SEQ 0001 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0001 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The...
23 downloads
1917 Views
29MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
SEQ 0001 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0001 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The Hatfield Memorial Lectures Volume III
SEQ 0002 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0002 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Dr William Herbert Hatfield FRS, 1882–1943. Courtesy of Sheffield Industrial Museums Trust
SEQ 0013 JOB IOM8627-000-016 PAGE-0003 PRELIMS REVISED 04AUG05 AT 00:07 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The Hatfield Memorial Lectures Volume III Edited and Foreword by
Peter Beeley
Woodhead Publishing and Maney Publishing on behalf of The Institute of Materials, Minerals & Mining
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
SEQ 0004 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0004 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Woodhead Publishing Limited and Maney Publishing Limited on behalf of The Institute of Materials, Minerals & Mining Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB1 6AH, England www.woodheadpublishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA First published 2005, Woodhead Publishing Limited IoM Communications Ltd, 2005 The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the author nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Woodhead Publishing ISBN-13: 978-1-84569-101-1 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN-10: 1-84569-101-6 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN-13: 978-1-84569-114-1 (e-book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN-10: 1-84569-114-8 (eook) CRC Press ISBN-10: 0-8493-9242-X CRC Press order number: WP9242 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset in the UK by Dorwyn Ltd, Wells, Somerset Printed by TJ International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall, England
SEQ 0005 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0005 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Contents Foreword Printed Sources
vii ix
Process Technology and Research Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention in the Birth of New Metallurgical Processes, F. D. Richardson, 1964 Twenty-Five Years On, H. M. Finniston, 1968 Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy, E. Pl¨ockinger, 1972 Eurosteelresearch, R. S. Barnes, 1973 From Invention to Industrial Development, L. Coche, 1978 Net Shape Solidification Processing of Steel, 1945–1995, M. C. Flemings, 1989 The New World of Steel, J. Edington, 1995 Technology–Driving Steel Forward, M. J. Pettifor, 2001 Metallurgical Modelling of Thermomechanical Processing, C. M. Sellars, 2002 Economics and Developments in the Iron and Steel Industry Development in the Iron and Steel Industry in Great Britain during the last Twenty-Five Years, T. P. Colclough, 1954 The Place of Mini-Steelworks in the World, W. F. Cartwright, 1971 Materials and Malthus, Sir Alan Cottrell, 1974 European Steel: What Future? Sir Robert Scholey, 1987 Iron, the Hidden Element – the Role of Iron and Steel in the Twentieth Century, R. Boom, 1999 Author Index Subject Index
1 3 25 45 63 89 97 101 123 143
165 167 183 201 207 227
247 249
v
SEQ 0006 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0006 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
SEQ 0007 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0007 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Foreword This third volume of Hatfield Memorial Lectures comprises two groups. In the first of these the central theme is process metallurgy, the lectures encompassing technical aspects of plant design and operation, including associated research and development. Lectures in the second group address the organization of the iron and steel industry, including its general structure and economic circumstances. Although there is occasional overlap, these two broad themes complement the three contained in the two earlier volumes, to cover five fields as contemplated at the outset: Volume I is devoted to Properties and Behaviour of Materials and to Applications, and Volume II to the single theme of Metallography and the Structure of Iron and Steel. A similar system to that used in the earlier volumes has been adopted in the present case: the lectures are arranged in date sequence within each group, providing pictures of the respective subject areas over the whole period since the outset in 1946, when the first lecture was delivered by Dr Hatfield’s contemporary Dr George B. Waterhouse. This dealt with Hatfield’s own work and formed the introduction to the first volume, which also contained biographical notes on Hatfield himself; further aspects of his life and character were portrayed in Professor A. G. Quarrell’s personal recollections, which provided the introduction to Volume II. William Herbert Hatfield had been born in 1883 and had died in 1943. The Memorial Lecture series had been instituted by the University of Sheffield in 1944 as a joint project with the Royal Society and the Iron and Steel Institute. The fiftieth lecture, the most recent and last to be included in the present series of volumes, was delivered by Professor C. M. Sellars of the same University in December 2002. The annual Hatfield Lecture continues to draw large audiences from far afield and reflects the ongoing interest in the major metallurgical advances of our time. Many of the chosen topics have significance over the wider field of materials and across diverse branches of engineering. It is hoped that supplementary volumes will add to the record of these occasions at suitable intervals in future years, and will be arranged on a similar thematic basis. Peter Beeley
P. R. Beeley DMet is a Life Fellow and former Senior Lecturer in metallurgy in the University of Leeds
vii
SEQ 0008 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0008 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
A shot at leisure. A picture of W. H. Hatfield from the Firth Brown Photographic Collection. Courtesy of Sheffield Industrial Museums Trust (copyright)
SEQ 0009 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0009 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Printed Sources Listed below are the lecture numbers, titles and authors of each of the papers appearing in this volume. The original place and date of publication are also given. Seventh Lecture: Development in the Iron and Steel Industry in Great Britain during the last Twenty-Five years, by T. P. Colclough J. Iron Steel Inst., July 1954, 297 Sixteenth Lecture: Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention in the Birth of New metallurgical Processes, by F. D. Richardson J. Iron Steel Inst., March 1965, 217 Nineteenth Lecture: Twenty-Five Years On, by H. M. Finniston J. Iron Steel Inst., February 1969, 145 Twenty-second Lecture: The Place of Mini-Steelworks in the World, by W. F. Cartwright J. Iron Steel Inst., April 1972, 221 Twenty-third lecture: Electroslag Remelting a Modern Tool in Metallurgy, by E. Pl¨ockinger J. Iron Steel Inst., August 1973, 533 Twenty-fourth Lecture: Eurosteelresearch, by R. S. Barnes Ironmaking Steelmaking, 1974, 1 (2), 61 Twenty-fifth Lecture: Materials and Malthus, by Sir Alan Cottrell Met. Mater., March 1975, 32 Twenty-eighth Lecture: From Invention to Industrial Development, by L. Coche Met. Mater., February 1979, 25 Thirty-fifth Lecture: European steel: what future? By Sir Robert Scholey Ironmaking Steelmaking 1987, 14, 267 Thirty-seventh Lecture: Net Shape Solidification Processing of Steel, 1945–1995, by M. C. Flemings Report from Cast Metals, 1990, 2 (4), 231 Forty-third Lecture: The New World of Steel, by J. Edington Ironmaking Steelmaking, 1997, 24 (1), 19 Forty-seventh Lecture: Iron, the hidden element: the role of iron and steel in the twentieth century, by R. Boom Steel World, 2000, 5, 1, 88 Forty-ninth Lecture: Technology: driving steel forward, by M. J. Pettifor Steel World, 2002, 7, 11 Fiftieth Lecture: Metallurgical Modelling of Thermomechanical Processing, by C. M. Sellars Previously unpublished
ix
SEQ 0010 JOB IOM8627-000-013 PAGE-0010 PRELIMS REVISED 31JUL05 AT 22:03 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
SEQ 0003 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0003 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE SIXTEENTH HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention in the Birth of New Metallurgical Processes F. D. Richardson At the time the lecture was given, Professor Richardson was Professor of Extraction Metallurgy at the Imperial College of Science and Technology. The lecture was presented at Church House, Great Smith Street, London, in the evening of Wednesday 25 November 1964.
I am greatly honoured that you should have invited me to give this 16th Hatfield Memorial Lecture. Honoured because of the importance and standing throughout the metallurgical world of our Iron and Steel Institute, and honoured because of the distinction of the man to whom these lectures are a memorial. I was not privileged to know Dr Hatfield, but from all I have read and heard of his life, I realise that I missed knowing a truly remarkable man. Many remember him for his obvious achievements – his work on stainless and heat resisting steels, his post as Director of Firth Brown, his Chairmanship of three very important ISI Committees, his Fellowship of the Royal Society and his Bessemer Medal. But to those who worked personally with him there remains a lasting impression of enterprise, energy and openmindedness: an awareness of scientific ability in others, great intuition, and style in all things.
When I came to consider a subject for this lecture I looked at Dr Hatfield’s Campbell Memorial Lecture1 given in the USA in 1928, and I was struck by his sharp interest in new ideas and new developments: by his recognition of the importance in this connexion of the growth of purely scientific knowledge and of the need for industrial enterprise and the state to ‘cast its bread upon the waters’ and help those who work, particularly in the universities, to develop the fundamental aspects of their subjects. I therefore came to thinking of the way new processes come about. I suppose that today people are searching as never before for new ideas which show promise of becoming new processes. At the same time most of us are unaware of how the new processes which surround us came to be developed. Although full details of existing processes are often available, the exact ways in which they have come about are rarely disclosed. I have always found the histories of new developments extraordinarily interesting and I think we can learn from them. I know that Halevy wrote ‘We learn from history that we do not learn from history’, and this pessimistic view may be true as regards politics and international affairs. But
3
SEQ 0004 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0004 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
4
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
when it comes to scientific development I believe some greater optimism is justified. I have therefore decided to look at a number of new processes and to examine how they came about, and at what points basic knowledge, discovery, and invention had their own particular impacts. I have chosen extractive processes because they are my special interest. I shall include both ferrous and non-ferrous topics, because much of interest has been happening in the non-ferrous world, and because I consider we lose a great deal if we restrict our thoughts, or our reading, to one field or the other. It is difficult to acquire the detailed historic knowledge with which I am here concerned for it is not to be found in books. I am therefore personally indebted to those who have so kindly given me the information I have sought. But before I come to discuss those modern processes I wish to dwell shortly on the character of the men who bring about new processes – or what may be called the ‘flesh and blood’ aspect of development.
THE INVENTIVE SPIRIT For a few minutes therefore let us go back to 1870 and to a young man of twenty, who was the first to look seriously at the chemistry of slags, and what more entrancing subject could you have than that! I refer to Sidney Gilchrist Thomas who in 1878 brought forth the basic steelmaking process. A lively, unfinished sketch of him is shown in Fig. 1. despite his frail physique, Thomas possessed exceptional enterprise, energy and intuition, and he coupled these with that singleness of purpose, which is usually needed for a great invention. At the age of twenty he had a mind uncluttered with irrelevant experience and he was able to think along lines which were closed to experienced metallurgists such as Percy and Lothian Bell. Thomas epitomises the human aspect of creating a new process. He had the character of an inventor; and was always looking for unsolved problems. We see him for example insisting, thirty five years before Haber’s synthesis, that ammonia should be produced from air and water because the elements hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen were to be had for nothing from these sources. In 1870 Thomas was the clerk in the Thames police court, working to support his widowed mother and family. Chemistry was his hobby and he attended a course of lectures at the Birkbeck Institution, delivered by George Challenor. At this juncture Challenor justified all the lectures he ever gave, for, with Thomas in his class, he had occasion to say that the man who eliminated phosphorus from iron by means of the Bessemer converter would make his fortune. This challenge sank deeply into Thomas’s mind and inspired him to wrestle with the idea for eight years, excited as much by the commercial prospect as by the scientific challenge. One cannot but be reminded of the young Hall who was similarly inspired by Professor Jewetts when studying chemistry at Oberlin, Michigan. From then on Hall’s ambition was to find a way of producing aluminium cheaply and he invented the electrolytic process in 1886, simultaneously with H´eroult in France but quite independently. I hope we university professors are as inspiring today as we were at the end of the
SEQ 0731 JOB IOM8627-001-013 PAGE-0005 16TH LECTURE REVISED 06FEB05 AT 19:27 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
Fig. 1
5
Portrait of Sydney Gilchrist Thomas.
last century! Sometimes I think that in teaching our students we lay too much stress on the unsolved theoretical problems and too little on the unsolved practical ones. We have a great opportunity to invent by proxy and we ought not to miss it! The problem of phosphorus elimination existed because there were great quantities of phosphoric ores; the orebody was providing the impulse for development as is so often the case in extractive metallurgy. The problem was solved in principle in the space of five years; during this time Thomas pieced together in an original way the available chemistry of phosphoric acid and silica, and of the slag–metal reactions which occur in the acid Bessemer and the old puddling processes. The problem was solved in practice after a further two or three years of dedicated work, during which Thomas obtained the help of his cousin Percy Gilchrist at Blaenavon steelworks in Wales. In this period Thomas ran, at first secretly, his tests with hot metal and developed the basic linings and the method of making lime additions. Most of the work was done at weekends, which started with a night’s journey from London to Blaenavon, and finished with a dash from the train home so Thomas could be in court on Monday morning. As Thomas wrote laconically in a letter to his cousin2 ‘I have not time enough to do. I only go home to sleep and eat. Most unsatisfactory’.
SEQ 0006 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0006 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
6
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Ultimately this hard struggle undermined Thomas’s health and he died in 1895. But by then he had reaped a great harvest of fame and had shown himself to be a man of social as well as technological imagination. His success depended on brilliant scientific extrapolation, and on invention in making the linings. A similar theoretical approach to this problem was made simultaneously by George Snelus, who was a chemist at Dowlais Steelworks and some thirteen years older than Thomas. He had likewise concluded that a basic lining would be necessary if phosphorus were to be removed in the converter process. Snelus appears to have been the only other man to stand on the verge of Thomas’s invention. He was also a remarkable man, later a Fellow of The Royal Society and Vice-President of The Iron and Steel Institute, but his way of life was utterly different from Thomas’s. He was an expert shot, an enthusiastic horticulturalist, and a staunch conservative, in much demand for public meetings, at least according to the Proceedings of the Royal Society! With all these interests he had not that singleness of purpose which is required to turn a good idea into a workable process. Today we seem far away in time from 1878, and our industrial scene has vastly changed. But the reactions we exploit in steelmaking are much the same and some of our current thoughts on the utilisation of slag are just the kind that Thomas would have had. For Thomas saw that the mountains of phosphoric slag that accrued from his basic process contained great quantities of phosphorus which could be of value in agriculture. He devoted the last years of his life to this problem and to buying tons of slag in anticipation of success! It was at first thought that the valuable phosphorus should be extracted chemically from the slag, but it later turned out that for agricultural use, it was only necessary to grind the slag to a sufficiently fine powder. As often happens, the ultimate solution to the problem was simpler than anyone had dared to hope. Today we have again become concerned with making use of slags, those blast furnace slags which we have regarded all too complacently in the past, and there is hope that inspired and tenacious work will lead to the production of useful microcrystalline bodies from this material.
BASIC KNOWLEDGE AND THE STRUCTURE OF METALLURGY Since Thomas’s time there have been enormous developments in our understanding of scientific and engineering principles. Metallurgy has developed in three main directions, first on the physical side, then the chemical and now most lately on the process engineering side. I referred to this matter in detail in my Howe Memorial Lecture to the AIME last February.3 Tonight I merely wish to stress that these three basic sectors are equally important and they provide the springboard from which the metallurgist must take his leaps into the unknown, it he is to make the best use of all the basic knowledge which has been accumulated before him. I find it convenient to represent the metallurgy of today by two triangles which will help to make clear the terms I use later in this lecture. These are shown in Fig. 2. On the left are the three basic sectors of chemical metallurgy, physical metallurgy and process
SEQ 0007 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0007 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
7
engineering metallurgy. Most of the phenomena of metallurgy can be considered on the micro scale, in terms of chemical and physical metallurgy. But as soon as one turns to the behaviour of metallurgical materials in bulk or to any form of processing, it is essential to bring in process engineering metallurgy. This is concerned with fluid and plastic flow and heat and mass transfer, in all kinds of metallurgical situations. It covers the principles involved in chemical and physical processing ranging from ore upgrading to metal treatment, and is especially concerned with phenomena, in which the chemical engineer has not so far displayed any marked interest. I call this sector process engineering though it might equally well be termed process science. It is a metallurgical responsibility and I do not believe that we can wait for the chemist to come up with the answers in chemical metallurgy. We have only to ask ourselves how much would be known about the chemistry of steelmaking, if it had not been for the work of Chipman, Korber, Oelsen, Herty, Schenck, and other distinguished scientists working principally in the metallurgy departments of universities or in the steel industry.
Fig. 2
The anatomy of metallurgy: (a) the three basic sections; (b) the three applied sections.
Founded on the three basic sectors of metallurgy are three applied sectors as shown on the right hand side of Fig. 2. These are extractive metallurgy based primarily on chemical and process engineering metallurgy, mechanical metallurgy (or metal treatment) based primarily on physical and process engineering metallurgy, and materials science (the design and behaviour of new materials and alloys) based primarily on chemical and physical metallurgy. The shaded overlap between these three sectors is meant to stress that none of them is based so completely on two of the three basic sections, that it is entirely independent of the third. The relative importance of the three basic sectors of metallurgy in any new development depends on the precise nature of the new steps. Broadly speaking there are three
SEQ 0008 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0008 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
8
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
kinds of new development; processes based on new reactions, in which both chemical and process engineering factors are important: processes in which old reactions are exploited in new ways, and which therefore depend primarily on new process engineering: new routes from ore to metal, in which existing processes are integrated in new ways, and which depend on critical path analysis and optimisation via systems engineering. If we look at this group in an iron and steel context we see that so far as oxide routes from ore to metal are concerned, there is little or no likelihood of discovering important new reactions, apart possibly from some vaporisation reactions, which might conceivably become important in vacuum refining. New oxide processes must therefore come from conducting old reactions in new ways, and such developments hinge on finding new methods of obtaining the necessary heat and mass transfer, either more conveniently or at greater rates. New iron and steelmaking reactions may, however, be found in halide routes; we have already seen the novel work of Reeve in this direction, and now the Peace River scheme in Canada (see below) looks to be imaginative and promising. New reactions may also be found in routes involving aqueous and organic solutions, and in this area I feel much awaits to be discovered. Reactions in such media may be uneconomic today but the progressive cheapening of heavy organic and inorganic chemicals may make them worthwhile in the future. Such routes will always involve relatively expensive chemicals, and these, especially the halogens and the organic solvents, must be recovered and recirculated, so that they do their chemical work again and again. For new aqueous and organic processes to become competitive for steel, I believe they must supplant not only the steps of iron and steelmaking but also much of the route from ingot to finished or semi-finished product. One way of doing this is to make powders and to rolll them into strip. This latest step is the weakest link in the chain of operations, and those interested in such routes need to concentrate much of their work on this stage.
THE ZINC-LEAD BLAST FURNACE A splendid example of a new process in which old and well known reactions have been exploited in new ways is the zinc–lead blast furnace,4 developed by the Imperial Smelting Corporation, with furnaces working or building in the UK, Australia and Europe. The blast furnace which is often considered ‘old hat’ in the iron and steel industry is very much ‘new hat’ in the zinc world. These zinc furnaces are rectangular in section; they have about 100 ft2 of hearth area and produce about 160 tons of zinc and 80 tons of lead per day. The process is represented in broad outline in Fig. 3. Our story starts in the late 1930’s when Stanley Robson and Kenneth Morgan of the Imperial Smelting Corporation considered it important to free the production of zinc from the small scale imposed upon it by continuous retorting. Their idea was to reduce a zinc oxide sinter to zinc vapour in a blast furnace and to recover the metal from the blast
SEQ 0297 JOB IOM8627-001-011 PAGE-0009 16TH LECTURE REVISED 21DEC04 AT 01:50 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
9
Fig. 3 Broad outline of the zinc–lead blast furnace process.
furnace gases. They saw that by this means they might also be able to treat lower grade concentrations than the retort process could accept. At the time they were much stimulated by a very good and imaginative review by Maier5 of the US Bureau of Mines, entitled ‘Zinc smelting from a chemical and thermodynamic standpoint’. This report in no way foreshadowed the zinc blast furnace. Rather the reverse, for it showed how the old idea of making liquid zinc in a blast furnace under high pressure was inherently unsound. Nevertheless Maier unwittingly contributed to the new process, for his report laid the basis for much of the thermodynamic reasoning done in the course of the development. This needs stressing for the contributions which reviews of this type make to industrial progress is all to often forgotten. Robson and Morgan realised that on grounds of fuel economy, it would be essential to convert substantial amounts of carbon to carbon dioxide and to carry this in the top gas. This brought with it a great risk from the back reaction Zn + CO2 = ZnO + CO which might occur so rapidly on cooling the top gases that the yields of metal would be poor. There was a second intrinsic chemical risk: that it might be impossible to avoid serious losses of zinc oxide in the slag, if the oxygen potential at the bottom of the furnace were kept high enough to keep iron oxide in the slag and prevent the production of solid iron. There were virtually no activity data on slags at that time (we have much more precise ideas today) but in the event this did not turn out to be a difficulty.
SEQ 0010 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0010 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
10
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
At the time the back reaction looked to be the most likely cause of failure; but the investigators had noted that in the existing process for fuming zinc from molten slag and recovering zinc oxide, reoxidation of the metal vapour was not so swift or complete as to preclude all hope of success. Shortly before the war the Corporation’s Research Department made some small-scale experiments on shock cooling gas mixtures of Zn + CO + CO2 by means of water cooled tubes and the results gave some encouragement. During the period 1945 onwards, a thorough thermodynamic analysis, together with heat balances, was made for the process by Stephen Woods and John Lumsden. It became clear that it should be possible to retain iron in the slag provided one could obtain a satisfactory control on the oxygen potential at the bottom of the furnace, and mass transfer in this region did not let one down. It also became clear that a good balance between Zn, CO, and CO2 in the top gas would be about 6% of metal, with a ratio of CO/CO2 of about 2/1 The problems then centred around the suppression of the back reaction and collection of the zinc. A small experimental brick furnace was built and fed with hot briquettes and cold coke. The zinc laden gases were drawn away at about 900°C via a flue situated about half way up the furnace. They were then passed through a heated column of coke to raise their temperature to 1000°C and eliminate some of the potentially dangerous carbon dioxide. Finally the gas was shock cooled by bubbling through liquid zinc. But the suction required to operate this condenser was undesirably high and the amount of reoxidation was unacceptably large. A highly original proposal was then made by Jack Derham. His idea was to bubble the gases through cool liquid lead, so that very rapid cooling and absorption of the zinc by the lead would be simultaneously attained. The idea of shock cooling a metal vapour in this way had come to him some years before when thinking about the production of magnesium. In this new context it seemed more promising. If lead were used as coolant it would dissolve the zinc and this might help in suppressing oxidation. The solubilities were known from the lead zinc phase diagram and there appeared to be practical advantages. Liquid lead was known to be much less corrosive to steel than liquid zinc, and it fortunately retains this advantage even when saturated with zinc. At the time however it did not look so promising, and the line of criticism was that if the zinc could be condensed as easily as that, somebody would surely have done it before! But Derham went ahead with his experiments and these led to the highly successful lead splash condenser. Today liquid lead saturated with zinc (2.15%) at 450°C is pumped into the condenser and broken into a spray by paddles. It cools the gas rapidly from 1000°C, absorbs 0.25% more zinc and leaves at 560°C. On cooling the lead back to 460°C, liquid zinc separates at the surface where it can be removed by a system of weirs and channels. This idea was undoubtedly the major inventive step, and on it hinged the success of all that had gone before. The rest of the development was carried out on a larger furnace of 7 ft2 cross-section and 10 ft high. There followed simplifications in treating the top gas before entering the condenser. It was found not to be necessary to pass the emergent gasses through heated
SEQ 0011 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0011 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
11
coke, for the back reaction was not serious except on the walls, even when the zinc pressure was three times greater than that in equilibrium with the CO and CO2, and even this surface reaction could be avoided, if the walls were kept hotter than the gas. It then turned out that provided the gases were raised from 900 to 1000°C after leaving the furnace, the zinc could be collected in the splash condenser with virtually no back reaction. The temperature is now raised by admitting a little air, a very neat thermodynamic trick. The equilibrium constant for the reoxidation shifts so rapidly from zinc oxide to zinc with rising temperature, and the heat evolved in the combustion of some of the CO by the added air is so great, that one can shift the equilibrium in favour of zinc vapour by the unexpectedly simple procedure of admitting air! Only a group well versed in the thermodynamic approach would have spotted this elegant solution. For it is not normal to admit an oxidising agent to prevent oxidation occurring! But the trick could never have been conceived, without the basic thermodynamic data for CO, CO2, Zn, and ZnO, which had been worked out by previously careful experimenters. With lead drosses inevitably being produced in the process of recovering the zinc, it was obviously sensible to smelt these in the furnace and collect the lead at the bottom. It was immediately apparent that this would impose no thermal, and virtually no chemical, demand on the furnace. Once this had been found to work, it was clear that a zinc/lead oxide sinter could be charged, and both zinc and lead produced simultaneously. In 1950, over ten years from the inception of the project, two pilot furnaces producing 20–30 tons of zinc per day were built: these now have capacities of 30–40 tons per day and production furnaces are making 160 tons per day. This development, now so very successful, took a very long time to complete. It was much delayed by the war and at more than one point it came near to being abandoned. Its very slowness would have daunted lesser teams and lesser companies, and it demanded as much tenacity as skill from all concerned, and especially from Kenneth Morgan.
LD AND LDAC The development of the LD provides another good example of a new process in which old reactions are exploited in new ways. Its origins are worth considering in detail because important point emerge, and because the fact that the process was not invented in Britain, is sometimes cited as criticism of the research effort in steel in this country. The idea of blowing oxygen into hot metal from above is mentioned in Bessmer’s Patent of 1856, but at that time there was no tonnage oxygen and the possibilities of making steel in this way could not be explored. It is evident from a drawing in his patent (Fig. 4a) that Bessemer had no conception of the hydrodynamics of jetting oxygen into hot metal. As we all now know, what actually happens in this system, so violently dispersed by the combined effects of oxygen jet and CO evolution, is more closely represented by Fig. 4b. When oxygen became available on the tonnage scale it was natural that its use should appeal to steelmakers on the Continent. The steel industry there was based on air blown
SEQ 0296 JOB IOM8627-001-010 PAGE-0012 16TH LECTURE REVISED 21DEC04 AT 01:45 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
12
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 4
Top blowing of hot metal with oxygen (a) drawing from Bessemer’s patent of 1856; (b) the top blown converter today.
converters, and it had always been troubled by the nitrogen which got into the metal at the end of the blow. In particular the Austrians at the end of World War II had no satisfactory means of making steel from their irons, which were of intermediate phosphorus content and unsuitable for the basic Bessemer. They did not want to build open hearths, because they were very short of scrap and they wished to avoid the high capital costs associated with these furnaces. They therefore turned to basic coverters using enriched air, and finally Suess of V¨oest produced the top blown oxygen process.6 In this he was much influenced by the work of Durrer and Hellbrugge7 who had produced steel successfully by blowing an inclined jet of oxygen on a bath of pig iron in a two ton converter. Suess started his experiments in 1949 and his company began regular production in 25–30 ton converters in late 1952. Today in some countries converters of 200 tons capacity are in continuous operation. Suess was the first to study in a systematic, though empirical, manner what I regard as the process engineering of top blowing; that is the relationships between lance height, and diameter, the rate of oxygen flow, and the course of the refining reactions. There was no directly relevant experience on which he could draw and he made his first trials with two ton melts. But he wisely passed to the 15 ton scale without waiting to get everything working smoothly with his little converter. In this he was exceptionally wise, for heat, mass, and momentum transfer and the course of the reactions in a dynamic and violently dispersed system such as this, cannot be reliably simulated on the small scale. To my mind the importance of this move cannot be overestimated. It was the key to rapid success and it underscores the necessity for those aiming to develop new processes or to increase our knowledge in process engineering, to have adequate large scale facilities at their disposal.
SEQ 0013 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0013 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
13
It was fortunate that only low phosphorus Austrian iron was available for the first stage of the work, for later attempts to use high phosphorus iron ran into difficulties. These were associated with getting much more lime into the slag and fluxing it at high speed, so that the phosphorus could be removed at the same time as the carbon. This problem was solved simultaneously by the Benelux CNRM and the French IRSID, who were also working for steel industries which were converter based. The CNRM had previously worked at the engineering of injecting powdered lime into flowing gases, for they had tried this on bottom blown converters and abandoned it. Thus it came about that when people tried to adapt the LD process for high phosphorus irons, Metz of the CNRM8 saw that the lime stood a far better chance of being fluxed immediately if it were injected into the oxygen gas and carried directly to the very hot zone where gas and metal meet. Experiments were then made at ARBED on the 26 ton scale and quick success fully justified this action. Marc Allard and his colleagues at IRSID thought along precisely the same lines, for they likewise had gained previous experience of injecting lime into flowing gases from their work on desulphurising hot metal with powdered lime carried in nitrogen. I referred to the industrial reasons why the LD did not evoke much response in Britain, but there was another reason for this lack of interest. There was a rational scepticism concerning the suitability of the LD process for British irons containing some 1%P. It arose from what I call a ‘hypertheoretical’ attitude. Basic knowledge of the [P]–[O]– (P2O5) equilibrium indicated that phosphorus could only be removed to low levels in the presence of substantial amounts of P2O5 in slag, if the oxygen activity in the metal was very high. This was perfectly correct. But it was then supposed on the basis of previous experience, that sufficiently high oxygen activities could not be attained in a pneumatic process without a correspondingly low carbon. At that time little or no basic knowledge existed concerning the kinetics of slag–metal and gas–metal reactions, although it was generally thought that they were transport controlled. Unfortunately thermodynamic data on slag and metal solutions were then too scarce to show that in steelmaking, equilibria betwen slag and metal of the type [Mn] + (FeO) = (MnO) + [Fe] 2[P] + 5(FeO) = (P2O5) + 5[Fe] could be quite closely approached (within 15%), although the equilibrium between metal and gas (the [C] [O]–CO equlibrium which is approached at a different interface) might be very far from attainment. This fact makes the removal of phosphorus in the LD possible. The reason lies in surface areas, concentrations, and mass transfer coefficients.9 Kinetics is played off against thermodynamics, not chemical kinetics but the kinetics of mass transfer in the vicinity of two different phase boundaries. Had our knowledge of process engineering metallurgy been as developed in 1949 as it is today, the first British theoretical estimates of the potentialities of the LD would have been much more favourable than they were. The tendency for the knowledgeable, good theoretician to put too much faith in his predictions, has resulted in highly competent and indeed imaginative persons failing to
SEQ 0014 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0014 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
14
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
make important discoveries. This was how Larmor in 1897 missed discovering the Zeeman effect. Larmor’s theory of radiation, before the era of the electron, suggested that if a source of radiation were plunged into a magnetic field the lines of the spectrum ought to be broadened. Larmor then calculated the magnitude of the effect to be expected with a reasonable field: he reckoned it would be too small to observe and that the experiment was not worth attempting. But Larmor’s treatment was not correct for he thought the atom would be radiating. Had he known of the electron he would have come to quite a different conclusion; for his theory predicted that the magnitude of the effect depended on the ratio of change to mass for the radiating particle. Zeeman however made the experiment with sodium flame in a strong magnetic field, and obtained a small but observable effect, which now carries his name. Looking back we can see that Larmor should have pressed on regardless. We can also see that whenever we make theoretical prodictions, it is wise to remember, that any experiment that has not been done before is worth attempting at least once; or if we believe, as I do, in the German saying ‘Ein Versuch ist kein Versuch’, at least two or three times! One must not, of course, over stress the caution of the theoretician, for more often than not it is the experienced practical man who has the lesser vision.
THERMAL MAGNESIUM In contrast with this last story, stands the development of the thermal process for magnesium production.10 Shortly before World War II, Professor Lloyd Pidgeon, who was then in the National Research Council Laboratory in Ottawa, was asked to study the production of magnesium for defence purposes in Canada. After considering the dry chlorination of brucite (Mg(OH)2) followed by electrolysis, he turned to direct reduction processes involving carbon and silicon. He considered that calcined dolomite, where the magnesium is present as oxide, might be reduced in a metal retort by ferrosilicon, the magnesium being distilled away from the solids and suitably condensed. The reaction is now known to be 2CaO + 2MgO + Si = 2Mg(g) + 2CaO.SiO2 but it was not then realised that the orthosilicate of calcium would be formed. Calculations were made on the supposition that the reaction gave only magnesium and silica. They were based on the then existing heat of formation of silica, which is now known to have been greatly in error. These calculations suggested that substantial equilibrium pressures of magnesium and hence reasonable rates of production, could only be achieved at 1300–1400°C. At these temperatures great problems would have arisen with the retorts so in the light of knowledge then available the theoretical assessment was most unpromising. Pidgeon, however, pushed ahead with experiments using Ni–Cr retorts, hoping that it might be possible to get the reaction to go reasonably fast under vacuum at 1100°C. The
SEQ 0015 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0015 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
15
results exceeded expectations for relatively high pressures of magnesium, of the order of 20 mmHg are in fact produced by the dolomite reaction under equilibrium conditions at 1100°C. But two further difficulties had to be overcome. The first tests had been made with a simple retort heated and cooled in a batch cycle, but this treatment produced cracks in the retort after some 20 experiments. The retorts therefore had to be maintained at the operating temperature and arrangements made to open the equipment to the air and disconnect the condenser with the retorts at temperature. Trouble then arose from the pyrophoric nature of the condensed magnesium. It was observed that the deposit was feathery and friable at the cooler end of the condenser and that ignition was initiated at this end when the vacuum was broken. This was also the end where the alkali metals were concentrated. Further experiments with sodium carbonate introduced into the dolomite, confirmed the connexion between the alkali metals and the feathery nature of the deposit and the difficulty was overcome by the introduction of a fractionating condenser. With this the deposit of magnesium was massive and crystalline: it could be exposed to air even at the condensing temperature of 500–600°C, and when melted it formed an ingot without significant losses from oxidation. This process is fully competitive with the electrolytic route and is used in the magnesium plant which has just been built in Britain at Hopton.
THE SUBHALIDE PROCESS FOR ALUMINIUM Now I would like to turn to a process which springs primarily from the discovery of a new reaction, and has a fair chance of slowly outsting the classic electrolytic process for making aluminium. This is the subhalide process which involves only thermal reactions.11 During World War II Phillip Gross, working in England, had occasion to advise on attempts to make magnesium by reducing salt water magnesia with aluminium scrap, a process very similar in principle to the Pidgeon process I have just described. The aluminium and magnesia were heated together with some 2% of calcium fluoride which was used as a flux. The flux was there because metallurgists quite rightly believe in fluxes, much as ordinary people believe in luck; it was actually unnecessary on this occasion but its presence turned out to be singularly fortunate. When the mixture was heated at 1200°C, magnesium was distilled away and the spinel MgO.Al2O3 was rather wastefully produced. In his work to improve this process, Gross observed that the magnesium collected always contained a percent or so of aluminium. The operators thought this came over as dust or vapour, but Gross reckoned that so much could not be accounted for in this way. Gross was interested and puzzled and searched the literature for papers relating to the vapour pressure and evaporation of aluminium. It became clear that the aluminium was not vaporising directly in significant amounts. Gross then found Willmore’s 1939 US Patent12 for purifying aluminium from iron and silicon by heating it at 1000–1200°C
SEQ 0016 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0016 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
16
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
under reduced pressure with Alf3, MgF2, CaF2 or Na3Alf6. Under these conditions Willmore had found that the aluminium vaporised together with the halide, but without the impurities, and that both metal and halide could be recovered intimately mixed together in a condenser. They could then be separated from one another by fusion, an operation that in practice is exceedingly difficult, so the process is of no account. Willmore had supposed that ‘some low boiling mixture or compound was formed’ between the salts and the metal and that this explained the simultaneous vaporisation of the two components. Gross therefore produced some magnesium from salt water magnesia without flux, and found no aluminium in the metal produced. Recollecting that although the aluminium atom has three electrons in the M shell, two are S electrons and one is a P electron, he thought it possible that the metal could be monovalent as well as trivalent. He then thought that Willmore’s reaction and the one occurring in the magnesium distillation might be 2Al + CaF2 = 2AlF(g) + Ca(g) So he searched the literature for spectroscopic data and found that Miescher had studied the band spectrum of AlCl3, had allocated some bands to AlCl and had estimated its dissociation energy. From this information and the known thermochemical properties of AlCl3, Gross estimated the free energy changes for the reaction 2Al + AlCl3(g) = 3AlCl(g) and concluded that this could be made to proceed at temperatures of 1000–1200°C and reversed at low. Gross immediately conceived the idea of exploiting this reaction to make aluminium by a thermal route. He could see that an iron–aluminium alloy could be made from bauxite in arc furnaces in the same way as ferrosilicon was made for the Pidgeon process, and that the aluminium could then be vaporised from the alloy as AlCl by treating it with AlCl3, the iron remaining behind. He therefore conducted experiments in which he led unsaturated AlCl3 vapour through finely divided aluminium supported on alumina at 1000–1200°C, and successfully condensed aluminium from the emergent gas stream. The existence of the monohalide was thus fully confirmed together with his view that in Willmore’s experiments the emergent vapours had consisted of AlF and Mg, Ca, or Na which reverted to Al and MgF2, etc. on cooling: similarly the simultaneous volatilisation of AlF and Ca had been the cause of the carryover of aluminium in Gross’s magnesium distillation. The next move was to determine step by step the thermodynamics of the reactions,13 and these established the correctness of his estimates of the properties of AlCl. The thermodynamics of the aluminium–iron alloys that might be conveniently produced from bauxite had also to be worked out, together with the heat and mass transfer problems arising in the treatment of briquettes of Fe–Al alloy moving down a tower up which AlCl3 gas passes. The process is being tried by Alcan, and a plant with an estimated
SEQ 0017 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0017 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
17
output of 8000 tons per year is being built. There are problems still to be resolved, and the process will have a hard time competing with the enormous electrolytic plants which now exist, but it seems to have a good chance of succeeding in the long run. So far as the conception of the process is concerned, the important points are the way Gross saw significance in a chance piece of information which others consistently neglected, how he deduced the existence of AlCl from the most basic of chemical principles, and how he then applied this in an utterly different context.
THE SHERRITT-GORDON PROCESS There is an extremely important hydrometallurgical process that springs directly from the discovery of new reactions. This is the Sherritt-Gordon process for the recovery of nickel, cobalt, and copper from the Lynn Lake ores of Saskatchewan. After mineral dressing, these provide a sulphide concentrate which contains some 12%Ni, 0.5%Co, 1.5%Cu and 30%Fe. The first part of the process was discovered by Professor Frank Forward, when he was Head of the Department of Metallurgy at the University of British Columbia. He had been interested in nickel ever since 1923 when he was an operator in a nickel refinery in Quebec. He had subsequently worked on the production of nickel in Japan and in 1945 he was working on the recovery of nickel from its oxide in Cuban laterites by the ammonia–ammonium carbonate leaching process. This involved prereduction of the concentrate to give nickel metal, followed by leaching in open vessels and boiling the leach solution to drive off ammonia and so precipitate basic nickel carbonate. In 1946 Forward heard of the Sherritt-Gordon discovery at Lynn Lake and he thought out a way of treating the concentrates, which was rather similar to the procedure for the Cuban ores. His idea was to roast to remove sulphur, then reduce the nickel, copper, and cobalt to metal, and leach with a solution of ammonia and ammonium carbonate. The copper had then to be separated, and a basic nickel carbonate produced, this finally being reduced to metal. He was strongly encouraged by the President of Sherritt-Gordon, Eldon Brown, to do everything possible to find a route different from established smelting and refining, and he produced a small amount of metal by the roasting–leaching route. The process was feasible but not economically attractive. Forward substantially gave up hope of success and most people would have abandoned the project at this point. But Forward was reluctant to give up work on ammonia leaching completely, so he pressed on hoping that it might somehow be useful for extracting metallic nickel from a high grade matte (such as that produced at Falconbridge), leaving the sulphides undissolved. In his next experiment therefore 5–10 g of powdered matte were placed in a Winchester with 500 mL of ammonia–ammonium carbonate solution. The air was displaced with oxygen, and the bottle sealed and rotated for two days at room temperature. At the end of that time it was found that the metallic nickel had dissolved as expected, but to everybody’s surprise, the nickel and copper sulphides had oxidised and
SEQ 0018 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0018 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
18
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
also gone into solution. The experiment was immediately repeated with the Lynn Lake concentrates; these behaved similarly; the nickel, copper, and cobalt went into solution, and the iron was left behind as a hydrated oxide. A most important new reaction had been discovered: as first conducted it was too slow for large scale use, but it was a reasonably simple step to increase the rate by raising the temperature to 83°C in the presence of an air pressure of 100 lb/in2. At the same time it was found that the ammonium carbonate was not required, because of the ammonium sulphate produced autogeneously during the leach, as shown in the equations below. It took some time to find the detailed course of the reactions and the kinds of ions produced. The most important steps may be represented stoichiometrically as follows14 2NiS + 8FeS + 14O2 + 20NH3 + 8H2O → 2Ni(NH3)6SO4 + 4Fe2O3.H2O + 4(NH4)2S2O3 2(NH4)2S2O3 + 2O2 → (NH4)2S3O6 + (NH4)2SO4 (NH4)2S3O6 + 2O2 + 4NH3 + H2O → NH4SO3NH2 + 2(NH4)2SO4 These discoveries opened the door to others and stimulated research into a whole new field of hydrometallurgy. V. N. Mackiw, Director of Research for Sherritt-Gordon, took up the work. He found that when the leach solution was boiled to remove some of the ammonia, considerable amounts of copper sulphide were precipitated. He then discovered that if sufficient thionate were present, it decomposed, as ammonia was removed, to give sulphide ions, and these precipitated most of the copper as sulphide. On this reaction the separation of copper in the full scale process is now based.15 The next question was how to recover the dissolved nickel and cobalt: the first idea was to produce crystalline nickel ammonium sulphate, to convert this to oxide and then reduce it to metal. At this stage the Chemical Construction Corporation was called in to discuss engineering aspects of the leaching process, because of their experience with ammonia plants. It turned out that they had been working on the deposition of nickel from ammonia solutions by hydrogen reduction. It had long been known that hydrogen under pressure would reduce metals from solution. There were, for example, the experiments of B´ek´etoff16 with silver salts in the Sorbonne in 1859; and the researches reported by Ipatiew17 from 1909 onwards. Sporadic interest in this type of reaction had continued, and in the 1930s I. G. Farben produced a patent for the production of nickel catalysts on silica by hydrogen reduction of ammoniacal nickel solutions. Schaufelberger,8 working for the Chemical Construction Company, had successfully produced nickel metal by using hydrogen to reduce nickel ammines dissolved in ammonia solutions. But he had difficulties with nucleating the new phase and unless he introduced powdered seed material, he obtained his metal as deposits on the walls of his reaction vessels. Such reductions may be represented by the general equation M2+ + H2 = M + 2H+
SEQ 0253 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0019 16TH LECTURE REVISED 20DEC04 AT 21:50 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
19
This equilibrium is exceptionally amenable to manipulation: the activity coefficients of the metal ions may be varied by complexing (e.g. with ammonia), and both hydrogen pressure and pH may be adjusted over wide ranges. By this means it is possible to get separations of one metal from another which are extremely selective and impossible to obtain by other methods. With the chance of a large scale aqueous route for nickel opening up, Schaufelberger’s work became very important, and it was quickly followed by more intensive studies by Mackiw19 and his colleagues in Sherritt-Gordon. They worked out the chemistry in greater detail, but still used fine nickel powder to seed the reduction and make it go at reasonable rates. It was then discovered that some solutions would reduce satisfactorily without seeding. Careful analytical investigations showed that these solutions had low ammonium sulphate contents and were contaminated with iron. This further discovery led to the use of ferrous sulphate as a reduction catalyst, so that a very fine and active metal powder could be produced without seeding. It appears that under the conditions obtaining in these solutions, the ferrous sulphate gives a very finely divided ferrous hydroxide, which is responsible for the catalysis, and that this dissolves at a later stage as the concentration of ammonium sulphate rises. This third discovery was the result of careful experiment and observation. It could hardly have come in any other way, in view of the present state of theory concerning nucleation from solution. The hydrogen reduction process, which is operated at about 170°C and 500 lb/in2, now consists of producing very finely divided nickel in the presence of ferrous sulphate and using this as seed on which to grow nickel reduced from batches of solutions in the absence of ferrous ion. This latter step is termed densification and is conducted in the presence of stearic acid, which prevents the particles from agglomerating and coating the walls of the autoclave. Some 12 to 15 densifications, averaging 60 min each, are typically used. Two samples of nickel are shown in Fig. 5a and b. The reduction of cobalt is conducted in a similar manner, although different catalysts and anti-agglomerating agents are used. Some beautiful cobalt platelets obtained in this
Fig. 5 Particles of metal powder about 10–2 cm across, produced by hydrogen reduction, all from Mackiw et al.20 (a) nickel after 40 successive depositions from an ammine solution; (b) nickel of almost theoretical density produced as in (a) but with small amounts of anthroquinae present; (c) platelets of cobalt from an ammine solution.
SEQ 0020 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0020 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
20
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
way are in Fig. 5c. These powders can be roll compacted, sintered and then cold rolled to produce a satisfactory strip. The possibilities are not of course limited to simple metal powders, for ‘tailor-made’ alloys may be produced by coating one metal with another,20 and some of these could not possibly be made by a high temperature process: furthermore metals or alloys may be precipitated upon different kinds of nuclei which could act as dispersion hardeners. Particles of iron and phosphorus coated with nickel, are shown in Fig. 6a and b.
Fig. 6
Particles of (a) iron and (b) phosphorus coated with nickel deposited by hydrogen reduction.
Aqueous processes for treating ores or concentrates culminate in electrodeposition, hydrogen reduction, or precipitation of a pure compound. If this compound is subsequently reduced at low temperatures, a metal powder must result. Such powder may become an important starting material for making strip. The work of compacting powder may be much less than that of rolling down ingots. Furthermore alloy strip of novel compositions, which could not be prepared by melting, might be made by such routes. In the world of iron and steel, it could be that aqueous processes can only become competitive if the end product is a powder whose physical properties are exploited to the full in making strip or special powder metallurgical products. This is the principle that seems to be in the minds of G. R. Heffernan, President of the Peace River Mining and Smelting Co. and C. P. Gravenor21 of the Research Council of Alberta. Here, as in the Sherrit-Gordon process, the desire to exploit a new orebody has been the impulse for devising a new route from ore to iron powder and developing new steps within this route. No entirely new reactions had to be discovered, so that process engineering has presumably dominated the project. The Clear Hills iron deposits near the Peace River consist of quartz fragments surrounded by layers of goethite and green iron aluminosilicate. The iron content is some 34% with 27%SiO2, 5%Al2O3 and 0.6%P. The process hinges on partially reducing the ore and leaching with hydrochloric acid to give ferrous chloride solution. Most of the ferrous chloride is crystallised in pure form by partial evaporation of the solution, and then converted to FeCl2.2H2O. This is next reduced by hydrogen to give iron powder and a simultaneous recovery of the HCl. But the valuable halogen must also be recovered from the solution left after separating the
SEQ 0021 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0021 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
21
ferrous chloride crystals. The existing Nordac-Aman process can be used for this purpose. It was originally designed for converting metal chlorides to oxides and for the recovery of hydrochloric acid from spent pickle liquor. The solution left after crystallisation is sprayed through oil or gas burners: the water evaporates and the solid chloride particles react at about 1000°C with steam. Hydrochloric acid gas is produced together with oxides of iron, aluminium, magnesium, and calcium which are all extracted in greater or less extent when the ore is leached. The reduction of ferrous chloride by hydrogen is conducted at 650°C in a packed bed or kiln. The reaction is strongly exothermic and half the heat required for the entire process is used in this step. The energy demands for the reducing roast, the crystallisation and reduction of the ferrous chloride and the hydrochloric acid recovery from the waste liquor, are so great that the process may not be economic except in a location where fuel is cheap and where the ore can be cheaply mined. These conditions are satisfied in Alberta where there is cheap natural gas and where these very large ore deposits can be worked by strip mining. The iron powder contains some 99.2%Fe, 0.05%P, 0.005%S, 0.03%C, 0.17%SiO2 and 0.75%Al2O3, and it can be rolled directly into strip. Thus a series of relatively low temperature steps supplants not only smelting and refining, but also casting and much of the mechanical working involved in the classical route from ore to strip. A pilot plant to produce some 15 tons of powder per day is now being built to test the process as a whole and the marketability of the product.
CONCLUSIONS How far is there any pattern in the origins of these diverse processes? Everything starts from the impulse to solve a problem, and in extraction metallurgy that impulse has most commonly come from the financial incentive to exploit a new orebody. We have seen this in four of the processes considered. But the impulse may also come from the desire to improve some existing and well established method of making metal. I call this the self-imposed problem, and the zinc– lead blast furnace is an example. For tackling this type of problem more enthusiasm and tenacity is required on the part of both the individuals and the companies involved. It is never so easy to pick worthwhile projects of this type, and the advantages which may come from success are never easy to assess. The opposition is usually great because it is so difficult to upset the complacent view that ‘we are getting along perfectly well as we are, thank you’. There are always financial reasons for not making changes, for this inevitably involves scrapping costly plant, and upsetting a smoothly working organisation. All the intertia of habit has to be overcome, and the new thoughts have to emerge without any spur from outside. In the development itself there are important principles which should be kept in mind. Some of them are almost platitudes, but these principles soon become overlooked once
SEQ 0022 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0022 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
22
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
the broad strategy of a development has been decided, and the detailed planning and execution is started. One must first exploit available basic knowledge to the full without putting undue faith in the data or the theories available. One must do experiments that have a chance of leading to discovery, and in this connexion any relevant experiment not previously attempted is worth doing once: one must make the most of all kinds of information and remember that acute observation can draw discovery out of accident or out of work and trials conducted for quite different ends. Success depends on invention when the route forward is blocked, and the logical extrapolation of existing knowledge can lead no further. Then one has to break out of current modes of thought and seek inspiration in quite different areas of science, technology or art. It is at this stage that weight of experience becomes a drawback and the newcomer to the problem has the great advantage of ignorance, the advantage of a mind uncluttered with objections and without a sense of impossibility. Tennyson wrote in ‘Ulysses’: I am part of all that I have met Yet all experience is an arch where thro’ Gleams that untravelled world whose margin fades For ever and for ever as I move. From this archway of experience we get a much-needed perspective, but from it we also get a restricted view. And when we have a great deal of experience, we run the risk of viewing the untravelled world as through the end of a long tunnel. A tunnel so long that sometimes the most experienced among us begin to think that everything has been done before and no untravelled world exists. The value of being able to bring ideas across from other fields of science and technology cannot be overstressed. This is where a multi-disciplinary training has a real advantage over narrower specialisations. This is one reason why I am so keen to see metallurgy taught in breadth. The metallurgist should have at his disposal as wide a range of basic ‘tools of thought’ as he can get. After university it is extremely difficult to acquire these. There is never sufficient time and most industrial and research experience tends to force the really successful man to become more and more specialised. For this reason I feel strongly that there are great advantages in a metallurgical training which recognises the anatomy of the subject as represented by my two triangles and gives the student a sound grounding in all three basic sectors. We should remember this need to bring new ideas across from other fields when we plan the activities of our metallurgical institutes. In terms of ideas it is a grave disadvantage to have our ferrous publications separated from non-ferrous. It is bad for students and bad, I suggest, for the old and experienced. I know there are strong organisational reasons for not making a change. But we could make positive attempts to offset the bad effects of segregation by organising our discussions more imaginatively. Instead of confining, for instance, our own Institute discussions to a group of papers published in our own Journal, we could bring together for discussion the authors of a group of papers which have some common interest, although scattered through all three British metallurgical journals, and
SEQ 0023 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0023 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Basic Knowledge, Discovery, and Invention
23
some of the chemical engineering and chemical publications also. I think, we would have all the advantages of a symposium without the tiresome business of pressing authors for special papers produced against the clock, and I am sure we could have some much livelier discussions. But there are other ways in which positive action could be taken to pave the way for new developments, and to make discovery and new ideas more likely. New chemical reactions involving metals in molten, aqueous, and organic phases should be sought and studied irrespective of any application. In the field of iron and steel work of a speculative nature needs to be undertaken to test the potentialities of halide, aqueous, and powder routes. One cannot tell where such work may lead, but there is a worthwhile chance that useful new products and processes may emerge. Basic knowledge in chemical and process engineering metallurgy needs to be built up where it is scanty, and where more detail looks like leading to interesting theory or to possible applications. Work in the field of process engineering needs to be supported by large scale experiments. Some national facilities are needed to which academic investigators should have access. The rates of processes, the patterns of heat and mass transfer, and sometimes the order in which reactions proceed in a process, are dependent on scale. Process engineering problems cannot be studied solely in the laboratory or on the very small scale which is adequate for investigating the thermodynamics and chemical kinetics of metallurgical reactions. Small scale tests may frequently be irrelevant and the results sometimes quite misleading. Much of the work that I have mentioned can be done in or organised by universities: it can probably be done most cheaply in this way. But when we look at research in British universities in the field of metallurgy, what do we see? Less than 10% is going into areas related to metal production (that is chemical and process engineering metallurgy), and over 90% is devoted to physical metallurgy. This is a gross imbalance. It is an imbalance that has, I am glad to say, now been recognised by the DSIR who are striving to redress it. Much can be done by industry and government to bring about a change. Contacts can be improved between the metals industries and the universities; academic posts, fellowships, bursaries and research grants, can be set up specifically for work in this field, for no scientist or engineer can work effectively in isolation. I regard four experienced persons as the minimum for a viable group, and the interests of these four need to be spread over both chemical and process engineering fields. Tonight I have attempted to look primarily at the interplay of the abstractions basic knowledge, discovery, and invention in the origins of processes. But I have not forgotten that the exciting game of developing processes is a ‘flesh and blood’ business. It requires forceful people with enthusiasm almost to the point of obsession. The kind of enthusiasm that was displayed by Sydney Thomas, that most lively inventor, and which shines forth even today in the message which he wrote at the end of a letter to his sister2 in 1883: By the way, dear child, you have still got to learn some chemistry and work with me. I am absolutely brimming over with things that demand investigation; the lines are
SEQ 0024 JOB IOM8627-001-009 PAGE-0024 16TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:11 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
24
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
already laid down and they must be investigated, I shall never have time by myself and you must help; you can’t tell what a glorious, entrancing, delightful occupation it will be, with rewards of the most magnificent description in reputation, work, benefits and lucre.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
W. H. HATFIELD: Application of Science to the Steel Industry, 1928, ASTM. R. W. BURNIE: Memoirs and Letters of Sidney Gilchrist Thomas, Inventor, Murray, London 1891. F. D. RICHARDSON: Trans. AIME, 1964, 230, 1213. S. W. K. MORGAN: Trans. IMM, (London), 1956–7, 66, 553–565. C. G. MAIER: US Bur. Mines Bull., 1930, 324. T. E. SUESS: V¨oest Jahrbuch, 1950/51, 21. H. HELLBRUGGE: Stahl Eisen, 1950, 70, 1208–1211. P. METZ: Pat. 551., 946, 19.10.1956. F. D. RICHARDSON: Iron and Coal Trades Review, 1961, 1105–1116. L. M. PIDGEON and W. A. ALEXANDER: Trans. AIME, 1944, 159, 315–352. P. GROSS: US Pat. 2, 470, 306 (17.5.1949). C. B. WILLMORE: US Pat. 2, 184, 705 (26.12.1939). P. GROSS: Disc. Faraday Soc., 1948, 4, 206–215. F. A. FORWARD: Can. Min. Met. Bull., 1953, 56, 363–370. V. N. MACKIW et al.: Chem. Eng. Prog., 1958, 54, 79–85. M. N. BEKETOFF: Compt. Rend., 1859, 48, 442–444. W. N. IPATIEW and W. WERCHOWSKY: Berichte, 1909, 42, 2078–2808; 1911, 44, 1755– 1758. F. A. SCHAUFELBERGER: Min. Eng., 1956, 8, (5), 539–548. V. N. MACKIW et al.: J Met., 1957, 789–793. V. N. MACKIW et al.: ‘Practice and potential of pressure hydrometallurgy’, IUPAC Congress, Montreal, 1961. C. P. GRAVENOR et al.: Can. Min. Met. Bull., 1964, 421–428.
SEQ 0025 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0025 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE NINETEENTH HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
Twenty-Five Years On H. M. Finniston At the time the lecture was given Dr Finniston was Deputy Chairman-Technical of the British Steel Corporation. The lecture was given at Sheffield University on 11 December 1968.
The title of this lecture is intentionally unspecific, even ambiguous, because when an author has to concern himself with the content much ahead of delivery, he is uncertain of the scope and even more of the detail of what may ultimately emerge. The options thus left open in the title through indecision, however, have the advantage of possibly attracting a larger audience by leaving each to put his or her own interpretation on what is intended, although one suspects that the success attending this temporary device is more probably a direct tribute to the man to whom this event is a permanent memorial. ‘Twenty-five years on’ is really compounded of two different eras. Twenty-five years have passed since William Herbert Hatfield died in October 1943 and the contrast between the iron and steel industry of his era and the present day is therefore appropriately caught in the title; the ambiguity concerns itself with an ill defined 25 years from now and the iron and steel industry which might face the Hatfield lecturer of the year 2000, who today is either just completing his postgraduate studies or just entering the metallurgical industry.
RESEARCH THEN . . . What would Hatfield think about the industry he served so well were he to return today to assume the prominent place he occupied in the late 30s and early 40s? Being oriented towards research (but not constrained by it, however) it would be to the changes in the research structure of the industry and its future thinking he would look first. Although the industry acknowledged in principle the importance of research to its continued well being, its laboratories were mainly concerned with trouble shooting and work directed towards short term quality improvement and control; laboratories which consciously and recognisably devoted a significant part of their effort to research in the broader sense were limited to very few companies. One of these was Hatfield’s own: the Princess Street Laboratory of Thomas Firth & John Brown Ltd opened in 1908; another was the United Steel Companies Ltd Central Research Laboratories which, under Dr Thomas Swinden, started at Stocksbridge in 1934. Research workers in the steel industry
25
SEQ 0026 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0026 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
26
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
outside the privileged few had to seek facilities in routine test laboratories or permission from management to do experiments on the shop floor. Hatfield, though an independent, recognised that in a technologically burgeoning industry he could not go it alone. He was, therefore, faute de mieux a strong proponent of collaborative research. The main channel for this form of enterprise was the Iron and Steel Industrial Research Council set up in 1929, whose Secretary, Edgar C. Evans, and a staff of half a dozen or so, also doubled as the Technical Department of the British Iron and Steel Federation. This organisation serviced a range of projects with a total budget of £65,000 at the time of Hatfield’s death; at today’s money values this would be equivalent to about £140,000. The Council had no laboratories directly responsible to it, but relied upon access to occasional facilities for construction and calibration of equipment for works trials at one of the universities to which part of the programme was contracted. The actual expenditure on research, however, was many times this budget, because this was the period of programme delegation by committee, which confused accountancy. The famous Heterogeneity of Steel Ingots Committee (the pioneers of them all), the Alloy Steel Research Committee, the Corrosion Committee, and the Steel Castings Research Committee had been joined by the Blast Furnace and Open Hearth Committees, all with their many sub-committees steering programmes entered into cooperatively and with specifically defined parts apportioned for action among the industrial members. Hatfield was a master at chairing and (less frequently) serving on these committees. A complex series of chemical analyses, a large amount of polishing and etching, or that supremely expensive business of sectioning an ingot or two: such tasks were distributed with an authority which left little room for dissent. The prosecution of experimental work is not an end in itself, however. The conclusions to be drawn, the lessons to be learned, and the implementation of the new knowledge in practice are the raisons d’etre for industry engaging in research development. Hatfield was as concerned with these aftermaths of the experimental work generated by him as in the initiation of the programme, and he showed the same authoritarian attitude towards gaining as much information out of the work as possible. As his obituary notice in the Royal Society archives reports: ‘He would occasionally argue obstinately against the acceptance of conclusions on which most of the members (of his committees) were agreed’, but he did this to improve the work rather than his reputation. It would be rash to assert that the value to the industry of results achieved through the cooperative practices of Hatfield’s time has been any less than are the much larger sums spent today in individual laboratories on self-centred projects. The pattern of laboratories and of the practices of Hatfield’s time can still be recognised today, even if some radical changes have been superimposed. The Iron and Steel Industrial Research Council was replaced by the British Iron and Steel Research Association in 1944, and in 1967 BISRA became the British Steel Corporation’s Inter-Group research organisation with four major laboratories, specialising in different fields of research and with an annual budget of £2m. With the British Independent Steel Producers
SEQ 0027 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0027 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
27
Association, however, the Corporation retained close contacts for continuing collaboration, using BISRA as its principal. New research laboratories costing £700,000 were opened in 1967 by Firth Brown; the United Steel Companies Stocksbridge Laboratories, although still in use, were replaced in 1950 by the extensive laboratories in Rotherham commemorating Swinden’s name; but as important as these are, there has been since Hatfield’s day a commendable increase in the numbers of research laboratories built by companies other than these two and now with considerable and established reputations. With nationalisation of the industry, many of these have become part of the assets of the Corporation, which is now faced with the problems of coordinating the research activities of 14 companies, some with research laboratories each of which spent more than a million pounds a year and others with much smaller investments in this area. Hatfield may not have approved of nationalisation but he would have welcomed the opportunity thus afforded for encouraging collaboration in research! In Hatfield’s day there was also limited support of a few favoured universities (mainly in the steelmaking districts) for fundamental research on ferrous metallurgy, notable examples being the work of Hay at the Royal Technical College, Glasgow (now the University of Strathclyde), of Edwards and of Luther Phillips at Swansea, and of Andrew at Sheffield. Of 22 universities in the UK in Hatfield’s time, nine boasted Chairs of Metallurgy and departments offering metallurgy as a first degree subject; now, among 44 universities, there are 22 Chairs of Metallurgy with some departments carrying two (or more) professors. Notwithstanding this growth, there may be some moral to be drawn from the fact that there are still today more professors of theology that there are of metallurgy.
. . . AND FOR THE FUTURE Depending upon how it is measured, research expenditure by the industry is running at a level of about £12m a year; the Science Research Council alone contributes some £500,000/year to ferrous metallurgy research in the universities. Will there be a continuing increase in this total expenditure? In some quarters, a figure of 1% of turnover has been suggested as a target for the research expenditure of the steel industry, and such a target would leave room for some expansion of present effort. It would be surprising if, during the next few years, the fields of our researches had not to be extended in keeping with increasing scientific growth within and outside the industry. This may well be achieved, however, without a corresponding increase in cost through a more critical attitude to research programmes and the freeing of existing resources to tackle new fields. In industry 90% of research expenditure has to be looked at with a close eye to what is really needed and can be justified rather than with an eye peering through rose coloured spectacles at some arbitrary target. The remaining 10% of funds has to be invested with faith in people who have the qualities of imagination, foresight, resourcefulness, and research ability; these are much fewer in number than self-opinionation would have us believe.
SEQ 0028 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0028 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
28
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III TOOLS OF THE TRADE
Hatfield was a man and metallurgist of parts, interested in the properties of steels whether these were mechanical, physical, or chemical and whether viewed from the scientific, technical, or practical aspects. In these areas there are three features which Hatfield would now find different. Firstly, were he with us today, he would revel in the new techniques and facilities which could be applied to solving and understanding the problems of iron and steel and to assisting in the further development of the industry. Much research depended, and still does depend, on large numbers of analyses. In Hatfield’s day this work was limited by the sheer physical capacity of laboratories to carry these out by the conventional wet methods of the time. Now the automatic recording spectrometer can deal with many of the elements of conventional analysis in an astonishingly short time, with remarkable ease, accuracy and directness of presentation, and sophisticated instruments for oxygen analysis are threatening the vacuum fusion apparatus to which Hatfield’s laboratory made important contributions. Inclusion counting and discrimination, which used to be a wearisome business involving subjective assessment by optical microscope and confirmation by laborious extraction methods, is now performed by the automatic counter and the electron probe microanalyser. The optical microscope was then the basic tool of the physical metallurgist but had not yet been developed to provide phase contrast, ultra-violet and dark field illumination and interference techniques. Structure analysis by X-ray was well known in Hatfield’s time (the pioneering work of Jay at Stocksbridge in the early 30s is still of classical dimensions) but the equipment is now much more refined, versatile, automated, and quicker in its provision of results. The electron microscope was being developed in Hatfield’s day in the USA, and the Journal of The Iron and Steel Institute of the period has a number of abstracts of American papers describing early work with this then revolutionary device. Today, to back up these techniques, there are developments in emission and mass spectroscopy, X-ray fluoresence, activation and atomic absorption analysis, emission, scanning and transmission electron microscopy, electron and neutron diffraction and field ion microscopy. All these techniques and the instruments associated with them have been in the direction of greater refinement in understanding what steel is: from the macrostructural characteristics as explored by Hatfield’s Committees to the microstructural substructures shown up by the electron microscope and the pin-pointing of individual atoms by the field ion microscope. So powerfully, for example, has electron microscopy developed as a technique for metallurgists that the British Steel Corporation in association with the Science Research Council is investing in a 1 MeV electron microscope to be housed in the Corporation’s laboratories at Sheffield for use by the steel industry in concert with the Universities of Sheffield, Newcastle, Manchester, Leeds, and Liverpool. The lesson to be learned for the future is that today’s research investments are tomorrow’s tools of the trade. This general refinement of experimental method applies to works trials as well as laboratory practices. Some of my present colleagues remember with pleasure, mainly retrospective, the works trials in Hatfield’s day. Typical of these were the waiting through
SEQ 0029 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0029 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
29
the small hours beside an ingot mould stuffed with thermocouples for a tap which was delayed; the probing of an open hearth furnace uptake with a water cooled pitot tube, whose apparently erratic behaviour gave the first clues towards the gas flow phenomena later investigated so thoroughly by Dr Chesters (your President) and his school; and the measuring of cold blast temperature hour by hour by uncorking a hole drilled in the cold blast main and pushing in a mercury thermometer against the blast pressure because funds did not run to a recorder. Today, the technical parameters of works trials are no longer measured by laborious manual recordings of U tube or thermocouple readings, or results analysed by applying a planimeter to a fuzzy line drawn by a flowmeter. Data loggers are now plugged in and the subsequent analytical calculations performed on-line by the ubiquitous computer. Although he might be somewhat critical about the way in which research workers can now get by with much less toil in the way of developing instruments, Hatfield would be persistent in ‘arguing obstinately’ for money towards still further improvement in the facilities available for iron and steel research. A second feature of the climate of Hatfield’s time was that the mechanical properties of steel were confined to a determination of the proof stress, maximum stress, elongation, reduction of area and impact value, creep (generally stress rupture or by Hatfield by his own time yield) and occasionally fatigue. Today, to these would have to be added such concepts as transition temperature (or its variations, isothermal crack arrest temperature or nil ductility transition) and the whole new field of fracture mechanics. The latter augments the research for improved elastic and plastic behaviour by seeking to limit disposition to fracture. The approach of fracture mechanics relates an experimentally determined parameter of fracture toughness (Ke for high strength, K1e for lower strength materials) to the limits of size and shape of crack or defect so that propagation will not occur, at the chosen design stress. An important implication of this approach is that steel (or any other metal) is not considered or treated as an ideal material free from defects; on the contrary it is recognised that even the best steels (and the best of other metals and alloys) have defects, e.g. fine cracks, inclusions, etc., which can be lived with to a greater or lesser degree depending upon the characteristics of the defects and the stresses and environment in which the steel finds service. Hatfield never acknowledged that steels made by his firm contained even the finest defects. There is a story which I hope is not apocryphal that during an epidemic of hairline cracking in alloy steels, Hatfield was asked by a research worker from outside the firm for a sample containing such cracks. Hatfield replied that he could not provide the sample because the steels made by his firm were entirely free from them and recommended that the enquirer direct his request to a competing company (needless to say now in the public sector). Through the science of fracture mechanics Hatfield today could acknowledge that while defects did occur in steels made by his firm he could still retain the firm’s good name through the claim that these defects and inclusions were fewer and smaller than those in steel made by his competitors. With interest now moving towards understanding and controlling fracture through theory and experiment, a new science of relating the detailed topography of fractured
SEQ 0030 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0030 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
30 Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III surfaces to the structure of the material and its fracture toughness should make ground. Figure 1a shows the detail of a tensile testpiece fracture surface as photographed through an optical microscope compared with the startlingly greater visual information shown by stereoscan electron microscopy. The differences in appearance (and hence propagation) of ductile and brittle fractures are to be seen by comparing 13Fig. 1b and c. For the future, low energy electron diffraction combined with Auger emission spectroscopy or field emission microscopy associated with field ionisation time of flight mass spectrometry might well be developed to determine the composition of single atomic layers on these fracture surfaces.
Fig. 1 (a) Fracture of tensile testpiece, optical magnification (×20); (b) stereoscan micrograph of same fracture showing ductile dimpled fracture (×2000); (c) stereoscan micrograph of brittle fracture showing cleavage facets (×600).
Thirdly, relationship between mechanical properties and microstructure has been recognised since the earliest use of the optical microscope by metallurgists in the late 19th century; microstructural features, such as martensite, twinning, etc., constituted pattern recognitions associated with qualitative assessments of strength and ductility. These patterns have since been analysed in greater detail optically and by electron microscope. Illustrative of the finer detail to be gained from microstructural examination by modern microscopy is the comparison in Fig. 2 of a quenched and tempered Cr–Mo–V steel
SEQ 0031 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0031 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
31
Fig. 2 (a) Quenched and tempered 12%Cr–Mo–V steel optically magnified (×750); (b) electron magnified by 30,000 showing larger alloy carbide precipitates at grain boundaries and smaller carbides within the grains.
structure photographed optically at × 750 and the same structure at × 30,000; the latter shows molybdenum carbide at the martensite plate boundaries and smaller carbides within the grains where optical microscopy had failed to detect either feature. Surprisingly, Hatfield made no reference to dislocations, although these had been reported upon in the literature since 1934. The concept and properties of this submicrostructural condition and the influence of dislocation patterns on the strength and ductility of steel and development of the microstructure, including recrystallisation, transformation, precipitation, etc., on heat treatment and on the deformation characteristics in service either escaped Hatfield or was considered by him as an unnecessary complication of limited significance. Today’s literature might convince him otherwise.
MAKING RESEARCH PAY While recognising the industrial value of the work done in Hatfield’s time, the fields which were tackled outside the laboratory were confined to improvement of then
SEQ 0032 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0032 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
32
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
existing processes rather than the invention of new processes. The measurement of simple blast furnace conditions gave some clues leading to the appreciation that good blast furnace performances depended on an evenly sized burden and the elimination of fines; studies of gas flow, air/fuel ratio, and the first example of true automatic control using feedback, i.e. automatic draught control, were yielding marked improvement in performance of open hearth furnaces; and the theory of metal deformation in rolling was being worked out. The development of major new production processes such as spray steelmaking, compact annealing, or the various new methods for applying metallic or organic powders to a steel base, the manufacture of plastic coated steel or the ‘Flox’ process for making pure oxide from lean ore were unsuited to the period, not because technical competence was lacking but because the scale of new developments was determined by the physical scale of the standard laboratory. This absence of pilot plant scale research was one of the less satisfactory aspects of Hatfield’s time and to a lesser extent still is. The excuse usually given was that in prosperous times the industry was too busy to engage in pilot plant work, and in less prosperous times it could not afford to do so. In recent years, BISRA/IGL and some of the more researchminded companies have extended the scale of pilot plant researches considerably, and any significant increase in the research and development expenditure of the British Steel Corporation is likely to be in this direction. The difficulties of organising this scale of experiment as a lead in to commercial production are well recognised; in many respects the approach to date from the development phase to industrial practice has been too gradual or restricted by the precedence given to the immediate needs of existing plants. The demands of modern competitiveness may well require new approaches to this conflict between present and future. To avoid the competing claims of technologists and management of production units, one approach might be the treatment of pilot plants as potential profit centres with high risk rather than as exercises to eliminate technical uncertainties or establish procedures.
INFORMING THE PUBLIC As one in charge of an important research laboratory and with a sense of public relations and its value, Hatfield might be less staggered today at the mass of scientific papers published, the plethora of technical conferences to attend, and the invitations he would be receiving to speak. He himself wrote about 150 scientific and technical papers (some in joint authorship) and would have regarded with distaste any suggestion of arbitrarily rationing publication. His obituary notice says he took ‘great pains in the preparation of [his] papers and the tables accompanying them’ and he would have been one of the first to protest at the amount of what can charitably be called ill prepared information which, along with papers of undoubted merit, reaches the printed page today. The recently announced intention of The Iron and Steel Institute to charge on a page basis for printing may discourage premature publication and encourage the brevity Hatfield sought.
SEQ 0033 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0033 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
33
It is interesting to compare the Journal of The Iron and Steel Institute for the first part of 1944 (which, because of the time lag in publishing will outline the research actually in progress at the time of Hatfield’s death) with the first six months of the Journal for 1968. In such areas as metallography, physical metallurgy, general works practice and analytical subjects, the pattern of papers is similar. However, there are noteworthy differences. In the early 1940s there was still active work on the sectioning of large ingots, and the examination of their macrostructure and segregation pattern. This type of investigation is very infrequently engaged in these days; this is partly because the earlier work established the general features of segregation and what could and could not be done by various measures such as changing ingot shape, and partly because useful information can now be got in cheaper ways by the examination of blooms and billet ends or by corner sampling. Much attention was being paid to various ways of measuring liquid steel temperature, the immersion thermocouple now universally used in various forms not having been established to the same extent. Steelmaking practice was concentrated on the OH furnace, and there were papers on slag control, on the use of mixed gas for heating, and on thermal efficiency. The chemistry of rimming steel was the subject of several papers. Few papers in these fields now appear in the literature. On the other hand, this year’s Journal contains numerous papers on topics which were not heard of in Hatfield’s day. Of some ten papers on practical steelmaking which appeared in the first six months of this year, only two were largely concerned with OH furnaces; the rest related to basic oxygen furnaces and in one case the fuel–oxygen–scrap (FOS) process. Continuing casting and automation, not in the subject list for 1944, are reported upon. The 1968 Journal has several papers with a bias towards economics and costs, matters condemned as far too dangerous subjects for open discussion by metallurgists 25 years ago. The present benefit/cost analysis approach to major research and development programmes and the closer integration of research with the market needs of the future suggest that these aspects will gain greater space in the journals of the latter part of the century.
THE STEEL INDUSTRY: STATIC OR DYNAMIC? As a director of a manufacturing company, Hatfield was a business man who had a concern for production and production techniques. How would he view today’s achievement in these areas? Figure 3 shows how both world and UK steel production have grown in the last 25 years. The figures speak for themselves, but two features might be pointed out. Firstly, world production has continued on an upward trend since World War II at roughly 5%/annum compound. World steel consumption per head, however, is now running at about 150 kg per head of population whereas in the most advanced industrial countries it is around 650 kg per head. The upward trend of world steel consumption is therefore likely to continue for many years yet. Extrapolated to 25 years from now, the
SEQ 0034 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0034 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
34
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 3 UK and world steel production 1943–1967.
world will have an output of 1800 m tons/annum which in relation to then world population would amount to 300 kg/head. The second point is that the UK share of world steel production has halved in the same period. It may be thought that we should not have expected to preserve our 10% share of the early post-war years as the developing countries (particularly Japan) increased their own steel production; that our share has halved, however, does surely point a warning finger to our competitiveness which we should be very foolish to ignore. One of the interesting developments since Hatfield’s day has been the change in pattern of steel product demand. Table 1 compares the pattern in 1943 with that of 1967. Rails, forgings and castings have declined and flat rolled products (sheet, tinplate, etc.) have boomed with the growth of the canned food and motor car industries. Hatfield Table 1
Changes in pattern of steel products made in 1943 and 1967.
Product
1943 ’000 tons
1967 ’000 tons
Ratio 1967–1943
Crude steel Rails, sleepers, and fishplates Plates (3 mm thick and over) Sections Arches and accessories Hot-rolled strip Cold-rolled strip Bright steel bars Sheets, uncoated Tinplate, terneplate, and blackplate Forgings (excluding drop forgings) Steel castings Alloy steels
13,031 354.0 1,836.3 1,244.8 163.7 588.8 230.5 412.7 993.3 532.1 233.9 365.1 245.5*
23,895 280.8 2,997.9 2,471.9 349.4 1,568.2 503.6 512.2 3,067.0 1,237.1 156.5 245.8 1,041.9
1.83 0.79 1.63 1.98 2.13 2.66 2.18 1.24 3.09 2.32 0.67 0.67 4.25
*1946: first peacetime year
SEQ 0035 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0035 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
35
would have been particularly interested to see the growth of alloy steel, since his reputation (and that of his firm) will long rest on association with stainless steel developments and to a lesser extent on his own developments of the 12Ni–5Mn–4Cr non-magnetic aero engine valve steels and the 5Ni–4Cr–3Mo for hot shears, and other applications for which thermal shock resistance is needed. The examination of how prices have moved since Hatfield’s time is sobering. Table 2 shows how the prices of some of the main resources used in making steel have increased, compared with the price of steel and the cost of living generally. The prices of most of the resources required for iron- and steelmaking have increased by between 3 and 4 times. A marked exception is imported ore where the availability of plentiful new deposits and lower shipping freights have helped keep prices down. The price of steel has increased by less than three times, which is most creditable when one considers the improved quality and performance one expects from similar articles of 25 years ago. Nevertheless, steel prices have increased by more than the general level of prices as reflected in the purchasing power of the pound, suggesting that if the steel industry is to maintain its position it must become even more efficient. Table 2
Typical increases in price of the main resources used in making steels. 1967–68 price as multiple of 1943–44 price
Home ore Imported ore Inland carriage of ore Coking coal Coke Scrap Wages Capital costs Ingot costs Board of Trade index of price of steel Reciprocal of purchasing power of pound
3.6 1.0 3.0 3.8 3.6 3.1 4.3 3.2 3.6 2.8 2.1
IRONMAKING Hatfield, although not directly concerned with ironmaking, was nevertheless interested in the whole spectrum of technology. In other places I have referred to the dramatic improvements in blast furnace practice and performance which have occurred since the war, but when we go back to Hatfield’s period the changes in ironmaking standards are even more marked. Arthur Dorman, in his Presidential Address to The Institute in 1944, said ‘the average weekly make per furnace [which at that time was about 1,300 tons] should be 3,000 tons at least, or considerably more if more adequate supplies of rich foreign ore were available, or some schemes of treating lean home ores became practicable’. Today, a good blast
SEQ 0036 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0036 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
36
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
furnace should produce 5,000 tons a day, some 12 times Arthur Dorman’s modest target of 1944. While much of the improvement has been due to the application of sound chemical engineering knowledge and will continue from this, it is only fair to point out that at the time of Arthur Dorman’s prophecy, rich imported ore was scarce, and it was thought this country would be much more dependent on lean home ores than has proved to be the case. Nevertheless, other shibboleths have had to be broken. For example, we are now all convinced that ore must be 100% prepared, if not sintered, but in a paper in June 1943 on ‘Blast furnace and steel plant’ it is stated categorically that no significant advantages accrue from going beyond 45% sinter! Many other defined limitations of the blast furnace have gone and are going. Table 3 shows the capability and performance characteristics of blast furnaces in the UK scene then, now, and (at a guess) in the future. The last column of Table 3 has been put in to answer a likely question by Hatfield ‘How far can we go?’ While it is dangerous to prophesy about blast furnaces, Table 3 does show what a long way technically we can still go in improving performance and, when one considers the enormous gap which exists between the average and the best, this branch of our technology affords one of the greatest challenges to the industry. Our average daily output is 830 tons (and the US about 1,600 tons) compared with the world best approaching 6,000 tons. Although size differences play a part, there is still room for improvement since our biggest (31 ft) furnaces record output (over a month) is only 2,700 tons/day. If our blast furnace practice were brought up to the standards of present day best world performance, some 80% of our existing furnaces could be dispensed with. To replace all 82 blast furnaces, which in 1967 provided for a steel output of 24 m tons by 14 modern blast furnaces to make iron for 36–38m tons of steel would mean a capital investment of some £300m. Although some ‘direct reduction’ processes were known in Hatfield’s time, the issue was not as live as it is today. Despite the great surge of activity in this field during the last 25 years in this country, the blast furnace has remained one economic jump ahead of Table 3
Blast furnace technology of UK industry. 1943
1967
No. of furnaces capable of being blown
141
82
Largest furnace in UK (hearth diameter), ft (metres)
22 (6.7) 7.2 66,900 3.10 10.6 1.22 .. 1.22
31 (9.5) 15.2 275,100 1.94 63.8 0.66 0.02 0.68
Production of iron, m tons Production per furnace year, tons Average burden weight, ton/ton Sinter or pellets, % Coke consumption, ton/ton Coke equivalent of injected fuel, ton/ton Total coke equivalent, ton/ton *assuming no change in basic technology
Sometime in next 25 years* 14 (would suffice for projected output below) 33–39 (10–12) 22 1,600,000 1.5–1.6 100.0 0.45 0.11 0.56
SEQ 0037 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0037 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
37
direct reduction. At today’s prices, coke constitutes some 40% of the cost of iron and iron 25% of the cost of finished steel. In the UK the price of coke in relation to the price of other fuels remains reasonably favourable to coke. Therefore, unlike the position of some other countries where alternative fuels (natural gas and oil) are very cheap, the influence of direct reduction on our practice is likely to be limited in the next few years to the import of some pre-reduced iron sponge or pellets in lieu of conventional scrap for electric arc furnaces, or to boost blast furnace output over short periods when iron may be scarce at a particular plant, e.g. during a blast furnace reline. In overseas countries where natural gas or oil has economic advantages direct reduction may be attractive economically and could take the place of the blast furnace.
STEELMAKING Twenty-five years ago, with the exception of the Bessemer plants at Corby, Ebbw Vale and Workington, the OH furnace had a practical monopoly of the manufacture of common steels. OHs accounted for 91% of the steelmake compared with 67% today, and electric furnaces were restricted to melting of the more expensive alloy steels which could carry the cost of the power. The decline in OH furnaces is due to their partial substitution by oxygen converters in hot metal shops and by electric arc furnaces in cold metal shops. Table 4 summarises the marked reduction in the number of OH furnaces and converters in the last 25 years and how there could be an even more dramatic reduction in future. OHs and converters are grouped together as non-electric steel furnaces to allow the picture then and now to be more easily summarised. (Electric furnaces have been excluded because the smaller requirements of special and alloy steel manufacture will require the retention of such furnaces in comparatively small sizes and correspondingly larger numbers.) The most remarkable change in steelmaking since Hatfield’s time is the arrival of the oxygen furnace which now accounts for about 22% of our total steel production and could make at anticipated rates of replacement and investment up to 70% of our steel in 1980. This is such familiar ground that one need not dwell on this subject except to say Table 4 Steel furnaces (other than electric) of UK industry. Sometime in next 25 years*
1943
1968
Number in active existence
452
253
Total non-electric steel production, m tons
12
Average production per furnace in active existence, tons/year Largest capacity unit Highest average, tons/h (est.)
27,650
22 (est.) 87,000
14 (would suffice) 28 (est.) 2,000,000
300 (OH) 25 (OH)
400 (OH) 120 (LD)
300 (LD) 400 (LD)
*assuming no change in basic technology
SEQ 0038 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0038 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
38
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
that the LD converter will prove able to make the full range of common and lowalloy steels required, and that this will be the only type of converter likely to be built in the immediate future. Assuming a wand could be waved over the UK steel industry then, of a total of 38m tons of crude ingot steel in, say, 1980, about one-quarter will be made in electric arc furnaces (to take advantage of scrap availability) and the remainder in 300 ton converters. Only 14 such furnaces (of which nine would be working at one time) would be needed compared with 253 active OH furnaces and oxygen converters in use today. Another 22 or so 200 ton electric furnaces would be needed for cold metal works. Thus the whole of say 33m tons of tonnage or non-special steels could be made in less than 40 furnaces. There is a risk in suggesting that oxygen furnaces will not get significantly bigger than 300 tons, but the savings in operating costs to be realised by increasing oxygen furnace size must over this seem small at present in relation to the inconveniences of operating larger units. There has been limited improvement in performance of OH practice compared with that of 25 years ago. The best OH furnaces in the UK today average about 38 tons/h output compared with 15 tons/h in Hatfield’s time. However, fuel consumptions have improved only from a ‘best practice’ of 45 therms/ton to one of around 40 therms/ton, ignoring the special case of the Ajax furnaces at Scunthorpe which, using 100% of hot metal, are more akin to oxygen furnaces than to the conventional OH. OHs are now driven harder, as the increase in furnace output shows, and hard driving leading to higher waste gas temperature is not conducive to thermal efficiency. Further, more low carbon steels requiring a higher tapping temperature are now made. Less spectacular than the advance of the basic oxygen furnace, but no less important, is the development of electric arc furnaces from exclusive use for special steels and a maximum size of about 30 tons to their use in large tonnage steel melting shops at sizes of up to 140 tons, and probably in future up to 200 tons. This is likely to be the main cold metal process of the future. It is sometimes said that the growing ability of LD converters to accept more scrap, up to, say, 40%, by preheating or by the introduction of fuel burners, will slow up the growth of electric arc furnace steelmaking. However, the tendency to concentrate cold metal practice in scrap producing districts may work against the transport of scrap to LD plants. How about spray steelmaking and the fuel–oxygen–scrap (FOS) processes? Like most new developments, original unqualified enthusiasm is now being tempered by the inevitable difficulties encountered in bringing them to full scale commercial production. Remembering the time it took, however, to bring other familiar steelmaking processes, such as LD or going further back the Bessemer and Thomas processes, to fruition, it may be some years yet before we see the large scale introduction of spray steelmaking or FOS, but my successor in 1993 with a lecture perhaps entitled ‘Fifty years on’ may be pointing out how spray steelmaking has replaced basic oxygen converters and FOS taken a large part of the manufacture in the electric arc furnace. Although the ‘undiluted’ FOS process, in which electricity was not used at all, has proved economically disappointing in its first large scale trial, the principle of oxy fuel
SEQ 0039 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0039 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
39
may yet be used in arc-furnace practice to preheat scrap, or to assist melting, because of the high cost of electricity in this country. Indeed, unless the latter is remedied, and the price advantage our large and constant load deserves is obtained, serious consideration will have to be given to the generation of our own power, maybe even using a nuclear reactor or coal fired station linked exclusively to the works. Indeed, as nuclear technology develops, frequent studies are made of the possibility of applying nuclear energy to the industry. So far, the maximum temperatures achievable in the heat exchange gases from gas cooled reactors are not high enough to be of much interest to conventional steelmaking, and the only immediate practical application would be the installation of a nuclear electric generating station to supply a steelworks. However, the more advanced reactors using ceramic fuel elements and carbon monoxide as coolant give promise of providing temperatures of the order of 1000°C, approaching those adequate for some of the direct reduction processes. Twenty-five years from now, direct application of nuclear heat may be widespread. Vacuum melting, i.e. carrying out the complete operation of induction melting and casting inside an evacuated vessel, was practised in Hatfield’s time but has not expanded much since, largely because it is expensive and the size of melting unit which can be used has been limited so far to about 50 tons. There are several furnaces of 10–15 tons in the world but the largest unit in the UK is the new Brown Firth 5 ton furnace capable on increase to 10 tons. Many of the desirable properties of vacuum melted material can be achieved by the relatively new processes of consumable arc vacuum melting and the more economical electroslag refining technique. The latter particularly is making great headway. There are now 47 plants in production or under construction in the world (outside the USSR) and ingots, including slab ingots, of up to 5 tons in weight have been produced in this way. Indeed, by the drop-bottom technique analogous to continuous casting there would seem to be no limit to the length of slab which could be produced in this way. Another dramatic change in the 25 years since Hatfield’s death is the recent rapid development of continuous casting, which is becoming a standard commercial method of production. Today, there are 172 plants of this type, ranging from small experimental units to major plants of over 2m tons a year capacity, and more revolutionary techniques, such as the casting of plates in the Hazelett type of machines, still await us. Hatfield would have called for the sectioning of many specimens produced in this way to examine the as cast structure of billet, slab or section with its tendency to axial porosity. Despite the amounts of commercial steel made by continuous casting, the possibility of developments in techniques are still in their infancy. These include sequence casting, the casting of shapes, and sequence rolling. Sequence casting could improve the yield of steel still more by eliminating a large amount of tundish skull and starter bar ends. The problems are largely those of securing refractories capable of extending tundish and nozzle life. Sequence rolling is already anticipated to some extent by the practice of imposing a reduction at the exit of the machine to remove central porosity, and to give a greater flexibility in size without the need to change moulds. The problems of finish
SEQ 0040 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0040 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
40
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
rolling in line with continuous casting are largely those of matching the relatively high rolling speed of a finishing mill to the slow output of a single strand, but by installing a transfer table at the discharge of a battery of strands and inserting a soaking or wash heating furnace for temperature equalisation, it should be possible to roll in sequence with the continuous casting plant. This is one more step towards continuous steelmaking. In recent years a number of proposals for continuous steelmaking have been put forward and the work of Thring in this country and of Howard Worner in Australia will be familiar. Both these inventors base their plants on counterflow slag movement in an OH type operation. IRSID in France are working on a continuous oxygen furnace and spray steelmaking could in theory be continuous, given a continuous supply of hot metal. The economic gains through continuous steelmaking have still to be established. One of the problems receiving much attention in Hatfield’s time was that of gases and inclusions in steel. It may seem commonsense to assume that applying a vacuum to liquid steel will at least encourage the removal of gases, but although this suggestion was made on more than one occasion to the Ingots Committee it was always dismissed on the grounds of high cost. Maybe Hatfield, had he lived, would have pursued this, but in the end it was left to the Germans to show that vacuum degassing was not hopelessly expensive, and it is now common practice for a range of steels. The first trials of vacuum degassing had as their objective the removal of hydrogen; it has since found a more generally applicable use for deoxidation. The chemistry is simple, namely that reducing the partial pressure of carbon monoxide in the system enables carbon to play its full part as a deoxidiser, so producing a gaseous deoxidation product and cleaner steel. The cost of processing is only a few percent of the cost of the steel, so considerable growth of vaccum degassing in future steelmaking operations can be anticipated. At present there is vacuum degassing capacity for only about 3% of the Corporation’s steel production.
STEELWORKING Rolling mills have not shown the novelty of the newer steelmaking and casting processes. Improvements have been more in the detail of engineering design, in better drives, and more powerful motoring; in Hatfield’s time, for example, there were many steam driven mills. In the section mill field the modern universal beam mill had been anticipated some time before by the Gray mill on Teesside. Plate mills were all two high, mainly single stand mills, compared with the modern plate mill with four high stands. There were two continuous hot strip mills (at Ebbw Vale and Shotton) but sheet was made mainly on the old fashioned hand mill, work at which was both heavy and dangerous. A considerable degree of automation ranging from programme control by punch card or peg board to the more sophisticated systems on wide strip mills is now in being and will be extended in future. Hatfield worked in a company which specialised in forging, casting and engineering
SEQ 0041 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0041 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On 41 rather than in rolling. He might, therefore, show only mild interest in these high tonnage developments, apart perhaps from seeing stainless steel sheet rolled in a wide strip mill. Very marked improvements in welding as a form of fabrication have been developed in the past 25 years. The forged boiler drum has disappeared and the large monobloc rotor and the large casting are under competition from the welded article. Thus, the tendency to ever increasing sizes of ingot at the very large end is now being halted, although for billets, bar, section, and flat rolled products in the common steels, the average size of ingot is tending to increase in size because of the economic advantages of yield and output. We shall see less of a practice which was always regarded as something of a tour-de-force in Hatfield’s time: the tapping of the contents of several steel furnaces into one mould. The largest ingots cast by English Steel Corporation (ESC) were 310 tons from four acid OH furnaces and a 220 ton ingot from five electric arc furnaces; at Firth Brown 219 tons were cast from four acid OHs. The largest casting, also made by ESC, was 260 tons from four acid OHs. Continuous casting of 300 tons from LD furnaces, however, may become commonplace. Forging, particularly in its lighter varieties has moved a long way from Hatfield’s time in the direction of improved heating practice and particularly of automatic controls permitting much faster press operations. Since many of the problems of extrusion are akin to forging. Hatfield would have been interested in the various possibilities of direct production of gear blanks, twist drills, etc. by hydrostatic extrusion, particularly the elegant use of back pressure to prevent breaking up of the metal on the downstream side. He would also have become involved with the growing developments of powder metallurgy, not only for making conventional pressings as alternatives to drop forgings or castings, but for compacting into strip and other basic forms. This is one of the developments the steel industry in this country must enter into energetically to tap a rapidly growing market.
MAKING STEELS BETTER . . . The development of new steels was energetically pursued in Hatfield’s time, as it is now. This subject is so extensive that it requires a lecture to itself, but it is hardly necessary to point out the great advances which have been made in the last 25 years. As an example, however, may be quoted the improvement in mechanical properties obtaining in common classes of steel since 1943. Shipbuilding plates for hulls had a yield stress around 13 tons/in2, and the specified impact value of 20 ft lb could be measured at 20°C; now hull plates for critically stressed parts have to have a yield stress of 17–22 tons/in2 and the 20 lb impact value held at –40°C to –50°C. At the same time the steel has to be weldable. In 1943 steam piping for electric generating plant was usually mild steel for service at 450°C and had to show a 100,000 h rupture stress of 6 tons/in2; now steels for service at 600°C and 100,000 h rupture stress of 8 tons/in2 are used.
SEQ 0042 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0042 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
42
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
To these may be added the steels for special application, as for instance the high temperature steels for gas turbine engines and the maraging steels where strength and weldability need to be combined with lightness; the creep resisting steels to meet the continued increase (to its present plateau) in the temperature of operation of power stations and for some of the process stages of making gas from oil; and the life of our motor car engines between top overhauls has been largely improved through valve steel development. Hatfield would have been interested in the various thermomechanical-cumtransformation processes, such as controlled rolling, maraging, ausforming, and isoforming, which can give greatly improved properties over a much smaller range of alloy steel composition than had hitherto been the case. The extent to which these developments will be commercially adopted must be largely one of economics, the main extra cost being that of the reduced output enforced by operating at lower rolling temperatures. Progress in this field certainly is a continuing extrapolation of today’s knowledge, punctuated at indeterminate intervals by discontinuous changes due to new discoveries or inventions. The next 25 years should see an improvement of some 25% on present-day mechanical properties by gradualness and even greater advance if some new feature of solid state or metalmaking practice, e.g. fibre technology, is practised. After all, practical realised strengths are only 1/100 of what they could be ideally.
. . . AND SPECIAL Corrosion is still one of the great enemies of iron and steel, and the work of the Corrosion Committee set up 25 years ago still continues in laboratories throughout the country. The resistance to corrosion in service applications was tackled in a number of familiar ways (by using non-corrodible compositions such as stainless steel, by tinning or galvanising, or by painting) all of which were and still are the subject of much research. The market for stainless steel has grown enormously, largely in the form of flat rolled products for the chemical and food industries, and for domestic and building use, and, by further developments yielding economies of scale, stainless sheet can become more competitive in a wider range of markets. In the structural and building industries, low alloy corrosion resistance steels are now available, of which unpainted Cor-ten steel in structures, e.g. bridges, may be quoted. As for coated steels, the familiar tinplate and galvanised sheet are still much in demand, in a much greater variety of coating types and thicknesses made possible by the trend, almost complete in the case of tinplate, towards electrolytic instead of hot dip coating. In the past 25 years the whole process of manufacture of tinplate has made a dramatic change from the crude packmill to the modern continuous electrolytic plant of today. There is now rapid development of entirely new coatings, not significant in Hatfield’s time, for developing industries: the soft drinks industry, canned foods, etc., for which the chromate (Hi-Top) or chromium (Cansuper) substitutes for tinplate are being made and the various plastic laminate coatings or ‘colour
SEQ 0043 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0043 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Twenty-Five Years On
43
coated’ steel made by a roller coating process for domestic application. A still wider range of coatings is being developed on a laboratory or pilot plant scale, based on vacuum deposition or the powder coating principle, and we now have the possibility of applying to steel almost any substance we wish.
CONCLUSION Were Hatfield able to return to the industry today there is little he would regret and much of which he would approve. He might regret the obsolescence of acid OH steel (thought by many in Hatfield’s day to be the best steel of all), the possible decreasing importance of the very large forging, and the standard of some of today’s literature. He would certainly approve the growth of the industry in size and range, the recognition of research as vital to its wellbeing, the powerful tools, theoretical and experimental, now available for metallurgical research, and some of the highly modern and efficient processes and plants for bulk production of all steels and particularly alloy and special steels. What he would think about the structure of the industry following nationalisation would be surmise, but that he would delight in the technical challenge to steel in the laboratories and in the shops and mills is undoubted.
SEQ 0044 JOB IOM8627-002-003 PAGE-0044 NINETEENTH LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:17 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
SEQ 0045 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0045 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE TWENTY-THIRD HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy E. Pl¨ockinger At the time the lecture was given Professor Erwin Pl¨ockinger was Director of Research, Gebr. B¨ohler and Co., Vienna, Austria. The lecture was given at Ranmoor House, University of Sheffield, on 9 January 1973.
The electroslag remelting process is one of the most important of the many new processes which have been developed for the production of special steels and alloys. The main reasons for this predominance are: the remelting under a slag layer of high reactivity removes undesirable elements as well as non-metallic inclusions without altering the desired chemical composition. The chemical composition can be kept within close tolerances in the remelted material. The controlled solidification of relatively small volumes of liquid steel results in a very homogeneous ingot without internal defects. These characteristics of the remelted ingot are the essential basis for the production of wrought steels having superior cleanliness and mechanical properties which cannot be achieved by other processes. Another advantage is that almost any ingot section and size can be produced by ESR. This even includes hollow ingots for producing seamless tubings and rings and preforms of different shapes in cross-section. The ESR process can be easily automatically controlled thus giving close tolerances in the chemical composition and the structure of the whole remelted ingot. From a discussion of the metallurgical reactions involved in the ESR process it can be concluded, that there are still many possibilities for major improvements, e.g. the method of electrolytic refining and the melting under controlled atmosphere. Practical experience proves that this process is especially suited for high grade nickel and cobalt base super alloys and special steels, such as high strength steels, tool steels, and heat and corrosion resistant steels, which have to meet extreme requirements of the consumer industries. ESR ingots could successfully be used for the production of isotropic materials having the same properties in all directions. A very important field of application is the production of heavy forgings for the power industry. Despite the additional costs involved, ESR in many cases is economically competitive and sometimes even superior to conventional processes. This is mainly due to its reliability and the very good overall yield. Because of its metallurgical and economic advantages ESR has already found a wide use as a modern and necessary tool for the production of high grade steels and alloys.
45
SEQ 0046 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0046 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
46
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
The recent progress in the field of steelmaking processes has been characterised by many important developments which have found a worldwide use in a relatively short period; for instance, the techniques of oxygen blowing and vacuum metallurgy. Besides a more economic production of steels and alloys, the new processes have made it possible to meet the continuously increasing demands of the consumer industries on the quality of these materials. At present this especially applies to the electroslag remelting process for the production of high grade materials.1,2,3 It is no exaggeration to say that electroslag remelting has already established new measures for special steels and therefore there seems a justification to review the reasons for its fast and general acceptance, and to describe its widespread field of application already existing. The technical and metallurgical possibilities of the electroslag remelting process are today by no means fully utilised. However, their representation should be helpful in predicting future developments and in describing further fields of application. Such a contribution to the philosophy of electroslag re-melting necessitates some simplifications and the renunciation of metallurgical and technological details in order to emphasise clearly the essential items. For this reason I shall try to limit my paper to the importance of the ESR process within the entire field of modern processes for the production of extremely high quality steels and alloys. Although the ESR process can be used for the refining of many ferrous and nonferrous metals and alloys, I should like to speak only about the manufacture of steel ingots, as this is the main application of the new process today where the technical progress achieved can be easily recognised. A careful examination of all steps in steel production shows that the final technological properties of the wrought steel do not only depend on the proper melting processes, the proper chemical composition and an adequate hot working and thermal treatment, but especially on the properties of the ingot. These properties of the ingot influence remarkably the hot workability as well as the quality of the final product. Therefore, in steel production it is not sufficient only to adjust to the required chemical composition and aim for the utmost cleanness in the molten steel. The decisive step is the solidification of the molten metal into an ingot free from internal defects.4 Such an ideal ingot should have the following properties: (i) uniform chemical composition, i.e. no segregation of any kind (ii) absence of undesirable and harmful elements and non-metallic inclusions (iii) uniform structure throughout the whole ingot without microporosity and blowholes. With conventionally cast ingots, as is generally known, these requirements can be achieved only to a limited extent. The problems arising from this fact will increase with increasing size and weight of the ingots. The major reason for this is not due to an improper technology in ingot production, but mainly to the physical laws controlling the crystallisation process. In conventional casting it is not possible to influence sufficiently
SEQ 0047 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0047 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
47
the solidification behaviour of industrial scale ingots under the given pouring conditions. To overcome all the disadvantages of the conventional solidification process in the ingot mould a fundamental change in the crystallisation of the liquid steel has to be achieved. That is possible only with the continuous solidification of small amounts of molten metal as it takes place in the remelting processes. Figure 1 shows schematically the difference in the structure of both a conventionally cast and a remelted ingot. The solidification of a large volume of liquid steel in the ingot mould leads to ingot segregation. The extent of such segregation depends upon the crystallisation behaviour of the solidifying multiphase system. Local accumulations of non-metallic inclusions and the formation of microporosity and shrinking holes cannot be avoided. The structure of the ingot shows dendritic and globular solidification patterns with varying orientation.
Fig. 1 Comparison of the structure of a conventionally cast and a re-melted ingot.4
In the remelted ingot a relatively small amount of liquid metal solidifies continuously according to the melting rate of the electrode. The solidification progresses into a shallow liquid-metal pool. Thus macrosegregation, accumulation of non-metallic inclusions and microporosity will not occur, and the remaining small amounts of non-metallic inclusions are evenly distributed. The ingot structure shows columnar crystals which are slightly inclined toward the longitudinal axis of the ingot. Therefore the remelted ingot nearly meets all the previously mentioned conditions for an ideal ingot. However, a certain microsegregation cannot be prevented even by this process. The first technical realisation of this principle took place in the vacuum arc furnace with consumable electrodes. The vacuum remelting process allows the degassing of the metal and the elimination of non-metallic inclusions, thus giving a remelted steel of high purity and the desired structure. However, no other metallurgical reactions are possible. Therefore the electrodes must have the same chemical composition as the remelted ingot, but possible losses of elements of high volatility must be taken into consideration. Some of the removed impurities and evaporated elements are deposited in the shell zone of the remelted ingot which generally has to be removed in the following manufacturing processes. If, on the other hand, the remelting of a consumable electrode is carried out in
SEQ 0048 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0048 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
48
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
a reactive slag as in the ESR process, further metallurgical and technological advantages can be achieved. These advantages have proved to be decisive for the rapid introduction of this new process. The principle of the electroslag remelting process is shown in Fig. 2. It is a continuous process in which melting, metallurgical reactions and solidification of the steel occur simultaneously. As the aim of the process is the production of ingots with superior quality, the rate of crystallisation determines the production rate. This is because the heat conduction of the solidified metal is limited and does not allow an increase of the rate of crystallisation at random.
Fig. 2 The principle of the ESR process.
Electroslag remelting can be carried out in different ways as shown in Table 1. The metallic charge usually is a cast electrode of suitable cross-section. Both forged and rolled electrodes can be used. The refining of liquid metal in the same way has also been suggested. This, however, would require additional heating of the slag with, for instance, auxiliary electrodes. Metallic powders together with a strip electrode can also be used for the production of remelted ingots. The melting heat is usually produced by resistance heating the slag bath. On the other hand, melting can also be carried out by means of either a permanent electrode or a plasma arc. The use of collar type moulds instead of fixed long moulds gives the possibility of producing ingots in any length required. By electroslag remelting not only round ingots, but also ingots of practically any desired shape such as square, rectangular or hollow, can be produced. It is possible to manufacture preforms even with varying cross-sections. This method is applied for example in the production of rolls.
SEQ 0049 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0049 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy Table 1
Possible features in electroslag remelting.
Metallic charge
Power supply
Mould design
Ingot shape
1. Cast electrodes
1. Resistance heating a) alternating current b) direct current c) ac superimposed dc
1. Fixed long mould
1. Round
2. Collar type mould a) movable mould b) moveable base plate
2. Square
2. Rolled or forged electrodes 3. Strip electrodes and metal powder 4. Liquid metal
49
3. Rectangular
2. Non-consumable electrode
4. Hollow
3. Plasma arc
5. Preform
The metallurgical reactions involved in the ESR process enable the metallurgist to adjust the refining process to a widespread range of requirements.2 I should like to show some details in the following examples in which only the standard process will be discussed. In this process a solid electrode is melted in a reactive slag and the liquid metal solidifies in a water cooled mould. Any metallurgical reaction in the ESR process has to be considered as a three phase reaction in which the molten metal, the slag and the gas phase take part. The reactions are characterised by high reaction rates due to a high surface to volume ratio between the liquid metal film at the electrode tip and the highly superheated slag, which furthermore is intensively moved by both thermal and electrical forces. The composition of the slag can be varied to quite an extent and thus be adapted for different metallurgical requirements. The slag consists mainly of fluorspar and varying contents of alumina and lime. Normally it should have a desulphurising effect on the metal and should be capable of absorbing the non-metallic inclusions. Other slags, however, may be adjusted to retain sulphur in the metal if desired, for example, in resulphurised tool steels. In any case, the composition of the slag should be such that the following conditions are met: (i) the electric specific resistivity should be between 0.20 and 0.50 ohm cm (ii) oxidation of alloying elements has to be avoided (iii) pick-up of undesirable elements such as P, Si, Al from the slag by the liquid metal should not occur (iv) the melting point of the slag should be lower than that of the metal to be remelted (v) the slag should be of low viscosity in order to produce just a thin slag layer on the ingot surface (vi) an adequate interface tension between slag and liquid metal must be achieved. The slag–metal reactions in the ESR process will follow the well known thermodynamic principles. Of course the high reaction temperatures, in the order of 1800°C, have to be taken into account. Figure 3, showing the Si–O equilibrium in electroslag remelting may be taken as a typical example.1 From the strong dependence of the silicon deoxidation constant on the slag basicity, or in other words its silica activity, it can be concluded that low oxygen contents in the remelted steel can be achieved only when slags with low silica
SEQ 0050 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0050 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
50
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 3 The de-oxidation constant of silicon K'Si in electroslag remelting.1,2
contents are used. Therefore the oxygen content of the ESR ingot depends only on the physico-chemical interactions between slag and metal during remelting, thus being independent of the oxygen content in the electrode. The operating slag not only interacts with the liquid metal, but also with the gas phase above the slag pool. With open melting the slag may absorb hydrogen and oxygen from the air. Oxygen pick-up leads to the formation of SO2 which escapes to the atmosphere, thus resulting in a constant desulphurisation during the entire remelting operation. This reaction, however, causes oxygen to pass through the slag into the melt which can lead to the oxidation of certain alloys, for example Al, Ti and Mg in high alloy steels and Ni base alloys and to a higher oxygen content in the steel. Figure 4 shows the influence of the partial pressure of oxygen in the gas phase above the slag pool on the oxygen content of the remelted steel for various slags.2 An undesirable oxygen pick-up can thus be prevented by using a gas atmosphere with sufficiently low oxygen contents. Another method is the application of a continuous deoxidation of the slag. Both methods are used for the production of metals and alloys with an extremely low oxygen content. Hydrogen pick-up from the atmosphere can be even more harmful, as a transfer of hydrogen to the liquid metal may occur. Such pick-up will be more pronounced the higher the humidity of the atmosphere and the larger the slag surface exposed to the
SEQ 0051 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0051 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
Fig. 4
51
Influence of the partial pressure of oxygen in the gas atmosphere on the oxygen content of AISI304 remelted under various slags.2
atmosphere. By remelting under a dry protective gas, hydrogen pick-up can be eliminated and even a reduction of the hydrogen content of the metal can be attained. As the slags used for remelting at high temperatures represent ionic solutions, the mode of current will influence the metallurgical reactions to an extent which should not be neglected. Varying results of the desulphurisation and oxygen content of the ESR ingot in dependence on mode of electric current are shown schematically in Fig. 5.5,6 When direct current is used, the metallurgical results obtained are strongly dependent on the current polarity and current density at the surface of the liquid metal pool. With increasing ingot diameter the current density will decrease and above a certain diameter, only the polarity of the consumable electrode will be responsible for the extent of the desulphurisation and deoxidation reactions. If alternating current is applied, the direction of these reactions will vary according to the frequency of the current. This in turn will result in an oscillation around the thermodynamic equilibrium which forces a rapid approach to the theoretical state of equilibrium. A combination of the metallurgical and economic advantages can be obtained if a superimposed dc is applied in ac remelting. As an example the effect of superimposed dc on the reduction of hydrogen during remelting is shown in Fig. 6. This effect is observed independent of the composition of the slag.7 Disadvantages of ac as compared to dc operation are increased resistance and inductive losses. These may be overcome by utilising a low frequency ac which is of special
SEQ 0052 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0052 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
52
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 5
Oxygen content and desulphurisation in ESR ingots independent of ingot diameter and current mode (schematic).5,6
Fig. 6 The change of hydrogen content in steel lime content of the slag and the mode of current.7
SEQ 0053 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0053 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
53
importance in the operation of large-scale ESR units. If solid-state equipment is used for the conversion to low frequency ac an alternating current with varying phase lengths can be obtained as shown in Fig. 7. This possibility could be used to influence further the direction of the desired metallurgical reactions.5
Fig. 7
Possible variations of negative and/or positive phase length with low frequency ac.5
In order to obtain ESR ingots having optimum structures it is important to adjust the melting rate and the power input to the slag pool so that a constant shape of the solidification fronts and unidirectional solidification are obtained. This requires a shallow liquid metal pool, which can be achieved by adequate selection of the operating parameters such as current and voltage under otherwise constant conditions. In Fig. 8 the influence of operating conditions on the primary structure of stainless steel ingots is shown.2 With proper conditions, as shown on the left, a uniform ingot structure with columnar crystallites slightly inclined to the longitudinal axis of the ingot is obtained. On the contrary, the use of operating conditions resulting in a deep metal pool leads to an ingot structure very similar to a conventional cast ingot with internal defects, as shown on the right. Before dealing with the material properties of remelted steels and alloys it should be mentioned that the ESR process is better suited for automation than any other melting process. More than that, it demands automation if highest uniformity in the production is to be maintained. Today the basic knowledge required is available, such as detailed experience in metallurgy, as well as the influence of operating conditions on the ingot structure. During remelting constant operating conditions can be maintained only by means of automatic control devices. Today such equipment is installed in all modern ESR plants, enabling not only automatic operation during the actual remelting but also automatic control of starting, hot topping and electrode change operation.
SEQ 0054 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0054 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
54
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 8 Influence of operating conditions on the macrostructure of ESR ingots:2 (a) 48 V, 2000 A; (b) 42 V, 5000 A.
In ESR the consumable electrode will not only be converted into perfectly desulphurised and deoxidised metal but furthermore into an ingot with a more or less perfect structure as discussed before. In any case the ingot structure is of such paramount importance that even higher contents of equally distributed non-metallic inclusions are less harmful to the properties of the alloy than in conventional cast ingots. Having discussed the ESR process in general, an attempt will be made to demonstrate the superior quality of the ESR material with regard to workability and properties of the final product.8–10 The ingot structure, without internal defects and ingot segregation, leads to improved hot workability of the remelted material, especially for high alloy steels difficult to hot work. In Fig. 9 a hot torsion test diagram of the AISI329 Cr–Ni–Mo stainless steel is shown as an example.11 The distinctly improved hot plasticity of this material means that it can be successfully used for the manufacture of complicated drop forgings. Such forgings manufactured from the as cast ESR ingot by a single drop forging operation are shown in Fig. 10. Even new alloys such as a 3%C–12%Cr steel not suited for hot working from the conventional ingot can now be rolled or forged without major problems from the ESR ingot. The superior quality of even large diameter ESR ingots especially with regard to ingot segregation, microporosity, and accumulation of non-metallic inclusions, represents a definite advantage in the production of heavy forgings. For these reasons it was to be expected that high quality forgings could be obtained from comparatively small ESR ingots as less hot working should be required. In order to determine the minimum reduction required by forging, a step down forging, as shown in Fig. 11, has been made from a 22 t 1000 mm diameter Cr–Ni–Mo
SEQ 0055 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0055 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
Fig. 9 Hot torsion test diagram of AISI329 from conventional and ESR ingots.11
Fig. 10 Upset forged parts directly produced from ESR ingot steel AISI329.2
55
SEQ 0056 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0056 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
56
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 11 Influence of hot working ratio on the reduction of area, step down forging from a 1000 mm diameter Ni–Cr–Mo steel ESR ingot12 (0.25%C, 3.5%Ni, 1.25%Cr, 0.5%Mo).
alloy steel ESR ingot.12 This forging, which was forged without upsetting, was heat treated and samples were taken from all steps. The tensile strength varied betweem 830 and 900 N/mm2 and showed no dependence on the direction or the location of the samples within the forging. Therefore it appeared more appropriate to use the toughness values in order to differentiate the mechanical properties. Figure 11 shows the influence of the hot working ratio on the reduction of area. It can be seen that excellent toughness properties were obtained both for the longitudinal and for the transverse direction in the periphery, mid-radius and centre position. This is true even for a hot working ratio as low as 2.5. Similar results were obtained for the notch toughness. The superiority of the electroslag remelted material over conventionally produced forging ingots is also proved by the results on generator shafts and heavy turbine discs. Two generator shafts each weighing 8.9 t were produced from a Ni–Mo steel. The first shaft was made by stretch and upset forging from a vacuum degassed 22 t forging ingot having 1200 mm diameter, and the second shaft was stretch forged only from an ESR ingot having a weight of 14 t and 1000 mm diameter. It can be seen from Fig. 12 that after heat treating to the same tensile strength (680 N/mm2) the shaft made from the ESR ingot had improved toughness properties. This is especially true for the transition temperature which was lowered with electroslag remelting by 20°C. A statistical evaluation of the mechanical properties of large turbine discs having a diameter of 1700 mm and a height of 600 mm also showed the superiority of the electroslag remelted ingot. These forgings were made from Cr–Ni–Mo steels. Figure 13 shows the toughness properties of two 9.2 t discs produced from a conventionally cast ingot by stretch and upset forging or from an ESR ingot by upset forging only, respectively. Even in larger turbine discs (2000 mm diameter, 16 t weight) which were upset forged from an 18 t ESR ingot having 1000 mm diameter no fibrous stucture or segregation could be observed. The mechanical properties were independent of the direction.13
SEQ 0057 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0057 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
Fig. 12
Comparison of the mechanical properties of two 8.9 t generator shafts of a low alloy Ni–Mo steel made from arc furnace vacuum cast and ESR ingots.12
Fig. 13
Comparison of the toughness properties of two 9.3 t turbine discs of a Cr–Ni–Mo steel made from arc furnace vacuum cast and ESR ingots.12,14
57
SEQ 0058 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0058 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
58
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
A further distinct advantage of the ESR ingot is represented by its low microsegregation. In Fig. 14 the microsegregation ratios of chromium and molybdenum are compared for both conventionally cast and ESR ingots of H13 hot work die steel. This low microsegregation combined with the freedom from ingot segregation is an important presupposition for the production of practically isotropic wrought special steels. This already can be realised on a technical scale by using special hot working techniques and heat treatments which have been developed in order to minimise further the microsegregation. These steels have practically the same properties in all directions. From Fig. 15 the marked improvement of reduction of area in the transverse direction with decreasing microsegregation ratio of molybdenum can be seen.
Fig. 14 Primary structure and microsegregation of H13 in conventionally cast and ESR ingots:14 (a) conventional ingot (centre), 300 mm diameter, as cast; (b) ESR ingot centre, 300 mm diameter, as cast.
Fig. 15 Influence of microsegregation on the reduction of area in the transverse direction in forged bars of H13.15
SEQ 0059 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0059 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
59
The extreme reduction of microsegregation is of definite importance in the production of high strength steels, tool steels and above all hot work die steels. A statistical evaluation of test results of a two year production period of H13 bar material in the diameter range 150–470 mm is presented in Fig. 16. Optimum results, particularly in the transverse direction, are obtained from ESR material specially treated to give minimum microsegregation. Conversely such a special treatment has only a rather limited effect on conventional cast ingots.
Fig. 16
Statistical distribution of toughness properties in the transverse direction in forged bars 150–470 mm diameter steel H13.15
Excellent and isotropic toughness properties result in an improved behaviour of materials under multiaxial stresses and in a reduction in notch sensitivity, as is shown in Fig. 17. This diagram contains the curves for the notch bar tensile strength v. tensile strength of open arc furnace, VAR and ESR material. It can be seen that remelting in the vacuum arc furnace or by the electroslag process not only improves the notch bar tensile strength, but also shifts the beginning of the decrease of the notch strength to higher values of the
Fig. 17 Notch tensile test diagram of steel H13 melted under various conditions.8,15
SEQ 0060 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0060 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
60
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
ultimate tensile strength. A further improvement is obtained by a special treatment for the removal of microsegregations. The fatigue properties are also markedly improved by electroslag remelting. Figure 18 shows that the fatigue strength of electroslag remelted steel H13 is superior to that of conventionally produced steel, and that the fatigue strength can also be further increased by the special treatment which has been mentioned before. This is true for both specimens with and without a notch. Indeed, the experience has proved that very remarkable improvements can be achieved in practice. For certain applications the life of H13 hot work tools has been increased by about 100 or 200% and more than the life of dies made from conventional H13.16
Fig. 18 Fatigue strength of steel H13, heat treated to UTS 1900 N.mm2, rotating bar test.8,15
CONCLUSIONS The improvements and achievements obtained by the ESR process to date can be briefly summarised as follows: 1. Remelting of case hardening steels is mainly carried out to improve the cleanness to an extent which cannot be attained in conventional melting and casting processes. The improved toughness properties in the transverse direction are of importance only when high strength levels are required. 2. For heat treatable steels the toughness properties in the transverse direction are of importance besides the improved cleanness. A typical example is represented by alloy steels used for aircraft landing gear which will safely meet the stringent specifications when electroslag remelted. 3. Improved toughness properties can be attained in high duty forgings such as turbine rotors and discs as well as generator shafts. The better overall yield attainable with this kind of production may to a certain extent compensate for the increased expenses due to the additional remelting operation.
SEQ 0061 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0061 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Electroslag Remelting – a Modern Tool in Metallurgy
61
4. The excellent cleanness and toughness properties together with a special hot working and thermal treatment leads to the production of practically isotropic hot work die steels and ultra high strength steels, thus justifying the application of the ESR process for these alloys. 5. By remelting ledeburitic tool steels, an extraordinary uniformity in carbide distribution is achieved throughout the cross-section, which in turn results in less distortion in heat treatment and in many cases, especially for cold working applications, in an improved service life. 6. Precipitation hardening Ni and Co base super alloys today are remelted by ESR, attaining at least the same standards as by the VAR process. For these alloys cleanness and structural homogeneity are of the same importance as the safe production to close analytical tolerances. The rapid adoption of the ESR process by practically all major steel producing countries is easily understood if one considers the metallurgical progress already attained and still attainable by this new process. As shown in Table 2, 37 production scale ESR units capable of producing ingots with diameters above 400 mm were in operation at the end of 1972 and 6 more units are under construction. The production of ESR material in the western countries will have reached approximately 80,000 metric tons in 1972. In considering the units under construction and additional projects to be carried out in the next years, the annual production in 1977 can be estimated to be 200,000 t. This would represent an average annual growth rate of 20%. Table 2 ESR units with ingot diameter ≥ 400 mm in the western world and their estimated production.
Country
ESR units operation, 1972
Estimated production, 1972
Units under construction, 1972
Estimated production, 1977
Western Europe Austria Belgium France German Fed. Rep. Great Britain Italy Sweden Spain USA Japan Others
2 .. 2 7 8 1 6 .. 10 1 ..
5000 .. 4000 16 500 14 000 2000 14 000 .. 21 500 3000 ..
.. 2 .. .. 1 1 1 .. 1 .. ..
200 000
Total
37
80 000
6
200 000
The units to be put into operation in the next few years will mainly cover the ingot diameter range 500–1000 mm. A number of large scale ESR units for the production of heavy forging ingots up to 3000 mm diameter will be out into operation; one 2500 mm unit has already been started up recently. Furthermore there is a demand for heavy slab
SEQ 0062 JOB IOM8627-003-004 PAGE-0062 TWENTY-THIRD LEC REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
62
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
units for the production of ESR slab ingots in excess of 50 tons, the construction of which, according to the present state of development, does not seem to be impossible. For ultra high quality products and special requirements remelting under controlled atmospheres will certainly gain importance. Generally speaking one can say that the ESR process will have to be used whenever the requirements of the properties of steels and alloys cannot be fulfilled by conventional melting and casting methods. It will, however, also be applied when improved yield and reduced rejection rates in certain cases will represent a cost saving factor, thus justifying the additional processing. The worldwide increasing application of the ESR process together with the experience gained so far may justify the statement that this new process represents a valuable tool for the metallurgical industry, enabling it to raise its technical standard to a higher level.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
¨ E. PLOCKINGER and W. HOLZGRUBER: Rev. M´et., 1968, 65, 463. ¨ W. HOLZGRUBER and E. PLOCKINGER : Stahl Eisen, 1968, 88, 638. M. WAHLSTER and H. SPITZER: Stahl Eisen, 1972, 92, 961. ¨ E. PLOCKINGER : Berg. H¨utten Monatsh., 1969, 114, 344. P. MACHNER and W. HOLZGRUBER: Paper presented at 7th internat. congress on electroheat, Warsaw, 18–22 Sept. 1972. W. HOLZGRUBER et al.: Paper presented at vacuum metallurgy conference, Pittsburgh, 16– 19 June 1969. W. HOLZGRUBER et al.: Paper presented at internat. symposium on special electrometallurgy, Kiev, 6–9 June 1972. ¨ E. PLOCKINGER : Stahl Eisen, 1972, 92, 972. A. RANDAK et al.: Stahl Eisen 1972, 92, 981. H. SPITZER: Stahl Eisen, 1972, 92, 994. W. HOLZGRUBER et al.: Radex Rund., 1970, 163. M. KRONEIS et al.: Paper presented at 5th internat. forging conference, Terni, 6–9 May 1970. M. KRONEIS et al.: Paper presented at 6th internat. forgemasters meeting, Cherry Hill, N.J., 1–6 Oct. 1972. A. SCHNEIDHOFER et al.: Berg. H¨utten. Monatsch., 1970, 115, 366. M. KRONEIS et al.: Berg. H¨utten. Monatsch., 1968, 113, 416. H. STRAUBE et al.: Schmiede. Mitt., Industrie-Anzeiger, 1971, 93, 609.
SEQ 0063 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0063 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE TWENTY-FOURTH HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
Eurosteelresearch R. S. Barnes At the time the lecture was presented Dr Robert S. Barnes was Director of Research and Development, British Steel Corporation. The lecture was given at the Royal Commonwealth Society, London, on 14 November 1973.
The further evolution of Europe as a steel producing region will call for larger production units, yet with sufficient flexibility to adjust to fluctuations, both in raw material supplies and in the market for steel products. The access to bulk supplies of iron ore, reductants and fuels, will dominate the location of the large steelmaking plants which will be augmented by smaller, more flexible units concentrating on the finishing processes and located nearer to the steel user. In the future new sources of indigenous reductants and fuels will increasingly affect the steelmaking pattern and in the long term nuclear energy will reduce the consumption of fossil fuels. The research and development needed for these changes to come about is considerable, but if the opportunity is taken jointly to solve some of the major problems there could be a marked effect upon the long term viability of Europe’s steel industry. This will call for a clear identification of the most effective way to deploy the many research and development skills distributed throughout Europe.
It may be thought, particularly by those who belonged to the European Coal and Steel Community from the outset, that it is hardly appropriate, or even proper, for a Briton to hold forth on the subject of cooperative research and development for the European steel industry. That Hatfield was a Briton, however, gives me good reason on this occasion of the 24th lecture in his memory, and the first to be given since the European Community was enlarged. Dr Hatfield was one of the main driving forces in establishing cooperative research in the UK. He helped establish the research committees which became the focal point for the technical scene in the British steel industry between the wars and provided the basis for the formation of the British Iron and Steel Research Association (BISRA). He was a pioneer who early realised that only by common effort could the ever growing technical problems of the steel industry be tackled. The conditions that Hatfield recognised have become intensified in the thirty years since his death and many of the major technological problems of the steel industry can no longer be adequately dealt with by the industry of a single nation. It is therefore fitting that this lecture should be concerned with the widening of the research and development activity to include the British steel industry into the
63
SEQ 0064 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0064 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
64 Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III framework of the wider European scene. This is a challenge – which Hatfield would certainly have welcomed. Also, this lecture comes at a time when The Iron and Steel Institute and The Institute of Metals are amalgamating to form The Metals Society – a body which will bring together, on a worldwide basis, members of the ferrous and non-ferrous metals industries to draw mutual benefit from discussing openly the results of each other’s technical successes and failures. I am sure Dr Hatfield would have applauded this initiative. I am greatly honoured at having been invited to deliver this lecture, and particularly on this subject. Having been outside the Community until recently helps me to look back over its achievements and, not having been associated with them, to look dispassionately and without prejudice towards the future role for research and development for the European steel industry. The only advantage I can have over so many others much more qualified is the experience gained, over the last four years in particular, in establishing a new identity and role for the previously independent research and development organisations within the British steel industry. This task has involved bringing together, from a research and development point of view, fourteen independent companies and BISRA, which was the largest research association and itself pursued cooperative research, but on a national scale. As each already had its own goals, traditions and structures, the task of bringing them all together has taken time. It has required patience and a measure of that pragmatism so necessary when dealing with complex situations, and often associated with the British. While these experiences can be only of marginal value in the examination of the research needs on a European scale, I hope they can help to point out some of the directions and stimulate the debate which is now beginning on the future for steel and thus for steel research in Europe. I shall give my own view, first on the place for steel in Europe, secondly on the areas appropriate for community research, and thirdly on some of the organisational requirements for such Eurosteelresearch.
THE PLACE FOR STEEL IN EUROPE It is not my purpose to dwell on the history of the steel industry, nor on its technical evolution. Although the part played by the early pioneers, by the men of action, by the early craftsmen, by the scientists and by the technologists each would make a good subject for a talk such as this, I shall merely list (Table 1) a few of the technological achievements of Europe’s steel industry. The cooperative research stimulated by the inception of the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) in 1951 (which was itself the forerunner of Euratom and the European Economic Community in 1957) started a trend and has evolved some concepts which will continue. Cooperative research projects have been stimulated by funds from the Commission, these funds being provided from a levy upon the coal and steel companies of the ECSC; normally the research is conducted with 60% financial support from the Commission. The way in which these expenditures have grown in the various
SEQ 0065 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0065 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
65
Table 1 Historical landmarks in steelmaking in Europe. (The modern steel industry was born in Europe as a result of Bessemer’s researches, and European inventions have continued to play a significant role, even though the major application of them has often occurred in other parts of the world). Year 1740 1856 1868 1878 1879 1877
1951 1971
Event Huntsman, Sheffield, England. Crucible steelmaking. About 20 lb per crucible. Bessemer in London, England. Pneumatic steelmaking 10 t in 15 min by the 1870s. Siemens Bros. in England, and Martin in France. Open-hearth steel-making: 20–30 t in 10 h. Thomas and Gilchrist. Paper on Basic Bessemer Steelmaking: main application in the 1880s in Europe. Siemens experiments with electric-arc steelmaking in England. 1900 Exploitation by Paul Heroult ´ in France. 1905 First Heroult ´ furnace in USA. Induction furnace experiments in Italy by de Ferranti. 1899 First commercial application, in Sweden. 1907 Experimental 2 t furnace, in Sheffield, England. 1914 First commercial application in USA. First LD experimental converter at Linz, Austria. Bottom-blown processes with oxygen and propane. Maximillianshutte, ¨ Germany
areas of research is shown in Table 2.1 There is also a contribution for pollution research, provided through the Social Affairs Directorate. (For the five years ending in 1972 the average amount was 0.8m units of account, while the average asked for, for the following five years, is 2m units of account.) This area of ‘Social Fund research’ is growing more rapidly than the Research Fund, which itself has increased to 8m units of account for 1973. The total ECSC support to research accounted for approximately 5% of the total research expenditure of the European steel industry in 1972. Loans have also been provided to stimulate technical development and there are indications that these mechanisms are becoming more common. Table 2 ECSC grants to steel research. Research areas supported by the Research Fund of the Commission, which increased to 8m units of account for 1973 (a unit of account is about 1.2 US dollars). Category
1955–1961
1962–1966
1967–1971
Iron ore Blast furnaces experimental other Sintering Direct reduction Steelworks Rolling mills Analysis and methods of measurement Properties in use Physical metallurgy Steel utilisation Various
2.8
1.9
0.7
2.1 1.6 0.6 1.2 0.6 0.1 .. .. .. .. 0.8
4.7 1.0 .. 2.7 2.3 2.6 1.9 1.7 0.1 0.6 1.1
1.3 2.5 0.7 0.1 3.9 3.2 2.8 4.1 1.5 1.2 1.3
Totals
9.8
20.6
23.3
Grand totals 5.4
}
13.2 1.3 4.0 6.8 5.9 4.7 5.8 1.6 1.8 3.2 53.7
SEQ 0066 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0066 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
66
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
While many of the projects have consisted of a number of small items often within a broad area of research, some have been larger in concept and capable of influencing more directly the future of Europe’s steel industry. Notable major projects were, for instance, the gas injection on the experimental blast furnace, the development of the Purofer direct reduction process, and the work on the IRSID continuous steelmaking process. The various research projects have succeeded in improving the contacts and the communications between the technical experts from the member countries. The research has been conducted in the laboratories of the various national research institutes, universities and the steel companies themselves. While these arrangements have not greatly enhanced the mobility of research workers within the Community, they have avoided the setting up of special research laboratories. Such laboratories have often been set up in other contexts, and experience has shown that this leads, in the long term, to problems of finding new roles when their immediate tasks have been achieved. Besides these considerable efforts on research itself, there is also the process of harmonising patent law and removing other technical barriers to trade within the Community. These could be most important to the future technical health of the industries of the Community and they can be greatly helped by a background of technical cooperation. The Market for Steel in Europe The growth in output of what is now the steel industry is shown in Fig. 1 from the year 1880 when iron was its main product.2 While the growth has not been steady, since the Second World War it has been impressive and shows no sign of abating.
Fig. 1 Iron and steel production in the UK and the Six 1880–1970. The output of what is now the steel industry is shown from 1880 when iron was its main product. The growth has not been steady, but since the Second World War has been impressive and shows no sign of abating.
SEQ 0067 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0067 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
67
As shown in Fig. 2,3 in the Six the growth in steel consumption averaged 5.5% per year between 1955 and 1970, compared with an average growth in the UK of 2%. In their Projection 85 the IISI suggest that demand in 1985 will be 36m t for the UK and 153m t for the Six.4 They do not explicitly forecast for the Nine, but on this basis consumption in the enlarged Community would be estimated at around 200m t/year by 1985.
Fig. 2 Steel consumption in ECSC and in UK (1950–1971). For the last 20 years steel consumption in the Six has been growing at a rate of 5.5% per annum compared with the much lower UK rate of 2%. Demand forecasts made by IISI are 153m t for the Six in 1985 and 36m t for the UK.
During this period of rapid growth, however, the industry has suffered serious fluctuations in demand. These fluctuations pose a serious problem as modern large high throughput plants are only profitable when their utilisation exceeds 85–90%. Sources of Raw Material In the Six, as in the UK, the growth in steel production since the Second World War has been accompanied by a switch in raw material sources from local to imported supplies. For iron ore this has been brought about by the discovery of higher grade ores overseas paralleled by the depletion of the better-grade home ores. France is the only large scale ore producer in the Community (56m t in 1971) and even there output is declining. Currently France imports about 20% of its ore compared with 55–60% (70% if only the
SEQ 0068 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0068 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
68
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
iron content is considered) for the Six as a whole.5 The fall in the cost of shipping ore as a consequence of the increase in the sizes of ships used has been a major influence in this switch. As Fig. 3 shows, since 1963 the average size of bulk carrier in the world fleet6 has increased from 20,000 to 30,000 dwt t; for an average voyage (3255 miles for the UK steel industry in 1973) this will decrease the cost of shipping the ore by about 22%.7 Of course, the largest vessels available offer much greater reductions in the cost of transport, hence the development of deep water ore terminals to make provision for these very large ships. For instance, the development of Europort at Rotterdam has been of particular value to the West German steel industry (whose home ore production has fallen from 19m t in the late 1950s to 7m in 1970)5 where the disadvantage of the long distance from the coast has been partially offset by the use of Rhine waterway transport.
Fig. 3
Size of dry bulk carriers. Since 1963 the size of bulk carrier in the world fleet has increased, decreasing the cost of shipping ore.
While coal retains its dominance as the reductant for iron oxide, and the ECSC is still a major coal producer, output has declined in recent years and imports, particularly of coking coal, for the steel industry, have increased. West Germany is still more than self-sufficient, but the steel industries of the Netherlands and Italy, in particular, depend upon imports of coking coal, mainly from the USA. France and Belgium also import some coking coal. Luxembourg, which has no coke ovens, is dependent upon blast furnace coke from West Germany. The shipping of coal has not yet developed on the same scale as that for iron ores and this is partly because oil has been available, and relatively cheap, and is more readily transportable. It has thus increasingly replaced coke in the blast furnace. Limestone is normally found locally. The other major raw material with significance for the location of the industry is scrap. In the main the European steel industry is selfsufficient so far as scrap is concerned, although Italy, for instance, imports about 10% of its consumption. Location of the Steel Industry With the trend to importing raw materials by sea comes increasing pressure for bulk steelmaking plant to be located on the coast with ready access to the ore terminals at deep
SEQ 0069 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0069 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
69
water sites. Currently, only about 20% of the steel production of the Six is on the coast compared with 40% for the UK, and the latter is planned to increase substantially by the early 1980s.8 Clearly there will be a trend for a greater proportion of the bulk steel production in Continental Europe to be located close to deep water. The cost of despatching the finished steel to the user, however, is a significant determinant in the economics of location. As Fig. 4 shows, the steel industry of the Six is heavily concentrated in the Ruhr–Lorraine–Luxembourg–Eastern Belgium region,5 and although the markets are more dispersed, there is a strong market concentration in the same areas. There are advantages in being close to the user, particularly for finishing mills, but also for steelmaking where the process and capital scrap originating there can be used most economically.
Fig. 4 Location of major European steelmaking regions. The steel industry of the Six is heavily in the Ruhr–Lorraine–Luxembourg–Eastern Belgium region although the markets are more dispersed.
SEQ 0070 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0070 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
70
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
The Technology The economies of scale to be gained by increasing the size of each production unit in the iron and steelmaking processes are being exploited in Europe as elsewhere. Figure 5 indicates the way in which the output per unit involved in the various iron- and steelmaking processes has been increasing over the last 20 years.9
Fig. 5 World’s largest iron- and steelmaking vessels. The size of the largest blast furnace has increased markedly and vessels used in steelmaking have also increased though already the maximum size of the BOF vessel is flattening out.
The output of the largest blast furnace has increased by a factor of 4 over the last 12 years and more than doubled in 5 years. The size of the blast furnace cannot go on increasing at this rate. Extrapolation of the present trends would indicate a single blast furnace providing 15m t/year in less than 10 years from now. With European annual steel production 200m t in 1985, 13 such blast furnaces would supply the whole of the Community. The sizes of the vessels used in making steel also show rapid growth, though less spectacular than that of the blast furnace, and already the size of the basic oxygen steelmaking vessel is flattening out. The economic benefits gained by increasing the size of the units diminish and ultimately become too small to offset the disadvantages of the organisational problems and the inflexibility which goes with such size. In a fluctuating demand situation the economics of operating the units below their maximum output penalises their overall economics. A further disadvantage in building very large units is that, unless they can come on full stream rapidly, they can involve a considerable financial penalty. These delays can
SEQ 0071 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0071 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
71
stem from construction and commissioning difficulties, even if they only occur in one critical part of the entire system. Also, unless a market for the output of the new unit can be built rapidly, either by closing obsolete units or by intense marketing, the financial penalties can accumulate. Figure 6 illustrates the penalties incurred by delays in commissioning a works. Thus the optimum size of the units is determined not only by the size but also the rate of growth of the market available.
Fig. 6 Net present value versus build-up period: cost penalty for slow commissioning. The diagram shows how the profitability of a major investment is eroded as the time to build up to full production increases. In this example, increasing the build-up time from one to two years is equivalent to increasing the capital cost by 8%.
The Emerging Pattern of the European Steel Industry The emerging pattern is thus of an industry with a steadily increasing output, where bulk steelmaking is increasingly concentrated in a small number of locations, each chosen for its ready access to cheap, high quality raw materials and with good access to its principal markets. The advantages of large scale operations for iron- and steelmaking conflict with the advantages of specialisation at the finishing end and with the advantage of close contact between the works and the customer. The result may well be a trend towards
SEQ 0072 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0072 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
72
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
polarisation of the industry with large coastal plants (increasingly financed by joint ventures between different European steelmakers) making bulk and semi-finished products which will be transported to finishing works near the markets (probably owned by the individual steel companies). Supplies of scrap (normally centred in the major market areas) will become increasingly important in opening up economic niches for mini-mills. The major suppliers of raw materials may ultimately wish to upgrade their raw material exports. In those cases where iron ore and reductant occur in close proximity, some prereduction will be carried out before shipment, and this will be particularly the case where the reductant (e.g. natural gas) cannot be exported so economically in any other way. Thus direct reduction plants will be built in such parts of the world, but for security of supply and flexibility of operation, there will be a number within Europe, particularly where a suitable reductant and a suitable iron ore can be obtained economically. While deep water for iron ore imports will become essential, the proximity of indigenous supplies of coal, and increasingly oil, could determine which ore terminals will be developed. The landing points for the offshore oil and gas fields could eventually decide the locations of these large steel plants and also those for the smaller direct reduction plants. These possibilities would need the development of the appropriate technologies, particularly those for using oil and natural gas.
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT NEEDED Having discussed broadly the likely pattern of the European steel industry of the future, I turn now to the research and development necessary to help bring this about and to meet the future with sufficient flexibility. Many areas for research are not appropriate for cooperative effort because of the need for competition, or they are too specialised. I shall indicate those areas where cooperative research between the countries of Europe could be most fruitful, summarised under the headings: steel utilisation, environment and human requirements, and raw materials and processes. Steel Utilisation Figure 7 indicates in a general way that iron based alloys can be formulated to cover a very wide strength spectrum at a reasonable cost compared with other basic materials.10 Notwithstanding its versatility and cost, steel is under constant pressure from a variety of competitive materials, each with a relatively circumscribed market range within which its peculiar properties enable it to compete with steel. In these areas there is continuous pressure to improve the properties of the various qualities. However, this is a field of product oriented research to improve competitive performance, and there is likely to be little scope for Eurosteelresearch so I will not dwell on it, other than to say that as steel products encompass a wider range of composites, for instance with non-ferrous metals and plastic laminates, so there will be a growing tendency for the scrap, which is
SEQ 0073 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0073 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
73
Fig. 7 Cost versus tensile strength for various materials. Iron based alloys cover a very wide strength spectrum at reasonable cost. Carbon fibre in appropriate admixtures with a plastic matrix also offers a wide range of strength, but at a very much higher cost.
ultimately offered for recycling, to pose more difficult problems. In this area there should be scope for cooperative research as these problems will bear upon all members of the industry. The extent to which the steel industry, as against steel users, should engage in research on improving steel utilisation is discussed continually; the trend is certainly for increasing use of ECSC funds. One thing is clear: ECSC funds in this field, as in others, should not be dissipated on small projects. Much of this work should be reflected eventually in standards and codes of practice, the rationalisation of which should be an important task of Eurosteel promotional efforts: without it many of the advantages of the bigger home market made possible by the formation of the European Community would not be realised. There is a need for the industry clearly to inform its customers on the precise characteristics and uses for steel products in general. Coordination of the increasing volume of creep and fatigue data and their use in practical design concepts could help further the effective use of steel in many cases. As another example, work on fully instrumented steel structures with stresses and strains continuously recorded could both improve the design and enable the full benefit of the characteristics of the steel to be achieved. To illustrate this point Fig. 8 shows a box girder, such as is used in bridge construction, under test by
SEQ 0074 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0074 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
74
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 8 Box girder test rig for improving design criteria for bridge construction.
the Corporate Engineering Laboratory of the BSC.11 Such an effort on a complete structure is expensive and would justify collaborative effort, preferably with major participation by user interests. Environment and Human Requirements The importance of environmental aspects to the steel industry is in no doubt. Environmental considerations need not themselves limit the general industrial growth which is necessary for worldwide prosperity, but it is essential for the steel industry to establish what is technically feasible to reduce air and water pollution and to pursue a vigorous policy of improvement, and to be seen to be doing so. This would be the best means of ensuring that environmental control requirements are based on what is practically attainable rather than just that which is theoretically possible. A framework of proper balance, as UK experience has shown, encourages industry to pursue socially responsible policies. Environmental control is an area particularly suitable for collaborative research, calling as it does for clearly defined tasks and a coordinated effort to fulfil them. ECSC funds have already been used to support two five year research programmes on air pollution in and around steelworks. The third will include water pollution and noise, this programme being aligned in the broadest sense to the recently approved Community environmental policy. The research programme should be drawn up with the help of representatives of those who will eventually apply the outcome of the research and development and should be closely connected with the research on the processes used by the industry; it is by the modification, sometimes radically, of these processes that reduction in pollution can be most effective in the long run. The need to ensure a sufficiently low level of noise within our plants leads naturally to a consideration of the role of our labour force. As Europe moves into the post-industrial phase of social and economic development, the labour force will increasingly expect more satisfying tasks. Increased use of mechanical handling and increased automation of
SEQ 0075 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0075 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
75
plant will enable many areas of the works to involve the human operator, backed up by automatic sensors and substantial computing power, who will fulfil an essential decision making role. The whole area of social and technical understanding of men, and women, in the working environment is thus far poorly understood and there is clearly great scope for social and ergonomic research which should surely be conducted on a cooperative basis for the European steel industry at large. Raw Materials and Processes The main materials used for making liquid steel are given in Fig. 9,12 which shows the balance of materials which go to make 1000 t of steel in a typical integrated iron- and steelworks using the BOS process. The main materials involved are iron ore, scrap, reductants, and fuel, and the major need, I believe, is to increase the flexibility in the use of these materials, so as to minimise costs and adjust to shortages, whether short or long term. Figure 10 gives data taken from that much criticised publication, The Limits to Growth.13 Though the two projections, that of constant demand and that of exponentially growing demand, are neither likely to prove correct, it is clear from this data (using only reserves known in 1970) that there is no imminent shortage of iron ore or of coal (although of course the requirement at the moment is for low sulphur coking coals, and these are more restricted).
Fig. 9
Major materials used for bulk steelmaking. Balance of materials used for a typical basic oxygen steelmaking plant within the British Steel Corporation.
Iron ore is, however, not only plentiful, it occurs widely over the earth’s surface, in both developed and undeveloped countries, and it has little use other than for the production of steel so that its price should have relative stability over the years. The increasing trend away from lower grade home ores to the import of higher grade foreign ores is likely to continue. While iron ore is the only true source of our steel, scrap is a very important component of the steel made. Although the steel industry is perhaps an example to many others in its ability to recycle, and thus reduce its consumption of raw materials, there is still need for research. The steel industry recycles some 55% of its output. In making 1 t of steel on
SEQ 0076 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0076 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
76
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 10 Lifetimes of known reserves of some natural resources (courtesy of Meadows et al.13). The chart shows two alternatives for the lifetimes of reserves known in 1970 for certain strategic raw materials.
average the UK steel industry consumes something like 0.55 t each of newly refined iron and of recycled scrap; of this 0.3 t is recycled scrap which has not crossed the works’ boundary, 0.12 t processed scrap which has been returned from industrial customers and only 0.13 t capital scrap, i.e. recycled fully used material.14 Allowing for the fact that in a growing market with an average product life of perhaps 10 years, the recycled capital scrap could never reach more than a fraction of the material actually turned into products by our customers, there is still room for improvement. Also, our 30% internally recycled material could be reduced by increasing the efficiency of our own processing techniques. The energy scene The principal reductant, coal, while plentiful in the earth’s crust, if often in deep seams and difficult and expensive to win, particularly in the much worked traditional coal mining areas, and the relative prices of coal and alternative reductants15 have to be considered (see Fig. 11). This is complicated because, in addition to using these for their chemical ability to reduce iron ore, they are commonly used as fuel, domestically, industrially and for the generation of electricity. The European steel industry operates within an energy market of which the UK pattern of consumption15 shown in Fig. 12 is fairly representative. It can be seen that oil’s
SEQ 0077 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0077 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
77
Fig. 11 Prices paid by UK industry for fuel. With the advent of North Sea supplies the price of gas has fallen sharply to equal that of coal and fuel oil. Even allowing for its relatively greater efficiency in use, electricity is still substantially more expensive. Relative prices can change rapidly.
Fig. 12 UK primary energy consumption. Coal’s share of the market has fallen continuously since 1956. Oil has accounted for almost all the growth although natural gas and nuclear power are becoming significant.
share of the market has grown appreciably over the last 15 years, largely at the expense of coal, while othery energy sources together only contribute the remaining 16% of the total. The situation is now changing, however, as oil prices rise and security of supply becomes less certain (and now, 1973, is again threatened by unrest in the Middle East). Throughout the world, some resurgence of coal may be expected, nuclear generation of electricity will be increased, and the percentage contribution of oil is likely to begin to fall even if absolute consumption does not. Europe, and particularly the UK, is fortunate in
SEQ 0078 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0078 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
78
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
having appreciable quantities of indigenous oil, and natural gas coming on stream from the recent finds in the North Sea,16 as indicated in Figure 13. During the next five years oil production from the North Sea will increase rapidly and it is now confidently predicted that the UK will be self-sufficient in oil by 1985, and that up to 20% of European oil requirements will be met from indigenous sources by that date. In the next decade this must have a marked influence upon the energy pattern, at least in the countries bordering the North Sea.
Fig. 13 Possible oil and gas production from UK and Norwegian offshore fields. During the next five years oil production from the North Sea will increase rapidly and by 1985 should make the UK self-sufficient in oil supplies.
Energy in the Steel Industry Figure 14 clearly shows the major dependence on coking coal,17 due to its dominance as the means of reducing iron ore in the blast furnace, where coke makes an essential contribution to the strength and permeability of the burden. Coking coals, won by deep mining in Western Europe are expensive, as is the subsequent coking process, particularly with the increasing costs of anti-pollution equipment. Thus a major aim should be to reduce our dependence on them. Also we should increase the flexibility to take maximum advantage of a changing energy market and of new opportunities such as the increasing availability of indigenous off-shore hydrocarbons. Let us consider some developments and the possibilities for cooperative research. The consumption of coke in the blast furnace has been reduced steadily (Fig. 15) by better operation, improved burden preparation, and latterly by hydrocarbon injection through the tuyeres.18 Further dramatic reduction in coke consumption will require the development of the bosh injection of reducing gases into the blast furnace.19 A proposal for a major trial is being completed jointly by steel companies of Belgium, Italy and the UK to
SEQ 0079 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0079 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
79
Fig. 14 Gross energy consumption (all purposes) per ingot tonne (all qualities) in UK (left) and ECSC (right). Both in the UK and the Six coking coal made a large contribution to the energy requirements of the iron and steel industry. The increase in oil consumption is largely for tuyere injection in the blast furnace.
Fig. 15 Coke consumption for ironmaking 1950–1972. Since 1952 coke rates have fallen steadily due to better operation, improved burden preparation and latterly to oil injection through the tuyeres.
SEQ 0080 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0080 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
80
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
inject a hydrogen–carbon monoxide mixture which could be generated from natural gas or oil. If successful this could lead to a halving of the coke required per tonne of iron produced. Figure 16 depicts the bosh injection system using hydrocarbon oxidation products (BISHOP). It shows the main alternatives being considered for the bosh injection trial currently being planned by the three countries. This is an example of a large project, of potential advantage to the industry as a whole, but beyond the means of one country’s research effort, and which is ideally suited for development on a European scale.
Fig. 16 Bosh injection system using hydrocarbon oxidation products (BISHOP). The main alternatives being considered for the bosh injection trial currently being planned by Belgium, Italy and the UK.
Whatever minimum coke rate is eventually attainable by replacement with hydrocarbons, some coke will still be required in the blast furnace. A further measure to increase flexibility is to produce this coke from non-coking coals. The usage of lower rank coals can be increased by pre-heating them before carbonisation and suitable technology is becoming available. Again this is of European interest, and indeed application has been made for partial ECSC funding for the building of a pipeline charging unit for two coke ovens at the British Coke Research Association to test the suitability of various coal blends for preheating pipeline or gravity charging and carbonisation in a tall or a conventional coke oven. Figure 17 gives a general view of the test plant at the BCRA. This currently includes a pre-heater, charging car and a conventional oven, and plans are in hand to add a tall oven and a pipeline charging system. There are other developments by which our dependence on coking coals can be reduced while still retaining the blast furnace, and there are alternative processes for reducing iron ore. Direct reduction processes in which the ore is reduced at a lower temperature to produce a solid product still containing the gangue, may use coal, hydrogen or a hydrogen–carbon monoxide mixture generated from a hydrocarbon.
SEQ 0081 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0081 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
81
Fig. 17 Coke oven test plant at British Coke Research Association. General view of the test plant at BCRA. This currently includes a pre-heater charging car and a conventional oven, and there are plans to add a tall oven and a pipeline charging system.
Direct reduction has been developed to provide a raw material to augment scrap in the electric arc furnace so further increasing flexibility. In the long term, however, the direct reduction electric arc furnace route could become the major route to steel, for it is in this way that nuclear energy is most likely to be harnessed to steelmaking. Nuclear energy and steelmaking While it is necessary in the future to ensure flexibility in the raw materials we can use, this is nowhere more important than in our fuel supplies. This is an area with considerable scope for greater economy, which will be most important if the real price of energy is to increase markedly in the future. However, for reasons of conservation alone, we should be more stringent in our use of hydrocarbons and in the long run confine their use to chemical feeds rather than as providers of chemical energy. In these circumstances nuclear energy must increasingly become both the desirable and also the economic source of heat. Already power in the form of electricity is being produced economically from nuclear stations in competition with coal and oil fired stations, despite the present high investment costs of the former. Further increases in fossil fuel prices will hasten the move to nuclear stations, and will perhaps begin to close the gap between the price for electricity and fossil fuels for industrial heating. While this would favour the electric arc
SEQ 0082 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0082 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
82
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
route, the likelihood that electricity will seriously compete with fossil fuels for bulk industrial heating is some way off and must await the dominance of nuclear generation. However, before this is the case it should be economical to use nuclear heat directly for various process applications for, if uranium is the most economical energy source for electricity generation, it should also be the most economical source of heat for process application, including steelmaking. While this could be the case now, the high temperature needed for the essential steelmaking route does not lend itself to existing or readily foreseen reactor technology. On the other hand, a low temperature direct reduction process followed by electric melting could be adapted to use direct nuclear heat (the electric arc furnace is already consuming electricity generated from nuclear power). It is important to assess the role nuclear heat could play in the future European steel industry so that the market potential for such systems can be determined. Roughly, 50m t/year of steel (a quarter of the projected European steel production for 1985) using nuclear heat to the maximum, would only require 10 nuclear reactors each producing 2000 MW of heat. Clearly, the organisational and safety problems involved in going straight to a completely self-contained nuclear steelmaking plant would be considerable, and because the nuclear reactor needs to be large to be economical, such a single step would demand too big a decision. A more modest, yet more feasible approach would be to separate the nuclear reactor from the steelmaking complex, so keeping the inherent problems of each from interacting strongly upon one another. Also, it would no longer be necessary to match a single steel plant to the large nuclear, gas and electricity producing station. Figure 18 illustrates schematically a system proposed in essence by Hawkes and Hosegood20 some time ago and indicates a possible arrangement. Here the high temperature nuclear reactor reforms natural gas and then heats the reducing gas produced. This then converts the iron ore to a prereduced iron which is fed to the arc furnace supplied by electricity generated from the reject reactor heat, contained in the helium heat transferring gas, after it has passed through high temperature heat exchangers. With sufficient foresight the development both for the nuclear and the steelmaking plant could be pursued as a natural sequence and the least cost development path taken, so avoiding the astronomical costs that were incurred in developing the nuclear electricity generating reactors. European cooperation is essential if there is not to be a proliferation of approaches. It was with such thoughts that we founded a European Nuclear Steelmakers Club (ENSEC) to determine the appropriate strategy and clearly to define the research that will be necessary to develop the preferred scheme.
ORGANISATIONAL ISSUES After the 22 years it has taken for the cooperative research in the Community to evolve, perhaps it is time to take stock and for a new member to give some views.
SEQ 0083 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0083 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
83
Fig. 18 Suggested nuclear steelmaking complex. Schematic diagram showing part of a high temperature nuclear reactor and a direct reduction electric steelmaking plant coupled to it. The parallel lines indicate two ways that the reactor complex could be separated from the steelworks.
Communications The wide range of interests throughout Europe makes it particularly difficult, both to distil broad and acceptable views of the research needed and to determine the priorities to be given to individual research projects. With so many interests involved it is essential that the role of representative groups is clear. There is need for a forum for debate on the scientific and technological problems and developments which relate to the industry. It is in this area that the ‘Learned Societies’ have an important role to play. The pattern in which the learned societies have developed their activities and their relationships with the iron and steel industry differ in each country. This diversity of approach could be adapted so that within the European Community each of the national societies could have a distinctive role, the one best suited to it, without the need itself to cover the whole field. The Directors and Secretaries of the metallurgical societies have been meeting twice a year for many years to coordinate their activities and avoid duplication of conferences, etc. I hope these contacts develop, certainly between the European societies, to produce a coordinated pattern of activity. The need to exchange technical views, and to construct and to develop cooperatively concepts for joint European research activity is now more necessary than ever it was.
SEQ 0084 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0084 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
84
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Technical Service and Research Centres Eurosteel collaboration would be advantageous both in the technical service and the research field. The concept of ‘centres’ equipped with the best staff and equipment for their particular service or research, often too expensive to be run on purely national lines, could be encouraged. An appropriate allocation of central funds to such centres could be important. There are numerous potential ‘centres’ throughout Europe, some independent, some already national research centres, some acting as cooperative steel research institutes and others integral parts of steel companies. These could both provide services and conduct research in special areas. Clear, distinctive, yet complementary roles for these laboratories will take many years to crystallise. However, an early recognition of the need could do much to move effortlessly in this direction, without the need for any ‘master plan’ other than a desire to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of our always scarce research staff. Research Strategy The Commission is at the centre of the biggest European steel research collaborative effort, paid for by the steel industry through the levy upon it. It is therefore essential for the Commission to be fully informed of the steel industry’s preferred strategy for this collaborative research, and, subject to constraints, such as any imposed by the ECSC treaty, this strategy should be used to help in selecting the research proposals. It might be thought that with the extensive use of experts, many from the steel industry, on its advisory committees, the Commission was able to do this. However, these experts are appointed as individuals. Clearly there is need for a steel industry organisation to produce, and regularly update, a strategy for collaborative research into which the Commission could inject its views. This organisation should represent those who have the need for the research and who will develop and apply its successful outcome. L’Association Europ´eene pour la Promotion de la Recherche Technique en Sid´erurgie (AERES), associated with the Club de Sid´erurgists could fill this role. Allocation of Funds Once such a strategy is available and known, new proposals for collaborative research would increasingly accord with it. There would be few irrelevant proposals and the bulk of the proposals could be sorted and coordinated before final submissions were made to the Commission. Indeed at present the sheer task of processing and assessing the waves of uncoordinated and untranslated proposals that sweep through the Commission and its advisory committees several times a year, is too great. The Commission’s executive committees (there must be about a hundred of these) only deal with narrow technical
SEQ 0085 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0085 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
85
areas and are often more concerned with the technical details rather than with the broad needs for the individual research projects or with the eventual application of their outcome. The numerous and often small research investigations have made it very difficult to take broad views. A concentration upon more clearly defined and important large projects would very much ease the whole communication and administrative problem involved in Eurosteelresearch. This need had become even greater with the enlargement of the Community. This and assistance in coordinating the individual projects in the light of agreed strategy by the industry could leave the Commission staff freer to deal with the broader Community aspects of the research, including the coordination of ECSC funded with other Community funded researches (in this context it is significant that non-ECSC funds are now becoming available for research on matters of steel industry interest, such as pollution control, corrosion, and plant engineering). Also, we should prepare for the agreed eventual merging of the three Communities and the consequential revision, or possibly the end, of the special levy which only the European coal and steel industries bear.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION The issues involved in determining the future pattern of steelmaking in Europe can be outlined as follows: (i)
(ii) (iii) (iv) (v)
The larger markets will lead to larger production units situated near to deep water to benefit from low transport costs of iron ore, while the finishing processes will be near to the customer. To achieve economic operation during demand cycles, there is need for plant with lower capital cost to augment the large production unit. There is a need for flexibility in the use of the main raw materials and particularly fuels, where indigenous supplies will be important. The availability of scrap will diminish as far as internally arising scrap is concerned, while capital scrap will become more difficult to process. The electric arc route could increasingly provide flexibility, provided any lack of scrap could be made up by prereduced iron.
The objectives for the research, which could with advantage be done cooperatively, might be as follows. (i) To develop plant and processes acceptable to our environment. (ii) To improve working conditions, develop sensors and instruments to enable automation and human control to be improved, and adapt mechanised handling devices to the needs of the industry. (iii) To widen the types of indigenous coals which may be used for coke in the blast furnace, and produce alternative reductants to coke.
SEQ 0086 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0086 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
86
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
(iv) To increase the ability to use oil and natural gas for direct reduction of iron ore while encouraging the development of a high temperature nuclear reactor eventually to minimise their consumption as fuel for steelmaking applications. (v) To improve design concepts to take maximum advantages of steel’s unique range of properties. Organisationally this would require the following. (i)
There should be a cooperative research strategy, indicating priorities, produced by the industry. (ii) Individual research projects should be of major importance to the European steel industry, cooperative in character, and fewer in number to ease communication. (iii) There should be encouragement for individual research institutions and company laboratories to specialise in particular research areas or on certain projects so that they will complement each other in areas appropriate for cooperative research. Similarly there should be encouragement of existing laboratories to provide technical service centres across Europe. All this points to a time of new opportunities for Eurosteelresearch, but to take advantage of them, the European steel industry must know exactly what it needs and be willing to take the necessary steps.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am most grateful for the help and understanding I have had from my European colleagues and I should like to thank all those who have helped in collecting data and illustrations for this paper; in particular R. Chapman, D. M. Cowie, Dr S. Klemantaski, A. Post, M. Smith and also D. Smith for preparing the illustrations.
REFERENCES 1. EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES: Medium Term General Directive on Research and Development in Steel, (2025/III-B/72F) European Commission, Brussels, 1972. 2. ‘Brown books’ (Statistics of the iron and steel industry of the United Kingdom) for the years 1938, 1955 and 1972. ‘Development in the iron and steel industry, Special Reports for 1957 and 1964’; pub. HMSO for Iron and Steel Board. ‘International steel statistics world tables 1970’; British Steel Corporation, London, 1973. 3. Estimates based on delivery, import and export data taken from Ref. 2 above. 4. Projection 85, International Iron and Steel Institute, Brussels, 1972, 4. 5. ‘Steel in the Nine, 1973’, reprinted from British Steel, Jan/Mar. 1973. 6. World Bulk Trades, Fearnley and Egers Chartering Co. Ltd, London, 1973. 7. L. R. P. PUGH: JISI, 1973, 211, 461.
SEQ 0087 JOB IOM8627-004-005 PAGE-0087 TWENTY-FOURTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:18 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Eurosteelresearch
87
8. BRITISH STEEL CORPORATION: ‘Ten year development strategy’, Cmnd.5226, HMSO, London, Feb. 1973. 9. W. F. CARTWRIGHT: JISI, 1969, 207, 729, and 33 Magazine, 1972, 10, July, 25–27; Aug., 32–33; September, 34–38 and 47–49. 10. R. L. CRAIK and I. L. DILLAMORE: private communication. 11. Steelresearch 72, British Steel Corporation, London, 1972, 31. 12. BRITISH STEEL CORPORATION: Annual Statistics for the Corporation 1972, British Steel Corporation, London, 1973. 13. D. H. MEADOWS et al.: The Limits to Growth, Earth Island, London, 1972. 14. Scrap is Our Business, British Steel Corporation, London, 1971. 15. DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY: United Kingdom Energy Statistics 1973, HMSO, London, 1973. 16. D. M. COWIE: private communication based on published information in Petroleum and Petrochemical International, Oct. 1973. 17. Based on energy consumption data taken from ‘United Kingdom Energy Statistics 1973’, op. cit., and ‘Energy statistics’ (pub. by the Statistical Office of the European countries) taken together with production data shown in Fig. 1. 18. W. F. CARTWRIGHT: JISI, 1971, 209, 89, and private communication from Iron and Steel Statistics Bureau. 19. Adapted from Steelresearch 71, British Steel Corporation, London, 1971, 10. 20. D. A. HAWKES and S. B. HOSEGOOD: Alternative Routes to Steel, Iron and Steel Institute, London, 1971, 130.
SEQ 0089 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0089 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE TWENTY-EIGHTH HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
From Invention to Industrial Development L. Coche At the time the lecture was presented Lucien Coche was Director General of l’Institut de Recherches de la Siderurgie Fran¸caise (IRSID). The lecture was given in Sheffield on 24 November 1978.
The structure and efficacy of industrial research organisations involves a high degree of cooperation: with other similar bodies, with universities and with industry itself. The director-general of one such European research body, Lucien Coche, stressed this theme in presenting the 28th lecture.
Dr Hatfield was an extremely bright applied scientist. In a book he wrote a few months before his death, he summarised his experience of the difficulties of creative scientific work in relation to industry; and I would like to quote what he wrote: When a piece of new scientific knowledge has been unearthed by the investigator it is some little time before either he, or someone in the world at large, realises how and where such knowledge can become of practical service; there is then very likely an even longer time to elapse before the conception of the utility of the knowledge can be construed into practical service. In the case of most applications of knowledge, many practical details have to be worked out and manufacturing plant devised and equipped. Also the potential users or consumers amongst the public must have their interest awakened, and that takes time. It is, therefore, obvious that from the inception of the idea as to how knowledge can be employed, considerable time elapses before the thing comes to fruition in everyday life and usage. That was written in 1943, 35 years ago. Since that time, industry has become more and more complicated. So much progress has occurred in many fields that further technical improvements have become a matter of cooperative work, involving many men or departments inside big companies, and usually also men working in other companies or organisations. This evolution has had a big influence on the structure of industrial research organisations. In the steel industry, possibly more than in many other industries, new technical developments can be directed to final industrial application only by the intimate cooperation of a
89
SEQ 0090 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0090 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
90 Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III number of researchers and engineers with different backgrounds, at the different stages which lead from an idea to what Dr Hatfield called ‘fruition in everyday life’. The history of a few technical developments that have recently entered industrial practice can be used for an investigation of what is necessary, taking into account the present structure of the European steel industry, to obtain that successful evolution from idea to fruition. As a first example, let’s look at the application of controlled rolling to the production of weldable plates of high properties. Much work was done in various countries, in the 1920s and 1930s, on the theory of rolling and plastic deformation of metal. When the French companies created an Institute for collective steel research, a group in charge of rolling techniques endeavoured to improve our knowledge of the fundamentals of rolling. In 1953, Paul Blain and Claude Rossard joined IRSID and started research work on the high temperature plastic deformation of steel. Experiments were first made on a conventional tensile testing machine, which was equipped with a heating furnace in order to control the sample temperature, and with a cam system to control the elongation speed applied to the sample. Subsequently, they used a hot torsion testing machine to attain higher elongations without breaking the sample. Such machines had been used for many years to measure the forgeability of steel. The one used by Blain at IRSID was modified to give an accurate measurement of the torque during the torsion test. From the shape of the curves representing the torque against number of revolutions, conclusions were possible about the structural changes of the steel. The hot torsion machine was then equipped with a fast quenching system, so that it became possible to see the grain structure at various stages of plastic deformation. Recrystallisation phenomena, either static or dynamic, were thus observed and better understood. In the University of Sheffield, at the same time, Dr Tegart was working on the same subject, with similar equipment, and a friendly and fruitful cooperation was established between him and Blain. Some work had also been done at IRSID by Blain and Fazan on the fundamentals of the rolling operation. They discovered that the stress and strain distribution in the superficial layer of a torsion sample was the same as inside the hot ingot during the rolling operation, so that one could expect to be able to predict the structure of a hot rolled plate by simulation on a hot torsion machine, with corresponding deformations, same number of passes, same temperatures and same waiting times between passes (Fig. 1). Unfortunately, this similarity of stress and strain distribution was valid only for a thin layer at the surface of the torsion test sample. It was possible to use microscopic observation as a means to observe the metal structure which was to be expected for the industrial rolling operation. But it was not possible to use an appreciable volume of metal for mechanical testing. This was undoubtedly a disadvantage of the torsion testing simulation; in order to predict physical properties of plates, it was necessary to calculate them from the metallurgical aspect, grain size distribution and similar characteristics.
SEQ 0091 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0091 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
From Invention to Industrial Development
91
Fig. 1 Time to the beginning of static recrystallisation, as a function of temperature, for values of rolling reduction between 20 and 80%. Diagram on left is for C–Mn–Al steel, on right for a steel containing niobium, which makes for slower recrystallisation. Research at IRSID led to new controlled rolling methods for these steels.
In the 1960s, automation was introduced in rolling mills. It required a closer control of operating data such as temperature, speed, torque and roll pressure. Since another group of IRSID researchers was working on automation of a plate mill they had an opportunity to take measurements and to collect accurate data on an industrial plate mill operation. They had close relations with the research group working on torsion testing, and jointly conducted experiments to test the industrial validity of those simulation methods. The results were unexpectedly good; proof was given that it was possible to simulate the hot rolling of plates, and have an excellent knowledge of the steel structure and physical properties, just by looking at the torsion sample, and deducing the physical properties from the optical observation. It was also possible, from torque measurements on the torsion testing machine, to predict the strain in the stand and rolls of the rolling mill. Measurements were made, and found to be in good agreement with the predictions. So it became possible to imagine new types of rolling operations, try them on the torsion machine, observe the resulting structure, deduce their physical properties, use the torque measurement to calculate the strain and check that an industrial experiment could be done without any risk of breaking a roll or the stand itself. Thus, the next step was to realise an industrial scale rolling test. Practical experience confirmed that those tests were always immediately successful. In the same period, much development was being done in the field of high resistance weldable steels to be used in shipbuilding and pipe lines. Niobium semi-killed steels were first used. Then in Europe and America controlled rolling was used, with the idea of getting fine grain structures and better mechanical properties (higher elastic limits and lower transition temperatures) through plastic deformation at temperatures lower than those used in normal rolling operations. In the Soviet Union, controlled rolling was applied for beams and bars.
SEQ 0092 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0092 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
92
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Plates became thicker and mechanical properties had to be higher. All major producing companies were competing for big markets. A new torsion machine specially designed for these plate rolling simulations was built at IRSID with induction heating, in order to get good temperature control, and with a computer to facilitate the simulation of multi-pass rolling operations. This machine was used for helping two plate producers. Usinor and Dillinger Huette. A new method for rolling plates was developed, the commercial Multiphi process. In 1974, using that process, these plate producers gained big orders, with profits which paid back more than the past research expenses. This new torsion machine has also been used to simulate hot strip mill and wire rod rolling operations. It is an extremely useful piece of equipment, which we are still using for all kinds of controlled rolling investigations.
FROM IDEA TO COMMERCIAL SUCCESS Industrial profits were first obtained about 20 years after the beginning of our research work in that field. A long succession of laboratory experiments has been necessary, since three successive testing machines had to be built; and industrial experiments lasted more than five years. A lone researcher, even though he might be a genius, would not have been able to lead that work from the beginning to industrial application; success could be attained only by cooperation by several teams which have been working on torsion testing, on the fundamentals of rolling, on precipitation hardening and weldable steels, and on rolling mill automation. Among the researchers involved in that development work, some had to be metallurgists. Others had to master mathematics and the theory of plastic deformation. Others had to be able to understand automation problems and to know a lot about computers, software and hardware. Others had to be field measurement engineers. All had to be experienced people in their fields, and no one single man could have had knowledge of all the various fields involved. Such intimate cooperation would have been extremely difficult, if not impossible, if those teams had been located in several distinct companies or organisations. Though Nippon Steel, US Steel, British Steel and the Soviet Union now have such size that they can maintain important research organisations, at the time that work was done it would have been practically impossible in Europe without the existence of a collective research organisation. The torsion test was not a fully satisfactory one, yet it could be used for practical application. The temptation of doing further research work in order to improve the laboratory testing methods was great, and it was a good decision not to try to look for a better test, but to try to use it as it was. From the Usinor management viewpoint, the industrial experiments could take place because there was a reasonable hope that this research could bring a solution to an
SEQ 0093 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0093 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
From Invention to Industrial Development
93
important commercial problem: success in hard worldwide competition for plates to be supplied for northern countries’ pipelines. That was a large and important market.
CONTINUOUS STEELMAKING Another story of long lasting research, which has not yet come to industrial application, is that of continuous steelmaking. In the 1950s French steel companies had many Thomas converter plants. Improving the Thomas operation was a big problem for them. Foaming and overflow losses were a difficulty; the blowing rate had to be reduced at certain periods of the blowing operation, and yet metal losses were high. IRSID had a good team of physical chemists under a well known Russian scientist in that field, Professor Paul Kosakevitch. After the Second World War, M. Malcor, who was at that time President of IRSID, engaged him, engaged assistants to work with him, and asked that research group to work, among other subjects, on the problem of Thomas slag foaming. So Professor Kosakevitch, Dr Olette and others of that same group conducted basic investigations on steelmaking slags and such physical properties as melting point viscosity and surface tension. In close cooperation with the IRSID group working on steelmaking problems, they observed what happened in Thomas converters, investigated the foam properties and discovered that the analysis of the small steel balls trapped in Thomas converter foam was excellent, with very low phosphorus and sulphur contents. Then the idea of using that foaming effect for continuous steelmaking came into their minds. No person would pretend to be the one who had that idea first. It came naturally to the minds of a group of men working together, starting either from semi-fundamental studies, or from industrial problems. It would be a long story to describe all the steps which led continuous steelmaking from that idea to the last step currently attained, which was a semi-industrial operation at Hagondange. There were first laboratory experiments, then a pilot plant built at Maizi`eres-l`es-Metz for about 3 tonnes per hour, then another pilot unit, also at Maizi`eres-l`es-Metz, for about 10t/h, then the semi-industrial plant at Hagondange, which produced 20–25t/h. Two stage operations with two slags were also tried. Operation of the experimental plant, erected in the steelworks of Hagondange, began in 1969; improvements had to be made and tested. In 1971, that plant was operated for three months; the first campaigns had to be stopped after a few hours, but week after week the technological difficulties were eliminated. And finally the engineers were able to get the results which were wanted: a full five days operation with 108 hours of actual blowing time and a smooth operation throughout that week. In 1973 and 1975, the Hagondange steel plant was used again, for two kinds of additional research. One was to use scrap, and see how massive scrap could be melted; it
SEQ 0094 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0094 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
94
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
was quite successful since, though it was only a small scale unit with 1 meter diameter at the cylindrical part of the reactor and 0.6 meter at the bottom, bloom scraps 200 mm square could be melted as easily as sugar lumps in tea. The other line of research was on the use of preheated granulated pig iron’, in addition to or instead of liquid hot metal. With phosphorus iron preheated at 850°C, it has been possible to use granulated iron alone, without any liquid hot metal. In bigger units, of course, the minimum preheating temperature would be lower. A total of 22,000 t of steel has been produced in that Hagondange pilot plant. Yields and all elements of the cost were measured; practical problems for starting, stopping and maintenance were encountered and solved. Almost all the problems that could be investigated at pilot-plant scale have been investigated and solved, at least for a single-stage operation. More work could have been done in order to operate the two stage process, but that would have needed more money than IRSID budgets could afford.
CONVINCING THE SCEPTICS Though no larger plant has yet been constructed, it is worth reviewing the various steps between the original idea and the final application. As for what we may consider to be the successful first part, some remarks expressed about controlled rolling are valid for continuous steelmaking as well: the length of time between the beginning of research work and industrial application will be more than 20 years, with a long succession of laboratory and pilot plant experiments. The cooperation of several research teams with different kinds of knowledge and experience has been absolutely necessary, and was possible only because those men were in a single big research organisation. Too, the men leading the project had a deep belief in its future: they were convinced of the advantages of continuous steelmaking. Now, let us consider the reasons why no bigger plant has been built. The investment for a 1.5 million t/y steelmaking unit is probably not less than £20 million. Second, the advantages of continuous steelmaking are not very obvious for people without strong technical experience. In the case of controlled rolling, the hope of winning arctic pipeline markets was a good argument that any non-technical director could easily understand. In the case of continuous steelmaking, if the technical director explains that, in addition to lower investment costs, the company may take advantage of easier and better quality control, as well as environmental control, those arguments are not easily perceived or appreciated by his colleagues with less personal technical experience. And they also overestimate the risks. I do not see any practical means for overcoming that kind of difficulty, because there is too much distance, and not enough communication, between the men who can decide a £20 million investment, and those with a deep enough technical knowledge of the process to be aware of its advantages.
SEQ 0095 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0095 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
From Invention to Industrial Development
95
From these two examples, we can draw conclusions about the necessary conditions for the industrial success of research. First, chance is important. But that does not lead to any practical conclusion. Second, the result of research work must be considered as really useful not only by researchers, but by the people who decide investment in the industry. Research projects which do not correspond to immediate commercial needs have little chance to come to realisation, even though they may have value for the remote future. Even for minor improvements, a close cooperation of various specialists is necessary. Blast furnace operators can decrease coke rates by several points per cent, just by applying well established rules for shaft operation control. But in order to do that, they must know enough physico-chemistry to understand the basic laws of blast furnace shaft operation. They also need to cooperate with measurement specialists for top gas temperature and analysis measurements, and with computer experts for the necessary calculations. Because so many different men, with different technical backgrounds, are involved, technical progress becomes impossible if we do not either have big companies, or a cooperative system to organise joint research. In both cases, the main qualities required from research people are knowledge, tenacity and imagination, together with the aptitude to cooperate in team work. At the time Dr Hatfield was working and writing, all these qualities were necessary: but the last has become more important. Since our steel industry must survive in extremely tough worldwide competition, I sincerely hope that in all the European countries men responsible for conducting steel research will be conscious of that evolution, and be able to create the structures for increasing cooperation.
SEQ 0096 JOB IOM8627-005-006 PAGE-0096 TWENTY-EIGHTH LE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 20:19 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
SEQ 0097 JOB IOM8627-006-004 PAGE-0097 37TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE THIRTY-SEVENTH HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
Net Shape Solidification Processing of Steel, 1945–1995 M. C. Flemings At the time the lecture was presented Professor Flemings was at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The lecture was given in Sheffield in 1989.
Professor Flemings’ Hatfield Memorial Lecture, the 37th, with the above title, was presented in 1989. No lecture manuscript is available, but the following entry is adapted from a short review which appeared in the journal Cast Metals, and is reproduced by kind permission of the Castings Technology Institute.
One of the most important papers to be delivered in the 1989 season was the 37th Hatfield Memorial Lecture, delivered in Sheffield, England, by Professor M. C. Flemings, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The title of the paper was ‘Net-shape solidification processing of steel, 1945–1995.’ The Lecture, which has become a major annual event in the European metallurgical calendar, was instituted in honour of the late Dr W. H. Hatfield, the noted Sheffield metallurgist who had, during his long association with the Brown Firth Research Laboratories, been responsible for many significant advances in ferrous metallurgy, including important aspects of the solidification of steel. Professor Flemings, author of two books and over 200 papers on aspects of casting, joined a long list of eminent figures in the metallurgical world who have been invited to give the lecture; his twin themes, expanded before a large audience, were the development of casting processes and the understanding of solidification over the half-century leading to 1995. Professor Flemings began by reviewing the transformation that had occurred since 1945 in a field until then dominated by the labour intensive process of sand casting and by the production of ingots for the wrought steel industry. In the shaped casting field, growing mechanisation, developments in sands and binders and the new concept of resin shell casting had been followed in the late 1950s by the appearance of the lost foam principle and later the V process, both also embodying no-binder moulding technology. The increasing emphasis on the three attributes of accuracy, thin section capability and surface quality was also featured in the parallel emergence of lost wax investment casting and eventually the ceramic shell system on to the industrial scene. The 1970s brought the
97
SEQ 0098 JOB IOM8627-006-004 PAGE-0098 37TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
98
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
counter gravity casting processes, using vacuum and pressure assisted filling to achieve half-millimetre wall thickness. Problems attending the use of pressure diecasting for steel were then emphasised, particularly the die heating aspect, to which no moulding material has yet offered a complete solution. The alternative approach was to keep the mould temperature low and cast below the liquidus, using semi-solid slurries, which offered an opportunity of achieving this aim in what was effectively a hybrid casting/forging system. Continuous casting had developed, over the period being considered, from an abstract perception to a process which may soon approach universal application for billet and slab production, with large multi-strand plants now a reality. This gave new impetus to ideas for the direct casting of strip and even wire; some work in these fields was described, including melt spinning. Pilot thin slab casters with capacities for production in the thickness range 20–40 mm and 2 m width, at rates of 2–10m/min, were in existence, but the eventual aim would be to achieve the cold rolling stage directly from the liquid or semi-solid state, requiring 1–5 mm cast thicknesses to be produced at 30 m/min. This could involve either twin or single roll systems. Professor Flemings then proceeded to review advances in the knowledge of solidification in steel castings and ingots over recent decades, first in the field of feeding principles for sound products, for which the main criteria were mentioned, based essentially on the total solidification time as emphasised in the equations produced by Adams and Caine. The mid 1950s had brought advances in the use of insulation and exothermic compounds and also the concept of feeding distance as developed by Pellini and others to attack the problem of centre line shrinkage. The early 1950s had seen the advent of the transistor and the requirement for the growth of single crystals of germanium and silicon, which gave impetus to the quantitative understanding of plane front solidification, but the extension of the same theoretical principles to dendritic growth had in the 1960s produced mistakes which indicated that the idealised concepts as envisaged by the physicists could not handle real systems. At a later stage new ideas from Scheil and others were successfully combined with the older to overcome this limitation. Special tribute was paid to the publications of Ruddle during the early phase of solidification research. The 1960s and 1970s had brought major advances in solidification science, especially application to microsegregation, macrosegregation and hot tearing. The audience was reminded of the earlier contribution of Dr Hatfield himself to the study of macrosegregation, through his chairmanship of the ISI committee on the Heterogeneity of Steel Ingots. It was pointed out that the phenomena in ingots and castings could now be simulated mathematically. Before the ’sixties, segregation had been seen mainly in terms of elements being ‘pushed ahead’ of the solidification front, together with the settling of crystals and tear filling. Between 1967 and 1970, however, the interdendritic flow of liquid, previously associated with inverse segregation, was seen to be relevant to all forms of segregation, whether in ingot, shaped, or continuous casting conditions. Mathematical and particularly computer modelling was not,
SEQ 0099 JOB IOM8627-006-004 PAGE-0099 37TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
Net Shape Solidification Processing of Steel, 1945–1995
99
however, only important to the research worker, but also to the practical man for process simulation. Professor Flemings believed that the picture of the next five years was clear and indicated three major trends. These would be, first the progressively closer approach to net shape, second, a continued quest for improvement in the quality attibutes of soundness, cleanness and properties, and third, the drive towards lower total costs of the final component and of the whole system, thus justifying higher selling prices for the products. In specific terms, the coming period might see more automation of investment casting, with possible hybrids of investment and sand casting practice, the application of semisolid diecasting and the continuous casting of thin slab and strip and perhaps later even of wire. Other changes foreseen by Professor Flemings in the final part of his review were increased emphasis on uphill metal transfer and on the application of computers for both simulation and control. The Lecturer had been introduced by the Vice-Chancellor of the University of Sheffield and a concluding vote of thanks was proposed by Professor R. W. K. Honeycombe. Dr. P. R. Beeley, The University of Leeds, England.
SEQ 0100 JOB IOM8627-006-004 PAGE-0100 37TH LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
SEQ 0101 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0101 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
THE FORTY-THIRD HATFIELD MEMORIAL LECTURE
The New World of Steel J. Edington At the time the lecture was given, Dr Jeff Edington was Executive Director Technology, British Steel plc. The lecture was given in Sheffield in December 1995.
Delivering the 43rd Hatfield lecture, Dr Jeff Edington promised his Sheffield audience a bright outlook for steel, the engineering material of choice for the twenty-first century. This presentation was delivered in December 1995 and the data included represent the state of technology development at that time.
SUMMARY In the early part of the next century the steel industry will be deploying worldwide new and even cleaner process technologies, new business processes and IT systems, as well as new products and systems based on symbiotic relationships with customers. It is an exciting and challenging time to be a technologist in the industry because most of the new technologies, on which all of this depends, are being developed and piloted now. The broad influence of technology on both the profitability and cleanliness of the industry as well as service to society has probably never been greater. Steel will continue to provide the world with the uniquely versatile, low cost engineering material. It fills a fundamental need in modern society and will continue to do so in such major markets as infrastructure construction, transportation, packaging, domestic white goods and engineering machinery. A key component in the overall acceptance of steel as the engineering material of choice is the fact that it is already by far the most recycled material in the world.
THE MARKET Steel is by far the largest metals industry and the second largest man made materials industry in the world, with an annual production of 750 Mt, compared with 1100 Mt cement, 100 mt plastic and 25 Mt of aluminium. As shown in Fig. 1, during the 1950s and 1960s production showed a steady growth of ∼ 6% per annum.1 However, in common with most other materials, the first oil shock transformed the situation into one
101
SEQ 0102 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0102 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
102
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Fig. 1 World steel production (1950–1994).
of very slow growth with large fluctuations arising from a fine balance between supply and demand. Since the end of the Cold War, growth in Asia Pacific, mainly in China, has compensated for shrinkage in Eastern Europe. Although the market overall has not grown much, the total amount of steel traded has because of the entry of steel from Eastern Europe into world markets for the first time. During the past 20 years the distribution of steel sales between the major product market segments has remained largely constant. Recent figures for the European Union, North America, and Japan, the three major and mature geographic markets, are shown in Fig. 2 (1993 statistics). From an estimated total consumption of about 250 Mt (product tonnes), the manufacture of automobiles accounted for 16%, metal goods and containers 10%, whereas building and construction used 38%. All geographic and product markets are mature except the emerging economies of Asia Pacific. Here, growth in steel consumption is driven largely by urbanisation and construction of an infrastructure typical of the early stages of economic growth and is likely to move on to consumer goods as the populations become more wealthy.
Fig. 2 Steel consumption by sector: USA, EU, Japan (1993).
SEQ 0103 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0103 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The New World of Steel
103
In all markets the industry is pursuing a four pronged strategy of: ● creative product and systems development based on enhanced symbiotic relationships with customers ● improvement in product quality and customer service ● continued cost reduction ● development of a series of even cleaner, lower capital cost manufacturing processes that, depending on the technology deployed, can produce steel economically at small or large scale and from a wide range of raw materials; these will provide more flexibility to tailor a viable scale of operation and reduce environmental impact to meet the widely different needs of local markets throughout the world.
PRIMARY PROCESS DEVELOPMENTS The industry has a long history of innovation both in technology and in management systems. For example, in the last century the industry has invented and implemented three different ways of making steel via the iron ore route, namely, the Bessemer (1865), open hearth (1868) and basic oxygen (1960s) processes. More recently, combined managerial and technical innovation have led to the implementation of minimills based on electric arc steelmaking from scrap combined with near net shape casting. These are low capital cost, very high productivity plants focused on regional markets and a narrow range of products. At present there are two established process routes to make steel, the blast furnace (BF) which produces liquid iron for refining to steel in the basic oxygen furnace (BOF) and the electric arc furnace (EAF) which remelts in plant arising and (collected) merchant scrap.
BLAST FURNACE–OXYGEN STEELMAKING ROUTE The BF–BOF is a tried and tested route capable of producing 4–6 Mt/year of high quality steel from two large blast furnaces and a three vessel BOF configuration on one vary large site. For example, British Steel’s Teesside plant produces 4 Mt/year based on one blast furnace and the largest steelplant in the world at POSCO’s Pohang site produces 9 Mt/ year from four blast furnaces. Iron ore is converted to sinter by drawing air through a mixture of iron ore, limestone, and coke at 1000°C, while, in parallel, coal is heated in airtight coking ovens to produce a coke feed. Both are fed into the blast furnace which produces molten iron by reducing the sinter and lump ore with carbon monoxide generated by combustion of the coke. In the next step the BOF charge is usually 300 tons and consists of 80% liquid iron and 20% scrap to cool the metal during the exothermic chemical reactions that occur as high purity
SEQ 0104 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0104 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
104
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
oxygen is blown through the BOF. The oxygen combines with carbon and other unwanted elements, eliminating these impurities from the molten charge. During the ‘blow’ (30 min), lime is added as a flux. Once the steel has been refined, it is tapped into a ladle when alloy additions may be made to adjust the composition and/or the steel may be degassed. The integrated BF–BOS route is being developed continuously to increase productivity, lower costs and reduce the environmental impact.2 For example, British Steel has poineered injection of coal into the blast furnace through the tuyeres at 200 kg per tonne of hot metal (thm) allowing coke rates to be reduced from ∼ 500 to ∼ 300 kg/thm. The limit of this injection technology is probably ∼ 250 kg coal/thm. In the future more productivity and cost gains will come from oxygen enrichment of the blast beyond 60% and reinjection of reheated top gas. Further cost savings and reduction in environmental impact will come from newly developing technology that allows ore fines and fluxes to be injected with the coal. This could lead to coke rates as low as 175 kg/thm which is the minimum to service the heat requirements of the hearth. In addition there are techniques to feed the BOF with 40% or more scrap, although productivity is reduced. All of these developments will reduce the environmental impact of steelmaking by lowering the production from potentially the most polluting steps in the manufacturing chain, the sinterplant and coke ovens. In addition, as illustrated schematically in Fig. 3, the BOF can be adapted to accept a wider range of feedstock. As an alternative to scrap, direct reduced iron (DRI) or hot briquetted iron produced by reduction of solid ore by natural gas in commercial processes such as Midrix3 is already in use. One further approach is to feed the BOF from a smelting reduction furnace which produces liquid iron, but on a smaller scale than the blast furnace. Several new smelting reduction processes are under development and one, Corex,4 has already been deployed. The first major plant, operating at 300 kt/year started up in 1988
Fig. 3 The adaptable BOF.
SEQ 0105 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0105 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The New World of Steel
105
at ISCOR in South Africa and a 600 kt/year unit is now operating at an actual output of 700 kt/year as POSCO in South Korea. Design of a 1 Mt unit is under way. Currently, approximately 2.4 Mt of Corex capacity is on order around the world. The Corex process telescopes the coke ovens, sinterplant and blast furnace into one process and has the advantage that non-coking coal can be used. The quality of the iron is identical to that obtained from the blast furnace and, because this process substitutes one fully enclosed process for one enclosed (blast furnace) and two open to the air (coke ovens and sinterplant), its emissions are considerably less.5 This technology also has the advantage that it produces large amounts of spare energy in the form of a gas similar to natural gas which can be used to make electricity, DRI, or oxygen depending on the local needs. For example, the gas from a 600 kt Corex produces ∼ 125 MW of electricity. As a result of the the developments summarised here, there is now a choice of cleaner iron ore based processes for making steel via a BOF that will enable plant to be tailored both for the size of the market anywhere in the world and to fit the local feedstock (iron ore, coal or natural gas). The price of all of these raw materials is determined in a world market with plentiful supply and, therefore, the fundamentals of the BOF route will always be low cost with little fluctuation in the real price of raw materials.
ELECTRIC ARC STEELMAKING ROUTE (EAF) The electric arc furnace (EAF) is illustrated schematically in Fig. 4 and is a well known and reliable technology that has been used for 85 years to make steel. Traditionally it has been an ac three electrode furnace fed entirely with scrap and the quality of the steel produced is directly dependent on the purity of the scrap. However, alternative feedstock can be used, such as DRI, hot briquetted iron, iron carbide,6 or liquid iron from either a
Fig. 4 The adaptable EAF.
SEQ 0106 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0106 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
106
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
Corex or a blast furnace. Because they come from an ore based route, they all provide a clean feedstock and are a direct substitute for top quality low residual scrap. Several recent developments of the EAF have improved its efficiency.2–7 The dc furnace offers advantages over the ac furnace in reduced electrode costs and reduced electricity network disturbance as well as simpler construction and operation. Although ac furnaces are still preferred at power inputs above 90 MW, the recent development of larger diameter electrodes and a twin electrode dc furnace will probably raise the upper power limit. Furthermore, the use of natural gas for in vessel and external scrap preheating, including the use of twin shell furnaces, have all increased production rates, reduced electricity consumption and lowered operating costs. For example, Tokyo Steel is installing a twin electrode dc arc furnace with a central preheating shaft from which scrap is fed continuously between the electrodes. The target output is 150 t h–1 utilising an electricity consumption of 230 kWh/t, which compares favourably with 450 kWh/t for a conventional ac unit. One further potential development is a high aspect ratio furnace that can accommodate a charge of either all liquid iron or all coarse lightly packed scrap, or any mix of the two, depending on the available resources. However, this is not available commercially at present. Depending on which of these technologies is chosen, the economically viable range of an EAF based melting shop is 0.5–2 Mt/year and the costs can be minimised for the particular location. However, unlike the BOF route input costs are not determined in an international market with plentiful supply. Electricity prices in some parts of the world are determined by governments through control of supply and taxation, so the economics depend on geography. Furthermore scrap prices vary considerably (× 2) through the business cycle depending on the balance between supply and demand, although the increasing availability of DRI will place an upper limit on the price of best quality scrap. As a result, although this is the low capital cost route, it is not always the best option for low overall cost.
IMPLEMENTING NEW PROCESSES IN THE FUTURE As mentioned above, the different process combinations available to make liquid steel can be tailored for local needs for capacity, product mix and quality, and feedstock. By the year 2010 it is estimated that about 45% of the world’s steel will be produced via the arc furnace and the remainder will be BF–BOF or Corex. About 20% of the overall supply for the EAF will be DRI, 55% will be obsolete scrap, with the remaining 25% scrap from manufacturing process losses. The choice of the various technologies will be dependent on the local infrastructure, such as the availability and cost of natural gas, electricity, coking coal, ore, and scrap. For example, in Western Australia the availability of natural gas and iron ore could enable DRI to be produced at the mine then exported as a higher value added product than iron
SEQ 0107 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0107 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The New World of Steel
107
ore. Again, in Indonesia local iron ore and non-coking coal are more compatible with Corex than BF–BOF technology. Consequently, the key issue in making the appropriate technology choice is to have an accurate cost model which can be used in different parts of the world to compare the capital and operating costs of particular steelmaking processes. The output of one such model based on the 1995 input prices for energy, raw materials, and manpower in Southeast Asia is shown in Fig. 5. In this case, for a capacity of 2.5 Mt/year, the Corex/BOF route is the most economical.
Fig. 5 Liquid steel costs in Southeast Asia for different steelmaking combinations.
ENVIRONMENT The industry has invested heavily to ensure that modern environmental standards are met and considerable progress has been achieved. For example, most major companies have reduced discharges to air and water by 90% since the 1960s. Indeed, to meet HMIP requirements in the UK, the emission of particles to air by sinterplants has reduced from 460 to 60 mg m–3. For EAFs emissions have reduced since 1966 from 115 to 15 mg m–3. This has been achieved by fitting filtration systems which capture most of the dust and fume which then becomes an economic source of reclaimable material. New technology developments range from the application of advanced computing technology to enhance the capacity and effectiveness of air pollution control equipment to development of instruments for monitoring continuously air and water quality. Considerable success has been achieved in the economic use of waste material from the blast furnace. Now up to 80% of this process waste can be recycled, processed into cement or sold to the road construction industry as a replacement for quarried materials. Several opportunities are being investigated aimed at using BOF slag to build roads or condition soil. In addition, extensive work is also being done to develop more value added products from waste and new technologies to recycle wastes previously sent to landfill. In the future consumers are likely to begin to make buying decisions on the (perceived) environmental impact of the manufacture and use of materials and indeed of the
SEQ 0108 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0108 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
108
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
environmental performance of individual companies. The most obvious recent example was the disposal of the Brent Spar oil platform which led to a boycott of the company’s products in Germany. Another is the need in some Scandinavian countries to meet environmental standards in manufacturing before being allowed to bid on some contracts. Another is the increased emphasis on life cycle analysis as a means of comparing the environmental impact of different materials. Much work needs to be done here to ensure that the industry fully understands these developing issues and responds effectively. We start from a strong base in which we have by far the most recycled material as described below and we already recycle and use much of our process waste. We have many opportunities to improve.
RECYCLING Steel is the easiest to recycle of the materials used in large volumes. Furthermore, steel is not downgraded when it is recycled and reappears in buildings, cars, engines, earthmoving equipment, tractors and white goods. Approximately 80% of all steel available in the UK is recovered and recycled so that almost half of the UK steel production is derived from scrap. The total amount of steel recycled annually in the world is 320 Mt, just under half of the world production at 750 Mt. The automobile sector is a good example of the excellent recycling track record of steel. In the UK, about 2 million scrapped cars are recycled each year, representing 97% of all redundant vehicles. The challenge for the future, should society require it, is to design and build consumer goods for long life followed by reuse rather than recycling. This is already done to some degree in many small industries based on reconditioning industrial machines, car components and household equipment in which steel components figure large.
ENERGY The steel industry is a large consumer of energy because carbon is the key element in the chemical reduction of iron ore in the BF/Corex and the purification step in the BOF. All of this absorbs 45% of the fuel consumed, and basic thermodynamics controls the chemistry so there is no alternative here. Nevertheless, there are planty of opportunities to work on the balance of 55% and most companies have considerably reduced their energy consumption during the past decade. For example, British Steel now uses 25% less energy in total than in 1980. The future lies in improving the operating efficiency of the processes in each individual plant by making many small improvements in energy consumption, the Japanese kaizen approach. These range from burners that will strike the optimum balance between energy efficiency and air pollution to fan speed control in extractions systems.
SEQ 0109 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0109 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The New World of Steel
109
DOWNSTREAM PROCESS DEVELOPMENT The past decade has seen considerable activity to improve the processes used to manufacture flat or long products. Like steelmaking this has been driven by the need for lower capital and operating costs and again like steelmaking this has led to telescoping process steps. This is best illustrated for hot rolled coil production. The conventional way is to start with a continuously cast strand typically 230–300 mm thick and up to 3 m wide. This is processed through a roughing mill, then a finishing mill, to produce coil. The production line is typically 500–800 m in length. The hot working schedule combined with the correct cooling rate enables the desired final shape and metallurgical properties to be achieved. However, near net shape casting techniques have been developed to simplify the process by minimising the amount of rolling required for both flat and long products.
THIN SLAB CASTING This process route is illustrated schematically in Fig. 6, although the details vary between the various manufacturers.8 The cast strand can be up to 2 m wide and 15–125 mm thick. This can be further reduced by in line rolling of the strand to 15–30 mm which is the normal entry thickness to the tandem mill in conventional rolling. Alternatively, casting may be followed immediately with a squeeze reduction before the centre of the strand has solidified. In effect the production line is reduced in length from 800 to 260 m and at most only a small roughing mill is needed. Combined with electric arc steelmaking, capital costs per tonne are less than one-half those of a conventional BF–BOF hot strip mill, but operating costs are only competitive where electricity is cheap and/or scrap is in the lower part of its price cycle. Surface finish is the limiting factor. At present 50–60% of the product range is attainable in quality terms, but it is expected that 80–85% will be reached soon with only the highest automobile and white goods grades out of reach of the process.
Fig. 6 Schematic diagram of thin slab casting route.
SEQ 0110 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0110 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
110
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III STRIP CASTING
Direct casting of strip < 8 mm thick is the next step in cost reduction because it reduces the investment in rolling mills. On paper, when combined with electric arc steelmaking, capital costs per tonne could be less than one-quarter and operating costs less than half those of a conventional BF–BOF hot strip mill. It is under intensive development. As shown in Fig. 7, steel is teemed via a protected shroud directly into the strip casting mould using a feeding system designed for minimum turbulence and even distribution across the mould width. The strip is fed, via pinch rollers, into a hot coiler and casting speeds of up to 100 m min–1 are possible, depending on product thickness. Througputs of up to 500 kt/year are possible for a single twin roll caster.
Fig. 7 Schematic diagram of direct casting of strip.
Strip casting of stainless steel is easiest because is has a lower melting point compared with conventional carbon steels and much greater oxidation resistance. It is close to commercial realisation, with Nippon Steel/Mitsubishi able to cast 10 t coils at 1330 mm wide. Ugine has reported production of 25 t coils of stainless at 860 mm wide and POSCO/Davy have recently installed a 1300 mm wide plant in Korea.9 BHP has reported success with carbon steels, a much more difficult product. Several 18 t coils 1400 mm wide × 1.9 mm thick have been produced at its Port Kembla works. Commercial processes for stainless production will be available within 2–3 years and perhaps for carbon steels in the early part of the next century. Initially surface quality will limit applications, but this will be overcome with time although probably not for all grades.
BEAM BLANK CASTING Beam blank casting in the process route to sections excludes typically five rolling stages in the breakdown mill before final rolling in the universal mill. The process was developed
SEQ 0111 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0111 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
The New World of Steel
111
at BISRA in 1968 and has been adopted for mills with a limited product range. Manufacturing a wide product range entails too many moulds and mould changes which translates into high capital and operating costs. However, design improvements have enabled more final shapes to be produced from a given cast shape and have enabled thinner web, wider flange sections to be produced. Thus, recent installations at Arbed have enabled a range of sections from 186 × 200 mm × 34/6 kg m–1 to 1008 × 302 mm × 349 kg m–1 to be made from only three cast beam blanks.10
BUSINESS PROCESS SIMPLIFICATION Information Technology (IT) The steel industry manages one of the most challenging manufacturing and product delivery systems in the world, consisting of a mixture of sequential batch and continuous manufacturing processes. This is exacerbated by orders that are sometimes much smaller than the minimum manufactured batch size and this must be harmonised with the customer’s requirement for just in time delivery and the steel company’s need for minimal stock. All of this leads to considerable difficulty in maximising the profit by optimising the loading of the assets while maximising the profit ability of the order mix. In this world effective IT systems are essential to run manufacturing and all companies have them. However, the new nexus between computing, communications, and information is providing the opportunity to move to totally new levels of efficiency and customer service that are already beginning to revolutionise the industry and will produce winners (those who implement the new technologies creatively and quickly) and losers (those who don’t) on a grand scale. All companies are progressing up the ladder shown schematically in Fig. 8. Here, the overall principle is to share information more and more broadly as the organisation progresses from the bottom to the top of the diagram. This will enable people to operate
Fig. 8 Business transformation and the IT revolution.
SEQ 0112 JOB IOM8627-007-006 PAGE-0112 43RD LECTURE REVISED 19DEC04 AT 21:00 BY TF DEPTH: 62.04 PICAS WIDTH 45.03 PICAS
112
Hatfield Memorial Lectures Vol. III
more effectively as individuals and to cooperate in teams. As a result the organisation will deliver much greater levels of service and efficiency to customers. At the top level is a new model for the creation of profit, the internetworked business, and at the bottom is a more effectively contributing person. For each level there is an enabling technology that is already available. Very little needs to be invented; the initiative lies with management and technologists to use it creatively. The opportunity is to develop a business enterprise which is both internally and externally integrated in a completely different way. Internally it will be integrated to greatly simplify and reduce the activities associated with order acceptance, manufacturing, and delivery. Externally it will be integrated with its suppliers, with the knowledge base in universities and consultants and other service providers, with up to date market databases and most importantly with engineering product development software shared with the customer and other vendors that cuts product development time massively. The way in which these opportunities have already been taken varies from industry to industry.11 For example, in retailing, Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is the world’s largest and most successful retailer with 1994 sales of US$80 billion from stores in the USA, Canada and Mexico and is an innovator in the business use of IT. Bar codes, read at the cash register, are communicated directly to the factory so that replacement goods are sent directly to the shop, so that 97% of them never see a warehouse. Sales drive the order process and the company can offer quality goods at low prices because stocks are minimal and there is no investment in warehouses. Levi’s Personal Pair Jeans mass customised jeans is another example in retailing. A customer can be measured by a clerk in a shop who is guided by touch screen software that does not require special computing skills. Using Lotus Notes, the measurements are transmitted over the Internet to the manufacturer who mails the jeans to the shop or the home within 3 weeks. The customer happily pays US$10 more for the jeans because the fit is guaranteed and profit is high because there is neither inventory nor distribution, which together account for 75% of the costs in the clothing industry. If the software is available at home from the Levi’s Jeans homepage on the Internet, there is no need for a shop; we have electronic shopping. In an industry where US$25 billion of manufactured clothing remains unsold or sells only after deep discounts, such preselling is revolutionary. Finally, the Boeing 777 is an example of a revolution in product design and development. This was a US$4 billion 5 year programme to design an aircraft digitally. Design packages Catia, Elfini, and Epic w