ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 44
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared in Cooperation wi...
35 downloads
1283 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 44
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared in Cooperation wirh the AMERICAN SOCIETYOF AGRONOMY
VOLUME 44 Edited by N. C . BRADY Science and Technology Agency for International Development Department of State Washington, D . C .
ADVISORY BOARD N. L. TAYLORH. G . HODGES
E. L. KLEPPERG . L. HORST R. J . KOHEL R. H. MILLER G . E. HAM S . MICHELSON K. H. QUESENBERRY C. W. STUBER G . H . HEICHELD. E. KISSEL
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers San Diego New York Boston London Sydney Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
@
Copyright 0 1990 by Academic Press, Inc. All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Academic Press, Inc. San Diego, California 92 10 1 United Kingdom Edition published by Academic Press Limited 24-28 Oval Road, London NW I 7DX
50-5598
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number:
ISBN 0-12-000744-4
(alk. paper)
Printed in the United States of America 9 0 9 1 9 2 9 3 9 8 7 6 5 4
3
2
1
CONTENTS CONTRIBUTORS ..........................................................................
PREPACE ..................................................................................
ix xi
VARIATION IN TIME OF SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS: A FEATURE THAT DETERMINES INDIVIDUAL GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT
L. R. Benjamin I. 11. 111. 1V.
.......................................... Introduction ................................ Factors That Influence Time of Seedling Emergence.. ......................... Importance of Variation in Time of Seedling Emergence to Crop Development .............................................................................. Conclusions ............................ References .................................................................................
1 2
9 20 21
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES: THEIR MANAGEMENTAND CONTRIBUTIONTO THE NITROGEN ECONOMY OF WET AND HUMID TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
Graeme Blair, David Catchpoole, and Peter Horne 1. 11.
111. 1v. V. VI. VII. VIII.
Introduction.. .......................................................... Species of Useful Tree Legumes. ............................................... Agronomic Performance of Tree Legumes ........................................ Tree Legume Leaf as Animal Feed .................................................. Management of Tree Legumes........................................................ Nitrogen Yields of Material Harvested from Tree Legumes .................. Nitrogen Recycling via Leaf and Excreta.. ...................... Conclusion ................................................................................. References ........................................................................
21 28 29 34 36 45 46 49 50
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATIONTRIALS
Jose Crossa I. 11.
Introduction ................................................................................ Conventional Analysis of Variance.. ................................................ V
55
51
vi
CONTENTS
111. Joint Linear Regression................................................................. IV. Crossover Interactions.. ................................................................ V. Multivariate Analyses of Multilocation Trials .................................... VI. AMMl Analysis ........................................................................... VII. Other Methods of Analysis ............................................................ VIII. General Considerations and Conclusions .......................................... References .................................................................................
61
68 70 76 80 81 82
EVALUATION AND DOCUMENTATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
A. B. Damania I. 11. 111.
IV. V. VI. VII.
Introduction ..................... ................................................ Evaluation of Cultivated Wheat ...................................................... Evaluation of Cultivated Barley ......................................... Genetic Resources from Ethiopia.. .................................................. Evaluation of Wild and Primitive Forms of Wheat and Barley ............... Documentation of Genetic Resources .............................................. Summary and Conclusions. .................... References .................................................................................
87 90 93 95 96 I02 I05 107
MODELING CROP ROOT GROWTH AND FUNCTION
Betty Klepper and R. W.Rickman 1. 11.
111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction .............................................. Early Models .............................................................................. Desirable Model Features.. ................................................... Model Components ...................................................................... Some Existing Root Growth and Function Models ............................. Limitations to Development of Root Growth Models ..........................
...............................
I13 114 115
118 I28 130 131
GENETIC MANIPULATION OF THE COWPEA (Vigna unguiculafa [L.] Walp.) FOR ENHANCED RESISTANCE TO FUNGAL PATHOGENS AND INSECT PESTS
A. 0. Latunde-Dada 1. 11. 111.
IV.
Introduction ................................................................................ Insect Pests ................................................................................ Fungal Pathogens.. ....................................................................... Tissue Culture Technology ............................................................
133 139 141 142
vii
CONTENTS V.
Conclusions and Epilogue.. .................................................... ........ References ............................................................ ....................
.
149
I 50
NITROGEN FIXATION BY LEGUMES IN TROPICAL AND SUBTROPICAL AGRICULTURE
Mark B. Peoples and David F. Herridge
I. 11.
111. IV. V. VI .
.
Introduction.. .................................................................. ........... Methods of Assessing N2 Fixation N2 Fixation in Legume Production Systems ...................................... Contribution of Legume N to Plant and Animal Producti Strategies to Enhance N2 Fixation ................................................... Concluding Remarks .................................,............ References ............................. ..............................................
i56 158 177 190 202 216 216
DISTRIBUTION, COLLECTION, AND EVALUATION OF Gossypium
A. Edward Percival and Russell J. Kohel
.
11.
Introduction.. ........ ........ ....................... Distribution ..........,.....................................................................
Ill. IV . V.
Evaluation.. ................................................................................ Concluding Remarks ................................ ..
1.
225 228 235 245 253 253
BREEDING WHEAT FOR RESISTANCE TO Septoria nodorum AND Septoria tritici
Lloyd R. Nelson and David Marshall
I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI .
Introduction.. .............................................................................. Identification of Resistance. ....................... Pathogen Variation.. ........... ......................................................... Genetics of Resistance ............................................. Sources of Resistance ..... ....,....................... Discussion and Conclusions ...........................................................
.
INDEX......................................................................................
257 258 268 270 272 272 214
279
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTRIBUTORS Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors' contributions begin.
L. R. BENJAMIN ( l ) , AFRC Institute of Horticultural Research, Wellesbourne, Wanvick CV35 9EF, England GRAEME BLAIR (27), Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research, Department of Agronomy and Soil Science, University of New England, Armidale, New South Wales 2351, Australia DAVID CATCHPOOLE* (27), Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research, Department of Agronomy and Soil Science, University of New England, Armidale, New South Wales 2351, Australia JOSE CROSSA (55), Biometrics and Statistics Unit, International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT),06600 Mexico D. F., Mexico A. B. DAMANIA (87), Genetic Resources Unit, International Centerfor Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA),Aleppo, Syria DAVID F. HERRIDGE (155), Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research (Project 8800),New South Wales Agriculture and Fisheries, Tamworth, New South Wales 2340, Australia PETER HORNE (27), Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research, Department of Agronomy and Soil Science, university of New England, Armidale, New South Wales 2351, Australia BETTY KLEPPER ( 1 13), United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Columbia Plateau Conservation Research Center, Pendleton, Oregon 97801 RUSSELL J. KOHEL (229, United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Southern Crops Research Laboratory, College Station, Texas 77840 A. 0. LATUNDE-DADA (133), Department of Crop Production, College of Agricultural Sciences, Ogun State university, Ago-Iwoye, Ogun State, Nigeria DAVID MARSHALL (257), Texas A&M University Research and Extension Center at Dallas, Dallas, Texas 75252 LLOYD R. NELSON (257), Texas A&M University Agricultural Research and Extension Center at Overton, Overton, Texas 75684
*Present address: Queensland Department of Primary Industries, Ayr. Queensland 4807, Australia.
ix
X
CONTRIBUTORS
MARK B. PEOPLES ( I S ) , Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research (Project SSOO), CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, Canberra, A . C . T . 2601, Australia A. EDWARD PERCIVAL (225), United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Southern Crops Research Laboratory, College Station, Texas 77840 R. W. RICKMAN ( 1 13), United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Columbia Plateau Conservation Research Center, Pendleton, Oregon 97801
PREFACE In the nearly 25 years I have had the privilege of editing this serial, it has been an inspiration to witness the desire and willingness of crop and soil scientists to prepare review articles for their compatriots. Scientists throughout the world have taken literally thousands of hours of their own time and energies to prepare articles for Advances in Agronomy gaining little but the satisfaction that they were doing a favor for their fellow scientists. They have indeed furthered the cause of science by writing these reviews. The authors of the nine articles in this volume have followed the tradition of their predecessors. Located at research institutions in six different countries, they maintain the international focus of this serial. The subjects covered vary from genetic resources of cereals and cotton to timing of seedling emergence and modeling of root growth and function. Two articles focus on tropical crops and agriculture as well as agro-forestry, subjects of keen concern as low-income farmers of the tropics struggle to increase food production while maintaining the quality of their environment and especially of their soils. Efforts to increase the host resistance of wheat and cowpeas are covered in two articles. These are evidence of the increasing focus on alternatives to the use of chemical pesticides to control plant pests. Host resistance is one of the characteristics evaluated in multilocational field trials around the world. The statistical analyses of such trials are the subject of another article in this volume. Thanks are due the advisory board of the American Society of Agronomy and the directors-general of three international agricultural research centers for suggesting topics and authors for this serial. To the 15 authors of the important reviews contained herein I express my special gratitude. N. C. BRADY
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 44
VARIATION IN TIME OF SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS: A FEATURE THAT DETERMINES INDIVIDUAL GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT L. R. Benjamin AFRC Institute of Horticultural Research Wellesbourne, Warwick CV35 9EF, England
Introduction Factors That Influence Time of Seedling Emergence A. Water B . Temperature C . Sowing Depth D . Seed Attributes E. Conclusions Ill. Importance of Variation in Time of Seedling Emergence to Crop Development A. Total Plant Growth B. Partitioning between Organs C . Organ Morphology and Composition D. Longevity IV. Conclusions References 1. 11.
I. INTRODUCTION The point in time when the growing point of a shoot emerges from the soil into the aerial environment is one of the most easily observed events in crop development. The range of percentage and timing of seedling emergence can be large, even in cultivated species, because emergence is the culmination of a large number of preceding events. For example, FinchSavage (1984) reported in carrots sown at eight different times between 1 1 February and 15 June in the United Kingdom that the number of days between the 10 and 90 percentile points for emergence ranged from 11 to 24. In noncultivated Umbelliferae. and in some cultivated Umbelliferae 1 Copyright Q 1990 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproductionin any form reserved.
2
L. R. BENJAMIN
species, there are also dormancy mechanisms that result in periodicity of emergence times (Roberts, 1979). Much attention has been directed to unraveling the complex interactions between the agronomic and genetic factors that influence seedling emergence. The salient features of these factors and their influence on variation in seedling emergence time will be reviewed here. Most plant communities are characterized by intense competition between individuals for growth resources, which leads to the development of dominance hierarchies (Watkinson, 1985; Benjamin and Hardwick, 1986; Weiner and Thomas, 1986). These hierarchies are important in crops because they contribute to variation in weight per plant, which is undesirable for a market that increasingly requires uniformly sized produce for processing and the fresh market (Anonymous, 1982), and can also contribute to loss of economic yield (Benjamin and Hardwick, 1986). The hierarchies are also important in natural communities because they contribute to size-dependent fecundity (Pacala and Slander, 1985; Watkinson et al., 1989) and to size-dependent mortality (Mithen et ul., 1984; Schmitt et ul., 1987; Thomas and Weiner, 1989). This review will examine the relevance of time of seedling emergence to the development of these hierarchies and seek mechanisms to account for any relationships.
II. FACTORS THAT INFLUENCE TIME OF SEEDLING EMERGENCE Crops have been bred and selected for genetic uniformity and elimination of seed dormancy mechanisms. Engineers have developed sophisticated equipment to produce good seedbed tilths and to sow seeds at uniform depth. So why should there be variation in times of seedling emergence? About a hundred papers are published annually on germination (Lovato, 1981) and this subject has been reviewed extensively (Koller, 1972; Heydecker, 1973; Harper, 1977; Heydecker and Coolbear, 1977; Johnston, 1979; Perry, 1982). The purpose of this review is not to make another exhaustive study but rather to examine the ideas that are implicit in most of these studies and to determine how much is already known about the causes of variation in time of seedling emergence. Although germination is a complex process, it has only three requirements: water, warmth, and a free exchange of gases. Seed dormancy is common in most species, but despite some notable exceptions, it has largely been overcome in commercial crops (Villiers,
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
3
1972; Maguire, 1983). Seeds are usually sown directly into soil, often at varying depths, and the subsequent germination is in conditions of fluctuating temperature and water supply. The effects of these factors on time of seedling emergence will be considered in the next sections. A. WATER Water influences the spread in time of seedling emergence in a number of ways. First of all, water is essential for germination, so any restriction on its supply reduces the rate and final percentage of seed germination. The supply of water to the seed is governed by the conductivity of the soil water (Collis-George and Sands, 1959; Williams and Shaykewich, 1971; Hadas and Russo, 1974a), the degree of seed-soil water contact (Sedgley, 1963; Manohar and Heydecker, 1964; Collis-George and Hector, 1966; Harper and Benton, 1966; Hadas and Russo, 1974a), and the osmotic and matric potentials (Collis-George and Sands, 1959, 1962; Manohar and Heydecker, 1964; Williams and Shaykewich, 1971; Dasberg and Mendel, 1971; El-Sharkawi and Springuel, 1979; Ross and Hegarty, 1979; Willat and Struss, 1979; Tipton, 1988). Increasing the supply of water can restrict the supply of oxygen that is necessary for germination. Oxygen is sparingly soluble and its solubility decreases with increasing temperature, whereas the metabolic demand for this gas increases with temperature. In addition, any complementary buildup of carbon dioxide has a poisoning effect on germination (Heydecker, 1958). Consequently, even slight excesses in the amount of moisture can have large inhibitory effects on germination (Heydecker et al., 1969; Dasberg and Mendel, 1971). Hanks and Thorp (1956) reported that emergence of wheat was restricted when the oxygen diffusion rate g cm-2 min-I. This corresponded to an air (ODR) fell below 75-100 x pore space of 16% in a silt clay and 25% in a fine-sandy loam. Subsequent work shows that the rate of germination is restricted by an ODR as little as 20 x lo-' g cmP2min-l (Dasberg and Mendel, 1971). Insufficient oxygen supply has been alleviated by coating seeds with calcium or zinc peroxides, or by incorporating calcium peroxide in the growing medium, but the beneficial effects varied greatly with species and occurred only when the moisture content of the growing medium was very high. Furthermore, the addition of peroxides in drier media often had a detrimental effect on germination and emergence (Brocklehurst and Dearman, 1983; Langan et af., 1986). Even if germination proceeds rapidly and uniformly, there can be a wide spread in time of seedling emergence due to a restriction of seedling growth
4
L. R. BENJAMIN
by the strength of the soil, which is largely governed by its water content (Arndt, 1965; Collis-George and Williams, 1968; Royle and Hegarty, 1977; Hegarty and Royle, 1978). In addition, slow drying gives closer packing of soil particles, resulting in high soil strengths (Gerard, 1965). However, the more important restriction to seedling emergence is the creation of crusts by surface drying (Hanks and Thorp, 1956,1957; Royle and Hegarty, 1977; Nuttall, 1982). Spread in time of emergence is determined by soil strength because the emergence force that seedlings exert develops dynamically and is a linear function of volumetric soil-water content and the cross-sectional area of the seedlings (Gerard, 1980). Taylor and Broeck (1988) measured the emergence force exerted by nine vegetable species at 25°C in sand at 15% moisture content and showed that the time taken to exert maximum force ranged from 4 hr in red beet to 21 hr in snap bean. Increasing the salinity of soil water caused a reduction in the size of the emergence force exerted by seedlings and increased the time required to exert the maximum force (Sexton and Gerard, 1982). Adding nitrogen fertilizers to soils has reduced percentage emergence, presumably because of osmotic effects (Hegarty, 1976a; Page and Cleaver, 1983). Nearly all studies of the effects of fertilizers on seedling growth have examined only final percentage emergence. However, Henriksen (1978)showed that addition of 75 or 150 kg N ha-' prior to sowing onions increased the standard deviation of emergence times by about half a day as well as reduced the percentage emergence compared with addition of the nitrogen after emergence. The salts that increase the salinity of the soil water can have the opposite effect of stimulating seedling growth by supplying essential mineral nutrients, such as phosphorus (Costigan, 1984). Most studies of seedling emergence have imposed constant soil moisture conditions. In nature, however, seeds are exposed to a fluctuating supply of water. This fluctuation affects variation in mean time of seedling emergence between populations in both weed (Roberts, 1984) and cultivated species (Hegarty, 1976b; Finch-Savage, 1986), but is also liable to be a major determinant of the individual-to-individual variation in time of seedling emergence within a population. B. TEMPERATURE In some species, seeds require exposure to low temperatures to break dormancy (see Roberts, 1972 for a review). All species show a qualitative relationship between germination parameters and temperature. The usual
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
5
responses are an approximately linear increase in rate (reciprocal in time taken to start of or some percentage of germination) with increasing temperature from a threshold to a maximum, with or without a plateau, followed by a linear decline at superoptimal temperatures. As a consequence of this linearity, it is convenient to describe the effect of temperature on the mean time of seedling emergence in terms of temperature sums (often erroneously called heat sums) (Hegarty, 1973; Bierhuizen and Wagenvoort, 1974; Garcia-Huidobro et al., 1982a). Only a few studies have examined the effect of temperature on the variability in the time of germination, but there is evidence in carrots that the spread in time of germination decreases with increase in temperature over the range 5°C to 25°C (Gray, 1979). In nature, seeds are exposed to fluctuating temperatures and, for noncultivated species, this might be a requirement for germination (Thompson, 1974). However, for most cultivated species, fluctuations in temperature have negligible practical effects on time of germination (Wagenvoort and Bierhuizen, 1977; Garcia-Huidobro et al., 1982b). In moist seedbeds, the rate of seedling emergence has a relationship with temperature similar to that described for germination (Muendel, 1986; Finch-Savage, 1986), and temperature sums have been used to describe the effects of temperature on the timing of emergence (Khah et al., 1986; Tenhovuori, 1986). However, the timing of seedling emergence is not governed entirely by the relationship between germination and temperature, because low temperatures also increase the time taken by seedlings to exert maximum force (Gerard, 1980). An example of this interaction between temperature and soil compaction was found in calabrese by Hegarty and Royle (1978). They showed that as temperature decreased from 20°C to 6"C, percentage emergence decreased from 93% to 78% when 0.6 N cm-* pressure had been applied, but the percentage emergence decreased from 90% to 33% when 4.8 N cm-* had been applied. The interaction between temperature and soil-water matric potential was quantified by Tenhovuori (1986), who showed that the temperature sum required for 50% emergence increased linearly above a threshold value as the soil-water matric potential increased. Gummerson ( 1989) examined the influence of seedbed preparation practices on the influence of moisture content, impedance, aeration, and temperature on the emergence of sugar beet. Of all four factors, he reported that temperature was the one that consistently limited rate of seedling emergence. There appear to be no studies that have quantified the relative importance of temperature for the spread in time of seedling emergence.
6
L. R. BENJAMIN
C. SOWING DEPTH The amplitude of diurnal variation in temperature lessens and the time of maximum and minimum daily temperature shifts with increasing depth (Orchard and Wurr, 1977). Hence, deep-sown seeds experience a more uniform temperature than shallow-sown seeds. Similar considerations would apply to moisture content of the soil. However, deep-sown seeds would be expected to take longer to emerge and small seeds often do not have the ability to penetrate through a deep layer of soil (Moore, 1943; Black, 1956; Stickler and Wassom, 1963; Arnott, 1969; Snyder and Filban, 1970; Bedford and MacKay, 1973; Wagenvoort and Bierhuizen, 1977; Abul-Fatih and Bazzaz, 1979; Buckley, 1982;Nuttall, 1982). This inability could be due to insufficient stored materials to generate the osmotic gradient necessary to overcome the pressure exerted by the soil (Black, 1956)or the seedling might be too weak to withstand the forces necessary to overcome the resistance of the soil, with the hypocotyl breaking as it drags the cotyledon through the soil (Rathore et al., 1981). Nuttall (1982) attributed better emergence of rape from small seeds to the requirement for less energy to push small cotyledons through the soil crusts. However, the differences in seed sizes were confounded with differences in cultivar in his experiments and the optimum sowing depths for cabbage, lettuce, carrot, and onion were 1.5-2.5 cm, despite differences between these species in seed size, presence of endosperm, and being mono- or dicotyledons (Heydecker, 1956). D. SEEDATTRIBUTES The previous sections have concentrated on the effects of the external environment on variation in time of seedling germination and emergence, but attributes of the seed also influence the rate of germination and emergence. Even in a favorable, uniform environment, seeds do not germinate synchronously but display a probability of germinating in a unit length of time (Thornley, 1977; Bould and Abrol, 1981).The effect of environmental factors such as temperature and water supply is to influence this probability of seed germination (Harper, 1977; Bould and Abrol, 1981). This stochastic nature might be an inevitable consequence of germination being a chain of many physical, biochemical, and physiological events (Thornley, 1977; Tipton 1984). For example, in carrots, germination was faster in seeds containing large embryos (from primary umbels) than in those containing small embryos (from secondary umbels) (Gray, 1979). Also the
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
7
standard deviation of germination time was less in seed lots with a low seed-to-seed variation in embryo length (mature seed lots) than in those containing variable embryo lengths (immature seed lots). Although dormancy is not considered to be a problem for germination in most cultivated species, it is well known in many natural species. Furthermore, there is a well-known inhibition of germination in some cultivated species by specific environmental stimuli. For example, light can inhibit germination of some cultivars of lettuce, tobacco, and tomato (Pollock, 1972). The corky capsules that surround beet seeds contain a watersoluble inhibitor to germination (but see Morris et al., 1984 for an opposing view). Carrot seeds were considered not to contain such inhibitors, but recent work on seed priming has revealed their presence (Pill and FinchSavage, 1988). Thus, these inhibitors of germination may be more ubiquitous in cultivated crops than previously suspected. Attributes of the seed also interact with environmental factors to determine the rate of germination. For example, Harper and Benton (1966) showed that the germination of all types of seeds was restricted by low matric potential when placed on sintered glass disks, but mucilaginous seeds were least sensitive, spiny reticulate seeds were the most sensitive, and smooth seeds showed a graded response to water tension. Small seeds were less sensitive to water tension than large seeds. Time of seedling emergence is controlled by genetic constitution (Eagles, 1988; Lafond and Baker (1986) and seed size (Lafond and Baker, 1986). However, some studies showed no effect of seed size on time of seedling emergence (Naylor, 1980; Stanton, 1984). These inconsistent results might be attributed to the use of different growing media in the different studies. The optimum seed-soil water contact for germination is achieved when the mean aggregate size of soil particles is one-fifth to one-tenth of the seed’s diameter (Hadas and Russo, 1974b). Adverse soil conditions might be partially overcome by using seeds that are “robust.” Some seed lots have persistently high field emergence over a wide range of soil conditions (Hegarty, 1974). Osmotic priming of seeds often improves seedling establishment, presumably by bringing all seeds to a uniformly mature state (see Bradford, 1986 for a review of this technique). It might be possible to breed for specific seed properties that favor germination, for example, small seeds and cracked testas (Whittington, 1978). However, these factors that favor germination might be detrimental to emergence of seedlings in field conditions. It is interesting to consider whether seed attributes or environmental factors dominate time of seedling emergence. Only a few studies have addressed this question directly, but indirect studies indicate an overriding importance of the environment. For example, varying soil texture has
8
L. R. BENJAMIN
large effects on seedling emergence (Hammerton, 1961 ;Wurr e f al., 1982). There are even large interactions between the method of watering (by capillary action or by surface watering) and soil moisture content on the percentage of seedling emergence (Heydecker, 1961). However, attributes of the seed can influence emergence in unexpected ways. For example, oil seed rape seedlings adapt to high soil impedance by decreasing the time taken to develop their full emergence force. This response to soil impedance was enhanced or inhibited by substances that affected ethylene production or action (Clarke and Moore, 1986). When such subtle interactions occur between seed and environment, it is perhaps naive to determine their relative importance. However, the relative importance of various attributes of seeds for variation in time of seedling emergence has been estimated (Waller, 1985). Waller collected seeds from cleistogamous (self-pollinating) and chasmogamous (cross-pollinating)flowers of jewelweed (Impatiens capensis) and found that between a third and a quarter of the variation in time of seedling emergence was associated with seed weight, seed type, maternal parent, and their interaction. E. CONCLUSIONS
Variation in time of seedling emergence arises because it is the culmination of a large number of preceding processes whose rates can differ between individuals. Differences between seeds in their genetic constitution, development on the mother plant, and exposure to extraneous factors, such as fungal attack, produce variation in time of germination in uniform environments. In nature, an additional source of variation in time of germination occurs from heterogeneity of the soil. Harper et al. (1965) suggested that germination of broadcast seeds depends on available sites of warmth and moisture. This idea is a useful concept also for buried seeds. Hegarty and Royle (1978) noted that there was greater seedling emergence in a dry soil that had been compacted than in a similar soil that had not been compacted. They speculated that compaction had improved the water supply to the seeds, presumably by increased seed-water contact, which effectively increased the number of sites for germination. Dasberg and Mendel (1971) claimed that “the rate of seed-water uptake governs germination. This rate is determined in general by the energy status of the water in the germination medium, by its conductivity, and by the area of contact between seed and medium, which is a function of pore geometry and surface tension.” Seed death is another important aspect of the effects of soil conditions on seedling emergence (Harper, 1955; Hegarty, 1978). In a system as multifaceted as the seed-soil complex, it is inevitable that
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
9
there is a wide spread in seedling emergence times, even in a crop sown synchronously (Hegarty, 1976b). The foregoing studies indicate that manipulation of any one of a number of processes would reduce the spread in time of seedling emergence, but no one treatment would produce synchrony of emergence. Spread in time of seedling emergence can be reduced by improved seed production techniques, by laboratory techniques to bring all seeds to maturity (priming), and by improved engineering to give uniform depth and optimum seed-soil contact in the seedbed. However, the most pragmatic way of reducing the spread in time of seedling emergence is to ensure a continued supply of soil moisture at a level that is optimum for germination during the period of imbibition, radicle emergence, and eruption of the shoots through the soil surface. The purpose of the rest of this review is to examine the importance of this spread in time of seedling emergence to the subsequent development of the plant community.
111. IMPORTANCE OF VARIATION IN TIME OF SEEDLING EMERGENCE TO CROP DEVELOPMENT In the remaining part of this review, I shall examine the importance of seedling-to-seedling variation in time of emergence within populations on the subsequent development of each plant. Although much work has been done to compare the effects of treatments that influence mean time of seedling emergence in separate populations (Hegarty, 1976b; Symonides, 1978; Gummerson, 1989), this is of little value for determining the importance of time of seedling emergence on the interactions between individuals within a population. Therefore, the remainder of the review will be confined to those few studies that examined the development of individual plants. Is the time of seedling emergence truly a boundary in the course of plant development, or is it just an event of no consequence to the plant but easily observed by humans? Certainly there is a switch from carbon for growth provided by the mobilization of seed reserves to carbon provided by photosynthesis. However, presumably some mineral nutrient and water absorption occurs through the roots of a seedling whose shoots have not yet broken the soil surface. Black and Wilkinson (1963) appear to be the only workers to have experimentally distinguished between time of seedling emergence and preemergence relative growth rate. Pregerminated subterranean clover seeds were sown either synchronously or in plots containing a mixture of
10
L. R . BENJAMIN
two sowing dates. In mixed sowing date plots, the plants were sown on a square grid with the early and late sowings alternating in a checkerboard design. The difference in sowing time was either 2, 4, or 8 days and the sowing positions were 1.5 cm apart. Despite sowing seeds carefully at uniform depth in boxes of compost, there was a spread in emergence time of 8 to 14 days for the early-sown plants and 5 to 10 days for the late-sown plants. Thus, there was a wide range of preemergence growth rates, which resulted in a wide overlap in the seedling emergence times from the different sowings. When the plants had a foliage height of 30 cm, the logarithm of dry weight was negatively correlated with time of seedling emergence. The novel point about this work was that the effect of time of sowing on the regression of weight per plant at harvest on seedling emergence time was examined and was found to have only a slight effect. Thus, time of seedling emergence, and not any correlation with preemergence growth rate, was responsible for the subsequent effects on plant weight. In the following sections the effect of time of seedling emergence on the growth, form, and composition of individuals in populations is examined.
A. TOTALPLANT GROWTH
At the point of seedlingemergence, plant weight is still minute compared with the potential and probable weight that the plant will attain. Plant growth at this time is nearly always exponential because there is virtually no self-shading or competition for growth resources from neighbors. Consequently, a difference of a few days in seedling emergence time can result in a manyfold difference in weight between plants. For example, Black and Wilkinson (1963)found that a delay in emergence of 5 days brought about a reduction in subterranean clover weight of about 50%, and a delay of 8 or 9 days produced a reduction in weight of at least 75%. Gray (1976) showed that, in lettuce at 26 days after sowing, seedlings that had emerged at 7 days were five to six times larger than those that had emerged at 15 days. When considering the importance of relative times of seedling emergence for the subsequent dry matter increment of individuals within a population, a number of factors have to be taken into consideration. First, the spread in time of seedling emergence in a population is important, but most studies relied on the natural spread in time of seedling emergence rather than attempting to modify it artificially. The time from seedling emergence to harvest is also relevant. As this time interval increases, there is a greater probability that individual plant growth will be influenced by some extraneous factor, for example, herbivory. Finally, the “state” of the population must be considered, such as the density of plants, or
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
11
whether the plants under consideration are a monoculture or part of a mixed-species population. Table I presents a summary of these factors and the percentage weight variation accounted for by spread in time of seedling emergence in a number of species. The percentage of weight variation associated with spread in time of seedling emergence was usually greatest when fewer than 20 days have elapsed between mean time of seedling emergence and harvest (Table I). (Gray, 1976; Benjamin, 1987). The paper by Benjamin (1982) (Table I) best illustrates how the percentage of weight variation associated with spread in time of seedling emergence increases as spread in time of seedling emergence increases. This trend is also seen in other work (Table I). Benjamin (1982) reduced the spread in time of carrot seedling emergence from 19 to 14 days by using a contact herbicide to kill the first seedlings to emerge. This treatment had no detectable effect on the frequency distribution of storage roots in different diameter grades, suggesting that relatively slight changes in spread of seedling emergence time have no detectable influence on variation in weight. Controlling time of seedling emergence might allow other sources of weight variability to be expressed more strongly. However, the residual sum of squares of root weight (after taking out the effect of emergence time) from plots that had small spreads in emergence times was no greater than the residual sum of squares from plots that had large spreads in emergence times (Benjamin, 1982). Therefore, there is no evidence that other sources of variation are able to express themselves to a greater extent when time of seedling emergence is controlled. The effect of density on the relationship between spread in time of seedling emergence and plant weight is difficult to interpret from Table I because the other factors were varied too. The very high percentage variation in weight associated with spread in time of seedling emergence reported by Ross and Harper (1972) is perhaps because they used extremely high densities (Table I). Benjamin (1982) showed that the increase in coefficient of variation (CV) of carrot shoot and storage root weight at wider spreads in seedling emergence time was greater at 400 than at 25 plants mP2. Ross and Harper (1972) noted that the last cocksfoot seedlings to emerge in a population growing at 30,000 plants m-’ had a weight only a little greater than that of seeds, even after 35 days of growth. The implication is that late-emerging seedlings are denied resources for growth by the earlieremerging plants and these competitive interactions are more intense at high densities. More direct evidence that relative time of seedling emergence determines the relative amount of growth resources that can be captured by an individual comes from a second experiment by Ross and Harper (1972) in
Table I Percentage Shoot Weight Variation Associated with Spread in Time of seedling Emergence
Species e
N
Dactylis glomerata Lactuca sativa
Spread in time of seedling emergence 10
Density (m-*)
Mean days from emergence to harvest
Accounted % variation
in weight
Notes
Reference
30,000
40
95
Ross and Harper
13 13 13 13 13 13 13
17 63 69 17
81 63 49 94
Gray (1976)
(1972) 9 9 9 11 11 6 5-10
Lolium perenne
-a
Impatiens capensis
23
24.48, or%
seedlings in 34 x 12cm tray 500- 1000
20
90
22 17
72 80
180
50
ca. 105
<1
Naylor (1980)
Fecundity measured, plants grouped into six emergence classes
Howell (1981)
Daucus carota
Lactuca sativa Daucus carota
Allium porrurn
Ludwigia leptocarpa Raphanus raphanistrum Beta vulgaris
a
Not stated.
25 and 400 25 and 400 25 and 400 9
ca. 120 ca. 120 ca. 120 ca. 33 ca. 117 ca. 27 ca. 75 ca. 140 ca. 259 110 ca. 50
3 4 72 61 25 11 22 ca. 0
21
ca.250 ca.250 ca.250 ca.250 18 18 1/23-cm pot 10 seeds in 10 x 10-cm tray 16
ca. 56
ca. 0
20 20 16 16 3
92 46 108 54 1/18-cm pot
11 93 8 80 77
44 39 83 58 ca. 0
3-5 6-1 1 15-21 ca. 10 19 19 43 43 11 11 18 3
5-10 7-23 16-48 0-12
Root weight measured Root weight measured Root weight measured Individual plants harvested from within crop when mature Root weight measured Root weight measured Root weight measured Root weight measured
Benjamin (1982) Wurr and Fellows (1983) Benjamin (1984a)
Benjamin (1984b) Dolan (1984) Fecundity measured, plants grouped into two emergence classes
Stanton (1985) Benjamin (1987)
14
L. R. BENJAMIN
which the growth of seedlings that had emerged at different times with and without the presence of neighbors was compared. Where neighbors were not present, then the difference in weights between plants that had emerged at different times was explained by the differences in durations of growth. However, where neighbors were present, then the late-emerging seedlings were smaller than expected from just their reduced period from emergence to harvest. Benjamin (1984~)grew carrots in either pure or mixed sowing date combinations at 400 plants m-*. The sowing dates were separated by a fortnight, thus ensuring different times of seedling emergence. At 35 days after the first sowing, the late-sown plants in mixed sowing date treatments had ceased growing, whereas there was no evidence that the late-sown plants in pure stand had ceased growth at the end of the experiment at 56 days. This experiment provides some of the strongest evidence that the rank each individual occupies in the hierarchy of sizes maintained by competition is largely determined by its time of seedling emergence relative to that of its neighbors. VanBaalen et al. (1984) set up a replacement series experiment with Scrophularia nodosa and Digitalis purpurea, species that have similar seed weights, but the former had a higher relative growth rate when grown in monoculture. The replacement series was repeated with the D. purpurea sown either at the same time as, 7 days earlier, or 7 days later than S . nodosa. They concluded that a delay of 1 day in the emergence of D. purpurea in mixed stand resulted in a 28% reduction in yield per plant, whereas a delay of 1 day in the emergence of S . nodosa gave a reduction in yield per plant of 5%. Therefore, the importance of spread in time of seedling emergence depends on the seedling relative growth rate, and perhaps the effect of given delay in the time of emergence on the growth of an individual should be “scaled” by the mean relative growth rate. The relative times of seedling emergence have been considered to be of importance in studies of competition between species. Nieto et al. (1968) first introduced the idea that there were critical periods in the development of crops during which the presence of weeds will suppress the growth of the crop, these critical periods being defined in terms of time after crop seedling emergence (Hewson and Roberts, 1971; Spitters and vandenBergh, 1982). Elberse and deKruyf (1979) set up replacement series experiments using Hordeum vulgare and Chenopodium album at a range of densities and with sowing the Chenopodium at various times before the Hordeum. They concluded that a difference of 15 days was the critical period; Hordeum outcompeted Chenopodium if Chenopodium was sown less than 15 days before Hordeum, but Chenopodium outcompeted
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
15
Hordeurn if sown move than 15 days before Hordeurn. The relative densities of the two species was of relatively minor importance to the outcome of these competitive interactions. More recently, Cousens et al. (1987) have developed a model to describe the relationship between crop yield and the combined effect of weed density and its time of seedling emergence relative to that of the crop. Some of the studies listed in Table 1 claimed to show that little of the variation in plant weight was associated with time of seedling emergence. How could this occur if the general tenet of this review is correct? Sometimes the lack of an association between plant weight and time of seedling emergence was because of a very low spread in time of seedling emergence (Dolan, 1984; Benjamin, 1987). The spread in time of seedling emergence in carrots in the study by Benjamin (1984a) was 19 days, yet only 3% weight variation at 33 days was associated with time of seedling emergence. However, in this study the vast majority of seedings (82%)emerged over only a 5-day period. The studies of Howell (1981) and Stanton (1985) were unable to show that spread in time of seedling emergence was important perhaps because they used fecundity rather than plant weight as a measure of plant performance, and they also classified seeding emergence date into a restricted number of categories. Sangakkara and Roberts (1986), in a competition study between grass species, argued that they had eliminated differences in time of seedling emergence between ryegrass, prairie grass, and cocksfoot by using transplants. They concluded that “competitive relationships seem to be determined by initial seedling size and the capacity to accumulate greater quantities of dry matter” and that “early emergence had no apparent effect in determining the competitive hierarchy established between these species.” However, they neglected the possibility that the different initial seedling sizes at the time of transplanting were a direct consequence of differences in time of seedling emergence. The bulk of the literature indicates that spread in time of seedling emergence is a major source variation in mature plant weight, probably because differences in emergence time have a large effect on seedling size at the point in time when plants start to compete with one another for growth resources. Time of seedling emergence has its largest effect when spread is large, when seedlings have a high relative growth rate (warm, moist conditions and fast-growing species), when between-plant competition is intense (at high plant densities), and when harvests are made not long after seedling establishment. In the following sections the effect that seedling emergence time might have on the morphology, physiology, and biochemistry of plants will be examined.
16
L. R. BENJAMIN
B. PARTITIONING BETWEEN ORGANS The previous sections have shown that the late-emerging seedlings become the smallest in the population and the ones most likely to be shaded by their neighbors. The position occupied by the foliage influences the temperature, humidity, and quantity and quality of light that shoots experience, which can have a large effect on the partitioning between organs. For example, Acock et al. (1979) showed that with increasing radiation or decreasing temperature, a greater percentage of dry matter is partitioned to the stem at the expense of the roots in chrysanthemums. This study shows that it is difficult to determine a general effect of late emergence on partitioning of dry matter because late-emergers will tend to have foliage both in the shade and at a lower temperature than early-emergers. Studies that examine the competition between species are relevant because between-species differences in plant stature might be analogous to the differences in stature within species caused by differences in time of seedling emergence. These studies also show conflicting effects of stature on partitioning of dry matter between organs. For example, Digitalis purpurea (a rosette-forming plant) grew more slowly and had a lower root : shoot ratio when grown in association with Scrophularia nodosa (a stem-forming plant) than when grown in monoculture (VanBaalen et al., 1984). In contrast, Hawthorn and Cavers (1982) reported that groups of Plantago major and P. rugelii plants, suppressed by the presence of larger neighbors, allocated a greater percentage of dry matter to the roots and caudices, whereas the larger plants devoted a greater proportion of dry matter to reproductive growth. Barnes (1979) presented extensive data from field experiments with carrots to show that at any given time there was a linear relationship between the logarithm of shoot weight and the logarithm of storage root weight, but the intercept of this relationship decreased with time. The variation in plant weight at any one time was largely due to the different imposed density treatments. The implication is that at any one instant, the relative growth rate of the shoots is a fixed proportion of that of the storage roots, but this proportion changes with time. Barnes reasoned that the shift in the relationship between shoot and storage root relative growth might be due to the lower maintenance respiration rate in storage organs. The expectation would be that plants derived from seedlings that had emerged at different times would exhibit different partitioning of photosynthates between organs because the plants were effectively of different ages. In a purely theoretical paper, Moms and Myerscough (1987) considered the effect of partitioning of dry matter between shoots and roots on the competition between plants in even-aged monocultures. They concluded
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
17
that the yield-density relationships could be influenced by shoot-root partitioning of dry matter, which implies that there could be complex feedback processes occurring in crops in which differences in time of emergence lead to differences in amounts of resources available to each plant, which in turn can lead to differences in shoot-root partitioning, which in turn leads to differences in the ability of plants to compete with their neighbors. Until data are presented to support this view, then the more simple assumption should hold, that is, suppressed plants adapt to allow them to scavenge resources not taken up by dominant plants (Robinson, 1986), but this adaptation does not deny resources to the dominant plants. Thus, there appear to be no studies that have examined the partitioning of dry matter between foliage and fibrous roots separately in plants derived from early- and late-emerging seedlings, but the effects of different emergence times on shoot-root partitioning might depend on the light intensity falling on the crop and the mineral status of its soil. C. ORGANMORPHOLOGYA N D COMPOSITION Iwaki (1959) made a large number of interesting observations on the effect of mixed or pure stands and the relative times of sowing on the canopy structure and weight of buckwheat (Fugopyrum esculentum) and green grams (Phaseolus uiridissirnus). In pure stands, buckwheat increases in weight slightly faster, and grows much taller, than green grams. In mixed stands there is a severe suppression of the growth of the green grams. This suppression is lessened by sowing the green grams earlier than the buckwheat, but a difference of 13 days was not sufficient to overcome the dominance of the buckwheat. An interesting feature of this study was that the canopy was harvested separately in 10-cm-deep strata, so that the effects of mixed and pure stand on canopy architecture could be examined. I have estimated the percentage of the photosynthetic system in each 10-cm band of the canopy from his Fig. 1 (Table 11). The plants growing in pure stand deployed over half their photosynthetic dry matter in the top 10-cm layer of the canopy, whereas the plants growing with buckwheat (which grew to a height of 120 cm) deployed their photosynthetic dry matter more uniformly along the length of the plant. However, these suppressed plants were nearly the same height as those in pure stand, but their total weight was less than half that of the pure stand plants (Table 11). Presumably similar morphological responses would occur where the cause of the dominance was a difference in time of seedling emergence. Perry (1985) reviewed the literature on competition in forest stands and
L. R. BENJAMIN
18
Table 11 Effect of Stand Type on the PhotosyntheticDry Matter (Percentage of the Entire Plant) at Various Heights above the Ground in a Crop of Green Grams” Stand type Height (cm) 0-10 10-20 20-30 30-40 40-50 Total (9) a
Sole
with Buckwheat
2
13
5 16
25 52 70
13
38 38 20
From Iwaki (1959).
included the morphological differences between dominant and suppressed trees. He concluded that shade leaves are larger and have more chlorophyll per unit area, and that sometimes the small trees have greater height and radial growth rates than their larger neighbors because of a lower respiration rate and higher specific leaf area. Dominant trees have larger and broader crowns, which allows them to maintain high rates of photosynthesis per tree, but at the expense of high maintenance respiration rate. Perry (1985) also pointed out that suppression of plant growth can influence the chemical composition of trees, with “reduced allocation of photosynthates to those chemical constituents that are energy-expensive.’’ To give an idea of the effects he quoted Chung and Barnes (1977), who determined the number of grams of glucose required to synthesize 1 g of the following substances in Pinus taedu: lipids, 3.02 g; phenolics, 1.92 g; lignin, 1.90 g; nitrogenous compounds, 1.58g; organic acids, 1.43 g; carbohydrates, 1.13 g. The more energy demanding compounds could be involved in deterring herbivory. Where insects and molluscs are the herbivores then the smallest plants in the community are most prone to predation (Perry, 1985; Gange et af., 1989; Thomas and Weiner, 1989), but where there are grazing mammals then the largest plants can be preferentially eaten (Weiner, 1988). Thus, the relative times of seedling emergence are likely to have a large effect on the shape and composition of plant organs. This is likely to be important in terms of the adaptation of plants to competition for growth resources. However, there are also commercial implications because there
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
19
is an increasing emphasis on the quality aspects of harvested produce, which includes its shape, size, and composition. For example, Wurr and Fellows (1983) showed that in studies with two cultivars of lettuce sown at three occasions, the heads of plants derived from late-emerging seedlings matured later than those derived from early-emerging seedlings. The results of these studies that follow the development of individual plants contrast strongly with those of Symonides (1978), who observed the year-to-year difference in the rate of development of five species contrasting in their rate and duration of development. Symonides (1978) found that the rate of development in all five species was faster in those years in which the date time of seedling emergence had been delayed because of climatic conditions. In this latter study, the development of the entire population rather than that of individual plants had been observed. Clearly, within populations, the tendency for accelerated development with late seedling emergence is overridden by the effects of competition with larger plants.
D. LONGEVITY There have been a number of studies that have demonstrated that the plants derived from late-emerging seedlings are more likely to die. For example, Stanton (1985) split a wild radish population into two emergence time cohorts. The early-emerging cohort consisted of larger plants and the probability of mortality before flowering was 0.21, but the corresponding value was 0.55 for the late cohort. vanderToorn and Pons (1988) studied the emergence patterns and survival of two Plantago species in plots in which other species (Poa triuialis, Phleum pratense, Alopecurus prarensis, Trifolium repens, and Ranunculus repens) had either been removed, clipped to a foliage height of 5 cm or 15 cm, or left unclipped. They reported a spread in seedling emergence times of 10 and 12 weeks for the two species. Seedlings that emerged earlier had higher survival rates, and there were greater survival rates in more open environments, with survival being positively correlated with the transmission of light in the different clipping treatments. Shaw and Antonovics (1987) made a population census of Slauia lyrata plants growing for nearly 3 years in pots. They reported that the plants that founded the population had the greatest chance of survival and produced the greatest number of seeds. Westoby and Howell (1986) approached the relationship between emergence time and mortality in a different way. They investigated whether the population structure of a community influenced the course of densitydependent self-thinning in radish. This course was described by graphs of logarithm of biomass per unit area plotted against logarithm of numbers of
20
L. R. BENJAMIN
surviving plants. When plants are self-thinning as a result of between-plant competition, the path of points on the graphs runs from bottom right (high density, low biomass) to top left (low density, high biomass). The slope of this path is claimed to be -4 (see White, 1980; Antonovics and Levin, 1980; Westoby, 1984 for reviews of self-thinning). Different population structures were achieved by making either a single sowing or two sowings separated by between 4 and 23 days in a pot. They concluded that the course of self-thinning in those pots that had a staggered sowing time was not consistently different from the course in the pots that had a single sowing. The implication is that plants derived from late-emerging seedlings are no more likely to die from competition with their neighbors than those derived from early-emerging seedlings. However, the relationship between mean weight of survivors and plant density varied greatly between the single sowing date pots in different experiments. This implies that this relationship is not sufficiently consistent to be used to distinguish between large differences in the probability of mortality of plants derived from early- and late-emerging seedlings. Indeed, Weller (1987) has now shown that many of the sets of data that were thought to support the -4 power law in fact do not have statistically significant correlations between logarithm of weight and logarithm of density.
IV. CONCLUSIONS Clearly, there can be a wide range of seedling emergence times, even in synchronously sown commercial crops. The causes of different times of seedling emergence are numerous, but the limited evidence suggests that in monocultures these preemergence processes are important only because they influence time of seedling emergence. This is an important hypothesis that deserves more attention and further experimental verification. If true, it replaces the plethora of possible interactions between individuals in monocultures by a simple measurable statistic, the relative times of seedling emergence. This statistic can be used as a predictor of future plant growth. If time of seedling emergence is to be used as a predictor of plant performance, there is a need for more consistent intervals of time into which emergence is classified. Where spread of emergence time is very wide, then seedlings that have emerged over several days often have been grouped, but more usually emergence is recorded daily. Consequently, comparisons between experiments have been made difficult because the time intervals into which seedlings were grouped have been inconsistent.
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
21
Strictly speaking, the relative weights of plants when establishment is complete are probably better predictors of future plant performance (Sangakkara and Roberts, 1986), but differences in weight between plants that emerge on the same day are likely to be small compared with the differences in weight between plants emerging on different days. An implicit assumption of this hypothesis is that the growth of plants after seedling emergence is largely under conditions in which individuals are competing with one another for growth resources, and the outcome of this contest for resources is determined by their relative weights. It is tempting to consider that this hypothesis can be extended to mixedspecies stands, but the work of Iwaki (1959) on competition between buckwheat and green grams shows that the faster rates of shoot elongation of buckwheat allowed this species to outcompete green grams even when the green grams had emerged several days prior to the buckwheat. Recent work by Ballare et ul. (1987) shows that the red:far red light ratio perceived by a seedling is modified by the presence of neighbors long before there is any between-seedling shading. This modification in the light regime was perhaps responsible for longer internode growth and lower leaf: stem dry weight ratio is Sinupsis seedlings grown on the sunlit side of a grass “fence” compared with seedlings grown on the sunlit side of a bleached grass “fence.” This implies that seedlings can detect and respond to the presence of neighbors before there is competition for resources. Thus, seedlings might modify their growth to allow them to partially overcome the disadvantage of late emergence. Relative time of seedling emergence is an important criterion for the future growth of plants, and its importance to plants has perhaps not been fully recognized. Further work is required to determine whether this importance is ubiquitous, generally true of all plant communities, true just of monocultures, or present just in special experimental conditions. Most evidence to date implies an importance in most monocultures and probably in many mixed-species stands. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I thank colleagues at IHR Wellesbourne for their criticisms of this manuscript.
REFERENCES Abul-Fatih, H. A., and Bazzaz, F. A. 1979. New Phytol. 83,817-827. Acock, B., Charles-EdwardsD. and Sawyer, S. 1979. Ann. Bot. 44,289-300. Anonymous. 1982. ‘‘Report on the Foot Industry and Technology, Cabinet Office Advisory Council for Applied Research and Development.” HMSO, London.
22
L. R. BENJAMIN
Antonovics, J., and Levin, D. A. 1980. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 11,411-452. Arndt, W., 1965. Ausr. J . Soil. Res. 3,55-68. Arnott, R. A. 1969. J . Er. Grussl. SOC.24, 104-110. Ballare, C. L., Sanchez, R. A,, Scopel, A. L., Casal, J. J. and Ghersa, C. M. 1987. Plunr Cell Environ. 10,551-557. Barnes, A., 1979. Ann. Eor. 43,487-499. Bedford, L. V., and MacKay, D. B. 1973. J . Nurl. Insr. Agric. Eor. (U.K.) 13,50-62. Benjamin, L. R. 1982. J . Agric. Sci. 98,537-545. Benjamin, L. R. 1984a. J . Agric. Sci. 102,69-77. Benjamin, L. R. 1984b. J . Agric. Sci. 103,527-537. Benjamin, L. R. 1984~.Ann. Eor. 53,549-557. Benjamin, L. R. 1987. J . Agric. Sci. 108,221-230. Benjamin, L. R.,and Hardwick, R. C. 1986. Ann. Eof.58,757-778. Bierhuizen, J. F., and Wagenvoort, W. A. 1974. Sci. Horfic. (Amsterdam) 2,213-219. Black, J. N. 1956. Ausr. J . Agric. Res. 7,98-109. Black, J. N., and Wilkinson, G. N. 1963. Ausf. J . Agric. Res. 14,628-638. Bould, A., and Abrol, B. K. 1981. Seed Sci. Technol. 9,601-61 I . Bradford, K. J. 1986. HortScience 21, 1105-1 112. Brocklehurst, P. A., and Dearman, J. 1983. Seed Sci. Technol. 11,293-299. Buckley, R. C. 1982. Eiorropicu 14,314-315. Chung, H., and Barnes, R. L. 1977. Can. J . For. Res. 7, 106-1 11. Clarke, C., and Moore, K. G. 1986. Ann. Eor. 58,363-369. Collis-George, N., and Hector, J. B. 1966. Ausr. J . Soil Res. 4, 145-164. Collis-George, N., and Sands, J. E. 1959. Aust. J . Agric. Res. 10,628-637. Collis-George, N., and Sands, J. E. 1962. Ausr. J . Agric. Res. W, 575-585. Collis-George, N., and Williams, J. 1968. Ausr. J . SoilRes. 6, 179-192. Cnstigan, P. A. 1984. Plunr Soil 79, 19!-201. Cousens, R., Brain, P., O’Donovan J. T., and O’Sullivan, P. A. 1987. Weed Sci. 35,720-725. Dasberg, S, and Mendel, K. 1971. J . Exp. Eor. 22,992-998. Dolan, R.W. 1984. Am. J . Eor. 71, 1302-1307. Eagles, H. A. 1988. Theor. Appl. Genet. 76,459-464. Elberse, W. T., and deKkruyf, H. N. 1979. Nerh. J . Agric. Sci. 27, 13-26. El-Sharkawi, H. M., and Springuel, I. V. 1979. Seed Sci. Technol. 7,27-37. Finch-Savage, W. E. 1984. J . Horfic. Sci.59,403-410. Finch-Savage, W. E. 1986. J . Agric. Sci. 107,249-256. Gange, A. C., Brown, V. K., Evans, I. M., and Storr, A. L. 1989. J . Ecol. 77,537-551. Garcia-Huidobro, J., Monteith, J. L., and Squire, G. R. 1982a. J . Exp. Eor. 33,288-296. Garcia-Huidobro, J., Monteith, J. L., and Squire, G. R. 1982b. J . Exp. Eor. 33,297-302. Gerard, C. J. 1%5. Soil Sci. SOC.A m . Proc. 29,641-645. Gerard, C . J. 1980. Agron. J . 72,473-476. Gray, D. 1976. Ann. Appl. Eiol. 82,569-575. Gray, D. 1979. Seed Sci. Technol. 7, 169-178. Gurnmerson, R. J. 1989. J. Agric. Sci. 112, 159-169. Hadas, A., and Russo, D. 1974a. Agron. J . 66,643-647. Hadas. A., and Russo, D. 1974b. Agron. J . 66,647-652. Hammerton, J. L. 1961. J . Agric. Sci.56,213-228. Hanks, R.J., andThorp, F. C. 1956. SoilSci. SOC.A m . Proc. 20,307-310. Hanks, R.J., andThorp, F. C. 1957. SoilSci. Soc. Am. Proc. 21,357-359. Harper, J. L. 1955. Ann. Appl. Eiol. 43,696-708.
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
23
Harper, J. L. 1977. “Population Biology of Plants,” pp. 111-147. Academic Press, London. Harper, J. L., and Benton, R. A. 1966. J . Ecol. 54, 151-166. Harper, J. L . , Williams, J. T., and Sagar, G. R. 1965. J . Ecol. 53,273-286. Hawthorn, W. R., and Cavers, P. B. 1982. Can. J. Bot. 60,2424-2439. Hegarty, T. W. 1973. I n “Seed Ecology” (W. Heydecker, ed.), pp. 411-432. Butterworth, London. Hegarty, T. W. 1974. J . Hortic. Sci. 49, 189-1%. Hegarty, T. W. 1976a. J . Sci. Food Agric. 27, %2-968. Hegarty, T. W. 1976b. J . Hortic. Sci. 51, 133-146. Hegarty, T. W. 1978. Acta Hortic. 83,297-308. Hegarty, T. W., and Royle, S. M. 1978. J. Appl. Ecol. 15,897-904. Henriksen, K . 1978. Acta Hortic. 72, 69-78. Hewson, R. T., and Roberts H. A. 1971. J. Hortic. Sci. 46,471-483. Heydecker, W. 1956. J . Hortic. Sci. 31,76-88. Heydecker, W. 1958. Nature (London) 181, 1140-1 141. Heydecker, W. 1%1. I n “Advances in Horticultural Science and Their Applications, Proceedings of the XVth International Horticultural Congress, Nice, 1958” (J.-C. Garnaud, ed.), Vol. 1, pp. 381-392. Pergamon, Oxford. Heydecker, W. 1973. Univ. Nottingham Sch. Agric. Rep. 1973/1974 50-67. Heydecker, W., and Coolbear, P. 1977. Seed Sci. Technol. 5,353-425. Heydecker, W., Orphanos, P. I., and Chetram, R. S. 1969. Proc. I n t . Seed Test. Assoc. 34, 297-304. Howell, N. 1981. A m . Mdl. Nat. 105, 312-320. Iwaki, H. 1959. Jpn. J . Bot. 17, 120-138. Johnston, M. E. H. 1979. I n “Advances in Research and Technology of Seeds” (J. R. Thompson, ed.), Part 4, pp. 43-83. PUDOC, Wageningen, Netherlands. Khah, E. M., Ellis, R. H., and Roberts, E. H. 1986. J . Agric. Sci. 107,431-438. Koller, D. 1972. I n “Seed Biology” (T. T. Kozlowski, ed.), pp. 1-101. Academic Press, New York. Lafond, G. P., and Baker, R. J. 1986. Crop Sci. 26,341-346. Langan, T. D., Pendleton, J. W., and Oplinger, E. S. 1986. Agron. J . 78,769-772. Lovato, A. 1981. I n “Advances in Research and Technology of Seeds” ( J . R. Thompson, ed.), Part 6, pp. 86-120. PUDOC, Wageningen, Netherlands. Maguire, J. D. 1984. I n “Advances in Research and Technology of Seeds” (J. R. Thompson, ed.), Part 9, pp. 25-60. PUDOC, Wageningen, Netherlands. Manohar, M. S., and Heydecker, W. 1964. Nature (London) u12,22-24. Mithen, R., Harper, J. L., and Weiner, J. 1984. Oecologia 62,57-60. Moore, R. P. 1943. J. A m . SOC.Agron. 35,370-381. Moms, P. C., Grierson, D., and Whittington, W. J. 1984. J . Exp. Bot. 35, 994-1002. Moms, E. C., and Myerscough, P. J. 1987. Ann. Bot. 59,629-633. Muendel, H.-H. 1986. Agron. J. 78,765-769. Naylor, R. E. L. 1980. New Phytol. 84,313-318. Nieto, J. H., Brondon, M. A., and Gonzalez, J. T. 1968. PANS C14, 159-166. Nuttall, W. F. 1982. Agron J . 74, 1018-1022. Orchard, T. J., and Wurr, D. C. E. 1977. Sci. Hortic. 6, 179-184. Pacala, S . W., and Slander, J. A. 1985. A m . Nat. 125,385-41 1. Page, E. R., and Cleaver, T. J. 1983. J. Sci. Food Agric. 34, 13-22. Perry, D. A. 1982. Sci. Hortic (Canterbury, Engl.) 33, 67-75.
24
L. R. BENJAMIN
Perry D. A. 1985. In “Attributes of Trees as Crop Plants” (M. G. R. Cannell and J. E. Jackson, eds.), pp. 481-506. Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Huntingdon, England. Pill, W. G., and Finch-Savage, W. E. 1988. Ann. Appl. Biol. 113,383-389. Pollock, B. M. 1972. In “Viability of Seeds” (E. H. Roberts, ed.), pp. 164-165. Chapman & Hall, London. Rathore, T. R., Ghildyal. B. P., and Sachan, R. S. 1981. PI. Soil62,97-105. Roberts, E. H. 1972. In “Viability ofSeeds” (E. H. Roberts, ed.), pp. 321-359. Chapman and Mull, London. Roberts, H. A. 1979. J. Appl. Ecol. 16, 195-201. Roberts, H. A. 1984. Ann. Appl. Biol. 105,263-275. Robinson, D. 1986. Ann. Bot. 58,841-848. Ross, H. A., and Hegarty, T. W. 1979. Ann. Boi. 43,241-243. Ross, M. A., and Harper, J. L. 1972. J . Ecol. 60,77-88. Royle, S . M., and Hegarty, T. W. 1977. J . Hortic. Sci. 52,535-543. Sangakkara, U. R., and Roberts, E. 1986. J . Agron. Crop Sci. 156,279-284. Schmitt, J., Eccleston, J., and Ehrhardt, D. W. 1987. J. Ecol. 75,651-665. Sedgley, R. H. 1%3. Ausi. J. Agric. Res. 14,646-653. Sexton, P. D., and Gerard, C. J. 1982. Agron. J. 74,699-702. Shaw, R. G . , and Antonovics, J. 1987. New Phyiol. 107,415-426. Snyder, F. W., and Filban, C. 1970. J . A m . SOC.Sugar Beet Technol. 15,703-708. Spitters, C. J. T., and vandenBergh, J. P. 1982. In “Biology and Ecology of Weeds’’ (W. Holzner and N. Numata, eds.), pp. 137-148. Junk, The Hague. Stanton, M. L. 1984. Ecology 65, 1105-1 112. Stanton, M. L. 1985. Oecologia 67,524-531. Stickler, F. C., and Wassom, C. E. 1%3. Agron. J . 55,78. Symonides, E. 1978. Ekol. Pol. 26,273-286. Taylor, A. G., and Broeck, C. W. T. 1988. HoriScience 23,367-369. Tenhovuori, M. 1986. J. Agric. Sci. Finl. 58, 185-192. Thomas, H. 1972. In “Viability of Seeds” (E. H. Roberts, ed.), pp. 370-372. Chapman & Hall, London. Thomas, S. C., and Weiner, J. 1989. J . Ecol. 77,524-536. Thompson, P. A. 1974. J. Exp. Boi. 25, 156-163. Thornley, J. H. M. 1977. Ann. Boi. 41, 1363-1365. Tipton, J. L. 1984. J . A m . SOC.Horiic. Sci. 109,451-454. Tipton, J. L. 1988. J . A m . SOC. Hortic. Sci. 1l3, 129-133. VanBaalen, J., Kuiters, A. T. and vanderwoude, C. S. C. 1984. Oecol. Plant. 5,279-290. vanderToorn, J., and Pons, T. L. 1988. Oecologia 76,341-347. Villiers, T. A. 1972. In “Seed Biology” (T. T. Kozlowski, ed.), pp. 220-281. Academic Press, New York. Wagenvoort, W. A., and Bierhuizen, J. F. 1977. Sci. Horiic. 6,259-270. Waller, D. M. 1985. New Phytol. 100,243-260. Watkinson, A. R. 1985. In “Studies on Plant Demography: A Festschrift for John L. Harper” (J. White, ed.), pp. 275-289. Academic Press, London. Watkinson, A. R., Lonsdale, W. M., and Andrew, M.H. 1989. J. Ecol. 77, 162-181. Weiner, J. 1988. In “Plant Population Biology” (A. J. Davy, R. J. Hutchings, and A. R. Watkinson, eds.), pp. 59-81. Blackwell, Oxford. Weiner, J., and Thomas, S. C. 1986. Oikos 47,211-222. Weller, D. E. 1987. Ecol. Monogr. 57,23-43. Westoby, M. 1984. Adv. Ecol. Res. 14, 167-225. Westoby, M., and Howell, J. 1986. J . Ecol. 74,343-359.
SEEDLING EMERGENCE WITHIN POPULATIONS
25
White, J. 1980. In “Demography and Evolution in Plant Populations” (0.T. Solbrig,ed.), pp. 21-48. Blackwell, Oxford. Whittington, W. J. 1978. Acra Horric. 72, 39-47. Willat, S. T., and Struss, R. G. 1979. Ann. Bor. 43,415-422. Williams, J., and Shaykewich, C. F. 1971. J . Exp. Bor. 22,586-597. Wurr, D . C. E., and Fellows, J. R . 1983. J . Horric. Sci. 58, 561-566. Wurr, D. C. E., Fellows, J. R., and Gray, D. 1982. J . Agric. Sci. 99, 123-129.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 44
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES: THEIR MANAGEMENT AND CONTRIBUTION TO THE NITROGEN ECONOMY OF WET AND HUMID TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS Graeme Blair, David Catchpoole,’ and Peter Horne Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research Department of Agronomy and Soil Science University of New England Armidale, New South Wales 2351, Australia
1. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction Species of Useful Tree Legumes Agronomic Performance of Tree Legumes Tree Legume Leaf as Animal Feed Management of Tree Legumes A. Age of First Cutting B. Cutting Height C. Cutting Frequency D. Density E. Interaction between Density and Cutting Management VI. Nitrogen Yields of Material Harvested from Tree Legumes VII. Nitrogen Recycling via Leaf and Excreta VIII. Conclusion References
I. INTRODUCTION Although herbaceous legumes usually form the basis of temperate pasture, tropical herbaceous legumes are renowned for their inability to persist under heavy grazing; in this context, tree and shrub legumes have been
’
Present address: Queensland Department of Primary Industries, Ayr. Queensland 4807, Australia. 21 Copyright 0 1990 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
28
GRAEME BLAIR ET AL.
increasingly proposed as a more suitable alternative (Anning, 1980; Jones et al., 1982; Jones and Jones, 1982; Brewbaker, 1986). In many areas of the wet and humid tropics, ruminant animals are not permitted to graze freely, but instead are tethered or kept in pens and cages, and feed is brought to the animals. Generally, feed for these animals is cut from areas unsuitable or unavailable for cropping, for example, hillsides or roadside verges and other public “common” land, and as such is often of poor nutritive value. Rarely is there any effort made by farmers to deliberately plant forage species, because of the perception that any improvement in draft power and animal production does not compensate for a reduction in the area available for cropping. In this context, leguminous trees can play a vital role in improving the nutritive value of the animal feed.
II. SPECIES OF USEFUL TREE LEGUMES There has been increasing recognition by scientists within the past few decades of the potential of tree legumes to increase agricultural and silvicultural production (Felker and Bandurski, 1979), especially in Third World countries where nitrogenous fertilizers are often too expensive for purchase by farmers. It is particularly in the poorer countries of the wet and humid tropics that increased adoption of management systems incorporating N-fixing tree legumes can result in improved human nutrition and living standards. Brewbaker and Styles (1982) listed 37 leguminous tree species they considered to be of major importance and 26 of minor importance. Halliday and Nakao (1982) prepared a list of more than lo00 woody species (legume and nonlegume) thought to have the potential for nitrogen fixation. Tropical leguminous trees have been used to various degrees as sources of fodder, fuelwood, or timber for many years in Africa, Asia, Australia, and the Americas. The increasing attention given them is reflected in the number of institutions conducting research on their use in those areas (Van den Beldt and Huxley, 1982). Some species are now widely distributed and used outside their country of origin. Notable examples include Leucaena spp. and Gliricidia sepium, which originated from Central America and are now important components of agricultural systems in many countries of Asia and Africa (Brewbaker and Styles, 1982; Sumberg, 1985). Growth of species introduced into new areas is often better than in the area of origin because of the absence of native pests and diseases (Whiteman, 1980). This quarantine can last for varying periods, but, once an outbreak of disease or insect attack occurs, it can have a serious effect on
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
29
plant performance. This has occurred recently in many parts of the Pacific and Southeast Asia, where the leaf psyllid (Heteropsylfa cubana) has attacked Leucaena leucocephala and caused severe yield reductions. Leucaena leucocephala has received the most attention, probably because of its popularity and multiplicity of uses (forage, human food, green manure, fuelwood, timber) (Brewbaker and Hutton, 1979; CSIRO, 1979; Delpeche et al., 1979; Mendoza and Javier, 1980; Chandrasekaran, 1981; Dutt, 1981; Mendoza et al., 1981; Chee and Devendra, 1983; Pathak and Patil, 1983; Pound and Martinez-Cairo, 1983; Prussner, 1983; Bray, 1984), but there is still relatively little information available on methods of cultivation and harvesting. In an attempt to help researchers become aware of other work currently being undertaken with Leucaena, since 1980 the Nitrogen Fixing Tree Association (NFTA) has published preliminary research results in annual volumes of “Leucuenu Research Reports.” Since 1983, NFTA has also published annually the research communications on other species in “Nitrogen Fixing Tree Research Reports.” The U.S. National Academy of Sciences has published general information on Leucaena (NAS, 1977, 1984), Calliandra (NAS, 1983c),Acacia (NAS, 1983b),and fuelwood trees (NAS, 1980, 1983a). Detailed species descriptions of many tropical forage tree legumes are contained in Skerman (1977). Evans and Rotar (1987a,b) reviewed the role of Sesbania spp. in agricultural systems, particularly in Third World countries. In addition to supplying forage, fuelwood, and timber, sometimes the foliage, flowers, and pods of tree legumes are used as a vegetable (NAS, 1977),and for some species the high concentration of certain chemicals has warranted consideration as sources of pharmaceuticals and other chemicals (NAS, 1977; Brewbaker and Styles, 1982; Romeo, 1984). Leguminous trees are often planted to provide shade for plantation crops. Leucaena is widely used in this role for crops such as coffee, cacao, tea, cinchona, citrus, and nutmeg (NAS, 1977). Sometimes the tree legume also functions as a support for climbing crops, for example, Gliricidia sepiurn has been used as a support tree for cultivation of vanilla (Alconero ef af., 1973). Tree legumes have the greatest potential to increase the quality and level of protein in the diet of people in Third World countries when it is used as a source of feed for animals.
Ill. AGRONOMIC PERFORMANCE OF TREE LEGUMES Leucaena has been shown to be extremely high yielding in a range of locations, with annual forage dry matter yields of 26.8 t ha-’ in Fiji
30
GRAEME BLAIR ET A L .
(Partridge and Ranacou, 1973), 11.5 t ha-' in Japan (Kitamura, 1986), 12.9 t ha-' in Australia (Ferraris, 1979), 14.3 t ha-' in Hawaii (Evensen, 1984), 14.2 t ha-' in Thailand (Topark-Ngarm, 1983), 8.4 t ha-' in the first year of growth in Indonesia (Ella et al., 1989), and 15.6 t ha-' ha-' over a 2.5-year period in Indonesia (Catchpoole and Blair, 1990a). There are very few reports of forage yields from other species. Holm (1972) obtained 7.2 t DM ha-' year-' from Sesbania grandijlora in Thailand. Chadhokar and Lecamwasam (1982) reported Gliricidia leaf fresh weight yield in Sri Lanka in excess of 40 t ha-', with dry matter percentage of leaf ranging between 20% and 23%. Gutteridge and Akkasaeng (1985) compared the growth of 15 tree species during the first 6 months after planting. Sesbania formosa and Sesbania sesban gave the best yields, whereas Sesbania grandijlora was comparable to Leucaena leucocephala and Calliandra calothyrsus. Evans and Rotar (1987b) also obtained comparable fodder yields from various perennial Sesbania species, Calliandra calothyrsus, and Leucaena leucocephala, during the first year after establishment. Little information is available on the best means of establishment and subsequent management practices for most species (Maasdorp and Gutteridge, 1986), although researchers with Leucaena have addressed such topics as rhizobiology (Diatloff, 1973; Jarvis, 1981; Bushby, 1982; Manjunath et al., 1984; Sanginga et al., 1986), response to pH (Ahmad and Ng, 1981; Norani and Ng, 1981),effect of CaC03 (Hutton and Andrew, 1978; Tham et al., 1977),nutrition and symptoms of nutrient deficiency (Gonzales et al., 1980; Haag and Mitidieri, 1980),and methods of establishment (Pound et al., 1980a,b;Pound and Santana, 1980; Falvey, 1981; Cooksley, 1981; 1982; Oakes, 1984; Olvera and Blue, 1985; Olvera and West, 1985). In an evaluation of 16 tree legumes conducted over a 4-year period in South Sumatra, Indonesia, Blair et al. (1988) found that after a 2-year establishment period, leaf yields were highest in Acacia mangium; this declined with time such that the highest total leaf production was recorded in Cassia siamea (Fig. 1). For another species comparison experiment conducted in South Sulawesi, Indonesia, Catchpoole and Blair ( 1990a) recorded leaf yields of 18.2, 19.2, 21.8, and 6.7 t DM ha-' in C. calothyrsus, G. sepium, L . leucocephala, and S . grandi3ora over a 14-month period from establishment. The high yield in Leucaena was recorded prior to the arrival of psyllids in this part of Indonesia. Forage yields per hectare are likely to be maximized if the shrub legumes are in a mixture with an understory of herbaceous pasture species, through increased efficiency of utilization of light and soil moisture (Gray, 1970). In an experiment conducted in Indonesia, Catchpoole and Blair (199Oa)
31
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS 1800r
1600
0 Feb. '82 to Ian. '84
-
a JM.
'84 to Fcb. '85
69 Feb. '85 to Apr. '86
1400 -
e .
1200
-
t . 4 d .
n
1000-
M
Y
U
Ix
800-
L
3
600
-
400
-
200 -
-
FIG. 1. Leaf production (g DM per tree) of the ten most productive species for three growth periods at Nakau, South Sumatra.
Table I
Dry Matter Yields (t ha-') over a 14-Month Period of TreelGrass Mixtures and Monocultures at Gowa, South Sulawesi, Indonesia"
Leaf DM Stem DM Total legume DM Grass DM Edible DM' Total DM
Tree monoculture
Treelgrass mixture
Grass monoculture
18 .74""
16.92" 9.18' 26. 10" 7.82" 24.74" 33.92"
12.00" 12.00" 12.00'
10.26" 29.00" 18.74" 29.00" ~
" From Catchpoole and Blair (]!Ma).
" Means within a row with the same letter are not significantly different ( p < .05). Edible DM = legume leaf DM and grass DM.
32
GRAEME BLAIR ET AL.
found that undersowing leguminous trees (Leucaena, Calliandra, Glirici&a) with Panicum maximum cv. Riverdale increased the dry matter yield of edible forage from 18.7 to 24.7 t ha-' over a 14-month period (Table I). In another Indonesian experiment, Horne and Blair (1990) found that although the quantity of light penetrating to 20 cm above the soil surface was similar in mixtures of Leucaena cut to 100 cm with Setaria sphacelata (HLSET) or Pennisetum purpureum (HLPEN) and Leucaena cut to 30 cm with Setaria (LLSET) or Pennisetum (LLPEN), the shape of the light profile was markedly different (Fig. 2) and the canopy within each stratum had a very different grass-legume composition.
b
a
-8 v
& 8
210
170
Leucaena Leaf
130 90
60
60 40 20 0 Relallve Irradlance (100 I/Io)
100
80
60
1
I
1
I
I
4 0 20 0 Reletlve lrradlanae (100 1/10) 60
80
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
20
40
60
0
20
40
60
80
?!z5l d
C
210
170 h
8
130
2M
90
.r.
4
t
100
0
210
v
Light proflle
p---o
90
50
GO
10100
80
60
20
40
Relallve lrradiance (100 I
1
I
0 1/10)
I
10100
80
60
20
40
0
Relative lrradiance (100 I/lo) f
I
I
I
20 40 60 0 20 40 60 C Leaf D.M. (kg ha-ld-') C Leaf D.M. (kg lia-'d-') FIG. 2. Mean light profiles of the mixtures and downward cumulative leaf dry matter production. (Z leaf) in the canopies of (a) HLSET, (b) LLSET, (c)HLPEN, and (d) LLPEN. Horizontal bars indicate standard errors of relative irradiance means. 0
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
33
The poor performance of low-cut Leucaena in both mixtures resulted largely from competitive interference for light. Pennisefum,although slow to recover from cutting, was able to produce a tall canopy that severely shaded low-cut Leucaena for most of each growth period. Examination of the mixture and monoculture leaf yields in the experiment of Home and Blair (1990) illustrates the “trade-off” that occurs between the legume and the grass in mixtures. The data presented in Table I1 compare the total leaf yields obtained from the mixtures over the 1-year experimental period with the potential yields obtained when the same land area was subdivided evenly between monocultures of the component species (the 50 : 50 monoculture option). Forage from all four monoculture options consisted of approximately 30% Leucaena leaf, a percentage widely considered to be optimal for ruminant production (Pound and Martinez-Cairo, 1983). Although total forage yields were higher from the low-cut Leucaena mixtures than from their monoculture options, Leucaena leaf made up no more than 12% of the total forage. The reason for this low percentage contribution, compared with the monoculture options, is the unexpectedly good performance of low-cut Leucaena in monoculture and its poor performance in mixtures. There are many reports in the literature that low cutting has an adverse effect on Leucaena leaf and stem yields and these have been summarized by Home e f al. (1986). Although successful incorporation of shrub legumes into an existing herbaceous pasture might prove difficult (Shaw, 1965), herbaceous species could be added to an established stand of shrub legumes by oversowing (Jones et al., 1982). A mixture of shrub legumes and grass also helps to provide an appropriate mixed diet for grazing ruminants (Jones and Bray, 1983) and would help reduce erosion on sloping land. In an experiment of Catchpoole and Blair (1990a), the undersowing of tree legumes with Panicum maximum did not increase the edible N yield of
Table 11 Total Leaf Dry Matter Yields (t ba-’ year-’) from the Mivtures and Potential Yields from the 50 :50 Monoculture Option Mixture
LLPEN HLPEN LLSET HLSET
50 : 50 monoculture
Leucaena
Grass
Total
Leucaena
Grass
Total
0.8 4.2 2.2 8.2
15.2 10.7 16.3 6.2
16.0 14.9 18.5 14.4
4.2 4.3 4.2 4.3
9.3 9.3 10.4 10.4
13.5 13.6 14.6 14.7
34
GRAEME BLAIR ET AL.
the system (652 kg ha-' year-'). Where grass was grown as a monoculture, the edible N yield was only 88 kg ha-'. Another approach is to fence off stands of shrub legumes and to control stocking of the shrub legume pastures and larger areas of herbaceous pasture in a rotation system, to enable optimum use of each pasture resource (Shaw, 1968; Blunt and Jones, 1977; Anonymous, 1981; Paterson et al., 1982; Foster and Blight, 1983). Judicious use of the shrub legume component would enable high-quality feed to be accumulated for use during dry periods (Jones and Bray, 1983). Another grazing system proposed for Leucaena (Wildin, 1980)is to grow the legume as tall trees and to allow grazing of the lower branches and seedlings under the canopy by stock. However, much research is needed to work out the best management system for animals grazing shrub legume pastures, such as size and arrangement of paddocks, time and frequency of grazing, stocking rates, tree spacing, and fertilizer requirements. The ultimate measure of pasture productivity is animal production itself.
IV. TREE LEGUME LEAF AS ANIMAL FEED Many plant species probably form a part of the diet of domestic animals at some time, but Table 111 can be used as a guide to the number of leguminous shrub and tree species used regularly as a source of feed. Often trees and shrubs are only used for feed during drought, or other times when herbaceous material is unavailable (Gray, 1970). A notable exception is Leucaena leucocephala, which can be harvested year-round to provide forage for penned animals in a cut-and-carry feed system (NAS, 1984).
Table 111 Nitrogen-Fixing Tree and Shrub Legumes Used for Forage" Mimosoideae
No. spp.
Papilionoideae
No. spp.
Caesalpinoideae
No. spp.
Acacia Paraserianthes Desmodium Leucaena Pithecellobium Pterocarpus Prosopis
12 1
Cajanus Chamaecytisus Desmanthus Gliricidia Medicago Pangamia Robinia
1 I I I 1
Parkinsonia Calliandra Erythrina Sesbania
1 1 2
I 5 1
2 4
After Brewbaker (1986).
I 1
4
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
35
When animals are maintained in low-quality roughage such as rice straw, the inclusion of high-protein tree legume leaf can have a significant effect on animal performance. An obstacle to the widespread acceptance of tree legumes as forage sources has been low quality or palatability (Jones, 1979; Minson and Wilson, 1980; D'Mello, 1982; Brewbaker, 1986). Chemical analyses and digestibility data of leaf of Leucaena leucocephala, Gliricidia sepium, and Sesbania grand;Jlora have been reported by Holm (l973), Adenaye (1979), Minson and Wilson (1980), and Ekpenyong (1986). Vercoe (1989) has presented data on 39 Australian tree and shrub species. Palatability and acceptance by stock are generally not a problem with Leucaena (Bray, 1984), but problems of stock acceptance of other tree legume species have been reported (Skerman, 1977). Gliricidia has been used as a feed supplement for sheep (Chadhokar and Kantharaju, 1980) and dairy cattle (Chadhokar and Lecamwasam, 1982). Carew (1983) showed that Gfiricidiaas the sole dry season diet for dwarf sheep was able to maintain them for a continuous period of 21 weeks, despite an initial drop in liveweight. There is a paucity of published information on the feed quality of other species, despite their potential as sources of high-protein feed for ruminant animals. Most of the literature reporting liveweight gains of animals grazing shrub legumes documents research predominantly undertaken in Queensland, Australia, with Leucaena. Jones and Bray (1983) have summarized research in Australia on animal production from grazed Leucuena pastures. Results from these experiments were obtained before Jones and Lowry (1984) showed that the mimosine toxicity problem in Australian ruminants could be overcome by infusion of rumen fluid from Indonesian ruminants. Jones and Bray (1983) surmised that elimination of Leucaena toxicity would result in a marked improvement in animal production. Despite the toxicity problem, Falvey (1976) reported that a Leucaena-Cynodon dactylon pasture in the Northern Territory of Australia resulted in higher liveweight gains than were obtained from heifers grazing Townsville stylo-Panicum maximum pastures. Jones and Jones (1982) reported annual liveweight gains of cattle grazing Leucaena-Setaria pastures of 3 1 1 kg ha-' compared t o 200 kg ha-' from Siratro-Setariu pastures. In Malaysia, Wong et af. (1983) reported that liveweight gains of cattle rotationally grazing a Leucaena-Brachiaria decumbens mixture were comparable to liveweight gains obtainable from nitrogen-fertilized pastures. In the Philippines, Moog (1983) reported that leaf production from Leucaena-Zmperata cylindrica pastures is three times that from native Imperata grasslands, and liveweight gains from Leucaena-Panicum maximum pastures have been of the order of 440 kg ha-'. However, nonru-
36
GRAEME BLAIR ET AL.
minants are susceptible to mimosine and this has led to problems when Leucaena makes up too high a proportion of the diet of poultry, rabbits, or humans (NAS, 1977). There appears to be no published information on performance of animals grazing other tree or shrub legume species, although other species are known to have potential. In Australia several species of Acacia, notably A. aneura, are grazed by animals, particularly during times of drought (Gray, 1970). Shrubby species belonging to the genus Desmodium were observed by Bryan (1966) to persist under grazing for 5 years, and thrived on soils unsuitable for Leucaena.
V. MANAGEMENT OF TREE LEGUMES The large number of latent growing points in the stem cambium of tree legumes, which are protected from damage by grazing, enables rapid recovery after being cropped by the grazing (or browsing) animal (Gray, 1970). The more extensive permanent root system of shrub legumes compared to that of herbaceous legumes confers an ability to retain highquality forage under conditions of moisture stress. This, together with reserves of nonstructural carbohydrates stored in roots and stem, enables rapid resumption of growth after the return of favorable conditions (NAS, 1979). However, a serious limitation to the widespread use of shrub legumes is the length of time and difficultiesinvolved in establishment (Maasdorp and Gutteridge, 1986; Jones and Bray, 1983). Another problem that can be encountered is that shrub legumes tend to grow too tall, unless some form of management can be imposed on the stand to keep the production of edible material within the reach of grazing ruminant animals (Gray, 1970). Most experiments measure yield by cutting material from trees, thus simulating cut-and-carry utilization of tree legumes. Although such information can sometimes indicate the potential of leguminoustrees to provide large quantities of high-protein animal feed, inappropriate choice of height or harvest interval for a given environment might equally result in yields well below potential. Accordingly, there has been some effort to determine cutting management strategies, primarily for the species Leucaena, given its widespread use as a forage and fuelwood tree in developing countries of tropical regions. Although the general usefulness of Leucaena is well known and high yields have been reported, there is relatively little information on how to manage it for maximum or sustainable forage production. Results from
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
37
experiments investigating the effect of cutting height and/or cutting frequency on Leucaena yield are summarized in Table IV. A major problem with many research reports is the use of incorrect or ill-defined yield terminology (e.g., Mendoza and Javier, 1980). Many reports are of limited utility because of a failure to accurately define “herbage” without making it clear whether this refers to edible material only or to total biomass yield. Most of the yield figures in Table IV conform with the assertion of Blom (1980) that annual edible dry matter production from Leucaena will generally range form 6 to 18 t DM ha-’ year-’. Comparison of yields and the effects of cutting height and frequency on Leucaena is made difficult because of the different cultivars used by the various researchers. The findings of cutting management experiments will be dependent on whether arboreal (“Salvador”), shrubby (“Hawaiian”), or lowbranching (“Peru”) cultivars have been used. Although the Salvador types with high leaf: stem ratios have often outyielded the Hawaiian and Peru types, the results have been confounded by the method of harvesting Table IV Cutting Height and Cutting Frequency Effects on Yield of LeucaendPb Cutting height (cm) 5 1 1SOd 150”
100 (5) (10)
Cutting interval (days) ( 120)
( 150) (60)
70d 70d (40) 110“
90
120“ 30/60/90 nsp 40 30 90
(100)
110
75 30-90 ns 120d
60 42-84 ns (30)
(30) 30“ 50d
Yield (t ha-’ year-‘)
Reference
50.6 FW total 28.7 FW total 39.4 FW total 28.0 FW total 113.0 FW total 13.0 DW leaf 9.0 DW leaf 8.2 DW leaf 5.4 DW leaf 14.6 DW total 12.5 DW total I 1 .O DW leaf 14.2 DW leaf 15.2 DW leaf 4.0 DW leaf
Takahashi and Ripperton (1949)r Castillo el al. (1979) Krishnamurthy and Munegowda (1982a) Krishnamurthy and Munegowda (l982b) Siregar (1983) Guevarra et al. (1978) Ferraris (1979) Savory and Breen (1979) Pathak et a / . (1980) Perez and Melendez (1980) Osman (1981a.b) Semali et al. (1983) Topark-Ngarm (1983) Evensen (1984) Isarasanee et al. (1985)
“ After Horne et al. (1986).
’
Figures not in parentheses are the best height/frequency used. Figures in parentheses are the only heightlfrequency used. Cited by Evensen (1984). Maximum height or longest frequency used. No significant differences.
”
38
GRAEME BLAIR ET AL.
(Evensen, 1984). Results from experiments investigating effects of cutting height and cutting frequency are often conflicting and will be considered separately here to clarify general trends emerging from the literature. A. AGEOF FIRST CUTTING Little information exists on the effect of age of tree legumes at first cutting on their productivity and persistence. Bhumibhaman er al. (1984) assessed the coppicing of 1-year-old Leucaena leucocephala trees and concluded that the amount of regrowth was positively related to stump size. Similar results were reported by Pathak and Patil(l983). Ella (1987) reported an increase in both leaf and wood production in L . leucocephala, C. calothyrsus, S . grandiflora, and G . sepium as age to first cutting increased from 13 to 21 months (Table V). Subsequent yields recorded over a 12-month period revealed that the yields of S . grandiflora and C . calofhyrsus were not related to age of first cutting, whereas in L . leucocephala and G . sepium, the highest yields were recorded from the trees that were first cut at 21 months. These results have prompted research to investigate the role of fastgrowing, weakly perennial species in supplying forage to animals (Bray er al., 1989). These studies have recorded high leaf yields from Cajanus cajan, Codariocalyx gyroides, and Sesbania sesban at sites in Indonesia and Australia. Planting of these species would allow farmers to leave the more perennial tree species uncut for a longer period and hence increase overall productivity. Table V Leaf and Wood Yield (mg DM Tree-’) of Tree Legumes“ Cut to 100 cm at Various Ages from Sowing Age (months)
Leaf
Wood
13 I5 17 19 21
0.35 a*” 0.40 a 0.71 b 1.35 c 2.11 d
0.47 a 0.60 a 1.53 a 3.59 b 6.79 c
a Mean of L. leucocephala, C. calorhyrsus, S . grandgora, and G. sepium.
Numbers followed by the same letter within a column are not significantly different.
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
39
B. CUTTINGHEIGHT Recommendations from cutting height experiments in the literature deal mostly with Leucaena and show wide variability, ranging from extremes as low as 5 cm up to 3 m. Takahashi and Ripperton (1949, cited by Evensen, 1984), in an early investigation of the effect of cutting height on Leucaena, compared total production when trees were cut at 5,38, or 76 cm and found that a cutting height of 5 cm gave maximum yields. By contrast, other workers have often found that higher cutting heights give better yields. Mendoza et al. (1975) found that yields of Leucaena cut at 300 cm were more thar double that of Leucaena cut at a height of 15 cm. Unfortunately, they c id not include an intermediate range of cutting heights in their experiment. Herrera (1967, cited by Evensen, 1984), Pathak et al. (1980), and Perez and Melendez (1980) all found that the highest yields were obtained from the highest cutting height under investigation, but as these were 75 cm or below, it might be that their experiments did not cover a wide enough range to properly investigate this effect. Horne and Blair (1991) found no significant difference in leaf or wood yields when L . leucocephala cv. Cunningham was cut at 30 or 100 cm. Krishnamurthy and Munegowda (1982a) found that 150 cm gave higher yields than 15-cm and 75-cm cutting height treatments, and in an additional comparison (Krishnamurthy and Munegowda, 1982b), the highest cutting height treatment (150 cm) again resulted in the highest yields compared with cutting heights of 60,90, or 120cm. Most other workers have reported optimum cutting heights in the range of 90-120 cm (Osman, 1981c; Siregar, 1983; Isarasanee et al., 1985). Lazier (1981) imposed three cutting frequency treatments (14-, 40- and 56-day intervals) with three heights of cutting ( 5 , 25, and 50 cm) on Codariocalyx gyroides and found that the 56-day cutting interval and the two higher cutting heights gave the best yields (2.7 t leaf DM ha-' year-'). Siregar (1983) imposed a range of cutting height treatments (up to 150 cm) on Calliandru calothyrsus and Flemingia congesta and reported that cutting height at 1 m gave the best yield. C. CUTTINGFREQUENCY Cutting frequency treatments imposed by researchers range from harvest intervals of 4 weeks (Perez and Melendez, 1980; Osman, 1981a) up to 16-17 weeks (Takahashi and Ripperton, 1949, cited by Evensen, 1984; Ferraris, 1979). Most experiments have set fixed cutting intervals, but it has been agreed that in areas with large variability in climatic conditions
40
GRAEME BLAIR ET A L .
(e.g., with distinct wet and dry seasons), optimum production is more likely if trees are cut on the basis of stage of regrowth (Evensen, 1984). Guevarra et al. (1978), Herrera (1967, cited by Evensen, 1984),Isarasanee et al. (1985), and Ferraris (1979) reported experiments in which cutting frequency treatments were imposed on the basis of attainment of some predetermined height of regrowth. In a more recent experiment, Catchpoole and Blair (1990a) found that leaf production in L . leucocephala, G . sepium, C calothyrsus, and S . grandifIora was unaffected by cutting to a height of 100 cm when the trees reached 150,200,or 250 cm. By contrast, stem production averaged over species increased from 10.16 to 21.45 t ha-' as attainment height was increased from 150 to 250 cm. Data from cutting experiments that use predetermined stages of regrowth to indicate the time of harvesting are more meaningful and more readily applicable to other locations than if only fixed cutting intervals are used (Hegde, 1983). Results of cutting frequency experiments with Leucaena reported in the literature vary considerably, and the variation in cutting heights makes it difficult for any general conclusions to be drawn. For example, whereas Takahashi and Ripperton (1949, cited by Evensen, 1984) and Ferraris (1979) obtained the best yields from infrequently cut trees at low cutting heights, Pathak et al. (1980) and Perez and Melendez (1980) found that yields were maximized at high cutting heights with shorter cutting intervals. The situation becomes a little clearer when the results from investigations reporting the effect of cutting frequency on total yield are considered separately from studies on the effects of cutting interval on yields of leaf or edible forage from Leucaena. Most workers investigating the effects of cutting frequency on total Leucaena yields have generally found that infrequent harvesting gives the highest total dry matter yields. Osman (1981a) compared cutring intervals of 30, 60, 90,and 120 days, with the 90-day treatment resulting in the highest total yield. The higher total DM production under infrequent cutting is generally attributed to the higher proportion of the total yield made up of stem material (Osman, 1981b; Horne et a / . , 1986). Ferraris (1979) found that leaf made up 54% of the total Leucaena yield after 60 days of regrowth, but only 31% after 120days. Similarly, Guevarra el al. (1978) reported a decline in the edible fraction from 81% after 70 days to 60% after 110 days of regrowth, and Topark-Ngarm (1983) from 69% at 40 days to 60% after 60 days. Thus it appears that the higher total yields of Leucaena obtained with infrequent cutting are due to a relative increase in the stem component (a lower leaf stem ratio) with lengthened harvest interval. However, it is difficult to draw general conclusions from experiments
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
41
investigating the effects of cutting frequency on leaf yields, as the results are much less consistent. Pathak et al. (1980) and Das and Dalvi (1981) found that the most frequent cutting treatments studied (40-day and 60-day intervals, respectively) gave the best yields of Leucaena leaf. In contrast, Semali et al. (1983) found that infrequent cutting (1 10 days) resulted in the highest leaf yields. Topark-Ngarm (1983) obtained higher leaf yields with a 60-day harvest interval than from a more frequently cut 40-day regrowth treatment. Evensen (1984) reported no significant differences in leaf yield across cutting heights of 30,60, and 90 cm, with harvest intervals of 40,60, and 120 days, despite the lower leaf fraction in the total yield at 120 days (44%) compared to at 40 days (69%). These results of Evensen (1984) have particular relevance to management recommendations for Leucaena production, as his findings imply that infrequently cut Leucaena can be used as a source of fuelwood without adversely affecting forage yield. However, such a practice is dependent on the nature of the farmer's tree legume resource and forage requirements-a smallholder with a limited number of trees will have to cut each tree more often to obtain a continuous supply of forage (Home et al., 1986). Although the available literature on the effects of cutting frequency on leaf dry matter yields is confusing, it is well known that the forage quality of Leucaena leaf declines with age, and therefore material from infrequently cut trees with a higher proportion of older leaf has a lower nutritive value than material harvested from frequently cut trees (Takahashi and Ripperton, 1949, cited by Evensen, 1984;Tangendjaja et al., 1986). Semali et al. (1983) showed that calcium, phosphorus, and nitrogen levels in leaf declined as cutting interval was lengthened beyond 60 days. An exception is that of Evensen (1984), who found no significant effect of cutting frequency on crude protein content, although this could be a reflection of the highly fertile soil on which his experiments were conducted. There is very little information concerning the effects of cutting height and frequency on yields of tree legume species other than Leucaena. Gore and Joshi (1976, cited by Evans and Rotar, 1987a) obtained the highest yields of N,P,K-fertilized Sesbania sesban with infrequent cutting (every 9-10 weeks) than with frequent cutting (5-6 weeks), over a 31-week growing period (14.2 t leaf DM ha-').
D. DENSITY The variation in tree spacing and planting configuration between published investigations into Leucaena cutting management strategy is a further confounding factor in the interpretation of the effects of cutting height and frequency on yield. The density employed in cutting height and fre-
42
GRAEME BLAIR ET A L .
quency experiments is usually determined with a view to the intended practical application. Rarely has equidistant spacing been used, but rather Leucaena has been planted in rows to simulate hedgerow or alley cropping management systems and, as such, density expressed as number of trees per unit area is less meaningful than specifications of inter- and intrarow tree spacing. Generally most researchers have found that Leucaena planted at higher densities gives better yields than at lower densities. Pathak et al. (1980) reported higher leaf dry matter yields (5.4 t ha-' year-') from trees at a density of 40,000 trees ha-' than at a density of 15,000 trees ha-'. (Both of these density treatments were cut at a height of 30 cm every 40 days.) Castillo et al. (1979) compared four densities (3000, 5000, 60oO, and 10,000 trees ha-') and obtained significantly higher yields from the two highest densities. Three densities (lO,OOO, 30,000, and 60,000 trees ha-') were compared by Savory and Breen (1979), who reported that 60,000 trees ha-' gave the highest yields. Van den Beldt (1983) reported that wood yields were higher at wider spacings. Ella (1987) studied tree legumes in mixtures with grasses in a distinctly monsoonal climate in South Sulawesi, Indonesia, where soil moisture deficits limit plant growth in the dry season and incident light is potentially limiting in the wet season. Four tree legume species (Sesbania grandijlora, Calliandra calothyrsus, Leucaena leucocephala, and Gliricidia sepium) were grown at four densities (5000, 10,OOO, 20,000, and 40,000 trees ha-') with an underplanted grass (Panicum maximum). Cutting intervals of 6 and 12 weeks were applied to the trees (cut at 1 m) and the grass (cut at 12 cm). Although there was some variability in results between species, there was a general trend toward increased grass leaf dry matter yields and reduced tree leaf dry matter yields with reduced tree density in the wet season. In the dry season, however, grass yields were positively related to tree density. Ella (1987) attributed this seasonal reversal of the tree density effect on grass yields to competition for light, which inhibited grass growth at the higher densities and longer cutting intervals, in the wet season and to reduced direct sunlight and transpiration benefiting grass growth in the same treatments in the dry season. A further confounding factor influencing the effect of tree density on grass yields is nitrogen fixation. Kitamura (1986) investigated the longterm effects of varying tree densities and regrowth intervals on the productivity of low-cut Leucaena (30 cm) interplanted with tall tropical grasses (Pennisetum purpureum and Panicum maximum). Total dry matter yields of Leucaena were reduced to only 2 1% of monoculture yields by Penniseturn, compared with 5% in the experiment of Horne and Blair (1990). This is probably because of the very high densities employed (10-cm intrarow spacings and 15-,30-, 60-, and 100-cm interrow spacings). Kitamura (1986) found that edible dry matter yields of both Leucaena and Penniserum were
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
43
maximized at the highest densities and longest growth intervals (attainment of 200-cm height by the Leucaena canopy). The explanation given for this was substantial transfer of nitrogen from the Leucaena to the grass in these treatments. The effects of interrow and intrarow spacing on yield have been investigated by Guevarra et al. (1978), Ferraris (1979), and Savory and Breen (1979). Ferraris (1979) found no differences between interrow spacings of 30 or 90 cm. Savory and Breen (1979) also found no significant differences between Leucaena leaf yields of the two interrow treatments (60-cm and 100-cm spacing between rows), but there was a significant effect of intrarow spacing, with significantly higher yields (7 t leaf DW ha-’ year-’) from trees 30 cm apart within a row compared to the 7.5- and 15-cm intrarow treatments. This is in contrast to the findings of Guevarra et al. (1978), who reported that wider intrarow spacing (45 cm) gave higher yields than closer spacings (15 or 30 cm). Thus the general observation that high densities result in higher yields must, however, take into account the planting configuration of trees, as the evidence from Guevarra et al. (1978) indicates that the closer spacing within rows can result in lower yields.
E. INTERACTION BETWEEN DENSITYA N D CUTTING MANAGEMENT One possible factor giving rise to the often conflicting findings of experiments investigating the relationship between height and frequency on leaf yields might be that of density. For example, the variation in cutting height recommendations could be due to the effect of density on rooting volumes. At high densities, which limit the soil volume that can be exploited by a single tree, a low cutting height will more severely impair regrowth than at lower densities. This shows the importance of the size of stumps remaining, from which reserves can be mobilized for regrowth, and explains the better yields obtained by Pathak et al. (1980), Perez and Melendez (1980), and Mendoza et al. (1975) at higher cutting heights. The literature in not consistent concerning cutting frequency effects on leaf yield and might be due partly to the different densities adopted by the various experimenters. There is a strong interaction between cutting frequency and density (Horne et al., 1986). The ideal time to harvest the woody species is after canopy closure and attainment of maximum Leaf Area Index, but before any shedding of leaves due to shading has begun. Harvesting after this stage will result in lower yields due to leaf abscission, whereas harvesting before this optimum stage will increase the relative proportion of the regrowth period taken up by the initial “lag phase” before regrowth commences (Evensen, 1984). Thus, at low densities, infrequent cutting will give the best yields, whereas at high densities, the
44
GRAEME BLAIR ET A L .
leaf canopy will close earlier and therefore shorter cutting intervals will result in higher yields. Planting arrangement will also affect the optimum time to harvest. Trees growing in widely spaced rows will not be subject to the same degree of light competition as trees equidistantly spaced, because of lateral irradiation. Consequently, one might expect longer cutting intervals to give the highest yields with trees planted in rows, whereas more frequent cutting is required with equidistantly spaced trees at the same density. At this stage, however, there is not yet a clear indication of the effect of density and/or plant arrangement on leaf yields or the leaf : stem ratio. Another possible reason for the conflicting findings concerning optimum cutting frequency is a potential interaction with height of cutting. Low cutting heights could limit the number of buds from which regrowth can arise. Evidence for this comes from the work of Perez and Melendez (1980), who showed that Leucaena cut at 30 cm formed fewer buds (89) after a harvest than trees cut at 50 cm ( 1 12 buds). This might explain why Guevarra et al. (1978) and Ferraris (1979), with very low cutting heights of 5- 10 cm, found that longer harvest intervals resulted in higher leaf yields, whereas those workers who reported that frequent cutting gave maximum leaf yields had higher cutting heights. Evensen (1984), however, did not find any interaction between cutting heights (30,60, and 90 cm) and cutting interval (40, 60, and 120 days). There is little information available on the long-term effect of cutting management on growth habit and form of each tree. The work of Savory and Breen (1979) suggested that frequent cutting ultimately results in a greater number of shoots regrowing from the stump than occurs with less frequent cutting. Consequently, it is possible that the optimum harvest interval might change with time. However, to date no cutting frequency experiment has been conducted long enough for this to become apparent. There are many other cutting management factors besides height and frequency that might be important determinants of yield and persistence but that have not yet been addressed by researchers. For example, it is likely that regrowth will be more rapid from shoots remaining on the tree after cutting than if regrowth arises solely from new buds, but no information is yet available to compare the effect of total versus partial removal of leaf on long-term yields. Another factor that has received little attention is the effect of age or size of the tree at the time of the first harvest on subsequent yields. Ella (1987) has found that an additional consideration that has not received any attention is whether initial cuts should be made at a lower height than subsequent harvests in order to promote a multibranched stem with theoretically more potential bud sites from which regrowth can arise.
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
45
VI. NITROGEN YIELDS OF MATERIAL HARVESTED FROM TREE LEGUMES Yields of nitrogen in material cut from leguminous trees are presented in Table VI. Information about possible nitrogen yields is scanty, even for Leucaena, because many of the experimenters who have reported dry matter yields did not take samples of leaf or stem material for analysis of nitrogen content. Generally, most researchers have found a mean nitrogen concentration in leaf tissue within the range of 3.5% to 4.5% N , although Endrinal and Mendoza (1979, cited by Mendoza, 1984) showed the N content of young leaves to be as high as 6% N , whereas for mature leaves the nitrogen concentration was found to drop to as low as 2.6% N. Table VI Reported Nitrogen Yields in Material Harvested from Tree Legumes Species Leucaena leucocephala
Sesbania sesban Sesbania grandgora Sesbania cannabina Calliandra calothyrsus Gliricidia sepium
Nitrogen yield (kg N ha-' year - I )
Reference
614 (leaf)
Evensen (1984)
414 (leaf) 581 (leaf) 195 (leaf) 485 (leaf, 9 months only) 240 (total) 751 (total) 613 (total) 715 (total) 630 (total) 450 (total) 731 (leaf) 848 (total) 160-195 (leaf, 221 days only) 120 (leaf) 160 (total) 76 (total, 70 days only) 474 (leaf) 581 (total) 586 (leaf) 700 (total)
Ferraris (1979) Guevarra et al. (1978) Hutton and Beattie (1976) Hutton and Bonner (1960) Anslow (1957)" Eriksen and Whitney (1982) Ferraris (1979) Guevarra et al. (1978) Kitamura (1986) Takahashi and Ripperton (1949)" Catchpoole and Blair (1990a)
" Cited by Hutton and Bonner (1960). Cited by Evans and Rotar (1987a).
Gore and Joshi (1976)b Catchpoole and Blair (1990a) Yost et al. (1985) Catchpoole and Blair (1990a) Catchpoole and Blair (1990a)
46
GRAEME BLAIR E T A L .
The nitrogen yield of 715 kg N ha-' year-', obtained by Guevarra et al. (1978), has often been quoted by other researchers in the past decade as evidence of the capacity of Leucaena to fix large quantities of atmospheric nitrogen. However, as Halliday and Somasegaran (1983) pointed out, this figure cannot be attributed solely to biological nitrogen fixation because of the contribution from soil nitrogen. Eriksen and Whitney (1982), in estimating nitrogen fixation by Leucaena, attempted to allow for nitrogen that had been taken up from the soil. They subtracted the average N uptake of three grasses grown adjacent to the tree legume plots from the total nitrogen accumulation in the harvested Leucaena material and obtained an estimate of nitrogen fixation of 656 kg N ha-' year-'. The limitation of this approach is that soil N uptake by the relatively shallow-rooted grass species might not provide a good indication of soil N uptake by deeprooted perennial Leucaena. This and other difficulties associated with techniques to estimate N fixation by tree legumes are discussed later. High-protein forage can, in theory, be continually cut from three legumes fertilized with all nutrients except nitrogen without adversely affecting nitrogen yields, because of the capacity for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. However, it is most unlikely that tree legumes used as sources of cut-and-carry forage throughout developing countries ever receive any fertilizer, and consequently yields will decline with nutrient depletion. Humphreys (1978) noted that where herbaceous pastures form part of a cut-and-carry animal feeding system, the reduction in pasture soil fertility is very rapid if the dung, urine, and reject forage are not carefully collected and returned to the pasture.
VII. NITROGEN RECYCLING VIA LEAF AND EXCRETA Although cut-and-carry animal feeding systems are the norm in densely populated areas of the tropics, in other areas where population pressure is not as high, or land is unsuitable for cropping, ruminant animals are permitted to graze freely. There are a number of advantages with grazing compared to cut-and-carry systems. The labor input is generally less, and nutrient rundown of the pasture is likely to be greatly reduced as a result of nutrient recycling through the animal. Disadvantages include trampling and the need for fencing and provision of water. In both systems there is potential for large amounts of nitrogen to be lost through ammonia volatilization. There are few reports of the direct contribution of tree legumes to an associated nonlegume. In a field experiment conducted by Catchpoole and
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
47
Blair (1990a),901 kg N ha-' year-' was removed in leaf and stem material of L . leucocephala, C. calothyrsus, G . sepium, and S . grandijlora when grown as a monoculture. No difference in grass N yield was recorded between the grass in monoculture and where it was planted under the tree legume (Table VII). In a subsequent glasshouse experiment using a split-root technique with "N, Catchpoole and Blair (1990b)found that the direct transfer of N from L . leucocephala and G . sepium was only 9% of the total harvested N yield. Most workers in the field of nitrogen cycling believe that transfer of biologically fixed nitrogen from legume to soil predominantly occurs as a result of leaf fall and subsequent decomposition, or via passage through grazing animals (Vallis, 1978, 1979). Substantial leaf fall has been shown to occur in a Leucaena-Gliricidia plantation by Sajise et al., cited by Van den Beldt (1983),who recorded an annual litter fall of 1 1.3t DM ha-'. Van den Beldt (1983)found leaf fall in a "Hawaiian Giant" Leucaena plantation to be 8.5 t DM ha-' year-', with an average nitrogen content of 1.2%. The relatively low N content of leaf litter compared to leaf on the plant is due to mobilization of nitrogen from leaf before abscission occurs. Thus the nitrogen contribution from tree legumes as shade trees might not be as high as in an alley cropping situation. There is a strong correlation between rate of decomposition and the nitrogen content of organic matter (Stevenson, 1986). Consequently, leaf cut from hedgerows with a low C/N ratio will break down and release N more quickly than abscised leaves with a high C/N ratio. In addition, it is possible that there will be a greater input of
Table VII Nitrogen Yields (kg ha-') over a 14-Month Period of Tree/Grass Mixtures and Monocultures at Gowa, South Sulawesi, Indonesia"
Leaf N yield Stern N yield Total legume N yield Grass (%N) Grass N Yield Total edible N Yield Total N yield ~~
~~
a
Tree monoculture
Treelgrass mixture
Grass monoculture
751 ab 150 a 901 a 752 a 901 a
669 b 132 b 801 b 1.3 a 100 a 769 a 901 a
0.9 b 103 a 103 b 103 b
~
From Catchpole and Blair (1990a). Means with the same letter are not significantly different ( p < .05).
48
GRAEME BLAIR ET AL.
nitrogen from nitrogen fixation into an alley cropping system because, according to one theory of symbiotic nitrogen fixation (Bethlenfalvay and Phillips, 1977; Bethlenfalvay et al., 1978), removal of large quantities of nitrogen from the legume will increase the demand of the plant for available nitrogen, thus stimulating the rate of N2 fixation. In addition to increasing the total level of soil nitrogen, leguminous trees also can increase the availability of nitrogen and other nutrients for uptake by the companion crop. Tiedemann and Klemmedson (1973) found the relative yield of grass grown in soil taken from under mesquite (Prosopis glandulensis) to be 15 times that of intratree soil, whereas the soils differed in total N by a factor of only 3. Tree legumes are known to have deep rooting systems, up to 50 m in some instances (Phillips, 1963), thus nutrients in low concentration throughout the soil profile can be taken up by the tree roots and become concentrated near the soil surface from litter fall and decomposition (Virginia, 1986). This redistribution of nutrients from deep soil to the surface increases the supply of nutrients to a shallow-rooted companion crop but, unlike nitrogen, the total quantity of the nutrient in the system does not increase. Tree roots can result in a loosening of the soil and improvement in porosity, and wind-blown soil particles can be intercepted by the tree canopy and washed to the ground beneath (Sanchez et al., 1985). Shade and the protection of the litter layer result in a moderation of soil temperature and dampening of temperature fluctuations, which can lead to more favorable conditions for microbiological breakdown and release of nutrients from organic matter (Virginia, 1986). The idea of incorporating tree legumes in fencelines as “living fences” or on the bunds between rice paddies has won widespread acceptance in many areas of the tropics. Piggin and Parera (1985) reported that in Timor large areas of hilly country have been planted to Leucaena leucocephala, and forage material is cut from these slopes and carried to animals tethered to horticultural trees (e.g., coffee or coconuts) in backyard gardens. This has resulted in an apparent improvement in horticultural yields since the adoption of this practice. It is likely that much of the increased growth is a result of nitrogen cycled through the animal and returned in feces and urine to the soil, given the low maintenance requirement of adult ruminants for nitrogen (Henzell and Ross, 1973). In Java, feces and uneaten leaf falling through the slatted floors of animal pens is periodically collected and spread onto neighboring vegetable gardens as fertilizer. Thus, improvement of animal feed quality through the use of tree legumes has ramifications not only for increased animal production, but also for greater crop yields. However, to date no research to quantify this avenue of nitrogen contribution from tree legumes in a cut-and-carry management system has been reported.
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
49
The use of material cut from tree legumes as fertilizer for nonlegume crops has long been a practice in many areas of Asia (Brewbaker and Glover, 1987; Evans and Rotar, 1987a). Traditional “green manuring” techniques, however, usually involved carrying branches or leaves cut from trees grown in one area to the intended area for cropping (Bin, 1983), whereas in an alley cropping system the trimmed foliage does not have to be camed as far (NAS, 1979). There has been very little research conducted comparing yields of nonlegume crops within an alley cropping system with yields obtainable from a monoculture of the crop on a per hectare basis. Hoekstra (1983)conducted an economic analysis of a simulated alley cropping system in a semiarid environment based on the assumptions of Torres (1983) that introduction of Leucaena hedgerows would halve the area available for maize, but at a rate of increase of 13.5 kg maize ha-’ for every kilogram of organic N added from Leucaena prunings. Research conducted at the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture in Nigeria showed that the material cut from Leucaena hedgerows was able to sustain maize grain yield for two consecutive years, but with no addition of prunings, maize yield declined (Kang et al., 1981).
VIII. CONCLUSION The growing body of literature concerning tree legumes is indicative of the increasing realization of their potential role in farming systems and their multiplicity of uses in developing countries. However, much of the evidence of the high productivity of leguminous trees in the tropics is indirect and inferential, with a paucity of information from controlled experimentation and research. There is a need for rigorous information on management options that can best exploit the potential of various species of tree legumes. Although much attention has been focused on Leucaena leucocephala, there has been very little investigative work done on the potential of other perennial legume species, particularly in areas where soil and climatic conditions are unsuitable for Leucaena. There are few published reports of long-term comparisons of productivity of several species at a single site, and virtually no information available on management strategies for cut-and-carry forage production for genera other than Leucaena. Much of the literature on cutting management of Leucaena for forage is conflicting, and there are very few reports of the yields of nitrogen that can be obtained when forage is cut from Leucaena, and little published information exists on yields of N from other species. Leguminous trees are already widely used in tropical Third World countries as sources of timber, fuelwood, forage, and shade for plantation
50
GRAEME BLAIR E T A L .
crops. However, if their role as a source of symbiotically fixed nitrogen is to be exploited fully, then it is important to have knowledge of their nitrogen input in the various agricultural systems in which tree legumes are employed. Developing countries in the wet and humid tropics have been drawn into the trap of using a single species of tree legume (Leucaena) by enthusiastic scientists and agriculturalists. They are now paying the penalty for this as the psyllid insect devastates large areas. Scientists must show the way with alternative species and information on their management to obtain sustainable production. REFERENCES Adenaye, J. A. 1979. Anim. Feed Sci. Techno!. 4(3), 221-225. Ahmad, N., and Ng, F. S. P. 1981. Malays. For. 44(4), 516-523. Alconero, R., Stone, E. G., and Cairns, J. R. 1973. Agron. J . 65(1), 44-46. Anning, P. 1980. Queensl. Aqric. J . 106(2), 148-171. Anonymous 1981. “Queensl. Dep. Primary Ind. Annu. Rep. 1981,” pp. 9-34. QDPI, Brisbane, Australia. Anslow, R. C., 1957. Rev. Agric. Suer. Ile Maurice 36,39-49. Bethlenfalvay, G . J., and Phillips, D. A. 1977. Plant Physiol. 60,419-421. Bethlenfalvay, G. J., Abu-Shakra, S. S., and Phillips, D. A. 1978. Plant Physiol. 62,127-130. Bhumibhaman, S . , Boonarutee, P., Luangjama, L.. and Thavorn, W. 1984. Leucaena Res. Rep. 5,70-71. Bin, J. 1983. Soil Sci. 135(1), 65-69. Blair, G. J., Panjaitan, M., Ivory, D. A., Palmer, B., and Sudjadi, M. 1988. J . Agric. Sci. 111, 435-441. Blom, P. S. 1980. Abstr. Trop. Agric. 6(3), 9-17. Blunt, C. G., and Jones, R. J. 1977. Trop. Grasslands 11(2), 159-164. Bray,, R. A. 1984. Aust. J . Exp. Agric. Anim. Husb. 24(126), 379-385. Bray, R. A., Palmer, B., and Ibrahim, T. 1989. Nirrogen Fixing Tree Rep. 7,7-8. Brewbaker, J. L. 1986. In “Forages in Southeast Asian and the South Pacific Agriculture” ( G . J. Blair, D. A. Ivory, and T. R. Evans, eds.), ACIAR Proceedings No. 12, pp. 43-50. ACIAR, Canberra. Brewbaker, J. L., and Glover, N . 1987. “Woody Species for Green Manuring in Rice-Based Cropping Systems,” Paper presented to the Workshop on Sustainable Agriculture, May 24-29, 1987. IRRI, Los Banos, Philippines. Brewbaker, J. L., and Hutton, E. M. 1979. In “New Agricultural Crops” ( G . M. Ritchie, ed.), pp. 207-257. AAAS Westview Press, Colorado. Brewbaker, J. L., and Styles, B. 1982. “Economically Important Nitrogen Fixing Tree Species” Nitrogen Fixing Tree Association miscellaneous publication 82-104. NFTA, Waimanalo, Hawaii. Bryan, W. W. 1966. Proc. Int. Grassland Congr. 1966 10,311-315. Bushby, H. V. A. 1982. Aust. J. Exp. Agric. Anim. Husb. 22(117), 293-298. CSIRO, Division of Tropical Crops and Pastures. 1979. “Leucaena,” CSIRO Tropical Crops and Pastures Divisional Report 1977-1978. CSIRO, Brisbane. Carew, B. A. R. 1983. Trop. Grasslands 17(4), 181-184.
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
51
Castillo, A. C., Moog, F. A., and Avante, D. C. 1979. “Effects of Row Arrangement and Plant Density on Herbage Production and Growth of Ipil-ipil.” Paper presented at the 16th Annual Convention of the Philippine Society of Animal Science, Manila. Catchpoole, D. W., and Blair, G. 1990a. Aust. J. Agric. Res. (in press). Catchpoole, D. W., and Blair, G. 1990b. Ausr. J . Agric. Res. (in press). Chadhokar, P. A., and Kantharaju, H. R. 1980. Trop. Grasslands 14(2), 78-82. Chadhokar, P. A., and Lecamwasam, A. 1982. Trop. Grasslands 16(1), 46-48. Chandrasekaran, N. R. 1981. Leucaena Res. Rep. 2, 19-20. Chee, W. S., and Devendra, C. 1983. I n “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, pp. 55-60. IDRC, Ottawa, Canada. Cooksley, D. G. 1981. Queensl. J . Agric. Anim. Sci. 38(2), 109-116. Cooksley, D. G . 1982. Queensl. J . Agric. Anim. Sci. 39(1), 47-54. Das, R. B., and Dalvi, G. S. 1981. Leucaena Res. Rep. 2,21. Delpeche, M., Marie, D., and Preston, T. R. 1979. Trop. Anim. Prod. 4, (abstract) 90. Diatloff, A. 1973. Queensl. Agric. J . 99(12), 642-644. D’Mello, J. P. F. 1982. World Rev. Anim. Prod. 18(4), 41-46. Dutt, A. K. 1981. Leucaena Res. Rep. 2,22-23. Ekpenyong, T. E. 1986. Anim. Feed Sci. Tech. 15(3), 183-188. Ella, A. 1987. Unpublished M. Rur. Sci. Thesis, Univ. of New England, Armidale, New South Wales. Ella, A., Jacobson, C., Stur, W. W., and Blair, G. 1989. Trop. Grasslands 23,28-34. Eriksen, F. I., and Whitney, A. S. 1982. Agron. J . 74(4), 703-709. Evans, D. O., and Rotar, P. P. 1987a. “Westfield Trop. Agric. Ser. No. 8.” Westview Press, Colarado. Evans, D. O., and Rotar, P. P. 1987b. Trop. Agric. 64, 193-200. Evensen, C. L. I. 1984. M.Sc. Thesis, Univ. of Hawaii, Manoa, Hawaii. Everist, S. L . 1969. Queensl. Dep. Primary Ind. Div. Plant Ind. Advisory Leajet no. 1024. Falvey, L. 1976. Trop. Grasslands 10, 117-122. Falvey, I. L. 1981. Inr. Tree Crops J . 1(4), 237-244. Felker, P., and Bandurski, R. S. 1979. Econ. Eor. 33(2), 172-184. Ferraris, R. 1979. Trop. Grasslands 13,20-27. Foster, A. H., and Blight, G. W. 1983. Trop. Grasslands 17(4), 170-177. Gonzales, A., Andrew, C. S., and Pieters, W. H. J. 1980. Tech. Pap. Div. Trop. Crops Pastures, CSIRO, 1980 No. 21. Gore, S. B., and Joshi, R. N., 1976. Indian J . Agron. 21(1), 39-42. Gray, S. G. 1970. Trop. Grasslands 4,57-62. Guevarra, A. B., Whitney, A. S., and Thompson, J. R. 1978. Agron. J. 70(6), 1033-1037. Gutteridge, R. C . , and Akkasaeng, R. 1985. Nitrogen-Fixing Tree Res. Rep. 3,60-61. Haag, H. P., and Mitidieri, J. 1980. Leucaena Newsl. 1 , 6 . Halliday, J., and Nakao, P. 1982. “The Symbiotic Affinities of Woody Species Under Consideration as Nitrogen-Fixing Trees.” Univ. of Hawaii NiFTAL Project, Honolulu, Hawaii. Halliday, J, and Somasegaran, P. 1983. In “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” pp. 27-32. Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, pp. 27-32. IDRC, Ottawa. Hegde, N. 1983. In “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, 23-26 November, 1982, pp. 73-78. IDRC, Ottawa. Henzell, E. F., and Ross, P. J. 1973. I n “Chemistry and Biochemistry of Herbage” (G. W. Butler and R. W. Bailey, eds.), Vol. 2, pp. 227-245. Academic Press, London.
52
GRAEME BLAIR E T A L .
Herrera, P. G., 1967. Agric. Trop. 23,34-42. Hoekstra, D. A. 1983. Agrofor. S y s t . 1(4), 335-345. Holm, J. 1972. Thailand J . Agric. Sci. 5,227-236. Holm, J. 1973. Thailand J. Agric. Sci. 6,257-266. Home, P., and Blair, G. 1991. Aust. J . Agric. Res. (in press). Home, P. M., Catchpoole, D. W., and Ella, A. 1986. “Forages in SE Asian and South Pacific Agriculture”, (G. J. Blair, D. A. Ivory, and T. R. Evans, eds.), ACIAR Proceedings No. 12, pp. 164-169. ACIAR, Canberra. Humphreys, L. R. 1978. “Tropical Pastures and Fodder Crops.” Longmans, Essex, England. Hutton, E. M., and Andrew, C. S. 1978. Aust. J . Exp. Agric. Anim. Husb. 18(90), 81-88. Hutton, E. M., and Beattie, W. M. 1976. Trop. Grasslands 10(3), 187-194. Hutton, E. M., and Bonner, I. A. 1960. J. Aust. Inst. Agric. Sci. 26,276-277. Isarasanee, A., Shelton, H. M., Jones, R. M., and Bunch, G. A. 1985. Leucaena Res. Rep. 5 , 3-4. Jarvis, B. D. W. 1981. (A. H. Gibson and W. E. Newton, eds.), “Current Perspectives in Nitrogen Fixation,” p. 459. Aust. Acad. Sci., Canberra, Australia. Jones, R. J. 1979. World Anim. Rev. 31, 13-23. Jones, R. J., and Bray, R. A. 1983. I n “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” pp. 41-49. Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, IDRC, Ottawa. Jones, R. J., and Jones, R. M. 1982. Trop. Grasslands 16(1), 24-29. Jones, R. J., and Lowry, J. B. 1984. Experimentia 40, 1435-1436. Jones, R. J., Jones, R. M., and Cooksley, D. G. 1982. “Agronomy of Leucaena leucocephala,” Division of Tropical Crops and Pastures, Information Service Sheet 41-44. CSIRO, Australia. Kang, B. T., Wilson, G. F., and Sipkens, L. 1981. Plant Soil 63(2), 165-179. Kitamura, Y. 1986. J . Agric. Sci. 106,623-624. Krishnamurthy, K., and Munegowda, M. K. 1982a. Leucaena Res. Rep. 3,25. Krishnamurthy, K., and Munegowda, M. K. 1982b. Leucaena Res. Rep. 3,31-32. Lazier, J. R., 1981. Trop. Grassl. 15(1), 10-16. Maasdorp, B. V., and Gutteridge, R. C. 1986. Trop. Grasslands 20, 127-134. Manjunath, A., Bagyaraj, D. J., and Gopala Gowda, H. S. 1984. Plant Soil 78,445-448. Mendoza, R. C. 1984. I n “Asian Pastures,” pp. 114-134. FFTC Book Series No. 25. pp. 114-134. Mendoza, R. C., and Javier, E. Q. 1980. Leucaena Newsl. 1,26. Mendoza, R. C., Altamarino, T. P., and Javier, E. Q. 1975. Philipp. J . Crop Sci. 1(3), 149- 153. Mendoza, R. C., Escano, L. R., and Javier, E. Q . 1981. Leucaena Res. Rep. 2,. 42. Minson, D. J., and Wilson, J. R. 1980. J . Aust. Inst. Agric. Sci. 46,247-249. Moog, F. A. 1983. I n “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” pp. 69-72. Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, IDRC, Ottawa. NAS 1977. “Leucaena: Promising Forage and Tree Crop for the Tropics.” National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. NAS 1979. “Tropical Legumes: Resources for the Future.” National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. NAS 1980. “Firewood Crops: Shrub and Tree Species for Energy Production.” National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. NAS 1983a. “Firewood Crops: Shrub and Tree Species for Energy Production, Volume 11.” National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. NAS 1983b. “Mangium and Other Fast Growing Acacias for the Humid Tropics.” National Academy of Science, Washington, D.C.
FORAGE TREE LEGUMES IN TROPICAL ENVIRONMENTS
53
NAS 1983~.“Calliandra: A Versatile Small Tree for the Humid Tropics.” National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. NAS 1984. “Leucaena: Promising Forage and Tree Crop for the Tropics,” 2nd Ed. National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C. Norani, A., and Ng, F. S. P. 1981. Malays. For. 44(4), 516-523. Oakes, A. J. 1984. Trop. Agric. 61(2), 125-127. Olvera, E., and Blue, W. G. 1985. Trop. Agric. 62(1), 73-76. Olvera, E., and West, S. H. 1985. Trop. Agriculture 62(1), 68-72. Osman, A. M. 1981a. Leucaena Res. Rep. 2,37-38. Osman, A. M. 1981b. Leucaena Res. Rep. 2,35-36. Osman, A. M. 1981~.Leucaena Res. Rep. 2,37-38. Patridge, I. J., and Ranacou, E. 1973. Trop. Grasslands, 7,327-329. Paterson, R. T., Samur, G. S., and Sauma, 0. 1982. Trop. Anim. Prod. 7(1), 9-13. Pathak, P. S., and Patil, B. D. 1983. In “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, pp. 83-88. IDRC, Ottawa. Pathak, P. S., Rai, P., and Roy, R. D. 1980. Forage Res. 6(1), 83-90. Perez, P., and Melendez, F. 1980. Trop. Anim. Prod. 5,282. Phillips, W. S. 1963. Ecology 44,424. Piggin, C. M., and Parera, V. 1985. In “Shrub Legume Researchin Indonesiaand Australia,” Proceedings of a workshop held at Balai Penelitian Ternak, Ciawi, Indonesia, Feb. 2, 1984, pp. 19-27. (E. T. Craswell and B. Tangendjaja, eds.), ACIAR, Canberra. Pound, B., and Martinez-Cairo, L. 1983. “Leucaena: Its Cultivation and Uses.” Overseas Development Administration, London. Pound, B., and Santana, A. 1980. Trop. Anim. Prod. 5 , 280. Pound, B., Ruiz, G., and Santana, A. 1980a. Trop. Anim. Prod. 5(1), 91. Pound, B., Santana, A., and Ruiz, G. 1980b. Trop. Anim. Prod. 5(3), 228-231. Prussner, K. 1983. In “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, pp. 161-168. IDRC, Ottawa. Romeo, J. T., 1984. Biochem. Sysr. Ecol. l2(3), 293-298. Sanchez, P. A., Palm, C. A., Davey, C. B., Scott, L. T., and Russell, C. E. 1985. Tree crops as soil improvers in the humid tropics. In “Attributes ofTrees as crop. plants” (M. C. R. Cannell and J. E. Jackson, eds.), pp. 327-358. Titus Wilson & Son, Cambria, Great Britain. Sanginga, N., Mulongoy, K., and Ayanaba, A. 1986. Biol.Agric. Hortic. 3(4), 347-352. Savory, R., and Breen, J. 1979. UNDP/FAO Project MLW/75/020, Working Paper 17. Semali, A., Syamsimar, D., and Manurung, T. 1983. “Proceedings 5th World Animal Production Conference” pp. 61 1-612. Tokyo, Japan. Shaw, N. H. 1965. “Division of Tropical Pastures, Annual Report,” p. 42. CSIRO, Townsville, Queensland, Australia. Shaw, N. H. 1968. “Division of Tropical Pastures, Annual Report,” pp. 11-13. CSIRO, Townsville, Queensland, Australia. Siregar, M. E. 1983. “Proceedings 5th World Animal Production Conference, pp. 613-614. Tokyo, Japan. Skerman, P. J. 1977. In “F.A.O. Plant Production and Protection Series,” No. 2. U.N., Rome. Stevenson, F. J. 1986. “Cycles of Soil: Carbon, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Sulfur, Micronutrents.” Wiley, New York. Sumberg, J. E. 1985. Trop. Agric. 62, 17-19. Takahashi, M., and Ripperton, J. C., 1949. Hawaii Agric. Exp. S t n . Bull. 100,56. Tangendjaja, B., Lowry, J. B., and Wills, R. B. H. 1986. Aust. J . Exp. Agric. 26(3), 315-318.
54
GRAEME BLAIR E T A L .
Tham, K. C., Wong, C. C., and Ajit, S. S. 1977. MARDI Res. Bull. 5 , 10-20. Tiedemann, A. R., and Klemmedson, J. 0. 1973. Soil Sci. SOC.Am. Proc. 37, 107-1 11. Topark-Ngarm, A. 1983. Leucaena Res. Rep. 4,77-78. Torres, F. 1983. Agrofor. Syst. 1,323-333. Vallis, I. 1978. Nitrogen relationships in grass/legume mixtures. In “Plant Relations in Pastures” (J. R. Wilson, ed.), pp. 190-202. CSIRO, Melbourne. Vallis, 1. 1979. I n “Nitrogen Relationships in Pasture Systems of Southern Queensland,” Proceedings of a workshop held at Toowoomba, June 5 , 1979, pp. 3-26. Dept. Primary Industries, Queensland. Van Den Beldt, R. J. 1983. In “Leucaena Research in the Asian-Pacific Region,” Proceedings of a workshop held in Singapore, November 1982, pp. 103-108. IDRC, Ottawa. Van Den Beldt, R., and Huxley, P. 1982. “Institutions Studying Nitrogen Fixing Trees,” Nitrogen Fixing Tree Association, miscellaneous publication 82- 106 NFTA, Waimanalo, Hawaii. Vercoe, T. K. 1989. I n “Trees for the Tropics” (D. J. Boland, ed.). ACIAR, Canberra. Virginia, R. A. 1986. For. Ecol. Manage. 16,69-79. Whiteman, P. C. 1980. “Tropical Pasture Science.” Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford. Wildin, J. H. 1980. Queensl. Agric. J . 106(3), 194-197. Wong, C. C., Izham, A., Chen, C. P., Hassan, W., Aminah, A., and Eng, P. K. 1983. Proc. 7th Annu. Con$ MSAP pp. 115-127. Yost, R. S., Evans, D. O., and Saidy, N. A. 1985. Trop. Agric. 62(1), 20-24.
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 44
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTI LOCATION TRIALS Jose Crossa Biometrics and Statistics Unit International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT) 06600 Mexico D. F., Mexico
I. Introduction 11. Conventional Analysis of Variance A. Limitations B. Components of Variance 111. Joint Linear Regression A. Statistical and Biological Limitations B. Other Measurements of Yield Stability C. Stability, Risk, and Economic Analysis IV. Crossover Interactions V. Multivariate Analyses of Multilocation Trials A. Principal Components Analysis B. Principal Coordinates Analysis C. Factor Analysis D. Cluster Analysis VI . AMMI Analysis A. AMMI Analysis with Predictive Success VII. Other Methods of Analysis VIII. General Considerations and Conclusions References
I. INTRODUCTION Multilocation trials play an important role in plant breeding and agronomic research. Data from such trials have three main agricultural objectives: ( a )to accurately estimate and predict yield based on limited experimental data; ( b )to determine yield stability and the pattern of response of genotypes or agronomic treatments across environments; and (c) to provide reliable guidance for selecting the best genotypes or agronomic treatments for planting in future years and at new sites. Agronomists in particular use multilocation trials to compare combinations of agronomic factors, such as fertilizer levels and plant density, and 55 Copyright 0 1990 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
56
JOSE CROSSA
on this basis make recommendations for farmers. Breeders compare different improved genotypes to identify the superior ones. Variation in yield responses among certain agricultural production alternatives (genotypes, agronomic treatments, and cropping systems), when evaluated in different environments, is known in the classical sense as interaction. This interaction is part of the behavior of the genotype or agronomic treatment and confounds its observed mean performance with its true value. Assessing any genotype or agronomic treatment without including its interaction with the environment is incomplete and thus limits the accuracy of yield estimates. Therefore, a significant portion of the resources of crop breeding and agronomy programs is devoted to determining this interaction through replicated multilocation trials. Data collected in multilocation trials are intrinsically complex, having three fundamental aspects: (a) structural patterns; (b) nonstructural noise; and (c) relationships among genotypes, environments, and genotypes and environments considered jointly. Pattern implies that a number of genotypes respond to certain environments in a systematic, significant, and interpretable manner, whereas noise suggests that the responses are unpredictable and uninterpretable. The function of the experimental design and statistical analyses of multilocation trials is to eliminate as much as possible of the unexplainable and extraneous variability (noise) contained in the data. Gauch (1988) mentions that statistical analysis of multilocation trials may have two different objectives. With the first, postdictiue criteria, a statistical model is constructed for a data set, and success is measured in terms of the model’s ability to fit this data set, with consideration of parsimony (reduced model with minimal degrees of freedom). With the second, predictive criteria, the data from a yield trial are partitioned into (a) data used to construct a model (modeling data) and (b) data used to validate the model (validation data). Success is measured in terms of the model’s ability to fit the validation observations. Gauch points out that predictive assessment of a multilocation trial is expected to provide more accurate yield estimates than a model chosen by postdictive criteria. Although many countries conduct extensive trials, little attention has been devoted to the most effective analyses of the data generated. This chapter reviews some of the conventional statistical analyses and stability methods for yield trials, Statistical and biological limitations are discussed. New methodologies for analyzing multilocation trials as well as multivariate analyses for assessing yield stability are presented.
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
57
II. CONVENTIONAL ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE Consider a trial in which the yield of G genotypes is measured in E environments each with R replicates. The classic model for analyzing the total yield variation contained in GER observations is the analysis of variance (Fisher, 1918, 1925). The within-environment residual mean square measures the error in estimating the genotype means due to differences in soil fertility and other factors, such as shading and competition from one plot to another. After removing the replicate effect when combining the data, the GE observations are partitioned into two sources: (a) additive main effects for genotypes and environments and (b)nonadditive effects due to genotypeenvironment interaction. The analysis of variance of the combined data expresses the observed (YG)mean yield of the ithgenotype at thejZhenvironment as
Yu = p
+ Gi + Ej + GEu + eu
(1)
where p is the general mean; Gi, Ej, and GEu represent the effect of the genotype, environment, and genotype-environment interaction, respectively; and eii is the average of the random errors associated with the rth plot that receives the ithgenotype in thejZhenvironment. The nonadditivity interaction as defined in (1) implies that the expected value of the ithgenotype in thePhenvironment (Y,>depends not only on the levels of G and E separately but also on the particular combination of levels of G and E. The presence of a significant genotype-environment interaction complicates interpretation of the results. Freeman (1985) mentioned two intuitive ways of overcoming this problem. The first is to examine the data and see if the interaction is due to one observed outlier. A high residual might be due to a recording error. In that case the outlier may be replaced by its expected value, using a model such as (1) without considering the interaction term. One can then determine whether the interaction in model (1) disappears. The second approach is to find a different scale on which the results can be expressed. Frequently, the logarithm transformation of the data removes interaction without rank changes and achieves both equality of variance within treatments and normality of residuals. However, crossover or rank change interactions cannot be removed by log transformation. When genotype-environment interaction exists and is not due to one outlier and cannot be removed by a suitable transformation, it should be assumed that an underlying model such as (1) is representing the data.
58
JOSE CROSSA
A. LIMITATIONS
Hill (1975) outlined the advantages of analysis of variance in obtaining unbiased estimates of genetic and genotype-environment interaction variance components. He failed, however, to recognize its limitations in describing further structures in the nonadditive component. In practice, if there is little variation in residual mean squares from one environment to another and the experiments are of equal size, the pooled error variance is found by averaging the residual mean squares of all environments. This combined experimental error is used to test the null hypothesis that the genotype differences are the same in all environments. This analysis is open to criticism, however, if error variances are heterogeneous. The F-test of the genotype-environment interaction mean squares against the pooled error variance is biased toward significant results. Cochran and Cox (1957 p. 554) point out that in agricultural experimentation, loss of sensitivity of the F-test is equivalent to discarding 10% to 20% of the data. A correct test of significance, by weighting each genotype mean by the inverse of its estimated variance, has been used by Yates and Cochran (1938) and Cochran and Cox (1957). The weighted analysis gives less weight to environments that have a high residual mean square. The sum of squares for genotype-environment interaction is inflated by errors in the weights; however, it can be reduced to a quantity that is distributed approximately as chi-square. The disadvantage of weighted analysis is that weights may be correlated to environment yield responses (with high-yielding environments showing higher error variance and low-yielding sites presenting lower error variances). This would mask the true performance of some genotypes in certain environments. It is recommended that less weight be assigned to agricultural environments of less importance (Patterson and Silvey, 1980). The genotype mean square is influenced by the pooled error variance, the variance of genotype-environment interaction, and the variance among true genotype means. The ratio of the genotype mean square to the genotype-environment interaction provides a test for the null hypothesis that there are no differences among the true genotype means. A criticism of this F-test is that, if the interaction variance is not the same for all of its components (some components of the interaction are much higher than others), too many significant results are obtained. In a trial of genotypes, this may occur when some genotypes are relatively unresponsive to a change in environment whereas others have a marked response. It is
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
59
recommended that the genotypes be further partitioned into a set of orthogonal components and that all of these components be tested for their interaction with the environment (Cochran and Cox, 1957). Often, the analysis of variance test of the significance of the genotypeenvironment interaction declares it not significant when in fact it is agronomically or genetically important and its sum of squares accounts for a large proportion of the total variation (Zobel et al., 1988). This may occur because the interaction contains a large number of degrees of freedom. One of the main deficiencies of the combined analysis of variance of multilocation yield trials is that it does not explore any underlying structure within the observed nonadditivity (genotype-environment interaction). Analysis of variance fails to determine the pattern of response of genotypes and environments. The valuable information contained in (G- I) (E-1) degrees of freedom is practically wasted if no further analysis is done. Since the nonadditive structure of a data matrix has a nonrandom (pattern) and random (noise) component, the advantages of the additive model are lost if the pattern component of the nonadditive structure is not further partitioned into functions of one variable each. Williams (1952), Mandel (1961, 1969, 1971), and Gollob (1968) have delineated methods for analyzing and interpreting two-way tables with interaction. They show that the sum of squares for interaction can be further partitioned in multiplicative components related to eigenvalues. The interaction part of Eq (1) can be expressed in the form GEU = klul;slj
+ k 2 ~ 2 ; ~ +2 j k 3 ~ 3 ; ~ +3 j . . .
(2)
h
then GEU=
knunisN, and n- 1
YU = p
+ Gi + Ej + (ck,vnisnj)+ eU h
(3)
n-l
where k, is the singular value of the nthaxis (kn2is the eigenvalue), u,; is the eigenvector of the Shgenotype for the nthaxis, si is the eigenvector of the
c h
fh
environment for the nthaxis, and
n- I
h
uni =
C si
=
I . This result links
n- I
the analysis of variance with the principal components analysis. This analysis is called Additive Main effect and Multiplicative Interaction (AMMI) and is considered in this chapter in the discussion of nonconventional analysis of variance.
60
JOSE CROSSA
B. COMPONENTS OF VARIANCE Analysis of variance of multilocation trials is useful for estimating variance components related to different sources of variation, including genotypes and genotype-environment interaction. Variance components have been widely used in genetics and plant breeding (Comstock and Moll, 1964; Cockerham, 1964; Gardner, 1964). In general, variance component methodology is important in multilocation trials, since errors in measuring the yield performance of a genotype arise largely from genotype-environment interaction. Therefore, knowledge of the size of this interaction is required to ( a ) obtain efficient estimates of genotype effects and (b) determine optimum resource allocations, that is, the number of plots and locations to be included in future trials. In a breeding program, variance component methodology is used to measure genetic variability and to estimate the heritability and predicted gain of a trait under selection. For balanced multilocation trials, that is, those with the same number of experimental units (genotypes or agronomic treatments) observed per site, estimation of the variance component is accomplished using the analysis of variance method. Each of the mean squares is known to estimate a linear function of the variance components defined in the model. These linear functions are called expected mean squares. By solving simultaneous equations, linear functions of the mean squares can be obtained that estimate each variance component. This method is limited to balanced data, and its main advantage is that it produces the best unbiased point estimators of the variance components (Graybill and Hultiquist, 1961). However, there is nothing intrinsic in the method to prevent negative estimates. The interpretation of a negative estimate of a nonnegative parameter creates controversy. In practice, the negative estimate can be accepted and used or a value of zero can be used instead. Thompson (1961, 1962) gives some rules for ignoring the negative component and reestimating the others. Genetic and genetic-environment variance components can be estimated by the maximum likelihood method. The disadvantage of these estimators, in the case of balanced data, is that they are biased downward (Patterson and Thomson, 1975). This problem can be overcome by using the restricted maximum likelihood (REML) method (Robinson, 1987). This method is analogous to the analysis of variance, and both produce identical estimators for balanced data. For unbalanced experiments, including incomplete block designs, estimating the expected mean squares can be difficult, and the analysis of variance method for variance component estimation is not necessarily a
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
61
desirable approach. Unbalancedness in multilocation trials can have many different causes, including shortage of seed, testing of some genotypes only at some locations (or in some years), and the addition of new genotypes to the trial system and discarding of others. General methods for calculating variance components in nonorthogonal data by means of REML analysis have been developed by Patterson and Thomson (1971, 1975).
Ill. JOINT LINEAR REGRESSION Another important model for analyzing and interpreting the nonadditive structure (interaction) of two-way classification data is the joint linear regression method. This approach has been extensively used in genetics, plant breeding, and agronomy for determining yield stability of different genotypes or agronomic treatments. The genotype-environment interaction is partitioned into a component due to linear regression (b;)of the ithgenotype on environmental mean and a deviation (d$: (GE)jj = biEj
+ djj
(4)
and Y j j= p
+ G; + Ej + (b;Ej + d j j )+ e j j
(5)
This model uses the marginal means of the environments as independent variables in the regression analysis and restricts the interaction to a multiplicative form. It was first proposed by Yates and Cochran (1938) in their analysis of a barley yield trial. The method divides the (G-1) (E-1) df for interaction into G-1 df for heterogeneity among genotype regressions and the remainder (G-1) (E-2) for deviation. Further details about interaction are obtained by regressing the performance of each genotype on the environmental means. Eberhart and Russell (1966) proposed pooling the sum of squares for environments and genotype-environment interactions and subdividing it into a linear effect between environments (with 1 df), a linear effect for genotype-environment (with G- 1 df), and a deviation from regression for each genotype (with E-2 df). Thus, not until the 1960s was it possible to solve the intractable problem of genotype by environment interaction by means of a regression approach. Part of the genotype’s performance across environments or genotype stability is expressed in terms of three empirical parameters: the mean performance, the slope of the regression line, and the sum of squares
62
JOSE CROSSA
deviation from regression. Although joint regression has been principally used for assessing the yield stability of genotypes in a plant breeding program, it may also be used for agronomic treatments. It has also been used to estimate biometrical genetical parameters (Bucio Alanis et al., 1969). When attention is focused on environments, the converse analysis may be performed by regressing each environment’s yields on the genotype means (Fox and Rathjen, 1981). Freeman (1973), Hill (1975), and Westcott (1986) have provided comprehensive reviews of regression methods for studying genotypeenvironment interactions. Several statistical and biological limitations of the regression method should be noted.
A. STATISTICAL A N D BIOLOGICAL LIMITATIONS The first statistical criticism of regression analysis is that the genotype mean (x variable) is not independent of the marginal means of the environments ( y variable). Regressing one set of variables on another that is not independent violates one of the assumptions of regression analysis (Freeman and Perkins, 1971; Freeman, 1973). This interdependence may be a major problem for small numbers, but not when the number of genotypes is large (say 15 to 20). If the standard set for stable yield is based on very few genotypes (say 4), each estimated stability coefficient involves regressing one genotype on an average to which it contributes one-fourth. Biological and algebraic interdependency also exists between slopes and sums of squares due to deviations from regression. Hardwick and Wood (1972) concluded that this is a necessary adjunct of the line-fitting procedure. The second statistical limitation is that errors associated with the slopes of genotypes are not statistically independent, because the sum of squares for deviation, with (C-1) (E-2) df, cannot be subdivided orthogonally among the G genotypes. The third statistical problem with regression analysis is that it assumes a linear relationship between interaction and environmental means. When this assumption is violated,the effectiveness of the analysis is reduced, and results may be misleading (Mungomery et al., 1974). In fact, the analysis requires that a high proportion of the genotype by environment effects should be attributable to linear regression (Perkins, 1972; Freeman, 1973). A nonlinear relationship between interaction and environmental effects has been proposed by Pooni and Jinks (1980), and Hill and Baylor (1983) have used an orthogonal contrast analysis of variance that subdivides the
63
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
variation over environments (years and sites) for each entry into sources due to environment linear and quadratic effects. Freeman and Perkins (1971) have criticized Eberhart and Russell’s partitioning of the pooled sum of squares for environments and genotypeenvironment interaction, noting that the 1 df sum of squares for the linear component between environments is the same as the total sum of squares for environments with E-1 df. A major biological problem with regressing genotype means on environmental means arises when only a few very low or very high yielding sites are included in the analysis. The fit of a genotype may be largely determined by its performance in those few extreme environments, with possibly misleading results (Hill and Baylor, 1983; Westcott, 1986). An example is presented by Westcott (1986) from the barley yield trial data of Yates and Cochran (1938), in which regression coefficients for the yield of the genotypes were calculated for all of the trials and for all except the highestand lowest-yielding site (Table I). The exclusion of one extreme point had a strong influence on the slope of genotypes 2 , 4 , and 5 , even though the lowest-yielding site was only 41.1 units apart from the grand mean. Crossa (1988) found that excluding 1 very low yielding site out of 20 or 1 high-yielding site out of 17 influenced the estimates of slopes and deviations from regression for some genotypes. The performance of some genotypes at only one site overshadowed their general response at most of the other sites. The author concluded that regression analysis should be used with caution when the data set includes results from a few extremely low or high yielding locations. Another biological criticism of the regression method is that the relative stability of any two genotypes depends not only on the particular set of locations included in the analysis but also on the other genotypes that are included in the regression calculation. It has been shown that the stability of a genotype depends on the mean performance of the group with which Table I Regression Coefficients of Five Barley Genotypes” Genotype
All sites included
Excluding highestyielding site
Excluding lowestyielding site
1 2 3 4 5
0.84 0.99 0.95 1.61 0.61
0.87 0.79
0.93 0.96 0.99 1.46 0.65
* From Wescott (1986).
1
.oo
1.92 0.43
64
JOSE CROSSA
that entry is being compared (Knight, 1970; Witcombe and Wittington, 1971; Mead et al., 1986; Crossa, 1988). Furthermore, it is possible that the ranking of two genotypes' stability coefficients may be reversed when they are compared with two other sets of genotypes. The stability of a particular genotype is unsatisfactory if its response is different from the mean response of the group with which it is being compared (Easton and Clements, 1973). This can be seen in Table 11, which gives the deviations from regression for 6 entries, considered ( a ) as members of the original set of 25 entries and (b) as an isolated group. It can be seen that the entry Raven x 65 RN 85 was originally a stable line (604) but appears unstable when considered as a member of the subset of 6 entries (6078). Crossa (1988) estimated Eberhart and Russell's stability parameters for genotypes considered, along with others, as a subset of the original group of 27 entries. When 7 genotypes were considered in isolation, deviation from regression of some genotypes changed drastically. This result confirmed that the yield stability of one entry, as determined by regression, varied according to the average response of the rest of the group. The author also pointed out that, in trying to determine which genotype is superior, plant breeders have difficulty reaching a compromise between the yield mean, slope, and deviation from regression, because the genotype's response to environments is intrinsically multivariate and regression tries to transform it into a univariate problem (Lin et al., 1986). An alternative approach to overcoming the dependency present in the regression analysis-one especially suitable for agronomic treatments-is to consider the joint distribution of a pair of treatments, say A and B, and to regress the yield differences (A-B)on the mean yield (A-B/2) (R. Mead,
Table I1 Deviation from Regression of 6 Genotypes when Considered as Members of the Original Group of 25 Genotypes and as an Isolated Group" Genotype
Member of 25 genotypes
Isolated group
Aotea Arawa 1020,Ol Nadadores 63 Hi-61 X Aotea Raven x 65 RN 85
8,942 5,267 9,645 8,235 12,402 604
1,347 4,839 3,486 6,425 9,543 6,078
From Easton and Clements (1973).
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
65
personal communication). Assuming an approximately linear relationship between both treatments, a positive slope would indicate that B is more stable than A. If a large percentage of the genotype-environment interaction sum of squares can be explained by the heterogeneity of regressions, then the joint regression method can efficiently describe the pattern of adaptation in the response of genotypes. However, Baker (1969), Byth et al. (1976), Eagles and Frey (1977), and Shorter (1981) reported that a very small portion (9- 16%) of the genotype-environment sum of squares is attributable to linear regression in various situations. Shorter (1981) concluded that, if this is the most common situation in field crops, the joint regression method of analysis is of little value. Moll ef al. (1978) studied the interaction of several populations of maize with environments, using the Eberhart and Russell procedure with the modification of Mather and Caligari (1974). The interaction sum of squares was divided into two parts: differences among genotypes in their variability among environments and differences in correlations among pairs of entries. Moll et al. found that heterogeneity of regression coefficients among genotypes may be due to heterogeneity of variance. Using results from Bruckner and Frohberg (1987) on kernel weight of 20 spring wheats tested in 15 environments, Baker (1988a) pointed out that the high correlation between regression coefficients and estimated variances over environments suggests that heterogeneity of slopes is explained by heterogeneity of variance. B. OTHERMEASUREMENTS OF YIELDSTABILITY Other methods of determining genotype stability are based on genotype-environment interaction effects and are briefly examined next. Plaisted and Peterson (1959) computed combined analysis of variance for each pair of genotypes included in a trial. The variance component of the genotype-environment interaction is estimated for each pair and each genotype. The genotype with the smallest mean variance component contributes less to the total interaction and is considered the most stable. Wricke (1962, 1964) defined the concept of ecovalence as the contribution of each genotype to the genotype-environment interaction sum of squares. The ecovalence (W;)or stability of the ithgenotype is its interaction with environments, squared and summed across environments, and expressed as w.= [_Yu. .- -y.1 . -- y J. - -y..32 (6) where
r, is the mean performance of genotype i in thejZhenvironment and
66
JOSE CROSSA
-
Yi. and y.j_are the genotype and environment mean deviations, respectively, and Y.. is the overall mean. Accordingly, genotypes with low ecovalance have smaller fluctuations from the mean across different environments and are therefore more stable. Shukla (1972) defined the stability variance of genotype i as its variance across environments after the main effects of environmental means have been removed. Since the genotype main effect is constant, the stability variance is based on the residual (GEu + eu) matrix. Lin and Binns (1988) defined the superiority measure (Pi)of the ithgenotype as the mean square of distance between the ith genotype and the genotype with maximum response as Pi = [n(Y;. - M . . ) 2 + (Yo - Y;.+ Mj. + M..)2]/2n
(7)
where Yu is the average response of the ithgenotype in thefh environment, Yi. is the mean deviation of genotype i, Mjis the genotype with maximum response among all genotypes in thejth location, and n is the number of locations. The first term of the equation represents the genotype sum of squares, and the second term is the genotype-environment sum of squares. The smaller the value of Pi, the less its distance to the genotype with maximum yield and the better the genotype. A pairwise genotypeenvironment interaction mean square between the maximum and each genotype is also calculated. This method is similar to that of Plaisted and Peterson (1959), except that ( a )the stability statistics are based on both the average genotypic effects and genotype-environment interaction effects and (b) each genotype is compared only with the one maximum response at each environment. Lin et al. (1986) reviewed nine stability measurements frequently used in biological research and grouped them into four categories, depending on whether they are based on the deviations from the average genotype effect or on the genotype-environment interaction effects. The authors defined three different parametric concepts of stability statistics. A genotype is stable if ( a ) its among-environment variance is small; ( 6 ) its response to environment is parallel to the mean response of all genotypes included in the trial; and (c) the residual mean square from the regression model on the environmental index is small. Stability methods based on the genotypeenvironment interaction sum of squares correspond to type b, whereas the Eberhart and Russell method is type c. As the authors point out, these parametric concepts of stability are relatively simple and address only some aspects of stability without giving an overall picture of the genotype’s response. A genotype may be considered to have type b stability and simultaneously type c instability. Since a genotype’s response to environment is multivariate, Lin et al. (1986) proposed using cluster analysis to classify genotypes.
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
67
C. STABILITY, RISK,A N D ECONOMIC ANALYSIS One of the main aims of breeders and agronomists is to recommend to farmers new agriculture production alternatives (genotypes, agronomic treatments, and cropping systems) that are stable under different environmental conditions and minimize the risk of falling below a certain yield level. Subsistence farmers using low levels of inputs in unfavorable environments tend to be reluctant to adopt new technology. Given the uncertainty of their circumstances, these farmers’ main concern is not so much to increase production as to avert catastrophe. Conventional regression analysis considers only three components of stability: (a) response to changing environment (regression coefficient); (b)yield variability; and (c) mean yield level. However, this assessment of stability is incomplete and inappropriate unless it is related to risk probability (Barah et a / . , 1981; Mead et al., 1986). The concept of risk efficiency of a particular genotype involves a tradeoff between its average yield and variance. A genotype is risk efficient if no other genotype has the same yield with lower variance or the same variance with higher mean yield. The mean-standard deviation analysis provides a method in which the benefits of reduced yield variability are measured against loss in yield (Binswanger and Barah, 1980). This analysis requires that the breeder or farmer specify how mean and standard deviation are “trade off.” Mean-standard deviation analysis translates the stability parameters of a genotype (slope and deviation from regression) into economic benefit for the farmer. Mean-standard deviation analysis and regression analysis were compared on yield data of pearl millet genotypes tested for 5 years in India and Pakistan (Witcombe, 1988). The results of both analyses were similar in all the environments and the standard deviation predicted well the values of deviation from regression. In comparing the risk stability of two cropping systems (two crops versus one crop), Mead et al. (1986) define risk as the probability of yield falling below certain prespecified levels. The authors describe a general method of expressing stability related to risk probability by adjusting a bivariate distribution to the data and then estimating a theoretical continuous risk curve. The method can be used for assessing the risk stability of any two genotypes or agronomic treatment. The stochastic dominance procedure (Anderson, 1974; Menz, 1980) ranks different agricultural alternatives according to farmers’ risk aversion and selects those with high risk efficiency. It is assumed that each alternative has a probability distribution of yield,Ai), and therefore a cumulative ~ firstdistribution function, F(i). Then, the Ai) is said to dominate A J by
68
JOSE CROSSA
degree stochastic dominance if all the values of the yield distribution of alternative i are greater than those of alternative j. Second- and thirddegree stochastic dominance appear when the distributions of yields are not easily separated. The importance of stochastic dominance is, unlike mean-standard deviation analysis, that the breeder or farmer does not have to specify the trade-off between average yield and variance. Under yield uncertainty a major problem is how to make trade-offs among conventional stability statistics, for example, mean yield, slope, and deviation from regression. The central concept in safety-first decision strategies is the assumption that breeders and farmers prefer genotypes with a small chance of producing small yields. Eskridge (1990) addressed this issue by developing safety-first selection indices based on four different stability approaches: (a) the variance of a genotype across environments (EV); (b) the regression coefficient used by Finlay and Wilkinson (1963) (FW); (c) the stability variance of Shukla (1972) (SH); and (4the regression coefficient and deviation from regression defined by Eberhart and Russell (1966)(ER). The rank correlations between the mean genotype rankings and the four selection indices show that FW, SH, and ER produce similar rankings (>0.65). The mean ranking, on the other hand, is poorly correlated with EV (0.152) and only moderately correlated with FW, SH, and ER (0.45 < rank correlations < 0.7). Only one genotype was ranked near the bottom for all indices. A safety-first index is useful for selecting genotypes in the presence of genotype-environment interaction (Eskridge, 1990)because: (a) it weights the importance of stability relative to yield; (b) it can be used with different types of univariate stability statistics for any trait; and (c) it is more likely to identify superior varieties when high costs are associated with low yields.
IV. CROSSOVER INTERACTIONS Interaction in the classic sense exists because the responses of genotypes are not parallel over all environments. In agricultural production, changes in a genotype’s rank from one environment to another are important. These are called crossovers or qualitative interactions, in contrast to noncrossovers or quantitative interactions (Baker, 1988b,c; Gail and Simon, 1985). With a qualitative interaction, genotype differences vary in direction among environments, whereas with quantitative interactions, genotypic differences change in magnitude but not in direction among environments. If significant qualitative interactions occur, subsets of genotypes are to be recommended only for certain environments, whereas
69
STATISTICAL ANALYSES O F MULTILOCATION TRIALS
with quantitative interactions the genotypes with superior means can be used in all environments. Therefore, it is important to test for crossover interactions (Baker, 1988b). Consider, for example, genotypes A and B tested in environments 1 and 2 Let and 7 A 2 be the means of genotype A in environments 1 and 2, respectively, and and be the means of genotype B in environments 1 and 2, respectively. The genotype effects in each environment are defined as
rA,
rBl rB2
dl = F A 1 d2 = Y.42 -
FBI F,2
No interaction and all types of interactions can be illustrated in the space of genotype effects by plotting d2 and dl (Fig. 1). Then, the line where dl = d2 represents the situation in which there are differences in genotype means but not in genotype-environment interac-
No genotype effect at orlgln A*
over Interaction 7 d7<0
B4
FIG.1. The space of genotype effects d , and d2. From Gail and Simon (1985).
70
JOSE CROSSA
tion; when d l = d2 = 0 (at the origin), there are no differences in genotype means and no interaction. Qualitative or crossover interaction will occur in the second and fourth quadrants when d1<0 and d2>0 or d1>0 and dz
V. MULTIVARIATE ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS Multivariate analysis has three main purposes: ( a ) to eliminate noise from the data pattern (i.e., to distinguish systematic from nonsystematic variation); ( b )to summarize the data; and (c) to reveal a structure in the data. In contrast with classic statistical methods, the function of multivariate analysis is to elucidate the internal structure of the data from which hypotheses can be generated and later tested by statistical methods (Williams and Gillard, 1971, cited by Gauch, 1982b). Multivariate analyses are appropriate for analyzing two-way matrices of G genotypes and E environments. The response of any genotype in E environments may be conceived as a pattern in E-dimensional space, with the coordinate of an individual axis being the yield or other metric of the genotype in one environment. Two groups of multivariate techniques have been used to elucidate the internal structure of genotype-environment interaction:
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
71
1. Ordination techniques, such as principal components analysis, principal coordinates analysis, and factor analysis, assume that data is continuous. These techniques attempt to represent genotype and environment relationships as faithfully as possible in a low-dimensional space. A graphical output displays similar genotypes or environments near each other and dissimilar items are farther apart. Ordination is effective for showing relationships and reducing noise (Gauch, 1982a, 1982b). 2. Classification techniques, such as cluster analysis and discriminant analysis, seek discontinuities in the data. These methods involve grouping similar entities in clusters and are effective for summarizing redundancy in the data.
A. PRINCIPAL COMPONENTS ANALYSIS
Principal components analysis is one of the most frequently used multivariate methods (Pearson, 1901; Hotelling, 1933; Gower, 1966). Its aim is to transform the data from one set of coordinate axes to another, which preserves, as much as possible, the original configuration of the set of points and concentrates most of the data structure in the first principal components axes. In this process of data reduction, some original information is inevitably lost. Principal components analysis assumes that the original variables define a Euclidean space in which similarity between items is measured as Euclidean distance. This analysis can effectively reduce the structure of a two-way genotype-environment data matrix of G (genotypes) points in E (environments) dimensions in a subspace of fewer dimensions. The matrix can also be conceptualized as E points in G dimensions. The model is written as
where the terms are defined as in (2). Under certain conditions, principal components analysis is a generalization of the linear regression analysis (Williams, 1952; Mandel, 1969; Johnson, 1977; Digby, 1979). Mandel (1971) analyzed a two-way data matrix by applying the AMMI analysis. The first step in his solution was to conduct an analysis of variance with terms for two main effects and the interaction between rows and columns. The residual table (i.e., the row-column interaction) was partitioned into multiplicative terms where eigenvalues and eigenvectors are obtained. Finally, the relationships between the first two eigenvectors, which accounted for most of the variation, were examined.
72
JOSE CROSSA
Freeman and Dowker (1973) used principal components analysis to interpret the causes of genotype-environment interaction in carrot trials. Hirosaki et af. (1975) found that principal components analysis was more efficient than the linear regression method in describing genotypic performance. On the other hand, Perkins (1972) reported that principal components analysis was not useful for studying the adaptation of a group of inbred lines of Nicotiana rustica. Principal components analysis combined with cluster analysis was effective in forming subgroups among 29 populations of faba bean (Vicia faba L.), which differed in mean performance and response across environments (Polignano et af., 1989). Principal components have also been used by Suzuki (1968), Goodchild and Boyd (1979, and Hill and Goodchild (1981). Zobel et al. (1988) presented analysis of variance and principal components analysis for seven soybean genotypes yield-tested in 35 environments (Table 111). The genotype by environment interaction sum of squares of the analysis of variance was large but not significant. The principal components analysis with the first three principal axes accounting for 76% of the variation is found to be statistically efficient but undesirable for describing the additive main effects. Kempton (1984) used AMMI analysis for summarizing the pattern of genotype responses across environments with different levels of nitrogen. The first principal component is the axis that maximizes the variation among genotypes. The second principal component is perpendicular to the first and maximizes the remaining variation. The display of the genotypes and environments along the first two principal component axes for the interaction table of residuals is called the biplot (Gabriel, 1971, 1981). Table I11 Analysis of Variance and Principal Components Analysis of a Soybean Trial' Principal components analysis
Analysis of variance Source
df
Mean square
Treat Geno Env GE Error
244 6 34 204 667
574*** 1499***
a
3105***
125 111
From Zobel et al. (1988).
*** Significant at 0.001 probability level.
Source Treat PCA 1 PCA 2 PCA 3 Res Error
df 244 41 39 37 I27 667
Mean square 574*** 2599***
471***
264*** 44 111
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
73
Figure 2 represents the biplot of 12 genotypes and 14 environments (7 sites each with low and high nitrogen levels). The component of the total interaction due to nitrogen level is small, since the biplot shows that highand low-nitrogen trials are closely associated. Environments represented by vectors of similar orientation but different length usually give similar genotype rankings. Zobel et af. (1988) and Crossa et af. (1990) used the same model to analyze a series of soybean and maize trials, respectively. Additive main effects for genotype and environments are first fitted by the analysis of variance. Then, multiplicative effects for genotype by environment interaction are calculated by principal components analysis. The biplot of the model helps to visualize the overall pattern of response as well as specific interactions between genotypes and environments. Ordination techniques such as principal components analysis may have limitations. First, in reducing dimensionality of multivariate data, distortions may sometimes occur. If the percentage of variance accounted for by the first principal components axes is small, individuals that are really far apart may be represented by points that are close together (Gower, 1967).
*i4
I 3L
Axla 1
FIG.2. First two principal component axes for genotypes ( 0 )and environments based on residual yields. (Sites are coded from I to 5 ; L and H are trials with low and high nitrogen levels, respectively.) From Kernpton (1984).
74
JOSE CROSSA
In this case, higher axes may be inspected to identify points with large displacement not revealed in lower dimensions. Second, a lack of correlation between variables prevents few dimensions from accounting for most of the variation (Williams, 1976). Third, sometimes the components do not have any obvious relationship to environmental factors. Fourth, contrary to analysis of variance, which assumes a complete additive model and treats the interaction as a residual, principal components analysis assumes a complete multiplicative model without any description of the main effects of genotypes and environments (Zobel et al., 1988). This is important in the context of multilocation trials, in which genotype means are of primary interest. Principal components analysis confounds the additive (main effects of genotypes and environments) structure of the data with the nonadditivity (genotype-environment interaction). The fifth limitation is that nonlinear association in the data prevents principal components analysis from efficiently describing the real relationships between entities (Williams, 1976). The linear regression method uses only one statistic, the regression coefficient, to describe the pattern of response of a genotype across environments, and, as mentioned previously, most of the information is wasted in accounting for deviation. Principal components analysis, on the other hand, is a generalization of linear regression that overcomes this difficulty by giving more than one statistic, the scores on the principal component axes, to describe the response pattern of a genotype (Eisemann, 1981).
B. PRINCIPAL COORDINATES ANALYSIS Principal coordinates analysis (Gower, 1966)is a generalization of principal components analysis in which any measure of similarity between individuals can be used. Its objective and limitations are similar to those of principal components analysis. Principal coordinates analysis was used in combination with cluster analysis (“pattern” analysis) to study the adaptation of soybean lines evaluated across environments in Australia (Mungomery et al., 1974; Shorter et al., 1977). The authors found these analyses to be useful for helping breeders choose among test sites for early screening of breeding lines. Principal coordinates analysis was employed to examine the use of a reference set of genotypes to monitor genotype-environment interaction (Fox and Rosielle, 1982a) and also to assess methods for removing environmental main effects to provide a description of environments (Fox and Rosielle, 1982b).
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
75
A spatial method for assessing yield stability, in which principal coordinates analysis is based on a suitable measure of similarity between genotypes, has been proposed by Westcott (1987). As pointed out by Crossa (1988), the method has several advantages: ( a ) it is trustworthy when used for data that include extremely low or high yielding sites; ( b ) it does not depend on the set of genotypes included in the analysis; and (c) it is simple to identify stable varieties from the sequence of graphic displays. The spatial method has been extensively used by Crossa et al. (1988a,b, 1989) to assess the yield stability of CIMMYT’s maize genotypes evaluated across international environments.
C. FACTOR ANALYSIS Factor analysis is an ordination procedure related to principal components analysis, the “factors” of the former being similar to the principal components of the later. A large number of correlated variables is reduced to a small number of main factors (Cattell, 1965),and variation is explained in terms of general factors common to all variables and in terms of factors unique to each variable. The axes of the general factors may be rotated to oblique positions to conform to hypothetical ideas. Factor analysis has been used to understand relationships among yield components and morphological characteristics of crops (Walton, 1972; Seiler and Stafford, 1985). Jardine et al. (1963) used an oblique rotation to indicate four relatively independent factors related to bread wheat baking quality. Peterson and Pfeiffer (1989) applied principal factor analysis to study the underlying structures and relationships of test sites, based on winter wheat performance. The authors grouped the original 56 locations into seven regions, which can be considered megaenvironments for winter wheat adaptation. The association between secondary factors was used to identify transitional environments between the seven major regions.
D. CLUSTER ANALYSIS Cluster analysis is a numerical classification technique that defines groups or clusters of individuals. Two types of classification can be distinguished. The first is nonhierarchical classification, which assigns each item to a class. Relationships among classes are not characterized, so this type is useful in the early stages of data analysis. The second type is hierarchical
76
JOSE CROSSA
classification, which groups individuals into clusters and arranges these into a hierarchy for the purpose of studying relationships in the data. Cluster analysis requires a measure of similarity between the individuals to be classified, and it imposes a discontinuity in the data. The method has been used to study genotype adaptation by simplifying the pattern of responses and to subdivide genotypes and environments into more homogeneous groups. Comprehensive reviews of the application of cluster analysis to the study of genotype-environment interactions can be found in Lin et af. (1986) and Westcott (1987). Some of the disadvantages of cluster analysis are: (a) numerous hierarchical grouping algorithms exist, and each of them may produce different cluster groups; (b)the truncation level of the classificatory hierarchies may be decided arbitrarily; (c) many different similarity measures can be used (Lin et af., 1986, listed nine), yielding different results; and (d) cluster analysis may produce misleading results by showing structures and patterns in the data when they do not exist (Gordon, 1981, cited by Westcott, 1987).
VI. AMMI ANALYSIS The additive main effect and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) method integrates analysis of variance and principal components analysis into a unified approach (Bradu and Gabriel, 1978; Gauch, 1988). It can be used to analyze multilocation trials (Gauch and Zobel, 1988; Zobel et al., 1988; Crossa et al., 1990). AMMI analysis first fits the additive main effects of genotypes and environments by the usual analysis of variance and then describes the nonadditive part, genotype-environment interaction, by principal components analysis. The AMMI model is given by Eq. (3). The AMMI method is used for three main purposes. The first is model diagnosis. AMMI is more appropriate in the initial statistical analysis of yield trials, because it provides an analytical tool for diagnosing other models as subcases when these are better for a particular data set (Bradu and Gabriel, 1978; Gauch, 1985). The second use of AMMI is to clarify genotype-environment interactions. AMMI summarizes patterns and relationships of genotypes and environments (Kempton, 1984; Zobel et al., 1988; Crossa et af., 1990). The third use is to improve the accuracy of yield estimates. Gains have been obtained in the accuracy of yield estimates that are equivalent to increasing the number of replicates by a factor of two to five (Zobel et al., 1988; Crossa et af., 1990). Such gains may be used to
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
77
reduce costs by reducing the number of replications, to include more treatments in the experiment, or to improve efficiency in selecting the best genotypes. This last benefit has obvious implications for breeding programs and particularly for maize hybrid testing systems, in which designs with fewer replicates per location are used (Bradley et al., 1988). A. AMMI ANALYSIS WITH PREDICTIVE SUCCESS Traditional analysis of variance of multilocation trials is intended to forecast agricultural performance, but it focuses only on postdictive assessment of genotype yield responses without evaluating the model’s predictive accuracy with validation data not used in constructing the model. Gauch (1985, 1988) emphasized the model’s success in predicting validation data (prediction criteria), in contrast to its success in fitting its own data (postdiction criteria). Because multilocation trials are used for selecting genotype or agronomic treatments for farmers’ fields in new environments, model evaluation should measure predictive success. Gauch proposed that AMMI analysis be used with prediction criteria. Prediction assessment consists of splitting data into two subgroups, modeling data and validation data, and comparing the success of several models by computing their sum of squared difference (SSD) between model predictions and validation data. A small value of SSD indicates good predictive accuracy. Several models are then constructed and compared empirically in terms of their ability to predict the validation data: AMMIO, which estimates only the additive main effects of genotypes and environments and retains none of the principal components axes (PCA); AMMI1, which combines the additive main effects from AMMIO with the genotype-environment interaction effects estimated from the first principal component axis (PCA 1);AMMI2 and so on, up to the full model with all PCA axes. The predictive values of the full model are equal to the average of the replicates selected at random for modeling. Results of postdictive AMMI analysis of a trial consisting of 15 soybean genotypes evaluated in 15 environments are given in Table IV (Gauch, 1988). The postdictive evaluation using F-test at 5% showed that three PCAs of the interaction are significant; therefore, the model, including the two main effects, has 103 df. However, this information includes pattern and noise (systematic and nonsystematic variation). Prediction assessment, on the other hand, does discriminate between pattern and noise and indicates AMMI with one interaction PCA as the best predictive model (Fig. 3). This model has 55 df-14 for genotypes, 14 for environ-
78
JOSE CROSSA Table IV AMMI Analysis for a Soybean Trial"
df 14 14 196 27 25 23 21
Environment Genotype G x E PCA I PCA 2 PCA 3 PCA 4 Residual Error
100
210
ss
MS
38,798 2,552 6,880 2,348 1,250 1,010 736 1,536 4,649
2,77 I *** 182*** 35*** 87*** 50*** M***
35 15
22
From Gauch (1988).
*** Significant at 0.001 probability level.
7000
J
72M) -
0
m m
7400-
E
Ti
1
7600-
7m-
Bwo I
1
28
55
80
103
124
143
160 175 188
208 22013/4
FIG.3. Sum of squared difference (SSD) between model prediction and validation data for IS models (AMMIO with 28 df to the full model with 224 df). From Gauch (1988).
79
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
ments, and 27 for the interaction PCA 1. Further interaction PCAs will capture mostly noise and therefore do not help to predict validation observations. The interaction of 15 soybean genotypes with 15 environments is best predicted by the first principal component of genotypes and environments. Thus, the model is
Yo = p
+ Gi + Ej + k l v , i ~ +l j eii
(9)
From (9) it can be seen that, when a genotype or an environment has an interaction PCA score of nearly 0, it has a small interaction. When both have PCA scores of the same sign, their interaction is positive; if different, their interaction is negative. For data in which AMMI1 is found to be the best predicted model, a graphical display of the genotype and environment interaction PCA I and their mean effects should be useful for revealing favorable patterns in genotype response across environments. Figure 4 gives the mean on the x axis and the AMMI interaction PCA 1 scores on the y axis of 17 maize genotypes tested in 36 environments (Crossa et al., 1990). Three groups of genotypes with different genetic composition can be seen: ( a )group 1 includes genotypes 13, 14,15, and 17, which contain temperate germplasm from the U.S. Corn Belt and southern Europe; (b) group 2 comprises genotypes 1, 2,3,4, and 5, which are from subtropical regions and have intermediate maturity; and (c) group 3 contains genotypes 6 to 12 and 16, which are derived from lowland tropical maize types from Mexico and the Caribbean islands. Interaction PCA 1 scores arrange the environments in a sequence from tropical environments 3020-
00
'0:
00
0
04
00
5 -10:
a
0 0
0
.
-20-
CO
-301
017
-40
013
015 014
0
-60
0
1880
2880
3880
4880
5880
6880
I
7880
Mean (kg ha-')
FIG. 4. Plot of the means (kg ha-') and PCA 1 scores of 17 maize genotypes ( 0 ) and 36 environments (0). From Crossa er a / . (1990).
80
JOSE CROSSA
(positive PCA 1) to temperate environments (negative PCA 1). The two temperate environments with the greatest negative PCA 1 scores favor temperate germplasm (group 1). At the other extreme of the diagram, tropical environments tend to favor genotypes from group 2 and 3.
VII. OTHER METHODS OF ANALYSIS Many other approaches might be employed for studying genotypeenvironment interactions. Several of them have not been examined systematically or extensively used for different crops. In most yield trials, environments are measured by the average yield of the genotypes or agronomic treatments. However, it is important to collect, analyze, and interpret physiological and environmental variables for ( a ) studying their relationships with genotype performance and (b)understanding the causes of the observed genotype-environment interaction (Westcott, 1986; Eisemann and Mungomery, 1981). The differential physiological responses of genotypes to edaphic and climatic factors, especially those related to nutrient efficiency and stress tolerance, are relevant to genotype-environment interaction (Baker, 1988a,c). The multilinear regression method, in which environmental data are used as independent variables, can be employed for predictive purposes (Knight, 1970; Feyerherm and Paulsen, 1981; Haun, 1982). Hardwick (1972) and Hardwick and Wood (1972) used physiological and environmental variables to develop a predictive multiple linear regression model. Principal components analysis, combined with multiple regression, may be useful for reducing the number of environmental variables to be included in the final analysis (Perkins, 1972). Principal components analysis was used by Holland (1 969) to summarize and interpret environmental data. However, it is of limited use, because the importance of a certain variable in the analysis may not be related to the extent of genotype response (Eisemann and Mungomery, 1981). Most of the exploratory or geometrical methods can be applied to the analysis of multilocation trials, although their use for this purpose has not been investigated. Ordination techniques, such as weighted average (Rowe 1956), polar ordination (Bray and Curtis, 1957), reciprocal average (Fisher, 1940), and detrended correspondence analysis (Hill and Gauch, 1980) have been used in community ecology to discover structures in data matrices (Gauch, 1982b). Their use in examining the pattern of genotype (or environment) responses needs investigation.
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
81
Canonical discriminant analysis has been used to allocate environments according to their interaction with genotypes (Seif ef al., 1979). The stratified ranking method was used by Fox et al. (1990)for analyzing general adaptation of a large international triticale data base. The technique scores the number of locations for which each line occurred in the top, second, and bottom one-third of the entries in each trial. A line that occurred in the top one-third of the entries across locations was considered well adapted. Unbalanced data often occur in multilocation trials as a result of ( a ) missing plots or ( b ) combining results of different experiments that do not have the same set of treatments. For incomplete data, missing plot values can be fitted, and the genotype-environment interaction sum of squares can be further partitioned into principal components (Freeman, 1975). An algorithm for inputting missing values and then fitting the additive main effect and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) model has recently been developed (Gauch and Zobel, 1990).
VIII. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS Data from multilocation trials help researchers estimate yields more accurately, select better production alternatives, and understand the interaction of these technologies with environments. Several methodologies have been presented for efficient statistical analysis of such data. For geneticists, plant breeders, and agronomists, parametric stability statistics, obtained by linear regression analysis, are mathematically simple and biologically interpretable. However, this method has major disadvantages: ( a ) it is uninformative when linearity fails; (6)it is highly dependent on the set of genotypes and environments included in the analysis; and (c) it tends to oversimplify the different response patterns by explaining the interaction variation in one dimension (regression coefficient), when in reality it may be highly complex. There is a danger in sacrificing relevant information for easy biological and statistical interpretation. A broad range of multivariate methods can be used to analyze multilocation yield trial data and assess yield stability. Although some of them overcome the limitations of linear regression, the results are often difficult to interpret in relation to genotype-environment interaction (as is the case with principal components analysis and cluster analysis). Certain multi-
82
JOSE CROSSA
variate techniques or a combination of them offer very relevant biological information and are statistically simple. The integration of certain ordination and classification multivariate methods into so-called “pattern” analysis and factor analysis and the biplot method are valuable tools for grouping environments or genotypes showing similar response patterns. The combination of analysis of variance and principal components analysis in the AMMI model, along with prediction assessment, is a valuable approach for understanding genotype-environment interaction and obtaining better yield estimates. Agronomic predictive assessment with AMMI can be used to analyze the results of on-farm trials. More research is needed to quantify the probability of successful selection of a genotype or agronomic treatment when using AMMI predictive value, compared with the probability of its selection based on the predictive value of other models. Only qualitative or crossover interactions are relevant in agriculture. Therefore, appropriate statistical analysis for quantifying and testing changes in rank from one environment to another is required. More attention has to be devoted to the collection, analysis, and interpretation of environmental and physiological variables. This will help to characterize particular genotypes and geographical regions and therefore better explain certain aspects of the interaction.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author thanks Drs. Kent Eskridge, Paul Fox, and Hugh Gauch for their helpful comments on the manuscript.
REFERENCES Anderson, J. R. 1974. R e v . Marketing Agric. Econ. 42, 131-184. Azzalini, A., and Cox, D. R. 1984. J. R . Stat. Soc. 46,335-343. Baker, R. J. 1969. C a n . J . Plant Sci. 49,743-751. Baker, R. J. 1988a. I n “Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Quantitative Genetics.” Sinauer, Sunderland, Massachusetts. Baker, R. J. 1988b. C a n . J . Plant Sci. 68,405-410. Baker, R. J. 1988c. “IS1 Atlas of Science: Animal and Plant Sciences.” Barah, B. C., Binswanger, H. P., Rana, B. S., Rao, N. P. 1981. Euphytica 30,451-458. Binswanger, H. P., and Barah, B. C. 1980. Research Bulletin No. 3. International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT). Palanchero, India. Bradley, J. P., Knittle, K. N., and Troyer, A. F. 1988. J . Prod. Agric. 1, 34-38. Bradu, D., and Gabriel, K. R. 1978. Technometries 20,47-68. Bray, J. R., and Curtis, J. T. 1957. Ecol. Monogr. 27,325-349.
STATISTICAL ANALYSES O F MULTILOCATION TRIALS
83
Bruckner, P. L., and Frohberg, R. C. 1987. Crop Sci. 27,31-36. Bucio Alanis, L., Perkins, J. M., and Jinks, J. L. 1969. Heredity 24, 115-127. Byth, D. E., Eisemann, R. L., and De Lacy, I. H. 1976. Heredity 37,215-230. Cattell, 1965. Biometrics 21, 190-215. Cochran, W. G., and Cox, G. M. 1957. “Experimental Designs,” 2nd Ed. Wiley, New York. Cockerham, C. C. 1964. “Statistical Genetics and Plant Breeding,” Vol. 982, pp. 53-93. National Academy of Science-National Research Council, Washington, D.C. Comstock, R. E., and Moll, R. H. 1964. “Statistical Genetics and Plant Breeding,” Vol. 982, pp. 164-196. National Academy of Science-National Research Council, Washington, D.C. Crossa, J. 1988. Theor. Appl. Genet. 75,460-467. Crossa, J., Westcott, B., and Gonzalez, C. 1988a. Theor. Appl. Genet. 75,863-868. Crossa, J . , Westcoot, B., and Gonzalez, C. 1988b. Exp. Agric. 24,253-263. Crossa, J., Westcott, B., and Gonzalez, C. 1989. Euphytica 40,245-251. Crossa, J . , Gauch, H. G., and Zobel, R. W. (1990). Crop Sci. 30,493-500. Digby, P. G. N. 1979. J. Agric. Sci. 93, 81-86. Eagles, H. A., and Frey, K. J. 1977. Crop Sci. 17,253-256. Easton, H. S., and Clements, R. J. 1973. J. Agric. Sci. 80,43-52. Eberhart, S. A., and Russell, W. A. 1966. Crop Sci. 6,36-40. Eisemann, R. L. 1981. I n “Interpretation of Plant Respnse and Adaptation to Agricultural Environments.” Univ. of Queensland, St. Lucia, Brisbane. Eisemann, R. L., and Mungomery, V. E . 1981. In “Interpretation of Plant Response and Adaptation to Agricultural Environments.” Univ. of Queensland, St. Lucia, Brisbane. Eskridge, K. M. 1990. Crop Sci. 30,369-374. Feyerherm, A. M., and Paulsen, G. M. 1981. Agron. J. 73,277-282. Finlay, K. W., and Wilkinson, G. N . 1963. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 14,742-754. Fisher, R. A. 1918. Trans. R. SOC.Edinburgh 52,399-433. Fisher, R. A. 1925. ‘Statistical Methods for Research Workers.” Oliver & Boyd, London. Fisher, R. A. 1940. Ann. Eugenics 10,422-429. Fox, P. N., and Rathjen, A. J. 1981. Ausf. J . Agric. Res. 32,691-702. Fox, P. N., and Rosielle, A. A. 1982a. Crop Sci. 22, 1171-1175. Fox, P. N., and Rosielle, A. A. 1982b. Euphytica 31,645-656. Fox, P. N., Skovmand, B., Thompson, B. K., Braun, H.-J., and Cormier, R. 1990.Euphyfica 47,5744. Freeman, G. H. 1973. Heredity 31,339-354. Freeman, G . H. 1975. Appl. Star. 24, 1-46. Freeman, G. H., 1985. J . Appl. Star. l2,3-10. Freeman, G. H., and Dowker, B. D. 1973. Heredity 30,97-109. Freeman, G . H., and Perkins, J. M. 1971. Heredity 27, 15-23. Gabriel, K. R. 1971. Biometriku 58,453-467. Gabriel, K. R. 1981. “Interpreting Multivariate Data.” Wiley, Chichester. Gail, M., and Simon, R. 1985. Biometrics 41, 361-372. Gardner, C. 0. 1964. “Statistical Genetics and Plant Breeding,” Vol. 982. pp. 225-252. National Academy of Science-National Research Council, Washington, D.C. Gauch, H. G. 1982a. Ecology 63, 1643-1649. Gauch, H. G. 1982b. “Multivariate Analysis in Community Ecology,” 1st Ed. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. Gauch, H. G. 1985. Mimeo 85-7. Cornell Univ. Ithaca, New York. Gauch, H. G. 1988. Biometrics 44,705-715. Gauch, H. G., and Zobel, R. W. 1990. Theor. Appl. Genet. (in press).
84
JOSE CROSSA
Gauch, H. G., and Zobel, R. W. 1988. Theor. Appl. Genet. 76, 1-10. Gollob, H. F. 1968. Psychometrika 33,73-116. Goodchild, N. A., and Boyd, W. J. R. 1975. Aust. J . Agric. Res. 26,209-217. Gordon, A. D. 1981. “Classification.” Chapman & Hall, London. Gower, J. C. 1966. Biometrika 53,325-338. Gower, J. C. 1967. Statistician 17, 13-28. Graybill, F. A., and Hultquist, R. A. 1961. Ann. Math. Stat. 32,261-269. Hardwick, R. C. 1972. Nature (London) New Biol. 236, 191-192. Hardwick, R. C., and Wood, J. T. 1972. Heredity 28,209-222. Haun, J. R. 1982. Agric. Meteor. 27, 191-207. Hill, J. 1975. J. Agric. Sci. 85,477-493. Hill, J., and Goodchild, N. A. 1981. Theor. Appl. Genet. 59,317-325. Hill, M. O., and Gauch, H. G. 1980. Vegeratio 42,47-58. Hill, R. R., and Baylor, J. E. 1983. Crop Sci. 23,811-815. Hirosaki, S., Okuno, T., and Shiyomi, M. 1975. “JIBP Synthesis,” Vol. 6. Univ. of Tokyo Press, Tokyo. Holland, D. A. 1969. Exp. Agric. 5, 151-164. Hotelling, H. 1933. J. Educ. Psycho/. 24,417-441. Jardine, R., Moss, H. J., and Mullaly, J. V. 1963. Aust. J . Agric. Res. 14,603-621. Johnson, G. R. 1977. Crop Sci. 17,837-842. Kempton, R. A. 1984. J. Agric. Sci. 103, 123-135. Knight, R. 1970. Euphytica 19,225-235. Lin, C. S., and Binns, M. R. 1988. Can. J. Planr Sci. 68, 193-198. Lin, C. S., Binns, M. R., and Lefkovitch, L. P. 1986. Crop Sci. 26,894-900. Mandel, J. 1961. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 56,878-888. Mandel, J. 1969. J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. (U.S.) 11,411-429. Mandel, J. 1971. Technometrics 13, 1-18. Mather, K., and Caligari, P. D. S. 1974. Heredity 33,43-59. Moll, R. H., Cockerham, C. C., Stuber, C. W., and Williams, W. P. 1978. Crop Sci. 18, 641-645.
Mead, R., Riley, J., Dear, K., and Singh, S. P. 1986. Biometrics 42,253-266. Menz, K. M. 1980. Field Crop Res. 3,33-41. Mungomery, V. E., Shorter, R., and Byth, D. E. 1974. Aust. J . Agric. Res. 25,59-72. Patterson, H. D., and Silvey, V. 1980. J. R . Star. SOC.143,219-252. Patterson, H. D., and Thompson, R. 1971. Biometrika 58,545-554. Patterson, H. D., and Thompson, R. 1975. Proc. 8th I n t . Biornetric Conf. pp. 197-207. Pearson, K. 1901. Philos. Mag. 2,559-572. Perkins, J. M. 1972. Heredity 29, 51-70. Peterson, C. J., and F‘feiffer, W. H. 1989. Crop Sci.29,276-282. Plaisted, R. L., and Peterson, L. C. 1959. A m . Potato J . 36,381-385. Polignano, G. B., Ugenti, P., and Pemno, P. 1989. Euphytica 40,31-41. Pooni, H. S., and Jinks, J. L. 1980. Heredity. 45,389-400. Robinson, D. 1987. Statistician 36,3-14. Rowe, J. S. 1956. Ecology 37,461-473. Seif, E., Evans, J. C., and Balaam, L. N. 1979. Aust. J . Agric. Res. 30, 1021-1026. Seiler, G. J., and Stafford, R. E. 1985. Crop Sci.25,905-908. Shorter, R. 1981. I n “Interpretation of Plant Response and Adaptation to Agricultural Environments.” Univ. of Queensland, St. Lucia, Brisbane. Shorter, R., Byth, D. E., and Mungomery, V. E. 1977. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 28,223-235. Shukla, G. K. 1972. Heredity 29,237-245.
STATISTICAL ANALYSES OF MULTILOCATION TRIALS
85
Suzuki, S. 1968. Proc. Int. Congr. Genet. 12th. 1968 1. Thompson, W. A. 1961. Bull. Int. Inst. Stat. 34, 1-4. Thompson, W. A. 1962. Ann. Math. Stat. 33, 273-289. Walton, P. D. 1972. Crop. Sci. U,731-733. Westcott, B. 1986. Heredity 56,243-253. Westcott, B. 1987. J. Agric. Sci. 108,267-274. Williams, E. J. 1952. Biometrika 39,65-81. Williams, W. T. 1976. “Pattern Analysis in Agriculture Science.” CSIRO, Melbourne and Elsevier, Amsterdam. Williams, W. T., and Gillard, P. 1971. Aust. J . Agric. Res. 22, 245-260. Witcombe, J. R. 1988. Euphytica 39, 11-18. Witcombe, J. R., and Wittington, W. J. 1971. Heredity 26, 397-411. Wricke, G. 1962. Z. Pjlanzenzuecht. 47,92-96. Wricke, G. 1964. Z. Pjlanzenzuecht. 52, 127-138. Yates, F., and Cochran, W. G. 1938. J. Agric. Sci. 28,556-580. Zobel, R. W., Wright, M. J., and Gauch, H. G. 1988. Agron. J. 80,388-393.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 44
EVALUATION AND DOCUMENTATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS A. B. Damania Genetic Resources Unit International Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA) Aleppo, Syria
I. 11. 111. IV . V. VI. VII.
Introduction Evaluation of Cultivated Wheat Evaluation of Cultivated Barley Genetic Resources from Ethiopia Evaluation of Wild and Primitive Forms of Wheat and Barley Documentation of Genetic Resources Summary and Conclusions References
I. INTRODUCTION Agriculture is a relatively recent historical phenomenon having begun just over 10,000 years ago in the near East and later in Central America. Through the increase of food after the beginning of the agricultural (neolithic = food producing) revolution, the human species has incredibly multiplied its own population at the expense of the rest of the world’s biota (Reed, 1969). Early farmers initiated a series of partly conscious selections that have resulted in the landraces we see today. Plant breeding activity did not begin until the mid-1800s. This activity gathered pace after the turn of the century and breeders such as Strampelli were already using wild and primitive forms in breeding programs following the rediscovery of Mendel’s work (Maliani and Bianchi, 1979). Vavilov (1926) was the first to realize the need for a broad genetic base for crop plant improvement. But after the Second World War, massive aid projects led to the development of high-yielding cultivars that began steadily replacing the local varieties (landraces), thus narrowing the genetic base of several vital crops such as wheat, barley, and rice. By the 1960s, an urgent need was expressed in two symposia (Frankel and Ben87 Copyright Q 1990 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduclion in any form reserved.
88
A. B. DAMANIA
nett, 1970; Frankel and Hawkes, 1975a) to preserve the older more variable germplasm and wild relatives, which began to be referred to as genetic resources. The term “genetic resources” per se excludes breeding lines and recently released varieties (Frankel and Hawkes, 1975b), which are composed of gene combinations rather than the genes themselves. The two symposia also thoroughly reviewed the need for immediate and systematic exploration and collection on a worldwide scale of genetic resources of food and other commercial crops. An International Board for Plant Genetic Resources (IBPGR) was formed in 1972 by the Technical Advisory Committee of the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research to undertake the plant collection and conservation recommended by the symposia. With the establishment of the IBPGR, collection and conservation of representative samples of genetic variability in landrace populations were accelerated and a large number of samples began to accumulate in the cold stores of the major genebanks. Genetic resources merely stored safely are of little value to plant breeders unless they are evaluated and the resulting data made widely available. Evaluation is, therefore, an essential link between conservation and use. In fact, Frankel (1987) categorically stated that genetic resources have been utilized without elaborate characterization, but never without evaluation. The next step was to evaluate the collected samples to identify sources of useful traits in order that the material be better utilized than in the past. The evaluation process for large collections follows several distinct stages: (a) seed multiplication and preliminary evaluation; ( 6 ) systematic evaluation of the entire collection; and (c) further evaluation of selected accessions (Chang, 1985). The utilization aspect of genetic resources was recently reviewed by Brown et al. (1989), wherein factors that are likely to limit or facilitate this process are discussed. Genetic resources workers discriminate between “characterization” and “evaluation” (Erskine and Williams, 1980; Hawkes, 1985), although this fact is not widely known. Characterization is defined as recording information only once on those traits that are highly heritable, easily visible, and expressed in all environments, for example, grain patterns and isozyme profiles. Characterization provides a standardized record of readily observable morphological characters that, together with passport (origin) data, identify an accession in the genebank. Evaluation, on the other hand, is the assessment of more variable traits for potential use in breeding, such as plant height, time to maturity, disease resistance, and protein content. This is done in several ways: growing the material in different environments, exposing it to various abiotic and biotic stresses, assessing grain quality, and selecting the best lines for the desirable attri-
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
89
butes. “Preliminary evaluation” refers to screening that is frequently carried out during multiplication, at a single location and without the use of replicates prior to the incorporation of the samples into the collection (Damania et al., 1983; Erskine and Williams, 1980). The information generated by characterization and evaluation not only improves utilization of the germplasm but also rationalizes storage space by identifying duplicates and eliminating redundant germplasm. In spite of the wide recognition given to the importance of conserving and evaluating genetic resources (Frankel and Bennett, 1970; Hawkes, 1971, 1983; Frankel and Hawkes, 1975a; Harlan, 1975; Plucknett et al., 1983; Holden and Williams, 1984; Rogalewicz, 1985), little was known about the variability in the primitive forms, old landraces, and wild relatives of cereals and much work still remains to be done. Detailed evaluation of stored populations of different origins allows an understanding of the patterns of variability. The population structure of a species is defined as the totality of ecological and genetical relationships among individual members that may coevolve as a result of gene exchange, but may also diverge under localized forces of evolutionary change (Jain, 1975). Landraces and primitive cultivars are products of many years of crop evolution, and it is vital to preserve their genetic composition during and after evaluation. Cases have been reported where polymorphic cereal populations have undergone radical changes in their genetic composition in one growing cycle (Shevchuk, 1973). However, in the case of samples collected from village markets or those that are subjected to biased sampling methods, it is sufficient to safeguard and maintain their genes and not necessarily their gene frequencies within populations. It is now widely recognized that extensive surveys of geographic areas for genetic variability and computerized documentation of the evaluation results are needed for the utilization of large collections of cereal genetic resources. The problems of describing geographic variability data and development of statistical methods for categorizing sets of population samples from diverse localities have been discussed by Gabriel and Sokal (1969), and the analysis of variability between and within genotypes and environments has been discussed by Freeman and Dowker (1973). Computers with appropriate statistical packages have greatly facilitated this task of documentation. This chapter reviews the status of evaluation and documentation of genetic resources of wheat and barley. The work of a multidisciplinary team of evaluators that include germplasm scientists, taxonomists, cytogeneticists, pathologists, biochemists, and physiologists is presented, followed by conclusions and suggestions for future avenues of research.
90
A. B. DAMANIA
II. EVALUATION OF CULTIVATED WHEAT The evaluation of cereal genetic resources collections goes back to the time when their value to crop improvement began to be appreciated by the breeders. Cultivated wheat has been the most extensively evaluated crop among cereals, which is in keeping with the prominent position it enjoys in terms of production tonnage and importance as a food crop. Qualset and Puri (1973) evaluated heading time in a world collection of durum wheat (Triticumdurum Desf.) and presented results for each geographic area from which samples were analyzed. They found a wide range of heading time in about 3700 samples studies and identified those that were highly photosensitive. Puri and Qualset (1978) also researched effect of seed and seeding rate on yield and other characteristics of durum wheat and found a positive correlation between large seed size and yield. In another study, geographic patterns of phenotypic diversity for qualitative traits of more than 3000 samples of durum wheats were evaluated in the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) world collection at Tulelake, California, by Jain et al. (1975). Observations were recorded on leaf sheath glossiness, glume pubescence and color, awn color, kernel color, and basal spike node fertility. Variability for each character was found usually within each geographical region. Although Jain et al. (1975) admit that the collection was small and not representative, they found centers of diversity among material from Ethiopia, India, and the Mediterranean countries. Some of the areas known to be important sources of genetic resources were poorly represented in the study, a fact emphasizing the need for intensification of efforts in exploration and conservation. Spagnoletti Zeuli and Qualset (1987) have reported an evaluation study on the same durum wheat entries for spike characters. Five clusters were delineated among 26 country origins and an east to west clinal pattern was detected that represented a gradient in unimproved to improved types. In a previous study, Porceddu (1976) evaluated 2400 wheat landraces from the world collection of durum wheat and recorded information on growth habit, beginning of shooting, heading time, culm length, and number of elongated internodes. Distinct differences were found to exist among samples from different countries. Multivariate analysis showed that samples from Mediterranean countries were very similar, probably due to old trade links. Similarity in other samples from Cyprus, Egypt, Jordan, and Palestine was also noted. Another discovery was the significant similarity between accessions from Turkey and the United States. This was attributed to the history of transport of germplasm from Turkey and subsequent inclusion in U.S. varieties. Konzak et al. (1973) also evaluated wheaL germplasm from Turkey for reaction to mildew at
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
91
Pullman, Washington, U.S.A., and estimated yellow berry content of the grain produced. Porceddu and Scarascia-Mugnozza (1983) carried out similar studies for ascertaining variability in landraces of durum wheat from Algeria, Ethiopia, and Italy and found that there was clear separation between Ethiopian and Italian material, but Italian landraces were more variable among themselves than Ethiopian ones and material from Algeria was more variable than both the other two. Hence, differences among landrace populations from the same country were highly significant for all 1 1 characters studied, except kernel weight and spike density. Using multivariate analysis also, Kosina ( 1980) evaluated structure and caryopsis quality of some hybrids of spring wheat. Ehdaie and Waines (1989) described genetic variability in T. aestiuum from Iran. They concluded that local landraces, such as those found in Iran, could be improved by selection for shorter genotypes with fewer tillers per plant, but with larger and heavier grains. Morphological and physiological variability in T. aestiuum collected from Afghanistan was also reported comprehensively by Tani and Sakamoto (1987). There are traits, such as resistance to diseases and tolerances to certain types of soils, for which variability can only be observed at particular sites. Such traits are economically important and every effort must be made to record and document them by carrying out evaluation at sites where the incidence of that particular stress is the greatest, such as the so-called disease “hot spots.” For example, for screening against resistance to Septoria tritici (leaf blotch), ICARDA uses a humid and high-rainfall site located on the Mediterranean coast in Syria in addition to artificial inoculation. For experiments on tolerance to salinity, a drought-affected site on the shores of salt lake Jabboul in northern Syria is used. Jana et al. (1983) evaluated 3000 durum wheat accessions from various countries at this site, and 10 lines were found to be highly tolerant to combined stresses of salinity and drought. However, it is known that salinity is highly variable in the field and if experiments do not comprise several replicates, laboratory confirmation with tests such as chlorophyll influorescence (Smillie and Nott, 1982) may be used to help identify salt-tolerant lines. Selected bread wheat and barley plants from landraces grown in Nepal and Pakistan were examined and variability for certain qualitative traits described by Witcombe (1975). Barley from Nepal was found to be more variable than barley from Pakistan, whereas in the case of wheat the reverse was true. Murphy and Witcombe (198 I ) further analyzed landraces of wheat from northern India by growing single plants under glasshouse conditions in Wales, U.K. Multivariate analysis of data on quantitative traits was used to distinguish between introduced material and indigenous germplasm on the basis of means recorded on single plants. This data
92
A. B. DAMANIA
analysis method was used to detect modern varieties so they could be excluded from genebanks as genetic resources. However, variability studies based on observations of quantitative traits on single plants in a controlled environment are inconclusive and should be verified by field studies before an inference is drawn. Damania et al. (1985) evaluated populations of wheat and barley landraces from Nepal (Triticum aestivum and Hordeum vulgare L.) and the Yemen Arab Republic (T. turgidum L. and H . distichum L.) for morphological variability and days-to-heading under field conditions using sufficiently large samples. Observations were recorded for 18 characters on 50 randomly selected plants from each landrace. There were significant differences in variability among regions in the Yemen and river valleys in Nepal, as well as among landraces in the same regions or river valleys. It was concluded that landrace variability within primary or secondary centers of diversity could not be fully evaluated without growing the plant material in the field under conditions similar to the original habitat, although an initial impression of the extent of variability can be obtained through the application of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) of seed proteins (Damania et a / ., 1983). Variability in high-molecular-weight glutenin subunits in landraces of hexaploid wheats from Afghanistan was also evaluated by Lagudah et al. (1987) using PAGE. The variability seemed to be independent of the altitude and geographical location of the collection site. A world collection of bread wheat (T. aestivum L.) maintained by the USDA was systematically analyzed for protein and lysine content by Vogel et al. (1973). Lewontin (1974) has expounded the advantages of electrophoretic surveys of proteins as measures of genetic diversity and reviewed the technical limitations and conceptual opportunities offered to plant biologists using this technique. Wheats can also be evaluated for quality and study of genomes and genotypes with the use of PAGE (Konarev et al., 1979). Kobrehel and Gautier (1973) studied peroxidase patterns of primitive and modern wheats by PAGE and found that brownness in macaronis can be associated with the compositions of the peroxidases. Damania (1985) demonstrated the usefulness of this technique in evaluating landraces of hexaploid wheats and their possible utilization in improving the bread-making quality of modern varieties. However, predictions on good or poor gluten quality based solely on presence or absence of certain bands in an electrophoretic gel may not be conclusive. It has been pointed out that the band with relative mobility (Rm) 45 and the band of Rm 42, which were indicators for good pasta and bread-making qualities in durum and bread wheat, respectively, were merely genetic markers, whereas other proteins (low-molecular-weight glutenins) were responsible for gluten viscoelasticity (Pogna et al., 1988).
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
93
Information on the genetic variability of a sample is extremely useful and the eventual objective of every evaluator should be to describe the variation on the basis of a list of differences between and within samples in the sequence of nucleotides in the deoxyribonucleic acid (Erskine and Williams, 1980). At present, the study of storage protein (prolamins) variants by electrophoresis is the most convenient and rapid method available for detecting genetic differences at the DNA level in a cereal collection (Damania et al., 1983). Documentation of data derived from electrophoretic studies of storage proteins in cereal genetic resources has been reviewed by Konarev et al. (1979). However, it may be argued that heterogeneity in storage proteins alone is of little value to the breeders or genetic conservationists because its correlation with any single agronomic character is obscure. Nevertheless, these markers can perhaps monitor the relative genetic diversity with a greater degree of accuracy (Brown, 1978; Damania, 1983) than field studies with an inadequate number of traits. A prescreening procedure for identification of the ploidy levels and chromosomal aberrations, such as deletions with the use of electrophoresis, has been described by Damania (1985). This technique can also be used as a tool for elimination of duplicate germplasm stocks (Damania and Somaroo, 1988).
Ill. EVALUATION OF CULTIVATED BARLEY Barley is one of the most dependable cereal crops in harsh environments. It is grown in semiarid areas as well as in cold, short-season areas. Local varieties and landraces of barleys occupy nearly 80% of the cultivated areas in West Asia and North Africa and these should be collected before they are lost. Ward (1962), in one of the early efforts to characterize a large number of germplasm samples, evaluated 6200 lines from the USDA world collection of barleys and recorded observations on seven qualitative characters. He concluded that only a very small portion of the potential genetic diversity in barley was represented in the collection. Farmers still rely on barley landraces that have a stable performance in the dry areas and rarely outyield modern homogeneous varieties (Ceccarelli et al., 1987). The variability within these landraces is large and compares well with that within populations of its wild relative, Hordeum spontaneum, growing in the same region (Jana and Pietrzak, 1988). Variability for agronomic traits in landraces of barley has been evaluated by several workers. De Pace et al. (1978) crossed a set of six old Italian wheat varieties (female parents) with five breeding lines from the International Wheat and Maize Improve-
94
A. B. DAMANIA
ment Center (CIMMYT). The F3 progenies were grown in the field and variability for flag-leaf size, heading, and maturity time was recorded on single plants. It was concluded that utilization of genetic resources distant from the present varieties is advantageous as it permits breakage of linkage groups. The Cereal Improvement Program at ICARDA collected barley landraces from 33 locations in the drier regions of Syria and Jordan (Weltzien, 1982a). On subsequent evaluation it was found that some samples from Syria had a definite cold requirement to induce flowering (Weltzien, 1982b), indicating that under local conditions this trait may contribute to yield stability by preventing winterkill of early-planted material. Information of this kind is valuable for a crop improvement program, not only by showing which characteristics contribute to adaptation but also by indicating the degree of plasticity present in the indigenous landraces for which varietal improvement may be undertaken. Tolbert et al. (1979) carried out a diversity analysis on the USDA world collection of barleys and Ceccarelli et al. (1987)evaluated genetic diversity of barley landraces from Syria and Jordan for agronomic, morphological, and quality traits. Considerable diversity was observed between as well as within collection sites. Single-plant progenies were identified with larger yields and more desirable expression of agronomic characters than the original landraces. On the other hand, Murphy and Witcombe (1986) performed discriminant and reciprocal averaging analysis on single plants of covered and naked barleys from the Himalaya and confirmed their difference in a multivariate way. Sixteen populations of two-rowed barleys from the Yeman Arab Republic were screened for loose smut (Ustilago nuda) disease and found to be highly resistant when compared to the six-rowed barley landraces from Nepal (Damania and Porceddu, 1981). Incidence of diseases varies depending on climatic factors and inferences made of natural infestation in a single season should be avoided as they can be misleading. In another screening of landrace material, van Leur et al. (1989) tested 280 barley lines collected from different sites in Syria and Jordan. Large variability in response to four disease-yellow rust, scald, powdery mildew, and covered smut-was observed. No consistent association between the environmental conditions of the collection site and the level of resistance of the landrace lines could be found. Variation of flavonoids between barley lines was studied and found to be greatest in the Near East (Afghanistan and Iran) and Ethiopia (Frost et al., 1975). Allard et al. (1970) reviewed some studies on enzyme variability in a world collection of barleys and reported on the geographical distribution of different enzyme variants and factors responsible for the development and maintenance of the observed variability in the samples.
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
95
In any survey of the distribution of genetic variability within a crop species of economic value, or its wild relatives, the most obvious pattern that emerges is the variability associated with broad geographical regions (Allard, 1970). It is important to sample not only the broadest geographical variability but also to have samples from the extremity of distribution of the species, that is, the marginal areas. According to the hypothesis of “peripheral diversity” put forward by Yamashita (1980), it has been suggested that there is considerable accumulation of diversity where a species has reached its geographical limits as a result of physical or climatic barriers that it cannot traverse. This variability needs to be collected, followed by evaluation for economically useful traits.
IV. GENETIC RESOURCES FROM ETHIOPIA A mention must be made of the very substantial amount of variability in genetic resources still to be found in Ethiopia (Porceddu and Perrino, 1973; Mengesha, 1975) and the considerable evaluation studies carried out on this material. This region of Africa has been often quoted as a secondary center of diversity of tetraploid wheats, and Vavilov (1932)was able to find a high amount of variability among and within samples. Porceddu et al. (1973) described 145 morphologically different phenotypes in a collection of tetraploid wheats from Ethiopia. The influence of altitude on yield and quality in cereals in Ethiopia was reported by Alkamper (1974). Bekele (1984) carried out an extensive evaluation study on populations of 153 tetraploid and 72 hexaploid wheats, respectively, collected from several regions in Ethiopia; 633 1 and 2700 individual plants were studied for 11 morphological characters. Jain et al. (1975) emphasized the importance of both regional and local patterns of genetic variability to genetic resources conservationists as well as to plant breeders. Analyses of regional patterns of variability for characters to determine the relative contribution of various regions to genetic resources showed differences in the level of importance of useful germplasm material. Polymorphism in characters was higher for tetraploid than hexaploid wheats, indicating that Ethiopia is almost certainly a center for diversity for tetraploid wheats. The contribution to total variability varied among characters and in both forms the contribution to the total phenotypic diversity was highest at the lowest level (within localities), followed by the differences among populations in a region, and among regions themselves. Qualset (1975) discussed optimal sampling strategy for germplasm possessing a single desirable trait in a center of diversity, using disease resistance in Ethiopian barleys as an example. The identity of genes in barley
96
A . B. DAMANIA
accessions from Ethiopia when compared with genes in primitive barley samples from the area of origin in the fertile crescent of the Middle East would provide evidence for the migration of this crop from the primary center of origin to Ethiopia. Negassa (1985a) evaluated the Ethiopian barleys for resistance to powdery mildew, studied the patterns of phenotypic diversity in a collection, and suggested that the Arussi-Bale highlands in Ethiopia was the secondary center of origin for H . vulgare (Negassa, 1985b). In another significant evaluation work, Negassa (1986) studied a collection of 293 entries of tetraploid and hexaploid wheats from Ethiopia. Some characters showed clinal variability, whereas others had localized concentrations. More significantly, a gene center for grain quality was identified in southern Ethiopia and this was confirmed by Dominici e f a / . (1988), who found lines with gliadin (storage protein of wheat) banding patterns not reported before from Ethiopian wheat landraces through an electrophoretic study. During 1967-1968, Kyoto University organized a collecting mission that covered Ethiopia (Sakamoto and Fukui, 1972).The principal objective was to investigate the variability pattern of cultivated plants and collect samples of their local strains. Seven hundred and seven accessions of wheat and barley were collected. Preliminary observations and analysis of variance on morphology and spike coloration have been published. Report of such information after evaluation of collected material is very useful for planning future collecting activities and every expedition must follow this example. The Ethiopian gene center certainly appears to be harboring interesting material when germplasm with such a high level of variability has already disappeared from other centers of diversity. Hence, further collections could be made to conserve genetic resources before the expanding human population and deforestation lead to genetic erosion.
V. EVALUATION OF WILD AND PRIMITIVE FORMS OF WHEAT AND BARLEY Wild relatives and primitive forms are those from which the present crop plants were domesticated and that continue to survive in conjunction with the cultivated species or by themselves as weeds. Several of these forms have become tolerant to biotic and abiotic stresses in their natural habitats, thus enhancing their value to agriculture as additional sources of genetic variability. However, their usefulness to plant breeders depends on their cytogenetic affinity and barriers to hybridization, the amount of
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
97
germplasm available for evaluation, and the desirable traits revealed, and whether repeated backcrossing is needed to eliminate undesirable traits introduced from the wild or primitive parent. The evaluation of wild relatives of crop plants, including wheat and barley, has also been reviewed by Harlan (1984). Many regions in the world have succeeded in improving crop production through the introduction of high-yielding varieties. However, these varieties have not met with great success in West Asia and North Africa because of their intolerance to an environment where moisture is limited and inputs are very low (Srivastava and Damania, 1989). To improve and stabilize cereal production in the drylands, characters such as earliness plus tolerance to drought, temperature extremes, low plant nutrients, and diseases need to be incorporated into varieties. The genes for these characters can probably be found in wild relatives and primitive forms that are well adapted to such environments through independent survival over a very long period of time. Wheat and barley plant breeders in developed countries consider landraces and primitive forms as unadapted germplasm and Hallauer and Miranda (1981) termed as exotics all germplasm that does not have immediate use without selection for adaptation to a given area. The exploitation of wild and primitive forms in wheat breeding has been insufficient for four reasons. First, collections of wild progenitors in the past have been fragmentary as well as scanty and material available in collections is not representative (Croston and Williams, 1981). Second, work on wild forms has primarily concentrated on evolutionary (Feldman and Sears, 1981) and taxonomic studies (Bowden, 1959; Chennaveeraiah, 1960; Morris and Sears, 1967; Kimber and Feldman 1987). Third, wild relatives are not well adapted to Europe and North America and hence are used mainly as single-gene donors. Finally, variability between and within populations of wild species has not been looked at in adequate detail and utilization has hardly commenced (Srivastava et al., 1988). The principal reason for utilizing wild species such as Aegilops, Agropyron, and Triticum dicoccoides Korn. in wheat breeding has been the transfer of genes for disease resistance, salinity tolerance, and highprotein content, respectively, when these desirable traits are not found in the available genetic stocks. However, confirmation of the sources of resistance and cataloging of genes for resistance should precede any attempt at transfer from the wild to the cultivated forms. This would involve collecting and evaluating in-depth relevant germplasm collections for genetic variability. In-depth evaluation would consist of replicated tests at different locations, resulting in genetic analyses and observations on traits such as disease resistance.
98
A. B. DAMANIA
It is also useful to gain knowledge of genetic relationships between the wild donor and cultivated recipient species because without ready crossability, desirable traits cannot be easily transferred. Thus, wild progenitors of the cultivated species should be considered an important source of variability for broadening the genetic bases of cultivated crops (Harlan, 1976; Hawkes, 1977; Lange and Balkema-Boomstra, 1988). Brown (1978) states that the genetic resources of wild relatives of crop plants should be systematically evaluated, for these sources of genes will supplement, and even rival, the primitive landraces in their effectiveness in crop improvement programs. There is an opinion among certain workers, especially those involved in breeding for favorable environments, that the variability in landraces of wheat and barley has been fully exploited and for further progress in introducing useful genes one should turn to wild relatives and other alien germplasm of the secondary and tertiary gene pools. Strampelli, working in Italy, was among the first plant breeders in Europe to utilize wild and primitive genetic resources, especially Triticum villosum Schur. and T . spelta L., to improve wheat in 1906 (Maliani and Bianchi, 1979). Elliot (1957) transferred stem rust resistance to common wheat from Agropyron elogatum and Riley et al. (1968) transferred yellow rust resistance from Aegilops comosa Sibth. to cultivated wheat by genetically induced homologous recombination. One of the most detailed evaluation studies of morphological, physiological, genetic, and cytological characteristics of Aegilops and Triticum species was carried out at the University of Kyoto (Kihara et al., 1965). A geographical survey of species of wheat and its wild relative Aegilops was conducted following the University of Kyoto expedition to Afghanistan, Iran, and Pakistan in 1955. Emphasis was placed on collecting Aegilops squarrosa L., the probable donor of the D genome to cultivated wheat; other species were also sampled whenever possible. There was evidence that bread wheat arose as a hybrid between cultivated emmer ( T . dicoccum Schub.) and A . squurrosu. This study was not only illustrated with photographs, but also contained valuable information on utilization of the germplasm. Cox et a/. (1989) evaluated 212 accessions of A. squarrosa from the University of Kyoto collection using polyacrylarnide gel electrophoresis and found gliadin diversity to be higher than in the D genome of cultivated bread wheat. Genetic variability in Aegilops species and primitive forms of wheat has been studied by several researchers (Hillel et al., 1973; Sharma et a/., 1981; Dhaliwal et al., 1986; Waines et al., 1987), whereas in the past more emphasis was placed on Triticum dicoccoides, the wild progenitor of wheat (Lawrence et al., 1958; Avivi, 1979) as reviewed by Poyarkova (1988). Also, Gerechter-Amitai and Stubbs (1970) found the source of resistance to yellow rust in T. dicoccoides from Palestine.
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
99
In another evaluation of primitive and wild types of wheat comprising 75 accessions of T . boeoticum Boiss., T . araraticum Jakubz., and T . dicoccoides; 42 of T . urartu Tuman.; and 34 of A . squarrosa seeking resistance to leaf rust, Hessian fly, and greenbug, Gill et al. (1989) found that all species except T . dicoccoides had resistance to both leaf rust and Hessian fly. Only A . squarrosa contained some resistance to greenbug, T . boeoticum had an intermediate response, but all other species were susceptible. Multiple resistance lines to leaf rust and Hessian fly were identified, but only A . squarrosa had two lines resistant to all three pests. Hillel et al. (1973) evaluated A . longissima Schweinf. and A . speltoides Tausch, two loosely related species that differ in their mating systems, to assess the direct effect of the mating system on the amount of genetic variability. They found that for most of the 36 quantitative characters examined, the differences between populations, the total variances of the populations, and the mean within-species variances were greater in the selfer (longissima) than the outbreeder (speltoides). These differences were attributed to the low probability of a successful gene flow in A . longissima, with each isolated population adapted to a specific microenvironment. Ninety-three accessions of cultivated emmer wheat ( T . dicoccum), five each of two wild tetraploid wheats ( T . dicoccoides)and T . araraticum, and the cultivated varieties ‘Modoc’ ( T . durum) and ‘Anza’ ( T . aestiuum) were evaluated for plant height, seed weight, flour protein content, and flour lysine content, as well as several morphological and grain quality characters by Sharma et al. (1981). Variability among lines for each trait in different species was significant except plant height in dicoccoides and araraticum. Primitive and wild wheats were higher in protein and lysine content, but lower in spike weight and 1000-kernel weight than the two modern cultivars. It seems that selection for larger kernels has resulted in a drop in the protein content of seeds from the wild species to the modern wheats. Lawrence et al. (1958) also found higher protein and lysine contents in wild wheats than in cultivated bread and durum wheats, but only one accession of T . dicoccoides and T . monococcum L. were analyzed. Avivi (1978) evaluated 47 samples of T . dicoccoides for protein content in kernels and found it to be highly variable, ranging from 19% to 28%. Waines (1983) did a comparative study of primitive diploid wheats such as T . monococcum with modern polyploid varieties and advocated the former’s direct usage as commercial varieties. Among the several positive characteristics of diploid wheats mentioned were less extraneous genetic material, only seven linkage groups and hence easier to manipulate than polyploid wheats, greater ecogeographic distribution and hence wider adaptability, and resistances to pests and diseases. However, Waines (1983) did not fully evaluate grain quality aspects such as pasta and dough
100
A. B. DAMANIA
products, which are vital to the success of any wheat variety, although one may tend to agree with him that exploratory research should be carried out to see if diploid wheats have a future as commercial varieties. Hordeum spontaneum C. Koch. is now recognized as the only progenitor of cultivated barley (Harlan, 1979). Wild barleys, H. spontaneum and H . murinum, and cultivated varieties from Afghanistan were collected by the Kyoto University Scientific Expedition. The morphological, physiological, and genetic characterization are described by Takahashi et al. (1965). Resistance to barley powdery mildew was also found in H. spontaneum, but the reaction was classified as being different from that of the cultivated forms. The overall diversity in this collection was reported to be low and the wild forms were less variable than the cultivated. Jana et al. (1987) studied genetic diversity in morphological characters in H. spontaneum and cultivated barleys from the Near East and also found that the latter were more variable than the former. However, it must be considered that this wild form in the near East has a long history of survival, has undergone millenia of natural selection pressures and therefore is better adapted to harsh environments (if not as variable as the cultivated landraces), and hence is a very valuable genetic resource for abiotic stress tolerance genes (Grando et al., 1985). An evaluation of H. spontaneum accessions was also carried out by Ceccarelli and Grando (1987) to assess the amount of useful genetic variability within this species. The results indicated that the progenitor is a useful source of genes for a number of economically important characters for breeding barley in the dry areas. Bakhteyev (1979) evaluated a collection of 77 samples of the same wild species originating from Iran, Iraq, and Turkey at an experimental farm in the Soviet Union. Considerable variability was observed in this study and the species merits breeders’ interest especially for adaptation to dry areas. Landraces of primitive wheats have been evaluated for several economically important traits. Blum et al. (1987) evaluated 13 accessions of T. compactum Host., a form of wheat cultivated in Syria and Palestine in the prepottery neolithic period (Renfrew, 1969), for grain quality. It was found, while comparing these with some modern cultivars of bread and durum wheat, that the latter were superior in all characters tested except protein content and quality. In a comparative study of wild and primitive forms of Triticum, Asins and Carbonell (1986) provided information for future use on intraspecific variability differences among species. Robertson et al. (1979) evaluated the genetic variability in primitive wheats for seedling root numbers, as it is well known that this character is probably responsible for drought resistance in wheats. Among the 16 species studied, the highest root numbers
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
101
were found in T. durum and the lowest in T . araraticum; seed weight was positively correlated with root number. A test of progenies showed that this character was stable from one generation to the next over two environments. O’Toole and Bland (1987) have reviewed genotypic variation in root systems of cultivated wheat and Aegilops. Electrophoretic techniques also have been applied to the study of variability of storage proteins in wild and primitive forms of wheat (Cole er al., 1981; Damania er al., 1988) and barley (Jana et al., 1987). Using this technique, Nevo et al. (1979) showed that there was greater variability in wild and weedy barleys ( H . sponraneum) collected from Palestine than in a composite cross of cultivated barley that included more than 6000 varieties in its parentage. This result was surprising since cultivated barley is conspicuously more variable than its wild and weedy relatives from the Near East (Harlan, 1984). However, Jana and Pietrzak (1988) reported almost identical levels of variability between the two in material collected from Greece, Jordan, Syria, and Turkey. Nevo et al. (1982, 1988) studied genetic diversity within and between Turkish populations of wild emmer, T . dicoccoides, utilizing electrophoretic and statistical analysis, and reported that climatic selection played an important role in genetic differentiation of populations of this species and that the wild gene pool represents a significant genetic resource for utilization in wheat improvement. In another study of the same material, Nevo and Payne (1987) reported variability in seed storage protein and the use of certain high-molecular-weight glutenins for improvement of bread-making qualities of wheat. Variability for kernel proteins in 841 accessions of T . dicoccoides has been reported also by Mansur-Vergara et al. (1986) using gel electrophoresis. The protein content measured ranged from 15% to 25% with some accessions having high protein content as well as large kernel size. A high percentage of protein content was also reported by Srivastava and Damania (1989) in dicoccoides accessions from Syria and by Avivi (1978) in those from Palestine. In a study of 167 accessions of T . dicoccum from 23 different countries of origin using sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE), Vallega and Waines (1987) identified a total of 20 alleles out of which 9 were different from those reported by earlier work. The newly discovered alleles enhance the genetic variability available to improve the industrial quality of wheats, and some of them may facilitate basic research on the relationship of industrial quality with highmolecular-weight glutenin subunit number. Success in future crop improvement depends largely on the ability to exploit existing genetic resources in wild relative and primitive forms,
102
A. B . DAMANIA
especially for less favorable environments. A better utilization and exploitation of these resources requires greater understanding of critical issues related to evolutionary pathways, geographical distribution, genetic diversity, and multicharacter associations. Variability studies, such as those described earlier, have provided this vital information. However, much more work needs to be done before evaluation can be instrumental in greater use of genes from wild relatives and primitive forms.
VI. DOCUMENTATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES An efficient system for dissemination of evaluation data on genetic resources material held in genebanks is essential if it is to be of use to breeders. Databases of genetic resources information on world collections have been established and contain a formidable amount of evaluation information that needs analysis and documentation (Ford-Lloyd, 1978). For example, 12,129 accessions of barley from a world collection were evaluated by ICARDA at one location (Somaroo et al. 1986, 1988); there was significant variability among the landraces for such characters as days to heading, plant height, 1000-grain weight, protein/lysine ratio, and resistance to diseases. In recent years much effort has been devoted to making these databases as comprehensive and mutually compatible as possible. However, less effort is being channeled toward considering how the results of these studies might be put to use. This is because most users are interested primarily in a very restricted aspect of the data (Williams et af., 1980). Plant breeders may be interested in an immediate problem such as resistance to a particular pathogen or a specific agronomic trait. Alternatively, their interest may reflect locally prevailing environmental conditions. For example, breeders at ICARDA are not interested in plants adapted for favorable conditions, as such environments are not common in West Asia and North Africa, where the Center operates (Damania and Srivastava, 1989). However, an international genetic resources center might be expected to take a wider view and Williams et al. (1980) contend that genetic resources evaluation data presently stored in computer memory banks contain more information of practical value than is immediately apparent without proper analysis. A detailed study of network analysis of genetic resources data has been attempted (Williams et af.,1980; Robinson et af., 1980; Burt et al., 1980). Internationally agreed descriptor states are not used when evaluation data are exchanged between genetic resources workers. Considerable time
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
103
and effort would be saved if a lengthy description of the method and intervals used for recording each character is avoided. The IBPGR has been convening small working groups of scientists for the purpose of arriving at an internationally agreed upon list of descriptors for describing information for wheat (IBPGR, 1985) and barley (IBPGR, 1982). However, experience has shown that it is too time-consuming to record observations on all descriptors mentioned in the descriptor lists, as the method of recording and the selection of characters are very much dictated by the region and the needs of local breeders at each institution concerned. It is also necessary to set out data in a standard format using a generally agreed upon series of descriptors and descriptor states for the crop. In this way the data can be entered into computers, retrieved, and exchanged among institutions with the least possible confusion and optimum efficiency (Hawkes 1985). For the purpose of utilization, systematic analysis and description of samples is useful in both distinguishing between populations and identifying duplicates, as well as in providing information on the extent of variation within a given germplasm collection. It is axiomatic that the more documentation on a collection, the greater the chance of its rational utilization. Information from the site where a particular sample was collected may be extremely important. For instance, at ICARDA, germplasm that is described as having a short maturity period receives immediate attention of the breeders as this trait is very useful to escape drought and high temperatures during grain filling in the dry areas. Therefore, information recorded by germplasm collectors at site would be very valuable later when the samples are evaluated. Peeters (1988) studied statistically a large barley germplasm collection at Cambridge and reported that despite extensive collecting activity in recent years and subsequent exchange between countries, combinations of characters have remained substantially different in germplasm by country gene pool. Material from the United States now contains more variability in toto than material from any other country. Subsequently, Peeters and Martinelli (1989) used hierarchical cluster analysis to classify entries from this collection according to their degree of similarity and concluded that this statistical analysis procedure could be used as a tool to classify entries to their respective gene pools even when no passport data are available. Often those responsible for entering data recorded at a collecting site into a computer data base believe that lengthy descriptive notes made at the collection site, for example, notes on disease observations or peculiarities of the habitat, are not relevant and hence should be omitted. Nothing could be more erroneous. Although it is recommended that passport data
104
A. B. DAMANlA
must not be encumbered with vast amounts of morphologicaldescriptions, it should certainly contain disease and habitat data and, more importantly, comments from the farmers as to the useful features that distinguish their material from the rest. Inadequate passport data very often inhibit effective utilization of collected germplasm. It has been repeatedly pointed out to collectors and genebank managers that passport data divulge extremely valuable and in many cases the only available information on the ecological adaptation of an accession and hence no effort should be spared to fill this important gap in documentation of germplasm (Frankel, 1987). Systematic description of samples for discrete traits has been limited to cataloging the phenotypic variation because of constraints in relating genotype with phenotype. Quantitative morphoagronomic traits are also currently used in characterization. These traits are controlled by several genes, each contributing a small effect that is quite often blurred by the environment. Consequently, the correlation between genotype and phenotype is obscured. Certain evaluation studies have used ranking as a method of describing results of economically important traits such as yield. This ranking may change from one site to another for some quantitative characters such as plant height and days to heading (Damania, 1983). Such unstable characters cannot be adequately described when studied at a single location. Thus, the concept of multilocation testing becomes imperative. We cannot commit ourselves to hard and fast rules regarding the selection of a representative sample, but it must be stressed that an evaluation that partially covers the total variability can only be of limited value at best. That is, if raw data are misinterpreted or incorrectly fed into the main data base, self-consistency is lost and the entire task becomes futile. Unfortunately, not all the samples assembled in our genebanks were collected with the aim of preserving genetic variability of populations in danger of extinction. On the contrary, several genetic resources collecting expeditions were targeted to filling certain gaps, such as finding resistant lines to specific stresses or studying relationships between wild and cultivated species. Therefore, genetic material from such expeditions represents only a fraction of the existing variability present in a particular area. This being so, it can provide useful genes for current breeding goals, but may be inadequate for tomorrow’s needs (Porceddu, 1976). The major collections of wheat and Barley now contain several thousand accessions. Such numbers may be too large for detailed evaluation. In response to this, there is a recent trend toward developing “core collections,” which are subsets upon which detailed evaluation work may
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
105
be concentrated (Brown, 1989). The remainder of the large collection constitutes a reserve still maintained in storage and available when a desired trait cannot be found in the core (Chapman, 1989). The ability of genetic resources managers to respond to requests from breeders for material depends very much on the adequate description of the accessions and the ability to query the information in a computerized data base. Hitherto, insufficient emphasis has been placed on recording passport data, and their absence is a major constraint to curators in assessing the range of variability in their collections and in identifying gaps (Williams, 1989).
VII. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS Genetically uniform cultivars are employed by cereal farmers in the major cereal-producing countries of the world. Because plant breeding is essentially a process for exploitation of genetic variability, breeders could also examine means of conserving already existing genetically variable germplasm as well as creating new varieties. Mak and Harvey (1982) have described the composite cross technique that creates, as well as exploits, genetic variability, using the USDA barley world collection as a model. This may be one of the ways to proceed for other cereal crops. When precise objectives of evaluation are known at the outset, the task becomes relatively simple. In the case of most wild and primitive forms, evaluation aims to reveal potentially useful variability for direct use in the breeding programs. This may necessitate initial characterization in nurseries and cataloging of passport information, followed by a more detailed field study in collaboration with the end-users of the germplasm. Inferences regarding geographical variability, even on the basis of evaluation of a world collection, cannot be considered truly representative as they represent findings based on the composition of a collection that may be comprehensive for some regions and deficient for others. Furthermore, variability studies based on collections made several years ago may not accurately reflect the variability to be found at present in the same area. It is presumed that, after observation of dramatic degradation of the environment and genetic erosion, there would be considerable decline in variability if not extinction of indigenous germplasm in several previously generich regions in the world (Hawkes, 1981). The utilization of germplasm collections in crop improvement for the major cereals has revealed the following:
106
A. B. DAMANIA
1. The use of exotic germplasm. The successful use of landraces and wild species in cereal improvement has been more extensive in the developed countries, which lack indigenous germplasm, than in the less developed countries. In recent years the International Agriculture Research Centers (IARC) have contributed substantially to generation and distribution of improved adapted germplasm with genes from landraces and wild forms to the national programs and other institutions, as the germplasm developed for more favorable environments has not succeeded in the dry areas. 2. Constraints to the use of exotic germplasm. Many plant breeders were reluctant to devote a greater part of their resources for the exploitation of landraces and wild species in the past. This was because the potential value of these germplasms for the stressed environments was not fully appreciated. However, in recent years, varieties targeted for lowinput, rain-fed agricultural systems possess genes from adapted landraces and even direct usage of selections of the best lines isolated from landraces have been recommended for release. 3. Support for plant genetic resources programs. Extensive use of landraces, primitive forms, and wild species will be more tenable for harsh environments when the process of conservation, evaluation, documentation, and exchange of germplasm is strengthened and adequately funded. Donor countries and international agencies could increase support for utilization of indigenous landraces and primitive forms in the recently established breeding programs of the developing world. 4. Use of computers and statistical program packages. Computer programs designed for analyzing a large quantity of evaluation data have greatly reduced the time and effort needed for arriving at tangible results. This in turn has led to the publication ofgermplasm catalogs, which have facilitated dissemination of information on genetic resources collections to actual users, allowing for greater utilization of the services rendered by genebanks. However, breeders prefer to receive a short list of accessions with specific traits to choose from rather than large genetic resources catalogs.
Electrophoretic techniques that permit rapid mass screening of samples are increasingly recognized as powerful research tools for the study of genetic variations in populations. A wider application of gel electrophoresis in the evaluation of plant genetic resources is expected. The use of restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLP) for evaluating genetic diversity has been described (Bernatsky and Tanksley, 1989), and is the best available means for detecting differences at the DNA level on samples of reasonable size. It would be useful if such techniques were utilized to a greater extent than at present on genetic resources collections.
EVALUATION OF GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
107
The breeding objectives of the developed countries, mostly located in favorable environments, are different from those of the West Asia and North Africa region. The advanced breeding programs in the former countries began utilizing exotic landraces about 100 years ago and have fully exploited them, so they no longer seek variability but only single genes from the wild relatives and grasses of the tertiary gene pool. The breeding objectives for West Asia and North Africa, on the other hand, are to develop varieties adapted to withstand harsh environments and low inputs. Hence, selections from landraces and crosses with wild and pnmitive forms are undertaken to produce well-adapted germplasm for targeted agroecological zones. In recent years, world collections of cereals have been evaluated by many scientists working in different countries who were searching for economically useful genes or gene combinations. Confidence has been expressed that such materials are a usable source of breeding stocks, although they still require thorough assessment. Large-scale evaluation, if carried out thoroughly, is an expensive, arduous, and time-consuming process. Therefore, it is imperative to carefully select the traits that one wishes to evaluate in consultation with the breeders. Further, not all material in a collection may be of immediate interest. Priorities need to be discussed and selection of the traits made on the basis of their importance to the actual user. Such a procedure will assure optimal utilization of physical facilities, manpower, and financial resources. Finally, breeding objectives change, sometimes rapidly, and hence evaluation needs to be adaptive to a certain extent to succeed. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author thanks Drs. W. Erskine, S. Ceccarelli, and J . Valkoun for their comments and suggestions on a draft of this review and the Government of ltaly for financial support.
REFERENCES Alkamper, von J. 1974. Z. Acker. Pfianzenbau 140, 184-198. Allard, R. W. 1970. I n “Genetic Resources in Plants-Their Exploration and Conservation” (0.H. Frankel and E. Bennett, eds.), pp. 97-108. IBP/Blackwell, London. Allard, R. W., Kahler, A. L., and Weir, B. S. 1970. In “Proceedings of Second International Barley Genetic Symposium” (R. A. Nilan, ed.), pp. 1-13. Washington State Univ. Press, Pullman. Asins, M. J., and Carbonell, E. A. 1986. Theor. Appl. Gener. 72,551-558. Avivi, L. 1978. In “Proceedings of Fifth International Wheat Genetics Symposium” (S. Ramunajam, ed.), pp. 372-380. ICAR, New Delhi. Avivi, L. 1979. Genet. Agric. 4, 27-38. Bakhteyev, F. Kh. 1979. Z . Pjianzenzuechr. 83,211-221.
108
A. B. DAMANIA
Bekele, E. 1984. Hereditas 100, 131-154. Bernatsky, R., and Tanksley, S. D. 1989. In “The Use of Plant Genetic Resources” (A. H. D. Brown, 0. H. Frankel, D. R. Marshall, and J. T. Williams, eds.), pp. 353-362. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Blum, A., Sinmena, B., Golan, G., and Mayer, J . 1987. Plant Breed. 99,226-233. Bowden, W. M. 1959. Can. J . Bot. 37,657-684. Brown, A. H. D. 1978. Theor. Appl. Genet. 52, 145-157. Brown, A. H. D. 1989. In “The Use of Plant Genetic Resources” (A. H. D. Brown, 0. H. Frankel, D. R. Marshall, and J. T. Williams, eds.), pp. 136-156. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Brown, A. H. D., Frankel, 0. H., Marshall, D. R., and Williams, J. T. (eds.). 1989. “The Use of Plant Genetic Resources”. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Burt, R. L., Pengelly, B. C., and Williams, W. T. 1980. Agro-Ecosystems 6, 119-127. Ceccarelli, S., and Grando, S. 1987. Genet. Agric. 41, 131-142. Ceccarelli, S., Grando, S., and van Leur, J. G. 1987. Euphytica 36,389-405. Chang, T. T. 1985. Iowa State J . Res. 59,379-397. Chapman, C. 1989. In “IBPGRTraining Courses: Lecture Series 2. Scientific Management of Germplasm: Characterization, Evaluation and Enhancement” (H. T. Stalker and C. Chapman, eds.), pp. 55-63. IBPGR, Rome. Chennaveeraiah, M. S. 1960. Acta Horti. Gotob. 23, 85-178. Cole, E. W., Fullington, J . G., and Kasarda, D. D. 1981. Theor. Appl. Genet. 60, 17-30. Cox, T. S., Harrel, L. G., Lubbers, E. L., and Amri, A. 1989. Annu. Wheat Newsln. 35, 140- 142. Croston, R. P., and Williams, J. T. 1981. “A World Survey of Wheat Genetic Resources.” IBPGR, Rome. Damania, A. B. 1983. Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. of Birmingham, Birmingham, U.K. Damania, A. B. 1985. Indian J . Genet. 45, 213-220. Damania, A. B., and Porceddu, E . 1981. Plant Genet. Resour. Newsl. 48,2-3. Damania, A. B., and Somaroo, B. H. 1988. Rachis, 7,54-56. Damania, A. B., and Srivastava, J. P. 1989. I n “Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Genetic Aspects of Plant Mineral Nutrition” (N. El-Bassam and B. C. Loughman, eds.), pp. 425-430. Kluwer, Dordrecht. Damania, A. B., Porceddu, E., and Jackson, M. T. 1983. Euphyrica 32,877-883. Damania, A. B., Jackson, M. T., and Porceddu, E. 1985.2. Pj7anzenzuecht. 94, 13-24. Damania, A. B., Tahir, M., and Somaroo, B. H. 1988. In “Proceedings of the Seventh International Wheat Genetics Symposium” (T. E. Miller and R. M. D. Koebner, eds.), pp. 937-941. IPSR, Cambridge. De Pace, C., Porceddu, E., and Blanco, A. 1978. In “Proceedings of the Fifth International Wheat Genetics Symposium” (S. Ramunajam, ed.), pp. 680-694. ICAR, New Delhi. Dhaliwal, H. S., Gill, K. S., Singh, P. J., Multani, D. S . , and Singh, B. 1986. Crop Improu. 16, 145-449. Dominici, L., Grottanelli, A , , Tomassini, C., Lafiandra, D., Porceddu, E., and Damania, A. B. 1988. Rachis 7,34-36. Ehdaie, B., and Waines, J. G. 1989. Euphyrica 41, 183-190. Elliot F. C., 1957. J. Hered. 48,77-81. Erskine, W., and Williams, J. T. 1980. Plant Genet. Resour. Newsl. 41, 19-33. Feldman, M., and Sears, E. R. 1981. Sci. Am. 244,98-109. Ford-Lloyd, B. V. 1978. In “Conservation of Plant Genetic Resources” ( J . G. Hughes, ed.), pp. 42-45. Univ. of Aston, Birmingham, U.K. Frankel, 0. H. 1987. IBPGR Southeast Asia Newsl. 11, 13.
EVALUATION O F GENETIC RESOURCES IN CEREALS
109
Frankel, 0. H., and Bennett, E. (eds.), 1970. “Genetic Resources in Plants-Their Exploration and Conservation.” IBPIBIackwell, London. Frankel, 0. H., and Hawkes, J. G. (eds.), 1975a. “Crop Genetic Resources for Today and Tomorrow.” Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Frankel, 0. H., and Hawkes, J. G. 1975b. I n “Crop Genetic Resource for Today and Tomorrow” (0.H . Frankel and J. G. Hawkes, eds.), pp. 1-1 I. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Freeman, G. H., and Dowker, B. D. 1973. Heredity 30,97-109. Frost, S . , Holm, G., and Asker, S. 1975. Heriditas 79, 133-142. Gabriel, K. R., and Sokal, R. R. 1969. Sysr. Zool. 18,259-278. Gerechter-Amitai, Z. K., and Stubbs, R. W. 1970. Euphyrica 19, 12-21. Gill, B. S., Raupp, W. J., Wilson, D. L.,