ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY
VOLUME 34
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME M. J . AMBROSE R. B . BEVERLY W. C. GREGORY UMESHC. GUPT...
29 downloads
1679 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY
VOLUME 34
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME M. J . AMBROSE R. B . BEVERLY W. C. GREGORY UMESHC. GUPTA Hu HAN C. L. HEDLEY
W. M. JARRELL PREMP. JAUHAR THOMASA . LARUE JOHN LIPSETT THOMAS G. PATTERSON SHAOQIQUAN JOSE
G . SALINAS
PEDROA . SANCHEZ H. K. SRIVASTAVA J. C. WYNNE
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared in cooperution with the AMERICAN SOCIETY OF AGRONOMY
VOLUME 34 Edited by N. C . BRADY Science and Technology Bureau Agency for International Development Department of State Washington, D . C .
ADVISORY BOARD
H. J . GORZ,CHAIRMAN E. J . KAMPRATH T. M. STARLING
J . B . POWELL J . W. BIGGAR
M . A . TABATABAI M. STELLY, EX
OFFICIO,
ASA Headquarters 1981
ACADEMIC PRESS A Subsidiary of Harcourr Bruce Jovanovich, Publishers
New York
London Toronto Sydney San Francisco
COPYRIGHT @ 1981, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, 1NC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART O F THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM T H E PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS,INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York. New York 10003
United Kirigdom Edition published b y ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ( L O N D O N ) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road, London NWI
7DX
LIBRARY O F CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER:50-5598 ISBN 0-12-000734-7 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES O F AMERICA 81 82 83 84
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
CONTENTS CONTRIBUTORSTO VOLUME 34 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . PREFACE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix xi
ADVANCES IN PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
Hu Han and Shao Qiquan I. I1. 111. IV . V. VI .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Anther Culture and Crop Improvement ..................... Some Fundamental Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Protoplast Isolation, Culture. and Genetic Manipulation . . . . . . . . Selection of Mutants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Miscellaneous: In Vi'itroPropagation through Plant Tissue Culture References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
2 5 7 9 10 11
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
Thomas A . LaRue and Thomas G . Patterson I. II. I11. IV .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods of Estimating Fixation by Crops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Estimates for Major Crops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
15 19 27 34 36
PEANUT BREEDING
J . C . Wynne and W . C . Gregory I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II . Germ Plasm Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III . Economic Importance and Breeding Objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Breeding and Quantitative Genetics ........................ V . Breeding Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Interspecific Hybridization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V
39 40 44 49 63 65 68 68
vi
CONTENTS
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS. PLANTS. AND ANIMALS
Umesh C . Gupta and John Lipsett
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Molybdenum Fertilizers. Their Rates and Methods of Application.
13
and Industrial Uses of Molybdenum .....................
75 78 81 85 Responses to Molybdenum on Crops ....................... Factors Affecting the Molybdenum Uptake by Plants . . . . . . . . . . 89 Deficiency and Sufficiency Levels of Molybdenum in Plants . . . 99 Molybdenum Deficiency and Toxicity Symptoms in Plants . . . . . 100 Molybdenum Toxicity and Molybdenum-Copper-Sulfur Interrelationships in Animals ........................... 105 Summary and Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 109 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
111. Physiological Role of Molybdenum in Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Determination of Molybdenum in Soils and Plants . . . . . . . . . . . .
V. VI . VII . VIII . IX .
X.
INTERGENOMIC INTERACTION. HETEROSIS. AND IMPROVEMENT OF CROP YIELD
H . K . Srivastava I . Introduction
...........................................
118
I1. Genetics of Mitochondria and Chloroplasts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 111. IV. V. VI . VII .
Organelle Involvement in Genetic Phenomena . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Genetic Implications of Intergenomic Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . Molecular-Genetic Aspects of Heterosis .................... Improvement of Crop Yield . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary and Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
130 147 164 174 182 185
THE DILUTION EFFECT IN PLANT NUTRITION STUDIES
W . M . Jarrell and R . B . Beverly
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I1. System for Expressing Results ............................ 111. Mechanisms
IV . V. VI . VII .
...........................................
Treatments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dilution Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concentration Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Implications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
197 199 200 202 204 216 219
CONTENTS
VIII . Summary and Future Research Needs ...................... References ............................................
vii
221 222
DESIGNING “LEAFLESS” PLANTS FOR IMPROVING YIELDS OF THE DRIED PEA CROP
C . L . Hedley and M . J . Ambrose I. I1. I11. IV . V. VI . VII .
General Introduction ..................................... Comparative Responses of Peas to the Crop Environment . . . . . . Attaining Maximum Biological Yield per Unit Area . . . . . . . . . . . Attaining the Maximum Economic Yield per Unit Area . . . . . . . . Improving the Efficiency of the Pea Fruit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Plant Ideotype for Improving Yields of Dried Peas . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
225 229 239 252 265 272 274 275
LOW-INPUT TECHNOLOGY FOR MANAGING OXISOLS AND ULTISOLS IN TROPICAL AMERICA
Pedro A . Sanchez and Jose G . Salinas 1. I1. I11. IV . V. VI . VII . VIII . IX .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Site Selection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Selection of Acid-Tolerant Germplasm ..................... Development and Maintenance of Ground Cover . . . . . . . . . . . . . Management of Soil Acidity .............................. Phosphorus Management ................................. Management of Low Native Soil Fertility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion ............................................ Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
280 293 295 308 334 354 380 390 397 398
CYTOGENETICS OF PEARL MILLET
Prem P . Jauhar I. I1. I11. IV . V.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Karyotypic Analysis ..................................... Meiosis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Abnormal Meiosis and Its Genetics ........................ Haploidy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
408 410 415 417 424
viii
CONTENTS
VI . Polyploidy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aneuploids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Structural Changes in Chromosomes ....................... B Chromosomes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Floral Biology and Hybridization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hybridization and Chromosome Relationships . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
VII . VIII . IX . X. XI . XI1 .
428 434 441 446 451 456 472 473
INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
481
CONTRIBUTORS Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
M. J . AMBROSE (225), Department of Applied Genetics, John Innes Institute, Norwich NR4 7UH, England R. B . BEVERLY (197), Department of Soil and Environmental Sciences, University of California-Riverside, Riverside, California 92521 W. C. GREGORY (39), Crop Science Department, North Carolina State University, Box 5 / 5 5 , Raleigh, North Carolina 27650 UMESH C. GUPTA (73), Research Branch, Agriculture Canada, P. 0. Box 1210, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, Canada CIA 7M8 HU HAN ( I ) , Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica, Beijing, People’s Republic of China C. L. HEDLEY (225), Department of Applied Genetics, John Innes Institute, Norwich NR4 7UH, England W. M. JARRELL (197), Department of Soil and Environmental Sciences, University of California-Riverside, Riverside, California 92521 PREM P. JAUHAR* (407), Department of Botany and Plant Sciences, University of California-Riverside, Riverside, California 92521 THOMAS A. LaRUE (15), Boyce Thompson Institute for Plant Research, Ithaca, New York 14853 JOHN LIPSETT (73), Division of Plant Industry, CSIRO, P. 0. Box 1600, Canberra City, A . C . S . 2601, Australia THOMAS G . PATTERSON (15 ) , Boyce Thompson Institute for Plant Research, Ithaca, New York 14853 SHAO QIQUAN ( I ) , Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica, Beijing, People’s Republic of China JOSE G. SALINAS (279), Tropical Pastures Program, Centro lnternacional de Agricultura Tropical, Apartado Aereo 67-13, Cali, Colombia PEDRO A. SANCHEZ (279), Soil Science Department, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina 27650 H. K . SRIVASTAVAT (1 I7), Department of Biology, University of Valle, Cali, Colombia J . C. WYNNE (39), Crop Science Department, North Carolina State University, Box 5155, Raleigh, North Carolina 27650 *Present address: Division of Cytogenetics and Cytology, City of Hope National Medical Center, Duarte, California 91010. thesent address: National Agricultural Research Project, Gujarat Agricultural University, Anand 388 1 10 (Gujarat), India. ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE Agronomy is an applied field of endeavor that embodies the combined efforts of soil and crop scientists to increase the yield and production of field crops. It utilizes the methods and inputs of the more basic physical and biological sciences to gain an understanding of plant and soil processes that constrain and/or enhance crop production. It encourages an integration of the best products of these more basic sciences into practical crop production systems. The contributions to this volume illustrate the usefulness of the findings of agronomists in seeking increased crop yields and production. Four of the articles deal with genetics and plant breeding. Research on the cytogenetics of an important food crop of the Old World, pearl millet (Pennisetum), is reviewed. Likewise, the remarkable progress made in recent years in breeding improved varieties of the common peanut (ground nut) is very effectively covered. Recent developments relating to improved crop yield through heterosis and intergenomic interaction are the focus of another article. During the past 30 years, there has been little interaction between scientists in the People’s Republic of China and those in the Western world. The contribution on tissue culture in China discusses an important subject to which the Chinese have made significant contributions during the past two decades. This method of crop regeneration and improvement is also beginning to provide plant breeders with a practical tool that may shorten the time needed to develop new varieties and may simultaneously increase rates of mutation. Soil fertility and management are the subjects of four articles. One deals with factors influencing the amount of nitrogen fixed by legumes, a topic of increasing importance as rising energy costs force concomitant increases in nitrogen fertilizer prices. A second related contribution, which will be equally important to researchers and farmers in large areas of Africa, Latin America, and Asia, focuses on the management of acid soils of the tropics. Means of alleviating the constraints placed on resource-limited farmers in these areas are considered. Soil fertility research methodology is given attention in a contribution concerned with the dilution effect in soil fertility experiments. This review will be helpful in interpreting data from such experiments. A second soil fertility article brings us up-to-date on research concerned with molybdenum in soils, plants, and animals. Knowledge of factors influencing the availability of this element is helpful in both developing and more developed countries. The article on the “leafless” pea crop is of special interest to crop physiologists. It focuses on the comparative responses of ‘‘leafless” and wellleafed peas to environmental and management conditions. The results reviewed will be of interest to scientists concerned with crop-environment-management interactions. xi
xii
PREFACE
As has become the norm for Advances in Agronomy, the subjects covered here are truly international, and the authors selected to review them come from different parts of the world. We sincerely thank these authors for their contributions, which will be of great value to the world’s crop and soil scientists and, ultimately, to the farmers on whom we depend to produce our food and fiber.
N. C . BRADY
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY
VOLUME 34
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 34
ADVANCES IN PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA Hu Han and Shao Qiquan Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica, Beijing, People's Republic of China
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
................... Wheat ....................................................... Rice . .............................................. Corn .......................... Rubber Tree . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Culture Media . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. Anther Culture and Crop Improvement
111.
IV .
V. VI .
A. B. C. D. E. Some Fundamental Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Androgenesis of Gramineous Species in Anther Culture B. Albinism of Pollen Culture-Derived Plants ................................ C. Genetics and Cytology of Progenies of Regenerated Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Protoplast Isolation, Culture, an A. Protoplast Isolation . . . . . . . B. Protoplast Culture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. 'Genetic Manipulation . . . . . . . . . . Selection of Mutants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Miscellaneous: In V i m Propagation through Plant Tissue Culture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Tissue Culture of Drug-Producing Plants.. ................................ B. In Virro Propagation by Plant Tissue Culture . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................
1
2 2 2 4 4
5 5 5
6 6
I I 8 8 9 10 10 10 11
1. INTRODUCTION Plant cell and tissue culture is an old as well as a new area of research in biological sciences in China. It is old because investigations in this field were initiated several decades ago. It is new because extensive research has been carried out and much progress has been made during the last decade, especially in the last few years. In the past foreign scientists were not aware of the research work done in China. As a result of the Sino-Australian Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture held in May of 1978 in Beijing and the participation of Chinese scientists in international meetings in recent years, this situation has gradually improved. 1
Copyright 0 1981 by Academic Ress, Inc. All rights of repduction in any form ~ ~ S E N U I . ISBN 0-12-ooO734-7
2
HU HAN AND SHAO QIQUAN
II. ANTHER CULTURE AND CROP IMPROVEMENT During the last ten years, much progress has been made in plant anther culture, including development of media, standardization of culture conditions, and determination of the response of genotypes to anther culture. In more than a dozen species, pollen culture-derived plants were first obtained by Chinese scientists (Table I). Emphasis has been placed on using anther culture techniques in crop plant improvement. A. W H E A T
Plants regenerated from anther culture have been more easily obtained from materials of hybrid origin than from pure varieties, and significant differences in plant regeneration frequency have been noted among various hybrid combinations. It is now possible to generate plants through pollen culture of winter and spring wheat varieties as well as their hybrid combinations. Using materials with high induction frequency of callus, several dozen green plantlets were regenerated under appropriate conditions from 100 inoculated anthers. Gangsu Academy of Agricultural Sciences is now capable of producing up to 600 pollen-derived and colchicine-doubled plants of wheat within a year. B . RICE
The induction frequency of rice plants regenerated through anther culture has markedly improved in recent years. For example, Zhang (1980) has been able to obtain 5106 clumps of green seedlings from 125 combinations of Oryza sutivu subspecies japonica intervarietal crosses and of indica -japonica intersubspecific crosses, resulting in thousands of pedigree lines with stable characteristics available for selection and evaluation in 1 year. Thus anther culture can now be used as a tool in applied plant breeding programs. Up to now several rice varieties developed through anther culture techniques in rice have been released for commercial production. Hua Yu No. 1, developed cooperatively by the Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica and the Institute of Rice Research, Tianjing, is characterized as high yielding (about 7500 kg/ha), resistant to bacterial leaf blight, and widely adaptable, and has been grown in suburbs of Tianjing and Beijing covering an area of thousands of hectares. Chen Ying et al. (1980b) were able to isolate microspores of rice using a float-
PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
3
Table I Species in Which Regenerated Plant Was First Obtained in China Species
Year"
References
Wheat (Triticum aesrivum)
1971
Triticale (Triticale) Wheat-wheat grass hybrid (Triticum aestivum X Agropyron glaucum) Maize (Zea mays L.) Boom corn (Sorghum vulgare) soybean (Glycine max) Alfalfa (Medicago denticulata) Rubber tree (Hevea brasiliensis) Poplar (Populus nigra L.) Pepper (Capsicum annum L.) Brassica pekinesis Chinese cabbage (Brassica chinesis) Sugar beet ( 2 n =4x=36) (Beta vulgaris L.)
1971
Ouyang et al. (1973) Wang et al. (1973) Chu ef al. (1973) Sun et al. (1973)
1973
Wang et al. (1975a,b)
1975
Ku et al. (1975)
1978
Zhao (1978)
1980
Yin et al. (1980)
1979
Xu (1 979)
1977
Chen et al. (1978)
1974
Wang et al. (1975a,b)
1971
Wang et al. (1973)
1973 1977
Teng and Kuo (1977) Chung et al. (1977)
1973
1979
Breeding Lab. Heilingchiang Sugarbeet Institute (1973) Shao (1979)
1979
Chen et al. (1980~)
I979
Sun (1979)
1978
He Ze Chinese Medicine Laboratory ( 1978)
Sugar beet (2n=2x=18) (Beta vulgare) Sweet orange (Citrus microcarpa) Flax (Linum usitatissimum) Rehmannia glurinoso
"Indicates the year the plants were obtained.
ing culture method-subjected pollen grains liberating continuously from dehiscing anthers-and obtained many calli and green plantlets. More recently green seedlings were directly induced from pollen grains on media without phytohormones.
4
HU HAN AND SHAO QIQUAN
C. CORN
It is valuable and beneficial to develop corn inbred lines through anther culture. Much investment of effort has gone into anther culture investigations of corn inbred lines in China. Different starting materials have been used, resulting in 25 inbred lines obtained by 14 institutes and universities in the past 2 years. Meanwhile a test crossing of some inbred lines is under way. Uniform canopy structure was demonstrated in these inbred lines. The comparison of corn inbred lines and the parent varieties “525” and “Gui No. 622” for plant height, ear length, 100 grain seed weight, and seed weight per ear revealed that the coefficient of variation was much lower in the pollen-derived inbred lines (Chen et al., 1979a). For example, a corn inbred line, Qunhua No. 105, has recently been produced from hybrid corn Qundan No. 105 through anther culture (Wu er al., 1980). Results of the test cross with this line showed that of the ten hybrid combinations tested, nine (90%) were superior than the control. Therefore, Qunhua No. 105 is a promising corn inbred line. Using corn varieties“Ba Tang Bai” and “Qundan No. 105” as parental materials, Cao (personal communication) and Wu and Zhong (1980) have been able to obtain maize cell clones through anther culture techniques in recent years. Gu (personal communication) and Cao (personal communication) have subcultured the cell clones derived from “Ba Tang Bai” every 4 weeks, and now these clones have gone through 30 generations of subculturing. The clones can be grouped into four types according to the degree of their totipotency. The No. 1 clone has intensive capacity of differentiation and regeneration, and green plantlets have been readily regenerated from it. Cytological studies of 427 cells of No. 1 clone and of 645 root tip cells of 35 plants regenerated from No. 1 clone revealed that 89.7% of the former and 87.4% of the latter were haploids. This type of cell clone, which has such high regeneration capacity and genetic stability, is a rare material in plant tissue culture. D. RUBBERTREE
Plants of rubber tree (Hevea brasiliensis) were regenerated in 1977 from anthers cultured in vitro (Chen, 1978). In the last 2 years Chen et al. (1979b) have studied the relationship between callusing anthers and the formation of pollen embryoids of Hevea brasiliensis. They found that after 20-30 days of culture 80% cells at metaphase of mitotic division were observed to be diploids (2n = 36), while after 50 days of inoculation only 10% were diploids and 69% were haploids. The result shows that after 50 days of culture the callus derived from
PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
5
anther walls was degenerating, whereas the haploid tissue of microspore derivation was dividing vigorously. In order to obtain haploid embryoids or calli it is appropriate to transfer callusing anthers to differentiation medium after 50 days of inoculation. A total of 238 cells from 46 embryoids were observed at mitotic metaphase. Of these, 4% had 9 chromosomes, 80% had 18 chromosomes, 15% had 27 chromosomes, and 1% had 32, 36, or 45 chromosomes. The preponderance of haploids originating from embryoids was demonstrated. Root tips of 18 plantlets were also analyzed cytogenetically and similar results were obtained (Chen et a f . , 1979b). E. CULTURE MEDIA
Several culture media developed first by Chinese scientists are now widely used within the country as well as abroad. For example, the potato medium (First Group, 1976; Ouyang e t a l . , 1977; Chuang e t a l . , 1978), which contains 10-30% potato extracts, works as well or even better than the Miller’s and MS’s media. The use of potato extract as a medium component has greatly improved callus induction. N6 is another efficient medium developed by Chu et al. (1975) in which ammonium salts in optimum concentration are added along with nitrate salts. The frequency of anther callus induction on N6 medium is higher than that on Miller’s and MS media. It was as high as 16% (even 50% in some cases) for intervarietal hybrids of rice.
Ill. SOME FUNDAMENTAL PROBLEMS A. ANDROGENESIS OF GRAMINEOUS SPECIES IN ANTHER CULTURE
The processes of androgenesis during anther culture, particularly of gramineous species such as wheat, triticale, rye, barley, rice, and corn, were studied in the last few years. In addition to A and B pathways, others (such as C, D, and E pathways) were discovered (Sun, 1978). It is obvious that the abnormal mechanisms occur in early stages of pollen grain development during anther culture of wheat under different incubation conditions, particularly at low temperature (Tseng and Ouyang, 1980). Results obtained are useful in establishing a scientific basis not only for improving the frequency of callus induction and plant regeneration, but also for the elucidation of the causes of spontaneous chromosome doubling and chromosome aberrations in some plants, as well as for understanding the mechanisms of microspore differentiation.
6
HU HAN AND SHAO QIQUAN
B. ALBINISM OF POLLEN CULTURE-DERIVED PLANTS
In gramineous species, more than one-third of the plantlets regenerated from anther culture are albinos. For the effective use of anther culture in haploid breeding it is important to discover the causes of albinism and seek remedies to overcome this problem. Systematic studies of this problem should also contribute to the understanding of the genetics, physiology, and cytology of chloroplast development. Systematic investigations on the occurrence of albino plantlets in rice revealed that the viability of the developing plastid in chloroplast was the direct cause of albinism. A barrier to the nucleic acid translation system of the proteins needed for the development of a plastic lamellar system (a barrier to gene expression) is perhaps present (Wang et al., 1978; Liang et al., 1978). Recently components of soluble protein and ribosomal RNA from green and albino pollen culture-derived plantlets of rice have been analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. It was found that little or no band 3 (Fraction I protein), 23 S RNA, and 16 S RNA are present in albino plantlets (Sun et al., 1978). Together with the evidence obtained from other investigations, it was suggested that the albinism is caused by the impairment function of DNA.
c. GENETICSA N D CYTOLOGY OF PROGENIES OF REGENERATED PLANTS 1 . Genetic Stability
Genetic stability of plants derived from tissue and anther culture has been investigated by numerous scientists in China as well as abroad. These investigations revealed that the progenies of tissue and anther culture-derived plants of crop species are highly stable. Anther and tissue culture-derived progenies of rice, tobacco, and wheat were compared with their parental varieties by several research groups. The coefficient of variation (CV) values for several agronomically important traits were similar in two groups or sometimes small in pollen culture-derived progenies. Ninety percent of the diploid lines obtained from doubled haploids of anther culture derivation were homozygous, whereas only 10% showed segregation (Hu et al., 1980). Cytological examination of root tip chromosome number of 54 H I (regenerated) plants of wheat showed that about 90% of the regenerated plants were either haploids or homozygous diploids. The analysis of PMCs of 72 H I wheat plants (Hu et al., 1980) showed that 87.5% of these regenerated plants were either 3x or 6x. Similar results were obtained from examination of somatic chromosome numbers of field-grown, pollen culture-derived plants of wheat. Over 80% were
PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
7
either haploids (3x) or homozygous diploids (6x). These observations favor the use of the anther culture technique in applied plant breeding programs.
2 . Variation
,
Cytological investigations of H plants revealed that approximately 10% have deviant chromosome numbers, such as monosomics, nullisomics, aneupolyhaploids, pentaploids, and octoploids. These plants with variant chromosome numbers have proved useful in chromosome and genome engineering. The mechanisms underlying the origin of these variant plants have been discussed by D’Amato (1978). Variability of chromosome number of regenerated wheat plants has also been analyzed in our lab. Mixoploids and cells showing tripolar mitosis, which could result in heteroploids and aneuploids, were observed in wheat root-tip and calk dicentric chromosomes and chromosome fragments in pollen calli, suggesting that in development of anthers cultured in vitro, chromosomevariation may occur (Hu et al., 1980). Moreover, in early stages of pollen callus formation in virro, nuclear asynchronous divisions, fusion of different nuclei, and endomitosis were occasionally observed. These abnormalities in mitosis may lead to the variation in the chromosome number of plants regenerated from anther culture. From the foregoing, we consider that either the stability or the variability of the chromosome numbers of progenies of plants derived through anther culture is useful in crop improvement as well as in genetic studies.
IV. PROTOPLAST ISOLATION, CULTURE, AND GENETIC MANIPULATION A. PROTOPLAST ISOLATION
Studies on protoplast isolation were initiated in China in 1973. Mesophyll cells and cells from cultured calli, especially of cereal crops, have been often used. In order to overcome the difficulty of inducing differentiation in long-term subcultures, stem tips of hybrid rice seedlings were cut and incubated, and spherical protoplasts were then released (Guangdong Institute of Botany, 1978). Potrykus et al. (1977) also reported that differentiation is more easily induced in corn protoplasts obtained in this manner than those from calli cultured for a long time. A complex enzyme extracted from Trichoderma viride EA3-867used in protoplast isolation has been as effective as cellulase Onozuka R-10made in Japan (Hsu, 1978).
8
HU HAN AND SHAO QIQUAN
B. PROTOPLAST CULTURE
Plants have been regenerated successfully from protoplasts of tobacco, petunia, dnd carrot (Li et al., 1978a,b; Wu et al., 1977). Efforts to generate plants from protoplasts derived from cereals, legumes, and other species have been less successful (Yen and Li, 1979; Li et al., 1978a,b; Cytology Lab., 1977; Tsai et al., 1978). Recently a two-layer culture method, i.e., liquid in the upper layer and solids in the lower, has been developed, and plants have been regenerated from mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana rustica x N . alata (Hsia et al., 1979). Moreover, typical division of cells regenerated from wheat and barley mesophyll protoplasts has been observed at about 0.1% frequency (Li, 1979a,b). Of the nutrients explored, vitamin and other organic compounds are very important to protoplast division, while glucose and low levels of other sugars have favorable effects on wheat protoplast culture. When protoplasts were cultured under lower osmotic conditions, e.g., 0.4 M glucose, budding, bulbing, and anuclear subprotoplasts were generated probably due to rapid swelling of protoplasts and incomplete cell wall formation (502 Group, 1974). More recently somatic hybrid plants have been regenerated through fusion of protoplasts from somatic cells of N . tabacum and those of N . rustica. Examination of chromosome number and identification of peroxidase isoenzymes revealed that the plants are of somatic hybrid origin (Wang et al., 1981; Gong et al., personal communication). C . GENETICMANIPULATION
Homologous fusion of mesophyll protoplasts of wheat, corn, and other species, and heterologous fusion of those of wheat and Viciafaba by adding NaN03 to culture medium were first obtained at a low frequency of approximately 4% (Sun, personal communication). Using Kao’s fusion technique with high pH, calcium ion solution, and PEG,interspecific fusion was induced between protoplasts from wheat yellowing leaves and those from green leaves of petunia. The fusion occurred at a frequency of 25%, and 10% of the fusion bodies were of heterologous origin. Nuclear staining confirmed that the fusion bodies were heterokaryons. Some of the fused protoplasts regenerated cell wall, underwent cell division, and developed into small calli after being transferred to fresh medium, but they could not be identified as hybrids due to lack of a selection system. In chloroplast transplantation research, chloroplasts of wheat and spinach were introduced into carrot callus protoplasts with PEG used as inducing agent and
PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
9
successful transfers occurred at a frequency of 2-5% (C. Ma, personal communication). The characteristics of rape mosaic virus (YMV 15) were studied by introducing the virus into tobacco (N. tubacum var. Sumsan) mesophyll protoplasts. It was found that YMVl5 is serologically related to TMV, but the infection pathway is different. When polyomithine was added, 46-96% of tobacco protoplasts were infected by YMVI5, and each infected protoplast contained (1-3) X 105 virus particles (Tian et al., 1977). Crown gall cell is useful in plant genetic engineering. In general plant tumor cells induced by different Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains cannot grow on medium containing o-lactose or D-galactose as the sole carbon source, since both sugars are toxic to these tumor cells. However, Li Xiang Hui and Schieder ( 1981) recently discovered that tobacco tumor cells induced by A . tumefaciens strain B6S3 are different from other tumor cells and can grow on medium supplemented with D-lactose as the sole carbon source. This characteristic might provide a selective system for protoplast fusion and transformation experiments. Somatic hybrids have been obtained through fusion of protoplasts from B6S3 tobacco tumor cells and those from mesophyll of N. tubacum cv. Xanthi. The hybrid characteristics were demonstrated by the presence of octopine identified in the hybrid cells. It now appears possible to transfer T:DNA segments of the tumor cells to normal ones through protoplast fusion (X. H. Li, personal communication).
V. SELECTION OF MUTANTS Cell cultures are also used as means of obtaining variant strains. Investigations on selection of mutants at plant cell levels got under way recently in China. This appears to be a promising field of research. A chlorophyll mutant of rice (HY 101) was obtained that segregated at a frequency of 19% from an H2strain. The anther callus of variety No. 8126 was treated with ethyl methane sulfonate (EMS) at an early stage in culture (Hu er al., 1981) and the aforementioned H 2 strain was obtained from this callus. The mutant plants are yellowish-green in color and stable in characteristics. The reciprocal F, s obtained from crosses between the mutant and normal rice plants were green. The F2population segregated in a 3 : 1 ratio of green yellowish-green plants. Green and yellowish-green plantlets appeared at a ratio of 1 : 1 in a plant population obtained from hybrids through anther culture. Chen et al. (1980a) were able to obtain a BUdR-resistant mutant from soybean cell line SB-1 which was irradiated by 1000-R y rays, and cultured for 20 days on y-rayed B5 medium. It is believed that irradiation might trigger chemical changes in culture medium in addition to the direct effects on the treated cells.
10
HU HAN AND SHAO QIQUAN
Thus the mutation rates may be increased by exposing the calli to the direct and indirect irradiations. Ho et al. (1980) were able to select a lysine analog (0L)-resistant tobacco callus mutant at a low frequency (ca. lo-') by first subculturing tobacco (N. tubacum L. cv. Gexin No. 5 ) callus through three successive passages on a medium containing lg/ 1 L-Coxalysine (OL), an inhibitor of callus growth, then culturing the treated tissue through 6 passages on a medium without the selective agent OL, and finally treating the callus cultures with 2% EMS. The resultant mutant is 10 times less sensitive to OL than the parent line, and in general it was stable through 12 passages of subcultures in the absence of the selective agent. It was found that the lysine analog-resistant tobacco callus mutant has accumulated twice the normal level of lysine content, while a different pattern of peroxidase isoenzyme spectrum has been discovered electrophoretically in the mutant as compared with that of parent lines.
VI. MISCELLANEOUS: IN VITRO PROPAGATION THROUGH PLANT TISSUE CULTURE A number of economically important plants, including seaweeds, have been propagated through tissue culture in China. In addition, many drug-producing plants have also been cloned in vitro. A. TISSUE CULTURE OF DRUG-PRODUCING PLANTS
Peking Pharmaceutical Institute was able to cultivate ginseng callus proliferated from young stems and roots. It was found that the total ginseng saponins was the same as that of the garden ginseng. For example, the ginseng callus contains 4% (dry weight) saponins, whereas the 6-year-old garden ginseng contained 3% (dry weight) of this chemical. Zheng and Liang (1976) were able to cultivate the famous herb Panax noroginseng, and chemical analysis showed that the herb contained 10.25% (dry weight) of gross saponin and sapogenin, in contrast to the tuberous roots of the natural plants, which contain 6.06% (dry weight) of the said drugs only. It has been found that callus tissue of Seopolia ocutagula plant produced 0.55% (dry weight) of Hyocyamine and seopolamine, whereas fieldgrown plants had only 0.139% of these drugs (Zheng and Liang, 1977). B. In Vitro PROPAGATION BY PLANTTISSUE CULTURE
Since 1975, Wang et al. (1975a,b; Wang and Chang, 1978a,b) have successfully regenerated seedlings from embryo (diploid 2n = 18) and endosperm
PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
11
callus (triploid 3 n = 27) of Citrus sinensis. The diploid plantlets have been easily induced either from bud primordia or through embryoid formation. The triploid seedlings were regenerated through embryogenesis of endosperm calli, which had been induced at the cell stage. A successful system for obtaining “virus-free’’ seed potato has been worked out by a number of institutions. Virus-free potato seed is now successfully produced and planted in about 20 provinces. The yield has increased significantly through the use of ‘‘virus-free’’ seed (unpublished results). Clones of sugarcane have been obtained through tissue culture in all canegrowing provinces (unpublished results). Meristem of stem apex or lateral buds as well as young leaves are used as initial culture materials for the induction of callus from which young seedlings are regenerated. The yield of canes raised through “test-tube” methods is the same as that of the control, but the tissue culture-obtained clones are more variable as some have more tillers and others have smaller stems. I n vitro fertilization of corn ovules was first achieved in 1977 with a simplified medium prepared mainly from natural extracts of potato (Shao et al., 1977). Fourteen seeds were produced in 1978, and the portion of seed set was 0.42%. Hybrid kernels matured in about 20-22 days after pollination and germinated in a test tube. After transferring to pots, only two plants survived. One of them had clear purple markers on leaves and stem. The chromosome number of root cells was 20. These results indicated that plants produced from test-tube fertilization were intervarietal hybrids but not parthenogenetic haploids (Jiang et al., 1979). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors wish to thank H. W.Li for his help in preparing the manuscript and R. B. Tan for her technical assistance.
REFERENCES D’Amato, F. 1978. In “Frontiers of Plant Tissue Culture” (T. A. Thorpe ed.), pp. 287-295. University of Calgary Offset Printing Office, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. Breeding Laboratory, Heilungchiang Sugarbeet Institute. 1973. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Anther Culture,” pp. 304-305. Science Pxess, Peking. Chen, C. H., Chen, F. T., Chien, C. F., Wang, C. H., Chang, S. J., Hsu, H. E., Ou,H. H., Ho, Y.T., and Lu, T. M. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” pp. 11-22, Science Press, Peking. Chen, L., Xu, Z., Yin, G.C. Zhu, Z. Y., and Bi, F. Y. 1979a. Acra Genet. Sin. 6 , 421-426. Chen, Z. H., Qian, C. F., Qin, M., W a g , C. H.,SUO,C. J . , Xiao, Y.L., and Hsu, H. 1979b. In “Annual Report of the Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica,” pp. 88-90. Chen, S. L., Tian, W. Z . , and Zhang, G.H. 1980a. In “Annual Report of the Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica,” pp. 100-102. Chen, Y., Wang, R. F., Tian, W. Z., Zuo, Q. X., Zheng, S. W. Lu, D. Y., and Zhang, G.H. 1980b. Acta Genet. Sin. 7. 46-54.
12
HU HAN AND SHAO QIQUAN
Chen, Z. G., Wang, M. Q., and Liao, H. H. 1980c. Acta Genet. Sin. 7, 189-191. Cheng, K . C., and Liang, C. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” pp. 469-479. Science Press, Peking. Chu, C. C., Wang, C. C., Sun, C. S . , Hsii, C., Yin, K. C., Chu, C. Y., and Bi, F. Y. 1975. Sci. Sin. 18, 659-668. Chu, Z. C., Wang, C. C., Sun, C. S . , Chien, N. F . , Yin, K.C., and Hsii, C. 1973. Acra Bot. Sin. 15, 1-11.
Chuang, C. C., Ouyang, T. W.,Chia, H., Chou, S. M., and Ching, C. K. 1978. In “Proceedingsof Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” pp. 51-56. Science Press, Peking. Chung, C. H., Jen, Y. Y., and Tai, W. K. 1977. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Anther Culture’’ (H. Hu, ed.), pp. 200-201. Science Press, Peking. Cytology Lab., Dept. Biology, Lanchow Univ. 1977. Acta Genet. Sin. 4, 242-247. 1st Group, 3rd Lab., Institute of Genetics. 1976. Acta Gener. Sin. 3, 25-31. 502 Research Group, Institute of Genetics. 1974. Acta Gener. Sin. 1, 59. Guangdong Institute of Botany. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Cell Culture and Somatic Hybridization,” p. 155. Lanzhou Univ., Langzhou. He Ze Chinese Medicine Lab., Shangton Province. 1978. Plant Mag. No. 4, p. 8. Ho, C. P., Xu, Z. Y., Xu, S. P., and Loo, S. W. 1980. Acra Phytophysiol. Sin. 6, 213-219. Hsia, C. A. er al. 1979. Int. Protoplasr Symp., 5th. Szeged. (Abstr.). Hsu, C. Y. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” p. 285. Science Press, Peking. Hu, H., Hsi, T. Y., and Chia, S. E. 1978. Acra Genet. Sin. 5 ( I ) , 23-30. Hu, H., Xi, Z. Y., Zhuang, J. J., Ouyang, J. W., Hao, S. He, M. Y., Xu, Z. Y., and Zou, M. Q. 1980. Sci. Sin. 23, 905-912. Hu, Z., Pang, L. P., and Cai, Y. H. 1981. Acta Genet. Sin. (in preparation). Jiang, X. C., Nui, D. S., and Shao, Q. Q. 1979. Acta Gener. Sin. 6, 339-342. Ku, M.K.,Cheng, W. C., Huang, C. F., Huang, C. H., Kuo, L. C., Kuan, Y. L., and An, H.P. 1975. Acra Genet. Sin. 2, 138-143. Li, W. A., Wang, K. Y., and Tang, T. 1978a. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” p. 325. Science Press, Peking. Li, W. P., Sun, Y. J., and Li, H. H. 1978b. Acfa Genet. Sin. 5 , 57-60. Li, X. H. 1979. Int. Protoplast Symp., 5th, Szeged pp. 261-267. (Abstr.). Li, X. H., and Schieder, 0. 1981. Plant Sci. Lett. (in preparation). Li, X. H., and Yen, C. S. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” p. 361, Science Press, Peking. Liang, C. C., Chou, Y. H.,and Chen, W. M. 1978. In “Proceedings Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,’’ pp. 161-166. Science Press, Peking. Ouyang, T. W., Hu, H., Chuang, C. T., and Tseng, C. C. 1973. Sci. Sin. 16, 79-95. Ouyang, T. W., Chuang, C. C., Chia, H.,Chou, S. M., and Ching, C. K. 1977. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Anther Culture” (H. Hu,.ed.), pp. 58-64. Science Press, Peking. Potrykus, I., Harms, C. T., and Thomas, H. 1977. Mol. Gen. Genet. 156, 347. Qin, M., Qian, C. F., Wang, C. H., Chen, Z. H.,and Xiao, Y. L. 1979. In “Annual Report of the Institute of Genetics, Academia Sinica,” pp. 85-87. Shao, C. C., Chiang, H. T., Li, C. K., and Chen. Y. C. 1977. Acta Genet. Sin. 4, 329-332. Shao, M . W. 1979. Zhongguo Tiancai 1, 27-30. Sun, C. S. 1973. Acta BOI. Sin. 15, 163-173. Sun, C. S. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” pp. 117-124. Science Press, Peking. Sun, C. S., Wu, S. C., Wang, C. C., and Chu, C. C. 1978. In “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” p. 248. Science Press, Peking.
PLANT CELL AND TISSUE CULTURE IN CHINA
13
Sun, H. T. 1979. Kexue Tongbao 24, 948-950. Teng, L. P., and Kuo, Y. H. 1977. I n “Proceedings of Symposium on Anther Culture” (H. Hu, ed.), pp. 198-199. Tian, B. e t a / . 1977. Acra Microbiol. Sin. 17, 306-310. Tsai, C. K., Chien, Y. C., Chou, Y. L., and Wu, S. H. 1978. I n “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” p. 317. Science Press, Peking. Tseng, C. C., and Ouyang, 2. W. 1980. Acta Genet. Sin. 7, 165-172. Wang, C. C., Chu, C. C., Sun, C. S . Wu, S. H . , Yin, K. C., and Hsii, C. 1973. Sci. Sin. 16, 2 18-222. Wang, C. C., Chu, C. C., and Sun, C. S. 1975a. Acra Bot. Sin. 17, 56-59. Wang, C. C., Chu, C. C., Sun, C. S . , Hsii, C., Yin, K. C.. and Bi, F. Y. 1975b.Acta Gener. Sin. 2, 72-80. Wang, C. C., Sun, C. S . , Chu. C. C., and Wu, S. C. 1978. I n “Proceedings of Symposium on Plant Tissue Culture,” pp. 149-160. Science Press, Peking. Wang, P. T., Chen, J. Y.,Zhao, S. M.,and Xu, J. X. 1981. Kexue Tongbao 26, 373-375. Wang, T. Y., and Chang, C. J . 1975. Acta Bot. Sin. 17, 149-152. Wang, T. Y., and Chang, C. J . 1978a. Acta Gener. Sin. 5, 133-137. Wang, T. Y., and Chang. C. J. 1978b. Sci. Sin. 16, 823-827. Wang, Y . Y., Sun, C. S . , Wang, C. C., and Chien, N . F. 1973. Sci. Sin. 16, 147-151. Wu, J . L., and Zhong, Q. L. 1980. Acta Phyrophysiol. Sin. 6, 221-224. Wu, J . L., Zhong, Q. L., Nong, F. H., and Zhong, T. M. 1980. Hereditas (Beijing) 2, 23-26. Wu, S. C., Lin, C. P., Ma, C., Wang, Y . S., Chao, Y. C., and Liu, H. C. 1977. Acta Genet. Sin. 4, 462-464. Xu, S. 1979. Plant M a g . No. 6 , 5. Yen, C. S., and Li, X. H. 1979. Heredifas (Beijing) No. 5, p. 25. Yin, G. C., Li, X . Z., Xu, 2. C., Li. Z. Z., and Bi, F. Y. 1980. Kexue Tongbao. 25 ( I t ) , 976. Zhang, 2. H. 1980. I n “Proceedings of Symposium on Celebrating the 20th Anniversary of IRFU” (in preparation). Zhao, W. B. 1978. Acta Genet. Sin. 5, 337-338. Zheng, G. Z., and Liang, Z. 1976. Acra BOI. Sin. 18, 163-169. Zheng, G. Z., and Liang, 2. 1977. Acra Bot. Sin. 19, 210-215.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY. VOL. 34
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX? Thomas A. LaRue and Thomas G. Patterson Boyce Thompson Institute for Plant Research, Ithaca, New York
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... A. The Importance of Obtaining Reliable Es ........................... B. The Energy Cost of C. Published Estimates of Nitrogen Fixation by Legume Crops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Methods of Estimating Fixation by Crops ........................... A. Nitrogen Accumulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... B. Difference Methods ............................... C. Isotopic Methods . . ............................... D. Acetylene Reduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Other Methods of C 111. Estimates for Major Crops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Forages . . . . . . . . . . . ........ B. Seed Legumes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Evaluation of Studies.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . for Future Research ..........................
........................................................
15 15
18 19
20 23
27 27 30 34 34 35 36
1. INTRODUCTION A . THEIMPORTANCEOF OBTAINING RELIABLE ESTIMATES
In the coming decades our increasing world population and the growing needs for higher quality food will place severe demands on agriculture. During this time the cost of nitrogen fertilizer will continue to rise with the price of energy. The processes of decreasing fertility, soil erosion and desertification will force agriculture onto land presently marginal and will boost efforts to reclaim land. The role of legumes in agriculture is certain to increase in importance. The pulses are sources of good-quality protein. The forages have a long-documented history of supporting livestock on poor soil. Both these factors are attributed in 15
Copyright 0 1981 by Academic Ress. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-000734-7
16
THOMAS A. LARUE AND THOMAS G. PATTERSON
part to the ability of legumes, in symbiosis with rhizobia, to obtain nitrogen from the air. But how much nitrogen is obtained? The direction of research and the future management of legumes in agriculture will require accurate knowledge of the amounts fixed by crops in the field. If fixation is less than we now think, then we will not achieve the expected returns of N. If fixation is as high or higher than some reports say, we must search out the reason why some legume crops can deplete soil N. Recent work in plant physiology indicates that symbiotic fixation is not ‘‘free fertilizer”; the plant must provide energy in the form of photosynthate. Whether a legume crop “pays” for fixation with decreased yield is not yet determined. Legumes require more phosphate fertilizer than cereals, and many are more demanding of water. The cost of inoculant will not be negligible to cash-poor farmers in developing countries. Does the N fixed compensate for these inputs? Ultimately, plant breeders and agronomists will require accurate estimates of the amount of fixation, and of its cost, to determine whether increasing fixation is economically justified. B. THEENERGYCOSTOF SYMBIOTIC FIXATION VERSUS NITRATEUTILIZATION
Despite apparent differences, there is a fundamental similarity between symbiotic nitrogen fixation and the industrial production of nitrogen fertilizer. Energy is required for both methods, for thermodynamics requires this of all possible methods of fixation. Nitrogenase requires energy in the form of ATP and electrons. In addition, there are energy costs associated with nodule formation and maintenance, hydrogen loss, and incorporation and transport of newly fixed N. There must also be an energy cost for using soil nitrate, but comparisons of the two have been difficult to examine experimentally. Silsbury (1977, 1979) estimated the respiratory burden of subterranean clover grown under artificial light with nitrate or NZ.He calculated the growth coefficients (the fraction of net C02uptake in light associated with the synthesis of new dry matter) and found them constant over a 50-day period. For nodulated plants they were significantly higher (0.189) than for plants using nitrate (0.137). Nodulated plants used 810 mg C02 for the synthesis of 1 g dry weight, while nonnodulated plants used only 510 mg C02. Mahon (1977, 1978) calculated the energy cost of fixation after measuring root respiration and estimating N fixation by acetylene reduction. He compared the respiration of plants grown on N, with similar plants treated a few days previously with ammonium nitrate. It was assumed that the respiration due to
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
17
growth and maintenance was the same in both populations, and that the decreased root respiration in the treated plants was associated with decreased nitrogenase activity. Mahon obtained a value of about 6.7 g C/g N fixed with soybeans, cowpeas, Phaseolus, and peas. Ryle and his co-workers (1979) compared growth, photosynthesis, and shoot and root respiration of soybean, clover, and cowpea grown on N2 or nitrate under bright light. The plants provided with nitrate grew larger. Gross photosynthesis did nor differ in the two populations, nor did shoot respiration. The fixing plants had respiration rates about twice those of nitrate-grown plants. Expressed as a percentage of the gross photosynthesis, the root respiration of fixing and nonfixing plants was 22 versus 11 for soybean, 27 versus 14 for cowpea, and 34 versus 21 for clover; that is, for three species, plants fixing their nitrogen respire 11-13% more of their photosynthate. The relationship between root respiration and N fixed varied during plant growth. In all species it was highest (- 15 g C/g N) in young plants. Presumably, energy was used in forming nodules. In soybean and cowpea it dropped to a minimum of 3-5 g C/g N just before the nodules senesced during pod fill. The average cost was 6.3 g C/g N-a figure very close to Mahon’s. It is remarkable that the same respiratory cost, approximately 6.5 g C/g N, was determined by two investigators using five legumes. The close similarity amongst species suggests that it may not be easy to find significant differences in efficiency within a single species. There is good evidence that photosynthate supply to nodules is a major limitation to symbiotic fixation (Hardy and Havelka, 1975). The carbon cost of 6.5 g C/g N estimated by Ryle et al. and Mahon suggests that fixation of 1 kg NH, would cost 15-20 kg dry weight. In evaluating some of the extraordinarily high claims for hundreds of kilograms of N per hectare from symbiotic fixation, one should question whether the crop is capable of fixing the required carbon and translocating it to the root. Would a nodulated legume crop ever yield less than one obtaining all its N from soil? The common observation on soils very low in available N is that effective nodulation increases yield compared to uninoculated controls. In soils of very high fertility, the soil N suppresses nodulation and fixation, and yields are generally equal. The aforementioned experiments, however, indicate that on soils of intermediate fertility, the energy cost of nodule formation and fixation might lower the yield of the crop obtaining some of its N via the symbiosis, compared to an uninoculated control. Such a result was observed in a Brazilian soil in which soil N was not limiting to growth. With Phaseolus cultivars there was a positive correlation of nodule weight with plant N content but a negative correlation with grain production (Pessanha et al., 1972). This is what is expected if fixation requires more
18
THOMAS A . LARUE AND THOMAS G. PATTERSON
photosynthate than nitrate utilization. We did not find similar results elsewhere in the literature. It may be that the difference in energy cost between nitrate and N2 usage is not so great in the field as in lab experiments.
C. PUBLISHED ESTIMATES OF NITROGENFIXATION BY LEGUME CROPS
In reviews and texts there are many published tabulations of the amount of fixation by legume crops. Most are derived from a very few sources. Two favorites are publications by Erdman (1949) and Lyon and Bizzell(l933, 1934). The first was an extension pamphlet promoting inoculation, and containing data that were not substantiated by methodology. Erdman stated that his estimates had been calculated in most cases from controlled pot experiments which when magnified to an acre basis gave results higher than the actual figures. Unfortunately others citing his figures did not include his caveat. The study of Lyon and Bizzell, as we will see, did not approximate the field crop condition and probably overestimated fixation. Bums and Hardy (1975) averaged a great many published estimates to arrive at an average figure of 140 kg N fixed per year per hectare of arable land under legumes. Shortly thereafter, that figure was considered by a group of scientists attending a conference on nitrogen-fixing microbes. They concluded (Burris, 1978) that a realistic figure would be half the Bums-Hardy calculation. This reassessment, however, was apparently based as much on intuition as on new data. In the literature much of the work reported on estimating fixation cannot be extrapolated to field conditions. A very common procedure, especially when isotopic N is used, is to grow legumes in small pots, often in the greenhouse. The substrate is so unlike the soil and the conditions of plant growth so different from the field that the results cannot be used to calculate fixation by crops. Many experimenters, including those using field plots, give results only as milligrams N per plant or percentage N of the yield or percentage plant N derived from fixation. In the absence of information about yield per area or planting density, it is impossible to calculate the fixed N per hectare. The published results of fixation as a percentage of plant N may, however, serve in estimating a realistic figure for fixation in farm crops. It is a common observation that yields in experimental or demonstration plots are much higher than the average crop yields in the area. It is likely true that symbiotic fixation is also less on the farm. Nodule formation and function are depressed by a variety of environmental factors-water stress, flooding, herbicides, improper fertilizer placement, etc. It is unlikely that the percentage N from fixation will be higher on farms than on well-tended research plots. Therefore the percentage N fixed in
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
19
test plots might be used in calculating a realistic upper limit on fixation in agriculture.
II. METHODS OF ESTIMATING FIXATION BY CROPS A. NITROGEN ACCUMULATION
The standard procedure for nitrogen analysis is the Kjeldahl determination (Bremner, 1965). Its major advantages are simplicity and low expense. The simplest estimate of N fixation is by total N accumulation of the crop. This is based on the intuitive assumption that the crop derives all its N via symbiotic fixation. We can find no published evidence that this is ever the case under field conditions. The many estimates based on total plant N certainly overestimate fixation. Growth on low-fertility soils or on soils artificially impoverished in available N is no guarantee that all N is obtained by fixation. Kohl et al. (1980) decreased available N in a soil by the addition of 34 tonnesha of corn cobs. The nodulated soybean neverthelessobtained 47% of its plant N from this soil, and a nomodulated isoline yielded 2106 kg/ha of grain. These results demonstrate the ability of a legume to scavenge soil N. A closer approximation to N fixed may be achieved by analyzing changes in soil N as well as that removed in the crop. The frequently cited study by Lyon and Bizzel (1933, 1934) was such an approach. These workers placed a mixture of 60% silty clay loam and 40% sand in outdoor frames of unstated dimensions. Various crops were alternated or grown together for 10 years and the N in the crops was assayed at each harvest. The N in the top 28 cm of substrate was analyzed at the beginning and end of the trial, and the “apparent fixation of nitrogen” was calculated on an annual basis. There was an accumulation of soil N under clovers, alfalfa, and vetch, and a decrease with soybeans, peas, beans, barley, rye, and oats. The clovers had an apparent fixation averaging 166-200 kg N/ha. Alfalfa accumulated 296-330 kg N/ha. Soybeans, peas, and beans averaged 125, 57, and 70 kg N h a annually, respectively. Nonlegumes accreted 2 1-37 kg Nha. This study is considered a classic for documenting the advantage to topsoil N of proper forage-cereal rotations. However, its limitations are that the change in soil N has based on only two estimates 10 years apart and that only the top layer was analyzed. Legume roots may extend downwards 3 m (Weaver, 1926). The unaccountably high “apparent fixation” by nonlegumes suggests that there was appreciably mobilization of nutrients from below the sampled zone.
20
THOMAS A . LARUE AND THOMAS G . PATTERSON
Experiments on legumes growing on artificially impoverished soils are not uncommon in the literature. The substrate used by Lyon and Bizzell was an artificial one and for that reason the data they obtained should not be extrapolated to estimate fixation by farm crops. Long-Term Nitrogen Balance Studies Using Lysimeters
A lysimeter is an enclosed soil system in which the addition and removal of nutrients, water, and plant material can be controlled and measured. Although many designs have been described (Kohnke et al., 1940), the basic construction consists of a tank or box placed in the ground and filled with soil. Leachate from the soil in the tank is collected from the bottom of the lysimeter. Lysimeters have been used in long-term studies on nitrogen balance in crops under different management systems (Chapman et al., 1949). In addition, lysimeters can be used to compare and calibrate different techniques for estimating N fixation under controlled conditions (Williams et al., 1977). Several disadvantages are inherent in lysimeter studies. They are expensive to install because they require the excavation of large volumes of soil and must be constructed of materials resistant to corrosion. Due to their expense, the size and number of lysimeters, and thus the number of treatments and replications, is limited. In some lysimeter studies, long-term nitrogen balances have shown unaccounted losses of nitrogen (Collison et al., 1933). This is attributed to volatilization of N from the lysimeters (Chapman et al., 1949; Patwary and Raikavich, 1979), although this assumption has been challenged (Craswell and Martin, 1975a,b). B. DIFFERENCE METHODS
An adjusted measure of fixation by the nitrogen accumulation technique is obtained when the contribution of soil N to the total N of legumes is estimated. This correction for the contribution of soil N is obtained by growing a nonfixing plant in comparison with the N-fixing legume. Total N content of the nonfixing crop (derived solely from soil N) is subtracted from the total N content of the N-fixing legume. The difference between the values is assumed to be the quantity of N derived by N fixation. This procedure is often referred to as the “difference” method (Williams et al., 1977). Three versions of the difference method are commonly used. 1 . Comparison of a Legume with a Nonlegume Soil N contribution to a fixing legume is estimated by growing a nonlegume concurrently with the legume. Annual small grains such as wheat and oats have
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
21
been used (Rizk, 1966). In studies of forage legumes, however, perennial grass species are used. This is preferred in studying N fixation in grass-legume mixed pastures. Sprague (1936) used wheat as a control crop to estimate the soil N contribution. The wheat contained 38 kg N/ha and the vetch 149 kg N/ha. By subtraction, he estimated the net fixation of the vetch to be 111 kg N/ha. Using a nonlegume as a control in the difference method requires two major assumptions. First, the nitrogen contained in the nonlegume is assumed to arise solely from the soil N pool. Secondly, the legume and nonlegume will take up soil N in proportion to the amount available, and differences due to growth patterns and root morphology will not be significant. The validity of the second assumption is open to question. No evidence exists that shows the exploitation of soil N is equal between a legume and its nonlegume control. The fixation estimated will obviously depend on the arbitrary choice of nonlegume control. Wagner (1954) calculated that the N fixation of ladino clover was 165 kg/ha when orchard grass was used as a control or 189 kg/ha when tall fescue was the control. 2 . Comparison of a Legume with a Nonnodulating Legume Another approach to the difference method utilizes the existence of nonnodulating legume genotypes. Soybean genotypes with nonnodulating characters have been described (Williams and Lynch, 1954). The nonnodulation character is controlled by a single recessive gene, labeled rj, . This nonnodulating gene has been backcrossed to produce near-isogenic lines. The advantages of using nonnodulating lines as a control species are that the growth pattern, root morphology, and N uptake patterns are assumed to be nearly identical. However, the nodulated isoline may absorb more soil N than the nonnodulated isoline (Ruschel et al., 1979). This suggests a synergistic effect of fixed N on N derived from other sources. Weber (1966) used nonnodulating isolines of soybean to estimate N fixation under different levels of applied fertilizer nitrogen. By subtracting the N content of the nonnodulating isoline from that of the nodulated soybean, N fixation rates of 14.7-84 kg/ha were calculated. In soybeans, isolines are available for only a few cultivars. Unfortunately, near isogenic nonnodulating and nodulating cultivars are not yet available for other legume species. 3 . Comparison of Inoculated and llninoculated Legumes
Another difference method is a comparison of single cultivars grown on inoculated or uninoculated soil. A variation of this procedure uses separate plots inoculated with effective or ineffective strains of rhizobium (Nutman, 1973). In this situation, the identical variety is used for the control and treatment, with the
22
THOMAS A . LARUE AND THOMAS G. PATTERSON
only variable being the presence or absence of nodules (or effective and ineffective nodules). This method requires a soil free of native rhizobium species capable of establishing an effective symbiosis with the legume being studied. Bezdicek et al. (1978) compared inoculated and uninoculated soybeans under field conditions. Uninoculated soybeans accumulated 76 and 105 kg N/ha in the 2 years, while nodulated soybeans yielded 387 and 368 kg N/ha. By difference, the net fixation was calculated as 31 1 and 263 kg N/ha. In areas where legumes are routinely grown, soils lacking the appropriate rhizobium species may not be available. When using this technique, considerable care is required to prevent contamination of the uninoculated soils with rhizobium. For these reasons this procedure has limited application in the routine evaluation of N fixation. Using the difference method with nonnodulating legumes or uninoculated plots requires the assumption that the root structure and function are not altered by the presence of nodules. This assumption has yet to be proven experimentally. 4 . N Fertilizer Equivalence
In some studies, an indirect estimate of nitrogen contribution from a legume to a nonlegume is used to estimate N fixation. Forage legumes and grasses are often grown together in pasture systems. The legumes have been observed to stimulate the productivity of the grass species (Lyon and Bizzell, 1911). If the response of the grass in the mixed stand is compared to the response of the grass in a pure stand with different amounts of applied fertilizer N, then an estimate of the N contributed to the grass by the legume is obtained. This method has been used in the studies of pasture management systems. Cowling (1961) calculated the “indirect effect” of clover on grass as the amount of fertilizer N applied to a grass plot to give a yield equivalent to the grass component of a clover-grass mix. He found that the effect of clover on cocksfoot was equivalent to 117-134 kg fertilizer N/ha. Another variation of the nitrogen contribution technique is to estimate the value of a legume to a following crop. Green manure crops have often been used to increase soil N (Kroontje and Kehr, 1956; Kamprath et a l . , 1958; Sprague, 1936). The N added to the soil by the legume crop gives a yield in the successive crop that is compared to the response to different levels of added N fertilizer. Kroontje and Kehr (1956) estimated that vetch added the equivalent of 107 kg N/ha to the soil. This resulted in a significant increase in barley yields following the vetch crop. Similarly, Sprague (1936) estimated that a winter crop of vetch was equivalent to 671 kg NaNO,/ha. In comparing the response of follow crops, urea can be used as the nitrogen fertilizer (de Souza, 1969) because it contains no other nutritional element that might contribute an effect. A N fertilizer is subject to leaching and volatilization, whereas the decomposing forage crop releases N more slowly and efficiently to
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
23
the nonlegume crop. Therefore the “equivalents N ” is likely an overestimate of N fixation. The beneficial effects of legumes on nonlegumes are not a direct measure of N fixation. However, they do show the utility of green manures in adding N to the soil, and the cost of the fertilizer spared may serve as an indication of the economic value of N fixation. C. ISOTOPIC METHODS
The use of 15N isotopes for studying N uptake by plants was recently reviewed here (Hauck and Bremner, 1976). Very few of the articles reviewed related to the use of I5N for estimating fixation by legume crops. The technique is likely to become more common, however, because of the lowered cost of the isotope and improvements in methodology. These include relatively inexpensive mass spectrometers designed for low-mass compounds (e.g., Micromass) and increased precision by using double introduction and double collection. Because it is a direct method, fixation of I5N2 remains the method of choice for checking the validity of other estimates of fixation (Burris, 1972). The cost of I5N2 and the volumes that would be required to test replicate plant samples over a growing season preclude estimates based on that gas. However, the technique has been used to test assays based on other methods. The methods are essentially those developed by Burris and Wilson (1957; Bums, 1972). Typically, nodulated roots (Saito et al., 1980) or nodules (Hudd et al., 1980) are briefly incubated in a chamber with a gas phase enriched in 15N1. The fixation is stopped by the addition of strong acid, the tissue is analyzed for total N (Kjeldahl) and I5N by mass spectrometry (Smith et al., 1963) or emission spectrometry (LloydJones et al., 1977). The major limitation to mass spectrometer methods is the high cost involved for the instruments and the isotopes. The procedures are fraught with potential errors. Although the proper techniques are well documented (Bremner, 1965), it remains true that the method is demanding and requires skilled operators. When N gas is excited by a high-frequency oscillator, the wavelengths of emitted light depend on the isotope composition. Commercial emission spectrometers, less expensive than mass spectrometers, are available for measuring 15N. The instruments are not as precise as mass spectrometers. Their major advantages are that they require only small samples (10 p g N) and they are not so demanding of operators.
I . Methods Based on Isotope Dilution Nitrogen fixation can be estimated by isotope dilution. In this method the fixing crop and a nonfixing control are grown in soil to which I5N has been added
24
THOMAS A. LARUE AND THOMAS G . PATTERSON
as a small amount of labeled nitrate or ammonium (McAuliffe et al., 1958; Legg and Sloger, 1975). The N in the control plant should have the same 15Ncontent as the available soil N. The plant obtaining part of its N from the atmosphere will have less of the isotope. The percentage of total N from fixation is calculated as %N=( 1-
at. % 15N excess test crop at. % I5N excess control crop
) x 100
This technique involves the assumption that the isotope incorporated into soil N is equally available to both crops. Moreover, if the soil N is low, the nonfixing crop may grow less well than the test crop and thus not be a comparable control. Fried and co-workers (1975, 1977) proposed the “ A N value” modification. Adequate labeled fertilizer N can be added to the soil for the nonfixing control to promote growth. I5N in fertilizer N is added to soil for test plants if the effect of fertilizer N on fixation is required. The 15Ncontent of the plants is measured after harvest. For each crop and treatment, the “AN” value is determined. The A N value (Legg and Stanford, 1967) is an indication of how much of a nutrient is available to a crop and is expressed as AN = B ( l - y ) / y where B is the amount of fertilizer N added (kilograms N per hectare) and y is the proportion of N in plant derived from that added: excess 15N in plant = excess 15N in fertilizer
The fraction of legume N from fixation is calculated as Nitrogen fixed (kg/ha) = (AN test plant - A N nonfixing control) N in crop x excess 15N X N in fertilizer x excess I5N It should be possible to calculate for each crop and treatment the contribution made by soil, fertilizer, and symbiotic fixation. Procedural details and potential sources of error in these methods have been reviewed by Hauck and Bremner (1976) and Rennie et al. (1978).
3 . Methods Based on Natural Isotope Abundance There are very slight isotope effects during chemical or biological processes involving N compounds. Symbiotic fixation seems to favor a very slight increase of 15N. This can be determined by growing a plant on N-free nutrient so that all its N arises by fixation. The isotope discrimination of fixation for soybean has been calculated as 1.0038 (Bardin, 1977) and 1.0014 (Amarger et al., 1979) but also as 0.999 (Kohl and Shearer, 1980).
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
25
Denitrification produces N 2 lowered in 15N and the nitrate remaining in soil slightly enriched. The degree of enrichment is measured as parts per thousand difference from the l5NP4N ratio in a standard (usually atmospheric nitrogen) (Hauck and Bremner, 1976) 615N = (15NP4N) - (l5NP4N) atm (I5NP4N) atm where one 6
15N
unit equals 0.00037 at. %
looo
15N.
A plant obtaining all its N from soil (e.g., nonlegume or nonnodulated control) will have a slightly enriched I5N relative to the atmosphere. A plant obtaining N from symbiosis will have a lower I5N composition. The I5N enrichment is not uniform throughout the plant, although it is claimed that the seed content is representative of the whole soybean plant (Shearer et al., 1980). The percentage of N from fixation is calculated (Domenach et al., 1979): % N fixed = 100 x
(% 15N control - % I5N legume) % I5N control - (% 15N airlb)
where b is the isotope discrimination of fixation. An appealing advantage of this method of estimating fixation is that it does not necessitate the purchase of isotopic N to add to soil. The major disadvantage is that the enrichment may not be uniform in the soil (Rennie et al., 1976). Karamanos and Rennie (1980) found that the P 5 N dropped with depth in welldrained profiles but was constant to a depth of 5 m in upper slopes. Pedogenic processes produced marked differences in the 6I5N profile within short distances. These results extended and confirmed those of previous workers that there is an unpredictable lack of uniformity of enriched N in soils. The possible isotope discrimination due to symbiotic fixation may favor the fixation of I4N. If this is not included in the calculation, the level of fixation will appear to be higher than it is (Rennie et al., 1978). Experienced critics (Hauck and Bremner, 1976) view the technique based on natural abundance as giving only qualitative or semiquantitative information. However the standard errors of the procedure when applied to field-grown nodulating and nonnodulating soybeans compared favorably with the errors of estimation based on N difference (Kohl et al., 1980). D. ACETYLENE REDUCTION
Nitrogenase reduces acetylene to ethylene and, so far, it is the only biological agent reported to do so. Typically, freshly excised roots are incubated in a chamber with 1-20% C2H, for 30-120 min. A sample of the gas phase is then
26
THOMAS A . LARUE A N D THOMAS G . PATTERSON
removed and the ethylene produced is measured by gas chromatography. Innumerable variations of the method have been described (Hardy et al., 1973). The principal assumption in the method involves the ratio of acetylene reduced to nitrogen fixed. The reduction of nitrogen to ammonia uses six electrons, while the production of ethylene requires two. Therefore, the ratio 3 : 1 was originally assumed, i.e., a mole of ethylene was equivalent to % mole of N 2 reduced. It is now realized that the reaction of nitrogenase approximates N2 + 8 H+ + 8e ---t 2 NH,
+ H?
Protons and acetylene compete for electrons, and, with the amounts of GH, usually used, only small amounts of H2 may appear. In the intact nodule the hydrogen may be metabolized by hydrogenase in appropriate strains of rhizobia and therefore not be detected. There is no adequate method now for calibrating ethylene formation with nitrogen fixation, but it seems that the ratio is approximately 4 : 1 for legumes (Hardy et al., 1973). The acetylene reduction method has the advantages of sensitivity, speed, and economy. A detection limit of pmole C,H,/ml gas permits estimation of nitrogenase activity even when only a few nodules are forming. It is possible to measure 40-80 samples/operator-day. The operation of a gas chromatograph can be easily learned, and the analysis may be conducted by semiskilled staff. No expensive reagents are necessary. If sensitivity is not required, there are inexpensive alternatives to measuring ethylene (LaRue and Kurz, 1975). Because the plant is usually destroyed in the assay, acetylene reduction is a one-time estimate of fixation. The incubation must be done immediately after the root is harvested. There is a diurnal variation in fixation by many legumes (Sloger et al., 1975). Much plant-to-plant variability is observed, and the entire nodulated root may not be recovered from the soil. Therefore an estimate of fixation over a growing season by a crop requires a mathematical summation of many frequently obtained assays on replicate plots. E. OTHERMETHODSOF COMPARING FIXATION
Several indirect methods have been used for estimating the nitrogen fixing ability of a legume. These include indices of nodulation-number of nodules, fresh or dry weight of nodules, and leghemoglobin concentration in nodule or amount per plant. Within a single cultivar these may be closely related to nitrogen fixation and will continue to be useful in screening rhizobial strains or scoring the effects of environment on nodulation. We have seen no evidence, however, that these nodule-related characters can be used to calculate the amount
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
27
of fixation by crops. Nodules that are pink or red internally are only an indication, and not a proof, of nitrogen fixation (de Souza, 1969). The concentration of the ureides allantoic acid and allantoin in the shoot is positively correlated with the amount of fixation by soybeans grown in the greenhouse under defined conditions (McClure er al., 1980). This suggests that estimates of fixation might be made by assays, nondestructive to the plant, of N compounds in the shoot parts. Several laboratories are pursuing this topic. While there are indications that it may aid in the qualitative ranking of cultivars, the procedure seems unlikely to measure the amount fixed by a crop.
Ill. ESTIMATES FOR MAJOR CROPS
A. THE FORAGES
Most published estimates of fixation by forages assume that plant N arises only from N fixation. Excluding these, there remain very few estimates, most of which are based on long-term lysimeter studies (Table I). Except where noted, all studies used pure stands of legumes. Chapman et al. (1949) studied the nitrogen balance of vetch (Vicia villosa) and sweetclover (Melilotus alba) used as winter cover crops at Riverside, California, over a 10-year period. Only one lysimeter per treatment was used, due to their large size (3.04-m diameter) and small number (12). The legumes were grown in a winter rotation and incorporated into the soil prior to planting a summer crop of barley or sudan grass. Nitrogen fixation of the legumes was estimated by the increase in soil N due to the incorporation of the green manure into the soil. A 10-year average of N added to the soil gave an annual fixation rate of 140 kg N/ha for sweetclover and 184 kg N/ha for vetch. Estimates for alfalfa (Medicago sativa), white clover (Trifolium repens), red clover (Trifolium pratense), and Korean lespedeza (kspedeza stipulacea) came from an 1 1-year lysimeter study by Karraker et al. (1950) in Lexington, Kentucky. They studied the nitrogen balance in a continuous cropping system with forage legumes and Kentucky bluegrass (Poa prarensis). The lysimeters were 57 cm in diameter, and each treatment was replicated twice. Although the authors presented only the total N accumulation over the 1 1-year experiment, the presence of the Kentucky bluegrass control permits our calculation of the average annual N fixation by the difference method. Averages for each legume, minus the bluegrass control, are 212, 128, 154, and 193 kg N/ha for alfalfa, white clover, red clover, and Korean lespedesa, respectively. Jones et al. (1977) used a lysimeter-difference technique to estimate N fixa-
Table I Estimates of Nitrogen Firation by Forage Crops Contml species
Duration of experiment (years)
Location
~
16 II 6O
Geneva. NY Lexington, KY R m m o u n t , MN Lexington. KY Northern Ireland Beltsville, MD
Collison cr d.,1933 Karralicr cr al.. 1954 Heichel cr d.,I 9 8 1 Karraker cr ol.. 1950 Halliday and Pate, 1976 Wagner. 1954 Karraker er 01.. 1950 S p g u e . 1936 chapman cr al.. I949 Sprague. 1936 Phillip and Bennca. 1978 Joms er al.. 1977 Rizk. 1%2
165- 189
Lysimeter Lysimeter-differeme Isotope dilution-"A" Lysimeter-difference C& reduction Difference
154 I 7b 140 9b 21-183 207 62-235
Lysimter-difference Difference Lysrmeter Difference "A" value Lysimete-difference Difference
Winter wheat Soh chess Soh chess chicory
3 2
Lexington, KY New Brunswick. NJ Riverside, CA New Brunswick, NJ Hopland, CA Davis, CA Giza,E g y p
21'
Difference
Winter wheat
5
New Bmnswick. NJ
Sprague, 1936
641
Difference
Winter wheat
5
New Brunswick. NJ
Sprague. 1936
Difference Lysimeter Lysimeter-differencc
Winter wheat
5 10
Kentucky bluegrass
II
New Brunswick, NJ Riverside, CA Lexington. KY
Sprague. 1936 chapman e r a / . , 1949 K&cr ct d..1950
Alfalfa (Medicago sariva)
229-290 212 I48
White clover (Trifoliurn repms) Ladin0 clover (Trifoliurnrepens var. Ladino) Red clover (Medicago prmense) Sweet clover (Mclibrn a h ) Subclover (Trifoliurn subrerraneurn) Egyptian clover (Trifolium alexandrinurn) Alsike clover (Trifolium hybridurn) Crimson clover (Trifoliurn indica) Vetch (Vicia vilbsa) K o m kspedeza (kspedew sripulacca)
I28 258
aDuration given in months. *Winter crop rotation.
-
I lob
I84 193
Kentucky bluegrms Reed canarygrass Kentucky bluegrass
II
-
1
Orchard grass-call fescue
I
Kentucky bluegrass Winter wheat
-
-
II 5
10 5 7'
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
29
tion in subclover (Trifolium subterraneum L.) at Davis, California. Over a 3-year period, subclover fixed 261, 398, and 207 kg N/ha, as estimated by difference. The soft chess control (Bromus mollis L.) accumulated 37, 32, and 72 kg N/ha. Sprague (1936) evaluated a series of legumes for their usefulness as winter green manure crops in New Jersey. Over a 5-year period, winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), hairy vetch (Vicia villosa), crimson clover (Trifolium incarnatum), red clover, alsike clover (Trifolium hybridum), and sweet clover were planted in August following a corn crop. In April of the following year samples of the tops and roots (to a depth of 28 cm) were harvested in N analysis. The remainder of the crop was incorporated into the soil and the corn summer crop was planted. Over the 5-year period, the average fixation by difference was 17, 9, 21, 64, and 110 kg N/ha for red clover, sweet clover, alsike clover, crimson clover, and vetch. The relatively low rates of fixation are most likely due to the winter cropping system used in this study. Hairy vetch was found to be most suited to a winter green manure rotation. Sears et al. (1965) reported an extremely high rate of 406-681 kg N/ha for white clover in New Zealand (difference method-mixed grass control). These figures were obtained, however, in an artificially depleted soil system. The top 15 cm of soil was removed, and the remaining subsoil was mixed with additional subsoil and replaced. Thus the experimental system had an artificially lowered soil N level. Additionally, these rates may exceed estimates from other locations because the growing season was a full 12 months. A white clover perennial ryegrass lye i n Northern Ireland fixed N for 8 months (Halliday and Pate, 1976), but there was essentially no acetylene-reducing activity during November-February when the soil temperature averaged 4-5°C. Integration of the seasonal acetylene reduction profile indicated a fixation of 268 kg N/ha. Wagner ( 1 954) examined N fixation in ladino clover by the difference method at Beltsville, Maryland. Over a 2-year period, the clover averaged 165-189 kg N/ha. A study by Rizk (1962) in Egypt estimated the fixation of two varieties of Egyptian clover (Trifolium alexandrinum) utilizing the difference method with chicory (Chicorium intybus) as a control. A considerable difference between the cultivars was found, with the average nitrogen fixation ranging from 62-235 kg N/ha. Phillips and Bennett (1978) utilized the “AN value” technique and compared it to acetylene reduction activity in rangeland plots of subclover and soft chess in California. The influence of planting density and percentage clover in the plots was also studied. The amount of N fixed (kilograms per hectare) was found to be dependent on both stand density and composition. Low-density stands with 50% clover fixed 21.2 kg N/ha and derived 84.5% of the clover N from fixation. A
30
THOMAS A. LARUE AND THOMAS G . PATTERSON
low-density stand of 100% clover fixed 58.1 kg N/ha but derived only 50.1% of the clover N from fixation. High-density stands fixed 103 and 183 kg N/ha (94.5 and 88.0% clover N from N2) in 50 and 100% clover stands, respectively. Estimates for alfalfa in a northern environment came from Heichel et al. (1981) in Rosemount, Minnesota. They used isotope dilution and A N value to estimate N fixation in two populations of alfalfa selected for high nitrogenase activity. Reed canary grass (Phalaris arundinacea) was used as a control. Average N fixation in the establishment year was 148 kg N/ha, with an average of 43% of the nitrogen derived from fixation. Both the amounts of N fixed and percentage of N derived from fixation varied over the season. Nitrogen fixation was 8-20 kg N/ha at the first and fourth harvests (25-30% of plant N from N2). During the second and third harvest period the legume fixed 47-87 kg N/ha (60% of plant N from N2). Estimates for forage legumes vary widely between studies. White clover, for example, was reported to fix 128 kg N/ha in Kentucky and 408-681 kg N/ha in New Zealand. Differences in climate, management practices, and growing season cause considerable variation in the N fixation rates of forage legumes. Direct comparisons of the values in Table I therefore must be approached with caution. B. SEEDLEGUMES The soybean Glycine max is the most important cash crop among legumes in North America, and its N fixation has received more attention than other crops. Most studies do not lend themselves to estimates of amounts of fixation, though several yield data on the percentage of N derived from fixation (Tables I1 and 111). Rizk (1 966) used the difference method to calculate fixation by soybean in a calcareous sand at Kutch, Egypt. Sesame (Sesamum indicum) was the nonfixing control and soil N was measured before sowing and after harvesting. Rizk reported a fixation of 16.7 kg N/ha and a seed yield of 13.7 kg N/ha. These low figures support his statement that he had not found the most suitable tillage practice for this crop. Weber (1966) compared the above-ground N content of a nodulating and a near-isogenic nonnodulating soybean cv. Lee at Ames, Iowa, for 6 years. In 2 years when moisture was limiting, the difference was 14.7 kg N/ha, representing about 13% of the plant N. In 4 years with good growth conditions, the mean difference was 72.3 kg N/ha in seed or 84 kg N/ha in total dry matter. In both cases this represented 40% of the total N in the nodulated plant. When the soil was amended with 45,000 kg/ha of corn cobs to immobilize N, the average difference in 3 years with good growth conditions was 160 kg N/ha in dry matter, or 74% of the total N . This higher figure may illustrate a potential for fixation by
31
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX? Table I1 Estimates of Nitrogen Fixation by Soybean
Location
Estimate (kg N/ha) 39.7 14.7-84
Egypt Iowa
Delaware
Method Difference Difference
GH, reduction
33-42 80- 120 103 56- I61
“ A ” value Difference
Minnesota
263 I05 76-152
Difference GH, reduction “ A ” value
Nebraska
43-146
“A” value
Southern Ontario
78-161
C,H, reduction
Illinois Arkansas Washington
Remarks Sesame Nonnodulating isoline, soil low in N Fertile soil
Nonnodulating isoline Uninoculated Soil low in N Nonnodulating isoline Nonnodulating isoline lnoculant trial
References Rizk ( 1 966) Weber (1966)
Hardy et a / . (1973) Johnson et al. (1975) Bhangoo and Albritton (1976) Bezdicek et a / . (1978) Ham and Caldwell (1978) Deibert et al. (1979) Muldoon et al. (1980)
soybean, but the extraordinary soil amendment is not representative of normal practice. Soybeans were grown in soils high in available N near Wilmington, Delaware, and assayed by the acetylene reduction technique. In 3 years with a low planting density, they fixed an average of 38 kg N/ha. In other trials with higher planting densities, rates of 80- 120 kg N/ha were calculated. These approximated to 25-30% of the total plant N (Hardy et a l . , 1973). Table 111 Estimates of Nitrogen Fixation by Pulses
Pulse Phaseolus vulgaris“ Pisum sativum Vicia faba Lupine Chick-pea Lentil Arachis hypogea
“25-120 mg/plant. bCalculated.
Estimate (kg N/ha) 1Ob
17-69 121-171 121-157 67-141 62-103 79 87-222
Method
Reference
GH, reduction GH, reduction Difference (barley) Difference (barley) Difference (barley) Difference (barley) Difference (sesame) Difference (uninoculated check)
Westerman and Kolar (1978) Mahler et al. (1979) b z k (1 966) Rizk (1966) Rizk ( I 966) Rizk ( I 966) Rizk ( 1 966) Ratner et al. (1979)
32
THOMAS A. LARUE AND THOMAS G . PATTERSON
Bhangoo and Albritton ( 1 976) compared nodulating and nonnodulating lines of cv. Lee for 3 years at Pine Bluff, Arkansas. The N differences in seed and dry matter were 130, 161, and 56 kg N/ha, representing 51, 64,and 22% of total plant N. In the first 2 years the trials were at the same plots, whereas in the third year the soybeans were planted on an area that had previously grown corn and had been heavily fertilized with NPK. This latter figure is probably more representative of the way soybean is generally grown. A comparison of inoculated and uninoculated soybeans cv. Merit was made in an irrigated low-N soil at Prosser, Washington (Bezdicek et al., 1978). The total plant N was 368 and 105 kg/ha; the difference of 263 kg N/ha representing 71% of the inoculated plant. An estimate based on acetylene reduction was 105 kg N/ha. The threefold difference in seed yield and plant top N suggests that the roots might not be comparable in the two treatments; perhaps inoculation provided sufficient N to support additional root growth to obtain soil N. In that case, the difference method would overestimate fixation. Ham and Caldwell (1978) tested cv. Clay at Rosemount, Minnesota, with plots amended with I5N and with different P levels. Fixation calculated by the “ A value” method was 76-152 kg N/ha. The authors reported that these results agreed with measurements made by Kjeldahl N and by weekly acetylene reduction experiments made with the same variety on an adjacent plot. In Nebraska, soybeans cv. Ford were grown with sprinkle irrigation (Deibert er al., 1979), with rates of added N of 0-134 kg/ha. At the & (beginning seed) stage, the total plant N was 70 and 178 kg/ha in nonnodulating and unfertilized nodulating lines, respectively, and at the highest levels of fertilizer were 170 and 180 kg N/ha. A , value calculations indicated that fixation had contributed 60 and 33%, respectively, under the two regimes. At harvest, the difference in seed N was 51 and 61 kg N/ha, and the percentage of N in seed from fixation was calculated at 66% in unfertilized and 31% in fertilized plants. Muldoon et al. (1980) compared a seed-applied inoculant and two soil-applied granular inoculants at three sites in southern Ontario, Canada. The fields had not been planted with soybean previously. Acetylene reduction assays indicated a range of 12-17 kg N/ha in uninoculated plots. Fixation with the largest amount of seed-applied inoculant was 78 kg N/ha. At the heaviest applications of two granular soil inoculants, the fixation rates were calculated at 128 and 161 kg N/ha. Differences in total plant N between inoculated and uninoculated plots were usually lower than the N (GH,)calculated. Interestingly, the added yield barely paid for the cost of granular inoculants if they were used at recommended levels. Four varieties of soybeans were grown in the field at Diome, France (Amarger et al., 19791, and fixation was estimated from variations in natural abundance. Yield figures were not presented, but fixation apparently contributed 13-37% of the plant N. The effect of soil fertility and added fertilizer on the degree of symbiotic
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
33
fixation was estimated by isotope dilution at Urbana, Illinois (Johnson et al., 1975). Soybeans in unfertilized fields fixed 48% of their N; this decreased to 10% as fertilizer rates increased to 224 kg N/ha. The authors concluded that the upper figure was a good estimate for their region. Calculations indicated that soybean is a good scavenger for soil N and that soybean removes larger quantities of N from soil than corn does. The natural abundance of I5N was measured in normal and nonnodulating isolines of soybean cv. Harosoy at Urbana, Illinois. The percentage of N contributed by fixation was calculated by the N difference method and calculations from isotopic concentrations (Kohl et al., 1980). In 2 years the N from fixation was 14 and 37% (by difference) or 33 and 43% (by W”). Depleting soil N by adding corn cobs increased the fixation to 5 3 or 56% estimated by the respective methods. The studies listed here are from every soybean-growing area of North America. Yields, when reported, were over 2000 kg/ha. Except when soil N was low, the contribution of fixation rarely exceeded 50%. The average American soybean yield (1975) was 1471 kg/ha. Assuming that the harvested seed represents about two-thirds of plant N, the whole plant N approximates 150 kg/ha on farms. Since it is unlikely that fixation on farms is more than 50%, the upper estimate for average fixation by soybeans in American agriculture is 75 kg N/ha.
I. Viciu faha L . Faba beans use soil or fertilizer N in preference to symbiosis. Pot experiments (Richards and Soper, 1978) show that they are as adept as barley in extracting available N. In pots low in N, 87% of the plant N was derived from fixation ( A N value method). Fertilizer addition decreased fixation without increasing total shoot N. In the field, faba bean yields are not responsive to added fertilizer. From this it was assumed that symbiotic fixation was adequate and that “the nitrogen in the grain is an approximate estimate of the atmospheric nitrogen “fixed” (McEwen, 1970). There was no experimental support for this view. The results of Sprent and Bradford (1977) indicate that during pod fill fixation estimated by acetylene reduction accounts for about one-third of the plant’s N gain. Estimates in soils at Giya and Sids, Egypt, were based on crop and soil accumulation of N, compared to barley, and were in the range 49-171 kg N/ha (Rizk, 1966).
2 . Arachis hypogaea L . Compared to sesame, peanuts at Kutah, Egypt, accumulated 79 kg N/ha in crop and soil (Rizk, 1966). In 3 years at Lakhish, Israel, the shoot N difference between uninoculated and
34
THOMAS A. LARUE AND THOMAS G . PATTERSON
inoculated peanuts was 222, 93, and 87 kg N/ha. These corresponded to 58,40, and 30% of total N in the inoculated plants (Ratner et a l . , 1979). The highest estimate of fixation was associated with a hay yield of 8667 kg/ha and a pod yield of 7042 kg/ha containing 5056 kg/ha kernel. The soil was not low in nitrogen and the crops were frequently imgated. The extraordinary yields suggest that the estimates for total fixation should not be applied to typical peanut crops, which have an average yield of 980 kg/ha (FAO, 1976). 3 . Pisum sativum L .
Mahler e f al. (1979) measured CpH, reduction in pea plots on the ridge top, south slope, and bottomland of a catina near Pullman, Washington. The three sites were within a few hundred meters of each other. The total plant N at the three sites was 75, 99, and 210 kg/ha. The calculated fixed N was 17 (23%), 22 (23%), and 69 (33%) kg/ha. The lower yields on the ridge and slope were associated with water stress. The differences in fixation observed within a small region demonstrate the futility of extrapolating amounts fixed in agriculture from single investigations. 4 . Phaseolus vulgaris L .
Acetylene reduction rates were estimated for 18 dry bean cultivars at Kimberly, Idaho (Westerman and Kolar, 1978). The calculated N fixation was in the range 25-120 mg N/plant. Fixation on an area basis was not reported, but the planting density was about 100,000 plants/ha. This suggests a fixation of about 10 kg N/ha, a small part of the total uptake of 150-400 kg N/ha. Unfortunately there are few estimates of fixation by pulses important to farmers in developing nations. The accumulation of plant and top soil N in low-N Egyptian soils was estimated by Rizk (1966). The rates of fixation by lupine (121-157 kg N/ha), chick-pea (67-141 kg N/ha), and lentil (62-103 kg N/ha) are not necessarily representative of the rates on farms. Cowpeas grown in a greenhouse can fix 88% of their N (Huxley, 1980). Cowpeas are generally grown as intercrops with maize or sorghum. Since the average yield of cowpeas is only 200 kg/ha (FAO, 1976), the amount of N fixed per hectare must be small.
IV. SUMMARY A. EVALUATION OF STUDIES
There is not a single legume crop for which we have valid estimates of the N fixed in agriculture. There are good estimates for soybean grown in representative
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
35
locations in experimental plots. However, extrapolation from this data to fixation in agriculture is speculative. For other pulses the few documented reports do not permit estimation of fixation on farms. The data on forage legumes are sparse and mostly derived from studies of pure stands. Estimates from more locations are required. In practice the forages are often planted with a grass, or over time become admixed by grasses. There is an almost complete lack of data on fixation by mixed stands, or on the amounts of fixation when forages are harvested or browsed. It is regrettable that fixation by legumes, which are important to the developing world, is not better documented. Dry beans are the most important legume crop for human consumption in Latin America. Cowpeas are a staple in much of Africa and Asia, and chick-pea is important in semiarid regions. For none of these are data available. There is no good evidence that any legume crop satisfies all its N requirements by fixation. Soybean fixation has been estimated in several areas of the United States and from consideration of all the data we must conclude that this crop depletes soil N. There are no substantiated reports that 100% N of any plant derives from symbiosis. The highest estimates (-80%) are typical of lowfertility soil or soils artificially made N-poor by admixture or carbon amendment. B. REQUIREMENTS FOR FUTURERESEARCH
Appropriate techniques for examining N fixation in perennial forage legumes must be developed. The interpretation and accuracy of long-term isotope studies needs to be evaluated. Since forage legumes are often grown in association with perennial grasses, techniques for estimating N fixation and N transfer between species need to be developed. A simpler technique, such as the difference method using a nonnodulating control, would find wide application if equivalence to the isotope procedures can be confirmed. The identification and development of more nonfixing forage genotypes should be a priority. Viands et al. (1979) have identified an ineffective nodulation character in alfalfa. Nonfixing strains in other species would be valuable. With the rising cost of N fertilizer, the potential of using legumes to increase soil N becomes increasingly attractive. Green manure systems were once much used to increase soil N (Sprague, 1936). A reexamination of the potential of legumes as a soil N source is called for. Quantitative data on the contribution of fixed N to the soil and to succeeding crops is needed for an adequate economic analysis of green manuring. Adequate methods of estimating fixation in pulses exist, but they are not yet so simple and inexpensive as to be commonly used. The acetylene reduction assay as now used requires too many samples over the growing season to be convenient
36
THOMAS A . LARUE A N D THOMAS G . PATTERSON
for analyzing many cultivar, strain, location, fertilizer, or environmental combinations. Nondestructive in situ measurements may be made with inexpensive apparatus (Mahon and Salminen, 1980), but the calibration of this assay with N fixed has not been accomplished. In developed countries with access to the necessary apparatus, isotopic techniques are likely to become more common. The 615N method of natural enrichment should be tested as a method of estimating fixation in agriculture by sampling seeds and comparing them with cereal grain harvested in the same region. This might serve as a way of estimating, albeit approximately, fixation over large areas. In developing countries there is need for inexpensive methods not requiring expensive imported apparatus. The Kjeldahl method for N accumulation in plant and soil would be useful if a way were found for estimating N mobilized from lower strata. This can be accomplished most easily if in each geographic region nonlegumes are found that utilize soil N in a manner similar to that of the major legume crops. There is then an urgent requirement to test nonlegumes that might serve as suitable controls for the difference method. Indirect methods based on N compounds in legume shoots might be used if they could be calibrated with fixation. Plant physiologists should determine whether symbiotic fixation in the field is more demanding of photosynthate than use of soil N. They should determine why legumes prefer to use soil N, and why even low levels of available N will decrease nodulation and fixation in the field. If this knowledge were available, it might be possible to breed legumes, especially forages, that would supply more of their N needs by fixation and leave soil N for grasses or cereals. REFERENCES We have omitted many articles and reviews stating estimates of symbiotic fixation without citing the source of information. We have also left out estimates, often anonymous, in commercial brochures and Institute or Station annual reports in which the experiment leading to the estimate is not documented. We noted only a few of the many reports that assume, without evidence, that total plant N, shoot N , yield, or some multiple of nodule weight, etc. is the measure of fixation. Amarger, N., Mariotti, A . , Mariot’ti, F . , Durr, J. C., Bourguignon, C., and Lagacherie B. 1979. Plant Soil 52, 269-280. Bardin, R., Domenach, A. M., and Chalamet, A. 1977. Appl. Rev. Ecol. Biol. Sol. 14, 395-402. Bezdicek, D. F . , Evans, D. W., Abede, B., and Witters, R. E. 1978. Agron. J . 70, 865-868. Bhangoo, M. S . , and Albritton, D. J. 1976. Agron. J . 68, 642-645. Bremner, J . M. 1965. In “Methods of Soil Analysis” (C. A . Black, ed.), Part 2, pp, 1149-1 179 and 1256-1286. Amer. SOC.Agron. Madison, Wisconsin. Bums, R. C., and Hardy, R. W. F. 1975. “Nitrogen Fixation in Bacteria and Higher Plants.” Springer-Verlag. New York. Bums, R. H. 1972. I n “Methods in Enzymology” (A. San Pietro, ed.), Vol. 24, pp. 415-431. Academic Press, New York.
HOW MUCH NITROGEN DO LEGUMES FIX?
31
Bums, R. H. 1978. In “Environmental Role of Nitrogen-fixing Blue-green Algae and Symbiotic Bacteria” (U. Granhall, ed.). NFR Editorial Service. Stockholm. Bums, R. H., and Wilson, P. W. 1957. In “Methods in Enzymology” (S. P. Colowick and N. 0. Kaplan, eds.), Vol. IV, pp. 355-366. Academic Press, New York. Chapman, H . D . , Liebig, G . F . , and Raynes, D. S. 1949. Hilgardia 19, 57-128. Collison, R. C.. Beattie, H. G., and Harlan, J. D. 1933. N.Y. Agric. Exp. Sta. Tech. Bull. No. 212. Cowling, D. W . 1961. J. Br. Grassl. Soc. 16, 281-290. Craswell, E. T . , and Martin, A . E. 1975a. Aust. J. SoilRes. 13, 43-52. Craswell, E. T., and Martin, A . E. 1975b. Aust. J. SoilRes. 13, 53-61. Deibert, E. J. Bijeriego, M . , and Olson, R. A. 1979. Agron. J . 71, 717-723. de Souza, D. I. A. 1969. East Afr. Agric. For. J . 34, 299-305. Domenach, A. M . , Chalamet, A., and Pachiaudi, C. 1979. C.R. Acad. Sci. (Paris) D289,291-293. Erdman, L. W. 1949. USDA Farmers Bull. No. 2000, pp. 1-20. F A 0 1976. “1975 Production Yearbook,” Vol. 29. Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations, Rome. Fried, M., and Dean, L. A. 1952. Soil Sci. 73, 263-271. Fried, M., and Middelboe, V. 1977. Plant Soil 47, 713-715. Halliday, J . , and Pate, J. S. 1976. J. Br. Grassl. SOC.31, 29-35. Ham, G. E., and Caldwell, A. C. 1978. Agron. J. 70, 779-783. Hardy, R. W. F., and Havelka, U. D. 1975. In “Symbiotic Nitrogen Fixation in Plants” (P. Nutman, ed.), Int. Biol. Prog. Ser. Vol. 7, pp. 421-439. Cambridge University Press, London. Hardy, R. W. F., Bums, R. C., and Holsten, R . D. 1973. Soil Biol. Biochem. 5, 47-81. Hauck, R. D., and Bremner, J. M. 1976. In “Advances in Agronomy” (N. C. Brady, ed.), Vol. 28, pp. 219-266. Academic Press, New York. Heichei, G. H . , Barnes, D. K.,and Vance, C. P . 1981. Crop Sci. 21, 330-335. Henzell, E. F. 1962. Aust. J. Exp. Agric. Anim. Hush. 2, 133-140. Hudd, G . A., Lloyd-Jones, C. P., and Hill-Cottingham, D. C. 1980. Physiol. Plant. 48, 1 I 1-1 15. Huxley, P. A . 1980. Trop. Agric. 57, 193-202. Jones. M. B., Delwiche, C. C . , and Williams, W . A. 1977. Agron. J . 69, 1019-1023. Johnson, J. W . , Welch, L. F., and Kurtz, L. T. 1975. J. Environ. Q u a / . 4, 303-306. Kamprath, E. J . , Chandler, W. V., and Krantz, B . A. 1958. N.C. Agric. Exp. Sta. Tech. Bull. No. 129. Karamanos, R. E., and Rennie, D. A. 1980. Can. J. Soil Sci. 60, 337-344, 365-372. Karraker, P. E . , Bartner, C. E., and Fergus, E. N . 1950. Kentucky Agric. Exp. Sta. Bull. No. 557. Kohl, D. H . , and Shearer, G. 1980. Plant Physiol. 66, 51-56. Kohl, D. H . , Shearer, G . , and Harper, J. E. 1980. Plant Physiol. 66, 61-65. Kohnke, H.. Dreibelhis, F. R . , and Davidson, J. M. 1940. USDA Misc. Puhl. No. 372. Kroontje, W . , and Kehr, W. R. 1956. Agron. J. 48, 127-131. LaRue, T. A , , and Kurz, W . G. 1973. Plant Physiol. 51, 1074-1075. Legg, J . O., and Sloger, C. 1975. In “Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Stable Isotopes” (E. R. Klein and P. D. Klein, eds.), pp. 661-666. Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, Illinois. Legg, J. 0.. and Stanford, G. 1967. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 31, 215-219. Lloyd-Jones, C . P . , Adam, J. S., Hudd, G. A., and Hill-Cottingham, D. G . 1977. Analyst 102, 473-476. Lyon, T . L., and Bizzell, J. A . 1911. Cornell Agric. Exp. Stu. Bull. No. 294. Lyon, T. L., and Bizzell, J . A . 1933. Agron. J. 25, 266-272. Lyon, T . L., and Bizzell, J. A. 1934. Agron. J. 26, 651-656. McAuliffe, C., Chamblee, D. S . , Uribe-Arango, H., and Woodhouse, W . W. 1958. Agron. J. 50, 334-337.
38
THOMAS A. LARUE A N D THOMAS G . PATTERSON
McClure, P. R . , Israel, D. W., and Volk, R . J. 1980. Plant Physiol. 66, 720-725. McEwen, J . 1970. J . Agric. Sci. (Cambridge) 14, 61-66; 67-72. Mahler, R. L., Bezdicek, D. F., and Witters, R. E. 1979. Agron. J. 71, 348-351. Mahon, J. D. 1977. Plant Physiol. 60, 812-816, 817-821. Mahon, J. D. 1978. Plant Physiol. 63, 892-897. Mahon, J . D., and Salminen, S. 0. 1980. Plant Soil 56, 335-340. Muldoon, J. F., H u m , D. J., and Beversdorf, W. D. 1980. C a n . J . Plant Sci. 60, 399-409. Nutman, P. S. 1973. I n “Symbiotic Nitrogen Fixation by Plants’’ (P. S. Nutman, ed.), pp. 211-237. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. Patwary, S. U., and Raikovich, Z. 1979. Plant Soil 52, 209-217. Pessanha, G. G., Franco, A. A . , Dobereiner, J., Groszmann, A., and de S. Britto, D. P. P. 1972. Pesqui. Agropecu. Bras. Ser. Agron. 7, 49-56. Phillips, D. A,, and Bennett, J. P. 1978. Agron. J . 70, 671-674. Ratner. E. I., Lobel, R., Feldhay, H., and Hartzook, A. 1979. Plant Soil 51, 373-386. Rennie, D. A , , Raul, E. A., and Johns, L. E. 1976. C a n . J . Soil Sci. 56, 43-50. Rennie, R. J., Rennie, D. A , , and Fried, M. 1978 In “Isotopes in Biological Dinitrogen Fixation,” IAEA, Vienna. Richards, J. E.. and Soper, R. J. 1978. Agron. J . 71, 807-811. Rizk. S. G. 1962. J . SoilSci. U . A . R . 2, 253-270. Rizk, S. G. 1966. J . Microbiol. U . A . R . 1, 33-45. Ruschel, A. P., Vose, P. B., Victoria, R. L., and Salati, E . 1979. Plant Soil 53, 513-525. Ryle, G. J. A., Powell, C. E . , and Gordon, A . J. 1979. 1. Exp. Bor 30, 135-144, 145-154. Saito, S. M. T., Matsui, E., and Salati, E. 1980. Physiol. Plant. 49, 37-42. Sears, P. B., Goodall, V. C., and Jackman, R. H. 1965. New Zeal. J . Agric. Res. 8, 270-283. Shearer, G . , Kohl, D. H., and Harper, J. E. 1980. Plant Physiol. 66, 57-60. Silsbury, J. H . 1977. Nature (London) 267, 149-150. Silsbury, J. H . 1979. Aust. J . Plant Physiol. 6, 165-176. Sloger, C., Bezdicek, D., Milberg, R., and Boonkerd, N. 1975. In “Nitrogen Fixation by FreeLiving Organisms” (W. D. P. Stewart, ed.), IBP No. 6, pp. 271-284. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. and Carter, J. N. 1963. Soil Sci. 96, 313-318. Smith, J. H., Legg, J. 0.. Sprague, H. B. 1936. N . J . Agric. Exp. Sfa. Bull. No. 609. Sprent, J. I . , and Bradford, A. M. 1977. J . Agric. Sci. (Cambridge) 88, 303-310. Viands, D. R., Vance, C. P., Heichel, G. H., and Barnes, D. K . 1979. Crop Sci. 19, 905-908. Wagner, R. E. 1954. Agron. J . 46, 233-237. Weaver, J. E. 1926. “Root Development of Field Crops.” McGraw-Hill, New York. Weber, C . R. 1966. Agron. J . 58, 46-49. Westerman, D. T . , and Kolar, J. J. 1978. Crop Sci. 18, 986-990. Williams, L. F . , and Lynch, D. L. 1954. Agrori. J . 46, 28-29. Williams, W. A,. Jones, M. B., and Delwiche, C. C. 1977. Agron. J . 69, 1023-1024.
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 34
PEANUT BREEDING' J. C. Wynne and W. C. Gregory Crop Science Department, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Germ Plasm Resources
Ill.
IV.
. .. .. .. . . .. ... .... . .. .. . .. .. .. .. . . ... ... . . ... .. ... ,
A. Subspecies and Commerci B. Related Wild Species. . . . C . Induced Variability . , , . . . , . , . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . , . , . , . . . , . , . . , , . . . . , . . . . , . , D. Origin and Distribution , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . , . . . , . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . , . , , . , E. Germ Plasm Collection , . . . , . . . . , . , , . , . , , . , , . , . , . . , . . , . . . . , . . , . . , . , . , . , Economic Importance and Breeding Objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Higher Yields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Oil and Protein Content.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . ............... ... .. ..., ., ., . , C . Pest Resistance.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . , . . . . . . . . Breeding and Quantitative Genetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Variability, Heritability, and Correlation , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , B . Type of Gene Action.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Effects of Selection . . . . , . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . , , . . . D. Genotype x Environment 1 .................. E. Evaluation of Stability . . . .................. F. Implications for Breeding ..................................... Breeding Methods .............................. A. Introduction and Pure-Line Selection , . , . , , , , , . , . , . . . , , . , . . . . , . . . . . , . , , , . . B. Hybridization . , , , . , , , , , . . , , . , . . , , , , , . . , , . . . , . , . , . , . , . _ _, . . . , . , . , . . . . Interspecific Hybridization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . '
V.
VI. VII.
39 40
42 42 42
44 44 44 45 49 49 54 59 59 61 62 63 63 63 65 68 68
1. INTRODUCTION Peanut (Aruchis hypogaea L.) breeding received little attention in the United States before the early work by Hull, Carver, and Higgins in Florida and Georgia in the 1930s and by Gregory in North Carolina in the 1940s. As a consequence, peanut breeders are now investigating the somewhat dated estimates of quantita'Paper No. 6741 of the journal series of the North Carolina Agriculture Research Service, Raleigh, North Carolina. 39
Copyright 0 1981 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
ISBN 0-12-ooO734-7
40
J. C. WYNNE A N D W . C. GREGORY
tive genetics and methods of field testing while needing to investigate novel approaches to interspecific hybridization and gene introduction into cultured cells. Ever since the natives of South America collected the ancestors of modern peanuts from the wild, the difficult process of adapting the peanut to new environments has been in progress. Some adjustments of the environment to peanut production have been made and will continue to be made in the future, but the great adaptive contingency lies with modification of the plant. Peanut breeding, like all other plant breeding efforts, is based upon confidence that application of the Darwinian theory of selection alters the hereditary constitution of the plant. Ideally, in a self-pollinated crop such as the peanut, it would be advantageous to insert genetic sequences of known and specific desired effect into the superior cultivars one already has, thus maintaining or enhancing the superiority already gained through the transformation of wild ancestors into cultivated plants. If this insertion were possible, the devastating effects of outcrossing to less effective germ plasm could be avoided and the temptations to narrow the genetic base could be resisted. The major costs of peanut breeding would be confined to the search for, identification of, and the insertion of the desired genetic sequences into the optimum number of sites and the final testing of the product. It has been demonstrated that there exist environments in which ordinary land races of peanuts are equal in productivity to the best products of the modern plant breeder (Hildebrand and Smartt, 1980). As Hildebrand and Smartt point out, the extraordinary response in Zimbabwe of the land races of Bolivia (5 1500 m above sea level at 16-17"s) to the plateau of Africa (15-16"s) and their corresponding low productivity near sea level in the United States is matched by the poor performance in the plateau of Africa of the exceptionally productive cultivars bred for the southeastern coastal plain of the United States. Elevation, photoperiod, and temperature-the environmental factors presumed to be involved in these differential responses-annot be changed. The task is to change the genome. It is the study of how these changes can be recognized and managed amongst the multitude of variables within local environments that is the principal theme of the review presented here.
II. GERM PLASM RESOURCES A . SUBSPECIES A N D COMMERCIAL NAMESOF CULTIVATED PEANUTS
Krapovickas and Rigoni (1960) subdivided A . hypogaea into two subspecies ( A . hypogaea ssp. hypogaea and A . hypogaea ssp. fastigiata Waldron), each
41
PEANUT BREEDING
composed of two botanical varieties. Krapovickas (1968, 1973) further clarified the classification of peanuts and identified five centers of diversity: Guarani, Bolivia, Peru, Amazon, and the region of Goias and Minas Gerais. Gregory and Gregory (1976) extended the number of regions to six to include the northeast of Brazil. The subspecific nomenclature was related to geographical regions as follows (Gregory el al., 1980): A . hypogaea L.
ssp. hypogaea var. hypogaea-Bolivian, Amazonian (Virginia type) var. hirsura-Peruvian ssp. fastigiata Waldron var. fastigiara-Guaranian, Goias and Minas Gerais, Peruvian northeast Brazil (Valencia type except for Peruvian) var. vulgaris Ha.-Guaranian, Goias and Minas Gerais, northeast Brazil (Spanish type) B. RELATEDW I L DSPECIES
The genus Arachis is comprised of 22 described species, including cultivated peanuts, and possibly 40 or more as yet undescribed annual or perennial species all originally collected from South America (Gregory er al., 1980). These species have been assigned to seven sections, several of the sections being subdivided into series (Table I) (Gregory et al., 1973; Krapovickas, 1973; Gregory et al., 1980). Table I Taxonomic Classification of the Genus Arachis L." Section Arachis nom. nud.
Erectoides Krap. et Greg. nom. nud.
Series Annuae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Perennes Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Amphiploides Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Trifoliolatae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Tetrafoliolatae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Procumbensae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud.
Caulorhizae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Rhizomarosae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Prorhizomatosae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Eurhizomatosae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Exrranervosae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Ambinervosae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. Triseminalae Krap. et Greg. nom. nud.
"After Gregory er a l . (1973, 1980) and Krapovickas (1973).
Ploidy level 2n 2n
4n 2n 2n 2n 2n 2n
4n 2n 2n 2n
42
J . C. WYNNE AND W . C. GREGORY
C . INDUCED VARIABILITY
Several induced mutation studies have bees conducted with peanuts (Ashri and Goldin, 1965; Emery et al., 1965, 1972; Avadhani and Rao, 1968; Gregory, 1968; Emery and Wynne, 1976). Gregory and his associates (Gregory, 1966, 1968) demonstrated that considerable variability controlled by both major and minor genes could be induced in the peanut using a mutagen. Mutants with higher yield (Gregory, 1968), Cercospora leafspot resistance (Cooper and Gregory, 1960), and potato leafhopper resistance (Campbell et al., 1976) were identified in irradiated populations. D. ORIGINA N D DISTRIBUTION
The cultivated peanut is found throughout the tropical and temperate regions of the world; however, wild species of Arachis are found only in South America. The species of Arachis are found in an area bounded by the Amazon River to the north, the Rio de la Plata to the south, the Andes Mountains to the west, and the Atlantic to the east. The Bolivian region was identified as the center of origin of the cultivated peanut, with the regions shown in Fig. 1 as secondary centers of diversity. Gibbons et al. (1972) classified the variability that had originated in or been introduced to Africa during the last five centuries. They emphasized that each of the botanical varieties of Krapovickas’ classification contains a large array of local cultivars. Gibbons et al. (1972) suggest that the variation in the African collection has arisen by hybridization and subsequent selection in Africa, making it an important secondary center of variation of both the Guarani and Bolivian peanuts of South America. Gregory et al. (1973) caution that additional exploration of the Bolivian center of origin is needed to resolve the relationship between South American and African variability. Such exploration has been in progress since 1976. E. GERMPLASMCOLLECTION
Collections of cultivated peanuts are already quite extensive (Banks, 1976). Much of the present collection was obtained from specific expeditions made to South America under the sponsorship of the United States Department of Agriculture with cooperation from state experiment stations and foreign countries. More recently, the International Board for Plant Genetic Resources has funded collection efforts. The most important collections are those of Archer in 1936;
43
PEANUT BREEDING
* I I
SECONDARY CENTERS :
I GUARANI I1 111 IV V VI
G O I A S AND M I N A S G E R A I S WESTERN B R A Z I L BOLIVIA PERU NORTHEASTERN BR A Z I L
FIG. 1. Centers of origin and diversity of the groundnut, Arachis hypogaea (from Gregory and Gregory, 1976).
Stephens and Hartley in 1947-1948; Gregory, Krapovickas, Pietrarelli, and others in 1959, 1961, and 1967; Hammons, Langford, Krapovickas, Pietrarelli, and others in 1968; and Gregory, Banks, Simpson, Krapovickas, Pietrarelli, and others in 1976, 1977, 1979, and 1980. Much of the germ plasm from Africa was introduced to the United States by Smartt in 1959. In addition, material has been received into the United States from other foreign sources (Banks, 1976). Approximately 4000 accessions are maintained by the Southern Regional Plant Introduction Station at Experiment, Georgia. The most extensive collection of cultivated peanut germ plasm is now maintained by the International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT) at Hyderabad, India. Their collection consists of over 8000 accessions (Rao, 1980).
44
J. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
Ill. ECONOMIC IMPORTANCE AND BREEDING OBJECTIVES The peanut is both an oilseed crop and a food grain legume. It is grown on an estimated 18.9 million ha in 82 countries for use as food, oil, and a high-protein meal. Peanut improvement programs have placed major emphasis on the development of cultivars with high yields, high oil content, good flavor, and characteristics desired by the processor. Breeding for pest resistance is receiving much effort as well. The incorporation of resistance to the many peanut diseases into adapted types has become a major goal of breeding programs. Breeding for insect resistance has not received as much emphasis as selection for disease resistance because insect problems are usually more localized and thus command less attention. A. HIGHER YIELDS
Despite the doubling of yields over the past 40 years, increased productivity remains one of the principal objectives of peanut breeding. Duncan et al. (1978) monitored the partitioning of the total assimilates in both new cultivars and old land races and found that the rate and duration of the fruit filling period were the factors that accounted for most of the variation in yield. They concluded that selection for yield has resulted in peanut cultivars that partition more of their daily assimilate to fruit (Duncan et al., 1978). This conclusion suggests that increased yields have resulted primarily from more efficient exploitation of existing fruiting sites rather than from increasing the number of sites available. If this suggestion proves to be correct, breeders may do well to alter their priorities or to achieve a greater insight into possible structural alterations in the peanut plant for increasing fruit production. B . OIL A N D PROTEINCONTENT
Recent oil analyses suggest that much could be done to increase oil production in peanuts. For example, Cherry (1977) determined the quantity of oil from 37 selected wild species and 21 cultivars and found oil content in the seeds was 46.5-63.1% for the wild species and 43.6-55.5% for the cultivars. The variability in oil yield, especially in the wild species, suggests that oil content of the peanut can be increased, perhaps dramatically. Oils from seed of different subspecies of peanuts differ in their tendency to develop oxidative rancidity and undesirable odors and flavors (Worthington and
PEANUT BREEDING
45
Hammons, 1971). Virginia-type peanuts produce oil with a lower linoleic acid content and tend to have greater oil stability than Spanish or Valencia types. Hybrids from subspecific crosses also vary in chemical composition of the oil (Tai, 1972). Khan et al. (1974) examined the refractive indices of oil from hybrids and segregating populations of six peanut crosses in order to assess fatty acid compositions of the groups. The iodine values were under the control of a few additive genes and thus highly heritable. A wide range of genetic variability in iodine value in the F2 populations of these crosses indicated that selection could improve quality and stability of oil. Peanut seeds contain about 26% protein and the resulting peanut meal about twice that percentage (Woodroof, 1966). Although variation in the protein level has been demonstrated for a wide range of genotypes (Holley and Hammons, 1968; Young and Hammons, 1973), little breeding work to exploit this variation has been reported. C. PESTRESISTANCE
In many countries there is a concerted effort to develop cultivars resistant to leafspots and rust, two of the most important diseases of peanuts worldwide. Norden (1973, 1980) reviewed the progress and difficulties encountered in breeding for disease resistance in peanuts. The progress in breeding for resistance to several important pests is summarized in what follows.
I . Disease Resistance a. Rust. Peanut rust, caused by Puccinia arachidis Speg., has become established throughout Asia, Australia, and much of Africa and has occurred with increasing frequency in the United States (Hammons, 1977). Sources of resistance to rust were identified over a decade ago (Bromfield and Cevario, 1970; Bromfield, 1974; Hammons, 1977). According to Hammons (l977), the resistant sources consist of three breeding lines, which are as follows:
(a) Tarapoto (PIS 259747,34 1879,350680,38 1622,405 132) originating from Peru. (b) Israel line 136 (PIS 298115 and 315608), which was selected from the cultivar Virginia Odom (Cook, 1972). Bromfield and Bailey (1972) concluded that the resistance of PI 2981 15 was controlled by two recessive genes. Fourteen progeny from the cross of PI 298 1 15 and an unknown pollen parent identified as FESR 1-14 were released as rust-resistant germ plasm. (c) DHT 200 (PI 314817), which was collected from Peru and is being considered for release in Australia (Shorter, 1978).
46
J . C. WYNNE AND W . C. GREGORY
At ICRISAT, Subrahmanyam et al. (1980) have screened over 4000 lines of cultivated peanuts for their rust reaction in the field and screenhouse. The resistance of Tarapoto and Israel line 136 was confirmed and several additional resistant germ plasms were identified. Two land races, NC Ac 17090 and EC 76446 (292), were more resistant than previously identified resistant sources. Several species of Arachis also have been shown to be resistant to rust, developing no symptoms when tested in India by Subrahmanyam et al. (1980) (Table 11). b. Cercospora Leafspots. Cercospora leafspots, the most common disease of peanuts, are caused by Cercospora arachidicola Hori (early leafspot) and Cercosporidium personatum (Berk. and Curt.) Deighton (late leafspot). Potentially valuable sources of resistance to C. arachidicola were identified in cultivated peanuts in Georgia (Sowell et a l . , 1976). Resistance was confirmed by Foster et al. (1980), who proposed to increase the level of resistance using recurrent selection and a detached leaf technique developed by Melouk and Banks (1978). Monasterios et al. (1978) evaluated the reaction of 180 peanut accessions for resistance to leafspot caused by both C. arachidicola and C . personatum. Of the genotypes screened, 14 had very few lesions caused by C . arachidicola, 10 had very few caused by C. personatum, and 15 had few lesions from either pathogen. Nigam et al. (1980) found that several accessions resistant to rust were also resistant to late leafspot. The wild species of Arachis are also resistant to leafspot (Abdou et al., 1974; Gregory et a l . , 1973; Moss, 1980). Sharief et al. (1978) inoculated three species of Arachis and three of their F, and F2 hybrids with spore suspensions from C. arachidicola and C. personatum. They concluded that variation in disease tolerance resulted from multifactonal genetic differences in the hosts. The authors suggested that introgression of genetic factors from the two resistant Arachis species studied ( A . chacoense Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. and A . cardenasii Krap. et Greg. nom. nud.) into the genomes of A . hypogaea could increase host Table I1 Wild Species of Arachis Immune to Pucciniu armhidis Speg." ~~~
Species A . duranensis Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. A . correntina (Burk.) Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. A . cardenasii Krap. et Greg. nom. nud. A . pusilla Benth. A . sp. 9661 A . sp 10596
"After Subrahmanyam et a l . (1980).
USDA PI No.
Section
Origin
2 19823 33 1 194 262141 338448 262848 216233
Arachis Arachis Arachis Triseminalae Rhizomatosae Rhizomatosae
Argentina Argentina Bolivia Brazil Brazil Paraguay
PEANUT BREEDING
47
resistance in the cultivated peanut. Smartt et al. (1978) advocated maximizing resistance by selection in the A . chacoense x A . cardenasii population before attempting gene transfer to the cultivated species. Hexaploids from crosses of cultivated peanuts with A . chacoense, A . cardenasii, and other diploid species have been exposed in field trials to C. permnatum in India and C. arachidicola in Malawi (Moss, 1977, 1980). Lines from the hexaploids of A . hypogaea x A . cardenasii were found to be resistant to both pathogens (Moss, 1977, 1980). Stalker et al. (1979) also reported resistant selections to both pathogens in 40-chromosome derivatives from an A . hypogaea x A . cardenasii hybrid population. c . Ajlatoxin. Aflatoxin produced by Aspergillus jlavus (Link) Fries is a major problem facing the peanut industry in the United States. Mixon and Rogers (1973) and Mixon (1976) found two Valencia accessions (PI 337394 and 337409) and several breeding lines resistant to seed colonization by two aflatoxin-producing strains of A.j7avus. LaPrade (1974) found that an intact testa is required for resistance, the testa appearing to act as a mechanical barrier to the fungus. Many additional factors seem to influence susceptibility of seeds to invasion by Aspergillus (Bartz et al., 1978). Therefore breeding of resistant cultivars has proven difficult. Seeds of genotypes resistant to invasion by A.flavus under field growth contained aflatoxin concentrations equal to genotypes easily colonized when the two were stored under humid conditions (Wilson et a l . , 1977). Nevertheless, Mixon (1976, 1980) has developed a productive line resistant to colonization. d . Rosette Virus. Rosette virus is transmitted by an aphid (Aphis craccivora Koch.). Cultivars resistant to rosette were developed in Senegal and the Upper Volta (Gillier, 1978). These cultivars are being used as source of resistance to deveiop cultivars adapted to other growing areas of Africa. e . Southern Stern Rot. No presently available lines of peanuts appear to be highly resistant to stem rot caused by Sclerotium rolfsii Sacc. Garren (1964) concluded that the Virginia cultivar NC 2 was the least susceptible to this disease and lines of the fastigiate type were the most susceptible. This observation was confirmed by Muheet et al. (1975). Despite breeding efforts to develop resistant cultivars at several institutions (Lin, 1959; Beute et a l . , 1976), except for NC 2 (Gregory, 1970), no cultivars resistant to stem rot have been released. f. Cylindrocladium Black Rot. Cylindrocladium black rot (CBR) is caused by a soil-borne fungus, Cylindrocladium crotalariae (Loos) Bell & Sobers. Valencia types are most susceptible and Spanish types are most resistant to CBR (Wynne et al., 1975b; Coffelt, 1980b). NC 3033 and Va GPl have been released as resistant germ plasm (Beute et al., 1976; Coffelt, 1980a). Advanced breeding lines resistant to CBR have been developed in North Carolina using an accelerated breeding program (Wynne, 1976b). Backcrossing to an adapted cultivar to
48
J. C. WYNNE A N D W. C. GREGORY
improve quality may be required before cultivar release. Hadley et al. (1979) studied the F, , F2, and parental generations from a four-parent diallel cross (two resistant to black rot, Argentine and NC 3033, and two susceptible, NC 2 and Florigiant) under greenhouse conditions to determine the inheritance of CBR resistance. Because general combining ability was significant for both generations, indicating that CBR resistance is primarily controlled by additive genetic effects, they proposed that genetically distinct sources of resistance be combined to produce genotypes with superior CBR resistance. Such material should buffer potential pathogen adaptation to overcome resistance. g. Nematodes. Lesion nematodes. Smith et al. (1978a) evaluated six peanut introductions and two commercial cultivars (Starr and Spancross) for resistance to lesion nematodes [Pratylenchus brachyurus (Godfrey) Felip Sch. Stek] under field conditions. Three introductions were found to have some resistance. Root-knot nematodes. Minton and Hammons ( 1975) conducted greenhouse tests for resistance to root-knot nematodes, Meloidogyne arenaria (Neal) Chitwood, a major parasite of peanuts in the southeastern United States. None of 479 entries tested showed resistance to the nematode. Banks (1969) tested about 400 accessions of cultivated peanuts and 33 species collections for resistance to the northern root-knot nematode, Meloidogyne hapla Chitwood. Although differences in susceptibility among the cultivated lines were observed, Banks (1969) concluded that resistance was not great enough to be useful in developing resistant cultivars. One wild species from section Rhizomatosae, PI 262286, had a moderately high level of resistance, but this species has not yet been successfully hybridized with cultivated peanuts. h. Other Diseases. Peanut breeders are also attempting to develop cultivars resistant to Verticillium wilt (Verticillium sp.), Sclerotina blight [Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (Lib.) DeBary], Webb blotch (Phoma arachidicola), collar rot (Diplodia gossypina), and pod breakdown (Pythium sp.). Resistant lines have been reported for Verticillium wilt (Smith, 1961; Frank and Krikun, 1969; Khan et al., 1972, 1974), Sclerotina blight (Porter et al., 1975), collar rot (Porter and Hammons, 1975), and Webb blotch (Smith et al., 1978b). 2 . Insect and Mite Resistance a . Southern Corn Rootworm. The southern corn rootworm (Diabrotica undecimpunctata howardi Barber) is the most destructive insect pest of peanuts in the Virginia-Carolina production area. The cultivar NC 6 has a high enough level of resistance to rootworm to eliminate the need for insecticide application in most soils of the region (Campbell et al., 1977). NC 6 is also moderately resistant to the potato leafhopper (Empoascafabae Harr.), although sources with a higher level of resistance have been isolated (Campbell et al., 1976).
PEANUT BREEDING
49
b . Lesser Cornstalk Borer. The lesser cornstalk borer, Elasmopalpus lignosellus (Zeller), is a major insect pest on peanuts in the southeastern and southwestern United States. Leuck and Harvey (1968) screened germ plasm for lesser cornstalk borer resistance but their results were inconclusive. Smith et al. (1980) screened seedlings of 490 genotypes for their reaction to lesser cornstalk borer larvae under greenhouse conditions. Eighty entries gave a significantly better reaction than the check cultivar, Starr. c. Mites. Johnson et al. (1977) have found resistance to the two-spotted mite, Tetranychus urricae Koch, a major pest of peanuts in North Carolina during dry seasons in several species of Arachis. No evidence of highly resistant commercial cultivars was reported. Several of the wild species of Arachis were found to have resistance approaching immunity. d . Thrips. Young et al. (1972) screened 872 peanut entries for resistance to tobacco thrips, Frankliniella fusca (Hinds). Only moderate resistance was found. Immature and adult thrip populations in the buds and flowers of developing peanut plants were studied by Tappan and Gorbet (1979) to evaluate thrip damage. They concluded that thrip control on peanuts is not economical because injurious populations occur too early in the growing season to influence yields. e . Fall Armyworms. Leuck and Hammons (1974) observed that the nutrition of the host plant can influence the expression of resistance to armyworm [Sportoptera frugiperda (J. E. Smith)]. They conducted a study using three growth media and various fertilizer combinations and found that armyworm preferred foliage of peanuts grown in Tifton loamy sand field soil over that of peanuts grown in washed sand or vermiculite. The data also showed that fall armyworm resistance varied with the types of fertilizer and with vigor and appearance of the single cultivar utilized in the study. Resistance to fall armyworm has been reported (Duke, 1980).
IV. BREEDING AND QUANTITATIVE GENETICS A . VARIABILITY, HERITABILITY, A N D CORRELATION
Bernard (1960) estimated genetic and environmental variability for several traits, including seed yield, number of pods, and weight per seed in the F, through F4 generations of 4 crosses between 8 diverse cultivars and 15 crosses between 6 F4 selections from the first group of crosses. Seed size (weight per seed) had a higher estimate of heritability than did seed yield. Several traits were correlated with yield, but a selection index including yield and any or all of the
50
J . C. WYNNE A N D W . C. GREGORY
remaining nine characters was not superior to selection for yield alone (Table 111).
Syakudo and Kawabata (1965) found that genotypic correlations among 15 characters in the 6 possible crosses of Virginia-, Valencia-, and Spanish-type peanuts were higher than phenotypic correlations. Estimates of broad-sense heritability were low for all traits of economic importance. Lin (1966) also found that estimates of heritability for number of pods and seed yield were relatively low. He reported that the major portion of genetic variance among F2 and F3 progenies of a Spanish X Virginia cross was due to dominance effects for number of pods and yield. Estimates of broad-sense heritability for an Fs bulk population were higher for yield and number of pods in high planting densities than in low densities (Lin et al., 1971). Martin (1967) obtained narrow-sense heritability estimates of approximately 70% for oil content, shelling outturn, and yield using F, and backcross progenies between two cultivars. He reported that cultivar differences were due to two pairs of alleles for oil content, one for shelling outtum and five for seed weight. Oil content was not correlated with yield. Coffelt and Hammons ( 1974) reported correlation coefficients and heritability estimates for nine components of yield in an F2 population between Argentine (Spanish type) and Early Runner (Virginia type). The characters measured were number of pods and seeds per plant, pod and seed weight per plant, 100-seed weight, length and breadth of 10 pods, number of seeds per pod, and pod length-to-breadth ratio. They found highly significant positive correlations between number of pods and pod weight, number of seeds and seed weight, pod weight and number of seeds, pod and seed weights, and number of seeds and seed weight. Selection for increases in any of the four characters, number of pods, pod weight, number of seeds, or seed weight, should result in a corresponding increase in the remaining traits. Pod breadth was also significantly correlated with 100-seed weight. Other significant correlations were obtained, but they were small in magnitude. Broad-sense estimates of heritability for 100-seed weight, pod length, pod breadth, and the pod length-to-breadth ratio were high (71-90%). Low heritability estimates were observed for number of pods, pod weight, number of seeds, seed weight, and seeds per pod. Tai and Young (1975) studied the inheritance of protein content and oil content using six cultivars and their F2 populations. They concluded that both protein content and oil content were quantitatively inherited. Correlations between protein content and oil content were negative and varied from nonsignificant to highly significant in the various populations. Holly and Hamrnons (1968) had previously reported a tendency for a reciprocal relationship between oil content and protein content. However, enough exceptions were found for the 26 cultivars tested to invalidate an absolutely negative relationship between oil and protein.
PEANUT BREEDING
51
The inheritance of amino acid and fatty acid composition of three crosses in Fz generation and their parents were also reported by Tai and Young (1975). These traits were also found to be controlled by genes acting in a quantitative manner. Some transgressive segregants were found for some of the amino and fatty acids. Correlations among the 18 amino acids and 8 fatty acids were inconsistent over parental and F2 cross populations. In another study Tai and Young (1977) used nine F2 families from crosses among six peanut cultivars and breeding lines to investigate the inheritance of dry matter accumulation and free arginine (as a measure of maturity). Dry matter accumulation was found to be a quantitative trait, whereas the free arginine level was found to be controlled by two major genes with partial dominance for low arginine. Broad-sense heritabilities were 38-78% for dry matter and 60-93% for arginine level. Mohammed et al. (1978) estimated heritability, phenotypic correlations, and genotypic correlations for yield, fruit size, and maturity using the F, and F, generations of two crosses between one Virginia and two Spanish lines. Broadsense heritability estimates based on intraplot variance for yield ranged from 42 to 82% for four year-location environments. Broad-sense heritability estimates were also high for fruit length, ranging from 79 to 92%. Estimates of heritability for several maturity traits were lower and less consistent over environments. Estimates of heritability computed by parent-offspring regression were much lower for all traits than those estimated by the variance partitioning method. Parent-offspring regression heritability for the two crosses for yield of pods was 21 and 16%, for weight of seeds 10 and 6%, for fruit size 42 and 50%, for fruit length 18 and 27%, for weight per seed 41 and 51%, and for a fruit maturity index 20 and 35%. The discrepancy between the variance and regression estimates of heritability for the F, populations suggests that broad-sense heritabilities based on intraplot variances are poor predictors of genetic advance from selection. The variance estimates of heritability were biased upward, probably from inflated genotypic estimates resulting from competition among plants within plots. The regression estimates of heritability were biased less by nonadditive variance and genotype X environment interaction and thus seem to be more useful as predictors of response to selection. Gibori er al. (1978) used a 9 x 9 diallel cross involving widely divergent cultivars as parents to estimate heritability and correlations for pod size, pod yield per plant, days to first flower, and shoot weight measured in the F2generation. Their estimates of heritability were calculated using the methods of Hayman (1954, 1958) and Jinks (1954, 1956). These authors suggest that the high heritability estimate obtained for pod yield per plant (79%) indicates that visual selection of promising plants in large F, populations followed by careful progeny testing can be used to increase productivity. Pod yield per plant was not highly correlated with the other three traits, suggesting that selection for yield cannot be
Table HI Estimates of Heritability in Peanuts from Populations Derived after Hybridization Yield bl
w
Parental material
Estimated
Reference population
Pod
F2 families in F3
Diverse set of 5 parents Intervarietal crosses among 3 parents Virginia x Spanish
H
Virginia X Virginia Virginia X Virginia Spanish X Virginia
Ill
F2 population
h’
F4, Fs families
Seed 0.54-0.68 0.83-0.85 0.66
F3 families in F, F2 individuals
Weight per seed
Oil
Protein
Other traits
Investigators Bernard (1960)
0.73-0.87 0.92-0.97
Syakudo and Kawabata (1965)
F5 bulks
Lin et al.
1 x 105 plantdha 1.5 x 105 3.0 x 105
0.64, 0.56 0.53, 0.49 0.38, 0.30
(1971)
0.66-0.76
0.70
O.7Oa
Martin (1967)
0.69-0.94b
Gupton and Emely ( 1970)
H
0.43
0.43
0.90
Coffelt and Hammons ( 1974)
Intervarietal sample of 6
Virginia X Spanish
w
"Leafspot resistance.
H
F2
0.72
0.47 0.38-0.78" 0.60-0.93"
F2 and F3 families
"Meat. bMaturity (oil index). "Total dry matter. dAM.
F2 individuals
H 'h
Intervarietal 9 parent diallel Virginia x Virginia Virginia x Virginia Virginia X Spanish VI
H
h'
Variance comp. Po regression F2 families
0.42-0.82 0.16-0.21 0.79
h2
F5 and F6 families
0.54
H
F3 families
0.28, 0.41
0.57, 0.83
0.47, 0.72
0.52, 0.68
0.77, 0.82'
Tai and Young ( 1974) Tai and Young (1977) Mohammed et a1 (1978) Gibori et al. ( 1978) Wynne and Rawlings ( 1978) Sandhu and Khehra ( 1977)
54
J. C . WYNNE A N D W. C. GREGORY
accomplished by indirect selection. They found a positive but low genetic correlation between fruit size and yield, supporting the practice of selection for both large pods and high yields. Layrisse et al. (1980) estimated correlation coefficients based upon F2 cross means and Spearman rank correlations based upon general combining ability effects for nine traits from the F2 generation of a diallel cross involving ten diverse parents. Correlation coefficients based on cross means are phenotypic; those based on general combining ability effects are phenotypic correlations that approximate genetic correlations. Fruit yield and seed yield were significantly correlated with oil content and protein content. Oil content and protein content were positively correlated but only the phenotypic correlation was significant. Wynne and Rawlings (1978) estimated heritability for yield and several fruit traits for the F5 and F6 generations of a cross between two Virginia cultivars. Narrow-sense estimates of heritability over reciprocal crosses and environments ranged from 54% for yield per plot to 89% for fruit length. Progress from selection in late generation should be expected from these crosses. Sandhu and Khehra (1977) determined heritability and predicted genetic advance for the F3 progenies of two peanut crosses for resistance to leafspot, pod yield, 100-kernel weight, oil content, and protein content. Broad-sense estimates of heritability were high for all traits except yield in both crosses. However, the estimated advance from selection was only high for resistance to leafspot. Hadley et al. (1979) estimated heritability for CBR resistance to range from 48 to 65% depending upon the method of calculation. Their estimates were obtained in the greenhouse for the F, and F2 generations of a four-parent diallel. B. TYPEOF GENEACTION
Although methods for characterizing genetic variability in self-fertilizing species are available (Hanson and Weber, 1961; Cockerham, 1963; Stuber, 1970), little information has been obtained on the types of gene action and their relative magnitude for important traits in peanuts. Brim (1973) has emphasized the importance of developing more efficient breeding procedures through a better understanding of the type of gene action governing the inheritance of quantitative traits .
I . Heterosis Heterosis, followed by inbreeding depression, usually indicates that nonadditive gene action is important. Marked heterosis for vegetative traits and pod yield were obtained for several combinations when Higgins (1941) crossed 16 cultivars in all combinations. Individual plant yields were highest for Spanish x Virginia
PEANUT BREEDING
55
crosses. Gregory el al. (1980), in a diallel cross of 10 diverse peanut lines made in 1944, found hybrid vigor for F, hybrids between subspecies. Most F2 hybrid means were equal to midparental values, although some F2 means were exceptionally high or low. Syakudo and Kawabata (1963) found appreciable heterosis for shoot weight in Virginia X Spanish and Valencia X Virginia F, hybrids. Heterosis was not present in crosses between cultivars within each botanical variety nor in Spanish x Valencia crosses. Lin (1966) found significant heterosis for length of main stem and branches for F2 plants grown in Taiwan from the cross of a Spanish type with Florispan Runner (Virginia type). The superiority of the F, hybrids over their better parents for yield, as well as for the number of branches and leaflet length, was shown by Hassan and Srivastava (1966) using crosses among three cultivars differing in maturity and growth habit. Parker et a f . (1970) noted that F, crosses of Valencia X Virginia gave greater heterosis than did crosses of Virginia X Spanish or Valencia X Spanish for several seedling characters measured in a controlled environment. Wynne et al. (1970), using the same parents as Parker et al., reported that F, hybrids from Virginia x Valencia parents gave greater heterosis than other crosses for vegetative plant characters. Crosses of Valencia x Spanish gave greatest heterosis for yield and fruit characters. The highest yielding population, however, resulted from a cross of Virginia x Spanish parents. Hammons (1973a) reported heterotic responses for fruit yield for F, hybrids resulting from crosses between the subspecific peanut groups. Five cultivars representing Virginia and Spanish types and all their possible hybrid combinations were evaluated in Senegal by Garet (1976). Heterosis was found for pod and seed size, pod and seed number per plant, and shelling outturn. In all cases where heterosis was observed, the cross was between Virginia and Spanish parents. Layrisse et al. (1980) found that hybrid vigor for fruit yield, seed yield, and 100-seed weight persisted in F2progenies of a diallel cross among ten lines, two from each of five centers of genetic diversity in South America. The parents of the crosses displaying significant heterosis most often came from different centers. Arunachalam et al. (1980) classified parents of two diallel crosses as high or low based on their general combining ability as computed for 15 characters. High x low crosses produced greater heterosis than high x high or low x low crosses. Isleib and Wynne (1980) crossed 28 diverse peanut lines with an elite Virginia breeding line and grew the F, and F2 generations at two North Carolina locations. Included in the parental sample were genotypes from five South American centers of diversity, Africa, China, and A . monticola. Positive heterosis was observed for pod yield, number, and size. Fastigiate parents generally produced greater heterotic responses than parents from ssp. hypogaea. Maximum responses were noted for fastigiate parents from the Peruvian center of diversity. The evidence is convincing that heterosis in peanuts, like heterosis in other crop species such as wheat (Fonesca and Patterson, 1968; Sun et al., 1972;
56
J . C. WYNNE AND W . C. GREGORY
Widner and Lebsock, 1973), alfalfa (Sriwatanapongse and Wilsie, 1968), cotton (Marani, 1963, 1968), corn (Moll et a l . , 1962), and tobacco (Matzinger and Wernsman, 1968), is related to genetic diversity. Heterosis in peanuts is most often observed in crosses between the subspecific groups. These results suggest that gene action differs in crosses made within and crosses made between botanical varieties. Additive genetic variance appears to be of primary importance in crosses made between parents chosen from a single botanical variety, but both additive and nonadditive genetic variance may be significant in crosses made between parents from different botanical varieties. 2 . Combining Ability Mating designs such as the diallel have been used in partitioning genetic variability into portions due to general combining ability (GCA) and specific combining ability (SCA). GCA indicates additive genetic effects, while SCA indicates nonadditive genetic effects. Gregory et al. (1980) crossed ten of the most diverse peanut lines in his collection in 1944 and estimated combining ability in the F, generation by using vegetative cuttings. He found GCA to be highly significant and several times greater in magnitude than SCA for yield and several yield components. In a series of experiments Parker et al. (1970) and Wynne et al. (1970, 1975a) reported the results from a series of combining ability analyses using six diverse parents. Parker et al. (1970) estimated combining ability for 17 characters of F, hybrid seedlings in a diallel set of crosses of 6 lines, 2 each from 3 centers of diversity in South America. In the controlled environment of a phytotron estimates of GCA were found to be higher than SCA. Wynne et al. (1970), however, reported combining ability estimates for SCA higher than those for GCA for yield and several yield components for the same F, hybrids in the field. However, when a more appropriate analysis of the data was made (Baker, 1978), estimates of GCA were found to be significant for all 17 characters. Furthermore, GCA estimates were larger than estimates for SCA for all except one character. Estimates of combining ability were also obtained for the F2 generation of these 15 crosses in both spaced and drill-planted tests (Wynne et al., 1975a). Estimates of both GCA and SCA were highly significant for yield, fruit length, seeds per kilogram, percentage extra-large kernels, and percentage sound mature kernels. GCA estimates were larger than SCA estimates for all traits except percentage sound mature kernels in the drilled tests. In the space-planted test, GCA and SCA were significant for all traits except for SCA for weight of sound mature kernels. GCA estimates were likewise of greater magnitude than SCA for all traits. Garet (1976) evaluated the F, hybrid progeny from a complete diallel of five cultivars chosen to represent a wide range of variation in Senegal. Estimates of
PEANUT BREEDING
57
GCA were significant for pod and seed yield per plant, the number of pods and seeds per plant, 100-pod weight, 100-seed weight, oil content, and shelling outturn. SCA and reciprocal effects were also significant for all traits except oil content. Since GCA effects were larger than SCA estimates for all traits except shelling outturn, Caret (1976) concluded that the major part of the total genetic variability was additive for all characters except shelling outturn. A graphic analysis of the data for pod yield per plant, 100-pod weight, and shelling outturn using the methods of Hayman (1954) confirmed the conclusions reached through the analysis of variance for combining ability. Pod yield per plant, days to first flower, pod size, and plant weight were studied by Gibori et al. (1978) by analyzing F, data from a 9 x 9 diallel cross utilizing cultivars of Virginia, Valencia, and Spanish types. They reported bidirectional dominance for pod yield per plant and days to first flower, whereas the alleles giving small pods were dominant and the alleles for large plants showed dominance and overdominance. Estimates of genetic components of variance indicated that additive genetic effects were significant for all traits and accounted for more of the variation than nonadditive effects for all traits except plant weight. Layrisse er al. (1980) used ten peanut lines, two from each of five centers of diversity in South America, and the Fz generation of all possible crosses among them to estimate combining ability for yield, fruit and seed traits, protein content, and oil content. Both GCA and SCA were significant for all traits except for SCA for protein percentage. The component of variation for GCA was larger than that for SCA for all traits. Hadley er al. (1979) (using greenhouse-grown plants of the F, and F, generations from a four-parent diallel) determined combining ability for CBR resistance. GCA was significant for both generations, suggesting that resistance was primarily due to additive genetic effects. Kornegay er al. (1980), using fieldgrown F I and F2generations from a six-parent diallel, determined the inheritance of resistance to early and late leafspot in Virginia-type peanuts. GCA was significant in both generations, indicating that variation in resistance to both fungi depended upon additive genetic effects. Crompton et al. (1979) used a complete diallel among four Virginia and two Spanish lines to estimate combining ability for seed calcium concentration and total adenosine phosphates. GCA, SCA, maternal effects, and reciprocal effects were significant for calcium concentration, while only SCA was significant for total adenylates. Reciprocal and SCA components of variation were larger for calcium concentration than the GCA component of variation, although GCA was sufficiently large to also be important. Isleib et al. (1980) crossed 10 South American cultivars in diallel to analyze the gene action for traits indicative of nitrogen fixation. SCA was significant and accounted for more variability than GCA for nodule number per plant, nodule mass, specific nitrogenase activity,
58
J . C. WYNNE A N D W. C. GREGORY
shoot weight, and total nitrogen for greenhouse-grown F, plants, suggesting that nonadditive gene action is important for these traits. 3 . Variance Studies
Mohammed et al. (1978) estimated additive and nonadditive genetic effects for crosses between one Virginia and two Spanish lines using a generation means analysis. Estimates of additive effects were significant for yield, maturity, and fruit size traits. Nonadditive genetic effects were also significant for yield and fruit size. Wynne and Rawlings (1978), using maximum-likelihood procedures from a nested mating design, estimated genetic variances for yield and several fruit traits for the F5 and F6 generations of an intercultivar cross. Estimates of additive and additive by environmental variances were significant for yield and fruit traits. Estimates of additive x additive epistatic variance were essentially zero for all traits; however, estimates of additive x additive x environmental variances were larger than their associated standard deviations for all traits except yield. The available evidence suggests that the principal component of genotypic variance for traits of economic importance in peanuts is additive. The importance of nonadditive effects is not known. The significant heterosis observed in some peanut crosses suggests that dominance deviations occur but hybrids cannot presently be utilized in peanut improvement. In the self-pollinated peanut, epistatic variance of the additive x additive type is potentially useful to breeders because it can be fixed in homozygous genotypes. Hammons (1973a) suggested that many important traits may be governed by epistatic variance. Significant estimates of epistatic variance for quantitative traits would not be surprising since the peanut is an allotetraploid and several qualitative traits have been found to be controlled by duplicate genes (Hammons, 1971, 1973b). A generation means analysis was used by Sandhu and Khehra (1 976) to determine the importance of epistatic variance for two crosses at two locations in India. Nonadditive genetic effects were more important than additive effects for pod yield, number of mature pods, and 100-kernel weight in one cross and for pod yield in the second cross at a single location. These authors concluded that epistasis cannot be ignored in peanut crosses. Isleib el al. (1978) tested for the presence of epistatic effects using progeny from a six-parent half-diallel of diverse peanut cultivars. Significant variability attributable to specific combining ability persisted over generations for yield and seed characters. Epistasis was indicated since dominance deviations could not account for the variance due to SCA in the F5 generation. Although their estimates were obviously biased by linkage disequilibrium, the authors reported that epistatic variance was greater than dominance variance for all traits. This study suggests that considerable epistatic variance may account in part for the heterosis in crosses derived from
59
PEANUT BREEDING
diverse parents. Cahaner et al. (1979) used a diallel in an attempt to detect genic interactions. Six traits, measured in the F2 generation of crosses made among four parents, were analyzed. A duplicate genic type of interaction and complementary interactions were detected using the methods suggested by Mather (1 967). They concluded that duplicate genic interactions were involved in the inheritance of pod yield and mean pod weight. The number of pods per plant, dry weight of plant, and the ratio of reproductive to vegetative branches were found to be controlled by additive-dominant genes. Genetic variance, heterosis, and epistatic variance estimates need to be integrated into the mainstream of selection procedures for the major objectives of peanut breeding programs. Information on the type and magnitude of genetic variance for important traits of both adapted and exotic intersubspecific crosses needs to be part of the ongoing process of cultivar development. C. EFFECTS OF SELECTION
In the absence of selection experiments to report in peanuts, we can only say that while the dramatic improvements in cultivar performance in peanuts attest to the breeders' skills and luck, they do not indicate firm courses of action for the future. The best we can report here are data comparing new cultivars with the old land race standards with which they have been tested (Table IV). D. GENOTYPE X ENVIRONMENT INTERACTIONS
Genotype x environment interactions influence the progress that a breeder makes in his breeding program. Well-buffered cultivars, those with small Table IV Comparison of Yield of Land Races of Peanuts with Improved Cultivars
Improved cultivar
Year of release
NC 2 NC 5 NC 6 Florigiant Florigiant
1952 1964 1976 1960 I960
Mean yield of land race Land race
(%)
NC 4" NC 4 NC 4 Va 56R" 35 Bolivian introductions 53 Guarani introductions 22 Peruvian introductions
103 112 119 120 137 134 145
Years tested
"Single plant selections from land races grown in North Carolina and Virginia.
6 6 4
8 3 3 3
No. of tests 20 19 13 38 3 3 3
60
1. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
genotype x environment interactions, are usually desired. Conversely, if cultivars are to be selected for specific environments, then cultivar development may be easier when large genotype x environment interactions are present. Several investigators have reported the presence and magnitude of genotype X environment interactions in peanuts. Chen and Wan (1968) measured the genotype x environment interaction using 13 peanut cultivars grown in Taiwan at 10 locations for 2 years. Both cultivar X year and cultivar x location interactions were small for yield; the cultivar x year X location interaction was highly significant. Ojomo and Adelana (1970) determined cultivar X environment interactions for 16 cultivars grown at 3 locations for 3 years in western Nigeria and found cultivar x location and cultivar x year X location interactions to be significant. The cultivars consisted of introduced lines and a few local standards. In Punjab, India, Sangha and Jaswal (1975), using 12 Virginia peanut cultivars, found significant cultivar x location and cultivar x year x location interactions for pod yield. Tai and Hammons (1978) estimated the magnitude of cultivar x environment interaction for pod yield, percentage sound mature kernels, percentage extralarge kernels, percentage fancy-sized pods, 100-seed weight, and other fruit traits for tests conducted under irrigated and nonirrigated management in Georgia at two locations for two years. The 19 cultivars used represented both early- and late-maturing groups. Significant cultivar x location x year interaction was found for most traits. The cultivar component of variance was larger than the first- and second-order interactions. Wynne and Isleib (1978) estimated cultivar x environment interactions for yield and several fruit traits for two groups of Virginia cultivars. A large cultivar X location x year interaction was observed for yield in both North Carolina studies. Both cultivar x location and cultivar x year interactions were small when compared to variation among cultivars. Yield, percentage sound mature kernels, and percentage extra-large kernels were determined for two years at two locations for nine crosses represented by eight lines per cross in the F4 and F5 generations by Wynne and Coffelt (1980) in North Carolina and Virginia. Cross populations and lines within crosses were significantly different for all traits. Cross populations interacted with the yearlocation environments for all traits, whereas lines within crosses interacted with the environment for all traits except yield. Although genotype x environment interactions vary with the material tested and the site chosen for testing, genotype X environment interactions in peanuts appear to be similar to those in several other autogamous species. Matzinger (1963) concluded that second-order interactions were prevalent in cotton, soybeans, and tobacco. In general, despite the results of Tai and Hammons, the second-order interaction also tends to be most important for peanuts. Thus the
PEANUT BREEDING
61
yield of a peanut cultivar in each individual experiment is unique and the environmental conditions differentiating the tests cannot be grouped according to years or locations. This is not surprising considering the indeterminate nature of the peanut. E. EVALUATION OF STABILITY
Because of limited resources peanut breeders have generally been interested in developing cultivars that are stable, that is, show a minimum of interaction over environments. Regression techniques have been used to characterize responses of genotypes under varying environmental conditions. Although many of the regression analyses used to measure phenotypic stability do not meet rigorous statistical requirements (Moll and Stuber, 1974), they are useful indicators of stability. Joshi et a / . (1972) measured the stability of five bunch genotypes and a local standard at seven environments in Gujarat, India, using the analysis suggested by Eberhart and Russell (1966). Cultivars showed average stability in all environments for yield. The local standard was low yielding in both good and poor environments, whereas one genotype, released for cultivation as “Junagadh, performed consistently well in both poor and good environments. Singh et al. (1975) evaluated eight cultivars for yield and stability at four locations in India during a single growing season. Their data were also analyzed using Eberhart and Russell’s (1966) methods. A significant genotype x environment interaction was found. Cultivar “M 13” (a subline of NC 13) had both high yields and average stability. Wynne and Sullivan (1978) found that eight Virginia cultivars differed in stability over environments for the percentage of seedlings that emerged. They tested at five locations in North Carolina during a 3-year period. Two cultivars, Florigiant and NC-Fla 14, produced a high percentage of emerged seedlings and gave greater stability over environments than the remaining six cultivars. The genotype x environment interaction for pod yield and days to maturity was found to be significant by Yadava and Kumar (1978) for 15 bunch genotypes grown in 4 environments at Hissar, India. The linear component of the genotype x environment interaction was significant for both traits, while the deviations from regression were also significant for days to maturity. The individual cultivars differed in stability for both traits as measured by both the regression coefficients. One cultivar was consistently early-maturing and high-yielding in all environments. Yadava and Kumar (1978) also used 17 genotypes grown in 4 environments to estimate genotype x environment interactions and stability parameter for 100-kernel weight, oil content, and shelling percentage. The linear and nonlinear portions of the genotype X environment interactions were signifi-
”
62
J . C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
cant for all three traits. One cultivar had consistently high 100-kernel weight and oil content in all environments. Another cultivar had high shelling percentage and was stable over all environments. The stability parameters for the different traits were apparently governed by independent genetic systems. In order to achieve stability of yield over a wide geographical area and over seasons, Norden (1 980) released cultivars that are early generation composites of 4-10 sister lines selected in the F4 through FBgenerations. Two such cultivars, Florigiant and Florunner, have been grown in the southeastern United States with outstanding results. The relative yield advantage and stability of this type of multiline was compared to its pure-line components in North Carolina and Virginia using 2 multilines composed of 4 sibling homozygous lines grown in 16 environments (Schilling et al., 1980). An analysis of stability was conducted to obtain a measure of relative stability among lines and a measure of the adaptation of each line to a range of environments. The two multilines did not yield significantly more than the better pure lines or the average of pure-line components. The stability for seed yield of the multilines was not different from the stability of the pure lines. The regression coefficients indicated that the mixtures were adapted to all environments, whereas the pure lines were different in their adaptation to the environment. These stability studies, although limited in number and scope, suggest that the adaptation and stability of a peanut line, both traits being under genetic control but acknowledged to be difficult to determine (Simmonds, 1979), should be evaluated and considered before a line is released for production. F. IMPLICATIONSFOR BREEDING PROCEDURES
With the evidence that additive genetic effects are the primary components of genotypic variance for traits of economic importance in peanuts, selection should lead to pure-line cultivars. Significant estimates of hybrid vigor in intersubspecific crosses notwithstanding the difficulty of obtaining hybrid seeds makes it unfeasible to develop hybrid varieties with favorable heterozygous gene combinations. Although evidence from soybeans indicates that in most cases homozygous lines surpassing the F, hybrid can be obtained (Brim, 1973), the amphidiploid character of peanuts might permit a breeding procedure that exploits both hybrid vigor and pure-line selection (see Fig. 3). Even if additive X additive epistatic variance is shown to be important, breeders will still have as their primary goal the production of pure-line cultivars. Breeding procedures such as the pedigree, modified pedigree, bulk, and backcrossing methods should continue to predominate in cultivar development.
PEANUT BREEDING
63
V. BREEDING METHODS Few novel breeding and selection methods for improving the peanut and other self-pollinated crops have been developed in recent years. The selection methods applied in peanut breeding are the same as those used in improving other autogamous species. These methods include mass selection, pedigree, bulk population, backcrossing, and other modifications of pure-line breeding methods, traditional procedures that have proved effective in the development of our best modern cultivars. A. INTRODUCTION A N D PURE-LINE SELECTION
Breeding programs at their inception can often fulfil their objectives through introduction and mass selection from, or direct use of, cultivars from other countries (Hildebrand and Smartt, 1980; Norden, 1980). Eventually, however, the breeder is confronted with the problem of combining the desirable traits of existing cultivars if advances are desired. Shorter (1978) found that although some introductions were higher-yielding than the local cultivars grown in Australia, these introductions were not acceptable to the peanut processing industry. This is generally the case in the presence of specialized markets and local pests. It is under these conditions that cultivar improvement through hybridization and selection provides its greatest opportunity (Norden, 1973). B . HYBRIDIZATION
I . Pure-Line Methods
Hybridization followed by selection among and within the offspring is currently the most common method used for improving peanuts. Norden (1973, 1980) suggested that parents be chosen that are adapted to and produce high yields within a given environment and that at least one parent of the cross be capable of reasonably high yields in the area where the new cultivar is to be grown. The pedigree breeding method with or without early testing or some modification is most often used by peanut breeders following initial hybridization. Cultivars developed by the pedigree method in Florida have been released as multiline strains (Norden, 1973). Each cultivar is a composite of 4-10 sister lines selected in the F4 to F8 generations. Each component line of a particular cultivar is so similar in phenotype that the individual lines are virtually indistinguishable.
64
J. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
The compositing of sister lines is expected to produce wider adaptability and stability than would result from any of the pure lines taken individually (Norden, 1973; Schilling et al., 1980). The individual lines are maintained separately by the breeder for future compositing. A number of peanut breeders utilize a bulk breeding method. The early generations are usually grown in bulk with single plant selections being made in the F6 or later generation. One of the major limiting factors in making progress in peanut breeding is the time required for cultivar development. After hybridization, it usually takes 12-15 years to develop a new cultivar. A modified pedigree method of selection using single-seed descent, proposed by Goulden (1941) and described by Brim (1966), has been applied to peanuts by Emery (Norden, 1973) and Wynne (1976b) in North Carolina. Using this method, each F2plant in the population is advanced by a single seed into late generation, where selection is practiced among essentially homozygous lines. The main advantages of this procedure are that the genetic variance for characters with low heritability is maintained and more than one generation can be obtained per year. This method has been used successfully at North Carolina to transfer southern corn rootworm resistance to lines with desirable agronomic qualities and to develop a high-yielding cultivar with early maturity. Details of the procedure are given by Wynne (1976b) and Wynne and Isleib (1980). This method combined with the use of a greenhouse, a phytotron unit, and a winter nursery in a tropical environment has been used to develop CBR-resistant peanut lines. Only 24 months were needed from the time of the initial cross to the evaluation of F5 progeny rows for pod characteristics and disease resistance. Early-generation testing for yield and other traits during the inbreeding phase is an alternative to rapid generation advance. Coffelt and Hammons (1974) used early-generation yield trials to test a large number of F2 lines from a single intersubspecific cross. They concluded that acceptable breeding lines can be selected using early-generation trials. Wynne (1976a) conducted a similar study but concluded that early-generation testing of crosses between lines from different botanical varieties was effective for fruit and seed size but was of limited value when selecting for yield. The first “hybrid” variety of peanuts produced in North Carolina, NC 2, was released from an early-generation testing program after only 5 years of yield trials of an F, progeny bulked in the F3 generation. Backcrossing is now being used in several peanut breeding programs (Krapovickas et al., 1968; Gibbons and Mercer, 1972; Norden, 1973). The procedure is mostly used for transferring desired traits from a donor source to an existing cultivar. With an increased emphasis on breeding for disease resistance, the backcrossing procedure may come to be used more frequently than in the past.
PEANUT BREEDING
65
2 . Population Improvement Traditional pure-line breeding methods impose severe restrictions on the amount of recombination among linked genes during the rapid approach to homozygosity. Branch (1 980), Norden (1 980), and Wynne and Isleib (1 980) report the use of multiple-crossing systems, such as the convergent cross, to create genotypic variability before selection. Hanson et al. (1967) suggested that the use of recurrent selection for self-pollinators should overcome the restrictions on progress imposed by selecting among homozygous lines generated from biparental crosses. Selection procedures that maximize recombination have not been used in peanuts because of the difficulties in making sufficient crosses to initiate the recombinational portion of each cycle and the length of time involved in each cycle (Norden, 1973). A modified recurrent selection scheme proposed by Compton (1968) and applied to peanuts by Wynne (1976b) minimizes the number of pollinations required per cycle while providing a large number of crosses between several genotypes. A winter nursery decreases the time required for each cycle to only 2 years even though the crosses are tested in the F4 generation. After only two cycles of selection, several crosses exceeded the yield of the check cultivar (Wynne and Isleib, 1980). A breeding procedure for self-pollinators called ‘‘a diallel selective mating system” (Jensen, 1970) is also being applied to peanuts (Wynne and Isleib, 1980). The method allows the breeder to use a selected group of parents and provides opportunity for multiparental gene recombination. As with other population improvement procedures, it is difficult to obtain the mass-crossing required to initiate each cycle.
VI. INTERSPECIFIC HYBRIDIZATION The utilization of the wild species in improving the cultivated crop is hampered by cross-incompatibility and sterility (Gregory and Gregory, 1979). Gregory and Gregory (1979) obtained 22 interspecific hybrids using cultivated peanuts as one of the parents. All of the hybrids were limited to section Arachis. It appears that the cultigen may be totally isolated from all species except those in section Arachis (Hull and Carver, 1938; Smartt and Gregory, 1967; Pompeu, 1977; Gregory and Gregory, 1979). However, because the diploid species of section Arachis will cross with species from sections Erectoides and Rhizomatosae, the genetic resources of more distantly related sections may eventually become available to peanut breeders through species bridging (Fig. 2 ) . With the introduction of germ plasm from the wild species of the section
66
J. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
FIG.2. Diagram of the crossing relationships in the genus Arachis. The symbols designate the sections and series of the genus as follows: A,, A,, AS, series of section Arachis; E l , &, &, series of section Erecroides; R,, &. series of section Rhizomarosae; C , section Caulorhizae; EX, section Extranervosae; T, section Triserninalae; and AM, section Ambinervosae. The arrows show the intraand intersectional hybridizations that have succeeded. The direction of the arrows indicates the direction of the cross, female X male (from Gregory and Gregory, 1979).
Arachis into breeding programs for peanuts, the simultaneous exploitation of additive genetic variance and hybrid vigor might be possible (Fig. 3). A similar scheme for another amphidiploid autogamous species, Nicotiana tabacum, was generated by Wernsman and Matzinger (1966). Smartt et al. ( 1 978) have suggested that A . hypogaea arose from an amphidiploid derived from a completely sterile hybrid similar to A . cardenasii (series Perennes) x A . batizocoi (series Annuae). If true, then adding genes from wild Perennes or Annuae in duplicate to each of the genomes of the amphidiploid A . hypogaea would be most difficult. In the absence of complete “dominance” for resistance across genomes, achievement of high levels of expression of the desired gene would be impossible. In case of a complete “recessive,” the whole effort would be worthless. However, Mroginski and Fernandez (1980) have recently succeeded in culturing plantlets from diploid cells of anthers of two different species of Arachis,
67
PEANUT BREEDING
both from section Erectoides. We speculate that the day of haploid plantlets from anther cells of A . hypoguea will shortly be at hand and that the breeding scheme for the simultaneous exploitation of hybrid vigor and additive genetic variance will be a viable alternative to the present prospect of gene substitution from wild species to cultivated peanuts by conventional methods. Even more remote is the possibility of recovering genes from distant species of Aruchis and by use of gene amplification to improve traits using techniques similar to those described by Schimke (1980) for experiments on the development of drug resistance in cultured mammalian cells (mouse and hamster). PROGRAM EXPLOITING ADDITIVE GENETIC VARIANCEAT Selected lines Line selections of species of Perennes genome haploid A . hypogaea
THE
DIPLOID LEVEL Selected lines species of Annuae genome 1
1
’
2
3 etc. PROGRAM EXPLOITING F, HYBRID VIGORWITHIN Selected 2n F, Selected 2n F, recurrent crosses to recurrent crosses to A . hypogaea haploids A . hypogaea haploids Annuae genome Perennes genome Induce to 4n level
THE
AMPHIDIPLOID
I
1
F:.--.2
2
3
.
1
3
I
Agronomic selection for combinability field testing for hybrid vigor at 4 n level and variety release program
I
Conventioh 4 n level breeding program and variety release program
FIG. 3. Proposed breeding scheme to exploit simultaneouslyadditive genetic variance and hybrid vigor.
68
J. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
VII. CONCLUSIONS Peanut yields in the United States have more than doubled during the past 40 years. Breeders have contributed from one-quarter to one-third of this increase through the development of high-yielding cultivars. The progress from breeding has been hampered by several factors including ( a ) the late initiation of peanut breeding programs (1930-194Os), (b) the regional importance of the crop in the United States, ( c ) the relatively few breeders assigned to peanuts, (d) the lack of financial resources, and (e) the difficulty associated with breeding an indeterminate crop whose fruit are formed underground. On a worldwide basis, international breeding efforts were boosted with the adoption of the peanut as a target crop by the International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics. Recognition of the importance of the peanut, particularly in developing nations, has given impetus to programs of breeding for disease and insect resistance, incorporation of diverse germ plasm into breeding populations, and population improvement. During the last two decades much emphasis has been placed on collection of wild species and exotic cultivars. As emphasis moves from collection to evaluation and exploitation of these genetic resources, progress in improving the productivity, pest resistance, and adaptability of the peanut can be expected. REFERENCES
Abdou, Y. A., Gregory, W. C., and Cooper, W. E. 1974. Peanut Sci. 1, 6-11. Arunachalam, A., Bandyopadhyay, Nigam, S. N., and Gibbons, R. W. 1980. “National Seminaron the Application of Genetics to Improvement of Groundnut,” pp. 1-19. Tamil Nadu Agricultural University. Ashri, A., and Goldin, E. 1965. Radiat. Bot. 5, 431-441. Avadhani, K. K., and Rao, B. V. R. 1968. Indian J . Sci. 2 , 77-82. Baker, R. J . 1978. Crop Sci. 18, 533-536. Banks, D. J . 1969. J. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 1, 23-28. Banks, D. J . 1976. Crop Sci. 16, 499-502. Bartz, J . A , , Norden, A. J., LaPrade, J. C., and DeMuynk, T. J. 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 53-56. Bernard, R. L. 1960. Ph.D. Thesis, North Carolina State Univ. Diss. Abstr. 21, 1028-1029. Beute, M. K., Wynne, 1. C., and Emery, D. A. 1976. Crop Sci. 16, 887. Branch, W. D. 1980. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. SOC. p. 48. Brim, C. A. 1966. Crop Sci. 6, 220-221. Brim, C. A. 1973. In “Soybeans: Improvement, Production, and Uses” (B. E. Caldwell, ed.), pp. 155-186. Amer. SOC. Agron., Madison, Wisconsin. Bromfield, K. R. 1974. F A 0 Plant Protect. Bull. 22, 29. Bromfield, K. R., and Bailey, W. K . 1972. Phytopathology 62, 748. Bromfield, K . R . , and Cevano, S. J. 1970. Plant Dis. Rep. 54, 381-838. Cahaner, A., Hillel, J., and Ashri, A. 1979. Theor. Appl. Genet. 55, 161-167. Campbell, W. V . , Emery, D. A., and Wynne, J. C. 1976. Peanut Sci. 3, 40-43. Campbell, W. V . , Wynne, J. C., Emery, D. A., and Mozingo, R. W. 1977. Crop Sci. 17, 346.
PEANUT BREEDING
69
Chen, C. Y., and Wan, H. 1968. J. Agric. Assoc. China 64, 1-12. Cherry, J. P. 1977. J. Agric. Food Chem. 25, 186-193. Cockerham, C. C. 1963. In “Statistical Genetics and Plant Breeding,”pp. 53-94. NAS-NRC Publ., Washington, D. C. Coffelt, T. A. 1980a. Crop Sci. 20, 419. Coffelt, T. A. 1980b. Peanut Sci. 7, 91-94. Coffelt, T. A., and Hammons, R. 0. 1974. Oleagineux 29, 23-27. Compton, W. A. 1968. Crop Sci. 8, 773. Cook, M. 1972. Plant Dis. Rep. 56, 382-386. Cooper, W. E., and Gregory, W. C. 1960. Agron. J. 52, 1-4. Crompton, C. E., Wynne, J. C., and Isleib, T. G. 1979. Oleagineux 34, 71-75. Duke, James A. 1980. In “The Handbook of Legumes (of World Economic Importance).” Plenum, New York. Duncan, W. G., McCloud, D. E., McGraw, R. L., and Boote, K. J. 1978. Crop Sci. 18, 10151020. Eberhart, S. A., and Russell, W. A. 1966. Crop Sci. 6, 36-40. Emery, D. A., and Wynne, J . C. 1976. Environ. Exp. Bot. 16, 1-8. Emery, D. A., Gregory, W. C., and Loesch, P. J., Jr. 1965. Radiar. Bor. 5, 339-353. Emery, D. A., Wynne, J . C., and Rawlings, J. 0. 1972. Radiat. Bor. 12, 7-18. Fonesca, S., and Patterson, F. L. 1968. Crop Sci. 8, 85-88. Foster, D. J., Wynne, J. C., and Beute, M. K. 1980. Peanur Sci. 7, 88-90. Frank, Z. R., and Krikun, J. 1969. Plant Dis. Rep. 53, 744-746. Garet, B. 1976. Oleagineux 31, 435-442. Garren, K. H. 1964. Phytopathology 54, 279-281. Gibbons, R. W., and Mercer, P. C. 1972. J. Am. Peanur Res. Educ. Assoc. 4, 58-66. Gibbons, R. W., Bunting, A. H., and Smartt, J. 1972. Euphyrica 21, 78-85. Gibori, A., Hillel, J . , Cahaner, A., and Ashri, A. 1978. Theor. Appl. Genet. 53, 169-179. Gillier, P. 1978. Oleagineux 33, 25. Goulden, C. H. 1941. Proc. Int. Gent. Congr. 7th, Edinburgh pp. 132-133. Gregory, M. P., and Gregory, W. C. 1979. J. Hered. 70, 185-193. Gregory, W. C. 1966. In “Plant Breeding” (K. J. Frey, ed.), pp. 189-218. Iowa State Univ. Press, Ames. Gregory, W. C. 1968. Radiar. Bor. 8, 81-147. Gregory, W. C. 1970. Crop Sci. 10, 459. Gregory, W. C., and Gregory, M. P. 1976. In “Evolution of Crop Plants” (N. W. Simmonds, ed.), pp. 151-154. Longmans, Green, New York. Gregory, W. C., Gregory, M. P., Krapovickas, A., Smith, B. W., and Yarbrough. 1973. In “Peanuts-Culture and Uses. ” Amer. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc., Stillwater, Oklahoma. Gregory, W. C., Krapovickas, A., and Gregory, M. P. 1980. In “Advances in Legume Science” (R. J . Summerfield and A. H. Bunting, eds.), pp. 469-481. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. Gupton, C. L., and Emery, D. A. 1970. Crop Sci. 10, 127-129. Hadley, B. A., Beute, M. K . , and Wynne, J. C. 1979. Peanut Sci. 6, 51-54. Hammons, R. 0. 1971. Crop Sci. 11, 570-571. Hammons, R. 0. 1973a. “Peanuts-Culture and Uses,’’ pp. 135-173. Amer. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc., Stillwater, Oklahoma. Hammons, R. 0. 1973b. J . Am. Peanur Res. Educ. Assn. 5 , 193-194. Hammons, R. 0. 1976. Crop Sci. 16, 527-530. Hammons, R. 0. 1977. PANS 23, 300-304. Hanson, W. D., and Weber, C. R. 1961. Genetics 46, 1425-1434. Hanson, W. D., Probst, A. H., and Caldwell, B. E. 1967. Crop. Sci. 7, 99-103.
70
J. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
Hassan, M. A., and Srivastava, D. P. 1966. J . Indian Bot. Soc. 45, 293-295. Hayman, 9. 1. 1954. Genetics 39, 789-809. Hayman, 9. I. 1958. Heredity 12, 371-390. Higgins, 9. 9. 1941. G a . Agric. Exp. Sin. Bull. 213, 3-11. Hildebrand, G. L., and Smarit, J . 1980. Zimbabwe J . Agric. Res. 18, 39-47. Holley, K. T., and Hammons, R . 0. 1968. Univ. G a . Coll. Agric. Exp. Sta. Res. Bull. No. 32. Hull, F. H., and Carver, W . A. 1938. Fla. Agric. Sta. Annu. Rep. pp. 39-40, Isleib, T. G., and Wynne, J. C. 1980. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Soc. 12, 74. Isleib, T. G., Wynne, J . C., and Rawlings, J. 0. 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 106-108. Isleib, T. G., Wynne, J. C., Elkan, G. H . , and Schneeweis, T. J. 1980. Peanut Sci. 7, 100-105. Jensen, N. F. 1970. Crop. Sci. 10, 629-635. Jinks, J. L. 1954. Genetics 39, 767-788. Jinks, J . L. 1956. Genetics 10, 1-30. Johnson, D. R., Wynne, J. C., and Campbell, W . V. 1977. Peanut Sci. 4, 9-1 1 . Joshi, S. N., Vaishanani, N. L., and Kabaria, M. M. 1972. Indian J . Agric. Sci. 42, 145-147. Kahn, A. R., Emery, D. A . , and Singleton, J. A. 1974. Crop Sci. 14, 464-468. Khan, 9. M. 1974. Ph.D. Thesis, Oklahoma State Univ. Diss. Abstr. 34, 4788b. Khan, 9. M., Wadsworth, D. F., and Kirby, J. S. 1972. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 4, 145.
Kornegay, J . L., Beute, M. K., and Wynne, J. C. 1980. Peanut Sci. 7, 4-9. Krapovickas, A . 1968. In “The Domestication and Exploitation of Plants and Animals” (P. J . Ucko and 1. S. Falk, eds.), pp. 427-441. Duckworth, London. Krapovickas, A. 1973. In “Agricultural Genetics, Selected Topics” (R. Moav, ed.), pp. 135-151. Wiley, New York. Krapovickas, A., and Rigoni, V. A. 1960. Rev. Invest. Agric. 14, 197-228. Krapovickas, A., Cenoz, H. M., and Ojeda, H. R. 1968. Bor. Cat. Genet. Fitotec, Corr. 5, 96. LaPrade, J. C. 1974. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Florida. Laynsse, A , , Wynne, J. C., and Isleib, T. G. 1980. Euphytica 29, 561-570. b u c k , D. B., and Hammons, R . 0. 1974. J . Econ. Entomol. 67, 564. b u c k , D. B., and Harvey, J. E. 1968. J . Econ. Enrornol. 61, 583-584. Lin, H. 1959. J. Agric. Assor. China 26, 44-48. Lin, H. 1966. J . Agric. Assoc. China 54, 17-24. Lin, H.,Chen, C. C., and Lin, C. Y . 1971. J . Agric. Assoc. China 47, 27-35. Marani, A. 1963. Crop Sci. 3, 552-555. Marani, A. 1968. Crop Sci. 8, 299-303. Martin, J . P. 1967. Oleagineux 22, 673-676. Mather, K. 1967. “The Elements of Biometry.” Methuen, London. Matzinger, D. F. 1963. In “Statistical Genetics and Plant Breeding” (W. D. Hanson and H. F. Robinson, eds.), pp. 253-279. Natl. Acad. Sci.-Natl. Res. Counc. Publ. No. 982, Washington, D.C. Matzinger, D. F., and Wernsman, E. A . 1968. Crop Sci. 8, 239-243. Melouk, H. A., and Banks, D. J . 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 112-1 14. Minton, N. A., and Hammons, R. 0. 1975. Plant Dis. Rep. 59, 944. Mixon, A. C. 1976. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. SOC. 8, 54-58. Mixon, A. C. 1980. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 12, 5 3 . Mixon, A . C., and Rogers, K. M. 1973. Agron. J . 65, 560-562. Mohammed, J.. Wynne, J. C . , and Rawlings, J. 0. 1978. Oleaginew 33, 81-86. Moll, R. H., and Stuber, C. W. 1974. Adv. Agron. 26, 277-313. Moll, R. H.,Salhuana, W. S., and Robinson, H. F. 1962. Crop Sci. 2, 197-198. Monasterios, T., Jackson, L. F., and Norden, A. J. 1978. J . Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 10,154.
PEANUT BREEDING
71
Moss, J. P. 1977. J . Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 9, 34. Moss, J . P. 1980. In “Advances in Legume Science” (R. J. Summerfield and A. H. Bunting, eds.), pp. 525-535. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. Mroginski, L. A., and Fernandez, A. 1980. Oleagineux 35, 89-92. Muheet, A., Chandran, L. S., and Agrawal, 0. P. 1975. Madras Agric. J . 62, 164. Nigam, S. N., Dwivedi, S. L., and Gibbons, R. W. 1980. In “Proceedings of the International Workshop on Groundnuts.” Patancheru, A. P., India. Norden, A. J. 1973. In “Peanuts-Culture and Uses,” pp. 175-208. Amer. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc., Stillwater, Oklahoma. Norden, A. J. 1980. In “Advances in Legume Science” (R. J. Summerfield and A. H. Bunting, eds.), pp. 515-523. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. Ojomo, D. A., and Adelana, B. 0. 1970. J . Agric. Sci. 75, 419-420. Parker, R. C . , Wynne, J . C., and Emery, D. A. 1970. Crop Sci. 10, 429-432. Pompeu, A. S. 1977. Cienc. Cult. 29, 319-321. Porter, D. M., and Hammons, R. 0. 1975. Peanut Sci. 2, 23-25. Porter, D. M., Beute, M. K., and Wynne, J. C. 1975. Peanut Sci. 2, 78-80. Rao, V . R. 1980. In “Proceedings of the International Workshop on Groundnuts.” Patancheru, A. P., India. Sandhu, B. S., and Khehra, A. S. 1976. Crop Improv. 3, 9-17. Sandhu. B. S . , and Khehra, A. S . 1977. Indian J . Genet. Plant Breed. 37, 22-26. Sangha, A. S . , and Jaswal, S. V. 1975. Oilseeds J . 5, 8-12. Shilling, T. T., Mozingo, R. W., Wynne, J. C., and Steele, J. L. 1980. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. SOC. 12, 71. Schimke, R. T. 1980. Sci. Am. 243, 60-69. Sharief, Y . , Rawlings, J. 0..and Gregory, W. C. 1978. Euphytica 27, 741-751. Shorter, R. 1978. Peanut Industry Workshop. Cons. Fertilizers, Kingaroy, Queensland. Simmonds, N. W. 1979. “Principles of Crop Improvement.” Longmans, Green, New York. Singh, M., Badwal, S . S., and Jaswal, S . V . 1975. Indian J . Genet. Plant Breed. 35, 26-28. Smartt, J . , and Gregory, W. C. 1967. Oleagineux 22, 1-5. Smartt, J . , Gregory, W. C . , and Gregory, M. P. 1978. Euphytica 27, 677-680. Smith, J . W., Jr., Posada, L., and Smith, 0. D. 1980. The Texas A&M Univ. System Publ. MP-1464, College Station, Texas. Smith, 0. D., Boswell, T. E., andThames, W. H. 1978a. CropSci. 18, 1008-1011. Smith, 0. D., Smith, D. H., and Simpson, C. E. 1978b. J . Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 5 , 193. Smith, T. E. 1961. Phytopathology 51, 411-412. Sowell, G., Jr., Smith, D. H., and Hammons, R. 0. 1976. Plant Dis. Rep. 60, 494-498. Sriwatanapongse, S., and Wilsie, C. P. 1968. Crop Sci. 8, 465-466. Stalker, H. T., Wynne, J. C., and Company, M. 1979. Euphytica 28, 675-684. Stuber, C. W. 1970. Crop Sci. 10, 129-135. Subrahmanyam, P . , Gibbons, R. W., Nigam, S. N., and Rao, V. R. 1980. Peanut Sci. 7, 10-12. Sun, P. L. F.. Shands, H. L., and Fornsberg, R. A. 1972. Crop Sci. 12, 1-5. Syakudo, K., and Kawabata, S . 1963. Jpn. J . Breed. B (3). 137-142. Syakudo, K., and Kawabata, S. 1965. Jpn. J . Breed. 15 (3). 167-170. Tai, P. Y. P., and Hammons, R. 0. 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 72-74. Tai, P. Y. P.,and Young, C. T. 1977. Peanut Sci. 4, 1-6. Tai, Y. P. 1972. Ph.D. Thesis, Oklahoma State Univ. Diss. Abstr. 33, 5698B. Tai, Y. P., and Young, C. T. 1975. J . Am. Oil Chem. SOC. 52, 377-385. Tappan, W. B., and Gorbet, D. W. 1979. J . Econ. Entomol. 72, 772-776. Wernsman, E. A., and Matzinger, D. F. 1966. Crop Sci. 6, 298-300. Widner, J. N., and Lebsock, K. L. 1973. Crop Sci. 13, 164-167.
72
J. C. WYNNE AND W. C. GREGORY
Wilson, D. M., Mixon, A. C., and Troeger, 1. M. 1977. Phytopathology 69, 159-162. Woodroof, J . G. 1966. “Peanuts: Production, Processing, Products.” AVI Publ., Westport, Connecticut. Worthington, R. E., and Hammons, R. 0. 1971. Oleagineux 26, 695-700. Wynne, J. C. 1976a. Peanut Sci. 3, 62-66. Wynne, J . C. 1976b. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 8, 44-47. Wynne, J . C., and Coffelt, T. A. 1980. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc 12, 75. Wynne, J. C., and Isleib, T. G. 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 102-105. Wynne, J . C., and Isleib, T. G. 1980. Proc. Am. Peanut Res. Educ. Assoc. 2, 48. Wynne, J. C., and Rawlings, J. 0. 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 23-26. Wynne, J . C., and Sullivan, G. A. 1978. Peanut Sci. 5, 109-111. Wynne, J. C., Emery, D. A,, and Rice, P. W. 1970. Crop Sci. 10, 713-715. Wynne, J . C., Rawlings, J. 0.. and Emery, D. A. 1975a. Peanut Sci. 2, 50-54. Wynne, J . C., Rowe, R. C., and Beute, M. K. 1975b. Peanut Sci. 2, 54-56. Yadava, T. P., and Kumar, P. 1978. Indian J . Agric. Res. 12, 1-4. Young, C. T., and Hammons, R. 0. 1973. Oleagineux 28, 293-297. Young, S., Kinzer, R. E., Walton. R. R., and Matlock, R. S. 1972. J . Econ. Entomol. 65,828-832.
ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY, VOL. 34
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS Umesh C. Gupta* and John Lipsett'f *Research Branch, Agriculture Canada, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, Canada and ?Division of Plant Industry, CSIRO, Canberra City, Australia
1. Introduction
73
11. Molybdenum Fertilizers, Their Rates and Methods of Application, and Industrial Uses
of Molybdenum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ill. Physiological Role of Molybdenum in Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Determination of Molybdenum in Soils and Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Total Molybdenum in Soils.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Available Molybdenum in Soils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... C. Molybdenum in Plants.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Responses to Molybdenum on Crops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Factors Affecting the Molybdenum Uptake by Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Parent Rock and Chemistry of Molybdenum in Soils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Soil pH ...................... C. Plant Species and Varieties . . . . . . D. Effect of Phosphorus and Sulfur . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Stage of Plant Growth and Plant Part Sampled . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Organic Matter. . . G. Drainage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Deficiency and Sufficiency Levels of Molybdenum in Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Molybdenum Deficiency and Toxicity Symptoms in Plants A. Deficiency Symptoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Toxicity Symptoms . . . . . . . . . . , . . , . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . IX. Molybdenum Toxicity and Molybdenum-Copper-Sulfur Interrelationships in Animals X. Summary and Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
75 78 81 82 82 84 85 89 89 94
96 96 97 98 99 99 100 100 104 105 107 109
1. INTRODUCTION Molybdenum is one of the most recently recognized nutrient elements considered to be essential for the growth of plants. The biological importance of Mo was not realized until Bortels (1930) showed that the element was highly beneficial in the fixation of N, by the nitrogen-fixing bacterium Azotobacter chroococcum.The essentiality of Mo for higher plants was first established by Arnon and 73
Copyright @ 1981 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
ISBN 0-12-000734-7
74
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
Stout (1939), who found that deficiency symptoms in tomatoes (Lycopersicon esculentum, Mill.) were controlled by the addition of minute quantities of Mo in the nutrient solution. This discovery later led to the detection of Mo deficiency in clover (Trifolium subterraneum L.) by Anderson (1942) and of “whiptail” in cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. borrytis L.) by Davies (1945) and Mitchell (1945). Responses to Mo have since been reported in a variety of crops in various countries of the world. Of the annual crops, tomatoes, lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.), spinach (Spanica oleracea L.), beets (Beta vulgaris L.), all the Brassica species [cauliflower, broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica Plenck. ), and rape (Brassica napus L.)] are very sensitive to restricted Mo supply (Johnson, 1966). Forage legumes, such as clover (Robinson er al., 1957) and alfalfa (Medicago sariva L.), also respond to Mo (Gupta, 1969). Deficiency symptoms for most micronutrients appear on the young leaves at the top of the plant because most micronutrients are not readily translocated. Molybdenum is an exception in that it is readily translocated and its deficiency symptoms generally appear on the whole plant (Bergmann, 1976). Symptoms include a general yellowing and stunting of the plant (Bergeaux, 1976), and interveinal mottling and cupping of the older leaves followed by necrotic spots at leaf tips and margins (Hewitt and Jones, 1948). Root interception and mass flow are considered to be the important mechanisms controlling the movement of Mo to plant roots growing in soil (Barber er a l . , 1966). Plants appear to absorb Mo in the form of the anion MoOiL- (Chesnin, 1972). This anion appears to be mobile as indicated by the experiments of Kannan and Ramani (1978), who found that when it was fed to one of the primary leaves of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.), most of it was transported to the stem and root. Tiffin (1972) stated that since H,MoO, is extensively dissociated in the range of pH 5-6, the anion MOO%- would therefore be the predominant form of Mo in plant xylem, assuming it does not associate with other plant constituents. It was further suggested by Tiffin (1972) that the form of Mo translocated in plants is unknown, and the possibility of organic complexing cannot be excluded. In soils Mo occurs in the following forms: (1) water-soluble present in the soil solution, (2) adsorbed by soil colloids, (3) held in the crystal lattice of minerals, and (4) present in organic matter (Bergeaux, 1976). Forms most available for plant use are the soluble forms present in the soil solution and Mo adsorbed by soil colloids. Highly weathered acid soils are apt to be more deficient in Mo (Giddens, 1964b). On the other hand, soils that are derived from granitic rocks, shales, slates, or argillaceous schists tend to be high in Mo (Kubota, 1972; Mitchell, 1974). Many peats, alkaline soils, and poorly drained soils with a high water table tend to produce forages high in Mo (Dye and O’Hara, 1959). The presence of large quantities of Mo in plants generally does not produce harmful effects or yield reductions in crops. Plant tissue Mo concentrations in
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
75
excess of 100 ppm (Allaway, 1977) andof 218 ppm (Gupta et al., 1978) in onion (Allium cepa L.) tops were not found to be associated with any toxicity. However, animals are quite sensitive to a high-Mo forage ration, which can cause Mo-induced Cu deficiency. Dietary levels of Mo of 10-20 ppm are nearly always associated with some evidence of disturbed Cu metabolism in ruminant animals (Allaway, 1977). Nonruminants, especially horses, are less subject to Mo toxicity. The objective of this article is to present an up-to-date report on soil as the source of supply of Mo, having regard to Mo availability to the plants, functions and methods of applying Mo in crops, factors affecting the Mo uptake by crops, and the interrelationship of Mo, Cu, and S in plants as associated with Mo toxicity in animals. The interaction effect of various factors in soils and plants will also be discussed.
II. MOLYBDENUM FERTILIZERS, THEIR RATES AND METHODS OF APPLICATION, AND INDUSTRIALUSES OF MOLYBDENUM Molybdenum can be applied to crops by various methods in the form of different fertilizer sources. In the most commonly used sources, Mo is present in the Mo6+ oxidation state as the ion in Na,MoO4.2HzO and (NH,),MoO, (Lehr, 1972). A list of some of the common sources of Mo fertilizers as outlined by Murphy and Walsh (1972) is given in Table I. Another source of Mo introduced recently is a yellow ammonium phosphomolybdate (NH4)3[P(Mo30,0)~] containing 61% Mo that is a reagent-grade experimental material (Cyanamid, 1970). Martinez et al. (1977) used molybdic acid for treating soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) seeds. Molybdenum frits containing 2-3% Mo (Murphy and Walsh, 1972) have also been used. Henkens Table I Percentage of Molybdenum and Chemical Formulae of Molybdenum Sources
Source
Formula
Sodium molybdate Ammonium molybdate Molybdenum trioxide Molybdenum sulfide
N%MoO,. 2 H 2 0 (NH&Mo,02, .4H20 Moo3 MoS,
Approximate Mo (%) 39 54
66 60
76
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
and Smilde (1966) found that frits are good sources of Mo and reported that their residual effect is somewhat larger than that of sodium molybdate. Molybdenum can be applied as a seed treatment, soil application, or as a foliar spray. The data summarized by Murphy and Walsh (1972) indicate that 50-100 g Mo/ha are generally needed for soil treatments on most agronomic crops and that as much as 400 g Mo/ha may be needed on vegetable crops, such as cauliflower. Applications of greater than 1 kg Mo/ha (Gupta and MacLeod, 1975) produced forages that could prove toxic if fed to livestock. For acid soils, broadcast applications of Mo are best mixed with limestone to prevent fixation of Mo (Berger, 1962). Molybdenum has also been applied to soils in combination with superphosphates and has been found to be readily available in a few New Zealand soils (Widdowson, 1966). Approximately 40-60% of the Mo applied by this method to beans (Phaseolus spp.) was recovered in the tops and seeds. Lipsett and David (1977) in Australia used molysuper, which is supposed to contain 0.04% Mo in each bag. However, the percentage distribution of Mo varied according to the fraction size, which was not evenly distributed within the bag. The fine material, which was mostly in the lower layer, contained an average of about 1900 ppm Mo compared with 1500 ppm in the medium-sized particles and only 260 ppm in the coarse ones. It was suggested that the addition of Mo be made during the early stages of manufacture, such as with the acid that is poured on the rock phosphate to produce even mixing.' The residual effect of Mo added to the soil varies from one soil to another. McLeod (1976) reported, based on his studies in New Zealand, that Mo applications of 140 g sodium molybdate would last 4-5 years. Gupta (1979) reported that the residual effect of Mo added at 0.4 kg/ha on some podzol soils should last 2-3 years from the crop sufficiency point of view. Foliar-applied Mo for rapid uptake and for overcoming Mo deficiency has been a common practice for many crops (Murphy and Walsh, 1972). Inden (1975) recommends use of wetting agents in the spray when applying Mo in foliar sprays on cauliflower or onions. Results of Gupta (1979) showed that foliar sprays may be more desirable than soil applications under dry conditions. It has been suggested that foliar sprays should allow a reduction in the rates of Mo needed to maintain adequate levels in certified hybrid maize (Zea mays L.) seeds (Weir et al., 1976); this method of application would also avoid the problem of Mo fixation in acid soils (Bergeaux, 1976). Weir etal. (1976) reported that both soil and foliar treatments of Mo raised the Mo concentration in corn (Zea mays L.) grain and leaves, but the foliar sprays were more effective. Spraying when the maize plants were 80 cm tall increased the Mo concentration in the seeds 'The company manufacturing the material now uses an oil carrier to try to improve adhesion.
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
77
more than earlier or later spraying. Likewise Boswell er al. (1967) found that the concentration of Mo in the kernels of peanuts (Arachis hypogaea L.) increased as the time of spraying was delayed for up to 6 weeks after bloom, after which there was a decline in the effect. Because of the extremely low Mo requirement of crops, the most common method of correcting a Mo deficiency is to treat the seeds with a Mo preparation. Seed treatment of Mo has been used to prevent Mo deficiency in Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea, var. gemmifera Zenker) (Gupta and Cutcliffe, 1968) and to increase the Mo concentration of soybeans (Golov and Kazakhkhov, 1973). The Mo content of seeds is important; for example, Hagstrom and Berger (1965) observed that large-seeded crops, such as peas (Pisum sativum L.), responded to soil applications of Mo when the seeds contained less than 0.2 pprn Mo, but not when they contained enough Mo (0.5-0.7 ppm) to supply the Mo needs of the crop. Gurley and Giddens (1969) also reported that high Mo content in large seeds may supply enough Mo to plants grown on Mo-deficient soils. In maize, severe Mo deficiency can be expected when seeds containing less than 0.02 ppm Mo are sown on Mo-deficient soils, but not when the seeds contain more than 0.08 ppm (Weir et al., 1966). Application of Mo in the lime of lime-pelleted legume seeds is a practical way of applying Mo in close proximity to the seeds and without detriment to the rhizobia in the inoculum (Date and Hillier, 1968). Results of Martinez et a f . (1977) indicated that when molybdic acid was seed-applied (0.04 ppm on soil basis), soybean growth was reduced. Although seed-applied Mo was at a low level when calculated on a soil basis, the concentration near the seeds would be higher than in the soil application and would account for the greater decrease in growth. Gupta and Kunelius (1980) found that use of moist seeds treated with a commercial Mo preparation at the rate of 14 g Mo/ha resulted in large quantities of Mo in forage crops, which when fed to the livestock could produce molybdenosis (Mo-induced Cu deficiency). In order to avoid excessively high concentrations of Mo in the crops, it would therefore be advisable not to treat germinating seeds with a Mo preparation. The rate of 28 g commercial source of Mo per 27 kg of seed (1 oz/bushel) is sufficient to meet the Mo requirement for soybeans (Bergeaux, 1976). According to the recommendation of Lancaster (personal communication from J. D. Lancaster of Mississippi State University in 1968) about 7-35 g Mo/ha (0.1-0.5 oz Mo/acre) annually is sufficient for seed treatment. Reisenauer (1963) also showed that seed application of sodium molybdate was much more effective than soil application for peas. The Mo supply was considered to be adequate when applied at the rate of 18-36 g/ha. Besides its use in fertilizers, Mo is used industrially as a component of hard, corrosion-resistant alloys with steel, a lubricant, and a pigment or other reagent,
78
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSE'IT
Table I1 Production of Molybdenum in 1976" Production ( lo3 tons)
Source
50.8
United States Canada Chile U.S.S.R.
13.4
9.8 8.8
Source
Production (lo3 tons)
China PeN Bulgaria Japan
I .8 0.8 0. I 0. I
"From Manheim and Landergren (1978)
notably catalytic. These uses account for the production shown in Table 11. Reserves amounting to a supply of 6- 10 years at this rate of usage appear to have been identified. Molybdenum is not abundant in the Earth's mantle, but it is widespread, as one would expect from its essential role in plants. Large amounts of Mo occur in sedimentary formations, especially marine manganiferous concretions. Concentrations may exceed 0.04%, but these amounts are not yet recoverable since the Mo tends to be dispersed in the sediments (Manheim and Landergren, 1978). The concentrations that are attributed to various materials are given in Table 111, based on Norrish (1975) and Manheim and Landergren (1978).
111. PHYSIOLOGICAL ROLE OF MOLYBDENUM IN PLANTS Molybdenum is a component of at least five distinct enzymes that catalyze diverse and unrelated reactions, namely nitrogenase, nitrate reductase, xanthine oxidase, aldehyde oxidase, and sulfite oxidase (Nicholas, 1975). Three of these enzymes, nitrate reductase, nitrogenase, and sulfite oxidase, are found in plants. The principal functions of Mo in plants are implicated in the electron-transfer system; for instance, nitrate reductase and nitrogenase require Mo in the reducTable 111 Concentration of Molybdenum in Rocks, Soils, Natural Waters, and Coal" Earth's CNSt
Igneous rocks
Sedimentary rocks
Soils
1
2
1-2
2 .O-2.5
"Values given in parts per million.
River, lake, and groundwater
0.5 x
10-3
Ocean
Coal
11.0 x 10-3
3-5
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, A N D ANIMALS
79
tion of NO,- and in the fixation of N,, respectively. This section will include a discussion of these two enzymes (molybdoproteins) as they function in the plant system. The first molybdoprotein, nitrate reductase, is known to require Mo and flavin for its activity and in the reduction of NO,- to No,- as follows: Reduced N A D
+ NO,-
+ NAD
+ NO,- + H,O
(1)
where NAD is nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide. The reduction mechanism from NO,- to NOz- has been proposed by Nicholas (1975) as NO,NO,-
+ 2H' + 2 e - + NO,- + H,O + H+ + 2e- -+ NO,- + OH-
Reaction (2) is based on the acidic half reaction, whereas reaction (3) allows for OH- participation at physiological pH. Nitrate reductase is found in most plant species as well as fungi and bacteria (Price et al., 1972). The increased Mo requirement of most plants grown on No,--N compared with NH,+-N can be almost completely accounted for by the Mo in nitrate reductase (Evans, 1956). The other major known molybdoprotein of plants, nitrogenase, fixes elemental nitrogen in the form of NH,, which is then assimilated by the plant (Koch ef al., 1967). The role of Mo in the fixation of N, has been reviewed in detail by Chatt (1974). The unique role of Mo in biological systems is exemplified by nitrogenase, the enzyme that converts N, into NH, at room temperature and normal pressure (Schrauzer, 1976). The nitrogenase is an enzyme complex composed of two distinct components that combine to reduce N, to NH, [reaction (4)] or acetylene to ethylene [reaction (5)] (Nicholas, 1975):
+ 6H+ + 6 e C,H, + 2H+ + 2eN,
-+
2NH3
+
GH,
(4)
(5)
Nitrogenases have been isolated from a variety of different sources, for example, from Azotobacter vinelandii, Rhizobium japonicum, Azotobacter chroococcum, and Klebsiella pneumonianum (Schrauzer, 1976). Recent studies by Agarwala et al. (1978) have shown that in addition to reduced nitrate reductase activity, Mo deficiency in corn resulted in significantly lower activities of catalase, aldolase, and alanine aminotransferase and higher activities of peroxidase, P-glycerophosphatase, and ribonuclease. In addition to the involvement of Mo in the fixation of N, and nitrate reduction, Mo is associated with other processes in plants. However, many of these processes are interrelated with the two main functions. For example, experiments of Malonosova (1 968) showed that addition of Mo to the soil resulted in better development of lupine (Lupinus spp.) and increased weight of its roots and nodules although the N, was not fixed. In this review of Russian work it was
80
UMESH C . GUFTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
reported that on soils containing little Mo, plants will develop many nodules on roots, but N, is not fixed. Merkel et al. (1975) showed that Mo deficiency in tomatoes decreased organic nitrogen content of the leaves to the same degree that it decreased the organic anion content of the leaves. This change was mainly in the contents of malate and citrate. Studies by Anderson and Spencer (1950) showed that deficiency of Mo decreased both the protein nitrogen and the nonprotein nitrogen percentages in the clover. The percentage crude protein in a number of plant species has been found to increase with optimum rates of Mo applied to the soil (Reddy, 1964). Hagstrom and Berger (1965) found that applications of Mo increased the nodulation and nitrogen content of peas and soybeans. The effect of Mo in plants is to increase the content of proteins and to create favorable conditions for the biosynthesis of nucleic acids (Peyve, 1969). Inden (1975) stated that deficiency of Mo can cause plant chlorosis, which is due to the inability of the plant to form chlorophyll. Further, since the deficiency of Mo reduces the rate of NO3- reduction in plants, photosynthesis decreases because the end products are not removed by combination with nitrogenous compounds. Das Gupta and Basuchaudhuri (1977) found that Mo applications enhanced the nitrate reductase activity in the rice (Oryza sativa L.) plant, particularly under the high-nitrogen nutrition. This ultimately led to greater concentration of reduced nitrogen and thereby created a concentration gradient for the uptake and subsequently greater assimilation of nitrogen in the tissues as suggested by Wardlaw (1968). This suggests that there exists a close functional relationship between the nitrate reductase activity and chlorophyll content as observed by Das Gupta and Basuchaudhuri (1977). The chlorophyll content of corn has been found to decrease due to a deficiency of Mo (Agarwala et al., 1978). Molybdenum was also considered to be associated with the metabolism of Fe and phosphoric acid (Inden, 1975). Premature sprouting of maize grain on the cob was shown to be controlled in glasshouse and field experiments by the Mo concentration of grain (Tanner, 1978). It was found that when the Mo concentration of grain fell below 0.05 ppm, sprouting occurred, the severity of which was enhanced by heavy, late sidedress of nitrogenous fertilizer. The explanation offered was that Mo-deficient plants have a decreased ability to reduce NO3- and consequent accumulation of inorganic NO3- promotes sprouting. Under Mo deficiency, plants accumulate low-molecular-weight nitrogen compounds and may have defective vascular bundles in the midrib in young leaves. There is a deposition of a brown substance on tissue surface and in intercellular spaces and cells (Busslar, 1970). Hewitt (195 1 ) pointed out that a low concentration of ascorbic acid in tissues is a characteristic of Mo deficiency in a number of species. Agarwala (1952) also demonstrated that cauliflower plants grown with various nitrogen sources, in-
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
81
cluding urea and ammonium sulfate, developed characteristic Mo deficiency symptoms known as “whiptail” and contained reduced concentrations of ascorbic acid. Subsequent studies by Agarwala and Hewitt (1955) showed that Mo deficiency decreased the total and reducing sugars in the leaves of young cauliflower plants. In nutrient culture studies in flax (Linurn usitatissirnurn L.), Mo has been found to be closely associated with the regulation of the deleterious effect of Mn, Zn, Cu, Ni, or Co on the physiological availability of Fe to the plant (Millikan, 1947).
IV. DETERMINATION OF MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS AND PLANTS Thiocyanate and dithiol are the two most commonly used reagents employed in the colorimetric determination of Mo from biological materials. The dithiol method used by Piper and Beckwith (1948), Clark and Axley (1955), and Bingley (1963) for plants and soils has been found to be more sensitive and precise than the thiocyanate method because the green-colored complex formed between Mo and dithiol was stable for at least 24 hours (Gupta and MacKay, 1965a). Later, Fuge (1970) developed a rapid and simple method in which a Technicon AutoAnalyzer is used for the determination of Mo on the basis of its catalytic action on the potassium iodide-hydrogen peroxide reaction. Fernandez et al. (1978) used 2,2-dihydroxybenzophenone reagent and considered it to be superior to the most commonly used Mo-thiocyanate complex method because an extra step is not necessary and the results are more reproducible. Molybdenum has also been determined spectrochemically after chemical concentration, using the cathode-layer arc technique (Mitchell, 1974) and polarography (Dekhkankhodzhayeva and Kruglova, 1972). Trace quantities of Mo have been determined by atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS), both flameless (Henning and Jackson, 1973; Jarrel and Dawson, 1978) and flame (Khan et al., 1979). Little and Kemdge (1978) used a carbon rod analyzer for determining very low levels of Mo. The high temperature required to atomize Mo in this procedure makes it easy to remove matrix materials during the ashing phase. The colorimetric method using dithiol and the most recently used AAS are probably the most commonly used techniques for determining Mo in soil and plant materials. The detection limits for determination of Mo by AAS using flame and graphite furnace have been found to be 10 and 2 ng/ml, respectively (Khan et al., 1979). Using the dithiol colorimetric method (Gupta and MacKay, 1965a), the satisfactory detection limit is about 20 nglml. The recovery of Mo added to the plant material as determined by these two methods has been found to range from 92 to 95%.
82
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
A. TOTAL MOLYBDENUM I N SOILS
The most common method for extracting Mo from soils is by perchioric acid digestion (Reisenauer, 1965). Dry ashing of soil and the extraction of ash using concentrated acids was employed for determining total Mo in soils by Perrin (1946) and Grigg (1953a). Total Mo has also been extracted by Na&O, fusion of soil (Purvis and Peterson, 1956). Unpublished data of the first author of this article showed that such extracts contained large quantities of interfering materials and required purification, which is time consuming. Little and Kerridge (1978) used HF-HC104 digestion for determining total Mo in soils. As for other plant nutrients, total Mo content of soils, except for very low levels, is generally not a good indicator of plant Mo availability (Little and Kemdge, 1978; Williams, 1971). Available Mo content has not been found to be closely related to the total Mo content of soils (Stone and Jencks, 1963). However, soil with a total Mo content of more than 20 ppm may be regarded as potentially “teart” (producing Cu deficiency in animals) in Scotland (Williams, 1971). Soils with low total Mo and neutral to alkaline pH may be depleted by many years of intensive cropping (Davies, 1956). Liming can correct Mo deficiency; therefore an estimate of total Mo content may provide some indication of the Mo supplying power of acid soils. Details of the effect of liming on Mo availability will be dealt with in Section VI,B. Little information exists on the levels of Mo in various soils but, in general, contents of 0.5-5 ppm are normal (Robinson and Alexander, 1953; Williams, 1971) and in agreement with the relative abundance of Mo in the lithosphere (2.3 ppm), whereas figures of 0.5 pprn or less would be considered particularly low (Williams, 1971). The Mo content of a few soils selected from areas of Canada close to industrial plants ranged from 1 .O to 11.3 ppm (Warren, 1973). MacLean and Langille (1973) reported that the Mo content of Nova Scotia (Canada) podzol soils ranged from 0.05 to 12.1 ppm. B. AVAILABLE MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS
The presence of extremely small quantities of Mo in the soil, the influence of chemical characteristics of soils (Karimian and Cox, 1979), the importance of seed reserves (Gurley and Giddens, 1969), and the possibility that seed reserves may mask a deficiency in the soil make the problem of determining Mo availability more difficult than for the other micronutrients. The first report on the available Mo in soils, which related extracted Mo to plant uptake, was by Grigg (1953b) in New Zealand. This involved an acid oxalate extractant buffered at pH 3.3. The responses and lack of responses as related to Mo extracted by Grigg’s reagent for a number of crops have been summarized by Reisenauer
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
83
(1967). However, oxalate-extracted Mo has not been found to correlate with Mo uptake by plants on various soils (Karimian and Cox, 1979; Little and Kerridge, 1978). The extracted-Mo values on some iron-rich soils may, however, be misleading (Little and Kerridge, 1978). Water has been used as an extractant for determining Mo in soils (Gammon et al., 1954; Lavy and Barber, 1964; Gupta and MacKay, 1965b). Difficulties are encountered in the analyses because quantities extracted are very low. Lowe and Massey (1965) used 10-hour leaching of soil with hot water and found the method to be more reliable for extracting available Mo than the Grigg method. Pathak et al. (1969) found hot-water-soluble Mo to be related to plant uptake of the element in a number of soils from India. The hot-water method, however, is time consuming and has not been tested extensively. Recently, anion-exchange resin (Dowex 1-X4) has been used to extract Mo from soils in Oregon (United States) by Bhella and Dawson (1972). The method involved equilibration of an aqueous soil-resin suspension and measurement of the sorbed molybdate using 2 M NaCl to displace it. The method was considered to be satisfactory, theoretically reasonable, and practically acceptable in assaying available soil Mo within the pH range 4.95-7.10. Later Jarrell and Dawson (1978) found that Mo uptake by subterranean clover ( T . subterruneum L., cv. Mt. Barker) grown in field experiments was significantly correlated with Mo extracted by anion-exchange resin. Although the Grigg and resin-soil test procedures may be used to separate Mo-responsive from non-Mo-responsive soils, neither was considered by Karimian and Cox (1 979) to be a good predictor of the size of response to Mo fertilization. They suggested that a measure of the degree of crystallinity of soil iron oxides, the active Fe ratio (amorphous Fe/free Fe), along with the soil pH could be used to reasonably predict response magnitude to Mo fertilization until a more reliable procedure is developed. Ammonium acetate and EDTA have also been used to extract Mo from soils; the extracted Mo together with soil pH and organic matter provided useful information on the potential uptake of Mo by pasture (Williams and Thornton, 1972). The most recent studies suggest extraction of soil after wetting it to field capacity and leaving it at this moisture content overnight (Little and Kemdge, 1978). A concentration of less than 4 p g Mo/liter thus obtained appeared to indicate soils that would respond to Mo application. A 12-hour extraction with 1 M (NH,),CO, at pH 9.0 was proposed by Vlek and Lindsay (1977) to reflect the more labile fraction that could come into solution. The amount of Mo obtained using this extractant on soils, with pH a 7 . 0 , amended with 0-2 ppm Mo as N+MoO, showed a correlation of r = 0.977 with Mo uptake by alfalfa. However, when soils with pH <7 were included, the correlation dropped considerably due to the extraction of more soil
84
UMESH C. GUFTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
Mo by (NH4)&03 than was available to plants. The method was considered to be good for predicting Mo toxicity in alkaline soils. With so many factors affecting the availability of Mo in soils and the uptake of Mo by plants, it is rather obvious that soil tests are often unsuccessful in predicting Mo deficiencies and toxicities. Microbiological assay of available soil Mo using A . niger has been used by Mulder (1948). It was later pointed out that, using this method, the discrepancy between the growth of cauliflower and the microbiological test could be ascribed to the presence of a high concentration of available Mn in the acid soils, which inhibited uptake of Mo by cauliflower but not by A . niger (Mulder, 1954). Soil Mo values obtained with A . niger have been reported to be only moderately correlated with field response (Donald et al., 1952) and not well related to soil solution Mo (Lavy and Barber, 1964). More recently Franco et al. (1978) used Azotobacter paspali nitrogenase activity (measured by acetylene reduction) to detect Mo deficiency in soils. The test is based on the percentage increase of nitrogenase activity of Azotobacter paspali growing in a defined medium with a small amount of soil as the Mo source. Using this test, 36 out of 41 soils tested showed a significant response to added Mo with a tropical forage legume (Centrosema pubescens Beth) and gave better correlation than the oxalate extractable Mo. C . MOLYBDENUM I N PLANTS
Due to the presence of Mo in microquantities in plant materials, its analysis is somewhat more difficult. However, due to advances made in the methodology for Mo as discussed earlier in this section, its analysis is carried out more precisely than before in most laboratories. Because of the unreliability of various methods of extracting Mo from soils from one region to another and from one group of soils to another, the analysis of plant materials for Mo continues to be one of the better indicators of Mo availability in soils as related to plants. The two most common methods of extracting Mo are dry ashing and wet digestion. Dry ashing has been used by Gupta and MacKay (1965a) and Fuge (1970). Recently Khan et al. (1979) used the wet digestion method and found that the results obtained were reasonably similar to those obtained by the dry ashing technique used by Gupta and MacKay (1965a). Wilson (1979) used matrix-compensated Mo standards to determine Mo in plant tissue by flameless AAS. The need for preparing Mo standards in an appropriate matrix solution was emphasized by the fact that an aqueous Mo standard gave an apparent Mo concentration 41% greater than a Mo standard prepared with the matrix solution of 0.55 M HC104. This acid concentration was used because the concentration of HClO., in the diluted plant digests ranged from
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
85
0.2 to 0.7 M. Concentrations of HCIOl ranging from 0.25 to 1.5 M had little effect on the observed Mo values. The recovery of Mo added to the plant digests of orchard leaves and alfalfa tops ranged from 95 to 105% (Wilson, 1979). Using this procedure, tissue Mo concentration of 0.1 ppm could be determined with good precision. However, tissue Mo values of 0.05 ppm and less were substantially less precise using this procedure.
V. RESPONSES TO MOLYBDENUM ON CROPS The criterion for response to an added nutrient in agricultural terms is usually an increase in growth of the plant, either in rate or in final yield. Sometimes a visible symptom of deficiency may be present, and its disappearance or prevention form part of the response. The first reported responses by higher plants to application of Mo were by tomato in solution culture, following scrupulous removal of all traces of Mo from the other nutrients (Amon and Stout, 1939). The purification was necessary because only extremely small amounts of Mo are required for normal plant growth. Some lower organisms-Azotobacter (Bortels, 1930), Clostridium (Bortels, 1936), and Aspergillus (Steinberg, 1936)-had already been shown to require Mo for the fixation of N, and for utilization of NO3-. Mulder (1948) showed that symbiotic Rhizobium in peas also required Mo for nitrogen fixation. It was further reported that “the growth-rate curve and the increasing sporulation of Aspergillus niger with increasing amounts of Mo were used in estimating very small amounts of this element in various materials. ” The first reports of responses by agricultural plants in the field soon appeared, notwithstanding reservations on the part of the first workers that a nutrient needed in such small amounts would be lacking in the field (Stout, 1972). Anderson (1942) obtained responses to Mo (applied as ammonium molybdate at a rate of 1 kg/ha) by the clover component of subterranean clover-perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.)-Phalaris tuberosa (now P . aquatica L . ) pastures in South Australia. Much work followed in Australia and other countries, and several conditions (“diseases”) in plants that had hitherto been unexplained were shown to respond to application of Mo. Probably the best known and most widespread of these was in cauliflower. “Whiptail” of cauliflower was marked by distortion of the leaf lamina. Quite early, cereals and other grasses were shown to respond to Mo (Fricke, 1947; Lobb, 1953; and Mulder, 1954, in Tasmania, New Zealand, and Holland, respectively). Several compilations (which will not be reviewed here) report the accumulated knowledge of Mo deficiency in agricultural plants, including field, horticulture, and pasture species (Wallace, 1951; Hewitt, 1956; Johnson, 1966; Lucas and Knezek, 1972).
86
UMESH C . GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSE'M
The early reports of responses by cereals to Mo application seem not to have affected commercial practice in cereal growing to any marked extent. Particularly in Australia (where deficient soils proved to be widespread), Mo deficiency was regarded as a complaint of Rhizobium, particularly that associated with subterranean clover. Because of this, subterranean clover with fertilizer N omitted became the standard experimental indicator plant. Molybdenum was applied in the field primarily in order to secure symbiotic fixation of N, for permanent pastures or leys. It was not applied unless the clover showed a response; associated grasses, or cereals in the rotation, were not assessed. However, Mo deficiency was reported in maize in a coastal area of New South Wales (Noonan, 1953). Further work of Weir and Hudson (1966) clarified the association of deficiency symptoms with seed reserves: symptoms were unlikely, even on low-Mo soils, for Mo contents in seed >0.08 ppm and likely for <0.02 ppm. Accordingly, application of Mo to crops producing hybrid seed of unsatisfactory content was stipulated as a requirement for certification (Weir et al., 1966). However, it was found that high rates of sidedress were often required. These were expensive and potentially hazardous to grazing ruminants in the rotation, so foliar sprays are now preferred (Weir et al., 1976). Maize appears to be relatively susceptible to Mo deficiency, particularly on acid soils. Tanner (1976) readily produced symptoms in the greenhouse and suggests that the problem is widespread in Rhodesia. Premature sprouting of the grain on the cob in Rhodesia has been linked with Mo-N balance (Tanner, 1978). Most of the corn in the United States seems to be adequately supplied with Mo from the soil. However, Brown and Clark (1974) reported Mo deficiency in a pot study of two inbred lines, grown on acid (pH 4.3) soil. One line developed symptoms (twisted leaves, chlorosis, and necrosis), whereas the other did not. Application of either Mo or lime cured the symptoms. This suggests different genetic abilities in taking up Mo from soil of low Mo availability. A relationship between deficiency symptoms and seed reserves has been found in some cases (Mulder, 1954; Hewitt, 1956), and has been advanced (Anderson, 1956) as a probable reason for the relative absence in early experience of deficiency in large-seeded legumes. Nevertheless, these species are by no means immune (de Mooy, 1970; Sedbeny et a f . , 1973; Parker and Hams, 1977), and the results suggest that deficiency may occur in the period of dependence on seed reserves of Mo before the new seedling of whatever species taps soil sources by means of an expanding root system. On the other hand, it is possible for a seed to contain more Mo than the whole new plant will require (Meagher et al., 1952). Meanwhile, application of Mo specifically to wheat (Triticum aesiivum L.) came to be practiced in Australia on soils that grew subterranean clover satisfactorily without it. In Western Australia, Gartrell (1966) found responses in grain yield by wheat and oats (Avenu sativa L.) on light sandy soils, particularly if ammonium sulfate was added. The untreated plants had a pale color and many
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, A N D ANIMALS
87
unfilled heads. In southern New South Wales, Freney and Lipsett (1965) and Lipsett and Simpson (1971, 1973) found that high levels of available N would render wheat seedlings responsive to Mo. The Mo had a protective function in alleviating damage (see Section 111) caused by accumulation of NO3- in the small plant. Of course, the protection breaks down if NO,- reaches high levels. It has long been known that fertilizer N commonly reduces grain yield in Australian wheat crops (Stonier, 1965; Dann, 1969), an effect most often ascribed to early exhaustion of moisture reserves in the profile, with consequent restriction of grain filling and hence of yield. There has been little experimental backing for this explanation, and the results with Mo (which attribute the reduction in yield to damage in the early seedling stage) may better account for the damage in many cases. Whatever the explanation, fertilizer N was avoided by farmers and bare fallowing was relied on to mineralize N for the crop. It appears that this intention may succeed too well at times, particularly in clover-based rotations, by mineralizing undue amounts of N. Aspects of the matter still to be investigated include the following: seasonal effects on mineralization and distribution of NO3- within the root profile; the role of seed reserves of Mo; the full geographical and pedological extent of the deficiency or imbalance; managerial practices in respect of N mineralization and N and Mo fertilizers. Plainly the temperate cereals are not immune to Mo deficiency. Since they are normally grown under cultivation, the appropriate techniques of applying Mo are not necessarily those that were worked out for undisturbed pastures. There is a relatively large gap between the plant requirement and the usual Mo fertilizer dressings, which provides an opportunity for economies by such techniques as seeddress or placement. These would appear mainly suited to crops that are reseeded frequently. It is not clear whether the tropical cereals suffer from Mo deficiency to any extent. Low available N and neutral to alkaline soils with adequate available Mo probably combine to safeguard the dryland crops in general. The nutrition of paddy rice (Oryza sativa L.) with respect to Mo is not clear, but should be considered because of the status of rice as a staple foodstuff. Rice in aerobic culture presumably exhibits at least the conventional requirement for Mo for nitrate reductase. Shukla et al. (1976) reported a field response to Mo in India by a new high-yielding variety. It might be expected that supplying N predominantly as NH4+ would lessen the demand for Mo in the paddy, whereas the likelihood of the presence of Fe'+ and Sz- ions would reduce the availability of Mo in the flooded soil. Although grasses in general have been thought to have low requirements for Mo, Lipsett (1975) found that Phularis tuberosa (now P . aquatica L.) was like wheat in showing a marked response to Mo on a soil on which perennial ryegrass grew strongly. It was not established whether the ryegrass was sustained by seed reserves, recovery of more soil Mo, or some other means. Phalaris aquatica
88
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
(tuberma) proved to be extremely sensitive to Mo deficiency in the seedling stage, particularly when supplied with NO3-. Johansen (1978a) examined three tropical grasses but found no marked sensitivity. However, there were indications of the interaction between Mo and Nog- on which this response to Mo is based. Since the yield response to Mo actually begins at an early growth stage, attempts have been made to describe and diagnose responsiveness by characterizing the biochemical processes that are affected most directly by the application of Mo. The activity of nitrate reductase in producing NO2-, and hence protein, and in lessening NO,- within the plant is the process primarily involved. Randall (1969) developed a method for diagnosing Mo deficiency in wheat by a bioassay of leaf material. Johnson et al. (1976) have suggested that nitrate reductase activity might serve as a predictive test of crop yield. One might expect a correlation where N is the main limiting factor. Responses by plants to Mo are closely related to soil properties, and consequently there are established geographical patterns of deficiency and of excess. Large areas of North America, Australia, New Zealand, and probably eastern Europe are potentially deficient. In Canada, responses to Mo have been limited to the eastern part of the country. The soils of this area are leached, are acidic, and have given response to Mo in controlling whiptail of cauliflower (Robinson and Campbell, 1956) and in increasing the yield of grass-legume hay and the nodule weight of red clover (Robinson et a!., 1957). Gupta (1969) reported that in greenhouse experiments, crops grown on coarse-textured soils gave response to Mo even when the soil was limed to pH 6.5. Results of field experiments conducted in Prince Edward Island showed that in the case of a suspected Mo deficiency, addition of about 0.2 kg Molha as a foliar spray or 0. 4 kg Molha applied to the soil should alleviate a Mo deficiency problem, and the residual effects at these levels of Mo should last 2-3 years (Gupta, 1979). There are many abstracts of reports dealing with Mo in the Soviet Union and associated countries, frequently with positive responses in yield. Valdek ( 1 974) and Agafonova et al. (1975) indicate that Mo is in regular use. Again, mainly light acid soils appear to be involved. Excessive amounts are of main concern in the western United States and Europe. Information is lacking for most of Africa, South America, and Asia, with the exception of India, where Mo appears to be generally in moderate supply. There is a dearth of reports for tropical areas in particular, yet there are large areas of leached, acid, ferruginous soils that would seem to be highly prone to Mo deficiency. Prasad and Page1 (1976) examined a range of tropical soils for ammonium acetate-extractable Mo, and reported a high incidence of deficiency in ferrallitic soils. Molybdenum deficiencies have been readily found in Queensland, Australia, in investigations for pasture establishment and growth on infertile soils (Jones and Crack, 1970; Bishop, 1974). The preference often shown
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
89
agriculturally for recent volcanic soils (as between Java and Sumatra) may reflect better Mo supply. It seems likely that Mo deficiency may be widespread on yellow earths and similar soils in resettlement areas in Indonesian Borneo (personal communication with L. F. Myers, CSIRO, Australia). The expectation is that any plant species sown on such soils would be potentially at risk of Mo deficiency, particularly if the crops involved are dependent on fixation of N, as their source of N. It is to be expected that the response in yield to Mo will be accompanied by an increase in Mo content, since applied Mo (or soil Mo on liming) is readily taken up by plants. Molybdenum contents can, in fact, reach levels at which the material is toxic to animals, notably ruminants. A figure of 10 ppm Mo in forage is widely assumed to be dangerous (see Section IX). This problem of molybdenosis may reflect soil properties, but the use of lime, the rates and frequency of application of Mo fertilizers, the composition of irrigation water, and the possibility of contamination from mining or from burning coal are all aspects to be considered. There were firm reports (Allaway, 1968), which seem not to have been followed up, that a relatively high Mo content in plant material in the diet favors dental health in humans.
VI. FACTORS AFFECTING THE MOLYBDENUM UPTAKEBYPLANTS A . PARENT ROCKAND CHEMISTRY OF MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS
1 . Parent Rock
Molybdenum is a transition element in the fifth row of group VIB of the periodic table. It is metallic and closely resembles tungsten (W) in chemical properties. General principles of the occurrence of Mo in the igneous rocks of the Earth’s crust are now fairly well established, since molten magmas represent comparable starting points of relatively well-blended materials. However, the concentration and form of Mo in other rocks and soils tend to vary according to particular origins and conditions of formation. Molybdenum is a versatile element insofar as valence is concerned, and it may precipitate under either oxidizing (Mofi+predominant) or reducing (Mo4+) conditions (Manheim and Landergren, 1978). Consequently, there may be local enrichments or depletions, and recent work is largely concerned with elucidating sequences of occurrence, mobilization, and deposition in particular situations. a . Occurrence in Igneous and Metamorphic Rocks. Igneous rocks make up some 95% of the crust of the Earth (Mitchell, 1964), and Mo occurs in both acid
90
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
and basic igneous rocks. Manheim and Landergren (1978) suggest an overall figure of nearly 2.0 ppm Mo for granitic rocks and somewhat lower for basalts. The Mo is found in feldspar and ferromagnesian minerals such as biotite and olivine, respectively. Although the occurrence of Mo in metamorphic rocks has not been widely studied, metamorphism would be expected to alter the form and site of occurrence rather than the amount of Mo present. New minerals may be formed that must undergo weathering-again, in the case of sedimentary parent materialbefore the Mo becomes available to plants. b. Occurrence in Sedimentary Rocks. The sedimentary rocks that are formed following weathering and transport usually retain some of the Mo of the parent material. Concentrations of Mo may be high if the rocks have formed under conditions favoring accumulation and precipitation of Mo, viz., at depth in oceans or in the presence of carbon (coals, oil shales, some limestones). The weighting given such sediments determines the average value actually quoted for Mo content. Manheim and Landergren (1978) suggest < I ppm Mo overall, but Norrish (1975) suggests 2 ppm. The lowest values are found in sandstones that contain stable minerals and have undergone high drainage losses. The carbonaceous materials are of interest mainly in relation to either contamination of the environment by spoil from mining and industrial uses or, in the case of some limestones, their deliberate addition to the soil for agricultural purposes. c . Weathering and Occurrence in Water and Soil; the Sedimentary Cycle. The Mo is released from rocks by weathering (Mitchell, 1964), which involves one or more cycles of solution, oxidation, and precipitation before the Mo from a given rock either appears in the soil formed from that rock or is transported to ocean sediments as part of the sedimentary cycle. Molybdenum is fairly readily released from primary minerals by weathering and, compared with other metals, it remains relatively mobile as potentially soluble molybdates (Mo")). Consequently, movement by leaching is likely, unless iron, aluminum, or manganese oxides interfere under conditions appropriate for occlusion on these minerals (Davies, 1956). Entry of Mo into surface or groundwaters is normal (Table III), and may be marked near ore bodies (Jackson et al., 1975), where the concentration may reach several ppm. Manheim and Landergren (1978) quote high natural values for rivers in arid regions, up to 10 p g Mo/liter, but suggest that pollution from industry and agriculture regularly leads to much higher values, and has caused a probable doubling in recent time of dissolved runoff of Mo. The amounts of Mo in coal (Table 111) indicate it to be one of the sources of the extra Mo. It appears in the ash and possibly in smoke and fumes. This dissolved Mo may be intercepted by anaerobic layers in lakes, and incorporated as the sulphide in bottom deposits, but the ocean is the ultimate sink for
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
91
the Mo that leaves the land. Currently there is an average concentration in the ocean of 11 p g Mo/liter (Table 111). The oceanic Mo may come out of solution, again into bottom deposits, under either oxidizing or reducing conditions. The former condition probably occurs under most oceans, and the latter occurs notably in the Black and Baltic seas (Manheim and Landergren, 1978). On land, the Mo content of the soil reflects the amounts in the parent rock. This and the effect of mobility are clearly seen near ore bodies where the influence of mineralization may be detected some distance away from the body. Measurements of the Mo content of soil have been used to locate deposits of Mo and associated metals such as Cu (Manheim and Landergren, 1978). Thornton and Webb (1 973) used the Mo content of stream sediment to map likely patterns of high-Mo soils in England and Wales. The soils of highest content are underlain by marine black shales. Soils on sediments in general vary more widely in Mo content than those on igneous rocks because the latter are more uniform. The variations of interest concern the extremes about the average figure of 2-2.5 ppm (Table 111) for soils. Since the requirements of plants for Mo are so low, removal in produce is not great as a rule, and absolute deficiencies were originally thought to be unlikely (Stout, 1972). However, they were duly found, initially on old soils in Australia (Anderson, 1956) and subsequently on the other continents. Soils formed on sandstones, which lack suitable minerals and may have already experienced heavy losses, are most likely to be deficient in total amount. Deficiencies also occur that are probably due to secondary reactions that reduce the availability of Mo. High Mo contents may be found in soils near ore bodies or formed on some shales. Plants may tolerate the high levels of Mo without difficulty (see Section I), but animals grazing on them develop molybdenosis (see Section IX). This was first reported for the teart disease of ruminants in Somerset, England (Ferguson et al., 1943). Further occurrences have been reported, particularly since it was realized that the toxic effects may be insidious, being quite substantial before clinical symptoms are shown. Particularly in the United States it seems that excess Mo is currently of more concern than are deficiencies. This reflects the predominance of young soils and the wide extent of Mo mineralization in the source areas of important imgation waters. 2. Chemistry of Molybdenum in the Soil The three dominant aspects of Mo as a soil species are occurrence as the anion, the effect of pH on solubility, and the possibility of changes in form with loss of availability. a . Occurrence as the Anion. It is now well accepted that Mo, having been released from crystal lattices by weathering, is found in well-aerated agricultural
92
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
soils (pH in water >5.0) mainly as molybdate ions, MoOL2- (Lindsay, 1972). This predominance of the anionic form makes Mo unique among metallic plant nutrients. It leads to known interactions with the other major anions SOg- and Pod3-, notably the reduction by SO%- of uptake of Mo (see Section VI,D). Thus it is feasible to control Mo content of forage at safe levels by applying SOL2(Gupta and Munro, 1969; Gupta and MacLeod, 1975). Reports disagree to some extent on whether PO-: affects uptake of Mo (Stout et al., 1951; Gupta and Cutcliffe, 1968); displacement from adsorption sites and competition for entry might be expected to have opposing effects. Whether NO3- ions as such interact also is not known, but it would seem possible. High concentrations of NO3appear to increase the requirement for Mo (J. Lipsett, CSIRO, Australia, unpublished results), but assessment of the precise interaction is hindered by the direct participation of Mo in removal of NO3- in the plant through the action of nitrate reductase (see Section 111). It seems that the chemical similarities between Mo0i2- and Po,3-(which were extensively relied on to establish a soil chemistry of Mo by analogy) were overemphasized. The similarities were most persuasive at acid pH, with respect to adsorptive reactions (see Section VI,A,2,c) with hydrous oxides of iron and aluminum (Smith and Leeper, 1969). At higher pH, on the other hand, Mo0L2and Pod- do not behave alike. High pH is marked by the presence of Ca2+ions, and whereas calcium phosphate has low availability to plants, calcium molybdate (CaMoO,) is readily available. Thus CaMoO, is too soluble to form or persist in most soils (Lindsay, 1972). b. The Effect of p H on Solubility of Soil Molybdenum. It is now well-known that availability of soil Mo to plants is, in general, increased by raising the pH and reduced by lowering it (see Section VI,B). However, high organic matter may in some way protect the Mo at low pH (Mitchell, 1964), which may explain the relative infrequency (Anderson, 1956) of Mo dressings applied to many of the Australian soils on which the deficiency was first observed. On these soils, clover growth was made possible by applying Mo with superphosphate, and soil organic matter increased substantially. Evidently, the only Ca added, that in the superphosphate, was not enough to saturate the new exchange capacity, and soil acidity increased (Donald and Williams, 1954). Nevertheless, the applied Mo apparently kept its availability, possibly because of protection by the organic matter. The use of lime has been postponed (Anderson, 1956) in this way. c . Forms of Molybdenum in Soils. The forms in which Mo occurs in soil are not yet completely described because of the difficulties in dealing with small amounts of relatively labile material. Five potential fractions are recognized: 1. Primary crystalline material. 2. Water-soluble molybdates in the soil solution. 3. Organically complexed Mo.
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
93
4. Molybdate adsorbed on positively charged surfaces. 5. Discrete, secondary compounds, either crystalline or amorphous. A full description of soil Mo would include extents of occurrence in these five categories, the transformations between them, and the availability of Mo in each to plants. It seems that high amounts of available Mo are probably the result of high values in fractions 2 and 3; thus wet soils high in organic matter commonly yield plants high in Mo (Davies, 1956; Kubota et al., 1963). Low amounts may reflect low content in the soil overall, but may also arise from the occurrence or formation of the fractions 4 and 5. The relative roles of these fractions are the main concern in the chemistry of deficient soils and in the correction of the deficiency. Smith and Leeper (1969) considered that in many of their soils residual availability of Mo applications was lost by slow reactions with the soil rather than by leaching. The implication is a transition into fraction 5. Recent work suggests that fractions 4 and 5 may be rather vaguely differentiated, particularly at certain pH values. The principal positively charged sites in the soil for anionic adsorption are provided by hydrous oxides of Fe and A1 (Reisenauer et al., 1962; Childs and Leslie, 1977). The importance of Fe in the reaction is shown by consistent correlations between it and Mo (Norrish, 1975). Molybdenum so held would presumably be well placed to form definite compounds with Fe, but Vlek and Lindsay (1974) believe that Fe,(MoO,), as such is too soluble to persist in soils as a major inert form. They favor PV+ as the most drastic combining cation, if it is present. Even PbMoO, would become more soluble if pH were to rise. Occlusion of Mo in fermginous concretions would seem to impose positional unavailability, and further work is needed on the association between Mo and Fe, which begins with adsorption of MOO,'- ions. For a time it was suggested that Mn played a part in immobilizing Mo, but its oxides do not develop a positive charge even under alkaline conditions (Childs and Leslie, 1977). Furthermore, the marine nodules in which there are conspicuous amounts of Mo and Mn are formed from alkaline solutions relatively high in both (Manheim and Landergren, 1978), so extrapolation to soil conditions does not seem to be valid. There seems to be little direct evidence for the mechanism that puts Mo into Mn marine nodules at high pH. d . Effect of Iron and Aluminum Oxides. The effect of adsorption in restricting the rate of supply of to plants is shown by the significant negative interaction term in the regression of extracted on plant response (Barrow and Spencer, 1971). Iron oxides found in acid soils carry positive charges and can react with MoOil-. Jones (1957) showed that a soil high in free iron oxide sorbed the largest quantities of MOO,'- from aqueous solution. Likewise, Karimian and Cox ( I 978) showed that Mo adsorption on mineral soils increased with free iron oxide content. Aluminum oxides are also capable of removing Mo from
94
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
aqueous solutions, but their effectiveness is less than that of iron oxide under the same conditions (Jones, 1957). Adsorption of Mo by Fe,O, is pH-dependent, as reported by Jones (1956), who showed that adsorption of Mo by Fe,O, i n a solution containing 100 p g Mo decreased from 98 p g at pH 7 to 22 p g at pH 9 after shaking for 15 hours with 100 mg of amorphous Fe,O,. It was suggested that Mo, in fermginous soils, is held on the surface of the colloidal femc oxides as the anion, which is replaceable by OH- ions. Since H+ and OH- are considered potential-determining ions, they cause a change in surface potentials of minerals with pH changes (Vlek and Lindsay, 1977). The adsorption maximum of MOO,'- on hematite was found to be reduced by 80% if the pH was changed from 4 to 7.75 (Reyes and Jurinak, 1967). The zero point of the charge of the hematite occurred at pH 8.0. A method for quantifying the amount of reactive hydroxides present on the surfaces of soil colloids has been suggested that involves reaction of soil with 0.85 M NaF solution at pH 6.8 (Perrott et al., 1976). The measurement of the released OH- in the first 25 min correlated well with extracted A1 and Fe. Fluoride ions reportedly bring structural AI and Fe"+ ions into solution, releasing OH- as ligands on the central Al or Fe ions (Huang and Jackson, 1965). However, Jarrell and Dawson (1978) reported that the Mo content of plants correlated poorly with Mo sorbed by the soil and NaF-released hydroxyls. Their work showed that Mo adsorption was related to the (NH,),C,O,-extractable Fe in the soil but not to other fractions of extractable Fe or to extractable Al forms. The (NH,),GO,-extractable Mo has also been found to be correlated with amorphous and free iron oxide contents, and this was probably a result of strong dissolution of iron oxide by oxalate (Karimian and Cox, 1979). B . SOILpH
Soil pH is one of the most important single factors affecting the uptake of Mo in plants. The beneficial effects of liming acid soils to increase Mo solubility are obvious. The concentration increases 100-fold for each unit increase in pH (Lindsay, 1972). With increase in pH, the soluble Moo4,- species in equilibrium with soil Mo is much greater than for HMoO,- and H,MoO,. At a pH of 5 or 6, the ion HMoO,- becomes dominant and at very low pH values the unionized acid H,MoO, and the cation MOO,'+ are the principal species present (Krauskopf, 1972). The anion exists in an exchangeable form in the soil. Thus, the fact that Mo availability to plants increases with increasing pH may possibly be explained by an anion exchange of the type 2 OH- Ft (Berger and Pratt, 1965). Even wulfenite (PbMoO,), the least soluble of possible soil compounds, becomes more soluble as pH increases (Vlek and Lindsay, 1974), so that the mode of action of liming in increasing the availability of Mo seems straightforward.
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
95
Earlier, Amin and Joham (1958) proposed a Mo cycle within the soil in which it is possible that oxidation may contribute to Mo availability in the long term and that immediate availability of the element may be governed by the equilibrium between MOO, and the salt form. Under acidic conditions the balance would be in favor of MOO,, thus reducing the amounts of molybdate salts present. This would account for the fact that Mo availability is lowered by increasing acidity. The highest amounts of available Mo are associated with soils derived from limestone and shale parent material (Stone and Jencks, 1963). In general, the need for Mo fertilization of most soils can be met by adequate liming of the soil. Ahlnchs et a1. (1963) stated that for Minnesota soils, the recommended liming practices substantially increase the Mo content of vernal alfalfa and thus direct Mo fertilization for those soils was not essential. Likewise, Rolt (1968) stated that with 2 tons of lime plus Mo or 4 tons of lime alone the maximum yield of white clover could be obtained. In a number of crops, a significant interaction effect between applied Mo and lime has been noted, whereby the increases in Mo concentration with added lime are of much greater magnitude with applied Mo than without added Mo (James el al., 1968; Gupta, 1969; Gupta et al., 1978). Unpublished results of U. C. Gupta and J . A. MacLeod on podzol soils of eastern Canada showed a continuous increase in the Mo concentration of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) plants with increases in the rates of lime application from 0 to 20 g/kg soil (Table IV). The lime rates were associated with a pH range of 4.9-8.0 and very small pH increases were noted beyond the 10-g lime rate. The soil pH increases from 4.9-5.6 to 7.0 increased the plant tissue Mo concentrations from 0.13-0.19 to 0.66 ppm. However, further pH increases to pH 7.8-8.0 resulted in much higher tissue Mo concentrations of 1.69-3.42 ppm. The principle of Mo release upon liming is dependent upon the total Mo content of soils. For example, lime applications to pH 6.5 on two soils of Prince Edward Island did not produce maximum yields of alfalfa and cauliflower in a greenhouse experiment (Gupta, 1969). Some addition of Mo was necessary to achieve maximum yields. Likewise on a sphagnum peat soil some addition of Mo, besides liming, was necessary to obtain maximum yield of some vegetable crops (Gupta et a / . , 1978). The observation of Anderson (1956) that plants responded to wood ashes but not to lime indicated the need for something in the ashes that was simply not provided by raising soil pH. Well-limed or naturally neutral soils may also be depleted of available Mo by cropping or by leaching (Johnson ef al., 1952). Rubins (1956) noted that some Mo deficiencies have occurred on well-limed or naturally neutral soils and on acid soils derived from calcareous parent materials. On highly oxidized soils of the southeastern United States, a high initial rate of 1 1,200 kg lime/ha or the equivalent amount in annual applications did not eliminate the need for Mo application to maintain alfalfa stands on these soils (Giddens and Perkins, 1972).
96
UMESH C. GUPTA AND JOHN LIPSETT
Table IV Effect of Increasing Lime Levels on the Mo Concentration of Barley Boot Stage Tissue (BST) on Three Soils“ Albeny sl
Charlottetown fsl Lime rate (g/kg soil)
Soil pH
Mo in BST (ppm)
0 0.8 1.7 2.5 3.5 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0
5.6 6.0 6.4 6.9 7. I 7.6 7.8 7.9 7.8
0.19 0.22 0.40 0.66 1.26 1.93 2.79 3.21 3.42
Soil pH 4.9 5.5
6.2 7.0 7.1 7.5 7.7 7.8 7.9
Culloden sl
Mo in BST (ppm)
Soil pH
0.14 0.13 0.26 0.60 0.68 0.94 1.09 I .34 1.69
5.4 5.6 6.2 6.7 7.1 7.6 7.8 1.9 8.0
Mo in BST (ppm) 0.13 0.15
0.18 0.45 0.58 1.16 I .62 2.03 2.70
“Unpublished results of U. C. Gupta and J . A. MacLeod, Research Station, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, Canada.
C . PLANTSPECIES A N D VARIETIES
Plant species have been found to have some influence on the plant tissue Mo concentration. Findings of Kubota and Allaway (1972) showed that different forage legumes grown on the same soil have nearly the same amounts of Mo. They further stated that grasses generally contain less Mo than legumes. Studies by Brogan et al. (1973) also showed that the Mo concentration is higher in clover than in grass growing on soils high in Mo. Gupta (1979), however, working on podzol soils of eastern Canada could not find consistent differences in the Mo concentration of red clover and alfalfa when compared to that of timothy. The cultivars of plant species have been found to differ in their ability to absorb Mo. For example, Chipman et al. (1970) found that among cauliflower cultivars “Pioneer” was not as efficient as “Snowball 84” in the uptake of Mo, especially at low levels of supply. D. EFFECTOF PHOSPHORUS A N D SULFUR
Plant uptake of Mo is usually enhanced by soluble P and decreased by available s. Earlier studies by Stout et af. (1951) showed that higher P levels in culture solutions increased Ma uptake as much as tenfold and therefore soil applications of Mo with P fertilizers may be effective. Since then a number of researchers‘have observed a similar effect of P on Mo uptake by plants.
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
97
The effect of P in increasing the concentration of Mo in plants has been reported to be associated with the stimulating effect of Po43ions on the uptake of Mo due to the formation of a complex phosphomolybdate anion, which is absorbed more readily by the plants (Barshad, 1951). Addition of S has been found to decrease the Mo content of crops, such as Brussels sprouts (Gupta and Munro, 1969), raya (Brassica juncea L.) (Pasricha and Randhawa, 1972), Berseem (Trifolium Alexandrinum L.) (Sisodia et al., 1975), soybeans (Singh and Kumar, 1979), tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) (Sims et al., 1979), and perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) and clover (Williams and Thomton, 1972). Significant Mo rate X rate interactions have been reported for Mo concentrations whereby adding fertilizer had a detrimental effect on the growth of burley tobacco at low soil Mo levels but positive effects at high soil Mo levels (Sims et al., 1979). A recent study by Singh and Kumar (1979) showed that applications of 40 ppm S significantly increased the total Mo uptake in 45- and 110-day-old soybean plants. This increase was suggested to be governed by yield and plant tissue Mo concentration. The inhibitory antagonistic effects of SO,’- on Mo content have been suggested to occur primarily during the absorption process, with some antagonistic mechanism involved during translocation from roots to leaves. McLachlan (1955) reported that deficiencies of P and S can limit the response to Mo unless P and S are applied. In both instances there is a deficiency of P and S rather than an indirect effect on Mo uptake. It was further stated that a deficiency of either P, S , or Mo is no indication of deficiency or sufficiency of the other two. E. STAGEOF PLANTGROWTHA N D PLANTPARTSAMPLED
The Mo content of tobacco leaves was found to be greater than other plant parts (Pal et al., 1976). Studies on tomato by Stout et al. (1951), on alfalfa by Reisenauer (1956), and on soybeans by Singh and Kumar (1979) showed that leaf tissue Mo was considerably higher than that of the stems. The interveinal areas of leaves have been found to preferentially accumulate Mo (Stout and Meagher, 1948). In the case of cereals, the Mo concentration of grain is generally lower than that of the boot stage tissue or straw in low-Mo soils. However when Mo was applied at 0.5 ppm or higher, the Mo concentration of grain was considerably lower than that of the boot stage tissue (Gupta, 1971a). With maturity, the Mo content of leaves and stems was found to decrease in soybeans (Singh and Kumar, 1979). It was also noted that grain contained higher quantities of Mo than either leaves, stems, or pod husks. In solution culture studies on Phaseolus vulgaris L. roots were found to contain higher quantities of Mo than stems and leaves (Wallace and Romney, 1977).
98
UMESH C. GUF'TA AND JOHN LIPSEIT
Unpublished data of U. C. Gupta (Research Station, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island) also showed that leaves of a number of plant species contained more Mo than petioles or stems with the exception of red clover (Table V). The above-ground vegetative portion of the plant is generally lower in Mo than the seeds. The Mo content of seeds varies from one plant species to another. In a study conducted on Prince Edward Island, the unpublished results of the first author of this chapter revealed that samples collected from adjacent sites showed the Mo content of seeds of a few crops to be in the following order: peas > barley > wheat. F. ORGANIC MATTER
The level of Mo adsorbed has been found to be closely related to soil organic matter (Karimian and Cox, 1978). Since Mo acts like an anion in the soil, it is difficult to explain its adsorption by organic matter. However, certain soils high in organic matter have been found to be deficient in Mo (Mulder, 1954; Davies, 1956). Mulder (1954) found a pronounced response to added Mo in several crops grown on these soils. The presence of organic matter may also promote the availability of certain elements, presumably by supplying soluble complexing agents that interfere with the fixation of elements. For example, soils rich in organic matter contain a readily exchangeable Table V Range of Mo Concentration of Plant Parts of Various Species from Five Locations Plant species Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gernmifera Zenker) Broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. iraka Plenck.) Cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. borryyris L.) Rutabaga (Brassica napohrassica Mill.) Alfalfa (Medicago snriva L.) Red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) "Mean ppm Mo given in parentheses.
Leaves
Petioles
0.11-2.98 (0.90)"
0.12-0.62 (0.36)
2.16- I I . 16 (3.76)
0.37-4.28 (1.76)
0.54-3.72 ( I .65)
0.37-1.10 (0.98)
0.20-1.59 (0.65) 0.10-0.72 (0.28) 0.06-0.23 (0.12)
0.17-0.78 (0.32)
Stems
0.08-0.28 (0.15) 0.08-0.35 (0.15)
MOLYBDENUM IN SOILS, PLANTS, AND ANIMALS
99
mobile Mo0i2- ion (Koval’skiy and Yarovaya, 1966). Laboratory experiments involving additions of various organic materials, such as compost, farmyard manure, and peat, to the soil increased the extracted Mo after 4-12 weeks of incubation (Gupta, 1971b). However, in the presence of added Mo the extracted Mo was consistently lower where organic materials were added. Bloomfield and Kelso (1973) reported that the anionic form of Mo persisted in solution even after a 3-week incubation period with anaerobically decomposing elant material. G . DRAINAGE
Generally, there have been few studies on the chemistry of Mo in the wet soils that produce high-Mo plants (Allaway, 1977). This may be due to the difficulties in transfemng the wet, poorly aerated conditions found in the field to conditions suited to precise laboratory studies of Mo solubility. However, soil wetness is one of the chief factors affecting the availability of Mo. Poorly drained soils accumulate so much available Mo0i2- that the plants grown on them produce toxicity when fed to animals (Davies, 1956; Kubota et al., 1961). Peats and mucks are products of a wet environment and are associated with Mo toxicity in the United States in the soils of the California delta, the Klamath area i n Oregon, and the Everglades in Florida (Kubota, 1972). Some Scottish soils with poor pedological drainage produced plants containing large quantities of Mo (Mitchell, 1974). The early term “peat scours” for Mo toxicity in cattle and sheep strongly suggests that the problem occurs frequently on wet soils. Well-drained soils, e.g., podzols and krasnozems, are likely to be low in Mo, and there is little enrichment in any layer (Mitchell, 1974). Wet soils, such as those in swamps and lakes that are not leached, te