat-related carbon monoxide poisonings by month.
other poisonings (higher in the summer instead of higher in the winter) and reflects the pattern of boat use.
7.3.2 LOCATION OF THE VICTIM AND SOURCE OF CARBON MONOXIDE Location (on the boat) was known for 546 of the cases. Two of every three victims (353/546) were documented to be inside the boat’s living quarters when poisoned.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 162 — #6
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
1
163
1
13 15 7
7
1 30
Lake powell 176 (29%)
19* 1
5
*Excludes lake powell cases
15
1 6 3
5
44
30
10
29
2 22*
2
1
45
3
4
2 4 20
1
12
Location unspecified 39 17
FIGURE 7.3 Distribution of boat-related carbon monoxide poisonings by state.
These poisonings in the boat cabin occurred in 88 incidents primarily involving multiple victims (as many as 17 victims at a time). In contrast, 190 people were poisoned outside the boat cabin, in 149 incidents which were more likely to involve one to three victims. Thus, the higher number of incidents of poisoning occurred outside the boat. The specific location of the victim was documented for 100 of the CO-related deaths, with 56 of the victims exposed to CO outside the boat’s living quarters, 44 exposed inside the living quarters or within a full boat canopy. Location on the boat was characterized for 446 of the 485 survivors of marine CO poisonings: 309 were exposed to CO inside the boat cabin in 69 incidents; 134 were exposed outside a boat cabin in 103 incidents; and 3 people (1 incident) were characterized as having been at various locations inside and outside. Again, although more poisoning survivors were inside boats when poisoned, more incidents occurred outside boat cabins. The specific source of CO exposure was documented for 487 of the 607 poisonings. Exhaust from onboard gasoline-powered marine generators used to produce electricity for onboard appliances (air-conditioners, televisions, refrigerators, etc.) was the most common source, linked to 302 of the 480 poisonings. Gasoline-powered propulsion engine exhaust was linked to 168 poisonings. Twelve people were exposed to exhaust from both types of engines (generators and propulsion engines) when they were poisoned. Source was undifferentiated (e.g., the record said “engine exhaust” or “exhaust fumes” but did not clearly define which engine) or unspecified for 120 cases. At this point, there are no poisonings known to have been associated with marine diesel-powered engines of either type.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 163 — #7
164
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
7.4 MEDICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE CASES Medical characteristics of marine CO poisonings to be discussed here include COHb as an indicator of exposure, death and loss of consciousness (LOC) as indicators of exposure severity, and Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS—a scale that assesses the degree of brain function) as a measure of victim status when EMS personnel arrived on the scene.
7.4.1 CARBOXYHEMOGLOBIN MEASUREMENT LIMITATIONS Many boat-related CO poisonings occur while the victim is swimming near the boat. In such incidents, the victim loses consciousness, sinks into the water or lays face down in the water, ultimately drowning as a result of the poisoning. As such, COHb concentrations are often lower than those typically associated with CO-related fatalities. As is true with all CO poisonings, there is no consistency regarding timing of the COHb measurement. Reported COHb concentrations must be viewed as indicators of exposure, because of the many factors impacting that measurement (i.e., oxygen therapy duration, number of half-lives that have passed since the CO exposure ended, activity level of the victim between exposure cessation and COHb measurement, etc.). COHb analysis related to fatal boat-related poisoning may be complicated by the fact that victims who are poisoned and subsequently drowned sometimes are submerged for extended periods before their bodies are found. In such cases, body decomposition, and related degradation of blood cells, may impact the ability to accurately measure COHb.
7.4.2 BOAT-RELATED CARBON MONOXIDE POISONINGS RESULTING IN DEATH COHb concentrations were available for 50 of the 122 marine CO-related fatalities. Six of those 50 people received oxygen therapy prior to blood analysis. Reported COHb concentrations for people that were poisoned outside the cabin ranged from 1.9% (after 440 min of oxygen treatment by intubation) to 100%. The related estimated CO exposure duration for these victims was surprisingly short, ranging from 30 s to 30 min. Most (47) of the 56 people who died as a result of poisoning outside the boat’s living quarters were in the water when they were exposed to CO, likely losing consciousness and sinking. Reported duration of submersion for those that drowned as a result of the poisoning ranged from 5 min to 13 days. Six people that died outside the living quarters were on the boat, either sitting in the rear seat or rear section of the boat, or leaning over the transom. Specific location of the victim was unknown for three people. COHb concentrations for deaths that occurred inside the cabin or a full canopy ranged from 27% to 77%. With one exception, the people that died in the cabin of boats had gone there to sleep or watch videos, and were found dead the following morning when someone had noticed them missing, or when someone noticed the boat adrift. The exception to this is an incident in which four children were found
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 164 — #8
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
Swim platform
165
Zippered canopy opening
FIGURE 7.4 Cabin cruiser with full canopy deployed.
unconscious (one of which was dead) in the rear area of a cabin cruiser boat that was covered with a full canopy (see Figure 7.4). The children were using a shower device that drew heated water from the operating propulsion engine’s cooling system. They unzipped a panel in the canopy and stood on the swim platform to use the shower hose. About 45 min after they had gone to the boat to shower, two of the boys were found unconscious on the bed in the boat cabin, and two (one of which died) were found unconscious in the area covered by the canopy. CO from the operating propulsion engine had apparently entered the canopied area and cabin. The COHb of the boy who died was 46.6%.
7.4.3 CARBON MONOXIDE EXPOSURE AS A DROWNING RISK FACTOR To assess the proportion of drownings and boat-related drownings for which CO poisoning was a contributing or primary cause of death, drownings that occurred on Lake Powell from 1994 to 2004 were identified.14 (The starting point was based on the year of the first confirmed CO-related drowning at Lake Powell.) Seventy-two people died of unintentional drowning within GCNRA during that time period. Seventeen percent (12 of the 72 people) of all drownings were CO-related. Twenty-five of the 72 people drowned in BARD-reportable boat-related accidents. This meant that nearly half (12/25) of all the boat-related drownings at Lake Powell were CO-related. These surprising numbers indicate that CO exposure may be a factor in many more drownings on other open water bodies than are currently recognized. This under-recognition is likely to continue unless COHb analyses are routinely included in autopsy protocols and hospital emergency room patient care procedures.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 165 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
166
To assess under-reporting of these cases, researchers examined the Coast Guard surveillance system (BARD) data and found that one of three Lake Powell boatrelated drownings were absent from BARD, and that CO-related and nonCO-related drownings were missing in similar proportions.
7.4.4 NON-FATAL BOAT-RELATED CARBON MONOXIDE POISONINGS As mentioned earlier, 485 people are known to have survived marine CO poisoning that required at least emergency medical treatment. It is important to remember that these patients did not always have easy access to transport (because they are out on a lake, river, or ocean), and that transport to a local hospital where blood is drawn (or equipment for breath analysis is available) often takes a while. These delays impact the COHb result significantly, especially if oxygen is being delivered to the patient during a lengthy transport. COHb concentrations were available for 128 of these poisoning victims, of which nearly half (i.e., 63) were treated with oxygen prior to COHb analysis (ranging from 10 to 645 min in duration). Measured COHb ranged from 1.9% to 47.8%. Information about LOC was available for 250 of the 485 survivors of poisoning, and just over half (i.e., 130) of the 250 were documented to have lost consciousness. GCS ratings were available for 112 of the survivors, with assessment ratings ranging from 3 (unconscious and unresponsive to deep pain) to 15 (indicating normal mental status at the time of EMS response and assessment). It was striking to note that 85 of the 112 GCS-rated patients were assessed as having normal mental status (GCS of 15), despite the fact that nearly 40% (33) of those patients reported profound LOC during their exposure to CO. Half of these patients (17/33) were evaluated by EMS personnel within 10–35 min of experiencing LOC, indicating that CO poisoning etiology can be easily missed if emergency response personnel do not know that CO exposures outside of an enclosure can result in rapid, serious poisoning.
7.5 BOATS AND CO SOURCES RELATED TO MARINE POISONINGS, WITH CASE STUDY PRESENTATIONS Types of boats involved in marine poisonings are categorized as follows: ski boats; cabin cruisers; houseboats; other pleasurecraft (fishing boat, personal water craft, etc.), or unspecified. The distribution of poisonings by boat is shown in Table 7.1, and are discussed below.
7.5.1 SKI BOATS Ski boats are typically a high-performance craft designed for speed and agility. They vary in size, but are typically about 21 ft. long and about 8 ft. wide. Ski boats associated with the outside poisonings (shown in Figures 7.4–7.6) are typically equipped with a high horsepower (310–400 hp) gasoline-fueled inboard direct-drive propulsion
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 166 — #10
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
167
TABLE 7.1 Distribution of Marine Carbon Monoxide Poisonings by Boat Type Boat Type Ski Cabin cruiser Houseboat Other or unknown Total by outcome
Inside Cabin 0 31 2 11 44
Fatal Outside Cabin 23 3 23 7 56
Unknown Location 0 4 0 18 22
Inside Cabin 0 102 177 30 309
Nonfatal Outside Cabin 45 14 54 21 134
Unknown Location 3 4 1 34 42
Total by Boat Type 71 158 257 121 607
Swim platform
Exhaust
Propeller
FIGURE 7.5 Ski boat transom, platform, exhaust, and propeller configuration.
engine, the propeller of which is under the belly of the boat and thus removed from close proximity to the victim and thought by many to be out of harm’s way. Most of these boats have a water level rear platform (see Figure 7.5) used to facilitate easy access to the water and donning of ski and wakeboard gear. Engine exhaust is dual piped, exiting the boat hull just below the rear platform. All fatal and nonfatal poisonings associated with ski boats occurred outside of any enclosure, and were caused by exposure to propulsion engine exhaust (this class of boat is not typically equipped with a generator). The details of these incidents are strikingly similar: 45 (63%) of 71 people poisoned on this type of boat were sitting on or holding onto the swim platform; 18 of the 45 people died and 27 of them survived poisoning (19 of whom experienced LOC). The ages of victims occupying the swim platform ranged from 2 to 23 years. Five people were poisoned, four of whom lost consciousness, while occupying the padded sunning deck at the rear of ski boats.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 167 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
168 (a)
“Teak surfing” or “platform dragging” Surfer Displacement wave
Engine exhaust outlet (x2) Vessel is operated at a speed that will create the largest possible displacement wave, usually 10–12 miles per hour
(b)
Boat transom (rear wall)
FIGURE 7.6 Teak surfing. (a) Side-view showing position of surfer, (b) View toward transom of boat showing same.
Much media, legislative, and educational attention has centered on a thrill seeking activity that has been labeled as “teak surfing” or “dragging” (shown in Figures 7.6 and 7.7), in which the person holds onto the rear swim platform (which is often made of teakwood, thus the term “teak surfing”) until the boat reaches a speed (typically 10–12 mph) and orientation that allows them to briefly release their grasp and be pulled forward by the displacement wave directly behind the boat. Five of the poisonings associated with platform occupancy (three fatal and two nonfatal) occurred during teak surfing. The predominance of incidents associated with platform occupancy actually occurred when the boat was moving at idle speed (5 mph) through the water, while the victim was being pulled from here to there, or was sitting on the platform dangling his/her feet in the water. In addition, one person who died on the platform and eight survivors were sitting there while the ski-boat was not moving at all, but the propulsion engine was idling. One of the later incidents involved the poisoning of a 4-year-old girl exposed to propulsion engine exhaust while she sat on the swim platform, playing with a shower device that is fed hot water by the operating engine. (This is the same device previously mentioned in Section 7.4.2) Case 1. In June 2001, an 18-year-old passenger of a ski-boat drowned in Lake Powell as a result of CO poisoning. Three of the ten boat passengers were being
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 168 — #12
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
169
Exhaust
Propeller
FIGURE 7.7 Position of teak surfer relative to engine exhaust terminus and propeller.
pulled behind the boat, teak surfing. Approximately 2 min after they began, one of the teenagers was unable to maintain her hold on the platform. She was reported as having “jerky arm movements” and difficulty in communicating. She was pulled into the boat by the passengers. Not recognizing the cause of her symptoms, another teen took her position on the platform, and they began teak surfing again. Approximately 1–2 min later, one of the three teens began to experience a severe headache and weakness. This teen pulled herself up onto the swim platform while the boat continued to move forward. The third surfer, still positioned for teak surfing, suddenly lost consciousness and released his hold on the platform. He sank beneath the surface. His body was retrieved from the water 3 days later. His COHb on autopsy was 57%. Case 2. In July 2000, a 15-year-old girl survived CO poisoning while she was lying on the rear padded sunning deck of a ski-boat on Lake Minnetonka in Minnesota. Boat occupants were waiting for a fireworks display, with the propulsion engine operating to power the onboard music system. Other occupants thought the girl was sleeping until they tried unsuccessfully to awaken her. She had stopped breathing. Her COHb measured upon transport to the local hospital was 30%. Case 3. In July 2005, a 21-year-old woman drowned as a result of CO poisoning. The woman was boating on the Gulf of Mexico with her husband and a group of friends in a 21 ft. ski boat. She and her husband were floating in the water, holding on to the swim platform of the stationary boat. The boat operator started the engine and began moving at about 5 miles per h when the woman slipped from the platform and sank. Her husband was unable to locate her. Several hours later, her body rose to the water’s surface and was discovered. Her COHb upon autopsy was 67%.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 169 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
170
FIGURE 7.8 Cabin cruiser.
7.5.2 CABIN CRUISERS A cabin cruiser is generally a large motorboat that has a cabin, and plumbing and other conveniences necessary for living onboard. The hull of a cabin cruiser (see Figure 7.8) is shaped like a conventional motorboat. Many modern cabin cruisers are equipped with air-conditioning and other electrical appliances that necessitate the use of an onboard generator for power. Most (31) of the 44 deaths inside a boat of any kind occurred in a cabin cruiser. Source of CO was known for 24 of the 31 deaths occurring in cabin cruisers: 18 of these deaths were associated with generator exhaust that infiltrated into the cabin; 5 from propulsion engine exhaust; and 1 from emissions from both types of engine. Four deaths occurred outside cabin cruisers, with the source being generator exhaust in three of the deaths and propulsion engine exhaust in the remaining incident. Case 4. In June 2005, a 36-year-old man and his 35-year-old wife died of CO poisoning while inside a cabin cruiser. The couple’s boat was moored at Lake George Inlet, Florida near two other boats; all three boats’ generators were operating to power the air-conditioners. When the victims’ generator ran out of gas at about 10:00 a.m., friends opened the door and found the occupants’ bodies. When emergency workers entered the cabin, they found high concentrations of CO. It was unclear if the CO was from the boat on which the couple died, or from the combined exhaust of all three generators. Autopsy results revealed that the husband’s COHb was 75.2%; the wife’s COHb was 77.2%.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 170 — #14
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
171
Case 5. In September 2001, a 62-year-old man was swimming near his cabin cruiser boat on Shasta Lake, California, talking with his wife who was on the boat. The boat was not moving, but the propulsion engine was operating at the time, charging the boat batteries. The man went to the swim platform at the rear of the boat to rest. While resting for approximately 1–3 min, he started splashing water at his wife. His eyes then became fixed, and he lost consciousness. His wife tried to pull him from the water, but couldn’t. She moved his body to a nearby island. Although the medical examiner initially listed his cause of death as a heart attack, this was changed upon receipt of forensic toxicological test results two months later indicating that his COHb concentration was 89.3%. The test was repeated, this time indicating a COHb concentration of 80.8%. Case 6. In August 2002, two 9-year-old girls were poisoned outside of a moored cabin cruiser on Lake Powell. One girl died and one survived. They were observed playing in shallow water (about 30 in. deep) near the rear of the boat very near the exhaust terminus of the operating generator. One girl was called into the boat by her parents, and when she climbed out of the water onto the swim platform, she stumbled and fell onto the floor. She was thought to be suffering from dehydration. The other girl was discovered to be missing about 15–30 min later. She was found lying on the bottom of the lake. Attempts to resuscitate her were unsuccessful. The survivor’s COHb was 15.1% after more than 70 min of oxygen therapy. The girl who died had a COHb of 39% after more than 40 min of resuscitative efforts, including CPR and intubation.
7.5.3 HOUSEBOATS A houseboat typically looks a bit like a house trailer mounted on a large floating barge (referred to as a monohull) or pontoons. Houseboats vary substantially in size, with some reaching 90 ft. in length and 16 ft. in width, dependent upon the requirements of the purchaser, restrictions of the water body on which the boat will be placed, transport restrictions, and so forth. Many of the fatal poisonings associated with houseboats (and all of the fatal houseboat poisonings on Lake Powell) were related to a specific design, shown in Figures 7.9 through 7.11. This design incorporates a monohull structure with an attached extended swim deck at the rear of the boat. The rear deck structure creates a cavity or air space between the hull and the water level swim platform. Exhaust of both propulsion engines, and sometimes that of the gasoline-powered generator, is directed into this air space, which came to be referred to by many as the “Death Zone” (a designation that will be used throughout this chapter for ease of reference). When the engines or the generator are operating, the build-up of CO in this cavity is so high that it creates an imminent danger of death for anyone who enters the cavity. Exhaust lingers in this cavity for on extended period following deactivation of either type of engine. CO poisonings have also been associated with the very high CO concentrations measured on or near the swim platform of houseboats. The common practice of continuous generator operation to provide power for air-conditioning, entertainment centers, and electronic suites while the houseboat is moored has exacerbated the problem.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 171 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
172
Living quarters/ boat cabin
Swim step
Extended deck
Engine compartment
FIGURE 7.9 Houseboat design associated with fatalities.
Propulsion engine outdrive
Generator exhaust terminus
FIGURE 7.10 Cavity beneath the extended deck (showing one of two propulsion engine outdrives and rear-directed generator exhaust location) - commonly referred to as “the Death Zone”.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 172 — #16
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
173
Exhaust from engine and generator
DANGER! Air pocket and water under step Swim platform
Used by permission. Copyrigh 2007 Boat Ed www.boat-ed.com
FIGURE 7.11 Diagramatic depiction of exhaust accumulation within the cavity.
Poisonings outside of houseboats were typically attributed to exposure to generator exhaust (15 fatalities and 44 nonfatal poisonings). In other incidents, the source of CO was a combination of generator and propulsion engine exhaust (two deaths and one nonfatal). Five people were poisoned by propulsion engine exhaust only (two deaths and three nonfatal). All poisonings that occurred inside the living quarters of houseboats (2 fatalities in 1 incident; 177 nonfatal poisonings in 27 incidents) were attributed to generator exhaust infiltrating the cabin. Case 7. In July 2004, a 34-year-old woman drowned and two others lost consciousness as a result of CO poisoning on Perry Lake, Kansas. A group of women were swimming behind several tethered (rafted) houseboats on which one or more generators were operating. There was little wind when the incident occurred. Two of the women were found unconscious. One of the women was not breathing, but was revived, and the second was unconscious and unresponsive. A few minutes later, someone noted that the third woman was missing. Her body was recovered approximately 30 min later. On autopsy, her COHb was 45%. Case 8. In September 2002, a 42-year-old man entered the airspace beneath the extended rear deck of a houseboat on Lake Powell shortly after the propulsion engines were deactivated. Just prior to the incident, the boat occupants were attempting to moor the boat during windy weather. As they maneuvered the boat, the anchor ropes became entangled in one of the engine propellers. Just after the engines were deactivated (estimated to be more than 3, but less than 5 min), the victim entered the air space beneath the stern deck to remove the lines from the propeller. He was wearing
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 173 — #17
174
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
a personal floatation device (PFD) at the time. After his first entry into the airspace (estimated to have lasted about 2 min), he emerged and removed the PFD because he was unable to access the propeller. After approximately 2 min, he entered the space again, and stayed there about 2 min. He emerged for 2 min, and then re-entered the space a third time. After about 2–3 min elapsed, he no longer responded to questions from the boat occupants and failed to emerge from the space. His overall time of exposure was thought to have been 6 min, with a total of approximately 15 min transpiring before he was no longer heard from. Although divers made many attempts to find him, they were unsuccessful. His body floated to the surface 3 days later. Autopsy results indicated that his COHb was 51%. Case 9. In June 1998, a 4-year-old girl was swimming at Lake of the Ozarks, Missouri with a group of children behind the rear deck of a houseboat. She was wearing a PFD, and was under the direct supervision of adult swimmers. She swam to the swim platform, held on to the ladder while her mother applied sunscreen to her face, and then swam away. Within moments she was observed floating face up on the water, unconscious, and rigid. She was quickly brought into the boat where her mother, a registered nurse, checked her for respirations and pulse. She appeared pale and stiff at that time, was unresponsive with poor respiratory effort. After 2–3 min of aggressive stimulation, the child began responding with grunts but was described as disoriented and sleepy. Paramedics were called and arrived 10–15 min later. They administered oxygen and transported the child to the nearest hospital emergency department within 30–45 min. Her COHb level at the hospital after approximately 1 h of oxygen therapy was 22.2%. Upon examining the houseboat during their next visit to the lake, the child’s parents discovered that the exhaust terminus for the onboard generator that was operating at the time of this poisoning was located at the edge of the swim platform, in the center of the rungs of the ladder that the child was holding onto when the sun screen was applied. Case 10. In June 2000, 15 people, ages ranging from 16 to 47 years, were overcome by CO on two rented houseboats on Lake Cumberland, Kentucky. The boats were tied together and anchored in a cove. Both boats had gasoline-fueled generators; the generator on one of the boats had a side-directed exhaust terminus. The exhaust of one of the generators seeped into the adjacent boat through an open bathroom window. CO was circulated through the full interior of the boat by the central air-conditioning system. A few boat occupants awoke at about 5:00 a.m. with headaches and nausea. Realizing they had a problem, the group radioed the marina and ambulances met the boats at the shore. The water patrol officer that responded to the emergency witnessed that two occupants were unconscious when he arrived, and others were drifting in and out of consciousness. All 15 people were treated at the emergency department of a nearby hospital; 3 were admitted as hospital inpatients for further treatment. There were six CO detector/alarms on this boat, but none were properly connected when the boat was inspected after the poisoning incident.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 174 — #18
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
175
7.6 AIRBORNE CARBON MONOXIDE CONCENTRATIONS MEASURED ON AND NEAR BOATS 7.6.1 METHODS FOR MEASURING, ANALYZING, AND EVALUATING CO IN AIR Four methods, each with different upper range of measurement capability, were used for collecting CO air samples in the investigations discussed below. Method 1: Direct-reading infrared instruments, more conventionally used to measure CO directly in engine emissions, were used to analyze air samples of very high CO concentrations (i.e., collected in the “Death Zone” and on swim platforms) from houseboats and ski boats. Emissions analyzers are capable of measuring CO in the ranges of percentages (1% CO equals 10,000 ppm) as high as 100%, and also measure oxygen concentration. Method 2: Direct-reading instruments with electrochemical sensor technology were used to measure CO in concentrations between 0 and 1000 ppm. These sensors can be damaged when exposed to excessive CO concentrations for extended periods. Method 3: Detector tubes (a glass tube filled with media that changes color when CO in air is passed through it) capable of measuring 30,000–70,000 ppm were used primarily to confirm ranges of measurement, and to indicate which technology could be safely used in different locations of measurement. Method 4: A laboratory analytical method was used to confirm very high CO concentrations measured by direct-reading instruments. Grab samples were collected using glass air-evacuated containers, which were then shipped to a laboratory for analysis. The sample inside each vial was then analyzed for a number of components, including CO and oxygen. This method was capable of analyzing 0–100% CO, as well as oxygen concentration. How much CO is too much? The answer to this question involves both duration of exposure (minutes, hours, days, etc.) and air concentration. Units of measure for CO concentration in air are parts of CO per million parts of air (ppm). Exposure to CO concentrations (in ppm) results in a rise in CO in the blood, referred to as COHb—expressed as percent saturation. Various health and safety agencies recommend or require limits for CO in air. Table 7.2 shows the limits for general populations and for workers. These limits are presented as evaluation criteria to help the reader understand the hazard associated with the air sampling data presented below.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 175 — #19
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
176
TABLE 7.2 Evaluation Criteria for Carbon Monoxide
Agency
Intent of the Limit
US Environmental Protection Agency
Established to protect the most sensitive members of the general population by maintaining increases in COHb to less than 2.1%77
World Health Organization
Recommendations established to protect the general population by maintaining increases in COHb to less than 2.5% when a normal subject engages in light or moderate exercise78
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
The 8-h limit is recommended to protect workers from health effects associated with COHb levels in excess of 5%. The IDLH (Immediately Dangerous to Life and Health) limit is recommended as a concentration at which an immediate or delayed threat to life exists or at which an individual’s ability to escape unaided from a space would be compromised. The ceiling limit is recommended based on acute effects of exposure79
Limit (in parts of CO per million parts of air) 35
1h
9 87
8h 15 min
52 26 9 1200
30 min 1h 8h IDLH value
200
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
The 8 h limit is recommended to protect workers from increases in COHb levels in excess of 3.5%. The agency similarly recommends a Biological Exposure Index (BEI) of 3.5% COHb for end of shift exhaled breath analysis in nonsmoking workers80
Occupational Safety and Health Administration
Required limit to protect workers from health effects associated with a COHb of 8–10%81
Time Period
35 125
25 50
Ceiling limit— never to be exceeded 8h Excursion limit (5 times the 8-h standard)
8h 8h
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 176 — #20
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
177
7.6.2 CARBON MONOXIDE CONCENTRATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH BOAT-RELATED CO POISONINGS 7.6.2.1 Ski Boats In June and July 2001, CO air samples were taken as part of the investigation of the Lake Powell death of an 18-year-old boy that succumbed to exposure to CO while “teak surfing” (see Section 7.5.1, Case 1).20 CO concentrations as high as 23,800 ppm in the unobstructed airspace above the swim platform (where the teak surfer’s face and upper body would be during the activity) were measured. When the airflow above the platform was obstructed by a form simulating the shape of the upper torso of a person with extended arms (like a “teak surfer”), CO concentrations above the platform were consistently between 10,000 and 26,700 ppm, despite the fact that engine maintenance had been conducted. In an August 2001 Connecticut incident, a 15-year-old boy who was teak surfing for an estimated 10–15 min, released the platform, floated briefly, lost consciousness, and sank. His COHb measured during the autopsy was 56%.21 An investigation involving air sampling for CO was later conducted on the boat. (The upper limit for equipment used to measure CO in air for this investigation was 1000 ppm.) CO concentrations exceeded 1000 ppm on the swim platform (and in what would be the breathing zone of simulated swimmers/teak surfers) at varying engine speeds, and whether the platform was obstructed or unobstructed. The operator of the boat was exposed to as high as 410 ppm during idle, depending on the wind direction. Average concentrations consistently exceeded 200 ppm during the entire sampling event when the boat was operating.
7.6.2.2 Cabin Cruisers In response to reported incidents that identified a potential safety problem involving CO for recreational boater occupants inside cabins, the USCG contracted a study to evaluate intrusion of CO into the passenger areas of gasoline-powered recreational cabin cruiser boats.2 Tests results reported in 1991 showed that under certain conditions, CO accumulated in the passenger spaces at a rate of about 1 ppm per minute, posing a health and safety threat to occupants. In areas at the rear of the boat (on the transom, in the rear deck passenger area, etc.) peak CO concentrations as high as 400 ppm, and 30 min average concentrations as high as 272 ppm, were measured. The authors concluded: “It is apparent that the potential exists for a serious health and safety problem for power boaters.” Results of an interagency investigation of a fatal and nonfatal CO poisoning that occurred near a cabin cruiser were reported in 2002.22 (See Section 7.5.2, Case 6 for details of the incident.) CO concentrations as high as 41,600 ppm, and oxygen concentrations as low as 12%, were measured in the open air within inches of the boat’s generator exhaust terminus (approximately where the poisoned children were exposed). In addition, CO concentrations consistently exceeded the upper limit of the air monitors placed on the swim platform and at locations one and five ft. from the exhaust terminus, indicating that the CO concentration at these locations were
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 177 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
178
somewhere between 1000 ppm and the maximum value measured at the exhaust terminus (41,600 ppm). Concentrations as high as 570 ppm were measured 10 ft. away from the exhaust terminus. 7.6.2.3 Houseboats Unless otherwise specified, all data discussed below pertain to houseboats designed similarly to those in Figures 7.9 through 7.11. In 1995, a 43-year-old man died in Florida as a result of a 5-min CO exposure within the airspace under the extended rear deck of a houseboat. The boat’s electrical power generator, which released exhaust into the airspace, was activated just before he entered; propulsion engines were not operating. Approximately 5 min after he entered the airspace, he was observed unresponsive floating face down in the shallow water; he subsequently died. His COHb measured in the hospital 2 h after exposure, and after more than an hour of oxygen therapy, was 29.7%. A forensic toxicologist estimated that the man’s COHb was greater than 70% when he collapsed. CO concentrations measured as part of the investigation of this death were reported in legal proceedings.17 Inspection and testing of the houseboat revealed that CO concentrations in that airspace would reach 4,000–10,000 parts per million (ppm) within 2–5 min after the generator was activated. As part of the initial investigation of the death of two young brothers exposed to generator exhaust in the airspace under the rear deck of their family houseboat at Lake Powell in August 2000, the NPS conducted air sampling to define the incident circumstances.23 CO concentrations at water level below the rear deck of three similar houseboats exceeded 2000 ppm (which was the maximum CO concentration the instrument could measure) approximately 10 min after generator activation. CO measurements collected above the swim platforms of the three boats were 800, 100, and 1156 ppm. Two of the people conducting the test began to experience headache, mild nausea, and weakness while conducting this air sampling. As other agencies joined in the investigation of past and ongoing CO poisonings at Lake Powell, air sampling on houseboats continued. In September 2000, air sampling in the airspace beneath the rear deck on similar houseboats documented the following maximum CO concentrations: 13,000 ppm when one propulsion engine operated; 30,000 ppm when the generator operated (with concurrent oxygen deficiency, 13% measured); and 20,000 when both the propulsion engines and generator operated. CO concentrations exceeding 1200 ppm above and around the water level swim platform were also measured. Repeat testing in November, 2000 confirmed these very high concentrations of CO in the “Death Zone” of similar boats, as well as on the upper rear deck and swim platform.24 Further testing was conducted on houseboats at Lake Cumberland in Kentucky, with results reported in December, 2000.25 This study again documented that CO concentrations near and under the rear deck of houseboats were very high (4,078 ppm measured near water level off the back of the swim platform when the gasolinepowered generator operated, and 10,224 ppm measured at the same location when the generator and propulsion engines operated). These measurements confirmed that there was significant potential for poisonings on houseboats on lakes other than Lake
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 178 — #22
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
179
Powell. This study was the first to characterize emissions of diesel generators—with a maximum CO concentration of 10 ppm measured when the diesel generator operated near the exhaust terminus and at the back of the boat. However, when the gasoline motors were in operation, CO concentrations increased considerably, with 455 ppm measured on the swim platform. In March, 2003, an interagency group collected air sampling data as part of a supplemental investigation of a fatal poisoning at Lake Powell.26 (See Section 7.5.3, Case 8 for a description of the death.) The purpose was to provide further information about clearance of propulsion engine exhaust from the “Death Zone” airspace. (Previously reported data documented that the CO concentration in that airspace decayed to 0 ppm within 8 min following deactivation of the generator and propulsion engines.27 ) In repeated tests conducted on two boats in the 2003 study, rates of decay varied widely—with initial CO concentrations as high as 88,200 ppm decaying to 2 ppm in widely varying time periods (from 10 to 30 min), indicating that CO clearance times in that airspace are unpredictable, and could feasibly be much longer than documented in these tests. 7.6.2.4 Carbon Monoxide Exposure in Areas of Congested Boat Traffic (Lake Havasu Study) During summer holiday weekends, as many as 700 boats collect in the Bridgewater Channel of Lake Havasu at any given time, some moored to the shoreline of the channel and many cruising slowly through it (see Figure 7.12). The City of Lake Havasu estimates that about one-third of the boats in the channel have engines operating, representing exhaust roughly equivalent to that of 40,000 automobiles. As a result of initial reports of poisonings occurring in an area congested with boats at Lake Havasu, Arizona, CO exposures among municipal employees and visitors at the Bridgewater Channel were evaluated through air sampling and expired breath measurements. Air sampling was conducted during summer holidays in 2002 and 2003, when boat traffic within the channel was congested.28 Initial sampling documented that CO concentrations in channel air exceeded all short-term exposure criteria listed in Table 7.2; and 4 of 12 boating patients reporting to a local hospital emergency department for any cause (injury, LOC, etc.) had COHb levels of 9.4–28.3%. In response to these findings, an interagency investigation of CO concentrations in the channel was conducted during Memorial Day weekend (May), and during June–September, 2003. These surveys documented excessive CO exposure and confirmed the health risk among vacationers and employees working in the channel near crowded motorboat gatherings, with a trend of higher exposures later in the day. Sixty-nine percent of monitored workshift exposures of 36 municipal employees involved short-term CO exposures that exceeded the NIOSH ceiling limit of 200 ppm. Overexposures were confirmed by postshift measurements of exhaled breath: 67% of sampled workshifts resulted in estimated COHb levels equal to or greater than the recommended limit of 3.5%,29 with the average COHb among nonsmoking employees increasing from 1% in the morning to 6% in the afternoon (maximum was 13%). Among 46 nonsmoking vacationers that volunteered for exhaled breath
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 179 — #23
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
180
FIGURE 7.12 Boats in Lake Havasu’s Bridgewater Channel.
measurements, the estimated COHb increased from a mean of 1% in the morning to 11% in the afternoon (maximum was 23%).19
7.7 PREVENTION EFFORTS 7.7.1 U.S. COAST GUARD REGULATION OF BOAT MANUFACTURING/RECALL AUTHORITY The USCG Recreational Boating Product Assurance Division of the Office of Boating Safety is responsible for such things as developing and enforcing federal safety standards and investigating consumer complaints. Specific responsibilities of the division includes inspecting and testing recreational boats for compliance, and issuing recalls of recreational boats and associated equipment. For this reason, boats are excluded from the jurisdiction of the US Consumer Product Safety Commission. After the August 2000 deaths of two brothers at Lake Powell (and related subsequent data collection), the Coast Guard determined that the houseboat design shown in Figures 7.9–7.11 (specifically a houseboat with an extended rear deck, water level swim platform, and rear-directed generator exhaust terminus that empties into the air space beneath the rear deck) was defective and fell within their recall jurisdiction. The agency contacted 71 houseboat builders, informing them about data documenting a deadly combination of generator exhaust and houseboat swim platforms on boats of this design.30 As a result of this and following mailings,
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 180 — #24
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
181
six manufacturers agreed to a voluntary recall.31 Initially, it was estimated that more than 2000 boats would have to be retrofitted with the new design suggested by manufacturers (rerouting rear-directed generator exhaust terminus from within the cavity to the side of the boat outside of the cavity), but that number was adjusted downward to 1087 boats. Manufacturers self-certified that over 800 boats were retrofitted as a result of the voluntary recalls.32 Side exhaust was seen as an improvement in design, but not a solution, as there had been poisonings associated with water level exhaust outside of any enclosure (such as the one formed by the cavity beneath the deck). In addition, the common practice of “rafting” several houseboats together raised concerns about side exhaust that would now be directed towards the next boat when the generator operated. The Coast Guard also acted to prevent poisonings associated with the use of a shower system at the back of the boat that draws heated water from the operating propulsion engine (thus exposing the user to propulsion engine exhaust). This device was associated with two poisoning incidents (one fatal and four nonfatal poisonings). In December 2005, the Coast Guard notified the manufacturer of the system that there were CO and other safety hazards for recreational boaters who use the shower system directly connected to the operating propulsion engine. The manufacturer responded with assurances that the system installation would be changed to eliminate connection to an operating propulsion engine, and that they would provide additional CO warnings in printed materials.30
7.7.2 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGULATION OF MARINE ENGINE EMISSIONS The Clean Air Act directs Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to regulate nonroad engines, a classification that includes marine propulsion engines and marine generators. Initial EPA regulations for gasoline-powered marine engines, published in 1996, pertained to outboard engines and personal watercraft only. These standards, phased in from 1998 to 2006, achieved approximately a 75% reduction in hydrocarbons (HC) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx ) from new engines. Although a cap in CO emissions was proposed in these regulations, none was finalized. However, some of the methods used to reduce outboard engine HC emissions also result in a reduction in CO emissions.33 In 2001, the California Air Resources Board adopted emission standards for new gasoline-powered sterndrive and inboard marine engines that are expected to require use of catalytic converters beginning in 2007.34 There are currently no federal standards for emissions from gasoline-fueled sterndrive and inboard marine propulsion engines. Consequently, while these engines remain uncontrolled, calculations conducted by Sonoma Technology, Inc. indicated that an average marine engine emits the same amount of CO as 188 automobiles35 EPA gave notice of its intent to develop a proposal for these engines in 2002.34 EPA regulates new gasoline-powered marine generators under 2 sets of rules. Rules for small generators (≤ 19 kW) vary depending on size of the engine, include limits for HC, NOx , and CO, and were phased in from 1997 to 2005. Regulations
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 181 — #25
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
182
relevant to large gasoline-powered marine generators (>19 kW) were effective in 2004, with substantial reductions in HC, NOx , and CO required for 2007 models.34
7.7.3 STATE LEGISLATIVE ACTION The National Association of State Boating Law Administrators (NASBLA) provides model language for individual state legislation related to boating safety. In 2003, NASBLA approved language related to marine CO poisoning, with revisions approved in 2005.36 The model act, referred to as the Safe Practices for Boat-Towed Watersports Act, and aimed at the practice referred to as “teak surfing”, included the following provisions: [Requirements.] a) No person shall operate a motorboat or have the engine of a motorboat run idle while a person is teak surfing, platform dragging, or body surfing behind the motorboat. b) No person shall operate a motorboat or have the engine of a motorboat run idle while a person is occupying or holding onto the swim platform, swim deck, swim step, or swim ladder of the motorboat. [Exemptions.] The provisions of this act do not apply when a person is occupying the swim platform, swim deck, swim step, or swim ladder while assisting with the docking or departure of the motorboat, while exiting or entering the motorboat, or while the motorboat is engaged in law enforcement activity. To date, five states have promulgated legislation or regulations intended to prevent marine CO poisonings, most using the model language proposed by NASBLA. Pennsylvania was the first state to revise boating regulations related to unacceptable boating practices in 2003.37 In 2004, the California State Legislature passed Assembly Bill (AB) 2222, the Anthony Farr and Stacy Beckett Boating Safety Act of 2004.38 This bill added to the NASBLA language by: 1. Requiring that all state-sponsored or approved boating safety courses include information about the dangers of CO poisoning at the stern of a motorized vessel and how to prevent that poisoning; 2. Requiring that any new or used motorized vessel, when sold, bear warning stickers as to the danger of CO poisoning on boats; and 3. Requiring that boat registration materials include similar informational about the dangers of CO poisoning and boats. Nevada followed in 200439 Oregon in 200540 and Washington state41 and Utah42 in 2006, each state adopting and embellishing the NASBLA model language.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 182 — #26
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
183
7.7.4 EFFECTIVENESS OF MARINE CARBON MONOXIDE DETECTOR/ALARMS IN PREVENTION 7.7.4.1 Case-Based Data Investigative records related to Lake Powell CO poisonings that occurred in the living quarters of houseboats were evaluated with regard to CO detector/alarm presence and function. From 1990 to 2004, 80 people survived poisonings inside houseboats in 15 incidents.14 Fifty of the eighty people were poisoned in boats that were known to have had CO detectors in the living quarters. However, in only one incident (four people poisoned) did the alarm sound alerting the occupants to the hazard. Twenty people were poisoned in three separate instances involving disarmed or “broken” detectors. Twenty-two people were poisoned in four instances involving functional detectors that failed to sound during the poisoning incident. Ten people were poisoned in a houseboat that was not equipped with CO detectors. Twenty people were poisoned in houseboats in which the record failed to document the absence or presence of detectors. In May 2005, an analysis of boat-related CO poisonings conducted by the National Marine Manufacturers Association (NMMA) pointed out that documentation was available regarding CO detectors in 12% (66) of 506 cases they analyzed, and for half of these cases (33), the exposure occurred with the CO detector disconnected.43 In 11 of the 66 cases (17%), the CO detector malfunctioned, and in only 1 of 66 poisonings did a CO detector sound. The failure of onboard CO detectors in the living quarters of houseboats on Lake Powell, as well as data related to detectors elsewhere, raises concern about the impact of such devices in CO-poisoning prevention. Improving the effectiveness of these devices is complex, as there were four types of problems identified, each indicating a different corrective strategy. (Identified problems included: failure to alarm; alarming when they shouldn’t; disarmed or dysfunctional detector; and absence of detectors.) Failure of functional detectors to warn occupants of high CO concentrations and the sounding of alarms for no discernable cause are related to detector sensor technology. A likely explanation of disabling of detectors by boaters is that the detectors are sounding frequently and the boater either cannot identify a cause for the alarm (also a detector technology issue) or cannot resolve the issue that is causing CO to enter the cabin (an issue related to boat design, technology, and boater education).
7.7.4.2 Marine Carbon Monoxide Detector Evaluation In 2004, the USCG Office of Boating Safety Recreational Boating Product Assurance Division released a contracted study of CO detector performance in the marine environment.44 The purpose of the study was to evaluate the reliability of CO detectors that, in 2002, were advertised as being suitable for marine environments. About 90 detectors (five different products) were evaluated; 54 had metal-oxide sensors, 18 had electrochemical sensors, and 18 had biomimetic sensors. The goal was to determine the impact of one or more factors (humidity, salinity, temperature
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 183 — #27
184
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
variants, or out-gassing of new boat construction materials) on detector performance, using the Underwriter Laboratories, UL 2034 standard for CO alarms on recreational boats, as evaluation criteria. The study also included data on performance of detectors following nonpowered storage, as is common with boats that have seasonal use. Results and related recommendations included: 1. Future studies should be performed over two season extremes. This was based on results of the study that indicated the detectors may be affected by seasonal changes. 2. The effect of long-term exposure of sensors to volatile compounds resulting from out-gassing of vessel construction materials and related impact on sensor functionality should be investigated. This was based on the data characterizing new and increased existing volatile organic compounds over time when ambient temperatures rise, and when the boat is in a “closed condition” as would be the case during storage in nonuse seasons. 3. The recovery time of the sensors used and the time required for the sensor to reach a stable operating condition should also be investigated. This was based on results of nonpowered detector testing of the metal-oxide sensors, documenting that prolonged storage in a nonpowered condition (as is the case during storage of the boat or periods of nonuse) can affect sensor performance. Instructions from the sensor manufacturer stated that these conditions may require a longer preheating period to stabilize the detector before use, and recommends storing the sensor in a sealed bag containing clean air and nothing else (as in, no silica gel). No other manufacturer provided any information regarding the proper or recommended storage practices when the detector is not in use and not under power. 4. Detectors should be installed on various types of vessels and a portable test chamber testing capability should be developed to allow for testing detectors in a real world setting.
7.7.5 ENGINEERING CONTROL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT By the time data from the investigation of boat-related CO poisonings at Lake Powell were published in December, 2000,13 work was already underway to develop controls to reduce the CO hazard. Initial efforts were directed towards houseboat generators, primarily based on Lake Powell data. (Of the 111 poisonings identified at Lake Powell at that time, 74 were on houseboats, and 64 of these were associated with exposure to generator exhaust. In addition, 7 of 11 deaths there had occurred near houseboats of the design shown in Figures 7.9 through 7.11, and 5 of the deaths were associated with generator exhaust only.) In May 2001, the USCG Office of Boating Safety cosponsored the first of what became a series of workshops to focus on ways to reduce marine CO hazards, bringing together boat manufacturers, control innovators, and government agencies.45 The initial meeting focused primarily on controls for houseboat generators, and spawned a number of research and development projects.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 184 — #28
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
185
FIGURE 7.13 Generator exhaust terminus—side exhaust (marked by arrow).
Houseboat generator control alternatives developed and evaluated since then included 1. Rerouting generator exhaust to the side (as shown in Figure 7.13)46,47 2. Rerouting generator exhaust through a hybrid wet/dry vertical stack exhaust system with an exhaust terminus several feet above the upper deck (Figure 7.14)27,47−57 3. Retrofitting generators with an emission control device (Figure 7.15)45,46,49,57 4. An electrical interlock device to deactivate the generator when conditions indicated that boat occupants were swimming (lowered swim ladder, open gates, etc.),48 and finally, 5. New manufacture of emission-controlled generators55,58 Control directly at the source is the preferred and most effective intervention. In February, 2004, Westerbeke was the first manufacturer to introduce a series of reduced-emission gasoline-powered marine generators, reporting a 99% reduction in CO emissions. This reduction was confirmed through Coast Guard-sponsored field testing of two generators (14 and 20 kW) installed and used on houseboats.55 Final results for the second round of tests, designed to assess longevity of effectiveness of the emission controls after 2300 and 1300 h of use (calculated to be equivalent to 92,000 and 52,000 miles of use for an average automobile) indicated little or no deterioration in the effectiveness of the controls.58 In 2005, Kohler
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 185 — #29
186
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
FIGURE 7.14 Stacks directing generator exhaust upward (marked by arrows).
FIGURE 7.15 Emission control device for retrofit of generators.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 186 — #30
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
187
also announced a new line of marine generators reported to reduce CO emissions by 99%.59 By 2002, focus shifted towards control of propulsion engine emissions. The Coast Guard and ABYC began semiannual meetings to discuss the progress of research and development of all marine engineering controls. These are held in conjunction with the International Boatbuilders Exposition meetings, and minutes of the meetings are available through ABYC. These periodic CO workshops have greatly facilitated the exchange of both technical information among manufacturers and the public, and also the sharing of accident information, and a general rising of awareness in the industry, government, and the public. The workshops have also served to accelerate other mitigating technologies, including diesel engines as viable alternatives for recreational boats.60 The result has been to highlight a much broader scope of research by adding express cruisers, towed activities, etc. The workshops have also served as a catalyst for revision of ABYC TH-23 (Design, Construction, and Testing of Boats in Consideration of CO),61 and addition of dry stack exhaust considerations to ABYC P-1.62 Concurrent with the workshops, the Coast Guard sponsored evaluations of CO emissions on recreational boats.63,64 Safe distances from the boat were evaluated to address the issue of potential CO exposures for those being towed on water “toys” behind the boat (tubers, wake surfers, etc.).65,66 Evaluations of the effectiveness of devices designed to reroute the exhaust of ski-boat engines were also conducted.67,68 Prototype catalyzed propulsion engines were introduced at the International Boat Builders Exposition in February 2005, and evaluations of the catalyzed engines continued.69−71 In March 2006, Indmar introduced the first production inboard propulsion engine with controlled emissions to be available on 2007 model year boats.72 Most recently (January 2006), results of a Coast Guard sponsored study of CO emissions and exposures on a class of cabin cruiser boat known as express cruisers were reported.73 The study was performed to better understand how CO poisonings may occur on express cruisers, identify the most hazardous conditions, and begin the process of identifying controls to prevent/reduce CO exposures. Many of the evaluated boats generated hazardous CO concentrations: peak CO concentrations often exceeded 1100 ppm, while average CO concentrations were well over 100 ppm at the stern (rear). Two boats with a combined exhaust system (exhausting at the sides and underwater) had dramatically lower CO concentrations than any of the other evaluated boats (about 40% lower).
7.7.6 INNOVATIONS IN EMS MEDICAL MANAGEMENT With the support of the USCG, in 2003 NPS EMS personnel at Lake Powell began using equipment that allowed noninvasive estimation of COHb concentration from analysis of exhaled breath samples for more effective triaging of patients. The decision logic shown in Figure 7.16 is used to guide medics in acting upon results of the analysis. A decision logic for use of a new noninvasive blood pulseoximeter has also recently been published74 and is discussed in another chapter of this book.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 187 — #31
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
188
CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING The micro CO meter is to be used on anyone who has been or you suspect has been exposed to or poisoned by carbon monoxide (CO) Consider scene safety for rescuers and patients. Rapid extrication from hazardous environment PRN.(1)
Address airway issues
NO
YES
Obtain exhaled CO measurement
Micro CO meter immediately available?
Administer high flow oxygen via nonrebreather mask
Administer high flow oxygen via non-rebreather mask
Obtain exhaled CO measurement as soon as Micro CO meter available Patient is pregnant, has abnormal cerebellar testing, COHb level of 25% or greater, exhibits cardiovascular dysfunction, continued abnormal mental status or had any of loss of consciousness or seizure?
YES
PATCH
Consider rapid transport to hyperbaric facility(3)
NO YES
NO Patient exhaled COHb level > 20%
Is patient symtomatic?
YES
NO
Transport to nearest medical facility for continued evaluation, treatment, and monitoring (2)
PATCH
Consider field treatment with no transport. Continue treatment with oxygen until COHb is <5% (or 10% in smoker) (2) (1) (2) (3)
Rescuers will be equipped with SCBA for extricating patients from hazardous environmentt. Continue measuring exhaled CO with Micro CO meter Q 15–30 minute intervals. Initiate preplanning with receiving facility. Refer to transfer guideline: Hyperbaric oxygen therapy for acute carbon monoxide poisoning.
FIGURE 7.16 Glen Canyon NPS decision logic for patient triage.
7.8 SUMMARY AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS On the positive side, in a span of just over 5 years, many agencies, companies, and individuals have joined to improve identification of marine CO poisoning, characterize risks, develop and evaluate control technologies, and launch a plethora of prevention programs. The resulting developments are impressive: (1) two manufacturers successfully developed low-emission marine generators that are on the market; (2) two major manufacturers developed and participated in testing of catalyzed inboard propulsion engines, with one introducing it in production engines; (3) devices for rerouting generator and propulsion engine exhaust were developed and tested; and (4) several states passed safe towing legislation or regulations.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 188 — #32
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
189
So what is left to do? We must remember that there are more than 12.8 million boats registered for use on US waters, more than 12 million of which are propelled by outboard, inboard, or sterndrive engines.75 The only engines that have emission controls are newly manufactured outboard engines and one inboard engine model. Thus, a large proportion of the gasoline-powered marine engines in use have no emission controls. Thus, even if EPA increases the scope of emission standards by regulating inboard and sterndrive engines, a lot of boats will continue to emit a lot of CO for a long time. EPA regulation of CO emissions for all marine engines is vital for prevention of marine CO poisonings. A reduction in automobile-related CO poisonings followed the EPA Clean Air Act regulations requiring emission control on automobiles.76 The same would likely follow similar requirements for marine engines. The key to improved prevention of boat-related CO poisonings lies in improved recognition and reporting. Until there is more comprehensive testing for COHb by physicians and those involved in death investigation, CO poisoning cases will continue to be missed. This results in inadequate or incorrect treatment of cases, related increased morbidity, inaccurate assignation of cause of death, and related failures in prevention. Development of standardized autopsy protocols, combined with more extensive training of the responding medical and law enforcement personnel to facilitate collection and transfer of adequate incident detail are needed for improved recognition. Adequately recognized poisonings must then be reported so that the full scope of the problem can be defined for prevention programs. Reporting of marine CO poisonings is low. This can be easily examined by comparing Lake Powell data for fatal and nonfatal boat-related CO poisonings, identified, and documented through extensive searches of EMS records, against Coast Guard data for reported CO poisonings. From 1990 through 2002, there were 13 fatal boat-related CO poisonings and 151 nonfatal boat-related CO poisonings requiring medical attention documented at Lake Powell (thus a total of 164 boat-related CO poisonings at that one lake). In that same period, Coast Guard data documented 170 injuries and 62 deaths related to CO reported from incidents across the entire country. Clearly, marine CO poisonings are not extensively reported to the Coast Guard. State Boating Law Administrators (the recognized reporting authority) should be encouraged to develop liaisons with other state-based surveillance efforts (i.e., state-based child fatality review boards, vital records departments, injury surveillance efforts), as well as Federal surveillance systems, to enhance identification and reporting of boat-related CO poisonings reporting. In addition, more extensive training of municipal law enforcement officers and first responders is needed, so that they can better understand the need to report CO poisonings. While developments in control have been impressive, implementation of new controls and retrofitting existing boats remains problematic, as evidenced by recent poisonings (not included in the 607 cases analyzed here). Recent Coast Guard data identified two new poisonings (one fatal + one nonfatal) related to entry into the “Death Zone”. Newspaper reports and related autopsy results document a June, 2006 death associated with ski-boat platform occupancy (COHb = 51%). The list of marine CO poisonings continues to grow.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 189 — #33
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
190
Boat manufactures must assess and address design features that attract occupancy at the back of the boat, redesigning to eliminate hazards. Consumer education, vital to the success of retrofit programs, must continue and increase. If boat owners don’t understand the problem, they won’t be motivated to go to the trouble of complying with recalls and consumer advisories. Failure of onboard CO detector/alarms raises concern about the impact of such devices in CO poisoning prevention. Improving the effectiveness of these devices is complex, as there were four types of problems identified, each indicating a different needed corrective strategy. Failure of functional detectors to warn occupants of high CO concentrations and the sounding of alarms for no discernable cause are related to much needed improvements in detector sensor technology. A likely explanation of disabling of detectors by boaters is that the detectors are sounding frequently and the boater either cannot identify a cause for the alarm (also a detector technology issue) or cannot resolve the issue that is causing CO to enter the cabin (an issue related to boat design, technology, and boater education). As has been documented here, quick death can and does occur from exposure to CO in the marine environment, even in the open air. Acceptance of this possibility remains difficult for technical audiences as well as consumers. Anecdotal accounts of medical examiners and hospital emergency departments failing or refusing to order COHb analyses related to incidents on boats continue. The need for increased awareness of the problem was recently underscored in the following quote by a family dramatically impacted by a teak surfing death: Unfortunately, widespread understanding of the issue among the boating public remains elusive. We still see kids teak surfing between wake boarding runs. Most people we talk to are surprised at the severity of the CO risk behind a boat. In spite of all our efforts, most seem not to realize the potential peril. I recently talked to two families from Canada who said they teak surfed all the time and were amazed when I told them it could be deadly. This risk is just not self-evident and consequently more kids die unnecessarily every year. Our family, the Dixey family, and people like us that have lost loved ones certainly know the costs of not knowing about or under-estimating this hazard. We who have now been warned have the responsibility to sound the dangers for others. By lifting our voice in warning, we can do our part to make sure that great kids don’t continue to die. This quote certainly applies to all types of gasoline-powered marine engines, all boaters, and to all deaths from this preventable cause of CO poisoning.
7.9 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Much of the work described in this chapter, including initial recognition of the problem and call for engineering changes, would not have happened without my colleague and good friend, Dr. Robert Baron. I am grateful for his guidance, wisdom, and partnership. Thanks to Claire Babik, who has worked so hard for prevention in honor of the brother she lost. In addition, gratitude is owed to Tim Radtke; to National Park
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 190 — #34
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
191
Service Rangers, Divers, Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs), and Medics at GCNRA; and to the researchers at the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. All of these fine public servants have devoted many hours to the cause of identifying and preventing marine CO poisonings. I pay respect to the families that have lost so much to this unnecessary cause. And to my own family, I want to say thanks for everything.
References 1. USCG, Boating Safety Circular 58, A good way to die, US Department of Transportation, United States Coast Guard, June, 1984. 2. Simeone L.F. The intrusion of engine exhaust into the passenger areas of recreational power boats, United States Coast Guard Office of Navigation Safety and Waterway Services Report DOT-VNTSC-CG-91-1, 1991. 3. Simeone L.F. A simple carburetor model for predicting engine air-fuel ratios and carbon monoxide emissions as a function of inlet conditions, United States Coast Guard Report CG-079, 1990. 4. Silvers S.M. and Hampson N.B. Carbon monoxide poisoning among recreational boaters. JAMA, 274, 1614–1616, 1995. 5. American Boat and Yacht Council, A-24, Carbon monoxide detection systems, American Boat and Yacht Council, Inc., 1997. 6. Struttman T. et al. Unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning from an unlikely source, JABFP, 11, 481–484, 1998. 7. Huff J.S. and Kardon E. Carbon monoxide toxicity in a man working outdoors with a gasoline-powered hydraulic machine, NEJM, 320(23), 1564, 1989. 8. First M.W. and Murphy R.L.H. Carbon monoxide exposures from snow melting machines. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J., 31, 754–757, 1970. 9. Hampson N.B. and Norkool D.M. Carbon monoxide poisoning in children riding in the back of pickup trucks, JAMA, 267, 538–540, 1992. 10. Jumbelic M.I. Open air carbon monoxide poisoning, J Forensic Sci, 43, 228–230, 1998. 11. Easley R.B. Open air carbon monoxide poisoning in a child swimming behind a boat, South Med J, 93, 430–432, 2000. 12. GCNRA NPS, Investigative Report, Case 94-4012, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area National Park Service, 1994. 13. CDC, Houseboat-associated carbon monoxide poisonings on Lake Powell—Arizona and Utah, 2000. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 49(49), 1105–1108, Dec 15, 2000. 14. NIOSH, Hazard evaluation and technical assistance report: 2000-0400 and 20020325, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area, Arizona and Utah, US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 2005. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/hhe/reports/pdfs/20000400-2956.pdf 15. US Coast Guard. Boating statistics—2004. US Department of Homeland Security, COMDTPUB P16754.17, 2005. Available http://www.uscgboating.org/statistics/ accident_stats.htm 16. 33 CFR 173.55, Vessel Numbering and Casualty and Accident Reporting, Code of Federal Regulations, Washington, DC, US Government Printing Office, Office of the Federal Register, 2002.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 191 — #35
192
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 17. DOI, Boat-related CO poisonings on US waters national case listing, Safety Management Information System (SMIS), US Department of the Interior (DOI), 2006. Available http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/cohouseboats.htm 18. CDC, Carbon-monoxide poisoning resulting from exposure to ski-boat exhaust, June 2002 - Georgia, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) 51(37);829–830, September 20, 2002. Available http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5137a3.htm 19. CDC, Carbon monoxide poisonings resulting from open air exposures to operating motorboats—Lake Havasu City, Arizona, 2003. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 53(15), 314– 318, April 23, 2004. Available http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/ mm5315a3.htm 20. McCammon, J.B. Letter to Joe Alston, Park Superintendent, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area from J.B. McCammon, NIOSH, CDC, PHS, DHHS, Denver, Colorado, July 31, 2001. Available http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/teakfinal.pdf 21. Ritter G. Air monitoring for Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection Division of Conservation Law Enforcement boating accident reconstruction, Prepared by TRC Environmental Corporation, September 13, 2001. 22. McCammon J.B. et al. Letter to Joe Alston, Park Superintendant, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area, Page, Arizona, from J. McCammon (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control), T Radtke (US Department of Interior), and DP Bleicher (National Park Service), December 3, 2002. Available http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/searayfinal.pdf 23. GCNRA NPS Investigative Report, Case 2000-4627: Carbon monoxide testing, August 25, 2000, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area National Park Service, 2000. 24. Hall, R.M. and McCammon, J.B. Letter to Joe Alston, Park Superintendent, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area from R.M. Hall and J.B. McCammon, NIOSH, CDC, PHS, DHHS, Cincinnati, Ohio, November 21, 2000. Available http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/HHE2powell.pdf 25. Hall, R.M. Letter to Dr. Rice Leach, Commissioner, Cabinet for Health Service, Commonwealth of Kentucky from R.M. Hall, NIOSH, CDC, PHS, DHHS, Cincinnati, Ohio, December 18, 2000. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Hazard evaluation and technical assistance report: 2001-0026. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/hhe/reports/pdfs/2001-0026-letter.pdf 26. McCammon J.B. et al. Letter to Joe Alston, Park Superintendant, Glen Canyon National Recreation Area, Page, Arizona from J. McCammon (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control), T. Radtke (US Department of Interior), and D.P. Bleicher (National Park Service), March 17, 2003. Available http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/notoriousfinal.pdf 27. Dunn K. et al. An evaluation of an engineering control to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings of individuals on houseboats at Sumerset Custom Houseboats, Somerset KY, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-26a, May, 2001 Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-26a.pdf 28. NIOSH, Hazard evaluation and technical assistance report: 2002-0393, Lake Havasu Municipal Employees, Lake Havasu City, Arizona, February 2004, US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 2004. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/hhe/reports/pdfs/2002-0393-2928.pdf
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 192 — #36
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
193
29. ACGIH, TLVs® and BEIs®. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, 2006. 30. McCormick D. Personal communication, 2006. 31. NBSAC, Minutes of the National Boating Safety Advisory Council 67th meeting, Cleveland OH, 2001. Available http://www.uscgboating.org/nbsac/MtgMin/pdf/ 67thNBSAC_Minutes.pdf 32. USCG, US Coast Guard Recall website, accessed Jan 30, 2006. Searched for “generator exhaust” and “exhaust system”. Available http://www.uscgboating.org/ recalls/recalls_database.htm 33. EPA, Regulatory update: Overview of EPA’s emission standards for marine engines, Publication EPA420-F-04-031, August 2004. Available http://www.epa.gov/otaq/regs/ nonroad/marine/420f04031.pdf 34. EPA, Program Announcement: Marine engine manufacturer develops low emission inboard marine engines. Publication EPA420-F-06-057, July 2006. Available http://www.epa.gov/oms/regs/nonroad/marine/si/420f06057.htm 35. Roberts P. Unpublished data. Sonoma Technology Inc., Petaluma, California. 36. NASBLA, Safe practices for boat-towed watersports act. NationalAssociation of State Boating Law Administrators, 2005. Available http://www.nasbla.org/pdf/Model% 20Acts/new/Boat-Towed%20Watersports%2092105.pdf 37. The Pennsylvania Code, 105.3 Unacceptable boating practices, 2003. Available http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/058/chapter105/s105.3.html 38. California Code, Harbors and Navigation Code, Section 680-685, Anthony Farr and Stacy Beckett Boating Safety Act of 2004, 2004. Available http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/ cgi-bin/displaycode?section=hnc&group=00001-01000&file=680-685 39. Nevada Code, NAC 488.435 Prima facie evidence of reckless or negligent operation, 2004. Available http://www.leg.state.nv.us/NAC/NAC-488.html#NAC488Sec435 40. Oregon Legislative Assembly, Senate bill 56 amending ORS 830.990, 2005. Available http://www.leg.state.or.us/05reg/measpdf/sb0001.dir/sb0056.en.pdf 41. Washington Senate Bill 6364, An act relating to the regulation of recreational vessels; amending 2 RCW 79A.60.610; adding a new section to chapter 79A.60 RCW; adding new sections to chapter 88.02 RCW; creating a new section; prescribing penalties; and providing an effective date, 2005. Available http:// www.leg.wa.gov/pub/billinfo/2005-06/Pdf/Bills/Senate%20Passed%20Legislature/ 6364.PL.pdf 42. Utah Administrative Code R651-224. Towed Devices. Available at http://www.rules. utah.gov/publicat/code/r651/r651-224.htm R651-224-2. Unlawful Methods of Towing. 43. Taylor R.K. et al. National Marine Manufacturers Association carbon monoxide label study. Design Research Engineering, Novi, Michigan, 2005. 44. US Coast Guard Contract Number DTCG39-00-D-R0009, Task Order 01-F-00016, September 2002. 45. US Coast Guard, Houseboat industry workshop on carbon monoxide, Summary record, Lexington, Kentucky, May 3, 2001. USCoast Guard Office of Boating Safety, Recreational Boating Product Assurance Division, Report prepared by Potomac Management Group. 46. Earnest G.S., Beamer B., and Dunn K.H. Evaluation of side exhaust and prototype and production emission control devices to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings on houseboats. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-29a, May 2002. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-29a.pdf
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 193 — #37
194
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 47. Dunn K.H. et al. Comparison of a dry stack with existing generator exhaust systems for prevention of carbon monoxide poisonings on houseboats. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-28a, August 2001. Available http://www.cdc.gov/ niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-28a.pdf 48. Earnest G.S. et al. An evaluation of an engineering control to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings of individuals on houseboats. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-25a, March 2001. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb171-25a.pdf 49. Earnest G.S. et al. An evaluation of an emission control device, exhaust stack, and interlock to prevent carbon monoxide poisoning of individuals on houseboats. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-27a, August 2001. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-27a.pdf 50. NIOSH, Evaluation of two exhaust stack configurations on two houseboats at Table Rock Lake, Missouri. HETA Report Number 2003-0318-2936. Cincinnati, OH: US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, June 2004. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/hhe/reports/pdfs/2003-0318-2936.pdf 51. Earnest G.S. et al. An evaluation of vertical exhaust stacks and aged production emission control devices to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings from houseboat generator exhaust. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-32a, October 2003. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-32a.pdf 52. Hammond D.R. and Marlow D.A. Followup evaluation of design changes to a houseboat generator exhaust stack system. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-34a2, July 2004. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-34a2.pdf 53. Hammond D.R., Earnest G.S., and Hall R.M. An evaluation of factors that might influence exhaust stack performance to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings from houseboat generator exhaust. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-34a1, January 2004. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-34a1.pdf 54. Hammond D.R. et al. An evaluation of conditions that may affect the performance of houseboat exhaust stacks in prevention of carbon monoxide poisonings from generators, JOEH, 3, 308–316, June, 2006. 55. ZimmerA.T., Earnest G.S., and Kurimo R.An evaluation of catalytic emission controls and vertical exhaust stacks to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings from houseboat generator exhaust. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-36a, September 2005. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-36a.pdf 56. Dunn K.H. et al. Carbon monoxide and houseboats, Prof Safety, 48, 47–57, Nov., 2003. 57. Earnest G.S. et al. An evaluation of an engineering control to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings of individuals on and around houseboats, AIHAJ, 63, 361–369, May/Jun, 2002. 58. Earnest G.S. et al. An evaluation of catalytic emission controls to prevent carbon monoxide poisonings from houseboat generator exhaust. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 194 — #38
Carbon Monoxide Dangers in the Marine Environment
59.
60.
61. 62. 63.
64.
65. 66.
67.
68.
69. 70.
71.
72.
195
Technology/EPHB Report 17/-38a, October 2006. Available http://www.cdc.gov/ niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-38a.pdf Kohler, Press Release: New generation gasoline generators from Kohler reduce carbon monoxide emissions by 99 Percent. Kohler Power Systems, Kohler WI. August, 2005. Available http://www.kohlerpowersystems.com/pr/GasolineEmission_2005.html Carlan K, Mastry Engine Center Presentation at the 2004 USCoast Guard / ABYC Carbon Monoxide Workshop, IBEX 2004, Miami Beach, FL, October 27, 2004. Minutes of the meeting available at http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/miami10-04_cominutes.pdf; presentation slides available at http://safetynet.smis.doi.gov/miami10-04_slides.pdf ABYC, TH-23: Design, Construction, and Testing of Boats in Consideration of Carbon Monoxide, American Boat and Yacht Council, Edgewater, Maryland, 2004. ABYC, P-1: Installation of Exhaust Systems for Propulsion and Auxiliary Engines, American Boat and Yacht Council, Edgewater, Maryland, 2002. Earnest, G.S. et al. Carbon monoxide emissions and exposures on recreational boats under various operating conditions. Lake Mead, Nevada and Lake Powell, Arizona. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-05ee2, February 2003. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-05ee2.pdf Echt, A. et al. Carbon monoxide emissions and exposures on recreational boats under various operating conditions, Lake Norman, N.C. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-31a, April 2003. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb171-31a.pdf USCG and ABYC, Carbon monoxide safe distance study. US Coast Guard, American Boat and Yacht Council, September 2003. Mann, L.W. Carbon monoxide exposure while operating an inboard boat and related water sports activities. [Online] Available at http://www.FreshAirExhaust.com (Accessed July 2004). Marlow D.A. et al. Evaluation of the “Fresh Air ExhaustTM ” system to reduce carbon monoxide exposure during motor boating and wake surfing. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-35a, August 2004. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-35a.pdf Marlow D.A., Hammond D., and Earnest G.S. Evaluation of the SideswipeTM exhaust system to reduce carbon monoxide poisoning during motor boating and wake surfing. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 171-37a, December 2005. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ectb-171-37a.pdf Hall R.M. et al. Case study: Evaluation of carbon monoxide emissions from engines on recreational boats equipped with prototype catalysts, JOEH 3(2), D4-D7, Feb., 2006. White J.J. Cleaner pleasurecraft: Lower-emission boats may be coming soon to a lake near you, Southwest Research Institute, 2004. Available http://www.swri.org/3pubs/ttoday/summer04/craft.htm Carroll J.N. Catalyzed marine engine saltwater durability, Presentation by Southwest Research Institute at the USCG Carbon Monoxide Seminar, Miami, Florida, October 2005, Minutes and presentation available from American Boat and Yacht Council, 3069 Solomon’s Island Road, Edgewater, Maryland, 21037. Indmar, Press release: Indmar introduces first production catalyst for inboard engines. Indmar Products Co., Millington TN. March 7, 2006. Available http://www.indmar.com/news/newsroom_article.cfm?id=31
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 195 — #39
196
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 73. Garcia A., Beamer B., and Earnest G.S. In-depth survey report of carbon monoxide emissions and exposures on express cruisers under various operating conditions, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health/Division of Applied Research and Technology/EPHB Report 289-11a, January 2006. Available http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-289-11a.pdf 74. Hampson N.B. and Weaver L.K. Noninvasive CO measurement by first responders: A suggested management algorithm, Elsevier Public Safety, Lethal Exposure, Supplement to J. Emerg. Med. Services, 10–12, Spring, 2006. 75. NMMA, 2005 recreational boating abstract. National Marine Manufacturers Association, 2005. Available http://www.nmma.org/facts/boatingstats/2005/files/ populationstats3.asp 76. Mott J.A. et al. National vehicle emission policies and practices and declining US carbon monoxide-related mortality. JAMA, 288, 988–995, 2002. 77. EPA, Air quality criteria for carbon monoxide, Publication No. EPA-600/8-90/045F, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 1991. 78. WHO, Environmental health criteria 213 - carbon monoxide (Second Edition), World Health Organization, Geneva, ISBN 92 4 157213 2 (NLM classification: QV 662) ISSN 0250-863X, 1999. 79. NIOSH, Recommendations for occupational safety and health: Compendium of policy documents and statements, US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 92–100, 1992. 80. ACGIH, 2005 TLVs® and BEIs®: threshold limit values for chemical substances and physical agents. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, 2005. 81. CFR 29 CFR 1910.1000, Code of Federal Regulations, Washington, D.C., US Government Printing Office, Office of the Federal Register, 1997.
8417: “8417_c007” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 196 — #40
8
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection Gary Hutter
CONTENTS 8.1 8.2
8.3
8.4 8.5
8.6
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Characteristics of Carbon Monoxide Formation and Movement as Related to Warnings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.1 Physical Characteristics of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.2 Combustion and Formation of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.3 Buoyancy, Migration, and Dilution of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . 8.2.4 Exit Velocity Considerations for Different Carbon Monoxide Producing Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.5 Absorption and Dissipation of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Common Sources of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.1 Consumer Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.2 Industrial Products and Processes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . What are Warnings, Labels, Instructions, and Other Forms of Communications? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Content, Configuration, and Design of Labels, Warnings, and Instructional Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5.1 Design of Labeling and Warnings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5.2 Written Instructional Information on Safety Materials . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5.4 Workplace Area Warnings and Labeling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5.4.1 Examples of General OSHA Warning Signage . . . . . . . . . 8.5.4.2 Examples of Specific OSHA Exposure Warning Signage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5.4.3 Other OSHA and Industry Warning Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . The Reasons, Rationale, and Scientific Bases for Providing Safety Information for Carbon Monoxide with Selected Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.1 Ethical and Philosophical Reasons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.2 Research Basis: the Need for Safety Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.3 Voluntary Standards for CO Warnings (Examples in Chronological Order) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.4 Mandatory Safety Information Regulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
198 198 198 199 200 202 204 204 204 205 206 206 207 209 211 211 212 213 214 214 216 219 219 197
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 197 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
198
8.6.4.1 State-Based Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.4.2 Federal Government Examples. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.5 The Custom and Practice of Carbon Monoxide Safety Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6.6 Litigation-Driven Safety Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
223 223 224 227 230
8.1 INTRODUCTION Other chapters in this book discuss about the chemical, physical, toxicological, and health concerns of exposure to carbon monoxide (CO). This chapter addresses warnings, labeling, instructions, and other communication modes (i.e., safety information) about the hazards of exposure to CO. This chapter addresses (1) the conditions that may lead to the static and variable formation of CO, (2) characteristics that may impact the need to provide user-safety information, (3) common sources of CO, and (4) the characteristic movement of CO through the air that may prompt a need for user-safety information. The mid-portion of the chapter discusses the functions, criteria, research, and basis for CO safety information. Finally, details about the current practices in communicating this information to those who are potentially exposed to CO is provided. Examples of codes, standards, and recommended practices are offered, and real-life examples of warnings, labeling, and instructions are provided from products currently in the stream of commerce. Under some subject headings, the impact of the subject on the need for warnings are provided.
8.2 CHARACTERISTICS OF CARBON MONOXIDE FORMATION AND MOVEMENT AS RELATED TO WARNINGS To understand better why CO exposure necessitates warning for the at-risk population, it is helpful to know the characteristics of CO that influence its hazardous nature.
8.2.1 PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF CARBON MONOXIDE CO is extremely toxic. It is often called a poison. It causes a broad array of symptoms that precede possible death. Kandarjian1 list 22 different symptoms that arise from CO exposure. (There are actually many more symptoms, signs, and conditions that can result from CO exposure.) CO is an invisible, odorless, nonirritating, and tasteless gas that in and of itself has no (or extremely poor) sensory warning characteristics for those exposed. This fact contributes to the insidious nature of CO exposure. However, some combustion processes that release CO also produce aldehydes and/or particles that have distinct odors, which may alert someone to the possible presence of CO. This is more likely
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 198 — #2
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
199
to occur from the combustion of solid (wood, charcoal) or liquid fuels (fuel oil), and is much less likely to occur from the refined gaseous fuels (e.g., methane, propane, butane). Natural gas and propane often have odorants added to the fuel mixture for leak detection purposes. Unfortunately, they are typically consumed in the combustion process, which eliminates the benefit of possible olfactory warnings. Under unusually poor combustion processes containing these odorants, some of the odor may be detectable in the exhaust stream. (It has been suggested that a substance be used that only gives odor when there is incomplete combustion, but none with complete combustion.) Labeling Implications: Carbon monoxide has poor sensory warning characteristics.
8.2.2 COMBUSTION AND FORMATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE Carbon-containing fuels that generate CO may originate as solids (e.g., charcoal, wood), liquids (e.g., kerosene, gasoline), or gases (e.g., methane, propane, butane). The combustion process actually takes place with the hydrocarbon components in the gaseous phase even though they may originate from a solid or a liquid. Therefore, the following discussion is written in terms of the gas phase of the fuel component. Given the correct initial conditions, carbon (typically from a hydrocarbon molecule) and oxygen will react to initially form CO as an intermediate compound, with carbon dioxide as the final product of combustion. CO generation as the final product of combustion is most often the result of interruption of the combustion process at the intermediate step (quenching) and incomplete combustion of carbon-containing materials. Stoichiometry is the evaluation of the fuel and air ratios associated with combustion efficiency of the gas phase. In theory, at an ideal stoichiometric mixture of carbon-based fuels, there would be sufficient amounts of oxygen, on a mass basis, to react with all of the carbon. This would allow the oxidation reaction to go to completion. In this case, there would be no CO remaining. An obvious corollary is that under insufficient oxygen conditions, CO is produced because there are not enough oxygen molecules to react completely with the carbon molecules. This incomplete combustion can be done intentionally, as is the case with iron ore refining blast furnaces or coke ovens. Both these processes intentionally operate under nonideal (oxygendeficient) stoichiometric conditions to refine (chemically reduce) the iron oxide to iron, and to thermally distill coal into coke. In both these processes, large amounts of CO are intentionally produced (1%), are an unavoidable part of the process, and are recovered as a fuel for other operations. Oxygen-deficient combustion that leads to the formation of CO can also be unintentional. This occurs because of restricted air supplies, inadequate exhaust gas management, or an overabundance of fuel. Examples of these scenarios include (1) comfort heating furnaces that are installed in closet-like locations with insufficient fresh (combustion) air supply vents, (2) chimneys that have developed internal blockages, and (3) burners that incorporate jets and/or orifices for the passage of
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 199 — #3
200
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
gaseous carbon fuels of different molecular weights (such as natural gas furnaces fueled with propane). All of these conditions can result in combustion problems and the subsequent generation and release of CO into people’s houses or other living spaces. A less obvious condition that leads to the formation of CO occurs when stoichiometrically correct ratios of carbon and oxygen do not have sufficient time, molecular intimacy, or energy (in the form of heat) in a combustion process to completely react, resulting in an interrupted or incomplete reaction. To avoid these conditions, gaseous fuels are often premixed with the combustion air in a turbulent fashion to provide the time and contact for a complete reaction. For example, in gas burners there are various fuel jets and mixing chambers that swirl the air and fuel together. This facilitates the dispersion of oxygen within the combustible fuel, and thus enhances combustion. Combustion temperatures influence the creation of CO, and reflect the heat available for a carbon–oxygen reaction to go to completion. These temperatures are typically controlled so that there is sufficient energy available for completing the reactions. Quenching the temperatures can shift the reaction kinetics and allow some of the carbon to react only to the CO state, resulting in the presence of CO in the exhaust. In low-temperature combustion processes, a catalyst can be used to lower the threshold combustion temperatures. This method better assures complete combustion and is used in catalytic heaters and reactors. Combustion processes depending on catalytic reactions are prone to the elevated formation of CO if the catalyst becomes damaged or poisoned. Finally, even well-managed combustion mixtures of carbon-based fuels and air can produce some finite quantity of CO simply because the processes are not ideal. Incomplete combustion occurs, and if not vented properly can result in the formation of even greater amounts of CO. For example, natural gas in a stove-top burner or oven may produce several parts per million (ppm) of CO,2 especially when at low settings. The CO is then diluted in the relatively large space of a typical home kitchen. The same stove-top burner or oven, operating under the same conditions in a small camper or motor home, results in higher concentrations of CO because of reduced dilution and the decline of oxygen content in the surrounding feed-air supply. These various combustion scenarios all produce CO concentrations, mass amounts, and temporal exposure variations that may repeatedly alternate from harmless, to chronic exposure levels, to acute exposure levels. Because of this, exposures may go unnoticed until a dangerous or even deadly situation occurs. Labeling Implications: The combustion processes most often associated with the production of CO can and do vary significantly due to small changes in ambient or process conditions resulting in situations where little CO is produced to situations where significant amounts of CO are produced.
8.2.3 BUOYANCY, MIGRATION, AND DILUTION OF CARBON MONOXIDE CO has a molecular weight close to that of air (CO = 28, Air = 28.9) and following the ideal gas laws would have approximately the same density as air across
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 200 — #4
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
201
the normal ambient temperature range. This would tend to make the gas neutrally buoyant; neither wanting to migrate upward or downward due to density differences when released into the environment. Therefore, if room temperature gas with CO escaped from a calibration tank, it would not pool on the floor or raise to the ceiling. Rather, its movement would be affected by the forces of the pressure drop at the leak, concentration-driven diffusion, Brownian movement, and local air disturbances.3 [Of course once mixing of the CO and air (oxygen, nitrogen, etc.) molecules occurs, separation of the molecules cannot take place once again without the addition of large amounts of energy, lest it violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics.] CO does not have any unusual adiabatic heat loss or gain characteristics. Therefore, it does not have a vertical lapse rate that is different from air, and there are no additional internal physical driving forces on it. Under local atmospheric “inversion” conditions, ambient temperature CO would move similar to other neutrally buoyant gases. On the other hand, certain conditions can cause CO to move upward. CO recently produced by a combustion process (e.g., in a residential furnace or boiler) is apt to be warmer than the surrounding ambient air, and therefore will be thermally buoyant and migrate upward, at least initially. For example, a few inches from the combustion zone of propane heaters, gases are typically several hundred degrees Fahrenheit above ambient temperatures. The extent of this temperature-driven density difference and accompanying upward migration is controlled by the ability of the exhausting plume to maintain the boundary of its thermal envelope. Further, mechanisms like cross air movement and heat sinks cause a loss of heat and buoyancy. These air movements and heat sinks can quickly inhibit further vertical movement. Certain conditions can also cause CO to migrate large distances. For example, the continual release of hot exhaust gases that contain CO (e.g., a leak in a basement furnace) produce their own convection currents that can effectively fumigate distant areas. A furnace located in a cooler portion of a building can release products of combustion—including CO—that move along the colder building cavities and migrate several floors above the original leak. This phenomenon is enabled by nonthermal volumetric expansions of simple gaseous carbon fuels due to changes in pressure (e.g., from a pressurized cylinder), and by the increased number of moles of gas in the by-products. The basic combustion equations for methane, ethane, propane, and butane are given in Table 8.1. Comparing the volume (or moles of gas) in the products of combustion (VP) to the volume of the reactants (VR), reveals a positive volumetric change for all but methane during the combustion process. Dilution of airborne gaseous contaminants typically follows an exponential decay profile. Ten thousand (10,000) cu. ft. of gas containing 500 ppm would require another 10,000 cu. ft. of clean dilution air to reduce the concentration to 250 ppm. It would take another 20,000 cu. ft. of dilution air (10, 000 + 20, 000 = 30, 000 cu. ft.) to reduce the concentration to 125 ppm; and a total dilution of 90,000 cu. ft. of dilution air (100,000 − initial 10,000 cu. ft. = 90,000 cu. ft.) would be required to reduce the level to the Occupational Health and Safety Administration (OSHA) 50 ppm PEL. Hence, a short-term release of 10,000 cu. ft. of exhaust from a furnace containing 500 ppm CO would need to be diluted into 90,000 cu. ft. along its path before it is
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 201 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
202
TABLE 8.1 Volumetric Expansion Due to Reaction and Released Heat from Reaction Gas Methane Ethane Propane Butane
Ideal combustion equation
VP/VR
CH2 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2 O CH2 H6 + 3.5O2 = 2CO2 + 3H2 O C3 H8 + 5O2 = 3CO2 + 4H2 O C4 H10 + 6.5O2 = 4CO2 + 5H2 O
3/3 5/4.5 7/6 9/7.5
Heat released (BTU/ft3 average) 1100 2500 3200
500
CO (ppm)
400 300 200 100
20,000 40,000
60,000 80,000
100,000
Total Volume of Air to Dilute Concentration
FIGURE 8.1 Effect of dilution on concentration.
reduced to 50 ppm. This exponential dilution decay mechanism allows for significant migration before the gas is rendered harmless (Figure 8.1). Labeling Implications: On the basis of molecular weight, CO is neutrally buoyant. It is thus more likely to move from its originating combustion process based on its thermal buoyancy. This buoyancy is more profound under conditions of greater temperature differential and with prolonged and continued releases compared to smaller “puff” releases. There are additional forces driving volumetric changes resulting from the combustion process. Owing to these characteristics, the contaminant moves in significantly variable ways depending on seasonal and ambient conditions.
8.2.4 EXIT VELOCITY CONSIDERATIONS FOR DIFFERENT CARBON MONOXIDE PRODUCING EQUIPMENT Some mechanisms that release CO have attached exhaust systems, so the exiting gases may have considerable range in their volumetric flow rates and initial exit velocities.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 202 — #6
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
203
The role that this range in exit velocity plays in the dispersion and distribution of the exhaust gas can be deceptive. For example, consider an engine’s exhaust system (seen in cars, construction vehicles, small gasoline-powered engines). These exhaust systems often accommodate at least an order of magnitude change in volumetric exhaust flow across their normal operation range. Under low speed operation, the volume of gases, and their ability to be propelled to a great distance from their exit point, may be extremely low. At high speeds, the velocity at the point of exit may be significantly greater. The general rule of thumb is that at approximately 20 diameters away from the exit point, the horizontal velocity has dropped to 10% of its initial value.4 Hence, it is a myth that the exhaust plume from most conventional engines can be propelled great distances backwards from their initial release point. In many combustion processes that have dedicated exhaust systems, there are relatively small changes in volumetric exhaust flow during normal operation. Furnaces, hot water heaters, and boilers are examples of this category of equipment, and they are typically operated at a constant firing rate, with burners either on or off. Thermal efficiency may be a consideration in the purchase of these devices, and therefore they are designed to achieve low exhaust gas temperatures, and incorporate large diameter exhaust systems to lower the resistance to exhaust flow, and sometimes utilize flue dampers5 to conserve heat during the “off” portion of the operation. Owing to the relatively small, thermally induced pressure differential in these systems, it is common to see some back flow and/or spillage of combustion products into the area where this equipment is located, at least under initial start-up conditions.6 The duration, cause, and consistency of this is highly dependent on the maintenance of the system, ambient conditions, and weather conditions. The footprint of this gas “spillage” is a sooty residue on air supply vents in residential furnaces and hot water heaters. While a small amount of “spillage” may be acceptable, consistent spillages can result in chronic exposure conditions. Some combustion sources do not have exhaust systems with well-defined exit velocities (e.g., stoves, welding torches, portable heaters). These devices exhaust directly into the area they operate in. They depend on their small size, clean exhaust, or area ventilation for the removal and dilution of the CO that they may produce. This is problematic when combustion is high in CO content, or when proper ventilation is not present. There have been numerous situations in which industrial welders or torch operators have been overexposed because they were working in a location with a poor ventilation system. Further, campers have been injured or killed because they used a portable heater or other combustion process in a tent that they thought was naturally ventilated. Labeling Implications: Automobile or other engine-powered equipment do not project their exhausts a significant distance horizontally due to high exit velocities; thermal effects are probably a greater driving force for movement of the CO. Installations with low forced exit velocities and low thermal content depend on their mechanical state of repair and ambient conditions for removal of the products of combustion. For CO removal, systems without dedicated exhaust systems rely heavily on the user, and on factors associated with their location.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 203 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
204
8.2.5 ABSORPTION AND DISSIPATION OF CARBON MONOXIDE CO is preferentially absorbed in comparison to oxygen. CO absorption and purging times (body dissipation time) from the blood system are a function of rate of respiration, and the oxygen content in the subsequent breathing air. The respiratory system is the only significant pathway for excretion of CO. The removal of the CO-exposed person and the introduction of oxygen-enriched breathing air are the most common means of removing CO from the body. The intravenous addition of blood can dilute the total amount of CO held within the body, but there are limits to the quantity of blood that can be added. Absorbed mass or body burden is a function of the rate of uptake and the size of the person. This means that large people generally take up a larger amount of CO than people with smaller body mass. Individuals who have a higher respiratory (i.e., ventilatory) rate will also take up CO faster. People with compromised respiratory systems, decreased levels of hemoglobin, or circulatory system problems are more at risk. Accelerated rate of absorption due to higher CO concentrations during exposure may compress the normal display of symptoms, whereas slower or chronic exposure may produce progressive steps in the symptomology. Symptoms may include flulike conditions, nausea, headache, sleepiness, and so forth followed by confusion, decreased cognitive capability, and unconsciousness. Variants in the symptoms of CO and variations among individuals can result in (1) CO exposures that go undiagnosed, (2) chronic exposures that cause long-term health problems, or (3) loss of consciousness and death. Safety and accident history information indicate that a significant percentage of total CO nonworkplace deaths occur through the use of camping and heating equipment that is used under poorly vented conditions, and from malfunctioning furnaces and water heaters. Both groups could benefit from warnings.
8.3 COMMON SOURCES OF CARBON MONOXIDE CO is associated with the following sources and locations:
8.3.1 CONSUMER PRODUCTS • Automobile and truck internal combustion engines (typically gasolinefueled types) • Cigarettes and side stream smoke • Combustion of charcoal/gas grills (typically propane) • Camp lanterns/stoves/gas or liquid fuel • Fire places, chimneys, flues, flue damper • Gasoline-powered engine implements: Lawn mowers Snow blowers High-pressure washers
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 204 — #8
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
• • • • • •
205
Power generators Air compressors Chain saws Hot water heaters (gas or oil) Kitchen stove burners and ovens (gas and propane fired) Motor boats, house boats Portable and stationary gas, liquid, and solid-fueled comfort and camp heaters Residential furnaces (gas or oil) Wood burning furnaces and heaters
8.3.2 INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS AND PROCESSES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
Blast furnaces Boiler operations (typically gas or oil) Calibration gases Cement kilns Chemical manufacturing (e.g., methanol, formaldehyde, ethylene) Coke ovens Construction site combustion space heaters Fuel gas generators (e.g., water gas, coal gas, producer gas) Gasoline engine powered tools and equipment Heat treating ovens (typically gas or oil) Industrial furnaces and space heating furnaces (gas, liquid, solid fuel) Industrial trucks and vehicles (typically gasoline or propane) Inert atmosphere generators Inhaling methylene chloride vapors (metabolizes to CO) Material handling/receiving docks (industrial trucks) Meat packaging additive Metallic ore refining Sewers and other underground structures Welding and torching operations Production of reducing oxides
This list demonstrates the ubiquitous consumer and industrial sources of CO. History has documented the numerous deaths and injuries associated with unexpected exposures. This situation has prompted the codification of methods to provide warnings and to investigate such hazards. Subsequent sections detail warning information; and an example of this investigation codification in contained in ASTM E2292-03 Standard Practice for Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Incidents. The scope of that standard states 1. Scope 1.1. This practice covers guidelines for collecting and preserving information and physical evidence related to incidents involving the poisoning of individuals by carbon monoxide.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 205 — #9
206
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
8.4 WHAT ARE WARNINGS, LABELS, INSTRUCTIONS, AND OTHER FORMS OF COMMUNICATIONS? In the context of this chapter, the phrase “warnings, labeling, instructions, and other forms of communications” (e.g., safety information) refers to those textual messages, words, pictures, alarms, and figures that are intended to eliminate or mitigate possible exposure to CO by alerting the person at risk, informing the person at risk, or reminding the person at risk of possible dangers. This last function of warnings to remind is especially important in situations where use of the equipment is highly intermittent, as may occur with seasonal camping equipment; or under circumstances where the manifestation of the hazard of CO may be transient. These warning items may appear as a label or tag directly on the product. They may be a part of the products’ packaging that includes depictions of the use of the product, or part of an instructional insert in the packaging. They may be a workplace sign or alarm that indicates when elevated levels of CO are detected. Warnings can be found in manuals that accompany products, or in locations where the products are used. There are also brochures compiled by CO hazard awareness advocate organizations. Many of these warning materials are now also available on the Internet or as inserts in promotional literature. This safety information is based on philosophical issues, safety research, voluntary, or regulatory requirements, the custom and practice of a given industry, or is litigation driven. Regardless of the forces at play, safety efforts have manifested themselves in a broad variety of warning schemes and warning materials.
8.5 THE CONTENT, CONFIGURATION, AND DESIGN OF LABELS, WARNINGS, AND INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS The term “label” is generally associated with writing or graphics that are attached to a product. Warnings may be a part of that “attached” label. They can also be included in other locations such as on the product packaging or on inserts provided within the packaging. The word warning itself is used as a specific “signal word” within a properly designed warning scheme. Warnings or safety information may also be found in certain locations rather than “on” a product. It is normal to see various warnings in the instructions, on packaging, and on doors and in areas of industrial facilities. Complicated safety instructions may be difficult to apply to an individual machine or use in an industrial setting, whereas some consumer products will have fairly detailed safety-related instructions. Instructions may also be a stand-alone item that contains both operational instructions and safety information. Usually when there are warnings that are difficult to actually apply to the product (e.g., or will not survive the life or usage of the product), there will be an instruction on the product to consult or “read the instructions” before operating or performing certain functions. On some products, there may even be a pouch or a compartment so that one can store the safety instructions along with the product.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 206 — #10
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
207
Arecent development on some chemical containers for lawn, garden, and pesticide products is a “fold out” label that provides additional space for written information.
8.5.1 DESIGN OF LABELING AND WARNINGS Although there is some latitude about the configuration and content of labeling, certain designs have become generic. Typically, the signal words of “Notice,” “Caution,” “Warning,” and “Danger” and the associated colors of blue, yellow, orange, and red are progressive with increasing degrees of danger (Figure 8.2). Often a triangular shape with an exclamation point or lightening bolt in its center is used to denote that the sign is related to safety concerns (Figure 8.3). These are called alert symbols. Typically, product warnings have well-defined borders or textual boxes containing the different elements of the warning. Figure 8.4 identifies 8 of the common elements of warnings based on a review of 11 publications addressing the design and configuration of warnings as tabulated in Table 8.2. Several American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standards provide guidelines on the minimum size of font height for warning signs, with 0.08 in. height being the minimum at a viewing distance of 1 ft. or less, 0.16 in. at 5 ft., and 0.22 in. at 8 ft. Konz,4 Woodson,7 McCormick and Sanders,8 and other authors on human factors provide considerations on the display of information with respect to letter size and readability, reading speeds, configurations, and conditions that may lead to errors in reading content. Table 8.2 compares the contents of 11 publications9−19 on 12 items related to the contents of warnings and shows a consistency across these items.
Pictorial
Your information here
Pictorial
Your information here
Pictorial
Your information here
Pictorial
Your information here
FIGURE 8.2 ANSI 535.2 type labels.
FIGURE 8.3 Typical alert symbols ANSI, ASAE, and SAE.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 207 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
208
Signal word Alert symbol Symbols & pictograph
DANGER Standard border
Hazard identification Result of ignoring warning
How to avoid hazard
Additional information
FIGURE 8.4 General vertical layout for warming label.
TABLE 8.2 Documents (A–K) Addressing Labeling/Warning Content Items (1–12) Content items 1. Hazard alert/symbols 2. Signal word 3. Color(s) 4. Symbols and pictures 5. Hazard identification 6. Result of ignoring hazard 7. How to avoid hazard 8. Location of label 9. Font size 10. Contents disposal 11. Material/durability 12. Fire/handling/Ref.
A9
B10
C11
D12
E13
F14
G15
H16
I17
x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x
x
x
x
x x x x x x x
x
x x x x x x x x x x
x
x
x x x x x x x x x
x x
x
x
x
x
x
x x x
x
J18 x x x x x x x x x
K19 x x x x
x x
x
One other labeling approach included in the ANSI standards is ANSI A13.120 for piping systems. It includes a color scheme, arrows to indicate the direction of flow, a signal word to identify the chemical content, and font size requirements. In a section entitled “Legal/Litigation Driven” there is an additional discussion of the contents of warnings/labels based on court decisions and legal interpretation. There are other places and products where specific warning designs are required by regulation and may not follow the criteria referred to above. The most ubiquitous of these is one of the warnings on cigarette packages (Figure 8.5). This particular warning is required by specific legislation,21 and does not conform to the criteria often found in the standards and guidelines for CO warnings.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 208 — #12
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
209
“SURGEONS GENERAL’S WARNING: Cigarette Smoke Contains Carbon Monoxide”
FIGURE 8.5 U.S. Government required CO warning on cigarette packages.
8.5.2 WRITTEN INSTRUCTIONAL INFORMATION ON SAFETY MATERIALS Safety instructions may require more space than is available on a label. In these cases instructions are described in a separate document. It is common to see warnings within manuals and other instructional materials that have the general appearance of an “on-product” warning, but are instead found in the accompanying materials. An example of a CO warning that is found with a product manual is shown in Figure 8.6. These messages are either bundled together into one section of the product literature or distributed in various sections of the literature. The Handbook of Technical Writing22 contains guidelines for the writing style that may be used in composing instructional materials. Writing and Designing Operator Manuals15 provides strategies for the composition and detail of safety manuals. The content found in these publications is the basis for instructional warnings about CO. Various gasoline engine-powered equipment have warnings in their instructional manuals about CO. Exemplar of this is the American Honda Motor Company Owner’s Manual23 for a line of small displacement engines that are used on lawn mowers, small portable generators, power washers, air compressors, and snow throwers. Their manual starts out with a brief discussion of what “Safety Messages” mean and how to identify them by a safety symbol, a signal word, and the box-like border around them. The manual uses the word “Warning” and the alert symbol and addresses the carbon monoxide hazard by stating Carbon monoxide gas is toxic. Breathing it can cause unconsciousness and even kill you. Avoid any areas or actions that expose you to Carbon monoxide.
This manual also contains a text under the title “Safety Information” that states Your engine’s exhaust contains poisonous carbon monoxide. Do not run the engine without adequate ventilation, and never run the engine indoors.
Under “Maintenance Safety,” there are additional “Safety Precautions” that state Carbon monoxide poisoning from engine exhaust. Be sure there is adequate ventilation whenever you operate the engine
(It should be noted that the exhaust emissions are met in part by the use of a catalytic converter system.)
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 209 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
210
_____________________________________________________________________________________________ Instruction Manual: COSTAR® P-1, 9V Personal CO Detector QGI P/N 099-0062-01 REV 07/25/01 Page 1 of 4
Personal Carbon Monoxide Detector Model P-1 OWNER’S MANUAL PLEASE READ AND SAVE! Personal & Automobile Use Dear New COSTAR® Model P-1 Owner, Congratulations as you have taken steps to help insure the health and life safety of you and your family. We are proud to offer you our unique, patented CO Sensor technology that detects CO in a manner similar to the human body's response. The COSTAR® P-1 is an ideal and low-cost way of warning you of both the acute and chronic effects of CO poisoning. Please read this owner's manual carefully so you will have a better understanding of the effects of CO poisoning and the COSTAR® P-1 Detector, as we work together pursuing a safer, healthier air quality for us all. To your good health and safety, Mark Goldstein, Ph.D. President Quantum Group Inc. 1.0 WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT CO Carbon monoxide (CO) is an insidious poison. It is a colorless, odorless and tasteless gas. It is a cumulative poison. Even low levels of CO have been shown to cause brain and other vital organ damage in unborn infants with no effect on the mother. The following symptoms are related to CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING and should be discussed with all members of the household: • MILD EXPOSURE: Slight headache, nausea, vomiting, fatigue (often described as “flu-like” symptoms), giddiness • MEDIUM EXPOSURE: Severe throbbing headache, drowsiness, confusion, fast heart rate • EXTREME EXPOSURE: Unconsciousness, convulsions, cardio-respiratory failure, death Many reported cases of CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING indicate that while victims are aware they are not well, they become so disoriented they are unable to save themselves by either exiting the building/automobile or calling for assistance. Also, young children and household pets may be the first affected. Your CO detector is designed to detect the toxic CO fumes that result from incomplete combustion, such as those emitted from appliances, furnaces, fireplaces and auto exhaust. (DO NOT put your detector next to the vehicle’s tailpipe. It may damage the detector permanently.) A CO detector is NOT A SUBSTITUTE for fire alarms, smoke alarms, or other combustible gas alarms. This carbon monoxide detector is designed to detect carbon monoxide gas from ANY source of combustion. CAUTION: This detector will only indicate the presence of carbon monoxide gas at the sensor. Carbon monoxide gas may be present in other areas at a higher concentration than at the detector’s location; therefore, immediately get fresh air. WARNING: This product is not designed to comply with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) commercial or industrial standards. Individuals with medical problems may consider using detection devices that provide audible and visual signals for CO concentrations under 30 PPM. 2.0 WHAT YOU SHOULD DO IF THE ALARM SOUNDS
WARNING: Actuation of this device indicates the presence of carbon monoxide (CO) which can KILL YOU.
_____________________________________________________________________ FIGURE 8.6 COSTAR® P-1, 9 V, personal CO detector.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 210 — #14
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
211
All of these statements are part of an effort to alert users of the potential release of CO, its poisonous nature, the need to vacate exposed areas, and means of mitigating exposure. More common are CO warnings found on internal combustion engine-powered cars and trucks. In the Hyundai 2003 Santa Fe Model Owner’s Manual,24 there is an entire page dedicated to engine exhaust emissions, predominantly associated with CO. That warning uses the alert symbol, the signal word “Warning,” and black lettering on a yellow background to garner attention and states that Exhaust fumes contain carbon monoxide, a colorless gas that can cause unconsciousness and death by asphyxiation.
Additional information is provided about how to avoid this hazard, what to look for in detecting this hazard, and other precautions.
8.5.4 WORKPLACE AREA WARNINGS AND LABELING Several ANSI and American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standards provide warning and labeling criteria for workplaces or work-related areas. They include Environmental and Facility Safety Signs, ANSI Z 535.2, 1991; Accident Prevention Signs, ANSI Z 535.5, 1998; Criteria for Safety Signs, ANSI Z 535.3, 1991. Standard Practice for Labeling Art Materials for Chronic Health Hazards, ASTM D 4236
On November 18, 1990 the Labeling of Hazardous Art Materials Act (Public Law 100-695) went into effect which embraces ASTM D 4236 (above) and requires labeling in that industry. OSHA has both general and activity-specific information about warning signs. Below are several examples. 8.5.4.1 Examples of General OSHA Warning Signage • For construction, 29CFR 1915.16(b) Posting of large work areas. A warning sign or label required by paragraph (a) of this section need not be posted at an individual tank, compartment or work space within a work area if the entire work area has been tested and certified: not safe for workers, not safe for hot work, and if the sign or label to this effect is posted conspicuously at each means of access to the work area. • For maritime, 1926.200(a) General. Signs and symbols required by this subpart shall be visible at all times when work is being performed, and shall be removed or covered promptly when the hazards no longer exist.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 211 — #15
212
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
• For general industry, 1910.145(a) Scope. 1910.145(a)(1) These specifications apply to the design, application, and use of signs or symbols (as included in paragraphs (c) through (e) of this section) intended to indicate and, insofar as possible, to define specific hazards of a nature such that failure to designate them may lead to accidental injury to workers or the public, or both, or to property damage. These specifications are intended to cover all safety signs except those designed for streets, highways, railroads, and marine regulations. These specifications do not apply to plant bulletin boards or to safety posters.
8.5.4.2 Examples of Specific OSHA Exposure Warning Signage • For asbestos activities, 1910.1001(j)(3) Warning signs. 1910.1001(j)(3)(i) Posting. Warning signs shall be provided and displayed at each regulated area. In addition, warning signs shall be posted at all approaches to regulated areas so that an employee may read the signs and take necessary protective steps before entering the area. 1910.1001(j)(3)(ii) Sign specifications. 1910.1001(j)(3)(ii)(A) The warning signs required by paragraph (j)(3) of this section shall bear the following information: DANGER ASBESTOS CANCER AND LUNG DISEASE HAZARD AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY • For cadmium and cadmium containing compounds, in all forms, 1910.1027(m)(2) “Warning signs.” 1910.1027(m)(2)(i) Warning signs shall be provided and displayed in regulated areas. In addition, warning signs shall be posted at all approaches to regulated areas so that an employee may read the signs and take necessary protective steps before entering the area. 1910.1027(m)(2)(ii) Warning signs required by paragraph (m)(2)(i) of this section shall bear the following information: DANGER CADMIUM CANCER HAZARD CAN CAUSE LUNG AND KIDNEY DISEASE AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY RESPIRATORS REQUIRED IN THIS AREA
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 212 — #16
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
213
1910.1027(m)(2)(iii) The employer shall assure that signs required by this paragraph are illuminated, cleaned, and maintained as necessary so that the legend is readily visible. 1910.1027(m)(3) “Warning labels.” 1910.1027(m)(3)(i) Shipping and storage containers containing cadmium, cadmium compounds, or cadmium contaminated clothing, equipment, waste, scrap, or debris shall bear appropriate warning labels, as specified in paragraph (m)(3)(ii) of this section. 1910.1027(m)(3)(ii) The warning labels shall include at least the following information: DANGER CONTAINS CADMIUM CANCER HAZARD AVOID CREATING DUST CAN CAUSE LUNG AND KIDNEY DISEASE 1910.1027(m)(3)(iii) Where feasible, installed cadmium products shall have a visible label or other indication that cadmium is present. 8.5.4.3 Other OSHA and Industry Warning Criteria There is no OSHA standard specific to CO signage. However, by following the criteria for general signage, hazard mitigation, and OSHA’s criteria for other chemicals, OSHA can utilize the “General Duty Clause” (a.k.a. “5a Clause”) to issue citations about inadequate CO warning signs. Other locations and industries have their own guidelines. Within the iron producing and steel manufacturing industry, CO is knowingly produced in blast furnace operations and in coke ovens. It is common in these industries to see warnings about the possibility of a CO outbreak (from a blast furnace) and the location of safe areas and evacuation routes. Since CO is produced in large quantities and at such elevated concentrations, blast furnace work areas are often equipped with monitors that continuously check CO concentrations. Safe rooms, rescue respirators, and signs about CO hazards are typical in these facilities. The Department of Defense Hazardous Chemical Warning Labeling System25 provides detailed labeling requirements including a mechanism for “rating” chemicals. The format for these Department of Defense (DOD) labels is unique, in part because of their use in wartime or under the stress of military conditions. They do not use the alert symbol, but do use the same hierarchy of signal words. They use a small selection of pictograms, including a skull and cross bones, which under their criteria is appropriate for CO. The DOD Hazardous Chemical Warning Label follows criteria set out in the 29 CFR 1910.1200 Hazard Communication Standard. It is often 8.5 by 11 in. in size, and contains information about specific categories of health, contact, fire, and reactivity. Following this format, a label for CO is rated as moderately toxic, severely flammable, and slightly reactive.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 213 — #17
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
214
8.6 THE REASONS, RATIONALE, AND SCIENTIFIC BASES FOR PROVIDING SAFETY INFORMATION FOR CARBON MONOXIDE WITH SELECTED EXAMPLES Many books and treatises have been written about the issues surrounding informing consumers of risk through warnings and informational means. A brief discussion of some of the bases for warnings, labeling, instructions, and safety communications is given below.
8.6.1 ETHICAL AND PHILOSOPHICAL REASONS The concept of “do no harm”26 is widely accepted as a moral and ethical obligation and may be an underling element (although not a part of) the Hippocratic Oath. All products, processes, and workplaces are capable of harm, and at a minimum people should be informed of hidden or unexpected risks that cannot be eliminated. Much of “being informed” comes from education, life experiences, and simple observation. With the added complications of modern technology, keeping oneself informed of product and workplace risks is difficult and in some cases impossible. From an ethical perspective, when hazards cannot be eliminated or reasonably safe guarded, it is necessary to provide information in the form of warnings, labeling, instructions, or other communications, so as to “do no harm.” One of the basic safety philosophies originating in part from the engineering and safety professional codes of ethics includes the notion that designers of equipment, products, and process have the three basic goals of (1) making a product/process that is functional, (2) making a product/process that helps human welfare by being available (and therefore is cost efficient), and (3) making a product/process that is reasonably safe. In other words, products have to work, be inexpensive enough for availability to the general public, and be reasonably safe.27 User information (warnings, labeling, and instructional information) affects all three of the items above. For most products and processes to function, there is a need for some directions and information. For most combustion processes, instructions about how the equipment is to function includes information that reduces the formation, accumulation, and concentration of CO. Instructional manuals, labels, and warnings all increase the cost of products. They can also delay the introduction of products into the market place. However, they can significantly increase consumer awareness about safety concerns. On complicated pieces of equipment and processes, informational materials often require testing and evaluations via “task analysis” to determine the effectiveness of the material before a new product enters the market place. Gordon and Hall28 and others suggest that a task analysis of a product and its accompanying documents should be a part of the normal product development sequence. In essence, warnings, labeling, instructional materials, and other forms of safety information should not be thought of as pieces of paper or decals, but as part of a vital scheme to do no harm.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 214 — #18
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
215
Within the safety community there is a general consensus that has developed over the years concerning steps that should be taken to ensure safe products and safe workplaces.29 The order to these incremental steps are 1. 2. 3. 4.
Eliminate the hazard Apply safeguarding technologies to control the hazard Warn potential users about the hazard and its features Provide training and/or personal protective equipment to mitigate exposure to the hazard
With CO, there is no real opportunity to “eliminate” the hazard as long as carbonbased fuels are in use. In some circumstances it is possible to provide safeguarding technologies. These include CO alarms, oxygen deficiency sensors (ODS),30 CO protective respirators, self-checking flue dampers, temperature sensors positioned to detect hot gas leaks (indicative of a leak of combustion gases), timers on space heaters, and the use of catalysts to enhance certain types of combustion processes. Providing information manifests itself in items (3) and (4). Unfortunately, this approach does not take into account the importance of safe product design in ensuring user safety. This factor is especially important in our technological world. Figures 8.7 through 8.12 show several excerpts of CO warning criteria that are not based on general codes or standards (though they may follow code criteria for their specific content and form), but are based on a range of ethical and philosophical safety criteria. Some of these warnings originate from an association or industry collective, while others are for products that do not produce CO, but are associated with other equipment that may produce CO. A diverse product mix is provided for instructional purposes.
“Carbon Monoxide Hazards from Small Gasoline Powered Engines Fact Sheet HS05-023B (8-05) “Tool Rental Agencies Should: …• Put warning labels on gasoline-powered tools. For example: WARNING - CARBON MONOXIDE PRODUCED DURING USE CAN KILL - DO NOT USE INDOORS OR IN OTHER SHELTERED AREAS.” FIGURE 8.7 Warning information from Texas Department of Insurance Division of Workers’ Compensation (TDI/DWC), E-mail:
[email protected]
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 215 — #19
216
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning “Important Alert for Gasfitters The Office of Gas Safety (OGS) alerts gasfitters that all open-flued instantaneous gas water heaters (IGWH) in toilets and bathrooms should be replaced as a matter of urgency…. Open-flued IGWH’s, in a confined living space, can expose gas users to the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning…. • Provided the Important Safety Warning including the dangers and symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning .”
FIGURE 8.8 Warning information from Office of Gas Safety Level 1, Wool House, 369 Royal Parade, Parkville, Victoria 3052.
Informational Brochure On CO Poisoning From Boating “Apply the enclosed carbon monoxide warning decals at the helm and by the swim deck as a reminder. Additional carbon monoxide warning decals may be obtained from any boating enforcement officer.”
FIGURE 8.9 Warning from National Marine Manufacturers Association, 200 East Randolph Drive, Suite 5100 Chicago, IL 60601-6528, Available at: www.nmma.org.
8.6.2 RESEARCH BASIS: THE NEED FOR SAFETY INFORMATION Much research into the efficacy of safety information has been conducted over the years. The findings are curiously polarized: safety information either helps or is not universal in effectiveness. However, there is not any substantial body of research finding that safety information hurts or causes a new harm. The literature repeatedly comes down to a discussion of to what extent safety measures help. Somewhere on this continuum, between safety measures being marginal to them being extremely useful, there is a middle ground wherein safety efforts help sufficiently and are reasonable in their design and application. A brief review of the safety literature over the past 25 years indicates that safety efforts are directed at the performance and efficacy of warnings, and that whether or not warnings should or should not be used is a less debated consideration. For example, in the publication entitled “Human Factors Perspectives on Warnings, 1980 to 1993,”31 the terms “effectiveness” or “effect(s)” appears in the title of listed papers and abstracts at least 27% of the time. These researchers are attempting to establish the threshold of effectiveness in warnings. In volume 2 of the same publication,32 covering the period 1994–2000, the research continues in that vein, with the added inquiries as to what aspects of a warning improves the effectiveness of the warning. Research into the colors by Braun et al.,33,34 symbols by Caird et al.,35 risk perception and warning dilution from multiple warnings by Chen et al.,36 legibility by Ringseis and Caird,37 and effects of age by Hancock et al.38 on word content are all examples of the direction the most recent
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 216 — #20
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
217
1.1.SAFETY ALERT SYMBOLS AND SIGNAL WORDS 1.2.14.1. Generator If your trailer is equipped with a gasoline or diesel generator, you must have and follow the generator manufacturer's instructions. You must also have one or more carbon monoxide detectors in the trailer's accommodation spaces. Carbon Monoxide is an odorless gas that can cause death. Be certain exhaust from a running generator does not accumulate in or around your trailer, by situations such as :
Being drawn in by fans or ventilators operated in a trailer ; Prevailing wind; Being trapped between your trailer and other trailers, vehicles or buildings; or Being trapped between your trailer and, or in a snow bank, or other nearby objects.
Operating gasoline and diesel generators can lead to death or serious injury by:
Carbon Monoxide Fire and Explosion Electrocution Have a working carbon monoxide detector in th e accommodation spaces before operating a generator. Do not refuel a running generator or refuel near ignition sources. 1.2.14.3. LP Gas Fuel System
You can die or be brain damaged by Carbon Monoxide. Make certain the exhaust from LP appliances is directed to the outdoors. Have a working carbon monoxide detector in th e accommodation spaces of your trailer before operating any LP gas appliance. Do not operate portable grills or stoves inside th e trailer.
FIGURE 8.10 Brockmann Trailers (a trailer manufacturer) (http://www.bockmann.co.uk/ supporta.asp), Lastrup, Northern Germany. Available at: http://www.bockmann.co.uk/ abouta.asp.
research has taken. None of these authors reports findings that product or process warnings are useless. Other research includes the role of “on-product” warnings, the interplay between warnings and training, and the relative effectiveness of verbal and nonverbal warnings. Examples of nonverbal warnings are included in Analysis of Workplace Factors on Auditory Warning Alarm Location by Nanthavanij.39 CO alarms and oxygen
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 217 — #21
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
218
!WARNING Failure to properly vent the water heater to the outdoors as outlined above and in the following section can result in unsafe operation of the water heater causing bodily injury, explosion, fire, or death. To avoid the risk of fire, explosion, or asphyxiation from carbon monoxide, NEVER operate this water heater unless it is properly vented and has an adequate air supply for proper operation.
FIGURE 8.11 Rheem, water heater manufacturer power vent residential gas water heater, use and care, AP10960-11 (04/02) manual (www.rheem.com/documents/resourcelibrary/use/ and care/rheempowervent/ap10960-11.pdf).
“Carbon Monoxide is a product of the reaction of H2 and CO2. Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odourless, tasteless and flammable gas which is acutely toxic. CO is introduced into the blood stream through the lungs and binds with the hemoglobin preventing it from carrying oxygen around the body. This can result in rapid damage to body tissues due to oxygen starvation. Since CO is an accumulating toxin it can be dangerous even when present in quite low concentrations over long periods of time.” ( note: triangular alert symbol is used)
FIGURE 8.12 Carbolite “coal ash fusion furnace,” installation, operation, maintenance instructions (industrial furnace), (industrial furnace) Hope Valley, S33 6RB, England CAF 16/38, MF45-1.0, Copyright 2002, 11/14/02.
depletion systems are prime examples of nonverbal warnings/alerting systems for exposure to CO. Some of the older research concerning the warning requirements for CO are contained in the Encyclopedia of Chemical Labeling.14 This book classifies CO as a chemical requiring identification as “extremely hazardous,” ”vapor extremely hazardous,” “poisonous if inhaled,” and a “poison.” The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) suggested in 1972 that CO cylinders and other containers be labeled “fatal if inhaled” and “do not breath gas.”40 For areas where CO gas may be present, they recommended signage stating that “high concentrations may be fatal.” In 1974, the American Insurance Association referenced the research work of the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) and concluded that, The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has repeatedly warned manufacturers of equipment which may produce carbon monoxide to label the equipment so as to inform the general public of the toxic hazards if improperly vented or used.41
Further, in 1971 through 1985, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) had a variety of research-based rules42 concerning ambient air quality. These included rules concerning CO content and how to alert or warn the public if they are at risk
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 218 — #22
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
219
of overexposure. The 1986 40 CFR Ch. 1, Par. 51.16 “Prevention of air pollution emergency episodes” required “Communication procedures for transmitting status reports [on carbon monoxide] for contact with the public officials, major emissions sources, public health, safety, and emergency agencies and news media”43
to warn the public of air pollution episodes.
8.6.3 VOLUNTARY STANDARDS FOR CO WARNINGS (EXAMPLES IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER) Numerous nongovernmental codes, standards, and guidelines recognize the need to inform workers and consumers of the hazards of CO. Figures 8.13 through 8.20 show some examples for different time periods, locations, and products.
8.6.4 MANDATORY SAFETY INFORMATION REGULATIONS Regulations regarding product warnings and labeling are based in part on our social value system. Our society has allowed for the formation of various regulatory bodies, and it is generally through these regulatory agencies that mandatory requirements “Carbon Monoxide DANGER! EXTREMELY FLAMMABLE GAS UNDER PRESSURE MAY BE FATAL IF INHALED Avoid breathing gas. Keep container closed. Use with adequate ventilation. Keep away from heat, sparks and open flames. Never drop cylinder. Keep cylinder out of sun and away from heat.”
FIGURE 8.13 Manufacturing Chemist Association (MCA) “Guideline for Chemical Labeling.” “NOTE: The 0.01% level of CO in indicated to protect the test personnel…”
FIGURE 8.14 Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) “Test Procedure for Measuring Carbon Monoxide Concentrations in Vehicle Passenger Compartments,” SAE J989, Approved 1968, 1971 Handbook. “Para:8.4.(b) WARNING: during an extended hot idle period of up to 60 minutes, idle exhaust CO from the test or traffic simulation vehicle will probably remain constant.”
FIGURE 8.15 Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) “Test Procedure for Measuring Carbon Monoxide Concentrations in Vehicle Passenger Compartments,” SAE J989a, Revised 1978, 1985 Handbook.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 219 — #23
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
220
“1.34.7 INSTALLATION MARKINGS… (c)… This appliance must be properly connected to a venting system. This appliance is equipped with a vest safety shutoff system. WARNING: Operation of this wall furnace when connected to a properly installed and maintained venting system or tampering with the vent safety shutoff system can resultin carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning and possible death.”
FIGURE 8.16 ANSI Z 21.49—1989 “Gas Fired Gravity and Fan Type Vented Wall Furnaces.”
“ Operation and Installation Instructions: 21.1J The word “WARNING”, and the following or equivalent text: “TO REDUCE THE RISK OF CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING, TEST DETECTOR OPERATION IF NOT IN USE FOR 10 DAYS OR MORE. (K) The word “WARNING”, and the following equivalent text: “This device may not alarm at low carbon monoxide levels. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has established that continuous exposure to levels of 35 ppm should not be exceeded in an eight hour period”
FIGURE 8.17 Use,” 1989.
UL 1524 “Standard for Safety—Carbon Monoxide Gas Detectors for Marine
WARNING! Do not use equipment and tools powered by gasoline engines inside buildings or other partially enclosed spaces unless the gasoline engine can be placed outdoors and away from air intakes
Tool rental Agencies Should: • Place warning labels on gasoline-engine-powered tools. For example: WARNING – CARBON MONOXIDE PRODUCED DURING USE CAN KILL – DO NOT USE INDOORS OR IN OTHER SHELTERED AREAS.
FIGURE 8.18 National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, NIOSH ALERT:1996, Pub. No. 96-118 “Preventing Carbon Monoxide Poisoning from Small Gasoline-Powered Engines and Tools.”
for product safety information are created. These efforts are a compromise between no regulation at all, or banning products that cannot be made safe without such information.44 Government regulatory agencies have to balance public demand, business interests, and political intrigue, with a well-established scientific basis for implementing safety standards.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 220 — #24
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
221
All unvented Servel Refrigerators shall have a warning label, protected from the environment, that is either affixed to the outside of the front door or inside the Un-Vented Servel Refrigerator in a location that is readily visible. The warning label shall have the following wording: Warning This refrigerator is prone to the production of Carbon Monoxide in levels that may be lethal. This refrigerator may only be operated in an area that is isolated from the living space such as: a remote shed, garage or open porch. The refrigerator shall be located a minimum distance of 12 inches from any opening to the living space
FIGURE 8.19 Technical Standards and Safety Authority, 14th Floor, Certre Tower, Toronto, Ontario, CAN, Ref. No FS-076-06, March, 2006, Director’s Order, Fuels Safety Program, Roland Hadaller, Director.
Using a generator indoors WILL KILL LYOU IN MINUTES. Exhaust contains carbon monoxide, a poison gas you cannot see or smell.
NEVER use in the home or in partly enclosed areas such as garages.
ONLY use outdoors and far from open windows, doors, and vents.
FIGURE 8.20 UL offered CO warning label (www.ul.com/media/newsrel/generatorCOMarking.pdf).
Scientific research into chemical hazards often has implications for the development of mandatory safety regulations. For example, Viscusi44 reports that “the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA’s) predominant risk standard for carcinogens is a lifetime risk of 1/1,000,000. This is ten times as conservative as the 1/100,000 lifetime risk embodied in California’s Proposition 65 (which mandated hazard warnings for risks of cancer and reproductive toxicity from products, jobs, and the environment).” Determining the accuracy of this risk assessment is difficult since there are no public death registries for CO, whereas there are well-established registries and protocols for cancer deaths (e.g., Centers for Disease Control, National Program for Cancer Registries). Typically, manufacturers have an idea concerning the number of deaths from CO related to their products. However, this information is generally kept at high levels of confidentiality. Burd (2002)45 reports in his research of a single county (Bexar County, Texas, population 1.4 million, 2000 census) over a six decade time period (1935–1995) that for the past 5 years (1991–1995) the death rate from CO was 40 deaths per 1,000,000
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 221 — #25
222
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
residents. Although a direct comparison to the FDA or the California numerical risk criteria noted above is not perfectly correct, there is a close correspondence. The CPSC has also investigated deaths from CO. In Non-fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths Associated with the use of Consumer Products 2001 Annual Estimates (www.cpsc.gov/LIBRARY/coed04.pdf) the CPSC reports that: In 2001 there were an estimated 130 unintentional non-fire CO poisoning deaths associated with consumer products under the jurisdiction of the U. S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Fifty-eight percent of the estimated deaths in 2001 were associated with the use of heating systems. Natural gas heating accounted for 37 percent and liquefied petroleum (LP) gas heating accounted for 35% of the estimated heating deaths. An estimated 18% of the 2001 annual CO poisoning deaths were associated with enginepowered tools, nine percent were associated with charcoal grills, eight percent were associated with gas ranges and ovens, one percent were associated with camp stoves and lanterns, and seven percent were associated with other or multiple appliances.46
Meanwhile, in the CPSC’S “Incidents, Deaths, and in-Depth Investigations Associated with Carbon Monoxide from Engine-Driven Generators and Other Engine-Driven Tools, 1990–2004” (December 1, 2005, Natalie E. Marcy, www.cpsc.gov/LIBRARY/coed05.pdf) there are reportedly 317 incidents of poisoning and 318 deaths from exposure. Both these reports indicate a significant death rate from CO, and are the basis for some of the mandatory regulations concerning warnings and labeling. In 1993, the OSHA published their “Final Rule” on confined spaces: Entry Permits: The entry permit.. shall identify: (7) The hazards of the permit space to be entered.
Applying this criteria to a space that may contain CO requires postings about the hazards of carbon monoxide. In 1994, OSHA implemented mandatory rules about chemical hazards, primarily directed at workers but that have labeling implications for both worker and consumer populations. The “Hazard Communication” provision of 29 CFR 1910.1200 requires specific information be provided on “all chemicals produced or imported” into the country. This section specifically states that: label means any written, printed, or graphic material displayed on or affixed to containers of hazardous chemicals.
Section (f) contains detailed labeling requirements addressing the use of: appropriate hazard warnings, or alternatives, words, pictures, symbols, or combination thereof …regarding the hazards of the chemical …
Applying this criteria to containers of CO, there would be information about the highly toxic nature of exposure, the need to take appropriate protection measures, and the necessity of ceasing contact with the gas. Figures 8.21 through 8.26 show examples of the current federal, state, and local regulations concerning safety information for the hazard of CO.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 222 — #26
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
223
Tennessee OSHA has instituted a Special Emphasis Program for Carbon Monoxide (CO). This is established to focus state-wide attention on carbon monoxide and to reduce employee exposure to, and eliminate deaths from, carbon monoxide.
Carbon Monoxide Warning Sign
WARNING CARBON MONOXIDE A colorless, odorless, toxic gas is produced from incomplete combustion of gas, oil, kerosene, and wood. May cause dizziness, nausea, or headache Excessive exposure may cause unconsciousness and death May aggravate heart and artery diseases
FIGURE 8.21 State of Tennessee OSHA F:\TN Department of Labor and Workforce Development.htm “Special Emphasis Program—Carbon Monoxide, The Hidden Killer.”
Mandatory Carbon monoxide Warning Decals Now Available Contact: June lljana (916) 263-0788 e-mail: pubinfo.dbw.ca.gov April 29, 2005 Sacramento – As of May 1, California boaters will be required to place stickers on their newly purchased boats warning against the threat of carbon monoxide poisoning The Farr and Stacet Beckett Boating safety Act of 2004 requires that a set of carbon monoxide warning stickers be placed on the transom and helm of all new and used motorized boats sold in California. The bill, AB 2222 (Koretz), was signed by Governor Schwarzenegger in September.
FIGURE 8.22 State of California, Department of Boating and Waterways, F:\Mandatory Carbon Monoxide Warning Decals Now Available.htm.
8.6.4.1 State-Based Examples Figures 8.21 through 8.23 show state-based examples. 8.6.4.2 Federal Government Examples Figures 8.24 through 8.26 show Federal Government examples.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 223 — #27
224
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
NECESSITY, FUNCTION, AND CONFORMITY: KRS 217.690 authorizes the Cabinet for Human Resources to adopt administrative regulations to regulate the control of hazardous substances in Kentucky. The purpose of this administrative regulation is to provide uniform standards relating to the "conspicuousness" of labeling requirements; to specify requirements to identify hazardous substances that present special hazards and require specialized labeling to protect the public health; and to prevent the deceptive use of disclaimers on labelsof hazardous substances.Section 1. Conspicuousness of Labeling Requirements. (1) The signal word, the statement of the principal hazard or hazards, and instructions to read carefully any cautionary information that may be placed elsewhere on the label shall appear together on the main panel of the label. The information shall be placed together and distinctively apart from other wording or designs. The necessary prominence shall be achieved by placement within the borders of a square or rectangle with or without a borderline, and by use of suitable contrasts with the background achieved by distinctive typography or color, and by both color and typography if needed. Section 2. Special Labeling Requirements. In addition to the requirements of KRS 217.670 the following hazardous substances are deemed to be misbranded unless the label includes the requirements stated below: (1) Charcoal briquettes and other forms of charcoal for cooking or heating. Because inhalation of the carbon monoxide produced by burning charcoal indoors or in confined areas may cause serious injury or death, containers of the products shall bear the following borderlined statements: "WARNING; Do Not Use for Indoor Heating or Cooking Unless Ventilation is Provided for Exhausting Fumes to Outside. Toxic Fumes May Accumulate and Cause Death".
FIGURE 8.23 Labeling and identification standards. Relates to: KRS 217.650-217.710. Statutory authority: KRS 194.050, 211.090, 211.180, 217.690, 902 KAR 47:020.
“(2) It shall be unlawful for any manufacturer or importer of cigarettes to advertise or cause to be advertised (other than through the use of outdoor billboards) within the United States any cigarette unless the advertising bears, in accordance with the requirements of this section, one of the following labels:… SURGEON GENERAL'S WARNING: Cigarette Smoke Contains Carbon Monoxide.”
FIGURE 8.24 Title 15—Commerce and Trade Chapter 36—Cigarette Labeling and Advertising §1331. Congressional declaration of policy and purpose.
8.6.5 THE CUSTOM AND PRACTICE OF CARBON MONOXIDE SAFETY INFORMATION “Custom and Practice” in the safety and engineering profession is a term referring to common customs and practices in the design of equipment, products, and processes. “Custom” having the meaning “a usual practice or habitual way of behaving; habit,” and “practice” having the meaning “to do or be engaged in frequently or usually.”47 Custom and practice is all around us. It is what we are accustomed to and what multiple designers have coalesced to in their designs. For example, the ubiquitous use of right-handed threads on nuts and bolts is the custom and practice for most threaded fastening applications. The introduction of metric threads was a change to a preexisting custom and practice in the United States. For some things the custom and practice is regional. In certain dryer portions of the southwest, residential air cooling is performed by evaporative coolers, while in more humid areas, compression cycle cooling units are used.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 224 — #28
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
225
To direct the Consumer Product Safety Commission to issue regulations concerning the safety and labeling of portable generators. (1) WARNING: portable generator sold to the public for purposes other than resale shall have a large, prominently displayed warning label on the exterior packaging, if any, of the portable generator and permanently affixed on the portable generator regarding the carbon monoxide hazard posed by incorrect use of the portable generator.
The warning label shall include the word “DANGER” printed in a large font, and shall include the following information, at a minimum, presented in a clear manner: (A) Indoor use of a portable generator can kill quickly. (B) Portable generators should be used outdoors only and away from garages and open windows. C) Portable generators produce carbon monoxide, a poisonous gas that people cannot see or smell. (2) PICTOGRAM.--Each portable generator sold to the public for purposes other than resale shall have a large pictogram, affixed to the portable generator, which clearly states “POISONOUS GAS” and visually depicts the harmful effects of breathing carbon monoxide.”
FIGURE 8.25 109th U.S. Congress (2005–2006) S. 2084: Portable Generator Safety Act, Introduced December 13, 2005.
Requirements for Labeling of Retail Containers of Charcoal; proposed Amendments AGENCY: Consumer Product Safety Commission. ACTION: Proposed rule.\1\ SUMMARY: Under the Federal Hazardous Substances Act, the Commission is proposing a rule to change the required labeling for retail containers of charcoal intended for cooking or heating. The labeling addresses the carbon monoxide hazard associated with burning charcoal in confined spaces. The proposed amendments, which include a pictogram, are intended tomake the label more noticeable and more easily read and understood and to increase the label's ability to motivate consumers to avoid burning charcoal in homes, tents, or vehicles. DATES: Comments on the proposal should be submitted no later than October 24, 1995.”
FIGURE 8.26 Consumer Product Safety Commission, 6 CFR Part 1500. Available at: http://www.cpsc.gov/businfo/frnotices/fr95/95-40785.html.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 225 — #29
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
226
CAUTION CARBON MONOXIDE MAY BE PRESENT
FIGURE 8.27 Seton Style No. M9699.
In some cases, the custom and practice is dictated by codes, standards, or guidelines. OSHA’s Standard Interpretations: Fluor Constructors, Inc. v. OSHRC, No. 87- 4029 1/22/1988 states that, a Commission judge agreed with the Secretary that both OSHA’s standards and industry custom and practice plainly distinguish between lifelines and lanyards.
This concept, or pattern of practice, is generally accepted as a means to establish what safety measures are reasonable. Where codes do not require user-safety information, custom and practice can be the basis for requiring notice of a hazard. In the United States Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission’s decision in “SECRETARY OF LABOR, Complainant, v. CITY OIL WELL SERVICE CO., Respondent”48 the Commission stated that, The evidence indicates that the custom and practice of the industry is for the well servicer to rely on the well operator or owner to advise it if H2 S hazards are present.
The phrase “of the industry” in the decision above associates custom and practice with the multiple providers of goods or services that comprise an industry. When there are few providers of these items, or if there is a single provider, it is difficult to say this “practice” is the “usual” in that it may be the “only” practice. In this context, one provider’s design does not establish enough of a pattern for there to be a custom and practice to evaluate safe design. In some cases, custom and practice criteria has been “institutionalized” into standalone business enterprises. Several firms sell standard and customized warning signs and labels, including ones directed at CO exposure (Emedco, Seton, VMC, Inc., Safetysign Inc.) (Figure 8.27). There does appear to be a general custom and practice with respect to safety warnings within the United States both with regard to their content and to a lesser extent concerning on what products or places warnings should be applied. The content aspect is well documented. The content of warnings and other safety information generally include (1) a signal word, (2) a pictorial, (3) a signal symbol, (4) a description of the hazard, (5) a statement of the consequences, and (6) a statement of how to avoid the hazard.9,10,14,28 With regards to which products and places require safety information, there is some variation among different products, product groups, and processes. With respect to CO, there are several established customs and practices for different products and places. In Carbon Monoxide: Its Hazards and the Mechanisms
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 226 — #30
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
227
INSTRUCTIONS “! WARNING! … Actuation of your CO alarm indicates the presence of carbon monoxide (CO) which can KILL YOU. … CAUTION: This alarm will only indicate the presence of carbon monoxide (CO) gas at the sensor. CO gas may be present in other areas of the RV.”
FIGURE 8.28 Model 3400 Carbon Monoxide Gas Alarm 5052 (CO Alarm for RVs) CCI Controls Co., Cecelia Street, South Gate, CA 90280. Phone: (323) 560-6060; Fax: (323) 560-1136; available at: www.ccicontrols.com.
Assembly Instructions “WARNING CARBON MONOXIDE HAZARD Burning charcoal inside can kill you. It gives off carbon monoxide, which has no odor. NEVER burn charcoal inside homes, vehicles or tents….”
FIGURE 8.29 Tabletop Grill™ (Drum-type Barbeque Grill), New Braunfels, Model 03407610.
of Its Actions (1944), published by the United States Public Health Service,49 there is reference to the early warning needs of CO exposure: In spite of these efforts, a large number of accidents from CO poisoning occur which are due to acts of carelessness of uninformed persons, as pointed out by Brumbaugh (1926) and it seems to be imperative that the public be informed about the proper handling of such appliances (bolding added for emphasis) [gas appliances and space heaters]… it appears that the public is not aware of the dangers resulting from the improper handling of gas appliances capable of forming CO due to incomplete combustion.
To the present time, the custom and practice is to continually inform the public of the hazards of CO exposure. Automobile manuals, for example, consistently and for many years have warned the public about the possibility of CO overexposure from operation of a vehicle’s engine in an enclosed space. Figures 8.28 through 8.31 show examples of warnings, labels, or instructions about CO that are the result of an existing or emerging custom and practice, and are not the result of voluntary standards or mandatory regulations.
8.6.6 LITIGATION-DRIVEN SAFETY INFORMATION It is not unusual for an injured party to complain about insufficient warnings or instructions in product defect or workplace injury cases. Since warnings and instructions can influence the safe use of a product, it is reasonable to consider them in
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 227 — #31
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
228
OPERATING INSTRUCTIONS AND OWNER’S MANUAL “WARNING: Early signs of carbon monoxide poisoning resemble the flu, with headache, dizziness and/or nausea. If you have these signs, heater may not be working properly. Get fresh air at once! Have heater serviced. … WARNING: Combustion by-products producedwhen using this product contain carbon monoxide, a chemical known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects (or other reproductive harm).”
FIGURE 8.30 Mr. Heater (Portable Propane Space Heater). Model # MH18B Enerco Group, Inc., 4560 W. 160th Street, Cleveland, OH 44135 · 216-881-5500 05/04 Revision L1 # 78435.
Operating and Maintenance Instructions“ WARNING_Engine exhaust contains carbon monoxide, an odorless, colorless, poison gas. …Breathing carbon monoxide can cause nausea, fainting and death.”
FIGURE 8.31 Briggs & Stratton, Power Products Group, Model AA0101 (four-stroke outboard engine), Milwaukee, WI, Form number MS-5682-9/03.
evaluating their effects on the safe use of the product or workplace. Safety criteria can be based on the precedence of prior cases or regional law. Individual states and the federal bench have their own juristically developed labeling, warning, and instructional criteria for product safety. Below is just one example of these criteria: Adequate warning: 1) it must be of such form that it could reasonably be expected to catch the attention of the reasonably prudent man in the circumstances of its use; and 2) the content of the warning must be of such a nature as to be comprehendible to the average user and to convey a fair indication of the nature and extent of the danger to the mind of a reasonably prudent person … the question of whether or not a given warning is legally sufficient depends upon the language used and the impression that such language is calculated to make upon the mind of the average user of the product. Implicit in the duty to warn with the degree of intensity that would cause a reasonable man to exercise.… the caution commensurate with the potential danger… A clear cautionary statement setting forth the exact nature of dangers involved would be necessary to fully protect the seller… .50
Weinstein and Twerski51 in 1978 reports (p. 41)
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 228 — #32
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
229
The court in Muncy vs Magnolia Chemical Company set forth its requisite for adequate warnings: ‘1) it must be of such form that it could reasonably be expected to catch the attention of the reasonably prudent man in the circumstances of use; and 2) content of the warning must be of such a nature as to be comprehensible to the average user… Implicit in the duty to warn is the duty to warn with a degree of intensity that would cause a reasonable man to exercise… the caution commensurate with the potential danger….’
In The Restatement of Torts: Products Liability,51 the American Bar Institute addresses the relationship between dangerous product design and product warnings and instructions. Section 402A states that, One who sells any product in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to the user or to his property is subject to liability for physical harm thereby caused to the ultimate user or consumer.
In The Restatement of Torts: Products Liability—the tension between product design and product warning, the author explains that, courts have interpreted [section] 402A to mean that a product may be unreasonably dangerous because of a defect in manufacturing, design, or warnings and instructions.
Silvergate expands this by including the third restatements of torts language in conjunction with proper design: [A Product] is defective because of inadequate instructions or warnings when the foreseeable risks of harm posed by the product could have been reduced or avoided by the provision of reasonable instructions or warnings by the seller or other distributor, or a predecessor in the commercial chain of distribution and the omission of the instructions or warnings renders the product not reasonably safe.
But that, In general, when a safer design can reasonably be implemented and risks can reasonably be designed out of a product, adoption of the safer design is required over a warning…
Hence, warnings and instructions have a second place behind proper design in the eyes of the judicial system, but they are a vital element in deciding if a product (or place or process) is reasonably safe. Many of these and other legal admonitions are passed on to the engineering community. In a how-to book for engineers called What every Engineer Should Know About Products Liability,52 the authors detail the four components of a warning communication (p. 58): 1. Intelligibility 2. Adequacy
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 229 — #33
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
230
3. Completeness 4. Placement and add that: If a product has obvious dangers, there is no duty to warn, since the danger is a matter of common knowledge. For example, the fact that a sharp knife is capable of cutting a careless user is a matter of common knowledge and is obvious. Similar remarks can be made for guns, blowtorches, and so forth. The hazards that must be warned against are the less obvious ones - inherent, latent, or concealed dangers the manufacturer has knowledge of but the user cannot foresee.
In the publication, Injury and Litigation Prevention, by Freeman, 1991,53 the author presents eight considerations that may be used in a judicial evaluation of warnings. Many of these are consistent with those detailed in previous sections, but also included is the concept of “motivate[ing] behavioral change.” Warnings should not just provide weak warnings, but the “consequences of continuing the forbidden activity must be clear, not remote or hidden.” Finally, while the courts and legal systems around the world have very different traditions and bases for their laws and judicial processes, Huber54 discusses the positions of several judicial systems around the world in regards to safety, liability, and warnings. Comparisons are made among English, Japanese, German, French, and Canadian case law, and reports that product warnings may be a basis for concluding a product is defective.
References 1. Kandarjian, L. Federal Policy Options for Indoor Air Pollution from Combustion Appliances, Transactions of Combustion Processes and the Quality of the Indoor Environment, Harper, J., ed., International Specialty Conference, Air and Waste Management Association, September 1988. 2. Flickinger, J. Characterization of Emissions and Indoor Air Quality Impacts Resulting from Vented and Unvented Gas Appliances in Ten Homes, Dames & Moore, Transactions of Combustion Processes and the Quality of the Indoor Environment, Harper, J., ed., International Specialty Conference, Air and Waste Management Association, September 1988. 3. Carbon monoxide. Material Safety Data Sheet, Genium Publishing Company, Schenectady, NY, January 1986, MSDS # 35. 4. Konz, S. Work Design, Industrial Ergonomics, 4th ed., Publishing Horizons, Inc., Scottsdale, AZ, p. 388, 1995. 5. Heating System Check Recommended for Carbon Monoxide—CPSC Release 88–92, November 1989. 6. Fugler, D. Indoor Pollution Measured in Combustion Spillage Testing, Research Division, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp., Ottawa, ON, Transactions of Combustion Processes and the Quality of the Indoor Environment, Harper, J., ed., International Specialty Conference, Air and Waste Management Association, September 1988. 7. Woodson, W.E. Human Factors Design Handbook, 2nd ed., McGraw Hill, NY, 1992.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 230 — #34
Application of Warnings and Labels for Carbon Monoxide Protection
231
8. McCormick, E.J. and Sanders, M.S. Human Factors in Engineering and Design, 5th ed., McGraw Hill, New York, NY, 1982. 9. Product Safety Label Handbook, Westinghouse Electric Company, Traftord, PA, 1981. 10. Product Safety Sign and Label System, FMC Corporation, Santa Clara, CA, Copyright 1990. 11. Holkham, T. Label Writing and Planning, Blackie Academic, London; Melbourne, 1995. 12. Holmes, N. Wordless Diagrams, Bloomsbury, USA, 2005. 13. Recchia, N. Warnings, Mark Batty, West New York, NJ, 2005. 14. Mellan, I. Encyclopedia of Chemical Labeling, Chem. Publishing Co., Newyork, NY, 1961. 15. Schoff, G. Writing & Designing Operator Manuals, Lifelong Learning Publications, Division of Wadsworth, Inc., Belmont, CA, 1984. 16. Product Safety Signs and Labeling, ANSI Z 535.4, 1998; “Safety Color Code”, ANSI Z 535.1, 1991; Environmental and Facility Safety Signs, ABSI Z 535.2, 1991; Accident Prevention Signs, ANSI Z 535.5, 1998; Criteria for Safety Signs, ANSI Z 535.3, 1991. 17. For Hazardous Industrial Chemicals—Precautionary Labeling, ANSI Z 129.1, 1994. 18. Ryan, J. Design of Warning Labels and Instructions, Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1991. 19. Specifications for Accident Prevention Signs, USA Standard, USAS Z38.1, 1959. 20. Scheme for the Identification of Piping Systems, ANSI A13.1, 1981. 21. Title 15—Commerce and Trade, Chapt. 36—Cigarette Labeling and Advertising. 1999. 22. Brusaw, C. Handbook of Technical Writing, 5th ed., St. Martins Press, NY, 1997. 23. Honda Owner’s Manual, GC160–GC190, American Honda Motor Co., 31Zl8A08 00X31-ZL8-A080, 2003–2005 copyright. 24. 2003 Owner’s Manual—Santa Fe, Hyundai Motor Co., A030A020-AAT. 25. Department of Defense Hazardous Chemical Warning Labeling System, Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense, 93-17976, DOD 6950.5 H, June 1989. 26. Hippocrates, The Epidemics, Bk. I, Sect. XI. 27. Professional Engineering Codes of Ethics, 1999. 28. Gordon, S. and Hall, P. Systematic Training Program Design, University of Idaho, Englewood, Cliffs, NJ, p. 70, 1994. 29. Barnett, R.L. and Brickman, D. Safety Hierarchy, Triodyne Inc., Safety Brief, Vol. 3, No. 2 Revised, Niles, IL, June 1985. 30. A.G.A. Requirements for Carbon monoxide Safety Shutoff Systems and Carbon Monoxide Warning Devices, Supplement to American National Standard for Automatic Gas Ignition Systems and Components, ANSI Z 21.20, as contained in report No. 2-86, Nov 10, 1986. 31. Human Factors Perspectives on Warnings, 1980–1993, Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 1994. 32. Human Factors Perspectives on Warnings, Vol. 2, 1994–2000, Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 2001. 33. Braun, C.C., Greeno, B., and Silver, N.C. Differences in Behavior Compliance as a Function of Warning Color, Proceedings of the HFES 38th Annual Meeting, USA pp. 379–383, 1998. 34. Braun, C.C., Holt, R.S., and Silver, N.C. Signal Word and Color Specifications for Product Warnings, Proceedings of the HFES 38th Annual Meeting, USA, pp. 1104–1108, 1994.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 231 — #35
232
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 35. Caird, J.K., Wheat, B., and McIntosh, K.R. The Comprehensibility of Airline Safety Card Pictorials, Proceedings of the HFEWS 41st Annual Meeting, USA, pp. 801–805, 1996. 36. Chen, J.C., Gilson, W.D., and Mouloua, M. The Comprehensibility of Airline Safety Card Pictorials, Proceedings of the HFES 41st Annual Meeting, USA, pp. 801–805, 1997. 37. Ringseis, E.L. and Caird, J.K. The Comprehensibility and Legibility of Twenty Pharmaceutical Warning Pictorials, Proceedings of the HFES 39th Annual Meeting, USA, pp. 974–978, 1995. 38. Hancock, H.E., Rogers, W.A., and Fisk, A.D. Understanding Age-related Differences in the Perception and Comprehension of Symbolic Warning Information, Proceedings of the HFES 43rd Annual Meeting, USA, pp. 617–621, 1999. 39. Nanthavanji, S. Analysis of Workplace Factors on Auditory Warning Alarm Location, In Advances in Industrial Ergonomics and Safety VII, Taylor & Francis, Bristol, PA, 1995. 40. Criteria for a recommended standard …Occupational Exposure to Carbon monoxide, U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), 1972. 41. Chemical Hazards Bulletin, Engineering and Safety Services, American Insurance Association, 85 John Street, NY 10038, August, 1974. 42. In 1971 Primary and Secondary National Ambient Air Quality Standards (36 FR 8186), in 1985 Review of the National Ambient Air Quality Standards for Carbon Monoxide, 40 CFR Part 50, FR Vol. 50, No. 176, September 13, 1985. 43. 40 CFR Ch. 1, 7-1-86 Edition, Para 51.16(e) (3). 44. Viscusi, W.K. Product-Risk Labeling—A Federal Responsibility, Am. Enterprise Institute, p. 1, Washington, DC, 1993. 45. Burd, L.T. CO Morbidity and Mortality Six Decades of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, Master of Public Health Thesis, University of Texas, Health Science Center at Houston, School of Public Health, August, 2002. 46. Non-fire Carbon Monoxide Deaths Associated with the use of Consumer Products 2001 Annual Estimates, CPSC, Susan Carlson, Directorate of Epidemiology, May 13, 2004. 47. Webster’s New World Dictionary of the American Language, 2nd College ed., World Publishing Co., 1970. 48. Decision in Secretary of Labor, Complainant, vs. CITY OIL WELL SERVICE CO., Respondent. OSHRC Docket number 81-1797, Buckley, Chairman; Cleary, Commissioner, September 30, 1986. 49. von Oettingen, W.F. et al. Carbon Monoxide: Its Hazards and the Mechanisms of Its Actions, Federal Security Agency, United States Public Health Service, Public Health Bulletin No. 290, 1944. 50. Weinstein, A.S. and Twerski, A.D. Products Liability and the Reasonably Safe Product, Wiley, p. 41, 1978. 51. Silvergate, S.H. The Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability—The Tension Between Product Design and Product Warnings, Florida Bar J., Vol. 75, pp. 10–17, December 1, 2001. 52. Thorp, J.F. and Middendorf, W. What Every Engineer Should Know About Products Liability, Marcel Dekker, Basel and NY, 1978. 53. Freeman, S.H. Injury and Litigation Prevention, Van Nostrand Reinhold, NY, 1991. 54. Huber, P.W. The Liability Maze, The Brookings Institute, Washington, DC, 1991.
8417: “8417_c008” — 2007/9/11 — 12:16 — page 232 — #36
9
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States: A Review of National Data Michael E. King and Joshua A. Mott
CONTENTS 9.1 9.2
Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.1 Public Health Surveillance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.2 Carbon Monoxide-Caused Mortality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.2.1 Recent Studies of National CO Mortality. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.3 Carbon Monoxide-Caused Morbidity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2.3.1 Recent National Studies of Nonfatal Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 Toward a National Surveillance System for Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . 9.3.1 Case Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3.2 Mortality Limitations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3.3 Morbidity Limitations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
233 234 234 236 237 241 242 243 243 244 245 246 248
9.1 OVERVIEW This chapter provides a review of epidemiologic studies describing national surveillance related to carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning in the United States. We discuss sources of surveillance data and recent studies of CO-caused mortality and morbidity. We conclude with a summary of national estimates and provide recommendations for improving public health surveillance efforts and establishing a national system specifically designed to track CO poisoning. 233
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 233 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
234
9.2 INTRODUCTION CO poisoning is an important public health problem in the United States, resulting in over 400 fatal unintentional poisonings annually.1 The burden of CO poisoning has been shown to vary from state to state,2 and risk factors for poisoning may vary across regions and populations, particularly in the wake of natural disasters.3,4 Ironically, CO poisoning in indoor environments “is almost entirely preventable by the correct installation, maintenance, and operation of devices that may emit CO indoors, combined with the appropriate use of CO detectors” (i.e., alarms).5 Surveillance activities are a critical component of any prevention effort and public health professionals rely on timely accurate surveillance to describe the magnitude and etiology of poisonings to better target interventions. Yet, despite increasing awareness of the dangers of CO poisoning, a timely national surveillance system is not in place to monitor CO poisonings or deaths in the USA. The purpose of this chapter is twofold: (1) to provide a review of epidemiologic studies describing national surveillance for CO poisoning in the United States, and (2) to discuss issues relevant to the development of an ongoing, national surveillance system for CO.
9.2.1 PUBLIC HEALTH SURVEILLANCE Environmental public health surveillance is broadly defined as: “the ongoing systematic collection, analysis, and interpretation of data, closely integrated with the timely dissemination of these data to those responsible for preventing and controlling disease and injury.”6 This definition emphasizes the importance of surveillance for CO poisoning, since information about the epidemiological aspects of CO poisoning is essential for targeting, monitoring, and evaluating risk factors and public health interventions. Surveillance activities are conducted routinely for diseases or conditions that are highly prevalent, result in excess emergency department (ED) or hospital use, and for which primary or secondary prevention is possible. However, with the exception of isolated reports from states responding to public health emergencies7,8 surveillance has not neen conducted for CO poisoning in the United States. The absence of a national system has resulted in “basic gaps in our knowledge of the epidemiology and outcomes of CO poisoning, including the long -erm sequelae, prevention, and risk behaviors.”5 The primary challenge for environmental surveillance is relating health outcomes, such as CO intoxication, to specific environmental exposures, and hazards.9 To facilitate this linkage, surveillance systems must collect, characterize, and disseminate data on health hazards, exposures, and interventions, in addition to health outcomes.9 Environmental health hazards are defined as chemical, physical, and biologic agents or biomechanical stressors in the air, food, and water.6 Exposure surveillance involves monitoring individuals for “the presence of an environmental agent, its metabolites, or its clinically inapparent (e.g., subclinical or preclinical) effects”.6 Tracking interventions includes monitoring programs and policies intended to prevent agents from becoming hazards or minimize exposures and health outcomes. Given the variety of data necessary to achieve these diverse surveillance objectives, no single dataset currently available is sufficient to serve as the sole source of surveillance data. Currently,
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 234 — #2
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
235
TABLE 9.1 Components of an Environmental Public Health Surveillance System and Potential CO Poisoning Data Sources, United States Surveillance Components Hazard surveillance Examples: • CO emissions data • Gas leak public call-data Exposure surveillance Example: • Carboxyhemoglobin level data Health outcomes Examples: • Nonfatal poisoning occurrences • Occupational poisoning data • Outpatient visits • Emergency department visits • Hospitalization data • Mortality data Interventions Examples: • Data on the presence of working catalytic converters in automobiles • CO-detector ownership data • Gasoline-powered generator safety knowledge/attitude data • Emission and CO-detector legislation data
Data Sources • US Environmental Protection Agency National Emission Inventory database • Utility companies/fire departments • Electronic lab reporting databases (e.g., the National Electronic Disease Surveillance System) • American Association of Poison Control Centers Toxic Exposure Surveillance System (TESS) • Consumer Product Safety Commission CO Poisonings database • National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS) • National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey • National Hospital Discharge Survey • National Vital Statistics System • Environmental Protection Agency • Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System • Private national surveys (e.g., Porter-Novelli annual Healthstyles survey) • National Conference of State Legislatures electronic legislation databases
Source: Adapted from Thacker et al. Am. J. Publ. Health, 86, 633–638, 1996. The National Workgroup on Carbon Monoxide Surveillance Carbon monoxide: A model environmental public health indicator. ONLINE. 2006. Available: http://www.maine.gov/dhhs/eohp/epht/documents/CO_White.pdf. (Oct. 1, 2006).
“there are 31 federally funded national data systems that collect data on injury mortality, morbidity, and risk factors.”10 However, a limited number of them are potentially useful for tracking CO poisoning. Table 9.1 provides examples of different types of data and data sources for surveillance of environmental hazards, exposures, health outcomes, and interventions related to CO in the United States. To date, the majority of national surveillance studies for CO have focused on health outcomes, and, in particular, estimates of mortality. This focus is perhaps due to the absence of a single system that captures national CO-related morbidity reliably. Likewise, CO is often only recognized as the cause-of-death upon postmortem examination, because the symptoms of CO poisoning are nonspecific and are frequently attributed to other causes or overlooked altogether by clinicians and the public.11
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 235 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
236
Most of the studies reviewed in this chapter concern poisonings resulting from unintentional and nonfire-related (NFR) events because both intentional and fire-related CO poisonings have distinctly different public health prevention strategies and are outside of the scope of this discussion.
9.2.2 CARBON MONOXIDE-CAUSED MORTALITY All US death certificates are compiled by the National Center for Health Statistics into the Multiple Cause-of-Death Mortality Database as part of the National Vital Statistics System (NVSS).12 To date, this system has served as the primary source of data for estimating national rates of poisoning death related to CO in the United States. This database provides mortality data by multiple-cause of death for all fatalities occurring in the United States. Each record is on the basis of information abstracted from death certificates filed in vital statistics offices of each state and the district of Columbia. Death certificates contain demographic and geographic information of the decedent, as well as up to 20 conditions that contributed to the death, coded according to the World Health Organization format International Classification of Diseases (ICD).13,14 The causes of death codes are compiled in two forms: the entity axis, which contains conditions as stated on the death certificate, and the record axis, which is edited by a computer algorithm to remove duplicate records and revise ICD codes to best describe the overall medical certification portion of the death certificate.15 It is important for researchers using Multiple-Cause data to be aware of the format and structure of the data file prior to use; documentation accompanying public use mortality data files specifies that the “record axis is designed for the generation of person-based multiple-cause statistics” and “by definition, the entity data cannot meet this requirement.”16 In other words, codes on the record axis may be used for CO surveillance to count people with conditions, whereas the entity axis data may only be useful for counting the number of times a particular condition was coded. The 8th Revision of ICD coding (ICD-8) was used for 11 years, from 1968 to 1978, the 9th Revision (ICD-9) from 1979 to 1998, and the 10th Revision (ICD-10) from 1999 to the present year. At the time of this writing, the most recent year of mortality data available was 2003 as there is a delay of 2–3 years before national mortality data are released to the public. As a reference, the ICD codes that have been used for the national surveillance of CO are provided in Table 9.2. One alternative source of national mortality data for the surveillance of CO is the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Wide-ranging Online Data for Epidemiologic Research (WONDER) data system. This system provides access to an array of health-related datasets, including the NVSS underlying cause-ofdeath files from National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) and injury mortality reports generated by the Web-based Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System (WISQARS) maintained by the National Center for Injury Prevention and Control (NCIPC). Although WONDER may be used to estimate national CO mortality, it is important to note that the system can only identify cases of CO poisoning using a single cause-of-death. Hence these data are likely to underestimate the burden of unintentional poisoning because of the inability to select cases using codes in multiple-cause-of-death codes fields.
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 236 — #4
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
237
TABLE 9.2 International Classification of Diseases Codes Specific to Carbon Monoxide Poisoning and Additional Codes Useful for Case Identification Underlying or contributing cause of death Toxic effect of carbon monoxide ICD-10: T58 ICD-8 and ICD-9: N986 Intent of death Unintentional injury ICD-10: X47 ICD-8 and ICD-9: E800-E949 Intent undetermined ICD-10: Y17 ICD-8 and ICD-9: E980-E989 Mechanism of death Fire-related (exclude from analyses) ICD-10: X00-X09 ICD-8 and ICD-9: E837, E890-E899, E923, or N940-N949 Motor vehicle-related ICD-10: No X-code specific to CO ICD-9: E800-E807, E810-E825, E830-E836, E838, E840, E841, E843-E847, E868.2, E929.0, E929.1, E952.0, E958.5, E958.6, E982.0, E988.5, and E988.6 ICD-8: E800-E807, E810-E825, E830-E836, E838, E840, E841, E843-E845, E873, E927, E940-E941, and E952.0 Nonmotor vehicle-related ICD-10: No X-code specific to CO ICD-9: E867, E868.0, E868.1, E868.3, E919, E920, E951, E981 ICD-8: E870-E872, E874, E920, E927, E928, E951, E981 Source: Adapted from Mott et al., JAMA, 288, 988–995, 2006.
9.2.2.1 Recent Studies of National CO Mortality The most recent analysis of unintentional, nonfire-related (UNFR), CO-related mortality data in the United States was produced by the National Center for Environmental Health’s Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch at the CDC.17 This study estimated national and state-specific CO mortality rates and described the demographic, seasonal, and geographic patterns in CO-related deaths for 1999–2002.17 Death certificate data were obtained from the NVSS using the underlying cause-of-death field and record axis fields from the multiple-cause-of-death files. A case of unintentional CO-related death was defined as a US resident death coded using the ICD-10 code T58 (toxic effect of CO) as the underlying cause-of-death and for which poisoning by accidental exposure (code X47) or exposure of undetermined intent (code Y17) to gases or vapors was listed as a contributing cause in one of the 20 record axis fields. All records of deaths caused by intentional or fire-related exposure to CO, coded as X00–X09, were excluded from the analysis. This study found that during
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 237 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
238
1999–2002, there were 11,132 CO-related deaths among U.S. residents, of which 1982 (18%) were classified as both unintentional and NFR. From 1999 to 2002, the total average age-adjusted annual death rate for UNFR CO was 1.8 deaths per million persons in the United States. Death rates were highest for adults (2.2 per million for adults aged >18 years, versus 0.4 per million for children aged 17 years or younger) and men (2.8 per million men versus 0.9 per million women). The average daily number of CO-related deaths was greatest during the months of January and December (277 per month) and lowest during the months of July and August (91 per month). For the period from 1999 to 2002, only 32 states had a sufficiently large number of UNFR CO-related deaths to calculate stable mortality rates (Figure 9.1). Although numerous states had rates above the national four-year average annual rate, the state with the highest statistically reliable UNFR CO mortality rate was Nebraska (5.6 deaths per million person-years) and the state with the lowest reliable rate was California (0.6 average deaths per million) (Figure 9.1). Reporting of acute CO poisoning by healthcare providers was mandated for 13 states, although there was no clear pattern of differences in CO-related mortality between states with mandated reporting and those without.17 In 2005, the National Center for Injury Prevention, in conjunction with the National Center for Environmental Health, used multiple-cause-of-death mortality data to estimate the annual incidence of fatal and nonfatal unintentional, NFR CO poisoning.18 This study provided national crude annual UNFR CO death rates by demographic characteristics and season for 2 years: 2001 and 2002. In addition, case-fatality rates were estimated by dividing the number of deaths by the sum
UR
UR (NH) UR (VT)
UR
UR
UR UR
MR MR
UR MR
UR
UR (ME) UR/MR (MA)
MR
MR
UR (RI) UR (CT) MR (NJ) UR/MR (DE) UR (DC)
MR UR MR
UR UR(HI)
CO Death Rate* > U.S. Average = U.S. Average
*Rate per 1,000,000 population per year, age-adjusted to 2000 US Census population . UR = Rate unreliable MR = CO death is a mandated reportable condition
< U.S. Average
FIGURE 9.1 Average rates of unintentional, nonfire, carbon monoxide-related death, by state, United States, 1999–2002.
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 238 — #6
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
239
of UNFR CO deaths and nonfatal exposures multiplied by 100. Fatal UNFR CO poisoning deaths were identified as those with ICD-10 code T58 as a leading or contributing cause of death and an underlying cause of death code indicating either accidental poisoning (X47) or poisoning of undetermined intent (Y17). This study found that the crude annual UNFR CO death rate for the United States was 0.17 per 100,000 with an average of 480 deaths per year. The annualized incidence of fatal UNFR CO exposures was greatest during the fall and winter months, with more cases occurring during December (56 deaths) and January (69 deaths). The crude death rate from CO was highest for adults over 65 years (0.32 per 100,000), males (0.24 per 100,000), and nonHispanic whites and blacks (0.17 per 100,000). The case-fatality rate increased with age, ranging from 0.6% for children under 4 years to 5.5% for adults aged 55–64 years. Overall, males had a 2.3 times higher casefatality rate than women and 23.5% of deaths occurred among adults aged 65 years or more.18 In 2002, Mott et al.19 conducted an ecological analysis of national CO death data from the NVSS and annual CO emissions estimates for light-duty vehicles obtained from the US Environmental Protection Agency. This study estimated the percent change in CO emissions and CO mortality rates by intent and mechanism for the years 1968–1998. The main outcome from this study was US resident deaths from 1968 to 1998 coded with ICD-8 or ICD-9 code N986 (toxic effect of CO) as a contributing cause -of -death or those records with an ICD external cause of injury code exclusive to CO poisoning (Table 9.2). From 1968 through 1998, this study identified 116,703 NFR deaths due to CO in the United States. During this same time period, crude mortality rates associated with NFR CO declined from 20.2 deaths to 8.8 deaths per million person-years in the United States. There were 2.2 intentional deaths for every one unintentional NFR CO-related death. Between 1968–1998, motor vehicles were identified as the mechanism for 70.6% of deaths and, following the introduction of the catalytic converter in 1975, annual estimates of NFR CO emissions decreased by 76.3%. In addition, unintentional motor vehicle-related NFR CO death rates declined by 81.3% and rates of motor vehicle-related NFR CO suicides declined by 43.3%.19 In 1996, the CDC published a summary of findings from an investigation of deaths associated with multiple motor-vehicle related CO poisonings in Colorado and New Mexico, together with national estimates of CO deaths from 1979–1992.20 This report presented the geographic pattern of national unintentional CO mortality associated specifically with stationary motor vehicles (UMVR). Deaths were identified using ICD-9 code E868.2, a code specific to deaths due to accidental poisoning by CO or another utility gas from the following sources: farm tractor not in transit, gas engine, motor vehicle not in transit, or any type of combustion engine not in a watercraft. This analysis found that crude death rates for UMVR CO were highest in states in the northern regions of the United States from 1979 to 1992, although no specific national or state rates were provided.20 In the early 1990s, Cobb and Etzel2 published a descriptive analysis of unintentional NFR CO-related deaths (UNFR) in the United States. This study calculated crude and age-adjusted death rates by demographic characteristic, season, and state for the years 1979–1988. All US resident deaths coded using ICD-9 code N986 were
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 239 — #7
240
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
identified between 1979–1988, excluding those coded as intentional (codes E950– E959 and E960–E969), intent undetermined (E980–E989), and those owing to fire (E837, N940–N949, E923). The 10-year average crude UNFR CO death rate for males (0.78 per 100,000 persons) was found to be 3 times higher than that for females (0.26 per 100,000 persons). Overall, 83% of UNFR CO-related deaths occurred among whites, yet “race-specific death rates were more than 20% higher for blacks (0.63 per 100,000) than for whites (0.51 per 100,000).”2 Annual incidence of unintentional CO-related death was found to be highest in the month of January, with an average of 181 deaths, and lowest in the month of July, with an average of 44 deaths. The state with the highest age-adjusted UNFR CO death rate for the 10-year period was Alaska (2.72 per 100,000) and the lowest rate was found in Hawaii (0.05 per 100,000).2 In addition to the above-mentioned surveillance reports produced by the CDC, national estimates of CO-related mortality produced by the Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) may provide useful national surveillance for CO-related mortality. These reports combine data from multiple sources, such as the NVSS and National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS), with proprietary CPSC datasets21 on the basis of death certificate data purchased directly from states and in-depth follow-up investigations of select deaths. These data are used to produce annual national estimates of unintentional NFR CO exposures and fatalities by product, victim age, and incident location. However, the reports currently available are limited to estimates associated specifically with the use of consumer products under the jurisdiction of the CPSC (e.g., engine-powered tools, charcoal grills, gas ovens, and other appliances). CPSC reports do not capture fatalities associated with motor vehicles, despite the fact that CO in motor-vehicle exhaust has been found to account for the majority of poisoning deaths in the United States.22 The most recent year for which a complete CPSC report of CO-related mortality is available is 2002.23 In 2002, CPSC identified 188 unintentional, nonfire CO-related deaths and the average annual estimate from 1999 to 2002 was 141 deaths. Heating systems were associated with 55% of deaths and engine-powered tools were associated with 28% of deaths in 2002. An estimated 71% of CO deaths occurred in the home. Overall, 81% of fatal CO incidents involved a single death, with adults over 45 years of age accounting for 55% of all unintentional, nonfire CO deaths in 2002.23 Although CPSC memoranda have been published covering both non-fatal CO exposure incidents and fatalities for the periods 1990–2004 and 2002–2005, respectively, CPSC notes that the counts for recent years contained in these reports may not be complete.24 Briefly, from 1990 to 2004, there were 318 nonfire CO-related deaths identified by CPSC, 274 of which were associated with the use of generators. Most of these deaths (39%) occurred during winter and 77% took place in the home. From 1990 to 2004, an estimated 33% of deaths occurred among adults aged 45–64 years and 75% of all “engine-driven tool” CO-related deaths were males.24 From 2002 to 2005, preliminary counts from CPSC indicate that 253 nonfire CO-related deaths were associated with engine-driven tools in the United States. An estimated 218 (86%) of CO deaths were associated with gasoline-powered generators.20
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 240 — #8
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
241
9.2.3 CARBON MONOXIDE-CAUSED MORBIDITY National surveillance for nonfatal CO exposures is challenging, given the limited number of data sources currently available (Table 9.1). One potential source for national nonfatal CO poisoning data is the NEISS, operated by the CPSC since 1971.25 The NEISS has been used to monitor consumer product-related injuries resulting from consumer products under the regulatory jurisdiction of the CPSC. In 2000, the surveillance system was expanded to collect data about all types and causes of injuries and poisonings treated in hospital EDs, whether or not they were associated with consumer products. This expanded system is called the NEISS All Injury Program (NEISS-AIP). NEISS data are currently collected from a nationally representative sample of 100 EDs, selected from a stratified probability sample of all US hospitals that have at least 6 beds and provide 24-h emergency services, while NEISS-AIP data are collected from a 66 hospital subsample. Data from approximately 500,000 injuryrelated ED cases are collected annually by NEISS and coded for cause and intent of injury using guidelines consistent with coding guidelines in the ICD-9-CM.25 Use of these data for CO surveillance is limited, however, they exclude incidents owing to occupational exposure, those associated with motor vehicles, and cannot provide state or local estimates.25 Another source of national nonfatal CO poisoning surveillance data is the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS) conducted by the National Center for Health Statistics of the CDC. The NHAMCS collects data on the utilization and provision of ambulatory care services in hospital emergency and outpatient departments. Findings are on the basis of a national sample of visits to the emergency and outpatient departments of noninstitutional general and short-stay hospitals, exclusive of federal, military, and veterans administration hospitals, located in the 50 States and the District of Columbia. Annual data collection began in 1992. Similarly, the national Toxic Exposure Surveillance System (TESS) operated by the American Association of Poison Control Centers has demonstrated capability to serve as a source of CO data for both state-based26 and national studies.27 Implemented in 1983, TESS is a comprehensive database that contains detailed toxicological information about over 24 million poisoning incidents reported to 61 poison control centers in the United States.28 The calculation of rates of calls to TESS for a given exposure is facilitated because participating poison control centers also report the size of the population they serve. However, the use of TESS data for CO surveillance may be limited by the fact that most reports pertain to the treatment of nonfatal poisonings. Therefore, TESS data may underestimate the incidence of fatal CO exposures. As of October, 2006, annual reports summarizing TESS data are available online for the years 1983–2004 (http://www.aapcc.org/annual.htm). Finally, recent studies have suggested that data obtained from hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) therapy centers may serve as an indicator of CO burden.27,30 HBO is typically used to treat those patients with the most severe CO poisoning,27 comprising approximately 6% of all patients seen for CO in EDs.30 According to Hampson, “as long as the spectrum of severity of the condition and treatment practices has not been recognized to have changed significantly during the period surveyed, the national rate of HBO therapy should serve as a qualitative marker of total disease incidence”.27
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 241 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
242
Using data from HBO therapy facilities for national CO surveillance is limited by the lack of general availability and the fact that these data do not include less severe cases, those not referred for HBO, or those treated at EDs using HBO. Likewise, a patient’s state of residence may differ from that in which they received the HBO therapy, complicating the calculation of valid state rates. 9.2.3.1 Recent National Studies of Nonfatal Carbon Monoxide Poisoning A 2005 study by Hampson27 used TESS data and information from a recent survey of HBOT facilities29 to compare trends in the annual incidence of nonfatal CO poisoning in the United States. Hampson27 searched TESS records from 1985 to 2002 for all calls received by poison control centers regarding cases of CO exposure, and calculated annual call rates per million person-years. This study found that annual call rates for CO poisoning increased from 31.1 per million in 1985 to 95.4 per million in 1996. Although the rate decreased to 54.5 per million persons from 1996 to 2002, there was a significant increase in calls for the entire 18 year period (p = .0022).27 Rates of HBOT for CO poisoning and rates of calls to poison control centers were also found to correlate strongly (r = 0.82, p = .0002).27 Also in 2005, the CDC published national estimates of unintentional, NFR CO exposures for 2001–2003 using NEISS-AIP data.18 Nonfatal cases of CO poisoning were considered to be those coded as “CO exposure” or “CO poisoning” in NEISS-AIP hospital data. Additional criteria used to identify nonfatal CO poisonings included: (1) intent of injury unintentional or undetermined, (2) principle diagnosis of “poisoning” or “anoxia”, and (3) additional narrative information indicative of CO. This study estimated that 15,200 patients were treated in EDs annually for nonfatal, unintentional, NFR CO poisoning during 2001–2003. Overall, the rate of nonfatal exposure was similar for males and females, although the rate was highest for children under 4 years of age (8.2 per 100,000 person). While most nonfatal CO exposures (64.3%) occurred in the home, only 9.3% of patients reported owning a CO detector.18 This study also provided national estimates of CO-related mortality discussed earlier in this chapter. Although not pertaining to CO specifically, a CDC report published in 1999 used data from the NHAMCS to describe poisoning-related ED visits from 1993 to 1996 in the United States.31 This study used a variety of ICD-9-CM codes to identify all injury-related ED visits, but did not provide sufficient detail to describe the etiology, intent, or mechanism of CO exposures. From 1993 to 1996, toxic effect of CO (ICD-9-CM code N986) was the sixth leading principle diagnosis identified among poisoning-related ED visits in the United States An annual average of 34,000 ED visits were attributed to CO during the 4 year study period.31 In an earlier study, Hampson30 reported a synthetic national estimate of nonfatal CO poisoning on the basis of a survey of EDs located in Washington, Idaho, and Montana. This survey collected data about the total number of patients seen for acute CO poisoning in 1994, although details regarding the etiology, source, or intent of the poisoning were not collected. This analysis extrapolated data from the three states to the United States as a whole and used state-specific age-adjusted CO death rates
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 242 — #10
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
243
to adjust for the fact that CO poisoning is more common in the Pacific Northwest region. The study estimated 42,890 ED visits for CO poisoning occurred in 1994 in the United States, resulting in a national ED visit rate of 16.5 per 100,000 persons for CO poisoning.30 The public health literature describing surveillance of CO poisoning included in this chapter is characterized by its variability. Although most studies focus on fire-related CO poisoning, different data sources and definitions of poisoning are used for case ascertainment, thus limiting the comparability of national estimates. In addition, other national estimates of nonfatal CO poisoning are available in the literature, although many of these focus only on poisonings resulting from a specific mechanism (i.e., consumer products) or are very old. For example, recent reports from the CPSC have used data from the NEISS to estimate that approximately 5000 nonfatal CO poisonings associated with motor-driven appliances occur annually in the United States.32 Likewise, a 1974 study estimated that 10,000 nonfatal CO poisonings occurred annually in the United States.33 The variability among national studies and estimates of CO poisoning underscores the need for a national surveillance system for CO.
9.3 TOWARD A NATIONAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM FOR CARBON MONOXIDE The lack of information linking environmental hazards to health outcomes has contributed to what has been labeled the “environmental health gap” by The Pew Environmental Health Commission.34 To address this gap and coordinate the development of CO surveillance in the United States., the CDC established The National Workgroup on Carbon Monoxide Surveillance, a partnership of public health professionals and agencies spanning private and federal jurisdictions from environmental health and injury prevention to emergency response.5 This workgroup has noted that the need for nationwide CO surveillance “is recognized in the Healthy People 2010 goal for the United States of ‘increasing the number of Territories, Tribes, and States, and the District of Columbia that monitor carbon monoxide poisoning from 7 to 51.’”5 One indicator of progress toward the Healthy People 2010 goal for CO is the number of states that mandate reporting of CO poisoning as part of the National Notifiable Disease Surveillance System. The National Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologist (CSTE) serves as a partner in the National Workgroup for CO Surveillance and monitors patterns of nonnotifiable diseases and conditions; currently, 15 states mandate reporting of CO poisoning (http://www.cste.org/NNDSSSurvey/ 2004NNDSS/NNDSSstatechrreporcondnona2005.asp). Similarly, although a number of states have mandated the installation of CO detectors, surveillance data are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of ongoing legislative interventions for CO.
9.3.1 CASE DEFINITIONS Although there is a growing recognition of the need to develop a national surveillance system for CO, methods of case identification and ascertainment remain a
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 243 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
244
serious challenge for injury and death due to CO. The ability to accurately describe CO-related morbidity and mortality depends heavily on the methods used to identify and classify cases, the rules for coding data, and the type of data available. Effective public health surveillance relies on the establishment of a widely adopted, clear, and reliable case definition that includes criteria describing person, place, and time.35 To date, no such consensus has been reached in the case of CO poisoning. According to the National Workgroup on Carbon Monoxide Surveillance, 2 national public health organizations have published their own version of a case definition for public health surveillance of CO poisoning; The CSTE and the State and Territorial Injury Prevention Directors Association (STIPDA). The STIPDA definition is more conservative than the CSTE definition, that is, if both definitions are applied to the same dataset, the STIPDA definition will identify fewer records as having CO poisoning than the CSTE definition. The CSTE definition has been modified by at least one state to make it a more conservative definition.36 The case definitions suggested by CSTE and STIPDA are listed in Table 9.3. A formal evaluation of these case definitions is the focus of a current study by the National Workgroup for CO Surveillance.36
9.3.2 MORTALITY LIMITATIONS In addition to achieving a uniform case definition for tracking CO poisoning, understanding the limitations of available data is vital to improve national CO surveillance efforts. For mortality specifically, the use of death certificate data for national CO
TABLE 9.3 Two Case Definitions for the National Surveillance of Carbon Monoxide in the United States Carbon Monoxide Case Definitions CSTE Confirmed case: ICD-9 Coded Data: (1) a record in which the Nature of Injury code N-986 “Toxic effect of CO” is listed or (2) a record in which an External Cause of Injury (E-Code) indicating exposure to carbon monoxide (exclusively) is listed such as E868.3, E868.8, E868.9, E952.1, or E982.1. Probable case: ICD-9 Coded Data: A record in which an E-code indicating acute carbon monoxide poisoning inferred from motor-vehicle exhaust gas exposure is listed, ie. E868.2, E952.0, or E982.0. STIPDA Records must have the N-code for CO poisoning (986) in the principal diagnosis field. Because this case definition relies only upon the presence or absence of the N-code, it does not define classification of cases, such as confirmed and probable. Source: National Workgroup on Carbon Monoxide Surveillance. Project to evaluate carbon monoxide surveillance CSTE and STIPDA case definitions with hospital data. 2006 Unpublished report. Obtained October, 2006 from the Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch, U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 244 — #12
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
245
surveillance is limited by recent changes in the way deaths are coded and classified. As noted earlier, the Tenth Revision of the ICD (ICD-10) was implemented in 1999 and is currently used to categorize causes of death in the NVSS. Earlier versions of ICD coding provided external cause of injury codes exclusive to CO poisoning (ICD 8 = E874, E875, and E952.1; ICD 9 = E868.3, E868.8, E868.9, E952.1, and E982.1) or poisoning from motor vehicle exhaust (ICD8 = E873 or E952.0; ICD9 = E868.2, E952.0, and E982.). Since CO is the only acutely poisonous gas in motor vehicle exhaust, in the past these latter codes could also be used to indicate CO poisoning. Although numerous ICD-10 codes mention CO, the Tenth Revision of ICD has only one code specific to CO:T58. While the latest revision contains codes that indicate the manner or intent of injury or can identify fire-related exposures, much detail has been lost in the ability to describe certain etiologic mechanisms (such as motor vehicle-related injuries) that could be described previously using E-codes related to CO. Hence, estimates of CO deaths classified using ICD-9 are not directly comparable to estimates derived from ICD-10 coded data. In addition to limitations regarding case ascertainment, data from NVSS do not become available to the public in a timely manner and lack other etiologic detail necessary for CO surveillance. For example, NVSS data do not contain sufficient detail to identify multiple victims of the same incident of CO poisoning. Estimating CO-related death from the NVSS requires a thorough understanding of the ICD coding rules and the limitations for case identification imposed by selection criteria for specific years of data. To summarize, the most important implication of the implementation of ICD-10 is that the already limited etiologic detail in the NVSS has been further reduced, thereby substantially decreasing its usefulness as national CO surveillance system. The use of the NVSS for national mortality surveillance indicates that there are roughly 500 unintentional, NFR CO deaths per year in the United States. Follow-up epidemiologic investigations of these deaths, however are needed to provide us with enough etiologic information to suggest meaningful public health interventions. Such investigations remain a high priority until alternate sources of surveillance data can be made available.
9.3.3 MORBIDITY LIMITATIONS Data currently available for the surveillance of nonfatal CO poisoning are limited by difficulties with case ascertainment. CO poisoning is characterized by nonspecific signs and symptoms that are often ignored or attributed to another condition by the public and medical professionals alike.11 In addition, those who experience nonfatal CO poisoning but do not present for medical treatment are not counted in morbidity estimates from medical records. Hence, all estimates of nonfatal poisoning are likely to underestimate the actual incidence of CO poisoning. The variation of populations and methods evident among datasets currently available suggest that no single source can serve as a comprehensive surveillance source for CO poisoning morbidity in the United States at this time. Despite these limitations, the continuing morbidity and mortality associated with acute CO poisoning in the United States necessitates the establishment of a national surveillance system. The goals of a national surveillance system
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 245 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
246
for CO range from planning for rapid public health responses following disasters and tracking the burden of CO poisoning over time, to improving our understanding of exposure sources, related hazards, and facilitating research.5,36 To promote and facilitate surveillance at the local, state, and federal levels, the National Workgroup for CO Surveillance has produced a summary report describing the attributes of CO as a model environmental public health indicator (http://www.maine.gov/dhhs/eohp/epht/documents/CO_White.pdf).5
9.4 CONCLUSIONS Although the overall national rate of death from NFR CO declined steadily from 1968 to 1998 in the United States,19 the average annual rate of unintentional nonfire-related (UNFR) CO-related death has remained relatively stable over the past 4 decades.17–19 From 1968 to 1998, the crude death rate for UNFR CO was 7.06 deaths per 1 million person-years.19 The most recent analysis of mortality data from 2002 reported a crude UNFR CO death rate of 1.8 deaths per 1 million person in the U.S.17 There are an average of 494 accidental, NFR deaths and approximately 1,747 intentional deaths due to CO-poisoning each year in the United States.19 Evidence from a recent ecological study suggests the decrease in all CO-related deaths in the United States was driven primarily by a reduction in deaths from exposure to motor-vehicle exhaust.9 This reduction has been attributed to the national implementation of the 1970 Clean Air Act. In contrast to trends in national CO mortality, the incidence of nonfatal CO poisonings rose, while rates of death fell from 1985 to 1996 in the United States27 The annual number of nonfatal poisonings then decreased from 1996 to 2002.27 Published estimates of ED visits due to UNFR CO poisoning suggest there are approximately 15,200 ED visits per year, with 1,676 resulting in subsequent hospitalization.18 Similarly, unpublished estimates from the 2002 National Hospital Discharge Survey using the CSTE-proposed case definition identified 1496 hospitalizations due to UNFR CO poisoning in the U.S.37 Across studies, men and older adults (ranging from over 45 to over 65 years) are most at risk for unintentional death or injury from CO.17–19 Despite the lack of uniform national surveillance data, the burden of CO poisoning in the United States may be summarized using estimates from a variety of related data sources (Figure 9.2). The substantial health burden of unintentional CO poisoning illustrated in Figure 9.3 suggests the need to put CO morbidity and mortality under ongoing public health surveillance. The de facto national surveillance system for CO poisoning in the United States has been the NVSS. However, this system has several limitations for the surveillance of CO poisoning. Although the data have taken two years to process following collection, the recent implimentation of ICD-10 codes has further limited the utility of the NVSS for CO surveillance due to the removal of several important ICD codes that denote etiologic mechanism of poisoning. Public health professionals must consider these recent changes in the ICD coding system when assessing CO-related mortality derived from the NVSS. When estimating nonfatal CO poisoning, data from multiple sources should be used to cross-validate estimates of morbidity, to reduce the likelihood of under-estimation from any single source of data. To obtain a complete picture of
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 246 — #14
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
247
120
10
100
8
80
6
60
4
40
1975– catalytic converters required on all new passenger cars
2
20
0
CO Emissions control timeline Grams of CO emited per VMT
CDR per1,000,000 personyears
Suicides 12
1975: Catalytic converter introduced on new passenger cars to meet new CO emissions standard of 15 g/mile. 1978:1975 and newer model year cars make up 34% of the U.S.passenger vehicle fleet.
0
5
120
4
100 80
3 60 2 40
98 19
94
96 19
92
19
90
19
88
CDR: Nonmotor vehicle
19
86
19
84
19
82
19
80
19
78
CDR: Motor vehicle
19
76
19
74
19
19
19
19
19
72
0 70
20
0 68
1
COEmissions (g/mile)
Gramsof CO emited per VMT
Unintentional deaths CDR per1,000,000 personyears
1970:Congress enacts Clean Air Act. CO emissions standard at 34.0 g/mile.
1980: All new passenger cars required to meet new CO emissions standard of 7.0 g/mile. 1975 and newer model year cars make up 50% of US.passenger vehicle fleet. 1981:All newcars required to meet new CO emissions standard of 3.4 g/mile. 1990:1975 and newer model year cars make up 91% of the U.S.passenger vehicle fleet. 1992: Standards setting emission limits for carbon monoxide at temperatures <20°F are established. Oxygenated gasoline is introducedin cities with high CO levels. Source: EPA CO emissions inventory data,and Fact Sheet OMS-12.
FIGURE 9.2 Annual crude death rates (CDR) from carbon monoxide poisoning, and annual estimated grams of CO emitted per vehicle mile traveled (VMT), United States, 1968–1998 (From Mott et al., JAMA, 288, 988–995, 2006.)
494 deaths17
1,496 hospitalizations37
13,201 emergency department visits18
15,633 calls to poison control centers27
FIGURE 9.3 The nonfire-related, carbon monoxide poisoning pyramid, 2002, U.S.
CO poisoning, surveillance systems must be established in a variety of settings and must be comprehensive, capturing the incidence, causes, and circumstances of both nonfatal and fatal poisonings in a timely manner. Likewise, innovative approaches may be necessary to gather surveillance data on nonresident populations, such as
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 247 — #15
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
248
undocumented immigrants who may be at increased risk for CO poisoning, but for whom the calculation of valid rates is challenging. Ultimately, the standardization of an ICD-coded case definition for CO-related morbidity and mortality is a necessary 1st step to describe the national burden of CO poisoning, to better target interventions, and to evaluate the impact of public health prevention efforts.5 Until additional resources can be identified and allocated to surveillance at the federal, state, and local levels, epidemiologic investigations of recent CO-related deaths will need to remain the foundation for obtaining the etiologic information necessary to mount effective public health campaigns.
References 1. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Poisonings fact sheet. ONLINE. 2006. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control. Available: http://www.cdc.gov/ncipc/factsheets/poisoning.htm. (Oct. 1, 2006). 2. Cobb, N. and R. A. Etzel. Unintentional carbon monoxide-related deaths in the United States, 1979–1988. JAMA 266: 659–663, 1991. 3. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Carbon monoxide poisoning after Hurricane Katrina—Alabama, Louisiana, and Mississippi, August–September, 2005. MMWR, 54: 996–998, 2005. 4. Daley, W. R., A. Smith, E. Paz-Argandona, J. Malilay, and M. McGeehin. An outbreak of carbon monoxide poisoning after a major ice storm in Maine. J. Emerg. Med. 18: 87–93, 2000. 5. National Workgroup on Carbon Monoxide Surveillance. Carbon monoxide: A model environmental public health indicator. ONLINE. 2006. Available: http:// mainegov-images.informe.org/dhhs/eohp/epht/CO_WHITE.pdf. (Oct. 1, 2006). 6. Nsubuga, P., M. White, and S. Thacker et al. Public health surveillance: A tool for targeting and monitoring interventions. In Disease Control Priorities in Developing Countries, 2006, D. Jamison, J. Breman, A. Measham, G. Alleyne, M. Claeson, D. Evans, P. Jha, A. Mils, and P. Musgrove, eds., pp. 997–1015, New York, NY: Oxford University Press. 7. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Unintentional carbon monoxide poisonings in residential settings—Connecticut, November 1993–March 1994. MMWR 44: 765–767, 1995. 8. Girman, J., Y. Chang, S. Hayward, and K. Liu. Causes of unintentional deaths from carbon monoxide poisonings in California. W. J. Med. 168: 158–165, 1998. 9. Thacker, S. B., D. Stroup, R. Parrish, and H. Anderson. Surveillance in environmental public health: Issues, systems, and sources. Am. J. Publ. Health 86: 633–638, 1996. 10. Institute of Medicine, Surveillance and data. In: Reducing the Burden of Injury: Advancing Prevention and Treatment, Bonnie, R., C. Fulco, and C. Liverman, eds., 1999, 60–81. National Academy Press, Washington, DC. 11. Raub, J., M. Mathieu, N. Hampson, and S. Thom. Carbon monoxide poisoning—A public health perspective. Toxicology 145: 1–14, 2000. 12. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. U.S. census populations with bridged-race categories. ONLINE. 2004. National Center for Health Statistics. Available: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/about/major/dvs/popbridge/popbridge.htm. (Oct. 1, 2006).
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 248 — #16
Public Health Surveillance for Carbon Monoxide in the United States
249
13. World Health Organization. Manual of the International Statistical Classification of Diseases, Injuries, and Causes of Death, 1967: 8th revision. Geneva. 14. World Health Organization. Manual of the International Statistical Classification of Diseases, Injuries, and Causes of Death, 1977: 9th revision. Geneva. 15. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Public use data file documentation: multiple cause of death for ICD-9, 1994. 1996, Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics. 16. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Public use data file documentation: mortality for ICD-10, 1999. 2002, Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics. Available: http://0-www.cdc.gov.mill1.sjlibrary.org/nchs/data/dvs/ Mort99doc.pdf. (Oct. 1, 2006). 17. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Update of unintentional, non-fire, carbon monoxide-related death rates, United States, 1999–2002. 2006, Unpublished data, Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch. 18. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Unintentional non-fire-related carbon monoxide exposures in the United States, 2001–2003. MMWR 54: 36-39, 2005. 19. Mott, J., M. Wolfe, C. Alverson et al. 2002. National vehicle emissions policies and practices and declining U.S. carbon monoxide-related mortality. JAMA 288: 988–995, 2006. 20. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Deaths from motor-vehicle related unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning, Colorado, 1996, New Mexico, 1980, 1995, and United States, 1979–1992. MMWR 45: 1029–1032, 2006. 21. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Non-fire carbon monoxide fatalities associated with engine driven generators and other engine driven tools in 2002 through 2005. ONLINE. 2006, August. Available: http://www.cpsc.gov/library. (Oct. 1, 2006). 22. Baker S., B. O’Neill, M. Ginsburg, and G. Li. The Injury Fact Book, 1992, 2nd ed., New York: Oxford University Press. 23. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Non-fire carbon monoxide deaths associated with the use of consumer products: 2002 annual estimates. ONLINE. 2006, Available: http://www.cpsc.gov/library. 24. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Incidents, deaths, and in-depth investigations associated with carbon monoxide from engine-driven generators and other engine-driven tools, 1990–2004. ONLINE. 2005, December. Available: http://www.cpsc.gov/library. 25. Kessler, E. and T. Schroeder. The NEISS sample: Design and implementation. 2000. Washington, DC: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 26. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Monitoring poison control center data to detect health hazards during hurricane season—Florida, 2003–2005. MMWR 55: 426–428, 2006. 27. Hampson, N. Trends in the incidence of carbon monoxide poisoning in the United States. Am. J. Emerg. Med. 23: 838–841, 2005. 28. Watson, W., T. Litovitz, C. Rubin et al. Toxic Exposure Surveillance System [abstract]. In: Syndromic Surveillance: Reports from a National Conference, 2003. MMWR 53: 262, 2004. 29. Hampson, N. and C. Little. Hyperbaric treatment of patients with carbon monoxide poisoning in the United States. Undersea Hyperb. Med. 32: 21–26, 2005. 30. Hampson, N. Emergency department visits for carbon monoxide poisoning in the pacific northwest. The J. Emerg. Med. 16: 695–698, 1998.
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 249 — #17
250
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 31. McCaig, L. and C. Burt. Poisoning-related visits to emergency departments in the United States, 1993–1996. J. Toxicol. 37: 817–826, 1999. 32. Mah, J. C. Non-fire carbon-monoxide deaths and injuries associated with the use of consumer products: annual estimates - October 2000. ONLINE. 2001, August. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Available: http://www.cpsc.gov/ library/co00.pdf. 33. Schaplowsky, A., F. Oglesbay, and J. Morrison et al. Carbon monoxide contamination of the living environment: A national survey of home air and children’s blood. J. Environ. Health 36: 569–573, 1974. 34. Pew Environmental Health Commission. America’s Environmental Health Gap: Why the Country Needs a Nationwide Health Tracking Network, 2000. Technical Report. Baltimore, MD: Pew Environmental Health Commission. 35. Teutsch, S. Considerations in planning a surveillance system. In Principles and Practice of Public Health Surveillance, 2000, S. Teutsch and R. Churchill, eds., pp. 17–29. New York: Oxford University Press. 36. National Workgroup on Carbon Monoxide Surveillance. Project to evaluate carbon monoxide surveillance CSTE and STIPDA case definitions with hospital data. 2006 Unpublished report. Obtained October, 2006 from the Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch, U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 37. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Estimates of unintentional, non-fire, carbon monoxide-related hospital discharges, National Hospital Discharge Survey, United States, 2002. 2006 Unpublished data, Air Pollution and Respiratory Health Branch.
8417: “8417_c009” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 250 — #18
10
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems Kosmas Galatsis and Wojtek Wlodarski
CONTENTS 10.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Sensor Technologies for Carbon Monoxide Gas Detection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Semiconducting Metal Oxide (SMO) Gas Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Optical Gas Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.3 Electrochemical Gas Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Sensor Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6 Appendix 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
251 253 254 256 261 263 265 265 265 267
10.1 INTRODUCTION Carbon Monoxide (CO) is one of the most important gases in the field of sensor technology. This is because its toxicity combined with its properties of being odorless, colorless, tasteless, and nonirritating to the respiratory tract. Attempts at detection of CO date back to the famous French physiologist, Claude Bernard, circa 1846,1 who performed experiments with CO poisoning dogs. Small birds and mammals were used for decades in mines as living CO detectors. CO has been called the “silent killer,” the “stealthy-poison,” and even the “smart poison” because it enters the body without notice and leaves so quickly with little trace. See an earlier discussion of CO detectors by Kwor in Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, 2000. Today’s CO detectors/alarms are small electronic devices. Such devices are installed in homes near heating devices or in garages where sources of CO such as combustion burners and/or motor vehicles may potentially pollute the breathing space. If a sufficient level of CO is detected, the device audibly alarms, giving occupants a chance to ventilate the area or safely vacate. Unlike smoke, CO is undetectable by the unaided human senses, and hence, people often find themselves in environments polluted with CO without knowing it.
251
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 251 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
252
During the mid 1990s, the installation of residential, wall-mounted CO alarms grew rapidly in the United States. This was a result of the availability of low cost CO alarms, marketing campaigns, education campaigns by the American Lung Association and advocacy by the US Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC). In 1995, Chicago was the first municipality in the United States to mandate CO alarms in all single and multiple family housing, and in some special use buildings such as schools, churches, theaters, museums. By 1998, approximately 20 million units had been shipped and an estimated 8–15% of homes had at least one CO alarm installed.2 CO alarms today retail for $20–$60 (U.S.), are widely available, and can either be battery-operated or AC (mains) powered. Other locales such as Massachusetts have followed Chicago in acknowledging CO poisoning as a priority and have enacted state legislation which requires CO detectors in homes. Such domestic detectors are required to meet performance standards such as BS EN 50291 (UK and Europe), UL 2034 (USA), and CSA 6-19-01 (Canada). The Canadian standard has been argued to be superior as it requires “time of manufacture” and test for “lifetime reliability.” As an example, the British–European standard requires domestic CO alarms to behave in the following way: • • • •
No alarm within 60 min at 45 ppm CO Alarm within 30 min, but not less than 10 min, at 150 ppm CO Alarm within 6 min at 350 ppm CO Recovery from the alarm state within 6 min in clean air
Although these design standards help set a benchmark for performance, they do not specify the degree to which alarms must maintain their performance, and hence has contributed to CO detectors known to becoming notoriously unreliable with age. Poor sensitivity at low humidity was a major problem in one field experiment, showing as much as 79% of alarms failed when tested at 5% RH and that 3 of the 10 brands tested worked well.3 Other than the domestic need for CO alarms, another important CO sensing application that has recently gained considerable interest is vehicle cabins. Exhaust pollutants find their way into the cabin through the ventilation system, also known as the heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) system. Independent studies4−7 have shown that vehicle cabins commonly show concentrations of toxic gases such as CO, hydrocarbons (HC), volatile organic compounds (VOC), and oxides of nitrogen (NOx ) higher than safety limits set by Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and World Health Organization (WHO). Among the array of toxins found in vehicle exhaust gases, CO is the most deadly poison. It is a major subject of overlooked issues concerning motor-vehicle cabin air quality and suicides involving CO.8,9 Of the 2320 suicides registered for the year 2002 in Australia, 416 persons (18%) died from use of motor-vehicle exhaust gases.10 By understanding the problem of CO pollution within vehicle cabins, CO sensor technology can be employed to circumvent the danger. See Chapter 9 of Carbon Monoxide Toxicity, 2000, and Appendix 1 for additional discussion of this issue.
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 252 — #2
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
253
10.2 SENSOR TECHNOLOGIES FOR CARBON MONOXIDE GAS DETECTION At the heart of any gas alarm and detecting system are the sensors. The sensor detects target gases, and then converts the information into an electrical signal for processing. There are numerous ways to sense gas. However, as cost, size, and simplicity are critical sensor attributes, three main sensing technologies have dominated domestic CO alarms. These are 1. Semiconducting metal oxide (SMO) technology 2. Electrochemical (EC) technology 3. Infra-red/optical technology (IR) SMO gas sensors are currently the smallest CO sensors available. These sensors have a small heated element, causing reducing/oxidizing gases to react with the surface of a metal oxide film, changing the semiconductor’s conductivity proportionally to the gas concentration. Electrochemical gas sensors have electrodes placed in contact with a liquid electrolyte to form an Electrochemical sensor. As the gas diffuses, it reacts with the working electrode, changing its electrical potential proportional to the gas concentration. And third are IR sensors, where the optical sensing element undergoes light transmission changes when exposed to the target gas. Table 10.1 compares the technologies against seven key sensor device criteria. Domestic CO alarms predominantly employ either the semiconductor or Electrochemical sensor. Semiconductor based CO sensors have penetrated the market with companies such as Figaro (Japan), Microchemical (MiCS) (Switzerland), and FiS (Japan). Some Electrochemical sensor manufactures include City Technology (U.K.), Monox (UK), and Kidde (USA). Optical CO sensors have been pioneered by Quantum (USA). For vehicle cabin air quality monitoring installed within the HVAC systems of vehicles, metal oxide sensors have dominated as they are small, have a long lifetime and the technology allows for the sensor element to be conveniently
TABLE 10.1 Comparison of Three Gas-Sensing Technologies with Respect to Desirable Carbon Monoxide Domestic and Vehicle Air Quality Monitoring Criteria Criteria Cost Life time Sensitivity Selectivity Response time Size Ease of use
Infra Red—Optical
Electrochemical
Metal Oxide
6 years Very good Excellent Seconds Medium Good
6years Very good Poor Seconds Small Excellent
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 253 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
254
optimized for various toxic gases. However, for aftermarket vehicle CO detectors, optical sensors from Quantum have dominated.
10.2.1 SEMICONDUCTING METAL OXIDE (SMO) GAS SENSORS SMO gas sensors are relatively small, reliable, durable, and have low cost. Traditionally, the major disadvantages of SMO as gas sensitive devices has been their poor gas selectivity, and the influences of humidity and temperature.11,12 The introduction of noble metal catalysts (such as platinum and palladium), filters (activated carbon), and modification to the SMO microstructure and nanostructure has enabled SMO sensor manufacturers to improve selectivity and stability performance.13 For reducing gases such as CO, molecules react with adsorbed oxygen ions (from ambient air) on the surface of the oxide. The adsorbed oxygen loses its electron by reacting with the reducing gas molecule, thereby increasing the films conductivity. A simple model consisting of three possible reactions is shown below14,15 : 2CO + O2− ←→ 2CO2 + e− CO + O− ←→ CO2 + e− CO + O2 ←→ CO2 + 2e− From this reaction it is obvious that a change in ambient oxygen concentration will also change the rate of this redox process and influence the output signal of the sensor. The relationship between film conductivity (σ ) and gas concentration (c) follows a power law that can be described by16 : σ = kcn where k is a measured proportionality constant unique to the film/sensor and the exponent n can range from 0.3 to 0.8. Owing to this intrinsic nonlinear semiconducting nature, linearization circuitry within hardware/software is usually required. In addition, for the SMO material to react with a gas, the material is elevated to temperatures between 90◦ C and 250◦ C enabling the reduction/oxidization process to occur. Elevating the sensor to high temperature requires an integrated heater circuit to be fabricated below or adjacent to the sensing element. Owing to this high temperature requirement, SMO gas sensors require relatively high power consumption. Traditional SMO sensors fabricated on alumina substrates typically consume above 350 mW. One way of reducing power consumption is by fabricating gas sensors using a thin Si membrane as done by MiCS in Switzerland. Power consumption of the MiCS sensor is about 30–50 mW. Typically for detecting CO gas, the sensitive film material used in SMO sensors is tin oxide (SnO2 ). Other transitional metal oxides such as tungsten oxide (WO3 ), indium oxide (In2 O3 ), chromium titanium oxide (Cr2 TiO3 ) fabricated at a thickness between 200 nm and 10 µm have also been shown to be effective CO sensing materials.17−24 For automobile air quality monitor (AQM) applications, MiCS manufactures dual element sensors for detecting both reducing gases such as CO and HC’s and oxidizing
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 254 — #4
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
255
gases such as NO2 and O3 . This allows for detection of gasoline pollution from cars and motorbikes, and diesel pollution from diesel-powered cars as well as trucks and buses. The Si based sensor chips (Figure 10.1a) are bonded to either transistor outline (TO) packages or SMD (surface mount device) packages. Figure 10.1b shows two sensor chips on the same housing developed for the automobile industry, capable of detecting both CO and NOx . Typically, the sensor is integrated on a printed circuit board with peripheral electronics and packaged as a CO alarm for domestic or automobile use.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
FIGURE 10.1 Photographs of commercial CO gas sensors. (a) The MiCS Micro-ElectroMechanical Systems (MEMS) chip 2.1 × 2.3 mm. This chip is made up of a thin Si membrane, which is a micromachined silicon platform that includes an integrated heater and interdigital electrodes. The sensitive layer is a thin (about 200 nm in. thickness) metal oxide polycrystalline film; (b) Dual MiCS MEMS chips mounted and bonded onto a TO5 package. These sensors are used in automobile applications to control the HVAC system, (c) The FIS SB series sensing element made up of a platinum coil heater (as shown in the inset) with a sensing platinum electrode in the middle of the coil. The structure is coated and covered with sensitive semiconducting metal oxide, tin dioxide (SnO2 ). The SnO2 material is made up of many small particles in the size range of submicron to several tens of microns, (d) The FIS SB series sensor package for integration within CO detectors. These sensor structures are encapsulated in nickel plated brass (as shown in the inset) with an attached active charcoal filter and then enclosed in an outer plastic housing. These sensors are typically employed within domestic CO detectors. (Courtesy of MicroChemical of Switzerland and FIS of Japan).
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 255 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
256
Figure 10.1c and d shows the sensor design of the FiS (Japan) sensor employed in domestic CO detectors. Compared to MiCS, the FiS design is based on a tin dioxide coated over a platinum coil and a sensing electrode. The coil heats the structure at an elevated temperature while the working electrode senses the conductance changes. Figure 10.2a shows the FiS sensor responding to CO gas. Some important characteristics to note are: (1) The sensor signal returns to its original baseline. This characteristic ensures that the sensor remains calibrated, free of drift that will result in signal errors. (2) The response time and decay time of the sensor is a few minutes which is adequate for either domestic or automobile applications. (3) The magnitude of sensor signal changes as a function of concentration (i.e., exponent n, based on Equation 10.1). This permits a greater signal to noise ratio and signal dynamic range. Figure 10.2b is a typical selectivity test performed to determine cross-sensitivity to other gases. As shown, the SMO sensor does not offer absolute CO selectivity. Improving selectivity requires optimizing calatyst concentration (such as platinum), optimizing material annealing temperature and optimizing crystal and grain properties. Figure 10.2c shows a stability test of the FiS CO sensor. The slight change in baseline is a result of the complicated nature of the crystallization process due to operation at elevated temperatures. The sensor is extremely stable over 1000 days—even after 1000 days a baseline change of only 10% occurs, which is usually mitigated by intelligent microprocessor algorithm programming. Improving this characteristic of SMO sensors is a great challenge that drives the active research disciplines of semiconductor metal oxide gas sensors.
10.2.2 OPTICAL GAS SENSORS IR-based sensors are relatively physically small, consume low power, are selective, and are rapidly decreasing in cost. These sensors are considered as solid state and have a lifetime of over 6 years (depends on IR source degradation/failure) with good resolution, relatively high selectivity, and broad dynamic range. These sensors identify gases by taking advantage of a gas’s unique IR absorption spectra. Most gases (more than one type of atom) can be detected by measuring their absorption at a particular IR wavelength, which corresponds to the resonance of the molecular bonding between dissimilar atoms. Figure 10.3a shows an IR absorption spectrum of some common gases. For example, to detect CO, the wavelength at which one carbon atom and one oxygen atom resonate in a carbon monoxide molecule is 4.7 µm. Therefore, the IR system will be filtered to detect radiation at a bandwidth centered at 4.7 µm. There are certain basic components common to all IR gas sensors: an IR source (e.g., incandescent lamp), an IR detector (e.g., thermopiles, pyroelectric detectors, photodiode), a means to select appropriate wavelengths (e.g., band pass interference filter) and a sample cell. The simple sensing setup is shown in Figure 10.3b. The IR source is at one end and the IR sensor at the other. The band pass optical filter must correspond with the absorption wavelength of the gas being measured. As the concentration of the gas being measured increases, the output signal from the sensor reduces as the IR is absorbed by the target gas molecules. The relationship between
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 256 — #6
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems (a)
257
5.0 CO 100 ppm clean air
CO 300 ppm clean air
CO 100 ppm clean air
VRL (V )
4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0
(b)
0
5
10
15 Time (min)
20
25
30
100000
Rs (Kohm)
10000
1000
100
CO 400 ppm
CO 60 ppm CO 100 ppm CO 200 ppm
Air
CO 30 ppm
Isopropyl alcohol 200 Carbon dioxide 5000p
Butane 300 ppm 2hr
Heptane 500 ppm 2hr Ethyl acetate 200 ppm
Methane 500 ppm 2hr
CO 400 ppm
1
Air CO 30 ppm CO 60 ppm CO 100 ppm CO 200 ppm
10
FIGURE 10.2 FIS SB series CO sensor data showing, (a) exposure to 100, 300, and 100 ppm CO with clean air cycles. The x-axis represents time (minutes) and the y-axis represents the proportional voltage response from the sensing element. The sensor is stable when responding to CO gas, returning to baseline within a few minutes. In addition, the repeatable response characteristic at 100 ppm also is another desirable sensing attribute, (b) selectivity to other gases following the UL2034 specification. The largest cross-sensitivity is with heptane (error bars overlap with an equivalent CO error signal of about 30 ppm), (c) long-term stability. The sensor’s stability over 1000 days shows extremely stable characteristics, even after 1000 days a baseline change of only 10% occurs, which is usually mitigated by intelligent microprocessor algorithm programming. (Courtesy of FIS, Japan).
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 257 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
258 (c) 10
R /R0(CO100)
R /Ro
R /R0(CO300)
1
0.1 0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000 1100
Time (days)
FIGURE 10.2 Continued.
IR transmission, I, and gas concentration, c, can be explained by Beers Law of Absorption: I = Io e(−kc l) where I is the intensity of IR radiation at the IR detector, Io is the IR radiation emitted from the IR source, k is the absorption coefficient, and l is the optical path length. To improve the signal to noise ratio, an improved IR detection setup as shown in Figure 10.3c was developed. The difference is that a reference detector was added to compensate for humidity, vibration, source intensity deterioration, detector contamination, vibration, and aging. As a result, a dual beam topology is typically employed with most IR gas sensors. A reference detector senses IR at a neutral wavelength where almost no absorption takes place (i.e., 4 µm). By taking the ratio of both detector voltage U1 and reference signal U2 , the common Io coefficient is cancelled, and the target gas signal component remains which corresponds to the target gas concentration. The Quantum Group (US) is the leading manufacturer of optical gas sensors for domestic CO alarms. They have developed a unique type of solid state IR gas sensor based on the “biomimetic” phenomena. The company has been successful in developing a broad range of domestic CO alarms and it is the first company to offer an aftermarket CO detector for vehicle safety applications. The IR-based “biomimetic” sensors are designed to replicate the CO uptake by hemoglobin in the blood, hence the name “biomimetic.” In doing so, the sensing element can be set to alarm based on the replicated blood level of carboxyhemoglobin (COHb). Figure 10.4a shows the elements of the biomimetic CO sensor. The patented sensing elements are made from a porous transparent disk coated with a monolayer
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 258 — #8
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
259
(a)
Absorption (arbitrary value)
1014
NO (5.3)
101
H2O (1.4)
SO2 (4)
CO (4.7)
HC (3.4) CO2 (4.3)
H2O (1.9)
0 1
2
3 4 Wavelength (µm)
(b)
5
6
IR bandpass filter
IR detector IR source
(c)
U1∝I0 exp (kcl) U2∝I0
Gas filter Reference filter IR light
FIGURE 10.3 IR sensor design that is based on, (a) the absorption bands of various gases in the IR region, (b) A simplified diagram of a single beam IR absorption gas detector and, (c) an improved version of the dual beam arrangement makes the gas detector insensitive to source performance deterioration. (Courtesy of PerkinElmer Optoelectronics, Germany).
of supramolecular organometallic complex. This complex is formed through a selfassembly process to generate the sensing elements that mimic hemoglobin. Upon exposure to CO, one or both of the sensing elements changes its spectral character and absorbs photons of light at a rate dependent on the concentration of CO in the surrounding environment. The sensing elements reverse their spectral shift by a selfgeneration process whose rate depends upon the decrease of CO in the environment.
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 259 — #9
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
260 (a)
Retainer clip
Filter element
Red sensing element Sensor housing
Window
Yellow sensing element
Photodiode
IR lED
Sensor holder
(b)
FIGURE 10.4 A commercialized optical CO gas sensor, (a) components and structure of Quantum’s biomimetic CO gas sensor, and (b) a photograph of the CO sensor cell incorporated within Quantum’s line of domestic and automobile CO detectors. (Courtesy of the Quantum Group, USA).
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 260 — #10
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems CO Exposure
Recovery period
120 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
Temperature = 0°C/15% RH Temperature = 25°C/30% RH
600
540
480
420
360
300
240
180
120
60
Temperature = 50°C/30% RH
0
I%
Preconditioning
261
RH = Relative humidity
Time (min)
FIGURE 10.5 Response curves of a Quantum biomimetic sensor towards 100 ppm CO for 90 min with varying ambient temperatures from 0◦ C to 50◦ C and relative humidity from 15% to 30% RH. It can be seen that varying these parameters influences the response time and baseline of the optical sensor. (Courtesy of the Quantum Group, USA).
This mechanism acts as a variable IR bandpass filter. By monitoring the rate of change in the amount of light transmitted through the sensing elements, the concentration of the CO in the surrounding environment can be determined accurately. The sensing elements are held in optical alignment by the sensor-housing placed between an IR light emitting diode (LED) and a photodiode. Pulses of light emitted by the LED pass through the first sensor-housing window and are attenuated by the sensing elements. The attenuated light exits through the second sensor-housing window and is then detected by the photodiode. The light transmittance follows Beer’s Law (Equation 10.2). Figure 10.5 shows the response of the Quantum Group’s biomimetic sensor over 90 min to a 100 ppm concentration of CO at varying temperatures and relative humidity. After the 90 min, the CO is removed and the sensor begins regenerating. When exposed to CO, the sensor rapidly absorbs photons at 940 nm. In a fixed alarm point detector, a value of 30% is typically set as the alarm point. Thus in such a detector, the alarm would be triggered within 40 min of exposure, which is well within the UL safety guidelines. When the sensor is again exposed to clean air (marked as recovery time), the biomimetic component begins a self-regenerating process. As the sensor reverses its spectral shift, the signal increases and within hours the sensor has fully recovered. Although the response time is slower than the SMO sensor, incorporating sensing algorithms based on the rate of change of signal, improves response time.
10.2.3 ELECTROCHEMICAL GAS SENSORS Electrochemical gas sensors are also small electronic devices. A City Technology CO sensor commonly found in CO domestic alarms is shown in the inset of Figure 10.6. In their simplest form they are comprised of two electrodes: sensing and counter,
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 261 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
262
Capillary diffusion barrier
Sensing electrode Separator Counter electrode Current collectors
Electrolyte Sensor pins
FIGURE 10.6 A simplified schematic of a two electrode electrochemical cell manufactured by City Technology. The inset show photographs of the complete sensor package. These sensors are employed within domestic CO detectors. (Courtesy of City Technology, U.K.).
separated by a thin layer of electrolyte. The structure is enclosed in a plastic housing that has a small capillary tube to allow gas entry to the sensing electrode and includes pins which are electrically attached to both electrodes and allow easy external interface. These pins may be connected to a simple resistor circuit that allows the voltage drop resulting from any current flow to be measured. Gas diffusing into the sensor is either oxidized or reduced at the sensing electrode and, coupled with a corresponding (but converse) counter reaction at the other electrode, a current is generated through the external circuit. Since the rate of gas entry into the sensor is controlled by the capillary diffusion barrier, the current generated is proportional to the concentration of gas present outside the sensor. Of great importance to any electrochemical gas sensor is the design of the diffusion barrier, which limits the flow of gas to the sensing electrode. The electrode is therefore able to react with all target gas as it reaches its surface, and still has electrochemical activity in reserve. The reactions that take place at the electrodes in a CO sensor are: Sensing: CO + H2 O− CO2 + 2H+ 2e− Counter: 12 O2 + 2H+ + 2e− > H2 O And the overall reaction is: CO + 12 O− 2 > CO2 Similar reactions take place for all other toxic gases that are capable of being electrochemically oxidized or reduced. From the reaction at the counter electrode, it is evident that oxygen is required for the current generation process to take place. This is usually provided in the sample stream by air diffusing to the front of the sensor, or by diffusion through the sides of the sensor (a few thousand ppm is normally sufficient).
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 262 — #12
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
263
However, continuous exposure to an anaerobic sample of gas may result in signal drift, despite the oxygen access paths which may cause the sensor to be poisoned. Similar to SMO gas sensors, electrochemical gas sensors are also affected by temperature variations. The baseline signal of most electrochemical sensors tends to increase exponentially with temperature, approximately doubling for every 10◦ C rise in temperature which proves problematic for domestic applications as the baseline shift with temperature could seriously affect the ability to measure these gases accurately and result in false alarming. Nevertheless, by compensating for this drift either in the hardware or software, such temperature influences can be reduced.
10.3 SENSOR SYSTEMS The CO sensor is the main component within all domestic CO detectors. Support electronics are also required to provide the sensor with intelligence so that it will actuate alarms according to compliant standards. Most detectors incorporate at least one microprocessor that allows them to be quickly reprogrammed and the behavior of the alarm to be altered to suit various applications or standards. For domestic applications, CO alarm design and alarm requirements are well defined by associated performance specifications. However, in emerging CO and air quality monitoring applications such as monitoring vehicle cabin air quality, specifications, and standards have yet to evolve. Vehicle cabin air quality concerns are usually generated by the following four scenarios: (1) Pollutant gases entering the vehicle through the ventilation system, (2) A lack of fresh airflow resulting in low oxygen and high carbon dioxide concentrations due to occupant respiration, (3) Pollutant gases entering from the external environment through window openings, imperfect seals, and other holes, and (4) Toxic gases entering the vehicle cabin by redirected exhaust fumes for self-harm (i.e., suicide) purposes. Currently, no system or aftermarket product addresses all four vehicle AQM concerns. Only two commercial AQM solutions currently exist for vehicles: (1) The most common are AQM systems controlling HVAC ventilation flaps, and (2) Less common are aftermarket toxic gas alarms for vehicle cabin applications, such as that commercialized by the Quantum Group (U.S.). Currently, the demand for AQM systems is driven by the increasing concern for passenger safety, health, comfort, and by automakers aiming for features and attributes that differentiate their vehicles. In turn, this growth has increased demand for reliable automotive air quality sensors. Figure 10.7 shows a simplified view of an AQM system controlling the HVAC ventilation flap. External gases enter the vehicle cabins through the ventilation system. Mounted in the air intake of the HVAC system, the AQM sensor sends a signal to the fresh air inlet flap to close when pollutant gases are detected and automatically reopen when the external air quality returns to an acceptable level. Although a driver could close the air inlet manually, forgetting to reopen it could cause the oxygen concentration in the cabin to decrease and carbon dioxide levels to increase. Therefore, a compromise must be reached. One way of tackling the problem to implement with the system an air quality factor. For instance, the absolute concentration of particular gas (Cx ) in the vehicle cabin is dependent on the exhaust flow rate (F), time (T ), cabin
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 263 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
264
CO2
O2 OPEN
3. Ventilation system/flap 2. Electronics/algorithms
CLOSED
1. Sensor response
CO NOx HC Particulates
FIGURE 10.7 An overview of a typical automobile air quality monitor (AQM) employed within a heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) system. When the ventilation flap is open, dangerous pollutants such as CO and NOx may enter the cabin. To mitigate this, electronics automatically close the ventilation flap. High carbon dioxide and low oxygen concentrations may result through occupant respiration. High carbon dioxide and low oxygen concentrations are dangerous because they induce fatigue and drowsiness, reducing driver attention and response times.
volume (V ), and cabin seal (S). Therefore, Cx = f (F, T , V , S) Concentrations of carbon monoxide (CCO ), and oxygen (CO2 ) have been identified as important gas species contributing to poor cabin air quality. The summation of each absolute gas species concentration gives rise to an air quality factor (AQcabin ) such as: AQcabin = αCO + δ(CO2 )−1 Where α, and δ are proportionality coefficients. It should be noted that other gas species such as hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxides have been ignored. Absolute threshold limits could then be set for scenarios such as suicide (AQsuicide ) and driver fatigue (AQfatigue ). For increased reliability and effective suicide attempt identification, the change of air quality with time (dAQcabin /dt) should also be incorporated into the driver fatigue and suicide detecting algorithms: ∂CCO ∂(CO2 )−1 dAQcabin =α +δ dt ∂t ∂t An alarm threshold, dAQsuicide /dt, could also be incorporated as done so by Quantum Group. Therefore, the cabin gas-sensing system should include both absolute and changing air quality factors, to determine if alarms need to be activated. Software solutions to improve CO detectors are commonplace. In addition, rate of change, humidity compensation (through humidity sensors) and temperature
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 264 — #14
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
265
compensation (through temperature sensors) are also common within sensor systems. However, compensation for environmental variables increases the cost of the CO detector. Data referenced above showing that 79% of alarms failed when tested at 5% RH3 is compelling evidence of performance standards not meeting real-life long-term requirements for adequate domestic CO monitoring.
10.4 CONCLUSIONS Detection of CO has gone far beyond the primitive approach of Claude Bernard and others. CO sensors and detectors employ advanced materials, electronics, and software to ensure reliable and selective performance while maintaining economic sensitivity and feasible for the domestic market. This chapter has discussed the three major sensing techniques employed in mainstream CO detector/alarms. SMO sensors depend on chemi-absorption between the oxide and CO molecules for CO detection. Various methods are employed by industry to increase selectivity through the introduction of catalysts such as Pt and Pd, and filters using activated carbon. Optical sensors depend on CO energy absorption by incident photons. Humidity, temperature, and pressure are environmental factors that may affect sensor components. Electrochemical sensors are also vulnerable to cross sensitivity, temperature, and humidity variations. The intrinsic deficiencies of materials and electronic components that make up commercial CO sensors and systems have been documented and are well known. These issues have plagued manufacturers and the research community for many years and continue to be areas of active scientific interest. Nevertheless, economic forces, government legislation, competition, and customer demand drive CO detector products to be sold at the lowest possible prices, while high customer standards, product superiority, competitive advantage and market reputation drive product quality and innovation. Hence, these forces lead to the classic economic balance between price and performance.
10.5 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors kindly thank all contributors including Dr Mark Goldstein from Quantum Group, Inc. (USA), Dr Herve Borrel from MiCS (Switzerland), Dr Nobuaki Murakami from FiS (Japan), Dr Jürgen Schilz from PerkinElmer Optoelectronics (Germany), and City Technology Sensors (UK).
10.6 APPENDIX 1 (D.G. PENNEY) Suicide in Australia, especially that of young men, had attained an alarming rate in recent years, higher than that in the USA and most other countries. The use of motorvehicle exhaust gas for this purpose was the most popular method. For this reason, in 1998 the Australian Medical Association in cooperation with other governmental and industrial groups as well as various individuals in Australia, invited me to provide conceptual solutions for reducing this tragic loss of young life.
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 265 — #15
266
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
Almost immediately, it was felt that by limiting the availability of the lethal component of motor-vehicle exhaust gas, carbon monoxide (CO), the use of this method of commiting suicide would decline, possibly saving several hundred lives per year. The use of CO was often chosen because of its availability, ease of use, and supposed painless induction of unconsciousness. Making CO unavailable would defeat this approach. Several solutions were considered: (1) Accelerate the rate of installation of effective catalytic converters on Australian motor vehicles, possibly by instigating a retro-fit program. (2) Require the sale or retroinstallation of CO detectors on all motor vehicles in Australia that would warn drivers/occupants of the danger, and/or, immediately shut-down the engine and prevent restarting. (3) Place a distinctive odorant in petrol/gasoline that would give motor-vehicle exhaust an unpleasant odor and thus discourage/warn potential suicide attempters. (4) Design ignition systems that would prevent motor vehicles from remaining in an “idle” mode for more than a short time. Catalytic converters are expensive, eventually wear-out, are slow to come on-line in Australia owing to a long mean vehicle life, and retro-fitting would be difficult and place financial burdens on people least able to pay. Also, current catalytic converters still permit exhaust gases to contain lethal CO concentrations. Finally, the fact that catalytic converters only become effective in reducing CO at elevated temperatures means that exhaust gases would continue to contain supra-lethal concentrations of CO during the “warm-up” period. CO detectors that produce engine “shut-down” would have to be carefully designed so as not to exacerbate traffic problems due to elevated ambient CO concentration. This approach appeared to be the best overall solution, and could have provided some additional health benefits separate from the suicide issue. Solutions involving odorants in motor-vehicle fuel might cause public discomfort and complaints and undesirable environmental pollution. Most motor vehicles need the capability to idle, for example, waiting for traffic or stop lights, taxis, and vehicles being repaired. Australia represented just 1% of the world motor-vehicle market. The average age of Australian motor vehicles (8 × 106 ) in 1997 was 12–14 years. It was my charge in visiting Australia in early April, 1998, to recommend to the Australian Medical Association (AMA) and the Working Group on Motor Vehicle Exhaust Suicide, a CO concentration that might be set as the threshold at which engine shut-down would occur. Mathematical modeling of motor vehicle exhaust gas revealed a “unique signature” that might be used to quickly and unequivocally identify a suicide attempt, distinct from simple leakage of outside gases into the vehicle. Motor vehicles would be equipped with a sensor array in the passenger compartment that was sensitive to: carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and oxygen. Sensor output would be directed to a microchip with an embedded program such that: (1) measured CO concentration was integrated over time in a manner modeling human CO uptake, and thus provides a Low warning alarm at 35 ppm (7% COHb), and a High warning alarm at 100 ppm (14% COHb), and (2) A CO concentration at 100 ppm and above, as well as rapidly rising CO2 concentration and rapidly falling O2 concentration would immediately trigger engine shut-down.
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 266 — #16
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
267
There were several advantages to this scheme: Low and high alarms give warning of CO presence at levels shown to impair psychometric performance (“drowse alarm”) and known to produce health damage in at-risk groups (congestive heart failure (CHF), coronary artery disease (CAD), fetus). These would give warning of elevated ambient CO and/or abnormal exhaust gas leaks into the motor-vehicle driver/passenger compartment. With concentration × time computer integration, neither heavy cigarette smoking, auto tunnels, nor congested roads would be likely to trigger even the low CO alarm. Use of CO2 concentration and O2 concentration changes along with CO concentration would prevent “false positives,” that is, inappropriate engine shut-down. Changes in the concentrations of these three gases would provide a unique “signature” of the suicide attempt. A second sensor array might be placed outside the motor-vehicle, preferrably near the rear tailpipe. This would cause engine shut-down in those instances where people attempt to commit suicide outside of the car, behind the tailpipe (in a garage, outside, etc.). If the cost of the three-sensor array proved too great, only one sensor responding to CO might instead be used. In this event, threshold CO concentration might be set somewhat higher in order to avoid inappropriate engine shut-downs. CO detectors are standard equipment in households in the USA, warning of furnace malfunction, etc. They are also required in motor homes, recreational powerboats, and other devices where people are fully or partially enclosed and in proximity to an internal combustion engine. Why shouldn’t such devices now become standard equipment in motor vehicles, considering that cars are such prodigious generators of CO and in such close proximity to the driver and passengers, and the fact that cars already incorporate minimally several microcomputers in their normal operation. For further details of the proposed scheme, see www.coheadquarters.com/CO1.htm.
References 1. C. Bernard, Introduction a l’etude de la medecine experimentale. Paris: J.B. Bailliere et Fils, 1865, pp. 85–92, 101–104, 107–112, 265–301. 2. Revised Standards to Improve Carbon Monoxide Alarm Performance, Gas Research Institute Digest (GRID), Chicago, vol. 21, pp. 24–25, 1998. 3. P. K. Clifford, Evaluating the Performance of Residential CO Alarms, Mosaic Industries, Inc., Newark GRI–02/0112, 2002. 4. K. Galatsis, W. Wlodarski, Y. X. Li, and K. Kalantar-zadeh, Vehicle cabin air quality monitor using gas sensors for improved safety, presented at COMMAD 2000 Proceedings. Conference on Optoelectronic and Microelectronic Materials and Devices (Cat. No. 00EX466). IEEE. 2000, pp. 65–68. Piscataway, NJ. 5. K. Galatsis, W. Wlodarski, L. Yongxiang, and K. Kalantar-zadeh, Ventilation control for improved cabin air quality and vehicle safety, presented at IEEE VTS 53rd Vehicular Technology Conference, Spring 2001. Proceedings (Cat. No. 01CH37202). IEEE. Part vol. 4, 2001, pp. 3018–3021, Piscataway, NJ. 6. K. Galatsis, B. Wells, and S. McDonald, Vehicle cabin air quality monitor for fatigue and suicide prevention, SAE Transactions, vol. 2000-01-0084, 2000. 7. S. Sato, R & D Review of Toyota CRDL 39, vol. 1, 36, 2004.
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 267 — #17
268
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 8. V. H. Routley and J. Ozanne-Smith, The impact of catalytic converters on motor vehicle exhaust gas suicides, Med. J. Australia, vol. 168, pp. 65–67, 1998. 9. M. A. Skopek and R. Perkins, Deliberate exposure to motor vehicle exhaust gas: the psychosocial profile of attempted suicide. Australian and New Zealand J. Psychiatry, vol. 32, pp. 830–838, 1998. 10. Motor Vehicle Census, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra Cat. 0309.0, 2001. 11. W. Gopel, New materials and transducers for chemical sensors, presented at Sensors and Actuators B (Chemical), vol. B18, no. 1–3, March, 1994, pp. 1–21. Switzerland. 12. N. Yamazoe, New approaches for improving semiconductor gas sensors, presented at Sensors and Actuators B (Chemical), vol. B5, no. 1–4, Aug.–Dec., 1991, pp. 7–19. Switzerland. 13. G. Sberveglieri, Recent developments in semiconducting thin-film gas sensors, presented at Sensors and Actuators B (Chemical), vol. B23, no. 2–3, Feb. 1995, pp. 103–109. Switzerland. 14. M. J. Madou and S. R. Morrison, Chemical Sensing with Solid State Devices: Academic Press, San Diego, 1989. 15. S. R. Morrison, In Semiconductor Sensors, S. M. Sze, ed., New York: J. Wiley, 1994. 16. H. Meixner, J. Gerblinger, and M. Fleischer, Sensors for monitoring environmental pollution, presented at Sensors and Actuators B (Chemical), vol. B15, no. 1–3, Aug., 1993, pp. 45–54. Switzerland. 17. G. Kiriakidis, N. Katsarakis, M. Katharakis, M. Suchea, K. Galatsis, W. Wlodarski, and D. Kotzias, Ultra sensitive low temperature metal oxide gas sensors, presented at 2004 International Semiconductor Conference. CAS 2004 Proceedings (IEEE Cat. No. 04TH8748). IEEE. Part vol. 2, 2004, pp. 325–331, vol. 2. Piscataway, NJ, USA. 18. K. Galatsis, Y. Li, W. Wlodarski, C. Cantalini, M. Passacantando, and S. Santucci, MoO3 , WO3 single and binary oxide prepared by sol-gel method for gas sensing applications, J. Sol-Gel Sci. Tech., vol. 26, pp. 1097–1101, 2003. 19. S. Kaciulis, L. Pandolfi, S. Viticoli, G. Sberveglieri, E. Zampiceni, W. Wlodarski, K. Galatsis, and Y.X. Li, Investigation of thin films of mixed oxides for gas-sensing applications, Surface and Interface Analysis, vol. 34, pp. 672–676, 2002. 20. L. M. Cukrov, P. G. McCormick, K. Galatsis, and W. Wlodarski, Microcharacterisation and gas sensing properties of mechanochemically processed nanosized iron-doped SnO2 , presented at Proceedings of IEEE Sensors 2002. First IEEE International Conference on Sensors (Cat. No. 02CH37394). IEEE. Part vol. 1, 2002, pp. 443–447, vol. 1, Piscataway, NJ. 21. Y. X. Li, D. Wang, Q. R. Yin, K. Galatsis, and W. Wlodarski, Microstructural characterization of sol-gel derived Ga2 O3 -TiO2 thin films for gas sensing,” presented at COMMAD 2000 Proceedings. Conference on Optoelectronic and Microelectronic Materials and Devices (Cat. No. 00EX466). IEEE. 2000, pp. 363–366. Piscataway, NJ. 22. Y. X. Li, K. Galatsis, W. Wlodarski, J. Cole, S. Russo, J. Gorman, N. Rockelmann, and C. Cantalini, Polycrystalline and amorphous sol-gel derived WO3 thin films and their gas sensing properties, presented at COMMAD 2000 Proceedings. Conference on Optoelectronic and Microelectronic Materials and Devices (Cat. No.00EX466). IEEE. 2000, pp. 206–209. Piscataway, NJ. 23. L. Yongxiang, W. Wlodarski, K. Galatsis, S. H. Moshli, J. Cole, S. Russo, and N. Rockelmann, Gas sensing properties of p-type semiconducting Cr-doped TiO2 thin films, presented at Transducers ’01. Eurosensors XV. 11th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors and Actuators. Digest of Technical Papers. Springer-Verlag. Part vol. 1, 2001, pp. 840–843, vol. 1. Berlin, Germany.
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 268 — #18
Carbon Monoxide Sensors and Systems
269
24. K. Galatsis, L. Yongxiang, W. Wlodarski, E. Comini, G. Sberveglieri, C. Cantalini, S. Santucci, and M. Passacantando, Comparison of single and binary oxide MoO3 , TiO2 and WO3 sol-gel gas sensors, presented at Transducers ’01. Eurosensors XV. 11th International Conference on Solid State Sensors and Actuators. Digest of Technical Papers. Springer-Verlag. Part vol. 1, 2001, pp. 836–839, vol. 1, Berlin, Germany. 25. For availability: www.coheadquarters.com/CO1.htm
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 269 — #19
8417: “8417_c010” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 270 — #20
11
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond: Use of the World Wide Web in Saving Lives Rob Aiers
CONTENTS 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7 11.8
My Introduction to CO Alarms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Use of the Internet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Department of Health . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Department of the Environment, Transport, and the Regions . . . . . . . The Department of Trade and Industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Health and Safety Executive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
271 274 277 281 281 282 284 285
11.1 MY INTRODUCTION TO CO ALARMS I have been involved with carbon monoxide (CO)-related issues for 8 years. My work and indeed my passion for getting the message out has resulted in our website becoming the number one CO-related issues website based on Google searches. From time to time we swap places with David Penney’s website. My background is in marketing, although I am an aircraft engineer by trade, serving 13 years in the Royal Air Force (RAF) and culminating in the first Gulf War. On leaving the RAF, I completed a diploma in sales and marketing management. I have worked for a number of large organizations and have been consulting in my own marketing business for 5 years. 271
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 271 — #1
272
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
My entre’ to the problem of CO exposure came when working for the world’s largest water utility company, as a consultant, with a remit for new and innovative products. My goal was to find a product that could be known outside the water company’s geographical area (water utilities in the United Kingdom cover a geographic area for their core business, but can own a number of such businesses in various areas) and thus make nonregulated profits (core business profits are regulated in the United Kingdom). The first product that I was asked to market was a product called Water Fuse. It was a water-related product that the water company took on before I joined. Although Water Fuse was a good product, it had a number of problems. It measured water usage and if a leak was detected, would shut off the water. We did a number of commercial trials for the product and found it to be very reliable, however that was not the whole story. We found that the cost of the product combined with the installation costs made it prohibitively expensive, around $550. Most people in the market for this type of product (i.e., the domestic user) were happy if they had a problem their insurance would cover. Indeed most people’s insurance premiums were less than the cost of Water Fuse and covered all elements of liability including fire, theft, and so forth. I set out to find a replacement for Water Fuse that would be cheaper and easier to install. It was at this time that we came across many wacky products. One that springs to mind is Eco-Balls. This was a product that one used in place of detergent. Its marketing blurb read, “unleash the ionic power of your washing machine.” The premise of this product was that when you put the balls in with your washer, the power of ions would clean your clothes. When tested in the lab, it was found to be only marginally more effective than water alone. On my travels I met with a company that had done a trial of a product that was similar to Water Fuse, but was much less expensive and easier to install. This product could also be expanded to cover small leaks in all parts of a property by utilizing the electrical ring main of the house to send a signal back to the master unit, turning off the water. At the end of the meeting I asked what other products they were working on. “We have a product that we think could be a major lifesaver, but it does not fit the water company profile.” The product it turns out was a CO detector. We spent more time talking about this product than about the Water Fuse replacement. I was amazed how little I knew about CO. I spent the next few weeks researching the topic and discovered I was by no means alone in my ignorance. I was further astounded at the conflict in the numbers of deaths and injuries from CO exposures/poisonings. The figures ranged from an official government statistic of around 50 deaths a year to as many as 1500 deaths per year from nonofficial sources. I was appalled that there wasn’t more information available and that the government did not and still doesn’t, recognize or promote CO safety. Every now and then, late at night on TV, there is a puny campaign about CO exposure consisting of a public relations commercial. I am quite cynical about why the government does not publicize the CO problem. I believe that if they made people more aware of CO, the government would be compelled to follow up with a plan to resolve the problem. The government in the
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 272 — #2
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
273
UK owns about 2.5 million homes, mostly “social housing.” If it publicized the problem, it would have to protect the residents from danger—the costs would be great. A CO alarm costs around $20.00. Multiply that by 2.5 million homes and the total is roughly $50 million. I saw the CO alarm to be a perfect public relations vehicle for a water company. It could be a true win-win situation. The water company had around 11 million customers and had access to the rest of the 60 million UK population through other water utilities. They could publicize the dangers of CO and also sell a product that could protect its users from future exposure. This might drastically reduce deaths. The company who first had the CO alarm was small, but it was innovative. It also had all the problems inherent to small companies, namely cash on hand. The product had been prototyped, with a short manufacturing run in Taiwan. However, the company had no money to move into full production. We concluded a deal where we had exclusive access to the product. The CO alarm was inserted directly into the wall electrical power receptacle. It incorporated some clever technology that allowed it to predict carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) levels, that is, blood CO content. We agreed to pay for an increase in product run once we had seen the product being built in a factory in Taiwan and were convinced that all was okay. Some colleagues and myself flew out to Taipei, Taiwan to verify the situation. This took a total of 5 days, either on the road or at manufacturing facilities. At every location we were dressed in full medical whites (“clean garb”), as the facilities also produced computer and automotive industry components. My view at that time was that Taiwan was just a producer of cheap toys for Christmas, crackers, and so forth. Nothing was further from the truth. All the facilities we saw were high-tech—at the top end of the computer industry. The costs of the CO alarms were a problem. If the selling price was too high, we’d be unable to sell many units. Not only would we not make projected profits, but more importantly, people would not be able to protect themselves from CO poisoning. Clearly the profit element was important and getting unit costs down was vitally important. We had to have the best product at the best price, so that when we advertised, we had an affordable solution for all. Ideally I would have liked to get the product down to a price of around £10 ($17). That is about the same price as a smoke alarm. We soon realized that the CO alarm was a much more complicated product and it may never be possible to make it as cheap as a smoke alarm. The smoke alarm industry had become a mature market, unlike that for CO alarms. It is worth drawing some parallels with what had allowed the smoke alarm industry to gain so much ground. In the 1980s, UK market penetration for smoke alarms was around 9% of households. At that time the government mounted a big campaign through the fire service and TV advertising. The “Smoke kills” campaign was responsible within a 9-year period of raising market penetration to around 65%. Recently, government legislation has caused that penetration to be near 100%. By law now, all new houses must have a smoke detector hard-wired into the construction, and it is now considered the norm to have such a device in place. The smoke kill’s campaign still goes on, but the focus is now more on maintaining existing devices. I think that the world would be a safer place if the same regulations existed for CO alarms.
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 273 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
274
We had to look for manufacturing facilities that would get CO alarms to market at a price that would ensure that most people would buy them. Many of the Taiwanese factories also had Chinese manufacturing facilities. These involve much reduced cost, since labor costs in the Republic of China are less than that of Taiwan. This would have been the next move had not something happened. It became clear that the price that I was trying to achieve was not realistic and that CO alarms would never be as cheap as smoke alarms. As stated above, this is because smoke alarms detect danger as the danger is occurring (by either optical sensors or ion detection), but do not require the complex circuitry required in a CO alarm. It is possible to have a large release of CO that causes an immediate audible alarm, or to have much lower levels of CO released over prolonged periods of time. The best type of CO alarm is one that can make the correct calculations regarding human CO uptake. As stated above, I also wanted to sell the best alarm, so it had to be a unit that measured CO concentration over time. Inexpensive card-type detectors are available that change color in the presence of CO, but these can be contaminated by chemicals, don’t give satisfactory low-level indications, and have no audible alarm. I am not totally opposed to this type of CO detector, as they play a role in raising CO awareness. Nonetheless, they are not sufficiently reliable for constant usage. We had by this stage fully evaluated the CO alarm market and were excited to get on with marketing the product and making the public aware that there was a problem. We hit on a major problem at this time—the water company was likely to be sold. This was happening at a high level in the company so none of us was aware of the impending sale. Orders came down from on high that we were to stop all unnecessary marketing and to get back to the core business. My vice-president at that time was a very talented woman who was not held in high regard by the company board. There followed a free for all with junior managers stepping on each others heads to try to gain political high ground. In particular, while I was on leave, an alliance was formed between two managers who were determined to steal our thunder, or better still, to totally kill our work. In the end they won and all of the people who had been working for me were let go or moved to other departments. With that, all of our efforts were dashed. I then left the company to move on to other things, but the company had no idea what contracts had been signed. Consequently a legal dispute ensued, because contracts had been signed for the water company (by me) that tied them to marketing and supply agreements. The company with whom we had been dealing needed the agreements in order to move forward, but foolishly had signed an agreement with a third party to sell the product before the legal wrangle was resolved and they ultimately lost everything.
11.2 USE OF THE INTERNET I resumed my marketing business at this time, after working initially on a consulting basis for the water utility. I worked for a number of large clients, but also felt the government could and should publicize the CO issue. It was around this time that I spawned the idea of a CO information website, that is, www.carbonmonoxidekills.com. I immediately began getting it set up.
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 274 — #4
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
275
Unfortunately I knew nothing about the internet, so I needed to team up with someone who was familiar with its complexity. It was at this time I met Frank Tiarks, a Danish chap who had been educated in the UK. Frank had a very good understanding of what was required to make website content user friendly, and of the content necessary to cause the major web search engines to list it first. I soon learned that it is no use just having a website—it has to be seen. I would liken it to having a shop that sells great products that people really need, but the shop is located down a dead-end road or in the depths of the countryside where no one will find it. One of the most important factors for success here is having a “Frank” who knows how to do it. There are many reasons why the world wide web (WWW) is an excellent way of getting your message out. First, the WWW is democratic. You have the same chance of getting your message across to the public if you are a small corner toy shop, as Toys-R-Us does. From that perspective it didn’t matter where you were geographically located as long as you could speak English. Anyone who has visited our website and has acted on the information there owes a debt to Frank Tiarks who has worked tirelessly to get CO-related information to the public. We needed to have a website with immediate impact, so we came up with the name, www.carbonmonoxidekills.com. As a capitalist, I had to generate a profit from the website simply to be able to continue running it. Over the past 5–6 years, some $80,000 has been spent on it, of which only a small percentage has been recouped. I am proud of the fact that we have become one of the most highly utilized, web-based CO information sites in the world. Approximately 5500 people per day look at the information on www.carbonmonoxidekills.com (see Figure 11.1). If we have saved one life or helped one sufferer improve his life, it has been money well spent. Some of the respondents have been referred to Dr. Penney for evaluation. More recently we have added some law firms as consultants, so some of our viewers have been helped with their legal problems. As you might guess, the website is quite comprehensive. Where questions are not answered, we pass the visitor on to an expert to answer the question (see Figure 11.2). It should also be noted that what you can see here is only the front page of the website. There are many additional layers, so almost any subject relating to CO poisoning can be found. It took some time to get us where we are now in terms of a web presence. We constantly re-examine the content of the website to insure that it has the best information for our visitors. We now get around 2 million visitors a year, many of whom e-mail us to thank us for the website. It is a sad indictment of those official government sources that should be doing this job and not be relying on individuals like me to do the job for them. Unfortunately we only get visitors who already are aware that there is a problem involving CO. In the words of Donald Rumsfeld, “we don’t know what we don’t know.” A clumsy way of saying that is, if you have never heard of CO, why would you look for information about it. That is the main issue here. If governments would just get the word out, people would be better able to decide for themselves whether there is a problem. The United States is much better at this than the United Kingdom. It may have to do with the fact that America is a more litigious society. We do not have a punitive damages system in the United Kingdom, so where someone may get an award of
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 275 — #5
276
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
FIGURE 11.1 The front page of www.carbonmonoxidekills.com
several hundred-thousand dollars in the United States, in the United Kingdom the award is more likely to be £10,000 at best. The questions we are asked through the website are diverse to say the least. In some cases they are downright stupid. In one case an American youth asked me if it was dangerous to travel in the trunk of his friend’s car. The great bulk of the questions from an uninformed public are completely justified (see Figure 11.3). About 75% of the website’s visitors are American—15% are from the United Kingdom (we have a lot of UK links from other websites, especially government sites), with the remaining visitors coming from the rest of the world. The reasons for this are several-fold. First, the United States has a larger population than the United Kingdom. Second, America is more web-savvy than most of the world. However the most important reason is that Americans are more aware of the dangers of CO, and are thus better able to seek out information. It should be noted that our website is in English alone, so other language speakers may not be able to use it. While there are charities and experts who work hard to get the message out, the same cannot be said of everyone. People with vested interests in CO issues have not,
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 276 — #6
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
277
FIGURE 11.2 The law connection to the Web.
in my view, been ready to sing from the same song sheet. There are three or four government departments in the United Kingdom who have some responsibility with regard to CO. From a public health perspective there is the Department of Health, from an environmental point of view (i.e., housing, etc) there is the Department of the Environment, and from a business perspective there is the Department of Trade and Industry. There is also the Health and Safety Executive who looks at the industrial side of safety.
11.3 DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH This department’s charge is the state of the nation’s health, with its remit covering doctors, nurses, and the general health infrastructure. Health concerns cover every part of people’s lives and some areas are covered better than others. Let me draw a parallel if I may. Meningitis affects about the same number of people in the United Kingdom as those who are affected by CO, based on government statistics. It is a
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 277 — #7
278
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
FIGURE 11.3 The forum associated with www.carbonmonoxidekills.com.
very serious disease that can kill or maim. Unchecked, CO poisoning can also kill, or damage people’s lives either through an acute poisoning episode or through chronic exposure. You would be hard pressed to find a parent in the United Kingdom who was not aware of the symptoms of meningitis and what to do if he/she suspected his/her child was suffering from it. This is just as it should be and is so because the government and the media have spent a good deal of time and effort publicizing its dangers. There was scarcely a time 3 years ago when you turned on the TV that this issue was not being aired. Please excuse me if I shout, “CO EXPOSURE IS AS DANGEROUS AS THE MANY STRAINS OF BACTERIA AND VIRUS THAT CAUSE MENINGITIS.” It is about time that politicians and health experts in the United Kingdom took a lead from some of the US states and began taking the CO exposure/poisoning issue more seriously. It is my opinion that most medical practitioners here and in the United States are only slightly better than useless when it comes to diagnosing and treating their
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 278 — #8
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
279
patients exposed to CO. If you visit your physician with flu-related symptoms, CO poisoning is usually the last cause he/she will include in the differential diagnosis, if it is included at all. Physicians are poorly trained about the dangers of CO poisoning— after all, the concern is primarily toxicological, not internal medicine. Physicians generally don’t know the correct questions to ask. For example, they usually fail to ask how your house is heated? Whether several people and even animals are sick at the residence? I very much doubt it. However, this is not an excuse for complacency. We must train our medical personnel better to recognize the symptoms of CO exposure. There are few ways for a physician to investigate the living circumstances of the person who has presented for treatment. That patient could be residing in a property where someone previously suffered similar symptoms. It is possible that over an extended period of time many people suffered CO poisoning in that building because no medical professional was alert. This scenario could go on for years. Early in 2006 I had a meeting at the Department of Health with a number of people. This included a lawyer who had represented victim’s interests in CO cases that had gone to court in the United Kingdom. There were a couple of representatives from a CO charity and the head of the Health Protection Agency, whose responsibility it is to deal with preventive health measures. I found the way the meeting was conducted to be astounding. We were informed that a leaflet had been sent to all UK physicians regarding CO. The leaflet was fairly brief. We asked if the department had followed up the leaflet to make sure that physicians had received it, and whether they had read and understood the information. The answer was no. We were also told that if there was a high demand for the leaflet there would be a reprinting, and that it was also available on the Department of Health’s website. If the physicians had not read the information in the first place how was there going to be a high demand? I told department personnel that I would help them in whatever way I could to get the message out, but that they needed to help me. One of the ways that this could be done quite simply and at very little cost, was for them to call TV stations to alert them to the problem. In the United Kingdom we have a morning program called GMTV. They spearheaded a brilliant campaign for meningitis and could do the same for CO. I have been unsuccessful in getting through to them. However one call from the chief medical officer would spur them into action at the cost of a phone call. At the meeting, a vice-president of CO Awareness said that she had tested the department’s system by calling “NHS Direct” (a phone hot line that gives health advice). She was told that the best people to speak with about CO was CO Awareness, her own charity. When questioned about the computer menu on their help line which advises what should be done when certain syptoms are mentioned, the official said that unexplained headaches and drowsiness would NOT be related to CO exposure by the operator. Of course this is incorrect. The problem goes much deeper. I asked the chief medical officer what would be the recommendation from physicians should they suspect CO poisoning? He replied that “the patient should be tested.” Do they have the appropriate equipment I asked? “I’ll have to get back to you,” he said. “So let’s accept the fact that they have the relevant testing equipment,” I said. “When do you recommend that the patient be tested?” “Well, during their consultation” was his reply. I had to point out that if the
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 279 — #9
280
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
FIGURE 11.4 www.codetection.com, which is lined to form carbonmonoxidekills.com
patient had been away from the source of the CO poisoning for more than a few hours, then they would likely give a negative test. In this event, someone who was suffering an episode of CO poisoning, but who happened to get an appointment at the end of the day might have CO dismissed as a potential cause of his/her illness, and then might go on being exposing needlessly to a life threatening situation. In some ways this is much worse than not being diagnosed at all. This problem was dismissed almost out of hand, likely because I was not a medical professional. The Department of Health should in my view be recommending that all homes be fitted with CO alarms (see Figure 11.4). There are a number of different views about CO alarms and their efficacy, but I think they are a good weapon in the arsenal for combating CO poisoning. They should also be recommending that all combustion appliances be checked annually. Only landlords have to perform an annual safety check. I am sorry to be bashing the Department of Health, because on the whole they do a great job. They are often hog-tied by a lack of government funding.
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 280 — #10
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
281
11.4 THE DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT, AND THE REGIONS This department is responsible for a numbers of areas. It is concerned with amongst other things, the air we breathe. Many people think that CO is only caused by vehicular emissions. There are major crossovers with other departments and I am loathe to list the full responsibility of this department, since by the time this book goes to print, it may have changed or there may be a new administration. This Department is responsible for dangers that lurk in our homes. It is responsible for planning regulations and for new building laws, for example, requiring newly built homes to have hard-wired smoke detectors. In my view, it is remiss in this respect in not also requiring CO detectors. The Department of the Environment requires landlords to have a safety check each year of accommodations where fossil or wood burning appliances are used. Because many people in the United Kingdom own there own homes, it means that a large fraction of residences are not covered by any regulation. It is unfortunately the way of the world that we buy “stuff” for which we can see a direct benefit. A CO detector costs about the same as a take-away meal, and at the end of that meal we are happy to part with our cash. Because it costs a bit more to get our furnace/boiler serviced (i.e., $100/200), many of us might shy away from the cost. It usually doesn’t make us feel good—in fact quite the reverse. We will only pay this charge if compelled to do so. We do not like paying our house or car insurance, but do it because we are compelled to. New York has the right idea in that landlords must by law install a CO alarm, and in turn can collect $25 from each tenant to help pay for it. Do yourself a favor. Purchase a recommended CO alarm to protect yourself and your family. Better yet, buy two CO alarms. By its nature CO is colorless, odorless, and has no taste. It does not occur to us that there will ever be a problem. You would not leave small children near a staircase lacking a gate to prevent them from falling.
11.5 THE DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY This department deals with the interests of trade, but also regulates some of the peripheral issues related to CO. One of the main areas of authority regarding CO are the gas supply companies, which until recently was reduced to just one supplier, “British Gas.” British Gas lost its monopoly and now there are many suppliers in the market place. These companies came into being as a result of denationalization, a trend in the United Kingdom. The majority of gas users still use British Gas. Some credit has to be given to British Gas for recent initiatives, but they are not on the whole completely altruistic in their nature. I will paraphrase a conversation that I had with one senior British Gas executive. He said that “if we publicize the fact that gas could be dangerous and that in certain circumstances gas appliances will give off CO, then we denigrate our product.” This is a bit like saying that we should not install seat belts in automobiles because it makes them appear unsafe. From a trade point of view they are missing the point. Their product is not the problem, it is what is done with that product when it leaves the pipeline that is key.
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 281 — #11
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
282
British Gas now sells CO detectors. In fact, they are the biggest UK distributor for the SF-350 CO detector, the best selling unit in Europe. Most of these have been given away with service, which is sold on a commercial basis. British Gas has a large service division that must make a profit. In my opinion, if they played the white knight and told people that there was a major problem, they would be seen as a responsible company with their customer’s interest at heart. They would benefit from their customers coming to them and asking for service. Also, people would in turn buy the CO detectors, and not expect them to be free. The company would not be held up as irresponsible as they are now by some groups for not publicizing the CO danger. In this way, they could benefit financially from making CO a safety and health issue.
11.6 THE HEALTH AND SAFETY EXECUTIVE This department, HSE, is responsible primarily for safety. I recently attended a meeting of their Gas Safety Committee. I had been invited by the head of a leading charity to present my views to the committee. A number of things came up in that meeting that I found astounding and frustrating. The Department had a £100,000 surplus at the end of the financial year which they had to spend quickly, otherwise it would disappear from the following year’s budget. They didn’t ask the charities who endeavor to get the message about the best course of action. They didn’t call on our firm for suggestions. Instead they called CORGI. CORGI is the regulatory body for heating engineers. You cannot work on gas appliances in the United Kingdom unless you are qualified and a member of CORGI. CORGI’s suggestion was to give it to them and they would do a survey; so they did. The HSE could not provide us with a qualitative or quantitative evaluation of what they were going to get for their money. I guess they will get a survey back which will form part of the departments future strategy that says, “CORGI are really good guys and are in the opinion of the people who where surveyed, a top organization?” The HSE Department has tried to develop a cohesive plan to alert people to CO dangers. They have not called on me. I have on occasion called them, but they seem to have no clue as to what is going on in the world outside government. An independent enquiry stated in 2000 that it would be desirable to impose a fuel levy on gas, oil, and coal of about 0.25%, which would be used to fund CO awareness publicity. The HSE has now said that they will not implement the tax after being lobbied hard by the gas companies. They can see this going the way of all taxes, that is, once introduced, the taxes will only go up. Consequently, they don’t want even a small tax that they could absorb. Instead they have said to the HSE, “We have spent £2 million this year on CO awareness.” In actual fact, they had a campaign about service that was high profile, with many UK celebrities in ads. Unfortunately the ads never mentioned CO. The ads were mainly about getting the British public to buy their service—service which I might add, will go on making millions for years because it is annual service. The net effect of this is that less people will be harmed by CO, but don’t for a minute think that they have done it for purely altruistic reasons, they want your buck.
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 282 — #12
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
283
All of these government departments have budgets which in and of themselves are not really that much, maybe a couple hundred thousand pounds each. If however, they combined their resources, they could do some real good. Also, if they had one team looking at this rather than many disparate groups, they would not be duplicating effort and could reduce spending. The effort could also be better coordinated so that we have something tangible to show for it. People would readily be able to see the dangers immediately, not months or years later. People would also be more aware about protecting themselves in the first place. In the last few months I have been to meetings at the House of Lords and subsequently with Lord McKenzie who is tasked with getting all the information on CO together in one place with one agency responsible. It seemed at last that there was some momentum, however that was some months ago and I have heard nothing since. We have created a website brand www.carbonmonoxidekills.com which is well recognized throughout the English-speaking world. Since I am a capitalist, our website is linked to a number of others. I submit that most problems in the world could be resolved by entrepreneur’s looking at them as opportunities to earn revenue. The more money that we make in this venture, the more we are able to plow it into CO awareness. It’s a win-win situation. Also, the more we get out there, the more information that we acquire, the more we can educate people about the issue. Dr. Penney asked me to write this chapter partly because we have a relationship going back a few years. He had kindly agreed to be our online “doctor” some years ago. As such, he responds to enquiries regarding CO from the public. We feel that he is an integral part of our online organization. We also have relationships with law firms who are able to answer legal questions. Therefore, we are able to get the best representation for people who have suffered CO poisoning episodes. As mentioned above, we sell CO detectors through another link on our website, that is, www.carbonmonoxidekills.com. This has been hard work and it has taken a great deal of effort to get where we are. People often contact me, asking how they can set up there own website. They are more than welcome to try, but we are the experts and that is why over the years we have arrived at the position that we hold. To achieve this, you have to get as much information about your subject on the website. That information needs to be updated regularly so that the search engine spiders can recognize new information. This keeps the rankings up. A spider is a computer routine that runs on search engines like Google, Yahoo, and so forth. Working for a high ranking is a bit of a catch 22 situation. Unless you have a good ranking, you can’t get one. Another factor in terms of search engine rankings, is how many other websites link to yours and the type of organizations they are. The best types of organizations are government departments, the next are educational establishments such as universities, and so forth. Media institutions are also good in that they attract lots of visitors on a given subject such as CO that appears in the news. Thus, you will get renewed interest at the time of newsworthy items. One has to be very careful when approaching these kinds of websites. They will not link to you if your information is commercial or inflammatory. Many charities suffer for the latter reason, because they will often hold someone accountable for an incident making them on occasion being seen as biased and having a narrow manifesto. No government department will link to them. It is also sometimes difficult to get
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 283 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
284
a government body—and most educational institutions are government influenced— to link to you unless another government institution has linked first. No one wants to be first to link because they are scared that it will impact their impartiality and position. The first one to come on board is the hardest to get. If I call an institution now and ask them to link to us, they are only too willing because we have 100s of other links. There is now a comfort factor for them. There has not been a willingness in the United Kingdom to grasp the nettle and do something about the issue of CO. Proper unbiased research need to be done, and we need to have a better understanding of the issue. Statistics on CO need to be consistent. Some of the country’s top toxicologists state numbers that differ greatly from the government’s official figures. I mentioned above that most physicians are ill-prepared to diagnose and treat CO poisoning. Moreover, if a physician has not identified the connection to CO, then people may never know that they had CO-exposure. They may have relocated from their house, their job, left home, etc. They may exhibit effects of CO in later life that will never be attributed to CO. Death certificates may not tell the whole story either for very similar reasons. The physician may list just one of the symptoms as the cause of death. The coroner’s office in the United Kingdom is not attached to the Department of Health—it is part of the Home Office. I was amazed to learn that until recently, the job of coroner was a part time job. I am glad to say that we are now going to get a full-time chief coroner. This may clarify the position and he/she will liaise closer with the Health Department. In short, we need to know who and how many people are affected. Only then can the problem be properly addressed. In Paris, France all cadavers are tested for poisoning of all types. As a result, more people are recorded to have died from CO than in all of the United Kingdom. This is probably not because Paris has a worse problem, but just that better monitoring is in place. Take for example the murderer Harold Shipman, who was a UK general practitioner. No one is quite sure how many people he killed. His story has been recognized as one shortcoming of the coroner’s office. As a result, certain remedial measures were suggested. The one I am most interested to see implemented is the checking of all bodies for poisons, including CO, as a matter of course. This could prove a real breakthrough and give us proper statistics so that the problem will be highlighted and solutions found.
11.7 CONCLUSIONS There is much work to be done. Combining the budgets of disparate government departments, along with some coordinated thinking would result in a better understanding. I have offered government departments use of our website facility. If they wish, we are able to run studies and research at little cost through our valued visitor stream. We are very well-placed to be able to assist. While recognized for the efforts that we have made, we are never seen as part of the solution. My ambition is that www.carbonmonoxidekills.com will be the world-wide marketing tool for all CO-related issues. I want to make myself redundant, in as much as
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 284 — #14
Marketing of Carbon Monoxide Information and Alarms in Europe and Beyond
285
we have done the job so well, there is no more need for publicity because the whole world has got the message and deaths and injury from CO are a thing of the past. I would like people to know as much about CO as about meningitis. If the government picked up the ball and ran with it, the issue of CO may actually pay for itself. Get the message out and people will be empowered to protect themselves. People would not be taking up the valuable time of physicians with mysterious illnesses or have to be hospitalized. I make no apologies for the fact that this chapter lacks high academic content. Instead, I hope you will appreciate the journey that we at www.carbonmonoxidekills.com have made over the last few years. We have tried to be the most open information platform possible, and not an exclusive high brow intellectual website that turns visitors off, indeed those that need us most. It has sometimes been tough, and I have thought about giving it up at times. It takes a lot of my time. Then I get an e-mail from a distraught mother, father or other relative or friend, that thanks us for our help and it all seems worthwhile. It is sad to say that unless governments do more, we are the only outlet for some people. I only wish that we could get through to more people, but language barriers make that difficult. It would be difficult for us to translate our website into other languages, such as Chinese. The paradox is that as the markets in the developing world get bigger, it is they who will need it most.
11.8 APPENDIX 2 Carbon Monoxide Headquarters known as COHQ, or “coheadquarters.com,” is one of the oldest carbon monoxide (CO) information sites on the web. It was started in 1996, so is now more than 11 years old. That is very old in terms of the history of the web! Initially COHQ ran on an old Macintosh computer in my research laboratory at the Medical School at Wayne State University in Detroit, MI. It had a long URL because it did not have its own registered domain name. In the late 1990s the website received its own domain name and I migrated it over to a commercial server in Texas. The new URL and the one used today is “coheadquarters.com/CO1.htm.” From a collection of a few dozen linked pages in the early days, COHQ has grown to a site containing hundreds of pages dealing with many subtopics in the field of CO toxicology: chronic CO poisoning, dangers to high risk groups, neuropsychological effects, FAQs, CO alarms/detectors, and so forth. COHQ was begun as a way to provide the public with straightforward, unbiased, information about CO and its effects on humans. It has been my operation from the beginning. With the exception of a few dozen pages written at first by my student Amy Derusha, all of the content, architectural design, art (whether good or bad), and maintenance was been done by me. The website was produced by writing HTML in “text” by hand—it never involved using a web-editor. As crude and lacking in flash as COHQ is, it still comes up in the top 15 sites in doing a Google search using the terms “carbon monoxide poisoning.” The goals of COHQ were: (1) To act as a platform for public information about CO, (2) To act as an educational resource for all viewers, including medical professionals,
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 285 — #15
286
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
(3) To act as a data resource—“look-up” and retrieval of information, and (4) To present new ideas and information at the forefront of research in the field. Like other good expert sites, it (1) Provides reliable, in-depth information in a narrow, defined span of knowledge, (2) Is accessible, understandable, and useful to the lay public as well as professionals in field, (3) Remains current as the field progresses and as viewers needs change, and (4) Is unbiased; that is not supported or influenced by a commercial interest in the field. The web was a very different place a decade ago. The number of websites was miniscule as compared to today. Google was not yet operating. “My Space” was years away. There were search engines running there, but they didn’t have the power and speed of today’s. It is hard to believe that in the middle 1990s it was difficult for us to even find sources of instruction for the HTML language. Much of the early writing was hit or miss—whatever worked was used. The objective of COHQ was never to sell new furnaces, to provide furnace maintenance, and so forth as so many thousands or tens of thousands of websites found by a “carbon monoxide” search pulls up today. I have been accused of using the site as an advertising vehicle. Any good information source, whether a book, storefront, or website inadvertently advertises the author/owner when people go there. Nonetheless, unlike most CO sites, COHQ has no axe to grind. It provides both simple and technical information free about CO to whoever wishes to look at it. The constant theme is public health, for groups and for individuals—educating and protecting people from this age-old poison [see other chapters in this book on misconceptions about CO (Chapter14) and on public perceptions of CO (Chapter15)]. The moto on the home page reads, “CARBON MONOXIDE HEADQUARTERS, (to) provide information, public service, help people, maintain health, save lives.” I was pleased when “carbonmonoxidekills.com” came along in the late 1990s as another major CO information source, in this instance, emanating from the United Kingdom. As you have now read, its major objective is to safe-guard everyone by everyone having CO alarms. Carbonmonoxidekills.com is currently number 1 when the same search noted above for COHQ is run on Google. So I was thrilled some years ago, when Rob Aiers, the owner, asked me to answer questions on CO from his website. I have continued in that role to this day. Thus, it was natural when this book was being planned that I would ask Mr. Aiers to tell us about his experience in developing a very successful website similar to COHQ.
8417: “8417_c011” — 2007/9/21 — 22:04 — page 286 — #16
12
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings Thomas M. Dydek
CONTENTS 12.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2 Signs and Symptoms of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.3 Assessments of Carbon Monoxide Exposure Level and Duration. . . . . . . . 12.3.1 Carboxyhemoglobin Levels as a Measure of Carbon Monoxide Exposure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.3.2 Occupational Exposure Standards for Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . 12.3.3 Community Exposure Standards and Guidelines for Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.3.4 Carbon Monoxide Exposure Duration Assessments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.4 Treatments for Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.5 Other Factors to Consider in Investigations of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.6 Case Study of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.7 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
287 288 289 290 291 291 292 295 296 297 299 300
12.1 INTRODUCTION Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless, tasteless, and potentially toxic gas. These properties have earned it the title of “the silent killer”.1 CO poisoning is responsible for more than one half of the poisoning fatalities reported in this country every year. It is the leading cause of death in industrial accidents as well. Fatalities and CO-related injuries are also common throughout the world. Another factor that makes CO an especially dangerous toxin is that the early symptoms of poisoning are easily confused (and often misdiagnosed) as the onset of a cold or the flu, stomach virus, or other common diseases.2 CO is produced by natural sources and by man-made sources. Natural sources include forest fires, oxidation of nonmethane hydrocarbons, and oxidation of methane. Plants can also emit CO as a metabolic by-product.3 Anthropogenic sources of CO are mostly associated with incomplete combustion of organic materials such as
287
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 287 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
288
gasoline, fuel oil, natural gas, wood, or plastics. Common man-made sources of CO include improperly vented cooking or heating devices, tobacco smoke, agricultural burning, and internal combustion engines. Exposure to CO is one of the chief dangers associated with the fighting of fires in buildings and forest fires. Workers in occupations in which routine exposures to CO occur include truck and bus drivers, mechanics, highway toll takers, garage attendants, and police officers. Everyone who drives a car or truck, especially in areas of congested traffic, has some exposure to CO.4 This chapter covers topics related to the investigation of CO-poisoning events. These investigations can occur in a number of different situations. Oftentimes these investigations are undertaken as part of legal proceedings. Many people have commented that we in the United States today are the most litigious society in the history of the world. While this may be a somewhat dramatic statement, there is a large element of truth in it. Many people in this country feel that pursuing legal remedies for perceived injuries which they believe they have suffered should be a first, rather than a last, resort. Expert witnesses in engineering, industrial hygiene, and toxicology are often called to investigate CO-poisoning incidents and to render opinions about whether or not the CO exposure reported was of at a sufficient level or duration to have caused the health harm alleged. The topics covered in this chapter include signs and symptoms of CO poisoning, exposure level and duration assessments, treatments for CO poisoning, differences in susceptibility between people, how the above factors affect the acute effects of exposure, and the long-term prognosis for CO victims, and other toxic exposures or conditions that mimic CO toxicity (differential analysis). All of these factors are important in the investigation of CO poisonings.
12.2 SIGNS AND SYMPTOMS OF CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING CO poisoning results in a decreased level of oxygen in the body. The brain and other parts of the central nervous system are the areas of the body which are among the most sensitive to oxygen lack.5 When oxygen levels in tissues fall, aerobic metabolism decreases and lactic acid accumulates. Neurons begin to break down, leading to cell death and brain damage.6 The longer the brain is deprived of adequate oxygen, the more widespread the damage will be. Similar effects occur in muscle tissues deprived of oxygen. This is of special concern when the muscle involved is in the heart. For many years most toxicologists believed that COs toxicity was fully explained by this hypoxic effect. More recent research has shown, however, that CO exerts direct toxic effects by inhibiting the activity of cytochrome a3 oxidase and by causing lipid peroxidation. These latter findings help to explain the clinical experience that carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) levels (an indicator of the risk of tissue hypoxia) are a very poor predictor of a patient’s medical condition and his or her prognosis.2,5,7
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 288 — #2
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
289
The acute symptoms seen with CO-poisoning depend on the concentration of CO and the duration of the exposure. At low levels of exposure there may be subtle changes in time discrimination, visual vigilance, and choice response. Exposure to higher levels will aggravate preexisting angina pectoris. Symptoms seen in people with higher level CO exposure include severe headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, mental confusion, visual disturbances, reddening of the skin (not always), compartment syndrome, loss of muscle tissue, fatigue, hypotension, and coma. Severe exposure can of course be fatal.8 The COHb levels measured in the CO-poisoned patient are sometimes used to classify CO exposures in terms of mild, moderate, or severe poisonings. In this system, COHb levels of less than 30% are termed “mild” poisonings. “Moderate” poisonings are those in which the victim has a COHb level of from 30% to 40% and “severe” poisonings occur when COHb levels are greater than 40% . This construct, while sometimes useful at a simplistic level,7 should be used with great caution since other signs and symptoms are known to be far more important in determining how and when to treat a patient poisoned by CO. Depending on the level and duration of CO exposure, delayed or prolonged symptoms can also occur in CO-exposed individuals. Some of these effects can be severe and can last for years. These symptoms can include sleep disturbances, vision problems, hearing loss, tinnitus, peripheral neuropath, mental deficits, memory problems, and difficulty concentrating, to name but a few. While there is often some recovery of mental function in CO poisoned individuals over time, many brain tissues damaged by CO show little, if any capability for regeneration. Similarly, the neurological or other damage done in cases of compartment syndrome is not generally reversible. Therefore, many of the chronic medical conditions brought on by severe CO poisonings are likely to be permanent.5,9,10
12.3 ASSESSMENTS OF CARBON MONOXIDE EXPOSURE LEVEL AND DURATION In any poisoning case the investigator must try to determine the amount of exposure an individual has had. The cornerstone of toxicology is the “dose makes the poison.” Knowledge of the “dose” as reflected by the exposure a person has experienced helps to assess the potential for adverse health effects the person may exhibit, guides treatment that the individual will require, assists in assessing the patient’s follow-up care needs, and determines his/her prognosis. In the legal arena, a large part of job of the expert witness as a poisoning incident investigator is to determine what the exposure level was. Exposure assessments are also required in the workplace to ascertain whether or not occupational exposure standards were exceeded. Community exposure standards and guidelines have also been established by federal and state environmental agencies and by private organizations. Monitoring ambient air levels of CO and keeping outdoor CO levels below applicable standards and guidelines is one of the jobs of federal and state air pollution control agencies.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 289 — #3
290
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
12.3.1 CARBOXYHEMOGLOBIN LEVELS AS A MEASURE OF CARBON MONOXIDE EXPOSURE When measurements of the CO level in the air have not been made or if made are not representative of the actual CO exposure levels a poisoning victim has experienced, other methods have been used to estimate CO exposure levels. One such method is to rely on COHb levels in the victim’s blood. When CO is inhaled, it is readily absorbed into the blood. Once there, the vast majority of the CO binds to hemoglobin in the erythrocytes to form COHb. CO binds to hemoglobin with an affinity more than 200 times that of oxygen. Thus CO displaces the oxygen from the hemoglobin, impairing oxygen delivery to critical body tissues such as the central nervous system, heart, and other organs.5 COHb levels in people exposed to CO reach a peak or plateau if the exposure lasts for 5–10 h. Further exposure to CO will not increase the COHb saturation of the hemoglobin if the air CO concentration remains constant. This is referred to as the “equilibrium” (or steady-state) COHb level. Estimates have been made as to what COHb level will be reached on the basis of concentration of CO in the air to which a person is exposed. For example, a person exposed to 30 ppm CO for an extended period of time will eventually have about 5% of their hemoglobin as COHb. An exposure to 100 ppm CO will yield an equilibrium COHb level of 20%. Exposures to 600 ppm gives a COHb level of more than 50%.11 In the latter case 50% of the hemoglobin is in the “carboxy” form. Whether more subtle toxic effects occur after this “plateau” COHb level is attained is the object of ongoing research. Various investigators have attempted to correlate health effects with COHb level. Such data nearly always show a huge variability, presumably because it is not just the effect of CO on hemoglobin that is important, but also the effects of CO on tissue and cells (e.g., on the cytochromes) and the effects of lipid peroxidation. Some studies have shown decreased vigilance in subjects with only 2–3% COHb.12,13 Others have shown no effects on vigilance or other health endpoints at COHb levels up to 12.6%.14−27 Conversely, there are studies that showed effects in addition to decreased vigilance at relatively low (less than 13%) COHb levels. These effects included small changes in the electrocardiogram, increased minute volume, reduction in exercise stamina, driving skill deficit, increased heart rate, visual sensitivity decrement, fatigue, and increased reaction time.28−41 Mild headaches are reported in people with COHb levels of 13–20%,16 but other effects have not generally been reported until COHb levels exceed about 30%.31,42−49 Symptoms seen at COHb levels of from 30% to 40% have been associated with severe headache, dizziness, difficulty concentrating, nausea, vomiting, polycythemia, and loss of consciousness.50,51 Subjects with COHb levels from 40% to 45% were unable to perform any tasks requiring even minimal physical exertion.52 Coma and convulsions usually occur at COHb levels of 50–60%, or below.51 Acute COHb levels near 70% are almost always lethal. Note that the median COHb saturation of people dead from CO-poisoning is near 53%. While such crude relationships between COHb levels and health effects may serve as a general guide, the toxicologist must be cognizant of the fact that different individuals are affected differently by CO. This issue is discussed more fully below.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 290 — #4
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
291
12.3.2 OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE STANDARDS FOR CARBON MONOXIDE Many CO exposures (and poisonings) occur in occupational settings. There are two main types of occupational exposures to CO: accidental exposures and routine exposures. In the case of accidental poisonings, the challenge for the investigator (who is usually not present at the accident itself) is to determine what the exposure levels might have been. It is rare for there to be air quality measurements in such situations and the actions of emergency response personnel may complicate the exposure level assessment. Obviously, the first duty of safety personnel is to assist the CO-poisoning victim. In this effort, first responders may open doors or windows or turn on fans or institute other ventilation efforts before they take measurements of ambient CO levels. Measurements made after ventilation has taken place will be lower that those responsible for the poisoning. CO levels during routine industrial operations are easier to obtain and interpret. Airborne CO levels are routinely monitored in some industrial settings, but in some cases where CO intoxication is suspected, monitoring may not be available. A typical function of the occupational safety investigator is to go to the place of business in question and to obtain CO levels in the air under normal plant operating conditions. These measured CO levels can then be compared to the existing occupation exposure standards. Occupational exposure standards have been set to protect worker’s health. There are three major types of occupational exposure standards and guidelines for CO in this country. The current Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) standard (which carries the force of law) is an 8-h average of 50 ppm. The National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) recommended standard is an 8-h average of 35 ppm.53 The American Conference of Governmental and Industrial Hygienists threshold limit value (TLV) over 8 h is 25 ppm.54 OSHA originally proposed lowering their standard to that recommended by NIOSH, but this rule was remanded by the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.55 These occupational standards and guideline limits were supposedly set to protect against adverse cardiovascular, respiratory, and neurobehavioral effects. These limits were set to also be protective of pregnant workers and their unborn children, and other workers at high risk, although whether this is actually true is open to question. NIOSH has also established a “ceiling” exposure limit for CO of 200 ppm. This level is not to be exceeded at any time during a working day. The “Immediately Dangerous to Life and Health” (IDLH) for CO is 1200 ppm. Exposure to levels of CO greater than the IDLH “is likely to cause death or immediate or delayed permanent adverse health effects or prevent escape from such an environment.”53
12.3.3 COMMUNITY EXPOSURE STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES FOR CARBON MONOXIDE Air pollution investigators are often called upon to access the levels of CO in community air. CO levels are typically highest near highways or major industrial facilities having combustion sources. As in the case of the industrial environment,
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 291 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
292
there are methods available to measure the levels of CO in community air. These measured levels can then be compared to air quality standards or guidelines set by federal or state agencies or by other organizations. A variety of community exposure guidelines have been set up to protect public health from air pollutants, including CO. Table 12.1 summarizes the current community exposure standards and guidelines for this chemical. The agencies and organizations that have set community exposure limits for CO include the American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA),56 the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),57 and the California Air Resources Board (CARB).58,59 Like the occupational exposure standards mentioned in the previous section, these limits have been set to protect members of the general population from the adverse effects of CO exposure.60 Since these standards and guidelines are subject to change, the reader is urged to consult with the agency or organization involved to get the most current exposure levels of interest.
12.3.4 CARBON MONOXIDE EXPOSURE DURATION ASSESSMENTS As mentioned briefly above, the CO exposure duration as well as the exposure level has to be considered in investigations of CO poisonings. In occupational and in some nonoccupational settings, the frequency of exposure is also important. One general rule in toxicology that reflects the importance of both exposure level and duration is referred to as Haber’s Law or Haber’s Rule. This rule can be stated as follows: C×t =k where C is the toxicant concentration or exposure level, t is the time of exposure, and k is a constant reflecting the severity of the toxic effect. For example, if a toxic substance obeys Haber’s Law, a 30 min exposure to 100 ppm of the chemical should give a similar level of toxic effect that a 60 min exposure to 50 ppm would (30 min × 100 ppm = 3000 ppm-min = 60 min × 50 ppm).61 The formation of COHb in CO-poisoned people does not seem to follow Haber’s Law. Data from research studies and from clinical experience is summarized in Table 12.2.62 Three different ranges of COHb levels are shown below: 2.0–2.7%, 7.0–8.5%, and 11.0–12.6%. These data show that the product of CO exposure level and exposure duration is in no way indicative of COHb levels. This may be partially explained by the fact that COHb levels reach an equilibrium concentration at some point in time and do not increase even when exposure duration does. If C remains constant and t is increasing, k, the COHb level in this case will not increase. The deviation from Haber’s Law may also explained by the fact that responses to CO exposures are highly variable from one individual to another. In any case, the duration of exposure is important to the CO investigator. Unless CO levels are very high, an exposure of a few minutes will rarely if ever cause adverse effects. On the other hand, long-term exposures to quite low levels of CO for extended periods of time (months to years) can lead to serious health consequences.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 292 — #6
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
293
TABLE 12.1 Summary of Existing Community Air Quality Standards and Guidelines Agency or Organization AIHA AIHA AIHA AIHA AIHA AIHA AIHA EPA EPA CARB CARB CARB
Type of Standard TEEL-0 TEEL-1 TEEL-2 TEEL-3 ERPG-1 ERPG-2 ERPG-3 NAAQS-1 NAAQS-2 AQS-1 AQS-2 REL
Carbon Monoxide Level (ppm) 50 83 83 330 200 350 500 35 9 0.25 0.04 20
Averaging Time 15 min 15 min 15 min 15 min 1h 1h 1h 1h 8h 1h 24 h 1h
The AIHA is the American Industrial Hygiene Association. The EPA is the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The CARB is the California Air Resources Board. TEEL-0, the threshold concentration below which most people will experience no appreciable risk of health effects. TEEL-1, the maximum concentration in air below which it is believed nearly all individuals could be exposed without experiencing other than mild transient adverse health effects or perceiving a clearly defined objectionable odor. TEEL-2, the maximum concentration in air below which it is believed nearly all individuals could be exposed without experiencing or developing irreversible or other serious health effects or symptoms that could impair their abilities to take protective action. TEEL-3, the maximum concentration in air below which it is believed nearly all individuals could be exposed without experiencing or developing life-threatening health effects. ERPG-1, the maximum concentration in air below which it is believed nearly all individuals could be exposed for up to 1 h without experiencing other than mild transient adverse health effects or perceiving a clearly defined objectionable odor. ERPG-2, the maximum concentration in air below which it is believed nearly all individuals could be exposed for up to 1 h without experiencing or developing irreversible or other serious health effects or symptoms that could impair their abilities to take protective action. ERPG-3, the maximum concentration in air below which it is believed nearly all individuals could be exposed for up to 1 h without experiencing or developing life-threatening health effects. NAAQS-1, the 1-h average National Ambient Air Quality Standard as established by the US EPA. NAAQS-2, the 8-h average National Ambient Air Quality Standard as established by the US EPA. AQS-1, the 1-h average air quality standard as established by the CARB. AQS-2, the 8-h average air quality standard as established by the CARB. REL, the Reference Exposure Level as established by the CARB. RELs are levels at or below which even the most sensitive members of the community would not suffer any adverse health effects.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 293 — #7
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
294
TABLE 12.2 Carboxyhemoglobin Levels for Different Carbon Monoxide Exposure Levels and Durations CO Exposure Level (C in ppm) 50 12 50 100 50 650 75 100 200
Exposure Duration (t in h) 1.33 192 0.42 2.5 192 0.75 168 8.0 2.67
COHb Level (%)
C × t (ppm-h)
2.0 2.4 2.7 7.0 7.1 8.5 11.0 12.0 12.6
67 2304 21 250 9600 488 12600 800 534
Another factor that comes into play in evaluating a person’s risk of CO exposure is the frequency of exposure as compared to the half-life of CO excretion in the body. For example, in the occupational world, workers normally work 8 h shifts. Unless a worker has significant CO exposures outside of the work place (a possibility, especially if the worker has a long daily commute through heavy traffic) he or she will have 16 h away from work to recover from CO exposure on the job. If a person takes in CO more quickly than it can be eliminated from the body, elevated COHb will tend to persist during off-work times. The half-life (expressed in units of time) of an exogenous chemical in an organism is the time it takes for a given level of that chemical to be reduced by one-half. In two half-lives, the chemical level would be 25% of the original level, after three half-lives, it would be 12.5%, and so on. In CO poisonings, it is sometimes useful to know what initial COHb level in a particular individual. This can be done if the COHb level is measured a short time after the CO-poisoning, and then back-calculating to get the initial level known at to , based on how many COHb half-lives have transpired. The half-life for COHb of a person breathing ambient or room air is roughly 4–5 h.63 Next consider the previously mentioned example of a worker exposed for 8 h on the job and then having little or no CO exposure for the following 16 h. Sixteen hours is approximately four half-lives for COHb for people breathing ambient air. After four half-lives have passed, COHb levels should be reduced by 94%. While this is a large reduction, it should be pointed out that the COHb levels would not return to the baseline levels before the worker went back to work the next day, again to be exposed to CO. On the second day of exposure the COHb level would start at a higher baseline and would then reach a higher level than reached on the first day. The intervening 16 h “rest” periods would decrease the COHb levels by 94% each day, but there would be some accumulation over the work week. Fortunately, the 63 h between 5:00 p.m. Friday afternoon and 8:00 a.m. Monday morning affords almost 16 half-lives, during which the COHb level would be reduced to less than 0.002% of the level on Friday afternoon.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 294 — #8
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
295
12.4 TREATMENTS FOR CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING Medical treatments administered to CO-poisoned patients are designed to reverse the effects that CO has on the body; namely, the effects on the blood oxygen carrying capacity, the binding to myoglobin in muscle, the interference CO exerts on the cytochrome oxidase system, effects on lipid peroxidation in the brain and other tissues, and so forth. The type of treatment provided can influence the investigator’s conclusions concerning the nature and extent of the damage caused by CO poisoning. Emergency medical technicians (EMTs) and other “first responders” are trained to administer 100% oxygen to people they suspect have been poisoned by CO. This treatment has the effect of reducing the COHb levels in the patient’s blood at a faster rate than would be expected without such treatment. As mentioned earlier, the halflife of COHb without supplemental oxygen is 4–5 h. The half-life of COHb in patients breathing 100% oxygen centers around 60–80 min.63,64 Oxygen treatment functions to promote the dissociation of COHb65 and to reduce tissue hypoxia. A more controversial treatment regime for the CO-poisoning victim is hyperbaric oxygen treatment (HBOT). See in-depth discussions of this treatment modality elsewhere in this book. HBOT is accomplished by placing the patient in a large sealed chamber, giving the patient 100% oxygen, and gradually increasing the pressure inside to levels several times greater than of atmospheric. It is clear is that HBOT can greatly decrease the half-life of COHb—to roughly 20–30 min.63,65,66 HBOT has also been shown to promote CO dissociation from cytochrome a3 oxidase in animal studies and to reduce brain lipid peroxidation.65 The efficacy of HBOT in humans has not been conclusive. Some studies have shown marked reductions in the number and severity of both acute symptoms and the incidence of delayed neuropsychological sequelae.67,68 Other investigators have reported either no advantage to HBOT69 or have even found that HBOT worsened the patient’s condition.70 One explanation for these conflicting findings, besides the variability in susceptibility expected in those CO-poisoned, is that the groups of patients studied came from a wide variety of CO poisoning situations. Some HBOT was done at less than the optimal pressures of from 2.5 to 3.0 atm., while in other studies there had been a delay in initiating the HBOT. Some groups of CO-poisoned individuals studied, included individuals who had lost consciousness, while others did not and some studies had flaws in design and execution.5,65,71 The current consensus seems to be that HBOT should be applied selectively. There are risks of side-effects to this treatment and the transport of critically injured patients to the nearest HBOT center also poses risks. HBOT may not be the best approach for all patients. HBOT is more likely to have benefits outweighing its risks for patients having one or more of the following characteristics: 1. Severe intoxication as evidenced by coma, seizures, focal neurological deficits or cardiac effects65 2. Those who can be given HBOT within 6 h of the poisoning event67
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 295 — #9
296
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
3. Those presenting with COHb levels in excess of 25%.5,71 4. Some studies suggest that patients with less severe CO poisoning may do just as well after normobaric treatment (i.e., sea level) with 100% oxygen.66
12.5 OTHER FACTORS TO CONSIDER IN INVESTIGATIONS OF CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING The investigator of CO-poisoning events needs to be aware of other causes of the symptoms that are associated with overexposure to CO. The process by which other causes are dealt with is called the “differential diagnosis.” Other conditions that can have symptoms in common with CO poisoning include viral infections, food poisoning, depression, anxiety, transient ischemic attacks, coronary artery disease, cardiac arrythmias, Parkinson’s disease, meningitis or encephalitis, epilepsy, migraine, drug overdose, ethanol intoxication, pneumonia, and sinusitis.10,65 Clues exist by which to discern whether the case being investigated is actually a CO-poisoning case. For example, if all of the occupants of a residence or business establishment are affected, many of the above alternate explanations can be eliminated. If symptoms improve when the victims depart the site, this usually points the finger at suspected site as the likely culprit. Indications of incomplete combustion, such as yellow flames on gas appliances or heaters provide an indication that CO exposure is possible/likely.70 In the occupational environment, CO exposures can occur wherever there is a source of combustion. Some examples include propane or gasoline powered forklifts (i.e., hi-lows, lift trucks), generators, bobcats, scissor lifts, cherry pickers, concrete saws and chain saws, floor strippers and polishers, and so forth. The toxicity of CO is enhanced at high altitudes, at elevated temperatures, and in people having increased ventilation or metabolic rates. The human fetus is at particularly high risk from CO poisoning because of its normal development in a somewhat oxygen-deprived environment. Children are at higher risk of CO poisoning because they generally have higher metabolic rates than adults. People with preexisting diseases such as anemia, cardiovascular, or cerebral vascular disease, hypovolemia, or those with increased endogenous CO production are also at higher risk of adverse effects from CO exposure.10 Exposures to some other chemicals either in the home or in the workplace can mimic CO exposures and are easy to confuse with those exposures. For example, exposure to methylene chloride (i.e., dichloromethane) can cause the same types of effects as exposure to CO. This is because methylene chloride is metabolized to CO and carbon dioxide in the body. An 8-h exposure to 150 ppm of methylene chloride produces the same elevated carboxyhemoglobin level that a 35 ppm exposure to CO would produce over the same time period. While causing less of an effect per ppm of exposure, it has been found that the half-life of methylene chloride-induced COHb is greater than that of CO-induced COHb, so effects may last for longer periods of time.7 Exposure to cyanide can mimic CO intoxication, mainly because cyanide also disrupts the functioning of cytochrome a3 oxidase.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 296 — #10
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
297
12.6 CASE STUDY OF CARBON MONOXIDE POISONING The following is an account of an actual case in which three individuals were severely poisoned by CO. This particular situation involved a faulty swimming pool heater at a hotel. Malfunctions of heaters are a common cause of CO-related poisonings and fatalities. The names of the victims, the other individuals involved in this incident, and the name of the hotel have been omitted to maintain privacy. The three individuals involved were staying at a hotel near Denver, Colorado. Victim #1 went jogging the evening of October 31 and returned to his room at about 7:00 p.m. He soon felt ill and probably passed out around 8:00 p.m. that evening. Housekeeping staff entered his room the next morning at 8:20 a.m., but seeing him on the bed, assumed he was just sleeping soundly and left the room. A colleague of Victim #1 who was staying at another hotel called Victim #1’s hotel at 9:45 a.m. on November 1 and asked the desk clerk on duty to check on his friend. The clerk went to Victim #1’s room, knocked on the door, but did not enter. He stated that it was against hotel policy to enter a room unless the guest gave them authorization to do so. Later that morning after repeated calls from the colleague, the hotel staff did enter Victim #1’s room. Hotel records show that Victim #1’s door was opened at 11:04 a.m. and 11:15 a.m. by the desk clerk trying unsuccessfully to rouse him. The colleague finally came to the hotel to check on Victim #1 at about 11:30 a.m. and went to his room. Finding him unconscious, the colleague asked the desk clerk to call 911 and to summon emergency medical personnel. Victim #1 was finally removed from the room at about 11:55 a.m. Victim #1 therefore had an approximately 17-h exposure to CO. In this case the duration of exposure could be obtained from what is known as an “audit trail.” At some hotels each time the card key is used to open the door, the time and whose card was used (guest, housekeeping, desk clerks, etc.) is recorded on the hotel computer. This victim suffered severe brain damage. Victim #2 has stated that she got into her room at the hotel at about 5:00 p.m. on October 31. After 15–20 min she felt confused and nauseated. Maids working at the hotel entered her room at about 8:30 a.m. the next day and found her passed out on the floor and thought that she had had too much to drink (example of a “misdiagnosis”). Upon reporting this to the hotel management, the maids apparently were told to leave Victim #2 alone. Nothing was done to aid her until the emergency personnel (who had been summoned to assist Victim #1) arrived and removed her from her room just before noon. She was therefore exposed to the CO for a total of about 19 h. This victim incurred cognitive deficits and had to have a leg amputated because of compartment syndrome she suffered caused by the CO exposure. Victim #3 entered her room at about 5:00 p.m. on October 31. She believed she passed out by about 6:00 p.m. Victim #3 awoke at about 6:30 a.m. the next morning, showered, got dressed, and passed out again. She called some friends to come and get her at about 8:00 a.m. Sometime shortly thereafter, she also called the front desk to let them know she had vomited and that the carpet needed to be cleaned. Her friends arrived at about 9:00 a.m. and seeing her condition took her to the hospital. Therefore, she was in her room and exposed to the CO for about 15.5 h. Her outcome involved limited neuropsychological deficits.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 297 — #11
298
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
Blood tests done after these three victims reached the hospital showed that each had elevated COHb levels. This confirmed that they had been exposed to CO. All three people were diagnosed by physicians at the hospitals as having CO-poisoning. Their symptoms at the emergency room (ER) included severe headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, reddening of the skin, compartment syndrome, loss of muscle tissue, fatigue, hypotension, and coma. These are consistent with what would be expected from CO exposures. In addition, all three victims suffered ongoing health damage involving sleep disturbance, vision problems, hearing loss, tinnitus, peripheral neuropathy, mental deficits, memory problems, and difficulty concentrating. During their investigations of this incident, local fire department personnel measured CO concentrations in the rooms occupied by the three individuals. They were all in excess of 200 ppm. These readings were taken after the doors to the rooms had been opened and some ventilation of these rooms had occurred. Because of this, the CO levels to which the victims were exposed would certainly have been higher than that recorded by the fire department. The source of the CO was traced to the swimming pool heater in the hotel. CO levels in this mechanical room were found to be “extremely high” according to fire department personnel. Police investigating this incident looked for, but did not find any evidence of the presence of drugs, drug paraphernalia, or alcohol in the Plaintiffs’ hotel rooms. Furthermore, there was no evidence of any violence or trauma to the victims. Victim #1 suffered occasional headaches and visual problems prior to the incident, but these became much worse afterwards. Otherwise, the Plaintiffs’individual medical histories prior to this incident were unremarkable. Thus, it was possible to rule out other possible causes for the victims’ adverse health effects. The conclusion reached in this CO-poisoning investigation was that the adverse health effects suffered by the victims were caused by their exposures to CO at the hotel. The bases for this conclusion are as follows: 1. Elevated levels of CO in excess of 200 ppm were found in the hotel rooms occupied by the individuals even after some ventilation of these rooms had occurred 2. The victims were exposed to high levels of CO for periods of time ranging from 15.5 to 19 h 3. The presence of elevated levels of COHb in the blood of these three individuals confirms that they did sustain an exposure to CO 4. Both the acute and the long-term symptoms exhibited by the three victims were entirely consistent with those associated with an overexposure to CO 5. Finally, the three victims in this case had no significant medical or psychiatric conditions or problems prior to the incident, and no other likely explanations could be found for the health harm suffered by the individuals. Another conclusion was that the victims’ injuries would have been less severe if they had been removed from their hotel rooms earlier. The housekeeping staff went into each of the three victims’ rooms at about 8:30 a.m. on November 1. Although the first two victims were found unconscious at that time, they were not taken out of their rooms until about noon. This resulted in each of them sustaining an extra three and
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 298 — #12
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
299
one-half hours of CO exposure. The odds of more serious injuries go up with each additional hour of exposure. Victim #3 was fortunate to have been able to summon aid on her own. Notably, she suffered fewer and less severe effects than the other two individuals who had 2–3 h more exposure to CO at the hotel. The basis for this finding is that neurological damage from CO poisoning is progressive. It becomes more severe the longer tissues are without adequate oxygen as explained above. If Victim #1 had been taken out of his room earlier and had received medical treatment sooner, he would have probably suffered less severe brain damage. If Victim #2 had been rescued earlier, she may not have suffered such a severe injury to her leg. Victim #3’s continuing injuries (problems with memory loss and other mental deficits), while not as great as those suffered by the other two victims, would most likely not have been as severe or taken as long to overcome had she been able to get to the hospital sooner.
12.7 SUMMARY CO poisoning is a leading cause of accidental injuries and fatalities in this country and throughout the world. Exposures to CO are possible wherever there is a source of combustion; for example, heating systems, fires, petroleum product fueled vehicles, and industrial equipment, to name a few. This chapter has been an overview of how investigations of CO-poisoning incidents are carried out and the types of information required in such investigations. Investigations include evaluations of the signs and symptoms of the intoxication, assessments of exposure level and duration, reviewing the medical treatments that may have been administered, and the ruling out of other factors that may have caused the poisoning. The investigator first of all should be familiar with the signs and symptoms of CO poisoning. Many of the symptoms are common to other conditions such as viral infections, alcohol intoxication, coronary disease, and other disease states. This can complicate a positive determination of CO’s involvement. Other chemicals can cause similar symptoms and should be also investigated as possible causes. It is crucial in an investigation of CO poisonings to determine how great a “dose” of CO the victim received. This may be done using CO measurement instruments, or by determining COHb levels subsequent to the poisoning incident. Measured airborne CO levels can be compared to occupational and community exposure standards and guidelines, to assess health risk in more routine human exposure scenarios. The medical treatment that an individual received can influence the investigation of CO poisonings. Whether a victim received no supplemental oxygen, was given 100% oxygen to breathe, or had HBOT, will influence the immediate health condition and the long-term prognosis for that individual. CO poisonings have occurred for tens of thousands of years, and probably even before humans inhabited the earth (from volcanic activity, forest fires, etc.). The advent of man’s use of controlled fires for warmth and cooking no doubt signaled a sharp rise in the risk and incidence of CO poisonings. Even with all of the technological advances that have been made over the millennia, CO poisoning is still common
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 299 — #13
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
300
and continues to be a major threat to public health. One objective of this chapter is to assist those who are involved in investigations of CO poisoning. This chapter and the others in this book also serve to raise awareness of this threat and to hopefully reduce the number of CO poisonings.
References 1. Shephard, R.J. Carbon Monoxide, The Silent Killer, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, Springfield, Illinois, 1983. 2. Kindwall, E.P. Carbon monoxide, In: Occupational Medicine, 3rd ed., Zenz, C., Dickerson, O.B., and Horvath, E.P., eds., Mosby, St. Louis, 1994, Chapter 29. 3. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide, USEPA Publication No. EPA 600/P-99/001F, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC., 2000. 4. Lipsett, M.J., Shusterman, D.J., and Beard, R.R. Inorganic compounds of carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen, In: Patty’s Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology, 4th ed., Vol. II, Part F, Clayton, G.D., and Clayton, F.E., eds., John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1994, pp. 4523–4552. 5. Tomaszewski, C. Carbon monoxide, In: Goldfrank’s Toxicological Emergencies, 6th ed., Goldfrank, L.R., et al., eds., Appleton & Lange, Stamford, Connecticut, 1998, pp. 1551–1563. 6. Victor, M., and Adams, R.D. Metabolic Diseases of the Nervous System, In: Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine, 9th ed., McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1980, pp. 1978–1979. 7. Hathaway, G.J., Proctor, N.H., and Hughes, J.P. Carbon monoxide, In: Proctor and Hughes’ Chemical Hazards of the Workplace, 4th ed., Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1996, pp. 113–116. 8. Smith, R.P. Toxic responses of the blood, In: Casarett and Doull’s Toxicology, The Basic Science of Poisons, 5th ed., Klaassen, C.D., Amdur, M.O., and Doull, J., eds., McGraw-Hill, New York, 1996, Chapter 11, pp. 343–344. 9. Smith, J.S., and Brandon, S. Morbidity from acute carbon monoxide poisoning at three-year follow-up, Br. Med. J. 1, 318, 1973. 10. Respiratory Toxicology, In: Ellenhorn’s Medical Toxicology, 2nd ed., Ellenhorn, M.J., et al., eds., Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, pp. 1465–1476, 1997. 11. Seinfeld, J.H. Air Pollution, Physical and Chemical Fundamentals, McGraw Hill Book Company, New York, 1975, pp. 22. 12. Fodor, C.G., and Winneke, C. Effect of Low CO concentrations on resistance to monotony and on psychomotor capacity, Staub-Reinhalt Luft, 32, 46, 1972. 13. Beard, R.R., and Grandstaff, N.W. Carbon monoxide and human functions, In: Environmental Science Research, Vol. 5, Behavioral Toxicology, B. Weiss and V.G. Laties, eds. New York, Plenum Press, 1975,pp. 1–27. 14. Sievers, R.F., Edwards, T.I., and Murray, A.L. A Medical Study of Men Exposed to Measured Amounts of Carbon monoxide in the Holland Tunnel for 13 Years, Public Health Bulletin No. 278, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC., 1942. 15. Mikulka, P.R., et al. The effect of carbon monoxide on human performance, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 174, 409, 1970. 16. Stewart, R.D., et al. Experimental human exposure to carbon monoxide, Arch. Environ. Health 21, 154, 1970.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 300 — #14
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
301
17. Horvath, S.M., Dahms, T.E., and O’Hanlon, J.F. Carbon monoxide and human vigilance, a deleterious effect of present urban concentrations, Arch. Environ. Health 23, 343, 1971. 18. O’Donnell, R.D., et al. Low level carbon monoxide exposure and human psychomotor performance, Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 18, 583, 1971. 19. Raven, P.B., et al. Effect of carbon monoxide and peroxyacetyl nitrate on man’s maximal aerobic capacity, J. Appl. Physiol. 36, 288, 1974. 20. Ettema, J.H., et al. Effects of alcohol, carbon monoxide and trichloroethylene exposure on mental capacity, Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 35, 117, 1975. 21. O’Hanlon, J.F. Preliminary studies of the effects of carbon monoxide on vigilance in man, In: Behavioral Toxicology, Weiss, B., and Laties, G., eds., Plenum Press, New York, 1975, pp. 61–75. 22. Benignus, V.A., et al. Lack of effects of carbon monoxide on human vigilance, Perception and Motor Skills. 45(3, Pt 1), pp. 1007–1014, 1977. 23. Luria, S.M., and McKay, C.L. Effects of low levels of carbon monoxide on vision of smokers and nonsmokers, Arch. Environ. Health 34, 38, 1979. 24. Davies, D.M., et al. The effects of continuous exposure to carbon monoxide on auditory vigilance in man, Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 48, 25, 1981. 25. DeLucia, A.J., Whitaker, J.H., and Bryant, L.R. Effects of combined exposure to ozone and carbon monoxide (CO) in humans, In: Advances in Modern Environmental Toxicology, Vol. 5, Lee, S.D., Mustafa, C.G., and Mehlman, M.A., eds., Princeton Scientific Publishers, Princeton, N.J., 1983, pp. 145–159. 26. Mihevic, P.M., Gliner, J.A., and Horvath, S.M. Carbon monoxide exposure and information processing during perceptual-motor performance, Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 51, 355, 1983. 27. Benignus, V.A., et al. Effect of low level carbon monoxide on compensatory tracking and event monitoring, Neurotoxicol. Teratol. 9, 227, 1987. 28. McFarland, R.A., et al. The effects of carbon monoxide and altitude on visual thresholds, J. Aviat. Med. 15, 381, 1944. 29. Ray, A.M., and Rockwell, T.H. An exploratory study of automobile driving performance under the influence of low levels of carboxyhemoglobin, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 174, 396, 1970. 30. Bender, W., Goethert, M., and Malorny, G. Effect of low carbon monoxide concentrations on psychological functions, Staub-Reinhalt Luft, 32, 54, 1972. 31. Ekblom, B. and Huot, R. Response to submaximal and maximal exercise at different levels of carboxyhemoglobin, Acta. Physiol. Scand. 86, 474, 1972. 32. McFarland, R. Low-level exposure to carbon monoxide and driving performance, Arch. Env. Health 27, 355, 1973. 33. Ramsey, J.M. Effects of single exposures of carbon monoxide on sensory and psychomotor response, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 34, 212, 1973. 34. Wright, G., Randell, P., and Shephard, R.J. Carbon monoxide and driving skills, Arch. Env. Health 27, 349, 1973. 35. Drinkwater, B.L., et al. Air pollution, exercise, and heat stress, Arch. Env. Health. 28, 177, 1974. 36. Gliner, J.A., et al. Man’s physiologic response to long-term work during thermal and pollutant stress, J. Appl. Physiol. 39, 628, 1975. 37. Horvath, S.M., et al. Maximal aerobic capacity at different levels of carboxyhemoglobin, J. Appl. Physiol. 38, 300, 1975.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 301 — #15
302
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning 38. Putz, V.R., Johnson, B.L., and Setzer, J.V. Effects of CO on Vigilance Performance. Effects of Low-Level Carbon monoxide on Divided Attention, Pitch Discrimination, and the Auditory Evoked Potential, Publication Number DHEW (NIOSH) 77–124, U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati, Ohio, 1976. 39. Putz, V.R., Johnson, B.L., and Setzer, J.V. A comparative study of the effects of carbon monoxide and methylene chloride on human performance, J. Env. Pathol. Toxicol. 2, 97, 1979. 40. Davies, D.M. and Smith, D.J. Electrocardiographic changes in healthy men during continuous low-level carbon monoxide exposure, Env. Res. 21, 197, 1980. 41. Bunnell, D.E. and Horvath, S.M. Interactive effects of heat, physical work and CO exposure on metabolism and cognitive task performance, Aviat. Space Env. Med. 60, 428, 1989. 42. Chevalier, R.B., Krumholz, R.A., and Ross, J.C. Reaction of non-smokers to carbon monoxide inhalation, cardiopulmonary responses at rest and during exercise, JAMA. 198, 1061, 1966. 43. Pirnay, F., et al. Muscular exercise during intoxication by carbon monoxide, J. Appl. Physiol. 31, 573, 1971. 44. Vogel, J.A. and Gleser, M.A. Effect of carbon monoxide on oxygen transport during exercise, J. Appl. Physiol. 32, 234, 1972. 45. Vogel, J.A., et al. Carbon monoxide and physical work capacity. Arch. Environ. Health 24, 198, 1972. 46. Parving, H.H. The effect of hypoxia and carbon monoxide exposure on plasma volume and capillary permeability to albumin, Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 30, 49, 1972. 47. Stewart, R.D., et al. Effect of carbon monoxide on time perception, Arch. Environ. Health 27, 155, 1973. 48. Hudnell, H.K. and Benignus, V.A. Carbon monoxide exposure and human visual detection thresholds, Neurotoxicol. Teratol. 11, 363, 1989. 49. Schulte, J.H. Effects of mild carbon monoxide intoxication, Arch. Environ. Health 7, 524, 1963. 50. DiMarco, A. Carbon monoxide poisoning presenting as polycythemia, N. Engl. J. Med. 319, 874, 1988. 51. Chiodi, H., et al. Respiratory and circulatory responses to acute carbon monoxide poisoning, Am. J. Physiol. 134, 683, 1941. 52. Stewart, R.D. The effect of carbon monoxide on humans, Ann. Rev. Pharmacol. 15, 409, 1975. 53. NIOSH Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazards, Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication Number 97–140, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 2003. 54. 2005 TLVs and BEIs, American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, ACGIH Signature Publications, Cincinnati, Ohio, 2005. 55. Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration, 29 CFR Part 1910, Air Contaminants, Federal Register, 54, 2651, 1989. 56. Current values for the American Industrial Hygiene Association can be found at the Internet Web Site http://www.eh.doe.gov/chem_safety/teel.html. 57. Current National Ambient Air Quality Standards can be found at the USEPA Internet Web Site http://www.epa.gov/air/criteria.html. 58. Current values for California Air Quality Standards can be found at the CARB Internet Web Site http://www.baaqmd.gov//pln/air_quality/ambient_air_quality.htm.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 302 — #16
Investigating Carbon Monoxide Poisonings
303
59. Current values for the California Reference Exposure Limits can be found at the CARB Internet Web Site http://www.oehha.ca.gov/air/pdf/acuterel.pdf. 60. Craig, D.K. Derivation of temporary emergency exposure limits (TEELs), J. Appl. Toxicol. 20, 11, 2000. 61. Pastenbach, D.J. The History and Biological Basis of Occupational Exposure Limits for Chemical Agents, In: Patty’s Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology, 5th ed., Volume 3, VI, Harris, R.L., ed., John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 2000, pp. 1953–1954. 62. National Research Council, Carbon monoxide, In: Review of Submarine Escape Action Levels for Selected Chemicals, National Academy Press, Washington, DC, 2002, pp. 69–96. 63. Varon, J. and Marik, P.E. Carbon monoxide poisoning, J. Emerg. Int. Care Med. 1, 1, 1997. 64. Weaver, L.K., et al. Carboxyhemoglobin half-life in carbon monoxide-poisoned patients treated with 100% oxygen at atmospheric pressure, Chest. 117, 801, 2000. 65. Gill, A.L. and Bell, C.N.A. Hyperbaric oxygen: Its uses, mechanisms of action, and outcomes, Q. J. Med. 97, 385, 2004. 66. Leach, R.M., Rees, P.J., and Wilshurst, P. ABC of oxygen: hyperbaric oxygen therapy, Brit. Med. J. 317, 1140, 1998. 67. Thom, S.R., et al. Delayed neuropsychological sequelae after carbon monoxide poisoning: Prevention by treatment with hyperbaric oxygen, Ann. Emerg. Med. 25, 474, 1995. 68. Ducasse, J.L., Celis, P., and Marc-Vergnes, J.P. Non-comatose patients with acute carbon monoxide poisoning: Hyperbaric or normobaric oxygenation?, Undersea Hyperb. Med. 22, 9, 1995. 69. Weaver, L.K., Hopkins, R.O., and Larson-Lohr, V. Neuropsychological and functional recovery from severe carbon monoxide poisoning without hyperbaric oxygen therapy, Ann. Emerg. Med. 27, 736, 1996. 70. Scheinkestel, C.D., et al. Hyperbaric or normobaric oxygen for acute carbon monoxide poisoning: A randomized controlled clinical trial, Med. J. Aust. 170, 203, 1999. 71. Harper, A. and Croft-Baker, J. Carbon monoxide poisoning: undetected by both patients and their doctors, Age Ageing 33, 105, 2004.
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 303 — #17
8417: “8417_c012” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 304 — #18
13
Carbon Monoxide Detectors as Preventive Medicine James W. Rhee and Jerrold B. Leikin
CONTENTS 13.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2 Carbon Monoxide Detector Technology: A Brief Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.3 Setting an Initial Standard . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.4 The Chicago Experience. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.5 Clinical Implications. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.6 Some Data Regarding Effectiveness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.7 Current and Future Directions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
305 306 306 307 308 308 309 310
13.1 INTRODUCTION Carbon monoxide (CO) is odorless, colorless, tasteless, and nonirritating. As such, CO has no warning properties that can alert unwary individuals to its presence. When people become ill owing to CO toxicity, the symptom complex can be nonspecific and variable making the diagnosis of CO poisoning difficult. Given its lack of warning signs and lack of distinct clinical features, CO has been labeled by some as a “silent killer.” Data analyzed by Cobb and Etzel from the National Center for Health Statistics, attributed 53,133 deaths to CO from 1979 to 1988—making it the most common cause of acute poisoning deaths.1 When Shepherd and Klein-Schwartz examined the mortality data from 1979 to 1994 for persons aged 10–19 years, they found 3034 out of 7936 poisoning deaths were attributable to carbon monoxide.2 As these numbers were derived from databases, they are likely to be significant under representation of the true number of deaths caused by CO. They also do not take into account the significant morbidity that may occur from severe CO exposures. Given the “silent” nature of CO and its significant impact on public health, a need for residential-based CO detectors was identified. In 1989, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) urged Underwriters Laboratories (UL) (Northbrook, Illinois) to develop a standard that would serve as a guideline for residential 305
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 305 — #1
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
306
CO detectors. This standard (UL 2034) applying to single and multiple station CO detectors was published in April, 19923 —subsequently, the first two CO detectors were listed later that year.4
13.2 CARBON MONOXIDE DETECTOR TECHNOLOGY: A BRIEF REVIEW Most of the residential CO detectors utilize one of the two methods of sensing the presence of CO—either a biomimetic sensor or a metal oxide sensor. The types of technology usually involved in residential sensors include the “Gel cell” metal oxide and electrochemical sensor. The nondispersive infrared technology (NDIR) is usually utilized for industrial purposes. The “Gel cell” based sensor sends a light beam through a biomimetic sensor to a photosensitive component which alarms at appropriate set points. This colorimetric sensor essentially mimicked the hemoglobin uptake of CO, thus changing the spectral response. These types of sensors exhibit proper sensitivity to CO and can achieve a unique accumulation of CO. There is some interference with other gases and vapors along with humidity, and these types of sensors take a longer time to recover in the setting of CO removal (slower response reversibility). The “Gel cell” detectors are rarely equipped with digital displays. The metal-oxide (usually tin-oxide) sensor detects CO by measuring the resistivity of the metal component through oxidation of CO to carbon dioxide, which reduces the resistance of the sensor. These sensors usually require main (i.e., AC) power and cannot use batteries as a primary power source. Upon exposure to CO, the electrochemical sensors will generate electricity through an acid electrolyte (usually sulfuric acid or phosphoric acid). This technology has been utilized as portable or fixed gas monitors in industry owing to its resolution (down to 1 ppm) and stability, and is probably the primary type of sensor used in residential detectors. These sensors can also be affected by cross-contamination of gases. The NDIR can measure CO concentrations with an accuracy of ±2 ppm, but are expensive and therefore usually not utilized in residential detectors. Metallocorroles utilizing cobalt (111) can selectively absorb CO gas on a molecular complex and may provide a future matrix in sensor development.5
13.3 SETTING AN INITIAL STANDARD UL is a well-known organization located in Northbrook, Illinois that develops standards and test procedures for materials, components, assemblies, tools, equipment, and procedures, chiefly dealing with product safety and utility. The CPSC worked closely with UL to develop standards for CO detectors. Part of setting this standard required UL to create thresholds at which the detectors would alarm. The threshold at which the residential CO detectors would alarm presented a unique challenge. Initially, set points were generated on the basis of extrapolating what levels of CO over what period of time would generate a carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) concentration of 10% in a nonsmoking individual. These values were based
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 306 — #2
Carbon Monoxide Detectors as Preventive Medicine
307
TABLE 13.1 UL 2034 (1992–1996). Carbon Monoxide Concentration Versus Time for Alarm Test Points Air Concentration (ppm)
Maximum Response Time (min)
100 200 400
90 35 15
on the Coburn–Forster–Kane equation. (In addition, the CO detector should alarm at an exposure of 6000 ppm within 3 min.)6 This initial standard (UL 2034) was set in place in 1992.3 Soon afterwards CO detectors were sold across the United States. Table 13.1 illustrates the original set points for activating the audible alarm in the CO detectors. Other standards, such as loudness of the alarm and the response to other gases needed to be clarified as well. Similar to smoke detectors, the CO detector was set to emit an 85-dB alarm (at 10 ft.), which is loud enough to wake most people when sounding outside a bedroom through a closed door. However, unlike smoke detectors, CO detectors have computer processor-based software which allow it to alarm at certain set points. Sensors were set to not alarm when exposed for 2 h to methane (at 500 ppm), butane (at 300 ppm), heptane (at 500 ppm), ethyl acetate (at 200 ppm), isopropyl alcohol (at 200 ppm), carbon dioxide (at 5000 ppm), toluene (at 200 ppm), and acetone (at 200 ppm).7 Other major features include a red lightemitting diode (LED) as a trouble signal, a green LED indicating normal operation and a reset mechanism for testing and resetting purposes. Some detectors utilize a digital display (over 30 ppm).
13.4 THE CHICAGO EXPERIENCE The state of Illinois, in the past had one of the highest fatality rates from CO— accounting for 8.7% of all unintentional CO deaths nation-wide, with a rate of about 0.9 deaths per 1000 people between 1979 and 1988.1 In light of this statistic, Chicago, Illinois, passed a mandatory CO detector ordinance in March, 1994 requiring CO detectors to be present in all homes, apartments, class “B” and “C” buildings with heat sources that generate CO.8 During the first 3 months of the ordinance implementation, 68 individuals were transported with suspected CO poisoning attributed to CO detector alarms.9 However, during this time period (October 1–December 31, 1994), the Chicago Fire Department received over 12,000 calls of CO detector alarming. In about 85% of these cases, less than 9 ppm of CO was reportedly measured by the Chicago Fire Department.9–12 This was climaxed on December 21–22, 1994, when the Chicago Fire Department was involved in 3464 CO investigations.11 It was subsequently determined that a thermal air inversion (upper atmosphere warmer than lower atmosphere) had caused a fivefold
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 307 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
308
elevation of ambient CO concentration, of 13–20 ppm, thus setting off multiple CO alarms. CO detector sensitivity or resistance specifications were 15 ppm over an 8-h period at that time.9,10 In response to the inordinate number of “nuisance alarms,” UL increased the 15 ppm resistance specification from 8 h to 30 days in the 1996 revised standard.7 The UL standard 2034 is under a continuous maintenance process and was last revised in 2006.
13.5 CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS Given the variable presentation of CO toxicity—it is apparent that healthcare providers could use assistance in diagnosing occult CO poisoning. Patients with CO poisoning are often misdiagnosed as having a viral syndrome or food poisoning.13 Earlier studies have shown that among adult patients presenting to an emergency department during the winter months with complaints of headache or dizziness, 3–5% have COHb levels greater than 10%.14 Because CO is a colorless, odorless, tasteless, and nonirritating gas, the physician and the patient have few clues as to the contribution of CO to the illness (see other chapters in this book). The CO detector can act as a useful screening tool to identify CO exposure. The CO detector should allow the clinician to obtain a history of exposure and prompt the clinician to begin investigating the potential for CO poisoning.
13.6 SOME DATA REGARDING EFFECTIVENESS CO detectors/alarms have made death from CO poisoning completely preventable. CO detectors can save lives. Despite the high number of false alarms in Chicago after the initial mandatory CO detector ordinance was established in 1994, only one CO-related death was reported in the Chicago media between September 1994 through February 1998. Compared to other cities during this same time period, Chicago (the only city to have a CO detector ordinance during the study period) had the lowest case fatality rate.15 And despite the loudly voiced criticisms and objections to the ordinance from various sources, a Chicago Sun-Times poll (though hardly scientific) reported that 77% of respondents supported such a mandatory ordinance. Krenzelok et al.16 found that in an investigation of emergency responses to possible CO poisoning, residences with CO alarms had lower CO concentrations (18.6 ppm with CO detectors versus 96.6 ppm without CO detectors) and fewer symptomatic patients (11.7% with CO detectors vs 63.4% without CO detectors).16 They concluded that audible CO detectors were effective in alerting people to the presence of abnormal levels of CO, thus resulting in less exposure to CO. This subsequently lead to a lower incidence of CO-related symptoms.16 A study conducted by Bizovi et al.10 found similar results where only about 5% of individuals at a site where a CO detector had activated displayed signs of CO poisoning, suggesting that the CO detector may have prevented more serious exposure.10
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 308 — #4
Carbon Monoxide Detectors as Preventive Medicine
309
Yoon et al.17 estimate that 78 out of 136 unintentional deaths due to CO poisoning that occurred during a 15-year period in New Mexico, may have been prevented if audible CO detectors were in use.17 In North Carolina, a couple of studies evaluated the impact of a local CO detector ordinance (which exempted all-electric heated homes) was conducted.18,19 While, the ordinance did not seem to decrease the amount of CO exposures, the relative incidence of severe poisoning requiring hyperbaric oxygen treatment was diminished.18 Another study evaluating a CO poisoning outbreak during a winter storm in 2002 demonstrated that the North Carolina county CO detector ordinance did not eliminate a CO poisoning outbreak, but it did mitigate its effects.19 Of note, the study found that none of the patients who developed symptoms of severe CO poisoning had a functioning CO detector.19 Despite the apparent effectiveness of CO detectors at saving lives, only 29% of respondents to a survey conducted by Runyan et al.20 reported the presence of CO detectors in their homes.20 The lack of widespread use of these detectors intuitively limits the effectiveness of these devices to have a profound impact on mortality and morbidity due to CO poisoning.
13.7 CURRENT AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS Newer aspects of CO detector specifications include an alarm reset within 6 min if the CO concentration exceeds 70 ppm, secondary power supply considerations, and alarm tests point revision (revised November, 2001—see Table 13.2). Usage in recreational vehicles/marine units and unconditioned areas was added in 1997.7 The revised UL 2034 standard is similar to that of the International Approved Services (IAS) and the British Standards Institute (BSI). While these new standards and new sepcifications for CO detectors facilitate the design and development of newer and better CO detectors, the potential impact these CO detectors can have on public health is limited by the prevalence of their use.
TABLE 13.2 UL 2034, revised November, 2001. Carbon Monoxide Concentration Versus Time for Alarm Test Points Based on 10% Carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) A. Carbon Monoxide Concentration (ppm) and Response Time Concentration, ppm Response time, min 70 ± 5 60–10 150 ± 5 10–50 400 ± 10 4–15 B. False Alarm-Carbon Monoxide Concentration Resistance Specifications Concentration, ppm Exposure time, (no alarm) 30 ± 3 30 days 70 ± 5 60 min
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 309 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
310
This problem can potentially be remedied by CO detector ordinances set at the state and local levels, since the ordinances already in place have had a demonstrable impact on public health.
References 1. Cobb, N. and Etzel, R. A. Unintentional carbon monoxide-related deaths in the United States, 1979 through 1988, JAMA, 266, 659, 1991. 2. Shepherd, G. and Klein-Schwartz, W. Accidental and suicidal adolescent poisoning deaths in the United States, 1979–1994, Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med., 152, 1181, 1998. 3. Standard for Safety UL 2034 Single and Multiple Station Carbon Monoxide Detectors, Underwriters Laboratories, Northbrook, IL, 1st ed., 1992. 4. Hrones, T. L. and Patty, P. E. Carbon monoxide detectors: protection against the silent killer, In Poisoning and Toxicology Compendium, Leikin, J. B., and Paloucek, F. B., eds., Lexicomp, Hudson, Ohio, 1998, 630. 5. Barbe, J. M., Canard, G., Brandes, S., Jerome, F., Dubois, G., and Guilard, R. Metallocorroles as sensing components for gas sensors: remarkable affinity and selectivity of cobalt(III) corroles for CO vs. O2 and N2 , Dalton Trans., 1208, 2004. 6. Coburn, R. F., Forster, R. E., and Kane, P. B. Considerations of the physiological variables that determine the blood carboxyhemoglobin concentration in man, J. Clin. Invest., vol. 44(11), 1899–1910, 1965. 7. Standard for Safety UL 2034 Single and Multiple Station Carbon Monoxide Detectors, Underwriters Laboratories, Northbrook, IL, 2nd ed., 1996. 8. City Council of the City of Chicago: Amendment of Title 13, Chapter 64 of the Municipal Code of Chicago by addition of new sections 190 through 300 requiring CO detectors in various buildings. Meeting of March 2, 1994. 9. Leikin, J. B. Carbon monoxide detectors and emergency physicians, Am. J. Emerg. Med., 14, 90, 1996. 10. Bizovi, K. E., Leikin, J. B., Hryhorczuk, D. O., and Frateschi, L. J. Night of the sirens: analysis of carbon monoxide-detector experience in suburban Chicago, Ann. Emerg. Med., 31, 737, 1998. 11. Eversole, J. M. Carbon Monoxide Detector Ordinance: Review of the Chicago Fire Department experience, In Poisoning and Toxicology Compendium, Leikin, J. B., and Paloucek, F. B., eds., Lexicomp, Hudson, Ohio, 1998, 633. 12. Leikin, J. B., Krenzelok, E. P., and Greiner, T. H. Remarks to the Illinois House of Representatives Executive Committee hearing regarding state carbon monoxide detector act (HB 603), J. Toxicol. Clin. Toxicol., 37, 885, 1999. 13. Barret, L., Danel, V., and Faure, J. Carbon monoxide poisoning, a diagnosis frequently overlooked, J. Toxicol. Clin. Toxicol., 23, 309, 1985. 14. Heckerling, P. S., Leikin, J. B., and Maturen, A. Occult carbon monoxide poisoning: validation of a prediction model, Am. J. Med., 84, 251, 1988. 15. Clifton, J. C. N., Leikin, J. B., Hryhorczuk, D. O., and Krenzelok, E. P. Surveillance for carbon monoxide poisoning using a national media clipping service, Am. J. Emerg. Med., 19, 106, 2001. 16. Krenzelok, E. P., Roth, R., and Full, R. Carbon monoxide: the silent killer with an audible solution, Am. J. Emerg. Med., 14, 484, 1996. 17. Yoon, S. S., Macdonald, S. C., and Parrish, R. G. Deaths from unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning and potential for prevention with carbon monoxide detectors, JAMA, 279, 685, 1998.
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 310 — #6
Carbon Monoxide Detectors as Preventive Medicine
311
18. Tomaszewski, C., Lavonas, E., Kerns, R., and Rouse, A. Effect of a carbon monoxide alarm regulation on CO poisoning, J. Toxicol. Clin. Toxicol.,41(5), 167–168, 2003. 19. Lavonas, E., Tomaszewski, C., Kerns, W., and Blackwell, T. Epidemic carbon monoxide poisoning despite a CO alarm law, J. Toxicol. Clin. Toxicol.,41(5), 711–712, 2003. 20. Runyan, C. W., Johnson, R. M., Yang, J., Waller, A. E., Perkis, D., Marshall, S. W., Coyne-Beasley, T., and McGee, K. S. Risk and protective factors for fires, burns, and carbon monoxide poisoning in U.S. households, Am. J. Prev. Med., 28, 102, 2005.
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 311 — #7
8417: “8417_c013” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 312 — #8
14
Misconceptions About Carbon Monoxide David G. Penney
CONTENTS 14.1 Properties, Presence, and Detection. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2 Physiology of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3 Symptoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.4 Treatment and Outcome . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.5 Miscellaneous . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
313 316 318 320 322 323
14.1 PROPERTIES, PRESENCE, AND DETECTION There are many many misunderstanding about carbon monoxide (CO), even today, by the general public, healthcare professionals, and others who ought to be better informed. The first grouping of these misconceptions are shown in Table 14.1. CO is known as the “Silent Killer” or the “Stealthy Poison” because it is impossible to detect by humans—we cannot smell, taste, or see CO gas, no matter what the concentration. For this reason gas supply companies often put smelly tracers in fuel gases to assist us in detecting their presence. With school groups and nonscientists I often refer to CO as a “smart poison,” as opposed to “dumber poisons” like hydrogen sulfide and others that we have warning of by our chemoreceptors (i.e., taste, smell). CO is also smart in that it enters our bodies simply by our breathing, and does not have to be “picked up” by ingestion through the mouth as lead largely is. Another element of “smartness” is that it leaves the body quickly, although damage may already have been done, while dumb poisons remain (lead, mercury, etc.) to be detected days, weeks, even years later. CO is of course slightly lighter than air, being made up of one carbon atom and one oxygen atom. It has about the dimensions of an oxygen molecule (i.e., diatomic oxygen), contributing to several others of its properties (i.e., ability to diffuse easily, attach to hemoglobin where oxygen sits). The molecular weight of CO is roughly 28 (see Reference Data, Chapter 35). Calculating the molecular weight of air, a mixture of nitrogen (28), oxygen (32), argon (40), carbon dioxide (44), and water vapor (18), gives a weighted average of approximately 29. Thus, CO is about 4% lighter than
313
8417: “8417_c014” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 313 — #1
314
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
TABLE 14.1 Misconceptions: Properties, Presence, and Detection • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
CO is easy to detect. CO is lighter than air and therefore rises (to the ceiling) and stays there. CO is not combustible. CO adsorbs and absorbs to fabric, crockery, walls and thus remains long after it has left the air. CO and natural gas are the same thing. Natural gas contains considerable amounts of CO. You can always tell if CO is present because of a peculiar odor that is present. A brand new, well designed, perfectly “tuned” heating/cooking device cannot produce toxic/lethal amounts of CO. Diesel engine exhaust never contains enough CO to cause harm. Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) and gas company service personnel always check for CO when performing maintenance/service on home heating systems. CO will be detected immediately by service personnel if it is present in a home heating system. When your home CO detector shows low levels of CO, it is probably just an instrument malfunction. Cracks in heat exchangers are responsible for the production of CO. Home CO detectors/sensors are the best devices to ferret out CO because they react to very low levels of the gas.
air. However, the assertion that CO rises to the ceiling when released into the air of a structure is incorrect. The CO is always mixed with vast quantities of excess air, mixes thoroughly and completely, and cannot unmix lest it violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics. The key to observations of higher CO concentration near ceilings stems from the fact that hot air rises, and exhaust containing CO is often warmer than the surrounding air. CO is of course combustible and has been used as a fuel gas. It will burn to carbon dioxide, which it does with the release of additional heat. CO was used as a fuel source in past years, for both lighting and heating. This property should be kept in mind when working around high concentrations of CO, where ignition may occur. We may forget about this property because usually the toxic effects are of greatest significance at far lower concentrations. CO does NOT attach in any way to fabric, glass, crockery, and so forth. I heard that a physician when seeing a patient who had sustained acute CO poisoning, told his patient’s mother to clean everything in the apartment after the incident because CO “sticks.” She did this as well as giving away all the furniture and clothing that had been in the apartment. This was of course entirely needless; the result of inadequate education in toxicology. Natural gas as it is used in the United States, contains little CO. Its main component is methane, CH4 . I understand there are also small amounts of other gases too, of the aliphatic series (e.g., ethane). CO may only be present around a combustion device using natural gas after the gas is combusted, and when that combustion process is incomplete, that is, not all of the gas is burned to form carbon dioxide and water vapor. Other possible incomplete combustion products include soot (i.e., elemental carbon).
8417: “8417_c014” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 314 — #2
Misconceptions About Carbon Monoxide
315
All common combustion devices involve some amount of incompelete combustion, although under certain circumstances this may be very small. So, all such devices produce some CO. Usually the concentration of CO generated is below levels set as safe by regulatory standards. But even these devices may under certain conditions produce extraordinarily high, even lethal concentrations of CO if something else in the heating system is inadequate or fails (compromised combustion air source, broken exhaust system), or if slow or catastrophic failure of the heating device itself takes place through corrosion, lack of cleaning, physical impact by outside forces, and so forth. Diesel engines generally produce lower CO concentrations in exhaust gases than gasoline-fueled engines. On the other hand, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) over the past several decades has required gasoline-fueled vehicles in the United States to have catalytic converters that work on the exhaust gases. This device converts the CO to carbon dioxide using various catalysts. They only work effectively when they are hot, that is, they are not effective at cold start. The key point here is that diesel engine equipped vehicles lack catalytic converters, so ALL the CO generated by the engine goes out the tailpipe. Thus, the CO emissions from many diesel powered vehicles are above those from gasoline-fueled vehicles. Heating and cooling technicians and gas company personnel should always monitor for CO when checking a combustion device. Unfortunately, this is not always done. “Sniffing” for natural gas or propane (LPG) is more common, to detect leaks that could lead to fire or explosion. Checking for CO that can lead to injury and/or death is sadly often not done. Unfortunately, even when CO is checked, a problem may be missed. A high CO reading is proof-positive of a problem with a combustion device or the system it is operating in. Failure to find CO on one attempt does not entirely rule out the possibility of a problem during that time frame and under slightly different environmental conditions. Of course measurements must be made when the combustion device is operating, and for sufficient time to catch possible delayed build-up. Often measurements will have to be made several times, and under slightly different conditions, for example, when other combustion devices are also operating, when exhaust fans are being run, when outside wind conditions change, and so forth. One of the most common, possibly lethal mistakes made by people is to assume that a residential CO alarm (i.e., detector) showing low, or even high levels of CO, is malfunctioning. “It never did before,” “it must be the battery,” “The smoke alarm is not sounding,” “take the battery out and go back to bed.” I recommend that people have a minimum of two CO alarms in their residence, one located very near where they sleep, and another near where they are when awake, reading, watching TV, and so forth. Two alarms sounding simultaneously make it much less likely that a person will come to the conclusion that the warning is due to malfunction. If there are two or more floors to the residence, an additional alarm should be installed for each additional floor. Home CO alarms are not the best devices to discover where CO is coming from in a breathing space. After all, they are built as “alarms,” not as instantaneous sensing devices. They have mathematical algorithms built in to simulate human CO uptake, and thus to provide warning before we have taken very much of the CO up into our blood and tissues. Also, their cost is minimal, making them affordable to the general
8417: “8417_c014” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 315 — #3
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
316
public, but by no means professional grade in accuracy. The best devices to ferret out CO sources and monitor it accurately are what we call “monitors.” They measure CO almost instantaneously and produce a reading in parts per million (ppm). They are usually portable and the readings are highly reproducible. As one might imagine, these kind of devices are more costly than home CO detectors.
14.2 PHYSIOLOGY OF CARBON MONOXIDE CO binds to hemoglobin reversibly (Table 14.2). While this binding is avid, as we know it is some 230 times that of oxygen, it is nonetheless a competitive process with oxygen. As the oxygen partial pressure rises, the CO is forced off the site on the hemoglobin molecule and oxygen takes its place. This mechanism is one of the major reasons for using hyperbaric (high pressure) oxygen in treating CO poisoning. CO-induced hypoxia is far more serious than hypoxic hypoxia. The presence of CO in the blood occupying the oxygen sites on the hemoglobin decreases the oxygen transport capability of the cardiovascular system, not unlike increasing high altitude does by desaturating arterial blood as lung partial pressure of oxygen falls. In addition to this, however, CO causes the remaining oxyhemoglobin to hold its oxygen more strongly, thus shifting the oxygen dissociation curve (ODC) to the left and making it harder to unload what oxygen remains in the blood to the tissues. People tend to forget this second action of CO on the ODC. Hypoxic hypoxia does just the opposite, shifting the ODC to the right and enhancing the unloading of oxygen to the tissues. Thus, CO inflicts a “double-whammy” on the body in terms of oxygen delivery capability that is much more serious than is that of hypoxic hypoxia. CO poisoning is also far more serious than a comparable simple anemia, where it may appear that there is the same amount of total hemoglobin able to carry oxygen. Like hypoxic hypoxia, anemia causes a right-shift in the ODC, which enhances oxygen
TABLE 14.2 Misconceptions: Physiology • • • • • • • • •
CO binding to hemoglobin is irreversible. CO (caused) hypoxia is no more serious than any other type of hypoxia. CO poisoning is no more serious than an anemia in which there is a comparable amount of hemoglobin able to carry oxygen. Small animals (birds, mice, etc.) die more quickly because their hemoglobin binds CO more avidly than that of humans, thus they were used as alarms for CO in mines. The fetus is protected from CO by the maternal body. Good COHb measurements can be obtained 1 day to a week after a person leaves the site of the CO poisoning. Breathing “clean” air for 2–3 h will eliminate all CO from the body. Breathing 100% oxygen for 20–30 min will eliminate all CO from the body. Breathing (filter) masks protect the wearer from the inhalation of CO.
8417: “8417_c014” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 316 — #4
Misconceptions About Carbon Monoxide
317
unloading to the tissues, whereas CO does the opposite. A condition where the body has only one-half of its normal hemoglobin concentration (i.e., anemia) is welltolerated, whereas a condition where half of the hemoglobin has CO attached [i.e., 50% carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) saturation] is usually quickly lethal. Small birds and mammals were at one time used as CO alarms in mines and other closed places where CO occurred. Canaries and other like small birds were especially popular in this capacity because they would fall off their perches when incapacitated, making it obvious to the observer there was a problem. The reason for their usefulness was not that the small birds or mammals were necessarily more sensitive to CO, but because their warm-bloodedness and high surface to volume ratio caused their metabolic rate to be necessarily much higher than that of humans, making their ventilation rate greater than that of humans. Hence they take up the CO much faster. This provided a living “early warning” system for CO. The fetus residing inside the maternal body is subject to the CO breathed by the mother. Being a nonirritating gas, unlike chlorine or nitrogen dioxide, it is taken up silently and without notice through the maternal lungs. The CO reaches the placenta through the circulating maternal blood, and again, it passes silently and readily across the membranes into the fetal circulation where it attaches to the fetus’ hemoglobin. While CO compromises oxygen delivery to tissues in the maternal circulation by the mechanisms described above, the situation is much more serious for the fetus, which normally is operating in an oxygen-depleted environment. The presence of CO makes the situation worse by further degrading the oxygen carrying capacity of the fetus. The right time to draw blood for accurate measurement of COHb is one of the biggest misunderstandings by lay people, and even members of the medical community. The half-life of COHb in humans breathing sea level ambient air centers around 4–5 h. That is, one-half of the COHb will be gone in 4–5 h, and half of what remains will be gone in another 4–5 h (i.e., two half-lives). Within one day, COHb level in the blood will be at or near background (0.4–1.4%) no matter how high it was to start with. For accurate measurement, blood sampling should be done within 2–4 h of leaving the site of the CO poisoning. Physicians must not say when contacted by a patient on Friday or on the weekend, “just come to the office on Monday and we’ll do the COHb test.” It will be too late and the results will be useless. On the basis of what we know of COHb half-life, it is clear that breathing “clean” air for 2–3 h. will not eliminate all the CO from the body—approximately 24 h is required. In the same way, breathing 100% oxygen for 20–30 min at sea-level pressure, known as normobaric oxygen therapy, will not eliminate all the CO from the body, since the half-life of COHb when breathing 100% oxygen under normal conditions centers around 50–70 min. A number of hours will be required to do this. Another misconception involves the use of masks in polluted environments. Dust masks or more complicated filtering respirators will remove particulates of various sizes. Virtually none of these devices will remove CO. Donning a mask that does not remove CO when the wearer believes it will, can be a very dangerous, even deadly mistake. In order to safely enter an atmosphere containing CO, self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA) is required, such as that used by firefighters and hazmat personnel.
8417: “8417_c014” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 317 — #5
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
318
14.3 SYMPTOMS While CO poisoning is classically described as causing the skin, nail beds, and exposed mucous membranes to turn pink or bright red, this is rarely seen in actual fact. Often dead CO victims appear gray or yellow. The COHb saturation must be high enough for the COHb to show; people dying in the water from acute CO poisoning usually reach only 40–45% COHb, the level at which incapacitation occurs. Breathing then ceases below the water’s surface. The pink color is of course difficult to see in darkly pigmented people (i.e., negroids), those with severe sunburn, and so forth. (see Table 14.3) Fever is rarely associated with CO poisoning, especially chronic CO poisoning. Nonetheless, thermoregulatory dysfunction is a common outcome of CO poisoning, and is thought to be due to brain damage caused by the poison. Victims with this condition usually feel cold in thermally neutral surroundings, and occasionally report being hot, however, in the latter instance actual body temperature is rarely above normal. Fever is reported following severe acute CO poisoning, probably associated with cerebral tissue damage and edema, gastrointestinal damage, and so forth. The lungs along with the nasal passages, throat, and trachea are generally unaffected by CO. Most of the CO uptake by the body occurs through the former route, and the CO goes directly into the blood. While congestion, cough, and hoarseness are not caused by CO inhalation, other substances that often accompany CO, particulates, nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, aldehydes, and so forth will do this. A recent book on CO (Dwyer et al., 2003, p. 5)1 lists “wheezing” or bronchial constriction” and “persistent cough” as “signs and symptoms of CO poisoning.” In my experience this is incorrect. Such symptoms may be due to other components of
TABLE 14.3 Misconceptions: Symptoms • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
The skin, nail beds, and so forth of people with CO poisoning are invariably red or pink in color. Fever is a common symptom of CO poisoning. Nasal congestion, cough, and hoarseness are symptoms of CO poisoning. The lungs are inflammed by low to moderate levels of CO and appear abnormal by x-ray. Hyperventilation is a response to low and moderate CO poisoning Symptom clusters involving prolonged headache, dizziness, nausea, and fatigue of the whole family should be blamed on viruses, bad food, or group craziness. Everyone responds to CO in the same way, that is, all people show the same symptoms. Depression is not a residual effect of CO poisoning. Loss of short-term memory capability is not a residual effect of CO poisoning. Muscle and/or joint pain is not a residual effect of CO poisoning. Difficulty with attention and concentration is not a residual effect of CO poisoning. Blurry vision is not a residual effect of CO poisoning. Personality change is not a residual effect of CO poisoning. More people experience acute CO poisoning than the chronic type There is a good dose–response relationship between CO in the air and COHb and immediate symptoms or long-term health damage.
8417: “8417_c014” — 2007/9/11 — 12:15 — page 318 — #6
Misconceptions About Carbon Monoxide
319
exhaust gases (e.g., Particulates, aldehydes, sulfur, and/or nitrogen oxides), but not to the CO specifically. As noted above, the lungs are virtually transparent to CO. In life-threatening CO poisonings, the lungs become edematous and begin to fill with fluid. This congestion is coughed up as a light to more darkly tan fluid, often mistaken for vomitus. It is usually observed at scenes of lethal CO poisonings, combined or not combined with vomitus. Tachypnea is not a symptom of low to moderately severe CO poisoning, since the carotid chemoreceptors are insensitive to percent saturation of the arterial blood, responding only to changes in arterial PO2 and pH, which generally change little until the CO poisoning becomes very severe. That is why hyperventilation with simple CO poisoning is so rare, and its presence suggests a more complicated poisoning. As discussed at le