ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 21
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME
F. J. CARLISLE D. J. GREENLAND
R. B. GROSSMAN S. B. HEA...
30 downloads
1759 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 21
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME
F. J. CARLISLE D. J. GREENLAND
R. B. GROSSMAN S. B. HEATH CHARLES E. KELLOGG
OLIVER E. NELSON J. M. OADES ARNOLD C . ORVEDAL W. F. RAYMOND
G. D. SWINCER R. W. WILLEY
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared under the Auspices of the
AMERICAN SOCIETY
OF
AGRONOMY
VOLUME 21
Edifed by N. C. BRADY Roberts Hall, Cornell University, ithaca, New York
ADVISORY BOARD
R. R. DAVIS F. A. HASKINS W. D. KEMPER
.I.P. MARTIN
J . W. PENDLETON W. A. RANEY 1969
@
ACADEMIC PRESS 0 N e w York and London
COPYRIGHT ‘C 1969,
BY
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, W I T H O U T WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM T H E PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. 1 1 1 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. Berkeley Square House, London W 1X 6BA
LIBRARY OF
CONGRESS CATALOG C A R D
NUMBER50-5598
PRI N TED IN T H E UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 21 Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
F. J . CARLISLE ( 2 3 7 ) , Soil Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Hyattsville, Maryland D. J . GREENLAND (195), Depurtment of Agricultural Biochemistry and Soil Science, Waite Agricultural Research Institute, University of Adelaide, South Australia R. B. GROSSMAN ( 2 3 7 ) , Soil Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Lincoln, Nebraska S . B. HEATH(28 11, Department of Agriculture, University of Reading, Reading Berkshire, England CHARLES E. KELLOGG( I09), Soil Survey, Soil Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C. OLIVER E . NELSON* (17 l ) , Purdue University, Lafayetre, Indiana J . M . OADES(195), Department of Agricultural Biochemistry and Soil Science, Waite Agricultural Research Institute, University of Adelaide, South Australia ARNOLDC. ORVEDAL ( 109), Soil Survey, Soil Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C. W. F . RAYMOND( I ) , The Grassland Research Institute, Hurley, England G . D. SWINCER (195), Department of Agricultural Biochemistry and Soil Science, Waite Agricultural Research Institute, University of Adelaide, South Australia R. W. WILLEY t (28 I ) , Department ofAgriculture, University of Reading, Reading Berkshire, England
*Present address: University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin. t Presenr address: Makerere University College, Kampala, Uganda. V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE
This volume marks a significant milestone in the history of Advances in Agronomy. The first 20 volumes were compiled under the very capable editorship of Dr. A. G. Norman, now Vice-president for Research at the University of Michigan. Mounting pressures of other responsibilities have prompted Dr. Norman to ask to be relieved as editor of this serial publication; this is the first volume that does not carry his name. It is fitting that we reflect briefly on the contributions he has made, not only to this work but to his profession as well. As editor of Advances in Agronomy, Dr. Norman has given 20 years of faithful service and leadership to agronomists and soil and crop scientists throughout the world. His extraordinarily good judgment in the selection of authors and of subject matter has been largely responsible for the success of this publication. His guidance to authors has helped both them and the quality of their papers. He has seen Advunces in Agronomy grow from a struggling review journal of concern only to American scientists to a prominent review series with contributors and subscribers in many nations. Dr. Norman has found other ways to benefit his profession. He has contributed directly as an active researcher in soil microbiology and in soil and plant biochemistry. He has served as director of a large, interdisciplinary research unit and has enriched the education and training of many soil and crop scientists as well as biologists. We are also indebted to Dr. Norman for his service in scientific societies. He served as vice-president and later president of the American Society of Agronomy during a very critical period in the Society’s history. In addition, for a period of three years he served as chairman of the Division of Biology and Agriculture of the National Research Council. Even though Dr. Norman has resigned his editorial responsibilities, Advances in Agronomy fortunately will reflect his influence for some time to come. The challenge of maintaining Dr. Norman’s high standards and the broad subject matter coverage he provided is materially aided by the efforts of such men as the eleven who have contributed to this Volume 2 I.
N. C. BRADY Ithaca, New York August, I969
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 21
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PREFACE .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
vii
2 3
.
.
.
.
V
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS W . F . RAYMOND
. . . . . . . . . . . I . Introduction . . . . . . . I 1 . The Components of Nutritive Value . . . . . . 111. The Digestibility of Forage Crops . . . . . IV . The Digestibility of Different Forage Species . . . . . . V . The Voluntary Intake of Forages . . . VI . The Efficiency of Utilization of Digested Nutrients . VII . The Relationship between Forage Quality and Forage Yield . . . . VIII . Forage Breeding for Improved Nutritive Value . IX . The Effects of Processing on the Components of Forage . . . . . . . . . . Nutritive Value . X . The Nutritive Value of Grazed Forage . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
. . .
. . .
.
.
. .
. .
65
4 16
27 38 68
.
.
.
.
69 80
.
.
97
. . . . .
. . . . .
POTENTIALLY ARABLE SOILS OF THE WORLD A N D CRITICAL MEASURES FOR THEIR USE CHARLES E. KELLOGGA N D ARNOL.D C . ORVEDAL
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . I 1 . The Principle of Interactions in Soil Use . 111 . Higher Production from Existing Arable Soils IV . New Potentially Arable Soils . . . . References . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
109
I12 122 140 169
GENETIC MODIFICATION OF PROTEIN QUALITY I N PLANTS OLIVERE . NELSON
I . lntroduction . . . . . . . . . . . . I I . The Genetic Control of Protein Structure . 111 . The Relative Constancy of Leaf Protein Composition
ix
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
171 173 177
X
CONTENTS
IV. The Storage Proteins of Seeds . . . . V. Theopaque-2 andJloury-2 Mutations in Maize VI. The Prospects of Improvements in Other Plants VI1. Summary . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
178 I80 I87 I90 191
THE EXTRACTION, CHARACTERIZATION, A N D SIGNIFICANCE OF SOIL POLYSACCHARIDES G. D. SWINCER, J. M. OADES,A N D D. J. GREENLAND I. Soil Carbohydrates . . . . . . . . . . 11. The Significance of Soil Polysaccharides . . . . . I l l . Studies on Soil Polysaccharides . . . . . . . IV. Methods for the Analysis of Complex Polysaccharide Materials V. Summary and Conclusions. . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
. .
. .
195 196 I99 222 229 230
FRAGIPAN SOILS OF THE EASTERN UNITED STATES R. B. GROSSMAN A N D F. J. CARLISLE 1. 11. 111.
IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX.
x.
Introduction . . . . . . Horizons of Fragipan Soils . . Occurrence of Fragipan Soils . . Properties of Fragipans . . . Fragipans and the Soil Water Regime . . . Genesis of Fragipans . Fragipans and Soil Use . . . Classification of Fragipan Soils. . Unresolved Problems. . . . Summary . . . . . . References . . . . . . Appendix . . . . . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
231 240 244 246 254 256 263 265 269 27 I 272 276
THE QUANTITATIVE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN PLANT POPULATION A N D CROP YIELD R. W. WILLEYA N D S. B. HEATH
I. 11.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . Relationships between Plant Density and Crop Yield.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
28 I 283
xi
CONTENTS
I l l . The Relationship between Plant Rectangularity IV. The Variation in Yield of the Individual Plant . . . . . . . V. Conclusions . . . . . . . . References .
AUTHORI N D E X . SUBJECT INDEX .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . . .
.
. . .
3 14 317 319 3 20
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
323
and Crop Yield
338
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS W. F. Raymond The Grassland Research Institute, Hurley, England
I. 11. 111.
IV.
V.
VI.
VII. v111. IX.
X.
Page Introduction. ...... ........................................................... 2 The Components of Nutritive Value .................................. .... 3 The Digestibility of Forage Crops ........... .................. 4 A. The Measurement of Digestibility in .................. 4 B. The Prediction of Forage Digestibility from Chemical Composition ....... 6 .... 7 C. Improved Chemical Techniques ..... . . . . . ................... ..... D. Estimation of Forage Digestibility by in Vitro Techniques ................. 10 E. The Relative Utility of Chemical and in Virro Estimations of Forage Digestibility _ . _ _____ . _,_. .._ _ _ _ ___._.__..__, _ _ _ _ . .._....._.___. ._.......... 16 The Digestibility of Different Forage Species ..._...._.... ... . ..... 16 16 A. Basic Patterns of Digestibility ....................... B. The Digestibility of Different Plant Fractions .. _........_____..._. 20 C. The Effect of Environmental and Other Factors on ...... ......... Forage Digestibility , . , . , . . . . . . . _ ._ . _ _ _ _ _._. ._. . _. . ,_..., __............. 23 .............................................. 27 The Voluntary Intake of Forages 27 A. The Factors Controlling Feed Intake ........................... 28 B. Intrinsic Factors Determining Forage Intake ..._.. .........._ 35 C. The Nutritive Value Index ........................................................... D. The Crude Protein Content of Forage and Voluntary Intake .............. 36 E. The Effect of Supplementary Feeds on Forage Intake ..... 37 The Efficiency of Utilization of Digested Nutrients. .................. 38 A. Methods of Expressing Energy Values ....... . , , .. .. .. ................ . .. ........ 38 B. The Role of Volatile Fatty Acids in Ruminant 40 C . The Utilization of the Crude Protein in Forages .................. 48 D. The Use of Nonprotein Nitrogen in Ruminant 51 E. The Mineral Nutrients in Forages ................................................. 54 F. Pharmacologically Active Components in Forage .................. 61 The Relationship between Forage Quality and Forage Yield ...... .............. 65 Forage Breeding for Improved Nutritive Value ....... . . ........... ..... 68 The Effects of Processing on the Components of Forage Nutritive Value , . _.. .._,, . . . _ .. . . . . . , , _ _ _...... . . ..., . . . . . ............. .............. 69 .......................................... 69 B. The Grinding and Pelleting of Dehydrated Forages ........ 71 C . The Ensiling of Forage Crops .......... ................................... 74 The Nutritive Value of Grazed Forage .... ................................... 80 A. Measurement of the Nutrient Intake by Grazing Animals ..... 80
2
W. F. RAYMOND
B. The Botanical Composition of Grazed Forage ................................. C. The Nutrient Intake of Grazing Livestock ...................................... D. The Effect of Management on the Productivity of Grazing Animals ........................................................................ References .......................................................................................
90 91 94 97
1. Introduction
Forages are grown for ruminant feeding, most ruminant animals eat forages. Thus a review of the nutritive value of forages is essentially a review of ruminant nutrition, yet with the difference that the nutritionist can treat the animal and the forage it eats in isolation, whereas the agronomist must also consider the problems that arise when the animal and its feed are brought together in practical systems of forage production and utilization. Ruminant feeding to date has been a nonintensive system of land use, in comparison with crop farming or the feeding of nonruminant livestock. This has been justified on the basis that forages are cheap to grow, and that harvesting by grazing is a cheap method of utilization. However, as Melville ( 1960) emphasized, present extensive pastoral systems produce very low outputs of human food per acre; as world demand for food increases, pastures will either have to become markedly more productive, or be replaced by crops that can be used by nonruminants, or directly by humans. In the latter cases forage-ruminant systems would be confined to noncultivable agricultural areas, and so would contribute only marginally to the nutrition of the world’s population. At that time of apparent food surpluses the replacement of ruminant products seemed remote; today analogue substitutes are already serious competitors to meat and milk in North America, the most sophisticated consumer market in the world. To date this competition has been in terms of cost and convenience; in future it will increasingly be in terms of competition for land, as foreseen by Melville. This means that the efficiency of soil-forage-ruminant systems must be greatly increased if they are to continue as a significant sector of agriculture. Raymond (1968) has considered this problem in terms of (a) the efficiency of use of incident light energy by the growing plant, (b) the proportion of the energy in the plant which is actually eaten by the ruminant animal, and (c) the efficiency with which different animal populations convert the energy they eat into products which can be used by humans. In many cases it appears that stages (b) and (c) are the main factors limiting the output of ruminant products per acre; until we can
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
3
ensure that a high proportion of the forage grown is eaten by efficient animals, there may be little advantage in concentrating effort on growing more forage. Efficiency of feed conversion (c) depends on many factors, including the structure of the animal population (the proportion of adult breeding animals to productive offspring; Spedding, 1965) and the genetic potential of the animals. But a dominant factor is the level of nutrient intake of the animals being fed: the higher the level of nutrient intake, the higher the level of productivity of the animals, and the lower the nutrient requirement for each unit of animal output. Thus, as the daily nutrient intake of the 300-kg. steer increases from 15.3 to 20.3 Mcal. of metabolizable energy, its daily rate of liveweight gain increases from 0.5 to 1.25 kg. per day: the corresponding requirement of metabolizable energy per kilogram gain decreases markedly from 30.6 to 16.2 Mcal. (Raymond, 1968). II. The Components of Nutritive Value
Thus the nutritive value of a forage should be considered not as a single parameter, but as composed of a complex of parameters that determine the nutrient intake of ruminant animals fed on that forage. In this it differs from the classical concept of nutritive value as a feed concentration (starch equivalent, total digestible nutrients, or net energy) by including feed intake as an integral component of nutritive value. With the major economic feeds of earlier feeding systems (cereals and pulses, oilseed residues, and industrial by-products) this was not necessary, as the quantity eaten was controlled by rationing; with forages, on the other hand, there is seldom any formal control of the amount eaten, which therefore depends on factors in the forage and in its method of presentation. This review therefore considers the nutritive value of forages in terms of the factors that determine the level of nutrient intake by ruminant livestock. It has proved useful to treat nutrient intake as the product of three parameters (Raymond, 1969b): Nutrient intake
= intake X
of feed x digestibility of feed efficiency of utilization of digested feed
(1)
each of which can be investigated separately, before their interactions in practical systems of ruminant feeding are considered. The importance of this approach is indicated by the conclusion of lngalls er al. ( 1 965) that 70 percent of the variation in production potential between forages can be accounted for in terms of differences in voluntary intake, compared with 30 percent by differences in digestibility, the nutrient concentration
4
W. F. RAYMOND
measure of earlier systems. Equation (1) is also possibly more informative than the analogous nutritive value index (Crampton et al., 1960), which combines intake and digestibility in one parameter, so that the relative importance of these two factors is not immediately evident. However, nutritive value and nutrient intake can have no real meaning except in relation to the needs of ruminant animals. Different animals have different nutritional requirements, depending on their species, sex, physiological status, and level of production, and this means that the nutritional adequacy of a forage diet can be assessed only in terms of the nutritional needs of the particular animals to be fed. The requirements by different classes of stock for energy, protein, minerals, and vitamins have been tabulated (Morrison, 1957; Agricultural Research Council, 1965; National Academy of Sciences, 1966). The objective must then be to establish relevant parameters to describe the nutritive value of forages which can be equated with these nutrient needs. The components in Eq. (1) provide a framework within which to assess our current knowledge of these nutritional parameters. Of these components, the digestibility of forage is considered first, because of the important influence which digestibility exerts on the other two components, intake and efficiency of utilization. These components are discussed in relation to fresh forages, but particular emphasis is then given to the effects of processing methods, feed interactions, and methods of feeding, all of which can markedly alter the basic nutritional features of forages. The practical aim must be to exploit this new information so as to improve the nutritional potential of forage feeding systems, and the effectiveness with which soil-forage-ruminant systems can compete for the world’s increasingly scarce land resources. Ill. The Digestibility of Forage Crops
A. THEMEASUREMENT OF DIGESTIBILITY in
ViVO
The digestibility of a feed is defined: Digestibility = ‘Ieed
- cfses
X
100
cfeed
Where Cfed is the amount of feed or feed component eaten (organic matter, cellulose, protein), and Cfecesis the corresponding amount of fecal excretion. The measurement of digestibility requires a preliminary feeding period during which the experimental animals adapt to the feed under test, followed by a test period, during which feed eaten and fecal output are measured. For precise measurement preliminary and test
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
5
periods of at least 10 days are recommended (Raymond et al., 1953); this presents the particular difficulty with fresh forages that the forage must be cut daily, and so may change in digestibility and chemical composition during this experimental period. In many studies this day-to-day variation in feed characteristics has been overcome by cutting at one time sufficient fresh forage for the complete digestibility experiment, and preserving this forage so that it can be fed over an extended period. Storage as hay (J. R. Jones and Hogue, 1963) or after artificial drying (Kivimae, 1959) has been used but, because of the changes in digestibility possible with these methods, cold storage of forages has been adopted by some workers (Raymond et al., 1953; Pigden et al., 196 1 ; Minson, 1966). The technique of storage at 5°F. has been described in detail (Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, 1961, pp. 88 and 150); it has been shown to have a negligible effect on the digestibility of the dry matter or organic matter in forage (Raymond et al., 1953) or of the rate of digestion within the rumen (Pigden et al., 1961), but slightly reduces the digestibility of the crude protein fraction (Raymond et al., 1953; Minson, 1966). An alternative technique, the continuous digestion trial with fresh forage, is now being increasingly widely used (Greenhalgh er al., 1960; Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, 196 1 ; Ademosum et al., 1968). Herbage is cut and fed daily over an extended period, and the amounts of forage eaten and feces voided are measured daily throughout the experiment. The amounts of forage eaten and feces are summed over 5day subperiods, allowing a 2-day lag for passage of the feces, and digestibility coefficients are calculated on these subperiods, each of which serves as the preliminary (adaption) treatment for the succeeding subperiod. This technique has proved of particular use in association with grazing experiments (see Section X,A,2), but it is less accurate than the cold-storage technique because of the shorter balance periods used. The measurement of the digestibility of forages conserved by natural or artificial dehydration presents no such problem, and most of the reported data on forage digestibility relate to such feeds. Silage is generally removed daily from silos for feeding, but cold storage of silage (Harris and Raymond, 1963) requires less labor, and eliminates any risk of day-to-day variation in silage quality. The many thousands of recorded determinations of forage digestibility have been collated at intervals and provide the broad background to our present understanding of forage nutritive value (Schneider, 1952; Leitch, 1969; tropical forages, Butterworth, 1967). However, such compila-
6
W. F. RAYMOND
tions may be of limited value in indicating the digestibility of an “unknown” forage, because of the difficulty of identifying it with a particular feed class. This problem, long recognized, led to the development of techniques such as the Weende feed analysis for estimating nutritive values; a major advance in the period under review has been in the development of improved laboratory techniques for predicting the nutritive value of forages, to replace wherever possible the laborious and expensive in vivo determination.
B. THE PREDICTION OF FORAGE DIGESTIBILITY FROM CHEMICAL COMPOSITION As Van Soest (1968) has noted, animal nutrition has had a history of inertia and complacency, each further experiment carried out with old techniques and old terminologies making it yet more difficult to adopt new ones. But it is still difficult to create a logical pattern from the torrent of new analytical techniques and new parameters of nutritive value that have recently been put forward to replace these older concepts. The requirement is to establish a relationship between a nutritional parameter (e.g., digestibility) of forages, measured in controlled in vivo experiments, and the chemical composition of the same forages, from which the nutritive value of other forages can be predicted. Digestion of forage by the ruminant is a most complex process; yet for nearly a century the attempt was made to predict the extent of forage digestion in terms of its proximate analysis based on Weende crude fiber, crude protein and nitrogen-free extractives. Sullivan (1 962) and Dijkstra ( 1 966) have both shown that when these analyses are applied to a limited range of forages close relationships between digestibility and chemical composition can be established, but that these relationships become less precise as the range of forages included is increased. As a forage crop matures its fiber content increases and it becomes less digestible; a close negative relationship between fiber content and digestibility is found. But this relationship is likely to differ from that with a different forage species (in particular, tropical forages; Butterworth, 1963) or from that with the same forage species at a different time of year; in each case the forage becomes less digestible as it becomes more fibrous, but at a given fiber content different forages can have markedly different levels of digestibility. To some extent this can be overcome by using tabulations of relationships, each based on a limited feed class (Dijkstra, 1966). But again these pose the problem of allocation to a particular feed class; more seriously, they add little to our basic understanding of the factors that determine forage digestibility.
T H E NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
7
The inadequacy of crude fiber as a determinant of nutritive value was clearly established by Norman ( 1 935). Tentative alternatives to crude fiber were proposed: cellulose (Crampton and Maynard, 1938), holocellulose (Ely and Moore, 1955), modified acid-detergent fiber (Clancy and Wilson, 1966). Each of these aimed to analyze a more precise chemical grouping than crude fiber, but each perhaps reflected the same basic thinking, that the complex process of forage digestion can be quantified by a single chemical analysis. The relationships between these “fiber” components and forage digestibility (reviewed by Miller, 196 1 ; Sullivan, 1962), are often more precise than those based on crude fiber; they are still inadequate for predictive purposes. This conclusion, which had become evident by 1960, stimulated the two main developments discussed below: the study of chemical techniques more relevant to the digestion process, and of biological techniques that attempt to simulate the process of rumen digestion by a laboratory technique. C. IMPROVEDCHEMICAL TECHNIQUES Forage digestibility, Eq. (2), is the summation C% content X % digestibility of all the different chemical components in the forage. Some of these components, such as soluble carbohydrates and organic acids, are completely digested as the forage passes through the ruminant tract; others, in particular the polysaccharides and lignin, are much less completely digested and comprise most of the feed residue excreted as feces. The “classical” approach, discussed above, assumes that the extent to which the fiber fraction is digested is directly related to the proportion of that fraction in the forage. Detailed studies of the digestibility of different fiber fractions, based on in vivo experiments, have clearly shown that this is not so. Thus Jarrige and Minson (1964) found that there was no decrease in the digestibility of the cellulose in S.24 ryegrass as the cellulose content increased from 14.1 to 19.0 percent of the dry matter in early spring, while Gaillard (1962) and others showed that the cellulose in alfalfa is much less digestible than that in grasses with the same content of cellulose. This led to the development of techniques of graded extraction with reagents of increasing concentration (Gaillard, 1958; Jarrige, 196 1 ; Burdick and Sullivan, 1963) and of cellulose solubility in cupriethylenediamine (Dehority and Johnson, 1963) which take some account of the chain length and resistance to digestion of the different polysaccharide fractions. However, no single procedure is likely to give results relevant to the wide range of polysaccharides and lignin that comprise the fiber
8
W. F. RAYMOND
fraction in forages, and Gaillard (1966) has developed a more comprehensive relationship between forage digestibility and composition: Digestibility of organic matter % = 0.37(C-19.19) - 5.51(L-5.58) - 0.51(H-18.10) (3) + 4. I I(U-3.80) 65. I
+
which includes the percent contents of cellulose (C), lignin (L), hemicellulose (H), and anhydrouronic acid (U). More recently Gaillard and Nijkamp (1968) have proposed a less complex analytical system, which replaces the separate determinations of cellulose and hemicellulose with neutral-detergent fiber (N DF, v.i.): Digestibility of organic matter % = 66.7 - 4.64(L-5.19)- 0.14(NDF-48.05) + 2.95(U-3.47)
(4)
An alternative approach, developed by Van Soest (1 967) and Terry and Tilley ( 1964a), emphasizes the contribution to total forage digestibility of the highly digestible cell-contents fraction in forages. These workers have considered forage to contain two main fractions, the cell contents which are almost completely digested, and the cell-wall constituents, which are only partly digested, and they have proposed analytical systems that (a) separate these two fractions and (b) indicate the extent to which the cell-wall fraction would be digested in the ruminant tract. In a series of papers (summarized by Van Soest, 1967) this author has described methods for separating a forage sample into a cell-contents fraction soluble in neutral detergent (S), and an insoluble cell-wall fraction (neutral-detergent fiber, NDF), as well as a fiber fraction insoluble in acid detergent (acid-detergent fiber, ADF) and lignin (L). In a key paper (Van Soest and Moore, 1966), the digestibility of the N D F fraction was shown to be negatively correlated with log X (r = -0.98**) where X , the concentration of lignin in the A D F fraction, effectively measures the extent of lignification of the cellulose in the forage (in that paper X was denoted as L, which was confused with percent lignin). The mechanism by which lignin reduces fiber digestibility probably includes the effects of physical incrustation, of lignin-carbohydrate complexes, and of molecular bonds. Van Soest (1967) also showed that the cell-content fraction in forages is almost completely digested (98 percent) by the ruminant. However, a significant amount of material soluble in neutral detergent occurs in ruminant feces. This is not undigested plant cell contents, but consists of endogenous materials (mucus, salts, bile residues, and undigested bacteria) resulting from the digestion process; digestibility as measured by Eq. (2) is not the “true” digestibility of the forage material, but the “apparent” digestibility, (feed - feces) measuring the amount of feed digested, less this inevitable
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
9
endogenous loss associated with the passage of the feed through the tract. Based on in vivo results with a limited range of feeds, Van Soest (1967) calculated this fecal loss to be 12.9 percent of the dry weight of forage eaten. Van Soest (1967) was then able to compute the apparent digestibility of forage: Apparent digestibility of dry matter % = 0.98s
+ W ( 1 . 4 7 3 - 0.789 log X ) - 12.9
(5a)
comprising the almost completely digested cell-contents (S),plus the cellwall constituents (W=NDF) digested to an extent depending on the degree of lignification of the A D F fraction ( X ) , and less the endogenous excretion. It has not yet been possible to test this relationship on a wider range of forages than those studied by Van Soest. But by taking account of the differing contents and digestibilities of the two main fractions in herbage, the cell contents and the cell-wall material, Eq. (5a) clearly represents an important advance over the more empirical methods summarized by Miller ( 1 96 1) and Sullivan (1 962). In the course of the development of the detergent-fiber methods, Van Soest ( 1 965b) examined the effect of the method of drying herbage samples before analysis on the measured levels of acid-detergent fiber and lignin. Drying temperatures above 50”C., particularly over an extended period, significantly increased the levels of both these fractions; this artifact “fiber” was shown to result from a nonenzymatic browning reaction, in which protein polymerizes with products of carbohydrate breakdown, so that the “lignin” fraction in particular contains an abnormally high percentage of nitrogen. In earlier work this had been corrected by subtracting %N X 6.25 from the apparent lignin analysis. However, Van Soest recognized that natural plant lignins may contain some nitrogen, and derived a relationship that would correct only for the nitrogenous matter which might be attributed to heat damage: % corrected lignin (L,)
=
1.208 X % measured lignin (LA)- 10.75 x %N in A D F + 0.42
(6)
The acid-detergent fiber (ADF) content is then corrected: % A D F corrected = % A D F observed - (LA- L,)
(7)
From Eqs. (6) and (7) the factor log X in Eq. (5a), based on corrected values for A D F and lignin, can be calculated. The need for this correction must reduce the utility (and precision) of Eq. (5a) and emphasizes the importance of adequate drying methods for preparing herbage samples for analysis. The method of choice must surely
10
W. F. RAYMOND
be freeze-drying (lyophilization). But the great majority of freeze-driers in current laboratory use are of small capacity (< 1 kg. water/24 hours), and this can introduce a source of error which is seldom recognized- that the sample of forage which is dried by this ideal method may be so small as to be quite unrepresentative of the material sampled. This possible contradiction between the precision of the drying method and the accuracy of sampling has been discussed (Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, 1961, p. 135); until much larger freeze-driers become available, the solution in many cases may be to dry forage samples of adequate size as rapidly as possible at 100"C.,so as to minimize the time during which nonenzymatic browning (which occurs only in the presence of water) can take place. The individual investigator can then test the success of his own drying method by the application of Eq. (6) to analyses on representative samples. Recently Van Soest and Jones (1969) suggested a further refinement to the concept summarized in Eq. (5a), by indicating that the silica present in plant material may exert much the same effect as lignin in reducing the digestibility of the neutral-detergent cell-wall fraction. L. H. P. Jones and Handreck (1967) discussed the forms and reactions of silica in the food chain from soil to plant to animal. They pointed out that silica absorbed by plant roots is carried in solution to the actively metabolizing tissues. As the transporting water is transpired, solid silica is deposited on to the cell walls so that as these develop the polysaccharides are intimately associated with encrusting silica as well as lignin. From examination of the digestibility in vitro of forage samples of silica content ranging from 0.5 percent to 5.4 percent, Van Soest and Jones (1969) proposed a modified form of Eq. (5a): Apparent digestibility of dry matter % = 0.98s + W(1.473 - 0.789 log X) - 3.O(SiO2)- 12.9
(5b)
As yet the evidence is restricted to relatively few forages, but further study may clearly indicate the need for refinement of the biological concepts implicit in Eqs. (5a) and (5b).
D. ESTIMATION OF FORAGE DIGESTIBILITY BY in Vitro TECHNIQUES The inclusion of silica as a further component which may influence forage digestibility illustrates the trend toward multicomponent chemical techniques for predicting digestibility. In effect, this accepts that no single component can quantify the complex process of ruminant digestion, and that this must be treated as a series of stages, each described by a logical chemical evaluation, as in the decreasing digestibility of the N D F fraction as the fiber becomes more lignified.
T H E NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
11
The inclusion of silica also illustrates a basic problem with chemical methods of evaluation, that a relationship such as Eq. (5a), which is found to be adequate with one population of forages, may give inaccurate prediction of the digestibility of other forages-in this case, of forages of unusually high silica content. This could arise from two causes: (a) the original relationship did not include all the components that exert a significant effect on forage digestibility and (b) chemical methods measure the content of different components in forage samples; they do not measure the physical distribution and organization of these different components within the plant, which must to some extent determine how far the plant fibers are digested by the microorganisms within the rumen. The chemical approach tends to treat a forage as a homogeneous material, an increase in lignin content, for instance, being visualized as an increase in lignification throughout the whole plant. In practice the forage plant is more realistically considered as made up of morphologically “distinct” fractions, each of which can be changing in chemical composition and digestibility in a way not necessarily related to the other fractions, so that chemical analysis (an average of the whole plant material) may well not describe the summation of the individual plant fractions that make up the digestibility of the whole plant. Thus, parallel to the development of chemical methods of forage evaluation, described in the previous section, has been the development of biological methods of evaluation, the artificial rumen or in vitro digestion methods. Essentially these have attempted to simulate the process of ruminant digestion by methods that can take account both of the overall chemical composition of the forage plant and of the distribution and physical interrelations of the chemical components within the different morphological parts of the plant. With the recognition that the digestibility of the “fiber” fraction of forages would be most affected by these physical characteristics the initial investigations of biological methods were concerned with fiber digestibility, and in particular with the digestibility of the cellulose fraction in forages. Although details of technique differed, all these methods were based on the incubation, under controlled conditions, of a sample of the test forage with a mixed culture of the microflora taken from the rumen of a forage-fed animal; the aim was to standardize the conditions of incubation so that the fiber in the forage sample was digested to the same extent as in the same forage when fed in an in vivo experiment (Quicke et al., 1959; Lefevre and Kamstra, 1960; Karn et al., 1967). These techniques were also used to measure the extent to which the dry matter (Clark and Mott, 1960), organic matter (R. L. Reid el al., 19601, or energy content (R. L. Reid et al., 1960; Baumgardt el al., 1962; Naga and El-Shazly,
12
W. F. RAYMOND
1963) in forage was digested in vitro. In most cases the extent of digestion in vitro was found to be less than that in vivo, and regression equations were developed to allow prediction of in vivo values. In an alternative system, a sample of dried forage is enclosed in a nylon or dacron mesh bag suspended within the rumen in vivo, and digestibility and rate of digestion are measured by the loss of dry matter or of cellulose from the sample (Lusk et al., 1962; Hopson et al., 1963). This technique could have the advantage that a normal microfloral population will be maintained, although this will tend to be that characteristic of the feed eaten by the host animal, rather than of the sample under test. However the technique does permit the comparison of large numbers of feed samples under standard conditions, and it could be of use in ranking forage samples in a breeding selection program. This approach was analogous to that with the earlier chemical methods, in attempting to predict the complex process of forage digestion by a single procedure. As with the chemical methods, the accuracy of prediction was found to decrease as the range of forages examined was widened; in particular marked divergences were found between results for grasses and legumes (Shelton and Reid, 1960). Tilley and Terry (1963) suggested that these discrepancies might be the result of correlating data from a single digestion with rumen organisms with those from digestion within the animal, which involves a mainly bacterial digestion within the rumen followed by a mainly enzymatic digestion in the remainder of the digestive tract. Within the rumen, the “digestible” polysaccharides, carbohydrates, and protein in the feed are broken down by the action of the microorganisms there; some of the products of digestion are absorbed directly through the lumen wall, but a considerable part serves as the substrate for microbial growth, and is resynthesized into protein, polysaccharides, and lipids within the proliferating bacterial and protozoal population. These microorganisms, entrained in the residues of undigested fiber and other feed components, then pass from the rumen to the abomasum and duodenum. In these organs the digesta are acidified and further digested by secreted enzymes that hydrolyze much of the bacterial and residual plant proteins to amino acids. These are then absorbed as the main source of amino acids for the metabolism of the host animal. The undigested residue from the in vitro digestion of forage material with rumen microorganisms is thus seen to contain, in addition to undigested feed, the rumen organisms which, in vivo, would be enzymatically digested in the ruminant hind tract. Tilley and Terry ( 1 963) proposed that this second stage should be simulated by subjecting the residue from the in vitro bacterial digestion to a second enzymatic digestion. They ex-
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
13
amined several enzymes and concluded that a two-stage procedure comprising digestion by rumen microorganisms followed by digestion by acid-pepsin gave the closest agreement with in vivo digestibility values for the dry matter and organic contents in forages. This method showed a correlation of 0.97 between in vitro and in vivo values when tested on a wide range of forages, including grasses fertilized with different levels of nitrogen, and legumes: Digestibility in vivo = 0.99 X digestibility in vitro - 1.O I (S.E. = f 2.3 I )
(8)
Similar high degrees of correlation have been found by O’Shea and Wilson ( I 965; r = 0.94), Wedin el al. ( 1966; r = 0.996) and Ademosum et af. ( 1 968; r = 0.96); Dent ( 1 963) found close agreement between two-stage in vitro and in vivo digestibility results with brassicas and forage maize. In a number of studies the precision of prediction of digestibijity in vivo by this in vitro technique has been compared with the chemical methods already discussed. Armstrong et al. (1964a) found that the metabolizable energy and net energy contents of a series of dried grass feeds were more accurately correlated with organic matter digestibility in vitro than with cellulose or lignin contents; Bosman (1967) and Ademosum ef al. (1968) have reported the in vitro method to correlate more closely with in vivo digestibility than the chemical methods tested; Engels and Van der Merwe (1967) have found the same result with lowdigestibility hays in South Africa. However, to date no direct comparison has been reported with the improved chemical technique proposed by Van Soest ( 1 967, Eq. 5 ) , and it is possible that these two techniques differ little in the precision with which they allow prediction of forage digestibility in the laboratory. In fact the stage may be approaching at which little further improvement in precision can be expected. In interpreting the error terms of these relationships, it is important to recognize that this error does not arise solely from deficiencies in the laboratory technique used (chemical or in vitro), but that errors are also associated with the actual measurement of the in vivo digestibility of the forages, and with the fact that digestibility in vivo is not a constant parameter of a particular forage. Thus digestibility determined in an animal experiment may depend on the amount of forage fed, digestibility decreasing as the level of feeding increases (Moe et al., 1963, and can be significantly reduced if the animal is parasitized with stomach worms-probably the rule rather than the exception with sheep (Spedding, 1954; Shumard et al., 1957). The standard deviation of an estimate of digestibility is between 1.0 and 1.3% (Raymond et al.,
14
W. F. RAYMOND
1953); as most digestibility determinations are made with only 2 or 3 sheep it is evident, even where the factors noted above are standardized, that much of the error in the relationships noted must result from errors in the in vivo determination, rather than in the concept or precision of the laboratory determination. Probably the main area for improvement lies then in the better standardization of the in vivo digestibility experiments, of the preparation of the forage samples for analysis, and of the conduct of the laboratory procedures. R. L. Reid et al. (1964) and Noller et al. ( 1966) have both reported significantly higher levels of dry-matter digestibility in vitro in forages prepared by freeze-drying than by oven-drying, presumably because of the production of indigestible artifacts during oven-drying, as suggested by Van Soest ( I965b). Tilley and Terry (personal communication), however, found no advantage of freeze drying compared with rapid ovendrying at 1Oo”C., although the same authors (1963) had reported considerable depression of digestibility in vitro in samples dried at temperatures above 1 10°C. The concept that fiber digestibility is limited by physical incrustation with lignin indicated that digestibility should be increased by fine subdivision, and both Dehority et al. (1962) and Tilley and Terry (1 963) reported increases of up to 50 percent in digestibility as a result of grinding forage samples in a ball mill before in vitro digestion. However, within the range of fineness of grinding found in forage samples ground by hammermill, Tilley and Terry (1 963) found no significant effect of particle size. The most serious problem arises, however, in the lack of standardization of in vitro procedures between different laboratories. Barnes (1967) reported the results of a collaborative study in which the in vitro digestibilities of the dry matter and cellulose in three forages were measured at 17 laboratories. The mean values for cellulose digestibility after 24 hours ranged from 40.0 to 63.9 percent, reflecting the use of different techniques in terms of sample size, preparation of the rumen inoculum, pH control, etc. In contrast, Raymond and Terry (1966) have reported close agreement between in vitro results from two laboratories using identical procedures, and have stressed the importance of different laboratories using the same “standard” forage samples as an additional check on the reproducibility of the method. Tilley and Terry ( 1 963) found that rumen liquors taken from donor animals fed on several contrasting forages were of similar digestive efficiency in the two-stage in vitro system, and Troelsen and Hanel(l966)
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
15
have reported that the potency of liquors taken from different sheep differs less than the in vivo digestive efficiency between sheep. I n general the most important consideration seems to be that the diet of the donor animals should contain at least 10 percent of crude protein (see below), that it should give a sample of rumen contents from which a strained liquor can readily be separated (i.e., the animals should be fed on a coarsely chopped hay rather than on a pelleted ground feed), and that the sample should be kept in an anaerobic condition and be prepared for inoculation of the digestion tubes as rapidly as possible. It must be accepted, however, that this in vitro procedure, developed with temperate grass and legume species, may not be directly applicable with other temperate species, or with tropical forage species, and Drew (1 966) has stressed that the system should wherever possible be checked with relevant samples of known in vivo digestibility. Thus Raymond and Terry (1 966) reported low in vitro digestibility levels when both the test forage (0.7 percent N) and the feed of the donor animal were of low nitrogen content, as can often occur with tropical forage species. The higher level of digestibility in vivo resulted from the animal’s ability to recycle urea via salivary and ruminal secretions, whereas digestibility in vitro was limited by a deficiency of nitrogen in the combined sample and inoculum. Addition of 6 mg. of N , as urea, to the in vitro system increased sample digestibility to the in vivo level. Engels and Van der Merwe (1967) found that the difference between in vitro and in vivo digestibility values of veldt grasses became greater as the nitrogen content of the test forages decreased. Addition of 20 mg. of urea N to each digestion tube gave in vitro values in close agreement with those in vivo. In a modification of the method of Tilley and Terry ( 1963), Alexander and McGowan ( 1966) have included ammonium sulfate in the buffer added to each tube. However in the author’s opinion this is advisable only where depressed levels of in vitro digestibility result from low nitrogen contents. Engels and Van der Merwe (1967) showed a marked depression in digestibility when 60 mg. of urea N was included in the digestion system, and a similar depression might occur when urea is added to an in vitro digestion of a forage sample already of high nitrogen content. Although some modification may be necessary in particular situations, the study reported by Barnes (1967) does emphasize the importance of the general adoption of standardized in vitro digestibility procedures, without which results reported by different laboratories cannot be directly comparable. The two-stage procedure described by Tilley and Terry (1963) is now used by many laboratories, and there seems a strong case
16
W. F. RAYMOND
that this should be adopted as a standard procedure in agronomic studies. But such a technique, based on digestion in vitro with a mixed culture of rumen organisms, must always be sensitive to uncontrolled biological variation, and there is a clear need for the future for a technique that can be more rigidly defined. A promising development, reported by Dehority et al. (1968), is the use of a pure culture of cellulolytic bacteria to replace the mixed inoculum taken from the rumen of a donor animal. Two of the strains of bacteria tested gave cellulose digestibility values in vitro in close agreement with the measured in vivo values; further development of this work could well lead to significant improvement in the standardization of laboratory in vitro techniques.
E. THERELATIVEUTILITY OF CHEMICAL AND in Vitro ESTIMATIONS OF FORAGE DIGESTIBILITY As has been indicated, the two-stage in vitro technique appears to give a better prediction of in vivo forage digestibility than any of the chemical methods yet investigated, and the use of this technique, reported below, has contributed greatly to our knowledge of forage digestibility. However this is an integrative technique, the measured digestibility being the sum of the digestibilities of the many different chemical fractions within the forage; without additional chemical information it can only describe, rather than explain, the differences in digestibility observed among different forage samples. This suggests that in vitro and chemical techniques should be considered as complementary, rather than competitive, methods of forage evaluation, the in vitro techniques being used to establish that forages differ in digestibility, and the chemical techniques to study the probable reasons for these differences. Such an understanding is essential if further improvement of forage digestibility is to be based on nonempirical concepts. IV. The Digestibility of Different Forage Species
A. BASIC PATTERNSOF DIGESTIBILITY The use of these more precise laboratory techniques for estimating the digestibility of forages has led to considerable progress in extending in vivo studies that were started in the 1950’s. It had long been recognized that as a forage becomes more mature it also becomes less digestible; the possibility that this imprecise statement could be quantified was proposed by Homb (1953), who showed a close relationship between the age (maturity) of a timothy-clover mixture and its digestibility, and by J. T. Reid et al. (1959), who suggested that the digestibility of a range of
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
17
forage species harvested during first growth during the spring could be estimated: % digestibility of dry matter = 85.0 - 0.48X (9) where X = number of days to harvest from April 30. These reports stimulated further investigations that have greatly increased our understanding of forage digestibility. Clearly the “date of harvest” in Eq. (9) can only be relevant in the area close to Cornell (Ithaca, New York), where the forages used in these in vivo digestibility determinations were harvested, but the basic principle, that digestibility is closely related to forage maturity, with “date of cutting” being used to describe stage of maturity in a particular location, was soon confirmed by other workers (Kane and Moore, 1959, and others; reviewed by Blaser, 1964). However, several divergences from the original concept, that all forages are of similar digestibility at a given date, became evident. Thus the digestibility of timothy (Phfeumpratense) (Mellin et a f . , 1962; Minson et a f . , 1964), of lucerne (Medicago sativa) (Demarquilly, 1966a), and in particular of white clover (Trifofium repens) (Harkess, 1963) were shown to decline less rapidly with advancing maturity than the 0.5 unit per day indicated in Eq. (9). Small differences in the digestibility of a given forage variety cut on the same date in different years may be due to the delayed onset of active spring growth in a “late” season (Minson et af., 1960), or to differences in leaf percentage in the forage grown in different years (R. H. Brown et a f . , 1968). But the most important observation has been that there can be large and consistent differences in digestibility between forage species and forage varieties. In a detailed series of in vivo experiments, Minson et a f . ( I 960, 1964) found that certain species (Lofium spp. and Festuca pratense) were considerably more digestible than others such as cocksfoot (Dactylis gfomerata) and tall fescue ( F . arundinacea); within a species late-maturing varieties (e.g., S.23 ryegrass) maintained a high level of digestibility to a later date than early-maturing varieties (e.g., S.24). These differences, illustrated in Fig. 1 , were considered large enough to be of agronomic and nutritional significance. Figure 1 also shows that the digestibility of each grass studied did not fall at a uniform rate as it matured. There was an initial period of almost constant digestibility before digestibility began to decrease. In the case of Lofium and Dactylis this change to a more rapid fall in digestibility, at a rate very similar to the 0.5 unit per day recorded by Reid et a f . ( 1 959), was closely associated with the first emergence of flowering heads; the digestibility of timothy (S.48), however, decreased well before this stage, and this species also showed the much slower rate of fall in digestibility noted above.
18
W. F. RAYMOND
In establishing these novel digestibility patterns, Minson et al. (1964) had two main advantages compared with their colleagues in North America-in the more general use of the genus Lofium in the United
I
I
10 20 April
30
Ib
20
May
3b
Ib
$0
$0
June
date of first cuttinq
FIG. I . The percent digestibility of the organic matter in grass varieties during first growth in the spring. S.23 and S.24, ryegrass; S.37 and Germinal, cocksfoot; S.215, meadow fescue; S.48, timothy; S. 170, tall fescue; O.M., organic matter. 0 indicates date of first ear emergence. (Data from Minson et al., 1964.)
Kingdom than in North America; and in the availability of widely differing maturity types, within this genus, developed at the Welsh Plant Breeding Station. These results stimulated other in vivo studies, which have in general confirmed the important conclusions implicit in Fig. 1. Thus Castle et a f . (1962) and Harkess (1963) have found consistently higher digestibility of ryegrass than of cocksfoot, and Lowe et af. (1962) reported that late-maturing varieties of grasses were more digestible than early-maturing at a given cutting date in the spring. These in vivo studies, initially on first spring growth, have also been extended to regrowths during the rest of the growing season, and consistent patterns have again emerged. The digestibility of regrowth cocksfoot and tall fescue is always lower than that of the corresponding regrowth of ryegrass, and the rate of fall of digestibility with time is much less in these later, largely vegetative, regrowths than in the first, reproductive, growth (Minson et af., 1960, 1964); a similar slower rate of fall in digestibility has been shown with regrowths of lucerne (Demarquilly, 1966a).
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
19
However, the digestibility of regrowth forage is likely to be less predictable than that of first growth. The latter comprises largely reproductive tillers which develop from the start of active growth in the spring; regrowths can contain both reproductive and vegetative tillers, the relative proportions of each depending on the management of earlier harvests. Thus the regrowth from a tiller whose reproductive growing point (ear) is harvested will comprise mainly leaf, which will decrease only slowly in digestibility at ca. 0.1 percent per day. In contrast, a tiller which is harvested before the ear has reached the height of cutting or grazing will continue to develop, and its digestibility will decrease at the 0.5 percent per day characteristic of first growth. Harvesting up to the time of first ear emergence will remove only some of the developing ears, and the digestibility of the regrowth will decrease at an intermediate rate, e.g., 0.3 percent per day. A later harvest, which removes most of the potential ears, will give a leafy regrowth which decreases more slowly in digestibility. Under a cutting regime regrowths are mainly leafy, and of relatively predictable digestibility (Minson et al., 1960, 1964). Under a grazing situation the prediction of the digestibility of regrowths is less precise. The grazing animal generally leaves some of the herbage on offer, and this continues to decrease in digestibility, so that the combined regrowth and remaining herbage is of lower digestibility than the corresponding regrowth from a cut sward (Tayler and Deriaz, 1963). As noted in Section IV, C , 2, the digestibility of a regrowth from grazing will also depend considerably on the moisture and nitrogen status of the sward, which determines the proportion of the next harvest that is composed of new growth of high digestibility. Limited information indicates that the digestibility of forage mixtures can be calculated from the proportions and digestibilities of the constituent species at the time of harvest (Harkess, 1963). An exception may be the case where the digestibility of one species is low because it is deficient in protein content (as has been shown with some tropical forages; Smith, 1962). Such a species, grown with another species of higher protein content, could have an enhanced digestibility, so that the digestibility of the “mixture” would be somewhat higher than predicted. The patterns of forage digestibility discussed above were all based on in vivo experiments; they have been considerably extended by the use of laboratory in v i m techniques. The validity of the two-stage in vitro technique was indicated by Terry and Tilley (1964a), who showed that the basic patterns of digestibility shown in Fig. 1, and in particular the nonlinear fall in digestibility with time and the consistently higher diges-
20
W. F. RAYMOND
tibility of ryegrass than of cocksfoot, could be closely reproduced by in vitro measurements. With this method many more forage samples can be examined than would ever be possible by in vivo experiments, but the need to confirm, in vivo, the more important conclusions indicated from in vitro studies must be emphasized. Thus Dent and Aldrich (1968) have measured the digestibility, in both first growth and regrowths, of numbers of varieties within several forage species. They have shown consistent differences in digestibility between species, and between maturity types within species, at different centers and in different years. Their work indicated that different varieties of the same maturity type within a species might differ in digestibility. Thus a small number of varieties of cocksfoot (e.g., Roskilde I1 and Scotia) appeared to be more digestible than the varieties Germinal and S.37, shown in Fig. 1, and Reveille tetraploid ryegrass was more digestible than S.24 ryegrass. These in vitro results, subsequently confirmed in in vivo experiments (Osbourn, unpublished) have particular relevance to the possibility of breeding more digestible forage varieties, discussed in Section VIII.
B. THEDIGESTIBILITY OF DIFFERENT PLANTFRACTIONS The use of in vitro techniques to measure the digestibility of different plant fractions has also provided a more logical understanding of these patterns of forage digestibility. These are in many cases contrary to what would have been predicted in terms of the earlier concepts of forage nutritive value, that leaf was more digestible than stem, and that forage fractions high in protein (N) content would be more digestible than those of lower N content. The results of Minson et al. ( 1 960) showed that these concepts might be incorrect. Thus in first growth, S.24 ryegrass forage cut in 1959 on May 1 , with a nitrogen content of 2.62 percent and 53 percent of leaf lamina, was of exactly the same digestibility as that cut on April 20, which had contained 3.66 percent N and 77 percent leaf, S.37 cocksfoot cut on May 5 , with 2.78 percent N and 58 percent leaf, was 4.5 units less digestible than the ryegrass cut on May 1 . In later experiments Tayler and Rudman (1966) harvested a S.24 ryegrass sward in two horizons, a top fraction cut above 13.5 cm., and a bottom fraction from 6 to 13.5 cm. The digestibilities of the organic matter in the two fractions, in vivo, were 84.0 and 82.6 percent, respectively. This indirect in vivo evidence has been followed up in detail by in vitro digestibility determinations on forage samples separated into fractions of leaf, leaf sheath, stem, inflorescences, and dead material. Terry and Tilley ( 1 964a) analyzed these fractions from the forages fed in vivo by Minson et al. ( 1 960, 1964) (Fig. 1). They showed that in all species the
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
21
digestibility of the leaf fraction fell only slowly with advancing maturity (0.13 percent per day) whereas that of the leaf sheath (0.4 percent) and stem fractions (0.7 percent) fell much more rapidly. In the immature forages the stem was always more digestible than the other components. On any given date each fraction in S.24 ryegrass was more digestible than the corresponding fraction in S.37 cocksfoot, of equivalent maturity type. A typical set of results is shown in Fig. 2. The digestibility of the
whole plant leaf sheath
----
leaf blade stem
--
-----.
FIG.2. The digestibility in vifro of the dry matter in the whole plant, and in the leaf blade, leaf sheath, and stem fractions of S.37 cocksfoot during first growth in the spring. Figures in parentheses are the percentage of stem in the whole plant. (Data from Terry and Tilley, I 964a. )
whole forage material, calculated from the proportions and digestibilities of the constituent fractions, changed with maturity just as in the in vivo experiments-that is, with a slow fall in digestibility up to the time of ear emergence, followed by a more rapid fall as the stem and leaf sheath fractions, by now less digestible than the leaf, comprised an increasing proportion of the total forage. The slower and more steady fall in the digestibility of S.48 timothy could be explained by the much higher proportion of leaf sheath in this species than in ryegrass or cocksfoot.
22
W. F. RAYMOND
These conclusions have been confirmed in considerable detail by Pritchard et al. (1963), Wedin et al. (1966), Walters et al. (1967), and Dent and Aldrich (1968); Mowat et al. (1965) found similar results with timothy and bromegrass, but were unable to show higher digestibility of cocksfoot stems than of leaves even in immature forage. Similar logical patterns of digestibility have been shown with legume forages (Terry and Tilley, 1964a; Mowat et al., 1965). With lucerne ( M . sativa), red clover ( T . pratense), and sainfoin (,Onobiychis viciifoliu) the older leaves tend to senesce and fall, so that the digestibility of the leaf fraction decreases very little as the plant matures. By separating the stem fraction into 6 inch subfractions, measured from the top of the plant, it was shown that digestibility decreased down the stem, but that the digestibility of any given fraction changed relatively little with maturity. A similar result has been found with the stems of brassicas and forage maize (Zea mays), the stem tip of marrow-stem kale being highly digestible (81.8 percent dry matter) and the stem base of lower digestibility (62.3 percent) (Dent, 1963). Within a particular forage species, Walters et al. (1967) and Dent and Aldrich (1968) have shown, at a similar stage of morphological development, that “late” varieties tend to be less digestible than “early” varieties because both the stem and leaf fractions are somewhat less digestible, and because they contain a higher proportion of senescent and dead material. Small differences in digestibility of a given variety at ear emergence in different years can be attributed to differences in leafistem ratios, stem at this stage being less digestible than leaf (R. H. Brown et al., 1968). Of particular importance is the observation, already noted, of differences in digestibility between varieties of similar maturity type within a species (Dent and Aldrich, 1968). The higher digestibility of REVEILLE ryegrass than S.24 was not accounted for in terms of leafstem ratio, but because both the leaf and stem fractions in REVEILLE were more digestible than the same fractions in S.24. Differences in digestibility have also been shown between the individual plants (genotypes) within a variety (Cooper et al., 1962; Walters et al., 1967; Mowat, 1969), resulting from differences in digestibility of the plant fractions rather than from different leaf stem ratios. However, while the in virro techniques used in these studies can describe the changes in digestibility within and between different forage. species, they cannot explain them; for this the newer chemical techniques (Section 111, C ) are needed, to analyze digestibility measured in vitro into its component parts. In detailed studies by Tilley, Terry, and Outen (unpublished) the forage sample is separated into a cell con-
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
23
tents fraction, soluble in acid pepsin, and a cell wall fraction (analogous to the fraction soluble in neutral detergent and the cell wall residue of Van Soest, 1967). The digestibility of the cell wall fraction is also measured by in vitro (rumen organism) digestion. Consistent differences have been shown between S.24 ryegrass and S.37 cocksfoot, harvested at the same stage of maturity: (a) the content of pepsin-soluble material is higher in the ryegrass than in the cocksfoot; (b) as a result there is a higher content of cell wall fraction in the cocksfoot; and (c) this fraction in the cocksfoot is less digestible than in the ryegrass, so that the content of “digestible cell wall material” in the two species is very similar. As a result the digestibility of the ryegrass (cell contents X 0.98 digestible cell wall fraction) is higher than that of the cocksfoot. Within different plant fractions, the small decrease in digestibility of the leaf fraction as the plant matures (Fig. 2) is accounted for by the consistently high level of cell contents and high digestibility of the cell wall fraction in the leaf. Young stem material contains an even higher proportion of cell contents than the leaf (hence its higher digestibility); but as the stem matures the cell content fraction decreases rapidly and is replaced by cell wall material which becomes less digestible with increasing lignification, so that the digestibility of the stem decreases rapidly with advancing maturity. Extension of these more detailed studies of the components of digestibility to the genotypes within a species which have been found to be of higher digestibility (Section VIII) may provide a more objective basis for selection for improved digestibility than the in vitro techniques that have so far been used.
+
c. THEEFFECTOF ON
ENVIRONMENTAL A N D OTHER FACTORS FORAGEDIGESTIBILITY
1 . Environmental Effects The difference in digestibility between forages cut on the same date at Cornell (J. T. Reid et al., 1959) and in Maryland (Kane and Moore, 1959) appeared to be due to the forages in these two locations being at different stages of physiological maturity. It is of course possible that, even at the same stage of maturity, the digestibility of a forage may differ between locations; thus Aldrich and Dent (1 967) have found an indication of higher digestibility at a northern than at a southern latitude in the United Kingdom in cocksfoot cut 10 days after 50 percent ear emergence. Deinum et al. (1 968) measured the in vivo digestibility of perennial ryegrass grown under high and low light intensities, and with low and high levels of nitrogen manuring. Considerable differences in chemical com-
24
W. F. RAYMOND
position of the grass were found between treatments, but these had no significant effect on dry matter digestibility at any one sampling. These experiments showed lower levels of digestibility on all treatments during the summer when temperatures were higher, confirming earlier results of Deinum, based on chemical analysis of ryegrass grown in controlled environment cabinets. Deinum et al. ( 1 968) postulated that this effect of high temperature might partly account for the generally lower level of digestibility of tropical than of temperate forages. Hiridoglou et al. ( 1966) have also shown that high summer temperatures were associated with low in vitro digestibility levels. Forages growing in summer also tend to contain lower moisture contents than late season forages; however, the only report found on the effect of water intake on forage digestibility (Thornton and Yates, 1968) has indicated a small increase in the digestibility by cattle of the dry matter and fiber in chaffed oat straw-lucerne hay when water intake was restricted. 2 . Fertilizers and Forage Digestibility The effects of fertilizer nitrogen on forage digestibility have been studied in numerous experiments; most of these have reported an insignificant effect from the use of widely differing levels of application (summarized by Blaser, 1964): thus Minson et al. ( 1 960) found no effect on the digestibility of ryegrass or cocksfoot from levels of nitrogen application varying from 0 to 175 pounds/acre. However, Raymond and Spedding (1 965) have indicated several situations in which fertilizer nitrogen is likely to affect forage digestibility: (a) in a mixed grass-clover sward the use of this fertilizer may reduce the contribution, in the forage harvested, of the more digestible clover complement: (b) uneaten herbage left on a sward after stock have grazed will continue to decrease in digestibility, and by diluting the highly digestible new growth will depress the digestibility of herbage available at the next grazing; fertilizer nitrogen will increase the proportion of new growth in this harvest, and so may increase its digestibility; (c) unfertilized herbage may contain an inadequate level of nitrogen for the growth of rumen microorganisms: thus Smith ( 1 962) found an increased level of digestibility after application of nitrogen to such forage; 40 pounds of fertilizer nitrogen per acre increased the crude protein content of late-cut veldt hay from 3.6 to 6.8 percent and the digestibility of the forage dry matter from 5 1.7 to 59.5 percent. These effects of fertilizer nitrogen are consistent with the concepts of forage digestibility already discussed. McIlroy ( 1 967) has summarized results showing that fertilizer nitrogen increases the crude protein content and decreases the soluble carbohydrate content of herbage. But
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
25
there is little net change in the content of crude protein plus soluble carbohydrate, which largely comprises the cell contents fraction, or in the composition of the cell wall fraction. Thus little change in the digestibility of the forage would be expected except when the digestibility of the cell-wall fraction is limited by the low content of protein in the forage. There is also the possibility that certain forages contain specific components which reduce bacterial activity within the rumen. Hawkins ( 1 959) suggested that the low digestibility of the protein fraction in Sericea lespedeza and vetches might be due to the formation of insoluble protein complexes with the tannin in these forages, and Smart et al. ( 1 96 I ) found a depression of cellulose activity in vitro by an extract from Lespedeza cuneata. Schillinger and Elliott ( 1 966) observed differences of u p to 15 percent between the digestibilities in vitro of different lucerne plants. Low levels of digestibility could be raised by addition of amino acids (glycine, aspartic acid, glutamine) to the in vitro system, and these amino acids also increased the growth rate of voles fed on the lucerne forage. These authors attributed these differences to the presence of water-soluble antimetabolites in the low digestibility plants. Such cases are, however, likely to be exceptional, and the digestibility of most forages appears to be in line with the systems of evaluation proposed by Van Soest ( 1967) and Terry and Tilley ( 1964a).
3. The Effect of Feed Supplements on Forage Digestibility These systems do not, however, predict adequately the digestibility of forages fed in mixed rations. Thus when carbohydrate (starch) supplements are fed with forages, there can be a significant decrease in the digestibility of the fiber (cell wall) fraction of the forage, unaccounted for by any change in the composition of the cell wall (Eq. 5 ) . This has been attributed to a preferential digestion of the starch by the rumen microorganisms, so that the extent of digestion of the plant fibers is reduced, or alternatively that the amylolytic bacteria compete preferentially for ammonia against the cellulolytic bacteria, so reducing cellulose digestion (El-Shazly et al., 1961). More recent work has indicated an alternative explanation. First, it is known that when a starch supplement is fed with a forage there is a reduction in the pH of the rumen contents compared with that when the forage is fed alone (Topps et al., 1965). Second, Tilley et al. ( 1964) have shown a marked reduction in the rate and extent of digestion of dry matter and cellulose in vitro when the pH of the in vitro system is reduced (Table I); a decrease, with decrease in rumen pH, has also recently been
26
W. F. RAYMOND
indicated in the rate of “digestion” of cotton threads suspended within the rumen in vivo (Wilkins, unpublished). Tilley et al. (1964) have therefore suggested that the lower rumen pH when a starch supplement is fed TABLE I The Effect of the pH of the in Vitro Digestion on the Extent of Dry Matter and Cellulose Digestibility of Samples of Cocksfoot, S.37, by the 2-Stage in Vitro Method“
Sample No.
In vivo
Percent of forage dry matter digested In vitro (48 hours) pH 6.8 pH 6.0 (normal)
76 73 72 72 64 63 59 59 5 49 49 “From Tilley et al. ( 1964). *Figures in parentheses are percentages matter.
(15)
(17) (16) (12)
67 (12) 63 ( I 1) 50 (10) 49 (10) 41 (7)
pH 5.5 54 53 37 36 29
(4) (5) (3) (2) (1)
of digestible cellulose in the digestible dry
may provide a less favorable environment for the cellulolytic and other bacteria that are able to digest plant fiber (see also Head, 1961). In anthropomorphic terms, the natural rumen microflora has become adapted to the pH 6.6 to 6.8 characteristic of the rumen contents of the grazing herbivore; any marked divergence from this pH finds a microfloral population increasingly unable to digest fiber. This hypothesis, if substantiated, could lead to the development of feeding regimes, aimed at optimizing rumen pH (and redox potential) to ensure maximum digestion of the cell wall fraction of forages. As already noted, forages may be of low digestibility because they are of very low protein content (< 4% crude protein). The digestion of these forages can be increased by feeding protein supplements, and there has been much interest in the use of urea for this purpose. Thus Campling ef al. (1962) measured an increase in organic matter digestibility from 41 to 50 percent when a urea supplement was fed with oat straw of 3.0 percent crude protein, and other examples have been reported (see M. H. Briggs, 1967). Within the rumen the urea is rapidly deaminated, the ammonia produced then being used by the celluloytic and other bacteria, whose digestive activity would have been limited by deficiency of protein in the unsupplemented forage. The feeding of urea to increase the digestibility of forage is not often used in practice, because a crude protein level in forage of less than 4
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
27
percent is uncommon. The main use of urea is likely to be as a substitute for protein in productive rations (Section VI, D). V. The Voluntary Intake of Forages
A. THEFACTORS CONTROLLING FEEDINTAKE
It was noted in the Introduction that the quantity of forage that ruminant animals eat is in practice seldom controlled in the same way that most other farm feeds are rationed. Yet the amount of forage that animals eat is in many cases the major factor determining their level of nutrient intake and their output of useful products. Increasing emphasis has been given in the last decade to the study of voluntary intake. Earlier studies of forage intake were undoubtedly hindered by the confusion of “intake” with “palatability” (Blaxter et al., I96 1 ; Campling, 1964), but it is now accepted that forage intake is mainly controlled by largely involuntary physiological reflexes within the animal, rather than by its subjective liking for different feeds. The development of some of the current concepts on voluntary intake have been reviewed by Balch and Campling (1962), Conrad ( 1 966), and L. D. Brown (1966). From these a broad distinction appears between the factors determining intake by ruminants and by nonruminants. Intake by nonruminants is controlled mainly by levels of blood metabolites, the animal ceasing to eat when these reach a threshold level. Intake by ruminants depends much more on the capacity of the digestive tract, particularly the rumen, eating ceasing when a certain degree of “fill” has been reached, and starting again when “fill” has been reduced by digestion and movement of food residues through the digestive tract: only on feeds of high energy concentration does blood metabolite level, rather than gastrointestinal fill, begin to control the amount of food that ruminants will eat (Conrad, 1966). However, as with other aspects of forage nutritive value it is essential to recognize that the amount of forage that animals will eat is likely to be determined by a complex of factors. Some earlier investigations may have oversimplified the problem; the observation by Blaxter et al. ( I96 1) that the newer concepts related to digestibility and rate of passage of foods are “attributes which are hardly consonant with their acceptability to the palate or taste” perhaps dismissed too lightly the possible significance of these other attributes. It is evident also that the amount of forage that animals eat may depend as much on the amount of forage available as on any inherent characteristics of the forage itself. Raymond (1966a) has proposed that the factors determining forage intake can be usefully divided into intrinsic factors (i.e., features inherent in the forage)
28
W . F. RAYMOND
and extrinsic factors, which depend on the method of presentation of the forage, on the effect of processes such as ensilage and dehydration, and on environmental factors. The intrinsic factors determine how much of a forage a ruminant animal could eat under ad libitum conditions; the extrinsic factors determine how much the animal is able to eat under the particular feeding conditions imposed upon it. B. INTRINSIC FACTORS DETERMINING FORAGE INTAKE It is first necessary to emphasize the great importance of rigid standardization of the conditions under which intake measurements are made, if comparisons are to be made between results from different centers (Chalupa and McCullough, 1967). Voluntary intake is generally defined as the amount animals will eat when an excess of 15 percent is offered (Blaxter et al., 1961). But fresh feed should be presented at least twice daily and uneaten residues removed to avoid soiling this fresh feed, so that limitation of intake by extrinsic factors is avoided. Ruminants are also found to vary much more in their capacities for feed intake than, say, in their digestive capacities, and adequate numbers of animals must be used to obtain reliable intake data. Heaney et al. (1968) summarized CV’s* of individual animal intakes ranging from 10.5 percent (Minson et al., 1964) to 16.4 percent in their own experiments. Complicating factors are also the species and size of the experimental animals, and most intake results are now reported in terms of the metabolic weight of the animal, expressed as liveweight to the power 0.75 (although agronomists must have detected that some of their colleagues in ruminant nutrition still prefer 0.73). In this way the voluntary intakes of both sheep and cattle could be expressed on a comparable basis (Blaxter and Wilson, 1962). But it must be accepted that intake cannot be a precise parameter of a forage, because the amount that an animal eats depends on the individuality of the animal (its species, sex, physiological status, health, etc.) as well as on the intrinsic features of the forage. 1 . The Relation between Forage Digestibility and Intake It is now accepted that the major factor limiting the amount of forage eaten by ruminants is the capacity of the rumen and digestive tract. Ruminants are able to eat much more of highly digestible forages than of less digestible forages, because the latter occupy more volume and are within the rumen for a longer time and because from them more indigestible residue has to be passed down the hind tract (Balch and Campling, 1962). A decrease in voluntary intake as forage becomes more mature, *Coefficient of variation.
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
29
and so less digestible, has been shown in many experiments both with temperate forages (Crampton et a / . , 1960; Minson et al., 1964; Demarquilly, 1966b; Osbourn et al., 1966; Heaney et al., 1966) and with tropical forages (Grieve and Osbourn, 1965; Milford, 1967; da Silva and Gomide, 1967). These results appeared to confirm the concept that rumen fill controls voluntary intake. Unfortunately this led to the more generalized concept that the voluntary intake of a forage could thus be predicted from its digestibility, and that a single forage parameter, related to digestibility, would be adequate to estimate both digestibility and intake, the two main components of nutrient intake. There is now increasing evidence that this is a too simplified concept. While with most forage species intake decreases as the forage becomes less digestible, the relationships between intake and digestibility can differ markedly between different forages. Therefore, different forage species at the same level of digestibility may be eaten in quite different amounts, a fact that is in conflict with the earlier concept. This first became apparent with the observation by several workers of higher intakes from legumes than from grasses of the same digestibility (e.g., Van Soest, 196%; Osbourn et a / . , 1966; Milford, 1967; Weston and Hogan, 1967) and subsequently of different levels of intake between grass species. Thus, low intakes have been reported with timothy (Phleum prarense) (Minson e f al., 1964; R. L. Reid and Jung, 1966; Miles and Walters, 1966), with tall fescue ( F . arundinacea) (Van Soest, 19641, and with Phalaris arundinacea (0. N. Andrews and Hoveland, 1965; O’Donovan et al., 1967) compared with other grass species. With timothy the rate of fall in intake with decreasing digestibility was found to be less than with ryegrass (Minson et al., 1964), and Heaney et a / . ( 1966) found only a negligible change in intake with decreasing digestibility of Phleum nodosum. Within a species, differences in intake characteristics have also been shown. Thus Osbourn et al. ( I 966) found the intake of a diploid variety of Italian ryegrass to be 16 percent greater than that of a tetraploid variety during first growth in the spring. Large differences in intake between different lines of Phalaris arundinacea have been shown by Roe and Mottershead ( 1962) and O’Donovan et al. ( 1967). 2 . Differences in Intake between Forage Species Observations of different intake-digestibility relationships for different forages are of considerable importance. As long as voluntary intake was accepted as being determined mainly by level of digestibility, there appeared to be little prospect of improving the nutritive potential (intake X digestibility) of forages except by an improvement in digesti-
30
W. F. RAYMOND
bility. The evidence that factors in forage other than digestibility can also affect intake now offers a much wider scope for the improvement of forage nutritive value. Two possible lines of development are indicated in the work of Osbourn et al. (1966) and O’Donovan et al. (1967), noted above. Thus Osbourn et al. (1966) and Osbourn (1967) showed marked differences in voluntary intake, in the order lucerne > ryegrass > timothy, at a given level of digestibility. Chemical analysis of these forages showed that the “digestible” fraction in lucerne contained a higher proportion of pepsin-soluble material, and a lower proportion of digestible fiber than the “digestible” fraction in timothy, with the levels in ryegrass intermediate between those for lucerne and timothy (Fig. 3).
PEPSIN SOLUBLE MATERIAL
DIGESTIBLE FIBER
INDIGESTIBLE MATERIAL
LUCERNE Voluntary intake qDM/kqO’~dldoy
82
S 24
5 48
73
bl
FIG. 3. The composition of the digested fraction, and the voluntary intakes of lucerne, S.24 ryegrass, and S.48 timothy forages of the same dry matter (D.M.)digestibility. (From Osbourn, 1967.)
Van Soest ( 1 965c) reported a similar conclusion, that lucerne contains a higher proportion of cell contents (material soluble in neutral detergent) and a. lower proportion of cell wall constituents, than grass of the same level of digestibility. While the grass and lucerne forages are of the same digestibility, it is likely that the lucerne will reach the “digested” stage more rapidly than the ryegrass, and the ryegrass than the timothy. The digestible fraction of the lucerne could thus occupy less volume X time within the rumen; as a result the animal could eat more of it than of the grasses. Osbourn ( 1 967) also reported that, in the experiment described by Osbourn et al. (1966), the diploid ryegrass had a higher content of pepsin-soluble material than the tetraploid ryegrass, which could have been associated with the higher intake of the diploid variety.
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
31
The observations illustrated in Fig. 3 offer one possible explanation as to why different forages of the same level of digestibility may be digested at different rates, and so have different intake levels. But there is also the possibility that rate of digestion, and in turn the rate of intake, may be affected by conditions within the rumen. As Tilley et al. ( 1 964) have shown (Table 1) the rate and extent of cellulose digestion decreases as the pH of an in vitro system (and by analogy of the rumen in vivo) diverges from the physiologically normal level of about pH 6.8. Some forages, particularly highly buffered, low-sugar, forages such as the legumes, are found to give a characteristically higher rumen pH (6.6 to 6.8) than perennial ryegrass (<6.5), and Raymond (1966a) has suggested that these differences in rumen pH could lead to a higher rate of digestion of the cell wall fraction of lucerne than of ryegrass, and that this could partly account for the higher level of intake of lucerne and of other legumes. This introduces the possibility of developing feeding regimes which, by maintaining rumen pH close to the optimum level of 6.8, could ensure the most rapid rate of digestion of the cell wall content in the feed, with a resulting high level of voluntary intake. The results of Roe and Mottershead (1962) and O’Donovan et al. (1967) have indicated that other factors may also modify the simple relationship between forage digestibility and forage intake. These workers showed that, within the species Pharlaris arundinacea, sheep showed a marked preference for certain strains compared with others. An extract from one low-preference strain, sprayed on a higher-preference strain, made it unacceptable to the sheep (Roe and Mottershead, 1962). O’Donovan el al. (1967) also established differences in intake between lines of this grass, and suggested that it might be possible to breed lines of improved intake characteristics. No intake problem appears to have arisen with P . tuberosa (0.N. Andrews and Hoveland, 196% but it is of interest that the Aberystwyth variety S.230 ( P . tuberosa X P. arundinacea) was found to be very unpalatable to sheep (U. I. Jones, 1959). Considerable differences have been found between the intake-digestibility relationships for different forage species but different workers are not in agreement about the form of these relationships. Blaxter and Wilson (1962) found a curvilinear relationship, intake increasing less rapidly with digestibility at higher levels of forage digestibility. J. B. Hutton ( 1963) and Conrad et al. ( 1 964) found no increase in intake above a forage dry matter digestibility of about 7076, and Baumgardt ( 1 967) found that the intake of a roughage-concentrate mixture did not increase when the energy digestibility was above 67 percent (ca. percent dry
32
W. F. RAYMOND
matter digestibility). In contrast Osbourn et al. (1966, and unpublished) have found no divergence from linearity with a wide range of grasses and legumes up to 80 percent dry matter digestibility. The results of J. B. Hutton (1963) and Conrad et al. ( 1 964) suggested that at high levels of forage digestibility intake begins to be limited by metabolic factors (blood levels of organic acids, glucose, etc.) rather than by gastrointestinal fill. That is, the ruminant begins to behave, in intake terms, like a nonruminant (Conrad, 1966). Freer and Campling (1963) also showed that the intake of (highly digestible) concentrated feeds was not limited by bulk. Van Soest ( 1965c) has suggested that this is likely to occur when forage dry-matter contains less than 5 5 to 60 percent of cell wall constituents. However, the level at which forage digestibility no longer limits intake must to some extent depend on the physiological condition of the animal being fed, i.e., on the critical level of blood metabolites at which it ceases to eat. The experiments of Osbourn et al. ( 1 966) were all carried out with “thin” sheep, with a high growth potential, which may therefore have had a higher threshold intake level than some other experimental animals, such as the mature sheep used by Blaxter et al. (1 961). Critical studies to compare the voluntary intake levels of the same forage by ruminants in different physiological states are needed: particular examples would be animals in early or late lactation, or subjected to climatic stress.
3. The Effect of Fertilizers on Forage Intake In many experiments initial observations of differences between forages have been made in “preference-ranking” tests in which sheep were offered a free choice from a number of different forages. In only few experiments have differences in voluntary intake characteristics then been established by feeding high and low preference strains separately to sheep under ad libitum conditions. This illustrates a most important feature in the testing of forage intake, that differences in preference ranking must be confirmed in intake experiments before superiority of the higher-ranking forages can be accepted. Thus Bland and Dent (1 962) reported a positive correlation between the preference ranking and the content of water-soluble carbohydrates in a number of varieties of cocksfoot, and Plice ( 1952) suggested that the low preference ranking of grass fertilized with nitrogen was due to the lower content of sugar in such grass. But experiments under ad libitum feeding have shown no effect on voluntary intake from widely different levels of N fertilization of grass. Thus Marten and Donker (1964) found no differences in voluntary intakes of Bromus inermis fertilized with no nitrogen (24 percent
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
33
crude protein; 7.2 percent ethanol-soluble sugar) or with 300 pounds of N per acre (28 percent and 5.4 percent). Likewise, R. L. Reid and Jung (1965) found similar levels of intake from Festuca arundinacea grown with or without nitrogen fertilizer, although sheep showed a marked preference for the low-nitrogen grass. Holmes and Lang (1963) and Hight er al. (1968) have also reported that nitrogen fertilization had no effect on the voluntary intake of grass fed to either dairy cows or sheep. Cameron ( 1967) found similar intakes of hay fertilized with 0 or 1 12 kg. of N per hectare. We cannot conclude from these results that nitrogen fertilization never decreases the voluntary intake of forage - the reports of feed refusal and poor animal performance sometimes experienced in practice cannot be ignored- but experimental confirmation is still lacking. And in other cases, described in Section V, D, there is clear evidence that the intake of forages of very low nitrogen content can be increased by nitrogen fertilization. Greenhalgh and Reid (1967) have suggested that the relative importance of “rumen fill” and “palatability” in determining the voluntary intake of forages may be studied by introducing feed directly into the rumen via a fistula. An equivalent decrease in the intake per 0s would demonstrate that intake is being controlled by rumen fill. If intake per 0s remains at the original level some other factor, such as palatability (or more strictly, unpalatability) would be indicated. When ad libitum chopped straw was fed to sheep per os, and an equal quantity of grass was introduced through the fistula, total daily intake was 23.5 g. dry matter per kilogram liveweight to the power 0.73, but when the feeding regime was reversed, total intake increased to 48.8 g., indicating that the amount of straw the sheep ate was not limited by rumen fill only. However, further examination of this technique, and in particular of the effect of the absence of mastication and salivary secretion on the feed introduced via a fistula is still needed. Sonneveld (1965) has suggested that forage intake by cattle may be related to the moisture content of the forage. Herbage was cut daily and fed to cattle throughout a complete year, and the voluntary intake on each day was related to a number of forage parameters by multiple regression. Intake on any day was slightly related to the level of forage digestibility, but more closely to day-to-day changes in moisture content. lntake was found to increase with a decrease in forage moisture content, relative to the previous day’s feed, when forages were at a low fiber stage, but the reverse was found when the forage was of high fiber content. Conversely Holmes and Lang (1963) found that intake did not change when forage moisture content increased to 84 percent, compared with 80 percent in
34
W. F. RAYMOND
the control forage, following nitrogen fertilization. The difference between these observations indicates a need for further study. While the higher intake of legumes than of grasses appears, at least in part, to be due to the higher proportion of cell contents in the legumes, this explanation does not appear to account for differences in intake which have been found between different legumes. Thus Van Soest ( 1 965a) reported a higher intake of birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus) than of lucerne of the same level of digestibility, and Osbourn et al. (1 966) found a similarly higher intake of sainfoin than of red clover or lucerne. In the latter experiment the content of pepsin-soluble material in the red clover (36.4%)was higher than in the sainfoin (33.5%). Troelsen and Bigsby (1964) had demonstrated an inverse relationship between the resistance to maceration and the voluntary intake of a series of hays; part of this relationship is likely to be due to a direct association of physical strength of plant materials with increasing fibrousness (and so to decreasing digestibility), but Osbourn et al. (1 966) suggested that there might remain differences in intake, as between sainfoin and red clover. A similar concept is seen in the fibrousness index of Chenost ( 1 966), which is measured as the electrical energy needed to pulverize a 5-g. sample of the dried forage, and which was shown to be closely related to dry matter intake. Evans ( 1 964) has shown differences in breaking strength of grass leaves, and Theron and Booysen (1966) have related breaking strength positively to the acid-insoluble lignin content of 8 grass species. Johnston (1967) has shown that the force needed to penetrate the stems of kale was closely related to in vitro digestibility values. L. H. P. Jones and Handreck (1967) raise the interesting possibility that variations in the degree of silicification in grasses may contribute to variations in culm strength. In addition grass may become less palatable to the grazing animal as a result of heavily silicified hairs on the leaf surface. These concepts of the intrinsic factors that may affect forage intake represent an important advance from the earlier, oversimplified, concept that forage intake is mainly determined by the level of forage digestibility. The demonstration that forages of the same digestibility can differ markedly in level of voluntary intake, and the elucidation of some of the possible causes for this, now indicates the prospect of breeding for improved forage intake. Any argument that the extreme cases noted are exceptional is surely irrelevant. Thus the observation, in Phalaris arundinacea, of strains of high and low preference rating suggests that there are also strains of intermediate preference. More important, knowledge of the factors causing these differences in preference should
THE NUTRITIVE V A LU E OF FORAGE CROPS
35
allow the breeding of new strains of even higher preference rating. “Palatability” may be an imprecise concept, but the observation of extreme unpalatability in some species indicates the likelihood of intermediate unpalatability in other species, which it would be unwise to dismiss. For a difference of only 10 percent in voluntary intake between two forages could have as great an effect on their relative values for animal production as the difference of 6 units in digestibility between S.24 ryegrass and S.37 cocksfoot, about which much has been written. C. THENUTRITIVEVALUEINDEX With the recognition that both voluntary intake and the level of digestibility of a forage play major roles in determining its nutritive value, Crampton et al. (1960) suggested that intake and digestibility should be combined in a single parameter, the nutritive value index. The concept was possibly complicated by relating the actual intake of a given forage, expressed per kilogram liveweight to the power 0.75 (kg. LW0.7s), to a theoretical standard forage of intake 80 g. dry matterlkg. LW0.75,the relative intake being calculated: Relative intake =
actual intakelkg. LW0.75 80
and the nutritive value index: NVI
= relative
intake X
% digestibility of forage energy content I00
( 1 1)
Crampton er al. (1960) proposed, from initial studies with 9 forages, that the rate of cellulose disappearance in a 12-hour standard in vitro digestion ( x ) could be closely related to the NVI: (12) Donefer et al. ( 1 966) subsequently reported an improved correlation between NVI and the percentage of the forage dry matter soluble in acid pepsin (P): NVI
=
1.3 1 4 ~ 7.8
NVI = 1.60P - 0.75 ( r = 0.95**)
(13)
In reporting these results, Donefer er al. (1966) suggested that both of the measures used, rate of cellulose digestion and pepsin solubility, are likely to be more closely related to the intake characteristics of forages than to digestibility. The high correlations with N V I result from the feature, already noted, that intake changes considerably more with changes in forage maturity than does digestibility (Ingalls et al., 1965). The relationship of pepsin solubility to voluntary intake is in line with the
36
W. F. RAYMOND
conclusions of Osbourn et al. (1966), illustrated in Fig. 3. However the relatively poor correlation of pepsin solubility with dry matter digestibility (Terry and Tilley, 1964b; Donefer et al., 1966) indicates that a more precise estimate of NVI might be obtained by a combination of analyses for pepsin solubility (relative intake) and in vitro digestibility. In that case, however, the separate estimates of intake and digestibility could be of more use than the single parameter of N V I , by indicating the relative importance of the differences in intake and in digestibility among the forages being studied. D. THE CRUDEPROTEINCONTENTOF FORAGE AND VOLUNTARY INTAKE
While nitrogen fertilization generally seems to have little effect on the intake characteristics of forages, an exception occurs in the case of forages of very low crude protein content, for which rate of digestion within the rumen, and so level of intake, seems to be limited by the lack of nitrogenous substrates for the rumen microorganisms. The critical level of feed protein depends on the type of forage, but it is commonly in the range of 4-6 percent crude protein. Thus Minson (1 967) showed a 54 percent higher intake of pangola grass (Digitaria decumbens) fertilized with 250 kg. of urea per acre (7.2 percent crude protein in the forage dry matter) than at 100 kg./acre (3.7 percent crude protein). Minson and Milford (1967) showed that the intake of the same species (at 3.6 percent crude protein) was increased when a supplement of lucerne was fed, to a maximum intake at a total diet content of 6 percent crude protein, after which the intake of the grass decreased as it was progressively replaced by lucerne. In most experiments the available feed nitrogen has been increased indirectly by supplementary feeding, particularly with' sources of nonprotein nitrogen, such as urea. This is discussed more fully in Section V , D; but in relation to forage intake there is evidence that the intake of low-protein forages can be considerably increased by feeding urea. Thus Campling et al. (1962) found a 40 percent increase in the intake of oat straw (3.0 percent crude protein), and Graham (1 967) found a 50 percent increase with Digitaria decumbens (4.0percent crude protein), resulting from urea supplementation. However, at a higher level of feed protein (5 to 7 percent), Kay et al. (1968) found no significant improvement in the intake of barley straw when supplementary nitrogen was fed. Weston (1967) showed that at very low levels of crude protein the main factor limiting the intake of wheaten hay was nitrogen deficiency; when this was remedied, intake was then limited by the rate of removal of indigesti-
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
37
ble residues from the rumen. However, Egan and Moir (1965) have queried whether the intake of low-nitrogen hay is limited solely by deficiency of feed nitrogen within the rumen, as infusion of casein directly into the abomasum or duodenum was found to increase the intake of such hay. This source of nitrogen could have benefited bacterial digestion within the rumen only indirectly, and these authors suggested that the amount of protein reaching the duodenum may itself affect voluntary intake. E. THEEFFECTOF
SUPPLEMENTARY
FEEDSON FORAGEINTAKE
The use of nonprotein.nitrogen compounds is one aspect of the larger subject of feed interactions, including the effect of other components of the total ration on the amounts of different forages that the ruminant will eat. Most studies to date have been essentially practical and have recorded mainly the changes in forage intake when supplements are fed. As with the effects of supplementary feeding on forage digestibility, noted in Section IV, C, 3 , an understanding of the biological basis of these interactions is essential if supplementary feeding is to be other than an empirical procedure. As might be expected, the most general observation is that, as increasing amounts of supplementary concentrates are fed, the ruminant animal eats less forage. This decrease in forage intake appears to be more marked with forages of high digestibility (i.e., of initially high intake) than with forages of lower digestibility and intake (Blaxter and Wilson, 1963; Campling and Murdoch, 1966). The considerable reduction in the voluntary intake of forages of high digestibility may well be associated with the observations, noted in Section V, B, 1, that such forages tend to behave like concentrated feeds, so that their voluntary intake may be determined by levels of blood metabolites, rather than by rumen fill; in that case level of forage intake might be expected to decrease as a result of the enhanced levels of blood metabolites following concentrate feeding. The reduction in intake of forages of lower digestibility may in part be related to the effects of supplementary feeding on rumen pH, noted in Section IV, C, 3. As the level of concentrate feeding increases, rumen pH tends to decrease (P.K. Briggs et al., 1957; Topps et al., 1965) and it is possible that this causes a reduced rate of digestion of the cell wall constituents in the forage (Tilley et al., 1964), and so a reduced level of voluntary intake. The depression in rumen pH could perhaps be greater with concentrates of low protein content (containing mainly cereals) than with those of higher protein content, and this may partly account for
38
W. F. RAYMOND
the greater reduction in forage intake when low-protein concentrates are fed. However, the most important feature is evident, that in many cases supplementary feeds partly replace rather than supplement the forage with which they are fed; the significance of this in determining the economic response to supplementary feeding emphasizes the urgent need for more detailed studies of these food interactions. VI. The Efficiency of Utilization of Digested Nutrients
The previous sections have examined the factors that determine the quantity of digested nutrients (intake x digestibility) made available to the ruminant; the following sections consider the efficiency with which it utilizes the various components within these digested nutrients, in particular the energy, protein, and minerals, as well as other components in forages which may modify their potential as practical ruminant feeds. A. METHODSOF EXPRESSING ENERGYVALUES 1 . Digestible Energy
Most results of digestibility experiments with forages have been reported in terms of the digestibility of the dry matter or of the organic matter in the forage (Eq. 1) or of its content of total digestible nutrients (TDN), which effectively measures the percentage of digestible organic matter in the forage dry matter (Minson et a f . , 1960). Digestibility is primarily an index of the energy value of a feed. Crampton et al. ( 1 960) have proposed that all results should be reported in terms of digestible energy by measuring C (Eq. 1) in kilocalories; TDN data already published could be converted on the basis of 4.4 kcal. of digestible energy per gram of TDN. The latter factor can only be approximate, as it varies with the crude protein and ether extract contents of the forage (Heaney and Pigden, 1963), and direct calorific determinations on feed and feces samples provide the only reliable method. 2 . Metabolizable Energy All the expressions of digestibility based on Eq. (1) measure the “apparent” digestibility, rather than the “true” digestibility of the feed energy, for the feces contain metabolic residues not derived from the feed (Section 111, C ) . But these are in practice more useful measures than “true” digestibility, because these metabolic residues represent an inevitable energy loss associated with the processes of digestion and
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
39
assimilation of the feed. Energy is also lost in the methane produced from microbial digestion of carbohydrates within the rumen, and in the waste products excreted in the urine. The metabolizable energy (ME) in the forage: ME = digestible energy - methane energy - urine energy
(14)
thus more usefully expresses the proportion of the energy in the feed which is available for the metabolic and productive activities of the animal. To measure metabolizable energy precisely requires, in addition to total collection of feces and urine, the measurement of methane production in a respiration chamber. For many purposes, however, an estimate of methane production: Methane (g.) = 2.4 I X
+ 9.80 (sheep; Swift ef al., 1948)
(15)
where X = grams of carbohydrate digested + 100, based on data from respiration chamber experiments, is likely to be sufficiently accurate; but wherever possible this should be checked, as Eq. (15) may not be valid in novel feed situations -for instance, when milled dehydrated forages are fed to ruminants (Blaxter and Graham, 1956). Furthermore, Flatt ( 1 966) has shown that methane and urine production is not constant, but decreases as the level of feeding of a particular feed is increased. As noted earlier, digestibility decreases as level of feeding increases (e.g., Moe et al., 1965). These changes in digestibility and in methane and urine production tend to compensate. As a result Flatt ( 1 966) found that the metabolizable energy content of a feed changes relatively little with change in the level at which it is fed, but this conclusion is not in complete agreement with that of Blaxter (1962), who concluded that metabolizable energy decreases with an increase in level of feed intake. Such divergences are in fact to be expected, because metabolizable energy is not thefixed characteristic of a feed that is sometimes implied. Urine energy, in particular, reflects the physiological status of the animal, the animal with a high positive nitrogen balance (e.g., the dairy cow, used by Flatt, 1966) giving a lower urine energy loss than one with lower nitrogen balance (e.g., the mature sheep, used by Blaxter, 1962). Because of this the dairy cow may show less decrease in the metabolizable energy of a feed than the mature sheep at feeding levels above maintenance. In general terms, Armstrong et af. ( 1964b) and Graham ( 1964) found that the metabolizable energy of grass was about 81 percent of the digestible energy content, and could therefore be calculated from its energy digestibility measured in vitro.
40
W. F. RAYMOND
3 . N e t Energy The classical studies of Kellner and Armsby established that as feeds become less digestible their content of metabolizable energy is less efficiently used by the ruminant animal. The methods of expression of useful energy used by the European workers (starch equivalent) and the North American workers (net energy) were different, as were some of the underlying concepts, but for some purposes the two systems can be equated, 1 pound of starch equivalent being taken as equal to 1,071 kcal. of net energy. These systems of feed evaluation accept that when the animal digests and metabolizes food there is a production of heat within the body which represents a net loss of energy that is an inevitable part of the utilization of the food (an exception is when the animal is in a very cold environment, and can use this heat production to maintain body temperature instead of needing to oxidize useful food for this purpose). In precise terms, net energy (NE) is an incremental measure: N E = (ME,
-
ME,)
-(HB
- HA)
(16)
where ME and H are the metabolizable energy and heat production from the same feed fed at levels A and B. But for practical feed evaluation it is treated: Net energy = (metabolizable energy) - (heat production) (17) As feeds become less digestible an increasing amount of heat is produced for each unit of metabolizable energy derived from the feed, so that the net energy falls more rapidly than metabolizable energy or total digestible nutrients content (L. A. Moore et al., 1953): N E = 1.393 x T D N
-
34.63 ( r = 0.977)
(18)
A similar result is achieved in the starch equivalent system by making a correction, based on the crude fiber content of the feed, which is thus inversely related to the level of digestibility. This wastage of heat was considered to be due to the energy of digestion, and the increase in heat production with less digestible feeds was attributed to the increased energy needed to eat and digest such feeds. This somewhat imprecise concept, challenged by recent developments in knowledge of ruminant digestion and metabolism, does still appear to account for much of the difference in energy value between feeds. B. THEROLEOF VOLATILE FATTY ACIDSIN RUMINANT METABOLISM 1 . The U s e of Volatile Fatty Acids as Energy Metabolites It has long been known that among the main products of microbial
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
41
fermentation within the rumen are steam-volatile fatty acids, in particular acetic, propionic, and butyric acids, with smaller amounts of isobutyric and longer-chain acids. Early in the 1950’s it was shown that these acids are absorbed from the ruminant digestive tract and provide a major source of energy metabolites for the animal (reviewed by Annison and Lewis, 1959). Recent work has suggested that some 70 to 80 percent of the energy supply of the ruminant on normal feeds is provided by volatile fatty acids (A. C. I. Warner, 1964). These acids are produced by fermentation of a very wide range of feed substrates-sugars, cellulose, hemicellulose, proteins, etc. As I. W. McDonald ( I 968) has emphasized, digestion within the rumen serves the remarkable function of converting a most diverse range of chemical constituents in the feedstuffs eaten by the ruminant into the relatively simple range of compounds that it absorbs and uses as metabolites. The acid produced by fermentation of feed within the rumen comprises mainly acetic, propionic, and butyric acids, but it was found that the proportions in which these are produced differs among classes of feeds: in general, as feeds become less digestible the combined proportions of propionic and butyric acids decreases, and that of acetic acid increases (Rook and Balch, 196 1). This observation assumed particular significance with the demonstration by Blaxter and his associates (Armstrong and Blaxter, 1957; Blaxter, 1962) that these three acids appear to be used by the ruminant with different efficiencies for different metabolic purposes. In a detailed series of calorimetric experiments these workers showed that, when these acids were infused into the rumen in vivo, they were used with equal efficiency for maintenance purposes (respiration, circulation, etc.), but that acetic acid was much less efficiently used for lipogenesis (body fat synthesis) than propionic and butyric acids. These results indicated that the decrease in efficiency ofuse of metabolizable energy as feeds become less digestible might at least in part be the result of theassociated shift in rumen fermentation products from propionate plus butyrate on highly digestible feeds to predominantly acetate on feeds of low digestibility. The observation that the three acids were equally efficiently used for animal maintenance purposes led Blaxter ( 1 962) to propose a system of feed evaluation in which the efficiency of utilization of metabolizable energy for maintenance (K,J is assumed to be constant, and the same for all feeds, but the efficiency of utilization for lipogenesis (fattening KJ)decreases as feed becomes less digestible, that is: K , = constant
K j = 0.8lQ + 3.0
(19)
42
W. F. RAYMOND
where Q is the ME, expressed as a percentage of the gross energy in the feed. The concept that the efficiency with which the ruminant uses its digestible and metabolizable energy intake is largely determined by the pattern of volatile fatty acid production within the rumen has had a most profound effect on ruminant research in the last decade. In many experiments in which feeds or rations have been compared, higher levels of animal production have been recorded on the feed or ration giving the higher proportion of propionate plus butyrate in the total rumen acidsand the conclusion has been drawn that the higher level of production was the result of the higher proportion of these acids. But this elegant explanation of differences between ruminant feeds contains anomalies, and its generalized validity must now be questioned. First, the original infusion experiments examined the efficiency of utilization of the different acids for lipogenesis in the mature sheep; they cannot equally well explain the decrease in efficiency of bovine milk production with decreasing level of feed digestibility, for as Rook and Balch (196 1) indicated, acetic acid, the predominant acid produced in the rumen from feeds of low digestibility, is more efficiently used for milk production than is propionic acid. Neither is there any evidence that acetic acid is less efficiently used than propionic or butyric acids for body protein synthesis, which comprised only a small part of the body-energy gain of the sheep used in the experiments reported by Blaxter; in fact Rook and Balch ( 1 96 1) indicated that efficiencies may be in the reverse order. Second, the conclusion that the ratio of propionic plus butyric acids to acetic acid is closely related to feed digestibility does not hold for all feeds: Terry and Tilley (1962) found very little relationship between rumen acid pattern and forage digestibility, and showed that the molar proportion of propionic acid in the rumen acids ( P ) was more closely related to the soluble carbohydrate content (C) in a range of forages: P
= 0.48C
+ 16.5
( r = 0.75)
(2 1)
As forages of the same digestibility can differ markedly in their content of soluble carbohydrate, a system of feed evaluation, based on rumen acid proportions, would indicate a more efficient utilization for lipogenesis of the metabolizable energy in a high-sugar than in a low-sugar forage of the same digestibility. Yet Thomson (1964) found identical energy gains when ryegrass samples of high or low sugar contents were fed to lambs. There was also an indication that a higher proportion of the energy gain by the lambs on the low-sugar grass (7 percent soluble carbohydrate, 29 percent crude protein) was in the form of body protein
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
43
than on the high-sugar grass (19 percent and 16 percent), a result which could be of economic significance. For, paradoxically, the one form of animal production, lipogenesis, for which propionic and butyric acids have been indicated as superior to acetic acid, is the one least required by the meat industry and the consumer. Third, while the measured differences in the proportions of volatile fatty acids between rations have generally been in the predicted direction, they have also nearly always been much too small to account for the observed differences in animal production. Blaxter and Wainman ( 1 964, Fig. 4) showed a decrease of 1.091 in K f for each 1 percent increase in the molar proportion of acetic acid in the rumen acids. In a comparison of immature and mature ryegrass feeds, Armstrong ( 1 960) found the Kf value of the immature feed to be 26 percent greater than of the mature feed; the corresponding molar proportions of acetic acid in the rumen acids, 61.0 and 65.4, would indicate a difference of only 5 percent in KJ values. On the basis of these and other experiments, in which no overall relationship could be established between the molar proportions of rumen acids in animals fed on different grass feeds and the efficiency of lipogenesis, Armstrong (1964) concluded that mechanisms, in addition to that based on rumen volatile fatty acids, must be sought for the observed differences in energy value between feeds. Finally the concept of energy metabolism based on the rumen acids indicated that the metabolizable energy of all feeds should be equally efficiently used for maintenance, and that differences would occur only in their use for productive purposes. However, Brouwer et al. (1961) reported that the requirement of metabolizable energy for maintenance of the 500-kg. cow increased from 11.3 Mcal. with an early-cut hay to 12.7 Mcal. for a mature hay. From a recalculation of earlier calorimetric experiments, Armstrong ( 1964) concluded that the efficiency of utilization of metabolizable energy for maintenance (K,,J decreased with a decrease in feed digestibility (metabolizable energy concentration in the feed, Q ) :
K,,, = 50.9 + 0.3759
(22)
From data on a wider range of feeds, Blaxter (1964) derived the relationship: K,,, = 54.8
+ 0.30Q
(23)
and Graham (1964) also concluded that metabolizable energy is less efficiently used for maintenance as feeds become more fibrous, i.e., as Q decreases.
44
W. F. RAYMOND
“It seems clear then that the earlier assumption that the metabolizable energy of all feeds is used with equal efficiency for maintenance purposes involved too wide an extrapolation of the results of experiments with rumen infusions of pure volatile fatty acids. In effect it implied that a constant proportion of the M.E. of feeds of widely differing digestibilities is absorbed from the rumen as volatile fatty acids. Armstrong ( 1 964) has suggested that, with diminishing digestibility in a series of feeds, an increasing fraction of the M.E. is lost as heat of fermentation, and a lower proportion absorbed as useful energy” (Raymond, 1966b). It is also most likely that maintenance requirement itself will effectively increase as a result of the greater muscular energy involved in chewing and movement of the larger quantity of more fibrous feed required to provide a given amount of metabolizable energy from a low than from a high digestibility feed. These mechanisms, viz. the decreased proportion of metabolizable energy absorbed as volatile fatty acids and the increased energy of digestion as feeds become less digestible, could both also be expected to occur in the utilization of metabolizable energy above maintenance. This increased wastage of energy might thus be expected to contribute to the coefficient 0.8 1 in Eq. (20); the remainder of this coefficient may then be accounted for by less efficient lipogenesis as a result of the increasing proportion of acetic acid in the rumen acids when feeds of low digestibility are fed. This analysis of the original proposals of Blaxter (1962) offers some explanation of the discrepancies noted. Thus both Kf and K , can be expected to decrease with decreasing feed digestibility; the quite small differences in rumen acid proportions often found could be adequate to explain the residual differences in Kf between feeds of different digestibilities: the decreasing efficiency of the lactating animal with decreasing feed digestibility would be due to the dominance of losses of energy in digestion, despite the higher efficiency of use of acetic acid for milk production (Rook and Balch, 1961). On this basis, the decreasing efficiency of utilization of metabolizable energy as feeds become less digestible would result mainly from the decrease in digestibility per se (as in the original Kellner system) with a further decrease in efficiency for lipogenesis due to the less favorable rumen acid pattern, which is not implicit in the Kellner system. This concept would place emphasis on level of feed digestibility, rather than on rumen acid pattern, as the main determinant of the eficiency with which the digestible and metabolizable energy in feeds are utilized by the ruminant. Yet since 1964 the number of publications in which differences in
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
45
nutritive value between feeds have been attributed mainly to differences in rumen acid patterns has increased, rather than decreased. It would be invidious-and unhelpful - to summarize them here; but it does appear that emphasis on this mechanism has diverted attention from differences in feed digestibility and feed intake, which have often been neither controlled, nor measured, in these experiments. This comment implies, not that the rumen acids are not important, but that interpretations of animal production results based on rumen acid patterns must be considered more critically. First, it is important, where rumen acid proportions are measured, that this is done accurately. Many experiments have relied on single samples of rumen fluid taken at a fixed time after feeding; but the concentration and proportions of the volatile fatty acids in rumen fluid can vary markedly throughout the day (Terry and Tilley, 1964b), reflecting the pattern of feeding of a given forage (I. H. Bath and Rook, 1963; Faichney, 1 9 6 8 ~or ) of a forage with concentrate ration (McCullough and Smart, 1968). The more irregular the feeding, the wider the fluctuations in rumen acids and the greater the need for an intensive sampling schedule. 2 . Rumen Condition and Rumen Acid Patterns There is also need for further study of the causes of the particular rumen acid patterns produced when different feeds are digested. Some evidence suggests that these are the result of the conditions established within the rumen by the particular feed and feeding regime adopted, rather than of the digestibility of the feed per se. Thus there was a shift from a higher to a lower acetate:propionate fermentation when the proportion of cereal in a mixed cereal-hay diet was increased, but I. H. Bath and Rook ( I 965) showed that this shift could not be accounted for solely by the increasing digestibility of the diet. I t is known that increasing the proportion of cereal in the diet leads to a decrease in the pH of the rumen content (P. K. Briggs et al., 1957; Topps et al., 1965). This led R. L. Reid et al. (1 957), C . L. Davis et al. ( 1 964), and Raymond ( 1 966a) to suggest that the rumen conditions associated with cereal feeding may favor the microbial production of propionic and butyric acids and discourage the production of acetic acid. This could be the result of a shift either in the bacterial population or in the nature of the end products of fermentation. Much reported evidence is consistent with this hypothesis. Thus C. L. Davis et al. (1964) found that sodium bicarbonate, fed with concentrates plus limited alfalfa hay, increased pH and led to an increased acetate and decreased propionate proportion in the rumen acids. Terry and Tilley (1963) reported a reduction in rumen pH and a de-
46
W. F. RAYMOND
crease in the acetate:propionate ratio when the level of feeding of S.24 ryegrass was increased. McCullough and Smart ( 1968) found that a corn silage-flaked corn mixture, fed in four equal feeds, gave a fairly level rumen pH throughout the day. When the grain and silage were fed separately, the rumen pH and rumen acetate level were both markedly depressed after the grain feeding, and did not increase until the silage was fed. Faichney (1968b) found a wide fluctuation in rumen pH when alfalfa pellets were fed in a single feed, with pH below 6.0 and an acetate: propionate ratio below 3.5 during the period of maximum acid concentration in the rumen. When the same quantity of pellets was fed in eight feeds, rumen pH remained above 6.0 and the acetate:propionate ratio was in the range 5.3 to 5.7 throughout the 24 hours. Von Kaufmann and Rohr (1967) have summarized the changes in rumen acid patterns with changes in rumen pH, measured in their own experiments (Fig. 4) which are in close accord with the foregoing observations.
RUMEN pH FIG.4. Schema of the changes in the molar contents of volatile fatty acids and lactic acid within the rumen at different levels of rumen pH: at low pH levels, either lactic or propionic acid may occur under different conditions. (From von Kaufmann and Rohr, 1967.)
At present these results indicate an association between rumen pH and rumen acid patterns, rather than a direct causation, but they help to explain the conclusion that rumen acid patterns can differ between feeds of the same digestibility: for rumen pH is clearly not solely determined by level of feed digestibility, but depends also on feed composition and pattern of feeding. This has led C. L. Davis et al. (1964) and McCullough and Smart ( 1 968) to suggest that it may be possible to predetermine the pattern of feeding of a given ration so as to shift the
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
47
rumen acid pattern in the required direction. This could be toward a propionate fermentation if body fat synthesis is required. Of much greater significance could be the possible control of milk composition; thus low levels of butterfat are often found in milk produced from rations containing low levels of fiber, and this has been shown to result from the low production of acetate (a precursor in milk-fat synthesis) in the rumen of cows fed on these rations (Balch et al., 1952). The above authors have suggested that by feeding concentrates and limited roughage together (McCullough and Smart, 19681, or by supplementing with sodium bicarbonate (C. L. Davis er d.,1964), mean rumen pH would be increased, and that this might lead to an increased acetate production and increased butterfat levels in milk. Conversely, too low a level of rumen propionate appears to reduce the level of solids-not-fat in milk. Baumgardt (1967) has suggested that the maximum overall efficiency of use of metabolites for milk production occurs with an acetate:propionate molar ratio of 2.75:1, and this could indicate the target toward which feeding regimes should aim; this ratio is very close to that indicated by von Kaufmann and Rohr ( 1967) in Fig. 4. In this perspective, the patterns of rumen volatile fatty acids produced from different forages are clearly of interest and importance. Although, as noted above, these patterns may not be mediated directly through rumen pH, the association seems close enough to indicate that, as the pH at which forage is digested in the rumen decreases, there is likely to be a shift in the products of rumen fermentation from acetic acid to propionic plus butyric acids. Thus forages of high soluble carbohydrate content tend to give the lowest rumen pH and the highest propionate values (Eq. 21). Application of nitrogen fertilizer can decrease the soluble carbohydrate content of grass (McIlroy, 1967). When this grass is fed it gives a higher rumen pH level and a higher proportion of acetate in the rumen acids than similar but unfertilized grass (Thomson, 1964; A. M. Bryant and Ulyatt, 1965; Grimes, 1967). R. L. Reid and Jung (1965) found no effect on rumen acid patterns resulting from nitrogen fertilization of grass; in that experiment there was also no effect on the soluble carbohydrate content of the grass. In these and other experiments no clear relationship has been shown between rumen acid pattern and level of forage digestibility. Thus Italian ryegrass of high digestibility and high sugar content has given 62 percent of acetate in the rumen acids; white clover of the same digestibility has given 67 percent (Terry and Thomson, unpublished). These results with white clover at the Grassland Research Institute differ, however, from those in New Zealand, where higher levels of sugar content and
48
W. F. RAYMOND
lower proportions of lumen acetate have been found with white clover (R. W. Bailey, 1964). The recent emphasis on lumen acids has also led to investigations of in vitro techniques of estimating rumen acid production, despite the indication by A. C. I. Warner (1964) of the assumptions involved in extrapolating from in vitro to in vivo results. The more recent work reported here reinforces this qualification. Thus Raymond and Terry ( 1 966) and Griffiths (1967) have reported that the proportions of acids produced in an in vitro system can be changed by altering the pH of the system: a reduction in pH produces, as might be predicted, a shift from acetate to propionate or butyrate production. This means that the acid production measured in an in vitro system may reflect the pH at which the system is buffered, rather than the nature of the feed being tested. As rumen pH in vivo can vary between 5.0 and 7.0, in vitro systems are most unlikely to give estimates of rumen acid patterns free from operator bias. It might be suggested that the in vitro system should be buffered at the pH measured in vivo when the test feed is fed-but the rumen acids could then be measured in vivo. However, the different activity in vitro than in vivo (A. C . I. Warner, 1964) must indicate the need for further research before in vitro systems can be considered for the assessment of rumen acid patterns. Increasing attention is also being given to techniques for measuring the rates of production of the volatile fatty acids during microbial digestion of feeds within the rumen in vivo. One technique is based on measurement of the rate of isotope dilution of the different acids labeled with I4C (Bergman et al., 1965; C . L. Davis, 1967; Weller et al., 1967), and this has also been used to study the absorption of the acids in different parts of the digestive tract (Weston and Hogan, 1968). In an alternative technique, samples of lumen contents are removed and incubated in vitro, and the rate of acid production is measured over periods of less than 40 minutes to maintain physiological relevance. The acid production is either extrapolated back to zero time (A. C . I. Warner, 1964) or used as a direct estimate of rate of acid production in vivo (Faichney, 1968a). These techniques, applied to forages, must increase our basic understanding of the nutritive value of these feeds; Leng et al. ( 1 968) have recently reported studies with grazing sheep, for which they used an isotope dilution technique.
c. THEUTILIZATION
FORAGES I . The Digestion of Protein within the Rumen OF THE C R U D E PROTEIN IN
Many experiments have shown that the digestibility (Eq. 2) of the
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
49
crude protein (percent N X 6.25) in forages is very closely related to the crude protein content (e.g., Minson and Kemp, 1961; O’Shea and Maguire, 1967). As with other feed components, Eq. (2) measures the “apparent” digestibility of the feed nitrogen: the “true” digestibility is very close to 100% (Van Soest, 1967), and the decrease in “apparent” digestibility results from the relatively constant excretion of endogenous fecal nitrogen per unit of feed dry matter eaten. The utilization of this “digestible protein” fraction has been the subject of much study; this has established that the rumen microbial population digests and modifies almost all the nitrogenous constituents eaten in the ruminant diet, so that the nature of these nitrogenous constituents may bear little relation to the form in which the nitrogen is absorbed from the digestive tract. The first stage in this reorganization of the feed protein is deamination, the ammonia produced forming one of the main nitrogen substrates for the rumen microbes which proliferate within the rumen medium, to bring about the digestion of the feed polysaccharides, characteristic of ruminant digestion. Entrained organisms then pass with the undigested feed residues from the rumen into the hind tract, where they are subjected to intense proteolytic action in the acid conditions in the abomasum. Here a high proportion of the microbial protein is broken down into amino acids, which are then absorbed and used as the main source of amino acids by the ruminant animal (Hungate, 1966). It is for this reason that the biological value of feed protein, in the terms appropriate to the nonruminant, has little relevance for the ruminant. As I. W. McDonald ( I 968) has emphasized, the biological value will be determined by the amino acid composition of the microbial protein digested in the hind tract, which need bear little relation to the amino acid composition of the feed. The main consideration then is with the factors that determine how efficiently the feed protein (nitrogen) is converted into microbial protein. Immediately after ingestion of food by the ruminant, there is a rise in the ammonia level within the rumen as a result of microbial degradation of nitrogenous compounds. However, the rate at which this ammonia is released may be greater than the rate at which the total rumen population can utilize it, and excess ammonia may then be absorbed through the rumen epithelium into the blood, there to be detoxified and excreted in the urine (I. W. McDonald, 1968). The efficiency of feed protein utilization thus depends on the relative rates of the two processes of ammonia release within the rumen and ammonia assimilation into bacterial protein, and optimum feeding should ensure that the former is not greatly in excess of the latter, so that ammonia absorption from the rumen is mini-
50
W. F. RAYMOND
mized. This is not to suggest that such absorption is necessarily wasteful; forage protein levels are frequently well in excess of animal requirements, and excretion of nitrogen via the rumen wall and urine may then be merely an alternative to excretion after the catabolism of absorbed amino acids. But as level of protein intake decreases toward theoretical requirements, loss of ammonia through the rumen wall must begin to deprive the animal of a supply of amino acids (from microbial protein) which it could effectively use. Factors which determine the level of free ammonia within the rumen include the solubility of the feed protein, rate of deamination decreasing with decreasing solubility of the protein (Annison et al., 1954), and the pattern of feeding, frequent small feeds tending to give lower rumen ammonia levels than few large feeds (Satter and Baumgardt, 1962). The rate at which the ammonia produced is assimilated by the rumen microflora depends mainly on the proportion of readily available energy in the ration, starch and soluble carbohydrates encouraging rapid microbial proliferation and so reducing rumen ammonia levels. Active carbohydrate fermentation also leads to a lower rumen pH, at which absorption of ammonia through the rumen wall tends to be reduced (I. W. McDonald, 1968). These considerations are particularly significant with forages. The nitrogen constituents of fresh forages are mainly in solution or suspended in the cell sap. These are released during mastication of the feed, and are rapidly deaminated in the rumen (Hogan, 1965); yet forages are often low in starch or soluble carbohydrate content, so that rate of microbial growth may not keep pace with rate of ammonia production, and high levels of rumen ammonia may result, with consequent high blood urea levels (Abou Akkada and El Sayed Osman, 1967). This would indicate advantage in more frequent feeding of forage as total nitrogen intake decreases toward animal requirements, but this does not appear to have been tested. At lower levels of nitrogen intake, rate of ammonia production in the rumen begins to limit rate of microbial growth, and can lead to the reductions in herbage digestibility and voluntary intake noted in previous sections. This is one of the situations in which ration supplementation with nonprotein nitrogen may be advantageous (Section VI, D, 2).
2 . .The m e c t of Processing of Forage on Nitrogen Utilization (See Also Section ZX) Many experiments have shown that heat-dehydration of forage can reduce the apparent digestibility of the crude protein in the forage
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
51
(Watson and Nash, 1960, p. 1101, and it has become accepted that this is undesirable. However, Annison et al. ( 1954) had shown that increased nitrogen retention by sheep could result when the solubility of the protein in casein or fish meal, fed in a mixed ration, was reduced by heating; this was despite a decrease in the digestibility of the protein and was mediated through a decreased rate of release of ammonia within the rumen. This led Synge (unpublished) to suggest that a similar advantage might result from a controlled heat-denaturing of the protein in grass. The recent results of Ekern et al. ( 1 965) showing similar levels of nitrogen retention by sheep fed on fresh or dehydrated forage, despite a lower digestibility of the protein in the dried forage, are consistent with this suggestion. This result, if confirmed, must indicate the need to establish optimum conditions for high-temperature dehydration, by which protein solubility is depressed without an excessive depression in protein digestibility. The reverse situation may exist with silage, in which the nitrogenous constituents may be in an even simpler and more soluble form than in the original herbage (Synge, 1952), so that a rapid increase in rumen ammonia level may follow the ingestion of silage. Little work has been reported on this, although McCarrick (1966) has reported that a higher proportion of the body energy gains of silage-fed animals than of hay-fed animals was in the form of body fat, which might indicate a deficiency of available amino acids from the silage diet. D. THEUSE
OF
NONPROTEIN NITROGENIN RUMINANT DIETS
1 . Sources of Nitrogen for Rumen Digestion Under extensive or range-grazing conditions, much of the herbage on offer contains levels of crude protein (N x 6.25) that are inadequate to support economic levels of animal production, and that in some cases may be inadequate for the needs of the rumen microbial population and its animal host even at the maintenance level of feeding. In some areas it is possible to increase the nitrogen level of the diet by sowing legumes within the grazing area or by fertilizing with nitrogen; an alternative is to supplement the animal’s diet either with a protein concentrate o r with nonprotein nitrogen. The possibility of using nonprotein nitrogen for this purpose, rather than preformed protein, arises from the mechanism of protein metabolism within the rumen, in which feed proteins are deaminated and the ammonia produced is assimilated into microbial protein. Simple chemical supplements, such as urea, which are degraded to ammonia within the rumen, might thus be expected to be used almost as efficiently by the
52
W. F. RAYMOND
ruminant as the normal feed proteins. Some success has been achieved in this direction, but despite a considerable research effort during the last thirty years some aspects of the use of nonprotein nitrogen supplements remain obscure (see reviews by M. H. Briggs, 1967: Chalupa, 1968). A more objective approach to the subject becomes increasingly possible, and recent information on nitrogen metabolism within the rumen indicates two distinct areas of interest, with forages, respectively, of very low and of medium protein contents.
2 . Low Protein Forages As discussed in Sections IV, C, 3 and V, E, the digestibility and the level of voluntary intake of forage both may be very low because the forage does not contain enough nitrogen compounds to sustain active bacterial digestion in the rumen. With forages of less than 4 percent crude protein, supplementation with urea (Campling et al., 1962) or other nonprotein nitrogen sources (e.g., biuret; Schaadt et al., 1966) has increased both level of digestibility and voluntary intake. At higher crude protein levels little increase in digestibility has been found: thus no response was found when urea was added to barley straw of 5 to 7 percent crude protein (Kay et af., 1968) or to oat straw of 4.4percent crude protein (Faichney, 1968b). The practical result is that urea supplementation will improve lowprotein pasture from a nutritive value at which animals lose weight to one where they maintain weight; but it will seldom lead to body weight gain, for even with urea, the level of digestibility and intake of such feeds is still too low to sustain production. This may be accentuated by deficiencies of other components in the diet, including minerals; thus it is possible that sulfur deficiency in the diet may limit microbial action even when urea is added, although I. W. McDonald (1 968) has questioned whether inorganic sulfur can be used by rumen organisms. 3 . Medium-Protein Forages
With many types of low-protein forage the response of animals to urea supplementation is limited by the low inherent digestibility and intake of these forages. But many other forages, despite a low protein content, may be of high digestibility and intake characteristics (e.g., forage maize). In other cases the overall digestibility and intake of a forage-based ration may be increased by supplementation with low-protein cereal grains or starch. Available energy need then no longer be limiting in the diet, and with informed use urea can contribute significantly as a protein supplement to such diets.
T H E NUTRITIVE V A L U E OF FORAGE CROPS
53
The main limitation to the use of urea then appears to lie in the very rapid rate at which it is deaminated in the rumen; unless urea is fed in phase with an appropriate energy source rumen ammonia and blood ammonia levels may rise so rapidly that the animal suffers, and may die, from ammonia toxicity. This problem can be most acute with feeds of low digestibility; with these rumen p H tends to be high, and ammonia is more rapidly absorbed into the blood than at the lower p H associated with the rapid fermentation of most feeds of high digestibility; but urea toxicity can still be a hazard with high-digestibility feeds, and feeding regimes must aim to keep rumen ammonia levels at a low level. Recent research indicates a number of advances in nonprotein nitrogen feeding. Thus J. R. Campbell et al. ( 1963) found lower rumen ammonia levels and more efficient nitrogen utilization when a grain ration with 3.3 percent urea was fed six times rather than twice daily. It has been suggested that urea toxicity may be avoided by reducing urease activity within the rumen by feeding barbituric acid (Clifford and Tillman, 1966) or by the use of antibiotics (Chalupa, 1968). Other workers have suggested the replacement of urea by biuret, which is less rapidly deaminated within the rumen, but results with this supplement have been conflicting: thus Schaadt et al. ( 1 966) found similar forage cellulose digestibility with urea or biuret, but Oltjen ef al. ( 1 968) found lower fiber digestibility with biuret than with urea even after an adaptation period of 32 days. Perez et al. ( 1967) have reported that a urea-phosphate combination is less toxic than urea alone, and can supply up to 40 percent of the nitrogen in the total ration. Of particular interest is the demonstration by Virtanen ( 1966) and Oltjen and Bond (1967) that the ruminant can adapt to gradually increasing levels of urea feeding, which makes possible a synthetic diet for dairy cows in which all the nitrogen is derived from urea. It has also recently been shown that urea is particularly efficiently used in ruminant rations when it is incorporated in a pellet with dehydrated lucerne (Karr et al., 1965). This has led to the development of feed supplements (e.g., Conrad and Hibbs, 1966), in which lucerne and urea are combined to give high crude protein CN X 6.25) levels; these have been used to replace soybean meal completely in dairy rations, without the toxic symptoms that might have been expected at the high levels of urea fed. The exact mechanism is uncertain; it has been attributed to “unidentified growth factors,” which could include minerals (Karr et al., 1965), or branch-chain fatty acids, which have been found to increase efficiency of utilization of urea nitrogen (Cline et al., 1966). And in relation to the possible effect of heat dehydration on the rate and site of digestion of the protein fraction in forages (Section IX, B), it is interesting to speculate that urea and dehydrated lucerne may act as
54
W. F. RAYMOND
complementary sources of nitrogen, the urea being deaminated rapidly and the lucerne slowly, so giving a steady provision of ammonia for microbial growth.
E. THEMINERALNUTRIENTS IN FORAGES The requirements of different classes of ruminant livestock for mineral nutrients, and the ability of forages to provide these requirements, cannot be fully covered in the present review; but a number of recent and significant developments are noted. Requirements are best stated as the total intake of a particular mineral needed by each class of livestock at different levels of production (Agricultural Research Council, 1965). Both the quantity of forage eaten (Section V) and the concentrations of minerals in this forage are important, but the relation of these to total requirements depends also on the availability to the animal’s metabolism of these minerals, and of interactions between them (Underwood, 1962, 1966). The first concern of the agronomist must be to establish the factors that determine the total intake of different mineral elements (forage dry matter X percent mineral content in the dry matter). Only when total intake is above the theoretical requirement do availability and interactions become of major concern. 1 . The Concentration of Mineral Elements in Forages Very many analyses of the mineral composition of forages, reported in the literature, have been summarized by Whitehead ( 1966). Such a summary is of value in indicating broad differences in composition between forage species: but it also indicates a wide range of contents of particular minerals within each forage species, which cannot always be related logically to stage of physiological maturity, in the same way as, for instance digestibility, protein, and fiber contents. Thus the copper content of perennial ryegrass can vary from 2 to 12 p.p.m., depending on soil copper status, soil pH, and fertilizer application. This means that an average figure for copper content may be of limited usefulness in indicating the adequacy of a particular crop of ryegrass as a source of copper, and emphasizes the importance of understanding the effects of these other factors. The mineral contents of temperate forage species grown under the same conditions have been reported by many workers, including Davies et al. ( 1 966) and Fleming and Murphy (1 968), of farm grassland heavily fertilized with nitrogen by de Groot and Keuning ( 1 967), and of tropical forages by Dougall and Bogdan ( 1966). From these, and from the summary already noted, a number of trends emerge. As a given forage ma-
T H E NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
55
tures, the percentage content of some elements, in particular, P, S, and Cu, tends to decrease. Among species the legumes have higher contents of some minerals than the grasses, particularly of Ca; within the grasses there are some notable differences, as in the consistently lower content of sodium in timothy (Phleum pratense) and meadow fescue (Festuca pratense) than in most other grasses (ap Griffith and Walters, 1966; de Loose and Baert, 1966). Mineral content varies markedly between different parts of the same plant, leaves being higher in Ca, Mg, S, Fe, and Si than stems and older tissues (Davey and Mitchell, 1968). When forages are being grazed this can be of importance because of the selective nature of grazing (Section X). Within these overall patterns, certain features of particular elements have emerged. 2 . Phosphorus 1. W. McDonald (1968) has pointed out that while phosphorus deficiency has been clearly established with cattle feeding on forages of low P content, this has not been shown with sheep. He suggests that this may be because, although the bodies of cattle and sheep contain very similar concentrations of phosphorus, the feed intake of sheep is 1.5 to 2 times that of cattle, per unit of body weight, so that sheep may require only about half the concentration of P in their feed compared with cattle. Under grazing conditions sheep may also be able to select plant fractions of higher P content-a difference of general significance, because of the higher content of most elements in plant leaves, which sheep are better able to select than are cattle.
3 . Sodium, Calcium, and Potassium The particular importance of potassium is that it can be absorbed from the soil in luxury amounts, and this can lead to marked reductions in the contents of the elements Na and Mg in forage plants. Ap Griffith and Walters ( 1966) and de Loose and Baert ( 1 966) have shown large differences in Na content between different species: thus ryegrass commonly contains several times as much Na as timothy, and Poa pratensis and Festuca pratense also have contents well below the concentration of 0. I 3 percent Na suggested as necessary for the high-yielding dairy cow (Kemp, 1964). Yet I. W. McDonald (1968) considers that there is no unequivocal evidence for sodium deficiency in ruminants that is not preceded by other deficiencies. Considerable differences in sodium content have been found between different timothy genotypes (de Loose and Baert, 1966). But there can be no case for breeding timothy varieties of higher
56
W. F. RAYMOND
sodium content; if sodium deficiency does occur it should be remedied by making a salt supplement available, rather than by introducing a marginal objective into a breeding program. With regard to calcium, Langlands et al. (1967) and I. W. McDonald ( 1 968) have suggested that deficiency in intake is seldom likely to occur on forage feeding; where it does occur other deficiencies, e.g., in crude protein or phosphorus intake, are likely to be primary. 4 . Magnesium
This element remains of particular interest because of the widespread occurrence of hypomagnesemic tetany in forage-fed animals in many parts of the world (reviewed by Allcroft and Burns, 1969; Grunes and Stout, 1969). Two forms of the disease have been distinguished. A chronic form is associated with a slight but prolonged deficiency of Mg in the diet, leading to low plasma-Mg levels; however, symptoms seldom occur until the animal is subjected to stress, and magnesium therapy may not then be effective. The acute form is most common when stock have access to rapidly grown fresh forage. This may stimulate higher production, e.g., of milk, but may not provide the Mg needed for this higher production: although body reserves of Mg may be high, this is mainly in bone, and being only slowly available cannot satisfy the suddenly increased demand, so that plasma-Mg falls to a critical level. The resulting tetany thus cannot be obviated by building up body reserves by feeding Mg supplements before the forage is fed, and supplementary feeding must continue throughout the period when animals are a t risk. The currently useful supply of magnesium depends on two main factors, viz. the daily intake of magnesium, and its availability to the animal. Many workers have reported Mg levels in forages (e.g., Davies et al., 1966; Hedin and Duval, 1966; de Groot and Keuning, 1967; Fleming and Murphy, 1968). Within the grasses no consistent differences appear: there is a trend to lower Mg levels in the spring, and a rise later in the season. Legumes may contain more Mg than grasses, and inclusion of clover in a ryegrass sward may improve the magnesium status of grazing stock, particularly in the spring. Nitrogen fertilizer has little effect on Mg levels, but they can be markedly reduced by potassium fertilization. Tetany is most commonly found when the Mg content of forages is below 0.18 percent of the dry matter, but Kemp ( 1 960) has suggested that it is the ratio [K] to ([Ca] [Mg]), expressed in milliequivalents per kilogram, that is important, the risk of tetany increasing when this ratio approaches 2.2. However, the low correlation in practice between such measures of total Mg intake and the incidence of hypomagnesemic tetany
+
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
57
indicates that availability, rather than intake per se, must often be the determining factor. In general the digestibility of magnesium in forages is about 20 percent; any reduction in this already-low digestibility must have a major effect on the quantity available to the animal’s metabolism. Thus Wind et al. ( 1966) have found high levels of higher fatty acids and lipids in young grass, and have suggested that these may form insoluble soaps with both magnesium and calcium. O’Sullivan ( 1968) has suggested that high levels of histamine may precipitate tetany; the histamine content of forage rises during dry cold weather, when tetany is most prevalent. Recently Stout et al. (1967) have shown high levels of trunsaconitic acid in some species growing on rangeland areas where tetany in cattle is prevalent. Grasses contained higher levels than other species, with a maximum content of 6.2 percent being recorded. A possible mode of action indicated is by inhibition of the enzyme aconitase in the tricarboxylic acid cycle, but the relation with serum-Mg level is not clear. However, Kennedy (1968) has reported that a supplement of trunsaconitate, fed to sheep at 7 percent of the feed dry matter intake, had little effect on blood levels of citrate or aconitate, on plasma levels of C a or Mg, or on urinary excretion of Mg. H e suggested that this was to be expected, because the rapid rate of metabolism of this anion within the rumen would preclude significant absorption into the blood. In the author’s view, hypomagnesemic tetany should now be considered a problem mainly of extensive grazing. Under intensive grazing or indoor feeding, the magnesium content of forage can be increased by fertilization with magnesium salts, or supplementary magnesium can be fed. With neither of these is there any evidence of damage resulting from an excessive intake of magnesium, and there can now surely be no excuse for tetany among intensively managed livestock. And with animals under extensive management a practical solution may emerge with the development of a slow-release magnesium bullet (University of Glasgow, 1965). 5 . Cobalt
The occurrence of areas of cobalt-deficient soils, the induced vitamin BI2 deficiency in ruminants eating forage grown on these areas, and methods of treatment by the use of cobalt fertilizers or by dosing livestock with cobalt bullets, have been fully documented (Underwood, 1966). E. D. Andrews (1966) has shown that the cobalt content of legumes is higher than of grasses, but on soils where lambs respond to cobalt dosing the cobalt content of all the forage species present is generally below 0. I p.p.m.
58
W. F. RAYMOND
6 . Copper and Molybdenum These two elements interact in ruminant feeding, a high level of molybdenum leading to effective copper deficiency even on pasture of high copper content, although this can be prevented by feed supplements or injections of copper (Dick, 1954; Underwood, 1966; I. W. McDonald, 1968). However, the more common problem appears to arise either from deficiency or low availability of copper in forage. Minimum copper levels for sheep have been reported to vary between 1 and 8 p.p.m. (Dick, 1954), the highest level being associated with high forage molybdenum content. However, Macpherson and Hemingway ( 1968) found swayback in lambs grazed on limed pasture with a copper content of 8.9 p.p.m., a level only slightly lower than on the control pasture, 9.6 p.p.m., on which no disease occurred. This was not due to high forage molybdenum content, and indicated a reduced absorption or retention of copper, reflected by a marked reduction in blood and liver copper levels. A daily supplement of 10 mg. of copper administered in several forms gave an adequate blood copper level of 1 p.p.m., without risk of toxicity. Alternatively herbage copper levels can be increased by fertilization, a single dressing of 10-20 pounds copper sulfate per acre giving a response for up to eight years (Reith, 1968). Excessive copper intake is also possible, and this could become more common if indiscriminate mineral supplementation follows awareness of a possible deficiency. The immediate response of the animal is to store excess copper in the liver, but under stress conditions this can become metabolized and cause toxicity, as hemolytic jaundice (I. W. McDonald, 1968); certain forages also contain hepatoxins which damage liver cells, and can lead to accumulation of copper (Bull and Dick, 1959). As with other mineral elements, analysis of the forage available may give an erroneous measure of the copper content of the forage eaten under grazing conditions, because of the considerable difference in content between forage species and between different parts of the same plant (Gladstones, 1962). Thus Van der Merwe and Perold (1967) reported that no symptoms of copper deficiency were found with cattle grazing grass of very low copper content; this was because the cattle were browsing the leaves of a shrub which contained 4 to 15 times as much copper as the grass. These authors pointed out the dangers that could arise from subdivision of extensive grazing areas if this reduces the opportunity for feed selection. 7 . Lead Mitchell and Reith (1 966) have discussed the possible risks to stock health of the considerable rise in lead content (up to 40 p.p.m.) which
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
59
can occur in forage in autumn and winter, compared with the normal level of about 1 p.p.m. in actively growing grasses and clovers.
8. Iodine Alderman and Jones ( 1 967) have reported on the changes in iodine content of six grass species at different stages of maturity. The average level was lower in ryegrass and fescues (0.22 p.p.m.) than in cocksfoot and timothy (0.32 p.p.m.); iodine levels fell with increasing maturity of the crop, and returned to early spring levels only in the autumn; content in all species was reduced by nitrogen fertilization. In very few instances did the iodine content reach the level recommended for pregnant or lactating animals. Butler and Glenday ( 1 962) showed that the iodine content of a forage species is strongly inherited, and this could make selection for higher iodine content possible. The practical solution, however, seems to make available an iodized salt lick, with which the danger of toxicity is remote. 9. Sulfur
The animal’s requirement for sulfur is mainly in the form of the sulfur amino acids cystine and methionine; thus the primary impact of any deficiency of S will be on the rumen microorganisms, which make these amino acids available to the host animal by synthesis from a wide range of nitrogenous compounds in the feed. Moir and Bray ( 1 967) showed that rumen bacteria have a relatively uniform content of sulfur amino acids, with a S:N ratio of 1:5, which is similar to that in the true protein in leaves. Barrow and Lambourne ( 1 962) found a ratio close to 1 :13 (based on total forage N content) in forages ranging from 0.05 to 0.58 percent sulfur in the dry matter. They emphasized, however, that there might be an effective deficiency of sulfur in feeds of low sulfur content, because the ruminant is able to recycle nitrogen as urea via the saliva, but this barely occurs with sulfur. This could account for the poor use of urea when fed with forages of low sulfur content, as noted by I. W. McDonald (1968). Sulfur deficiency in ruminants appears rare, but must be kept in mind with the increasing trend toward the use of chemical fertilizers that contain no sulfur. 10. Selenium
Selenium in forage has assumed importance because of the association in several countries of low forage selenium levels with white-muscle disease in young stock (a detailed review by Rosenfeld and Beath, 1964). Hamilton and Beath (1964) suggest that a level of 0.1 to 0.3 p.p.m. Se should give protection. Only small differences have been found in the Se
60
W. F. RAYMOND
contents of different forages growing on deficient soils (Hamilton and Beath, 1964), but on soils of high Se content, or with Se fertilization, 10-fold differences between species have been found (Ehlig et al., 1968), lucerne having a relatively high content compared with the grasses. Selenium content tends to be lower in rapidly growing grass, and to be reduced by nitrogen fertilization or irrigation, under which a marginal situation may become critically deficient (Hamilton and Beath, 1964). Correction of selenium deficiency can be by pasture topdressing (Allaway and Hodgson, 1964) or by drenching the stock, but Paulson et al. ( 1 968) suggested that use of a selenium-fortified salt lick may be the safest method. However, care is needed in all cases to avoid building up toxic levels of selenium in the animal carcass, and the possibility must be considered of a buildup in pasture selenium content as a result of absorption from the excreta of grazing stock (Peterson and Spedding, 1963). I. W. McDonald ( 1 968) has pointed out that white-muscle disease may not be directly attributable to selenium deficiency, as no specific role has been defined for this element in ruminant metabolism; thus it might operate by counteracting some other toxic component in the feed. There is clearly an association with the vitamin E status of the young animal, as dosing with this vitamin can prevent the disease; but administration of the vitamin to the ewe will not prevent the disease in the lamb, indicating that selenium, but not vitamin E, is transferred from the ewe to the lamb (Paulson et al., 1968). However, whatever the mechanism of the disease it is clearly associated with selenium. Feeds on which young stock have developed white-muscle disease have always contained less than 0.1 p.p.m. of selenium, although not all feeds with this low level cause the disease (Allaway and Hodgson, 1964). 11. Silica
Sheep and cattle in some areas in North America and Australia may suffer severely from the deposition of siliceous uroliths in the urinary tract. The etiology of urolithiasis in sheep and cattle has been recently reviewed by L. H. P. Jones and Handreck (1967). The calculi in both sheep and sattle have been shown to consist largely of amorphous silica. Despite a better understanding of the formation of these calculi, effective prophylactic measures under rangeland conditions are still needed. Baker et al. ( 196 1) have suggested that the solid silica of plants may be an agent of wear in sheeps’ teeth, because it is harder than the dental tissues. In addition soil quartz may be ingested in such quantities as to be equally important as a cause of wear in teeth (Healy and Ludwig, 1965).
T H E NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
61
F. PHARMACOLOGICALLY ACTIVECOMPONENTS I N FORAGE The practical use of a forage species, otherwise nutritionally adequate in terms of digestibility, protein, and minerals may be restricted because it contains also a pharmacologically active component. The occurrence of such toxic forage plants is widespread (reviewed by E. G. C. Clarke and Clarke, 1967), and the surprising feature is perhaps that toxic symptoms in ruminant livestock are not more common. I. W. McDonald ( 1968) has suggested three possible reasons for this; many toxic plants are distasteful to livestock; animals reared in a given environment seem to develop a capacity to avoid toxic plants; and where toxic plants comprise only part of a mixed community, the quantity eaten may represent only a minor fraction of the total forage intake. He noted, however, that main emphasis has usually been placed on obvious symptoms of toxicity, and less on subclinical effects that may still reduce productivity or reproductivity efficiency. Most serious is the limitation placed on the use that can be made of agronomically and nutritionally desirable forage species because they may at times contain toxic components. I . Estrogenic Compounds Many forage species, in particular the legumes, contain compounds that exhibit estrogenic activity in ruminants. This was first observed in Australia, where the breeding efficiency of ewes grazing subterranean clover ( T . subterraneum) was found to be impaired. This had most serious implications because of the great potential this species offered for improving forage production in the subcontinent, and a major research effort has been directed to the problem (reviewed by Moule er al., 1963; Bickoff, 1968). Biochemical studies isolated a number of isoflavone compounds, including formononetin, genistein, and biochanin A, which have estrogenic activity when injected into mice, of which the change in uterine weight is used as a bioassay. However, potency, assessed by this method, sometimes showed little correlation with observed responses in sheep, and Moule et al. ( 1963) concluded that it was advisable to use relevant animals. In many cases bioassay has been replaced by chemical assay, but these methods also do not always appear to correlate closely with animal response. Although Beck ( I 964) considered that chemical assay could give a reasonable estimate of estrogenic activity, Lindner ( 1 967) found that it could not be closely correlated with reproductive disturbance in ruminants. This is partly because of the different activity of the different isoflavones, and as Bickoff (1968) has emphasized, interactions are also possible, and the presence of estrogen inhibitors must also be con-
62
W. F. RAYMOND
sidered. However, with these limitations, chemical methods have been of value, particularly in screening large numbers of forage samples, which would not be practicable in vivo. Thus Beck (1964) and Francis and Millington (1 965) showed that the leaves of subterranean clover contain much more isotlavones than the petioles -a feature of practical importance under conditions where sheep may graze a higher proportion of leaves than petioles. Rossiter and Beck (1966) showed isoflavone content to increase with increasing environmental temperature, and under conditions of soil phosphate deficiency. Morley and Francis (1968) reported the isoflavone contents of 151 lines of subterranean clover. Differences between the same line grown at different centers were small. Differences between varieties within a subspecies were large enough to indicate the possibility of breeding for low levels of particular isoflavones, although evidence of a negative correlation between the contents of genistein and biochanin A might present problems in selection. Reduced breeding efficiency in sheep has also been found with red clover ( T . prutense; Barrett et al., 1965) and with lucerne (Coop and Clark, 1960). Assays for isoflavone content were made on both legumes, but it was subsequently found that lucerne also contains a compound, coumestrol, which is 15 to 100 times more potent than the most active isoflavone, formononetin (see Bickoff, 1968). Hanson ( 1965) showed considerable differences in coumestrol content among lucerne varieties, and Loper (1968) reported that fungal and aphid attack could considerably increase the coumestrol content of lucerne; aphid-resistant varieties, such as MOAPA, thus had a lower content than a susceptible variety, VERNAL. Newton and Betts ( 1 968) have recently shown considerable estrogenic activity in legumes grown in the United Kingdom, using as bioassay techniques both the effect on reproductive efficiency in ewes and the increase in teat length of wether sheep. High levels of activity were found in S.123 red clover, lower levels in lucerne and white clover, and no activity in sainfoin. While most experimental evidence has been that the effects from pasture estrogens are undesirable, at one stage it was considered that the stimulation of milk production in ruminants grazing spring pasture might be due to estrogens (Pope, 1954). However no correlation or causation could in fact be established (Pope et al., 1959). More recently it has been suggested that pasture estrogens may stimulate growth and feed conversion efficiency in growing and fattening stock, by mechanisms similar to those from dosing or implantation with stilbestrol or hexestrol. Thus Oldfield et al. ( 1966) considered that the coumestrol content of lucerne may benefit the growth and carcass quality of lambs. However, in gen-
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
63
era1 it is likely that estrogens in pasture are undesirable, and Bickoff ( 1 968) has concluded that even low levels may be unacceptable because their effects, although unspectacular, may impair overall economic efficiency. 2 . Phalaris Alkaloids A chronic condition, phalaris staggers, may affect sheep grazing P . tuberosa. This can sometimes be prevented by regular cobalt dosing, but R. M. Moore and Hutchings ( 1 967) showed that this was not associated with vitamin BI2 status, as is the case with straight cobalt deficiency. An acute syndrome (Gallagher et al., 19661, however, is not cured by cobalt therapy. Biochemical fractionation of extracts from toxic forage have isolated a number of alkaloids, derivatives of dimethyl tryptamine, which have produced symptoms of acute phalaris staggers when administered to sheep (Gallagher et al., 1966). Studies using this chemical assay have shown that factors leading to nitrate accumulation in Phalaris also produce high alkaloid levels (R. M. Moore and Hutchings, 1967): of particular importance, 20-fold differences in alkaloid content have been found between different lines of Phalaris. Commercial Australian varieties were consistently high, whereas lines from Algeria were all of low alkaloid content, and this indicated the possibility of breeding nontoxic varieties (Oram and Williams, 1967).
3 . Alkaloids in Tall Fescue Cattle grazing tall fescue suffer from a reduction in skin temperature and from gangrene which is sometimes fatal. Yates and Tookey (1965) found, in extracts from tall fescue, an alkaloid, festucine, which is possibly a toxic principle. 4 . Bloat-Producing Compounds
A most serious economic disease of grazing is bloat, in which gas produced by microbial fermentation of feed is trapped within the rumen, and the animal may die from the resulting pressure on the heart. Earlier theories were that this was due to paralysis of the muscles involved in eructation, but it is now accepted that the main cause is the formation of a stable foam within the rumen which traps the fermentation gases ( C . S. W. Reid, 1960). The main foaming agent appears to be plant cytoplasmic protein (Laby and Weenink, 1966), and a specific protein fraction, 18 S protein, has been isolated (McArthur and Miltimore, 1966). Bloat-producing forages, in particular lucerne, were found to contain over 4.5 percent of this protein compared with contents of less than 1
64
W. F. RAYMOND
percent in nontoxic forages. It has become clear that a number of factors can reduce the stability of the foam produced within the rumen, so that not all forages with high levels of 18 S protein will produce bloat. Thus the foam is most stable at a pH of 5.5 to 6.0 (characteristic of the diseased rumen condition in vivo); restriction of the rate at which forage is eaten so as to reduce the extent to which rumen pH falls below the resting level, ca. 6.8, is indicated. E. M. Hutton and Coote (1966) and Kendall (1 966) have suggested that a high tannin content may prevent bloating with potentially toxic forages by forming a nonfoaming complex with the active protein. Thus crownvetch (Cornilla varia L.), containing 10 percent tannin, and birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus L.1 do not cause bloat (Kendall, 1966); of the legumes introduced into Australia Desmodium may contain over 9 percent of tannin (E. M. Hutton and Coote, 1966). The most effective treatment is to dose the animal or to spray the pasture with antifoaming agents, such as peanut oil (Johns, 1959). R. T. J . Clarke ( 1 965) has suggested that rumen protozoa may produce foam-stabilizing secretions and that antiprotozoal drugs may reduce bloat. McArthur and Miltimore ( 1 966) consider that the best solution may be to prevent the risk of bloat by agronomic measures; by growing potentially toxic legumes in combination with nontoxic varieties; and by studying the effect of environment, so as to manipulate environmental factors to minimize the 18 S content of legumes.
5 . The Nitrate Content of Forages M. J. Wright and Davison (1964) have reviewed in detail the factors determining toxicity arising from high nitrate content in forages: this anion is reduced to nitrite within the rumen, and when absorbed this can lead to the toxic condition of methemoglobinemia in which ferrous iron is oxidized to ferric, so that the blood cannot carry oxygen to the tissues. However, no specific level of nitrate intake can be stated as toxic; a drench of nitrate, or very rapid forage intake, can lead to toxicity at a level of nitrate intake that would be safe under normal feeding and nitrate is less toxic if the ration also contains readily digested feeds, such as carbohydrates, which can reduce the nitrite before it is absorbed. This suggests that nitrate poisoning may be particularly associated with a high content of nitrate in a forage of low digestibility. If symptoms do appear, and they cannot be reproduced by feeding nitrate, then some other causal agent must be sought; but the effect of sublethal doses of nitrate is not well understood (M. J . Wright and Davison, 1964). However, high nitrate contents should clearly be avoided; even if they do not
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
65
always indicate a forage toxic to animals, they do indicate a forage that has made inefficient use of this nutrient, which it has absorbed from the soil but has not metabolized. 6 . Other Problems
Sweet clover (Melilotus alba) contains a coumarin which can cause hemorrhages in sheep. Linton et al. ( 1964) showed considerable protection against this disease when a low-coumarin variety, CUMINO, was compared with a toxic variety, ARCTIC. A serious photosensitization disease, facial eczema, has been suffered by sheep grazing autumn pasture in New Zealand. Detailed research showed that this is due to a toxin produced by a fungus, Pithomyces chartarum, which proliferates on the senescent and dead litter within these swards (reviewed by Brook, 1963). This disease has not been reported elsewhere; however, the possibility of similar, but subclinical, infections in other environments cannot be ignored. A less serious photosensitization, due possibly to an alkaloid, perloline, has also been reported with perennial ryegrass (Bennett, 1963). Recent research has begun to clarify a most unusual toxicity, enteque seco, found in restricted areas in Argentina; cattle suffer calcification of the blood vessels due to high blood levels of calcium and phosphate (Worker and Carrillo, 1967). Observation of the areas of incidence implicated an erect plant, Solanum mufacoxylon.Although this appears to be unpalatable to stock, as the plants senesce the leaves fall on the pasture plants below and are ingested as the animals graze these plants. A different problem is also indicated in the possibility that chemicals in certain forage plants may be absorbed and secreted in milk, to which they give an off-flavor. These seem to be associated with legumeswhite and red clovers (Honkanen and Moisio, 19631, ladino clover (Woods and Aurand, 1963), and lucerne (Dunham et al., 1968)-but no clear relationships have been shown, although dimethyl sulfide from lucerne appears in milk some 3 hours after feeding. Many livestock men are also convinced that pasture composition can affect the flavor of meat. VII. The Relationship between Forage Quality and Forage Yield
Both experimental and practical evidence shows that as a forage crop grows its yield increases but its nutritive value tends to decrease. Thus the practical exploitation of any crop involves a compromise between yield and nutritive value. This requires, in addition to the information on nutritive value reported in the previous sections, data on yields at dif-
66
W. F. RAYMOND
ferent stages of maturity, as given by Minson et al. (1960, 1964) in association with the digestibility data shown in Fig. 1 . The use of in vitro digestibility techniques has made possible the compilation of yielddigestibility relationships for many different forage materials; these are most usefully reported in the form used by Green ( I 966) and Aldrich and Dent (1967) for grasses and legumes, and by Rogers (1967) for arable forage crops (Fig. 5 ) . From these graphs different forage species and
2
diqestible orqanic matter content
\
75
655500
I
I
I
Ib./ocre YIELD
I
! I
10,000-
8,000-
I
1 0 20
Aprd
i
3 0 10 2 0 3 0 10 2 0 May
June
FIG. 5. The changes in yield and digestibility of the first growth of S.24 ryegrass during first growth in the spring. (From Green, 1966.)
varieties can be compared in terms of their yields at a given level of digestibility. Figure 6 shows the yields per acre of different grass varieties during first spring growth when they all contain 65 percent of digestible organic matter (Green, 1966). This figure illustrates clearly the higher yields of ryegrass varieties than of other grass species harvested at the
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
67
same level of digestibility, and the interval of 23 days between the dates at which the digestibility of the earliest (S.24) and the latest ryegrass variety (VERTAS HARDGRAZING) falls to 65 percent digestible organic matter content. The interpretation of such results is complicated, however, by the fact that the harvest of a perennial forage, unlike that of an arable crop, is also a treatment for the following regrowth. A forage harvested a t an Ib./acre YIELD OF DRY MATTER
I0,OOO
1
eS 321 Q RvP
s 22
6,000
1
Q .
QTetronc
OS 152
20 MAY
oPetro
0523
524
0 5.215
Ib
ORcveille
5.53 5.48
30
A
TOII fescue
A
Cockrfmt
4
I?
JUNE
FIG.6. The date at which the content of digestible organic matter in the dry matter falls to 65 percent during first growth of different grass varieties. (From Green, 1966.)
immature, high digestibility stage will regrow more rapidly than if harvest is delayed until a more mature stage; as a result, the total yield, of the first growth plus regrowth, from early or late harvested forage may differ much less than would be indicated from Fig. 5. In terms of digestible organic matter yield the difference may be even less. Very few data are available on the comparative annual yields from different timesequences of harvesting a forage through a complete growing season, yet such data are essential if harvesting or grazing programs are to be planned on an objective basis.
68
W. F. RAYMOND
VIII. Forage Breeding for Improved Nutritive Value
The first objectives in a forage breeding program must concern agronomic characters -yield, persistence, disease resistance, growth habit in relation to planned method of use-and only when these are achieved does it seem justified to select specifically for improved nutritional features. But such further selection can already be considered within the numerous forage materials of high agronomic quality now available. Until recently the main criteria used in selection for nutritive value have been those accepted for many years, namely crude protein content and leaf stem ratio. Crude protein content assumed less importance with the recognition that it was only casually related to the digestibility and energy content of forages, but the usefulness of leafstem ratio was accepted until the more recent studies (Section IV, B) which demonstrated that, in immature plants, stem may in fact be more digestible than leaf. The importance of digestibility as a measure of energy value, and also as an index of voluntary intake characteristics, and the availability of in vitro techniques for estimating forage digestibility, have emphasized digestibility as a promising selection parameter (Rogers and Whitmore, 1966). Cooper et al. ( 1962) found considerable differences in digestibility between individual plants of S.37 cocksfoot, all the plants being at a young leafy stage. Furthermore, the progeny of crosses between the genotypes of highest digestibility showed a mean value higher than the main population, with a heritability of 0.5. This early study, showing the possibility of objective selection for high digestibility in herbage plants, has been confirmed by other workers. Julen and Lager ( 1966) found that the more digestible plants within a cocksfoot population maintained this higher digestibility at different growth stages, and that both the leaves and the stems of some plants were more digestible than in others. The same authors later reported similar differences in digestibility between plants of other grass species, as well as with several legumes and fodder rape, which might form the basis for a breeding program, and Mowat (1 969) reported similar results from Canada. Knight and Yates (1 968), however, found no consistent digestibility ranking for cocksfoot plants grown in a Mediterranean environment in Australia. They concluded that under these conditions responses to temperature, resistance to rust diseases, and the observed 4-fold differences in yield between genotypes were much more important than possible marginal improvements in digestibility. This concept is most important. For if one genotype is of higher yield than another when both are at the same level of digestibility,
THE NUTRITIVE V A L U E O F FORAGE CROPS
69
then the first genotype is likely to be of higher digestibility when both are harvested at the same yield-and improved yield is in other respects a rewarding objective. Significant genetic variation has been found in other nutritionally important characters of forages, in particular of minerals, including sodium (de Loose and Baert, 1966). This illustrates an important aspect of the responsibility of the nutritionist in advising the plant breeder on nutritional objectives, for selection for improved sodium content may well be irrelevant in comparison with direct sodium supplementation of the animals that are to be fed. This means that the nutritionist must consider most carefully before advising the plant breeder to start a selection program. In particular he must recognize that a breeding program takes many years, so that the nutritional objectives he defines must be relevant to the likely feeding systems of the future, rather than to those presently operating (Raymond, 1968). Within the context of the nutritional developments outlined in other sections, including forage processing, feed combinations, and mineral and urea supplementation, the impact of selection for improved digestibility or for higher contents of soluble carbohydrates or minerals could well be marginal. In particular a more effective use of nonprotein nitrogen supplements would relieve the breeder of the necessity to ensure “feeding standard” levels of crude protein in forages. The most important developments may lie in improving the intake characteristics of forages, and in eliminating toxic components. Selection for improved palatability within Phalaris tuberosa (Section V, B, 2 ) and for reduced levels of estrogens witin subterranean clover and of coumarins in sweet clover (Section V, F) are examples of breeding objectives that are unlikely to be made obsolete by other advances in nutritional science. IX. The Effects of Processing on the Components of Forage Nutritive Value
The previous sections have considered some of the basic nutritional features of forage crops. However, many forage crops are cut and processed before they are fed; it is clear that such processing may at times markedly modify the nutritive features found in the fresh crop, and an understanding of these changes is essential to the development of improved processing techniques. A. DEHYDRATION The effects of dehydration on the digestibility and voluntary intake of
70
W. F. RAYMOND
forages has been considered in Sections IV, C and V, B. Both the digestibility and intake of dehydrated forage have been found to be similar to those of the fresh forage, but the apparent digestibility of the nitrogen fraction is reduced if the temperature of the forage is maintained above 105°C. for a significant period during drying (see, e.g., Ekern et al., 1965). Despite this reduction in nitrogen digestibility, body nitrogen retention from dried forages is not reduced (Ekern et al., 1965) unless heat damage is excessive: possible reasons for this were considered in Section VI, C. In practice the main method of forage dehydration is haymaking. Considerable changes in nutritive value can occur in this process, due not to dehydration per se, but to deficiencies in the techniques used, leading to dry-matter losses in the field which may rise to 25 percent or more under unfavorable conditions. Because of differential loss of leaf the loss of crude protein from the crop may be as high as 40 percent and dry-matter digestibility may be reduced. Shepperson (1960) compared the digestibility of hay made by three methods (slow field making, rapid field making, and barn drying) with the digestibility of the herbage cut. The digestibility of all the hay samples was lower than that of the original crop, the depression in digestibility being directly related to the time the cut crop remained on the field before it was lifted, the amount of mechanical tedding needed before lifting, and the extent of leaching by rain. The hay under the least favorable conditions was 7 units less digestible than the herbage cut. Many other similar experiments (Watson and Nash, 1960, p. 53) have confirmed the importance of rapid field curing if depression of digestibility is to be avoided; but it is certain that most of the hay made today still suffers high losses of both dry matter and nutritive value. As Shepperson ( 1960) indicated, nutrient losses during haymaking can be so great that crop digestibility, based on species and stage of maturity, may give only a very approximate guide to the digestibility of the resulting hay. Further deterioration can occur in storage. Even under optimal conditions there is a slow loss of dry matter; thus Melvin (1963) found a 10 percent loss of weight from ryegrass hay stored for 40 weeks, and Greenhill et al. (1961) showed that storage losses increased with increased moisture content in the hay and at higher temperatures. These losses are mainly in the sucrose, glucose, and fructose fractions in the hay and may lead to some decrease in digestibility. More serious is the depression in digestibility which occurs when hay overheats in storage (Watson and Nash, 1960), and molding can also lead to reduced intake of hay (Demarquilly, 1966a) and may present a toxic hazard to both animals and man (Lacey, 1968).
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
71
B. THEGRINDING A N D PELLETING OF DEHYDRATED FORAGES One of the most important advances in the period under review has been the discovery that grinding and pelleting a dried forage may lead to a considerable increase in its nutritive potential. Earlier studies were mainly practical, but recent research has greatly clarified the mechanisms involved (see reviews by Minson, 1963; Beardsley, 1964; L. A. Moore, 1964). Most workers agree (a) that the voluntary intake of pelleted ground forages is considerably higher than of the corresponding long forage, (b) that under ad libitum conditions the long forage is more digestible, but (c) that there is usually an increase in the net intake of digestible energy on the pelleted forage. The magnitude of these effects differs, however, among forage species and with the stage of maturity of a given forage (Heaney et al., 1963). These results can primarily be attributed to the markedly higher rate of passage through the digestive tract of the small particles in ground forages compared with the larger particles in long or chopped forages. The latter must remain within the rumen until they are broken down by mastication and microbial digestion to a size small enough to pass through the reticulo-omasal orifice (Campling et a/., 1963). As voluntary intake of forage depends largely on rate of passage (Section V), the animal is able to eat more of ground than of chopped forage. However, because the ground forage passes more rapidly through the reticulorumen there is much less time for it to be subjected to microbial digestion, and digestibility, particularly of the fiber fraction, is reduced (Campling et al., 1963). Dehority et al. ( I 962) and Tilley and Terry ( 1963) had shown that the digestibility of forage in vitru is increased by fine grinding (presumably by making the fiber structure more accessible to microbial attack), but in vivo any such effect seems to be outweighed by the reduced time available for digestion. Hinders and Owen ( I 968) have also shown a change in the site of digestion of fiber, only 60 percent of the fiber which is digested from pelleted lucerne being digested within the rumen (the remainder being digested in the hind tract, including the cecum), compared with over 90 percent with lucerne fed long. As a given crop becomes more mature, the increase in intake following grinding is greater, however, than the corresponding decrease in digestibility, so that the effect of grinding on digestible intake increases. The digestibility of legumes is depressed by grinding less than that of grasses; thus Demarquilly and Journet ( 1 967) found an average decrease of 9 units in digestibility for grass compared with 4 units for lucerne, and
72
W. F. RAYMOND
Buchman and Hemken ( 1964) reported little reduction in digestibility when lucerne was ground and pelleted. The difference in response between grasses and legumes is in line with the data in Fig. 3. At a given level of digestibility the “digestible” fraction of lucerne contains much less digestible fiber than does grass, and so might be expected to be less sensitive to reduction in fiber digestibility following grinding. Demarquilly and Journet (1967) also suggested that grinding lucerne led to an increased rate of fermentation within the rumen, in contrast to evidence of a marked depression in rate of cellulose digestion with grass hay (Campling et al., 1963). The stage has now been reached when the terms drying, grinding, and pelleting may be inadequate descriptions of these processes, and more detailed specifications, e.g., of temperature and duration of drying, and of particle size and pellet dimensions, will be needed. Possible effects of different drying conditions have been noted (Sections IV, C, VI, C). Demarquilly and Journet ( I 967) found that very fine grinding through a 1.5-mm. screen depressed grass digestibility more than through a 5-mm. screen, but that there was little increase in intake consequent on the finer grinding, which may thus be disadvantageous. Kamstra and Jahn (1966) found that very high pellet pressure may increase cellulose digestibility. The pelleting process itself may also be important, by making ground herbage (a dusty material) more acceptable to stock: conversely practical experience confirms a marked reduction in intake when pellet density is too hard. Ronning and Dobie ( 1962) have reported detailed studies on the effects of pellet size on voluntary intake, which may be reduced below that of the long forage when unsuitable pellets are made. Pelleting may also have less effect when it is applied to forages of very low protein content. Thus Minson ( 1 967) found an increase in intake of only I4 percent when unfertilized Pangolagrass (3.7 percent crude protein) was pelleted, compared with a 30 percent increase with fertilized grass of 7.2 percent crude protein; intake of the low protein grass may have been limited by the low nitrogen status of the animal (Egan and Moir, 1965) rather than by rate of passage, and so have been relatively insensitive to grinding. It also appears that the metabolizable energy value of ground forages cannot be calculated from Eqs. ( 1 9) and (20), because of the reduction in methane production consequent on the reduced fiber digestion within the digestive tract, compared with long forage: net energy values also cannot be calculated because of the lower heat increment with milled than with long forages. As a result Blaxter and Graham (1956) found very similar net energy values for chopped dried grass and finely ground
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
73
grass, even though the energy digestibility of the latter was 1 1 . 1 units lower. Recently Graham ( 1967) has reported that the net energy value of pelleted rations can be further improved if they are fed at frequent intervals rather than once or twice per day. Using a comparative slaughter technique, Paladines et al. ( 1964) found very similar levels of digestibility when equal intakes of chopped o r pelleted hay were fed to lambs, but lower body energy gains by the lambs on the chopped hay. This they accounted for in terms of higher heat increment (wastage) on the chopped hay. Under ad libitum feeding conditions they attributed 78 percent of the higher energy gains on the pelleted hay as resulting from increased intake and 2 2 percent resulting from increased efficiency of utilization of metabolizable energy; the possible role of decreased methane production (found by Blaxter and Graham, 19S6) could not be assessed with the experimental technique used. Numerous experiments (reviewed as above) have shown the effects of processing dried forages on animal production, and many of these have related the results to measured intake and digestibility data. These results are often difficult to interpret because of the different significance of digestibility for long and ground forages. They are also complicated when concentrates are fed with the forage, and particularly when concentrates and forage are pelleted together. Thus the intake of pellets containing ground forage and concentrates may be less than that of the long forage and concentrates fed separately (McCroskey et al., 196 1 ) . There is often a marked effect of grinding and pelleting on rumen volatile fatty acids, and many experiments have shown higher propionate: acetate proportions in the rumen liquor of animals fed on pelleted compared with long feeds. Earlier experiments had indicated that this would only occur with mixed forage-concentrate feeds, but P. L. Wright et al. ( 1963) showed a marked shift from acetate to propionate production when hay was ground, and Demarquilly and Journet (1967) have found a similar but smaller effect with dried lucerne. As with other ruminant feeds, the higher nutritive value of pelleted feeds has sometimes been attributed to this higher proportion of propionic acid in the rumen acids, but it appears likely that the lower methane production and the lower heat increment with ground feeds may be more important factors than the differences in rumen acids. An important exception occurs with milk production, where there is clear evidence of a depression in the butter fat content of milk associated with the decreased acetate production when ground forage is fed. G. D. Thomas et al. ( 1 968) found a depression in milk fat from 4.6 to 3.9 percent when coarsely ground hay in a mixed ration was replaced by finely ground hay; at the same time there
74
W. F. RAYMOND
was a decrease from 68.3 to 59.2 percent in the molar proportion of acetate in the rumen acids. Another quite different effect from diets of ground forages is the disease of rumen parakeratosis, which is characterized by hardening of the small papillae on the rumen wall, and which leads to reduced nutrient absorption and decreased animal production. The problem is most acute with finely ground feeds, but is reduced when small amounts of long roughages are fed (Garrett et al., 1961). Processing forages by grinding and pelleting clearly offers exciting possibilities for improving levels of ruminant production. Much more detailed work is needed, however, if such processing is to become an integral part of a planned program of crop production and animal feeding, rather than a somewhat empirical operation, as at present. Its implications may then extend beyond purely nutritional advantages, with drying and pelleting providing efficient conservation of forage crops in a form suited for mechanized handling and feeding (Raymond, 1968).
c. THE ENSILINGOF
FORAGE CROPS
Ensilage can be simply described as the storage of wet crops under anaerobic conditions by preservatives that inhibit microbial or enzymatic changes in the crop. The most common preservatives are acids-either mineral or organic acids added to the crop, or organic acids produced by bacterial fermentation of carbohydrates present in, or added to, the crop. In general, the higher the moisture content and the buffering capacity from organic salts in the forage, the lower is the pH needed to ensure stability (Playne and McDonald, 1966). Crops high in crude protein and moisture content, such as legumes and nitrogen-fertilized grass, are the most difficult to ensile; with these, wilting to reduce moisture content, or the use of additives, is advised, in particular when the ratio of crude protein:soluble carbohydrate in the forage exceeds 2 (Gordon et al., 1964). 1 . The Voluntary lntake of Silage The very considerable literature summarized by Watson and Nash (1960) reveals a remarkable imbalance of work to that date toward studies of the chemistry and microbiology of the ensiling process compared with studies of the effect of ensilage on the nutritive value of the product. Deficiencies in silage as a ruminant feed were often noted in practice, but the first formal definition of the problem appears to have been by Presthegge ( 1 959) and L. A. Moore et al. ( 1 960), who showed that the voluntary intake of silage was less than that of hay. This has
T H E NUTRITIVE V A L U E OF FORAGE CROPS
75
been confirmed by many other workers, and Harris and Raymond ( 1963) have also shown that the intake of silage is generally lower than that of the fresh crop. In all these experiments products from the same crop were compared: most previous comparisons of hay and silage had been confounded by silage being made at the “silage stage of growth” and hay at the “hay stage,” that is from a more mature and less digestible crop. Presthegge (1959) and L. A. Moore et al. (1960) also showed that the intake of silage was increased if the crop was wilted before ensiling. These results appeared just at the time that the significance of voluntary intake was becoming widely recognized, and as a result particular emphasis came to be placed on the importance of wilting crops before ensiling so as to ensure high intake levels. As noted above, wilting may be advantageous in ensuring an efficient ensilage process, and is essential if silage is to be made in tower silos. But many crops, such as forage maize and ryegrass, contain sufficient available carbohydrate to give stable, low pH, silage with minimal wilting. Chemical additives can also be used with unwilted crops. In these cases wilting, which makes the silage system more weather-sensitive, appears unnecessary as an essential part of the ensilage process, but might appear advantageous because it leads to an increase in silage intake. Because of the practical problems in wilting, recent research on the causes of low intake of silage has thus aimed to develop alternative methods of increasing intake which will obviate the need for wilting. As with forage intake, it is clear that there is no single factor causing the intake of unwilted silage to be lower than that of the equivalent fresh or dried forage. It is not due to the high moisture content per se in the silage, for addition of water to hay or wilted forage does not decrease voluntary intake (J. W. Thomas et al., 1961). Campling (1964) has suggested that silage within the rumen forms a fibrous dough from which “digested” feed particles can pass only with difficulty to the hind tract, so that rate of passage, and as a result level of feed intake, is restricted. Most workers, however, have considered that during the ensilage process chemical compounds are produced which limit intake. In the case of poorly fermented silages with high contents of butyric acid and amines, this could be a direct effect of unpalatability, but Neumark ( I 962) suggested that protein breakdown products of specific pharmacological activity might also be present in such silages. Neumark’s original suggestion that the active compound might be histamine was not confirmed by P. McDonald et af. (1963), who found no decrease in voluntary intake when histamine was added to silage. More recently, however, Neumark and Tadmor ( 1968) have indicated that histamine is active only when
76
W. F. RAYMOND
acetic or formic acid is also present, and that these compounds may act within the abomasum rather than within the rumen itself. More serious is the problem of low intake with the low pH silage which the efficient preservation process aims to make, and in which there is minimal degradation of the protein fraction. There is now some evidence that this is at least partly due to the high content of free organic acids in such silage (Harris et al., 1966; McCullough, 1966). It is recognized that some chemical additives, such as mineral acids or ammonium bisulfate may reduce silage intake (Watson and Nash, 1960, p. 641; McCarrick et al., 1965), but this has been attributed to the ruminant animal's inability to metabolize inorganic anions, in contrast to the organic acid anions, which comprise its main energy metabolite. However, it has been found that a number of silage constituents, including lactic, acetic, and propionic acids and longer-chain fatty acids, may lead to reduced feed intakes when they are added to silage before feeding, or infused directly into the rumen (J. W. Thomas et al., 1961; Rook et al., 1963; Ulyatt, 1965). Thus McLeod, Wilkins, and Wilson ( 1968, unpublished) have shown a linear depression of silage intake by lambs as the pH of silage was progressively lowered by the addition of lactic acid (Table 11). Lambs were used because they appear to be most sensitive to the factors in silage that depress intake. In the reverse direction,' McCarrick et al. (1965) and McLeod, Wilkins, and Wilson (1968, unpublished) have found significant increases in voluntary intake by the addition of sodium bicarbonate to silage. In the latter experiments the intake of unwilted silage by lambs and calves was raised by I5 percent when the silage was partially neutralized from pH 4. I to pH 5.3 before feeding. TABLE I I The Voluntary Intake, by Lambs, of Silage Acidified to Different Levels of pH by Addition of Lactic Acid".b Silage Oeginal Acidified
PH
I 2 3
5.4 4.8 4.4 3.8
Intake (DM % LWY 2.4 2.3 2.2 I .9 S.E. of treatment mean, 0.12 ~~~
"FromMcLeod, Wilkins, and Wilson (unpublished). "The original silage, pH 5.4, was prepared by partially neutralizing an acid silage, pH 4.0, with sodium bicarbonate. 'Dry matter as percentage of liveweight.
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
77
The exact mechanism whereby the organic acids in silage may limit the voluntary intake of silage is still uncertain. I t appears unlikely to operate directly within the rumen; while R. G. Warner et al. ( 1966) found a 40 percent reduction in hay intake when rumen pH was reduced to 6.0 by infusions of lactic or citric acids, this depression of hay intake could have been the result of decreased cellulose digestibility at this low pH (Section IV, C, 3) which would be quite uncharacteristic of that of the animal fed on silage, which is generally in the pH range 6.6 to 6.8. It appears that silage is largely neutralized by saliva before it is swallowed. Thus Lambourne ( 1 965, unpublished) used esophageal-fistulated sheep to collect the feed bolus swallowed by the animal, and showed that silage (pH 4.0) was partially neutralized (ca. pH 5.8) before it was swallowed. Unwilted silage (pH 4.0, 20 percent dry matter) can contain 20 times as much H+ ion per unit of feed dry matter as unwilted silage (pH 5.0, 40 percent dry matter); thus it may be postulated that the intake of unwilted silage is lower than that of wilted because of the much greater quantity of acid to be neutralized by saliva during the process of ingestion. Orth and von Kaufmann ( 1966) have also suggested that saliva secretion may be depressed by the high acid content and lack of physical structure in high-moisture silage. There is as yet no firm evidence that silage intake is limited via restriction of salivation. But if the apparent effect of high silage acidity in depressing voluntary intake is further confirmed it may indicate a possible contradiction between high intake and the requirement for high acidity in the ensilage process. The comparison of the voluntary intakes of hay, wilted silage, and unwilted silage is an important and legitimate research study. But the results of these studies, which have compared hay or silage when each was fed as a sole feed, have perhaps been extrapolated too widely in advice on practical feeding systems, in which hay or silage are most unlikely to comprise the sole feed of productive livestock. The relevant question then is how much hay or silage is eaten when both are fed in combination with the other ration components. Recent information suggests that the superiority, in intake terms, of hay o r wilted silage compared with unwilted silage, when each is fed alone, may largely disappear when they are fed in mixed rations. Thus Osbourn (1967) found that the intake of hay by lambs was 35 percent higher than that of unwilted silage (pH 4.4, 2 3 percent dry matter) made from the same crop. As increasing amounts of rolled barley were fed, the hay intake decreased by 0.68 g. per gram of barley fed, but the silage intake decreased by only 0.28 g.; when barley comprised 40 percent of the total dry matter intake, there was no difference between the hay and silage intakes (Fig. 7). Campling and Murdoch
78
W. F. RAYMOND
(1966) also found that the intake of silage by dairy cows was depressed less than the intake of hay when concentrates were fed, and S. M. Brown ( 1 960) found that the intake of unwilted silage by cows was depressed FORAGE INTAKE q. D. M{ kq.Wo'7J/24hr.
"1
---
HAY y = - O . b 4 ~ + 5 2 . 9 0 SILAGE y = - 0 . 2 6 ~ + 3 8 . 6 0
20
1 0 20 INTAKE OF BARLEY q. D.M./ kq.Wo.7y24 hr.
30
40
FIG.7. The voluntary intake, by lambs, of hay and silage made from the same crop of ryegrass and fed with increasing levels of rolled barley. D.M. = dry matter. (Based on Osbourn, 1967.)
less than that of wilted when both were supplemented by concentrates. Of particular interest are recent experiments in which supplements of pelleted dehydrated forages have been fed with silage (Wilkins and Osbourn, unpublished). S.24 ryegrass was conserved either as silage (pH 4.3, 20 percent dry matter) or as pellets after dehydration and grinding. The dry matter intakes of the silage and pellets when fed as sole feed to sheep were 15.3 g./kg. LW and 26 g./kg. LW, respectively. Increasing amounts of pellets fed with the silage resulted in no decrease in the amount of silage dry matter eaten until pellets comprised 40 percent of the total ration: at this point the intake of silage plus pellets was similar to that of the pellets fed alone, and the intake of digestible dry matter was in fact higher because of the lower digestibility of the pellets than of the silage. The nutritional and practical implications of this observation could
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
79
be of considerable importance, for instance, in the use of dehydrated lucerne (high crude protein and minerals) as a supplement to low protein silage made from ryegrass or wholecrop cereals (Raymond, 1968). A further interesting development has been the addition of urea to the crop before ensiling, with the aim of increasing the crude protein content of silages made from low protein crops, in particular corn silage (reviewed by M. H. Briggs, 1967; Essig, 1968). An addition of 0.5 to 1.0 percent urea appears to increase dry matter loss slightly, and markedly to increase the free ammonia content in the silage; a perhaps unexpected observation is that simultaneous addition of 0.5 percent ground limestone improved silage fermentation. Essig ( 1968) reported a 5 percent increase in gains when treated corn silage was fed to cattle. In general it seems likely that, in mixed rations, the intakes of wilted and well-preserved unwilted silage may not differ greatly (S. M. Brown, 1960). This could mean that a decision to wilt a crop before it is ensiled should be made on the basis that wilting is needed to ensure successful ensilage, rather than with the aim of increasing voluntary intake. 2 . The Digestibility of Silage While most attention has been paid to the intake characteristics of silage, the digestibility of silage is also an important determinant of its nutritive value. Earlier studies (Watson and Nash, 1960, p. 397) had indicated a rather lower digestibility of silage than of the crop ensiled. In some cases, however, this may have been because the intake of silage was based on dry matter determinations made at 100°C. As Harris and Raymond ( 1963) have shown, samples of silage from digestibility experiments may suffer considerable losses of volatile constituents during oven-drying. This leads to an underestimate in the amount eaten and in the measured digestibility (Eq. 2). These authors measured the true dry matter content of silage by toluene distillation and showed almost identical digestibilities for silage and the original crop. Harris ( 1 963) also found that the digestibility of corn silage was very similar to that of the fresh crop, and Johnson and McClure ( 1968) found the digestibility of corn silage cut at increasing stages of maturity to be 65.3 percent, 71.9 percent, and 69.8 percent, in line with the expected changes in crop digestibility. In this experiment, voluntary intake was closely related to silage digestibility (42.9, 58.9, and 54.0 g./kg. LW0.75, respectively), but this has not been found with unwilted grass silages (Harris and Raymond, 1963). Ensilage under poor conditions can lead to depressed digestibility for instance, when there are high losses of soluble constituents in effluent,
80
W. F. RAYMOND
or when overheating and caramelization occur (Watson and Nash, 1960; Wieringa et al., 1961). A small decrease in dry matter digestibility may also occur when forage is wilted before ensiling. Thus Harris et al. (1966) found a mean dry matter digestibility of 63.9 percent for a number of wilted silages (26 to 54 percent dry matter) compared with 66.3 percent for unwilted silages from the same crops (16 to 23 percent dry matter); Schulz and Oslage (1967) found a similar fall in digestibility with some silages, but concluded that this did not necessarily result from wilting. The reason for this lower digestibility is not known, but if it occurs generally it must somewhat reduce the advantage attributed to higher intake with wilted silages. X. The Nutritive Value of Grazed Forage
Grazing, the most common method of using forages, imposes a number of modifying factors on the basic components of nutritive value already discussed. Thus “forage grazed” may differ markedly in composition from “forage on offer,” because animals are able to graze selectively; the amount of forage eaten may depend as much on extrinsic factors such as feed availability and environment as on the intrinsic factors discussed in Section V ; and the nutrient requirements of grazing livestock may differ from those of housed livestock, with which all basic data on requirements have been determined. A. MEASUREMENT OF THE NUTRIENT INTAKE BY GRAZING ANIMALS
Central to any consideration of these factors is the need for information on the nutrient intake by grazing ruminants. Yet despite much research effort in the last twenty years the techniques now available still appear inadequate, and they limit the precision with which grazing studies can be interpreted. Two distinct types of technique have been used, involving, respectively, measurements on the pasture and measurements on the animal. The former, which include “IN - OUT” pasture sampling and “browse unit” estimates, have been fully reviewed by D. Brown ( 1 954) and J. T. Reid (1962). They are not considered further here, except to note that the technique of estimating forage intake as the difference between yield samples before and after grazing appears to be reasonably precise only when applied to “strip” grazing, where the difference between the yield estimates is large and pasture growth during the period of grazing is small.
81
T H E N U T R I T I V E V A L U E O F FORAGE CROPS
The most commonly used techniques are based on a rearrangement of Eq. (2): Intake of forage (1)
= weight
of feces voided (F) X
I00 (100- 7% digestibility of forage eaten (D)
1
(24)
and requires estimates to be made of (F) and (D); from (D) the metabolizable and net energy values of the forage eaten can also be calculated to give estimates of nutrient intake (Eqs. 19 and 20). (See reviews by Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, 196 I , p. 92; 1. W. McDonald, 1962; J. T. Reid, 1962.)
1. The Estimation of Fecal Output by Grazing Animals The most precise method of measuring fecal output is undoubtedly by total collection, using harness and fecal bags. However this method is laborious, is difficult under extensive grazing conditions, and may interfere with animal behavior and production, so that most workers have preferred the indirect estimation of fecal production by the use of indigestible tracers. A known weight of the tracer is fed to each animal daily; from the concentration of tracer in a sample of feces the weight of feces which would contain the total weight of tracer is calculated as the total output of feces. This requires (a) that the tracer is completely recovered in the feces and (b) that the sample of feces analyzed is truly representative. a . The Recovery of Tracers. Many different substances have been examined as fecal tracers, but the most commonly used is still chromic oxide, Cr203,which is cheap and nontoxic. Administration is easy with the use of factory-produced capsules (Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, I96 I , p. 93), as is also the analysis of the oxide in feces (Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, 196 I , p. 152). Unfortunately the fecal recovery of this tracer has so often been found to diverge from the theoretical 100 percent that the assumption of complete recovery, without confirmation under the conditions of the particular experiment, must be questioned. Thus Kane et al. ( 1950) and Raymond and Minson ( 1955) found mean recoveries close to 100 percent, whereas several other workers, including Christian et al. (1965; 92.8 percent) and McGuire et al. (1966; 94.2 percent) have found low recoveries. The reasons for such low recoveries, particularly over the 66-day feeding period studied by Christian et al. (1965). which must have eliminated “end errors,” are still uncertain; they may include regurgitation and rejection of cap-
82
W. F. RAYMOND
sules, an impurity of soluble chromate in the chromic oxide, and differential loss of fine particles of the oxide during milling of the feces sample prior to analysis (see, e.g., P. H . Bailey et al., 1957). But they do indicate that error, in an overestimation of fecal output, can arise unless an independent check on recovery is made within the experiment. Attention has thus been given to other tracers, including techniques based on the use of the rare earth elements, which have been shown to be almost completely indigestible (Bell, 1964). With the use of radioactive materials, only minute amounts of tracer are needed, and physical, rather than chemical methods of fecal analysis can be used; furthermore the rare earths appear to become firmly bound to plant materials and to pass through the digestive tract with the undigested fiber residues (Bell, 1964) in contrast to chromic oxide, which appears to move with the liquid digesta phase (Raymond and Minson, 1955). As a result the diurnal variation of excretion of tracer in the feces seems to be reduced (Section X, A, 1 , b). Radiocerium oxide has been used by Huston and Ellis (1968), but dysprosium appears to have particular advantage (Ellis, 1968) as its concentration in feces can be measured by activation analysis, so avoiding the need to feed radioactive material, with the consequent problem of waste disposal. The fecal recovery of dysprosium was 99.8 percent, and this tracer showed only a small diurnal variation in excretion (Ellis, 1968). Radiocerium also gave high recovery and low variation, and variation among animals was found to be less than with chromic oxide or polyethylene glycol (Huston and Ellis, 1968). Further development of the use of radioactive tracers is awaited with much interest. b. The Pattern of Excretion of lndigestible Tracers. Where the tracer can be thoroughly mixed with all the feed eaten it is fairly uniformly excreted in the feces; but this is not possible with grazing livestock, and here the pattern of dosing of the tracer, which is generally given once or twice daily, is clearly reflected in a markedly nonuniform excretion in the feces. Kane et al. ( I 952) studied this under indoor feeding conditions, and proposed that a representative sample of feces could be obtained by “grab” sampling directly from the animal’s rectum at fixed times each day. Raymond and Minson ( 1 955) showed, however, that even under indoor conditions marked variations in excretion pattern could occur, depending among other factors on the type of feed and the level of feeding. Both of these can affect the rate of passage of digesta through the tract, and so the time between chromic oxide dosing and the peak of excretion in the feces. These authors concluded that “grab” sampling would thus be invalid under grazing conditions, where the excretion pattern would
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
83
depend on the kind and amount of forage grazed, the very parameters the technique is intended to measure. They proposed that feces should be sampled directly from the sward being grazed, and details of sampling methods have been described (Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, I96 1 , p. 94). To permit the feces from different animals to be sampled separately, each grazing animal is dosed daily with a capsule containing polystyrene granules of a particular color, which can readily be identified in the feces lying on the field (Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, I96 I , p. 95). This technique is suitable only for cattle, as sheep are able to chew the granules. Another approach has been to minimize the extent of the diurnal variation in the content of tracer in the feces by feeding it in a form which passes through the tract with the undigested residues. Corbett et a f . ( I 960) developed a kraft paper impregnated with chromic oxide, with which a high proportion of the oxide remains associated with the feed residues, rather than moving with the liquid digesta phase. They showed a marked reduction in diurnal variation of oxide excretion in the feces and, as expected, a change in the times of maximum and minimum excretion, compared with the oxide dosed in capsules. Cowlishaw and Alder (1963) showed a similar improvement in uniformity of excretion with the chromic oxide paper, but concluded that the greater ease of administration of commercially produced capsules justified the effort involved in sampling feces from the sward. The use of the rare earth elements, noted in the previous section, may well be a promising solution to this problem. 2 . The Estimation of the Digestibility of Grazed Forage The earliest applications of Eq. (24) made use of a determination of the digestibility of forage cut from the sward being grazed. Observations showed that this could vary markedly from the forage actually being eaten by the grazing animals. These earlier studies are likely to have underestimated the amount and digestibility of the forage grazed, because this forage tends to be the more digestible part of the forage on offer - as indicated by the generally higher fiber content and lower protein content in forage sampled after grazing than before grazing. However, estimates of the composition (digestibility) of forage grazed, based on samples taken before and after grazing, are subject to considerable error (D. Brown, 1954). Thus attention has been given to methods of estimating the digestibility of grazed forage based on chemical analysis of the feces produced. In the ratio techniques, digestibility is calculated from the relative contents of a naturally occurring “indigesti-
84
W. F. RAYMOND
ble” tracer in samples of “forage grazed” and in feces (summarized by J. T. Reid, 1962). But because of the difficulty of obtaining relevant forage samples, these methods have been superseded by the fecal index techniques (see Raymond et al., 1954). These were developed from observations by Lancaster ( 1949) from which it appeared that the nitrogen content of feces was correlated with the digestibility of the forage eaten; thus the nitrogen content of the feces of grazing livestock should allow an estimate of the digestibility of the forage selectively grazed from a sward. Fecal contents of chromogen (J. T. Reid et al., I952), nitrogen and fiber (Raymond et al., 1954), lignin and methoxyl (Richards et al., 1958), phosphorus (Barrow and Lambourne, 1962), and copper, magnesium, and silica (McManus et al., 1967) have all been shown to relate to forage digestibility and these fecal index markers have been widely used in grazing experiments. In a related technique Owen and lngleton (1963) found that the intake of forage dry matter could be related directly to a dissolved fecal fraction (feces extracted for 18 hours with 0.2 N hydrochloric acid at room temperature) thus:
+
Intake of forage (g.) = 250 17.8 X weight of dissolved fecal fraction excreted (g.) (25) Langlands and Corbett (1964) reported a less precise estimate by this method than by the use of a fecal nitrogen relationship. In all these studies the precision of each technique was assessed in terms of the statistical correlation between forage digestibility and fecal composition, based on indoor feeding experiments with cut forages. The aim was to develop a relationship based on a wide range of forages, so as to be generally applicable, yet with low errors of prediction (Raymond et al., 1954). Arnold and Dudzinski ( 1963) tested several increasingly complex statistical relationships with only a marginal reduction in prediction errors. McManus et al. ( 1 967) found that a multiple fecal index relationship based on fecal contents of nitrogen, copper, and silica gave slightly lower errors than one based only on fecal nitrogen. Hennaux et al. ( 1967) found similar precision of estimation of forage digestibility using eithep chromogen ratio or fecal chromogen techniques. L. E. Davis et al. (1 967), however, found better prediction using fecal nitrogen because of the low recovery of forage chromogen in the feces, particularly with lucerne: fecal nitrogen reflected differences in digestibility between Bromus and lucerne which were not picked up by fecal chromogen, indicating that the latter might not be valid in comparisons between forage species. It is now evident, however, that other, possibly more serious, errors
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
85
may be involved in the practical application of fecal index methods. First, there is the possibility that “application” errors may arise when an indoor-based regression is applied in the field, because of the different levels of forage intake likely in the two situations (Raymond et al., 1956). Indoor experiments with the same forage fed at different levels of intake indicated that fecal nitrogen and chromogen contents may change in a self-compensating way, but that regressions based on fecal contents of fiber, lignin, and methoxyl may introduce error if forage intake in the field differs from that indoors. J. B. Hutton and Jury ( I 964) have also found that the statistical errors of fecal index relationships based on forages fed under ad libitum conditions are greater than under the restricted intake conditions of most of the earlier digestibility experiments ( e g . Raymond et al., 1954). Second, it was found that the assumption in the regression analyses that the errors were randomly distributed was incorrect, and that different populations of feeds showed a biased distribution about the “general” regression line. Thus Greenhalgh and Corbett ( 1960), Minson and Kemp ( 196 1 ), and Lambourne and Reardon ( 1963) showed considerable differences in the relationships between forage digestibility and fecal nitrogen content with the same forage species at different seasons of the year, or at different levels of nitrogen fertilization, and similar differences occur in relation to fecal chromogen content. As a result the feces from animals grazing pasture heavily fertilized with nitrogen contain more nitrogen than feces from less heavily fertilized pasture; this would indicate a higher level of digestibility for the fertilized forage, but this is not found in practice (Minson and Kemp, 196 I). This indicated the need for “restricted” regressions, each based on forage cut from the sward under study, in order to reduce error due to bias. The continuous digestibility experiment, using fresh forage cut daily from the sward, was considered appropriate for this purpose (Greenhalgh and Corbett, 1960; Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, 1961, p. 97), but the need for such associated indoor feeding must limit the situations in which this technique can be applied. More serious, however, is the recent evidence which questions the basic premise of the fecal index technique, that a relationship based on the feeding of cut forage indoors can be used to predict the digestibility of that part of the forage that the grazing animal selects in the jield. This was indicated by the results of Minson and Kemp ( 196 I ) that forages of the same digestibility, but containing different levels of nitrogen, give feces of different nitrogen contents. Lambourne and Reardon ( 1 962) showed that the “stem” and “leaf’ fractions of a sward may produce
86
W. F. RAYMOND
quite different digestibi1ity:fecal nitrogen relationships (Fig. 8), and Pearce et al. (1962) found different relationships for the “top” and “bottom” fractions of a sward, harvested and fed separately in digesti-
& I
2
b I
3 % N in fecal O.M.
4
FIG. 8. Relationship between percent digestibility of forage organic matter and percent nitrogen in fecal organic matter (O.M.), for whole-cut forages and for leaf-rich and stemrich fractions separated from these forages. As fecal nitrogen decreases from 3.6 percent to 2.6 percent, the whole-plant regression indicates a fall in digestibility of herbage grazed from 8 1 percent to 73 percent ( x to y). The actual fall in digestibility, as the type of feed selected changes from leafy to stemmy, would be much less, i.e., from x’ toy’, as indicated by the dashed line. (From Lambourne and Reardon, 1962; Raymond, 1966b.)
bility experiments. The effect of this is illustrated in Fig. 8; use of a regression equation based on whole forage plants will indicate a much greater effect of selective grazing on the digestibility of forage eaten than is in fact the case. Confirmation of this conclusion has been provided by studies with fistulated animals (below). These show that the earlier concept that the digestibility of grazed forage decreases markedly on the successive days of grazing on a paddock is often erroneous. This must mean for instance that the fecal index technique cannot validly be used to study the effects of grazing pressure on forage selection or intake. As Langlands (1 967b) concludes, the appropriate fecal index relationship must be derived from herbage similar to that being selected by each particular group of animals-in which case a less indirect method of estimating forage digestibility must surely be possible. “This must mean that, even in experiments where ‘local’ regressions have been used, incorrect estimates may have been made of the effects of selective graz-
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
87
ing, whilst there must be even greater doubt of the validity of the results of the large number of (grazing) experiments which have used ‘general’ regressions” (Raymond, 1966b).
3 . The U s e of Fistulate Techniques This conclusion has stimulated investigation into other methods of studying the forage intake of grazing animals, and in particular the use of fistulated animals for obtaining samples of the herbage actually being selected, on which botanical and chemical determinations can be made. The establishment of esophageal fistulas in ruminants was first described by Torell ( 1954), and their earlier experimental use was reviewed by Van Dyne and Torell (1 964). The more general application of the technique was advanded by the development of the split-plug closure technique, which reduces the hazards of the initial operation and simplifies the handling of the animals in the field (McManus et al., 1962). The technique was initially used for species-selection studies (see below), but many workers have also used it to estimate the nutritive value of the herbage grazed (e.g., Bedell, 1967; Bredon and Torell, 1967). I t has been important, then, to examine how far the extrusa sample collected through the fistula is fully representative of the feed eaten, and whether the chemical composition of the sample differs from that of the feed. D. L. Bath et al. ( 1956) and Grimes et al. ( 196.5) have shown reasonable agreement between the botanical composition of herbage eaten and that measured on the extrusa sample; but greater differences can occur in chemical composition, due both to the contamination of the sample with saliva before it can be collected and to the preparation of the sample for analysis. Thus Lombard and van Schalkwyk ( 1963) and C. M. Campbell et af. (1968) found higher ash contents in extrusa samples than in the herbage eaten, and Hoehne et al. ( 1967) found higher ash, phosphate, and chloride levels, lower nitrogen and water-soluble carbohydrate contents, but similar contents of crude fiber and lignin. Gonzalez Gonzalez and Lambourne ( 1 967) showed that when a hay-saliva mix was dried, the measured in vitro digestibility of the hay increased by up to 4 percent units, indicating the importance of removing saliva contamination before drying extrusa samples. Hoehne et al. ( 1 967) suggested that this should be by squeezing the sample to remove excess saliva before it is dried; Robards and Wilson (1967) have shown that washing the sample to remove saliva reduced in vitro digestibility by as much as 7 units. Thus the method generally adopted is gentle squeezing of the sample in a muslin bag, but the validity of any procedure used must be checked against forage samples wherever possible.
88
W. F. RAYMOND
A similar problem may arise when forage samples are collected manually via a rumen fistula: this technique has been used by, among others, Ridley et al. ( 1 963) and Tayler and Deriaz (1963), but it is applicable only to cattle because of limitation in the diameter of the cannula with sheep. The observer has to walk alongside the animal to make the collection, whereas with an esophageal fistula the extrusa samples are collected in a bag tied under the animal’s neck. An advantage of sampling from the rumen is that the sample can be related directly to the particular sub-area of pasture being grazed; measurement of the in vitro digestibility of such samples has provided valuable information on the effects of management and grazing pressure on selective grazing, which differs significantly from earlier evidence based on the fecal index technique (Tayler and Deriaz, 1963). The digestibility of the forage eaten by animals grazing immature forage changes relatively little as the sward is grazed down, despite a marked decrease in the nitrogen content in the feces produced. Where uneaten residues remain from a previous grazing, these form a low-digestibility component which dilutes the high digestibility of the new growth. If this residue is in a lower horizon than the new growth, cattle can select forage of high digestibility, but little selection occurs where the old and new growth are intimately mixed within the forage on offer, or where high grazing pressure is imposed so that selection is difficult. There are several limitations in the use of fistulated animals for estimating the digestibility of “forage grazed” and in the prediction of forage intake from Eq. (24). First, there is some uncertainty as to the validity of the digestibility estimate, because of the possible effect of saliva contamination, noted above. Second, in vitro digestibility is a parameter of a forage measured under standard conditions. It is not necessarily the same as the in vivo digestibility of the forage by the particular animals being studied, yet it is this measure of digestibility which is required in Eq. (24). Finally, extrusa samples are collected only at intervals from a proportion of the animals within a flock or herd, and intensive sampling may be necessary to obtain a representative sample. Langlands (1967b) has thus suggested that a “local” fecal index regression should be calculated between the in vitro digestibility of the extrusa samples and the chemical composition (nitrogen and cellulose) of the feces voided by the fistulated animals. He showed different relationships for whole forage fed indoors and for forage selected in the field as would be expected from Fig. 8. The latter relationship should allow corrections for selection on the basis of contents of nitrogen and cellulose in feces from the nonfistulated animals within the herd. A multiple-regression approach to the same problem has been described by Arnold and Dudzinski ( 1967a).
T H E NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
89
An alternative method of using extrusa samples has been described by Cook et al. (1963), the contents of lignin or silica in the extrusa samples, and in the corresponding feces, being measured, and the digestibility of the forage eaten estimated by the ratio method. This method may well have advantage over the direct measurement of in vitro digestibility on the extrusa sample, although it relies on the assumption of 100% indigestibility of the lignin or silica, or the use of an indigestibility coefficient measured in vivo on herbage cut from the sward under test. For precise results it is also necessary for fistulated animals to be adapted to the pasture being examined, before they can be considered to give a representative sample of the forage grazed. Thus Langlands ( 1967a) found that fistulated sheep newly moved onto a ryegrass-clover pasture gave extrusa samples containing 3.8% nitrogen, compared with 3 . 3 3 % nitrogen in extrusa samples from sheep already adapted to the pasture. This indicates that fistulated sheep should not be moved, as tester animals, between different experimental groups. A novel approach, outlined by Wilkins ( 1966), is now being examined. This is based on the premise that there is a maximum extent to which the cellulose in a given forage can be digested (potential digestibility) which is controlled by the cellulose structure and degree of lignification. Cellulose digestibility in vivo will be less than this either because the feed passes through the digestive tract too rapidly for all the cellulose to be digested, or because the rumen medium is deficient in nutrients needed for efficient microbial digestion, or because rumen pH is not optimal for cellulose digestion. As a result the feces still contain cellulose which can be digested by an in vitro incubation. The level of cellulose digestibility in vivo (CD) is related to the potential cellulose digestibility (PCD, determined in a 6-day in vitro incubation) as under: CD =
100 (PCD - FCD) 100 - FCD
where FCD is the potential digestibility of the cellulose in the feces. The intake of cellulose can then be calculated from the quantity of cellulose excreted in the feces: Intake of cellulose =
O0 x fecal production 100-CD
(26)
x % cellulose in feces Analysis of the potential cellulose digestibility in a sample of forage eaten, collected via an esophageal fistula, and of the potential cellulose digestibility in the feces, permits calculation of C D from Eq. ( 2 5 ) . Substitution
90
W. F. RAYMOND
of this value for C D in Eq. (26) gives an estimate of the intake of cellulose. From the percentage content of cellulose in the forage sample the intake of forage dry matter or organic matter can be calculated: Intake offorage= intake of cellulose X
100 100 - content of cellulose in forage
7%
(27)
This may appear to be a complex procedure. But it is based solely on the determination in feed and feces samples of the content and potential digestibility of a chemical entity which can be analyzed simply and with considerable precision (cellulose by the method of Crampton and Maynard, 1938). More important, it appears to compensate for the animal factors (level of intake, effect of feed supplements, parasite damage) which, by affecting the in vivo digestibility of a feed, may invalidate both fecal index techniques and the use of in vitro digestibility determinations on fistula extrusa samples. It does, however, make the assumption that the process of digestion in vivo does not render potentially digestible in the feces cellulose which was not measured as potentially digestible in the feed. Despite this, it appears to offer the most logically valid approach to the estimation of grazing intake that has yet been proposed. B. THE BOTANICAL COMPOSITION
OF
GRAZEDFORAGE
The original use of the esophageal fistula by D. L. Bath et al. (1956) was to measure the botanical composition of grazed forage, and the technique has been widely used for that purpose to replace the earlier swardsampling techniques. This has been more successful with cattle than with sheep, presumably because sheep masticate feed more completely before it is swallowed. Ridley et al. ( 1 963) were able to distinguish smoothstalked meadowgrass from cocksfoot and tall fescue in herbage sampled from the rumen of cattle grazing a mixed sward, whereas Cook et al. (1958) were not able to distinguish between species grazed by sheep from cultivated pasture. However with rangeland forages Cook et al. (1967) were able to study species selection by both cattle and sheep and to show differences in preference between the two classes of stock. The technique has also been used successfully by Van Dyne and Heady (1965) and Leigh and Mulham (1966) on rangeland vegetation and by Hodge and Doyle ( 1967) on cultivated pasture. The latter workers were primarily concerned with selection of either ryegrass or clover from a mixed sward, and this degree of separation was readily achieved in extrusa samples taken from lambs and yearling sheep. In nutritional
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
91
terms selection of different plant fractions may often be as important as interspecies selection, and Tayler and Deriaz ( 1 963) were able to draw important conclusions from samples of leaf, stem, and dead and senescent forage separated from samples collected via a rumen fistula. This separation was essentially quantitative, whereas species separations must normally be accepted as qualitative, because of the considerable part of an extrusa sample which cannot be identified by species-but which could be allocated to a leaf or stem separate. The same restriction to a qualitative botanical separation also applies to the microscopic examination of feces samples for residues of epidermis and cuticle, characteristic of the different species in the plant community being grazed (e.g., Hercus, 1963; Stewart, 1967). C. THENUTRIENTINTAKEOF GRAZING LIVESTOCK It is evident from the consideration of the possible errors involved, discussed in the previous sections, that some reservation must be applied to many published estimates of the nutrient intake by grazing livestock. However, where the experimenter has used a “local,” rather than a “general,” fecal index relationship, the results are likely to be of reasonable validity.
I . The Energy Requirements of Grazing Animals
1. W. McDonald (1968) has emphasized the considerable assumptions implicit in the extrapolation, to field conditions, of energy standards based on controlled calorimetric studies. Most of the experiments in which fecal techniques have been used to estimate grazing intake indicate that the maintenance energy requirement of grazing livestock is considerably higher than of stall-fed animals (Coop and Hill, 1962; Langlands et al., 1963), particularly when the amount of pasture available is restricted (Lambourne and Reardon, 1963). Clapperton (1 964) showed that maintenance requirement is increased by walking activity; Blaxter ( 1 964) calculated that this was unlikely to increase the requirement by more than 18 percent, and that environmental effects, such as wind, rain, and air temperature would also be important. Graham ( I 966) has developed equations for calculating the maintenance requirement of grazing livestock in terms of locomotion, grazing energy, and environmental stress, and Lambourne and Reardon ( 1963) suggested that heat production may be increased by endocrine stimulation initiated by stress when the supply of forage is inadequate.
92
W. F. RAYMOND
2 . Factors Affecting Intake by Grazing Ruminants: “Extrinsic” Factors Under grazing conditions it is important to know to what extent forage intake is controlled by the “intrinsic” factors, discussed in Section V , and how far it depends on “extrinsic” factors associated with management and environment. Under effectively ad libitum grazing conditions, Hodgson ( I 968) found a linear decrease in intake by calves as the dry matter digestibility of the forage on offer fell from 82 percent to 68 percent, but under most practical conditions forage availability appears to be the more important factor (see review by Fontenot and Blaser, 1965). Thus Arnold and Dudzinski (1967b) concluded that the amount of dry matter available per acre accounted for 40 percent of the differences in intake between grazing treatments, and also that leaf length was important. But Greenhalgh et al. (1967) found that the organic matter intake by grazing cows decreased only from 26.4 to 23.9 pounds/day when the quantity of dry matter available was reduced from 45 to 25 pounds a remarkable result indicating virtually 100 percent utilization of the forage with only a marginal reduction in forage intake. In a comparison between ryegrass and cocksfoot, Greenhalgh and Reid ( 1968) found the ryegrass to be consistently more digestible than the cocksfoot (average 4.6 units), but only in grazing periods later in the season was intake on the ryegrass higher. Evidence on other extrinsic factors which may affect forage intake by grazing animals, such as sward structure, weather conditions, or soiling by excreta and fungal infections, is quite inadequate, and these urgently need detailed study. An example is recent work by Marten and Donker ( 1 966) in which forage, heavily fertilized with dung, was not unpalatable when fed to housed stock. This indicates that rejection of such forage by grazing animals may be due to the physical presence of residual dung in proximity to the forage, which MacLusky (1960) found might be affecting S O percent of the pasture at any one time. 3 . The Level of Production by Grazing Animals In most cases the effects of pasture species, management, and environment on the amount and quality of forage grazed can only be inferred indirectly from measurements of the resulting levels of animal production. Thus Cameron (1965) and Large and Spedding (1967) found very little effect on liveweight gains by either lambs or calves from very high levels of nitrogen fertilizer, and they concluded that intakes at low and high levels of fertilizer were very similar. In a series of papers (Rae et al., 1963, to Cramer et al., 1967), New Zealand workers reported markedly
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
93
higher rates of liveweight gain by lambs grazing short-rotation ryegrass than perennial ryegrass, and also higher gains when white clover was grown in mixture with either type of ryegrass. This was attributed to the production of a higher proportion of propionate to acetate during rumen fermentation of the more productive forages, but this conclusion perhaps underestimated the likely significance of differences in voluntary intake and digestibility between the forages. If priority must be placed on the order of importance of the components in Eq. ( 1 ) in determining the productivity of grazing ruminants it must surely be that intake > digestibility > utilization of digested nutrients. It is now also recognized that, under grazing conditions, nutritional differences between forages or between management treatments can be confounded by animal health factors, in particular by the effects of gastrointestinal parasites. In classical terms, parasites were considered to be of significance oniy when grazing livestock showed clinical symptoms of parasitism; however Spedding and his co-workers (Spedding, 1965) have shown that low levels of parasitism (subclinical infestation) can markedly reduce the productivity of grazing ruminants by reducing the amount of forage the animals will eat and the extent to which they are able to digest this forage, and possibly by stress on the animal. This effect was shown by Lindahl et al. ( 1 963), who found that lambs fed on cut forage gained more rapidly than those grazing on initially “clean” pasture, and both groups more rapidly than lambs grazing on infected pasture, even though parasitism in the latter two groups was a t a subclinical level. It is evident that grazing experiments, particularly with sensitive animals such as lambs, may often be measuring primarily the effects of management and pasture structure on the level of parasiticworm infestation on the forage, rather than any specific nutritional effects of the treatment. A response to supplementary feed could thus be because this feed is “worm free” rather than because it supplies additional nutrients. Moreover, the usual techniques of fecal egg counts are quite inadequate measures of level of animal infestation, from which to assess the relative contributions of nutrition and infection to the observed animal production response (Spedding, 1952). This led Spedding to develop the concept of the “worm-free” pasture as a tool in nutritional studies under grazing conditions, and of rearing “worm-free’’ animals for use in critical grazing experiments (Spedding et al., 1965). This has allowed nutritional effects to be studied at stocking rates in excess of 40 lambs per acre, which could have been catastrophic if carried out with normally reared lambs. In this way lamb gains on ryegrass pasture fertilized with 200, 600, or 1,000 pounds of
94
W. F. RAYMOND
nitrogen per acre could be compared, without the differential effects of parasitism obscuring the nutritional conclusion, that there was no difference in rates of gain on the three treatments (Large and Spedding, 1967). These techniques, originally conceived as experimental tools, are also likely to be of increasing practical and economic significance. Despite recent developments in anthelmintic treatment, the risk of parasitic infestation is a major factor limiting pasture intensification -the problem of stocking pasture with the number of productive animals needed to graze the high yields of forage than can now be grown. The concepts of the “worm-free” pasture, of the early separation of the young from its dam (which is generally the primary source of infection), and of the management of the breeding and productive units within a livestock population in separate nutritional environments, could be key features in future systems of exploiting the nutritional potential of forages (Spedding, 1965).
D. THE EFFECTOF MANAGEMENT ON THE PRODUCTIVITY OF GRAZINGANIMALS With adult animals the effects of parasitism are likely to be less serious, and their level of productivity is likely to reflect more closely the nutritional parameters in Eq. (1). A more critical approach to grazing experiments has followed the paper by McMeekan (1956) at the 7th International Grassland Congress. This led to the recognition of the importance of stocking rate in determining level of animal productivity, as against earlier emphasis on grazing method. Harlan (j958) showed that, as stocking rate was increased beyond a certain point, rate of production per animal began to decrease. Rate of production per acre however continued to increase beyond this stocking rate, producing the familiar double-exponential equations, expressed graphically by Mott (1960) and by Riewe ef al. (1 963) (Fig. 9) and recorded subsequently in numerous grazing experiments (e.g., McMeekan and Walshe, 1963; Conway, 1968a). This is a most important concept in forage research, for it poses the problem of how a high proportion of the forage grown can be grazed without reducing the level of productivity of the individual grazing animal. While the practical implications may differ between milking animals (where output per acre is immediately salable) and meat animals, and in different economic conditions, biological efficiency of land use demands a solution to the problem of achieving a high intensity of forage utilization (point S ) by high-producing animals ( P ) (Raymond, 1968,1969a).
95
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
The relative importance of intake, digestibility, and utilization will differ in different situations. At very low stocking rates, daily output per animal may in fact decrease as a result of the very low digestibility of
output Per animal
lutput Per acre
A
B
Crazinq intensity+ FIG.9. The responses in animal output, per animal and per acre, with increasing grazing intensity in pasture systems. (From Raymond, 1968.)
undergrazed forage. But at higher stocking rates, intake is likely to be the critical factor, with a secondary effect from the reduced possibility for selection of forage of high digestibility from that on offer. Raymond ( I 968) has used Fig. 9 to indicate three possible methods of combining high production per animal with high intensity of forage use: a. The division of the animal population into animals with currently high or low nutrient requirements; the former group graze first at low intensity, and are followed in the rotation by the lower-producing animals, which can still satisfy their nutrient requirements at a high intensity of grazing. Examples are “forward-creep’’ grazing, in which the lamb grazes ahead of the ewe (Dickson, 1959), and the split-herd technique with high- and low-yielding dairy cows. b. The feeding of supplements to animals grazing at high intensity. H. T. Bryant et al. ( 1 96 1) found a greater response in milk yield to supplementary feeding of dairy cows grazing the “bottom” horizon of a sward than by “top” grazers, and Conway ( 1 968b) has shown a similar effect with beef cattle, which gave a response to carbohydrate supplements at a stocking rate of 2.5 animals per acre, but no response at 1.75 animals per acre. Both these experiments illustrate a possible deficiency in the current description of grazing in terms of stocking rate, for the relevant parameters are grazing pressure - the number of animals per
96
W. F. RAYMOND
unit of available forage-and the amount of forage per unit area. A fixed stocking rate within a treatment can conceal wide variations in grazing pressure at different seasons of the year, as well as on the successive days of grazing on a given paddock; yet it is only at those times when grazing pressure is high that a significant response to supplementary feeding can be expected. It is not surprising then that some experiments in which supplements have been fed throughout have shown only marginal responses (e.g., Castle et al., 1968); supplementary feeding must surely be a tactical management tool, to be used only when grazing pressure is so high that forage intake-and so level of animal productionis likely to be significantly reduced. c. Forages can be harvested and fed, either directly or after some form of conservation. In theory this should allow a high efficiency of utilization of forage ( B , Fig. 9) by high-producing animals ( P ) ; yet many conservation systems involve high losses ( A ) and the conserved products are only of low nutrient potential. Raymond ( 1 968) has suggested that this reflects preconceived attitudes to forage conservation, rather than inherent deficiencies in conserved forages per se. The information outlined in earlier sections indicates current developments in forage conservation that may allow a large proportion of the forage grown to be fed to productive animals. The solution of this problem, by creating a storage buffer between the growing and the utilization of forages, will present new perspectives for the agronomist. For grazing requires a succession of growths of forage in phase with current animal requirements, and the agronomist must also aim to make this forage as nearly as possible a complete food for the animals to be fed. By contrast, forages for conservation can be grown at times when they make best use of the environment. The range of species grown is not restricted by the requirement that they must be suitable for grazing; and no single conserved forage need be a complete feed, so that several forages and other feeds, each outstanding in a particular nutritional feature, can be fed in appropriate combination so as to provide optimal nutrition for different classes of ruminant livestock. Thus systems of forage Conservation and nutritional interactions between feeds must be major subjects for future investigations. The agronomist who must produce forage as a complete feed for grazing is involved in compromise - between yield and digestibility, between yield and protein content, between annual and seasonal production. In contrast, forages for conservation, each presenting a much less demanding specification, may offer a more rewarding field for agronomic advance. Figure 9 thus provides a basic, though simple, biological framework
T H E NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
97
within which the problem of land use, presented in the Introduction, can be considered. Most of the world’s ruminant livestock are now at a low level of productivity because they are underfed; the need for the future will be to integrate these new nutritional concepts into practical systems of exploiting, with high-producing animals, the increasing levels of forage production made possible by agronomic research. REFERENCES Abou Akkada, A. R., and El Sayed Osman, H. 1967.J. Agr. Sci. 69,25-3 1. Ademosum, A . A., Baurngardt, B. R., and Scholl, J . M. 1968. J. Animal Sci. 27,818-823. Agricultural Research Council. 1965. “The Nutrient Requirements of Farm Livestock, No. 2 Ruminants.” H.M. Stationery Office, London. Alderman, G., and Jones. D. I. H. 1967.J. Sci. FoodAgr. 18,197- 199. Aldrich, D. T. A., and Dent, J. W. 1967.J. Nail. 1nsr.Agr. Botany 11,104-1 13. Alexander, R. H., and McGowan, M. 1966. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 21, 140-147. Allaway, W. H., and Hodgson, J. F. 1964. J . Animal Sci. 23,27 1-277. Allcroft, R., and Burns, K. N. 1969. New Zealand Vet. J . In press. Andrews, E. D. 1966. New ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 9,829-838. Andrews, 0. N., and Hoveland, C. S. 1965.Agron. J . 57,3 15-3 16. Annison, E. F., and Lewis, D. 1959. “Metabolism in the Rumen,” Chapter 3. Methuen, London. Annison, E. F., Chalmers, M. 1.. Marshall, S. B. M., and Synge, R. L. M. 1954. J . Agr. Sci. 44,270-273. apGriffith. G.. and Walters, R. J . K. 1966. J. Agr. Sci. 67,8149. Armstrong, D. G. 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 485-489. Armstrong, D. G. 1964.J. Agr. Sci. 62,399-4 16. Armstrong, D. G., and Blaxter, K. L. 1957. Brif. J . Nutr. 11,247-272.392-408, and 4 I3425. Armstrong:, D. G., Alexander, R. H., and McGowan, M. 1964a. Proc. Nurr. Soc. f E n g l . Scot.) 23, xxvi. Armstrong, D. G., Blaxter, K. L., and Waite, R. 1964b.J.Agr. Sci. 62,417-424. Arnold, G. W., and Dudzinski, M. L. 1963.J.Agr. Sci. 61,33-43. Arnold, G . W., and Dudzinski, M. L. 1967a.J. Agr. Sci. 68,2 13-2 19. Arnold, C. W., and Dudzinski, M. L. 1967b.Australian J. Agr. Res. 18,657-666. Bailey, P. H., Hughes. M., and McDonald, A. N . C . 1957. J. Brif. Grassland Soc. 12,157165. Bailey, R. W. 1964. New ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 7,496-507. Baker, G., Jones, L. H. P., and Wardrop, 1. D. 1961. Nature 189,682-683. Balch, C . C., and Campling, R. C. 1962. Nu!r. Abstr. Rev. 32,669-686. Balch, C. C.. Balch, D. A., Bartlett, S., Cox, C. P., and Rowland, S. J. 1952.J. Dairy Res. 19,39-50. Barnes, R. F. 1967.J. Animal Sci. 26, I 120- 1 130. Barrett, J. F., George, J. M., and Lamond, D. R. 1965.AustralianJ.Agr. Res. 16,189-200. Barrow, N . J., and Lambourne, L. J. 1962.Ausrralian J. Agr. Res. 13,46 1-47 I . Bath. D. L., Weir, W. C., and Torell, D. T. 1956.J. Animal Sci. 15,i 166- I 17 1.
98
W. F. RAYMOND
Bath, 1. H., and Rook, J. A. F. 1963. J . Agr. Sci. 61,341-348. Bath, I . H., and Rook, J. A. F. 1965. J . Agr. Sci. 64,67-75. Baumgardt, 9. R. 1967. J . Animal Sci. 26,1186- I 194. Baumgardt, 9. R., Cason, J. L., and Taylor, M. W. 1962. J . Dairy Sci. 45, 59-61 and 62-68. Beardsley, D. W. 1964.J. AnimalSci. 23,239-245. Beck, A. B. 1964. Australian J . Agr. Res. 15,223-230. Bedell, E. 1967. J . AnimalSci. 26,933-934. Bell, M. C. 1964. Proc. 6th Intern. Congr. Nutr., Edinburgh, 1963, p. 185. Livingstone, Edinburgh and London. Bennett, W. D. 1963. New Zealand J . Agr. Res. 6,3 10-3 13. Bergman, E. N., Reid, R. S., Murray, M. G., Brockway, J. M., and Whitelaw, F. G. 1965. Biochem. J. 97,53-58. Bickoff, E. M. 1968. Commonwealth Bur. Past. Crops, Rev. Ser. 111968. Bland, B. F., and Dent, J. W. 1962.J. Brit. Grassland Soc. 17,157- 158. Blaser, R. E. 1964. J . Animal Sci. 23,246-253. Blaxter, K. L. 1962. “The Energy Metabolism of Ruminants.” Hutchinson, London (2nd Impression, 1967). Blaxter, K. L. 1964. Proc. Nutr. SOC. (Engl.Scot.) 23,62-7 1. Blaxter, K. L., and Graham, N. McC. 1956. J . Agr. Sci. 47,207-21 7. Blaxter, K. L., and Wainman, F. W. 1964. J . Agr. Sci. 63,113-128. Blaxter, K . L., and Wilson, R. S. 1962.Animal Prod. 4,35 1-358. Blaxter, K. L., and Wilson, R. S. 1963.Animal Prod. 5,27-42. Blaxter, K. L., Wainman, F. W., and Wilson, R. S. 196 1. Animal Prod. 3,5 1-62. Bosman, M. S. M. 1967. Jaarb. Inst. Biol. Scheik. Onderz. LandbGewass. pp. 97-100. Bredon, R. M., and Torell, D. T. 1967. J . Range Management 20,3 17-320. Briggs, M. H. 1967. “Urea as a Protein Supplement.” Pergamon Press, Oxford. Briggs, P. K., Hogan, J. P., and Reid, R. L. 1957.Australian 1.Agr. Res. 8,674-690. Brook, P . J. 1963. New ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 6,147-228. Brouwer, E.. van Es, A. J. H., and Nijkamp, H. J. 1961. Proc. 2nd Intern. Symp. Energy Merab., Wageningen, 1961, pp. 153-163. Brown, D. 1954. Commonwealth Bur. Past. Field Crops, Bull. 42. Brown, L. D. 1966. J . Dairy Sci. 49,223-230. Brown, R. H., Blaser, R. E., and Fontenot, J. P. 1968. J . Animal Sci. 27,562-567. Brown, S. M. 1960. Res. Exptl. Record Min. Agr. Northern Ireland 10,9-19. Bryant, A. M., and Ulyatt, M. J. 1965. New ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 8,109-1 17. Bryant, H. T., Blaser, R. E., Hammes, R. C., and Hardison, W. A. 1961. J . Dairy Sci. 44, 1733- I74 I. Buchman, D. T., and Hemken, R. W. 1964. J . Dairy Sci. 47,861-864. Bull, L. B., and Dick, A. T. 1959. J . Pnthol. Bacteriol. 78,483-502. Burdick, D., and Sullivan, J. T. 1963.J . Animal Sci. 22,444-447. Butler, G . W., and Glenday, A. C. 1962. Australian J . Biol. Sci. 15,183-187. Butterworth, M . H. 1963. J.Agr. Sci. 60,341-346. Butterworth, M. H. 1967. Nutr. A bstr. Rev. 37,349-368. Cameron; G . D. T. 1965. Can. J . AnimalSci. 45,79-83. Cameron, G. D. T. 1967. Can. J . Animal Sci. 47,123- 125. Campbell, C. M., Eng, K. S., Nelson, A. B., and Pope, L. S. 1968. J . Animal Sci. 27,23 I233. Campbell, J. R., Howe, W. M., Martz, F. A., and Merilan, C. P. 1963. J . Dairy Sci. 46,I3 1134.
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
99
Campling, R. C. 1964. Proc. Nutr. Soc. (Engl. Scot.) 2 3 , 8 0 4 8 . Campling, R. C., and Murdoch, J . C. 1966. J. Dairy Res. 33,l - I I . Campling, R. C., Freer, M., and Balch, C. C. 1962. Brir. J. Nurr. 16, 115-124. Campling, R. C., Freer, M., and Balch, C. C. 1963. Brif.J. Nutr. 17,263-272. Castle, M. E., Drysdale, A. D., and Watson, J. N . 1962.5. Dairy Res. 29,199-206. Castle, M. E., Drysdale, A. D.,andWatson, J. N. 1968.1.Brit.GrassZandSoc. 23,137-143. Chalupa, W. 1968. J. Animal Sci. 27,207-2 19. Chalupa, W., and McCullough, M. E. 1967. J. Animal Sci. 26,l 135- 1 143. Chenost, M. 1966. Proc. Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 406-41 I . Christian, K. R., Williams, V. J., and Carter, A. H. 1965. N e w Zealand J . Agr. Res. 8, 530-541. Clancy, M. J., and Wilson, R. K. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 445-453. Clapperton, J. L. 1964. Brit. J. Nutr. 18,39-46 and 47-54. Clark, K. W.,and Mott,G. 0. 1960. Can.J. PlantSci. 40,123-129. Clarke, E. G . C., and Clarke, M. L. 1967. i n “Garner’s Veterinary Toxicology,” 3rd ed. Tindall & Cassall, London. Clarke, R. T. J. 1965. Proc. 25th Con$ N e w ZealandSoc. AnimalProd. pp. 96-105. Clifford, A. J . . and Tillman, A. D. 1966.5. Animal Sci. 25,899. C1ine.T. R.,Garrigus, U. S.,and Hatfield, E. E. 1966.J.AnimalSci. 25,734-739. Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux. 196 I . Commonwealth Bur. Past. Crops, Bull. 45. Conrad, H. R. 1966. J. AnimalSci. 25,227-235. Conrad, H. R., and Hibbs, J. W. 1966. Dairy Sci. Deprl. Ser. 10, No. 4, Ohio Agr. Res. Devel. Ctr., Wooster, Ohio. Conrad, H. R., Pratt, A. D., and Hibbs, J. W. 1964. J . Dairy Sci. 47,54-62. Conway, A. 1968a. IrishJ. Agr. Res. 7,93-104. Conway, A. I968b. Irish J . Agr. Res. 7,105- 120. Cook, C. W., Thorne, J. L., Blake, J. T., and Edlefsen, J. 1958. J . Animal Sci. 17, 189-192. Cook, C. W., Blake, J. T., and Call, J. W. 1963. J. Animal Sci. 22,579-581. Cook, C. W., Harris, L. E., and Young, M. C. 1967.5. AnimalSci. 26, I 169-1 174. Coop, 1. E.,andClark,V. R. 1960. New ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 3,922-933. Coop, 1. E., and Hill, M. K. 1962.J. Agr. Sci. 58, 187-199. Cooper, J. P., Tilley, J. M. A., Raymond, W. F., and Terry, R. A. 1962. Nature 195, 1276- 1277. Corbett, J. L., Greenhalgh, J. F. D., McDonald, I., and Florence, E. 1960. Brit. J . Nutr. 14, 289-299. Cowlishaw, S . J., and Alder, F. E. 1963.5. Brit. GrasslandSoc. 18,328-333. Cramer, D. A,, Barton, R. A., Shorland, F. B., and Czochanska, Z. 1967. J . Agr. Sci. 69, 367-373. Crampton, E. W., and Maynard, L. A. 1938.1. Nutr. 15,383-395. Crampton, E. W.. Donefer, E., and Lloyd, L. E. 1960. J. Animal Sci. 19, 538-544 and 545-552. da Silva, J. F. C., and Gomide, J. A. 1967. Rev. Ceres 13,255-275. Davey, B. G.,and Mitchell,R. L. 1968.5. Sci. FoodAgr. 19,425-431. Davies, W. E., ap Griffith, G., and Ellington, A. 1966.5. Agr. Sci. 66,35 1-357. Davis, C. L. 1967. J . Dairy Sci. 50, I62 1- 1625. Davis, C. L., Brown, R. E., and Beitz, D. C. 1964. J . Dairy Sci. 47,12 17-1 2 19. Davis, L. E., Marten, G. C., and Jordan, R. M. 1967. Agron. J . 59,544-546. de Groot, T., and Keuning, J. A. 1967. Stikstof5,289-293 and 32 1-327. Dehority, B. A., and Johnson, R. R. 1963.5. AnimalSci. 22,222-225 and 1 134.
100
W. F. RAYMOND
Dehority, B. A,, Johnson, R. R.,and Conrad, H. R. 1962. J . Dairy Sci. 45,508-5 12. Dehority, B. A,, Scott, H. W., and Johnson, R. R. 1968.J . Dairy Sci. 51,567-572. Deinum, B., van Es, A. J. H., and Van Soest, P. J. 1968. Netherlands J . Agr. Sci. 16, 217-223. de Loose, R.,and Baert, L. 1966. Plant Soil 24,343-350. Demarquilly, C. 1966a. Fourrages 26,12-33. Demarquilly, C. 1966b.Ann. Zootech. 15, 147-169. Demarquilly, C., and Journet, M. 1967. Ann. Zootech. 16,123-150. Dent, J. W. 1963. J . Brit. GrasslandSoc. 18,181-188. Dent, J. W., and Aldrich, D. T. A. 1968. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 23,13- 19. Dick, A. T. 1954. Australian J . Agr. Res. 5 , 5 I 1-544. Dickson, G . R. 1959. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 14, 172- 176. Dijkstra, N. D. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 393-397. Donefer, E.. Crampton, E. W., and Lloyd, L. E. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 442-445. Dougall, H. W.. and Bogdan, A, V. 1966. East African Agr. Forestry J . 32,45-49. Drew, K. R. 1966. Proc. N e w Zealand Soc. Animal Prod. 26,52. Dunham, J . R., Ward, G . . Bassette, R., and Reddy, M. C. 1968. J . Dairy Sci. 51,44-46. Egan, A. R., and Moir, R. J. 1965.Australian J . Agr. Res. 16,437-449 and 45 1-472. Ehlig, C. F., Allaway, W. H., Cary, E. E., and Kubota, J. 1968. Agron. J . 60,43-47. Ekern, A., Blaxter, K. L.,and Sawers, D. 1965. Brit. J . Nutr. 19,417-434. Ellis, W. C. 1968. J . Agr. FoodChem. 16,220-224. El-Shazly, K., Dehority, B. A., and Johnson, R. R. 1961.J . Animal Sci. 20,268-273. Ely, R. A., and Moore, L. A. 1955. J . Animal Sci. 14,7 18-724. Engels, E. A. N., and Van der Merwe, F. J. 1967. South African J . Agr. Sci. 10,983-995. Essig, H. W. 1968. J . AnimalSci. 27,730-738. Evans, P. S. 1964. N e w Zealand 1. Agr. Res. 7, 508-5 13. Faichney, G. J . 1968a. Australian J . Agr. Res. 19,791-802. Faichney, G . J. 1968b.Australian J . Agr. Res. 19,803-81 I . Faichney, G. J. 1 9 6 8 ~Australian . J. Agr. Res. 19,8 13-8 19. Flatt, W. P. 1966.J . Dairy Sci. 49,230-237. Fleming, G. A., and Murphy, W. E. 1968. J. Brit. GrasslandSoc. 23, 173- 185. Fontenot, J. P., and Blaser, R. E. 1965. J . Animal Sci. 24,1202- 1208. Francis, C. M., and Millington, A. J. 1965. Australian J . Agr. Res. 16,557-573. Freer, M., and Campling, R. C. 1963. Brit. J . Nutr. 17,7948. Gaillard. 8. D. E. 1958. J.Sci. FoodAgr. 9, 170-177and 346-353. Gaillard, 9. D. E. 1962. J . Agr. Sci. 59,369-373. Gaillard, 9. D. E. 1966. Netherlands J . Agr. Sci. 14,2 15-223. Gaillard, B. D. E., and Nijkamp, H . J. 1968. Netherlands J . Agr. Sci. 16,2 1-24. Gallagher, C. H., Koch, J. H., and Hoffman, H. 1966.Australian Vet. J . 42,279. Garrett, W. N., Meyer, J. H . , Lofgreen, G. P., and Dobie, J. 8.1961. J . Animal Sci. 20, 833-838. Gladstones, J. S. 1962. Australian J . Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 2,2 13-220. Gonzalez Gonzalez, V., and Lambourne, L. J. 1967. Rev. Nutr. Animal, Madrid 4,34-40. Gordon, C. H., Derbyshire, J. C., Wiseman, H. G . , and Jacobson, W. C. 1964. J . Dairy S C ~47,987-992. . Graham, N. McC. 1964.AustralianJ.Agr. Res. 15,100-1 12. Graham, N . McC. 1966. Proc. Australian Soc. Animal Prod. 6,364.
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF FORAGE CROPS
101
Graham, N . McC. 1967.Australian J . Agr. Res. 18,467-485. Green, J. 0. 1966. Ann. Rept. Grassland Res. Inst., Hurley, 1965, pp. 15-1 8. G reenhalgh, J. F. D., and Corbett, J . L. 1960. J . Agr. Sci. 55,37 1-376. Greenhalgh, J . F. D., and Reid, G . W. 1967. Nature 214,744. Greenhalgh, J . F. D., and Reid, G . W. 1968. Animal Prod. 10,23 I . Greenhalgh, J. F. D., Corbett, J . L., and McDonald, 1. 1960.5.Agr. Sci. 55,377-386. Greenhatgh, J. F. D., Reid, G . W., and Aitken, J . N. 1967. J . Agr. Sci. 69,2 17-223. Greenhill. W. L., Couchman, J. F., and de Freitas. J . I96 I . J . Sci. Food Agr. 12,293-297. Grieve, C. M., and Osbourn, D. F. 1965.J.Agr.Sci. 65,411-417. Griffiths, T. W. 1967.5.Agr. Sci. 69,355-366. Grimes, R. C. 1967. J . Agr. Sci. 69,33-4 I . Grimes, R. C., Watkin. B. R., and May, P. F. 1965. J . Brit. Grussland Soc. 20, 168-173. Grunes, D. L., and Stout, P. R. To be published. Hamilton, J . W., and Beath. 0. A . 1964. Agr. Food Chem. 12,37 1-374. Hanson, C. H. 1965. U S .Dept. Agr., Tech. Bull. 1333. Harkess, R. D. 1963. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 18,62-68. Harlan, J . R. 1958.5. RangeManagement 11,140-147. Harris, C. E. 1963. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 18, 189. Harris. C. E.. and Raymond. W. F. 1963. J . Brit. Grussland Soc. 18,204-2 12. Harris. C . E., Raymond. W. F., and Wilson, R. F. 1966. Proc. loth Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 564-568. Hawkins. G. E. 1959. J . Animal Sci. 18,763-769. Head, M. J . I96 I . In “Digestive Physiology and Nutritionbf the Ruminant” (D. Lewis, ed.), Chapter 23. Butterworth, London and Washington, D.C. Healy, W. B., and Ludwig, T. C. 1965. N e w ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 8,737-752. Heaney, D. P., and Pigden, W. J. 1963. J . Animal Sci. 22,956-960. Heaney, D. P., Pigden. W. J., Minson, D. J., and Pritchard, G . I. 1963. J . Animal Sci. 22, 752-757. Heaney, D. P., Pigden, W. J., and Pritchard, G . 1. 1966.J.AnimalSci. 25,142-149. Heaney, D. P., Pritchard, 0.I., and Pigden, W. J. 1968.5.AnimalSci. 27,159-164. Hedin, L., and Duval, E. 1966. Fourrages 28,3- 15. Hennaux. L., Compere, R.,Frankinet, M., and Fabry. J. 1967. Bull. Rech. Agron. G e m bloux 2,473-506. Hercus, J. M. 1963. N e w ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 6 , 8 3 4 9 . Hight. C . K., Sinelair, D. P., and Lancaster. R. J. 1968. N e w ZealandJ. Agr. R e s . 11,286302. Hinders, R. G.,and Owen, F. G . 1968.5. Dairy Sci. 51,1253-1257. Hiridoglou, M., Dermine, P., Hamilton, H. A , , and Troelsen, J. E. 1966. Can. J . Plant Sci. 46, I0 I - 106. Hodge, R. W.. and Doyle, J. J . 1967. Australian J . Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 7, 141143. Hodgson, J. 1968. J . Agr. Sci. 70,47-5 I . Hoehne, 0. E., Clanton, D. C., and Streeter, C. L. 1967.5.Animal Sci. 26,628-63 I . Hogan, J . P. 1965. AustralianJ. Agr. Res. 16,855-862. Holmes, J . C., and Lang, R. W. 1963. Animal Prod. 5.17-26. Hornb,T. 1953.ActaAgr. Scand. 3,1-32. Honkanen, E., and Moisio, T . 1963.Acta Chem. Scand. 17,588. Hopson, J. D.. Johnson, R. R., and Dehority, B. A . 1963.J . Animal Sci. 22,448-453.
102
W. F. RAYMOND
Hungate, R. E. 1966. “The Rumen and its Microbes.” Academic Press, New York. Huston, J. E., and Ellis, W. C. 1968. J . Agr. Food Chem. 16,225-230. Hutton, E. M., and Coote, J. N. 1966. J . Australian Ins?.Agr. Sci. 32,139- 140. Hutton, J . B. 1963.Proc. NewZealandSoc. Animalprod. 23,39-51. Hutton, J. B., and Jury, K. E. 1964. New Zealand J . Agr. Res. 7,583-595. Ingalls, J. R., Thomas, J. W., Benne, E. J., and Tesar, M. 1965. J. Animal Sci. 24, 11591164. Jarrige, R. 1961. Ann. Biol. Animale, Biochim., Biophys. 1,163-205. Jarrige, R., and Minson, D. J. 1964. Ann. Zootech. 13,118- 150. Johns, A. T. 1959. New Zealand J . Agr. 99,2-9. Johnson, R. R., and McClure, K. E. 1968. J . Animal Sci. 27,535-540. Johnston, T. D. 1967. Euphytica 16,365-369. Jones, J. R., and Hogue, D. E. 1963. J . AnimalSci. 22,881-885. Jones, L. H. P., and Handreck, K. A. 1967.Advan.Agron. 19,107-149. Jones, U . I. 1959. Rep?. Welsh Plant Breeding Sta., 1956-1 958, p. 52. Julen, G., and Lager, A. 1966. Proc. 10th Infern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 652-657. Kamstra, L. D., and Jahn, J. R. 1966. J . Range Management 19,196-200. Kane, E. A., and Moore, L. A. 1959. J . Dairy Sci. 42,936. Kane, E. A., Jacobson, W. C., and Moore, L. A. 1950.J . Nutr. 41,583-596. Kane, E. A., Jacobson, W. C., and Moore, L. A. 1952.J . Nutr. 47,263-273. Karn, J. F., Johnson, R. R., and Dehority, B. A. 1967.J . Animal Sci. 26,38 1-384. Karr, M. R., Garrigus, U. S., Hatfield, E. E., and Norton, H. W. 1965. J . Animal Sci. 24, 459-468. Kay, M., Andrews, R. P., MacLeod, N. A., and Walker,T. 1968.AnimalProd. 10,171-175. Kemp, A. 1960. Netherlands J . Agr. Sci. 8,28 1-304. Kemp, A. 1964. Netherlands J . Agr. Sci. 12,263-280. Kendall, W. A. 1966. Crop Sci. 6,487-489. Kennedy, G . S. 1968. Australian J . Biol. Sci. 21,529-538. Kivimae, A. 1959.Acta Agr. Scand. Suppl. 5. Knight, R., and Yates, N. G. 1968. Australian J . Agr. Res. 19,373-380. Laby, R. H., and Weenink, R. 0. 1966. New ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 9,839-850. Lacey, J. 1968. J . Gen. Microbiol. 51,173-177. Lambourne, L. J., and Reardon, T. F. 1962. Nature 196,96 I , Lambourne, L. J., and Reardon, T. F. 1963. Australian J . Agr. Res. 14,239-256,257-27 1 , and 272-293. Lancaster, R. J. 1949. New ZealandJ. Sci. Technol. A31,3 1-38. Langlands,J. P. 1967a.AnimalProd. 9,167-175. Langlands, J. P. l967b. Animal Prod. 9,325-33 I . Langlands, J. P., and Corbett, J. L. 1964. J . Agr. Sci. 63,305-3 10. Langlands, J. P., Corbett, J. L., McDonald, I., and Reid, G. W. 1963. Animal Prod. 5, 11-16. Langlands, J. P., George, J. M., and Lynch, J. J. 1967. Australian J . Expfl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 7,325-328. Large, R. V., and Spedding, C. R. W. 1967. J . Agr. Sci. 67,41-52. Lefevre, C. F., and Kamstra, L. D. 1960.J . Animal Sci. 19,867-872. Leigh, J. H., and Mulham, W. E. 1966. Australian J . Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 6, 460-467. Leitch, Isabella. 1969. In preparation.
T H E NUTRITIVE V A L U E OF FORAGE CROPS
103
Leng, R. A., Corbett. J. L., and Brett, D. J. 1968. Brit. J . Nutr. 22,57-68. Lindahl, I . L., Kates. K. C., Turner, J. H., Enzie, F. D., and Whitmore, G . E. 1963. J. Parasitol. 49,209-2 17. Lindner, H. R. 1967.AustralianJ. Agr. Res. 18,305-333. Linton, J. H., Goplen, B. P., Bell, J. M., and Jaques, L. B. 1964. Can. J . Animal Sci. 44, 76-86. Lombard, P. E., and van Schalkwyk, A. 1963. South African J . Agr. Sci. 6, 205-21 I. Loper, G . M. 1968. Crop Sci. 8, 104-106. Lowe, C . C., Reid, J. T., and Meredith, W. R. 1962. Agron. Abstr. p. 94. Lusk, J. W., Browning, C. B., and Miles, J . T. 1962. J. Dairy Sci. 45,69-73. McArthur, J. M.. and Miltimore, J. E. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 5 18-524. McCarrick, R. B. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 575-580. McCarrick, R. B., Keane, E., and Tobin, J. 1965. Irish J. Agr. Res. 4 , l 15-1 23. McCroskey, J. E., Pope, L. S., Stephens, D . F., and Waller, G . 1961.J.AnimalSci. 20,4245. McCullough, M. E. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 58 1584. McCullough, M. E., and Smart, W. W. G . 1968. J. Dairy Sci. 51,385-391. McDonald, 1. W. 1962. Commonwealth Bur. Past. Crops, Bull. 46,43. McDonald, I . W. 1968. Nutr. Abstr. Rev. 38,38 1-400. McDonald, P.. MacPherson, H. T., and Watt, J. A. 1963. J. Brit. Grassland Soc. 18,230231. McGuire, R. L., Bradley, N. W., and Little, C. 0. 1966. J . Animal Sci. 25,185- I9 I . Mcllroy, R. J . 1967. HerbageAbstr. 37,79-87. MacLusky, D. S. 1960.J. Brit. Grassland Soc. 15, I 8 I - 188. McManus, W. R., Arnold, G . W., and Hamilton, F. J . 1962.Australian Vet. J . 38,275-28 I . McManus, W. R., Dudzinski, M. L., and Arnold, G . W. 1967. J. Agr. Sci. 69, 263-270. McMeekan. C . P. 1956. Proc. 7th Intern. Grassland Congr., Palmerston, N e w Zealand, 1956, pp. 146-155. McMeekan, C. P., and Walshe, M. J. 1963. J. Agr. Sci. 61,147- 163. Macpherson, A.,and Hemingway, R. G . 1968.5. Sci. FoodAgr. 19,53-56. Marten, G . C., and Donker, J. D. 1964.J. Dairy Sci. 47,87 1-874. Marten, G. C., and Donker, J . D. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 359-363. Mellin, T. N., Poulton, B. R., and Anderson, M. J. 1962. J. Animal Sci. 21,123- 126. Melville, J . 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 35-40. Melvin,J. F. 1963.J.Sci. FoodAgr. 14,281-283. Miles, D. G., and Walters, R. J. K. 1966.J . Agr. Soc. Univ. Coll. Wales 47,4-9. Milford, R. 1967.Australian J. Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry I, 540-545. Mi1ler.T. 6. 1961. HerbageAbstr. 31,81-85and 163-167. Minson, D. J. 1963.5. Brit. GrasslandSoc. 18,39-44. Minson, D. J . 1966.5. Brit. GrasslandSoc. 21,123-126. Minson, D. J . 1967. Brit. J . Nutr. 21,587-597. Minson, D. J . , and Kemp, C. D. I96 I . J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 16,76-79. Minson, D. J., and Milford, R. 1967. Australian J . Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 7,5465 5 I. Minson, D. J., Raymond, W. F., and Harris. C . E. 1960. J. Brit. Grassland SOC. 15, 174180.
104
W. F. RAYMOND
Minson, D. J., Harris, C. E., Raymond, W. F., and Milford, R. 1964. J . Brit. Grassland SOC.19,298-305. Mitchell, R. L., and Reith, J. W. S. 1966. J. Sci. FoodAgr. 17,437-440. Moe, P. W., Reid, J. T., and Tyrrell, H. F. 1965. J. Dairy Sci. 48,1053- I06 1. Moir, R. J., and Bray, A. C. 1967. Sulphur Inst. J . 4,M- 18. Moore, L. A. 1964. J . Animal Sci. 23,230-238. Moore, L. A., Irvin, H. M., and Shaw, J. C. 1953. J . Dairy Sci. 36,93-97. Moore, L. A., Thomas, J. W., and Sykes, J. F. 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 701-704. Moore, R. M., and Hutchings, R. J. 1967. Australian J . Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 7, 17-21. Morley, F. W. H., and Francis, C. M. 1968. Australian J . Agr. Res. 19,I5-26. Morrison, F. B. 1957. “Feeds and Feeding,” 22nd ed. Morrison, Ithaca, New York. Mott, G. 0. 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 606-61 1. Moule, G . R., Braden, A. W. H., and Lamond, D. R. 1963. Animal Breeding Absrr. 31, 139-157. Mowat, D. N. 1969. “Symposium: Forage Quality Evaluation.” Am. SOC. Agron. Spec. Publ. 13,85-95. Mowat, D. N., Fulkerson, R. S., Tossell, W. E., and Winch, J. E. 1965. Can. J . Plant Sci. 4 5 3 2 1-33 I . Naga, M. M. A., and El-Shady, K. 1963. J . Agr. Sci. 61,73-79. National Academy of Sciences. 1966. Natl. Acad. Sci. -Natl. Res. Council, Publ. 1349. Neumark, H. 1962. Nature 195,626. Neurnark, H., and Tadmor, A. 1968. J . Agr. Sci. 71,267-270. Newton, J . E., and Betts, J. E. 1968. J . Agr. Sci. 70,77-82. Noller, C . H., Prestes, P. J., Rhykerd, C. L., Rumsey, T. S., and Burns, J. C. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 429-434. Norman, A. G. 1935. J . Agr. Sci. 25,529-540. O’Donovan, P. B., Barnes, R. F., Plumlee, M. P., Mott, G. 0.. and Packett, L. V. 1967. J . Animal Sci. 26,1144- I 152. Oldfield, J. E., Fox, C. W., Bahn, A. V., Bickoff, E. M., and Kohler, G. 0. 1966. J. Animal Sci. 25,167-174. Oltjen, R.R., and Bond, J. 1967. J.Animal Sci. 26,225. Oltjen, R. R., Slyter, L. L., Kozak, A. S., and Williams, E. E. 1968. J . Nutr. 94, 193-202. Oram, L. R. N., and Williams, J. D. 1967. Nature 213,946-947. Orth, A., and von Kaufmann, W. 1966. Z. Tierphysiol., Tierernaehr. Futtermittelk. 21, 327. Osbourn, D. F. 1967. Brit. GrasslandSoc. Occ. Symp. 3,20-28. Osbourn, D. F., Thomson, D. J., and Terry, R. A. 1966. Proc. 10th Intern. Grassland Congr., Helsinki, 1966, pp. 363-366. O’Shea, J., and Maguire, M. F. 1967. Irish J . Agr. Res. 6,127-129. O’Shea, J . , and Wilson, R. K. 1965. Irish J . Agr. Res. 4,235-237. O’Sullivan, M. 1968. J . Sci. FoodAgr. 19,12-15. Owen, J . B., and Ingleton, J. W. 1963. J.Agr. Sci. 61,267-274. Paladines, 0. L., Reid, J. T., van Niekerk, B. D. H., and Bensadoun, A. 1964. J . Nutr. 83, 49-59. Paulson, G. D., Broderick, G. A , , Baumann, C. A., and Pope, A. L. 1968. J . Animal Sci. 27,195-202. Pearce, G . R., Vercoe, J . E., and Freer, M. 1962.J. Agr. Sci. 59,397-402.
THE NUTRITIVE VALUE O F FORAGE CROPS
105
Perez, C. B., Warner, R. G., and Loosli, J. K. 1967.J . Animal Sci. 26,8 10-8 19. Peterson, P. J., and Spedding, D. J. 1963. N e w ZealandJ. Agr. Res. 6, 13-23, Pigden, W. J., Pritchard, G. I., Winter, K. A., and Logan, V. S. 1961. J . Animal Sci. 20, 796-80 I . Playne, M. J., and McDonald, P. 1966.J . Sci.FoodAgr. 17,264-268. Plice, M. J. 1952.J . Range Management 5,69-75. Pope, G. S. 1954. DairySci. Abstr. 16,333-356. Pope, G. S., McNaughton, M. J., and Jones, H. E. H. 1959. J . Dairy Res. 26,196-202. Presthegge, K. 1959. 93 Berern. Insr. Husdryrernaering og FBringslaere Agr. Coll. Norway, Vollebekk. Pritchard, G. I., Folkins, L. P., and Pigden, W. J. 1963. Can.J . Plant Sci. 43,79-87. Quicke, G. V., Bentley, 0. G., Scott, H. W., and Moxon, A. L. 1959. J . Animal Sci. 18, 275-287. Rae, A. L., Brougham, R. W., Glenday, A. C., and Butler, G. W. 1963. J . Agr. Sci. 61, 187- 190. Raymond, W. F. 1966a. I n “The Growth of Cereals and Grasses’’ (F. L. Milthorpe, ed.), pp. 259-27 I . Butterworth, London and Washington, D.C. Raymond, W. F. 1966b. In “Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition” (J. T. Abrams. ed.), pp. 81-1 18. Churchill, London. Raymond, W. F. 1968. J . Roy. Agr. Soc. Engl. 129,85-105. Raymond, W. F. I969a. “Symposium: Forage Economics.” A m . Soc. Agron. Spec. Publ. 13,25-35. Raymond, W. F. 1969b. “Symposium: Forage Quality Evaluation.” A m . SOC.Agron. Spec. Pub/. 13,47-63. Raymond, W. F., and Minson, D. J. 1955. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 10, 282-296. Raymond, W. F., and Spedding, C. R. W. 1965. Proc. Fertiliser Soc. 88, 5-34. Raymond, W. F., and Terry, R. A. 1966. Outlook Agr. 5,60-68. Raymond, W. F., Harris, C. E., and Harker, V. G . 1953. J . Brit. Grassland Soc. 4, 3 I5320. Raymond, W. F., Kemp, C. D., Kemp, A. W., and Harris, C. E. 1954. J . Brir. Grassland SOC.9,69-82. Raymond, W. F., Minson, D. J., and Harris, C. E. 1956. Proc. 7th Intern. Grassland Congr., Palmerston, New Zealand, 1956, pp. 123- 133. Reid, C. S. W. 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 668671. Reid, J. T. 1962. “Pasture and Range Research Techniques,” p. 43. Am. Soc. Agron., Comstock, Ithaca, New York. Reid, J. T.. Woolfolk, P. G., Hardison, W. A., Martin, C. M., Brundage, A. L., and Kaufmann, R. W. 1952.J . Nutr. 46,255-269. Reid, J. T., Kennedy, W. K., Turk, K. L., Slack, S. T., Trimberger, G . W.. and Murphy, R. P. 1959.J . Dairy Sci. 42,567-57 1. Reid, R. L., and Jung, G . A. 1965.J . Animal Sci. 24,6 15-625. Reid. R. l.., and Jung, G . A. 1966. Proc. 9th Intern. Grassland Congr., Suo Paulo, 1966, p. 863-869. Reid, R. L., H0gan.J. P.,and Briggs, P. K. 1957.AustralianJ.Agr. Res. 8,691-710. Reid, R. L., Clark, B., Welch, J. A., Jung. G. A., and Shelton, D. C. 1960. J . Animal Sci. 19,13 12. Reid, R. L., Jung, G . A., and Murray, S. 1964.J . Animal Sci. 23,700-7 10. Reith, J. W. S. 1968.J . Agr. Sci. 70,39-45.
106
W. F. RAYMOND
Richards, C. R., Weaver, H. S., and Connolly, J. 0. 1958. J. Dairy Sci. 41,956-962. Ridley, J. R., Lesperance, A. L., Jensen, E. H., and Bohman, V. R. 1963. J. Dairy Sci. 46, 128-130. Riewe, M . E., Smith, J. C., Jones, J. H., and Holt, E. C. 1963. Agron. J. 55,367-369. Robards, G. E., and Wilson, A. D. 1967. Australian J. Exptl. Agr. Animal Husbandry 7, 22-24. Roe, R., and Mottershead, B. E. 1962. Nature 193,255. Rogers, H. H. 1967. Brit. GrasslandSoc. Occ. Symp. 3,66-75. Rogers, H. H., and Whitmore, E. T. 1966. J. Brit. GrasslandSoc. 21,150-152. Ronning, M., and Dobie, J. B. 1962. J. Dairy Sci. 45,969-97 1. Rook,J. A. F., and Balch, C. C. 1961. Brit. J. Nutr. 15,361-369. Rook, J. A. F., Balch, C. C., Campling, R. C., and Fisher, L. J. 1963. Brit. J. Nutr. 17, 399-406. Rosenfeld, I., and Beath, 0. A. 1964. “Selenium. Geobotany, Biochemistry, Toxicity and Nutrition.” Academic Press, New York. Rossiter, R. C., and Beck, A. B. 1966. Australian J. Agr. Res. 17,29-37. Satter, L. D., and Baumgardt, B. R. 1962. J.Animal Sci. 21,897-900. Schaadt, H . , Johnson, R. R., and McClure, K. E. 1966.J.Animal Sci. 25,73-77. Schillinger, J. A., and Elliott, F. C. 1966. Quart. Bull. Michigan Agr. Expt. Sta. 48, 570579. Schneider, B. H. 1952. “Feeds of the World.” West Virginia Univ., Morgantown, West Virginia. Schulz, E., and Oslage, H. J. 1967. Wirtschaftseigene Futter Part 4, pp. 298-306. Shelton, D. C., and Reid, R. L. 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 524-528. Shepperson, G . 1960. Proc. 8th Intern. Grassland Congr., Reading, Engl., 1960, pp. 704708. Shumard, R. F., Bolin, D. W., and Evelet