ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 14
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared under the Auspice...
29 downloads
3529 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 14
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared under the Auspices of the AMERICANSocm-ry OF AGRONOMY
VOLUME 14 Edited by A.
G. NORMAN
The Uniuetsity of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
ADVISORY BOARD E. G. HEYNE F. L. PATTERSON R. W. PEARSON
W. H. h L A W A Y W. H. F ~ T E C. 0. G m m
1962
ACADEMIC PRESS
New York and London
COPYRIGHT @ 1962, BY ACADEMICPRESSINC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
NO PART O F THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 FIFTHAVENUE NEW YORK 3, N. Y.
United Kingdom Edition Published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. BERKELEYSQUAREHOUSE,LONDON W. 1
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 50-5598
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 14 C. ROY ADAIR,Research Agronomist, Crops Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Beltsville, Maryland
L. T. ALEXANDER,Chief, Soil Survey Laboratoy, Soil Conservation Semice, United States Department of Agriculture, Plant Industy Station, Beltsville, M aylund H. M. BEACHELL, Research Agronomist, Crops Research Di&on, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Beaumont, Texas R. L. BERNARD, Research Geneticist, United States Regional Soybean Laboratory, Crops Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Urbana, Illinois D. R. BOULDIN,Soil Chemist, Tennessee Valley Authority, Muscle Shoals, Alabama
J. G. CADY,Soil Scientist, Soil Survey Laboratory, Soil Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Plant Industry Station, Beltsville, Maryland J. L. CARTTER,Agronomist-in-charge, United States Regional Soybean Laboratory, Crops Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Urbana, Illinois
MARLIN G. CLINE,Professor of Soil Science, Department of Agronomy, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York
E. E. HARTWIG, Research Agronomist, United States Regional Soybean Laboratoy, Crops Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Stoneville, Mississippi HERBERT W. JOHNSON, Research Agronomist, Crops Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Beltsville, Maryland DONKIRKHAM, Curtiss Distinguished Professor of Agriculture and Professor of Soils and Physics, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa
RAYMONDJ. KUNZE, Assistant Professor of Soils, Department of Agronm y , Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa V
vi
CONTRIBmoRs
M . D. MILLER,Extension Agronomist, Agronomy Department, University of California, Davis, CaZifornia S. SNARAJASINGHAM, Assistant Chemist, Soil Surceys, Department of Agriculture, Peradeniya, Ceybn
DWIGHTD. SMJTH,Assistant Director for Water Management, Soil and Water Conservation Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Beltsoilk, Maryland
GILBERT L. TERMAN, Agronomist, Tennessee Valley Authority, Muscle Shoals, Alabama
FRANKG. VETS, JR., Chief Soil Scientist, Northern Plains Branch, Soil and Water Conservation Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Fort Collins, Colorado J. R. WEBB, Associate Professor of Soils, Department of Agronomy, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa
WALTER H . WISCHMEIER, Research Investigations Leader for Water Erosion, Corn Belt Branch, Soil and Water Conservation Research Division, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Purdue University, Lafayette, lndiana
PREFACE The eight chapters in this volume fall into the general pattern established for this series, which is to include reviews of research progress in soil and crop science and developments in agronomic practice. The central theme is the soil-plant relationship. Some European reviewers of this series have expressed the view that the range of subjects covered is far too wide to justify the implied suggestion that they are all branches of one science and that the literature reviewed is predominantly American. Essentially this criticism hinges on the definition of the word “agronomy” which in European usage and particularly British usage does not have the same connotation as in the U.S. Indeed one British reviewer states that “In England, little would be left for agronomy when the claims of chemistry, entomology, plant pathology and so on had been stated-perhaps the study of green manuring, seed rates and sowing dates.” As understood in the United States there is, however, a professional field of agronomy in which the above and many other disciplines have a part. There is a professional organization of agronomists with upwards of 4,000 members trained in a variety of disciplines which they bring to bear on a great diversity of problems relating to the soil, and its efficient use in the production of economic crops. Much of the science involved is international; but there are aspects that are regional and must be so. For example, in this issue there are two extensive reviews dealing respectively with the genetics of soybeans and the management of the soybean crop. Some sixty percent of the world soybean production is located in the United States. An even higher percentage of the total scientific work on this fascinating crop plant is carried on in the United States, and it is inevitable, therefore, that the literature should be predominantly American. Much the same applies to the article on rice production in the United States, where man hour per acre have been reduced to an astonishingly low figure. In contrast, attention should be drawn to the authoritative review on the subject of laterite by Sivarajasingham, Alexander, Cady and Cline, which reflects the world-wide distribution of the investigators of laterites rather than the distribution of lateritic soils. Greater fertilizer usage accounts in part for the steady yield increases recorded in most countries in recent years. In the development of fertilizers considerable attention is being directed towards new and unconventional materials, the evaluation of which presents challenging problems. Some of these are discussed by Terman, Bouldin and Webb. vii
viii
PmFACE
Viets, on the other hand, considers the involved relationships between fertilizer usage and the water requirement of crops, a very important issue in many areas of the world where rainfall is erratic and water reserves inadequate. The remaining articles deal directly with soil properties. Kirkham and Kunze discuss some of the applications of the use of isotopes and radiation to problems in soil physics, and Smith and Wischmeier the physical principles of soil erosion by rain. A. G . NORMAN Ann Arbor, Michigan July, 1962
CONTENTS
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME14 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Puge v
PREFACE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
LATERITE BY S. SIVARAJASJNGHAM. L. T. ALEXANDER.J . G . CADY.AND M. G. CLINE I. I1. I11. IV. V VI. VII .
.
The Term “Laterite” ........................................ The Nature of Laterite .................................... The Environment of Laterite ................................ Profiles Containing Laterite ................................. Formation of Laterite ...................................... Geomorphic Relationships .................................. Softening of Laterite ....................................... References ...............................................
1 5
14 20 26 53 55 56
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN THE UNITED STATES
.
BY c. ROY ADAIR. M. D. MILLER.AND H . M BEACHELL
I. I1. I11. IV. V.
Introduction .............................................. Rice Culture in the United States ............................ Rice Field Pests ........................................... Origin, Botany. and Genetics of Rice ......................... Rice Breeding and Improvement in the United States . . . . . . . . . . . References ................................................
61 68 85
92 96 104
RAINFALL EROSION BY DWIGHTD . SMITHAND WALTERH . WBCHMEIER I. I1. I11 IV .
.
Introduction .............................................. Mechanics of Rainfall Erosion ............................... Basic Factors Affecting Field Soil Loss ........................ Soil Loss Prediction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix
109 113 123 137 144
CONTENTS
X
SOYBEAN GENETICS A N D BREEDING BY HERBERTW . I. I1 . 111. IV . V.
JOHNSON AND
RICHARDL . BERNARP
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reproduction ............................................. Genetics of Qualitative Characters ........................... Genetics of Quantitative Characters .......................... Breeding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
149 152 157 172 199 218
FERTILIZERS AND THE EFFICIENT USE O F WATER
BY FRANK G . VIETS. JR. I. I1. I11. IV .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. Definition of the Problem ............................. ........... Validity of Evapotranspiration Data . . . . . . . . . . . The Effects of Fertilizers on the Relationship of Evapotranspiration and Yield ......................... ..................... V . Fertilizers and Water-Use Efficiency in Terms of Applied Water . . VI . Fertilization and Water-Use Efficiency with Limited Moisture Supply ................................................. .... VII . Fertilization and Moisture Extraction by Roots . . . . . . . . VIII . Fertilizers and the Infiltration of Water ...................... IX . Fertilization. Crop Maturity. and Water Use . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . x . Other Practices for Increasing Water-Use Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . XI . Is Maximum Water-Use Efficiency Desirable? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... XI1. Conclusions .......................... References . . . . . . . . . . ........................
223 226 228 233 246 246 252 254 256 257 259 260 261
EVALUATION OF FERTILIZERS BY BIOLOGICAL METHODS
BY G. L TERMAN.D. R . BOULDIN.AND J . R . WEBB I . Introduction ......................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Chemical and Physical Characteristics of Fertilizers . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Concepts of Fertilizer Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Methods Used in Fertilizer Evaluation Tests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
References
...............................................
265 266 280 295 316 317
xi
CONTENTS
ISOTOPES METHODS A N D USES I N SOIL PHYSICS RESEARCH BY DONKIRKHAMAND RAYMONDJ . KUNZE
I. I1. I11. IV. V. VI . VII . VIII . IX . X.
Introduction .............................................. Soil Water ............................................... Soil Density and Soil Structure .............................. Soil Aeration ............................................. Soil Temperature ........................................... Soil Particle Movement .................................... Transformation of Soil Materials from One Form to Another ..... Soil Profile Formation and Dating ............................ Disposal of Radioactive Waste .............................. Proposed Future Work ..................................... References ................................................
321 322 342 347 348 348 350 352 353 354 355
THE MANAGEMENT OF SOYBEANS BY JACKSON L . CARTTER AND EDCARE . HARTWIG
.
1 Introduction .............................................. I1. Soil and Climatic Adaptation ............. I11. Time of Planting and Varietal Adaptation .................... IV Planting Methods and Equipment ............................ V Rotation Practices and Erosion Control ........................ ....... VI . Weed Control .................... ....... VII. Seed Quality and Seed Treatment ... VIII Nutrient Requirements ..................................... IX Water Requirements and Utilization .......................... X. Growth-Regulating Chemicals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI . Harvesting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI1 Seed Storage ............................................. XI11 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. .
...................
360 365 372 378 383 386 389 390 401 403 404 406 407 . . . 408
AUTHOR INDEX. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
413
SUBJECT INDEX ......................................................
427
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
LATERITE S. Sivarajasingham, L. T. Alexander, J. G. Cady, and M. G. Cline Department of Agriculture, Peradeniya, Ceylon, United States Department of Agriculture, Belhville, Maryland, and Carnell University, Ithaca, New York
Page I. The Term “Laterite” . . ...................... 11. The Nature of Laterite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Physical Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Chemical Characteristics ................................ C . Mineralogical Characteristics . 111. The Environment of Laterite . . . . . A. Climate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... ......... ......................................... C. Parent Material . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Topography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Age . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ IV. Profiles Containing Laterite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Soil Material Overlying Laterite .......................... B. Laterite within Soil Horizons .............................. C. Horizons or Layers Beneath Laterite ...................... V. Formation of Laterite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Weathering as a Preconditioner of Material of Laterite . . . . . . . . B. Development of Microstructures .......................... C. Hardening of Laterite .................................... D. Development of Laterite in Place without Enrichment from Outside Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Enrichment from Outside Sources ........................ F. Principal Processes Involved . .................. VI. Geomorphic Relationships . . . . . . . ...................... VII. Softening of Laterite . ............................ References . . . . . . . . . . ..................
1
5 5 7 14 15 16 20 20 21 22 24 26 28 38 39
45 45 53
55
1. The Term ”Laterite”
The term ‘laterite” was originally coined by Buchanan (1807) for a ferruginous, vesicular, and apparently unsbatified material occurring in immense masses over the country rock of Malabar in India. The freshly 1 This review constitutes Agronomy paper No. 542, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.
1
2
S . SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
dug material, as described by Buchanan, was soft enough to be readily cut into blocks by an iron instrument, but upon exposure to air it quickly became as hard as brick and remarkably resistant to the action of air and water. Since this material was used as building brick, and was called “brickstone” in several of the indigenous languages, Buchanan aptly called it ‘laterite” after later-the Latin for brick. Prescott (1954, pp. 1-2) has reported that Buchanan did not use the term “laterite” in his journals between 1807 and 1814 but used the term “brickstone” and that Babington (1821) was the first to use ‘laterite” in formal scientific literature. According to Prescott and Pendleton (1952, p. I ) , Buchanan used the word “brickstone” only in his later travels (1807-1813) through what is now Bihar to describe occurrences in the Rajmahal hills: “He noted the similarity of the Bihar occurrences to those of Malabar, but was puzzled by the fact that the former masses of material while still in the ground and excluded from the air retained their stony form.” At first in Malabar, he had used the terms ‘laterite” and “brickstone” interchangeably in his descriptions of the soft materials that harden; his later use of the term ‘8rickstone” in Malabar may have been out of a desire to reserve the term “laterite” for the soft ferruginous material that hardens. Though some of Buchanan’s immediate successors ( Voysey, 1833; Stirling, 1825) used “iron clay” as an alternative term, the word ‘laterite” gradually came into wide use in India. Detailed morphological descriptions of laterite, still considered to be among the most vivid, were given by Newbold (1844, 1846). Interest in laterite was stimulated in other parts of the world by the publication of a chapter by Blanford (1879) in the first Manual of the Geology of India, with which the name laterite became finally confirmed (Fox, 1936). Before the end of the nineteenth century, laterite as a surficial or shallow formation was identified on the basis of physical characteristics in many widely distributed areas of Australia, Africa, and South America. Fermor (1911) considered use of the term only for soft materials that could be cut into bricks, a severe restriction, though such use appears to conform with the intentions of Buchanan. Blanford (1859) had mentioned that in some cases the lithomarge underlying laterite becomes hard on exposure, and Harrison (1910) also recorded the occurrence of mottled, creamy white and dark red sesquioxide-poor deposits that harden on exposure. Thus, the property of hardening as a criterion of laterite became controversial. Later this aspect was further confused when Talbott in Australia (Prescott, 1931) extended the term
LATERITE
3
to include not only hard ferruginous surface formations, but also siliceous and travertine crusts, designating them ferruginous, siliceous, and calcareous laterite, respectively. Prescott, however, confined “laterite” to the ferruginous and aluminous forms and cited the earlier suggestion of Woolnough (1927), who introduced the term “duricrust” to cover the other kinds of crusts. Though many earlier observers had suggested the ferruginous and even the aluminous nature of laterite (Mallet, 1883), the fundamental chemical character of laterite was first established by Bauer (1898). His analyses revealed the low content of silica and the high contents of alumina and iron oxide in samples collected from the Seychelles. Subsequent investigations of samples from many different parts of the tropical region gave similar results (du Bois, 1903; Warth and Warth, 1903; Holland, 1903). Great interest developed because of the possible use of laterite as an ore for aluminum (Holland, 1905) and, in some cases, for manganese (Fermor, 1909). Consequently, much of the early work was confined to chemical analysis of bulk samples that were selected for high aluminum content. This prompted a reviewer (Bull. Imp. Inst. 1909, vii, p. 133) of Harrison’s work to suggest that the term laterite be restricted to products of weathering containing free alumina. As a result, controversy developed among geologists regarding the chemical properties of laterite. Fermor (1911) finally abandoned the physical property of hardness of a material in its natural state or on exposure as a criterion of laterite and developed a comprehensive system of nomenclature of lateritic materials on the basis of chemical composition, though he rejected the presence or absence of alumina in large quantity suggested by Crook (1909). He subscribed to the views of Evans (1910) that “though the chemical composition of laterite varies within wide limits, . . . one feature remains constant-the small amount of combined silica in proportion to the alumina present. . . . It is in this respect that laterites differ from clays, which also occur as tropical decomposition products.” Fermor, consequently, based his classification on arbitrary limits of the ‘lateritic” constituents, which he defined as the oxides of iron, aluminum, titanium, and manganese. Meanwhile Walther ( 1889,1915,1916) had erroneously assumed that the term “laterite” had been chosen to signify red color and “proposed that the word should be used for all red-colored alluvia” (Prescott and Pendleton, 1952, pp. 35-36). Ultimately, any tropical red earth came to be called ‘laterite” or “lateritic.” As studies of tropical soil progressed, attempts were made to standardize the use of these two terms on the
4
S. SIVhRAJASINGHAM ET AL.
basis of chemical composition. The silica-alumina ratio and, later, the silica-sesquioxide ratio were used to classify soils into “laterite,” “lateritic,” and “nonlateritic” (Martin and Doyne, 1921, 1930; Joachim and Kandiah, 1935). The terms received even wider connotation with the adoption of “laterite” and “lateritic” as the names of Great Soil Groups by the Lhited States Soil Survey Staff (Byers et al., 1938; Baldwin et al., 1938). Pendleton (1936) strongly urged that the term “laterite” be restricted to the original concepts of Buchanan, restated nearly 100 years later by Oldham ( 1893). As a consequence of this rigorous definition of “laterite,” Pendleton and Sharasuvana (1946, p. 434) defined a “laterite” soil as “one in which a laterite horizon is found in the profile.” They considered a “lateritic” soil to be “one in which there is an incipient or immaturely developed laterite horizon, and in which it is believed a true laterite horizon will develop if the prevailing conditions persist long enough.” The definitions put fonvad by du Preez (1949) for ‘laterite soil” and “lateritic soil” are essentially similar to those of Pendleton and Sharasuvana. His definition of laterite, like that of Pendleton and Sharasuvana, fails to recognize the importance of alumina, and while he covered some morphologicaI aspects of laterite comprehensively, he ignored the soft variety that hardens on exposure. Mohr and van Baren (1954) defended use of the terms ‘laterite” and “lateritic” for soil on grounds of similarity of weathering products that produce soil as well as material that hardens. Kellogg (1949, p. 79) confined the term ‘laterite” to four principal forms of sesquioxide-rich material that either are hard or that harden upon exposure: ( 1 ) soft mottled clays that change irreversibly to hardpans or crusts when exposed, ( 2 ) cellular and mottled hardpans and crusts, ( 3 ) concretions or nodules in a matrix of unconsolidated material, ( 4 ) consolidated masses of such concretions or nodules. The Soil Survey Staff of the United States Department of Agriculture (1960, p. 62) proposed a new term, plinthite (Gk. plinthos, brick), for essentially the same concept, defining it as “the sesquioxide rich, humus poor, highly weathered mixture of clay with quartz and other diluents, which commonly occurs as red mottles, usually in platy, polygonal, or reticulate patterns; plinthite changes irreversibly to hardpans or irregular ( hard) aggregates on repeated wetting and drying, or it is the hardened relicts of the soft red mottles.” The term “plinthite” was introduced to avoid the confusion arising from use of the word “laterite” without precise definition for many widely divergent materials. In this paper, the term laterite is retained as a term that would be recognized by most readers, though its use is restricted to material that conforms generally with the definitions of laterite by Kellogg (1919) and of plinthite by the Soil Survey Staff (1960).
LATERITE
5
II. The Nature of Laterite
The term laterite is restricted in the remainder of this paper to highly weathered material ( 1 ) rich in secondary forms of iron, aluminum, or both; ( 2 ) poor in humus; ( 3 ) depleted of bases and combined silica; ( 4 ) with or without nondiagnostic substances such as quartz, limited amounts of weatherable primary minerals, or silicate clays; and ( 5 ) either hard or subject to hardening upon exposure to alternate wetting and drying. The term as used implies no restrictions, other than those inherent in the properties defined, on size or shape of the masses, on their internal organization, on the processes by which diagnostic properties have developed, or specific conditions of place or time as factors essential to such development. In this sense it includes Buchanan’s laterite and hardened equivalents of it. In addition, it includes certain highly weathered material in sesquioxide-rich humus-poor nodules2 that are hard or that harden upon exposure, though they may be surrounded by earthy material that does not harden, as well as masses of such nodules cemented together by sesquioxide-rich material. It excludes ( a ) sesquioxide-rich earthy material, which has been called “laterite” or “lateritic soil,” that does not harden upon exposure; ( b ) ironrich masses or nodules with significant amounts of humus, which are characteristic of certain podzols; ( c ) hard masses cemented by silica, carbonates, or substances other than sesquioxides, though highly weathered sesquioxide-rich fragments or nodules within such masses might be included; and ( d ) certain hard pellets or “shot” found in slightly weathered material. A. PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS Laterite occurs in various morphological forms. Pendleton and Sharasuvana (1946, p. 438) recognized two distinct physical forms, vesicular and pisolitic, with many types intermediate between the two. Du Preez (1949, p. 57) has defined laterite as “a vesicular, concretionary, cellular, vermicular, slaglike, pisolitic or concrete-like mass.” The description of a vesicular laterite by Newbold (1844) is quoted in part here after Prescott and Pendleton (1952, p. 5). “The laterite . . . , generally speaking, is a purplish or brick red, porous rock, passing into liver brown perforated by numerous sinuous 2 The term “nodule” is used not only in the sense defined by Bryan (1952) to include “rounded lumps” of a variety of compositions whether formed by accretion or by centripetal enrichment, but also to include rounded fragments of laterite inherited from a laterite crust.
6
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
and tortuous tubular cavities either empty, filled, or partially filled with a greyish-white clay passing into an ochreous, reddish and yellowish brown dust; or with a lilac-tinted litheomargic earth. The sides of the cavities are usually ferruginous and often of a deep brown or chocolate color; though generally not more than a line or two in thickness, their laminar structure may frequently be distinguished by the naked eye. . . . The interior of the cavities has usually a smooth polished superficie, but sometimes mammillary, and stalactiform on a minute scale . . . . The surface masses of the softer kinds present a variegated appearance. The clay and lithomarge exhibit lively colored patches of yellow, lilac, and white, intersected by a network of red, purple, or brown. The softness of this rock is such that it may be cut with a spade; hardening by exposure to the sun and air, like the laterite of Malabar.” (Omissions are by the present authors.) Vesicular laterite may be soft or of varying hardness and commonly has earthy material in the cavities. It usually occurs near the surface. Cellular slag-like laterite is a scoriaceous mass. The many empty cavities are separated by ferruginow material similar in appearance to that which separates the earthy substance in vesicular laterite. Cellular laterite is usually dark colored and may have a dull or lustrous surface. It is of varying hardness and is brittle, being usually easily shattered when struck a sharp blow with a hammer. According to Fox (1936), cellular laterite is formed by removal of kaolin and other earthy material from the cavities in vesicular laterite when the latter is exposed to erosion and leaching at the surface. Falconer (1911), from his observations in nothern Nigeria gave a similar explanation, though he avoided using the term laterite for “surface ironstone.” Nodular laterite consists of individual concretions, pisolites or other crudely round masses, usually the size of a pea but commonly larger or smaller; it is generally ferruginous. The nodules may occur as a superficial covering or as a component in one or more horizons in the soil, varying in concentration from low or insignificant amounts to very high amounts. The nodules vary in hardness; some can be readily cut by a knife but most are hard and brittle. When the nodules of a layer are cemented together, hard “pisolitic” or “concrete-like” laterite is formed. It occurs mainly at or near the surface. The individual nodules may either be joined directly to one another or be discrete entities in a cementing matrix of similar, but usually less ferruginous, material. Recent studies by Alexander and Cady ( 1962) present enlightening detail on the physical arrangement of discrete components. Though various specimens exhibit a great variety of micromorphological features,
7
LATERITE
certain structures are common to many, but not necessarily all, varieties. Commonly under magnification in thin sections, tiny bodies ranging from perfect spheres to oblong rounded forms may be seen embedded in a matrix of fine particles; the matrix may be either very dense or spongelike. The rounded bodies may be individual units or, commonly, may be aggregates of smaller spherical units closely packed. Such rounded bodies may be widely spaced or closely packed in the matrix. Their boundaries may be smooth and definite or irregular and indefinite in various specimens. The matrix may be unorganized, may have a gridlike rectangular or reticulate network of oriented material, or may be largely oriented. Oriented material commonly lines pores and may appear as skins on the nodules. Crystalline oriented material is common as pseudomorphs after primary minerals, as porefillings, and as discrete bodies ranging from barely visible units to relatively large homogeneous masses. Rock structure may be preserved or may be entirely absent. Quartz particles may be included, and in some specimens weatherable minerals encased in a protective covering of weathered material have been observed.
B. CHENICAL CHARACTERISTICS Materials identified in the field as laterite have a wide range of chemical characteristics. A prominent feature common to all laterites, nevertheless, is a high content of either iron or aluminum or both relative to other constituents (Alexander et al., 1956). This is clearly illustrated by the following analyses, which are thought to be typical examples (Table I ) . Bases are almost completely absent. Combined silica is generally TABLE I Chemical Composition ( % ) of Selected Laterites Constituent Quartz Feldspar SiO, A1203 Fe7.03 TiO, CaO H,O (loss on ignition)
Site:a
1
2
3
4
5
0.76 NDb 1.77 4.32 80.02 6.06
ND ND 1.93 62.32 1.88 11.87
4.32 2.35 17.08 20.83 40.18 1.72
7.06
ND ND 0.37 43.83 26.61 4.45 0.86 23.88
21.54
11.05
ND ND 31.37 19.22 38.51 1.12 0.10 9.10
-
99.99
100.00
97.53
99.42
-
-
99.54
-
-
Site: 1, Coolgardie, Australia (Simpson, 1912). 2, Satara, Bombay, India (Warth and Warth, 1903). 3, Bagru Hill, Bihar, India (Fox, 1936). 4, Cheruvannur, India; Buchanan’s original site (Fox, 1936). 5, Djougou, Dahomey; laterite on granite (Alexander and Cady, 1962). 0 ND, not determined.
8
S. SIVAFUJASINGHAM ET AL.
low (sites 1, 2, and 3, Table I ) , but some varieties, such as the original laterite of Buchanan (site 4, Table I ) , may have significant amounts. This is probably largely in the form of kaolin, which has been found in recent work by Alexander and Cady (1!362) to be the principal or only identifiable silicate clay mineral in samples from Africa. Alumina may be the principal sesquioxide (site 3, Table I ) , but more commonly iron oxide (site 1, Table I ) or iron oxide and alumina together (sites 2, 4, and 5, Table I ) are the major constituents. Combined water, determined by loss on ignition, is appreciable but is generally higher in aluminous than in ferruginous varieties, as is shown in Table I. Titanium is also common in significant amounts in most varieties and may be a major constituent (site 3, Table I ) . Vanadium and chromium are found, but rarely in appreciable quantities. Quartz may be absent or present in only limited amounts, but on rocks high in quartz it is commonly a significant or major component, as on the granite of site 5 of Table I, for which petrographic studies showed that much of the total silica was contributed by quartz. Quartz is also common in laterite over nonquartzose rock, where it appears to be derived mainly from wind-blown or detrital material from outside sources. Ten samples of detrital laterite from various parts of India had an average of ,2074 quartz (Warth and Warth, 1903). Pendleton and Sharasuvana (1912, p. 10) have emphasized that differences in amount of quartz commonly contribute to major variation in SiO, among samples, even in the same profile. The impoverishment in combined silica and bases and concentration of sesquioxides during weathering and laterite formation on a dolerite is illustrated in Table 11. The “primary laterite” of Harrison is not to be confused with ‘laterite” as used in this review. It was a weathered earthy product that lay between the surficial hard laterite crust and the unweathered dolerite rock. Major differences in proportions of iron and aluminum and in amount of combined water between weathered material and laterite presumed to have formed in similar material are common, as in Table 11, but it is rarely possible to be certain that the laterite crust has indeed formed in material like that of the underlying weathered product. No consistent relationship seems to exist between the relative amounts of silica, iron, and alumina and the degree to which the physical properties of laterite are developed. The shortcoming of any chemical classification was shown by Fox (1936) from the analyses of laterite samples from Buchanan’s original sites (site 4, Table I ) . These would have been called ‘lateritic lithomarge” in Fermor’s ( 1911) classifkation because of the high content of combined silica, though the material was vermicular and was being quarried for building purposes.
9
LATERITE
The analyses considered so far refer to bulk samples of massive laterite without distinction between segregated nodular material and the matrix. The nodular material is, however, found either to be similar in composition to the matrix or to contain less combined silica and more TABLE I1 Chemical Composition ( ”/o ) of Dolerite, “Primary Laterite,” and Associated Laterite Ironstone at Eagle Mountain, British Guianaa Constituent
Dolerite rock
“Primary laterite”
Laterite ironstone
2.40 49.60 17.29 2.90 8.26 0.35 0.53 0.05 6.95 8.80 0.18 2.81
2.86 0.50 46.80 23.64 2.50 22.96 0.69 Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil
0.14 0.62 10.54 74.43 0.65 9.60 3.91 Nil Trace 0.02 Nil Nil
99.95
99.91
H,O (loss on ignition) TiO, MnO MgO CaO K,O Na,O a
-
-
100.12 From Harrison (1933).
TABLE I11 Selected Chemical Constituents (%) of Nodules of Laterite at 5 Sites and of the Matrix in Which the Nodules Were Embedded at One of Them 5 Constituent Site:a SiO, A1203 Fe,% TiO, MnO,
1
2
3
4
Soft nodules
Matrix
8.0 4.7 67.9
29.7 29.1 21.7 2.0 2.3
26.1 14.2 20.7 6.3 13.1
49.8 2.7 28.9 9.8 1.1
39.3 19.3 30.1 0.9 0.1
54.8 20.6 13.5 1.0 0.1
0.5 Nil
a Site: 1, Natal; ferruginous nodules (Beater, 1940). 2, Welimada, Ceylon; aluminous and silicious nodules (Joachim and Kandiah, 1941). 3, Peradeniya, Ceylon; manganiferous nodules (Joachim and Kandiah, 1941). 4, Hambantota, Ceylon; titaniferous nodules (Joachim and Kandiah, 1941), 5, Congo; soft nodules and matrix (Alexander and Cady, 1962).
ferric oxide. Site 5 of Table 111 illustrates the latter in soft nodules of a ground-water laterite of the Congo. Prescott and Pendleton (1952, p. 21) believed that nodules usually contain less free alumina than the more massive forms and that they are low in manganese.
10
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM ET
AL.
Nodules studied by Alexander et al. (1956) were high in sesquioxides and low in silica. Other workers have, however, reported appreciable contents of both quartz and combined silica (Joachim and Kandiah, 1941; Waegemans, 1954). The data in Table 111 illustrate the wide range of silica, alumina, iron, titanium, and manganese in nodules from different places. The work of Bennett and Allison (1928) also reveals variations in the composition of nodules in different soils.
L C. M W ~ L O G I C ACHARAC~ERISTLCS Chemical analysis alone is not sufficient to reveal the nature and origin of laterite ( Harrison, 1910; Campbell, 1917). Laterites having similar physical properties, such as hardness or morphology, may differ greatly in chemical composition, and, conversely, laterites having similar chemical compositions may have greatly different physical properties. Petrographic studies of thin sections ( Harrison, 1910, 1933), adsorption of dyes (Hardy and Rodrigues, 1939), differential thermal analysis (Humbert, 1948; Bonifas, 1959), and X-ray analysis (Alexander et al., 1956; Bonifas, 1959) have been used to supplement chemical determinations. Free alumina is mostly in the form of gibbsite (A1203.3H20),as boehmite ( A1203.H20), or as an amorphous hydrated form which has been called cliachite and a variety of other names (Hanlon, 1944; Palache d aE., 1944). Iron is found in the form of goethite (FeO-OH), hematite ( FeeOa),and as amorphous oxides or unidentifiable coatings on other minerals (Alexander et al., 1956). Free silica is mostly inherited quartz (Alexander et al., 1956),though Harrison ( 1933, p. 40) reported PLATE 1 Photomicrographs illustrating features of weathering and laterite formation A. Weathering diorite, North Carolina. Crossed Nicols. The lath-like forms are gibbsite pseudomorphs after feldspar. Some dark areas are allophane and some are iron oxide. €3. Soft laterite from granite, Nigeria. Crossed Nicols. The light areas of the crystal aggregate (upper left) and of the filled channel (lower right) are gibbsite formed upon weathering of kaolinite. Dark areas are iron-impregnated clays and iron oxides, which are isotropic or have a very low birefringence. C. Hard laterite from granite, Nigeria. Plain light. The dark areas are impregnated with iron by local redistribution from the light areas. The higher population of quartz grains (white areas) in the part that has lost iron indicates that these parts have collapsed. D. Hard laterite from granite, Kigeria. Crossed Nicols. The yellow parts are crystalline goethite which forms a continuous network, especially on the walls of the small channel at the left. The dark streak through the center is a former channel filled with fine-grained hematite. White spots are quartz grains.
A
C
B
D
PLATEI
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
LATERITE
13
secondary quartz in laterites presumed to have been derived from basic igneous rocks containing only small amounts of quartz. Chalcedony and opaline forms have been observed also. Presence of colloidal silica has been suspected. Besides quartz, other resistant minerals like magnetite, zircon, sphene, anatase, and ilmenite have been found. Combined silica is known to occur in kaolin and comparable silicate clay minerals that can be identified but is present in amorphous or subcrystalline forms as well. Montmorillonite and illite types of clays have not been identified in significant amounts. The distribution and form of constituents within the laterite has special significance. Recent studies by the authors have shown that the finely divided matrix is commonly largely unoriented and unidentifiable by petrographic techniques, though identsable portions range from none to most of the material. Grains and large patches of oriented aggregates ranging from kaolin slightly stained with iron oxide through kaolin highly impregnated with iron oxide to almost pure goethite or hematite are among the more prominent identifiable constituents. Variable optical density within the matrix is related to the degree of iron impregnation (Plate 1, C and D). Hardness of the mass appears to be related to the degree of crystalinity and continuity of the crystalline phase of the impregnating iron, which is largeIy in the form of goethite. Tiny spherical bodies comparable to incipient nodules of centripetal enrichment described by Bryan (1952) are largely unoriented earthy material having a higher degree of iron impregnation than the surrounding matrix. Some have films of crystalline goethite on the surface or as concentric shells within the body. Other spherical bodies embedded in the matrix may be concretionary or pisolitic forms of gibbsite, boehmite, goethite, or hematite. Gridlike networks of oriented materials are found in the matrix of many specimens and are composed principally of goethite (Alexander et al., 1956) or hematite ( Sivarajasingham, 1961). Gibbsite pseudomorphs after feldspar (Plate 1A) and goethite pseudomorphs after ferromagnesian minerals are common constituents. These appear to be most abundant in young laterites whereas concretionary or pisolitic nodular forms of the same minerals are more conspicuous in older varieties (Alexander et al., 1956). Gibbstite and boehmite are found commonly as fillings in cracks and pores, both in the matrix and in nodules. Pores and cracks may also be lined with oriented kaolin having varying degrees of iron impregnation, or even with oriented goethite (Plate 1D). In hard laterite crusts, hematite may be found as pore linings, as bands, or as discrete masses (Plate 1D). In varieties derived from quartzose material, quartz grains are generally distributed randomly through the matrix (Plate 1C) and earthy nodular bodies.
14
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
Quartz, apparently derived from outside sources, may also be present in laterite over nonquartzose rock (Alexander et aZ., 1956). 111. The Environment of Laterite
Laterite is widely distributed in Africa, Australia, Southeast Asia, and South America; Prescott and Pendleton (1952) have given a comprehensive review of its geographical distribution. The observed distribution of laterite relative to present environment, however, is not necessarily a criterion of conditions under which laterite forms (Hallsworth and Costin, 1953, p. 25; Pendleton, 1936, p. 107). A. CLIMATE Pendleton (1941) considered that an effective rainfall capable of supporting a forest is necessary and that laterite probably never develops in a climate that would support a savannah-type climax vegetation. Maignien (1958, p. 15) concluded that the Sudano-Guinea climate of 80 or more inches of rain per year with 2 to 4 months relatively dry is optimum for mobilization, accumulation, and induration of iron in laterite. Humbert ( 1948, pp. 281-282) concluded that continuously wet conditions do not favor laterite formation. The occurrence of a period of drought, which is observed in many areas where laterite occurs, was though to be a requisite by Maclaren (1906). This was disputed by Scrivenor ( 1909), however, who declared that laterite occurs in Malacca, where there is no such alternation of seasons. Campbell (1917) and Humhert (1948, p. 282) considered that a regular alternation of wet and dry seasons is not necessary if there are periods of wetness and dryness, even though irregularly distributed. Mohr and van Baren (1954, pp. 69-71) have suggested, on the basis of effective rainfall and evapotranspiration, that a monthly rainfall not exceeding 60 mm. would constitute an adequately “dry” season to provide no excess of rain over evapotranspiration in tropical regions. Simpson ( 1912) thought that laterite was forming under the semiarid conditions of western Australia. It appears clear that some minimum amount of water is necessary for weathering, the removal of bases and combined silica, and segregation of iron so evident in the resultant material. It also appears reasonable that periods of drying should favor the crystallization of goethite or similar minerals, which appear to be associated with hardening. Observations by the authors suggest that approximately equal wet and dry seasons favor crust formation and that some degree of alternating wet and dry season is probably essential for this process. It is not clear whether the material may or may not be conditioned for this final segregation and crystallization in permanently wet conditions. To some degree,
LATERITE
15
conflicting views may be the result of two confounding factors: (1) the occurrence of laterite under climates that are unlike those under which the laterite formed, and ( 2 ) differential effectiveness of climatic wetness or dryness in combination with differences of topography, parent material, and time. Laterite is found where temperatures are warm or are believed to have been warm at the time of formation. This does not preclude the possibility, however, that time, not temperature, is the controlling factor. If the principal effect of high temperature is to accelerate rates of reactions, the time interval necessary for laterite formation in temperate regions may exceed the period of time that appropriate landscapes have been stable. Similarly, observations of Oldham ( 1893), Joachim and Kandiah (1935), and Prescott and Pendleton (1952) that laterite has not formed under the cool temperatures of highlands in the tropics may be due less to cool temperature than to landscape instability. Nevertheless, field observation generally agree with the hypothesis that warm temperatures favor the formation of laterite.
B . VEGETATION A forest vegetation was considered necessary for laterite formation by Glinka (1927, pp. 33-34). More detailed observations have shown that, while laterite occurs in regions with a rain-forest vegetation, welldeveloped laterite is most commonly found under a low forest and that hard surficial laterite is a very common feature of the open savannah adjacent to the forest. Maignien (1958, p. 16) concluded that laterite is most extensive and strongly expressed at the boundary of forest and savannah. DHoore (1954,1957, p. 55) found iron mobilized to a greater degree and to greater depth under tropical grasses than under forest. Buchanan’s type of soft laterite is found in Ceylon in the forested areas of the southwestern lowland. Humbert (1948) suggested that laterite forms in a climate that has a wet and a dry season, and his descriptions and illustrations indicate that the laterite he observed was in an open savannah that was gradually replacing forest, a common condition where a dry season is prominent. The change from soft laterite to the hard form within a few years after man has cleared the forests has been reported by Alexander and Cady ( 1962) in French Guinea and other parts of West Africa. Blackie’s (1949) description of soils of Fiji and Aubert’s (1950) description of Dahomey also confirm the hardening of laterite following a change from forest to savannah caused by man’s activities. It would appear from the literature that laterite is most extensive in areas of savannah but that laterite forms under forest though its hardening is favored by lack of forest cover.
16
S. SIVARAJASLNGHAM ET AL.
Nodular forms are very common in forested areas, though they also appear to be most widespread in the savannah. Rosevear ( 1942) has reported a case where reforestation softened hard laterite significantly in as little as 16 years. The possible explanations of the effect of vegetation on hardening and softening will be considered later. C. PARENT MATERIAL Laterite is found overlying a variety of kinds of rock. It is common over basic igneous rocks such as basalt, norite, and diabase as well as over acid rocks such as granite, granulites, gneisses, and sericitic schists. Laterite has also been observed on shale, sandstone, and other sedimentary rocks including limestone (Jones, 1943; Stephens, 1946, p. 11). Marbut (1932, p. 76) has described laterite outcropping on the banks of the Amazon, presumably in alluvium, in association with a ground water table. Maignien (1958) has shown that fermginous laterites may develop on a variety of materials providing there i s a source of iron either in the parent rock or in adjacent higher-lying areas from which water may introduce ferruginous material. The laterite layers may be in material unrelated to the underlying bedrock. In some places, laterite clearly has formed in residuum of rocks that have weathered in place, as evidenced by features such as a constant proportion of iron oxides to alumina with depth or by a continuation of quartz veins from the rock into the laterite. It is also found in colluvial deposits; examples are described by Maignien ( 1958). Often laterite is associated with material that has been transported locally; recently recognition of stone lines in surhial mantles of this character has directed attention to the frequency of such conditions (Ruhe, 1959). Though such surficial deposits may not be directly related to the underlying bedrock, they may not be very different from residuum of the major rocks in the locality, since transport is often of a local nature as in cases cited by Nye (1955a) and by Ollier ( 1959). The parent material in which laterite forms may also be derived from material of different and highly contrasting strata than the underlying rock currently present. Whatever the source of material in which laterite forms, an adequate supply of iron appears to be essential. Alexander and Cady (1962) have noted that the thickness of laterite crusts is sometimes related to the iron-richness of associated rocks.
D. TOPOGRAPHY Laterite has been generally associated with a level or gently sloping surface. This characteristic was emphasized by Oldham (1893) in his review of numerous laterite locations in India and has been subsequently
LATERITE
17
confirmed by many workers from other parts of the tropics. Campbell ( 1917), from his many observations, reported that laterite currently being formed covers the flatter ground and stops where the slopes are steep. Holmes (1914) observed that in Mozambique laterite occurs only on gently undulating plateaus and never on steep slopes. Humbert (1948), from his study of laterite in Australian New Guinea, concluded that the best examples of laterite occur almost exclusively on areas of low relief and gentle slopes. Prescott and Pendleton (1952, pp. 25-26) also emphasized the nearly level nature of the terrain where laterite occurs. The horizontal disposition of laterite deposits is very striking in many relatively arid regions. Newbold (1846) observed that in the interior of South India laterite occurs in almost horizontal beds as cappings on the tops of mountains. Woolnough (1918) emphasized the significance of relic laterite deposits in western Australia on slightly elevated plateaus. Similarly in southwestern Australia, laterite is found in many localities as massive or concretionary deposits forming protective cappings on flattopped residuals (Mulcahy, 1960, 1962). Laterite is also present in extensive bodies on dissected tablelands (Stephens, 1946). Laterite is found along river banks and on terraces adjacent to higher ground. These masses of “gallery laterite” are believed by DHoore (1957, p. 97) to be formed by enrichment with iron during flood stage followed by its immobilization when the flood subsides. In the flat humid areas, where it is believed that laterite is forming currently, a high but fluctuating water table is common. The drainage is more or less imperfect, and the ground water at and below the water table is thought to be somewhat sluggish. This has led to a common opinion that topography conducive to a high water table may be essential. Soft laterite is found at a shallow depth on low hillocks in southwestern Ceylon, generally not much more than 100 to 200 feet above sea level (Prescott and Pendleton, 1952, p. 9 ) . The slopes are undulating and are certainly not level, Though Oldham (1893) dismissed these occurrences as “a more or less ferruginous subsoil which never passes into laterite,” the descriptions of Joachin and Kandiah (1935) indicate that these materials, locally called “cabook,” conform to Buchanan’s concept in every way. It should be noted, however, that the underlying rock in this region is charnockite, a quartzo-feldspathic gneiss or granulite with hypersthene, and that the rainfall is over 100 inches per annum but with dry intervals. High rainfall and high iron content of the parent rock may favor the formation of laterite even where the surface is not level but is stable owing to the nature of the weathered material and forest cover. Mulcahy (1960, p. 222, 1962) emphasized that peneplain condi-
18
S . SIVARAJASINCHAM ET AL.
tions of low relief are not essential, though low available relief conducive to stable land surfaces for long periods is most favorable. Laterite on areas of low relief, nevertheless, is the most common. Blanford (1879) classified the Indian laterites into high-level and lowlevel varieties, depending on the mode of occurrence. This distinction was at first intended only to signify two contrasting positions, high-level laterite capping the summits of hills and plateaus on the highlands of central and western India and low-level laterite covering large tracts in the coastal regions (Holland, 1903). Subsequent workers observed that low-level laterite is generally the more fenvginous and commonly does not exceed 30 feet in thickness. It also commonly contains inclusions of sand and pebbles, which indicate a multicycle or detrital origin (Oldham, 1893). Low-level laterite, however, does not everywhere contain such foreign inclusions. Since it was once thought that laterite can form only at or near the water table, the low-level laterite on areas with a high water table was called “live” laterite. The laterite on ground above the reach of the water table was thought to have been a product of an earlier period when the groundwater fluctuation reached the laterite zone. Hence, this was called “dead laterite ( Campbell, 1917). The high-level laterite is generally more homogeneous and may be relatively thick, as much as 100 to 200 feet according to Oldham (1893), though it is probable that such thickness is a feature of plateau margins. Though it was considered “dead” by Campbell ( 1917), Harrison (1933, p. 16) believed that laterite can form on high-level positions, as on the plateau of the Eagle Mountain range in British Guiana, under conditions of heavy rainfall though the water table is low. As it is presumably being formed currently, this would be called “live” laterite. Laterite in highlevel position may include pebbles from even higher surfaces, indicating detrital origin (Ruhe, 1954, p. 18). The laterite found on distinct slopes adjacent to higher ground may be called foot-slope laterite to indicate its topography. It is often detrital, being formed by the consolidation of fragments of the laterite of the higher level that have moved down the slope as erosion has advanced (Oldham, 1893). The second member of Greene’s ( 1945) “ironstone catena” would be this class. “Terrace” laterite occurs on terraces adjacent to high ground or along the banks of streams. It is thought to be formed by the deposition of dissolved material where ground water moving laterally and down the adjacent slope encounters the oxidizing conditions of the surface horizons (Campbell, 1917). Maignien (1958, 1959) emphasized the occurrence of laterite crusts at the borders of natural drainage areas, such as piedmonts, river banks, dissection forms, and
19
LATERITE
other abrupt breaks in slopes where the profile of a saturated zone approaches the surface. Another type recognized by Fermor (1911) is “lake” laterite formed in marshy areas by water flowing from the surrounding higher land, either along the surface or by seepage. Lake (1890) used the accompanying tabulation to classify the laterites in Malabar, India, according to topographic position, character, and origin: Group
Nature of the laterite
Origin
Plateau laterite Terrace laterite Valley laterite
Vesicular Pellety Partly vesicular Partly pellety
Nondetrital Detrital Partly nondetrital Partly detrital
More elaborate schemes of classification, based on other factors, have been published by DHoore (1955),Maignien (1958), and du Preez (1949). Four physiographically distinct landscapes with which laterite is commonly identified in the literature are: (1) high-level peneplain remnants, (2) colluvial footslopes subject to water seepage, ( 3 ) lowlevel plains having high water tables or receiving water from higher land, (4) residual uplands other than peneplain remnants. The first three are illustrated diagramatically in Fig. 1. Hlgh-Level Plateou wlth Loterite Cap
Laterits Detritus Laterite Enriched
FIG. 1. Relationships among physiographically distinct landscapes with which laterite is commonly associated.
Laterite on high-level peneplain remnants may be in residuum of rocks weathered in place or may be in transported material deposited prior to peneplain dissection. Its present position is a consequence of landscape inversion such as that described by Bonnault (1938); it once occupied a low-level position comparable to that illustrated in Fig. 1. With uplift or with lowering of base level, areas protected by laterite have remained as erosion lowered the surrounding areas. Such areas now occupy the highest positions and are being reduced slowly by
20
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM
ET AL.
lateral retreat of slopes, as on the two Tertiary surfaces described by Ruhe (1954, p. 18-25). At the base of peneplain remnants, detritus from above, including fragments of the crust, accumulates and is recemented to form younger laterite on the colluvial footslope (Maignien, 1958, 1959; D’Hoore, 1954, 1957). On low-level plains soft laterite is commonly currently forming above a water table; and on undulating upland surfaces, laterite may be forming locally in clayey iron-rich residuum whose impervious nature periodically causes saturation with water.
E. AGE Many existing laterites are clearly relics of geologic antiquity. Those of Queensland, Australia, are reported to be products of two humid periods of the Pliocene (Whitehouse, 1940). In Ceylon, of the crusts described most are thought to be products of the Pleistocene and some, of Pliocene or earlier periods (Fernando, 1948). Laterites of Nioka (Ituri), Congo have been related to mid- and late-tertiary surfaces by Ruhe (1954). Though laterite may be forming currently on some ancient peneplain remnants, many high-level crusts are considered to be “dead products of the age of peneplain development. Their existence may commonly be considered a factor in the preservation of the land forms on which they occur, and the period since the lowering of base level is a measure of the time required for landscape inversion under given conditions. Nevertheless, many examples of laterite believed to be forming currently have been reported ( Fermor, 1911; Simpson, 1912; Campbell, 1917; Marbut, 1932; Harrison, 1933; Joachim and Kandiah, 1941; Pendleton and Sharasuvana, 1942; Kellogg and Davol, 1949). Though it is commonly assumed that formation of laterite requires a very long time, some laterites of “absolute accumulation” ( D’Hoore, 1957, pp. 94-98) apparently may form rapidly. Obviously, formation of laterite from solid unweathered rock can be no more rapid than the time required to attain a high degree of weathering. In unconsolidated weathered material subject to enrichment in iron from outside sources, however, rate of development may be relatively rapid. Hardening of the soft preconditioned material may take place in a few years upon exposure (Alexander and Cady, 1962). IV. Profiles Containing Laterite
Though either nodular or vesicular laterite may lie within, and may be genetically related to, the solum of the modem soil, as defined by the Soil Survey Staff of U.S.D.A. (1951), many laterites appear to be
LATERITE
21
unrelated genetically to present soil horizons. Consequently, the Soil Survey Staff (1960) has defined “plinthite” independently of soil horizon definitions, though they use the presence of soft “plinthite” within the solum as a criterion of soil classification. This discussion is concerned with horizons or layers in the entire weathered section, which commonly is much thicker than the part that would be considered “solum.” A. SOILMATERIALOVERLYING LATERITE At sites where laterite is thought to be forming, it is generally found as a shallow but not surficial layer. Prescott and Pendleton (1952) reported laterite in Ceylon at various depths, averaging about 2 feet, and in Thailand from a fraction of a foot to 6 feet. Humbert (1948) described “red to yellow loam” 2 to 6 feet thick over laterite in Queensland. Some Iaterite layers have been described by Alexander and Cady (1!362) at a depth as great as 13 feet in Sierra Leone but others were found near or at the surface. Similar observations are very numerous in the literature and indicate that soil material over laterite is mainly less than 10 feet thick. Laterite crusts at the surface are very widespread ( Oldham, 1893; Maclaren, 1906; Simpson, 1912; Walther, 1915; Prescott and Pendleton, 1952, among many authors), but such exposure is generally attributed to erosion. Though hardening of laterite is thought to be a phenomenon favored by surface position, the literature implies that the initial development of material that will harden most commonly occurs at some depth below the surface. Hardened laterite crusts as thick as 200 feet (Oldham, 1893) suggest that development can proceed to this depth, but such an extreme may be only at the edge of peneplain remnants where the material is affected by vertical exposure. A crust 30 feet thick has been reported by Alexander and Cady (1962); Campbell (1917) observed that laterite seldom exceeds 30 feet in thickness. Mohr (1944) considered laterite to be essentially a soil horizon of sesquioxide accumulation to which the overlying soil material is related genetically. This concept has been elaborated by Mohr and van Baren (1954, pp. 300304) and was accepted by Pendleton (1936, p. 106). Marbut ( 1932) postulated a comparable genetic relationship between laterite and soil material above it. In all these cases, the authors have dealt with restricted conditions, comparable in many respects to the original laterite of Buchanan. The work of Maignien (1958, 1959), Mulcahy (1960), and D’Hoore (1954, 1957) and observations by the authors (Alexander and Cady, 1962) show clearly that the presence of a suficial mantle of soil over laterite is no assurance that the soil is related to the underlying laterite genetically, or that if genetic relationships are involved, they may be quite unlike those postulated.
22
S . SIVAEWJASINGHAM
ET AL.
The overlying soil material may be from sources different than the material in which the laterite has formed. Stone lines marking erosion surfaces (Ruhe, 19.59) are very common in the tropics and may mark major discontinuities of material vertically. Ollier ( 1959), however, has reported extensive areas in Uganda where the stone lines appear to be the result of sorting by termites, leaving coarse fragments below and moving fine earth to the surface. Nye (1954) also emphasized the activities of termites but reported substantial sorting and downslope creep of the sorted material. Berry and Ruxton (1959) also have emphasized an upper zone of migration. Resistant minerals, such as quartz, in soil over laterite from quartz-free rock are common and indicate at least contamination of the upper layers of material from outside sources. In some cases surface material can be demonstrated to be residual from the same rock as that from which underlying laterite has formed and either predates or is contemporaneous with the laterite. There are also cases known to the authors in which a surficial soil mantle has developed by disintegration of the upper part of a laterite crust. Such soils are commonly thin over the laterite and contain pieces of the disintegrating laterite. Thus, a great variety of soils may overlie laterite. Where such soil horizons are residual, they are composed of highly weathered material high in sesquioxides with or without kaolin and with some component of whatever highly resistant minerals may have been present in the parent rock. They may be uniform in character with depth, like Latosols, or may have genetic A-B horizon sequences not unlike Red-Yellow Podzolic Soils. Commonly, the first laterite encountered with depth is in the form of individual nodules within the soil horizons. These may reach a maximum with depth below which they decrease without being joined into masses as in examples given by Nye (1954, 1955a) and Radwanski and Ollier (1959), or they may pass into masses of nodular or vesicular laterite, as in profiles described by Joachim and Kandiah (1941) and Ollier (1959).
B. LA-
SOILHORIZONS Many soils of the tropics have laterite within genetic horizons. These may be detrital nodules or fragments from adjacent higher-lying landscapes containing laterite ( Greene, 1945; Ruhe, 1954), relics of disintegrating laterite crusts in which soils are forming (Mulcahy, 1960, 1962), or units developing concurrently with the modem soil (Ollier, 1959). The “murram” used for surfacing roads in India (Prescott and Pendleton, 1952) is mainly nodular laterite and may be in horizons of the modern WITHIN
23
LATERITE
soil. The authors have observed profiles comparable to both Red-Yellow Podzolic Soils and Latosols, both containing nodular laterite in various horizons, in widely separated areas of East and West Africa and in the Philippines. The Tifton series, a Red-Yellow Podzolic Soil of southeastern United States, contains laterite nodules in both Az and B horizons. The nodules in the B horizon of Tifton are intact and either forming or stable, whereas those in the A2 are apparently dissolving, leaving quartz grains protruding from the iron-rich matrix. Similar conditions in soils
0’
600
300
1200 1
900
Horizontal Scole, Feet
0-
12-
24
-
:
.z 3 6 -
e
z
48-
60
I. Dork. Sendy Loom
h r k . Sandy Loom
Red Sandy
Red So*
Lmm
with M Nodule.
Sandy
84 -
96
-
108
-
Loam
Nodules
Red Sandy Cloy with Few Fins
Nodular
-
Dork.Sandy Loom
Groyirh Brown
Cloy Loom rnth Commn
..
:a\/Cortkm
1.r
Mottled Sandy cloy Loam
r
Nodular
-
Mottled Red I and Brownish Yellow Sandy Clov Loom
,.,,’I
72
4
3. 0ork.Sondy Loom
GIOY Sandy Clay with Few Matller
FIG.2. Laterite nodules in soils of a catenary association of Southern Nigeria.
containing iron nodules have been observed in Southern Rhodesia and parts of Australia by the authors. Though laterite nodules are common in soils that have no obvious high water table ( Raychaudhuri, 1941) , such nodules commonly increase progressively downslope on a given land form. Figure 2 shows this relationship at a site near Ibadan, Xigeria where proximity of a zone of saturation to the surface appears to be a controlling factor. It is believed that these are developing concurrently with the modem soil and are analogous to the forms described by Nye (1954, 1955a) in Ghana. In the “Ground-Water Laterite” soil described by Kellogg and Davol
24
S. SWARAJASISGHASL ET AL.
(1949), the laterite is considered to be a genetic horizon of the modern soil. In this profile, laterite nodules are present at a depth of 8 inches, increase in numbers with depth, and occupy a major part of a weakly cemented horizon from 23 to 45 inches, which rests on soft massive laterite that hardens upon exposure to air. Mohr (1944) and Mohr and van Baren ( 1954) have postulated progressive soil development involving ( I ) laterite-free profiles in which an impervious substratum forms, ( 2 ) stages having horizons containing nodular laterite, and ( 3 ) a final stage involving massive laterite.
C. Homoss
OR
LAYERS BENEATH LATERITE
Obviously, detrital laterite fragments and nodules come to rest capriciously on whatever material may be present on footslopes of dissection forms, and in such areas of landscape inversion (Bonnault, 1938) the detrital laterite and the underlying material may be unrelated. The laterite detritus, however, commonly contributes iron to enrichment of adjacent layers (Maignien, 1958, 1959). A great variety of unrelated layers may be found under laterite zones in such positions. Where the laterite zone is apparently residual, however, the literature reveals some measure of consistency of kinds of underlying layers. Though Holland (1903) reported that laterite may rest on unaltered bedrock, most descriptions show highly weathered, commonly thick, earthy layers between the laterite zone and bedrock. In dry areas or where conditions contribute to good aeration, as on some high-level positions, the underlying material may be high in chroma (bright colored) though commonly variegated in color ( Kellogg and Davol, 1949, p. 52). More commonly, especially on low-level positions, the laterite zone is underlain by either a mottled zone, a light-colored layer, or both, suggestive of poor aeration, reduction of iron, and possible lateral leaching of sesquioxides. U‘alther ( 1915) introduced the terms “mottled zone” and “pallid zone” for comparable parts of profiles of western Australia, which contained the following layers: (1) ironstone crust, ( 2 ) mottled zone, ( 3 ) pallid zone, and (4)parent rock. Simpson (1912) described similar sequences on both granite and greenstone schist in the same region. Though Maclaren (1906) used different terms in describing a lSfoot section in India, his sequence, hard laterite-soft laterite-reddish buff sandy clay-white grit-decomposed biotite and quartz schist, is very similar. Marbut’s (1932, p. 74) idealized description of typical “Ground-Water Laterite” of the Amazon Valley and Cuba reveals the same layers: (1) soil, ( 2 ) iron-oxide layer,
LATERITE
25
porous, slaglike, (3) mottled layer, ( 4 ) gray layer, and (5) unconsolidated clay and sand. He reported that the gray layer (pallid zone) may be absent. Kellogg and Davol (1949) did not specify distinct mottled and pallid zones in a “Ground-Water Laterite” of the Congo, but their description shows mottling intermingled with high color values ( light colors) in the lower part of the profile. Mohr and van Baren ( 1954, p. 302) described similar layers in idealized profiles on volcanic ash in which laterite is formidg in Indonesia:
- Redearth B3- Layer of mottled A
B2B1C
-
clay differentiable into an upper layer of Fe203(incipient laterite) and a lower gibbsitic layer (mottled zone?) Spotted white clay (pallid zone) Layer with siliceous cement Unaltered ash of the basic suite
The numbering of “ B horizons by superscripts upward indicates the hypothesis of development upward above the slowly permeable silicacemented B1 layer, which supports a perched water table. Mulcahy (1960, 1962) described thick pallid zones in Australia under ancient laterite in high-level positions where mean annual rainfall is now less than 20 inches per year, their thickness decreasing from 60 or 80 feet under 20 inches of rain to about 10 feet under 13 inches. Jessop (1960) described pallid zones from 60 to 200 feet thick in the southeastern part of the Australian arid zone under a silicified cap on plateau remnants and concluded that the pallid zone is a relic of an ancient profile from which the ferruginous material has been stripped. From observations in Africa and Australia, Alexander has concluded that some pallid zones are consequences of exclusion of air by overlying laterite; they appear to be actively forming even on high-level positions in relatively dry climates when they lie beneath a crust dense enough to permit little access of air and where the zone is saturated for some period during a rainy season. A profile by Kellogg and Davol (1949, p. 52) in the Congo suggests that on relatively dry sites a thick (4-foot) layer of unmottled soil, comparable to laterite-free soils of the locality, may lie between a relic laterite crust and a mottled zone. Commonly immediately above unweathered rock is a soft layer that has undergone major chemical change while retaining the structural character of the rock from which it was formed. This was called “zersatz” by Harrassowitz (1926, 1930). This may lie beneath a mottled or pallid zone, as in the “Ground-Water Laterite” of Kellogg and Davol (1949).
26
S . Sn‘AEMJASINGHAhl ET AL.
may be separated from massive laterite by only a zone of concretionary laterite, as in a profile described by Humbert (1948), or may occur in profiles without laterite. In the more arid regions of western Australia, an additional horizon of siliceous nature has been recognized by Whitehouse (1940) in profiles containing laterite. Layers of silica-cemented sandy material, known as ‘billy,” or clayey material, known as “porcellanite,” were described beneath laterite and over sedimentary rocks. Jessop ( 1960) has described silicified layers within the pallid zones of profiles presumed to have once contained laterite and has concluded that they were formed in the manner postulated by Mohr and van Baren for silica-cemented layers under laterite in volcanic ash. Though such materials have been recognized in both western and southern Australia, their relationship to laterite, if any, has not been clearly demonstrated. They may be the result of accumulation of silica removed from iron-rich layers above in at least some cases. In summary, profiles containing laterite may have, from the surface downward, some combination of layers of the following sequence: ( 1 ) soil with or without nodular laterite in some horizon, ( 2 ) laterite, ( 3 ) “mottled zone,” ( 4 ) “pallid zone,” ( 5 ) silica-cemented layer, ( 6 ) “zersatz.” Descriptions of profiles with these layers in India have been presented by Satyanarayana and Thomas ( 1961 ) . All may be present, and one or all apparently may be related genetically to the laterite. None except the laterite itself appears to be essential to development of laterite in all environments, however. Accurate appraisal of relationships among such layers is enormously complicated by the common occurrence of laterite as relics of a former contrasting environment, the variety of geomorphic relationships involved in landscapes on which laterite is currently found, and the fact that the enrichment necessary for laterite formation can occur in a number of different ways. V. Formation of Laterite
The early theories of laterite formation were as varied as the nature of the material and the conditions under which it is found. Lake (1890) has given an excellent summary of these to 1890 in the appendix to his report of the geology of South Malabar. Briefly, one group including Babington (1821), Benza ( 1836), Blanford ( 1859), Buist ( 1860),Clark (1838), Kelaart (1853), McGee ( 1880), Wingate ( 1852), and others considered it to be a residual product of weathering in place. Blanford (1859), Cole (1836), King and Foote (18641, Newbold (1844, 1846), Theobald ( 1873), and Wynne ( 1872) recognized detrital, sedimentary,
LATERITE
27
or other origins not dependent upon residual weathering, though several of these authors recognized residual forms as well. Voysey (1833) and Carter ( 1852), among several, proposed volcanic origins with subsequent weathering. Issues of the Memoirs of the Geological Survey of India, starting with Volume 1 in 1859, the Madras Journal of Literature and Science during the first half of the nineteenth century, and the Record of the Geological Survey of India, starting with Volume 1 in 1868 are rich in articles on laterite. The various theories proposed were not without reasons. The slaglike character of laterite and its occurrence as horizontal masses over basalt flows of the Deccan plateau led Voysey (1833) to suggest a volcanic origin. Oldham ( 1893), possibly influenced by Mallet’s ( 1881) comparison of Indian laterite to certain ferruginous sedimentary beds of Ulster, postulated a lacustrine origin. Thickness as great as 200 feet locally, occurrence as extensive sheets overlying rocks as unlike as basalt and gneiss, high concentration of iron in laterite over rocks low in iron, and similar apparent anomalies led him to reject hypotheses of weathering in place advanced earlier by Newbold (1844, 1846), Foote (1876), and Lake (1890). Holland (1903) conceded that weathering of sorts is involved but concluded that a simple hypothesis of chemical weathering could not explain the abrupt transition from laterite to weathered rock nor the absence of laterite in regions having warm summers but cold winters. He postulated action by an organism capable of separating alumina from silica in silicates but destroyed by low temperatures-a process to be added to “the long list of tropical diseases against which the very rocks are not safe.” As DHoore (1955) has indicated, it is evident that the chemical composition of laterite can be a consequence of either or both of two processes: ( 1 ) concentration of sesquioxides by removal of silica and bases; or ( 2 ) concentration of sesquioxides by accumulation from outside sources. It is not often possible to decide on the basis of chemical analyses alone whether one or the other or both are involved. Commonly the nature of the parent material is not known with certainty, as the laterite may be in unidentifiable transported surficial deposits or may occupy positions that could receive iron-bearing water from adjacent areas. Even where the laterite is clearly in residuum of rock weathered in place, resistant index minerals or chemical constituents that can be used to reconstruct absolute changes in composition from rock to such highly weathered material are commonly not present in amounts or forms that would make such calculations unquestionably reliable. It is not surprising, therefore, that many conflicting theories have been propounded, even in recent years.
23
S. SIVARAJASIXGHAM ET AL.
Among the earlier workers, Glinka (1899), Holland (1903) and others suggested that the concentration of sesquioxides is primarily a consequence of removal of silica and bases. Maclaren (1906), Simpson (1912), Campbell (1917), Mohr ( 1944), Vine ( 1949), and others, however, postulated the probability, if not the necessity, of accumulation from outside sources. Vine postulated an aeolian mechanism; the others proposed accumulation from ground water, either from a high water table, from laterally moving water, or from both. There is, however, no specific basis for assuming that laterite can form in only one way or that all existing laterites have formed by the same combination of gross processes. Indeed, there is increasing evidence that although certain fundamental conditions are prerequisite to the chemical and mineralogical alterations that occur, these may be satisfied by a variety of local combinations of weathering reactions, water relationships, and other factors. These will be considered in more detail in the following pages. A. WEATHERING AS
A
PRECO~~ITIONER OF MATERIAL OF LATERITE
Whether or not a given laterite has been enriched in sesquioxides from outside sources, weathering is a major determinant of the ultimate composition and is considered here not only in relation to formation of laterite, but also as a preconditioner of material in which laterite may form. If the literature on chemical composition of laterite that is hard or that hardens upon exposure is compared with the literature on composition of soil material and weathering products that do not harden, it is apparent that the range of composition of laterite is included in the range of composition of what has been called ‘lateritic soils.” Thus, hardening is apparently not determined by gross chemical composition per se. Futhermore, the range of mineral species in materials that do not harden includes the mineral species in laterite, though differences may exist in proportions and continuity of crystallinity. For this reason, weathering and mineral transformations are treated in the pages that follow as processes and reactions that are not unique to laterite but that are essential to its development. Glinka emphasized the effects of rapid decomposition of organic matter in the tropics, with consequent release of energy and carbon dioxide, on weathering “so strong that laterite, essentially uniform in character, has been developed from rocks that vary widely in character” (Glinka, 1927, p. 35). He recognized intermediate stages in which “argillaceous aluminum silicates” accumulate with hydrated sesquioxides, and he inferred that secondary silicates are potential precursors of at least some of the sesquioxides that characterize the ultimate weathering product ( p. 42).
LATERITE
29
Harrassowitz ( 1926) applied the term “allophane” to weathering products consisting of various hydrous aluminum silicates or mixtures of hydroxides of aluminum and silicon whose crystallinity had not been demonstrated. The mass of clay in which “allophane” is a principal constituent but which contains the mineral kaolin was called siallite, and the process by which it had formed was called “siallitization.” Marbut ( 1928, p. 106) emphasized that “lateritization and siallitization are identical,” both being primarily processes of gradual “desilicification” leaving behind aluminum and iron after a very long period and going to completion only in hot humid climates. Marbut, like Glinka, believed firmly that “in cool climates it is apparent that siallite represents a product that is final so long as the environment remains constant” (p. 106). This distinction between weathering in temperate and in tropical climates and the concept of secondary silicates as intermediate products in the tropics appear repeatedly in the literature prior to 1933. Both have been questioned as consistent relationships subsequently. Harrison (1933), Alexander and co-workers (1941, 1956), D’Hoore (1954,1957), Leneuf ( 1959), Maignien ( 1958,1959), Briggs (1959), and others have clarified the mechanisms of weathering greatly since 1933 by detailed chemical and mineralogical studies; Harrison’s ( 1910) earlier work along similar lines had attracted little attention. As Mohr and van Baren (1954) have reviewed the literature prior to 1954 in more detail than is possible here, principally the work of Harrison and of selected individuals who worked after Mohr and van Baren’s book was published are considered in detail. Harrison (1933) found that weathering of basic igneous rocks in the tropics under more or less free drainage is accompanied by almost complete removal of silicon, calcium, magnesium, potassium, and sodium, leaving an earthy residue of gibbsite, ‘‘limonite,’’ a few unaltered fragments of feldspars, secondary quartz locally, and the various resistant minerals originally present in the rock. He called this earthy residuum “primary laterite,” a term which should not be confused with laterite as used in this paper. The loss of silicon relative to that of iron and aluminum is illustrated in Table IV by values based on Harrison’s data on composition of drainage water relative to the rock over which it had passed. Harrison concluded that the change from basic rock to primary weathering product is not gradual, as suggested by Glinka, Marbut, and others, but that sesquioxides are formed first, directly from their parent minerals, within a zone not greater than 1/6 inch from the hard rock. Farther from the rock, he found kaolin in significant quantities, which he attributed to resilication by small quantities of silica in percolating water. Mohr and van Baren (1954) have calculated the theoretical mineralogi-
30
S . SIVARAJASINCHAM ET AL.
cal composition of Harrison’s samples of dolerite and its weathered zones by allocating chemical constituents to specific mineral species ( Table V ) . Although the mineral species indicated are not necessarily identifiable in the amounts given, the theoretical mineralogical compositions of the dolerite rock and of the “latentic e a r t h more than 73 mm from the rock TABLE IV Silica, Iron Oxide, and Alumina in Water and in Weathering Rock Like That from Which It Had Drained5 Hornblende schist
Constituent SiO, Fez03 ~ 2 0 3
a b
Seepage water (mg/l)b 32.89 3.30 0.38
Epidiorite
spring Rock
water Rock (mg/l)b % 12.35 49.06 6.90 0.00 18.87 1.81
”/o 45.45 11.01 12.18
Basic rocks River Rock water (average) (mg/l)b % 24.69 48.95 3.99 11.34 - 15.97
Calculated from data of Harrison (1933, pp. 13, 15, 31, 35). Increase relative to rain water. TABLE V Theoretical Mineralogical Composition of Dolerite Rock and Successive Weathered Zonesa
Mineral Species Quartz Plagioclase Augite Magnetite Ilmenite Gibbsite Diaspore Goethite Hematite Kaolin Water 0
b c
Dolerite
Weathered material at indicated distance from the rock ( % )
%
Wmm
3-21mm
2 51 42 4 1
13 10 3 4 3 38 28
-
21-71mm
71-73mmb
73mm5mc
13
12
12
-
-
-
5 4 40
5 2 35
4
1 10
-
-
-
28
34
8 13 52
-
-
7 6
10 2
-
Mohr and van Baren ( 1954, p. 140). Hard crust. “Lateritic earth.”
are consistent with Harrison’s qualitative observations based on microscopic examination. The microscopic studies also showed segregation of alumina in nodules of gibbsite in a matrix of argillaceous material within the “zone of resilication.” Data such as these have been the principal evidence on which hypotheses of resilication of gibbsite have been based. In contrast to Harrison (1933) and Hardy and Rodrigues (1939),
LATERITE
31
who postulated, respectively, that silica for resilication comes from ascending and descending ground-water solutions, Alexander et al. ( 1941) concluded that the uniform thickness of the zone of resilication could be explained only on the basis that the source of silica was the core of weathering rock. The presence of a very thin zone relatively free of resilicated material was never satisfactorily explained on either basis, since the proposed roles of acidic and basic environments and of bases on mobilization and immobilization of silica under conditions of weathering with intense leaching are questionable. The very thin zone relatively free of resilicated material and the uniform thickness of the resilicated zone may be explained on the basis of relatively rapid rate of formation of gibbsite from the liberated alumina in relation to a slow rate of synthesis of kaolin from mobilized alumina under small but constant concentration of silica in soil water; the age of the zones of material are presumed to increase with increasing distance from the core of unaltered rock. Other studies of rock weathering where gibbsite is an early product have shown that allophane may also be present (Cady, 1951); this is illustrated in Plate 1A. The possibility exists that kaolin may in time form from allophane and that part or all of the gibbsite may be lost concurrently. Later studies by Alexander and Cady (1962) of weathering of dolerite at Mamou, Guinea, a site also studied by DHoore (1954, p. 52), allow more specific elaboration of the successive changes from rock to primary weathering product to laterite. The rock, on a ridge top, had weathered in tetrahedral form. Surrounding each tetrahedral core were successive shells of weathered material of about equal thickness, and the whole was surrounded by a shell of hard laterite. The rock, the altering margin of the rock, the weathered shells, and the hard laterite were sampled. Detailed chemical and mineralogical studies of these samples reveal certain significant relationships. Total chemical analyses of selected samples are reported in Table VI. Composition of scrapings from the hard rock may have been biased by differential removal of softer more weathered ferromagnesian minerals in preference to harder less-weathered feldspars, causing an apparent loss of aluminum and gain of iron and magnesium. The data do indicate, however, that conversion of ferrous to ferric iron is one of the first reactions. This was seen in thin sections of the material as a change in color associated with staining of the rock with ferric iron. Primary minerals in the shell immediately adjacent to the rock were completely weathered; successive shells outward had essentially the same chemical composition. Bases had been almost completely removed, and if either iron or aluminum is assumed to have been retained without loss, more than 90 per cent of the silica had also been removed. The ratio of aluminum to iron
32
S . SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
remains essentially constant ( 1.23 to 1.29 as sesquioxides) throughout the rock and weathered shells. This indicates a high probability of little or no loss of either, as losses so consistently in equal proportions are most unlikely considering differential solubilities and chemical behavior of the compounds involved. The abrupt increase of combined water and its constancy through the weathering shells are signi6cant. TABLE VI Chemical Analyses of Selected Weathered Shells, of Hard Laterite, and of Parent Dolerite at Mamou, Guinea
Rock
Scrapings of rock margin
Shell adjacent to rock
Outer weathered shell
Hard laterite knobs
Constituent
(%I
(%I
(%I
(%I
(%I
SiO, TiO, AW, Fe,O:, FeO MnO CaO h4gO KzO Na,O
54.0 1.2 15.0 1.8 8.9 0.2 9.3 5.7
45.3 2.1 9.4 23.3 0.5 0.3 5.6 7.7 1.o 0.5 0.1 5.1
10.8 2.0 37.4 29.4 0.5 0.1
16.4 1.8 23.5 45.0 0.5 0.1
0.1 0.1
9.5 2.0 37.5 30.3 0.5 0.1 0.1 0.1
0.2 0.1 0.3 20.4
0.2 20.8 100.3
P,O, H,O (ignition loss)
1.0 2.4 0.1 0.2
-
-
-
99.8
100.4
101.4
0.1
0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 13.3
100.2
The hard outer laterite knobs, however, show apparent gains of silica and iron and losses of alumina and combined water. If these are recalculated on the assumption of constant iron, however, the differences would appear to be almost entirely the result of loss of aluminum and combined water. Microscopic examination and bulk density measurements in relation to chemical composition indicated little change in volume from the rock to the weathered shells. Under the microscope it could be seen that feldspar laths of the original rock had been replaced by gibbsite. These were embedded in a reddish brown mass having the appearance of fine-grained iron-stained clay, unidentifiable as to mineral composition. The laths appeared spongy and were slightly farther apart than in the original rock; opaque minerals also appeared to be slightly more widely spaced than in the rock, suggesting possible volume increase. Bulk densities measured in the weathered shells ranged from 1.2 to 1.5 compared to 2.95 in the fresh rock. Assuming no volume change and either aluminum or iron constant
33
LATERITE
from rock to weathered shells, calculated bulk densities would be approximately 1.2, a figure which compares very favorably with the measured values on samples, particularly if the shrinkage due to airdrying is taken into account. Differential thermal and X-ray analyses of the five innermost weathered shells indicated gibbsite to be the principal crystalline mineral present. A low temperature endotherm indicated the presence of some amorphous material. In the outermost weathered shell, however, crystalline kaolin was present in significant amounts. In the hard laterite knobs, gibbsite was significantly less than in the weathered shells and crystalline kaolin and goethite or limonite were major components. Study of thin sections showed collapse and loss of rock-replica structure as well as loss of gibbsite in the outer weathered shell. Casual examination of these results suggest solution of gibbsite and its combination with silica in solution to form kaolin in the laterite shell. Allocation of silicon, iron, and aluminum to expected mineral species would give the distribution shown in the accompanying tabulation. Mineral species Kaolin Gibbsite Goethite
Weathered shells
Laterite knobs
%
%
22 45 32
35 15 50
It will be noted, however, that the ratios of theoretical kaolin to theoretical goethite are remarkably similar in the two materials. Although neither kaolin nor goethite was detected in appreciable amounts by either X-ray or differential thermal methods in the weathered shells, the constancy of the ratio of their theoretical values and the absence of quartz in amounts that would account for even a small fraction of the silica suggest that materials of their approximate composition were present but not crystallized to an extent that could be detected by the methods available. If this were the case, a simple solution Ioss of 79 per cent of the gibbsite as calculated would give almost the exact composition found in the laterite shell. This study has been reported in some detail, because it illustrates several significant aspects of the problem. First, it illustrates the very large loss of material during weathering, about two-thirds of the original rock. Second, it demonstrates that these changes may occur with little change in volume. Third, it shows dramatically the abrupt change from unweathered rock to a weathered material that has lost almost all its bases and more than 90 per cent of its silica within 1 mm from the rock.
34
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
These are common observations. In addition, however, this study emphasizes the possible role of poorly crystalline material, which is too commonly ignored because of lack of methods for identification, and the possibility that such material even with low amounts of silica may in time acquire continuity of crystal structure, which with loss of aluminum could account for apparent resilication of gibbsite in at least some cases. Further: it introduces the development of the crystalline state and its degree of continuity as a factor in hardening of laterite from weathered material, which will be considered in detail later. In contrast to his observations on basic rocks, Harrison (1933, pp. 60-70) found thick zones of transition from rock to weathered product over granite. Though general trends of changes in chemical composition were similar to those on dolerite, i.e., loss of silica and bases accompanied by concentration of sesquioxides, losses of iron were substantially greater and none of the sections studied had a discrete zone lacking in kaolin. In Table VII losses of major constihients in zones of alteration of a granite TABLE VII Cornpoution of a Granite and Losses of Chemical Constituents in Overlying Zone? of Alteration, Expressed as Per Cent of the Original Constituenta
Constituent
S102 A’20.3
Fe203 and FeO TiO,
MnO h1go CaO KZO Na,O
Per cent in underlying granite 72.35 14.32 1.93 0.70 0.31 1.02 1.24 4.86 2.99
Distance above the rock (feet)
2
2 112
12
% lost
70 lost
70 lost
9
16
41
14 lost 52
-
-
-
-
30b
20 26 100
30 21 100 87 98 74 95
63 11 100 94 99 94 97
0 100 57 73 27 68
87 98 58 95
a Recalculated from original data of Harrison (1933, pp. 71-72, Table 51, Layers 11, VIlI, IX, XVIII, and XXI), assuming aluminum constant. Apparent gain.
have been calculated from Harrison’s data, assuming aluminum constant. Aluminum was present in drainage waters only as traces. From the chemical data and field observations, Harrison concluded that a zone 2 feet thick above the rock was primarily a region of partial weathering of biotite and feldspars resulting in physical disintegration of the rock, small losses of silica, and substantial losses of bases. From 2 to 2% feet above the rock, however, was considered a zone of active ‘‘kaolinization’’ coincident with nearly, but not absolutely complete,
35
LATERITE
weathering of biotite and soda-lime feldspars, processes that were seemingly operative, though slower, throughout the next 10 feet of overlying material. Thus, ‘Icaolinization” and coincident weathering of primary minerals were apparently not complete in a zone more than 12 feet thick above the rock. No gibbsite was observed. It may be inferred that “kaolinization” proceeded directly from the primary minerals or that “resilication,” if it occurred, proceeded concurrently with disruption of the crystal lattice of the primary minerals. Harrison’s (1933, p. 46) studies of weathering of an intermediate igneous rock, quartz diorite, at Blue Mountain indicated gradual transition from rock to weathered product, as in granite, as well as the presence of minute crystalline flakes of gibbsite in the weathering material 2 feet above the rock and possible resilication in a zone immediately above that. The hypothesis for resilication was based on an apparent increase in SiOz calculated on the basis of constant aluminum, a dangerous assumption considering the evidence for potential loss of aluminum described above. Data of Alexander and Cady (1962) on samples collected at the Experiment Station at Samaru, Nigeria, a site also described and illustrated by D’Hoore (1954), indicate formation of kaolin in the zone nearest the granite rock and its dedication in overlying zones. Chemical and mineralogical data are presented in Table VIII. Plate 1B is a thin section from the soft laterite. The character and distribution of quartz revealed by studies of thin sections of the three layers indicated residual origin of the entire profile. TABLE VIII Chemical and Mineralogical Data of Laterite and Underlying Weathered Granite at Samaru, Nigeria Constituent or species SiO, TiO,
H,O (loss on ignition) Kaolinb Gibbsitec Boehmitec Goethiteo 0
b
c
Granite saprolite, 64-120 in.a
Soft laterite,
(%)
(%) 55.2 1.1
32-64 in.a
67.3 0.9 18.4 6.3 7.1 40 Detected
21.4 13.7 8.9 30 Detected
Detected
Detected
-
Depth below surface. Differential thermal analyses. X-Ray diffraction.
-
Hard laterite, 0-32 in.a
(%) 35.6 1.4 18.8 33.9 10.1 15 Detected Detected Moderate
36
S . SNARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
Petrographic studies of thin sections were consistent with the marked decrease of kaolin upward, as indicated by differential thermal analysis, and suggested increases in the proportions of boehmite and gibbsite, as well as goethite, in the surface crust, which were not demonstrated by X-ray diffraction. Quartz in the upper layer was spaced more closely than in the saprolite, suggesting loss of volume upward. If iron is assumed to have remained constant, the loss of S O z from saprolite to hard laterite was 90 per cent of that in the saprolite; the loss of A1203,81 per cent of that in the saprolite. Calculations of this kind, whatever assumptions may be made, indicate losses of S O 2 far in excess of that which can be attributed to weathering of kaolin, but decreasing kaolin upward is clearly evident. Considering that a large part of the Si02 is quartz, some mechanism of external enrichment in iron or a discontinuity in the profile is probable. Humbert (1948) studied weathering of a conglomerate of diabase and granite and found by differential thermal methods 75 per cent kaolin and no gibbsite in residuum of granite fragments and 50 per cent kaolin and a trace of gibbsite in residuum of fragments of diabase. The remainder was not identified, but a slight endothermic maximum between 100” and 200°C. for the diabase suggested some hydrous type of amorphous material. Kaolin pseudomorphs after feldspar without distinguishable gibbsite were observed in the residuum of diabase fragments. Humbert questioned the possibility that pseudomorphic form could be retained if kaolin were formed after crystallization of gibbsite and its subsequent resilication, since there would be associated changes in volume. Consequently, in contrast to views based on the more extensive work of Harrison (1933) and Alexander et d.(1941), he concluded: “It is apparent that primary laterite, as defined by Harrison, will not occur until the clay minerals have been broken by the agents of weathering with release and removal of silica and with accumulation of oxides of aluminum and iron in their hydrated states” (p. 286). This position is not tenable in the light of currently available information in the literature (Gordon and Tracy, 1952; Abbott, 1958; Cady, 1951). Humbert’s work is signscant to this discussion mainly as a case in which rock of highly contrasting composition in the same gross environment weathered to comparable products, suggesting that the presence of kaolin or gibbsite may be governed by the environment in which weathering proceeds, not solely by the character of the parent rock. Mohr and van Baren (1954), in their review of rock weathering, have shown that although many studies have shown gibbsite to be a product of weathering of basic rocks, and kaolin of acid rocks, this is by no means the universal pattern. Lacroix (1923), for example, found gibbsite
LATERITE
37
derived from all feldspar-containing rocks including granite in Madagascar, but in Guinea he found gibbsite from syenites and gabbros and kaolin from granites, gneisses, and mica-schists. Mohr (1944) found both kaolin and gibbsite among the weathering products of andesite in Java whereas Idenberg (Mohr and van Baren, 1954) reported only kaolin on basalt in Sumatra. An amphibolite on Madagascar gave a product rich in gibbsite, whereas a similar rock on the island of Yap weathered to kaolinitic material. Mohr and van Baren concluded that these differences are probably related to conditions governing the composition, movement, and amount of soil water. The authors have observed in Hawaii that in some cases gibbsite appears to form directly as basalt weathers; in others halloysite forms. Both are found in regions of high rainfall, and reasons for the difference are unknown. The foregoing discussion suggests that material within the observed range of composition of laterite may be developed from rock in place by several possible courses of weathering and mineral transformations, all of which involve almost complete removal of bases and at least substantial losses of the combined silica of primary minerals. In the judgment of these authors, hypotheses of the probable course of weathering have been unduly influenced by the techniques available for mineral identification, which leave a major part of initial weathering products unidentified. The evidence appears clear that under some circumstances gibbsite is the first identifiable crystalline material to appear. It is equally clear that kaolin may be identified as a primary decomposition product without evidence of gibbsite as a precursor, and that gibbsite may form by desilication of kaolin. It is also evident that resilication of gibbsite to kaolin is a possible reaction. It is accepted as a well-established mechanism by many workers. It is likely, however, that it may not be as widely prevalent as has been postulated by earlier workers, who have tended to ignore the unidentifiable fraction. Resilication probably involves an intermediate mobilized form of alumina derived from gibbsite, if gibbsite is the precursor. It may also involve unorganized material in which alumina is a major component. Certainly, a consistent stepwise weathering sequence such as that from primary mineral to micalike clay to kaolin to gibbsite, has no basis in fact as the sole source of the material of laterite, though such a sequence may, indeed, have been the course through which some laterite materials have evolved. Jackson et al. (1948) imply such a sequence as a general trend but specifically suggest omission of steps, as in direct formation of gibbsite, and reversals, as resilication of gibbsite to kaolin, under appropriate conditions. The most significant feature, however, is that the mass of unidentified subcrystalline or amorphous material commonly present ( and commonly
38
S. SIVAR4JASINGHAM ET AL.
ignored) in the initial weathering product remains a major potential parent material of identifiable crystalline material upon aging. This with the potential for differential loss, local movement or enrichment of alumina or iron, potential resilication, and potential desilication make most attempts to reconstruct precisely the course of events extremely hazardous. It would appear that any one or all may be major determinants in certain environments.
B. DEVELOPMENT OF MICROSTRUCTURES Alexander et aZ. (1956) have described some of the variety of internal structures revealed by study of thin sections, but the most striking feature of their report is the evidence for movement, segregation, and development of organization of material in a variety of patterns. Some laterites retain some elements of rock structure, including “rough outlines of grain boundaries, organization of minerals following cleavage or twinning of feldspars and pyroxenes or amphiboles, or actual goethite, gibbsite or kaolin pseudomorphs after such rock minerals” ( p. 68). In addition, however, evident reorganization and segregation of constituents suggests local movement of material or, in some cases, enrichment from sources outside the sample sectioned. Their descriptions of these features and additional studies by the authors are reviewed here in some detail. Examples of some of the most common features are illustrated in Plate 1. A latticelike network of oriented Elms of kaolin stained or impregnated with iron oxide is very common on a microscale, and the network does not conform with expected structural elements of possible parent minerals of the original rock. It appears more like the arrangement of the oriented clay in a Latosol. This indicates either movement of part of the kaolin into such a regular pattern of films, which would appear unlikely, orientation by pressure, or crystallization in a regular pattern for some unknown reason. Commonly, some impregnating iron-bearing material, usually goethite if it is crystalline, is superimposed on such films, as in Plate 1, C and D. In many specimens goethite-rich tiny spherical aggregates of clayey material, a few microns in diameter, are assembled in popcorn ball-like clusters or surround pisolites, with which they have optical continuity. The density of packing of these tiny aggregates is associated with variations of apparent degree of impregnation of various parts of the specimen with iron compounds. Oriented films of iron-stained kaolin or pure goethite commonly line pores and cavities. These features suggest either movement of kaolin and iron oxide or crystallization of kaolin and iron oxide in an organized pattern, or both. The iron impregnation so commonly observed is consistent with expected mobility of iron and with the findings of Fripiat and Gastuche (1952) that iron is
LATERITE
39
adsorbed and immobilized by kaolin. Thin sections commonly reveal evidence that such immobilized iron may be set free to move and recrystallize in various forms by destruction of kaolin. Alexander et al. (1956) and Alexander and Cady ( 1962) have found definitely defined separate bodies to be conspicuous in most laterites. Some are true pisolites with concentric structure, commonly with radial cracks indicative of shrinkage upon crystallization from a gel-like state. Pisolites having rhythmic bands of precipitates, such as those illustrated by Humbert (1948) are common. In addition to such structures and pseudomorphs after primary minerals, bodies of various shapes composed of a variety of segregated minerals are commonly present. Some appear to be fillings of former pores or cracks; others cannot be related to physical cavities of any kind. Some are pure goethite or hematite or pure gibbsite; others are amorphous or are unidentifiable mixtures of clay-size material stained with iron oxide ( see Plate 1 ) . The amount of material that has obviously moved, though perhaps only locally, to segregate either as definite crystalline material or as amorphous substances, or selectively to impregnate discrete parts of the matrix, is most impressive in thin sections under magnification. Although Hanlon (1944) suggested that pisolites form at or above a water table, many of the sites from which the observations above were derived could not have had a water table within many feet, and normal movement of soil water must have been the medium of transfer. Some pisolitic structures appear to have formed by crystallization from a gel state, as demonstrated by Bucher ( 1918) with ferric chloride. Schade (1910) demonstrated experimentally that “concretionary” bodies form when a substance passes from the “emulsoid to the solid state. He concluded that the resulting structure is radial if the substance is pure but is concentric if other material, either colloid or crystalloid, is present. Many of the forms observed can be attributed to such transformations, but others cannot. The processes involved are not evident, but the fact of at least local movement and segregation remains and is believed to be an important factor in differentiation of material that hardens from that which will not.
C. HARDENING OF LATERITE Mere concentration of sesquioxides does not insure the capacity to harden. The phenomenon of hardening has been discussed by Alexander et al. (1956), D’Hoore (1954), and Maignien ( 1958). Their data and unpublished work of authors of this review appear to confirm earlier opinions that iron plays a key role in the hardening process. Aluminous laterites do exist, as at site 3 of Table I, and it is known that alumina does
40
S . SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
crystallize and cause hardness. The evidence indicates, however, that this probably involves crystallization of greater quantities of material and longer time intervals than are necessary if iron is involved. Most hardened laterites contain relatively high concentrations of iron, as in the examples of Table IX, Many contain almost no free aluminum, but TABLE IX Silicon, Aluminum, and Iron Oxides and Their Identifiable Mineral Species in Hardened Laterite and Underlying Soft Materiala, b SiO, A,O,
Location Sierra Leone ~
Sierra Leone Guinea
Ivory Coast Dahomey
h igeria Nigeria
Condition Hard Soft Hard Soft Hard Soft Hard Soft Hard Soft Hard Soft Hard Soft
Fe,O,
Qt
( 7 0 ) (70’0) ( % I 7.6 7.8 -
16.4 9.5 21.5 25.1 31.4 39.5 35.6 67.3
-
-
23.6 50.0
51.3 21.4
-
-
-
-
23.5 37.5 20.0 19.3 19.2 25.3 18.8 18.4
45.0 30.3 45.9 43.6 38.5 23.7 33.9 6.3
-
-
-
K1
Gb
Bh
Gt Hm
(70) (70) x
-
x
x
KK
20 65
-
xx
x
-
-
X
xx
X
X
-
xXx10
5
-
-
15 40 20 85
x x
-
-
-
xx x xx
-
x
x
x
- - - - - - - - - - x 20 - - xx x x 40 - x x xx 10 x x xx xx 40 - x x
XYX
XYX
-
-
x
-
-
Alexander and Cady (1962). Abbreviations and symbols: Qt, quartz; Kl, kaolin; Gb, gibbsite; Bh, Boehmite; Gt, goethite; Hm, hematite; x, detected; xx, moderate; xxx, abundant. a
b
few if any contain no free iron oxide. It appears, therefore, that while aluminum may be the major element involved in hardening of some laterites and may contribute significantly to the hardness of many, iron is by far the more common and more important agent, and probably the sole contributor to the rapid hardening, observed upon exposure, of many laterites. In most cases, some minimum amount of iron appears to be a primary requirement for hardening, that amount ranging widely among different materials and under different environments. Mere high concentrations of iron do not, however, ensure hardening. Many examples of earthy iron-rich material that is not hard and does not harden upon exposure are cited in the literature (Sivarajasingham, 1961; Marbut, 1928; Hough and Byers, 1937; Cline, 1955). Soft and hard material of similar iron content may occur in the same profile, as in material of the Ivory Coast (Table IX) .
LATERITE
41
In every case known to the authors, the iron-bearing parts of a hardened laterite have a greater degree of crystallinity or greater continuity of the cystalline phase than the soft materials with which they are associated. The data on goethite and hematite in the six comparisons of TabIe IX illustrate the increase of amount of crystalline material from soft to hard material. Thin-section studies of these materials showed also that the crystalline phase of iron-oxide minerals in the hard material occurs in a framework having a high degree of continuity within the mass, though the exact form may vary widely from specimen to specimen. Such continuity is illustrated in Plate 1D. In most cases, the mineral involved is goethite, though hematite is prominent in some specimens. It would appear, therefore, that conditions that permit segregation and crystallization of iron in a pattern that will provide a rigid framework are essential to the hardening process of most laterites. This implies conditions favorable to the movement of iron, at least locally, and favorable not only for development of crystallinity, but also for development of a significant degree of continuity of the crystalline phase, The change from soft to hard laterite may involve only a small fraction of the mass; indeed, it may involve very little of the iron present. Buchanan’s original laterite, for example, appears from Fox’s (1936) data cited in Table I to be an iron-rich kaolinitic material having few unusual characteristics; yet it hardened quickly upon exposure. Its chemical composition is very similar to that of the laterite from the Ivory Coast reported in Table IX, thin-section studies of which showed the principal change upon hardening to be apparently minor reorganization, as indicated by the following descriptions of thin sections: Soft material: Large parts of the sections are composed of nets of small flakes of oriented iron-stained clay. Much of this oriented clay surrounds balls of more densely impregnated material. The sections contain more heavily impregnated areas than sections of material at greater depth, which does not harden, and the impregnated areas are more dense and have more definite boundaries, suggesting greater organization yet without the continuity of crystallinity that is associated with hardness. The sections contain more quartz per unit area than the deeper material, and this, with the discontinuity of clay nets and clay skins, suggests some breakdown of kaolin accompanied by loss of volume and release of iron that had been adsorbed on the clays. Some red highly birefringent pore linings, crack fillings, and other spots are goethite. Hard material: The main matrix of the thin sections appears quite clayey, and it is difficult to understand why the material is as hard as it is. It does not appear to be much more densely impregnated than the underlying soft material. The red areas are more extensive and more
42
S . SlVARAJAS1A'GIuh.I ET AL.
continuous, however, and show distinct oriented clay nets and some incipient ball-like aggregates. Some almost opaque heavily impregnated areas and definite concretions are present but are not abundant. Oriented clay coats in pores and cracks are less abundant than in the soft material; most of the crack and pore linings are goethite. The refractive index of even the pale parts of the matrix is high, indicating either a high iron content or loss of kaolin. It will be noted that chemical, mineralogical, and micromorphological differences between the soft and the hard material are not great. A decrease in kaolin is associated with an increase in crystallinity and continuity of goethite, which is believed to be the primary cause of the change from soft to hard material. Some materials, outwardly similar to Buchanan's laterite and to the soft specimens reported in Table IX, do not harden on exposure, however. At least some of such seemingly anomalous behavior can be explained by the work of Fripiat and Gastuche (1952), who demonstrated that kaolin has a substantial capacity to absorb and immobilize iron. Kaolin is a very common constituent of the soft material from which hard crusts form, and it has been noted that upon hardening the kaolin present is commonly isolated in pockets, encapsulated in a shell of crystalline goethite, or stained by iron materials. From the work of Fripiat and Gastuche, one would expect that kaolin to which iron in solution has access would have to be saturated with iron before goethite could crystallize. It will be noted in Table IX that the percentage of kaolin in the hardened product is lower in all cases than that in the underlying soft material. This is a common, but not a universal, relationship. Moreover it is impossible to conclude that the observed lower content of kaolin is due to an actual loss, since enrichment in iron from outside sources is obvious in some cases and possible in most. Yet the magnitude of decrease in many cases strongly suggests that kaolin has weathered, as suggested by Jackson et al. (1948). Such weathering of kaolin accompanied by release of iron and crystallization of gibbsite has been found in many thin sections by the authors and is illustrated in Plate IB. Such a loss of kaolin would decrease the capacity of the mass to immobilize iron and would increase the potential for development of the crystalline continuity of goethite so commonly observed. The potential for development of crystalline continuity of goethite could be due to either an absolute loss of kaolin or to absolute accumulation of iron from outside. The magnitude of decrease in kaolin from soft to hard material by itself cannot be used as good evidence to suggest either loss of kaolin or accumulation of iron. D'Hoore (1954) and
LATERITE
43
Frankart et al. (1960) have used electron microscope photographs to decide between the two. Kaolin platelets with frayed edges indicate loss of kaolin as at least one possible mechanism for observed concentration of iron. Kaolin platelets with well-developed hexagonal outlines indicate that the concentration of iron is due to absolute accumulation from outside. Many factors may contribute to mobilization and movement of iron to sites where development of crystallinity results in hardening. Some iron, of course, is in soil solutions at all times, but conditions of high acidity, presence of reducing agents, and presence of complexing or chelating agents would increase the capacity for mobilization. The materials are commonly acid. In some cases iron may move as complexes with organic decomposition products comparable to those demonstrated by Bloomfield ( 1951) . This would be most likely in cases of iron enrichment by seep but is a potential mechanism in many cases. Some amounts of reducing agents from organic or other sources are potential components of most systems. The evidence at hand indicates that although reduction and complexing are among potential mechanisms, other processes also must contribute to mobilization and movement of iron in some laterites. A site in Guinea illustrates the influence of alternate wetting and drying on local rearrangement resulting in hardening. An ornamental ball and bricks for a house had been cut from a nearby laterite quarry 15 years before they were sampled by Alexander in 1951. The ball was exposed to the rain, but the walls of the house were protected by wide overhanging eaves. The walls of the house were soft enough to be cut by a thumbnail 15 years after exposure, but the ball was hard enough to require a moderate blow of a hammer to break it. The apparent difference in conditions was the alternate wetting and drying of the ball under the 70-inch annual rainfall of the area. X-ray and differential thermal analyses showed a decrease in kaolin and an increase in gibbsite, goethite, and hematite from the quarry to the ball. Chemical analyses and petrographic studies showed migration of iron within the ball from the matrix to channel linings and to an exterior shell, which were the hard portions. Comparable local rearrangement is illustrated in Plate 1C. Organic matter as a reducing or complexing agent could not have been a factor in the movement and segregation of iron in this case; only solution and precipitation as the ball was wet by the rains and dried between the rains could have been involved, yet the changes on a microscale had major consequences. This and similar observations, such as hardening on one side of an excavation exposed to the sun while the shady moist side remains soft, leads us to the conclusion that alternate wetting and drying, not drying alone,
44
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
is essential for hardening. This is consistent with the observed hardening after removal of vegetation and exposure of the surface to extreme drying-wetting cycles under the extremes of temperature induced by removal of vegetation. D'Hoore ( 1954, pp. 70-71) has measured temperatures of 50°C. in exposed surface material during the heat of midday while in an adjacent forest the temperature was only 27°C. It is also consistent with the observed tendency for little hardening where rainfall is very low or where rainfall is almost continuous. Not only wetting and drying related to pronounced seasonal distribution of rainfall but also the wetting and drying from rain to rain in cycles of several days or a few weeks should be important. It is also our conclusion that the zone of segregation must be maintained in a condition at or above field capacity for appreciable periods of time. This does not imply the necessity of a water table as such, though a fluctuating water table should contribute to the necessary wetting and drying cycles. The pallid zone so commonly found under laterite is a kaolin-rich, iron-poor layer that appears to be in an environment conducive to relative stability of kaolin and mobility of iron. This appears to be inconsistent with the discussion of immobilization of iron by kaolin in the preceding section, but it is possible that maintenance of the iron in immobilized form is related to wetting and drying cycles. The pallid zone is saturated for varying periods during the rainy season, with conditions favorable to mobilization of iron. As it occurs at a depth where the drying portion of the cycle is absent, or at least not intense, however, conditions for development of some degree of crystallinity may be lacking. The iron is clearly removed to other zones, probably over substantial periods of time. Although the pallid zone may be a source of iron for the laterite above it under some circumstances, its iron is probably lost mainly to water that moves downward or laterally to other zones or areas. The very thick cnists commonly found near the edges of plateau remnants probably derive their iron from such sources. If the hypothesis for a requirement of periodic near-saturation is correct, relatively flat surfaces that would favor accumulation of water during rainy periods would favor laterite development. This is consistent with the observed occurrence of laterite predominantly on flat surfaces. With appropriate rainfall pattern and consequent wetting and drying cycles, however, a flat surface should not be prerequisite; the cases of laterite on low hillocks in Ceylon reported by Prescott and Pendleton (1952) and the instances reported by Mulcahy (1960) substantiate this conclusion.
LATERITE
45
D. DEVELOPMENT OF LATERITE IX PLACEWITHOUT ENRICHMENT FROM OUTSIDE SOURCES There is no doubt that some laterites have formed from residuum of rock weathered in place without enrichment from outside sources, as proposed by Newbold (1844), Glinka ( 189!3), and others. Hanlon ( 1944) observed that some laterites have the same proportions of iron and aluminum oxides as the parent rock and emphasized how unlikely it would be that two constituents of such divergent character could be introduced from outside sources or could be removed in so nearly the same proportions. A similar case has been presented in Table VI from a site in Guinea, and evidence has been given that the final hard product resulted primarily by “relative enrichment” as defined by D’Hoore (1955) through loss of bases and silica, followed by development of the firm skeleton of crystalline goethite from iron inherited from the parent rock. Such local reorganization is consistent with the hypotheses presented in preceding sections, assuming that the original rock contained iron in adequate amounts. Cases in which the property of hardening is weakly expressed in weathered material of rock low in iron are consistent with this view. The processes involved are discussed in detail in preceding sections. It is probable that a high proportion of the laterites of the world owe their character in whole or in part to these processes, but many are clearly affected to a major degree by enrichment from outside sources.
E. ENRICHMENTFROM OUTSIDE SOL~XS Much of the literature postulates that sesquioxides have accumulated from sources outside the immediate laterite zone. Though such enrichment appears not to be essential to the formation of laterite, the evidence clearly indicates that many laterites have been enriched, especially in iron, and such enrichment would be expected to favor development of a material that will harden. There are, in addition, some cases in which low iron content of the original rock would be expected to make enrichment essential. The authors find no basis in fact for postulating that laterite can form only by reorganization in place or only by enrichment.
1. Enrichment by Movement Downward in Solution Though combined silica and bases have been shown to be the dominant constituents that are mobilized from primary minerals and that are subject to loss, percolating waters contain small but significant amounts of aluminum and commonly greater amounts of iron (Table IV) . Profiles in which earthy material of variable thickness overlies the laterite
46
S . SIVAJ3AJhSIXCHAM ET AL.
are very common (Campbell, 1917; Marbut, 1928); indeed various authors, including Blanford as early as 1879, have suggested that laterite at the surface is the result of erosion of overlying earthy material. Such overlying material is commonly lower in iron than the laterite with which it is associated, and analyses of soils associated with laterite commonly show increasing iron with depth ( Marbut, 1928). It would be expected from the work of Bloomfield (1951) that iron in the upper layers would be more mobile than that deeper in the profile as a result of complexing with organic decomposition products. Bloomfield ( 1955) has also suggested immobilization of downward-moving ferrous iron by sorption on ferric iron particles or clays of deeper layers. Enrichment from above by such processes may be a contributing factor in many cases. That it could be the major source of enrichment in many laterites appears most unlikely, however, considering the relative amounts of iron involved in the laterite zone and in the overlying earthy material and the small amounts of organic matter present in these materials.
2. Enrichment by Capillury Rise Maclaren (1906) concluded that the pallid zone is a zone of reduction and solution of iron that moves upward by capillarity to enrich the overlying laterite. Data of Harrassowitz (1926) and others show that iron commonly increases upward from the pallid zone to the laterite, consistent with that hypothesis. Simpson ( 1912) suggested that laterite crusts are essentially efflorescences at the surface due to evaporation of water carrying iron upward by capillary rise. Though it is now recognized that upward capillary movement of water is less than was formerly thought, requiring at least a month to rise the maximum of 2 to 2.5 meters in the most favorable material (Baver, 1956; hlohr and van Baren, 1954), it could be significant immediately adjacent to a zone of saturation, either temporary or permanent, where extended periods without rain are common. Water from such a zone would be expected to carry significant amounts of reduced iron subject to oxidation upon contact with air. To what extent downward-moving water carrying reducing agents during rainy periods would reverse the process is unknown, but unless the forms of iron deposited were highly resistant, the reverse process should be appreciable in humid regions, as suggested by Nye ( 1955b). Enrichment by capiIlary rise would probably be most significant in regions having long dry seasons under special conditions that would maintain a zone of saturation well into the dry period. It would be expected to be effective only a short distance above the saturated zone (Sherman, 1950). Some of the Australian laterites underlain by a slowly permeable
LATERITE
47
siliceous layer may have developed in sediment-filled “bolsons” by capillary enrichment during a former arid regime. The unusual rodlike laterite described by du Preez (1949) in aeolian sands over a laterite sheet at Bornu, Nigeria, was probably enriched by such a process. The rodlike iron-rich forms were found in almost vertical orientation rising from a common base about 18 inches above a hard laterite sheet, suggesting deposition along capillary openings above a water table maintained by the laterite sheet. It is unlikely, however, that capillary rise alone could account for thick laterites or those far above a zone of saturation. Development of thick laterites by this process would require a slowly receding water table. Laterites far above a zone of saturation would be beyond the reach of capillary water. It is probable that capillary rise of iron-bearing water plays some role in enrichment of some part of many laterites but that it is not the major source of iron in most. Though the amounts of iron transported annually might be very small, the aggregate over the time scale visualized could be significant, but the effects should be seen only short distances above a zone of saturation. It is possible that the zone of laterite nodules found commonly in horizons of some soils having restricted internal drainage may originate in this manner (Fig. 2 ) . It is also possible that the zones of nodules in some soils of regions having very pronounced dry seasons, as in nothern Nigeria, may be in part a consequence of some upward movement of water after the rains without a distinct water table as such. Some upward movement does occur after a soil is brought to field capacity and evapotranspiration removes moisture near the surface. In the aggregate over very long periods of time, this could be a significant factor within the narrow zone in which water passes from the liquid to the vapor phase.
3. Enrichment by a Fluctuating Water Table The more widely accepted hypotheses of enrichment from outside have been based on assumption of a fluctuating water table at the upper boundary of which iron is precipitated as a result of oxidation (Campbell, 1917; Marbut, 1932; Mohr, 1944; Pendleton, 1941). Campbell ( 1917) postulated two-stage decomposition of rocks, each stage governed by access of oxygen and vadose water. To facilitate reference to these conditions, he defined three zones: ( 1 ) the zone of nonsaturation, including all the profile above the reach of vadose water; ( 2 ) the zone of intermittent saturation, including all the profile from the highest point to which capillarity raises vadose water to the lowest point at which atmospheric oxygen can penetrate; and ( 3 ) the zone of
46:
S. SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
permanent saturation, including all the profile pervaded by vadose water and below the reach of atmospheric oxygen. One may disregard his hypotheses of weathering, which are not acceptable in the light of modern knowledge. He postulated enrichment of the zone of intermittent saturation, however, by iron carried downward by solutions rich in humic acids from the zone of nonsaturation and by ferrous compounds rising from the zone of permanent saturation. The latter could be precipitated by oxidation at the surface of the water table during the period of its recession or could be precipitated by oxidation from rising capillary solutions slightly above the water table. As the zone of intermittent saturation would be restricted to shallow depths by the requirement of access of oxygen, it was believed that this would account for the shallow occurrence and limited thickness of laterite observed. Development of laterite would not continue downward with recession of the water table because of lack of access of oxygen. If a down-cutting river established a new base level and developed a flood plain, laterite could form on the lower terraces but would not extend into the old land form because of lack of oxygen. Hence, different laterites would not form, one below the other. The hypothesis explained the occurrence of laterite overlying essentially all kinds of rocks on the basis of movement of lateritic constituents into the area in vadose water, whose variations in composition from area to area would also explain the variations of laterite composition observed. CampbelI’s hypotheses have been partial bases of many subsequent ideas on laterite formation, such as those of Marbut (1932, 1928) and Mohr (1944). Greene (1945) used the term “zone of alteration,” though he may have meant the “pallid zone” which implies no distinctive process such as that ascribed to this zone by Campbell. Mohr (1944) and later Mohr and van Baren (1954) used some of Campbell’s concepts, modified in the light of recent knowledge about weathering, to account for development of laterite in volcanic ash in Indonesia. It was proposed that during hydrolysis of volcanic glass and primaiy minerals in the ash, silica-bearing water would dissolve progressively more calcium and magnesium with depth until silica would precipitate, cementing the ash. Ultimately a siliceous hardpan would form, restricting permeability and causing a zone within which a water table would fluctuate. It was proposed that kaolin, gibbsite, and iron oxide would separate in this zone, the iron precipitating in the upper part where the water table fluctuates and the kaolin in the lower (pallid) part, further sealing the mass to movement of water. This was thought to result in a gradually rising water table with iron continuously subject to removal from sites of former precipitation to be redeposited in increasing
LATERITE
49
concentration at the top of the fluctuating water table higher in the profile. Alumina was also thought to move gradually upward in the ascending water table, but at a slower rate than iron; the lower part of the laterite zone would be gibbsitic while the upper part would be characterized by iron and would harden upon exposure. This is in direct opposition to the hypothesis of Nye (1955b) that iron is dissolved from the top of the laterite and enriches underlying layers as normal erosion lowers the zone of saturation. While the explanation of precipitation of iron in the zone of fluctuation by conversion from ferrous to ferric state is consistent with principles of chemistry, the few explanations advanced for enrichment in aluminum from outside sources (Simpson, 1912; Campbell, 1917) are not tenable in the light of modem chemistry. Moreover, ground water proposed as a medium for enrichment in free alumina in the zone of fluctuation is also credited with resilication of gibbsite to kaolin in other zones, a seeming discrepancy that may be rationalized in terms of differing composition or environment but with little obvious basis in known chemical behavior. It would appear that enrichment directly by a fluctuating water table should apply principally to iron. It is not clear exactly how iron would be moved to the top of a fluctuating water table in an extensive plain such as those on which laterite is found. Movement of ground water is downward under the force of gravity, either downward vertically or laterally and downward. According to the Ghyben-Herzberg hypothesis ( Wentworth, 1955), the ground water at the end of a period of rains should have a lower layer consisting of the water present at the beginning of the rains on which should “float” an upper layer of water introduced by the rains and containing less dissolved material. This principle is employed on a practical basis in development of water supplies in Hawaii. Except as ground water moves laterally and downward to lower-lying landscapes and is mixed in the process, the upper layer of a rising ground water table should carry no more material for enrichment than is dissolved during its descent through the overlying soil and laterite zone. The authors can visualize no mechanism for the mechanical mixing implied by hypotheses of ground-water table fluctuation on land surfaces that do not lie adjacent to higher areas. Under these conditions, it is suggested that enrichment by a fluctuating water table would be confined to two principal effects: (1) temporary detention of material dissolved in overlying layers, with consequent increased opportunity for adsorption or precipitation in the zone of enrichment; ( 2 ) accelerated differential dissolution with associated differential losses, local translocation, and segregation of various constituents. Alternating oxidation and reduction,
50
S. SIVARAJASINCHAM ET AL.
hydrolysis, and slow removal of the most soluble end products should be favored in the zone of fluctuation and should “enrich” the zone in lateritic constituents by removal of other components. Thus, it would appear that “enrichment” at sites where ground water is not introduced laterally from higher-lying land may be largely accomplished through transformations in place reinforced by introduction of solutes in water from overlying layers and intensified by the effects of ground-water fluctuation. Under these circumstances, a fluctuating ground-water table would be expected to intensify transformations by increasing the period of time during which conditions favorable for segregation of iron would prevail and by increasing the thickness of the zone in which such segregation would take place.
4. Enrichment b y Laterally Moving Watcr Under appropriate topographic conditions, iron especially, and to some degree aluminum, are clearly transported from one area to another, where they contribute in varying degrees to the sesquioxides of laterites. The increasing concentration of laterite nodules downslope in Fig. 2 is a case in which water moves laterally and downward in relation to topography, contributing to enrichment in the lower-lying positions. Greene (1945) described such a mechanism in relation to the catena concept. Gentle slopes at the base of higher-lying land, marshy areas or low-lying plains that receive water from other areas near or far, and similar topographic positions ( D’Hoore, 1957, pp. 48-51) are frequently sites of enrichment from outside sources. D’Hoore (1954, 1957, pp. 49) has described sites where iron has migrated from high-level laterites to successively younger laterites at lower levels down the slopes of dissection forms. Maignien (1958, pp. 185-187, 214-215) has emphasized the effects of a source of iron in old laterites at high levels on enrichment of new laterite on lower-lying areas. The enormous supply of sesquioxides at higher elevations permits extension of new laterite on nearby lower land much farther and much more rapidly than would be possible if the sole source of iron were that in primary minerals of the parent rock. The very thick laterite crusts found commonly near the edge of laterite-capped plateau remnants are apparently due to the issue of laterally moving iron-bearing water above a very slowly permeable zone at the face of the dissection form. In these cases, as in the Federal District of Brazil (Feuer, 1956, pp. 70-76), the laterite thins rapidly with distance from the face of the cliff and may be absent at some distance into the plateau. This is probably the situation of the very thick laterites
LATERITE
51
reported by Oldham ( 1893 ) . Maignien ( 1958, pp. 184-185) has illustrated "corniche"laterite of this kind in Guinea. Cases of obvious enrichment from ground water are numerous, and the mechanisms of transport are easy to visualize where iron accumulates on a low-lying landscape from higher-lying land. This would include extensive areas of low-level laterite. Enrichment on one landscape, however, implies impoverishment on another higher one. It is probable that the pallid zone of high-level laterites is a major source in some areas, but the iron commonly present in water from weathering rock is probably adequate to account for slow enrichment on the lowlands generally without postulating any special zone of impoverishment. The process is conceived to be slow and wasteful, with small proportions of the reIatively small iron content of drainage waters contributing minute increments of enrichment over very long periods of time. At sites where a decomposing laterite crust or its detritus serves as an extraordinary source of iron, the enrichment is much more rapid.
F. PRINCIPAL PROCESSES INVOLVED The genesis of laterite requires enrichment of a material in iron, or sometimes aluminum. The enrichment required may be small if the material is coarse textured, i.e., if it has a small specific surface to take up the iron coatings; greater accumulations are required if texture is finer. The enrichment may come about by removal of other constituents. The potential for this type of accumulation would appear to be greatest in volcanic ash and basic rocks. The iron may come from outside the laterite layer itself; transport in seeping ground water from higher land is probably the most common external origin. Local enrichment sufficient to cause hardening or to develop a material that will harden on exposure also takes place as a result of local rearrangement of constituents within the layer itself, as illustrated in Plate 1C. Some parts of the mass lose iron; other parts gain. This process results in mottles which may develop into nodules or into a cellular framework arrangement. It can be accompanied, or caused by, weathering of kaolin to free the iron, but kaolin destruction is not required. The material may then have: ( a ) volumes high in iron because clay has been removed and iron has remained; ( b ) volumes high in iron because clay has been removed in adjacent volumes releasing the iron to move into the mottle or nodules; ( c ) volumes high in iron because of iron movement alone with no destruction or movement of clay. The iron may be mobilized by any of several mechanisms. The solubility of the hydrated ferric oxides is very low, probably of the same order
52
S. SIVhR4JASINGHAM ET AL.
of magnitude as that of Fe( OH)3 for which Latimer ( 1952) calculated a At pH 5.0 this implies Fe++ + theoretical solubility product of 6 x’ concentration of the order of lo-”) M. Such small amounts are essentially insignificant at any one time, though they could aggregate significant amounts over the time span involved in laterite development. Considering the relatively high solubility of ferrous forms, reduction is a much more potent mechanism in systems that contain the necessary reducing agents. Wetness alone is not enough; organic decomposition products are the most likely sources of reducing agents. Mobilization as complexes or chelates of organic substances may be more important than reduction. Some mechanism other than simple solution of ferric forms must be involved to account for iron of the order of a few milligrams per liter commonly found in drainage waters. Immobilization of iron at selected sites presents a more difficult problem, but on a macro scale it appears to be associated with sites within the vertical section or horizontally within landscapes where the rate of movement of solutions is slowed and loss of solvent occurs periodically or continuously. This may occur at sites within the landscape where laterally moving water approaches the surface and is reduced in volume by evaporation or transpiration, as where slope gradients change. Abrupt discontinuities in permeability, vertically or horizontally, can slow the rate of movement and enhance the chance of loss of water. Alternating wet and dry seasons, supplemented by transpiration, provide periodic excesses of losses over additions of water in various zones. Within this frame of reference, it would appear that oxidation of the ferrous to the ferric form upon introduction of oxygen, destruction of organic complexing or chelating agents, adsorption of ferrous forms either alone or complexed with organic compounds on ferric forms already present, adsorption on kaolin or similar compounds, and slow accretion on microcrystals with associated energy changes, are the most likely mechanisms of immobilization. There is no evidence that any single mechanism is responsible under all conditions. hlany of the characteristics of the resulting material are the same whether the enrichment was from outside or was a result of local rearrangement. It is difficult to prove the origin by examining a sample except in a case where the matrix material was originally devoid of iron or where it currently contains an abundance of easily weathered minerals that remain encapsulated within iron coatings. These would be obvious cases of external enrichment. Most laterites are developed by a combination of these processes of loss and gain and rearrangement of constituents. There are few clear examples of formation of laterites by a single mechanism.
LATERITE
53
The hardening is also complex. Two processes appear to be involved in addition to gross or local enrichment: Crystallization of iron minerals into continuous aggregates or networks, as in Plate 1D. The iron may be combined with or mixed with clay but the hardest materials contain free crystalline goethite and hematite. Dehydrution is a factor in development of hard crusts. Hydrous, amorphous iron oxides lose water and crystallize as goethite. Old, very hard laterites are high in hematite. Goethite decreases and hematite increases with increasing age and increasing hardness in materials of similar origin. If gibbsite is present there is a correlative increase in boehmite. VI. Geomorphic Relationships
Any comprehensive concept of laterite as it exists must take into account not only the geomorphic relationships of the existing landscapes, but also the geomorphic history of the region. Ruhe (1954) has described in some detail the relationship in the Congo between remnants of a high-lying mid-Tertiary erosion surface capped by a laterite crust from which blocks and gravel are abundantly distributed on the slopes of the dissection forms and on an adjacent lower-lying end-Tertiary surface. Greene ( 1945), Andrew ( 1948), du Preez ( 1949), D’Hoore ( 1954) , Maignien ( 1958) , Mulcahy ( 1961), and others have described similar relationships between high-level laterite of ancient land forms and its detritus in soils and soil material of more recent erosion surfaces. The remnants of ancient erosion surfaces, uplifted and attacked in a new erosion cycle, are conspicuous features of many regions in which laterite occurs and stand as evidence of a more extensive plain cut to the control of a base level long since altered. The present multistepped land forms separated by steep slopes are consistent with the concept of back-wearing and parallel retreat of slopes propounded by Penck (1953) rather than the process involving reduction of slope gradients proposed by Davis ( 1902). As the ancient surface is worn away from the sides, fragments of its cap of laterite are let down upon the new surface, mantling the retreating slope with pieces ranging from huge blocks to fine detrital debris which gravitate to the pediments3 and the new plain in pieces of decreasing size and increasing roundness with distance from the source. An excellent discussion of these geomorphic relationships has been presented by Mulcahy (1962) with special reference to the land forms of western Australia. In this manner the new surface inherits the segregated material of 3 Pediment is used in the sense defined by Ruhe (1956, p. 442) and does not imply an arid region.
54
S . SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
the old, initially by physical transport under the force of gravity. Maignien (1958) and D’Hoore (1954) have shown that such detritus decomposes and serves as a rich source of iron in solution which moves downslope to enrich and cement new laterite at new sites on the lowerlying stepped landscapes, the “absolute accumulation” of DHoore ( 1955). The enrichment process appears to be much more rapid and more intense than that dependent wholly on sesquioxides from weathering primary minerals. Thus, the segregations of ages past tend to perpetuate themselves in part on the new erosion surface. On the footslopes the laterite matrix is an iron-cemented colluvial material frequently containing fragments of the older crust. In some places iron-bearing water moving over cemented material builds successive layers in planes parallel to the surface of the originaI hardened material, and the crust can be split along these planes. Transported material of various origins may be involved in the cemented matrix on different erosion surfaces in the same locality contributing to the wide variety of forms and compositions observed. On low-lying surfaces, detrital material may be found as nodular forms in soil profiles or as nodules cemented in a matrix, though the site may be far from present remnants of the higher and older erosion surface. On extensive low-lying plains, the surface is presumably in equilibrium with the drainage system controlled by the base level of the region. On such surfaces, the kinds of laterite described by Marbut (1932) would be expected to develop in unconsolidated sediments over the water table of the region. If one applies the geomorphic relationships of the present to the landscapes of the distant past, some of the variety found in high-level laterites may be explained. From the concept of succesive erosion surfaces presented by Ruhe (1954) and others and the concept of landscape inversion presented by Bonnault ( 1938), it is reasonable to believe that all the high-level landscape remnants of today were not always parts of featureless plains; at least some may have been low points in a plain or low-level surfaces among older high-level remnants. There is ample evidence of discontinuities vertically in the surficial mantles of such plains. Stone lines representing buried erosion surfaces are reported with increasing frequency ( Ruhe, 1959). Milne ( 1940), for example, found evidence of “a superposed dual morphology” when he visited some of Harrison’s sites, reporting not only truncation but also rejuvenation due to a change of ground-water relations. Indeed, mixing and translocation of surficial material appears to be the rule rather than the exception on old land surfaces. The fact that they are ancient erosion surfaces, in itself, implies a still higher surface, pediment development, and some inheritance of whatever material originally lay above them.
LATERITE
55
One cannot regard them as the beginning, but as one stage in the endless transformations to which the earth‘s surface is subjected. If viewed in this perspective, it is reasonable to expect that many of the high-level forms were subjected to the same kinds of conditions of mass movement, lateral drainage, and enrichment observed on low-lying erosion surfaces today. VII. Softening of Laterite
Laterite does decompose; even it is not permanent in the landscape, though hard thick laterite crusts may persist for very long periods-even measured in geologic time. In some cases, decomposition occurs in a remarkably short period, as in the case described by Rosevear (1942) where a measurable reversal of hardening was accomplished under a teakwood plantation in 16 years. Maignien (1958, 1959) and DHoore (1954, 1957) have discussed decomposition of laterite as a normal process in the cycle of transfer of lateritic constituents from high- to lowlevel landscapes. Alexander et al. (1956) reported examples of disintegration or softening of laterite, including some of the same sites observed by Maignien and D’Hoore. Kellogg and Davol (1949, p. 8) considered that, although hard laterite is more resistant to mechanical and chemical breakdown than are rocks like granite, even it may weather to material of new soils or may contribute to colluvial or alluvial deposits in which new soils may form. Studies of soiI material over a disintegrating crust (Alexander et aE., 1956) showed that coarse fractions retained the composition of the underlying laterite but that fine fractions contained more silica and bases, related at least in part to introduction of fresh material from outside sources. Gottmann (1942) cited conclusions of Scaetta that introduction of weathering rock material would soften laterite, in direct contrast to Vine’s (1949) suggestion that introduction of aeolian material contributes to laterite development. Studies of a hard crust and a softened boulder from it (Alexander et al., 1956) showed increases of silica and iron and decreases of aluminum and combined water on a percentage basis. Thin-section studies and mineralogical analyses revealed an increase in porosity, removal of gibbsite near large pores and cavities, appearance of traces of kaolin, and conspicuous rearrangement of constituents in the softer specimens. Some parts were highly depleted of iron while others were very densely impregnated, suggesting that the softening was associated with a decrease in continuity of the impregnating material. The authors suggested that the impregnated parts would become residual nodules in a softened matrix that could be penetrated by water and roots. Studies by the same workers on detrital laterite
56
S . SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
fragments on low-lying areas in the Ivory Coast revealed loss of boehmite and gibbsite, with loss of iron from some fragments and apparent segregation of goethite in others within the same horizon. Kaolin was the principal clay mineral, and whether the aluminum of gibbsite and boehmite had been lost or had been silicated to kaolin could not be determined, but loss appears more likely. Iron was clearly mobile, but how much was lost and how much resegregated was unknown. These and similar observations indicate that laterites soften when processes comparable to reversal of the hardening mechanisms destroy the continuity of crystallinity. A decrease in amount, and especialIy in continuity, of crystalline material is most striking. Silication of aluminum compounds to kaolin may occur. Loss of aluminum is evident; loss or redistribution of iron and increase in hydration of iron compounds seem to be involved. Maintenance of a moist condition and actively growing vegetation appear to be associated with the process where it has been reported, and it is possible that the complexing of iron by organic compounds is involved. The time intervals involved in such softening are unknown, but from a very small and inadequate number of observations, it would appear that improvement of some areas that have had some degree of hardening may be possible in reasonable time providing there is material suitable for establishment and growth of trees. Improvement does not appear to be feasible on bare, hard laterite lacking soft parts with waterholding capacity great enough to support vegetation. Furthermore, the presence of encapsulated unweathered minerals from which plant nutrients may be available may be a critical factor in attempts to soften the material, and in its usefulness if it can be softened. The practicality of attempts to soften crusts remains very uncertain; that crusts do soften under natural processes over long time spans is a certainty. Prevention of hardening of laterite that is still soft is a more feasible enterprise. Use of the land in a manner that prevents erosion of the protecting unconsolidated soil cover, minimizes exposure to high temperatures and dehydration, and provides the mechanical disruption of extensive root systems is clearly helpful. Examples of hardening under opposite conditions are abundant. In some cases, maintenance of such areas in forest appears to be the only feasible use; in others, carefully managed agriculture is possible. Either is very difficult to accomplish in many areas in the face of mounting population pressure, ~FEFIENCES
Abbott, A. T. 1958. Econ. Geol. 63, 842-853. Alexander, L.T.,and Cady, J. G. 1962. Genesis and Hardening of Laterite. U . S. Dept. Agr. Tech. Bull. (in press).
LATERITE
57
Alexander, L. T., Hendricks, S. B., and Faust, G. T. 1941. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 6, 52-57. Alexander, L. T., Cady, J. G., Whittig, L. D., and Dever, R. F. 1956. Trans. Intern. Congr. Soil Sci. 6th Congr. Paris 1956 E, 67-72. Andrew, G. 1948. In “Agriculture in the Sudan” (J. D. Tothill, ed.), pp. 102-103. Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York. Aubert, G. 1950. Trans. Intern. Congr. Soil Sci. 4th Congr. Amsterdam 1950 3, 127-128. Babington, B. 1821. Trans. Geol. SOC. London 6, 328-329. Baldwin, M., Kellogg, C. E., and Thorp, J. 1938. Yearbook Agr. U . S. Dept. Agr. Soils and Men pp. 973-974. Bauer, M. 1898. Neues Iahrb. Mineral. 2, 163-219. Baver, L. D. 1956. “Soil Physics,” 3rd ed., pp. 247-261. Wiley, New York. Beater, B. E. 1940. Soil Sci. 60, 313-329. Bennett, H. H., and Allison, R. V. 1928 “The Soils of Cuba.” Tropical Plant Research Foundation, Washington, D. C. Benza, P. M. 1836. Madras 1. Lit. and Sci. 4, 241. Berry, L., and Ruxton, B. P. 1959. J. Soil Sci. 10, 54-63. Blackie, W. 1949. Commonwealth Bur. Soil Sci. (Gt. Brit.) Tech. Commun. No. 46, 54-58. Blanford, W. T. 1859. Mem. Geol. Survey India 1, 290. Blanford, W. T. 1879. In “Manual of Geology of India” (H. B. Meldicott and W. T. Blanford, eds.), Part I, Chapt. 15, pp. 348-370. Geol. Survey India, Calcutta. Bloomfield, C. 1951. J . Soil Sci. 2, 196-211. Bloomfield, C. 1955. 1. Soil Sci. 6, 284-292. Bonifas, M. 1959. Mbm. serv. carte gbol. Alsace et Lorraine No. 17. Bonnault, D. 1938. Bull. serv. Mines A. 0. F. No. 2, 51-52. Briggs, R. P. 1959. Tram. 2nd Caribbean Geol. Conf. Mayaguez 1959, pp. 103119. Bryan, W. H. 1952. Univ. Queensland Papers Dept. Geol. Reprint No. 46. Buchanan, F. 1807. “A Journey from Madras through the Countries of Mysore, Canara, and Malabar,” Vol. 2, pp. 436-460 ( 3 volumes in all). East India Company, London. Bucher, W. H. 1918. J. Geol. 26, 563-569. Buist, G. 1860. Trans. Bombay Geograph. SOC. 16, 22. Byers, H. G., Kellogg, C. E., Anderson, M. S., and Thorp, J. 1938. Yearbook Agr. U . S. Dept. Agr. Soils and Men pp. 948-978. Cady, J. G. 1951. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 16, 337-342. Campbell, J. M. 1917. Mineral. Mag. 17, 67-77, 120-128, 171-179, 220-229. Carter, H. J. 1852. J. Bombay Asiatic SOC. 4, 199. Clark, J. 1838. Madras 1. Lit. and Sci. 8, 334-346. Cline, M. G. 1955. U . S . Dept. Agr. Soil Survey Ser. 1939 No. 26, pp. 77-78, 433-437. Cole, R. 1836. Madras I. Lit. and Sci. 4, 100-108. Crook, T. 1909. Geol. Mag. [V] 6, 524-526. Davis, W. M. 1902. J. Geol. 10, 77-111. D’Hoore, J. 1954. Publs. inst. natl. btude agron. Congo Belge sbr. sci. 62. D’Hoore, J. 1955. African Soils 3, ( l ) ,67-81. D’Hoore, J. 1957. C.S.I.R.O. (Australia) Div. Soils Trans. No. 3101.
58
S . SIVARAJASINGHAM ET AL.
du Bois, G. C. 1903. Mitt. Mineral Petrogr. 22, 1-61. du Preez,J. W. 1949. BuU. agr. Congo Belge 40, 53-66. Evans, J. W. 1910, Geol. Mag. [V] 7 , 189-190. Falconer, J. D. 1911. “The Geology and Geography of Northern Nigeria.” Macmillan, London. Fermor, L. L. 1909. Mem. Geol. Suruey India S7, 1039-1040. Fennor, L. L. 1911, Geol. Mag. [V] 8, 454-462, 507-516, 559-568. Feuer, R. 1956. Ph.D. Thesis, pp. 68-82. Cornell University, Ithaca, New York. Fernando, L. J. D. 1948. Bull Imp. Inst. London 66, 303-325. Foote, R. B. 1876. Mem. Geol. Survey India 12, 208. Fox, C. S. 1936. Records Geol. Suroey India 69, 389-422. Frankart, R., Gastuche, M. C., and Fripiat, J. J. 1980. Publs. inst. natl. ktude agron. Congo Belge skr. sci. 86. Fripiat, J. I., and Gastuche, M. C. 1952. Pub&. inst. natl. ktude agron. Congo Belge ser. sci. 64. Giinka, K. D. 1899. Trans. Russian Imp. Mineral SOC. [Z] 37, 333-341. Glinka, K. D. 1927. “The Great Soil Groups of the World and Their Development” (C. F. Marbut, Transl. ). Edwards, Ann Arbor, Michigan. Cordon, M., Jr., and Tracey, J. I., Jr. 1952. Am. Insf. Mining and Metal. Engrs. Symposium ( St. Louis 1951) p. 27. Gottman, J. 1942. Geograph. Rev. 32, 319-321. Greene, H. 1945. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 10, 392-395. Hallsworth, E. G., and Costin, A. B. 1953. J . Soil Sci. 4, 24-45. Hanlon, F. N. 1944. I. PTOC. Roy. SOC. New South Wales 78, 94-112. Hardy, F., and Rodrigues, S. 1939. Soil Sci. 48, 361-384. Harrassowitz, H. 1926. Fortschr. Geol. u. Pakzeontol 4, (14), 253-566. Harrassowitz, H. 1930. I n “Handbuch der Bodenlehre” (E. Blanck, ed.), Vol. 111, pp. 387-436. Springer, Berlin. Harrison, J. B. 1910. Geol. Mag. [V] 7 , 439452, 488-495, 553-562. Hamson, J. B. 1933. “The Katamorphism of Igneous Rocks Under Humid Tropical Conditions.” Imperial Bur. Soil Sci., Harpenden, England. Holland, T. H. 1903. Geol. Mag. [IV] 10, 59-69. Holland, T. H. 1905. Records Geol. Suroey India S2, 175-184. Holmes, A. 1914. Geol. Mag. fVI] 12, 529-537. Hough, C. J., and Byers, H. G. 1937. U. S . Dept. Agr. Tech. Bull. No. 584. Humbert, R. P. 1948. Soil Sci. 65, 281-290. Jackson, M. L., Tyler, S. A., Willis, A. L., Bourbeau, G. A., and Penington, R. P. 1948. 1. Phys. & Colloid Chem. 62, 1237-1260. Jessop, R. W. 1960 J. Soil Sci. 11, 106-113. Joachim, A. W. R., and Kandiah, S. 1935. Tsop. Agriculturalist (Ceylon) 84, 323-334. Joachim, A. W. R., and Kandiah, S. 1941. Trop. Agrieulturakst (Ceylon) 96, 67-75. Jones, B. 1943. Farm and Forest 4, 15-23. Kelaart, E. F. 1853. Edinburgh New Phil. I. 64, 24. Kellogg, C. E. 1949. Commonwealth Bur. Soil Sci. ( G t . B r i t . ) Tech. Commun. NO. 46, 76-84. Kellogg, C. E., and Davol, F. D. 1949. Publs. in.st. natl. ktude agron. Congo Belge s8r. sci. 46. King, W., and Foote, R. B. 1864. Mem. Geol. Survey India 4, 257-267.
LATERITE
59
Lacroix, A. 1923. “Mineralogie de Madagascar.” Vol. 111, Librairie Maritime et Coloniale, Pans; cited by Mohr and van Baren, 1954. Lake, P. 1890. Mem. Geol. Survey India 24, 217-233. Latimer, W. M. 1952. “The Oxidation States of the Elements and their Potentials in Aqueous Solutions,” p. 224. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Leneuf, N. 1959 “L’Alteration des Granites Calo-Alcalins et des Granodiorites en Cote d‘Ivoire Forestiere et les Sols qui en sont derives.” ORSTOM, Paris. McGee, W. J. 1880. Geol. Mag. [N. S.] 7, 310. Maclaren, M. 1906. Geol. Mag. [V] 3, 536-547. Maignien, R. 1958. Mem. Seru. Carte Geol. Alsace Lorraine 16. Maignien, R. 1959. African Soils 4, ( 4 ) , 4-41. Mallet, F. R. 1881. Records Geol. Survey India 14, 139-148. Mallet, F. R. 1883. Records Geol. Survey India 16, 103-118. Marbut, C. F. 1928. “Soils, their Genesis and Classification.” Lectures U.S.D.A. Graduate School published by Soil Sci. SOC.Am., 1951. Marbut, C. F. 1932. Trans. Proc. 2nd Intern. Congr. Soil Sci. 6, 72-80. Martin, F. J., and Doyne, H. C. 1927. J . Agr. Sci. 17, 530-546. Martin, F. J., and Doyne, H. C. 1930. 1. Agr. Sci. 20, 135-143. Milne, G. 1940. “A Report on a Journey to Parts of the West Indies and the United States for the Study of Soils.” Govt. Press, Dar es Salaam, Tanganyika. Mohr, E. C. J. 1944. “The Soils of Tropical Regions with Special Reference to the Netherlands East Indies” (H. L. Pendleton, Trans!). Edwards, Ann Arbor, Michigan. Mohr, E. C. J., and van Baren, F. A. 1954. “Tropical Soils.” Interscience, New York. Mulcahy, M. J. 1960. J . Soil Sci. 11, 206-225. Mulcahy, M. J. 1961. Z . Geomorphol, New Series, 211-225. Newbold, T. J. 1844. J . Asiatic SOC. Bengal 13, 984-1004. Newbold, T. J. 1846. J . Roy. Asiatic SOC. 76, 227-240. Nye, P. H. 1954. J . Soil Sci. 5, 7-21. Nye, P. H. 1955a. J. Soil Sci. 6, 51-62. Nye, P. H. 1955b. J . Soil Sci. 6, 63-72. Oldham, R. D. 1893. “A Manual of the Geology of India,” 2nd ed., pp. 369-390. Geol. Survey India, Calcutta. Ollier, C. D. 1959. J . Soil Sci. 10, 137-148. Palache, C., Berman, H., and Frondel, C. 1944. “Dana’s System of Mineralogy,” 7th ed., Vol. 1, p. 667. Wiley, New York. Penck, W. 1953. “Morphological Analyses of Landforms” (H. Czech and K. C. Boswell, Transls.). St. Martins, New York. Pendleton, R. L. 1936. Am. Soil Survey Assoc. Bull. 17, 102-108. Pendleton, R. L. 1941. Geograph. Reu. 31, 177-202. Pendleton, R. L., and Sharasuvana, S . 1942. Soil Sci. 64, 1-26. Pendleton, R. L., and Sharasuvana, S. 1946. Soil Sci. 62, 423-440. Prescott, J. A. 1931. C.S.I.R.O. ( A u s ~ T u ~Bull. ~ u ) NO. 62. Prescott, J. A. 1954. J . Soil Sci. 6, 1-6. Prescott, J. A., and Pendleton, R. L. 1952. Commonwealth BUT. Soil Sci. ( G t . Brit.) Tech. Commun. No. 47. Radwanski, S. A., and Ollier, C. D. 1959. J . Soil Sci. 10, 149-168. Raychaudhuri, S. P. 1941. fidian 1. Agr. Sci. 2, 220-235. Rosevear, R. D. 1942. Fann and Forest 6 ( 1 ) .
60
S . SNARAJASINCHAM ET AL.
Ruhe, R. 17. 1954. Publs. inst. w t l . ktude agron. Congo Belge sSr. sci. 59. Ruhe, R. V. 1956. Soil Sci. 82, 441-455. Ruhe, R. V. 1959. Soil Sci. 87, 223-231. Satyanarayana, K. V. S., and Thomas, P. K. 1961. 1. Indian SOC. Soil Sci. 8, 110. Schade, H. 1910. Kolloidschem. Beih. 1, 375-390. Scrivenor, J. B. 1909. Geol. Mag. [V]6,574-575. Sherman, G. D. 1950. Pacific Sci. 4, 315-322. Simpson, E. S. 1912. Geol. Mag. [5]9, 399-406. Sivarajasingham, S. 1961. Ph.D. Thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York. Soil Survey Staff. 1951. “Soil Survey Manual.” U. S. Dept. Agr. Handbook NO. 18. U. S. Govt. Printing Office, Washington, D. C. Soil Survey Staff. 1960. “Soil Classification, A Comprehensive System,” 7th Approximation. U. S. Govt. Printing Office, Washington, D. C. Stephens, C. G . 1946. C.S.I.R.O. (Australia) Bull. No. 206. Stirling, A. 1825. Asiatic Research 15, 163-338. Theobald, W. 1873. Mem. Geol. Survey India 10, 244. Vine, H. 1949. Commonwealth Bur. Soil Sci. (Gt. Brit.) Tech. Commun. NO. 46. Voysey, H. W. 1833. 1. Asiatic SOC. Bengal 2, 298-305. Waegemans, G . 1954. Publs. inst. natl. e‘tude agron. Congo Belge skr. sci. 60. Walther, J. 1889. Verhondl. Ges. Erdkunde 16, 318-328. Waither, J. 1915. Z. deut. geol. Ges. 67B, 113-140. Walther, J. 1916. Petennanns Geograph. Mitt. 62, 1-53. Warth, H.,and Warth, F. J. 1903. Geol. Mag. [IV] 10, 154-159. Wentworth, C. K. 1955. U . S . Dept. Agr. Soil Suruey Ser. I939 No. 25, 15-18. Whitehouse, F. W. 1940. Unb. Queensland Papers Dept. Geol. 2 (1). Wingate, G . 1852. Trans. Bombay Geograph. SOC. 10, 287. Woolnough, W. G. 1918. Geol. Mag. [6] 5, 385-393. Woolnough, W. G. 1927. Proc. Roy. SOC. New South Wales 61, 1-53. Wynne, A. B. 1872. Mem. Geol. Survey India 9, 68-70.
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN THE UNITED STATES
.
.
. .
C Roy Adair. M D. Miller. and H M Beachell United States Department of Agriculture. Beltsville. Maryland. and the University of California. Davis. California
Page I . Introduction ................................................ 61 A . Importance as a Food Crop and Uses in the United States 61 and Elsewhere .......................................... B. History of Rice Growing in the United States ................ 62 I1. Rice Culture in the United States .............................. 68 A. Soil and Climatic Requirements .......................... 68 B. Cropping Systems ........................................ 69 C . Land Preparation ........................................ 71 D . Irrigation and Drainage .................................. 73 E . Seeding Rice ............................................ 77 F. Crop Fertilization ........................................ 79 G . Harvesting. Drying. Storing. and Milling .................... 83 I11. Rice Field Pests .............................................. 85 A . Weeds .................................................. 85 B. Diseases ................................................ 88 C . Insects and Other Pests .................................... 89 IV Origin. Botany, and Genetics of Rice ............................ 92 A . Origin and Species of Oym 92 B. Description of the Rice Plant .............................. 94 95 C . Genetics. Cytology. and Linkage Groups in Rice .............. V. Rice Breeding and Improvement in the United States .............. 96 A . History of Rice Breeding in the United States ................ 96 B. Current Objectives and Methods for the Rice-Breeding Program in 97 the United States ........................................ C . Results of the Rice-Breeding Program ...................... 99 References .................................................. 104
.
1
A . IMPORTANCE AS
.
introduction
FOODCROPAND USESIN THE UNITEDSTATES AND ELSEWHERE Rice is one of the most important food crops in the world. and it has been so for a long time. as agriculture and rice or food and rice are synonymous in the languages of China and India. its most probable A
61
62
C. ROY ADAIR,
M. D. MILLER, AND H. 1%. BEACHELL
area of origin. Rice is widely distributed throughout tropical, subtropical, and temperate zones of all continents. Asia produces over 90 per cent of the total world crop. Communist China, which produced about 160,OOO million pounds in 1960, leads in total production. North America is the fourth continent in production, and the United States is second to Brazil in the Western Hemisphere. Although the Agricultural Statistics, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 1960, showed that the average annual wheat production in the United States was about 13.5 times as much as rice during the 5-year period 1950-1954432,261,730 tons compared with 2,387,350 tons-the world production of these two important food crops was about equal. The average annual world production of rough rice was 197,962,000 tons compared with 209,400,000 tons of wheat. Since more wheat than rice is used for animal feed and seed, it is likely that as much rice as wheat is consumed by humans. Rice is the principal item in the diet of most of the people in southeast Asia and the adjacent islands and in some Latin American countries. Rice for food is used primarily as a whole-grain food product although the by-products from milling are used in other food products and beverages. During the milling process the hulls, bran, and embryos are removed. The bran and embryos are used primarily for animal feed. The whole grain (head rice) and larger pieces of broken grains (second heads) are used as table rice and processed cereals, the smaller pieces of broken kernels may be used for cereal products (grits) or ground into flour, and the smallest pieces of broken kernels (brewers' rice) are used in the brewing industry. Highly milled rice is low in protein and vitamins compared with some cereals. Milled rice does, however, contain 5 to 10 per cent protein with a good complement of the essential amino acids. Although highly milled rice is very low in vitamins, parboiled or slightly undermilled rice contains an appreciable amount of the B complex (Kik and Williams, 1945, p. 60).
B. HISTORY OF RICEGROWIK'C. IN THE UNITED STATES 1. Acreage and Prodtiction The history of rice growing in the United States and the method of culture used have been discused by many authors. Some of these are Copeland ( 1924), Gray and Thompson ( 1941 ) , Efferson ( 1952), Van Royen (1954), and Beachell (1959). Other authors have discussed phases or areas of rice culture in the United States. Several of these papers are referred to throughout this article. Rice has been grown as a commercial crop in the United States since
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE I N UNITED STATES
63
the latter part of the seventeenth century. It was one of the crops the colonists tried to grow soon after settling at Jamestown, Virginia. Gray and Thompson (1941) reported that early records of the Virginia colony mention the intention to plant rice in 1609 and in 1622 a trial planting was made. Some upland rice for domestic use was grown in North Carolina and South Carolina before 1680. Successful rice culture was not established in the colonies until somewhat later than this. According to Salley (1936), Captain John Thurber, master of a New England brigantine, put in at Charles Town Harbor sometime prior to 1686. From him, Dr. Henry Woodward got about a peck of goldhulled seed rice obtained from Madagascar. Dr. Woodward planted the seed, had a very good yield, and distributed it to his friends for further planting. By 1690 the production of rice had so advanced that the planters asked that it be specified as one of the commodities with which they might pay their quitrents, and by 1700 its production was so great that there were not enough ships in Charles Town to export it all. Another version regarding the introduction of rice growing in the Colonies claims that Governor Langrave T. Smith obtained rice from a ship sailing from Madagascar that was forced to stop at Charles Town in 1694. This is probably an embellishment of the facts as it is known that rice had been in continuous production for several years before that date. Gray and Thompson (1941, p. 278) stated, “while rice was undoubtedly cultivated in South Carolina before 1694, the various accounts point to 1694 as a significant date, probably because varieties of superior quality were introduced which were better adapted to the physical condition of the Colony than were the varieties previously employed.” Thus it must be that 1685, a date frequently given, was the approximate date of the starting of continuous rice culture in the Colonies and that 1694, a date also frequently given, was about the time rice culture was firmly established. Rice production data by States are given for 1840, 1850, 1860, and 1870 and acreage and production for each tenth year from 1880 to 1960 in Table I. Holmes (1912) summarized the available rice production statistics for 1717 to 1911. He reported that the production in 1718 was over 17 million pounds of rough (paddy) rice, so there were about 12,OOO acres that year as 1350 pounds per acre was about the average yield. Rice production in the United States has fluctuated from year to year, and it has been influenced by economic conditions and production in ather countries and by wars, but data in Table I1 show that the trend in production has been upward recently. The production in 1960 was 53,363,000 bags of 100 pounds each, or about 300 times the production in 1718. The United States was a net exporter of rice until the Wax between
TABLE I Acreage and Production of Rice in the United States for Selected Years from 1840 to 1980k Year
Acreage ;tnd production
Total
Cal.
Miss.
N.C.
36.04 44.25 0.88 0.26 63.31 158.54 0.64 42.0 0.34 231.88 0.62 0.009 84.4 0.2 1.08 0.07 756.45 8.7 0.02 201.7 71.87 0.09 1,727.32 0.1 264.8 60.0 371.2 3,932.1 1.4 1,080.0 5,746.0 281.0 162.0 175.0 700.0 4,299.3 3,717.9 3,858.8 11,340.0 186.0 110.0 172.0 491.0 4,396.0 3,272.0 3,678.5 8,617.0 291.0 118.0 191.0 469.0 4,248.0 4,315.0 8,442.0 7,490.0 482.0 238.0 342.0 551.0 13,248.0 7,780.0 10,882.0 11,568.0 417.0 288.0 383.0 458.0 12.639.0 13,053.0 12.927.0 13.248.0
7.77 27.20 8.09 3.75 3.50 17.19 1.5 6.77 2.1 7.39 2.8 37.8 3.0 41.8
28.2 605.91 54.66 1,599.3 75.94 1,191.0 323.05 20.59 10.85 78.39 56.09 520.78 42.2 12.2 303.39 58.46 22.3 77.7 78.93 473.60 17.0 1.0 160.8 12.2 7.0 78.8
Ark.
La.
Texas
____I__
1840'A 1850" 1860" 187oC 1880 1890" 1900c
1910 1920 19301 1940f 19509 19SOn
l'rocluction'l Production Production Production Acrcagei Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreaee Productionj
808.41 2,153.13 1,871.67 736.35 174.17 1,101.31 161.3 1,285.9 351.3 2,837.23 722.8 11,029.5 1,336.0 23,429.8 959.0 19,934.5 1,069.O 24,495.0 1,620.0 38,889.0 1,595.3 531363.0
0.05 0.63 0.17 0.73
-
-
-
S.C.
7.0 189.0 45.0 1.350.0
_.
-
-
Ga. 123.85 389.50 525.08 222.77 34.97 253.70 18.1 145.58 22.0 111.75 4.0 39.6 4.0 46.8
-
Fla.
Ala.
4.81 1.49 10.75 23.12 2.24 4.93 2.23 4.02 1.58 2.55 12.95 8.11 0.8 1.8 10.12 3.99 23.0 5.4 9.27 22.54 0.9 1.o 8.8 11.2 1.0 3.0 32.4 14.0
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
P
E
-
H 3I
l?
Minor production reported in Ky., Tenn., Ill., Mo., \'a. b Minor Droduction renorted in Tenn., Mo., Va. c Minor production reported in Tenn. d Minor production reported in Va. e Minor iroduction reported in Hawaii and Va. f Minor production reported in Mo., Miss., S.C., Ga., Fla., Ala., N.C. a
Minor production reported in Mo., S.C., Ill., Tenn., Fla., Okla., Ariz., N.C. h .I000bags ( 100-pound bags). i 1000 acres, harvested. j Preliminary report. k Census Reports 1840-1900; U.S.D.A. Statistics 1910-1960. g
P
TABLE I1 Annual United States Rice Acreage and Production by States, 195619606 State Arkansas Louisiana Mississippi Texas California Other Statesa Total a b 0
Acreage and production Acreage Productionb Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production Acreage Production
1956 391,136 11,178.8 463,137 11,378.9 45,414 1,267.2 416,245 11,083.4 293,511 10,379.1 9,062 188.3 1,618,505 45,475.7
1957 337,246 10,355.4 427,990 10,660.7 33,073 999.8 346,434 10,666.5 231,807 9,602.9 6,678 152.8 1,383,228 42,438.2
1958 340,187 10,907.9 423,864 11,406.1 41,773 1,130.0 381,554 12,284.0 260,940 11,657.2 6,683 182.8 1,455,001 47,568.0
1959 391,901 12,642.9 463,437 12,915.7 45,242 1,355.5 416,054 13,388.0 291,511 11,944.2 8,897 267.5 1,617,052 52,513.8
Includes Florida, Illinois, Missouri, Oklahoma, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee. 1000 bags (100-pound bags). Statistics compiled by the Rice Millers Association, New Orleans, Louisiana.
1960
Average
385,982 12,583.4 462,573 13,161.0 45,139 1,297.7 417,039 13,484.6 288,458 12,921.8 9,226 290.6 1,608,417 53,739.2
369,291 11,533.7 448,200 11,904.5 42,130 1,210.0 395,465 12,181.3 273,246 11,301.0 8,109 216.4 1,536,441 48,347.0
E? 3
2
*
3 2
5 g 2!
9
8 ?
h
i
66
C.
ROY ADALR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. B E A W L L
the States (1861), but from that time until 1916 this country was a net importer. This position is now changed and in recent years the United States has been third or fourth in exports among rice-producing nations. The major rice-producing area of the United States was in South Carolina, North Carolina, and Georgia until about 1890. During 1884, 1885, and 1886, experimental plantings of rice were made in the prairie section of southwest Louisiana, using cultural methods and machinery employed in wheat production in the North Central States. After certain adjustments and modifications of these machines and methods had been made, and with irrigation water from streams, rice was grown successfully in this area (Knapp, 18%). Rice production expanded rapidly in the coastal prairies of southwest Louisiana and adjacent Texas. Production then declined rapidly in the southeastern States. Doar (1936), writing on rice production in South Carolina and the expansion of production in Louisiana, stated, “with these [rice producers in Louisiana], able to use machinery of all kinds, we could not compete with our system of hand labor, nor could we produce rice as cheaply as they.” A limited acreage of rice was grown along rivers in southeast Arkansas as early as 1840. The crop did not become of importance until rice growing was started on Grand Prairie in the early 1900’s. According to Vincenheller ( 1906), experimental plantings were made near Lonoke in 1902, and in 1904, 435 acres were sown and 5535 hundred-pound bags of rough rice were produced on the 260 acres harvested. The acreage expanded rapidly so that 60,000 acres were grown in Arkansas in 1910. Rice was not grown commercially in California until production was started in the Sacramento Valley about 1912. Chambliss (1912) reported that successful rice trials were conducted near Butte Creek in 1909. Starting in 1912, the acreage expanded so rapidly that rice was grown on 162,000 acres in California in 1920. Rice was grown along the rivers in Mississippi as early as 1840 (Table I ) , but it was not until 1948, when rice was produced by modern methods in the Greenville area, that rice became an important crop. The acreage expanded rapidly to about 79,000 acres in 1954. Because of the limited history of production, the acreage in Mississippi was reduced under the National Acreage Control Program to the present level of about 45,000 acres. Although rice has been grown in all southeastern States, as well as in Illinois, Missouri, Oklahoma, and Arizona, it now is an important commerical crop only in Arkansas, California, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas, with minor production in Missouri and the southeastern states. The annual acreage and production for 1956 to 1960 for each state are given in Table Ii.
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
67
2. Cultural Methods Cultural methods used for rice in early times in the Carolinas were described by Gray and Thompson (1941), Doar (1936), and Allston (1854, 1855). The first rice was grown in the North American Colonies without irrigation but experience proved that irrigation throughout the growing season improved rice yields. A system was developed for irrigating rice along streams influenced by the tide. Hand labor was used to cbar timber from the land, to dig canals and ditches, and to plow or work the land with a hoe during the winter. Doar (1936) summarized a report made in 1850 of cultural methods then practiced by the best farmers. Rows were laid off in 13-inch centers with a 4-inch trenching hoe and seed was sown at the rate of 2% to 3 bushels (112 to 135 pounds) an acre. On “low gummy” soils the seed was not covered, but when soil was well prepared, it was covered. Water was then put on and held until the grain sprouted, 3 to 6 days after seeding. The water then was drained. The rice was irrigated and drained four times during the growing season. This made it possible to hoe and pull weeds and helped to control insects. The rice was cut by hand with a sickle, tied in sheaves, conveyed on “flats” through the canals, and stacked in the barnyard. Some planters used cradles to cut rice, but this was not a general practice. Some planters tried to use patent reapers, but this implement was not successful in the miry fields. When the grain was cured, it was threshed with a flail. The first mechanical thresher, which was operated by wind power, was tried in 1811 without success. A horse-powered thresher, introduced about 1829, was fairly successful and by 1851 steam-powered threshers that could thresh lo00 bushels a day were available. Mules and oxen replaced hand labor for seedbed preparation and hauling the sheaves to the flats, but much hand labor continued to be used in the “Carolina Low Country” until rice culture was discontinued. Production methods used in southwest Louisiana and southeast Texas in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries are described by Knapp (1899, 1900, 1910) and Bond and Keeney ( 1902). The best rice soil was considered to be a “medium loam” with about 50 per cent clay, underlain by an impervious subsoil. The fields were divided by small canals into subfields of “suitable” size, with a small levee on the border of each subfield. Each subfield was leveled so that the depth of irrigation water was uniform. The land was plowed, usually with a 2-gang, 10-inch moldboard plow. Sometimes plowing was done in the late fall or in the winter, but usually it was done in ‘the earIy spring. Plowing was followed in a short time by disking and then by harrowing. Seeding was
68
C. ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
done from mid-March to mid-May, but April seeding was considered the best. Seeding with a grain drill was recommended, but much rice was sown with a broadcast seeder and covered with a harrow. The seeding rate was 45 to 135 pounds per acre. When the soil was dry at seeding time, it was flooded and drained immediately so that the seed would sprout. The rice was imgated when the plants were 6 to 8 inches tall. The depth of water was 3 to 6 inches, and to avoid stagnation, water was renewed by continuous inflow and out0ow. The fields were drained about 10 days before the rice was ready to harvest. This allowed the soil to dry and become firm enough so the rice could be cut with a binder. Ten sheaves then were placed in a well-capped shock. As soon as the straw was cured and the grain was dry, it was threshed with a steampowered thresher. The grain was put in large burlap bags, usually about 185 pounds to a bag, and placed in a warehouse or hauled directly to the mill. Except for gradual improvements in the machinery and in irrigation systems, there apparently were no major changes in cultural methods from 1900 to about 1920. The use of tractors and gasoline-powered binders had become fairly common by about 1918. Soon after that, the power take-off-operated binder, which was a big improvement over the bullwheel and gasoline engine-powered binder, was perfected. As larger tractors and more efficient equipment were built, it was possible to time better and otherwise improve culture practices. The binderthresher method of harvesting continued for many years. The first change from this method was in about 1929 when “swathers” and pick-up combines were used to harvest rice in California. At about this time, studies were started by Smith et al. (1933) and Bainer ( 1932) to determine whether it would be possible to harvest rice with a combine. The extensive research that has been done in this field since about 1930 was reviewed and summarized by Dachtler (1959). The combine harvester is now universally used to harvest rice in the United States. To maintain the milling quality, rice must be harvested when it is too moist to be stored. With direct combine harvesting has come postharvest artificial drying of rice. Drying is done in farm or commercial drying plants. Bainer et al. (1955) reported that rice is produced in California with 7 9 man-hours per acre, as compared with 900 man-hours in Japan, where much hand labor is used. 11.
Rice Culture in the United States
A. SOIL~ ~ CLIMATIC i i REQUIREMENTS Rice generally is grown on silt loam, silty clay, and clay soils although it can be grown on all types of soils. It sometimes is grown on
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
69
organic soils (Green, 1956), and sandy loams are often used. Satisfactory rice soils must have an impervious stratum within 2 to 5 feet of the surface or the texture must be fine enough to reduce water percolation so that seepage is reduced. Because of excessive percolation losses, rice grown on open permeable soil may require two to three times as much water as rice of comparable yield grown on "rice" soil. The surface of the soil must be level so that a uniform depth of about 6 inches of water can be maintained with a minimum number of levees, yet with enough slope so that surface water can be drained for seedbed preparation and harvest. Rice requires a relatively long, frost-free growing period. The optimum growing period for United States varieties is 105 to 170 days. The range of air temperature for rice production is about 70°F. minimum to about 95" maximum. Ormrod (1961) showed that CALORO rice seedlings maintain an appreciable net photosynthetic rate at low air temperature (40" or 60" ) and a wide range of light intensities. Low light intensities at a higher temperature (80' ) resulted in net losses of carbon dioxide from the plants. Rice often is considered to be a tropical crop, although it is grown throughout the tropical, subtropical, and temperate zones from the equator to nearly 50" latitude. The range in the United States is from the Gulf Coast (30"N) to about mid-United States (40"N). The yields generally are higher in the temperate than in the more tropical areas. This difference may be due partly to varieties grown, but climate and soil contribute to this difference.
B. CROPPING SYSTEMS The riceland cropping systems now used in the United States have evolved over the years. These systems are based on experience of growers and information gained from controlled experiments. The cropping system used depends on the soil type and climatic conditions. In most rice-producing areas of the United States, crop rotation is followed because, if cropped continuously, the soil usually becomes depleted in fertility, the organic content becomes so low that the deteriorating physical conditions make seedbed preparation difficult. The soil also becomes progressively infested with weeds that lower the yield and quality of the rice. In the early years in the Carolinas, rice was grown continuously in the same field, with occasional rest, according to Gray and Thompson ( 1941). Rice fields in that area were sometimes planted to oats in the fall, followed by potatoes the next year. Some farmers made a practice of growing rice and cotton on alternate years. This helped to control the weeds in both crops. In the South Central States, the fields were
70
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
cropped to rice year after year until the yield became low and the quality was poor because of mixture of weed seeds and red rice in the threshed grain. Fields were then allowed to lay idle for a year or two and then put back into rice. This practice improved the yield but did not control the weeds satisfactorily, so the rice fields were grazed during years they were “laid-out.” This helped control the grass and weeds but did not control the red rice. Some farmers practiced summer fallowing for a year or two between rice crops and thus controlled the weeds and red rice more effectively than when the fields were not cultivated. In Arkansas, starting about 1930, rice was rotated with soybeans and lespedeza. Fall-sown oats had been rotated with rice to some extent before the use of the legume crops. A common rotation system for Arkansas was rice, soybeans, followed by fall-sown oats with lespedeza sown in the oats in the early spring. This is a difficult rotation to manage because of the likelihood of rain at a critical time which may prevent the seeding of the oats. However, when this rotation can be used, four crops are produced in three years, the soil is benefited, and weeds are controlled to some extent. Farming systems for rice farms in Arkansas are described and discussed by Mullins and Slusher ( 1950, 1951) . More recently, fish culture has been beneficially inserted into the rice rotation system in Arkansas and Mississippi (Green and Mullins, 1959). Because of weather conditions and diseases, oats and soybeans have not been grown in rotation with rice in the Gulf Coast area. The usual cropping system in this area is to rotate rice with improved pastures and to raise beef cattle as a supplemental enterprise. This system of rice farming and this method of establishing pastures are discussed by Moncrief and Weihing ( 1950). Walker and Sturgis (1946) conducted experiments on the establishment of pastures following rice on three soil types in Louisiana and described the results with respect to improving the pasture and the results of this treatment on the following rice crop. They found that fertilizer at the rate of 400 pounds of 3-12-6 and 1 ton of ground limestone an acre before seeding the pasture with white clover, Persian clover, common lespedeza, carpet grass, and bermudagrass, and 200 pounds an acre of the same fertilizer the next year almost doubled the production of the pasture compared with growth that occurred naturally following rice. Rice yields following the improved pasture were over 10oO pounds an acre higher than rice following unimproved pasture. This system or some modification of it is commonly used in Louisiana and Texas, according to Jones et al. (1952). In California, no definite system of crop rotation has yet emerged (Jones et al., 1950). To date no serious rice disease in that State has made crop rotation on riceland necessary. When rapidly advancing
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
71
knowledge of weed control, fertilization, and other improved cultural practices are used, fields can be cropped continuously to rice with everincreasing per acre yields. Some California farmers follow rice with spring- or summer-plowed fallow, on which wheat or oats and vetch is fall-sown. After the ensuing grain crop, the field is returned to rice for an indefinite numbers of years. Currently, spring-sown grain sorghum, field beans, and saf3ower are being used on the medium-textured soil types for 1 or 2 years, the land then being returned to rice. To a limited extent, imgated ladino or strawberry clover-trefoil-grasspastures may be inserted in the rotation for a continuing period of 4 to 7 years. C. LANDPREPARATION The seedbed for rice is prepared in much the same manner as that for other small grains. The procedures generally followed are given by Davis (1950), Jones et al. (1950, 1952>,Reynolds (1954), and Finfrock and Miller (1958). The primary aim is to destroy weeds and to provide a suitable seedbed. Whether it should be rough or mellow on the surface will be governed by the seeding method used. If the rice is to be sown in the water, the soil surface should be rough; and if it is to be drilled, the soil surface should be mellow. Rice fields are usually plowed in the late summer, fall, or winter in Louisiana and Texas. Land that has been in pasture for several years, when plowed at that time, will be mellowed by the frost and rain during winter and early spring. A good seedbed can be prepared by disking, harrowing, and floating (dragging) in the spring. When the land is plowed in the spring, it is disked and harrowed immediately to prevent clod formation by baking. When cropped successively to rice, the land is disked as soon after harvest of the rice crop as soil condition permits. In Arkansas, rice fields usually are disked immediately after harvest. The tractors used to pull the grain carts while the combines are operating often are used early in the morning to disk the land harvested the previous day. Disking chops the stubble and straw and puts it in contact with the soil and thus hastens its decay. The fields may be disked another time or two during the winter as weather permits so that it can be seeded to lespedeza in early spring without further seedbed preparation. When rice follows soybeans that have been intertilled, a seedbed may be prepared by working the soil with a heavy disk, followed by a lighter disk and smoothing harrow. When rice follows lespedeza, the land is plowed, usually with a moldboard plow, disked, and harrowed. In California, the land is plowed in the spring to a depth of 4 to 6 inches, disked, and then harrowed or smoothed with a drag. Sometimes where rice follows beans, sorghum, or safflower, the seedbed may be
72
C . ROY AD=,
M. D. MILLER, A h 9 H. M.
BEACHELL
prepared by spring disking. When the rice is to be sown in the water, the soil should not be worked too soon after a rain and it should be left loose and rough on the surface. Since water seeding is the predominant method, a clod size ranging from 5 inch to 4 inches in diameter is the goal. As the clods slake down after flooding and seeding, the silt covers the seed. If the soil is compacted and puddled by working when it is too wet, algal growth is induced and oxygen essential for good root development is excluded from the soil. Usually, in Arkansas, the last field operation before flooding is to till the soil with a spring-tooth harrow or field cultivator. A heavy spike-tooth harrow is generally used for this last operation in California. In addition to the other advantage, a rough seedbed helps prevent drifting of the seed in the water. An essential part of rice culture is to have the soil surface as level as possible within each subfield. That is, knolls should be cut down and shallow sloughs and dead furrows filled so that the field is uniformly graded to the natural slope of the terrain. This will make it possible to keep the fields drained of winter water thus expediting seedbed preparation and speeding harvest by providing for rapid field drainage at maturity. The levees can be straightened when the fields are graded to a uniform slope from the upper to the lower side. This will reduce tillage and harvesting costs by cutting turning time and increase the rice yields by eliminating “drowned-out” and weedy spots. In most cases a rice field can be improved for water management by land planing before or during seedbed preparation. Regular earthmoving equipment is required to grade very rough fields. Grading rice fields while flooded has been successfully demonstrated in Louisiana (Faulkner and Miears, 1961). After a field has been adequately graded, it then can be maintained by regular land planing or floating prior to seeding the rice. Levee construction is an integral and important part of preparation for growing rice. Levees are the key device used to control the depth of application of water to the crops. The levees must be located accurately in order to maintain a uniform depth of water; they are constructed on the contour, that is, on lines of equal elevation. They should be located by an experienced surveyor or operator using an accurate instrument. The soil should be smooth, so the surveying can best be done immediately after the land has been floated. The contour interval between levees is usually 0.2 to 0.3 foot, depending upon the slope- of the land. On flat land they are built OR 0.1 to 0.2 foot contour, and on steep, sloping land on 0.3 foot. The levee should be as compact as possible and high enough to hold the water at the desired level. In the southern States, the levees
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
73
have gently sloping sides so that the rice can be drilled and harvested over the levee. In this case the levees are complete after drilling the rice. In California, the levees are higher and have steep sides so that the area between pairs of levees is harvested as a field or unit. In the southern States, the base of the levee is made by plowing one round with a 3bottom plow and then finishing with a single-or a double-blade pusher on clayey soils or with a levee disk on sandy loam and loam. The levee base is built as early as possible so that it can settle. In California, a V-type diker or soil crowder that is 14 to 16 feet wide in front and 4 feet wide in the back is used. Two or more crawler-type tractors are used to pull the diker. The levees usually are 30 to 36 inches high when freshly made and settle to 16 to 20 inches. Levees usually are made in the fall and allowed to settle during the winter. A bulldozer or a tractor with front-end scoop is used to close the gap at the water-control boxes and at the end of each levee. Scott st al. (1961) reported on the possibilities of using plastic film rice levees in lieu of soil levees. Their studies show that plastic levees are physically feasible but of undetermined economic benefit. A machine to install plastic levees mechanically is required before this type of levee will be commercially feasible.
D. IRRIGATION AND DRAINAGE The water requirement of rice is high. Flood irrigation is used for all rice grown in the United States. That is, the soil is submerged in 4 to 8 inches of water most or all of the time from seeding until the grain is nearly ripe. Upland, or rain-fed, rice is grown in some areas of the world, but only where rain is almost a daily occurrence. Rice will not produce a profitable crop on stored soil moisture or infrequent rains as will some other cereals. Senewiratne and Mikkelsen (1Wl) suggest that differences in growth responses of flooded and unflooded rice may be due to differences in auxin metabolism. They found that plants grown under unfiooded conditions had a low catalase activity and a high peroxidase activity which favored accelerated auxin degradation. They suggested that high manganese levels in plants grown under unflooded conditions affect the indoleacetic oxidase mechanism resulting in retarded growth and depressed grain yields. Rice grown with ammonium nitrogen (flooded) collected small amounts of manganese, whereas plants grown with nitrate nitrogen (typical of upland rice) contained much more manganese. Clark et al. (1957) “concluded that the better growth of rice in submerged as compared to upland culture in at least some soils is due to greater Mn availability under submerged soil conditions.” A reliable source of comparatively salt-free irrigation water is required, The total amount required will depend upon seepage, average
74
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
temperature, relative humidity of the air, and the amount and distribution of rainfall, as well as the length of growing season of the variety being produced. The amount varies from 1.5 to 3 acre-feet per acre in Arkansas and Louisiana to 3 to 8 acre-feet in California (Adair and Engler, 1955). A rate of %owequal to 1 cubic foot per second (450 gallons per minute) for each 50 acres being irrigated is usually required to maintain water levels in California rice fields ( Finfrock et aZ., 1960). In the United States, irrigation water is diverted from streams or is pumped from rivers, bayous, wells, lakes, or reservoirs. Water is conveyed to the fields in canals. If a large canal serves many farms, as in some areas in California, Louisiana, and Texas, the water is diverted to lateral canals for each farm or small group of farms. The water generally is turned into the top check of a field and flows through boxgates in the levee to reach each succeeding check. Some fields will have a lateral canal down the side so that each check can be watered separately. The water must be relatively free of salts toxic to rice. The characteristics of irrigation water which determine quality include: total concentration of soluble salts, relative ratio of sodium to other cations, concentration of boron or other toxic elements, and under some conditions, the bicarbonate concentration as related to the concentration of calcium plus magnesium. According to Finfrock et al. (1960), the qualities to look for in excellent to good water for rice irrigation are the following: specific electrical conductivity, ( K x lo6) less than 750; boron, parts per million (ppm) less than 1; S.A.R. Index (tendency to form alkali soil) less than 10. Other points to consider are the initial salinity of the soil, the effect of internal drainage while the soil is flooded, and the total salt content of the soil. The point of greatest importance is the nature of the soil solution or saturation extract found in the zone of rice roots. If soil saturation extracts have a conductivity index of 4 to 8 millimhos (mmhos) or more, the yield of CALORO rice may be reduced 50 per cent (Pearson, 1958). Rice seedlings are very sensitive to salinity during early development but are progressively less so at 3 and 6 weeks of age (Pearson, 1958). When soils are strongly saline, having an excessively high concentration of sodium, calcium, or potassium, the concentration of salts in the soil solution (including the standing water) may be so great that it will injure or kill the seedling rice (Pearson and Ayers, 1960). Excessive salt concentration results in restriction in downward percolation. Therefore the flood water is subject to a longer period of evaporation with an ensuing increase in salt concentration. Thus water having a higher salt
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
75
concentration enters the soil, and the concentration of the soil solution is increased. Flooding, draining, and reflooding before seeding will help prevent such injury on fields known to give difficulty. Prompt draining and reflooding seedling stands in difficulty has usually corrected the condition. In Arkansas, the continued use of water from shallow wells, which may contain 75 ppm. of calcium and 22 ppm. of magnesium, for several years may change the soil reaction from acid (pH 5) to alkaline ( pH 8 ) . Hall (1959) reported that the condition can be corrected to some extent by alternate flooding and draining at about weekly intervals and by applying nitrogen fertilizer. When the rainfall is below normal, the amount of water pumped for rice from a bayou near the Gulf Coast may be more than the flow of the stream. In this case, brackish water may encroach from the Gulf. Quereau (1920) and Fraps (1909, 1927) reported the effect of brackish water on the growth of rice. The damage depends on the concentration of salts in the water, the time the salt water is applied, the length of time the injurious water is used, the amount of rainfall, and the variety of rice. In addition to causing a loss in yield of rice, the excessive use of salt water or the continued use of salt water for several years may deflocculate the soil so that stickiness, compactness, and impermeability increase and the soil is hard to cultivate. California experience has shown that rice culture is useful in the reclamation of saline soils, provided the fields to be reclaimed are first well drained. Mackie (1943) reported that one rice crop grown on Imperial clay near ImperiaI reduced the saline content 72 per cent to a depth of 6 feet. In his experiments he found the usual reduction in saline content from the first rice crop to be one-third to two-thirds. The temperature of the irrigation water should be not less than 70°F. or more than 85" for best results. Raney (1959) showed that the critical seasonal threshold of water temperature for normal growth of CALORO rice was near 69". If the mean temperature is 5" lower, maturity is delayed 30 days beyond the normal 160 days. Rice yield was highest when the mean water temperature was 80". At water temperature above 85", yield was reduced, and root development was poor, probably because of the low oxygen content of the water. Ehrler and Bernstein (1958) reported that at a constant root temperature of 64.4"F. CALORO shoot growth was twice that at 86" and root growth one and a half times as great; however, grain yield was only three-fourths as much at the lower root temperature. No significant interaction was found between root temperature and cationic concentration or cationic rates.
76
C. ROY ADAIR, X I . D. MILLER, A h 3 H. M. BEACIIELL
Seeds germinate slowly when the temperature is less than 70°F. The temperature of water from rivers in northern California and shallow wells in some southern States may be 65" or lower. This temperature will retard and lower the germination of rice sown in the water and retard the development of plants so that the stand may be thin and late near the inlet to the field. According to Raney et al. (1957), field studies over a 3-year period showed that plant-free warming basins, 6 to 12 inches in depth, equal in size to 2 per cent of the area to be served, successfully raised the mean water temperature of 60" water to 70". Water management systems vary widely, depending upon method of seeding, soil type, climate, crop rotation, diseases, and insects. Methods of irrigating rice in Texas vary widely, according to Reynolds (1954). Where rice is drilled, the fields may be flushed for germination. Thereafter the drilled rice is irrigated for the first time when the plants reach a height of 4 to 6 inches. At this time water is applied to a depth of 1to 2 inches and is gradually increased to 4 to 6 inches as the plants increase in height. The water then is held at 5 inches until drained for harvest. Water may be drained once or twice during the growing season for fertilization and pest control. M'here rice is sown in water, some growers drain as soon as possible after seeding; others may delay draining as much as 36 hours. After the seedlings are well established, the practices are essentially as outlined for drilled rice. \Vater management is very similar in Louisiana and Arkansas. In Louisiana, water seeding is not common, but where it is practiced, the water is drained when the rice seedlings are 9 inch long ( Wasson and Walker, 1955). It then is allowed to grow until flooding is needed. Drilled rice may be flushed if necessary for uniform germination. Normally the rice is not flooded until it is 6 to 8 inches tall, and then only to a depth of 4% inches. Fields are drained as necessary for top-dressing with fertilizer and for pest control. In California, where japonica-derived varieties predominate, rice fields normally are flooded to a depth of 6 to 8 inches just before seeding and seeded by air with soaked seed. The water is maintained at that depth until drainage for harvest. Water may be lowered to about a 3-inch depth for weed control and at stand establishment time during cool weather. Good drainage, including winter rain water, of rice fields is necessary for several important reasons. Spring plowing and fall harvest are expedited by good drainage. Crops grown in rotation with rice may be damaged by impounded water from rains or irrigation if provision is not made for proper drainage. Drainways around and through the field that connect with main drainage ditches leading to natural drainage
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
77
channels are essential. These ditches should be of sufficient size and depth to allow the removal of large quantities of water quickly. The time to drain the water before harvest varies with the soil type, rice variety, weather conditions, and drainage system. The water should be drained when the panicles are turned down and the grains at the tips of the panicles are ripe and those at the base of the panicle are in the hard-dough stage. This stage ordinarily is about 2 weeks before the crop is mature. When drained at this stage, there usually will be sufficient soil moisture so the rice matures normally, and within 2 weeks the soil will be firm enough to support the harvesting machinery.
E. SEEDINGRICE 1. Quality and Treatment of the Seed The choice of seed is an important part of rice culture. To achieve top yield, the variety to be grown must be adapted for the area. This is discussed in Section V, C. After deciding upon the variety, it is necessary to select a lot of rice that is free from varietal mixtures, does not contain red rice and weed seed, is high in percentage of viable seeds, and has high bushel weight. The seed requirements have been discussed by Jones et aE. (1950,1952) and Finfrock and Miller (1958).All rice-producing States have a rice seed certification program designed to provide high quality seed for the rice industry. The seed should be treated with a fungicide to control seedborne diseases, and with an insecticide in areas where there is likely to be a heavy infestation of rice water weevils. In California, soaking seed in a sodium hypochlorite solution (5.25 per cent by weight) at the rate of 1 gallon per 100 gallons of water is recommended as a seed protectant and to deactivate germination inhibitors located in rice hulls. Mikkelsen and Sinah (1961) reported the presence of six compounds in the hulls that inhibit germination of CALQRO rice. When present in large amounts, these compounds diffuse into the embryo and inhibit germination. Compounds identified include vanillic acid, ferulic acid, p-hydroxybenzoic acid, p-coumaric acid, p-hydroxybenzaldehyde, and possibly indoleacetic acid. In low concentrations, these chemical substances prove stimulatory to germination and ensuing growth. Leaching the seed by soaking with water reduces the concentration to stimulatory levels. The probable action of sodium hypochlorite solution is to modify these inhibitors, so that seedling growth is stimulated.
2. Methods of Seeding Several methods are used to seed rice in the United States. It may be sown with a grain drill much the same as other small grains, sown
78
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
broadcast on dry soil and disked or harrowed to cover, or sown in water by airplane. On nonsubmerged soil, the rice is sown 1% to 2 inches deep. The field may be flushed and drained immediately to provide moisture for germination or there may be sufficient moisture in the soil or from rain for germination and seedling growth. When drilled rice is imgated before emergence, the water is drained immediately because the rice seedling cannot emerge through 1 to 3 inches of soil and thence through 4 to 8 inches of water. Several modifications of the water-seeding method are used. In California, the usual practice is to soak the seed for 18 to 24 hours, drain for 94 to 48 hours, and seed in the water. Seed rice will absorb the maximum amount of water in 18 to 24 hours. In Arkansas, rice sometimes is sown in water. When this is done, the fields are flooded to a depth of about 6 inches just before seeding. Dry seed is then sown by airplane, the water being maintained at a constant level for about 5 weeks; then it may be drained off to apply fertilizer or to control root maggots. In Texas (Reynolds, 1954) and sometimes in Louisiana, a water-seeding method that is different from the method used in California or Arkansas is used. In this method, which generally is used on clayey soils, a rough seedbed is prepared and levees are constructed. The field is flooded with enough water to cover the soil. The soil is then tilled with a spike-tooth or disk harrow, and sprouted seed is sown immediately. The soil suspended in the water lightly covers the seed when it settles out of the water. The water is drained from the field within 12 to 24 hours. In 7 to 10 days after draining, the field is reflooded to a shallow depth; and as the seedlings develop, the depth of water is increased gradually to 5 to 6 inches. When rice is sown with a drill in clayey soils in Texas, it is seldom sown over 1 inch deep and is flushed as soon after seeding as possible. In sandy loams, the rice is sown 3 or more inches deep and cultipacked immediately to conserve soil moisture. Frequently a harrow or a rotary hoe is used to break the crust to allow the rice to emerge. Water is not applied until the rice is 30 or more days old.
3. Time and Rate of Seeding Most rice in the southern States is sown from April 1 to May 30, but occasionally some fields are sown in late March and others as late as June 30. When rice is sown early while the soil or the water is relatively cool, it is subject to very slow germination and to rotting, so the seed should be treated with a fungicide. Seed germinates more quickly if sown later when the soil or water temperature is more nearly optimum. Date-of-seeding tests reported by Jenkins ( 1936), Adair ( 1940), Jodon
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
79
(1953), and Reynolds (1954) show that there is a comparatively long seeding period for rice in the South. Most farmers take advantage of this fact to spread the work load both at seeding time and at harvest. By doing this, they can also make better use of the available irrigation water, especially if a well is the source of irrigation water. In California, the period for seeding rice is more restricted than in the South. Some rice is sown in California soon after April 1 and some as late as June 15, but most of it is sown from April 15 to May 15 (Finfrock and Miller, 1958). When rice is sown as late as May 30 in California, it should be fertilized at a moderate rate and a short-season variety such as COLUSA preferably should be grown. In the South, the seeding rate is about 90 to 100 pounds per acre when drilled and 110 to 140 pounds per acre when sown broadcast on dry soil or in the water. In California, seeding rates when sown in the water average about 150 pounds and range from 125 to 200 pounds (dry-weight basis) per acre. Rice seeds average 15,000 per pound; with a seeding rate of 150 pounds per acre, seeds are sown at the rate of 50 seeds per square foot. Excellent yields have been reported, from plant populations ranging from 8 to 30 per square foot. Seeding rates between these extremes apparently do not influence yields. Extremely dense stands lodge more readily than optimum stands. Rice in denser stands heads and matures more uniformly than thinner stands with abundant tillering. The higher seeding rates usually are used on old land.
F. CROPFERTILIZATION 1. Commercial Fertilizers Fertilizers were not commonly used for rice in the United States until comparatively recent years. Allston ( 1854) reviewed rice-fertilization practices up to about 1850. He reported that it was a fairly common practice to return the rice straw and chaff to the rice fields and to apply farmyard manure. At about that time some rice growers started to use lime ( 100 bushels an acre) and to apply rice-flour (bran) between the rows prior to the “long-flow.” Knapp (1899) reported that an application of 300 pounds of cottonseed meal, 150 pounds of acid phosphate, and 50 pounds of kainite plowed under before seeding increased the yield of grain and straw 25 per cent in Louisiana. Chambliss and Adams (1915) and Chambliss (1920b) do not mention the use of fertilizer for rice in California. Jones ( 1923), Dunshee (1928), and Davis and Jones (1940) report results of rice fertilizer experiments with good response to nitrogen. Jones et al. (1950) and Davis (1950) recommend ammonium sulfate at rates up to 250 pounds, 50 pounds of nitrogen an acre applied before flooding to 65 days after seeding.
80
C. ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, A N D H. M. BEACHELL
Mikkelsen and Finfrock (1957) subsequently reported that subsurface (drilled) placement of ammonium nitrogen produced better growth and yields of lowland rice than similar nitrogen applied on the soil surface (broadcast) before or after flooding. Mikkelsen et al. (1958) confirmed these findings and set forth conditions under which the use of phosphate fertilizers and top-dressing might be beneficial. Increases in yield of 3OOO pounds per acre as compared with the controls through use of improved fertilization practices were reported. Mikkelsen et al. (1961) reported that ammonium chloride as a source of nitrogen for rice was equal to other ammonium nitrogen sources. Ingebretsen et al. (1959) reported that the application of ferric sulfate to nonsaline-alkali (high-sodium) soils in California rice fields had greatly increased yields. They attribute the beneficial effects of Fe, to the correction of iron deficiency in such areas. ( Chambliss (1920a) reported that about 1920 the use of complete mineral fertilizer on rice was not a common practice in the South. Some phosphate and potash fertilizer was used and good results had been obtained with the use of ammonium sulfate. Experiments conducted in Louisiana during 1919 to 1923 (Chambliss and Jenkins, 1925) showed little or no benefit from various combinations of nitrogen, phosphate, potash, and lime; however, there was a substantial gain in rice yield when soybeans were plowed under before the rice crops. Jones et al. ( 1938) reported increased yields of rice from nitrogen and phosphate under most conditions. The best time of application of phosphate was at seeding. The best time to apply the nitrogen varied under different conditions from seeding time to 6 to 8 weeks after seeding. Jenkins and Jones (1944) reported that applications of an 8-10-6 fertilizer at rates of 100, 200,and 300 pounds per acre gave increases, respectively, of 4.5, 4.1, and 6 bushels per acre on alternately cropped land. Jones et al. (1952) reported that it was customary for farmers to use fertilizer in the South at that time. Good response was obtained from nitrogen on most soils although the time and rate of application vaned from one soil and type of management to another. They reported that phosphate sometimes was beneficial. The response to nitrogen appeared to be due in part to better cultural, irrigation, and weed control practice. Wasson and Walker (1955) recommended for Louisiana the use of 30 to 60 pounds of nitrogen, 20 to 40 pounds of phosphate, and 0 to 40 pounds per acre of potash, drilled with or below the seed. A top-dressing of 30 to 40 pounds per acre of nitrogen increases yields on the heavier soils. The extensive use of commercial fertilizer on rice in Arkansas has been a common practice for only a comparatively few years. Nelson
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
81
(1908) conducted fertilizer trials in that State in 1907 to determine whether yields could be increased or maturity hastened. He stated that there was an apparent benefit from an application of a mixed (3-13-11) fertilizer at the rate of 200 pounds per acre and from cottonseed meaI at the same rate, but no yield data were reported. Nelson (1931) reported results of fertilizer trials conducted in Arkansas during 1927 to 1930 on weedy lands. He found that the fertilizer stimulated the grass and weeds more than it did the rice so that yields of rice were lower on fertilized than on unfertilized plots. Kapp ( 1933) conducted extensive experiments in the field and greenhouse on rice fertilization and concluded that “the lack of nitrogen is responsible for most of the abnormal growth and low yields of rice.” Nelson (1943) reported results of experiments on rice fertilizations in Arkansas during 1931 to 1940. Most of the experiments were on plots cropped continuously to rice. Under this type of culture, none of the treatments maintained yield at the level it was the first year, but the yield was higher with applications of 20 pounds per acre of nitrogen than when no fertilizer was applied. Beacher (1952) reported results of rice fertilization trials conducted over a wide range of conditions in Arkansas during 1946 to 1951. He found that when fertilizer was applied on dry soil 6 to 8 weeks after seeding, the average yield increase was 11 to 22 pounds of rice per pound of nitrogen applied at rates of 40 to 50 pounds per acre of nitrogen. The yield increase per pound of nitrogen was lower, but total yields and profits were high with rates of 80 to 100 pounds per acre of nitrogen. Responses from phosphate were not consistent. Beacher and Wells (1960) reported that in Arkansas ammonium sulfate, urea, anhydrous ammonia, liquid nonpressure mixture of urea and ammonium nitrate, and ammonium phosphate-sulfate and diammonium phosphate were equally effective when applied at equivalent nitrogen rates at any time up to 50 days after seeding. When applied 70 to 85 days after seeding, amonium nitrate and urea were equally effective. These workers also report that under some conditions nitrogen applications sometimes hastened maturity but that a single application of nitrogen at heavy rates of 135 to 180 pounds per acre before the second irrigation delayed maturity. They also reported that application of nitrogen increased the protein content of the grain. Rice fertilizer experiments were started in Texas in 1915. Results of experiments conducted from 1915 to 1940, inclusive, were sumarized by Wyche ( 1941). Experiments were conducted on Lake Charles clay, Beaumont clay, Lake Charles clay loam, and “light-colored soils, probably of the Katy series.” Rice on Beaumont clay responded to application of nitrogen alone with an additional increase when phosphate was used
82
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, A N D H. M. BEACHELL
with nitrogen. Rice on the Lake Charles clay responded to phosphate
but not to nitrogen when these fertilizers were each used alone, the best yields being produced when the two were used together. On “lightcolored soil,” rice responded to phosphate alone but not to nitrogen either alone or in combination with phosphate. There was no response to application of the minor elements iron, manganese, copper, zinc, and boron. Best results were obtained when the nitrogen and phosphate were drilled with the seed. Reynolds (1954)reported that “applications of 80 pounds of nitrogen and 40 pounds of phosphoric acid per acre (8040-0)gave better results than other fertilizers on Beaumont clay, Lake Charles clay, and Lake Charles clay loam, and are recommended for these soils. The use of 40-40-20 is recommended for Katy fine sandy loam. Sulfate of ammonia, urea and cyanamid were better sources of nitrogen for rice than nitrate of soda.” He reported also that 80-40-0 also gave best results on Hockley fine sandy loam and Edna fine sandy loam. Evatt and Beachell (1958) reported a varietal difference in reaction to nitrogen fertilizer as their results indicated that short-season varieties and short-strawed varieties could utilize higher rates of nitrogen than long-season and tall varieties. 2. Green Manure and Crop-Residue Management Residue from preceding crops often are incorporated into the soil before seeding rice. Some of these practices are discussed in Section 11, B. Jones et al. (1950) recommended the use of burclover (Medicago hiqida Gaertn.). Recently, Williams et al. (1957) reported that the use of vetch green manure increased yields of rice about 1000 pounds an acre. Purple vetch (Vicia atropurpurea Desf.) is most commonly used. It can be sown in the rice after most of the water has been drained off but before the rice is cut. It also can be sown after other crops or after summer fallow. Other species of Vicia also are used, as well as field peas and burclover. Horsebeans (Vicia Juba L. ) are also used but are usually drilled into a prepared seedbed. Reed and Sturgis (1937) reviewed and reported that organic matter such as soybean hay increased rice yields and improved soil structure. However, they found that organic nitrogen and potash alone and in combination did not increase rice yields but were effective when applied with phosphate. Nelson (1944) reported increased rice yields following hairy vetch (Vicia o i l h a Roth.) and soybeans [Glycine max ( L.) Merr.]. Williams et al. (1957) reported that green manure crops added nitrogen to the highly carbonaceous rice crop residue. When this is done, decomposition of the subsequently incorporated material proceeds with-
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE I N UNITEXI STATES
83
out tying up nitrogen needed by the ensuing rice crop and provides an alternative to the deleterious rice crop residue-burning practice. G. HARVESTING, DRYING,STORING, AND MILLING 1. Harvesting
Almost all rice grown in the United States is cut with a combine harvester and dried artificially before storing or milling. The only exception is a small percentage of seed rice which is cut and swathed and threshed when it has dried to 12 per cent moisture or less. Bainer (1932), Smith et al. (1933), Slusher and Mullins (1948), and McNeal (1950a) reported research which has led to greater efficiency in the mechanization of the rice harvest. Smith et al. (1938), McNeal (1950b), and Kester (1959) reported results of research related to time of rice harvest based upon maturity of the grain. It was clearly shown that maximum yield of head rice was obtained if harvested when the moisture content of the grain was 18 to 24 per cent and then artificially dried. Harvesting when the grain moisture content was higher caused a reduction of the yield and milling quality. If the moisture content is less than 18 per cent at harvest, the milling quality usually will be low because alternate wetting by dew and rain and drying of ripe rice cause a checking of the grain which can result in excessive kernel breakage when the rice is milled. In the United States rice is usually handled in bulk. The rice combine harvester is equipped with a tank for collecting the threshed grain. Rice is mechanically augered into a self-propelled “bank-out” or a tractor-drawn cart which takes the rice to a truck. After the truck is mechanically loaded from the “bank out” or cart, the rice is then taken to a drier or to a bin where it is aerated. 2. Drying and Storing
Rice in the United States is harvested or cut with too much moisture for safe storage; so it must be dried or aerated soon after threshing. If the grain is not dried or aerated, it will be damaged and the quality lowered. It is dried to about 13 per cent moisture with forced air, which may be heated or unheated. Dachtler (1959) reviewed United States research work on conditioning and storing rough and milled rice. For the proper drying of rice, moisture must be removed from inside the kernel. If rice is dried too fast or if the temperature of the drying air is too high, serious loss of quality will result. To prevent checking or shattering of the rice kernels from drying too rapidly, the drying usually is done in 3 to 5 stages. In each stage the rice passes through
84
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
the drier and then is tempered in a bin so that the kernel moisture will equilibrate. Stored rice is subject to attack by a number of insects. The larvae of the lesser grain borer, the rice weevil, and the Angoumois grain moth attack sound rough rice kernels. The grain and flour beetles (cadelle, saw-toothed grain beetle, the flat grain beetle, red flour beetle, and the confused flour beetle) attack broken kernels or dehulled kernels. Moths that infest the surface of bulk or bagged rough rice and that spin webbing in profusion include the Indian-meal moth, the almond moth, and the rice moth, In bran and milled rice, bran bugs including the flour beetles are important (U.S. Dept. Agr., 1958; Rouse et al., 1958).
3. Milling The milling process and the machinery used were described by Kik and IVilliams (1945). Although improvements have been made in many of the machines used and the over-all organization of rice milling is more efficient, the present-day milling process is basically the same as it has been for many years. Modern rice mills perform the milling process mechanically, starting with cleaning the field-run grain and ending with milled rice which has been sorted into grades. The cleaning process involves (1) scalping to remove sticks, mud lumps, etc.; ( 2 ) bearding to remove the awns, culms, and leaves; and ( 3 ) monitoring or cleaning to remove sterile florets and any remaining foreign matter. In succession the grain passes to the hulling machine or “stones” to remove the hulls, leaving “brown rice”; to the ‘hullers” where the “bran” is removed; and to the brush which removes the “polish” that consists of the remainder of the innermost or aleurone layer and adhering floury particles. The “milled rice” is then graded into four size classes. The whole grains or “head rice” may not contain more than 4 per cent of large broken grains, large broken grains or “second heads,” smaller broken grains or “screenings,” and finely broken grains or “brewers’ rice.” Milled rice may also pass through an additional step whereby it is coated with glucose and talc powder and in some cases enriched with thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, and iron, and given a final polishing in a trumbal. The milling quality of United States varieties varies over a rather wide range. The conditions under which the rice is grown, dried, and stored also influence the milling quality. The milling results for trash-free rough rice usually are in the range of 17 to 20 per cent hulls, 48 to 65 per cent head rice, 4 to 8 per cent second heads, 5 to 10 per cent screenings, 1 to 3 per cent brewers’ rice, and 8 to 11 per cent bran and polish.
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNWED STATES
85
111. Rice Field Pests
A. WEEDS
1. Important Weeds in Rice Fields More than 50 grasses, sedges, and broadleaf weeds are troublesome pests in United States rice fields. The more important weeds were listed by Beachell ( 1959).Certain of the more important weeds were discussed by Prince (1927), Smith ( 1940), Jones et al. ( 1950), Davis (1950), Williams (1955, 1956), and Finfrock et al. ( 1958). Smith et al. (1959) list the principal troublesome United States rice weeds as being barnyardgrasses ( Echinochloa spp. ), red rice ( Oryza sativa L.), coffeeweed (Sesbania exaltata (Raf.) Cory), curly indigo ( Aeschynomene virginica (L. ) B.S.P. ), Mexican weed (Caperonia castaneaefolia ( L. ) St. Hil. ), mudplantain ( Heteranthera sp. ), arrowheads ( Sagittaria spp. ), gooseweed ( Sphenoclea zeylanica Gaertn. ), redstem ( Ammunnia coccinea Rottb. ), bulrush ( Scirpus sp. ), umbrellasedges (Cyperus spp.), and spikerushes (Eleocharis spp.). These authors estimated that barnyardgrass may reduce rice yields by one-fourth or more in seriously infested fields and may be costing United States rice growers as much as twenty million dollars yearly in reduced yield. Among the many widely dispersed serious broadleaf weeds, mudplantain reduced potential rice yields by 18 to 48 per cent when allowed to compete with rice the first month after seeding. Weed control is an important problem wherever rice is grown (see Section I, B). Lack of effective weed control has frequently been the main cause of limited production. Rice usually is grown under a moisture regime which favors rapid growth and reproduction of aquatic and semiaquatic weeds. Most of the species involved are prolific seed producers and quickly infest land only a season or two after it is first seeded to rice, especially if a planned control program is not initiated early. Weeds reduce yields by competing with the developing rice plants for light, nutrients, water, and space. They increase harvesting costs by their presence and by promoting lodging. Weed seeds in the threshed grain cause lowered grain grade. Current United States standards for rough rice prescribe a maximum tolerance for No. 1 rough rice of two weed seeds per 500 grams or 0.5 per cent of red rice. 2. Control of K'eeds Research and field experience contributed much in the past decade to improved chemical methods of selective weed control in rice; however,
86
C. ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILUER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
cultural methods still remain the most economical and most widely employed procedures. In practice, a modem rice weed control program proceeds on three fronts: ( 1 ) Weed infestation prevention by seeding weed-free seed and by forestalling seed formation of weeds that volunteer. For example, in California some growers use sheep to keep weeds grazed from the levees. ( 2 ) Seedbed preparation done so as to destroy the maximum amount of weeds before seeding the rice crop. Proper time and method of crop fertilization play an important role in weed control. ( 3 ) Use of appropriate herbicides for grass and broadleaf weed control. Crop rotation such as rice-pasture in Louisiana and Texas, rice-fish or rice-soybeans-oats in Arkansas, and rice-field beans, grain-sorghum, or safflower in California can ameliorate the weed problem in rice fields. For long-range effectiveness, the entire rotation period must be weed free. The system that includes summer or fall fallow is especially effective. Well-leveled land, appropriately engineered levees, and a dependable water supply are important in weed control. These factors collectively make it possible to reduce the weed problem by controlling the depth of irrigation water. They also facilitate drainage, which helps to control algae and certain aquatic weeds. Seeding into the water as soon as possible ( 1 to 7 days after flooding) is generally practiced in California to control barnyardgrass, spikerush, and other weeds. Except possibly in cool years or in emergencies, the fields are continuously flooded to a depth of 4 to 8 inches until harvest. The germinating and seedling watergrass is inhibited or killed under flooded conditions. Such a procedure, however, may cause an increase of algae and other weeds. In the South, seedling weeds are partially controlled by judicious flooding of drill-planted seedling rice. For watergrass control, the first flood is usually for 2 to 3 weeks to a depth of 4 to 6 inches. Frequent cultivation at 1- to 3-week intervals in the spring before seeding is regularly followed to reduce weed infestations. The last operation usually should be shallow so that more viable weed seed is not brought to the surface. Roughly prepared seedbeds tend to discourage weed seed germination. Rice fertilization practices influence the rice field weed population. According to Smith et al. (1959), applying both phosphate and nitrogen fertilizer too soon before seeding the rice will greatly increase the competitive ability of the native weeds. Applying phosphate to the preceding rotational crop or delaying fertilizer application to just before the rice is first flooded is helpful in reducing weed activity. In some of the southern States when weed grass infestations are high, rice yields are almost doubled by delaying nitrogen application until the barnyardgrass has
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE
IN UNITED STATES
87
headed. When the fertilizer is applied earlier, the barnyardgrass utilizes the applied nutrients; its competitiveness with the rice is enhanced. In California, a correctly integrated fertilizer-weed control program calls for the drilling or disking of the fertilizer to a depth of 2 to 4 inches beneath the soil surface just ahead of flooding for seeding. Properly placed fertilizer usually enables the rice to emerge from the water and to compete successfully with weeds. Phosphate fertilizer applied to the dry surface without incorporation into the seedbed or if applied to standing water accelerates development of algae and watergrass. A seed certification program has effectively reduced red rice. Smith et al. (1959) estimated that 40 to 60 per cent of the United States rice crop now is treated annually with one of the phenoxyacetic acid herbicides for the selective removal of weeds from the growing crop. Kaufman and Crafts (1956) and Ryker and Brown (1947) described the effects of the several formulations, rates, dates, and methods of application. Although the compounds can be applied by groundrig, the greater part of the acreage is treated by airplane application. The recommended rates are 6 to 24 ounces of acid equivalent per acre in 5 to 10 gallons of aqueous solution. The most frequent time of application is 55 to 65 days after seeding the rice. In California, MCPA (2-methyl4-chlorophenoxyacetic acid) has proved less likely to cause injury to the rice than 2,4-D (2,4-dichlorophenoxyaceticacid) and is now the recommended herbicide for control of many monocotyledonous weeds as well as dicotyledons. Barnyardgrasses (Echinochloa spp. ), the most serious weedy grasses common to all rice areas in the United States, recently have yielded to chemical methods of control. Smith (1960a) found that pre-emergence application to drilled rice of isopropyl N-( 3-chloropheny1)carbamate (CIPC ) at 6 to 8 pounds per acre provided good control of barnyardgrasses and did not injure rice that had been planted at a depth of 1 to 2 inches. Barnyardgrass was not killed if sprayed at the 3- or 4-leaf stage. Selectivity depended upon the location of roots in the soil so that deeper planting protected rice from the chemical. Baker (1960) mentioned a morphological characteristic of barnyardgrass in which elongation of the first internode causes the roots to be formed at the soil surface regardless of the depth of the seed. The seminal rice roots arise very near where the seed is placed and, therefore, can be protected by deep sowing. While CIPC has been recommended for barnyardgrass control in Arkansas, the method and depth of seeding, time of application, and water management are critical factors in its effectiveness. This chemical
88
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
is not widely used because poor control of the grass or rice injury often results from misuse. Smith (196Ob, 1961) reported on the evaluation of 3,4-dichloropropionanilide (DPA) as a selective postemergence herbicide for barnyardgrass control in rice. He found that in Arkansas, DPA was effective at 4 pounds per acre when the grass was in the 1- to 3-leaf stages. Rice in the 3- or 4-leaf stage was injured by application of 8 pounds per acre. Method of seeding, depth of seeding, water management, and volume of application did not affect results. In California, Viste (1961) reported that control was best when DPA was applied at 8 pounds an acre 4 weeks after seeding. Control was poor for earlier applications because grass seeds continued to germinate after treatment. Results of research and commercial-scale field trials in all rice-growing areas in 1961indicate that DPA at 3 to 4 pounds per acre will be a commercially acceptable herbicide for the selective control of barnyardgrass in rice. “Scum” or ‘moss” found in rice fields consists of algae. Scum may develop soon after flooding and interfere with the emergence of young seedlings from the water. In California, the scum problem is accentuated by incomplete incorporation of previous crop residues into the seedbed just before flooding. Chemical control has been erratically successful (Olsen, 1957). Chemicals that sometimes have been effective in Arkansas and California include copper sulfate, dichlone, /3-[2-( 3,5-dimethyl-2oxocyclohexyl ) -2-hydroxyethyl]glutarimide, and dehydroabietylamine acetate. Effective cultural control methods include deep plowing, early sowing, and judicious draining if scum appears.
B. DISEASES Most of the known important diseases of rice occur in the United States. Exceptions are rice dwarf virus, rice stripe virus, and some diseases caused by bacteria and physiological disturbances reported from Japan and other countries. Some minor fungal parasites of rice have not been reported in the United States. The rice diseases that occur in the United States were described by Atkins ( 1958). The principal ones are blast (Piriczrlaria ovyzae Cav. ), brown leaf spot (Helminthosporium oryzae de Haan), narrow brown leaf spot (Cercospora o y m e I. Miyake), root rot and seedling blight caused by various fungi, stem rot (Sclerotium o y m e Catt.), straighthead (nonparasitic), and white tip (Aphelenchoides oyzae Yokoo.). Kernel smut (Neouossia barclayanu Bref.) sometimes caused fairly heavy losses. Hoja blanca is a virus disease of rice that causes serious losses in some areas in Central and South America. It has been reported in the United States (Atkins et al., 1960) b u t has not caused important
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
89
losses. Many of these diseases can be controlled by growing resistant varieties, following recommended cultural and water management practices, or treating the seed with a fungicide or with hot water. Leaf spots are very common in the South. Losses usually are not severe, but occasionally narrow brown leaf spot causes lodging. When very severe, brown leaf spot blights the panicle. Blast sometimes is serious when nitrogen is applied in excessive amounts and the weather is damp and nights are warm. Varieties now available are resistant to the races of the causal fungus commonly occuring in the United States. Straighthead is one of the most serious diseases of rice in the South. It is a physiological disorder that can be controlled by proper water management. Tisdale and Jenkins ( 1921) reported that straighthead could be controlled by draining and drying the soil. Todd and Beachell (1954) studied this problem further and found that the water should be drained off the field and the soil thoroughly dried just before floral initiation. No variety grown in the United States is highly resistant but some are fairly resistant. In California, germinating seeds and young rice seedlings are frequently killed by products from the anaerobic decomposition of highly carbonaceous crop residues. Early draining and aerating affected fields as soon as the condition is observed usualry will correct it. White tip is caused by a seedborne foliar nematode. This disease can be controlled by treating the seed with hot water (Cralley, 1952) or with certain chemicals (Todd and Atkins, 1959). Some varieties are resistant and nematode-free seed of susceptible varieties is now sown, so this disease is no longer a problem in the United States. Several species of parasitic root nematodes ( Atkins and Fielding, 1956) and a root knot nematode (Tullis, 1934) were reported on rice in the United States, but the loss they caused has not been determined. Stem rot sometimes causes severe losses in local areas in the South. Diseased plants lodge and the grain is chalky and light. None of the varieties grown in the United States is resistant, but some are less susceptible than others. Although the sclerotia of the causal fungus live for many years in the soil ( T u b and Cralley, 1941), crop rotation, use of potash fertilizer (Cralley, 1939), and early draining (Cralley and Adair, 1943) also aid in the control of stem rot. This disease was reported in California (Tullis et al., 1934), but it has not caused losses in-that state. C. INSECTS AND OTHERPESTS There are a number of insect pests of rice in the South. The most important insects are listed (Table 111). Douglas and Ingram (1942) and more recently Bowling (1960 and
90
C . ROY AD-,
M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
Rolston and Rouse (1960) reported studies on rice insects and their control in the South. TABLE I11 Insect Pests of Rice in the United States Common name Rice stinkbug Sugarcane borer Rice stalk borer Sugarcane beetle Rice water weevil Grape Colaspis
Fall armyworm Southern corn rootworm Chinch bug Flea beetle Grasshopper Rice leaf miner
Midge
Western yellow-striped armyworm Leafhopper
Onion thrips
Scientifk name Oebalus pugnax (Fabricius) Diutraea saccharalis (Fabricius) Chilo pkjahllus Zincken Euetheola rugiceps (Le Conte) Lissorhoptnrs oryzophilus ( Kuschel) Maecolaspis Maecoluspis jluvida (Say) Paromius longulus (Dallas) Laphygmu frugiperdu (J. E. Smith) Diabrotica undecimpunctata howardi Barber Blissus leucopterus (Say) Systena hudsonias (Forster) Conocephulus fmciatus (De Geer) Hydrellia griseolu (Fallen) Lerodeu eufnlo (Edwards) Cricotopus syEueStris ( Fabricius ) Tunytarsus sp. Paralauterborniellu subcincta ( Tomes) Prodenia praefiCu Grote Draeculacephala sp. Ezitianus aitiosus (Uhler) Nesosteles neglectus ( DeLong & Davidson) Macrosteles fmcifrom (Stal) Thrips tabaci Lindeman
The rice stinkbug feeds on the grain in the milk and soft-dough stages and reduces yield and quality (Douglas and Tullis, 1950).The “pecky rice” grains usually break when milled, and kernels that do not break are damaged. Only 0.5 per cent “peck‘‘-damaged grains are allowed in No. 1 milled rice. This insect sometimes can be controlled with aldrin, dieldrin, and toxaphene. However, in Texas malathion gives the best control. The insecticide should be applied when the rice starts to head. The eggs are parasitized by two species of wasplike insects that are an important means of control. Stalk borers cause some damage to rice, especially in the Gulf Coast area. Douglas and Ingram (1942) reported losses of 2.3 to 10.3 per cent in Louisiana. Damage was least in varieties with small culms and most in varieties with large culms. The mortality of borers due to cold in the
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
91
winter is high. Fall plowing gives effective control, and heavy pasturing of stubble will reduce survival about 75 per cent. The sugarcane beetle damages rice in the seedling stage and at maturity after the fields are drained before harvest. Flooding the field will control this insect early in the season. Delayed drainage when the rice is ripe will reduce the time when damage might occur at that stage. The larvae of the rice water weevil damage rice by feeding on the roots. The damage seems to be greater in Arkansas than farther south, but this insect is sometimes a serious pest in Texas. Isely and Schwardt (1934) reported good control and increased yields by draining infested fields about 3 weeks after flooding and allowing the soil to dry before re3ooding. Seed treatment with aldrin at 1/4 pound per bushel was reported by Rolston and Rouse (1960) to give effective control. The overwintering larvae of the grape colaspis also reduce rice stands by feeding on germinating seeds and young seedlings. This insect can be controlled by treating the seed with aldrin at 1/4 pound per bushel (Rolston and Rouse, 1960). The other insects listed in Table I11 cause minor injury to rice. Usually they occur in localized areas and can be treated by hand. Grasshoppers sometimes become serious enough to warrant control by treating the field with an insecticide as recommended by Bowling ( 1960). The planthopper Sogato orixicola is the vector of the virus which causes hoja blanca. This insect has not become established in the United States, but it was found in Florida, Mississippi, and Louisiana in 1957 to 1959 (Atkins et al., 1960). Although California1 is free from most of the serious rice insect pests of the world, it does harbor many pests capable of “explosive” outbreaks (Table 111). This was demonstrated in the 1922 and 1953 outbreaks of the rice leaf miner (Lange et al., 1953). About 165,000 acres of rice were treated with dieldrin in 1953. Grigarick (1959) reported on the complicated ecological relationships of this species, existing between weather conditions, increase on native and introduced grasses, and migration of adults into rice fields. The leaf miner has been a rather minor factor in rice production since the 1953 attack, but 20,000 to 30,000 acres are treated in some years. The rice water weevil of the southern States was first found in California on June 1, 1959, near Biggs (Lange and Grigarick, 1959). This insect has not been serious on rice in California, probably because of the rather wide use of dieldrin for control of the rice leaf miner. The crustacean, commonly referred to as the tadpole shrimp, has 1 The review of the California insect pest situation was prepared in cooperation with Dr. W. H. Lange of the Entomology Department, University of California.
92
C. ROY A D A I R , M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
been a pest of rice in California since 1947 (Rosenberg, 1947). The tadpole shrimp (Triops Eongicuudutus) feeds on the young seedlings and also muddies up the water, creating conditions considered adverse to rice production. Later, Portman and Williams (1952) reported the use of DDT for control. This still is a standard control measure for this pest, although Grigarick et uZ. (1961) reported that malathion, diazinon, and sevin all have possibilities for the control of the tadpole shrimp. The larvae of midges belonging to the family Chironomidae (Tendipedidue) occasionally cause damage to rice by feeding on germinating rice or eating holes in rice blades lying on the surface of the water. Dieldrin applied when attacks occur has given satisfactory control. Darby (19Sl) found 30 species of midges breeding in rice fields and pointed out the many ecological relationships involved between midges and rice fields as freshwater habitats. In California, many other insects occasionally attack rice in certain years and under particular conditions. A butterfly larva, the rice leaf folder, causes characteristic feeding and folding of rice blades. The omnivorous yellow-striped armyworm is sometimes a severe pest of rice in localized areas. Four species of leafhoppers are associated with rice and may cause stunting and yellowing of rice foliage. Several thrips cause damage to young rice in certain years. IV. Origin, Botany, and Genetics of Rice
A.
ORIGIN Ah?) SPECIES OF O T y Z U
The many species of O y u r (Table IV) are widely distributed throughout tropical and subtropical areas of the world. The generally accepted origin of the principal cultivated species, 0. sutivu L., is southeast Asia and the adjacent islands (Chattejee, 1951). Orym glaberrima Steud., a species cultivated in West Tropical Africa, had its origin in that area. Rice probably was first cultivated in India as early as 3000 to 2500 B.C. (Chatterjee, 1947). Rice cultivation spread from India to China and the southeastern countries of Asia at a very early time. Rice was grown in countries to the west of India as early as 400 to 300 B.C. It spread to Egypt early in the Christian era and later to Europe, Africa, and the Western Hemisphere. The progenitor of Orym sutiua has not been clearly defined. Sakai (1935) and Nandi (1936) concluded from cytological studies that 0. sutiva is a secondary balanced allotetraploid which originated through hybridization between two different five-chromosome species in which two chromosomes were duplicated, owing probably to meiotic irregu-
TABLE IV Chromosome Number and Distribution of O q z a Species Species 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0.
sativa L. sativa L. forma spontanea Roschev. perennis Moench grandiglumis ( Doell. ) Prod. punctata Kotschy ex Steud. stapfii Roschev. breviligukta A. Cheval. & Roehr. australiensis Domin gkberrima Steud. alta Swallen latifolia Dew. oficinalis Wall. ex Watt eichingeri Peter minuta Presl granulata Nees & Am. ex Hook. f. meyerianu (Zoll. & Mor.) Baill. schlechteri Pilger ridleyi Hook. f. COaTCtata Roxb. brachyantha A. Cheval. & Roehr. tisseranti A. Cheval. perrieri A. Camus subulata Nees
Chromosome no. (2n) 24 and 48 24 24 24 and 48
-
24 24 24 24 24 and 48 48 24 48 48 24 and 48 24
48 48 24
-
24
Distribution India and Indochina Asia Tropical America, West Indies, Tropical Africa, Ceylon, and India South America North East Tropical Africa West Tropical Africa West Tropical Africa Australia West Tropical Africa South America and Central America Central America, South America, and West Indies India and Burma East Africa Malay Peninsula, Philippines, Sumatra, Java, and Bomeo India, Burma, Java, and Siam Java, Bomeo, Philippines, and Siam New Guinea Malay Peninsula, Siam, Borneo, and New Guinea India and Burma West Tropical and Central Africa Central Africa Madagascar South America
2
j 5
2
2 a 5E 2 d
i ?
i!
94
C. ROY ADAJR, M. D.
MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
larities in the hybrid. A subsequent doubling of the chromosomes attained the secondary balance of n = 12, the present existing number in 0. satiua. More recently, Shastry et al. (1960) reported that on the basis of their length and arm ratios, 12 pachytene bivalents in a s t r a i n of 0. satioa could be identified. This report cast some doubt on the validity that 0. sativa is a secondary balanced allotetraploid. It was suggested by G. Watt, according to Chattejee (1948), that OT~JZU safiuu might have been derived from wild rices in India. Ramiah sativa and Chose (1951) stated that “there is clear evidence that OTYZU var. futzta which occurs mainly in South and East Asia in a large number of forms and crossed freely with 0. sativa has contributed to the enormous varietal diversity existing in India.” Sampath and Govindaswami (1958) presented evidence in support of their theory that 0. satiua var. fatua Prain is a progeny of the cross 0. sativa x 0. perennis Moench., and that 0. perennis was the progenitor of 0. satiua. Results reported by Yeh and Henderson (1961) support this theory. However, 0. sutiua var. fatw occurs as a weed in rice fields in South and East Asia and crosses readiIy with cultivated varieties (0.sativu); so its does contribute to the “varietal diversity.” Much is known regarding interrelationships between species of 0y z a as a result of investigations presented by Roschevicz (1931), Kihara ( 1959), Chattejee (1951), Sampath and Rao (1951), Ramiah and Chose ( 1951), and Yeh and Henderson ( 19sl). However, as Kihara ( 1959) pointed out, much study is needed to elucidate fully the origin and evolution of the genus Oyza. The 23 species of Oyzn and the chromosome number and distribution as enumerated by Chatterjee (1948) and Kihara (1959) are shown in Table IV. Since the synonomy used by Chatterjee was followed, some of the species shown by Kihara ( 1959) and Roschevicz (1931) are not listed. “Oryzu perennis var. b a h g a ” is not listed although Yeh and Henderson (1961) presented evidence that this form should have specific status as 0. balunga.”
B. DESCRIPTION OF THE RICE PLANT Rice ( O y z a sutiua) in the Gramineae tribe Oryzeae usually is described as an annual although it is a perennial when soil moisture and temperature are optimum for continued growth. Rice plants have been maintained in the greenhouse for over twenty years. The roots which arise from the lower nodes spread laterally and do not usually penetrate more than 6 inches in depth. The primary culm has 12 to 18 nodes, depending upon the variety, but only 4 to 7 elongate. There is a bud or potential bud in the axil of the leaf at each node that can give
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
95
rise to a tiller. When space and soil fertility are optimal, some varieties may produce as many as 100 tillers although when sown at the rate usually followed in the United States, the number of tillers is 2 or 3. The culms have hollow stems and solid nodes and vary in length from 2 to 6 or more feet, depending upon variety, soil fertility, and other factors. Most varieties in the United States have culms 3 to 5 feet long. The leaf consists of a sheath, auricle, ligule, junctura, and blade. There is a leaf at each node, but the number of functional leaves at any one time is usually 4 or 5 because the older, lower leaves die as new leaves are produced. The leaf blades vary in width from about a fourth to more than a half inch, and the color ranges from light yellowish green to dark green. The inflorescence is a panicle with the branches arranged singly or in pairs. It varies from compact and erect to open and drooping. The spikelet has one flower; it is strongly compressed laterally and articulates below the two small outer glumes. Two bract-like organs occur at the enlarged end of the pedicel. Weatherwax (1929) stated that these bractlets are sometimes sufficiently elongated to be mistaken for glumes. The true glumes are above the articulation. The “flowering glumes” are the lemma, which has five nerves and may terminate in an awn, and the palea, which has three nerves, two of which may terminate in short conical teeth. There are two lodicules at the base of the palea, which become turgid and open the flowering glumes at anthesis. The flower consists of six stamens and a two-branched plumose stigma. Anthesis usually occurs between 9:00 A.M. and 2:OO P.M. (Adair, 1934). The time the flowers open is influenced by temperature and sunlight. They open earlier on warm and sunny days than on cool or cloudy days. Rice is normally self-pollinated although as much as 0.5 per cent natural crossing may occur in the United States (Beachell et al., 1938). The amount of natural crossing is higher when the relative humidity of the air is high. C. GENETICS, CYTOLOGY, AND LINKAGE GROUPSIN RICE Most genetic studies on rice have been conducted in Japan, India, China, or the United States. Most cytological studies that have been reported were done in Japan, India, or the United States. Several papers summarized rice genetic studies and two or three attempts were made during the last twenty years to standardize the system of gene nomenclature in rice. Jones (1936) summarized information on the mode of inheritance of characters in rice. Kadam and Ramiah (1943) pointed out the need of a standard system of gene nomenclature and suggested a system that
96
C . ROY A D A I R , hl. D. MILLER, A N D H. M. BEACHELL
might be used. They also summarized results of all available genetic studies on rice. Nagao (1951) summarized the rice genetic data and proposed a modification of the system outlined by Kadam and Ramiah. Nagao also defined 4 linkage groups. Jodon (1955) summarized the information on rice genetics and defined 8 linkage groups, and Nagao and Takahashi (1960) gave a preliminary report on 12 linkage groups in rice. The International Rice Commission (FAO) Working Party on Rice Breeding in the 1955 meeting recognized the need for a standardized system of genic nomenclature and for a comprehensive survey of the information available on linkage relationships in rice. A committee then was appointed to undertake the work of proposing a system of nomenclature and summarizing the data on linkage groups. A preliminary summary of the committee report (Anonymous, 1959) outlines the system suggested for nomenclature of rice genes and gives the recommended symbols for each gene that has been studied. The system proposed by this committee follows the rules of the International Genetic Congress. The report of this committee also summarized the information on linkage groups in rice which followed closely the summary by Nagao and Takahashi (1960). A more extensive review of the subject has been prepared by this committee (Anonymous, 1962). V. Rice Breeding and Improvement in the United States
A. HISTORYOF RICEBREEDING IN THE UNITED STATES Although rice varieties were introduced subsequent to the establishment of rice culture in South Carolina, no effort was made by Federal or State agencies to improve rice varieties for the United States until rather recently. An abortive attempt was made in 1866, but the seed of the four varieties introduced failed to germinate. However, work was started by the U. S. Department of Agriculture in 1899 when Seaman A. Knapp, then an explorer in the Division of Botany, introduced from Japan 10 tons of Kyushu rice which was distributed in southwestern Louisiana and probably eastern Texas, where he arranged farm demonstrations of rice varieties and cultural methods. Many varieties were introduced and tested by Department workers on demonstration farms in Louisiana and Texas and later in Arkansas and California before the establishment of Rice Experiment Stations in these states. The Rice Experiment Station at Crowley, Louisiana, was established in 1909. The Biggs Rice Field Station, Biggs, California, and the Rice Experiment Station, Beaumont, Texas, were established in 1912. The Rice Branch Experiment Station, Stuttgart, Arkansas, was established
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
97
in 1926. Rice experiments were conducted also at Elsbeny from 1928 to 1941 and later at Palmira in Missouri. Rice investigations were started at the Delta Branch Experiment Station, Stoneville, Mississippi, in a small way about 1950, and a fairly comprehensive breeding program now is being conducted. Breeding investigations are conducted cooperatively by the U.S. Department of Agriculture with State Agricultural Experiment Stations at each of these locations. Most of the earlier work consisted of testing selections from foreign introductions. Some of the varieties developed by selection from 1909 to about 1930 were CALORO, COLUSA, FORTUNA, NIRA, and REXORO. CALORO and COLUSA are the leading varieties at this time in California, and REXORO is grown on a significant acreage in Louisiana and Texas. Salmon L. Wright, a rice farmer in Louisiana, obtained material from varietal experiments on demonstration farms before the establishment of the Rice Experiment Station at Crowley. From this material he selected the medium-grain varieties BLUE ROSE and EARLY PROLIFIC and the long-grain varieties EDITH and LADY WRIGHT. None of these varieties is now in production, but for many years, about 1915 to 1944, they were the leading varieties in the South. The varieties developed during these earlier years were described by Chamliss and Jenkins (1923), Jones ( 1936), and Jones et al. ( 1941). Rice improvement investigations were summarized by Jones ( 1936). He stated that at that time the objectives were “to develop varieties that are resistant to diseases, that do not lodge or shatter, that mature at the desired time and that produce high field and mill yields of good table quality.’’ It is seen that the present-day objectives, as given in Section V, B, are simply a refinement and more detailed statement of the earlier objective.
B. CURRENT OBJECTIVES AND METHODS FOR
THE RICE-BREEDING PROGRAM IN THE UNITED STATES
Rice-breeding research at all experiment stations in the United States is closely coordinated. This coordination is achieved because most of this work is conducted cooperatively by the U. S . Department of Agriculture and the State Experiment Stations. The Rice Technical Working Group meets biennially, so all rice breeders and geneticists can discuss their common problems with other rice research workers. Uniform yield and disease experiments conducted in the South further unify the work. Objectives of the rice-breeding program are to develop short-, medium-, and long-grain varieties that germinate quickly and have seedling vigor; tolerate low temperatures in the germinating and seedling stages; are resistant to alkaline soils and salt in the irrigation water; are
98
C . ROY ADAIR, M. D. MILLER, AND H. M. BEACHELL
resistant to diseases and insects; respond to maximum rates of fertilizers; have short, stifE straw and resist lodging; mature uniformly; produce high field and mill yields over a wide range of environmental conditions; and have the desired cooking and processing characteristics. Breeding methods used for rice have followed the usual pattern for all small grains. Up until about 1920, rice varieties were introduced from most rice-producing countries and tested for adaptation in the United States. Selections were made from the better varieties and several fairly well-adapted varieties were obtained. These are mentioned in Section V, A. It was not possible to attain all breeding objectives by these methods; so, about 1920, some of the rice breeders started to make crosses in an attempt to combine desired characteristics. All varieties that have been released since 1942 are progeny of hybrids. The backcross or a modified backcross method now is commonly used. One example of a method now commonly used to achieve a breeding objective is described: In 1956, the potential threat of hoja blanca, a virus disease, to rice production in the United States was recognized. In 1957, experiments were started in Cuba and Venezuela to test all available material to determine the reaction to the hoja blanca disease. It was learned that many varieties and breeding lines were resistant. All the leading commercial varieties grown in the United States were susceptible to hoja blanca, but short- and medium-grain types were resistant and could be grown if the disease became established in this country. There were no hoja blanca-resistant long-grain varieties adapted to the environmental and cultural practices in the United States. Crosses between resistant types and leading United States long-grain varieties were made in the field in 1957. The F1 plants were grown in the greenhouse and some were backcrossed to the long-grain parent during the winter of 1957-1958. When this program started, the backcrossed plants were saved until their progeny had been tested to see which carried genes for resistance to hoja blanca. The plants carrying resistance were then backcrossed to the long-grain parent. It now i s possible to plant the backcross seeds; and as soon as the plants tiller, they can be divided and a part of each plant tested for reaction to hoja blanca in the greenhouse. Results of these tests are available by the time the plants flower so that resistant plants can be backcrossed to the recurring parent. Plants have been selected from each round of crossing and the progeny continued in the selecting and testing program. Concurrently with testing this material for reaction to hoja blanca, the lines were tested for cooking and processing characteristics as described in Section V, C.
RICE IMPROVEMENT AND CULTURE IN UNITED STATES
99
C. RESULTS OF THE RICE-BREEDING PROGRAM All the rice varieties now grown in the United States were developed by the U. S. Department of Agriculture in cooperation with the State Agricultural Experiment Stations and other agencies. All varieties being grown on farms and a few varieties that had been used as parents but were not in production were described by Johnston (1958). Of the 22 varieties described by this author, 16 were developed and released after about 1930, and 6 had been developed and released earlier. One of these older varieties is BLUE ROSE, one of the Salmon L. Wright varieties mentioned in Section V, A. Most of these varieties were described by Jones et aE. (1953). Two additional varieties, GULFROSE and BELLE PATNA, have been released since 1958. The annual acreage and production of rice varieties in the United States for 1956 to 1960, inclusive, are given (Table V ) . The total acreage was about the same in 1960 as in 1956 but it was lower in 1957 and 1958. The acreage of the R E x o R o - t y p e varieties declined sharply during this period, but there was an increase in acreage in 1960 as compared with that in 1959. The acreage of CENTURY PATNA 231 declined sharply. The acreage of BLUEBONNET 50 increased slightly as did that of ARKROSE. The CALROSE acreage increased in 1960 in California with a corresponding decrease in the acreage of the short-gain varieties CALORO and COLUSA. The acreage of TORO increased sharply in 1957 and 1958 and then declined in 1959 and leveled off in 1960. The greatest change in varieties was the rapid increase in the acreage of NATO and the corresponding decline in the acreage of ZENITH and MAGNOLIA. The days from seeding to maturity, plant height, and grain yields for 13 of the leading varieties are given (Table VI). The long-grain, late